id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14091v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14091v1 | Protecting Privacy Through Approximating Optimal Parameters for Sequence Unlearning in Language Models | 2024-06-20T08:12:49 | 2024-06-20T08:12:49 | Dohyun Lee, Daniel Rim, Minseok Choi, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although language models (LMs) demonstrate exceptional capabilities on
various tasks, they are potentially vulnerable to extraction attacks, which
represent a significant privacy risk. To mitigate the privacy concerns of LMs,
machine unlearning has emerged as an important research area, which is utilized
to induce the LM to selectively forget about some of its training data. While
completely retraining the model will guarantee successful unlearning and
privacy assurance, it is impractical for LMs, as it would be time-consuming and
resource-intensive. Prior works efficiently unlearn the target token sequences,
but upon subsequent iterations, the LM displays significant degradation in
performance. In this work, we propose Privacy Protection via Optimal Parameters
(POP), a novel unlearning method that effectively forgets the target token
sequences from the pretrained LM by applying optimal gradient updates to the
parameters. Inspired by the gradient derivation of complete retraining, we
approximate the optimal training objective that successfully unlearns the
target sequence while retaining the knowledge from the rest of the training
data. Experimental results demonstrate that POP exhibits remarkable retention
performance post-unlearning across 9 classification and 4 dialogue benchmarks,
outperforming the state-of-the-art by a large margin. Furthermore, we introduce
Remnant Memorization Accuracy that quantifies privacy risks based on token
likelihood and validate its effectiveness through both qualitative and
quantitative analyses. | [
-0.0933547765,
-0.5977758765,
0.0775934234,
-0.205787167,
-0.3796728849,
0.2888753712,
-0.315680176,
0.0595362484,
-0.3389973044,
0.664732337,
-0.4395535886,
-0.4992608428,
-0.4857880175,
-0.3860658109,
-0.3759082258,
1.0048815012,
0.3908427358,
-0.0702819973,
0.1424382031,
0.0379462279,
-0.1092341095,
-0.5995007753,
-0.4134949446,
0.0239820499,
0.1893702894,
0.2650818527,
0.3868374825,
0.8104310036,
-0.0348595716,
0.3136282563,
-0.3568367958,
0.3133157194,
-0.7191468477,
0.2635696232,
-0.0273166504,
-0.4916348457,
0.0864715427,
-0.0434002951,
0.9652436376,
0.9325113297,
-0.2380087227,
0.1307155639,
0.2952449322,
0.8364217877,
-0.9666801095,
0.0043546022,
-0.8370002508,
0.2043572664,
0.048911076,
-0.480032742,
-0.6979877949,
-0.3523624241,
0.0769267827,
-0.3337977827,
0.1741185188,
0.1577981859,
0.7113791108,
0.3293729722,
-0.1460808963,
0.0771657452,
-0.6621346474,
0.8294020295,
-0.6099020839,
0.6303706765,
0.6092053056,
0.0119147794,
-0.5678696036,
-0.593786478,
0.0269758403,
-0.1728318334,
-0.0534992591,
-0.142931208,
-0.2454914451,
0.119573094,
0.3538756967,
0.3869381249,
-0.4815657139,
0.3496678472,
-0.4773205519,
-0.5023006797,
0.388794452,
-0.1748850793,
0.086393863,
0.0105506908,
-0.561070621,
0.0386900827,
-0.7670029402,
0.5197697878,
0.6448192596,
0.2509818375,
0.2459151,
0.2438336462,
0.0728928745,
0.5211259723,
0.1417063177,
-0.2030562013,
0.4644412994,
-0.0455138385,
-0.1100433692,
-0.1717040539,
0.9320386052,
0.0701335892,
0.4042833149,
-0.5313691497,
-0.1949063092,
-0.6518915892,
0.161050871,
-0.6206968427,
0.0311524309,
0.3482784331,
-0.488986522,
-0.2372331321,
0.2467504591,
-0.9402418137,
-0.2547506988,
-0.0965292007,
0.301597923,
-0.5206186175,
-0.259293139,
-0.0233840458,
0.0390737057,
-0.1903796494,
-0.2478954345,
-0.9666805863,
0.3359533846,
0.7758589387,
0.7370733619,
-0.0533047467,
-0.3688622415,
-0.838317275,
0.1908882856,
-0.2914523482,
0.0191126987,
-0.5815858841,
-0.7539322972,
0.0788619816,
-0.0489491783,
-0.2785728574,
-0.4960438609,
0.2869645655,
-0.5216687322,
0.5412623882,
0.2850074172,
-0.9931993484,
-0.1193649322,
-0.1858398914,
-0.5682583451,
0.9511772394,
0.088555716,
-0.6704013348,
0.2631193697,
-0.5998242497,
-0.2828420997,
-0.1228476539,
-0.0196688585,
-0.6437619925,
0.2396751493,
0.1456330568,
0.4509190321,
0.1032794788,
0.2258372605,
-0.1251238286,
-0.3913796842,
0.4736875892,
-0.6548392177,
0.9295313954,
0.314825505,
-0.3894976676,
0.0909900293,
-0.8508011103,
0.1968656331,
-0.1282547414,
-0.4552303255,
-0.4403267801,
-0.2941682935,
-0.5468786359,
0.0024872255,
0.3832315505,
-0.6006655693,
-0.1858786494,
-0.6501269341,
0.4359806776,
1.020999074,
0.2372181416,
0.8545303345,
-0.0854828283,
0.4684785604,
0.070325613,
0.4406505525,
-0.5900596976,
-0.4008105099,
-0.3529804945,
-0.5399067998,
0.6060506105,
0.5694885254,
-0.057417281,
0.7412113547,
-0.0900639445,
-0.3177420199,
-0.488723129,
0.3662180901,
0.9245671034,
0.5297952294,
0.061519023,
-0.3248162866,
-0.4278160632,
-0.7313778996,
-0.6246832013,
-0.1734663248,
-0.0782746524,
0.1379946619,
0.0802155212,
0.0804217681,
0.9825024605,
-0.3254351914,
-0.1175689325,
-0.0983775407,
0.0419013761,
0.0884985179,
0.6130180359,
0.2950127721,
-0.8160776496,
-0.1997344792,
-0.1701932997,
-0.3812935352,
-0.0111576719,
-0.0886707231,
-0.1840976328,
0.4757274091,
0.4425658286,
-0.4911136031,
0.7824332118,
0.2821584046,
-0.0222254526,
0.2483672053,
-0.5093063712,
-0.4050831795,
-1.0781174898,
0.2415868789,
-0.2892636359,
-0.4569474161,
-0.8699223399,
-0.073239848,
0.0150371715,
-0.2340362221,
-0.7485828996,
0.6274815798,
-0.6883773208,
-0.0125676068,
-0.2516291142,
-0.2613703609,
-0.2304028273,
0.852447927,
-0.060774833,
0.6064964533,
0.6639669538,
-0.7121776938,
-0.255366683,
0.0037101018,
-0.2346926481,
-0.0194537006,
-0.2893799245,
0.3663063645,
-0.2686557174,
-0.0365739651,
-0.7902908921,
0.2261680961,
0.3637515903,
-0.5874431133,
0.6041540504,
-0.4302394688,
-0.3809795976,
-0.050655704,
-0.4283987284,
0.1436787695,
1.0684456825,
-0.600600183,
0.660081923,
0.5720534921,
0.1786531359,
-1.1341110468,
-0.2375300974,
-0.2596644461,
-0.4329833984,
-0.0410691239,
0.2022100836,
-0.0902632475,
0.0968706086,
-0.1388768256,
-0.1881558299,
-0.189395979,
0.1248457953,
0.5067228675,
0.0229426268,
0.178616643,
-0.2347223312,
-0.1370464265,
-0.5790880322,
-0.03445879,
-0.4883596897,
0.7031641603,
-0.1054213718,
-0.3167202771,
-0.5481936336,
0.4573822021,
0.5684110522,
-0.2308976054,
0.9389212132,
0.5930072069,
-0.5025592446,
-0.4148639739,
-0.4293845594,
-0.2143784612,
-0.5187687278,
0.240237698,
-0.1304715723,
-0.9107404947,
0.5856118202,
-0.2214997113,
0.4591340423,
-0.0366264433,
0.4753314257,
0.0526973419,
0.7119980454,
0.542842567,
-0.4112775326,
0.6587106586,
-0.1972227544,
0.354745388,
-0.8234027028,
-0.4145333767,
-0.2880726457,
-0.1291163564,
-0.5436983109,
-0.1961417049,
0.1514172703,
0.3426665664,
-0.3735575676,
0.3032908142,
-0.3676466644,
0.8421143889,
0.9967815876,
0.128737554,
0.2454673052,
0.4070162773,
-0.3005715907,
0.1002452746,
-0.5620197058,
-0.415182054,
1.3102767467,
0.4520796239,
0.5313001871,
-0.0443318784,
0.9643996954,
0.1899500638,
-0.0990188643,
-0.3132901788,
0.5386163592,
-0.2374617308,
-0.5255789757,
-0.449724257,
-0.6689119339,
-1.0796350241,
0.3224112689,
0.2018423378,
-1.287586689,
0.2179774195,
0.3754466772,
-0.4166009426,
0.6302744746,
-0.5679356456,
0.7503162026,
-0.1717077047,
-0.4199601114,
0.1851009429,
-1.0609858036,
0.2437327206,
-0.3316205144,
0.2623279691,
-0.0205013175,
-0.0490421131,
0.6994928718,
-0.5813029408,
1.1290209293,
-0.4591083527,
0.085607104,
0.1845907569,
0.2051798254,
0.4391879439,
-0.1646377295,
0.0535874479,
0.2682148516,
-0.0245957412,
-0.3683501482,
-0.7019646764,
0.497336328,
-0.581486702,
-0.6355344057,
-0.2233516276,
-0.3320397139,
-0.2999811471,
0.3266736865,
0.5511282086,
0.3161179125,
-0.1499252617,
0.2008437514,
0.6118906736,
-0.2453165799,
0.8915743828,
0.7145180106,
-0.1347002983,
-0.4309388697,
1.076382637,
-0.0007527326,
0.4384480417,
0.5030831099,
0.5202951431,
-0.6909971833,
-0.7301246524,
-0.3469755948,
0.1649892926,
-0.6328526735,
-0.007645037,
-0.5366849899,
-0.3735167086,
-0.0534883142,
0.1697221845,
-0.4965879917,
-0.5519508719,
-0.4820971489,
-0.2562409937,
0.3019081056,
0.1973821968,
-0.4807447791,
0.2436185926,
-0.913154304,
-0.0582515523,
-0.1110239848,
0.4260362983,
0.0866532847,
-0.8590168357,
0.1063080952,
0.1300073266,
-0.128668949,
-0.5775170922,
0.4109281301,
0.3849261701,
0.6976156235,
0.6760418415,
0.178688392,
0.6006850004,
-0.7182588577,
0.5906169415,
0.2668132186,
-0.9020512104,
0.3501211107,
-0.197492525,
-0.1577972919,
0.7267770171,
0.2960647047,
-0.3486854732,
-0.2186999619,
-0.9680566788,
-1.0342617035,
0.547821641,
0.1926361173,
0.3173209429,
0.1991247684,
0.5703567863,
0.3600790203,
0.4910378158,
-0.4001145065,
-0.4497535527,
0.0030108858,
-0.2152085155,
0.0046475604,
-0.1940926015,
0.0227519497,
-0.1130897179,
0.5580341816,
0.1955554336,
0.0404300988,
-0.4157494903,
-0.1440921426,
0.0184220299,
0.2440318316,
0.4980042875,
0.6804355383,
-0.2068454474,
0.0490461737,
0.0438504405,
-0.5258439183,
0.2845879495,
-0.1043827459,
-0.4520069957,
0.0708676055,
0.0745565295,
0.6105512381,
0.4052503705,
-0.8008238673,
0.6695407629,
0.1022208631,
0.0729823261,
-0.4695477486,
0.2671646774,
-0.2333576977,
-0.1790741235,
0.3034137785,
0.1032050475,
-0.0710082054,
-0.3103682399,
0.7146459818,
0.4012259841,
-0.5112330317,
-0.2403704375,
0.5988975167,
0.039800588,
-0.7175351381,
0.4925251603,
0.0038279663,
-0.5155196786,
0.1867797077,
0.5339797735,
0.8891325593,
-0.6435275078,
0.1773785055,
0.1052965894,
0.1007766575,
-0.301803261,
0.1304515153,
-0.0436400138,
-0.5063508749,
-0.0058148489,
-0.484608531,
-0.2824833691,
0.3075815737,
-0.7922587991,
-0.2569491267,
-0.9198721647,
0.0248319898,
-0.4250515699,
-0.2652569413,
-0.4155203998,
0.0461441316,
-0.18925412,
0.6783184409,
-0.420617044,
0.4992226958,
0.0710081831,
-0.4097401202,
-0.7595529556,
-0.1607205868,
0.2872256637,
-1.0470397472,
0.3733110428,
0.0937726796,
-0.1083200872,
-0.0833698884,
-0.2342960685,
-0.8182332516,
0.5315676928,
0.5795221329,
-0.8396092653,
0.2434180826,
0.4145204723,
0.3323460817,
-0.2317119986,
0.0267530251,
0.5895645022,
-0.0083931126,
0.0500702299,
-0.6978706121,
-0.0383493602,
-0.2829931676,
-0.2510967851,
0.3120671213,
-0.54088974,
0.6756611466,
-0.3309299648,
-0.2233519852,
0.2503233552,
0.5467697978,
0.1549859345,
0.0882049799,
0.6795067191,
0.4001223743,
1.1858501434,
0.1589722037,
0.9320098758,
-0.5182780027,
0.2370801568,
1.1055161953,
0.0276600085,
0.8942338824,
0.3748317659,
0.0575597174,
0.0823431015,
0.7629436851,
0.2707153857,
0.7215658426,
0.5632382035,
-0.349721849,
-0.0162740164,
-0.0037657053,
-0.2903704643,
0.255033195,
0.1681767702,
-0.7600719333,
0.0941994041,
-0.1580089033,
0.4752860367,
0.0050964369,
-0.1147353798,
0.849661231,
0.158945471,
-0.3813067675,
0.6750315428,
-0.1043760851,
0.3516075313,
-0.6521212459,
0.2906674147,
-0.402757436,
0.4528113604,
-0.1211551279,
-0.3519013822,
-0.0662508383,
0.1209520102,
-0.1443098933,
-0.2220466137,
0.3242475688,
-0.6603896022,
-0.4262503684,
0.1809471995,
0.3228473663,
0.3699456751,
-0.0019565332,
-0.7269151211,
-0.2135036439,
0.1383640468,
-0.3472496867,
0.6014642119,
0.2422686815,
0.1248942539,
0.8152284622,
0.9643445015,
0.1392034143,
0.3828186095,
0.3261282146,
0.8007788062,
-0.5336036682,
-0.7105680704,
-1.141546011,
0.4628149569,
-0.1517485231,
-0.4899788499,
0.7382501364,
0.7334788442,
0.8128420115,
0.110211812,
0.7499570847,
0.5774746537,
0.684007287,
-0.706299603,
0.7447178364,
-0.3994134367,
0.5401903987,
-0.2144265771,
-0.9487764239,
-0.4508787692,
0.4756141007,
-0.0557602383,
0.2922903299,
0.537978828,
0.9533586502,
0.0645038262,
0.0993278995,
0.4197187722,
-0.0666672811,
0.4051591158,
0.6861791611,
0.8403640985,
-0.2720504403,
0.4701668322,
-0.4329085648,
-0.3293642998,
0.0822181553,
-0.9429614544,
-1.1493475437,
-0.6060348153,
-0.1948695481,
-0.2712635696,
0.2435380667,
0.9764922857,
0.782638669,
-0.7779026628,
0.0104465168,
0.0796750262,
0.0951185077,
-0.0974475071,
-0.1118517444,
0.7289878726,
-0.2343457043,
-0.6725327373,
0.5240780711,
0.298048079,
0.1261171997,
-0.2910335362,
-0.1309878528,
0.1586481929,
-0.1304853708,
0.0296901669,
0.8368726969,
-0.7488506436,
-0.1736466885,
-0.0335175507,
0.3684446812,
0.0309586395,
1.1095157862,
-0.5394710898,
0.3408072889,
0.3003800511,
0.9783895612,
0.2219840735,
0.3228514194,
0.5746303797,
-1.0971425772,
0.3294089437,
0.1228412017,
0.5698207021,
0.3307451904,
-0.5052285194,
0.2261071354,
0.1286459714,
-0.3684760332,
-1.1498177052,
0.2005580962,
-0.5780364275,
-0.2958067954,
0.9840754867,
-0.5137591958,
-0.5654379129,
-0.2945826948,
-0.0224203262,
0.1333088577,
-0.6152160764,
0.7811079621,
0.259262979,
0.0429199859,
-0.2656307817,
-0.0769193023,
0.7550538182,
0.4970911443,
-0.2480608076,
0.4917110503,
0.1734340489,
0.4268550873,
-0.0771314949,
0.5285646915,
-0.3319747746,
0.0680766925,
-0.2965115011,
-0.4392347634,
-0.5421538949,
-0.572886765,
-0.4119825661,
0.3364576399,
-0.2140008956,
-0.6980904937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14088v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14088v1 | ReaLHF: Optimized RLHF Training for Large Language Models through Parameter Reallocation | 2024-06-20T08:04:07 | 2024-06-20T08:04:07 | Zhiyu Mei, Wei Fu, Kaiwei Li, Guangju Wang, Huanchen Zhang, Yi Wu | cs.DC | cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) stands as a pivotal
technique in empowering large language model (LLM) applications. Since RLHF
involves diverse computational workloads and intricate dependencies among
multiple LLMs, directly adopting parallelization techniques from supervised
training can result in sub-optimal performance. To overcome this limitation, we
propose a novel approach named parameter ReaLlocation, which dynamically
redistributes LLM parameters in the cluster and adapts parallelization
strategies during training. Building upon this idea, we introduce ReaLHF, a
pioneering system capable of automatically discovering and running efficient
execution plans for RLHF training given the desired algorithmic and hardware
configurations. ReaLHF formulates the execution plan for RLHF as an augmented
dataflow graph. Based on this formulation, ReaLHF employs a tailored search
algorithm with a lightweight cost estimator to discover an efficient execution
plan. Subsequently, the runtime engine deploys the selected plan by effectively
parallelizing computations and redistributing parameters. We evaluate ReaLHF on
the LLaMA-2 models with up to $4\times70$ billion parameters and 128 GPUs. The
experiment results showcase ReaLHF's substantial speedups of $2.0-10.6\times$
compared to baselines. Furthermore, the execution plans generated by ReaLHF
exhibit an average of $26\%$ performance improvement over heuristic approaches
based on Megatron-LM. The source code of ReaLHF is publicly available at
https://github.com/openpsi-project/ReaLHF . | [
-0.5179971457,
-0.9784198999,
0.6236869097,
0.1051032841,
-0.2146498114,
0.2623487413,
-0.4665463567,
-0.547991395,
0.1630902588,
0.4852049351,
-0.8321774602,
-0.2755590677,
-0.3036223054,
-0.2482034117,
-0.1562946886,
0.6744475961,
-0.2163358331,
-0.0491614379,
-0.1706135422,
-0.2253844291,
0.0262850951,
-0.5727331042,
-0.609888792,
-0.5240707994,
0.8678816557,
0.59965837,
0.9652560949,
1.1804083586,
0.5208677053,
0.2358818948,
0.0551619902,
0.2462140322,
-0.5594646931,
0.217854023,
-0.0114790816,
-0.3757489026,
-0.0843489692,
-0.2299767435,
0.9750137329,
0.4145142734,
-0.7537574768,
0.2974459529,
-0.4950607419,
0.7486426234,
-0.617033124,
0.2263452709,
-0.1071959063,
0.3236364424,
-0.0350734331,
-0.1743031293,
-0.2169489563,
-0.4673290551,
0.1726359278,
-0.6074118614,
0.0119572505,
0.3632771671,
1.0054332018,
0.4637580514,
0.0139158405,
0.1266140044,
-0.9338600636,
0.955127418,
-0.7160067558,
0.6632529497,
0.0385083109,
0.6174921393,
-0.2791844606,
-0.6664410233,
-0.6471152306,
-0.4945957661,
-0.0068993741,
-0.2072251886,
0.3226286173,
0.3585816324,
0.3670505583,
0.1157472953,
-0.6751351953,
0.3887000978,
-0.3499568105,
-0.1712603718,
0.5849405527,
0.2725754976,
0.0694088265,
0.2828789353,
-0.1148991883,
-0.4142502844,
-0.7592046857,
-0.1955316514,
0.7386066318,
0.333653748,
-0.2099241763,
0.124524191,
-0.352838695,
0.9134950638,
-0.111611627,
-0.4344112575,
0.1489725411,
0.0812377855,
-0.039537482,
0.0934024304,
0.6750290394,
-0.1957603991,
0.4505720735,
-0.1751847118,
-0.2171957642,
-0.3925811946,
0.5131259561,
-1.0346330404,
-0.0926165432,
0.1959479004,
-0.4818826318,
-0.4656400084,
0.1465916783,
-0.7528866529,
-0.0782329813,
-0.3439675868,
-0.0123742083,
0.0245719217,
-0.3746449351,
-0.2163426429,
0.2368332446,
0.0911006778,
0.0519030243,
-0.9801180363,
0.3692706525,
0.7826071382,
0.6670773029,
-0.1597465426,
-0.7060111165,
-0.9383097887,
0.1365344822,
-0.3218326569,
0.6289368272,
-0.6551250219,
-0.214200601,
0.1312755644,
-0.0976984128,
-0.0734935254,
-1.0464369059,
0.4129211903,
-0.8214910626,
0.0009685486,
-0.2469481975,
-0.3844355345,
-0.1582825929,
0.1118840948,
-0.6728809476,
1.1257480383,
0.1510926187,
-0.5466570258,
0.1245150566,
-0.6889988184,
-0.3101176322,
-0.0941766202,
-0.174723506,
-0.7652207017,
-0.2209113091,
0.0656605288,
0.3169866502,
-0.431266129,
0.4551796317,
-0.5276107192,
-0.6178414822,
0.0749318451,
-0.3043757975,
0.1617259383,
0.2956912518,
-0.4502398074,
0.6535451412,
-0.7352390289,
0.0453420915,
0.1854000241,
-0.6525889039,
0.3456149697,
0.2089911401,
0.1022929698,
0.1022074297,
-0.0064361347,
-0.4097512364,
0.0713741928,
-0.5831462741,
0.3716169596,
0.540830195,
0.0136194918,
0.3222995102,
-0.1612639874,
0.8653357029,
-0.2159485668,
0.342720747,
0.148688212,
-0.1972447336,
-0.6487013102,
-0.4289648831,
0.3382311761,
0.639280498,
-0.4062624872,
0.3599576354,
-0.0693619624,
-0.3963329792,
-0.5932331681,
0.1089468375,
0.6739197969,
0.6075368524,
0.3303274214,
0.2028863579,
-0.4426729083,
-1.1225137711,
-0.0969438925,
-0.3053013384,
0.1941023022,
0.2724400759,
0.3647806942,
-0.2612734735,
0.7926382422,
-0.7902078629,
0.0224139653,
-0.2824171185,
0.2698171437,
0.1035261899,
0.372815311,
0.3397311866,
-0.5969532728,
-0.2915647626,
0.026605444,
-0.5603150129,
-0.0451887064,
-0.0585933924,
-0.1292035431,
0.0251665972,
0.5900701284,
-0.5598148108,
0.1012305543,
0.7260475159,
0.0639174134,
0.899985671,
-0.4704983532,
-0.0804435089,
-0.6458292007,
0.0700896978,
-0.0729402825,
-0.511246264,
-0.1813554615,
0.449316889,
0.0140525559,
-0.1200931072,
-0.5847662687,
0.717841506,
-0.3421723545,
-0.3151998818,
-0.3461520076,
0.0101648569,
-0.4648571908,
0.83049196,
0.129390955,
0.8735979199,
0.3846181035,
-0.5695618987,
0.7883705497,
-0.1526402086,
-0.3203967512,
0.1240554005,
-0.5100742579,
0.0728776008,
-0.0817158967,
0.4801648557,
-0.6471568942,
-0.4378034472,
0.420984298,
-0.0136057138,
0.1934081763,
-0.1384538561,
-0.65843153,
-0.487336576,
-0.1918399185,
0.5068136454,
0.53481251,
-0.9224504828,
0.3871819079,
0.3281639218,
0.0302754492,
-0.4744713306,
-0.3674838245,
-0.1006579399,
-0.1487554014,
-0.3649613261,
0.2337904274,
0.1223403811,
-0.1715430617,
0.0646585226,
0.0408366807,
-0.1600989997,
-0.017539233,
0.3734273612,
0.0862827152,
-0.0268575996,
0.1632216126,
0.0693529472,
-0.2961096764,
-0.0469001681,
-0.446808964,
0.4985381365,
-0.2163754553,
-0.4818343818,
-0.6530119777,
0.0878423676,
0.575340271,
-0.2779283226,
0.8682963252,
0.9229035974,
-0.2189568281,
-0.3754348159,
-0.519254148,
-0.4739893377,
-0.4216105044,
0.6163375974,
-0.1860612929,
-1.1303192377,
0.442510277,
-0.2796032727,
0.1142717525,
0.044966016,
0.6299951077,
0.0010910456,
1.1027027369,
0.594363153,
-0.132387206,
0.5735262632,
-0.2079837918,
0.2802771032,
-0.549592793,
-0.1413156837,
-0.2531368434,
-0.6711372137,
-0.611212492,
-0.6701462269,
0.4052021205,
0.1271403581,
-0.4070442319,
0.2057928592,
-0.4310059249,
0.559250772,
0.5888137817,
0.1203133613,
0.1293036193,
0.0223091058,
-0.2432980388,
0.0663616955,
-0.8906472921,
-0.2773064077,
0.7825366855,
0.6229757071,
0.6438459158,
-0.033850491,
0.7124532461,
0.2181050479,
0.333848536,
-0.8611271977,
0.6310256124,
0.2470406443,
-0.2027314603,
-0.6533595324,
-0.6273688078,
-0.7052429318,
0.3444372714,
-0.1460291892,
-0.4970082045,
-0.0538047813,
0.554959774,
-0.6234064698,
0.5212083459,
-0.5630984306,
0.6876410246,
-0.2218161225,
-0.4585266411,
-0.8117892742,
-0.5906163454,
0.280949086,
-0.0130630406,
0.1785413474,
-0.1659149528,
-0.0688718334,
0.8473410606,
-0.7652021646,
0.560395658,
-0.4444646239,
-0.1954446882,
0.3277038038,
-0.0756457523,
0.9933864474,
0.0723233297,
-0.2129822671,
-0.079726696,
-0.0182098709,
-0.5260201097,
-0.6419278979,
1.0221050978,
-0.8368581533,
-0.3697066307,
-0.2033257484,
-0.445130825,
-0.3344312906,
0.0416597016,
-0.1749807447,
0.3450926244,
-0.0077268858,
-0.0813059509,
0.706784606,
-0.2818040848,
0.5088546276,
0.3679366112,
-0.3957899213,
-0.4749173522,
1.1204160452,
-0.1045309156,
0.1979112476,
0.4149932563,
0.4089866877,
-0.3583561182,
-0.4842178226,
-0.81254071,
0.6109409332,
-0.3545717299,
0.0740898401,
-0.3998793066,
-0.0639784113,
-0.0156035023,
-0.0721842945,
-0.7039305568,
-0.3108403981,
-0.2378568947,
-0.178102687,
0.3171194494,
0.469230175,
0.0999772251,
0.6255414486,
-0.8175846338,
0.2362934202,
0.4969433844,
0.6432318091,
0.1546288133,
-0.4729500413,
-0.5670551658,
-0.146532312,
-0.0249123797,
-0.5749022961,
0.3277569115,
0.1639773399,
0.5214149356,
0.3106127083,
-0.0240778588,
0.7385629416,
-0.3755417168,
0.3670352399,
0.1754135191,
-0.4113267064,
0.1469484717,
-0.4148023129,
0.3761223555,
0.5189757943,
0.3070691228,
-0.4043921828,
-0.0701701269,
-0.572893858,
-0.6518245935,
0.8941690922,
-0.3000304997,
-0.1420135647,
0.3554479182,
0.7210152745,
-0.2095000446,
0.2055841684,
-0.2267584801,
-0.1011015251,
0.2115057707,
-0.1640412807,
0.2919206023,
-0.2922661901,
-0.1438240558,
-0.3727904856,
0.6873100996,
-0.3329918087,
0.2063702792,
-0.1060918868,
-0.0913897306,
-0.5214965343,
-0.0111329919,
0.7387372851,
0.9532961845,
-0.2976720631,
0.0053594098,
0.1851579249,
-0.3435469866,
0.1031379178,
-0.0762664527,
0.0079610562,
-0.3169641197,
0.4042804539,
1.1462275982,
0.3843274117,
-1.2835789919,
0.2388726473,
-0.003999637,
-0.4530830085,
-0.2343969047,
0.3626825809,
0.2161670178,
0.3991984129,
0.0992151946,
-0.3284472525,
-0.1889999509,
-0.4174510241,
0.4070718586,
0.0455772914,
-0.5410084128,
-0.4276737571,
0.5602045655,
0.2086516321,
-0.4230212867,
0.8129108548,
-0.2418400347,
-0.5857447386,
0.5924986005,
0.417165041,
0.911260128,
-0.1264674515,
0.3887370229,
0.5521610379,
-0.0680589676,
-0.3711293638,
0.1703630537,
-0.1107645184,
-0.4511547089,
-0.7036318779,
-0.9141678214,
-0.6496991515,
-0.0238436218,
-0.3830352724,
0.1249935627,
-0.9869825244,
0.0264357589,
-0.3560226262,
-0.0572459176,
-0.3151012957,
0.1703711152,
0.1419109255,
0.6256031394,
-0.456099093,
1.0795762539,
0.8269777298,
-0.1373035312,
-0.7979254127,
0.2056609541,
0.005041305,
-0.8404707909,
0.6838918924,
-0.2954932451,
-0.2377654314,
0.2075571716,
-0.4299609363,
-0.9581152797,
0.8944368958,
0.5601148605,
-1.0112866163,
-0.0238790382,
0.0241094846,
0.5336729288,
-0.1931890249,
0.2903929055,
0.6271746159,
0.6826018691,
0.2726206779,
-0.9064939618,
0.076889284,
0.2259444594,
0.0074661807,
0.5254201293,
-0.863239944,
0.4737973511,
-0.5526033044,
0.0610608608,
-0.0632517114,
0.8009854555,
0.5617566109,
-0.2142634094,
0.6294814944,
0.8254845142,
0.6110912561,
0.1753782481,
1.001704216,
-0.3694226742,
0.4561811686,
1.0696040392,
-0.1492770165,
1.1632782221,
0.4804681242,
-0.3716883659,
0.4741221964,
0.6905601621,
0.1221105605,
0.50493294,
0.6968974471,
-0.3581132293,
-0.2321218848,
0.0471703671,
-0.0272261687,
0.0273432061,
0.071292378,
-0.0249143969,
-0.3477799296,
0.1021391898,
0.2105333805,
0.1182871833,
0.1401520818,
0.5764921904,
-0.0885461047,
-0.8082812428,
0.9539731741,
0.3008471131,
0.6272058487,
-0.6089952588,
-0.2004193217,
-0.1280990094,
0.3865846992,
-0.3504078686,
-0.3916171193,
0.4076212943,
-0.1526842415,
-0.2321104705,
-0.2579060793,
0.4562807083,
-0.4622053802,
-0.2448693961,
0.4827168882,
0.0205332953,
0.0375082269,
-0.122386314,
-0.8152320385,
0.4084963202,
0.0307548456,
-0.3936996162,
0.6105877757,
-0.1939291805,
-0.2091982067,
0.9369667768,
0.7210042477,
0.3420162499,
0.1149448529,
0.2506586313,
0.7038705945,
-0.7376943827,
-0.4574500024,
-0.6327794194,
0.0263103545,
0.231692344,
-0.2181186974,
0.2064072788,
0.4430208206,
0.8082259893,
-0.0043311412,
0.633469522,
0.2517246306,
0.6099150181,
-0.3505504131,
0.5077913404,
-0.5248973966,
0.2887472808,
0.1736673415,
-1.0579118729,
-0.2434985936,
0.4162237942,
-0.3271704912,
-0.0664496794,
0.5370458961,
1.1259393692,
-0.1137498319,
-0.1402091682,
0.2283230871,
0.0977877527,
0.5625991821,
0.1904633343,
0.7379992008,
-0.0205576383,
0.5767963529,
-0.438703537,
-0.2780397832,
-0.4527323544,
-0.6947762966,
-0.5211315751,
-0.3238239288,
-0.4845530987,
-0.0374145843,
0.3297660947,
1.1706918478,
1.1309293509,
-0.8687865138,
-0.5397475958,
-0.3443302512,
0.1343601197,
-0.3167996109,
-0.2272868454,
0.3375865519,
-0.5068569183,
-0.6014065742,
0.5551247001,
0.3290534616,
-0.3198985457,
-0.6917082667,
-0.5764134526,
-0.3441879451,
-0.0342518836,
0.4431781471,
0.7363638282,
-0.7748223543,
-0.2821754217,
-0.361143589,
0.0934836268,
-0.2064688057,
0.8282292485,
-0.8111849427,
0.1972765625,
0.6680335402,
0.9999196529,
0.7057561278,
0.1143271998,
0.5597513914,
-0.6259936094,
0.3856428564,
0.1811249703,
-0.1057497188,
-0.0065676775,
-0.3411489427,
0.3496101499,
0.4662280381,
-0.5866208673,
-0.9063802361,
0.2075690925,
-0.6730542183,
-0.2827374935,
1.0222553015,
0.0924391225,
-0.3205958307,
0.2002154738,
-0.2729738951,
0.2452027947,
-0.5399585366,
0.7649963498,
0.4417077601,
-0.4566081762,
-0.4852593243,
-0.6944935322,
0.5758653879,
0.5524722338,
-0.8720766306,
0.2000598162,
0.4036953747,
0.0728422776,
-0.1547668725,
0.3568410575,
-0.0473420732,
0.1894655973,
-0.2770673037,
0.1272250265,
-0.2398796231,
-0.4826546311,
-0.0974866375,
0.3380823731,
0.3185696304,
-0.1492725313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14075v1 | EXCEEDS: Extracting Complex Events as Connecting the Dots to Graphs in Scientific Domain | 2024-06-20T07:50:37 | 2024-06-20T07:50:37 | Yi-Fan Lu, Xian-Ling Mao, Bo Wang, Xiao Liu, Heyan Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | It is crucial to utilize events to understand a specific domain. There are
lots of research on event extraction in many domains such as news, finance and
biology domain. However, scientific domain still lacks event extraction
research, including comprehensive datasets and corresponding methods. Compared
to other domains, scientific domain presents two characteristics: denser
nuggets and more complex events. To solve the above problem, considering these
two characteristics, we first construct SciEvents, a large-scale multi-event
document-level dataset with a schema tailored for scientific domain. It has
2,508 documents and 24,381 events under refined annotation and quality control.
Then, we propose EXCEEDS, a novel end-to-end scientific event extraction
framework by storing dense nuggets in a grid matrix and simplifying complex
event extraction into a dot construction and connection task. Experimental
results demonstrate state-of-the-art performances of EXCEEDS on SciEvents.
Additionally, we release SciEvents and EXCEEDS on GitHub. | [
-0.5195307136,
-0.5681159496,
0.5368953347,
0.2770830691,
-0.2282688916,
0.4426780641,
-0.1267134398,
-0.8199463487,
0.4391955733,
0.0030923258,
-0.5504072905,
-0.3805934489,
-0.6459532976,
0.2782213688,
-0.3846808076,
1.1588766575,
-0.0003517935,
-0.183104068,
-0.5828366876,
0.2264242172,
0.1498682797,
-0.4425190091,
-0.5007948875,
-0.3425714076,
0.6426938176,
0.3864552081,
0.2171301544,
0.459469378,
0.7005179524,
0.2166617066,
-0.117401801,
0.7731518745,
-0.7404944301,
0.0808138773,
-0.0886577517,
-0.1145523414,
-0.3810969889,
0.0429078713,
0.6659976244,
0.8216704726,
0.415325433,
0.1148729175,
-0.279471457,
0.5247281194,
-0.54231745,
0.4018814266,
-0.3627854884,
0.3154979646,
-0.437264055,
-0.4892710149,
-0.3751445115,
-0.4426729381,
0.0297198761,
-0.8381162286,
0.2185122073,
-0.2196510881,
1.0876208544,
-0.3306915462,
-0.6435762644,
-0.1070042178,
-0.4109838903,
0.7055974603,
-0.152266115,
0.283514291,
0.2043241113,
0.307782203,
-0.4454619288,
-1.0890654325,
-0.4636573792,
-0.1132907793,
0.1111796498,
-0.0427171327,
-0.3951668441,
-0.1809067428,
0.570104003,
-0.0192117114,
-0.6992524266,
0.0859988928,
-0.6784598231,
0.0887275562,
0.9529684782,
0.3404771984,
0.3188175559,
-0.149367094,
-0.2632701099,
-0.0351132601,
-0.9612334371,
-0.0196481179,
0.1097386256,
0.1183892339,
0.1795223504,
0.7151033282,
-0.4256146848,
0.2065194547,
0.1319146305,
0.1233904213,
0.3134056628,
-0.4559599757,
0.1756192446,
0.1786055565,
0.5104167461,
0.2783291638,
0.2096463889,
-0.3235339224,
0.4192356169,
-0.1781253815,
-0.1249048784,
-1.1930611134,
-0.384683311,
0.4219209254,
-0.1428468525,
-0.3031347394,
-0.0552935936,
-0.7616699934,
-0.6220273972,
-0.4736845195,
0.3415206373,
-0.4582863152,
-0.1437397748,
0.1095489636,
-0.4074855745,
0.011315587,
0.5652416945,
-0.3399305642,
0.2131258696,
0.8445675969,
1.0669039488,
-0.4145335555,
-0.1496337205,
-0.7100216746,
0.2740196288,
-0.3114796579,
1.1033676863,
-0.8426616788,
-0.5499750972,
-0.3316718638,
-0.078762494,
0.2099402696,
-0.2172891349,
0.5317769647,
-0.8814895749,
-0.0753180161,
-0.6680560708,
-0.7730639577,
-0.1007560566,
-0.0787963271,
-0.3813913465,
0.8037138581,
-0.0528744049,
-0.6006540656,
0.4935795963,
-0.8320064545,
-0.6998912096,
0.5507833958,
-0.3974096179,
-0.5230640173,
0.0075152558,
0.13182199,
0.5566202402,
-0.1723389328,
0.4192478955,
-0.5378264785,
-0.1158719435,
0.3396616876,
0.0882684737,
0.7719464898,
0.1825402081,
-0.1038552001,
0.2393007576,
-1.1926676035,
0.1200628504,
0.210332647,
0.017618997,
-0.278862685,
0.1544608921,
0.1597565711,
0.2389828414,
0.3291612267,
-0.9005330801,
0.5765603185,
0.0480905585,
0.5653966069,
0.6040161848,
0.2540250719,
0.3653261364,
0.0241843071,
0.4320492446,
-0.0734077021,
0.1497242749,
-0.2319128364,
-0.3118891716,
-0.1760372072,
-0.3182914853,
0.1219992116,
0.2157802284,
-0.4556277394,
0.6425576806,
-0.6346559525,
-0.7077255249,
0.2967330813,
-0.2704722583,
0.1146196797,
0.3802481294,
0.1611980349,
-0.1678481847,
-1.0607017279,
-0.5135575533,
0.0774787441,
0.1954555213,
-0.0898065567,
0.0304393508,
0.6439990997,
-0.1937857419,
1.0392993689,
-1.0002963543,
-0.1979265511,
0.0712306648,
0.1814208031,
0.2560052574,
0.2417497337,
0.5374082923,
-1.071439147,
-0.5054319501,
0.5688894391,
-0.8375740051,
-0.1469679326,
-0.1659919024,
-0.0053291908,
-0.2930784822,
0.4662139118,
-0.5133010149,
0.3481774926,
0.255744487,
-0.5117483139,
0.9431400895,
0.2000633329,
0.0691282079,
-0.7623973489,
0.1660072505,
-0.0318127684,
-0.2864783108,
-0.7008517981,
-0.2700622082,
0.1907960624,
-0.1582395583,
-0.1698068231,
0.374214381,
-0.4287140071,
-0.3523976803,
-0.3001852334,
0.2223388404,
0.5145034194,
0.0781400651,
0.1751826108,
0.7144898772,
0.5907338262,
-0.5356627703,
0.5976490378,
0.4379906654,
-0.3906264305,
0.5695305467,
-0.7804315686,
-0.1505511105,
-0.1314113438,
0.5150637627,
-0.6809921861,
-0.3082465231,
-0.2292122096,
-0.5710229278,
0.3489101827,
0.0538414903,
-0.4119805992,
-0.4780699909,
-0.3069280088,
0.0150664505,
0.1855146587,
-0.5769273639,
0.4500289857,
0.5647897124,
-0.474409163,
-0.5255944133,
-0.2013527304,
0.488819629,
0.0270312149,
-0.6155388951,
0.102979742,
-0.3061481416,
-0.0336397178,
0.0338263214,
-0.1251306981,
-0.0561707504,
-0.1930598319,
0.5442706943,
0.1212095246,
-0.1771542728,
-0.0120172827,
0.236608237,
-0.2306362838,
0.0501749776,
-0.4967037737,
0.3120115101,
-0.2306383699,
-0.4001168609,
-0.4240067899,
0.6175174117,
0.57426548,
-0.1514714062,
0.4930884242,
0.6924597621,
-0.5317775011,
-0.0539526641,
-0.3666951358,
-0.2347095311,
-0.4860718548,
0.857428968,
-0.5865181088,
-0.8138076067,
0.7034583688,
-0.433796972,
0.1274254173,
0.5125469565,
0.0946057215,
-0.061404977,
1.1656897068,
0.2512488961,
0.3528046608,
0.3796992004,
-0.2429874688,
0.1790352017,
-0.8909855485,
-0.6818953753,
-0.6260439157,
-0.014377187,
0.1677297503,
-0.2894010842,
0.6944848299,
0.2259899825,
-0.1143550873,
0.4210061133,
-0.4023240507,
0.7383459806,
0.1988760233,
-0.2045720518,
0.1910418272,
0.2789027989,
0.2825505733,
-0.3248044848,
-0.7615261078,
-0.2709149718,
0.7783242464,
0.0982323363,
0.3565171361,
-0.1349981427,
0.3400411904,
0.2283457816,
0.2811941504,
-0.4210934341,
0.3761152625,
-0.0725875348,
-0.4727763534,
-0.4152764678,
-0.5951546431,
-1.0113915205,
0.1646623909,
-0.2083196342,
-0.6996285319,
0.7923876047,
-0.4486563504,
-0.1448707134,
0.2993597686,
-0.6091556549,
0.4901510179,
0.0052876929,
-0.2144637406,
-0.0056688115,
-0.6294609308,
0.187775135,
-0.3640168607,
0.3983358741,
-0.1924038976,
0.1114152744,
0.776738584,
-0.310683161,
0.7981240153,
0.1983269304,
0.2191568762,
0.2953554094,
0.3273518384,
0.9858154655,
0.2508134246,
-0.1085528508,
0.2884721756,
0.1717998981,
-0.5396233797,
-0.4998474419,
0.8220854998,
-0.7377123237,
-0.1608821303,
-0.2886954844,
-0.3802841008,
0.020992998,
0.3156035244,
0.2437799424,
0.7775331736,
-0.0402374789,
0.2174594551,
0.6076234579,
0.1464227587,
0.3559155464,
0.6195264459,
0.0597101375,
-0.4023910165,
1.0958132744,
0.4202788174,
0.0921054929,
0.2182555348,
0.1562830508,
-0.3377532959,
-0.7479756474,
-0.4684301019,
0.0510316566,
-0.7718275189,
-0.6189396977,
-1.1598507166,
-0.3544500768,
-0.6990160346,
-0.5750593543,
-0.1938354969,
-0.7126902342,
-0.5973655581,
-0.4564301074,
0.5663717389,
0.7012323737,
-0.5713452697,
-0.0063811084,
-0.9774842262,
0.261777699,
-0.0111767054,
0.2568162084,
0.0241053812,
-0.2637631297,
-0.2660512328,
-0.3309877515,
-0.2523943186,
-0.6748893857,
0.5427624583,
0.6664507985,
0.4331391156,
0.8656586409,
0.1068352237,
1.0681800842,
-0.6638097763,
0.6707683802,
0.4890842736,
-0.9467371702,
0.5665554404,
-0.3508975208,
0.0549590401,
0.2290693223,
0.7634133697,
-0.6373271942,
-0.0945558921,
-0.8756157756,
-1.000643611,
0.6165552735,
0.3384456038,
-0.2430838197,
-0.1103614196,
0.6553640366,
0.4591394365,
0.1396173388,
-0.5287893414,
-0.2117165625,
0.1730932444,
0.1770038605,
-0.0738831908,
-0.2445167452,
-0.2983177602,
-0.0395665839,
0.5807633996,
-0.0528913848,
-0.184421882,
0.4346545637,
0.1481689513,
-0.4495643973,
-0.2022009045,
0.5706964135,
1.0270556211,
-0.1056537032,
0.3931980133,
0.1996920407,
-0.6640520692,
-0.3603883386,
0.3395164013,
-0.0324012153,
-0.0061537209,
0.6348136067,
0.5117152929,
0.0253683161,
-0.8196501136,
0.3848997951,
0.0798569918,
-0.2293456942,
-0.3230093122,
0.0579292774,
-0.0831903443,
0.4569215775,
0.8694376349,
-0.10287375,
0.520204246,
-0.3367207944,
0.681117475,
0.2384885699,
-0.5747384429,
-0.5752530694,
0.6131876707,
0.1305354089,
0.1327735931,
0.2591272295,
-0.4575495422,
-0.5530449748,
0.9746366143,
0.5853742957,
0.2605738938,
0.0453736112,
0.2905211449,
0.523401916,
0.0713329464,
0.2158535421,
0.3007241786,
-0.0578544922,
-0.1693403423,
-0.9594640732,
-0.6800569296,
-0.2715971768,
-0.0515624098,
-0.3969582021,
0.310526371,
-0.1351561546,
-0.0160966869,
0.6937358975,
0.5785036087,
-0.2757184505,
-0.0252305456,
-0.0080922889,
0.844617188,
-0.982519269,
0.4598073959,
0.4432233274,
-0.3006112874,
-0.1331991106,
-1.1968585253,
0.087082468,
-0.4723810554,
0.7941340208,
-0.1120197028,
0.2102392465,
-0.0884023383,
-0.6293917894,
-1.1296274662,
0.7758048773,
0.0436035283,
-0.8215357065,
0.1820729077,
0.0307277571,
0.5533257127,
-0.3318932354,
0.1447180659,
0.0764263198,
0.6829823256,
0.6768827438,
-0.5171895027,
0.1014277712,
-0.3197937012,
-0.545773685,
0.4469509125,
-0.3418929875,
0.5299383998,
-0.4855921566,
-0.3667242825,
-0.2997627258,
0.9143704176,
0.3783023953,
0.8449220657,
0.009957863,
0.0780888423,
0.9902510047,
-0.1472587138,
0.980469048,
0.2383781374,
0.478300035,
0.8916607499,
-0.4988211691,
0.4026726186,
0.0884642452,
-0.4150674641,
0.1679450274,
0.8477455378,
-0.1244416907,
0.1805383712,
0.2223691195,
-0.2539212406,
-0.4385866225,
-0.2840258181,
-0.6491045952,
-0.1174287125,
0.940119803,
0.2085621655,
-0.4378655255,
0.1981674582,
-0.0001239202,
-0.1494919956,
-0.3298151791,
0.5152057409,
0.2309390754,
0.0582181811,
0.19762142,
-0.2957461774,
0.1028629914,
-0.7298057675,
-0.1074563116,
0.0873583183,
-0.2343751192,
-0.481127739,
-1.0057039261,
0.2439864129,
-0.2112818807,
-0.2236321718,
0.0902027562,
0.8600296378,
-0.2268880457,
-0.4733541906,
0.0358065553,
0.0658328459,
0.4653095603,
-0.094430007,
-0.3603514731,
0.0257485546,
-0.1196081266,
-0.3047338128,
0.3375094235,
0.7624197006,
-0.3955800831,
0.5465818644,
1.1052504778,
0.3143948913,
0.1853239834,
0.1552333534,
0.9802969694,
-0.6186735034,
-0.4107280076,
-0.5688910484,
0.1963780075,
-0.6925678253,
-0.3414776623,
0.79895401,
0.8891997933,
0.3380840123,
0.1302866191,
0.7578150034,
-0.0897715613,
0.1904001236,
0.1021836475,
0.3200500309,
-0.3721985519,
-0.1651915461,
-0.0939922929,
-0.7104544044,
-0.8155609965,
0.1272871941,
-0.3095491529,
-0.3875266612,
0.3648777902,
0.2165046483,
-0.0498444512,
0.3449829519,
0.2846314013,
0.3232532144,
0.8644556403,
0.4055510461,
0.8958087564,
-0.3273900449,
0.4794311225,
0.1837736815,
-0.3733375669,
-0.6159704924,
-0.8813370466,
-0.6928523779,
-0.8190664053,
-0.6002086997,
-0.2685376406,
0.2164409161,
0.7074776888,
0.8825632334,
-0.8875020146,
0.3158008754,
0.0421316959,
0.1891605109,
-0.1201316118,
-0.2712309659,
0.9439302087,
-0.459589541,
-0.5754266381,
0.518225193,
0.5903965235,
-0.0170415547,
0.2427785397,
0.2463887036,
0.0040840763,
0.0318055861,
0.9872580767,
0.6682277322,
0.1051080376,
-0.324200213,
0.0150715206,
0.052664835,
0.0874108076,
0.7222399712,
-0.5508306623,
0.430739373,
0.6494406462,
0.4523352087,
0.8810059428,
-0.2815797925,
0.3754513562,
-0.797281146,
-0.0534786098,
0.2426233739,
0.1025099307,
0.0012276756,
-0.741050601,
0.5160108805,
0.2446506917,
-0.6787444949,
-1.1188471317,
0.3123392761,
-1.3442965746,
-0.4712767601,
1.2045131922,
0.0419437885,
-0.2211454213,
-0.4938528836,
-0.0453318432,
0.0908082053,
-0.2544175088,
0.8629841805,
0.3953525424,
-0.6987575889,
0.3260053992,
-0.3317985833,
0.4924249649,
-0.1434088051,
-0.9363875985,
0.1391852647,
0.5531553626,
0.0742990822,
0.5753552318,
0.2224266529,
-0.3153950572,
0.3646174073,
0.1070860028,
0.0897781178,
-0.4348603189,
-0.6545532942,
-0.1185414419,
0.6375880837,
-0.4552204609,
0.1446750462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14051v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14051v1 | How Many Parameters Does it Take to Change a Light Bulb? Evaluating Performance in Self-Play of Conversational Games as a Function of Model Characteristics | 2024-06-20T07:17:09 | 2024-06-20T07:17:09 | Nidhir Bhavsar, Jonathan Jordan, Sherzod Hakimov, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | What makes a good Large Language Model (LLM)? That it performs well on the
relevant benchmarks -- which hopefully measure, with some validity, the
presence of capabilities that are also challenged in real application. But what
makes the model perform well? What gives a model its abilities? We take a
recently introduced type of benchmark that is meant to challenge capabilities
in a goal-directed, agentive context through self-play of conversational games,
and analyse how performance develops as a function of model characteristics
like number of parameters, or type of training. We find that while there is a
clear relationship between number of parameters and performance, there is still
a wide spread of performance points within a given size bracket, which is to be
accounted for by training parameters such as fine-tuning data quality and
method. From a more practical angle, we also find a certain degree of
unpredictability about performance across access methods, possible due to
unexposed sampling parameters, and a, very welcome, performance stability
against at least moderate weight quantisation during inference. | [
-0.3389216959,
-0.7630633712,
0.6216860414,
0.450025022,
-0.1216333061,
-0.231393829,
-0.1877212673,
-0.5558683276,
-0.3020611107,
0.5539465547,
-0.2430262566,
-0.108964555,
-0.3616190553,
0.0170448385,
-0.5758075118,
0.7992101312,
0.1747490168,
0.2026845515,
-0.3512721956,
-0.2357547432,
-0.5596367717,
-0.3098035455,
-0.5711406469,
-0.4070317149,
0.5319893956,
0.507160008,
0.6725099683,
0.8596137762,
0.6983836293,
0.3595514596,
0.0623457022,
-0.0768510327,
-0.744653821,
0.3553369641,
-0.0671759024,
-0.8225023746,
-0.2401695549,
0.2939300537,
0.6566336751,
0.5823061466,
-0.1195653006,
0.3513897359,
0.2364563048,
0.556014061,
-0.0794633478,
0.3056818247,
-0.7533270121,
-0.1981307715,
-0.1361270994,
-0.263089776,
-0.2363682687,
0.0500342026,
0.0923357308,
-0.5511863232,
0.4219030142,
0.1611757278,
0.641158998,
0.1839052141,
-0.4098377228,
-0.16676642,
-1.0263134241,
0.8595753908,
-0.8649569154,
0.2596779168,
0.2519513667,
0.4653331339,
-0.1487485915,
-0.4910497069,
-0.1471924633,
-0.4491219223,
0.2430954129,
0.0714210793,
0.0110245878,
0.1878685951,
0.6303846836,
0.2576594651,
-0.2473161221,
0.1382272542,
-0.5021417141,
0.2023021132,
1.0039281845,
0.4052407444,
-0.1275940239,
0.0403567106,
-0.2777687609,
-0.1616898179,
-0.6792550087,
0.2676438391,
0.6227173209,
0.3973100185,
0.0178942401,
0.370793432,
-0.3318403661,
0.5471593142,
0.094879806,
-0.1672764122,
-0.1548861861,
-0.1888501644,
0.0519153737,
-0.2087583244,
0.7559216619,
0.3396662176,
0.2751034796,
-0.2963783145,
-0.151861012,
-0.0986906886,
0.337338686,
-0.8002790213,
-0.3074311316,
0.1534135193,
-0.5666218996,
-0.2179984301,
-0.1656384617,
-0.6860676408,
-0.3914189041,
-0.192570582,
0.6650511026,
-0.5559436083,
-0.0795237944,
0.1630078256,
-0.1149415448,
0.3929511905,
0.3247103393,
-1.1000268459,
0.6103991866,
0.6333028078,
0.8122929931,
-0.2927940488,
-0.4757364392,
-0.2343281657,
-0.1032605395,
-0.3850309551,
0.6153669357,
-0.6327201724,
-0.6373725533,
-0.0816688389,
-0.3150212765,
0.0027579868,
-0.6602469683,
0.2613059282,
-0.519264102,
-0.1004524454,
-0.5461477041,
-0.7886184454,
0.0952009931,
0.0826591477,
-0.7230608463,
0.9323388338,
-0.0135301286,
-0.399117291,
0.4676490128,
-0.6148727536,
-0.4458859861,
0.1673231423,
-0.2285885811,
-0.1996077001,
0.6191239953,
-0.1493916661,
0.198150292,
-0.274145335,
-0.0103219189,
-0.3643978536,
-0.5451627374,
0.5219745636,
-0.7140823007,
0.3450119197,
0.1907179803,
-0.2353184521,
-0.0299491938,
-1.0350034237,
0.2566221356,
-0.0101041151,
-0.5411823988,
0.0736419708,
0.495331496,
-0.0069889147,
0.300951153,
0.1595934778,
-0.4016906619,
0.0349096656,
-0.2955908775,
0.5167673826,
0.4423738122,
0.0891772509,
0.2743569314,
-0.3613327742,
0.5950185061,
-0.0956207439,
0.335958451,
-0.2150246203,
-0.511241138,
-0.9013074636,
-0.0079006767,
0.5258476138,
0.1898889989,
-0.4655972123,
0.1361641139,
0.2354319692,
-0.8107545376,
-0.5483970046,
0.3061323464,
0.392990917,
0.3143714666,
0.1675910652,
-0.3586565256,
-0.1618515849,
-0.8156729341,
-0.4934261441,
-0.575884819,
0.0898210034,
0.7128974795,
0.4173995554,
0.3759657145,
0.7875424623,
-0.2541233301,
-0.070197247,
-0.1569786817,
0.3619804978,
0.1082426235,
0.4266084135,
0.615793407,
-0.5092282891,
-0.3124641776,
-0.2446284443,
-0.815839231,
-0.3686744571,
-0.0915161818,
0.2402746975,
-0.0459324121,
0.6483955383,
-0.4774438143,
0.1997088939,
0.7491308451,
-0.1976713538,
0.5700748563,
-0.5896306038,
0.3947179317,
-0.3840533793,
-0.0165756121,
0.0655622929,
0.1161364317,
-0.5592187047,
0.4347973168,
-0.0795680583,
-0.0587031245,
-0.4720902443,
0.554384172,
-0.5771439672,
-0.2981101573,
-0.3136210442,
0.1184547246,
0.0799928904,
0.2252893597,
-0.3324981034,
0.9363924861,
0.5854035616,
-0.8503042459,
0.4625768661,
-0.0310413148,
-0.4610099196,
0.5109595656,
-0.8311476111,
0.115610607,
0.0929752216,
-0.2341824323,
-1.3299291134,
-0.0164672118,
-0.2759286165,
-0.2154999375,
0.0579005033,
-0.071857661,
-0.6742927432,
-0.2051638216,
0.1136990637,
0.4486169219,
0.3909633756,
-0.2166799009,
0.4287058413,
0.0209402945,
0.1838738024,
-0.0112620099,
-0.4512658119,
0.1609872282,
-0.4683783948,
-0.4887792766,
0.4342587292,
-0.4605081975,
-0.2556105256,
-0.322506845,
-0.0101457024,
0.0671571344,
0.4780488908,
0.1762526482,
-0.3158941865,
-0.2883624732,
0.4512206018,
-0.3016186059,
-0.0653091446,
0.4118281901,
0.1478778422,
0.5468941927,
-0.3241553307,
-0.5314515233,
-0.0758173987,
0.2206324637,
0.2783797979,
-0.2265797853,
0.4465391934,
0.2412025034,
0.1096940041,
-0.279338181,
-0.5793127418,
-0.2217816412,
-0.5420370102,
0.5773242116,
-0.6286582351,
-0.7514126897,
1.0084632635,
0.0398705266,
-0.1140783355,
0.3575723767,
0.3907444179,
-0.2187074423,
1.2092452049,
0.643765986,
0.3096310496,
0.4052532017,
0.1395810992,
0.0862670466,
-0.5146278143,
-0.1242573336,
-0.5908785462,
-0.4933025241,
-0.8966667056,
-0.3559885323,
0.3216462433,
0.1780775785,
-0.2454473227,
0.2697050869,
0.0083188852,
0.5436888933,
0.6161639094,
0.1498077065,
0.4199654758,
-0.4778335989,
0.209441781,
-0.1781353951,
-0.7646474838,
-0.5434430242,
0.9917443991,
0.4987257421,
1.0865994692,
0.4268880486,
0.6879281998,
0.0695001855,
-0.0142494943,
-0.6569663882,
0.7679737806,
0.1248686239,
-0.9747648239,
-0.5237765312,
-0.5018564463,
-0.8194817305,
0.1236553416,
-0.1304329038,
-0.6826097369,
-0.0093432572,
0.2445793003,
-0.3417496979,
0.0821176767,
-0.752834022,
0.8415167928,
-0.8242227435,
-0.5327609181,
-0.3557655513,
-0.3159977198,
0.1127870008,
-0.0554779917,
-0.213461116,
-0.2881310284,
-0.1643559635,
0.7017748952,
0.1043574587,
0.7612376809,
-0.0634495541,
-0.0059963334,
0.1965772659,
0.3782709539,
0.1042927429,
0.2065991014,
-0.2353982925,
0.2246330231,
0.3893092275,
-0.4577109814,
-0.900374949,
0.4508055151,
-0.7729283571,
-0.9734381437,
-0.2810611427,
-0.6147794724,
-0.7016208768,
0.1386407167,
0.2159827054,
0.5098034143,
-0.6003149748,
0.431558758,
0.673671782,
-0.3100153208,
0.5971506834,
0.6717191935,
-0.2798689902,
0.2854186893,
0.8296380639,
0.5327885151,
0.5905457735,
0.2545737028,
0.3208591342,
-0.2534808517,
-0.8412961364,
-0.3393601775,
0.1187491938,
-0.7101979256,
0.0415463336,
-0.1634828597,
-0.2784078717,
-0.0379531384,
0.2982094884,
-0.4583903849,
-0.0444210134,
-0.4908287525,
0.157588318,
0.3117605448,
0.962972343,
0.0564431921,
0.6490231752,
-0.5537212491,
-0.0498393141,
0.5196859837,
0.835555017,
0.1181420907,
-0.8372331262,
-0.3423365951,
-0.2218814641,
-0.2706851363,
-0.8377465606,
0.2060949206,
0.3002145588,
0.7836341858,
0.6572870016,
-0.0703963712,
0.6359320283,
-0.6920853853,
0.8389161229,
0.0348985009,
-0.8068877459,
0.2509249151,
-0.6614086032,
0.2956807017,
0.5314548016,
0.094541572,
-0.3623592854,
-0.2813315392,
-0.8863610029,
-0.467246294,
0.6650220156,
0.0984185338,
0.6365986466,
0.0112606687,
0.419721216,
0.0373653695,
0.3681103885,
-0.5137923956,
-0.3299283981,
-0.1763294637,
0.1161946878,
-0.2167066187,
-0.5507723093,
-0.2541979253,
-0.1755036116,
0.3663425148,
-0.1997105777,
0.2967780232,
-0.1906321943,
0.1795287281,
-0.0454883203,
0.2325347215,
0.581402421,
1.069890976,
-0.3445565104,
0.0789080933,
0.1467385441,
0.0189773925,
-0.0793367028,
0.0844335854,
0.1164772734,
-0.3084807396,
0.470908463,
0.6926470995,
0.470240742,
-0.6263650656,
0.2950886488,
-0.0039762175,
-0.1326944828,
0.1920591146,
0.7116689086,
-0.0522534959,
0.4738706052,
0.4241938889,
-0.3372919261,
0.2570773661,
-0.7627694011,
0.2299986184,
0.5094508529,
-0.4923752248,
-0.3676041067,
0.6487319469,
0.3539708853,
-0.6933071613,
0.09102045,
-0.2872708738,
-0.0894398615,
0.6798642874,
0.5764154792,
0.529859066,
-0.198885262,
0.3743804991,
0.150982663,
0.1727842689,
-0.1854485869,
0.0738315061,
0.174939692,
-0.7368451953,
-0.1925721765,
-0.321839571,
-0.3999054432,
0.165686056,
-0.5761471391,
-0.1241780818,
-0.6121526957,
-0.3329647779,
0.1380480826,
0.3016274571,
-0.739389956,
0.2399554849,
0.0388851874,
0.8749184012,
-0.8078264594,
0.458779633,
0.2712206542,
-0.5861127377,
-0.5342758298,
-0.1570665389,
-0.1278154701,
-0.8556217551,
0.5037522912,
-0.1626824886,
0.0497728474,
0.0027578198,
-0.7392500639,
-1.1035245657,
0.7747268081,
0.3784439266,
-0.5233719349,
-0.0659933463,
0.213504374,
0.8548824191,
-0.4077030718,
0.4891600609,
0.7047636509,
0.1495965272,
-0.0976938307,
-0.8992037773,
-0.2596370578,
0.1030552164,
0.2676732838,
-0.2338708639,
-1.1305458546,
0.8147290349,
-0.1486753821,
-0.1431788653,
0.3591732085,
0.685377717,
0.2572928369,
0.096462436,
0.3331399858,
0.1882029325,
0.4520946145,
-0.2004820853,
0.9574801922,
-0.5541025996,
0.4706463218,
0.9142208099,
-0.4852728844,
0.8430908322,
0.4827195108,
-0.417278111,
0.0854123309,
0.4228146374,
-0.2986818254,
0.3318791091,
0.3431593478,
0.0344719514,
-0.4431257546,
0.1943111867,
-0.218494311,
0.9559608698,
0.0320266373,
-0.3884325027,
-0.2631407082,
-0.3140233755,
-0.1461861432,
0.344284147,
-0.1199205369,
0.6983591318,
0.0343505293,
-0.7297459841,
0.0848378986,
0.0803819448,
0.2650405765,
-0.6522873044,
-0.2124314159,
-0.219361648,
0.192954421,
0.0956865102,
-0.783400476,
-0.2386460602,
-0.3168342113,
-0.2455809414,
-0.0426897891,
0.3782277405,
-0.177121982,
-0.6060317755,
0.4033195972,
0.7856681943,
0.2625259161,
0.1660847664,
-0.9659739137,
0.3545965552,
-0.3217740059,
-0.2534837127,
0.4954228103,
0.6220257282,
0.303876549,
0.7896634936,
0.3103784621,
0.2826949656,
0.1155482605,
0.1495472938,
0.4507098496,
-0.7558774352,
-0.3874142766,
-0.7456217408,
0.1436949223,
-0.0486892536,
-0.7748686075,
0.9828214645,
0.4723959565,
0.6720625758,
0.1200660393,
0.4877743423,
0.1737646908,
0.3700701296,
-0.5840178132,
0.5873366594,
-0.3910502791,
0.4667100012,
-0.3080607057,
-0.9785169363,
0.0192803591,
0.4896630347,
-0.4278437495,
0.684389174,
0.4258534312,
0.7608056068,
0.1827620417,
-0.1177763715,
0.8259401917,
0.2087196708,
0.5952185988,
0.3377308846,
0.9763906002,
-0.550597012,
0.5248554349,
0.0282665752,
-0.0449828543,
-0.3516524434,
-0.9359742403,
-0.75465101,
-0.6613008976,
-0.370652169,
-0.3646571636,
0.1311641484,
0.4955866635,
1.0456231833,
-0.6282457113,
-0.6314417124,
0.0701564699,
-0.1615556926,
-0.5062003732,
-0.2027819902,
-0.0097134104,
-0.6279187202,
-0.5520036817,
0.3514831662,
0.042733036,
-0.2139293998,
-0.6983064413,
0.0100581655,
0.0136697264,
0.4377986789,
0.5118547082,
0.4161233902,
-0.7028791308,
-0.5061354637,
0.0493156761,
-0.1245231926,
0.2102195621,
0.677156508,
-0.5659343004,
0.6263822317,
0.1800098717,
0.5158388615,
0.5926492214,
0.175882712,
0.5487712026,
-0.7727718353,
-0.1608631611,
-0.0064354655,
0.1764281541,
0.196219489,
-0.068800211,
0.3952585161,
0.1628346741,
-0.8091079593,
-0.771998167,
0.3323009312,
-0.8148676753,
-0.1998509616,
1.2927360535,
0.061754521,
-0.094185859,
-0.0254063867,
-0.0853020027,
-0.135630548,
-0.2318845838,
0.9431923032,
0.8917268515,
-0.6720487475,
-0.5361782908,
-0.8300604224,
0.7682933807,
0.2157065868,
-0.4907326102,
0.2171621919,
0.3988475502,
0.3629415035,
0.1376204938,
0.4419898689,
0.1084628999,
0.1835982651,
0.2027929127,
-0.1868756711,
-0.0339678563,
-0.5176507235,
-0.4247895479,
0.1906354278,
0.5735675097,
-0.0944291502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14048v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14048v1 | Prompt Injection Attacks in Defended Systems | 2024-06-20T07:13:25 | 2024-06-20T07:13:25 | Daniil Khomsky, Narek Maloyan, Bulat Nutfullin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models play a crucial role in modern natural language
processing technologies. However, their extensive use also introduces potential
security risks, such as the possibility of black-box attacks. These attacks can
embed hidden malicious features into the model, leading to adverse consequences
during its deployment.
This paper investigates methods for black-box attacks on large language
models with a three-tiered defense mechanism. It analyzes the challenges and
significance of these attacks, highlighting their potential implications for
language processing system security. Existing attack and defense methods are
examined, evaluating their effectiveness and applicability across various
scenarios.
Special attention is given to the detection algorithm for black-box attacks,
identifying hazardous vulnerabilities in language models and retrieving
sensitive information. This research presents a methodology for vulnerability
detection and the development of defensive strategies against black-box attacks
on large language models. | [
-0.2794189453,
-1.4851989746,
0.7457790971,
0.0475885347,
0.0783193186,
0.0455386043,
0.1197425276,
-0.619977653,
-0.4857293963,
0.7504575849,
-0.2940675616,
-0.2361651957,
-0.4957500994,
0.0843308419,
-0.4893728495,
0.6979599595,
0.2517087758,
-0.2095190287,
0.2276483178,
0.2206486613,
-1.1170035601,
-0.7674623132,
-0.6660433412,
0.1522895396,
0.093790561,
-0.1003578529,
0.7968167067,
0.1843037903,
0.3445437849,
0.4065473378,
-0.1815913469,
-0.6128310561,
-0.0209641475,
0.6072168946,
-0.3759683371,
-0.6898775101,
-0.3481149971,
-0.3572382629,
0.5367153883,
0.4377053976,
-0.0294828173,
-0.1484201699,
-0.1673208922,
0.1715213805,
-0.9229310751,
-0.3143647909,
-0.7474915981,
0.24309659,
-0.6218357086,
-0.105552122,
-1.0854384899,
0.0250730701,
0.0261479486,
-0.0827842951,
-0.1129158959,
0.189577803,
0.6551243067,
-0.1308165938,
-0.4630286396,
-0.160779044,
-0.5482730269,
0.8144806623,
-0.8505308628,
-0.0830433741,
0.2430920005,
0.7383463383,
-0.4750192761,
-0.1806214154,
-0.6110229492,
-0.3475026786,
-0.1584687382,
-0.427560091,
-0.9313572645,
0.1491210461,
0.4504620433,
0.2206255794,
-0.5737524033,
0.450694412,
0.0264165793,
-0.1298140585,
0.2655129731,
0.1675106734,
0.7897381186,
-0.4737291932,
-0.3232237697,
-0.0131756356,
-0.8250895143,
-0.0276647545,
0.5697695613,
0.5168146491,
-0.1273410618,
0.511960566,
-0.0647658035,
0.9893195033,
0.039614208,
-0.105344519,
-0.2220010906,
-0.3006212413,
-0.3001225591,
-0.1086142883,
0.8912810683,
-0.0165111274,
0.1645197719,
-0.0547070466,
-0.6303297281,
-0.0518963672,
0.5551418662,
-0.6034023762,
0.2608086467,
0.4215334058,
-0.1918551922,
-0.6038748622,
-0.1553616971,
-1.0233058929,
-0.4913513064,
0.5357762575,
0.526181519,
-0.4753837287,
-0.394071281,
0.1947076023,
-0.2619454563,
0.2644450665,
0.0370766222,
-0.7562741041,
0.4319538474,
0.7891435623,
0.8451983929,
-0.1301041692,
0.1588238329,
-0.9009744525,
0.5585796237,
-0.2276934683,
0.773506701,
-0.6531217098,
-0.3820477724,
0.3924710453,
0.0365944877,
0.3836174011,
-0.3856739402,
0.4322103262,
-0.6102187037,
0.1090177149,
0.1503812224,
-0.2902211845,
0.0143436221,
0.3580623269,
-0.529283762,
0.7459869385,
-0.0227423571,
-0.9697101116,
-0.265561074,
-0.6228419542,
-0.6171995997,
0.4415750802,
0.031940639,
-0.2293219268,
0.2245714366,
0.1905990392,
0.7772889137,
-0.2479963303,
0.1615876257,
-0.4987370074,
-0.0847007036,
0.262650013,
-0.4416554868,
1.1199139357,
0.2312705517,
-0.4321325123,
0.051619038,
-0.7027481198,
-0.1158448607,
0.3864824176,
0.1773153692,
-0.55210042,
-0.0259139705,
-0.3119912744,
-0.025121063,
0.0943331942,
-0.5295525789,
0.2932983935,
-0.6939259171,
0.6123384833,
0.6474026442,
0.5113356113,
0.2981502414,
0.2154889405,
0.8572175503,
0.1745556146,
0.6134926081,
-0.5067322254,
-0.4509598315,
-0.3066807091,
-0.1793273538,
-0.0023656422,
0.9235252142,
-1.0060452223,
0.5436770916,
0.2283652872,
-0.3113334775,
-0.186451003,
-0.1769952476,
0.4736604393,
0.2286593914,
0.3551048338,
0.2967259586,
-0.1079905182,
-1.1434748173,
-0.1844873279,
-0.1706060022,
-0.1850860566,
-0.2619945109,
0.4941437542,
-0.2920183539,
0.5656126142,
-0.6027875543,
0.2827279866,
-0.2088750005,
-0.1189993769,
0.2033200115,
0.6597739458,
0.8600110412,
-0.3079848289,
-0.2439547032,
0.240359202,
-0.7261627316,
-0.265594393,
0.0658396035,
-0.2028947175,
0.1373870671,
0.4372493327,
-0.8277718425,
0.3823491931,
0.3492379785,
-0.4014233053,
0.7476682663,
0.1180715561,
-0.0182591993,
-1.001873374,
-0.134483695,
0.0634071529,
-0.2841660678,
-1.2801926136,
0.7436857224,
0.1662672907,
-0.4929539263,
-0.6507279277,
0.7355104089,
-0.3141937256,
0.1575318724,
-0.1220150217,
-0.1926442832,
0.2370908111,
0.0924723521,
-0.2722287178,
0.656245172,
0.9978508949,
-0.5036341548,
0.2782168686,
-0.0890412405,
-0.2514454722,
1.0061937571,
-0.8374208212,
0.2424521595,
0.0271853581,
0.2117913067,
-0.9534773827,
-0.0188588724,
0.6603674293,
-0.2169047892,
0.7160957456,
-0.2200081348,
-0.3878314495,
-0.4240612388,
-0.4057407081,
0.3953911364,
0.1844982207,
-0.2846689522,
0.4657675326,
0.4359560609,
-0.4153867364,
-0.972561419,
-0.782086432,
0.4844934642,
-0.3878318667,
-0.6342602372,
0.19701536,
0.1482105404,
-0.4098926187,
-0.390633136,
0.2398473769,
-0.0375746749,
0.6475468874,
0.0188957695,
0.3435992002,
-0.1634385586,
-0.1208520159,
-0.0491674468,
-0.1340281665,
0.202100262,
-0.1775612831,
0.5063910484,
0.1482970566,
-0.6109502912,
-0.7225855589,
0.9864371419,
0.5534495711,
-0.1829006821,
0.7502405643,
0.3010153472,
-0.6214863062,
-0.317266494,
-0.7477744222,
-0.1390168369,
-0.4927220643,
0.4601884484,
-0.4764306843,
-0.7139619589,
0.3584563732,
0.4410788715,
0.0054870551,
0.2760526538,
0.4392971992,
0.2143340856,
1.2723088264,
0.4304676056,
0.0190709569,
0.4571015239,
0.1497572809,
0.5965248346,
-0.4958636761,
-0.0903927386,
-0.9666509032,
0.3565910459,
-0.2528726757,
-0.1896332651,
0.1582219303,
0.1118231267,
-0.3070009351,
0.488891691,
-0.5040255189,
0.4028221965,
0.312294811,
-0.1475242376,
0.0238559674,
-0.1467172801,
-0.299854815,
0.2875833213,
-0.3515427709,
-0.5855022669,
0.5888293982,
0.7718859315,
0.7550801635,
0.4188412428,
0.4411025643,
0.4872690439,
0.0386858508,
-0.6065559983,
0.7021983862,
0.2755702734,
-0.5209033489,
-0.163907066,
-0.3939685524,
-0.9844394326,
0.1908238679,
-0.0428522602,
-0.8864064813,
0.1365408748,
-0.1075349525,
-0.5481598973,
0.3003918529,
-1.2408348322,
0.8829313517,
-0.2702045739,
-0.3246799409,
0.0107940519,
-0.3439056277,
0.582128644,
-0.2370740324,
0.219392091,
0.2093596607,
0.1250687987,
0.3541601896,
-0.2207160741,
0.8884970546,
-0.4401742816,
-0.455432117,
0.0455559343,
0.6270576715,
0.6766024828,
0.2282509655,
-0.1089270711,
0.1643405706,
0.1536144018,
-0.7474853396,
-0.4354825318,
0.5785492659,
-0.3619272411,
-1.3931241035,
-0.5076721311,
-0.275011301,
-0.1183079481,
0.2721947134,
-0.0949637443,
0.3842345476,
-0.0824983791,
-0.0543928556,
0.5385064483,
-0.9808658361,
0.7390114665,
0.5930305719,
-0.0183181055,
-0.2186892033,
0.5879878402,
-0.0425383523,
0.6921549439,
0.4364435375,
0.022960946,
0.010870304,
-0.9351720214,
-0.3411106467,
0.0548639335,
-0.5581341386,
-0.7546947002,
-0.8229833245,
-0.0761231631,
-0.6122891307,
-0.0892889872,
0.0171353351,
-0.0714295208,
0.0569998436,
-0.1760791242,
0.1782374531,
0.8302517533,
0.5394208431,
0.4926805794,
-0.623160243,
0.2008124441,
0.4505846202,
0.2136805654,
0.2477304935,
-0.2262662649,
-0.0684009045,
-0.0554935895,
-0.4850587249,
-1.3881863356,
0.3583586812,
-0.4271374941,
0.654892385,
0.4878791273,
-0.0635900795,
0.157804504,
-0.7266765833,
1.0251438618,
0.1068529785,
-1.0832960606,
0.8207965493,
-0.350053221,
0.6110203266,
0.0828729868,
0.1881254613,
-0.4051367044,
-0.6181761622,
-0.4318742156,
-0.4151430726,
0.6672095656,
0.2190077454,
0.2776039243,
-0.4319236279,
0.1743580699,
0.01432746,
0.1505559683,
-0.8657802343,
-0.0544262156,
-0.1558244526,
0.2675595582,
0.2814343274,
-0.4322143197,
-0.1529688686,
0.2195451111,
0.6653092504,
0.0989174545,
0.1251621395,
-0.2127114832,
-0.1705554724,
0.0816423967,
0.6673329473,
0.5536262393,
0.1608811021,
0.0847282112,
0.3356465995,
0.1283881664,
-0.1412288398,
0.4981470704,
0.0670101047,
-0.2937030494,
-0.172379151,
0.4598688781,
0.7099233866,
0.2559259534,
-0.5854740739,
0.7642882466,
0.0261114389,
0.439878881,
-0.0619305149,
-0.0166594405,
-0.1677313,
0.1153587103,
0.3471564353,
-0.0701810122,
0.1339543015,
-0.6275751591,
-0.0321374573,
0.9250187278,
-0.282768786,
-0.3420741558,
0.1065625921,
0.0040479414,
-0.5688922405,
0.0636224076,
0.0251452979,
-0.62868011,
0.4491150379,
0.82916224,
0.8269963861,
-0.8384199142,
0.2334920019,
0.1706440002,
0.4733929634,
-0.056307707,
-0.1815582961,
0.0843068957,
-0.4916046262,
-0.2731599212,
-0.5171890855,
-0.1607340872,
0.2773968279,
-0.4093503356,
0.3715398908,
-0.5965740681,
-0.3542610705,
0.2210289836,
-0.3869339526,
-0.4260657728,
-0.4963771403,
0.2655477226,
0.8387346268,
-0.7087163925,
0.3631094992,
0.2930928767,
-0.2293864638,
-0.2293116301,
-0.1627540737,
0.0728788972,
-0.4921449423,
0.584775269,
0.147942856,
0.0324257687,
-0.3793461621,
-0.3685537577,
-0.6094742417,
0.3015479743,
0.6353000998,
-0.435901165,
-0.0294003002,
0.0486804582,
0.3811593056,
-0.1009296179,
0.3714253008,
0.6197375655,
0.5380862951,
-0.5109848976,
-0.637235105,
0.4142488241,
-0.2494074255,
0.1463635713,
0.4226074219,
-0.2194040865,
0.812338531,
0.1833323389,
-0.5826416612,
-0.1540371329,
0.3294165134,
0.2525461018,
-0.232413277,
0.5156236291,
0.5184445381,
0.4803221822,
0.0432948954,
1.3511517048,
0.1347905546,
-0.2003584504,
0.516171515,
-0.5310397148,
0.8682821393,
0.4127661884,
-0.219365716,
0.4796778262,
0.0842286348,
-0.1159249023,
0.090659976,
0.3502526879,
-0.4359661043,
0.0946889892,
-0.0508341119,
-0.5455738306,
0.1238625124,
0.5540006161,
0.0457238145,
-0.3329063058,
0.5321382284,
0.3850350976,
-0.0814785138,
-0.1880099475,
0.8229604363,
-0.0238051023,
-0.8180658221,
0.7662233114,
0.2147134393,
0.6088271141,
-0.6374607682,
-0.0416242033,
0.0273602139,
-0.0312371887,
0.028551979,
-0.8110008836,
0.0260808039,
0.1140920222,
-0.1417093128,
-0.1396954805,
0.6644687057,
-0.0413143672,
-0.306581378,
0.4060764611,
0.2105773687,
-0.4042984545,
-0.1749054641,
-0.6022079587,
0.2533543408,
-0.27898103,
-0.1493708044,
0.5338997841,
0.4490191042,
-0.2203655839,
0.8367707133,
0.6263703108,
0.241268158,
-0.0203645304,
0.1927645952,
0.5922083259,
-0.5208850503,
-0.6171759963,
-1.2234104872,
0.2957958877,
-0.3339034021,
0.3328813314,
0.7603608966,
0.084433049,
0.409261018,
-0.0955074281,
0.7617211342,
0.1594309956,
0.3005401492,
-0.5564071536,
0.5152220726,
-0.0607404076,
0.5376039147,
-0.6325772405,
-0.787591815,
-0.4970140159,
0.1091093048,
-0.2517745793,
-0.107688725,
0.8874079585,
0.9900617599,
0.187834084,
-0.078625299,
0.2447075993,
0.4987846017,
0.7837330103,
0.6795082688,
1.0887764692,
-0.2859842181,
0.481356889,
-0.1755332351,
-0.3877122998,
-0.084524028,
-0.9670693278,
-1.1690509319,
-0.3895947039,
-0.0998380631,
-0.3840830922,
0.3477012217,
0.3227292299,
0.7050522566,
-1.1525734663,
-0.1440428197,
0.2219928354,
0.3142109513,
-0.1688350737,
-0.3008300662,
0.088191621,
-0.2886445224,
-0.4270434082,
0.5336195827,
0.5641261339,
0.2990906239,
-0.6430914402,
0.4695576131,
-0.4259367287,
0.1388711035,
0.5572431684,
0.3675056994,
-0.9415299892,
-0.5727420449,
-0.3433823586,
-0.113110058,
-0.3122302294,
0.7506924272,
-0.5777393579,
0.2377253622,
0.4670729041,
0.9606855512,
-0.1782530695,
-0.2375734895,
0.9666473269,
-0.7919291854,
0.443454951,
0.2317529619,
0.3659127057,
0.41483289,
-0.781205833,
0.0318689346,
0.0461065173,
-0.2044799328,
-1.4520082474,
0.4548244178,
-0.8547270298,
-0.5425239801,
0.981363833,
-0.0464228615,
-0.3091703653,
-0.3929054141,
-0.209233135,
-0.1441788524,
-0.4241094887,
0.5863089561,
0.9009653926,
0.546697855,
-0.1738846004,
-1.0077170134,
0.4610155225,
0.2913999557,
-0.9576812983,
0.2143677175,
0.2880013287,
-0.0836444721,
0.3300301135,
0.0468556024,
-0.2511278689,
0.2414489686,
-0.2780108154,
-0.0386327356,
0.1246289164,
-0.1606219858,
-0.5869330764,
0.7581784725,
-0.1165056676,
0.1477585286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14043v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14043v1 | Taxonomy-Guided Zero-Shot Recommendations with LLMs | 2024-06-20T07:06:58 | 2024-06-20T07:06:58 | Yueqing Liang, Liangwei Yang, Chen Wang, Xiongxiao Xu, Philip S. Yu, Kai Shu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | With the emergence of large language models (LLMs) and their ability to
perform a variety of tasks, their application in recommender systems (RecSys)
has shown promise. However, we are facing significant challenges when deploying
LLMs into RecSys, such as limited prompt length, unstructured item information,
and un-constrained generation of recommendations, leading to sub-optimal
performance. To address these issues, we propose a novel method using a
taxonomy dictionary. This method provides a systematic framework for
categorizing and organizing items, improving the clarity and structure of item
information. By incorporating the taxonomy dictionary into LLM prompts, we
achieve efficient token utilization and controlled feature generation, leading
to more accurate and contextually relevant recommendations. Our Taxonomy-guided
Recommendation (TaxRec) approach features a two-step process: one-time taxonomy
categorization and LLM-based recommendation, enabling zero-shot recommendations
without the need for domain-specific fine-tuning. Experimental results
demonstrate TaxRec significantly enhances recommendation quality compared to
traditional zero-shot approaches, showcasing its efficacy as personal
recommender with LLMs. Code is available at
https://github.com/yueqingliang1/TaxRec. | [
-0.2830399275,
-0.4375191927,
0.478785485,
0.0552768186,
-0.6627269983,
0.1559339911,
-0.0323292874,
-0.1594075561,
0.8032144904,
0.6593283415,
-0.7793582678,
-0.8635346889,
-0.3546836376,
0.1495624185,
-0.1794754565,
1.0285896063,
0.1320754439,
-0.1936487257,
-0.42690593,
-0.0922865346,
-0.8010793924,
-0.3955409825,
-0.5490961671,
-0.5242506862,
0.8898274899,
0.4722927511,
0.4141431749,
0.7950861454,
0.3931855261,
0.0680985823,
-0.1425801665,
0.2382426411,
-0.4064166248,
0.4706853926,
-0.3222206235,
-0.4330589175,
-0.4494250119,
-0.3520667553,
0.1741253436,
0.5918115377,
-0.6115736961,
0.30833745,
0.0269108117,
0.4065008759,
-0.9384918809,
-0.0454819091,
-0.5698771477,
0.001914665,
-0.3343120813,
-0.5509129167,
-0.2959817052,
-0.2012194097,
0.2476763427,
-0.5717368722,
-0.0223614536,
0.0361021124,
0.4732297063,
0.1073204428,
-0.3847477734,
-0.0592540167,
-0.8150523305,
0.6873761415,
-0.6098918319,
0.3808038533,
0.3851222694,
0.11616081,
-0.1586836576,
-0.6816343069,
-0.1977306306,
-0.030386474,
0.0392393284,
0.0909191966,
-0.4760231972,
0.0620632097,
0.0705393851,
0.1647755802,
-0.6962645054,
0.1150127202,
0.0513644442,
-0.1060689986,
0.3209047019,
0.3948978782,
-0.0411087908,
-0.165413484,
-0.5072432756,
0.2147614211,
-0.7702050805,
-0.2482369542,
-0.0138048641,
0.5615705848,
0.2832722068,
0.632532537,
-0.4320479929,
0.8562107086,
-0.0337634422,
-0.1517638564,
0.0924521983,
-0.461373359,
-0.2203468531,
-0.013894598,
0.5289055705,
0.5857351422,
0.0829324201,
-0.1502705663,
-0.3750099838,
-0.1254730523,
0.2809532285,
-0.7981154919,
-0.0926391184,
0.2539840341,
-0.2156606764,
-0.4454155266,
-0.1053532958,
-0.7011549473,
-0.5944117308,
-0.07390026,
0.5380517244,
-0.214113757,
-0.1112676486,
0.2334421575,
-0.116687417,
-0.0129262507,
0.2592308223,
-0.9082246423,
0.3081359863,
0.8166940212,
1.1679089069,
0.0201764442,
-0.0340484902,
-0.7180228829,
0.2263382524,
-0.3026324511,
1.22635746,
-0.51699543,
-0.527212441,
0.2266352475,
-0.1989325881,
0.4332958162,
-0.5373396873,
0.1332755685,
-0.3886443079,
0.0546948686,
-0.1000738144,
-0.6216220856,
-0.2601317763,
0.3107871115,
-0.1747449934,
0.7680972219,
0.2708627284,
-0.337008208,
0.6591511965,
-0.5058047771,
-0.4959399998,
0.7160652876,
-0.06553673,
-0.0341719985,
0.0571979918,
0.0990444794,
0.6198377013,
-0.3542875648,
0.2995633781,
-0.4431087375,
-0.3331244886,
-0.2537556887,
-0.1420155317,
0.3525625169,
0.2625666261,
0.0760906562,
0.3284769952,
-0.5714041591,
-0.0721986368,
0.0581056215,
-0.136052683,
-0.5531727672,
-0.0423227735,
-0.1452772468,
-0.1082091033,
0.3586730063,
-0.5173590779,
0.5760399103,
-0.7313827872,
0.4388995171,
0.6574049592,
0.2793085277,
0.5970473886,
-0.5267924666,
0.7030344009,
-0.1189872995,
0.11625126,
-0.4658147395,
-0.3655077815,
-0.6045293808,
-0.1147240624,
0.4076731503,
0.5006109476,
-0.8126559258,
0.6874123812,
-0.1299645156,
-0.5206856728,
-0.2047971785,
0.2217795104,
0.1581878662,
0.4658400118,
0.2415071875,
-0.6521451473,
-0.5226210356,
-0.5977609158,
-0.081790328,
-0.2610793412,
-0.3367562294,
0.4792258143,
0.2703512609,
-0.2774737775,
0.905559957,
-0.9631547928,
-0.5380249023,
-0.17037265,
0.079116717,
0.4716229439,
0.0575734898,
0.4630473852,
-0.0034678585,
-0.1076083481,
-0.5157244802,
-0.0193598904,
-0.403840512,
-0.095833011,
-0.2067928314,
0.199894771,
0.040041551,
-0.2578929663,
0.4146786034,
0.1053128093,
-0.6139490604,
0.293546468,
-0.2228862494,
-0.3044786453,
-1.2208214998,
-0.1492399126,
0.3096614182,
-0.3822467029,
-0.5199050307,
-0.1756229401,
-0.0744272172,
0.2065772116,
-0.3581520021,
0.7807179689,
0.1014729589,
0.2003037632,
-0.2073624283,
0.1863838285,
0.1649936885,
0.4006721079,
0.1730698794,
0.4212456644,
0.5753318071,
-0.6260029078,
0.4498286545,
0.3041341007,
-0.4723281264,
0.7562397718,
-0.3690435588,
-0.0378877744,
-0.034258496,
0.3443897665,
-0.9911364317,
0.1031656414,
0.3773182333,
-0.1337668896,
0.1914419979,
-0.2566807568,
-0.4857139587,
-0.0327416025,
-0.7121487856,
0.3431020677,
0.3413302004,
-0.5760191083,
0.549751997,
0.2144500464,
0.019558968,
-0.5951388478,
-0.609143734,
0.2787112892,
-0.0706057772,
-0.2923365235,
0.4425486028,
-0.2278118581,
0.0545403212,
-0.0309187695,
-0.2359393984,
0.2893380821,
0.1379316747,
0.4486021399,
0.4802482724,
-0.1621247828,
0.4274066985,
-0.2142019719,
-0.1322109848,
-0.2697737217,
-0.685682714,
0.6938099265,
0.1730867177,
0.0152055323,
-0.2166367918,
0.1398064494,
0.3979216516,
-0.1399336904,
0.5286579132,
0.343500495,
-0.1726136655,
-0.4153048098,
-0.6166127324,
-0.2450955361,
-0.4621857405,
0.1483448297,
-0.2577896416,
-0.9618930817,
0.1116064191,
-0.1827795655,
0.1987144947,
0.289054662,
0.5822719932,
-0.0156459995,
0.6593110561,
0.7585991621,
-0.2749807239,
0.7109486461,
-0.4050026536,
0.0937520564,
-0.9211705923,
-0.4385483861,
-0.38254866,
-0.2580901384,
-0.3610361516,
-0.2300006151,
0.1753209084,
0.0126851806,
-0.4818845987,
0.501529336,
-0.7791603804,
0.4154971242,
0.8106830716,
-0.0115122227,
0.3566298783,
0.079504855,
-0.2260185629,
0.353582412,
-0.8714180589,
-0.2473914921,
1.0544685125,
0.2304976881,
0.9083793759,
0.1141299307,
0.9347304106,
0.2559868693,
0.1824029237,
-1.4319983721,
0.5522524118,
-0.5247582793,
-0.2284573317,
-0.1125273481,
-0.311555326,
-0.9254341125,
-0.0366174728,
-0.3178484142,
-0.7573110461,
0.4409922659,
-0.170358941,
-0.9969905019,
0.4045310915,
-0.2976623476,
0.558118701,
-0.2369936407,
-0.2154695988,
-0.1234191731,
-0.2738526464,
0.0927673206,
-0.178221792,
0.0196423233,
-0.4115979671,
-0.4556403756,
0.8056928515,
-0.5139816403,
0.6385038495,
-0.1690435261,
-0.2137504667,
0.2275163978,
0.7436204553,
0.2075857371,
0.1140129641,
-0.0400718264,
0.4879341125,
0.4584877491,
0.1159188151,
-0.62820822,
0.762039721,
-0.4135127664,
-0.7082141638,
-0.5433914661,
-0.3422453403,
-0.2727027833,
0.4178314209,
0.0773459822,
0.5905584097,
0.0430952162,
0.1087223813,
0.1901391149,
-0.1394002736,
0.3639017642,
0.8997408152,
-0.4514903724,
-0.8396847248,
0.8706749678,
0.1593493521,
-0.0709682181,
0.5843833089,
0.316927284,
-0.5585586429,
-0.6321256757,
-0.2125516087,
0.293397665,
-0.5251449943,
-0.7749519944,
-0.1677245498,
0.1307122558,
-0.5630851388,
-0.2077725083,
0.0037917064,
-0.4371910691,
-0.6126927137,
0.0633117557,
0.6671335697,
0.921380043,
0.0366050974,
0.4069873393,
-0.6168422699,
0.318392247,
0.1675098389,
0.9806424379,
-0.0451907516,
-0.7616019845,
-0.1045436338,
-0.1391461045,
-0.1822521091,
-0.4181134999,
0.452616632,
0.1664923579,
0.1109052077,
0.6685515642,
0.2309782952,
0.7620467544,
-0.5440441966,
0.896376133,
0.2934939563,
-0.6446624994,
0.7407929897,
-0.2248180211,
0.5265274048,
0.4531932771,
0.1921596825,
-0.7613629103,
-0.1684487462,
-0.338427335,
-0.8715967536,
0.6543926597,
-0.0941998586,
0.2067612857,
-0.1322099119,
0.7198952436,
0.0149850668,
0.2127370387,
-0.0876744837,
-0.3134085536,
-0.1164440885,
-0.0654436275,
-0.3870239854,
-0.7670394182,
-0.2052211165,
-0.1319092959,
0.5925220251,
-0.0608869381,
-0.1046361402,
0.2271215916,
0.2946851552,
-0.4187820852,
0.2942559123,
0.6527588964,
0.5710219741,
-0.5880591273,
0.0520489849,
0.0863992348,
-0.2497165352,
0.2121686041,
-0.2600845397,
-0.1515600532,
0.0552258752,
0.2297746837,
0.6492736936,
0.1932719946,
-0.4158159792,
0.4090182185,
-0.0854714438,
-0.3656014502,
-0.1707761586,
0.0563376583,
-0.0575860366,
0.2233767211,
0.1859248579,
-0.0660879761,
-0.037220262,
-0.4763276279,
0.2880936861,
0.6431519985,
-0.2120194435,
0.0578570738,
0.3504024148,
0.4185346961,
-0.436355263,
0.4573095739,
0.1494249701,
-0.1379299611,
0.1439899504,
0.5011231899,
1.1924005747,
-0.0310233533,
0.3846886456,
0.2546720505,
0.2000651509,
-0.2572354078,
0.1138691604,
-0.3513576388,
-0.8166427016,
-0.395871222,
-0.9530104995,
-0.515159905,
0.0561765768,
-0.5302470922,
0.5652947426,
-0.7772564292,
-0.3628064394,
0.0983875319,
0.1389428079,
-0.3461951613,
-0.0084729902,
0.399178803,
1.1050708294,
-0.3068699539,
0.6920318007,
0.4822180271,
-0.4809554517,
-0.8119343519,
-0.2807864547,
0.1619451344,
-0.8338903785,
0.4137689173,
-0.2130770683,
-0.4673302174,
-0.0107228057,
-0.233233735,
-0.7025687695,
1.2948482037,
0.3080279827,
-0.764079392,
0.2056382895,
0.0096701728,
0.4579350352,
-0.5644606352,
0.4097233117,
0.4342673719,
0.2458923906,
0.7870278358,
-0.8869004846,
0.0822913721,
0.067699492,
0.3217719793,
0.3732607365,
-0.4512958229,
0.3059407473,
-0.1549729109,
-0.3797905743,
0.1826014072,
0.2212904394,
0.1881081015,
0.2685461044,
0.5137553215,
0.6018585563,
0.6683518291,
0.1423978657,
0.8737428188,
-0.3692273796,
0.2846232951,
1.3617597818,
-0.5822206736,
0.9408788085,
0.2761003077,
-0.10916581,
0.7510770559,
0.8017963767,
-0.3920016885,
0.5037913322,
0.232965529,
-0.3487372696,
-0.3838041425,
-0.6969183087,
-0.0678765625,
0.3570587039,
0.1774376631,
-0.0480884425,
-0.5000632405,
-0.0623326413,
-0.2584634125,
-0.2906270921,
-0.4329431057,
1.1762149334,
0.125708431,
-0.4909279943,
0.8810006976,
-0.0747597516,
1.1321650743,
-0.7481641173,
-0.1672682017,
-0.3514454365,
-0.0907071382,
-0.4115841687,
-1.05717659,
0.1198834181,
0.0998872221,
-0.1134090498,
-0.4081167579,
0.7611125708,
-0.4372967184,
-0.3686566353,
0.1321835518,
0.3667365909,
0.148679167,
-0.2277575731,
-0.3493571877,
-0.4005074501,
-0.1246856377,
-0.0332860984,
0.2631504238,
0.2364000976,
0.2065579146,
0.9748631716,
0.4839769006,
0.4797988534,
-0.5431662202,
0.3602137268,
0.5913661718,
-0.7660030127,
-0.236494422,
-1.029409647,
0.1156949922,
0.4960851073,
-0.1554033756,
0.6748762727,
0.5824354291,
0.9435280561,
0.0213954467,
0.3822931349,
0.2307498008,
0.3048037887,
-0.1632369757,
0.5659921169,
-0.7513900399,
0.7275557518,
0.0038780042,
-0.9097111821,
-0.906288147,
0.208002165,
-0.0646576211,
-0.0702826455,
0.4876915216,
1.0860772133,
0.3501281738,
-0.2683021724,
0.5703272223,
-0.044247061,
0.2081551552,
0.5176100731,
0.6625154018,
0.0373054035,
0.6510121822,
-0.4586947262,
-0.0416894667,
-0.3342804313,
-0.8876750469,
-0.651758194,
-0.5270976424,
-0.4313376844,
-0.3474876583,
-0.1245277971,
1.2526454926,
0.5922229886,
-0.7936457396,
-0.4553568065,
0.0007441215,
0.289668709,
-0.0529646464,
-0.2116460204,
0.1577662081,
-0.103851974,
-0.2985861003,
0.370026052,
0.6880688071,
0.0049545332,
-0.3899502158,
0.2009316087,
-0.1786340922,
0.1923995167,
0.7450464964,
0.0114217615,
-0.9780366421,
-0.3403338194,
0.0083066458,
0.2040105909,
-0.0031793818,
0.9559927583,
-1.1883406639,
0.6605627537,
0.5129334927,
0.0436516032,
0.24896954,
-0.0270823613,
0.5158304572,
-0.6962936521,
-0.2652672529,
0.3967880905,
0.3108406365,
-0.1584638804,
-0.4475341737,
0.6013669968,
0.2313352823,
-0.3288554251,
-0.8618052602,
0.190804407,
-1.1057567596,
-0.3917934299,
1.2860513926,
0.0802996978,
-0.14909935,
0.0077168769,
-0.2461843491,
0.0993750468,
-0.7611343265,
0.6678007245,
0.5164026618,
-0.158828333,
-0.0817102119,
-0.1804769635,
0.2312775254,
0.2759846747,
-0.3015344739,
0.2891893387,
0.3573296666,
0.5409194231,
0.1011878252,
0.5630570054,
0.2877370715,
-0.0543831512,
-0.3966835141,
0.1473881304,
-0.3171127141,
-0.2663110197,
-0.8839821219,
0.1380337626,
0.225794062,
-0.1408406049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14039v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14039v1 | CryptoGPT: a 7B model rivaling GPT-4 in the task of analyzing and classifying real-time financial news | 2024-06-20T06:59:46 | 2024-06-20T06:59:46 | Ying Zhang, Matthieu Petit Guillaume, Aurélien Krauth, Manel Labidi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.NE | CryptoGPT: a 7B model competing with GPT-4 in a specific task -- The Impact
of Automatic Annotation and Strategic Fine-Tuning via QLoRAIn this article, we
present a method aimed at refining a dedicated LLM of reasonable quality with
limited resources in an industrial setting via CryptoGPT. It is an LLM designed
for financial news analysis for the cryptocurrency market in real-time. This
project was launched in an industrial context. This model allows not only for
the classification of financial information but also for providing
comprehensive analysis. We refined different LLMs of the same size such as
Mistral-7B and LLama-7B using semi-automatic annotation and compared them with
various LLMs such as GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. Our goal is to find a balance among
several needs: 1. Protecting data (by avoiding their transfer to external
servers), 2. Limiting annotation cost and time, 3. Controlling the model's size
(to manage deployment costs), and 4. Maintaining better analysis quality. | [
-0.2508661747,
-0.7088191509,
0.2884802818,
0.131064266,
-0.8788115382,
0.5646710992,
-0.01139249,
-1.1932973862,
0.1384677142,
0.6703159213,
-0.3690917492,
-0.5505167246,
-0.3955599964,
0.0327730365,
-0.5309749842,
1.08111763,
-0.058282733,
0.1267061532,
0.2487754375,
0.1547335237,
-0.2434066981,
-0.7200794816,
-0.942846477,
-0.2362592518,
0.1019593403,
0.0306169968,
0.7099266648,
0.8645194173,
0.9022582173,
0.3771179616,
0.1763020456,
0.1669262648,
-0.2662557364,
-0.161804527,
0.0249857586,
-0.5131883025,
-0.6864975095,
0.1606302112,
0.3760823607,
0.1240322292,
-0.2545664608,
0.462597996,
-0.1312406361,
0.393743068,
-0.4095893204,
0.4352675676,
-0.5553873777,
-0.0041699898,
-0.1042801142,
-0.2049531341,
-0.0689017996,
-0.2983137369,
0.2216080129,
-0.5802431703,
0.4219958782,
0.4245398641,
1.1864714622,
0.0701588094,
-0.1176806092,
-0.2367234975,
-0.6788559556,
0.6302057505,
-0.8624734282,
0.0766581669,
0.3168408573,
0.4336043,
0.3120020032,
-0.8800777793,
-0.0734299049,
-0.1931494176,
0.1269695908,
-0.0048379013,
0.0143249594,
0.3178735077,
0.2317290902,
0.365001291,
-0.2470190227,
0.0192344524,
-0.8615754247,
-0.6776457429,
0.5852919817,
0.1557081342,
-0.1018161848,
0.0085243331,
-0.4357306361,
-0.0560984798,
-0.666970551,
-0.3346732557,
0.7002127767,
0.1204510257,
0.1167944595,
0.3041566908,
-0.4015155435,
0.673941195,
0.140656963,
-0.5150715709,
0.1889324635,
-0.2065046132,
-0.376190871,
0.5033745766,
0.5704437494,
0.5630279183,
-0.1422988921,
0.0315849409,
-0.6333753467,
0.211022675,
0.4388006628,
-0.8375905156,
-0.3343532979,
0.0526380055,
-0.595702529,
-0.7327967286,
0.0425529405,
-0.6722924709,
-0.1620246023,
-0.5414011478,
0.5020326972,
-0.0651238933,
-0.0123402933,
0.1656848341,
-0.2448427677,
0.0757695809,
0.4890931845,
-0.8510125279,
0.3406864405,
1.0338470936,
1.0752737522,
0.0384848416,
0.2207420021,
-0.3143555522,
0.3512410522,
-0.2533009946,
0.9981616139,
-0.2580881119,
-0.2487574518,
-0.3075410724,
-0.1863545775,
0.3221053183,
-0.6897312403,
0.1586952358,
-0.6122732162,
0.1347706914,
-0.0512976125,
-0.3763782382,
-0.4366794229,
0.6196941733,
-0.7608231306,
0.6359161139,
0.1913333088,
-0.8376061916,
0.5810146332,
-0.5647138953,
-0.1568035483,
0.3659778833,
-0.3242574632,
-0.6178802252,
-0.0505356602,
0.0132563803,
0.2266655713,
-0.4243804812,
0.1004286408,
-0.5228427052,
-0.516979754,
0.2245854139,
-0.5136166215,
0.2756591439,
0.2952546179,
-0.7154842615,
0.1715295464,
-1.0992898941,
-0.1358403116,
-0.0801141188,
-0.2545579672,
-0.2497438937,
-0.0230663922,
-0.008181191,
0.1130150259,
0.5353832841,
-0.4590504169,
0.353330344,
-0.4938042164,
0.9136680365,
0.9252372384,
0.0927899927,
0.0208335258,
-0.6012135148,
0.5431588292,
-0.3507902324,
0.6861390471,
0.2482459098,
-0.1916621476,
-0.5639795661,
-0.6937012672,
0.5654430985,
0.5171748996,
-0.2135038376,
0.1119950488,
-0.0812438577,
-0.5235798359,
-0.6829177737,
-0.0023992052,
-0.0748561397,
0.2600477636,
0.2624853849,
-0.5183404684,
-0.5352685452,
-1.1740287542,
-0.0993848518,
-0.1142534539,
0.1706241816,
-0.1796056628,
0.1917865127,
-0.1760002971,
0.6181645393,
-0.3013795912,
-0.1123720706,
-0.2185548991,
0.3198923767,
0.3745652735,
0.314981699,
0.4021467865,
-0.7066056728,
-0.1893015802,
0.0631023273,
-0.4623290598,
-0.24044469,
-0.3572615683,
-0.1104153171,
0.0718667582,
0.4587590396,
-0.7104740143,
0.5285690427,
0.2871615887,
-0.2585718632,
0.7709633112,
-0.0910854787,
0.2475018948,
-0.7492104173,
0.06565056,
-0.2295180559,
-0.5582802296,
-0.3282082975,
0.1773173362,
0.0651983172,
-0.1393022537,
-0.4354331493,
0.5534440875,
-0.497966975,
-0.2059283406,
-0.5052832365,
0.1744900942,
-0.0974787548,
0.2410810441,
-0.1008615643,
0.6712492108,
0.3610439897,
-0.447889477,
0.7883785963,
-0.2616924644,
-0.3123868704,
0.1692240089,
-0.5929242373,
-0.1051374599,
0.2511287332,
-0.0169879068,
-0.6200069189,
-0.0010900366,
0.6615447402,
-0.1538166553,
0.3718741834,
-0.2372970581,
-0.7928055525,
-0.2026633024,
-0.5924297571,
0.2779800296,
0.5185902715,
-0.3092123866,
0.6862057447,
0.0429223925,
-0.1996997893,
-0.4890196323,
-0.611025393,
0.162127614,
-0.6663430929,
-0.5475199223,
0.2953137755,
0.0250115693,
-0.4152278006,
-0.016296234,
-0.6827912331,
0.2252465785,
0.1979817897,
0.2673607767,
0.780826509,
-0.0541175269,
-0.2784748375,
-0.1553784013,
-0.4164357483,
0.1048585847,
-0.5470266342,
0.3960615993,
0.0464914851,
-0.2240559459,
-0.7169329524,
-0.1880349219,
0.4392177463,
-0.0800390616,
0.4949279726,
0.3897615671,
-0.2325952947,
-0.2041793466,
-0.852761507,
-0.209585771,
-0.5713381767,
-0.0052605937,
-0.2158974409,
-0.9156485796,
0.7061367035,
-0.0424160659,
0.2529349625,
0.7262681723,
0.6401979327,
0.248598218,
0.9646019936,
0.4731564224,
-0.2590817809,
0.6120616794,
-0.3503389955,
0.3895831406,
-0.3952031732,
-0.141539529,
-0.3830600679,
-0.3644468188,
-0.6713915467,
-0.1495452821,
0.223911494,
0.1392683089,
-0.1360744983,
0.3326244056,
-0.6922908425,
0.2260224521,
0.6078096032,
0.0380248725,
0.5692477822,
0.3218619525,
0.0551051497,
0.2520233095,
-0.4236574173,
-0.6475000381,
1.1072727442,
0.5097206831,
0.9413200021,
-0.2121342868,
0.7139803767,
0.3355686963,
0.620833993,
-0.4506363571,
0.4030518532,
0.2111067176,
-0.8067346811,
-0.0750130937,
-0.536490202,
-0.6547541618,
0.4021629393,
0.0365917683,
-0.6937963367,
0.1174484342,
0.1865916252,
-0.5432116985,
0.2814006805,
-0.4904946089,
0.7668446302,
-0.4007101655,
-0.2721966803,
-0.4945215583,
-0.301165849,
0.2980186343,
-0.2156856209,
0.4193543494,
-0.4933616221,
-0.3012476861,
0.6267430186,
-0.6519418359,
0.897568047,
-0.0314145163,
-0.0835819021,
0.6337475777,
-0.073231183,
0.5465033054,
0.4255597889,
0.0214710869,
0.229491502,
0.3508611321,
-0.394333005,
-0.3797337711,
0.5730499029,
-0.8533599377,
-0.6120448709,
-0.8171268702,
-0.1652285457,
0.1739636809,
0.2046647668,
0.3334000409,
0.4736520648,
0.1646425426,
0.0812564865,
0.2059583664,
0.3550687432,
0.3502773941,
0.4863924086,
-0.1504732072,
-0.5741646886,
0.9973595142,
0.3220051229,
0.1741499305,
0.415823251,
0.1183371842,
-0.3773548603,
-0.9262225032,
-0.0325939059,
0.2832348347,
-0.7397806644,
-0.5342102647,
-0.2354965508,
-0.2618270814,
-0.4831072688,
-0.1009046361,
-0.3772878349,
-0.6165010333,
-0.4527190626,
-0.3596186042,
0.2592354417,
0.4642745256,
-0.2169619799,
0.4811803699,
-0.9409449697,
0.3656338453,
0.2720245719,
0.3207162619,
-0.1580283791,
-0.399384141,
-0.4802312851,
-0.0269881897,
-0.5436154008,
-0.747461617,
0.4244375229,
-0.0545502976,
0.3946298957,
0.7022869587,
-0.0351565816,
0.5626037717,
0.1636520028,
0.5100368857,
0.1946552098,
-0.9107251763,
0.2721603513,
-0.3355041444,
0.0898868516,
0.5043088198,
0.157540977,
-0.3615264297,
-0.5887531638,
-0.9481681585,
-1.0760672092,
0.5146569014,
0.2514436245,
-0.2980214655,
0.1398604214,
0.762311101,
0.0987233818,
0.7072318196,
-0.8251562119,
0.2960903645,
-0.2961088121,
-0.2795069516,
0.3531447649,
-0.2057961375,
-0.1366751641,
0.0456893444,
0.8645122051,
0.0103741856,
0.1063484102,
0.2655816376,
-0.0554523766,
-0.0274407454,
-0.0733873472,
0.2685566843,
1.1108222008,
-0.336219728,
0.1378763318,
0.1470027566,
-0.569277823,
-0.0542314053,
0.2522294223,
-0.397780478,
-0.1005282328,
0.7239851952,
0.7864009142,
0.173181802,
-0.8495383859,
0.2281208336,
0.021848496,
-0.38567397,
-0.3898841441,
0.3198329508,
-0.2012606859,
0.5794675946,
0.5242003202,
-0.1960246563,
0.5360833406,
-0.7488238811,
0.1173511818,
0.1721784323,
-0.2441936731,
-0.3376762569,
0.6830874681,
0.0052502258,
0.0625593141,
0.7104424834,
-0.3202140629,
-0.5103163719,
0.768676579,
0.2791679204,
0.7632295489,
-0.0782190859,
0.0184867848,
0.0973883346,
0.5140311718,
-0.5466496348,
0.4068646431,
0.0835423321,
-0.3903499246,
-0.5824270248,
-0.6260518432,
-0.3641374409,
0.2906884849,
-0.4618930817,
0.5709022284,
-1.0162727833,
-0.5715838075,
0.0369871855,
0.3901147544,
-0.3991657794,
0.3006239533,
0.1191481203,
0.8229195476,
-0.316354841,
0.5677344203,
0.4989774227,
-0.104803659,
-0.4594554007,
-0.4224513471,
0.0136370184,
-0.8939576745,
0.2059938312,
0.230366841,
0.1504736692,
-0.1401492059,
-0.5582780838,
-0.7554777265,
1.2768855095,
0.2549860179,
-1.1517423391,
-0.1383530349,
0.0742863268,
0.5363384485,
-0.2895280123,
-0.0453968719,
0.527528286,
0.6407803297,
-0.0160445552,
-0.7396387458,
-0.0525454469,
-0.026293667,
-0.3103976548,
0.5499759912,
-1.0616495609,
0.6160838008,
0.0519700497,
-0.1080665141,
-0.1692328304,
0.5933628082,
0.25884974,
0.4902989864,
0.5399675965,
0.465523839,
0.3887497783,
0.022526253,
0.7425889373,
-0.5764212012,
0.6412316561,
0.8693147898,
0.0897013247,
0.6852009892,
0.2462283522,
-0.119660601,
-0.0160547402,
1.1728072166,
-0.606844902,
0.499930948,
0.464633137,
-0.2738988996,
-0.3443788588,
0.2232318223,
-0.2934503555,
0.185930863,
0.2795868516,
-0.0456646793,
0.0530542955,
-0.3031357825,
-0.1437644362,
-0.5120558143,
-0.4785030782,
0.5782138109,
0.2688271105,
-0.089519389,
0.1693460792,
0.4256261289,
0.5415750146,
-0.7080914974,
0.2154368609,
-0.0566437766,
0.0539244711,
-0.1753812283,
-0.1233593673,
0.3311995268,
-0.2055150568,
0.2369724661,
0.0397526585,
0.8323205113,
-0.3556108177,
-0.6600576043,
0.2509625256,
-0.0298263784,
-0.073358357,
-0.3814084828,
-0.7086158991,
0.2206826806,
0.0134685747,
-0.368270129,
0.3591221273,
0.4076309502,
-0.260894388,
0.7876471281,
0.764125824,
0.2604378462,
0.0253228918,
-0.0847352818,
0.7697088122,
-0.8761914968,
-0.7569053173,
-0.9066711068,
0.1087593436,
-0.2277696431,
-0.0587839186,
0.4857122898,
0.8430331349,
0.734133184,
0.1501343101,
0.9195967317,
0.2723563015,
0.2443697751,
-0.5754263997,
0.3853082061,
-0.3458119631,
0.4862192869,
0.0209821071,
-1.0486732721,
-0.176714614,
0.677993238,
-0.1106830612,
-0.1771237701,
0.6069867611,
0.4911983907,
-0.1267609,
0.0787371546,
0.0673039481,
0.2949257195,
0.4585274458,
0.0525027178,
0.7614335418,
-0.2919559181,
0.6972445846,
-0.4399647117,
-0.170911938,
-0.5034734011,
-0.8941445947,
-0.8598773479,
0.0001321018,
-0.6265261173,
-0.1664166301,
0.1648198366,
0.9321216941,
0.6037118435,
-0.5189473629,
-0.3477454484,
0.3020513058,
-0.1342674792,
-0.2737938166,
-0.1592661291,
0.3583706319,
-0.2977872193,
-0.3016498685,
0.1506577879,
0.5331462026,
0.2877892256,
-0.3628369868,
0.2967725098,
0.3737054467,
0.0644906387,
0.4236180782,
-0.0706595927,
-0.510414958,
-0.4444121122,
-0.2999903858,
0.1066489294,
0.0630013198,
0.9832344651,
-0.1797811389,
0.1308024675,
0.5389107466,
0.3656193316,
0.8691670299,
0.2478883415,
0.4857578874,
-0.1341201514,
0.3250751495,
0.2087791562,
0.1240629926,
0.0932741612,
-0.5632021427,
0.4940561354,
0.570230484,
-0.5598974228,
-0.6156133413,
-0.3345623314,
-0.9741613865,
-0.4268957376,
0.813011229,
0.1210583597,
-0.3951478004,
-0.0576688759,
-0.3565798402,
0.1788720936,
-0.5955607891,
1.1364989281,
0.840479672,
-0.0917423368,
-0.0882516652,
-0.9185209274,
0.5570512414,
-0.2033417523,
-0.6423110366,
-0.0213381574,
0.3493098915,
0.3816165924,
0.0465146936,
0.7247502804,
-0.1891868562,
0.2629623711,
0.008864684,
0.0259181131,
-0.2448051721,
-0.3158237636,
-0.0803787485,
0.3671668172,
0.2979924679,
-0.1199593544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14036v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14036v1 | Toward Infinite-Long Prefix in Transformer | 2024-06-20T06:56:35 | 2024-06-20T06:56:35 | Jiuxiang Gu, Yingyu Liang, Zhenmei Shi, Zhao Song, Chiwun Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Prompting and contextual-based fine-tuning methods, which we call Prefix
Learning, have been proposed to enhance the performance of language models on
various downstream tasks that can match full parameter fine-tuning. There
remains a limited theoretical understanding of how these methods work. In this
paper, we aim to relieve this limitation by studying the learning ability of
Prefix Learning from the perspective of prefix length. In particular, we
approximate the infinite-long Prefix Learning optimization process by the
Neural Tangent Kernel (NTK) technique. We formulate and solve it as a learning
problem of the infinite-long prefix in a one-layer attention network. Our
results confirm the over-parameterization property and arbitrary small loss
convergence guarantee of the infinite-long Prefix Learning in attention. To the
implementation end, we propose our NTK-Attention method, which is "equivalent"
to attention computation with arbitrary prefix length efficiently. Its time
complexity mainly depends on the sub-quadratic of input length (without
prefix), and our method only requires $d^2 + d$ extra parameters for
representation, where $d$ is the feature dimension. In addition, we conducted
experiments that compare our NTK-Attention with full parameters fine-tuning,
LoRA, and P-Tuning V2 methods across vision or natural language datasets. The
results indicate our approach may be a promising
parameter-efficient-fine-tuning method since it has demonstrated superior
performance in numerous scenarios. Our code can be found at
\url{https://github.com/ChristianYang37/chiwun/tree/main/src/NTK-Attention}. | [
-0.7302903533,
-0.8302412033,
0.5610880256,
0.2225987911,
-0.6066502333,
-0.1782694012,
-0.5924788117,
-0.4669403434,
0.2470330894,
0.1387321651,
-0.8105717301,
-0.3466269076,
-0.4773307741,
0.2779299319,
0.0071109468,
0.8354961276,
0.1602522582,
-0.1832249612,
0.1958263367,
-0.0907472819,
-0.8132661581,
0.1255488992,
-1.111353159,
-0.0670419484,
0.8604146838,
0.617429018,
0.4900590181,
0.9583611488,
0.2321625054,
0.2294495702,
-0.3804835081,
0.310996145,
-0.599588871,
0.0405576713,
-0.1564138532,
-0.3069638908,
-0.2177337855,
-0.1662451774,
0.943790555,
0.678776741,
0.2995856404,
0.2178889364,
0.2099955529,
0.7876669168,
-0.6645388007,
0.0292777959,
-0.5868702531,
0.2287411988,
-0.0666071475,
-0.2821724117,
-0.3083181977,
-0.4942473471,
0.1473092884,
-0.6873624921,
0.2478358895,
0.1884264052,
0.8218287826,
0.7127625942,
-0.3478972316,
-0.1031075791,
-0.6503586173,
0.9076589942,
-0.6002182961,
0.7029730678,
0.5307907462,
0.3242374957,
0.006615601,
-0.5674302578,
-0.5149055123,
-0.4450770319,
-0.0597303957,
0.1265657991,
0.1313645393,
0.2187291682,
0.4631448388,
0.2861786485,
-0.2916351855,
0.2170240283,
-0.4315147996,
0.0201200973,
0.3186395466,
0.2541852891,
-0.1224467158,
-0.0389182605,
-0.4660616815,
0.0465326943,
-0.5865436196,
0.253046304,
0.2706313729,
0.2052522749,
0.0376875587,
0.0958344117,
-0.2950967848,
0.7836791277,
0.3134798706,
0.0053699473,
-0.0529685318,
-0.0057360274,
-0.2491288632,
0.2574651241,
0.4162894785,
0.2953911424,
0.3796794713,
-0.6966127753,
0.0666566193,
-0.1175462827,
0.582913816,
-0.6400213242,
0.2113175839,
0.0426833257,
0.0089294417,
-0.1387536079,
-0.1161785647,
-0.7830656767,
0.1220480502,
-0.7831483483,
0.3930241764,
-0.6064491868,
0.0315170847,
0.200945884,
0.2066985071,
0.466563344,
0.140276894,
-0.8042186499,
0.3373306394,
0.8750032187,
0.8605419993,
-0.3419786096,
-0.4874162972,
-0.5933545828,
-0.2191335261,
-0.4406757653,
0.4894532561,
-0.3400743306,
-0.2346877158,
-0.4469152689,
-0.1466521323,
0.0133810658,
-0.2952795923,
0.6047646999,
-0.7686499357,
-0.190709874,
-0.0931278318,
-0.434566468,
-0.2213258296,
0.1639674157,
-0.5657628775,
1.0095530748,
0.1832887828,
-0.6080334187,
0.2626155913,
-0.8136796951,
-0.388120532,
0.0849791691,
0.2701221406,
-0.3483712673,
0.3358052373,
0.1686166376,
0.454613477,
-0.3944113851,
0.2655251324,
0.0456359573,
-0.3131909072,
0.055022344,
-0.5295937061,
0.480555743,
0.0076545947,
-0.3998612165,
0.0624280572,
-0.7223352194,
0.1900082827,
0.0738285631,
-0.140763998,
-0.2361249477,
-0.3481256068,
-0.1512887627,
0.2018643767,
-0.1114192531,
-0.8459714055,
0.1099552959,
-0.89308393,
0.4652408361,
0.8853846788,
0.0589448921,
0.503436029,
0.1345175058,
0.4198192358,
-0.1634993404,
0.3410963714,
-0.3552794755,
-0.3098230362,
-1.1155585051,
0.0240107141,
0.7148026824,
-0.0309027955,
-0.4932559431,
0.4875163436,
-0.5111798048,
-0.1188345328,
-0.3970260918,
-0.1273133904,
0.4669762552,
0.9493836164,
0.5312355161,
-0.3158285022,
-0.1972830147,
-0.931255877,
-0.1457450688,
0.3019696474,
-0.0618459694,
0.3972045779,
0.2221535593,
-0.0116338944,
1.3559566736,
-0.7695450187,
-0.3133170307,
-0.1051731408,
-0.0496797711,
0.1936637163,
0.2475519031,
0.2914539874,
-0.7402319312,
-0.6195191741,
0.0829010457,
-0.1653781384,
0.0491107441,
0.0452376455,
-0.1766079813,
0.2570735216,
0.5408742428,
-0.3267640769,
0.6736108065,
0.0615134761,
-0.3205670714,
0.5163919926,
-0.2174725384,
-0.3868714273,
-0.9585710764,
0.1639011502,
0.0624630712,
-0.3483287096,
-0.8328962922,
0.0772181228,
0.367610842,
0.0297186282,
-0.5326850414,
0.7360990047,
-0.2203262597,
0.3784220815,
-0.449598819,
0.004994581,
-0.1135778427,
1.1175024509,
-0.0867302269,
0.595138073,
0.6157881021,
-0.8997243643,
0.4387080073,
0.0674205869,
-0.0669540465,
0.5675858855,
-0.6485520601,
0.3055805266,
-0.4298439324,
0.0174348336,
-0.9373314977,
-0.0142337615,
0.3358484209,
-0.3624178767,
0.5420378447,
0.0469692387,
-0.4301274419,
-0.3595756292,
-0.196674332,
0.5791441202,
0.4818686247,
-0.7065130472,
0.5783408284,
0.000212173,
0.0150209535,
-0.571665585,
-0.4214934409,
0.0673810169,
-0.3759398758,
-0.3619784713,
0.385545522,
0.0924352631,
0.4957329631,
-0.1540923715,
-0.3951400816,
0.1055096686,
-0.0325423218,
0.2410806715,
0.0314550847,
-0.3100012541,
0.4214650393,
-0.0275899488,
-0.6975508332,
-0.0048370627,
-0.5166915655,
0.541655302,
-0.2450172156,
-0.1152404472,
-0.3903800547,
0.2260653377,
0.3790516853,
-0.422131896,
0.3231834769,
0.5829375386,
-0.0956134424,
-0.5192146897,
-0.7360283732,
-0.4916823506,
-0.5041493773,
0.4559511542,
-0.2867967188,
-0.9408085942,
0.37616539,
-0.3898929358,
-0.0673400238,
0.3740870357,
0.2464932501,
0.2347723991,
0.5682689548,
0.8993769288,
-0.1932384968,
0.1535997093,
-0.4569399655,
0.4060006738,
-1.0842363834,
-0.2721263766,
-0.2710514367,
-0.8925572038,
-0.1510836333,
-0.1143748015,
0.506708324,
-0.0376446508,
-0.2881778479,
0.405500561,
-0.5419476032,
0.8298642039,
0.5942701697,
0.2225021124,
0.1623052061,
0.0548996143,
-0.2050707042,
-0.1398952305,
-0.6430873871,
0.2026750296,
0.6291583776,
0.5081273317,
0.4202747643,
-0.2305220366,
0.2642922401,
-0.1294226944,
-0.1553649455,
-1.1931760311,
0.5537755489,
0.2003317028,
-0.0970283374,
-0.6612065434,
-0.3894251585,
-0.9304465652,
-0.0921665877,
0.403319627,
-0.8536068201,
0.2635485828,
0.0021732333,
-0.5501573682,
0.3786660433,
-0.5057172775,
0.7644574642,
-0.1690242738,
-0.3079577088,
-0.2821850777,
-1.1381975412,
-0.0400051847,
-0.2961037457,
-0.4079363346,
-0.1036533043,
-0.2402169704,
0.5778938532,
-0.1198470369,
0.8564504981,
0.0513461046,
-0.2625403106,
-0.0086330855,
0.0453049131,
0.3717046976,
0.3395906091,
0.1185047925,
0.1732513011,
-0.6119188666,
-0.1254792809,
-0.8384705782,
0.7361002564,
-0.5722219944,
-0.4547111988,
-0.1035352349,
-0.6402549148,
-0.4323556721,
0.3076475561,
0.2575925291,
0.6343145967,
0.0244826823,
0.1504596174,
0.7974043489,
-0.0186978318,
0.7764132023,
0.43588835,
0.0737406686,
-0.294658035,
0.9708420038,
0.0933471248,
0.2408098727,
0.4808535874,
0.4991271496,
-0.3779745102,
-0.1234772205,
-0.349176079,
0.3848057091,
-0.5323946476,
-0.4734850526,
-0.6807701588,
-0.3791334629,
0.145375222,
-0.0298210885,
-0.5209976435,
-0.3541009128,
-0.2173313349,
-0.0047143833,
0.6738532186,
0.4595884681,
0.1736016423,
0.4158570468,
-0.4311948419,
0.5664574504,
0.4464268982,
0.9903131127,
0.5089393258,
-0.7378672361,
-0.3870095611,
0.0005755676,
-0.4215314388,
-0.4853727818,
0.123702094,
0.5058273673,
0.0327020139,
0.6210614443,
0.0369161442,
0.7834075093,
-0.8390354514,
0.5155138373,
0.0324875228,
-0.8958771825,
0.4533112347,
-0.0327042378,
0.7339932323,
0.5515764356,
0.4439819455,
-0.7353165746,
-0.1255015731,
-0.6765509844,
-0.9228934646,
1.1344143152,
0.2988950312,
0.4163787365,
0.135056302,
0.510111928,
0.2415548712,
-0.1196297482,
-0.2453594953,
-0.6028635502,
-0.1297883689,
0.2348013967,
-0.0430299155,
-0.2841462493,
0.146782279,
-0.5901330113,
0.5745093226,
-0.2343935668,
0.2948371768,
0.1816391647,
0.1254775524,
-0.0695642605,
0.2435921878,
0.7890303731,
0.7529444695,
-0.0731066838,
0.0132792061,
0.6517481804,
-0.6673433185,
-0.0383658372,
-0.0918359309,
0.0792069063,
0.0938304216,
-0.1280018687,
1.134559989,
0.2992839515,
-0.1764519215,
0.3632247746,
-0.0687195659,
-0.1753904223,
-0.0710465908,
-0.0176058244,
0.0350678675,
-0.0710173473,
0.4644723833,
-0.005322739,
-0.0236358419,
0.1854169965,
0.1627462804,
0.2256020457,
-0.7026534677,
-0.300036937,
0.5463367105,
-0.1119425297,
-0.391159147,
0.6430341601,
-0.0998412669,
-0.4908638895,
0.8033012152,
0.6338207722,
1.0797331333,
-0.2980126739,
0.0592476688,
0.359636575,
0.0234402735,
0.0922354534,
-0.1319661587,
-0.4519678056,
-0.2435927391,
-0.713544488,
-0.7286699414,
-0.0494932793,
0.2286641002,
-0.3109613359,
0.3811375797,
-0.4265504479,
-0.1172678471,
0.215871498,
-0.1559973508,
-0.4967020452,
0.242984578,
0.162988171,
0.9619657993,
-0.2924176753,
0.6838257313,
0.3965711892,
0.061637599,
-0.9682922363,
0.143550843,
-0.4009288549,
-0.6235303283,
0.892393291,
0.3812585771,
-0.3136262298,
0.4998229742,
-0.437820375,
-0.8118060827,
0.7905787826,
0.3820342422,
-0.349268347,
-0.2642703354,
0.5745972395,
0.5031374693,
-0.0382668823,
0.2671467364,
0.582059145,
0.3966547847,
0.1255055368,
-0.9313046336,
0.012834114,
-0.0537928902,
0.3610745966,
0.5733146667,
-0.8065997958,
0.318800211,
-0.1071519628,
-0.3527014256,
-0.1524755955,
0.8141545057,
-0.4118919969,
0.1342783272,
0.4067688882,
0.7329837084,
0.2124733627,
-0.0346580222,
0.7888112664,
-0.3415798843,
0.6421638727,
0.7391973734,
0.3209708035,
0.3963288367,
0.6134875417,
-0.0946869701,
-0.0057520191,
0.3786065876,
0.0895645916,
0.6296573877,
0.3730177581,
-0.0221787225,
-0.0378605835,
-0.2803987265,
-0.2948160768,
0.2661295831,
0.3977379203,
-0.1413394809,
-0.6765877008,
0.2825262845,
-0.2977484763,
-0.3046630323,
-0.4850258827,
0.901810348,
0.4917404652,
-0.670579493,
1.0434765816,
0.0034087005,
0.6362076402,
-0.678915143,
-0.0306170452,
-0.147288397,
0.0907128155,
-0.0541414432,
-0.6948772669,
0.2751389146,
-0.3596564829,
-0.1596168727,
0.0436432064,
0.3990971148,
-0.3212805092,
-0.3196732998,
0.0646172389,
-0.0616448149,
-0.0902600363,
-0.2219264954,
-0.3618237376,
-0.3239693046,
-0.1187027767,
-0.0726937354,
0.0695238337,
0.4339337349,
0.007584604,
0.6818777919,
0.3442934155,
0.005768057,
0.1478865594,
-0.1191157326,
0.8430152535,
-0.5869208574,
-0.8612188697,
-1.1105926037,
0.3959801495,
0.1754813045,
-0.6015489697,
0.5339584351,
0.4462521374,
0.8581960797,
-0.2898608446,
0.1639627218,
0.0626924038,
0.2667830288,
-0.4404713809,
0.4194002151,
-0.5569546223,
-0.1354177445,
-0.0322656967,
-1.267921567,
-0.5395397544,
0.0685642511,
-0.4005747139,
-0.0280494802,
0.8724247813,
0.7610562444,
-0.693367362,
0.341504842,
0.3761086464,
-0.0166857578,
-0.1410422474,
0.7474520206,
0.6263298392,
-0.2904568613,
0.1849347949,
-0.4545586109,
0.0196164716,
-0.1871641278,
-0.8295218349,
-0.838388145,
-0.6615758538,
-0.1794067323,
-0.0660663247,
0.1072095931,
0.8873667717,
0.5806400776,
-0.7024872899,
0.2159921229,
-0.2911266685,
-0.0283668768,
-0.1493000388,
-0.1887235641,
0.9185055494,
-0.7084403634,
-0.7369039655,
0.0686759725,
0.4329859018,
-0.230187133,
-0.0963957086,
-0.0286948849,
0.063406162,
-0.3020498455,
0.5517551899,
0.5151427984,
-0.8098312616,
-0.1212179214,
0.2442605048,
0.0507027619,
0.4891091585,
0.8440574408,
-0.9797082543,
0.5595898032,
0.3034467101,
1.051107049,
0.380849272,
0.1324829161,
0.3539307415,
-1.133318305,
0.1909005195,
0.39251405,
-0.1940357536,
0.0356370769,
-0.5225826502,
0.3920270503,
-0.2000765949,
-0.5829597712,
-0.4465328753,
0.2727230191,
-0.9482295513,
-0.0266054496,
1.1492513418,
0.3446807861,
-0.3336680532,
-0.1678452641,
-0.4872621,
0.3573907316,
-0.4916807711,
0.7030844688,
0.329053551,
0.0809368268,
-0.14234294,
-0.5593875051,
0.7611314654,
0.7101437449,
-0.2677277923,
-0.0043846294,
-0.1498885006,
0.0285692178,
0.323246181,
-0.0719064996,
0.1221798286,
0.4056243896,
-0.7031838298,
-0.2743492126,
-0.4327004552,
-0.5702915192,
-0.6807371974,
0.0279366858,
-0.1761893928,
-0.2115378976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14035v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14035v1 | Two Giraffes in a Dirt Field: Using Game Play to Investigate Situation Modelling in Large Multimodal Models | 2024-06-20T06:56:19 | 2024-06-20T06:56:19 | Sherzod Hakimov, Yerkezhan Abdullayeva, Kushal Koshti, Antonia Schmidt, Yan Weiser, Anne Beyer, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While the situation has improved for text-only models, it again seems to be
the case currently that multimodal (text and image) models develop faster than
ways to evaluate them. In this paper, we bring a recently developed evaluation
paradigm from text models to multimodal models, namely evaluation through the
goal-oriented game (self) play, complementing reference-based and
preference-based evaluation. Specifically, we define games that challenge a
model's capability to represent a situation from visual information and align
such representations through dialogue. We find that the largest closed models
perform rather well on the games that we define, while even the best
open-weight models struggle with them. On further analysis, we find that the
exceptional deep captioning capabilities of the largest models drive some of
the performance. There is still room to grow for both kinds of models, ensuring
the continued relevance of the benchmark. | [
-0.2515307069,
-0.5270641446,
0.7281795144,
0.4166464806,
-0.0662352443,
-0.0973482355,
-0.2017891556,
-0.4310138822,
-0.2814208865,
0.5656169057,
-0.6337952018,
-0.1853863746,
-0.6354119778,
-0.0739530846,
-0.1447282732,
1.1124224663,
-0.0821668804,
0.1175563261,
-0.7680568099,
-0.3308945,
-0.8136752844,
-0.654718101,
-0.4204371274,
-0.5318387151,
0.409712702,
0.1862347424,
0.9408268332,
0.4794720411,
1.0622645617,
0.4688868821,
0.1266064644,
-0.0417720824,
-0.421487987,
0.5391333103,
-0.2155635655,
-0.2840985358,
0.0574192293,
0.3060585558,
0.4481388032,
0.1993017644,
0.0246427786,
0.1653949469,
-0.0313807093,
0.228533119,
-0.5536726117,
0.5738946795,
-0.0797411948,
0.3334537148,
0.4002998471,
-0.2475578189,
-0.2453237772,
0.0058455192,
0.4324864149,
-0.7732499838,
-0.043290861,
-0.1196379513,
1.029645443,
0.1196747869,
-0.6287067533,
-0.4952268004,
-0.8509582877,
0.802110076,
-0.5458378196,
0.1290217489,
-0.0181627069,
0.4693593085,
-0.2417018563,
-0.5082116723,
-0.6232122779,
-0.4879947305,
0.0312109664,
0.3317780793,
-0.0743912384,
0.2026244849,
0.3660976887,
0.1476974338,
-0.032826975,
-0.2858313322,
-0.3381544948,
-0.1548485011,
0.730335474,
0.3707703054,
0.3243701458,
-0.4353042841,
-0.6887426972,
-0.1604881883,
-0.2746086717,
0.4345749319,
0.3161682189,
0.1193584651,
-0.2534638047,
0.8564106822,
-0.077318348,
0.5292215347,
-0.1353331506,
-0.4025721252,
0.0728977993,
-0.3917714655,
-0.2071048915,
-0.3752549291,
0.8059607148,
1.0709176064,
0.2208481878,
-0.0067299916,
-0.4765858352,
0.4072193503,
0.3852565587,
-0.806553483,
-0.2700645626,
0.1478250623,
-0.6239156127,
-0.4411512017,
-0.1795023233,
-0.9823602438,
-0.6043925881,
-0.271101594,
0.7778619528,
-0.5235276818,
-0.3859967589,
0.144701615,
-0.304586798,
0.1647496969,
0.6284400225,
-0.6306100488,
0.1819105297,
0.6045588851,
1.0858769417,
-0.075086236,
-0.3982819319,
-0.2706516981,
0.0114037888,
-0.6228504777,
0.8209727407,
-0.527805686,
-0.6416014433,
0.0471213944,
-0.1303425878,
0.112922281,
-0.2186473459,
0.6238821745,
-0.4800358415,
0.2154766023,
-0.3252451122,
-0.2248283923,
-0.1572041214,
0.8461828828,
-0.8128798008,
0.8162984848,
-0.0373013169,
-0.6798356175,
0.6349213123,
-1.1987851858,
-0.4871706665,
-0.0784503371,
-0.0676495805,
-0.1969666183,
0.2733865678,
0.1110178232,
0.2604728639,
-0.3698669374,
0.4808970392,
-0.5427963734,
-0.4117150009,
0.1555153877,
-0.3900988698,
0.2260472625,
0.3983252048,
-0.0251100566,
0.1422089487,
-0.1047071666,
0.1781995893,
0.3358651102,
-0.3322095573,
-0.3090771139,
0.3203237057,
-0.0860114992,
0.7477931976,
0.0306649785,
-0.41574049,
0.3731876016,
0.1487704813,
0.8673893213,
0.4457333684,
-0.1966581047,
0.561146915,
-0.4904403687,
0.6172747016,
0.3126581907,
0.4763296843,
-0.6805068851,
-0.4687667787,
-0.6451506019,
-0.1841981262,
0.6427901387,
0.3516501784,
-0.9352787137,
-0.3002199531,
-0.4368742108,
-0.3463492393,
-0.4803038239,
-0.308830291,
0.3507306874,
0.2036301941,
0.0207930114,
-0.6212576628,
-0.2937000394,
-0.9791713953,
0.1720446646,
-0.4048049152,
0.5219925046,
0.7199918032,
0.7038054466,
-0.1539861858,
0.9182916284,
-0.2213042229,
-0.2422379404,
-0.0824974477,
0.5276482105,
-0.0247398019,
0.554800272,
0.700583756,
-1.0977158546,
0.1721775532,
-0.2665587664,
-1.1192855835,
0.2827281356,
-0.3307630718,
0.1069041416,
-0.0674330667,
0.2418611646,
-0.8661754131,
0.232294023,
0.7166646123,
-0.3839097023,
0.5751439333,
-0.5089921355,
0.8227933645,
-0.3814692795,
-0.0867625251,
0.1385526955,
-0.2321057022,
-0.4127919972,
0.5830006003,
-0.0809255242,
-0.3723165393,
-0.3634161055,
0.5727295876,
-0.7064670324,
-0.4015999436,
-0.1316400468,
0.1976477951,
0.3023588061,
0.2614769042,
0.2616710067,
0.8252706528,
0.5241173506,
-0.6113862395,
0.4816212058,
0.3208982944,
-0.7515214682,
0.4986981452,
-0.5829841495,
-0.2307099402,
-0.295861274,
0.2620019317,
-1.2032220364,
-0.3648743331,
0.2139378488,
-0.310832262,
0.0746637359,
-0.2304714471,
-0.5063958168,
-0.7854760289,
-0.3668027818,
0.562264502,
0.1751189083,
-0.3931317031,
0.6781199574,
0.4702235758,
-0.2249769121,
-0.5696411729,
-0.650488317,
0.3480789363,
-0.3127988279,
-0.6781827807,
0.2919252515,
-0.3248574734,
-0.2696461976,
-0.1456062496,
0.0193959568,
-0.1937258095,
0.1071632653,
0.5207031369,
0.1382253021,
-0.3149956167,
0.4625736773,
-0.1692236364,
0.2170836627,
0.0571053103,
0.2500985563,
0.3421087563,
-0.2302302122,
-0.215404138,
-0.0183962099,
0.5823525786,
0.6531482935,
-0.4171577096,
0.3237489462,
0.0960073024,
-0.2316549867,
0.3782730401,
-0.5702815652,
0.1371209919,
-0.4398453534,
0.4916571975,
-0.7144778967,
-0.704652667,
0.4755656421,
-0.2749840021,
-0.0707499608,
0.439820081,
0.4406561255,
-0.2724452615,
1.1407802105,
0.7801204324,
0.3605157733,
0.4080151916,
-0.2092536837,
-0.0579936095,
-0.6786565185,
-0.4817136824,
-0.2363015264,
-0.2696178555,
-0.3167836368,
-0.640812397,
0.2921831906,
0.135715723,
-0.3014345169,
0.1996251494,
-0.3588093221,
0.535784781,
0.4428833425,
0.1604256183,
0.2758661807,
-0.2657975256,
-0.2857786119,
-0.1634636074,
-0.9901378751,
-0.6507490277,
0.9041644931,
0.3941751719,
0.6779354215,
0.1062903181,
0.6368350983,
0.6113741994,
0.754550457,
-0.7765750885,
0.41833812,
0.1611008644,
-0.9210780263,
-0.3079558313,
-0.3037368655,
-0.7808846235,
0.4621087313,
-0.6202600598,
-0.473487407,
0.0452555791,
-0.0649267063,
-0.6392056942,
-0.0214532465,
-0.9031163454,
1.3035846949,
-0.5303259492,
-0.4695840776,
-0.1231882796,
-0.5050239563,
0.5927732587,
0.2969836593,
0.5581074357,
-0.051297009,
-0.0040893755,
0.5472925901,
0.0290971976,
0.404286623,
-0.1391066909,
-0.1369692087,
0.6873885393,
0.4586628973,
0.0982860327,
0.1854961962,
-0.024923848,
0.0994855538,
0.4472551942,
-0.2320839316,
-0.6748600006,
0.8467852473,
-0.857008338,
-0.7812821865,
-0.6772717237,
-0.649199307,
-0.1969225556,
0.0292865001,
0.0992727578,
0.5289188623,
-0.4828737676,
0.0787953809,
0.2070658654,
-0.3431983888,
0.7556659579,
0.367050916,
-0.4545322061,
-0.1920907795,
0.6827449799,
-0.0085148504,
0.0382365435,
0.0857302099,
0.1079733446,
-0.404299736,
-0.3493071795,
-0.6365661621,
-0.1029175818,
-0.7368327975,
-0.3653391302,
-0.4986724854,
-0.0700572804,
-0.0310568027,
0.1064073965,
-0.2219460756,
-0.1735385507,
0.1211145297,
0.0594569184,
-0.1289567202,
0.9267627597,
-0.1664707214,
0.456212163,
-0.7738457322,
0.2057503164,
0.305773586,
0.628410697,
0.0051585329,
-0.2093869597,
-0.0618559904,
0.1630062312,
-0.5925884247,
-0.8990345597,
0.2534840703,
0.0868728757,
0.4484395981,
0.1986673623,
-0.2305669338,
0.7651078701,
-0.5807934999,
1.0159561634,
0.4783227444,
-1.0062917471,
0.287009269,
-0.4858435392,
0.273106873,
0.3820282519,
0.1828107238,
-0.5631633997,
0.2069946527,
-0.5717904568,
-0.4120134413,
0.8598057628,
0.2603619099,
0.5781431198,
-0.063683331,
0.2217740119,
-0.0661776215,
0.6177393794,
-1.1006439924,
0.249408707,
-0.4937328696,
0.0561489351,
-0.3864121735,
-0.4917925298,
-0.359991163,
-0.1028394848,
0.1780153215,
-0.1954109818,
0.7057077885,
0.2694974244,
-0.1905234456,
-0.1831474155,
0.2535568476,
0.6499810815,
0.5529999137,
0.0081484811,
-0.0811276585,
-0.0400011651,
0.1159554794,
0.338388741,
0.0870072618,
0.0239535142,
-0.0801241845,
0.6475195885,
0.7568586469,
0.6480658054,
-0.8503599167,
0.9621796012,
-0.0042110789,
-0.1202021241,
0.0812775418,
0.0427079685,
-0.0862251297,
0.6124051213,
0.0550814271,
0.119646199,
0.4303327501,
-0.9832433462,
0.1754493862,
0.5678076148,
-0.5126709938,
-0.0042366614,
0.6872324347,
0.376852572,
-0.306276381,
0.4550227523,
-0.1697410941,
-0.6857552528,
1.0103555918,
0.4520757496,
0.4241131842,
-0.0229692943,
0.650545001,
0.4246620834,
0.2636744082,
-0.3664582372,
0.2428647876,
-0.033182621,
-0.6884136796,
-0.4761964083,
-0.3784109652,
-0.4002643526,
0.125913322,
-0.3972527087,
0.1373195499,
-0.3247497082,
-0.6598922014,
0.1965167075,
-0.0160595588,
-0.824563086,
0.6253064275,
0.3001635969,
0.5465899706,
-0.4803102016,
0.4080875516,
0.6987172961,
-0.4630609155,
-0.277877003,
-0.2579124272,
-0.324252069,
-0.4111985266,
0.8052392006,
0.4237210453,
0.0116309635,
-0.5995028615,
-0.7750178576,
-0.8333447576,
0.9458352923,
0.4008707106,
-0.6383820772,
-0.1828342974,
-0.2849157751,
0.7815529108,
-0.6900867224,
0.7199499011,
0.1620509923,
0.5901892185,
0.0891335905,
-0.7017500401,
-0.3645611405,
-0.3126115799,
0.0305706561,
0.0641851723,
-0.9884902239,
0.9751222134,
-0.6574114561,
-0.2518871725,
0.3585110605,
0.7283149958,
-0.1220629066,
0.4009413421,
0.6226421595,
0.2248076648,
0.1673218608,
-0.3797285557,
1.3435430527,
-0.2054461837,
0.6067895889,
1.090749383,
-0.5127508044,
0.5054927468,
0.238213256,
0.1835117936,
0.3674683273,
0.7094560266,
-0.2574141622,
0.7975466251,
0.2135705203,
0.1329285502,
-0.7118937969,
-0.0452281758,
-0.3003394306,
0.8494078517,
0.0826609358,
-0.3978449106,
-0.4940128028,
0.0574530065,
-0.3156997859,
0.1013145298,
-0.4104143083,
0.5854209661,
-0.2138719559,
-0.9932063818,
-0.0139764389,
0.3157105446,
0.5030511022,
-0.537646234,
-0.2352620959,
-0.0237411223,
0.0380318239,
0.2350297421,
-0.9669511318,
0.0133431349,
-0.1857221127,
-0.2495242506,
-0.1502865255,
0.6549358964,
-0.4182760119,
-0.5095963478,
0.5284976959,
0.5736763477,
-0.0604689829,
-0.0503077097,
-0.9790005684,
0.1481471956,
-0.404851079,
-0.2649922073,
0.286311686,
0.5304028988,
-0.2182828784,
0.8709952831,
0.2644332349,
-0.4263427258,
-0.3010637462,
-0.2592183948,
0.7710889578,
-0.7130931616,
-0.5225947499,
-0.9261455536,
0.3722805679,
-0.1448260546,
-0.6804361939,
0.4695056081,
0.6027467251,
0.3886930943,
-0.2830564082,
0.8171339035,
-0.0840527639,
-0.1750416011,
-0.4516128302,
0.4853598177,
-0.759139657,
-0.377792716,
-0.5573882461,
-0.7036811709,
-0.0337034017,
0.7583189011,
-0.3693837225,
0.1800623238,
0.3329159319,
0.2345737666,
-0.0980546027,
0.1205625981,
0.5080262423,
-0.0475862212,
0.1588458717,
0.7860165834,
1.3143302202,
-0.5112693906,
0.5606654882,
-0.1148722395,
-0.2420073301,
-0.1432648599,
-1.2043842077,
-0.9660022259,
-0.7653270364,
-0.2452908456,
-0.3711740375,
0.2988304198,
0.673781693,
0.887933135,
-0.4857750535,
-0.2137894928,
0.5066798925,
0.0520604961,
-0.3585676551,
-0.1989434212,
-0.1355154067,
-0.1773950011,
-0.6288095117,
0.1856431216,
0.2941183448,
0.0871881992,
-0.3970777392,
-0.0546800718,
-0.3002228737,
0.5131146908,
0.9593810439,
-0.0386101194,
-0.578407824,
-0.6074011922,
-0.1581423134,
-0.2807360291,
0.3154251277,
0.96351403,
-0.7833333015,
0.7417868376,
-0.0277992375,
0.3546893001,
0.6588339806,
0.0934349298,
0.7012842298,
-0.1829452217,
0.1204258129,
0.178785935,
0.4097587168,
0.5388747454,
-0.2296668589,
0.7085006833,
0.0858315006,
-0.4267752171,
-0.7799340487,
0.2105396241,
-0.738653481,
-0.1730959266,
1.0941258669,
-0.427744478,
-0.1072456613,
0.4340661764,
-0.4387015104,
0.2070816755,
-0.282689333,
0.882239759,
1.4531258345,
0.1349120736,
-0.1770350933,
-0.7277345657,
0.3877035081,
0.1506059021,
-0.5904209018,
-0.2622264624,
0.8445085287,
0.2066423148,
0.4394688606,
0.4562802613,
-0.058366444,
0.3216899931,
0.1109501719,
0.0462808199,
-0.3197695315,
-0.8236794472,
-0.2776563764,
0.3713559508,
-0.1672875732,
-0.1059158817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14026v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14026v1 | Demystifying Forgetting in Language Model Fine-Tuning with Statistical Analysis of Example Associations | 2024-06-20T06:46:23 | 2024-06-20T06:46:23 | Xisen Jin, Xiang Ren | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Language models (LMs) are known to suffer from forgetting of previously
learned examples when fine-tuned, breaking stability of deployed LM systems.
Despite efforts on mitigating forgetting, few have investigated whether, and
how forgotten upstream examples are associated with newly learned tasks.
Insights on such associations enable efficient and targeted mitigation of
forgetting. In this paper, we empirically analyze forgetting that occurs in $N$
upstream examples while the model learns $M$ new tasks and visualize their
associations with a $M \times N$ matrix. We empirically demonstrate that the
degree of forgetting can often be approximated by simple multiplicative
contributions of the upstream examples and newly learned tasks. We also reveal
more complicated patterns where specific subsets of examples are forgotten with
statistics and visualization. Following our analysis, we predict forgetting
that happens on upstream examples when learning a new task with matrix
completion over the empirical associations, outperforming prior approaches that
rely on trainable LMs. Project website:
https://inklab.usc.edu/lm-forgetting-prediction/ | [
-0.2778002024,
-0.8165407777,
0.552264452,
-0.1376084983,
-0.1332125217,
-0.0346279368,
0.0047047641,
-0.0901758075,
0.2501963973,
0.3819326162,
-0.6796517968,
-0.4876154065,
-0.5973387361,
-0.2201804817,
-0.3940793872,
1.1194930077,
-0.2044764459,
-0.1715209335,
-0.3633185327,
-0.2261036783,
-0.9010007977,
-0.3306604624,
-1.0767979622,
-0.4479322433,
0.7664574385,
0.5743768811,
0.1157548726,
0.6648272276,
0.3654731214,
0.231873855,
0.0667560101,
-0.1315532923,
-0.9241584539,
0.2377071232,
0.0193419904,
-0.7173941731,
-0.5179026723,
-0.1072840318,
0.8879852295,
1.1143343449,
-0.1450171024,
0.3618482649,
0.2608804405,
0.866312623,
-0.8781302571,
0.5063847899,
-0.8946456909,
-0.0557931438,
-0.0331068523,
-0.1812868714,
-0.2829653621,
-0.0247777142,
-0.0120199695,
-0.4940382242,
0.3874348104,
-0.1558301598,
0.5913127065,
0.1661313027,
-0.0666593239,
-0.3683845103,
-0.8231699467,
1.0110766888,
-0.6529243588,
0.2186005414,
0.737372756,
0.3368703425,
-0.1372118741,
-0.4446732998,
-0.2457538098,
-0.039955724,
0.0044664927,
0.1566557437,
-0.3833779693,
-0.2319336236,
0.2483418286,
0.3723211288,
-0.2884406149,
0.1547858566,
-0.4796559215,
-0.3169474304,
0.2099620402,
0.3731040359,
0.1861995608,
0.4502293766,
-0.0992453992,
-0.0750579983,
-0.9744824767,
-0.1198518574,
0.2554182708,
0.4459555447,
-0.1982268095,
0.1516075432,
-0.353802681,
0.329741329,
-0.0342866778,
-0.0309336688,
0.3023113012,
-0.2062077224,
-0.1866332293,
-0.1916197836,
0.4867849052,
0.2526855171,
0.7197219729,
-0.1182816774,
-0.3970630765,
0.006155293,
0.1680319607,
-0.584900558,
-0.509616375,
0.1445297599,
-0.515396893,
0.2377923727,
-0.4570225179,
-0.393974185,
-0.3446496725,
-0.4063099325,
0.5927847028,
-0.5894903541,
-0.3692470491,
-0.0354630463,
-0.3186615407,
-0.0459464379,
0.2799105644,
-0.8484374881,
0.4596754014,
0.6421491504,
0.789080441,
0.2186994851,
-0.78860569,
-0.4929166734,
0.1406622976,
-0.4204769433,
0.6747918725,
-0.4535571933,
-0.1158065051,
0.0023423443,
-0.099950999,
-0.3438012898,
-0.5992753506,
0.3175867498,
-0.4421656728,
-0.0059593702,
-0.4609853327,
-0.9071887136,
-0.4236671925,
0.1891822368,
-0.8904017806,
0.8304445744,
-0.0748670623,
-0.5259639025,
0.6202460527,
-0.2126777023,
-0.0435811318,
-0.22879453,
0.0466821343,
-0.6908060312,
0.4314903915,
-0.1277548075,
0.8196083307,
0.0696966201,
0.0327652022,
-0.614051342,
-0.5314972997,
-0.0644260272,
-0.191909954,
0.4564515352,
0.0251557715,
0.1377899945,
0.1773363352,
-0.7646740675,
-0.4129648805,
0.2394032478,
-0.2374276519,
-0.6787674427,
0.1546891481,
-0.2803814113,
0.0660152584,
0.0836143345,
-0.2457669675,
0.0416093543,
-0.1078350469,
0.1959255487,
0.8752970695,
0.3966523707,
0.5404085517,
-0.3963552415,
0.4386506975,
0.403132081,
-0.1663653553,
-0.752505362,
-0.192553699,
-1.0849983692,
0.0284573343,
0.1201074645,
0.219930917,
-0.3267715275,
-0.0837122276,
-0.282274127,
-0.5142899156,
-0.1987351626,
0.4398100376,
0.4012927413,
0.3515112698,
0.3239678144,
-0.4238358736,
-0.5909332037,
-0.9937825799,
-0.3585213423,
-0.1328682154,
-0.0062006139,
-0.0960655585,
0.7608513236,
-0.1650819182,
0.6157275438,
-0.3122246563,
-0.6130086184,
-0.3565010726,
0.3362638056,
0.1004545614,
0.4809205532,
0.5974404216,
-0.2885848582,
-0.2419862151,
-0.2977227271,
-0.5369087458,
0.1671420187,
-0.3487376869,
0.199021697,
0.2148384452,
0.8492305279,
-0.2968862057,
0.2355592102,
0.3382731974,
-0.2503572106,
0.4193552136,
-0.3814485669,
-0.3502773046,
-0.9713180661,
-0.1179543138,
-0.0533184074,
0.0440503359,
-0.8529942632,
-0.1386252493,
0.157791689,
0.1994431466,
-0.1496688426,
0.3899922967,
-0.8674013615,
0.1254207343,
-0.4235085845,
-0.1055903658,
-0.4002792537,
0.7425920963,
-0.273026973,
0.4454489946,
0.7284748554,
-0.8370671868,
-0.3997454047,
-0.280927062,
-0.0983105823,
0.0724486411,
-0.5198129416,
0.0159076564,
-0.5050113201,
-0.1140449122,
-1.0464293957,
-0.0564828925,
0.0204928424,
-0.2556117475,
0.4077382088,
-0.3466296792,
-0.4311698377,
0.1353185624,
-0.2040969431,
0.3714084923,
0.5407682657,
-0.0575065687,
0.5199587345,
0.5792880058,
-0.2913664281,
-0.5056516528,
-0.4255647361,
-0.0229085088,
-0.424351424,
0.1978290826,
-0.006183438,
0.1712802947,
-0.1289248616,
-0.1159501001,
-0.1557628512,
-0.1578858346,
0.5438662767,
0.4117569923,
-0.1068616062,
-0.1393680573,
0.3279909492,
0.0436909311,
-0.2654526532,
0.2728154063,
0.0086348793,
0.7198135257,
-0.1323667914,
-0.4594734013,
-0.2706257403,
0.3096216023,
0.6970565319,
-0.0336608589,
0.7199132442,
0.5569028854,
-0.6266221404,
-0.3022669852,
-0.4172852039,
-0.4540715516,
-0.3742578328,
0.6720719934,
-0.2459115088,
-0.8791760802,
1.0435469151,
-0.0724147484,
0.2636264265,
0.368145287,
0.4799928069,
-0.1535593271,
0.7228865027,
1.0194741488,
-0.4835552573,
0.6039705873,
-0.3415879309,
0.086610429,
-0.650234282,
0.1634667516,
-0.3879233599,
-0.4511232674,
-0.5855704546,
-0.2573385537,
0.0487933271,
0.4736951888,
-0.2130438834,
0.2840337753,
0.252246201,
0.5861935019,
0.7304569483,
-0.1982858628,
0.1991250217,
0.032841295,
-0.1358446032,
0.0490491055,
-0.896001637,
-0.5364063978,
1.2567725182,
0.4054475725,
0.6472088695,
-0.0225360952,
0.9676277637,
0.1866154522,
0.3824461699,
-0.6048693061,
0.544303,
-0.0676432252,
-0.3891215026,
-0.1564949751,
-0.3142203093,
-1.1468755007,
-0.0436473787,
-0.1258234531,
-0.8648275733,
0.0998463705,
0.7043117285,
-0.1871792078,
0.2835699916,
-0.8468427658,
0.704882443,
0.3172933757,
-0.2969508171,
-0.5017549396,
-0.2605003119,
0.3387339115,
-0.1241367608,
0.1911511719,
-0.3153695762,
0.2298734039,
0.6981441975,
0.0627046078,
1.4124382734,
-0.2682421803,
-0.1645966917,
0.2104960084,
0.2218773216,
0.3254924119,
-0.3443477154,
-0.0394267552,
0.13249138,
-0.255186677,
-0.5505677462,
-0.4600807726,
0.8578212857,
-0.3673301041,
-0.3521526754,
-0.1983637512,
-0.6988320351,
-0.1899797022,
0.20212394,
-0.2151804417,
0.222165972,
-0.2739990652,
-0.0025724964,
0.7452120185,
-0.0725150779,
0.7373428345,
0.4467391968,
-0.1986308545,
0.029164644,
1.134275794,
0.3713225126,
0.4060820341,
0.4249863923,
0.0200836118,
0.084241204,
-0.8686324954,
-0.2255904824,
0.2016488761,
-0.7416573763,
-0.0854744613,
-0.4924549162,
0.1412905902,
-0.1755453348,
0.2245944589,
-0.2814058363,
-0.5012952089,
-0.2958849669,
-0.1759401262,
0.3116194904,
0.7263531089,
0.0618301928,
0.3002827466,
-0.5933539271,
0.2048757523,
0.1503309757,
0.4753834903,
0.5549021959,
-0.2591615319,
-0.6681706309,
0.113373138,
-0.3494886458,
-0.6501912475,
0.195791766,
0.5427082181,
0.8216460347,
0.697303772,
-0.3088136017,
0.8391660452,
-0.5596021414,
0.4140321612,
0.0710258707,
-0.6633319855,
0.4755429327,
-0.3960879147,
0.5221930146,
0.4743102789,
0.3836213052,
-0.5240164995,
-0.7481265068,
-0.4829639792,
-0.8896250725,
0.3781178594,
0.0358302817,
0.1888875216,
0.0226862989,
0.3902897835,
0.1732097566,
0.0504879914,
-0.6423950195,
-0.5335236788,
0.3130909801,
-0.1232344955,
-0.40286237,
-0.4849784374,
0.2495436221,
-0.1901082397,
0.570322752,
-0.0808465779,
0.1611720175,
-0.2382566333,
-0.4358896315,
-0.0441214368,
0.1476275623,
0.6762266755,
0.6490401626,
-0.2235559523,
0.2176181823,
0.385318011,
-0.5464357138,
-0.1726327837,
-0.1852867454,
-0.2096282095,
0.0687671453,
0.6417599916,
0.7925258875,
0.4594182372,
-0.5526506901,
-0.0846783966,
0.1493810564,
-0.0515405908,
-0.5640496016,
0.295897752,
0.5071882606,
-0.0690312907,
0.461276114,
0.1986310184,
0.1847366393,
-0.7445427179,
0.186652109,
0.5697054863,
-0.7923324704,
-0.515308857,
0.432020694,
-0.2454386204,
-0.1226710975,
0.3335856497,
-0.1668964028,
-0.3819163144,
0.6137340069,
0.465652436,
0.9948388934,
-0.3234606683,
-0.2108866274,
0.4754438698,
0.488771975,
-0.1365549862,
0.2118394524,
-0.0043192762,
-0.8243312836,
-0.3768766522,
-0.6526741982,
-0.254968375,
0.3110316694,
-0.8376451731,
0.080334723,
-0.324919939,
-0.0102710435,
-0.0719210282,
-0.2012998164,
-0.5639566183,
0.0857606754,
0.063820526,
0.680434227,
-1.3666630983,
0.8308902979,
0.6435357332,
-0.5063998699,
-0.6528459787,
-0.0401710384,
0.0790642351,
-0.7311497331,
0.3883945048,
0.1441993117,
-0.2320039272,
-0.1727830917,
-0.0912179053,
-0.8163101077,
0.9977847338,
0.3733344972,
-0.5458561778,
0.2584072948,
0.146406576,
0.6367843151,
-0.3937136233,
0.2421211451,
0.7374070287,
0.0613420568,
-0.3764520884,
-0.6964746118,
-0.1072319746,
-0.351888299,
-0.1879574805,
0.5544492602,
-0.3811269999,
1.2139877081,
-0.4664503038,
-0.2645688653,
-0.0988957286,
0.4734575152,
0.2580848038,
0.6663385034,
0.4823739827,
0.6485890746,
0.6366605163,
0.0920811146,
0.8400652409,
-0.0319160819,
0.3348861933,
1.5387552977,
0.0247820485,
1.0000789165,
0.7656850219,
0.0454520546,
0.4594144523,
0.4930379391,
0.1726301759,
0.4077602029,
0.1368881166,
-0.0817222893,
-0.2530045509,
0.1684562564,
-0.1700084656,
0.3800536096,
0.5884451866,
-0.5274830461,
-0.4795421362,
-0.0300955083,
0.1222947165,
0.026153015,
-0.6886146069,
0.9036063552,
0.259942621,
-0.4264517128,
0.6556017995,
-0.2594404817,
0.3243788183,
-0.5760945082,
-0.2328931391,
-0.4596794546,
0.416098088,
0.1854600161,
-0.3949115872,
0.2994776368,
-0.2758759558,
-0.5764311552,
-0.4412286878,
0.5796533823,
-0.5894526243,
-0.7074674368,
0.3629276752,
0.8043355346,
0.1712320149,
-0.118579939,
-0.4122277796,
-0.0516779721,
0.0758333206,
-0.1316252202,
0.5808843374,
0.4873628914,
-0.4470660985,
1.0966287851,
0.384241432,
0.0397975817,
0.0757621601,
0.2629055083,
0.6250298619,
-0.6353856325,
-0.2410446256,
-1.0289459229,
0.3579159975,
0.1601941884,
-0.3961638212,
1.0177843571,
0.6349336505,
0.9466343522,
-0.4513442218,
0.5376244783,
0.4721120596,
0.5737358332,
-0.623883307,
0.9220115542,
-0.5517868996,
0.4818982184,
-0.3131006658,
-0.6542291641,
-0.3891391158,
0.2965293825,
-0.1735914201,
0.1763639301,
0.6211112142,
0.8499805927,
-0.347751528,
-0.2579867542,
0.3793945312,
0.316600889,
0.0166853182,
0.8011638522,
0.7204549313,
-0.4354162216,
0.2658698559,
-0.4234903157,
-0.0154717285,
-0.136959672,
-0.8830386996,
-0.9554246068,
-0.7968949676,
-0.4679269791,
0.187322557,
-0.0073873224,
0.470975101,
0.5539572835,
-1.1409261227,
-0.4903147817,
-0.3287216723,
0.3088006079,
-0.4708350897,
-0.1713186949,
0.3046052456,
-0.6609244943,
-0.8022964001,
0.0892017186,
0.2330260575,
0.2491448969,
-0.2214340866,
0.151086688,
-0.2080122679,
-0.2419902831,
0.4455560744,
0.2785603106,
-0.6064035892,
-0.1222455502,
-0.2103192359,
0.3610280752,
-0.1125525311,
1.0273809433,
-0.9413449764,
0.2215559483,
0.2867834866,
0.3613340855,
0.3927200139,
-0.3226337731,
0.6916790009,
-0.7961748838,
0.0838173404,
0.0278280247,
0.709541142,
0.238516286,
0.1116927415,
0.1001560763,
-0.0527325235,
-0.3108044267,
-0.7882224917,
0.2818537354,
-0.6548650861,
-0.282284826,
0.7454181314,
-0.2313635647,
-0.1463485807,
-0.2467879504,
0.1001879647,
0.2654190063,
-0.2769437432,
0.9987050891,
0.7242093086,
0.1324242204,
-0.2751321793,
-0.6746408343,
0.5329557061,
0.6770891547,
-0.3804879785,
0.4687019289,
0.5016957521,
0.4731842875,
0.1091012582,
0.5271527171,
0.320879519,
0.2560369372,
0.0314872488,
0.0920077488,
0.0316194482,
-0.3763689101,
-0.5275393724,
0.2172397077,
0.1867877245,
-0.2389172763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14024v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14024v2 | LLM Critics Help Catch Bugs in Mathematics: Towards a Better Mathematical Verifier with Natural Language Feedback | 2024-06-20T06:42:27 | 2024-06-30T13:44:04 | Bofei Gao, Zefan Cai, Runxin Xu, Peiyi Wang, Ce Zheng, Runji Lin, Keming Lu, Junyang Lin, Chang Zhou, Wen Xiao, Junjie Hu, Tianyu Liu, Baobao Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mathematical verfier achieves success in mathematical reasoning tasks by
validating the correctness of solutions. However, existing verifiers are
trained with binary classification labels, which are not informative enough for
the model to accurately assess the solutions. To mitigate the aforementioned
insufficiency of binary labels, we introduce step-wise natural language
feedbacks as rationale labels (i.e., the correctness of the current step and
the explanations). In this paper, we propose \textbf{Math-Minos}, a natural
language feedback enhanced verifier by constructing automatically-generated
training data and a two-stage training paradigm for effective training and
efficient inference. Our experiments reveal that a small set (30k) of natural
language feedbacks can significantly boost the performance of the verifier by
the accuracy of 1.6\% (86.6\% $\rightarrow$ 88.2\%) on GSM8K and 0.8\% (37.8\%
$\rightarrow$ 38.6\%) on MATH. We have released our code and data for further
exploration. | [
-0.4950532913,
-0.6947640777,
0.4820840061,
0.1928078532,
-0.2975184023,
0.0430662297,
-0.2432983369,
-0.3315905929,
0.1871193796,
0.3006497324,
-0.6702287793,
-0.4297308922,
-0.6990228295,
0.4437827766,
-0.2460332066,
1.245757103,
-0.0443229266,
0.4818970859,
-0.4793305099,
-0.0352588259,
-0.2294170409,
-0.5096824169,
-0.9435818195,
-0.4085845649,
0.534016788,
0.3247495294,
0.7631255984,
0.4805872142,
0.6029884219,
0.4917701185,
-0.0906502679,
0.3655209541,
-0.3191692531,
-0.0278161559,
-0.0523716472,
-0.7438590527,
-0.2240182012,
0.0535704754,
0.3872741759,
0.3103611469,
-0.1452268362,
0.1033583432,
0.0432245955,
0.7850954533,
-0.5625600815,
0.1136316657,
-0.2200221121,
0.1668773592,
-0.1174390614,
-0.1423424929,
-0.5464918613,
-1.0932481289,
-0.0135363387,
-0.7239307761,
0.029289959,
-0.0758748874,
0.7746431828,
0.6011664867,
-0.2289259732,
-0.5893634558,
-0.7941596508,
0.8906188607,
-0.7694782615,
0.2652814984,
0.5950602293,
0.7487827539,
-0.0916950926,
-0.4132851362,
-0.598792851,
-0.4903390706,
-0.2676671445,
0.0262382291,
-0.2069819272,
-0.1308576316,
0.5944402814,
0.2195217758,
-0.0448122844,
-0.1268298626,
-0.360247165,
-0.6790201068,
0.6384241581,
0.0669780746,
0.1141273007,
-0.2646566927,
-0.178982541,
0.1204167828,
-0.6909644604,
0.2418419421,
0.3970523179,
-0.219737336,
-0.0199849717,
0.5764118433,
-0.1403211802,
0.7634682059,
0.1217182726,
-0.5903317928,
0.1492329985,
-0.4892819226,
0.0625349209,
-0.220573321,
0.6617575288,
0.1437977701,
0.28748101,
-0.1888955832,
-0.4574213922,
0.5933399796,
0.2461604774,
-1.0399961472,
-0.2558417916,
-0.2504217029,
0.1517818272,
-0.4555194676,
-0.0215644334,
-0.6379261017,
-0.4575379491,
-0.8606007695,
0.306409508,
-0.6166235209,
0.2326182723,
0.013975352,
0.0339679159,
-0.1456607282,
0.6774128079,
-0.6827226877,
0.4170426726,
0.8841592669,
0.6862934828,
0.2236019373,
-0.0473099425,
-0.903239727,
-0.3018679023,
-0.411560595,
1.1247549057,
-0.518517375,
-0.1789782047,
-0.039663747,
-0.3567536473,
0.0055727079,
-0.5393942595,
1.1281714439,
-0.5574508905,
0.6121858358,
-0.3008808494,
-0.5728776455,
-0.1395719647,
0.4809933305,
-0.5212785006,
1.1083340645,
0.0386732891,
-0.7480264306,
0.2871152759,
-0.4146546721,
-0.2224340439,
-0.0921664909,
-0.2540341318,
-0.3800305426,
0.2042332143,
0.3453525901,
-0.1252871305,
-0.3224338889,
0.0802277103,
-0.3883250952,
-0.3041070998,
0.5710859895,
-0.5667008758,
0.6216185093,
0.1495120972,
-0.1972765774,
-0.021131821,
-0.9438890219,
0.3276923299,
-0.1755729169,
-0.589277029,
-0.2247912586,
-0.0983747542,
-0.4694624841,
0.1385782361,
-0.060934484,
-0.6746408939,
0.1277285814,
-0.6272537112,
0.4338919222,
0.7740858793,
-0.1013887748,
0.4509607255,
-0.4996554554,
0.7527151108,
-0.2640996277,
0.1237877458,
0.0139975008,
-0.5141988993,
-0.8268264532,
-0.3793444932,
0.6449394822,
0.7578719258,
-1.0587849617,
0.2952562273,
-0.3306369483,
-0.3860839009,
-0.4846768975,
0.6911045313,
0.7127444744,
0.6255102754,
0.0979016647,
-0.0930842906,
-0.5661744475,
-0.7250915766,
-0.3718700707,
-0.1633072495,
-0.2531436086,
0.1502432227,
0.5012629032,
-0.3546147346,
1.2198188305,
-0.3547487557,
-0.1260976344,
0.0392724015,
0.003886431,
0.2448227257,
0.1948475391,
0.4486811459,
-0.3912788928,
-0.3932956159,
-0.3140058219,
-0.5680461526,
-0.4125877321,
0.1858962774,
-0.3295223117,
0.1947690398,
0.0299599469,
-0.418114692,
0.3366423845,
0.5604040027,
-0.40802598,
0.5859091878,
-0.0775488615,
0.0052261604,
-0.7237359881,
-0.2429000437,
0.2589927614,
-0.5578593612,
-0.4762045145,
-0.1305414587,
-0.0609177016,
0.131157726,
-0.1379794776,
0.2454179227,
-0.0967566147,
0.4200350046,
-0.3699612021,
0.397305429,
0.1023860723,
0.357727915,
-0.2548692822,
0.5888804793,
0.4835403562,
-0.8456088901,
0.5449401736,
0.1185449734,
-0.2100143135,
0.9158908129,
-0.6816251278,
0.4197585583,
-0.1132031083,
0.2759826183,
-1.0275382996,
-0.1285334229,
0.6311923265,
-0.7707219124,
0.2267864496,
-0.4219040871,
-0.6896337867,
-0.6528678536,
-0.5434633493,
0.1196499765,
0.3301763833,
-0.7099496126,
0.7283223271,
0.4002623856,
-0.1310872436,
-0.5058999658,
-0.6723814607,
-0.0523868613,
0.1619400382,
-1.0133341551,
-0.1812127978,
-0.3760509193,
-0.3088567853,
-0.1103296876,
-0.2560673654,
-0.1169175506,
-0.0127213914,
0.3555938303,
0.4834463894,
-0.1225658581,
0.1741790175,
0.0171080809,
-0.8412092924,
0.5064107776,
-0.2146294266,
0.1872738153,
-0.3335084319,
-0.5909290314,
-0.5092257261,
-0.1355244815,
0.3195399344,
0.0419680513,
0.1265244782,
0.2872207463,
-0.501860857,
-0.1452164352,
-0.6314746737,
-0.42165488,
-0.5622054935,
-0.0925540626,
-0.3277027905,
-0.9759638906,
0.2318045795,
-0.1263484508,
0.1657712758,
0.3932341039,
0.4113308787,
0.0138480533,
1.1706671715,
0.4107411504,
-0.2571052611,
0.1585588902,
-0.2337048054,
0.3971147835,
-0.3762164116,
-0.2149568051,
-0.7896357775,
-0.2994353175,
-0.2320355773,
-0.4856341481,
0.1478540301,
0.3375947177,
0.1075197682,
0.2397379428,
-0.5837839246,
0.8022204041,
0.4213820696,
0.0244776476,
0.3035543263,
0.2188973874,
-0.2519266605,
-0.7317473888,
-0.4847200215,
-0.646288693,
0.6377485991,
0.3741912842,
0.8228663206,
0.2695408165,
0.8639235497,
0.0577170327,
0.8942335844,
-0.901163578,
0.4574622512,
0.1702831835,
-0.647557795,
-0.2053992003,
-0.9031173587,
-0.4159793854,
0.2827709317,
-0.1477255821,
-0.5448648334,
-0.1412332654,
0.4829900563,
-0.3650981486,
0.1158910543,
-0.6702849269,
0.5550863743,
-0.2589651346,
-0.5356360674,
-0.319958359,
-0.1563409418,
0.5602657795,
0.0209940337,
0.7469689846,
0.0426934399,
-0.003472717,
0.7151359916,
-1.0827858448,
0.9887399673,
-0.3964222968,
-0.3294190168,
0.5733933449,
0.3463489115,
0.7512231469,
0.5488699079,
0.0614018403,
-0.2369232476,
-0.0999183357,
-0.1525037885,
-0.9724211097,
0.6527220607,
-0.5835961699,
-0.5613508821,
-0.5225461125,
-0.1128799319,
-0.3180122077,
0.0543193854,
0.2320507914,
0.460696876,
0.4525280297,
-0.0484796762,
0.7337441444,
0.3163895905,
0.1818178892,
0.6647923589,
-0.4670594931,
-1.0676939487,
1.0344657898,
-0.0737861097,
0.0099345334,
0.2585864067,
0.575848043,
-0.416881144,
-0.2738908529,
-0.6853414178,
0.3507254422,
-0.9121977687,
-0.5031921268,
-0.2334370613,
-0.1583266258,
-0.077801913,
-0.0060688723,
-0.3833832443,
-0.6837326884,
0.1608244926,
-0.2915649414,
0.5880246758,
0.9148637056,
-0.2012723386,
0.1987497509,
-0.7927717566,
0.2488009781,
0.4197281599,
0.591814518,
-0.3528989851,
-0.8770463467,
-0.2920008004,
0.1646424532,
-0.3374924362,
-0.8088632226,
0.0017322912,
0.1060961708,
0.3769979775,
0.6123077869,
-0.101139918,
0.7445428371,
-0.3439733088,
0.471734792,
0.3221561611,
-1.1689237356,
0.4893024862,
0.1810388714,
0.1103294194,
0.7284738421,
0.1563592702,
-0.4675901234,
-0.5781399012,
-0.3341074288,
-0.3815883398,
0.8275928497,
0.3493468165,
0.1501877755,
0.2127271146,
0.5451056957,
0.0546822287,
0.0848987848,
-0.7692701817,
-0.2600614429,
-0.1789793968,
-0.0823104382,
0.1490449309,
-0.5333276391,
-0.309976548,
-0.4434647858,
0.8383162022,
-0.1758096516,
-0.0026720946,
0.1175945103,
-0.1690852493,
-0.2650782168,
0.3401020467,
0.8453922868,
0.8142921925,
0.1245617792,
0.3691031337,
0.3195381761,
-0.6245639324,
0.3189125061,
0.1617100537,
-0.6079064012,
0.4782916605,
0.3755802214,
0.5995107889,
0.3561201692,
-0.3124122024,
0.5166759491,
-0.300193727,
-0.4220076203,
-0.3129544258,
0.1211751774,
0.0513591133,
-0.0931704864,
0.078603752,
0.492241323,
0.0867234468,
0.1204013079,
0.3244200945,
0.357103765,
-0.4498843253,
-0.4981268644,
0.425199002,
0.228745997,
-0.5013272166,
0.2444678545,
-0.4251033366,
-0.8756300211,
0.3565096855,
0.4094504118,
0.5660243034,
-0.077656664,
0.3627078235,
0.6910472512,
0.3819919527,
-0.0250427146,
0.2446644157,
-0.3361680806,
-0.4824637771,
-0.7783870697,
-0.5980719924,
-0.7423829436,
-0.4700604081,
-0.4502565861,
0.2869556248,
-0.7993032336,
-0.4301849306,
-0.0137932887,
0.1305127442,
-0.4781266451,
0.0857631043,
0.3918285668,
0.8997284174,
-0.4664658904,
0.7061721683,
0.6042405963,
-0.1963517666,
-0.8217459321,
-0.5631160736,
0.3182240427,
-0.7679846883,
0.7448359132,
0.2331752479,
-0.6139116883,
-0.327816546,
-0.6971362233,
-0.8990828395,
0.7316786647,
0.5869015455,
-0.7534468174,
0.3899515867,
0.2315400094,
0.7069616318,
-0.0037084194,
0.6517421007,
0.361236304,
0.6665367484,
0.3356173038,
-0.5235431194,
0.0151811233,
-0.6037903428,
0.011488718,
0.3773778975,
-0.2804778516,
0.2928420603,
-0.3671199977,
-0.2539443374,
0.0423046574,
0.8684167862,
0.5577150583,
0.6355555654,
0.7244025469,
0.9611117244,
1.083463788,
-0.3312450051,
1.3133627176,
-0.4340825081,
0.376226455,
1.042850256,
0.0725176707,
0.6612075567,
0.4455297589,
-0.4776193202,
0.7903375626,
0.3127943277,
0.0640714914,
0.3084997237,
0.6749995351,
-0.2866179347,
-0.4132775068,
0.1219672486,
-0.3447149098,
-0.2659237683,
0.2170191556,
-0.0980434865,
-0.3124683201,
-0.1480062455,
0.2649870515,
0.2378466725,
-0.0379093178,
0.5018164515,
0.3154517412,
-0.6692703366,
0.5843426585,
0.1475875974,
0.8045721054,
-0.7254080176,
0.0395150445,
-0.4160721004,
0.4933947027,
-0.4813587964,
-0.4747588634,
0.2777601182,
0.2668510973,
-0.2121431679,
-0.1044749245,
0.6313561797,
-0.0520591736,
-0.814884007,
0.1244200319,
0.1024720669,
-0.0580002517,
0.0916677117,
-0.5859590769,
-0.0118916128,
0.063089788,
-0.148987025,
-0.1179133505,
0.7343045473,
0.1775252968,
0.8954216838,
0.8631676435,
0.0060657682,
0.362041533,
0.272870481,
0.8889519572,
-0.5530676246,
-0.3764582276,
-1.0843791962,
0.363486141,
-0.1771425605,
-0.5149239898,
1.17996943,
0.6652706861,
0.8011112809,
-0.0543338396,
0.6329029799,
0.2127896249,
0.7155637145,
-0.5552011132,
0.2662705183,
-0.098396115,
0.5733177662,
-0.0095139658,
-0.6980399489,
-0.4865769148,
0.6836194992,
-0.5386691689,
-0.030893473,
0.7364350557,
0.7939255834,
0.1767310202,
0.3188366294,
-0.0733615756,
0.0907588527,
0.4605466127,
0.5819329619,
1.2354302406,
-0.3451883793,
0.8742722273,
-0.7268843651,
-0.2440989316,
-0.0996585339,
-0.601054728,
-0.9947689176,
0.1920125782,
-0.5733317733,
-0.8160071373,
-0.2507223785,
0.8028366566,
0.5312220454,
-1.0605562925,
0.0934990123,
-0.2528215051,
0.4012240469,
0.0595444888,
-0.2226320952,
0.0342301466,
-0.573946774,
-0.608982861,
0.159544453,
0.2695422173,
-0.0030348448,
-0.2743069232,
-0.672739327,
0.6160364151,
0.1396867335,
0.5138636231,
0.2629756629,
-0.6889643073,
-0.2120615542,
-0.0212358367,
-0.4355819523,
0.0791451409,
1.1124267578,
-0.905896008,
0.38189587,
0.5429208875,
0.7756301761,
0.1210006252,
-0.0991059244,
0.3813430667,
-0.4478209317,
-0.0314855203,
0.3808761537,
0.4540337026,
0.317418009,
-0.2074316442,
0.5368275642,
0.6074345708,
-0.4597099423,
-0.7890405059,
0.165658623,
-0.7285538316,
0.3167772293,
0.9610213041,
-0.0838701949,
-0.4066615105,
0.1691526622,
-0.4895354509,
-0.1882520169,
-0.5375326276,
0.911485672,
0.8813675046,
0.0670101494,
-0.0475926027,
-0.4433101416,
0.5650913119,
0.7593913078,
-0.8889711499,
-0.3505339026,
0.6335790753,
0.3273767531,
0.6024870276,
0.4718622267,
-0.1561396122,
0.4702169597,
-0.0817717165,
-0.3173981905,
-0.1537039578,
-0.2587671876,
-0.3681149781,
0.0330880694,
0.2940725982,
-0.0928392783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14023v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14023v1 | Evaluating Implicit Bias in Large Language Models by Attacking From a Psychometric Perspective | 2024-06-20T06:42:08 | 2024-06-20T06:42:08 | Yuchen Wen, Keping Bi, Wei Chen, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As Large Language Models (LLMs) become an important way of information
seeking, there have been increasing concerns about the unethical content LLMs
may generate. In this paper, we conduct a rigorous evaluation of LLMs' implicit
bias towards certain groups by attacking them with carefully crafted
instructions to elicit biased responses. Our attack methodology is inspired by
psychometric principles in cognitive and social psychology. We propose three
attack approaches, i.e., Disguise, Deception, and Teaching, based on which we
built evaluation datasets for four common bias types. Each prompt attack has
bilingual versions. Extensive evaluation of representative LLMs shows that 1)
all three attack methods work effectively, especially the Deception attacks; 2)
GLM-3 performs the best in defending our attacks, compared to GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4; 3) LLMs could output content of other bias types when being taught with
one type of bias. Our methodology provides a rigorous and effective way of
evaluating LLMs' implicit bias and will benefit the assessments of LLMs'
potential ethical risks. | [
-0.2939358056,
-0.9150466323,
0.7866284251,
0.363099128,
-0.0294084642,
0.0684426054,
-0.3681722283,
-0.4641224742,
-0.1054139882,
0.5687633157,
-0.5817857981,
-0.4475675523,
-0.7339689136,
0.0862953439,
-0.415170759,
0.9649760127,
-0.0778427944,
0.7991214991,
0.0446410105,
0.0507789254,
-0.199139446,
-0.7766667604,
-0.6625366211,
-0.1910339743,
0.60631001,
-0.074495703,
0.5606638789,
0.3502785265,
0.3170769513,
0.2382072955,
-0.0217087753,
-0.1913223863,
-0.704080224,
0.2085384279,
-0.1910014004,
-0.5298926234,
-0.3023432791,
0.2917193174,
0.6527286768,
0.5785176158,
0.0215167385,
0.3847652078,
0.187726602,
0.5538083911,
-0.8381199837,
-0.0293155424,
-0.7477702498,
0.1387453228,
-0.3199711144,
0.0026737195,
-0.663887918,
-0.5987884402,
0.1186591312,
-0.1893944591,
0.1359601021,
-0.0593951866,
0.3595671654,
-0.0713634789,
-0.4006317854,
-0.5266907811,
-0.5242036581,
0.9656691551,
-0.6370902061,
0.2089327276,
0.4241499901,
0.2252404243,
-0.2060350925,
-0.2639538348,
-0.3181673586,
-0.3208582699,
-0.0851328596,
0.0896015242,
-0.2297484726,
0.0935328156,
0.5812881589,
0.1391167045,
-0.425642401,
0.2595648468,
-0.2832236886,
-0.2909888327,
0.7365859151,
0.1729054451,
0.3445828557,
0.0197580811,
-0.40503636,
0.0760692358,
-0.9034410119,
-0.283595562,
0.9583563209,
0.2192040682,
-0.167102769,
0.6921395659,
-0.073068656,
0.5034469366,
0.21502316,
-0.04489455,
-0.0471898615,
-0.195983097,
-0.1059383154,
0.1801743358,
0.8661261797,
0.4359904528,
0.561119616,
-0.1912109703,
-0.2638137043,
0.1658314914,
0.2907032669,
-0.6322572827,
0.3784610033,
0.2636975646,
-0.2905701697,
-0.4301654398,
-0.1164174229,
-1.0185011625,
-0.5818024278,
-0.0391732752,
0.1995581388,
-0.2214618176,
0.0014969074,
-0.0163593907,
0.0510008447,
0.5939925909,
0.3400458395,
-0.8633645773,
0.5195089579,
0.7391862869,
0.6152777076,
-0.2911472321,
-0.1411964297,
-0.8220742941,
0.4053344727,
-0.3343257606,
0.4475411475,
-0.6622242332,
-0.6080210805,
0.2937356234,
-0.2700239122,
0.1820954382,
-0.2101130038,
0.6923577189,
-0.5964817405,
0.5232313275,
-0.4676736295,
-0.5012431145,
-0.1387507319,
0.4018116593,
-0.7197157145,
0.9043599367,
-0.1862355322,
-0.9998307824,
0.1364220232,
-0.659044981,
-0.3782735765,
-0.2344296575,
-0.4225287139,
-0.0825254098,
0.1867150068,
0.4740760028,
0.4846731126,
-0.458594501,
0.2100458145,
-0.5433692336,
-0.3811799586,
0.3589683771,
-0.7387185693,
1.1323881149,
-0.074230209,
-0.5550342202,
-0.0037895569,
-0.4818941057,
0.0690095201,
0.3768502474,
-0.2091300935,
-0.549318254,
0.0074628126,
-0.1539133787,
0.0092205405,
0.2020968348,
-0.6143783331,
0.2193530947,
-0.4316851497,
0.0395150818,
1.1200121641,
0.0567616448,
0.4337329268,
-0.0372773185,
0.5889220238,
-0.3790934682,
0.5117379427,
0.2074157298,
-0.2308016866,
-0.5140929818,
-0.2810820341,
0.0900032148,
0.3840235174,
-0.4814732075,
0.0114222048,
-0.1089439467,
-0.392825067,
-0.5135532022,
0.152367577,
0.5797056556,
0.2945315242,
0.2059826553,
-0.0216047466,
-0.4539016783,
-1.1004209518,
-0.7570442557,
-0.1767210215,
-0.1977030188,
0.0203142352,
0.4921548069,
-0.1869904399,
0.6955394745,
-0.3607985675,
-0.1392719001,
-0.0542383976,
0.048969727,
0.0615670048,
0.2776960135,
0.5406168699,
-0.4952290952,
-0.4631995261,
-0.2866054475,
-0.6835166216,
-0.2674187422,
0.1706551164,
-0.0933987722,
0.4052623808,
0.3270072341,
-0.6250648499,
0.2781511843,
0.4274551272,
-0.2211383283,
0.5934518576,
0.2977578342,
-0.016341038,
-0.5809978247,
-0.2121067345,
0.1379234791,
0.0096050901,
-0.6672142148,
0.1763719171,
-0.0605581552,
0.3479019105,
-0.6645920277,
0.8150721788,
-0.6262563467,
-0.0453805178,
-0.0187837984,
-0.0291764177,
-0.1093232781,
0.3782481551,
-0.1748530567,
0.3287937641,
0.6315049529,
-0.3503611088,
0.3351204097,
-0.1404518187,
-0.3969177008,
0.7889253497,
-0.5487088561,
0.6291496754,
-0.2864122391,
0.463275671,
-0.7933501601,
-0.1080198139,
0.5557578206,
-0.3528958559,
0.2925918102,
-0.3301203549,
-0.5292955637,
-0.2184257954,
-0.6454347372,
0.3898636699,
0.35393399,
-0.585883379,
0.8327786326,
0.2633695602,
-0.1782055944,
-1.0269931555,
-0.4987275004,
0.027339533,
-0.5887132883,
-0.311486572,
0.0516885296,
-0.1232207119,
-0.6888767481,
-0.2556709945,
-0.1787540168,
0.1412205845,
0.0584597252,
0.0390370265,
0.3406790793,
0.0357122235,
-0.4350070357,
-0.3264109492,
0.1688206941,
0.5298785567,
-0.1355266869,
0.7161431313,
-0.1839508563,
-0.6904645562,
-0.100608632,
0.4923234284,
0.5254830718,
0.0010333717,
0.4748387039,
0.6949750781,
-0.3878536522,
-0.0995311812,
-0.9617739916,
-0.294960767,
-0.4709479511,
0.5627000928,
-0.1061785817,
-0.7756037116,
0.348862648,
0.3157829344,
0.1278802603,
0.2450447381,
0.815392077,
-0.0088607715,
1.4099860191,
0.3821661174,
-0.3512224257,
0.1467116177,
-0.0460094325,
-0.0056493641,
-0.8946265578,
-0.4226833284,
-0.5961792469,
-0.0087942444,
-0.4918697774,
-0.3875189424,
0.3288953602,
-0.1557261944,
-0.310880363,
-0.2774144113,
-0.1064667106,
0.589787066,
0.3254538476,
0.0050194436,
0.219982788,
0.2035938203,
-0.0834087059,
-0.0392710567,
-0.3768633604,
-0.6763616204,
1.398435235,
0.8043578267,
0.9992497563,
0.3491442204,
0.3824519813,
0.3604117334,
0.6128253341,
-0.7327712774,
0.6494141817,
0.2638556063,
-0.8037730455,
-0.3271896541,
-0.33408764,
-0.6887890697,
0.4102591276,
-0.0222853366,
-0.9274374247,
-0.0441443734,
0.0523017831,
0.055115059,
0.2255362719,
-0.6117075086,
0.4452187717,
-0.74113065,
-0.5655729771,
-0.1026453972,
-0.4958797991,
0.6597938538,
-0.3583190143,
0.2577157617,
-0.0330754668,
-0.2141950876,
0.8581536412,
-0.0640456676,
1.1628082991,
-0.3779343367,
-0.5119152069,
-0.0403414704,
0.1762628555,
0.6025357842,
0.0411159396,
-0.255494833,
0.4235293865,
-0.2143748105,
-0.4978986979,
-0.7688374519,
0.6182323098,
-0.5604060888,
-0.9899222851,
-0.4637709856,
-0.4898261726,
-0.5583766103,
0.1744148731,
0.1876309067,
0.1960605085,
-0.5760255456,
-0.1263897717,
0.6171902418,
-0.2704376876,
0.2819486558,
0.8323733807,
-0.2703931332,
-0.2500845194,
0.5116145611,
-0.0477255248,
0.5225637555,
0.1307866275,
0.216676265,
-0.4926471412,
-0.4261406064,
-0.2801104784,
0.2825159132,
-0.8329535723,
0.0289014131,
-0.5597798824,
-0.0334392749,
-0.5159058571,
0.0239240378,
-0.265273273,
0.1122357696,
0.1894222498,
-0.1434729397,
0.0695158318,
0.9342110157,
0.1785617322,
0.3462266326,
-0.1897788942,
0.1279753298,
0.3374170661,
0.240363732,
0.0508317351,
-0.387524724,
0.0290560648,
0.0945733339,
-0.185649395,
-1.156139493,
0.0496244542,
-0.2707858384,
0.8184195161,
0.4352046847,
-0.0385694057,
0.2358433157,
-0.6978003979,
0.6461905241,
0.1807076186,
-0.9770185351,
0.3268268108,
-0.3872807026,
0.0712288469,
0.3675436974,
0.7592871189,
-0.2182992399,
-0.5344442129,
-0.7076931,
-0.6261995435,
0.6701205373,
0.1423785537,
0.2399274111,
-0.0590768233,
0.1713707,
0.0310664847,
0.1972064823,
-1.0970597267,
-0.2894145548,
0.094078064,
-0.1793362796,
0.0675663799,
-0.4760801792,
-0.6034475565,
-0.0214696713,
0.610484004,
-0.1514201611,
0.2050464302,
0.1194511205,
-0.1855628043,
0.047591649,
0.3663954437,
0.5391165018,
0.5462397337,
-0.1055098474,
0.2446644306,
0.4067828655,
-0.5961690545,
0.3327268958,
-0.1214522198,
-0.2618494034,
-0.0885252804,
0.5238018632,
0.6457839608,
-0.0237568375,
-0.6128278971,
0.6903578043,
0.0153280692,
0.0162460618,
-0.338239938,
-0.0981479287,
-0.0309011359,
0.2239665091,
0.3034701049,
-0.343963474,
0.0517291911,
-0.6666032076,
-0.1900656819,
0.8644221425,
-0.4063645303,
-0.2267261297,
0.2846385837,
-0.0171589348,
-0.0890099704,
0.3153495491,
0.063799262,
-0.7585623264,
0.4345142841,
0.6653522253,
0.8562790751,
-0.5487191081,
0.1844290346,
0.0415995941,
0.7498599291,
-0.0530570187,
0.1348483264,
0.1667824388,
-0.7029250264,
-0.5061584711,
-0.4354811311,
-0.4605205059,
0.5007158518,
-0.7676439285,
0.1910577267,
-0.5764490366,
-0.0290237479,
-0.1833076179,
-0.1084938422,
-0.6250542402,
0.0257084351,
0.4387386441,
0.7901107073,
-0.754165411,
0.5434535742,
0.4025865793,
-0.2090482414,
-0.4994951487,
0.295999974,
0.3502577543,
-1.1158384085,
0.8406839371,
0.0618744977,
-0.2306779176,
-0.3303067386,
-0.8441693783,
-0.7280739546,
0.4980918765,
0.6695167422,
-0.4111674428,
-0.0871176645,
0.3988387585,
0.3421727419,
-0.4389244318,
0.4305920899,
0.6941959262,
0.7224411368,
-0.242265135,
-0.5685846806,
0.2382293642,
-0.008985824,
-0.1320687085,
-0.1210271716,
-0.5549887419,
0.6389200687,
-0.0561355203,
-0.2067640871,
-0.2933310568,
0.4745179415,
0.359230727,
-0.0638782606,
0.5507899523,
0.0658279955,
0.7838426828,
0.0981737375,
1.1676176786,
-0.0168534853,
0.0646816269,
1.1486591101,
-0.5733640194,
0.4960391521,
0.5351074338,
-0.0444719121,
0.2470066696,
0.3685339093,
-0.2016679496,
0.3857420981,
0.5952606797,
-0.1945708394,
0.2841040492,
-0.0578761436,
-0.2593106329,
0.386313647,
0.5567366481,
-0.221176967,
-0.2188293487,
-0.0177474394,
0.6602407098,
-0.0094002876,
-0.531406641,
0.4880354404,
-0.0114985891,
-0.6225566268,
0.4350427389,
0.2118888497,
0.6814842224,
-0.6984330416,
0.1909428239,
-0.2690989971,
-0.0321603976,
-0.2521435916,
-0.672675252,
-0.114703007,
0.4601839185,
-0.0423903316,
-0.0720708296,
0.5632197857,
-0.3114437461,
-0.5378546715,
0.5453927517,
0.3788250983,
-0.0174128506,
-0.093677789,
-0.7780268788,
0.42664662,
0.0879164413,
-0.4920261502,
0.3756558597,
0.0680704787,
-0.2180716395,
0.5408360958,
0.537586689,
0.3867357075,
0.1586298198,
0.2714396715,
0.6309443712,
-0.5331255198,
-0.2226211876,
-1.2790122032,
0.1343774796,
-0.3025127351,
0.1293252856,
1.0539799929,
0.4867394567,
0.8639294505,
0.0893614739,
0.9208400249,
0.3723041117,
0.3585951328,
-0.9000507593,
0.5120286345,
-0.1090899929,
0.4994917512,
-0.5911443233,
-1.1328083277,
-0.0763823614,
0.4778745174,
-0.7004740238,
0.3420968056,
0.6913374662,
0.659752667,
0.1030543447,
0.1386021823,
0.0413278677,
0.565749526,
0.4507599771,
0.4415071011,
1.2401809692,
-0.1220225394,
0.2753106356,
-0.0290468428,
-0.339971751,
0.0456714891,
-0.9825702906,
-1.1517332792,
-0.106180951,
-0.1183392927,
-0.5188248158,
0.1161880642,
0.8028683662,
0.4411908686,
-0.4741635323,
-0.3288149834,
0.5216614604,
0.0604237989,
0.1100429818,
-0.2146811634,
0.4258171618,
-0.0715198815,
-0.9458093047,
0.4605267644,
0.044379361,
-0.049271591,
-0.8249818683,
-0.0864972845,
-0.0198404659,
0.3200458288,
0.5361269712,
0.0229171328,
-0.8934690356,
-0.4658986926,
-0.1352576017,
-0.1778288037,
-0.2889550328,
0.8041129708,
-0.3913894594,
0.1399712414,
0.0606629699,
0.6339039207,
0.2558076084,
-0.0915649384,
0.7345113754,
-0.6625277996,
0.1948006451,
0.3578445315,
0.3264985383,
0.3643748462,
-0.5161544085,
0.5682240725,
0.0138733108,
-0.1547992527,
-1.056855917,
0.2133378834,
-0.8282960057,
-0.3031391501,
1.5719350576,
0.1292109489,
-0.3126399815,
-0.131558001,
-0.1995716691,
-0.057287626,
-0.2231098861,
0.7332014441,
0.7900100946,
0.1035765931,
0.4147937298,
-0.7657701969,
0.4803387523,
0.4809626043,
-0.6268442869,
0.1284965426,
0.6111658812,
0.4527963698,
0.01699185,
0.5862300992,
-0.472424984,
0.0306148399,
-0.3282760084,
0.0513482578,
0.1399981976,
-0.1627053916,
-0.4339492321,
0.2002331764,
-0.1749618798,
0.1597495526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14022v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14022v1 | Investigating the Pre-Training Dynamics of In-Context Learning: Task Recognition vs. Task Learning | 2024-06-20T06:37:47 | 2024-06-20T06:37:47 | Xiaolei Wang, Xinyu Tang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The emergence of in-context learning (ICL) is potentially attributed to two
major abilities: task recognition (TR) for recognizing the task from
demonstrations and utilizing pre-trained priors, and task learning (TL) for
learning from demonstrations. However, relationships between the two abilities
and how such relationships affect the emergence of ICL is unclear. In this
paper, we take the first step by examining the pre-training dynamics of the
emergence of ICL. With carefully designed metrics, we find that these two
abilities are, in fact, competitive during pre-training. Moreover, we observe a
strong negative correlation between the competition and ICL performance.
Further analysis of common pre-training factors (i.e., model size, dataset
size, and data curriculum) demonstrates possible ways to manage the
competition. Based on these insights, we propose a simple yet effective method
to better integrate these two abilities for ICL at inference time. Through
adaptive ensemble learning, the performance of ICL can be significantly
boosted, enabling two small models to outperform a larger one with more than
twice the parameters. The code is available at
https://github.com/RUCAIBox/Competitive-ICL. | [
-0.4427140355,
-0.320197016,
0.24277924,
0.0639348179,
-0.2774625421,
0.3276483417,
-0.1926059872,
-0.6955727339,
-0.306861341,
0.0386565551,
-0.4080227315,
-0.0967406332,
-0.6910068989,
-0.0583352521,
-0.2589531541,
1.0371260643,
-0.0674461871,
-0.045767013,
-0.6562168598,
-0.292019695,
-0.5882478952,
-0.7013270855,
-0.5903488398,
-0.3228061199,
0.2898330688,
0.4407956898,
-0.0944202915,
0.3870037794,
0.3013702631,
0.3493935466,
0.1717745364,
0.1024464071,
-0.4849001467,
0.195047006,
-0.1803773195,
-0.3557810187,
-0.179845199,
0.3396961987,
0.7275710702,
0.5780953169,
0.0498356074,
0.2458308935,
0.7904005051,
0.2701313198,
-0.7931002975,
0.1718721092,
-0.731223762,
0.0148338778,
-0.5096365213,
-0.4746131003,
-0.4072173834,
0.1846759021,
0.5654603243,
-0.6753286123,
0.2022524625,
0.0960718542,
0.8706621528,
0.2604928911,
-0.3599357605,
-0.3710482121,
-0.6602212787,
0.7990686893,
-0.0850512311,
0.398443073,
-0.0117316814,
0.3186731637,
-0.101659663,
-1.0792326927,
-0.2404365987,
-0.4395468831,
-0.1310319752,
0.2167722285,
-0.1396137774,
-0.0380058251,
0.2742078602,
-0.011978521,
-0.3421675563,
0.3051303327,
-0.2178945094,
0.1303028017,
0.4289097488,
0.0893365517,
0.3017958701,
0.4311855733,
-0.5504317284,
-0.1941338032,
-0.5523803234,
0.5858908892,
0.0490798429,
0.2916769385,
-0.0810843408,
0.035823781,
-0.0199494287,
0.5049602985,
0.5931643248,
-0.1400092691,
0.2077271789,
-0.0020241826,
-0.2766832113,
0.3991551995,
0.4795288444,
-0.1769978851,
-0.1566419899,
-0.3377242386,
-0.2195150703,
-0.0786558092,
0.5195171833,
-0.4796634912,
-0.0817125514,
-0.07790187,
-0.5368858576,
-0.2096331418,
0.1084718555,
-0.3243812919,
-0.0415937714,
-0.6254992485,
1.1290029287,
-0.1738587469,
-0.2087827474,
-0.2560985386,
-0.1304216236,
0.1895621121,
0.4444235265,
-0.6469599605,
0.6239674091,
0.6343274713,
0.745511055,
-0.4385837615,
-0.6480078697,
-0.7333568931,
0.0960044414,
-0.2390795797,
0.5894599557,
-0.3377999663,
-0.1951595843,
-0.1969832927,
-0.0003804341,
-0.4212092161,
-0.8023971915,
-0.0128231067,
-0.9165304899,
-0.1117293611,
-0.1468357742,
-0.571593821,
-0.0202294588,
0.1499648392,
-0.5322670937,
0.9193463326,
0.0018167008,
-0.8076568246,
0.8873522878,
-0.944863081,
-0.5144360065,
0.3415907323,
-0.1973910928,
-0.4508836865,
-0.0139093278,
-0.2377412468,
0.6290893555,
-0.0073498469,
-0.0811547786,
-0.3965527415,
-0.4631994665,
0.1096925437,
0.0543909743,
0.6835557222,
0.1873024255,
-0.6472167373,
0.1225835234,
-0.5064861178,
-0.1551483274,
-0.0904229283,
-0.2313614488,
-0.2521819174,
0.4165263772,
-0.3312362134,
0.2637455165,
0.0794470534,
-0.2036060244,
-0.0761685744,
-0.1556371599,
0.4414052665,
0.6338729858,
-0.1153900921,
0.4941808283,
-0.2601400912,
0.4513596296,
0.3028300107,
0.0236948989,
0.1768889129,
-0.0062396014,
-0.4652176797,
-0.1189035922,
0.2784454226,
0.4473986328,
-0.6498653889,
0.2258644253,
-0.1605787575,
-0.4521003962,
-0.1269880682,
0.118348062,
0.4489283264,
0.5982760191,
0.4403257668,
-0.4128877521,
-0.5204018354,
-0.4053238034,
-0.2683859468,
-0.0776613653,
0.0758396685,
0.4126962423,
0.6758144498,
0.3262676299,
0.7781563401,
-0.1009403616,
-0.4296136498,
-0.3412409127,
0.4249915779,
-0.2035896778,
0.887332499,
0.768011272,
-0.8250679374,
-0.8070137501,
0.1469545364,
-0.6994284987,
0.1419603676,
-0.0139553202,
-0.1640987396,
-0.0371759906,
0.8061978221,
-0.1223537773,
0.5995900631,
0.2949323952,
-0.0734402165,
0.594966948,
-0.2318942845,
0.3237836659,
-0.6984142065,
0.1020154878,
0.0636883527,
0.0410709232,
-0.6864080429,
0.1600292623,
0.2181770056,
0.0282271411,
-0.5847796202,
0.3814154863,
-0.5135062337,
-0.314807713,
-0.143428117,
-0.0889556333,
-0.4245811999,
0.5403485298,
0.2627239525,
0.8744869232,
0.721788466,
-0.8159739375,
-0.1780934781,
-0.0545438826,
-0.8440645933,
0.5034540296,
-0.4549555779,
0.0482698269,
0.0805340335,
0.2959435284,
-0.862801373,
-0.3609493077,
0.047170449,
-0.2244304866,
0.5218908191,
-0.2750515342,
-0.3244242966,
-0.2496919334,
0.1505820006,
0.8106716275,
0.5656356215,
-0.7115628123,
0.6073074341,
0.3288790584,
0.109832637,
-0.717861414,
-0.4001399279,
-0.2083069533,
-0.6150397062,
-0.2110539824,
0.7683660388,
-0.1032979786,
-0.1476718634,
-0.2879790068,
-0.0513738543,
-0.3734552264,
0.5004962087,
0.2695996165,
0.0978066623,
-0.2276715934,
0.143117249,
0.1627969593,
0.0659233183,
-0.0649328008,
-0.4463011026,
0.2274161726,
-0.0520044491,
-0.2385393381,
-0.672468245,
0.0563345663,
0.7147600055,
-0.4325567186,
0.5336981416,
0.330296129,
-0.2156292945,
-0.2908804715,
-0.4512843192,
-0.129365012,
-0.4353464842,
0.3679285944,
-0.3458050191,
-0.5301107764,
0.3781554997,
-0.2265542746,
-0.0571687743,
0.0844332203,
0.3396311998,
-0.3253323138,
1.1346453428,
0.5914470553,
0.1206456274,
0.9152219296,
-0.3348931372,
-0.1115746647,
-0.8035951257,
-0.453833729,
-0.3572366238,
-0.6071664095,
-0.2479972988,
-0.0641294122,
0.6124922037,
0.2818898857,
-0.4849776328,
0.3058018386,
-0.2372302711,
0.5028302073,
0.713819325,
0.4840326011,
-0.070020698,
-0.1708693355,
-0.1306487918,
0.0262710843,
-0.7953889966,
-0.2495463789,
0.9852777123,
-0.0272521749,
0.4515054822,
-0.1392645389,
0.7410589457,
0.1761084348,
0.3704266548,
-0.4010908604,
0.467992872,
-0.3195147812,
-0.3679159284,
-0.0659130812,
-0.0343466625,
-1.04550457,
0.1726008356,
-0.5144091845,
-0.8673231602,
0.1996632963,
0.6550378203,
-0.5396894813,
0.3431760073,
-0.5982451439,
1.1124261618,
-0.4524350166,
-0.686480999,
-0.3894687891,
-0.852987051,
0.0626089275,
0.0502686054,
-0.0292851832,
0.2903569639,
0.0370153151,
0.7049876451,
-0.0783279538,
0.7779027224,
-0.2345755994,
0.4526723623,
0.3765811324,
0.0512701049,
0.3886749446,
-0.1949913353,
0.2647426128,
-0.1687847823,
-0.0254628509,
-0.513047576,
-0.5164818168,
0.4905586243,
-0.7616128922,
-0.5571818948,
-0.2315199375,
-0.3545880318,
-0.2383498251,
-0.0061340784,
0.5717589259,
0.7450438142,
-0.2533851862,
0.4137851,
0.776397109,
0.1884931773,
0.525592804,
0.3643091321,
0.3798310161,
-0.0194124263,
0.8120657802,
0.3941119611,
0.3562208414,
0.5503054261,
0.0231292564,
-0.156883806,
-0.8097260594,
-0.2483177632,
-0.28595227,
-0.4535356164,
-0.0801010579,
-0.6159008741,
-0.0512049012,
-0.1027519479,
-0.3842250109,
-0.0204013363,
0.3008286655,
-0.7238093019,
0.2306757122,
-0.2654948235,
0.6638335586,
-0.0688148215,
0.4665013552,
-0.4775485396,
-0.3161742687,
0.6671353579,
0.2335097194,
0.4789381623,
-0.4735720754,
-0.4706483483,
-0.0975815132,
-0.5038699508,
-0.5703799129,
0.2600041926,
0.2403838485,
0.801550746,
0.6382831931,
-0.0883469135,
0.8472938538,
-0.4940990508,
0.8347967267,
0.1214280277,
-1.0839891434,
0.4439530373,
0.0143293543,
0.0180878025,
0.4056269526,
0.685790658,
0.0751560926,
-0.2322229445,
-0.7118135691,
-0.4250681698,
1.0054808855,
-0.0158198699,
-0.1456083208,
0.1912709475,
0.0911500156,
0.1399131119,
0.2713770568,
-0.6655955315,
0.1068608984,
-0.2602509558,
-0.1990716606,
-0.2211301178,
0.0623076558,
-0.1900103539,
-0.4757772684,
0.3176454902,
-0.094062902,
0.1518927366,
-0.0590488203,
-0.5526340604,
0.1068335623,
-0.1288952529,
0.5067443848,
0.4950521886,
-0.0723668337,
0.0396785364,
0.3595229387,
-0.3527849019,
0.1507530659,
0.0292342845,
0.4051587284,
-0.5334961414,
0.7322179079,
0.8377087116,
0.7828066945,
-0.7556287646,
0.603736937,
0.127211839,
-0.5071001053,
-0.0900350437,
0.294123441,
-0.3763722777,
0.7438749671,
0.5831974745,
0.2762129605,
0.0706659332,
-0.6629739404,
0.2635775208,
0.5649402142,
-0.406953156,
-0.5151873231,
0.7322154045,
0.1742407233,
-0.3016861677,
0.4334803522,
-0.2254902571,
-0.635297358,
0.9575771689,
0.4983694553,
0.8057737947,
-0.167528227,
0.0096334415,
0.2598646581,
-0.25550282,
0.0331913494,
-0.1631886661,
-0.6301130652,
-0.6223400831,
-0.2010701895,
-0.1873284876,
-0.0188469868,
0.0899251252,
-0.7420140505,
0.2951621711,
-0.3644142151,
-0.0124470042,
0.1066729501,
0.1772297621,
-1.0001688004,
0.2415404469,
0.0684872344,
0.6464312673,
-0.7474014759,
0.8425047994,
0.8674346209,
-0.1724950522,
-0.7096111774,
0.2240886986,
-0.0723628104,
-0.4442437291,
1.1667405367,
0.3158594966,
-0.007527479,
0.2687621713,
-0.6328690648,
-0.9022384286,
1.3734617233,
0.217804566,
-0.3787293732,
-0.1594433933,
-0.4644713104,
0.4524858296,
-0.769762516,
0.1206433624,
0.3787231147,
-0.039391309,
-0.0533792377,
-0.9428138137,
-0.3338871598,
0.0566010736,
-0.2210759372,
0.1925697029,
-0.4226479828,
0.8435980678,
-0.2015775591,
-0.5264520049,
0.0999882892,
0.5751248598,
0.1258856058,
0.6752560735,
0.7809737325,
0.305013001,
0.447390914,
-0.1314724833,
0.6457121372,
-0.315448761,
0.1501025856,
1.1479690075,
-0.3090550303,
0.9576477408,
0.2851313651,
-0.2496206313,
0.7504913211,
0.7097027302,
0.276458919,
0.7576299906,
-0.0632638261,
-0.4153248966,
-0.5426840186,
0.1517850161,
-0.1849560887,
0.5305221081,
0.3667258322,
-0.3436245322,
-0.1356633157,
0.424651593,
-0.4502696693,
0.0742099658,
-0.6375496387,
0.9325264692,
-0.3358779252,
-0.7863935232,
0.1949960887,
-0.675254643,
0.546497345,
-0.7366225719,
-0.0891617164,
0.2572848499,
0.0625797957,
-0.0770273358,
-0.5391584635,
-0.0682868138,
-0.2610594034,
-0.0651277006,
-0.0789232701,
0.5488237143,
-0.4407950342,
0.1276363581,
0.4536188543,
0.3959329128,
-0.0177884381,
0.2514934838,
-0.6481155157,
-0.1221843585,
-0.3706185222,
0.0878290683,
0.895209074,
0.2384564728,
-0.152864784,
0.5272499919,
0.3577376008,
-0.2650454938,
0.0595437102,
-0.4333420694,
0.7377613187,
-0.0463287383,
-0.7539699078,
-0.6009334326,
0.676543951,
-0.0955193266,
-0.4515746832,
0.3030416369,
0.3037682772,
1.2949254513,
-0.1057365611,
0.5411201715,
-0.2162682414,
0.389038831,
-0.4475622177,
0.5764990449,
-0.9589474201,
-0.1140162423,
-0.3949185014,
-0.4417536259,
-0.0890069529,
0.3921686411,
-0.3728725016,
0.137709707,
0.5819183588,
0.4464620054,
-0.4117122293,
-0.1345135719,
0.2798453569,
0.0389852375,
-0.0165381376,
0.6590572596,
0.9842335582,
0.0142665813,
0.3862962425,
-0.3063824177,
-0.477820307,
-0.4350123107,
-0.952008009,
-0.8029739261,
-0.898825109,
-0.2593339086,
-0.161301136,
0.0971818343,
1.1544735432,
1.1691577435,
-0.6089787483,
-0.5895913839,
-0.2225566357,
-0.02577167,
-0.9498823881,
-0.1805746555,
0.3208763003,
-0.6674466729,
-0.662460804,
0.4045635462,
0.0302092042,
0.1889217645,
0.1587049216,
-0.2180688083,
-0.2248859107,
-0.1675867736,
0.7737416625,
0.571182251,
-0.4802019894,
-0.2199992239,
-0.4409804642,
0.2237690687,
-0.0088591576,
1.119295001,
-0.9928902984,
0.5520433784,
0.1898247004,
0.5850544572,
0.4333983362,
-0.0206499994,
0.4216795266,
-0.5920698643,
0.1319705397,
0.1945766509,
0.2744229138,
-0.233482793,
-0.216437608,
0.3122062385,
0.3500462472,
-0.7581779361,
-1.0882200003,
0.1996491402,
-0.7371920347,
-0.34889099,
0.3093875647,
-0.3160043657,
0.1499591172,
-0.1734119952,
-0.0205657985,
0.2795042694,
-0.0124671431,
0.7938497663,
0.5666196346,
-0.5836063027,
0.0484534502,
-0.4230884612,
0.9231578708,
0.317595005,
-0.5560408235,
-0.247575447,
0.0457764529,
0.3954062462,
0.0171304233,
0.1900773942,
0.2331190258,
0.6741910577,
-0.1166868731,
-0.4051798284,
-0.0619207621,
-0.6858072877,
-0.204720214,
0.4804038703,
0.0525689833,
-0.4490032196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14021v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14021v1 | HIGHT: Hierarchical Graph Tokenization for Graph-Language Alignment | 2024-06-20T06:37:35 | 2024-06-20T06:37:35 | Yongqiang Chen, Quanming Yao, Juzheng Zhang, James Cheng, Yatao Bian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.QM | Recently there has been a surge of interest in extending the success of large
language models (LLMs) to graph modality, such as social networks and
molecules. As LLMs are predominantly trained with 1D text data, most existing
approaches adopt a graph neural network to represent a graph as a series of
node tokens and feed these tokens to LLMs for graph-language alignment. Despite
achieving some successes, existing approaches have overlooked the hierarchical
structures that are inherent in graph data. Especially, in molecular graphs,
the high-order structural information contains rich semantics of molecular
functional groups, which encode crucial biochemical functionalities of the
molecules. We establish a simple benchmark showing that neglecting the
hierarchical information in graph tokenization will lead to subpar
graph-language alignment and severe hallucination in generated outputs. To
address this problem, we propose a novel strategy called HIerarchical GrapH
Tokenization (HIGHT). HIGHT employs a hierarchical graph tokenizer that
extracts and encodes the hierarchy of node, motif, and graph levels of
informative tokens to improve the graph perception of LLMs. HIGHT also adopts
an augmented graph-language supervised fine-tuning dataset, enriched with the
hierarchical graph information, to further enhance the graph-language
alignment. Extensive experiments on 7 molecule-centric benchmarks confirm the
effectiveness of HIGHT in reducing hallucination by 40%, as well as significant
improvements in various molecule-language downstream tasks. | [
-0.2083475292,
-1.0572019815,
0.3353974521,
-0.0952843577,
-0.070545055,
0.6019084454,
-0.257113874,
-0.3588573337,
0.6183564067,
0.3555016816,
-0.1769267768,
-0.8671611547,
-0.7265488505,
0.06977579,
-0.0042997496,
1.0675393343,
0.0296087414,
-0.0343457758,
-0.1102411076,
-0.0544291586,
-0.1707123965,
-0.664922595,
-0.6813385487,
-0.433273524,
0.934130311,
0.2258077413,
0.8129909635,
1.131501317,
0.6056576371,
0.3101709485,
-0.3109167814,
0.2634370625,
-0.8028635979,
-0.2266901284,
-0.027241841,
0.0418495536,
-0.9320675731,
-0.1981982738,
0.6291697621,
1.1290388107,
0.2885320187,
-0.0742317513,
0.1228040159,
0.6530638933,
-0.3799230158,
0.4818246365,
-0.6562086344,
0.0464476719,
-0.2075690031,
-0.2431306094,
-0.3293000162,
-0.1834466308,
-0.0767688975,
-0.7115747929,
0.0310043413,
0.2126487494,
1.067256093,
0.1366780251,
-0.5078541636,
0.0478552021,
-0.503012538,
0.219159171,
-0.5253623724,
0.4258196354,
0.1199969873,
0.113329865,
-0.3342691958,
-0.7134460211,
-0.4080744684,
-0.1147653386,
-0.2425574809,
0.0582699254,
-0.0505384877,
0.5263502598,
0.1144992486,
0.292740494,
-0.652762711,
0.2111455202,
-0.0415345468,
-0.4266346097,
0.0075154928,
-0.1454047412,
0.3004235029,
-0.5015374422,
-0.4207601249,
0.0005347955,
-0.6030260324,
-0.2237357348,
0.1815483421,
0.8937066793,
0.2581190169,
0.7560995221,
-0.1495669037,
0.3322050273,
0.0986278877,
0.2122739404,
0.3960367143,
-0.5326868296,
-0.2774606943,
0.4917890728,
0.7500575781,
0.241533339,
0.3536452353,
-0.3764064312,
-0.2724226713,
0.0633655339,
-0.0133965621,
-1.0886679888,
-0.2180680484,
0.1795885116,
-0.5216414332,
-0.4823497236,
0.0507957414,
-0.7941456437,
-0.4497076273,
-0.1783747524,
0.4664761424,
-0.3864559233,
-0.0566165447,
0.0359689593,
-0.1066085622,
-0.2718490958,
0.0524639189,
-1.0453921556,
0.5528794527,
0.87851578,
1.0998563766,
-0.5450575352,
-0.5292965174,
-0.9286152124,
0.5142554045,
-0.3028949797,
0.4594639838,
-0.6220039129,
-0.0031102109,
-0.2697806358,
0.1174469739,
-0.2111737579,
-0.602186799,
-0.0450034291,
-0.3659263551,
-0.0847217664,
-0.2502568066,
-0.5185963511,
0.1413234025,
0.2443872541,
-0.482311964,
1.1544418335,
0.2343443334,
-0.8090385199,
0.2646780908,
-0.5422489643,
-0.5250706673,
0.1253961623,
-0.5278664231,
-0.4464941025,
-0.1394325644,
0.390712291,
0.3505037129,
0.0816641077,
0.3345207274,
-0.210762471,
-0.5187807679,
-0.0359906219,
-0.1458337009,
0.5733650327,
-0.1205478236,
-0.4671090245,
0.6163261533,
-0.6972752213,
-0.1719707698,
-0.0428401679,
-0.3107429147,
-0.1744628549,
-0.1365214139,
0.0685909092,
0.0962786078,
0.346880734,
-0.5564191937,
0.400770247,
-0.5641124249,
0.6032377481,
1.1353378296,
0.0100276731,
0.3411748707,
-0.003662545,
0.1788582355,
0.2070674598,
-0.1173220649,
0.1599975526,
-0.3947136998,
-0.4753039479,
-0.4911286533,
0.2872956693,
0.436422497,
-0.4847665429,
0.8706309795,
-0.635707736,
-0.1452695131,
-0.1319668889,
0.0369092301,
0.2374425083,
0.681573391,
0.3995629251,
-0.3297734559,
-0.5394594073,
-0.6611717343,
-0.1212759838,
-0.2899780273,
0.1490857452,
0.4191872478,
0.5923181772,
-0.5781205893,
0.7325178981,
-0.4024585783,
-0.4464309812,
-0.0642765984,
0.0283969305,
0.1097000241,
0.6072298288,
0.2896395326,
-0.3985167742,
-0.2441706657,
0.6006977558,
-0.6299325824,
0.059573479,
-0.0007819895,
-0.5899656415,
-0.0629136935,
0.6560813189,
-0.800150156,
0.3017559648,
0.3091638386,
-0.409661144,
0.2476833016,
-0.0464600548,
-0.0105735101,
-1.2848850489,
0.1424078941,
-0.2637637854,
-0.2938031554,
-0.4342778027,
-0.2067694515,
-0.2193090469,
-0.3315688372,
-0.0841893032,
0.4737548828,
-0.3353214264,
-0.2179322094,
-0.1011542529,
0.1861625761,
-0.1467090994,
0.7438547015,
-0.0717404783,
0.5953422189,
0.5738028884,
-0.0833421499,
0.2477848381,
0.3072380722,
-0.0065560215,
0.148724705,
-0.6194825768,
0.1240354925,
-0.0710398704,
0.2650665343,
-1.0811924934,
-0.462766856,
0.3090213537,
-0.4268759787,
0.3807465136,
-0.2877921462,
-0.550252676,
-0.1338900179,
-0.1797454953,
0.4956893325,
0.3449881971,
-0.5851957202,
0.5566455126,
0.3386966884,
0.0394454747,
-0.5746566653,
-0.4430944026,
0.301425159,
-0.1596071124,
-0.4794299603,
0.515438199,
0.277297914,
0.237198323,
-0.0206127055,
-0.436958462,
0.1928324997,
0.0067956112,
0.2638042271,
0.1627182364,
-0.4851036966,
0.0471536554,
-0.0362920091,
-0.3194707334,
-0.1254628748,
-0.79083848,
0.7706882954,
-0.2911444902,
-0.1578956991,
-0.5516588092,
0.1830349416,
0.797983408,
-0.2503366768,
0.7248610854,
0.4822683036,
-0.760234952,
0.142490387,
0.0344946124,
-0.2534728646,
-0.4777252674,
0.6792022586,
-0.3831821084,
-0.9514017701,
0.4918245375,
-0.3219092786,
-0.3683635592,
0.2113306373,
0.5681145191,
0.0479687229,
1.2051411867,
0.3293003738,
-0.2448803782,
0.5332399011,
-0.1406188905,
0.6723076105,
-0.6281049848,
-0.071287252,
-0.4531233907,
-0.4290404618,
-0.6937767267,
-0.3604030609,
0.4013600647,
0.3140823245,
-0.5617970228,
0.4614941478,
-0.5785118937,
0.5872206092,
0.1838477701,
0.2288528681,
0.1194573939,
0.5876703858,
-0.3833174407,
0.1689766794,
-0.686434567,
-0.5165407062,
0.6224569678,
0.3727611899,
0.613407433,
-0.1204414964,
0.9147017598,
0.0169071648,
0.0784412697,
-0.9982190132,
0.5744483471,
-0.2202483714,
-0.1690717191,
-0.5375006795,
-0.6824913025,
-1.0750973225,
0.131210044,
-0.0616888776,
-1.1847115755,
0.2933081388,
0.107787624,
-0.1436109096,
0.329761982,
-0.5466868877,
1.2540562153,
-0.0789775476,
-0.2397847921,
0.1257040799,
-0.6967408657,
-0.1830696613,
0.052377332,
0.1506763101,
0.0009382238,
0.1235855222,
0.7345989347,
-0.6621425152,
0.9664050341,
-0.0966905802,
-0.0640545115,
-0.0985745713,
0.1972594857,
0.7297822833,
-0.071157366,
-0.0073363292,
0.1573824137,
-0.0504334159,
-0.6087160707,
-0.6403666735,
0.778195262,
-0.7556128502,
-0.4033336937,
-0.203583315,
-0.5983155966,
-0.2503440976,
0.6569056511,
0.2923413515,
0.4723273516,
-0.1193388179,
0.1775549054,
0.3863365948,
0.0283362791,
0.1400153488,
-0.4949114025,
-0.3914601505,
-0.7673923969,
1.2529942989,
0.1107464954,
0.427790314,
0.5241715908,
0.3893395364,
0.017282417,
-0.604726851,
-0.5310765505,
0.1879498661,
-0.8107193112,
-0.113358818,
-0.7389438748,
-0.3280391097,
-0.6220107079,
-0.3249512613,
-0.3787676096,
-0.6576764584,
-0.0770851299,
-0.3821383715,
0.2734422386,
0.5392234921,
0.1641257256,
0.227208212,
-0.570993185,
0.4963424802,
-0.0095872777,
0.3823725879,
0.0226798579,
-0.0009361747,
-0.3691062629,
-0.0191255659,
0.0487311818,
-0.6565467119,
0.0308548585,
0.1720755845,
0.2473554611,
0.3086038828,
-0.388237536,
0.9310131073,
-0.4467606246,
0.5936846733,
0.1761079878,
-0.952824831,
0.3891575038,
-0.4704007506,
0.077352412,
0.5315237641,
0.2393862903,
-0.7034227848,
-0.3748051226,
-0.1672706306,
-1.0479792356,
0.4106857181,
0.4137985706,
0.0020644134,
-0.3699262142,
0.4475711882,
0.0020998474,
0.2012308836,
-0.7488511801,
-0.1667408198,
-0.338729769,
-0.506660521,
0.0387062132,
0.2241298705,
-0.179133743,
-0.542940855,
0.4991051257,
-0.4332205653,
0.1750855148,
0.0529140718,
0.0552286804,
-0.2424565703,
-0.0130030382,
0.0634124428,
0.5462235808,
-0.2673788667,
0.6264232993,
-0.161931932,
-0.4991706312,
0.1248229519,
0.0885411575,
-0.1297833025,
-0.1954368651,
0.4826843739,
0.7711143494,
-0.0075322599,
-0.3888747394,
0.4405602217,
0.2736259997,
-0.0556416921,
0.5248672366,
-0.1567221731,
0.2116410434,
-0.080073677,
0.0653476566,
0.1799495667,
-0.1141724437,
-0.7225638032,
0.3215980828,
0.4169329703,
-0.5549795032,
-0.2264706045,
0.6614482403,
0.0292334463,
-0.39187181,
0.5767306685,
0.080700174,
-0.6549589038,
0.5678044558,
0.7603955269,
0.90379107,
0.1150880828,
0.0944451168,
0.2618272603,
0.1394294351,
0.37423715,
0.1462861001,
-0.0760806575,
-0.7135846019,
-0.1855403483,
-0.7189462781,
0.0153113734,
-0.1818168461,
-0.320756197,
0.0702797472,
-0.4394364059,
-0.1286816746,
0.3242200017,
-0.1629630625,
-0.1724683195,
-0.0333390087,
-0.0416793562,
0.469653666,
-0.7208737731,
0.8964065909,
0.5230443478,
-0.4315119088,
-0.522883296,
0.1561212391,
-0.1032663584,
-0.6206434369,
0.7689271569,
0.3721185923,
-0.3752097785,
0.3379746377,
-0.4464334249,
-0.9571802616,
0.8251574039,
0.328887403,
-0.4402862787,
-0.3638656139,
0.4499950409,
0.5842584372,
-0.5410616994,
-0.2732364535,
0.5894771218,
0.5032286644,
0.2479397207,
-0.6894432306,
0.401704222,
-0.3458170295,
0.1333843321,
0.3683343828,
-0.4569965899,
0.7097226977,
0.001240925,
-0.2189008445,
0.0167602319,
0.587905407,
0.2664114237,
0.1896823794,
0.3199108839,
0.3988887966,
1.0453746319,
-0.158734411,
0.7290269136,
-0.3881260455,
0.2721558809,
0.9205448031,
-0.4295288324,
0.5809862614,
0.807448566,
0.155535683,
0.3014029562,
0.8297016621,
0.1420293301,
0.3172239959,
0.5428475738,
-0.0593211837,
-0.1915851831,
-0.2070450187,
-0.1931797862,
0.1781408042,
0.2978232503,
-0.1210823283,
-0.1221898422,
-0.0137952138,
-0.0289941933,
-0.0614083745,
-0.1376463771,
0.826202333,
-0.1360434294,
-0.3130931854,
0.8396963477,
-0.1451002061,
0.3234612644,
-0.1670168191,
-0.0442762561,
-0.2046951652,
0.1720228642,
-0.4367865324,
-0.3909797072,
0.121274665,
-0.2249272168,
-0.0559589528,
-0.2502521276,
0.5621196032,
-0.3795266747,
-0.4243486822,
0.5167399049,
0.4652057588,
0.1786346287,
0.0142974528,
-0.4173087776,
-0.0651389435,
-0.3347227275,
-0.1825339496,
0.2478727996,
0.6860379577,
-0.2813389599,
0.2067323625,
0.5774156451,
0.2030712515,
-0.0288048256,
0.3445652425,
1.0189810991,
-0.7978631258,
-0.348128289,
-0.9565551281,
-0.0107266577,
-0.0982310623,
-0.2239245176,
0.6930821538,
1.0203030109,
0.9798352718,
0.2180160284,
0.6171956062,
0.1250887066,
-0.1641628593,
-0.5905720592,
0.7258443236,
-0.4552583396,
0.1370416284,
-0.5422315598,
-1.0076690912,
-0.5905392766,
0.4650190771,
-0.0448448211,
0.0732251555,
0.9222300649,
1.1265542507,
-0.1437835693,
-0.2011996806,
0.1231778711,
0.4890682101,
0.5218541026,
0.4216016829,
0.6617756486,
-0.404879421,
0.3538901806,
-0.088680096,
-0.240527451,
-0.1518910527,
-0.7590973973,
-1.1009210348,
-0.4136923552,
-0.3671764433,
-0.7549766302,
0.2219268233,
1.1910837889,
0.7364451885,
-0.871257484,
-0.4477539957,
-0.5052009821,
0.2224022597,
-0.2924762666,
-0.2066396028,
0.8200291395,
-0.2896521688,
-0.5030580163,
0.4762608111,
0.6979874969,
0.3180614412,
0.0775137916,
-0.1258575916,
-0.1552743912,
-0.0433734767,
0.6279445291,
-0.015514723,
-0.6344263554,
-0.6509909034,
0.1847830862,
-0.4280093312,
0.7063936591,
0.8916425705,
-0.5586343408,
0.2475411892,
0.6793202162,
0.8234318495,
0.5717152357,
0.1450410932,
0.4452468753,
-0.7899651527,
-0.095549427,
0.1193145961,
0.32414186,
0.214174509,
-0.6021308899,
0.3551779985,
0.5596310496,
-0.3527257144,
-0.880023241,
0.1059264243,
-1.2020224333,
-0.3674388826,
0.9502877593,
0.2046816051,
-0.5087630153,
-0.0167226177,
-0.4036746919,
0.6117817163,
-0.294393301,
0.7597433925,
0.7028801441,
-0.2720153332,
0.2556882501,
-0.177028954,
0.5546508431,
0.3376650512,
-0.9573141932,
0.6279473305,
0.5164453983,
-0.0845224857,
0.2431921363,
0.6436796784,
-0.2713108659,
-0.0139653701,
-0.0686239898,
-0.0876450539,
0.0658481047,
-0.5533269048,
-0.1570680439,
0.2225381881,
-0.0529100895,
0.0563655198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14012v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14012v1 | Seeing Through AI's Lens: Enhancing Human Skepticism Towards LLM-Generated Fake News | 2024-06-20T06:02:04 | 2024-06-20T06:02:04 | Navid Ayoobi, Sadat Shahriar, Arjun Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | LLMs offer valuable capabilities, yet they can be utilized by malicious users
to disseminate deceptive information and generate fake news. The growing
prevalence of LLMs poses difficulties in crafting detection approaches that
remain effective across various text domains. Additionally, the absence of
precautionary measures for AI-generated news on online social platforms is
concerning. Therefore, there is an urgent need to improve people's ability to
differentiate between news articles written by humans and those produced by
LLMs. By providing cues in human-written and LLM-generated news, we can help
individuals increase their skepticism towards fake LLM-generated news. This
paper aims to elucidate simple markers that help individuals distinguish
between articles penned by humans and those created by LLMs. To achieve this,
we initially collected a dataset comprising 39k news articles authored by
humans or generated by four distinct LLMs with varying degrees of fake. We then
devise a metric named Entropy-Shift Authorship Signature (ESAS) based on the
information theory and entropy principles. The proposed ESAS ranks terms or
entities, like POS tagging, within news articles based on their relevance in
discerning article authorship. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our metric
by showing the high accuracy attained by a basic method, i.e., TF-IDF combined
with logistic regression classifier, using a small set of terms with the
highest ESAS score. Consequently, we introduce and scrutinize these top
ESAS-ranked terms to aid individuals in strengthening their skepticism towards
LLM-generated fake news. | [
-0.2743816972,
-0.6634058356,
0.8521590233,
0.0735216737,
-0.2957929969,
0.3665437102,
0.1088938266,
-0.6900183558,
0.5028617382,
0.2460500598,
-0.5007013679,
-0.5238133073,
-0.7681437731,
0.4593095183,
-0.4855086803,
0.7861269712,
-0.0450874195,
0.0172905382,
-0.3217383027,
0.2001201808,
0.2670050561,
-0.0768326372,
-0.7233612537,
-0.289097935,
0.7097273469,
0.0015520978,
0.5179572105,
0.7254191637,
0.4539236426,
0.1765276641,
0.1561414003,
0.580106914,
-0.1178416088,
-0.2771927416,
-0.004654631,
-0.8521888256,
-0.2504190803,
0.3484748304,
0.4405067861,
0.0595016666,
0.1055865288,
0.4363732636,
-0.0243193675,
0.5161255598,
-0.5590389967,
-0.2780916393,
-0.9010391235,
0.1384835094,
-0.5498028994,
-0.4730033875,
-0.397472471,
-0.3756817877,
-0.2634270191,
-0.7835103273,
0.3271872997,
0.3317185342,
1.0575249195,
0.3711197376,
-0.5044398308,
-0.1581186503,
-0.5277916789,
0.4539748728,
-0.7104493976,
0.3338730335,
0.548078239,
-0.1912714243,
-0.0954395235,
-0.4258468151,
-0.8618230224,
-0.2034688294,
-0.0892449245,
0.1436529607,
-0.1860367507,
-0.2469969243,
0.1163798422,
0.0772852898,
-0.5203655958,
0.1250143945,
-0.1857817769,
-0.5909439325,
0.6744408607,
0.0489072986,
0.3804389536,
-0.0114822369,
-0.5820031166,
0.0108502964,
-0.9286030531,
-0.0730634853,
0.7244045734,
-0.0607581921,
-0.0567192584,
0.5051442981,
-0.0835212395,
0.3934940994,
0.2715964913,
-0.3687915206,
0.2319359481,
-0.0643608868,
-0.2169075459,
0.1493837982,
0.6991029978,
0.4337188303,
0.0881490856,
-0.0896639749,
-0.117146641,
0.4619711936,
0.4108821452,
-0.3666593432,
0.1087113097,
-0.0874901414,
-0.5712103248,
-0.7278782725,
0.5655969381,
-0.4880537391,
-0.8151167631,
-0.3217063844,
0.486436218,
-0.1817286313,
-0.1625650525,
0.1026604325,
-0.3160210252,
0.3908358216,
0.5906944275,
-0.292986244,
0.1057557687,
0.6152701378,
0.5861862898,
-0.3131928146,
-0.3159055412,
-0.4436592758,
0.3050620854,
-0.5926291943,
0.8147397637,
-0.3690852225,
0.2006803751,
-0.0620576553,
-0.2882873118,
0.0665701702,
-0.4432155192,
0.4840223789,
-0.624550581,
0.2788850665,
-0.2335545719,
-0.5964998603,
-0.0052407412,
0.3608010411,
-0.3925386667,
1.0823339224,
-0.1841239035,
-0.7928986549,
0.7525380254,
-0.4616934955,
-0.7149873376,
0.1240598336,
-0.3169457316,
-0.4091338217,
0.1915137619,
0.4040871263,
0.4077070653,
-0.0333740152,
0.1761971861,
-0.1659013033,
-0.106092155,
0.632121861,
-0.4991580546,
0.7282717824,
0.2180007994,
-0.5480014682,
-0.091295138,
-0.6018762589,
-0.2677248418,
-0.0859911442,
-0.4634419978,
-0.4034585357,
0.0336163491,
-0.2380716205,
-0.055493366,
0.0887894183,
-0.5396441221,
0.0899836197,
-0.2143801451,
0.1903674752,
0.8620189428,
0.2061564177,
0.3037265241,
-0.6606388092,
0.4125098586,
0.2788291872,
-0.0273065399,
-0.0710487366,
-0.5448549986,
-0.7386233211,
-0.3285582066,
0.0665964037,
0.7196375728,
-0.8172112703,
0.5991104841,
-0.1066033617,
-0.5952632427,
-0.8575915098,
0.4176703393,
0.3324608207,
0.4783492386,
0.2172069997,
-0.2383336127,
-0.406062901,
-0.746999383,
-0.9391626716,
-0.6128621101,
-0.3131821156,
0.1008131281,
0.3545617163,
-0.1971134841,
0.8939928412,
-0.3553377688,
-0.3092267811,
0.1058139578,
0.4118116498,
-0.1219152063,
0.1390740126,
0.3840683401,
-0.8464606404,
-0.3302243948,
-0.1867769212,
-0.8315207958,
-0.1588254422,
-0.5396136045,
-0.1062170863,
0.441703707,
0.6859468818,
-0.8944903016,
0.7956288457,
0.0357594676,
-0.5617877245,
0.5267955661,
0.2137917727,
0.3184555471,
-1.0170282125,
-0.0535350479,
0.346635133,
-0.4620136023,
-0.3495438099,
0.0338427126,
-0.1486920267,
0.384773016,
-0.4368463159,
0.6554170847,
-0.5778601766,
0.0649517402,
0.0508632213,
0.0177680105,
-0.0525354072,
-0.0470202118,
-0.080945529,
0.5805627704,
0.4552703202,
-0.391815722,
0.1590345651,
-0.0477610417,
-0.5957373381,
0.6310168505,
-0.246667549,
0.2131577879,
-0.1766494066,
0.3207431734,
-0.9757498503,
-0.3145888746,
0.5547511578,
-0.7613099813,
0.2525697052,
0.2823082507,
-0.8362913728,
-0.2530314624,
-0.3845953345,
0.0492304265,
0.4342600405,
-0.3893884122,
0.7602176666,
0.1829485744,
0.0183750503,
-0.5027380586,
-0.8451609015,
0.5893415809,
-0.5210561156,
-0.7233479619,
0.4768856168,
0.0455346331,
-0.7304900885,
0.0570506528,
-0.1712187529,
0.2591260672,
0.1605620682,
0.1337524205,
0.079189539,
-0.2588422894,
0.0081807878,
0.0789407641,
0.0391755402,
0.1712214798,
-0.1345023811,
0.0554895513,
0.0290963706,
-0.3337475359,
-0.9449849129,
-0.0040180157,
0.5602289438,
0.0247287378,
0.5920618176,
0.8657422662,
-0.4261532724,
-0.275404036,
-0.8934565783,
-0.5921738148,
-0.4450452924,
0.1176032349,
0.0825578943,
-0.6161084771,
0.413849771,
-0.1463933885,
-0.1824107468,
0.4261505604,
0.6687302589,
-0.2780656815,
0.7578048706,
0.4896009564,
-0.3917760253,
0.2600906193,
0.1854982078,
0.0913666114,
-0.5066993833,
-0.2045467496,
-0.24307549,
-0.5014709234,
-0.2642544806,
-0.4321478009,
0.4901681542,
-0.1296649724,
-0.0496963076,
0.0751864091,
-0.4692212939,
0.5663544536,
0.8458347321,
0.3890081942,
0.4326166511,
0.2778523266,
0.1953329742,
0.0021184084,
-0.2802108824,
-0.7042717934,
0.9795662761,
0.3991247714,
0.7806954384,
-0.0581975095,
0.8108155131,
1.0108048916,
0.5143151283,
-0.4640530944,
0.5965024233,
0.2429923564,
-0.7210556865,
-0.2368737608,
-0.2100641131,
-0.6046709418,
-0.0606599413,
-0.3124629259,
-0.6561543345,
0.0527846925,
0.09429425,
-0.231122613,
0.4494497776,
-0.506660521,
0.2084097564,
-0.4488722384,
-0.2597159147,
-0.2761540413,
-0.8946257234,
0.0794864595,
-0.0798759684,
0.3107630014,
-0.1423081607,
-0.3669078648,
0.649410069,
-0.1362048388,
1.3600801229,
-0.0655088872,
-0.1775251627,
0.3005239964,
0.2518743277,
0.5932115912,
0.3639982641,
-0.0629723072,
0.4076721668,
-0.5496174693,
-0.0761481225,
-0.1350422651,
0.2764000595,
-0.8464869261,
-0.8085087538,
-0.4651715457,
-0.3401071131,
-0.0284164697,
0.2228992581,
0.6617786884,
-0.0940412208,
-0.0537283756,
-0.0589232743,
0.4884895682,
0.0149980737,
0.2926568091,
0.4759714007,
0.0962715372,
-0.3320798874,
0.7548767924,
-0.1304882616,
-0.1614807099,
0.5382506251,
0.1492351294,
-0.1348348856,
-0.459902823,
-0.4919631481,
0.201674059,
-0.4329839349,
-0.4846790731,
-0.2283554971,
-0.0986077636,
-0.5154431462,
-0.5915433168,
0.0173626281,
-0.1743464768,
-0.7522308826,
-0.3997050226,
0.2242598236,
0.5067818761,
-0.1071608961,
0.2313822955,
-0.3780556321,
0.5886443257,
0.1172441095,
-0.165300101,
-0.2320137769,
-0.4913990498,
-0.0397756286,
0.2098677456,
-0.4592444897,
-0.8846150637,
0.3170432448,
0.1915131062,
0.4900914133,
0.9289301634,
0.1607111692,
0.4314332604,
-0.2052269727,
0.9689145088,
0.1959213912,
-0.9901924133,
0.5592326522,
-0.564155221,
-0.255384177,
0.3803862035,
0.3827461004,
-0.1705655307,
-0.9082299471,
-0.5345178246,
-0.6257942915,
0.5196970701,
0.2761397064,
0.2330564708,
-0.0074884067,
0.5149048567,
0.285266012,
0.3508518934,
-1.0074102879,
-0.2281662673,
0.0494941659,
-0.1325679719,
0.1052603275,
-0.1418510824,
-0.3540016711,
-0.2969694734,
0.6982036829,
-0.2013275921,
0.2869262099,
0.4838835299,
-0.0862965658,
-0.3726908863,
-0.0328224376,
0.7909426093,
0.6528465748,
0.0317119583,
0.4174144864,
-0.0055153612,
-0.4686442018,
0.092683807,
-0.1431652904,
-0.4875109196,
-0.016483169,
0.7652796507,
0.6209604144,
-0.2816382945,
-0.4294134378,
0.4976727068,
0.275598675,
-0.3081549108,
-0.4639418423,
0.1744288355,
0.1318037659,
0.3085431457,
0.8271775246,
0.4159523249,
-0.0457952693,
-0.5172819495,
0.1189946681,
0.3957825601,
-0.0772493705,
-0.551492393,
0.8016492724,
0.1866483241,
-0.4391327798,
0.5082336068,
-0.2570745945,
-0.4364741147,
0.6709447503,
0.5313394666,
0.9078530669,
-0.1120122075,
0.488201946,
-0.0510142632,
0.7325909138,
-0.1647397429,
0.0987139419,
0.0029571117,
-1.0867369175,
0.0473239012,
-0.5696433187,
-0.0569623373,
0.0721005276,
-0.5436573625,
0.443693608,
-0.3017904758,
-0.3166619241,
0.1296500415,
-0.1471363455,
-0.5724335909,
0.1692382544,
0.4722612798,
0.8340461254,
-1.0898916721,
0.4714583457,
0.8622932434,
-0.1309804618,
-0.407477051,
0.5891382098,
0.6099202037,
-1.0426181555,
0.5259506702,
0.1941597313,
-0.1204942167,
0.0050878283,
-0.9138652086,
-0.5421380401,
1.1382871866,
0.6820980906,
-0.3045831919,
-0.1984222978,
0.3874426782,
0.5004116893,
-0.527787447,
-0.1705994606,
0.1356028616,
0.7657027245,
-0.0806357935,
-0.5025256872,
0.2045227736,
-0.1334159076,
-0.3071349561,
0.0247960482,
-0.7639961243,
0.5797305107,
-0.3227637708,
-0.104640469,
-0.0171850342,
0.5612156987,
0.2366750389,
0.9402672052,
0.4192495346,
0.7826393843,
0.9088908434,
0.1597952545,
0.9499756694,
-0.1341411471,
-0.0156272873,
0.6681135893,
-0.3502621055,
0.6478810906,
0.6834571958,
-0.155753687,
0.6855429411,
0.6181551814,
-0.391885668,
0.3396852911,
0.1967001408,
-0.3380004168,
-0.5424244404,
-0.0564268306,
-0.2225816995,
0.4286819696,
0.403464824,
-0.6907606721,
0.056560915,
-0.0707422346,
0.2825801373,
0.0728342682,
-0.4016394019,
0.8034792542,
0.2708879113,
-0.5580000877,
0.0048251273,
0.104132548,
0.9109767675,
-0.4062405527,
0.1371505558,
-0.2038617432,
0.0644638389,
-0.3678564429,
-0.5919910669,
0.1963634789,
0.0396441519,
-0.3212042749,
-0.3383623958,
1.0839002132,
-0.1989181191,
-0.7761693001,
0.0015226887,
0.6556356549,
0.1706491858,
-0.2150709331,
-0.4481232166,
-0.0227290709,
0.0415710546,
-0.3828882575,
0.2667502761,
0.4345701337,
-0.1245938167,
0.5826677084,
0.7546402216,
0.3528707027,
0.039350044,
-0.3138333261,
0.5058139563,
-0.4244523346,
-0.5023446083,
-1.1285572052,
0.343886435,
-0.1425815076,
-0.5235199928,
0.969855547,
0.6479464769,
0.8633224964,
-0.2218608409,
0.7866991162,
-0.0274918713,
0.4251714349,
-0.6592673063,
1.0442962646,
-0.7689881325,
0.2852413654,
-0.3626227975,
-0.7023295164,
-0.4380385876,
0.4355403483,
-0.0988440737,
0.0118632447,
0.4161426127,
0.8540104628,
0.1233258098,
-0.3606650531,
0.1478598267,
0.2112080455,
0.1318396181,
0.0786318928,
0.9759625196,
-0.200905636,
0.2454092354,
0.0239149053,
-0.0924702361,
-0.3323735595,
-1.0601712465,
-0.9249861836,
-0.5543292165,
-0.7445363402,
-0.3638574481,
-0.0093203485,
0.6386811137,
0.7757416964,
-0.4866794348,
0.1140219346,
-0.1858954728,
0.1657411307,
-0.3213715553,
-0.2895820141,
0.3342699111,
0.0164622907,
-0.3559591472,
0.2571386695,
0.2246305346,
-0.0090724453,
-0.2242349386,
-0.1253112555,
-0.0141217168,
0.4599837661,
0.3900589645,
0.1061179265,
-1.1003404856,
-0.4187794626,
0.0911352187,
-0.1571859121,
0.0171881486,
0.7816101909,
-0.8616728783,
0.1566711664,
0.3562124372,
0.6198561788,
0.2231586576,
0.263740629,
0.3527534008,
-0.9818094373,
-0.0702936649,
0.2078381032,
0.1126645729,
0.3472393453,
-0.8809587359,
0.4784793854,
0.7266266942,
-0.3171155155,
-0.9707997441,
0.0644028038,
-0.864123404,
-0.1352414489,
1.2259192467,
0.1305367649,
-0.1180185601,
-0.0212022103,
-0.0217398964,
0.0548038147,
-0.4588341415,
1.2469496727,
0.6630836725,
-0.2722489238,
-0.0769866332,
-0.0739558563,
0.6696314812,
0.1534417868,
-0.9385147095,
-0.2477542162,
0.4053451121,
0.3707146347,
0.3192429841,
0.6360016465,
-0.0413300358,
0.229339093,
0.0414749831,
0.01727763,
-0.1327130049,
-0.3796741366,
0.1503668278,
-0.0601995215,
-0.1551480442,
0.0465336405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14005v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14005v2 | Information Guided Regularization for Fine-tuning Language Models | 2024-06-20T05:18:37 | 2024-06-21T12:41:17 | Mandar Sharma, Nikhil Muralidhar, Shengzhe Xu, Raquib Bin Yousuf, Naren Ramakrishnan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The pretraining-fine-tuning paradigm has been the de facto strategy for
transfer learning in modern language modeling. With the understanding that task
adaptation in LMs is often a function of parameters shared across tasks, we
argue that a more surgical approach to regularization needs to exist for
smoother transfer learning. Towards this end, we investigate how the
pretraining loss landscape is affected by these task-sensitive parameters
through an information-theoretic lens. We then leverage the findings from our
investigations to devise a novel approach to dropout for improved model
regularization and better downstream generalization. This approach, named
guided dropout, is both task & architecture agnostic and adds no computational
overhead to the fine-tuning process. Through empirical evaluations, we showcase
that our approach to regularization yields consistently better performance,
even in scenarios of data paucity, compared to standardized baselines. | [
-0.3466079533,
-0.764545083,
0.3014536798,
-0.2404101342,
-0.158363983,
-0.4101338387,
-0.6022334695,
-0.1790350825,
-0.2068585306,
0.4989525378,
-0.940354526,
-0.5744798779,
-0.7695800066,
-0.2150089592,
-0.3737744093,
1.2971737385,
-0.1927271783,
0.0507364981,
0.066183649,
0.2785922289,
-0.872638464,
-0.1301969737,
-0.8237813711,
-0.1091556326,
0.6454765797,
0.3246463835,
0.5075258017,
1.0410485268,
0.7483161092,
0.0741181895,
0.1311855316,
0.2343860865,
-0.7475243211,
-0.213058427,
-0.2161041647,
-0.6957749724,
-0.1748721004,
0.0680751204,
0.6967570782,
1.3179116249,
-0.2153718174,
0.1198792607,
0.5484889746,
0.7945385575,
-0.8478793502,
0.1127631515,
-0.6103848815,
0.1924231201,
-0.2631624937,
-0.3454678655,
-0.4345294237,
-0.405279994,
0.1371478587,
-1.0861955881,
0.4718737304,
-0.1517726183,
1.0039993525,
0.7155686021,
-0.0591518544,
-0.0172117501,
-1.1085429192,
0.7605241537,
-0.5371367335,
0.6459563375,
0.5387545824,
0.158371523,
-0.1925125867,
-0.459282428,
0.1116474196,
-0.1858588457,
0.0381752886,
-0.1176266894,
0.0231485665,
0.4530084133,
0.239351809,
0.1795065105,
-0.4075926542,
0.0888660327,
-0.5305549502,
-0.1321486831,
0.3367215693,
-0.0256264415,
0.10986913,
0.5114142299,
-0.1141279042,
-0.015891917,
-0.9103607535,
0.0934652686,
0.2357898951,
0.4596487284,
0.1133780032,
-0.1527111232,
-0.3521931171,
1.1091314554,
0.4754652977,
0.0082991058,
-0.2923258245,
-0.4017809033,
-0.2623163462,
-0.0966886133,
0.3110077083,
0.4108507931,
0.4469659626,
-0.170424059,
-0.0073406571,
-0.2102383971,
0.4031273425,
-0.8689795732,
-0.563819468,
-0.2558430433,
-0.6908162832,
-0.1302272081,
-0.0656227469,
-0.2895255387,
-0.285823226,
-0.564124763,
0.4617326856,
-0.3317738473,
-0.1528717279,
0.4685766101,
0.1961349547,
0.0886025354,
0.5516061187,
-0.9599444866,
0.4422856569,
0.6448835135,
0.7200044394,
-0.3555108905,
-0.1345527172,
-0.8670682311,
0.3502113819,
-0.4902914166,
0.4443287849,
-0.6101111174,
-0.1659920961,
0.0009344885,
0.1100099981,
-0.393969804,
-0.6494659781,
0.4537108243,
-0.3781718016,
0.1636082679,
-0.1798922569,
-0.5346147418,
-0.4376142323,
0.020730868,
-0.3804068565,
0.9309144616,
0.0326665975,
-0.4548185766,
0.6617081165,
-0.5357934237,
-0.3741330802,
-0.1034034416,
-0.1110668704,
-0.1313332617,
0.3575175703,
-0.0108282231,
0.5704349279,
-0.2768022418,
0.4054097235,
-0.2632300258,
-0.5858659744,
-0.3557493091,
-0.1894047111,
0.4346996844,
0.3302620351,
-0.1549647003,
0.0090309754,
-0.8352984786,
0.0596667491,
-0.2640376985,
-0.5396404862,
-0.680729568,
0.0531678833,
0.0880336165,
-0.0419256687,
0.0537539162,
-0.3306566477,
0.4368335009,
-0.3693797588,
0.2853496075,
0.7552753687,
-0.1365521997,
0.5983592868,
-0.2334028333,
0.3374353051,
0.0435414352,
0.4922941923,
0.1537750959,
-0.0874907672,
-0.95212394,
-0.3085894883,
0.6296144128,
0.538123548,
-0.4221339226,
0.384596169,
-0.1728695035,
-0.312207073,
-0.6875144839,
0.2217040956,
0.5011624694,
0.7232145667,
0.2248468101,
-0.513888061,
-0.5304119587,
-0.9806736708,
-0.4602705836,
0.2476418018,
-0.0176373348,
0.200616166,
-0.0643449575,
-0.2895430624,
0.7270719409,
-0.6110604405,
-0.593369782,
-0.0210747495,
0.0173650812,
0.2809794545,
0.8808300495,
0.43279019,
-0.507520318,
-0.458896935,
0.1772319973,
-0.4731084704,
-0.0943677276,
-0.1740757972,
-0.2827740014,
-0.1294496506,
0.6345367432,
-0.4253645539,
0.5379603505,
0.4628575146,
-0.0438477844,
0.1564712822,
-0.3758028746,
0.0810160711,
-1.1011072397,
0.2565834224,
-0.0189683046,
-0.358923614,
-0.990060389,
-0.3057532012,
0.1546952575,
-0.0095585827,
-0.1967924833,
0.3216273487,
-0.574277401,
0.1920538545,
-0.2161363661,
-0.1272437274,
-0.0428804643,
0.440349251,
0.0150207728,
0.6143942475,
0.8366568089,
-0.9990124702,
-0.0533808172,
0.1119683981,
-0.1484519988,
0.341766268,
-0.4216672182,
0.1833489239,
-0.3097800314,
0.0224748757,
-0.7457634807,
-0.2261445075,
0.2747528553,
-0.1767834574,
0.6104923487,
-0.4546375275,
-0.0711499304,
0.2007575184,
-0.1988870949,
0.4536100328,
0.4790837169,
-0.2828229368,
0.4176873863,
0.1643315107,
-0.2792155743,
-0.5026747584,
-0.6244195104,
-0.2958592772,
-0.1598348767,
-0.4282923937,
0.4820325077,
-0.3746334612,
0.0707494095,
-0.0132498881,
-0.2535100281,
-0.437169224,
0.3914553523,
0.1543811709,
0.0303115938,
-0.2512519062,
0.2437225729,
0.2699261308,
-0.0282700472,
-0.2636247277,
-0.3727348149,
0.3942664266,
0.2214663774,
-0.2602077127,
-0.9331117272,
0.2452879548,
-0.0350426547,
-0.168202281,
0.6425039768,
0.7199500203,
-0.4340448976,
-0.2637302577,
-0.6177424192,
-0.5691176057,
-0.4499557614,
0.6307761669,
-0.3708931804,
-0.8943911195,
0.3716487885,
-0.4273176491,
0.0539922751,
0.2320970446,
0.1782325804,
-0.0564453229,
0.9946185946,
1.40442276,
-0.1352112591,
0.9453650713,
-0.199301213,
0.2726823986,
-0.5343587995,
-0.0234029926,
-0.4215587974,
-0.2495354116,
-0.3558304012,
-0.2300485671,
0.0918020681,
0.6740422845,
0.0558864437,
0.1283745468,
-0.3988972902,
0.489144057,
0.5847887993,
0.1165028736,
0.2120205611,
-0.0189410355,
0.2605064809,
-0.1991764754,
-0.8423867226,
-0.2008901536,
0.9941370487,
0.2184261531,
0.8481276035,
-0.2615037262,
0.676898241,
0.3938771188,
0.1895818859,
-0.7050463557,
0.2407609224,
-0.2977269888,
-0.2315870821,
-0.2983832359,
-0.3838496208,
-1.0527330637,
-0.1238934174,
-0.186686188,
-0.5337405801,
0.3616841137,
0.5403904915,
-0.6505410671,
0.0322368704,
-0.7421298027,
0.8702665567,
0.168894738,
-0.1994241625,
-0.283229351,
-0.6668921709,
-0.000044407,
-0.2331905216,
0.3594203889,
-0.1166610494,
-0.1713722944,
0.7742239833,
-0.3017974496,
0.9061657786,
-0.4281371236,
-0.0591626652,
-0.1418239772,
0.3214021325,
0.7097952366,
-0.2389648557,
0.0028842469,
0.0640443712,
-0.0204667989,
-0.3863405287,
-0.8945716619,
0.7130277157,
-0.5834252834,
-0.5489346981,
0.2124569416,
-0.8720297217,
-0.4521360695,
0.3682647943,
0.2295305282,
0.4574426115,
0.0738048777,
0.1948693991,
0.9271242619,
0.1050399989,
0.2652956247,
0.4971727431,
0.200819999,
-0.0478594713,
0.7981975079,
0.2248753905,
0.2743886113,
0.3198913336,
0.110007152,
0.0211119279,
-1.0961782932,
-0.3388880491,
0.2285078764,
-0.6402416229,
-0.0212501101,
-0.2049022764,
-0.1415898055,
-0.4164673984,
-0.1261921078,
-0.5385988951,
-0.2040035725,
-0.5919923782,
-0.0511889271,
0.1762540191,
0.8904918432,
0.0048816302,
0.4024249315,
-0.9101012349,
-0.0098852608,
0.0103681479,
0.5472125411,
-0.3711276352,
-0.8345060349,
-0.6285047531,
0.0075064241,
-0.0906350836,
-0.7071366906,
0.1444462538,
0.7423798442,
0.6832056642,
0.6001710892,
0.1020859554,
1.0066090822,
-0.5854611397,
0.5033803582,
0.2490983307,
-0.9435839653,
0.7222491503,
-0.4192601442,
0.122033231,
0.7156718969,
0.3628734946,
-0.57345891,
-0.1767428517,
-0.1863460094,
-0.6327363253,
0.8639854193,
-0.191634208,
0.051746659,
0.3639153242,
0.7931629419,
0.3785529435,
0.3002829552,
-0.4912441373,
-0.2191900909,
0.2640841305,
-0.4227953553,
-0.1449525654,
-0.0522990264,
-0.1323214173,
-0.2660156488,
0.5223237276,
-0.1672944427,
-0.1983545572,
0.1303305328,
-0.3488246202,
-0.1972084045,
0.0443581194,
0.6719400883,
0.7164983153,
-0.0455110744,
-0.0065257936,
0.0988859236,
-0.4770438969,
-0.1777319163,
0.1220444515,
-0.4143458307,
-0.0426512919,
0.2542860508,
1.087094903,
0.1706125736,
-0.3963961899,
0.4751596451,
0.0568599291,
-0.374481231,
0.2495339215,
0.2141121626,
-0.3439597487,
0.1705285162,
0.3087786138,
0.509346664,
0.5281184316,
-0.2643554807,
0.1403215826,
0.386582911,
-0.7664731145,
-0.4347963929,
0.4643708766,
0.2422960848,
-0.2249363214,
0.1604771465,
0.2289405614,
0.0137070762,
0.3052486479,
0.2721519768,
0.8673475385,
-0.4421075583,
0.0099729169,
0.2128530145,
0.3197465241,
-0.3417539001,
0.1176346019,
-0.2137657851,
-0.309070617,
-0.6822924614,
-0.4787524045,
0.0099939546,
0.2327522337,
-0.9056414962,
0.2705189586,
-0.62223351,
-0.1390235573,
-0.2158598006,
-0.2396549433,
-0.6956560016,
0.3538754582,
0.1478842497,
0.7169799209,
-0.7910241485,
0.8236368895,
0.685336113,
-0.152093038,
-0.8664311171,
0.1732085496,
-0.3596593142,
-0.5646474361,
0.7933047414,
0.1000831574,
-0.2158900499,
0.2353837639,
-0.5009518862,
-1.2147305012,
0.7576540112,
0.9363408089,
-0.8044139743,
-0.2760017514,
-0.0601257645,
0.3117926419,
-0.3101114929,
-0.0829957128,
0.5678995848,
0.3754617572,
-0.2287231833,
-1.2486479282,
0.0366957635,
0.0467606187,
0.3055389524,
0.4333413839,
-0.5165435672,
0.8035460711,
-0.1921987832,
-0.3408070505,
-0.1554622501,
0.3146700263,
-0.4323073328,
0.1248113737,
0.3776403666,
0.4716531634,
0.7767074108,
-0.0792988762,
0.9771507978,
-0.5093856454,
0.3768813908,
1.0277152061,
0.1683528572,
0.7349125147,
0.6652166843,
0.0371096805,
0.0728070438,
0.9768676162,
0.3210272789,
0.8469880819,
0.4101375639,
0.0909800678,
-0.4178863764,
-0.3368784189,
-0.3548964262,
0.2320356667,
0.099343963,
-0.3707679212,
-0.210604161,
0.1853779256,
-0.0339592136,
0.0614403524,
-0.6955376267,
0.8879749775,
-0.0663835704,
-0.7303515673,
1.045024395,
-0.1653443426,
0.6141198874,
-0.5717083812,
-0.1872097999,
-0.2517401278,
0.33035326,
-0.3497517705,
-0.16961357,
0.308875829,
-0.3526005745,
-0.434685111,
-0.4078750908,
0.7078296542,
-0.6994481683,
-0.1775248498,
0.2896222174,
0.5062691569,
0.2669092715,
-0.164252013,
-0.5735560656,
0.1302615553,
0.1466609538,
-0.2239154577,
0.5011381507,
0.144325152,
-0.132148847,
0.6767315269,
0.6472789645,
0.3491214216,
0.3603263199,
0.2681886852,
0.962868154,
-0.4748868346,
-0.4529133737,
-0.7656336427,
0.2394521832,
0.1726934463,
-0.2860639989,
0.654104352,
0.456718564,
1.0505700111,
-0.3372962773,
0.7835594416,
0.335686177,
0.6249392629,
-0.7490219474,
0.6554519534,
-0.7770467401,
0.1257080883,
-0.1377288997,
-0.9426012039,
-0.4677515626,
0.4189215899,
-0.347864151,
0.1641165018,
0.5546439886,
0.8916296959,
-0.2455301285,
-0.436295867,
0.5137012601,
-0.0132055497,
-0.0057788207,
0.6139637232,
0.5640669465,
-0.4914849102,
0.6364315152,
-0.1117943153,
-0.3144018352,
-0.402266413,
-0.6995758414,
-0.8474170566,
-0.6004636288,
-0.5621689558,
0.0860841647,
0.594733417,
0.6353061199,
1.3175030947,
-0.7209814787,
-0.2704559863,
-0.3153751493,
-0.1851129532,
-0.1985732019,
-0.1342795044,
0.3084263802,
-0.6207088828,
-0.7051151395,
0.3852785826,
0.2659260035,
-0.0005415641,
0.0436035022,
-0.1108015105,
-0.0001830967,
-0.0580099449,
0.2090316266,
0.1625984609,
-0.6678555608,
-0.3152839243,
-0.1639984399,
0.1080057621,
0.0830252618,
1.0057768822,
-0.4596719444,
0.4180257022,
0.2490491569,
1.0130040646,
0.4651625752,
0.087404184,
0.7573051453,
-0.8924130797,
0.2791863978,
0.1360122114,
-0.0442673452,
0.2345713079,
-0.5722344518,
0.4349517822,
0.3389505446,
-0.3794337511,
-0.8837003708,
0.3544680178,
-0.7704812884,
-0.1186695173,
1.0056180954,
-0.2113611847,
-0.3218463063,
-0.2103841752,
-0.2694995105,
0.4614925385,
-0.3600776494,
0.6199862957,
0.6246455312,
-0.1208501309,
-0.3280310035,
-0.5685802698,
1.0934925079,
0.6349397898,
-0.8933492899,
0.2171190232,
0.5551655889,
0.5980111361,
-0.0327394456,
0.5623689294,
0.3676590025,
0.340512991,
-0.3863244057,
0.3078844249,
-0.1326572597,
-0.5074596405,
-0.6147723794,
-0.101020515,
0.3481520414,
-0.4717244208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13997v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13997v1 | "Global is Good, Local is Bad?": Understanding Brand Bias in LLMs | 2024-06-20T04:52:19 | 2024-06-20T04:52:19 | Mahammed Kamruzzaman, Hieu Minh Nguyen, Gene Louis Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CE | Many recent studies have investigated social biases in LLMs but brand bias
has received little attention. This research examines the biases exhibited by
LLMs towards different brands, a significant concern given the widespread use
of LLMs in affected use cases such as product recommendation and market
analysis. Biased models may perpetuate societal inequalities, unfairly favoring
established global brands while marginalizing local ones. Using a curated
dataset across four brand categories, we probe the behavior of LLMs in this
space. We find a consistent pattern of bias in this space -- both in terms of
disproportionately associating global brands with positive attributes and
disproportionately recommending luxury gifts for individuals in high-income
countries. We also find LLMs are subject to country-of-origin effects which may
boost local brand preference in LLM outputs in specific contexts. | [
-0.2830941975,
-0.6345657706,
0.2815428972,
-0.0508981906,
-0.2273449749,
0.3760715425,
0.0048394203,
-0.8195022941,
0.6734740734,
0.5380353332,
-0.5735200644,
-0.3879852295,
-0.6874107718,
-0.0512302667,
0.2254936546,
1.1707845926,
-0.2560574114,
0.5884743929,
-0.4893395007,
-0.5226966143,
-0.3338387609,
-0.7884858847,
-0.4962646067,
-0.578496635,
0.5257392526,
0.4503539801,
0.8147328496,
-0.1294444799,
0.5512462854,
0.2033647895,
-0.1490864009,
0.1984689832,
-0.9037162662,
0.3040854335,
-0.1554166228,
-0.5894421339,
-0.5407290459,
0.092832543,
0.1175243706,
0.4168637097,
0.2528423667,
0.7396634817,
0.1899412572,
0.5292184353,
-0.6360707283,
-0.152075693,
-0.5946128368,
-0.1253582984,
-0.3701345325,
0.0335749798,
-0.0048576077,
-0.6785991192,
0.1466221064,
-0.5240837932,
0.4041181207,
0.145486936,
0.9616221189,
0.0525826775,
-0.7399578691,
-0.6212604046,
-0.808414042,
1.053948164,
-0.3594244421,
0.1494474858,
0.4378993213,
0.1722334623,
-0.2062579244,
-0.171084553,
-0.005553198,
0.1389358789,
-0.0747234523,
0.1534417719,
-0.1558032036,
-0.3918341696,
-0.1358209699,
0.4518726766,
-0.1807721108,
0.0736938417,
-0.469042927,
-0.099762328,
0.6540212035,
-0.1370332986,
0.6243565679,
-0.0992296785,
-0.6872287393,
0.6885408163,
-1.4523851871,
0.2556894422,
0.492472291,
0.2598260343,
-0.1351167858,
0.3128475249,
-0.2183159888,
0.4000269473,
-0.0388261527,
0.0604260713,
0.1682352722,
-0.3988910913,
-0.1991510838,
0.3973310888,
0.2334648222,
1.0144603252,
0.7313398719,
-0.0289600044,
-0.1757656783,
-0.0192043707,
0.0623900183,
-0.6460546851,
0.4741846323,
-0.1286380589,
-0.6121339798,
-0.3195509613,
0.1533744037,
-0.3172318935,
-0.6429939866,
-0.3018064797,
0.337428242,
0.8613951802,
-0.1236068681,
0.1995680034,
-0.1760849059,
0.1559862196,
-0.2601916492,
-0.7067523003,
0.2135723829,
0.4041233659,
0.6976554394,
-0.4002602696,
0.3092823327,
-0.255921483,
0.2408538163,
-0.2772855759,
0.9409344792,
-0.4188781083,
-0.7198358178,
0.0866700783,
0.3120093644,
0.5265445709,
-1.2674269676,
0.6723651886,
-0.6774168015,
-0.1812553853,
-1.1995053291,
-0.0670642704,
0.2461364418,
0.0816979632,
-0.3695251346,
0.7946745157,
-0.0270181671,
-0.6413286924,
1.0750225782,
-0.1954039037,
-0.4604917467,
-0.0997902676,
-0.0573162846,
-0.2853004932,
0.4165082276,
0.4113991559,
0.5846591592,
-0.3287296593,
0.2622335553,
-0.9070448279,
-0.7018218637,
0.2794188261,
-0.2705933452,
0.6444936991,
0.3572566211,
-0.2632883489,
-0.1494839936,
-0.3124472201,
-0.7267152667,
0.2978301048,
-0.185773477,
-0.9192937016,
-0.0344560444,
-0.2054981291,
0.3650965095,
0.3501896858,
-0.5500996709,
0.4122354984,
-0.1321446449,
0.4331425428,
1.1445819139,
0.3740668893,
0.678658843,
-0.5403804779,
0.4866444767,
0.0931450203,
0.5102468729,
0.4597063959,
-0.2714155018,
-0.8085026741,
0.1492680907,
-0.1921132654,
0.0300782956,
-0.5025842786,
-0.2178340107,
-0.1416710019,
-0.1430739015,
-0.1319122314,
0.194848761,
0.0868218839,
0.1425060779,
-0.0244529881,
-0.3419843614,
-0.1956819445,
-1.3248466253,
-0.7179604173,
0.4002869725,
-0.150568381,
0.5791991353,
0.3616946936,
-0.2574065626,
0.9545702934,
-0.5407195687,
-0.651355803,
-0.0758306459,
-0.310554266,
0.4661805928,
0.0005447533,
0.4210335314,
-0.419549346,
-0.3769218028,
-0.1544484198,
-0.4802539051,
-0.3819718659,
0.0587499999,
-0.2290779501,
0.1289960444,
0.275946945,
-0.2149580419,
0.2195226848,
0.4260252714,
-0.600045383,
0.4779386818,
0.0741514936,
0.1274138987,
-1.008654356,
-0.4661147296,
0.6842159033,
0.1896689087,
-0.2083891332,
-0.2129283249,
-0.3136412799,
0.4878344238,
-0.7133499384,
0.8665318489,
-0.4917884171,
-0.3547215462,
0.0102622416,
-0.0686810985,
0.3957776129,
-0.0675408244,
-0.0916944072,
0.7918383479,
0.3840340376,
-0.7334013581,
0.1427466273,
-0.0939041451,
-0.728790462,
0.8947829604,
-0.6000813842,
-0.0861075521,
-0.1445119679,
0.5202386975,
-0.8180699348,
-0.0812260434,
0.3036944568,
-0.2050604969,
0.0790004954,
-0.1894043386,
-0.4324128032,
-0.4111308455,
-0.198737964,
0.615342319,
0.3439858854,
-0.8637139201,
0.1261160076,
0.5622190833,
-0.0195709821,
-0.5422919393,
-0.7769821882,
-0.1396274716,
-0.6475655437,
-0.7111255527,
0.233320713,
-0.0132657085,
-0.9932281971,
-0.4545127749,
-0.6494066715,
0.2391756475,
-0.0745208338,
0.2648228407,
0.0177391246,
-0.03364297,
-0.181623593,
-0.2090429813,
0.0118459184,
0.2547209859,
-0.20782502,
0.144389376,
-0.1210705712,
-0.2550928891,
-0.0177286677,
0.1073578149,
0.3265976608,
0.1578034461,
0.162393555,
0.3146847785,
-0.230160296,
-0.4835423529,
-0.5782635808,
-0.3165266514,
-0.5942112207,
-0.0037423361,
-0.2139627934,
-0.7609598041,
0.6425954103,
0.1330264956,
-0.2271588594,
0.123133406,
0.7189671397,
-0.272369504,
0.7883289456,
0.5098871589,
-0.5219560862,
0.147660166,
-0.4114665389,
0.4850079715,
-0.5446124077,
-0.2061374336,
-0.3602909148,
-0.7789998055,
-0.6051478386,
-0.3768676519,
0.2060566843,
0.1465790272,
-0.4550856054,
-0.2411048263,
-0.6100626588,
1.0453480482,
0.6050843,
-0.0331115201,
0.3089667559,
0.2576330602,
-0.2274964452,
-0.2816003263,
-0.5750407577,
-0.6086914539,
0.8791680932,
0.2578199208,
1.2301924229,
0.0101355864,
0.2938852906,
0.4930430353,
0.6164639592,
-0.6196894646,
0.2103623897,
-0.2619507611,
-0.7932241559,
0.4988887608,
0.1186652929,
-1.1343295574,
-0.0039812122,
0.1234383062,
-0.8497815132,
0.5569070578,
0.234141767,
-0.3117418289,
0.609333992,
-0.5609661937,
0.4621216655,
-0.4816816747,
-0.9689389467,
0.2041244954,
-0.2888632417,
0.5831236839,
0.1991242468,
0.5942411423,
-0.6519833207,
0.3082747161,
0.5855545402,
0.1335599869,
0.9014334679,
-0.1449773163,
-0.5133930445,
0.2460087836,
0.1172769442,
0.4438881278,
0.2866134942,
-0.1191375628,
0.5815506577,
-0.343413204,
-0.6640769243,
-0.2876121402,
1.1214997768,
-0.8297573924,
-0.4452672005,
-0.5024846196,
-0.2303937823,
-0.401909411,
-0.0691993386,
0.4861443639,
0.3970800042,
-0.4595808983,
-0.1780868918,
0.6141646504,
-0.514847219,
0.1891056597,
0.313301146,
-0.1691973358,
-0.2459965348,
1.0044920444,
0.3680619895,
0.5318316817,
0.1240618899,
0.3254630268,
-0.4272657335,
-0.0930564031,
-0.2227279246,
0.1174587607,
-0.928059876,
-0.023294514,
0.1635998785,
0.2383798957,
-0.2571175694,
-0.6047334671,
-0.134427622,
-0.1666424274,
-0.2043318152,
-0.3223226666,
0.0174886659,
1.2975959778,
0.1591342241,
0.3211729825,
-0.2177872956,
0.2932572365,
0.3327540457,
0.4679085016,
-0.2544300258,
-0.3652091324,
-0.3423626125,
-0.1404218525,
-0.5194718242,
-0.4363396466,
0.1423432678,
-0.4386399388,
0.6223976612,
0.9118659496,
0.0898459107,
0.147898823,
-0.1139577106,
1.1728718281,
0.0190233942,
-0.4964573383,
0.1226339713,
-0.7241761088,
0.6349766254,
0.3249803782,
0.5465930104,
-0.6718778014,
-0.6273038387,
-0.5886685252,
-0.9409606457,
0.2838949859,
-0.2332080901,
0.5031128526,
-0.2059062272,
0.2717564404,
0.2832012475,
0.4123592079,
-1.1299397945,
-0.8717922568,
0.0694951713,
0.4814120829,
-0.3471727073,
-0.6211836934,
-0.2121431231,
-0.1503946334,
0.6958263516,
0.162782222,
0.2819818556,
0.0859110057,
-0.0806696936,
-0.2210379839,
0.2529923916,
0.6951925755,
0.8237115145,
-0.5097235441,
0.1999898255,
0.2518856823,
-0.1008617505,
0.3150562346,
-0.6293409467,
-0.2812010646,
-0.0199486166,
-0.1723818928,
0.4637626112,
0.1355442554,
-0.001988559,
0.2671424448,
-0.0278853476,
-0.1394766271,
-0.0984548405,
-0.175590232,
0.2636058629,
-0.04455759,
0.4237877727,
0.2222067714,
0.1721012741,
-0.5674706697,
-0.0135570429,
0.835352242,
-0.5212455392,
-0.2649409473,
0.676458478,
0.7469147444,
-0.1924221665,
0.2258321047,
-0.0912150294,
-0.3642756939,
0.6979030967,
0.4984793961,
0.7572592497,
0.0326348022,
0.2107109874,
0.3186919093,
0.4365912676,
0.2808710337,
0.1335755885,
-0.0633505732,
-1.2234759331,
-0.076326862,
-0.7063550949,
-0.4404441714,
0.1367497295,
-0.5514621735,
0.3243590891,
-0.284213841,
-0.4953255951,
-0.4440384805,
-0.0122656617,
-0.8825747371,
0.1722223163,
0.3707937002,
0.5608003139,
-0.9235919714,
0.7862962484,
0.3829540014,
-0.1876617074,
-0.274210006,
0.109719567,
0.3177063465,
-1.0953809023,
0.9542375207,
0.3271512985,
-0.3038128316,
-0.6519480944,
-0.3110311925,
-1.0775694847,
0.7986660004,
0.1681410819,
-0.4057355225,
0.1074792668,
0.4159666002,
0.0426613055,
-0.2477830797,
0.174511686,
0.8025034666,
0.4484045506,
-0.0270068534,
-0.5522242785,
-0.1363982409,
-0.0799031407,
0.000420574,
0.0428257659,
-1.0475567579,
0.2810986638,
-0.2286596596,
0.0560753755,
-0.322817862,
0.0162571315,
0.3289861083,
0.4289883077,
0.098687917,
0.2857275903,
0.6190601587,
-0.2093418986,
0.9976557493,
-0.2179111689,
0.1732369363,
1.0178720951,
-0.5544549227,
0.4115528166,
0.606384635,
-0.1158439964,
0.3984864354,
1.1211035252,
-0.1465449631,
0.5799558759,
0.892549634,
-0.4201512337,
0.0133291446,
-0.3276810348,
-0.4986189306,
0.2347056419,
0.2575749457,
-0.2941399217,
-0.3370917737,
-0.3018339872,
0.1853659302,
-0.2734929621,
-0.5526514649,
0.3968396187,
0.4211701751,
-0.4228456318,
0.4613932669,
-0.119558081,
1.2673506737,
-0.6537238359,
0.552788496,
-0.651815474,
0.3851628602,
-0.4608901143,
-0.3991317749,
0.3599390388,
-0.2543248534,
-0.29749915,
-0.5813880563,
1.0185478926,
0.0404902846,
-0.5837717652,
0.3689108193,
0.5576108098,
0.0898056403,
0.0281294696,
-0.727743566,
0.1541976035,
-0.0254645012,
-0.5081022382,
0.3970958889,
-0.0522870831,
-0.1218195558,
0.7484217286,
0.4260511994,
0.1881170124,
0.0527615882,
0.286382705,
0.1174502,
-0.4700109065,
-0.1698190719,
-0.8964041471,
0.4079427123,
-0.1659454256,
-0.5709102154,
1.3827326298,
0.6086989641,
1.231464386,
0.0879498869,
0.8251330256,
0.6584882736,
-0.015108766,
-0.2124212384,
0.8795391321,
-0.6831943989,
0.5874262452,
-0.1957472265,
-1.0572214127,
-0.3176828325,
0.5362941027,
-0.6931275129,
0.2409994155,
0.2779296935,
0.8198140264,
-0.0421754457,
0.0231304094,
0.1150648594,
0.1523511261,
0.189770788,
0.1287840754,
1.173619628,
0.1144663468,
0.1277074963,
-0.0403525569,
0.171686843,
-0.1391573101,
-0.963049531,
-0.5635130405,
0.0513353944,
-0.315687269,
-0.4809948802,
0.1429269761,
0.9864139557,
0.7561753392,
-0.7221579552,
-0.5457748771,
0.2773635089,
0.6709794998,
0.1285990179,
-0.3019299805,
-0.0349032246,
-0.3409869671,
-0.6822106242,
0.1010560542,
0.313057363,
0.1396336257,
-0.3798212409,
-0.0083932551,
0.3384150863,
0.4045911431,
0.7701035142,
-0.2603623271,
-0.9300527573,
-0.0142377205,
-0.1170172915,
-0.0724780336,
0.4402245283,
0.9375563264,
-0.5937085152,
0.36625579,
0.1281793714,
0.038464196,
0.3474118114,
-0.1921877414,
0.8075814247,
-0.7518050075,
-0.3328321576,
-0.0466834642,
0.567044735,
0.4183206558,
-0.3778403401,
0.2191453427,
0.3898875713,
-0.9694150686,
-0.6557250619,
0.4428677559,
-0.5772072673,
-0.4557156861,
1.6515774727,
0.4315557778,
0.018925434,
-0.09397313,
-0.2885240018,
-0.1795365661,
-0.4861707091,
0.8025507927,
0.8306352496,
-0.0992440134,
0.7805162072,
-0.8030384779,
0.5801948309,
0.196739465,
-0.379265666,
-0.0742917508,
0.4731348157,
0.8501966,
-0.1408281475,
0.7747113705,
0.0561222322,
-0.1655739695,
-0.4996352196,
0.008501864,
0.3798983395,
-0.1159186512,
-0.2996838987,
0.0077120359,
0.3014399111,
-0.0843074843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13993v1 | Exploring Changes in Nation Perception with Nationality-Assigned Personas in LLMs | 2024-06-20T04:44:20 | 2024-06-20T04:44:20 | Mahammed Kamruzzaman, Gene Louis Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Persona assignment has become a common strategy for customizing LLM use to
particular tasks and contexts. In this study, we explore how perceptions of
different nations change when LLMs are assigned specific nationality personas.
We assign 193 different nationality personas (e.g., an American person) to four
LLMs and examine how the LLM perceptions of countries change. We find that all
LLM-persona combinations tend to favor Western European nations, though
nation-personas push LLM behaviors to focus more on and view more favorably the
nation-persona's own region. Eastern European, Latin American, and African
nations are viewed more negatively by different nationality personas. Our study
provides insight into how biases and stereotypes are realized within LLMs when
adopting different national personas. In line with the "Blueprint for an AI
Bill of Rights", our findings underscore the critical need for developing
mechanisms to ensure LLMs uphold fairness and not over-generalize at a global
scale. | [
-0.5713123679,
0.0139432726,
0.7864720225,
0.3972837925,
-0.2281722724,
0.492416352,
0.0594907068,
-0.6437447667,
0.4996868372,
0.7716668248,
-0.3834337294,
-0.3472085893,
-0.6102856994,
0.372603178,
0.1561989039,
1.004024148,
-0.1866764873,
0.1904928386,
-0.4623506963,
-0.3420560062,
-0.4342645109,
-0.7678499818,
-0.3034864366,
-0.7656648159,
0.796274662,
0.4398013651,
0.3183667362,
0.0510070063,
0.6684222817,
0.2845079005,
0.1277184635,
-0.1683667153,
-0.4239171445,
-0.0743912607,
-0.5621082783,
-0.9903354049,
-0.5283803344,
0.3464665711,
0.4375396967,
0.4720192552,
0.243663609,
0.4847677946,
0.0421838239,
0.6011609435,
-0.5793293715,
0.3859034777,
-0.6667194963,
0.1021681726,
-0.2154506743,
-0.304643482,
-0.3063331246,
-0.3247320354,
0.3523332179,
-0.382288605,
0.1440221518,
0.2352023721,
0.4478820264,
0.099188976,
-0.9381725788,
-0.0297445077,
-0.808863759,
0.8686906099,
-0.0972284228,
0.2263674587,
0.0342889726,
0.3935472071,
-0.1255725175,
-0.2417832166,
-0.1709767729,
-0.0064444761,
-0.1717584431,
0.4307156205,
0.0259021912,
-0.0283102989,
0.3243667185,
0.2216662169,
-0.1855237633,
0.1976549327,
-0.241687268,
-0.4537904859,
0.8488945961,
0.2681863606,
0.5904582739,
-0.203082189,
-0.5024706721,
0.4204486609,
-0.9394344687,
0.2345962822,
0.6382391453,
0.2838217914,
-0.350676775,
0.4712469876,
-0.37447685,
0.6017136574,
0.3723777533,
-0.2001916021,
0.2053300738,
0.2674050629,
-0.0279965419,
0.2493142337,
0.3146102428,
0.8395966291,
0.5208607316,
-0.1836882532,
-0.1883470714,
-0.1252557784,
0.3609466553,
-0.6245322227,
0.1799989343,
0.0338247679,
-0.769519031,
-0.0672255605,
0.2268849462,
-0.6513774991,
-0.8949772716,
-0.7681025863,
0.2320804894,
-0.1102968678,
-0.0658019409,
-0.1380783916,
-0.1769161969,
0.5938462615,
0.4658617079,
-1.149106741,
0.1556980163,
0.6929100752,
0.5817250609,
-0.6164642572,
-0.2391367257,
-0.1184940487,
-0.0125637334,
-0.3621098697,
0.8222427368,
-0.5334943533,
-0.5087985992,
-0.018762337,
-0.008566766,
-0.3531410694,
-0.7921028137,
-0.1921221018,
-0.6094092131,
0.1915728301,
-1.0600237846,
-0.1875460893,
0.292407155,
0.5229133964,
-0.278898567,
0.25886935,
0.149588123,
-0.6674486995,
0.6218953729,
-0.7609829307,
-0.0087173367,
0.1379161775,
-0.4377406836,
0.1361435056,
0.4183063805,
-0.0625090301,
0.3963554502,
-0.162981987,
-0.1669307947,
-0.2281449288,
-0.6046446562,
0.7280765176,
0.0665536821,
1.2222355604,
0.1888293177,
-0.1444835514,
-0.0573729239,
-0.2760517299,
-0.4309352636,
0.04379379,
-0.5715457797,
-0.4179126918,
-0.1788735986,
-0.3041324615,
0.3438740373,
0.5731404424,
-0.8850197792,
0.2930262387,
-0.277954787,
0.1974071562,
0.9854753017,
0.4020046592,
0.6327773333,
-0.5986028314,
0.7114297152,
0.1178917363,
0.3082338274,
0.2661222219,
-0.476973772,
-0.9676478505,
-0.0199155901,
0.04700993,
0.7184445858,
-0.5795829296,
0.00138885,
-0.3331089318,
-0.0933565944,
-0.4705157578,
-0.0660525486,
0.1724726409,
0.3545984626,
0.0964599177,
-0.4404816926,
-0.4062259495,
-1.2488111258,
-0.6525386572,
-0.6335468888,
-0.1455213875,
0.4538131356,
0.6568012834,
-0.1169418618,
1.0355806351,
-0.3660871685,
-0.3331394494,
-0.2905908525,
-0.2168392092,
-0.2779679894,
0.236789614,
0.7019462585,
-0.8174348474,
-0.7297564745,
-0.2141734809,
-0.4877153337,
-0.1296053082,
-0.3412231207,
-0.2982672155,
0.3101007044,
0.4922175109,
0.0055774362,
0.307672292,
0.3961888552,
-0.5215291381,
0.6359677911,
-0.0382927693,
0.4510478675,
-1.112062335,
-0.1335549355,
0.1736890227,
0.0391575433,
-0.4397638142,
0.1761707664,
0.0447386652,
0.3528949022,
-0.7337470055,
0.8300381899,
-0.3342019618,
-0.4400318265,
0.1025900543,
-0.1115674451,
0.0448501371,
0.3300670385,
-0.0822887719,
0.8252735734,
0.5291222334,
-0.5315148234,
0.3890357316,
0.5437287688,
-0.5719291568,
1.4865064621,
-0.1289623082,
0.3922180533,
-0.5989624262,
0.4365178645,
-0.8580286503,
-0.1980796754,
0.379442364,
-0.2215700448,
0.0349132381,
-0.2564745247,
-0.3306179345,
-0.1675479859,
-0.0241621509,
0.1735536605,
0.4588441551,
-0.6302330494,
0.6806347966,
0.4567034543,
-0.1356923431,
-0.4443852901,
-0.9766577482,
0.4677004516,
-0.8304306269,
-0.2569260299,
0.7781386375,
-0.1533510983,
-0.9152001143,
-0.4204135537,
-0.0167845748,
0.1252474636,
0.0155541124,
0.401470691,
0.041456867,
0.3225381374,
-0.2081333846,
-0.2008469701,
-0.2937586308,
0.2389605492,
-0.0919064805,
0.5161685348,
-0.0000298531,
-0.444699049,
-0.4327771366,
0.2474486977,
0.6570641994,
-0.5602878332,
0.5761895776,
0.203426823,
-0.0836211517,
-0.0647860244,
-0.578351438,
-0.1063895226,
-0.4829918146,
0.1059838384,
-0.4128396809,
-0.6292636395,
0.9392838478,
-0.1129917726,
0.3965545297,
0.1278168708,
0.6981726885,
-0.3054287434,
0.6751597524,
0.7746996284,
-0.2365465313,
0.4142696261,
-0.2224840522,
0.1939318627,
-1.1418817043,
-0.843727529,
-0.5429716706,
-1.0005341768,
-0.9690185189,
-0.204899326,
0.3341931999,
-0.6606870294,
-0.3216306269,
-0.0704386681,
-0.1737557203,
0.5865790844,
0.4323039949,
0.09020634,
0.29556337,
0.0767846778,
-0.2389214486,
-0.4377054572,
-0.1411695629,
-0.7053887844,
1.102255702,
-0.0082097882,
0.7774944901,
0.4475260079,
1.1455159187,
0.4526049197,
0.5975313783,
-0.7752479911,
0.861076057,
-0.2901993394,
-0.5952563882,
0.1168535203,
-0.0802418888,
-1.0806821585,
0.3242541552,
0.0567115098,
-1.0534735918,
0.4735845327,
0.1543779373,
-0.44279778,
0.2890786827,
-0.1575990319,
0.4956807792,
-0.2996588945,
-0.0555580445,
-0.1165101379,
-0.4919674098,
0.3405150771,
0.0149589973,
-0.2355304658,
-0.4551468194,
-0.2533331215,
0.5551977158,
0.0970784575,
0.7972048521,
-0.4970859289,
-0.3277933896,
0.1252051592,
0.0832904726,
0.0763668567,
0.168320179,
-0.5663504004,
0.1294144243,
-0.3300354779,
-0.413118124,
-0.3816757202,
0.8985762596,
-1.0261785984,
-0.8547836542,
-0.4368791878,
-0.7330735326,
-0.3183422089,
-0.117698051,
0.5139427185,
0.3167796433,
-0.5411758423,
-0.0401625372,
0.6951095462,
-0.5091969967,
0.2492313385,
0.5735325813,
-0.2777486145,
0.0921950638,
0.7546879649,
0.4520283043,
0.3184232116,
0.412133038,
-0.196763739,
-0.4227735102,
-0.2035565227,
-0.3157802522,
0.0703065619,
-0.6253670454,
0.1852695495,
-0.495459944,
0.0827806965,
-0.3390370905,
-0.3331931531,
-0.0664461404,
-0.3193415105,
-0.1589390188,
0.0690012351,
0.0352221169,
0.4325952232,
0.1832626313,
0.4842099845,
0.0380865298,
0.5856850743,
0.6824535728,
0.4015474319,
-0.6058151126,
-0.7707913518,
0.0625857636,
-0.2441211343,
-0.2626072168,
-0.8943300843,
0.0965869501,
-0.0337177329,
0.8205397129,
0.3327399492,
0.2115563005,
0.536645472,
-0.3835127056,
0.8567423224,
-0.174086675,
-0.5918499827,
0.2695416808,
-0.4357324243,
0.6104598045,
0.5003431439,
0.1551380903,
-0.9356464744,
-0.7282912731,
-0.4815051556,
-0.413328737,
0.6954827309,
-0.2735167444,
0.764536202,
0.1679340005,
0.6224759221,
0.1185786799,
0.2826839089,
-0.7424679399,
-0.7923853397,
0.0645260811,
0.0881492272,
-0.1202057004,
-0.2950519621,
-0.3291543424,
0.0925629586,
0.3829951882,
-0.0800522864,
0.6624850035,
0.1193361431,
-0.186387673,
-0.1123258993,
0.4784040749,
0.2819188535,
1.0753375292,
-0.0617484972,
0.0484888032,
0.031188719,
-0.1157580093,
0.5154755712,
-0.1961777359,
-0.5968664885,
-0.071614407,
0.0542543121,
0.763029933,
-0.0505324639,
-0.0599599853,
0.239148587,
-0.1308104843,
-0.4218498468,
-0.3375053108,
0.4464192092,
0.1146948934,
0.2174664289,
0.4578323066,
0.0537227318,
-0.0274008643,
-0.8564602733,
-0.0975059569,
0.6463598609,
-0.1930372864,
-0.3998836577,
0.7449171543,
0.4393838346,
-0.5744665861,
0.4931949973,
-0.1522149146,
-0.454766959,
0.8331318498,
0.6277887821,
0.7614570856,
-0.346970886,
0.7475143075,
-0.0309652947,
0.3641752601,
0.2986242771,
0.3684890568,
0.3278369904,
-1.0909579992,
0.0569817759,
-0.4620714188,
-0.6317008734,
0.2276042104,
-0.8038882613,
0.0630322322,
-0.7560843825,
-0.4283698797,
-0.3249515891,
0.4253954291,
-1.1516163349,
0.1669151485,
0.4500384927,
0.5732247829,
-0.9566678405,
0.4285182655,
1.1313126087,
0.1926185042,
-0.1355457306,
0.4329019785,
0.4664191008,
-0.9004068971,
0.4692501426,
0.251778096,
0.3200953007,
0.0218952466,
-0.2156593502,
-0.9004019499,
1.0072023869,
0.7590815425,
-0.3800966144,
0.3055599332,
0.7215229869,
0.4122650027,
-0.8392451406,
-0.215947181,
0.877884686,
0.6791881919,
-0.2716839015,
-0.8618565202,
-0.3673320413,
0.205899626,
0.0127002718,
0.017771719,
-1.4124401808,
0.7742189765,
-0.3390746713,
0.1526790708,
-0.1975313425,
0.3648078442,
0.6586173773,
0.4218082428,
0.6754187942,
0.1015652269,
0.8310286999,
-0.0796275958,
0.7774628401,
-0.222892791,
-0.2845554054,
0.9408498406,
-0.7141960859,
0.2430916131,
0.6587615609,
-0.3078208864,
0.9356125593,
0.7412183285,
-0.0120253125,
0.3266872168,
0.3184411228,
-0.5272900462,
-0.1569576561,
-0.2699159086,
-0.1604834795,
0.834002912,
0.1777557582,
-0.2547293603,
-0.2007902712,
0.1633751988,
-0.1233081818,
0.1640475541,
-0.5523251295,
0.6668499708,
0.2152981162,
-0.8705369234,
-0.224566564,
0.2724192739,
0.6398176551,
-0.2613551915,
0.3082967401,
-0.7398192883,
-0.0644199178,
-0.2833946347,
-0.3616310358,
0.0871862471,
0.1952788234,
-0.3064720333,
-0.7237281799,
0.5324810743,
-0.0667069629,
-0.7145668864,
0.1548046917,
0.7187374234,
0.5445600152,
-0.0133368243,
-0.9140062928,
-0.0588822551,
0.2284915149,
-0.3876715004,
0.8411074281,
0.1494477838,
-0.3409257829,
0.681163013,
0.1298386455,
0.1200645566,
-0.0331919529,
0.1033259332,
0.2387902588,
-0.3415292799,
-0.5428263545,
-0.7618119121,
0.5567103028,
0.0085450187,
-0.2112994194,
0.8794247508,
0.5494013429,
0.9300098419,
-0.0113738002,
0.9035899043,
-0.2596406639,
0.2581499517,
-0.3159439564,
0.7363231182,
-0.4318443835,
0.2097524256,
-0.0394702256,
-1.2399927378,
-0.0434932038,
0.4092371166,
-0.60782969,
0.1288903356,
0.0994903073,
0.5964974165,
0.1551196426,
-0.5009221435,
0.198699981,
-0.0422649048,
0.4322400391,
0.3316780627,
0.8238279819,
0.1997448951,
0.1502087265,
-0.3147179186,
0.0741877928,
-0.1889694333,
-0.8047229648,
-0.6600443721,
-0.4878264666,
-0.6350639462,
-0.0636598915,
-0.1474968344,
0.9639110565,
0.5679544806,
-0.6077066064,
-0.4318007231,
0.5516693592,
0.2815336585,
0.1688994616,
-0.2409054488,
-0.0470500551,
-0.1582375318,
-1.0945938826,
0.1456829906,
0.2723475993,
0.2319938987,
-0.5547469258,
-0.0612922721,
0.2080018818,
0.26343593,
0.558934927,
0.3080250919,
-0.9106116891,
-0.453042537,
-0.0764523074,
-0.1982106268,
0.2986305952,
0.9020937681,
-0.9732087255,
0.4059872031,
0.1829388887,
0.0824525654,
-0.0239135996,
0.4138884842,
0.5693656802,
-0.7344569564,
0.3048274517,
0.096954219,
0.3055484295,
0.4552728832,
-0.4716252983,
0.1854700148,
0.0225282349,
-0.6036568284,
-0.6398525834,
0.3767923713,
-0.56142658,
-0.0939748213,
1.0625163317,
-0.033809226,
0.2129677981,
-0.3034334183,
-0.1467985809,
-0.1483126581,
-0.3894583285,
1.1428488493,
0.6692149043,
-0.6621750593,
0.1729489416,
-0.6962102056,
0.4993287921,
0.3590881526,
-0.9089475274,
-0.1707360595,
0.5658767223,
0.6448469758,
0.0249980949,
1.0177817345,
-0.0660075322,
0.0042092861,
-0.6507271528,
-0.1046408936,
0.2260304391,
-0.6122373939,
-0.2280317247,
-0.0328788869,
0.1019152701,
-0.1116907597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13990v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13990v2 | Inference-Time Decontamination: Reusing Leaked Benchmarks for Large Language Model Evaluation | 2024-06-20T04:35:59 | 2024-06-23T16:46:00 | Qin Zhu, Qingyuan Cheng, Runyu Peng, Xiaonan Li, Tengxiao Liu, Ru Peng, Xipeng Qiu, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The training process of large language models (LLMs) often involves varying
degrees of test data contamination. Although current LLMs are achieving
increasingly better performance on various benchmarks, their performance in
practical applications does not always match their benchmark results. Leakage
of benchmarks can prevent the accurate assessment of LLMs' true performance.
However, constructing new benchmarks is costly, labor-intensive and still
carries the risk of leakage. Therefore, in this paper, we ask the question, Can
we reuse these leaked benchmarks for LLM evaluation? We propose Inference-Time
Decontamination (ITD) to address this issue by detecting and rewriting leaked
samples without altering their difficulties. ITD can mitigate performance
inflation caused by memorizing leaked benchmarks. Our proof-of-concept
experiments demonstrate that ITD reduces inflated accuracy by 22.9% on GSM8K
and 19.0% on MMLU. On MMLU, using Inference-time Decontamination can lead to a
decrease in the results of Phi3 and Mistral by 6.7% and 3.6% respectively. We
hope that ITD can provide more truthful evaluation results for large language
models. | [
-0.1994138062,
-0.6982622147,
0.5413249731,
0.1152696759,
-0.379534632,
0.2095506191,
-0.2854009271,
-0.5587238073,
-0.3839840591,
0.4835300446,
-0.2587855458,
-0.4255200326,
-0.593343854,
-0.2550007105,
-0.5964621305,
0.6290486455,
-0.1612553149,
-0.0542928651,
-0.1319058388,
-0.0683862418,
0.056720078,
-0.4716873765,
-0.6933213472,
-0.2919275165,
0.1228998527,
0.4138987958,
0.2439758778,
0.9848073125,
0.0086645084,
0.3587933481,
-0.2415301055,
-0.0732198805,
-0.5225224495,
-0.0044200546,
-0.2713925242,
-0.6198400855,
-0.2336116582,
0.0625553951,
0.7812408805,
0.5377867818,
-0.3857741356,
0.4238802195,
0.1010671258,
0.7477675676,
-1.1248422861,
0.3491239846,
-0.7278718948,
0.0208652336,
-0.3268474638,
-0.2414410412,
-0.6807958484,
-0.4855633378,
-0.2713657618,
-0.4052106142,
0.3592655957,
-0.0604279675,
0.7552193999,
0.4795843065,
-0.0707003027,
0.2326257229,
-0.8843686581,
0.8721433282,
-1.026165843,
0.3920493722,
0.2565368116,
0.5194177032,
-0.0929830819,
-0.64933604,
-0.4272315502,
-0.183814913,
0.2862720788,
-0.0629167631,
-0.1013818756,
-0.2311733365,
0.4876988232,
0.4630458653,
-0.1935048103,
0.2606142461,
-0.2752611339,
-0.276109606,
0.723495245,
0.1140505075,
0.1612475961,
0.0469752476,
-0.4679253101,
-0.2954302728,
-1.0073239803,
-0.2566275597,
0.5134965777,
0.0412606709,
0.1953736544,
0.3316845298,
-0.2247992605,
0.2320713848,
-0.2462369502,
-0.3010098338,
0.4602537751,
-0.0756128058,
-0.3201828003,
0.1221458688,
0.6407134533,
0.1738280952,
0.3507374227,
-0.2195570022,
-0.1366959214,
0.009075895,
0.2351277024,
-1.0468189716,
-0.2005777955,
0.3557166755,
-0.3310878575,
-0.2864777744,
-0.1846072525,
-0.8560407162,
-0.2867137492,
-0.1304803044,
0.2608755231,
-0.416370362,
-0.5197287798,
0.2733369768,
-0.2246878147,
-0.0864098892,
0.2328500301,
-0.7250856161,
0.2082030028,
0.8935976028,
0.4824807048,
-0.040252056,
-0.466525048,
-0.5407600403,
0.4623300433,
-0.2895289958,
0.8222935796,
-0.4426059127,
-0.4702480137,
0.113224864,
-0.0962181836,
-0.0595852882,
-0.9775083065,
0.9264168143,
-0.4179067016,
0.0219880957,
-0.086972326,
-0.8457391858,
0.0971706435,
0.1744451821,
-0.9004300237,
1.1142352819,
0.0018362006,
-0.8525511026,
0.3039728701,
-0.3730705678,
-0.2800491452,
-0.141775474,
0.108214274,
-0.666511178,
0.0821777284,
0.5663803816,
0.252897203,
-0.3237616718,
0.2163198292,
-0.5287406445,
-0.5965765715,
0.1337044984,
-0.8225908279,
0.9235916138,
0.3127298057,
-0.4786887169,
-0.228966251,
-0.7886019945,
0.2851516902,
0.0175031088,
-0.5656096935,
-0.3503005803,
0.001045283,
-0.1492069662,
0.0431454256,
0.0085394019,
-0.5733010173,
0.0701612979,
-0.3446211517,
0.3984274566,
0.9727635384,
0.1349193603,
0.2557864189,
-0.4209903479,
0.4170804918,
0.0094884615,
0.2165950686,
-0.1036366001,
-0.1061324924,
-0.820982933,
-0.4577911198,
0.3695085943,
0.4106930196,
-0.6391060352,
0.1180614308,
-0.4783076644,
-0.7724245191,
-0.5950878263,
0.1404323578,
0.6403407454,
0.5741698742,
0.3945991695,
0.2311531752,
-0.2215690911,
-0.9324491024,
-0.7552489638,
-0.4008870423,
-0.2173738033,
0.1153501794,
0.4315816164,
0.016304804,
0.5142520666,
-0.3770751953,
-0.0494419672,
-0.049296204,
0.156134367,
-0.1505007297,
0.5540399551,
0.446885407,
-0.4101080298,
-0.1239002571,
-0.4464692771,
-0.5140032172,
-0.3355953097,
0.0379092395,
0.0385591388,
0.2238527983,
0.7649331689,
-0.3359446228,
0.2902293801,
0.453484863,
-0.0924938917,
0.9055393934,
-0.2258477062,
0.2144985795,
-0.845705986,
0.1550256759,
-0.1520786434,
-0.220339492,
-0.3488828838,
0.2438184321,
0.4047175348,
0.0306011476,
-0.7003193498,
0.7867134809,
-0.4758847654,
-0.1949233115,
-0.1117199138,
0.2560083866,
0.2541609704,
0.1514960527,
-0.2317823768,
0.7088384628,
0.128027752,
-0.4847157598,
0.0882819816,
-0.0076861861,
-0.8788180351,
0.1555959284,
-0.5014869571,
0.1828246713,
0.2203693986,
0.3465189636,
-0.7131409645,
0.231946364,
0.0890752077,
-0.1284379512,
0.3992543221,
-0.3815593123,
-0.7218040824,
-0.0732408464,
-0.4128410518,
0.5615704656,
0.4209427536,
-0.9732311368,
0.3078839183,
0.2472704649,
-0.1609628499,
-0.9325904846,
-0.6689327955,
-0.0333141536,
-0.4480088949,
-0.6440590024,
0.5329107642,
-0.0620876513,
-0.3926073909,
0.0026023565,
-0.2875711322,
-0.0587915853,
0.3717249632,
0.2597128749,
0.2062609345,
-0.0950694159,
0.2267734706,
0.0742983222,
-0.3688572943,
0.2236207426,
0.0568095855,
0.525434196,
0.0087864418,
-0.7044238448,
-0.4928869903,
0.3776403368,
0.5266752243,
-0.3652888238,
0.7024068236,
0.5657625794,
-0.4348847866,
-0.3806193471,
-0.9212397933,
-0.1160652116,
-0.5106549859,
0.21783261,
-0.4044941068,
-0.6257941723,
0.4937872589,
-0.5230617523,
0.1720110923,
0.3599679172,
0.4673741162,
-0.0091364728,
0.6489713192,
0.5318990946,
-0.3009925187,
0.6077617407,
-0.3825678825,
0.0469275676,
-0.8188562393,
-0.0921919271,
-0.7430637479,
-0.2129472047,
-0.2274488956,
-0.4678532481,
-0.0126348445,
0.3028931618,
-0.2846513093,
0.0455265008,
0.0029837615,
0.7260901332,
0.3468452394,
0.0447464585,
0.4502866566,
-0.0126589052,
-0.1767241806,
-0.0255867131,
-0.3383480012,
-0.591247797,
1.139552474,
0.4021614492,
0.7811468244,
-0.0040074317,
0.855837822,
0.1137764379,
0.4366197288,
-0.398550719,
0.4623345435,
-0.0288395025,
-0.5613111854,
-0.2277123779,
-0.5430505276,
-0.6298153996,
0.297701031,
0.1201968193,
-0.9496067166,
0.3176271915,
0.0868674442,
0.0015816703,
0.5496606827,
-0.8426678777,
0.7797483206,
0.0688820854,
-0.3977949619,
-0.3306573033,
-0.1103534177,
0.6119711995,
-0.1706582904,
0.1950907856,
-0.338264972,
-0.0384331457,
0.7222223878,
-0.6046879292,
0.5374594927,
-0.1772196293,
-0.322955668,
0.0560974814,
0.2392829359,
0.7400332689,
0.1299301237,
-0.5104595423,
0.2955151796,
0.0864824802,
-0.4432632029,
-0.6793576479,
0.7399383783,
-0.4904542267,
-0.7735591531,
-0.2184095383,
-0.4873801172,
-0.2792552412,
0.0862047449,
0.3280304372,
0.5549917817,
-0.0695880279,
0.0853108838,
0.515140295,
-0.2282982469,
0.6619318128,
0.6777226925,
-0.1180245653,
-0.0652540699,
0.7411261797,
-0.0517497957,
0.6444903016,
0.2885955572,
0.2642432153,
-0.4098136425,
-0.8373401761,
-0.2591796517,
0.2458443195,
-0.7692789435,
-0.0741928667,
-0.4109534025,
-0.1622020006,
-0.2355083972,
0.1592395753,
-0.8669162393,
-0.5352592468,
-0.0223321039,
-0.3105350137,
0.0972832143,
0.2225755602,
-0.1067354009,
0.1626595259,
-0.7656254172,
0.3351798058,
-0.0311152712,
0.3053450286,
-0.0496877395,
-0.6007936597,
-0.1533170789,
0.0821166486,
-0.0344183668,
-0.6931905746,
0.3309689164,
0.2120301723,
0.7618671656,
0.5367644429,
0.4137720764,
0.6866892576,
-0.5632245541,
0.6537594199,
-0.2274111211,
-1.0650895834,
0.2969609201,
-0.0412619822,
0.2109061182,
0.4659155607,
0.1114572883,
-0.3858882487,
-0.6575106978,
-0.7777606845,
-0.9340201616,
0.4745562375,
-0.0465032868,
-0.1533060223,
0.1248503625,
0.3626227081,
0.0326600932,
0.0799835399,
-0.27792117,
-0.4456699193,
0.0085035544,
0.1668856889,
-0.1850038022,
-0.7551125288,
-0.3279567361,
-0.0932346657,
0.6764954329,
0.0529098734,
0.1521012336,
-0.0958030745,
-0.3874403536,
0.0725125,
0.5574147105,
0.4485984743,
0.9398354292,
-0.2386618257,
0.2810704112,
0.2267720997,
-0.4136746228,
0.420173645,
0.0503402688,
0.0637503564,
-0.1489150226,
0.463322252,
0.3470109403,
0.2637306452,
-0.7758136392,
0.4122042358,
-0.1696434319,
0.0566814244,
-0.3613548875,
0.1702487618,
0.4993516207,
0.3122256994,
0.3225573003,
-0.1511431187,
0.0829161704,
-0.6111116409,
0.3547196686,
0.1974753439,
0.0159703717,
0.0738585517,
0.540132463,
0.0130057717,
-0.0836424008,
0.7611661553,
-0.0586471483,
-0.5806975365,
0.5344130993,
0.6652043462,
0.9042183757,
-0.7205451131,
0.0850727484,
0.4197866917,
0.4200395346,
-0.1658400595,
0.079340376,
0.1612954289,
-0.6358907223,
-0.6124206185,
-0.4130411446,
-0.259218812,
0.4227674007,
-0.8246738315,
0.0271307975,
-0.5147045851,
0.206731081,
0.046602346,
-0.0305084419,
-0.3591626287,
0.0701044127,
-0.0411981232,
1.164660573,
-0.910497725,
0.9037928581,
-0.0255590621,
-0.1192541048,
-0.8605461717,
0.0960919335,
0.1242811903,
-0.6470380425,
0.6257830858,
0.0945146903,
-0.0452498607,
-0.1976650953,
-0.3084673882,
-0.5846771002,
1.1143887043,
1.0461469889,
-0.6425805688,
0.1520431042,
0.1220469624,
0.3401924372,
-0.025938211,
0.428819865,
0.9525516629,
0.4663086832,
-0.1596805155,
-0.8923427463,
0.2241109461,
-0.4731735587,
-0.0980913714,
0.1892826259,
-0.5805324912,
0.9401907325,
-0.3011072278,
-0.6175734401,
-0.0186317507,
0.2141177207,
0.3368256986,
0.0896286964,
0.5849867463,
0.7595885396,
0.8707327843,
-0.1529230624,
1.2054387331,
-0.1393865943,
0.2952647805,
1.3893228769,
-0.2140452713,
1.162627697,
0.4694215655,
-0.1701049954,
0.3017765284,
0.4932155013,
0.0397157222,
0.4057786167,
0.4141436815,
-0.5230298042,
-0.1980784982,
0.0983727276,
-0.6065679789,
0.2615510225,
0.2982110679,
-0.3113875091,
-0.5906742215,
-0.2398963422,
0.359656781,
0.0326879956,
0.0364343002,
0.5214808583,
0.0396098457,
-0.3798471987,
0.7762711048,
0.0084496886,
0.2991007566,
-0.2473845631,
-0.0406148955,
-0.3375301361,
0.5920048356,
-0.1513021737,
-0.447506547,
0.2484210879,
-0.0196923018,
-0.1450210363,
-0.2984922528,
0.6666457653,
-0.4557979107,
-0.3117307723,
0.414955318,
0.417873323,
0.2151859999,
-0.4821930528,
-0.6585633159,
0.362932533,
0.0212051328,
-0.3067461848,
0.4595313668,
0.1781230718,
0.0950411186,
1.1803431511,
0.6426408291,
0.22175093,
0.2695654631,
0.2666447461,
0.8264796138,
-0.4540088475,
-0.2698027194,
-1.0412735939,
0.3587765694,
-0.0726771206,
0.0375468545,
0.7526816726,
0.7155719995,
0.7874305844,
-0.0235338975,
0.7388106585,
0.5107154846,
0.6572476625,
-0.741656661,
0.9215525985,
-0.3570831716,
0.6586683989,
-0.3563555777,
-1.0593343973,
0.0883693844,
0.1459118575,
-0.2817632556,
0.0483915955,
0.904250741,
0.7609472275,
-0.041706387,
0.0019718807,
0.2040852755,
0.1834255606,
0.8443363905,
0.7211113572,
0.9584134221,
-0.4883873761,
0.791476965,
-0.6771037579,
-0.0995903313,
-0.2824757099,
-1.2253654003,
-0.6008614302,
-0.4571011662,
-0.6468980312,
-0.256983459,
0.1178872883,
0.3136288524,
0.417065829,
-0.5753105879,
-0.0148905804,
0.1810591668,
0.177011475,
-0.5112963319,
-0.214582786,
0.6800174117,
-0.2249426991,
-0.9878972173,
0.661587894,
-0.0055442136,
-0.1082967967,
-0.2918725014,
0.2234182656,
-0.0640319511,
-0.1739343256,
0.2002234608,
0.4047030807,
-0.6659713984,
-0.5364778638,
-0.5026907921,
0.0127727026,
-0.0773503855,
0.7480911613,
-0.792075634,
0.4258582294,
0.4588161707,
0.7888989449,
0.8236765265,
0.1320159286,
0.6758032441,
-0.7832374573,
0.1859292388,
0.0767038167,
0.5910553336,
0.2830994725,
-0.1863898337,
0.5772619247,
-0.013546383,
-0.4216551781,
-1.119943738,
0.0688246638,
-0.6048598886,
-0.2482624948,
1.3162330389,
-0.6354336143,
-0.3192629814,
-0.1495556533,
0.0816078261,
0.3641699553,
-0.2894102037,
0.9365009069,
0.7421815395,
0.3281025887,
-0.3233599365,
-0.7615510225,
0.5237796903,
0.2489863336,
-1.0108305216,
0.5531088114,
0.382024169,
0.8022107482,
0.0852230117,
0.4632023275,
-0.4672682285,
0.1034535766,
0.2429018021,
0.0956342295,
-0.4228070974,
-0.1275182515,
-0.2077815235,
0.1136670634,
0.0332220979,
-0.3070892692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13975v1 | MR-BEN: A Comprehensive Meta-Reasoning Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T03:50:23 | 2024-06-20T03:50:23 | Zhongshen Zeng, Yinhong Liu, Yingjia Wan, Jingyao Li, Pengguang Chen, Jianbo Dai, Yuxuan Yao, Rongwu Xu, Zehan Qi, Wanru Zhao, Linling Shen, Jianqiao Lu, Haochen Tan, Yukang Chen, Hao Zhang, Zhan Shi, Bailin Wang, Zhijiang Guo, Jiaya Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have shown increasing capability in
problem-solving and decision-making, largely based on the step-by-step
chain-of-thought reasoning processes. However, it has been increasingly
challenging to evaluate the reasoning capability of LLMs. Concretely, existing
outcome-based benchmarks begin to saturate and become less sufficient to
monitor the progress. To this end, we present a process-based benchmark MR-BEN
that demands a meta reasoning skill, where LMs are asked to locate and analyse
potential errors in automatically generated reasoning steps. MR-BEN is a
comprehensive benchmark comprising 5,975 questions collected from human
experts, covering various subjects such as physics, chemistry, logic, coding,
and more. Through our designed metrics for assessing meta-reasoning on this
benchmark, we identify interesting limitations and weaknesses of current LLMs
(open-source and closed-source models). For example, open-source models are
seemingly comparable to GPT-4 on outcome-based benchmarks, but they lag far
behind on our benchmark, revealing the underlying reasoning capability gap
between them. Our dataset and codes are available on
https://randolph-zeng.github.io/Mr-Ben.github.io/. | [
-0.5755147338,
-0.8711823821,
0.9115718007,
-0.0403183922,
-0.0709234551,
-0.0850979015,
-0.2726412117,
-0.4715177715,
-0.1104205698,
0.4265906513,
-0.7842071056,
-0.5304025412,
-0.5575221181,
0.40584144,
-0.0974290296,
0.543806076,
-0.1773842871,
0.1345776916,
-0.2275848836,
-0.1747877151,
-0.5481840372,
-0.1681153178,
-0.5614724159,
-0.4167347848,
0.7193783522,
0.4633460641,
0.7445655465,
0.4665387869,
0.7677482367,
0.25656268,
0.1144527569,
0.3446609676,
-0.0525149293,
0.2749652267,
-0.8003336191,
-0.2033382207,
-0.6008960605,
-0.0670334473,
0.745439589,
0.8245901465,
-0.0305091348,
0.4447365701,
-0.2135015577,
0.7550860643,
-0.8327921033,
0.1544109285,
-0.5587859154,
-0.0908032283,
-0.2724143863,
-0.030723216,
-0.4122954607,
-0.3026635945,
-0.095513463,
-0.0816176906,
0.1517021954,
0.0461362042,
0.5909860134,
0.5107706785,
-0.2304771096,
-0.1904062033,
-0.7229459286,
0.7789161205,
-0.7319418788,
0.5662552118,
0.366096735,
0.6364860535,
-0.2023545057,
-0.6199489832,
-0.5500056148,
-0.1733870804,
0.0208375268,
-0.0863534808,
0.0364699587,
-0.0907308236,
0.2781050503,
0.1179970205,
-0.8151864409,
-0.2612591982,
-0.2022658587,
-0.0448540188,
0.4747007191,
0.2600181699,
0.0007982543,
-0.245780915,
-0.1279727966,
-0.2409090698,
-0.525496304,
-0.3096727133,
0.2738877833,
0.3685132861,
0.2049550712,
0.793258965,
-0.2591357827,
0.7584696412,
-0.2389897555,
0.009473918,
0.234040603,
-0.2526556551,
-0.2864855528,
-0.1907349229,
0.8877872825,
-0.0713166669,
0.4388393462,
0.1904546916,
-0.1375191063,
-0.3187454045,
0.1884693056,
-0.7108331323,
-0.1712125987,
0.3460072279,
-0.3530989587,
0.2917658985,
0.1309627742,
-0.7600623369,
-0.2767543495,
-0.1265075207,
0.3926549554,
-0.5543981791,
-0.386431843,
0.1605811566,
0.0020833695,
0.2558839321,
0.2495905161,
-0.663207233,
0.0949279964,
0.7903496623,
0.7123317719,
0.0445500016,
-0.3693107963,
-0.4702569842,
0.1288073659,
-0.4702841938,
0.9460301399,
-0.7642172575,
-0.2214462161,
-0.2484126538,
-0.2342893183,
-0.1882949471,
-0.6971994042,
0.9515946507,
-0.5005646348,
0.1106227934,
-0.6877164245,
-0.4467628598,
-0.193155542,
0.5260806084,
-0.6287103295,
0.9473756552,
0.1362105608,
-0.7357659936,
0.2934507728,
-0.7249473929,
-0.3422433436,
-0.0927772969,
-0.4895828664,
-0.3286843002,
0.1511911154,
0.1765853763,
0.4207074344,
-0.7261925936,
0.4576275945,
-0.6677342057,
-0.3955518007,
0.4979670048,
-0.6272667646,
0.6718557477,
0.2595378757,
-0.4460782707,
0.164567098,
-0.8417742848,
0.2247668505,
0.1099371165,
-0.4131630063,
-0.0632167533,
0.1999994963,
-0.4197474122,
0.385551393,
0.2106600404,
-0.2409145534,
-0.0793693364,
-0.1174943745,
0.2218354046,
0.7943276763,
-0.302932322,
-0.1030049324,
-0.2472073734,
0.3748420775,
-0.1246912926,
0.045493558,
-0.2869416475,
-0.4977965951,
-0.6569286585,
-0.4945163429,
0.3753412962,
0.5814293027,
-0.5050957799,
0.6674667001,
-0.5187277794,
-0.2561020851,
-0.548656106,
0.2162988186,
0.4711753428,
0.4891017973,
0.5818889737,
-0.117984049,
-0.1978707016,
-1.1229665279,
-0.4316213131,
-0.2073704898,
-0.2092381418,
0.3479745984,
0.7820154428,
-0.3978379965,
0.8893726468,
-0.2972619534,
-0.0385049358,
-0.1650940478,
0.2405253202,
0.1824667752,
0.2347810715,
0.0349677093,
-0.5412392616,
-0.2609574497,
-0.1542491019,
-0.9007279277,
-0.3725105226,
0.0559195317,
-0.0347250253,
0.402140826,
0.491240859,
-0.7721844316,
0.134634912,
0.5150442719,
-0.4597629607,
0.7584233284,
-0.2902350426,
0.4573283792,
-0.8338063359,
0.4989210367,
-0.0294379275,
-0.1916704178,
-0.1209018901,
0.2454826385,
0.2094293684,
0.0028095008,
-0.1875266582,
0.6725817323,
-0.4344534576,
-0.4694116712,
-0.2129473686,
0.1687544286,
-0.1669098437,
0.413312912,
0.1670076698,
0.769790709,
0.2211299837,
-0.4739250541,
0.4499627054,
0.0033104937,
-0.3664433062,
0.9201756716,
-0.6295573115,
0.0190566927,
0.0471436307,
0.3198318183,
-0.9541849494,
-0.2936698198,
0.3395130038,
-0.5063797235,
0.3152071536,
0.0172326081,
-0.9359624982,
-0.4447875619,
-0.1980971247,
0.468255043,
0.2068614811,
-0.4034018517,
0.8750474453,
-0.1745053828,
-0.0749697462,
-0.8195165992,
-0.8153594136,
0.2136442661,
0.0579072945,
-0.7976202369,
0.137165606,
-0.2819950283,
-0.338350594,
0.293816179,
-0.2234807163,
0.0156132691,
-0.2355429232,
-0.0444144793,
-0.001226233,
-0.2275380641,
0.1456384063,
0.0108708926,
-0.4228307307,
0.3768272102,
-0.1569665372,
0.4663876593,
-0.3268503845,
-0.9579293728,
-0.2096452266,
0.2608736455,
0.8673602939,
-0.4172908366,
0.7947887182,
0.6521895528,
-0.3805781007,
-0.3343054652,
-0.7245639563,
-0.1680335253,
-0.4331933558,
0.3110904992,
-0.6868561506,
-0.6487832665,
0.5411638618,
-0.1668292582,
0.0836346149,
0.6267274618,
0.526417017,
-0.0267817322,
0.8138012886,
0.130400613,
0.2376833409,
0.00683808,
0.023950953,
0.1112066135,
-0.8635700345,
-0.2624464631,
-0.6027414799,
-0.1782467812,
-0.3355308473,
-0.8488508463,
0.3735657334,
-0.023605546,
-0.4624172151,
0.1924102008,
-0.2566585839,
0.4089136422,
0.650606513,
0.1009202227,
0.355959177,
-0.3375411928,
-0.3956592083,
0.1174856424,
-0.5406545997,
-0.5515655279,
1.0872594118,
0.3642276525,
0.6083171368,
0.2730601132,
0.5454392433,
0.3066577315,
0.3111559749,
-0.4025338292,
0.8512486219,
0.0886994675,
-1.1628693342,
-0.3585048616,
-0.9040957689,
-0.6610609293,
0.3741776943,
-0.233714059,
-0.3281196356,
-0.2077947259,
0.0781746879,
-0.1292035729,
0.5852597952,
-0.4962007105,
1.06658566,
-0.382073909,
-0.7381722927,
-0.5558785796,
-0.6543185711,
0.6117375493,
-0.2093895227,
0.416349411,
-0.259097755,
-0.0879115313,
0.3987223208,
-0.3848572075,
0.5958920121,
-0.0335431173,
-0.1536241919,
0.4643125832,
0.1549771875,
0.3813062906,
-0.1443207264,
-0.2186581194,
0.0864447057,
0.0055057807,
-0.5850296021,
-0.4294532835,
0.7183732986,
-0.395714432,
-0.5272128582,
-0.580450654,
-0.310257405,
-0.373723954,
0.2283686548,
-0.102621235,
0.2036190927,
-0.2412165254,
0.0809734538,
0.9086845517,
-0.5338864326,
0.411097616,
0.6187004447,
-0.1520688534,
-0.6844114065,
0.6084703803,
0.0487747192,
0.2016703039,
0.539296329,
0.3038612306,
-0.3895539939,
-0.5868157744,
-0.6036515236,
0.4656090736,
-0.9766201973,
-0.1284922212,
-0.4479408562,
-0.0959427282,
-0.1357804686,
0.1129914522,
-0.5297705531,
-0.0972174332,
0.027066078,
0.1496913284,
-0.130899772,
0.5275565386,
-0.0911993161,
-0.2784965634,
-0.9163607955,
0.3729934096,
0.4822715819,
0.838830173,
-0.0883397534,
-0.4077194333,
-0.2921671271,
-0.1490714252,
-0.2916889787,
-0.8313536644,
-0.1925011426,
-0.1529002339,
0.7287556529,
0.4348567128,
0.0593292527,
0.5050204396,
-0.5247644186,
0.6271885633,
0.1166621298,
-0.9963223338,
0.537694633,
-0.5410290956,
0.4746975601,
0.6626618505,
0.2506851256,
-0.168955341,
-0.224451229,
-0.485268265,
-0.4669301212,
0.4611470997,
0.1087092459,
-0.2486738414,
-0.271640569,
0.4000199139,
-0.0216609277,
0.1504144222,
-0.7070669532,
-0.1468908936,
0.152396217,
-0.3032186329,
-0.0512219369,
-0.2156335413,
0.0211300161,
-0.2439759821,
0.677562058,
-0.135142073,
0.2128457725,
0.2619266808,
-0.0997118652,
-0.3665851355,
0.4121758044,
0.842807889,
1.0025367737,
-0.4733136296,
0.3301077783,
0.3565843701,
-0.1085261405,
0.0160409212,
0.2814186215,
0.2437439263,
-0.0461902022,
0.6768649817,
0.213586539,
0.2036490142,
-1.1001610756,
0.4272581041,
0.0946542323,
-0.3952762783,
-0.2738617063,
0.120096907,
0.3325343728,
0.5751891136,
0.2980400622,
0.0336782709,
0.022343874,
-0.751206398,
0.1658123434,
0.6321812868,
-0.1070569232,
-0.2176642418,
0.6621924043,
0.2072429955,
-0.2916534841,
0.5268446207,
-0.2977595627,
-0.3410381675,
0.2764707804,
0.1201380417,
1.079097271,
-0.3649012744,
-0.0008746681,
0.6259740591,
0.6379758716,
-0.2401361465,
0.3525558114,
-0.0162477363,
-0.4886347651,
-0.7540633082,
-0.586918354,
-0.653198421,
0.2218928039,
-0.200267002,
0.3801292479,
-0.5658717155,
-0.2205512375,
-0.186141178,
0.0891781226,
-0.6305205226,
0.2203883678,
0.1259223223,
1.0557253361,
-0.6549443603,
0.7266631722,
0.5851684809,
-0.3485023677,
-0.2520161271,
0.0193788782,
-0.0151723167,
-0.5301372409,
0.4673511982,
0.2078547925,
-0.4278885722,
-0.4346349239,
-0.2109232247,
-0.777664423,
1.0686395168,
0.5974499583,
-0.6152547002,
0.0956392288,
0.2219125479,
0.4655342996,
-0.1836509407,
0.4533134401,
0.6049086452,
0.8746797442,
0.1925233454,
-0.9926121235,
0.181402564,
0.010564982,
-0.3618330657,
0.4313772619,
-0.5287126303,
0.8589569926,
-0.2869853377,
-0.0619425103,
-0.2318128198,
0.4858957231,
0.4654091895,
0.5209020376,
0.4016265273,
0.9263685942,
0.6666771173,
-0.0712724999,
0.8038549423,
-0.3035754859,
0.1991001517,
1.1563273668,
-0.4003418088,
1.0704782009,
0.2423163354,
-0.3789643645,
0.759716332,
0.6338486075,
0.0548215024,
0.2025585324,
0.3452872336,
-0.2461746931,
-0.5397552848,
0.5235922337,
-0.3016110957,
0.1952536851,
0.3417397439,
-0.4979179502,
-0.268056035,
-0.3927467167,
-0.1186725721,
0.1001759693,
-0.1263897717,
0.5385321379,
0.08333157,
-0.8330383301,
0.5610465407,
0.2586740851,
0.3511688709,
-0.6551529765,
-0.0495943911,
-0.043265678,
0.3384907842,
-0.1210879907,
-0.8978481293,
0.5967667699,
0.0306852553,
-0.1381958872,
-0.0410202444,
0.6173114181,
-0.1835638881,
-0.5199921727,
0.452272594,
0.8887203336,
0.1487359107,
-0.227018103,
-0.8357565999,
0.2205474973,
-0.2145798653,
-0.3882224858,
0.1506524682,
0.5174431205,
0.0313737467,
0.9200903177,
0.4633880258,
-0.0516719632,
-0.1474280506,
0.0197532587,
0.5411911011,
-0.9849165082,
-0.1088737622,
-1.1464561224,
0.3876865804,
0.0343022868,
-0.0866061747,
0.4411066473,
0.5222054124,
0.7222272754,
0.065513894,
0.7110445499,
-0.0540065467,
0.7134029865,
-0.4896859229,
0.2803418338,
-0.5621646047,
0.5101316571,
-0.3450807333,
-1.1387268305,
-0.2556291521,
0.645853281,
-0.3626048267,
0.5626268387,
1.0041749477,
0.6411307454,
-0.3428560197,
-0.1394520253,
0.2940746844,
-0.1246933565,
0.3953735232,
0.7916274071,
0.7178769112,
-0.1090488508,
0.7612393498,
0.175022155,
-0.2980908751,
-0.3321126401,
-1.1267635822,
-1.2125936747,
-0.5367915034,
-0.3157758117,
-0.1940807849,
0.0500211194,
1.0221390724,
0.6788095236,
-0.6378346086,
-0.1296839267,
-0.2625582218,
0.2171924412,
-0.3348231316,
-0.198910594,
0.2773794234,
-0.3887522519,
-0.4228785634,
0.3847597539,
0.2371426523,
-0.2385739833,
-0.5211475492,
-0.121261254,
-0.2044231445,
0.5281002522,
0.5637303591,
0.2514171898,
-0.8195352554,
-0.3412049413,
-0.169100672,
-0.0452825949,
-0.0312591046,
0.7392892838,
-0.5545102358,
0.3547955751,
0.5898033977,
0.7590856552,
0.4059703052,
-0.1032832786,
0.4492511749,
-0.4417907298,
-0.6081206799,
0.1152877808,
0.4651706517,
0.5055060983,
0.2871645391,
0.6387204528,
0.3411333859,
-0.6284236312,
-0.7363318801,
0.4295293391,
-0.7238879204,
-0.6727338433,
1.0500124693,
0.0204342455,
-0.0054501952,
0.0897492394,
0.1322627813,
0.2100051939,
-0.2140077204,
0.7486845851,
0.9536119699,
-0.2652368844,
-0.5132187009,
-0.8134744167,
0.2173265219,
0.3917291462,
-0.9694542885,
0.379928261,
0.6798704863,
0.430118382,
0.2700055838,
0.5631452799,
-0.1326577961,
0.2446112633,
-0.0142700663,
0.0256540012,
-0.275416106,
-0.5997236371,
-0.1938089579,
0.3495342135,
0.15139094,
-0.0176887065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13960v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13960v1 | Evolving to be Your Soulmate: Personalized Dialogue Agents with Dynamically Adapted Personas | 2024-06-20T03:02:38 | 2024-06-20T03:02:38 | Yi Cheng, Wenge Liu, Kaishuai Xu, Wenjun Hou, Yi Ouyang, Chak Tou Leong, Xian Wu, Yefeng Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Previous research on persona-based dialogue agents typically preset the
agent's persona before deployment, which remains static thereafter. In this
paper, we take a step further and explore a new paradigm called Self-evolving
Personalized Dialogue Agents (SPDA), where the agent continuously evolves
during the conversation to better align with the user's anticipation by
dynamically adapting its persona. This paradigm could enable better
personalization for each user, but also introduce unique challenges, which
mainly lie in the process of persona adaptation. Two key issues include how to
achieve persona alignment with the user and how to ensure smooth transition in
the adaptation process. To address them, we propose a novel framework that
refines the persona at hierarchical levels to progressively align better with
the user in a controllable way. Experiments show that integrating the personas
adapted by our framework consistently enhances personalization and overall
dialogue performance across various base systems. | [
-0.4615161121,
-0.2895222604,
0.7997984886,
0.3648930192,
-0.0225414503,
0.6600071192,
0.1946974397,
-0.3232040703,
0.3857696354,
0.6166290641,
-1.093367815,
-0.0576600209,
-0.1249566376,
0.0799607038,
0.2492524385,
0.8821176887,
0.4791125655,
-0.0522669852,
-0.230738312,
-0.4617770314,
-0.9600010514,
-0.1821491718,
-0.6706309319,
-0.4957462847,
0.443800211,
0.4595716,
0.6770631671,
0.3885600865,
0.278485328,
0.3837133646,
0.2475024313,
-0.1285352111,
-0.3944406509,
0.7885080576,
-0.4536114633,
-0.4040411711,
-0.7355792522,
-0.1808185577,
0.4629693329,
0.5339747667,
-0.166486457,
0.0577102192,
-0.039763771,
0.7310092449,
-0.4615368843,
0.0029248006,
-0.5670269132,
0.108615756,
0.0021399888,
-0.5071388483,
-0.1982279122,
-0.4199741483,
0.5977059603,
-0.6148952246,
-0.2264798731,
-0.094784677,
0.3792690337,
0.4273641109,
-0.4826346636,
-0.0848358274,
-1.008535862,
0.4730934799,
-0.4976845682,
0.3504357636,
-0.3651105165,
0.8081734776,
-0.260445416,
-0.6876258254,
-0.4984371364,
-0.1859159917,
0.232770592,
0.2966993749,
-0.1473421305,
0.0665352046,
-0.0284561682,
0.1353330016,
-0.3101504445,
0.0456911139,
0.1129259542,
0.0669128895,
0.4289700389,
0.4100223482,
0.4458302557,
-0.0660419688,
-0.1811190248,
0.0401302576,
-0.2189643383,
0.2112241685,
0.3590561748,
0.2938294411,
-0.1107410565,
0.0605529845,
-0.2202060223,
0.299515605,
0.9638194442,
-0.2709940672,
0.4290620387,
-0.0813560858,
-0.1001818851,
0.1956732869,
0.3852639496,
0.5608232617,
0.16575028,
-0.341247648,
0.098827228,
-0.206214413,
0.6612306237,
-0.7333108187,
-0.1589305401,
0.3368056715,
-0.4599460661,
-0.3388501406,
-0.3328415155,
-0.8253523111,
-0.7303230166,
-0.3097110093,
0.1715894639,
-0.3516733944,
-0.2105911523,
0.1144303679,
0.0546701066,
0.4720552564,
0.5777480006,
-1.188790679,
0.3335886896,
0.7929998636,
0.6309913993,
-0.1733469218,
-0.2738086283,
-0.2942728996,
0.1663009673,
-0.3609230816,
0.9218443036,
-0.7121202946,
-0.416364193,
-0.1411947161,
0.1097756028,
-0.1895842552,
-0.4598800242,
0.3156545758,
-0.5937311649,
0.538778007,
-0.4905598462,
-0.0293994043,
-0.0079408763,
0.110500358,
-0.1017238721,
0.6426482797,
0.6834504008,
-0.3344478905,
0.3493192196,
-0.838548243,
-0.0939969644,
0.3941293955,
-0.0437418558,
-0.2079573274,
0.128031224,
-0.0267204456,
0.4391496778,
-0.057172861,
0.0321740955,
-0.5873853564,
-0.0636538789,
0.3814483583,
0.2909963131,
0.6237756014,
0.2275400758,
-0.185708642,
0.3570410907,
-0.731235981,
-0.1251539737,
-0.0792846307,
0.1499306858,
-0.2168486118,
0.1051943153,
-0.2610147297,
0.3975227177,
0.5010591149,
-0.3994406164,
0.3352652192,
-0.518019259,
0.3458771706,
1.1536465883,
0.3371385634,
0.9621732831,
-0.5799792409,
0.5147029161,
0.2508208156,
0.2872191072,
-0.3531420827,
-0.3273929656,
-0.7342226505,
-0.1438774318,
0.0278428756,
0.5636738539,
-0.3285782039,
0.8473660946,
-0.5456692576,
-0.4824823141,
-0.4413679242,
-0.0267410539,
0.0820525512,
0.637524128,
0.0277927648,
-0.8857977986,
-0.3503573239,
-0.9284737706,
-0.1674028337,
-0.3539452255,
0.0259165652,
0.4457182288,
0.2312629223,
-0.7165588737,
1.3598856926,
-0.374224633,
-0.1927601248,
-0.2248151302,
-0.2339497805,
0.0311609544,
0.6575101614,
0.8202386498,
-0.6506378055,
-0.783395052,
0.1455735713,
-0.8876379132,
-0.4078468084,
-0.6976721883,
-0.4073284566,
-0.4244253337,
0.1258260161,
-0.4579999447,
-0.0665786043,
0.3260895312,
-0.5379830003,
0.5241770744,
-0.1741775423,
0.2302027345,
-1.5657360554,
-0.1073173881,
-0.0298421495,
-0.4145195782,
-0.9746378064,
-0.1738346219,
-0.2270981818,
-0.2179922014,
-0.1206009164,
0.6998984218,
-0.2794083655,
-0.338401556,
-0.4963806868,
0.217229113,
-0.125947699,
0.7624589801,
-0.2109387517,
0.7801160216,
0.6308603287,
-0.6472327113,
0.4240401685,
0.7620533705,
0.0349131115,
1.4377142191,
-0.4237774312,
0.3983050287,
-0.2909856737,
0.6564666629,
-0.6744309068,
-0.1459809989,
0.6610021591,
-0.2135626525,
0.0211347267,
-0.0697003528,
0.0378684103,
0.0123427091,
-0.3287951052,
0.1194183901,
0.6084252596,
-0.5429856181,
1.055216074,
0.2699406445,
-0.5014372468,
-0.1237902343,
-0.0418447927,
0.3164771199,
-0.5298256278,
-0.8812624216,
0.5557931066,
-0.5992263556,
-0.3021894395,
-0.2474364489,
-0.1886982173,
0.1863410175,
0.1797751635,
0.4074560106,
-0.1253786236,
-0.1952318698,
-0.1682089567,
0.3928263485,
-0.3760157526,
-0.0624967813,
-0.3113210201,
0.6306784749,
-0.0469276048,
-0.1074970439,
-0.973950386,
0.2911536098,
0.9842548966,
-0.1476846039,
0.5599349141,
0.4596959054,
-0.1106449142,
-0.1146817729,
-0.6623027325,
-0.3027917445,
-0.5662519336,
0.1803670228,
-0.8502404094,
-0.6053950787,
0.9426523447,
-0.5576347709,
0.3116347492,
-0.0627735555,
0.5055927038,
-0.3752755523,
1.1646916866,
1.0443211794,
0.0811983347,
0.8039375544,
0.1831849366,
0.2116727233,
-1.4865185022,
-0.471419394,
-0.2991640568,
-0.5955802798,
-0.6197117567,
-0.1808547378,
0.2161964923,
-0.1656953394,
-0.4154887497,
0.4547670186,
-0.5078247786,
0.0962186605,
0.096659936,
0.0702966154,
0.0849282295,
-0.4655694067,
0.2673089802,
-0.3422400653,
-0.2034714073,
-0.6099994779,
0.7937982678,
0.5693479776,
0.4784678519,
0.3708638847,
0.5525202155,
0.6032270789,
0.1482347995,
-0.438228488,
0.5871725678,
0.2747585177,
-0.3034258783,
-0.1087695658,
-0.0665205047,
-0.950953424,
0.4192247689,
-0.0730169192,
-1.2182292938,
0.6894031167,
0.2109685689,
-0.6257588863,
-0.3450779319,
-0.5319516659,
0.8642590046,
-0.3316216171,
-0.2700188458,
-0.3136640489,
-0.8566580415,
0.0347325429,
-0.449375838,
-0.1938060522,
-0.4695068598,
-0.1910122931,
0.5134036541,
-0.0960985869,
0.6154247522,
-0.3447724283,
-0.1552277505,
-0.1630162299,
0.2567673922,
0.6083814502,
0.1923361421,
-0.1538585424,
-0.3976003826,
0.0662211478,
-0.66103369,
-1.1827766895,
0.6787134409,
-0.719443202,
-0.9082258344,
-0.4982824326,
-0.2832272351,
-0.6550013423,
0.1726865172,
-0.1393896043,
0.131630078,
-0.7045913339,
0.0342994854,
0.7077519894,
-0.1479906142,
0.2200183272,
0.7393587232,
-0.0466572791,
-0.3961038888,
0.6847704649,
-0.2263816446,
0.2650944293,
0.1663546264,
0.3497233391,
-0.2842720747,
-0.5349690914,
-0.4310177267,
0.248111099,
-0.5899211764,
0.244288981,
-0.8438206911,
0.0466121547,
-0.7238699794,
-0.5977413058,
-0.2500913143,
-0.1639671773,
-0.4062261283,
0.1273398399,
-0.0138576813,
0.4810178876,
0.1537691504,
0.748478651,
-0.5411663055,
0.2636910975,
0.7808852792,
0.1831322461,
-0.1523706764,
-0.7945374846,
-0.0264517479,
0.0618329048,
-0.5280239582,
-1.0345472097,
0.2634304464,
0.3242206275,
0.7303991318,
0.6246089935,
-0.030087376,
0.829215467,
-0.5707088709,
0.7856886387,
0.1561724544,
-0.8592140079,
0.5173345804,
-0.7411836386,
0.4044184983,
0.9109452963,
-0.0129206143,
-0.8590296507,
0.0140596749,
-0.6226806641,
-0.2996114492,
0.5745607018,
0.0092573352,
0.6512659192,
0.6028034687,
0.7479022145,
0.2233523428,
0.4199437797,
-0.4889431894,
-0.0529331341,
-0.336980015,
-0.1348622292,
-0.0445079431,
-0.0007394517,
-0.156694904,
-0.2520168126,
0.5312353373,
-0.6758306623,
0.5082293153,
-0.1322542876,
0.0259369109,
-0.1927812099,
0.1679660827,
0.5193186402,
0.699644804,
-0.2136895061,
-0.3114999831,
0.3688878119,
-0.1692261249,
0.3565016389,
-0.3169774711,
-0.0344546847,
-0.4267094731,
-0.0430524386,
0.8804228902,
0.6684750319,
-0.4713492692,
0.4238151312,
-0.1821425855,
0.0744918734,
-0.4395208061,
0.3956169784,
-0.0068888948,
0.7282670736,
0.344255656,
0.3831596673,
0.1417686492,
-0.85920012,
0.1749903113,
0.3519354761,
-0.5031414628,
-0.8279739022,
0.5499956012,
0.7065756917,
-0.8327512741,
0.2422880381,
-0.07576444,
-0.5565516949,
0.1098073721,
0.5846527219,
1.3371812105,
-0.6326631308,
0.550160706,
-0.1742423773,
-0.1108112708,
0.1314594597,
-0.0577327237,
-0.406227529,
-0.8300392032,
0.2340892702,
-0.6221469641,
-0.5903528929,
-0.1932053864,
-0.4827755392,
0.0919277146,
-0.5681641102,
-0.1648746133,
-0.0822219178,
0.1840695739,
-0.4094897807,
0.1612467617,
-0.0246853922,
0.669767797,
-0.5942903161,
0.7585601807,
0.5843986273,
0.1468805522,
-0.2779843509,
0.2830812335,
0.0048338147,
-0.5646739006,
0.2822779417,
-0.063235499,
-0.2808822393,
0.2725961804,
-0.13931036,
-0.9410301447,
1.346111536,
0.4674783945,
-0.4257513285,
-0.3323149681,
-0.0773123354,
0.8271116018,
-0.8998194933,
0.0620218962,
0.6709396243,
0.427307725,
0.1383308768,
-0.7629171014,
-0.1363521963,
-0.3403109312,
0.1471302509,
-0.108737275,
-1.1121673584,
0.425342381,
-0.0018695641,
-0.1130437478,
0.4139776826,
0.871709764,
0.0192567408,
0.4589246511,
0.694904685,
0.2934231758,
0.7165439725,
0.0255921595,
0.4803144634,
-0.5738295913,
-0.19303222,
0.9900558591,
-0.7987840772,
0.3908924162,
0.1827897578,
0.1083793268,
1.2209914923,
0.8219243288,
0.0215539206,
0.6292706728,
-0.2376874089,
-0.4512715936,
-0.339141041,
-0.0590659268,
-0.2472877055,
0.4513016641,
0.2083493918,
-0.2747123539,
0.0378296003,
0.3398669362,
-0.1640258282,
0.1965921372,
0.0025225002,
1.0129486322,
-0.0415320024,
-0.8353265524,
0.0390230305,
-0.1559467763,
0.57216084,
-0.6908356547,
0.3361549675,
-0.2575269341,
0.1940702647,
-0.2914094031,
-0.2609505057,
-0.0939089134,
-0.4020827711,
0.0164849516,
-0.5876393318,
0.7752706409,
-0.0603133291,
0.1101938039,
0.283980757,
0.6778966188,
-0.033782322,
0.0923764035,
-1.1193594933,
0.0535626747,
-0.0767110959,
-0.2086323649,
0.6461157203,
0.2286497951,
0.0840401053,
1.1276483536,
0.6009907722,
-0.1492572874,
-0.0597529262,
-0.068800725,
0.9261081815,
-0.5938766599,
-0.7427762747,
-0.5038346052,
0.6596276164,
-0.2381174564,
-0.5926969051,
0.8218961954,
0.366317451,
0.2318584323,
-0.0407672673,
0.7222723365,
0.0833841115,
0.3262470663,
0.0349631906,
0.5819979906,
-0.3927792013,
0.1815468222,
-0.662470758,
-1.2574744225,
0.2344789356,
0.6339690089,
-0.1085194051,
0.2195774913,
0.5613296628,
0.7840384841,
0.0356996804,
0.0651962981,
0.2650493085,
0.0596486181,
0.6010817885,
0.4592528641,
0.8325457573,
-0.1835426837,
-0.1944598556,
-0.2427946478,
-0.3854544759,
-0.3828525245,
-0.6112170815,
-0.7679912448,
-1.0129666328,
-0.5945668221,
-0.3490627706,
0.2841435373,
1.0239089727,
1.0257216692,
-0.4211941659,
-0.2273251712,
0.0019552573,
-0.1133202836,
-0.2711005211,
-0.1803328991,
-0.2550356984,
-0.3376835883,
-0.8995110393,
0.7652417421,
0.6969886422,
0.2544454336,
-0.7036590576,
-0.360645473,
0.1690292805,
0.4973383248,
0.5036390424,
0.6398029923,
-0.3221401274,
-0.6487916112,
-0.0185678452,
-0.1046025604,
0.4653769135,
1.0047351122,
-1.0218788385,
0.6133154035,
0.2733337879,
0.5577922463,
0.3260798752,
0.4006797075,
1.0032602549,
-0.3824240863,
-0.0591556579,
0.4145353734,
-0.1357436031,
0.3646580875,
-0.5543062091,
0.1479639709,
0.2826567888,
-0.7701861858,
-1.0820262432,
0.4990756214,
-1.4187190533,
0.0203942452,
0.621126771,
-0.0159708485,
-0.1302656382,
-0.4618500173,
-0.3273343444,
0.0068896483,
-0.5886026025,
0.9030023217,
0.4581670463,
-0.615482688,
-0.359224081,
-0.0914493501,
0.7604828477,
0.3995500207,
-1.1362673044,
-0.0856570452,
0.1393952668,
0.4903331101,
0.4016162753,
0.9513619542,
0.2987974286,
0.5083653331,
-0.1875263751,
-0.3202659786,
0.2005135566,
-0.3679499924,
-0.5055376291,
0.2383310497,
0.134570986,
-0.0085049681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13948v1 | CityGPT: Empowering Urban Spatial Cognition of Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T02:32:16 | 2024-06-20T02:32:16 | Jie Feng, Yuwei Du, Tianhui Liu, Siqi Guo, Yuming Lin, Yong Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models(LLMs) with powerful language generation and reasoning
capabilities have already achieved success in many domains, e.g., math and code
generation. However, due to the lacking of physical world's corpus and
knowledge during training, they usually fail to solve many real-life tasks in
the urban space. In this paper, we propose CityGPT, a systematic framework for
enhancing the capability of LLMs on understanding urban space and solving the
related urban tasks by building a city-scale world model in the model. First,
we construct a diverse instruction tuning dataset CityInstruction for injecting
urban knowledge and enhancing spatial reasoning capability effectively. By
using a mixture of CityInstruction and general instruction data, we fine-tune
various LLMs (e.g., ChatGLM3-6B, Qwen1.5 and LLama3 series) to enhance their
capability without sacrificing general abilities. To further validate the
effectiveness of proposed methods, we construct a comprehensive benchmark
CityEval to evaluate the capability of LLMs on diverse urban scenarios and
problems. Extensive evaluation results demonstrate that small LLMs trained with
CityInstruction can achieve competitive performance with commercial LLMs in the
comprehensive evaluation of CityEval. The source codes are openly accessible to
the research community via https://github.com/tsinghua-fib-lab/CityGPT. | [
-0.433067441,
-0.832849443,
0.917137444,
0.1988338977,
0.1315266788,
0.2073005438,
-0.4367874861,
-0.3661506474,
-0.2568754852,
0.304788202,
-0.2383091599,
-0.6299350858,
-0.294135958,
-0.2171619534,
-0.1323909312,
0.6678851843,
-0.2228479385,
0.0947922096,
-0.1980291456,
0.0824918672,
-0.6634918451,
-0.2808220088,
-0.6532534957,
-0.4307878315,
0.046788089,
0.5966153741,
0.6096224189,
0.5953526497,
0.4928378761,
0.2239374816,
0.1023063883,
0.2597644329,
-0.4226243198,
-0.4072055519,
-0.3588962555,
-0.099232696,
-0.3978806436,
-0.2870824039,
0.5869731307,
0.6597000957,
-0.478113234,
0.0203112625,
0.110992156,
0.4002072811,
-0.3134307563,
0.2915093899,
-0.5201028585,
-0.0926295072,
0.0570114776,
-0.0099325739,
0.0519063435,
-0.4065454602,
0.1303519309,
-0.6330817342,
0.1841265112,
0.3363924623,
0.3782661259,
0.4495069087,
-0.4536709189,
-0.2118097991,
-0.8710807562,
0.7224443555,
-0.5209887624,
0.5576306581,
0.2471936643,
0.5510413647,
-0.152520299,
-0.3909761906,
-0.4548504353,
-0.1819508076,
-0.000361731,
0.1881486475,
0.1139813513,
0.1320477873,
0.4312794805,
0.1028919965,
-0.7744925618,
0.0007174085,
-0.5184556842,
0.0530534722,
0.4712849557,
0.2726528943,
0.2139098048,
-0.1332778782,
-0.4704322815,
-0.01558246,
-0.9298748374,
-0.1127652526,
-0.1269662529,
0.2385968864,
-0.1340595335,
0.4008370936,
-0.0808680728,
0.3516151011,
-0.154281646,
0.0019354445,
0.0449200794,
-0.2869534791,
-0.3335395157,
-0.1167163774,
0.5691924095,
0.0265008956,
0.3210599124,
-0.2146880925,
-0.1028093919,
-0.3081819713,
0.21758838,
-0.6991904974,
-0.3593058288,
0.332580179,
0.1303934306,
0.03414822,
-0.0884904265,
-0.6088266969,
-0.365937084,
-0.4308276176,
-0.0820844397,
-0.5614547133,
-0.1746606827,
0.4418813884,
0.1017058045,
0.2259785086,
0.4764038622,
-1.2309868336,
-0.0266547464,
0.7007302046,
0.5814275742,
0.0206214208,
-0.5036922097,
0.1835966259,
0.5791876316,
-0.2810890973,
0.8209974766,
-0.4574582875,
-0.3426215649,
-0.0541154444,
-0.3608363271,
-0.0224098545,
-0.68993783,
0.5219869614,
-0.227477476,
-0.1938851476,
-0.1921119839,
-0.3009858727,
0.0208251774,
0.6726603508,
-0.4243472815,
1.4412202835,
0.1995283812,
-0.455458045,
0.4014202654,
-0.8366225958,
-0.3458206058,
0.3132197559,
-0.1750745475,
-0.1237095818,
0.0170985479,
0.7904416919,
0.4462827146,
-0.1365709901,
0.5999393463,
-0.2501539886,
-0.3796233535,
-0.1866338253,
-0.0735075623,
0.5153613687,
0.0929071754,
-0.3053627908,
0.0598904453,
-0.7166953087,
-0.002775043,
0.1681041569,
-0.5641644001,
-0.1540264636,
0.0476586781,
-0.0112666972,
0.1333544403,
0.391859144,
-0.642760098,
0.4066200256,
-0.5749093294,
0.5643570423,
0.5550876856,
-0.1524654925,
0.7358738184,
-0.3223777115,
0.4955708981,
-0.261094749,
0.0687923133,
0.1749802679,
-0.3500239253,
-0.5195862055,
-0.3633013964,
-0.1142913327,
0.6060156226,
-0.9369100332,
0.3507800102,
-0.7267815471,
-0.714448452,
-0.382378459,
0.1224042028,
-0.0787463933,
0.2549482882,
0.2253251672,
0.3308283985,
-0.7713531852,
-0.5161910057,
-0.004763491,
0.0182765853,
-0.2609866261,
0.5893179774,
0.6907278299,
-0.186096698,
1.0031952858,
-0.4728152454,
-0.1104632244,
-0.3375238776,
-0.3125225008,
0.0838220567,
0.4271991253,
0.5454477072,
-0.5004653931,
-0.279119432,
0.0656081438,
-0.7563729286,
-0.2110187262,
0.1009387225,
-0.2093989998,
-0.3498866558,
0.4621999264,
-0.7652228475,
0.2531003952,
0.4909240603,
-0.2763531804,
0.6155369282,
-0.3913058341,
0.134686321,
-0.8459048271,
-0.1627488583,
-0.0501163527,
-0.2382792979,
-0.4499663413,
0.5434336066,
-0.1354734004,
-0.5682953596,
-0.3770953715,
0.7736942172,
-0.083989732,
-0.2708877027,
-0.1579093486,
0.6090197563,
0.0490520075,
0.5257202983,
0.2524258494,
0.8833345175,
0.347589761,
-0.3218944669,
0.4861592352,
0.3859462142,
-0.8155133128,
0.1261135638,
-0.5728415847,
0.3089538813,
-0.0217104275,
0.3759348989,
-0.8495793343,
-0.2380358875,
0.0424994454,
-0.0853212923,
-0.3695572615,
-0.083662115,
-1.078669548,
-0.4039318264,
-0.009591518,
0.4416073561,
0.130994007,
-0.8537057638,
0.608941555,
0.2188905329,
-0.0704702437,
0.0119307507,
-0.7033492327,
0.0312856063,
-0.2475144714,
-0.6925420761,
-0.1299552172,
-0.2727569938,
-0.2419680953,
-0.2532712221,
0.2423479855,
-0.112655364,
0.1667993963,
-0.0278719254,
0.0764176771,
0.1085168272,
0.2408027053,
-0.0998796299,
0.0147988414,
0.1119482443,
-0.6350332499,
0.4747976959,
-0.1431165636,
-0.5102571845,
0.2772291303,
0.2131578326,
0.5098454952,
-0.4144395292,
0.3726736605,
0.6018413901,
-0.4196175635,
-0.4172443151,
-0.3002599776,
-0.0416492708,
-0.4669494629,
0.5520606637,
-0.4108629525,
-1.1890180111,
0.447414875,
-0.4777311683,
0.1948345453,
-0.0733970925,
0.6861815453,
-0.3281877339,
0.8367701769,
0.490260601,
-0.0318686031,
0.36449036,
-0.1369704902,
0.4580174088,
-0.9431260228,
-0.3483982384,
-0.3009026051,
-0.3819419444,
-0.4880955815,
-0.8960021138,
0.6356392503,
0.0529583097,
-0.6460800171,
0.2707095742,
-0.5538610816,
0.727689743,
0.4739444852,
0.2405557632,
0.2961137891,
0.2127597183,
-0.1120970696,
-0.1790109873,
-1.0103936195,
-0.4200230241,
0.8969860673,
0.3182194233,
0.7274869084,
0.3665294349,
0.5161859989,
0.0797380432,
0.1274419874,
-0.5889251828,
0.6226226091,
-0.1010567546,
-0.6564564109,
-0.4018267691,
-0.3769563437,
-0.8019406796,
0.214547649,
-0.2286405414,
-0.870129168,
-0.0487261489,
-0.0517572537,
-0.5125843883,
0.4283209741,
-0.4967164993,
0.5777112246,
-0.4166557193,
-0.2631866634,
-0.4410843551,
-0.0075409124,
0.1883614063,
-0.1446779817,
0.5272921324,
-0.1309026182,
0.1195747852,
0.2048175484,
-0.1002267525,
0.8866038918,
-0.213683784,
-0.4045482576,
0.1589542031,
0.0339382738,
0.5608163476,
0.1298869401,
-0.0450370088,
0.3447366953,
-0.1846212298,
-0.4671032131,
-0.7950755358,
0.703497529,
-0.7459075451,
-0.40208143,
0.1615931392,
-0.983528614,
-0.4036163688,
0.0289707053,
-0.0319381803,
0.430790931,
-0.322881192,
-0.102979891,
0.7436398268,
-0.260410279,
0.1694160551,
0.403216511,
-0.5380090475,
-0.4278150201,
0.8081078529,
-0.1557450593,
-0.0312138293,
0.5254660249,
0.3516226709,
-0.254539907,
-0.6122871637,
-0.5369333029,
-0.1385313421,
-0.7349191904,
-0.0469114259,
-0.1228475571,
-0.0916568413,
-0.3834860325,
-0.4928103983,
-0.1678452939,
-0.2117545903,
0.3002655506,
-0.3408825994,
0.101387538,
1.1275280714,
-0.0646376461,
0.293099165,
-0.8068928719,
-0.0030844219,
0.2015498728,
0.3403035998,
0.2162116915,
-0.2791109383,
-0.7470138669,
0.2079026848,
-0.1089209169,
-0.3200463355,
0.2478642762,
-0.2973051369,
0.3144297004,
0.1958673894,
-0.267375201,
0.7665561438,
-0.6010176539,
0.7146606445,
-0.2134716064,
-0.738720417,
0.779389739,
-0.8002265096,
0.7536779046,
0.318381995,
-0.0487451069,
-0.3283800483,
-0.5107184649,
-0.4904522002,
-0.7348634601,
0.4142031372,
0.124878183,
-0.0716292262,
-0.0058051031,
0.5493048429,
-0.1622953564,
0.109046638,
-0.6959459186,
0.259850204,
-0.180145815,
-0.2723838687,
0.0277815089,
-0.1483908147,
-0.1682348102,
-0.5576584339,
0.5400146246,
-0.2075165808,
0.0911633745,
0.1968666464,
-0.1109234542,
0.2168731689,
0.3886165321,
0.5111457109,
0.6807205677,
-0.125455603,
-0.0240175705,
0.5933349729,
-0.4267925918,
0.0513942726,
-0.0019987852,
-0.2610276639,
-0.6104844809,
0.5492348075,
0.6466513872,
0.5093896389,
-0.7498098016,
0.2402968109,
0.0486580841,
-0.1649360806,
-0.3151299357,
-0.0440220386,
0.1273398548,
0.5901573896,
0.283833921,
-0.1167006195,
-0.009874125,
-0.3381407261,
-0.0077665281,
0.2340567112,
-0.28198421,
-0.0583153665,
0.6440592408,
0.3709605336,
0.0004899178,
0.8621223569,
-0.3059518635,
-0.5799590349,
0.6111562252,
0.6269295216,
0.7169434428,
0.0327780396,
-0.1709053516,
0.6187934279,
0.6459800601,
0.0879902691,
0.2666305304,
-0.0152384415,
-1.0674418211,
-0.7291615009,
-0.6189929843,
-0.3074978292,
0.1355096698,
-0.2278384566,
-0.0662187189,
-0.7653466463,
0.1801601648,
-0.7069000602,
0.329290092,
-0.5767546892,
0.1720852256,
0.3405769765,
1.1756358147,
-0.7376990914,
0.9246841073,
1.149186492,
0.0462347977,
-0.9736475945,
0.0643141717,
-0.2384851128,
-0.843970418,
0.6265903711,
-0.1386243701,
-0.1408181936,
0.0977889672,
-0.8137907386,
-0.7672261,
1.2489106655,
0.4597725868,
-0.9145359993,
-0.0800230056,
0.6052511334,
0.545553565,
-0.4031087458,
0.1407578737,
0.7384517193,
0.6304418445,
0.1114013568,
-0.9043833017,
0.0909356549,
0.2437097728,
0.0999651998,
0.2218405306,
-0.6821708083,
0.3399277031,
-0.4920231104,
-0.0808487907,
0.1424452513,
0.5077436566,
0.6278133392,
-0.0457998812,
0.450575918,
0.9241857529,
0.9126348495,
-0.3822531402,
0.9957627654,
-0.3619734943,
0.4069542289,
1.0672037601,
-0.1225806847,
0.8072371483,
0.0729777738,
-0.1084278077,
0.337043047,
0.5324705243,
-0.1889861375,
0.5295469165,
0.2921147943,
-0.3726401329,
-0.5498464108,
0.0478562713,
0.0968546122,
0.7135125399,
0.5150591731,
0.3859261572,
-0.4790386856,
0.2250785679,
-0.1334311068,
0.1722385585,
-0.357216835,
0.6547925472,
0.0765265226,
-0.3446603119,
0.1301585734,
-0.0717835501,
0.3905967176,
-0.6022465229,
-0.2119128555,
-0.2635845244,
0.2044841349,
-0.2321398109,
-1.0162028074,
0.2975162566,
-0.1714839488,
-0.2960297465,
-0.3051036894,
0.6971960068,
-0.5980893373,
-0.403857559,
0.2798476815,
0.4099567831,
0.1576460004,
-0.1009157896,
-0.6552093029,
-0.0222540814,
0.0528574139,
0.0620361567,
0.2202669978,
0.7290896773,
-0.2333676666,
1.0036331415,
0.6926100254,
0.30839625,
-0.1764530241,
0.3259171844,
0.6184094548,
-0.4895986021,
-0.3421391249,
-0.6955077052,
0.2483471036,
-0.0209544767,
-0.0846920386,
0.6813439131,
0.7898747921,
0.8823520541,
0.0976879895,
1.0443031788,
-0.0980519727,
0.3001589775,
-0.4992902875,
0.6282393932,
-0.2391228378,
0.5834257603,
0.1658597142,
-0.8544741869,
-0.2391586006,
0.6458975673,
-0.6545934677,
0.070502162,
0.4750182629,
0.6447889209,
-0.199607715,
-0.1627630293,
0.5034386516,
0.2008166164,
0.5861650109,
0.9962578416,
0.9207985997,
-0.2367521226,
0.7847604752,
-0.1032275409,
-0.2554064691,
0.2523947954,
-0.6916729212,
-1.1040540934,
-0.2423406392,
-0.057216011,
0.096715197,
0.0494720973,
0.6886900067,
0.8467739224,
-0.526402235,
-0.1005441546,
-0.1941046268,
0.0394902676,
-0.0256442968,
-0.2646131516,
0.4210758507,
-0.0615939908,
-0.9150753617,
0.6848275661,
0.358915031,
-0.0104652327,
-0.4283972681,
-0.0397525057,
0.1508196741,
-0.0789451748,
0.7004430294,
-0.006675642,
-0.3465699852,
-0.5374052525,
-0.1722488105,
-0.2177752107,
0.0273365639,
0.8363764286,
-0.6971927881,
0.1649837494,
0.2459029406,
0.5109208226,
0.490790695,
-0.1000992879,
0.6481044292,
-1.165818572,
0.2166149765,
0.0459706821,
0.5841363668,
0.6120842099,
-0.3377005756,
0.6495110393,
-0.0117862523,
-0.8161616325,
-0.0882465839,
0.4102027714,
-0.6122095585,
-0.2376593351,
1.2439669371,
0.0311721489,
-0.0456160568,
-0.1668286473,
-0.2970853746,
-0.0493178964,
-0.4778900743,
0.9442094564,
0.6684256196,
0.1346400827,
-0.3041427732,
-0.8983169198,
0.2266810238,
0.0843542367,
-1.0201207399,
0.3610735238,
0.4234218001,
0.2701025903,
0.0445214845,
0.6515412927,
0.0901544243,
0.0832445174,
0.0289576631,
0.2969303429,
-0.2199069113,
-0.2997223139,
-0.1991482675,
-0.0525011085,
0.1697228104,
0.1415303051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13947v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13947v1 | AspirinSum: an Aspect-based utility-preserved de-identification Summarization framework | 2024-06-20T02:29:46 | 2024-06-20T02:29:46 | Ya-Lun Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Due to the rapid advancement of Large Language Model (LLM), the whole
community eagerly consumes any available text data in order to train the LLM.
Currently, large portion of the available text data are collected from
internet, which has been thought as a cheap source of the training data.
However, when people try to extend the LLM's capability to the personal related
domain, such as healthcare or education, the lack of public dataset in these
domains make the adaption of the LLM in such domains much slower. The reason of
lacking public available dataset in such domains is because they usually
contain personal sensitive information. In order to comply with privacy law,
the data in such domains need to be de-identified before any kind of
dissemination. It had been much research tried to address this problem for the
image or tabular data. However, there was limited research on the efficient and
general de-identification method for text data. Most of the method based on
human annotation or predefined category list. It usually can not be easily
adapted to specific domains. The goal of this proposal is to develop a text
de-identification framework, which can be easily adapted to the specific
domain, leverage the existing expert knowledge without further human
annotation. We propose an aspect-based utility-preserved de-identification
summarization framework, AspirinSum, by learning to align expert's aspect from
existing comment data, it can efficiently summarize the personal sensitive
document by extracting personal sensitive aspect related sub-sentence and
de-identify it by substituting it with similar aspect sub-sentence. We envision
that the de-identified text can then be used in data publishing, eventually
publishing our de-identified dataset for downstream task use. | [
-0.1574752778,
-0.7147132754,
0.1783507466,
0.024403153,
-0.3679035008,
0.0691619366,
-0.3308471739,
-0.3757092059,
0.3562143445,
0.8194674253,
-0.075371623,
-0.6242798567,
-0.587867856,
0.0894859433,
-0.3686448336,
1.1150565147,
-0.1123183295,
-0.4164981842,
-0.412409693,
-0.0523095168,
-0.0556577668,
-0.819437027,
-0.6506206989,
-0.3190092146,
0.4216311872,
0.5872654915,
0.175469622,
0.7149599791,
0.6211085916,
0.3368723989,
-0.35597229,
0.0815726966,
-0.2385838479,
0.102449283,
-0.4528766572,
-0.2157095671,
-0.7165036201,
-0.1747763455,
0.5989887714,
0.7085027099,
0.3009062409,
0.3360541463,
0.5139981508,
0.821446836,
-0.8339468241,
0.0354204141,
-0.4665086567,
-0.1682459861,
-0.1911984384,
-0.3590552509,
0.0142732635,
-0.338218689,
-0.0330650955,
-0.5010812879,
0.315220356,
-0.0932919756,
1.0670950413,
0.0080784643,
-0.618819356,
-0.2891561389,
-0.5668443441,
0.6325842738,
-0.5859504342,
-0.1419409513,
0.6948984265,
0.1433726549,
-0.1116512269,
-0.4673365057,
-0.3775885105,
0.1542796642,
-0.2719919384,
-0.070321247,
0.1574358642,
0.090573065,
-0.1330094486,
0.540466845,
-0.3674334884,
0.1487283111,
-0.2756570578,
-0.2822714746,
0.6679685712,
-0.0319546983,
0.0710536316,
-0.4721417725,
-0.4178683162,
0.2648220062,
-0.8209497333,
0.0411787443,
0.2023609728,
0.47930637,
-0.15625377,
0.5058627725,
-0.4570268095,
0.2518741786,
0.0510442741,
-0.1692575812,
0.3780247867,
-0.1157698557,
-0.4935885668,
0.2605771422,
0.8068181872,
0.4537137449,
0.0687823594,
0.048079662,
-0.0321370512,
-0.2685442567,
0.0477168001,
-1.0420765877,
-0.3901840746,
0.5247780085,
-0.4433391988,
-0.2730590701,
-0.0870397016,
-0.8097203374,
-0.7120088339,
-0.2713834047,
0.3601043224,
-0.6689369678,
-0.2797601223,
-0.2953905761,
-0.0032029669,
-0.2843302786,
0.6885929704,
-0.9918413162,
0.3150552511,
0.9526720047,
0.7427277565,
-0.3350590169,
0.0217369758,
-0.1964607686,
0.3711620569,
-0.0300739631,
0.8872050047,
-0.4812813401,
-0.443780154,
0.0754370913,
0.1883890927,
0.0873589516,
-0.6292594671,
0.5354314446,
-0.3939987719,
0.1628998816,
-0.4185219705,
-0.4191238582,
-0.6174060702,
0.6320905685,
-0.4816153646,
0.6243115664,
0.0245807935,
-1.0242648125,
0.4956385195,
-0.704723537,
-0.5104712248,
0.1596665382,
-0.1390324533,
-0.813297987,
0.0570467673,
0.2776290774,
0.5285310149,
-0.3514225781,
0.3374828398,
-0.193642512,
-0.1603856385,
0.4484036863,
-0.3264575899,
0.7355774641,
0.3497309685,
-0.0600778274,
0.2151646316,
-0.6785864234,
-0.2910232246,
-0.1216001138,
-0.3923790753,
-0.8236830235,
0.0009830336,
0.2957124412,
-0.0787015706,
0.5715326667,
-0.4770967066,
0.0610620491,
-0.4276114106,
0.1351716965,
0.7016977668,
0.3523084521,
0.3815970123,
-0.3632534742,
0.433763057,
0.2727036178,
0.0392639264,
-0.1867268085,
-0.251514256,
-0.7274746299,
-0.5015099049,
0.669644177,
0.4641295671,
-0.7470134497,
0.6857661605,
-0.5286533237,
-0.1808012724,
-0.1518678069,
0.1808546782,
0.6204584241,
0.5250251293,
0.2032056302,
-0.3483411968,
-0.3254351914,
-1.0018004179,
-0.4354977906,
0.0297394656,
-0.3169064522,
0.3736914098,
0.4668471813,
-0.1164907664,
1.0150692463,
-0.5653575659,
-0.6673128605,
-0.4633092284,
0.0675996765,
0.1063643247,
0.6167542934,
0.4657568038,
-1.1580357552,
-0.4674121141,
0.1379993856,
-0.5682551861,
-0.2367468476,
0.2293857783,
-0.0181777142,
0.286513865,
0.0857015625,
0.1246615797,
0.4646576643,
0.4653642178,
-0.6416239142,
0.096406281,
-0.4304074943,
0.7127384543,
-1.4481582642,
0.6083171368,
0.1578739136,
-0.4573915303,
-0.5812391639,
-0.0256420039,
0.2688149214,
-0.1938584894,
-0.3275603056,
0.5717331171,
-0.4317620397,
0.2350316495,
-0.4518025815,
0.2001225948,
-0.0476663895,
0.5322671533,
0.1009874269,
0.4289957583,
0.3194407225,
-0.8872674108,
-0.295003593,
0.3045382202,
0.028280763,
0.7483332157,
-0.3044909835,
-0.075585328,
-0.2125235647,
-0.1098656431,
-0.7737993002,
-0.3209469616,
0.4096462429,
-0.3790682852,
0.3403069973,
-0.2968592942,
-0.371538341,
0.0986444205,
-0.4949587882,
0.2426563501,
0.2892683446,
-0.3722825646,
0.7549408078,
0.8714585304,
-0.5308949947,
-0.5592965484,
-0.4649032056,
0.1306697279,
-0.5508677959,
-0.1277320236,
0.6688747406,
0.2117739469,
-0.1599074751,
0.179174006,
-0.0763847828,
-0.4319112897,
0.3009714186,
0.5226602554,
0.1146782339,
0.1617854238,
0.3243879974,
0.4797920287,
-0.2988529801,
-0.219378069,
0.1790954322,
0.3111473918,
0.3605097234,
-0.2082065046,
-0.5125003457,
0.6199662685,
0.1362550259,
-0.1060948744,
0.4108530581,
0.1702826619,
-0.519918561,
0.0900725126,
-0.3880917132,
0.1294080764,
-0.5082173944,
0.4001893997,
-0.3045601547,
-0.81832546,
0.4743282199,
-0.4824757278,
0.2349117249,
0.5347273946,
0.4938602448,
0.0514451787,
0.1771799326,
0.7694499493,
-0.2327804416,
0.491855979,
-0.1275533587,
-0.0149560943,
-0.971442461,
-0.217391476,
-0.5953291059,
-0.4660409987,
-0.3964657187,
-0.2571850717,
0.5150759816,
0.1118086874,
-0.1036822572,
0.2228693813,
-0.7189387679,
0.3453127742,
0.3394373655,
0.3510768712,
0.5692651868,
0.0040137176,
0.3446478844,
0.1039189324,
-0.1150677726,
-0.641438663,
1.2021820545,
0.2916544676,
0.5888164043,
0.2478505522,
0.803706646,
0.481243223,
0.5520020127,
-0.5665565729,
0.5389870405,
-0.5350286961,
-0.6187857389,
-0.1765517741,
-0.5552660227,
-1.1215484142,
0.1383722425,
-0.218835935,
-1.0211158991,
0.240183115,
0.5350853801,
-0.4490931332,
0.1316326112,
-0.6258610487,
0.6160585284,
-0.0400281139,
-0.2960138917,
-0.1605705619,
-0.3683853149,
0.1046927348,
-0.2051014602,
0.227328226,
-0.3930864334,
-0.1920862794,
1.143964529,
-0.5254299045,
0.9014410377,
-0.3872400522,
0.0829188004,
0.2350147367,
-0.0257504545,
0.2068226933,
0.138602376,
0.0687594488,
0.178174451,
-0.0154668745,
-0.2050467581,
-0.5327323675,
0.8881807923,
-0.6340069771,
-0.569391489,
-0.3977278471,
-0.105575338,
-0.2078632414,
0.2944662571,
0.2818382978,
0.5980528593,
-0.1997381151,
0.2246460319,
0.5876760483,
-0.2220281363,
0.6597645879,
0.7287247181,
-0.1009365171,
-0.7023240924,
0.9304449558,
0.2260796279,
-0.162196964,
0.8236070871,
0.3743335009,
-0.2356429696,
-0.6514750123,
-0.1514045745,
0.0164738912,
-0.5459659696,
-0.4687391818,
-0.9287056327,
-0.1273746341,
-0.4326986372,
-0.2949716747,
-0.3132124543,
-0.4649509788,
-0.3994899094,
0.224435389,
0.6573430896,
0.5517219901,
0.163144201,
0.2482584864,
-0.6282510757,
0.3226350248,
0.0703211501,
0.2739429772,
-0.0688990057,
-0.6036040783,
-0.281909287,
0.0088870712,
-0.3008919358,
-0.7306744456,
0.6049177051,
0.2745439112,
0.2540188432,
0.5284273624,
0.305556953,
0.4917938411,
-0.2558804452,
0.669704318,
0.1256140023,
-0.9521222711,
0.5278172493,
-0.2250831574,
0.0496281013,
0.8684954643,
0.3910597563,
-0.4773986638,
-0.3153429627,
-0.6368842125,
-1.3229337931,
0.4431288242,
0.1365134418,
0.0283425599,
0.404084295,
0.3912546039,
0.3572772443,
0.4948984385,
-0.3857865632,
-0.2830361128,
-0.0288794283,
-0.4388783872,
-0.0954338834,
-0.4172071517,
-0.1085054502,
-0.2132915556,
0.7577869296,
-0.1037406549,
0.1638294905,
0.3535421789,
-0.1529141963,
0.299271971,
0.5137143731,
0.4741435051,
0.3494659066,
-0.2110957354,
0.3561536074,
-0.0077018198,
-0.8401534557,
0.2126389891,
0.1195626855,
-0.0671447217,
-0.1995985657,
0.1705277413,
0.2745898068,
0.2520596683,
-0.4503533244,
0.760291636,
0.2102941424,
-0.0739874393,
-0.616682291,
0.195073694,
-0.1888961345,
-0.0769846216,
0.5498372912,
-0.0378592014,
0.3931778073,
-0.3686203361,
0.3183733821,
0.1382410377,
-0.601228416,
-0.3587251008,
0.6139537096,
0.4249450862,
-0.4310820699,
0.2075232863,
-0.2351366132,
-0.3927097321,
0.4777837694,
0.3113613725,
1.1063870192,
-0.330611527,
0.0333331153,
0.0654943883,
-0.1136907861,
0.2241443843,
0.3361509144,
-0.1236299798,
-0.6282063127,
-0.2971602082,
-0.6055828929,
-0.206863448,
0.1670261174,
-0.5398318172,
0.255220741,
-0.5752997398,
-0.1697314233,
0.0729609579,
0.2513632178,
-0.4489597678,
0.3215898275,
-0.1312917322,
0.617895484,
-1.0683175325,
0.9208968282,
0.7330848575,
-0.1697403044,
-0.5294359922,
0.1779830158,
0.2722171545,
-0.441737026,
0.3657325804,
0.1052901968,
0.1149660721,
-0.203621015,
-0.1656036228,
-0.6717757583,
1.1037977934,
0.2453983277,
-0.3128932714,
0.2545626462,
-0.0477521792,
0.533927381,
-0.3479771614,
0.1023573503,
0.3908315301,
0.31654495,
0.4451802671,
-0.9760125279,
0.36668998,
-0.4716005325,
-0.0087187514,
0.2464691848,
-0.6199824214,
0.8237698674,
0.0127174063,
-0.1865922362,
-0.1394194514,
0.6387495995,
0.0346684605,
0.4174916446,
0.3386518657,
0.2372000962,
0.6411424875,
0.0405253433,
0.744163096,
-0.2366810143,
0.392306298,
1.0996545553,
-0.1283660531,
0.9309861064,
0.2586970329,
0.0347520486,
0.2884663343,
0.4868989885,
0.2386172861,
0.6006372571,
-0.1431082338,
-0.3285799325,
-0.0033952799,
-0.2143303603,
-0.2007895559,
0.5238016248,
0.5302057862,
-0.7335397005,
-0.204006359,
0.0477572307,
0.4122782648,
0.1702391952,
-0.5606452227,
1.13618505,
-0.0405255109,
-0.3661979735,
0.3579021692,
0.166877225,
0.8071298599,
-0.4910161793,
0.0810676068,
-0.145817101,
0.2206529677,
-0.4261031449,
-0.5744072199,
0.3602672815,
0.030576231,
-0.0923246071,
-0.1129682437,
0.8179191351,
-0.5695723295,
-0.4136429131,
-0.3125741184,
0.216270119,
0.1709606797,
-0.265206784,
-0.4819046557,
-0.1671814322,
0.086946778,
-0.1857073605,
0.7067911625,
0.5726038814,
-0.1131720394,
0.4882320464,
0.2328674942,
0.2303496599,
-0.8481794596,
-0.1736574918,
1.0349160433,
-0.7736180425,
-0.9529953599,
-0.9336902499,
0.6449623108,
-0.6180920601,
-0.4424037933,
0.7705563307,
0.8034640551,
0.085201852,
0.1061439514,
0.900021255,
-0.2193825543,
0.8936068416,
-0.4908682108,
1.2146624327,
-0.5117326379,
0.2152741849,
-0.5219329,
-0.4891634881,
-0.4058223963,
0.2600774467,
-0.4278768599,
-0.066666767,
0.7542440295,
0.637701869,
-0.0556018278,
-0.114825435,
0.2683555484,
0.0073754941,
0.4845983982,
0.4064718485,
0.1087799892,
-0.272788316,
0.2172403932,
-0.2185239792,
-0.6309661269,
-0.60900563,
-0.9400719404,
-1.2084027529,
-0.9750716686,
-0.7280886173,
-0.12429896,
0.0787650943,
0.9766519666,
0.4275961518,
-1.0354319811,
0.1069465429,
0.1875090897,
0.0706336722,
-0.3072892427,
-0.2151925266,
0.9246958494,
0.1436607689,
-0.6618002057,
-0.1036741957,
0.4874386191,
0.133215785,
-0.0668974146,
0.4576409459,
0.0745781958,
-0.0859897584,
0.4570097625,
0.3582515419,
-0.3542049229,
-0.3659124672,
-0.4917885065,
0.0537994877,
0.1245244071,
1.0280302763,
-0.6808235049,
0.3519023955,
0.3900696337,
0.511479497,
0.1386492103,
0.5015087724,
0.4994482696,
-0.8077247143,
0.3411999345,
0.2946905196,
0.1751901954,
0.4084881246,
-0.7775819898,
0.1999760568,
0.0665976629,
-0.5424329042,
-0.4910233915,
-0.0283795465,
-0.9372353554,
-0.3627035916,
1.2938174009,
-0.4300115705,
-0.6556457877,
-0.6119933128,
-0.2459196895,
0.0808795393,
-0.6963983774,
1.0789504051,
-0.0325851105,
-0.117802009,
-0.0057143243,
0.0158832055,
0.8238607049,
-0.1170271412,
-0.9853292108,
0.4461204112,
0.3111191988,
0.4366958141,
0.2219208479,
0.9868765473,
-0.1546231657,
-0.1582691222,
-0.1303625107,
0.0822722316,
-0.3850738704,
-0.2246041745,
-0.2764401734,
0.6786335707,
0.0734548941,
-0.504121542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13945v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13945v1 | CityBench: Evaluating the Capabilities of Large Language Model as World Model | 2024-06-20T02:25:07 | 2024-06-20T02:25:07 | Jie Feng, Jun Zhang, Junbo Yan, Xin Zhang, Tianjian Ouyang, Tianhui Liu, Yuwei Du, Siqi Guo, Yong Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) with powerful generalization ability has been
widely used in many domains. A systematic and reliable evaluation of LLMs is a
crucial step in their development and applications, especially for specific
professional fields. In the urban domain, there have been some early
explorations about the usability of LLMs, but a systematic and scalable
evaluation benchmark is still lacking. The challenge in constructing a
systematic evaluation benchmark for the urban domain lies in the diversity of
data and scenarios, as well as the complex and dynamic nature of cities. In
this paper, we propose CityBench, an interactive simulator based evaluation
platform, as the first systematic evaluation benchmark for the capability of
LLMs for urban domain. First, we build CitySim to integrate the multi-source
data and simulate fine-grained urban dynamics. Based on CitySim, we design 7
tasks in 2 categories of perception-understanding and decision-making group to
evaluate the capability of LLMs as city-scale world model for urban domain. Due
to the flexibility and ease-of-use of CitySim, our evaluation platform
CityBench can be easily extended to any city in the world. We evaluate 13
well-known LLMs including open source LLMs and commercial LLMs in 13 cities
around the world. Extensive experiments demonstrate the scalability and
effectiveness of proposed CityBench and shed lights for the future development
of LLMs in urban domain. The dataset, benchmark and source codes are openly
accessible to the research community via
https://github.com/tsinghua-fib-lab/CityBench | [
-0.461242497,
-0.7982753515,
0.7124944925,
0.5282598734,
-0.1067237854,
0.3338563144,
-0.4758408666,
-0.4396650791,
-0.1517766863,
0.2256752849,
-0.1856428087,
-0.8647850752,
-0.1141385064,
-0.0584693402,
-0.4768698514,
0.3321757019,
-0.2379035354,
0.3755466044,
-0.4477271438,
-0.1939925104,
-0.4401997924,
-0.3391162455,
-0.6919589639,
-0.452213794,
0.0357194804,
0.3618323803,
0.4108697474,
0.4389297664,
0.5830997825,
0.3342714012,
-0.0168595687,
-0.1371154189,
-0.4751304388,
-0.166237697,
-0.454523325,
-0.0266926028,
-0.4386241138,
-0.1461064816,
0.7863690853,
0.7447380424,
-0.4868238866,
0.3545078635,
0.045815289,
0.3672200441,
-0.3117747009,
0.2464908063,
-0.3177734315,
-0.1034422368,
-0.1347424239,
0.1692843735,
-0.0284799878,
-0.4036510885,
0.0976208374,
-0.2187710553,
-0.1140402183,
0.3363231719,
0.4203662276,
-0.0065773465,
-0.4513960183,
-0.061637681,
-0.9402180314,
0.7597621679,
-0.5469486713,
0.6235921383,
-0.1252397597,
0.7839770317,
-0.2212164402,
-0.6239314675,
-0.5057200789,
-0.4140338898,
0.2177105248,
0.1039653271,
-0.0423105173,
-0.0190960709,
0.32317698,
0.3425109386,
-0.6930685043,
0.1370397508,
-0.2759652436,
0.0195926838,
0.4707374871,
0.5687307119,
0.1469620466,
-0.3382555544,
-0.5433946848,
-0.0721636489,
-0.4702608287,
0.0726514533,
0.0416878462,
0.2288811356,
-0.3928261697,
0.291585207,
-0.3640249968,
0.4081966579,
-0.3251661956,
-0.2379746139,
0.4767299592,
-0.4130862355,
-0.2588246167,
-0.3233896494,
0.8956933022,
0.3970940113,
0.1128599495,
-0.3384789228,
-0.1596971303,
-0.1808328182,
0.1188940704,
-0.8201267123,
0.0930171162,
0.441781491,
-0.2711929977,
-0.1502685696,
-0.0697280541,
-0.9693570137,
-0.3702644706,
-0.2237290144,
-0.2285952568,
-0.2433176637,
-0.3442876339,
0.1938291192,
0.2174396068,
0.3364605308,
0.5762863159,
-0.6537459493,
0.4469462931,
0.6149181128,
0.8387059569,
-0.5276565552,
-0.3711977005,
-0.0356441997,
0.2374715656,
-0.2509629726,
0.7267119288,
-0.3531904817,
-0.5044041276,
-0.0921062827,
-0.2462119311,
0.2568314373,
-0.7279854417,
0.662422955,
-0.3227162957,
-0.5133778453,
0.0319947824,
-0.3180924058,
-0.0331255831,
0.5903924704,
-0.732676208,
1.3947952986,
0.1806190312,
-0.4348029494,
0.3152773976,
-0.7645694613,
-0.2414229065,
0.3030489385,
-0.2484351546,
-0.122437939,
0.0214476567,
0.1543467045,
0.1657003462,
-0.5507529974,
0.7203826904,
-0.5191277266,
-0.5200707316,
0.0667994171,
-0.2021961808,
0.6553066373,
0.2733005285,
-0.2865466475,
0.1574413627,
-0.9327679276,
0.003226652,
0.1184047759,
-0.4887772799,
-0.1819405556,
0.0306870397,
0.3250438869,
0.3728390932,
0.3859620988,
-0.813305378,
0.3238459527,
-0.3665795922,
0.2411896586,
0.5175146461,
-0.1322404444,
0.3678835332,
-0.062949203,
0.7377179265,
-0.1984882802,
0.12939924,
0.2853237092,
-0.111773096,
-0.5353634953,
-0.3230278492,
0.427206248,
0.4296261072,
-0.6650067568,
0.289848417,
-0.6175403595,
-0.7535048127,
-0.4523458779,
0.0958301276,
0.004893241,
-0.0074369963,
-0.0635160655,
-0.1491283029,
-0.7963951826,
-0.7759783268,
-0.0893295854,
-0.0362712704,
-0.0809931681,
0.370313853,
0.6200227141,
-0.2824084759,
1.0125975609,
-0.1664559692,
-0.0327679478,
-0.4798496366,
-0.0890392661,
0.0791445002,
0.3116743267,
0.747816205,
-0.4521254003,
-0.293956846,
-0.246338129,
-0.6140054464,
-0.3052296042,
0.1196862459,
-0.2541245818,
-0.1885497123,
0.4366342425,
-0.6210458279,
0.3048796654,
0.7158999443,
0.059937086,
0.6963742375,
-0.0017173401,
0.1979657561,
-0.8537838459,
0.3685232401,
-0.1477647722,
-0.4588289261,
-0.313058883,
0.4697800875,
-0.0554822385,
-0.407052964,
-0.5574173331,
0.992487371,
-0.0485118106,
-0.4642959237,
-0.0295016859,
0.5606831908,
-0.0116765061,
0.3531388342,
-0.0905772299,
0.6773015857,
0.4122830927,
-0.2814339697,
0.7910754085,
0.0981567353,
-1.0458060503,
0.3386173546,
-0.5149643421,
0.139145866,
0.1467693448,
0.407571584,
-0.7570769191,
-0.0880685896,
-0.0074368604,
0.0851408392,
-0.4042786658,
0.0911133513,
-1.2144654989,
-0.7439485192,
-0.2806288898,
0.3193569481,
0.121317558,
-0.5484877229,
0.624578774,
0.383557409,
-0.0563453436,
-0.0091414656,
-0.5788627267,
0.2405676395,
-0.1073560715,
-0.5425925851,
-0.0371643305,
-0.4752807617,
-0.4484865069,
-0.3070827723,
0.0488784164,
-0.0825500041,
0.2860380411,
0.3262591958,
0.1579116434,
0.2238274664,
0.0278980695,
-0.268027246,
0.0088090971,
0.0966274291,
0.0474692099,
0.620331645,
-0.3321442008,
-0.4664642811,
0.0400568545,
0.1051024497,
0.6971292496,
-0.3376033604,
0.4201865494,
0.4585201442,
-0.3973118961,
-0.3100840747,
-0.4198974669,
0.2693859637,
-0.4389408827,
0.5563249588,
-0.4800495207,
-0.8472284675,
0.6353045702,
-0.7457145452,
0.1665772647,
0.0875861272,
0.7639582753,
-0.0514364392,
0.884734869,
0.5304915905,
-0.0384700298,
0.2151774317,
-0.0920375139,
0.2059380859,
-0.8383976817,
-0.3824628294,
-0.4862829149,
-0.3221382797,
-0.3997245431,
-0.6662649512,
0.5203415155,
0.2460493445,
-0.1982606351,
0.150739193,
-0.0165095404,
0.4172976315,
0.2071714252,
-0.1214594394,
0.6306566,
-0.0228762906,
-0.5634692907,
-0.0530896895,
-0.5581367612,
-0.6493025422,
0.8897637129,
0.4816353917,
0.8475461006,
0.1692738533,
0.4455606341,
0.1923151612,
0.4321907461,
-0.5875071883,
0.7993623018,
0.035143666,
-0.8001672029,
-0.1938683093,
-0.3676035404,
-0.7388160825,
0.3475471735,
-0.1956476122,
-0.8667150736,
-0.0122494074,
-0.2890360951,
-0.4270272851,
0.4327937365,
-0.215511471,
0.7481199503,
-0.5335088372,
-0.2956418097,
-0.4439556599,
-0.0988660976,
0.2887189984,
-0.3814025819,
0.6659420133,
-0.3939459324,
0.1694950312,
0.4336950183,
-0.122591503,
0.5478101373,
-0.1344435513,
-0.2277700603,
0.1494244933,
0.1650603414,
0.3178358078,
0.0306579415,
-0.5500005484,
0.571403861,
-0.0717298016,
-0.1231411025,
-0.5691815615,
0.8849952817,
-0.6224239469,
-0.2462337166,
-0.085024558,
-0.5814270973,
-0.4261986315,
0.2475915253,
-0.3916143477,
0.3929769397,
-0.8010030389,
0.2034225613,
0.0274410136,
-0.2726741731,
0.3173769414,
0.9776132703,
-1.0586813688,
-0.315205723,
0.6715139151,
-0.2290576398,
-0.057688795,
0.1666386425,
0.1754018962,
-0.1725114733,
-0.7346511483,
-0.6544198394,
-0.1990427673,
-0.5721740127,
-0.0596314482,
-0.2759879231,
-0.0357553959,
-0.0650953427,
-0.1445809901,
-0.4024770856,
-0.0645907447,
0.4165694416,
-0.2684743702,
-0.0172705352,
0.8982657194,
-0.0154097816,
0.065773651,
-0.672827065,
0.3329783976,
0.0506945141,
0.8187846541,
0.3124443293,
0.0283099823,
-0.6571557522,
0.0383013152,
-0.2976995111,
-0.3875871301,
0.2111371756,
-0.3728277087,
0.5158277154,
0.3512004018,
-0.0457796231,
0.6402691603,
-0.4859174788,
0.6307150722,
-0.138970837,
-0.7473301291,
0.3547585011,
-0.4672763944,
0.5894429088,
0.8061022162,
0.0353859253,
-0.4404799342,
-0.62075001,
-0.3881663382,
-0.7516227365,
0.5673223138,
0.0752132237,
0.001053996,
0.0235482529,
0.2536270022,
0.0922425687,
0.4235854745,
-0.6674411297,
-0.1528459638,
0.1572467089,
-0.0719952434,
0.0513385609,
-0.1833861172,
0.0189341549,
-0.4985616803,
0.3435434997,
0.0612046905,
-0.1961299777,
-0.0244903229,
-0.1702758223,
-0.1898937076,
0.5173102617,
0.2069075853,
0.971280396,
-0.4442378283,
-0.0751239806,
0.5692679286,
-0.2055387646,
0.0951343626,
0.056461446,
-0.2589994371,
-0.2098143697,
0.2544211149,
0.6860166788,
0.4863826931,
-1.0694698095,
0.5313799381,
-0.0410833731,
0.0168042574,
-0.4022628069,
-0.1288262606,
0.3057332337,
0.4894891381,
0.3261141181,
-0.168129608,
0.1755431592,
-0.589279592,
-0.0136431875,
0.3055782616,
-0.2559116483,
-0.0645223856,
0.5138399601,
0.4832249284,
-0.1044207588,
0.6082572341,
-0.3301330209,
-0.5101493597,
0.5600492954,
0.3244044185,
0.7558089495,
-0.1218056753,
-0.1380170435,
0.423638463,
0.3908093572,
0.1027798429,
0.3470179737,
0.1524317712,
-0.6228732467,
-0.4660723805,
-1.0263986588,
-0.6156642437,
0.2247180194,
-0.4362496734,
0.2923549116,
-0.6665785909,
-0.143186152,
-0.4513211846,
0.3322660923,
-0.7362491488,
0.08756084,
0.3715830147,
1.3978682756,
-0.5054914355,
0.9048874378,
0.988884151,
0.0679220259,
-0.4956865907,
0.0330014713,
-0.1298196316,
-0.6270303726,
0.5733870268,
0.0894176289,
-0.3400613368,
-0.0773578957,
-0.6297662854,
-0.6951293945,
1.1500122547,
0.411757946,
-1.048246026,
0.0930834338,
0.5749120116,
0.7178657055,
-0.4225282967,
0.4653902352,
0.7049739957,
0.8158095479,
-0.0085200686,
-1.0719721317,
0.1447672248,
-0.0069708554,
0.29604128,
-0.0714683756,
-0.9492827654,
0.4577773809,
-0.1908239126,
-0.1529923379,
0.3379133642,
0.4270072579,
0.3357076347,
-0.0627763718,
0.5749900937,
0.6854894161,
0.4398655891,
-0.1718850136,
1.0765144825,
-0.5545125008,
0.6039957404,
0.9818635583,
-0.4941509366,
0.9976778626,
0.1172994971,
-0.3910829425,
0.6707602143,
0.3694192171,
-0.2642476261,
0.4064117074,
0.5686248541,
-0.0237019863,
-0.3529633284,
-0.1022925526,
0.1162155792,
0.7127350569,
0.2330035418,
0.3589327931,
-0.6305633783,
0.1092612967,
-0.2853112519,
-0.1109659299,
-0.185432151,
0.5951605439,
0.0799435526,
-0.2132682204,
0.2344994098,
0.3911219835,
0.3833271265,
-0.7947665453,
-0.0663628727,
-0.1976822764,
0.0602300465,
-0.0935418829,
-0.7869191766,
0.1228044182,
-0.0404928848,
-0.1471912712,
-0.1136516184,
0.5380342007,
-0.3898192942,
-0.489672333,
0.7389451861,
0.4195836186,
0.2250035107,
-0.0044925781,
-0.823064208,
0.5211449265,
-0.1857958734,
-0.2692219019,
0.2275982648,
0.38942191,
-0.2035891116,
0.9131695032,
0.6687192917,
0.1777932942,
-0.3088566363,
0.4332362115,
0.6874001622,
-0.7122353911,
-0.3876193166,
-0.7343934178,
0.2539595068,
-0.1068725809,
-0.0327988751,
0.8411774039,
0.9386450052,
0.6916321516,
0.1357053369,
0.8677117229,
-0.0881794766,
0.5404645205,
-0.1316574067,
0.6908558011,
-0.469076395,
0.5085525513,
-0.2611583471,
-1.0001523495,
-0.1099493131,
0.4299381077,
-0.37758255,
0.087598078,
0.6426082253,
0.3870106041,
-0.1994460821,
-0.0926519632,
0.4505446255,
0.4021756053,
0.2600412071,
0.4781232178,
0.8080102205,
-0.1182703972,
0.6785274148,
-0.2287674546,
-0.2778368592,
-0.2615583241,
-0.8584534526,
-0.9089667797,
-0.1278156042,
-0.0182229932,
0.0516470522,
-0.0226901527,
0.7867003679,
0.7234771252,
-0.7841125727,
-0.5885902047,
0.1186841652,
0.0604402907,
-0.0482583381,
-0.2845477462,
0.1747604162,
0.2264274061,
-0.9037817121,
0.585678041,
0.410530597,
-0.0048886742,
-0.7460542321,
-0.0124222599,
0.0476431027,
-0.0823046789,
0.6282032728,
-0.0544851758,
-0.4728326201,
-0.1891239136,
-0.3803870976,
-0.451701194,
0.0340663567,
0.73806113,
-0.8727887869,
0.4383798838,
0.1957794428,
0.3253639638,
0.5742902756,
-0.0400570668,
0.6251434684,
-0.7126341462,
0.1654875427,
-0.1054767147,
0.4589667618,
0.4672296941,
0.1755496711,
0.6423604488,
-0.0584152713,
-0.359402895,
-0.4656061232,
0.1134887263,
-0.834541142,
-0.1729098707,
1.1592320204,
-0.0643877536,
-0.0450641811,
-0.1964141428,
-0.174898833,
-0.0115558598,
-0.575774014,
0.7517558932,
0.8067601919,
0.1884829253,
-0.0062887673,
-1.0102561712,
0.0999174491,
0.0801262632,
-1.0053817034,
0.3344536126,
0.4970015287,
0.4254082739,
0.0280079655,
0.6697800159,
-0.1026392952,
-0.0126626389,
-0.1070454344,
0.4447011352,
-0.0400772206,
-0.2813791037,
-0.3238451183,
0.08301498,
0.2552589476,
0.2666046023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13940v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13940v1 | AutoCAP: Towards Automatic Cross-lingual Alignment Planning for Zero-shot Chain-of-Thought | 2024-06-20T02:19:33 | 2024-06-20T02:19:33 | Yongheng Zhang, Qiguang Chen, Min Li, Wanxiang Che, Libo Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual chain-of-thought can effectively complete reasoning tasks
across languages, which gains increasing attention. Recently, dominant
approaches in the literature improve cross-lingual alignment capabilities by
integrating reasoning knowledge from different languages. Despite achieving
excellent performance, current methods still have two main challenges: (1)
Manual language specification: They still highly rely on manually selecting the
languages to integrate, severely affecting their generalizability; (2) Static
weight allocation: Current methods simply integrate all languages equally. In
fact, different language reasoning paths should have different weights to
achieve better complementation and integration. Motivated by this, we introduce
an Automatic Cross-lingual Alignment Planning (AutoCAP) for zero-shot
chain-of-thought to address the above challenges. The core of AutoCAP consists
of two components: (1) Automatic Language Selection Prompting to guide LLMs to
select appropriate languages and (2) Automatic Weight Allocation Prompting to
automatically allocate alignment weight scores to each reasoning path.
Extensive experiments on several benchmarks reveal that AutoCAP achieves
state-of-the-art performance, surpassing previous methods that required manual
effort. | [
-0.5010221004,
-0.4091359973,
0.5057138801,
0.2051660717,
-0.1124621332,
0.4607193768,
-0.0994483083,
-0.676263988,
0.5114600658,
0.2661434114,
-0.6049504876,
-0.2644183338,
-0.4852063656,
0.0609427877,
-0.0563863032,
0.6580997705,
-0.7809080482,
-0.0948074833,
-0.0430520251,
-0.2600620687,
-0.9404286742,
-0.0512793809,
-0.3624962568,
-0.1640340686,
0.4971325099,
0.7630298138,
0.6824085116,
0.9046781063,
0.4174148142,
0.186512962,
0.5750809908,
0.2221694738,
-0.0472818501,
0.2120163143,
-0.6003127694,
-0.2665695548,
-0.69850564,
-0.126676783,
0.564510107,
0.7747407556,
-0.0264946707,
0.0974200517,
-0.2935274839,
0.6590627432,
-1.0310651064,
-0.0456041433,
-0.8671785593,
0.3752310872,
-0.0429940633,
-0.0953612402,
-0.1416663229,
0.2345048785,
0.1934573352,
-0.8336059451,
-0.4001571238,
0.5206543207,
0.6953425407,
0.422929734,
-0.1985705346,
-0.2998305857,
-0.5092151761,
0.8573791385,
-0.3564092517,
0.2953401506,
0.1060600355,
0.4117074311,
0.1139869988,
-0.0472094491,
-0.5412439108,
0.2292982191,
-0.0950220004,
0.1514890045,
-0.448046267,
0.0295209195,
0.2119235545,
0.3230039477,
-0.9171785116,
0.1880988777,
-0.0910375938,
-0.33975932,
0.7243985534,
0.1377090663,
0.7714771628,
0.2511074245,
-0.4593948722,
0.0445293859,
-0.521658361,
-0.2451283038,
0.2706177533,
0.2093681246,
0.0499174446,
0.7334797978,
-0.5870594978,
0.8795910478,
0.4492099881,
0.3242174983,
0.1662557423,
-0.5350276828,
-0.5560873747,
0.5771063566,
0.963003099,
0.3585224152,
0.4676266313,
-0.214949429,
-0.1037013605,
-0.020777937,
0.2326979786,
-0.3699223995,
-0.1510029584,
0.100703083,
0.2167838812,
0.0002002158,
-0.3988994658,
-0.4684013128,
0.2578005195,
-0.3956156671,
0.5656309724,
-0.2463981211,
-0.1169167981,
0.4017396569,
-0.0011164614,
0.4723983407,
0.3238531649,
-1.1237633228,
0.2529690266,
0.3709341288,
0.7351677418,
-0.5346213579,
-0.6781738997,
-0.5597548485,
0.6655163169,
-0.5881714225,
1.0413018465,
-0.3622677624,
0.1326146424,
-0.0381550491,
-0.018116029,
-0.2579031289,
-0.0603859387,
0.0883627683,
-0.3659261763,
0.4486865103,
-0.5425473452,
-0.4072378278,
-0.1164078116,
0.6376109719,
-0.4640284479,
0.8889963627,
-0.0592473485,
-0.6205070019,
0.5877926946,
-0.4829996824,
-0.7490075231,
0.1501699239,
-0.3358451426,
-0.0502233393,
-0.3954465389,
0.6534625888,
0.1217261627,
-0.4006021917,
0.2270367593,
-0.2874663472,
-0.2859448493,
-0.2403715849,
-0.1124152169,
0.9882761836,
0.3133467436,
-0.8779212832,
0.178038314,
-0.3639743924,
0.1977823377,
0.031651102,
0.411460191,
-0.2202528715,
-0.4364185631,
-0.3347653449,
0.388002336,
0.3855496049,
-0.4834648371,
0.6428081393,
-0.5208998919,
0.122978963,
0.4573476911,
-0.1309634149,
0.8593845963,
-0.191875875,
0.6975483894,
-0.0744069442,
0.309681654,
-0.1063930765,
-0.4093047082,
-0.8501213789,
-0.0701441765,
0.1591163427,
0.8595808744,
-0.7958490849,
0.7297001481,
0.0180613995,
-0.4648405015,
-0.5267398357,
0.3363206983,
0.5737808943,
0.5292950273,
0.4536801875,
-0.7782923579,
-0.4459885061,
-1.0290936232,
-0.3466887176,
-0.3504400551,
0.2147826701,
0.0436459817,
0.4150429964,
-0.0240553617,
1.021365881,
-0.6122018099,
-0.5635620952,
-0.2790713608,
0.4104783535,
-0.1317048818,
0.4723166227,
0.5783585906,
-0.1987065077,
-0.9390438199,
0.1584759653,
-0.7081186771,
-0.5588046312,
-0.5567408204,
-0.775798142,
0.3143284619,
0.3935938776,
-0.4157287776,
0.3069191873,
0.3231838346,
-0.1551840901,
0.4970701933,
-0.1981859356,
0.0463782139,
-0.6640325785,
0.1636840999,
-0.2321551591,
-0.2148163468,
-0.2866560817,
-0.2811358571,
0.0083896853,
0.1459595412,
-0.4410330951,
0.7166360617,
-0.8895084262,
-0.4239406884,
-0.2389266789,
0.1865650564,
0.1915231198,
0.7303965092,
0.2840132415,
0.728694737,
0.8870338798,
-0.3307218254,
0.3925120533,
0.2160949558,
-0.3784946799,
0.8604505062,
-0.4035573304,
0.0307329316,
0.171731174,
0.2534148693,
-1.0667581558,
0.0209081322,
0.6940974593,
-0.2263358086,
0.5879753828,
0.1189042255,
-0.422845602,
-0.139007777,
-0.1388991326,
0.930464685,
-0.0447950996,
-0.207063958,
0.5235161781,
0.8029227853,
-0.0824822485,
-0.9146962762,
-0.9539498091,
0.3530920744,
0.1096860021,
-0.2956994474,
0.4400834739,
-0.1236215085,
0.03229139,
0.1361654699,
-0.1535032839,
0.1170876399,
-0.4121362865,
-0.2033583522,
0.5003569126,
0.069071278,
-0.145940572,
0.3742162287,
-0.3016987145,
-0.1814498156,
-0.7955545187,
0.3510950804,
-0.1497098953,
-0.5912286639,
-0.3635275364,
0.3571740091,
0.673610568,
-0.2755207419,
0.0988038704,
0.3626208901,
-0.2207466364,
-0.1686769873,
-0.8573271036,
0.399276495,
-0.3793782294,
-0.0718721598,
-0.1794517189,
-0.5982075334,
0.3247163892,
0.1604081988,
0.3056097925,
0.4519671202,
0.646057725,
-0.2352593988,
0.9727758765,
0.5537455082,
-0.382851541,
0.3321292102,
-0.0878752768,
0.3074782193,
-0.8040713668,
-0.0175383855,
0.0623303913,
-0.6575824618,
-0.3193766177,
-0.6601737142,
0.1471966207,
-0.1469006985,
-0.3838469386,
0.7728348374,
-0.7711425424,
0.6375563741,
0.2612884939,
-0.6479540467,
0.2956697941,
0.0136057641,
-0.7085231543,
0.1171469837,
-0.9576040506,
-0.0861400664,
0.8692702055,
0.0686911717,
0.5432351828,
-0.3617550135,
0.5337814093,
0.1517416686,
0.1660963148,
-0.8224739432,
0.5956987739,
0.0486809425,
-0.796099484,
-0.5333380699,
-0.0494348034,
-0.6118836999,
0.2175916135,
-0.0198253151,
-0.7079154253,
0.5063431263,
0.1175339818,
-0.5723528862,
0.3886285424,
-0.3451805711,
0.8984878063,
-0.7797310352,
-0.1871204674,
0.0064828629,
-0.8948475122,
0.27529791,
-0.0474174879,
0.1631521434,
-0.1944406182,
-0.1528251469,
0.5923334956,
-0.2751131356,
0.8017430305,
0.1487651616,
-0.2872974575,
0.4963133335,
0.2673617303,
0.4139014184,
-0.4190648198,
0.2844313383,
0.35588485,
0.0213085767,
-0.3503956497,
-0.5785512328,
0.5245870948,
-0.4681822956,
-0.4411573112,
-0.6938729882,
-1.0460119247,
-0.3391729891,
0.4277852178,
0.1493903697,
-0.1530411392,
-0.1567465365,
-0.4365164042,
0.3935521543,
-0.335773766,
0.5210798979,
0.7186845541,
-0.3646976054,
-0.9635031819,
0.8867509961,
0.3824956119,
0.4996190369,
0.6834278107,
-0.1126507595,
-0.1870126724,
-0.1104034036,
-0.9813171625,
0.3288570642,
-0.5881303549,
-0.3678706586,
-0.633687675,
-0.0973384455,
-0.4829422832,
-0.6280709505,
-0.5129913688,
-0.7283979654,
0.2378994972,
0.0171501674,
-0.1507336646,
0.2119868547,
-0.4250664115,
0.0845134482,
-0.4549288452,
0.2947964072,
0.3491668105,
0.3543406427,
-0.0443987623,
-0.2270920575,
-0.2130396217,
-0.1439501345,
-0.3202509284,
-0.8071340322,
0.3666871488,
-0.0291861072,
0.5527016521,
0.4731108844,
0.038574446,
1.1210683584,
-0.5885579586,
0.4164880514,
0.5032474995,
-1.0682529211,
0.5699118376,
-0.2044315934,
0.7136064172,
0.9161615968,
0.6221580505,
-0.7206614614,
-0.5646627545,
-0.4033076763,
-0.7038421631,
0.5799912214,
0.1245955452,
-0.3765614331,
-0.0664790496,
0.0209856294,
0.1405791342,
0.1806368083,
-0.5597550869,
-0.04420745,
0.0259540193,
-0.0708440244,
0.3368512988,
0.182282269,
-0.0756861493,
-0.6289268732,
0.701155901,
-0.4597417712,
0.1593312472,
0.2563994825,
-0.3568905294,
-0.7487254143,
0.0384769961,
0.4473679662,
0.6994044185,
0.0514118038,
0.0706374496,
0.5195275545,
-0.2067371756,
0.1870824099,
-0.2361596674,
-0.3194428682,
-0.167574808,
0.3496704698,
0.6850981712,
0.4446326792,
-0.6621826291,
0.4629208744,
0.1499254256,
-0.4345489144,
-0.2567680776,
-0.0035582588,
-0.1885204017,
0.1949486881,
0.0920013264,
-0.0622380488,
-0.0319062173,
-0.7546456456,
0.3164308369,
0.6804169416,
-0.5542820096,
-0.0879234672,
0.497959137,
-0.0163006242,
0.1276808679,
0.5475926399,
-0.3191033006,
-0.7680341005,
0.4232884049,
0.3293359876,
1.2712500095,
-0.1915659457,
0.2283082902,
0.4534342885,
0.5753296018,
-0.0132458899,
0.3687111139,
-0.4217354655,
-0.8777864575,
-0.9240563512,
-0.500901401,
-0.5923966169,
-0.485615015,
-0.5079020262,
0.4945239723,
-0.378842473,
0.1766599864,
-0.2774111331,
0.160727039,
-0.5386087894,
0.2229998857,
0.5470507145,
0.9425758719,
-1.0238063335,
1.0108263493,
0.5215634704,
-0.5999640226,
-0.6780877113,
0.0729375184,
0.1362297088,
-1.063449502,
0.7639281154,
-0.0056008007,
-0.3583405316,
-0.1160521805,
-0.1900668591,
-1.1199532747,
1.1840083599,
0.2648435831,
-0.9365488887,
-0.4044037461,
0.4823995531,
0.2986838222,
-0.7351189256,
0.3630959988,
0.5253601074,
0.6386641264,
0.5931193233,
-1.2942632437,
0.2133973986,
-0.0139831295,
-0.2783410847,
0.3920813799,
-0.7468391061,
0.3174737096,
-0.1461598724,
-0.3000841141,
-0.3758837283,
0.6606030464,
0.0146675007,
0.2443615347,
0.8269464374,
0.9299436808,
0.5243428349,
0.2385538071,
0.4657298923,
-0.6277437806,
0.0039789262,
1.2864722013,
-0.6715001464,
0.6551355124,
0.4986957908,
0.0009641494,
0.4452473521,
0.4941922426,
-0.2464338839,
0.5553531051,
-0.0217949841,
0.1467403024,
-0.3916268945,
-0.1026142612,
-0.1299334466,
0.6009390354,
0.2001821548,
0.017227307,
-0.3420514762,
-0.1298550367,
-0.1574142873,
-0.465290308,
-0.1988907456,
0.7500907779,
0.0070666773,
-1.1474773884,
0.5605658293,
-0.4292471409,
0.5293728709,
-0.4401592016,
0.0587807596,
0.0107509568,
-0.1765506119,
-0.1119763628,
-0.9564300179,
0.8260188103,
0.061714761,
0.1265437901,
-0.7071856856,
0.7763068676,
-0.7577137351,
-0.4016467631,
0.4612324238,
0.5321026444,
0.1345550567,
0.050001353,
-0.8675814271,
-0.0247478895,
-0.0860432237,
0.0908064917,
0.4387799501,
0.5761454701,
-0.1502808928,
0.5143447518,
0.5434539318,
0.2629986107,
-0.136733979,
-0.1579765081,
0.6356148124,
-0.6122381091,
-0.4523479044,
-0.7889416218,
0.3740513623,
-0.0757591054,
-0.3046794832,
0.4437836707,
0.7214787602,
1.1924462318,
0.2463339567,
0.6128678918,
-0.1761895865,
0.0089265397,
-0.3514655232,
0.7013695836,
-0.7837752104,
0.0679018795,
-0.4185856879,
-0.9223112464,
-0.576892674,
0.6495283842,
-0.6353556514,
-0.4891318679,
0.9654445648,
0.4544189274,
0.0502833463,
-0.2425829172,
0.299369514,
-0.1806594282,
0.1806649715,
0.9267914295,
0.407517463,
-0.3442265689,
0.7021421194,
-0.3762781918,
-0.3312440813,
-0.0522964709,
-1.1766321659,
-0.6536824107,
-0.502843678,
-0.6835708022,
0.3523148,
-0.0337463431,
0.9852766395,
0.5462841988,
-0.756344974,
-0.6534147859,
-0.3237377107,
0.1007559225,
-0.435228914,
-0.1732674092,
0.1136489213,
-0.7245307565,
-0.6948969364,
0.3213974237,
0.9938935041,
-0.2892376781,
-0.4842773974,
-0.0382435545,
-0.5826211572,
0.1731209159,
0.4290040433,
0.7397845984,
-0.7655622363,
-0.1729381979,
0.1687607318,
-0.2224655449,
0.1609506011,
0.8718067408,
-0.707171917,
0.8663095236,
0.6167515516,
0.7152918577,
0.495893687,
-0.2948324084,
1.0626333952,
-0.4268160164,
-0.0312748216,
0.3332393169,
0.5008218884,
0.009053818,
-0.2269356996,
0.4922363758,
0.1146786287,
-0.5860876441,
-0.7425885201,
0.3188579977,
-1.0231031179,
-0.2649726868,
0.8441393971,
0.0907624438,
-0.2815022171,
-0.0883133635,
-0.2315196246,
0.509262681,
0.002316548,
0.7012682557,
0.9876122475,
-0.4554170072,
-0.1265288889,
-0.4496098757,
0.2850410342,
0.811580658,
-0.6794310808,
0.2625598013,
0.2797703147,
-0.0151180532,
0.3216360807,
0.8096052408,
-0.1347181499,
0.3531379998,
-0.2796369493,
0.3007281423,
0.2566592097,
-0.6350338459,
0.0537083521,
-0.1256694496,
-0.2555577457,
-0.1851469576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13934v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13934v1 | Reasoning Like a Doctor: Improving Medical Dialogue Systems via Diagnostic Reasoning Process Alignment | 2024-06-20T02:02:53 | 2024-06-20T02:02:53 | Kaishuai Xu, Yi Cheng, Wenjun Hou, Qiaoyu Tan, Wenjie Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Medical dialogue systems have attracted significant attention for their
potential to act as medical assistants. Enabling these medical systems to
emulate clinicians' diagnostic reasoning process has been the long-standing
research focus. Previous studies rudimentarily realized the simulation of
clinicians' diagnostic process by fine-tuning language models on high-quality
dialogue datasets. Nonetheless, they overly focus on the outcomes of the
clinician's reasoning process while ignoring their internal thought processes
and alignment with clinician preferences. Our work aims to build a medical
dialogue system that aligns with clinicians' diagnostic reasoning processes. We
propose a novel framework, Emulation, designed to generate an appropriate
response that relies on abductive and deductive diagnostic reasoning analyses
and aligns with clinician preferences through thought process modeling.
Experimental results on two datasets confirm the efficacy of Emulation.
Crucially, our framework furnishes clear explanations for the generated
responses, enhancing its transparency in medical consultations. | [
-0.3793767989,
-0.629208684,
1.3078056574,
-0.2977170944,
-0.3263023794,
0.039760109,
-0.0173943583,
-0.2577927709,
0.7479915023,
0.5794371963,
-0.4070881903,
-0.3321775794,
-0.4902411103,
0.1949142963,
-0.0920104831,
0.4831060469,
0.0041195955,
0.3515093923,
-0.2932344377,
-0.0042492356,
-0.4942044914,
-0.3513528109,
-0.7530587316,
-0.4604156613,
-0.01628194,
0.2845799327,
1.1305128336,
0.7274502516,
0.2156343162,
0.2295728773,
0.2087368071,
0.3672764301,
-0.07866963,
0.6076400876,
-0.2454498112,
-0.1622217447,
-0.6887177825,
-0.1562917829,
0.3133290708,
0.757768333,
-0.3826949,
-0.1962854266,
0.0110395383,
0.1680957824,
-0.3210056126,
-0.0947473943,
-0.0813609064,
0.1775017828,
0.3670032918,
-0.3609894216,
-0.3217254877,
-0.5552398562,
0.1181012094,
-0.8504264951,
0.0823601112,
-0.1567536891,
0.3987298906,
0.456232816,
-0.0521374717,
-0.1019861251,
-0.9710251689,
0.2800999582,
-1.0324937105,
0.2691795826,
0.3634748161,
0.4199635684,
-0.100300625,
-0.52857548,
-0.5489220619,
0.2140900493,
-0.1474461704,
0.3116403222,
-0.1252229214,
0.2687505186,
0.378616184,
0.037826933,
-0.3041986227,
0.0394385196,
0.0043027243,
0.2179217637,
0.5990788341,
0.5041799545,
0.1530551314,
0.2503916025,
-0.1168878824,
0.1916271746,
-0.5029079914,
-0.1137113869,
-0.2266477793,
-0.0459319018,
-0.0068464223,
0.6041787863,
-0.1679597646,
0.8080973029,
0.5857418776,
-0.2490246296,
0.1411810219,
-0.20041053,
-0.6316427588,
0.4135565758,
0.827358067,
0.6742139459,
0.1206829995,
0.0023501555,
-0.0687316284,
0.2106034011,
0.6723671556,
-0.363838315,
-0.2136783302,
0.7497625351,
-0.5649441481,
-0.2958518565,
-0.2633458376,
-0.5869503617,
-0.6391620636,
-0.5676124692,
0.2188149244,
-0.5505899787,
-0.382343024,
0.3553468287,
0.0111132385,
-0.0454823077,
0.7514442205,
-0.9127100706,
0.5715148449,
0.8489239812,
0.4758693874,
0.2016778886,
0.2132534534,
-0.5649172068,
0.4227713346,
-0.3299773335,
0.8830215335,
-1.0117871761,
-0.6809850931,
-0.1120556071,
-0.0102492217,
-0.2152206749,
-0.6447200775,
0.2471033335,
0.1584174782,
0.2385764867,
-0.0390584208,
-0.7672381997,
0.0591697656,
0.370524168,
-0.1073826551,
0.4345245361,
-0.0136154275,
-0.4773742557,
0.2758129239,
-0.6121019721,
-0.1862339526,
0.0640968382,
-0.6606660485,
0.064954266,
0.1169068143,
0.4157301784,
0.3227921724,
-0.4698024094,
0.2667239606,
-0.5427505374,
-0.3922425807,
0.2384940684,
-0.171579957,
0.7206756473,
0.240215525,
-0.3267517686,
-0.0641772971,
-0.4300498664,
-0.0016302688,
-0.1307169348,
0.2978160679,
-0.3846523464,
-0.0160174761,
-0.6838507056,
0.1501378566,
-0.1228276491,
-0.7736682892,
0.5385837555,
-0.7081301808,
0.0873009786,
0.3030873239,
0.1554195285,
0.4264709055,
-0.6823939085,
1.0537495613,
0.2522772253,
0.2677562833,
-0.1833444536,
-0.7882305384,
-0.2868673801,
-0.3787458539,
0.0638859197,
0.6644051671,
-0.3937828839,
0.217325449,
-0.1439831108,
-0.4057983458,
-1.1101316214,
-0.2161661237,
0.3575443327,
0.6498622298,
0.1799061894,
-0.4959501624,
-0.2980479002,
-0.7732843757,
-0.0404351838,
-0.1949529797,
-0.0886242092,
0.5087355971,
-0.2920126915,
-0.158014074,
0.8479588032,
-0.6442393064,
-0.1742898375,
0.0339335129,
-0.3447518349,
0.2602732778,
0.6508706212,
0.3427248299,
-0.4192124605,
-0.3004032373,
0.2008250654,
-0.8649245501,
-0.2397709787,
-0.2703415751,
-0.0896840468,
0.2089686841,
0.5871896744,
-0.6361121535,
0.7503224611,
0.2733020186,
-0.5133358836,
0.402076453,
-0.4279225767,
0.5345212817,
-1.3396844864,
0.135511741,
-0.1787652522,
-0.3894756436,
-0.4970374107,
-0.1456392705,
-0.3599405885,
-0.2213708907,
-0.2234400958,
0.6211598516,
-0.1534914225,
0.0345656723,
-0.3042272627,
0.1835624278,
0.2498690039,
-0.0796159655,
0.1942247152,
0.3498527408,
0.5574223995,
-0.4596677423,
0.5986665487,
0.7053651214,
0.0821283236,
1.0783624649,
-0.637396872,
0.0236686449,
0.0516553931,
0.2212447077,
-0.9197295904,
-0.1208700091,
0.6503810287,
-0.4106259346,
0.4219318628,
-0.3964407146,
-0.4578113854,
-0.1831366569,
0.0984391198,
0.476747483,
0.629660964,
-0.3382463753,
0.7458732724,
0.4911896586,
-0.4360918403,
-0.3488508463,
-0.4239690602,
-0.0685391575,
-0.2029706389,
-0.4548712373,
0.1960745454,
0.0433494933,
-0.4171810448,
-0.0317060798,
0.1087647602,
-0.1100143045,
0.0666765049,
0.4386329651,
0.1271886528,
-0.2339259684,
0.2002909184,
0.6228289604,
-0.1766674817,
0.2114925385,
-0.1149677187,
0.4582620561,
0.2940877378,
-0.8323400617,
-0.7459282279,
0.535946846,
0.7027236819,
-0.0956019238,
0.3530137539,
0.0180316102,
-0.5063648224,
0.1419820487,
-0.4594637156,
-0.4123435318,
-0.3722266853,
-0.2018242925,
-0.5286716223,
-0.377635479,
0.4229026437,
-0.2140147835,
0.3639602065,
0.0560406372,
0.6940937042,
-0.3922387362,
1.7329543829,
-0.0165320337,
0.6097542048,
-0.1154035404,
0.0754087418,
0.2921997309,
-0.8868685961,
-0.3425211608,
-0.2498784512,
-0.3353785276,
-0.2368865311,
-0.4547865093,
0.4892545342,
-0.1163123325,
-0.2841334641,
0.0514409468,
-0.8552482128,
0.1356785148,
0.3961102068,
0.2478160262,
0.399548918,
-0.2231048197,
-0.5553438663,
-0.0339969583,
-0.7405734062,
-0.770950973,
0.807823956,
0.2806344926,
0.9852585793,
0.1721684337,
1.1183393002,
-0.0300802905,
0.1524744481,
-0.5725542903,
0.3876942098,
-0.1977460384,
-0.2832122743,
-0.1056982204,
-0.0316329487,
-0.9366796613,
0.1301035583,
-0.2389084101,
-0.7464966774,
0.3090771139,
0.5321410894,
-0.8248067498,
0.1718536317,
-0.6172632575,
0.7629826665,
0.1348545402,
-0.252279222,
-0.315106988,
-0.7302299142,
0.1681317985,
0.0602289066,
0.2206962258,
0.0218785498,
0.1213029772,
0.1821773499,
-0.586433351,
1.0336668491,
-0.290651232,
-0.2305538505,
-0.0562765859,
0.5244957805,
-0.0395433381,
0.3974236548,
-0.0412550792,
-0.2892847657,
0.5847964883,
-0.1894425601,
-0.8963112831,
0.7625386715,
-0.2397341728,
-1.1612855196,
-0.3348459899,
-0.3610085547,
-0.5332666636,
-0.0286852475,
-0.1050487086,
0.5586044788,
-0.4104320407,
-0.513260901,
0.4869278073,
-0.1140069291,
-0.115620546,
0.349481374,
-0.4439297616,
-0.1462430656,
0.3048610389,
-0.1959664524,
0.4015336633,
0.0562314913,
0.2120955735,
-0.1930863857,
-0.1316307038,
-0.8837909698,
0.2888407409,
-0.5016002059,
-0.2626369894,
-0.8276211619,
-0.1271964163,
-0.6874980927,
-0.3403046429,
-0.1980081946,
-0.67463094,
-0.3987016976,
0.1277633458,
0.3475841582,
0.7116366625,
-0.0311694015,
0.0305402726,
-0.8630763292,
0.2535040081,
0.0885081887,
0.2888673544,
0.0676663592,
-0.5071281791,
0.0029253743,
0.4162415266,
-0.6653750539,
-0.967497468,
0.3521022499,
-0.0266673677,
0.5600387454,
0.8810126781,
0.0733765438,
0.7556846738,
-0.6742446423,
0.7250325084,
0.1451074183,
-0.8148063421,
0.8659071326,
-0.075750865,
0.1817204654,
0.3961957693,
0.3282591105,
-0.3886557221,
-0.9156239033,
-0.8880603313,
-0.1352887601,
0.4468534887,
-0.1984391361,
-0.0968582481,
-0.3177011311,
0.4024927914,
0.3434459567,
-0.0494284779,
0.2701691389,
-0.0606807023,
-0.2452455461,
-0.5993731618,
0.0053981785,
0.1513164639,
-0.7734435797,
-0.4682291448,
0.3997389376,
-0.3728809655,
0.3776616752,
0.6311738491,
0.3494341969,
-0.0829698443,
0.1346801817,
0.4772111475,
0.5111641288,
0.0372294597,
0.0954315662,
-0.1030488536,
-0.2112810463,
0.2761828005,
0.2920736969,
0.0438822322,
0.1636425555,
-0.1516555846,
0.3793973923,
0.1148773953,
-0.7319521904,
0.51759094,
-0.1514842212,
-0.1876222938,
-0.1273452193,
0.297970891,
0.3405825198,
0.5410250425,
-0.3339003026,
0.1356018782,
0.3083825111,
-0.3695114255,
0.2806967497,
0.4451164603,
-0.5821868777,
-0.2475339621,
0.8214483261,
0.295704931,
-0.5009981394,
0.6867502928,
0.0779415369,
-0.3039529622,
0.5853404999,
0.8784835935,
0.679921627,
-0.2853599191,
0.3399771452,
0.261127919,
-0.1408967972,
-0.1510017514,
0.6090036035,
-0.0930804536,
-0.664799273,
-0.3341462016,
-0.1756903827,
-0.705563128,
-0.3985577524,
-0.7146487236,
0.3427653015,
-0.4735770226,
-0.4420858026,
0.2088337988,
-0.4230528474,
-0.6089918613,
0.285099566,
0.1692975312,
0.8894423842,
-0.6195814013,
0.7197856903,
1.0155956745,
-0.2187200934,
-0.7630355954,
-0.1058689952,
0.1498601735,
-0.8982927799,
0.1591450274,
-0.1190157756,
-0.1149332523,
-0.1221266612,
0.0455907173,
-0.3882457614,
0.8904545307,
0.4413130879,
-0.4800159037,
-0.0560807623,
-0.2234866321,
0.64578408,
-0.8835551739,
0.3578935564,
0.6180382371,
0.1421480775,
0.0034999824,
-1.331803441,
0.507101059,
-0.1861597747,
-0.4302877784,
0.2672500908,
-0.1930630207,
0.1758194715,
-0.7069700956,
-0.1145751774,
0.3052062392,
-0.2425621599,
0.3679428399,
0.5465518832,
0.393253386,
0.8331363201,
0.6383703947,
0.0984358862,
1.1682174206,
-0.4900822937,
-0.1149654016,
1.0816111565,
-0.6604316235,
0.573769033,
0.64422369,
0.0468661226,
0.5363511443,
0.3767847419,
0.1306044012,
0.3700057268,
-0.2257757336,
-0.5041896105,
-0.4101814032,
-0.2799883783,
-0.4780299366,
0.4808593392,
0.569365263,
-0.7249458432,
0.1181791201,
-0.1727934182,
-0.193747893,
0.2967510521,
0.0398920886,
1.2109140158,
0.2329972088,
-0.8564084172,
0.6146047711,
-0.5172304511,
-0.1404126287,
-0.1948243678,
-0.2763661742,
-0.0353975669,
-0.0007114024,
-0.3263831735,
-1.0116529465,
0.3368525505,
-0.3152861893,
-0.1652458161,
-0.2489122003,
0.2839974165,
-0.5082546473,
-0.3233279288,
-0.0494886301,
0.6432545185,
0.4205537438,
0.3600378931,
-0.6286847591,
-0.3011474609,
0.0808683485,
0.1287430972,
0.1622283608,
0.4804033637,
0.2583810687,
0.6327543855,
0.3858159482,
0.3867012262,
-0.4219310284,
0.4700945318,
0.8146814108,
-0.552486062,
-0.4800933003,
-0.7043801546,
0.2008889467,
-0.1752641648,
-0.3062616587,
0.2302829772,
0.4763817489,
0.4401264787,
-0.0604553483,
0.6588298082,
0.2347711176,
0.8901062012,
-0.3102881014,
0.5827414989,
-0.6079776883,
0.3253668249,
-0.3327086568,
-0.5228608847,
-0.3022777736,
0.7463623285,
0.0103361672,
-0.0464227758,
0.5697752833,
0.7499334216,
-0.3037615716,
0.3537415266,
0.4847503006,
0.1464633793,
0.335844785,
0.6822239757,
0.7314136028,
-0.0454037301,
-0.0913599953,
-0.2558152676,
-0.4342489243,
-0.1443915665,
-0.6015276909,
-0.5770178437,
-0.3094538748,
-0.4161857367,
-0.651083529,
0.0696880668,
1.1451230049,
0.5806894898,
-0.5476911068,
0.0177990962,
0.2040056139,
-0.1443141252,
-0.4520439208,
-0.1680622697,
0.1671105474,
-0.0639775172,
-0.728926897,
0.3591278791,
0.4088059962,
0.2522474825,
-0.0494402535,
-0.0935282186,
0.1853362173,
0.1220520213,
0.2298339158,
0.3148588538,
-0.8269295692,
-0.249078095,
0.0758789629,
-0.1743113995,
0.3337838352,
0.7866107821,
-1.0480232239,
0.9905175567,
0.0559762642,
0.6152451038,
0.2167589217,
0.2587161362,
1.2189424038,
0.0033777442,
-0.1383939534,
0.6357867718,
0.2765209079,
0.1861183047,
-0.5151716471,
0.2684749067,
-0.1412749887,
-0.5555953383,
-0.7258172035,
0.4970683455,
-1.0158557892,
-0.1546923369,
0.9564188123,
-0.256552279,
0.1305214614,
-0.4660500586,
-0.487830162,
0.2565073669,
-0.4156416059,
0.8439760208,
0.3177938461,
-0.7966285944,
0.0748476759,
-0.1390699595,
0.5022038221,
0.6822964549,
-0.666426897,
-0.0629268363,
0.3341199458,
0.3633278012,
-0.0178898461,
0.8853282928,
-0.3208353817,
0.6408807635,
-0.0489608757,
-0.1648142487,
0.0316339955,
0.1623619944,
-0.3759581149,
-0.2517851293,
-0.017167313,
-0.2532227933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13929v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13929v1 | Large Language Models are Skeptics: False Negative Problem of Input-conflicting Hallucination | 2024-06-20T01:53:25 | 2024-06-20T01:53:25 | Jongyoon Song, Sangwon Yu, Sungroh Yoon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we identify a new category of bias that induces
input-conflicting hallucinations, where large language models (LLMs) generate
responses inconsistent with the content of the input context. This issue we
have termed the false negative problem refers to the phenomenon where LLMs are
predisposed to return negative judgments when assessing the correctness of a
statement given the context. In experiments involving pairs of statements that
contain the same information but have contradictory factual directions, we
observe that LLMs exhibit a bias toward false negatives. Specifically, the
model presents greater overconfidence when responding with False. Furthermore,
we analyze the relationship between the false negative problem and context and
query rewriting and observe that both effectively tackle false negatives in
LLMs. | [
-0.4619165361,
-1.2830867767,
0.9178559184,
0.1056152582,
-0.0392620713,
-0.1012773588,
-0.2708083391,
-0.4941247404,
0.4488319159,
0.7736176848,
-0.6463673711,
-0.1145554483,
-0.8563067317,
0.1150806025,
-0.7069451213,
0.8224248886,
0.0337058976,
0.3186305165,
-0.1740419269,
-0.1808564663,
-0.7146289945,
-0.8565466404,
-0.4453188777,
-0.4815399647,
0.6049444079,
0.1320361942,
1.0685505867,
0.0124917654,
0.2770644724,
0.2846888602,
0.1141456366,
-0.2243950814,
-0.55056113,
0.436193943,
-0.559181869,
-0.6201473475,
-0.0091008339,
0.0418091938,
0.3378278911,
0.7475566268,
-0.1419051439,
0.036760956,
-0.2120747864,
0.4136052728,
-0.5657967925,
-0.1061920449,
-0.9847560525,
0.0732343867,
0.0200513192,
-0.3176220953,
-0.677847147,
-0.5266004801,
0.22265625,
-0.2644712627,
0.3856014907,
0.034571562,
0.9089851379,
0.4492169321,
-0.6387813687,
-0.6951698661,
-0.8026106358,
0.6947164536,
-0.9151874185,
0.5251243114,
0.4880481064,
0.1370818615,
-0.3432848454,
0.0436684527,
-1.0654957294,
-0.4748013616,
0.0443394892,
-0.3603329957,
0.0391856916,
-0.0501178466,
0.3181751966,
0.186885342,
-0.4494276643,
0.1386738867,
-0.2798387408,
-0.2701914608,
0.6724631786,
0.234033823,
0.3522750437,
-0.2632606924,
0.067306377,
0.1898906231,
-0.7491776943,
-0.4196436703,
0.4268899858,
0.3819063306,
0.1383628249,
0.9124221802,
0.1242372617,
0.8357662559,
0.299629122,
-0.1846050471,
0.2021944374,
-0.1272796094,
-0.3006329536,
0.1896961182,
0.5909919143,
0.2950176001,
0.1842246801,
-0.2301930785,
-0.3244975209,
0.5448143482,
0.3711548746,
-0.5898162723,
0.2752743661,
0.3671601415,
-0.2248205543,
-0.4665536284,
-0.1479299664,
-0.8806230426,
-0.7437472939,
-0.4607913792,
0.8277155161,
-0.0528908223,
-0.2089300752,
0.2971327007,
0.0195675585,
0.2098283917,
0.3536213934,
-0.595726192,
0.3212325871,
0.5430040956,
0.6472213268,
-0.2048671246,
-0.1844326556,
-0.6043874025,
-0.108358413,
-0.5207437277,
0.4827034473,
-0.699587822,
-0.4646739066,
0.1328017265,
0.2486660331,
-0.0108966427,
-0.6691067815,
0.4391961992,
-0.5551555753,
0.5765327811,
-0.6016643047,
-0.502981782,
-0.2397050261,
0.3386159539,
-0.5410969853,
0.8161330819,
0.0462901257,
-0.7309631109,
0.360823065,
-0.2166814804,
-0.4108279943,
-0.1097755432,
-0.518967092,
-0.1829982847,
0.5237571001,
-0.3549725115,
0.3186838329,
-0.5321184397,
0.7904741764,
-0.5229899287,
-0.5055214167,
0.6363189816,
-0.4748572111,
0.7353998423,
0.0014732252,
-0.6916218996,
0.2148635089,
-0.8720464706,
-0.0928716436,
0.2709784508,
-0.1682234257,
-0.5578573942,
0.1517709494,
-0.1787010133,
0.56525594,
0.1204297468,
-0.5508549213,
0.3883344829,
-0.3694411516,
0.4780326188,
0.8432785869,
-0.0404343121,
0.1084798351,
-0.3004441261,
0.3035575151,
0.161757946,
-0.1867911518,
0.2393966019,
-0.3294339776,
-0.9209478498,
0.3368590474,
-0.0731278658,
0.4770019352,
-0.9527925253,
0.3410827816,
0.0266616102,
-0.3114675879,
-0.3023525178,
-0.085722506,
0.2043662816,
0.5934109688,
0.2567642033,
-0.0124728642,
-0.5558844209,
-1.1194604635,
-0.2214225084,
-0.1717864126,
0.1939473748,
0.3314620256,
0.7517184615,
-0.7277830243,
0.5923545361,
-0.5820510983,
-0.3328387141,
-0.1350969225,
0.2631006837,
0.2692486048,
0.2349576354,
0.3169446588,
-0.6873925924,
-0.2355425358,
-0.3405613899,
-0.7357652187,
-0.1075451449,
-0.1955629885,
0.2094358802,
0.7909423709,
0.4470431805,
-0.9802257419,
0.2853311598,
0.7078819275,
-0.5391145945,
0.9638414383,
0.0427525677,
0.1037512124,
-0.9903479218,
-0.0850342065,
0.0938993171,
0.195171982,
-0.4480656385,
0.1316356212,
-0.1607966274,
0.141771853,
-0.1718987077,
0.4905607998,
-0.3393137753,
0.1003974229,
-0.4038638175,
0.1783036888,
-0.0052017956,
0.3258737922,
0.0801868662,
0.7099727988,
0.5229251385,
-0.6198596358,
0.4262842238,
0.0244723037,
-0.2568583786,
0.421227932,
-0.6244332194,
0.1004222184,
-0.4037306905,
0.4067852199,
-1.0902389288,
-0.5064831972,
0.204166308,
-0.387180686,
0.1767587215,
0.3150439262,
-0.5410955548,
-0.5177112818,
-0.2368944734,
0.4517915547,
0.3477237523,
-0.5322214365,
0.4594083428,
0.2575338185,
0.1124116853,
-0.813359201,
-1.000607729,
0.0814130828,
-0.0043992302,
-0.4292838871,
0.0539000519,
-0.0078566112,
-0.5449368954,
-0.0149511471,
-0.2713632286,
-0.1243033707,
-0.2326894403,
0.2114703208,
0.4092665315,
-0.3029163182,
0.1930488497,
-0.1958168894,
0.2835739851,
0.4959424138,
0.0030083186,
0.8645830154,
0.172531575,
-0.4474051297,
-0.5590223074,
0.3366616666,
0.9220548868,
0.3136637211,
1.0408309698,
0.1595948189,
-0.5235286951,
-0.121356152,
-0.9269123673,
-0.459440589,
-0.4167640209,
0.481298238,
-0.4134601355,
-0.9611486197,
0.5501502156,
0.475879401,
-0.3194241226,
0.466619283,
0.8285365701,
0.2636939585,
1.1779433489,
0.4806679189,
-0.1365669966,
0.015139685,
0.002588769,
0.5708839297,
-0.6148194671,
-0.2930844128,
-0.6386247873,
0.0073537561,
-0.6112194657,
-0.2196771502,
-0.0864367336,
-0.132252261,
-0.2996628881,
0.1712199748,
-0.4552098513,
0.412058264,
0.2383216619,
-0.1343998462,
0.1286785901,
-0.2906478047,
-0.0474295877,
-0.3328812718,
-0.6054879427,
-0.4924508929,
1.0238544941,
0.314206332,
1.0636874437,
0.2372691184,
0.3668121099,
0.1981094778,
0.4553174675,
-0.910797298,
0.4659341872,
0.2051004171,
-1.0791110992,
-0.2795039415,
-0.4050311148,
-0.5486848354,
0.4828366637,
-0.4124577641,
-0.995614171,
0.3475164175,
0.1870263517,
-0.3159838915,
0.3997502327,
-0.7377389669,
0.6316853166,
-0.2926182747,
-0.6747311354,
-0.028701568,
-0.5157583356,
0.8468809128,
-0.2845644057,
0.2485408336,
0.1800244749,
0.2892193794,
0.4062566459,
-0.2638816535,
0.924405098,
-0.0798748136,
-0.6062422395,
0.1624085009,
0.5529994965,
0.6922993064,
0.1373087913,
-0.0768299848,
0.2176461816,
-0.0403905734,
-0.1536336541,
-0.5900148153,
0.8540542722,
-0.896946013,
-1.0668234825,
-0.7994789481,
-0.5188190341,
-0.3593629003,
0.2159578651,
0.6326275468,
0.4050899446,
-0.0945939794,
0.174211964,
0.8648456335,
-0.707775414,
-0.0108798472,
0.5562551618,
-0.519108355,
-0.0095753735,
0.8679864407,
0.4141215086,
0.502767086,
0.1677680314,
-0.0545169152,
-0.3527450264,
-0.3478421867,
-0.2115505636,
0.4558652043,
-0.6489548087,
-0.0083580026,
-0.7387613058,
-0.4161197841,
-0.6200236678,
-0.1325051337,
-0.4081185758,
-0.0427327976,
-0.2115000337,
0.0480254628,
-0.3859232664,
0.8870187998,
0.1771291047,
0.0475917198,
-0.422619313,
0.4405576587,
0.3225768209,
0.2467422336,
0.3373446465,
-0.6598104239,
0.056575533,
-0.0162153076,
-0.3692552745,
-1.1639516354,
0.3488736153,
-0.5148012638,
0.4445010424,
0.4731175601,
-0.030550668,
0.4798714519,
-0.4637098014,
0.9556230903,
0.2932598591,
-1.1627842188,
0.1140248701,
-0.3886810243,
0.3233813941,
0.3907116354,
0.5559146404,
-0.7474984527,
-0.6039335132,
-0.5537250638,
-0.7250467539,
0.6076313257,
-0.0231695157,
0.1964641809,
-0.2413485795,
0.2753525674,
0.3667158782,
0.4427146614,
-1.1637279987,
-0.279864192,
-0.2047662586,
0.1319467574,
-0.2276369631,
-0.808686018,
-0.3255476356,
-0.1973853856,
0.8127251267,
0.0355931409,
0.2639306486,
0.2321749777,
-0.0749257803,
-0.5776100159,
0.4334459007,
1.1754288673,
0.9438572526,
-0.1997393966,
0.416767031,
0.1799928546,
-0.203281641,
0.4034825563,
-0.4146673381,
-0.3312317729,
0.1173539236,
0.4477585554,
0.7654836178,
-0.0977580026,
-0.5815298557,
0.5835872293,
-0.0759128779,
-0.385576427,
-0.5532565713,
0.0352200419,
0.0931856334,
0.0389872715,
0.5165768266,
0.1900484413,
0.1109680831,
-0.8241065145,
0.0017700809,
0.7832222581,
-0.3921215236,
-0.4160541594,
0.7058666348,
0.0734870806,
-0.5031969547,
0.5012981296,
-0.2031542808,
-0.765810132,
0.4854466617,
0.8584840298,
0.8101663589,
-0.1712937802,
0.3090832829,
0.4164897203,
0.4834395051,
-0.1676163524,
0.1874396354,
0.3939068019,
-0.907014966,
-0.5991728306,
-0.5078555942,
-0.2376072854,
0.947535038,
-0.6547481418,
0.3746078908,
-0.3277052641,
-0.1950531155,
-0.0416172408,
-0.1668250114,
-0.3171143234,
0.3075003624,
0.1197014749,
0.6992456913,
-0.8627586961,
0.8203015924,
0.3173083961,
-0.3535355031,
-0.7315238118,
0.3550998867,
0.1705884933,
-0.6240971684,
0.8683217764,
0.1335383952,
-0.212884441,
-0.5399699807,
-0.7389459014,
-1.0533759594,
0.3629223704,
0.417244494,
-0.7940799594,
-0.2045834512,
0.1905729771,
0.6235084534,
-0.3570684791,
-0.0950352103,
0.471807003,
0.5442562699,
0.1832175851,
-0.8972781897,
0.4303754866,
0.0877666697,
-0.0292302072,
0.3553112745,
-0.5991021991,
1.1501047611,
-0.2806464732,
-0.1020026132,
0.0006043356,
0.270501405,
0.2958523631,
0.2811967134,
0.3056909442,
0.5221591592,
0.4669773281,
-0.1367964298,
1.0091347694,
-0.2268488705,
0.3884552419,
1.2905682325,
-0.641928792,
0.6746070385,
0.8309654593,
0.0796304718,
0.4275878072,
0.4529705048,
0.0090693608,
0.3187401891,
0.4406610429,
-0.009767672,
-0.2173003554,
0.1004246548,
-0.7143777609,
0.3077893853,
0.438049674,
-0.3931313753,
-0.1229230091,
-0.0196631849,
0.0784489363,
0.0764019564,
-0.0189728513,
0.415469408,
-0.0053248932,
-0.9392498136,
0.7687479854,
0.1087911502,
0.8772915006,
-0.3528490663,
-0.012460121,
-0.0889266357,
0.0661146566,
-0.4479686916,
-0.4769474268,
0.4551611245,
-0.3211691976,
-0.3977066278,
0.2863814235,
0.5819058418,
-0.3442241848,
-0.3749848306,
0.4331741333,
0.4698173106,
-0.0474727638,
0.0304298103,
-0.6247577071,
0.4473161101,
0.1128141806,
-0.2699777782,
0.1794631034,
0.4746447802,
-0.1502299011,
0.6657526493,
0.4248138368,
0.2167342901,
0.0612648129,
-0.0143385651,
0.6822852492,
-0.8096586466,
-0.3092419803,
-1.0937387943,
-0.020551784,
0.04568455,
-0.2322398126,
0.8929285407,
0.3401523829,
0.8993664384,
-0.1455526203,
0.8606520295,
-0.0236475002,
0.4810605943,
-0.3396993577,
0.6666688323,
-0.5906617641,
0.2931265831,
-0.4606671035,
-1.2033839226,
-0.1695294976,
0.6762777567,
-0.6598684788,
0.1423964202,
0.8803253174,
0.7988843918,
0.1441609263,
0.1209377274,
0.4897179306,
0.8476295471,
0.1962839663,
0.5929840207,
0.9899660945,
-0.292534709,
0.0938372388,
0.0811932012,
0.0577381887,
-0.4411995411,
-0.5426243544,
-0.9305379987,
-0.7337555885,
-0.2491661161,
-0.8159112334,
-0.0621475838,
0.9289690256,
0.4656708837,
-0.9897640944,
-0.2803979516,
-0.2293617576,
0.3338410258,
0.348315835,
-0.3565197885,
0.0609818548,
-0.2788144052,
-0.5648044944,
-0.1277932227,
0.2401500791,
0.1356248111,
-0.8649602532,
-0.0555875413,
-0.334492892,
0.5549991727,
0.5925735831,
0.1152348444,
-1.0810259581,
-0.5003595948,
0.012639869,
-0.4086786807,
-0.082892254,
0.7498717308,
-0.6082289219,
0.2208495885,
0.2217308283,
0.5832125545,
0.1897186637,
-0.2431465685,
0.577678144,
-0.2690512538,
0.2521307766,
0.260050863,
0.1647013128,
0.2887214422,
-0.6369052529,
0.255710125,
0.3756717443,
-0.5627771616,
-1.3320797682,
0.4572725594,
-0.7124707699,
-0.6384506822,
1.3404773474,
0.5637719631,
-0.1990794241,
0.022425225,
-0.3102534413,
-0.0337286703,
-0.1299263239,
1.3124366999,
1.325607419,
-0.2018034309,
0.2783404589,
-0.6794326901,
0.4574198127,
0.6071325541,
-0.3579436541,
-0.1003972217,
0.692984283,
0.3426415026,
0.5021976829,
0.5244736671,
0.0023155531,
0.1161826849,
0.0669421256,
-0.0583596677,
0.389347434,
-0.3172588646,
-0.3209837675,
0.3648459315,
0.1259445697,
0.3030587137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13925v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13925v1 | GenderAlign: An Alignment Dataset for Mitigating Gender Bias in Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T01:45:44 | 2024-06-20T01:45:44 | Tao Zhang, Ziqian Zeng, Yuxiang Xiao, Huiping Zhuang, Cen Chen, James Foulds, Shimei Pan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are prone to generating content that exhibits
gender biases, raising significant ethical concerns. Alignment, the process of
fine-tuning LLMs to better align with desired behaviors, is recognized as an
effective approach to mitigate gender biases. Although proprietary LLMs have
made significant strides in mitigating gender bias, their alignment datasets
are not publicly available. The commonly used and publicly available alignment
dataset, HH-RLHF, still exhibits gender bias to some extent. There is a lack of
publicly available alignment datasets specifically designed to address gender
bias. Hence, we developed a new dataset named GenderAlign, aiming at mitigating
a comprehensive set of gender biases in LLMs. This dataset comprises 8k
single-turn dialogues, each paired with a "chosen" and a "rejected" response.
Compared to the "rejected" responses, the "chosen" responses demonstrate lower
levels of gender bias and higher quality. Furthermore, we categorized the
gender biases in the "rejected" responses of GenderAlign into 4 principal
categories. The experimental results show the effectiveness of GenderAlign in
reducing gender bias in LLMs. | [
-0.0631131977,
-0.4713374972,
0.1960851848,
0.0181122869,
-0.0059940065,
0.2795865536,
-0.1463471949,
0.1429629922,
-0.0579547249,
0.535315752,
-1.0568914413,
-0.6132094264,
-0.3923195601,
0.1203174666,
-0.3335104883,
0.8631815314,
0.1251274496,
0.5848125815,
-0.3559583724,
-0.1913591027,
-0.9286681414,
-0.1564803869,
-0.5490520597,
-0.5792282224,
0.5303869843,
0.515263021,
0.8237926364,
0.8299634457,
0.6239237189,
0.2026141435,
-0.1522366107,
0.0607035831,
-0.8257614374,
0.3108911514,
-0.1698366106,
-0.3121505678,
-0.6243088841,
0.0952756405,
0.910733521,
0.8214095235,
-0.4956620634,
0.428491503,
0.0994847044,
0.9202845097,
-0.5806352496,
-0.0661423355,
-0.5830850601,
0.1615142822,
-0.4834261835,
0.0758944005,
-0.2613457739,
-0.4283904433,
0.0677651167,
-0.6959226727,
0.0251323003,
0.5030599236,
0.6983927488,
0.3696907163,
-0.2864181101,
-0.0005105264,
-0.6337336898,
0.9033499956,
-0.9383004904,
0.5254538059,
0.2951675951,
0.2772930562,
-0.3776588738,
0.0763278231,
-0.4604670107,
0.2279857546,
-0.0337380543,
0.0070544444,
-0.0038626157,
-0.0872565061,
0.2529942393,
0.1847610474,
-0.8249822855,
0.442730248,
-0.175386712,
-0.3323833644,
0.6309344172,
0.3103309274,
0.3974589705,
-0.0116558075,
-0.1012807861,
-0.0516979918,
-1.2240405083,
-0.2299885005,
0.9436756372,
0.6692768335,
-0.1373110414,
0.6977105141,
0.109957628,
0.5753216743,
0.4646272361,
-0.4055312574,
0.2727862298,
-0.0541003719,
-0.2553086877,
0.6547151804,
0.6870664954,
0.5941402912,
0.3218744993,
0.1227675825,
-0.0625796244,
-0.1519040763,
0.1425251812,
-0.5773134232,
0.1264224797,
0.1746017933,
-0.677437067,
-0.347655803,
-0.1086500585,
-0.6923782229,
-0.7946016192,
-0.5792858005,
0.0671322793,
-0.0088130059,
-0.4385459721,
0.1745422482,
-0.0396500565,
0.4373685718,
0.2828599513,
-0.9525955915,
0.197216481,
0.9142045975,
0.487244606,
-0.1569154412,
-0.1116474792,
-0.4493277967,
0.3286208808,
-0.3428980112,
0.3524171114,
-0.7348304391,
-0.1762702614,
0.1148218587,
0.038463369,
0.0285119507,
-0.5912664533,
0.5437672138,
-0.2239708602,
0.5127151012,
-0.536295414,
-0.5959952474,
0.1069865301,
0.2283683866,
-0.6957104802,
0.8578428626,
-0.093234323,
-0.9803398848,
0.4813314676,
-0.4990527928,
-0.2576956153,
-0.0069610165,
-0.3652704954,
-0.6373229027,
-0.2469367534,
0.3917748034,
0.1174910367,
-0.3990919292,
0.526871562,
-0.5420566201,
-0.2485384643,
0.2813163102,
-0.3510419726,
0.630918026,
0.0978768617,
-0.2353641689,
0.3405183256,
-0.494694978,
-0.3096089661,
0.1373514086,
-0.0753032342,
-0.4401385486,
0.0066895606,
-0.116989851,
0.1747048348,
0.1391046643,
-0.5104656816,
0.2334748209,
-0.3943739235,
0.332105726,
1.0226230621,
-0.5353032351,
0.8996831775,
-0.4206979275,
0.6952491403,
-0.0521285906,
0.2202867419,
0.2623153925,
-0.4370881915,
-0.5632067919,
-0.1672912538,
0.425971657,
0.5562256575,
-0.4114283025,
0.5789473653,
-0.4365123212,
-0.093177937,
-0.9603756666,
0.3530552983,
0.5756886005,
0.656775713,
0.043068964,
-0.0597703084,
-0.5196527839,
-1.2187954187,
-0.4684593678,
-0.09249378,
0.0922152326,
0.0596701093,
0.3283953667,
0.1056298912,
0.8994602561,
-0.3817350268,
-0.4014929235,
-0.0701225847,
0.2202379704,
0.1068652049,
0.521500349,
0.2118482292,
-0.5899231434,
-0.0279224031,
-0.2810990512,
-0.5640403628,
-0.319503963,
0.0650935248,
-0.5857102871,
0.2130201459,
0.6234719157,
-0.4260094464,
0.2567691207,
0.7284362316,
-0.3531781137,
0.2768480778,
0.3291734755,
-0.0281999111,
-1.0249987841,
0.1657047719,
-0.0184814334,
-0.3936244547,
-0.4473438859,
-0.324239403,
0.0915055051,
-0.0266245939,
-0.4204528034,
0.5889974236,
-0.5345636606,
-0.2650795281,
-0.0125336172,
0.1425306499,
-0.206888631,
0.1684273034,
-0.0919571966,
0.7764729857,
0.119958289,
-0.2770006359,
0.1063081175,
0.7479449511,
-0.0666266903,
0.946077168,
-0.3184232116,
0.1893883944,
-0.4903711975,
0.2637362182,
-0.8960408568,
-0.2385729402,
0.5295384526,
-0.3955241144,
0.5730707645,
-0.1901974082,
-0.1820591539,
-0.3311192989,
-0.4989749789,
0.6068361402,
0.0992847979,
-0.454000473,
0.5012150407,
0.5282390714,
-0.449028343,
-1.0632373095,
-0.5273533463,
0.0498472266,
-0.3959065378,
-0.5050476193,
0.2029695213,
-0.2526127398,
-0.2110732645,
-0.0827912763,
-0.1324452311,
0.389667809,
-0.116269812,
0.2201714069,
0.2694345713,
-0.2105483711,
0.4460030198,
0.0097492831,
-0.089248769,
-0.0197037272,
-0.0565467328,
0.830142498,
0.1477177888,
-0.5630844235,
-0.4878925681,
0.4544548094,
0.6347152591,
-0.0757157058,
0.8244796395,
0.5323427916,
-0.5105785131,
0.0506923124,
-0.5226192474,
-0.2291174084,
-0.4805170298,
0.2122969627,
0.0693450347,
-1.1944497824,
0.38718009,
0.1428187788,
0.1617359221,
0.3605329692,
0.5682303905,
-0.2000746429,
1.4078013897,
0.4502145946,
-0.4921002686,
0.392991811,
0.3330028951,
0.4586350024,
-1.0208939314,
-0.2493752986,
-0.6452473998,
-0.7426053882,
-0.7058171034,
0.0434692763,
0.0065809055,
-0.1809207648,
-0.9121569991,
0.0255159717,
-0.5667685866,
0.3765341938,
0.5029986501,
0.0390645601,
0.3117243648,
0.0098984847,
0.0680740774,
-0.4808944166,
-0.7009695768,
-0.6600628495,
1.1255397797,
0.5204644203,
1.1125061512,
0.4226112068,
0.3826404512,
0.1149813682,
0.3093280494,
-0.6868625283,
0.4768198729,
-0.2363318354,
-0.874925971,
-0.4479664266,
-0.656879127,
-0.9998459816,
-0.1011678576,
-0.3793430924,
-0.7033377886,
0.0620625392,
0.2159727812,
-0.1869995743,
0.2622191012,
-0.3533174396,
0.7556009293,
-0.3106280267,
-0.3474262655,
0.1378050447,
-0.6280088425,
0.5562975407,
-0.1278038621,
0.2146023065,
-0.4289322793,
0.2404452115,
0.9612523913,
-0.3283508718,
0.9370406866,
-0.1062360182,
-0.4523208439,
-0.3036913574,
0.0886049792,
0.3669014573,
0.0620826632,
-0.0678810477,
0.0526365303,
-0.3021429479,
-0.1473930627,
-0.3178725541,
0.7682857513,
-0.73919034,
-0.6526216865,
-0.4123524725,
-0.7972578406,
-0.1718343943,
0.3124285638,
0.1250842363,
0.2640183866,
-0.14386262,
0.0190383829,
0.752626121,
-0.3918316662,
0.2254837751,
0.5029928088,
-0.3470809758,
-0.4691387713,
0.4676211774,
-0.0156108467,
0.2788555324,
0.3215692639,
0.2339428812,
-0.4973942041,
-0.2272692323,
-0.4076968133,
0.4439550638,
-0.6151438951,
-0.5451767445,
-0.2870980799,
-0.2145171463,
-0.7143191695,
0.078087464,
-0.4177867174,
-0.3847840428,
-0.2639074028,
-0.1079812795,
0.3498785496,
0.6073015332,
0.2187839448,
0.4896064401,
-0.6740583181,
0.2793600857,
0.2957089841,
0.4695267081,
-0.2892392278,
-0.6065046191,
0.3032443523,
0.1884491444,
-0.2123308778,
-0.6722190976,
0.4101047516,
0.1922282726,
0.5926633477,
0.3773509562,
-0.0219972245,
0.7889690995,
-0.4157683253,
0.6039184928,
0.4456224144,
-1.0516736507,
0.5593349934,
-0.6570379734,
0.4913974404,
0.5699763894,
0.2201191336,
-0.7276211381,
-0.2589826286,
-0.3182334006,
-0.7804297805,
0.747217834,
0.3410574198,
-0.0379885659,
0.3330172598,
0.5167530179,
0.2014316171,
0.6516156793,
-0.5942004919,
-0.368044436,
0.178334862,
-0.7501131892,
0.0787352473,
-0.089883782,
-0.5568286777,
-0.3222559094,
0.8690626621,
-0.2206333429,
0.3243374527,
-0.2353494018,
-0.1984142214,
-0.4904806316,
0.2914201915,
0.7441338301,
0.5614668727,
-0.3089577258,
-0.0618338808,
0.0094528301,
-0.5162910223,
0.1864475459,
-0.0708389729,
-0.287078619,
-0.2578603923,
0.2672589123,
0.679358542,
0.0382816195,
-0.3802787662,
0.5180992484,
-0.285330981,
-0.1761018932,
-0.191534549,
-0.1474749446,
0.3692064583,
0.2259767354,
-0.0140317669,
-0.2102833241,
-0.0066026468,
-0.3040736318,
-0.1555103511,
0.6862280369,
-0.4831939042,
0.0951725319,
0.7137892842,
0.3449854255,
-0.3532135487,
0.9660208821,
0.0343014449,
-0.4263794422,
0.492210418,
0.5993227363,
0.7380539179,
-0.4204759896,
0.1514885575,
0.4761585295,
0.4290681481,
-0.3480575085,
0.2363883406,
0.4536158442,
-1.0447611809,
-0.464933008,
-0.496309191,
-0.3974520862,
0.3398827314,
-0.7894994617,
0.364558816,
-0.4620393515,
-0.2754733264,
-0.2492193431,
-0.3153061569,
-0.6603688002,
-0.1266721189,
0.4377359748,
0.5828418136,
-0.9689015746,
0.4175271988,
0.6949511766,
-0.1534458846,
-0.7871491313,
-0.0470351875,
0.5894008279,
-0.9722255468,
0.5567007065,
0.2521369755,
-0.2675927281,
-0.1903085411,
-0.7894824743,
-1.0244470835,
1.1094624996,
0.7623137832,
-0.9911806583,
0.1003059074,
0.4623915851,
0.0345164239,
-0.4697456658,
0.0813957751,
0.793777287,
0.7824445367,
-0.09078978,
-1.0188168287,
0.2481963038,
-0.172545135,
0.0200601667,
0.3466060162,
-0.5705553293,
0.5715423226,
0.2300580293,
-0.1036679745,
0.0470823236,
0.3109885454,
0.4982939363,
0.2205132246,
0.6188800335,
0.7248851061,
1.0014464855,
-0.3872978091,
0.3770854175,
-0.0470803864,
0.2247227281,
1.2756233215,
-0.6844876409,
0.5462433696,
0.5518870354,
-0.0230385102,
0.2443964481,
0.6113099456,
0.0875621885,
0.2610197663,
0.4663089514,
-0.0096784318,
-0.5337353945,
-0.283822298,
-0.3685970902,
0.4650933146,
0.4038465321,
-0.243749097,
-0.0698046312,
-0.0761874914,
0.3193738163,
0.1153010204,
-0.3096635342,
0.7838807702,
0.1339439601,
-0.509760797,
0.1961354911,
-0.2182167321,
0.8035472631,
-0.4445888996,
-0.1168797836,
-0.2973776758,
0.1831612736,
-0.4327012002,
-0.7900260687,
-0.0263643339,
-0.14226529,
-0.3431601822,
-0.3897936344,
0.8065767288,
-0.800077498,
-0.5986842513,
0.1248713806,
0.4858166873,
-0.1725198328,
0.1010299176,
-0.8404510617,
0.0954711363,
-0.0575910248,
-0.0099507654,
0.2882711887,
0.1934074312,
-0.2255046368,
0.8060953617,
0.5747181773,
0.0002320534,
-0.165667817,
0.434966594,
0.5617868304,
-0.7288864255,
-0.3069962263,
-0.7868093252,
0.4328339696,
-0.2538251877,
-0.3401090503,
0.6720685959,
0.4774116576,
0.59788239,
0.2201180905,
0.6700434685,
0.4202772975,
0.6629571319,
-0.6557685137,
0.7690326571,
-0.5280493498,
0.4671018422,
-0.4178583026,
-0.9561328888,
-0.5598300099,
0.752269268,
-0.1544733495,
0.2088606954,
0.4493077695,
1.1315200329,
0.0071489126,
0.1353165358,
0.0742568746,
0.0542931408,
0.3229534626,
0.1893721521,
1.138830781,
-0.2824059129,
0.4057796896,
0.1572538912,
0.0418418199,
-0.1941603273,
-1.1846408844,
-0.8481350541,
-0.2580039203,
-0.581142962,
-0.201433152,
0.1695528775,
1.0843081474,
0.7583400607,
-0.6332666278,
-0.2675392926,
0.0442043915,
0.2107806206,
-0.0403338447,
-0.1936547309,
0.2095933408,
-0.0543243997,
-0.5733261704,
0.1190285534,
0.0807267204,
-0.0711010322,
-0.2755079567,
-0.2828930318,
-0.2724845707,
-0.1753769517,
0.242672503,
0.036549028,
-0.614916265,
-0.4142692387,
0.1403779835,
-0.1062390655,
0.2196865082,
0.8365162015,
-0.3249786794,
0.2190554142,
0.5436097383,
0.3512553275,
0.0508758016,
0.0252954215,
1.0561431646,
-0.8817503452,
-0.0466479883,
0.1834278256,
0.39737764,
0.7462824583,
-0.5782065392,
0.2652828693,
-0.0466702953,
-0.5989052653,
-0.7196345329,
0.1989315152,
-0.9421392679,
-0.199857682,
1.3187861443,
0.3773466349,
-0.2922936678,
-0.105751738,
-0.3534096479,
0.5137583017,
-0.7857692838,
0.5219561458,
0.8895439506,
0.1420518458,
-0.2682785094,
-0.4850615263,
0.4327125251,
0.6744584441,
-0.796525538,
0.3305034935,
0.5903781652,
0.3513633907,
-0.0814384967,
0.3704505563,
-0.3044999838,
-0.0025935932,
-0.6122152805,
0.281681329,
0.2249108404,
-0.1764418036,
-0.7092908621,
-0.2350168675,
0.1216951758,
-0.0362030454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13923v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13923v1 | PIN: A Knowledge-Intensive Dataset for Paired and Interleaved Multimodal Documents | 2024-06-20T01:43:08 | 2024-06-20T01:43:08 | Junjie Wang, Yin Zhang, Yatai Ji, Yuxiang Zhang, Chunyang Jiang, Yubo Wang, Kang Zhu, Zekun Wang, Tiezhen Wang, Wenhao Huang, Jie Fu, Bei Chen, Qunshu Lin, Minghao Liu, Ge Zhang, Wenhu Chen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM | Recent advancements in Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have leveraged
extensive multimodal datasets to enhance capabilities in complex
knowledge-driven tasks. However, persistent challenges in perceptual and
reasoning errors limit their efficacy, particularly in interpreting intricate
visual data and deducing multimodal relationships. Addressing these issues, we
introduce a novel dataset format, PIN (Paired and INterleaved multimodal
documents), designed to significantly improve both the depth and breadth of
multimodal training. The PIN format is built on three foundational principles:
knowledge intensity, scalability, and support for diverse training modalities.
This innovative format combines markdown files and comprehensive images to
enrich training data with a dense knowledge structure and versatile training
strategies. We present PIN-14M, an open-source dataset comprising 14 million
samples derived from a diverse range of Chinese and English sources, tailored
to include complex web and scientific content. This dataset is constructed
meticulously to ensure data quality and ethical integrity, aiming to facilitate
advanced training strategies and improve model robustness against common
multimodal training pitfalls. Our initial results, forming the basis of this
technical report, suggest significant potential for the PIN format in refining
LMM performance, with plans for future expansions and detailed evaluations of
its impact on model capabilities. | [
-0.1554678231,
-0.4299785197,
0.4870121181,
0.4086444378,
-0.3811388016,
0.1125024781,
-0.2748355567,
-0.159968242,
0.0814576223,
0.0703978464,
-0.5328365564,
-0.6201143265,
-0.6015933156,
-0.2013077736,
-0.0629568547,
0.7662402391,
-0.2173965722,
0.4799430668,
-0.4316785634,
-0.3874548674,
-0.6450730562,
-0.5165144801,
0.0035439942,
-0.1818412691,
0.7665153742,
0.7215859294,
0.2821194828,
0.8301492929,
1.0035486221,
0.0950060636,
0.4571270943,
0.6121457219,
-0.4776885211,
0.0715187639,
-0.1514598876,
-0.2839003801,
-0.6251347661,
0.1861733943,
0.5997424722,
0.8123114705,
0.2485082448,
0.1421952695,
0.0081778327,
0.6380990148,
-0.4572641551,
0.6487995386,
-0.8131130934,
-0.1413086206,
-0.3445491493,
-0.2952113152,
-0.4090878963,
-0.0280899405,
-0.0380825363,
-0.8640038371,
0.3689638078,
0.0289433859,
0.5347427726,
0.0970876515,
-0.6327964067,
-0.2124536484,
-0.4624162316,
0.6103522778,
-0.3682130873,
0.6221833229,
0.4707083404,
0.3319981098,
0.1450511068,
-0.8117896914,
-0.5503416657,
0.2205952108,
0.0110297278,
0.1331549734,
0.4799840152,
0.1540321857,
0.3293772042,
0.1356021166,
-0.5909720659,
0.047828082,
-0.5495826602,
0.0005806158,
0.5751251578,
0.2363208085,
0.2790163457,
-0.2270354629,
-0.505743444,
-0.478492856,
-0.6475471854,
0.2765161693,
0.394119978,
0.4708869755,
-0.3988819122,
0.6780764461,
-0.2845861018,
0.4891808927,
-0.0230218433,
-0.3588033617,
0.3166968822,
-0.5028128028,
0.2497401834,
0.0039729304,
0.5971054435,
0.9071843624,
-0.0021032945,
-0.1137591079,
-0.019962769,
0.2094170004,
0.1305840909,
-0.7458446622,
-0.5482953191,
0.1154147089,
-0.5181142688,
-0.147028327,
0.4976746142,
-0.7063978314,
-0.660612762,
-0.3471411169,
0.5741872191,
-0.7115451097,
-0.1984586567,
0.127365157,
-0.2478810102,
0.1135822088,
0.4253258407,
-0.9161570072,
-0.1206806153,
0.6631906629,
0.8575031161,
-0.1184448376,
-0.4836036563,
-0.3505595624,
0.5524370074,
-0.3868500292,
0.6057134271,
-0.685023129,
-0.1921801418,
-0.1250963658,
0.242812112,
-0.0618164055,
-0.4235508144,
0.6059356928,
-0.1851415038,
-0.3499327302,
-0.4599944949,
-0.3758915365,
-0.4132320583,
0.4115333557,
-0.9308080673,
0.85337466,
-0.1570361704,
-0.8181824088,
0.8258569241,
-0.5790666342,
-0.4915894866,
0.0294365846,
-0.5222665071,
-0.2589421272,
-0.0093650538,
0.4543067217,
0.8240220547,
-0.262863785,
0.671279788,
-0.868701756,
-0.3833779693,
0.1370117217,
-0.4230704308,
0.2789576948,
-0.0744400695,
-0.1129922569,
0.1907119751,
-1.0614010096,
-0.2539087534,
0.1325262785,
-0.2132357508,
-0.3877068758,
0.0805940032,
-0.0920108035,
0.2855121791,
0.1978636682,
-0.7535614371,
0.2777626216,
0.4019874036,
0.620713532,
0.8392888308,
-0.049597472,
0.2337516695,
-0.5262151361,
0.1735356599,
0.355995506,
0.3467407823,
-0.7286707163,
-0.4241393507,
-0.6902801394,
-0.4391069412,
-0.0551351793,
0.0841368735,
-0.7991137505,
0.1718875617,
-0.5265452266,
-0.6122484803,
-0.7195472717,
0.220252201,
0.2564760149,
0.7073773146,
0.4168395996,
-0.1107321158,
-0.5428678393,
-0.9378641248,
0.1213926151,
0.0367947817,
0.3465399146,
0.3531499803,
0.5398093462,
-0.1763155758,
0.8124245405,
-0.2738973498,
-0.3950690031,
-0.0650038123,
0.3359562457,
0.277775228,
0.8733687997,
0.284863025,
-0.8910188079,
-0.4136016965,
-0.1121221706,
-1.0094015598,
0.2835203111,
-0.2004676312,
-0.2206057161,
-0.3585323691,
0.4871597886,
-0.3141967952,
0.2494754195,
0.5255188346,
-0.149017483,
0.3204340637,
-0.2236267477,
0.427025944,
-0.9467228055,
0.2162794024,
-0.1951895654,
0.1272336841,
-0.4150693715,
-0.1168502942,
0.6862748265,
-0.3014025688,
-0.3303985894,
0.4632560909,
-0.4496329427,
0.0940173194,
0.2316441536,
-0.1995244026,
0.3808296919,
0.5289155245,
0.1704860777,
0.6034926176,
0.3148157895,
-0.3000662327,
0.5589078665,
0.4366177619,
-0.4987155497,
0.8672814369,
-0.4720733762,
0.2335280329,
-0.2594043016,
0.0923772231,
-0.9183831215,
-0.554854393,
-0.0559223853,
-0.4529557824,
0.202400282,
-0.228566885,
-0.7282254696,
-0.17693609,
-0.6799378395,
0.6411332488,
-0.1412120163,
-0.6728339791,
0.3959042728,
0.0799227804,
-0.0922061205,
-0.5702614188,
-0.5639090538,
-0.1745310426,
-0.0750921071,
-0.8633897305,
0.1353883892,
-0.4010878205,
0.0628746971,
0.0753247812,
-0.0393195897,
-0.1590750813,
-0.1534747481,
0.6794604659,
0.3689781725,
-0.091206342,
0.5273625255,
0.126287058,
0.0208222829,
-0.2219242007,
-0.0807669461,
0.5799913406,
0.1186963171,
-0.7983794212,
-0.2875843942,
0.550383985,
0.6960729957,
-0.5401584506,
0.7067947388,
0.7513448,
-0.4018162787,
-0.0608756766,
-0.4756919742,
-0.1976859868,
-0.3847863078,
0.3482976556,
-0.6474373937,
-0.5354296565,
0.3151002824,
-0.0436337925,
0.0685359165,
0.1262447685,
0.2469379008,
-0.5280737877,
1.0320042372,
0.604847014,
0.1783451289,
0.2838309705,
-0.3847579956,
0.127517581,
-0.9079750776,
-0.954072535,
-0.0814475715,
-0.7077076435,
0.0788956285,
-0.734911263,
0.5873923898,
0.1735035926,
-0.2720964849,
-0.1686363816,
-0.142567575,
0.1819651425,
0.7142346501,
0.5851433277,
0.549508214,
0.025025947,
-0.1627269685,
-0.4258630276,
-0.7434135079,
-0.3226622045,
1.4804365635,
0.3177191913,
1.2051647902,
-0.1609164029,
0.1639720201,
0.3445387483,
-0.217625916,
-0.5355229974,
0.2943938375,
-0.3218603134,
-0.7087699175,
0.1243297905,
-0.1401918977,
-0.4620656669,
-0.1279185414,
-0.5390692949,
-0.1418091953,
0.3089961708,
0.238889277,
-0.1255135834,
0.6455080509,
-0.8915879726,
0.9819918871,
-0.5020626783,
-0.2907500863,
-0.1169433743,
-0.8363435864,
0.5030857325,
-0.2682581246,
0.1621565074,
-0.3785215318,
-0.0029939185,
0.8305317163,
-0.2018912733,
0.8801273704,
-0.1847797781,
0.2152505219,
0.0415175073,
-0.0371229053,
0.3219829202,
0.2200350314,
0.1684603542,
0.1373198479,
-0.0697430372,
-0.3901726007,
-0.5489510298,
0.6378399134,
-0.8673531413,
0.0097502535,
-0.1950518191,
-1.281750083,
-0.404422909,
0.2690104246,
0.1609621942,
0.933229208,
0.2329224944,
0.8750928044,
0.7117198706,
-0.1328643709,
0.2186787874,
0.413392216,
0.0902679041,
-0.5923095345,
1.0481057167,
0.3143423796,
0.2811286747,
0.4980932772,
-0.1408354938,
-0.3861990571,
-0.5911483765,
-0.2532426417,
0.4102532268,
-0.9048008323,
-0.1909357905,
-0.8822891116,
-0.1056584269,
-0.5547634363,
-0.2436480075,
-0.4434438348,
-0.3663680553,
-0.1910231411,
-0.3837470412,
0.4550459385,
0.6873009801,
-0.2890183926,
0.3669538498,
-0.7893449068,
0.4483739138,
0.3474857509,
0.6612195373,
-0.1432650089,
-0.1436858624,
-0.2380401343,
0.0458064936,
0.1096541137,
-0.5619724989,
-0.0269347634,
0.3367224336,
0.7059558034,
0.6332114339,
0.2714723051,
0.8306524754,
-0.3498200178,
0.430572629,
0.3704128563,
-0.4979456961,
0.5863953233,
-0.4345613718,
-0.0196322836,
0.6695225835,
0.7879106998,
-0.5739421248,
0.2843487859,
-0.3855130374,
-0.6802370548,
0.6966744065,
-0.3614257276,
-0.2054484338,
0.3436969519,
0.0900479257,
0.6219601631,
0.4434978664,
-0.5555765629,
0.1882391423,
-0.4535485804,
-0.6089950204,
-0.2266139239,
-0.3882820606,
-0.4287825823,
-0.2684155703,
0.3553107381,
-0.3707732558,
0.060213469,
0.1617003381,
-0.4865200222,
0.2134575695,
-0.1637094021,
0.3710932136,
0.7918806672,
-0.5568013787,
0.4807890356,
-0.4410446882,
-0.6453450918,
0.2114173174,
0.1006906554,
-0.0905904919,
-0.2539601922,
0.6102070212,
0.772718668,
0.1073506922,
-0.8276851177,
0.5513387918,
-0.0354484729,
-0.1430919915,
0.1932835579,
-0.3775001764,
-0.0505468175,
0.4587049484,
0.2554409504,
-0.0400834158,
-0.1456065029,
-0.4660227597,
0.3384500742,
0.2229469717,
-0.4525313079,
-0.4657892585,
0.6266040802,
0.4563542306,
0.3509146869,
0.5342274308,
-0.0834414661,
-0.1947532445,
0.298029691,
0.3828329742,
0.2249276191,
0.1989207268,
0.2091064304,
0.3723558784,
0.6042104363,
0.1153884754,
0.5136935711,
-0.0932839289,
-0.7130134702,
-0.0392772779,
-0.3387015164,
-0.2393834591,
0.2240116745,
-0.7231117487,
0.3764353096,
-0.7948497534,
-0.0036126196,
-0.5540207624,
-0.0427111499,
-0.6814620495,
0.2646695673,
0.008096586,
0.9465480447,
-0.9774762392,
0.8335277438,
0.7424968481,
-0.6804276705,
-0.9035825133,
-0.5240707397,
-0.0015771806,
-1.0396473408,
0.6975613832,
0.3408273757,
0.216228351,
-0.2492280155,
-0.552647233,
-0.6214993596,
1.3763233423,
0.3343695104,
-0.6223964095,
-0.1471541375,
0.2968064845,
-0.1602417082,
-0.2922461927,
0.0323913246,
0.2494736314,
0.3859892488,
0.1012973189,
-0.6083658934,
-0.1614004374,
-0.3822724521,
-0.122949861,
-0.0082773054,
-0.7889229655,
1.106140852,
-0.0899866223,
0.0427766368,
-0.1253704429,
0.433734417,
0.3527397215,
0.3667398095,
0.3956184983,
0.5861987472,
0.713606298,
-0.2552121282,
0.4015654922,
-0.3889303207,
-0.0217461362,
1.3322327137,
-0.3572689295,
0.5823794603,
0.6140779257,
0.3301342428,
0.215110451,
0.6187090874,
-0.1820498258,
0.5361115932,
-0.5217049122,
-0.0432584994,
-0.3747342527,
-0.5256830454,
-0.5636540651,
0.5211136937,
0.3715077639,
-0.154559806,
-0.1538626254,
0.298315376,
-0.0270179138,
0.2084271163,
-0.2992539108,
0.3754078448,
-0.2048419565,
-0.0762376115,
-0.0514570773,
-0.2938534319,
0.8011269569,
-0.8237662911,
-0.3599750102,
-0.3417492509,
0.2301665992,
-0.2465550601,
-0.9323914647,
-0.2230511308,
-0.0265879035,
-0.4065141082,
-0.2868884504,
0.7620745301,
-0.5715554953,
-0.5351395607,
0.3012761474,
0.3888676763,
-0.0649232343,
-0.1696321368,
-0.435841769,
0.4136823118,
-0.3429910839,
0.3825777471,
0.1130894721,
0.6617712975,
-0.1050073057,
0.6706591249,
0.7983155847,
-0.0130688939,
0.4119491577,
-0.0132918293,
1.0079277754,
-0.6101517081,
-0.4255975187,
-0.4490688741,
0.677955091,
-0.1821893901,
-0.2267706394,
0.6466254592,
0.6819056869,
0.9758511782,
-0.0823427513,
0.796661675,
-0.046662204,
0.6610789895,
-0.5890648961,
0.8061000109,
-0.6172776818,
-0.1159643307,
-0.2279769629,
-0.6403460503,
-0.2211476713,
0.2398983687,
-0.1011673734,
-0.1884738505,
0.569955945,
0.6756496429,
-0.2246142924,
-0.1445670873,
0.2896566093,
0.0189488325,
0.6253883839,
0.6289131641,
0.9788826704,
-0.3315311372,
0.7769566178,
-0.672544241,
-0.3237748444,
-0.2425165027,
-0.7647987008,
-1.0104836226,
-0.8938981295,
0.1267896444,
0.2282799035,
-0.098491177,
0.9572217464,
1.0772008896,
-0.4454856813,
-0.1737659425,
0.4092311561,
-0.2114576101,
-0.0158447586,
-0.0831211582,
0.2890420258,
-0.3098447621,
-0.5489678979,
0.5162798762,
0.413947016,
0.0181756392,
-0.1421511471,
-0.1358381361,
-0.5217219591,
-0.3931708634,
0.6161768436,
-0.0381252356,
-0.2699292302,
-0.2619762719,
0.1341508329,
-0.0465624779,
0.2721650898,
1.0235135555,
-0.4389165044,
1.1102902889,
0.566347003,
0.6954962015,
0.301088661,
-0.0760798678,
0.5425171852,
-0.755490005,
0.5822230577,
0.1686493009,
0.5182130337,
0.4249722958,
-0.0178777147,
0.5485223532,
0.6374688745,
-0.1308537573,
-0.9073569775,
-0.0003543472,
-1.4004263878,
-0.2145056576,
0.7020004392,
-0.4199619591,
0.0444335155,
0.0534344316,
-0.3629794121,
0.2195758522,
-0.4078074992,
0.5103557706,
0.6748524904,
0.0948001072,
-0.2338485122,
-0.3407330811,
0.0866865739,
0.0505668223,
-0.7947505713,
-0.1357218325,
0.3751053512,
-0.0558306798,
-0.0460233614,
0.3902170956,
-0.2689346373,
0.2173288167,
0.2557749748,
0.1408942789,
-0.5966985226,
-0.9937083721,
-0.1942326576,
0.288010329,
0.0690692216,
-0.4524148405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02511v1 | LLM-A*: Large Language Model Enhanced Incremental Heuristic Search on Path Planning | 2024-06-20T01:24:30 | 2024-06-20T01:24:30 | Silin Meng, Yiwei Wang, Cheng-Fu Yang, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL | Path planning is a fundamental scientific problem in robotics and autonomous
navigation, requiring the derivation of efficient routes from starting to
destination points while avoiding obstacles. Traditional algorithms like A* and
its variants are capable of ensuring path validity but suffer from significant
computational and memory inefficiencies as the state space grows. Conversely,
large language models (LLMs) excel in broader environmental analysis through
contextual understanding, providing global insights into environments. However,
they fall short in detailed spatial and temporal reasoning, often leading to
invalid or inefficient routes. In this work, we propose LLM-A*, an new LLM
based route planning method that synergistically combines the precise
pathfinding capabilities of A* with the global reasoning capability of LLMs.
This hybrid approach aims to enhance pathfinding efficiency in terms of time
and space complexity while maintaining the integrity of path validity,
especially in large-scale scenarios. By integrating the strengths of both
methodologies, LLM-A* addresses the computational and memory limitations of
conventional algorithms without compromising on the validity required for
effective pathfinding. | [
-0.1459484249,
-0.9856833816,
1.0263774395,
0.1838897616,
-0.1731956303,
0.2769908309,
-0.1939408034,
-0.5417555571,
0.5040894151,
0.399630487,
-0.9692387581,
-0.5603732467,
-0.3978547454,
-0.2859931588,
-0.2197833657,
0.0455425829,
-0.3021480143,
0.1381384581,
-0.1382293701,
-0.2896343172,
-0.2801978886,
-0.5165027976,
-0.7209394574,
-0.4962916672,
0.7939826846,
0.3538561463,
0.8183365464,
0.7051335573,
0.646299243,
0.2314979583,
-0.2321797311,
0.3715267479,
-0.0601703078,
0.3022916317,
-0.2983874083,
-0.0389892943,
-0.505602777,
-0.3750084341,
0.9457945228,
0.6028944254,
-0.132093519,
0.0526409224,
-0.5545617342,
0.6063554883,
-0.7836977839,
-0.0558842197,
-0.7121909261,
0.0964956954,
-0.1124795377,
-0.4570116699,
-0.0457466953,
-0.1652465761,
0.2538420856,
-0.6198170781,
-0.2690312862,
0.220453158,
0.6063218713,
0.4139409661,
-0.3545010984,
-0.4678321183,
-0.9648035765,
0.8094041348,
-0.6943666935,
0.4448139369,
0.0014286408,
0.5738384128,
-0.2627367079,
-0.3093520403,
-0.5852447152,
-0.3732560277,
0.0869192705,
-0.0282574948,
0.0508368276,
0.1113278717,
0.2467763573,
0.0358901806,
-0.4949359,
0.3031355143,
-0.2660720944,
-0.1977667958,
0.7694196701,
0.3381361365,
0.3137548864,
0.0377954729,
-0.5215365887,
0.0145952478,
-0.9993955493,
0.0861465856,
0.2645210028,
0.2554521859,
0.1077812687,
0.7352022529,
-0.316872716,
0.5769544244,
-0.5694429278,
-0.2651490569,
-0.0961020067,
-0.48345083,
0.1779134721,
-0.0240222048,
0.6728093028,
0.1524983644,
0.1187355667,
-0.2129149586,
-0.2176288366,
0.0204909276,
0.0757708773,
-0.5656015277,
-0.1499082893,
0.3176072836,
-0.2916487157,
0.352016449,
-0.2345552146,
-0.5946311355,
-0.2744608521,
-0.3652084172,
0.4255694449,
-0.4341955483,
-0.3216153979,
0.2217316329,
0.0163326971,
0.2973086536,
0.7011427283,
-0.4303994775,
0.1181258485,
0.5538241267,
0.9185131788,
-0.1167122275,
-0.4391805828,
-0.4871542752,
0.4424687028,
-0.1501083076,
0.8508812189,
-0.7127982974,
-0.5108859539,
-0.1425718963,
-0.2892047763,
-0.0195101611,
-0.3074499071,
0.6133660674,
-0.5610393286,
-0.1315563768,
-0.3225276768,
-0.3508951962,
-0.785214901,
0.4888395071,
-0.4998371005,
1.0013010502,
-0.0172881614,
-0.3311689496,
0.3248358369,
-0.8569824696,
-0.7069808841,
0.1361232549,
-0.017646974,
-0.1512497663,
-0.2778377831,
0.393366158,
0.2000391781,
-0.3755804896,
0.3870066106,
-0.1488805711,
-0.4603332281,
-0.2434694916,
-0.3390520811,
0.8296669722,
-0.0446377769,
-0.2882139385,
0.5459678173,
-0.6264348626,
0.1042843312,
0.2101043165,
-0.5890045166,
-0.4881354272,
0.371286869,
-0.011859376,
0.4494330287,
0.7635607123,
-0.5577951074,
0.5469616652,
-0.4354446232,
0.1928350925,
0.8467665911,
0.023708351,
0.6669021249,
-0.3469778895,
0.6451919079,
-0.3715595901,
0.22927019,
-0.4537328482,
-0.6018425226,
-0.8572784066,
-0.1070931852,
-0.1264713109,
0.9804227352,
-0.4570188224,
0.5864290595,
-0.3127156496,
-0.5910393,
-0.2012269795,
0.0773291066,
0.1396972835,
0.1221856922,
0.4664588273,
-0.1419566423,
-0.8106411695,
-0.3786168396,
0.0219924878,
-0.1126840189,
0.2045176178,
0.6363883615,
0.4944723248,
-0.4729188979,
0.7727303505,
-0.4102460444,
-0.2094942629,
-0.287235558,
-0.4126687646,
0.0237662755,
0.2723246813,
0.2148221433,
-0.650631249,
-0.2665295601,
-0.2469976544,
-0.8758624792,
0.1008517295,
-0.2466463745,
-0.3322342634,
0.0295066349,
0.6390429735,
-0.6809900999,
0.2263509035,
0.5246381164,
-0.4896214008,
0.3183695078,
-0.5007274151,
-0.1850406528,
-0.6577971578,
-0.0841353536,
0.0890607685,
0.0851220042,
-0.2205533385,
0.5592659712,
-0.0552638285,
0.0859449655,
-0.4735083282,
1.0004729033,
-0.4867386818,
-0.1725961268,
-0.231468454,
0.0528065339,
-0.236297667,
0.3967518508,
-0.0327126309,
0.6747627854,
0.73960042,
-0.6801108718,
0.5050350428,
0.2164304703,
0.0154192606,
0.220936358,
-0.2406160235,
0.1396086365,
-0.11746189,
0.5529272556,
-0.8833514452,
-0.002427699,
0.0564787015,
-0.0295511857,
0.101763308,
0.0343411714,
-0.8831886649,
-0.4371678829,
-0.1620766819,
0.710164547,
0.3873756528,
-0.6674739122,
0.8909071684,
0.4118840694,
0.0458072796,
-0.1782528907,
-0.3005728424,
0.3198400736,
-0.213050887,
-0.9218034744,
0.2242573947,
-0.2471579909,
-0.3505468667,
-0.0975903049,
-0.1309152097,
0.0629412755,
0.1422629952,
0.1642068326,
0.2707332671,
-0.1051099673,
-0.2819062769,
-0.0952425301,
-0.3095240891,
0.1095300838,
-0.3265819252,
0.7328108549,
0.3003479838,
-0.5160961747,
-0.420023948,
0.543933332,
0.7338769436,
-0.4193615615,
0.5493171811,
0.4716510475,
-0.3966523409,
-0.1532892138,
-0.4268898964,
-0.1512848437,
-0.5042721629,
0.2889694571,
-0.2511360347,
-0.9452157021,
0.3925026655,
-0.6105806828,
0.1942960769,
0.335203141,
0.2944185138,
0.0153867239,
0.821520865,
0.6402765512,
-0.1236693785,
0.3466973305,
-0.477009058,
0.4266662002,
-1.0084615946,
-0.5369156003,
-0.3412825167,
-0.4376322031,
-0.6047537923,
-0.6226018071,
0.7602534294,
-0.1647884846,
-0.4544985294,
0.3309411705,
-0.2697825134,
0.2724535167,
0.699230969,
0.0149271116,
0.3826404512,
-0.0504381843,
-0.3629214168,
0.1448179483,
-0.9768266678,
-0.3330510259,
0.950115025,
0.2472319305,
0.6155039072,
0.1534085721,
0.569121778,
-0.1716442108,
0.1149165034,
-0.9420877695,
1.0090614557,
-0.1228167415,
-0.4629579186,
-0.5813921094,
-0.3844208717,
-0.7695084214,
0.2737903297,
-0.4924363196,
-0.9897507429,
-0.1930096298,
0.1759701073,
-0.3158771694,
0.6189563274,
-0.3468492329,
0.4112603366,
-0.5864428878,
-0.5562392473,
-0.4000453055,
-0.4666171968,
0.2339825481,
0.0368912481,
0.3985688388,
-0.3411582708,
-0.254347831,
0.38408041,
-0.1192563027,
0.3110568523,
-0.2822847664,
-0.2660857737,
0.3076321781,
0.4527312517,
0.9592137337,
-0.0938847512,
-0.3449887037,
0.3902443945,
-0.5929425955,
-0.1680172533,
-0.3544529974,
0.8013615012,
-0.238712281,
-0.6635651588,
-0.3363190591,
-0.8601123095,
-0.1868768632,
0.0649178773,
0.0009966339,
0.2746390104,
-0.0580621772,
-0.2054344863,
0.4629923701,
-0.7374770641,
0.6400288343,
0.5785598755,
-0.1117434576,
-0.1051602587,
0.7095799446,
0.0215975791,
0.0713181347,
0.698948741,
0.3593787551,
-0.4239946604,
-0.7684708834,
-0.53417027,
0.2299226373,
-0.5112611055,
0.0293936413,
-0.7951830029,
-0.4341085851,
0.0830937773,
-0.5056576133,
-0.4062553048,
-0.4178699553,
0.2266141921,
0.0642229095,
0.3597762287,
0.6667026281,
-0.1675831527,
0.2472525388,
-0.6146571636,
0.3329018056,
-0.0244846418,
0.2058691382,
0.1957774013,
-0.0931230858,
-0.1664616466,
-0.0159090348,
-0.3200594187,
-0.3990696669,
0.4399852455,
-0.0317901522,
0.7711712122,
0.0860111639,
-0.2714385986,
0.6230099797,
-0.718369782,
0.5800315142,
0.0705262721,
-0.5355889797,
0.7695310116,
-0.6281142831,
0.6112375855,
0.2857210338,
0.3786123991,
-0.2898835838,
-0.4138948023,
-0.455054611,
-1.4267537594,
0.2797183692,
0.2175912559,
-0.1331167221,
0.2908353508,
0.3341773152,
-0.0554417707,
-0.0725954324,
-0.6717960835,
-0.2371126711,
0.4657351077,
0.1608921736,
-0.2671545744,
-0.4400779903,
-0.0142377289,
-0.5410053134,
0.6522083879,
0.110831216,
0.2328574806,
0.0657942444,
0.1109352559,
-0.4346401691,
0.149731189,
0.4902064204,
0.7540451884,
-0.3010631502,
0.0901116356,
0.2464955598,
-0.268891871,
0.4098663926,
-0.0313732065,
-0.5860530734,
-0.1654458642,
0.4237413108,
0.2845847309,
0.0321340263,
-0.8578544855,
0.1589970291,
0.2608050108,
-0.0385074131,
-0.398001194,
0.3057937324,
0.0954184756,
0.3765476048,
0.413382262,
0.0898132771,
0.2466154546,
-0.4847400486,
0.0984697863,
0.5965314507,
-0.0528487973,
0.0398362279,
0.5595597029,
0.1648264974,
-0.4894970655,
0.4646314979,
-0.4097193778,
-0.6099441051,
0.6006616354,
0.3364666104,
0.8614099026,
-0.2317380458,
-0.1493216902,
0.7840173244,
0.5986306667,
-0.2934136391,
0.3860218227,
0.0247260723,
-0.6571335196,
-0.5984035134,
-0.7704540491,
-0.5286152363,
-0.0529674701,
0.0869459435,
0.0939802602,
-0.6419078112,
0.2106449902,
-0.4619593322,
0.0896605849,
-0.4815296531,
0.2298420072,
-0.0516855828,
1.0314457417,
-0.4781945646,
0.5530008078,
0.9502587914,
0.0599073023,
-0.7017579675,
0.3425623775,
0.1364148855,
-0.7981173992,
0.4307080805,
0.2163918912,
-0.5415349603,
-0.143056035,
-0.2027547359,
-1.361276865,
1.3234786987,
0.212663874,
-0.8042132854,
-0.1699514091,
-0.1234858185,
0.2724732459,
-0.3040087819,
-0.1754345149,
0.3183141649,
0.6709203124,
0.513658464,
-1.0502419472,
0.3413974941,
0.0180717949,
0.0436402522,
0.4226286113,
-0.7251781821,
0.654689908,
-0.5299555063,
-0.1736669391,
0.4183707237,
0.1705747098,
0.6025455594,
0.4063084722,
0.6566337347,
0.6061326265,
0.7055510283,
0.0302069914,
0.9703701735,
-0.3797234595,
-0.0741184875,
0.9431211352,
-0.3796118796,
0.8248273134,
0.3263004422,
-0.049659878,
0.5683060884,
0.5264183879,
0.3221176267,
0.7099971175,
0.3880503774,
-0.5343755484,
-0.4397810698,
0.0448052697,
-0.0749019384,
0.5853304267,
0.4657123983,
0.1282718033,
-0.4367161691,
-0.144060716,
0.0003358653,
0.1843168437,
-0.591375649,
0.4157907367,
0.0513897128,
-0.6745999455,
0.2676360011,
0.1891316772,
0.8040805459,
-0.6805491447,
-0.1301153898,
0.0554663353,
0.1469582766,
-0.1237231866,
-0.5987787247,
0.3790605962,
-0.2078583539,
0.1992294639,
-0.4159556627,
0.7262690663,
-0.1510121673,
-0.5992441773,
0.6548262835,
0.6788417697,
-0.2108682096,
-0.0688754916,
-0.6205745339,
0.0493452363,
-0.2692530155,
-0.095074594,
0.0154871475,
0.4771982431,
-0.1973526776,
1.2389909029,
0.806625843,
0.1269558966,
-0.025587393,
-0.173794359,
0.8394370079,
-0.9315175414,
-0.6296197176,
-0.9972900748,
0.4143566787,
0.3023940027,
-0.0413720831,
0.8372612,
0.7505862117,
0.5521122813,
0.362177521,
0.5871161819,
0.2163923681,
0.2576532662,
-0.9473118782,
0.2656289339,
-0.7306953073,
0.7409039736,
-0.185000971,
-1.0309422016,
-0.3675273061,
0.859187305,
-0.3639028668,
0.1295044571,
0.632627666,
0.7709113359,
-0.2052930593,
-0.3453114331,
0.1577375382,
-0.0032000404,
0.3054732084,
0.9802266359,
0.9343521595,
0.0021928633,
0.2938337624,
0.0000972797,
-0.141989097,
-0.1176200584,
-0.9852935076,
-0.5861296654,
-0.3953403533,
-0.1486909837,
-0.2465600073,
0.2054236978,
0.8408577442,
0.8945439458,
-0.1853724867,
-0.4797038138,
-0.4741613865,
0.2527848482,
0.0039569787,
-0.1653676927,
0.149194777,
0.0892236978,
-0.2373550236,
0.8956926465,
0.7464877367,
0.0333742872,
-0.8486398458,
-0.3096832037,
-0.4730705619,
0.2180847377,
0.5983384848,
0.2310562283,
-0.6782081723,
-0.1478803009,
0.1020613015,
0.1779097468,
0.1325898468,
0.8410639167,
-0.6926860213,
0.3527665734,
0.1905969679,
0.2525212765,
0.6974651217,
-0.3571441472,
0.7335751653,
-0.5501621366,
0.4671778679,
0.30668208,
0.5342656374,
0.5012928843,
-0.5864495039,
0.6591844559,
0.064808771,
-0.4336633384,
-0.3515469432,
0.6200002432,
-1.2481205463,
-0.3599197567,
1.6745345592,
-0.0450222753,
-0.0730341226,
0.1837355196,
-0.3804099262,
-0.0001673161,
-0.4683305025,
0.718311131,
0.4212587476,
-0.3052896857,
-0.1131288633,
-0.6349353194,
0.1909564584,
0.0128757861,
-0.7809110284,
-0.1435555071,
0.5781925917,
0.0752843767,
0.1894635707,
0.9227463603,
0.2425781339,
0.2275249064,
-0.1371819377,
-0.1653735489,
-0.0470021889,
-0.6980448961,
0.0322412625,
0.2183427662,
0.0892584622,
0.1241884381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13905v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13905v1 | Persuasiveness of Generated Free-Text Rationales in Subjective Decisions: A Case Study on Pairwise Argument Ranking | 2024-06-20T00:28:33 | 2024-06-20T00:28:33 | Mohamed Elaraby, Diane Litman, Xiang Lorraine Li, Ahmed Magooda | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generating free-text rationales is among the emergent capabilities of Large
Language Models (LLMs). These rationales have been found to enhance LLM
performance across various NLP tasks. Recently, there has been growing interest
in using these rationales to provide insights for various important downstream
tasks. In this paper, we analyze generated free-text rationales in tasks with
subjective answers, emphasizing the importance of rationalization in such
scenarios. We focus on pairwise argument ranking, a highly subjective task with
significant potential for real-world applications, such as debate assistance.
We evaluate the persuasiveness of rationales generated by nine LLMs to support
their subjective choices. Our findings suggest that open-source LLMs,
particularly Llama2-70B-chat, are capable of providing highly persuasive
rationalizations, surpassing even GPT models. Additionally, our experiments
show that rationale persuasiveness can be improved by controlling its
parameters through prompting or through self-refinement. | [
-0.3166142702,
-0.6778078675,
0.8525753021,
0.3065740764,
-0.3880579472,
-0.3501403928,
-0.4234173894,
-0.0176623408,
0.1154329404,
0.5679639578,
-0.1919144392,
-0.4660595357,
-0.3373623192,
0.1459516287,
-0.2148088217,
1.1412236691,
-0.028854467,
0.0181069784,
-0.5226852894,
-0.2783181369,
-0.4884139299,
-0.9082195163,
-0.6159992814,
-0.3900143802,
0.9379896522,
0.6788570285,
0.5246605277,
0.2311012149,
0.2892414629,
0.2846634686,
0.0907970071,
0.1039897278,
-0.3386499286,
0.6891577244,
-0.3717859685,
-0.5359455943,
-0.2046571821,
0.2546829879,
0.2586733997,
0.4761831462,
-0.0940850452,
0.0903006569,
0.0582640767,
0.7594518065,
-0.3995466232,
-0.1848359853,
-0.8951126337,
-0.0715025067,
-0.2432433367,
-0.2841325402,
-0.3602559566,
-0.3717699945,
0.4491740167,
-0.4857046902,
0.0502094105,
0.0250666253,
0.6859776974,
0.3178288341,
-0.2037895173,
-0.4004844725,
-0.5762284398,
0.820655942,
-0.9425184131,
0.0986001194,
0.2512116432,
0.0502444319,
-0.1173732728,
-0.4491327703,
-0.4326089919,
-0.2819227278,
-0.0049367179,
0.152432695,
-0.3310566247,
0.2439489514,
0.2643779516,
0.1883942187,
-0.2826268673,
0.3143593073,
0.1379538476,
-0.0491536669,
0.6126402617,
-0.0580152161,
0.1149525344,
-0.3750307262,
-0.2914575934,
0.0908786431,
-0.542789042,
0.1929505169,
0.5629589558,
-0.0183514394,
0.0383237004,
0.8140310049,
-0.4147740304,
0.4087199867,
0.3146598935,
-0.0929169506,
-0.1816673428,
-0.2980747521,
-0.3285669684,
0.1408492327,
0.9041861296,
0.4404102564,
0.2274256498,
-0.2806318998,
-0.1250358969,
0.0837850124,
0.2234993577,
-0.7818157673,
-0.1939009577,
0.5982164741,
-0.496652782,
-0.4747143984,
-0.2086120993,
-0.6047287583,
-0.4257773757,
-0.3862272799,
0.1268129051,
-0.128954187,
-0.3422877491,
0.1156651676,
-0.1811471581,
0.1900678873,
0.5012249351,
-0.8398604393,
-0.2242944837,
0.8280849457,
0.7622423172,
-0.2897119224,
0.1932432801,
-0.4373112321,
0.1249712408,
-0.5296159387,
1.3836066723,
-0.4805616438,
-0.4091458619,
-0.0716142356,
-0.368501544,
0.1963589936,
-0.5767812729,
0.9274687171,
-0.3505703509,
0.4330004752,
-0.580303669,
-0.5285267234,
-0.0724365562,
0.3726500273,
-0.3196286261,
0.7316002846,
-0.5302924514,
-0.9618656039,
0.3994580507,
-0.7362981439,
-0.1984710097,
0.242319122,
-0.3299354911,
-0.1249885485,
0.1792844683,
0.135603562,
0.4697218835,
-0.4500286579,
0.6141633391,
-0.4644365311,
0.0906387195,
0.5355128646,
-0.6355759501,
0.5376130939,
0.1220219508,
-0.4276829958,
0.5349342823,
-0.322447449,
-0.0363182165,
0.1159087121,
-0.2898384333,
-0.6386734843,
0.3045247495,
-0.5146431923,
0.1446023434,
0.1667730063,
-0.3622303605,
0.051320143,
-0.5898023248,
0.2535392344,
0.9302200079,
0.1039314121,
0.5133876801,
-0.3674488962,
0.3363786638,
-0.0430233926,
-0.0498590134,
0.1162403524,
-0.8751362562,
-0.8726032972,
-0.0786279961,
0.2456831485,
0.5977434516,
-0.6186817288,
0.0607522912,
0.0661156625,
-0.4381091595,
-0.3781760633,
0.1032376438,
0.2679795027,
0.6283969879,
0.1301650107,
0.2582125068,
-0.5355295539,
-1.2183643579,
-0.3858735561,
-0.2965974212,
-0.1274452806,
0.4329717755,
0.074005343,
0.0441588536,
1.040135622,
-0.3279692829,
0.131736666,
-0.1185384691,
0.2513122559,
0.0884986445,
0.3230140209,
0.4035502672,
-0.5506875515,
-0.1976809353,
-0.2757400572,
-0.9652944803,
-0.5680602789,
-0.2328313142,
-0.5711545944,
0.4671980441,
0.1892375946,
-0.4788107872,
0.1881742328,
0.4407988787,
-0.3083286583,
0.7084136009,
-0.0770724565,
0.0589829572,
-1.026584506,
-0.0704704374,
0.2574267089,
0.04463806,
-0.528839767,
-0.0407550074,
-0.4692310393,
0.1339990199,
-0.3428484797,
0.5453772545,
-0.1276497096,
0.2418712825,
-0.336070329,
0.5227401257,
-0.2540714741,
0.2669870257,
0.2554282546,
0.7983526587,
0.1827866137,
-0.4870406389,
0.210033983,
0.1205793992,
-0.2054895461,
0.6078324914,
-0.8257377148,
0.2359348834,
-0.0153700821,
0.2800062895,
-1.064262867,
-0.2403344065,
0.2447827309,
-0.1925496608,
-0.2679927051,
-0.3325664103,
-0.1889676154,
-0.0051827184,
-0.394209832,
0.2593106031,
0.2969500721,
-0.5652266741,
0.1692876667,
0.5270349979,
-0.3591600955,
-0.3960504532,
-0.4085511863,
0.2927294672,
-0.4106622338,
-0.7600736618,
0.1726820171,
-0.2817057073,
-0.8153852224,
-0.2276674062,
-0.1970023215,
0.3545588553,
0.0844585747,
0.440979898,
0.260895133,
-0.2312205136,
0.11315611,
0.4041726589,
-0.3913372457,
0.2664977908,
-0.3104274869,
0.3566042781,
-0.1369603127,
-0.1925716251,
-0.319668591,
0.584795177,
0.2432171106,
0.0580649041,
0.4856463969,
0.1424313784,
-0.1505316049,
-0.1624262333,
-0.9798957705,
-0.1267540753,
-0.468095094,
-0.1869822592,
-0.0997852981,
-1.1023389101,
0.1459060013,
-0.0204502847,
0.2951645553,
0.4355866611,
0.8467043638,
-0.0602446459,
1.1186022758,
-0.1150850728,
0.3069708347,
0.3953013122,
0.0308627132,
0.1791738719,
-0.5000815392,
-0.2834412754,
-0.614523828,
-0.217734471,
-0.5651867986,
-0.4130744636,
0.322797209,
0.1226730645,
-0.062252637,
-0.2646520734,
-0.6715836525,
0.6734121442,
0.6451758146,
-0.0944987088,
0.382602632,
0.1539318413,
-0.3219679594,
-0.1878506243,
-0.5381548405,
-1.0354659557,
1.0633484125,
0.2088339478,
0.2900034785,
0.1002558842,
0.7849035263,
0.1762894243,
0.5219062567,
-0.9712452292,
0.8205013275,
-0.1160436794,
-0.4416374564,
-0.1031610742,
-0.438403517,
-0.834540844,
0.3675673902,
-0.4185360968,
-0.5114051104,
0.0155275576,
0.2569998801,
-0.2778126001,
0.1952141076,
-0.6883519292,
0.6346282363,
-0.3096686304,
-0.5652249455,
-0.576215744,
-0.24867405,
0.488499403,
0.1465345174,
0.0398724228,
-0.3588776886,
-0.1397193521,
1.0493224859,
-0.3746701479,
0.6019589901,
-0.2825708687,
-0.5243042111,
0.2525456548,
0.1021003574,
0.2690642774,
0.4671556652,
-0.36986202,
0.2661034167,
-0.2292934209,
-0.2833101451,
-0.4588814676,
1.1044280529,
-0.6169810295,
-1.2988352776,
-0.2591148019,
-0.3876609206,
-0.4256723821,
0.0733973235,
0.1194619536,
0.3580623269,
-0.0109610409,
0.4126935601,
0.7356050014,
-0.294890821,
0.4375471473,
0.2410856187,
-0.0800071657,
-0.6773588657,
0.8345253468,
0.1417428851,
0.1598587632,
0.1616637558,
0.686345458,
-0.3998215199,
-0.7362928391,
-0.4943252504,
0.2751367688,
-0.6549880505,
-0.2325781137,
-0.6621927619,
0.2057182044,
-0.2171387672,
-0.3951741159,
-0.0211994983,
-0.8430492878,
-0.2828172743,
-0.2459354997,
0.287132442,
0.6779029965,
-0.0202529822,
-0.1186250299,
-0.6508846283,
0.2701515555,
0.5916160941,
0.3606385589,
0.0419155136,
-0.1815066338,
0.0937976837,
0.1648760587,
-0.4347497821,
-0.9468484521,
0.0421040207,
-0.4821700752,
0.5874063373,
0.3905915916,
0.2945596576,
0.4036255479,
-0.0876269639,
1.1018074751,
0.168877095,
-0.7818035483,
0.5394439101,
-0.6546068788,
0.1540398002,
0.427480191,
0.37757954,
-0.3325081766,
-0.3990294635,
-0.5387847424,
-0.8205171824,
0.6308682561,
0.2046589702,
0.0407877043,
-0.0215491578,
0.398728013,
0.2019694746,
0.2475475669,
-0.5992146134,
-0.1325174272,
-0.3856054246,
-0.0285214391,
0.2317250818,
-0.5336745977,
-0.2903065085,
-0.1644435078,
0.7965458035,
-0.1145788804,
0.0518467687,
0.4279785752,
0.2003970295,
-0.0149098635,
0.5140677691,
0.7190665603,
0.1108759865,
0.0146237891,
0.0092959888,
0.1610765159,
0.2159824371,
0.1260959804,
-0.0383266397,
-0.3289560378,
-0.1397360116,
-0.0114552127,
0.7971943021,
0.1400150359,
-0.5878902674,
0.3499048054,
-0.1011811122,
-0.6166027784,
-0.089360334,
0.0739331692,
0.3669076562,
0.3593473732,
0.1919627041,
-0.012394812,
0.0793097019,
-0.2021213025,
-0.3255964816,
0.8063657284,
0.1459701806,
-0.220650211,
0.7019876242,
0.5602021813,
-0.3533180654,
0.2248071134,
-0.0644895285,
-0.3157179356,
0.1845382303,
0.4842447639,
0.9563471079,
0.1685002148,
0.3496950269,
0.3154011369,
-0.0965161398,
-0.0744310543,
-0.0078717163,
-0.3288267851,
-0.7386728525,
-0.3311343193,
-0.4084110856,
-0.8243553042,
0.1883104742,
-0.0798567161,
0.1400529593,
-0.570192337,
-0.2495704591,
-0.0061403392,
-0.0986564234,
-0.153481856,
-0.0810591131,
0.3495348692,
0.5844696164,
-0.3248308301,
0.5513666272,
0.6946117878,
-0.4511751831,
-0.7938313484,
0.2290207893,
-0.0934791043,
-0.4609627128,
0.4899488986,
0.1006092504,
-0.362467885,
-0.2871104181,
-0.7529169321,
-0.637745142,
0.7768465877,
0.6097909212,
-0.3747272193,
-0.1832162291,
0.0655727834,
0.457044512,
-0.2174342275,
0.2315775156,
0.0874809995,
0.6725304723,
0.1057777479,
-0.6039136648,
0.2573343515,
-0.173924163,
0.0356113575,
0.0137850419,
-0.6575086713,
0.3341883719,
-0.2879018784,
-0.1597182304,
-0.0004172574,
0.7203868032,
0.3985043168,
0.4468862116,
0.7114046812,
0.335344404,
0.6239716411,
-0.0465396307,
0.9468640089,
-0.243588388,
-0.1101064384,
0.7500693798,
-0.3564383388,
0.9410579801,
0.4706497192,
0.1454717815,
0.7358316183,
0.3109018207,
0.3630667031,
0.0964804664,
0.0851889402,
-0.4289532006,
-0.7299306989,
-0.2594413459,
-0.2491559088,
0.2694778144,
0.2811053097,
-0.1230704039,
-0.1204253435,
-0.2260836512,
0.2792633176,
0.2146617323,
-0.0014512782,
0.910340786,
0.0562264808,
-1.2477021217,
0.5325180292,
0.0519733317,
0.8836906552,
-0.5337131023,
0.0877434462,
-0.2263126224,
0.048823148,
-0.4549335539,
-0.8188616633,
0.2464029342,
0.4189363122,
-0.2075572312,
-0.6275775433,
0.7910146117,
-0.2543444335,
-0.0562085509,
0.1526660472,
0.5391642451,
-0.0066071791,
-0.0873791724,
-0.654037416,
-0.2191951871,
0.1162995398,
-0.5329412222,
0.5245773792,
0.4417628944,
-0.1205613688,
0.5139543414,
1.1833457947,
-0.0458183922,
-0.3194572031,
0.1020692736,
0.8895223737,
-0.4216645062,
-0.1248113066,
-0.9516088367,
0.3912878036,
-0.2157878727,
-0.211603418,
0.9972811937,
0.5421909094,
0.5398927927,
0.1155994907,
0.8001566529,
0.2629953325,
0.3864091337,
-0.4967330694,
0.5405836105,
-0.4914659262,
0.3723126054,
-0.3153783083,
-0.4937724769,
-0.2537612617,
0.5091589093,
-0.6239568591,
-0.2383226454,
0.5003128648,
0.8259299397,
0.360221386,
0.3998488188,
0.112190783,
0.0605366528,
0.5083657503,
0.2004461586,
0.9703059793,
0.3056930602,
0.5744627118,
-0.2393521518,
-0.4077318311,
-0.0412823223,
-1.1937474012,
-0.9170433879,
-0.403935194,
-0.338447392,
-0.5250810981,
-0.0465797894,
1.3201960325,
0.3388721347,
-0.6659058928,
-0.3571026027,
-0.1761454046,
0.3535833657,
0.1466903538,
-0.2457678318,
-0.0081926621,
-0.5723403692,
-0.4586160481,
0.4784524441,
0.291760087,
-0.1965626627,
-0.2214478999,
-0.0937461555,
-0.2136428654,
0.5520969033,
0.8031175733,
0.1515199393,
-0.9813144803,
-0.2034673542,
-0.0191354062,
0.0825074539,
0.0407908522,
1.1917462349,
-0.9077458978,
0.097703658,
0.6686993837,
0.359919548,
-0.0697955266,
0.1811582744,
0.7018862367,
-0.3763507307,
-0.0766662955,
0.1775862277,
0.4205468893,
0.3224986792,
-0.0787571147,
0.4103176594,
0.4370603561,
-0.7862427831,
-0.8461903334,
0.0685018748,
-1.0662420988,
-0.2989922166,
1.7028466463,
0.0399466716,
0.1525804251,
-0.1103140935,
-0.7603901029,
0.0635620803,
-0.7777726054,
0.6570592523,
0.7892161608,
-0.261174053,
0.1258958578,
-0.111922659,
0.5558439493,
0.6885043383,
-0.9833139181,
0.3700277507,
0.6798593402,
0.2151940614,
0.1257232875,
0.7861432433,
0.0096185058,
-0.0056146379,
-0.2114574313,
-0.3596032262,
-0.0877493247,
-0.0319861732,
-0.1517062932,
0.5098279119,
0.4074621499,
0.1710300893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13903v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13903v1 | Generative AI for Enhancing Active Learning in Education: A Comparative Study of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 in Crafting Customized Test Questions | 2024-06-20T00:25:43 | 2024-06-20T00:25:43 | Hamdireza Rouzegar, Masoud Makrehchi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | This study investigates how LLMs, specifically GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, can develop
tailored questions for Grade 9 math, aligning with active learning principles.
By utilizing an iterative method, these models adjust questions based on
difficulty and content, responding to feedback from a simulated 'student'
model. A novel aspect of the research involved using GPT-4 as a 'teacher' to
create complex questions, with GPT-3.5 as the 'student' responding to these
challenges. This setup mirrors active learning, promoting deeper engagement.
The findings demonstrate GPT-4's superior ability to generate precise,
challenging questions and notable improvements in GPT-3.5's ability to handle
more complex problems after receiving instruction from GPT-4. These results
underscore the potential of LLMs to mimic and enhance active learning
scenarios, offering a promising path for AI in customized education. This
research contributes to understanding how AI can support personalized learning
experiences, highlighting the need for further exploration in various
educational contexts | [
-0.2151311189,
-1.4744074345,
0.5780209899,
-0.0777482539,
0.2724237144,
0.6107691526,
-0.0089855259,
-0.3086670935,
0.0977412462,
0.0671772063,
-0.4968392849,
-0.4041828215,
-0.1850079447,
0.1668873578,
-0.3526050448,
0.851356566,
-0.3955406547,
0.1852587312,
-0.3538188636,
0.0779759362,
-0.5292646885,
-0.5423497558,
-1.0263682604,
-0.1831752956,
0.4187455177,
0.3876564205,
0.4673139453,
0.0398967639,
0.8534709215,
0.3110941052,
-0.0567706525,
0.12524198,
-0.1690761,
0.2698465586,
0.0357715674,
-0.5625877976,
-0.702953577,
0.3125327229,
0.7028009295,
0.7783299685,
-0.1847814918,
0.1102396473,
0.1280041933,
0.4073373973,
-0.295525074,
0.1182758659,
-0.2643472552,
0.50654006,
0.0249241404,
0.0516304635,
0.0562522486,
-0.5811938643,
0.2254496813,
-0.8568535447,
0.541534245,
-0.3704705834,
0.6907386184,
0.4659105837,
-0.2249339223,
-0.4100823998,
-0.7573872805,
0.4668629467,
-0.3706240654,
0.2918026447,
0.423941642,
0.4081067443,
0.1089470387,
-1.0492954254,
-0.414508611,
-0.256241411,
0.2536679506,
0.6275236011,
0.0227647629,
0.1576774865,
0.3804020286,
0.8255481124,
-0.6557392478,
0.0551060215,
-0.4744319916,
-0.1441406459,
0.3999851644,
0.3781338036,
0.3495391905,
0.2392815351,
-0.1584786922,
0.0687686801,
-0.8217381835,
0.1966000497,
0.6312301755,
0.0978598446,
0.0771586746,
0.6937208176,
-0.0111699319,
0.7076915503,
0.1578022689,
0.1294168234,
0.2243158817,
-0.378254205,
-0.0491750985,
-0.170512408,
0.4281617403,
-0.0232748259,
0.1675568521,
-0.0152532263,
-0.3493922949,
0.122050643,
0.3391469419,
-0.6566436887,
-0.5564708114,
0.0749614239,
-0.0467464626,
-0.3734927177,
0.09084066,
-0.3884478211,
-0.0713740289,
-0.4099821746,
0.6859286427,
-0.2826502323,
-0.0996988788,
0.0699134469,
0.0042313724,
0.2990565896,
0.6389655471,
-0.9141161442,
0.3336630762,
0.4081115723,
0.6720417738,
-0.6939398646,
-0.2006683052,
-0.2711910009,
0.133949995,
-0.2046670616,
0.7235787511,
-0.7718262076,
-0.5736427307,
-0.0044934321,
-0.2927674949,
-0.065715149,
-0.8156430721,
0.3165793419,
-0.6280608773,
0.6129345894,
-0.0525837764,
-0.6282469034,
-0.2303310186,
1.069283247,
-0.6817712188,
1.1088596582,
0.435719043,
-0.2344241291,
0.0496642329,
-0.9428300261,
-0.2968344092,
0.3413541019,
-0.5189508796,
-0.6683060527,
-0.1827918142,
0.2408892512,
0.1788860559,
-0.0388635099,
0.0444798507,
-0.1645213962,
-0.604337275,
0.0627807975,
-0.4356222451,
0.5707430243,
0.0186356753,
-0.6510782838,
0.4333508313,
-0.4723625481,
0.2395816743,
0.3697158694,
-0.6784610152,
0.0623017438,
-0.1192503944,
-0.4236884713,
-0.1821868271,
0.4467285573,
-0.2728359699,
0.550216496,
-0.2095443904,
0.2123036981,
1.0153368711,
0.1812497973,
0.477376163,
-0.3524899185,
1.0248589516,
-0.1328760982,
0.3366963565,
-0.0814348608,
-0.7759996057,
-0.8225366473,
0.12818636,
0.2963665128,
0.6187197566,
-0.6398636699,
0.0706373826,
0.217675671,
-0.1536942571,
-0.5397488475,
0.3022520542,
0.1757593602,
0.5257658362,
0.5023216605,
-0.3465443254,
-0.3088989854,
-0.4575929046,
-0.1107573509,
-0.1854793131,
-0.0850963742,
0.4229280353,
0.4614329934,
-0.024696948,
0.7527940869,
-0.8225331903,
-0.3422431052,
-0.2145216465,
-0.0957810283,
-0.0851680785,
0.4263092875,
0.5042652488,
-0.8424456716,
-0.892274797,
-0.1685484946,
-0.8248161077,
-0.0306508839,
0.0278685689,
0.0183825903,
-0.3694419563,
0.2956907153,
-0.4262534678,
0.3545246422,
0.3288757503,
-0.3712198436,
0.5269348621,
-0.0644034743,
0.1909459084,
-0.8869972825,
-0.2530995011,
-0.2545436919,
0.1081358269,
-0.4696040154,
0.1073412672,
0.0646232069,
-0.3198029995,
-0.2064916641,
0.6693373322,
-0.3659265339,
-0.172528863,
-0.1734781116,
0.023560442,
-0.0970614329,
0.3703404069,
-0.1975733042,
1.0709614754,
0.5543580651,
-0.319744736,
0.5283285975,
0.3765432239,
-0.1874068528,
0.2753965259,
-0.7658908963,
0.2942585647,
0.2652477324,
0.1654118001,
-0.8307937384,
-0.1253353804,
0.4204379022,
-0.5158835649,
0.1206045598,
-0.0180927161,
-0.3751367033,
-0.2788360417,
-0.3707688153,
0.4941578209,
0.7987177372,
-0.4823291302,
0.5259970427,
-0.0289310589,
-0.3844150603,
-0.1919330508,
-0.2754330039,
-0.0402119011,
-0.2462251335,
-0.3639950752,
0.5099146366,
-0.6580713987,
-0.4075163901,
0.0895051062,
-0.0664824024,
0.032893274,
0.450417906,
0.019250825,
0.3467648327,
-0.3898526728,
-0.0981541276,
0.1196270287,
0.0992488191,
0.2097408026,
-0.0155281872,
0.2736205161,
-0.1176218167,
-0.657826364,
-0.2365062833,
0.314331919,
0.100499846,
-0.3546666205,
0.2512339652,
0.6056600213,
-0.2987269163,
-0.2500246167,
-0.2565669417,
-0.549864769,
-0.5162257552,
0.021630602,
-0.4977558255,
-1.1532710791,
0.5386040807,
-0.0554057844,
0.2014854699,
0.2159868181,
0.7224683762,
-0.1693874747,
1.3844927549,
0.4586676359,
0.0984581858,
0.8646237254,
-0.731046319,
0.0315341838,
-0.7792335153,
-0.3540559709,
-0.075862132,
-0.5124565363,
-0.4233277142,
-0.3758813441,
0.3985826671,
-0.0666461438,
-0.4970848262,
-0.4150014818,
-0.6821622849,
0.4760878682,
0.6649751663,
0.0800211206,
0.2065846026,
-0.0144313397,
-0.1885962486,
0.0908804536,
-0.5018456578,
-0.4664733112,
1.0165467262,
0.0178427976,
0.6759642959,
0.5554643869,
0.6534317136,
0.136871025,
0.6576642394,
-0.8435878158,
0.5939230323,
0.3299253583,
-1.0005801916,
-0.2830419242,
-0.3336408436,
-1.069491148,
0.1280169487,
-0.0550458133,
-0.1916901022,
-0.424569726,
0.1083534583,
-0.5189831853,
0.3918432593,
-0.7472592592,
0.5936006308,
-0.3551490009,
-0.5660988092,
0.1356318891,
-0.4493708313,
0.1257599741,
-0.2279015779,
-0.3321873844,
-0.0067330194,
-0.2378807664,
0.7122516036,
-0.0667024329,
1.0204828978,
-0.2214846164,
-0.117156446,
0.6483619809,
0.0665902495,
0.2799123824,
0.1407113969,
-0.0933832079,
-0.385668993,
-0.5634766817,
-0.5605846643,
-0.7175494432,
0.8291473389,
-1.0643358231,
-1.1763491631,
-0.5869085789,
-0.5165051222,
-0.3767584264,
0.1251561791,
-0.0839447528,
0.1371179074,
-0.1183306873,
-0.062920399,
0.9030621052,
-0.0065675676,
0.4993738532,
0.464153856,
0.1705894321,
-0.4141674042,
0.8133102655,
0.2249916345,
0.1132314876,
0.3074160516,
0.3633106947,
-0.2719092667,
-0.7780304551,
-0.4880921841,
-0.0299169589,
-0.6896282434,
-0.2992552519,
-0.3309226334,
-0.4038668871,
-0.4751273692,
-0.4768551886,
-0.1338986754,
-0.3759628534,
-0.6156392097,
-0.5009948015,
0.1560294032,
0.9728035927,
0.1728387177,
0.2622987628,
-0.4916025996,
0.2035188973,
0.7989539504,
0.2568809986,
-0.1844306141,
-0.6452084184,
0.0843074918,
-0.1190831363,
-0.9482825994,
-0.7323711514,
0.0511577502,
0.3211334348,
0.7339052558,
0.3595072627,
-0.1869109422,
0.6088869572,
-0.4732059538,
1.2155598402,
0.0280997586,
-0.551784873,
0.7152346969,
-0.3629490137,
0.2755844593,
0.2996637821,
0.5587233901,
0.151056096,
-0.2737611234,
-0.8392000198,
-0.7037727237,
0.4223047793,
0.2454092056,
0.4910545945,
0.0977751017,
0.8601873517,
0.2055782527,
0.1248428449,
-0.783752501,
-0.3445966244,
-0.4111310542,
-0.408144176,
-0.1088273227,
-0.0759486184,
-0.2293722183,
-0.4575164616,
0.4713107049,
-0.1879503578,
0.3189359307,
-0.1157049164,
0.0728551,
0.0024156375,
0.0806998089,
0.7575522661,
0.6418735385,
-0.1200358421,
0.0501644947,
0.4773426056,
-0.8714307547,
0.3238156736,
0.0900385827,
-0.2450467348,
-0.3908369541,
0.419197917,
0.5930998325,
-0.0355172455,
-0.4466596246,
0.3684059978,
-0.2229607999,
-0.487796247,
-0.6282416582,
0.4760389626,
-0.1571977735,
0.2216234356,
0.4706365764,
-0.3025842011,
0.0864321366,
-0.5719589591,
0.0793083906,
0.281032443,
-0.3853524923,
-0.7541931272,
1.0006816387,
0.3760465682,
-0.679048717,
0.9282106161,
0.0430113077,
-0.5591725111,
0.8044928312,
0.8743201494,
0.8153682947,
-0.5922003984,
0.2087702304,
0.4629511237,
-0.0280975811,
0.1060947627,
0.6751168966,
-0.2909853458,
-0.7744359374,
-0.1592960954,
-0.1993927211,
-0.8290560842,
0.1744883657,
-0.5168048739,
0.0134764062,
-0.6767473817,
-0.038280867,
-0.2581575513,
0.2564006448,
-0.4715626836,
0.4253937006,
-0.1243567169,
0.3724346459,
-0.6361613274,
0.6314775348,
1.3753846884,
-0.5859878063,
-0.9721211791,
0.0612972006,
-0.2074682862,
-0.8821210861,
0.448674649,
0.0375596024,
0.253243655,
0.4761206806,
-0.4006240368,
-0.6041927338,
1.3800387383,
0.0573913269,
-0.1735574156,
-0.1696825176,
0.1859474778,
0.5274521112,
-0.0924352482,
0.2527025044,
0.1452704966,
0.3615932763,
0.3008410633,
-0.4651033878,
-0.2863354087,
-0.4053552747,
-0.4316385984,
0.2554666102,
-0.6665676832,
0.876645267,
-0.4360563755,
0.2359835207,
0.0827955157,
0.7406461239,
0.5172194242,
0.5769199729,
0.3403759301,
0.5043557882,
0.6747316122,
-0.2480347753,
0.8842331171,
-0.0666178018,
0.2370057553,
0.8169760108,
-0.1161223575,
0.5153924227,
0.4399589896,
-0.395642072,
0.3291315734,
1.0901279449,
-0.1605258584,
0.474470973,
0.2909701765,
-0.7973620892,
-0.1303177774,
0.3593460023,
-0.5258436799,
0.247890681,
0.3510965407,
-0.0632981509,
0.0439792201,
0.1153041795,
-0.2157952636,
0.0668850467,
-0.4729743302,
0.7314629555,
0.0385706648,
-0.7077521682,
0.1033768058,
-0.1187633649,
0.4098105133,
-0.4750826359,
-0.2492667586,
-0.5892400146,
0.2440133691,
-0.1714680493,
-0.8519723415,
-0.0444820113,
0.0387859605,
-0.0003271353,
-0.4176448584,
0.4523158371,
-0.3733791113,
-0.491483897,
-0.2739036679,
0.764944315,
0.0510544255,
0.1832381785,
-0.9633195996,
-0.0154103637,
0.0882132128,
-0.4783635139,
0.3381122053,
0.2448790371,
-0.1491122991,
0.6414139271,
0.6901507378,
0.0106678959,
0.2303325385,
0.2716149092,
0.8310191631,
-0.6464241147,
-0.2555034459,
-0.5601986647,
0.4073463678,
0.148234278,
-0.3789823651,
0.9115664363,
0.7021098733,
0.9333202243,
-0.0864858404,
0.8926166892,
0.107051,
0.3155970871,
-0.3441670835,
0.2431866378,
-0.56750983,
0.4780475497,
-0.1111291945,
-1.1655756235,
-0.3946183324,
0.7299257517,
-0.3714609146,
0.4753721952,
0.639738977,
0.3765141964,
-0.0985291973,
-0.0667461827,
0.376518786,
-0.2265752852,
0.7956457734,
0.3014978766,
1.1959116459,
-0.2725777626,
0.4790560305,
-0.2820597887,
-0.1412391514,
-0.0213464964,
-0.1687130481,
-1.011572957,
-0.5453612208,
-0.5199888945,
-0.0720399022,
0.0691963732,
0.425108552,
0.0595736727,
-0.5514079332,
-0.0406911485,
-0.2486174852,
0.1401071697,
-0.0729082823,
-0.2307709605,
0.5547657609,
-0.4003354907,
-1.0330877304,
0.5238484144,
-0.1238623038,
0.7220903039,
-0.4529785514,
-0.0295836385,
0.1853653044,
-0.0170293506,
0.6614007354,
0.1073390469,
-0.5414019227,
-0.3205885589,
0.3525577784,
0.018623488,
0.1041122377,
0.9246669412,
-0.8138974309,
0.2646496296,
0.400380075,
0.7000936866,
0.4879304171,
0.160708487,
0.3041695654,
-0.4193953574,
-0.0729262531,
0.7986044884,
0.0078112353,
0.3213302195,
-0.4689633846,
0.7541158795,
0.3820833564,
-0.4940406084,
-0.7314323783,
0.1316178739,
-0.941872716,
-0.0787734985,
1.0990196466,
-0.3159920573,
0.289783895,
-0.0680587813,
-0.2671440244,
-0.0406346507,
-0.0052326629,
0.9856703281,
0.6714429855,
-0.655105412,
-0.1370739788,
-0.8197135925,
0.5087797046,
0.6429260373,
-0.9326223135,
-0.7015580535,
0.2230576575,
0.3624720275,
-0.1814845651,
0.6018352509,
-0.1113024056,
0.3518932462,
-0.1629840285,
-0.0849041566,
-0.2415803075,
-0.163567543,
-0.0805336758,
0.4582275748,
0.2998147607,
-0.3008780181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13898v1 | The Use of Multimodal Large Language Models to Detect Objects from Thermal Images: Transportation Applications | 2024-06-20T00:05:10 | 2024-06-20T00:05:10 | Huthaifa I. Ashqar, Taqwa I. Alhadidi, Mohammed Elhenawy, Nour O. Khanfar | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.CY | The integration of thermal imaging data with Multimodal Large Language Models
(MLLMs) constitutes an exciting opportunity for improving the safety and
functionality of autonomous driving systems and many Intelligent Transportation
Systems (ITS) applications. This study investigates whether MLLMs can
understand complex images from RGB and thermal cameras and detect objects
directly. Our goals were to 1) assess the ability of the MLLM to learn from
information from various sets, 2) detect objects and identify elements in
thermal cameras, 3) determine whether two independent modality images show the
same scene, and 4) learn all objects using different modalities. The findings
showed that both GPT-4 and Gemini were effective in detecting and classifying
objects in thermal images. Similarly, the Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE)
for pedestrian classification was 70.39% and 81.48%, respectively. Moreover,
the MAPE for bike, car, and motorcycle detection were 78.4%, 55.81%, and
96.15%, respectively. Gemini produced MAPE of 66.53%, 59.35% and 78.18%
respectively. This finding further demonstrates that MLLM can identify thermal
images and can be employed in advanced imaging automation technologies for ITS
applications. | [
-0.6210644841,
-0.678224504,
0.7821210027,
-0.0272197183,
-0.3372636139,
-0.0276185814,
-0.257854104,
-0.8142885566,
-0.3450570405,
-0.115278475,
-0.3273492455,
-0.4802326262,
-0.4431324005,
0.0345413983,
-0.3283219635,
0.2649145126,
-0.1228161007,
0.0173510499,
-0.0395168252,
-0.106358014,
-0.368730396,
-0.7327749729,
-0.3376103342,
-0.0610870235,
0.8256182671,
-0.2248427272,
0.767942667,
0.3950032592,
0.7091855407,
0.4350329041,
0.415307492,
0.4412174821,
0.0700869411,
0.0056110425,
-0.1435042322,
-0.0152855255,
0.0785628706,
-0.3599362373,
0.6868978143,
0.0333327875,
-0.1506832987,
-0.0337997973,
-0.3580011427,
0.539031148,
-0.8864433765,
0.3896237612,
-0.6724894643,
0.0631946027,
-0.2323201746,
-0.2530927956,
-0.4848831296,
0.1420793682,
-0.3318807483,
-0.4950531125,
0.0866267979,
0.3758445382,
0.8946351409,
0.1174233481,
-0.7407796383,
-0.407635659,
-0.8597998619,
1.0013968945,
-0.6146305799,
0.8221503496,
0.0826150998,
0.5165583491,
0.1034021899,
-0.3548745811,
-0.866589427,
-0.2499821931,
-0.4618528485,
0.1862702221,
-0.1442582607,
-0.1737058312,
0.2440198511,
-0.1251462549,
-0.9388218522,
0.2258267403,
-0.4647256434,
-0.2083755434,
0.5109552741,
0.3452320099,
0.4267255366,
0.0968031585,
-0.4020026922,
-0.0492909178,
-0.1378601342,
-0.062030416,
0.1971337795,
0.3325465322,
-0.0396027789,
0.3638077974,
0.2330227196,
1.0502371788,
-0.5471027493,
-0.4737631977,
0.4905909896,
-0.1818242371,
-0.6120445132,
-0.1576876342,
0.8339036703,
0.2873060405,
0.2212138921,
-0.2387928665,
-0.5467646718,
-0.0735462308,
-0.1191031858,
-0.6143536568,
-0.2465971261,
0.1026583984,
-0.6100656986,
0.0456990562,
0.3215198517,
-0.2630180717,
-0.2245472223,
-0.6582756042,
0.3036135733,
-0.2000621706,
-0.7937124968,
0.4477334619,
-0.1997427493,
0.8558751345,
0.6691638231,
-0.8170896173,
-0.1903135926,
0.6643764973,
0.7188116312,
0.0381153822,
-0.3738600016,
-0.1583590806,
0.2846951485,
-0.1246952638,
1.0657521486,
-0.5964860916,
-0.3850444555,
-0.0981006175,
0.230893597,
-0.4276068211,
-0.4748203456,
0.3537952602,
-0.7324647307,
0.155124858,
-0.1536204368,
-0.0477016941,
-0.4720428884,
0.5489610434,
-0.5044016242,
0.9260903597,
0.0745521486,
-0.6925250888,
0.4218837321,
-0.5310125351,
-0.6422994137,
-0.1394200623,
-0.1648999155,
-0.6336170435,
0.0197133366,
0.0742517561,
0.8470774293,
-0.1678709388,
0.2241800874,
-0.3987563848,
-0.1550505757,
0.4533624649,
-0.5889615417,
0.4846232235,
0.416487813,
-0.0940801501,
0.1450505853,
-0.4504191577,
-0.0948273987,
0.0640219375,
-0.6111134887,
-0.2005563676,
-0.2050343901,
0.6268004179,
0.2896039188,
0.0664516464,
-0.7069517374,
0.0420451127,
0.347155422,
0.0217241067,
0.9416819811,
-0.4037151635,
0.176039502,
0.05919585,
0.3257534504,
0.5057408214,
0.2912929952,
-0.1977641284,
-0.6483741999,
-0.5592425466,
-0.3956338167,
-0.2930551171,
0.7348759174,
-0.9661856294,
0.2644367814,
0.1001782045,
-0.6085752845,
-0.0866946951,
-0.0394950099,
0.2729909122,
0.4944005311,
0.3585241735,
0.2357638925,
-0.4643247426,
-0.8200030923,
-0.0533298403,
-0.0385131873,
-0.0668100715,
0.4750006795,
0.6771531701,
-0.3056357205,
0.646897018,
-0.548540175,
-0.0556176305,
0.1069471017,
-0.067698814,
0.2579111755,
0.6040295362,
0.8889244795,
-1.1136060953,
-0.5468633771,
0.503483057,
-1.301609993,
0.6714500189,
0.0490996242,
-0.0050856387,
0.1241343468,
0.5319613218,
-0.5516136289,
0.2900820673,
0.3110393286,
-0.4170727134,
0.3435920477,
-0.4089083672,
0.2507293224,
-0.6597132087,
-0.0178672764,
0.3833146691,
-0.4194968343,
-0.905813694,
-0.0112162745,
0.3566061556,
-0.0555288456,
-0.7484516501,
0.3389223814,
-0.667571485,
-0.2706173658,
-0.2809766829,
-0.1871792376,
-0.074939698,
0.3740808964,
0.447924912,
0.6288074851,
0.9615748525,
-0.6033409834,
0.7164797187,
-0.3291012049,
-0.7563331723,
0.5503898263,
-0.3181855977,
0.3311545253,
-0.7257322073,
-0.0331127308,
-0.9965405464,
-0.1950168014,
0.3938367665,
-0.1032013744,
0.4756801426,
0.0831160024,
-0.85162431,
-0.4251431525,
0.1650955379,
0.390111953,
0.2481418401,
-0.4226043224,
1.1178480387,
0.2772728503,
0.3530387878,
-0.5398288369,
-0.6199969053,
-0.0088186515,
-0.2635984719,
-0.5331868529,
-0.3447502255,
-0.0229914952,
-0.294359833,
-0.037976183,
0.4328496754,
-0.3243860602,
0.1888958663,
0.1915403008,
0.4711876214,
-0.5118290782,
0.3853742182,
-0.4855870605,
-0.059696395,
-0.0596114919,
-0.21914424,
0.593904078,
-0.4749911726,
-0.567895174,
-0.5874067545,
0.3078941107,
1.0576139688,
-0.2342753708,
0.8926714063,
1.3931791782,
-0.3861913085,
0.505209446,
-0.6866645813,
-0.1977392435,
-0.5240738392,
0.4859576225,
-0.6039281487,
-0.3909875751,
0.4030631781,
0.3187080026,
-0.0236645956,
0.4022720754,
0.6123670936,
-0.3098622859,
1.0243084431,
0.3603955805,
-0.1002771109,
0.4005743563,
-0.1742687672,
0.2598660886,
-0.9296063185,
-0.8877748251,
-0.5199253559,
-0.3934109807,
-0.330912441,
-0.4078761339,
0.4259029925,
-0.6614168286,
-0.4622003734,
0.1265182793,
-0.6177136898,
0.5612269044,
0.4191920459,
0.6622276306,
0.1732672155,
0.0199991651,
0.2091972083,
0.1219049245,
-0.4526230693,
-0.2160740942,
0.8008378744,
0.483638674,
0.9418728352,
0.2454879135,
0.0444104075,
0.2124586254,
0.5358819366,
-0.8477042317,
0.5182840824,
-0.2619100511,
-0.7757087946,
-0.1676106006,
-0.299021244,
-0.8210920691,
0.5048014522,
-0.2708735466,
-0.3075668514,
0.3810093999,
-0.0259070564,
-0.0419066623,
0.6954467297,
-0.8882100582,
0.838176012,
-0.7178789377,
-0.1998960674,
0.0709323809,
-0.5692401528,
0.5494417548,
-0.1886062324,
0.4371742606,
-0.3561085463,
0.0459517799,
0.6339010596,
0.308049798,
0.6484465599,
-0.4920291603,
-0.1002819464,
0.0857880265,
-0.0715789348,
0.2388748229,
-0.2391665429,
-0.1963049322,
0.1121845692,
-0.2588444948,
-0.4281494617,
-0.68473804,
0.541967392,
-0.7930817604,
-0.5141988397,
-0.5103013515,
-0.8074005246,
-0.010043527,
0.1227861792,
-0.0036296526,
0.4633949697,
0.4074177444,
0.2129941136,
0.4685745835,
-0.234617129,
0.6600176692,
0.7054863572,
-0.3596150279,
-0.0032647722,
1.0587692261,
-0.1343876272,
0.0760457516,
0.4619906247,
0.2782649994,
-0.5053463578,
-0.5844936371,
-0.449357897,
0.3010160625,
-0.9866691232,
-0.2652883828,
-0.6443830132,
-0.0632905588,
-0.2873096168,
-0.2597067654,
-0.1455875486,
0.104815051,
-0.561172843,
-0.0314935334,
0.1482297033,
0.7748478055,
0.0189932324,
0.1779661477,
-0.7100532651,
0.1691875309,
0.6079213023,
-0.2101383954,
0.0068678497,
-0.3314210474,
-0.1923929155,
-0.0153254457,
0.0090534091,
-0.3893701732,
0.397041887,
0.0041272347,
0.7414607406,
0.6693776846,
-0.1488550007,
0.7616978884,
-0.0931862444,
0.6838958859,
0.6160726547,
-0.7482913733,
0.327937901,
-0.2926290929,
0.4244927764,
0.0407537445,
0.37806499,
-0.2388246655,
-0.2693244517,
-0.1469254047,
-0.3274817169,
0.4543018341,
0.0653901845,
0.1749985069,
0.2579523027,
0.2351030558,
-0.1223649755,
0.2725258172,
-0.9765837789,
-0.0252281409,
-0.3356350958,
-0.0901629403,
-0.1030580327,
0.0150477337,
0.0607229285,
-0.3285845518,
0.2859208882,
-0.0096878037,
0.5566048026,
0.1669089943,
0.0313171968,
0.1558397859,
0.1736626774,
1.1489542723,
0.6328856945,
-0.4297330081,
0.6590546966,
-0.0292162988,
-0.4897185862,
0.1944890469,
-0.4676716328,
0.2279922515,
0.1857007295,
0.5692776442,
0.6005676985,
-0.2271510214,
-0.5483840704,
0.2936081588,
-0.0921860337,
-0.0731904656,
-0.2239135802,
0.1038772315,
-0.1373466998,
0.4332614541,
0.3839950562,
0.4443648756,
0.0541159734,
-1.016823411,
-0.0395651981,
0.8356946111,
-0.3182358444,
-0.3916684389,
0.5548405647,
0.0931226388,
0.0773669779,
0.8797694445,
-0.211489439,
-0.7715544105,
0.8954002261,
0.5074464083,
0.6485850215,
-0.3800843656,
-0.1892110407,
0.3455524445,
0.5602447987,
-0.0910816714,
0.3060910404,
-0.2235019952,
-1.3735053539,
0.0192725267,
-0.3145569265,
-0.1272253841,
-0.2497531474,
-0.5678525567,
0.1128159836,
-0.4269393981,
-0.2046104223,
0.0018441686,
-0.6542764306,
-0.9868392348,
0.4090702236,
0.4620608389,
0.7017021775,
-1.2140661478,
1.0483131409,
0.6049280167,
-0.0830076858,
-0.8093313575,
-0.3805763423,
-0.0971816406,
-1.2105528116,
1.3264688253,
0.2432081401,
-0.3595627248,
-0.0600199029,
-0.4227615893,
-0.4147696197,
1.1264566183,
0.3130187392,
-0.5322101116,
-0.0752668455,
0.0516605042,
0.2254623771,
-0.3829915226,
0.4492743611,
0.2322814912,
1.027358532,
0.3346147239,
-1.1143805981,
-0.085603185,
-0.0333460346,
-0.0659859627,
0.2785126865,
-0.564850986,
0.9989056587,
-0.2477718741,
-0.2039719969,
-0.1544661671,
0.3402498066,
0.0454129018,
0.599250555,
0.7245077491,
0.5054686666,
0.6369470954,
-0.3085284233,
0.8688584566,
0.1539086103,
0.5702871084,
0.4417893291,
-0.3481829166,
0.7686927915,
0.4541984797,
-0.1167867258,
0.5958202481,
0.5926325321,
-0.2325248122,
0.8595789075,
-0.0501259565,
-0.6175507903,
-0.4768661559,
-0.0255510174,
-0.5054834485,
0.4999310672,
0.6475259066,
-0.3487357199,
-0.1692803204,
0.7799267173,
-0.0355537646,
-0.4150479734,
-0.4800756872,
0.6857295632,
-0.1902031451,
-0.3421861231,
0.4855142534,
-0.0043197484,
0.5014901161,
-0.4362767041,
0.2329457104,
0.2217753083,
0.3645852804,
-0.5164216161,
-1.1724383831,
0.3345105946,
-0.1766469032,
0.0727163926,
-0.2472452223,
0.7441150546,
-0.21846883,
-0.7780318856,
0.048731938,
0.2421171963,
0.2207323164,
-0.2786350548,
-0.5670059323,
0.4939630032,
-0.0303505398,
-0.0795507357,
0.1101444066,
0.3562856615,
0.4662448466,
0.8190001249,
0.7775672674,
-0.2922087014,
0.2100850493,
-0.2875843942,
0.9893778563,
-0.7036869526,
-0.1082577258,
-0.9721224308,
0.6835047007,
0.1265020669,
0.3155791759,
0.8132785559,
0.9414010048,
0.5357860327,
-0.6046100855,
0.7577142715,
0.2084094286,
0.07058651,
-0.9841268063,
0.0763563365,
-0.5900156498,
0.19723019,
-0.1102080718,
-0.759003222,
-0.6137046814,
0.8777202964,
-0.3222199678,
0.0711081699,
0.7085617781,
0.9965447187,
-0.5411040187,
-0.2078351378,
0.6998177767,
-0.0842034146,
0.6114809513,
0.5749658346,
1.1424438953,
-0.5013020039,
0.3993535042,
-0.0829688758,
0.0371641815,
-0.0393411294,
-0.7840594053,
-1.0357534885,
-0.6673865914,
-0.3750937581,
-0.2989751399,
-0.1877939254,
0.434333235,
1.1261694431,
-0.6469258666,
-0.1713964045,
0.1866570115,
0.1343621463,
0.0930269733,
-0.2188570201,
0.3900054395,
0.1141871139,
-0.690128386,
0.2651185095,
0.6619774699,
0.3953553438,
-0.5499648452,
-0.001617173,
-0.0731115714,
-0.290325284,
0.8279653788,
0.335070312,
-0.8489595652,
-0.3095774055,
0.1263206154,
-0.1535470486,
0.102114588,
1.0762757063,
-0.5986415148,
0.5119969249,
0.4011478126,
0.1075615212,
0.4638437927,
-0.1601301432,
0.0306800846,
-0.3787652254,
0.7371317744,
0.0619707406,
0.7470412254,
0.3885563016,
-0.3815341592,
0.1948964447,
0.369864732,
-0.6026430726,
-0.5558811426,
0.257378757,
-1.3501198292,
-0.4108836949,
1.1432942152,
-0.1500793248,
-0.3562374115,
-0.5978802443,
-0.2486272156,
-0.3019020259,
-0.3543318212,
0.4642064869,
0.2709311545,
-0.1697882712,
-0.8107874393,
-0.4585356116,
-0.1779269725,
-0.3529993296,
-0.9958893657,
-0.1793253273,
0.3299287558,
0.1891330928,
0.4027675986,
0.3719559312,
0.2511541545,
0.2249495685,
-0.3909530044,
-0.2742165327,
-0.3174688816,
-0.1641906947,
0.0683294237,
0.3208374679,
-0.0601206534,
-0.5256676674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13893v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13893v1 | Open Generative Large Language Models for Galician | 2024-06-19T23:49:56 | 2024-06-19T23:49:56 | Pablo Gamallo, Pablo Rodríguez, Iria de-Dios-Flores, Susana Sotelo, Silvia Paniagua, Daniel Bardanca, José Ramom Pichel, Marcos Garcia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have transformed natural language processing.
Yet, their predominantly English-centric training has led to biases and
performance disparities across languages. This imbalance marginalizes
minoritized languages, making equitable access to NLP technologies more
difficult for languages with lower resources, such as Galician. We present the
first two generative LLMs focused on Galician to bridge this gap. These models,
freely available as open-source resources, were trained using a GPT
architecture with 1.3B parameters on a corpus of 2.1B words. Leveraging
continual pretraining, we adapt to Galician two existing LLMs trained on larger
corpora, thus mitigating the data constraints that would arise if the training
were performed from scratch. The models were evaluated using human judgments
and task-based datasets from standardized benchmarks. These evaluations reveal
a promising performance, underscoring the importance of linguistic diversity in
generative models. | [
-0.1578831226,
-0.2583146691,
0.5958794951,
0.5318435431,
-0.2920102477,
0.1885694414,
-0.6377589703,
-0.498532474,
0.1676203609,
0.6231028438,
-0.4982544184,
-0.750367403,
-0.8310792446,
0.1273815036,
-0.1779900193,
0.863014102,
-0.0624450669,
0.3402824998,
-0.0549684763,
-0.3025581539,
-0.4673881829,
-0.2186772972,
-0.5530747175,
-0.2839092612,
0.4470483959,
0.2404904962,
0.6069082022,
0.5690168142,
0.3246719837,
0.2860933244,
-0.002111763,
0.1759772301,
-0.6986241937,
0.0139889903,
-0.2879222631,
-0.5728726983,
-0.2342549711,
-0.1166904941,
0.7937272191,
0.7437111735,
-0.3192913234,
0.0906809717,
0.0223993994,
0.6581277847,
-0.4598562717,
0.2666426897,
-0.976477325,
0.0902139321,
-0.528090775,
0.0805831477,
-0.4992769063,
-0.4270579517,
-0.0550776795,
-0.6248691678,
0.4152264893,
-0.1625214517,
0.4739761353,
0.4499300718,
-0.120402731,
-0.3718031347,
-0.9274955392,
0.767020762,
-0.4805624485,
0.7218649983,
0.2090991139,
0.1754436195,
-0.1403249204,
-0.5488438606,
-0.2023870647,
-0.4739866257,
0.0504729673,
0.3130485117,
-0.6266983151,
0.1361583024,
0.0646840334,
0.4379088581,
-0.7629431486,
0.6839959621,
-0.6001310945,
0.0442355797,
0.2046611905,
0.1185313836,
0.1411837488,
0.1721780002,
-0.3394605219,
-0.0398583002,
-0.9723380208,
-0.2847166657,
0.6490367651,
0.5009183288,
-0.1922975928,
0.5465853214,
-0.0590380281,
0.7291930318,
-0.0367777199,
-0.1381089836,
0.3466665745,
-0.0015087907,
-0.2898982763,
-0.1556520462,
0.8025453687,
0.0257941224,
0.2306637466,
-0.3268846869,
-0.0587859116,
0.1411799341,
0.243755281,
-0.4226971567,
-0.0771561787,
-0.0187040493,
-0.254463017,
0.0283200573,
0.0400309861,
-0.5564359426,
-0.104978472,
-0.2848508358,
0.0577145554,
-0.2536593676,
-0.1226978749,
0.4126716852,
0.1021107286,
0.0534917675,
0.4111312628,
-1.1175177097,
0.3621513844,
0.6958898306,
1.0041924715,
-0.2787876129,
-0.2463973612,
-0.5034959912,
0.1243661866,
-0.3181703985,
0.6280733347,
-0.2799534798,
-0.3518745899,
0.1006517261,
0.0651801303,
-0.1167617217,
-0.8292239308,
0.611496985,
-0.6162679195,
0.1146929115,
0.1179127172,
-0.0802796185,
0.1951554418,
0.1752091497,
-0.9427245259,
1.0223016739,
0.5636478066,
-0.713080883,
0.218072474,
-0.5221675038,
-0.202518627,
0.3744830489,
-0.038814906,
0.0730173886,
0.2896572351,
0.1281425804,
0.2338231653,
-0.6394117475,
0.4238634109,
-0.0478121638,
0.1716747582,
-0.1758697331,
-0.5185548067,
0.704934895,
0.1728909314,
0.156105563,
0.203861475,
-0.691644311,
-0.1254890263,
-0.1226414666,
-0.5093508959,
-0.3998700082,
-0.1743775308,
0.0650253147,
0.3509238362,
0.2903942466,
-0.6661343575,
0.0951388851,
-0.7037435174,
0.3559513688,
0.7896614075,
-0.5842239261,
0.5461554527,
-0.0841106698,
0.8109468818,
-0.1096919701,
0.2051485628,
0.1670143753,
-0.5148621202,
-0.8112059236,
-0.6850414872,
0.382481277,
0.5984682441,
-0.7582594752,
0.0989036709,
-0.2966103852,
-0.5101730227,
-0.9494031668,
0.403303653,
0.4919392765,
0.2667158246,
0.380338639,
-0.2883477509,
-0.6640463471,
-1.0842374563,
0.1328575164,
-0.2854571939,
-0.3798877597,
0.0350815617,
0.4002518058,
-0.3299197257,
0.6765471101,
-0.5404792428,
-0.2139389813,
-0.2096373439,
0.1475308686,
0.3218928576,
0.194304198,
0.5789937973,
-0.5834732652,
-0.4565247297,
0.2334786057,
-0.4591335356,
-0.4836553037,
0.3761719167,
-0.0579139479,
0.1794167459,
0.5268157721,
-0.4422283769,
-0.0800108537,
1.0227612257,
-0.0088857263,
0.3974970877,
-0.3491120934,
-0.2689765692,
-0.9625034928,
-0.1988143623,
-0.050362736,
-0.2129882872,
-0.5136922598,
0.1421699375,
-0.0611781143,
0.1639722139,
-0.6198458672,
0.686425209,
-0.478687346,
-0.1709028631,
-0.1300921142,
-0.1346714795,
-0.2371167839,
0.0309432708,
0.1329033971,
0.7117707133,
0.3203313351,
-0.2733977437,
0.2216449678,
0.2359047532,
-0.3435881734,
0.2788172662,
-0.6135887504,
-0.0232835039,
-0.3254448175,
0.1408746392,
-0.6851413846,
-0.3397223353,
0.0842509121,
-0.1507948041,
0.2468945384,
-0.3009620309,
-0.30095312,
-0.5323659182,
-0.2810253799,
0.2928746939,
0.4820358157,
-0.8526883125,
0.4800935388,
0.3549316823,
-0.3724817336,
-0.4758904576,
-0.5938003063,
-0.0237142332,
-0.0810553953,
-0.7737071514,
0.5149935484,
-0.1156618968,
-0.4421025217,
-0.0462480597,
0.2409280986,
-0.0780460462,
-0.0113223763,
0.3282868862,
0.2363457233,
-0.2870110571,
0.1898271143,
-0.0193636809,
-0.0788773969,
-0.1934174746,
-0.6910410523,
0.8059090376,
-0.1910188496,
-0.3383231461,
0.0654724464,
0.4110453129,
0.5107778311,
-0.3359633386,
0.7021377683,
0.5035716891,
-0.298283875,
-0.3755243719,
-0.5576608777,
0.334936738,
-0.3927759826,
0.3660805821,
-0.1426347643,
-1.4484014511,
0.6014808416,
0.148781985,
-0.0468171388,
0.5278017521,
1.0955222845,
0.2316766828,
0.6024546027,
0.8581530452,
-0.1132222638,
0.4244049788,
-0.0129268253,
-0.1234951094,
-0.6941995025,
-0.2315949649,
-0.6517345905,
0.1454410404,
-0.8357043862,
-0.838351965,
0.3827101588,
0.1314888895,
0.0134552466,
0.1933451742,
-0.1731837541,
0.4963084757,
0.5661666393,
-0.0403862372,
0.3913668692,
-0.0935702249,
-0.0872363597,
-0.0154078575,
-0.8164259791,
-0.6400610209,
1.1167510748,
0.5879499912,
0.8219047785,
0.1344112605,
0.5773281455,
0.0957834572,
0.6971558928,
-0.651254952,
0.2544474602,
-0.6804439425,
-0.4067399204,
-0.2257143408,
-0.3950370252,
-0.8760870695,
0.3740972281,
-0.1141951829,
-0.5394839644,
-0.0627089813,
0.0719463527,
-0.1179064959,
0.2620035112,
-0.4977185428,
0.6331965923,
-0.3021498322,
-0.3951741159,
-0.0284202676,
-0.3603208959,
0.4830471873,
-0.3132093251,
0.320533812,
-0.1312027574,
0.0626800507,
0.5795240998,
-0.3164322972,
0.7700279355,
-0.0716067404,
-0.3872740865,
0.1715506613,
-0.0767262727,
0.3341622353,
0.0603267103,
-0.1147017628,
0.3703939617,
-0.4960195422,
-0.272967428,
-0.2280998379,
0.7547789216,
-0.7783797383,
-0.4531694353,
-0.1949728429,
-0.544369936,
-0.2822715342,
-0.0865235478,
0.3523570001,
-0.0815990791,
-0.6337653399,
0.1234350055,
0.7377012968,
-0.397154212,
0.1636485606,
0.7518309355,
-0.1590478718,
-0.5571115613,
0.5517259836,
-0.0047278591,
0.5210232139,
0.3936227858,
0.1284437925,
-0.2103149742,
-0.7620258331,
-0.566623807,
0.2408176214,
-0.4817102253,
-0.1901519448,
-0.6476951241,
-0.046949394,
-0.4195076525,
-0.2123592794,
-0.5209340453,
-0.2834370434,
-0.3961259723,
-0.2157837301,
0.1041806117,
0.8873121142,
-0.3415449262,
0.5590217113,
-0.7984250784,
0.3596281409,
0.385102272,
0.3591417968,
-0.111155197,
-0.5523291826,
-0.2161587924,
-0.1012394056,
-0.1740770638,
-0.5798501372,
0.6684240103,
-0.0420221873,
0.484167546,
0.2665803432,
-0.5001801252,
0.288163662,
-0.7493917346,
0.5957024097,
0.4302860796,
-0.5560563207,
0.3237845898,
-0.7535453439,
0.2367852777,
0.5484173298,
0.5685757995,
-0.362416327,
-0.5043244362,
-0.3362451196,
-0.9273858666,
0.7225180864,
-0.0239920244,
0.0895555541,
-0.2848645747,
0.0619542785,
0.5125076175,
0.2189324796,
-0.8859040141,
0.2803745866,
0.0043748384,
-0.310570389,
-0.2169282138,
-0.1595840603,
-0.0136686461,
-0.1969158649,
0.5476410985,
-0.1359718591,
0.1526573151,
-0.2996118665,
-0.0968338177,
-0.1244755462,
0.4445686936,
0.5413012505,
0.5226925015,
-0.2334526181,
-0.0901263431,
0.234656617,
-0.5932767987,
0.2023199648,
0.1244197413,
-0.3140514195,
0.0885236785,
0.3961633444,
0.906108439,
0.2745345533,
-0.5778948069,
0.3722772002,
0.0774850175,
-0.1906887591,
-0.3825625777,
-0.0070231752,
0.2629995346,
0.4626449943,
0.1082924083,
-0.2510344386,
-0.1694587022,
-0.5204327106,
-0.3011967838,
0.5254656076,
-0.3486052454,
-0.366843015,
0.5879895687,
0.1117994562,
-0.1782868356,
0.5151544213,
-0.2190848887,
-0.4958675802,
0.4440220594,
0.8495798707,
0.9009452462,
-0.2530442476,
0.462660104,
0.3328457773,
0.602793932,
-0.55446738,
0.2322273999,
0.2704460323,
-0.7893316746,
-0.5479890108,
-1.0705840588,
-0.4406195581,
0.253044188,
-0.6515837312,
0.1555167586,
-0.2979738116,
-0.0713992119,
-0.1626654267,
-0.5218940973,
-0.835996151,
0.0186401643,
0.1803201437,
0.8858818412,
-1.1212887764,
0.7322022915,
0.5092163086,
-0.2812155485,
-0.3732995987,
-0.2499130219,
-0.2989684045,
-0.8289888501,
0.9170255065,
-0.1695994437,
-0.2082681358,
-0.0210239924,
-0.5291421413,
-0.719068408,
0.9256816506,
0.7304884195,
-0.7827088833,
-0.2896505892,
0.2887816727,
0.7900303602,
-0.4409363866,
0.1471757591,
0.496822685,
0.3825882971,
-0.1613490283,
-1.0789811611,
-0.4209114313,
0.0482650474,
0.1464314163,
0.5541911721,
-0.684961617,
1.1624077559,
0.0219518971,
-0.1590634286,
0.1894520223,
0.582690239,
0.1713936031,
0.0922550857,
0.1666858345,
0.9207745194,
0.8280153871,
-0.0907802135,
0.9092065692,
-0.0166066326,
0.1149180308,
1.2025307417,
-0.4267355502,
0.865885675,
0.3889378011,
-0.2956608236,
0.3834697306,
0.1946115494,
0.086846903,
0.4628961086,
0.3821908236,
-0.6222090125,
-0.1886283308,
-0.232690841,
-0.3042961061,
0.7038161755,
0.477646172,
-0.488073796,
-0.5143934488,
0.1590617299,
-0.141178906,
0.2665709853,
-0.6328121424,
0.5949755907,
-0.0114642167,
-0.5783439279,
0.3190473616,
0.4218980074,
0.8792318702,
-0.7778081894,
0.0664499775,
-0.1674835533,
-0.0313067585,
-0.1228604093,
-0.6108783484,
0.1780312657,
0.3703031838,
-0.5683854818,
-0.48663041,
0.7136723399,
-0.368137449,
-0.5515502691,
0.6028878093,
0.72850281,
0.0355442055,
0.0689899102,
-0.2129321992,
0.0127160959,
0.0105706854,
0.0336850025,
0.3630007803,
0.3154873848,
-0.3791511655,
0.4113712311,
0.709710896,
0.386783123,
0.3108615875,
0.2533749342,
0.9973788857,
-0.3984060585,
-0.3275030255,
-0.7774825096,
0.1985533237,
0.305147171,
-0.421199441,
0.4991287589,
0.5817681551,
1.2702306509,
-0.4205850363,
0.7445374727,
0.1483708769,
0.5355138183,
-0.9420980215,
0.4754450321,
-0.0541525595,
0.0938815027,
-0.0020090197,
-0.9484847784,
-0.2992163301,
0.4834951758,
-0.3162168562,
-0.1166943833,
0.4058324993,
0.7286856174,
-0.0908075646,
-0.1507488936,
0.4097212553,
0.4192584157,
0.1494575441,
0.84490031,
0.936480999,
0.0673217475,
0.13476336,
0.0888924226,
-0.3499143422,
-0.0522301197,
-0.9701106548,
-0.7394681573,
-0.3983538449,
0.1321751624,
-0.08002536,
0.225707829,
1.018825531,
0.3619614244,
-0.5646449327,
-0.3004127443,
-0.1412622631,
-0.1053529754,
0.4141456187,
-0.1181745678,
0.0110818781,
-0.116167672,
-0.645414114,
0.6209258437,
0.4215773344,
0.0286721773,
-0.5642371178,
-0.1963021308,
-0.0067389952,
-0.14076671,
0.8269144297,
0.4145858288,
-0.6138522625,
-0.0268560834,
-0.0266360678,
-0.1342939138,
0.1353929639,
0.6575472355,
-0.8085736036,
0.3424700499,
0.4013323486,
0.4838835895,
0.5335295796,
-0.1240456477,
0.4804132879,
-0.7450470924,
0.4568997324,
0.4846218526,
0.2947586775,
0.4756651223,
0.0562625229,
0.5505496264,
0.0206622072,
-0.2351303995,
-0.7822943926,
0.3535100818,
-0.8142269254,
0.0434415415,
1.2058564425,
-0.0911385641,
-0.0482823364,
0.0204173792,
-0.0422230363,
0.2111963779,
-0.0612704158,
0.4921413064,
0.8353205919,
0.1596214473,
0.2027211189,
-0.9693127275,
0.2738374174,
0.0787437335,
-0.8893973231,
0.0322913155,
0.7122522593,
0.1620205194,
0.0740251839,
0.8477205634,
-0.302071631,
0.0868248791,
-0.1631000936,
0.1692801863,
0.0385143682,
-0.7141780853,
-0.5196288228,
0.1575504839,
0.4582745433,
0.131337285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13892v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13892v1 | Adaptable Logical Control for Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T23:47:59 | 2024-06-19T23:47:59 | Honghua Zhang, Po-Nien Kung, Masahiro Yoshida, Guy Van den Broeck, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the success of Large Language Models (LLMs) on various tasks
following human instructions, controlling model generation at inference time
poses a persistent challenge. In this paper, we introduce Ctrl-G, an adaptable
framework that facilitates tractable and flexible control of LLM generation to
reliably follow logical constraints. Ctrl-G combines any production-ready LLM
with a Hidden Markov Model, enabling LLM outputs to adhere to logical
constraints represented as deterministic finite automata. We show that Ctrl-G,
when applied to a TULU2-7B model, outperforms GPT3.5 and GPT4 on the task of
interactive text editing: specifically, for the task of generating text
insertions/continuations following logical constraints, Ctrl-G achieves over
30% higher satisfaction rate in human evaluation compared to GPT4. When applied
to medium-size language models (e.g., GPT2-large), Ctrl-G also beats its
counterparts for constrained generation by large margins on standard
benchmarks. Additionally, as a proof-of-concept study, we experiment Ctrl-G on
the Grade School Math benchmark to assist LLM reasoning, foreshadowing the
application of Ctrl-G, as well as other constrained generation approaches,
beyond traditional language generation tasks. | [
-0.1052152738,
-1.07774055,
0.9102256894,
0.1639677435,
-0.0812475458,
0.0469990335,
-0.4855583012,
-0.23764503,
-0.3068961501,
0.4608915746,
-0.7906000018,
-0.5560061932,
-0.550999403,
0.1937488467,
-0.2744614482,
0.9653724432,
-0.1170973703,
-0.332698971,
-0.0137696955,
0.1029769406,
-0.4445989132,
-0.5573912859,
-0.490436554,
-0.2080331892,
0.4951173961,
0.1646205187,
1.1580278873,
0.7979431152,
0.2489660531,
0.4044800699,
-0.0860016793,
0.3485906422,
-0.3694157004,
0.1631043255,
-0.5778883696,
-0.519110918,
-0.3932246864,
0.0880265608,
0.5259094238,
0.4091177881,
-0.1604659855,
-0.2104163766,
0.0984573513,
0.6186071634,
-0.463953793,
0.2112165838,
-0.9101122022,
0.1022955179,
-0.0972263291,
-0.0324833989,
-0.4947635531,
-0.7361582518,
-0.1362742037,
-0.8849384189,
-0.0746882558,
-0.1879067272,
0.649615407,
0.5318796635,
-0.5210026503,
-0.514918685,
-0.8489314318,
0.7351774573,
-0.8120052814,
0.2989829779,
0.1518368423,
0.3895687163,
-0.5827500224,
-0.7177113295,
-0.7148458958,
-0.3454999328,
-0.0266965497,
0.0625954717,
-0.2339812815,
0.2889758348,
0.5607950091,
-0.0961593613,
-0.3454410732,
0.101298742,
-0.1380757242,
-0.1442990601,
0.2810996175,
0.3324322104,
0.2724893391,
0.1007468551,
0.0197146479,
0.1820761114,
-0.8811445832,
-0.0937488675,
0.4162193537,
-0.0124969278,
0.0445518717,
0.7607584,
-0.3174933791,
0.9028086066,
0.2901749313,
-0.1105573773,
-0.0239539742,
-0.3092008233,
-0.333045572,
-0.2470225543,
0.6934545636,
0.2541897893,
0.3576040268,
0.1478594691,
-0.2015421093,
0.3810245395,
0.1480473876,
-0.7024359703,
-0.3480130136,
-0.0061626635,
-0.1075232252,
-0.2821855843,
-0.1762026697,
-0.3788075745,
-0.3367328346,
-0.5054824352,
0.37354213,
-0.364005208,
0.1126999483,
0.2301768959,
0.0669575781,
0.121312879,
0.8697198033,
-0.8342314959,
0.2780004442,
0.7027422786,
0.7406320572,
-0.2604441643,
-0.0303406809,
-0.7959481478,
0.3312918842,
-0.3851014376,
0.2433000505,
-0.6614562273,
-0.2456851751,
-0.1490978748,
-0.2035349458,
-0.2573034763,
-0.3507173955,
0.3324825168,
-0.5199293494,
0.56783849,
0.1359357089,
-0.5746095777,
-0.1258618236,
0.2402593791,
-0.5417881012,
0.566688776,
0.1511912197,
-0.8223724365,
0.2108017653,
-0.4555022418,
-0.3174490631,
-0.12351197,
-0.532297492,
-0.2887835503,
0.1611717343,
0.1494757086,
0.2307906896,
-0.3723087013,
0.5446443558,
-0.4604428113,
-0.0349348187,
0.4170470834,
-0.5480761528,
0.7382923365,
0.2470040172,
-0.5040878654,
0.4363511503,
-0.6945209503,
0.251773715,
-0.0721956044,
-0.5554376245,
0.072093904,
0.2425561845,
-0.0721209049,
0.4576482177,
0.3218227625,
-0.2777145207,
0.5373479128,
-0.1226256043,
0.753288269,
0.655982554,
-0.00272874,
0.2651328743,
-0.3342526853,
0.6519546509,
-0.3620356023,
0.0454326011,
0.214039132,
-0.2846066654,
-0.655251205,
-0.3818313777,
0.1668441594,
0.7363654375,
-0.9409712553,
0.5793759823,
0.017658839,
-0.3784754574,
-0.2958281934,
0.1584384739,
0.3590983152,
0.5561901927,
0.1171374768,
0.099474445,
-0.2899850011,
-0.9132088423,
-0.3179123998,
-0.1061081812,
-0.4000916183,
0.1409366578,
0.3121373355,
-0.1276084483,
0.6845161319,
-0.3549215794,
-0.1647034883,
-0.5136125684,
0.1290553361,
0.4123343229,
0.5402465463,
0.2663200498,
-0.7242008448,
-0.3561070561,
0.1966506243,
-0.6139705777,
-0.4539675713,
-0.4813008308,
-0.1073211581,
0.5810065269,
0.6047936082,
-0.8371375203,
0.5577016473,
0.5684099793,
-0.5643011332,
0.6744189858,
-0.5184009075,
-0.0401170775,
-0.7961025238,
0.1024898365,
-0.3472225666,
-0.4667247832,
-0.5695494413,
-0.0082697012,
0.1485784054,
0.223367393,
-0.3375815153,
0.3444096148,
-0.253682673,
0.0943582058,
-0.3551875949,
0.2346320897,
-0.0311424155,
0.5770710707,
0.1789557189,
0.4959604442,
0.434841007,
-0.5174034238,
0.0658772364,
0.2204295993,
-0.4824311137,
0.2175004482,
-0.7797065973,
0.0671706423,
0.1040042788,
0.3911254108,
-0.5883899927,
-0.2560892701,
0.3301149905,
-0.2645023465,
0.1079293638,
0.0667603835,
-0.5892943144,
-0.0995794758,
-0.0101741822,
0.0640481189,
0.5474303365,
-0.3724566102,
0.8773361444,
0.0406736992,
-0.2421735823,
-0.2261545211,
-0.683935225,
0.0267089866,
-0.2756309509,
-0.4855971932,
0.2937822044,
-0.4165614843,
-0.3972740769,
-0.0708298683,
-0.1245601252,
0.1096719429,
0.3085515201,
0.0672299191,
0.2778109312,
0.0295055825,
-0.0774390697,
0.3375950754,
0.0139965732,
0.0762403756,
-0.3971635103,
0.3447504044,
0.0004230998,
-0.3084540963,
-0.5464632511,
0.1741757393,
0.8175709844,
-0.1753877997,
0.2558888495,
0.2549189031,
-0.2023386359,
-0.4914064109,
-0.3143723607,
0.0585065633,
-0.5575066805,
0.5176069736,
-0.4808734953,
-1.1292604208,
0.3271964788,
0.0795871988,
0.2982258499,
0.2740631402,
0.8588533998,
0.2017232627,
1.129732132,
0.5782163739,
-0.0301903337,
0.4627783298,
0.2739033103,
-0.0572324656,
-0.4997151196,
0.1067698821,
-0.5459885597,
-0.3943186402,
-0.9224818945,
-0.4193025529,
0.3792027235,
0.3466225564,
-0.4683152735,
0.2044345438,
-0.3439109325,
0.4862475395,
0.5612126589,
0.0852279887,
0.4441689253,
-0.3587617874,
-0.350745976,
-0.0178524349,
-0.782317102,
-0.4749720395,
0.6380109191,
0.1569532156,
0.918733418,
0.2711775303,
0.5345131159,
0.1386215389,
0.2945578992,
-0.5267279148,
0.6447442174,
-0.1825236529,
-0.531933248,
-0.3110718131,
-0.5631593466,
-0.5676128864,
0.2701236904,
-0.1547598094,
-1.0268396139,
-0.1710183918,
0.5119258165,
-0.348005265,
0.2610915601,
-0.6219733953,
0.885445416,
-0.3132905066,
-0.5757708549,
-0.2876295149,
-0.6323702931,
0.3033842146,
-0.2346785069,
0.2067995816,
-0.0671170354,
-0.2127022147,
0.2921493351,
-0.4883609712,
0.896903038,
-0.1111529395,
-0.2610077262,
0.4408642948,
0.6307324767,
0.8872352839,
0.0585493036,
-0.1070689857,
-0.3157415688,
-0.2889104784,
-0.0661151409,
-0.9583423138,
0.8191384077,
-0.6011728048,
-1.0558029413,
-0.207305178,
-0.9129333496,
-0.2334900945,
0.3788265586,
0.1523901671,
0.334439069,
-0.0003718692,
0.248621121,
0.4793798029,
-0.4441443682,
0.5510991812,
0.3663546145,
-0.4775990844,
-0.5035225153,
0.656434238,
0.0430051647,
0.7641124725,
0.5766102672,
0.4254923165,
-0.2911972702,
-0.4839092791,
-0.5075823069,
-0.0970784426,
-0.485909164,
-0.0190590452,
-0.6182842255,
-0.1492052972,
-0.1513049006,
-0.4855472445,
-0.1283067912,
-0.8822874427,
-0.331243813,
-0.1442596912,
0.3317714334,
0.8124777675,
-0.0386165567,
0.2941459715,
-0.5749447346,
0.2967706621,
0.2496742457,
0.0920627564,
-0.2508969903,
-0.504609108,
0.0616004989,
-0.2350344062,
-0.4141601324,
-0.7328265905,
0.3332003653,
0.1697558761,
0.166890502,
0.2210317403,
-0.1055909693,
0.2902481258,
-0.6269196272,
0.5322842598,
0.1863455772,
-1.156349659,
0.3409180641,
-0.7945882082,
0.8734817505,
0.3256706595,
-0.0283162668,
-0.3912728131,
-0.813893497,
-0.4372491241,
-0.5301570296,
0.5465640426,
0.4015685916,
-0.1859255731,
0.1000819281,
0.1809833944,
0.0558345616,
0.3506279886,
-0.801151216,
0.2316798419,
-0.0888841152,
-0.4098248482,
0.1531367153,
0.0369473025,
0.0907196254,
0.0118095316,
0.5845011473,
-0.2577653229,
-0.0888387337,
0.1459552348,
-0.0456322879,
0.0499220379,
0.5303260684,
0.7706970572,
0.6721211672,
0.0712820813,
0.2604807317,
-0.0204001069,
-0.2718424201,
0.0492201149,
0.1875177622,
-0.5823005438,
-0.2435231805,
0.3214686811,
0.7002695799,
-0.0150197307,
-0.5510191917,
0.0543210506,
0.0845173746,
-0.4336820543,
-0.0479423255,
0.5268530846,
0.1355439276,
0.4039520621,
0.0575162843,
-0.0964291543,
-0.1474372447,
-0.2692877352,
0.2360633314,
0.3820962012,
-0.2560551763,
-0.3468479812,
1.0690798759,
-0.0060219117,
-0.0779164284,
0.54132092,
-0.0595739186,
-0.6548658609,
0.6022600532,
0.7113154531,
0.9761618972,
0.0483531132,
0.061014872,
0.270565033,
0.5011391044,
0.0779495984,
0.4731814861,
0.0744403303,
-0.6702931523,
-0.5901415348,
-0.2751324475,
-0.3708172739,
0.1048179716,
-0.2179688215,
0.2597154081,
-0.8022699952,
-0.0896877199,
-0.0160879977,
-0.1207249984,
-0.6500996351,
0.1711902022,
-0.0603543408,
0.9465251565,
-0.4185172021,
1.25504601,
0.3562816679,
-0.1185523942,
-0.7937211394,
-0.2733316422,
0.4050940871,
-0.455262959,
0.5551239252,
0.0560078807,
-0.2415261567,
0.0256059989,
-0.5398122668,
-0.6512678266,
1.0618475676,
0.383002311,
-0.9809757471,
-0.0973144844,
0.1857584864,
0.6215028167,
-0.3079941869,
-0.0162060857,
0.6307304502,
0.6725848317,
0.0331217721,
-0.9080916047,
0.2322105914,
-0.0544777401,
-0.0575654209,
0.3039479852,
-0.5339167714,
0.7006340027,
-0.4475924075,
-0.2196721286,
0.3056231737,
0.7770181298,
0.4420376122,
-0.1145728081,
0.6476889849,
0.4994230568,
0.7433179021,
-0.1279169023,
0.8887387514,
-0.169914335,
0.0776887015,
1.5838214159,
-0.3745218217,
0.5287492871,
0.4439719617,
0.1154609621,
0.2749528885,
0.2076156437,
0.0994805396,
0.405783534,
0.5048756599,
-0.3270652592,
-0.4024413228,
0.0117316609,
-0.0084384074,
0.1565704048,
0.5385820866,
-0.2988753617,
-0.214429155,
-0.165474534,
0.3282887042,
0.2289201915,
-0.3271587193,
0.5644152761,
-0.0370095298,
-0.8140772581,
0.4203770161,
0.0864474252,
0.3582457006,
-0.7986234426,
-0.1347937286,
-0.1227321252,
0.3502077162,
-0.0118049271,
-0.7311227918,
0.2815526128,
0.1708542109,
-0.1623878181,
-0.2736625671,
0.7398837209,
-0.6859217286,
-0.5247724652,
0.0378833562,
0.4542595148,
-0.2705372572,
0.1664970964,
-0.505022943,
0.3173387945,
0.4329970479,
-0.4986498654,
0.174598217,
0.859891355,
-0.411334306,
0.8685020804,
0.470906496,
0.0865018144,
0.1342837662,
-0.213840723,
0.8834301829,
-0.6998520494,
-0.4905414879,
-0.8636882901,
0.332126677,
0.2170526683,
-0.3096146286,
0.5628310442,
0.3310629725,
0.9812566042,
-0.1659445912,
1.1157295704,
-0.4012302756,
0.3038139641,
-0.7427858114,
0.7113939524,
-0.2838206887,
0.0729248524,
-0.22649993,
-0.7816835046,
-0.6022594571,
0.4348000586,
-0.3697703183,
-0.0748440251,
0.6293587089,
0.821074903,
0.0465838201,
-0.2077446133,
0.3911844194,
0.3561394811,
0.6647916436,
0.7919846773,
0.8575865626,
0.3316926658,
0.3751256168,
-0.0218598675,
-0.2770158052,
0.1148004681,
-1.2436769009,
-0.8641193509,
-0.2319768667,
-0.3541004658,
-0.2549887896,
0.0021120743,
1.1408625841,
0.2348521352,
-0.7628343701,
-0.1873905361,
-0.3393593132,
0.2613613605,
-0.2137512267,
-0.2023927271,
0.438008517,
-0.2887551188,
-0.9026758075,
0.4453139901,
0.2443992496,
0.0620447472,
-0.1063497439,
-0.1473662108,
-0.0826686397,
0.1245368868,
0.5890206099,
0.2939407527,
-0.8020288348,
-0.4997973442,
-0.0931946561,
-0.2179457098,
-0.2549595833,
1.0552914143,
-0.6951072216,
0.4920209944,
0.522323668,
0.833083868,
0.153961271,
-0.0386533402,
0.9464412332,
-0.3340492845,
-0.0073588248,
0.148249194,
0.2523193359,
0.0776759461,
-0.2107388824,
0.4631823003,
-0.0151892276,
-0.5756023526,
-0.246583268,
0.488899976,
-1.0044496059,
-0.3035454154,
1.1679186821,
-0.0961813703,
-0.0673447251,
0.1254299134,
-0.4371177256,
0.2244398147,
-0.3596228361,
0.7973005176,
0.6042020917,
-0.1797455847,
0.0835975781,
-0.6481580138,
0.5338941813,
0.3386885822,
-0.97627002,
0.3729482591,
1.0712975264,
0.169639796,
-0.260977447,
0.4725038111,
-0.1586173922,
0.2364743501,
-0.576223433,
-0.0471686609,
-0.207429111,
-0.4978367984,
-0.2242360711,
0.0813334808,
0.0650012568,
0.1307326108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13890v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13890v1 | ClinicalLab: Aligning Agents for Multi-Departmental Clinical Diagnostics in the Real World | 2024-06-19T23:44:25 | 2024-06-19T23:44:25 | Weixiang Yan, Haitian Liu, Tengxiao Wu, Qian Chen, Wen Wang, Haoyuan Chai, Jiayi Wang, Weishan Zhao, Yixin Zhang, Renjun Zhang, Li Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | LLMs have achieved significant performance progress in various NLP
applications. However, LLMs still struggle to meet the strict requirements for
accuracy and reliability in the medical field and face many challenges in
clinical applications. Existing clinical diagnostic evaluation benchmarks for
evaluating medical agents powered by LLMs have severe limitations. Firstly,
most existing medical evaluation benchmarks face the risk of data leakage or
contamination. Secondly, existing benchmarks often neglect the characteristics
of multiple departments and specializations in modern medical practice.
Thirdly, existing evaluation methods are limited to multiple-choice questions,
which do not align with the real-world diagnostic scenarios. Lastly, existing
evaluation methods lack comprehensive evaluations of end-to-end real clinical
scenarios. These limitations in benchmarks in turn obstruct advancements of
LLMs and agents for medicine. To address these limitations, we introduce
ClinicalLab, a comprehensive clinical diagnosis agent alignment suite.
ClinicalLab includes ClinicalBench, an end-to-end multi-departmental clinical
diagnostic evaluation benchmark for evaluating medical agents and LLMs.
ClinicalBench is based on real cases that cover 24 departments and 150
diseases. ClinicalLab also includes four novel metrics (ClinicalMetrics) for
evaluating the effectiveness of LLMs in clinical diagnostic tasks. We evaluate
17 LLMs and find that their performance varies significantly across different
departments. Based on these findings, in ClinicalLab, we propose ClinicalAgent,
an end-to-end clinical agent that aligns with real-world clinical diagnostic
practices. We systematically investigate the performance and applicable
scenarios of variants of ClinicalAgent on ClinicalBench. Our findings
demonstrate the importance of aligning with modern medical practices in
designing medical agents. | [
-0.256508857,
-0.450266242,
0.818793416,
0.172863692,
-0.086410448,
0.6280283332,
-0.0687472597,
-0.8504427671,
0.1505140066,
0.1757852435,
-0.4686315358,
-0.5741606951,
-0.4642229974,
0.3391890228,
0.1271681488,
0.747405827,
-0.1434847116,
0.4830739796,
-0.7366220951,
-0.72242558,
-0.6039271951,
-0.3124231398,
-0.582257688,
-0.7189491987,
0.5611825585,
0.248053968,
1.1689995527,
0.7511643171,
0.9013915062,
0.4207059145,
0.2778675258,
0.3778436184,
-0.1766642779,
0.3392430842,
-0.2125713974,
-0.2987293601,
-0.9300646186,
-0.1365882307,
0.2671923041,
0.7198258042,
-0.1860852987,
-0.1358759999,
-0.421992898,
0.3849285543,
-0.5108736157,
-0.2554217279,
-0.0812228695,
0.1973204166,
-0.0595845059,
-0.2548984289,
-0.3408379555,
-0.4591869414,
0.1954504251,
-0.8439471722,
0.4203135371,
-0.0330367237,
0.8569289446,
0.3583815396,
-0.4787966311,
-0.1112688929,
-0.5155715942,
0.6345432401,
-0.509531796,
0.270458132,
-0.1197797656,
0.9915142059,
-0.1312517524,
-0.8002321124,
-0.1188706458,
-0.3582674861,
-0.1230090708,
0.4737695456,
-0.026401585,
0.0809292495,
-0.0612235181,
-0.0540133156,
-0.9263563752,
0.4914718866,
-0.024395043,
-0.3319615424,
0.6011395454,
0.682341516,
0.3915117383,
0.4456230402,
-0.6883937716,
-0.27146101,
-0.4622192383,
-0.3428458869,
-0.2903339267,
0.1159251556,
-0.0457589962,
0.3980019689,
0.0054373802,
0.5787631869,
-0.1959703416,
-0.4730193615,
0.3655540943,
-0.2978567481,
-0.1756413281,
0.3208175898,
0.8270514607,
0.5343450308,
0.0754916444,
-0.307856679,
-0.1740768403,
0.4971887767,
0.6047357321,
-0.4937629402,
0.1547926068,
0.5362662673,
-0.2613308132,
-0.4504582286,
-0.2628214955,
-0.7037127614,
-0.9422754645,
-0.4730933607,
0.2719308734,
-0.4034409225,
0.0104039423,
-0.0634406954,
-0.1911362708,
0.2701756656,
0.6540695429,
-0.3503664732,
0.5847647786,
0.7052551508,
0.6269843578,
-0.3413957357,
-0.2478927076,
-0.4377850294,
0.1917951703,
-0.4703876674,
0.9591467977,
-0.4896713793,
-0.3463696539,
0.0219442025,
0.1406682134,
-0.0217528827,
-0.9209983945,
0.4059031606,
-0.140981093,
-0.2295851111,
-0.2197524011,
-0.4823605716,
0.4225998819,
0.3961627483,
-0.3558156192,
0.6970903277,
0.2866360247,
-0.1900425553,
0.4923897982,
-0.3237033784,
-0.1121851653,
0.4095470607,
-0.5700244904,
-0.7027831078,
-0.1135879606,
0.0497481488,
0.1856059581,
-0.6937003136,
0.4959537685,
-0.4319709539,
-0.3228997588,
0.4678972363,
-0.1482258737,
0.6170603037,
0.3652007282,
0.0242200755,
0.4111148119,
-0.9329294562,
0.1107847244,
0.018520873,
0.2020735294,
-0.0227158573,
-0.1363170296,
-0.1461725384,
0.0887549818,
0.2527476847,
-0.5946639776,
0.2609323561,
-0.1508534849,
-0.050790593,
0.6948725581,
-0.2876887918,
0.2000604868,
-0.9069829583,
1.0986421108,
-0.0188746881,
0.3182176352,
0.2637991309,
-0.4327699542,
-0.3710753322,
-0.5843968987,
0.021144459,
0.6401975155,
-0.362799257,
0.4575513303,
-0.3056449592,
-0.7870554328,
-0.6672797203,
-0.1400437057,
0.5508122444,
0.6059764624,
0.3254475892,
-0.3471863568,
-0.3519810736,
-0.9599888921,
-0.2002902478,
0.1524441838,
-0.1231197864,
0.1385197043,
0.1477625519,
-0.6224251986,
0.9431145191,
-0.3160946369,
-0.5654920936,
-0.227835089,
-0.2184794396,
0.3632636666,
0.2396881282,
0.4957332015,
-0.3945557773,
-0.4904197156,
0.4263452291,
-0.9279490113,
-0.5895451307,
-0.0380782001,
-0.1377059221,
-0.0713954642,
0.491996944,
-0.5080180168,
0.3953511417,
0.4674115181,
-0.3454097211,
0.5529842377,
-0.5798707008,
-0.0940061286,
-0.8754281998,
0.0714960098,
-0.0518218689,
-0.5504701734,
-0.5885888934,
0.0901154727,
0.3126295209,
-0.1616533101,
-0.5316780806,
0.8175801635,
-0.3193190694,
-0.0326873064,
-0.0906224102,
0.5090295076,
0.334107697,
-0.1376898438,
-0.2089571953,
0.6359091997,
0.4888876677,
-0.4498271644,
0.6500734687,
0.3158736229,
0.0858661905,
1.0032807589,
-0.6382162571,
-0.0926885828,
-0.0595995747,
0.4310109019,
-0.6766868234,
-0.0868137628,
0.1216953769,
-0.2012035996,
0.4754559696,
0.1566059291,
-0.4735667109,
-0.1754163206,
-0.2923864424,
0.5466617942,
0.4798871577,
-0.4169993401,
0.4876830578,
0.0806342065,
0.1224753633,
-0.646156013,
-0.6080289483,
0.0241144393,
-0.2379222363,
-0.7166750431,
0.4977921844,
0.1080603749,
-0.3103545904,
-0.1019435599,
-0.1925025731,
0.1370759159,
-0.0727004036,
0.1606709659,
0.3625873327,
-0.2441697717,
0.1625177413,
-0.0828301162,
-0.4629832804,
-0.0698515996,
0.1443053931,
0.2374942154,
-0.1324419975,
-0.818685472,
-0.3345921636,
0.1079871356,
0.6726786494,
-0.0778670609,
0.6287361383,
0.5587159991,
-0.2416584194,
-0.1663500518,
-0.4983711541,
0.0894297287,
-0.4709803462,
0.4076124132,
-0.3259955943,
-0.3166042864,
0.7425079346,
-0.3666433394,
-0.0888320431,
0.299530983,
0.6593394876,
0.0288255084,
1.0793434381,
0.0818569437,
0.4526025653,
-0.152679652,
0.0512587205,
0.3797066212,
-0.858474195,
-0.346139878,
-0.4857418537,
-0.3736045957,
-0.491004765,
-0.2369943708,
0.8013827801,
-0.1556718498,
-0.0453607589,
0.2066602409,
-0.8359633684,
0.2988404632,
0.1023948416,
0.1512233466,
0.2051663995,
-0.2342936546,
-0.4368978739,
0.0424128883,
-0.5563538074,
-0.7013570666,
1.0962446928,
0.4490991533,
0.8054689765,
0.4761485755,
0.7185752392,
0.2524154782,
0.5240362287,
-0.7574701309,
0.5322035551,
-0.1561260819,
-0.4204584658,
-0.0816361308,
-0.0346691944,
-1.447334528,
0.5604154468,
0.1512067765,
-0.6426669955,
0.3338293135,
-0.1440054178,
-0.3560205102,
-0.3659131825,
-0.6426295638,
1.0453737974,
-0.3445208669,
-0.4635881186,
0.0024633107,
-0.8730732799,
0.0081165871,
-0.2727165222,
0.2651886344,
-0.4512565732,
-0.2361406833,
0.313667506,
-0.9435691237,
0.8077979684,
-0.0111601641,
-0.2257329971,
-0.0855833963,
-0.0713614821,
0.250092566,
0.162201643,
-0.0753794163,
-0.0221836027,
0.5394893289,
-0.4717003107,
-0.5457697511,
0.7014575005,
-0.9143381715,
-0.4106610715,
-0.759110868,
-0.5951882601,
-0.6824538112,
0.11579822,
0.1393607855,
0.7473885417,
-0.2583428919,
-0.3139914572,
0.2707910836,
-0.3614092171,
0.1131832451,
0.7259463072,
-0.0953679234,
-0.4417296946,
0.827768743,
-0.1565993726,
0.4864625037,
0.2683663666,
0.2641145885,
-0.5077307224,
-0.4021134973,
-0.4902187586,
0.3761892319,
-0.8821884394,
-0.4624326527,
-0.2328159958,
-0.1703689545,
-0.5502403975,
-0.6230084896,
-0.3585401177,
-0.1092891246,
-0.154453963,
0.2761436701,
0.2485240102,
0.536588788,
0.0405389555,
0.2865124047,
-0.8823364973,
0.3878865242,
-0.1473526955,
0.2262752205,
-0.3114463687,
-0.2006208003,
-0.1156505421,
-0.0114796339,
-0.6559949517,
-0.7778202295,
0.3514920473,
0.0747196376,
0.7507072091,
0.6560062766,
0.2334807813,
0.9090224504,
-0.3517287374,
0.3283964992,
0.1772185266,
-0.6006278396,
0.3305264413,
-0.1354291886,
0.2202435434,
0.5355758071,
0.1082058996,
-0.3869551718,
-0.5887989402,
-0.5344001651,
-0.6139672399,
0.6186459661,
0.1335359663,
-0.4404629469,
0.0899864063,
0.1120497659,
0.1967054605,
-0.0648710579,
-0.1733639091,
-0.199223116,
0.181939289,
-0.6422927976,
-0.1528998315,
0.2504997849,
-0.6834905744,
-0.2091470212,
0.3647761941,
-0.2092274427,
0.2975820303,
0.5604737401,
-0.0741591975,
-0.110168457,
0.2117252201,
0.6794841886,
1.1304622889,
-0.2406227738,
0.0886710286,
0.0148620093,
-0.4919062853,
0.4661919177,
0.3488924503,
0.4018484354,
0.0571665503,
0.5927906036,
0.3114923239,
-0.1029325575,
-0.9916579723,
0.5524235964,
-0.104381755,
-0.2328343987,
-0.3839144409,
0.0112119876,
-0.1022078395,
0.3430846334,
-0.080771625,
0.105438225,
-0.1299099028,
-0.4917710423,
0.241682291,
0.5402782559,
-0.531208396,
-0.0232553706,
0.6499928832,
0.0912598372,
-0.430552274,
0.5086821914,
-0.3344889879,
-0.1596114486,
1.1699061394,
0.6971492767,
0.7552752495,
-0.2105602324,
0.2655899525,
-0.2256774008,
0.1499637812,
0.2114285678,
0.1999303997,
0.2720943391,
-0.6777544618,
-0.2767697573,
-0.4916147888,
-0.7773668766,
-0.1357481182,
-0.5536225438,
0.5705990195,
-0.4033179581,
-0.3424009383,
0.0816016495,
-0.0129210148,
-0.5001882315,
0.209172219,
-0.1143556237,
0.7623474598,
-0.4938137233,
0.7706656456,
1.0226052999,
-0.1061193049,
-0.4649292529,
-0.540872097,
0.3830209076,
-1.0659546852,
0.1050268263,
0.24777475,
0.2217687964,
-0.320066005,
-0.0650155544,
-0.5123381019,
1.2763197422,
0.3947260082,
-0.5577527285,
0.2790513635,
0.532830894,
1.0592948198,
-0.4527489245,
0.445409596,
0.5019599199,
0.4527718127,
0.1697711796,
-1.1698652506,
0.4558857977,
-0.1903657317,
-0.2538480759,
0.3481001556,
-0.5268727541,
0.4363252819,
-0.1445985734,
-0.0323795415,
0.3595509827,
-0.1806699783,
0.6865698099,
0.8758187294,
0.0699733049,
0.7184573412,
0.7291733623,
-0.1574018151,
1.0959397554,
-0.2911373973,
0.1877304465,
0.7957525253,
-0.7966747284,
0.1601444036,
0.204708457,
-0.5160399079,
0.1473581344,
0.618059814,
-0.2750969231,
0.0996423215,
0.3244531751,
-0.5283884406,
-0.1479835659,
-0.3503116965,
-0.5839694142,
0.1911849529,
0.5282326937,
-0.0489839129,
-0.3378154039,
-0.1015566736,
-0.2052744031,
0.0040261638,
0.2082762271,
0.6356382966,
0.0185413957,
-0.4917335808,
0.7350010276,
-0.2405428141,
0.0168976039,
-0.7721402645,
0.0332261696,
-0.1058761328,
0.5528944135,
-0.314610213,
-0.3580077589,
0.2178245932,
-0.4460817277,
0.3553933203,
-0.1300151795,
0.5575715899,
-0.0481888056,
-0.332262218,
0.3317621946,
0.5186182261,
0.2275414169,
0.2659587562,
-0.6998694539,
0.2330584824,
-0.4331957698,
0.3149133623,
0.5559344888,
0.6328779459,
-0.1054575816,
0.8382186294,
0.4101412594,
0.2271851599,
-0.0408482589,
0.5591698885,
0.6519678235,
-0.4863525927,
0.0003527617,
-0.7192537785,
0.2877405286,
-0.0589956157,
-0.3472709954,
0.4092420042,
0.588336587,
0.2525820434,
0.0959371254,
0.5197876692,
0.3120962083,
0.4638136029,
-0.1759667993,
0.4868408442,
-0.7116299868,
0.3700902164,
-0.2247028798,
-0.783721745,
-0.4683236182,
0.2880054414,
0.3085007071,
0.0064849686,
0.965165019,
0.7289733291,
0.0943069682,
-0.1039877906,
0.5490151048,
0.1956422776,
0.7101949453,
0.4674857855,
0.8222724199,
-0.2467584014,
0.2775191069,
-0.3682254553,
-0.462913096,
-0.2206755877,
-0.6576783061,
-0.7302753329,
-0.0739374459,
-0.5881959796,
-0.3363093138,
0.0859461278,
0.7571143508,
0.6364006996,
-0.6091088653,
-0.1882030219,
-0.1905643642,
-0.0234661121,
-0.4989715815,
-0.2424293756,
0.3811146021,
-0.5905711651,
-0.6445350051,
0.6051790118,
0.5004282594,
0.1091872007,
-0.1390221566,
-0.1176091507,
0.1678190976,
-0.1552163064,
0.4313263595,
0.3322282135,
-0.7873895168,
0.0154430978,
-0.0869386867,
-0.3025356531,
0.14461115,
0.5331423283,
-1.0308098793,
0.6454776525,
0.1206974313,
0.7628852725,
-0.0141587602,
0.0856150389,
0.6355780959,
-0.4891700447,
0.0701065287,
0.5231055617,
0.2254921794,
0.0059712683,
-0.283583045,
0.6529792547,
0.1418792605,
-0.8573310971,
-0.9331815839,
-0.0151623702,
-1.321367979,
-0.1129229888,
0.8139945269,
0.1444734037,
0.0982184485,
-0.4206349254,
-0.2047583908,
0.2319586724,
-0.2649718523,
0.4549830258,
0.3607479334,
-0.7917708755,
0.2646379471,
-0.5454737544,
0.2478694916,
0.6003782153,
-0.902363658,
-0.3932679892,
0.398548007,
0.0967126936,
0.2433131784,
0.6951996088,
-0.2854293883,
0.3426432312,
-0.1266004741,
0.0916846618,
0.0973839089,
-0.043151971,
-0.118357189,
-0.1507052332,
-0.0259307697,
-0.3574127555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13885v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13885v1 | Knowledge Tagging System on Math Questions via LLMs with Flexible Demonstration Retriever | 2024-06-19T23:30:01 | 2024-06-19T23:30:01 | Hang Li, Tianlong Xu, Jiliang Tang, Qingsong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge tagging for questions plays a crucial role in contemporary
intelligent educational applications, including learning progress diagnosis,
practice question recommendations, and course content organization.
Traditionally, these annotations are always conducted by pedagogical experts,
as the task requires not only a strong semantic understanding of both question
stems and knowledge definitions but also deep insights into connecting
question-solving logic with corresponding knowledge concepts. With the recent
emergence of advanced text encoding algorithms, such as pre-trained language
models, many researchers have developed automatic knowledge tagging systems
based on calculating the semantic similarity between the knowledge and question
embeddings. In this paper, we explore automating the task using Large Language
Models (LLMs), in response to the inability of prior encoding-based methods to
deal with the hard cases which involve strong domain knowledge and complicated
concept definitions. By showing the strong performance of zero- and few-shot
results over math questions knowledge tagging tasks, we demonstrate LLMs' great
potential in conquering the challenges faced by prior methods. Furthermore, by
proposing a reinforcement learning-based demonstration retriever, we
successfully exploit the great potential of different-sized LLMs in achieving
better performance results while keeping the in-context demonstration usage
efficiency high. | [
-0.4923330247,
-0.8115820885,
0.6519006491,
-0.1910521388,
-0.3180488944,
0.1683571041,
-0.1363583505,
-0.1434668899,
0.193249613,
0.378621012,
-0.4326345921,
-0.4820915461,
-0.6516254544,
-0.0332709067,
-0.1951840967,
0.799646914,
-0.4461455345,
-0.0121652903,
-0.668384552,
0.0844558179,
-0.4788953662,
-0.5811941028,
-0.5809388757,
-0.5483726859,
0.1653454453,
0.2257893384,
0.4944142401,
0.6634883285,
0.701595366,
0.3697420955,
0.2141697407,
0.2581976652,
-0.0380796865,
0.1620386839,
-0.3074501455,
-0.705616951,
-0.3067145944,
-0.0489831306,
0.7691316605,
0.7964772582,
-0.1544193476,
0.1493189782,
-0.2267923504,
0.151141271,
-0.3824462295,
0.2622981668,
-0.7502800226,
0.1509978026,
0.055533886,
-0.1505742222,
-0.1456560045,
-0.4622160792,
0.1117021143,
-0.6737852097,
-0.0842563361,
-0.0504536442,
0.8156309128,
0.4515158534,
-0.2632502615,
-0.4006960392,
-0.6940687299,
0.900747478,
-0.5890693665,
0.1907278448,
0.4799083471,
0.5778264403,
-0.2014992684,
-0.6108604074,
-0.6167212725,
-0.1556834579,
-0.1453487277,
-0.1062480733,
-0.186756134,
-0.1220949069,
0.6559627652,
0.1605683118,
-0.423743397,
0.0281668752,
0.0027316972,
-0.3534615636,
0.5651218891,
0.2859253585,
0.1822982877,
-0.1899227947,
-0.4729771912,
-0.1683544666,
-0.6631091833,
-0.0930903703,
0.1349290758,
-0.0655350387,
0.3724412918,
0.7842838168,
-0.233877793,
0.8238499165,
-0.2690294385,
-0.3471519053,
0.1344347894,
-0.0834811181,
-0.2188985348,
-0.2797473967,
0.5910238624,
0.0242131781,
0.4401432872,
0.0231375191,
-0.3168489635,
0.270327419,
-0.0759732425,
-0.7061802149,
-0.2682727575,
-0.2503251433,
-0.0363986492,
0.2239005268,
-0.2291436195,
-0.4648806751,
-0.2498508245,
-0.322763145,
0.896681726,
-0.6075304151,
-0.1974183321,
0.2735826373,
-0.0815409422,
0.3846019804,
0.5570482016,
-0.6683456898,
0.3437602222,
0.6984032393,
0.3144563437,
-0.0732593611,
-0.01550774,
-0.4468766451,
0.2469244301,
-0.2243660986,
0.720023632,
-0.7065244913,
-0.1987567693,
-0.1124746278,
-0.2696567476,
-0.1353962421,
-0.5710206628,
0.1232537329,
-0.964030385,
0.0627350882,
-0.1808034778,
-1.1461775303,
-0.1166456118,
0.7047796249,
-0.2730698586,
0.7342970371,
-0.0316013806,
-0.5065483451,
0.1394654661,
-0.5395761132,
-0.2994062603,
0.4363388717,
-0.4780050516,
-0.2729820609,
-0.1475438327,
0.1965041757,
0.6829800606,
-0.1679771841,
0.3550709486,
-0.1459955126,
-0.2365533113,
0.374768883,
-0.3326533139,
0.2869439423,
0.0216521993,
-0.2286669463,
-0.1059757248,
-0.5642933846,
0.0931980833,
0.5013748407,
-0.3123987317,
-0.5290824175,
-0.0535208471,
-0.7912130356,
0.1479470283,
0.4672749043,
-0.4476989508,
0.5222920179,
-0.4386103153,
0.0261017177,
0.5547578335,
0.0580539331,
0.344486624,
-0.3994699419,
0.766895175,
-0.0411904529,
-0.1481010616,
-0.326195091,
-0.3936222196,
-0.7652534246,
-0.1299272329,
0.5630287528,
0.5762073398,
-1.1271377802,
0.2753568292,
-0.3043549955,
-0.3533658981,
-0.2955414653,
0.3220283091,
0.4236857593,
0.6845979691,
0.2947506905,
-0.1537388712,
-0.2136508524,
-0.980984211,
-0.2622541189,
-0.0722060204,
-0.2013343126,
0.3933828771,
0.6608915925,
-0.0072696842,
1.1055521965,
-0.8668065071,
-0.3789122999,
-0.2427232563,
0.2581813037,
0.0216440111,
0.4460814595,
0.316960156,
-0.7548124194,
-0.255859673,
-0.2501541376,
-0.6340675354,
-0.0004574783,
0.0792316943,
-0.133846432,
0.2042548507,
0.4297457039,
-0.5944253206,
0.4506786764,
0.0612151399,
-0.0875848681,
0.4814091921,
-0.1801072508,
-0.0769907236,
-1.0214931965,
-0.1257020235,
0.0561345145,
-0.4023709297,
-0.3259088993,
0.072438024,
0.0429326855,
-0.0110801132,
-0.3095043004,
0.6476093531,
-0.3159205616,
-0.1303530037,
-0.1417776346,
0.330501765,
-0.079192549,
0.5126697421,
0.1978438348,
0.4865188599,
0.3741171956,
-0.67060256,
0.7323966622,
0.2177642435,
-0.2794312537,
0.4007813632,
-0.495683372,
0.0910701454,
-0.1417749971,
0.2951441109,
-1.0054594278,
-0.1816480607,
0.2428781986,
-0.5502017736,
0.2721355855,
-0.3053839207,
-0.8687884808,
-0.4903243184,
-0.2193554342,
0.3912955821,
0.8228959441,
-0.3637627661,
0.6773803234,
0.3246900141,
-0.2022120208,
-0.4676806331,
-0.3179142773,
-0.2087281793,
-0.2043270767,
-0.3905988038,
0.2045536786,
-0.1698196977,
-0.2063211948,
0.0241760314,
-0.1488958895,
-0.0541222319,
0.3385207653,
0.0300715324,
0.4277514517,
-0.2053773403,
0.577606082,
0.134745717,
-0.2379891276,
0.3763403893,
-0.3719040453,
0.6962152719,
-0.052562654,
-0.8171049356,
-0.1680319011,
0.2238580287,
0.0260613188,
-0.4533770382,
0.5032168031,
0.3058888614,
-0.7724810839,
-0.2802729011,
-0.6679773331,
-0.1459593028,
-0.4731049836,
0.2048379034,
-0.4535911381,
-1.0618339777,
0.4425242543,
-0.5271267891,
0.0065618437,
0.4833884239,
0.3877693415,
-0.1246493682,
1.1227586269,
0.5136710405,
0.047141023,
0.3096941113,
-0.3872454166,
-0.0718514398,
-0.5386543274,
-0.3279751837,
-0.4519970715,
-0.1828210354,
-0.0747443885,
-0.6603651643,
0.3599272072,
0.2151406854,
-0.2631027102,
0.10232611,
-0.3637227118,
0.6161527038,
0.5070385337,
-0.1164476499,
0.4168856144,
0.1212874055,
-0.3366102576,
-0.2140315324,
-0.655005455,
-0.4860281646,
0.9457406998,
0.3051611483,
0.8765313029,
-0.0129157193,
0.8126679659,
-0.017267704,
0.3856377602,
-0.9619658589,
0.7865390778,
0.070833087,
-0.4892029762,
-0.3489498496,
-0.5253672004,
-0.6714992523,
0.090334408,
-0.1153693125,
-0.5254222155,
-0.3023229241,
0.1081360355,
-0.3967228532,
0.4257721305,
-0.5824257731,
0.6438512802,
-0.2280852199,
-0.0796001926,
-0.0222981721,
-0.470508188,
0.2436464429,
-0.1936304122,
0.0747573897,
-0.1067231894,
-0.141754806,
0.9983722568,
-0.4181244969,
0.7084185481,
-0.3563643992,
-0.2289420962,
0.3222049773,
0.2772860229,
0.3727114797,
0.0569968931,
0.2330160439,
-0.3588150442,
-0.1134965643,
-0.2524119914,
-0.9447512627,
0.5962668657,
-0.6317548156,
-0.8594443798,
-0.3477692604,
-0.6499295831,
-0.4675482512,
0.1886503398,
-0.2235464752,
0.4097765088,
0.2240234166,
-0.1247775629,
1.0955917835,
-0.214078024,
0.4185366631,
0.5698310733,
-0.3525960147,
-0.212636441,
1.1185272932,
0.1974563301,
0.1164281815,
0.5452510715,
0.1510692388,
-0.4969048798,
-0.459458828,
-0.424118191,
0.5038830042,
-0.8415359855,
-0.6788977385,
-0.7566751242,
-0.3692495823,
-0.4093003273,
-0.1165953204,
-0.1744095087,
-0.4666804075,
-0.1985809952,
-0.0092486795,
0.4639846087,
0.695554316,
0.1934726089,
0.2595389783,
-0.5555660129,
0.3868418634,
0.7712721229,
0.4907649755,
-0.0732120052,
-0.5414003134,
-0.0815670863,
0.0523684323,
-0.3065270185,
-0.7474216819,
0.2587442398,
-0.0936509371,
0.5835363269,
0.2389935404,
0.0784085616,
0.5774710178,
-0.4490154982,
0.5556332469,
0.1425841302,
-0.9701656103,
0.7067086697,
-0.193559587,
0.1834025234,
0.246366784,
0.8319523335,
-0.2413871884,
-0.1682596207,
-0.5976649523,
-0.596754849,
0.6791355014,
-0.1040049866,
0.1865355223,
-0.0381944105,
0.5440400839,
0.0644235387,
0.3292540908,
-0.4654170871,
-0.2696309686,
0.0053062318,
-0.3018015325,
-0.0156185953,
-0.0943235308,
-0.1772584468,
-0.3917502165,
0.7180142999,
-0.279602915,
0.3124025464,
0.1306793094,
-0.4034520984,
0.111801587,
0.3979913592,
0.5058896542,
0.6244267821,
0.0110875815,
0.0976140723,
0.398430109,
-0.1624737531,
0.1348328739,
0.5052518845,
-0.0205240231,
-0.1619544178,
0.169017598,
0.587597549,
0.0250970442,
-0.7586453557,
0.7073705196,
-0.0735134631,
-0.3377320766,
-0.4920817912,
0.1951472312,
0.2519592643,
0.2395491153,
0.4948807955,
-0.4285240769,
-0.1450755,
-0.1773095429,
0.1579679847,
0.753570497,
-0.1324652135,
-0.0661168098,
0.4056642354,
-0.0971860588,
-0.485973537,
0.4836433232,
-0.3772738576,
-0.8440051079,
0.8205086589,
0.7304984927,
0.2435986549,
-0.2297261804,
0.1603919268,
0.110976547,
0.1370179802,
0.0444957837,
0.2518930137,
-0.3405908346,
-0.8039181828,
-0.6378889084,
-0.6633396745,
-0.5865275264,
0.0288002603,
-0.5079314113,
0.2497537136,
-0.6312206388,
-0.0133146355,
-0.0273999795,
0.3250314593,
-0.7561047077,
0.3893098235,
0.4515309632,
1.0124876499,
-0.6727927327,
0.8317075372,
1.1100623608,
-0.2710691392,
-1.0363383293,
-0.3866012692,
-0.2959692776,
-0.8971341848,
0.7646859884,
-0.0002348712,
-0.0392792001,
0.2257499844,
-0.7002413273,
-0.8361821175,
1.1534079313,
0.2923396528,
-0.3746265173,
-0.1302596778,
0.2951305211,
0.4945753217,
-0.4459385276,
0.3462926745,
0.401058197,
0.2940976918,
0.40877527,
-0.7693466544,
0.071863465,
-0.1662468165,
-0.1445839107,
0.4191756546,
-0.3555108309,
0.6485717297,
-0.0186933,
0.0367097221,
-0.0261653829,
0.7990874052,
0.3311748505,
0.3478115499,
0.553620398,
0.7217710018,
0.6479273438,
-0.1469851434,
0.8524644971,
0.0997680053,
0.4119668901,
0.8731396794,
-0.326084882,
0.7749489546,
0.2862665653,
-0.2655336857,
0.5227902532,
0.3298810422,
-0.1328276992,
0.0558936447,
0.6760934591,
-0.2032107115,
-0.7311878204,
-0.1658516228,
-0.4592041969,
0.4239756763,
0.6937506199,
-0.0913004428,
-0.4343428314,
0.1133015379,
-0.0168014709,
0.1005867645,
-0.4509194195,
0.882252574,
-0.0371955074,
-0.6275205612,
0.4386845529,
-0.0019525831,
0.8304389715,
-0.8883576989,
-0.3340645432,
-0.1949326098,
0.0328079425,
0.0927382261,
-0.8074324131,
0.1603648663,
-0.0630136952,
0.0090099284,
-0.2003585994,
1.0261316299,
-0.4098707736,
-0.4873508215,
0.0738371909,
0.7020637989,
0.3180283904,
0.1078540906,
-0.5314984918,
-0.1495885849,
-0.3127791882,
-0.0772255808,
0.4198164046,
0.4098507762,
-0.0904919282,
0.8611388803,
0.4905920923,
-0.1143661886,
0.201866433,
-0.0175492577,
1.0797584057,
-0.7369008064,
-0.2244274914,
-0.7244598269,
0.2164224088,
0.0186612532,
0.069949761,
0.8276071548,
0.450191468,
0.9668042064,
0.0523208342,
0.6244775057,
0.1619013995,
0.6625776291,
-0.3538583815,
0.6041405797,
-0.5693840384,
0.2760205567,
-0.2603304386,
-0.7553510666,
-0.4636420608,
0.5892267227,
-0.5539819002,
0.0776148885,
0.498049885,
0.3648249209,
0.0104074348,
-0.0916108564,
0.381991446,
-0.0787369683,
0.3004224896,
0.9172372818,
1.0879627466,
-0.1634474397,
0.7442656159,
-0.2701201141,
-0.2016065866,
-0.0708067641,
-0.7696439624,
-1.0376033783,
-0.5196729302,
-0.4686735272,
-0.0927307308,
-0.2078021765,
0.9808664918,
0.3453487158,
-0.5335161686,
0.0478090867,
0.2670566738,
0.3413199186,
0.262349695,
-0.2281941473,
0.3642012775,
-0.3064222634,
-0.5857591629,
0.0776435062,
0.0497899055,
0.272342205,
-0.2882299721,
0.303463906,
-0.2340155095,
0.058947552,
0.3965143263,
0.2408049852,
-0.4299632609,
-0.2993258238,
0.09469717,
-0.0579492599,
-0.1357459128,
0.8335311413,
-1.3083868027,
0.1905951947,
0.3299556375,
1.0574098825,
0.4349389076,
-0.0369754359,
0.2220202982,
-0.6762797236,
-0.2545244694,
0.4421228468,
0.3583284914,
0.340523988,
-0.1216039956,
0.1639542431,
0.3793160021,
-0.387349844,
-0.7399213314,
0.3533574343,
-0.6694868803,
-0.138769269,
1.0566880703,
-0.4793027937,
-0.2538320124,
-0.0963127464,
0.0013053092,
0.3616591096,
-0.1050900519,
0.5172663927,
0.7746809721,
-0.1087458506,
0.0957063213,
-0.3653108478,
0.2838546038,
0.6898528934,
-0.7569678426,
-0.2135284692,
0.4240093827,
0.4809854627,
0.2958514392,
0.5183978081,
-0.0381339975,
0.114078626,
-0.3393501639,
0.1138323694,
-0.2384316921,
-0.2036474645,
-0.4317449033,
0.355799228,
0.0493417569,
-0.2059548944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13862v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13862v1 | Knowledge Graph-Enhanced Large Language Models via Path Selection | 2024-06-19T21:45:20 | 2024-06-19T21:45:20 | Haochen Liu, Song Wang, Yaochen Zhu, Yushun Dong, Jundong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown unprecedented performance in various
real-world applications. However, they are known to generate factually
inaccurate outputs, a.k.a. the hallucination problem. In recent years,
incorporating external knowledge extracted from Knowledge Graphs (KGs) has
become a promising strategy to improve the factual accuracy of LLM-generated
outputs. Nevertheless, most existing explorations rely on LLMs themselves to
perform KG knowledge extraction, which is highly inflexible as LLMs can only
provide binary judgment on whether a certain knowledge (e.g., a knowledge path
in KG) should be used. In addition, LLMs tend to pick only knowledge with
direct semantic relationship with the input text, while potentially useful
knowledge with indirect semantics can be ignored. In this work, we propose a
principled framework KELP with three stages to handle the above problems.
Specifically, KELP is able to achieve finer granularity of flexible knowledge
extraction by generating scores for knowledge paths with input texts via latent
semantic matching. Meanwhile, knowledge paths with indirect semantic
relationships with the input text can also be considered via trained encoding
between the selected paths in KG and the input text. Experiments on real-world
datasets validate the effectiveness of KELP. | [
-0.1508862674,
-1.0474563837,
1.0918911695,
0.1121120453,
-0.2360323668,
-0.0951278582,
-0.4406741261,
-0.6922018528,
0.3106188476,
0.6616436243,
-0.3275859356,
-0.5690308213,
-0.6448844075,
0.1056929976,
-0.1182262897,
0.7411062717,
0.0162882395,
0.0426397249,
-0.2723526359,
0.0253832713,
-0.4720855951,
-0.2371158451,
-0.6848473549,
-0.6112929583,
0.8195638657,
0.3079864383,
0.6476281881,
0.4945872724,
0.4107773602,
0.2193883359,
-0.1958295554,
0.3537983,
-0.3939124048,
0.596652329,
-0.1125363857,
-0.2027223855,
-0.3236093521,
-0.2411253601,
0.7189980745,
0.9810349345,
0.1439980865,
-0.0511495955,
0.106747061,
0.5937469602,
-0.4291844964,
0.4000639021,
-0.8306037784,
0.1812388599,
-0.134020254,
-0.0275882203,
-0.4497420192,
-0.4602976441,
0.139779821,
-0.4826393723,
-0.273293227,
-0.03313848,
0.6002737284,
0.1243619174,
-0.4406134188,
-0.6779481173,
-0.7120188475,
0.4217378795,
-0.6925492883,
0.9146424532,
0.5628479719,
0.5352237225,
-0.3537450135,
-0.8650900722,
-0.6595756412,
-0.3609076142,
-0.2699116766,
-0.0769649222,
0.1819171607,
0.0891879946,
0.160606578,
0.0509931222,
-0.39539814,
0.2096973211,
-0.2861864269,
-0.3291642368,
0.436694026,
0.0653213337,
0.1033314914,
-0.410574317,
-0.0743499249,
-0.2157611549,
-0.7294288874,
-0.1564945728,
0.4344457984,
0.6721745729,
0.2759577334,
0.8073848486,
-0.3054341674,
0.8230865002,
-0.076084733,
-0.4949360192,
0.2813030481,
-0.0094991121,
-0.0520894714,
0.1529567242,
0.8877666593,
0.1735908091,
0.1074292734,
-0.7349840999,
-0.1946296692,
-0.0928608775,
0.0994555578,
-0.7496709228,
-0.25305444,
0.26669994,
-0.2601602376,
-0.2824116945,
-0.2407511026,
-0.9741518497,
-0.6203116775,
-0.1565485597,
0.5065702796,
-0.7079513669,
-0.2015355527,
0.0463857725,
-0.1037993729,
0.1358436495,
0.3603179157,
-0.7536345124,
0.2380992323,
0.5244617462,
0.9262969494,
-0.2005776167,
-0.1749851704,
-0.6272912025,
0.6080824733,
-0.2003738582,
0.5650157332,
-1.0360152721,
-0.3803533018,
-0.1022348553,
-0.271874845,
-0.0724997595,
-0.3973571956,
0.597992301,
-0.8101536632,
0.2601479888,
-0.482096076,
-0.7347183824,
-0.4499930739,
0.3776989877,
-0.6177004576,
0.9964485765,
0.0629294142,
-0.7354012132,
0.3730098605,
-0.6811363101,
-0.6854063869,
0.0422333181,
-0.2880245745,
-0.0893826112,
-0.2083540708,
0.254394114,
0.7088673115,
-0.1045102924,
0.489045769,
-0.4253328443,
-0.2135714591,
-0.3910917044,
-0.3361841142,
0.694141686,
0.1470417529,
-0.3903836608,
0.0437635109,
-0.8836797476,
0.0109489812,
0.0541005619,
-0.6226742864,
-0.463177681,
0.1036318094,
-0.2977915108,
0.3512308002,
0.1053261533,
-0.3922686875,
0.3072420359,
-0.3433804214,
0.1767505258,
1.008915782,
0.0539346188,
0.4342299402,
-0.053106539,
0.372679323,
-0.1772878021,
-0.190637365,
0.2428510934,
-0.5609481931,
-0.7751842737,
-0.1674650759,
0.1610297263,
0.3388291597,
-0.8341177106,
0.6686189771,
-0.5234037042,
-0.6016892195,
-0.2213235646,
0.2110034823,
0.089716211,
0.7948593497,
0.3027637005,
-0.0122043407,
-0.2921046317,
-0.4467633665,
-0.0694362298,
-0.3993809819,
0.0781316012,
0.679213047,
0.3350118399,
-0.3787302077,
0.8377110362,
-0.6380557418,
-0.408728987,
-0.3208016455,
-0.2559975982,
0.2653066814,
0.2000856996,
0.1518218219,
-0.7623602748,
-0.4443156123,
0.2035952359,
-0.8366517425,
0.003749463,
0.0821425915,
-0.2793646753,
-0.0300250202,
0.5592479706,
-0.8187516332,
0.0277615804,
0.4166454971,
-0.3838711083,
0.6154559255,
-0.1640844792,
-0.0410147198,
-0.9841373563,
0.1734579504,
-0.1104384586,
-0.349988848,
-0.4030522406,
0.0590358265,
-0.2424265444,
0.1450196952,
-0.0641404316,
0.7184128165,
-0.0523751751,
-0.1928889602,
0.0152868461,
0.3126829565,
-0.0826967657,
0.5353435874,
0.3495855331,
0.1915706098,
0.388638407,
-0.7797150016,
0.5115277767,
0.3084217608,
-0.3343506455,
0.1411704719,
-0.321847707,
0.511197865,
-0.1353229433,
0.2969923019,
-0.7725239992,
-0.3266952336,
0.4712005258,
-0.187014848,
0.1933650374,
-0.0133939339,
-0.7064009905,
-0.2200341225,
-0.0330607928,
0.0578366183,
0.528385222,
-0.6147199273,
1.0169734955,
0.3479710519,
-0.0340034142,
-0.4493306875,
-0.3281128109,
-0.0051825116,
-0.2932370305,
-0.6108857393,
0.1910179257,
-0.07907179,
-0.1692607701,
0.0676551983,
-0.1049708128,
0.138029322,
-0.0542691089,
0.2270713001,
-0.009470175,
-0.0430264883,
0.2192595154,
0.1319872737,
0.0459137373,
0.1322902888,
-0.4807583392,
0.788841188,
0.200007081,
-0.5187577009,
0.0030406206,
-0.0104876328,
0.6322878599,
0.1020522192,
0.707533896,
0.7445288301,
-0.5017144084,
-0.2386642694,
-0.556918025,
-0.2783379853,
-0.477507174,
0.5117670298,
-0.5078376532,
-0.969383359,
0.4680181742,
-0.2377395779,
-0.0461217202,
0.3230685592,
0.3904196918,
0.0904965401,
0.7417830229,
0.4643698633,
-0.0695060045,
0.1315808296,
-0.0759840533,
0.4634441435,
-0.8650889397,
-0.6899057627,
-0.3721146584,
-0.1098199636,
-0.4920656681,
-0.2758653462,
0.4785089195,
0.1822225451,
-0.1403221786,
0.2325465977,
-0.1670763195,
0.3893051445,
0.3784663677,
0.3160345852,
0.3187537193,
0.1144805998,
-0.7052358985,
-0.0226182081,
-0.8718560338,
-0.5142062902,
1.0167561769,
0.3341239095,
0.5179466009,
0.1341128349,
0.5590626597,
0.1580565721,
-0.0450324081,
-0.8513124585,
0.8862167001,
-0.0622625351,
-0.3701869845,
-0.6952391267,
-0.6618115902,
-0.7084047794,
0.3034871817,
-0.341188103,
-1.0650035143,
-0.175809741,
0.0726849139,
-0.262770921,
0.534663558,
-0.5049034953,
0.6416423917,
-0.2264735997,
-0.4995489419,
-0.0860845223,
-0.6646636724,
0.3568909466,
-0.3583934903,
0.2925490439,
0.0752562881,
0.332821846,
0.7515819073,
-0.2488981187,
0.8515326381,
-0.3219884634,
-0.2709885538,
-0.0333763137,
0.4056270421,
1.053612113,
-0.0181389917,
-0.247162655,
0.0376137011,
-0.2796453536,
0.0611242615,
-0.7473654747,
0.6146444082,
-0.5336902738,
-0.7526005507,
-0.2166384161,
-0.6419327855,
-0.6687958241,
0.4493683279,
0.0176406689,
0.2664460242,
0.0941514149,
0.0873560086,
0.4360097051,
-0.4008971155,
0.3399338722,
0.2433481365,
-0.6088701487,
-0.3108051121,
0.9299635291,
0.2416074425,
0.259258002,
0.3833591938,
0.3952122927,
-0.5610509515,
-0.6115352511,
-0.1435158551,
0.1816957444,
-1.0494059324,
0.0191340633,
-0.9598437548,
-0.3384709656,
-0.6614454985,
-0.0453615598,
-0.1459952295,
-0.3138455451,
-0.0058749435,
-0.2758561373,
0.3722263277,
0.9182060957,
-0.190023452,
0.0137578035,
-0.7403939962,
0.3377946317,
0.4578009546,
0.3579666615,
0.289478898,
-0.3365499675,
-0.0678995326,
-0.0720718428,
-0.0231269263,
-0.6918732524,
0.2265679091,
-0.0076376325,
0.6095778346,
0.5419496298,
-0.0776707977,
0.8864202499,
-0.6204504967,
0.6144336462,
0.1846297681,
-0.7165224552,
0.4994300604,
-0.3287824988,
0.1327552795,
0.4352597296,
0.506513238,
-0.650372982,
-0.3989709318,
-0.5215621591,
-0.8432326913,
0.5232523084,
0.3300823569,
0.0349195674,
0.0360033922,
0.4640858769,
0.3778226376,
0.1473332644,
-0.979688704,
-0.0206881594,
0.1176076457,
-0.2467066646,
0.046553731,
-0.2166468501,
0.1180334091,
-0.4249998927,
0.8896376491,
-0.0606917627,
0.0681223348,
0.1253774315,
-0.118083857,
-0.0476600155,
-0.1391102374,
0.0258386284,
0.6768972278,
-0.3263311982,
0.4852389395,
0.1985791177,
-0.6112840772,
-0.0108332317,
-0.0730182305,
-0.3042640686,
0.0032815738,
0.6275180578,
0.7160284519,
-0.019920174,
-0.6163048744,
0.2663417459,
0.3005402386,
0.0503575392,
-0.2218998373,
0.2728053331,
0.137400642,
0.4957651198,
0.0917613208,
-0.0377452672,
0.0082277544,
-0.3918613791,
0.2046303749,
0.5244966149,
-0.5571115017,
-0.1807949841,
0.4644263983,
0.0770974308,
-0.327965349,
0.7868278623,
-0.4291663468,
-0.6044160128,
0.0946333408,
0.6079677939,
0.616358757,
-0.0276053697,
0.2127979398,
0.3240877092,
0.2459800541,
-0.0181450155,
-0.0014439577,
-0.0484799184,
-1.0011464357,
-0.4088867903,
-1.0075991154,
-0.0911162421,
0.5157510638,
-0.2242099494,
0.4620777369,
-0.2756110728,
0.0573139749,
-0.130829215,
-0.0587628335,
-0.5597405434,
0.1622662544,
0.1225437894,
0.9060856104,
-0.862706542,
0.9808144569,
0.5094495416,
-0.3167701364,
-0.9782605767,
0.155240804,
-0.3263893425,
-0.7011142373,
0.7559335232,
0.0735655278,
-0.0958587974,
0.1171577349,
-0.2679882348,
-0.8414526582,
1.2560999393,
0.5466643572,
-0.5708682537,
-0.3278599381,
0.3587901592,
0.2135922164,
-0.3477020264,
0.0873698071,
0.4635818303,
0.6106099486,
0.6099382639,
-0.759157896,
0.3102241158,
0.0869816765,
-0.1874544322,
-0.0264646467,
-0.4753709137,
0.4664744735,
-0.0762364417,
0.0239681434,
-0.2222997695,
0.4309429228,
0.5198487043,
0.052643925,
0.7477913499,
0.5914400816,
1.0363770723,
0.1839234829,
0.8753053546,
-0.1667279154,
0.0711479336,
1.2407341003,
-0.4551185668,
0.7822036147,
0.5987176299,
-0.1278246939,
0.5327867866,
0.7212772965,
0.116206266,
0.8219464421,
0.1163373142,
-0.1455904245,
-0.4088229239,
-0.1203933656,
-0.1728904545,
0.474354744,
0.3091096282,
-0.4290250838,
-0.2340817302,
-0.190295577,
0.2309361398,
-0.2013920397,
-0.1812550426,
0.696282506,
0.0582719743,
-0.5393880606,
0.1167847663,
-0.1098267585,
0.3682495356,
-0.8876639605,
-0.3488788307,
-0.0375972874,
-0.1454024017,
-0.1714331955,
-0.6199812293,
0.1318974495,
-0.1358065307,
0.0417829566,
-0.0119991815,
1.1463233232,
-0.3350349069,
-0.6861084104,
0.6457014084,
0.6282414794,
0.2354109138,
-0.0497142598,
-0.2458049655,
-0.0161179472,
-0.0109747993,
-0.3032358587,
0.0984554142,
0.5760408044,
0.0362186655,
0.681781292,
0.7313592434,
0.3862363696,
-0.0303215347,
0.1407068968,
0.9829092622,
-0.5554482937,
-0.5575976968,
-1.0781093836,
0.3079256415,
-0.2116427571,
0.0205852557,
0.7943220139,
0.5713862181,
0.7117769718,
0.2275631428,
0.8974209428,
-0.1929485798,
0.1058713719,
-0.8966249228,
0.8140462637,
-0.3212035596,
0.403095156,
-0.5458757281,
-1.2417778969,
-0.2437087148,
0.6876656413,
-0.4535074532,
0.165328607,
0.7881342173,
0.7104606032,
-0.1723830402,
-0.0524911024,
0.320750773,
0.3813439906,
0.2952861488,
0.5374537706,
0.6770712733,
-0.0171457827,
0.4918483794,
-0.1465880275,
0.0780393705,
0.0361408703,
-1.0121046305,
-1.0151162148,
-0.7068296671,
-0.150546819,
-0.5381795764,
0.0474211127,
0.7823508978,
0.6430178881,
-0.5114218593,
-0.1071096808,
-0.3524180055,
0.4093492329,
0.0621787384,
-0.2247061729,
0.637229681,
-0.3742892146,
-0.4670493305,
0.4954076707,
0.2462420911,
0.0719074532,
-0.3674236238,
-0.3472425044,
-0.1785632968,
-0.1727761477,
0.7178287506,
-0.2775881886,
-0.6620830894,
-0.7003142238,
-0.0262501389,
0.1367988437,
-0.0139920823,
0.4815898836,
-0.9024268985,
0.4529761076,
0.3659584522,
0.6603502631,
0.6555697322,
-0.5700479746,
0.6303314567,
-0.6846233606,
-0.0415171236,
0.2645434439,
0.4106095731,
0.3620786667,
-0.4686032534,
0.6842995882,
0.3590684533,
-0.1651595086,
-0.7915406823,
0.2300370783,
-0.7055740356,
-0.3980495334,
1.7012033463,
-0.0845261067,
-0.1896453947,
-0.0047034919,
-0.052263733,
0.3664948046,
-0.0983872339,
0.888923645,
0.9593550563,
-0.1481953412,
0.2079715431,
-0.5481643081,
0.5254384279,
-0.0356818773,
-0.7544833422,
0.0021675352,
0.557731986,
0.1868302524,
0.327054143,
0.6063477397,
-0.0671525896,
-0.3262403607,
-0.0651180744,
-0.1968359947,
-0.1491793096,
-0.4710378945,
0.0157173034,
0.4266123474,
0.1995892823,
0.1842019558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15507v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15507v1 | Few-shot Knowledge Graph Relational Reasoning via Subgraph Adaptation | 2024-06-19T21:40:35 | 2024-06-19T21:40:35 | Haochen Liu, Song Wang, Chen Chen, Jundong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Few-shot Knowledge Graph (KG) Relational Reasoning aims to predict unseen
triplets (i.e., query triplets) for rare relations in KGs, given only several
triplets of these relations as references (i.e., support triplets). This task
has gained significant traction due to the widespread use of knowledge graphs
in various natural language processing applications. Previous approaches have
utilized meta-training methods and manually constructed meta-relation sets to
tackle this task. Recent efforts have focused on edge-mask-based methods, which
exploit the structure of the contextualized graphs of target triplets (i.e., a
subgraph containing relevant triplets in the KG). However, existing
edge-mask-based methods have limitations in extracting insufficient information
from KG and are highly influenced by spurious information in KG. To overcome
these challenges, we propose SAFER (Subgraph Adaptation for Few-shot Relational
Reasoning), a novel approach that effectively adapts the information in
contextualized graphs to various subgraphs generated from support and query
triplets to perform the prediction. Specifically, SAFER enables the extraction
of more comprehensive information from support triplets while minimizing the
impact of spurious information when predicting query triplets. Experimental
results on three prevalent datasets demonstrate the superiority of our proposed
framework SAFER. | [
-0.2758933008,
-0.8132041097,
0.4635618925,
-0.2227826118,
-0.2138327658,
-0.0543986633,
0.2894588113,
-0.3333411217,
-0.026460737,
0.5721014738,
-0.725777626,
-0.6953075528,
-0.4468075931,
0.1086831763,
0.2880949676,
1.0666013956,
0.0762631968,
-0.2843859494,
-0.1920981705,
-0.1008440107,
-0.5139131546,
-0.2741073966,
-0.5272917747,
-0.311331749,
0.4323454499,
0.646217227,
0.8023582101,
0.4734531939,
0.5165904164,
0.0871941075,
0.0564087145,
0.2766282856,
-0.6938243508,
0.0698192269,
-0.2352766842,
-0.3175588548,
-0.6198223233,
-0.2380830497,
0.4870243371,
0.7577541471,
0.2213329226,
-0.1061944738,
0.0719193518,
0.9909766316,
-0.9960001111,
0.4901587963,
-0.8378302455,
0.1597091109,
-0.3005885184,
-0.2428609133,
-0.621925354,
-0.2930530608,
-0.0343174152,
-0.9348509908,
-0.2647595704,
0.1783010066,
0.3854395151,
0.2689557374,
-0.4982990026,
0.2622646093,
-0.5348135829,
0.3690918386,
-0.349824965,
0.3005241454,
0.7204672098,
0.7667152286,
-0.5695791841,
-0.6127933264,
-0.2132146508,
0.2073567212,
-0.4525700808,
0.2028421164,
-0.5044756532,
0.1568461359,
0.3075841367,
-0.3041390479,
-0.4244728088,
-0.0796318501,
-0.207615152,
-0.2899317145,
0.5504569411,
0.1884682029,
0.1693105847,
-0.5012061596,
-0.3431132734,
0.0987202749,
-0.8958493471,
-0.149298504,
0.1135886163,
0.6890745759,
0.0275760368,
0.4407801032,
-0.7075363398,
0.8064680696,
-0.0716123506,
-0.5855347514,
0.2198051512,
-0.4204957485,
-0.2366136163,
0.1325750202,
0.8532053828,
0.4797508717,
0.7487717867,
-0.1465466619,
0.2869224846,
-0.1706958413,
-0.1813067645,
-0.6382362247,
-0.5370850563,
-0.0641537085,
-0.248302862,
-0.3168319762,
-0.3528709114,
-0.7863109708,
-0.5553938746,
0.2585216463,
0.3227941096,
-0.7783476114,
-0.1028924435,
-0.1962485313,
-0.1109215617,
-0.0790949985,
0.2018497139,
-0.7850026488,
0.2327037007,
0.4839075506,
0.6380643845,
0.0980503857,
-0.3736199141,
-0.6188825965,
0.7980025411,
-0.3251956701,
0.9803111553,
-0.5350265503,
-0.1924841106,
-0.1643793732,
-0.1623378545,
-0.275180161,
-0.1518605202,
0.4427959025,
-0.6238211393,
-0.1489764601,
-0.2677603662,
-0.3163406849,
-0.2590437531,
0.4411218166,
-0.5629732013,
0.8102764487,
0.3103951514,
-1.1759240627,
0.6128283143,
-0.5816311836,
-0.5400204062,
0.1164984778,
0.0332419761,
-0.4150285125,
-0.5201331973,
0.7278615236,
0.4012257159,
0.1163417846,
-0.2287618667,
-0.8984666467,
-0.142165482,
-0.0506603755,
-0.0443729237,
0.8106837273,
-0.1066912413,
0.1240663454,
-0.2364282161,
-0.6951227188,
0.2602107525,
0.0231740288,
-0.0113658188,
-0.4690349996,
-0.1428107321,
-0.7453896403,
0.1873365492,
-0.3378865123,
-0.2962402701,
0.4204771519,
-0.3889975548,
0.0114838872,
0.6843857169,
0.5114994049,
0.6447982788,
-0.2451452464,
0.535082221,
0.2582193613,
0.3416852653,
-0.0847909003,
-0.7878190279,
-0.3828592896,
-0.2470618933,
0.3585747182,
0.7746658921,
-1.2551846504,
0.0303420704,
-0.5548124909,
-0.3423030376,
-0.0732088462,
0.2829503417,
0.4641803503,
0.703933239,
0.5795723796,
-0.02664016,
-0.6305297017,
-0.9211200476,
-0.6320631504,
-0.3305087686,
0.2204641104,
0.3607901037,
0.5330042839,
-0.1834179759,
1.3154697418,
-0.7510005236,
-0.6947675347,
-0.4928382635,
0.0189533848,
0.0250823386,
0.4890597761,
0.6791419983,
-0.5533665419,
-0.756059885,
-0.0418830439,
-0.747872889,
0.0501962416,
0.1236587316,
-0.4214723706,
0.1506779194,
0.4093099236,
-0.5049064159,
0.7231118083,
0.1438326389,
0.0189894699,
0.1976202875,
0.4680317938,
-0.2138054073,
-0.9729127288,
-0.3657185435,
-0.2677650154,
-0.5690814257,
-0.5304535627,
-0.2164976001,
-0.0654177368,
0.2240245491,
-0.5685155392,
0.5638248324,
-0.2882892489,
-0.1623436958,
-0.0313064978,
0.0826793388,
-0.0582511127,
0.4848189354,
-0.0229380317,
0.3646669686,
0.7275924683,
-0.5614699125,
0.4201007485,
0.3706676364,
-0.1119491234,
0.6303355694,
-0.0850816667,
0.4695204794,
-0.2088417411,
0.6707746983,
-0.6813307405,
-0.4177794158,
0.6699845195,
-0.5478583574,
0.2486827672,
-1.0787248611,
-0.4426648021,
-0.2894622684,
-0.3551554382,
0.3926229179,
0.3152825832,
-0.4740165174,
0.7718651891,
0.3856056631,
-0.0228970423,
-0.7864871025,
-0.6922840476,
-0.1214968488,
-0.0366911739,
-0.7636104822,
0.1297384202,
0.2206178159,
-0.1857242435,
0.4848685861,
-0.1661108136,
-0.1220144182,
0.1224457398,
0.3019877672,
0.0894989669,
-0.1660333127,
0.2388677001,
0.2718568742,
-0.7104265094,
-0.3570863008,
-0.4766872525,
0.0660168529,
-0.3069496751,
-0.2991725802,
-0.199391529,
0.2622536719,
0.2050789744,
0.3062530458,
0.9973108172,
0.5337301493,
-0.6126618385,
-0.2063051313,
-0.2123072147,
-0.2336620986,
-0.4171911478,
0.1590436399,
-0.5964438319,
-0.6562729478,
0.3113644123,
-0.1607129723,
-0.3470321298,
0.3856588304,
0.2181383669,
-0.1891255826,
1.037325263,
0.4966261089,
0.0552402884,
0.148819074,
-0.2164224684,
0.240056023,
-0.7839930654,
-0.2646464407,
-0.0929197446,
-0.2352134138,
-0.5941157341,
-0.0843394548,
0.8393750787,
0.3915118873,
-0.1248024553,
0.390448004,
-0.1622632742,
0.9659478664,
0.6494939923,
0.235180974,
0.4773103595,
-0.012563318,
-0.3536335826,
0.0745468736,
-1.0561878681,
-0.2077446133,
1.1070685387,
-0.1304552406,
0.7984089851,
0.2973293662,
0.8144199848,
0.0500106514,
0.3432843983,
-0.8074778318,
0.5790300369,
-0.0241282862,
-0.9690457582,
-0.3447001874,
-0.6689105034,
-0.8198936582,
0.285782367,
-0.4970606863,
-1.0847966671,
0.1177214906,
0.2116595358,
-0.5152171254,
0.3243240416,
-0.8415917754,
0.8643231392,
0.1905579865,
-0.4409508705,
0.3265872002,
-0.9401435256,
0.6196300983,
0.0037176311,
0.3705627918,
-0.2105905861,
0.309812665,
0.7208000422,
-0.312330544,
0.9988659024,
-0.244657293,
0.6366103888,
0.5394750834,
0.460334152,
0.7618929744,
0.1581783444,
-0.0686944127,
-0.0907506943,
0.2407484949,
-0.5082365274,
-0.7178714275,
0.3570648432,
-0.5442783237,
-0.6056010127,
-0.4139253497,
-0.6653552651,
-0.6451323032,
0.6786791682,
0.2602671385,
0.191699639,
0.0649750084,
0.1667553782,
0.2338926047,
0.073062472,
0.4945355356,
0.1511876881,
-0.2148610801,
-0.5749616623,
0.475243032,
0.2747709155,
0.2944137156,
0.5080888867,
0.563372314,
-0.2662833035,
-0.6188728809,
-0.4889143407,
-0.0572071224,
-1.1917945147,
-0.7658509016,
-0.8293052316,
-0.0980240107,
-0.792473793,
-0.1163643971,
-0.2692866921,
-0.7081739902,
-0.081863828,
-0.3673155904,
0.6968759894,
0.425201267,
-0.3617069423,
0.3548829257,
-1.0613241196,
0.4308553636,
0.7614957094,
0.313275516,
-0.3949848711,
-0.1637073308,
-0.0759250671,
-0.1797053069,
-0.15853104,
-1.0603163242,
0.0695796683,
0.2077541947,
0.5185473561,
0.2688623667,
0.5752907991,
0.7275131941,
-0.3256688416,
0.367421478,
0.0938626602,
-0.7576975226,
0.7418407798,
-0.5869129896,
-0.0647770017,
0.9575875401,
0.3872115612,
-0.1153182462,
0.1319889724,
-0.5531779528,
-0.565800488,
0.9841269255,
0.3440590203,
-0.2071147412,
0.1306667328,
0.3069721162,
-0.0043099667,
-0.1427544653,
-0.9405914545,
0.0109847477,
-0.1528935283,
-0.1315714419,
0.5447841883,
-0.2108938992,
-0.4730333984,
-0.2218280882,
0.8386618495,
-0.6968961358,
0.0087156454,
0.009914482,
-0.2360476404,
-0.191149652,
0.2964343131,
0.1074910983,
0.54514575,
-0.412891686,
0.4489966333,
0.5293602943,
-0.2911636531,
0.0087130433,
0.0078496328,
-0.2007644773,
-0.3352772295,
0.7399932742,
0.6403952837,
0.1099952608,
-0.0575572476,
0.7286638618,
0.2091149241,
0.0381315351,
0.0167115666,
0.2130318582,
0.11799936,
0.1936104298,
0.1120897382,
0.2300241441,
-0.0530996211,
-0.6347050071,
0.2337202728,
0.328404963,
-0.4659337401,
-0.0045027654,
0.2696864903,
0.0988222882,
-0.0159729384,
0.5091279149,
-0.5535837412,
-0.6140651107,
0.3640601039,
0.6136274338,
0.7429666519,
-0.014338362,
0.1313028634,
0.4584147334,
0.5453746319,
0.2191202492,
-0.0891810432,
0.1353301704,
-0.9908725023,
-0.2665516436,
-0.2901407778,
-0.3708577156,
-0.2044956237,
-0.2292836159,
0.3564023376,
-0.4830909669,
-0.0715095848,
-0.1077629998,
-0.2011912465,
-0.5036876202,
0.0702226534,
0.0033548297,
0.8287544847,
-0.9375276566,
0.9056837559,
0.4623787701,
-0.4126535356,
-0.7789269686,
-0.0648432299,
0.3109532893,
-0.9550501108,
0.7175269127,
-0.0293020979,
-0.283621639,
-0.023947686,
-0.440284878,
-0.9228050709,
1.1846404076,
0.4105068445,
-0.2011752129,
0.1385705173,
0.1352600306,
0.1627060026,
-0.3959153593,
0.227093488,
0.6644632816,
0.6130647063,
0.4938739538,
-0.7162547708,
0.2520718277,
0.0245807506,
-0.1744283885,
0.2019698471,
-0.4618209898,
0.5209214687,
-0.4754751921,
-0.2738237679,
-0.3681667447,
0.4631635845,
0.4899752438,
0.5738792419,
0.6170264482,
0.6758070588,
0.6946579814,
-0.0229668841,
1.1324762106,
0.1726806462,
0.3179457486,
1.3426992893,
-0.3683941066,
0.5577591658,
0.1935609728,
-0.2856277823,
0.6286255717,
0.4689935446,
0.3419445157,
0.8063514233,
-0.1266919225,
-0.0464277714,
-0.6028546095,
-0.0548649393,
-0.5000959039,
0.4684566259,
0.3897346854,
-0.1567775458,
-0.3336353898,
-0.3551037908,
0.2484339476,
-0.4079502523,
-0.2163045257,
0.9701883793,
0.184589237,
-0.5208956003,
0.4124127328,
-0.204444617,
0.0627147406,
-0.3951964974,
0.0116685387,
-0.1946553886,
0.0723207071,
-0.5784367323,
-0.7692632675,
0.4107563198,
-0.1669607908,
-0.1331182271,
0.089850083,
1.3599447012,
0.0246311147,
-0.6186699867,
0.293451339,
0.6098002791,
0.0004519117,
0.0707934797,
-0.6034880877,
-0.3892639577,
-0.1475375146,
-0.1586267799,
0.4028282166,
0.498403132,
-0.1766948551,
0.6933723092,
0.7083010674,
-0.2101466209,
0.1768376678,
0.0903012455,
1.0122146606,
-0.5153812766,
-0.5824689865,
-0.9814857841,
0.2754766941,
-0.047338292,
-0.0226312652,
0.6441127658,
0.3338015378,
0.5314221978,
0.1328999251,
0.9225826859,
0.0405451655,
0.3802189231,
-0.8084955215,
0.5269458294,
-0.1740559489,
0.2361850291,
-0.6708368063,
-0.8421725035,
-0.8279992342,
0.4270591736,
-0.6481366158,
0.1490467042,
0.9101420641,
0.7886107564,
-0.2977821529,
0.0862149373,
0.241635114,
0.2062135041,
0.1410013437,
0.9093994498,
0.8391901851,
-0.3863787353,
1.1559005976,
-0.5245671868,
-0.2829389572,
-0.3407037258,
-1.3608605862,
-0.9944607019,
-0.1231656671,
-0.4732565284,
-0.5521355271,
0.2230844945,
0.6660800576,
1.0038330555,
-0.6310667992,
0.586060226,
-0.2288487256,
0.7262265682,
-0.2186784297,
-0.2275656015,
0.460470885,
-0.0031429182,
-0.2353368551,
0.5326073766,
0.4224629402,
0.0607589036,
0.2712961733,
0.0828902498,
-0.2099130899,
-0.1539774537,
0.5204982162,
0.3435393274,
-0.29134354,
-0.6869030595,
-0.3853168786,
0.1379654109,
0.1214386895,
0.5598301888,
-1.1349080801,
0.4774308205,
0.8344838023,
0.4935385883,
0.5660536885,
-0.0426644981,
0.2525882423,
-1.0324062109,
0.1273636073,
0.3348455429,
0.317355901,
0.3933649063,
-0.4170046747,
0.9660946131,
0.6456694603,
-0.0884959176,
-0.7972174287,
0.6658401489,
-0.9345445037,
-0.3061229289,
1.4339916706,
-0.2893603146,
-0.2784768939,
-0.5113729239,
0.1348963529,
0.2828204036,
-0.2803239226,
0.3346234858,
0.5046557784,
-0.6472448707,
-0.3529619873,
-0.2671548426,
0.5454389453,
0.0292375013,
-0.8773897886,
0.0029570765,
0.2745039761,
0.3674976826,
0.1646985561,
1.007802844,
-0.0588417202,
0.2159862816,
0.1942088902,
-0.462177068,
-0.2706724405,
-0.5262083411,
0.2533603311,
0.3270379603,
-0.068272762,
-0.1854210347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13858v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13858v1 | Distributional reasoning in LLMs: Parallel reasoning processes in multi-hop reasoning | 2024-06-19T21:36:40 | 2024-06-19T21:36:40 | Yuval Shalev, Amir Feder, Ariel Goldstein | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown an impressive ability to perform
tasks believed to require thought processes. When the model does not document
an explicit thought process, it becomes difficult to understand the processes
occurring within its hidden layers and to determine if these processes can be
referred to as reasoning. We introduce a novel and interpretable analysis of
internal multi-hop reasoning processes in LLMs. We demonstrate that the
prediction process for compositional reasoning questions can be modeled using a
simple linear transformation between two semantic category spaces. We show that
during inference, the middle layers of the network generate highly
interpretable embeddings that represent a set of potential intermediate answers
for the multi-hop question. We use statistical analyses to show that a
corresponding subset of tokens is activated in the model's output, implying the
existence of parallel reasoning paths. These observations hold true even when
the model lacks the necessary knowledge to solve the task. Our findings can
help uncover the strategies that LLMs use to solve reasoning tasks, offering
insights into the types of thought processes that can emerge from artificial
intelligence. Finally, we also discuss the implication of cognitive modeling of
these results. | [
-0.3231316209,
-0.9583240747,
1.0793865919,
0.0883100405,
-0.0814069062,
0.0482566729,
-0.1918603629,
-0.3779011667,
0.1589626521,
0.7438402176,
-0.9089101553,
-0.3802772164,
-0.7161425352,
0.0711398497,
-0.4007993639,
0.5018580556,
-0.1816477925,
0.0805956051,
-0.5109490752,
-0.1022389755,
-0.6179586053,
-0.5360791683,
-0.5916400552,
-0.4584380984,
0.5955120921,
0.3192961216,
0.6961583495,
0.5868136883,
0.6593270898,
0.3361148238,
-0.1430666596,
0.1984006464,
-0.1604890972,
0.4823257029,
-0.1217792183,
-0.9768311977,
-0.1796628386,
-0.286593914,
0.6427435875,
1.060308814,
-0.0697834343,
0.1092348173,
-0.0855471417,
0.694956243,
-0.4017010927,
0.1320405453,
-0.6969440579,
0.108260937,
-0.3158963621,
-0.2637642324,
-0.5307070017,
-0.034668427,
-0.0120519027,
-0.3529727161,
0.0090279635,
0.106259793,
0.0467312448,
0.4133601487,
-0.5031819344,
-0.5280731916,
-0.8464184403,
0.7451604605,
-0.3613586426,
0.4106213748,
0.2770059109,
0.5408981442,
-0.2647958994,
-0.6913890243,
-0.5479719043,
-0.2545365095,
-0.0274969805,
-0.0332776681,
-0.0925251693,
0.0474568643,
0.2720282376,
0.0156291164,
-0.5116587281,
-0.0804477707,
-0.1405137181,
-0.044644624,
0.4464692473,
0.4524731338,
0.2560269237,
0.1397300214,
-0.4004671574,
0.0442052633,
-0.5891036391,
0.1140067652,
0.2323382348,
0.1709636003,
-0.029800402,
0.8254994154,
-0.1198448166,
0.5948178172,
-0.4251104295,
-0.0070915534,
0.0851285085,
-0.170742631,
-0.1625865847,
-0.1866664439,
0.5335040092,
-0.0347417742,
0.4410666525,
-0.1236214712,
-0.1648335606,
0.154202655,
0.091230765,
-0.4028253257,
-0.0934765413,
0.5294415951,
-0.5655736923,
-0.0807836652,
-0.146198526,
-0.3269044459,
-0.4734645188,
-0.4574681222,
0.1093721315,
-0.4346655905,
-0.2792457938,
0.3562976122,
-0.3501564562,
0.0146855535,
0.5678597093,
-0.6715785265,
0.2883618772,
0.8680058718,
0.7226150036,
-0.1370844692,
-0.6318386793,
-0.2052276582,
0.3570023775,
-0.3157776594,
1.1538975239,
-0.7618378401,
-0.0572141968,
-0.1236278415,
-0.1429966241,
-0.2886093855,
-0.6764099002,
0.4166951478,
-0.6496633887,
-0.2686697841,
-0.5022794008,
-0.8478865027,
0.0020636418,
0.4333928525,
-0.6140127182,
0.7106939554,
-0.383410871,
-0.8782106042,
0.1008449197,
-0.716686964,
-0.0784538165,
0.1028977185,
-0.2544570863,
0.1437964439,
0.0535837337,
0.2321195155,
0.5102970004,
-0.3630779088,
0.1548022479,
-0.7931376696,
-0.0860322192,
0.696698904,
-0.3642060459,
0.8388747573,
0.1788592488,
-0.0917119458,
0.1260102838,
-0.5604528189,
-0.0936975107,
0.1907869428,
-0.0768868849,
-0.293285042,
0.3693505228,
-0.6767739654,
0.1532105207,
0.1806049943,
-0.3640716374,
0.2720348537,
-0.0869184062,
0.4170591235,
0.9473827481,
0.0758939385,
0.6783742905,
-0.283388555,
0.472287178,
0.3545429409,
0.2665819824,
-0.2226298302,
-0.8881089687,
-0.7534283996,
-0.1406405419,
-0.2678717375,
0.5663517714,
-0.6182624102,
0.0670984909,
-0.0276328959,
-0.2175778896,
-0.3108671308,
0.0770334825,
-0.1152464822,
0.258474201,
0.2049843073,
0.1910268515,
-0.4555738568,
-0.7349834442,
-0.3644565344,
-0.0468796939,
0.2057452053,
0.2311826944,
0.6564122438,
-0.4143433273,
0.700843811,
-0.6208119392,
-0.0010560818,
-0.3586860299,
-0.0047752275,
0.2963230312,
0.1525091082,
0.0278856605,
-0.5464963913,
-0.1143055707,
-0.0987071097,
-1.1748930216,
-0.1292878687,
-0.2461504489,
-0.4737496674,
-0.3299680352,
0.7173290849,
-0.9337755442,
0.2427379936,
0.3520791531,
-0.2791537642,
0.7279353738,
-0.2002945244,
-0.3900863528,
-0.8286494017,
-0.4891281724,
0.0147349099,
-0.0123917731,
-0.5021415353,
0.1382192522,
-0.1816732138,
0.0754422694,
-0.0352731943,
0.4993896782,
-0.5532460809,
-0.4585338831,
-0.3628157973,
0.095599696,
0.0050549721,
0.2144616544,
0.0975748673,
0.5450463295,
0.6850159168,
-0.4274771214,
0.6456198096,
0.1432619691,
-0.328587234,
0.3677485287,
-0.4345918298,
0.0326343924,
-0.3795750439,
0.5976607203,
-1.0313287973,
-0.0605116785,
0.194312349,
-0.3191848695,
-0.2469903231,
-0.0888728872,
-0.6349171996,
-0.4276831448,
0.0804492384,
0.4658924639,
0.2718384266,
-0.4040291607,
0.4382111728,
0.2908198535,
0.0158815812,
-0.474837333,
-0.7662987113,
-0.071220763,
-0.2918337286,
-0.8219832778,
0.0010731211,
-0.2082895488,
-0.5809682608,
0.065236114,
0.1687796414,
-0.0749478862,
0.0515317544,
0.1523439288,
0.0978472158,
-0.3416194618,
0.3632948995,
0.1336350292,
-0.0244733654,
0.5131340623,
-0.5543600321,
0.4899084568,
-0.1503188163,
-0.8823218942,
-0.364944905,
0.456272006,
0.6979677677,
-0.1931489259,
0.8678477407,
0.3741591871,
-0.3663245142,
-0.6844450235,
-0.3270326853,
-0.3265101612,
-0.4130735993,
0.0814151987,
-0.7020232677,
-0.6993858814,
0.8255884647,
-0.4353355765,
-0.3103974164,
0.3176431656,
0.7741902471,
-0.3914257288,
1.0373305082,
0.2746160328,
0.475333482,
0.2637448311,
-0.4363016784,
0.275454402,
-0.7460757494,
-0.5622460842,
-0.3124137223,
-0.2638201714,
-0.5338438749,
-0.7804894447,
0.507637918,
0.2161635458,
-0.3331981003,
0.0136574367,
-0.2536787987,
0.5848904252,
0.6086201072,
0.1377322823,
0.31754601,
-0.1125360429,
-0.4445246756,
0.2392005324,
-0.5871990919,
-0.4954579771,
1.0199558735,
0.4518877268,
0.7010523081,
0.0564547367,
0.7741211653,
0.2136295587,
0.161871165,
-0.7123261094,
0.643699646,
0.029607676,
-0.5514535308,
-0.3670192957,
-0.4094111323,
-0.7886322737,
0.5207164288,
-0.0979747027,
-0.8710924387,
0.0577764437,
-0.1979946047,
-0.0795662329,
0.6017954946,
-0.6781414151,
0.6228621602,
-0.2594759762,
-0.0489142276,
-0.3469286561,
-0.6269311905,
0.5924352407,
0.068303749,
0.3612600863,
-0.3222684264,
0.1387462467,
0.472034514,
-0.3690832555,
0.9005604982,
-0.130369097,
-0.0040935553,
0.4777045548,
0.2362395823,
0.5419658422,
-0.0603910759,
-0.1041204184,
0.1859062612,
-0.000642431,
-0.3473384678,
-0.849121511,
0.4643402696,
-0.781058073,
-0.671397984,
-0.2420070618,
-0.8430102468,
-0.3508696258,
-0.0819232985,
-0.0888211355,
0.1708233804,
0.2346496433,
-0.0373947099,
0.5780752301,
-0.1263871193,
0.275216341,
-0.097457774,
-0.3056712151,
-0.1930779219,
0.4935522974,
0.0686955526,
0.2336536497,
0.582042098,
0.5161698461,
-0.5337677002,
-0.6304424405,
-0.4329288304,
0.4584145844,
-1.1674588919,
0.1422381699,
-0.6624201536,
-0.2321916223,
-0.232136786,
0.0342967622,
-0.2054886371,
-0.4308101237,
-0.2103884965,
-0.087441653,
-0.0393796153,
1.0578217506,
0.0858863592,
0.193623215,
-0.848809123,
0.1989284605,
0.3890407383,
0.0917943344,
0.2400631011,
-0.357480377,
-0.2025978118,
0.104739055,
-0.3086416423,
-1.0202791691,
0.1872496158,
-0.0744854063,
0.8333474994,
0.4828696549,
-0.1127726734,
0.5622664094,
-0.538325727,
0.6205278039,
0.09235847,
-0.7608302236,
0.5612276793,
-0.3128886521,
0.0523789413,
-0.0347754881,
0.4592767656,
-0.2965048552,
-0.4314779341,
-0.3939468563,
-0.4719027579,
0.4394506514,
0.1591941863,
-0.0078790896,
-0.1284067482,
0.2558805645,
0.1568387896,
0.027273003,
-0.7035290599,
-0.2299628705,
0.1000065207,
-0.0075388099,
0.0327449739,
-0.3164376318,
-0.2424428612,
-0.342554599,
0.2319030464,
-0.1519981623,
0.4650616944,
-0.0086566769,
0.0131679978,
0.0245890766,
0.1806579083,
0.5274907351,
0.7117244601,
-0.1386300623,
0.5446158051,
-0.0736172721,
0.0802040026,
0.1739008576,
-0.2003364861,
0.2302427441,
-0.248644188,
0.6181938648,
0.8189355135,
-0.1920435578,
-0.5545858741,
0.5056815743,
0.0138458572,
-0.1585384756,
-0.5259635448,
-0.0797841772,
0.4494522512,
0.8170455694,
0.2004235685,
0.2483986616,
0.2167340666,
-0.611266017,
0.0621084087,
0.4531153142,
-0.0174548663,
-0.4026581645,
0.6220458746,
-0.0553700477,
-0.2433884144,
0.7018697858,
-0.1235524863,
-0.4144558311,
0.6368803382,
0.7040790915,
0.93447119,
0.0295148399,
0.3516015708,
-0.0101806326,
0.4002685845,
-0.0501185246,
0.2639448047,
-0.2165098041,
-1.1828044653,
-0.6125623584,
-0.7007814646,
-0.4837302268,
-0.0610301606,
-0.316906631,
-0.0221533477,
-0.2919086814,
0.0145385023,
0.239636004,
-0.5901777744,
-0.548406601,
0.0114131458,
0.5497689843,
0.8439881802,
-1.0802642107,
0.8278520107,
0.7069485784,
-0.2453479618,
-0.6999952197,
0.1737091243,
-0.1393752396,
-1.0273638964,
0.9840320349,
0.1730657071,
-0.1932534426,
-0.2969802022,
-0.4482358396,
-0.9728630781,
0.9231073856,
0.5948878527,
-0.2167149037,
-0.1474001557,
0.5772809386,
0.4941240549,
-0.5707523227,
0.4442737997,
0.4841633141,
0.2536439598,
0.3716470301,
-0.548369348,
0.0597207695,
0.0362076946,
-0.0012820325,
0.0611549951,
-0.3866218925,
1.2592693567,
-0.3342046738,
0.0058685434,
-0.2339159399,
0.4522483647,
0.6643144488,
0.5544586778,
0.4787316024,
0.7345007658,
0.9014265537,
0.1281369925,
1.2087874413,
-0.0977629051,
0.1972577423,
0.8549932241,
-0.4673445821,
0.9137189388,
0.5554409623,
-0.3066244423,
0.9202378392,
0.5848997235,
0.4755548835,
0.4366922081,
0.2997020483,
-0.3953408897,
-0.5901458859,
0.0165760927,
-0.0444555208,
0.5459266305,
0.6061143279,
-0.2792187333,
-0.1084350049,
-0.007611929,
-0.4158686697,
-0.0984959826,
-0.2816127241,
0.6558475494,
0.3353823423,
-0.7373824716,
0.2917160392,
-0.1076330617,
0.2262788862,
-0.3140005767,
-0.0766283497,
-0.1582289189,
0.3417217731,
-0.1392936707,
-1.1648346186,
0.5704145432,
-0.2954663932,
-0.2422159314,
-0.4462261498,
0.7442981601,
-0.1624573767,
-0.541428864,
0.6156046391,
1.0224353075,
0.3594503701,
-0.2631125152,
-0.7807228565,
-0.129324019,
-0.1932471395,
-0.3380543292,
0.3029887378,
0.9255893826,
-0.3735093772,
0.9739394188,
0.8309233189,
0.2488133311,
0.5057590008,
0.4591950476,
0.7859358191,
-0.6379990578,
-0.5193211436,
-1.0400502682,
0.4044638574,
0.0319889784,
0.128322646,
0.5808885694,
0.2529986501,
0.7904314399,
-0.0068245097,
0.8377894163,
0.3710725009,
0.408446759,
-0.7063985467,
0.1953710467,
-0.4234871864,
0.5708292127,
0.0151783414,
-0.8096286058,
-0.2158181816,
0.3115208447,
-0.5272234082,
-0.1034659222,
1.1328678131,
0.6123890877,
-0.1434648335,
0.2902304828,
0.4829628766,
0.1179911792,
0.2124052942,
0.628534615,
1.396374464,
0.0147201875,
0.4167411029,
-0.3486213386,
-0.1024448574,
0.1461798549,
-0.7409006953,
-0.8401010633,
-0.6148641706,
-0.0345222428,
-0.1944153309,
-0.1661106199,
0.6638368368,
0.5959052444,
-0.629345119,
-0.4645970464,
-0.5417366624,
0.4310563207,
-0.2578935623,
-0.2150258571,
0.171052143,
-0.5404049754,
-0.3456067443,
0.4453779161,
0.3312530518,
-0.1556335539,
-0.3287975788,
-0.0095379194,
-0.1493326277,
0.2448667139,
0.6127416492,
-0.2814767659,
-0.960737288,
-0.0848633274,
0.0965998545,
0.1747877598,
0.0494545028,
1.0340139866,
-0.4868338704,
0.4106636941,
0.6512529254,
0.6546456814,
0.5546347499,
-0.083073549,
0.3027186692,
-0.6180492043,
0.1074329466,
0.2144900113,
0.6954257488,
0.1232240424,
-0.2723940015,
0.2297435701,
0.5063017607,
-0.6196971536,
-0.720207274,
0.6263654828,
-0.7957795858,
-0.5483242869,
1.3637892008,
-0.1280276626,
-0.2951381505,
-0.040218439,
0.0757309124,
0.1586262137,
0.0244531259,
0.4988639653,
0.6883838773,
-0.6719966531,
-0.4182798266,
-0.6586952806,
0.1522257775,
0.2712228298,
-0.9185965657,
0.0991098359,
0.3057002127,
0.1940301061,
0.0993344784,
0.829462111,
0.1597825289,
-0.1519459337,
0.181134522,
-0.1739633828,
0.1054081023,
-0.4311900437,
-0.1871767491,
0.3844571114,
0.1649098247,
-0.2762592733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13846v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13846v1 | Text Serialization and Their Relationship with the Conventional Paradigms of Tabular Machine Learning | 2024-06-19T21:19:37 | 2024-06-19T21:19:37 | Kyoka Ono, Simon A. Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent research has explored how Language Models (LMs) can be used for
feature representation and prediction in tabular machine learning tasks. This
involves employing text serialization and supervised fine-tuning (SFT)
techniques. Despite the simplicity of these techniques, significant gaps remain
in our understanding of the applicability and reliability of LMs in this
context. Our study assesses how emerging LM technologies compare with
traditional paradigms in tabular machine learning and evaluates the feasibility
of adopting similar approaches with these advanced technologies. At the data
level, we investigate various methods of data representation and curation of
serialized tabular data, exploring their impact on prediction performance. At
the classification level, we examine whether text serialization combined with
LMs enhances performance on tabular datasets (e.g. class imbalance,
distribution shift, biases, and high dimensionality), and assess whether this
method represents a state-of-the-art (SOTA) approach for addressing tabular
machine learning challenges. Our findings reveal current pre-trained models
should not replace conventional approaches. | [
-0.1800321788,
-1.049677968,
0.4781584144,
-0.072718814,
-0.1358523965,
0.2395131588,
-0.2457961589,
-0.560670495,
-0.010989476,
0.733479321,
-0.1485725045,
-0.5442580581,
-0.4681109488,
0.065648213,
-0.4580191374,
1.0913922787,
-0.1255649328,
0.2676351666,
-0.4836672843,
0.1184361577,
-0.6222143173,
-0.9325304031,
-0.4531008303,
-0.2255241722,
0.3424389064,
0.3644700646,
0.8224528432,
1.0375586748,
0.7885504961,
0.2555406094,
0.0994305387,
0.2248791307,
-0.284538269,
0.2522481382,
0.2111198306,
-0.6263859868,
-0.7227752805,
-0.0660461783,
0.6220051646,
0.8128554821,
-0.093539834,
0.2508945465,
0.1323240399,
0.6086333394,
-0.3171190023,
0.2788828313,
-0.8653154373,
0.3368760049,
-0.4191774726,
-0.5137856603,
-0.662553668,
-0.5020657182,
-0.0106610795,
-0.5198512077,
0.2592219412,
0.2093429118,
0.5722792149,
0.304359287,
-0.2198569775,
-0.2488488555,
-1.1084216833,
0.6769721508,
-0.5923776031,
0.5483025312,
0.4803108275,
0.390825063,
-0.1593732685,
-0.8760174513,
-0.2274883389,
-0.3122218549,
-0.3167963326,
-0.1894138157,
0.1605263203,
0.0934897438,
0.3314992189,
0.2379267812,
-0.772834897,
0.4947512448,
-0.4424847364,
0.1564759761,
0.4217975438,
0.4526839852,
0.2272914946,
0.0507529266,
-0.3421139419,
0.0283576921,
-0.5195040703,
0.362442106,
0.0347680673,
0.6305598617,
0.280924201,
0.2522473931,
-0.0111410823,
0.8845465183,
-0.0908057839,
-0.1730334908,
0.0380007923,
-0.2522608936,
-0.4496147037,
0.0129050035,
0.7818760276,
0.2217460722,
-0.0223666579,
-0.4268877208,
-0.2465732992,
0.0099716913,
0.5192747712,
-0.8821356893,
-0.0846784711,
0.1912889034,
-0.6599751115,
-0.4593415558,
0.1535399109,
-0.7835922241,
-0.553955853,
-0.4402084351,
0.469968766,
-0.1438540369,
0.0819264576,
-0.0560330488,
0.0564552918,
-0.2733574808,
0.3134422004,
-1.2273448706,
0.4167382717,
0.7493557334,
0.6183007956,
-0.3330608308,
-0.2149169743,
-0.3408513665,
-0.0164990462,
-0.5842966437,
0.7965233922,
-0.6844670177,
-0.2151433378,
0.1223169714,
0.0565110296,
-0.0122268088,
-0.7864615321,
0.5429803729,
-0.439374119,
-0.2793969214,
-0.041760914,
-0.5688868761,
-0.155298382,
0.1280614883,
-0.8362585306,
1.1025503874,
0.0389124602,
-0.6118118763,
0.8109098673,
-0.3307843804,
-0.4057292342,
0.1734113842,
-0.2883873284,
-1.0582374334,
0.096813783,
0.0247448962,
1.0212951899,
-0.2736038566,
0.4040234387,
-0.3862002194,
-0.5787513852,
0.3502036333,
-0.2073396891,
-0.0153737692,
0.3828381002,
-0.1106314063,
0.0717750862,
-0.888038516,
0.0350935571,
-0.0859163702,
-0.3600556254,
-0.0429913141,
0.321290493,
0.1900647432,
0.0158450995,
0.1961380094,
-0.2166957855,
0.3884239197,
-0.1453786939,
0.4391844273,
0.3798424602,
-0.2569466531,
0.6599036455,
-0.2625847757,
0.5765188336,
0.1919549555,
0.0609271079,
-0.2099623978,
-0.1597207338,
-0.3933372498,
-0.0147808837,
0.5206435323,
0.5864900947,
-0.48850739,
0.1209019274,
-0.3757187724,
-0.7207192779,
-0.2816416919,
0.0345897824,
0.1846508235,
0.2235365212,
0.5139439702,
-0.0387891829,
-0.9150399566,
-0.7647614479,
-0.3899465799,
0.1720110327,
0.2512248456,
0.1138604879,
0.2220063657,
-0.3310322464,
0.926225543,
-0.1273256689,
-0.2625677884,
-0.5281302333,
0.3287633359,
0.047750771,
0.5900924206,
0.4958645999,
-0.861174643,
-0.6251568794,
0.566806078,
-0.8525411487,
0.2968667746,
-0.1482408643,
0.4538638592,
0.5740751028,
0.6992791891,
-0.2178594917,
0.8641195297,
0.2486647516,
-0.1473187953,
0.4509699345,
-0.16456604,
0.3538145423,
-0.8634589314,
-0.0472083017,
-0.0939107686,
-0.2622591257,
-1.1794747114,
-0.199368909,
0.2210219055,
-0.2222280055,
-0.0953770652,
0.185046792,
-0.3259678781,
-0.2932676673,
-0.326441735,
-0.2206024826,
-0.1572041959,
0.1999206245,
0.2238011658,
0.849178791,
0.241395399,
-0.6135994792,
0.0012009816,
0.0054905848,
-0.2535895705,
0.098172076,
-0.4409728348,
-0.1644584388,
-0.2695080638,
0.1616584957,
-0.7964708805,
-0.0329976715,
-0.1882511377,
-0.6033970714,
0.5660195947,
-0.0004533656,
-0.4255863726,
-0.3447096944,
-0.2054280192,
0.2085145712,
0.3290267885,
-0.1352612376,
0.4819705188,
0.3709289134,
-0.0618183799,
-0.7468307018,
-0.7949182391,
-0.0862196088,
-0.3331188858,
-0.3124153018,
0.4230652452,
0.2753894925,
0.0433672704,
-0.136390999,
-0.0905135348,
-0.0883538574,
0.4200216532,
0.3961010277,
0.1792791486,
-0.2786764503,
0.3509736061,
-0.0687604696,
-0.1017772555,
-0.264554143,
-0.2720322907,
0.728800118,
-0.0733411163,
0.2017783523,
-0.4115416408,
0.0238145441,
0.3079942465,
-0.2781208456,
1.1537382603,
0.7978244424,
-0.6093099117,
-0.2942018807,
-0.4504841864,
-0.2197782397,
-0.410114795,
0.5388505459,
-0.5799268484,
-0.8737667799,
0.6049535871,
-0.0984873548,
-0.0136246784,
0.0660765022,
0.4150638282,
-0.3986757696,
0.9204534292,
0.7443333268,
-0.0061994591,
0.5566483736,
-0.3741351068,
0.415204376,
-0.3614042997,
-0.246838361,
-0.9281682968,
-0.3092740476,
-0.893394351,
-0.1693368405,
0.2244231701,
0.3515613377,
-0.11317911,
0.4192728698,
-0.3862502575,
0.2807698846,
0.3797850907,
0.026210729,
0.3504814506,
0.1852954328,
0.1683511585,
-0.1802862734,
-0.6860422492,
-0.8807849288,
1.2308135033,
0.5459174514,
0.6618667841,
-0.4116826057,
0.6682468057,
0.4610839784,
0.2396926582,
-0.593865633,
0.3643138111,
-0.5349373817,
-0.4135968387,
-0.4705415368,
-0.4813550115,
-1.1478234529,
0.102625221,
-0.5216680765,
-0.8805543184,
-0.0020752498,
0.2631552219,
-0.3396845758,
0.4285834432,
-0.668263793,
1.1378051043,
-0.0252574589,
-0.431384176,
0.1505082697,
-0.4215951562,
-0.0326274335,
-0.173182413,
0.3429302275,
0.2819286287,
0.1445688754,
0.8713054061,
-0.2698966563,
0.6261610985,
-0.1464767456,
0.0189849008,
0.1281161904,
0.1365238726,
0.3791738153,
-0.0546081513,
-0.1554789692,
-0.061555557,
0.462125361,
-0.176840052,
-0.8378533721,
0.4388890564,
-0.7414346337,
-0.446284771,
-0.1788791567,
-0.4692593813,
-0.3415222764,
0.0915633366,
0.1417968273,
0.6012199521,
-0.1304433048,
0.492523849,
0.6572640538,
-0.0708142519,
0.388671279,
0.1615505964,
-0.534011662,
-0.4196690619,
1.073521018,
0.6018502712,
-0.0019727091,
0.6862215996,
-0.0062093902,
-0.1222373694,
-0.9908134937,
-0.469863683,
-0.2621116042,
-0.4308767915,
-0.3656240106,
-0.6725320816,
-0.1760138124,
-0.4444912076,
-0.1120332554,
-0.1918441057,
-0.4572142959,
-0.4124133289,
-0.3072061241,
0.3440608978,
0.8564757705,
0.3964881897,
0.4828901887,
-0.8995741606,
0.2169262022,
-0.1199080423,
0.3626319766,
0.0256814267,
-0.3690253198,
-0.6580526233,
-0.0640301928,
-0.3629352748,
-0.818998158,
0.3288973868,
-0.0518699326,
0.3730235398,
0.1247801855,
-0.2850206792,
0.5718148351,
-0.6147940755,
0.7161231637,
-0.1719424427,
-0.508628428,
0.3611767888,
-0.4677137733,
-0.1091333404,
0.5581918359,
0.5392795205,
-0.4645293057,
-0.2055250108,
-0.311111778,
-0.4552180469,
0.7747759819,
-0.2588522136,
-0.2479296923,
0.3974773586,
0.3922664821,
0.6579984426,
0.4183601141,
-0.8803941607,
-0.2414236218,
-0.0584714524,
-0.4371406436,
-0.3165450096,
-0.1981537342,
0.5519903302,
-0.2455866039,
0.5014920831,
0.0032167444,
0.2568760812,
-0.1420750022,
-0.1879001707,
-0.0828359574,
0.4718703926,
0.5254148245,
0.712464869,
-0.3343206644,
0.0339392796,
-0.0220216755,
-0.6372116208,
0.1096297801,
0.1195646524,
-0.5095888972,
-0.0259699542,
0.0659588724,
1.1107960939,
0.1217603162,
-0.379253149,
0.0510875657,
0.1059167534,
-0.2145700008,
-0.134769544,
-0.1666404456,
-0.0392925404,
0.0934509113,
0.3589415848,
0.1574499607,
0.4421340823,
-0.7925129533,
0.1641250849,
0.5206341743,
-0.3815999627,
-0.1995422095,
0.6129582524,
-0.2549118102,
-0.404792726,
0.0466303974,
0.0661703199,
-0.4512259662,
0.5369175076,
0.5990651846,
0.4939445555,
-0.1359657049,
0.324931711,
0.2318073213,
0.3541887105,
-0.0741233006,
0.2138353884,
-0.1015818492,
-0.5266447663,
-0.1399229765,
-0.8726939559,
-0.2641058564,
0.2096865326,
-0.5805380344,
0.3341400325,
-0.4971165359,
-0.4597818553,
-0.1045168564,
0.2302892953,
-0.6470585465,
0.2250916064,
0.1859276891,
0.647090137,
-0.7078354955,
0.7896463275,
0.8231381774,
-0.3521257639,
-0.8108108044,
-0.3137346506,
-0.4833892584,
-0.2113268673,
0.5779739618,
0.2422295213,
0.2825834453,
-0.1061665863,
-0.1344283521,
-0.5892737508,
0.9858551025,
0.0937633514,
-0.5072898865,
-0.0680693239,
0.7715200186,
0.6856564283,
-0.189168945,
0.4143072665,
0.8943180442,
0.3329211771,
-0.4429780245,
-1.0994027853,
-0.1790794879,
-0.0191070177,
0.3897196352,
0.4289827049,
-0.3502798676,
0.798194766,
0.1743999869,
-0.1327510178,
-0.0023741592,
0.6978876591,
-0.012569597,
0.6847229004,
-0.1708588004,
0.5391596556,
0.6617843509,
-0.2888943255,
0.5901501179,
0.0469606034,
0.3046587706,
0.9736309648,
-0.2525947094,
1.0583767891,
0.4062584639,
-0.4493176937,
0.4125826061,
0.7019118667,
-0.0171656236,
0.315282464,
0.1884590983,
0.1888296455,
-0.0334584862,
0.0213028695,
-0.4412737787,
0.3745368421,
0.5295552015,
-0.4365755916,
-0.0387299471,
0.3500089049,
-0.1351179481,
0.5008180141,
-0.5903457403,
0.9903272986,
-0.157898888,
-0.4831202924,
0.5945082903,
0.0104594007,
0.7212538123,
-0.2029006481,
-0.020389339,
-0.0832102001,
0.2472306639,
-0.5054605603,
-0.4158385694,
0.103770189,
-0.097661145,
-0.3686782122,
-0.3431209922,
0.8605015874,
-0.4365890026,
-0.4870229065,
-0.1083037183,
0.5066201091,
0.0704119876,
0.2549577355,
-0.2824158669,
0.2608210742,
-0.1558197141,
-0.0265480187,
0.5358870029,
0.4482692778,
-0.2548341155,
0.7150090337,
0.3073621988,
0.1840754598,
0.3168006539,
-0.1089746505,
0.6087685227,
-0.5562211275,
-0.336795032,
-0.9436392188,
0.4093543589,
0.1770934761,
0.1044753417,
0.6091398597,
0.6818635464,
0.7983430028,
-0.4292494357,
0.70668751,
0.2983145118,
0.7885537744,
-0.7386823893,
0.7877013683,
-0.4585158527,
0.1131370813,
-0.3646192253,
-0.8794084787,
-0.4943131804,
0.3918532431,
-0.418530345,
0.0859537646,
0.737760365,
0.6356673241,
0.1252449751,
0.3682214916,
0.4074377418,
-0.0094315941,
0.1638716906,
0.0997675732,
0.8967701793,
-0.6322671175,
0.2782981992,
-0.2416478246,
-0.054057084,
-0.4079381227,
-0.5874353647,
-0.9441774487,
-0.8775166273,
0.0028453923,
0.112923272,
0.1951189041,
0.8362886906,
0.5505691767,
-0.8214831352,
-0.398809582,
-0.1184606254,
-0.1052228212,
-0.1894167513,
-0.2290105969,
0.3634293675,
-0.6342532039,
-0.5281797647,
0.0605002083,
0.1985499561,
0.2769452631,
-0.1201633662,
0.1380425841,
0.197005868,
-0.302582562,
0.6452661157,
0.1368265152,
-0.5227071643,
0.0232313164,
0.302429229,
-0.1790956706,
0.2499120682,
0.9350206852,
-0.9858001471,
0.1971808523,
0.4470556974,
0.9042323232,
0.4820678234,
0.1655140221,
0.4228805602,
-0.3908658028,
0.1726039648,
0.3415713608,
0.1607781202,
0.06835109,
-0.4974508882,
0.3153651655,
-0.0922639295,
-0.7815977335,
-1.2445870638,
-0.0780040324,
-0.7241217494,
-0.1812280267,
0.6712717414,
0.0553631112,
-0.173747018,
-0.0844449177,
-0.174115032,
0.2752475142,
-0.1860841066,
0.6453166008,
0.4475334287,
-0.1108546034,
-0.2101232558,
-0.7605380416,
0.9633266926,
0.3431240022,
-0.9928366542,
0.2217658162,
0.1718101501,
-0.2123215497,
0.0815373287,
0.404086411,
-0.07031174,
0.2873888612,
-0.141505897,
0.0550277345,
-0.1129031777,
-0.6192876697,
-0.266684711,
0.2172762007,
0.3130066395,
0.1233020127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13842v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13842v1 | Joint vs Sequential Speaker-Role Detection and Automatic Speech Recognition for Air-traffic Control | 2024-06-19T21:11:01 | 2024-06-19T21:11:01 | Alexander Blatt, Aravind Krishnan, Dietrich Klakow | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Utilizing air-traffic control (ATC) data for downstream natural-language
processing tasks requires preprocessing steps. Key steps are the transcription
of the data via automatic speech recognition (ASR) and speaker diarization,
respectively speaker role detection (SRD) to divide the transcripts into pilot
and air-traffic controller (ATCO) transcripts. While traditional approaches
take on these tasks separately, we propose a transformer-based joint ASR-SRD
system that solves both tasks jointly while relying on a standard ASR
architecture. We compare this joint system against two cascaded approaches for
ASR and SRD on multiple ATC datasets. Our study shows in which cases our joint
system can outperform the two traditional approaches and in which cases the
other architectures are preferable. We additionally evaluate how acoustic and
lexical differences influence all architectures and show how to overcome them
for our joint architecture. | [
-0.5239978433,
-0.4286299646,
0.3220109046,
0.15854761,
-0.279073745,
0.4341235757,
-0.0748460889,
-0.4678156078,
0.2288336456,
0.5087482929,
-0.2509469092,
-0.0925811455,
-0.6041451693,
0.1704471111,
-0.612134099,
0.4383458495,
-0.0101054776,
0.0703697056,
-0.2107697129,
-0.0407636799,
-0.5289902091,
-0.6918804646,
-0.9834264517,
-0.4635442793,
0.2171332389,
0.6113498807,
0.7820801735,
0.5378872156,
0.4981843531,
0.4170610309,
0.0199442189,
0.0163296759,
0.5153071284,
0.1850784868,
0.0317287855,
0.0476098843,
-0.3378480673,
-0.2448381037,
0.9077173471,
0.6920364499,
-0.4400041401,
-0.2589919865,
-0.2900324166,
0.5637280941,
-0.5451302528,
0.1398612112,
-0.3811557293,
-0.1629197448,
-0.5201935172,
-0.3004060686,
-0.3395614326,
0.1262857318,
0.0710957274,
-0.4629273713,
0.0606015995,
0.2013715357,
0.6123094559,
0.424954623,
-0.8019036055,
-0.2715595663,
-1.0422633886,
0.6365787387,
-0.3762843311,
1.0491398573,
0.1077119485,
0.5035956502,
-0.0223986022,
-0.392034471,
-0.834454,
-0.0060041542,
-0.3448945284,
0.2423824966,
-0.202395618,
0.0698596314,
0.065071553,
0.2823735178,
-0.812455833,
0.3658481836,
-0.5325863957,
-0.2209131867,
0.6721872687,
-0.0799077526,
0.3905102611,
-0.3163613975,
-0.4184314311,
-0.353733629,
-0.5846799612,
0.2934505939,
0.2862174511,
0.6261402369,
-0.0759144351,
0.1806453615,
-0.1603524536,
0.4676685929,
0.0007553031,
-0.039242845,
0.1875758618,
-0.1147145852,
-0.3834756613,
0.4980162084,
0.9248383045,
-0.3373576105,
0.1197732091,
-0.3892185986,
-0.4445384443,
0.2815704048,
0.5685010552,
-0.112822257,
-0.0472943746,
0.1893072724,
-0.5445124507,
-0.006022763,
0.5427528024,
-0.3511557579,
0.1481153518,
-0.79328686,
0.527957499,
-0.1166899949,
-0.4431799352,
0.099658154,
-0.1821823418,
0.5912853479,
0.2611324787,
-0.8100304604,
0.9554514289,
0.778085053,
0.7183557153,
-0.458073765,
-0.1456963271,
-0.7919901013,
0.2509959638,
-0.1983581483,
1.0706615448,
-0.5356881022,
-0.784815073,
-0.2880541682,
-0.0369286239,
-0.5141748786,
-0.7514358163,
0.5848484039,
-0.6639633775,
0.2545654476,
-0.075590983,
-0.1410251707,
0.0292719956,
-0.3435134888,
-0.7413783669,
0.6808939576,
-0.2791855037,
-0.5654158592,
0.3102432787,
-0.7131008506,
-0.7667589784,
-0.0019650611,
-0.7486530542,
-0.5340701938,
-0.123548992,
0.359805733,
0.1712684035,
-0.2070467472,
0.2917594314,
0.314440906,
-0.5768408775,
-0.0257034134,
-0.4457428455,
0.7822200656,
0.3570407629,
-0.1665555388,
0.2097834796,
-0.7036563754,
-0.2639582753,
-0.1786002219,
-0.5358576179,
-0.1885658503,
0.4705436528,
0.2619838417,
0.0972676501,
-0.1981041431,
-0.4535348713,
-0.1513098031,
-0.3190384507,
0.0899791345,
0.6119083166,
-0.1364537627,
0.4116219878,
-0.2459502518,
0.4684886038,
0.3649276495,
0.0127720693,
0.2214041054,
-0.4814839065,
-0.7186568379,
-0.0799729973,
0.0698343962,
0.9090976119,
-0.9111866355,
0.9384815097,
-0.3655429184,
-0.1594402492,
-0.3879141212,
-0.2777511477,
0.4562859535,
0.1918411404,
0.4521180391,
-0.6623240113,
-0.5800388455,
-0.776858151,
-0.2409116179,
-0.6037343144,
-0.1242329478,
0.0053442614,
0.0784692094,
0.10938254,
0.7874805331,
-0.1646140069,
-0.4658783972,
-0.2142539471,
0.1697007269,
-0.0123747187,
0.6546033025,
0.239624083,
-1.1422848701,
-0.6531635523,
0.1875847876,
-0.3288477659,
-0.157547459,
0.0182820857,
0.2891198993,
0.2313949764,
0.8819282055,
-0.7001093626,
0.6791788936,
0.2673548162,
-0.3533804417,
0.201691106,
-0.0940916687,
0.2947922349,
-0.7663196921,
0.1543251872,
-0.353251785,
-0.1617024988,
-1.1647055149,
-0.2693641782,
-0.1725947708,
-0.1239970848,
-0.238644883,
0.0527907498,
-0.4203960896,
-0.5972422957,
-0.3611468077,
-0.0557089187,
-0.0361932591,
0.3458790183,
0.4480583072,
0.7572423816,
0.5151683688,
-0.4715559483,
0.3504056931,
0.5625695586,
-0.3672797978,
0.3140535355,
-0.4968957305,
0.3051014245,
-0.2178219557,
0.6200780869,
-0.9997164607,
-0.100772053,
0.2647505403,
-0.5514211059,
0.3826147318,
-0.2831970155,
-0.5318719149,
-0.4551147819,
0.0759082809,
0.590220511,
0.4191529453,
-0.5175990462,
0.9709692001,
0.5013358593,
-0.317422837,
-0.4050526023,
-0.7517650723,
0.078956075,
-0.2043376267,
-0.5049222708,
0.6008350253,
0.4353625178,
-0.3550970256,
-0.1917492747,
-0.4924257994,
-0.2512462437,
-0.2071790397,
0.3987753689,
0.3727141321,
-0.2366334051,
0.0243318882,
-0.1084579974,
-0.349568516,
-0.0079178801,
-0.240623489,
0.4390311837,
0.1818740368,
-0.6493576765,
-0.7557990551,
0.7709104419,
0.7384201288,
-0.5183829069,
0.6197240353,
0.4983740449,
-0.1840960681,
0.0278395098,
-0.7238352299,
-0.018255027,
-0.5493403673,
-0.1955350786,
-0.5303154588,
-0.7295028567,
0.4755991101,
0.3156028688,
-0.142319724,
0.3656620383,
0.3035676777,
0.0463866554,
0.7134378552,
0.3097684085,
-0.5031868219,
0.5849783421,
0.1032434702,
0.4455349445,
-0.4832162261,
-0.3059617579,
-0.9259667397,
-0.1968306005,
-0.6355060935,
-0.3482751846,
0.6319137812,
-0.2263573259,
-0.3326945901,
0.5229277015,
-0.4809035659,
0.1474684626,
0.6061051488,
-0.1115169674,
0.5835545659,
-0.0927947685,
0.1853708774,
0.4200169146,
-0.5079001784,
-0.5027282238,
0.5342832208,
0.2126044929,
0.5179387331,
0.2758411765,
0.6632433534,
0.0896496624,
-0.2134529352,
-0.7774587274,
0.5980272293,
-0.6798946261,
-0.379309386,
-0.3855268657,
-0.5043645501,
-0.7424535155,
0.258320421,
0.2168785781,
-0.5932375789,
0.5814339519,
0.1253582835,
-0.5822293758,
0.3581658602,
-0.8584337234,
0.5454479456,
-0.0975377038,
0.4278232753,
-0.2609290481,
-1.0778719187,
-0.1200646311,
0.1275579631,
0.2821267545,
0.0997637585,
0.0871964619,
0.9547290206,
-0.3029641509,
0.4190149307,
-0.5202956796,
0.0302626006,
0.2557162046,
-0.1985951513,
0.3889077604,
-0.1175242886,
-0.133049041,
0.0394301265,
-0.0418013334,
0.0003646601,
-0.5340013504,
0.6809101105,
-1.0153096914,
-0.6334634423,
-0.4268521369,
-0.1704988629,
-0.2554701269,
0.0572515689,
-0.0524849743,
0.6437860131,
-0.0066704578,
0.2026712298,
0.232013151,
-0.1900390536,
0.608240962,
0.8017902374,
0.0884164572,
-0.2458545864,
0.7156615257,
0.0966936499,
0.2684184611,
0.777693212,
-0.0362058058,
-0.3404294848,
-0.5419377089,
-0.2067974061,
-0.1051683798,
-0.5626186728,
-0.1978054643,
-0.7610906363,
-0.6528518796,
-0.8385156989,
-0.1051594615,
-0.4004757404,
-0.3631437719,
-0.074210465,
0.213522166,
0.055085469,
0.6708382964,
-0.0636915863,
0.6105597019,
-0.6810836792,
0.8184686899,
0.4536112845,
0.2530293167,
-0.1257428974,
-0.4354275465,
-0.1154320166,
-0.2158425003,
-0.320887655,
-0.4199109077,
0.2101389468,
0.230698958,
0.5694887638,
0.2070373595,
0.1383880824,
0.8061401844,
-0.688854754,
0.6188294291,
-0.1013032272,
-1.0046024323,
0.4739597738,
0.0330881327,
0.2568354309,
0.6066867709,
0.1530022025,
-0.6133492589,
-0.3911055028,
-0.4274515808,
-0.6639125943,
1.2391976118,
0.4816460609,
-0.4565480053,
0.1820300519,
-0.0332704782,
-0.2706184089,
0.0151584288,
-0.1517124474,
-0.0391787402,
-0.310839355,
-0.1126223281,
-0.1757601202,
0.3398538232,
0.1111283898,
-0.2598086298,
0.532807529,
0.0430414416,
0.5041847825,
0.2841175199,
0.1707574725,
-0.4199232161,
0.526797533,
0.2892330587,
0.0443796292,
-0.2649326921,
0.2344445884,
0.1207932606,
-0.4360851049,
0.2571493387,
0.2062419355,
0.267834425,
0.0726409107,
0.4917761385,
0.8019317389,
0.1681214422,
-0.4704011977,
0.7193661928,
0.0292891189,
0.0193808842,
-0.4421288967,
0.1117950901,
-0.1332349479,
0.2139218003,
0.4717532694,
0.4890881181,
0.3320905864,
-0.4088912606,
0.4551645815,
0.2786247432,
-0.1208472177,
-0.4029119611,
0.5114309192,
0.2832489014,
-0.5035141706,
0.5986285806,
0.090995416,
-0.6603213549,
0.6865945458,
0.2018432021,
0.9807974696,
-0.6946164966,
-0.1921959966,
-0.1063270941,
-0.0511075631,
-0.1626671851,
0.2822433412,
-0.4704804718,
-1.0046439171,
-0.5431236625,
-0.4727663994,
-0.5133329034,
-0.1348235607,
-0.8574542999,
0.5508570671,
-0.3187897205,
0.0296067316,
0.211901173,
0.019202441,
-0.474650234,
0.2750093341,
0.4586051404,
0.7465648651,
-0.8545199633,
1.2874171734,
0.7286589742,
-0.0638830289,
-1.0574227571,
0.3298561573,
0.214930892,
-0.5556395054,
0.8360561132,
0.114409335,
-0.3911053538,
-0.0189632624,
0.2281538993,
-0.5855946541,
1.2197949886,
-0.0121644167,
-0.5997683406,
-0.3738603294,
0.3078350425,
0.3745835423,
-0.0803175792,
0.1070666164,
0.67966187,
0.4798170328,
0.4349953234,
-1.6038132906,
-0.3197709918,
-0.1494195312,
0.0139163556,
0.2450297475,
-0.6687645912,
0.6861154437,
0.3320013285,
-0.6531812549,
-0.2518092394,
0.507025063,
0.2128323466,
0.3033434749,
1.2932457924,
0.4472578168,
0.1232412085,
-0.0224568062,
0.6662320495,
-0.0964656025,
-0.1301500201,
1.1771812439,
-0.4786657691,
1.1012750864,
0.7411791086,
-0.4281332791,
0.5436261892,
0.0281051733,
0.317889601,
0.6778181791,
-0.1044295579,
-0.4612623155,
-0.2246859968,
-0.0528750494,
-0.0696157515,
1.0121695995,
0.3142741024,
0.0598081462,
-0.1998945922,
0.1592694223,
-0.3827457726,
0.0498077273,
-0.0552601032,
1.0973520279,
0.2088124156,
-0.6594076753,
0.1860058606,
0.0003384531,
0.5956566334,
-0.6709906459,
0.2329318374,
0.0972843915,
0.1204974502,
-0.3274242878,
-0.5436043739,
0.8852283359,
-0.0372675918,
-0.098209165,
-0.7609780431,
0.8388579488,
-0.4634537995,
-0.1030651033,
0.4527858198,
0.5712616444,
-0.0123076485,
-0.0485996492,
-0.2154766917,
0.5212603211,
-0.2269047797,
0.0926657543,
-0.104181774,
0.2513457239,
-0.1901345849,
0.5238301754,
0.5035684705,
0.393103689,
0.038034033,
0.4168418944,
0.9877629876,
-0.6053602099,
-0.8775146008,
-0.4838182628,
0.4608286023,
0.077315405,
0.2400625646,
0.3735138178,
0.5831487179,
0.8222112656,
0.1585980505,
0.7068410516,
-0.2330341488,
0.7792696953,
-0.4924064279,
0.4138014615,
-0.4261639416,
0.6068832874,
-0.0991274491,
-0.6240203977,
-0.4512907565,
0.6957204938,
-0.1961130798,
-0.196207568,
0.5033528805,
0.9476807714,
-0.3963998556,
0.436978966,
0.1459441632,
-0.2238949686,
0.8114360571,
0.3968713284,
1.0011633635,
-0.6660636067,
0.5189505816,
-0.1116870195,
-0.069708623,
-0.0389054082,
-0.3259246349,
-0.5135537982,
-0.7474439144,
-0.4517532885,
0.2406978756,
0.0694144294,
1.1550397873,
0.8040830493,
-1.2094311714,
-0.5845575333,
-0.2018865198,
-0.0937750563,
-0.3381314278,
-0.2629717588,
0.2744345069,
-0.1849980801,
-0.5178471804,
1.0558780432,
0.3943626583,
0.1475896984,
-0.0817476138,
-0.1973531842,
-0.0508148372,
-0.0232387148,
0.2276716083,
0.2014590502,
-0.7843759656,
-0.7885740995,
-0.3582049608,
0.0505013503,
0.1702504158,
1.3384155035,
-0.8986725211,
0.3067829311,
0.6823269129,
0.4539795518,
0.1640517414,
0.2386246622,
0.6628761888,
-0.9707024097,
0.2930507362,
0.2336450964,
0.1889261156,
0.2369612902,
-0.1623057574,
0.165152058,
0.2727166116,
-0.7484821081,
-0.648935616,
-0.0244146883,
-1.3530800343,
-0.1079917848,
0.7408916354,
0.0340344459,
0.2909158766,
-0.6970400214,
-0.0488101169,
0.431581378,
-0.5308032632,
0.3924368024,
0.2454846203,
-0.3599235415,
-0.079053469,
-0.1685381532,
0.4104884565,
0.0636568367,
-0.7128249407,
0.1163095459,
0.1635864228,
-0.1169518754,
0.454928726,
0.8682382107,
-0.1333278418,
0.061682187,
-0.0862504989,
-0.1808091998,
0.1471682936,
-0.7534661889,
-0.4263239801,
-0.0046257558,
-0.1427889317,
-0.4059663117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13840v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13840v1 | StackRAG Agent: Improving Developer Answers with Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-19T21:07:35 | 2024-06-19T21:07:35 | Davit Abrahamyan, Fatemeh H. Fard | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Developers spend much time finding information that is relevant to their
questions. Stack Overflow has been the leading resource, and with the advent of
Large Language Models (LLMs), generative models such as ChatGPT are used
frequently. However, there is a catch in using each one separately. Searching
for answers is time-consuming and tedious, as shown by the many tools developed
by researchers to address this issue. On the other, using LLMs is not reliable,
as they might produce irrelevant or unreliable answers (i.e., hallucination).
In this work, we present StackRAG, a retrieval-augmented Multiagent generation
tool based on LLMs that combines the two worlds: aggregating the knowledge from
SO to enhance the reliability of the generated answers. Initial evaluations
show that the generated answers are correct, accurate, relevant, and useful. | [
-0.5597205758,
-0.7194321156,
0.2911741138,
0.3319864869,
-0.0545952693,
0.7189068794,
-0.027738234,
-0.536499083,
0.5572661757,
0.4831333756,
-0.2755875587,
-0.3125492632,
-0.3990289271,
0.009402547,
-0.4147160053,
1.3500522375,
0.2520124316,
-0.3917477727,
-0.3278515339,
0.019087499,
-0.5101397634,
-0.4717997611,
-0.7833352685,
-0.1640143692,
0.4690229893,
0.4694540501,
0.7871701121,
0.3361530304,
0.4122300446,
0.3346288502,
-0.1000055224,
0.3454722464,
-0.6442748904,
0.7120053768,
0.046630688,
-0.2018934935,
-0.583735466,
-0.398312062,
0.1118443608,
0.2901070118,
-0.533051312,
0.4150566459,
-0.1343042105,
0.2253028899,
-0.8117725849,
-0.1288005859,
-0.7573613524,
-0.1012947857,
-0.0873273462,
-0.5798069835,
-0.3199926317,
-0.4763090014,
-0.1764332503,
-0.6146425605,
0.3408210278,
-0.0870719627,
0.4661122262,
0.5106521249,
-0.2199930698,
-0.7080686092,
-0.7392852306,
0.6558789015,
-0.4710140228,
0.0855634287,
0.1686984301,
0.3817698359,
-0.3269978762,
-0.6984497309,
-0.6371589303,
-0.3047651052,
0.0082078874,
0.3650015891,
-0.1942425519,
-0.2496307492,
0.1539984345,
0.0996020436,
-0.7121553421,
0.1651365906,
-0.6320161819,
-0.2836619318,
0.7408853173,
0.2304006517,
0.5168700814,
-0.1462874115,
-0.4460281432,
-0.0152657907,
-0.801340878,
-0.1395605803,
0.4116951525,
0.0814329237,
0.3500068486,
0.7001408935,
-0.056038633,
0.7487340569,
0.1276840717,
-0.1260327697,
0.2598010898,
-0.2540214956,
0.2834474444,
0.1334656626,
0.6200484633,
0.2321791947,
-0.0324496627,
-0.4579194486,
-0.1457292587,
0.1523421556,
0.6204014421,
-0.9815410972,
-0.1901317984,
0.7894669175,
-0.0840776563,
-0.4851494431,
-0.0176839605,
-0.9009892941,
-0.5406636,
0.3227735162,
0.054832723,
-0.3216183782,
-0.6614925265,
-0.0967570022,
-0.4317320883,
0.314217627,
0.2151597142,
-0.6481675506,
0.1121158302,
0.6290614605,
0.7245919704,
-0.1568237543,
-0.4397479892,
-1.0840651989,
0.1713971049,
-0.3641692102,
1.1849293709,
-0.5727823377,
-0.6809572577,
-0.0328745767,
-0.5234241486,
0.2727551162,
-0.7345983982,
0.4175775051,
-0.9344616532,
0.3800388873,
0.0480453148,
-0.3616493046,
0.1280179024,
0.4918227196,
-0.5392927527,
1.2987235785,
-0.0309981406,
-0.5956273675,
0.2257257104,
-0.6347162724,
-0.2642472684,
0.5266321898,
-0.1446324885,
-0.3047455847,
-0.0220288131,
0.2480950207,
0.3745442033,
-0.2023325562,
0.1265154183,
-0.1465043426,
-0.3210251629,
0.2075158954,
-0.0716240406,
0.5843587518,
0.302545011,
-0.1608053744,
0.023975661,
-0.6839742064,
0.4013762176,
-0.0301140994,
-0.5104696751,
-0.0728392676,
0.0532457642,
-0.1018045843,
0.448787123,
0.340896368,
-0.497084707,
0.1266708225,
-0.1367800981,
-0.0226512756,
0.5703158975,
0.0717354789,
0.241942957,
-0.4111478329,
1.2066659927,
-0.0511772111,
-0.3224564195,
-0.2111559957,
-0.5080735087,
-0.3646275699,
-0.0686115026,
0.0388213694,
0.6307095289,
-1.1306805611,
0.3084179163,
-0.4218563735,
-0.8748086095,
-0.5121037364,
0.3527784944,
0.5250765681,
0.3605368137,
0.325371027,
-0.2227867544,
-0.5367028713,
-0.3578940332,
-0.2044460624,
-0.3771576881,
-0.1241553575,
0.3030044734,
0.355576694,
-0.4038970172,
0.8969926238,
-0.6785123348,
0.1409613192,
-0.2796668708,
0.2148085386,
0.0717575699,
0.0503171608,
0.6413607001,
-0.8267454505,
-0.4345920384,
0.086634554,
-0.740060389,
-0.3852676451,
0.2512433827,
-0.0821181759,
0.038830094,
0.4734185934,
-0.824054122,
0.0385920554,
0.7867981791,
-0.2230747491,
0.8828241825,
-0.0633971766,
0.0243282095,
-1.4366873503,
0.2043542862,
-0.28692922,
-0.1586135328,
-0.5527155399,
0.3383308947,
-0.2473148108,
-0.4113915861,
-0.4750022292,
0.8223576546,
-0.493783474,
-0.1927527338,
-0.4713623226,
0.8036006093,
0.0525891855,
0.1898035705,
-0.2564254999,
1.3579053879,
0.3658272326,
-0.8529912233,
0.7347061634,
0.3721617758,
-0.0165962167,
0.7653604746,
-0.8207420111,
0.3329425156,
-0.2863420844,
0.3380005062,
-0.914576292,
-0.4858537912,
-0.0388126746,
-0.7235445976,
-0.101653412,
-0.2154106051,
-0.5788637996,
-0.4513142109,
-0.2949469984,
0.3137450218,
0.544608891,
-0.762696743,
0.4601861835,
0.6737607121,
-0.4702363312,
-0.9495203495,
-0.411024034,
0.0341353938,
-0.2381733805,
-0.8152190447,
0.3404850662,
-0.2003425509,
-0.332629472,
0.0373741798,
-0.0562562905,
-0.1621721685,
-0.0432615839,
0.1061090231,
-0.0409427956,
-0.1620156914,
0.618616581,
-0.1572621763,
-0.1810061932,
-0.0589754544,
0.013558289,
0.7021027207,
-0.0990615562,
-0.3106819987,
0.4251503646,
0.3770709932,
0.5921264887,
-0.5646340847,
0.583927989,
0.7970619202,
-0.0461025126,
-0.3727061152,
-0.6710979342,
-0.1652553529,
-0.4525947869,
0.4960767627,
-0.3731282055,
-0.9549987316,
0.8234314322,
-0.2027489692,
0.1575970054,
0.4073818624,
0.6361166835,
0.0595283173,
1.0271036625,
0.4112082422,
0.108959496,
0.3326648176,
-0.0901857167,
0.1279780418,
-0.792270422,
-0.3012340069,
-0.7206625342,
-0.1075596064,
-0.4757916629,
-0.2772169709,
0.5615751743,
0.2253261656,
0.0672298223,
0.2955485582,
-0.8518877029,
0.589756906,
0.3353128433,
-0.0910565034,
0.2988519967,
-0.112392582,
0.2149988115,
0.3328719735,
-0.8229339719,
-0.506929636,
0.8575116992,
-0.1233248711,
0.8480696082,
0.5882676244,
0.8486523628,
0.2010593563,
0.358704567,
-0.6421296597,
0.6632080078,
0.1948920488,
-0.6469614506,
-0.2008609027,
-0.5288524032,
-1.3207776546,
0.4858869016,
0.0005912631,
-0.5578308702,
-0.0790311769,
0.1608126312,
-0.4926934838,
0.061737828,
-0.7659320235,
0.7056467533,
-0.3365192413,
-0.3456353843,
-0.2399641126,
-0.397654295,
0.4554114938,
-0.1232973635,
-0.1019298658,
-0.0344921835,
-0.1536046714,
0.5444694757,
-0.7337034345,
0.6129724979,
-0.1236216724,
-0.3167526126,
0.6837070584,
0.1398039162,
0.6683028936,
0.107351236,
-0.3345351815,
-0.4229675531,
-0.0642207786,
-0.5214194059,
-0.7527945042,
0.8336536288,
-0.6770703197,
-0.5821707845,
-0.3054932952,
-0.4324771464,
-0.0263723508,
0.2364430726,
0.3012319207,
0.3762127161,
-0.1728559732,
0.1423619837,
0.4500097334,
-0.3245597184,
0.3370834291,
0.431792289,
-0.4782973826,
-0.2944955528,
0.7290139198,
0.0259049181,
0.0784123242,
0.1550062448,
-0.0199776962,
-0.4111231863,
-0.2011365592,
-0.6193624139,
-0.1317399591,
-0.6074185967,
-0.5068486929,
-0.7459956408,
-0.3443621993,
-0.2168207616,
-0.1432201564,
-0.2660045922,
-0.4129579663,
-0.0153437518,
-0.2538017631,
0.7247873545,
0.6241546273,
-0.0257967748,
0.2841981947,
-0.9472757578,
0.3030175269,
0.5145667791,
0.1862632632,
-0.0331503674,
-0.235056296,
-0.2270479798,
0.2102512568,
-0.5459408164,
-1.0694361925,
0.318107754,
0.072085917,
0.5960773826,
-0.1018988937,
0.0438556932,
0.8419679999,
-0.2898234129,
0.8505266309,
-0.0565530024,
-0.6518209577,
0.6486489773,
-0.3980130553,
0.346831888,
0.3456208408,
0.1199927628,
-0.4833000004,
-0.6353926063,
-0.8320962191,
-0.86811167,
0.3689427376,
0.1200245172,
0.4185564816,
-0.2842211425,
0.0986395031,
0.0385810584,
0.4242753386,
-0.3621771038,
0.0550096631,
-0.1455564797,
0.1147790253,
0.3031155765,
-0.3392718136,
0.0646508709,
0.2033890784,
0.7393510938,
-0.0919254795,
0.0814327523,
-0.0956897736,
-0.2508834004,
0.0088382857,
0.4399861693,
0.6831836104,
0.9129349589,
-0.0389132239,
0.3359166086,
0.2522639334,
-0.5321680307,
0.2183386087,
0.1449046284,
0.0518130101,
0.2243196517,
0.1232830286,
0.4455092251,
-0.1081960425,
-0.9369035363,
0.4159265459,
0.1578806192,
0.1524522007,
-0.5599117875,
0.3042083681,
0.0841581225,
0.2846778333,
0.5494256616,
0.1600265354,
-0.0094536953,
-0.3736105263,
0.3632824421,
0.3635101318,
-0.1603715867,
-0.1644007117,
0.5962429047,
0.4449718595,
-0.5384937525,
0.7452101707,
-0.6308307648,
-0.5076267719,
0.7197235227,
0.6039966345,
0.8450117111,
-0.4069642127,
0.5661673546,
0.2346586287,
0.0214258395,
-0.0210126676,
0.3740204871,
0.0846046507,
-0.8038852811,
-0.8476628065,
-0.3799626529,
-0.5529710054,
-0.1201305091,
-0.3976983726,
0.2147789747,
-0.0726275072,
-0.3215229511,
-0.1520694047,
-0.0717214122,
-0.5740132928,
-0.0604682975,
-0.4594688118,
0.532218039,
-0.5079170465,
0.4729586244,
0.8883184195,
-0.753557682,
-0.710365653,
0.0236292183,
-0.2722691298,
-0.7342601418,
0.562985301,
-0.0796221644,
-0.4574353397,
0.2430435866,
-0.6371102929,
-0.6473773122,
1.1276264191,
0.3641275465,
-0.0166923162,
0.1825832725,
-0.2463080734,
0.9598691463,
-0.1532904804,
0.5982444882,
-0.079550527,
0.1969088465,
0.3026001751,
-0.9031890035,
-0.1311307847,
-0.6040357351,
-0.0086255921,
0.4319576919,
-0.6118651628,
0.6684428453,
-0.4221888483,
-0.2700449526,
-0.0370398834,
0.3092741668,
0.8863052726,
0.140685603,
0.2384580821,
0.5593113899,
0.9015950561,
0.1302577257,
1.1777201891,
-0.6510035992,
0.2159865648,
1.0781645775,
-0.3404508531,
1.00642097,
0.2691046894,
0.1073073968,
0.7461385131,
0.3233243823,
-0.0381161198,
0.1708595306,
0.2412499785,
-0.4158169031,
-0.1472001374,
-0.327576071,
-0.4664825797,
0.4927459955,
0.2930381,
-0.0749526694,
-0.3958812952,
-0.1767621338,
0.2522617579,
0.1111115441,
-0.1208758652,
0.8914946914,
-0.0148030678,
-0.986351788,
0.6029099226,
-0.1228162944,
0.568806529,
-0.3291013241,
-0.1028737575,
-0.4096571505,
0.0626465529,
-0.3960239887,
-0.9064689875,
0.4197018147,
0.3384805918,
-0.183566168,
-0.1955649108,
0.9584107995,
-0.4923203588,
-0.3146678209,
0.2112734318,
0.9591909647,
0.419583112,
-0.0208114926,
-0.4836308062,
-0.0646432936,
-0.2985237539,
-0.0713546574,
-0.0497816652,
0.4701670706,
0.0843836591,
0.9603033662,
0.6352388859,
0.2545189857,
0.3277587593,
-0.2164519131,
0.885451138,
-0.3351425529,
-0.4426197112,
-0.7634943724,
0.7307023406,
-0.3807757795,
-0.4033938944,
0.8847646117,
0.6732315421,
0.603223443,
-0.1502724141,
0.9185442924,
-0.2695400417,
0.6464605927,
-0.3129312396,
0.5456190705,
-0.3872057199,
0.5687252879,
-0.1986428946,
-1.2614253759,
-0.2165255249,
0.3492655456,
-0.2389776409,
0.3513585031,
0.4125458896,
1.0509759188,
-0.21646294,
-0.3294935524,
0.2084134817,
0.0729366243,
0.5064148903,
0.4645732343,
1.0586842299,
-0.3366943598,
1.1080971956,
0.2229117006,
0.0107002724,
-0.2675652504,
-0.6381184459,
-0.7112019062,
-0.3737587333,
-0.319106549,
-0.5342937112,
0.2192921191,
0.6152085066,
0.6125843525,
-0.4436250925,
-0.2084697336,
-0.0534761287,
0.2398249507,
-0.0920153484,
-0.2251392752,
0.1196841076,
-0.60135144,
-0.4552412629,
0.3115819097,
0.2170126885,
-0.2099507302,
-0.4875434339,
-0.1750408411,
0.1532360166,
-0.1660322845,
0.7140826583,
0.4517774284,
-0.5052778721,
-0.2719516158,
0.1280580312,
-0.2358853817,
0.0735304877,
0.5572743416,
-0.9671078324,
0.530451417,
0.7596857548,
0.8007444739,
0.4236908257,
0.2971390784,
0.6489203572,
-1.1974172592,
0.0946351811,
0.4111621678,
-0.0283637624,
0.3671130538,
-0.2762829959,
0.7610677481,
-0.2641547918,
-0.8663197756,
-0.7632613778,
0.4229333699,
-0.5133116841,
-0.02748565,
1.2382380962,
0.1774398685,
0.1301169842,
-0.1966418177,
-0.363879621,
0.0223762654,
-0.5096511245,
1.1028184891,
0.5667457581,
-0.1812358648,
-0.4300539494,
-0.5032573342,
0.4867015779,
0.2432538122,
-1.2412909269,
-0.1657646298,
0.5640809536,
0.0702756718,
0.7891408205,
0.8344902396,
0.0887663141,
0.3282624781,
0.2448179871,
0.3073529601,
0.0925364643,
-0.1669986844,
0.19201231,
0.4069359303,
0.2997086644,
-0.2205771804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13828v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13828v1 | Neuro-symbolic Training for Reasoning over Spatial Language | 2024-06-19T20:47:36 | 2024-06-19T20:47:36 | Tanawan Premsri, Parisa Kordjamshidi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent research shows that more data and larger models can provide more
accurate solutions to natural language problems requiring reasoning. However,
models can easily fail to provide solutions in unobserved complex input
compositions due to not achieving the level of abstraction required for
generalizability. To alleviate this issue, we propose training the language
models with neuro-symbolic techniques that can exploit the logical rules of
reasoning as constraints and provide additional supervision sources to the
model. Training models to adhere to the regulations of reasoning pushes them to
make more effective abstractions needed for generalizability and transfer
learning. We focus on a challenging problem of spatial reasoning over text. Our
results on various benchmarks using multiple language models confirm our
hypothesis of effective domain transfer based on neuro-symbolic training. | [
-0.1044797227,
-0.8370947242,
1.1318223476,
0.2408794612,
0.0889908746,
-0.1607517451,
-0.218890518,
-0.6966136098,
-0.1826621741,
0.453510493,
-0.5405150652,
-0.3680092394,
-0.9372131824,
0.0944680721,
-0.4218543172,
0.6478882432,
-0.3540504575,
0.1733931154,
-0.1532738805,
-0.2002852559,
-0.8228849769,
-0.9160755277,
-0.706361413,
-0.7068619132,
0.1789466739,
0.0596596189,
0.6878174543,
0.4524192214,
0.5624107718,
0.3432451785,
0.0739212707,
0.3354642391,
0.0263629742,
0.0058863047,
-0.6105301976,
-0.4371564388,
-0.1598735452,
-0.1225100532,
0.4010934532,
1.0527756214,
-0.1038332731,
-0.3550561368,
-0.4355141521,
0.4698352516,
-0.5232102275,
0.3122178018,
-0.6604855061,
0.2221267074,
0.4388851821,
-0.2062556744,
-0.4795643687,
-0.5044142604,
0.4239315093,
-1.0959787369,
-0.025676962,
-0.0005768018,
1.0259846449,
0.2280805856,
-0.5361235142,
-0.2272165418,
-1.0087143183,
0.6423962116,
-0.5041871667,
0.3055507541,
0.7719994187,
0.519872725,
-0.0243595913,
-0.4394860268,
-0.50856179,
-0.4972263575,
-0.2865222394,
-0.2231334448,
-0.3443722427,
-0.0317631252,
0.5354666114,
-0.5436252356,
-0.3367610872,
-0.2813698053,
-0.311437875,
-0.0754698738,
0.6619752049,
0.2449526638,
0.6873168945,
0.1461271942,
-0.3519356251,
-0.0546698086,
-0.5421147346,
-0.2787673771,
0.1326274723,
0.313174814,
-0.0828833804,
0.449760288,
-0.172925815,
0.8132944107,
-0.040804483,
0.2657333612,
0.0259722434,
-0.4485175014,
0.1236632094,
0.00281795,
0.4753782153,
0.1255151927,
0.8835213184,
-0.379121244,
-0.3309324086,
0.2693983614,
0.4187490642,
-0.4865162969,
-0.4245091081,
-0.1422088146,
-0.0806846395,
0.236774981,
-0.0542945378,
-0.3346448541,
-0.3541664779,
-0.9981150031,
0.446742326,
-0.7956014276,
-0.2382383347,
0.715672791,
-0.2994369566,
0.0563784577,
0.6621013284,
-1.365598321,
0.5270809531,
0.6367458701,
0.773419261,
-0.0654556677,
-0.5306005478,
-0.1102711037,
0.5643666387,
-0.2842947543,
1.1641665697,
-0.6986250281,
0.0075561614,
-0.0364179425,
-0.043827761,
-0.4518568218,
-0.337008208,
0.3684327602,
-0.1643642187,
0.0116094304,
-0.3031958342,
-0.4014736116,
-0.3463009,
0.3813475668,
-0.4785394073,
0.8632715344,
0.3452579677,
-0.4053310454,
0.2923075557,
-0.685713172,
-0.7545511723,
-0.2340990305,
-0.1848853678,
0.0383801833,
0.1307714283,
0.4693999588,
0.2093010247,
-0.1600736678,
0.5200139284,
-0.3918910027,
-0.2895406783,
0.1829236746,
-0.0257695932,
0.7932468653,
0.0631432906,
-0.4187771976,
0.1329909563,
-0.5511844158,
0.0874737501,
0.2706061304,
-0.032539174,
-0.6818763614,
0.0406071357,
0.0057047387,
0.2356108278,
0.0078292964,
-0.5455812812,
0.2167286277,
-0.5385901332,
0.6257376671,
0.4991175532,
-0.1373215467,
1.0658876896,
-0.0843634605,
0.3575772345,
-0.052399382,
-0.0509795547,
0.4365015328,
-0.3127417862,
-0.5962455273,
-0.0276912265,
-0.0093683535,
0.7917529345,
-0.786087811,
0.4867784083,
-0.3128051758,
-0.4101163149,
-0.0588390008,
-0.1161700487,
0.2223014832,
0.5152931213,
0.3231666684,
0.0080955392,
-0.5942772627,
-0.7236555815,
-0.2671650648,
0.0686434433,
0.0657549426,
0.2231746018,
0.846126318,
-0.1331923604,
0.739453733,
-0.4877104163,
-0.2637776136,
-0.3896306753,
0.1879425645,
0.1037494242,
0.5206764936,
0.6017022729,
-0.5016858578,
-0.306214273,
0.4321778715,
-1.0748833418,
-0.1587560624,
-0.3892285526,
-0.4079576731,
0.253413409,
0.6705491543,
-1.0404170752,
0.5089655519,
0.2456749082,
-0.7113232017,
0.488158673,
-0.4255640805,
-0.0862054527,
-0.6282263398,
-0.0033138061,
0.1460624188,
-0.1538482457,
-0.6816685796,
-0.0085040666,
-0.1753684878,
-0.2024572343,
-0.2600111961,
0.7961528897,
-0.5978935957,
0.0415696092,
-0.4230130315,
0.2500889897,
0.004138215,
0.6150628924,
0.5613829494,
0.3997990489,
0.7729076743,
-0.6119261384,
0.4032745361,
0.3641572595,
-0.1066517308,
0.7407090664,
-0.8449741006,
0.0784004107,
-0.1972959042,
0.2985815108,
-0.7239840627,
0.036127992,
0.38534832,
-0.2213208526,
0.1058328301,
-0.000334295,
-0.5078792572,
-0.1629410088,
0.3481320441,
0.3820734024,
0.1879776269,
-0.4996406734,
0.8629818559,
0.3046523631,
0.0757052675,
-0.2263678163,
-0.8091427088,
-0.0475206152,
-0.1154774874,
-0.5699534416,
0.0907558054,
0.2439375073,
-0.2395258695,
0.2026055902,
-0.236781016,
-0.5823602676,
0.1484495997,
0.0961309224,
0.1296490282,
-0.046052739,
0.1553032696,
0.2026464045,
-0.3976981938,
0.5808687806,
-0.4580314457,
0.3466933668,
-0.1223332956,
-0.5893719792,
-0.530779779,
0.5510892272,
0.3034846485,
-0.1684797853,
0.6616424322,
0.2440267056,
-0.6178434491,
-0.4647858143,
-0.018776454,
-0.60868752,
-0.4124242365,
0.5592279434,
-0.4280310273,
-0.7253543139,
0.2339307219,
-0.2282829583,
-0.2373846024,
0.1836766005,
0.2290010452,
-0.1383965164,
1.2636216879,
0.5632629991,
0.1759931594,
0.3127345443,
-0.0395336784,
0.3972117305,
-0.2828190327,
-0.410695076,
-0.6623072028,
-0.4838659465,
-0.0211237855,
-0.2478138804,
-0.0637869686,
-0.2474946976,
-0.5658032894,
0.690969348,
-0.6604034901,
0.6879909039,
0.5205852389,
0.1664274782,
0.1960519254,
0.3241505623,
-0.0733694807,
-0.1594383717,
-0.6950065494,
-0.3608764112,
0.5853363276,
0.2267260402,
0.8284936547,
0.0975582153,
0.2501680851,
-0.1230450273,
0.1417143196,
-0.6099773049,
0.7013014555,
-0.0915658921,
-0.5547009706,
-0.3345781267,
-0.4692112207,
-0.8669682741,
0.3073508143,
-0.2586912513,
-0.7905119658,
0.2554713488,
-0.1427812129,
-0.1644230634,
0.4083665609,
-0.7594839334,
0.7086617947,
-0.381871134,
0.0246055909,
-0.1444611847,
-0.6949148178,
0.2163631022,
0.070833981,
-0.047829669,
-0.2099890411,
0.1162251458,
0.327301681,
-0.3652785718,
0.9206271768,
-0.2232817262,
-0.1144534349,
0.1420476288,
0.2658805251,
0.3900322616,
-0.1841354966,
0.2572392523,
0.331739068,
-0.0490534417,
-0.3254114091,
-1.025889039,
0.3965454996,
-0.9341061711,
-0.4037139416,
-0.6422511339,
-1.0299863815,
-0.4646885395,
0.1487947255,
0.1698755324,
0.1280157715,
0.1815701872,
-0.256379813,
0.7571082711,
0.0594948977,
0.1670491099,
0.2679773867,
-0.1012213305,
-0.2200456411,
0.7220305204,
-0.0732188672,
0.1779202074,
0.4148866534,
0.066690892,
-0.4674379826,
-0.5462272763,
-0.1767008752,
0.3206427693,
-0.755859673,
-0.0198154505,
-0.6372029781,
-0.4915829003,
-0.2522149384,
-0.3571812809,
-0.1412840337,
-0.6675498486,
-0.1412776411,
-0.1541282386,
0.3075717092,
0.793389976,
-0.0102980509,
0.3687359691,
-0.7762377262,
0.3285757005,
0.2299235761,
0.1506358236,
0.0063311891,
-0.6817984581,
0.0087411013,
0.1216509044,
-0.1676275283,
-0.9798722267,
0.4025866687,
0.0957863554,
0.69205302,
0.0558063239,
-0.3955917954,
0.5557423234,
-0.6544572115,
0.2306444347,
0.3090956509,
-0.99326545,
0.8312007189,
-0.5021597147,
0.4073076248,
0.4558533132,
0.5759858489,
-0.4120950401,
-0.3191153407,
-0.4270121455,
-0.5701580644,
0.6421024799,
0.0485710911,
0.2541859746,
-0.0766748264,
0.4577353001,
-0.0987216532,
-0.0596755035,
-0.7429363728,
0.0280939136,
-0.0628644824,
-0.1078943834,
0.3466496468,
0.0574827008,
-0.1931892633,
-0.8514492512,
0.5088201165,
-0.2309976369,
0.3640326858,
0.2452813834,
-0.1857221276,
0.1451671869,
0.0363804884,
0.7555039525,
0.7987805605,
0.1581440568,
0.2542256415,
0.167746067,
-0.3701276481,
0.3795892298,
0.0548306219,
-0.2342551947,
0.0716671497,
0.3249080181,
0.8975458145,
0.3050496876,
-0.662782073,
0.4257195592,
0.0806857124,
-0.7989020944,
-0.2321657091,
-0.0574871935,
0.1794902831,
0.1301949918,
-0.0953793973,
0.3868174553,
-0.0412549376,
-0.2930704653,
0.1553591341,
0.335295558,
-0.3854866326,
-0.5016550422,
0.6802489758,
0.034250062,
-0.0832541808,
1.1395789385,
0.0140864495,
-0.5099033713,
0.7843191028,
0.9920164943,
0.8100150824,
0.0684382915,
0.3196283877,
0.6050220132,
0.6080179214,
-0.3070168793,
0.3986361325,
0.1991373748,
-0.9209690094,
-0.6656853557,
-0.2009596527,
-0.4580338299,
-0.2672360837,
-0.2504890561,
0.0225145761,
-0.7902489305,
-0.1633375734,
-0.118800275,
-0.500636816,
-0.3229702413,
0.0357164294,
0.2066842318,
0.9776724577,
-1.1169095039,
0.7897809744,
1.0630893707,
-0.4640136063,
-0.9429216385,
-0.5850855112,
-0.2721505165,
-0.5772808194,
1.1461786032,
0.0857818574,
-0.2035462558,
-0.3543568552,
-0.8435027003,
-0.7383041978,
0.5663286448,
0.9177874327,
-0.304521203,
-0.1769666374,
0.3523122966,
0.7821985483,
-0.3525525331,
0.0769895688,
0.5880412459,
0.7286249399,
0.2045462728,
-0.7789700627,
0.2485439032,
-0.257496506,
-0.1136216223,
0.3341629505,
-0.0979923159,
0.8257077336,
-0.3417343795,
-0.2172398269,
-0.0103694675,
0.7390967607,
0.3839277625,
0.3605276346,
0.3306692839,
0.8708323836,
0.7936607599,
-0.3623117507,
1.1577041149,
-0.0188603532,
0.2239046693,
1.2347786427,
-0.4241959751,
0.7795411348,
0.5681941509,
0.0477692485,
0.7379125357,
0.1929549426,
-0.0927912444,
0.5210901499,
0.3005462885,
-0.1783733368,
-0.4593278468,
-0.2571373284,
-0.1658783704,
0.4265660048,
0.3464097679,
-0.0471345857,
-0.6022440195,
-0.0430084392,
-0.0527778864,
0.682580471,
-0.1933916658,
0.4806161821,
0.254632026,
-0.7190074325,
0.3989753127,
-0.1140407622,
0.359508276,
-0.6975710988,
-0.3656328917,
-0.1778448373,
0.2216440141,
-0.1884725094,
-0.7205190063,
0.7592990398,
-0.3634389341,
-0.1584988981,
-0.5802591443,
0.9592084885,
-0.4103092253,
-0.2836422026,
0.2805794179,
0.5658609867,
0.1481900066,
-0.3361183107,
-0.6747213006,
-0.3260284662,
-0.2789048851,
0.240928039,
0.3526753485,
0.8156989217,
-0.3867967725,
0.853767097,
0.6522758603,
0.3174338639,
0.0773958415,
0.1607576311,
0.6324824095,
-0.7861018181,
-0.5345358849,
-0.878746748,
0.0752118528,
-0.0807362571,
-0.3431908488,
0.6750147343,
0.1658077538,
0.7345992327,
-0.3628202081,
0.6135228276,
0.0569297001,
-0.0755601898,
-0.4984970689,
0.7686178684,
-0.2714955211,
-0.0003665287,
-0.0086230766,
-0.9344062805,
-0.5160922408,
1.1160677671,
-0.5798715949,
0.198779434,
1.2405730486,
0.4737701416,
-0.1436853856,
0.2420911491,
0.2543988824,
-0.1145702899,
0.1036697105,
1.3426679373,
1.2132749557,
-0.2529023886,
0.2381290793,
-0.218206808,
0.0673174039,
0.3343854547,
-0.8979958296,
-0.9968757629,
-0.4454416931,
-0.4221865535,
-0.1718970686,
0.2576428652,
0.5379017591,
0.9573521614,
-0.748564899,
-0.2151482701,
-0.5213484764,
0.0986585766,
-0.3907353282,
-0.1954041421,
0.2706652582,
-0.410913676,
-0.6682209969,
0.2285242081,
0.2241084129,
0.1575318426,
0.0084477188,
-0.0311159994,
-0.4740141332,
0.0627602488,
0.5577046275,
0.4202167094,
-0.438901335,
-0.4568832815,
0.0285125449,
-0.4552853703,
-0.1119347215,
0.9220877886,
-0.6888929605,
-0.1062202007,
0.6252141595,
0.9554226398,
0.2636261582,
-0.130713433,
0.6901487708,
-0.7520676255,
0.3359771967,
0.2796509564,
0.3943947256,
0.2236413062,
-0.3634731472,
0.6470290422,
0.4337836802,
-0.3735354841,
-0.480427742,
0.2929005921,
-0.9566401243,
-0.5235584974,
1.270247221,
0.079091534,
-0.3697500527,
-0.2872780263,
-0.3059836924,
-0.0893911645,
-0.2074780166,
0.6165764928,
0.8132814765,
-0.2829900682,
-0.0976179987,
-0.6872960329,
0.2448785454,
0.779609561,
-1.2590876818,
-0.026555134,
0.6635876894,
0.1278530955,
0.2096028924,
0.5569845438,
-0.0271333065,
0.5246787071,
0.2054225206,
0.1094183624,
-0.0905613005,
-0.6614457369,
-0.4262490273,
0.1221816316,
-0.1044471934,
0.0980515033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13827v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13827v2 | Fine-Tuning BERTs for Definition Extraction from Mathematical Text | 2024-06-19T20:47:23 | 2024-06-27T22:31:07 | Lucy Horowitz, Ryan Hathaway | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we fine-tuned three pre-trained BERT models on the task of
"definition extraction" from mathematical English written in LaTeX. This is
presented as a binary classification problem, where either a sentence contains
a definition of a mathematical term or it does not. We used two original data
sets, "Chicago" and "TAC," to fine-tune and test these models. We also tested
on WFMALL, a dataset presented by Vanetik and Litvak in 2021 and compared the
performance of our models to theirs. We found that a high-performance
Sentence-BERT transformer model performed best based on overall accuracy,
recall, and precision metrics, achieving comparable results to the earlier
models with less computational effort. | [
-0.4946270585,
-1.0655099154,
0.5078540444,
0.2582127452,
-0.4393985271,
-0.1924117506,
-0.3883806169,
-0.732455194,
0.0364306346,
0.5433868766,
-0.5333439708,
-0.2360215783,
-0.7868565321,
0.3727107644,
-0.5021293163,
1.3315011263,
-0.0589863174,
0.0280538741,
-0.3168489337,
0.1990755498,
-0.4559712708,
-0.2777310312,
-0.4015441835,
-0.4249210358,
0.5867301822,
0.2264494747,
0.9220758677,
0.5735635757,
0.7950721383,
0.31641379,
-0.0958134308,
0.1633560359,
-0.2799105644,
-0.0588284619,
-0.1055556312,
-0.4434143007,
-0.2634036541,
0.1284009069,
0.5603698492,
0.959872365,
0.1066116095,
0.1543177962,
0.1545889825,
0.5284860134,
-0.4634299874,
0.4735494554,
-0.7776881456,
-0.088034071,
-0.03281058,
0.0341263413,
-0.3803604245,
-0.904294014,
0.4745178223,
-0.5634469986,
0.4793370068,
-0.1495416313,
1.4480667114,
0.1729828268,
-0.1872920245,
-0.3888522387,
-0.8559498191,
0.8941779733,
-0.7433821559,
0.3328900337,
0.5423417687,
0.1337315887,
0.0869793743,
-0.8032260537,
-0.5984636545,
0.0034246175,
-0.2337465882,
0.1129298732,
-0.2967406213,
0.0573262535,
0.2707847357,
0.0431652293,
-0.4221602082,
0.1629159451,
-0.6946589351,
-0.1927152872,
0.7602288127,
0.0599698573,
-0.2817061841,
-0.2815006971,
-0.15908885,
-0.061190173,
-0.4272950292,
0.0581302531,
0.2240261585,
0.3768847287,
0.0517378077,
0.7404821515,
0.1374819279,
0.5660543442,
-0.275306344,
0.0761546418,
0.1829724908,
-0.2783381641,
-0.2424577177,
-0.1252947003,
0.495577395,
0.0870710984,
0.7039065361,
-0.2944986522,
-0.6072636247,
0.0189842023,
0.4173484445,
-0.8743730187,
-0.5642963648,
-0.1914954185,
-0.619402349,
-0.4596025944,
0.1892711222,
-0.5606982708,
0.11856547,
-0.873639822,
0.817995131,
-0.6590307355,
0.1365140975,
-0.0142483898,
-0.2425659597,
0.1344956607,
0.3177238107,
-0.9359393716,
0.3227775395,
0.8418124318,
0.7221833467,
-0.0146862175,
0.1267398894,
-0.3205154538,
-0.3445012569,
-0.4704511166,
0.9123247266,
-0.6584473848,
-0.2965928614,
0.2009776086,
-0.0634121299,
0.1649221182,
-0.5350965261,
0.5425984263,
-0.5857857466,
0.4248673022,
-0.2316690832,
-0.7882076502,
-0.2146269083,
0.0450477526,
-0.5781878829,
1.1689707041,
0.3195827007,
-0.4826021194,
0.4385284781,
-0.7493721843,
-0.8043454885,
0.2006381601,
-0.1310299784,
-0.5024804473,
0.6147089601,
0.194870621,
0.6265121102,
-0.2360069901,
0.146784693,
-0.2741889656,
-0.3638124168,
0.3841983378,
-0.3573930264,
0.7412948012,
0.3980121911,
-0.1004407629,
-0.141883418,
-0.9389036298,
0.3063721061,
0.1641912162,
-0.2899149358,
-0.5106180906,
0.3189868331,
0.3778199553,
0.0786605626,
0.4278559685,
-0.6386166215,
0.2900656164,
-0.6980234981,
0.3662084341,
0.930090785,
-0.2836840153,
0.311848253,
-0.4168048203,
0.2719681263,
-0.3574590385,
0.029795045,
0.0609789528,
-0.475263387,
-0.7949448228,
-0.3554602861,
0.8190941811,
0.4583776295,
-0.7238956094,
0.9368801117,
-0.3506536186,
-0.5125597119,
-0.5089160204,
-0.0239168052,
0.1527101249,
0.5562748313,
0.4075938761,
-0.0057795811,
-0.4304836392,
-1.0454177856,
-0.1629457474,
0.1084503978,
-0.2414470762,
0.3840122223,
0.5597661138,
-0.2205134928,
1.2319750786,
-0.8693017364,
-0.1277637631,
-0.1198870838,
0.6110037565,
0.2797688246,
0.2988498509,
0.6715567112,
-0.7732515335,
-0.6023966074,
-0.1464105248,
-0.5178941488,
-0.2442477643,
-0.0567345247,
0.0213238634,
0.2449642718,
0.2796730101,
-0.1730521619,
0.6050723791,
0.2851356864,
-0.2392923534,
0.7526144385,
-0.3497335017,
-0.2784846127,
-1.0767028332,
0.1323907822,
-0.1103207916,
-0.2095041722,
-0.4493196905,
-0.1507818103,
0.1800223738,
0.0065243836,
-0.1862210035,
0.2725454271,
-0.0541075282,
0.0784069151,
-0.23288019,
0.1726325303,
0.0132386135,
0.2239784896,
0.0643751472,
0.7718542814,
0.3764774799,
-0.8085780144,
0.3377048969,
0.335301578,
-0.4581620693,
0.1219140366,
-0.7770828605,
0.1689476371,
-0.1528887153,
-0.3538348675,
-1.0415866375,
0.0972272828,
-0.2974327505,
-0.429693222,
0.1486029476,
0.2120631337,
-0.8759993315,
-0.3759183586,
-0.0793959796,
0.1118145809,
0.6895285845,
-0.4912189841,
0.5867805481,
0.0511127934,
-0.4340603054,
-0.2525290251,
-0.5340895653,
-0.3511776924,
-0.028127173,
-0.4604301751,
0.4621499777,
-0.0874698609,
-0.18553406,
0.0230924357,
-0.0128375022,
-0.3564179838,
0.2581004798,
-0.0529333577,
0.5295498967,
-0.2190481871,
0.5695855618,
0.2373921722,
0.0171399731,
0.2651423216,
-0.2089607865,
0.5554670095,
0.0372475684,
0.2503934801,
-0.2436705083,
0.3761178553,
0.3313675225,
-0.3195349574,
0.7319845557,
0.7346426845,
-0.6646835804,
-0.0173985474,
-0.5293810964,
-0.397254616,
-0.4734346271,
0.2006378919,
-0.3461555839,
-0.8367886543,
0.4691921473,
-0.1029177234,
0.3361425102,
0.7400550842,
0.375869751,
-0.4551198781,
1.0902314186,
1.1131628752,
0.1162475348,
0.6671631336,
-0.2368219048,
0.2264956832,
-0.3706591427,
-0.0679920539,
-0.8880722523,
-0.4614847004,
-0.5435887575,
0.1854397357,
0.3133246303,
0.0955058783,
0.0514254011,
0.4297138453,
-0.5266250968,
0.4176151156,
0.5061376095,
0.0260312892,
-0.0383707806,
0.2222635448,
-0.277084887,
-0.389226824,
-0.2232811153,
-0.6005309224,
1.1245654821,
0.1669289768,
0.6393742561,
0.1918671429,
0.6225970984,
0.1865520328,
0.2032234818,
-0.8811023831,
0.2690955997,
-0.5238537192,
-0.7089021802,
-0.2802715302,
-0.5692951679,
-1.2431818247,
-0.0698130727,
-0.711242795,
-0.7569234967,
0.0162864178,
-0.0394995734,
-0.4997551143,
-0.0274196025,
-0.8100347519,
0.6584271193,
-0.2654049397,
-0.0734670237,
-0.3412768841,
-0.508384943,
0.1913972497,
-0.5807440281,
0.2376312315,
-0.1967570633,
0.1153821796,
0.9220690131,
-0.412208885,
0.5830229521,
0.0760302842,
-0.2565882802,
0.1642503887,
0.0844214112,
0.3467865884,
-0.03208955,
0.037416365,
0.2458312511,
0.5004704595,
-0.417688787,
-0.6087642908,
0.1921364069,
-0.9191740155,
-0.0275827758,
-0.2041485459,
-0.4350388646,
-0.1609092057,
0.4304091036,
0.3807837069,
0.4815734029,
-0.2443635017,
0.3576975465,
0.5380623937,
-0.0984455347,
0.7325211167,
0.5727053285,
-0.2017544657,
-0.219225198,
0.7939751744,
0.163818121,
0.0543482192,
0.5686657429,
0.424841851,
-0.4339550734,
-0.3316411376,
0.0950643048,
0.2174431086,
-0.4055502117,
-0.3656238317,
-0.3664111793,
-0.5201013088,
-0.5503693819,
-0.1784529239,
-0.3045459688,
-0.5587044358,
-0.5801456571,
0.1766664088,
0.4377955198,
0.981911242,
0.0154302567,
0.5623016357,
-1.0131776333,
0.255987674,
0.1995576322,
0.4862676859,
-0.3296121359,
-0.5808109641,
-0.472913295,
0.0803343356,
-0.4585004449,
-0.5868805051,
0.5431041121,
0.433955878,
0.2391413301,
0.6369590163,
-0.0060793594,
0.7213015556,
-0.6193110347,
0.6873804927,
0.185182035,
-1.1072961092,
0.7187422514,
-0.0374937281,
0.1593000591,
0.326050669,
0.3158495724,
-0.2969318628,
-0.134930253,
-0.8157786727,
-0.5258222222,
0.5126372576,
0.4520409703,
0.3218127191,
-0.0057985773,
0.7486451864,
0.4775588512,
0.177881375,
-0.4988033772,
-0.1788539141,
0.0035852713,
-0.5804276466,
-0.4071688652,
-0.2775669396,
0.0500982329,
-0.4524275661,
0.4107113779,
-0.1321201175,
0.4565989673,
0.0749983266,
-0.2808999717,
-0.0882550701,
0.2350338101,
0.6684371233,
0.8982349634,
-0.2985277474,
0.1427586377,
0.1124827266,
-0.6780029535,
-0.3731173277,
0.5544359088,
-0.09330488,
0.2373011559,
0.703871727,
0.4025616348,
0.232780382,
-0.7389745712,
0.4121910334,
-0.2296085209,
-0.5076844096,
-0.3610796034,
0.1117053851,
-0.4232987761,
0.0863956586,
0.3884083927,
0.1342211962,
0.0820526853,
-0.2112992704,
0.3802690208,
0.514826715,
-0.2122711837,
-0.3921426833,
0.4397285283,
-0.0204180218,
-0.3619424403,
0.9521420598,
-0.0166927893,
-0.6157907248,
0.5271823406,
0.5410217047,
0.7877681851,
0.1336652935,
-0.1450435817,
0.2682355046,
0.3551216722,
0.1236631572,
0.3999608755,
-0.0052930936,
-0.9013938904,
-0.490424782,
-0.6592368484,
-0.0807099566,
0.1209130958,
-0.9430660605,
0.4582564831,
-0.5189876556,
-0.2433722466,
0.5934101343,
0.3499204218,
-0.9349561334,
0.2258409411,
0.0216667447,
0.8332777619,
-0.9184583426,
0.9489346743,
0.6160040498,
-0.4193370342,
-0.7681261301,
-0.3461338282,
-0.3930903673,
-0.7325513363,
0.6838719249,
0.0584748127,
0.2096562237,
0.1356442273,
-0.905852735,
-0.7679826021,
0.767354548,
0.2440095097,
-0.6769989729,
-0.0911920965,
0.014686157,
0.5923902392,
-0.2036982179,
0.1512162238,
0.6484371424,
0.3680351079,
-0.0905452967,
-1.1718050241,
-0.4286922514,
-0.0846219808,
-0.0115652271,
0.3319942951,
-0.1793521494,
0.8953956366,
-0.0840393528,
-0.0161599703,
0.1399529725,
0.7491641641,
-0.362374872,
-0.0707717761,
0.4696852267,
0.4712111056,
0.883924067,
-0.4090731442,
0.7118889689,
-0.0556787141,
0.6710507274,
0.8592352867,
0.0222230833,
1.0719085932,
0.2585042715,
-0.3821489811,
0.553117156,
0.6712101698,
-0.273306042,
0.5978597999,
0.0494473875,
-0.0102007305,
-0.3641305268,
0.2320680618,
-0.2992968559,
0.7035296559,
0.5310533047,
-0.440454185,
-0.2291609794,
0.0132292239,
-0.083941415,
0.1225424781,
-0.2527497411,
1.098775506,
-0.1159108728,
-0.6188285351,
0.5584753752,
0.1191326007,
0.5517571568,
-0.5451737046,
-0.1596129984,
-0.0991313159,
0.3908457458,
0.0223964769,
-0.6575015187,
0.5312036276,
0.0233707391,
-0.3054936826,
-0.1149746254,
0.6154680848,
-0.4260056019,
-0.7960915565,
-0.0348681547,
0.4766966701,
0.3539746702,
-0.0047562551,
-0.7957715392,
-0.1559822261,
-0.0044955006,
0.3337637782,
-0.0737982541,
0.6512459517,
0.152231276,
0.3533593416,
0.6072080731,
0.0928327292,
0.1189579144,
0.0948172137,
0.6632970572,
-0.7509824634,
-0.4106519222,
-0.8964073658,
0.2369683534,
-0.0217044596,
-0.4134390056,
0.4476903677,
0.8088608384,
0.6670466661,
-0.2696779072,
0.6670920849,
-0.08189933,
0.6347882152,
-0.5078029037,
0.7728601694,
-0.5209122896,
-0.0922926962,
-0.3757528961,
-0.971601069,
-0.4624866843,
0.9924196005,
-0.1765963733,
0.0381400548,
0.8564251661,
0.3676720858,
-0.0124056097,
0.2281982899,
0.1994986832,
0.1582206935,
0.5077236891,
0.3491786122,
0.5444791317,
-0.5112190843,
0.61513412,
-0.4171953201,
-0.1963464469,
-0.34192729,
-0.8594307899,
-1.056348443,
-0.7442538142,
-0.2622381151,
-0.3249816,
-0.320024848,
0.9067189693,
0.6853113174,
-0.9092037082,
0.0768266469,
-0.1045411527,
0.0794473588,
-0.4283110499,
-0.2617741823,
0.5560635328,
-0.8170523047,
-0.7651540041,
-0.0937251896,
-0.107305482,
0.3263484538,
0.0190926474,
0.4133174121,
-0.0781422555,
0.2923737466,
0.8216102123,
-0.157587111,
-0.7384092212,
-0.6960194111,
0.1575591266,
-0.0360650122,
0.0153031005,
0.7837228775,
-0.7858764529,
0.5226075053,
0.2943221033,
0.6900933385,
0.4275230765,
-0.0104620764,
0.5780990124,
-1.0408520699,
-0.0398726128,
0.2985801995,
0.290179342,
-0.0246203169,
-0.2042178512,
0.34924528,
0.3109104037,
-0.4329583347,
-0.6762631536,
-0.0620512776,
-0.9502843022,
-0.429864794,
0.8114942312,
0.1199101061,
-0.0028509642,
-0.0836923644,
-0.2877824605,
0.3107967377,
-0.1685879678,
1.0046845675,
1.0943371058,
-0.1399641484,
-0.1321552843,
-0.4046450555,
0.5430147052,
0.3638226092,
-0.574630022,
-0.0036379641,
0.2784132957,
0.313868463,
0.3813560605,
-0.0974059328,
0.0689416379,
0.1727774441,
-0.2917496264,
0.1991896629,
0.1515713185,
-0.2603603601,
-0.3510296345,
0.0533782616,
-0.0454824679,
-0.2091418654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13820v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13820v1 | Framing Social Movements on Social Media: Unpacking Diagnostic, Prognostic, and Motivational Strategies | 2024-06-19T20:31:34 | 2024-06-19T20:31:34 | Julia Mendelsohn, Maya Vijan, Dallas Card, Ceren Budak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media enables activists to directly communicate with the public and
provides a space for movement leaders, participants, bystanders, and opponents
to collectively construct and contest narratives. Focusing on Twitter messages
from social movements surrounding three issues in 2018-2019 (guns, immigration,
and LGBTQ rights), we create a codebook, annotated dataset, and computational
models to detect diagnostic (problem identification and attribution),
prognostic (proposed solutions and tactics), and motivational (calls to action)
framing strategies. We conduct an in-depth unsupervised linguistic analysis of
each framing strategy, and uncover cross-movement similarities in associations
between framing and linguistic features such as pronouns and deontic modal
verbs. Finally, we compare framing strategies across issues and other social,
cultural, and interactional contexts. For example, we show that diagnostic
framing is more common in replies than original broadcast posts, and that
social movement organizations focus much more on prognostic and motivational
framing than journalists and ordinary citizens. | [
-0.0850403309,
-1.0164009333,
0.8713577986,
0.0888064206,
-0.5843592286,
0.826263845,
0.1356062889,
-0.0444030799,
0.8185908198,
0.3538259566,
-0.4809572995,
-0.4971147478,
-1.0416440964,
-0.274592042,
-0.7885705829,
0.8489955664,
-0.473505646,
0.2421396971,
0.4048476815,
-0.3705249727,
-0.3403544128,
-0.1996649206,
-0.8307512403,
0.0780349448,
0.7207568884,
-0.0050821863,
0.562286377,
0.8231657147,
0.3788499236,
0.2724025846,
-0.2696149051,
-0.1859534234,
-0.7433659434,
0.006058644,
0.0147710489,
-0.0794877559,
0.1114666313,
0.0043283659,
0.6968963742,
0.4627260864,
0.1848142892,
0.4498443604,
-0.064857021,
0.8436583877,
-0.4087087214,
-0.1183527559,
-0.1549354941,
0.1912392378,
-0.4738020599,
-0.1783814877,
0.1891975701,
-0.6137151718,
-0.4679710269,
-0.3058780134,
0.3080612719,
-0.2906113863,
0.5952993035,
0.0326073878,
-0.835264504,
-0.1398923844,
-0.8315282464,
0.2774481773,
-0.1577342004,
0.3105676472,
0.3674378395,
0.3946627378,
-0.0885292888,
-0.610252738,
-0.2482077181,
0.5297718644,
0.2897760272,
-0.083779566,
-0.4848437011,
-0.1806531847,
0.0727928355,
-0.0275139082,
-0.4990566373,
-0.334038049,
-0.698412776,
-0.0928412154,
0.9057266116,
0.3450559974,
0.3853248358,
-0.175930649,
-0.4469126165,
0.3060921133,
-0.5260969996,
0.2143933177,
0.496759057,
0.1996095031,
-0.4565985501,
0.6508471966,
-0.3033343256,
0.4528168142,
0.148912847,
0.1868908554,
-0.0581060536,
-0.4626388252,
0.1098122075,
0.1542385221,
0.8561373949,
0.6520568132,
0.0292653721,
-0.1194157302,
-0.0875162706,
0.1034308076,
0.3407875299,
-0.6174095273,
0.1378543377,
0.0451004468,
-0.9072140455,
-0.2638332248,
0.1768603772,
-0.5157097578,
-0.7546513677,
-0.2355126739,
0.5926663876,
-0.1236947551,
-0.3880857527,
0.0928938165,
-0.5226565599,
0.3459559679,
0.2501133382,
-0.6256783605,
-0.0933808237,
0.8387356997,
1.2213515043,
0.0644844994,
0.2900919318,
-0.5707836747,
0.1542904377,
-0.6598657966,
0.6418816447,
-0.4364535809,
-0.2913811207,
0.4714101255,
0.2690635324,
-0.051717516,
-0.0852861702,
0.1469329298,
-0.5956147313,
-0.4179358482,
-0.713979423,
-0.5291458368,
-0.1012876257,
0.2780819833,
-0.6500139236,
0.6635415554,
-0.0264010057,
-0.57665205,
0.2774398923,
-0.7182474732,
-0.3951844573,
0.086963281,
-0.2241926491,
-0.0440524109,
0.2606984377,
-0.3535473347,
0.8484213948,
-0.1070297584,
0.375141263,
-0.3319351673,
-0.3641915917,
0.1360582709,
-0.0818266347,
0.7773543596,
0.1020584404,
-0.3981406689,
0.4582085609,
-0.5108270645,
-0.5612539649,
0.4290484488,
-0.2537476122,
-0.1180753186,
0.4071682394,
-0.1695565283,
-0.1496064067,
-0.0757866129,
-0.609641552,
-0.1391118616,
0.1029139981,
0.8298108578,
0.6002850533,
0.4154664278,
0.1714152247,
-0.4357626438,
0.7387672663,
-0.0465530343,
0.4637171924,
-0.136929661,
-0.5929301381,
-0.2314098179,
0.0790845156,
-0.2179180682,
0.3613191247,
-0.7983617783,
-0.2246665359,
-0.1728283763,
-0.445512861,
-0.3839151561,
0.0752166882,
0.1020678133,
0.1251356006,
0.1855498403,
-0.1399668455,
-0.4019706845,
-0.6511759758,
-0.5858126283,
-0.2329620719,
0.3786088228,
-0.412979126,
0.2826526761,
-0.0846095309,
0.4842694402,
-0.2894033492,
-0.1448353678,
-0.4212843776,
0.3975312412,
-0.040327888,
-0.1590063274,
0.3551037908,
-1.1746575832,
-0.7352568507,
-0.0528782457,
-0.3873381913,
0.1140340716,
-0.0743730441,
-0.0052915635,
-0.0223566629,
0.8696596026,
-0.3349504471,
0.8565092087,
0.443670392,
-0.5517482758,
0.2277906984,
0.5389496684,
0.6452716589,
-1.2874470949,
-0.305840075,
0.3351358771,
-0.500187397,
-0.8086809516,
-0.272624433,
-0.311337024,
-0.1749632061,
-0.7403957844,
0.4081700146,
-0.2172070742,
0.0954296291,
-0.2148775607,
0.1026879549,
-0.3184294403,
-0.1155364215,
0.020792162,
-0.0523029752,
0.5285120606,
-0.2175324857,
0.3482015133,
-0.0040351916,
-0.5510219932,
0.3204644918,
-0.7155514956,
0.0613506697,
-0.4224355221,
0.166732505,
-1.243701458,
-0.2753987014,
0.6135296226,
-0.564699471,
-0.0089743575,
-0.2944301069,
-0.2261640728,
-0.4663329422,
-0.4248915315,
0.229554981,
0.0013735901,
-0.0582680218,
0.5700529814,
0.8160785437,
0.1174537763,
-0.2235031128,
-0.6590505838,
0.0434484072,
-0.5136626363,
-0.3619607687,
0.1207755432,
0.3177128434,
-0.4333839715,
0.0494284965,
0.0392481759,
0.029723404,
0.1423879266,
0.3733093739,
-0.2698062956,
-0.1087565497,
0.2678631246,
-0.0929677114,
-0.0270222463,
0.1062350869,
0.3343446851,
0.5625174642,
0.0037067807,
-0.3682996929,
-0.1504964679,
1.087069869,
0.4568754137,
-0.0606906712,
0.7043992877,
1.0619096756,
-0.5228634477,
0.4551538825,
-0.369999975,
-0.1018684506,
-0.3611936867,
0.0335057974,
0.1870306581,
-1.0404514074,
0.4718166888,
-0.1626761705,
0.0958498269,
0.0732814297,
0.666675508,
-0.2368063331,
1.0790916681,
0.5337599516,
-0.0347181186,
0.6899497509,
-0.1050050333,
0.4361521304,
-0.442825675,
-0.2060093135,
-0.4103041291,
-0.6016251445,
-0.2498895228,
-0.7046114802,
0.2235126644,
0.2278176397,
-0.3240536749,
0.4769500792,
-0.5046060085,
0.4772311151,
0.2761357427,
-0.0096945548,
0.1609411091,
-0.1369234771,
0.2638438642,
0.0275819954,
-0.4697134197,
-0.8119639754,
0.6478474736,
0.3316530883,
0.4290356934,
0.3903565109,
0.7763904929,
0.682836771,
0.726682663,
-0.76164639,
0.6866596341,
0.0077784606,
-0.768461585,
-0.1260491908,
-0.2750423551,
-1.2222954035,
0.0120613994,
-0.3605450094,
-0.8355811238,
0.3228195906,
0.0066601224,
-0.4520458281,
0.5422471166,
-0.4999383688,
0.9603633881,
-0.3539590538,
-0.1220353842,
-0.194256559,
-0.7361690402,
-0.0760753825,
-0.1512315124,
0.4159111381,
-0.6164004207,
-0.0466256663,
0.8901072145,
-0.1475737095,
1.118645072,
-0.202343449,
0.347322613,
0.268702358,
-0.2387069762,
0.0061889784,
-0.0304586552,
0.3826490343,
0.1995803118,
0.2860506177,
-0.2210526913,
-0.1341053993,
0.3369187415,
-0.4973405302,
-0.5721499324,
-0.1477015615,
0.0634499341,
-0.0545590557,
0.1412483603,
0.281221956,
0.4369786382,
-0.7332959771,
0.3694250584,
0.4126261771,
0.2964856625,
0.8686413169,
0.5885792375,
-0.1556046754,
-0.4284129739,
0.564982295,
0.3955904841,
0.0245498735,
0.3914706707,
0.433051765,
-0.2810753882,
-0.4833068848,
-0.5165866613,
0.0863007978,
-0.5073555708,
-0.2393643409,
-0.672414422,
0.1000275016,
-0.4462537766,
-0.4086582959,
-0.3320278525,
-0.1894536018,
-0.2956078649,
-0.2363151312,
0.3658653498,
0.7389782667,
-0.2484361082,
0.5271880627,
-0.7963702679,
0.4386093616,
0.1778951585,
0.0767755285,
-0.3335869312,
-0.0461334847,
-0.5367072821,
0.1961458325,
-0.7667922378,
-1.855363369,
0.0341316126,
-0.2554352283,
0.427059859,
0.548007071,
0.4278629422,
0.5392247438,
-0.5065277815,
0.7837738991,
0.4450189471,
-0.8304624557,
0.8120881319,
-0.6728954315,
-0.0917462558,
0.4214349389,
1.1107667685,
-0.6044989824,
-0.2483033389,
-0.416341424,
-0.9066298008,
0.1521596462,
-0.1896968037,
0.497751385,
-0.4426792562,
0.3461816609,
-0.4249201119,
0.127456218,
-0.7155109644,
0.0212588571,
-0.2935180962,
-0.1336624324,
0.0070153056,
-0.1288021654,
-0.7946986556,
-0.2795948088,
0.3625619709,
-0.230170235,
0.1086939424,
0.2132941484,
0.2377917022,
-0.5336164236,
-0.0583185516,
0.3540516794,
0.6664341092,
0.0594449453,
-0.1731624454,
-0.2255485356,
-0.2175591737,
0.4204855859,
0.0040698517,
-0.2094645649,
0.1971732825,
0.2934009731,
1.0598660707,
0.1988020539,
-0.2517109811,
0.5846087337,
-0.1043983921,
-0.6063309312,
-0.3249039352,
-0.1449463367,
0.5330488682,
0.843667984,
0.6067485213,
-0.2388807833,
0.1220433637,
-0.8393251896,
-0.2407826334,
0.5040504336,
-0.8148488402,
-0.4400947094,
0.7848727703,
0.1200295314,
-0.9336619377,
-0.2171165943,
0.0092681386,
-0.4650586247,
0.2910693586,
0.2062085569,
0.9952844977,
-0.1448097825,
0.7195620537,
0.1348599792,
0.3886635602,
-0.2574144304,
0.0254178066,
-0.048023358,
-0.8890880346,
-0.25148651,
-0.2644881904,
-0.233260572,
-0.0290836412,
-0.8799996972,
0.18381311,
-0.4484316707,
-0.7530351877,
0.3820803463,
0.1136154681,
-0.3287212849,
-0.119875297,
0.0863949955,
0.709053874,
-1.2435698509,
0.3754110336,
1.0392898321,
-0.2488750964,
-0.5613570213,
0.199542284,
0.5262999535,
-0.5609775782,
0.2279987186,
0.3633319438,
-0.0806887522,
-0.2588694692,
-0.5333091617,
-0.6044761539,
1.0397315025,
0.4998800457,
-0.2835382223,
0.3835988045,
0.1331061423,
0.495354861,
-0.4208216667,
-0.3495445848,
0.3926397562,
0.4553169012,
0.1193692461,
-0.4081057906,
0.0755090788,
-0.1289450675,
0.1422424614,
0.5517573357,
-1.0669183731,
0.244128257,
-0.1551147401,
-0.7531839609,
-0.2409795672,
0.3219179511,
-0.1385411918,
0.6293593645,
0.4095524549,
0.3343523741,
0.2465066761,
-0.3887372613,
1.0725073814,
-0.3070343435,
0.0464717299,
0.3657670617,
-0.0648059621,
0.8651512861,
0.5155825615,
0.088386111,
0.1922282279,
0.7102198005,
0.405801326,
0.3769092858,
0.1583252549,
-0.4215081334,
-0.3202299178,
-0.0141630275,
-0.2511608601,
0.5127043128,
0.3110804558,
-0.3256001472,
-0.4713080227,
0.1708500087,
0.1661087722,
0.4332329929,
-0.3174712062,
0.8096401691,
0.0759599656,
-0.2870505154,
0.0769951865,
0.0521447584,
0.1064929292,
-0.6264401078,
0.1411609054,
-0.0644968972,
-0.1188152805,
0.0856349245,
-0.6928739548,
1.0417497158,
-0.2452404499,
-0.2922306359,
-0.6074715257,
0.8377109766,
-0.3470215797,
-0.2259176075,
0.4755175412,
0.5040675402,
0.0177778583,
-0.1979469359,
-0.95494771,
0.7504093051,
-0.1821201891,
-0.313559562,
0.4110624492,
0.4392131567,
-0.2526951432,
0.4895050824,
0.565248549,
0.1645377725,
0.0246711578,
0.0608640425,
0.730230689,
-0.6495350599,
-0.0855863765,
-0.9343103766,
0.5749737024,
-0.3446950614,
-0.3959552348,
0.6850043535,
0.2793740034,
0.475888133,
0.1872572303,
0.3371142745,
-0.0544897355,
0.5417797565,
-0.4062071741,
0.6842162609,
-0.6224533916,
-0.2657955587,
-0.0303483196,
-0.4076170623,
-0.3094134033,
0.651620388,
-0.2763426006,
-0.4053716362,
0.1718132645,
0.7938611507,
0.2929985821,
0.1839572787,
0.2069957703,
0.0208734348,
0.2958469689,
0.1233747378,
0.8930200934,
-0.216628328,
0.3429159522,
0.203488782,
-0.1393959969,
-0.3020690382,
-0.7971882224,
-1.0798237324,
-1.0133292675,
-0.7263021469,
-0.421267122,
0.3006114364,
0.8497161269,
0.871922493,
-0.252515167,
-0.0777188241,
0.2116562724,
0.4789060652,
-0.1432024539,
-0.216013059,
0.1547893733,
0.01683807,
-0.3494148552,
0.2632239759,
0.4314909577,
0.0587121993,
-0.1701418012,
0.1016538516,
-0.4270502925,
0.2917345166,
0.8006824255,
0.5557920337,
-0.4961172938,
-0.2346852869,
-0.1920698881,
0.0990433097,
-0.2824131846,
1.0920575857,
-0.1852875054,
0.264729321,
0.5306968093,
0.7482774854,
0.5531411171,
-0.0144016519,
0.5348320007,
-0.4565838873,
-0.1956967711,
0.2270335853,
0.3647598326,
0.4345033169,
-0.2042477429,
0.6466596127,
0.5616204143,
-0.356176734,
-0.8022252917,
0.173746109,
-0.7752535343,
-0.2034674734,
1.3084995747,
0.14480865,
-0.2773623466,
-0.4416884184,
-0.0333778188,
0.4390852451,
-0.1503838897,
0.7781401277,
0.8240076303,
0.1295831203,
-0.4106422663,
-0.7491523027,
0.4433091581,
0.0322012752,
-0.4008893073,
-0.2577010095,
0.3906039894,
0.2410505563,
0.1093450785,
1.2750276327,
-0.1700611264,
0.1355262995,
-0.4316084385,
-0.4857957065,
0.2465052754,
-0.2510594428,
-0.0491167568,
0.1214090735,
-0.5571833849,
-0.3841119111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13807v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13807v2 | AlanaVLM: A Multimodal Embodied AI Foundation Model for Egocentric Video Understanding | 2024-06-19T20:14:14 | 2024-06-21T09:53:41 | Alessandro Suglia, Claudio Greco, Katie Baker, Jose L. Part, Ioannis Papaioannou, Arash Eshghi, Ioannis Konstas, Oliver Lemon | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | AI personal assistants deployed via robots or wearables require embodied
understanding to collaborate with humans effectively. However, current
Vision-Language Models (VLMs) primarily focus on third-person view videos,
neglecting the richness of egocentric perceptual experience. To address this
gap, we propose three key contributions. First, we introduce the Egocentric
Video Understanding Dataset (EVUD) for training VLMs on video captioning and
question answering tasks specific to egocentric videos. Second, we present
AlanaVLM, a 7B parameter VLM trained using parameter-efficient methods on EVUD.
Finally, we evaluate AlanaVLM's capabilities on OpenEQA, a challenging
benchmark for embodied video question answering. Our model achieves
state-of-the-art performance, outperforming open-source models including strong
Socratic models using GPT-4 as a planner by 3.6%. Additionally, we outperform
Claude 3 and Gemini Pro Vision 1.0 and showcase competitive results compared to
Gemini Pro 1.5 and GPT-4V, even surpassing the latter in spatial reasoning.
This research paves the way for building efficient VLMs that can be deployed in
robots or wearables, leveraging embodied video understanding to collaborate
seamlessly with humans in everyday tasks, contributing to the next generation
of Embodied AI. | [
-0.5908335447,
-0.6824739575,
0.6801242828,
0.0143358409,
-0.2045381218,
-0.2793023884,
0.0126763824,
-0.6802837253,
0.0762516484,
0.5617694855,
-0.8087947965,
-0.5464878082,
-0.5885840058,
0.1240355074,
-0.5358129144,
0.4335920513,
-0.1128517464,
0.1317656785,
-0.5175524354,
-0.6579947472,
-0.3359731436,
-0.5193065405,
-0.1337350607,
-0.1661034524,
0.2813797295,
0.4043408632,
0.6696279645,
0.4834817648,
0.2226317227,
0.3711140454,
0.4883186519,
0.3981921375,
-0.0464880131,
0.1221678406,
0.2322446257,
-0.3507217467,
-0.4772826433,
-0.1013623774,
0.4402905107,
0.5307394266,
-0.2441819757,
0.3678064644,
-0.1264953315,
0.5274413824,
-0.6384453177,
0.1706923544,
-0.2968231142,
0.2462738007,
0.1293687969,
0.2651895285,
-0.1914438307,
0.1955736428,
0.0000199003,
-0.7766920328,
0.2107322067,
0.1999143362,
0.5212068558,
0.8523395061,
-0.0490677319,
0.0865433738,
-0.7943860292,
0.3448715508,
-0.4656640291,
0.8286008239,
0.6721948981,
0.5779054165,
0.528303802,
-0.6947497725,
-0.9788611531,
-0.1759914607,
0.2100556195,
0.1067833304,
-0.1553536355,
0.3831324577,
-0.149713695,
0.0901110321,
-0.7580028176,
-0.0986857936,
-0.4475491345,
0.1804120094,
0.6733649373,
0.2666363418,
0.2482337356,
-0.1149116307,
-0.1490945816,
-0.1479850262,
-0.2555354536,
-0.190375641,
0.1731766909,
-0.1109949499,
-0.1771393716,
0.7085785866,
-0.1474652737,
1.0647447109,
0.174239412,
0.2593615949,
0.0722906291,
-0.2223353982,
-0.6777393818,
-0.1752783805,
0.3583814502,
0.2647531033,
0.0430977494,
-0.1164319441,
0.1297345906,
-0.0002725422,
0.7289451957,
-0.4931534827,
-0.3213572204,
0.3831410408,
-0.3730546236,
0.1577411294,
0.1525391638,
-0.2373601198,
-0.3529952765,
-0.772280097,
0.6470297575,
-0.2597505748,
-0.0094677815,
0.2556325793,
0.1415965855,
0.5369002819,
0.7651753426,
-0.6346277595,
0.3300930262,
0.6011491418,
0.7737253308,
0.3233401775,
-0.6750347018,
-0.5478675961,
0.3612869084,
-0.2307781577,
0.6392636895,
-0.3079786003,
0.0049459767,
0.0882173032,
-0.1148664951,
0.0911176428,
-0.4638304114,
0.1206346527,
-0.2685546577,
0.1983412951,
-0.1425571889,
-0.2538600564,
-0.6856061816,
0.3958126903,
-0.5841141343,
0.5423474312,
-0.1340654939,
-0.2052806318,
0.4233490527,
-0.6962871552,
-0.148158595,
0.3613792956,
-0.5496612191,
-0.2971803546,
-0.0413718186,
0.3044991493,
0.6793702245,
-0.1795101315,
0.0054465635,
-0.4143287241,
-0.1003452912,
-0.0317592248,
-0.2751215696,
0.5685813427,
0.0465939343,
-0.3951740861,
0.2603079379,
-0.4775354564,
-0.1820584983,
-0.1801857054,
0.3731552362,
-0.2259007692,
0.0169834662,
0.0855542868,
0.1576745957,
0.0668736622,
-0.3828808367,
-0.1191296577,
-0.1881279796,
0.3872865736,
0.9551654458,
-0.3137608171,
0.2883864343,
-0.1932140589,
0.6832551956,
-0.2561566532,
0.7076771259,
-0.0753534362,
-0.5119390488,
-0.6929433346,
-0.493158102,
-0.5527836084,
0.154964745,
-0.7832944989,
0.1856176257,
0.0807823315,
-0.3651279807,
-0.9521393776,
0.3699477613,
0.5057913065,
0.4533714652,
0.3675811589,
-0.5772271752,
-0.3557499945,
-0.9973471165,
-0.1604518443,
-0.6509025097,
0.0142581938,
0.8692598343,
0.4669175446,
-0.3030329645,
0.7298887372,
-0.3919914365,
-0.5453351736,
-0.1011805832,
0.1112066954,
0.0397095233,
0.0714619979,
0.6738384962,
-1.1052459478,
-0.4143401682,
0.1360498667,
-1.1014639139,
0.1630669385,
-0.0375897884,
-0.0398518145,
-0.1245625392,
0.3405343592,
-0.7039841413,
0.6143821478,
0.599637568,
-0.4708591104,
0.5486631989,
-0.5019309521,
0.259855032,
-0.4759018123,
0.0087801972,
-0.0446611755,
-0.6160715222,
-0.6333771944,
0.4296158254,
-0.2313398123,
-0.052585911,
-0.6361578107,
0.6594229937,
-0.5686192513,
-0.5646526217,
-0.0790736675,
0.2600806355,
-0.0546394698,
0.7111331224,
0.1461201906,
0.6778706908,
0.5478157997,
-0.6570840478,
0.6414851546,
0.739921689,
-0.3568583727,
0.8482909799,
-0.8393307924,
0.3253502548,
-0.5815557241,
-0.0409577899,
-0.9438315034,
-0.5782741904,
0.4190935194,
-0.6197954416,
0.0411313809,
-0.0031580292,
-0.3430074155,
-0.3398469687,
-0.0687692016,
0.59858042,
0.3102034628,
-0.6470078826,
1.213994503,
0.3942007124,
0.0093464293,
-0.4691750407,
-0.6431430578,
0.0101787634,
-0.1899336725,
-0.8077254891,
-0.031768579,
-0.3523081243,
-0.4522096813,
0.0464377813,
0.0159433931,
-0.1881139278,
-0.0145081449,
0.4525876939,
0.1739694923,
0.0072363731,
0.025135057,
-0.1870072931,
0.1054521948,
0.0270527992,
-0.4206500351,
0.307618767,
-0.3998735845,
-0.7598566413,
-0.6486111283,
0.5050138831,
0.7202684879,
-0.2934804261,
0.753809154,
0.7193208933,
-0.3242694139,
0.0513023473,
-0.6705393195,
-0.1299055666,
-0.4301934838,
0.6175289154,
-0.2025612444,
-0.6838243008,
0.3623593152,
0.5182788372,
0.1981713921,
0.0225310531,
0.8701244593,
-0.3515828848,
0.9912011027,
0.7259595394,
0.0976769552,
0.5205719471,
-0.364251405,
-0.0684196278,
-0.8989456296,
-0.5149475932,
-0.171669811,
-0.3003892601,
0.0395015776,
-0.6146335006,
0.8166182041,
-0.4720616639,
-0.5927427411,
0.2890531123,
-0.3430722058,
0.3335152864,
0.4645561576,
0.3266094327,
0.1929860711,
-0.2011136413,
0.3289730251,
0.1531362385,
-0.6474734545,
-0.3320641518,
0.8958998919,
0.1251456439,
0.6607663035,
0.3822587132,
0.3303690553,
0.4784616232,
0.2821329832,
-0.4147707224,
0.5301283598,
-0.0174888894,
-0.7667686343,
-0.3601546884,
0.1518217623,
-0.6061784029,
0.3854120374,
0.0591514297,
-0.6166270971,
0.2354794443,
0.4839275777,
-0.4820985496,
0.1394497901,
-0.6106710434,
0.8652831912,
-0.3704866469,
-0.677298367,
-0.345513761,
-0.9537600279,
0.3221663535,
0.4001022577,
0.2580144107,
0.1518129855,
-0.1589481384,
0.3139041066,
-0.3657348156,
0.8610764742,
-0.3084367216,
0.1209340617,
0.2848032415,
0.0516154543,
0.1734295338,
0.1402115524,
0.3726418614,
0.3133657873,
-0.3182277083,
-0.4536240697,
-0.6746121049,
0.3548170626,
-0.9763189554,
-0.6146149635,
-0.1821346283,
-0.2996559441,
-0.0674349442,
-0.1269297749,
0.0793185979,
0.4995578527,
-0.0845123231,
0.2668957114,
0.5927877426,
-0.1122148782,
0.1452173889,
0.3286968172,
-0.2039062828,
-0.4413531125,
0.5035116076,
-0.2167976946,
0.2531705499,
0.3140201271,
-0.2784150541,
-0.2978848815,
-0.2084237039,
-0.7294633985,
0.3635437191,
-0.8485791683,
-0.1078409925,
-0.8792562485,
0.0452984311,
-0.3230877519,
-0.3387601972,
-0.4427840114,
-0.1048389897,
-0.3762783408,
-0.3437602222,
0.1976427138,
0.8121871948,
-0.129321292,
0.1648897827,
-0.5799891353,
0.6277103424,
0.7751566768,
0.1645619571,
0.1991828978,
-0.5019613504,
-0.3505215049,
-0.0503709763,
-0.1499684155,
-0.8212544918,
0.5311956406,
0.3721114993,
0.5716950297,
0.5221347809,
-0.209533751,
1.0972479582,
-0.5680888295,
0.8788585663,
0.0778406262,
-0.7885062695,
0.2293150425,
-0.2102735639,
0.1898416579,
0.5703392029,
0.3409047127,
-0.5529100895,
-0.2110576183,
-0.6249212623,
-0.7251986861,
0.705965519,
0.3920938969,
0.1144968793,
0.2475623935,
0.4818026423,
0.3721982539,
0.5600486398,
-0.6836029887,
-0.2790060341,
-0.4543580413,
-0.3936096132,
-0.364400357,
0.1783354282,
-0.0746240169,
-0.5192761421,
0.5790453553,
-0.1795593202,
0.5092054009,
0.5795867443,
-0.3138697445,
-0.0480428636,
-0.4391172826,
0.6090531349,
0.5650969744,
0.0400798097,
0.0166744348,
0.0544588417,
-0.5655428171,
0.1229586378,
0.0140642924,
0.0732375011,
-0.1128309742,
0.5755698681,
0.8746387362,
-0.0788949877,
-0.8879134655,
0.5349074006,
-0.1883865744,
-0.2241613269,
-0.8988572359,
0.0033315641,
-0.2930117846,
0.6074319482,
0.24606511,
0.2807689011,
0.4192005396,
-0.6682377458,
0.0960825309,
0.4633929729,
-0.4740901589,
-0.7261471748,
1.132620573,
0.146435827,
-0.4755670428,
0.5324329138,
0.1304299533,
-0.48755458,
0.6202635765,
-0.0051292307,
1.1498010159,
-0.2695201933,
0.347635299,
0.1161872,
0.3960018754,
0.1429517865,
0.2265266925,
-0.7773390412,
-0.6379011273,
-0.2367575616,
-0.2296811789,
-0.4082454443,
-0.2040632963,
-0.6237197518,
0.2121394277,
-0.3978734016,
0.20313631,
-0.0162075236,
-0.3908168375,
-1.0864822865,
0.1082039103,
0.3093655407,
0.3955545127,
-0.8808259964,
0.4533744752,
0.8856195211,
-0.4313791096,
-0.5343285799,
-0.2086287141,
0.0399841592,
-0.9492173195,
0.5817040205,
0.035359025,
-0.343488127,
-0.0494451486,
-0.9192252159,
-0.5528054833,
1.2600187063,
0.3875872791,
-0.3646984696,
-0.2153283805,
-0.2580862343,
0.5081878304,
-0.3783435822,
0.4688512087,
0.1678427756,
0.4794213772,
0.1353767514,
-0.7788383961,
-0.5592032671,
-0.3017164171,
-0.1078614369,
0.0192414951,
-0.8696557283,
0.7799658179,
-0.2122452855,
0.2288450003,
0.294811666,
0.7953306437,
0.1000652611,
0.6108360887,
0.3392737806,
0.4924784899,
0.487924993,
0.4607004523,
1.2872488499,
0.0839193165,
0.087109156,
1.1386967897,
-0.3933720887,
0.5617188811,
0.4844317138,
-0.1298214197,
0.4839583933,
0.2345162332,
0.3475347459,
0.5071741939,
-0.3491433263,
-0.3829511702,
-0.6686733961,
0.144291088,
-0.1565829813,
0.7661570311,
0.1973719299,
-0.1888570338,
0.1481406391,
0.56701231,
-0.3958344758,
0.1912698895,
-0.3152486086,
0.9848262072,
-0.0058323685,
-0.6410304904,
0.3408592641,
-0.230468601,
0.0803213641,
-0.5275075436,
-0.2324125767,
-0.205705002,
0.2918227315,
0.0151090622,
-0.4957797229,
0.1285003722,
0.1531270295,
-0.0205006637,
-0.1808967739,
0.454662323,
-0.3934384882,
-0.3190049231,
0.1413091868,
0.3844077289,
0.3531428277,
-0.2356041521,
-0.5898563862,
0.0042892769,
-0.1289498955,
0.1176571846,
0.1000890136,
0.363405019,
0.0945811942,
0.9037539363,
0.2892072201,
-0.1711140275,
0.1155040786,
-0.0596553795,
0.8355361223,
-0.4227893651,
-0.584836483,
-0.7365888953,
0.6427900195,
0.0197764654,
-0.1794771403,
0.7366859913,
0.2311667949,
0.853305459,
-0.2250937074,
0.6723448038,
-0.1444062442,
0.0810634047,
-0.4812746942,
0.5766612887,
-0.8916143179,
-0.0495087653,
-0.3963074386,
-0.8466259241,
-0.3626302481,
1.0068359375,
-0.1011914983,
0.1163219884,
0.2415970564,
0.4055867195,
-0.114282243,
-0.0061071124,
0.6060256362,
0.5092490911,
0.3219326138,
0.5257319212,
0.7152992487,
-0.369617641,
0.2193417549,
-0.1571025699,
-0.2290877998,
-0.4010262489,
-0.5153362751,
-0.9162145257,
-1.0716557503,
-0.2301428169,
0.1055816337,
0.3772981763,
1.028399229,
1.0706076622,
-0.1585721672,
-0.2636014521,
-0.2152464092,
-0.2222586423,
-0.3826235831,
-0.0756772086,
0.1197327003,
0.2357230186,
-0.6984779835,
0.1784571111,
0.4503362775,
-0.168561995,
-0.7974905372,
-0.5468207598,
-0.1810718924,
0.0167627893,
0.8504834771,
0.4857088923,
-0.901247263,
-0.5606126189,
0.2142667919,
0.4474160671,
0.0642480403,
0.5732759833,
-0.8919150829,
0.8936973214,
0.1621306837,
0.6336025596,
0.7787398696,
0.3318085372,
0.5422379971,
-0.6558914781,
0.3819314837,
0.4254368246,
0.2486442327,
0.3939187527,
-0.3772004843,
0.465466857,
0.1531234831,
-0.5633403659,
-0.6484209299,
0.2277598828,
-0.9578686953,
-0.1707598567,
0.9684771895,
-0.0356368646,
-0.5807604194,
-0.1947455406,
-0.4601889849,
0.0029679253,
-0.0531557091,
0.7490618229,
0.5921760798,
-0.357483536,
-0.5389739275,
-0.7097355723,
0.1298562288,
0.3896863461,
-0.8140459657,
0.0430900864,
0.7214154005,
-0.0928305387,
-0.12167532,
0.732960701,
0.0521727018,
0.7413836718,
-0.1647602618,
0.1812329292,
-0.5239836574,
-0.7933721542,
-0.423663497,
0.0322165936,
0.0238628648,
-0.3386246264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13805v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13805v1 | WikiContradict: A Benchmark for Evaluating LLMs on Real-World Knowledge Conflicts from Wikipedia | 2024-06-19T20:13:42 | 2024-06-19T20:13:42 | Yufang Hou, Alessandra Pascale, Javier Carnerero-Cano, Tigran Tchrakian, Radu Marinescu, Elizabeth Daly, Inkit Padhi, Prasanna Sattigeri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has emerged as a promising solution to
mitigate the limitations of large language models (LLMs), such as
hallucinations and outdated information. However, it remains unclear how LLMs
handle knowledge conflicts arising from different augmented retrieved passages,
especially when these passages originate from the same source and have equal
trustworthiness. In this work, we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of
LLM-generated answers to questions that have varying answers based on
contradictory passages from Wikipedia, a dataset widely regarded as a
high-quality pre-training resource for most LLMs. Specifically, we introduce
WikiContradict, a benchmark consisting of 253 high-quality, human-annotated
instances designed to assess LLM performance when augmented with retrieved
passages containing real-world knowledge conflicts. We benchmark a diverse
range of both closed and open-source LLMs under different QA scenarios,
including RAG with a single passage, and RAG with 2 contradictory passages.
Through rigorous human evaluations on a subset of WikiContradict instances
involving 5 LLMs and over 3,500 judgements, we shed light on the behaviour and
limitations of these models. For instance, when provided with two passages
containing contradictory facts, all models struggle to generate answers that
accurately reflect the conflicting nature of the context, especially for
implicit conflicts requiring reasoning. Since human evaluation is costly, we
also introduce an automated model that estimates LLM performance using a strong
open-source language model, achieving an F-score of 0.8. Using this automated
metric, we evaluate more than 1,500 answers from seven LLMs across all
WikiContradict instances. To facilitate future work, we release WikiContradict
on: https://ibm.biz/wikicontradict. | [
-0.4833897054,
-0.5663528442,
0.5080193281,
0.1035055965,
-0.2560884953,
0.1855790913,
-0.1760006249,
-0.7875049114,
0.152030617,
0.2749066949,
-0.5727034211,
-0.1933408827,
-0.565549016,
0.238482818,
-0.3465884328,
1.0944267511,
-0.3127501905,
0.1618911326,
-0.6960305572,
-0.3209867477,
-0.3314544857,
-0.2323829234,
0.0110938922,
-0.4482870698,
0.5506832004,
0.2284977883,
0.4816444814,
0.05457104,
0.5218408108,
0.3047916293,
-0.0581793934,
0.2490468174,
-0.6551929116,
0.7111927271,
-0.4545788765,
-0.1694422215,
-0.0719319284,
0.2535577416,
0.2890714109,
0.4478752613,
-0.1503941119,
0.7073483467,
-0.0234889053,
0.6040295362,
-0.904133141,
-0.2350565344,
-0.7094484568,
0.0229643285,
-0.2563707232,
-0.0339145511,
-0.2267778963,
-0.7209196091,
0.3476986289,
-0.7989928126,
0.0235077161,
0.0147054149,
1.0906660557,
0.4758325815,
-0.4074982405,
-0.4380125105,
-0.7419162989,
0.4373212755,
-0.5608412623,
0.4450794458,
0.2548942566,
0.3426575363,
-0.3935483396,
-0.8788995147,
-0.7448279262,
-0.4104988873,
0.1251635998,
0.4051511288,
-0.1900557429,
-0.2505786121,
0.4139406383,
0.007969371,
-0.5576149225,
-0.0785162449,
-0.3453409076,
-0.2940618694,
0.5299621224,
0.1845022142,
0.0074990392,
-0.5187034011,
-0.5597201586,
-0.0423544869,
-0.6670136452,
0.0276435409,
0.6078397036,
-0.4285538197,
0.1829786897,
0.7140391469,
-0.4772689641,
0.6398502588,
0.1135248244,
-0.1786654741,
0.1999960542,
-0.0756540895,
0.0997440293,
-0.253418237,
0.796710372,
0.4443032444,
0.1380598098,
-0.3449878693,
-0.2602615654,
0.0153294411,
0.6302645206,
-0.7265586257,
-0.1220747605,
0.0790126324,
-0.206582427,
-0.3760673702,
-0.0444211699,
-0.6416192055,
-0.449395597,
-0.2123121172,
0.7615795135,
-0.4619827867,
-0.2764879167,
-0.237767294,
-0.2762701511,
0.0487375595,
0.4156162143,
-0.2795044184,
0.1076992452,
0.6657395363,
0.5680745244,
-0.3367915154,
-0.2598422468,
-0.3739319742,
0.0527155064,
-0.2584959269,
1.1318292618,
-0.3363652825,
-0.269585073,
-0.1841084659,
-0.4146369398,
0.0812263191,
-0.6393745542,
0.6870440245,
-0.7497166991,
0.3170401454,
-0.3582893908,
-0.818264544,
0.0333766155,
0.6129412055,
-0.6699799299,
1.2826786041,
0.1401726156,
-1.0751544237,
0.5267802477,
-0.3973306715,
-0.0814481452,
0.4576326609,
-0.3215728402,
-0.2847931683,
0.2119694054,
-0.4898958206,
0.1508043259,
-0.5935217738,
0.2272403985,
-0.3451558352,
-0.3975894153,
0.4349216819,
-0.519387126,
0.5808977485,
0.1709439754,
-0.4151453972,
-0.1310975701,
-0.7527791858,
0.214060843,
0.119096227,
-0.485301882,
-0.6437453628,
0.0347818062,
-0.1007657051,
0.4438380301,
0.4643450975,
-0.742130518,
0.0174396057,
-0.1954275817,
-0.2577130497,
0.8907291293,
0.0818607956,
-0.086258091,
-0.4390072227,
0.6956561804,
-0.1488974541,
0.3023946881,
0.3723772764,
-0.4721425772,
-0.5959743261,
0.0770306587,
0.3852663934,
0.4703425467,
-0.9628162384,
0.3002966642,
-0.5039024949,
-0.6916366816,
-0.7078837156,
0.0808131844,
0.5070100427,
0.7856231332,
0.2297951579,
-0.2772242129,
-0.3310390711,
-1.0134755373,
-0.4935673773,
-0.308942169,
0.0597291924,
0.4425207675,
0.4793471992,
0.0453653075,
1.04730165,
-0.2350280583,
0.140813902,
0.2065197527,
0.3690407872,
-0.0370349921,
0.0516774841,
0.2087821513,
-0.9168377519,
-0.7117744088,
-0.0085679879,
-0.7806766629,
-0.380194068,
0.2085654736,
-0.103804037,
0.1951912642,
0.1708074063,
-0.8335229158,
0.3197769523,
0.740362227,
-0.5027554035,
1.0580222607,
-0.0155707793,
0.4164155126,
-1.0983492136,
0.3298888206,
-0.2834462821,
-0.2239940017,
-0.3665335178,
0.102589339,
0.2392788231,
0.2998398542,
-0.5411661863,
0.5872704983,
-0.2618680596,
-0.1303588003,
-0.0846936479,
0.4596267343,
0.0213909447,
0.2577023804,
-0.4048486948,
1.0276800394,
-0.1550836712,
-0.3201197088,
0.5976448059,
0.2187298238,
-0.6982885599,
0.7911592126,
-0.3872214854,
0.1592470109,
0.0391489826,
0.2730512619,
-0.8163779378,
-0.1551216692,
0.1076947749,
-0.3891535997,
-0.0031809746,
-0.2678334117,
-0.6958336234,
-0.2543389201,
-0.4280859828,
0.363706857,
0.4991346598,
-0.5395931005,
0.5970429182,
0.2737215757,
-0.1540153027,
-0.9188807607,
0.0249247197,
0.0252583735,
-0.0283524245,
-0.6356899738,
0.2400096655,
-0.3134672642,
-0.3603758216,
0.3069663346,
-0.4857384562,
0.1096781343,
0.1886695772,
0.3928965628,
0.2714119852,
0.0005717778,
0.1191150844,
0.0641507134,
-0.0788570717,
0.1993029118,
-0.1675275713,
0.4658685327,
0.2265621126,
-0.4795012474,
0.1001429856,
0.0490397401,
0.5176160336,
-0.0722506344,
0.5062515736,
0.5124453902,
-0.1598002762,
-0.1804071367,
-1.0150864124,
0.0819634795,
-0.4450721741,
0.3627462983,
-0.4370322526,
-0.8318266273,
0.4710741639,
-0.3674462438,
0.1366921365,
0.5764648914,
0.6596351862,
-0.404597789,
0.6817346215,
0.1820291728,
0.136886999,
0.3039722145,
-0.0136185717,
-0.0529081747,
-0.8361670971,
-0.4841665328,
-0.5189571977,
-0.2970527112,
-0.6025824547,
-0.3774671257,
0.454644233,
0.3101010025,
0.1247080341,
0.3487102091,
-0.2795146406,
0.7040033937,
0.2412944883,
-0.1475420296,
0.422942251,
-0.2480586618,
-0.5561052561,
-0.1200648919,
-0.549513936,
-0.5335420966,
1.1753634214,
0.0802259222,
0.6368027925,
0.3498679698,
0.7645107508,
0.2976415157,
0.8026542664,
-0.5275548697,
0.5278189182,
0.0858047381,
-0.7951142788,
-0.0938211977,
-0.6935153008,
-0.8661071062,
0.496489197,
-0.4751788974,
-0.5514196754,
-0.0680593774,
-0.0273463838,
0.0184561033,
0.2264623642,
-0.6922119856,
0.7769807577,
-0.2462820858,
-0.5283702016,
-0.3010670841,
-0.4173420966,
0.5477848053,
-0.3046434522,
0.0716597736,
-0.3928652704,
-0.1405327767,
0.8166117668,
-0.2265995294,
0.4495836198,
-0.1771803796,
-0.188763693,
0.0285567362,
0.2072429657,
0.5109185576,
-0.0090978276,
-0.0457487851,
0.1319588721,
0.2583472729,
-0.2382010967,
-0.5616703033,
0.8696087599,
-0.8702472448,
-0.6759651899,
-0.4355704784,
-0.5172911882,
-0.4470987618,
0.3113330305,
0.4907838404,
0.2807531655,
-0.5318540931,
-0.0701359361,
0.724327445,
-0.1171639264,
0.0461801589,
0.7978503108,
-0.1534363329,
-0.3489046693,
0.8550983071,
0.2599408925,
0.3250935674,
0.1249426454,
0.0562846772,
-0.2653461695,
-0.605335772,
-0.3881403804,
0.1602193564,
-0.8169541359,
-0.593129456,
-0.543839395,
-0.1149382889,
-0.1800345033,
0.2684588134,
-0.3255222142,
-0.662106514,
0.188381061,
0.1165055782,
0.3432816565,
1.0898556709,
0.1248254403,
-0.3922260106,
-0.7018766403,
0.3923284411,
0.3167925775,
0.5893836617,
-0.1582155079,
-0.4677370787,
-0.4087629914,
-0.171956718,
-0.5494421721,
-0.8938214779,
-0.0806033164,
-0.2195364684,
0.7292023301,
0.0250577535,
0.3472446203,
0.7525541186,
-0.647487402,
0.6133287549,
0.1234069467,
-0.6618589759,
0.2265804857,
-0.1077227518,
0.1669475883,
0.7455853224,
0.5011492372,
-0.6365822554,
-0.7367538214,
-0.6993979812,
-0.8547879457,
0.4632208943,
0.1618068516,
-0.0481643081,
-0.0579603575,
0.5290033817,
0.2144862264,
0.0455225296,
-0.5234425664,
-0.2732189894,
-0.0671770871,
-0.3245756924,
0.3433985412,
-0.2695334256,
-0.3481880128,
-0.0558392256,
0.7326664925,
0.0540904552,
0.0242249668,
0.1586399078,
-0.4789548516,
-0.3481144309,
0.2765791416,
0.6520836949,
0.8495419621,
-0.1890585274,
0.0546633564,
0.3627983034,
-0.7542476654,
0.3146937788,
0.3769327402,
-0.331335783,
0.0713636428,
0.4913361371,
0.4170484543,
0.2112819701,
-0.9155112505,
0.7710157633,
-0.3103129268,
-0.2679150701,
-0.4738542736,
0.0961384103,
0.1335970163,
0.3944067359,
0.5145722628,
0.0883832872,
0.1152689308,
-0.0696920156,
0.2774650753,
0.563367188,
-0.1158667207,
-0.242756024,
0.3943226337,
0.3198987842,
-0.2379792184,
0.281781137,
-0.2336951047,
-0.5752407312,
0.2382694632,
0.0989807174,
0.8252003789,
-0.1654862463,
0.1471181214,
0.1824976355,
0.1823795289,
0.2078853846,
0.0710687339,
-0.1758462787,
-0.6957021356,
-0.652836144,
-0.6287561059,
-0.665124774,
0.066959314,
-0.7829669714,
-0.0337241888,
-0.439470619,
-0.3416123688,
-0.0996205956,
0.4125234187,
-0.7739576101,
-0.1313026249,
-0.1400250494,
1.1330856085,
-0.5772450566,
0.9075407982,
0.6799773574,
-0.3999758959,
-0.534858048,
0.3460134268,
-0.0931176096,
-0.5773628354,
0.8172075152,
-0.1197969317,
-0.2842731774,
-0.1805075109,
-0.3834598362,
-0.7067716718,
1.2475491762,
0.5144175887,
-0.521841526,
0.1172624081,
-0.1117201149,
0.5119601488,
0.1080817878,
0.2456277162,
0.4628601074,
0.4189510047,
-0.0818756968,
-1.0521957874,
-0.0202091467,
-0.3427079618,
-0.1786101013,
0.3261737227,
-0.5722892284,
0.5173470974,
0.0878601819,
-0.2381882966,
0.1854085773,
0.4096886516,
0.3883484304,
0.1651449203,
0.5897698402,
0.6856378913,
0.6371256113,
-0.0742276385,
1.0206564665,
-0.3332485557,
0.4048474431,
1.0128782988,
-0.4486011863,
1.0624243021,
0.7291362882,
-0.1760800779,
0.5976532698,
0.3476534486,
0.1484853625,
0.4562093318,
0.1786981523,
-0.4878639281,
-0.1133597493,
-0.1024818718,
-0.2639337778,
0.2613062859,
0.1373786479,
0.1360462755,
-0.2534747422,
-0.0784520432,
-0.0875666589,
0.1592838019,
0.2454219013,
1.0784558058,
-0.2250567526,
-0.7861098647,
0.5025559068,
-0.0869182572,
0.7108870149,
-0.7171459794,
-0.1208988205,
-0.2872076929,
0.0063279499,
-0.1092605665,
-0.7922309637,
0.0165018849,
0.3229415417,
-0.1772989482,
0.0035180033,
0.6487816572,
-0.3509021997,
-0.3011421561,
0.4615584612,
0.5032451153,
0.0562580936,
0.3649177253,
-0.7500330806,
0.2599218488,
-0.077171728,
-0.5266098976,
0.4644345343,
0.6560063362,
0.0027004529,
0.6777837276,
0.6727357507,
0.3591989279,
0.0858383402,
-0.0690069795,
1.0592520237,
-0.4204149842,
-0.1426330358,
-0.499214977,
0.3930900991,
-0.3096263409,
-0.4424344897,
0.9082217813,
0.5975791216,
0.9463666677,
0.1562637389,
0.7240038514,
-0.1384074092,
0.8360355496,
-0.4439941645,
0.8079089522,
-0.4823762476,
0.2899823189,
-0.3169935644,
-0.9450988173,
0.1586808562,
0.6120212078,
-0.2528457642,
-0.0075562969,
0.5144608617,
0.5642545819,
-0.0959112868,
-0.0370844416,
0.5108320117,
0.3473030031,
0.3396183848,
0.3202627897,
1.1740279198,
-0.3836356997,
0.7794244289,
-0.3356899321,
-0.060628809,
-0.1603301913,
-0.8516938686,
-0.6475707293,
-0.6510509849,
-0.1020255908,
-0.5279181004,
0.1592523754,
1.1162490845,
0.4745664895,
-0.5364614129,
-0.0713609308,
0.3498030901,
0.215814501,
0.067360498,
-0.2130207866,
0.12459445,
-0.325345546,
-0.3862381279,
0.2959015667,
0.0654718354,
-0.1567857563,
-0.4994699955,
-0.4036795497,
-0.16795744,
0.1851615757,
0.5381505489,
0.126235947,
-0.7926101089,
-0.4815827608,
-0.2286691368,
-0.2862191498,
-0.3002380133,
0.8984178901,
-0.9245772362,
0.4490590096,
0.3956317604,
0.6556737423,
0.6674582958,
-0.0164526068,
0.39139238,
-0.7896818519,
-0.0211786404,
0.4161652029,
0.1394367069,
0.2975237072,
-0.1851346195,
0.4416732192,
0.3291332424,
-0.5227565765,
-0.9069766402,
0.1291274875,
-0.6459925771,
-0.2952385247,
0.8992618918,
-0.2641230524,
0.0225773323,
-0.2730052173,
0.0062465887,
0.0685623512,
-0.1488313973,
1.0127624273,
0.8758954406,
0.0032033792,
0.0482350215,
-0.7418367267,
0.5839282274,
0.3203194141,
-0.8599354029,
0.2023386508,
0.612660706,
0.6565431356,
0.2623311281,
0.4942317903,
-0.0550442263,
0.5709197521,
-0.0858938769,
0.1308037639,
-0.1721094102,
-0.1351671964,
-0.1542596966,
0.0906323493,
0.2996080816,
0.1551442146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13803v1 | Semantic Structure-Mapping in LLM and Human Analogical Reasoning | 2024-06-19T20:07:37 | 2024-06-19T20:07:37 | Sam Musker, Alex Duchnowski, Raphaël Millière, Ellie Pavlick | cs.CL | cs.CL | Analogical reasoning is considered core to human learning and cognition.
Recent studies have compared the analogical reasoning abilities of human
subjects and Large Language Models (LLMs) on abstract symbol manipulation
tasks, such as letter string analogies. However, these studies largely neglect
analogical reasoning over semantically meaningful symbols, such as natural
language words. This ability to draw analogies that link language to
non-linguistic domains, which we term semantic structure-mapping, is thought to
play a crucial role in language acquisition and broader cognitive development.
We test human subjects and LLMs on analogical reasoning tasks that require the
transfer of semantic structure and content from one domain to another. Advanced
LLMs match human performance across many task variations. However, humans and
LLMs respond differently to certain task variations and semantic distractors.
Overall, our data suggest that LLMs are approaching human-level performance on
these important cognitive tasks, but are not yet entirely human like. | [
-0.3302368224,
-0.8859809041,
0.7348137498,
-0.254360497,
-0.1972810924,
0.0827069059,
-0.2111363858,
-0.8137586117,
0.1430084556,
0.431527406,
-0.5512000322,
-0.6469349861,
-0.5276725888,
0.1762830466,
-0.2437006533,
0.5312161446,
-0.2685097754,
0.0236100983,
-0.2888203263,
-0.0794020146,
-0.3494329154,
-0.674701035,
-0.5455238223,
-0.6225332022,
0.4987260699,
0.1522466987,
0.706338048,
0.805586338,
0.5337732434,
0.3633337915,
-0.2830237448,
-0.1261592507,
-0.2913875282,
0.0532875806,
-0.5266740322,
-0.6927639246,
-0.7783880234,
-0.06119854,
0.6147886515,
1.2899097204,
0.1241743043,
0.1878855079,
-0.0113048777,
0.7360053658,
-0.4247997701,
0.3658241928,
-0.700073421,
-0.2862155735,
-0.046859324,
-0.1912860721,
-0.0405567251,
-0.2934827507,
0.2535015941,
-0.9284452796,
0.2623687685,
0.4708202183,
0.7964456677,
0.0854239166,
-0.4593265355,
-0.4560682774,
-0.4938419461,
0.7013728023,
-0.545940876,
0.3085696995,
0.3970532417,
0.0329743996,
-0.5819208026,
-0.4147026539,
-0.5678958893,
-0.5373744965,
-0.0692671388,
-0.1084662154,
0.0506148562,
0.3394132853,
0.4476157725,
0.1507669836,
-0.5171129107,
0.2495808154,
-0.5924195051,
-0.2421580404,
0.4708442688,
0.3300481439,
0.7125965357,
-0.138159126,
-0.6176180243,
-0.177972585,
-1.0067667961,
-0.0186509043,
0.4203902781,
0.3712382913,
0.019293705,
0.7092964053,
-0.2383915037,
0.9026950002,
-0.2551905215,
-0.2636540532,
0.0617736392,
-0.3191586435,
0.0361776128,
0.2541860044,
0.4439554513,
0.5971678495,
0.7317796946,
-0.2486177385,
-0.0863032043,
0.7033731341,
0.2106380612,
-0.4559671283,
-0.1953527629,
-0.0125033716,
-0.3731295466,
0.08489611,
-0.0046580592,
-0.3768093884,
0.0369247198,
-0.5701780915,
0.436131686,
-0.4487975538,
-0.1146201119,
0.3172498345,
-0.2864869833,
0.3789863586,
0.3441170454,
-1.0496873856,
0.6827161312,
0.8065276742,
0.462715745,
-0.5585645437,
-0.5355139375,
0.0896956772,
0.2941571176,
-0.4322172105,
1.002658844,
-0.520862639,
-0.4442954361,
-0.1871462911,
-0.0535424761,
-0.1177075133,
-0.7550101876,
0.5514617562,
-0.3734030128,
-0.0228165109,
-0.5059541464,
-0.5758942962,
-0.5239676237,
0.4195793867,
-0.5519067645,
0.8140858412,
0.3570339978,
-0.4150301516,
0.2670273781,
-0.453738302,
-0.6000041366,
-0.0651036799,
-0.3140838146,
0.023508409,
0.1735380888,
-0.1548558623,
0.1953911334,
-0.5570163131,
-0.0736200064,
-0.4398667812,
-0.7392868996,
0.3340482116,
0.1932950467,
0.5926828384,
-0.0723279566,
-0.2645222247,
0.3079712689,
-0.5979902148,
0.0917984694,
0.087709561,
-0.2448048294,
-0.5997154117,
0.1994972676,
-0.0158099215,
0.5206112266,
0.092282854,
-0.5770356059,
0.2293468118,
-0.7021741271,
0.6057131886,
0.5760416389,
-0.1868731827,
0.56146276,
-0.6264815331,
0.3819827437,
0.1435639113,
-0.3557823896,
-0.0431060679,
-0.5747599602,
-0.66184026,
-0.2751610875,
0.0526128225,
0.4956384897,
-0.2918951213,
0.549050808,
-0.4613229036,
-0.2743982673,
-0.4563851058,
0.1326783299,
0.4034330845,
0.6026290059,
0.3500749171,
-0.5287774801,
-0.343616575,
-0.9229378104,
-0.3016519845,
-0.5165452361,
-0.2845223844,
0.0060031926,
0.5511884689,
-0.1069443449,
0.7214366198,
-0.3985973299,
-0.4914896786,
-0.1951775104,
0.0374153703,
-0.0644262135,
0.1897551715,
0.3079186976,
-0.700943172,
-0.0016580782,
-0.0511098914,
-0.6175897717,
-0.1659545898,
0.0078010322,
-0.1438937187,
0.0767741352,
0.5403611064,
-0.7149164081,
0.3760505021,
0.1673639268,
-0.5142638087,
0.494327426,
-0.2949680686,
0.2451454699,
-0.8293359876,
-0.0360135809,
-0.1228639409,
0.041270975,
-0.4913299978,
0.2348317504,
-0.0534278192,
0.0527331047,
-0.5519536734,
0.653136909,
-0.6882612705,
-0.4812841415,
-0.3830269575,
0.5135728717,
-0.0271324255,
0.6068816185,
0.1030448675,
0.6165944934,
0.4746756852,
-0.6199806333,
0.2151563168,
0.0946467146,
-0.2937859595,
0.6512800455,
-0.807664454,
-0.1170903742,
0.0044314791,
0.2238330245,
-1.0216178894,
-0.0806011036,
0.2706206441,
-0.3405329585,
0.1494234651,
0.3479144871,
-0.6546308994,
-0.100037694,
-0.3416231871,
0.6376723647,
0.6605699062,
-0.1730592251,
0.7075055838,
0.1912540048,
-0.0253725201,
0.0381587856,
-0.6146509051,
-0.0626935139,
-0.3730068505,
-0.6636598706,
0.4998337328,
0.0860977247,
-0.482529968,
0.2381102443,
-0.3206766248,
-0.0084290737,
0.3634701073,
0.4263921976,
0.4034873247,
-0.4484269619,
-0.0883165672,
-0.1473063231,
-0.1740598828,
0.4842554331,
-0.0968850553,
0.2258547992,
-0.2382528037,
-0.6471526623,
-0.2874245942,
0.3096139431,
0.5897265673,
0.1490302086,
0.5281444788,
0.0422034077,
-0.420971334,
0.0451179259,
-0.3940505981,
-0.3875718713,
-0.3720400929,
0.5181566477,
-0.6682257056,
-0.9499526024,
0.6128425598,
-0.2925274372,
-0.1398130804,
0.5722514987,
0.7630175352,
-0.4297323227,
0.6307991147,
0.2498909533,
0.1965952218,
0.0431575663,
0.0170080457,
0.03769302,
-1.0296685696,
-0.0737626031,
-0.5073117018,
-0.5887261629,
-0.626855135,
-0.4417624176,
0.0492981747,
0.1310381144,
-0.1213333607,
0.3979147971,
-0.338717103,
0.3697116077,
0.2845217288,
-0.066865772,
0.4826841354,
-0.0823100656,
-0.2018973082,
-0.0757147893,
-0.4567919672,
-0.69741714,
1.1103215218,
0.0998852253,
0.8627775311,
-0.0194274317,
0.4848792255,
-0.1034783348,
0.2480299473,
-0.9049879909,
0.8769564629,
-0.088168636,
-0.5187016726,
-0.2585531771,
-0.2390625626,
-1.1248735189,
0.6717433929,
-0.2977329195,
-0.8350716829,
-0.0541941486,
0.1070676744,
0.1593572348,
0.3358054459,
-0.7311035991,
0.6433127522,
-0.092546992,
0.2039286047,
-0.3119491041,
-0.8287562728,
0.3309415281,
-0.1116296276,
0.2923367321,
-0.4561053813,
-0.266261965,
0.5286731124,
0.0202109311,
0.8686919212,
0.3169884384,
-0.0056782141,
0.2317899317,
0.3684221506,
0.2156798989,
-0.5913286805,
0.1131827384,
0.3251406252,
0.112625517,
-0.5688599944,
-0.8417941332,
0.6860425472,
-0.717291832,
-0.9047306776,
-0.4509392083,
-0.8491623402,
-0.1351284236,
-0.0297585763,
-0.0274297036,
0.166499719,
-0.151329726,
0.0828568786,
0.5948306918,
0.2382923216,
0.0686133429,
0.3648014665,
-0.0546618439,
0.1119941697,
0.6422139406,
0.0352437273,
0.6369433999,
0.679679215,
0.2952566147,
-0.2613441944,
-0.6641367078,
-0.3342614472,
0.2782153487,
-0.7990682125,
0.2063823491,
-0.3840671182,
-0.0843438059,
-0.1001642272,
-0.3543834388,
-0.1313150674,
-0.6135892868,
-0.1424441189,
-0.0709449127,
0.070454143,
0.4744542241,
0.3389529884,
-0.0790502951,
-0.4405481815,
0.6509672999,
0.2279367149,
-0.0635696277,
-0.0136353588,
-0.4555656612,
0.1328680813,
0.0620585755,
-0.3230377436,
-0.8663929701,
-0.1755939126,
0.2127366811,
0.7175942659,
0.1619627923,
-0.0973378345,
0.7340424657,
-0.5141479373,
0.6640226245,
0.186975956,
-0.7652325034,
0.4830918014,
-0.2686484158,
0.4852137864,
0.2012687773,
0.3389867544,
-0.4165797532,
-0.589111805,
-0.3954382837,
-0.8851780891,
0.4289277196,
0.2542931437,
-0.0840041488,
-0.0921089649,
0.5689504743,
-0.0227937903,
-0.0677353144,
-0.4669667482,
-0.1617885679,
0.1559159756,
-0.2961339355,
-0.0061310646,
-0.0899498463,
-0.209273234,
-0.2775940001,
0.1202890202,
-0.1650536656,
0.1609047353,
0.1747037917,
-0.3230454326,
-0.2077242434,
0.4142409861,
0.751953721,
0.9478164315,
-0.1861116737,
0.4885896742,
0.3891426623,
-0.336019963,
0.3403509557,
-0.0611321107,
-0.0037583462,
-0.3751639128,
0.8388804793,
0.5386503339,
0.835790813,
-0.9223116636,
0.2171300501,
0.3630807996,
-0.3475107551,
-0.1235386878,
0.3702608645,
0.4318763912,
0.1191729531,
0.1767196655,
-0.1113884225,
0.1012368128,
-0.854863584,
0.0520879626,
0.4394339025,
-0.2314219028,
-0.6259992123,
0.7313136458,
-0.0918849334,
-0.4659610689,
0.5546581149,
0.1956630349,
-0.4477533102,
0.7560924888,
0.7777303457,
0.8298788667,
-0.0175426472,
-0.3381681442,
0.196795702,
0.3645951748,
-0.0764670894,
0.3268475235,
-0.1541606933,
-0.7873953581,
-0.3825664818,
-0.5500878096,
-0.2832786143,
-0.3569290638,
-0.7344601154,
0.2272768468,
-0.2324278802,
-0.1065144688,
-0.1373859942,
-0.1998378485,
-0.6155112386,
0.3106918633,
0.0300816409,
0.8597310781,
-0.9123199582,
0.9320816994,
0.9886731505,
-0.3243674934,
-0.5904143453,
-0.0700582713,
-0.0407309867,
-0.8043416739,
1.1717416048,
0.0133139817,
-0.4280526936,
-0.1778485328,
-0.1222260892,
-0.8217850327,
1.2096697092,
0.3950383365,
-0.2539357841,
-0.4300079346,
0.2471234947,
0.8557028174,
-0.5922512412,
0.1262628883,
0.4931875169,
0.2591843009,
0.3835940659,
-0.8167770505,
0.3803322613,
0.2054114044,
0.3746381998,
0.3346149027,
-0.1963994056,
0.7464289069,
-0.2129487693,
-0.3212731481,
0.0421684347,
0.6584506035,
0.7274119258,
0.104515627,
0.5907789469,
0.6171488762,
0.2673994899,
-0.0534673966,
1.0175559521,
-0.2310582846,
0.053206306,
1.0932867527,
-0.3450389504,
1.106246233,
0.8522890806,
-0.2388194501,
0.5735038519,
0.5315207839,
0.3121932149,
0.2328138649,
0.6248092055,
0.1201395243,
-0.2814650238,
0.0805071443,
-0.2278386056,
0.3512910903,
0.5510025024,
-0.14221178,
-0.4012829661,
-0.4426452219,
-0.0549725257,
0.3521164358,
-0.1360979676,
0.7041111588,
0.3030015826,
-0.5707282424,
0.6073209047,
0.0895750225,
0.3792854548,
-0.6813391447,
-0.1843811572,
0.0685330108,
-0.0919597149,
0.0632347688,
-0.8199204803,
0.534855485,
-0.4697712958,
-0.2036045045,
-0.199667871,
0.7703060508,
-0.4888521731,
-0.3299557865,
0.6464909315,
0.5424979329,
0.3131494522,
0.0414703973,
-0.5149240494,
0.1236475408,
-0.3983264863,
-0.2611888945,
0.5573248267,
0.3418669701,
-0.4781953394,
0.8425604105,
0.7036255002,
0.3222698569,
0.1149329096,
-0.216666162,
0.8368483186,
-0.9685502648,
-0.3931595385,
-0.8992616534,
0.1888567805,
0.3059941828,
-0.2938799858,
0.6166517138,
0.4495178163,
1.0166208744,
-0.142727837,
0.1822568476,
0.2419608086,
0.1996316761,
-0.593462944,
0.4298672676,
-0.5296147466,
0.1171269566,
-0.2305128276,
-1.1990537643,
-0.2676967978,
0.5720186234,
-0.2238765359,
-0.1022310704,
1.018753171,
0.7071268559,
-0.1216583997,
-0.0602344759,
0.5986777544,
0.2263247818,
0.126366213,
0.8269553781,
0.8814900517,
-0.2819740772,
0.3440192938,
0.1279485971,
-0.1668108255,
-0.1146195307,
-0.7664561272,
-1.0731037855,
-0.6797220111,
-0.3166797459,
-0.0466958918,
0.0411557928,
0.9276313186,
0.5776571035,
-0.6314115524,
-0.5267553926,
-0.0505998917,
0.3159394264,
-0.3505659103,
-0.1806275845,
0.4751065075,
-0.1927017421,
-0.6230196953,
0.2206508666,
0.5197871923,
0.0128108999,
-0.4266284406,
0.0822279528,
-0.1787571907,
0.0690232664,
0.559427321,
0.2333443463,
-1.4679095745,
-0.4067650139,
-0.0912673101,
-0.3391328156,
0.1662659347,
0.9363572598,
-0.6997044683,
0.3700121641,
0.6152193546,
0.5232223868,
0.3283984959,
-0.0058891643,
0.4468197823,
-0.350975126,
0.2897096276,
0.0830642581,
0.2886069715,
0.2493073493,
-0.124128066,
0.3999683559,
0.4474006891,
-0.3126419485,
-0.5772168636,
0.4970483184,
-1.2302888632,
-0.3807342947,
1.1047005653,
-0.1126602739,
-0.5622333884,
-0.2242736071,
-0.2162714303,
0.0689703673,
-0.0439728759,
0.8015657067,
0.9357837439,
-0.3357401788,
0.119574666,
-0.4769753516,
0.247969538,
0.3475693464,
-0.9126908779,
-0.3374041617,
0.327016294,
0.4639035165,
0.064945586,
0.5751808286,
-0.2299051732,
0.3116919696,
-0.0976388231,
0.1650414914,
0.0412527062,
-0.1129944474,
-0.0077989721,
0.2649024129,
0.184026286,
-0.2285093218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13791v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13791v2 | IoT-Based Preventive Mental Health Using Knowledge Graphs and Standards for Better Well-Being | 2024-06-19T19:35:14 | 2024-06-29T15:29:56 | Amelie Gyrard, Seyedali Mohammadi, Manas Gaur, Antonio Kung | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) give the UN a road map for development
with Agenda 2030 as a target. SDG3 "Good Health and Well-Being" ensures healthy
lives and promotes well-being for all ages. Digital technologies can support
SDG3. Burnout and even depression could be reduced by encouraging better
preventive health. Due to the lack of patient knowledge and focus to take care
of their health, it is necessary to help patients before it is too late. New
trends such as positive psychology and mindfulness are highly encouraged in the
USA. Digital Twin (DT) can help with the continuous monitoring of emotion using
physiological signals (e.g., collected via wearables). Digital twins facilitate
monitoring and provide constant health insight to improve quality of life and
well-being with better personalization. Healthcare DT challenges are
standardizing data formats, communication protocols, and data exchange
mechanisms. To achieve those data integration and knowledge challenges, we
designed the Mental Health Knowledge Graph (ontology and dataset) to boost
mental health. The Knowledge Graph (KG) acquires knowledge from ontology-based
mental health projects classified within the LOV4IoT ontology catalog (Emotion,
Depression, and Mental Health). Furthermore, the KG is mapped to standards
(e.g., ontologies) when possible. Standards from ETSI SmartM2M, ITU/WHO, ISO,
W3C, NIST, and IEEE are relevant to mental health. | [
-0.5206874013,
-0.6577268839,
0.7437810898,
0.0962797925,
-0.2388448417,
0.1063842326,
0.2378878742,
-0.7295945883,
0.4352174997,
0.4258442819,
-0.9153220654,
-0.7337995768,
-0.5663177371,
0.0785694867,
-0.076280579,
1.167951107,
-0.1375815719,
0.1864077151,
-0.1017474607,
0.3308747411,
-0.6212285161,
-0.1202354878,
-0.8545244336,
-0.6082547307,
0.4974003732,
0.5360792279,
0.4098748863,
0.1938072741,
0.8332574964,
0.1239760369,
0.2410689145,
0.1519640684,
-0.4545859098,
0.0171116907,
0.0805282742,
-0.4034667909,
-0.7730469108,
-0.0576629341,
0.0399241745,
0.3052017093,
-0.1234841421,
0.2088258862,
-0.0255530402,
0.9362290502,
-0.2815662324,
0.3930246234,
-0.0119382972,
0.3412800729,
-0.1144948527,
-0.2664940953,
0.4043302536,
-0.6275205612,
-0.172424823,
-0.521633327,
-0.1335902512,
-0.1792753786,
0.6198278666,
0.5764621496,
-0.6342115998,
-0.119604975,
-0.788133204,
0.4736732244,
-0.5031502247,
0.3672957718,
0.6382083297,
0.3159819841,
-0.2330729514,
-0.547011435,
-0.6523805857,
0.5080744624,
0.0410006158,
0.5002378821,
-0.4176904559,
0.0035210343,
0.4606203735,
0.1110745594,
-0.5049276948,
-0.2680168152,
-0.5516216755,
-0.1139805242,
0.8507571816,
0.4100506306,
0.4705925286,
-0.1564538181,
-0.3465285003,
0.2108634561,
-0.5277500749,
0.0005321563,
0.0518950149,
-0.0255937167,
-0.5095151663,
0.5457942486,
-0.4538360834,
0.3902168274,
0.1342976987,
-0.4962868989,
0.3133457005,
-0.4711734354,
0.1060666442,
0.2833973169,
0.4773703218,
1.0166279078,
0.0921757296,
-0.2739758193,
0.0126989214,
0.2960642278,
0.5265637636,
-0.7461425662,
-0.23876068,
0.6749265194,
-0.4869437516,
0.0704957992,
-0.040193662,
-0.7592087984,
-0.5130754113,
-0.6220377088,
0.4342032373,
-0.7091798782,
-0.3496873975,
0.2723760605,
-0.2236104757,
-0.164225474,
0.1526662707,
-0.6156725883,
0.2521557808,
0.8780053854,
0.7700802088,
-0.0157174189,
0.2573076785,
0.1199318841,
0.6136621237,
-0.0947782248,
0.7151967883,
0.0696009323,
-0.3761238456,
-0.2305778861,
-0.1589817107,
0.1163409948,
-0.3206881583,
0.7327501774,
-0.1766066104,
0.1882459372,
-0.5736759901,
-0.381690383,
-0.047263667,
0.5386611819,
-0.3598099351,
0.6633539796,
0.1134068593,
-1.0414590836,
0.4558826387,
-1.1778075695,
-0.6153742671,
0.2716239691,
0.011680495,
-0.3850618005,
-0.2088297307,
0.1941806525,
0.5827405453,
-0.5220674872,
0.1255743057,
-0.5853081942,
-0.3926404119,
-0.3143185675,
0.0997021496,
0.7746990323,
0.2501879036,
-0.3403167129,
0.1927774549,
-0.675622642,
0.3268382251,
0.0547289588,
0.0393153839,
-0.4484130442,
0.1004179493,
-0.223742798,
0.4571829736,
0.2448062301,
-0.8156948686,
-0.1388829798,
0.1454798132,
0.5787388086,
0.5190772414,
0.4415237904,
-0.444465667,
-0.6669831276,
0.2719705701,
0.1472102255,
0.848171711,
0.4195539355,
-0.6853426695,
-0.1801713556,
-0.6876416206,
-0.2629821301,
0.7913697362,
-0.6346347332,
1.0822519064,
-0.4491040409,
-0.5695487857,
-0.5234133005,
-0.1922344267,
-0.1677036583,
0.8975910544,
0.2774164081,
-0.1415487975,
-0.4938982129,
-0.4963095784,
0.1355887353,
-0.0854598135,
-0.0004292521,
0.0164200068,
0.3334656358,
-0.8551270962,
1.0385251045,
-0.5529824495,
-0.6158047318,
-0.010892597,
-0.0189712811,
0.1230725124,
0.5433135033,
0.2662114203,
-1.018112421,
-0.337471664,
-0.0756921992,
-1.0476016998,
-0.123656936,
0.3845932484,
-0.1563575566,
-0.1750651896,
0.0826046169,
-0.406560719,
0.4764695466,
0.282395184,
-0.4493647516,
0.2710560858,
-0.242762953,
0.3138687015,
-1.2420004606,
0.2153549939,
-0.0605189167,
-0.198722139,
-0.7118281722,
-0.4812845886,
0.0097761462,
-0.2926288545,
-0.1257816851,
0.3295248747,
0.3370508254,
0.2700323164,
-0.1429408342,
0.0199293699,
0.0729990602,
-0.0007570687,
-0.3375758827,
0.4001913071,
0.500475347,
-0.3727865219,
0.6115434766,
0.2640915811,
-0.101686947,
1.3890988827,
-0.5743171573,
0.1390088052,
-0.2157192826,
0.2840208411,
-0.3988669515,
-0.1333773285,
0.3153186738,
-0.4474418461,
0.0594254509,
0.6256076097,
-0.8837896585,
-0.8517274261,
-0.5161090493,
0.1669434905,
0.3609986007,
-0.2074237168,
0.1566928178,
0.5225746632,
-0.148443684,
-0.2260414362,
-0.5990436077,
0.1052351892,
-0.5969393253,
-0.7057566643,
0.3960955739,
-0.1685053855,
-0.2002158314,
0.2448292375,
-0.2029217631,
0.1869454682,
0.004659134,
0.6008784771,
0.4113878608,
0.1879773438,
0.5522220731,
-0.048672501,
-0.6468065381,
0.2836726904,
-0.5654708743,
0.4341396093,
-0.1354206353,
-0.457028091,
-1.0183233023,
0.8684208989,
0.481652379,
-0.017274633,
0.7920261025,
0.6542136669,
-0.7738131285,
0.4582375586,
-0.6193158627,
-0.3901965022,
-0.4120966494,
-0.0045351023,
-0.3375164866,
-0.8877258301,
0.5532089472,
-0.2249463052,
-0.232289046,
0.3556762934,
0.3540610075,
-0.6315616965,
1.3791294098,
0.6280732751,
-0.0556065477,
0.2555069327,
-0.2326808423,
0.76782161,
-0.845703125,
-0.3330693841,
-0.3057380021,
-0.4976004064,
-0.7028718591,
-0.0437799394,
0.8355152011,
0.3638187647,
-0.6098161936,
0.0123619251,
-0.7706280947,
-0.0432172194,
0.5670641661,
0.5308884978,
0.4760011435,
-0.1572560519,
-0.1157481968,
-0.337229073,
-0.3733190894,
-0.4188843668,
1.07883811,
0.08404845,
0.7332761884,
0.183214128,
0.8850861192,
0.5764718056,
0.2374557704,
-0.5346606374,
0.1938762665,
-0.1756171286,
-0.6884894967,
-0.1292986274,
-0.6650939584,
-0.9136833549,
-0.5773611665,
-0.1787427664,
-1.1926572323,
0.2638303339,
-0.0969647244,
-0.3720303178,
0.2941606939,
-0.5574246645,
0.5602651238,
-0.406440556,
-0.1642503738,
-0.5658308864,
-0.6431835294,
0.2419229895,
-0.3841684163,
0.1748125106,
-0.5541891456,
0.3887366056,
0.8318816423,
-0.21481058,
0.6091936827,
0.030094808,
0.1676639169,
0.2436955869,
-0.5974096656,
0.2460629046,
0.1798159778,
0.0622360967,
0.2977475524,
0.433862716,
-0.4074794054,
-0.6125664711,
0.6692730784,
-1.0830773115,
-0.4814524949,
-0.1082327887,
-0.4867098331,
-0.4116155505,
0.5894737244,
0.1588475406,
0.1932113618,
0.2011264265,
-0.0190355256,
0.5549775958,
0.1005669609,
-0.086518079,
0.3319559991,
-0.1105904505,
-0.5693727732,
0.9629868865,
0.2266375721,
0.0833976343,
0.1774952114,
0.3550067246,
-0.2129255235,
0.0023983971,
0.2813815773,
0.2339548767,
-0.5696738362,
-0.3441044092,
-0.6455770135,
-0.3458250165,
-0.7880753875,
-0.1973525137,
-0.1423900425,
-0.179538399,
-0.0867065489,
-0.2457708716,
0.7021362185,
0.9013735056,
-0.5921596289,
0.0516335182,
-0.8236042857,
0.6963824034,
0.6569561958,
0.6833761334,
-0.1713161021,
0.5825458169,
-0.1499112546,
0.2434058636,
-0.4083971381,
-0.8773466945,
-0.0158912838,
-0.4031503201,
0.2796697319,
0.7649803758,
0.4646683037,
0.7831947207,
-0.0507047586,
0.3089602292,
0.6174376607,
-0.6558331847,
0.7400816083,
-0.494964689,
0.1405185163,
0.6019174457,
0.3994356692,
-1.0478423834,
0.2398272604,
-0.6097586155,
-0.7355411053,
0.6279439926,
0.0996545777,
-0.3200720549,
0.0350715183,
0.4552351236,
-0.0343885608,
0.1606217325,
-0.3210880458,
-0.2465068847,
-0.345643729,
-0.5523305535,
0.1991786957,
0.0638450608,
-0.7466459274,
-0.2800017893,
0.7649875879,
-0.0987432152,
0.7029550076,
0.1844013929,
0.5379888415,
-0.1456545144,
0.0536663458,
0.1790298074,
0.2680605948,
-0.4902604818,
0.2761728168,
-0.1231626049,
-0.5210624933,
0.1132791191,
0.2336104512,
-0.2889564633,
-0.5455793142,
0.1545065492,
0.5698966384,
-0.2349572331,
-0.415314436,
0.0417956039,
-0.070360288,
0.0569913425,
-0.1635173708,
0.1855899543,
0.3046206832,
0.5589436293,
0.1092387736,
-0.1975746006,
-0.0040003425,
-0.3853924274,
0.2198619843,
0.3012409806,
-0.6430677176,
-0.2666070759,
0.5023215413,
0.2873870134,
-0.553483367,
0.5926523209,
-0.314788878,
-0.3843349218,
0.5669839978,
0.6684733033,
0.5115209818,
-0.0674262345,
0.3045186996,
0.177619487,
0.2953113914,
0.0421566181,
0.896281004,
-0.1770261973,
-0.685151279,
0.0100378944,
-0.0601064228,
-0.3020622134,
0.050053861,
-0.7215512991,
0.3737384081,
-0.4391995072,
-0.7541906834,
-0.3437923491,
0.4131244421,
-0.8820215464,
0.5677660704,
0.3369224072,
0.5824304223,
-0.6311329603,
0.6372156739,
0.795096159,
-0.1303428262,
-0.5671644807,
0.1031433642,
0.3838250339,
-0.6654269695,
0.2202899456,
0.3246226907,
-0.2365393043,
0.1027402505,
-0.2083721608,
-0.9478568435,
1.3308675289,
0.20511204,
-0.2150579989,
0.0640422702,
0.4967027605,
0.5457984805,
-0.2194391787,
0.0417207666,
0.404766649,
0.8858927488,
0.0065660258,
-0.5596471429,
-0.03186116,
-0.3009146154,
-0.0723456293,
0.2579870522,
-0.6554459929,
0.406501323,
-0.2711383402,
-0.2804593146,
-0.5748532414,
0.0402688384,
0.3439602256,
0.5215556026,
0.3944912553,
1.0677962303,
0.9204876423,
-0.1827738881,
0.8083264828,
-0.5283593535,
0.3580886424,
0.8938862681,
-0.4153295159,
0.4717163146,
0.3494587541,
-0.4048490524,
0.2173047215,
0.7787636518,
0.1432949007,
0.6387430429,
-0.0225878507,
-0.4663552642,
-0.0700398758,
-0.4074628651,
-0.6304773092,
0.0744965896,
0.6481876969,
0.2153566629,
-0.2310102433,
0.3131957352,
0.2136780322,
-0.2496055961,
-0.1648082137,
0.6578544974,
0.1843767315,
-0.2020744383,
0.0611904338,
-0.0640598312,
0.4722549319,
-0.6598982811,
0.0690832958,
-0.0276877191,
0.2779401243,
-0.4132565558,
-0.6773692966,
0.6545889378,
0.104572475,
-0.317073524,
-0.3311499357,
0.8524713516,
-0.0512161031,
-0.6050456762,
0.550735116,
0.4459906816,
-0.0137530835,
-0.0687602982,
-0.5142385364,
-0.295543313,
-0.2702277601,
0.1566879153,
0.0859614015,
0.512247324,
-0.1811946332,
0.6398684978,
0.5917976499,
0.338018328,
-0.169990629,
-0.17856583,
0.5821109414,
-0.7078837752,
-0.5491864681,
-0.4763410389,
0.3292499483,
-0.2737950683,
-0.270355612,
0.4925251901,
0.1320568025,
0.3973371387,
0.4156481624,
0.8713425994,
-0.3352239728,
0.5445343256,
-0.0090307426,
0.9805650115,
-0.6534917951,
-0.2188426107,
-0.0558570437,
-0.7492250204,
-0.4424792528,
0.385897249,
-0.4296088517,
-0.056774199,
0.5522772074,
0.2635486126,
0.3701590002,
0.3283305764,
0.1120803282,
-0.0021075695,
0.7155029178,
0.674151361,
0.4132906199,
-0.2537120581,
-0.1120467857,
-0.5866312981,
-0.2312130034,
-0.1120757312,
-0.6287708879,
-0.5508086085,
-0.5759384036,
-0.5300080776,
-0.1214504167,
0.2865981162,
0.9127499461,
0.8125061989,
-0.6555396914,
0.1771692783,
-0.1819236875,
0.414114058,
-0.4196223021,
-0.2348918319,
0.4541900158,
0.2140366137,
-0.1276660264,
-0.1063073874,
0.6260101199,
0.0412738211,
-0.1901011765,
0.1508000195,
-0.1291546971,
-0.2771544158,
0.2723247409,
0.1737468392,
-0.313944757,
-0.4895250201,
-0.2368953824,
-0.2422073931,
0.1828650385,
0.3702332377,
-0.7056205273,
0.5237058401,
0.4895128012,
0.2947758734,
0.2750836909,
-0.1617382467,
0.3402705789,
-0.1692143679,
-0.0777769983,
0.1278045028,
0.2616147697,
0.4251233935,
-0.6956503987,
0.6342154145,
0.4053999186,
-0.3862270415,
-0.4505960047,
0.2203667909,
-0.8439260125,
0.0772575587,
0.5044670701,
-0.2053476423,
-0.0073262942,
-0.317222774,
-0.0338928066,
0.6548244357,
-0.2383406609,
1.3111686707,
0.4938067496,
-0.7264711261,
0.0233976468,
-0.6136885881,
0.1810564399,
0.2375546098,
-1.4394879341,
-0.3915235102,
0.0129369842,
0.0042561549,
0.2708576024,
0.509201169,
-0.1358820945,
0.2031132281,
-0.1753945351,
0.3866790831,
-0.0537588075,
-0.0059666657,
0.0720142499,
-0.215296343,
-0.5242755413,
-0.2206682265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13781v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13781v1 | A Primal-Dual Framework for Transformers and Neural Networks | 2024-06-19T19:11:22 | 2024-06-19T19:11:22 | Tan M. Nguyen, Tam Nguyen, Nhat Ho, Andrea L. Bertozzi, Richard G. Baraniuk, Stanley J. Osher | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML | Self-attention is key to the remarkable success of transformers in sequence
modeling tasks including many applications in natural language processing and
computer vision. Like neural network layers, these attention mechanisms are
often developed by heuristics and experience. To provide a principled framework
for constructing attention layers in transformers, we show that the
self-attention corresponds to the support vector expansion derived from a
support vector regression problem, whose primal formulation has the form of a
neural network layer. Using our framework, we derive popular attention layers
used in practice and propose two new attentions: 1) the Batch Normalized
Attention (Attention-BN) derived from the batch normalization layer and 2) the
Attention with Scaled Head (Attention-SH) derived from using less training data
to fit the SVR model. We empirically demonstrate the advantages of the
Attention-BN and Attention-SH in reducing head redundancy, increasing the
model's accuracy, and improving the model's efficiency in a variety of
practical applications including image and time-series classification. | [
-0.4148512781,
-0.2760245204,
0.0919618085,
0.5303931236,
0.1668344587,
-0.2903338373,
-0.0717092231,
-0.0625077933,
0.0566689447,
0.6818016171,
-0.8917816877,
0.2790853083,
-0.3769879937,
-0.0052769119,
-0.4951395094,
0.9390659332,
0.2304932773,
-0.2604030371,
-0.1512411237,
-0.2337700427,
-0.3771248162,
-0.5385338068,
-0.6091846824,
-0.3183786571,
0.8171171546,
0.2131924033,
0.7449560761,
0.9515866041,
0.9358278513,
0.3835973144,
0.2853443027,
-0.2338045985,
-0.3404562473,
0.1987761408,
-0.244507879,
-0.2932837903,
-0.4142764807,
0.0628739595,
0.5108129978,
0.4916246831,
0.0995117128,
0.6292270422,
0.2740195692,
0.9881404638,
-0.5895967484,
0.1437487453,
-0.2183839977,
0.4618755877,
0.2713015974,
-0.0940787196,
-0.2429772168,
0.1151595563,
0.4453683197,
-0.2828132212,
0.7985625863,
-0.3136456311,
0.5477910042,
0.9301645756,
-0.3417418599,
0.5227294564,
-1.0543974638,
0.9390198588,
-0.2800055742,
0.5626500249,
-0.1456403881,
0.4428299963,
0.2531722486,
-0.7840707302,
-0.2574293911,
0.0360709168,
-0.214942053,
0.327016294,
-0.2621378005,
0.1316393018,
0.3112463355,
0.4567482769,
-0.2367864251,
-0.1059191748,
-0.6261866093,
-0.04008637,
0.4313111901,
0.1892794669,
-0.0335300043,
-0.337317735,
-0.8832787871,
-0.1207240224,
-0.4255020022,
0.130592972,
0.1830262989,
0.5027399063,
-0.169197008,
0.612850368,
0.0092624025,
0.7260658145,
0.4907778502,
0.047577627,
0.0698606223,
-0.1512159705,
-0.6712117195,
-0.1661113948,
0.7504485846,
0.4056707323,
0.4772870541,
-0.4912081063,
-0.2173207104,
0.1447894573,
0.8890865445,
-0.5302647948,
-0.0593676604,
0.2146739066,
-0.7471855283,
-0.5507619977,
-0.1864222884,
-0.6867431998,
0.0253244489,
-0.8149507642,
0.6446758509,
0.0380578563,
-0.3302815259,
-0.07028234,
0.0122602675,
0.4246298969,
-0.0701835155,
-1.0874279737,
0.3361138999,
0.5392365456,
0.5732061267,
-0.2082945555,
0.0815030038,
-0.4238093197,
0.1058931425,
-0.0940625966,
0.6784054041,
-0.2396328747,
0.0296374112,
-0.1925031394,
-0.07329081,
-0.2135803103,
-0.4202904105,
0.5753685236,
-0.4764558077,
0.2375026792,
-0.1024324074,
0.0491432324,
-0.1545257866,
0.0438585989,
-0.7193550467,
1.3182165623,
0.4436568022,
-0.754756093,
0.0353898294,
-0.7524957061,
-0.6213002205,
0.2454272956,
-0.1901726276,
-0.3279450536,
0.2368130237,
0.2138240039,
0.8563529253,
-0.5013319254,
0.0491508767,
-0.1114400253,
-0.0006950541,
-0.1266300827,
-0.2910879254,
0.4054581523,
0.0957036316,
-0.5662446618,
0.1853064299,
-0.7401880622,
0.0025560856,
0.1633121222,
0.0088670515,
-0.0343281627,
-0.0009344177,
0.1672588289,
0.4364074469,
0.090759635,
-0.3162511289,
0.1273768395,
-0.5410598516,
0.7052001953,
0.8302479386,
-0.0811511651,
0.8140468597,
0.0229189433,
0.6116090417,
0.0378609374,
0.4279660285,
-0.3991671503,
-0.1177119091,
-1.043155551,
-0.1714975089,
0.1416978985,
0.505474329,
-0.1662556827,
0.6513951421,
-0.2766253054,
-0.1024230719,
-0.4664479792,
0.2086444497,
0.2295342237,
0.8079701662,
0.3780462742,
-0.3556454778,
-0.7324368358,
-1.5815213919,
-0.032439474,
0.0936288238,
-0.3935731351,
0.4090388715,
0.0125949932,
-0.1802536398,
1.1711701155,
-0.2706161737,
-0.7621343136,
-0.3789555132,
-0.1447104663,
0.2441588342,
0.4268345833,
0.4561942518,
-0.9854075313,
-0.3399264812,
-0.1443959922,
-0.7716706991,
0.1794997603,
-0.2669129372,
-0.172613278,
-0.2904387414,
0.4514291883,
-0.2529361248,
0.410136044,
0.269433856,
0.0865124688,
0.1099870279,
0.2076460123,
-0.2853313088,
-1.1201763153,
0.1604804099,
0.6162831783,
-0.3340733945,
-0.8656420112,
0.1183323637,
0.2512742877,
-0.0714981258,
-0.2765197158,
0.2916747034,
-0.2754825354,
-0.1329160482,
-0.3458386362,
-0.0959217697,
0.0131458128,
0.9480767846,
-0.080839701,
0.6589897275,
0.6151983738,
-0.6810001731,
0.5461807847,
0.2748047113,
0.2620477676,
0.4900265038,
-1.104150176,
0.2010708451,
-0.5250627995,
-0.2167090327,
-1.2366731167,
-0.1351923347,
0.2888323963,
-0.284802556,
0.6113458276,
-0.448169589,
-0.1767809987,
-0.9298000336,
-0.1242692396,
0.4144598544,
0.54107517,
-0.5729517937,
1.1266753674,
0.2244912833,
-0.0447612405,
-0.8327274919,
-0.7804439664,
-0.1177768707,
-0.1648129076,
-0.880237937,
0.3653822839,
0.2208450437,
-0.0810885131,
0.0765489712,
-0.4520343244,
-0.0075541716,
0.0079454742,
0.3473879695,
0.3680266738,
-0.6673045754,
0.083957985,
-0.3504154384,
-0.4778067172,
0.2683151066,
-0.5796803236,
0.4007724524,
-0.1706273109,
-0.0008253176,
-0.6276619434,
0.44003582,
0.7737391591,
-0.4554054141,
0.2910866439,
0.4000855088,
-0.2977778912,
-0.1384731382,
-0.8703401685,
-0.5425544977,
-0.5736200213,
0.2209361643,
-0.3327297866,
-0.5894113183,
0.492243588,
0.4096929431,
-0.0354671516,
0.8175398707,
0.6386831999,
-0.1496882588,
1.0269868374,
0.9116744399,
-0.2743744254,
0.5384642482,
-0.3708595634,
0.2352769673,
-1.2225215435,
-0.1234115213,
-0.2035454363,
-0.6960287094,
-0.3138876259,
-0.2231923789,
0.3164568841,
-0.321516186,
-0.2492608577,
0.5875573158,
-1.0827133656,
0.4618090391,
0.4987301826,
0.1218818501,
-0.1937869489,
0.157011196,
0.092010498,
-0.3263581395,
-0.7431499958,
-0.2795330584,
0.9791024327,
0.670224309,
0.7757865191,
-0.2712693214,
0.2011498511,
0.2934599817,
0.2995579541,
-0.9677661657,
0.2959424853,
-0.123078458,
-0.7239781022,
-0.2845526636,
-0.2881788611,
-0.6134619713,
0.3394851089,
0.2347727567,
-0.5168140531,
0.3320296705,
0.332888335,
-0.8078629375,
0.0390906595,
-0.9130990505,
1.1197403669,
-0.1210881919,
-0.5770365,
-0.0471152402,
-1.0759102106,
0.2554077804,
0.0988884866,
-0.3353264034,
-0.1449792534,
-0.0278049745,
0.6734364629,
-0.0347841009,
1.0377831459,
-0.0708095357,
0.0757722035,
0.3654996157,
-0.2617489398,
0.4069280624,
-0.0352594033,
0.383205086,
-0.290393889,
-0.5328710675,
-0.3275766075,
-0.7517454028,
0.5614299178,
-0.7985484004,
-0.841870904,
-0.2702070177,
-0.5118265152,
-0.0537594296,
0.1662574559,
0.0784213021,
0.6234245896,
0.1719558537,
0.4380668104,
0.7944567204,
0.3271979988,
0.4907820821,
0.1277742237,
0.0723036081,
-0.1952664405,
0.4888191521,
0.1098636314,
0.3879870772,
0.408954829,
0.2379117608,
-0.3808028102,
0.0690848082,
-0.4196345508,
0.160298869,
-0.7000640035,
-0.4511777461,
-1.0775538683,
-0.6745818257,
-0.5752636194,
0.0859480202,
-0.580105722,
-0.5422204137,
-0.2441104501,
0.0032215677,
0.2748795748,
0.6328321099,
-0.0308266804,
0.3060237765,
-0.5760754347,
0.7576861382,
0.7263178825,
0.3903330266,
0.3221244514,
-0.6755022407,
-0.156273663,
-0.2336381674,
-0.4167560935,
-0.5269679427,
0.4442960322,
0.1111730114,
0.7891767025,
0.4914517105,
-0.0766827464,
0.4799955189,
-0.6448085904,
0.2625618279,
0.3621877134,
-0.6124461889,
0.3529920578,
-0.4369231761,
0.3197449744,
0.289643079,
0.2605599761,
-0.5745431185,
-0.105390735,
-0.5664991736,
-0.8955271244,
0.9699235559,
0.4182828963,
0.4758274555,
0.3142386675,
0.5982006192,
-0.1363371909,
0.1299300194,
-0.7857580781,
-0.6838416457,
-0.5455431342,
-0.2287484556,
0.0372568183,
-0.3298906088,
-0.1598262191,
-0.254093647,
0.2891149819,
-0.2649877965,
0.6875067353,
0.5944045782,
0.1007809043,
-0.2771161199,
-0.0149498275,
0.3443505466,
0.1222533286,
-0.2068201154,
0.1283315718,
0.0301223882,
-0.4185044765,
0.1718109697,
-0.0538660549,
-0.0137518272,
-0.4926534593,
-0.0313962847,
0.6449046135,
0.3586528003,
0.0847842619,
0.4967030585,
0.0675980896,
-0.0509555899,
-0.389383167,
0.0651477352,
0.0420704968,
0.2841527462,
0.8192816973,
0.6719008088,
0.3223493993,
-0.1072817817,
0.342127949,
0.2213525921,
-0.8131123185,
-0.2758476138,
0.9046909213,
0.3591333032,
-0.4008907378,
0.3269913495,
0.3206106722,
-0.7448102832,
1.0044505596,
0.5305480361,
1.1533432007,
-0.3685013652,
-0.0483381227,
0.4287914336,
0.4241449833,
-0.0240301974,
-0.0637288392,
-0.1545041651,
-0.7062840462,
-0.7057082057,
-0.4086566567,
0.0369518027,
0.1700125486,
-0.8841699958,
0.2671336532,
-0.6000460982,
-0.343593061,
0.3274250627,
-0.5100708008,
-0.9425820708,
0.4784238935,
0.0975640044,
0.5623477697,
-0.6369091272,
0.5010274649,
0.4032478034,
-0.3213567138,
-0.641079843,
-0.0836734101,
-0.278696239,
-0.6850687861,
0.9402854443,
0.6120403409,
-0.3047350645,
0.3469260037,
-0.2487281859,
-1.3061469793,
0.7377356887,
0.1924616247,
-0.4154423475,
-0.2387309968,
-0.0221640207,
0.5620422959,
-0.5166386366,
0.0508144498,
0.3377241194,
0.1763320863,
0.1786978543,
-0.4327464402,
-0.1307495385,
-0.2620409131,
0.0850345194,
0.2671144307,
-0.9395382404,
0.6702006459,
-0.0865024403,
-0.3740667403,
-0.1764691174,
0.9532902837,
-0.5501274467,
-0.1222384647,
0.5388050675,
0.4013796747,
-0.0598959252,
-0.0917941853,
1.1211818457,
-0.304781884,
0.3251104057,
0.9165048599,
-0.1301592886,
0.433255583,
0.442258507,
-0.2276872098,
0.2390854806,
0.3116239607,
-0.4484459758,
0.614803493,
0.0074188621,
0.1903175861,
-0.3317247033,
-0.0119217029,
-0.3763102889,
0.293371886,
0.1062752604,
-0.6823154688,
-0.0732549056,
0.1404120028,
-0.6595081687,
-0.0796646476,
-0.4484369755,
0.6244695783,
0.0868069977,
-0.5954729915,
0.3768392205,
-0.0987704545,
0.5143994689,
-0.3106121123,
0.3134303987,
-0.0122517711,
0.5505747199,
-0.13332358,
-0.403701216,
0.4029914737,
-0.1924577057,
-0.698462069,
-0.398497045,
0.7705664635,
-0.1533507109,
-0.7164337635,
0.3052935004,
0.107322529,
-0.4691105485,
-0.2179260254,
-0.6654574275,
-0.3115341365,
-0.0696651563,
-0.5004874468,
0.0383492708,
0.081234701,
0.1945654601,
0.6689212918,
0.4753368497,
-0.6466356516,
0.3644792736,
0.257488817,
0.9626510143,
-0.5408853889,
-0.4187801182,
-0.8610176444,
0.6107037067,
-0.1017286479,
-0.1659296751,
0.6057878733,
0.5831707716,
0.3035699427,
-0.2908308506,
0.8499455452,
0.2000427991,
0.4932861328,
-0.0369180813,
0.3745402694,
-0.5509868264,
-0.2762720585,
-0.1096458733,
-1.2178658247,
-0.5271490812,
0.8112367392,
-0.2828101516,
0.2026853263,
0.4922420382,
0.5470919609,
-0.453029424,
-0.0569262579,
0.2789872587,
0.0513362698,
-0.0459222458,
0.4288823903,
0.6818579435,
-0.6795098782,
0.480063349,
-0.4444927573,
-0.1066701412,
-0.1817403734,
-0.7112683058,
-0.9549341202,
-0.4868780673,
-0.298684299,
-0.3073738813,
-0.3239818811,
0.9273613691,
1.0013341904,
-0.7353294492,
0.0883876532,
-0.0483275428,
-0.3493848443,
-0.2182957083,
-0.2792239785,
0.2858307958,
-0.6286504865,
-0.5750397444,
0.3035387993,
0.6310318708,
0.2472712249,
-0.6631112695,
0.3458662033,
0.1853838861,
0.1113848239,
0.553047359,
0.3124646246,
-0.7911450863,
-0.2713858187,
0.5777215362,
-0.4225481153,
0.4396365583,
1.0776309967,
-0.9095496535,
0.3424725235,
0.3208803236,
0.6819341779,
0.6163262129,
0.1704266965,
0.8667058945,
-1.0095295906,
0.4064627588,
0.3472355902,
0.2222523838,
0.5052866936,
-0.710778892,
0.6343745589,
0.1275366843,
-0.5266523361,
-0.5672498345,
0.376460582,
-1.2056281567,
0.3911442757,
1.0113928318,
0.2708242536,
-0.5062978268,
0.0007846779,
-0.2117857039,
0.1968355775,
-0.2320786864,
0.6711195707,
0.3791233599,
0.0730876848,
-0.3356325924,
-0.531871438,
0.4013471603,
0.6371180415,
-0.2311204225,
0.22625494,
-0.0403058566,
0.1697785556,
0.4661021531,
0.0152637539,
-0.1333420575,
0.3577230871,
-0.3589050472,
0.1045574322,
-0.0017877544,
-0.5197646022,
-0.4332855642,
0.4576699436,
-0.464202106,
-0.3080565631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13779v1 | FoRAG: Factuality-optimized Retrieval Augmented Generation for Web-enhanced Long-form Question Answering | 2024-06-19T19:06:36 | 2024-06-19T19:06:36 | Tianchi Cai, Zhiwen Tan, Xierui Song, Tao Sun, Jiyan Jiang, Yunqi Xu, Yinger Zhang, Jinjie Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) has become prevalent in
question-answering (QA) tasks due to its ability of utilizing search engine to
enhance the quality of long-form question-answering (LFQA). Despite the
emergence of various open source methods and web-enhanced commercial systems
such as Bing Chat, two critical problems remain unsolved, i.e., the lack of
factuality and clear logic in the generated long-form answers. In this paper,
we remedy these issues via a systematic study on answer generation in
web-enhanced LFQA. Specifically, we first propose a novel outline-enhanced
generator to achieve clear logic in the generation of multifaceted answers and
construct two datasets accordingly. Then we propose a factuality optimization
method based on a carefully designed doubly fine-grained RLHF framework, which
contains automatic evaluation and reward modeling in different levels of
granularity. Our generic framework comprises conventional fine-grained RLHF
methods as special cases. Extensive experiments verify the superiority of our
proposed \textit{Factuality-optimized RAG (FoRAG)} method on both English and
Chinese benchmarks. In particular, when applying our method to Llama2-7B-chat,
the derived model FoRAG-L-7B outperforms WebGPT-175B in terms of three commonly
used metrics (i.e., coherence, helpfulness, and factuality), while the number
of parameters is much smaller (only 1/24 of that of WebGPT-175B). Our datasets
and models are made publicly available for better reproducibility:
https://huggingface.co/forag. | [
-0.516798377,
-1.1713190079,
0.5681926608,
0.2818537652,
-0.2786622643,
0.0564909913,
-0.0727564469,
-0.6232165098,
0.222219184,
0.2342609912,
-0.5541909933,
-0.2439074069,
-0.150908336,
0.0805378482,
-0.2615110874,
1.2906947136,
0.0932257921,
-0.3277513087,
-0.5288011432,
-0.2175173312,
-0.3089443445,
-0.3895180821,
-0.4743605256,
-0.2146673948,
0.609166801,
0.3711555898,
0.6138466597,
0.4513923824,
0.5285616517,
0.1960639209,
-0.0962626711,
0.632656157,
-0.8788356185,
0.0356046259,
-0.1527121961,
-0.2561454475,
-0.5861453414,
-0.1530833393,
0.4529032111,
0.4469413757,
-0.3145859838,
0.6971899867,
-0.0212187096,
0.7018331289,
-0.9086570144,
-0.0303762518,
-0.8056149483,
-0.2429745048,
-0.0431016646,
-0.2661642134,
-0.4123622477,
-0.4166503251,
0.0113890739,
-0.7944425344,
0.2847186327,
0.1827633083,
1.0937170982,
0.3353177011,
-0.3252966106,
-0.6167790294,
-0.6412394643,
0.6990687847,
-0.6061446071,
0.4467914402,
0.1201940328,
0.4576567411,
-0.3008669317,
-0.8483527899,
-0.7145199776,
-0.1214153692,
-0.0653643534,
0.3561268747,
-0.0541468225,
0.0325798281,
0.2148064524,
0.4873377085,
-0.6473546624,
-0.1155286729,
-0.3920078278,
-0.3188652992,
0.8553622365,
-0.0020262918,
0.0289343856,
-0.1945860386,
-0.6221986413,
0.113863945,
-0.7862457037,
0.3845359385,
0.2533844709,
0.2194017917,
0.0534157939,
0.4865422249,
-0.4600764215,
0.5583734512,
0.3082228303,
-0.6157737374,
0.1178696826,
-0.2457234859,
0.0004062637,
-0.0881281719,
0.2785066366,
0.348110348,
-0.0454967842,
-0.008391046,
-0.3361080289,
-0.1884292215,
-0.0413128473,
-1.0057454109,
-0.0450989343,
0.5951576829,
-0.438986361,
-0.1741254628,
-0.0852866769,
-0.6615778208,
-0.353728652,
-0.177829951,
0.4064721465,
-0.0776867643,
-0.3728747964,
-0.0324863456,
-0.2030779421,
0.450558871,
0.3351207078,
-0.448584646,
0.083768189,
0.7285649776,
0.3779163659,
-0.2582751811,
0.0132799735,
-0.7199626565,
0.1590245366,
-0.4480277598,
1.0412427187,
-0.2522767186,
-0.1979591697,
0.1998494267,
-0.4619585276,
0.1862639934,
-0.5808048844,
0.7934966683,
-0.8945615888,
0.4264478385,
-0.3100062013,
-0.6264072061,
-0.2025003582,
0.5081256032,
-0.656488061,
0.9903837442,
-0.2670577466,
-0.790700078,
0.4576375782,
-0.5629913807,
-0.1628987938,
0.0642662942,
-0.1559565365,
-0.4767523408,
-0.0026853394,
0.3288767934,
0.2614840865,
-0.459828794,
0.4356967807,
-0.1825153232,
-0.3526909947,
0.1804637462,
-0.5403162241,
0.4605968297,
0.3738611937,
-0.3228208721,
0.0475774631,
-0.8673926592,
0.325222224,
0.1388050616,
-0.5911079049,
-0.0923712924,
0.0531323068,
-0.1026932001,
0.2151258886,
0.3704246879,
-0.5856949687,
-0.2952798903,
-0.4813651145,
-0.2920323908,
0.7487768531,
0.1584633887,
0.0039152228,
-0.4210734963,
0.463698864,
-0.1918609291,
0.15049918,
0.0865451321,
-0.4873981178,
-0.8475311995,
-0.5280195475,
0.4047511816,
0.664660275,
-0.8762802482,
0.2730177343,
-0.3333040476,
-0.4090186954,
-0.5365559459,
0.0187241342,
0.6026214957,
0.4830830395,
0.378272891,
-0.0523663387,
-0.3841147721,
-0.8659091592,
-0.2553390861,
-0.0728853643,
0.132900849,
0.5135295391,
0.3386138082,
-0.0667816103,
1.0449534655,
-0.6140136719,
0.0892613456,
-0.1657471359,
-0.0627985299,
0.2484895438,
0.1954350919,
0.3635375798,
-0.9813221097,
-0.5545262694,
-0.1913549155,
-0.6895321608,
-0.1272884458,
-0.1459403485,
-0.2287821025,
0.4086440206,
0.1271620542,
-0.5324115157,
0.5560292006,
0.5205118656,
-0.1922856569,
0.6945694685,
0.1224652529,
0.1868444234,
-0.9502578974,
0.4542024136,
-0.2381327003,
-0.2789906263,
-0.5725941658,
0.2816592753,
-0.2445383668,
-0.2052997649,
-0.2931127548,
0.8382433653,
-0.5052380562,
-0.0089699356,
-0.4330019057,
0.4094094932,
0.0583696365,
0.6289228201,
-0.2616626918,
1.0014573336,
0.0406420045,
-0.6075976491,
0.2945851982,
0.3140462935,
-0.1333127916,
0.4102346003,
-0.8098746538,
0.3289916217,
-0.2211846262,
0.3151931167,
-0.9543628097,
-0.3272114098,
0.0740106329,
-0.6680107713,
0.1810985357,
0.0366073474,
-0.2638687491,
-0.1924784184,
-0.4550121427,
0.3539182842,
0.6433378458,
-0.7724380493,
0.5180160403,
0.2787803113,
-0.1804938167,
-0.8728530407,
-0.140469268,
-0.0184768178,
-0.0785998777,
-1.0271376371,
0.1890250295,
-0.183065787,
-0.2955830693,
-0.2552866936,
-0.3261618614,
-0.0459502749,
-0.0357322954,
-0.2238468826,
0.1288983524,
-0.1749572009,
0.213673085,
0.1863258481,
0.0925072581,
0.1557018459,
0.224120155,
0.503900826,
-0.1944045871,
-0.3761531711,
-0.1655336618,
0.6147560477,
0.043542292,
-0.5301795602,
0.6449178457,
0.6957334876,
-0.0570390113,
-0.2977928221,
-0.7967408895,
-0.2791083753,
-0.5231026411,
0.3144358993,
-0.4807237685,
-0.9441584945,
0.6324304342,
-0.0807733834,
0.3508036733,
0.5027320385,
0.5283232331,
-0.0362440608,
0.9576588273,
0.3894499242,
0.4436526895,
0.0981333479,
-0.0101136062,
0.1934748292,
-0.5906786323,
-0.1807934195,
-0.399182409,
0.0640095621,
-0.7793970108,
-0.3537020981,
0.6728258133,
0.108093068,
-0.1848201752,
-0.5701234937,
-0.4539752007,
0.2821533084,
0.4313433766,
0.1632799953,
0.2494329959,
0.088392742,
0.051659897,
0.1648140699,
-0.798833549,
-0.3974461555,
0.9836391807,
0.2115374207,
0.6654465199,
0.2796253562,
0.7623910904,
0.3625663221,
0.1287958324,
-0.5910225511,
0.5980650783,
0.0746062845,
-0.8323506117,
-0.1961452216,
-0.3054991066,
-1.0439888239,
0.1544693708,
-0.3781313002,
-0.3456690311,
-0.0142260129,
0.5395107865,
-0.1649242789,
-0.0591463111,
-0.5835506916,
0.4930469394,
-0.0530835912,
-0.5891054869,
-0.273663342,
-0.8365576863,
0.6451231241,
0.047044646,
0.1371899396,
-0.1077178195,
0.1415688097,
0.5726881027,
-0.2928052843,
0.4650895,
-0.3189020455,
-0.2929776311,
0.673556447,
-0.2082771212,
0.7717202306,
0.1689953655,
0.0879612193,
-0.1985959858,
-0.0351229683,
-0.5697289109,
-0.7420339584,
0.4786304235,
-0.6571381092,
-0.9846829176,
-0.3259411752,
-0.3262544274,
-0.2792959511,
0.1937087029,
0.1080823168,
0.683409512,
-0.1169160455,
0.2851510942,
0.9005998373,
-0.296521157,
0.0776745081,
0.315325886,
-0.4153144658,
-0.5364674926,
0.9827661514,
-0.1805461794,
0.4717254341,
0.3452038169,
0.3414672315,
-0.4005429149,
-0.4778947234,
-0.6032223701,
0.3131873906,
-0.8895969987,
-0.2468734086,
-0.4852582216,
-0.2826685905,
-0.5860211253,
0.0196710248,
-0.1146608889,
-0.5186232328,
0.0224165097,
0.0135413455,
0.4039936364,
0.3756111264,
-0.0682716221,
-0.0941063613,
-0.8641862273,
0.6831954122,
0.4204044044,
0.254964143,
0.016121788,
-0.4074652791,
-0.2734737694,
0.3490460217,
-0.3073185384,
-0.6600258946,
-0.115066953,
0.3949787915,
0.6632260084,
0.092262432,
0.1850796938,
0.7932542562,
-0.5271441936,
0.8223894835,
-0.003819746,
-0.6223585606,
0.3715634942,
-0.3928685188,
0.057127282,
0.4482648373,
0.2281523198,
-0.3144489825,
-0.1308220625,
-0.6542343497,
-0.9043868184,
0.2709827721,
0.3347112834,
0.0419027247,
0.0830810815,
0.4886296988,
0.1832518429,
0.3340024054,
-0.4986945689,
-0.3665103614,
-0.3354327977,
-0.1959668398,
0.3424867392,
-0.471639514,
-0.2210325301,
-0.0536721721,
0.8916903734,
-0.2560917139,
0.435670644,
0.3911692798,
-0.004711282,
0.1496692151,
0.333661288,
0.6511519551,
0.9616254568,
-0.1984632015,
-0.195171088,
0.2161561102,
-0.4521711767,
-0.0922726542,
0.3611517549,
-0.3541890681,
0.0039765467,
0.1961563975,
0.7149577737,
-0.5832820535,
-0.7752928138,
0.4180834293,
0.1658222079,
0.0050860243,
-0.5189115405,
0.072394371,
-0.112191014,
0.1438250095,
0.6142296195,
-0.3626146913,
0.536984086,
-0.5064404011,
0.1854910702,
0.6115641594,
0.0185075141,
-0.0851183236,
0.5174693465,
0.5278459787,
-0.1132610366,
0.4577119648,
-0.3500609696,
-0.4186398983,
0.3514129221,
0.585457325,
0.7552954555,
0.1598723233,
0.1417514682,
0.4430247247,
0.0453520119,
0.2755802572,
0.5093902349,
-0.0077383085,
-0.6288211942,
-0.6247823238,
-0.6837747693,
-0.4416037202,
0.0358044766,
-0.5455633998,
0.125237152,
-0.1853748113,
-0.0805688277,
-0.1563429534,
0.2161186635,
-0.4880154431,
0.5800780058,
0.0345890857,
0.7396913767,
-0.4494845569,
0.2524046004,
0.6309758425,
-0.4568943381,
-1.0178445578,
0.0748438016,
-0.1443361789,
-0.8111870885,
0.2906436026,
0.0945089385,
-0.4590392709,
0.0316413194,
-0.7782866955,
-0.9387792349,
1.1877965927,
0.1734094471,
0.0451853238,
-0.080192931,
0.1456371248,
0.4880399108,
-0.0500093251,
0.1374763697,
0.3114181459,
0.4882714152,
0.3126839697,
-0.8593021035,
0.1840913594,
-0.3790232837,
-0.063636966,
0.1439890116,
-0.9247959256,
0.5134364963,
-0.101163052,
-0.3189630806,
0.2010758519,
0.9293933511,
0.8237735629,
0.5051940084,
0.4461732805,
0.3959151804,
0.7266230583,
0.0580340587,
0.9627683759,
-0.1737175435,
0.3177678883,
0.9273139238,
-0.1575736403,
0.7236503363,
0.500154078,
0.0109972851,
0.5386121273,
0.4238780737,
0.1847888231,
0.3725267053,
0.2246599048,
-0.2628655136,
-0.2496235073,
-0.2468389571,
-0.3213468194,
0.5719408989,
0.153831318,
0.0527760014,
-0.3283695579,
-0.2488602102,
0.274929136,
0.3484436572,
-0.2358020842,
0.9438275099,
-0.2206176221,
-1.0072889328,
1.1386568546,
0.0317774229,
0.6963630915,
-0.6202495694,
-0.3132731616,
-0.4681514502,
0.1018646285,
-0.3175814152,
-0.6060426831,
0.124068588,
0.2253475338,
-0.249725908,
0.1356398761,
0.9786332846,
-0.4323090911,
-0.3534918427,
-0.2409906983,
0.6511614919,
0.2278853506,
0.1126345769,
-0.772010088,
-0.1138486266,
0.2195191681,
-0.3737465739,
0.0521260984,
0.4022099078,
-0.1593134701,
0.6304479837,
0.805680275,
0.0002480611,
0.1979713887,
-0.2113824934,
0.8568371534,
-0.3361222744,
-0.4269649386,
-0.4024081826,
0.7106792331,
-0.4093906283,
-0.2649218142,
0.7943426967,
0.6973502636,
0.4725517929,
0.0423502177,
0.6643560529,
-0.2654712796,
1.0471596718,
-0.5717657208,
0.6122691631,
-0.7080067396,
-0.0207465868,
-0.1691066921,
-0.8423848152,
0.0255191121,
0.1541892886,
0.1232794374,
0.141500473,
0.4953921735,
0.8380463123,
0.0922484472,
-0.2359957248,
0.2257641554,
-0.0832052082,
0.6517572403,
0.2572302818,
0.694806993,
-0.4126226604,
0.7579013705,
-0.0670847297,
-0.2567993402,
-0.159374848,
-0.7341243029,
-0.8002440929,
-0.5761016607,
-0.0481774509,
-0.4594090283,
0.2402370274,
0.9142317176,
0.2965542376,
-0.6127024293,
-0.0598187149,
0.2579159439,
0.0485401899,
-0.040297512,
-0.2282282263,
0.6366458535,
-0.5370310545,
-0.5303000808,
0.1373614967,
-0.0826729238,
-0.0927874148,
-0.2112887353,
0.0347457677,
-0.4639045596,
0.470618546,
0.7685810924,
0.3469333351,
-0.7404600382,
-0.5768520832,
0.2720634937,
0.0531371906,
0.0203115512,
0.3566009104,
-0.6255880594,
0.3869557083,
0.5132291317,
0.9137209654,
0.3727748096,
0.5207643509,
0.4704407156,
-0.8671781421,
0.1447909772,
0.3448367119,
-0.0634531453,
0.4049936235,
-0.3979069591,
0.4990141988,
0.100564003,
-0.7602316737,
-0.8726845384,
0.2658599615,
-0.9042673111,
-0.1100159064,
1.5041812658,
-0.0476113595,
-0.1168369651,
-0.0239952374,
-0.4006622136,
0.300819695,
-0.4083612263,
0.9197738171,
0.5599304438,
-0.2491257042,
0.1234014407,
-0.4081434608,
0.8104434609,
0.3539763093,
-0.9854767323,
-0.0563037246,
0.8657997847,
0.1768219322,
0.249356702,
0.5511051416,
0.1123293489,
0.67270118,
-0.0869737566,
0.1219850108,
-0.1449107379,
-0.2023266703,
0.211919412,
0.1948496699,
0.2749989331,
-0.1017173231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13777v1 | Game of LLMs: Discovering Structural Constructs in Activities using Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T19:02:44 | 2024-06-19T19:02:44 | Shruthi K. Hiremath, Thomas Ploetz | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Human Activity Recognition is a time-series analysis problem. A popular
analysis procedure used by the community assumes an optimal window length to
design recognition pipelines. However, in the scenario of smart homes, where
activities are of varying duration and frequency, the assumption of a constant
sized window does not hold. Additionally, previous works have shown these
activities to be made up of building blocks. We focus on identifying these
underlying building blocks--structural constructs, with the use of large
language models. Identifying these constructs can be beneficial especially in
recognizing short-duration and infrequent activities. We also propose the
development of an activity recognition procedure that uses these building
blocks to model activities, thus helping the downstream task of activity
monitoring in smart homes. | [
0.0339368023,
-0.9314715862,
0.7751108408,
0.1742868721,
-0.1036185622,
0.5307642221,
0.1306910664,
-0.3849281967,
0.3164297342,
0.3617369235,
-0.5429937243,
-0.4264813662,
-0.3769094944,
-0.1147845387,
-0.326908201,
0.5599707961,
-0.2673117816,
-0.084025681,
0.0647743419,
0.2354153544,
-0.281459868,
-0.2376333028,
-0.5042184591,
-0.5736570358,
0.2829170227,
0.2660878301,
0.3244888484,
0.8880727291,
0.424046725,
0.3785476983,
-0.1815954,
0.347905457,
-0.4251332581,
0.1501218081,
0.2185623944,
-0.3162925839,
-0.5958935022,
-0.1355432421,
0.51412642,
0.6925037503,
0.0658434108,
0.7017757297,
-0.0364823565,
0.747105062,
-0.0718631521,
0.5851377249,
-0.2919670641,
0.4341882765,
-0.3283246458,
-0.4669452906,
-0.0340934843,
-0.0513984598,
-0.0261323191,
-0.0889910161,
0.41330567,
0.4080060422,
0.7141928673,
0.0741804987,
-0.4531447291,
-0.5488603115,
-0.9401583672,
0.7586001754,
-0.5552566648,
0.478518188,
0.6303902864,
0.1032351777,
-0.5809969306,
-0.2272713035,
-0.1712839901,
-0.4071990848,
0.0016891123,
-0.2013415098,
-0.0005074416,
-0.0346913263,
0.4903762043,
0.4764932394,
-0.5126563311,
-0.151082918,
-0.5207745433,
-0.5238377452,
0.7989950776,
0.710398972,
0.3168987036,
-0.5092539787,
-0.3554116786,
0.8081890941,
-0.7661376595,
0.3840989172,
0.4254172444,
0.3573625684,
-0.2274547219,
1.0549072027,
-0.0992330536,
0.5742255449,
-0.0250300411,
-0.6104047894,
-0.0044957134,
-0.4108580649,
0.0351095386,
0.3709750772,
0.2832060754,
0.1517460197,
0.1744538695,
-0.2365122437,
-0.3762222528,
0.2158284485,
0.0587783307,
-0.7082287669,
-0.2375608236,
0.359051168,
-0.6919940114,
-0.1216956452,
-0.0527355,
-0.3027256429,
-0.6122517586,
-0.3428233862,
0.1308990121,
0.0495411269,
-0.1867377162,
0.2967193723,
-0.1409278065,
0.2055167854,
-0.1128305867,
-0.8426466584,
0.6335189342,
0.7948760986,
0.9999260902,
-0.1850408018,
-0.0055552255,
-0.5367824435,
0.1848967224,
-0.2849702835,
0.806312561,
-0.0725425258,
-0.718313992,
-0.1047677994,
0.1423977762,
0.2020999044,
-0.4994783998,
0.0075494079,
-0.5854533315,
0.1356690377,
-0.140066877,
-0.8133451939,
0.1697444618,
0.4838117957,
-0.8549969196,
1.0109145641,
0.1967383027,
-0.4999282956,
0.1347251385,
-1.0551772118,
-0.734555006,
0.1773644537,
-0.0105248783,
-0.7352792025,
0.4604151547,
-0.3295846879,
0.680762887,
0.031583067,
-0.002217341,
-0.1457246542,
-0.4456717372,
0.3423312306,
-0.2105954438,
0.6826074719,
0.3741425276,
-0.2806685269,
0.2104437053,
-0.9205691814,
-0.5486984253,
0.1297563016,
-0.6841948628,
-0.2933396995,
0.8057254553,
-0.3367848098,
-0.0954142436,
0.4720542729,
-0.7876549959,
0.1043809652,
-0.07006035,
0.5808905363,
0.7741956711,
0.0547022894,
0.3056393862,
-0.4665798545,
0.5273749828,
-0.1498158127,
0.1353439838,
-0.2475200593,
-0.6002092361,
-0.3717164099,
-0.6485588551,
0.1924608499,
0.6367629766,
-0.3807532787,
0.4266429245,
-0.4547461867,
-0.1344933808,
0.0946661383,
0.2257965207,
0.1373469383,
0.2275518328,
-0.1020921469,
-0.395590812,
-0.8843705654,
-0.3717114031,
-0.1147296429,
-0.3162331283,
-0.0489450023,
0.4236325324,
0.4583052993,
-0.2865318358,
1.1130212545,
-0.8062952161,
-0.249398008,
-0.3360129595,
0.0553258583,
0.2959246635,
-0.055289492,
0.3441129923,
-0.758453846,
-0.4319248497,
-0.081572473,
-0.754858613,
-0.0025691311,
-0.0769404098,
0.2362391949,
-0.1982078999,
0.8192527294,
-0.27603212,
0.4777024984,
0.4993364215,
-0.7575832009,
0.5988196135,
0.1034132242,
-0.1623941213,
-1.1819531918,
-0.3300349712,
0.0190446787,
-0.5071536899,
-0.6095632315,
-0.2969351411,
-0.1781397313,
-0.1579191685,
-0.4800718725,
0.7383176684,
-0.9133646488,
-0.451592505,
-0.181457594,
-0.1514213085,
-0.2358987182,
0.5802625418,
-0.018728124,
0.6380565166,
0.4138118923,
-0.6760413647,
0.6562138796,
-0.1685413867,
-0.8582136035,
0.214069277,
-0.3302656412,
-0.0377354212,
-0.003691535,
-0.1179214716,
-1.2861247063,
-0.4377698004,
0.1203983054,
-0.3606587648,
0.0443707705,
-0.0295543242,
-0.6556304693,
-0.4464824498,
-0.6830451488,
0.3916812539,
0.3996777833,
-0.3965211809,
0.921251297,
0.8038102388,
-0.0671895146,
-0.2749794126,
-0.2844590247,
-0.2798455656,
-0.4786529541,
-0.3711181879,
0.3163115382,
-0.1826718301,
-0.4371187091,
-0.0082158269,
-0.286252588,
-0.2081926614,
0.4831809402,
0.7082009912,
0.5716732144,
-0.2280906737,
0.0664846823,
-0.5510286093,
0.0897040516,
0.2293604016,
0.0096571734,
0.630841732,
-0.1936997622,
-0.5034672618,
-0.1806314141,
0.2761384845,
0.6647694707,
-0.0634967759,
0.1737872362,
0.3489365876,
-0.6816752553,
-0.0207357127,
-0.4444483519,
0.0459752157,
-0.5309222341,
0.5347800255,
-0.1873148978,
-1.2560442686,
0.9577059746,
-0.2712403238,
0.2667735517,
0.0099232113,
0.7401590943,
-0.3089157939,
0.9582638741,
0.8435848951,
-0.268849045,
1.066852808,
-0.0709155276,
0.5474280119,
-1.199668169,
-0.2907753885,
-0.2581817806,
-0.576418519,
-0.4775451422,
-0.4865091145,
0.2792411447,
-0.2792172134,
-0.1510155052,
0.5288231373,
-0.1540130079,
0.5336219668,
-0.0346694179,
0.2992642522,
0.5327426791,
0.1556879282,
0.0442987457,
-0.0366946608,
-0.5233622193,
-0.5787412524,
1.06559515,
0.5697715878,
0.8640313148,
0.2876780331,
0.91686517,
0.6930277944,
0.6129027009,
-1.2673580647,
0.8355412483,
0.1174776033,
-1.0615296364,
-0.4567726851,
-0.4016163945,
-1.4201704264,
-0.3566131592,
0.1764786243,
-0.8106985688,
0.0587654933,
-0.0602366999,
-0.6803509593,
0.4418785274,
-0.4706299603,
0.4599737227,
-0.4834649861,
-0.2793942392,
-0.1466055959,
-0.1067802012,
0.4136550128,
0.1438843906,
0.5909113884,
-0.3722273707,
0.1260416061,
0.5708681345,
-0.0814510956,
1.0616366863,
0.1871306747,
-0.323179096,
0.7651149035,
0.2655002475,
0.428552568,
0.0772183165,
0.2504103184,
-0.1401709318,
-0.278750807,
-0.459851414,
-0.2725000978,
0.5441938639,
-0.4189979732,
-0.5248494148,
-0.5723058581,
-0.4777014852,
0.0323855765,
-0.0985188559,
-0.1655369997,
0.5497161746,
-0.4909283221,
0.1621527821,
0.61980021,
0.4312703311,
0.7555221915,
0.7160543203,
-0.3651690781,
0.1772440523,
1.2231841087,
0.3381172121,
-0.2272313535,
0.4122650027,
0.3223275244,
-0.3257370591,
-0.6148830056,
-0.0238194354,
0.2565051019,
-0.3725086749,
-0.1138305888,
-0.1733738333,
-0.1847606152,
-0.0326486714,
0.0149625726,
-0.2078145742,
-0.4378336668,
-0.4417689145,
-0.3202238679,
0.1728867292,
0.9268392324,
0.0028562804,
0.1439572126,
-0.9380844235,
0.6945715547,
0.6450907588,
0.6094810963,
-0.1010304764,
-0.314376682,
-0.4596338272,
-0.3787445128,
-0.2709461451,
-0.8414635658,
0.0890725628,
-0.0734041706,
0.7575230002,
0.4785056114,
-0.2917148471,
0.4935599267,
-0.6452419162,
1.0178449154,
0.2195284218,
-0.8423229456,
0.2572858334,
-0.3052798212,
-0.0644891337,
0.0865856111,
0.2876242101,
-0.2767775059,
0.3794313073,
-0.6661595106,
-0.8104239702,
0.1310960203,
-0.0264875833,
0.1218737438,
-0.1480608881,
0.2103725374,
-0.2766785622,
0.3833121657,
-0.8535334468,
0.0540898629,
0.0787725002,
-0.0483487882,
0.3008293211,
-0.2717093825,
-0.2806653976,
-0.2648255229,
0.4576368332,
-0.16740188,
0.359479934,
-0.0151888458,
-0.2401969582,
-0.2538222075,
0.1259512156,
0.6540210843,
0.6069718599,
-0.1300610453,
0.1858309209,
0.2520117164,
-0.6784741282,
0.2032391131,
-0.1753558815,
0.1574296802,
0.0587635152,
0.6030675769,
0.5909745097,
0.2951752245,
-0.8415566087,
0.289039284,
0.0635998771,
-0.0845309421,
-0.6521264911,
0.1813989729,
0.1641340405,
0.6355894804,
0.1585771441,
-0.1596272439,
0.2150741071,
-1.196829319,
0.0878306031,
0.512676537,
-0.5928234458,
-0.6066929698,
0.2955211997,
0.1640692055,
-1.1037495136,
0.5619750619,
-0.3650490344,
-0.6274471879,
0.7830458283,
0.2102741152,
1.016428709,
-0.2887154222,
0.1369030923,
0.0954513326,
0.0427173488,
-0.2325193584,
0.883577764,
-0.2774790525,
-0.8320275545,
-0.4593498111,
-0.6724285483,
-0.2642245889,
-0.0076870485,
-0.3217797577,
0.1336756945,
-0.5485723019,
-0.4123420119,
-0.0593327098,
0.2885120809,
-0.5259931684,
0.0138905626,
0.5091369748,
0.5725674033,
-0.8491867185,
0.7149452567,
0.673032105,
0.153868556,
-0.6991009116,
-0.2580794096,
0.3177536726,
-0.6247683167,
0.6259106994,
-0.2002936155,
-0.4696239829,
-0.1709464639,
-0.62340343,
-0.7508652806,
1.3958722353,
-0.1187592447,
-0.5371018648,
-0.0592716224,
0.0525231063,
0.6565054655,
-0.668173492,
-0.3851599395,
0.4643586874,
0.5186675191,
-0.2438557595,
-0.5629755259,
0.0512712896,
-0.1720749587,
-0.1692847759,
0.1981915683,
-0.5448940992,
0.8047590852,
-0.5204593539,
-0.3532109559,
0.1508176476,
0.7862525582,
0.6298606396,
0.682839334,
0.6136466861,
0.0412031338,
0.642401278,
-0.0880432352,
0.8035855293,
-0.449860394,
0.4762253463,
0.8452367187,
-0.4178898931,
0.6849051118,
0.4870435297,
-0.5203896165,
0.6423887014,
0.7790710926,
-0.0884348601,
0.4788413942,
0.7207533121,
-0.3560158014,
-0.2324432284,
-0.0894868895,
0.0147124454,
0.4262869954,
0.7603015304,
-0.25045982,
-0.1832913309,
-0.2716584206,
0.0620330721,
-0.0184505433,
-0.2536836565,
0.6313503981,
0.1667293459,
-0.4424373806,
0.0943089575,
-0.0351675861,
0.5576871634,
-0.8910422325,
-0.1025395691,
0.0084225805,
0.063134931,
-0.3652684093,
-0.5621100068,
0.3660154045,
-0.1598439813,
-0.3858042359,
-0.3004417419,
0.6704409719,
-0.1816937029,
-0.504353106,
0.2588506043,
0.6965700984,
0.2581062913,
0.0003874438,
-0.3374024928,
-0.0531408973,
-0.2182570696,
-0.4262552857,
0.3787548244,
0.5525095463,
-0.3845967352,
0.5954008698,
0.7282090187,
0.1496782303,
0.2662013471,
-0.0976690128,
0.6998252869,
-0.7919582725,
-0.5301603079,
-0.9042128325,
0.4083795547,
-0.0105036553,
-0.2926778197,
0.9299740791,
0.9347093105,
0.4636283815,
-0.1727223545,
0.513792038,
0.0301899556,
0.4459269941,
-0.4231959879,
0.2170937508,
-0.3699153066,
0.7581840158,
0.0420940854,
-0.9168493152,
-0.1285546124,
0.6537616253,
-0.1457890421,
-0.5850611925,
0.6613023281,
0.8075080514,
-0.1769952029,
0.0612792969,
0.3001433313,
0.1627923846,
0.4750925004,
0.3595644832,
1.0189114809,
-0.2305215746,
0.25879246,
0.0470234342,
-0.2110922933,
-0.3843687177,
-1.1250060797,
-1.1458944082,
-0.5876734853,
-0.3740878403,
-0.4429143965,
-0.1020547003,
1.0721924305,
0.6664145589,
-0.8765319586,
-0.910928309,
0.1397396177,
0.4238844812,
-0.5316598415,
-0.1809330732,
0.3708264232,
0.1041560546,
-0.3454926312,
0.6722542048,
0.513769567,
0.1394992024,
-0.6843167543,
-0.0034963712,
-0.2647410333,
0.3496632576,
1.0740176439,
0.6692870855,
-0.5276688933,
-0.4280364811,
0.3470217586,
0.0125729516,
0.0812350363,
1.3503572941,
-0.5558386445,
0.1320583671,
0.8770487309,
0.3848268688,
0.5948951244,
-0.0827170536,
0.0096968086,
-0.8982102871,
-0.0624137893,
0.1002311483,
0.6154793501,
0.187695846,
-0.5273218751,
0.7122402191,
0.3505738378,
-0.4784040451,
-0.8750937581,
0.5262771249,
-1.0673390627,
-0.4029527307,
1.0249625444,
-0.0569862798,
-0.544591248,
-0.8520573974,
-0.3420951664,
-0.0224888325,
-0.2825623155,
1.2865771055,
1.0033739805,
-0.6020035148,
0.1579124779,
-0.5617411137,
0.4165817499,
-0.0964770243,
-0.6987068653,
0.0496756658,
0.3486317694,
0.4344089031,
0.6007342935,
0.7660979033,
-0.1716559976,
0.0437572561,
-0.2815873623,
-0.4916603267,
-0.1772136241,
-0.5347514749,
0.068005383,
0.3619783521,
-0.1945217103,
-0.2211927176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13770v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13770v1 | Elliptical Attention | 2024-06-19T18:38:11 | 2024-06-19T18:38:11 | Stefan K. Nielsen, Laziz U. Abdullaev, Rachel Teo, Tan M. Nguyen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML | Pairwise dot-product self-attention is key to the success of transformers
that achieve state-of-the-art performance across a variety of applications in
language and vision. This dot-product self-attention computes attention weights
among the input tokens using Euclidean distance, which makes the model prone to
representation collapse and vulnerable to contaminated samples. In this paper,
we propose using a Mahalanobis distance metric for computing the attention
weights to stretch the underlying feature space in directions of high
contextual relevance. In particular, we define a hyper-ellipsoidal neighborhood
around each query to increase the attention weights of the tokens lying in the
contextually important directions. We term this novel class of attention
Elliptical Attention. Our Elliptical Attention provides two benefits: 1)
reducing representation collapse and 2) enhancing the model's robustness as the
Elliptical Attention pays more attention to contextually relevant information
rather than focusing on some small subset of informative features. We
empirically demonstrate the advantages of Elliptical Attention over the
baseline dot-product attention and state-of-the-art attention methods on
various practical tasks, including object classification, image segmentation,
and language modeling across different data modalities. | [
-0.7555356026,
-0.7013347149,
0.4362527132,
0.4552437067,
-0.1568969041,
-0.1934242547,
-0.3517872691,
-0.5032631159,
0.5073040128,
0.5278906822,
-0.4935615361,
-0.5781847835,
-0.6754459143,
0.0491294339,
-0.5970031619,
0.777887702,
0.0259971116,
-0.4173625708,
-0.2783820629,
-0.3264032006,
-0.3857373297,
-0.6302746534,
-0.2905223966,
0.3496411443,
0.9018978477,
0.5400097966,
0.7598734498,
0.8646384478,
0.7997451425,
0.362082094,
0.3034237325,
0.1780789346,
-0.5905240178,
0.3156756461,
-0.0884604529,
-0.5172079206,
-0.3675920069,
-0.033234179,
0.3934442699,
0.8371317387,
-0.0008057629,
0.6110615134,
0.202742368,
1.0434396267,
-0.9269205332,
0.032212276,
-0.3847928345,
0.1708940268,
-0.3884981871,
0.0365864523,
-0.0791608021,
-0.1183432415,
0.0327112488,
-1.0433067083,
0.1449617594,
0.3956696391,
0.9846301675,
0.7702363729,
-0.1109572127,
-0.0081221545,
-0.8662628531,
0.802541554,
-0.1407880634,
0.6398189068,
0.3754605353,
0.5479972959,
0.0832751542,
-0.6689906716,
-0.4413360953,
0.2019289434,
-0.0164081734,
0.2362558693,
-0.4123864472,
-0.0099216066,
0.0583914891,
0.1880055368,
-0.2140220553,
-0.2020888627,
-0.474527806,
0.1014441922,
0.3306755424,
0.1910117567,
0.1207003146,
-0.2966893911,
-0.6249437332,
-0.0765590891,
-0.7131730914,
-0.0569124036,
0.3851286173,
0.1423651278,
0.2406508178,
0.6838209033,
-0.5539438128,
0.7282833457,
0.8073465228,
0.2142510712,
-0.0465097576,
-0.109237574,
-0.2668065429,
-0.0529112034,
0.4726390541,
0.4960986376,
0.1519379467,
-0.3643024266,
0.0776297301,
-0.3894194663,
0.50690341,
-0.6846436262,
-0.1576213986,
0.255343169,
-0.7501491904,
0.1077788174,
-0.0125671374,
-0.7374102473,
0.1927783191,
-0.6509967446,
0.4236729145,
-0.2473465353,
0.0267154127,
0.1969306916,
0.1192414463,
-0.1387815922,
-0.0646761134,
-1.2547872066,
0.133790642,
0.5632879734,
0.54018116,
-0.2828944325,
-0.0147284642,
-0.3391963243,
0.4376443028,
-0.4007357657,
1.0756323338,
-0.7179883122,
-0.0947163999,
-0.0519542918,
0.0284910891,
-0.1125977635,
-0.6968829036,
0.7134071589,
-0.4695882499,
0.1582533717,
-0.2471240312,
-0.2285801917,
-0.3219701946,
0.2311892956,
-0.5839547515,
1.477373004,
0.1097831428,
-0.8963669538,
0.3748551011,
-0.4111707211,
-0.4077430964,
0.2222401947,
-0.1523235291,
-0.7923720479,
0.1324389577,
0.6246130466,
0.6110238433,
0.1951745152,
-0.3820486367,
-0.6809486747,
-0.1602968276,
0.0190514214,
0.0317276083,
0.2110890895,
-0.0667966828,
-0.6717537045,
0.1818909496,
-0.7926048636,
0.0032835731,
0.0724467114,
-0.0969012529,
-0.7826041579,
-0.0511282384,
0.2996407747,
0.2195705026,
0.4078308344,
-0.2708588839,
0.09470319,
-0.4683096707,
0.2022766024,
0.6476004124,
-0.0289685577,
0.5476137996,
0.1709564775,
0.6327602863,
0.0307222214,
0.5238770247,
-0.075014554,
-0.1456467956,
-1.0628005266,
-0.6663424373,
0.2401571721,
0.0656609312,
-0.5703898668,
0.8331571221,
-0.1675671786,
-0.4712694585,
-0.5380401611,
0.1683778018,
0.3424471915,
0.5868467689,
0.2892670631,
-0.2616914809,
-0.4771876633,
-1.3266763687,
-0.3114611506,
0.1508833915,
-0.2736888826,
0.4166639745,
0.1006609946,
-0.1337619275,
0.9068468213,
-0.5257406235,
-0.8224371076,
-0.0718668625,
-0.2138884962,
0.1328569651,
-0.0547696538,
0.6345664859,
-0.7987338901,
-0.6132650971,
-0.0152813364,
-0.3373036981,
-0.0120725203,
0.0037742867,
-0.5121935606,
-0.1030367091,
0.5337354541,
-0.766661346,
0.5065687299,
0.4509319961,
-0.2938683629,
0.4281221926,
-0.0002013197,
0.1030305475,
-0.8980278373,
0.3277351558,
0.1177379265,
-0.2279542089,
-0.4254546165,
-0.0976349115,
0.0610870309,
0.1126490906,
-0.3416002095,
0.3686683476,
-0.7284559608,
-0.332437098,
-0.1680990756,
0.4120351672,
0.1796760857,
0.962737143,
0.0346340351,
0.5659576654,
0.5005959868,
-0.6332633495,
0.361228317,
0.4032075405,
-0.2073414624,
0.94483006,
-0.8559577465,
0.2048753649,
-0.0191239826,
-0.1782163829,
-1.1786952019,
-0.1598702371,
0.3183541596,
-0.4706490934,
0.2683567107,
0.1992269456,
-0.4730153382,
-0.4664944708,
-0.2983707786,
0.7042155266,
0.2088331282,
-0.7912803888,
0.6507745981,
0.3579033017,
-0.1309449375,
-0.5515936017,
-0.5212278962,
-0.0755498111,
-0.6641930342,
-0.6921185851,
0.2245337516,
0.3777287304,
0.0206502192,
0.1752201766,
-0.0596402027,
0.2017848045,
-0.1330639571,
0.4416055381,
0.0521668606,
-0.1192087084,
0.1155373156,
-0.0359967835,
-0.2266863883,
0.2187957168,
-0.5007568598,
0.3295283914,
0.2526479959,
-0.3362432122,
-0.5165873766,
0.5763248801,
0.4709173143,
-0.5580055714,
0.4976323247,
0.5461639762,
-0.4173136353,
-0.1425000727,
-0.5515096784,
-0.3633234501,
-0.5106204748,
0.6841599345,
-0.3628550172,
-0.6970559359,
0.3416358531,
0.2066064775,
-0.3508550227,
0.3383247554,
0.8840203285,
-0.130053401,
1.2104303837,
0.7378966808,
-0.2094820738,
0.7271825075,
-0.0531410649,
0.6507345438,
-1.1381940842,
-0.335082531,
-0.4647935331,
-0.5866022706,
-0.1221960858,
-0.5110505819,
0.6963398457,
-0.0968846083,
0.0659654513,
0.485973537,
-0.9009596109,
0.4203942716,
0.6031635404,
0.2191707939,
0.0687252283,
0.2077335566,
0.1257898659,
-0.4810059369,
-0.7433866858,
-0.3137005866,
1.266533494,
0.3984689116,
0.6931817532,
-0.2611453831,
0.5203099251,
0.0719285533,
0.1274634898,
-0.7032766938,
0.2510259748,
0.115715079,
-0.7126578689,
-0.5000898838,
-0.0542789847,
-1.052339673,
0.3317409456,
0.0589313731,
-0.5939697623,
0.4380850792,
0.199966535,
-0.5997747183,
-0.168699488,
-0.6663357615,
0.8723177314,
-0.1858647615,
-0.5353915095,
-0.3434834182,
-0.5805882215,
0.0856718495,
0.1634030938,
0.0659013689,
-0.2866674364,
-0.199568823,
0.6309776902,
-0.1415471286,
0.6923636198,
0.0193598978,
0.1606749743,
0.0933180451,
0.0137671409,
0.2609256804,
-0.0184170194,
0.7213469744,
0.3393655717,
-0.3867242634,
-0.5781304836,
-0.7036187053,
0.4704275429,
-0.6094766259,
-0.799050808,
-0.0675708577,
-0.5122128725,
-0.1089847535,
0.3915979862,
0.1443109065,
0.3139149547,
-0.0745418444,
0.1233916655,
0.654045701,
0.2374349236,
0.3737920821,
0.0190952905,
-0.2334008813,
-0.4376944602,
0.6520000696,
0.1031982824,
0.2425252497,
0.467440784,
-0.2460827082,
-0.4470379651,
-0.2800603509,
-0.4147348106,
0.3097819388,
-0.5377551913,
-0.3630233109,
-0.6600558162,
0.1926351041,
-0.2643963695,
-0.0537510701,
-0.6563673019,
-0.8136143684,
-0.1210772321,
-0.0731299669,
0.0816669241,
0.6560696959,
-0.0342940725,
-0.0505753197,
-0.3163542151,
0.3815297186,
0.4821642339,
0.1909281015,
0.0046096612,
-0.3565399945,
-0.6340500712,
-0.3884370029,
-0.4762163758,
-0.6191187501,
0.5459915996,
0.1758180261,
0.5663170815,
0.8325195312,
-0.0834064335,
0.759776473,
-0.6923107505,
0.3196174502,
0.2909145057,
-0.7423834801,
0.3942959309,
-0.4442647994,
0.3087991178,
0.4049315453,
0.4136485159,
-0.6564919949,
-0.7264788151,
-0.2575071752,
-0.8561162949,
0.5255593657,
0.5507620573,
-0.0829850137,
-0.0563173071,
0.4233646393,
-0.1158269495,
-0.0086222244,
-0.2964572906,
-0.5128219128,
-0.2474140972,
-0.4355990887,
0.2242787182,
-0.1044755355,
-0.306943506,
-0.2362531275,
0.4374262094,
-0.2465642542,
0.4592155218,
0.6124119759,
0.0719517693,
-0.1062052324,
-0.2585669756,
0.3424192965,
0.4464568794,
0.0963591635,
0.1673134714,
-0.0431049392,
-0.5214354992,
-0.1080255508,
0.2951689959,
0.104492642,
0.0575319901,
0.1176534742,
0.3715559542,
0.4202652574,
-0.2899386287,
0.4457955956,
-0.0749149546,
0.0662445053,
-0.2743952274,
-0.2692162395,
0.2196696848,
0.2173004746,
0.5481503606,
0.0329852104,
0.788207531,
-0.1612136066,
0.2514442801,
0.369605571,
-0.5284574032,
-0.3325721622,
1.0244055986,
0.4041787386,
-0.1009256765,
0.1695911437,
0.2198438793,
-0.7039222121,
0.7926804423,
0.206130445,
0.8407405615,
-0.361510098,
-0.111275956,
0.4385367334,
0.1776729971,
0.3540811241,
-0.3326533437,
-0.4465997517,
-0.3296834528,
-0.1041490957,
-0.2754510045,
-0.1411132962,
-0.608537972,
-0.7520037889,
0.3519360423,
-0.4273141921,
-0.3248219192,
0.0219930112,
-0.332942158,
-0.5809984207,
0.2475258261,
0.2654362619,
0.4073197544,
-0.430008173,
0.6232946515,
0.5032473207,
-0.3250249028,
-0.5591132641,
-0.0427579023,
-0.4762658775,
-0.9307051897,
0.7719369531,
0.5779328942,
-0.3820125461,
-0.2451279312,
-0.3811084032,
-1.3462259769,
0.976797998,
0.309376359,
-0.9149681926,
-0.1704734564,
0.4821559191,
0.5312334299,
-0.4558478892,
0.278799206,
0.5246845484,
0.3479555547,
-0.2005521059,
-0.645632565,
-0.0407554507,
-0.0636175573,
0.274235487,
0.3644062877,
-1.1840940714,
0.3705933392,
-0.0138050411,
-0.5018620491,
-0.0084015699,
1.0138632059,
0.1172554195,
0.2530008554,
0.5457509756,
0.7276893854,
0.3029000461,
-0.1255115271,
0.9073277116,
-0.7023178339,
0.6025338769,
0.7902721167,
0.1139420718,
0.7572811842,
0.7868565917,
-0.2419980168,
0.5260961652,
0.6938208342,
0.1375096291,
0.6973314285,
-0.0813968778,
0.1658427417,
-0.3240443766,
0.080264993,
-0.2142578512,
0.2355787307,
0.3432289362,
-0.3374095857,
0.1654957235,
0.0034117231,
-0.026164161,
0.3141136765,
-0.2142181993,
0.5618075132,
0.1299870014,
-0.6310887337,
0.5297352672,
-0.2544592917,
0.2966883183,
-0.0789950788,
0.0541734546,
-0.3332332373,
0.5697361827,
-0.2452042848,
-0.3908326924,
0.4727685153,
-0.4275215566,
-0.3426517844,
0.0796412826,
0.4569815397,
-0.5282737017,
-0.6756126881,
0.4110637605,
-0.1142362654,
-0.1292250305,
-0.4490142465,
-0.7762362361,
0.0039188298,
-0.1747178286,
-0.4882285893,
-0.0899018049,
0.6947575808,
0.1383418888,
0.6418883801,
0.36835742,
-0.2843833566,
0.5045226216,
-0.1132109091,
0.8414537907,
-0.5652068853,
-0.6209272742,
-0.4748179913,
0.3575687408,
-0.2780809104,
-0.3898228109,
1.0092029572,
0.6165724993,
0.6101386547,
0.0637976006,
0.4389847815,
0.1490413547,
0.627177,
-0.3627274632,
0.5744818449,
-0.6701043844,
-0.2026939243,
-0.1102719828,
-1.3116869926,
-0.4679920673,
0.4231368899,
-0.5378306508,
0.0524949506,
0.8243629336,
0.5870409012,
-0.1009705961,
-0.5296846032,
0.4861879647,
0.0864845365,
0.0464098118,
0.7826296687,
0.7088056803,
-0.4243705571,
0.7735599875,
-0.3087495565,
-0.2007298917,
-0.3525015116,
-0.1605555564,
-1.2235376835,
-0.6371157169,
-0.2895772755,
-0.0612533242,
0.1127239391,
0.3751094639,
1.2914102077,
-0.5749827027,
0.2146580964,
0.1609262526,
-0.0032920223,
-0.2119284123,
-0.2285791337,
0.7505743504,
-0.5103616714,
-1.0838713646,
-0.2897583246,
0.8864069581,
-0.2903727889,
-0.696534276,
0.1834124923,
0.1385645568,
0.1314787269,
0.4130370617,
0.1718608141,
-0.7497663498,
-0.270573318,
0.240118742,
-0.295145303,
0.4969327748,
0.6979312301,
-0.4983832538,
0.5257165432,
0.1585602313,
0.5799039006,
0.6946790218,
0.3372645974,
0.5060235262,
-0.7114737034,
0.4942421317,
0.2127600461,
0.2204390168,
0.5355498791,
-0.7648060918,
0.2519404888,
0.0819579139,
-0.7528811693,
-0.1987424195,
0.3162676692,
-1.0214607716,
0.1173717752,
1.0860087872,
-0.1656453758,
-0.9139301777,
-0.0931498855,
-0.5072655678,
-0.11374598,
-0.4214604497,
1.2244055271,
0.6430909634,
-0.1959451735,
-0.0038021803,
-0.2716332376,
0.4755243361,
0.9985662699,
-0.7306888103,
-0.0051983064,
0.238525033,
0.1794456095,
0.3755883276,
-0.1357329935,
-0.3753996193,
0.3822728992,
-0.1470288634,
0.4015620351,
0.3059639037,
-0.5193876624,
-0.1376515329,
0.3358337879,
-0.0898988917,
-0.6036145091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13764v1 | Can LLMs Reason in the Wild with Programs? | 2024-06-19T18:26:19 | 2024-06-19T18:26:19 | Yuan Yang, Siheng Xiong, Ali Payani, Ehsan Shareghi, Faramarz Fekri | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown superior capability to solve
reasoning problems with programs. While being a promising direction, most of
such frameworks are trained and evaluated in settings with a prior knowledge of
task requirements. However, as LLMs become more capable, it is necessary to
assess their reasoning abilities in more realistic scenarios where many
real-world problems are open-ended with ambiguous scope, and often require
multiple formalisms to solve. To investigate this, we introduce the task of
reasoning in the wild, where an LLM is tasked to solve a reasoning problem of
unknown type by identifying the subproblems and their corresponding formalisms,
and writing a program to solve each subproblem, guided by a tactic. We create a
large tactic-guided trajectory dataset containing detailed solutions to a
diverse set of reasoning problems, ranging from well-defined single-form
reasoning (e.g., math, logic), to ambiguous and hybrid ones (e.g., commonsense,
combined math and logic). This allows us to test various aspects of LLMs
reasoning at the fine-grained level such as the selection and execution of
tactics, and the tendency to take undesired shortcuts. In experiments, we
highlight that existing LLMs fail significantly on problems with ambiguous and
mixed scope, revealing critical limitations and overfitting issues (e.g.
accuracy on GSM8K drops by at least 50\%). We further show the potential of
finetuning a local LLM on the tactic-guided trajectories in achieving better
performance. Project repo is available at
github.com/gblackout/Reason-in-the-Wild | [
-0.259460628,
-0.8898256421,
0.8513863087,
0.3624960184,
-0.1856997013,
0.1753843427,
-0.5562313199,
-0.290490061,
0.1548665464,
0.6094688773,
-1.0174980164,
-0.591417551,
-0.5537214279,
-0.0663540512,
-0.2031453997,
0.7427805066,
-0.2705497742,
-0.0777334422,
0.0280342642,
-0.39793697,
-0.7293416858,
-0.5316373706,
-0.3130342662,
-0.3049726188,
0.5956581831,
0.5588611364,
0.6930888295,
0.4071652293,
0.5031041503,
0.2580370605,
-0.1205570325,
0.5473549366,
-0.6731647253,
0.4168376327,
-0.3353888392,
-0.7026321888,
-0.072277382,
0.1518421322,
0.4278870821,
0.7646662593,
-0.1993322521,
-0.2375412881,
-0.2676499188,
0.4740637541,
-0.5454350114,
-0.2320706695,
-0.9040959477,
0.1037181467,
-0.2886952162,
-0.34730497,
-0.1655362844,
-0.3091962934,
0.1628264487,
-0.6825815439,
-0.0442627445,
0.1620706767,
0.9088025093,
0.2314002067,
-0.4882989824,
-0.494176507,
-1.086370945,
0.8920323849,
-0.7380642891,
0.0616416335,
0.2380972803,
0.6488210559,
-0.6315984726,
-0.4175987542,
-0.3251119852,
-0.1708951145,
0.1978319138,
0.024390256,
-0.1819638908,
0.0164384767,
0.6196362972,
0.0750778466,
-0.5539826751,
0.2344274372,
-0.4009943008,
-0.2193596214,
0.7455019951,
0.3614380956,
-0.0421275757,
0.4163691103,
-0.1462388486,
0.0417047441,
-0.7822219133,
0.2123384774,
0.4178637862,
0.2743861079,
0.0264792927,
0.9190030694,
-0.3004024923,
0.8669723272,
-0.2103656381,
-0.0387831703,
-0.3195493519,
-0.1980511546,
-0.3667828739,
-0.2270307243,
0.4450393021,
0.3376351297,
0.4423054755,
-0.1736914814,
-0.4116329551,
0.1482400298,
0.0038026075,
-0.4066726267,
-0.1199732348,
0.2771059275,
-0.1719361842,
-0.1051505879,
-0.327183634,
-0.5293149352,
-0.6549050808,
-0.4008514285,
0.3083023429,
-0.4970756173,
-0.0524875559,
0.5481618643,
-0.2309940904,
0.4999300838,
0.3522456288,
-0.7880817652,
-0.0300138053,
0.7999995947,
0.7195336223,
-0.0505411811,
-0.3869569898,
-0.526380837,
0.061399959,
-0.6032761931,
0.8300669789,
-0.6321706176,
-0.3633580506,
0.0107003842,
-0.2597185075,
-0.1205297336,
-0.5863903761,
0.6658690572,
-0.4548173249,
-0.1425147802,
-0.3860758245,
-0.5739378333,
-0.0954701528,
0.6387965679,
-0.3108898997,
0.7545449138,
-0.2638427615,
-0.4252575636,
0.5434201956,
-0.4453926384,
-0.4846050739,
-0.1303371638,
-0.374293983,
-0.0933909491,
0.2341742963,
0.1284228265,
0.4499173164,
-0.315721482,
0.4192889929,
-0.4512155652,
-0.5043261051,
0.402177304,
-0.3669359386,
0.6705205441,
0.2391176969,
-0.2587383091,
0.3255999684,
-0.6573659778,
0.1746246219,
0.2733669877,
-0.399037987,
-0.3771308362,
0.2059765905,
-0.5826636553,
0.1138716266,
0.0707735643,
-0.3146364391,
0.6095607877,
-0.4453845024,
0.5352364779,
0.7177014947,
-0.0040782527,
0.4717358351,
-0.3731634617,
0.6402838826,
-0.3128375411,
0.1550922245,
0.0070616771,
-0.6121697426,
-0.852868557,
-0.1200987995,
-0.1536908895,
0.556381762,
-0.5422482491,
0.0671757609,
-0.0632456541,
-0.4394932389,
-0.0248599183,
-0.0810146779,
0.0926929191,
0.1721983552,
0.1984812319,
0.2582529783,
-0.6000701189,
-0.5934096575,
-0.6564455628,
0.1045029387,
0.1456458569,
0.421787262,
0.5104438663,
-0.2945633829,
1.0823428631,
-0.5064283013,
-0.1192086712,
-0.5037638545,
0.1251602322,
0.3858894706,
0.2170318812,
0.3696938753,
-0.8273615241,
-0.003113192,
-0.0836871192,
-0.7379443645,
-0.2856003046,
-0.3882799447,
-0.2286533415,
-0.1388210505,
0.5348776579,
-0.7560776472,
0.2400802821,
0.381704092,
-0.4404470325,
0.7683019638,
-0.2495675087,
-0.1910459995,
-0.4084481597,
-0.0776760951,
0.0250100289,
0.0893394575,
-0.5349156857,
0.3218699992,
-0.2757539451,
-0.0054295612,
-0.2936775684,
0.4867195785,
-0.3226131201,
-0.1205641925,
-0.1205754206,
0.1002712548,
-0.0500609651,
0.3567401171,
0.0636945814,
0.5799772143,
0.7676424384,
-0.4906316102,
0.6087752581,
-0.2714042366,
-0.2862022221,
0.3063120842,
-0.4194217622,
0.0088265762,
-0.1677708626,
0.2203300595,
-0.7676912546,
-0.3646669686,
0.1281560361,
-0.2393728495,
0.1878749132,
-0.2620822489,
-0.3476771414,
-0.3717951477,
0.0430746935,
0.108900331,
0.3242934644,
-0.3343290985,
0.5715967417,
0.0474064201,
0.3499955833,
-0.5489885807,
-0.6373018622,
0.099532783,
-0.565384686,
-0.7397161126,
-0.0853196979,
-0.0234473553,
-0.714448154,
-0.1700725108,
-0.4137495756,
0.0585965887,
0.1935117096,
0.210297212,
0.1504338235,
-0.1646217555,
-0.0136150345,
-0.0214033481,
0.081521675,
0.1943728477,
-0.624576509,
0.231152311,
-0.302288413,
-0.6188694835,
0.438267231,
0.4727905691,
0.6079053879,
-0.2663071752,
0.5861008763,
0.2576691806,
-0.3712723851,
-0.6860579848,
-0.4063687325,
-0.1724835783,
-0.4720060229,
0.050645031,
-0.4633174539,
-0.9829389453,
0.6618314385,
-0.432192862,
0.2202684283,
0.1104445383,
0.4965993464,
-0.0361199267,
0.9706886411,
0.5570878386,
0.2517331541,
0.0519429334,
-0.4721283615,
0.3731558323,
-0.4029874802,
-0.4866724014,
-0.2983367145,
-0.3885839283,
-0.5017484426,
-0.6343372464,
0.3591096401,
0.3693133593,
-0.1815164387,
0.1534649581,
-0.4315369427,
0.8058848977,
0.4066387117,
-0.0860805884,
0.1833969355,
-0.2728313804,
-0.601123929,
-0.0499109849,
-0.799939096,
-0.5763810277,
1.0115246773,
0.2913201153,
0.9021633267,
0.1040824801,
0.7443258166,
-0.0413278639,
0.3811560571,
-1.1203187704,
0.7666405439,
0.0266332887,
-0.8007586002,
-0.3803771734,
-0.398991704,
-0.9378840327,
0.4365917444,
-0.3066906333,
-0.8046568036,
0.045989316,
0.0867607519,
-0.4784237146,
0.3036663532,
-0.5644219518,
0.9736738801,
-0.491691947,
-0.3973498344,
-0.0200551674,
-0.6956996322,
0.6758995056,
-0.0221062209,
0.2655509412,
-0.4055195153,
0.1210373864,
0.5223539472,
-0.3830887973,
0.756558001,
-0.0189469941,
-0.1765192002,
0.4332411289,
0.240759939,
0.7213635445,
-0.0185391754,
-0.0263608955,
0.0471010432,
-0.0231737047,
-0.1532595009,
-0.7615535855,
0.7084926367,
-0.3536456227,
-0.8291355371,
-0.5498709679,
-0.7951198816,
-0.4224780202,
0.2661086619,
0.2474622875,
0.3314537704,
0.033792682,
-0.1328658909,
0.9613600373,
-0.168985635,
0.2627595663,
0.6541693807,
-0.2592105567,
0.1632954925,
0.8123376369,
0.1015576348,
0.2229644209,
0.1999365389,
0.4820190668,
-0.2807985544,
-0.9163861275,
-0.3134714067,
0.055282101,
-1.0026190281,
-0.0114023099,
-0.2348185778,
-0.1273562908,
0.072968781,
-0.4657967091,
-0.1332277507,
-0.2108391076,
-0.1573229581,
0.1857562959,
0.2256907374,
0.5817933679,
-0.0155553846,
0.113454029,
-0.5490580201,
0.1401436627,
0.2773010433,
0.124451153,
-0.3906932473,
-0.4450966418,
-0.0378354974,
0.0817322135,
-0.3035718799,
-0.9674944878,
0.4310107231,
-0.0751044527,
0.7505095601,
0.3109917939,
0.070957087,
0.6012529731,
-0.2921997309,
0.5188320875,
-0.1455606967,
-0.5540736318,
0.7262314558,
-0.7622689009,
0.2651174664,
0.2849891186,
0.3044396639,
-0.3040158451,
-0.7175037265,
-0.4001463056,
-0.6296352148,
0.5828806758,
0.2642647922,
-0.0886239931,
0.2105813175,
0.4538632631,
-0.1557581127,
-0.0593748949,
-0.5531376004,
-0.105114162,
0.0966402367,
0.1694745272,
0.0030420215,
0.1429529637,
-0.5672608018,
-0.1496217549,
0.3223336935,
-0.284856081,
0.0831120759,
0.0449427702,
0.2629447877,
-0.1457335204,
0.4373256862,
0.8529471159,
0.7882218957,
-0.2529091537,
0.2292649746,
0.2095116675,
-0.1631038636,
0.1276925504,
0.1457467079,
-0.0043782224,
-0.2520753145,
0.4870612323,
0.5713124871,
0.0572399236,
-1.0547115803,
0.4974840879,
-0.0484855399,
-0.2622211277,
-0.0894928798,
0.288271904,
0.0552147329,
0.5128104091,
0.4432626665,
0.2538157403,
0.027916152,
-0.6534217,
-0.1847714186,
0.7719855309,
0.0823965147,
0.05478663,
0.4798380733,
0.0105528822,
-0.2460447401,
0.375094384,
-0.4244960845,
-0.6876155734,
0.9678395987,
0.476516813,
0.6930853128,
0.2848035395,
-0.0492467023,
-0.0585713126,
0.6671177745,
-0.1772194058,
0.4146408737,
-0.0450033136,
-0.8242737651,
-0.7820055485,
-0.500700295,
-0.6120391488,
0.2950538993,
-0.2410850972,
0.2793322504,
-0.4399589002,
-0.0292132627,
-0.0359583609,
-0.0208026581,
-0.4401596189,
0.1289809346,
0.2215940058,
1.0076332092,
-0.7899516225,
0.8009117246,
0.9020822644,
0.0733841658,
-1.0372364521,
0.0945100859,
0.1614975184,
-0.766305387,
0.677891314,
0.1873959303,
-0.1963142604,
-0.3613897264,
-0.798340857,
-0.8362993598,
0.8434328437,
0.3204451203,
-0.8055938482,
0.0973985866,
0.0586503819,
0.4169518948,
-0.2101789117,
-0.015454635,
0.7958191633,
0.5956261158,
0.6200228333,
-0.7885299921,
0.0529227518,
0.1550084949,
-0.3672728837,
0.299459368,
-0.5269927382,
0.6919141412,
-0.730491221,
-0.0236267596,
-0.0159872845,
0.5020711422,
0.637180388,
0.5758781433,
0.1280025989,
0.4916995764,
0.7770389915,
-0.3022118509,
0.8920437098,
0.0940821767,
0.1711390018,
0.8884184957,
-0.4536295235,
0.4756546915,
0.5104808807,
0.0403903797,
0.2462162077,
0.7817994952,
0.2113344073,
0.5632297397,
0.6368814707,
-0.2592825294,
-0.6745429039,
0.2866387665,
-0.0050384565,
0.5522142649,
0.6960082054,
0.1478147358,
-0.4433071613,
0.0179728512,
0.0244909413,
0.1471540332,
-0.3031411469,
0.2175198495,
0.1402945817,
-0.9128510356,
0.6177383661,
0.265540272,
0.5685184002,
-0.9347672462,
-0.0504197441,
-0.315528512,
0.2799023688,
-0.1797310114,
-1.0432014465,
0.5550148487,
-0.1396104544,
0.1501431167,
-0.2181399018,
0.917041719,
-0.2726266384,
-0.2492471933,
0.0194058046,
0.4876765013,
0.1666011959,
0.0836589187,
-0.646946013,
0.3099996448,
-0.1519502997,
-0.2042835057,
0.2852980494,
0.8628243208,
-0.255553335,
1.0544776917,
0.7493978143,
0.2831694782,
0.2590725124,
-0.0670509338,
1.0656729937,
-0.5008202791,
-0.4281793535,
-1.0355707407,
0.1170028597,
0.0015989367,
-0.481490314,
0.9821804762,
0.4420548379,
0.6179991961,
0.2052515,
0.6220478415,
-0.0326601937,
0.0855343267,
-0.751770854,
0.1948541403,
-0.3772551715,
0.5953081846,
0.1238198206,
-0.6788223982,
-0.5048511624,
0.7498724461,
-0.638907373,
-0.1072412804,
0.50737077,
0.8028185368,
-0.0693602413,
0.0566070117,
0.4010339677,
0.1203619316,
0.4679575264,
0.9884518385,
1.3068879843,
0.2345253974,
0.6073998213,
0.0175698344,
-0.4096558392,
-0.2415200174,
-1.1436026096,
-1.0191017389,
-0.1061721966,
-0.1766805053,
-0.292616725,
0.1931488663,
0.7687714696,
0.713310957,
-0.3401517868,
-0.2112421542,
-0.4461968541,
0.4272063076,
-0.2456933856,
-0.2001999021,
-0.1100029871,
-0.3890720308,
-0.2601675987,
0.7857035995,
0.3377396166,
0.0550289862,
-0.4057104588,
-0.185034737,
-0.0319500826,
0.4074842036,
0.4452550113,
0.5849752426,
-0.7616179585,
-0.1305807531,
0.2012626976,
-0.0330442749,
-0.3969108164,
1.1931055784,
-0.6991736889,
0.3982809186,
0.2340526432,
0.3682134748,
0.5421571136,
-0.2604953945,
0.4928350449,
-0.6283490658,
0.0609778911,
0.6292242408,
0.4135355949,
-0.002897915,
-0.2643174231,
0.376686275,
0.2459778488,
-0.6979176998,
-0.7063961029,
0.4077655375,
-0.9099545479,
-0.4081982374,
1.6821434498,
-0.1654921174,
0.0760516822,
-0.1861037314,
-0.3955512643,
-0.1204026863,
-0.1977953911,
0.4512521923,
0.7791451216,
-0.4084196687,
0.1007032394,
-0.6954913139,
0.5165230632,
0.5024315715,
-0.6585398912,
0.1973876804,
0.6421883106,
0.1772487909,
-0.0510443337,
0.5322998166,
0.2418322414,
-0.0012034694,
-0.1241439134,
-0.5901507139,
-0.0725925267,
-0.4648689628,
-0.3021922708,
-0.0142238932,
0.1940497905,
-0.0559379868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13762v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13762v1 | Unveiling the Hidden Structure of Self-Attention via Kernel Principal Component Analysis | 2024-06-19T18:22:32 | 2024-06-19T18:22:32 | Rachel S. Y. Teo, Tan M. Nguyen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML | The remarkable success of transformers in sequence modeling tasks, spanning
various applications in natural language processing and computer vision, is
attributed to the critical role of self-attention. Similar to the development
of most deep learning models, the construction of these attention mechanisms
rely on heuristics and experience. In our work, we derive self-attention from
kernel principal component analysis (kernel PCA) and show that self-attention
projects its query vectors onto the principal component axes of its key matrix
in a feature space. We then formulate the exact formula for the value matrix in
self-attention, theoretically and empirically demonstrating that this value
matrix captures the eigenvectors of the Gram matrix of the key vectors in
self-attention. Leveraging our kernel PCA framework, we propose Attention with
Robust Principal Components (RPC-Attention), a novel class of robust attention
that is resilient to data contamination. We empirically demonstrate the
advantages of RPC-Attention over softmax attention on the ImageNet-1K object
classification, WikiText-103 language modeling, and ADE20K image segmentation
task. | [
-0.4826770723,
-0.6152176261,
0.4803074896,
0.3613616228,
-0.1099753901,
-0.1028764918,
0.033983212,
-0.2773255408,
0.1504067183,
0.4265429974,
-0.8289657831,
-0.3668019474,
-0.4035532176,
-0.1039155275,
-0.3542028368,
0.6612351537,
0.24946329,
-0.474642396,
-0.245767951,
-0.0216834694,
-0.6052612662,
-0.630415678,
-0.2256449014,
0.1066313609,
0.725782156,
0.4113458395,
0.3813348711,
0.8577499986,
0.9116171598,
0.2766135037,
0.1523603201,
-0.1875065565,
-0.6470758915,
0.2334321886,
-0.3451759219,
-0.3146739006,
-0.6281492114,
0.3346896172,
0.4195772111,
0.4430014491,
0.2801157236,
0.4061985612,
0.5433356166,
0.8267300725,
-0.992171526,
0.3127223551,
-0.3562234044,
0.5979425907,
-0.0310362391,
-0.2524610162,
-0.4580788314,
0.3180691302,
0.1487224847,
-0.3982748687,
0.6868489981,
-0.4149803817,
0.6194798946,
0.7872991562,
-0.1709133536,
0.2836247683,
-0.6024304032,
0.9278615713,
-0.0081185419,
0.6027418971,
0.5920062661,
0.3557423353,
-0.1207729205,
-0.6796941757,
-0.2139967531,
0.0547972918,
-0.0171887819,
0.4838766456,
-0.1010278016,
-0.0371736698,
-0.1966650337,
0.4436539412,
-0.3454250097,
0.142042011,
-0.4624567926,
-0.2292862535,
0.2425650358,
0.1739839464,
0.0382481627,
-0.2540510893,
-0.6498085856,
-0.3625577092,
-0.5499742031,
0.1259015054,
0.0121513866,
0.4799095094,
-0.0926374719,
0.484045893,
0.0037296142,
0.5700944662,
0.4381181896,
-0.0188261457,
-0.0434984565,
-0.4178721607,
-0.5753287077,
0.0503754392,
0.6342745423,
0.0614365004,
0.0553517193,
-0.2193965316,
0.1488655061,
0.3226518929,
0.827055335,
-0.4152899086,
-0.4820955694,
0.2439336926,
-0.9303034544,
-0.706150651,
-0.1152118295,
-0.9310869575,
0.1827887744,
-0.279409647,
0.3579331338,
-0.1764146239,
0.0449424684,
-0.1244957298,
0.3657921553,
0.4320625365,
0.1169435754,
-1.0024706125,
0.1738597304,
0.8929626942,
0.5945077538,
-0.4857945144,
-0.2070711851,
-0.5474123955,
0.0050056609,
-0.393509239,
1.1015590429,
-0.4588101804,
-0.2105871737,
-0.3846342564,
0.0779307261,
-0.1296747774,
-0.2762625217,
0.6196244955,
-0.2934406102,
0.1755892336,
-0.2508443594,
-0.1798860282,
-0.2048468292,
0.2049324661,
-0.4893340468,
1.0359127522,
-0.0885888338,
-0.842633903,
0.2643278837,
-0.3876122534,
-0.3722379804,
0.1958511472,
-0.4274138808,
-0.6524426937,
0.3310635984,
0.4562597573,
0.7799678445,
0.0164668802,
-0.0932648852,
-0.6355124712,
0.0076178205,
0.1507661939,
-0.5319076777,
0.5308132172,
0.3302634656,
-0.3567092717,
-0.0167772938,
-0.7551810741,
-0.1167595312,
0.0988650396,
-0.2428885847,
-0.0433071591,
0.0305929631,
0.0239393581,
0.3115003407,
0.2154392451,
-0.4241964817,
0.0404090807,
-0.2569716871,
0.303481251,
0.9698786736,
-0.0382710397,
0.4736901522,
0.4596982896,
0.736923635,
0.0869159997,
0.4242250621,
-0.5746895671,
-0.5132325292,
-0.6345482469,
-0.6049407721,
0.1713130772,
0.3559043109,
-0.0520149656,
0.5747100115,
0.1431689113,
-0.1862622797,
-0.4494534135,
0.130298242,
0.4547171295,
0.8173933625,
0.2517680228,
-0.587295115,
-0.1581509709,
-1.2723354101,
-0.0586372353,
0.0530772582,
-0.0464994982,
0.3538109958,
-0.0688595101,
-0.2009193897,
1.046151638,
-0.5965263247,
-0.9038761258,
-0.22265324,
0.029683115,
-0.0136176832,
0.4087307751,
0.504645288,
-0.5789145231,
-0.4659320116,
-0.0645812899,
-0.5819272995,
0.0641184896,
-0.0825996995,
-0.0342743173,
-0.1704216152,
0.6829701066,
-0.1383199245,
0.7157831192,
0.166990906,
-0.3715780079,
0.1548368186,
-0.1378593445,
-0.2176665962,
-0.9427382946,
0.4282345176,
0.1029468253,
-0.3621144593,
-0.4901069105,
0.2549510598,
0.2754569948,
-0.3970238864,
-0.4138428569,
0.10386087,
-0.3577294946,
-0.4123950005,
-0.4613782167,
-0.0332526676,
0.0500140376,
0.9385236502,
-0.1142851561,
0.6786212921,
0.5548258424,
-0.4616095722,
0.117746748,
0.5049734116,
0.0900372267,
0.4934301674,
-0.7660609484,
0.2592251599,
-0.4395170212,
-0.059769012,
-1.4281036854,
-0.1526944786,
0.2790723145,
-0.4229862094,
0.709280014,
-0.1219966635,
-0.1308169514,
-0.4461100399,
-0.2911232412,
0.6656063199,
0.0870995298,
-0.6218500137,
0.6027874947,
0.4610157311,
-0.162211448,
-0.6854665875,
-0.6448107958,
0.1142335609,
-0.0727471784,
-0.423491776,
0.2629598677,
0.0706936494,
0.1559431255,
0.089195013,
-0.2759521306,
-0.3710443377,
0.293892622,
0.4599930942,
0.0382521786,
-0.1344197541,
0.1216044948,
-0.2368836552,
-0.6454790235,
0.1799685806,
-0.2020251453,
0.1959911734,
-0.0083679082,
-0.2952753007,
-0.8415147066,
0.5635119677,
0.5874430537,
-0.6112554073,
-0.0047822366,
0.5273174047,
-0.229981631,
-0.0387703367,
-0.4941964447,
-0.5995910168,
-0.477674067,
0.4617928565,
-0.4047377408,
-0.8841642141,
0.5702194571,
0.4060216844,
-0.2719165683,
0.4964110255,
0.5901966691,
-0.0928543061,
0.9840751886,
1.0593518019,
-0.3255113661,
0.3886312544,
0.0601937734,
0.2948252261,
-0.7252317667,
-0.268525362,
-0.4946761727,
-0.517711699,
-0.5799843073,
-0.1675035357,
0.434712559,
-0.4754774272,
0.1467352062,
0.2518288195,
-0.8586325049,
0.4743134975,
0.6682583094,
0.1884408444,
-0.1224279553,
0.0603847615,
-0.0848256275,
-0.3722210824,
-0.8190823197,
-0.0832100138,
0.9851567745,
0.9844323993,
0.9743093252,
-0.5736756325,
0.54945755,
0.294718802,
-0.1187448874,
-0.8271514773,
0.3434309065,
-0.276479125,
-0.4164595008,
-0.0608173348,
-0.0822109729,
-0.7988687158,
0.1892199218,
0.2219048142,
-0.5857089162,
0.9505036473,
0.352814585,
-0.7930452228,
-0.1542035043,
-0.583029449,
1.3270618916,
0.0437658168,
-0.5064301491,
-0.2235821187,
-0.8729526997,
0.2966478765,
-0.1514351964,
-0.1071676537,
-0.1278263181,
0.148663491,
0.5099132657,
-0.1223680526,
1.2359126806,
0.1688157022,
-0.2679538429,
0.212073341,
0.0854576603,
0.3025252819,
-0.0437575914,
0.8915583491,
-0.1434362233,
-0.3205990195,
-0.4417819679,
-0.3790293038,
0.6926009655,
-0.7156162262,
-0.4614142776,
-0.4339470267,
-0.2751207948,
0.0348367281,
0.2069912851,
0.2501937747,
0.3982840478,
0.0116413534,
0.346382916,
1.0386646986,
-0.1768825799,
0.5783277154,
0.2015037388,
0.1847229153,
-0.4286634624,
0.8854312301,
0.076538071,
0.019860724,
0.5749883652,
0.1819459945,
-0.1843434572,
0.001153158,
0.1352623999,
0.0509790964,
-0.7049307823,
-0.3476973772,
-0.9582946897,
-0.0499226376,
-0.6088498831,
0.0039749946,
-0.9654249549,
-0.5885873437,
-0.6187898517,
-0.1726026237,
-0.1095948741,
0.5287868381,
-0.3330680728,
0.1059232429,
-0.4609687626,
0.573076427,
0.9876943827,
0.383874476,
0.0913789198,
-0.4356536865,
-0.1599767208,
-0.6482679248,
-0.5770773292,
-0.7276675105,
0.6981028318,
0.2789699435,
0.5896158218,
0.7356903553,
-0.0877677798,
0.3934458792,
-0.4194683135,
0.4370892942,
-0.056901563,
-0.7046470046,
0.7549914718,
-0.2889046967,
0.4459089041,
0.5072445273,
-0.0246950202,
-0.1554107219,
-0.3917536438,
-0.3822898567,
-0.8439933658,
0.780718267,
0.2546423674,
-0.1013298258,
-0.0683077276,
0.4941854477,
-0.0451010726,
-0.1571439803,
-0.8266330957,
-0.2869343162,
-0.6054730415,
-0.2403520346,
-0.003342917,
-0.709184587,
-0.0175947938,
0.0606603809,
0.3271273375,
-0.3960747719,
0.6716716886,
0.6592242718,
0.1663333327,
-0.2136731297,
0.0166144539,
0.7020192146,
0.4177716672,
-0.3521381617,
0.4905004799,
-0.311522752,
-0.7586098313,
-0.0154037578,
-0.0370749123,
0.2058996856,
-0.4664535224,
0.2768431008,
0.2019569576,
0.3626581728,
-0.0157140438,
0.4990245104,
-0.3218695223,
0.0853776857,
0.0187729057,
-0.2053866237,
-0.1591162682,
-0.0020568548,
0.5479683876,
-0.1589801013,
0.4229842424,
-0.3039010763,
0.5216994882,
0.3379008174,
-0.9549646378,
-0.3662821949,
0.8764164448,
0.0740486458,
0.075644426,
0.4568087459,
0.3083644211,
-0.6313661337,
0.7778055072,
0.3834736347,
1.3055343628,
-0.5264014006,
-0.0480522066,
0.0240640007,
0.5864025354,
0.5426764488,
0.3327455223,
-0.4333176613,
-0.3913335204,
-0.5930170417,
-0.4285347462,
0.0266485922,
0.1241529658,
-0.7463236451,
-0.0915821791,
-0.5414230227,
-0.115060702,
0.2249084264,
-0.3087301254,
-0.7538471222,
0.4057643414,
-0.0346070826,
0.7501680851,
-0.7798552513,
0.5187268257,
0.4592927992,
-0.0399778932,
-0.4359770715,
-0.1137727499,
-0.3169921637,
-0.7302006483,
0.9343355894,
0.4509801865,
0.0339197963,
-0.1106081232,
-0.521251142,
-0.9243747592,
0.7654137611,
0.2994147539,
-0.4511611462,
0.381829679,
0.1270458847,
0.3497637212,
-0.1772354394,
-0.3319694698,
0.1914196163,
0.1351335347,
-0.2150098085,
-0.5284499526,
-0.170250833,
-0.1489955336,
-0.1099999994,
0.0277668536,
-0.8926851153,
0.6330387592,
0.0102949589,
-0.2763410509,
-0.4871773124,
1.0998271704,
-0.2230461538,
0.1201213747,
0.1834188253,
0.8869868517,
0.1120935902,
0.2154743671,
0.8859265447,
-0.3186635673,
0.5231957436,
1.1191879511,
0.0273349117,
0.5574865937,
0.5112153292,
-0.1497191936,
-0.0132185938,
0.5950939059,
-0.1194201931,
1.0076799393,
-0.3861098289,
0.0034042522,
-0.5736382604,
0.0374737792,
-0.3287681341,
0.7103589177,
0.1888085157,
-0.5655389428,
-0.2596578002,
0.1186854839,
-0.440443188,
0.0317509025,
-0.3771657944,
0.9187846184,
0.2642201185,
-0.5142502189,
0.2438388914,
-0.2012728453,
0.0667117089,
-0.1994773746,
0.0081266146,
-0.338740766,
0.543212533,
0.0847361088,
-0.5422632098,
0.3493440747,
-0.3436127305,
-0.5517790318,
-0.2485717982,
1.0514527559,
-0.0622238666,
-0.6184509397,
0.1483388692,
0.0144673567,
-0.1574015617,
-0.2615014017,
-0.5905715823,
0.0995798931,
-0.1666006148,
-0.066470392,
0.4269321263,
0.312726438,
0.3722264767,
0.7579025626,
0.2438795865,
-0.6379855871,
0.2213793993,
-0.3909898102,
0.9411693215,
-0.6742890477,
-1.0088033676,
-0.8014537692,
0.0918434188,
0.3152350783,
-0.1044769883,
0.7506026626,
0.5044660568,
0.3752583265,
-0.2919012606,
0.5121574402,
0.5798509717,
0.4298374653,
0.0071136956,
0.6061136723,
-0.1300194263,
-0.2328714132,
-0.3355913758,
-0.9205154181,
-0.4600657523,
0.7467357516,
-0.053671442,
-0.100201644,
0.4335812032,
0.4380040467,
-0.4513213038,
-0.2718493044,
0.4168837368,
0.2079431713,
0.3957802355,
0.4948046505,
0.4140107036,
-0.3471283317,
0.3360018134,
-0.4953900874,
-0.4830272198,
-0.2411742359,
-1.0245296955,
-0.8885484338,
-0.4248330593,
-0.5143707991,
-0.0079701077,
-0.0357065536,
0.4923478067,
0.8917467594,
-0.9239153266,
0.1473603398,
-0.3081290722,
-0.0495167114,
-0.256008625,
-0.2599163949,
0.8481305838,
-0.8265536427,
-0.4268415868,
0.7040822506,
0.8529318571,
0.2060688138,
-0.7118740082,
0.5515568852,
0.0818938613,
-0.1556153446,
0.6636565924,
0.4662460387,
-0.4850817621,
-0.1573549807,
0.2584239841,
-0.1774324775,
0.1889711767,
0.7963940501,
-0.9719811678,
0.6586219668,
0.5650681257,
0.884524107,
0.3900374472,
0.0369304828,
0.7558948398,
-0.9383841157,
0.1916770786,
0.0414403751,
0.13876535,
0.2797768116,
-0.7789626718,
0.3885692656,
0.2769993246,
-0.8029275537,
-0.6821696162,
0.2131576985,
-1.213966012,
-0.2168363333,
0.5222216845,
-0.1980614662,
-0.769369781,
-0.1635452956,
-0.1058154628,
-0.0959695652,
-0.2432353646,
1.2141450644,
0.3342477381,
-0.0797680989,
-0.3702784479,
-0.2449726611,
0.570328474,
0.6336541176,
-0.5262932777,
0.3406001031,
0.2418558598,
0.0782856196,
0.4179919958,
0.2134272456,
-0.3094900548,
0.4814601243,
-0.3379842639,
0.0201368723,
0.0701140985,
-0.771089077,
-0.5492091775,
0.8056498766,
-0.2952211499,
-0.6531828046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13748v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13748v1 | Every Language Counts: Learn and Unlearn in Multilingual LLMs | 2024-06-19T18:01:08 | 2024-06-19T18:01:08 | Taiming Lu, Philipp Koehn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper investigates the propagation of harmful information in
multilingual large language models (LLMs) and evaluates the efficacy of various
unlearning methods. We demonstrate that fake information, regardless of the
language it is in, once introduced into these models through training data, can
spread across different languages, compromising the integrity and reliability
of the generated content. Our findings reveal that standard unlearning
techniques, which typically focus on English data, are insufficient in
mitigating the spread of harmful content in multilingual contexts and could
inadvertently reinforce harmful content across languages. We show that only by
addressing harmful responses in both English and the original language of the
harmful data can we effectively eliminate generations for all languages. This
underscores the critical need for comprehensive unlearning strategies that
consider the multilingual nature of modern LLMs to enhance their safety and
reliability across diverse linguistic landscapes. | [
0.0507460013,
-0.8134009838,
0.3742273152,
0.1614773422,
-0.2070227712,
0.3095061481,
-0.3022171259,
-0.5600092411,
-0.0899109319,
0.6155439019,
-0.359538734,
-0.4988614023,
-0.4762922525,
-0.0838661268,
-0.3287411928,
1.1823040247,
0.1378707141,
0.4717957079,
-0.3256310523,
-0.270640105,
-0.2156333476,
-0.8876914382,
-0.6001617908,
-0.3996008337,
0.7259793282,
0.4607853889,
0.4358421862,
0.4739071727,
0.0459522791,
0.2539089024,
-0.1139920205,
0.3538614511,
-0.7331054211,
0.1018150672,
-0.3042797148,
-0.672757864,
-0.0335104987,
-0.0934841931,
0.7978641391,
0.9605200291,
-0.3737266362,
0.2146451771,
0.3403279185,
0.4102246165,
-0.6307631135,
0.05723143,
-0.6800352931,
-0.0051729134,
-0.3626024723,
-0.3401617706,
-0.6723400354,
-0.4162826836,
-0.296741128,
-0.4838463664,
-0.087920472,
-0.3122672439,
0.3598725796,
-0.2617849112,
-0.9916223288,
-0.5824981928,
-0.9548926353,
1.1654493809,
-0.5184354782,
0.453288734,
0.3940513432,
-0.1331958622,
-0.1201471835,
-0.497875303,
-0.3271855414,
-0.0285728015,
0.1629786789,
0.1810119599,
-0.2469932437,
-0.241096586,
-0.1101160422,
0.0541097671,
-0.5204274654,
0.4035346806,
-0.6648815274,
-0.4174405932,
0.6581005454,
-0.0152676115,
0.5940141678,
0.0876321718,
-0.4917571843,
-0.0008683344,
-1.1538076401,
-0.066693157,
0.7901642323,
0.2445833087,
-0.1287711114,
0.217475161,
0.2549048066,
0.3975262642,
-0.6129716635,
-0.6131851077,
0.3247767389,
-0.3141919971,
0.098489657,
-0.0517796054,
0.82820189,
0.2847822011,
0.6675715446,
-0.42711851,
-0.0597931705,
0.0015575861,
0.1852211356,
-0.5636418462,
0.1047538519,
-0.0471927859,
-0.1969841123,
-0.2924907207,
0.0589039512,
-0.7734014988,
-0.3728293478,
-0.1246705353,
0.3658809364,
-0.6692593694,
-0.4691199958,
0.1547143757,
0.1367733479,
0.143710658,
0.2006686032,
-0.5591139793,
0.040997047,
0.4459601045,
0.4109939039,
-0.0758936703,
-0.7077568769,
-0.3143142462,
0.2864321768,
-0.6405398846,
0.51500386,
-0.3587692082,
-0.4682536125,
0.4735814929,
0.3174459338,
-0.1217374578,
-0.6330899596,
0.4839227498,
-0.4523531497,
0.1503233016,
-0.229384616,
-0.5677366853,
-0.5457889438,
0.0682884231,
-0.5212429166,
0.5330904722,
-0.3436730802,
-0.4769606292,
0.4215450287,
-0.0988473296,
-0.888682723,
0.0492432863,
0.0502249934,
-0.4365914762,
0.0994794741,
-0.3290892839,
0.4703771174,
0.0901998729,
0.4910680354,
-0.2509857714,
-0.2636806667,
0.4449324608,
-1.1087632179,
1.0932753086,
0.2192611247,
-0.2180045247,
-0.0055704382,
-0.58470577,
0.0422430709,
0.3542087674,
-0.6597940922,
-0.4131958485,
0.0529264174,
0.1839461476,
0.3029053509,
0.0753877684,
-0.7526942492,
-0.0210381988,
-0.1785327643,
0.2809078991,
0.6313861012,
0.2039323598,
0.3039600551,
-0.5560917854,
0.4843513668,
0.2842267156,
0.2337071598,
-0.372479856,
-0.4345783591,
-0.5358710885,
-0.0181940831,
-0.0571856238,
0.7123521566,
-0.869984746,
0.0259585772,
-0.2952080667,
-0.6130829453,
-0.5367677808,
0.7152096629,
0.7738019824,
0.2615737915,
0.1989072263,
-0.1628742963,
-0.5463008881,
-0.7634133101,
-0.4526095688,
-0.283654213,
0.2715235651,
-0.021987129,
0.5269117355,
-0.2324742973,
0.3660791218,
0.0020217418,
-0.1927090734,
-0.4497928917,
0.0637675673,
-0.2922984958,
0.2975019515,
0.6052796841,
-0.6204810143,
-0.4810644686,
-0.0056590415,
-1.0214995146,
0.2316113412,
-0.1838560551,
0.3484238088,
0.5794758797,
0.4254289567,
-0.3207639456,
0.3907744586,
0.5701236129,
-0.2066986561,
0.4919062853,
-0.4257667661,
0.2051976174,
-1.0352846384,
0.0618188605,
-0.2197969258,
-0.1519185305,
-0.9750003815,
0.1212064847,
0.1942879558,
0.1033290923,
-0.9932103157,
0.7517579198,
-0.5597046018,
0.3930271268,
-0.152533859,
-0.1640003473,
-0.0034248019,
0.3677836657,
-0.0874723941,
0.5820298791,
0.460172385,
-0.6693940759,
0.293276757,
0.0882533863,
-0.6233503222,
0.5049335957,
-0.2878893614,
0.0215020347,
-0.484597832,
0.1140506342,
-0.8786121011,
-0.1224118173,
0.0331135876,
-0.5303729773,
0.4137437046,
-0.1955909878,
-0.6658092737,
-0.0437605418,
-0.2918568254,
0.3812525272,
0.4359023273,
-0.7349538803,
0.1117652878,
0.5875820518,
0.0154023003,
-0.7955090404,
-0.968578577,
0.0753713101,
-0.4745117426,
-0.4290077388,
-0.2076373398,
-0.2458949983,
-0.4555385113,
-0.2495733947,
0.0185091384,
-0.2571853697,
0.3464649022,
0.373026818,
0.1695743501,
0.0916879252,
0.3132858872,
-0.22419177,
0.1460203826,
0.2063615024,
-0.2177603096,
0.5949596763,
0.1671666056,
-0.6689016819,
-0.1615584642,
0.5574630499,
0.7732743025,
-0.1482932121,
1.2548030615,
0.5825397372,
-0.4197913706,
-0.3042435646,
-0.5875864625,
0.0933395252,
-0.4489989281,
0.489518851,
-0.1516058445,
-0.7823835015,
0.5153735876,
0.0445728488,
0.3423691094,
0.1149415225,
0.5108942389,
-0.170827359,
0.95448488,
0.8169455528,
-0.3847515285,
0.1840771139,
-0.1301387697,
0.3275803328,
-0.2612044811,
-0.5946229696,
-0.3711795807,
0.1479296088,
-0.533151865,
-0.4129779339,
0.3890087008,
0.4066196978,
-0.2939816713,
-0.002973346,
-0.0262497868,
0.6441430449,
0.4911616743,
0.1361130625,
0.5910233259,
0.3153488338,
-0.1572139114,
-0.1281825751,
-0.7861930728,
-0.5167742372,
1.2531987429,
0.217216894,
0.8776928186,
0.4220484197,
0.564753592,
0.0947048366,
0.5858505368,
-0.6077072024,
0.1398736238,
-0.2447953373,
-0.707197547,
-0.2771979868,
-0.5678738952,
-1.223515749,
0.2440007925,
0.0615898371,
-0.6454335451,
0.0304273982,
0.0542712808,
-0.1105573028,
0.9820028543,
-0.5673408508,
0.567134738,
-0.5855409503,
-0.3419832289,
-0.2902780473,
-0.3944706023,
0.5643888116,
-0.5822944641,
0.81327039,
0.1027776226,
-0.0597942285,
0.8333203197,
-0.1097399294,
1.3522340059,
0.040104527,
-0.4649167955,
0.3069746196,
0.3091717958,
0.3809729218,
-0.0090565681,
-0.1079678982,
0.5536856651,
-0.0064923703,
-0.5793575048,
-0.1335958689,
0.7190446258,
-0.7882371545,
-0.2884016037,
-0.269670248,
-0.4142040014,
-0.1978868991,
0.2626850605,
0.4906469882,
0.2842236757,
-0.4509889483,
0.1869437248,
0.70659554,
-0.5691111088,
0.6172917485,
1.1511855125,
-0.0531078912,
-0.3047195375,
1.2835643291,
0.2585279942,
0.4774035215,
0.1844131351,
-0.0890836567,
-0.3226893544,
-0.4166835546,
-0.3403313458,
0.5044579506,
-0.9567884803,
-0.1094396934,
-0.5407103896,
-0.2496192306,
-0.4069102705,
-0.0977125987,
-0.4639760554,
0.1275140941,
-0.0858069658,
-0.301995188,
0.2368266135,
0.9489570856,
-0.3729612231,
0.2926458418,
-1.1167964935,
-0.061989665,
0.0944092199,
0.4233642519,
0.1330650449,
-0.5810685158,
-0.3542299867,
0.3644791543,
-0.2293902487,
-0.8339694738,
0.6225321293,
0.2607389987,
1.003618598,
0.5058203936,
-0.0663716495,
0.388445586,
-0.5356166959,
0.4706342816,
0.3735950291,
-0.6854435205,
0.1887598634,
-0.4014865756,
0.2118242383,
0.2743645012,
0.7747032642,
-1.1639904976,
-0.4071815312,
-0.6815903783,
-1.058182478,
0.4219289124,
-0.290484339,
0.5154003501,
-0.207826376,
0.0865921453,
0.3009179235,
0.2555202842,
-1.0239819288,
-0.5073854327,
0.1692090929,
0.0281080958,
-0.3920429349,
-0.5606586933,
-0.197691083,
-0.0401791185,
0.6079576612,
0.020066848,
-0.2600004375,
-0.1498785913,
-0.6055759192,
-0.27344203,
0.4067042768,
0.4937328696,
0.7795192003,
0.3063859046,
0.2478263378,
0.2368004173,
-0.513615191,
0.4605360329,
-0.6313650012,
-0.348903209,
-0.0112936907,
0.7267450094,
0.6288624406,
0.4747816622,
-0.7166714072,
0.4953530431,
0.1985807866,
-0.2747973204,
-0.4918448329,
-0.1720177531,
0.2487679869,
-0.2864158154,
0.1784674525,
-0.1183952093,
-0.3959244192,
-0.9798488021,
0.5020883083,
0.4593595564,
-0.4109958708,
-0.4683662057,
0.496062547,
0.0697805509,
-0.1216993555,
0.6981519461,
-0.0305952318,
-0.5566159487,
0.4483821392,
0.6479622722,
0.4068703353,
-0.7865855694,
0.4816307425,
0.3247095048,
0.7205433846,
-0.1669504046,
0.2412846684,
0.2548252642,
-1.0369256735,
-0.7239151597,
-0.7013140321,
-0.2369935513,
0.4669057131,
-0.5386588573,
-0.1721203029,
-0.2584953606,
0.3988775015,
-0.0989394635,
-0.1989904344,
-0.5884819031,
0.1248771176,
0.3482584953,
0.6426210999,
-1.3437364101,
0.8558533788,
0.6294669509,
-0.4496457279,
-0.6502571702,
-0.1528038383,
0.5119535923,
-1.0333744287,
0.5669067502,
0.0361310057,
-0.0176146775,
-0.1096954718,
-0.4054169357,
-0.8575186729,
0.4664379358,
0.4306892455,
-0.2980254591,
0.5326194763,
0.6482631564,
0.447060287,
-0.0474874154,
0.1933485121,
0.3816542327,
0.4817741811,
-0.0183042455,
-0.8183764219,
-0.3087660372,
-0.1156630144,
-0.377361238,
0.1723368615,
-0.632512629,
0.7061787844,
-0.3045995235,
-0.3093474805,
-0.1086097956,
0.2073475271,
0.05293997,
0.1103299111,
0.4699353874,
0.3325045705,
0.9298586845,
0.011851564,
1.0211607218,
-0.2329469323,
0.1215667129,
0.9210535288,
-0.2075074464,
0.5629538894,
0.2952098846,
0.0516464151,
0.0222140271,
0.4164335728,
0.1706053466,
0.1851042211,
0.2931509912,
-0.3440858424,
-0.216767177,
-0.2759670615,
0.0032944691,
0.6365462542,
0.3486257195,
-0.0706354231,
-0.4302059114,
0.454927057,
0.6426723599,
0.1247034147,
-0.1838713586,
0.6640836596,
0.1782101989,
-0.4841388464,
0.6853666902,
0.0353740156,
0.8297339678,
-0.6596724391,
0.010938352,
-0.5087851286,
0.3442550898,
-0.3903600872,
-0.747145772,
0.4013886452,
-0.0386445485,
-0.0926555693,
-0.4113925993,
0.403906256,
-0.8232383132,
-0.6259419322,
0.7009494305,
0.8513589501,
0.4891526401,
-0.0365857333,
-0.4842115939,
-0.0576427132,
0.3465079665,
-0.2965805829,
0.7299670577,
0.3595194519,
-0.2872350812,
1.1204006672,
0.8705036044,
0.4773392975,
0.3487630785,
0.2254124731,
0.4274298847,
-0.5581499338,
-0.1465763897,
-0.8733313084,
0.4890194535,
0.1388471425,
-0.1462718397,
1.0768529177,
0.5843086243,
1.2700817585,
0.0593661144,
0.8206479549,
0.4713245034,
0.4982263446,
-0.3441732824,
1.0706145763,
-0.7217831016,
0.3662214279,
0.0262608342,
-0.733263135,
-0.339512974,
0.1515307128,
0.1046257913,
0.0179432724,
0.6491599083,
0.6753224134,
0.0463956445,
-0.2697253823,
0.7389554381,
0.3523036838,
0.255951941,
0.4101832807,
0.8989118338,
-0.2669166625,
0.8518449068,
-0.3689564764,
-0.0766841993,
0.1167175397,
-0.4413090348,
-0.6592968106,
-0.5489355326,
-0.2886362374,
-0.3156915903,
0.1741527617,
0.3357431591,
0.5395315886,
-0.8683835864,
-0.5130526423,
0.3295505047,
0.3547091484,
-0.0176415611,
-0.2066962123,
0.1674990654,
-0.3798844516,
-0.7406461835,
0.6574026346,
0.1622401178,
0.1408487409,
-0.3490074575,
-0.0825393274,
-0.1977291554,
-0.0301070269,
0.6315245628,
0.5221267343,
-0.5887156725,
-0.1537806541,
-0.1378235966,
-0.2333099693,
-0.1472212076,
0.8323208094,
-0.5131844282,
0.2394105494,
0.3263376355,
0.2665576339,
0.0547852069,
-0.3385503292,
0.6623301506,
-1.0779352188,
0.3531018496,
0.0752214938,
0.4458512366,
0.4377115965,
-0.3037756085,
0.449349761,
0.3494222164,
-0.3611174524,
-0.9667721391,
0.3070908487,
-0.2911642492,
-0.7400214672,
1.3612043858,
-0.2879546583,
-0.2169860601,
-0.5278316736,
0.2648184001,
0.356197685,
0.0006382731,
0.6165457964,
0.5858385563,
0.3271707594,
-0.1018696204,
-0.8409103155,
0.4187754393,
0.4086853564,
-0.6348482966,
0.2581304312,
0.380541563,
0.805269599,
0.123079069,
0.5178985,
-0.3556762934,
0.0942154825,
-0.2100543678,
0.3807255328,
0.0822051316,
-0.6491885781,
-0.6143299937,
0.0692729279,
0.0162815284,
0.0634277835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13743v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13743v2 | GenAI-Bench: Evaluating and Improving Compositional Text-to-Visual Generation | 2024-06-19T18:00:07 | 2024-06-21T19:09:36 | Baiqi Li, Zhiqiu Lin, Deepak Pathak, Jiayao Li, Yixin Fei, Kewen Wu, Tiffany Ling, Xide Xia, Pengchuan Zhang, Graham Neubig, Deva Ramanan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | While text-to-visual models now produce photo-realistic images and videos,
they struggle with compositional text prompts involving attributes,
relationships, and higher-order reasoning such as logic and comparison. In this
work, we conduct an extensive human study on GenAI-Bench to evaluate the
performance of leading image and video generation models in various aspects of
compositional text-to-visual generation. We also compare automated evaluation
metrics against our collected human ratings and find that VQAScore -- a metric
measuring the likelihood that a VQA model views an image as accurately
depicting the prompt -- significantly outperforms previous metrics such as
CLIPScore. In addition, VQAScore can improve generation in a black-box manner
(without finetuning) via simply ranking a few (3 to 9) candidate images.
Ranking by VQAScore is 2x to 3x more effective than other scoring methods like
PickScore, HPSv2, and ImageReward at improving human alignment ratings for
DALL-E 3 and Stable Diffusion, especially on compositional prompts that require
advanced visio-linguistic reasoning. We will release a new GenAI-Rank benchmark
with over 40,000 human ratings to evaluate scoring metrics on ranking images
generated from the same prompt. Lastly, we discuss promising areas for
improvement in VQAScore, such as addressing fine-grained visual details. We
will release all human ratings (over 80,000) to facilitate scientific
benchmarking of both generative models and automated metrics. | [
-0.5737552047,
-0.5006411672,
0.7053060532,
0.3449504673,
-0.3428690135,
0.0779970661,
-0.2590356469,
-0.3605890274,
-0.3450503349,
0.2296052724,
-0.4255851507,
-0.5283026695,
-0.4146236181,
0.0815136954,
-0.503379643,
0.5589857101,
-0.0365196988,
0.1658639163,
-0.8027693033,
-0.0046500023,
-0.8129242063,
-0.0164154116,
-0.5500490069,
-0.3366138339,
0.3818743527,
0.5282317996,
0.4871024191,
0.6116268039,
0.4898355305,
0.3615880907,
0.2099591643,
0.1340097189,
-0.5405138731,
0.2916312218,
-0.097999759,
-0.3296395838,
-0.1482617706,
0.0474007949,
0.7223228216,
0.4440332651,
0.0367425866,
0.2580195367,
0.001481389,
0.8266561031,
-0.7400126457,
-0.03536468,
-0.342882514,
0.0846206024,
-0.1002677977,
-0.368532151,
-0.4158026874,
-0.294295758,
0.2136295438,
-0.693512857,
0.3801638186,
-0.0659880191,
0.9486895204,
0.4130038023,
-0.3998288214,
0.2745212913,
-0.6870126128,
0.7798967361,
-0.4123160839,
0.2284872234,
0.3217147291,
0.6921938062,
0.0276207943,
-0.859160006,
-0.4006758034,
-0.2787704468,
0.3175116479,
0.5717070699,
-0.0629359633,
-0.075819619,
0.3532596231,
0.5660898685,
-0.6817619801,
-0.024741441,
-0.2849488854,
-0.044768706,
0.8560715318,
0.3056295216,
0.5790559649,
-0.3879146576,
-0.4120183289,
-0.637339592,
-0.4079077542,
0.0324747674,
0.2718245983,
-0.4201048911,
-0.0139794713,
0.569185257,
-0.5697821975,
0.7690756321,
0.0846610516,
-0.0487898737,
0.1351035833,
-0.5661022067,
-0.3245475888,
-0.3066845238,
1.0707184076,
0.9472609162,
0.2790235877,
0.0045078611,
-0.1163179576,
0.3358394504,
0.3460153639,
-1.0473399162,
-0.3587537706,
-0.0888521224,
-0.6033760309,
-0.4376676977,
0.1744139493,
-0.9822665453,
-0.554338634,
-0.4262743294,
0.5347896814,
-0.5671403408,
-0.0092928391,
-0.2391687334,
-0.5513002276,
0.4978149533,
0.5601742268,
-0.9467346668,
0.0069643427,
0.4711492658,
0.591062963,
-0.1530100703,
-0.3353453577,
-0.4260604382,
0.0509841777,
-0.464563787,
1.1569435596,
-0.4466009736,
-0.5751844645,
-0.0818756521,
-0.3108213842,
-0.0840270743,
-0.7025453448,
0.6615762711,
-0.0224057082,
0.4288631082,
-0.6119249463,
-0.4620555341,
-0.0302661546,
0.2868529856,
-0.6785004735,
0.9739568233,
0.3335689306,
-0.5221025348,
0.7554891109,
-0.4938867986,
-0.3568014205,
0.2629415989,
-0.634237349,
-0.3311097324,
0.1000405177,
0.581708014,
0.1942005455,
-0.7041820288,
0.3779649436,
0.1164289638,
-0.3301645219,
0.3999403417,
-0.5583359599,
0.3913684785,
0.3064942062,
-0.5314720869,
0.4025316536,
-0.8409388661,
0.1523312181,
0.1906029731,
-0.1984920949,
-0.1267017424,
-0.0013821579,
0.150877893,
0.0732038692,
-0.0300745256,
-0.4873076975,
-0.0922319368,
-0.1735334992,
0.2512002289,
0.6775293946,
0.2721753716,
0.4584205747,
-0.3885164857,
0.6066510677,
-0.1381792128,
0.416308552,
-0.3145981431,
-0.7789273262,
-0.7279306054,
-0.1653407365,
0.3918438256,
0.4465195537,
-0.8795989156,
0.2258615196,
-0.2615632117,
-0.6029504538,
-0.404761821,
0.1584554315,
0.4959830344,
0.7779473066,
0.1371855736,
-0.7284352183,
-0.3421572745,
-0.9343809485,
-0.0448773652,
-0.1574243903,
-0.2605879307,
0.3845963776,
0.2154641002,
-0.1265249848,
0.8087935448,
-0.3837658465,
0.0744051486,
-0.0270789564,
0.6338301897,
-0.2444460839,
0.3950871229,
0.7867699862,
-0.8190278411,
-0.5282119513,
-0.0946292505,
-0.9614023566,
-0.2067099363,
-0.1215319782,
-0.3161351681,
0.0058911415,
0.4486098588,
-0.454164803,
0.5235116482,
0.272764504,
-0.4091105461,
0.6637297273,
-0.1872389764,
0.6746512055,
-1.1053166389,
0.1812056005,
0.2915458083,
-0.1031688303,
-0.363841176,
0.1584347188,
-0.1011176705,
-0.3821320832,
-0.2562794089,
0.3748074472,
-0.4027822316,
-0.2687941194,
-0.2548696399,
0.0532289594,
0.1921943724,
0.1825879365,
-0.1496940553,
0.9609405398,
0.5024251342,
-0.4313328266,
0.5835325718,
0.4267922342,
-0.7036629319,
1.0429289341,
-0.8279695511,
-0.0796608999,
-0.2192084789,
0.2141815871,
-1.2714788914,
-0.5102812648,
0.1745235175,
-0.592217505,
0.2586458325,
0.2373846173,
-0.4321588576,
-0.3779933155,
-0.5319300294,
0.6178125143,
0.6794442534,
-0.4603547752,
0.4622714221,
0.0363778882,
-0.1207932755,
-0.295011133,
-0.6091271639,
0.3743840754,
-0.1301018298,
-0.8743898273,
0.4143202901,
-0.2188404649,
-0.1888794154,
-0.0420300215,
0.1371658593,
0.2135525793,
0.0378901213,
0.3668830991,
0.2638460994,
-0.1644075215,
-0.0340012088,
-0.027747551,
-0.208828032,
0.2558787763,
0.0686648786,
0.4044170976,
0.0462524258,
-0.2551163435,
-0.474678576,
0.3936016262,
0.4725202918,
-0.3321853578,
0.2812644243,
0.9605873227,
-0.1791026741,
-0.0156715028,
-0.5437558293,
0.0267077126,
-0.450668931,
0.2180349529,
-0.3414558172,
-0.4283085763,
0.2436830699,
-0.1456142217,
-0.0819685981,
0.7530033588,
0.6959528327,
-0.2378657162,
1.3389846087,
0.4298646152,
0.1787894666,
0.7403498888,
-0.4920034707,
-0.177111119,
-0.8744191527,
-0.3623509705,
-0.3914839029,
-0.4756485522,
-0.5415855646,
-0.3611332178,
0.4613916576,
-0.1662216485,
-0.1812663227,
0.1942660064,
-0.5975353122,
0.491820097,
0.7708389163,
0.3368509412,
0.1378540546,
0.1747172624,
-0.1272669286,
-0.0640145019,
-0.5406955481,
-0.3364378214,
1.1577391624,
0.1330649555,
0.6046385765,
-0.0107989265,
0.6476118565,
0.4098058641,
0.3894286454,
-0.6631100774,
0.7114754915,
-0.3855878115,
-0.3251753747,
-0.2750971615,
-0.4303606451,
-0.7365260124,
0.120728977,
-0.4061507881,
-0.6515566111,
0.2976849079,
-0.0565803833,
-0.4104428589,
-0.0320826843,
-0.8180311322,
1.1333304644,
-0.4307133853,
-0.5051063299,
-0.1449294984,
-0.6395821571,
0.593139708,
0.2218770385,
-0.1905591637,
0.043068286,
0.1303897202,
0.7561286092,
-0.4662381411,
0.635691762,
-0.0600818731,
-0.028836634,
0.3449610472,
-0.1804354787,
-0.1063994467,
-0.0455213264,
0.1095381901,
-0.2644979656,
-0.0302322488,
-0.3721119761,
-0.6754342914,
0.6144661903,
-0.9569562674,
-0.4448235631,
-0.1999724656,
-0.5912915468,
-0.2043895274,
-0.1242942661,
0.8028438091,
0.5443609357,
-0.4443065226,
0.3002131283,
0.6330143809,
-0.3496106267,
0.3564594984,
-0.0713272989,
-0.2331331372,
-0.8591237664,
1.0924619436,
-0.1404113024,
0.266002655,
0.3637667596,
0.2621985078,
-0.3322558403,
-0.3174057305,
-0.9035153985,
-0.0028214029,
-0.7319233418,
-0.2501722574,
-0.2781419456,
-0.2248152047,
-0.3904913962,
0.0652137026,
-0.0569538809,
-0.2833878994,
-0.3926078677,
0.0129829664,
0.0667049512,
0.5745412707,
0.0588114709,
0.300951004,
-0.6740264297,
0.6087594032,
0.7834230065,
0.2370033562,
0.0529624261,
-0.4268826842,
0.0155125083,
-0.1306702793,
-0.5834186673,
-0.823220253,
0.1536030322,
0.2456983179,
0.586458087,
0.4928351045,
-0.3212166429,
0.7425715327,
-0.1813637018,
0.9759156108,
0.4588533044,
-0.9051899314,
0.8017811179,
-0.5308027267,
0.5131409168,
0.7513878345,
0.0139101669,
-0.2790389955,
-0.1391505301,
-0.5508158803,
-0.6595839262,
0.2971287668,
0.2115852088,
-0.0731961504,
0.194653511,
0.2303050011,
-0.0043149958,
0.1754324734,
-0.4391518235,
0.0771617964,
-0.488291949,
-0.2906460166,
-0.1603885591,
-0.3207418621,
-0.1634389013,
-0.582262218,
0.3312338293,
-0.1478931606,
0.0785189569,
0.2834936082,
0.0589858964,
-0.5164928436,
0.3447742164,
0.683832109,
0.7854824662,
-0.1727903932,
-0.126635462,
-0.2168382704,
-0.2723464668,
0.1539637148,
0.1514956057,
-0.5919427872,
-0.0745453984,
0.2640020251,
0.9743939042,
0.2134936005,
-0.7903829813,
0.67580235,
-0.3032804728,
-0.530630827,
-0.1358672827,
0.2294771373,
-0.1955575794,
0.1842041016,
0.340213269,
0.1102587506,
0.3750473559,
-0.7840965986,
0.1255788058,
0.2827603519,
-0.2602911294,
-0.1192253083,
0.9360523224,
0.4411003888,
-0.0354404449,
0.7671122551,
-0.1739767492,
-0.441839546,
0.7076105475,
0.3897480071,
1.0768419504,
-0.210871309,
0.7016717792,
0.5715047717,
0.2394259125,
-0.114867188,
0.4370787144,
-0.3083396256,
-0.3768930733,
-0.3819965124,
-0.4096597731,
-0.5162081122,
-0.0886116251,
-0.5416597724,
0.0341391191,
-0.449901849,
-0.4742874205,
0.0835322961,
-0.0488849208,
-0.6909405589,
0.4649145603,
0.3400904536,
0.7771934867,
-1.0265601873,
0.3448607922,
0.8264580369,
-0.8038190603,
-0.7508949041,
-0.0668996647,
-0.1895230561,
-0.375256449,
0.4050858021,
0.3228808045,
0.1839708388,
-0.0382025391,
-0.8823387623,
-0.5011733174,
1.5009995699,
0.3509476185,
-0.4176318645,
0.1963771284,
0.1053609252,
0.7177084088,
-0.3325822949,
0.3888558447,
0.6922538877,
0.6498131156,
0.2546416223,
-0.5754457116,
0.027286578,
-0.5328480601,
0.379711777,
0.0380524285,
-0.6284109354,
0.7792503238,
-0.1232506558,
-0.4225752354,
0.6899570823,
0.6526834369,
0.33192572,
0.6020755172,
0.481490761,
0.850774467,
0.4747295976,
-0.267532289,
1.3618178368,
0.029559901,
-0.1337080002,
0.8696056604,
-0.2634913921,
0.7403492332,
0.4330518544,
-0.0802250579,
0.6760740876,
0.6276919246,
-0.4147200584,
0.5718671679,
0.2218396962,
-0.2250829935,
-0.4259270132,
-0.5003471375,
-0.3454380929,
0.3814333677,
0.0249428824,
-0.4494734108,
-0.1332078576,
0.0826090947,
-0.6049849987,
0.4286448359,
-0.1846589893,
0.8201854229,
-0.0283002593,
-0.9459074736,
0.4266210794,
-0.0587173663,
0.3163087368,
-0.2598347366,
-0.0717914924,
-0.2300581485,
-0.0655958578,
-0.1401453018,
-0.7574857473,
-0.3140336871,
0.1230954379,
-0.1674245447,
-0.1380219609,
0.8415536284,
-0.3588154614,
-0.5381069183,
-0.0211925283,
0.6124797463,
-0.1159285456,
-0.1435968429,
-0.5846891999,
0.0876819566,
-0.2095721662,
-0.0991275236,
0.2355526984,
0.3002951443,
-0.0817954913,
0.3998943567,
0.5948476195,
-0.2492645085,
-0.0241034869,
0.7655807734,
0.6955315471,
-0.7123005986,
-0.3626721501,
-0.5457816124,
0.5047465563,
-0.4587228894,
-0.5514307618,
0.473628521,
0.5353722572,
0.6370264888,
-0.2590519488,
0.7329431772,
0.0128199812,
0.0076997243,
-0.536747694,
0.6909853816,
-0.5646623969,
-0.0976126716,
-0.4842402637,
-1.1855939627,
-0.1104858965,
0.2955690622,
-0.2279766053,
0.1918405443,
0.6299555302,
0.5287448764,
0.0489490777,
0.0336546078,
0.3604283035,
-0.1683270931,
0.3153655529,
0.6511505246,
1.2860713005,
-0.7565641999,
0.5004319549,
-0.3656352162,
-0.3577201366,
-0.0543427356,
-0.7707060575,
-0.7978156209,
-0.6317961812,
-0.3475519717,
-0.0336847045,
-0.0035950101,
0.4336205721,
0.6573982835,
-0.513169229,
-0.2883630693,
-0.1814597845,
-0.3169728518,
-0.2217192799,
-0.305326581,
0.1334480643,
-0.1586452574,
-0.6036453843,
0.3505563438,
0.3233985007,
0.09258122,
-0.4819895029,
-0.1318815351,
-0.0389803685,
-0.0191472359,
0.7090668082,
0.2824990153,
-0.6032522321,
-0.2379073799,
0.0202517472,
-0.2931685746,
0.0775826573,
0.8438968062,
-0.8505792022,
0.6699801683,
0.9936794639,
0.6528562903,
0.5319009423,
0.4738742709,
0.8504322171,
-0.6691871285,
-0.2439289838,
-0.0402054414,
0.3607830405,
0.7416529059,
0.0152435936,
0.6773873568,
0.3739986718,
-0.6364796162,
-0.5419530869,
0.1619462818,
-1.3154190779,
-0.0733859986,
0.8783012629,
0.3339990079,
-0.400349915,
0.5580849648,
-0.4826550484,
0.2825114727,
-0.3058234155,
0.8921657205,
0.5528088212,
0.0471745059,
-0.4153212011,
-0.5100266337,
0.3524517119,
0.513635993,
-1.1808497906,
-0.3920924366,
0.8623530269,
0.1045858413,
0.0921448469,
0.4791231751,
-0.1970981658,
0.8643841147,
0.0470459312,
-0.0459178798,
0.0263606645,
-0.3882393241,
-0.1650494188,
0.0153913843,
0.070989497,
-0.3250456452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13720v1 | On the Utility of Domain-Adjacent Fine-Tuned Model Ensembles for Few-shot Problems | 2024-06-19T17:24:36 | 2024-06-19T17:24:36 | Md Ibrahim Ibne Alam, Parikshit Ram, Soham Dan, Horst Samulowitz, Koushik Kar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have been observed to perform well on a wide
range of downstream tasks when fine-tuned on domain-specific data. However,
such data may not be readily available in many applications, motivating
zero-shot or few-shot approaches using domain-adjacent models. While several
fine-tuned models for various tasks are available, finding an appropriate
domain-adjacent model for a given task is often not straight forward. In this
paper, we study DAFT-E, a framework that utilizes an Ensemble of
Domain-Adjacent Fine-Tuned Foundation Models for few-shot problems. We show
that for zero-shot problems, this ensembling method provides an accuracy
performance close to that of the single best model. With few-shot problems,
this performance improves further, at which point DEFT-E can outperform any
single domain-adjacent model while requiring much less data for domain-specific
fine-tuning. | [
-0.6054985523,
-1.1975774765,
0.5649920106,
-0.0753218159,
-0.0294067021,
0.068787992,
-0.1366125345,
-0.7417455316,
-0.1312741488,
0.2727811038,
-0.8269156814,
-0.3836455643,
-0.6268870234,
0.2428211272,
-0.6368743777,
0.734392643,
0.1566212177,
-0.4727318883,
-0.0376398563,
0.1548045278,
-0.0976788104,
-0.0813629851,
-0.4432356358,
-0.5071501136,
0.144982785,
0.7018581629,
0.4765282869,
0.5431757569,
0.637308538,
0.2232152224,
-0.0399031192,
0.2177818269,
-0.7245545387,
-0.0279741623,
-0.0662998557,
-0.4070370793,
-0.5282438993,
-0.1869198382,
0.3891156316,
0.9513413906,
-0.021500282,
0.22350806,
0.1024160609,
0.6761286855,
-0.6926816106,
-0.3356231153,
-0.7900665402,
-0.1795557737,
-0.3645214438,
-0.0677128285,
-0.163419947,
0.0705239028,
0.3150547147,
-0.6298954487,
0.1990876198,
0.0031193495,
0.8121144176,
0.5207184553,
-0.3365475833,
0.3462097347,
-0.6659153104,
0.9697310328,
-0.8107039928,
0.2353704423,
0.5793336034,
0.2387536168,
-0.3201448023,
-0.3064205348,
-0.6940271258,
0.4379343987,
0.0270813853,
-0.0208086167,
-0.4041852057,
0.255618751,
0.0712192357,
0.1093600914,
-0.6846744418,
0.3647027016,
-0.1244921833,
0.128116101,
0.7569983006,
0.2547325194,
-0.0429100506,
0.2393122017,
-0.3797141016,
0.1183339432,
-0.9141045809,
-0.2675733566,
0.4937577546,
0.6113156676,
-0.2152688801,
0.4711232185,
-0.5135034323,
1.3062717915,
0.4702880979,
-0.2495614886,
-0.1878529936,
0.0627059191,
-0.488956511,
-0.2005710155,
0.2198698372,
0.1153574511,
0.3839401305,
-0.1070076227,
-0.3939459324,
0.029872749,
0.0067638662,
-0.7930380106,
-0.3430384696,
0.5835766196,
-0.2237942964,
-0.1874061525,
-0.2086702585,
-0.553200841,
0.1097705215,
-0.3428135216,
0.6118097901,
-0.5388047695,
-0.2107066214,
0.1400708109,
-0.171240449,
0.0546474829,
0.4358025491,
-1.0130977631,
0.4264208078,
0.9543076754,
0.9338680506,
-0.4295563698,
-0.3884633482,
-0.5413882732,
0.1253428608,
-0.3694787323,
0.9853697419,
-0.8564223051,
-0.2151720375,
-0.0909060463,
-0.2183987945,
-0.1399242431,
-0.3832699656,
0.3675566018,
-0.5695183277,
-0.3873952329,
0.1076528579,
-0.9543415904,
-0.1675334871,
0.3141192794,
-0.3682344556,
0.7014599442,
0.2347047031,
-0.4943115115,
0.3268040121,
-0.2638674974,
-0.4289571941,
0.3096541166,
-0.3172700107,
-0.2612684369,
0.393271327,
0.0693206266,
0.6603933573,
-0.1245829016,
-0.1589331031,
-0.6690066457,
-0.7710596323,
-0.3252189755,
-0.3078986406,
0.6070564985,
0.2662866116,
-0.1197103411,
-0.6620749235,
-0.9660695791,
0.1028381586,
0.1302781254,
-0.1592894346,
-0.6590189338,
-0.2493079752,
0.0046902066,
-0.022711996,
0.0575180426,
-0.63001436,
0.2414000332,
-0.7218931913,
0.2268790305,
0.6993613839,
0.0658737347,
0.706386447,
-0.6254983544,
0.5547584295,
-0.0293530971,
-0.4468972385,
-0.3563138843,
-0.5520140529,
-0.3690739274,
-0.5934940577,
0.3690674007,
0.33360973,
-0.4398966134,
0.2792336941,
-0.0988244042,
-0.5153862834,
-0.3268238902,
0.0611134842,
0.0521472767,
0.4965278506,
0.1437812448,
-0.0094039897,
-0.2214352489,
-0.8000815511,
-0.2269895673,
0.0265321806,
0.0848566294,
0.3223865628,
0.7732226849,
-0.0548552983,
1.286970377,
-0.6425111294,
-0.2448781878,
0.1288274974,
0.184290573,
0.3624225855,
0.456908375,
0.7523838282,
-0.4858961701,
-0.7523323894,
0.0837884918,
-0.3846362233,
-0.1991029531,
-0.006953537,
-0.1374929696,
0.33885625,
-0.0698593333,
-0.5149790049,
0.2412725985,
0.6468872428,
-0.0078041572,
0.2458570898,
0.1210246086,
0.1689287722,
-0.5704804659,
-0.0764963776,
0.2222486734,
-0.2602374554,
-0.8580256701,
0.1079390496,
-0.0589902215,
0.0527900308,
-0.4953079522,
0.7006598115,
-0.3979050517,
0.1253816485,
-0.4422961473,
0.1519225389,
0.0226381607,
0.3826096952,
0.3199570477,
0.5379759669,
0.8069618344,
-0.8086903691,
-0.0768308118,
0.4612973332,
-0.2350180298,
0.9326119423,
-0.5847084522,
0.5376321673,
-0.0781253129,
-0.1336673051,
-0.9121911526,
-0.5078851581,
-0.4123184085,
-0.2746950388,
0.6554715633,
-0.5638021231,
-0.2160102278,
-0.2128404081,
-0.3513537645,
0.4913991988,
0.4153438807,
-0.6553855538,
0.1031008214,
0.435461998,
-0.2447873205,
-0.6003816128,
-0.9594898224,
-0.3206624985,
-0.3079604506,
-0.9735909104,
0.7789939046,
0.1454167664,
-0.2954589427,
-0.0960931629,
-0.3697614968,
-0.3966829479,
0.2780766785,
-0.036859829,
0.0410544015,
-0.1718176454,
0.2931648791,
0.2833516896,
0.049182564,
-0.5090065598,
-0.4049131274,
0.308137089,
-0.1129474267,
-0.4569850266,
0.0517684631,
0.5904301405,
0.2272742242,
0.0337085761,
0.6308481097,
0.1836488396,
-0.8780146837,
-0.6858006716,
-0.5549556613,
-0.455298543,
-0.4766495228,
0.2646120489,
-0.6488553882,
-1.1713945866,
0.3817929029,
-0.1772302091,
0.2406165004,
0.4243099689,
0.6052993536,
-0.3905439377,
0.809967339,
1.06612432,
-0.0475990288,
0.2275303751,
-0.2445756346,
0.2036495656,
-0.425780803,
0.3036975265,
-0.6746929884,
-0.3900355995,
-0.3413422108,
-0.0128276907,
0.4855808318,
0.3241471052,
-0.409088403,
0.6726400852,
-0.3471137583,
0.6821671128,
0.2482019216,
-0.0045493506,
0.6255320907,
0.2085828632,
0.1279270202,
0.1320570558,
-1.0069156885,
-0.5506467223,
1.0335719585,
0.2474435121,
1.110960722,
0.1612617224,
1.2457107306,
0.032533057,
-0.2835248113,
-0.8171303272,
0.1425244957,
-0.3147364259,
-0.7862851024,
-0.5121095777,
-0.2287841141,
-0.784607172,
0.1908202469,
-0.1885806173,
-1.0562707186,
0.5160768628,
0.2330169678,
-1.1162416935,
0.1589717269,
-0.672603786,
0.4697018862,
0.0734440163,
-0.6245877743,
-0.2619867623,
-0.4405162036,
0.6068986058,
-0.6854792833,
0.1189891249,
-0.2174069881,
-0.0496691093,
0.5377021432,
-0.4524162412,
0.781175673,
0.1382895857,
-0.2516272068,
0.4286227822,
0.3627010584,
0.7116774917,
-0.0969909057,
-0.2376541048,
0.2761831582,
0.3457129002,
-0.3149420321,
-0.3852650821,
0.9116564393,
-0.5383794308,
-0.6052971482,
-0.1892098039,
-0.3647281229,
-0.5739292502,
0.1847434491,
0.2928426564,
0.3654171228,
-0.1540924907,
0.1586402953,
0.5152588487,
0.1544404775,
0.8141926527,
0.7150386572,
0.2941348851,
0.2304441333,
0.5768851638,
0.3467460275,
0.398696959,
0.3285160065,
-0.0333323739,
0.0085276077,
-0.5600870252,
-0.428126663,
-0.0020682288,
-0.4677470028,
-0.6138375998,
-0.6854766607,
0.0217244495,
-0.3012671471,
-0.4517775476,
-0.4912026227,
-0.7079421878,
-0.2349620014,
0.1603268236,
0.5701344609,
0.58326298,
-0.1608953923,
0.5111848712,
-1.1466180086,
0.2526299655,
0.2866246104,
0.5153975487,
-0.033296261,
-0.7691971064,
-0.3394665122,
0.0476220585,
-0.3710305989,
-0.8425761461,
0.3192673326,
0.5669371486,
0.5349037647,
0.2610270679,
0.1424132735,
0.879381299,
-0.6226143241,
0.4723058343,
-0.1296323389,
-0.8325813413,
0.4634449482,
-0.5762383342,
0.2764703035,
0.6835147738,
0.3977205455,
-0.1026550382,
-0.0964409709,
-0.5859009624,
-0.5857957006,
0.930234611,
0.3339256048,
0.1190307662,
-0.1108916178,
0.3233453631,
0.280991286,
0.1949810386,
-0.2510383427,
-0.2262776345,
0.317335695,
-0.1887004822,
0.1316663623,
0.1732800901,
-0.1686258614,
-0.1586548537,
0.774110496,
-0.4800137579,
0.3254033029,
0.1412288398,
-0.2192707509,
-0.7885591984,
0.3070959151,
0.4974709153,
0.3821580112,
-0.2725310028,
-0.1867578179,
0.3221120536,
-0.1657054126,
0.2779660821,
0.1976378262,
-0.2083551884,
-0.2295580953,
0.448160857,
0.4303297698,
-0.1380918771,
-0.5292803049,
0.5221190453,
0.5810407996,
-0.2805695534,
0.1829067022,
0.0503984466,
-0.1292840689,
0.5550872684,
0.5572462082,
0.1702736616,
0.2571205497,
-0.461687088,
0.5360388756,
0.7107486725,
0.0638116822,
-0.2423562109,
0.4140511155,
0.292250514,
-0.1879910678,
0.3789153099,
-0.0470214933,
-0.3253551424,
0.8236260414,
0.7279917002,
0.9732061625,
0.1385465413,
0.0327143483,
0.2405941635,
0.3421112597,
-0.3390321732,
0.0599940531,
-0.0481702983,
-0.9870828986,
-0.6394481063,
-0.7039782405,
-0.3911043108,
-0.0206303671,
-0.3275188804,
0.4902822673,
-0.2109506726,
-0.3096933961,
-0.1233657673,
-0.0434193052,
-0.8910753131,
0.2291309834,
0.3367656767,
0.9371153712,
-0.8156469464,
0.7955249548,
0.6256350279,
0.0187208373,
-0.622330308,
0.0962994918,
0.3622785509,
-0.6640444398,
0.4656873643,
-0.0716735199,
-0.3856022954,
0.400880307,
-0.6691040397,
-1.0675271749,
1.0402480364,
0.5700249672,
-1.1732133627,
-0.0447396562,
-0.1090380847,
0.4870811701,
-0.4014343917,
0.1840059012,
0.9688072205,
0.3818995059,
0.1645930409,
-1.0550808907,
-0.2833502889,
0.0949385762,
-0.2606503963,
0.3149506748,
-0.8433071375,
0.8014140725,
-0.2589659691,
-0.3033478558,
0.0127439816,
0.3675569892,
0.3622262776,
0.1327319145,
0.4483750761,
0.6592403054,
0.6993135214,
-0.1337203383,
0.9279474616,
-0.3426194489,
0.6318858862,
1.1168189049,
-0.4659053683,
0.9283583164,
0.4244983494,
-0.4662086964,
0.0065816366,
0.6174912453,
0.1059165299,
0.7928660512,
0.0327339247,
-0.1140269563,
-0.5772633553,
0.3275237083,
-0.2092678249,
0.7218503952,
0.3590791225,
0.2260433137,
-0.5024744868,
-0.2783023119,
-0.4943068326,
0.0098082982,
-0.3315536976,
0.6917056441,
0.4916282594,
-0.4992742538,
0.6987472773,
0.1577557623,
0.9812117815,
-0.2995663285,
-0.1977199912,
-0.2102354467,
0.0847979486,
-0.5880410075,
-0.5424389243,
0.5235158205,
0.0788406953,
0.0507140383,
0.1059431955,
1.003125906,
-0.4645696282,
-0.3567649424,
0.0566365719,
0.8639197946,
-0.0460950285,
-0.1498970091,
-0.4467300475,
-0.2422739416,
-0.3237088621,
-0.3777952492,
0.3559369445,
0.3120863736,
0.0680361018,
0.4864678383,
0.273837626,
-0.1954573691,
-0.0025790262,
-0.1214230806,
0.5676260591,
-0.4891783893,
-0.4299789965,
-1.0802793503,
0.5374130011,
0.3399360776,
-0.3207284212,
0.4803963304,
0.2844371498,
0.8982489109,
0.0286769196,
0.7921882868,
-0.0461728498,
0.5066224933,
-0.4973480403,
0.475158155,
-0.8515153527,
0.2885900438,
-0.5082045794,
-1.0568749905,
-0.3861694336,
0.7843738198,
-0.0491638221,
0.2248690724,
0.5893042088,
0.8095412254,
-0.281924367,
0.1866942048,
0.7685523629,
0.0077619231,
-0.1112529188,
0.7446283102,
0.6672164798,
-0.4515185952,
0.139595136,
-0.3865021467,
-0.1836274415,
-0.099562794,
-0.9517432451,
-0.8598963022,
-0.3547331095,
-0.4372778237,
0.2110118568,
0.0651540235,
1.1201255322,
1.0194693804,
-0.9338128567,
0.0337063409,
-0.1065588966,
-0.1326234043,
-0.2153515965,
-0.1631961018,
-0.0106099462,
-0.2873682678,
-1.1211391687,
0.6822330356,
0.5278853774,
0.2794384062,
0.034515094,
0.1298647225,
-0.2614645064,
0.3576243222,
0.5419098139,
0.1135070473,
-0.4826969206,
-0.4318344593,
0.2435221076,
0.0008682192,
-0.046749752,
0.4104354382,
-0.9159662724,
0.2175798118,
0.5722648501,
0.9131378531,
0.7600795031,
0.1731418818,
0.7197966576,
-1.0119016171,
0.1445216686,
0.2771759033,
0.3392148912,
0.0786887705,
-0.41105479,
0.7433861494,
0.1047892421,
-0.472763747,
-0.831997931,
0.110243082,
-0.7100910544,
-0.3083610833,
1.1172448397,
-0.0919245481,
0.0054715322,
-0.1434795409,
0.2603674233,
-0.0864604786,
-0.4005213976,
0.4672904909,
0.959653914,
-0.3262959123,
-0.2832520008,
-0.3306969404,
0.3743416071,
0.5607591271,
-0.6846538186,
-0.2535994947,
0.3726718724,
0.2628357112,
-0.0531761311,
0.5535311103,
0.2196473181,
0.1505727023,
0.1408328861,
-0.4812654853,
0.0318378881,
-0.548161149,
-0.7704978585,
0.2815053761,
0.129434526,
0.0260197092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13718v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13718v1 | Evaluating Large Language Models along Dimensions of Language Variation: A Systematik Invesdigatiom uv Cross-lingual Generalization | 2024-06-19T17:20:28 | 2024-06-19T17:20:28 | Niyati Bafna, Kenton Murray, David Yarowsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models exhibit certain cross-lingual generalization
capabilities, they suffer from performance degradation (PD) on unseen
closely-related languages (CRLs) and dialects relative to their high-resource
language neighbour (HRLN). However, we currently lack a fundamental
understanding of what kinds of linguistic distances contribute to PD, and to
what extent. Furthermore, studies of cross-lingual generalization are
confounded by unknown quantities of CRL language traces in the training data,
and by the frequent lack of availability of evaluation data in lower-resource
related languages and dialects. To address these issues, we model phonological,
morphological, and lexical distance as Bayesian noise processes to synthesize
artificial languages that are controllably distant from the HRLN. We analyse PD
as a function of underlying noise parameters, offering insights on model
robustness to isolated and composed linguistic phenomena, and the impact of
task and HRL characteristics on PD. We calculate parameter posteriors on real
CRL-HRLN pair data and show that they follow computed trends of artificial
languages, demonstrating the viability of our noisers. Our framework offers a
cheap solution to estimating task performance on an unseen CRL given HRLN
performance using its posteriors, as well as for diagnosing observed PD on a
CRL in terms of its linguistic distances from its HRLN, and opens doors to
principled methods of mitigating performance degradation. | [
-0.3147945404,
-1.0046209097,
0.3705767691,
0.2644698322,
-0.0604089573,
-0.0862011909,
-0.5150884986,
-0.5701841116,
-0.1224660426,
0.5533164144,
-0.5350900888,
-0.3639378846,
-0.2752409875,
-0.1724588722,
-0.180042997,
0.7552366257,
0.4046825469,
0.1188748628,
-0.0336669795,
-0.1778700948,
-0.2944133878,
-0.4955249429,
-0.5437448621,
-0.3158772886,
0.4541808069,
0.0119150551,
0.7039978504,
0.5626648068,
0.569924593,
0.3189480603,
-0.3321354091,
-0.1410546452,
-0.5060921311,
0.3684484363,
-0.3589527607,
-0.5030668974,
-0.2418994606,
-0.3760016859,
0.9995497465,
1.2443778515,
-0.0529603101,
0.0226343069,
0.1234866828,
0.5236958861,
-0.6556842327,
0.3157995939,
-0.4482601881,
0.0945386216,
-0.4886994064,
0.1975200772,
-0.140552476,
-0.0663398802,
0.2807199657,
-0.5610245466,
0.3684141934,
-0.2356264889,
0.7896339297,
0.2707338035,
0.0415937044,
0.0781063735,
-0.902025938,
1.0057297945,
-0.8077578545,
0.8119287491,
0.4946148396,
0.1955379099,
-0.0880265683,
-0.1379330456,
-0.3153662086,
-0.5009286404,
-0.0538576581,
-0.0793452039,
-0.3323601782,
0.1678072363,
0.3947890997,
0.5487723947,
-0.6229476333,
0.283401072,
-0.3613137901,
-0.2451743186,
0.5407168865,
0.2022794187,
0.3125207126,
-0.0490046144,
0.1393948942,
-0.1399743408,
-0.7152065635,
-0.123562932,
0.6955875158,
0.4585196376,
-0.2668464184,
0.2322577834,
-0.3127785027,
0.7243975997,
0.0057512969,
-0.2381043583,
0.1846794635,
-0.3876118958,
-0.0948035941,
-0.3362309039,
0.8349699974,
-0.0310992952,
0.0532943532,
-0.5006712675,
-0.2263570577,
0.0357284062,
-0.0274904799,
-0.5275123715,
-0.4487873018,
-0.1374191344,
-0.4624265134,
-0.0108356448,
-0.267166853,
-0.9187242985,
-0.3478557765,
-0.2660802007,
0.3555165529,
-0.502106607,
-0.5469853282,
-0.1185516417,
0.0199168716,
-0.167720452,
0.0448436737,
-0.8517302275,
0.4608718455,
0.5956564546,
0.7096322179,
-0.3197547495,
-0.38865906,
-0.5197712779,
0.0604000986,
-0.5259913206,
0.4870421588,
-0.6768162251,
-0.5426673889,
0.0384883992,
-0.1446060836,
-0.0747784227,
-1.0497633219,
0.290115267,
-0.4531750083,
-0.105678834,
-0.2319433242,
-0.1715446264,
-0.0944178998,
-0.0913524106,
-0.8668444753,
1.0942789316,
0.2215951681,
-0.7879929543,
0.5007072687,
-0.572686255,
-0.5243215561,
-0.0074933232,
0.099324204,
-0.3267965317,
0.4340616763,
-0.0334307402,
0.373988837,
-0.3953166306,
0.1324678659,
-0.4293387532,
-0.218290329,
0.0427199937,
-0.5161693096,
0.7118142247,
0.1288150847,
-0.3707405925,
0.0285709966,
-1.1699601412,
-0.1546531022,
-0.2221874893,
-0.5187293291,
-0.8205578923,
0.118694067,
-0.0080960793,
0.1501168311,
0.2111870795,
-0.4491024613,
-0.0996478572,
-0.5472839475,
0.2036465406,
0.5451853871,
-0.0820184425,
0.3476784229,
-0.0929735824,
0.6333159804,
0.2153136432,
0.1889860928,
0.1606568247,
-0.2495461851,
-0.8094838858,
-0.288782239,
0.3013034463,
0.2569954693,
-0.603669703,
0.1318523884,
-0.435875386,
-0.541081965,
-0.5065885782,
0.1104749814,
0.6326475143,
0.2431340218,
0.247769326,
-0.6302300692,
-0.2446639538,
-1.1236486435,
-0.2222157121,
-0.4012296796,
-0.1106281951,
0.0031674728,
0.1522471309,
-0.3539224267,
0.6109957099,
-0.0262507033,
0.1412263066,
-0.1384546608,
0.2266002148,
-0.0118128732,
0.4425754547,
0.3139716685,
-0.4874273241,
-0.3645839989,
0.3029141724,
-0.4229736924,
-0.4872952402,
0.1200690866,
0.0693335459,
0.4823161364,
0.4145708978,
-0.4861112237,
0.4369297028,
0.8518765569,
-0.1395231485,
0.838335216,
-0.2627241313,
-0.030734418,
-0.4723882377,
0.2371228784,
0.2664593756,
0.1581616998,
-0.654501915,
0.2047601938,
-0.3744867742,
0.0015840244,
-0.0555759892,
0.4432554543,
-0.506716013,
-0.3615893126,
-0.0230495706,
-0.1433446258,
-0.3467698991,
0.5428413749,
0.1967604011,
0.4985516667,
0.6456905007,
-0.722391963,
0.1187301874,
-0.3499794304,
-0.5133546591,
0.6407827735,
-0.6080847383,
-0.135808304,
0.0635148808,
-0.1804527491,
-0.8326231241,
-0.075397253,
0.1332592368,
-0.1092377454,
0.3973083198,
-0.1820675135,
-0.6589406133,
-0.0091053285,
0.1185585782,
0.7640206814,
0.3029963374,
-0.2506201863,
0.2357233763,
0.4325896204,
-0.2780660093,
-0.2934006751,
-0.7742720842,
-0.0712286234,
-0.2890034318,
-0.5781373978,
0.0566695407,
-0.0264119748,
-0.6709300876,
-0.0680547431,
-0.0248800777,
-0.3810597956,
0.0464197397,
0.3629101217,
-0.1123986691,
-0.4161028564,
0.3453938067,
0.0351305231,
0.049085252,
0.2191940397,
-0.2258478105,
0.6173669696,
0.0502432771,
-0.4382192194,
-0.2456572801,
0.4444870353,
0.5213945508,
-0.3134233057,
0.5881455541,
0.6647742987,
-0.2980263531,
-0.3082293272,
-0.6813322902,
-0.0200731754,
-0.4105479717,
0.6965712309,
-0.6047618985,
-0.6749766469,
0.7574624419,
0.1051976755,
-0.1856514215,
0.4707665741,
0.635450542,
0.3666316867,
0.7749254107,
0.8452220559,
-0.210050106,
0.5587319732,
-0.2098045647,
0.1491562575,
-0.5156412125,
-0.1474863291,
-0.470959872,
0.0084060663,
-0.8717713952,
-0.5208416581,
0.396319747,
0.0637636408,
-0.3668500781,
0.2222681344,
-0.0965765491,
0.2652048171,
0.7816476226,
-0.0339304917,
0.3599872291,
0.1894265115,
-0.376137197,
-0.1804393381,
-0.915009439,
-0.1750728637,
0.7800014019,
0.4200757146,
0.8845072389,
0.0094787469,
0.5850995779,
0.1664748043,
-0.052429691,
-0.538690865,
0.4626787305,
-0.0532117188,
-0.509913981,
-0.598426044,
-0.7213954926,
-0.9407066703,
0.3339536786,
0.2021459341,
-0.9061161876,
0.4429715574,
-0.010633151,
-0.2622866035,
0.3510899246,
-0.3658873737,
0.9245985746,
-0.0604260452,
-0.6676625013,
-0.5901030302,
-0.6516624689,
0.2611145079,
-0.2473276407,
0.383425802,
0.0930848196,
-0.0387583114,
0.7704045177,
-0.3636997342,
0.9438958168,
-0.1163096949,
-0.5251581073,
0.1110691503,
0.5280013084,
0.0633425266,
-0.1897247583,
-0.2924692631,
0.5113598704,
0.0723095536,
-0.3876295686,
-0.4409971535,
0.7921943665,
-0.7010059357,
-0.480289489,
0.0486345775,
-0.8385327458,
-0.3874493837,
0.1263121665,
0.3355877995,
0.4343952835,
-0.2065844834,
-0.1293350011,
0.552306056,
-0.5439855456,
0.4332650006,
0.4897882938,
-0.0885767117,
-0.2327761203,
1.1416381598,
0.3042520285,
0.4855640233,
0.4778624773,
0.2899503112,
-0.16822052,
-0.5087555647,
-0.2802619934,
0.3315294087,
-0.4601986408,
0.2418433577,
-0.3330259621,
0.0318831243,
-0.2448299229,
0.2244909406,
-0.5066435337,
-0.4062382579,
-0.0805100054,
0.1394974589,
-0.0730389133,
0.9885804653,
-0.5734401345,
0.3278542757,
-0.6183888316,
0.1397332251,
0.1554702371,
0.4447714686,
0.130771175,
-0.5790230036,
-0.5990896821,
0.261705786,
-0.263528496,
-0.7055822611,
0.474070549,
0.3099026382,
0.6778440475,
0.4885292351,
-0.0896047726,
0.7283787131,
-0.3263043761,
0.8626830578,
0.1084750295,
-1.0522916317,
0.4136509895,
-0.6477262974,
0.2830570936,
0.2378836274,
0.2400969565,
-0.4533027709,
-0.6609991193,
-0.6506917477,
-0.69751513,
0.5765390396,
-0.0056317993,
-0.1337538809,
0.1389057636,
0.1504063904,
0.2353649735,
0.118803151,
-0.7264252901,
-0.1180430278,
0.2041493803,
0.2064967155,
-0.3259572983,
-0.2655213177,
0.0813734755,
-0.3320337534,
0.5674641132,
0.0355935395,
0.1579259634,
-0.0848728642,
-0.1904077381,
-0.3997169733,
0.1137278229,
0.4911290705,
0.8286359906,
0.0881642625,
0.0391640514,
0.1611057967,
-0.1644636095,
0.0379229449,
0.0736838654,
0.0110879121,
0.1854406446,
0.6583032608,
0.6743910909,
0.3677778244,
-0.7642387748,
0.3076133728,
0.3627578318,
0.1570691317,
-0.0330038518,
-0.082921125,
-0.0134944012,
0.3796441555,
-0.0009885556,
-0.0516459942,
0.3191528618,
-0.7988309264,
0.1073119938,
0.3631875217,
-0.5945965052,
-0.6607135534,
0.5123003125,
-0.0189917944,
-0.1547569036,
0.4821730256,
-0.128115803,
-0.5213927031,
0.4931692183,
0.375837326,
0.8371585011,
-0.394076705,
0.1029208079,
0.1515769064,
0.3389685452,
0.0684136599,
0.0080597205,
-0.1683358997,
-0.3530261815,
-0.5649265051,
-0.8111563325,
-0.1668993533,
0.1541830301,
-0.7344321609,
0.0297109839,
-0.3191712201,
-0.1685627103,
-0.0977753475,
-0.0329896174,
-0.5671331882,
0.1963338554,
0.1201614738,
0.3985957801,
-0.7038402557,
0.7926924825,
0.5024878979,
-0.2812881172,
-0.5198802352,
0.3154198527,
-0.2686702907,
-0.6190081239,
1.1049540043,
-0.1950619817,
-0.1277348697,
-0.5181919932,
-0.195694834,
-0.7757166624,
0.4487472177,
0.6933833957,
-0.6958888173,
0.0729657114,
0.5880537033,
0.9351146221,
0.1335649043,
0.1318607181,
0.7183889151,
0.3322383165,
-0.383726567,
-1.4073073864,
-0.0571672805,
-0.13218005,
0.2810571492,
0.3957266212,
-0.8382716775,
1.0618542433,
-0.1214216724,
-0.2390672266,
0.1721177995,
0.3390267193,
-0.0160696469,
0.0424673893,
0.3938594759,
0.7078354955,
0.5243279934,
0.0654120445,
0.8960107565,
-0.3672036827,
0.2893081307,
1.0038455725,
0.0160186142,
0.7778531313,
0.3572425246,
-0.3385647535,
0.3870618641,
0.5315114856,
0.1943100095,
0.4554429054,
0.7564971447,
-0.3329339623,
-0.3796095848,
-0.0714118257,
-0.3006861806,
0.4028591216,
0.3912080526,
-0.3589152694,
-0.2554531097,
0.0553182475,
-0.2088371813,
0.073423788,
-0.2665315568,
0.5941182375,
-0.0067705531,
-0.5306304693,
0.7838311195,
-0.00724664,
0.5744414926,
-0.5045682788,
0.0458784103,
-0.305927515,
0.3162242174,
0.0178004168,
-0.3355978727,
0.3870721459,
-0.2123672962,
-0.2593870461,
0.1901740283,
0.4195897877,
-0.4944058061,
-0.645780921,
0.7009496093,
0.577883482,
0.3014801145,
-0.1063779145,
-0.5141906738,
0.281354636,
-0.2515787184,
-0.0433819704,
0.4027411044,
0.7121251225,
-0.1169543341,
0.8547870517,
0.3829657733,
0.4548885822,
0.3686540723,
0.0894370005,
0.6607787609,
-0.3917371631,
-0.4262009859,
-0.8239176869,
0.1167744324,
0.1936791837,
-0.3707080781,
0.7026155591,
0.5818454027,
1.1303988695,
-0.1027541757,
0.7838587761,
0.1047267243,
0.5944070816,
-0.4231924117,
0.7977244854,
-0.762382865,
0.3961181939,
-0.5351341367,
-0.975940764,
-0.3130002618,
0.5000542998,
-0.439586848,
0.0549682602,
0.516361773,
1.0945248604,
-0.212276563,
-0.3278446794,
0.7812418938,
0.3399416208,
0.0151877236,
0.4511953592,
0.888459146,
-0.1682467014,
0.5512200594,
-0.6575556993,
-0.1098539531,
-0.0865868926,
-0.4275641143,
-0.7926011682,
-0.7345023751,
-0.5440750122,
-0.2185253948,
0.4305170476,
0.4903159142,
0.8520556092,
-0.8627723455,
-0.7553111911,
-0.10170912,
0.0719897076,
-0.3761942685,
-0.2712423801,
0.373778671,
-0.3586925268,
-0.7696617246,
0.2246691287,
0.1784185618,
-0.2154283077,
-0.6541672945,
-0.103301771,
0.1115569621,
-0.0752687827,
0.6528941393,
0.2903214693,
-0.911862731,
-0.2040276229,
-0.4055793881,
-0.0041270354,
-0.1279251575,
0.7237402201,
-0.5150202513,
0.4568913281,
0.5136688948,
0.4456724524,
0.2470554113,
-0.380656004,
0.7323489189,
-0.6709061861,
0.2162691653,
0.1813731939,
0.2362263203,
0.3439225852,
-0.1660094857,
0.4328052402,
0.4257798195,
-0.4924181104,
-0.7519078255,
0.2672596574,
-0.7879838943,
-0.2106985599,
1.3327809572,
-0.2836704552,
-0.1731730253,
-0.1892323047,
0.0810941532,
0.1971402317,
-0.3621314466,
0.7535703778,
0.7955426574,
-0.0050066044,
-0.0853370279,
-0.5294273496,
0.4730560482,
0.4999883473,
-0.4448258579,
0.279694289,
0.7423581481,
0.3808919787,
0.3302414119,
0.1812544316,
-0.1426139474,
0.2091683745,
0.4058465362,
0.0569401942,
0.3668940365,
-0.2871545255,
-0.3991485834,
0.148594588,
0.1544519961,
-0.0350427441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13714v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13714v1 | BEACON: Balancing Convenience and Nutrition in Meals With Long-Term Group Recommendations and Reasoning on Multimodal Recipes | 2024-06-19T17:14:41 | 2024-06-19T17:14:41 | Vansh Nagpal, Siva Likitha Valluru, Kausik Lakkaraju, Biplav Srivastava | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | A common, yet regular, decision made by people, whether healthy or with any
health condition, is to decide what to have in meals like breakfast, lunch, and
dinner, consisting of a combination of foods for appetizer, main course, side
dishes, desserts, and beverages. However, often this decision is seen as a
trade-off between nutritious choices (e.g., low salt and sugar) or convenience
(e.g., inexpensive, fast to prepare/obtain, taste better). In this preliminary
work, we present a data-driven approach for the novel meal recommendation
problem that can explore and balance choices for both considerations while also
reasoning about a food's constituents and cooking process. Beyond the problem
formulation, our contributions also include a goodness measure, a recipe
conversion method from text to the recently introduced multimodal rich recipe
representation (R3) format, and learning methods using contextual bandits that
show promising results. | [
-0.3016377091,
-0.5795894861,
0.6134781241,
0.4438931942,
-0.2100490034,
-0.1971476674,
-0.1115903705,
-0.5159530044,
0.5416350365,
0.4539704323,
-0.5840030313,
-0.3294888437,
-0.4259623885,
0.0931457579,
0.0882648677,
0.9249727726,
-0.0824581981,
0.1675361991,
-0.2081397772,
-0.2680463195,
-1.142132163,
-0.2735149562,
-0.6355053186,
-0.413410604,
0.8929941058,
0.8633424044,
0.8649293184,
0.4957782626,
0.3183300495,
0.1395285726,
0.0872490853,
0.4004724622,
-0.2726123929,
0.5297634602,
-0.2556001544,
-0.3738207519,
-0.3999463022,
-0.0332682654,
0.0113516608,
0.9764890075,
0.0155511647,
0.1110320762,
0.0728214383,
1.0189496279,
-0.6865822077,
0.1537668258,
-0.1385042816,
0.1776702404,
-0.2547400594,
-0.3160883784,
-0.3740495145,
-0.4018331766,
0.1521094888,
-0.6777530909,
-0.0711538717,
0.2807843685,
0.0882502049,
0.2821390629,
-0.7816342115,
-0.7587538958,
-0.5841469765,
1.030367136,
-0.313090831,
0.4154236317,
0.8646043539,
0.4284256399,
-0.4039861858,
-0.4996030629,
-0.2247158289,
-0.2316413522,
-0.1308250725,
0.25036484,
0.2845039666,
-0.3257360756,
-0.2421213537,
0.2402684093,
-0.5361720324,
-0.2862638533,
-0.0543879569,
-0.013946645,
0.4693597853,
0.3022745848,
0.1606596708,
-0.3434152305,
-0.8253403902,
0.1787466556,
-0.5081732869,
0.231380716,
0.0082392823,
0.3101642728,
0.0743826777,
0.6994953752,
-0.3593533039,
0.8893772364,
-0.0972110927,
-0.0876970589,
0.3226955831,
-0.7935271263,
0.1497634202,
0.1305216551,
0.2291213423,
1.2928140163,
-0.2602481842,
0.0100169573,
-0.1601145118,
-0.0164432209,
-0.0242090058,
-0.398586452,
-0.3818892241,
0.2947585285,
-0.6289454103,
-0.0068574655,
-0.1766958237,
-0.7088496685,
-0.4167529345,
-0.2713092566,
0.5220986605,
-0.4604372978,
0.0704237521,
0.2941527069,
-0.5460441709,
-0.0649128407,
0.2180185318,
-0.9083150625,
0.0827538073,
0.1192419007,
0.927778542,
-0.0073540271,
-0.1473253071,
-0.6593179107,
0.7623577714,
-0.0958744735,
0.9362744689,
-0.788336575,
-0.9074730873,
-0.2944273055,
0.0587922633,
0.2610812783,
-0.3102664649,
0.7985064983,
-0.0550200343,
0.2156296819,
-1.1597331762,
-0.4615091681,
-0.0029757814,
0.2705921829,
-0.6910656095,
0.6632808447,
0.3773337305,
-0.5239822268,
0.6335217953,
-0.2977079749,
-0.9963315725,
0.3583673537,
-0.1417840421,
0.0252915528,
0.0426173545,
0.3106981516,
0.2735117674,
-0.1802053154,
0.1612754911,
-0.1995434761,
-0.2918200195,
0.2675493956,
-0.3292323947,
0.2075538784,
0.42241925,
0.0561057776,
0.3952105045,
-0.4324421585,
0.1888097227,
0.0704312399,
-0.3785399795,
-0.8013269305,
0.545801878,
0.184133321,
-0.2394101918,
0.2495566458,
-0.0788903162,
0.2455614656,
-0.2508240342,
0.8416957855,
0.7204601765,
-0.0181107987,
0.6762035489,
-0.7184779644,
0.0878864601,
-0.1293144971,
0.6739710569,
-0.3964428306,
-0.7575660944,
-0.4462377429,
-0.2379180938,
0.2205238491,
0.3269541264,
-0.8763540983,
0.4787529707,
-0.0671397522,
-0.0713753775,
0.02434556,
-0.3440403342,
0.1216404438,
0.8049589396,
0.8976069689,
-0.2974593043,
-0.2833194137,
-0.7954038382,
-0.3132396638,
0.4636089802,
0.1107106954,
0.2072760165,
0.0739714205,
-0.22824651,
1.2715770006,
-0.7738714814,
-0.3202944398,
-0.533352077,
-0.3174735904,
0.2951215804,
0.5477724671,
0.5801341534,
-1.0138862133,
-0.4719682634,
-0.1365701556,
-0.4192847908,
0.2446452975,
0.0007741811,
-0.1620137841,
-0.2791507244,
-0.0099467579,
-0.4970802367,
0.2877274156,
0.4534150958,
-0.6565920115,
0.3997801244,
-0.0895381272,
0.2862169743,
-1.3935940266,
-0.2796951532,
0.1278433353,
-0.0301705282,
-0.2885838747,
-0.1885384172,
0.2553938031,
0.0211088508,
-0.1724319458,
1.1825374365,
-0.1569292992,
0.0877893418,
-0.0928389877,
-0.4591265917,
0.1171854883,
0.1106367856,
-0.1060222685,
0.6124936938,
0.2616452575,
-0.7047353387,
0.3966999948,
0.0235751923,
-0.2683298588,
1.0953273773,
-0.5810655355,
-0.2358431071,
-0.0275762416,
0.626373589,
-1.1834406853,
-0.5165783763,
0.7285625935,
-0.2480999082,
-0.1298421025,
0.0808039829,
-0.2698874176,
-0.2621755898,
-0.4377541244,
0.7049289346,
0.0478981696,
-0.6040294766,
0.9394435883,
0.0341049805,
-0.1305069178,
-0.3559084535,
-0.6444455385,
0.2069619,
-0.2068387866,
-0.4262751639,
0.7890940309,
-0.4219994843,
-0.2293023467,
0.3191452324,
-0.2044360638,
0.2109734714,
-0.0945970118,
0.3986110389,
0.2678946257,
0.2723443508,
0.179550305,
0.0297831036,
-0.3442316055,
-0.3893751502,
-0.1218215451,
0.5574643612,
-0.0404865518,
-0.1161606014,
-0.2550140023,
0.9020766616,
0.0853102878,
-0.4277135134,
0.5183612704,
0.6860121489,
-0.0992838219,
-0.138008222,
-0.3231725991,
-0.1831831485,
-0.4485826492,
-0.086431019,
-0.2506036758,
-0.4436928034,
0.6792702675,
0.135714516,
-0.0441305637,
0.1077436358,
0.1650803387,
-0.1839125156,
0.6889439821,
0.0729746819,
0.0768139064,
0.5072157383,
0.0183861461,
0.086660713,
-0.7030210495,
-0.5461956859,
-0.340131551,
-0.6061584949,
-0.1869244874,
-0.5289957523,
0.7243087888,
-0.2389204353,
-0.1169471741,
-0.0457924381,
-0.539711833,
0.8200472593,
0.6451510191,
0.5501172543,
0.3763954341,
-0.1953116804,
-0.3316932917,
-0.0362322591,
-0.4655932188,
-0.0734249577,
0.8138700724,
-0.0359321348,
0.9142318368,
0.2106956095,
0.7052112222,
0.6709442139,
0.0309956614,
-0.9968613982,
0.413921237,
-0.103861779,
-0.6036083102,
-0.067678459,
-0.7969527841,
-0.9112927914,
0.1028740555,
-0.159924522,
-0.2523244023,
-0.0745202228,
0.1695920527,
-0.614346981,
-0.2168878317,
-1.1655381918,
0.7428788543,
-0.6954115629,
-0.8355575204,
0.0897654369,
-0.7181156278,
-0.0840076357,
0.5065526962,
0.5294091105,
-0.1348361671,
0.1294428855,
0.4772359133,
0.0035835423,
0.4916799664,
-0.1356349736,
0.1214630902,
-0.1389405876,
0.2265092134,
0.1693016738,
0.5170224309,
-0.1655496657,
-0.0228745155,
0.1362214237,
-0.4954484999,
-0.8487387896,
1.0230209827,
-0.3523834646,
-0.437010169,
-0.6924065948,
-0.4990525544,
-0.3068277836,
0.446454227,
0.2753865123,
0.4883936048,
-0.005839895,
0.211389184,
0.2361044437,
0.0268334001,
0.4298123121,
0.1481011808,
-0.2550840378,
-0.9319072962,
0.970805347,
0.1575914025,
-0.0093031563,
0.3103665709,
0.5639642477,
-0.2873528898,
-0.0499259569,
-0.2833971083,
-0.1858114898,
-0.5755963326,
-0.2595878839,
-0.0775299221,
0.3444004059,
0.0982199758,
-0.6292493939,
-0.4603628814,
-0.3521940112,
-0.2054815143,
0.0954565555,
-0.2284929156,
0.5551348329,
0.0605882406,
0.0416573212,
-0.5965027809,
0.2479528189,
0.4567627311,
0.3365905285,
0.1630417109,
0.1418422461,
-0.3618791997,
-0.0420905687,
-0.5637221336,
-0.930924356,
0.3114339709,
-0.0632858723,
0.6029683352,
0.3905703723,
0.0299784485,
0.2536462843,
-0.2618682981,
0.9330542684,
0.7446014285,
-0.8301270604,
0.5038269162,
-0.2113331556,
0.3742295802,
0.5860220194,
0.5391137004,
-0.7063543797,
0.3580295444,
0.1486039013,
-1.0400948524,
-0.1556273103,
0.1450984925,
0.0109349024,
-0.5112553835,
0.3204637468,
0.4814956486,
0.2755004466,
-0.539491415,
-0.1858351082,
-0.6456614137,
-0.1174269468,
-0.2004997879,
-0.1234883964,
-0.3652688265,
-0.5182721019,
0.2215479016,
-0.1417389512,
0.0487016365,
0.0885316879,
0.5424399972,
-0.1003441364,
0.4732933342,
0.5711858273,
0.9662053585,
-0.4738104939,
0.4114813507,
-0.2442829162,
-0.1452623308,
0.2232186794,
-0.0614187457,
0.2986436188,
-0.3030539453,
0.1815603822,
0.3669140339,
0.3424110115,
-0.3372708559,
0.2744728625,
-0.3602894247,
-0.0948009565,
0.0096717961,
0.2479325384,
0.0883834064,
0.3425860405,
0.5270597339,
0.3960374892,
0.2351587713,
-0.6138692498,
0.0366267823,
0.5805372596,
-0.1627440602,
-0.1971899271,
0.2478713691,
0.6641460657,
-0.1320291907,
0.6264297366,
-0.115259625,
-0.1188587397,
0.1763086766,
0.6181473136,
0.384229213,
-0.4458800256,
0.4692157805,
0.0461877771,
-0.007533947,
-0.2839432657,
0.200346157,
-0.2862557173,
-0.7748243213,
-0.0940693989,
-0.5152488947,
-0.246444419,
-0.1301174164,
-0.7899927497,
0.0032297005,
-0.0789504945,
-0.7350271344,
0.0515385121,
-0.1625762731,
-0.7446042895,
0.077610895,
-0.0431203805,
0.7745357752,
-0.5956325531,
0.4713865817,
0.5934188366,
-0.3371547461,
-0.3716564178,
0.3433526456,
-0.1231974661,
-0.6880933642,
0.3756886125,
0.2852096856,
-0.2999274731,
-0.3199762702,
-0.5009514689,
-0.7213304043,
0.6646627188,
0.3041226566,
-0.3547838628,
-0.4081175625,
-0.1988117546,
0.0006246952,
-0.1311345845,
0.1452727318,
0.0607431196,
0.8901589513,
0.6710017323,
-0.6068992019,
-0.0704813078,
-0.0047542397,
0.0061127548,
0.2069508284,
-0.7883258462,
1.0172395706,
-0.4054406285,
-0.1042766422,
-0.1474518627,
0.3637657464,
0.1712771356,
0.8130472898,
0.2326564491,
0.4986358285,
0.552713573,
0.0163681172,
1.053861618,
-0.1027788818,
0.3550462723,
1.3167105913,
-0.7918682694,
0.2723453641,
0.727184236,
-0.1417495608,
0.1509547979,
1.102244854,
0.2350093275,
1.22019732,
-0.1445566565,
-0.0668615326,
-0.3379420042,
-0.3641051948,
-0.9558508992,
0.5310640931,
0.2944034934,
-0.4857598543,
-0.5062737465,
0.0020268764,
-0.1664990932,
-0.2088749111,
-0.1348677576,
0.5385347009,
0.0874850377,
-0.4679130912,
0.3772181869,
0.1088691056,
0.3444777131,
-0.4642969072,
-0.3852143586,
-0.398665458,
0.0758452713,
-0.360889256,
-0.9877665043,
-0.0063528684,
-0.9716825485,
-0.4680158198,
-0.1336935759,
0.2811700404,
-0.2614096403,
-0.5085249543,
0.1582943946,
0.5984469652,
-0.6771264076,
0.1198480949,
-0.3789015114,
0.386192441,
-0.1040761247,
-0.0322736427,
0.1587762088,
0.1017812118,
0.4234120548,
0.3850920498,
0.3993881047,
0.0355622061,
-0.3019727767,
-0.2654303014,
1.1290531158,
-0.688536942,
-0.9525151849,
-0.8757343888,
0.3673138618,
0.0248161741,
-0.4749623537,
0.8065603375,
0.5203292966,
0.7213683128,
-0.0432467498,
0.74101758,
0.0580758229,
0.1335093081,
-0.9543339014,
0.1913621724,
-0.7296303511,
0.2961882949,
0.0544670634,
-1.1433006525,
-0.2626053095,
0.8024739623,
-0.6279867887,
0.2717101574,
0.7294781208,
0.4801139235,
-0.3217191994,
0.4016607404,
0.1062909514,
-0.4350697398,
0.4525111616,
0.7251728177,
0.8520002961,
0.2280556113,
-0.3276109099,
0.1395293027,
-0.3929012716,
-0.4631066024,
-0.717469573,
-0.4949284196,
-0.6510030627,
0.2641175985,
-0.1091158539,
0.3785170317,
1.2293732166,
0.9146940708,
-0.4102519453,
-0.0727377012,
0.1910625994,
0.3216394186,
-0.6586251855,
-0.193418473,
0.2305135429,
-0.2790509164,
-0.081535235,
0.8797900081,
0.3684788942,
-0.2959134579,
0.0527038239,
-0.0003159574,
-0.0912583768,
0.2223409712,
0.8671545386,
-0.0081964005,
-0.5306072831,
-0.2831469178,
-0.2406944931,
0.18632254,
0.0288427435,
0.8447876573,
-0.5291734338,
0.8290197253,
-0.0759211406,
0.3899526,
0.1311376244,
0.1056231409,
0.2049691379,
-0.8013161421,
-0.0186027419,
0.1739368737,
0.2302983254,
0.3260230124,
-0.3828489184,
0.383063674,
0.2923188806,
-0.7678462863,
-0.4029678106,
0.3883572817,
-1.0959687233,
-0.4641823471,
1.193675518,
0.1602976173,
-0.1905947179,
0.039983891,
-0.2357974052,
0.1303929836,
-0.7366838455,
1.0702632666,
0.683513701,
-0.4784484506,
0.2732827961,
-0.5033965111,
0.5801118016,
0.422306329,
-0.7941768765,
-0.2742148042,
0.7781125903,
0.3593632579,
0.2075559199,
0.5144016147,
0.3684473634,
0.1756784469,
-0.3229463995,
-0.2067165673,
-0.2971745431,
-0.8121039271,
0.4462066591,
0.4255479872,
-0.1804986447,
-0.2087229788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13713v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13713v1 | Benchmarking Open-Source Language Models for Efficient Question Answering in Industrial Applications | 2024-06-19T17:11:51 | 2024-06-19T17:11:51 | Mahaman Sanoussi Yahaya Alassan, Jessica López Espejel, Merieme Bouhandi, Walid Dahhane, El Hassane Ettifouri | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the rapidly evolving landscape of Natural Language Processing (NLP), Large
Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in tasks such
as question answering (QA). However, the accessibility and practicality of
utilizing these models for industrial applications pose significant challenges,
particularly concerning cost-effectiveness, inference speed, and resource
efficiency. This paper presents a comprehensive benchmarking study comparing
open-source LLMs with their non-open-source counterparts on the task of
question answering. Our objective is to identify open-source alternatives
capable of delivering comparable performance to proprietary models while being
lightweight in terms of resource requirements and suitable for Central
Processing Unit (CPU)-based inference. Through rigorous evaluation across
various metrics including accuracy, inference speed, and resource consumption,
we aim to provide insights into selecting efficient LLMs for real-world
applications. Our findings shed light on viable open-source alternatives that
offer acceptable performance and efficiency, addressing the pressing need for
accessible and efficient NLP solutions in industry settings. | [
-0.2313785404,
-0.6953780055,
0.7266262174,
0.131949693,
-0.0725042596,
-0.0990581438,
-0.3835877478,
-0.6536291242,
-0.3700737655,
0.4970777929,
-0.4949809015,
-0.566167891,
-0.0768455863,
0.1926583797,
-0.3105252385,
0.457149148,
-0.1572089642,
0.0174003541,
-0.6604211926,
-0.5134471059,
-0.2686788142,
-0.4820596874,
-0.6506942511,
-0.1240816489,
0.5067682862,
0.1932706237,
0.8203392625,
0.6837765574,
0.6447418928,
0.3078485429,
-0.0298419166,
-0.0909869373,
-0.2803711593,
0.3266208768,
-0.3147154748,
-0.4786502719,
-0.2668172419,
-0.1164000258,
0.6040765643,
0.7406427264,
-0.0478462875,
0.654001832,
-0.1634470969,
0.5719867945,
-0.9310028553,
0.0857039839,
-0.9238322973,
-0.0545361415,
-0.1228307113,
0.0835491866,
-0.3156402409,
-0.7065059543,
-0.0368861929,
-0.5722346902,
0.1532388031,
0.2278688997,
0.6113887429,
0.427906245,
0.1908491254,
-0.1573452801,
-0.9051558971,
0.9658158422,
-1.0142445564,
0.6873160601,
0.1269339919,
0.5711841583,
0.1406086683,
-0.9214650393,
-0.4320031404,
-0.2228615582,
0.0758828595,
0.0873792022,
-0.4956735969,
0.0402971357,
0.2707650065,
0.4948142469,
-0.7994454503,
0.3986110985,
-0.2703112662,
0.1036119312,
0.2097552419,
0.1590162814,
0.1922923326,
0.1129926443,
-0.2031499743,
0.0062968261,
-0.4554311633,
0.0370593891,
0.1537920684,
0.3452388048,
0.2405036837,
0.736600399,
-0.4775770903,
0.6782613397,
-0.6764603257,
-0.0112591833,
0.1612848788,
-0.1578210145,
-0.5177605152,
-0.2249234468,
0.7899419069,
0.2797042727,
0.0543712378,
-0.6262628436,
-0.2095119357,
-0.0608045198,
0.2776136696,
-0.7323016524,
0.0996009931,
0.4980243444,
-0.5013384819,
0.1301286519,
-0.2132459879,
-0.7592555285,
-0.3133771122,
-0.0636117831,
0.3686589301,
-0.1754163653,
-0.2775413692,
0.0676026642,
-0.4243378341,
0.5174844265,
0.1494796276,
-0.5445125699,
0.2122900337,
0.9658588171,
1.2089476585,
-0.0747537091,
0.0442770049,
-0.6924847364,
0.0139326937,
-0.3895119429,
0.7478904128,
-0.4832529426,
-0.17752029,
0.0136122843,
-0.2418887615,
-0.0334030241,
-1.049251318,
0.9472124577,
-0.6753308177,
-0.0590376295,
-0.2465886921,
-0.3683434129,
-0.1749784499,
0.1994853616,
-0.8554893136,
1.2317314148,
0.1795718968,
-0.7980696559,
0.0069035324,
-0.6353398561,
-0.0995476022,
0.2356008291,
-0.0740056336,
-0.2503297031,
0.3193443418,
-0.0186594296,
0.2461946458,
-0.7729608417,
0.0263895895,
-0.5883126855,
-0.3215466142,
0.2930668592,
-0.4796289206,
0.8012722731,
0.5192137957,
-0.0890882909,
0.2079530358,
-0.9061728716,
0.2295540869,
0.2326936275,
-0.2086649835,
-0.5518817902,
0.0914588869,
-0.1044197381,
0.1107730269,
0.299554795,
-0.7752223611,
-0.3231562674,
-0.3779845536,
0.2979242504,
0.5792102218,
-0.3002994061,
0.1780546755,
-0.3765652478,
0.668407917,
-0.352363348,
0.2110474259,
0.1127286106,
-0.4070846438,
-0.6836613417,
-0.282464385,
0.2164425254,
0.6305995584,
-0.8062081933,
0.0733404011,
-0.1071333289,
-0.695951283,
-1.0477287769,
0.1536087841,
0.3615874946,
0.7785127163,
0.4079995453,
-0.1075516194,
-0.4556804597,
-1.1938865185,
-0.7459358573,
-0.4492396116,
-0.61023736,
0.3759295344,
0.1084111258,
0.1466724277,
1.1675269604,
-0.6406881809,
0.2018926889,
-0.2240548432,
0.1171508208,
0.4062546194,
0.1175058335,
0.5431674123,
-0.4545913339,
-0.3469799757,
0.0383311547,
-0.7873181105,
-0.5334115028,
0.2410640568,
-0.2710326612,
0.2610917389,
0.5782552958,
-0.4202242494,
0.094895117,
0.7576829195,
0.1398416907,
0.6853849292,
-0.0590585917,
-0.0301877409,
-0.8563213944,
0.6333495378,
0.102629967,
-0.2445623577,
-0.6556347013,
0.3653894961,
0.2013063282,
-0.2451577336,
-0.821716845,
0.613827467,
-0.4833165407,
-0.4523130655,
-0.1847365946,
0.3189710677,
0.1605605334,
0.4411407709,
0.0489934161,
1.285804987,
0.1467770189,
-0.4217203856,
0.2303498238,
0.0105903316,
-0.6407630444,
0.2272591889,
-0.8935694695,
0.1552841663,
-0.0188216008,
-0.195809707,
-0.7637485266,
0.3123294711,
0.1711882204,
-0.0668449253,
-0.3480447531,
-0.0540820211,
-0.7907994986,
-0.3926520944,
-0.3451181054,
0.2053313404,
0.6901531816,
-0.5532466173,
0.4968072176,
0.1136918887,
-0.4211755097,
-0.4420031011,
-0.7152789831,
-0.0884090066,
-0.0842604265,
-0.5185710788,
-0.030706415,
-0.1734683514,
-0.5383663177,
0.1362676471,
-0.3588490188,
-0.3792557418,
0.3871548772,
-0.1271093786,
0.2188012898,
-0.6512804031,
0.1553377062,
-0.1572796553,
0.0615946203,
0.2299085557,
-0.1570095867,
0.3999682069,
-0.1253330559,
-0.4042756557,
-0.2314041555,
0.4276935756,
0.4907202721,
-0.6093094349,
0.9208781123,
0.2771020532,
-0.2448046952,
-0.4097525179,
-0.5981866717,
0.1080608815,
-0.5391178131,
0.3729667366,
-0.1244547442,
-0.7815247774,
0.4330822229,
-0.1991571337,
0.4512387812,
0.4501140416,
0.4064817429,
0.1261307448,
0.7110460401,
0.3174507916,
-0.0136852963,
0.4432143569,
0.1067581698,
0.250138551,
-0.8458760977,
0.0678472817,
-1.1874350309,
-0.1905077249,
-0.3843523562,
-0.752024591,
0.4037947953,
0.1618897617,
-0.2875657678,
0.1752426624,
-0.290525794,
0.5147494674,
0.7907446027,
-0.2678202391,
0.7139694691,
-0.3116408288,
-0.0096058957,
0.2984377742,
-0.7530244589,
-0.7533473969,
0.8957095146,
0.3932894766,
0.6837909222,
0.1814847291,
0.1702246368,
-0.0284933783,
0.2354100943,
-0.5392308831,
0.6695221663,
-0.2927366495,
-0.6649438739,
-0.3606847227,
-0.580278933,
-0.6958326697,
0.3609372079,
-0.1344948709,
-0.6650466323,
-0.0130407354,
0.0390602686,
-0.2045117617,
0.6662655473,
-0.8088508844,
1.0930738449,
-0.3307364285,
-0.3799910247,
-0.0576714426,
-0.2824490368,
0.3265599012,
-0.0741121769,
0.0825247467,
-0.378016144,
-0.2605551481,
0.4232361913,
-0.2670031786,
0.5258416533,
-0.1212931275,
-0.1731367856,
0.2991460264,
-0.0891462564,
0.3156157434,
-0.1188523695,
-0.670983851,
0.5098070502,
-0.0189868547,
-0.2943056524,
-0.5987919569,
0.6677104235,
-0.5771733522,
-0.4883331656,
-0.3832736909,
-0.4886615276,
-0.504876554,
0.3719472587,
-0.0478332154,
0.3664723337,
-0.3971735537,
0.4436294734,
0.6454436779,
-0.6375102401,
0.5973563194,
0.6479501724,
-0.1433758289,
-0.200889349,
0.6247583628,
0.0479443856,
0.5428130627,
0.5172919035,
0.1281714588,
-0.4818739891,
-0.7830391526,
-0.668648839,
0.1962237805,
-0.6297691464,
-0.1972857416,
-0.8573744893,
-0.1923101991,
-0.2730099261,
0.0029616728,
-0.4676566124,
-0.4571741223,
-0.1448903829,
0.0558964424,
0.3750523627,
0.3889205754,
0.3308947384,
0.0749747232,
-0.8348014355,
0.5404823422,
0.3719582558,
1.1229586601,
0.3070794344,
-0.0421360917,
-0.3706682622,
-0.0024709252,
-0.325630188,
-0.5928863883,
0.0452665128,
0.1232720464,
0.7311289907,
0.1582473814,
0.4988237321,
0.3505181968,
-0.4903941453,
0.7873824835,
-0.1184146106,
-0.7985989451,
0.2084658891,
-0.1963451505,
0.6028184891,
0.7451268435,
0.516387701,
-0.6605427861,
-0.6307852268,
-0.131174162,
-1.058131218,
0.7361780405,
0.2674052417,
-0.2252030224,
-0.0150326323,
0.1366886199,
0.3016108274,
0.3970034122,
-0.394097507,
-0.182121858,
0.0412712954,
-0.2549864948,
-0.2194803506,
0.0398895815,
0.0974592492,
0.1469805986,
0.8040358424,
-0.1253561527,
0.1924685091,
0.1093934774,
-0.2068339586,
-0.049105119,
0.4787474573,
0.3038507402,
0.6334974766,
-0.5233751535,
-0.0123552196,
0.2975200713,
-0.2146104574,
-0.1770349145,
0.0706272051,
-0.2806889713,
0.2045925409,
0.1735955328,
0.7772753239,
0.0314695127,
-1.2686499357,
0.2514670789,
-0.2325312644,
-0.0318300687,
-0.2056353092,
0.1588739157,
0.4774118066,
0.3732723296,
0.2924002111,
-0.2869608402,
0.3851568997,
-0.545537293,
-0.2000824809,
0.5644367933,
-0.1221828461,
-0.0052431496,
0.9715374708,
0.1501919925,
-0.4686650336,
0.5481755733,
0.180923745,
-0.0854881108,
0.5356855989,
0.2685487568,
1.335693121,
0.1516418159,
0.0316992402,
0.2074242383,
0.3566949069,
-0.0378232934,
0.2721919417,
0.0213665087,
-0.4149100482,
-0.6181052923,
-0.7830284834,
-1.0413761139,
0.172440052,
-0.6979967952,
-0.0001496044,
-0.498457104,
-0.0287413169,
-0.0894368514,
-0.1443078667,
-0.6432281733,
0.125344187,
0.0781020075,
1.2785609961,
-0.6599095464,
0.6756113172,
0.6202728748,
-0.3425157964,
-0.5311582088,
0.0081496798,
-0.3900354505,
-0.4965348542,
0.1323424578,
0.1619992405,
-0.3113709986,
-0.1282630712,
-0.2580478787,
-0.7177074552,
1.0718232393,
0.6420131326,
-0.5594699383,
-0.0610026382,
0.4056787193,
0.7387535572,
0.0467120148,
0.5498574376,
0.5279482603,
0.3054579198,
-0.197981447,
-0.908579886,
-0.0254007801,
-0.3378360271,
0.1501865089,
0.2809416056,
-0.7884793282,
0.6378306746,
0.3076500595,
-0.3219144046,
0.2402991951,
0.7499958277,
0.2474182397,
0.5665510893,
0.48892501,
0.4707109034,
0.5953671336,
0.0465386882,
0.9903479815,
-0.3813190758,
0.0533891805,
1.1960867643,
-0.5646836162,
1.2639294863,
0.2949559987,
-0.2680370212,
0.4466388822,
0.3006268442,
0.2186088562,
0.3116796613,
0.1008053347,
-0.3201732039,
-0.0579075627,
-0.2190537453,
-0.3090470433,
0.3001668453,
-0.1410467476,
-0.1647151262,
-0.3588334322,
-0.3558281064,
-0.1742409021,
0.168876335,
-0.3148195446,
0.8896959424,
0.046643775,
-0.6902806163,
0.5720053315,
0.1237417012,
0.5282000899,
-0.7688783407,
0.1431760043,
-0.3010207713,
0.0912808254,
0.1176473871,
-0.6331185699,
0.6091011167,
0.4461523294,
-0.2047623843,
-0.3941730261,
0.4777848125,
-0.1585669369,
-0.3622029722,
0.4346012473,
0.5447075367,
0.1149012372,
-0.2145207375,
-0.5494674444,
0.1478628665,
-0.3645416796,
-0.1679903716,
0.3246848285,
0.3733029366,
0.0345831849,
0.8115603924,
0.5704583526,
0.1367562562,
0.2192531973,
-0.0279549826,
0.7780920863,
-0.6321614385,
-0.3921770453,
-0.5124213099,
0.365450263,
-0.0771077424,
-0.1780529916,
0.79977566,
0.90949893,
0.9515932202,
-0.1002998278,
0.8650853634,
0.1669578254,
0.9484376311,
-0.5416914821,
0.5996357799,
-0.663267374,
0.2737231255,
-0.3160708249,
-1.045676589,
-0.1519025117,
0.1637683809,
-0.2219095528,
-0.1164824143,
0.6206002235,
0.7754284143,
-0.1326730698,
0.1606642902,
0.317725569,
0.2410544604,
0.2583999932,
0.4398362041,
0.6401119828,
-0.0871176049,
0.7070612311,
-0.2645287216,
-0.093645677,
-0.1984704435,
-1.2106910944,
-0.5657939315,
-0.3221664727,
-0.1353686154,
-0.0586528555,
0.0795648843,
0.9649107456,
0.3599351943,
-0.8014698625,
-0.4042783976,
0.0901828408,
0.0744525865,
-0.578245759,
-0.1535650939,
0.2010167986,
-0.2699852884,
-0.8319209814,
0.5286133289,
0.271055907,
-0.407338202,
-0.2927405238,
0.2175066471,
-0.2243568748,
0.4118142128,
0.6166185737,
0.4954882562,
-0.5164317489,
-0.0983664393,
0.3091954291,
0.0428067558,
0.1726854146,
0.8440256119,
-0.6056504846,
0.3807807267,
0.8257662058,
1.1189415455,
0.1743287146,
0.2043070197,
0.6453900933,
-0.6608803272,
0.0632230118,
0.3925150633,
0.1619734317,
0.3566758633,
0.0625564381,
0.620108664,
-0.045704674,
-0.5878067613,
-0.9919662476,
0.121779874,
-0.7596848607,
-0.6155065298,
1.0004996061,
-0.0761552081,
-0.4089251757,
-0.1977192014,
-0.0178306624,
0.2429269552,
-0.2548256516,
0.5102382302,
0.4457371533,
0.0150270527,
-0.0990101323,
-0.9565714002,
0.0674354136,
0.3630843759,
-0.897170186,
0.3737949133,
0.5206719637,
0.1247621775,
-0.1952642947,
0.6669143438,
-0.0331369229,
0.1774364412,
-0.0905105844,
0.3469404876,
-0.07930962,
-0.1047787964,
-0.3794022202,
0.470975697,
0.5877892971,
-0.2866022587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13706v1 | Breaking News: Case Studies of Generative AI's Use in Journalism | 2024-06-19T16:58:32 | 2024-06-19T16:58:32 | Natalie Grace Brigham, Chongjiu Gao, Tadayoshi Kohno, Franziska Roesner, Niloofar Mireshghallah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Journalists are among the many users of large language models (LLMs). To
better understand the journalist-AI interactions, we conduct a study of LLM
usage by two news agencies through browsing the WildChat dataset, identifying
candidate interactions, and verifying them by matching to online published
articles. Our analysis uncovers instances where journalists provide sensitive
material such as confidential correspondence with sources or articles from
other agencies to the LLM as stimuli and prompt it to generate articles, and
publish these machine-generated articles with limited intervention (median
output-publication ROUGE-L of 0.62). Based on our findings, we call for further
research into what constitutes responsible use of AI, and the establishment of
clear guidelines and best practices on using LLMs in a journalistic context. | [
-0.0741451979,
-0.7905422449,
0.6417839527,
0.4151305258,
-0.2212739587,
-0.0746432245,
-0.2206148803,
-0.7244877219,
0.0819316432,
0.5618484616,
-0.4716145992,
-0.3822035193,
-0.5034756064,
0.3563297987,
-0.9595245123,
1.1191427708,
-0.111759536,
0.1650577337,
-0.3044772148,
-0.2686375082,
-0.2898766696,
-0.6359081864,
-0.4904107749,
-0.2059202641,
0.840688169,
0.209109202,
0.8219180107,
0.4867013097,
0.6288141608,
0.3225392103,
-0.1568131298,
0.0618324168,
-0.5899333358,
0.1035884023,
-0.1442994922,
-0.543574214,
-0.1439141631,
0.3237659335,
0.3867240846,
0.4311871827,
0.0356084667,
0.2587447762,
-0.1603608131,
0.6021963954,
-0.3317630291,
-0.0594852753,
-0.378844142,
0.195294261,
-0.2863044143,
-0.1651046127,
-0.4217429757,
-0.4071530402,
-0.2145159096,
-0.5492640138,
0.2669759691,
-0.1816518754,
0.7931956053,
0.3513164818,
-0.6937659979,
-0.4935040474,
-1.0165231228,
0.3383260667,
-0.6825234294,
0.1388071775,
0.5883443952,
0.0727342144,
-0.0411764532,
-0.6704699397,
-0.6303054094,
-0.3561047614,
-0.1760429591,
0.1720443517,
-0.2079296261,
-0.0119213192,
0.3386485875,
0.2891044915,
-0.4669351876,
0.4709461331,
-0.6756680012,
0.0151081467,
0.8854380846,
0.2364005595,
0.3291031122,
0.0334028676,
-0.0506104156,
0.1325570047,
-0.903291285,
-0.3280138969,
0.6526192427,
0.0617676005,
-0.2516616285,
0.8635091782,
-0.0449854247,
0.7041795254,
-0.2980433702,
0.0919113904,
0.2977564037,
-0.459163785,
-0.2310929,
0.0332498029,
0.8385081291,
0.5526227355,
0.4169783294,
-0.0473128706,
-0.1817773879,
-0.0147196567,
0.5190653205,
-0.6071527004,
0.1133916751,
-0.021728985,
-0.4077225924,
-0.7546420097,
-0.0073609324,
-0.6049910188,
-0.5917421579,
-0.2588504553,
0.0403628759,
0.1998463422,
-0.2922593951,
-0.142285347,
-0.3055710196,
0.3153367937,
0.0845751986,
-0.5703744292,
-0.1038076952,
0.4974179864,
0.70749861,
0.0187195744,
-0.3583327532,
-0.4378056228,
0.2286630273,
-0.6200166941,
0.6312077641,
-0.264510721,
-0.3052748442,
0.5002235174,
-0.3026863635,
0.3228186965,
-0.5922691226,
0.5240327716,
-0.6821737885,
-0.0122744404,
-0.0498503745,
-0.4089919627,
0.1781262159,
0.2336026877,
-0.8786594868,
0.7402496934,
0.0230626892,
-0.6305146217,
0.5360180736,
-0.4180586338,
-0.6282714605,
0.0280325972,
-0.2883444428,
-0.611569345,
0.3051715791,
0.1278358698,
0.5043073893,
0.0888465568,
0.4744822383,
0.046325244,
-0.2561523914,
0.6339093447,
-0.5824699402,
0.5978605151,
0.1666150391,
-0.0589057244,
0.2537433803,
-0.5299196839,
-0.6739251614,
0.1323134154,
-0.6794258952,
-0.3858417273,
-0.1309281439,
0.2229118198,
0.0359084718,
-0.1694214493,
-0.3004873693,
0.2033890933,
0.0404592417,
0.503418386,
0.5368313193,
0.0327864848,
0.3795142174,
-0.4779906869,
0.4641193449,
0.009133813,
0.0567634106,
-0.4578483403,
-0.3081054688,
-0.7502401471,
-0.0802673623,
0.2690207362,
0.3342245519,
-0.657869935,
0.1171862632,
0.1008666158,
-0.3878027797,
-0.6267412901,
0.1559865177,
0.0405665115,
0.2854498923,
-0.05467638,
0.0716393888,
-0.4843657911,
-0.8049706221,
-0.5750312209,
-0.0983819887,
-0.0031146242,
0.4405995607,
0.1119199544,
-0.3668071032,
1.1169558764,
-0.0093812151,
-0.1875972003,
-0.2890863121,
0.537129283,
0.0977207273,
0.2208515406,
0.6415299773,
-1.1020320654,
-0.3577922881,
-0.5012562275,
-1.154471755,
-0.2636602223,
-0.6835345626,
0.0868546665,
0.4212333858,
0.9124597311,
-0.9269487858,
0.6624912024,
0.6005579829,
-0.3728770912,
0.5081884861,
0.0859964043,
0.0152350217,
-0.8390197754,
-0.0457934923,
0.2452838719,
-0.5354623199,
-0.73806566,
0.1538228393,
-0.1014871076,
-0.2656646967,
-0.6161693335,
0.2967952192,
-0.6691132188,
-0.1250088364,
-0.369401902,
0.1638177037,
-0.1861581355,
-0.1283538043,
-0.0104015628,
0.8197395205,
0.4090676606,
-0.4230232537,
0.4525801241,
0.2701000869,
-0.4504343867,
0.1593750566,
-0.5566728711,
0.2636071444,
-0.3056469262,
0.2676390707,
-0.5633818507,
-0.267678231,
0.1552975625,
-0.3436282873,
0.0858191326,
0.0383786596,
-0.9381517768,
-0.2708185315,
-0.2623220384,
0.41777426,
0.3622374833,
-0.3442775011,
0.4254279733,
0.4706999063,
-0.3991559446,
-0.2044839859,
-1.1580096483,
0.6201749444,
-0.3417963088,
-0.3961435556,
-0.0339383967,
0.0236778185,
-0.5146601796,
0.2276476622,
0.137061581,
-0.0772400349,
0.211326614,
0.1878767461,
0.2619170845,
-0.2230629474,
0.078386113,
-0.0605024174,
0.1313507706,
0.286475271,
0.5840010643,
0.5054579973,
0.1717646718,
-0.2676512301,
-0.541901648,
0.6608019471,
0.572268784,
-0.1481347382,
0.7671387196,
0.557005167,
-0.1159632653,
-0.0759452954,
-0.497284472,
-0.355245769,
-0.458640486,
0.4095790982,
0.2536562085,
-0.874160409,
0.3252881467,
-0.0461517684,
0.0172588695,
0.4105146527,
0.7235956192,
-0.0271340683,
0.8168683648,
0.869299233,
-0.6285161972,
0.5746364594,
-0.0192466192,
0.3323488533,
-0.3940605521,
-0.3351997435,
-0.4590879083,
-0.1185050607,
-0.7740033865,
-0.053305313,
0.3901548088,
-0.0137463305,
0.0460392572,
0.052594699,
-0.2787199616,
0.5526766181,
0.5442641973,
-0.2198640853,
0.5729961395,
-0.1568250358,
0.4094345868,
0.3274579346,
-0.6405053139,
-0.5333842039,
0.8226453066,
0.433701694,
1.0569154024,
0.0504502766,
0.6663630605,
0.5864752531,
0.6752874851,
-0.892634213,
0.5413948894,
0.1901077479,
-0.6417154074,
-0.1561424732,
-0.4121179283,
-0.9333959818,
-0.0190696493,
-0.1751575917,
-0.3694082201,
-0.0517285839,
-0.1197314635,
-0.1886026859,
-0.0056351149,
-0.4277038574,
0.2813511789,
-0.1885289103,
-0.0000423627,
-0.425101757,
-0.5247142315,
0.4590853751,
0.0089026112,
0.3288238645,
-0.0154010495,
0.0889628604,
0.5403667688,
-0.0288780294,
1.183513999,
0.2487157881,
-0.113499999,
0.3070282638,
-0.1896911114,
0.4707429409,
0.2526108921,
0.0808022246,
0.3676194549,
-0.3993042111,
-0.0324314609,
-0.0336032547,
0.4967046678,
-0.9177589417,
-0.8051353097,
-0.8427416086,
-0.9050164223,
-0.037260104,
0.2412154078,
0.322562784,
0.1940570921,
-0.3783594072,
0.2668224871,
0.3076008558,
0.0584244132,
0.6047642827,
0.7090108991,
-0.2155990154,
0.0125068417,
0.6094760895,
0.2026391625,
-0.0933267102,
-0.0197035689,
0.0953148007,
0.2706321478,
-0.5624224544,
-0.5418918133,
0.2845348418,
-0.3533708751,
-0.4041823149,
-0.4101799428,
-0.66696769,
-0.3275111318,
-0.1852684617,
-0.0266379789,
-0.1329834908,
-0.6187824607,
-0.3817570508,
0.2850016654,
0.8931467533,
-0.0708446726,
0.2694928348,
-0.9510351419,
0.5115243793,
0.1919585019,
-0.0003973118,
-0.40256387,
-0.0201712158,
-0.40759027,
-0.0323955566,
-0.3083896637,
-1.0660805702,
0.3679274321,
-0.0116729485,
0.6436597109,
0.350476414,
0.125444144,
0.0028608507,
-0.4725354612,
0.9302277565,
-0.1228657439,
-0.6975969672,
0.3764823079,
-0.7488793135,
0.1240939796,
0.4032085538,
0.5113925934,
-0.5413444042,
-0.8642004132,
-0.5524117351,
-0.959898293,
0.4325846434,
0.1836087257,
0.7281436324,
0.0451650545,
0.4293547273,
-0.0038388802,
0.5960175395,
-0.78458637,
-0.1863612533,
0.0610902607,
-0.1920840144,
0.0811504051,
-0.6793830991,
-0.4492072761,
0.0317679942,
0.4834879041,
0.030936582,
0.115914613,
0.1496209651,
-0.1529567689,
-0.2673371732,
0.0596250743,
0.5428861976,
0.7973102927,
0.2860213816,
0.117473945,
-0.3073005378,
-0.4242455661,
-0.0986617655,
0.18655321,
-0.4292497635,
0.1770792156,
0.4718393385,
0.533377111,
-0.2593453228,
-0.8722061515,
0.6579371691,
-0.0501995124,
-0.1771515161,
-0.6188933849,
0.0272101797,
0.1397645473,
0.4165513515,
0.4318586588,
-0.1175960451,
0.2754757702,
-0.8936622739,
0.1018010378,
0.3708620369,
-0.0893222243,
-0.1899161339,
0.4283154905,
0.4009370208,
-0.3987232745,
0.940828383,
-0.0146431839,
-0.3899708092,
0.7746328712,
0.5282633305,
0.652905941,
-0.0219511073,
0.5343779325,
-0.3150700927,
0.4251835942,
-0.1265985966,
0.1037643626,
0.1773957759,
-0.8966681957,
-0.3870361745,
-0.1417788416,
-0.4286080003,
0.3436719477,
-0.7214649916,
0.1549559087,
-0.2563023567,
-0.1122298017,
0.1884639114,
-0.2040754706,
-0.6562305689,
-0.0414217338,
0.4076251388,
0.8695676923,
-1.1554169655,
0.5351698399,
0.5302240849,
-0.5914621353,
-0.54129076,
0.3403065205,
0.3004479706,
-0.7811249495,
0.3408922553,
0.161729604,
0.2994116545,
-0.2695134282,
-0.7929382324,
-0.3241224885,
0.8928198814,
0.4880586267,
-0.637503624,
0.053767208,
0.4800094068,
0.5578627586,
-0.2563161254,
-0.0006637187,
0.6126019955,
0.44114995,
-0.2337376177,
-0.7417929173,
0.0080309119,
-0.2090506852,
-0.17500633,
0.0224148557,
-1.1452455521,
0.6680702567,
-0.2505308688,
-0.0522516072,
0.1704836041,
0.6899518967,
0.0704260916,
0.7449021339,
0.1983913332,
0.3998236656,
0.5870605707,
0.2817954719,
1.0568600893,
0.0086094197,
0.0996749327,
0.8768222332,
-0.2632304728,
0.4299284518,
0.4987279773,
0.244248718,
0.3032648861,
0.5514820814,
-0.5252235532,
0.5617988706,
0.2970040739,
-0.4482349455,
0.1876900047,
-0.5857218504,
-0.1279065013,
0.4580140412,
0.2580384314,
-0.6581117511,
-0.0865162238,
0.1847759485,
0.3680027425,
0.1171943024,
-0.3607804179,
1.0576443672,
0.2637028694,
-0.3636615872,
-0.0626195818,
0.1965200007,
0.4001009166,
-0.2123245448,
-0.0592673421,
-0.3454452157,
-0.1752842963,
-0.2532274127,
-0.8212949038,
0.601544261,
0.4253258705,
-0.2646284401,
-0.2038089931,
0.8206428885,
-0.4935734868,
-0.5929062963,
0.0408054702,
0.6864739656,
0.195194304,
-0.1118341461,
-0.2393671423,
0.3761461675,
-0.3460200727,
-0.5461233854,
0.4400564134,
0.3644709587,
-0.0982809141,
0.3950171471,
0.6447732449,
0.3473058641,
-0.0715490058,
0.4671142101,
1.2072341442,
-0.5445831418,
-0.2829712927,
-0.947208643,
0.3005750477,
-0.2660871148,
-0.4493363202,
0.7554773092,
0.6603016257,
0.7242817283,
0.1419256777,
1.0734984875,
0.0976320058,
0.1300319135,
-0.684922576,
0.8566066027,
-0.0968635976,
0.0974577442,
0.1487505436,
-0.783937037,
-0.3158444762,
0.3581460118,
0.0033490299,
0.0115514323,
0.3615581989,
0.6727882624,
0.1454002112,
0.0144292684,
0.338881731,
0.3467952013,
0.3050015271,
-0.0310961809,
0.9956257343,
0.0942178965,
0.4591325223,
-0.0691872388,
-0.180108726,
-0.3396173418,
-0.9436516762,
-1.1078140736,
-0.3625953197,
-0.2673564851,
-0.1011920124,
0.3120508492,
0.5768063068,
0.4971613288,
-0.2780835927,
-0.0314427763,
-0.196870178,
0.065200232,
-0.0873248726,
-0.2465290874,
0.0850651562,
-0.2656083107,
-0.6735724807,
0.4044838548,
-0.0733842254,
-0.0413168147,
-0.5772286654,
0.2681160271,
-0.0293731987,
0.2353159338,
0.4767616689,
0.2228883952,
-0.2937620878,
-0.1899830401,
-0.1797706187,
-0.2883533835,
-0.0494885854,
1.2155095339,
-0.6410998106,
0.0223130323,
0.4143991768,
0.7391138673,
0.7224630117,
0.0179316625,
0.5660629869,
-0.7547066808,
0.2831716239,
0.4749486744,
0.0608593486,
0.5089490414,
-0.7870288491,
0.3955116868,
0.0986229256,
-0.7649385929,
-0.9294340014,
0.019028388,
-0.678709805,
-0.1566406637,
1.4140874147,
0.0144997099,
-0.0240709689,
0.0247317031,
-0.0275497772,
0.2712365091,
-0.5553321838,
0.971122086,
0.6089962125,
-0.1273287982,
-0.5172569156,
-0.9405270815,
0.376476258,
-0.0258402526,
-0.8976812363,
-0.1176914796,
0.6663211584,
0.1670039147,
-0.0345605426,
0.5993767977,
0.0367738307,
0.066426456,
-0.0779704377,
-0.2676880062,
-0.2956605256,
-0.4732698798,
-0.2883017957,
-0.1265515685,
0.01904287,
-0.0116195157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13698v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13698v1 | MMTE: Corpus and Metrics for Evaluating Machine Translation Quality of Metaphorical Language | 2024-06-19T16:52:22 | 2024-06-19T16:52:22 | Shun Wang, Ge Zhang, Han Wu, Tyler Loakman, Wenhao Huang, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine Translation (MT) has developed rapidly since the release of Large
Language Models and current MT evaluation is performed through comparison with
reference human translations or by predicting quality scores from human-labeled
data. However, these mainstream evaluation methods mainly focus on fluency and
factual reliability, whilst paying little attention to figurative quality. In
this paper, we investigate the figurative quality of MT and propose a set of
human evaluation metrics focused on the translation of figurative language. We
additionally present a multilingual parallel metaphor corpus generated by
post-editing. Our evaluation protocol is designed to estimate four aspects of
MT: Metaphorical Equivalence, Emotion, Authenticity, and Quality. In doing so,
we observe that translations of figurative expressions display different traits
from literal ones. | [
-0.2747419775,
-0.5002626181,
0.5307166576,
0.4707519412,
-0.5438899994,
0.3445224166,
-0.1971610785,
-0.587967217,
0.4455292821,
0.184644416,
-0.431332171,
-0.4561906159,
-0.8863089085,
0.5847210288,
-0.4294390678,
0.9012876749,
-0.1626106203,
0.1983575821,
-0.233009547,
-0.4812454581,
-0.6673701406,
-0.6287827492,
-0.5333066583,
-0.0541249588,
0.6378829479,
-0.1182929277,
1.2877572775,
0.7977551818,
0.7285328507,
0.4101997018,
0.3521698117,
0.2619466484,
-0.252088964,
-0.212370187,
-0.1784952432,
-0.4728967845,
-0.563215971,
0.5631799698,
0.9568144679,
0.5166463852,
0.0611223169,
0.2977410853,
-0.0270149577,
0.4958606064,
-0.3574594557,
0.1456325948,
-0.6398903728,
0.0830969289,
-0.1687705964,
-0.5391262174,
-0.4367899001,
-0.4195955694,
-0.2682997584,
-0.5033069849,
0.0100671677,
0.2524107695,
1.0815246105,
0.582891047,
-0.4362952411,
-0.2104056627,
-0.331715852,
1.1039017439,
-0.5637361407,
0.5458930135,
0.3520523608,
0.5875811577,
0.1671439856,
-0.7490034699,
-0.5591114163,
-0.5764171481,
-0.4144628346,
0.3908824921,
-0.3207035363,
-0.2854426503,
-0.033491943,
0.3636976779,
-0.6290645003,
-0.0734365433,
-0.2428912073,
-0.3811521232,
0.5007040501,
0.404918015,
0.5790886283,
-0.2655344307,
-0.5378582478,
-0.2025721222,
-0.5201301575,
-0.3835941255,
0.4686971009,
-0.0706453025,
-0.1204901934,
0.6877114773,
0.1303739101,
0.6518939137,
-0.6513006091,
-0.3936105072,
0.6800473332,
-0.569291532,
-0.2559650242,
-0.0699765235,
0.9612032175,
0.7022775412,
0.1762025803,
-0.4536482394,
-0.484849304,
0.5523740649,
0.4338654876,
-0.7618188858,
0.3137982488,
0.1229411811,
-0.6140148044,
-0.4124551117,
0.1101387367,
-0.4283536375,
-0.1254186183,
-0.6083931923,
0.3924772739,
-0.667501092,
-0.0657877475,
0.1819907874,
-0.2360617369,
-0.311560899,
0.4048075378,
-0.2437373102,
0.0628359467,
0.5310791731,
1.0177912712,
-0.2301331908,
-0.7310000658,
-0.4866899848,
0.0341084115,
-0.3910964429,
0.6239208579,
-0.3817826807,
-0.0337813646,
-0.3150281608,
-0.1203895435,
-0.4270982146,
-0.4475274682,
1.066480279,
-0.4241343737,
0.2006560415,
-0.1259306818,
-0.3678635061,
-0.229778111,
0.4002167583,
-0.6386476755,
0.8342319131,
0.2525069118,
-0.9369419217,
0.2624696195,
-0.7374373674,
-0.1939456165,
-0.0898321643,
-0.0472269282,
0.1663888246,
0.3957581818,
0.0495900996,
0.3826884925,
-0.6908672452,
0.2739420533,
-0.033883363,
-0.3237172067,
0.6734098196,
-0.4534089863,
0.6296602488,
0.6263722777,
0.0282754265,
0.3854330182,
-0.4654668272,
0.069218263,
0.0635818318,
0.0055090999,
-0.2661717534,
-0.2593814135,
0.422798574,
0.7100721598,
0.3195101917,
-0.5778764486,
-0.2691013813,
-0.3082585633,
0.5882393122,
0.4443060756,
-0.1953146756,
0.0259078424,
-0.375394851,
0.5729852915,
0.1341926008,
0.0814907998,
0.0463678837,
-0.4761935174,
-0.513330698,
-0.5841712952,
0.7416582704,
0.6022515297,
-0.7764644027,
0.4446314573,
-0.6165248752,
-0.6071379185,
-1.0141862631,
-0.090148069,
0.5863665938,
0.4075784385,
0.4228351116,
-0.5334112048,
-0.2285435945,
-1.13540411,
-0.4198262095,
-0.2325936556,
-0.2154271603,
-0.0103786364,
0.4722502232,
-0.3968505859,
0.6273957491,
-0.1906367689,
-0.281950742,
0.0481870659,
0.6112855077,
0.0051691299,
0.5138634443,
0.9496365786,
-0.6057869196,
-0.1014413983,
-0.0326343812,
-1.057357192,
-0.2019874156,
-0.2659246325,
-0.4442831278,
0.0163104925,
0.2606223226,
-0.8095312715,
0.0510706641,
0.8199369311,
-0.3610946536,
0.9890064597,
-0.1739821434,
0.7795093656,
-1.1409885883,
0.082803376,
-0.0039080488,
-0.2459886074,
-0.2120177001,
0.4022007883,
0.0287481882,
0.0689831153,
-0.7096014023,
0.6816345453,
-0.2879361212,
-0.2417183816,
-0.096972242,
0.3721289635,
0.0236784797,
-0.0720637068,
-0.0589489341,
1.0193583965,
0.2070604265,
-0.1444853097,
0.3543074727,
0.0448490605,
-0.2690609097,
1.0298702717,
-0.615737617,
0.021181874,
0.0275573842,
0.0902020857,
-0.746093452,
-0.0583974905,
0.1312234849,
-0.7064467072,
0.1755326539,
0.2506527305,
-1.3216381073,
-0.2051026821,
-0.1401099712,
0.4615706801,
0.4410768449,
-0.1802186966,
0.1816065311,
0.1844310313,
0.192862466,
-0.5681878924,
-0.7088597417,
0.5367158651,
-0.3588681817,
-0.8940706253,
0.3145055473,
-0.2040355504,
-0.1628031582,
0.0941921845,
0.0280359089,
-0.2499215305,
0.0279134288,
-0.0965109169,
0.0871060193,
-0.4638862312,
-0.0923492983,
0.2701160908,
-0.4472063482,
0.1956622005,
-0.0386386067,
0.3449499905,
-0.4525316656,
-0.2894921601,
-0.6083039045,
0.2073711902,
0.9893188477,
-0.3366255164,
0.8874201775,
0.9836868048,
-0.5988993049,
0.5754851103,
-0.6326941848,
-0.1864867806,
-0.343161881,
0.2600253522,
-0.8067745566,
-0.746440649,
0.4498486221,
-0.0719125345,
-0.0940199643,
0.8059291244,
0.6129774451,
-0.1731521636,
0.9745216966,
0.3043356836,
0.0336756893,
-0.0630608276,
0.2385667562,
-0.0221868567,
-0.6480494738,
0.1668571085,
-0.7084590197,
-0.4702588618,
-0.4593157172,
-0.712530911,
0.2005119324,
0.3176962733,
-0.0597019531,
0.6704300046,
-0.2608505785,
0.2659789622,
0.3014011383,
-0.1378746331,
0.5948759317,
0.0533860624,
-0.3708057404,
-0.5901688337,
-0.4122385681,
-1.1276466846,
0.7151090503,
0.5341243148,
0.0337558053,
0.0942452475,
0.4343777597,
0.3124312758,
0.7771170735,
-0.6658283472,
0.4229060411,
0.0437700488,
-0.6313404441,
-0.0850175545,
-0.7093798518,
-0.8049893379,
0.5902517438,
-0.2859337926,
-0.7291610241,
-0.3071359694,
-0.0228365473,
0.2067012489,
0.0876304656,
-0.6259378791,
1.3110380173,
-0.3562713265,
0.0410398617,
-0.6685307622,
-0.8653361797,
0.5474151373,
-0.3265551031,
0.3071887791,
-0.3686593175,
-0.393730104,
0.6352993846,
-0.1418945044,
0.352474004,
0.2133919746,
0.2806173265,
0.1592848301,
0.4395179152,
0.1468595713,
-0.0542178527,
-0.3111156523,
0.6196506619,
0.4235869348,
-0.5460850596,
-0.7653329372,
0.5950253606,
-0.866663456,
-0.1366402209,
-0.4049179554,
-0.8400657177,
-0.2961308956,
0.2054042071,
0.2473028898,
-0.0051658372,
-0.3909250796,
0.0529320762,
-0.1219901592,
-0.3379994929,
0.1825760454,
0.215329051,
-0.026434714,
-0.5460025072,
0.9934408665,
0.0341535397,
0.2835178375,
0.3640853465,
0.2135581672,
-0.6130590439,
-0.2699139714,
-1.0086675882,
0.5321313739,
-0.6707848907,
-0.3215349019,
-0.6538124681,
-0.1420693547,
0.1287771612,
-0.1915512234,
-0.6364955306,
-0.4623675644,
-0.0467340685,
-0.0363677517,
0.1660580188,
0.3034772575,
0.2162631154,
0.3402861059,
-1.0566483736,
0.2199733406,
-0.4013462365,
0.1422136426,
-0.3307233453,
-0.6129611135,
-0.2013817281,
0.1520601511,
-0.2350820303,
-0.9489483237,
0.5476728678,
-0.1528124511,
0.4160128534,
0.3635428846,
-0.1569249183,
0.6916360855,
-0.7158147693,
0.6308009624,
0.6550836563,
-1.0453236103,
0.2232893109,
-0.3385879993,
-0.152347818,
0.5373311639,
0.4331787527,
-0.652115643,
-0.6220828891,
-0.6983705759,
-0.2396551222,
0.3178600073,
0.7056990862,
0.2871349454,
-0.113321133,
0.0002425324,
0.1557477713,
0.6432811618,
-0.5130437016,
-0.2822602391,
-0.364612937,
-0.2961994112,
-0.4447826147,
-0.1123880818,
-0.1824164838,
-0.2735978961,
0.2328235805,
0.1390972584,
0.3823249936,
-0.1677686274,
-0.4508269429,
0.166084826,
0.3475131094,
0.7177048922,
0.883474648,
-0.2751089931,
0.2518086731,
0.0800642595,
-0.2995530069,
0.126508683,
-0.0648911074,
0.0202515032,
0.4398823977,
0.1926398724,
0.4748039544,
0.0967891961,
-0.6183397174,
0.4762835801,
0.1520489752,
0.0412829295,
-0.0746418312,
-0.4428674877,
0.199518308,
-0.0693730712,
-0.0509070009,
0.3231589198,
0.3564974368,
-0.4099519551,
0.1581103653,
0.13235946,
-0.5679510236,
-0.459246695,
0.7406089306,
0.0830966681,
-0.1114144176,
0.6208580136,
-0.4162340164,
-0.2796114981,
0.3294796944,
0.6296989322,
0.8712432981,
-0.317969501,
0.2099995464,
0.4231873453,
1.0028283596,
0.1202624962,
0.1371731609,
0.5623989105,
-0.5767604709,
-0.6290665865,
-0.9573513865,
-0.1756681502,
-0.1078087911,
-0.3614106476,
0.2976303101,
0.0206128359,
-0.307716459,
-0.058312688,
-0.4421392381,
-0.8007155061,
0.4433883727,
-0.1920383573,
0.8849247098,
-1.0062259436,
0.9875279069,
0.8620328307,
-0.7974507809,
-0.6122324467,
-0.3246792853,
0.0209886637,
-0.5737356544,
0.8231061697,
0.2380143106,
-0.3782372773,
0.0929818302,
-0.0136090145,
-0.63462466,
0.872308135,
0.9350649118,
0.0034157117,
0.3561505079,
0.3955135345,
0.8776583672,
-0.4827897549,
0.5232802033,
0.6850199103,
0.6530495882,
-0.1111555845,
-1.1713123322,
0.2658495009,
-0.3242394328,
0.2194867879,
0.0565991439,
-0.4343678653,
0.5498639345,
0.1865871251,
-0.2914344966,
0.1943517476,
0.7019943595,
0.1569526345,
0.2889323235,
0.4717125297,
0.7256510258,
0.5919766426,
-0.1601894051,
1.3055205345,
-0.4379104972,
0.2220578045,
0.8841415644,
0.135515064,
0.9726697803,
0.633517921,
-0.1974729598,
0.2555623353,
0.8740064502,
0.1733927578,
0.1046960801,
0.2946495712,
-0.0875089914,
-0.1588686556,
-0.2467782497,
-0.4709692895,
0.3527615964,
0.3678341806,
-0.6315797567,
-0.1957521886,
-0.1037950218,
0.16796197,
0.1672483236,
0.0704093948,
0.1521058381,
0.1505994946,
-0.4563019872,
0.6778730154,
0.6234282851,
0.442386657,
-0.0997131318,
-0.0011801532,
-0.1160918921,
-0.2502313554,
-0.1910995841,
-0.7479761243,
0.7981046438,
-0.0671981201,
-0.1849812567,
-0.1974913329,
0.1848645955,
-0.091175653,
-0.6359254122,
0.3232540488,
0.9848044515,
0.9316526651,
-0.4113634527,
-1.0848939419,
0.1348019987,
-0.5582168102,
-0.0366351232,
0.3888214231,
0.5823985934,
-0.2014351785,
0.5506273508,
0.7972060442,
-0.1397453249,
0.0475664474,
0.2330931872,
0.4366058409,
-0.6308862567,
-0.3826257288,
-0.8753791451,
0.6047773957,
-0.0373179279,
-0.5311889052,
0.6981422901,
0.690122664,
0.7747252584,
-0.3446579576,
0.2607068121,
0.0787398666,
0.1677856147,
-0.4008060694,
0.9406530261,
-0.7005063891,
-0.0739209354,
-0.6581092477,
-1.2506765127,
-0.5006982684,
0.7028380036,
0.0072423797,
-0.1639969349,
1.3451024294,
0.725696981,
-0.413276732,
-0.0237187035,
0.6863058805,
0.1281598955,
-0.194817856,
0.2769549191,
1.0021244287,
-0.6793900132,
0.4185167253,
0.0106724622,
-0.2318851352,
-0.0146920886,
-1.048784852,
-0.6502340436,
-0.6062542796,
-0.4978082776,
-0.5065431595,
-0.0851521939,
0.8162794709,
0.5818728209,
-0.510360837,
-0.4343902469,
0.2799819112,
0.0399679132,
-0.5366501808,
-0.2058638185,
0.4905396402,
-0.5264619589,
-0.8209679723,
0.2749955952,
0.4647299051,
-0.1673924327,
-0.0557807125,
-0.3059388101,
0.1334768981,
0.0579898544,
0.9062098861,
-0.3108724356,
-1.0958068371,
-0.3160330653,
-0.0919367746,
-0.5087794662,
0.1455328315,
0.6500168443,
-0.3337293565,
0.4329530597,
0.2377646714,
0.8244273663,
0.202461198,
-0.0449624732,
0.527327776,
-0.6009469032,
0.3094372451,
0.247199595,
0.5284238458,
0.2667042911,
0.013264792,
0.8120667338,
0.5875106454,
-0.2784742713,
-0.8711772561,
0.1276885569,
-1.1307742596,
0.0128375124,
0.8167443275,
-0.3827857673,
-0.0259049498,
0.236689806,
-0.2483638376,
0.2758076191,
-0.1441120058,
0.6830670238,
0.8429555297,
-0.075889647,
-0.1251337528,
-1.2405929565,
0.141161561,
0.4735138416,
-0.8796108365,
-0.3668732643,
0.7716302276,
0.1608824581,
0.3215193152,
0.2827957571,
-0.6496766806,
0.3435330391,
0.0893214047,
0.1880115122,
0.1258349866,
-0.3160943985,
0.1176851019,
0.0951568782,
0.198784411,
-0.3046617806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00071v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00071v1 | Combinatorial Reasoning: Selecting Reasons in Generative AI Pipelines via Combinatorial Optimization | 2024-06-19T16:47:44 | 2024-06-19T16:47:44 | Mert Esencan, Tarun Advaith Kumar, Ata Akbari Asanjan, P. Aaron Lott, Masoud Mohseni, Can Unlu, Davide Venturelli, Alan Ho | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.ET, cs.LG | Recent Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities
at tasks that require human intelligence and are a significant step towards
human-like artificial intelligence (AI). Yet the performance of LLMs at
reasoning tasks have been subpar and the reasoning capability of LLMs is a
matter of significant debate. While it has been shown that the choice of the
prompting technique to the LLM can alter its performance on a multitude of
tasks, including reasoning, the best performing techniques require human-made
prompts with the knowledge of the tasks at hand. We introduce a framework for
what we call Combinatorial Reasoning (CR), a fully-automated prompting method,
where reasons are sampled from an LLM pipeline and mapped into a Quadratic
Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) problem. The framework investigates
whether QUBO solutions can be profitably used to select a useful subset of the
reasons to construct a Chain-of-Thought style prompt. We explore the
acceleration of CR with specialized solvers. We also investigate the
performance of simpler zero-shot strategies such as linear majority rule or
random selection of reasons. Our preliminary study indicates that coupling a
combinatorial solver to generative AI pipelines is an interesting avenue for AI
reasoning and elucidates design principles for future CR methods. | [
-0.5971550941,
-0.7391799092,
0.8589493036,
0.393399924,
-0.36143291,
0.2970055044,
-0.2215537578,
-0.2099788785,
-0.0966156572,
0.4465886056,
-0.8576181531,
-0.3400883079,
-0.2824994028,
0.4246892929,
-0.3014679551,
0.7394167185,
0.0593646392,
0.1464188099,
-0.7635325789,
0.0552878566,
-0.6385646462,
-0.6112446785,
-0.7158362269,
-0.4867762923,
0.7334502339,
0.5236504078,
0.375773102,
0.5458943248,
0.1337779015,
0.2490118295,
0.0896516517,
0.4849157035,
-0.3135341704,
0.5277411938,
-0.1170305088,
-0.7704102397,
0.2075385898,
-0.3155371845,
0.2838556468,
0.7144914865,
-0.0218693297,
0.0555228405,
-0.3897149265,
0.5988823771,
-0.682431221,
-0.0116042411,
-0.6965267062,
0.0429704525,
-0.3583395183,
-0.4908442497,
-0.3411460221,
-0.2748508453,
-0.1267017275,
-0.5514771342,
0.2275186479,
0.4706607759,
0.3586660028,
0.5696902871,
-0.134461835,
-0.3697330356,
-0.8152478933,
0.8595383763,
-0.3802523315,
0.2939680517,
0.2599842548,
0.1643862277,
-0.2857450843,
-0.5119585991,
-0.6787207723,
-0.2156030685,
0.1660468876,
0.2170270532,
-0.253593117,
0.1430836469,
0.3734043539,
0.3041838109,
-0.6683394313,
0.2180678546,
-0.1168206334,
-0.2529948056,
0.6815924048,
0.4380696416,
0.2540558875,
0.1062993184,
-0.160388574,
0.0008806242,
-0.7978792191,
0.2405035049,
0.4539794326,
-0.0630657524,
0.1517869234,
0.4618352056,
-0.2076174319,
0.8639577031,
0.0384335518,
0.1370380074,
-0.2995567322,
-0.3015913069,
0.0612260737,
-0.0895342007,
0.6618714929,
0.0545675009,
0.2220192999,
-0.2124572247,
-0.1965114325,
0.3095747232,
0.2086647004,
-0.5785470605,
-0.4543769658,
0.5008736849,
-0.1071761549,
-0.1924557835,
-0.2146421075,
-0.6302639842,
-0.3045299649,
-0.425206542,
0.2337461412,
-0.3968031108,
0.2324116826,
0.0416691564,
-0.4773138762,
0.3762200177,
0.3901866674,
-0.9432325363,
-0.1816248894,
0.8168109059,
0.5088923573,
-0.1821982563,
-0.1911278367,
-0.7507772446,
-0.0060484922,
-0.5205846429,
1.1210041046,
-0.7628869414,
-0.7041878104,
-0.0750264451,
-0.5432189703,
0.0683831498,
-0.6513773203,
0.5783813596,
-0.5139481425,
0.2462941259,
-0.4855682254,
-0.4678215981,
-0.0842378512,
0.1298144758,
-0.3088510931,
0.6623808146,
0.0632268116,
-0.3112126291,
0.3354661465,
-0.8421612382,
-0.6587888598,
0.5396279693,
-0.4333418608,
-0.2324693948,
0.021651119,
0.3572800756,
0.0206552036,
-0.5588048697,
0.1616123021,
-0.2930388451,
-0.2493222356,
0.3759520352,
-0.3847019076,
1.0705826283,
0.3698413074,
-0.1584608406,
0.4346365929,
-0.3364162147,
0.1715361774,
0.2626184821,
-0.181901291,
0.0148228956,
0.273086071,
-0.517385304,
-0.0841757208,
0.2078460157,
-0.2001586258,
0.2987008095,
-0.0690469071,
0.6590774059,
0.8486616015,
0.0765633956,
0.3533468246,
-0.4617915154,
0.965846777,
0.0262628589,
0.1584328711,
-0.2387089282,
-0.7268972397,
-0.8320319653,
-0.1979591846,
0.2407421172,
0.6217546463,
-0.6664991975,
0.4230301976,
0.3570418954,
-0.1545386761,
-0.5003157258,
0.310818702,
0.2100219131,
0.4060298204,
0.1973005831,
-0.0500158668,
-0.6365468502,
-0.7164280415,
-0.084446609,
-0.1821588576,
-0.0326910987,
0.3265991807,
0.3058874309,
-0.1443961263,
1.0450502634,
-0.5626819134,
0.1204916164,
-0.5501797795,
0.2491455078,
0.1388380229,
0.0917443931,
0.5293732285,
-0.776330471,
-0.2073819339,
-0.3327555656,
-0.6907648444,
-0.5379189849,
-0.5003235936,
-0.5222991705,
0.0183408745,
0.3620457351,
-0.8573334813,
0.2517127991,
0.266443193,
-0.0008231678,
1.0387226343,
-0.0636733621,
-0.3688527644,
-0.6169396043,
-0.0911460891,
-0.1046658754,
-0.0233379528,
-0.3209492564,
0.0559136868,
-0.3921524584,
-0.1932426691,
-0.0199230872,
0.5451990366,
-0.4750374258,
0.0144839454,
-0.3202356398,
0.1217805594,
0.2487098724,
0.4916124642,
0.0473020673,
0.894580543,
0.6794450879,
-0.6482922435,
0.8120768666,
0.4469797909,
0.005734399,
0.6395487785,
-0.6231999993,
0.2162639648,
-0.2181599885,
0.3582127392,
-0.807743609,
-0.1170840934,
0.3122170568,
-0.5142202973,
-0.0407802463,
-0.0012772117,
-0.4053997993,
-0.6748809218,
-0.1221383065,
0.4555307627,
0.4836849272,
-0.7176476717,
0.5235950351,
0.0591790341,
-0.0987397656,
-0.2070972621,
-0.1859417409,
0.2226852924,
-0.3144494593,
-0.6037192941,
0.4873942733,
-0.6035182476,
-0.3995682299,
-0.2188897431,
-0.175676778,
0.1724853963,
0.2243992537,
0.2291472256,
0.3555002511,
-0.0017583047,
-0.0542788021,
0.2025824636,
-0.3691969812,
0.4324259162,
-0.5584897995,
0.645359993,
-0.112447843,
-0.4249580801,
-0.2224093676,
0.7118038535,
0.2510353625,
-0.4644876719,
0.4170349538,
0.4543703794,
-0.1774047613,
-0.5521624088,
-0.4671035707,
-0.3140283525,
-0.4335317016,
-0.1119660214,
-0.3075714707,
-0.91212672,
0.3979749978,
-0.0795871839,
-0.0128204115,
0.0448215567,
0.9662786126,
-0.2895813584,
1.3028877974,
0.0817802325,
-0.0356953777,
0.4614315629,
-0.3249096572,
0.5131165385,
-0.6649528742,
-0.2172512412,
-0.5340947509,
-0.2130315304,
-0.3032481372,
-0.3191575706,
0.5371758938,
0.3439275026,
-0.1564669907,
0.009993731,
-0.4887402058,
0.6002110243,
1.0598201752,
-0.1096492112,
0.1517767012,
-0.2579456866,
-0.3209706843,
0.4609038234,
-0.8889758587,
-0.3493345082,
0.6527629495,
-0.2206192315,
0.4192646146,
0.0208387282,
0.8651738167,
0.2819310427,
-0.0340445526,
-0.9065591693,
0.7572222948,
0.1936933547,
-0.5784059167,
-0.1966230869,
-0.4304650128,
-1.0964689255,
0.0457294248,
-0.2445112467,
-0.7314992547,
0.0408275723,
0.2687170208,
-0.6846017241,
0.0976080075,
-0.6117576361,
0.6597329974,
-0.6049543023,
-0.235597223,
-0.317201972,
-0.6072023511,
0.1608884335,
0.1105181798,
-0.0481341407,
0.0248061214,
0.2673920095,
0.3986752331,
-0.5731533766,
0.6363663673,
0.0276619606,
0.1808032691,
0.5195122957,
0.0962042436,
0.3489115536,
0.0463855676,
0.0794470087,
0.1215693727,
-0.0890054032,
-0.3635395467,
-0.8168047667,
0.4828238487,
-0.6017284989,
-1.0174380541,
-0.2986133695,
-0.6991438866,
-0.3282744288,
0.1189596727,
0.4155440927,
0.4431283772,
0.3170177937,
0.1099305153,
0.4724668264,
-0.0760228857,
0.481112659,
0.0423315801,
-0.0946775749,
-0.248395592,
0.9460096359,
-0.1255543232,
0.0942251459,
0.4577319026,
0.548038125,
-0.5511750579,
-0.8865832686,
-0.6506744623,
0.0820883438,
-0.6001443863,
-0.3390135765,
-0.2804180384,
-0.2184614837,
-0.075639762,
-0.4255289435,
0.1682229489,
-0.3359191716,
-0.4310521483,
-0.0174832381,
0.3591789901,
0.3865357637,
-0.1889727414,
-0.018781621,
-0.7498885989,
0.3500509262,
0.6746243238,
0.0816149935,
0.0583262853,
-0.0842425004,
-0.0125435777,
0.0260209683,
-0.554585278,
-0.8918217421,
0.2029170394,
-0.1808522195,
0.8789879084,
0.6154210567,
0.2765533328,
0.5832204819,
-0.1422988623,
0.7033523321,
0.0919997469,
-0.8025494218,
0.6243278384,
-0.528627038,
0.1571663469,
0.3065976799,
0.3826735616,
-0.3447871804,
-0.1436079592,
-0.4979065955,
-0.7118785977,
0.4073027968,
0.2946164608,
-0.202394262,
-0.3018520176,
0.3198927343,
0.0185668133,
0.2919464707,
-0.3083970845,
-0.1100791246,
-0.0725952312,
-0.0787030309,
0.3371626437,
-0.1367927045,
-0.3610502481,
-0.1841715127,
0.6040965319,
-0.2967979014,
0.3987287283,
0.0637140572,
-0.0495243333,
-0.2648023367,
0.1817257404,
0.6397721171,
0.808159709,
0.0707130283,
-0.0940677673,
0.1089707315,
0.1780610532,
0.0364283398,
0.0309920795,
-0.3826509416,
-0.3712897301,
0.219316259,
0.8453678489,
-0.24044846,
-0.8695163131,
0.1377460659,
0.0415838324,
-0.2077521533,
-0.3838492036,
0.4709400833,
0.1820695996,
0.4571825862,
0.5050222874,
-0.095120661,
0.0979523361,
-0.450271219,
-0.1351700872,
0.7947859764,
0.0936662331,
-0.0874907002,
0.6828283072,
0.2534954548,
-0.8539283276,
0.8124067783,
-0.5580066442,
-0.7904891968,
0.598282516,
0.5821446776,
0.872805953,
0.1533262581,
0.2866241336,
0.115784511,
-0.0611375533,
0.2191888243,
0.2496075183,
-0.4131933749,
-1.0335621834,
-0.5760668516,
-0.4524821341,
-0.7377862334,
-0.1273772866,
-0.459477663,
0.0428037792,
-0.6625451446,
-0.0767670199,
-0.0482934117,
-0.0908926651,
-0.5290768743,
0.0257150847,
0.528251946,
0.5755593777,
-0.4327731729,
0.386395216,
0.5781971812,
-0.5631577373,
-0.6619357467,
-0.0822177008,
0.0184037331,
-1.0328674316,
0.463447243,
0.0844580755,
-0.1588315964,
0.1616891176,
-0.8080070019,
-0.3545722961,
0.9069433808,
0.3721416593,
-0.6374425888,
-0.0882514715,
0.1075566784,
0.3260318339,
-0.4398129582,
0.2387957126,
0.5859971046,
0.554350853,
0.3743939996,
-0.4157945514,
-0.1769280285,
-0.1578920782,
0.0447497703,
0.401845932,
-0.7294204831,
0.473549813,
-0.6481887698,
-0.0149842128,
0.235620603,
0.5652961135,
0.8778219819,
0.4657932222,
0.6401053071,
0.6862520576,
0.8931308985,
-0.1967184246,
1.2035677433,
-0.2992371321,
-0.0549741946,
0.6074953079,
-0.2942640483,
0.411601007,
0.5343735218,
-0.4239771962,
0.7983196974,
0.8169564605,
-0.0704328269,
0.3525866568,
0.3535616398,
-0.5414178371,
-0.8971880078,
-0.202267617,
-0.0092854686,
0.4524104893,
0.4112545252,
0.0988524333,
-0.1732691228,
-0.1940875947,
-0.2038099319,
-0.0294088162,
-0.2040037364,
0.6765838861,
0.2022470236,
-0.9067873955,
0.3290751278,
-0.2117573768,
0.3131302297,
-0.5015926957,
-0.1915405542,
-0.2139996737,
-0.1302727759,
-0.0906482264,
-0.6717165709,
0.1616534442,
-0.1365838796,
-0.3849529028,
-0.2791587412,
0.4710148275,
-0.223437041,
-0.483397305,
0.045826979,
0.5343663692,
0.0528024882,
-0.1124107689,
-0.8147402406,
0.0032426699,
0.045361165,
0.1707078964,
0.3309903145,
0.479470104,
-0.2686116993,
0.9132788777,
1.2185103893,
0.0701046959,
-0.0316638984,
0.342112422,
0.9220636487,
-0.7557861805,
-0.5093438625,
-0.8939494491,
0.4526803195,
0.0466977172,
-0.1962831467,
0.494507432,
0.3499143422,
0.6358611584,
0.0746106133,
1.0468869209,
0.0339772776,
0.2422190458,
-0.6261021495,
0.0981792212,
-0.3518664837,
0.3037942052,
0.0965678841,
-0.8553985953,
-0.3263262212,
0.7157607079,
-0.4819975197,
0.1473902017,
0.6316917539,
0.7659378052,
0.3785907328,
0.3196841478,
0.202996403,
-0.0862983614,
0.4948771894,
0.7117707133,
1.1541136503,
0.3710630238,
0.6604796052,
-0.1668251604,
-0.1335530728,
-0.4031883776,
-1.1361101866,
-0.8519461751,
-0.49528265,
-0.315404743,
-0.1218550578,
0.0663164183,
1.0741513968,
0.5886212587,
-0.6902592778,
-0.1671088636,
-0.4958256185,
0.5344814062,
-0.2796582878,
-0.2557952404,
-0.1438163817,
-0.5566058159,
-0.517835319,
0.6040061712,
0.4733467102,
-0.2553684115,
-0.4920543134,
-0.1649852842,
0.021785181,
0.16743806,
0.5671852231,
0.5387942195,
-0.8050768375,
-0.2142470777,
0.1230826005,
0.3796572685,
0.1649441868,
1.0930720568,
-0.8731603026,
0.5477340817,
0.7011028528,
0.7327215075,
0.4849120975,
0.3101455569,
0.7108181715,
-0.4586879313,
-0.1403987855,
0.5618257523,
0.5037813783,
0.3036286831,
-0.2589618266,
0.2612893879,
0.4120559096,
-0.7858499289,
-0.6706597805,
0.5879876018,
-1.1137776375,
-0.2349360883,
1.1317551136,
0.2120287567,
-0.1734779626,
-0.1820280403,
-0.3692106307,
0.0079005137,
-0.4589664042,
0.7772729993,
0.7097979784,
-0.6637209058,
-0.5330992341,
-0.1144783944,
0.232731685,
0.5931625366,
-0.7409251332,
-0.0643878356,
0.6475667953,
-0.0058327862,
0.1494185328,
0.5085680485,
0.2450410277,
0.3646357358,
-0.0698069036,
-0.1777167916,
-0.211029321,
-0.4758886099,
-0.0524076037,
0.0383948162,
0.31609869,
-0.0882359743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15504v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15504v1 | Dr.E Bridges Graphs with Large Language Models through Words | 2024-06-19T16:43:56 | 2024-06-19T16:43:56 | Zipeng Liu, Likang Wu, Ming He, Zhong Guan, Hongke Zhao, Nan Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Significant efforts have been directed toward integrating powerful Large
Language Models (LLMs) with diverse modalities, particularly focusing on the
fusion of vision, language, and audio data. However, the graph-structured data,
inherently rich in structural and domain-specific knowledge, have not yet been
gracefully adapted to LLMs. Existing methods either describe the graph with raw
text, suffering the loss of graph structural information, or feed Graph Neural
Network (GNN) embeddings directly into LLM at the cost of losing semantic
representation. To bridge this gap, we introduce an innovative, end-to-end
modality-aligning framework, equipped with a pretrained Dual-Residual Vector
Quantized-Variational AutoEncoder (Dr.E). This framework is specifically
designed to facilitate token-level alignment with LLMs, enabling an effective
translation of the intrinsic `language' of graphs into comprehensible natural
language. Our experimental evaluations on standard GNN node classification
tasks demonstrate competitive performance against other state-of-the-art
approaches. Additionally, our framework ensures interpretability, efficiency,
and robustness, with its effectiveness further validated under both fine-tuning
and few-shot settings. This study marks the first successful endeavor to
achieve token-level alignment between GNNs and LLMs. | [
-0.2119244933,
-0.684779048,
0.3437093496,
-0.3032478392,
-0.3833980858,
0.3865721822,
-0.3183160424,
-0.3062371016,
0.2276819497,
0.2238488644,
-0.2998252213,
-0.7062109113,
-0.5398535728,
0.0584100485,
-0.2445435673,
0.6851527691,
-0.3077203333,
0.0320269465,
-0.1420290321,
-0.3914559782,
-0.3683185577,
-0.4445863068,
-0.7244423032,
-0.2961557508,
0.7788521647,
-0.051564008,
0.7753983736,
0.8183723092,
0.3345322609,
0.273853153,
0.0567646213,
0.5295279026,
-0.6239569783,
-0.1698720753,
-0.1167948619,
-0.2827973962,
-0.6554586291,
-0.2401390523,
0.6839895248,
1.0258432627,
-0.1525241733,
-0.1631341726,
0.1825622171,
0.5083887577,
-0.2971041799,
0.2111955583,
-0.4383769035,
0.1281719208,
-0.141963914,
-0.0807588473,
-0.3341490924,
0.1305011362,
-0.0806704685,
-0.7478746772,
-0.1241623536,
0.2720551193,
1.1295933723,
0.4137223363,
-0.8933697343,
-0.0018203136,
-0.4568985701,
0.2703411281,
-0.6518934369,
0.602144599,
0.1185229868,
0.3285785615,
-0.2462732792,
-0.9331991076,
-0.6726554036,
0.1064285487,
-0.0435014665,
0.0327354781,
-0.2838981152,
0.4614170194,
-0.002091046,
0.5245629549,
-0.7901605964,
0.4827937782,
-0.0909827948,
-0.3858243823,
0.4039981663,
0.2152476311,
0.4714360833,
-0.0219049845,
-0.4031383395,
-0.1834878623,
-0.5718336105,
-0.176266253,
0.4019849896,
0.4188401997,
-0.2759408653,
0.6501940489,
0.1194643378,
1.0238828659,
0.0666942298,
0.277507931,
0.4155835211,
-0.4862668216,
-0.4465771317,
-0.0952652693,
1.0890086889,
0.3903446496,
0.0773389637,
-0.3027371764,
-0.2370031476,
0.138114363,
0.0191103518,
-0.6508476734,
-0.2691743672,
-0.0359034203,
-0.3539832532,
-0.2570847273,
-0.0193229802,
-0.3557317853,
-0.3279532194,
-0.4696111679,
0.4725358784,
-0.2708010375,
-0.3367087543,
0.340442121,
-0.0284836888,
0.1602832377,
0.2162702084,
-0.7964301705,
0.3513286412,
0.6858773232,
0.8903312087,
-0.0469419695,
-0.1883845627,
-0.4951585233,
0.4723054171,
-0.5119270086,
0.3491156101,
-0.4553397,
-0.1143818647,
-0.0068367179,
0.1517042518,
-0.2193365544,
-0.350768894,
0.4051954448,
-0.6308461428,
0.3195003569,
-0.1025331467,
-0.7551849484,
-0.1453549713,
0.30171597,
-0.5477598906,
1.0213766098,
0.4586233199,
-0.7986546159,
0.3811641932,
-0.4512555897,
-0.5270825028,
-0.0225697923,
-0.6268433332,
-0.2378929406,
0.0907685906,
0.2129256576,
0.2740062773,
-0.2734230757,
0.4630596638,
-0.3956806362,
-0.1716090739,
0.1860220581,
-0.5169318318,
0.5457713604,
0.0595297031,
-0.2235754132,
0.3297037184,
-0.5697892308,
-0.1659615189,
0.0886839032,
-0.1586679071,
-0.2608650327,
-0.1426718235,
0.0153712146,
0.4063987732,
0.1854429096,
-0.6153215766,
0.2916001081,
-0.494910121,
0.9135578275,
0.8587164879,
-0.5453577638,
0.4229656458,
-0.1479584277,
0.5556880832,
0.0325225778,
-0.1594666243,
-0.1776880175,
-0.169512555,
-0.596630156,
-0.4928236604,
0.5491619706,
0.3894059062,
-0.6525192857,
0.8161904216,
-0.7226893306,
-0.1110032573,
-0.470156759,
-0.0157247111,
0.1788571775,
0.7747898698,
0.2682000101,
-0.5809370875,
-0.3786380887,
-0.952878654,
0.0754358321,
-0.1241538227,
-0.0170283355,
0.6651526093,
0.1755959094,
-0.3919854462,
1.028326869,
-0.4603182971,
-0.3792082667,
-0.0381953828,
0.1451073438,
0.0514880046,
0.4571765065,
0.5441831946,
-0.5940296054,
-0.4414907992,
0.2281612009,
-0.7693706751,
-0.1550908387,
0.0023777767,
-0.3884693682,
-0.1038278118,
0.7304610014,
-0.3477913737,
0.2253977954,
0.7542725801,
-0.5782372355,
0.1343981028,
-0.1850592643,
0.0400570557,
-1.3292144537,
0.0768889114,
-0.2225855142,
-0.7752720714,
-0.3593688309,
-0.3715994358,
-0.0063955649,
-0.3568048179,
-0.0268845577,
0.6222499013,
-0.5582023859,
-0.1974008679,
-0.2310725898,
0.290507257,
0.3444162309,
0.4006711841,
-0.2876369655,
0.6689731479,
0.6988042593,
-0.2817371488,
0.5144042969,
0.3469237089,
0.0240502935,
0.7012882829,
-0.6077059507,
0.3566354215,
-0.1878611892,
0.3853421807,
-1.0716625452,
-0.2078809291,
0.3844794929,
-0.33122769,
0.9887301326,
-0.2205124199,
-0.4958160222,
-0.4417600334,
0.0000680587,
0.6137080789,
0.1959642321,
-0.4599078894,
0.9273858666,
0.4444296658,
-0.0330551565,
-0.5231747627,
-0.7130443454,
0.6626892686,
-0.0670273528,
-0.7561594248,
0.5539232492,
0.0579059273,
0.2537946701,
0.3192733824,
-0.0314568318,
0.0159489773,
0.049222324,
0.0077194348,
0.1532573402,
-0.3289624155,
0.2602930069,
0.1467292756,
-0.3019177318,
-0.2069489658,
-0.7636463046,
0.6187884212,
-0.0630933046,
-0.6476888061,
-0.4576398134,
0.3180350363,
0.6944650412,
-0.3924141526,
0.628999114,
0.6245515943,
-0.4607604146,
-0.1451618075,
-0.1660205573,
0.024146175,
-0.4713780582,
0.7223374248,
-0.4553591609,
-1.247071147,
0.380587548,
-0.2997917831,
-0.2232853323,
0.3326902688,
0.2938717902,
-0.120161131,
1.0907008648,
0.8579333425,
-0.1956255436,
0.5000851154,
-0.0815570056,
0.5549812913,
-1.0626758337,
-0.0322893225,
-0.1706759036,
-0.5874143839,
-0.3091342151,
-0.6075404882,
0.1343631148,
0.2623097897,
-0.4252250493,
0.268081069,
-0.5618276596,
0.1370767057,
0.092765823,
0.1159065664,
0.0642252937,
0.026845593,
-0.2839916646,
-0.0111880768,
-0.8456248641,
-0.4418139756,
1.0861588717,
0.5156143904,
0.8117389679,
0.096832335,
0.5632654428,
0.2180009335,
0.2826409638,
-0.8514021635,
0.4466305971,
-0.3274302781,
-0.2366192192,
-0.4009462893,
-0.4753340185,
-0.7581880093,
0.3256919086,
0.0775726512,
-0.5165328979,
0.271968931,
0.1358900964,
-0.1061643213,
0.3784781098,
-0.3493312299,
1.1776063442,
-0.5022236109,
-0.3082159758,
-0.07691098,
-0.741093874,
0.0796117857,
-0.0674907267,
0.3903024197,
-0.1762491763,
-0.3243569732,
0.5407417417,
-0.5661548972,
1.021453619,
-0.0675968602,
-0.2818321288,
0.0055509727,
0.0028951438,
0.5029420853,
-0.2206591666,
0.2012774497,
0.23399131,
-0.3225984573,
-0.3494343758,
-0.6001849174,
0.5653269291,
-0.7487940192,
-0.3377478719,
-0.1708972901,
-0.6603397131,
-0.2993593812,
0.3588142097,
0.0893055797,
0.689001441,
-0.2699616253,
0.0920337439,
0.5261877179,
-0.1223291755,
0.2293920964,
0.2090208679,
-0.2981209457,
-0.8372053504,
0.8655956388,
0.0860928893,
0.40710935,
0.4255755544,
0.1782433093,
-0.3076484799,
-0.5451973081,
-0.9211653471,
0.2673173547,
-0.7416660786,
-0.3448361754,
-0.7231450081,
-0.1135489792,
-0.3261458278,
-0.2872687578,
-0.3228365481,
-0.2457886785,
-0.4300873876,
-0.3183987141,
0.1419879198,
0.5530807376,
-0.2049671113,
0.1478099078,
-0.741173327,
0.172101289,
0.2702130079,
0.4023211598,
-0.0893968716,
-0.5457539558,
-0.339435935,
0.0736762807,
0.0985724032,
-0.8619685173,
0.16194354,
0.5668486953,
0.5812331438,
0.4551073313,
-0.1357556134,
0.7680671215,
-0.5041765571,
0.6778685451,
0.5976207852,
-1.021089673,
0.1667842418,
-0.5103828907,
-0.1181239188,
0.5248203874,
0.0742558464,
-0.7188386321,
-0.1573130041,
-0.1818507463,
-1.1274108887,
0.3779046535,
-0.0950806215,
0.3696844578,
-0.1613158584,
0.3204059005,
-0.033988405,
0.4366728663,
-0.6823469996,
-0.2081692964,
-0.3978556395,
-0.9350553155,
0.0371039622,
-0.0674993545,
-0.5015523434,
-0.361330092,
0.3614605367,
-0.6316202879,
0.1445780694,
0.2525711954,
-0.3294354379,
-0.169758752,
0.052624695,
0.3506249785,
0.6874953508,
0.3386992216,
0.4157074392,
0.0245093238,
-0.1957719922,
0.1691925079,
0.3003650308,
0.0313000679,
-0.1857025474,
0.3550472558,
1.0131697655,
0.4004339874,
-0.4694877267,
0.798207581,
-0.025142923,
-0.2688013017,
0.076486297,
-0.3417701721,
0.289622277,
0.050767336,
0.1745747328,
-0.2818149924,
-0.1745841503,
-0.3876689374,
0.3764796853,
0.5910526514,
-0.6802292466,
-0.3917933404,
0.8705654144,
0.370193094,
-0.1417883039,
0.6418004036,
-0.2704446018,
-0.6847974062,
0.4117062688,
0.7484003901,
0.8934218884,
0.0981558487,
0.0850436985,
0.1880115867,
0.2058737725,
0.3223190606,
0.2500648499,
0.0572911091,
-0.8337525129,
-0.7188254595,
-0.6969192028,
0.0239570998,
-0.2763667405,
-0.5337696075,
0.1113672033,
-0.2334272265,
-0.2824209332,
-0.3154208958,
-0.4022814929,
-0.7244192958,
0.0488478839,
0.4513218403,
0.7350660563,
-0.970218122,
0.7011518478,
0.8109939098,
-0.4661930203,
-1.0811436176,
-0.2639739811,
-0.1329066306,
-0.9105191231,
0.7071384788,
0.1297922134,
-0.1711656302,
0.4424286187,
-0.5025636554,
-0.8403600454,
1.2501071692,
0.4913485348,
-0.8706129789,
-0.1737260222,
0.2491038293,
0.3690162897,
-0.5132376552,
0.0099018412,
0.108415097,
0.4114969969,
0.1690044403,
-1.0725594759,
0.1911208034,
-0.2248482853,
-0.0262356196,
0.470600754,
-0.5607854128,
0.771015048,
0.0248604957,
-0.3186000288,
-0.2771697044,
0.8366143107,
-0.2900924385,
0.133900255,
0.6013886929,
1.0256688595,
1.0998743773,
-0.1050072759,
0.6908754706,
-0.6784361601,
0.2274400294,
1.021464467,
-0.4362027347,
0.4439018369,
0.3874079287,
-0.1772846282,
0.6621053815,
0.7776609063,
0.0698338971,
0.4258490801,
0.5000419021,
-0.2032182813,
-0.3774714768,
-0.3891587853,
-0.3702113032,
0.3341203928,
0.2613979876,
-0.2967841327,
-0.1558153927,
0.0420868546,
0.0023066932,
0.0135719972,
-0.2219728678,
0.7422664762,
0.371948868,
-0.0053809094,
0.4717696607,
-0.1786876917,
0.6355081201,
-0.5829511285,
0.0143446149,
0.0674947947,
-0.123618558,
-0.2521090209,
-0.5249356627,
0.1159184501,
-0.3544354737,
-0.0423142985,
-0.2063599527,
0.6412112713,
-0.6274470091,
-0.2476717532,
0.4640484452,
0.5739044547,
-0.0979032591,
0.2222689837,
-0.5772306323,
0.0568202101,
-0.2318829745,
-0.1026863381,
0.3414391875,
0.7559933662,
0.0279223192,
0.3922547996,
0.6852911115,
-0.0150809679,
-0.0321387276,
0.4412641227,
1.2593252659,
-0.6512342691,
-0.5852352381,
-0.8275863528,
0.5482769608,
-0.1684698015,
-0.197859481,
0.4424913824,
0.8009474277,
0.673324585,
0.5687310696,
0.8099830151,
-0.0461053774,
-0.0749606863,
-0.4433117807,
0.6123863459,
-0.6694133878,
0.0357991271,
-0.0525260717,
-0.6447786689,
-0.262283504,
0.4645775259,
-0.0949269161,
-0.0593928546,
0.6978126168,
0.7016857862,
-0.1271636337,
-0.4089794159,
0.3627982736,
0.1727936566,
0.5499870777,
0.6736075282,
0.6136162877,
-0.2685326338,
0.5164390802,
0.2295710742,
-0.3828035891,
-0.0242806133,
-1.0323005915,
-0.804834187,
-0.3755047023,
-0.4098273218,
-0.3767788112,
-0.0170690604,
0.8142652512,
0.600509584,
-0.3805036247,
0.0110519314,
-0.3195510805,
-0.1333714426,
0.057735011,
-0.1549665183,
0.6443625689,
-0.183438614,
-0.5664468408,
0.5853735209,
0.6236521006,
0.1995806247,
-0.3365683854,
-0.1622960418,
0.1496208757,
-0.1435106546,
0.4453251958,
0.181388557,
-0.6282600164,
-0.5849884152,
0.2478190362,
-0.3803582489,
0.2966307402,
0.8104948997,
-0.734693408,
0.669557333,
0.4706016183,
0.9172064066,
0.3211532831,
-0.02100542,
0.9973716736,
-0.509757638,
-0.0409919769,
0.3434469402,
0.609239161,
0.606359303,
-0.1830193698,
0.3613594174,
0.2951600552,
-0.4695970118,
-0.9750520587,
0.5153720379,
-1.0036535263,
-0.18914029,
1.0197168589,
-0.2020578384,
-0.2446827739,
-0.2154500633,
-0.2555756867,
0.6651213169,
0.0026197517,
0.286364764,
0.6408140659,
0.0453743637,
-0.0205269996,
-0.3036916554,
0.1440448761,
0.2832949162,
-0.4826941788,
0.2025382817,
0.6421782374,
0.1475903392,
-0.2168878466,
0.7133790255,
-0.1518996805,
-0.1960756332,
-0.0393458009,
0.1108604074,
-0.5724192858,
0.0101215811,
-0.5211814046,
0.0042146998,
0.2158497423,
-0.2446871251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13692v1 | Synchronous Faithfulness Monitoring for Trustworthy Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-19T16:42:57 | 2024-06-19T16:42:57 | Di Wu, Jia-Chen Gu, Fan Yin, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented language models (RALMs) have shown strong performance and
wide applicability in knowledge-intensive tasks. However, there are significant
trustworthiness concerns as RALMs are prone to generating unfaithful outputs,
including baseless information or contradictions with the retrieved context.
This paper proposes SynCheck, a lightweight monitor that leverages fine-grained
decoding dynamics including sequence likelihood, uncertainty quantification,
context influence, and semantic alignment to synchronously detect unfaithful
sentences. By integrating efficiently measurable and complementary signals,
SynCheck enables accurate and immediate feedback and intervention, achieving
0.85 AUROC in detecting faithfulness errors across six long-form
retrieval-augmented generation tasks, improving prior best method by 4%.
Leveraging SynCheck, we further introduce FOD, a faithfulness-oriented decoding
algorithm guided by beam search for long-form retrieval-augmented generation.
Empirical results demonstrate that FOD outperforms traditional strategies such
as abstention, reranking, or contrastive decoding significantly in terms of
faithfulness, achieving over 10% improvement across six datasets. | [
-0.1269732714,
-0.8824352026,
0.5397284627,
0.0976909474,
-0.4744994938,
0.0180714168,
0.0000648385,
-0.5867411494,
0.3253959715,
0.2569682896,
-0.641712606,
-0.3533741236,
-0.4317908585,
0.2380432039,
-0.5217381716,
0.7456166744,
-0.3924345076,
-0.1348509043,
-0.2215538621,
-0.2820528448,
-0.5121281743,
0.0888328776,
0.1473881006,
-0.4752592742,
-0.0703343749,
0.3613709509,
1.1864550114,
0.5116164088,
0.2218944579,
0.2829256654,
0.1997652203,
0.7752588391,
-0.4415299892,
0.8555349708,
-0.3699595034,
-0.2270984948,
-0.4333212674,
-0.0305830706,
0.5641063452,
0.3734923601,
-0.2054643482,
0.442392081,
0.355009824,
0.5607404709,
-1.0844044685,
0.2583679259,
-0.7268385887,
-0.1071263254,
-0.5951249599,
-0.4568440914,
-0.523137033,
-0.1581479907,
-0.2266568691,
-0.6209405661,
0.0378324725,
0.5655418038,
0.8619271517,
0.3211038411,
-0.0454536155,
-0.2625898719,
-0.1437220424,
1.1322705746,
-0.6329850554,
0.7376317978,
1.013911128,
-0.2748863697,
-0.4689017534,
-0.5952436328,
-0.397670418,
-0.2319073081,
-0.2154056728,
0.1532639265,
-0.2159852833,
0.0100562936,
0.0794072524,
0.6109164357,
-0.3283444941,
-0.4765857756,
0.5086895227,
-0.7661999464,
0.3946079612,
0.1192338094,
0.3821442425,
-0.279045552,
-0.3013901412,
-0.0369733498,
-0.3196408451,
-0.1790563464,
0.3166016936,
0.1546240598,
0.092299886,
0.4749685526,
-0.4309279323,
0.5800648928,
0.1410037726,
0.0280118715,
0.0704308227,
-0.7495145798,
-0.1928462237,
0.0062060668,
0.6610897183,
0.1917438805,
-0.3143816292,
-0.1945714802,
-0.6046808958,
0.2373878956,
0.3330343664,
-0.7728542686,
-0.0302172229,
0.1908397526,
-0.5122432113,
-0.4107097387,
0.0568098277,
-0.7791781425,
-0.0947766975,
0.01802155,
0.5001118183,
-0.7811581492,
0.0317250416,
-0.0510884635,
0.3024303019,
-0.0571976192,
0.4414999187,
-0.8307433128,
0.0506898202,
0.7362967134,
0.9640557766,
0.0249760691,
-0.5000061393,
-1.2991966009,
-0.0192283951,
-0.3716359735,
0.4049182534,
-0.3553011715,
-0.1696456969,
0.3050020337,
0.0823965594,
0.2977180183,
-0.1776544154,
0.6605540514,
-0.6961194277,
-0.1496050656,
-0.2833065987,
-0.5744177103,
0.3059879839,
0.3332824111,
-0.4107789099,
1.0775549412,
0.2768734992,
-1.2172499895,
0.4055919945,
0.122848995,
-0.4673869908,
0.0886354968,
-0.0912957266,
-0.605715394,
0.1893528402,
0.0769546404,
0.307992667,
0.0313028544,
0.2101015598,
-0.4328764081,
-0.517439127,
0.0641819462,
-0.3907735944,
0.4814142585,
0.3699923158,
-0.5096083283,
-0.1177551821,
-0.6188516617,
0.1590925604,
-0.028689675,
-0.1614368707,
-0.8347967267,
0.2157014608,
0.0323084816,
-0.3797477186,
0.4483180344,
-0.7657219768,
-0.1289395243,
-0.3726260364,
-0.1475474983,
0.5380597711,
-0.0850144625,
0.2423059791,
-0.3920535147,
0.14638111,
-0.1870780438,
0.2541045547,
-0.542447865,
-0.280482024,
-0.4874305129,
-0.0576826893,
0.00307765,
0.173739329,
-0.9920657873,
0.4309664667,
-0.0111014629,
0.0611605346,
-0.6537436843,
0.5201410055,
0.7826139331,
0.5153381824,
0.3624870777,
-0.4238396287,
-0.514690876,
-0.3989147246,
-0.7126821876,
-0.2979933321,
0.2688075602,
-0.1206047833,
0.4544385374,
-0.6890237331,
0.8486119509,
-0.0714580566,
-0.2881194949,
0.3556256592,
0.3965690136,
-0.1726381034,
0.4706028998,
0.2678282261,
-0.5832618475,
-0.2335444838,
0.0755819157,
-0.8253315687,
-0.2854376435,
0.0680670142,
-0.1296367049,
0.4197518528,
0.3717972338,
-0.374137491,
0.4506885409,
0.7968557477,
-0.596993506,
0.5652666688,
-0.2478618175,
0.47607252,
-0.9951885343,
0.0980910659,
-0.5136830211,
-0.7013325691,
-0.2177239209,
0.3455163836,
0.2477653176,
0.3842518032,
-0.1334642023,
0.4286652803,
-0.7524006367,
-0.1222542524,
-0.3852855265,
0.1971021444,
0.0817077309,
-0.0646936446,
-0.3591094017,
0.9877106547,
0.1306732148,
0.0384266563,
0.2779973447,
0.5621222854,
-0.2976996899,
0.304440856,
-0.2450429946,
0.081445694,
0.0840590522,
0.1011015698,
-0.7944173813,
-0.4991709292,
-0.1467288435,
-0.5860086679,
0.2875054479,
0.104457438,
-0.5816503167,
0.0636162087,
-0.7081071138,
0.4558704793,
0.3967972994,
-0.665959537,
0.4715437293,
-0.0991713479,
0.3367775679,
-0.9716531634,
-0.8634557724,
-0.2984157205,
0.6072054505,
-0.7148256898,
0.0230944883,
0.2733364999,
-0.427662462,
-0.008853144,
-0.6788470745,
0.0741584376,
0.1546998173,
0.5310865045,
0.2929554582,
-0.0943566263,
-0.1984253377,
0.2071097642,
-0.090316318,
0.1180635393,
-0.2813325226,
0.4515059888,
-0.3621433973,
-0.4753399193,
-0.5741837621,
0.2780683637,
0.8144163489,
-0.2955119908,
0.6466185451,
0.6148768067,
-0.2678605914,
-0.6428055763,
-0.5287970901,
-0.5403177142,
-0.5497113466,
0.0211775359,
-0.1300981194,
-1.0342172384,
0.5564360023,
0.0112357708,
0.0799613595,
0.1597752422,
0.3144503236,
-0.0178882275,
0.836139679,
0.1924195737,
-0.1185034513,
0.5921052098,
0.2539734542,
0.0007897164,
-0.4697816968,
-0.1215007603,
-0.2473400086,
0.1237800717,
-0.3418545723,
-0.3923698962,
-0.0772477388,
0.5148766041,
-0.0222194605,
0.1014758274,
-0.1912538409,
0.1964983195,
0.4251318872,
0.3152332604,
0.6356648207,
-0.0440756753,
-0.3661561012,
-0.2911689878,
-0.0705453306,
-0.4181475937,
0.8266533017,
0.101443477,
1.1354154348,
-0.1589369625,
0.8583819866,
0.6542274952,
0.0471786596,
-0.3203323483,
0.3332335353,
0.0263226703,
-0.3807570338,
-0.0038172167,
-0.4491606951,
-0.5816128254,
-0.0959616676,
-0.3691700399,
-0.5152238011,
0.0886458233,
0.6042198539,
-0.2286444455,
0.3320206404,
-0.2873903811,
0.5432209969,
-0.0110821174,
-1.0268284082,
-0.2321835458,
-0.6599444747,
0.5160659552,
-0.2565489411,
0.1326111108,
-0.0823768079,
0.2133319527,
0.2634917498,
-0.7073689103,
0.4969418347,
-0.006707544,
-0.0739547461,
0.2954111993,
0.6970748901,
0.949857831,
0.4402146637,
0.0033286612,
0.0828632712,
0.0942935348,
-0.4141195416,
-0.3204165995,
0.7861572504,
-0.5089313388,
-0.1915287077,
-0.5537211895,
-0.6501657367,
-0.4393149614,
0.4934096634,
0.3627029359,
0.2783960104,
-0.2083604038,
0.1669359803,
0.77928406,
0.0161374453,
0.2628505826,
0.4973722696,
-0.4209216833,
-0.3118554354,
0.7462332845,
-0.3091009855,
0.3607518971,
0.3450177312,
-0.0405779369,
-0.1193031445,
-0.5097663403,
-0.254689157,
-0.0222207475,
-0.4225138724,
-0.5957565904,
-0.4464992881,
0.1718108207,
-0.1726808399,
-0.2310046405,
-0.7602114081,
0.1998206377,
-0.1679781973,
0.1359110326,
0.4817095697,
0.3447667062,
-0.0376381502,
0.0732809231,
-0.9298001528,
0.537722826,
0.5090978742,
0.5316441655,
-0.1978448778,
-0.3393384218,
-0.1361127794,
0.2659631371,
-0.1428998858,
-0.8682665825,
0.3124470115,
0.039487645,
0.0804478675,
0.4536896944,
0.3716730773,
0.7912569046,
-0.3312868476,
0.6997157335,
-0.0034327924,
-1.4784066677,
0.8116654754,
-0.4191268981,
0.221975103,
0.9059451818,
-0.2583890557,
-0.2561987638,
-0.6941574216,
-0.2904579043,
-0.6452587247,
0.7548788786,
0.4800220132,
-0.0561030619,
-0.1547878087,
0.4963105917,
0.259639591,
0.3808812201,
-0.1704948694,
-0.295598805,
-0.3120628893,
-0.2374388129,
0.2728557289,
-0.3570765555,
0.0691453516,
0.1293068677,
0.7751387358,
-0.2836131155,
0.0845955014,
0.5934650898,
-0.3468953669,
-0.7488311529,
0.4625671804,
0.4346512258,
0.4692679048,
-0.5402843952,
0.5022985339,
0.0786280334,
-0.8405556083,
-0.016342761,
0.068070218,
-0.3821118772,
0.4180151224,
0.5299736857,
0.4477432668,
0.293220818,
-0.7858034968,
0.8399644494,
0.0037172919,
0.0461012051,
0.0148150576,
-0.1746041477,
-0.3141570389,
0.2938384116,
0.3636585474,
0.3323052227,
0.1307592541,
-0.6933906674,
0.808273375,
0.6230211854,
-0.2244201303,
-0.5393697619,
0.9499441981,
0.0377842486,
0.0393880233,
0.6016486287,
-0.2691805363,
-0.4029822648,
-0.0762662441,
0.4482596219,
0.7661135197,
-0.5912942886,
0.1612939388,
0.0762510747,
0.2971857786,
-0.6176137924,
0.5801262259,
-0.4130592346,
-0.8129600286,
-0.4063872993,
-0.9491496086,
-0.4889216423,
-0.3238578141,
-1.0958601236,
-0.1237451583,
-0.2711761594,
-0.0561994128,
-0.3665450215,
0.2121446729,
-0.2399947047,
0.0048421072,
0.0376613401,
0.8335159421,
-0.7938429117,
1.0568845272,
0.5499249101,
-0.3018266559,
-0.7453063726,
0.1344825625,
0.1957905591,
-1.0490114689,
0.275534302,
0.0404972285,
-0.599619627,
-0.2433739007,
-0.6335348487,
-0.5519502163,
1.2468193769,
0.6615451574,
-0.72289294,
0.0880132094,
-0.2169897407,
0.3158412278,
0.0048974101,
0.0465691648,
0.3928131163,
0.4574458897,
-0.3229226172,
-0.990369916,
0.2235965431,
-0.126126349,
-0.1769154668,
0.5493627787,
-0.7349251509,
0.773537159,
-0.072323136,
-0.4072382152,
0.4123240411,
0.9375510812,
0.4513112605,
0.7366636992,
0.3909919858,
0.4358340502,
0.8025534749,
-0.1636597514,
0.9202725887,
-0.506788373,
0.7108402848,
1.1415436268,
-0.3524356484,
0.9176422358,
0.8972753286,
0.1636505872,
0.5185883641,
-0.046426516,
0.118101567,
0.5997522473,
-0.4541782439,
-0.2487026602,
-0.6077215075,
-0.2904316783,
-0.2911911011,
0.3071323037,
0.1094896048,
-0.4699415565,
-0.2935421169,
0.0860171542,
0.1582303792,
0.5406313539,
-0.2827305198,
0.2927037776,
0.20744735,
-0.7098748088,
0.576371491,
-0.2049770653,
0.8706271648,
-0.8695914745,
-0.1982397437,
-0.4231874347,
0.5870999694,
-0.4534001946,
-0.7075304389,
0.3006575406,
-0.1355822235,
-0.2887729406,
-0.4592641294,
0.9504231215,
-0.5608077049,
0.0509761199,
0.5447611809,
0.5322744846,
-0.3573283255,
0.0325996689,
-0.379694432,
0.6813600659,
0.1741621494,
-0.1425344944,
0.3247071505,
0.3220342696,
-0.0961559117,
0.4894034564,
0.6325757504,
0.0584658086,
0.293426007,
-0.395059675,
0.7099798322,
-0.4388460517,
-0.5563450456,
-0.7221263051,
0.1463203132,
0.0656192824,
-0.131839484,
1.3109418154,
0.4257424176,
0.8604074717,
0.1005714461,
0.3402694464,
0.1203772277,
0.4609042406,
-0.4853886664,
0.7794994712,
-0.6138000488,
0.111558795,
-0.3616751432,
-0.7067955732,
-0.0807973891,
0.6179121137,
0.2593478262,
-0.2954270244,
0.6819255948,
0.6979777217,
-0.2450373471,
0.4651592076,
0.3934854269,
0.3116123974,
-0.0901618227,
0.2647326887,
0.8393483162,
-0.7293648124,
0.1930992603,
-0.319188714,
-0.026891334,
-0.2798711061,
-0.812187016,
-0.7601941824,
-0.4144367576,
-0.2551038861,
-0.761451304,
0.4170243144,
0.7680432796,
0.5740798116,
-0.9715237021,
0.1624510288,
-0.3737441897,
-0.0369952992,
-0.2454967201,
-0.2453557551,
0.2715904713,
-0.6877540946,
-0.4313424826,
0.5568319559,
0.3099601269,
-0.1966369003,
-0.1782153547,
-0.2943839133,
-0.0115956375,
-0.0138256485,
0.2835471034,
0.277076602,
-0.8019016981,
-0.4395211339,
0.0104558524,
-0.1393014491,
-0.2858807743,
0.8727269173,
-0.6018080711,
0.9461569786,
0.6486366987,
0.7305931449,
0.3155041039,
0.320361495,
0.4122285247,
-1.1204599142,
0.2320862114,
0.2305466831,
0.6429334283,
0.1779762357,
-0.3295862675,
0.2648812234,
0.2747303545,
-0.8093898892,
-1.0810824633,
0.1082985625,
-1.0183944702,
-0.0592032596,
1.0066581964,
-0.2616191506,
-0.4611347318,
-0.2035534233,
0.0477454439,
0.2994039953,
-0.6177770495,
0.4314853549,
0.6200541854,
0.1764752567,
0.1873476952,
-0.5966570377,
0.8387392759,
0.8366559744,
-0.5776116252,
0.4191279709,
0.8468460441,
0.2668291628,
0.3774877191,
0.3948274553,
-0.1777551174,
0.4822746217,
0.2279230952,
-0.0929107815,
-0.2600024343,
0.0385272056,
-0.3140571117,
0.213372916,
-0.0196757875,
-0.4224026501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13677v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13677v1 | Leveraging Large Language Models to Measure Gender Bias in Gendered Languages | 2024-06-19T16:30:58 | 2024-06-19T16:30:58 | Erik Derner, Sara Sansalvador de la Fuente, Yoan Gutiérrez, Paloma Moreda, Nuria Oliver | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Gender bias in text corpora used in various natural language processing (NLP)
contexts, such as for training large language models (LLMs), can lead to the
perpetuation and amplification of societal inequalities. This is particularly
pronounced in gendered languages like Spanish or French, where grammatical
structures inherently encode gender, making the bias analysis more challenging.
Existing methods designed for English are inadequate for this task due to the
intrinsic linguistic differences between English and gendered languages. This
paper introduces a novel methodology that leverages the contextual
understanding capabilities of LLMs to quantitatively analyze gender
representation in Spanish corpora. By utilizing LLMs to identify and classify
gendered nouns and pronouns in relation to their reference to human entities,
our approach provides a nuanced analysis of gender biases. We empirically
validate our method on four widely-used benchmark datasets, uncovering
significant gender disparities with a male-to-female ratio ranging from 4:1 to
6:1. These findings demonstrate the value of our methodology for bias
quantification in gendered languages and suggest its application in NLP,
contributing to the development of more equitable language technologies. | [
-0.263460815,
-0.6020845175,
0.4234380424,
0.464705646,
0.2253191769,
0.2846091688,
-0.3184205294,
-0.1915102303,
-0.0419400074,
0.2681031525,
-0.7420018911,
-0.3907903433,
-0.6186187863,
0.4715662301,
-0.4098596573,
0.533693552,
0.1094761714,
0.6003339291,
-0.3571783006,
0.0161017627,
-0.7067254186,
-0.6054178476,
-0.3262552917,
-0.3377817869,
0.4034921825,
0.2411494255,
0.4435592592,
0.3286030591,
0.34670946,
0.2694857419,
-0.3375140727,
0.2592382133,
-0.3015818298,
0.0347124785,
-0.2544206083,
-0.4568181038,
-0.4134042561,
-0.0473563634,
0.7845981121,
1.0484341383,
0.0782217309,
0.3394230902,
0.2188169211,
0.662142992,
-0.5784469247,
0.234855324,
-0.6255404353,
0.349134177,
-0.2327072918,
-0.3481702507,
-0.3071901798,
-0.2165265679,
0.0540726595,
0.0006677344,
0.3503436446,
0.1819459051,
0.3908703923,
0.1141967624,
-0.5486350656,
-0.3524600863,
-0.5424196124,
1.0218902826,
-0.6634591222,
0.8787506819,
0.2773502767,
0.1268124729,
-0.2967369556,
-0.1901781857,
-0.4156135619,
-0.3044931591,
0.0213295072,
-0.344874531,
-0.2228076607,
-0.4029543996,
0.2889140844,
0.109052673,
-0.3302264214,
0.2795886397,
-0.2192966789,
-0.0434102379,
0.3846624196,
-0.2982258201,
0.4579410255,
-0.2026863545,
-0.1604697108,
-0.0654101074,
-0.838457942,
-0.2229928374,
0.7838079929,
0.5434507728,
-0.0090623153,
0.6054043174,
0.2437599599,
0.4015400112,
0.1301885098,
-0.1480337232,
0.4592197537,
0.0301844459,
-0.1486791074,
0.1337903738,
0.7480141521,
0.2562420964,
0.321223855,
-0.146945551,
-0.0991578102,
-0.0273624975,
0.0810387135,
-0.5520811677,
0.4901734591,
0.0382404365,
-0.2095521837,
-0.2184224725,
0.0218893103,
-0.8319534659,
-0.4076268673,
-0.1891619265,
-0.2121002823,
0.0025911888,
-0.3013370335,
0.0848429799,
-0.215699777,
0.138990432,
-0.0071558151,
-1.099235177,
0.3067025542,
0.7910935879,
0.6943507791,
-0.0129393358,
-0.2210909724,
-0.4125370383,
0.1700808704,
-0.3867277205,
0.5115993619,
-0.4397245049,
-0.2822634876,
0.1631864756,
0.0184334666,
0.0096247969,
-0.6627157927,
0.4549404383,
-0.2564837337,
0.2118800133,
-0.3211612999,
-0.4038642049,
0.1234965995,
0.2953371406,
-0.7829397321,
1.1792231798,
-0.1052524522,
-0.8806027174,
0.4313658178,
-0.5035813451,
-0.2239345163,
-0.2125114053,
-0.4781801701,
-0.3340515196,
0.2012117803,
0.5078580976,
0.6734987497,
-0.586933434,
0.7177891135,
-0.2514713109,
0.0581063554,
0.4375694096,
-0.5833829045,
0.7361562848,
-0.1581408828,
-0.2837610245,
0.0634964332,
-0.4999154508,
-0.4069281816,
0.1138600037,
-0.0034839448,
-0.5315936208,
0.1784545481,
0.1007597521,
0.1940720677,
0.2917239964,
-0.517446816,
-0.1583741456,
-0.4672853649,
0.5097583532,
0.7025996447,
-0.4406117797,
0.8177528381,
0.0110350959,
0.4362149239,
-0.3415236473,
0.0169120096,
0.0696515515,
-0.290932864,
-0.4924131036,
-0.3646969199,
0.3570235372,
0.3781695068,
-0.3762718737,
0.6014598608,
-0.3102174103,
0.0123800915,
-0.3035001159,
0.2318342179,
0.3098537028,
0.4546657801,
0.1934338808,
-0.0169312861,
-0.6554775834,
-1.1921054125,
-0.328994751,
-0.1915618628,
-0.4815372229,
0.0620065592,
0.8607277274,
-0.3182903826,
1.0936611891,
-0.2650555372,
-0.3311315775,
-0.3142572641,
0.0863435343,
0.0594878495,
0.3863603771,
0.578007102,
-0.6006659865,
0.141254589,
-0.0226289071,
-0.6631093025,
-0.5801275373,
0.2680942416,
-0.2231277823,
0.0642160624,
0.7947018147,
-0.0984411165,
0.0571107753,
0.8384356499,
-0.5336604118,
0.3449163735,
-0.0016764305,
-0.0241205283,
-0.7696564198,
0.0905526802,
0.3766780794,
-0.5915055871,
-0.4011865258,
0.0751214251,
0.2355718017,
0.2065176815,
-0.5068961382,
0.6517942548,
-0.7111697793,
-0.408557117,
-0.0405799113,
0.1191961989,
-0.0829046667,
0.1870905012,
0.1204149798,
0.6051247716,
0.0128872087,
-0.2968702912,
-0.0605161749,
0.1911843866,
-0.1182031855,
0.7608636618,
-0.6143853664,
0.0765845031,
-0.4578381479,
0.2792305946,
-0.7942133546,
0.0827600658,
0.0813932866,
-0.3132741749,
0.2064420283,
-0.2468590885,
-0.5364275575,
-0.3519023955,
-0.4697414339,
0.5019891262,
0.0105502224,
-0.4690249562,
0.4948524833,
0.6654114127,
-0.1289542466,
-0.7789647579,
-0.77474612,
0.0175738186,
-0.1446174085,
-0.601610899,
0.3421196342,
0.0459911786,
-0.4723049104,
-0.420039326,
-0.1353241205,
-0.1188368574,
0.1410745531,
0.1914580762,
0.2522491217,
0.0100223441,
0.2672351897,
0.2926053107,
0.0881916434,
0.2070604563,
-0.1134832799,
0.8838741779,
-0.191797331,
-0.4088487327,
-0.0797950923,
0.4187833965,
0.534402132,
-0.0916360766,
0.7939521074,
0.3765207231,
-0.666026175,
-0.3742948771,
-0.6553643942,
-0.2379097342,
-0.4028158784,
0.4167177081,
-0.1934424043,
-1.1227464676,
0.6208307147,
-0.0464512073,
0.0801039934,
0.3582000732,
0.562041223,
0.0375473984,
0.9851372838,
0.6388468742,
-0.2349247485,
0.3871464133,
-0.0741689801,
0.0010379826,
-0.9141945243,
-0.291649431,
-0.9217656255,
-0.1826148778,
-0.5838883519,
-0.8044970036,
0.1672099978,
-0.229877755,
-0.4541661739,
-0.0297123082,
-0.145457074,
0.5142627358,
0.4214292765,
-0.0257360376,
0.3592408299,
0.0191664156,
-0.0774962455,
-0.3765722513,
-0.700971067,
-0.8655599952,
0.9733182788,
0.749361515,
0.3365080655,
0.0965807587,
0.2537819147,
0.5495308638,
0.2305360883,
-0.6516442299,
0.4344231188,
-0.2504172027,
-0.656010747,
-0.3291969597,
-0.5651512742,
-0.9009695053,
0.523809433,
-0.2655315101,
-0.6089882255,
0.3672535419,
-0.0641431957,
0.2564532161,
0.2659509182,
-0.3643411994,
0.7937029004,
-0.1950964183,
-0.3922462463,
0.101996839,
-0.2261181176,
0.3990799189,
-0.1495245546,
0.6510490179,
-0.2917822003,
-0.1957613528,
0.8791874647,
-0.5114364028,
0.9736351967,
0.0845481604,
-0.7334917784,
-0.2903748453,
0.076123178,
0.1728416085,
0.1515455991,
-0.1716882735,
0.6409659386,
-0.2342768908,
-0.3941516876,
-0.2374421507,
0.705986619,
-0.6526514292,
-0.1682117879,
-0.638933301,
-0.6166718006,
-0.2823061347,
0.0053669256,
-0.0303629115,
0.1977189332,
-0.6434826255,
-0.0030549054,
0.6362492442,
-0.5985064507,
0.3431496918,
0.4475959241,
-0.2196117342,
-0.0434409566,
0.2685856223,
0.0005771734,
0.0702767074,
0.5516760349,
0.3224685788,
-0.4269663095,
-0.1369934827,
-0.3899404109,
0.4116838872,
-0.4816614985,
-0.1367132664,
-0.5698990226,
0.1408141404,
-0.4278596044,
-0.2119881958,
-0.5507253408,
0.0102840457,
-0.096492067,
-0.2117445767,
0.0096628061,
0.4583637714,
0.2755514085,
0.2787169218,
-0.4633902609,
0.4753578007,
0.4452723861,
0.0419348888,
-0.0179765765,
-0.5126600862,
0.2447529584,
0.1400044113,
0.0611202717,
-1.25263381,
0.7786124945,
0.1647639126,
0.4811064899,
0.0848555565,
-0.2403991222,
0.419334203,
-0.7186188698,
0.6059496999,
0.251455158,
-1.2850092649,
0.5730141997,
-0.5280889869,
0.2747416496,
0.3644917011,
0.2668109834,
-0.7008651495,
-0.5190518498,
-0.2464306653,
-1.0283875465,
0.4636371732,
0.323971808,
0.2845035791,
-0.3075213134,
0.2346600145,
0.1145170704,
0.5451069474,
-0.8441302776,
-0.272695601,
0.3949785531,
-0.225539133,
0.0054764319,
-0.3886730373,
-0.0188543592,
-0.2663285136,
0.6512865424,
-0.2180714309,
0.3959933519,
0.0095267687,
-0.5561563969,
0.04139781,
0.4960421324,
0.3282587528,
0.8410065174,
-0.3109937608,
0.2996424139,
0.388214469,
-0.4576871991,
0.1351109296,
-0.1422168612,
-0.2619607747,
0.211112082,
0.4167514443,
0.4962886274,
0.3689792454,
-0.7750579119,
0.5677163601,
-0.1381341219,
-0.1224397048,
-0.4450309277,
-0.4674911797,
0.141836524,
0.3831961453,
0.5163590908,
-0.1743561476,
0.1342702657,
-0.6785079241,
-0.1330426186,
0.5526301861,
-0.3752338588,
-0.1358694434,
0.6208571792,
0.3607862294,
-0.1587524265,
0.2790187895,
-0.0707529113,
-0.5233328938,
0.7840245366,
0.5895684958,
0.9265927672,
-0.3037388623,
0.42323035,
0.3629620373,
0.6195200682,
-0.5285497904,
0.1288287491,
0.3533652425,
-0.8910886049,
-0.536659956,
-0.5988317728,
-0.155481115,
0.0578631461,
-0.4931669533,
0.3105920553,
-0.3992312253,
-0.2417293042,
-0.0014997503,
-0.272785753,
-0.7393488884,
-0.1307404488,
0.4934112728,
0.5443056822,
-1.2662343979,
0.254796505,
0.5601601005,
-0.041444242,
-0.358927846,
-0.0192384273,
0.1888767332,
-0.7329787016,
0.9080539346,
0.1965770572,
-0.3705012798,
-0.3615381122,
-0.3978769779,
-0.6452761889,
0.8297687769,
0.7650716305,
-1.0321276188,
0.1627509743,
0.4221538007,
0.5755552649,
-0.493167758,
0.5557301044,
0.6758406162,
0.510088861,
-0.3631490171,
-0.9807442427,
0.0852341726,
-0.2060677856,
0.3027758002,
0.1933658421,
-0.2832933962,
0.7589170933,
0.2930369675,
-0.0126801394,
-0.4171516001,
0.7798666358,
0.2794325352,
0.2977927029,
0.6289912462,
0.1160395071,
1.1062208414,
-0.125839591,
0.7273612618,
-0.004223282,
0.1956472993,
1.0557495356,
-0.3598768711,
0.724796176,
0.6798252463,
-0.2733708024,
0.3837270141,
0.2155056,
0.2261985838,
-0.1250202358,
0.6428312063,
-0.2419962585,
-0.1014194712,
-0.3598012626,
-0.3193543851,
0.3719716072,
0.3299151957,
-0.5648097396,
-0.0059704203,
0.1911715269,
0.442392081,
0.4322494566,
-0.3977950215,
0.3892677426,
0.1335880756,
-0.2810283005,
0.3560748398,
0.2378458381,
1.0820972919,
-0.4356844425,
0.1328336746,
-0.2456724048,
-0.0308178142,
-0.2711852193,
-0.5115881562,
0.1551064998,
0.4663734734,
-0.4493995905,
-0.4756111205,
0.5983543992,
-0.5809509158,
-0.9184718728,
0.3754584193,
0.8762122989,
-0.1418414265,
-0.2376377732,
-0.3876955807,
0.1100207344,
-0.0538940057,
0.0149205327,
0.3915427625,
0.3184908032,
-0.3984647691,
0.7933173776,
0.4301816821,
0.1161439046,
0.0784009844,
0.59372437,
0.47783342,
-0.6098599434,
-0.3951819837,
-1.131629467,
0.1956126541,
-0.1944409013,
-0.2125329077,
0.8797543049,
0.6041642427,
0.7758899331,
-0.0935548842,
0.6399149299,
0.1047122255,
0.4179401994,
-0.3358462155,
0.4319436848,
-0.3249363303,
0.6327722073,
-0.5699711442,
-1.2329427004,
-0.5338633657,
0.888843894,
-0.3361358643,
-0.002970536,
0.5438109636,
0.7283374071,
-0.0543235689,
-0.0992723182,
0.075232476,
0.1382453293,
0.2565872073,
0.1475744247,
0.8794354796,
-0.359087348,
0.1906449646,
-0.0186399017,
-0.2300208956,
-0.1663218737,
-1.1929167509,
-1.0837816,
-0.3238660693,
-0.4776373506,
-0.0303157736,
0.2077197134,
1.1691200733,
0.5974394679,
-0.4895066023,
-0.6161578894,
-0.0378069393,
0.3597936928,
-0.1097749099,
-0.1619047225,
0.1935295314,
-0.2131206989,
-1.1167565584,
0.2722722888,
0.0801373944,
-0.2864584029,
-0.6611597538,
-0.0258862041,
-0.2222305387,
0.0061996165,
0.8223553896,
-0.0446341708,
-0.441912353,
-0.0913627595,
0.0319879651,
0.0585677139,
-0.1169445291,
0.8350673318,
-0.5911781788,
0.1393635124,
0.7214737535,
0.325337708,
0.2566805184,
-0.363954246,
0.9840945005,
-1.2599956989,
0.2952117324,
0.2604214251,
0.4710305631,
0.6649324298,
-0.1322395205,
0.4777083993,
0.060036961,
-0.3101415038,
-0.9601655602,
0.1425125003,
-0.9109421968,
-0.5449225903,
1.3772822618,
0.2729305327,
-0.301609695,
-0.0870879069,
-0.2895299196,
0.2605197728,
-0.6190678477,
0.5628293157,
0.5024219155,
0.4912051857,
-0.0786749125,
-0.9299046993,
0.2398395836,
0.3160938919,
-0.701536417,
0.0920232162,
0.6891613007,
0.1738410741,
-0.0331291258,
0.4067006409,
-0.2741889954,
-0.1524438858,
-0.3972285688,
0.3315426707,
0.1561366022,
-0.1481691301,
-0.4249016345,
0.1266505867,
-0.0814873353,
0.1241893917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13663v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13663v2 | Model Internals-based Answer Attribution for Trustworthy Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-19T16:10:26 | 2024-07-01T12:39:26 | Jirui Qi, Gabriele Sarti, Raquel Fernández, Arianna Bisazza | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Ensuring the verifiability of model answers is a fundamental challenge for
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) in the question answering (QA) domain.
Recently, self-citation prompting was proposed to make large language models
(LLMs) generate citations to supporting documents along with their answers.
However, self-citing LLMs often struggle to match the required format, refer to
non-existent sources, and fail to faithfully reflect LLMs' context usage
throughout the generation. In this work, we present MIRAGE --Model
Internals-based RAG Explanations -- a plug-and-play approach using model
internals for faithful answer attribution in RAG applications. MIRAGE detects
context-sensitive answer tokens and pairs them with retrieved documents
contributing to their prediction via saliency methods. We evaluate our proposed
approach on a multilingual extractive QA dataset, finding high agreement with
human answer attribution. On open-ended QA, MIRAGE achieves citation quality
and efficiency comparable to self-citation while also allowing for a
finer-grained control of attribution parameters. Our qualitative evaluation
highlights the faithfulness of MIRAGE's attributions and underscores the
promising application of model internals for RAG answer attribution. | [
-0.28476578,
-0.4412587881,
0.9048677087,
0.2456400394,
-0.1527686715,
-0.0551022962,
0.1030929163,
-0.3413651884,
0.028507119,
0.4780861735,
-0.4361738563,
-0.0475092717,
-0.2095435411,
0.1892130673,
-0.4727433026,
1.0130679607,
-0.0743790269,
0.0090294071,
-0.7929192781,
-0.0019833825,
-0.2505691946,
-0.5941962004,
-0.6358407736,
-0.1287164837,
0.7697352171,
0.5069035292,
0.5229275823,
0.4189590812,
0.4135133028,
0.2556490302,
0.0342809334,
0.3921901584,
-0.4006337523,
0.4544937313,
-0.5212224722,
-0.4536814094,
-0.1470227391,
-0.0982025117,
0.6900113821,
-0.0161882956,
-0.1015114784,
0.6570677757,
0.0554299057,
0.4693106413,
-0.8157234192,
-0.1388976723,
-1.0618940592,
-0.4491093755,
-0.1773682833,
-0.3706745505,
-0.3976080418,
-0.5001122355,
-0.1622411758,
-0.4668095112,
0.22189641,
0.0210939702,
0.9723246694,
0.4642243683,
-0.3188204169,
-0.3656500876,
-0.5714597702,
0.6461982727,
-0.8036566973,
0.2184224725,
0.3721376956,
0.5183262229,
-0.1265328676,
-0.7158780098,
-0.5591973662,
-0.2235860229,
-0.1319808662,
0.0546205342,
0.1674461216,
-0.5807954669,
-0.090525344,
0.2953766584,
-0.3989626169,
-0.1208077595,
-0.2654240131,
0.0205826741,
0.6227568984,
0.0134604881,
-0.0415374748,
-0.4872274399,
-0.6384469271,
0.0475779474,
-1.136792779,
0.0898375884,
0.3023179471,
0.2853513658,
0.0269660037,
0.6655786633,
0.035918463,
0.4687669873,
0.0874616727,
-0.0151227117,
-0.1439999789,
-0.4200927019,
0.0000201407,
-0.1682912856,
0.6767988205,
-0.0476751998,
0.3995998502,
-0.326736778,
-0.4145914316,
-0.5194965005,
0.5168397427,
-0.7115998268,
-0.1318754405,
0.3520578146,
-0.3523121178,
-0.5638751984,
-0.0203622095,
-0.6526862979,
-0.3858803809,
-0.2535801828,
0.6586580873,
-0.2481223345,
-0.3307603598,
-0.4146686494,
-0.0073194988,
0.2759899199,
0.3403370678,
-0.3093309999,
0.0699757263,
0.4937471151,
0.8491600156,
-0.2491190135,
0.0258920565,
-0.5518348813,
0.4934232831,
-0.3253242075,
1.0751932859,
-0.4695473313,
-0.4799395204,
0.0244667195,
-0.274569422,
0.1235597208,
-0.5150693655,
0.6222598553,
-0.8428901434,
0.4180621207,
-0.6169267297,
-0.4525103271,
-0.0933563188,
0.39457497,
-0.4547401071,
1.2785480022,
0.0625431016,
-0.8822553158,
0.1079877988,
-0.5761017203,
0.0493071787,
-0.029782854,
-0.2205481827,
-0.4590412378,
0.282093972,
0.4030748308,
0.3690809608,
-0.342289418,
0.2031509727,
-0.3819588721,
-0.164188683,
0.8002636433,
-0.7099471688,
0.7824063301,
0.3527378142,
0.0214243159,
0.1058183685,
-0.6495441198,
0.1611665934,
0.4000274837,
-0.1468576044,
-0.3929037154,
-0.0437229462,
-0.1040698141,
0.3934246302,
0.4947456419,
-0.5024346113,
0.0592131726,
-0.2205487937,
-0.182352379,
0.7804688215,
0.329456836,
0.1757367104,
-0.2695048451,
0.6336319447,
0.0038555805,
-0.0347058438,
-0.4147209525,
-0.4638881087,
-0.5144808292,
-0.2423069924,
0.35970366,
0.3980128169,
-0.9670565724,
-0.2281671166,
-0.3827979565,
-0.4141104817,
-0.515278995,
0.0985396504,
0.6616799235,
0.9270211458,
0.3962990642,
0.0899481252,
-0.2835938036,
-0.9841284156,
-0.45277071,
-0.2949567735,
-0.1051601171,
0.550041914,
0.4952786565,
0.1279487163,
1.2097563744,
-0.3334097564,
-0.1283763647,
0.1529958993,
0.1102826744,
0.0801403522,
0.3440383077,
0.6386245489,
-0.9114122987,
-0.6916402578,
-0.1773680598,
-0.8208327293,
-0.2130642682,
0.0456469394,
-0.214319244,
0.0569751449,
0.4724166691,
-0.2595615685,
0.2783952355,
0.47984308,
-0.3466649055,
0.7591161132,
-0.2123491317,
0.2591495514,
-1.2249491215,
0.3696314692,
-0.0161631908,
-0.4738079309,
-0.3347422481,
0.3971640468,
0.1163949594,
0.0200781804,
-0.5435080528,
0.9590848088,
-0.4684664607,
-0.2634138763,
-0.3537306786,
0.1664739102,
0.2068689764,
0.2121013254,
-0.0668149516,
1.2161698341,
0.2131849974,
-0.5754793882,
0.1808770746,
0.240355283,
0.0749993101,
0.668882072,
-0.8036905527,
0.141364947,
-0.1768048704,
0.2396848351,
-1.1491787434,
-0.3191956878,
0.1653877944,
-0.5686326027,
0.3525426388,
-0.406099081,
-0.7319157124,
-0.2360827625,
-0.1872004271,
0.4836299419,
0.3426494896,
-0.8520841002,
0.7081991434,
0.2180675268,
-0.3344898522,
-0.5527148843,
-0.3127407134,
0.0180546734,
-0.4450787306,
-0.8078918457,
0.1939212382,
-0.111569643,
-0.3277644217,
-0.0401969962,
-0.0779746026,
-0.3633794487,
0.1558274925,
0.1687386185,
0.412671864,
-0.2577376068,
0.2505521476,
0.0623857677,
-0.0241512582,
0.292715162,
0.0734656304,
0.1531069875,
-0.1538677216,
-0.459020108,
-0.1266469508,
0.4687415659,
0.4495057464,
-0.5245394707,
0.8148127794,
0.4831524193,
-0.155886218,
-0.0899591744,
-0.7725071311,
-0.3763270676,
-0.4950858355,
-0.084989801,
-0.5763254762,
-0.5431662798,
0.8453469276,
-0.030629741,
0.2540717721,
0.6590099931,
0.5990882516,
-0.172249034,
0.8272336721,
0.3396036923,
0.2842765749,
0.2704203129,
0.0751749352,
-0.1663217396,
-0.9928793311,
-0.2768354714,
-0.8107908964,
-0.0623939149,
-0.0715987906,
-0.5099595785,
0.6774232388,
0.0976735428,
-0.1932745427,
-0.1165823787,
-0.5934349298,
0.4756997824,
0.5285301208,
-0.0684756562,
0.4911611676,
-0.0005658146,
0.1042727083,
-0.1003707722,
-0.5795887113,
-0.5317367315,
1.1793048382,
0.4496155977,
0.7556651831,
0.4923647344,
0.8304161429,
0.0477797017,
0.6010954976,
-0.17371656,
0.2479999959,
0.1931310147,
-0.8628507853,
-0.2948256433,
-0.368991971,
-0.6010549068,
0.4000792801,
-0.2041271478,
-0.7427225113,
0.1752414852,
0.1958406717,
-0.3203882873,
-0.0114111779,
-0.5028208494,
0.7166791558,
-0.119427979,
-0.6036737561,
0.0401307903,
-0.4408642054,
0.7124757767,
-0.2680151165,
0.2426798046,
-0.0380331166,
-0.0809097961,
0.5253520012,
-0.3369386494,
0.6167851686,
-0.1874584258,
-0.5431299806,
0.5215432048,
0.3220289946,
0.8319909573,
0.3990513384,
-0.2794536054,
-0.0526725054,
0.0786165148,
-0.1100237891,
-0.8081137538,
0.9594275951,
-0.4632111788,
-0.6780098081,
-0.3564325869,
-0.4149346352,
-0.3714761138,
0.0403216705,
0.4152437449,
0.4915985763,
0.0582229346,
0.0515929349,
0.8973062038,
0.0156939905,
0.276747942,
0.6878070831,
-0.6090719104,
-0.2761771381,
1.1084184647,
-0.1519089341,
0.1905429959,
-0.0663423315,
0.2673618793,
-0.6427246332,
-0.445926398,
-0.8550159931,
0.5066640377,
-0.8276994228,
-0.4777078032,
-0.4710052907,
-0.2493964732,
-0.2301424891,
-0.1616362333,
-0.4792529941,
-0.3616843522,
-0.4773423672,
0.2106697857,
0.4507031739,
0.8114953637,
0.1208296865,
0.0652711317,
-0.8340488076,
0.4565502703,
0.3401234448,
0.2659287751,
0.1064644307,
-0.9613205791,
-0.3797457516,
0.2002886087,
-0.2173565477,
-1.1740305424,
0.2836649716,
0.247189194,
0.5657604933,
0.186412856,
-0.005270733,
0.8074662089,
-0.5777775645,
1.0203658342,
-0.1841455102,
-0.7166567445,
0.5621516109,
-0.5094745159,
0.1634086221,
0.5812166929,
0.3684605062,
-0.0458783656,
-0.6651210785,
-0.7790825963,
-0.7522906065,
0.3886713088,
0.2664044797,
0.1413618624,
0.0267129689,
0.7997259498,
0.0932429209,
0.0728195161,
-0.7558119893,
-0.3469409347,
-0.2130969465,
-0.1070870012,
0.1733771414,
-0.3934474289,
-0.3417882323,
0.0814318135,
0.907273829,
-0.3844607174,
0.1350308806,
0.3911339641,
0.0423681512,
-0.2438594699,
0.1136221588,
0.5962497592,
0.7244673371,
-0.0502453148,
0.0632243827,
0.0519200899,
0.0412497632,
0.050214503,
-0.0564198494,
-0.3036335707,
0.284602195,
0.0336013474,
0.1485099643,
0.2990859747,
-0.4662578702,
0.7545555234,
-0.1187231988,
0.2214623094,
-0.6184270978,
-0.0933714807,
0.1554187834,
0.2197479457,
0.6794380546,
-0.2360491902,
0.3869340122,
-0.2346660793,
0.2861949205,
0.8493509293,
-0.2803032994,
-0.1362788379,
0.8715544939,
0.0886771083,
0.0478017963,
0.3002695441,
-0.0876573995,
-0.411183089,
0.3872189522,
0.6746014953,
0.8988523483,
-0.3855673969,
0.2560537755,
0.512883842,
-0.0803756788,
-0.013676432,
0.2318859994,
-0.0033892957,
-0.463745445,
-0.4750716984,
-0.7175636888,
-0.4671549797,
-0.180365324,
-0.6224969029,
0.0650853291,
-0.1065078154,
0.0496475436,
-0.3034804463,
-0.3374210298,
-0.5393710732,
0.2847232521,
0.2749845982,
0.8465368748,
-0.6966717243,
0.7971848249,
0.5502184033,
-0.7895799875,
-0.8876093626,
-0.0223790221,
-0.075425677,
-0.5887656212,
0.7739354372,
-0.2258107066,
-0.2463915199,
-0.0176847372,
-0.8053995967,
-1.4123268127,
1.0831692219,
0.5027376413,
0.0615102239,
-0.2477231622,
-0.2581098378,
0.3797601461,
-0.4336181283,
0.4354345202,
0.004085714,
0.3887389302,
0.4991459548,
-0.9634267092,
0.1338449419,
-0.0973319784,
0.0212263986,
-0.1868460029,
-0.4336057901,
0.8086444736,
-0.1668730676,
-0.2154053003,
0.14570342,
1.2102973461,
0.6594481468,
0.0682253093,
0.2777694762,
0.2968286276,
0.6671205759,
0.1123192906,
1.277077198,
-0.1969450563,
0.2384820879,
1.4858181477,
0.0117389364,
1.2180995941,
0.6265945435,
-0.1031654105,
1.0673773289,
0.4249737859,
0.2962416708,
0.4600241482,
-0.0110816509,
-0.2658842802,
-0.2871085107,
-0.1231191158,
-0.4110574126,
0.3445664346,
0.3163132966,
-0.5660316348,
-0.3922306597,
-0.2762330174,
0.0507082008,
0.1688761115,
-0.3700778186,
0.7960929871,
0.1791491657,
-0.7907854319,
0.5489183664,
-0.1082099378,
0.4107443988,
-0.6373106837,
-0.1750411093,
-0.0519215688,
0.0138080418,
-0.2902800739,
-0.9537271261,
0.3469323814,
0.0886737034,
-0.3057753146,
-0.1865036339,
0.7481884956,
-0.5357145667,
-0.5000770092,
-0.2364269197,
0.599701941,
0.2231860757,
-0.4239917696,
-0.6462927461,
-0.2156193703,
-0.0145732807,
-0.4541965127,
0.3217685223,
0.5927197337,
-0.0635208935,
0.9426377416,
0.8035900593,
-0.0205211323,
0.2629506588,
-0.3672985137,
0.8708934188,
-0.2156947702,
-0.4733486176,
-0.5477847457,
0.913569808,
-0.2622166574,
-0.2351894081,
1.1804931164,
0.475766331,
0.2595807016,
-0.0813894793,
0.624248147,
0.2944631577,
0.8937453628,
-0.4858205318,
0.6968697906,
-0.8857960701,
0.3105020225,
-0.2433191538,
-1.1303530931,
-0.0232220981,
0.4763361216,
-0.0848893151,
0.0594896711,
0.3727048039,
0.7233313918,
-0.2215574831,
-0.3979326487,
0.1630908102,
0.0310530644,
0.4912918508,
0.1123382822,
0.6230555177,
-0.3613314331,
0.5097848773,
-0.0011981335,
-0.0986529738,
-0.2923929989,
-1.0971585512,
-0.6452797651,
-0.7591283917,
-0.2928214371,
-0.6585282087,
-0.1005538926,
0.5349699259,
0.3463586569,
-0.647621274,
0.0400094315,
0.1925862581,
0.1678629965,
0.1047825143,
-0.3091734052,
0.3962560594,
-0.5832922459,
-0.5338586569,
0.6294578314,
0.0551876016,
0.0922095403,
-0.8950343728,
-0.0038666318,
-0.1665814519,
0.3887815177,
0.263374418,
0.5123794675,
-0.9639799595,
-0.3710113466,
-0.0147596812,
-0.2583956122,
0.0214749221,
0.6803785563,
-1.1377594471,
0.4603144526,
0.3766638041,
0.5095978379,
0.3675820529,
0.4986404777,
0.7730582952,
-0.9660813212,
-0.2424726486,
0.2586228549,
0.2551018,
0.5193018317,
-0.5184319615,
0.5032960773,
-0.1402375102,
-0.8731497526,
-0.9201874733,
0.2316908985,
-0.6578304768,
-0.2659657598,
1.3811246157,
-0.3595368564,
-0.3062278628,
-0.1909711659,
-0.2191179544,
-0.0857430175,
-0.3258039355,
0.8502648473,
0.5785625577,
0.0198126081,
-0.224060297,
-0.3063335419,
0.6687939167,
0.3036276102,
-0.848104775,
0.2342671305,
0.555791378,
0.3695222139,
0.4963989854,
0.6034644842,
-0.2234666795,
0.3800498247,
-0.0902646706,
0.0344570167,
-0.2916887403,
-0.3715983033,
-0.3363994658,
0.2763701379,
0.2994203269,
0.1076149419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13662v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13662v1 | ObscurePrompt: Jailbreaking Large Language Models via Obscure Input | 2024-06-19T16:09:58 | 2024-06-19T16:09:58 | Yue Huang, Jingyu Tang, Dongping Chen, Bingda Tang, Yao Wan, Lichao Sun, Xiangliang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered significant attention
for their exceptional natural language processing capabilities. However,
concerns about their trustworthiness remain unresolved, particularly in
addressing "jailbreaking" attacks on aligned LLMs. Previous research
predominantly relies on scenarios with white-box LLMs or specific and fixed
prompt templates, which are often impractical and lack broad applicability. In
this paper, we introduce a straightforward and novel method, named
ObscurePrompt, for jailbreaking LLMs, inspired by the observed fragile
alignments in Out-of-Distribution (OOD) data. Specifically, we first formulate
the decision boundary in the jailbreaking process and then explore how obscure
text affects LLM's ethical decision boundary. ObscurePrompt starts with
constructing a base prompt that integrates well-known jailbreaking techniques.
Powerful LLMs are then utilized to obscure the original prompt through
iterative transformations, aiming to bolster the attack's robustness.
Comprehensive experiments show that our approach substantially improves upon
previous methods in terms of attack effectiveness, maintaining efficacy against
two prevalent defense mechanisms. We believe that our work can offer fresh
insights for future research on enhancing LLM alignment. | [
-0.2856063247,
-1.0687019825,
0.9353467226,
0.0340465531,
-0.3026187718,
0.1726821959,
-0.2513188422,
-0.4967031479,
0.3147501945,
0.6582775712,
-0.7585852742,
-0.4217786789,
-0.7575571537,
-0.0151378345,
-0.2336097956,
0.8695539832,
-0.1117079034,
-0.0647012591,
0.1621359587,
-0.3404000401,
-0.5275634527,
-0.2572108805,
-0.2626545727,
0.1833668202,
0.3940939009,
0.4569729865,
0.9078467488,
0.7763211727,
0.5498231053,
0.2299591303,
-0.1530527174,
0.102014333,
-0.5826519728,
0.2983733416,
-0.3797048032,
-0.3242361844,
-0.2333559543,
-0.1280221343,
0.5195251703,
0.5769940615,
-0.1405247897,
-0.0004575454,
0.1008431762,
0.6564224958,
-0.994117856,
-0.2542621195,
-0.8640586138,
-0.1543862522,
-0.5194736123,
0.1780790985,
-0.5966576934,
-0.4392475188,
-0.2444031984,
-0.3143570423,
-0.0314794704,
0.1821431071,
0.6018530726,
0.2735608518,
0.131882593,
-0.3100784421,
-0.599368751,
0.5198985338,
-0.7219531536,
0.0742418841,
0.4425082803,
0.4087798297,
-0.630166769,
-0.342238009,
-0.5588988066,
-0.3744454682,
0.0449912027,
-0.1902075559,
-0.5700913072,
-0.012927426,
0.1816972643,
0.1281883568,
-0.5278144479,
0.4384787977,
-0.1702603549,
-0.1571073234,
0.4323268235,
0.0579412282,
0.4090994,
0.0031792072,
-0.5127718449,
0.1996109933,
-1.0563187599,
0.1009449288,
0.8283897042,
0.2122804224,
-0.0877568945,
0.7707859278,
0.0017379555,
0.8127028346,
0.0969334245,
0.1038129255,
-0.0034502277,
0.0574275665,
-0.0816178396,
0.2589965165,
1.0357891321,
0.137820527,
0.0104925018,
-0.3584685624,
-0.2032442987,
-0.2995871603,
0.1432734579,
-0.505063951,
0.0403619222,
0.3970371485,
-0.1978802085,
-0.3975666761,
0.2312328666,
-0.6820448637,
-1.0356285572,
0.3047131598,
0.443397522,
-0.6699190736,
0.0290635098,
-0.0355197936,
-0.0865056962,
0.0256944224,
0.2185540646,
-0.7834922671,
0.1231690943,
0.7355029583,
0.8179119229,
-0.000977528,
-0.1327439696,
-0.8880710602,
0.2038546652,
-0.1597487032,
0.453350246,
-0.6585713029,
-0.1885592937,
-0.2849130034,
-0.0922214389,
0.2270027697,
-0.6095294356,
0.6151041985,
-0.4823806882,
-0.1386360228,
-0.0422029346,
-0.4946430027,
0.0949702933,
0.1806780547,
-0.8788889647,
0.6454948783,
-0.0137175648,
-0.8827136159,
0.0106746238,
-0.4443054795,
-0.0814998075,
0.0020344432,
-0.2184197009,
-0.380931586,
0.2567272484,
0.3311981261,
0.2780552208,
-0.0833876356,
0.3742240369,
-0.7871901393,
-0.22522448,
0.5082726479,
-0.5467855334,
1.0032576323,
0.2874582708,
-0.4349486232,
-0.1041980237,
-0.6912974715,
-0.2556753457,
0.3100457788,
0.1800369024,
-0.7515252829,
-0.0675308332,
-0.3517423868,
-0.1368820518,
0.3632229269,
-0.8002156615,
0.548722744,
-0.6418311596,
0.5626263022,
0.8411179781,
0.0755466372,
0.5374671221,
-0.1230876893,
0.5942809582,
-0.1952945143,
0.2772040963,
-0.1328303367,
-0.4333643615,
-0.1193569824,
-0.5743220448,
0.2472481132,
0.5768586397,
-0.6600372195,
0.4608455598,
0.1086097732,
-0.5783301592,
-0.790517211,
0.281722784,
0.412184149,
0.4128872454,
0.2099890709,
-0.1965847909,
-0.5367094874,
-0.862287581,
-0.859136939,
-0.0659013018,
0.1001117229,
-0.0684663802,
0.1831794381,
-0.2110943794,
1.0275261402,
-0.5619719028,
-0.2788074315,
-0.3916172683,
-0.0461655408,
0.4323898852,
0.613451004,
0.5436196327,
-0.4519828856,
-0.2431652993,
-0.3332237303,
-0.4238628149,
-0.2014622092,
-0.1490693092,
-0.0310796592,
-0.0646677315,
0.8139458895,
-0.8951897025,
0.4831800163,
0.4190359712,
-0.4488655925,
0.6251388788,
-0.1338218004,
-0.2091128081,
-0.7866578102,
-0.1872133911,
-0.2341102809,
-0.3058435321,
-0.5864846706,
0.4723983109,
0.2494285554,
-0.0474764518,
-0.487023741,
0.6612829566,
-0.5421035886,
0.359339118,
-0.1251835227,
0.1720427871,
-0.1064612344,
0.0612040386,
-0.2845104635,
0.4863518775,
0.6258155107,
-0.1488708556,
0.016911801,
0.1546583027,
-0.381296277,
0.5161046982,
-0.465888679,
0.341117084,
-0.3120110929,
0.0267696157,
-1.0896949768,
-0.2199937254,
0.5957471728,
-0.384819895,
0.5007559657,
-0.3607329726,
-0.5428237915,
0.0351909846,
-0.5578640103,
0.5400045514,
0.5596446395,
-0.700137794,
0.517478466,
0.2216748595,
-0.2840012014,
-0.765117228,
-0.485760808,
0.2182026505,
-0.5750060081,
-0.4043618441,
0.2731329203,
-0.0661540255,
-0.6775532365,
-0.0751419738,
-0.1594600379,
-0.0605371445,
0.2220281363,
0.3343927264,
0.2721068263,
-0.1911101937,
-0.3094041944,
-0.0203783996,
0.1195335835,
0.1026684269,
-0.266977638,
0.4790800214,
0.0491135679,
-0.4709548056,
-0.2788351178,
0.419551909,
0.6108862162,
-0.1717469543,
0.8364266157,
0.2135985941,
-0.2268160731,
-0.4314733744,
-0.4870958626,
-0.0287102982,
-0.5596624017,
0.2708955407,
-0.0348196179,
-0.7278110385,
0.555157721,
-0.0406319462,
0.0778422356,
0.073945269,
0.3171496391,
-0.0845831856,
0.9645321369,
0.6488132477,
-0.1034669131,
0.4722067118,
0.3710188568,
0.3377273679,
-0.6942457557,
-0.105100356,
-0.476780057,
-0.3097822368,
-0.4200627208,
-0.3414033651,
0.2712109387,
0.4790553153,
-0.1056776121,
0.4323019683,
-0.1027354449,
0.7236673236,
0.2178269029,
0.2704332173,
0.2932056785,
-0.2893100977,
-0.230670318,
-0.1259409338,
-0.4284307957,
-0.3759202957,
1.0230515003,
0.4676180184,
0.8810559511,
0.4070605338,
1.0217766762,
0.2422262281,
0.2433693409,
-0.7242639065,
0.3952805698,
-0.1195856705,
-0.4429265559,
-0.2262654454,
-0.3613849282,
-0.8983636498,
0.0844437107,
-0.0324661471,
-1.3043751717,
0.1282917261,
0.2695296705,
-0.5237064958,
0.4963008463,
-0.8211414218,
0.730681181,
-0.2586910427,
-0.3886027336,
0.3291162252,
-0.7727584839,
0.7307033539,
-0.2078355849,
0.7252036929,
-0.079220362,
0.0348790623,
0.5308597684,
-0.9840134978,
0.9938492775,
-0.2353978902,
-0.2472205162,
0.1190745309,
0.4619218111,
1.0478285551,
0.2515026331,
0.0042131622,
0.0648980513,
-0.346496135,
-0.2981071472,
-0.7286750078,
0.6746116281,
-0.4210797846,
-0.8787543774,
-0.1139250547,
-0.6842103601,
-0.4174341261,
0.3590644896,
0.4481102228,
0.2047269642,
-0.2332144529,
-0.1575635374,
0.8415038586,
-0.2028034776,
0.4911525249,
0.5761027932,
-0.1214635447,
-0.3947957754,
0.7507712841,
-0.0145119661,
0.474917382,
0.3443260789,
0.3655219376,
-0.2229331136,
-0.6994863749,
-0.5550528765,
0.1085822135,
-0.7846245766,
-0.2430436611,
-0.5049183369,
-0.0503660142,
-0.3031806648,
-0.3110548854,
-0.4963148832,
-0.5992685556,
-0.2090945542,
-0.0479588509,
0.5722568631,
0.713044405,
0.0293437559,
0.3520297706,
-0.8202804327,
0.4615637064,
-0.1826951206,
0.3152245879,
-0.2435298115,
-0.6773130894,
0.2511323094,
-0.1891702116,
-0.0878938437,
-1.2097040415,
0.3037098646,
0.0359735265,
0.599378705,
0.7158882618,
0.5629829168,
0.5838092566,
-0.6955505013,
0.5068683028,
0.3273949325,
-0.9519636631,
0.4818222821,
-0.2977416217,
0.2041823268,
0.8158029914,
0.2096692622,
-0.0785873383,
-1.0898265839,
-0.7820238471,
-1.1749839783,
0.6401634812,
0.2026182562,
0.0832890421,
0.1878180355,
0.3892982602,
0.4909901321,
0.0604234263,
-0.7133593559,
-0.4195140302,
0.0592576377,
-0.4523270726,
0.0974518582,
-0.1548781395,
-0.2549380362,
-0.1485494673,
0.2773332596,
0.2200170606,
-0.1362577528,
0.1417797953,
-0.295819968,
0.0801602155,
0.5037645698,
0.5242266059,
0.5140316486,
-0.2715646625,
0.4568375945,
-0.1540023386,
-0.8060812354,
0.2417135537,
0.1031891108,
-0.3345755935,
0.067294538,
0.3844433129,
0.695106864,
0.138989076,
-0.969655931,
0.5900472999,
0.0304111261,
0.0994256362,
-0.3182796836,
0.2185288072,
-0.1768816113,
0.3460005522,
0.2284261286,
0.3587894142,
0.0152897853,
-0.633884728,
0.1658887118,
0.5903339386,
-0.6362107396,
-0.1565367579,
0.7355490327,
-0.2577583492,
-0.3854415417,
0.3415339887,
-0.4234457016,
-0.3086741567,
0.4958218038,
0.6650828719,
0.9366624951,
-0.1922992766,
0.1054321527,
-0.0969289765,
0.7268165946,
-0.2580740154,
0.2295080274,
0.1326316893,
-0.5768126249,
-0.1958984286,
-0.377199322,
-0.3023410439,
0.3293778896,
-0.8230517507,
0.4466261566,
-0.7691833377,
0.1212939471,
-0.1052892655,
-0.6519420743,
-0.305440098,
-0.2772429883,
0.0718517601,
1.0722129345,
-0.6425241232,
0.8376916647,
0.5042404532,
-0.0610098392,
-0.7785289288,
0.3301585317,
0.2006769925,
-0.939036727,
0.2504399121,
0.1657811105,
-0.0517156459,
0.0356947221,
-0.861307919,
-0.87320894,
0.6034667492,
0.8531078696,
-0.8854495287,
0.2373840809,
0.0063256868,
0.0328638516,
-0.1159655005,
0.0574388504,
0.9202887416,
0.5914009213,
-0.065720059,
-0.6660760641,
0.4976209104,
-0.1616941541,
-0.5747436285,
0.4904812872,
-0.3868719339,
0.7150092721,
-0.6720237136,
-0.1218414828,
0.2765827775,
0.2888834178,
0.6332267523,
0.2565008104,
0.3234146237,
0.6271947026,
0.8450291753,
0.0432948247,
0.8460335135,
0.1227951422,
0.1548739821,
1.3910419941,
-0.42542243,
0.790369451,
0.8304075003,
0.0702202842,
0.4716914892,
0.2648706138,
-0.0867851824,
0.8331707716,
0.2688987851,
-0.0593122803,
0.0162649583,
0.2103339136,
-0.2467739433,
0.4947296083,
0.4202155173,
-0.349134475,
-0.4696685076,
0.1402887255,
0.5086128712,
0.1980424523,
-0.4672416151,
0.6270988584,
0.1012732983,
-0.3600567877,
0.623722136,
0.2230487168,
0.613797605,
-0.7159784436,
0.0173010565,
-0.1513774842,
0.0926201791,
-0.1511497498,
-0.6788838506,
0.1215302795,
0.3024898767,
-0.1355305016,
-0.0937635675,
0.3886262178,
-0.1574937999,
-0.366804719,
0.159348011,
0.1023557186,
-0.0424550325,
-0.2349088192,
-0.4315112829,
0.324091047,
-0.0449114069,
-0.3050909638,
0.5250044465,
0.5572813153,
-0.2713773251,
0.4754030704,
0.4921870828,
0.2953855991,
-0.0048233643,
-0.21516186,
0.9227728248,
-0.8007144928,
-0.5876789093,
-1.4554798603,
0.4323130846,
-0.0384048373,
-0.2755581737,
0.9105854034,
0.3063455224,
0.4709933698,
0.1034855619,
0.854698658,
-0.1430274099,
0.2240413129,
-0.9334816337,
0.9448168278,
-0.2400041968,
0.7664127946,
-0.4833970964,
-0.5543935895,
-0.3895612955,
0.1220279858,
-0.4477551281,
-0.3496344388,
0.7192786336,
0.7412917614,
-0.0266125612,
-0.1048677117,
0.209390834,
0.4959286153,
0.2189773023,
0.5755354762,
1.1175025702,
-0.0257111471,
0.5102748275,
-0.1879490018,
-0.424628973,
-0.1962532401,
-1.0756617785,
-0.8284816742,
-0.0853255019,
-0.1261674017,
-0.4328016043,
0.1449394822,
0.9009014964,
0.3052426279,
-0.8411175013,
0.2314437926,
-0.2783442438,
0.3414841592,
-0.2628505528,
-0.2029230893,
0.3941214979,
-0.0858028233,
-0.3510446548,
0.8062545657,
0.2446478456,
0.0060896352,
-0.2754905224,
0.0646564513,
0.1497592926,
0.126838401,
0.0646338239,
0.4766505957,
-0.7408009171,
-0.2522123158,
-0.1198377758,
0.1299890131,
-0.0211070031,
0.8885040283,
-0.6056284904,
0.484790206,
0.2749914229,
0.6182464361,
-0.0702803507,
0.2794696987,
0.6343317032,
-1.0014849901,
0.4288477004,
0.3700543046,
0.509711802,
0.1559301615,
-0.7778268456,
-0.0800826028,
0.0958622396,
-0.1471742541,
-1.1844259501,
0.5008137226,
-0.8403122425,
-0.6993804574,
1.2409120798,
-0.253364116,
-0.4659068882,
-0.4215394258,
-0.2471868992,
-0.2345801443,
-0.4857366681,
0.8650268316,
0.4934696555,
-0.0430623256,
0.0685212761,
-0.6837893128,
0.3815348744,
0.2588934302,
-0.4974212646,
0.3782097995,
0.391797781,
0.3669176996,
0.0362777188,
0.3329806924,
-0.3524748385,
0.1930335313,
0.0006719516,
-0.1709169149,
-0.3339882493,
-0.2418272644,
-0.5702156425,
0.4271716177,
0.2829425931,
-0.1445072144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13660v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13660v1 | Towards Minimal Targeted Updates of Language Models with Targeted Negative Training | 2024-06-19T16:06:21 | 2024-06-19T16:06:21 | Lily H. Zhang, Rajesh Ranganath, Arya Tafvizi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generative models of language exhibit impressive capabilities but still place
non-negligible probability mass over undesirable outputs. In this work, we
address the task of updating a model to avoid unwanted outputs while minimally
changing model behavior otherwise, a challenge we refer to as a minimal
targeted update. We first formalize the notion of a minimal targeted update and
propose a method to achieve such updates using negative examples from a model's
generations. Our proposed Targeted Negative Training (TNT) results in updates
that keep the new distribution close to the original, unlike existing losses
for negative signal which push down probability but do not control what the
updated distribution will be. In experiments, we demonstrate that TNT yields a
better trade-off between reducing unwanted behavior and maintaining model
generation behavior than baselines, paving the way towards a modeling paradigm
based on iterative training updates that constrain models from generating
undesirable outputs while preserving their impressive capabilities. | [
-0.1212660894,
-0.7764831781,
0.2689430416,
-0.0841503367,
-0.0992772728,
-0.043098744,
-0.3739272952,
0.0234806612,
0.0389092155,
0.6810176373,
-0.7570229769,
-0.6085947156,
-0.5563851595,
-0.2648209035,
-0.6132052541,
0.8698992729,
0.3393752277,
-0.3693921268,
-0.1090205535,
-0.0224360041,
-0.601788342,
-0.517095685,
-0.8298408985,
-0.4375102222,
0.3891814351,
0.697512567,
0.6310988665,
0.5911437869,
0.2548756599,
0.1523176432,
-0.1888713241,
-0.3993053436,
-0.905090332,
-0.050950136,
-0.1037233472,
-0.3088279963,
-0.180227682,
-0.1693466306,
0.5968363285,
0.987354219,
-0.1142560467,
0.1576231271,
0.2630289495,
0.6050037146,
-0.7171065807,
-0.1588045359,
-0.8213395476,
0.1339037716,
-0.1975550205,
-0.4367084205,
-0.8894852996,
-0.2050519884,
-0.2830729485,
-0.0930450708,
0.3607881963,
-0.3366186619,
0.6207786798,
0.3237937689,
-0.5549654961,
0.1713041067,
-0.9009079337,
0.9446074367,
-0.6162688732,
0.312186718,
0.4135130048,
0.1276949197,
-0.3207154572,
0.0378023162,
-0.062493179,
-0.7649100423,
0.2103445679,
-0.0971131921,
-0.6035736203,
0.0757767335,
0.4682770669,
-0.0020980958,
-0.234698385,
0.3859994113,
-0.4125244021,
-0.1676740646,
0.3861286938,
0.0396342389,
0.1569177806,
-0.1044167951,
-0.1141168922,
-0.2065696567,
-1.0763052702,
-0.095055826,
0.4792838693,
0.5020030141,
-0.3361981511,
0.9593214393,
-0.342451185,
0.6642260551,
0.1741856188,
0.266489774,
0.0905990824,
-0.0414968506,
-0.1115570888,
0.0166367348,
0.5700246692,
0.0985318646,
-0.001086019,
-0.2132481486,
-0.1832997352,
0.2387989908,
0.2213680148,
-0.5722441077,
-0.1952668428,
-0.0003644633,
-0.2250894606,
-0.8634176254,
-0.5652718544,
-0.4497754276,
-0.3722269833,
-0.0830721632,
0.3142746091,
-0.5433003902,
-0.0372524299,
-0.0415127389,
-0.0185162202,
-0.1217996553,
0.5203821063,
-1.20670259,
0.2108137757,
0.5760775208,
0.6204135418,
0.3629266024,
-0.0287960041,
-0.7512345314,
0.4548660815,
-0.5619001985,
0.6511647105,
-0.5197558999,
-0.2325887382,
-0.020986747,
-0.3704596758,
0.2725910544,
-0.5264209509,
0.2953632772,
-0.3131578863,
0.166454196,
-0.2417922318,
-0.4453570843,
-0.036391072,
0.4530145824,
-0.3918864429,
1.0584734678,
0.3723700047,
-0.6613609195,
0.3811813891,
-0.6102237105,
-0.4290657938,
-0.1236722618,
0.108079657,
-0.4493646622,
0.4449736476,
-0.1744158864,
0.2628172934,
-0.1580054313,
0.1645069271,
-0.3447880447,
-0.4333231747,
-0.0158816408,
-0.5861344934,
0.8820489645,
-0.0036435034,
-0.4018010497,
0.2371362746,
-0.8473858237,
-0.2562513947,
0.0653602481,
-0.42773664,
-0.5061052442,
0.0509307645,
-0.1499349624,
0.2494280934,
0.1072530448,
-0.6172015071,
0.4941761792,
-0.5423509479,
0.1828409731,
1.0502392054,
0.0111952666,
0.6923798323,
-0.4223999977,
0.651763618,
0.0010153992,
0.311996609,
0.1599676162,
-0.5573416352,
-0.7079816461,
-0.0523250028,
0.4361988008,
0.3514070511,
-0.9458981156,
0.1390530914,
-0.3347435892,
-0.5053983331,
-0.390081048,
0.4084659815,
0.259300977,
0.5928999186,
0.3678072393,
-0.268882066,
-0.535908103,
-0.8290768266,
-0.3178948164,
-0.2776068747,
0.0029135225,
-0.0742723048,
0.2468160987,
-0.221447289,
0.8170384169,
-0.4031871855,
-0.3532772958,
-0.6403419375,
0.2550371587,
0.2203451097,
0.7470044494,
0.6152009964,
-0.4763988554,
-0.655543685,
0.1034122184,
-0.3831762969,
-0.3140831292,
-0.3447424471,
0.2122723013,
-0.0526551269,
0.4407967925,
-0.7056429982,
0.3337228596,
0.6744582653,
-0.1462943852,
0.2141391933,
-0.129164964,
-0.1002856418,
-0.8548072577,
-0.0549374744,
0.1551115662,
-0.2729052901,
-1.2730914354,
0.0779609084,
-0.0841683745,
-0.451282829,
-0.7105884552,
0.8259544969,
-0.1391840428,
0.0990478992,
-0.3319402337,
-0.1448431015,
-0.1837107837,
0.6290217638,
0.0224598553,
0.4994235337,
0.6368509531,
-0.8044947982,
0.019092558,
0.17761603,
0.1604472548,
0.2706073523,
-0.3407244086,
0.1235725954,
-0.470808804,
-0.1882458925,
-0.5340354443,
0.0884708464,
0.7727358937,
-0.473110944,
0.4926946163,
-0.4672523737,
-0.3354338109,
-0.3413634598,
-0.5789839625,
0.1294220239,
0.8170591593,
-0.218864277,
0.362172991,
0.0987288207,
0.2679111958,
-0.4020682573,
-0.7359106541,
0.183862552,
-0.3218301237,
-0.257357955,
0.3023170829,
0.0344706848,
-0.0968016386,
0.1681067497,
-0.1256092787,
-0.0135508692,
0.3570144773,
-0.227127865,
-0.0569227375,
-0.1164734587,
0.056797564,
-0.0003679257,
-0.4146650732,
-0.1736744791,
-0.3866391778,
0.4876670241,
0.3501071036,
-0.4957248271,
-0.29293257,
0.1749780923,
0.1093410775,
0.1709616482,
0.8638758659,
0.6480834484,
-0.5810524821,
-0.1199587956,
-0.4030093551,
-0.3898743093,
-0.5383358598,
0.5720437169,
-0.5134907365,
-0.7018225193,
0.1450399756,
0.0193617009,
-0.0327458717,
0.4522730708,
0.575137198,
-0.1214004308,
1.2135567665,
1.0521014929,
0.0152227823,
0.7200312614,
-0.1227841526,
0.2440325767,
-0.8972887993,
0.0462453701,
-0.5821204185,
-0.094695501,
-0.5343273282,
-0.4961307943,
0.1808234155,
0.2614090741,
-0.036445953,
0.8482233286,
-0.6132452488,
0.1954997331,
0.9309560061,
0.0342833214,
0.0578341223,
-0.0368385203,
0.0215802472,
-0.2834373415,
-1.0720146894,
-0.326334089,
1.174131155,
0.1650829166,
0.8850916028,
0.4005699456,
0.8894194961,
0.5989409685,
0.8363494277,
-0.6650159955,
0.6422882676,
-0.2990185022,
-0.5666749477,
-0.2251314372,
-0.7615423799,
-0.792244494,
0.0144155752,
-0.3023150265,
-0.8582700491,
0.2333656698,
0.7428651452,
0.0170968454,
0.5662559271,
-0.7438029051,
1.2050147057,
-0.0058063897,
-0.3590139151,
-0.2251553833,
-0.1498420089,
0.2502121329,
-0.1268824786,
0.0170886628,
-0.0965048596,
0.0835746229,
0.2644920945,
-0.3180784285,
1.088136673,
-0.475502789,
-0.1298719645,
0.3851661086,
0.5101424456,
0.9058543444,
-0.3049401641,
-0.1154484972,
-0.0221496467,
-0.3922863007,
-0.7580396533,
-0.5522024035,
0.3365624249,
-0.5526565313,
-0.8655516505,
-0.3501935303,
-0.3730326593,
-0.2488409877,
0.2782136202,
0.2836027741,
0.4257890582,
-0.2891702354,
0.1985872984,
0.5313119888,
-0.6001181602,
0.1574719548,
0.4488195181,
0.1304267049,
0.1467609257,
1.1796108484,
-0.040229395,
0.5884695649,
0.8547587395,
0.479901731,
-0.2733308077,
-1.0317206383,
-0.1978846788,
-0.0057257959,
-0.8684923053,
-0.0423961021,
-0.5622195601,
0.0300867576,
-0.5007176399,
-0.2253813744,
-0.5153931379,
-0.3523262143,
-0.3704097271,
0.0110221487,
0.1296878755,
0.7505320311,
-0.4421077073,
0.3490098119,
-0.599617362,
0.2910523415,
0.2174548805,
0.121280551,
-0.1032826304,
-0.6985491514,
-0.2053989321,
0.2989821434,
-0.5354440808,
-1.009032011,
0.313660413,
0.2055588216,
0.2051625699,
0.1920711547,
0.2343562096,
0.6412466168,
-0.4706053436,
0.5586425066,
0.4429144561,
-1.1429468393,
0.8428182602,
-0.6692616343,
0.6646507382,
0.5207787752,
-0.0427486002,
-0.8148103952,
-0.8134514093,
-0.6398729086,
-0.4751573503,
0.7009240985,
0.3153896332,
0.6850071549,
-0.2779708207,
0.2793193758,
-0.1550382227,
0.3768765628,
-1.2075120211,
-0.0874971449,
-0.2364079505,
-0.261039108,
0.0497735739,
-0.3157393038,
-0.0467648022,
-0.2095396668,
1.1362297535,
-0.27632761,
0.2308448106,
-0.2715801299,
-0.270981431,
-0.2924800515,
0.5131223798,
0.9531879425,
0.1597180665,
-0.4067763388,
0.0393512174,
0.3899165094,
-0.2312658727,
0.4981137812,
-0.2161825746,
-0.7238729,
-0.0939045027,
0.2452894896,
0.7823973894,
0.4505775571,
-0.6691156626,
0.6457240582,
0.2163022757,
-0.160884738,
-0.0677264109,
-0.0031777956,
-0.0932060778,
-0.1404016018,
0.2802101076,
0.7556762099,
0.0182476267,
-0.5102002621,
0.1865297556,
0.4277722239,
-0.8507986665,
-0.5200765133,
0.8788936734,
-0.0162750632,
-0.2661135197,
0.4954491556,
-0.7175978422,
-0.3742980063,
0.6140504479,
0.5736196041,
0.78839463,
-0.0676755682,
0.5267183781,
0.3130254745,
0.8589960337,
0.0174442269,
-0.1223123372,
0.0871781409,
-0.741294384,
-0.5228380561,
-0.0919449031,
-0.4341691136,
0.2517001629,
-0.3538501859,
0.8046011925,
-0.6166671515,
-0.1785261929,
-0.1945099086,
-0.3333678246,
-0.4753094018,
0.128961727,
0.3240132928,
0.6606302261,
-0.8927329779,
1.016605258,
0.4572789371,
-0.3502771258,
-0.5006303787,
-0.0396267138,
0.1589434147,
-0.5387929678,
0.5648162365,
0.0360759906,
-0.0071475036,
0.1966133118,
-0.2970832586,
-0.9712058306,
0.4911354184,
0.787853837,
-0.5373257995,
0.0533021912,
0.2430187613,
0.5904111266,
0.0164282843,
0.0037765491,
0.012517496,
0.2655719519,
0.1943131685,
-0.2759791315,
0.1224540547,
-0.2144526243,
0.0130985733,
0.4250079393,
-0.4595218599,
0.8072285652,
-0.3997171819,
-0.4106520712,
0.1023554951,
0.457251668,
-0.0457355715,
-0.1380986273,
0.3592448831,
0.77745682,
0.386608094,
-0.1382491738,
1.2838855982,
-0.0989751592,
0.5249096751,
1.3476872444,
-0.3290600479,
0.4885466695,
0.4863277376,
0.0868093967,
0.171570316,
0.5935865641,
-0.2205067128,
0.9249774218,
0.2867174447,
-0.2558403909,
-0.083555758,
-0.3265652359,
-0.2744805515,
0.352529943,
-0.0432101861,
0.0230839048,
-0.4568369687,
0.2467007637,
0.0342768952,
0.210491091,
-0.2669591308,
0.7120845318,
-0.0562094152,
-0.4944263995,
0.8243331313,
0.3877580464,
0.532194376,
-0.4828124344,
-0.0309703685,
-0.1983790696,
0.0477696955,
-0.0070173997,
-0.1744446456,
0.555180788,
0.1514991671,
-0.1157695204,
-0.3811081052,
0.6605543494,
-0.4165562689,
-0.4743242562,
0.3904473186,
0.1487822086,
-0.4226050079,
0.1082080007,
-0.8607190251,
0.0769825056,
0.0828869343,
-0.0754278004,
0.2534993887,
0.3046404421,
-0.0496863201,
0.8559436798,
0.7612103224,
0.3973899186,
0.2427169979,
0.4344229102,
0.8003311753,
-0.6311873198,
-0.513740778,
-0.9014285207,
0.4260593653,
0.0378539711,
-0.075752221,
0.6559942365,
0.2491905689,
0.8243857622,
-0.1502419412,
0.7245471478,
-0.2181396931,
0.2519603074,
-0.3460602164,
0.2151876688,
-0.469302088,
0.5861335397,
-0.2907335758,
-1.0933918953,
-0.3265294135,
0.3276821971,
-0.5186989903,
0.0150369387,
0.5290397406,
0.7181363702,
-0.1799259335,
-0.3883026838,
0.5730515122,
0.5572639704,
0.3836941421,
0.7061825991,
0.9459406137,
-0.6242578626,
0.438490361,
-0.7400063276,
-0.0662700459,
-0.0507357679,
-0.8826544285,
-1.0868598223,
-0.1732638478,
-0.6742129922,
-0.3357338309,
0.1571895927,
0.9954128265,
0.7656177878,
-1.0209189653,
-0.1528999656,
-0.4799662232,
0.2392597347,
-0.4142432809,
-0.2475330681,
0.1086178124,
-0.2630065978,
-0.6363893747,
0.5189896822,
0.4125378728,
0.2661777437,
-0.1561649442,
-0.012177893,
-0.354604125,
0.0857590809,
0.4596921802,
0.4839965403,
-0.4827876389,
-0.6950442791,
-0.1140302271,
-0.0248776842,
0.1251408607,
0.612100482,
-0.8390911818,
0.2578607202,
0.1502969563,
0.693587482,
0.5259256363,
-0.2085780203,
0.5935173631,
-1.3657510281,
0.561950326,
0.4026783407,
0.0562891364,
0.5900136232,
-0.3550512493,
0.380625546,
0.2478665709,
0.183342427,
-1.1672638655,
0.4439667165,
-0.6043949723,
-0.2388384938,
0.9416679144,
0.296171546,
-0.192932725,
-0.1770775318,
0.0707696378,
0.1612980664,
-0.2327418923,
0.9383124113,
0.4442462921,
0.2114057094,
-0.3805235326,
-0.4987622201,
0.5627682805,
0.7734923959,
-0.587548852,
0.034862563,
0.1520250142,
0.2398359179,
-0.0673580989,
0.9557462335,
0.0661286861,
0.4090822637,
0.0257336143,
-0.0161585622,
0.113499701,
-0.3621821702,
-0.6081264019,
0.1978771389,
0.4016891122,
0.1142473817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13632v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13632v2 | Can Few-shot Work in Long-Context? Recycling the Context to Generate Demonstrations | 2024-06-19T15:28:29 | 2024-06-23T07:19:22 | Arie Cattan, Alon Jacovi, Alex Fabrikant, Jonathan Herzig, Roee Aharoni, Hannah Rashkin, Dror Marcus, Avinatan Hassidim, Yossi Matias, Idan Szpektor, Avi Caciularu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs), their
performance on tasks involving long contexts remains sub-optimal. In-Context
Learning (ICL) with few-shot examples may be an appealing solution to enhance
LLM performance in this scenario; However, naively adding ICL examples with
long context introduces challenges, including substantial token overhead added
for each few-shot example and context mismatch between the demonstrations and
the target query. In this work, we propose to automatically generate few-shot
examples for long context QA tasks by recycling contexts. Specifically, given a
long input context (1-3k tokens) and a query, we generate additional
query-output pairs from the given context as few-shot examples, while
introducing the context only once. This ensures that the demonstrations are
leveraging the same context as the target query while only adding a small
number of tokens to the prompt. We further enhance each demonstration by
instructing the model to explicitly identify the relevant paragraphs before the
answer, which improves performance while providing fine-grained attribution to
the answer source. We apply our method on multiple LLMs and obtain substantial
improvements (+23\% on average across models) on various QA datasets with long
context, especially when the answer lies within the middle of the context.
Surprisingly, despite introducing only single-hop ICL examples, LLMs also
successfully generalize to multi-hop long-context QA using our approach. | [
-0.3406389058,
-0.7633136511,
0.7296848297,
0.1981550157,
-0.5125143528,
-0.3527213931,
-0.207431972,
-0.381447196,
-0.0104623027,
0.4215072393,
-0.614942193,
-0.4373693764,
-0.1493433863,
0.2533130646,
-0.4661276937,
0.9305668473,
0.1404126436,
-0.2089053839,
-0.2538678646,
-0.3241223693,
-0.4117844701,
-0.2106383443,
-0.8494771123,
-0.266997993,
0.4424123764,
0.7328622937,
0.1152528375,
0.3657693267,
0.015450893,
0.2464330494,
-0.1006843448,
0.3334315419,
-0.6929056644,
0.0629199147,
-0.1985854208,
-0.3725660443,
-0.0443861745,
-0.0833677873,
0.8779368401,
0.6216471791,
0.075192295,
0.2615888715,
0.3669944704,
0.4309036732,
-0.7154040933,
-0.0343524702,
-0.7289850712,
-0.1612359583,
-0.2231666744,
-0.289845407,
-0.5708270669,
-0.0630789772,
0.0812530965,
-0.4522607923,
-0.2276580483,
0.0339640789,
0.5369954109,
0.1685275286,
-0.6642637253,
-0.2087423801,
-0.6314860582,
0.8244632483,
-0.9778908491,
-0.1044267714,
0.2430508435,
0.6197706461,
-0.3632007241,
-0.670345366,
-0.6960857511,
-0.0993076265,
-0.2374864966,
-0.0293241218,
-0.2411546707,
-0.1181626916,
0.5238466859,
-0.2750197947,
-0.2863242924,
0.2284025103,
-0.3096382022,
-0.0706078038,
0.4712589383,
0.389179945,
-0.0158670712,
-0.3083651066,
-0.4436307549,
0.130579561,
-1.0896917582,
0.3821339309,
-0.095989652,
0.5445611477,
-0.0802769363,
0.5462257266,
-0.3692094684,
0.7081270814,
0.2139525861,
-0.4563097954,
-0.0341212936,
-0.5245643854,
-0.2744763494,
-0.0959787667,
0.6724717021,
0.2296816409,
0.0249159187,
-0.0136333387,
-0.2281688899,
-0.355230391,
0.0388439298,
-1.0348107815,
0.0407686643,
0.1509656161,
-0.2971606553,
0.002656945,
-0.2834238708,
-0.6803306937,
-0.1963455677,
-0.1885921508,
0.5447484255,
-0.4114195108,
0.2017702311,
-0.0302588772,
-0.0111213,
0.4228409231,
0.4159122407,
-0.5190571547,
0.3006682396,
0.7584711909,
0.6864575148,
-0.304577738,
-0.5326243639,
-1.0729138851,
0.3168029189,
-0.3301434815,
0.7050443292,
-0.3563989997,
-0.3322513103,
0.1645493805,
0.0095492322,
0.1199469492,
-0.6388748884,
0.0427251346,
-0.4680868089,
0.3274975121,
-0.2512713969,
-0.7276098132,
0.1973711103,
0.5613487959,
-0.3860863745,
0.8830251694,
0.1321724504,
-0.6202425361,
0.4960485995,
-0.7622874379,
-0.5357156396,
0.1017569304,
-0.3039829135,
-0.4128269851,
-0.0203948878,
0.2719363272,
0.6032486558,
0.0509099029,
-0.1362204552,
-0.2339511663,
-0.821333468,
0.2154162675,
-0.411755383,
0.7051992416,
-0.1604774594,
-0.4248823822,
0.1253069341,
-0.6382467747,
0.134079963,
-0.0547443591,
-0.4368676543,
-0.4213550389,
-0.2215907276,
0.0085385283,
0.3879859149,
-0.1070881784,
-0.4384397864,
0.4166867137,
-0.666431725,
0.3793386817,
0.6447621584,
0.2810971737,
0.5690171719,
-0.3752371669,
0.6686146259,
0.2045727521,
-0.0195427313,
-0.3913114667,
-0.2304118574,
-0.5884208679,
-0.6472407579,
-0.2087232918,
0.3011361361,
-0.9701788425,
0.0541541651,
-0.3931542933,
-0.1163368076,
-0.3076674044,
0.45913589,
0.4546494484,
0.7473476529,
0.4200477898,
0.1251278669,
-0.3591997027,
-0.8417229652,
-0.3528598845,
-0.236035049,
-0.0736841708,
0.6233136654,
0.6565387249,
-0.0908411816,
1.334338665,
-0.42964679,
-0.2830168903,
-0.4258315861,
0.1067736521,
0.2551202476,
0.3287646174,
0.6885892153,
-0.4464387596,
-0.5901564956,
-0.333835423,
-0.5710980892,
0.0422557443,
-0.2640662789,
-0.2225728035,
0.1526038945,
0.5842295885,
-0.5997796655,
0.3517160714,
0.0951298103,
-0.2109434754,
0.5844959617,
0.0814867988,
0.0304848161,
-1.3747872114,
-0.1035021991,
-0.1036015227,
-0.4798459709,
-0.4218229651,
0.126600042,
0.0683277547,
-0.1016159505,
-1.0656189919,
1.0681550503,
-0.2255779952,
0.0079933209,
-0.5034642816,
0.0920959637,
0.038060762,
0.4984375238,
-0.2072375566,
0.9783760309,
0.5510779619,
-0.8383410573,
0.0978473052,
0.2088919282,
-0.4745829999,
0.4752756655,
-0.5341038704,
0.19372347,
-0.2437127084,
0.5821682215,
-0.9136192799,
-0.3219424784,
0.2110756785,
-0.014599096,
0.1074066609,
-0.4894353449,
-0.547321856,
-0.1500734538,
-0.3608630896,
0.5433705449,
0.6901572347,
-0.8439148068,
0.2743584216,
-0.1157542095,
0.0040371623,
-0.6327038407,
-0.7111488581,
-0.0316329151,
-0.5793030262,
-0.4477603137,
0.3379480243,
-0.0995918736,
-0.0323818475,
-0.2972480357,
0.0325171947,
-0.149379611,
0.1719689965,
0.2668347359,
-0.1516357511,
-0.2369718552,
0.4530429244,
0.0624777861,
0.1672130227,
-0.1228908673,
-0.2921323776,
0.3792331517,
-0.1467816532,
-0.5616750717,
-0.6533549428,
0.6044741869,
0.5755463243,
0.0461439416,
0.4586790204,
0.5014691353,
-0.4402752817,
-0.5217624903,
-0.4101738334,
-0.447590977,
-0.4702822268,
0.3232248425,
-0.5249967575,
-0.958878696,
0.4439047575,
-0.1606820524,
0.1472480297,
0.0169816334,
0.3522510827,
-0.3150742948,
0.8403012156,
0.677862525,
-0.3185740709,
0.6675422788,
-0.4307881594,
0.1275263578,
-0.6867289543,
0.1673591435,
-0.3220411241,
-0.2823778391,
-0.2918356657,
-0.391238302,
0.6884136796,
0.3207777441,
-0.1841320246,
0.2071542144,
-0.0824219063,
0.8781856894,
0.4270695448,
0.2638620436,
0.2105525583,
-0.0661770776,
-0.000514971,
0.2420209497,
-0.85044384,
-0.6616082191,
1.0316106081,
0.1244167462,
0.6641432643,
0.1664337516,
1.3433409929,
-0.1425325722,
0.3704985082,
-1.032984376,
0.6728495359,
-0.004418279,
-0.3867838383,
-0.5351593494,
-0.1855499148,
-0.9616179466,
0.1483868361,
0.0797483549,
-0.6925087571,
-0.1670659482,
0.3107808232,
-0.7233703136,
0.0362806432,
-0.5399988294,
0.9306774735,
0.182354942,
-0.6534373164,
-0.2200193256,
-0.544159472,
0.4694848657,
0.0113968849,
-0.0022411174,
-0.0184613597,
0.0982711986,
0.6168069243,
-0.455717355,
1.0359859467,
-0.2480964065,
0.0129074557,
0.6242772937,
0.051942993,
0.7268671989,
0.3034546077,
-0.1028023213,
-0.4574070275,
0.1438073069,
-0.5971145034,
-0.8087610602,
0.6719802022,
-0.2482107282,
-0.6628213525,
-0.0800749511,
-0.2968586683,
-0.2398907095,
0.0754266828,
0.2658468187,
0.5938017964,
-0.1608566195,
0.142230615,
0.2929024696,
-0.0618022904,
0.7672832012,
0.4003582001,
-0.0368728451,
0.0282018073,
0.5183669329,
-0.1499150097,
0.2478376329,
0.1896673739,
0.3055075705,
-0.2656988502,
-0.5892355442,
-0.4269298613,
0.1053000465,
-0.9250130057,
-0.3339833319,
-0.5132035613,
0.1718201935,
-0.3752679527,
-0.2695358396,
-0.2591125369,
-0.1496708095,
-0.3929322064,
0.160132587,
0.2258643061,
0.3557379246,
0.284053117,
0.4854375422,
-0.9191052318,
0.3645118177,
0.6917513013,
0.1076457053,
0.0992735103,
-0.5057448149,
-0.3074699938,
0.0687495843,
-0.2092518061,
-0.7112858891,
0.3385837078,
0.3850185871,
0.3268930614,
0.4687067866,
0.1182305887,
1.1229032278,
-0.7602268457,
1.0124138594,
-0.0324059986,
-0.9318148494,
0.5676474571,
-0.1148443744,
0.7549920082,
0.8371171951,
0.3302715421,
-0.4449067712,
-0.4438872337,
-0.2515033185,
-0.7751156092,
0.5964430571,
-0.0180837344,
0.4150874019,
-0.3997223079,
0.3988542855,
0.1919277012,
-0.0768101662,
-0.7809084654,
0.1200369373,
0.1257235557,
-0.150533393,
0.129281193,
-0.2516582012,
-0.3947736621,
-0.1900798082,
0.6703151464,
-0.7378088236,
0.1191084981,
0.1087930724,
-0.3945609629,
0.1344690323,
0.6691372991,
0.6686452627,
0.9351875782,
0.0060335244,
0.1161588579,
0.4358803928,
0.1503437161,
0.174356699,
-0.2974742949,
-0.1563786119,
-0.0251504276,
0.5255807638,
0.5189684629,
0.354245156,
-0.8810679913,
0.8573997617,
0.16760993,
0.2374521047,
-0.4871517718,
-0.1621682793,
0.0135339322,
0.5597890019,
0.4910985827,
-0.3603048027,
0.1846307963,
-0.779720962,
0.4586868882,
0.6107771397,
-0.1454812288,
-0.1150019541,
0.2811622918,
0.1702457815,
-0.1486558318,
0.8192589283,
-0.6127245426,
-0.5417463183,
0.7061092257,
0.7470260859,
0.8125240803,
0.4994439781,
0.0624631569,
0.2854782343,
-0.1967622191,
-0.1745489985,
0.1534698606,
-0.2605009973,
-0.5108246207,
-0.5675640106,
-0.3448407054,
-0.2426653802,
0.1275698543,
-0.4500850737,
0.524604857,
-0.2909033597,
-0.022448387,
-0.0472769439,
-0.0930586457,
-0.8150575161,
-0.0803076178,
0.1134318411,
0.7892926931,
-0.850777626,
0.9997544885,
0.5353891253,
-0.4406293631,
-0.6808701754,
0.1846890748,
0.0250977725,
-0.5089137554,
0.9114804268,
0.3021755815,
-0.3500871658,
-0.1914907545,
-0.9443353415,
-0.5098115206,
1.3091973066,
0.1719024479,
-0.5252924562,
-0.155323714,
-0.0682052821,
0.5013279319,
-0.6750202775,
0.1839520484,
0.3584890664,
0.1163070425,
0.0659189224,
-0.9959660769,
0.1420656741,
0.1763463616,
-0.1781724989,
-0.0027398348,
-0.6245473623,
0.6174090505,
-0.4287758768,
-0.3368397653,
0.3479179442,
0.684540391,
0.5880880952,
0.6855648756,
0.672172308,
0.1967224032,
0.444541961,
0.3066116273,
1.0279009342,
-0.1638896018,
0.2764376104,
1.4658710957,
-0.4362260103,
1.0562102795,
0.8327940106,
0.0051042438,
0.3839257658,
0.3907104433,
0.2896451652,
0.5618306398,
0.2308449745,
-0.3936233222,
-0.4057353437,
-0.0429079048,
-0.0203921739,
0.6905929446,
0.1050017327,
-0.2397845536,
-0.5040338039,
0.3523028493,
-0.016497381,
0.0445785448,
-0.1541921794,
0.9179296494,
0.1559919715,
-0.6675466895,
0.7706173658,
-0.1085189208,
0.9124709368,
-0.5046117902,
-0.2060490102,
-0.3841720223,
-0.0499304757,
-0.0859214216,
-0.5342676044,
0.2210188955,
0.0241295211,
-0.1530705392,
-0.2966563702,
0.5784038901,
-0.5678052306,
-0.1648432761,
0.0100367572,
0.5563902855,
0.4294806123,
-0.1082335487,
-0.3943430483,
-0.405719012,
-0.1731593311,
-0.1294597536,
0.5564190149,
0.4817326665,
-0.154074654,
0.8288170695,
0.3878584802,
-0.2123132497,
0.1129528731,
0.0152518461,
0.9409021735,
-0.7499158382,
-0.4603243172,
-0.9097269773,
0.5595833659,
-0.0806998983,
-0.3704900444,
0.5677078962,
0.6502355337,
0.9461715221,
-0.1981403083,
0.5945308208,
0.2771980166,
0.3653516769,
-0.7292664051,
0.5926439762,
-0.6976055503,
0.349620074,
-0.0850495622,
-0.6756167412,
-0.0864319801,
0.2877727747,
-0.0420056283,
-0.1314101368,
0.7741476893,
0.8444774151,
-0.3015297055,
-0.4046002328,
0.4133491516,
-0.0211996734,
0.553717792,
0.850938499,
0.81599015,
-0.4238573015,
0.6305980086,
-0.4269804358,
0.1092042923,
-0.4353486598,
-1.1298912764,
-0.8752014637,
-0.4560851455,
-0.5068231225,
-0.2627213597,
0.0543723553,
1.3179036379,
0.8960376978,
-0.6322159171,
-0.2146250308,
0.33508569,
0.2927499115,
-0.362916261,
-0.3025355935,
0.3560651839,
-0.4847760499,
-0.8949528337,
0.8154566288,
0.2562636733,
0.1806087345,
-0.1160419136,
0.1243931949,
-0.1510659903,
0.0571524389,
1.0656479597,
0.4427565336,
-0.846295774,
-0.7175946832,
-0.0805483535,
-0.2931903899,
0.0754668936,
0.8850002289,
-1.2082406282,
0.2544499934,
0.5468426943,
0.8246934414,
0.5563806891,
0.0453930534,
0.2879385352,
-1.2387604713,
0.1719526947,
0.4858685434,
0.2570176125,
0.1345483214,
-0.1620420814,
0.2684383094,
-0.1517128199,
-0.2905961275,
-0.9011175632,
0.4909512103,
-1.1497473717,
-0.3899480402,
1.449882865,
-0.3392023444,
-0.1827682406,
0.0466803722,
-0.1049435586,
0.0720305964,
-0.4205341637,
0.8645954132,
0.6067038774,
-0.372638166,
-0.1710646003,
-0.2756774127,
0.5572279692,
0.4653796852,
-0.9618921876,
0.0222930554,
0.6448162794,
0.5775863528,
-0.1757832319,
0.8001083136,
0.1229949892,
0.2992681563,
-0.3264500499,
-0.4275403917,
-0.0862219557,
-0.3278434575,
-0.5355997682,
0.294816345,
0.1950428039,
-0.3182336986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13629v1 | InstructRAG: Instructing Retrieval-Augmented Generation with Explicit Denoising | 2024-06-19T15:25:29 | 2024-06-19T15:25:29 | Zhepei Wei, Wei-Lin Chen, Yu Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has shown promising potential to enhance
the accuracy and factuality of language models (LMs). However, imperfect
retrievers or noisy corpora can introduce misleading or even erroneous
information to the retrieved contents, posing a significant challenge to the
generation quality. Existing RAG methods typically address this challenge by
directly predicting final answers despite potentially noisy inputs, resulting
in an implicit denoising process that is difficult to interpret and verify. On
the other hand, the acquisition of explicit denoising supervision is often
costly, involving significant human efforts. In this work, we propose
InstructRAG, where LMs explicitly learn the denoising process through
self-synthesized rationales -- First, we instruct the LM to explain how the
ground-truth answer is derived from retrieved documents. Then, these rationales
can be used either as demonstrations for in-context learning of explicit
denoising or as supervised fine-tuning data to train the model. Compared to
standard RAG approaches, InstructRAG requires no additional supervision, allows
for easier verification of the predicted answers, and effectively improves
generation accuracy. Experiments show InstructRAG consistently outperforms
existing RAG methods in both training-free and trainable scenarios, achieving a
relative improvement of 8.3% over the best baseline method on average across
five knowledge-intensive benchmarks. Extensive analysis indicates that
InstructRAG scales well with increased numbers of retrieved documents and
consistently exhibits robust denoising ability even in out-of-domain datasets,
demonstrating strong generalizability. | [
-0.4644856453,
-0.736784935,
0.2255672067,
0.1716308296,
-0.0804432929,
0.2298413366,
-0.3090918958,
-0.217907086,
-0.1916530877,
0.6223505139,
-0.325883925,
-0.3335977197,
-0.3944210112,
0.067818433,
-0.5466305614,
1.2332960367,
0.045290295,
-0.0367464572,
-0.2911245227,
0.2212389857,
-0.4969662428,
-0.3026123643,
-0.6232860088,
-0.3774780333,
0.0492431857,
0.466581583,
0.3110617697,
0.3549496531,
-0.0046596862,
0.1949622929,
-0.0883078873,
0.4641912878,
-0.6493662,
0.3439464867,
-0.086600557,
-0.3003371358,
-0.1479161978,
-0.0420955718,
0.7319517732,
0.6409857869,
-0.4095275402,
0.3474259973,
0.3459350467,
0.7128424048,
-0.8509535193,
-0.0143121816,
-1.0138173103,
-0.1132268012,
0.0121419942,
-0.3146381676,
-0.7548555136,
-0.349098742,
-0.3576644957,
-0.6425245404,
0.6009639502,
0.1889038384,
0.7115365267,
0.5694916844,
-0.2361992151,
-0.4803179204,
-0.8395630717,
0.6576095819,
-0.5521519184,
0.3550187647,
0.6937274337,
0.2520478666,
-0.4444814324,
-0.9590398669,
-0.6178304553,
-0.1192738041,
-0.2962547243,
0.4247250557,
-0.1942446381,
0.1368091106,
0.3056938648,
0.4673576057,
-0.4977304637,
-0.0014900502,
-0.6273673177,
0.140024364,
0.4617421925,
-0.1422964633,
0.1341119111,
-0.2595904768,
-0.5018830299,
-0.0742294118,
-0.8799464703,
-0.2164307088,
0.3704893291,
0.185510397,
0.0638957471,
0.3361130953,
-0.2272957563,
0.6377527118,
0.7108092904,
-0.2643008232,
0.0557899885,
-0.0072431918,
-0.3365371227,
0.3543342054,
0.4659387767,
0.0685005113,
-0.161346525,
-0.3082857132,
-0.4134808481,
0.0883067921,
0.6051948071,
-1.0032359362,
-0.2630327642,
0.1256836951,
-0.0754643679,
-0.4639684856,
-0.1486006677,
-0.9291036725,
-0.29073596,
-0.4043292403,
0.7046152353,
-0.3673955202,
-0.2155133933,
0.1494359374,
-0.0737791285,
0.1421373338,
0.298537612,
-0.9953351617,
0.450226754,
0.6081448197,
0.4996364713,
0.1467337608,
-0.0095368167,
-0.8468850255,
0.3838250935,
-0.6498154998,
0.8399592638,
-0.4284549356,
-0.5055260658,
-0.0663859323,
-0.1497881562,
-0.1977380961,
-0.7902570367,
0.8296223879,
-0.5639004111,
0.6119195819,
0.090263404,
-0.9642999172,
-0.2474413067,
0.0913020745,
-0.3646586835,
1.2741962671,
0.4143366814,
-0.7920255065,
0.3604778051,
-0.4207739532,
-0.2668431997,
0.2854772508,
-0.1060836837,
-0.3644210994,
-0.0485874265,
0.433878243,
0.4757151008,
-0.139432773,
0.4616817832,
0.1431556642,
-0.4141705632,
-0.1378091574,
-0.6340022087,
0.749319911,
0.3477678299,
-0.4296146929,
-0.102960825,
-0.7457754612,
-0.0832447261,
-0.121788837,
-0.3473159969,
-0.3641762733,
-0.3393339217,
-0.3162859082,
-0.2754180431,
-0.0825612172,
-0.6763513684,
0.1015133634,
-0.677492559,
-0.1014910638,
0.5663669109,
0.3414738774,
0.7565936446,
-0.5103162527,
0.7397010922,
-0.3356823325,
0.0982093439,
-0.1663864255,
-0.2525455356,
-0.6947158575,
-0.3602273166,
0.2921793759,
0.2869051993,
-0.7376943827,
0.0563522391,
-0.1052268595,
-0.5580125451,
-0.7461496592,
0.3362600803,
0.7727173567,
1.0639022589,
0.5568946004,
0.1569554806,
-0.5030290484,
-0.5217105746,
-0.1182439625,
-0.0828994215,
-0.0518300906,
0.0533088446,
0.2708766758,
-0.3030947447,
0.7609952092,
-0.3424209654,
-0.2909882665,
-0.1532102823,
0.4588911533,
0.2345181555,
0.5511505604,
0.4306973219,
-0.9105802774,
-0.7179160118,
-0.044304058,
-0.7104222178,
-0.3347327411,
-0.1032172665,
-0.0862225667,
0.4662764072,
0.7258611321,
-0.5310072303,
0.4950478077,
0.5745104551,
0.0067753242,
0.8344891667,
-0.5420944095,
0.0724304542,
-1.0504493713,
0.079238221,
-0.3445807993,
-0.0945739672,
-0.555362761,
0.070656091,
0.0313636065,
-0.0288717616,
-0.0926346034,
0.692291379,
-0.5420006514,
0.1292233467,
-0.1534581333,
0.0307304356,
0.2370244414,
0.525904417,
-0.2952143848,
1.0476408005,
0.1720437706,
-0.7187264562,
-0.1000403687,
0.5216156244,
-0.5387804508,
0.5355043411,
-0.6394065619,
0.1459029168,
-0.641217947,
0.2475635558,
-0.9317899942,
-0.4113718867,
0.1621872485,
-0.4712587595,
0.8136940002,
-0.8360872865,
-0.4136478305,
0.0197033379,
-0.0927606151,
0.0668789819,
0.7175283432,
-0.9821395278,
0.4810100794,
0.5098250508,
-0.1603308171,
-0.9386328459,
-0.2064818442,
-0.0871675462,
-0.3694933951,
-0.1077539474,
0.5747949481,
-0.1957280785,
-0.3587115407,
0.0683849975,
-0.0384925567,
-0.3183980882,
-0.0281218085,
0.3953966796,
0.1213910878,
0.1055179089,
0.3605334163,
0.5846717358,
-0.1504101157,
0.0610071607,
-0.0952643529,
0.3202814162,
0.0066438345,
-0.1844163984,
-0.040650595,
0.1547017843,
0.2940438688,
-0.3595764935,
0.4641336799,
0.7783312798,
-0.1579366773,
-0.8248984814,
-0.50292027,
-0.329886198,
-0.5273804069,
0.0448402949,
-0.272916764,
-0.8164991736,
-0.0399068594,
-0.2636826336,
0.3424017131,
0.1880564541,
0.3798893988,
-0.3641305268,
0.7911273241,
0.3433999717,
0.3115143776,
0.318018198,
-0.573580265,
-0.0306695569,
-1.0407201052,
-0.2916444838,
-0.4964869618,
0.177079469,
-0.3899759352,
-0.4878019989,
0.7151734829,
0.4454067349,
-0.3560146391,
0.0580419041,
-0.8347290158,
0.4795819223,
0.555357933,
0.1666600257,
0.2684774697,
0.3800728917,
0.0475346446,
-0.1147792861,
-1.0004122257,
-0.4015049338,
0.9626359344,
-0.0858427137,
0.8275600076,
-0.0718436241,
0.9539415836,
0.4292967618,
0.581700623,
-0.6216835976,
0.314120084,
-0.2262787074,
-0.6428044438,
-0.2629563212,
-0.4082295597,
-1.1748483181,
0.3584678769,
-0.3334908485,
-0.1054696292,
0.1472511888,
0.3849927783,
-0.269726038,
0.3211896718,
-0.5541094542,
0.5620061159,
0.0396749377,
-0.4366823435,
-0.4023459852,
-0.5199750066,
0.4795727134,
-0.1553269774,
0.4017815292,
0.048424568,
0.2607391775,
0.598839879,
-0.3654763401,
0.978421092,
-0.3220031261,
-0.2071568966,
0.5025178194,
0.4467501044,
0.5602853298,
0.00374749,
-0.1563670486,
-0.2968587279,
0.0286395997,
-0.0168625806,
-0.902328372,
0.6329714656,
-0.4436984062,
-0.6211803555,
-0.0288404338,
-0.505422473,
-0.2727680504,
0.2161076367,
0.4230612814,
0.9896745086,
-0.0634941608,
0.1906192005,
0.8749386668,
-0.208168,
0.3333123922,
0.4026785195,
-0.2870882154,
-0.7114499211,
0.905021131,
0.2161927819,
0.1340876222,
0.5249465704,
0.3573203683,
-0.4644448757,
-0.4388019741,
-0.8144664168,
0.248884201,
-0.7451396585,
-0.3992048502,
-0.7394384742,
-0.0987581313,
-0.2068718225,
-0.2663059533,
-0.3567388952,
-0.4690948725,
-0.1013867483,
-0.0991401002,
0.4617550671,
0.8907160759,
-0.2804935575,
0.2501596808,
-0.6812355518,
0.4670357704,
0.3894878626,
0.1053721532,
-0.071652934,
-0.9733595252,
-0.3100630939,
0.2586624324,
-0.0719247162,
-0.6562793851,
0.4942226112,
0.2860278487,
0.6443554759,
0.1405932605,
0.5908579826,
0.8865150809,
-0.4953865707,
0.3808908165,
-0.2768948078,
-0.6929274797,
0.4549954832,
-0.3291753232,
-0.0296921134,
0.6367368102,
0.3513046205,
-0.081253536,
-0.5093070269,
-0.8844923377,
-0.6777432561,
0.3902887106,
0.0052094893,
0.3123161495,
-0.0483266748,
0.5033281446,
0.2858376801,
0.3125157654,
-0.3376311362,
0.0370921083,
-0.1482919604,
-0.2007321119,
0.1061796173,
-0.5952450633,
-0.0513256043,
-0.2931239307,
0.8908029795,
0.0243742131,
0.0591708981,
0.3152835071,
-0.1581541747,
-0.19652915,
0.3281770945,
0.4908471406,
0.5483218431,
-0.2748041153,
0.3017567098,
0.3027264476,
-0.350936532,
0.1594230831,
-0.1645230204,
-0.6330212355,
0.3173833489,
0.2156522572,
0.5187581778,
0.4062637389,
-0.4953805208,
0.423487246,
0.1594468951,
-0.0860218853,
-0.6309940219,
0.1358835101,
-0.1770280898,
0.069798395,
0.2143438011,
0.1424881667,
0.2081471384,
-0.1403455138,
0.2922205925,
0.4031663239,
-0.1845089346,
-0.2338537723,
0.7971159816,
-0.0422712415,
-0.0399445891,
0.5685364008,
-0.4157928526,
-0.448423624,
0.2676579952,
0.7875775099,
0.8139505386,
-0.2663484216,
0.3309356868,
0.7866951227,
0.2405181676,
-0.212513566,
0.0640960112,
-0.3538655937,
-0.6988753676,
-0.6338173747,
-0.8915698528,
-0.5212320089,
0.0074467473,
-0.7671532035,
-0.0972178951,
-0.3416015208,
0.0694398955,
-0.2284596264,
-0.0404641926,
-0.201559335,
0.2982670665,
-0.3169198334,
0.6034724712,
-0.4802199602,
0.8103511333,
0.466165781,
-0.4034448266,
-0.9727556705,
-0.0520680659,
-0.3708822727,
-0.4810958803,
0.7864306569,
-0.0740729123,
-0.4995390773,
0.3524214029,
-0.7485927939,
-0.4319958985,
0.7377476692,
0.7388678789,
-0.1502521187,
0.2478004545,
-0.2992046177,
0.4834750891,
-0.2305691093,
-0.0523338206,
0.0263436493,
0.4045474231,
0.1347717494,
-0.6998649836,
-0.0757972747,
-0.1427179277,
-0.3216324151,
0.2197734267,
-0.3426592052,
0.7744000554,
-0.3019422889,
-0.553709805,
-0.0219882689,
0.4541489482,
0.2287071645,
0.3769153655,
0.4151721597,
0.6435029507,
0.8476814032,
0.3709521592,
1.1571381092,
-0.2715488076,
0.1113996431,
1.5028376579,
-0.0014878268,
0.9520335793,
0.2552753985,
-0.050642129,
0.721973896,
0.0175714511,
0.0958396345,
0.3793649375,
-0.1642673612,
-0.5567848682,
-0.1497529149,
-0.2975249588,
-0.2780771255,
0.5635265112,
0.4078272581,
-0.1210834906,
-0.2603126466,
-0.0885647759,
0.3890012503,
0.529574573,
-0.2494450212,
0.8399549723,
-0.0954327211,
-0.8365603089,
1.1306158304,
-0.2272848636,
0.5206279159,
-0.4662237167,
-0.4732449949,
-0.5024981499,
0.2431683987,
-0.3451357782,
-0.6164669991,
0.3232854009,
0.0700228587,
-0.2810539305,
-0.4346113205,
0.8253227472,
-0.7220827937,
-0.4618459642,
-0.0236629061,
0.362073034,
0.213300705,
0.0049351184,
-0.2645925879,
-0.2802251577,
-0.0053191213,
0.0303549524,
0.3436702788,
0.3776203394,
-0.0033866917,
0.7748188376,
0.7076987624,
0.0168633759,
0.0110421395,
-0.1026488543,
0.7591167688,
-0.0553767793,
-0.1948565245,
-0.4811969399,
0.3768500686,
-0.1211307868,
-0.1107824966,
1.0540204048,
0.5912411809,
1.0449860096,
-0.1989025772,
0.7391331196,
-0.0128555223,
0.9184728265,
-0.5708733797,
0.8608732224,
-0.5174748898,
0.2400876284,
-0.1656044722,
-0.6155349612,
-0.194786489,
0.5645781755,
-0.0616312288,
-0.1236306056,
0.2961593568,
1.2067557573,
-0.1336330026,
-0.2487361878,
0.3853707016,
0.2698846459,
0.1562399119,
0.0427572355,
0.9522608519,
-0.3881935477,
0.4872981906,
-0.6930178404,
-0.0520279258,
0.0723379105,
-0.6914960742,
-0.8817872405,
-0.5475974679,
-0.2185961157,
-0.3671066165,
0.1063134074,
0.8176916838,
0.5481986403,
-0.6336590052,
-0.2214991301,
-0.166900143,
0.176010251,
-0.119695805,
-0.2147727907,
0.4480254948,
-0.7795940638,
-0.7359393835,
0.8802599907,
0.051173348,
0.0145486724,
-0.1462168247,
-0.2279272974,
0.1232038662,
-0.1032207012,
0.6777850986,
0.3558277786,
-0.414283812,
-0.0386387892,
-0.2197808325,
0.0053266361,
-0.1653342694,
0.5618802905,
-1.0796735287,
0.7328713536,
0.3118955791,
0.5884248018,
0.7316356301,
0.2979677916,
0.5084931254,
-0.9770494699,
0.3176587522,
0.2678354383,
0.1744884104,
0.4064476788,
-0.254752636,
0.82824862,
0.0227488019,
-0.6884367466,
-1.1542150974,
0.1693078578,
-0.6041004658,
-0.2661302984,
1.1359171867,
-0.1046840623,
-0.0464673713,
-0.2749477327,
-0.4614846408,
0.3498409092,
-0.1412165612,
1.011059761,
-0.1309140325,
0.1571313739,
-0.2277032882,
-0.6596828103,
0.9095150828,
0.3303604424,
-0.6311168075,
0.2244823724,
0.69245857,
0.169326812,
-0.0862420127,
0.4588038623,
-0.0682936907,
0.1723068208,
0.332724005,
0.1699599624,
-0.3666901886,
-0.3686306477,
-0.1911547631,
0.2968544066,
0.1434375793,
0.0069192033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13626v1 | Fine-Tuning Gemma-7B for Enhanced Sentiment Analysis of Financial News Headlines | 2024-06-19T15:20:19 | 2024-06-19T15:20:19 | Kangtong Mo, Wenyan Liu, Xuanzhen Xu, Chang Yu, Yuelin Zou, Fangqing Xia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this study, we explore the application of sentiment analysis on financial
news headlines to understand investor sentiment. By leveraging Natural Language
Processing (NLP) and Large Language Models (LLM), we analyze sentiment from the
perspective of retail investors. The FinancialPhraseBank dataset, which
contains categorized sentiments of financial news headlines, serves as the
basis for our analysis. We fine-tuned several models, including
distilbert-base-uncased, Llama, and gemma-7b, to evaluate their effectiveness
in sentiment classification. Our experiments demonstrate that the fine-tuned
gemma-7b model outperforms others, achieving the highest precision, recall, and
F1 score. Specifically, the gemma-7b model showed significant improvements in
accuracy after fine-tuning, indicating its robustness in capturing the nuances
of financial sentiment. This model can be instrumental in providing market
insights, risk management, and aiding investment decisions by accurately
predicting the sentiment of financial news. The results highlight the potential
of advanced LLMs in transforming how we analyze and interpret financial
information, offering a powerful tool for stakeholders in the financial
industry. | [
-0.2666755915,
-0.7989700437,
-0.0417848378,
0.7594152689,
-0.4730711579,
0.3912577331,
-0.2179451287,
-0.5792152882,
0.3146043718,
0.4837372303,
-0.2578906715,
-0.8158056736,
-0.8471723795,
0.217742905,
-0.3968471587,
1.1720074415,
0.345037967,
0.533033371,
0.2378611714,
0.0900979489,
-0.401422739,
-0.1877065301,
-1.0390795469,
-0.1674479693,
0.4231846929,
0.1198045239,
1.1162688732,
0.4082224071,
1.1235921383,
0.2183198035,
-0.598846674,
0.4055974782,
-0.362231493,
-0.5269200802,
-0.1878445894,
-0.4549413025,
-0.8272548914,
0.071791485,
0.4125724435,
0.5670570731,
-0.1773219407,
0.2363067716,
0.3585217297,
0.8913038969,
-0.369081825,
0.6354258657,
-0.5767790675,
0.0620920062,
-0.166313529,
-0.5954213142,
-0.6299278736,
-0.363684535,
0.1180869192,
-0.3535098732,
0.1333309263,
0.1724302322,
1.075204134,
0.2832947373,
-0.4184567034,
-0.4812727273,
-0.3347896338,
0.7403992414,
-0.6467143893,
0.3057418168,
0.1820443273,
0.2497939467,
-0.2642755508,
-0.4362950623,
-0.0246943869,
-0.1828805506,
0.0879751667,
0.1959369928,
-0.5083293319,
0.125217095,
-0.1030775681,
0.7602714896,
-0.1954379678,
0.1540340483,
-0.5796759725,
0.007077971,
0.5833827257,
0.118916437,
-0.0446159206,
-0.3355711102,
-0.5264199376,
-0.1412631273,
-0.7750682235,
0.0413788818,
0.4999162853,
0.8206263185,
-0.0431156717,
0.4971036315,
-0.2766367495,
0.6794507504,
0.4335837662,
-0.4179389775,
0.3176667988,
-0.0300964247,
-0.4851149619,
0.3736505508,
0.2854996622,
0.75455302,
0.1984300464,
0.0129881641,
-0.1546750665,
0.0524953343,
0.3608580828,
-0.7882234454,
-0.2452834845,
0.1972153038,
-0.8427831531,
-0.6166905165,
0.1182878837,
-0.9302854538,
-0.5628938079,
-0.4688741565,
0.1663190573,
-0.2063007802,
-0.0832870603,
0.7937538028,
-0.3815190792,
0.5722500086,
0.4606753588,
-0.839405179,
0.0987251028,
0.7872235179,
0.6263872981,
0.0642734692,
0.1141791567,
-0.6488662362,
0.0915974826,
-0.4139392674,
0.9076981544,
-0.5794956684,
-0.590780139,
-0.0624786168,
-0.3193207383,
0.0018966887,
-0.7553792,
0.501283288,
-0.4668698311,
-0.0625406131,
-0.2820264399,
-0.4256852865,
-0.3422295451,
0.42613554,
-0.651398778,
0.7481175065,
0.1543389559,
-0.9135308266,
0.641946733,
-0.8270633817,
-0.3809191585,
-0.1071914434,
0.2704597414,
-0.4513085783,
0.31076774,
0.6376844645,
0.4937859178,
-0.5376229882,
0.1860903203,
-0.5193706155,
-0.1022672057,
0.4983429313,
-0.5476753116,
0.3684620261,
0.2860784531,
-0.1676207036,
-0.0243167002,
-0.8245453835,
-0.4687382579,
-0.111280933,
-0.2495981306,
-0.313673377,
0.08991988,
0.2810264826,
-0.1009286642,
0.625965476,
-0.432014972,
0.2640979886,
-0.5001087785,
0.3486428261,
0.7518674731,
0.0338097885,
0.4904473126,
-0.2249003351,
0.5992183089,
0.2173126191,
0.5395158529,
0.0934250727,
-0.3552620113,
-0.4826785624,
-0.4902627468,
0.3202519417,
0.522341907,
0.1224706322,
0.3345292211,
-0.0946996063,
-0.4400265813,
-0.6744487882,
0.338081032,
-0.0186005123,
0.3469264507,
0.6070090532,
-0.0664756075,
-0.5082300901,
-0.8530442715,
-0.6003681421,
-0.1511397362,
0.2926340699,
-0.0372265577,
-0.1419070214,
-0.3384082913,
0.8219611049,
-0.8344421387,
-0.5160805583,
-0.4337340295,
0.2309675962,
0.6506954432,
0.1628043503,
0.7855147719,
-0.9978976846,
-0.1395120472,
0.260099113,
-0.4335767329,
0.0347499885,
-0.3927942812,
0.0001697343,
0.036669787,
0.5918521881,
-0.563819468,
0.5163697004,
0.3831820786,
-0.67180264,
0.2025827467,
0.1289688796,
0.0082061402,
-1.1897054911,
-0.3813187778,
0.286816299,
-0.2391459346,
-0.1623250544,
0.0601315759,
-0.071809873,
0.1630242914,
-0.2240621448,
0.5461052656,
-0.2781481147,
-0.0711401328,
-0.5290953517,
-0.0326053202,
0.1869537979,
0.0312158167,
-0.0968614817,
0.7122850418,
0.5814471245,
-0.2561007142,
0.2239256054,
0.2370123714,
-0.3274480104,
0.3207898438,
-0.488027513,
-0.3730654716,
-0.0447271243,
-0.0144076571,
-1.1192952394,
-0.0483991057,
0.0542377271,
-0.4819935262,
0.3160505593,
0.1021968424,
-0.5620676875,
-0.1417881995,
-0.3004192412,
-0.0058550127,
0.2203715295,
-0.7009503245,
0.7747932076,
0.2133452892,
-0.391271919,
-0.5571869016,
-0.5428521037,
0.382055372,
-0.6917254329,
-0.4682433307,
0.264221698,
0.1921030134,
-0.4965035915,
-0.2521166503,
-0.2102460563,
0.1904094815,
0.3364759088,
0.153792426,
0.5831605196,
-0.1213771775,
-0.0387557894,
0.1257226467,
-0.2841493785,
0.2474283129,
-0.1273694932,
0.4628618658,
-0.4058664441,
0.129278034,
-0.2988057435,
0.0509059392,
0.4906855822,
-0.3321579993,
0.9095799923,
0.6064007282,
-0.2060825229,
-0.0428934805,
-0.5353245735,
0.1664869338,
-0.5462489128,
0.4172851741,
-0.121273011,
-0.9472655058,
0.7263500094,
-0.0172364339,
-0.0872200355,
0.6957715154,
0.7192967534,
0.1323056668,
1.1152291298,
0.7484533191,
-0.4705494642,
0.491476208,
-0.1164412275,
0.600579381,
-0.4071413577,
-0.2713133097,
-0.4395878613,
-0.4212261736,
-0.5439355969,
-0.123509258,
0.2248619646,
0.3749081194,
-0.0273715872,
0.1817617714,
-0.3402225971,
0.3774274588,
0.3550305068,
0.1412743777,
0.4866630435,
-0.0694008097,
-0.0078040883,
0.152230382,
-0.2093329281,
-0.6023126841,
1.0357910395,
0.7612687349,
1.1584342718,
0.0107441442,
0.4986819923,
0.4996023476,
0.4419978857,
-0.7968214154,
0.2573078275,
-0.4044659734,
-0.3032543957,
0.0480893068,
-0.4398514926,
-0.4845720232,
-0.1600786299,
-0.1556874365,
-0.4232747555,
0.4813553989,
0.0517122932,
-0.7071914077,
0.1296982467,
-0.5496790409,
0.7462138534,
0.0948596746,
0.0284675974,
-0.373691082,
0.0131886117,
0.4318525195,
-0.0845291093,
0.2904193997,
-0.3411226273,
0.1702305377,
0.4193600714,
-0.1701449901,
0.9571382999,
-0.0374099985,
-0.5680404902,
0.2085776627,
-0.2840925753,
0.3919283748,
0.6373261213,
-0.167680949,
0.1847904921,
-0.2086295485,
-0.5368456841,
-0.342202872,
0.5948500633,
-0.720050931,
-0.5459758043,
-0.3424859941,
-0.6439238191,
-0.1737641841,
-0.3075036705,
0.16220963,
0.3324376047,
-0.0983223692,
0.4072948694,
0.1814280897,
-0.0205482021,
0.4165990949,
0.2476987988,
-0.4634572566,
-0.6137681603,
0.6750466228,
-0.092230238,
0.0431410633,
0.6518681049,
0.2658014297,
-0.5451464653,
-0.7833080888,
-0.116663374,
-0.0970855132,
-0.6677307487,
-0.6422100663,
-0.4090997875,
-0.0360543281,
-0.5965600014,
-0.3241902888,
-0.5207995176,
-0.1824421287,
-0.7011097074,
-0.5810400844,
0.7500628233,
0.5582479835,
0.0319484361,
0.4502171874,
-1.1754386425,
0.4150058925,
0.1123591363,
0.2810233235,
-0.1648354977,
-0.5420445204,
-0.5907372236,
0.1199326366,
-0.4646590054,
-0.6221266389,
0.7306463718,
0.1218330115,
0.0921655074,
0.9434891939,
0.0536030456,
0.9119008183,
0.2042411864,
0.4424053729,
0.1121826619,
-0.8755649328,
0.4136683047,
-0.6154760718,
0.2079217136,
0.5523692966,
0.0338387378,
-0.0942120403,
-0.7149121761,
-0.2209367007,
-0.8628243804,
0.0941593871,
0.0583846606,
0.1596317738,
-0.5058811903,
0.5680648088,
0.0281203669,
0.3849532604,
-0.6013337374,
0.0074941716,
-0.1915744096,
-0.3610586226,
-0.0780843049,
-0.382155478,
0.1229733899,
-0.2763362229,
0.4072669148,
-0.2426147908,
-0.0160125196,
0.1338527501,
0.0192714613,
-0.1518592238,
0.1251646578,
0.2172863483,
0.7911248207,
-0.5363039374,
-0.3304698169,
0.1679713279,
-0.491697073,
-0.3043043017,
0.2596260607,
0.0835126415,
-0.0264495462,
0.4058198035,
0.6019589305,
0.5231452584,
-0.7312746644,
0.4031855762,
-0.2494040132,
-0.173534587,
-0.4828032851,
0.0062442478,
0.0632128417,
0.6939704418,
0.7871353626,
0.3057649434,
0.5435712934,
-0.721775651,
0.0601276681,
0.5075364113,
-0.3822804391,
-0.3026176095,
0.7124041915,
0.0390365049,
0.3076331615,
0.5003267527,
-0.0075043272,
-0.2212803066,
0.658189714,
0.4863415062,
1.0949251652,
0.0026117661,
0.3353981972,
0.0101277018,
0.1328947544,
-0.328961283,
0.5519299507,
0.3717413247,
-0.8935447931,
-0.6779064536,
-1.2862925529,
-0.438470453,
-0.1872576624,
-1.2479015589,
0.5886448622,
-0.7158796787,
-0.4587138891,
0.2652110159,
0.13198331,
-0.5542350411,
0.5640215278,
0.1391779333,
1.2589441538,
-0.6315188408,
0.5043697357,
0.7440693974,
-0.1681472063,
-0.6848871112,
-0.1873877347,
-0.2597263753,
-0.7073125839,
0.5688018203,
0.407715261,
-0.0587612689,
-0.0444098115,
-0.4632584155,
-0.6263170242,
0.9045103192,
0.409814328,
-0.7034069896,
-0.1627865285,
0.1007358506,
0.5231574774,
-0.6673951149,
-0.1014363989,
0.6500104666,
0.5872256756,
0.2573720515,
-0.699454546,
-0.5380791426,
-0.3930010498,
-0.3464797735,
0.4332175851,
-0.8652842045,
0.7654486299,
-0.1296615452,
0.279548943,
-0.0825280398,
0.9086706042,
0.1363765448,
0.4071269929,
0.30325827,
0.6024949551,
0.6297215223,
-0.1051923633,
1.0697972775,
-0.6251349449,
0.5038866997,
0.8492591977,
-0.1300589442,
1.1011092663,
0.3026892841,
-0.2650009394,
0.4182418883,
0.7556974888,
-0.2051493526,
0.4191201031,
0.0814809501,
-0.1559245586,
-0.4744594097,
-0.1576285809,
-0.2423274815,
0.9106375575,
0.4689468145,
-0.6064514518,
-0.1583194584,
-0.0294588339,
0.0267360192,
0.0521668047,
-0.9365581274,
0.6891414523,
0.4811783135,
-0.0815975666,
0.0517374165,
0.3089614809,
0.6715183854,
-0.4281906486,
0.3742268384,
-0.263963908,
0.5085381866,
-0.1635240018,
-0.5847129226,
0.5942409635,
0.0666827112,
-0.365811497,
-0.2754538357,
0.5542202592,
-0.1165506169,
-0.838945508,
0.6309546232,
0.0890230238,
-0.3901487589,
-0.4587801993,
-0.4432935715,
-0.2699460685,
0.0337663144,
-0.3558235466,
0.4947850108,
0.4196769595,
0.1841032207,
0.5773967505,
0.9519996047,
0.0612089224,
-0.0561447181,
0.2127993554,
0.9074913263,
-1.2373950481,
-0.73306036,
-1.0498415232,
0.198651135,
0.020760905,
-0.5296490192,
0.7599893212,
0.712579906,
0.5489590168,
-0.060002435,
0.3803861439,
0.7189269662,
0.3909647167,
-0.819527328,
0.6249265075,
-0.3217687011,
0.4322695732,
-0.3911583424,
-0.9394794703,
-0.5999317765,
0.4814135134,
-0.3316482008,
-0.2081128955,
0.2980109453,
0.7217159867,
0.0863339007,
0.3687151372,
0.059507519,
0.2668754458,
0.1566634029,
-0.0347209126,
0.5401873589,
-0.2804793119,
0.500572443,
0.0416171849,
0.1662626863,
-0.3871193826,
-1.0250612497,
-1.0939459801,
0.0752480552,
-0.3899537027,
-0.2818483114,
-0.0853674114,
1.0265591145,
-0.0191746484,
-0.6878884435,
-0.1713301539,
0.0799053609,
-0.0964834243,
-0.1811928153,
-0.3319457471,
0.4353427589,
-0.6691527367,
-0.689299643,
0.3550943136,
0.7791255116,
0.08221782,
-0.1715703011,
0.1730136871,
0.2983661592,
0.3660125136,
0.6187619567,
-0.373880744,
-0.4219881296,
-0.2905227542,
0.1186042801,
0.0627012104,
0.1315228194,
0.4425877929,
-0.3295352459,
-0.0043804706,
0.3482974172,
0.6241012216,
0.0778472126,
0.365238905,
0.775318861,
-0.3077087402,
0.2833401263,
0.050862655,
0.5526376367,
0.2539719343,
-0.6381041408,
0.0903322399,
-0.1775959134,
-0.3080033064,
-0.6271505356,
-0.2776293159,
-1.1791012287,
-0.1984155476,
1.0937825441,
0.1196951568,
-0.3665190041,
0.145128876,
-0.260866046,
-0.1403852701,
-0.6733521819,
1.1364030838,
0.6328000426,
0.3251478374,
-0.231017679,
-0.407351613,
0.5633921623,
0.2892161608,
-0.538872838,
0.0661184192,
0.1701023728,
-0.0371046439,
0.1064387932,
0.375831157,
-0.2920359373,
0.468146354,
-0.156037733,
-0.1475074738,
-0.0271596164,
-0.4189533889,
-0.3357184827,
0.4226312637,
0.2839318514,
-0.2496451735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13621v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13621v1 | Improving Visual Commonsense in Language Models via Multiple Image Generation | 2024-06-19T15:17:10 | 2024-06-19T15:17:10 | Guy Yariv, Idan Schwartz, Yossi Adi, Sagie Benaim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Commonsense reasoning is fundamentally based on multimodal knowledge.
However, existing large language models (LLMs) are primarily trained using
textual data only, limiting their ability to incorporate essential visual
information. In contrast, Visual Language Models, which excel at
visually-oriented tasks, often fail at non-visual tasks such as basic
commonsense reasoning. This divergence highlights a critical challenge - the
integration of robust visual understanding with foundational text-based
language reasoning. To this end, we introduce a method aimed at enhancing LLMs'
visual commonsense. Specifically, our method generates multiple images based on
the input text prompt and integrates these into the model's decision-making
process by mixing their prediction probabilities. To facilitate multimodal
grounded language modeling, we employ a late-fusion layer that combines the
projected visual features with the output of a pre-trained LLM conditioned on
text only. This late-fusion layer enables predictions based on comprehensive
image-text knowledge as well as text only when this is required. We evaluate
our approach using several visual commonsense reasoning tasks together with
traditional NLP tasks, including common sense reasoning and reading
comprehension. Our experimental results demonstrate significant superiority
over existing baselines. When applied to recent state-of-the-art LLMs (e.g.,
Llama3), we observe improvements not only in visual common sense but also in
traditional NLP benchmarks. Code and models are available under
https://github.com/guyyariv/vLMIG. | [
-0.3506594598,
-0.6645174026,
0.7955168486,
0.0535332523,
-0.4394501448,
-0.2755946517,
-0.2742021084,
-0.3453181982,
-0.1526913494,
0.700953424,
-0.2834873199,
-0.6500555277,
-0.484996289,
0.1995162219,
0.085301429,
0.6144447923,
0.0557946041,
-0.0361246839,
-0.6680531502,
-0.2917113006,
-0.5886523128,
-0.1573749632,
-0.2948074937,
-0.3529928923,
0.5454947948,
0.6039716601,
0.6872496605,
0.3966712356,
0.3772402704,
0.4024505615,
-0.0352355093,
0.4929600358,
-0.3548811078,
0.1138407141,
-0.1840662062,
-0.2297627032,
-0.2771299779,
-0.1434228271,
0.5411567688,
0.3662897646,
0.0427221395,
-0.2565673888,
-0.1017308682,
0.3601561189,
-0.7172523141,
0.1777978092,
-0.9067413211,
-0.1210527495,
-0.0071595199,
-0.208718732,
-0.4848004878,
0.0219545495,
0.0874699876,
-0.7177095413,
-0.0039886092,
0.0969804674,
0.818875432,
0.324883163,
-0.4599719644,
0.0761204213,
-0.0540999286,
1.0555039644,
-0.777323544,
0.5218542814,
0.3838802576,
0.2631926239,
-0.0739431009,
-0.7080116868,
-1.0395004749,
-0.3811907768,
-0.2238642871,
0.2985816896,
-0.3571010232,
-0.1442533284,
0.1350499392,
-0.0083274338,
-0.5278152227,
0.1409343332,
-0.2703660429,
-0.1371632814,
0.4321406484,
-0.0161701981,
0.4544231892,
-0.4942782521,
-0.6552351117,
-0.2254597843,
-0.5325400829,
-0.2215852886,
0.113558501,
0.1127411053,
-0.2611724138,
0.7403311729,
-0.2158545405,
1.0148209333,
-0.2921696305,
-0.4222441614,
0.4810220599,
-0.4513399601,
-0.1958322972,
-0.1777966768,
0.6657493711,
0.8649531603,
0.236260578,
0.2977376282,
-0.352645725,
0.2989060283,
0.0756555274,
-0.4934332669,
-0.2437247187,
0.1902199686,
-0.5348086357,
-0.5115895867,
-0.408013612,
-0.725271225,
-0.5490305424,
-0.4593355656,
0.2648531497,
-0.5888445377,
-0.4764507413,
0.203459084,
-0.3587708473,
0.2612997293,
0.6758085489,
-0.7184616327,
-0.0262332447,
0.3862564564,
0.713899672,
-0.1765113473,
-0.5727187991,
-0.7205595374,
0.2965599597,
-0.0356897861,
1.1268451214,
-0.7257320285,
-0.1709245294,
0.0128669757,
-0.2225628495,
0.0079738311,
-0.488304317,
0.4024323523,
-0.3190419376,
0.072665967,
-0.0763026699,
-0.2752193511,
-0.1703090966,
0.5435622931,
-0.7353165746,
0.8132869005,
-0.2781397998,
-0.8307814598,
0.4560563564,
-0.5993958712,
-0.4409211874,
0.1989225894,
-0.3369435072,
-0.3647274077,
0.0393715799,
0.68822366,
0.802731514,
-0.0410152152,
0.4154013395,
-0.4965002835,
-0.0237174146,
0.4517976344,
-0.6882451773,
0.4113349915,
0.2683618963,
0.0127183385,
0.2640519142,
-0.7320050597,
-0.1303875297,
0.1340574324,
-0.1826847643,
-0.3914607465,
-0.0746664777,
0.2589715123,
0.2205361277,
0.2216857523,
-0.2570309341,
0.0305048507,
-0.1541125327,
0.1856835783,
0.7074522376,
-0.0641518831,
0.4637844861,
-0.291836977,
0.1199083924,
0.2597497106,
0.0797294751,
-0.4858897626,
-0.7330573201,
-0.7581581473,
-0.3705004752,
-0.3254075944,
0.5912026763,
-1.283645153,
0.1202531233,
-0.3970407844,
-0.3470484316,
-0.2174062729,
0.4112695158,
0.5505831242,
0.5984261036,
0.5032123923,
-0.2234516293,
-0.2542399466,
-0.9066115618,
-0.4011572599,
-0.2006245852,
0.1828283221,
0.536567986,
0.5767148137,
-0.3268181682,
0.7113758922,
-0.6219972968,
-0.2416780889,
-0.4636018574,
0.3202540576,
0.2299772799,
0.5138359666,
0.4203442335,
-1.0347552299,
-0.1402765214,
0.1671003848,
-0.7407753468,
-0.1576688141,
-0.3128671646,
-0.068438679,
0.1806434095,
0.4793419838,
-0.5321750045,
0.259667486,
0.6999508739,
-0.3274975121,
0.5090535283,
-0.2024074793,
0.2261308283,
-1.0196075439,
-0.1768936515,
0.395358175,
-0.243133381,
-0.7305484414,
0.0851837248,
-0.0104894182,
-0.1852340251,
-0.8292269707,
0.8839179873,
-0.5130597949,
-0.0124985129,
-0.2280716449,
0.242804125,
0.1451073736,
0.5726906657,
0.4675163627,
0.6200535297,
0.6677453518,
-0.4792195857,
0.4709955752,
0.1626965255,
-0.393586725,
0.7806732059,
-0.5431500673,
-0.0856557861,
-0.3391948044,
0.1533673555,
-1.1114513874,
-0.466119498,
0.1787851751,
-0.345652163,
0.2272012234,
-0.1396007687,
-0.6165757179,
-0.2621168494,
-0.1483911276,
0.3945023417,
0.2966445088,
-0.7418589592,
0.8539770842,
0.1254369617,
-0.1332615465,
-0.7093942165,
-0.9428715706,
0.2311525494,
-0.0456234515,
-0.7956746221,
0.141607672,
0.125233829,
-0.3906601071,
0.1095716655,
0.0860393867,
-0.2092147321,
-0.0410834067,
-0.0092861028,
0.4625291824,
-0.1278925091,
0.3313278854,
0.1664421856,
-0.2642299235,
-0.3364535868,
-0.2816037834,
0.3426314592,
-0.5184711218,
-0.5020782351,
-0.4036683142,
0.2633013427,
0.5265827179,
-0.4288990796,
0.5750259161,
0.7763172388,
-0.2439304292,
-0.121289596,
-0.7803410292,
-0.0949551389,
-0.4396888912,
0.3962547183,
-0.4104286134,
-0.7493817806,
0.207960844,
-0.1350089461,
0.0328152515,
0.2734116316,
0.5162656903,
-0.2784738541,
0.7456759214,
0.331867367,
0.4775976241,
0.3770219684,
-0.0835951343,
-0.0353650488,
-0.5441947579,
-0.2616172731,
-0.1176575646,
-0.0348694734,
-0.422742039,
-0.7936268449,
0.3563993573,
0.048316028,
0.1631049067,
0.0865140781,
-0.2907932699,
0.6806527972,
0.6122364998,
0.3852697909,
0.3502469063,
0.1866126955,
-0.1805106252,
-0.0712856054,
-0.8244376779,
-0.5563137531,
0.9110500813,
0.2508598268,
0.698961556,
0.2654775381,
0.7239438295,
-0.0370857194,
0.3932417035,
-0.5192877054,
0.728215456,
-0.4507721663,
-0.2102226913,
-0.13462089,
-0.3613649905,
-0.5793971419,
0.6090174317,
-0.6760645509,
-0.3942085505,
0.053210821,
0.4393622279,
-0.0062675136,
0.2433488816,
-0.9042547345,
0.9873694181,
-0.4122525454,
-0.6868889928,
-0.2694542408,
-0.4994180202,
0.7461982369,
0.1477160007,
0.3296901584,
-0.0101233451,
-0.1258485019,
0.393581301,
-0.2486982197,
1.2280811071,
-0.1059348807,
-0.1423941553,
0.1975681186,
-0.2505218089,
0.4546443224,
0.0486367419,
0.1598231196,
0.1303076595,
-0.3760922551,
-0.5063946247,
-0.5705302358,
0.8571522832,
-0.5663856268,
-0.4585438669,
-0.3287573457,
-0.5601724386,
-0.161220178,
0.3368467689,
0.0663884133,
0.5022158027,
0.0224219617,
0.0801149532,
0.7873513103,
-0.6054985523,
0.5032101274,
-0.0082464134,
-0.1657619327,
-0.749982357,
0.9270809293,
-0.3395425379,
0.4590772986,
0.4796719551,
0.316516161,
-0.624222517,
-0.5115036368,
-0.3779315054,
0.2214946747,
-1.1544107199,
-0.292237401,
-0.6825187206,
0.2308863997,
-0.5089252591,
-0.3807210028,
-0.1204795018,
-0.1706239283,
-0.4882787764,
0.1135837138,
0.4130851626,
0.4298869073,
0.0139346924,
0.3471874297,
-0.8606918454,
0.7724930048,
0.6713755727,
0.3939521611,
-0.0662121028,
-0.2911407948,
0.1946165562,
-0.1760616302,
-0.0934130251,
-0.8791238666,
0.339684695,
0.1350183338,
0.7913065553,
0.3422262967,
-0.1578311324,
0.6743252873,
-0.4061647654,
0.7937672138,
0.8920371532,
-0.8088659644,
0.6485546827,
-0.3811971545,
0.5988246202,
0.3873453438,
0.0135188131,
-0.304302603,
-0.4135303795,
-0.4986898303,
-0.6230460405,
0.2851359546,
0.2124017328,
0.2603983283,
-0.1240390167,
-0.2460132241,
0.1073403507,
0.0372566693,
-1.0565441847,
0.0360234417,
-0.5959441066,
-0.2976212502,
0.0485180542,
-0.3276842833,
-0.0917612985,
-0.1524837166,
0.4696514904,
-0.4123764634,
-0.0937935635,
0.0531776696,
-0.3233417273,
0.3527286649,
0.5219071507,
0.8592858315,
0.509955883,
0.0733309016,
0.5511995554,
0.2761379778,
-0.3315329254,
-0.1372063309,
0.030166382,
0.0495960154,
0.1318181753,
0.6913119555,
1.0069929361,
0.4263494313,
-0.7996171117,
0.7594261169,
0.0417130664,
-0.3137794435,
-0.0668997988,
-0.0289412048,
0.1134631559,
0.3540924191,
0.1791288704,
0.4575120211,
-0.1352752447,
-0.2806783915,
0.3158345819,
0.2974911034,
0.108120665,
0.1161422282,
0.440805316,
0.3902402818,
0.2160485536,
0.4957959056,
-0.1644125879,
-0.5077243447,
0.3501747251,
0.6059800386,
0.5853058696,
0.1652579308,
0.3113816082,
0.3124219477,
0.3526421189,
-0.1114649549,
0.3754638135,
-0.0954296887,
-0.985218823,
-0.5898150206,
-0.4163410068,
-0.1604253501,
0.0523965769,
-0.0944618434,
0.5373336673,
-0.3955443799,
-0.1193017364,
-0.2115909457,
-0.3482399881,
-0.7200576067,
0.3059587479,
0.3859843314,
0.6485188007,
-1.0966246128,
0.6613488793,
0.792963922,
-0.4974948466,
-0.4269146919,
-0.2338094711,
-0.017413266,
-0.9346334338,
0.7849234939,
0.2820126414,
-0.1868205816,
-0.1605456918,
-0.8749969602,
-0.6007624865,
0.9803939462,
0.1858973652,
-0.6351700425,
0.3555078208,
-0.1203575581,
0.2344348729,
-0.315161109,
0.2202947289,
0.1423628777,
0.7333885431,
0.4522988498,
-0.6819553971,
-0.0403621159,
-0.3137729466,
0.2369087636,
-0.1050070152,
-0.2498684227,
0.6390349269,
-0.5359817743,
-0.1909595579,
-0.0758528858,
0.8588710427,
0.8509198427,
0.5802768469,
0.7005778551,
0.8489210606,
0.689619422,
0.025174886,
1.0184924603,
0.1496918052,
-0.0539836586,
1.2270736694,
-0.203707099,
1.0063129663,
0.8207675815,
0.3140783012,
0.2909526825,
0.2377159595,
-0.2689273655,
0.5829985142,
-0.0701503307,
-0.2699141204,
-0.6047545075,
-0.3884470761,
-0.2289439589,
0.5798754692,
0.2310478985,
-0.3413595855,
-0.2825388312,
0.2418660671,
-0.1421392262,
0.4799244106,
-0.3754437864,
0.7036539912,
0.0226692129,
-0.4932265282,
0.6324808002,
-0.1177304015,
0.9388857484,
-0.2622526586,
-0.3338958621,
-0.093098104,
-0.075845845,
-0.2236644924,
-1.0960975885,
-0.016212387,
0.1367176622,
-0.0027136796,
-0.5035223365,
1.0586055517,
-0.60846138,
-0.5860630274,
-0.0249349792,
0.5767400861,
0.1706912071,
0.1751183122,
-0.611523211,
0.2420305163,
-0.0200973023,
0.0785073787,
-0.0201921351,
0.4601091444,
-0.0138238743,
0.5632494688,
0.9323874712,
0.0501080677,
-0.0204037521,
0.3804952204,
0.9730800986,
-0.4997786283,
-0.2990197539,
-0.7549456358,
0.7507041097,
-0.3592356145,
-0.398645997,
0.4098694324,
0.29923895,
0.7866261601,
-0.3309746087,
0.7890524268,
0.2119806111,
-0.0772117898,
-1.0605299473,
0.6704672575,
-0.8803191185,
0.1337164044,
-0.4030697942,
-0.7286682725,
-0.6499419212,
0.5721603632,
-0.2906624973,
-0.1125932261,
0.594533205,
0.8065837622,
-0.2203889638,
-0.204055354,
0.5783951283,
0.0752981454,
0.1959710568,
0.5723890066,
0.9965016842,
-0.1176358983,
0.50472188,
-0.1373910755,
-0.1754449457,
-0.10383863,
-1.2298941612,
-0.9897304773,
-0.5276617408,
-0.3024178445,
-0.0953867733,
-0.0831319541,
0.571960628,
0.493702054,
-0.3610505164,
0.1161196902,
-0.2112267017,
0.1595197618,
-0.1000013873,
-0.1906040907,
0.0602156855,
-0.4046574235,
-0.5497584939,
0.322335124,
0.3743736446,
0.2270972282,
-0.0984888747,
-0.1987724304,
-0.3673337102,
-0.1491122842,
0.7939425707,
-0.056365747,
-1.1052268744,
-0.1488981098,
-0.0213971697,
-0.1350521296,
-0.0739376619,
0.5205699205,
-0.7684036493,
0.5991011262,
0.6394540071,
0.5599755049,
0.3613680899,
-0.1694843024,
0.50101614,
-0.7841818929,
0.2521257401,
0.1934311539,
0.5856528878,
0.6865143776,
-0.0548333079,
0.1832069606,
0.3335398138,
-0.0166267734,
-0.6914716363,
0.4396239519,
-1.1525400877,
-0.4988639057,
1.3299620152,
0.0603642166,
-0.2860112786,
0.0384248681,
-0.2550238371,
0.1019411311,
-0.4104069471,
0.2954876423,
0.5393612981,
0.1192269474,
-0.861448884,
-0.379655391,
0.1457985491,
0.5219748616,
-1.0071837902,
0.056935437,
0.9406918883,
-0.054354243,
0.2051519305,
0.5472554564,
0.0521208085,
0.4928421974,
0.203821674,
0.0644610301,
-0.2083404809,
-0.3988001049,
-0.260925293,
-0.0026472784,
-0.0927095339,
-0.1078628376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13618v1 | In-Context Former: Lightning-fast Compressing Context for Large Language Model | 2024-06-19T15:14:55 | 2024-06-19T15:14:55 | Xiangfeng Wang, Zaiyi Chen, Zheyong Xie, Tong Xu, Yongyi He, Enhong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the rising popularity of Transformer-based large language models (LLMs),
reducing their high inference costs has become a significant research focus.
One effective approach is to compress the long input contexts. Existing methods
typically leverage the self-attention mechanism of the LLM itself for context
compression. While these methods have achieved notable results, the compression
process still involves quadratic time complexity, which limits their
applicability. To mitigate this limitation, we propose the In-Context Former
(IC-Former). Unlike previous methods, IC-Former does not depend on the target
LLMs. Instead, it leverages the cross-attention mechanism and a small number of
learnable digest tokens to directly condense information from the contextual
word embeddings. This approach significantly reduces inference time, which
achieves linear growth in time complexity within the compression range.
Experimental results indicate that our method requires only 1/32 of the
floating-point operations of the baseline during compression and improves
processing speed by 68 to 112 times while achieving over 90% of the baseline
performance on evaluation metrics. Overall, our model effectively reduces
compression costs and makes real-time compression scenarios feasible. | [
-0.4133228064,
-0.5871679187,
0.5435914993,
0.2069043815,
-0.4327725172,
-0.1072047204,
-0.4980795383,
-0.5223736167,
0.104465954,
0.3853740394,
-0.4519144297,
0.0568200424,
-0.341073513,
-0.0373488516,
-0.5886474252,
0.6771218777,
-0.0110988356,
-0.2332002223,
-0.1510938555,
0.0537935458,
-0.4310240149,
-0.7018691301,
-0.5833849311,
-0.3223764896,
0.3538936675,
0.3860246539,
0.3805555403,
0.5100269914,
0.3758971393,
0.2584503591,
-0.2090808004,
-0.2156228125,
-0.7105089426,
0.165439859,
-0.0251236949,
-0.3472444415,
-0.3487836719,
-0.0240254421,
0.635615766,
0.6571290493,
-0.0033563441,
0.2774023712,
0.2368076742,
0.6158705354,
-0.8585372567,
-0.0124502443,
-0.7557403445,
0.1863357723,
-0.1363525391,
-0.5477133393,
-0.811296165,
0.1318682581,
-0.1108536795,
-0.170152843,
0.1538638026,
0.1887510419,
0.4970375001,
0.3639629185,
-0.2045084089,
0.2675197721,
-0.8216217756,
0.8619523048,
-0.7475412488,
0.6023188233,
0.1091626436,
0.3120135665,
-0.0994626731,
-1.0612177849,
-0.7388243675,
0.0741112605,
-0.0522495396,
-0.0675874949,
-0.1149324626,
0.0459781587,
0.3881956339,
0.4768951833,
-0.3169156611,
0.0333147012,
0.0598087981,
-0.0668146312,
0.1301640123,
0.0225603729,
0.159524858,
-0.2116456777,
-0.3436946571,
-0.0902954042,
-1.2570775747,
0.0698960721,
-0.1340445876,
0.109352544,
-0.1053558737,
0.4312711656,
-0.3398316205,
0.8054906726,
0.2365269512,
-0.3964813352,
0.043325875,
-0.3691329956,
-0.44386971,
0.0369938873,
0.4424321949,
0.4267832637,
-0.1012016162,
-0.3938458562,
-0.1614709944,
0.0542271771,
0.0431540869,
-1.1842707396,
0.0485957526,
0.2113135308,
-0.6461548209,
0.0782134458,
-0.1117973328,
-0.6569504738,
0.2427690476,
-0.3772349954,
0.2757667899,
-0.2332102507,
0.1242790595,
0.0099433744,
0.1198140085,
0.23543185,
0.2604146898,
-0.7335528135,
0.2705044746,
0.5912491083,
1.0024602413,
0.0156430323,
-0.0417327508,
-0.9583775997,
0.36305812,
0.0695372075,
0.6019705534,
-0.5601072311,
-0.3589220345,
-0.073428981,
-0.1060166061,
0.288510412,
-0.3733020425,
0.5839526653,
-0.6949801445,
0.1000887379,
0.0329596885,
-0.6401103139,
0.1165497974,
0.1266720891,
-0.4506379366,
1.1502301693,
0.2459048182,
-0.8405359387,
0.3182449341,
-0.2977925241,
-0.6289432645,
0.1615027785,
-0.1815155298,
-0.1816229969,
0.3370517492,
0.544963479,
0.6073506474,
-0.5899868608,
0.25756374,
-0.2957454026,
-0.7882922292,
-0.0418609977,
-0.4534963071,
0.5608836412,
0.0992348418,
-0.5448998809,
-0.1357643753,
-0.5168269873,
-0.0787926242,
-0.0023408346,
-0.502989769,
-0.4308021069,
-0.1493314654,
0.0199592002,
0.5103197694,
0.1746223271,
-0.584960103,
0.3159275353,
-0.6018034816,
0.6704601645,
0.5388343334,
-0.1870997548,
0.5471529961,
-0.0452403799,
0.4103502929,
-0.1578130275,
0.3091807365,
-0.3027825058,
-0.0724849254,
-1.0066651106,
-0.342877239,
0.3007945418,
0.2552178502,
-0.9734997153,
0.6950832605,
-0.7790440917,
-0.4191813469,
-0.2627162039,
-0.1472882777,
0.4466593564,
0.7178061008,
0.393787235,
-0.0111694215,
-0.4400227964,
-0.8633175492,
-0.1479870081,
-0.0305330437,
-0.1179363579,
0.3969596624,
0.2974884808,
-0.1639298797,
1.0456957817,
-0.5882552862,
-0.0571460426,
-0.3243357539,
0.2552579343,
0.3372380435,
0.4652099609,
0.5381366611,
-0.8164333105,
-0.5396226645,
-0.2891501486,
-0.2825640738,
-0.2600215971,
0.0029934761,
0.0980137214,
0.0783750936,
0.8132415414,
-0.6451038718,
0.5270050764,
0.7804906964,
-0.1137938648,
0.331877321,
-0.1668827385,
0.151498124,
-1.0096577406,
0.1080393419,
-0.2008436322,
-0.3972516954,
-0.5283600688,
0.1176536381,
0.5412514806,
-0.233326003,
-0.7923489809,
0.7109143138,
-0.8399370909,
-0.0746975839,
-0.2719731927,
0.1145870835,
-0.1181871593,
0.6395417452,
0.0645086616,
0.9867047668,
0.4668515623,
-0.6973451376,
-0.0539565682,
-0.0889932141,
-0.5305112004,
0.3738163114,
-0.5898697972,
0.3044773042,
-0.2569502592,
0.7036676407,
-0.7925287485,
0.0659279525,
0.0391065702,
-0.0154256932,
0.462790668,
-0.2184716165,
-0.7802456617,
-0.3733987808,
-0.4072669446,
0.8106687069,
0.5367638469,
-0.8485305309,
0.5167857409,
0.1856149733,
-0.0191536769,
-0.5289352536,
-0.8824324012,
0.4333420098,
-0.3166613579,
-0.436109215,
0.9938095212,
-0.4213232696,
-0.1940225065,
-0.106954962,
-0.140493229,
0.199876532,
-0.1005444601,
0.0794227049,
0.0602306873,
-0.113383837,
0.098152779,
0.1436734647,
-0.1395045668,
-0.3879826963,
-0.1738283634,
0.7312983274,
0.305981189,
-0.0789632723,
-0.4054625034,
0.5623662472,
0.6221421957,
-0.058966171,
0.8347366452,
0.2309025079,
-0.439139545,
-0.2633172572,
-0.6497491598,
-0.3290619552,
-0.4606956542,
0.2032500654,
-0.3409835398,
-1.121499896,
0.2413093448,
-0.2134863436,
-0.0409057662,
0.2077719569,
0.4415544569,
0.2725408077,
0.795699656,
0.6754635572,
-0.4147645831,
0.8216304779,
-0.1237725094,
0.5694535375,
-1.0133023262,
0.0895655751,
-0.5405753255,
-0.3227074146,
-0.0242894236,
-0.5793712139,
0.5659077168,
0.0779129565,
0.1251125932,
0.5238078237,
-0.3415589929,
0.4858258963,
0.23172611,
0.095414713,
0.1707491726,
-0.0574344285,
0.1621273458,
-0.0807751268,
-0.8040309548,
-0.0339870937,
0.7975370288,
0.2292953134,
0.7601597309,
0.284917146,
0.5060475469,
0.1107948497,
0.6359304786,
-0.90023911,
0.5652692914,
-0.1093915552,
-0.3192937076,
-0.1280732006,
-0.4625567198,
-0.7956618667,
0.2400254458,
-0.0855239183,
-0.9698824883,
-0.0045880014,
0.1135741845,
-0.5014366508,
0.1375656873,
-0.6682217121,
0.3962962329,
0.0565175116,
-0.3417185843,
-0.2999326885,
-0.7042174935,
0.4113505185,
-0.169402048,
0.2749023438,
0.2446409017,
-0.1383750737,
0.5357698798,
-0.7054319382,
0.8813482523,
0.0081832027,
-0.1049015895,
0.0773090795,
-0.018566478,
0.7998833656,
0.0833089501,
0.1445971131,
-0.0671611503,
-0.3419592679,
-0.1234135032,
-0.9127140641,
0.8972617984,
-0.2495909482,
-0.5024946928,
-0.0992787406,
-0.6212873459,
-0.2352878302,
0.0455830544,
0.4754745364,
1.047206521,
0.0634639934,
0.5589522123,
0.6476163864,
0.0140206348,
0.9952381253,
0.3805021644,
-0.0375016332,
-0.3764126301,
0.3332039714,
0.189553991,
0.188694641,
0.8126185536,
0.1605350375,
-0.3240475953,
-0.5074221492,
-0.2397767454,
0.3348896205,
-0.7030522227,
-0.5368250012,
-0.7988682389,
-0.0632757694,
-0.5847723484,
-0.4070104063,
-0.3884581327,
-0.336984843,
-0.2468618453,
0.3109319508,
0.0285672229,
0.2336462736,
0.2576421797,
0.6958291531,
-0.8643787503,
0.3821489811,
0.2320466489,
0.2734694779,
0.2041934282,
-0.6889188886,
-0.4889476001,
-0.3113436997,
0.0905267894,
-0.6811847091,
0.436776787,
0.3578208089,
0.3989423513,
0.4837202728,
0.2328107804,
0.9041827321,
-0.6167799234,
0.9205396771,
0.2534623742,
-1.2032853365,
0.239037469,
0.1545350999,
0.6359173656,
0.4171571732,
0.1453186423,
-0.5299768448,
-0.3179505765,
-0.5736430287,
-1.114988327,
0.5297952294,
0.2490828484,
0.1243634298,
-0.0634930581,
0.6465350986,
0.0480355099,
0.1104787663,
-0.8859021664,
-0.3144699931,
0.2035266012,
-0.1169715971,
-0.2920219302,
-0.6146947742,
0.0574190021,
-0.4526756406,
0.5617129207,
-0.188989982,
0.3314235508,
0.4184128642,
-0.5209243298,
0.1855867654,
0.2883929014,
0.5332689881,
0.3746491969,
-0.1222803965,
0.5283439755,
0.1416245699,
-0.2698020041,
0.2685152888,
-0.0252314005,
-0.1571914852,
-0.1651388705,
0.4027582705,
0.5964227915,
0.682084918,
-0.6505525708,
0.6483889222,
-0.4053570032,
0.1771684438,
-0.3029727042,
-0.0792664364,
-0.1126914471,
0.246618256,
0.430560261,
-0.1705687493,
0.3773888946,
-0.5941144824,
0.1414219737,
0.2319058627,
-0.1616732478,
-0.2217104733,
0.5097180605,
0.1371902972,
-0.2010085136,
0.3755500317,
0.0431222096,
-0.4401056468,
0.1884747744,
0.8197055459,
0.8428686857,
-0.136254251,
-0.3267127275,
0.3335824311,
0.0293235425,
-0.2821925879,
0.0131809749,
-0.5285575986,
-0.592651248,
-0.7806791663,
-0.3865534961,
-0.1317586005,
0.2876135707,
-0.4032417536,
0.3000869155,
-0.2672520578,
-0.1999403536,
-0.3176488876,
-0.2368212938,
-0.5631298423,
0.3746087551,
-0.0938792601,
1.1286890507,
-0.5657639503,
1.0249938965,
0.2374328822,
-0.046052929,
-0.6248244643,
0.3278524876,
-0.2725007534,
-0.2991664708,
0.6984304786,
0.4061297178,
-0.4399321377,
0.0299931727,
-0.6971697211,
-1.0833464861,
0.8907662034,
0.510145545,
-0.8468127847,
-0.074851118,
-0.229809463,
0.5067219138,
-0.364202559,
0.2172992676,
0.5045958757,
0.3574856818,
-0.0383194834,
-0.7087022066,
0.2723633647,
-0.1504226774,
0.0777968168,
0.4196711183,
-0.7290632725,
0.7741928697,
0.2112657726,
-0.3733780086,
0.0676655173,
0.8906452656,
-0.1268870085,
-0.1321774125,
0.7125704288,
0.6260483861,
0.354654938,
0.1596063972,
1.1510031223,
-0.6036616564,
0.435102284,
1.1398543119,
-0.1533014476,
0.976559937,
1.0044240952,
0.0085514691,
0.3164530694,
0.4611777961,
0.5132984519,
0.6948147416,
0.1590595692,
-0.3777581751,
-0.2165272832,
-0.2371665835,
-0.309540391,
0.382555902,
0.1885160953,
-0.3239788711,
-0.1327307075,
-0.0455283225,
0.2841935158,
-0.2050455362,
-0.1928930134,
0.4668734074,
0.1632558405,
-0.8320589066,
0.6445997953,
-0.0518102907,
0.9393368959,
-0.4454632998,
0.0352933183,
-0.2751970589,
0.0310430042,
0.0644250885,
-0.4627996981,
0.3052633107,
-0.0218910221,
-0.2239695638,
-0.4445134699,
0.5763756037,
-0.5416227579,
-0.2579106092,
0.4640696347,
0.2364361137,
0.1377889365,
-0.2574909627,
-0.2730307281,
0.2020007521,
-0.1770063639,
-0.4032998681,
0.3134170175,
0.3528920114,
0.1218537465,
0.6556693316,
0.4128334224,
0.1159649491,
-0.2479120195,
0.0524243712,
1.1077709198,
-0.7063775063,
-0.6544407606,
-0.8290820122,
0.4652186036,
-0.0682964772,
-0.202801168,
0.5298460722,
0.5034605861,
0.7646694779,
-0.0135780172,
0.5307948589,
-0.064844653,
0.2917905748,
-0.8666730523,
0.501598537,
-0.8399608731,
0.1285834461,
-0.3845083714,
-1.0121990442,
-0.5424506664,
0.238445878,
-0.1096541137,
-0.084727481,
0.9662492275,
0.5750231147,
-0.2377741337,
-0.3504194617,
0.3933851719,
0.0368107706,
0.3339141011,
0.5858449936,
0.5412583947,
-0.4079068899,
0.5567165613,
-0.4526073933,
-0.2680518031,
-0.4789696038,
-1.2499001026,
-0.8338996768,
-0.5282920599,
-0.230838269,
-0.1120838672,
-0.3017588854,
0.9040105939,
1.0241718292,
-0.4206994474,
0.0685372502,
0.0335961804,
-0.1877930164,
-0.205019936,
-0.2239850014,
0.3979401886,
-0.0628608987,
-0.7900816202,
0.7249658704,
0.4812206328,
0.0446542799,
-0.1929563433,
0.0463745482,
0.0715460181,
0.0194875672,
0.9108349681,
0.0106599499,
-0.6618236303,
-0.5589334369,
-0.2044451386,
0.0245568063,
0.2440722734,
1.1926153898,
-1.0401166677,
0.2922501564,
0.6182895899,
0.5912855268,
0.7796007395,
-0.0373432301,
0.5680502057,
-0.8325576782,
0.7105071545,
0.0932467356,
0.8516321778,
0.3940016329,
-0.6614097953,
0.3956848085,
0.2150870264,
-0.4844297767,
-0.7543288469,
0.2481284589,
-0.9288851023,
-0.3919325769,
1.1250807047,
-0.2100643218,
-0.4432672262,
0.0618669279,
-0.2923071682,
0.4278009832,
-0.5506745577,
0.7840871215,
0.5212306976,
-0.0642651692,
-0.3523058295,
-0.1533651948,
0.3663479686,
0.4654841721,
-0.8597406745,
0.1257596612,
0.4671709538,
-0.016487347,
0.0414263159,
0.551022172,
-0.0022191945,
-0.0434808917,
-0.0224897563,
0.1147641093,
0.2468224764,
-0.5953065157,
-0.4424821734,
0.3760009706,
-0.1948587298,
0.1453903168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13617v1 | Optimizing Psychological Counseling with Instruction-Tuned Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T15:13:07 | 2024-06-19T15:13:07 | Wenjie Li, Tianyu Sun, Kun Qian, Wenhong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advent of large language models (LLMs) has significantly advanced various
fields, including natural language processing and automated dialogue systems.
This paper explores the application of LLMs in psychological counseling,
addressing the increasing demand for mental health services. We present a
method for instruction tuning LLMs with specialized prompts to enhance their
performance in providing empathetic, relevant, and supportive responses. Our
approach involves developing a comprehensive dataset of counseling-specific
prompts, refining them through feedback from professional counselors, and
conducting rigorous evaluations using both automatic metrics and human
assessments. The results demonstrate that our instruction-tuned model
outperforms several baseline LLMs, highlighting its potential as a scalable and
accessible tool for mental health support. | [
-0.3444420695,
-0.8993707895,
0.9098628163,
0.4734484553,
-0.0211376511,
0.0598326996,
-0.6747871637,
-0.0328105278,
0.0021469593,
0.469792366,
-1.1678712368,
-0.5837267637,
-0.5737361908,
0.2352634221,
0.1887189895,
0.9057949185,
0.0106481677,
0.5339679718,
-0.0981445312,
0.3370667398,
-0.7922086716,
-0.2295981944,
-1.0070617199,
-0.4614416063,
0.5288755298,
0.4606860578,
0.5141057372,
0.5807239413,
0.483646214,
0.2644823492,
0.0045334683,
0.4646553993,
-0.6030903459,
0.2612455487,
-0.0495334566,
-0.4958383441,
-0.671522975,
0.0339171663,
0.5454772115,
0.8217808008,
-0.5259176493,
0.2660045624,
0.0403030775,
0.4998218417,
-0.6380614042,
0.0836540684,
-0.4399021566,
0.1672496498,
0.1479012668,
-0.3649352193,
-0.6340483427,
-0.4535639882,
0.2249152213,
-0.5925822854,
0.1124047637,
0.0880016312,
0.304195106,
0.4420339465,
-0.4507978559,
-0.2996585369,
-0.6420688629,
0.8333919644,
-0.5536926985,
0.4109583795,
0.6527751684,
0.3093734682,
-0.4963319898,
-0.4449423254,
0.145689249,
-0.349765718,
0.070121184,
0.112680003,
-0.292670548,
0.3226993084,
0.5476169586,
0.3600510359,
-0.4110854566,
0.3879507184,
-0.0337618813,
-0.0201607496,
0.710011363,
0.7339994311,
0.1861215383,
0.35492149,
0.2596577406,
0.1481152326,
-0.4055401683,
0.0413270891,
0.1427905262,
0.3319178224,
-0.0979455784,
0.6103637815,
0.0464095287,
0.8697715998,
0.5405846834,
-0.4948655665,
-0.4274093509,
0.288728267,
-0.261357069,
0.0499243215,
0.4650317132,
0.6849523783,
0.2705135942,
-0.2663571239,
-0.1052239388,
-0.0090283332,
0.4846830368,
-0.8112888336,
-0.1777208596,
0.0528015383,
-0.3256685138,
0.0835695267,
-0.4102881849,
-0.9002342224,
-0.6158341169,
-0.8327151537,
0.0427327342,
-0.5020333529,
0.1687064022,
0.3556354642,
0.0955764949,
0.1353205591,
0.307251364,
-1.0757268667,
0.2941530645,
0.7131090164,
0.8822337985,
0.012582669,
0.1533923894,
-0.7095547915,
0.2153895795,
-0.4208878577,
0.6352814436,
-1.0189281702,
-0.5029162169,
0.2575070262,
0.0715553015,
0.1496663392,
-0.434248358,
0.6375479698,
-0.2086602151,
0.2726394832,
-0.429823786,
-0.8465138674,
0.2500661612,
0.2446738929,
-0.2787178457,
0.7482545972,
0.4694233835,
-0.4261674285,
0.1436798871,
-0.6650876999,
-0.3394356668,
0.0608832315,
0.0316862576,
0.0239047464,
0.4591346681,
0.458986938,
0.4245041907,
-0.6175562143,
0.0351093821,
-0.4372231364,
-0.5567378402,
0.4033186436,
-0.3475626111,
0.3659562469,
0.1472032964,
-0.0579395667,
0.2163988799,
-0.7405251265,
0.225914672,
-0.0709405839,
-0.5759877563,
-0.2457944155,
-0.139887616,
-0.0892826095,
-0.1530340314,
0.214754194,
-0.4686669409,
0.3089337647,
-0.5229608417,
0.27172786,
0.8117442131,
0.1208622679,
0.3869781792,
-0.1425612867,
0.9335699081,
-0.4373871684,
0.1142859086,
-0.3455077708,
-0.2664868236,
-0.4874337316,
-0.6891799569,
-0.3284841776,
0.5301613212,
-0.3050612807,
0.7081971765,
0.2102768868,
-0.4786851406,
-0.7357242107,
0.2463295013,
0.2041713744,
0.4399172664,
0.2589261532,
0.1208317503,
-0.5832069516,
-0.7499325871,
-0.4658438563,
0.4546581209,
-0.1992677748,
0.2727584839,
-0.1004707813,
-0.349714607,
0.8080889583,
-0.8901357651,
-0.0000147305,
-0.1160349622,
0.0391584225,
0.2751323581,
0.1105919331,
0.461601913,
0.0607490353,
-0.6736581326,
-0.1914259493,
-0.6199492812,
-0.5592674017,
-0.0622701645,
-0.3599244952,
-0.1608385295,
0.4023907781,
-0.2950799465,
0.0125310617,
0.3677041531,
-0.5196153522,
0.5299874544,
-0.4418224394,
-0.0723973885,
-0.8969607353,
-0.3723845184,
0.2599721551,
-0.2942889631,
-0.4992837906,
-0.1223702654,
-0.0737207085,
-0.2330857813,
0.015780367,
0.3205043972,
-0.4343233109,
0.3884139955,
-0.633701086,
0.1083384976,
-0.2804066539,
0.442697227,
-0.2374710143,
0.7657637596,
0.7023816109,
-0.4254022539,
0.7070317268,
0.2181359828,
-0.1263676882,
1.0088473558,
-0.4981440604,
0.2977036834,
-0.270288527,
0.4841929376,
-0.5096763968,
-0.4332949221,
0.1623711139,
0.288495928,
0.4215554297,
0.1119861007,
-0.2785699368,
-0.4120391011,
-0.1464996487,
0.0852499381,
0.4311897159,
-0.4791517258,
0.4118432403,
0.2133450955,
-0.3782361746,
-0.2495636493,
-0.2592851818,
0.0758171454,
-0.3654536605,
-0.4106869102,
0.252886951,
-0.2351246327,
-0.2387229502,
-0.277472049,
0.0763515532,
0.2367690057,
0.0041613295,
0.3807223439,
0.2389107943,
-0.2027254105,
0.4379886985,
0.3836447597,
-0.216574356,
0.3731589913,
-0.404767096,
0.6985296011,
-0.3229037821,
-0.3744463027,
-0.5210236311,
0.667927742,
0.4341439307,
-0.1836782694,
0.9225353003,
0.7979084849,
-0.4149439931,
-0.2799438536,
-0.6000278592,
-0.4191870689,
-0.5239994526,
0.5018285513,
-0.0167502649,
-1.1221849918,
0.087991938,
-0.2408106327,
0.0314641036,
-0.2275514901,
0.7146935463,
-0.0877137929,
1.7299169302,
0.6253646612,
0.1028736979,
0.7550244331,
0.0329806432,
0.4317521155,
-0.8721443415,
-0.0338541344,
-0.2126607895,
-0.4182183743,
-0.4936465323,
-0.2398088276,
0.5229344368,
0.0071744062,
-0.7817903757,
-0.3016305268,
-0.5786210895,
0.4629910588,
0.2788354158,
0.5122028589,
0.0840144679,
0.0045121759,
-0.1025468707,
-0.5934817195,
-0.3528669477,
-0.7126711011,
0.8944150805,
0.5429998636,
1.1107099056,
0.0535174832,
0.3918936849,
-0.0160354394,
0.6394935846,
-1.0229412317,
0.380122602,
-0.1684142798,
-0.3963006139,
-0.2435799539,
-0.2904051542,
-0.8273534775,
0.0117938295,
-0.2512387931,
-1.1529785395,
-0.1552936435,
0.1503070593,
-0.4267827868,
-0.1672798693,
-0.6211149693,
0.5920079947,
-0.5445612669,
-0.1345490515,
-0.5395526886,
-0.2395077497,
0.3272190988,
-0.2972724438,
-0.0230602752,
-0.3987117708,
-0.1274674088,
0.5741200447,
-0.4116407931,
0.7839188576,
-0.188827008,
-0.4772278666,
-0.1209204942,
-0.0525787249,
0.3843365908,
0.2174327821,
-0.2375723124,
-0.8441246152,
0.2042109519,
-0.3278284967,
-1.1514912844,
0.6417526007,
-0.8016980886,
-0.902921021,
0.1184512377,
-0.9539903402,
-0.886906743,
0.0282528512,
0.1860521436,
0.4414574504,
-0.2727992833,
-0.0604478642,
0.6865568161,
-0.4727558196,
0.0588430576,
0.8244401813,
-0.3931578994,
-0.4783595204,
0.67260921,
-0.1403297484,
0.0833610445,
0.0089901481,
0.4214399457,
-0.3602611721,
0.0370336771,
0.0014656171,
0.5783583522,
-0.944026649,
-0.2285449505,
-0.4648398459,
0.199300915,
-0.5082065463,
-0.4997200072,
-0.2479606569,
0.0806834251,
-0.3333101273,
-0.2314188927,
0.7927873731,
0.6359704733,
0.0544707105,
0.7052563429,
-0.9861501455,
0.1134776622,
0.1960428655,
0.5082968473,
0.2284371853,
-0.6162530184,
-0.3916000724,
0.0837609544,
-0.4720548689,
-1.1202856302,
0.3208532631,
0.3439972699,
0.5842152834,
0.7187220454,
0.0870731622,
0.9973791242,
-0.5134600401,
0.4472163618,
0.2007353604,
-0.9205176234,
0.8644427061,
-0.5326410532,
0.4692519307,
0.4724267125,
0.5001166463,
-0.6836550832,
-0.4168725908,
-0.1454342902,
-0.5623666048,
0.8685438037,
-0.4287108481,
0.4863595068,
-0.1399228573,
0.7369670868,
-0.1622724533,
0.0283945203,
-0.3506241739,
-0.0876726434,
0.1917406768,
-0.6403521299,
0.0847447067,
-0.1764775813,
-0.5558277369,
-0.4473666549,
0.6609037519,
-0.2692427039,
0.4155279994,
-0.0669407472,
0.2125355303,
-0.5859702229,
0.3408190608,
0.4317783415,
0.4987689853,
-0.0472762883,
-0.1281716228,
0.4683993459,
-0.4359551072,
0.3303599358,
-0.0883194208,
0.2706152797,
-0.2705202997,
0.3743897378,
1.0749956369,
0.4098562598,
-0.8375601768,
0.1873658001,
-0.2523492277,
0.085160397,
-0.0944918841,
0.4177641869,
0.2195278108,
0.5263572335,
-0.0145961447,
-0.6003454924,
-0.0744787827,
-0.5434444547,
-0.1412370503,
0.4062331319,
-0.557091713,
-0.0911339521,
0.3288095593,
0.0836469978,
-0.7351091504,
0.8240888715,
0.1159525737,
-0.2038726509,
0.2360375375,
1.1044170856,
0.7484286427,
-0.2687959075,
0.2089050114,
0.163145408,
0.0056730597,
-0.2245824784,
0.4408249259,
0.0669573992,
-0.3505160809,
-0.4754689336,
-0.733648479,
-0.4362748265,
0.1768119782,
-1.1643035412,
0.3230206966,
-0.6725533605,
-0.5114400983,
-0.3054488897,
-0.0353691354,
-0.7767341733,
0.1585952044,
0.27297768,
1.0031883717,
-0.7479128838,
0.4711116254,
0.9958030581,
0.030166328,
-1.0623619556,
-0.0428504236,
0.1135836691,
-0.7138974667,
0.2387932241,
0.190469712,
-0.2046385258,
0.1362770051,
-0.5249193311,
-0.7271028757,
0.8793803453,
1.0711164474,
-0.6903367043,
-0.184978202,
0.1166583747,
0.8498569727,
-0.6440345049,
0.3415851295,
1.0601141453,
0.6079882383,
-0.1688995063,
-0.5768238306,
0.1629041135,
-0.1217591986,
0.1078659147,
0.0260987189,
-0.4769918323,
0.245456025,
-0.0584389791,
0.0607835427,
0.1257362813,
0.4929488301,
0.4096360207,
-0.0509034581,
0.3694828153,
0.2294603288,
1.1799547672,
0.0077885613,
0.8963934183,
-0.4171403944,
0.1936623603,
1.1310138702,
-0.2439815998,
0.5996524692,
0.3305701315,
-0.181015566,
0.3918496668,
0.9246234894,
-0.2919404805,
0.2632038891,
0.2882907391,
-0.4908020496,
-0.4788634181,
-0.5457578301,
-0.1016563624,
0.3514183164,
0.7444399595,
-0.5072437525,
-0.0838992521,
0.3342429996,
-0.0335067771,
0.2665213346,
-0.4318177104,
0.614005208,
0.4978981912,
-0.8480423689,
0.4905984998,
0.1866583973,
0.2876431942,
-0.5346533656,
0.067630142,
-0.1743009388,
0.3009660244,
-0.2486478835,
-0.4963989854,
0.1564591676,
0.4519880414,
-0.3249591291,
-0.3552817702,
0.4768294394,
-0.4241260886,
-0.7651325464,
0.4118200243,
0.376475215,
-0.1020805836,
0.0608706847,
-0.5222193599,
-0.1566012204,
-0.3426432014,
-0.2286383361,
0.4345332086,
0.5993639231,
0.0648570657,
0.6616413593,
0.4601782262,
0.2119986117,
0.0070792795,
0.5435575843,
0.729516089,
-0.6314738393,
-0.4911507666,
-0.8655928373,
0.224289611,
-0.0066809044,
-0.2960409224,
0.7631930113,
-0.0038959743,
0.2126419544,
0.0084698703,
0.5726498365,
0.4290927052,
0.4504112303,
-0.4737238884,
0.239733696,
-0.4692056179,
0.3758773208,
-0.1291708648,
-0.9519580603,
-0.2693639696,
0.7289918065,
-0.6929131746,
0.075136207,
0.5050470233,
0.965090096,
0.1171823591,
0.2325212508,
0.2582116127,
0.0095741292,
0.4647821486,
0.5294101238,
1.1141089201,
0.2838977575,
0.1427977085,
-0.0509852059,
-0.3969180584,
-0.0899983793,
-0.7219098806,
-1.0683389902,
-0.0328243002,
-0.1865120828,
-0.1280166209,
-0.0158435665,
1.4960649014,
0.4946997762,
-0.5413650274,
-0.208843708,
0.1351653636,
-0.3261435628,
-0.0996998996,
-0.1835816801,
0.054399915,
-0.771550715,
-0.5625742674,
0.549177289,
0.4384103417,
-0.1577231884,
-0.3934696317,
-0.0915874764,
0.2641738951,
0.387216568,
0.5033761859,
-0.1874249578,
-0.7746470571,
-0.2521483302,
0.1875356734,
-0.1830147952,
-0.0167476758,
1.1451518536,
-0.2452090234,
0.3824063241,
0.1112282127,
0.7192118764,
0.1864305437,
0.0945087671,
1.1390849352,
-0.7278088331,
-0.0476938114,
0.100051865,
0.3428285718,
0.3642342687,
-0.83039397,
0.272626698,
-0.2523190379,
-0.6199356914,
-0.7826483846,
0.22103329,
-0.6221842766,
-0.2777120173,
1.0354036093,
-0.4303668439,
0.0392687395,
-0.0396672897,
-0.5832930207,
0.5447083712,
-0.3912740052,
0.9006131291,
0.8568395376,
-0.5359303355,
-0.4420320988,
-0.3232549131,
0.4249507785,
0.5582248569,
-0.7876051664,
0.1710771769,
0.5003390312,
0.2061298788,
-0.2912072539,
0.4030723572,
0.2002806365,
0.1614443213,
-0.3378255665,
-0.4010117054,
0.1730183512,
0.0330490731,
-0.608756125,
-0.1423698366,
0.3118650019,
0.3930532038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13578v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13578v1 | Enhancing Distractor Generation for Multiple-Choice Questions with Retrieval Augmented Pretraining and Knowledge Graph Integration | 2024-06-19T14:12:05 | 2024-06-19T14:12:05 | Han-Cheng Yu, Yu-An Shih, Kin-Man Law, Kai-Yu Hsieh, Yu-Chen Cheng, Hsin-Chih Ho, Zih-An Lin, Wen-Chuan Hsu, Yao-Chung Fan | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we tackle the task of distractor generation (DG) for
multiple-choice questions. Our study introduces two key designs. First, we
propose \textit{retrieval augmented pretraining}, which involves refining the
language model pretraining to align it more closely with the downstream task of
DG. Second, we explore the integration of knowledge graphs to enhance the
performance of DG. Through experiments with benchmarking datasets, we show that
our models significantly outperform the state-of-the-art results. Our
best-performing model advances the F1@3 score from 14.80 to 16.47 in MCQ
dataset and from 15.92 to 16.50 in Sciq dataset. | [
-0.7700572014,
-0.9732035398,
0.6894481182,
-0.110740684,
-0.2933712602,
0.1829584539,
-0.0369344503,
-0.4401347339,
0.122429952,
0.5996182561,
-0.5007476807,
-0.1203974113,
-0.681243062,
0.0542257614,
-0.1541821212,
0.8467298746,
-0.1450039148,
0.0584855713,
-0.2518706024,
0.0696280152,
-0.6671150327,
-0.6046173573,
-0.6616780758,
-0.0990409851,
0.7797167897,
0.3157972693,
0.430849582,
0.3776687086,
0.3450066149,
0.264015764,
0.0650751218,
0.4930459261,
-0.471567899,
0.1972756386,
-0.0798075646,
-0.1807224452,
-0.2022761703,
0.1230414361,
0.6029866934,
0.6283358335,
0.1560038477,
-0.0328133702,
0.2031615525,
0.5544105768,
-0.9373106956,
-0.0762928352,
-0.4459902048,
-0.2108134031,
-0.1734776199,
-0.1610133499,
-0.4795465171,
-0.6242146492,
0.1935802698,
-0.6782745719,
-0.0346549749,
0.213136524,
0.7466651797,
0.6710087061,
-0.7162874937,
-0.3635178506,
-0.5823802948,
0.7532125711,
-0.1970364749,
0.5064638853,
0.3847125173,
0.1251188219,
-0.0437584072,
-0.9459196925,
-0.4720753431,
-0.3338354528,
-0.3118283451,
0.3292685449,
0.0345109962,
0.1057460085,
0.3709374666,
0.2952325046,
-0.433050245,
-0.141237244,
-0.3966708779,
-0.1554694921,
0.7199090719,
0.033468917,
0.0980875343,
-0.2063942403,
-0.4128189087,
0.0137843145,
-0.5140866637,
-0.3022878766,
0.5363910198,
0.2644797862,
0.7310449481,
0.4144986868,
-0.2340462506,
1.2122173309,
0.3680748045,
0.083731994,
0.3747996986,
-0.6273161769,
0.2202566117,
-0.0921660513,
0.8111018538,
0.1004034355,
0.325067848,
0.0802335218,
0.0779126436,
-0.3206781447,
0.4282276928,
-0.8860321641,
-0.5492662191,
0.228829667,
0.0004093812,
-0.2430602908,
-0.1055752113,
-0.5874685645,
-0.17978248,
-0.2848088145,
0.4832499921,
-0.7050533295,
-0.3822330236,
-0.0145755215,
-0.260342896,
-0.1562820226,
0.2520260811,
-0.7010156512,
0.0890521705,
0.1055759564,
0.41386953,
-0.3470391035,
-0.4846587479,
-0.5603129268,
0.1276317388,
-0.2853542268,
0.9924808741,
-0.6106515527,
-0.3581330478,
-0.2196392417,
-0.451677978,
-0.6240885258,
-0.6253338456,
0.4061004221,
-0.8480843902,
0.6677802205,
-0.5638629794,
-0.6496865749,
-0.3740592897,
0.3490390182,
-0.7902032137,
1.4970692396,
0.4299323559,
-0.9522574544,
0.744400382,
-0.9119624496,
-0.3515875936,
0.2311006039,
-0.1008699685,
-0.0671498179,
-0.3614813387,
0.4647126794,
0.1021604612,
-0.0129230861,
0.3678642213,
-0.2676508129,
-0.3442289829,
0.1895284057,
-0.0630370528,
0.6346051097,
0.256511271,
-0.0223970115,
0.0621587336,
-0.6915194988,
0.3657484055,
-0.1176983714,
-0.4386965036,
-0.4308359325,
0.0639276877,
-0.1879388839,
0.7460586429,
0.2072017193,
-0.4030473232,
-0.1137161329,
0.0401164219,
-0.02662481,
0.5736263394,
0.2497697473,
0.2288670689,
-0.4360326827,
0.6231960058,
0.1808709949,
0.0139302695,
0.1905535012,
-0.3898068964,
-0.6570523381,
-0.4864958525,
0.5152849555,
0.5636507869,
-1.0370960236,
0.4763574302,
-0.0286946706,
-0.3552616239,
-0.4097496867,
0.0601829886,
0.3020410836,
0.8105338216,
0.6319569945,
0.0609272085,
-0.6260394454,
-0.4724237621,
-0.3235296011,
-0.0094429236,
-0.010407947,
0.5391947031,
0.4592987597,
0.1533040404,
1.0220464468,
-0.9265298843,
-0.1008903384,
-0.2890490592,
-0.0386774614,
-0.0946258828,
0.5593508482,
0.6602356434,
-0.9375118017,
-0.7755707502,
-0.3783543408,
-0.5259210467,
-0.0530125611,
0.3036255836,
-0.4627624154,
-0.2500387728,
0.5483466983,
-0.4096478522,
0.1024428159,
0.0496951379,
-0.2337760925,
0.721129179,
0.218991667,
0.3496623933,
-1.1803576946,
0.27525267,
-0.3641237617,
-0.1427111924,
-1.0388419628,
-0.1445706338,
-0.0127159059,
0.0271927007,
-0.6601253748,
0.751755178,
-0.2518385649,
0.3917813897,
-0.2334224731,
0.4893378019,
0.1145340726,
0.2685603499,
0.0457946844,
0.8327719569,
0.4838969409,
-0.9867632985,
0.1727241874,
0.4813182056,
-0.3835112154,
0.4644819498,
-0.4871883988,
0.2837665975,
-0.2953172922,
0.0326838195,
-1.1643688679,
-0.3952361643,
0.3595538139,
-0.2861360312,
0.2740160227,
0.0584736466,
-0.4354403615,
-0.6526033282,
-0.1406272501,
0.5241229534,
0.3530085683,
-0.686293602,
0.5655828714,
0.2200378627,
-0.1240166426,
-0.8866382837,
-0.4178043306,
-0.5381124616,
-0.3583955169,
-0.5467159748,
0.4396266639,
-0.3461940289,
-0.039452333,
-0.1352819502,
0.1559814513,
-0.0547202677,
0.0263604615,
-0.1539285481,
0.2871401012,
0.0044243289,
0.43533957,
-0.013466794,
0.0006305182,
-0.0633260831,
-0.2730540335,
0.7407265306,
0.3964061439,
-0.3965644538,
-0.0082494235,
0.3286972344,
0.2296897173,
-0.4094533622,
0.5117649436,
0.6801553369,
-0.2189286351,
0.0511434302,
-0.8403261304,
-0.1573985964,
-0.498899281,
0.5310455561,
-0.6053898931,
-1.0960373878,
0.5347599983,
-0.2949145734,
-0.2558623254,
0.409766227,
0.344222039,
0.0947221965,
1.3556007147,
0.4507537186,
0.1832886934,
1.0284113884,
0.0277156215,
0.1340058446,
-0.9779451489,
-0.1694089472,
-0.2387592942,
-0.2300319076,
-0.3741661012,
-0.2409894913,
0.1767042577,
0.512969017,
-0.2852065563,
-0.015697185,
-0.6315791607,
0.5542311072,
0.7476315498,
0.1731233597,
0.0169153046,
-0.1778346151,
-0.442171663,
-0.0134129534,
-0.8682243824,
-0.2625391185,
1.2617019415,
-0.2040643394,
0.4635192454,
-0.0265141856,
1.0464047194,
-0.1391723305,
0.4105194509,
-0.4812723994,
0.537457943,
0.0107094236,
-1.0196182728,
-0.3423275054,
-0.5205585361,
-0.9022823572,
0.4571246505,
-0.0135131162,
-0.7954434752,
0.2346472293,
0.1545487791,
-0.7045955062,
-0.0408471115,
-0.8905851245,
0.8723705411,
-0.3925733566,
-0.4069799483,
0.1267232001,
-0.3321488202,
0.7030466199,
-0.2219947129,
-0.1147722006,
-0.0451459736,
0.3469873667,
0.9066905379,
-0.1861670762,
0.3582155406,
-0.4132580757,
0.259234488,
0.6925195456,
-0.3068316579,
0.32215783,
-0.0281658005,
-0.3385981023,
-0.4570873976,
-0.1210010275,
-0.4633000493,
-0.6042333841,
0.5548471212,
-0.7205826044,
-0.6960707903,
-0.2121206075,
-0.9638469815,
-0.3293936849,
0.5526629686,
0.2793180943,
0.2441412807,
-0.2037496865,
-0.2534896433,
0.5844579339,
0.1003279015,
0.3654147983,
0.3831062913,
-0.421985954,
-0.713340342,
0.8407381773,
0.3848288655,
0.4821032882,
0.1472804844,
-0.0211581215,
-0.7348728776,
-0.4737876952,
-0.3865821362,
0.1698535383,
-0.8354689479,
-0.1254567504,
-0.9224930406,
-0.389651835,
-0.4931402504,
0.0761027336,
-0.0634025708,
-0.2884042263,
-0.5797675848,
-0.3021855354,
0.2525953948,
0.892164886,
-0.0597346537,
0.3527536094,
-0.5949344635,
0.1868348122,
0.6573477387,
0.3733562827,
-0.1855839044,
-0.3408657014,
-0.1598909199,
0.0434634201,
-0.5326713324,
-0.9644176364,
0.0924012735,
-0.0320317671,
0.8478025794,
0.4382554293,
0.2151355594,
0.9065336585,
-0.3094291985,
0.6393163204,
-0.0384339616,
-0.7636309266,
0.6378875971,
-0.1627095193,
0.2672688663,
0.9463511705,
0.604541719,
-0.0372418948,
-0.3265198767,
-0.6709534526,
-0.5838337541,
0.8409192562,
0.0471398234,
-0.1867799461,
-0.3654258549,
0.4189287722,
-0.1277766824,
0.1932225376,
-0.5814135075,
-0.165691942,
-0.3048209846,
-0.109220393,
-0.0766581148,
-0.4345805049,
-0.161831513,
-0.2006224692,
0.567725122,
-0.2471778244,
0.1219874918,
0.1465477198,
-0.2400684655,
0.1291235238,
0.1076224446,
0.5264855623,
0.7006504536,
-0.353299588,
0.150002569,
0.4376193285,
-0.482713908,
0.1300809085,
0.5906081796,
-0.1653322428,
-0.1237214506,
0.0099115456,
0.7038353086,
-0.0674951226,
-0.377528429,
0.251598835,
0.043036934,
-0.4698019326,
-0.0965669453,
0.3670598269,
-0.1764334738,
0.1181911752,
0.4927283823,
0.0027771972,
0.0696278811,
-0.059970282,
0.4413768351,
0.3923719227,
-0.5211570859,
-0.0187763516,
0.760211587,
0.0497447886,
-0.0884602144,
0.6634627581,
-0.4860878289,
-0.7930327654,
0.3392137885,
0.6306123137,
0.4543320239,
-0.4796381593,
0.1207590699,
0.7274359465,
0.0994446129,
0.0353652127,
0.7515729666,
-0.1626042724,
-0.847193718,
-0.5968956947,
-0.3846236169,
-0.2180873901,
0.1609660089,
-0.5609462857,
0.2837765515,
-0.0626512989,
-0.3899403811,
-0.1507730037,
0.2773684561,
-0.648135066,
0.4692082107,
0.0449813046,
0.6815455556,
-0.6886399388,
0.7124485373,
0.7752680182,
-0.6982927918,
-0.7939561009,
0.0385161489,
-0.4910643399,
-0.5416041613,
0.7966979146,
0.1460464746,
0.0028388521,
0.438521713,
-0.3891989291,
-1.4611338377,
1.1795423031,
0.2029993087,
-0.1107936054,
-0.0468036383,
0.1948380619,
0.2379554957,
-0.4078166187,
0.6827455759,
0.7190452814,
0.5581905842,
0.1685474664,
-0.5617579818,
0.184460938,
-0.2219331712,
-0.1547403634,
0.2503481805,
-0.687797606,
0.9913952947,
-0.2194028199,
-0.3142433465,
-0.297748059,
0.4759238362,
0.6354691982,
0.0117615797,
0.5966515541,
0.4972501099,
1.0402630568,
-0.1939339638,
1.0250842571,
-0.5918115973,
0.1230814904,
1.2173796892,
-0.3909225166,
0.6535505652,
0.57509619,
-0.0202904679,
0.4569249749,
0.7366961241,
0.2737799287,
0.6461472511,
0.2768349349,
-0.2518879473,
-0.4739818573,
-0.249405697,
-0.4031864107,
0.3810236156,
0.3699281514,
-0.3260321021,
-0.0789833963,
0.1435922831,
-0.0546959005,
-0.1567605585,
-0.0309852306,
0.8034847975,
-0.2227111757,
-1.134704113,
0.648349762,
-0.5832647681,
0.4275696278,
-0.7341760993,
0.0908597186,
-0.1198535413,
0.2621329725,
-0.1356369257,
-0.5999390483,
0.1076097414,
-0.3860525191,
-0.1695601642,
-0.2300489545,
0.9553676248,
-0.6900967956,
-0.3346598744,
0.3870995045,
0.8649917245,
0.0970240235,
-0.2201976478,
-0.6231741309,
-0.2476613075,
0.0754743665,
-0.325974226,
0.2869369984,
0.2307562679,
0.1671246141,
0.5414349437,
0.7046912909,
-0.2594219446,
0.4314362109,
0.2467807531,
1.1135005951,
-0.5369848609,
-0.4857123792,
-0.6635683179,
0.7544189692,
-0.3348296583,
-0.4619344473,
0.9472266436,
0.672588706,
0.8566797376,
0.0055911457,
0.9455647469,
-0.2419745177,
0.7486566901,
-0.3474283516,
0.6908233762,
-0.3998091221,
-0.1096055582,
-0.3715924323,
-0.7472344637,
-0.310908258,
0.3974190056,
-0.7497122884,
0.5064277649,
0.9734137058,
0.7663276196,
0.0245811697,
-0.1208057702,
0.33786726,
-0.4222047329,
0.3665751815,
0.5866454244,
1.4228923321,
-0.5025892258,
0.8188015223,
-0.3187758029,
-0.0434664264,
-0.1840540767,
-0.5098121762,
-1.1666654348,
-0.5879048109,
-0.4273870885,
-0.2226227522,
-0.1598142236,
0.4793171883,
0.8280869126,
-0.7556462884,
0.1412270665,
-0.0938039348,
0.3878111243,
-0.1968722492,
-0.2489944696,
0.4366381764,
-0.7421656251,
-0.7459720373,
0.3506037891,
-0.1525420994,
0.1509791762,
-0.027670227,
-0.0747979432,
-0.8569794297,
0.0174254198,
0.570577383,
-0.1073262766,
-0.4962140024,
-0.6182404757,
0.1902734339,
0.0492937937,
0.0013594021,
0.8324785829,
-0.9889717698,
0.5473971367,
0.4382784665,
0.3576518893,
0.6445370913,
0.4829474986,
0.3549038768,
-1.0128252506,
-0.0024214846,
0.3786472082,
0.165796414,
0.2441068441,
-0.3915525973,
0.3961175382,
-0.0067865737,
-0.6680014133,
-0.7649772763,
0.420659095,
-0.3209786415,
-0.1179548055,
1.0691981316,
0.0308118891,
0.0408698134,
-0.4334342778,
-0.3724347651,
0.4258264005,
-0.0653781146,
0.6188995242,
0.9687724113,
-0.5568199754,
-0.1520202011,
-0.442114681,
0.7984150648,
0.5723020434,
-0.8880668283,
-0.1294155866,
0.6341472268,
0.3558652997,
0.4564816654,
0.9379507303,
0.0764298588,
0.3751324415,
0.2900524139,
0.0555515513,
-0.2863591015,
-0.3070017695,
0.0089906985,
0.3431753218,
0.1238883808,
-0.395745039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13560v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13560v1 | Lexically Grounded Subword Segmentation | 2024-06-19T13:48:19 | 2024-06-19T13:48:19 | Jindřich Libovický, Jindřich Helcl | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present three innovations in tokenization and subword segmentation. First,
we propose to use unsupervised morphological analysis with Morfessor as
pre-tokenization. Second, we present an algebraic method for obtaining subword
embeddings grounded in a word embedding space. Based on that, we design a novel
subword segmentation algorithm that uses the embeddings, ensuring that the
procedure considers lexical meaning. Third, we introduce an efficient
segmentation algorithm based on a subword bigram model that can be initialized
with the lexically aware segmentation method to avoid using Morfessor and large
embedding tables at inference time. We evaluate the proposed approaches using
two intrinsic metrics and measure their performance on two downstream tasks:
part-of-speech tagging and machine translation. Our experiments show
significant improvements in the morphological plausibility of the segmentation
when evaluated using segmentation precision on morpheme boundaries and improved
R\'enyi efficiency in 8 languages. Although the proposed tokenization methods
do not have a large impact on automatic translation quality, we observe
consistent performance gains in the arguably more morphological task of
part-of-speech tagging. | [
-0.4076057374,
-0.8877514601,
0.4172705412,
0.177335605,
-0.8505086303,
0.3084871173,
-0.078443788,
-0.3902254105,
0.486626029,
0.0106762983,
-0.1746716052,
-0.6479552984,
-0.6326861382,
-0.1187850386,
-0.3348953426,
0.5410513282,
0.1731602699,
0.3584482372,
-0.3281580806,
-0.2418565601,
-0.5271176696,
-0.9337325096,
-0.3555457592,
-0.3976492584,
0.3427646458,
0.0347088166,
0.7916096449,
1.1204912663,
0.3853326738,
0.2278911471,
-0.5110701919,
0.1148337498,
0.0528825782,
-0.0123810321,
-0.4247975647,
-0.5129753351,
-0.3282231688,
-0.1844864637,
0.641982913,
0.8204292655,
-0.0289025847,
-0.0245724935,
-0.4400412142,
0.4898852706,
-0.6614351273,
0.06216795,
-0.7917487025,
0.402825892,
-0.5147517323,
-0.0664481372,
-0.1023164839,
-0.0951992571,
-0.0697025731,
-0.3079198599,
0.0588064007,
0.0150522823,
0.8853079081,
0.2949444056,
0.0716548786,
-0.3897138834,
-0.0525294878,
0.8549871445,
-0.519872725,
0.9003247023,
0.2625654042,
-0.1458367854,
-0.1090090871,
-0.8735178709,
-0.1571287215,
-0.2347953469,
-0.0367309526,
0.0926290527,
-0.3146760762,
0.1349142939,
0.071080856,
0.5619414449,
-0.1131495982,
0.3111048341,
-0.1044858322,
-0.50404948,
0.2303897887,
-0.0460917614,
0.5548301339,
-0.2305110842,
-0.2961835563,
0.1930057555,
-0.7398936749,
-0.2317361236,
0.1623043269,
0.1839322746,
0.238016203,
0.8589176536,
0.1886782199,
0.2745862305,
-0.1332991123,
-0.3540105522,
0.2784227133,
-0.6133409739,
-0.0631548017,
0.1844172478,
0.3991536796,
0.1403651685,
0.4365358651,
-0.3101932704,
-0.3467314839,
0.3129890561,
-0.0327251069,
-0.614156723,
-0.176663056,
-0.0264102351,
-0.5000473857,
0.1389807612,
-0.0214854646,
-0.5983436704,
-0.3254356086,
-0.3267099559,
0.2302651554,
-0.7310814857,
-0.2446342707,
0.0518390425,
-0.2947199345,
0.3311528265,
0.1007893309,
-0.9173898697,
0.3878446221,
0.9408921003,
1.160649538,
-0.2342626005,
0.1098091006,
-0.2477661967,
0.0212802514,
-0.5590022206,
0.7231431603,
-0.514331758,
-0.5187373757,
-0.0814050734,
-0.2090907991,
-0.1365507394,
-0.6237619519,
0.2223208845,
-0.6049419641,
-0.3680747151,
-0.0704109743,
-0.6354202628,
-0.1157316193,
0.4266957343,
-0.2888745368,
1.0729949474,
-0.0812030062,
-0.741494,
0.5726801157,
-0.6465581059,
-0.5952616334,
0.1278364509,
-0.1829396039,
-0.0715698078,
0.5605965853,
0.6076043844,
0.2299437821,
-0.1220631152,
0.034492366,
0.2287740409,
0.0519595034,
0.0959258527,
-0.1568816304,
0.3507479429,
0.138555944,
-0.2060952634,
0.2544012666,
-0.4973937869,
0.2324632704,
0.0954962671,
-0.0455938764,
-0.6934815645,
0.1674729586,
0.0610374808,
-0.1168970764,
0.4220723808,
-0.8082265258,
-0.0390924327,
-0.6713132262,
0.701954186,
0.5100773573,
-0.026213875,
0.5190114975,
0.2978096902,
0.5536445379,
0.2498223484,
-0.0545282848,
-0.4214073718,
-0.2765752971,
-0.869397819,
-0.7464728951,
1.00093472,
0.3789033294,
-0.5048593283,
0.5739894509,
-0.2125255167,
-0.617534101,
-0.2179632783,
-0.3486993015,
0.4960518479,
0.2412063926,
0.5536507368,
-0.3853801191,
-0.5321195722,
-0.9472390413,
-0.2575462759,
-0.16902408,
0.3262075484,
0.0444813631,
0.5310338736,
-0.4597948194,
1.2315123081,
-0.6155136824,
-0.3599139452,
-0.2927116156,
0.1010718569,
0.0326912105,
0.7524709105,
0.518678546,
-0.7124316692,
-0.1519608796,
0.2048317343,
-0.2927785218,
-0.2284854352,
0.2964678109,
0.0063818791,
0.1129755601,
0.9331553578,
-0.5143995285,
0.5713371634,
0.197751075,
-0.1013454795,
0.0808591321,
-0.1897141039,
-0.3137844205,
-0.9670174122,
-0.2074003369,
-0.2225872576,
-0.2663249969,
-0.3675630689,
0.203254804,
-0.0574305356,
0.0022749747,
-0.4990878701,
0.5806339979,
-0.6021748781,
-0.3931570053,
-0.262830019,
0.0496078059,
-0.2865260243,
0.2090945244,
0.1640763283,
0.8545022607,
0.5221325755,
-0.4198319912,
-0.03774295,
0.0854469314,
-0.2682826519,
0.0799373463,
-0.9266725779,
0.1763553023,
-0.2411315292,
0.1516672522,
-1.1053731441,
-0.011481341,
0.3984083235,
-0.4237405956,
0.135767892,
-0.3045141399,
-0.5308741331,
0.3076356649,
-0.0641999841,
0.7908783555,
0.5593364835,
-0.4059313238,
0.5114278197,
0.8645278215,
-0.0825097039,
-0.0469317734,
-0.7294193506,
0.143121019,
-0.2398371696,
-0.5097117424,
0.7649454474,
0.5464156866,
-0.3168789446,
0.0831684917,
-0.2691507638,
-0.0755141377,
0.012003731,
0.1497335732,
-0.1225476414,
-0.1845414937,
0.1495731324,
0.1658295542,
-0.4522368908,
-0.1445845664,
-0.6050366759,
0.9328868985,
-0.0977396518,
-0.4473487437,
-0.1586412936,
0.446816653,
0.5967005491,
-0.7698577046,
0.6018608809,
0.5617328882,
-0.7586637735,
0.0995578691,
-0.5989527702,
0.146727711,
-0.3452113271,
0.4694800973,
-0.5047075748,
-0.8832323551,
0.5356987715,
-0.2834630013,
0.1274004728,
0.4897715747,
0.5816370845,
0.3421553969,
1.3462940454,
0.6019019485,
0.1899095178,
0.5815550685,
-0.0615535751,
0.385340035,
-0.8290712833,
-0.3349995315,
-0.5817569494,
-0.1874088943,
-0.5050413609,
-0.7111245394,
0.3537479639,
0.2064626068,
0.3965395987,
0.2239702344,
-0.3692381084,
0.4707934856,
0.3798722327,
-0.3670015335,
-0.0481824651,
0.1824977547,
-0.7391893864,
-0.3028943241,
-0.6713095903,
-0.5047952533,
0.2719040811,
0.7058932185,
0.8164132237,
-0.2237481177,
0.6390690804,
0.3226594329,
0.1539832652,
-1.5504086018,
0.4166965485,
-0.1620954871,
-0.3989353776,
-0.1692671329,
-0.1586574614,
-0.7793744206,
0.7093519568,
0.0799168795,
-0.5824395418,
0.2064903677,
-0.0111034298,
-0.2891792357,
-0.0111039123,
-0.7013434768,
0.589867115,
-0.1943126917,
0.0470050052,
-0.283578068,
-0.3991377056,
-0.2830137312,
-0.1536879689,
0.3455921412,
-0.3205152452,
-0.3502314389,
1.1426707506,
-0.5927010179,
0.5138217211,
-0.3547551632,
-0.0212782584,
0.2991324067,
-0.1195856258,
0.0090427566,
0.1652082652,
0.0970592722,
0.5995100141,
0.3527289629,
-0.2492488474,
-0.4862550795,
0.3348052204,
-0.4683128297,
-0.4788013399,
-0.6400564313,
-0.2071848661,
-0.3987134099,
0.3983029425,
0.3441631198,
0.5967303514,
-0.2113372833,
0.2946251631,
0.3417499661,
-0.060987249,
0.5275982022,
0.0385671109,
-0.2202604413,
-0.8094053864,
0.5674650669,
0.3272281289,
-0.2378686219,
0.5083838105,
0.5931501985,
-0.7087433338,
-0.8376663327,
-0.3604650795,
0.2614406943,
-0.7111513615,
-0.1669561416,
-0.7134912014,
-0.1297972053,
-0.3902046978,
-0.2211310714,
-0.667830646,
-0.4568966031,
-0.1665596664,
-0.1140999943,
0.0308601167,
0.4631034136,
-0.1804352403,
0.3868134022,
-0.9231193662,
0.0961456895,
-0.0620906129,
-0.1563277692,
-0.0980536193,
-0.4212502837,
-0.2742049396,
0.0678972155,
0.049594108,
-0.6072049141,
0.2240664661,
0.0820239931,
0.6824809909,
0.440277338,
-0.3045361936,
1.1210135221,
-0.9119365215,
0.8967360258,
0.3617310524,
-1.3565876484,
0.4572738409,
-0.0527509972,
0.1920890063,
0.4946398139,
0.1035829931,
-0.4957273006,
-0.0269541834,
-0.3605711162,
-1.1250947714,
0.4214578271,
0.1018091962,
0.4388817251,
-0.6122117043,
0.355433166,
0.0741920397,
0.0471791513,
-0.3876484931,
0.0440969877,
-0.1994746178,
-0.0367227122,
0.0488753133,
-0.5092171431,
0.0744375885,
-0.4262800217,
0.4660346508,
-0.0574132763,
0.2001414299,
0.3772977293,
-0.4823453426,
0.4147290885,
0.2387542427,
0.6198622584,
0.9519625902,
0.2388830185,
0.4798814952,
0.1724723727,
-0.7156233191,
0.3597408533,
-0.2321337759,
-0.0356205404,
0.2545512319,
0.5382300019,
0.4133069515,
0.2488504797,
-0.5635890365,
0.3558924496,
0.0764193684,
-0.1618805826,
-0.3107633889,
-0.2474144548,
0.0659610108,
0.0406623706,
0.247908771,
-0.1839512885,
-0.1932776272,
-0.4589733183,
0.1812620163,
0.5467309356,
-0.6637009382,
-0.4122846425,
0.2713536918,
0.0773908123,
-0.3786478937,
0.437048465,
0.0665422454,
-0.8569558859,
0.5076488256,
0.8668008447,
0.9149537683,
-0.015557508,
-0.0383882523,
0.0801145509,
0.3430861831,
0.1155537665,
0.1450506598,
-0.2082798481,
-0.7688754201,
-0.2219842076,
-0.8754005432,
-0.1003992856,
-0.2689998746,
-0.4997240901,
-0.0005262099,
-0.6451252103,
-0.4292224348,
0.13176772,
-0.3837241828,
-0.2319632471,
0.3258671165,
0.0350193046,
1.0734373331,
-0.506788373,
0.4703421891,
1.2362748384,
-0.0048641157,
-0.5161318183,
0.1666099578,
-0.4297040999,
-0.8900294304,
0.7259426117,
0.2656038702,
-0.3168470562,
0.1690560877,
-0.2053539753,
-1.0253329277,
0.7622998953,
0.0901585221,
-0.2844979763,
0.070677951,
0.1570762843,
0.4983856976,
-0.3095183074,
-0.0187804122,
0.6009315252,
0.3503609598,
0.3104857206,
-0.5706322789,
-0.1264435053,
-0.0387697332,
0.2552961707,
0.5668077469,
-0.353756249,
0.7735590339,
0.2784801424,
-0.4793116152,
0.0900082663,
1.0196102858,
0.0170075055,
0.1045410261,
0.8005142808,
0.7646382451,
0.6107875109,
-0.2186935991,
0.5671950579,
-0.3330881,
0.2814220488,
0.479809612,
-0.0417664684,
0.5066273212,
0.835673213,
-0.0953604579,
0.1743321866,
0.6552951932,
0.2143460214,
0.7216698527,
0.4705032706,
-0.1616331935,
-0.4024216533,
-0.6463589072,
-0.4743491411,
0.9032807946,
0.6229209304,
-0.3953533471,
-0.571965456,
0.0739328787,
0.2965335548,
-0.003484366,
-0.4341985881,
0.7025408745,
0.1508428305,
-0.6761312485,
0.3154478967,
0.7939851284,
0.6216070652,
-0.5740922093,
-0.0910878032,
-0.2387639433,
0.1254888773,
-0.1914255768,
-0.2945584059,
0.4381650984,
0.0950033218,
0.1864301264,
-0.2608893514,
0.8515703082,
-0.0614575259,
-0.4013156593,
0.0644320771,
0.7445581555,
0.1093411744,
0.0160238799,
-0.4736787081,
0.1425756812,
-0.2976857424,
0.0836973637,
0.2142143399,
0.4777953625,
-0.3844954073,
0.2226277441,
0.7198553681,
-0.0691919848,
0.3621238768,
0.2218729109,
0.9255099297,
-0.59862113,
-0.8021590114,
-1.2168216705,
0.2236507684,
0.1213804632,
-0.4422924519,
0.7320201397,
0.6405258775,
0.5765067339,
0.0296186227,
0.4087368548,
-0.1876320392,
0.2252604663,
-0.7977508903,
0.4116491079,
-0.5559338927,
-0.2365483344,
-0.2811774611,
-1.0115696192,
-0.5759493113,
0.8832966089,
-0.2917114198,
-0.1278398633,
0.7915222645,
0.6381181479,
-0.2348681539,
-0.2319199443,
0.3802060485,
-0.3910499513,
0.3888115287,
-0.1054666191,
1.153875351,
-0.0931952074,
-0.0993128791,
-0.0708203167,
-0.3584080637,
0.0318097621,
-0.8117803335,
-0.9370422959,
-0.3403478861,
-0.2875851989,
-0.0370077081,
-0.0143524176,
1.1116292477,
0.7494790554,
-0.635632515,
0.1263594925,
-0.3979095817,
0.1337409168,
0.0534628518,
-0.2135828584,
0.4560877681,
-0.5411698222,
-0.7580437064,
0.5517908931,
0.5578663349,
-0.0538553149,
-0.1840272397,
0.3190039992,
-0.3076518476,
0.2933886051,
0.701554358,
0.0038647661,
-0.8285989165,
-0.4813537002,
0.0934111625,
0.0421799235,
0.0651270822,
0.9745972753,
-0.5918961167,
0.1468340755,
0.626652658,
0.9172360897,
0.2238659859,
0.4051968753,
0.210096851,
-0.8008006811,
0.3400982618,
0.3946658373,
0.5393766761,
0.281380415,
-0.1082088426,
0.5169227123,
0.4490136504,
-0.0262444578,
-0.7188600302,
0.3647916019,
-0.5983012915,
-0.1715636402,
1.1223530769,
-0.2594426274,
-0.2775534689,
-0.1915076971,
-0.3640610576,
0.292357564,
0.0179041233,
0.1850116104,
0.8871189952,
-0.0983733982,
0.0050825318,
0.0829084069,
0.2058180869,
0.6763592958,
-0.6877715588,
-0.188477695,
0.3958234489,
0.1705712378,
0.5953014493,
0.6501444578,
-0.6420212984,
-0.0151696457,
0.1641792059,
-0.1255230755,
-0.1635126472,
-0.442946434,
-0.174241811,
0.3475128114,
0.0614609048,
-0.6542493701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13556v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13556v1 | Evaluating Short-Term Temporal Fluctuations of Social Biases in Social Media Data and Masked Language Models | 2024-06-19T13:45:21 | 2024-06-19T13:45:21 | Yi Zhou, Danushka Bollegala, Jose Camacho-Collados | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social biases such as gender or racial biases have been reported in language
models (LMs), including Masked Language Models (MLMs). Given that MLMs are
continuously trained with increasing amounts of additional data collected over
time, an important yet unanswered question is how the social biases encoded
with MLMs vary over time. In particular, the number of social media users
continues to grow at an exponential rate, and it is a valid concern for the
MLMs trained specifically on social media data whether their social biases (if
any) would also amplify over time. To empirically analyse this problem, we use
a series of MLMs pretrained on chronologically ordered temporal snapshots of
corpora. Our analysis reveals that, although social biases are present in all
MLMs, most types of social bias remain relatively stable over time (with a few
exceptions). To further understand the mechanisms that influence social biases
in MLMs, we analyse the temporal corpora used to train the MLMs. Our findings
show that some demographic groups, such as male, obtain higher preference over
the other, such as female on the training corpora constantly. | [
-0.2432167083,
-0.9584485292,
0.536944747,
0.5567531586,
-0.1392351985,
0.4576767981,
-0.3699215055,
-0.471483171,
0.6158567667,
0.286110878,
-0.7667825818,
-0.4377925694,
-0.9736557007,
0.0331615806,
-0.4432970583,
0.9602020383,
0.0939490274,
0.2267480195,
0.1759539694,
-0.3029116988,
-0.2482352108,
-0.7453276515,
-0.6403169036,
-0.1199641898,
0.6883001328,
0.15259552,
0.8722881675,
0.4892701209,
0.1791985184,
0.1950378418,
-0.2551330328,
-0.0407125764,
-0.8411171436,
-0.0362878144,
-0.1878722608,
-0.338816762,
-0.2532418966,
0.083729811,
0.7851657271,
1.0118023157,
0.1757010669,
0.4955228269,
0.0673145726,
0.7759363055,
-0.5931714773,
-0.0039387043,
-0.803429842,
0.0410948098,
-0.3605148196,
-0.513291657,
-0.2410793602,
-0.5453539491,
0.2193620503,
-0.2490799278,
0.5740825534,
-0.020271752,
0.7608838677,
-0.2661758065,
-0.4344674349,
-0.1580527127,
-0.9456534386,
0.8216176629,
-0.2277460247,
0.5622219443,
0.5237795115,
0.3656640947,
-0.0971595645,
-0.5445804,
-0.2487450838,
-0.3280608654,
0.0919801444,
-0.3000991344,
0.0298519358,
-0.2753171623,
0.4630964398,
-0.0732803941,
-0.1952644587,
-0.0003248031,
-0.609418869,
-0.117188096,
0.735673964,
0.1759576052,
0.515630722,
-0.1601089537,
-0.1219807863,
0.1613003761,
-0.6590986848,
0.0481766425,
0.8667010069,
0.1996588707,
-0.1839535087,
0.6834094524,
-0.0669338852,
0.1863268912,
0.1994652897,
0.0168852713,
0.179243505,
-0.1897740215,
0.0672212467,
0.1369797885,
0.7784078717,
0.6273112893,
0.5956428647,
-0.1443234831,
0.0095044039,
0.2612778246,
0.0737353563,
-0.7855961919,
0.1920543313,
-0.0374697819,
-0.5588660836,
-0.5018532276,
-0.0073795915,
-0.8275554776,
-0.6157724261,
-0.1254393309,
0.0143761942,
0.0138493925,
-0.3777998686,
0.0052043949,
-0.3796149492,
-0.1788906455,
0.039638333,
-0.9594683051,
0.3673692942,
0.5077767968,
1.0661300421,
-0.2957082391,
-0.1454353929,
-0.5252274275,
-0.1176730692,
-0.5700342059,
0.334756881,
-0.6872375607,
-0.4318381846,
0.4418570995,
0.3993918002,
-0.1704661399,
-0.4352719784,
0.1528651565,
-0.7223540545,
-0.0038904997,
-0.4420022964,
-0.4148540497,
0.6201704741,
-0.1489640921,
-0.5511391163,
1.0764629841,
0.1040972546,
-0.8971632719,
0.793056488,
-0.4648536146,
-0.1351240873,
-0.1021626741,
-0.4222850204,
-0.4376211762,
-0.091631636,
0.2354933172,
0.5835040808,
0.1264567822,
0.362860918,
-0.943784833,
-0.5371702909,
0.6074027419,
-0.2565584183,
0.9664288759,
0.0257325098,
-0.6115120649,
-0.1836575121,
-0.6625449657,
-0.6691278815,
0.1837636828,
-0.1144624352,
-0.5415558815,
0.3103573024,
-0.0023085356,
0.2563298941,
0.0052899886,
-0.5688834786,
-0.136495769,
0.0153307766,
0.7132363915,
1.0305887461,
0.3590192795,
0.6637315154,
-0.2608223855,
0.4439421296,
0.2370475829,
0.2979459465,
0.099708721,
-0.3691370189,
-0.6929038763,
0.1433552951,
0.0703504831,
0.2247906327,
-0.6997477412,
0.0512934923,
-0.468203187,
-0.1852608174,
-0.422247082,
0.3496961594,
-0.0802815482,
-0.1254428029,
0.0741481707,
-0.1791699082,
-0.4416074455,
-1.0175420046,
-0.452439487,
-0.1697196364,
-0.1669433117,
0.3900246918,
0.4697647393,
-0.6479244828,
0.9644842148,
-0.4422898889,
0.1006478667,
0.0501929857,
0.3076012135,
-0.2053877264,
0.1706261635,
0.7129864097,
-0.5925121307,
-0.3228003681,
-0.2046900541,
-0.3599929214,
-0.344455421,
-0.1702871323,
-0.1775213778,
0.4193446934,
0.8431519866,
-0.3824626505,
0.4082641602,
0.5946772695,
-0.3156888783,
0.654510498,
0.3395433426,
0.1283626109,
-0.7609912753,
-0.2245589048,
0.2925432324,
-0.2632285655,
-0.5859594941,
-0.6742676497,
0.0597081482,
0.0672727749,
-0.4747768342,
0.7045202255,
-0.652166903,
-0.2374369502,
-0.0903314278,
0.2581016719,
-0.3738313317,
0.5218778849,
0.0458730198,
0.3496359587,
0.3722515404,
-0.5300195813,
-0.1986198723,
-0.4629354179,
-0.529381752,
0.2330564111,
-0.6339259744,
0.5101411343,
-0.4103850424,
0.028661143,
-0.8508478999,
-0.2112145871,
0.1292307377,
-0.4782084525,
0.0912732482,
-0.3839603662,
-0.3686372638,
-0.3126567602,
-0.3756326437,
0.1808452606,
0.2566639185,
-0.3126349747,
0.4553452432,
0.6549479961,
-0.2177269608,
-0.7269513607,
-0.3816256523,
-0.0965347961,
-0.2718555033,
-0.5764499307,
0.0758578405,
-0.1773575097,
-0.6729224324,
0.1302557439,
-0.1905353069,
0.1116139814,
-0.0704200864,
0.4267942011,
0.1310915202,
0.0118467128,
0.048672244,
0.1192510501,
0.2986084521,
0.1648382992,
-0.0819559395,
0.742569983,
-0.0876060575,
-0.2399235666,
0.0573327094,
0.2173069268,
0.4502086341,
0.3092500865,
0.9764212966,
0.7886531949,
-0.4301991165,
-0.2267215699,
-0.8105864525,
-0.2639366686,
-0.4652939439,
0.3528793454,
0.0831366405,
-1.247300148,
0.7603532076,
0.4504674971,
0.1241681725,
0.3863393962,
0.661809504,
-0.3017554283,
1.1897879839,
0.6451486349,
-0.2213044614,
1.0843244791,
-0.2261579633,
-0.2548656166,
-0.3824349046,
-0.1147971898,
-0.2486896217,
-0.215408802,
-1.0743495226,
-0.2662673891,
0.1088617742,
-0.0673321709,
-0.2680431008,
-0.146884039,
0.0002448786,
0.4423668981,
0.2877373993,
0.21694763,
-0.1651275009,
0.1237706989,
0.1919152886,
-0.0650005788,
-0.6026777625,
-0.4172003865,
1.0018978119,
0.6194342971,
0.6404989958,
-0.0681628883,
0.3134705722,
0.7266546488,
0.4727194607,
-0.3413564265,
0.5074006319,
-0.0389686786,
-0.8003469706,
-0.3088888526,
-0.4025189281,
-1.0325409174,
-0.0519929901,
-0.3896324635,
-0.7255001068,
0.5929692984,
0.2385549843,
-0.0546015315,
0.1651409715,
-0.7227041721,
0.6827467084,
-0.1610955,
-0.6576449275,
-0.0053104912,
-0.8571968675,
0.4003645182,
-0.1793530136,
0.2195398062,
-0.5100878477,
0.0776031315,
0.97662884,
-0.3038840592,
1.0956864357,
-0.197472468,
0.3300980031,
0.0698263273,
-0.1042221785,
0.4084443152,
0.111933358,
0.2827045023,
0.4565592408,
-0.0227717664,
-0.7200683355,
-0.6191551685,
0.5772066712,
-1.0112977028,
-0.4786918163,
-0.4503137469,
-0.3502633274,
-0.1030411795,
0.0212680195,
0.1533624977,
0.422794193,
-0.4066162109,
0.2869764566,
0.5287547112,
-0.2658576369,
0.5415760875,
0.4329535663,
-0.3609776497,
-0.2764292061,
0.4606984854,
0.5311250687,
0.6647459269,
0.0819365457,
0.2425193042,
-0.0623398349,
-0.1416237801,
-0.3005793095,
0.3483870924,
-0.4085971415,
0.4354238808,
-0.908649683,
-0.2124430537,
-0.5796034336,
-0.1597328335,
-0.3243777156,
-0.301399976,
-0.2663726211,
-0.1274940819,
0.3649494052,
0.7302468419,
0.0043775374,
0.4082363248,
-0.5360293984,
0.3450931311,
0.3345248997,
0.3309500813,
-0.1731133014,
-0.3151704073,
-0.4885081351,
0.0989527106,
0.0596577078,
-1.2765686512,
0.2709918022,
0.0096610906,
0.4734637439,
0.5579748154,
-0.277797699,
0.5666411519,
-0.5644711852,
0.9417521954,
-0.0177212097,
-0.6506157517,
0.3547155559,
-0.7034132481,
0.3858302534,
0.4523041248,
0.5610044003,
-0.8421813846,
-0.7492682338,
-0.7615198493,
-0.8782833219,
0.5336153507,
0.297616154,
0.306928128,
-0.2879632711,
0.3838959336,
-0.0422526151,
0.4191702604,
-0.7354441881,
-0.4888952971,
-0.1430410892,
0.2090274245,
-0.2948593795,
-0.7805882096,
-0.0676985458,
-0.0927550569,
0.5201687217,
0.1626181901,
0.3070931733,
-0.0748958364,
-0.2969048619,
-0.2601661086,
0.2447671741,
0.7554115653,
0.9831844568,
-0.7842952609,
0.1769727767,
0.1591622531,
-0.7747803926,
0.0770570859,
0.0530746467,
-0.2935220599,
0.5157898068,
0.1361351907,
1.0010396242,
0.2005567551,
-0.3202029169,
0.5064105988,
-0.1109681204,
-0.0447411463,
-0.6395335197,
-0.1635085195,
0.2299113572,
0.2497070283,
0.5181683898,
-0.0134488475,
-0.2010483891,
-0.904055059,
-0.0308314431,
0.3345021904,
-0.5346127748,
-0.3431700766,
0.7253919244,
0.1011432931,
-0.3613657057,
0.1531563997,
-0.1269984245,
-0.3909782171,
0.4238621593,
0.2776739001,
0.9432225227,
-0.2493638843,
0.2310673296,
0.1049604192,
0.645139873,
-0.1642032713,
-0.0353330225,
0.0998921394,
-0.8711713552,
-0.2495288253,
-0.6726676226,
-0.1958693266,
0.3169525862,
-0.6922160387,
0.4182904661,
-0.352853626,
-0.8308094144,
0.1168237478,
-0.016698936,
-0.8285264373,
0.0421727635,
-0.0072190007,
0.5704483986,
-1.2716181278,
0.623239398,
0.4367778301,
-0.1542076617,
-0.2917547524,
-0.047345534,
0.2553945184,
-0.7242180705,
0.81458956,
0.1144830585,
-0.2318885475,
-0.4409154952,
-0.7535635829,
-0.7008426785,
0.7010927796,
0.3814962208,
-0.6795544028,
-0.0464816168,
0.4371187985,
0.7866281271,
-0.5116710067,
0.0739172325,
0.706703186,
-0.0214162972,
-0.2496112585,
-0.629553318,
-0.2562164962,
-0.344810605,
0.4056536853,
0.2137544155,
-0.4305764139,
0.6282743812,
0.0105511686,
-0.4991880655,
-0.5708161592,
0.6512224674,
0.2697352469,
0.6407076716,
0.7425786853,
-0.0582642928,
0.4877608716,
-0.0045515243,
0.9092949629,
-0.471942842,
0.1258997619,
1.064032793,
-0.1034580842,
0.5998544693,
0.4705658555,
-0.1119414866,
0.497204721,
0.9699519277,
0.1330165267,
0.2396925837,
0.1330876201,
-0.0887895152,
-0.1083715782,
-0.1117062941,
-0.4915899038,
-0.2047321349,
0.3143481314,
-0.706035316,
0.3455984294,
-0.0369345434,
0.5281546712,
-0.2065572441,
-0.4135903418,
0.368868947,
0.2526602447,
-0.4059729874,
0.1753575057,
-0.1242745295,
0.7338753939,
-0.6895542741,
0.390845418,
-0.4390810728,
0.0004541649,
-0.2103404701,
-0.5527267456,
0.1475239396,
0.0522722304,
-0.3389635682,
-0.1796656102,
0.8408517241,
-0.7026642561,
-0.724848628,
0.5140908957,
0.4912382066,
0.1219532713,
0.0903353468,
-0.5310476422,
0.259478122,
-0.224667877,
-0.1973466426,
0.4548979998,
0.2428710908,
-0.2691631317,
0.6476177573,
0.7304968834,
0.3738081157,
0.6727060676,
0.5876674056,
0.7408380508,
-0.5585101843,
-0.4716268778,
-1.0730686188,
0.2494316101,
-0.4492325485,
-0.0938071087,
1.0620164871,
0.3617763221,
0.9056247473,
0.1927461624,
0.5978155136,
0.296117574,
0.4627043903,
-0.4388110936,
0.7680409551,
-0.4752453268,
0.3345017731,
-0.4952437282,
-1.0173429251,
0.1179434359,
0.0755715743,
-0.6004807949,
0.277312398,
0.5098916888,
0.8220465779,
0.1652428061,
0.0048632687,
0.0342851691,
0.17757456,
0.1318258345,
-0.196222797,
0.9394181371,
0.0117116179,
0.3035316169,
-0.333715409,
-0.0502164997,
-0.297452718,
-0.8356732726,
-1.2387641668,
-0.5241063237,
-0.3303526342,
-0.6347474456,
0.6063703299,
1.1969140768,
0.5314131975,
-0.617087245,
-0.4113527238,
0.4942753613,
0.2008208632,
-0.2151506245,
-0.3012548387,
0.375384897,
-0.1038576514,
-0.6916214824,
-0.0377260894,
0.1618095338,
0.0297549665,
-0.4478628933,
0.091924578,
-0.1778128296,
0.3438332677,
0.9236992002,
0.1017536148,
-0.3255167902,
-0.3333999515,
0.3440111876,
-0.2405008525,
0.0147299366,
1.0056000948,
-0.0967994109,
0.4608833194,
0.47253111,
0.3664136231,
0.7985205054,
0.0462412536,
0.5284546018,
-0.8829225898,
0.0787619203,
-0.1064898148,
0.4739056528,
0.4507425129,
-0.1523635983,
0.3843876123,
0.6087111831,
-0.6092836857,
-1.053514719,
-0.1238479614,
-0.7559253573,
-0.3330334723,
1.7900686264,
0.3564947844,
-0.2024417222,
-0.4023106694,
0.1495072842,
0.2990625501,
-0.52337569,
1.0512800217,
0.8799946904,
0.0553475358,
-0.0780684948,
-1.0080680847,
0.656745255,
0.1381356865,
-0.3730641305,
-0.1412166953,
0.5895220041,
0.6386560202,
0.1683421433,
1.0630292892,
-0.113246344,
0.1662276536,
-0.0464532189,
-0.3300873935,
0.2912693918,
-0.2845710814,
-0.2076077014,
0.0937463269,
-0.2277765274,
-0.0895571485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13555v1 | BiLD: Bi-directional Logits Difference Loss for Large Language Model Distillation | 2024-06-19T13:44:56 | 2024-06-19T13:44:56 | Minchong Li, Feng Zhou, Xiaohui Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have shown exceptional
capabilities across various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However,
such impressive performance often comes with the trade-off of an increased
parameter size, posing significant challenges for widespread deployment.
Knowledge distillation (KD) provides a solution by transferring knowledge from
a large teacher model to a smaller student model. In this paper, we explore the
task-specific distillation of LLMs at the logit level. Our investigation
reveals that the logits of fine-tuned LLMs exhibit a more extreme long-tail
distribution than those from vision models, with hidden "noise" in the long
tail affecting distillation performance. Furthermore, existing logits
distillation methods often struggle to effectively utilize the internal ranking
information from the logits. To address these, we propose the Bi-directional
Logits Difference (BiLD) loss. The BiLD loss filters out the long-tail noise by
utilizing only top-$k$ teacher and student logits, and leverages the internal
logits ranking information by constructing logits differences. To evaluate BiLD
loss, we conduct comprehensive experiments on 13 datasets using two types of
LLMs. Our results show that the BiLD loss, with only the top-8 logits,
outperforms supervised fine-tuning (SFT), vanilla KL loss, and five other
distillation methods from both NLP and CV fields. | [
-0.2813590765,
-0.8470441699,
0.6593056321,
0.2613282502,
-0.4330627918,
0.2987858355,
-0.4703418612,
-0.3937832415,
-0.1831920743,
0.4527763724,
-0.3301820755,
-0.4421101809,
-0.826716125,
-0.067226626,
-0.5312748551,
1.2031542063,
0.1497424096,
0.1988690943,
-0.3244435489,
-0.0308168288,
-0.8356554508,
-0.5320909023,
-0.8451551795,
-0.5523467064,
0.6446487308,
0.1212992221,
0.3392925858,
0.1518463343,
0.5403940082,
0.2453968972,
-0.4950523973,
0.0535468943,
-0.7231538892,
0.0286615025,
-0.4425588846,
-0.7535910606,
-0.120942302,
-0.1043812782,
0.8373901844,
1.0257076025,
-0.1511773169,
0.2291352153,
0.4921394289,
1.2417765856,
-0.5105211139,
0.1695904583,
-0.7248812318,
0.048229754,
-0.3311637938,
-0.0614319146,
-0.6115012765,
-0.2262672335,
0.2929461896,
-0.0478100143,
0.3379550576,
0.1002332717,
0.8807094097,
0.3409148455,
-0.6397343874,
-0.0563468821,
-1.0570092201,
0.7190007567,
-0.8633392453,
0.5240203738,
0.2519620061,
0.2691411972,
-0.1795369238,
-0.4128725231,
-0.5247014761,
0.1985339969,
-0.0903944671,
-0.1730166674,
-0.2030216157,
0.0568131506,
0.0943094268,
0.2288479656,
-0.4777268767,
0.3123343885,
-0.3811064065,
0.1044333652,
0.5157940984,
0.1088421345,
-0.3138175905,
0.1660902351,
-0.2578960657,
-0.3856961727,
-0.7615545988,
0.0052111885,
0.3886429965,
0.2191355079,
0.1182200685,
0.4493159056,
-0.1291912794,
0.6901459694,
0.248088032,
-0.4689614475,
0.0206130091,
-0.3623094261,
-0.3593524992,
0.2411015481,
0.4633087218,
0.5574067831,
0.2000650465,
-0.0618071407,
-0.2061241716,
-0.2623113692,
-0.4343737066,
-0.9876917005,
-0.7115077376,
-0.2467990369,
-0.4495871365,
-0.3082273602,
-0.1114477813,
-0.6067858934,
-0.764478147,
-0.4862439632,
0.522086978,
-0.1569956541,
-0.5046274066,
0.1593427658,
-0.3382463157,
0.0688370615,
0.1489080638,
-0.8278044462,
0.1614253223,
0.5552399755,
0.9160541296,
-0.2849275172,
-0.0912250578,
-0.4430018067,
0.2086933404,
-0.3289927244,
0.5047482252,
-0.3089947402,
-0.4569802284,
-0.3191359341,
-0.1381075382,
-0.1578208506,
-0.9567301273,
0.13865605,
-0.5873106122,
0.0808627307,
-0.1744062304,
-0.5814232826,
-0.446513772,
-0.0145623852,
-0.5494593382,
1.1303111315,
-0.0237542391,
-0.7819119096,
0.4547868967,
-0.3037239313,
-0.4564305246,
-0.0109160086,
0.0137587609,
-0.605640471,
0.3816885948,
-0.0806325525,
0.5315576792,
-0.5237605572,
0.3963773549,
-0.2182409018,
-0.1653236747,
0.1841246188,
-0.7020149231,
1.0568578243,
-0.1563469768,
-0.383362174,
-0.1215614527,
-0.8555085063,
-0.1579917669,
0.1139111593,
-0.4405497611,
-0.9823369384,
0.0725469962,
0.0134499026,
-0.0887964442,
0.1033826545,
-0.5619603992,
0.2974615693,
-0.2284443676,
0.2831005752,
0.8903879523,
0.0488844663,
0.3489099741,
-0.126343146,
0.0329233781,
0.2278153002,
0.0244136136,
0.3889630437,
-0.5330280066,
-0.7348272204,
-0.3437535465,
0.4113267064,
0.3991120458,
-0.5620400906,
0.2314108759,
-0.2748629749,
-0.5375041366,
-0.4269140065,
0.4394018948,
0.2894550562,
0.7473754287,
0.2095757276,
-0.051798813,
-0.4326693714,
-0.9202781916,
-0.3337366879,
-0.270277679,
-0.1129944921,
-0.1983997822,
0.2047522664,
-0.0462385453,
0.9495559931,
-0.6550641656,
-0.6122501493,
-0.4285861552,
0.2192347348,
0.4136293232,
0.1875212044,
0.584613204,
-0.7879381776,
-0.8655435443,
0.0873762742,
-0.4028370678,
-0.2078871578,
-0.2095558941,
-0.1719363034,
0.513961494,
0.4145449102,
-0.7077795863,
0.6110354066,
0.7641168833,
-0.6043673158,
0.5986452103,
-0.1283270717,
-0.1951397508,
-0.8325258493,
-0.0782662928,
-0.041779954,
-0.2807070613,
-0.4684668779,
-0.2647385001,
-0.0312203486,
0.2291882783,
-0.1062487438,
0.3069076836,
-0.4293341637,
0.0432085693,
-0.2410580516,
0.1111818776,
0.4048984647,
0.5031935573,
0.0256437734,
0.4670993388,
0.5403747559,
-0.6319545507,
0.5123129487,
-0.0522422716,
-0.5666647553,
0.6330680251,
-0.5648587942,
-0.0092369886,
-0.2302154303,
0.2200995833,
-1.1398112774,
0.2925180793,
-0.0362021886,
-0.0841637477,
0.5337544084,
-0.2375714183,
-0.6474715471,
-0.1949310899,
-0.2547789514,
0.2376306206,
0.5999037027,
-0.6317324042,
0.285666585,
0.094413206,
-0.3521589935,
-0.3320018649,
-0.8790498972,
0.2619785368,
-0.472479254,
-0.5477077365,
0.254814446,
-0.135494411,
-0.2894476056,
0.2655388415,
-0.2047891319,
-0.1027906835,
0.0014211987,
0.1444171667,
0.4769605994,
-0.331849277,
0.3529661,
0.1285726726,
0.0743916929,
0.2959277034,
-0.2902001441,
0.5326702595,
-0.0936774686,
-0.3947655261,
-0.5050033331,
0.223377496,
0.4461300969,
-0.1345618665,
1.0890702009,
0.529079318,
-0.0623140074,
-0.3504393399,
-0.6809433103,
-0.1863274127,
-0.4977491796,
0.6104745269,
-0.2909043133,
-0.5358146429,
0.3546412885,
-0.2049825341,
0.1768378913,
0.3334412873,
0.4592954218,
-0.1938919276,
0.9888834357,
0.7352615595,
-0.2495241165,
0.4396687448,
-0.4107274413,
0.6338512301,
-0.5736291409,
-0.4365846813,
-0.5194416642,
-0.6333750486,
-0.3682054281,
-0.3406470716,
0.5547605157,
0.393637687,
-0.0952756628,
0.0168905333,
-0.5300877094,
0.5654031634,
0.8437999487,
-0.1672410071,
0.6247031689,
0.1926757842,
-0.0158784445,
0.0424980223,
-0.6730519533,
-0.2338926047,
1.0405167341,
0.3442667425,
0.8303682208,
0.378190726,
0.8729249835,
0.1842133403,
0.0537592582,
-0.7003206015,
0.6725872159,
-0.2285363227,
-0.5640198588,
-0.7136211991,
-0.4628053904,
-0.8002949953,
0.3341152966,
-0.091156289,
-0.481865406,
0.1940623969,
0.1099221036,
0.0507159643,
0.722830236,
-0.8256586194,
0.7884404063,
-0.1979678869,
-0.2181289345,
-0.2552351356,
-0.6287621856,
0.2900624275,
-0.2381870747,
0.1726918966,
-0.1277169585,
0.4059800208,
0.7359510064,
-0.6106073856,
0.8296199441,
-0.5389745831,
-0.18787691,
0.4020473361,
0.2098991275,
0.7218487263,
-0.1084548309,
0.06319087,
0.414183259,
0.28732723,
-0.2055015564,
-0.6991677284,
0.7148288488,
-0.5828681588,
-0.7457797527,
-0.2165065706,
-0.3616286218,
-0.0982457697,
0.1391132474,
0.1866292506,
0.3540023565,
0.2584969699,
0.5449895263,
0.8322627544,
-0.067667976,
0.613269031,
0.5058611035,
-0.4580923617,
0.228860721,
1.0352526903,
0.2401292622,
0.4494695961,
0.3515255153,
0.4819973409,
-0.5493083,
-0.767891407,
-0.5743631721,
0.2495608926,
-0.7827201486,
-0.2933522761,
-0.1392061263,
-0.253969878,
-0.4127964973,
0.0500306115,
-0.3807927668,
-0.3414366543,
-0.202602312,
-0.1710887551,
0.4901928306,
0.7166380882,
0.0595873073,
0.1920193285,
-0.6367994547,
0.0951151103,
0.2827070057,
0.4591696262,
0.0960604176,
-0.7729290724,
-0.3291395009,
0.177350834,
-0.1651327014,
-0.7631472349,
0.4072309732,
0.5382057428,
0.2741298378,
0.4294977784,
0.3752119839,
0.8864610791,
-0.4400247335,
0.630921185,
0.4721276462,
-0.6517857313,
0.2338093519,
0.0530461669,
0.4486071467,
0.5658464432,
0.0822798386,
-0.4548097849,
-0.572360158,
-0.1384036243,
-0.9747010469,
0.5564029217,
-0.0372662321,
0.0218963828,
0.2081826031,
0.0390346609,
0.2577806115,
0.0842809379,
-0.7910398245,
-0.4262363911,
-0.0082284566,
-0.2809934616,
-0.1837946624,
-0.1472060084,
-0.0483945981,
-0.5001700521,
0.7952791452,
0.3376528323,
-0.1703931242,
0.0418040343,
-0.104134053,
0.0007756682,
0.2282296419,
0.13594459,
0.5273683667,
-0.2123335749,
0.5035265088,
0.2206452042,
-0.5049595237,
0.1641349345,
-0.065020591,
-0.194020927,
0.3522355258,
0.2748042345,
1.0110797882,
0.050528191,
-0.686514318,
0.4844216108,
0.1326054186,
-0.3014872968,
-0.3389217556,
-0.0912407413,
0.4071481526,
0.4131115079,
0.5325410962,
-0.0149861472,
0.2581114173,
-0.5810494423,
-0.2310545594,
0.3126388788,
-0.1007012948,
-0.2065868229,
0.5769420266,
0.1503970027,
-0.1969538927,
0.6834430695,
-0.1309216022,
-0.1926300675,
0.4607321918,
0.4560712576,
0.8438144326,
-0.1482035816,
0.1848609895,
0.127180323,
0.1248223856,
-0.0427092761,
-0.2380396426,
0.0566520095,
-0.3172961473,
-0.4753225148,
-0.9028676152,
-0.0868793577,
0.2567269504,
-0.6702693105,
0.372518152,
-0.4049247205,
-0.1367260367,
0.2391563654,
-0.1722562462,
-0.7060729861,
-0.1501891315,
0.0996146649,
0.4346394241,
-0.6814485788,
0.9230332971,
0.7119710445,
-0.1068431437,
-0.7700834274,
-0.1714487076,
0.0104336748,
-0.3093569279,
1.1607170105,
0.0184434745,
-0.2904258668,
-0.0495477282,
-0.192710042,
-0.6957330108,
1.0630884171,
0.3590558767,
-1.1323256493,
-0.2505835891,
0.4707293808,
0.5554137826,
0.0270593669,
-0.231157288,
0.5358312726,
0.3968669474,
0.1902182996,
-1.1202403307,
-0.0812597126,
0.1831418723,
0.140616551,
0.5476672649,
-0.5730488896,
0.8436188102,
-0.0997584611,
-0.2975184023,
-0.4082544446,
0.407756865,
-0.0119455298,
0.7048330903,
0.6795938015,
0.3779913187,
0.6468377113,
0.0580863096,
0.5813530684,
-0.103080079,
0.4107885063,
1.325812459,
-0.3135227859,
0.9910846949,
0.7860320807,
-0.4538457692,
0.4975002706,
0.3586653769,
0.0836837143,
0.7051584721,
0.291768223,
-0.4239956737,
-0.1175118238,
0.1999882013,
-0.1823680699,
0.3546076119,
0.1699339598,
-0.1718720794,
-0.265727818,
0.3265526295,
0.0222852994,
0.0998263583,
-0.237411499,
0.7852663398,
0.0292667244,
-0.5461384058,
0.8672400117,
0.0793082416,
0.5965462327,
-0.4745360017,
-0.0352567211,
-0.2521679699,
0.380613327,
-0.1144447327,
-0.6955875754,
0.4697287977,
-0.0592876561,
-0.370651871,
-0.2496268898,
0.6210273504,
-0.8024941087,
-0.6199852228,
0.4572918117,
0.2345211208,
0.3067831695,
-0.2279906273,
-0.3424520195,
0.051466044,
0.1228083447,
-0.4351970851,
0.5774251223,
0.5752381682,
-0.0809698924,
0.622179091,
0.4728807509,
0.1889070421,
0.3805036247,
0.1206521541,
0.9069389105,
-0.3763769865,
-0.1766584665,
-1.0032461882,
0.2494843602,
-0.2032674998,
-0.0884662345,
0.8500494361,
0.6770172119,
1.0031498671,
-0.2415807992,
0.6896255612,
-0.0261859894,
0.7894061208,
-0.6029962897,
0.8665432334,
-0.4736883044,
0.5185694695,
-0.1431907564,
-1.2289783955,
-0.1019786298,
0.3982690573,
-0.113340877,
-0.2826533914,
0.6114201546,
0.7098716497,
0.0722424239,
-0.302128613,
0.5653090477,
0.4583573937,
0.3902649581,
0.5364012718,
0.453166008,
-0.2243791521,
0.7016986012,
-0.4192659557,
-0.1019268185,
-0.4941485524,
-0.746142745,
-1.1909970045,
-0.6990829706,
-0.5079858899,
-0.0211246721,
0.1937808394,
0.5224980712,
0.5434619784,
-0.6471660137,
-0.2578891814,
-0.0823963657,
0.1958040595,
-0.2748587132,
-0.2844308317,
0.537296772,
-0.2098918855,
-0.8394750357,
0.2692681849,
0.0788597912,
0.0080587585,
-0.4047088623,
-0.0741933808,
-0.3086441457,
-0.0704661459,
0.9381113052,
-0.0976246148,
-0.7536718249,
-0.3352111876,
-0.2606060803,
0.1049019247,
-0.2124097496,
0.6260268092,
-0.7092031837,
0.4610759616,
0.509169817,
0.5908344984,
0.7251098752,
-0.1639861315,
0.2571333647,
-0.8788964152,
0.1032242849,
0.0686989948,
0.047925707,
0.2465668172,
-0.2686775029,
0.4690241814,
0.4770677388,
-0.5167158842,
-1.1258553267,
-0.0330286063,
-0.9036455154,
-0.540951848,
1.2635425329,
-0.1292615235,
0.0565686785,
-0.1573276669,
-0.4074792266,
0.2085782886,
-0.2120399177,
0.7448989749,
0.9894410968,
-0.1630084962,
-0.2092903554,
-0.5994418263,
0.384876579,
0.6448282003,
-0.3068966866,
0.3779667616,
0.577829659,
0.5365464687,
-0.03453831,
0.229711175,
0.0341346376,
-0.26653862,
-0.0277483054,
0.1309144795,
-0.2261510044,
-0.4394403398,
-0.1313761622,
0.0375817493,
0.3652285039,
-0.1829890907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13553v1 | Mining United Nations General Assembly Debates | 2024-06-19T13:43:27 | 2024-06-19T13:43:27 | Mateusz Grzyb, Mateusz Krzyziński, Bartłomiej Sobieski, Mikołaj Spytek, Bartosz Pieliński, Daniel Dan, Anna Wróblewska | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | This project explores the application of Natural Language Processing (NLP)
techniques to analyse United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) speeches. Using
NLP allows for the efficient processing and analysis of large volumes of
textual data, enabling the extraction of semantic patterns, sentiment analysis,
and topic modelling. Our goal is to deliver a comprehensive dataset and a tool
(interface with descriptive statistics and automatically extracted topics) from
which political scientists can derive insights into international relations and
have the opportunity to have a nuanced understanding of global diplomatic
discourse. | [
-0.6308570504,
-0.5942037702,
0.3493289351,
0.0356410518,
-0.4434241354,
0.3984641433,
-0.040913634,
-0.5521329045,
0.2023708224,
0.6977712512,
-0.5440785885,
-0.5901095271,
-0.4921284616,
0.2588863969,
-0.5423417687,
0.8442502022,
0.5213092566,
0.1111332253,
-0.2177473605,
-0.1321210712,
-0.1807434112,
-0.6141409874,
-0.7514548302,
-0.6832638979,
0.1184961572,
0.5683609247,
0.7403016686,
0.3610777557,
0.3500336111,
0.35036847,
-0.5001144409,
0.0559607297,
-0.084828034,
-0.1724959016,
-0.5909670591,
-0.3031905591,
-0.0894196555,
0.1186310574,
0.5003809333,
0.7167879343,
-0.3130294085,
0.0647690594,
0.1746443212,
0.7815172076,
-0.1405370682,
0.4665939808,
-0.8473353982,
0.2260291427,
-0.4099854529,
-0.4054758549,
-0.1547979265,
-0.0366136059,
0.4356179237,
-0.2213467807,
0.3178364336,
-0.1098265722,
0.7037694454,
-0.0538410693,
-0.3532970846,
-0.4387784898,
-0.45745942,
0.7916119099,
-0.9566261172,
-0.1188176349,
0.2049666345,
0.0741077065,
-0.8605687618,
-1.0015141964,
-0.4898014963,
0.0811176226,
-0.0214762148,
0.1869191974,
-0.5795752406,
0.3118814528,
0.0600837059,
0.6754512191,
-0.5774682164,
0.0659003332,
-0.5582662225,
0.0557013154,
0.98428756,
0.0380803905,
0.4983823001,
-0.7493409514,
-0.1774122417,
0.3168783784,
-0.5136995316,
-0.0080523323,
0.5198905468,
0.4565813839,
-0.1004260704,
0.5659663081,
-0.7472939491,
0.9609040022,
-0.3076132834,
0.3202591538,
-0.1241857037,
-0.2890019417,
-0.3930721581,
0.1152304038,
1.103006959,
0.6303682327,
0.2020044476,
-0.3227841556,
0.2123724967,
0.4413853288,
0.1983485073,
-0.6405028105,
-0.3319552839,
0.1187413782,
-0.5237135887,
-0.2813673019,
0.2407033443,
-1.5040893555,
-0.1646387577,
-0.4584046602,
-0.1965982467,
0.1754778773,
-0.1176433712,
0.3041280806,
-0.4400935173,
0.0661911592,
-0.1353115439,
-1.126950264,
0.4487899244,
0.6836823821,
0.989136219,
-0.3009908199,
0.3523473442,
-0.3333934546,
-0.1324374229,
-0.005719502,
1.2600569725,
-0.7868041992,
-0.8042421937,
0.0828816965,
0.0704920962,
0.238553226,
-0.6625378132,
1.0631967783,
-0.3018552065,
0.4823378921,
-0.3723223507,
-0.7152051926,
-0.2186925113,
0.0248667579,
-0.7058945298,
0.8749625683,
-0.2346273661,
-0.7963850498,
0.246912092,
-1.2826340199,
-0.1236270517,
0.1842959523,
-0.5283386707,
0.1547887176,
0.3165147603,
0.4694299698,
0.4132860601,
-0.6642391086,
0.5038808584,
0.1462413222,
-0.0788147673,
-0.0726601481,
-0.233721301,
0.8518308997,
0.3097347617,
-0.1904704422,
0.2814743817,
-0.8956969976,
0.2480552793,
0.0928745493,
-0.3189653158,
-0.2523809969,
0.4060135484,
-0.0354682431,
0.1868899465,
-0.13741377,
-0.6302913427,
0.6900951266,
-0.6407029033,
0.7976401448,
0.5370762944,
0.4489260018,
0.3705500066,
0.1139839292,
0.4262593091,
-0.2634749413,
-0.2780222893,
0.1562010348,
-1.1258845329,
-0.4840556681,
0.3923012018,
0.6076908708,
0.7007465363,
-0.669608593,
0.2982442379,
0.1227237508,
-0.3310197294,
-0.5544955134,
0.1260176897,
0.1183241978,
0.3693119287,
0.2239706665,
-0.5534461141,
-1.0370448828,
-0.7774595618,
-0.5202955008,
-0.3831197917,
-0.2504629493,
-0.1108927876,
0.4532160163,
-0.237226963,
1.18522048,
-0.5675140619,
-0.0595413968,
-0.2470376194,
1.0540939569,
0.3660929203,
0.2860642076,
0.2021532357,
-0.9490027428,
-0.2752707005,
0.1164065376,
-0.8004519343,
-0.2486544698,
-0.0636855066,
-0.0653416142,
0.163492769,
0.5479673743,
-0.3948569298,
0.7077693939,
0.5164676309,
-0.5661091208,
0.409278214,
0.0301601626,
0.3571350873,
-1.0673590899,
-0.0818547606,
0.1016770676,
-0.0612618141,
-0.7190405726,
-0.1828103513,
-0.6772882938,
-0.3002539873,
-0.3254160583,
0.4811486304,
-0.6112846136,
-0.0097477194,
-0.6664541364,
0.1619206667,
-0.0239132755,
0.2191047221,
0.1748643965,
0.7707629204,
0.6233379245,
-0.656039834,
0.5944558382,
0.5515959859,
-0.652305007,
0.641498208,
-0.5959338546,
0.3705771267,
0.038602788,
-0.2452524304,
-0.9179185033,
-0.2500382066,
0.0661121979,
-0.5444008708,
0.0725137219,
-0.391892463,
-0.2023182958,
-0.5306768417,
0.0349692404,
-0.3154064119,
0.2489249259,
-0.4308834672,
0.3356609046,
1.1312763691,
-0.643517375,
-0.6840842962,
-0.6452695727,
0.6186240911,
-0.2276422232,
-0.5160142183,
0.3315473497,
0.1736192107,
-0.7255457044,
0.3008054197,
-0.1834471375,
-0.0869016871,
-0.1063777953,
0.4237739444,
0.03445841,
-0.1552926898,
-0.1624677628,
-0.2834404111,
-0.3424087465,
0.3947930932,
-0.0716157183,
0.6901405454,
-0.3206561804,
-0.0705651045,
-0.5049513578,
0.7389014959,
0.1520978808,
0.049820751,
0.6104454398,
0.3248401284,
-0.3251313269,
0.0011157098,
-0.280656606,
0.2387797087,
-0.4601110816,
0.2761900127,
0.0509292521,
-0.8948405385,
0.7244203091,
-0.4851390719,
0.2100776732,
0.8261494637,
0.4550560415,
0.0366293378,
1.0643299818,
0.6996004581,
-0.777203083,
0.174387753,
-0.2389824539,
0.1546344608,
-0.6577458382,
-0.4264733791,
-1.025916934,
-0.2922676504,
-0.5264149308,
-0.393268168,
-0.1410770118,
0.0684097931,
0.1592547446,
-0.0980843231,
-0.9353893995,
0.6595811844,
0.5449214578,
-0.6080532074,
0.2533124089,
0.2503239214,
0.0609561838,
-0.196686402,
-0.416046679,
-0.7777080536,
0.8370931745,
-0.0539483204,
0.9130206704,
-0.210201025,
0.4118568003,
0.5787087679,
0.0619774163,
-0.713440001,
0.8239319921,
-0.1322759986,
-0.4909577072,
-0.2535561621,
-0.5052901506,
-1.2544652224,
0.287696749,
-0.3791173398,
-0.9521344304,
0.0345165506,
-0.2289215475,
-0.2783550024,
0.7639482617,
-0.3638303578,
0.7380974293,
-0.0360552743,
0.3392151296,
-0.1203848571,
-0.5632760525,
0.2895616293,
0.6114512682,
0.12152493,
-0.2173179835,
0.3965220153,
1.1510506868,
0.1412181705,
0.5695083141,
-0.116596587,
-0.1213233471,
0.7385948896,
-0.3356240392,
-0.0322932824,
0.3037910759,
-0.2229661793,
0.4944133461,
-0.3320749104,
-0.0234747268,
-0.328124404,
0.8427328467,
-0.6249886155,
-0.7964743972,
-0.7593834996,
-0.5802680254,
-0.1277115196,
-0.0142765865,
0.2624753416,
0.3131656945,
-0.8303063512,
0.1677713245,
0.2454808056,
-0.0400994495,
0.6593412757,
0.0437622145,
-0.3874468505,
-0.437418133,
0.6041733027,
0.1067890823,
0.0685659498,
0.2020487934,
0.2247291803,
-0.5471148491,
-0.6617590189,
-0.5785105228,
-0.117221497,
-0.6221320629,
-0.3946991563,
-0.5246940851,
-0.3667986989,
-0.2215449661,
0.0417986661,
-0.0026191797,
-0.6975052357,
-0.2428502589,
-0.2770726383,
0.3994042873,
1.0815132856,
-0.3632856309,
0.6081649661,
-0.7226138115,
0.7264074683,
0.4478927255,
0.2774846554,
-0.5506469607,
-0.3663948476,
0.1697007269,
-0.0112620788,
-0.6720153689,
-1.1315214634,
0.5958608985,
0.3346020281,
0.6185004115,
0.4107903242,
-0.1855054647,
0.7758603096,
-0.432746619,
1.1490174532,
0.1133699641,
-0.9499410987,
0.8942097425,
-0.3790179193,
0.3157801628,
0.5378991961,
0.2448157966,
-0.6119713187,
-0.3544166684,
-1.0357575417,
-0.9202523828,
0.655862689,
0.0800213218,
-0.038882073,
-0.1760428399,
0.4750515521,
-0.232323125,
0.3218460083,
-0.6226489544,
-0.3895536363,
0.1414686739,
0.1919686645,
-0.0014940713,
-0.4619926214,
-0.422244072,
-0.1465089619,
0.6635814905,
-0.2100568414,
0.1593404263,
0.2446534187,
0.3628967404,
-0.314553082,
0.791624248,
0.2940614223,
0.9958890676,
-0.1339851022,
0.0181691814,
0.0906955451,
-0.3167273402,
0.0501988754,
0.0831646472,
-0.2462224513,
0.5346490741,
0.1128085926,
0.5924945474,
-0.0307751317,
-0.5601329803,
-0.0174554717,
-0.3718241751,
-0.409766674,
-0.1837045848,
-0.0530731454,
0.4077135026,
0.2192047834,
0.5323111415,
0.1040928215,
0.451323539,
-1.1977971792,
0.5663872957,
0.6504333019,
-0.2628188431,
-0.2793292403,
0.747610867,
0.1958648711,
-0.5351883173,
0.7610515952,
-0.1734561771,
-0.4820676744,
0.4772936702,
0.5456584096,
0.6409207582,
-0.3393134773,
0.6391997337,
0.3849990964,
0.1742755771,
-0.0542722456,
0.6753721237,
0.4526664615,
-0.3673675656,
-0.7805261612,
-0.5709082484,
-0.6649457216,
0.5224212408,
-0.9857096076,
-0.0412709676,
-0.4265877008,
-0.3558447659,
0.2397748828,
0.4085051715,
-0.3447113335,
0.1940979362,
0.4636789858,
0.7839617729,
-0.9016338587,
0.4649376273,
0.4706350565,
0.0108835604,
-0.3821533322,
-0.3555878103,
0.4047228694,
-0.3123015165,
0.3223209977,
0.1593550593,
0.0131872222,
-0.412507385,
-0.905759573,
-0.4928293526,
0.5118979216,
0.4303978086,
-0.4934834242,
0.0498794131,
0.3756256104,
0.3940556943,
-0.2540542185,
-0.2223814726,
0.983166635,
0.5968117118,
0.0643760487,
-0.766520083,
-0.3543721735,
-0.4039604664,
-0.357608825,
0.4952616096,
-0.337528795,
0.8507205844,
0.0372194648,
-0.4627637565,
0.0581841692,
1.3269805908,
0.0403671041,
0.2677746415,
0.4526141286,
0.7111788988,
0.9354454875,
-0.4547597468,
0.8204327226,
0.1395692527,
0.1715772152,
0.9883416295,
-0.2158169746,
0.5740255713,
0.5083839297,
-0.2036739886,
0.5040786862,
0.4018246531,
-0.0826514959,
0.4612611234,
0.5660694838,
-0.3062306941,
0.0948015451,
-0.3343634307,
-0.3376196623,
0.836855948,
0.6018509865,
0.2056090981,
-0.4319670498,
-0.4417216778,
-0.0657357499,
0.405144006,
-0.6718515158,
0.9940013885,
0.3706667721,
-0.7014124393,
0.0967942923,
0.1688399315,
0.6556120515,
-0.6358146071,
-0.4949522018,
0.0605343096,
0.0537053049,
-0.276769191,
-1.0939683914,
0.7364150286,
0.3814178407,
-0.0108153829,
-0.0861774907,
0.7987012267,
-0.2786437869,
-0.3951347768,
0.2845691741,
0.4061507583,
0.1595498621,
-0.1929800212,
-1.0330266953,
-0.1074409485,
0.2713085413,
-0.3547562361,
0.3529819846,
0.7221214175,
0.1354357302,
0.5258943439,
0.7326148748,
0.4367627203,
-0.1657584459,
0.2615645826,
0.88817662,
-1.0180336237,
-0.4140007496,
-1.1012774706,
0.4702491462,
-0.5525118709,
-0.4447858632,
0.7902483344,
0.6692141294,
0.6945686936,
0.137903288,
0.9287027121,
-0.2875723541,
0.4913803339,
-0.7255411148,
0.6958196163,
-0.1784981042,
-0.2989170849,
-0.3485650122,
-0.5666250587,
-0.34918046,
0.8913547397,
0.059682183,
-0.4910932779,
0.3208358884,
0.3481704295,
0.1065686569,
0.6792111397,
0.0202028137,
-0.0795729458,
0.3749275506,
0.228542462,
0.9737746716,
-0.0978034139,
0.3282479942,
-0.1247562245,
0.2032215595,
0.2231921554,
-1.0167642832,
-0.8781487942,
-0.5286409259,
-0.1599179655,
-0.2152459919,
-0.259634465,
0.6528670192,
0.3775764406,
-1.1177300215,
-0.5947915316,
0.0494391136,
0.0714553818,
0.0289493315,
-0.2556504607,
0.4931226671,
-0.1983830333,
-0.8148235679,
0.7141464353,
0.4197061956,
-0.1749520302,
-0.1197470427,
0.3055959344,
-0.776394248,
0.0848762542,
0.3657277524,
0.6858821511,
-0.7051318884,
-0.3542777598,
-0.4660539925,
0.45842278,
0.2383327037,
0.9261954427,
-0.5460499525,
0.4957674146,
0.4804006219,
0.6204439998,
0.1994565278,
0.3562118411,
0.6553182602,
-0.8396925926,
0.6179570556,
0.2317083627,
0.5163046122,
0.4738696814,
-0.2817456424,
1.0114241838,
0.0480299257,
-0.9610740542,
-0.8686172962,
0.0301187485,
-1.061737895,
-0.0988295823,
0.8757735491,
0.0382881239,
-0.1286609322,
-0.5671722889,
-0.3862637579,
0.2226177752,
-0.4153603613,
0.7809503675,
0.9436946511,
-0.3995001018,
0.1804399937,
-1.0243623257,
0.7499734759,
0.1757351756,
-1.1579176188,
0.0453647599,
0.3547431231,
-0.1097373962,
0.3565276563,
0.9067225456,
-0.205295831,
-0.2580953538,
-0.1456350237,
0.1687304974,
0.4684326947,
-0.4169757366,
-0.2915695906,
0.3533289135,
-0.4288164973,
-0.124610588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13551v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13551v1 | Mitigating Social Biases in Language Models through Unlearning | 2024-06-19T13:38:34 | 2024-06-19T13:38:34 | Omkar Dige, Diljot Singh, Tsz Fung Yau, Qixuan Zhang, Borna Bolandraftar, Xiaodan Zhu, Faiza Khan Khattak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Mitigating bias in language models (LMs) has become a critical problem due to
the widespread deployment of LMs. Numerous approaches revolve around data
pre-processing and fine-tuning of language models, tasks that can be both
time-consuming and computationally demanding. Consequently, there is a growing
interest in machine unlearning techniques given their capacity to induce the
forgetting of undesired behaviors of the existing pre-trained or fine-tuned
models with lower computational cost. In this work, we explore two unlearning
methods, (1) Partitioned Contrastive Gradient Unlearning (PCGU) applied on
decoder models and (2) Negation via Task Vector, to reduce social biases in
state-of-the-art and open-source LMs such as LLaMA-2 and OPT. We also implement
distributed PCGU for large models. It is empirically shown, through
quantitative and qualitative analyses, that negation via Task Vector method
outperforms PCGU in debiasing with minimum deterioration in performance and
perplexity of the models. On LLaMA-27B, negation via Task Vector reduces the
bias score by 11.8% | [
-0.370000273,
-0.8964167833,
0.1555505395,
0.2110741585,
-0.5149952173,
0.2781102061,
-0.4271242023,
-0.0099009769,
0.0160591509,
0.6201361418,
-0.5314903259,
-0.6786324978,
-0.5318529606,
-0.2754956186,
-0.2591618598,
0.9189355969,
0.0479550064,
0.3448422551,
-0.409391433,
-0.2179390043,
-0.4079367518,
-0.5304160118,
-0.5959150791,
-0.834235549,
0.3815706074,
0.5500611663,
0.474558562,
0.4101263285,
0.1496997178,
0.2474536002,
-0.293371439,
0.2503607571,
-0.9624477029,
0.1040215939,
-0.1046241075,
-0.5589795113,
-0.1397235841,
-0.0305074863,
0.4287217557,
0.9101177454,
-0.2071979046,
0.3813475072,
0.6245704293,
1.0059319735,
-0.9947348237,
0.2653606534,
-0.6606834531,
0.1431219578,
-0.1052631885,
-0.0172676444,
-0.4121333063,
-0.3837028444,
-0.1810735017,
-0.5591068864,
0.1766228229,
-0.3951437771,
0.3545011878,
0.5076262951,
-0.2752514184,
0.1079198867,
-0.7773464322,
1.1325423717,
-0.6964355707,
0.186065495,
0.6004455686,
0.1769470572,
-0.2278476655,
-0.2237488329,
-0.4498419762,
0.2061677724,
0.0149402209,
0.0389519595,
-0.3752156794,
-0.0245145708,
0.0922443792,
-0.0153622758,
-0.2869163752,
0.5333034396,
-0.3442197442,
-0.1345593333,
0.4185065031,
0.0130994767,
0.0710829645,
-0.1481544822,
-0.2321713418,
0.0111429645,
-0.9867706895,
-0.0818862244,
0.4741345048,
0.2869305313,
-0.181068629,
0.4361957014,
-0.2991711795,
0.1551559567,
0.0993701145,
0.030860696,
0.5720819235,
-0.0812865049,
-0.2810590565,
-0.0829670504,
0.7854214311,
0.5170676708,
0.612995863,
-0.1385195255,
-0.0627164245,
0.5086566806,
-0.0736100674,
-0.6411166191,
0.0406908579,
-0.0028062388,
-0.8731843233,
-0.3811120987,
-0.4808499217,
-0.9346823096,
-0.7015382051,
-0.4713822603,
0.3379174769,
-0.1791326851,
-0.2868080139,
-0.0938065946,
0.0044416906,
0.23804304,
0.4378300905,
-0.5638942122,
0.3423883319,
0.6196562648,
0.6549424529,
-0.0882999972,
-0.1789277494,
-0.5868704319,
-0.0524996482,
-0.2795288861,
0.5374888182,
-0.7457273602,
-0.5273007154,
-0.0025183379,
-0.0838464051,
0.0596218221,
-0.7561805844,
0.4618871212,
-0.3457184434,
0.2477948666,
-0.4771655202,
-0.4135641754,
-0.2759524584,
-0.0132788131,
-0.3238936067,
1.0303618908,
-0.1779329032,
-0.862924695,
0.1923147589,
-0.2207849175,
-0.5426999927,
-0.1137836501,
-0.3020707667,
-0.4985014796,
0.2567017078,
0.431727916,
0.5338834524,
-0.3466423154,
0.4889514148,
-0.4926729798,
-0.7070125937,
-0.1442142427,
-0.496987164,
0.9624065161,
0.2679047883,
-0.602663815,
0.2125693411,
-0.6667174101,
-0.349631995,
0.2002523541,
-0.2101804912,
-0.6978553534,
0.2659386396,
-0.2325671315,
0.1295813173,
0.1368984133,
-0.6182272434,
-0.2047366351,
-0.2209341973,
0.4451667964,
1.0426331758,
-0.3092672229,
0.6987991929,
-0.2080131024,
0.3907114565,
0.1869949549,
0.2418684363,
0.0496376976,
-0.3362394571,
-0.9638020396,
-0.1215003058,
0.0781540945,
0.5848602057,
-0.8275741339,
0.1424803138,
0.1654406488,
-0.5578552485,
-0.6899736524,
0.3577542603,
0.6791759133,
0.547416687,
0.3507446051,
-0.1085092798,
-0.5393092632,
-0.8750470281,
-0.3076196313,
0.0480321757,
-0.1287769079,
0.3212585449,
0.3277058601,
-0.5184589028,
0.5323554277,
-0.3450641036,
-0.3609530926,
-0.2463658899,
-0.0205593556,
0.070279263,
0.416241616,
0.3093880415,
-0.5200498104,
-0.3563833833,
-0.221983254,
-0.6788594127,
-0.3211764693,
0.2923893332,
-0.0312648751,
0.3788092732,
0.6742284298,
-0.3821149468,
0.6294042468,
0.6187179685,
-0.0093510309,
0.3173371851,
-0.3421047032,
-0.2510524392,
-0.9331513047,
-0.0446801968,
0.059800446,
-0.1634271145,
-0.6548706293,
-0.2696121633,
-0.0840834826,
0.0345323756,
-0.4203172624,
0.3482007086,
-0.6404261589,
0.0119353095,
-0.5078604221,
0.1841754913,
-0.1196445152,
0.6976410747,
-0.1250860095,
0.4631150663,
0.4758515954,
-0.6709108949,
-0.1338298768,
0.1270870715,
-0.2761043608,
0.2470985204,
-0.6623303294,
0.2348407358,
-0.721575439,
0.1859813631,
-0.9151232839,
0.429800272,
0.2139021456,
-0.3446059823,
0.1903764009,
-0.1836864203,
-0.2903852165,
0.0931423083,
-0.3936872184,
0.492595911,
0.8062436581,
-0.717941463,
0.2788126171,
0.7445257902,
0.0162929166,
-0.8829650879,
-0.6950873137,
-0.2823909521,
-0.2465857714,
-0.1526874006,
0.3854470849,
0.0261444468,
-0.4229343534,
0.0234873537,
-0.0404569097,
0.1691793203,
0.1019794419,
0.3887010515,
0.1528490782,
0.1476595402,
0.0154131493,
0.1208970919,
-0.1869515181,
0.042484466,
-0.0318135656,
0.7407656312,
0.1555896103,
-0.4185183942,
-0.0709805861,
0.2928443849,
0.4928030074,
-0.3680121005,
0.8849667311,
0.6154157519,
-0.5003598332,
-0.5081750751,
-0.6371980906,
-0.1967122108,
-0.4650450945,
0.333383292,
0.2039447427,
-1.1677377224,
0.6109924316,
-0.1243639812,
-0.0453268848,
0.0760334209,
0.7263118625,
0.0721509084,
1.0373317003,
0.7113535404,
-0.5567708015,
0.5590445399,
-0.0987158939,
0.2613258362,
-0.900388658,
-0.3416590989,
-0.5565311313,
-0.3293114603,
-0.8624961376,
-0.7016097903,
0.3029557168,
0.241423279,
-0.2813487947,
-0.1287038177,
-0.3903838396,
0.702260375,
0.7205024958,
0.3409814239,
0.1155629084,
0.2524223626,
-0.3347785473,
0.1367272586,
-0.660748601,
-0.512341857,
1.3281672001,
0.279199481,
0.7677466273,
-0.1675633937,
0.7160262465,
0.1558381468,
0.2192840129,
-0.4122707844,
0.6612302065,
-0.4446034729,
-0.413202852,
-0.3674203753,
-0.6035354733,
-0.8166385889,
0.6508585215,
-0.259903729,
-0.7090322971,
0.3314892948,
0.3079119623,
-0.0431484655,
0.3557530046,
-0.5625782013,
0.726909399,
0.0987710655,
-0.6066033244,
-0.5657717586,
-0.4700575769,
0.3409436047,
-0.050761871,
0.4172427952,
-0.2643915415,
0.2520522475,
0.7792922854,
-0.4218931198,
1.2785573006,
-0.3961463571,
0.100377433,
0.1563861072,
-0.040906392,
0.6521846056,
-0.1839912981,
-0.1589334756,
0.4085999131,
-0.3478410542,
-0.5071261525,
-0.2644370496,
0.7519749999,
-0.8045842648,
-0.470901072,
-0.1359056532,
-0.3546954393,
-0.1781114638,
0.1747070402,
0.2501752675,
0.2344193012,
-0.2846123576,
0.201239571,
0.8438593149,
-0.7224834561,
0.5297425389,
0.5824754238,
0.0319966786,
-0.2814247906,
0.841093123,
0.0171798673,
0.2135259211,
0.3695940971,
0.3576020598,
-0.071485661,
-0.5409014821,
-0.0389895588,
0.3205435574,
-0.7824961543,
-0.1106631532,
-0.4948402047,
0.1203999594,
-0.4056280553,
-0.074538134,
-0.3032111228,
-0.2386699915,
-0.5236677527,
-0.1736385822,
0.0937007144,
0.718945384,
-0.1261243224,
0.3079161644,
-0.4087557197,
0.2821784019,
0.029622199,
0.3699594438,
0.3385146856,
-0.3780475557,
-0.0678984076,
0.2102840096,
-0.1921958029,
-0.794814229,
0.5264443755,
-0.0962997004,
0.6604129076,
0.5588229299,
0.2436393052,
0.6009709239,
-0.5706781149,
0.3869154155,
0.1396271884,
-0.9538479447,
0.3263486326,
-0.4228401482,
0.3219318092,
0.5112072229,
0.2992775738,
-0.5183278918,
-0.2817024291,
-0.2164626122,
-0.9218060374,
0.5525488257,
-0.0453842841,
0.1356645077,
-0.0288039539,
0.1895059496,
0.2195900828,
0.4162472486,
-0.5671645999,
-0.5186140537,
-0.1604161114,
-0.1068024635,
-0.5432904363,
-0.5793959498,
0.187267825,
-0.2968562245,
0.7436480522,
0.0376807898,
-0.0955658853,
-0.1135498434,
-0.343398869,
-0.1312940866,
0.4273780882,
0.4113902748,
0.5262088776,
-0.0664616153,
0.213504374,
0.2044986188,
-0.3040023744,
0.0779618695,
-0.0248048343,
-0.6428427696,
-0.1139379516,
-0.0252970271,
0.8293854594,
0.2270998657,
-0.4198347926,
0.4251911938,
0.0480015688,
-0.1135804951,
-0.1698491126,
-0.1618808955,
0.2224577218,
0.1711360067,
0.0042206231,
-0.1723970473,
-0.0005185264,
-0.4002701044,
-0.1992290616,
0.6967949867,
-0.4393972158,
-0.1308753788,
0.639590323,
0.3831887245,
-0.1128792614,
0.5447747111,
-0.1286945194,
-0.5233367085,
0.4402163029,
0.6186484694,
0.8167852759,
-0.3841224015,
0.4578615129,
0.0418384224,
0.5198259354,
-0.1401908547,
0.1789240241,
-0.2236783803,
-0.892131567,
-0.607590735,
-0.6140229702,
-0.3451561332,
0.3362007737,
-0.6545024514,
-0.0550552756,
-0.3504600227,
0.0224000774,
-0.2645249665,
-0.050730072,
-0.6150456667,
-0.0175045244,
0.1572369933,
0.5417686105,
-0.9616322517,
0.7417281866,
0.5660008788,
-0.1099335328,
-0.6062122583,
-0.2217049152,
0.158116594,
-0.876201272,
0.6463986039,
0.1673694402,
-0.194611907,
-0.1778085977,
-0.3305597901,
-0.6076825261,
0.7070345283,
0.6382778287,
-0.6805188656,
0.3840151727,
0.4052249491,
0.3991507292,
-0.1450635493,
0.2922163308,
0.4478819966,
0.1688316315,
-0.2478780299,
-0.7536438704,
0.1532706767,
-0.2585804462,
0.0019348074,
0.2538604736,
-0.5889809728,
0.95337677,
-0.2080791444,
-0.1086434871,
-0.5291773677,
0.3118137717,
0.1905246079,
0.370739609,
0.6326611042,
0.4986453652,
0.8790777326,
0.1343268305,
0.5862312913,
0.0659616664,
0.1091898754,
0.9738012552,
-0.5219535232,
0.6062669754,
0.4931331873,
0.0517398715,
0.344643712,
0.413649261,
0.3442745209,
0.5571551919,
0.5212901831,
-0.2649472952,
-0.217264086,
-0.2521643043,
-0.0763522461,
0.4665682018,
0.1494193822,
-0.292439729,
-0.3828236163,
0.092421025,
0.4431408644,
0.3840936422,
-0.6008899212,
0.7830053568,
0.2546181381,
-0.5448191166,
0.5911281705,
0.0232790932,
0.8773675561,
-0.3406573534,
-0.030103391,
-0.6151353121,
0.57296139,
-0.2299443036,
-0.1145393699,
0.0771079063,
0.1853813827,
-0.3097676933,
-0.3339951038,
0.8750457168,
-0.5319207311,
-0.4306408763,
0.6850611567,
0.5439644456,
-0.0715534166,
-0.1872077137,
-0.6445878148,
0.1048748493,
0.1276992857,
-0.1971672773,
0.6746469736,
0.1089908853,
-0.2387750298,
0.9139322639,
0.6143757701,
0.0342978276,
-0.0737454817,
0.4745887816,
0.9691554308,
-0.4026474059,
-0.4206598401,
-1.0548315048,
0.2143343836,
0.0070574624,
0.0655053779,
0.9721420407,
0.3819150329,
1.1160795689,
0.1302274466,
0.8974331617,
0.601965189,
0.5527572632,
-0.3475282192,
0.7952196002,
-0.3750486076,
0.4667519033,
-0.5076889992,
-0.7381052971,
-0.1359021664,
0.4364418089,
-0.3012368977,
0.1015713215,
0.3676066995,
0.8068394661,
0.1019711122,
-0.0581891462,
0.2369992584,
0.0875995904,
0.1492176503,
0.5769968033,
0.6932560802,
-0.0223898571,
0.3706918061,
-0.4574273825,
-0.5047011971,
-0.0532377362,
-0.9306390285,
-1.3086379766,
-0.1538429111,
-0.282033056,
-0.2105889916,
0.3920559883,
0.741558075,
0.5029976368,
-0.811830163,
-0.4935852885,
-0.081808418,
0.4066469669,
0.0070260498,
-0.1208739951,
0.3507440686,
-0.2648744583,
-0.47795403,
0.3528125584,
0.0644328222,
-0.2272710502,
-0.3203744888,
-0.1432559937,
-0.0126550077,
-0.0611993633,
0.609382391,
0.1622285098,
-0.4777644277,
0.0847111121,
-0.1297794282,
0.2499858588,
-0.1467373669,
0.6580581069,
-0.9996308684,
0.1756042242,
0.5553326011,
0.5411462188,
0.5105236769,
0.0426362082,
0.6399433017,
-0.6550651789,
0.2561448216,
-0.0963711739,
0.4832126796,
0.4461221397,
-0.1859804988,
0.2487303913,
0.0610629842,
-0.5560134649,
-1.0052167177,
0.286621958,
-0.2909034193,
-0.6136860847,
1.2065886259,
0.1094744951,
-0.2775235474,
-0.0192540959,
-0.0292944238,
0.5931504965,
-0.3571897149,
0.7608827353,
0.3071885407,
0.2926460207,
-0.0481019579,
-0.3738718629,
0.5096812248,
0.6360650659,
-0.6725034118,
0.377145648,
0.4859922528,
0.3439344168,
-0.320735693,
0.7048038244,
-0.0828034878,
-0.0690489262,
-0.3313759267,
0.2633278072,
-0.1867121905,
-0.0811675191,
-0.6270183921,
0.016863659,
-0.2060275078,
-0.4234886765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13542v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13542v1 | Self-play with Execution Feedback: Improving Instruction-following Capabilities of Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T13:29:53 | 2024-06-19T13:29:53 | Guanting Dong, Keming Lu, Chengpeng Li, Tingyu Xia, Bowen Yu, Chang Zhou, Jingren Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | One core capability of large language models (LLMs) is to follow natural
language instructions. However, the issue of automatically constructing
high-quality training data to enhance the complex instruction-following
abilities of LLMs without manual annotation remains unresolved. In this paper,
we introduce AutoIF, the first scalable and reliable method for automatically
generating instruction-following training data. AutoIF transforms the
validation of instruction-following data quality into code verification,
requiring LLMs to generate instructions, the corresponding code to check the
correctness of the instruction responses, and unit test samples to verify the
code's correctness. Then, execution feedback-based rejection sampling can
generate data for Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning from
Human Feedback (RLHF) training. AutoIF achieves significant improvements across
three training algorithms, SFT, Offline DPO, and Online DPO, when applied to
the top open-source LLMs, Qwen2 and LLaMA3, in self-alignment and
strong-to-weak distillation settings. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/QwenLM/AutoIF. | [
-0.1684017479,
-0.5452834964,
0.3249066472,
0.5036298037,
0.0356309041,
0.107305415,
-0.0925109014,
-0.0789571181,
-0.0423893221,
0.6545444131,
-0.7135577798,
-0.534825623,
-0.4090484977,
0.1650099158,
-0.5559439063,
0.7675933838,
-0.2862566113,
-0.1048663408,
-0.2167073935,
-0.0793448091,
-0.3495512307,
-0.4311489165,
-0.4473455846,
-0.2010834515,
0.207279712,
0.6109694839,
0.3350872099,
1.0620105267,
0.3677724898,
0.4213013649,
0.6877351403,
0.4577476978,
-0.5422200561,
0.1687134206,
0.168269366,
-0.2679598927,
-0.4347651005,
-0.0061602592,
0.7661570311,
0.1062642634,
-0.4386278391,
0.148384735,
0.2081522346,
0.743309617,
-0.3551699817,
0.2657349408,
-0.2745725811,
0.0140926903,
0.2032863945,
-0.2797283828,
-0.5498352051,
-0.5529544353,
-0.1111496389,
-0.417727381,
-0.0537801832,
0.1284941584,
0.6773167849,
0.8291524053,
-0.2104628831,
-0.4733602703,
-0.7570828199,
0.4120430648,
-0.9825379252,
0.3289698064,
0.6337590218,
0.3017852604,
-0.4718730152,
-0.4777714312,
-0.4417617917,
-0.4250410497,
-0.2618223727,
0.0599351116,
0.046870999,
0.0886219665,
0.2239705771,
0.3867020011,
-0.4455550313,
0.1672848761,
-0.1926401705,
-0.0759735927,
0.8263314366,
0.0953101069,
0.2643032074,
0.0314138681,
-0.1721474677,
-0.1738184541,
-0.8688223362,
0.0372266844,
0.6056537628,
0.026308449,
-0.0678694695,
0.3162265718,
-0.4867587984,
0.7721365094,
0.5289746523,
-0.1176210493,
0.2221771628,
-0.317065686,
-0.2750095725,
-0.020584235,
0.9768308997,
0.1772292405,
0.1157676429,
-0.1707934588,
-0.4648678899,
-0.4834917784,
0.2214353085,
-1.0168155432,
-0.5285135508,
0.0769727826,
-0.3485281765,
-0.4080717266,
0.107499674,
-0.4128159583,
-0.0361874439,
-0.4363078773,
0.461081177,
-0.3894459605,
-0.0520942174,
-0.2452454865,
0.3507879674,
0.3190005422,
0.2287208438,
-1.0500885248,
0.3002575338,
0.381251812,
0.4526878893,
-0.2969089746,
-0.5812399387,
-1.0305598974,
0.2614537477,
-0.4695342779,
0.7697225213,
-0.2492926568,
-0.3282198608,
-0.1930138022,
0.143080771,
0.0019065613,
-0.5805001259,
-0.0427727252,
-0.3034666181,
0.131519109,
-0.157632336,
-0.8163173795,
-0.0350926481,
0.0995343477,
-0.4958873391,
1.2297819853,
0.1984691471,
-0.2418246865,
0.3123392463,
-0.4730197489,
-0.6961271167,
0.0172330104,
-0.4074505866,
-0.3909879029,
0.0305406265,
0.3569963872,
0.303883642,
0.0360986888,
0.1162551492,
-0.2552075386,
-0.3579408526,
-0.1254262924,
-0.5078379512,
0.3306284547,
-0.1207103282,
-0.8490410447,
0.0690649599,
-0.99077636,
0.2660076916,
0.0130208433,
-0.4680187702,
0.2073694915,
0.2371641695,
-0.4664897919,
0.1471883208,
0.044475466,
-0.4176262021,
0.3881730139,
-0.3760133088,
0.3108758926,
0.6672865748,
0.0940086916,
0.3190221488,
-0.1232151985,
0.6035804749,
-0.4858424962,
0.2157360166,
-0.4380802214,
-0.0043541165,
-0.6900387406,
-0.3430533111,
0.3260394037,
0.6514959335,
-0.8508841395,
0.5726321936,
0.2189140916,
-0.4366929531,
-0.5969084501,
0.6883099079,
0.5500589013,
0.5468429923,
0.321380794,
-0.1568784863,
-0.5492145419,
-0.7025269866,
0.163687706,
-0.4513235688,
0.249395594,
0.310426116,
0.199131608,
-0.3674125075,
0.8963911533,
-0.2910419405,
-0.3718642592,
-0.0379838906,
0.4683976173,
-0.1196008697,
0.6166405678,
0.5328813195,
-0.1944100708,
-0.5140774846,
-0.2398465872,
-0.5949583054,
-0.4343600273,
-0.1122757345,
-0.2002817243,
0.3598077595,
0.6171373725,
-0.0488958023,
0.4181355238,
0.7992781997,
-0.0300991014,
0.3642479479,
-0.5018770695,
0.5051455498,
-0.7212608457,
0.0155527033,
-0.3625976145,
-0.5008057356,
-0.2851966321,
-0.1330377162,
0.1233207211,
0.2588745952,
-0.220577687,
0.2644427419,
-0.5204982162,
-0.162515521,
-0.5989547968,
-0.2610901892,
-0.0378573947,
0.4371327162,
0.1485124677,
1.0365884304,
0.4684131145,
-0.7372557521,
0.4904803932,
0.2087846696,
-0.1710320413,
0.2484808862,
-0.779805243,
0.178765893,
0.0478552841,
0.3677232862,
-1.1353313923,
-0.4974711835,
0.2568059564,
-0.2580578923,
0.4881247282,
-0.4125169218,
-0.7057420611,
-0.4885163605,
-0.0284634009,
0.1240089312,
0.6262346506,
-0.7260860801,
0.5032761693,
0.2818610072,
0.0408972725,
-0.4867677093,
-0.6738003492,
-0.0744987354,
0.3309749365,
-0.1564116329,
0.0503999591,
-0.3510335386,
0.2093263417,
-0.1960852444,
-0.027491048,
-0.070619151,
0.2277446091,
0.3111763895,
0.2550641298,
-0.0210085362,
0.0875936225,
0.1354029775,
-0.1193696037,
0.1857395023,
-0.2334807664,
0.1898689568,
-0.0812329277,
-0.6182540655,
-0.7477734685,
0.0410372205,
0.3627977073,
-0.3546944559,
0.1910986453,
0.5755177736,
-0.0939952582,
-0.5552972555,
-0.5613396168,
-0.2351028621,
-0.5245864391,
0.1169510111,
0.0044540111,
-0.7411719561,
0.0849099159,
0.049571652,
0.4443563521,
0.3348941803,
0.6147642136,
-0.3935613334,
1.1297568083,
0.6577541232,
-0.0368707776,
0.4746469259,
-0.2656579018,
0.0075305635,
-0.5211774111,
0.0163251963,
-0.1736367345,
-0.1291689575,
-0.4854632914,
-0.3842714429,
0.0933199972,
0.0495087467,
-0.0344507992,
0.5342770219,
-0.6244668961,
0.5045465231,
0.5649504066,
-0.1534747034,
0.1529071927,
-0.1913061142,
-0.0270167533,
0.2507880628,
-0.6900931597,
-0.3999660909,
0.9182211757,
0.4471274614,
1.1857004166,
-0.0888217241,
1.2857446671,
0.3569270074,
0.7624939084,
-0.5231345892,
0.3259311914,
-0.0800852403,
-0.3130748868,
-0.4444461167,
-0.6623485684,
-0.3882836401,
-0.230644241,
0.0236978345,
-0.3311826885,
-0.0309100654,
0.8441540003,
-0.7494559884,
0.0512280874,
-0.7606489062,
0.6173209548,
-0.6527307034,
-0.3125,
0.0056726327,
-0.3850639164,
0.2412356585,
0.0765137523,
0.1026951745,
-0.1077273488,
0.0507769771,
0.4478960335,
-0.5264256001,
0.8693292737,
-0.235561341,
-0.4790647924,
0.640684247,
0.3142082989,
0.668178916,
0.0369017497,
0.0989323631,
-0.2203097641,
0.0265775658,
-0.1124624982,
-0.6729078889,
0.7977429032,
-0.6729055047,
-0.6400797367,
-0.1672479361,
-0.2841558754,
-0.1605932266,
0.28858006,
0.157845825,
0.623558104,
-0.1591006964,
0.0689944699,
0.7415849566,
-0.0590606332,
0.5526592731,
0.6231287122,
-0.355899483,
-0.6296162009,
1.0974684954,
0.1690689921,
0.2309354693,
0.3441838026,
0.0447995253,
-0.2556782365,
-0.4995695651,
-1.0946061611,
0.0964300558,
-0.559345603,
-0.4026097059,
-0.4964093268,
-0.2118409276,
-0.4416388571,
0.1942366958,
-0.5494868755,
-0.1309642643,
-0.3068563342,
-0.0641512796,
0.2582195401,
1.2035337687,
-0.1681861281,
0.2613090277,
-0.9534186125,
0.126489833,
0.4763016105,
0.6408461332,
-0.0840626955,
-0.6249920726,
-0.3153144717,
-0.0544120483,
-0.1488387436,
-0.6989333034,
0.2654369771,
0.4298449457,
0.6577791572,
0.2933433354,
0.0284888037,
0.5666840672,
-0.7697085738,
0.4440497756,
-0.100847967,
-0.8285101652,
0.5624424815,
-0.121717006,
0.2992940545,
0.7664526701,
0.2469879389,
0.0072155441,
-0.4643531144,
-0.3793801665,
-0.6299771667,
0.7126181126,
0.1397442371,
0.0473662876,
-0.2124843299,
0.5500083566,
0.132814467,
0.2762079239,
-0.487090528,
-0.3355776668,
-0.2706891,
-0.5662336946,
0.0622518808,
-0.0316089317,
0.0580876097,
-0.1868149191,
0.888444066,
-0.5024912953,
0.2233202457,
0.33802104,
-0.3107971549,
-0.4340040088,
-0.2271966934,
0.4761661291,
0.5584697723,
-0.0760483742,
-0.0354365371,
0.1900290847,
-0.2276204079,
0.3374203742,
0.1562672406,
-0.1402088106,
-0.2141861171,
0.3581511378,
0.6812526584,
0.2935926914,
-0.6825050712,
0.4424499273,
-0.300319761,
-0.3165309727,
-0.411862582,
0.6283106208,
-0.0213289596,
0.1928344816,
0.2142324448,
-0.3630007207,
0.319693625,
-0.4424374402,
0.6433607936,
0.2397244126,
-0.3662477732,
-0.2828578651,
0.4953223467,
0.2728214562,
-0.2817266285,
0.5304792523,
-0.4466510713,
-0.5392159224,
0.5916138887,
0.3922253847,
0.7495781183,
-0.3857459426,
0.2864143252,
0.5159279108,
0.3125485182,
-0.1622361392,
0.184365347,
-0.340320915,
-0.1417283714,
-0.6143161654,
-0.5341028571,
-0.4847556353,
-0.1200536117,
-0.5932494402,
0.1593192965,
-0.6355152726,
0.1214909554,
-0.3540124595,
-0.0708076432,
-0.5895140767,
0.2392714024,
0.3189702928,
0.7901527882,
-0.4924001098,
0.9503463507,
0.440005064,
-0.3453504145,
-0.9321662784,
0.1800146252,
-0.0916246697,
-0.8303566575,
0.6695495248,
0.2648410499,
-0.3200941682,
0.2922214866,
-0.6203328371,
-1.1263335943,
1.1602429152,
0.1870052963,
-0.8671504855,
0.0170833673,
-0.046278704,
0.5345497131,
-0.5823101401,
0.4844582677,
0.6326056123,
0.2603727877,
0.242056638,
-0.6633040905,
-0.0268659908,
0.0121321566,
-0.2190673202,
0.178149581,
-0.8311781883,
0.2517782152,
-0.2351703197,
-0.0873534009,
0.0692984164,
1.0007083416,
-0.0662457347,
-0.1001770422,
0.6629232168,
0.5874121189,
0.5693203211,
0.1326479465,
0.8914194107,
-0.6381896138,
0.253878504,
1.5861570835,
-0.3585295081,
0.8502870202,
0.1216802076,
0.0498638339,
0.6471540928,
0.5102540255,
-0.2321365625,
0.4840761423,
0.313339591,
0.2149553746,
-0.1324294806,
0.3880632222,
-0.0001555044,
0.4207553566,
0.1247396842,
-0.362418294,
-0.1739212573,
-0.1526219547,
-0.2085874081,
-0.0615157932,
-0.0595001653,
1.0843532085,
-0.2129705846,
-1.0205558538,
0.7014490366,
-0.1223507673,
0.4548813701,
-0.5279032588,
-0.535512507,
-0.2369992733,
0.0594750568,
-0.2511496246,
-0.611559391,
0.2660005689,
0.0741617978,
-0.0954687744,
-0.2456450313,
0.5102656484,
-0.7380236387,
-0.2968103588,
0.373193562,
0.3207911253,
-0.0498514213,
0.3946003318,
-0.685182929,
0.0584431142,
0.1249914691,
-0.3779720068,
0.2004937828,
0.33628124,
0.3091830611,
0.6808232665,
0.5103749633,
-0.0716475621,
0.1285795122,
0.0453264415,
0.7132134438,
-0.3636692464,
-0.3557853997,
-0.6728496552,
0.2330511361,
0.001133915,
-0.3769890964,
0.633978188,
0.2702180743,
0.8455041051,
0.2087626755,
0.7157423496,
-0.1160285622,
0.4456397295,
-0.3926632702,
0.7813233137,
-0.3812210858,
0.1665045321,
0.0441827178,
-0.6455019712,
0.0283015985,
0.5897242427,
-0.144242838,
0.1459218115,
0.381052494,
0.8292146921,
0.0072409119,
-0.1818972677,
0.274040997,
0.2033283561,
0.3506191075,
0.2294909209,
0.6236850023,
-0.431925863,
0.602404356,
-0.4692660868,
-0.4773755968,
-0.2935114801,
-1.0101325512,
-0.9833467007,
-0.3422676623,
-0.4561701417,
-0.3484342098,
0.0560267679,
1.3305130005,
0.9327314496,
-0.9703794718,
-0.283801347,
-0.3068223596,
-0.0838524252,
-0.2486899644,
-0.1827309728,
0.3353942633,
-0.7415389419,
-0.617046237,
0.6621460915,
0.3441565335,
0.1732618958,
-0.5959025025,
-0.4256770909,
-0.1011923701,
0.2408284992,
0.3612344563,
0.4737910628,
-0.4736484289,
-0.3444722891,
0.0236914549,
-0.3260479569,
0.045004122,
0.6156817675,
-0.7120084167,
0.4167229831,
0.28954795,
1.0269720554,
0.0748974904,
0.0768969506,
0.8417237997,
-0.5617790222,
-0.44953987,
0.1709881574,
0.2600883245,
0.3574596941,
-0.5625241995,
0.4819075763,
0.0062855077,
-0.7121851444,
-0.67099756,
0.1539846361,
-0.2610689998,
0.2221425176,
1.1049385071,
-0.4782856107,
-0.4816356897,
0.3082891703,
-0.1933218539,
0.1972155273,
-0.4373050034,
0.9169028997,
0.702118516,
-0.296931386,
-0.3526347876,
-0.4946314991,
0.8273345232,
0.3557117581,
-1.010351181,
0.2855531573,
0.4974585176,
0.360675782,
-0.2987526655,
0.5881865621,
0.0140949851,
0.492549479,
-0.401139915,
0.1945783496,
-0.2790067792,
-0.5269541144,
-0.3130542934,
-0.1581923962,
0.2022345215,
-0.1391724944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13502v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13502v1 | ManWav: The First Manchu ASR Model | 2024-06-19T12:47:34 | 2024-06-19T12:47:34 | Jean Seo, Minha Kang, Sungjoo Byun, Sangah Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This study addresses the widening gap in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR)
research between high resource and extremely low resource languages, with a
particular focus on Manchu, a critically endangered language. Manchu
exemplifies the challenges faced by marginalized linguistic communities in
accessing state-of-the-art technologies. In a pioneering effort, we introduce
the first-ever Manchu ASR model ManWav, leveraging Wav2Vec2-XLSR-53. The
results of the first Manchu ASR is promising, especially when trained with our
augmented data. Wav2Vec2-XLSR-53 fine-tuned with augmented data demonstrates a
0.02 drop in CER and 0.13 drop in WER compared to the same base model
fine-tuned with original data. | [
-0.1919895262,
-0.2986938953,
-0.0431844667,
0.0883546695,
-0.3272225559,
0.2065434754,
-0.1114220843,
-0.4909530878,
-0.0502315424,
0.6030281782,
-0.4682836831,
-0.1226597279,
-0.7059364319,
-0.1544909626,
-0.7113967538,
0.4506394565,
0.314933598,
0.111221917,
0.3324671388,
-0.2758380771,
-0.2380761802,
-0.4954580069,
-0.7882080078,
-0.2583710849,
0.237490043,
0.5305454135,
0.6807371974,
0.8550131321,
0.4405421317,
0.3065708876,
-0.2878108919,
-0.0654980093,
-0.172005102,
-0.3524356782,
0.2072099,
-0.3169052601,
-0.2309033573,
-0.0522842035,
0.7671667337,
0.4980388582,
-0.6005340815,
0.1326497644,
-0.0943858773,
0.3466410339,
-0.4347094893,
0.1913470179,
-0.6217601299,
-0.2119523138,
-0.7273237705,
0.2254357785,
-0.4069173336,
0.0855619758,
0.382901758,
-0.855879426,
0.1123660952,
-0.032584168,
1.0250070095,
0.5235975981,
-0.4369353056,
0.1249104962,
-0.927472055,
0.9824422598,
-0.569793582,
0.6472321153,
0.6429860592,
0.5615574121,
0.0472938344,
-0.7125236988,
-0.778631866,
-0.2155856043,
0.1105523333,
-0.0379046984,
-0.3273192942,
-0.3121940494,
0.1005764902,
0.2724204063,
-0.2236540318,
0.3179406524,
-0.9930850267,
-0.5633647442,
0.6439340115,
0.3207629323,
0.1725400984,
-0.6076837778,
-0.3596043587,
-0.1899455041,
-0.3891950846,
0.3088131547,
0.0531920008,
0.3793248534,
-0.1865627468,
0.46707955,
-0.2022791356,
0.6796296239,
-0.0718469545,
-0.0324716009,
0.0957421064,
-0.2353888452,
-0.0900613815,
0.1281677932,
0.8298650384,
0.126353398,
-0.0450904816,
0.3599567115,
-0.1626422703,
0.2143753767,
0.0923147202,
-0.4316782951,
-0.5531193018,
-0.2684800327,
-0.5603160858,
-0.0930089131,
-0.0001036156,
-0.4199693203,
-0.6195929646,
-0.0856302008,
0.6180923581,
-0.4358327389,
-0.7473427653,
-0.2597614229,
-0.2180990279,
0.884503603,
0.1447602808,
-1.0883426666,
0.6082576513,
0.8340332508,
0.5235486627,
0.0700187758,
-0.2198432535,
-0.4722843468,
0.0216786284,
-0.5306053162,
0.6400849223,
-0.5798001885,
-0.7289103866,
-0.4679052234,
-0.0041352822,
0.4461828768,
-0.6843043566,
0.9354196787,
-0.3953299224,
0.1452841312,
-0.3793148398,
-0.1612644792,
-0.1326632351,
-0.2204831094,
-0.6551539302,
0.9418535233,
0.4256795645,
-0.6129391789,
0.6240116358,
-0.7270827293,
-0.4926989377,
0.2208430171,
-0.2765425742,
-0.460144788,
-0.1539949477,
-0.1461391598,
-0.0065082661,
-0.7407460213,
-0.07203798,
0.2838068604,
-0.1706203222,
0.1584656388,
-0.465885669,
0.8873980045,
0.3351769447,
-0.1498413235,
0.2232893109,
-1.0321071148,
0.0919499397,
0.3085717559,
-0.7259210348,
-0.6359375715,
0.1580461115,
0.3692562282,
0.1975141764,
0.0363071151,
-0.9613633156,
-0.3668863773,
-0.622369349,
0.6144856215,
0.6732578278,
-0.4572893381,
0.4690478146,
-0.0782612935,
0.0585753508,
0.0717245564,
0.3743984699,
0.0501686707,
-0.47182706,
-0.9771090746,
-0.2927686572,
0.365719378,
0.5766979456,
-0.5783953071,
0.0392938294,
0.0591685846,
-0.6898394227,
-1.0426079035,
-0.1527884305,
0.6488868594,
0.4854403734,
0.2594228983,
-0.2512044609,
-0.9359552264,
-1.2924870253,
-0.1379663497,
-0.425837338,
-0.2001302242,
0.3881357908,
-0.1822874844,
-0.3380752504,
0.8149621487,
-0.4988399446,
-0.4615695477,
-0.226382792,
0.1850050539,
-0.0143745784,
0.5401598215,
0.0991780832,
-1.0755355358,
-0.6654146314,
0.123815529,
-0.2838295698,
0.0278711542,
0.5211051106,
0.0630666614,
0.6032338142,
0.3648653924,
-0.3757893443,
0.190824613,
0.5128361583,
-0.1356464177,
0.3182076514,
-0.2442722172,
0.1333672702,
-1.1644217968,
0.1077917889,
-0.1025281698,
0.0030553106,
-1.0737601519,
-0.3030832708,
0.2439444661,
-0.1566940844,
-0.4651355743,
0.4831077158,
-0.4318931401,
-0.0821147189,
-0.2947964668,
-0.2028370649,
-0.3665086627,
0.0531460904,
0.1938881874,
0.6714693904,
0.5818364024,
-0.5932889581,
0.3762260079,
0.6435749531,
-0.429525733,
0.303083837,
-0.8203410506,
0.1417148113,
-0.0437431112,
-0.1819352657,
-0.6861976981,
-0.4509476721,
0.1863523275,
-0.8115664124,
0.4892173409,
0.0623817295,
0.0313319564,
-0.501496315,
-0.0634660199,
0.2344090492,
0.9125823379,
-0.4785681963,
0.643738687,
1.1803319454,
-0.115837343,
-0.6333767176,
-0.5600364804,
0.0102890283,
-0.0861198381,
-0.5138038397,
0.1210284159,
0.1525587887,
-0.4081612229,
-0.2931395769,
-0.299174726,
-0.4330568314,
0.02655177,
0.343693912,
0.6337132454,
-0.2739825249,
-0.3690221012,
-0.1711891741,
-0.6108964086,
0.0391373932,
0.023177037,
0.46484676,
-0.1398520619,
-0.0549808517,
-0.5739747882,
0.3262885809,
0.465151757,
-0.3694739044,
0.2989400625,
0.5989257097,
-0.7330560684,
0.213330701,
-0.5554320216,
0.0362696387,
-0.5333457589,
0.4916275442,
-0.3986912668,
-0.6069273353,
0.2604502738,
0.2357297242,
0.0366529077,
0.7085843086,
0.3935361207,
0.1184936911,
1.0938074589,
0.8835847974,
-0.1525695026,
0.4910523593,
-0.1858822405,
-0.1458403915,
-0.9788036942,
-0.5636720061,
-0.6275985837,
0.19981049,
-0.5787465572,
-0.4590711594,
0.4322397709,
-0.4171799719,
-0.1666375548,
0.4842377603,
-0.5618718863,
0.4742465615,
0.7435497046,
0.0571514964,
0.1727033556,
-0.3953534663,
0.2909159064,
-0.3984712958,
-0.5159292817,
-0.2648187876,
0.8376334906,
0.2426508367,
1.025676012,
0.1513488889,
0.3282722235,
0.4237391353,
0.0285026785,
-0.6485150456,
0.573230207,
-0.7417874336,
-0.7808819413,
-0.7671889663,
-0.2820655406,
-0.9153155088,
0.1328265369,
-0.235315308,
-0.2391931117,
0.0432410501,
0.2488043457,
-0.5255323648,
0.0268243235,
-0.5645922422,
0.7206158042,
-0.2204445899,
-0.0952070281,
-0.3125191927,
-1.0895340443,
0.3952754438,
-0.0959628075,
0.255961448,
-0.1186846271,
-0.007301894,
0.9744853377,
-0.3795878589,
0.3010876775,
-0.3732742965,
0.1412839442,
0.351764977,
-0.1223212257,
0.3479310274,
-0.4225426316,
-0.0702493787,
0.1989604086,
-0.0608017966,
-0.4193948209,
-0.0856525078,
0.5309403539,
-1.256744504,
-0.7039231062,
-0.3731732965,
-0.2052209079,
0.1669060588,
0.3044174314,
0.3769596517,
0.5281808376,
-0.2992078662,
0.2116704881,
0.4965459704,
-0.3463969529,
0.1127628237,
0.9438229799,
-0.0177606381,
-0.5263520479,
1.0785974264,
0.3842162192,
0.5441130996,
0.1844482571,
0.361747086,
-0.299602896,
-0.414262861,
-0.6000538468,
0.0594196543,
-0.6149175763,
0.0647131279,
-0.877243042,
-0.6576205492,
-0.2284883112,
-0.0342770219,
-0.7600308657,
-0.469080925,
-0.3495451212,
0.3043798804,
0.3104496896,
0.8050971031,
-0.3307386935,
0.2133153081,
-0.7581887841,
0.5625662804,
0.5124406815,
0.3651852012,
-0.2207927853,
-0.9017418027,
-0.1802298278,
0.0461515673,
0.1637490243,
-0.3284887969,
0.5277663469,
0.325938791,
0.6612045765,
0.2537714541,
0.3637583852,
0.6011938453,
-0.546127677,
0.8554375172,
0.2531900108,
-1.0023896694,
0.5282776356,
-0.3294347823,
0.3354069293,
0.1881735474,
0.1076697558,
-0.5929850936,
-0.2192896605,
-0.4912220538,
-0.955360353,
1.0948368311,
-0.2072998434,
0.154947862,
0.2572242618,
-0.0039453381,
0.4050944746,
-0.0508992895,
-0.2361070514,
-0.2693481147,
-0.5146491528,
-0.0007415597,
-0.1487957388,
-0.2587537467,
0.1247029975,
-0.4416300654,
0.7534207702,
0.1267523915,
-0.0463668182,
0.087033391,
-0.2840535641,
-0.4354136884,
0.3737458587,
0.4647886157,
0.1756104529,
-0.090616107,
0.0544955917,
0.5018111467,
-0.7071430087,
0.2069653869,
0.1965167969,
-0.2272904217,
-0.0927689746,
-0.1812580973,
1.1002887487,
0.3907974362,
-0.667060256,
0.4579205811,
-0.217306748,
0.0058513419,
-0.7765493989,
0.1647556573,
0.045415923,
0.3477110565,
0.6108884215,
0.1966271847,
0.2575921714,
-0.5512464046,
0.2221795171,
0.5810876489,
-0.5535794497,
-0.2141247988,
1.2159768343,
0.4136083424,
-0.7630216479,
0.6924203634,
0.0759968609,
-0.6427845359,
0.4282845259,
0.5690706372,
0.7386960387,
-0.6013287902,
-0.0120337131,
0.5275412798,
0.4751107395,
-0.0503248647,
0.2840826213,
-0.0630423874,
-0.4658069909,
-0.1286416948,
-0.655672431,
-0.8338312507,
-0.023020599,
-0.9868788719,
0.7956851721,
-0.4138880968,
-0.1330061406,
0.3668757081,
0.0555057414,
-0.1801198125,
0.0780753568,
0.3695344031,
0.9974873066,
-0.6788781881,
0.9953556657,
0.4823882282,
-0.2255099714,
-0.8411939144,
-0.1459096372,
0.1576113254,
-0.8370927572,
0.4344326854,
-0.082842648,
-0.2558090091,
0.3544365466,
-0.390733391,
-1.2224370241,
1.1815413237,
0.1526106149,
-0.3196733594,
0.246724084,
-0.059724234,
0.4686387479,
0.0814637393,
-0.1699626595,
0.9194286466,
0.4161959887,
0.2839106619,
-1.4394230843,
-0.0948648825,
-0.3795714676,
0.0657146201,
0.5149794817,
-1.0222210884,
1.1547435522,
-0.697668016,
-0.5517845154,
0.2975652218,
0.6773927808,
-0.0436395071,
0.1309049875,
0.6408753395,
0.118654117,
0.583055079,
-0.0761360973,
0.8187782168,
0.1732768267,
-0.1087523848,
0.8715763688,
-0.4348583221,
1.1753464937,
0.1231566221,
-0.4558676481,
0.2428364903,
0.4158232212,
0.036810644,
0.7108965516,
-0.0739793703,
-0.318673104,
-0.0857683048,
-0.2626204193,
-0.300471127,
0.8787428737,
0.3801598847,
0.0312660076,
0.2126334757,
0.023065744,
0.0455207191,
0.0546119101,
-0.419429183,
1.2103279829,
-0.0669137016,
-0.4073788822,
0.930660367,
0.017045157,
0.8898524642,
-0.8616996408,
0.1267910302,
0.239035368,
0.2678466439,
-0.1697282195,
-0.7118829489,
0.5578404069,
0.0975229368,
-0.4391121268,
0.2915965617,
0.977324903,
-0.4738534987,
-0.269459486,
0.3374730349,
0.0637326911,
0.2037447691,
0.253249228,
-0.2423725426,
0.2689651251,
0.0762626678,
0.004046421,
0.3205117285,
-0.075518392,
-0.1287374943,
0.6735178232,
0.6693568826,
-0.0816331357,
0.299223423,
-0.1058182344,
0.8728039861,
-0.8753535748,
-0.442501694,
-0.6939777136,
0.6342070699,
-0.1342532188,
-0.1902251542,
0.5689108372,
0.5154818296,
0.6893740892,
0.0115320105,
0.9455785751,
-0.3648662269,
1.0015107393,
-0.1181587726,
1.2039114237,
-0.451525569,
-0.0297220983,
-0.1965097785,
-0.1667671055,
-0.0517623946,
0.6159498096,
0.1178043261,
-0.4152180552,
0.2075790167,
0.8433051109,
0.2304233313,
0.1458854824,
0.5563185811,
0.5189613104,
0.1552782059,
0.2399481386,
0.9694584608,
-0.5994594693,
0.8587760925,
-0.2873817086,
-0.417525351,
-0.1541662663,
-0.2838984728,
-0.344071418,
-1.0878597498,
0.0197404269,
-0.2866721749,
-0.061047487,
1.1840258837,
0.7941153646,
-0.8340014815,
-0.2879894376,
0.3976167142,
-0.1655873209,
0.0146029061,
-0.1664212793,
0.0743053779,
0.4907462895,
-0.5174803734,
0.498244673,
0.2925308049,
0.0947100893,
-0.3803852201,
-0.5034886003,
-0.1135367006,
0.1887552142,
0.7120274305,
0.6970325708,
-0.9871242046,
-0.3716703951,
0.3120231032,
-0.1486361921,
0.1507675946,
0.4533245564,
-0.7841973305,
0.5110843182,
0.2072224021,
0.4263890088,
0.439468205,
-0.0348392613,
0.5788658261,
-0.5287501812,
0.1521082222,
0.1417720616,
0.1913360804,
0.7325049043,
0.0834827572,
0.4036901295,
0.0090133678,
-0.5512638092,
-1.163164258,
0.1863262653,
-0.8904170394,
0.2661836743,
0.9970591068,
0.2501624525,
-0.1838386804,
-0.3704476655,
-0.7764630914,
0.5299239159,
-0.4873802662,
0.8189111352,
0.557109952,
-0.0911613107,
-0.4026307464,
-0.4345236421,
0.6114115715,
0.0507173054,
-0.6360159516,
0.3542702794,
0.4607233405,
0.4416552484,
0.1862768233,
0.9790984392,
-0.1736600548,
0.582372427,
0.5440278053,
0.0235812906,
0.0059260777,
-0.2566122413,
-0.3739567101,
-0.2062851638,
0.6090017557,
-0.3845446408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13476v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13476v3 | LLMs Are Zero-Shot Context-Aware Simultaneous Translators | 2024-06-19T11:57:42 | 2024-06-25T04:45:19 | Roman Koshkin, Katsuhito Sudoh, Satoshi Nakamura | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advent of transformers has fueled progress in machine translation. More
recently large language models (LLMs) have come to the spotlight thanks to
their generality and strong performance in a wide range of language tasks,
including translation. Here we show that open-source LLMs perform on par with
or better than some state-of-the-art baselines in simultaneous machine
translation (SiMT) tasks, zero-shot. We also demonstrate that injection of
minimal background information, which is easy with an LLM, brings further
performance gains, especially on challenging technical subject-matter. This
highlights LLMs' potential for building next generation of massively
multilingual, context-aware and terminologically accurate SiMT systems that
require no resource-intensive training or fine-tuning. | [
-0.1926315725,
-0.627710402,
0.8828451037,
0.2110999227,
-0.3729726672,
0.1401025504,
-0.4515348971,
-0.3320109248,
0.0347240008,
0.5793167949,
-0.4524772763,
-0.6009091139,
-0.8178469539,
0.1548879296,
-0.7392451167,
0.8417311907,
-0.3105678856,
0.0402588993,
-0.21070382,
-0.2700679898,
-0.4140317142,
-0.5238457918,
-0.3304278255,
-0.3886857331,
0.748218298,
0.3157622516,
0.819208324,
0.8441261649,
0.5906839967,
0.2996592224,
0.0374249667,
0.0104864677,
-0.3999103308,
0.3369671404,
-0.0818255469,
-0.6087412238,
-0.4561761618,
-0.0744692162,
0.6515743732,
0.632388711,
0.1905862093,
0.2296968997,
-0.0869119018,
0.3699515462,
-0.5955063105,
0.0409251265,
-0.7664725184,
0.0592751913,
-0.1450348645,
-0.5125807524,
-0.4944616854,
-0.0955576301,
-0.3532906473,
-0.4924899042,
0.0073931538,
-0.0061011203,
0.5918029547,
0.6049948931,
-0.6781736612,
-0.0340842865,
-0.9919749498,
0.875675261,
-0.5494965315,
0.4377808571,
-0.2742123008,
0.403324455,
-0.2212324291,
-0.5970696211,
-0.5186358094,
-0.1439409405,
-0.0846281424,
0.237862125,
-0.1254649907,
0.0120934993,
0.3066808283,
0.5324029326,
-0.4640361965,
0.3134140968,
-0.1692055911,
0.088996537,
0.3114143908,
0.3501932919,
0.3738681674,
0.0187692214,
-0.5876243711,
0.2871235907,
-0.8638960719,
-0.3939731419,
-0.1874319166,
0.3751170039,
-0.3442414105,
0.8750473857,
-0.1236226708,
0.755844295,
-0.3154959679,
-0.2536035776,
-0.0538515151,
-0.4874670506,
-0.4453001022,
-0.0961382613,
0.9285054207,
0.1027598232,
0.2845748961,
-0.4904156923,
-0.2387212366,
0.0346925445,
0.0002936798,
-0.7609258294,
0.3864583075,
0.3452058136,
-0.1215291396,
-0.0498396382,
-0.1334345192,
-0.1741108894,
-0.126606971,
-0.6210880876,
0.5467546582,
-0.2611396313,
-0.1010315642,
0.1995880604,
-0.085378021,
0.3975007534,
0.5978306532,
-0.544655025,
0.1563788205,
0.7507737279,
1.2281790972,
-0.3033962548,
-0.3285827637,
-0.6790643334,
0.4906793535,
-0.6212732792,
0.6302876472,
-0.1642088741,
-0.3141729832,
0.0277692601,
-0.1466732323,
0.1668164879,
-0.4733008444,
0.3923779726,
-0.5665022731,
-0.1196554825,
-0.226187855,
-0.5050754547,
0.0919163898,
0.1279354244,
-0.3008967042,
0.9467622638,
0.0361748375,
-0.4683114588,
0.2906932533,
-0.5312591195,
-0.4994375706,
0.5208419561,
-0.1438010037,
0.1715213507,
0.4221350253,
-0.0314136334,
0.6492224932,
-0.4336835444,
0.1840673536,
-0.2160338461,
-0.5800540447,
0.171452716,
-0.5115006566,
0.4592103362,
0.2686107755,
-0.1263511628,
0.1965130121,
-0.4126467407,
-0.1282500476,
0.0915455893,
-0.3460709155,
-0.2743229568,
-0.0648268461,
-0.0586822964,
0.4962709248,
0.3027151525,
-0.6453205943,
0.3251778483,
-0.2450169921,
0.3544207215,
0.4871100485,
-0.437658608,
0.5135162473,
-0.2608410716,
0.4605308175,
0.0732614547,
-0.1741147935,
-0.5813117623,
-0.3658625484,
-0.9316384792,
-0.7370238304,
0.2086616904,
0.7481585145,
-0.8559315205,
0.3017292619,
-0.4227695167,
-0.3106094897,
-0.5146986842,
0.4516055882,
0.08984337,
0.3480502069,
0.36193645,
-0.1038747206,
-0.3767187595,
-0.9249714613,
-0.269441545,
0.229860872,
-0.3458854556,
0.1422808319,
0.3677344024,
-0.1912134439,
0.7998344898,
-0.3779958487,
-0.3556438684,
-0.3773901463,
-0.0327792168,
0.3952922225,
0.1459127367,
0.3821166456,
-0.5732824206,
-0.6979128718,
0.2455502301,
-1.1988451481,
-0.2800913751,
-0.0459654927,
-0.0824456066,
0.1486329287,
0.650190711,
-0.8334872723,
0.0389104709,
0.7403653264,
0.0984846205,
0.1295691729,
-0.3395373523,
-0.0350914896,
-1.3047665358,
0.2048360109,
-0.121096544,
-0.6500223279,
-0.789257288,
0.1762439907,
0.2922078669,
0.0035170186,
-1.0049796104,
0.7127642632,
-0.5953541398,
-0.4638728499,
-0.4306601882,
0.4510030448,
-0.2949339449,
0.1797300577,
-0.0711784884,
1.0039415359,
0.5521431565,
-0.5599002838,
0.3307109177,
0.051703386,
-0.2060975283,
0.7180767059,
-0.4354488254,
0.0340058394,
-0.0847436041,
0.3735331595,
-0.7736386657,
-0.4331492186,
0.1163344979,
-0.3025197685,
0.4075962603,
0.0473030321,
-0.7292563915,
-0.3356593847,
-0.0751819685,
0.4033197761,
0.583234787,
-0.4251199961,
0.4396001399,
0.0841464996,
-0.1668461263,
-0.589299798,
-0.8538466692,
0.3223394752,
0.0759518743,
-0.4941344261,
0.2236264348,
-0.0663217455,
-0.251811564,
-0.0137647307,
-0.1330968738,
-0.0786231011,
0.2702265084,
0.3224873841,
0.386018008,
-0.3490685523,
0.1829891354,
-0.0786712393,
-0.2665090561,
-0.3828236163,
-0.4782291055,
0.4423317015,
-0.1933673471,
-0.558819294,
-0.5101110339,
0.3548562825,
0.8658378124,
-0.0980643108,
0.9194617867,
0.3791972101,
-0.2539435029,
-0.1124225408,
-0.6206015348,
0.1659528017,
-0.4509781003,
0.2208019495,
-0.4540330768,
-1.3884162903,
0.2985516787,
-0.1776304096,
0.2048058212,
0.5023213029,
0.8992162347,
-0.1235843748,
0.8605692387,
0.6714236736,
0.0098257205,
0.3369440734,
0.1184701547,
0.2843547463,
-0.6583313346,
-0.0843337476,
-0.3541792333,
-0.2600072622,
-0.4325833619,
-0.7488162518,
0.3788052797,
0.3044683039,
-0.1765856296,
0.4173960984,
-0.2086509764,
0.5600672364,
0.4379180074,
-0.2555343509,
0.714269042,
-0.0727528632,
-0.1090606004,
0.0920818374,
-0.6286736131,
-0.631274879,
0.9926151037,
0.2015688717,
0.6467419863,
0.0233046412,
0.6023710966,
0.0651376843,
0.5418681502,
-1.0211315155,
0.6107096672,
-0.4436235726,
-0.5122383237,
-0.2217486203,
-0.4419770241,
-0.6228436828,
0.5528915524,
0.0205684416,
-0.4567339718,
-0.3774439991,
0.0449992865,
-0.2889236808,
0.5942991376,
-0.3411393464,
0.5527496338,
-0.5857021809,
-0.3586827815,
-0.1275296211,
-0.4583013058,
0.5755698085,
-0.4908970594,
0.1865424812,
-0.4080435932,
-0.5674051046,
0.0472225174,
-0.1086842045,
0.496969521,
0.1749619693,
-0.2036875933,
0.0898251906,
0.262237519,
0.2502345443,
-0.129285112,
-0.0396606103,
0.634318471,
-0.0947206616,
-0.418625921,
-0.5097301006,
0.9925765991,
-0.5761021972,
-0.8202044964,
-0.3562577963,
-1.1287223101,
-0.0536523312,
0.4184124172,
0.0501813702,
-0.0076819807,
-0.1681060791,
0.557880044,
0.5635483861,
-0.4368787408,
0.5526953936,
0.7915601134,
-0.3212584853,
-0.2038348466,
0.526411593,
0.1449653655,
0.5760191679,
0.7304548025,
-0.1917650998,
-0.1376516968,
-0.4103310108,
-0.785441339,
0.3770859241,
-0.5773633122,
-0.3008508384,
-0.9471622109,
-0.3040486574,
-0.2295987755,
-0.4901347458,
-0.440670073,
-0.522928834,
-0.0773995593,
0.0699727833,
0.1160600185,
0.9067033529,
-0.1903634965,
0.441814065,
-0.8838802576,
0.5149037242,
0.1970706284,
0.3994072378,
-0.3870984614,
-0.4415796697,
-0.281683296,
0.0166349318,
-0.4176856577,
-0.5722683668,
0.3528465927,
-0.1461276114,
0.5028467178,
0.0848457515,
-0.2088411152,
0.56209445,
-0.7403063774,
0.8786938787,
0.319624126,
-1.0174767971,
0.2317171693,
-0.4957788885,
0.6112909317,
0.2132038325,
0.3918983042,
-0.8919993043,
-0.5378376842,
0.0468307957,
-0.7230148315,
0.9697980881,
0.16679281,
0.4085587561,
0.0456134751,
0.3472672105,
0.0149211884,
0.432754457,
-0.7163233161,
-0.3167095482,
0.0557766072,
-0.2236552089,
-0.4029925764,
-0.2425792515,
-0.0087203765,
-0.0700978041,
0.4588148594,
-0.1735855043,
0.290196389,
-0.0626197681,
-0.3198020756,
-0.3471786082,
0.5602203608,
0.8203119636,
0.4456326663,
-0.2455964088,
0.2322779894,
0.4785590768,
0.0711776614,
0.4943223,
-0.2104820311,
-0.3598547578,
0.0983696207,
0.2652715147,
0.7651808858,
0.5674417019,
-0.4474139512,
0.6799946427,
0.2334503233,
-0.1871244758,
-0.163664937,
-0.0739885345,
0.3718416393,
0.2276954204,
0.3965254724,
-0.045061823,
-0.2158500701,
-0.4240734875,
0.1434227377,
0.5932120085,
-0.3566577137,
-0.2982872725,
0.7143185139,
0.1131792217,
-0.339332521,
0.2223840654,
0.1896580458,
-0.2014520466,
0.4411676228,
0.5965884924,
1.0773601532,
-0.2410982847,
0.0772079378,
0.1739207953,
0.4316320121,
-0.3483211696,
-0.073902458,
-0.1345896125,
-0.5179117322,
-0.7464452386,
-0.9308175445,
-0.5107204914,
0.1830102354,
-0.3920857012,
0.5445373654,
-0.1814292073,
0.0542945191,
-0.2375024259,
-0.5175693035,
-0.7400500774,
-0.081113793,
0.1840235591,
1.0511341095,
-0.5650631785,
1.0158888102,
0.609515667,
-0.3621409535,
-0.3477544487,
-0.0978458747,
0.0371842235,
-0.6541908979,
0.826713264,
0.2325894535,
-0.1669746637,
0.0995732024,
-0.3111999929,
-1.046864152,
1.1771503687,
0.8615345955,
-0.6897575855,
-0.1839918643,
0.5892462134,
0.5735068917,
-0.2356168479,
0.2191314697,
0.2733325064,
0.3959933221,
0.2091501355,
-1.0135492086,
-0.1001008004,
0.296887517,
0.1945886463,
0.4475620091,
-0.7023487091,
0.8941171765,
0.0373185277,
-0.3917869031,
0.1525196582,
0.555834949,
-0.0446511693,
0.1791723073,
0.0570171401,
0.4012170136,
0.2668678164,
-0.1774283499,
1.4488850832,
-0.5957044363,
0.1407226622,
1.2243481874,
-0.524758935,
0.9984622598,
0.5317488909,
0.0552505925,
0.1088260636,
0.1358066797,
0.1637826264,
0.19208318,
-0.0047490862,
-0.47320351,
-0.579030931,
-0.2455679476,
-0.3029718697,
0.384739697,
0.2609250247,
-0.4030989707,
-0.4515226483,
-0.0559154637,
0.0514967404,
0.0007672156,
-0.2465639859,
0.6736804247,
0.5522894263,
-0.6124580503,
0.4985719621,
0.1917057782,
0.8584862351,
-0.7008172274,
0.197964102,
-0.2897204161,
0.1957365125,
-0.0815498009,
-0.7778291702,
0.4230658114,
0.189711228,
-0.0840460584,
-0.6020183563,
0.5972371101,
-0.5167649984,
-0.4450868368,
0.6513001323,
0.8158411384,
0.2098052949,
-0.1683994234,
-0.3688527048,
0.07384599,
-0.2820848823,
-0.103959173,
0.3535435498,
0.4204745889,
0.0326920785,
0.7191684842,
0.5381904244,
0.1476613581,
0.2104859948,
-0.2487704754,
0.5309990644,
-0.7320275903,
0.0730934963,
-1.002907753,
0.4529576898,
0.1346693337,
0.0682870224,
1.0103533268,
0.6729195714,
0.965862751,
-0.0449076779,
0.8025468588,
0.3026861846,
0.3588736951,
-0.3181072474,
0.6111687422,
-0.7888711095,
0.1492577344,
-0.0241484903,
-1.1236615181,
-0.6825699806,
0.021332236,
-0.217970863,
-0.1655417681,
0.6507757902,
0.7760545015,
-0.2295422256,
-0.2705852389,
0.9916937351,
0.2612670362,
0.1860432327,
0.6341801882,
0.8936599493,
-0.3835091889,
0.6857230067,
0.029834142,
-0.149206087,
-0.23566854,
-0.9762946367,
-0.7712023854,
-0.1212147102,
-0.1000515968,
0.1800108999,
-0.0300473776,
0.8335996866,
0.674593389,
-0.8044857383,
-0.426341027,
0.048522573,
0.0941631645,
0.0919695348,
-0.0965951681,
-0.2434662282,
-0.548594296,
-0.8893321157,
0.7528967261,
0.9279449582,
0.1182756796,
-0.4399830401,
-0.2436065376,
-0.1239269674,
0.3961274922,
0.865008533,
0.0754005015,
-1.0420581102,
-0.1575002372,
0.0855334103,
-0.5850558281,
0.223642692,
0.8452746272,
-0.587390244,
0.3501768112,
0.4247261584,
0.7983151674,
0.5648759007,
-0.1310666054,
0.5989843607,
-0.727822423,
0.394718498,
-0.0745784342,
0.3552775085,
0.4294657111,
-0.212748453,
0.5658079982,
0.185190618,
-0.4322142303,
-0.8690112233,
0.2456420958,
-0.8790822625,
-0.1840732396,
1.2760101557,
-0.1019017473,
-0.0447296984,
0.0918503031,
0.0190899596,
0.4545485973,
-0.1650236249,
0.2054629326,
0.7060310841,
0.1725132167,
-0.1592336595,
-1.0135266781,
0.0095244264,
0.4717088938,
-0.7956761718,
-0.1184094921,
0.4756169021,
0.2667168081,
0.0743971542,
0.622862041,
-0.1631183326,
0.0963429511,
-0.2338331342,
0.1907994896,
-0.2321276516,
-0.3681887984,
-0.5173666477,
0.3708257675,
0.211655274,
-0.0881659761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13469v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13469v1 | Encoder vs Decoder: Comparative Analysis of Encoder and Decoder Language Models on Multilingual NLU Tasks | 2024-06-19T11:50:09 | 2024-06-19T11:50:09 | Dan Saattrup Nielsen, Kenneth Enevoldsen, Peter Schneider-Kamp | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | This paper explores the performance of encoder and decoder language models on
multilingual Natural Language Understanding (NLU) tasks, with a broad focus on
Germanic languages. Building upon the ScandEval benchmark, which initially was
restricted to evaluating encoder models, we extend the evaluation framework to
include decoder models. We introduce a method for evaluating decoder models on
NLU tasks and apply it to the languages Danish, Swedish, Norwegian, Icelandic,
Faroese, German, Dutch, and English. Through a series of experiments and
analyses, we address key research questions regarding the comparative
performance of encoder and decoder models, the impact of NLU task types, and
the variation across language resources. Our findings reveal that decoder
models can achieve significantly better NLU performance than encoder models,
with nuances observed across different tasks and languages. Additionally, we
investigate the correlation between decoders and task performance via a UMAP
analysis, shedding light on the unique capabilities of decoder and encoder
models. This study contributes to a deeper understanding of language model
paradigms in NLU tasks and provides valuable insights for model selection and
evaluation in multilingual settings. | [
-0.4064679742,
-0.6039111018,
0.3609937727,
0.373102814,
-0.21881558,
0.0226902664,
-0.2625374198,
-0.7869598866,
-0.1319020838,
0.3744535446,
-0.1965750009,
-0.2623565793,
-0.6548117995,
0.6715859175,
-0.1981342137,
0.5373935699,
-0.1707373559,
0.3797481954,
-0.634685576,
-0.2486402541,
-0.5197726488,
-0.7903907299,
-0.6971622705,
-0.5543031096,
0.1774130613,
-0.3185611069,
0.5224641562,
0.4741331637,
0.6514854431,
0.2947318852,
-0.4476367235,
0.022469053,
-0.5306892395,
0.1361312866,
-0.0952610597,
-0.3538126647,
-0.2820081413,
-0.4393568337,
0.4851174653,
0.7620353103,
-0.0687104166,
0.0993511155,
0.2488535941,
0.4060963094,
-0.7778775096,
0.2840852737,
-0.1595211178,
0.052260451,
-0.0797958076,
-0.1459843069,
-0.646648407,
-0.2276411504,
-0.1900993884,
-0.5421000719,
0.3871559799,
-0.1572793722,
0.5492479205,
0.2839281857,
-0.5599111915,
-0.3454537094,
-0.8437770605,
0.654258132,
-0.658065021,
1.0590190887,
0.2726569474,
0.1748326123,
0.1988173723,
-0.2419290692,
-0.3453782797,
-0.0510612614,
-0.1865342408,
0.2661105394,
-0.6170589328,
0.0878786519,
0.2397152632,
0.5470984578,
-0.8187990189,
0.1811285913,
-0.355691582,
-0.033098314,
0.4452316463,
0.2623967528,
0.0773252174,
-0.251395613,
-0.2496852279,
-0.2197545469,
-0.3792645037,
0.121835947,
0.4083036184,
0.190438509,
-0.3083632588,
0.4714482427,
-0.094148986,
0.8954426646,
-0.1677766442,
-0.1483413428,
0.2810239196,
-0.4636229277,
-0.1318101287,
-0.103913255,
0.5150445104,
0.155422911,
0.02189699,
-0.6667143106,
-0.4131833315,
0.4459373653,
0.1970208287,
-0.6862469316,
0.0423445478,
0.0364030972,
-0.7591645122,
0.2300144583,
-0.153568089,
-0.6094836593,
-0.2165815979,
-0.2842549384,
0.1495608985,
-0.394718647,
-0.6535342932,
0.5509764552,
-0.3497258425,
0.6280263662,
0.1725002378,
-0.6483036876,
0.6225578189,
0.8273771405,
0.575506866,
-0.4264711142,
-0.4297767282,
-0.1741410345,
-0.1212720871,
-0.345158726,
0.7931544781,
-0.6285925508,
-0.448882401,
0.1713844687,
-0.0057734661,
-0.4040565491,
-0.5297050476,
0.6118866801,
-0.8037462831,
0.0980782881,
-0.4074330926,
-0.6933723092,
-0.4408753812,
0.3890101612,
-1.2255276442,
1.0446097851,
-0.0440655164,
-0.8527912498,
0.3456855118,
-0.9007053375,
-0.5478041172,
0.1815080494,
0.0049888133,
0.3147671521,
0.4317756891,
0.1696774662,
0.4087592065,
-0.5258626938,
0.126098603,
-0.0368455835,
-0.4255693853,
0.1397973597,
-0.5843232274,
0.8904663324,
0.2003072351,
0.0011414805,
-0.0881864876,
-0.7877072692,
-0.1664672643,
0.3113667071,
-0.8455836177,
-0.3527351916,
-0.0657984614,
0.5232080817,
0.1532786787,
0.0703784227,
-0.6736984849,
-0.3271555007,
-0.2677389979,
0.1622106731,
0.3136094809,
-0.3618786335,
0.4831929207,
-0.0684329569,
0.8121529222,
-0.208422184,
-0.0341306105,
-0.186746493,
-0.2935836017,
-0.5774381757,
-0.1486572623,
0.5030968189,
0.5723803639,
-0.8719596863,
0.0711529627,
-0.41835168,
-0.2557375431,
-1.1859145164,
0.0393524952,
0.5957673192,
0.1119224727,
0.3328604698,
-0.3648341,
-0.4377140105,
-0.6963564754,
-0.508859098,
-0.0420041904,
-0.0654000416,
0.0543006696,
0.4976221323,
-0.2474780679,
0.589979887,
-0.0704450011,
-0.0238333773,
-0.7363730073,
-0.0405528769,
0.3059960306,
0.3830170631,
0.6537451148,
-0.8144564033,
-0.2252819091,
0.2643356621,
-0.8198260665,
0.2833458781,
0.0814029723,
0.2175021768,
0.4985964298,
0.5264607072,
-0.588793993,
0.3255234957,
0.7942730784,
-0.5249720216,
0.6098303199,
-0.4154923558,
0.2562504411,
-0.8437836766,
0.2573377192,
-0.2032355219,
-0.149797976,
-0.9646751881,
0.4851201177,
0.2353468984,
0.04801213,
-0.505666554,
0.5743579268,
-0.6791442633,
-0.3591822684,
-0.0374202952,
-0.2665123343,
0.2511456609,
0.4626727104,
0.3047585785,
0.6413132548,
0.4158368409,
-0.5041300654,
0.1107464582,
0.2218300253,
-0.5564828515,
0.3707625568,
-0.8457812071,
0.3048750758,
-0.292134732,
-0.0720569566,
-0.811057806,
0.0602338426,
-0.1642895043,
-0.3326595724,
0.3801854253,
-0.2673855722,
-0.7271168232,
-0.3004842103,
-0.0338306874,
0.6288985014,
0.3206406236,
-0.5053702593,
0.7817025185,
0.1984516978,
0.1279506832,
-0.6166409254,
-0.7557621598,
0.0075646252,
-0.1944936365,
-0.5747444034,
0.4290512502,
-0.0160415601,
-0.3091696501,
0.0631995648,
-0.1123463213,
-0.1191592291,
0.2480200678,
0.1103360206,
0.1612420976,
-0.4096410871,
-0.0186203197,
-0.1285546869,
-0.2712326944,
0.133534953,
0.0168843716,
0.637186408,
-0.3553946316,
-0.4313474596,
-0.1076365113,
0.6942815781,
0.3944181502,
-0.6971077919,
0.848353982,
0.5951898098,
-0.3322925866,
0.2497366518,
-0.6920730472,
-0.1459599733,
-0.3972515166,
0.3036617339,
-0.9358193874,
-0.8575196862,
0.7107102871,
0.1717340648,
0.124866657,
0.4780771434,
0.4584627748,
0.0447988994,
0.9842740893,
0.9866144657,
0.0257658381,
0.242416814,
-0.3557871878,
0.14147003,
-0.7511298656,
-0.2615632713,
-0.6924672723,
0.0083223796,
-0.4999212623,
-0.5516088605,
0.1143412814,
0.2116026282,
0.0468942523,
0.3850294948,
-0.2396769375,
0.5853850842,
0.3315199316,
-0.3257878423,
0.4160132706,
-0.0133857708,
-0.2619833946,
0.0270167217,
-1.0922828913,
-0.5754628778,
0.9421101213,
0.3517432213,
0.7766386271,
0.2697426975,
0.6295810938,
0.1359345168,
-0.1291860342,
-0.6588056684,
0.2040498406,
-0.3497017324,
-0.5546829104,
-0.0491387062,
-0.2802762389,
-1.2491315603,
0.8033690453,
-0.1107055843,
-0.4697185755,
0.5863711834,
-0.1569223851,
-0.0320864022,
0.3110076785,
-0.6493183374,
1.1346254349,
-0.1839951575,
-0.0140364878,
-0.2495274097,
-0.3301492333,
-0.0851511434,
0.2063234299,
0.4002322257,
0.0168107282,
0.1137907207,
0.8934237957,
0.4102673531,
0.5591745377,
-0.1236161366,
-0.2723641694,
-0.1602900028,
0.2653897405,
0.1198108569,
-0.1997840255,
-0.4310518205,
0.6217879653,
0.3330719769,
-0.3835188746,
-0.4095135033,
0.3348006904,
-0.7491996288,
-0.3548468649,
-0.1924928427,
-0.5348451138,
0.0768647045,
0.189296335,
0.4177804291,
0.6548160911,
-0.5821946859,
0.0763607994,
0.4963862896,
-0.0783736259,
0.6344213486,
0.628745079,
0.0268457476,
-0.0695422962,
0.6630154252,
-0.2100926936,
0.2806896269,
0.6739572883,
-0.2688852847,
-0.4745995402,
-0.6344984174,
-0.4447829127,
0.2774706185,
-1.0381000042,
-0.1145565286,
-0.7408677936,
0.0366295092,
-0.4159612656,
-0.1812364012,
-0.5737531185,
-0.1040005311,
-0.0790397823,
-0.1173691303,
0.2032354027,
0.9035241008,
-0.0639023259,
0.0630652159,
-0.6274074912,
0.4728022516,
-0.0651344359,
0.4022317529,
0.0505730659,
-0.2766248882,
-0.2910702527,
-0.0355005451,
-0.0274445675,
-1.0189224482,
0.3849363923,
-0.0641511157,
0.8459243178,
0.3541589379,
0.0047024544,
0.5345702171,
-0.4346560836,
0.5271934271,
0.0197458416,
-0.9339883327,
0.124374561,
0.0620207191,
0.721975863,
0.4229814112,
0.3779158592,
-0.7217872739,
-0.3300963044,
-0.3417263329,
-0.8214462399,
0.7878527045,
0.1927196383,
0.0699412674,
-0.0500546806,
-0.0778443813,
0.448551029,
-0.0955231115,
-0.689657867,
-0.1337967813,
-0.0657078922,
0.0996066332,
-0.4840605557,
-0.4016734362,
-0.063557528,
-0.1697915196,
0.1278349757,
-0.1768413335,
0.6158287525,
0.1193870977,
-0.7555152178,
0.26756531,
0.57401824,
0.2834759951,
0.7943834662,
-0.220771879,
0.1186647713,
0.3909181356,
-0.3469161987,
-0.0695179775,
0.2349694669,
0.1107697487,
0.5151931643,
0.722786665,
1.1718336344,
0.3932180107,
-0.5138411522,
0.188387394,
-0.4904388487,
-0.1102762744,
-0.0217449479,
-0.340788722,
0.3137124777,
0.1645396948,
0.270860076,
0.041986987,
0.3841509819,
-0.2649330497,
-0.3127910495,
0.2481310815,
-0.1951987743,
-0.4014757574,
0.5091418028,
0.2315562814,
-0.2838569582,
0.5954437256,
-0.1856605709,
-0.49706164,
0.783049643,
0.7967872024,
0.832757771,
-0.3921914101,
0.0384913273,
0.2850596607,
0.4513851404,
-0.055977039,
0.5902493596,
-0.2705159783,
-0.8845160007,
-0.5562391281,
-0.8152647018,
-0.1856591552,
0.0014537318,
-1.2335532904,
-0.2601819038,
0.369692415,
-0.2001555115,
0.1594890207,
-0.2178280056,
-1.229711175,
-0.1130720824,
0.1247580275,
1.0901486874,
-0.7704575658,
0.8468708992,
0.953969419,
0.0294123441,
-0.3015167713,
-0.3155039549,
-0.2450478971,
-0.2984414697,
0.5594999194,
0.260166049,
-0.3323489428,
-0.1886375546,
0.3912036121,
-0.7242361307,
0.7078187466,
0.6773437262,
-0.4263583124,
-0.0811382979,
0.2769558728,
0.6774790287,
-0.3057552576,
0.4349928498,
0.9220825434,
0.4023854136,
-0.365095228,
-1.2160820961,
-0.1546766907,
-0.514041841,
0.3312012255,
0.2415850312,
0.0154614393,
0.6670334339,
-0.1624960452,
-0.5405831337,
-0.0823781863,
0.4042674601,
-0.0219568685,
0.1495719254,
0.3343013525,
0.4131967723,
0.4144035578,
-0.1627668738,
1.6212559938,
-0.330714494,
0.2302941531,
0.9568232894,
-0.1426438093,
1.0629867315,
0.4944555163,
-0.3203285635,
0.1365913302,
0.5294724107,
0.1086881831,
0.5442562103,
-0.2131814212,
-0.0013896241,
-0.2788024247,
-0.0840476975,
-0.4795553386,
0.7594133615,
0.1473742574,
0.0175046809,
-0.3345112801,
0.3364044726,
-0.0550237522,
0.0716379583,
-0.2564986944,
1.1126534939,
-0.0907436758,
-0.6033966541,
1.0342923403,
0.3305191398,
0.8382959366,
-0.467138201,
0.1478256881,
-0.3358481824,
0.3510074019,
0.0775013193,
-0.6910510063,
0.5774862766,
0.2046460509,
-0.2347655892,
-0.2861741781,
0.6635596752,
-0.4412647486,
-0.4482108057,
0.9799472094,
0.659560442,
0.2423613816,
-0.0036692575,
-0.6284136176,
0.4994859397,
-0.2219381779,
-0.1246559769,
0.1307666153,
0.0556725785,
0.1440494359,
0.5230211616,
0.4692378342,
-0.2541942596,
0.2938230038,
0.1598567665,
0.5941956639,
-0.5904324651,
-0.4285973012,
-0.7481818795,
0.3955129683,
0.1531231552,
-0.2738045156,
0.9471364617,
0.7913188934,
1.2939435244,
-0.488702327,
0.547783196,
-0.0473579504,
0.2473540008,
-0.4537548423,
0.7255121469,
-0.523088634,
-0.1493255347,
-0.0955392644,
-0.9894961119,
-0.1367946416,
0.499239862,
-0.1862611324,
-0.0835366547,
0.6318278313,
0.5823540092,
-0.1067731157,
0.1936350912,
0.4778142571,
-0.0441362448,
0.1035975516,
0.5647525787,
0.9193431139,
-0.5419591665,
0.2321504205,
-0.2946136594,
0.0970420539,
-0.0159139521,
-0.5929083228,
-0.8321511149,
-0.6686771512,
-0.1270967871,
-0.013467594,
0.3145074248,
0.4837908745,
0.6207532287,
-0.9014837742,
-0.6677038074,
0.3338077962,
0.2346898019,
-0.6544166803,
-0.1825956851,
0.3359553218,
-0.2972855568,
-0.8094393015,
0.6012309194,
0.1242321208,
-0.1543882936,
0.0500716083,
-0.4677317739,
-0.1020046398,
0.0949199274,
0.8129925728,
0.1919635981,
-0.996496737,
0.4146614075,
0.1830846369,
0.0110980114,
0.0622004382,
0.9167689681,
-0.7622089982,
0.5880113244,
0.6476969719,
0.776807189,
0.6703174114,
-0.3885543048,
0.6345425248,
-0.4069885314,
0.2163031697,
0.237934351,
0.4927689433,
0.4997470677,
-0.1692786664,
0.5100395679,
-0.2721955478,
-0.0993310511,
-0.9011309743,
-0.0135311261,
-0.6922552586,
-0.5065925717,
1.0995208025,
-0.2437215298,
-0.1050290763,
-0.4252712727,
0.1023889631,
0.0548948571,
-0.1402080953,
0.373077035,
0.6343611479,
0.0673798695,
-0.1535216421,
-0.6959366798,
0.402232945,
0.3964728415,
-0.6729106307,
0.0703117624,
0.2515889108,
0.1642300934,
0.0613716058,
0.4132204354,
-0.1951709688,
0.5409623384,
0.24696742,
0.3313162029,
-0.0554210208,
-0.3475088775,
-0.9092186093,
0.2725543678,
-0.0100943558,
-0.21272026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13444v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13444v2 | VDebugger: Harnessing Execution Feedback for Debugging Visual Programs | 2024-06-19T11:09:16 | 2024-06-27T17:09:24 | Xueqing Wu, Zongyu Lin, Songyan Zhao, Te-Lin Wu, Pan Lu, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Visual programs are executable code generated by large language models to
address visual reasoning problems. They decompose complex questions into
multiple reasoning steps and invoke specialized models for each step to solve
the problems. However, these programs are prone to logic errors, with our
preliminary evaluation showing that 58% of the total errors are caused by
program logic errors. Debugging complex visual programs remains a major
bottleneck for visual reasoning. To address this, we introduce VDebugger, a
novel critic-refiner framework trained to localize and debug visual programs by
tracking execution step by step. VDebugger identifies and corrects program
errors leveraging detailed execution feedback, improving interpretability and
accuracy. The training data is generated through an automated pipeline that
injects errors into correct visual programs using a novel mask-best decoding
technique. Evaluations on six datasets demonstrate VDebugger's effectiveness,
showing performance improvements of up to 3.2% in downstream task accuracy.
Further studies show VDebugger's ability to generalize to unseen tasks,
bringing a notable improvement of 2.3% on the unseen COVR task. Code, data and
models are made publicly available at https://github.com/shirley-wu/vdebugger/ | [
-0.2835484743,
-0.8428798914,
0.5780698061,
0.1941993088,
-0.0440162681,
0.2064048499,
-0.1297780126,
-0.3195846081,
-0.0740958825,
0.7152370214,
-0.4852097929,
-0.5353625417,
-0.410094738,
-0.0777061954,
-0.3988459706,
0.7206003666,
-0.2196286321,
0.078948915,
-0.4703593254,
-0.0364887156,
-0.7165622115,
-0.3408590555,
-0.5355662704,
-0.109290354,
0.28794083,
0.5504087806,
0.2065807432,
0.3549855053,
0.7528777122,
0.3633303642,
0.4203207195,
-0.0345485434,
-0.7749565244,
0.050536789,
-0.3603863716,
-0.851518333,
-0.0928272828,
-0.3309336305,
-0.0341656543,
0.3207340539,
-0.1806120127,
0.3436536193,
-0.1270634681,
0.7223006487,
-1.1034224033,
0.273491025,
-0.0094267353,
0.1049299687,
-0.069187358,
-0.3227251768,
-0.3549147248,
-0.5967472196,
-0.1284529567,
-0.4397550821,
0.3116186559,
-0.1004000306,
0.7045600414,
0.8256103396,
-0.2262489945,
0.1799261421,
-0.9074826837,
0.5866932273,
-0.5550328493,
0.0273665935,
-0.0398054533,
0.6406574845,
-0.0500957668,
-1.004799962,
-0.4919977486,
-0.1433801055,
-0.0118863378,
0.223211661,
-0.5491628647,
0.2679234445,
0.7156776786,
0.388265729,
-0.5264761448,
-0.1161478162,
-0.4984258115,
-0.071427606,
0.3474425673,
0.3446239829,
0.2321935892,
-0.0109284958,
-0.5822006464,
-0.2019894421,
-0.2273159772,
0.351754427,
0.2294843346,
-0.2384689748,
0.1347168386,
0.3717772067,
-0.682318747,
0.8962513804,
-0.0232997444,
0.3989583552,
0.2397194654,
-0.2211098969,
-0.3336773515,
0.0087975161,
0.3658168614,
0.8030887842,
0.5749403834,
0.1474472284,
-0.2002249062,
0.5283511281,
0.6659936309,
-0.9552926421,
-0.7744804025,
0.1822652072,
-0.18316257,
-0.4981849492,
0.2978264093,
-0.7729179263,
-0.4965756536,
-0.4844658971,
0.3962684274,
-0.1857946068,
-0.3917757273,
0.3659629226,
-0.5120793581,
0.2399301678,
0.6050841212,
-0.2430688888,
0.2079374939,
0.5350385308,
0.451903969,
-0.105598785,
-0.0533587411,
-1.2240865231,
-0.0237371866,
-0.3930277526,
1.0378519297,
-0.5791162848,
-0.244213894,
-0.213719368,
0.0701548234,
-0.0123548713,
-0.8399881124,
0.2340517491,
-0.176257804,
-0.3627810478,
-0.4885057509,
-0.4231105149,
-0.3213531673,
0.295370996,
-0.6708394289,
0.9828013182,
0.1504355669,
-0.7116529942,
0.2043465078,
-0.472312212,
-0.0402980149,
0.126634419,
-0.4295837581,
-0.2604327798,
0.5839260221,
0.2769655287,
0.1203511655,
-0.1043178067,
-0.0028038495,
-0.4371173978,
-0.7689617872,
-0.2369881421,
0.0324458964,
0.75621593,
0.0591557771,
-0.7803920507,
0.5831602812,
-0.9490674734,
0.3822292686,
0.0790336803,
-0.1112155244,
-0.3463326991,
-0.0373314545,
-0.074465856,
-0.0215290487,
-0.0700378194,
-0.4665023088,
0.4664026499,
0.1112885624,
0.1984259635,
0.9383101463,
0.086311616,
0.0485865101,
0.2245565802,
1.1040304899,
0.1059228778,
0.2496283501,
-0.1107272357,
-0.267108649,
-0.8978877068,
-0.3206768036,
0.0724425092,
0.8349034786,
-0.9738220572,
-0.0176960919,
0.0235927496,
-0.3414198458,
-0.2974708378,
0.1050582081,
0.4404577911,
0.6478176713,
0.0622120313,
-0.4065293372,
-0.6380708218,
-0.7328157425,
-0.4164086878,
-0.158912763,
0.2119767517,
0.0588914044,
0.6159438491,
-0.5756186247,
0.9466982484,
-0.9533091784,
-0.0472174101,
-0.232117787,
0.0854133219,
0.0072069187,
0.3124169409,
0.6739598513,
-0.3996649981,
-0.2246388048,
-0.1886722594,
-0.9026169777,
-0.5122853518,
-0.0977425426,
-0.2009621561,
-0.0351946354,
0.832017839,
-0.1445255727,
0.8514248133,
0.5205205083,
-0.5578138232,
0.9229717851,
-0.1959455907,
0.1866663992,
-0.4051675797,
0.1237274632,
-0.0604785495,
-0.3115221262,
-0.059885066,
0.1660870314,
0.0054579712,
-0.1258644015,
-0.25558725,
0.2186374366,
-0.2320017219,
-0.1014040187,
-0.2919762135,
-0.2521075606,
0.2526269257,
0.4886514544,
-0.0928243101,
0.5453982353,
0.6616224051,
-0.4267840087,
1.0863044262,
-0.2508666813,
-0.5808789134,
0.9131278396,
-0.8225737214,
0.1938141435,
-0.2648020387,
0.0500647463,
-1.2006536722,
-0.1144885644,
0.3311910331,
-0.2103369683,
0.1234394237,
-0.2773211896,
-0.1901259422,
-0.5639545918,
-0.2512179017,
-0.0691258088,
0.2511918545,
-0.695597589,
0.3665311933,
-0.1012579352,
0.1709248722,
-0.6614590883,
-0.4656793177,
-0.0209790636,
0.0883448198,
-0.6252562404,
-0.2791512609,
-0.1553615481,
-0.5091072321,
0.3076484501,
-0.585226059,
-0.0868445709,
0.1911729276,
0.4912011325,
0.0319351479,
-0.1378231645,
-0.0841884986,
-0.2625914812,
-0.578762114,
0.2837516963,
-0.1184723377,
0.0582538694,
-0.4538619816,
-0.5432738066,
-0.2179807574,
0.3498049676,
0.5254254341,
-0.5263544321,
0.1637161672,
0.9425855279,
-0.2149783969,
-0.603027761,
-0.2767204642,
-0.2182714343,
-0.4836939871,
0.4555060267,
-0.5230323672,
-0.5800982714,
0.4156149924,
-0.4976735115,
-0.257850796,
0.0835663378,
0.2691281438,
0.0616765246,
1.2145470381,
0.9721207619,
0.2036605775,
0.6146627665,
-0.6097171903,
0.2996237576,
-0.6055380106,
-0.0797563121,
-0.3825547695,
-0.4056332409,
-0.2119710743,
-0.4954912961,
0.2242732793,
0.6427857876,
0.0804795101,
0.1374148577,
-0.7377257347,
0.6716836095,
0.8186126351,
0.0281985067,
0.2612719536,
-0.054936029,
0.1258730441,
-0.2919689119,
-0.5415986776,
-0.2482047081,
0.690525651,
-0.0772498176,
1.1949176788,
-0.0925712138,
0.7156092525,
0.3685209155,
0.0901764259,
-0.7169262171,
0.4610619545,
0.1611170471,
-0.1121854484,
0.1246805415,
-0.3149316907,
-0.3687603772,
0.2065414339,
0.2809450626,
-0.7226511836,
0.3719362915,
0.4742726982,
-0.4487935007,
0.2290176004,
-1.0966595411,
1.4232339859,
-0.2889925241,
-0.5855063796,
-0.3651915789,
-0.2582735717,
0.3695615828,
0.4973351359,
-0.1794934571,
0.136628136,
0.3481057882,
0.3135221899,
-0.72169137,
0.8936199546,
-0.5122125745,
-0.1762494892,
0.3992200196,
0.2126220763,
0.713496089,
0.1051473394,
0.335315764,
0.1161229163,
0.2011632025,
-0.3560123444,
-0.9227426052,
0.9479911327,
-0.3343747854,
-0.6378091574,
-0.6490479708,
-0.0557725504,
0.1671464294,
0.081923306,
0.1961842924,
0.4916320145,
0.1934712529,
0.2141937912,
0.5993142724,
-0.337107867,
0.2598017752,
0.5642424226,
-0.5190273523,
-0.2168447822,
0.9493851662,
0.0088844402,
0.1036888734,
0.0059474041,
-0.0073859743,
0.2748689651,
-0.2622410953,
-0.523362875,
-0.3240326643,
-0.8859401345,
-0.2604894042,
-0.3627460599,
0.1699386835,
0.0991820246,
-0.1194743961,
-0.3751790524,
-0.1440938264,
-0.0182675458,
-0.3499103189,
0.4938460588,
0.7437848449,
-0.1846435666,
0.1272259206,
-0.4997457862,
0.6023743153,
0.4430683255,
0.6426450014,
-0.2397114038,
0.2571656704,
-0.3903556466,
-0.2328982055,
-0.2449145019,
-0.7870947719,
0.1925506294,
-0.1350815594,
0.4017671049,
0.3600974977,
0.2289565653,
0.876804173,
-0.2193401158,
0.7006800175,
0.0254852865,
-0.8831886649,
0.9463528991,
-0.1042554751,
0.5635719299,
0.451174736,
-0.2002007812,
-0.2085357159,
-0.3945515752,
-0.2811748385,
-0.8745288253,
0.6141800284,
-0.1829345971,
-0.3246474564,
-0.1044832021,
0.1176438406,
-0.0816638768,
0.2083390057,
-0.2176791728,
-0.0251048077,
-0.2399673462,
0.1016786173,
-0.0111616421,
-0.1889476776,
-0.1128362566,
-0.5608522892,
0.1666784286,
-0.3911675811,
0.2265160829,
0.4404658377,
-0.4018255174,
-0.3154074252,
-0.0061724088,
0.7462548614,
1.1121045351,
-0.3691149354,
0.2541570365,
-0.1641370356,
-0.347282052,
-0.2333711088,
-0.1358428001,
-0.0074365851,
0.0971611068,
0.2776399553,
0.9040434361,
-0.0562496968,
-0.9756401777,
0.6533898711,
-0.3620971739,
0.1992389858,
-0.5353056788,
0.4408330619,
-0.140065968,
0.6165244579,
0.1447363198,
0.4671406448,
0.4375793636,
-0.3316424489,
0.2043564171,
0.0916347131,
-0.5925149918,
-0.2907654941,
0.9377461076,
0.3612607121,
0.0002927941,
0.8175773025,
0.0325012468,
-0.6364020109,
0.9433192015,
0.2605723739,
1.1035625935,
0.0817545727,
0.1447850019,
0.4263806045,
0.2890609801,
0.1141429916,
0.6508260965,
-0.2110020965,
-0.2634361088,
-0.8653609753,
-0.5028421283,
-0.4941956401,
-0.1046172231,
-0.9186555147,
0.1041363999,
-0.4620942473,
-0.2391830832,
-0.3417288065,
-0.1983486861,
-0.6978802085,
0.0999510735,
0.1716459841,
0.8003977537,
-0.6629484892,
0.6645488739,
0.7617123723,
-0.492223978,
-0.4127830863,
-0.2629402876,
0.0757228062,
-0.3517443538,
0.9543935061,
0.4525454044,
-0.3749271035,
0.0943531692,
-0.7962690592,
-0.4494237304,
0.7242529988,
0.7114042044,
-0.8221129179,
0.2194940299,
-0.34209463,
0.5237585902,
-0.0904109105,
0.2697032988,
0.5472624302,
0.5069776773,
-0.1517930329,
-0.5963821411,
0.0038741769,
-0.5582762361,
0.1471342295,
0.1963423043,
-0.5076812506,
0.5386512876,
-0.7203395367,
0.106289506,
-0.2008050233,
0.3921635449,
0.0253700092,
0.2990193069,
0.3587992191,
0.9210060239,
0.6300398707,
-0.459344089,
1.3964333534,
-0.2825324833,
0.248448506,
1.2741017342,
-0.0727036074,
0.5972661376,
0.5605954528,
0.1121398136,
0.7485206127,
0.355414331,
-0.0761039555,
0.5697087646,
0.5045233965,
-0.0735042095,
-0.3853620291,
0.1435827017,
-0.3016705811,
0.2851312459,
0.1915439516,
-0.2227513492,
-0.2320065349,
0.2277288735,
-0.1775857061,
-0.055649776,
-0.2982655168,
0.4760305583,
-0.0280348863,
-0.4723054469,
0.7292637229,
-0.225172475,
0.4219090343,
-0.4157904685,
-0.4956812263,
-0.2693133354,
0.9266503453,
-0.4521131516,
-0.5575847626,
0.4321959615,
0.001920937,
-0.3369019032,
-0.2062434256,
0.5958444476,
-0.0061718961,
-0.2442952991,
0.4081516564,
0.1510472894,
-0.0792358071,
-0.5138732791,
-0.339050442,
0.4788244665,
0.2412696928,
-0.4707818031,
-0.2254580706,
0.3669136167,
-0.3260651529,
0.7062368989,
0.5032593608,
-0.0477548242,
0.3483752906,
0.2841970623,
0.7100490332,
-0.8657535911,
-0.3610012829,
-0.7780326605,
0.8943092227,
-0.3269780874,
-0.2530128062,
0.9661061168,
0.5513914824,
1.1792092323,
-0.4361121655,
0.8420595527,
-0.0788816437,
0.1713066101,
-0.102294907,
0.2189503461,
-0.3173047304,
0.2777816653,
-0.310421288,
-0.9745100141,
-0.1024399772,
0.704932332,
-0.4426802099,
-0.1752216816,
0.4856650829,
0.7597100139,
-0.0644862428,
-0.3073531687,
0.0820147172,
0.2411946505,
0.5195559859,
0.6429758668,
0.8680768609,
-0.2925008237,
0.4738496244,
-0.3546915948,
-0.3802693188,
-0.45483464,
-0.6787978411,
-0.6977951527,
-0.07869073,
-0.7600858808,
-0.4947659671,
0.056097541,
0.2685982585,
0.7025750279,
-0.7604277134,
-0.1947331876,
-0.4118862748,
0.0857764855,
-0.7087228298,
-0.3834470212,
0.0220659059,
-0.3244627416,
-0.6631577015,
0.1934261471,
0.4732784927,
-0.4609769881,
-0.4041857719,
-0.0100631714,
0.3671578765,
-0.1990465671,
0.6850696802,
0.3961500525,
-0.5370182395,
-0.4782077968,
-0.1161788106,
-0.0708105639,
-0.1244411096,
0.742970705,
-1.1613843441,
1.0908865929,
0.912781179,
0.4514368176,
0.7837773561,
-0.0279166885,
0.7283607721,
-0.59866184,
0.0760512128,
-0.0144207887,
0.2697265446,
0.1274940073,
-0.2510048449,
0.8343379498,
0.4438862503,
-0.2368957251,
-1.0199028254,
0.4119273424,
-0.9353355169,
-0.2390672415,
0.6430781484,
-0.0379506834,
-0.4123057425,
0.3824710846,
-0.7429372668,
-0.0211251285,
-0.1867812127,
0.6756675839,
0.4981576502,
-0.2120037526,
-0.4998507798,
-0.8698555827,
0.571790576,
0.0838200822,
-0.7614690661,
-0.0114371739,
0.8306412101,
0.5275201797,
0.0520589761,
0.4452431798,
0.0945108533,
0.5635159016,
0.2322756946,
0.4738886952,
-0.3221526742,
-0.2958090305,
-0.4052836299,
0.1137050614,
-0.1902109236,
-0.5033419728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13443v1 | Dual-Phase Accelerated Prompt Optimization | 2024-06-19T11:08:56 | 2024-06-19T11:08:56 | Muchen Yang, Moxin Li, Yongle Li, Zijun Chen, Chongming Gao, Junqi Zhang, Yangyang Li, Fuli Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Gradient-free prompt optimization methods have made significant strides in
enhancing the performance of closed-source Large Language Models (LLMs) across
a wide range of tasks. However, existing approaches make light of the
importance of high-quality prompt initialization and the identification of
effective optimization directions, thus resulting in substantial optimization
steps to obtain satisfactory performance. In this light, we aim to accelerate
prompt optimization process to tackle the challenge of low convergence rate. We
propose a dual-phase approach which starts with generating high-quality initial
prompts by adopting a well-designed meta-instruction to delve into
task-specific information, and iteratively optimize the prompts at the sentence
level, leveraging previous tuning experience to expand prompt candidates and
accept effective ones. Extensive experiments on eight datasets demonstrate the
effectiveness of our proposed method, achieving a consistent accuracy gain over
baselines with less than five optimization steps. | [
-0.1973878592,
-0.7882555723,
0.7142232656,
0.5786349773,
-0.5299173594,
0.1498191208,
-0.4946110845,
0.0729487017,
-0.1929884255,
0.1651289016,
-1.0849829912,
-0.4107804894,
-0.4099894464,
0.3325191736,
0.0590914488,
0.7652289271,
-0.1075219288,
0.2024501562,
-0.0665373281,
0.2163879424,
-0.8644638658,
-0.0607956946,
-1.0824311972,
-0.0863805637,
0.7729709148,
0.9037023187,
0.2576691508,
0.6566006541,
-0.0085584745,
0.2103278786,
-0.2244191766,
0.5023353696,
-0.5435536504,
0.6120210886,
0.1012754738,
-0.1718706042,
-0.0142588448,
-0.1420423836,
0.8093950748,
0.5701892972,
-0.1807138473,
0.2888290882,
0.3333099782,
0.6992052794,
-0.6611687541,
0.1668879986,
-0.2584019601,
0.0491992757,
-0.0711840391,
-0.571731329,
-0.3849574924,
-0.4634704292,
-0.0015401207,
-0.8167122006,
0.3073485196,
0.1799877584,
0.4135886729,
0.343506068,
-0.3522830904,
-0.3794414401,
-0.5922269821,
0.9372736812,
-0.445946753,
0.192382887,
-0.1529926956,
0.2162328809,
-0.3108075857,
-0.5689923763,
-0.3666697443,
-0.2463775277,
0.167676419,
0.0582925603,
0.0587320626,
0.3227437139,
0.3743360043,
0.1792111844,
-0.6418611407,
0.2803400755,
-0.0403504968,
-0.1387282759,
0.363022238,
0.4076817632,
0.2228687555,
-0.0896528736,
-0.45547539,
-0.0379214138,
-0.4579633176,
0.654145956,
0.3682975471,
0.9109554887,
-0.0700284168,
0.5306800604,
-0.3358938396,
0.4811105728,
0.4689483643,
-0.1493984461,
0.0865146518,
-0.8263069391,
0.1697333455,
0.0472232513,
0.7181232572,
0.3402137458,
-0.0357180201,
0.0611790009,
-0.3828894794,
-0.0062184348,
0.039443478,
-0.9621995091,
0.3067287505,
0.4278371632,
-0.1954486519,
-0.1478459537,
-0.2957446873,
-1.2710243464,
-0.5988869667,
-0.531103611,
0.4738950729,
-0.0573295094,
0.0687138513,
0.1615904421,
-0.0522897132,
0.1161089465,
0.3373415172,
-0.8534739614,
0.0033748297,
0.782219708,
0.8430938721,
0.0855818689,
0.013700407,
-1.2867361307,
-0.1945024431,
-0.3666165769,
0.5834192634,
-0.6665856838,
-0.6406456232,
0.1944551915,
-0.1740304083,
0.0669481829,
-0.1818110049,
1.0676677227,
-0.4718199372,
0.4297599792,
-0.6892929673,
-0.0730641335,
-0.0632064268,
-0.0637546107,
-0.3640956581,
1.3949797153,
-0.0484140031,
-0.6212126017,
0.2482213527,
-0.7139483094,
-0.5909952521,
0.1130529493,
-0.0382220708,
-0.0080006486,
0.3868659139,
0.5731582642,
0.2952196896,
-0.7159181237,
0.4097685218,
0.2517058849,
-0.3920762241,
-0.3304055035,
-0.2277818769,
0.5594842434,
-0.0627788529,
-0.3889527619,
0.4468883276,
-0.753601253,
-0.0534846671,
0.0445797853,
-0.404292345,
-0.2138763666,
-0.0236277748,
-0.3922491074,
0.1927205473,
0.4620682895,
-0.5059615374,
0.3357837498,
-0.5731178522,
0.0867832601,
0.9268511534,
0.1105968505,
0.5971761346,
-0.0382151455,
0.9042570591,
0.0295953806,
0.2267968357,
-0.615726769,
-0.4175716937,
-0.8952611089,
-0.2952317595,
0.0511584468,
0.9290373325,
-0.8548383117,
0.5595869422,
0.0211503953,
-0.1370246261,
-0.7215178609,
0.2545482814,
0.4655356109,
0.9900161028,
0.504596889,
0.0437570624,
-0.337567538,
-0.8645742536,
-0.3831042647,
0.2301430106,
0.0829362869,
0.4093137383,
-0.0212566424,
-0.0855747238,
0.8066017032,
-0.625080049,
0.2314090878,
-0.2567161024,
0.4839357734,
0.7331598401,
0.2886215746,
0.2092101723,
-0.4905362129,
-0.7443367243,
-0.3701618314,
-0.4917778373,
-0.6854798198,
-0.168335259,
-0.2945922017,
0.012581747,
0.2355839312,
-0.5652654767,
-0.0770712197,
0.3903813958,
-0.4495203495,
0.5669682026,
-0.2297845483,
0.2714420557,
-0.9741760492,
-0.0190286301,
0.1080741286,
-0.0601139814,
-0.8140041828,
-0.0138020841,
0.1088879257,
-0.4411649108,
-0.1577970088,
0.7930307388,
-0.8048155308,
0.2782705128,
-0.3564033806,
0.3282613456,
0.0070674578,
0.5593451262,
-0.3484474719,
1.2183748484,
0.8224633336,
-0.6110861301,
0.2958598435,
0.1160716936,
-0.2980234325,
0.4915785491,
-0.729390502,
0.2837713659,
-0.7042644024,
0.1292528808,
-1.1921186447,
0.2038988769,
0.4668026865,
-0.0341814123,
0.5317363739,
0.0725892335,
-0.4855588377,
-0.6495192051,
-0.5694963336,
0.4359655976,
0.6499746442,
-0.6933364868,
0.5237891078,
-0.3635223508,
-0.614569962,
-0.9335107207,
-0.088461116,
0.0393933691,
-0.0453946404,
-0.7885450721,
0.0854928941,
-0.372838676,
0.0546878912,
-0.4435815513,
-0.0501766689,
0.29265818,
0.0412560068,
0.024279587,
0.0586348698,
-0.2704404294,
0.0834143832,
0.5613399148,
-0.475207597,
-0.1815532446,
-0.5239179134,
0.6898297668,
0.3141716123,
0.1601459533,
-0.8827680349,
0.6741750836,
0.3322465718,
-0.2639777958,
0.6099760532,
0.5687735081,
-0.1196666285,
-0.5542770624,
-0.3636579514,
-0.2925184071,
-0.5941726565,
0.1859539598,
-0.3772216141,
-0.746473372,
0.2897654772,
-0.0905207694,
0.2380938828,
0.1347593218,
0.5563257933,
0.1413223296,
0.9532174468,
0.5422581434,
0.1735076159,
0.5742490292,
0.0538472421,
0.3229835331,
-0.7790309191,
-0.1462037712,
-0.8258881569,
-0.3572233021,
-0.1633826643,
-0.7999369502,
0.6085502505,
0.2823920548,
-0.233371973,
0.0831564441,
-0.4535667002,
0.3606855571,
0.7468004823,
0.0808674768,
0.2735358477,
-0.0509597585,
-0.476290822,
-0.1216063872,
-0.6162829995,
-0.4039629996,
0.8625863194,
0.2754113972,
0.5572575331,
-0.2757223547,
0.6066615582,
0.242892012,
-0.105432108,
-0.7025093436,
0.5676027536,
-0.1675345898,
-0.22018224,
-0.2339588702,
-0.547875762,
-0.799413085,
0.2711751163,
-0.1315300167,
-0.4758913815,
0.120726116,
0.2705937922,
-0.6414612532,
-0.2338449508,
-0.5817497969,
0.749550581,
-0.3174512386,
-0.3499593139,
-0.2053404897,
-0.7115638256,
0.3254777491,
-0.200107649,
0.3518372476,
-0.2708922327,
-0.4919544458,
0.5294730663,
-0.2553759515,
0.5948753953,
-0.6915980577,
-0.301409632,
0.1948123276,
-0.1363973469,
0.8788868785,
0.1962788701,
-0.2442646623,
-0.2640930414,
-0.4248386919,
-0.4211871028,
-0.6757006049,
0.4761779904,
-0.4260352552,
-0.6265767217,
-0.1476244479,
-0.5135730505,
-0.4112221897,
0.2502752542,
0.199812755,
0.7984318137,
-0.0321582183,
-0.28661412,
0.7515658736,
-0.4818312824,
0.6808293462,
0.6344552636,
0.1279040277,
-0.6770273447,
0.6182396412,
-0.3538538814,
0.2242051363,
0.4516505599,
0.5114740133,
-0.3291714489,
-0.7555439472,
-0.6340495348,
0.4246962667,
-0.5466249585,
-0.218183741,
-0.7354546189,
0.3671247065,
-0.4244391918,
-0.2082479745,
-0.1261799484,
-0.3067061603,
-0.6763082147,
0.2043659836,
0.0656348243,
0.2149752229,
0.1115952507,
0.5850513577,
-0.9650729299,
0.4786675572,
0.1814633012,
0.0463414937,
-0.1724015921,
-0.5785195827,
-0.1346808374,
0.0814519599,
-0.1511686891,
-0.7213336229,
0.219413802,
0.2965044379,
0.7204120755,
0.5070912242,
0.1612344533,
0.4930713773,
-0.8141373396,
0.9852939248,
0.3261053264,
-0.8140975237,
0.7032552361,
-0.4172345698,
0.572945714,
0.7618279457,
0.4419229925,
-0.4928745329,
-0.1208098754,
-0.0075059282,
-0.8568233848,
0.746334374,
-0.1431666911,
0.3056152463,
0.091188468,
0.6458252668,
0.3078877032,
0.549723804,
-0.1715081036,
-0.4094888866,
0.2337967157,
-0.4036519229,
-0.229814291,
-0.7263352275,
-0.3019928634,
-0.0566689707,
0.7301144004,
-0.4199828207,
0.3063333929,
0.0064375652,
0.1326529235,
-0.4540482461,
0.3539886475,
0.8901845813,
0.4019650817,
0.1039673463,
-0.2414684743,
-0.002476407,
-0.4391334653,
0.3267974854,
0.3726384342,
-0.4370734692,
-0.059864983,
0.094022885,
0.9042862654,
0.2522378266,
-0.5550328493,
0.6499603987,
-0.1638165116,
0.120366469,
0.1781065017,
0.0616784692,
-0.1760250032,
0.5256258845,
0.5691454411,
-0.2555336654,
0.1095762849,
-0.3002105653,
-0.0419670418,
0.5690417886,
-0.0438690223,
-0.334341228,
0.6557537913,
0.6941475272,
-0.4288978279,
0.5738188624,
-0.2717851102,
-0.5206019878,
0.3580308259,
0.5071594119,
1.2808653116,
-0.3394173086,
0.1999544501,
0.6983013749,
0.2832638025,
-0.2439871579,
0.700319767,
-0.1660169363,
-0.4901997745,
-0.5836107135,
-0.8475177884,
-0.2037398964,
-0.3754757643,
-0.4702778161,
0.6973193288,
-0.5197814107,
-0.1282292157,
-0.4706905484,
0.1946022063,
-0.5180161595,
0.079474844,
0.1404968053,
0.9907597303,
-0.6317652464,
0.3853003383,
0.2341050804,
-0.055527553,
-0.5765814185,
0.0188518446,
0.0581867434,
-0.9261537194,
0.4222559035,
0.3657498062,
-0.1547370702,
0.1949426085,
-0.3204036653,
-0.8367766738,
1.1311738491,
0.286008507,
-0.9120497108,
-0.4212135375,
-0.1855074614,
0.2556891739,
-0.3252208531,
0.1990891844,
0.3603164554,
0.6127666831,
0.2519003153,
-0.8012745976,
0.2425872386,
0.0314582065,
0.1208385453,
0.4974226654,
-0.6952932477,
0.7368559241,
-0.3225077689,
-0.70494771,
0.2241232693,
0.8086169362,
0.1063081175,
0.3574670851,
0.6185907722,
0.4488462806,
1.0203574896,
0.0161672588,
0.8986427784,
-0.5886471272,
0.2075296491,
0.9053323269,
-0.241052106,
0.4192323387,
0.4877467453,
0.0378254727,
0.6080417633,
0.6929245591,
0.1185054556,
0.6836660504,
0.1909903735,
-0.632997334,
-0.1448517591,
-0.3957014084,
-0.2346096188,
-0.1150159314,
0.2025048733,
-0.3320889175,
-0.3394645154,
0.0931589156,
-0.0046085007,
0.0433971807,
-0.4246747494,
0.5533989072,
-0.034915939,
-0.8464707136,
0.562117517,
0.0718322471,
0.7678703666,
-0.6714331508,
0.1829653233,
-0.3879033029,
-0.3284445405,
0.096716851,
-0.4021294117,
-0.2458669692,
0.1247739196,
-0.3036066592,
-0.6185142994,
0.5001811981,
-0.5749869943,
-0.4164248407,
0.1725168973,
0.4434253871,
-0.2064226866,
0.0621694624,
-0.609525919,
-0.1092440188,
-0.1380144805,
-0.3821804523,
-0.0637073368,
0.4113470018,
0.3098688424,
0.4958284795,
0.6678035259,
0.1035799533,
0.0996869653,
-0.0460263491,
0.8933128715,
-0.6907575727,
-0.5877760053,
-0.7630999088,
0.8271163106,
0.0811307728,
-0.3854983151,
0.4955202639,
0.4979615808,
0.04051999,
0.0652407557,
0.6620633602,
0.2022178322,
0.6716396213,
-0.7995917201,
-0.1045697853,
-0.5978792906,
0.224584192,
-0.1269075423,
-1.1304401159,
-0.0690171197,
0.0487020239,
0.0022541147,
-0.0102429865,
0.8802050352,
1.0203107595,
0.1414884925,
0.0379388705,
0.0950899199,
0.0443491377,
0.2372539788,
0.6702696681,
0.8486180305,
-0.0488403887,
0.3606562912,
-0.1719788015,
-0.5920537114,
-0.1619791687,
-1.0823928118,
-0.8950456977,
-0.3048063517,
-0.1706995517,
-0.3377080858,
0.0809675604,
1.1596410275,
0.4266774952,
-0.6333620548,
-0.0492835753,
0.0019893376,
0.0224498305,
-0.1104575545,
-0.2001920193,
0.0794338062,
-0.8946481943,
-0.8886321783,
1.0117017031,
0.3437152207,
-0.1230794638,
-0.2757584155,
0.0648810565,
0.0028697478,
0.3743441105,
0.4799200892,
0.1878921539,
-0.5339422226,
-0.0829022378,
0.1893575639,
-0.2812079489,
0.0644444302,
1.2347196341,
-0.5032944679,
0.4775056839,
0.7735788226,
0.7261227369,
0.249345392,
0.4851923883,
0.8760336637,
-0.9115064144,
0.1769059002,
0.2929326594,
0.0784109682,
0.3192798495,
-0.6876999736,
0.2444874346,
0.3440453708,
-0.6120014191,
-0.8570521474,
0.1390389353,
-1.098896265,
-0.1963198185,
1.4194391966,
0.1177652478,
0.067283839,
0.1010953486,
-0.4346054494,
0.3027106524,
-0.8170535564,
0.4653825462,
0.5037499666,
-0.2760881782,
-0.2704930305,
-0.5626215935,
0.5737979412,
0.5485183597,
-0.6608026028,
0.1136635616,
0.7082632184,
-0.0130709913,
-0.0218354277,
0.6501288414,
0.318806231,
0.1843930632,
-0.1487711817,
-0.24914442,
-0.1630923599,
-0.5610848665,
-0.8189975023,
0.2918256521,
0.0624388158,
-0.2407305539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13439v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13439v1 | Finding Blind Spots in Evaluator LLMs with Interpretable Checklists | 2024-06-19T10:59:48 | 2024-06-19T10:59:48 | Sumanth Doddapaneni, Mohammed Safi Ur Rahman Khan, Sshubam Verma, Mitesh M. Khapra | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly relied upon to evaluate text
outputs of other LLMs, thereby influencing leaderboards and development
decisions. However, concerns persist over the accuracy of these assessments and
the potential for misleading conclusions. In this work, we investigate the
effectiveness of LLMs as evaluators for text generation tasks. We propose FBI,
a novel framework designed to examine the proficiency of Evaluator LLMs in
assessing four critical abilities in other LLMs: factual accuracy, instruction
following, coherence in long-form writing, and reasoning proficiency. By
introducing targeted perturbations in answers generated by LLMs, that clearly
impact one of these key capabilities, we test whether an Evaluator LLM can
detect these quality drops. By creating a total of 2400 perturbed answers
covering 22 perturbation categories, we conduct a comprehensive study using
different evaluation strategies on five prominent LLMs commonly used as
evaluators in the literature. Our findings reveal significant shortcomings in
current Evaluator LLMs, which failed to identify quality drops in over 50\% of
cases on average. Single-answer and pairwise evaluations demonstrated notable
limitations, whereas reference-based evaluations showed comparatively better
performance. These results underscore the unreliable nature of current
Evaluator LLMs and advocate for cautious implementation in practical
applications. Code and data are available at https://github.com/AI4Bharat/FBI. | [
-0.2247870713,
-0.888009727,
0.8800459504,
0.3416079283,
-0.0721106157,
0.3906343877,
-0.0344509296,
-0.4357231855,
-0.050074216,
0.5887816548,
-0.3690419197,
-0.6649740934,
-0.7029975057,
0.3088850081,
-0.6810831428,
1.2213531733,
-0.3042450547,
-0.2020023167,
-0.384546876,
0.019801436,
-0.4821152091,
-0.2622137368,
-0.3030855656,
-0.3584665656,
0.3859024048,
0.6184411049,
0.5421407223,
0.3329486549,
0.7503067851,
0.2682459056,
-0.1412288249,
0.270922333,
-0.4697346985,
0.0512443371,
-0.1076731905,
-0.4271615446,
-0.6442409158,
0.0893193632,
0.7242746949,
0.5579857826,
0.0306989849,
0.3251589239,
0.2664266825,
0.3901444077,
-0.7019730806,
0.0474986769,
-0.5519554615,
-0.0177709088,
-0.3567177951,
-0.3712624907,
-0.4873310626,
-0.4053764343,
-0.0140696215,
-0.1838237345,
0.3184606731,
-0.1952637285,
0.7336517572,
0.4227803349,
-0.4142968357,
-0.4365549386,
-0.7148641944,
0.7960845232,
-0.7950363755,
0.2503635883,
0.4825970531,
0.0757148713,
-0.2468038052,
-0.5984188318,
-0.6580913067,
-0.4043961465,
0.1016962901,
0.1430391967,
-0.0448793396,
0.0298318006,
0.2244026959,
0.4069777131,
-0.4580356181,
0.2418660522,
-0.0115906419,
-0.3680876493,
0.6193519831,
0.3626411855,
-0.0008308008,
-0.2201254517,
-0.2601597309,
0.2053852528,
-0.7683814168,
0.3720736802,
0.4534648359,
-0.0475758947,
0.0736020952,
0.6403445601,
-0.2449032217,
0.6452175975,
0.1309143007,
-0.3116660714,
0.0833955035,
-0.40273121,
-0.2104401141,
-0.5246284604,
0.4836261868,
0.1361840963,
-0.0633114949,
0.1769018173,
-0.4745247066,
-0.1634786576,
0.1949917674,
-0.7875149846,
-0.2306494862,
0.2663539946,
-0.2963159978,
-0.5260111094,
0.0237025283,
-0.6261056066,
-0.673873961,
0.0459090136,
0.3069317639,
-0.1646709293,
0.0987369195,
-0.0993253887,
0.115418613,
0.0574774593,
0.4330607653,
-0.6960961223,
0.2253727019,
0.4993685782,
0.5035729408,
-0.2834933698,
-0.2979038358,
-0.7794144154,
-0.2218806595,
-0.3645612597,
0.9780005813,
-0.5346180201,
-0.193301186,
0.1802235246,
-0.2974589169,
0.0517357476,
-0.6840674877,
0.5910841227,
-0.4890224338,
0.011908845,
0.0495136455,
-0.5368763208,
-0.1336715966,
0.2783079445,
-0.5382381082,
0.8893795609,
0.050551787,
-0.4426212311,
0.3518984318,
-0.4159916043,
-0.4644008577,
0.1361106932,
-0.3182199895,
-0.5808770061,
0.2204219401,
0.0912261754,
0.5896770954,
-0.4844691157,
0.3105005622,
-0.0672332644,
-0.5903655291,
0.7312785387,
-0.7145296335,
0.5815690756,
-0.0362086035,
-0.5087452531,
0.2148721814,
-1.0337548256,
0.1880030483,
-0.0826376528,
-0.8413103819,
0.2004171014,
0.1156823337,
0.1334927231,
-0.0672976151,
0.1601043791,
-0.2898674011,
-0.2901288867,
-0.195054099,
0.111401096,
0.8644448519,
0.122171022,
-0.058310464,
-0.3517350852,
0.8944028616,
-0.1873487681,
-0.0020384123,
-0.2401329279,
-0.4158094823,
-0.8062840104,
-0.2025139779,
0.3124015927,
0.4080831707,
-0.8364889622,
0.6073345542,
-0.0912797153,
-0.5799623728,
-0.3759102523,
0.6097574234,
0.7854676843,
0.3272140324,
0.0861570686,
-0.1753326058,
-0.1287193,
-0.8211219311,
-0.2833185494,
-0.3153039515,
-0.0291201621,
0.0835301206,
0.5634391904,
-0.2134171575,
0.8433679342,
-0.2450881451,
-0.2257209271,
-0.4224175811,
-0.0243524481,
0.0490911379,
0.26950261,
0.3221347928,
-0.4563091993,
-0.3425177932,
-0.212966606,
-0.5594918132,
-0.3519063592,
-0.1565261781,
0.0333843417,
0.3597551286,
0.3104846776,
-0.369586885,
0.4951733947,
0.8073239923,
-0.6119415164,
0.8500352502,
0.1796638668,
0.0138444314,
-0.6705754399,
0.2347963899,
-0.0924631953,
-0.165459767,
-0.6253497005,
0.07536529,
0.1524233967,
0.1393180341,
-0.3312166631,
0.5707582831,
-0.3849062622,
0.0471925177,
-0.2062607855,
0.4475981593,
0.2258799225,
0.3313164115,
-0.4504370391,
0.5492208004,
0.1568399221,
-0.3490895927,
0.2985109091,
0.2550643682,
-0.6711480021,
0.5758357644,
-0.320494771,
0.2802763879,
0.1089815721,
0.1948564798,
-1.0793339014,
-0.3846869767,
0.1713963449,
-0.3352243602,
0.3868603706,
0.2196654528,
-0.4790323675,
-0.30313766,
-0.4643968046,
0.1787422299,
0.1619859487,
-0.5193434358,
0.3628964126,
0.1666346639,
-0.1859784871,
-0.8572103977,
-0.6911622286,
0.0859404504,
0.0021241189,
-0.5136607289,
-0.0853992701,
-0.2805798352,
-0.3114378452,
-0.0404774286,
-0.4410601258,
-0.0265683047,
0.5367404819,
0.224642694,
0.3124881983,
-0.1757999063,
0.1115169674,
0.1424832493,
0.0894342512,
0.195467338,
0.2233749628,
0.3314236104,
-0.1798643321,
-0.5666031837,
-0.4053732455,
-0.0799573585,
0.4379931092,
-0.2389968634,
0.3951732516,
0.3985677063,
-0.1498993635,
-0.5020106435,
-0.7262550592,
-0.0652559474,
-0.4684461951,
0.6311467886,
-0.434491545,
-0.7402271628,
0.535784781,
0.124463506,
0.1393943578,
0.2416450679,
0.4094315171,
-0.0776234642,
0.7196224928,
0.6502209902,
0.2884375751,
0.4309719503,
-0.2747532725,
0.3327976465,
-0.9189118147,
-0.2430465221,
-0.4820693433,
-0.1500934213,
-0.2907345891,
-0.4129563272,
0.2038051188,
0.261546582,
0.1794261634,
-0.1231794283,
-0.2224048972,
0.5623975992,
0.2390485257,
0.0588781238,
0.4168798625,
-0.0524965227,
-0.1905737221,
0.0398189425,
-0.5150495768,
-0.8804294467,
1.199085474,
0.5985075235,
0.6617688537,
0.1384440809,
0.6522473693,
0.3778260946,
0.8060376048,
-0.760828495,
0.7084190249,
-0.0062407204,
-0.518907249,
-0.4937620461,
-0.3249945343,
-0.7455611825,
0.1880536675,
-0.379489243,
-0.4978111386,
0.2069026828,
0.0857524723,
-0.3362806141,
0.007847378,
-0.4550073445,
0.9406748414,
-0.3192198575,
-0.5366187096,
-0.0312333256,
-0.1457041353,
0.4599184692,
-0.5782418251,
0.082020618,
-0.2488169074,
-0.1032018736,
0.6455087066,
-0.218421936,
0.8242926002,
-0.0830472335,
-0.3527008593,
0.3075247109,
0.1718757898,
0.6149737239,
-0.0348942839,
-0.3911815286,
0.3556438982,
-0.2463649809,
-0.3609431982,
-0.7104596496,
0.5363525152,
-0.4738672078,
-0.9287085533,
-0.3227849305,
-0.5197015405,
-0.3426197171,
0.2669538558,
0.1487803906,
0.4305589199,
-0.2550626099,
0.293050915,
0.1248444468,
-0.2535040975,
0.234286949,
0.7134112716,
-0.2954926491,
-0.3090207279,
0.8904322386,
0.0612363927,
0.306126982,
0.046528656,
0.0544072799,
-0.1287230253,
-1.2228804827,
-0.4557590187,
0.1881002486,
-0.942338109,
-0.2796611786,
-0.1965747774,
-0.3521744907,
-0.2798508108,
-0.1057563275,
0.0549901053,
-0.2640374303,
-0.2944892645,
-0.2583526075,
-0.1346402317,
0.9266121984,
0.3107683361,
0.1863968223,
-0.6676055193,
0.1164501086,
0.208076328,
0.4137588441,
-0.051572375,
-0.6916428208,
-0.566762507,
-0.2074380964,
-0.6959828734,
-0.870298028,
0.2136549354,
-0.0239978079,
0.5730971694,
0.5485111475,
0.0183302071,
0.5844038725,
-0.1784120798,
0.7868530154,
0.0031317526,
-1.1989352703,
0.5087866187,
-0.0967892185,
0.1934248358,
0.5792927146,
0.0318761095,
-0.0145868734,
-1.0919672251,
-0.4219726026,
-0.6243725419,
0.7540165186,
0.5108813643,
-0.0881112739,
0.1205851883,
0.3323471248,
0.0102563919,
0.2640739083,
-0.6506572366,
-0.1724275351,
0.0870668218,
-0.3198533952,
-0.2580930591,
-0.5771939158,
0.025107665,
0.1275814921,
0.5617863536,
-0.1211130172,
-0.2545338869,
0.2308198959,
-0.1615774035,
-0.3080313504,
0.4635162354,
0.5793446898,
1.0011444092,
-0.1137911752,
0.1780161858,
0.121972248,
-0.5790147185,
0.220103547,
0.1880413741,
-0.4462093115,
-0.0573442765,
0.7148903012,
0.5826122761,
0.1411783099,
-1.0779608488,
0.4709072113,
0.043359343,
-0.1619325876,
-0.3756518066,
0.2320717573,
-0.1275213808,
0.2747574449,
0.4128534496,
0.1709389687,
0.2580248713,
-0.5788133144,
-0.0333345644,
0.4636701047,
-0.3342871368,
-0.3017816842,
0.4530517459,
0.4837523401,
-0.5516489148,
0.4193850756,
-0.0849911124,
-0.4478073716,
0.8238021135,
0.4873143435,
0.957905829,
-0.2788698077,
0.2708479464,
-0.1511425823,
0.5372151732,
0.1993813068,
0.232404694,
-0.1145838797,
-0.7536994815,
-0.4265575707,
-0.7249228954,
-0.6896525621,
0.3506705165,
-0.5096879601,
0.1839771718,
-0.5006020069,
-0.3134041429,
0.0151525624,
0.2373571098,
-0.6617488265,
0.0283920635,
-0.0750803798,
0.5878243446,
-0.6655198336,
0.6619269252,
0.7921698093,
-0.4134643078,
-0.8312385082,
0.3940146267,
0.0366224833,
-0.5369909406,
0.6776412725,
0.1859814376,
-0.1093934104,
-0.1970495433,
-0.2765306532,
-0.8131811023,
0.970972836,
0.3463161886,
-0.6442770958,
0.1162071601,
0.2944775522,
0.7475398183,
-0.2205277234,
0.3990444541,
0.9008566737,
0.6357596517,
-0.254401207,
-1.0088331699,
0.3506287336,
-0.3158406019,
-0.1644132584,
-0.0000468085,
-0.6288260818,
0.6048378348,
-0.337748915,
-0.3512932658,
0.4638361335,
0.2080896944,
0.5157228708,
0.7194604874,
0.2686224282,
0.2144259512,
0.7580771446,
0.0347975157,
1.0405653715,
-0.1779503673,
0.1231409907,
0.9675192833,
-0.4299985766,
0.9989870191,
0.370981127,
-0.1048149243,
0.5610595942,
0.2947288156,
-0.1929939091,
0.0275502782,
0.413130939,
-0.1861325204,
-0.176072672,
0.0154966414,
0.238316983,
0.4752593637,
0.2055522799,
-0.3523527682,
0.0613870509,
-0.0103930654,
-0.1043821797,
0.3203041553,
-0.005521141,
0.5243414044,
0.0066078617,
-0.7366734743,
0.6804994941,
0.0171882976,
0.381901294,
-0.2133489251,
-0.278860122,
-0.4335387051,
0.2984682918,
-0.5016865134,
-0.9443652034,
0.129740566,
0.3652620018,
-0.0623851605,
-0.2390964627,
0.5913226008,
-0.173572883,
-0.4936321676,
0.2180939466,
0.606136024,
0.3560503423,
0.080821678,
-0.4247605801,
0.2811309397,
0.2388240993,
-0.4282433689,
0.094597891,
0.3796772957,
0.0482858159,
0.6539298892,
0.661663115,
0.3108558953,
0.0085729072,
0.0963775143,
0.6145578623,
-0.7155519128,
-0.0952483118,
-0.7008289099,
0.5391269922,
0.0981711,
-0.495408386,
1.0076973438,
0.5431104898,
0.7586875558,
0.0399030522,
0.6677950025,
0.2211408317,
0.5111530423,
-0.6490904689,
0.7434633374,
-0.4303889573,
0.8374564648,
-0.2622957528,
-1.132999897,
-0.2777186334,
0.3584712744,
-0.2057966888,
-0.008238066,
0.8347468972,
0.7114543319,
0.3772823811,
-0.2559390664,
0.659455061,
0.5194974542,
0.6469912529,
0.3895457685,
1.2522065639,
-0.4532052875,
0.9101381302,
-0.1902882606,
-0.2491552532,
-0.302881062,
-0.5159687996,
-1.0639660358,
-0.3137557209,
-0.2404871285,
-0.352948159,
0.1075694934,
0.4766482413,
0.3626923859,
-0.6656375527,
-0.2686722279,
-0.0489020273,
0.49262169,
0.0036979644,
-0.3046267033,
0.3603413105,
-0.3434448838,
-0.7597776055,
0.4528746605,
0.1812581718,
-0.1698470861,
-0.5124621987,
-0.1482647806,
0.240449816,
0.2720694244,
0.5817327499,
0.0441660844,
-1.0202971697,
-0.4393442571,
-0.0979782566,
-0.1512695849,
-0.2367079705,
0.6253220439,
-0.7036249042,
0.4379170537,
0.370326072,
0.615639329,
0.2513995171,
-0.0397856422,
0.3219097853,
-0.5600453615,
-0.2709902823,
0.4958933294,
0.2232457846,
0.2459806204,
-0.2950164676,
0.3776397109,
0.0939012319,
-0.7512260079,
-1.0777398348,
0.0179000981,
-0.7544298768,
0.0043287445,
1.1677000523,
-0.3755552471,
0.0772803426,
-0.3080361485,
-0.0285341721,
-0.1657543927,
-0.2583203614,
1.0720596313,
0.8196002245,
-0.2539413571,
-0.1186833009,
-0.359439522,
0.4161399603,
0.6163960099,
-0.9683473706,
0.0109685529,
0.7803572416,
0.3632178605,
0.442961067,
0.6389318705,
0.0197567046,
0.5239450932,
-0.004488335,
0.0387600139,
-0.0746222809,
-0.4082652926,
-0.5730862021,
0.2530391514,
0.4198500216,
0.1113396287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13431v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13431v2 | Children's Speech Recognition through Discrete Token Enhancement | 2024-06-19T10:45:12 | 2024-06-24T15:31:59 | Vrunda N. Sukhadia, Shammur Absar Chowdhury | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Children's speech recognition is considered a low-resource task mainly due to
the lack of publicly available data. There are several reasons for such data
scarcity, including expensive data collection and annotation processes, and
data privacy, among others. Transforming speech signals into discrete tokens
that do not carry sensitive information but capture both linguistic and
acoustic information could be a solution for privacy concerns. In this study,
we investigate the integration of discrete speech tokens into children's speech
recognition systems as input without significantly degrading the ASR
performance. Additionally, we explored single-view and multi-view strategies
for creating these discrete labels. Furthermore, we tested the models for
generalization capabilities with unseen domain and nativity dataset. Results
reveal that the discrete token ASR for children achieves nearly equivalent
performance with an approximate 83% reduction in parameters. | [
-0.3822218478,
-0.0940931141,
0.0290660653,
0.011438949,
-0.5103027225,
0.2744270861,
-0.0041080257,
-0.690462172,
0.0704248622,
0.2408934385,
-0.5026843548,
-0.1530561745,
-0.6178178191,
-0.1748449951,
-0.4817075133,
0.7205116153,
0.2295793742,
-0.1111287773,
-0.245625779,
0.0684212148,
-0.2160252631,
-0.8946918845,
-0.6018472314,
-0.1610312462,
0.4368240833,
0.3867514431,
0.2426785082,
0.9404128194,
0.4131763875,
0.3008341789,
-0.3571994603,
0.0790802911,
-0.1330389678,
-0.0994326845,
-0.2866512835,
-0.0789365992,
-0.5306580663,
-0.1352120936,
0.9205751419,
0.8092436194,
0.1035298556,
0.0445266925,
0.2921283841,
0.4351968169,
-0.5961213708,
0.3641443253,
-0.4416342974,
0.3318739533,
-0.5361521244,
0.2264653295,
-0.1599078476,
-0.4382969737,
0.3195228875,
-0.4375712276,
0.1104340479,
-0.2573611438,
0.3004698455,
0.2191043943,
-0.2720814347,
-0.211552456,
-1.006498456,
0.7732443213,
-0.5541090369,
0.3083701134,
0.6064094901,
0.0410234705,
0.1572924554,
-0.8653842807,
-0.5708349943,
0.1070674658,
-0.4168188572,
-0.2156911939,
-0.4238508344,
0.1762987971,
0.3637761474,
0.2213371992,
-0.4399273992,
0.1083543673,
-0.477956593,
-0.2875388265,
0.4989245832,
0.1487515271,
0.2365813851,
-0.0790335461,
-0.1772276014,
-0.0933303237,
-0.1740882546,
0.312972635,
0.1015504897,
0.8188064098,
-0.4267564714,
0.3823389411,
-0.2415994555,
0.5975282192,
0.2179562002,
-0.2646826804,
0.3197874427,
-0.4877839088,
-0.0493190065,
0.4665447176,
0.4192101657,
-0.1185584739,
0.2412867099,
-0.1525488645,
-0.2188862413,
0.5209293365,
-0.0310691223,
-0.8360393643,
-0.0512136109,
0.0142307095,
-0.4909036756,
-0.2901304364,
0.1230334118,
-0.7372269034,
-0.402834326,
-0.392272979,
0.2016802728,
-0.3617541194,
-0.2089374512,
0.0478949808,
-0.3469056189,
0.1098547578,
0.0381591022,
-1.1657736301,
0.8068596721,
0.6914792061,
0.6653635502,
-0.2096830904,
0.0671497285,
-0.7696545124,
0.343922168,
-0.1566070467,
0.8060046434,
-0.8325089812,
-0.8297477365,
-0.2470246851,
-0.3299005032,
-0.3033112586,
-0.6584489346,
0.2458750308,
-0.230339095,
0.0999776796,
-0.1859576106,
-0.351200074,
0.1811831146,
-0.3267828226,
-0.4885737598,
0.5986350179,
-0.0964545161,
-0.6437100172,
0.6320015788,
-1.0550324917,
-0.658398807,
0.3357749283,
-0.3612095714,
-0.3414174318,
0.3419410884,
0.6343032718,
0.0179570206,
0.2536921799,
0.1452593952,
0.0791129619,
-0.5390303731,
0.5135959387,
-0.9839777946,
0.4778870046,
0.0675247163,
-0.4760716558,
-0.1618831307,
-0.8599068522,
0.1313740164,
-0.3449172676,
-0.5119773746,
-0.321244508,
0.0661129653,
0.1662079692,
0.2672837079,
0.2160662115,
-0.6977931857,
0.01361713,
-0.5577872396,
0.3550489247,
0.6267209053,
0.0167390238,
0.4236879349,
-0.40019539,
0.3502981663,
0.2000974268,
0.6741138697,
0.0780265927,
-0.7351595759,
-0.5729554296,
-0.7037238479,
0.747200191,
0.1089417934,
-0.6482496858,
0.4411144853,
-0.5347712636,
0.0712125301,
-0.4492223859,
-0.291482091,
0.7044857144,
0.4564345181,
0.2479021847,
-0.8358761072,
-0.6907711029,
-0.5915336609,
0.1069412455,
-0.1930940449,
-0.1793866456,
0.6837881804,
0.2172254622,
-0.1047316045,
0.9875582457,
-0.0146270255,
-0.2369306386,
0.1517184377,
-0.0287852082,
0.1977794915,
0.9093945622,
0.3014956117,
-0.894502759,
-0.342181325,
0.0600076281,
-0.348307997,
-0.0344721787,
0.2818940878,
0.392363131,
0.003938966,
0.049433887,
-0.1854614466,
1.1027829647,
0.6578233242,
-0.4804872274,
0.1225843951,
0.0795715004,
-0.0039938209,
-0.4225242138,
0.1078681126,
-0.5634926558,
-0.2663715184,
-0.9143986702,
-0.3742466271,
-0.0830922499,
-0.2970654666,
-0.8187462091,
0.5557085276,
-0.2243167907,
-0.3719805181,
-0.3291367888,
0.1237323284,
-0.0581235215,
0.2799947858,
0.0438117757,
0.8588203192,
0.7037739158,
-0.5932232141,
0.2614291608,
0.1568769962,
0.071201615,
0.6351439357,
-0.4189179838,
0.5070225,
-0.051675912,
0.1358242929,
-0.7403865457,
-0.130861491,
0.350200057,
-0.7239066362,
0.4401058257,
-0.1509567052,
-0.5520504713,
-0.2799483538,
-0.2474118173,
0.6792470217,
0.4849461913,
-0.8625934124,
0.6282759905,
0.5015071034,
-0.2245975137,
-0.4790934324,
-0.8556770086,
0.1542246193,
-0.1614786983,
-0.2226443291,
0.6343297362,
-0.0372161195,
0.0964905471,
0.5050894618,
-0.3751870394,
-0.254796207,
-0.3346982598,
0.3580860496,
0.1634312272,
-0.3501686156,
0.1424236894,
0.2438069582,
-0.4633822739,
-0.2741250992,
-0.5124248266,
0.6311915517,
0.0120319929,
-0.4499962628,
-0.7725627422,
0.4111038148,
0.5554734468,
-0.293171972,
0.4729419649,
0.252687633,
-0.7968159914,
-0.1269141287,
-0.3769499362,
-0.0569671914,
-0.5584782362,
-0.189512983,
-0.3308659792,
-0.7366738915,
0.45376724,
-0.0126624787,
-0.3130541146,
0.0959335268,
0.1806426793,
0.0321159214,
0.8686674237,
0.3212021887,
-0.2626281083,
0.6125274301,
-0.0939952657,
-0.0975949764,
-1.0225255489,
-0.4558579028,
-0.5734712481,
-0.5010002255,
-0.4586050808,
-0.5493072867,
0.1109693572,
-0.2431145608,
-0.1513475329,
0.0624022223,
-0.9391973019,
0.4611107111,
0.9054365754,
0.2051175684,
0.4481906295,
0.135348767,
-0.2457628399,
-0.2071876973,
-0.7025707364,
-0.3363802433,
0.9562378526,
0.1695435345,
0.484389931,
0.2096685916,
0.7874625921,
0.1902599931,
0.2301118821,
-0.7296037078,
0.4781829119,
-0.7997239232,
-0.5689169168,
-0.4470339715,
-0.2925682366,
-0.9662560225,
0.2425379455,
-0.0631632581,
-1.0602391958,
1.0747568607,
-0.0350461937,
-0.6208995581,
0.1482661813,
-0.4657134116,
0.0542988405,
-0.2690740824,
-0.2071007043,
-0.0539414957,
-0.3124545813,
0.0568166338,
-0.467651397,
0.224338904,
0.3305547833,
-0.2047712058,
0.9018154144,
-0.6373910904,
1.0655409098,
-0.4912204146,
0.4160294235,
0.2206065059,
-0.5022287369,
0.2576804459,
-0.0323004872,
0.0091756843,
0.1410222799,
-0.161421299,
-0.1341388077,
-0.5775747895,
0.8089080453,
-0.6556675434,
-0.189091295,
-0.5685660243,
-0.3405045271,
-0.3550486267,
0.1497513205,
-0.1733037978,
0.7339164019,
0.3416944146,
0.4091055691,
0.5682945848,
-0.1760869771,
0.7080639601,
0.3963369429,
-0.0440172106,
-0.7576828599,
0.8766268492,
0.4202155769,
0.1157659143,
0.0413525328,
0.4183067977,
-0.542788744,
-0.5974746943,
-0.3021914661,
0.2263287157,
-0.4606915116,
-0.1185187548,
-0.3425346911,
-0.5467072129,
-0.4428009987,
-0.1896464825,
-0.2078024,
-0.7217146754,
-0.5018389225,
-0.2851575017,
0.3218479455,
0.5626767874,
-0.6135728359,
0.5028047562,
-0.592822969,
0.6233796477,
0.8226550817,
0.6450816393,
0.1555571407,
-0.5421504378,
-0.0377908163,
-0.0651613176,
0.1589093208,
-0.4776307046,
0.2127928287,
0.3127892017,
0.430896759,
0.5623238087,
-0.0402466953,
1.1425628662,
-0.545547843,
0.7560311556,
0.1752747297,
-1.2831366062,
0.5413738489,
-0.2446667999,
0.1307607144,
0.4323316216,
-0.3048639894,
-0.3265607655,
0.0236232169,
-0.6486941576,
-0.7207683325,
1.1140775681,
0.3314488828,
0.2723366916,
0.3819852471,
0.1751719117,
-0.1400668174,
0.4440065026,
-0.2155732363,
-0.3922024071,
-0.3562214673,
-0.1433403045,
0.1440586299,
-0.1196111813,
-0.0103372931,
-0.6698649526,
0.0966150165,
0.2851550281,
0.3148443103,
-0.0011354705,
0.5060992241,
-0.0130264377,
0.0235581733,
0.4321795106,
0.2030497193,
0.0211375672,
0.1702707559,
0.1535799056,
-0.7995510101,
0.1929017603,
0.379881978,
-0.1326067001,
0.1630420834,
0.2496614158,
0.7135535479,
0.2972812057,
-0.293177098,
0.4538579285,
-0.3440434337,
-0.2030003369,
-0.2488573492,
0.1488563716,
0.0588339493,
0.2842839956,
0.3466431201,
-0.1130910888,
0.2545840442,
-0.3781246841,
0.4509573281,
0.2860237658,
-0.4892530441,
-0.2044330835,
0.6929119229,
0.218300432,
-0.6498095989,
0.661334753,
-0.0007920802,
-0.2436397672,
0.4950613379,
0.8059189916,
0.8925445676,
-0.5785339475,
0.2832047045,
-0.1220769286,
0.26351735,
0.3486869931,
0.2635134161,
-0.5183894634,
-0.5417504907,
-0.2901153862,
-0.4102846086,
-0.6183034778,
0.23997657,
-0.6964903474,
-0.0928370282,
-0.6287629008,
-0.4004458785,
0.0069097425,
-0.0816922337,
-0.672973752,
0.5334054232,
0.4090920687,
0.3431279659,
-0.6150950789,
0.9110307097,
0.3903129995,
-0.1772059202,
-0.7722194791,
-0.0294660367,
-0.088310197,
-0.6002586484,
0.6998595595,
-0.0423042364,
-0.4342809916,
0.0292636268,
-0.2623279989,
-1.1435358524,
0.6233364344,
0.1063779816,
-0.4898819029,
0.0080781281,
0.7245920897,
0.6808162928,
-0.3081205487,
-0.3107560277,
0.5144488811,
0.5837547779,
0.2402166873,
-1.0629729033,
-0.1140881926,
-0.2953183055,
0.2831215262,
-0.1243211553,
-0.3082542717,
0.8125123978,
0.1732479334,
-0.4839738309,
-0.3193786144,
0.3129272759,
0.367100507,
0.6909947991,
0.414853096,
0.1205622405,
0.9192051291,
-0.0014809157,
0.7081935406,
-0.1797653437,
-0.000708732,
0.9561411142,
-0.1300631911,
0.7704761028,
0.5307825208,
-0.2474899292,
0.2414935976,
0.1512725502,
0.3251605332,
0.8541263342,
0.304482609,
-0.7318251729,
0.226078853,
-0.4141998291,
-0.1200210899,
0.5187225938,
0.8336914182,
-0.2351771742,
0.171908021,
0.076235801,
-0.1581931859,
0.002630461,
-0.4273394346,
1.0438965559,
0.2859675586,
0.0419306196,
0.5179027915,
-0.1249816716,
0.7976213098,
-0.3641343117,
-0.0704318807,
-0.1771472543,
0.0245537125,
-0.4715274274,
-0.2156452984,
0.4280445278,
0.4119544327,
-0.101054579,
-0.1401271671,
0.8342959285,
-0.0174764171,
-0.6347481608,
0.1319106221,
0.3450873792,
0.1164215654,
0.1537338942,
-0.4214893281,
-0.0082466369,
-0.1210789084,
0.1939595789,
0.3494441807,
0.3944722712,
0.0064741699,
0.4129106402,
0.9529728889,
0.4745237827,
0.2647763491,
0.1586198658,
1.1113791466,
-0.4885776639,
-0.4549102783,
-0.662296176,
0.7383012176,
-0.1021475196,
-0.090486303,
0.5251568556,
0.559941113,
0.6676784754,
0.0828516111,
0.9230915308,
0.19802697,
0.7481188178,
-0.1661571413,
0.7470189929,
-0.0396272205,
0.1780526787,
-0.4640831649,
-0.5563949347,
-0.7043544054,
0.7885245681,
-0.2918191552,
-0.037756633,
0.4924222529,
0.5384303331,
-0.1380213797,
0.0880850926,
0.4235101342,
-0.3225788176,
0.4159600735,
0.4222349226,
0.8930602074,
-0.2052157968,
0.4103804827,
-0.4107673466,
-0.3785687983,
-0.0072031822,
-0.4628255665,
-0.743555069,
-0.3271178007,
-0.385599494,
0.0058891708,
0.3368855715,
0.4795945585,
0.8112009764,
-0.9662618041,
0.0023268776,
-0.0230450761,
0.0488488823,
-0.1363521069,
-0.179942295,
0.5545945168,
0.1090838164,
-0.9112513661,
0.6837451458,
0.2753245234,
0.1622567475,
-0.0368165039,
0.196848169,
0.389724493,
0.2776748836,
0.4205167592,
0.3369427025,
-0.4240987599,
-0.5420649648,
-0.1874695718,
0.248458147,
0.1764081568,
0.6327194571,
-1.046064496,
0.5984691381,
0.2066570371,
0.4666405916,
0.7070356011,
0.4941799343,
0.1033422649,
-0.9731608033,
0.2390142232,
0.5414001942,
-0.0295616817,
0.2948389947,
-0.2090712786,
0.106034182,
0.259334892,
-0.2383251339,
-0.9493690133,
0.0979759395,
-0.6083354354,
0.1172806025,
0.7531673908,
0.0028426766,
0.0568917766,
-0.566498816,
-0.093775779,
0.1189799681,
-0.6859586835,
0.5697076917,
0.187107563,
-0.4145123065,
-0.0231450442,
-0.0297592506,
0.4295769036,
-0.1861891896,
-0.5874265432,
-0.0607669428,
0.4151562154,
0.0101419901,
0.250321269,
0.8114583492,
-0.5245479941,
0.1627449244,
0.4183544219,
-0.2456906438,
-0.0353457443,
-0.3298347294,
-0.8354594707,
0.2792858183,
-0.0249354858,
-0.9039767981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13415v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13415v1 | Factual Confidence of LLMs: on Reliability and Robustness of Current Estimators | 2024-06-19T10:11:37 | 2024-06-19T10:11:37 | Matéo Mahaut, Laura Aina, Paula Czarnowska, Momchil Hardalov, Thomas Müller, Lluís Màrquez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) tend to be unreliable in the factuality of their
answers. To address this problem, NLP researchers have proposed a range of
techniques to estimate LLM's confidence over facts. However, due to the lack of
a systematic comparison, it is not clear how the different methods compare to
one another. To fill this gap, we present a survey and empirical comparison of
estimators of factual confidence. We define an experimental framework allowing
for fair comparison, covering both fact-verification and question answering.
Our experiments across a series of LLMs indicate that trained hidden-state
probes provide the most reliable confidence estimates, albeit at the expense of
requiring access to weights and training data. We also conduct a deeper
assessment of factual confidence by measuring the consistency of model behavior
under meaning-preserving variations in the input. We find that the confidence
of LLMs is often unstable across semantically equivalent inputs, suggesting
that there is much room for improvement of the stability of models' parametric
knowledge. Our code is available at
(https://github.com/amazon-science/factual-confidence-of-llms). | [
-0.1056268513,
-0.8634417653,
1.1202170849,
0.1701388657,
0.1717496365,
0.1939543337,
-0.2901895344,
-0.3945300281,
-0.0479134731,
0.0891864896,
-0.1520886421,
-0.6174530387,
-0.8032376766,
0.209509775,
-0.4534187615,
0.6462606192,
0.1524899155,
0.4123905897,
-0.7534831762,
-0.1325268745,
-0.2161659449,
-0.3811868131,
-0.5187156796,
-0.1566827893,
0.6658362746,
0.0333419666,
0.7580065727,
0.386305958,
0.5223401189,
0.3675822616,
-0.3001629412,
0.2188545167,
-0.4427605271,
0.3733330369,
-0.2414185852,
-0.8769376278,
-0.2118563801,
0.1919202805,
0.6607890725,
0.7091990709,
-0.303822428,
0.2534005046,
0.0072932034,
0.3272770941,
-0.9497839808,
0.2320896983,
-0.7699769735,
-0.0979370847,
0.0803041309,
-0.0283081196,
-0.5522177219,
-0.7793762684,
0.0774541721,
-0.2924379706,
0.1821787208,
0.1893392652,
0.868258357,
0.4962370396,
-0.4931050241,
-0.3261819184,
-0.8468573093,
0.9135169387,
-0.9078454971,
0.5123618245,
0.5024873018,
0.087679252,
-0.1479348987,
-0.6231450438,
-0.6356236339,
-0.7877705097,
-0.0828016177,
0.1738805473,
0.0041539497,
0.0077600065,
0.354208827,
0.452457875,
-0.5163024068,
0.2218811512,
-0.0635365471,
-0.3967165053,
0.4049075246,
-0.0990542471,
0.148004353,
-0.1443953514,
-0.4340824485,
0.0384590924,
-0.7806661129,
0.0146578923,
0.3375809193,
0.0331363641,
0.0245662257,
0.8895751238,
-0.2019586116,
0.3983308077,
-0.0103477733,
-0.6082744002,
0.0701025352,
-0.2657509744,
-0.1713272929,
-0.071623534,
0.6434452534,
0.2984906435,
-0.0124003803,
-0.2833880484,
-0.3435238898,
0.2479798347,
0.0748777166,
-0.4642521143,
0.0485918708,
0.4047453403,
-0.2079513073,
-0.272978276,
0.1091679856,
-0.3981812298,
-0.4350690842,
-0.0632695109,
0.4161069393,
-0.2441058457,
-0.1086477488,
0.0503336936,
-0.0682190359,
0.4042416215,
0.3005231917,
-0.4850808084,
0.3193616569,
0.7600328922,
0.7454023957,
-0.2880445421,
-0.1133922711,
-0.4998931885,
-0.151898995,
-0.5973502398,
0.5808694959,
-0.2230611891,
-0.1930306852,
0.1466474533,
-0.00664311,
-0.1332975626,
-0.4354719818,
0.8925226927,
-0.7100646496,
0.2935804427,
-0.5777975917,
-0.8074243665,
-0.0020734023,
0.7596483231,
-0.642483592,
1.1342533827,
-0.3184518516,
-1.037425518,
0.329793781,
-0.1329377443,
-0.0159266721,
-0.2290910631,
-0.2693883181,
-0.4044653773,
0.1823350191,
-0.0443020277,
0.458741039,
-0.2548505068,
0.35396716,
-0.7415595651,
-0.4166357815,
1.0223681927,
-0.8940663338,
0.7449300885,
0.0079067862,
-0.2412427217,
-0.3090400398,
-0.8030208349,
-0.1109110191,
0.0812113658,
-0.5684074163,
-0.1317741126,
0.2045769542,
-0.3978889883,
0.0634460375,
0.3430465758,
-0.8833222985,
-0.1303599775,
-0.3930131495,
0.0030278799,
0.6247178316,
-0.079118818,
0.1958539784,
-0.5398743153,
0.3789840341,
-0.2423781902,
-0.1152613759,
0.1901823729,
-0.4055691659,
-0.8328441381,
-0.295396775,
0.7559242845,
0.6640294194,
-0.4865507185,
0.4127621651,
-0.4020727873,
-0.407481581,
-0.2295195311,
-0.0269819088,
0.446759522,
0.7117907405,
0.168680355,
0.0510902815,
-0.3625531495,
-0.7283914089,
-0.1697537601,
-0.5150223374,
-0.1420676112,
0.0686871335,
0.5283771157,
0.008505092,
0.8027083278,
-0.3604080379,
0.3168381751,
0.012640506,
0.1018038616,
-0.0026613218,
0.1880763471,
0.4942321181,
-0.6806339025,
-0.1950073391,
-0.335303992,
-0.9578613043,
0.2332431376,
0.2601718307,
0.1655769199,
0.4530739188,
0.3077961206,
-0.9464968443,
0.453174293,
0.7538875341,
-0.0903401598,
0.6758542657,
-0.0562399998,
0.2435508072,
-0.7886109948,
0.1528775096,
0.0340999737,
-0.5096347332,
-0.3413688242,
0.0603221357,
0.0064099501,
0.3217257559,
-0.4539553523,
0.3671445251,
-0.4229571521,
-0.1033518687,
-0.2231382132,
0.308139652,
0.0102966353,
0.1835784167,
-0.0280720145,
0.7982774973,
0.4932931364,
-0.5251882076,
0.4560670555,
0.1837031394,
-0.5663138628,
0.4021095634,
-0.6821391582,
0.1013624668,
0.0071340082,
0.2049164176,
-1.0928471088,
-0.1934872568,
0.2444404066,
-0.5999495387,
0.4246867001,
-0.2366105467,
-0.5891488791,
-0.1775658429,
-0.3688442707,
-0.1617343724,
0.6207510233,
-0.4717643559,
0.4661180079,
0.3341413736,
-0.4998999834,
-1.0197846889,
-0.8623567224,
0.2337057143,
-0.0412088186,
-0.42026636,
-0.124947764,
-0.1892813295,
-0.6141137481,
0.1110961437,
-0.3884627819,
-0.1893776804,
0.1988964975,
0.1513179392,
0.3707200587,
-0.3255205452,
0.2974592149,
-0.0641512796,
0.1120596081,
0.4310685992,
-0.0606010631,
0.2324392051,
-0.3233079016,
-0.7601678371,
-0.2596637905,
-0.0684163198,
0.4812907577,
0.0058448799,
1.0237473249,
0.3067027032,
-0.2508744001,
-0.0061031687,
-0.8765093684,
-0.16217044,
-0.4346447885,
0.2210320383,
-0.1186523736,
-0.9770287871,
0.3762235045,
-0.0727172643,
0.1543767899,
0.233407557,
0.6105369925,
-0.4216496348,
0.8267663121,
0.6052376032,
0.151245147,
-0.1551136822,
0.1379170269,
0.0642013773,
-0.3526569903,
-0.2143429816,
-0.7022562027,
0.0208926667,
-0.639641881,
-0.3693527877,
0.2214220464,
-0.1954147667,
-0.1296271533,
-0.2211063206,
0.0314747132,
0.3802576661,
0.4208070636,
0.1343505532,
0.3368779719,
-0.1288078129,
-0.0810612217,
-0.1056540981,
-0.6795828342,
-0.8245362043,
1.034602046,
0.5139591694,
0.8724591136,
0.3226959109,
0.4509322047,
0.1520230472,
0.2578032613,
-0.8926558495,
0.5433461666,
0.1497044414,
-0.7980947495,
-0.3873074949,
-0.5391941667,
-0.647400558,
0.0819062591,
-0.5892829895,
-0.5732272267,
0.2379249185,
0.3200348616,
-0.2417915016,
0.3909715414,
-0.3148631155,
0.3854318559,
-0.3341623247,
-0.4043329954,
0.1105886325,
-0.7732799053,
0.5547788143,
-0.1064871326,
-0.0385070145,
-0.3610721827,
-0.1390987635,
0.5532559156,
-0.26105389,
0.8973298073,
-0.008440542,
-0.2737559974,
0.3445594609,
-0.0243633501,
0.5597483516,
0.3225933611,
-0.3343613148,
0.1518446207,
0.2102392614,
-0.5831108093,
-0.7481951118,
0.5818223953,
-0.5656111836,
-0.649836421,
-0.7766661644,
-0.5296130776,
-0.539650023,
0.0952754244,
0.1777854711,
0.4011881948,
-0.4050463736,
0.5737280846,
1.2415652275,
-0.0918023139,
0.3872136474,
0.5356158018,
-0.0640000254,
-0.13638179,
0.3679524958,
0.1323941499,
0.4518972933,
0.6064204574,
0.2349773794,
-0.5373640656,
-0.5742387176,
-0.2005234659,
0.2224054784,
-0.7959635854,
-0.2314680219,
-0.4261570871,
-0.3464416862,
-0.3799695075,
0.2326114178,
-0.6305046678,
-0.4359515905,
-0.0136239817,
-0.4943739176,
0.2986622155,
0.6444709301,
-0.0152287828,
-0.0826236159,
-0.5711045265,
0.2070135325,
0.4552128911,
0.1513590068,
-0.3675943017,
-0.5168224573,
-0.0456117205,
0.1954102367,
0.110736914,
-0.8509066105,
0.0766728744,
-0.0458014831,
0.7094925642,
0.3669808805,
0.3072887957,
0.1869418025,
-0.3177118897,
0.7916805148,
0.0838657618,
-0.739751339,
0.099307321,
-0.1628791988,
-0.042843312,
0.6695533991,
0.6491948366,
-0.2232948095,
-0.5954642296,
-0.4955437481,
-0.4331530333,
0.1883517504,
0.1008356586,
0.0952101946,
0.0737120956,
0.4200457633,
0.0795558542,
0.3595008254,
-0.7783049941,
-0.3810303211,
-0.1110329852,
-0.27928707,
0.00810342,
-0.6547452807,
-0.5950977206,
0.1401115805,
0.6277415156,
-0.1424595565,
0.298918426,
0.251045078,
-0.1253050864,
0.2487896979,
0.4732792377,
0.5619907975,
1.0428282022,
-0.4046878517,
0.5929221511,
0.5856221318,
-0.4723467529,
0.2646036744,
-0.0378547311,
-0.4157457054,
0.200274229,
0.4565564692,
0.534601748,
0.3160073459,
-0.619728744,
0.792216897,
-0.3366135061,
-0.2491625547,
-0.5300307274,
0.0696617663,
0.3031516373,
0.0895296708,
0.1558025777,
0.2431156784,
0.0032602453,
-0.5356934071,
0.0108560929,
0.579254508,
-0.3575749397,
-0.2051269412,
0.4391446412,
0.0656833351,
0.0117841335,
0.5044390559,
-0.3074787855,
-0.3646720648,
0.3620022535,
0.5437969565,
0.6355460882,
0.0608760267,
0.2422204465,
0.1087558344,
0.5454180837,
-0.392349571,
0.3141976297,
0.2596435249,
-0.9794322252,
-0.6328974962,
-0.5716553926,
-0.7505593896,
0.128248021,
-0.6355836391,
-0.0388003029,
-0.4210588038,
-0.2754924297,
-0.4972520173,
0.2141194791,
-0.477003336,
0.2863718569,
0.2227728963,
1.0263166428,
-0.8927266002,
0.7008799314,
0.6365398169,
-0.2596685886,
-0.8878416419,
0.29653579,
0.0149081489,
-0.7108507156,
0.2878614664,
-0.0561815761,
-0.5031227469,
-0.295894593,
-0.9853947759,
-1.0565326214,
1.1202421188,
0.7168059945,
-0.4483920038,
0.1290082484,
-0.0390003622,
0.4713480175,
0.0274238661,
0.1996919513,
0.4098519087,
0.5044215322,
0.3108426332,
-0.7749965787,
0.0395048,
0.0671474412,
-0.1165257841,
-0.3497555256,
-0.4301353991,
0.5679367781,
-0.1537009627,
-0.3203877509,
0.3756551445,
0.9075517654,
0.6479799747,
0.4362412393,
0.4654764235,
0.4881218672,
1.1693894863,
-0.267883122,
1.0699827671,
-0.4541514814,
0.4489812851,
1.0219631195,
-0.3733183742,
0.9614902139,
0.2971147001,
-0.3476868868,
0.4637306035,
0.4442211986,
-0.0007396989,
0.110857822,
-0.0474532321,
-0.3067433238,
-0.2718370259,
0.0032444024,
-0.1126540825,
0.3898925781,
0.1418925375,
-0.0353181846,
0.0801099613,
-0.3672073781,
0.4001743197,
0.0939984545,
-0.1458048671,
0.397636652,
0.2764504254,
-0.4785426855,
0.4217715263,
0.0260912832,
0.7239266634,
-0.6944412589,
0.2146576345,
-0.2535124719,
-0.0722939149,
-0.1399545372,
-0.8101204634,
0.0753052235,
0.0916628316,
-0.1561033428,
0.0815890431,
0.82524544,
-0.2679111362,
-0.5831626058,
-0.1046449393,
0.7962466478,
0.1362885535,
0.187818557,
-0.5697253346,
0.1287278533,
-0.3607158363,
-0.3305737078,
0.1118300855,
0.2467075735,
0.2530502081,
0.9158445597,
0.580922544,
0.3106459379,
0.3576707542,
-0.2673943043,
0.4762309492,
-0.4652864933,
-0.0093696686,
-0.7209905386,
0.3347864151,
-0.1236547157,
-0.1689935774,
1.1935945749,
0.4552760124,
0.6881851554,
-0.0188178085,
0.840713203,
0.0291499756,
0.6991797686,
-0.8096217513,
0.7370770574,
-0.2650790215,
0.3315382898,
0.0085309464,
-0.8805916309,
-0.3062823117,
0.5821759105,
-0.2335326672,
0.1215917096,
0.766245544,
0.841008842,
0.0026561196,
-0.1433036476,
0.4656923413,
0.5293468237,
0.0021308085,
-0.046554625,
1.3000020981,
-0.1391320676,
0.3941847682,
-0.2461792678,
-0.0089575937,
-0.0295693502,
-1.0420085192,
-0.6351928711,
-0.2817786336,
-0.3202450275,
-0.4221529961,
0.1638376266,
0.7405570149,
0.5434265137,
-0.7346252799,
-0.1256792694,
0.1643830538,
0.2758850455,
-0.0035825716,
-0.1669632941,
0.3272481263,
-0.2657376528,
-0.7793935537,
0.5608311892,
0.1620208323,
0.0022058592,
-0.4045885801,
0.0125535512,
-0.139545396,
0.4714247286,
0.42312482,
0.3819486499,
-0.7790001631,
-0.5357580781,
0.175692901,
-0.4039410055,
-0.0254555251,
0.3833676577,
-0.5932371616,
0.0795451701,
0.4988332689,
0.7711520195,
0.2521750033,
0.1443189085,
0.4310498536,
-0.6666177511,
-0.1253875494,
0.2743167281,
0.4714436829,
0.6109637618,
-0.2030851543,
0.3531077504,
0.1750035733,
-0.7921725512,
-1.0611861944,
0.2485462278,
-1.0449086428,
-0.1628216505,
1.2135858536,
-0.4167774022,
-0.1801895052,
-0.1093692407,
0.1538989693,
0.1138601229,
-0.1257624477,
0.7468585372,
0.7096900344,
-0.0647470951,
0.0634958073,
-0.6049968004,
0.4235654771,
0.3128282726,
-0.5946022868,
-0.2029275447,
0.3964197338,
0.6744865179,
0.3192857802,
0.4798652828,
0.0167199913,
0.0354558378,
0.0657002181,
-0.0103349518,
0.2422892004,
-0.3116086423,
-0.3249723315,
0.2087244838,
0.473110497,
-0.0790194944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13408v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13408v1 | SQLFixAgent: Towards Semantic-Accurate SQL Generation via Multi-Agent Collaboration | 2024-06-19T09:57:19 | 2024-06-19T09:57:19 | Jipeng Cen, Jiaxin Liu, Zhixu Li, Jingjing Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | While fine-tuned large language models (LLMs) excel in generating
grammatically valid SQL in Text-to-SQL parsing, they often struggle to ensure
semantic accuracy in queries, leading to user confusion and diminished system
usability. To tackle this challenge, we introduce SQLFixAgent, an innovative
multi-agent collaborative framework designed for detecting and repairing
erroneous SQL. Our framework comprises a core agent, SQLRefiner, alongside two
auxiliary agents: SQLReviewer and QueryCrafter. The SQLReviewer agent employs
the rubber duck debugging method to identify potential semantic mismatches
between SQL statement and user query. If the error is detected, the
QueryCrafter agent generates multiple SQL statements as candidate repairs using
a fine-tuned SQLTool. Subsequently, leveraging similar repair retrieval and
failure memory reflexion, the SQLRefiner agent selects the most fitting SQL
statement from the candidates as the final repair. We evaluated our proposed
framework on five Text-to-SQL benchmarks. The experimental results show that
our method consistently enhances the performance of the baseline model,
specifically achieving an execution accuracy improvement of over 3\% on the
Bird benchmark. Our framework also has a higher token efficiency compared to
other advanced methods, making it more competitive. | [
0.0324157625,
-0.7984726429,
0.6591237783,
0.1125159487,
0.0208448991,
0.286144346,
-0.065581277,
-0.3765158355,
0.1548845619,
0.7845150232,
-0.6900920272,
-0.4312056899,
-0.213203758,
0.1975559294,
-0.5220703483,
0.9078712463,
0.2984398901,
0.0414114259,
-0.3704681396,
-0.3369239569,
-0.6570411921,
-0.3236092627,
-0.6206942797,
-0.2607842386,
0.2727365792,
0.3553327024,
1.0324870348,
0.6075230837,
0.2382218093,
0.4869985878,
0.1953531653,
0.6401642561,
-0.7254133821,
0.3202409744,
-0.5584775805,
-0.5062552094,
-0.6101923585,
-0.3524241149,
0.2768448293,
0.5142077804,
-0.5547010899,
-0.2850943804,
0.0449575447,
0.7203751206,
-0.5247657895,
-0.036295794,
-1.1483592987,
-0.1060675904,
0.031966418,
0.1130166948,
-0.5496560335,
-0.3075329661,
-0.2388486862,
-0.5245478749,
0.6099523902,
0.2565537691,
0.6157022715,
0.4281170964,
-0.4750836194,
0.0878559053,
-0.5487636924,
0.8786271811,
-0.7035527229,
0.293040365,
0.071195215,
0.398689121,
-0.8173809052,
-0.7706288695,
-0.7037516236,
-0.0156606399,
-0.2544690967,
-0.1318271011,
-0.0511382893,
0.1288647205,
-0.0167938173,
0.0734258592,
-0.5600683689,
-0.264159888,
0.205961436,
-0.3819953799,
0.8273358345,
0.4708393514,
0.3179851472,
0.23408629,
-0.3670863509,
0.0714171007,
-0.5796937943,
-0.5072832704,
0.0854984522,
0.5686718822,
0.3727221191,
0.5766454935,
-0.0513743833,
0.7836897373,
-0.1225447059,
0.0823325738,
0.0851258785,
-0.6849282384,
-0.1789486706,
0.3549472988,
0.6238229871,
0.2337689251,
0.1948712915,
-0.4676104188,
-0.3993677795,
0.1589578688,
0.4457392991,
-0.4776082337,
-0.1406519264,
0.6618719101,
-0.1206040382,
-0.2604807615,
0.0552720539,
-0.3565218747,
-0.7367861271,
-0.2815589607,
0.3454927206,
-0.6439795494,
-0.5904257894,
0.1616417319,
-0.2134944499,
0.0401154272,
0.5490634441,
-0.4263655841,
0.2234351039,
0.8174809813,
0.5316910744,
-0.14955616,
-0.6701231003,
-0.7277879119,
0.6009949446,
-0.4346861243,
1.1242072582,
-0.4017346203,
-0.3369883895,
-0.1133464277,
0.0789135844,
-0.2809985578,
-0.516074419,
0.2395449579,
-0.2723302245,
-0.0060696895,
-0.2134515792,
-0.656521678,
0.3016894758,
0.2896598876,
-0.7531429529,
0.9633657336,
0.2786435187,
-0.4284221232,
0.5665844083,
-0.3603151739,
-0.1380690187,
0.130283609,
-0.2605287135,
-0.6296089888,
0.103891097,
-0.0235875007,
0.2915231287,
-0.4231635034,
0.3091207147,
-0.3033832312,
-0.551422298,
0.2060437053,
0.1082389057,
0.4849546552,
0.0901729837,
-0.4370283484,
0.2269506902,
-1.0181083679,
0.3189741075,
0.2717456818,
-0.1941593885,
-0.1750083715,
0.1782442778,
0.1345628947,
0.0939389542,
-0.0479269661,
-0.7144750953,
-0.196905151,
-0.7091169953,
0.3018652201,
0.7456784844,
-0.128877461,
0.2108780295,
-0.5447447896,
0.1255634427,
0.1882325262,
0.0071416367,
-0.2014342993,
-0.1041017473,
-0.8298572898,
-0.3773856759,
0.0051693306,
0.4772200584,
-0.7267118096,
0.4768185914,
-0.2530490756,
-0.6062748432,
-0.2885819077,
0.1433603615,
0.3483213186,
0.3614871204,
0.3877995014,
0.0555989891,
-0.2912694812,
-0.6666243672,
-0.7556057572,
-0.3299610913,
0.3032833636,
0.2482962906,
0.3093823791,
-0.3362158239,
1.090244174,
-0.4578792155,
-0.6388478279,
-0.1155110374,
-0.0243785009,
0.1250763237,
0.488795042,
0.5058258772,
-0.5785214901,
-0.511054635,
0.1975594163,
-0.4964919686,
0.1234191507,
-0.05943406,
-0.3050740957,
0.7727812529,
0.3433968723,
-0.6393470764,
0.260196507,
0.060508661,
-0.7857583165,
0.5394778252,
-0.1775083691,
0.2790431082,
-1.1742604971,
-0.1279806346,
-0.4320959151,
-0.3856799603,
-0.5675062537,
-0.0837940499,
-0.1679865867,
-0.158302173,
-0.4619298577,
0.1779832095,
-0.414994657,
0.1785862595,
-0.1981907934,
0.026593294,
0.1906633973,
0.0668853372,
-0.0540931672,
0.8955967426,
0.0092335884,
-0.2069195062,
0.5939612389,
0.4009514153,
0.1349521875,
0.8521683216,
-0.7409059405,
0.3208211958,
-0.117537275,
0.0906655937,
-1.3183190823,
-0.3626362383,
-0.1693567783,
-0.4660023749,
0.0163780265,
-0.1336134225,
-0.6190674305,
0.0913360119,
-0.1994544417,
0.0091476543,
-0.0308866575,
-0.6238162518,
1.0022236109,
0.1624648869,
-0.0185733717,
-0.7351980805,
-0.7514139414,
0.1944569796,
0.0990873501,
-1.0891467333,
0.3550482094,
0.3561717868,
-0.2870917022,
0.1994125843,
0.0152614117,
-0.2935171425,
0.0060965312,
-0.0053460402,
0.2870896757,
-0.3202483058,
0.4949070811,
0.0950175375,
-0.0844645053,
-0.019965075,
-0.2066491544,
0.409620285,
-0.2400583774,
-0.4418085814,
0.1730260849,
0.5588888526,
0.5119760036,
-0.3832609057,
0.9949002862,
0.597209096,
-0.3750686049,
-0.4770402312,
-0.7727706432,
-0.3535296023,
-0.454967767,
0.3843453526,
-0.2883853614,
-0.7639593482,
0.2772845924,
-0.1434291154,
0.0712118968,
0.4519371092,
0.2674900591,
0.2594107985,
1.373649478,
0.6984616518,
0.3885260522,
0.0292113014,
0.1245479435,
0.140299052,
0.0569523722,
-0.2443738133,
-0.7611328363,
0.2724126279,
-0.2615458071,
-0.2555673718,
0.3073022962,
-0.2539047301,
-0.3947462738,
0.4204077423,
-0.6129466295,
0.688411355,
0.14051494,
0.0778179392,
0.3884331584,
0.2621774971,
-0.3326674104,
-0.0090610981,
-0.6158311963,
-0.4501226544,
0.7047922611,
-0.1479544938,
0.7405636907,
0.535790205,
0.8615575433,
0.3722173572,
-0.12384478,
-0.4647256732,
0.5439985394,
-0.0415790491,
-0.4492222071,
-0.2964615226,
-0.3845938742,
-0.9193561673,
0.3680049777,
-0.5771057606,
-0.4520863891,
0.0612570047,
0.2497052848,
-0.1613948643,
0.1236929297,
-0.9340006709,
0.9783949852,
-0.0504740961,
-0.9694046974,
-0.4616445601,
-0.6037750244,
0.1184735224,
-0.2988156974,
0.0307902396,
-0.1552212089,
-0.2164790183,
0.1415558904,
-1.1461240053,
0.725687921,
-0.2899852395,
-0.0233995691,
0.2455152273,
0.2292526364,
0.6802526116,
-0.0351108722,
-0.3113803864,
-0.0823171437,
0.2984841466,
-0.5101306438,
-0.5022760034,
0.7043148875,
-0.6599785686,
-0.3530786037,
-0.582257092,
-0.5496745706,
-0.3206170201,
0.3386102021,
-0.2318665832,
0.3162089884,
-0.4089652002,
-0.104937017,
0.4647891819,
-0.0866727084,
0.2382004559,
0.6607307196,
0.0087891016,
-0.3771081865,
0.966583252,
-0.1817703098,
0.0573719293,
0.185149312,
-0.0758016855,
-0.332177192,
-0.3262419105,
-0.4543144107,
0.4886742532,
-0.491568923,
-0.4633670449,
-0.7096170783,
-0.0011767771,
-0.4198290706,
-0.1716063321,
-0.5691049695,
-0.3751166761,
-0.1927662641,
0.2216327488,
0.453569144,
0.6874662042,
0.1925482452,
0.2964513302,
-1.1712334156,
-0.340651691,
0.0945325345,
0.2664188445,
-0.2765716016,
0.1246643066,
-0.0425375253,
0.0349785835,
-0.2317421734,
-0.7353501916,
0.2224875242,
0.5633350611,
0.6370175481,
-0.1104582176,
0.1488638818,
0.6957559586,
-0.5641383529,
0.842617929,
0.2911482453,
-0.9762428403,
0.8088468313,
-0.2443623394,
0.0735717192,
0.7052403688,
-0.1057764143,
-0.187854439,
-0.6292483807,
-0.4985594749,
-0.8637670279,
0.8317649961,
0.2468749732,
-0.0646303594,
-0.2076246142,
0.3814999163,
0.1586772949,
0.0852001831,
-0.1764522046,
-0.0014153072,
-0.2568883002,
-0.3309948742,
-0.0179191194,
-0.1332974583,
-0.0466057062,
0.1685691178,
0.8012754321,
-0.5988194942,
0.1962113082,
0.2595732808,
-0.2922671437,
-0.1770717204,
0.3678877354,
0.3658183217,
0.9163585901,
-0.1214791462,
0.0162896011,
0.2314589471,
-0.4015505016,
0.2330905199,
0.3057971597,
0.4794090986,
0.0733985603,
0.3646585047,
0.223581031,
-0.2466973513,
-0.9651899934,
0.729578495,
-0.4235394299,
0.043119356,
-0.4971404076,
0.3199068308,
0.1338311583,
0.1863903105,
0.1500365585,
0.2235769928,
0.230397284,
-0.2215728909,
0.4522052705,
0.4895009696,
-0.5582675338,
-0.0395931229,
0.7366467118,
0.2963718474,
-0.117644906,
0.8360800147,
0.09775538,
-0.2318215668,
0.5616257191,
0.6026655436,
0.7122291327,
-0.3263319433,
0.2384535968,
0.2273325324,
0.1561414897,
-0.0116879782,
0.4580498338,
0.1117486507,
-0.985573411,
-0.4657735527,
-0.459038049,
-0.3529267907,
-0.4291099906,
-0.2996151149,
0.4142380059,
-0.2330781668,
-0.2358249128,
0.2767436504,
-0.107330583,
-0.1298224926,
0.0045781909,
-0.5123836398,
0.8899940252,
-0.7096275687,
0.7315140367,
0.9743017554,
-0.4687961042,
-0.8035919666,
-0.2694875002,
0.2696146667,
-0.672591269,
0.3310196102,
0.14613837,
-0.3898385167,
0.0596462078,
-0.5082298517,
-0.4464943111,
1.0883033276,
0.6887290478,
-0.4418997467,
0.1656876951,
0.6536099911,
0.4903149903,
-0.3711868227,
0.3887383938,
0.6746046543,
0.2320725769,
0.2240154147,
-0.7997238636,
0.2957344353,
-0.1696538925,
0.0715631172,
0.5924466252,
-0.6909211278,
0.6549248099,
-0.3591966033,
-0.0099842763,
0.2108382285,
0.4669544995,
0.4834314883,
0.1895657778,
0.7878754139,
0.4965296686,
0.7081199884,
-0.1835711151,
0.8552289605,
-0.1944707483,
0.3001504838,
1.0560557842,
-0.7355883718,
0.6911200881,
0.4926157296,
-0.1353513598,
0.4758481383,
0.0876660496,
0.1155577078,
0.1922041327,
-0.0029741565,
-0.4661889374,
-0.6480258703,
-0.4495610297,
-0.2229342312,
0.4609442055,
0.2891309559,
-0.3398571908,
-0.5256525278,
-0.3432686925,
0.0710912794,
0.5156808496,
0.0485860631,
0.9461757541,
-0.1541787833,
-0.6685122848,
0.6060872674,
-0.1041465551,
0.1713217646,
-0.5793955922,
-0.4247389734,
-0.1821018308,
0.8342445493,
-0.4881905615,
-0.6488630176,
0.6372826695,
-0.3634076118,
-0.1219347566,
0.1279238462,
1.2201215029,
-0.5275959969,
-0.197641924,
0.4304112494,
0.6397281289,
-0.0523519255,
-0.2737148404,
-0.8604953885,
0.109749794,
-0.0130847963,
0.2311779261,
0.1677872092,
0.4130311608,
0.0646118224,
0.3912028074,
0.6426320672,
-0.0648799166,
-0.0745968968,
0.0532789975,
0.9224845767,
-0.5499972105,
-0.2506860793,
-0.8372699618,
0.5276488066,
-0.4910324514,
0.040472094,
0.4796661735,
0.7244418859,
0.5304154158,
-0.0833329856,
0.5160411596,
0.0760338381,
0.7578700781,
-0.3156630397,
0.9653663039,
-0.6603121758,
0.4029466212,
-0.2004680783,
-1.0938379765,
-0.3124464154,
0.3162343204,
0.3435092568,
-0.0552739538,
0.7271107435,
1.3591725826,
0.1166747808,
0.2755532265,
0.3980473578,
0.3737277389,
0.4032355249,
0.4800736606,
0.9633854032,
-0.4186351299,
0.8414040804,
0.0343702026,
-0.2994351387,
0.0847377628,
-0.8266682625,
-0.8777198195,
-0.4000654817,
-0.4120014608,
-0.7984751463,
0.4103347361,
1.1713047028,
0.5316584706,
-0.8078367114,
-0.2038886398,
-0.441005677,
0.2062617242,
-0.3249728084,
-0.2628338933,
0.1886550188,
-0.8401530981,
-0.4692474008,
0.3242338002,
0.2513707578,
-0.1847881973,
-0.0296748392,
0.0551585555,
-0.2602144182,
0.2527107,
0.6081389189,
-0.1420550346,
-0.5147234201,
-0.3937284946,
-0.0475498848,
-0.234623909,
-0.1990570575,
0.5244144797,
-0.7206556797,
0.3452265859,
0.5034254789,
0.8235055804,
0.2191540003,
-0.0849177092,
0.7554736137,
-0.792224586,
-0.1406522095,
0.1008598134,
0.3109725714,
0.3478733599,
-0.5867809057,
0.8755648732,
0.4724169374,
-0.7179200649,
-0.7623026371,
0.1206672564,
-0.7882269025,
-0.3390440047,
0.9998875856,
-0.0619738176,
-0.599361062,
-0.4381908178,
-0.4441600144,
-0.0359097831,
-0.4182046056,
0.3445741832,
0.443148315,
-0.2140987515,
0.1121049449,
0.2153502852,
0.4914916456,
0.5301184058,
-0.7823265791,
0.1671896726,
0.890045166,
0.5064001083,
0.1610511988,
0.6034117937,
-0.2388728857,
0.4672336578,
0.3059575558,
0.0567559823,
-0.1545188129,
-0.0055737095,
-0.0474278927,
0.0493659042,
0.1166918948,
0.2015664726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13397v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13397v1 | MoreHopQA: More Than Multi-hop Reasoning | 2024-06-19T09:38:59 | 2024-06-19T09:38:59 | Julian Schnitzler, Xanh Ho, Jiahao Huang, Florian Boudin, Saku Sugawara, Akiko Aizawa | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most existing multi-hop datasets are extractive answer datasets, where the
answers to the questions can be extracted directly from the provided context.
This often leads models to use heuristics or shortcuts instead of performing
true multi-hop reasoning. In this paper, we propose a new multi-hop dataset,
MoreHopQA, which shifts from extractive to generative answers. Our dataset is
created by utilizing three existing multi-hop datasets: HotpotQA,
2WikiMultihopQA, and MuSiQue. Instead of relying solely on factual reasoning,
we enhance the existing multi-hop questions by adding another layer of
questioning that involves one, two, or all three of the following types of
reasoning: commonsense, arithmetic, and symbolic. Our dataset is created
through a semi-automated process, resulting in a dataset with 1,118 samples
that have undergone human verification. We then use our dataset to evaluate
five different large language models: Mistral 7B, Gemma 7B, Llama 3 (8B and
70B), and GPT-4. We also design various cases to analyze the reasoning steps in
the question-answering process. Our results show that models perform well on
initial multi-hop questions but struggle with our extended questions,
indicating that our dataset is more challenging than previous ones. Our
analysis of question decomposition reveals that although models can correctly
answer questions, only a portion - 38.7% for GPT-4 and 33.4% for Llama3-70B -
achieve perfect reasoning, where all corresponding sub-questions are answered
correctly. Evaluation code and data are available at
https://github.com/Alab-NII/morehopqa | [
-0.6315352917,
-0.8624867797,
0.6520036459,
0.2933147848,
0.1208291799,
0.3822507858,
-0.0030895036,
-0.388448149,
-0.0758385733,
0.4700310826,
-0.7041870952,
-0.1628660709,
-0.4698125422,
0.1715537757,
-0.3475455046,
0.6184262037,
0.0320010185,
-0.2460075766,
-0.0598936006,
-0.1400311738,
-0.5171352625,
-0.5181120634,
-0.4871406853,
-0.16206415,
0.3665695488,
0.585180521,
0.7422202229,
0.1758784652,
0.3450477421,
0.2148085833,
-0.1534816623,
0.3686537147,
0.0076069767,
0.1102982014,
0.2187933624,
-0.4039514959,
-0.3217960298,
0.0046520438,
0.2807108462,
0.5584382415,
-0.0860832259,
0.359064132,
-0.5395356417,
0.6600655913,
-0.5186745524,
0.0345255211,
-0.4440526366,
-0.2034805268,
-0.1886260957,
-0.0924845263,
-0.4359011054,
-0.6230788231,
0.0214657057,
-0.6781772375,
-0.0222215001,
0.0028263074,
0.755608201,
0.2474043518,
-0.7551644444,
-0.2762125432,
-0.6285931468,
0.5862631798,
-0.5345168114,
0.7700282931,
0.3879572451,
0.7051042318,
0.0136897359,
-0.6238721609,
-0.8052974343,
-0.1518745869,
0.2015760839,
0.2772955894,
-0.094048284,
-0.3854121864,
0.5148617625,
0.2229036987,
-0.6940151453,
-0.3747465014,
-0.4276553988,
-0.3077190816,
0.4739256799,
0.1140607819,
0.2621338069,
-0.3533519506,
-0.199609831,
-0.3311584294,
-0.730968833,
0.2381764501,
0.3214435875,
0.3397799432,
-0.0192413535,
0.6127026677,
-0.3303130567,
0.8153893352,
-0.1008487716,
-0.1981106699,
0.5731059909,
-0.3308508098,
-0.0765945315,
-0.3199744821,
0.4581038356,
0.0410488471,
0.508387208,
-0.0159773808,
0.3119217753,
-0.1103532091,
-0.0591372661,
-0.5498636365,
-0.5553324819,
0.6499701738,
-0.266400516,
-0.0791465864,
-0.1176177785,
-0.5247116685,
-0.3360708952,
-0.2992073894,
0.3226517439,
-0.7687120438,
-0.4771814644,
0.3148540556,
-0.384137243,
0.6380692124,
0.4923548996,
-0.4399439692,
0.1069588289,
0.7439970374,
0.9077566862,
0.0686434582,
-0.5158618093,
-0.4675334394,
0.0554361902,
-0.5284588337,
0.7529910803,
-0.7264615893,
0.104009673,
-0.3215493858,
0.0031078451,
-0.2131235749,
-0.3280071914,
0.7598128319,
-1.0578340292,
0.3549592495,
-0.7119634151,
-0.472448945,
-0.400423497,
0.5684645176,
-0.917185545,
1.0188162327,
0.044350341,
-0.8678612113,
0.3198543787,
-0.7912428975,
-0.5836522579,
-0.0211013574,
-0.0554869287,
-0.1523442119,
-0.1208020151,
0.6678775549,
0.1762887836,
-0.5432129502,
0.3849425316,
-0.2740638852,
-0.1951321661,
0.3102485538,
-0.6604593992,
1.3642840385,
0.3070591986,
-0.1696786284,
-0.1951057017,
-0.8737276196,
0.2911397219,
0.1248778403,
-0.5339804292,
-0.0977326483,
-0.339705497,
-0.1470419466,
0.5679113865,
-0.2806891501,
-0.6717045307,
0.3365145326,
-0.1225329936,
0.4455636144,
0.4467616379,
0.0519849174,
0.1496570706,
-0.418020159,
0.7385428548,
-0.0784123689,
0.1571151018,
-0.2607890069,
-0.9738804102,
-0.672703445,
-0.2808903158,
0.256597966,
0.600472331,
-0.834725976,
0.0589174293,
-0.3414993286,
-0.3795462847,
-0.5321092606,
-0.1542584151,
0.0225255582,
0.5341935158,
0.6574559212,
0.2002721429,
-0.4149476886,
-0.4876383841,
0.0146046728,
-0.0955851302,
-0.0642460361,
0.3207701743,
0.5487185717,
-0.0221031252,
0.8305384517,
-0.4712796211,
0.1438391805,
-0.3521597087,
0.3180923164,
0.3780968189,
0.1542066634,
0.3281913996,
-0.8251639009,
-0.3675327599,
-0.2818127573,
-0.5551817417,
0.0131023759,
-0.3105211854,
-0.2452220619,
-0.4573327005,
0.410438776,
-0.8953883648,
-0.0173342526,
0.3897616267,
-0.1462876797,
0.7795211077,
0.2121467888,
0.3747463524,
-1.0874334574,
-0.1317380816,
-0.3266950846,
-0.0964583308,
-0.6216917634,
0.3947392404,
0.1502476931,
-0.017826831,
-0.2626706362,
0.4459251761,
-0.6429357529,
-0.156575039,
-0.1947194338,
-0.1625956744,
0.5137971044,
0.5393594503,
0.256829083,
0.7583250999,
0.8432948589,
-0.5826968551,
0.82736063,
0.6931685209,
-0.5267167687,
0.118856065,
-0.7238144875,
0.2940174341,
-0.2318154871,
0.5872329473,
-1.1007144451,
-0.4717142582,
0.1076831445,
-0.7009924054,
-0.1295037866,
-0.4364371896,
-0.5425459146,
-0.5779334307,
-0.3562033176,
0.694771111,
0.2321015447,
-0.7539384961,
0.5435906053,
0.052219294,
-0.2121216506,
-0.5788012147,
-0.6304044127,
0.1577455252,
-0.2423996776,
-0.8280308843,
-0.0413837954,
-0.1189637855,
-0.1921538413,
-0.232851699,
0.172549203,
-0.3430452347,
-0.0446013995,
-0.052975025,
0.2508171797,
-0.2206093371,
0.2338324189,
0.1646101773,
-0.1513884664,
0.0547974855,
-0.2443755716,
0.6912902594,
-0.0915454999,
-0.7134047151,
-0.2901001871,
0.5158612728,
0.7068430185,
-0.6118430495,
0.491853416,
0.7067742348,
-0.2141146958,
0.2228435725,
-0.4854682684,
0.0082897367,
-0.384904474,
0.1238184571,
-0.825048089,
-0.7753421664,
0.4209060371,
-0.1645279527,
0.2770255804,
0.2627172172,
0.7203458548,
-0.0509262905,
1.0392252207,
0.2510885596,
0.0859998837,
-0.1088630036,
-0.3842967451,
0.186632067,
-0.9754271507,
-0.3915618956,
-0.4798541069,
-0.0134889856,
-0.5440052748,
-0.7742646337,
0.4302200973,
-0.0717270821,
-0.4696833491,
0.3987427652,
-0.1466171145,
0.441025883,
0.7781764269,
-0.0949760377,
0.4791462421,
-0.2258152813,
0.0139346262,
0.3588671088,
-0.697968781,
-0.2218374461,
1.2107651234,
0.3290116787,
0.5807954669,
0.5707857013,
0.529530406,
-0.099434033,
-0.012289457,
-0.7349110842,
0.066784136,
0.3317122757,
-1.1253765821,
-0.4383645952,
-0.5794622898,
-0.6246998906,
0.3351631165,
-0.0596256293,
-0.5475382209,
0.3317171037,
-0.0006878137,
-0.7739179134,
0.1361207068,
-0.7585645318,
0.5251960158,
-0.4429505765,
-0.2188226581,
0.325104177,
-0.8559952378,
0.7680917382,
0.0689601526,
0.4569602013,
-0.2499051392,
0.3846698403,
0.6196359992,
-0.3108724654,
0.3761199713,
-0.090874657,
-0.152898252,
0.6085921526,
0.0852728412,
0.2962170243,
0.2531301081,
-0.1314986348,
-0.0723795369,
0.2892065048,
-0.5013635159,
-0.7038670182,
0.3366487622,
-0.7098682523,
-0.3831940889,
-0.3199385703,
-0.5157820582,
-0.7258673906,
0.0544745661,
0.3043705821,
0.6453199983,
0.3885395229,
0.0667377338,
0.5937399864,
-0.3681978583,
0.3079055548,
0.2245587856,
-0.1301638633,
-0.3997136056,
0.7177599669,
-0.1978579313,
0.2321446389,
0.3733070493,
0.4930969775,
-0.7506895661,
-0.3718652427,
-0.7976148725,
0.0144049842,
-0.72113204,
-0.3157824874,
-0.8909038901,
-0.1645696163,
-0.7518045902,
0.2299614102,
-0.3428747952,
-0.7222318053,
0.307678014,
-0.2854933739,
0.4754118323,
0.4353379607,
-0.2436884493,
0.2789883912,
-0.9264020324,
0.8859820366,
0.6845445037,
0.2591109574,
0.113408573,
-0.7691881061,
0.1734815389,
0.0205472708,
-0.1365531087,
-1.2674176693,
0.1244288906,
0.328258276,
0.4016005695,
0.1925953627,
0.0504614152,
0.8268627524,
-0.4783343673,
0.6809853315,
0.1121594012,
-0.7678694129,
0.278973192,
-0.2592360675,
0.3156039417,
0.7047709823,
0.6921812892,
-0.5436978936,
0.017287286,
-0.4120232761,
-0.7906740308,
0.5565899014,
0.3492428362,
0.1998201013,
0.0505868345,
0.2546252012,
0.290564388,
0.1112167835,
-0.896568954,
-0.2299578637,
-0.3548073173,
0.2091661543,
0.1973883212,
-0.2508755326,
-0.0924721658,
-0.5629773736,
0.6444295049,
-0.1661905497,
0.2202702314,
-0.1646600813,
-0.1424536407,
0.329046309,
0.4617931545,
0.0613157749,
0.6016047001,
-0.0608490519,
0.1857418269,
-0.0598831587,
-0.1747969389,
0.2604805827,
0.0030547997,
-0.1407513767,
-0.2162439376,
0.7752117515,
0.6359816194,
-0.4830151796,
-0.565629065,
0.7145450115,
-0.2221740335,
-0.3268300593,
-0.1729447991,
-0.1622364372,
0.2707291543,
0.3644527793,
0.1887104511,
-0.0043905885,
0.4389049709,
-0.6967097521,
0.4408196807,
0.2450685948,
0.0413355157,
-0.2121873498,
0.5375754237,
0.0465761423,
-0.0317989215,
0.8816692233,
-0.4541508555,
-0.6622498035,
0.4054729939,
0.4752036929,
0.5021924973,
-0.0677522719,
0.6282500029,
0.5549183488,
0.3888663948,
-0.1005132943,
0.6484885216,
-0.2842132151,
-0.9903889298,
-0.8812047243,
-0.5383352637,
-0.4468275309,
0.3531292677,
-0.519752562,
0.1438014507,
-0.2636856139,
0.0789789036,
-0.0072047897,
-0.1677443087,
-0.562320888,
0.3760480583,
0.0657785609,
0.9835874438,
-1.1855307817,
0.6079673767,
0.5490487218,
-0.5073882937,
-1.0999279022,
0.2496952564,
0.0104828542,
-0.7538238764,
0.3783279061,
0.1576284319,
-0.1503798813,
-0.0544726774,
-0.6317552328,
-1.0871915817,
0.7305775285,
0.4335203171,
-0.2658182085,
-0.0617070533,
0.1726917624,
0.3882566988,
0.1001728624,
0.6589626074,
0.9153748155,
0.6538700461,
0.7741664648,
-0.7096943259,
-0.2099481821,
-0.4108698964,
-0.5502380729,
-0.0951639265,
-0.5998389721,
1.0855902433,
-0.5303808451,
0.0121015077,
-0.0759132206,
0.3194122314,
0.5350011587,
0.1588683873,
0.3376695514,
0.5677758455,
0.874556601,
-0.0853671059,
0.9623803496,
0.0233230852,
0.1121846735,
1.4414452314,
-0.1737225503,
0.6497517228,
0.2399291992,
-0.3234483004,
0.5305062532,
0.8389068246,
0.2592698932,
0.3733584881,
0.1954459846,
0.0147402193,
-0.6985585093,
0.243874222,
-0.3925653994,
0.8902003765,
0.0248732381,
0.3504111767,
-0.2080356032,
-0.0553848557,
-0.0832957625,
-0.2388311476,
0.210600093,
0.6020653248,
-0.1696939617,
-0.5389877558,
0.5635148287,
0.1532702446,
0.3164262176,
-0.2810916305,
-0.2142815143,
-0.2788794041,
-0.3625100255,
-0.1861810684,
-0.8185853362,
0.234067753,
0.1853987575,
0.0496939793,
0.0210595131,
0.3107472658,
-0.1626643687,
-0.8323408365,
0.0523237064,
1.0507794619,
0.204762876,
-0.326397419,
-0.7494433522,
-0.120225139,
-0.1006653979,
-0.2051384002,
-0.2459103167,
0.633812964,
-0.2922968566,
0.874546349,
0.7220937014,
0.1293240488,
0.5241712332,
0.5545951128,
0.8404355645,
-0.5354644656,
-0.4625991285,
-0.5511769652,
0.3502942026,
-0.1083335429,
-0.2423433959,
0.7009832859,
0.6616552472,
0.628631115,
0.1625686139,
1.0639021397,
-0.2848238051,
0.7501038909,
-0.4904868007,
0.0602679998,
-0.4503824711,
0.279096961,
-0.5952656269,
-0.7198666334,
-0.1466796249,
0.6788753271,
-0.2394805402,
0.2478440106,
0.5409148932,
0.5306989551,
-0.2299515605,
0.2200304419,
0.2435698509,
-0.0800957307,
0.6275559068,
0.8503012657,
1.4766021967,
-0.5617423058,
0.6192551851,
-0.2888785303,
-0.3922303617,
0.3036532402,
-0.8072963953,
-0.7427372932,
-0.6936600804,
-0.1839249432,
0.0058626523,
-0.207851544,
0.7064151168,
0.6674312353,
-0.9323485494,
0.0522472672,
-0.1011007056,
0.1274403036,
-0.3615770936,
-0.2168678343,
0.4453928471,
-0.1241188794,
-0.516441226,
0.4709604084,
0.0921551436,
-0.2015805542,
0.0449864678,
0.0351430811,
-0.3736682236,
0.0791583881,
0.765602529,
0.1420891583,
-0.3721228242,
-0.3692038059,
0.439963907,
0.4935520291,
0.2109246403,
0.8945333958,
-0.590473175,
0.3284537196,
0.5597297549,
0.8083161712,
0.5108867884,
0.398163259,
0.2019557953,
-0.6287958622,
-0.1342006326,
0.2839950919,
0.2278295755,
0.4200417995,
-0.1908555627,
0.2355725467,
0.0825558305,
-0.1795707494,
-0.4231611192,
0.6995093822,
-0.7664657831,
-0.3787806928,
1.3889210224,
-0.0061548492,
0.1104835048,
-0.6001834869,
-0.2545262873,
0.1777702719,
-0.2203087509,
0.6805824637,
0.7639119029,
-0.7513879538,
-0.4124581218,
-0.5269038677,
0.4911376536,
0.1548565328,
-1.0938532352,
0.3774542212,
0.8602800369,
0.3170965612,
0.2098184228,
0.8676200509,
-0.2585550249,
0.4634291828,
0.0213401914,
-0.3425045609,
-0.2559387684,
-0.854953289,
-0.0707137361,
0.448027581,
0.1790941507,
-0.2479123175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13381v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13381v1 | CoAct: A Global-Local Hierarchy for Autonomous Agent Collaboration | 2024-06-19T09:23:53 | 2024-06-19T09:23:53 | Xinming Hou, Mingming Yang, Wenxiang Jiao, Xing Wang, Zhaopeng Tu, Wayne Xin Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing LLMs exhibit remarkable performance on various NLP tasks, but still
struggle with complex real-world tasks, even equipped with advanced strategies
like CoT and ReAct. In this work, we propose the CoAct framework, which
transfers the hierarchical planning and collaboration patterns in human society
to LLM systems. Specifically, our CoAct framework involves two agents: (1) A
global planning agent, to comprehend the problem scope, formulate macro-level
plans and provide detailed sub-task descriptions to local execution agents,
which serves as the initial rendition of a global plan. (2) A local execution
agent, to operate within the multi-tier task execution structure, focusing on
detailed execution and implementation of specific tasks within the global plan.
Experimental results on the WebArena benchmark show that CoAct can re-arrange
the process trajectory when facing failures, and achieves superior performance
over baseline methods on long-horizon web tasks. Code is available at
https://github.com/xmhou2002/CoAct. | [
-0.4012087882,
-0.5791934133,
0.5272601843,
0.3353317082,
0.2718885541,
0.7031203508,
0.1048135832,
-0.7371414304,
0.4895354807,
0.6208053827,
-0.9752044082,
-0.5513638258,
-0.192448616,
0.0514633916,
-0.3150795698,
0.8992119431,
0.0320069045,
-0.4609217942,
-0.5447731018,
0.1373569965,
-0.4974959493,
-0.6761654615,
-0.9398871064,
-0.6270002723,
0.4095826447,
0.4732815921,
0.8783498406,
0.7579294443,
0.6673415899,
0.3864885569,
0.1111245826,
0.5858978629,
-0.3777016997,
0.2451893389,
-0.3045617342,
-0.3652316928,
-1.0355489254,
-0.1958186924,
0.3260860145,
0.7194818854,
-0.1388129443,
-0.0984113216,
0.2504795194,
0.6124874353,
-0.6117072105,
0.3827688992,
-0.5658815503,
0.1627295762,
0.3312272429,
-0.3126641512,
-0.3354113698,
0.0612940006,
0.1990470886,
-0.8039594293,
0.0889648423,
0.0948024988,
0.3165506721,
0.4188077748,
-0.4605396688,
-0.1841337383,
-0.7525770068,
0.6316691637,
-0.142261982,
-0.1058794037,
0.4582286775,
0.0754885301,
-0.5714917779,
-1.0008647442,
-0.1701381803,
-0.1003723368,
-0.1503506154,
0.2752340436,
-0.2350614071,
0.2332959473,
-0.2986391485,
0.0833137631,
-0.8002473712,
0.142410323,
-0.0241936594,
-0.1958151162,
0.6097795367,
0.5965737104,
0.1948892623,
0.1474563181,
-0.7814489603,
0.4233709574,
-0.5411498547,
0.1600242108,
-0.0941438749,
0.33488217,
-0.513213098,
0.1246155351,
-0.4235154688,
0.5574674606,
-0.016169427,
0.0471288562,
-0.0699967891,
-0.4847633839,
-0.2935239375,
-0.0933834836,
0.6615770459,
0.3053959012,
0.1604866087,
-0.4357047677,
-0.0108917579,
0.1554919928,
0.483638972,
-0.3264505565,
-0.248255536,
0.4905609787,
-0.1884064227,
-0.3698265254,
0.0444672517,
-0.3390026391,
-0.4870815575,
-0.4052951932,
0.1145359278,
-0.1956973672,
0.0419379435,
-0.0720129237,
0.2319723964,
0.0630148351,
0.4773752987,
-0.5733396411,
0.8158124089,
1.1113209724,
1.1759754419,
-0.6109254956,
-0.6176003814,
-0.7574325204,
0.4975213706,
-0.3022861183,
1.0119003057,
-0.0474969409,
-0.4681417942,
0.1070104688,
-0.0605826713,
0.0088181952,
-0.5188308954,
0.58119452,
-0.2657624483,
-0.2048405707,
-0.1768406481,
-0.1733736396,
0.0351362713,
0.2746854126,
-0.6226121187,
0.6889501214,
-0.067624718,
-0.5660648942,
0.0459884852,
-0.8309052587,
-0.7515287995,
0.2566985488,
-0.1712867469,
-0.0532034561,
-0.5532910228,
0.137359336,
0.8097736835,
-0.3939570189,
0.081015259,
-0.070036374,
-0.4444342852,
-0.1110447794,
0.1421549618,
0.8715564609,
0.2364097685,
-0.3495740592,
0.4962920845,
-0.7398462892,
0.1639173478,
-0.200256303,
-0.1688416153,
-0.0800569654,
0.1842816621,
-0.2079472691,
0.3745453954,
0.45733881,
-0.1690368652,
0.5930080414,
-0.1037437916,
0.5933129787,
0.7899404764,
0.1323803961,
0.8996675611,
-0.9054473042,
0.5717874169,
-0.4210817516,
0.4031097591,
0.1232149974,
-0.5066321492,
-0.7223851085,
-0.5135768056,
-0.4072627723,
0.7501947284,
-0.7908098102,
0.6955837607,
-0.3415589929,
-0.448486656,
-0.1886529922,
0.0662255809,
0.2732610106,
0.5079928637,
0.2749134302,
-0.267111659,
-0.836363852,
-0.8107615113,
0.34275949,
-0.3414450288,
-0.1014205888,
-0.2044044733,
0.5798108578,
-0.3978742957,
1.235933423,
-0.3418091834,
-0.8372479677,
-0.3129751086,
0.3029789329,
0.0162219368,
0.3594697416,
0.137343064,
-0.8176741004,
-0.5559670925,
0.1748863459,
-0.8622666597,
-0.190683797,
-0.3255740404,
-0.3515591919,
0.4277642071,
0.4461436868,
-0.576218605,
0.3116587698,
0.7685638666,
-0.2211590409,
0.7308779955,
-0.1648295671,
0.1379968822,
-1.1972856522,
0.0292031858,
-0.4482984245,
-0.4453703761,
-0.5903870463,
0.2743709385,
-0.2812203765,
0.2494779229,
-0.6028450727,
0.3707582653,
-0.4895761311,
-0.2069874853,
-0.2748932838,
0.211056456,
-0.0084728021,
0.6772796512,
0.0535654575,
0.8814894557,
0.4572628736,
-0.7132733464,
0.3453561664,
0.2918078601,
-0.2601560354,
0.6672389507,
-0.552529335,
0.3441376984,
0.4449044168,
0.5736299157,
-0.8065568209,
-0.1828097999,
0.079444319,
-0.323651582,
-0.2492705733,
-0.1209283471,
-0.6069734097,
-0.0732524842,
-0.2659032941,
0.145989731,
0.2039040923,
-0.3542505205,
0.9494865537,
0.4489049315,
0.0215999316,
-0.5964306593,
-0.8527650833,
0.2133021951,
0.177463606,
-1.0443229675,
0.6758055687,
-0.192043528,
-0.4659938514,
-0.0598387606,
-0.0597602725,
-0.2874809206,
0.0422792993,
0.7564765811,
0.0891420841,
0.2511389256,
-0.3910598457,
-0.2989865243,
-0.1896359921,
-0.0271020066,
-0.2058034688,
0.7072246671,
-0.2527101934,
-0.1265844703,
-0.5832647085,
0.5941551924,
0.6199561357,
-0.2962693274,
0.4461175799,
0.3417752981,
-0.1774996966,
-0.565469861,
-0.2281709015,
0.0986574292,
-0.5248993039,
0.14465487,
-0.4733134508,
-0.7758910656,
0.8487964869,
-0.1439229697,
0.1837208122,
0.018671276,
0.6920598745,
-0.2756400406,
0.698898375,
0.8622024059,
-0.2913911045,
0.211707741,
-0.6924484968,
-0.1772810966,
-0.7863100171,
-0.2148071378,
-0.2835843265,
-0.2442223877,
-0.3118075132,
-0.6683812737,
0.5001618862,
-0.2830439806,
-0.2486666739,
0.5224969387,
-0.486294806,
0.365750581,
0.5372481942,
-0.2600576878,
0.760989666,
-0.2026371956,
-0.208493039,
0.2800262272,
-0.8195473552,
-0.4447106421,
0.3213052452,
-0.0392591245,
0.6318602562,
0.0459547117,
0.8893347979,
0.710203588,
0.0390397608,
-0.7082315683,
0.8767535686,
0.0524152964,
-0.4071816206,
-0.1924278289,
-0.1322914958,
-1.4461132288,
0.2762690187,
-0.2498849034,
-0.8225249648,
0.1362674236,
-0.0477393121,
-0.2099018842,
0.3418442011,
-0.5092846155,
0.5765372515,
0.0194312707,
-0.4752367437,
-0.2578861415,
-0.8921639919,
0.1470493674,
0.0159328226,
0.5331729054,
0.0140126143,
-0.270057857,
0.3389201164,
-0.3215812445,
0.959803462,
0.3636655211,
-0.1071817204,
0.4461498857,
0.6570934057,
0.8110235929,
-0.2012605518,
-0.1822701395,
0.2297441512,
-0.2647994757,
-0.2197151631,
-0.588676393,
0.7535492182,
-0.8235800862,
-0.2513121068,
-0.497379005,
-0.9981282353,
-0.1195069551,
0.001398565,
0.1634651423,
0.2710824907,
-0.4037926495,
0.1870342642,
-0.1595072895,
0.3580635786,
0.537573874,
0.4186332822,
-0.0258360934,
-0.4526006281,
0.5394756794,
0.1271889806,
0.5467204452,
0.8003742099,
-0.2129251063,
0.1062996536,
-0.2962026,
0.1891768277,
-0.1930589229,
-0.6845985055,
-0.2317008078,
-0.4890463054,
-0.1954624504,
-0.420761764,
-0.8948358893,
-0.3964519501,
-0.309032023,
-0.0650491938,
0.0977337137,
-0.0656312257,
1.0115879774,
-0.1936426163,
0.378834337,
-0.4398438334,
0.3315228522,
-0.0163008086,
-0.0295403097,
-0.0000127412,
-0.0074510872,
-0.3257110119,
-0.0940577388,
-0.3864206076,
-0.4091502726,
0.4103016853,
-0.0124737732,
0.4358481467,
0.0238277204,
0.4153118432,
0.9175564051,
-0.4812229872,
0.6786181331,
-0.106268622,
-0.7971712351,
0.4466985464,
-0.5062699318,
0.4593084157,
0.4699350595,
0.4477159381,
-0.5387305021,
-0.6324133277,
-0.6124808192,
-1.0189187527,
0.5747287869,
0.4326449037,
-0.5345673561,
0.2565447986,
0.272277534,
-0.068807371,
0.0207387302,
-0.6070081592,
-0.3312000632,
0.3119550645,
0.0730596781,
0.1041729078,
0.2945336699,
-0.2902704477,
-0.1285932213,
0.4480347335,
-0.2702257335,
0.3712065816,
0.4474667907,
-0.0838721544,
-0.1396167427,
0.0916194692,
0.4283930957,
0.6459494233,
-0.1231504008,
0.4429651201,
0.0684378371,
-0.3746975064,
0.2235766351,
-0.2825142145,
-0.1218136176,
-0.7609111071,
0.9949692488,
0.0251169894,
0.1744877994,
-0.299423635,
0.1962697506,
0.0189763587,
-0.397193253,
-0.4372727573,
0.202258572,
0.1330758184,
0.4630597234,
0.545385778,
0.2188555747,
0.1135727242,
-0.7774945498,
0.5382698178,
0.3106123507,
-0.2109647393,
-0.2513369322,
0.5471291542,
0.4232686162,
-0.6491861939,
0.2872602642,
-0.3844093978,
-0.4564183652,
0.7616615295,
0.6658782959,
0.8798960447,
0.0223088712,
0.4353854656,
-0.1042130962,
0.3641704619,
0.1374469846,
0.2615815401,
-0.1548964828,
-0.5949724317,
-0.6602960825,
-0.3152810335,
-0.6494998932,
-0.2600573003,
-0.256023854,
0.2344000638,
-0.6099604368,
0.001297536,
-0.3378501534,
0.4781481028,
-0.389528513,
-0.0281736478,
-0.0775225312,
0.633641839,
-0.4203644395,
0.9209086895,
0.8110287189,
-0.2779369652,
-0.497748673,
0.0528120771,
0.2866280973,
-0.7984383702,
0.576825738,
-0.0868001431,
-0.7838762403,
0.0258916598,
-0.5080792308,
-1.0072948933,
1.4958893061,
0.2643376887,
-0.3185452223,
-0.2251425385,
0.255523026,
0.6757637858,
-0.7341787815,
-0.1015596762,
0.1156582311,
0.3470870852,
0.2569271028,
-1.0336513519,
0.2714614868,
-0.0333815068,
-0.3442417383,
-0.01906473,
-0.8777049184,
0.8942854404,
-0.2121209949,
-0.2651147246,
0.344288975,
0.7098222375,
0.2398028076,
0.1726885736,
0.6045033932,
0.0697661117,
0.6469621062,
0.0971098617,
0.9679307938,
-0.3672510087,
0.2444541901,
1.4168512821,
-0.5856500864,
0.8785178661,
0.1742741317,
-0.1057734266,
0.7538017035,
0.2713730633,
0.217498973,
0.4967176616,
-0.0910866931,
-0.2425903678,
-0.2525170445,
-0.3612554371,
0.1796622574,
0.4835745692,
0.1508644074,
0.4456214309,
-0.1664037257,
-0.2416083217,
0.133517608,
0.240404278,
-0.2946571112,
0.6891573071,
0.0890423208,
-0.8999283314,
0.5447179079,
-0.23531048,
0.7413820624,
-0.6939802766,
-0.197098285,
-0.0311919805,
0.4035969079,
-0.6339415312,
-0.8929937482,
0.5471326709,
-0.4670461714,
-0.0902463943,
-0.3420473039,
0.7741453052,
-0.2125074714,
0.121041961,
0.8259114623,
0.5214694738,
-0.0571907721,
-0.2224559337,
-0.7714689374,
0.1007938161,
-0.3001739979,
0.0950657353,
0.2885279655,
0.252992034,
-0.3572302163,
1.1570119858,
0.6825972199,
0.0424899012,
-0.0852371082,
-0.0798757821,
0.556867063,
-0.3579853475,
-0.7269555926,
-0.6795046926,
0.6308102608,
-0.0507457815,
-0.0860096738,
0.4599609673,
0.5778439641,
0.8332719803,
0.2089894712,
0.7068356872,
-0.2490544915,
0.1247304678,
-0.2892690301,
0.5868973136,
-0.5300857425,
0.1333704442,
-0.2529111505,
-0.6507338881,
-0.537080586,
0.7319776416,
0.0421220399,
-0.2603226006,
0.9425215125,
0.603777349,
0.2549004257,
-0.2143197805,
0.4256078899,
0.2586165071,
0.6251168847,
0.685908854,
0.7362142801,
0.0397745743,
0.6396855116,
-0.4479510784,
-0.2816839516,
0.030225547,
-0.9054703712,
-0.8204783797,
-0.9714890718,
-0.1303424835,
-0.0083899079,
0.193651408,
1.3973042965,
1.0580164194,
-0.3786243498,
-0.8614105582,
-0.379024148,
0.2911790013,
-0.4763020873,
-0.2539744377,
0.2635206878,
-0.406157285,
-0.5580713749,
0.6874501705,
0.3628683686,
-0.3319271803,
-0.3700054586,
-0.2496688962,
-0.6167412996,
-0.2298289537,
0.8273282647,
0.148204267,
-0.6024516821,
-0.2696294188,
0.0130870249,
-0.2801043987,
0.2424583137,
0.9759369493,
-0.8547040224,
0.046843145,
0.38715446,
0.3687248826,
0.4257211983,
0.0584608801,
0.7875258923,
-1.1311318874,
0.1844524145,
0.2757174075,
0.2175143808,
0.0272743329,
-0.5306394696,
1.1381967068,
0.1576519758,
-1.029512167,
-0.509688735,
0.3124341071,
-1.5734598637,
-0.285115689,
1.0516961813,
0.041358307,
-0.161333099,
-0.5651627183,
-0.3269680142,
0.195520103,
-0.5268542767,
0.6207285523,
0.4661739767,
-0.6998260021,
0.1923283488,
-0.5577607155,
0.4601255655,
0.0807471871,
-1.0147826672,
0.2283024341,
0.2848427892,
0.0403879024,
0.4434299171,
1.112822175,
0.263879776,
0.1308008879,
-0.1015481651,
0.3715025187,
-0.1697482169,
-0.6376385689,
0.0681129992,
0.3200594783,
-0.1523302644,
0.0521281771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13375v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13375v1 | ALiiCE: Evaluating Positional Fine-grained Citation Generation | 2024-06-19T09:16:14 | 2024-06-19T09:16:14 | Yilong Xu, Jinhua Gao, Xiaoming Yu, Baolong Bi, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) can enhance the credibility and verifiability by
generating text with citations. However, existing tasks and evaluation methods
are predominantly limited to sentence-level statement, neglecting the
significance of positional fine-grained citations that can appear anywhere
within sentences. To facilitate further exploration of the fine-grained
citation generation, we propose ALiiCE, the first automatic evaluation
framework for this task. Our framework first parses the sentence claim into
atomic claims via dependency analysis and then calculates citation quality at
the atomic claim level. ALiiCE introduces three novel metrics for positional
fined-grained citation quality assessment, including positional fine-grained
citation recall and precision, and coefficient of variation of citation
positions. We evaluate the positional fine-grained citation generation
performance of several LLMs on two long-form QA datasets. Our experiments and
analyses demonstrate the effectiveness and reasonableness of ALiiCE. The
results also indicate that existing LLMs still struggle to provide positional
fine-grained citations. | [
-0.0141952848,
-0.6255146265,
0.9770417213,
0.2571127117,
0.0673061684,
-0.0885525122,
0.0359945036,
-0.43003124,
0.0734462366,
0.1521746814,
0.0979066417,
-0.6003357768,
-0.429711014,
0.305583775,
-0.4362902641,
0.5850494504,
0.0266893003,
-0.0733622313,
-0.2508260608,
-0.0459003635,
-0.3388629556,
-0.3062992394,
-0.5570055246,
-0.1445402354,
0.5512546301,
0.3667995632,
0.7233166695,
0.6078924537,
0.6166123152,
0.2892930508,
-0.0135079939,
0.3623379767,
-0.1194288358,
0.180002138,
-0.65055722,
-0.1920462996,
-0.4103403389,
0.0600825474,
0.899882853,
0.7211049795,
0.0999285802,
0.3205300868,
0.01296659,
0.650449872,
-0.9301643968,
-0.0648799166,
-0.9433081746,
-0.2741627395,
-0.3284961879,
-0.4284876287,
-0.6000347733,
-0.5481683612,
-0.0367286988,
-0.2637696564,
-0.1894015819,
0.1974463165,
1.1491253376,
0.1501553953,
-0.6238793135,
-0.4852099121,
-0.6252301931,
0.9034795165,
-0.723384738,
0.1446741819,
0.4469030201,
0.2828062177,
-0.2209942788,
-0.9319812655,
-0.322555393,
-0.6054286361,
-0.0915275663,
-0.0669382587,
-0.2457866222,
-0.0881744847,
-0.0633465499,
0.3388787806,
-0.5130876899,
-0.1068610325,
-0.2050797641,
-0.0634151101,
0.7176270485,
-0.1608166695,
0.2879313827,
-0.7485023141,
-0.3541278839,
0.0125540048,
-0.7505393624,
-0.1217868328,
0.3015343845,
0.4838059545,
0.4128052592,
0.61676085,
-0.258250773,
0.3262391984,
0.3296425343,
0.0005054793,
0.1034981832,
-0.4637241364,
-0.3992491364,
0.264618814,
0.8427299857,
0.1092249528,
-0.0178190432,
-0.2078573406,
-0.1564358622,
-0.3926671147,
0.3019427359,
-1.09359622,
0.0441718735,
0.5593236685,
-0.6147451401,
-0.3097449243,
0.2298780978,
-0.1666589677,
-0.2413250059,
-0.3602134585,
0.4395293593,
-0.570296824,
0.2235978544,
-0.3333557546,
0.2007023245,
-0.0467092656,
0.185414657,
-0.5443632007,
-0.1643270403,
0.6406049728,
0.9478970766,
-0.0402313545,
-0.2639319003,
-0.9068804979,
0.2358965427,
-0.4055197537,
1.1473947763,
-0.7344392538,
-0.2025667876,
0.3029353917,
-0.0295042489,
0.0239570271,
-0.7481274009,
0.8623608351,
-0.5485038757,
-0.2260351032,
-0.2676177621,
-0.7743543983,
0.126474902,
0.3156708181,
-0.6187705398,
0.8915838599,
0.2234428972,
-0.5435634255,
0.3741199672,
-0.358733654,
-0.3165900707,
0.143557772,
-0.2079032212,
-0.2598116696,
0.3164734244,
-0.0252650063,
0.4031271636,
-0.3922334313,
0.5229277015,
-0.2698952556,
-0.1135537401,
0.3718869984,
-0.3404105604,
0.7381348014,
0.5411608219,
-0.0382174365,
0.1353024542,
-1.1749870777,
0.2809450924,
-0.121672824,
-0.4840784669,
-0.7933968306,
0.0730619058,
0.1331145167,
0.0046075834,
0.522516191,
-0.4360300899,
0.0973494425,
-0.4883823991,
0.3570163846,
0.4622637331,
0.2159035355,
0.349625051,
-0.129730612,
0.4270057678,
-0.2387336046,
-0.0178035293,
-0.231792897,
0.1048446968,
-0.5319313407,
-0.0991473645,
0.5152254105,
0.3206527531,
-0.591008842,
0.5427638888,
-0.3542820513,
-0.3452642858,
-0.2390743345,
0.2471041381,
0.3677487969,
0.2709935606,
0.3597742617,
-0.0073356247,
-0.3643005788,
-1.0013279915,
-0.2219678909,
-0.5538628697,
-0.0807293206,
0.1782092303,
0.6163291335,
-0.0819989815,
1.0340731144,
0.0371752717,
-0.0459817015,
0.1716119498,
0.6679834723,
-0.1117535979,
0.573387742,
0.6497771144,
-0.4869584441,
-0.533688724,
0.0785850286,
-0.8953770399,
-0.4102463126,
-0.1916136742,
-0.3293198049,
0.047570996,
0.5248025656,
-0.4828574955,
0.0552257523,
0.3431210518,
-0.4679110348,
0.6516967416,
-0.015333591,
0.4488241374,
-1.1893092394,
0.360221535,
-0.0687756389,
-0.3536643386,
-0.2691225708,
0.3556306064,
0.1933238357,
-0.0243434049,
-0.3475365043,
0.6046723127,
-0.4059991837,
-0.191790849,
-0.551120162,
0.317417562,
0.3707554042,
-0.1098066121,
-0.2864781022,
0.9004479647,
-0.0331059545,
-0.2563048303,
-0.0091156512,
0.1553118974,
-0.4903388917,
0.9471375346,
-0.7962093353,
-0.0497231521,
0.1926712245,
0.2199058831,
-0.9074894786,
-0.2527567148,
-0.3478216529,
-0.3092250824,
0.2290333062,
-0.2383638322,
-0.5308163762,
-0.1208176166,
-0.3040608466,
0.5277619362,
-0.018005427,
-0.6329744458,
0.3342573941,
0.167490527,
-0.4433900416,
-0.4818809032,
-0.3325344026,
0.3075110018,
-0.2337411791,
-0.7111740708,
0.3907011449,
0.0217303131,
-0.7227786183,
-0.2429572791,
-0.0302153621,
-0.1531638056,
0.2479844838,
0.1528758258,
0.0055503971,
-0.2721991241,
0.3540016115,
0.2993802726,
0.0063380189,
0.1406965852,
-0.3270052075,
0.3268604875,
-0.4180089533,
-0.3874303401,
-0.3963706791,
0.3714156151,
0.3990636468,
-0.1671450138,
0.3792897165,
0.3825563788,
-0.2845410407,
-0.1798838228,
-0.4533980489,
0.1505454481,
-0.4087761343,
0.230416581,
-0.3213414252,
-0.54763937,
0.2961955667,
-0.3246846795,
-0.0425693505,
0.5838063359,
0.3798103929,
0.0126627469,
0.7410687208,
0.2887568474,
0.1258003861,
0.4175269902,
0.0023447296,
0.0673729032,
-0.6217437387,
0.1337741166,
-0.8718140721,
-0.1153622866,
-0.3882177174,
-0.3742254078,
0.2218325436,
0.6251743436,
-0.4451351762,
0.154145211,
-0.3476954103,
0.5186857581,
0.5485266447,
-0.2094675153,
0.492980808,
0.0126822619,
0.0320503451,
0.1807724237,
-0.1968585998,
-1.0941469669,
1.0657800436,
0.2994941175,
0.4392752945,
0.2144627571,
0.9141973853,
0.6702761054,
0.2458250821,
-0.8241724372,
0.5050078034,
-0.1248154491,
-0.491500169,
-0.239508763,
-0.2610863149,
-1.0184847116,
0.0637957603,
0.1408067197,
-0.7606061101,
0.4588841498,
0.131952554,
-0.7204236984,
-0.3648003042,
-0.5920972228,
0.6511259079,
-0.2932217121,
-0.8011270165,
-0.0147461081,
-0.4557034075,
0.2820083201,
-0.0711074769,
0.0222563408,
-0.1833968461,
0.3074309528,
0.666212678,
-0.7907617688,
0.4078967869,
-0.2658373415,
-0.3127728999,
0.5966313481,
0.3515827954,
0.7304524183,
0.2263738364,
-0.5178454518,
-0.0012217172,
0.1956897676,
-0.3255796731,
-0.5224173665,
1.0752539635,
-0.5602048635,
-0.3184240758,
-0.3870880902,
-0.6174108386,
-0.285027355,
0.3212424815,
-0.0375214629,
0.3190686405,
-0.3066084087,
0.2822108269,
0.3325389922,
-0.2597305477,
0.4647274017,
0.4049263,
-0.11466299,
-0.5883609653,
0.8971492052,
0.0838992968,
0.1271758527,
0.3672297299,
0.2050007582,
-0.1765444279,
-0.6625562906,
-0.3911111057,
0.1346051693,
-0.7063525319,
-0.4324443042,
-0.3772001266,
-0.2545132041,
-0.3670498431,
-0.3476884663,
-0.5785802007,
-0.5638707876,
-0.113895759,
-0.0768627971,
0.0684713274,
0.5260377526,
-0.0000918736,
0.3575241864,
-0.8118588328,
-0.0239055995,
0.1734996289,
0.0452222414,
-0.0317047872,
-0.4156083763,
-0.4726586342,
-0.1916537136,
-0.4312979281,
-0.6104424596,
0.4543521106,
0.2517186105,
0.3077971637,
0.4482328892,
0.1460474879,
0.7935917974,
-0.7641695738,
0.9206141233,
0.0152392257,
-0.9927079082,
0.8591583967,
-0.3135922253,
0.0689244643,
1.0054937601,
0.2613384724,
0.2874701023,
-0.399486959,
-0.5596552491,
-1.219525218,
0.3080487847,
0.3831477463,
-0.1732459068,
-0.3257685304,
0.4188168645,
0.0990343094,
0.1025089547,
-0.7691492438,
-0.119256787,
-0.0754431263,
-0.3981295526,
0.3578667045,
-0.4993903339,
-0.1936196387,
0.060734313,
0.7740080953,
-0.1485303491,
0.1694092453,
0.4119165242,
-0.3450113237,
-0.1053373292,
0.687372148,
0.3878233135,
0.9552569985,
-0.4100189507,
0.3025524914,
-0.3606100976,
-0.048772905,
0.2110082805,
0.4243099391,
-0.5535477996,
0.2908038497,
0.313121736,
0.3860206604,
0.2663455606,
-0.6165079474,
0.4503617585,
0.2362662107,
0.0944707468,
-0.5932506919,
-0.1295990497,
-0.1906265169,
0.5548563004,
0.5124133229,
-0.2472587377,
0.500892818,
-0.6605578661,
0.2926445305,
0.5002807379,
-0.1458438635,
-0.225487873,
0.7383046746,
0.2459045947,
-0.1014083996,
0.1978701353,
-0.2660026848,
0.0528147817,
0.3537617326,
0.5785370469,
0.9727397561,
-0.1866315156,
0.2824319005,
0.6413523555,
0.0810295716,
0.0539770797,
0.0496529751,
-0.0865866095,
-0.4004319012,
-0.3409679234,
-1.0674726963,
-0.2768400311,
0.1471582949,
-0.5702314377,
-0.0338354446,
-0.3155555129,
-0.3701532781,
0.1772144586,
0.2711930573,
-0.4002535343,
0.0603773817,
0.2138120681,
0.7924156189,
-0.6950665712,
0.8294289708,
0.7262825966,
-0.7933872938,
-0.8219390512,
0.144802779,
-0.3035215735,
-0.5962057114,
1.1252753735,
0.1312567741,
-0.3594469726,
-0.1138096675,
-0.6377248764,
-1.0090800524,
1.328981638,
0.3852997422,
-0.5359216928,
-0.0129795074,
0.109920539,
0.307726711,
-0.3963651657,
0.5160928965,
0.4976778328,
0.5268705487,
0.0782875791,
-0.9629004598,
0.1855783165,
-0.4015906155,
0.3360169232,
-0.1975116432,
-0.7286510468,
0.7698509097,
0.1661619097,
-0.1290736645,
0.5555080771,
1.0121251345,
0.6094996333,
0.5729815364,
0.2186568826,
0.292272836,
1.0980935097,
0.1105387732,
1.0780709982,
-0.494550705,
0.3869358599,
1.4805747271,
-0.7393636107,
1.2139636278,
0.5548599958,
-0.2400745451,
0.7425081134,
0.3944324851,
0.0417448059,
0.310208261,
0.1392244846,
-0.1651940346,
-0.2962797284,
-0.3730128109,
-0.2473312467,
0.3168415427,
0.1758864224,
-0.871948421,
-0.3317601383,
0.0718208402,
0.1053223684,
0.3014692366,
-0.3941166401,
0.370554179,
0.0887904763,
-0.7213745117,
0.677434504,
0.0981865153,
0.1851410866,
-0.3851650059,
-0.1245354265,
-0.338583529,
0.1978619397,
-0.2728073895,
-0.3995532393,
0.216411382,
0.2493811995,
-0.3127885163,
-0.030757403,
0.7551237941,
-0.1637639254,
-0.5644291043,
0.1550883949,
0.3210721612,
0.2689752877,
-0.0822175369,
-0.4691422284,
-0.0289177056,
-0.1828324646,
-0.4337005317,
0.3502990901,
0.6765808463,
-0.1074513718,
0.3948209286,
0.5089411736,
0.0301964842,
-0.1230597496,
0.3425599933,
0.4113676846,
-0.6126583815,
-0.1661248058,
-0.7224697471,
0.3804865479,
-0.2394197136,
-0.0919699594,
1.0698632002,
0.6617444158,
0.519364655,
0.2332365662,
0.905152142,
-0.1553203315,
0.3827242255,
-0.6532723308,
0.6249021888,
-0.6874516606,
0.4244008064,
-0.3469641209,
-0.8988606334,
-0.2583959997,
0.802108109,
-0.3524008095,
0.005871383,
0.872690618,
0.6093264818,
-0.0425033383,
-0.2803655267,
0.2552934289,
0.5125123858,
0.4463408291,
0.2584865391,
0.8870385885,
-0.6735827327,
0.5090176463,
-0.0231325943,
-0.049193114,
-0.4309562147,
-1.0013816357,
-0.5255502462,
-0.4105606079,
-0.4473558962,
-0.5356048942,
0.0925870314,
1.1724399328,
0.634914279,
-0.9236523509,
-0.158503294,
-0.2487487495,
-0.0178213771,
0.0134501224,
-0.354228884,
0.691390574,
-0.6425102949,
-1.0409997702,
0.7302146554,
0.3254939616,
-0.2481168956,
-0.2430962473,
-0.0325060524,
-0.4400830567,
0.2848287225,
0.9204678535,
0.3191155791,
-0.6393108368,
-0.5314859748,
-0.2766219974,
-0.4011270106,
0.0679138079,
0.6904215217,
-0.6888653636,
0.200195998,
0.4921506345,
0.5534826517,
-0.013786627,
0.4653697014,
0.4211017191,
-0.6785709262,
-0.2300078869,
0.1254795045,
0.5335971117,
0.1890973002,
-0.2130138427,
0.4860035777,
-0.0950266495,
-1.0676444769,
-0.8925811648,
-0.0430352502,
-1.2525011301,
-0.3678744435,
1.4169654846,
-0.3834970891,
-0.2799651027,
0.02265702,
-0.0778168514,
0.0916748643,
-0.4089958966,
0.8912628293,
0.6645829082,
-0.0598132052,
0.3810242712,
-0.4328562915,
0.1223818883,
0.3758119047,
-0.9098258615,
0.0977970883,
0.9568167925,
0.2012882531,
0.5901131034,
0.4121107161,
-0.1381804049,
0.1584707052,
-0.0239892881,
0.0321339518,
-0.1577646732,
-0.4593427479,
-0.0410607047,
0.500113368,
0.5496877432,
0.0809559226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13363v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13363v1 | Evaluating Structural Generalization in Neural Machine Translation | 2024-06-19T09:09:11 | 2024-06-19T09:09:11 | Ryoma Kumon, Daiki Matsuoka, Hitomi Yanaka | cs.CL | cs.CL | Compositional generalization refers to the ability to generalize to novel
combinations of previously observed words and syntactic structures. Since it is
regarded as a desired property of neural models, recent work has assessed
compositional generalization in machine translation as well as semantic
parsing. However, previous evaluations with machine translation have focused
mostly on lexical generalization (i.e., generalization to unseen combinations
of known words). Thus, it remains unclear to what extent models can translate
sentences that require structural generalization (i.e., generalization to
different sorts of syntactic structures). To address this question, we
construct SGET, a machine translation dataset covering various types of
compositional generalization with control of words and sentence structures. We
evaluate neural machine translation models on SGET and show that they struggle
more in structural generalization than in lexical generalization. We also find
different performance trends in semantic parsing and machine translation, which
indicates the importance of evaluations across various tasks. | [
0.1317868084,
-0.7037813663,
0.5005918145,
0.5015815496,
-0.3291991651,
0.0084172087,
-0.2878871858,
-0.2081540227,
0.2066078931,
0.2060117275,
-0.2424907833,
-0.7565090656,
-0.7801327109,
0.1626248509,
-0.5524302721,
1.1096507311,
-0.2259806097,
0.2965998352,
-0.212871626,
-0.288038373,
-0.7989330888,
-0.5041555166,
-0.4278440773,
-0.4334565699,
0.4146971703,
-0.3219396174,
0.7743332982,
0.8922122121,
0.7383634448,
0.4867221713,
-0.3153889775,
-0.0001761792,
-0.1700592935,
0.2892619967,
-0.3092622161,
-0.834956944,
-0.5127705336,
-0.2132539898,
0.9995777607,
1.2159141302,
0.0662869364,
0.0532183051,
0.0883613899,
0.7377456427,
-0.2767213583,
0.2606893778,
-0.680555284,
0.3101757765,
0.095035553,
-0.0144858314,
-0.2094501257,
-0.2596611679,
0.2731407881,
-0.5842314363,
0.2576457262,
-0.2234176993,
0.6635285616,
0.2696528435,
-0.5842749476,
-0.2480892241,
-0.6865513325,
0.7183467746,
-0.6097676158,
0.4983020425,
0.1717820913,
0.381398648,
-0.0806015655,
-0.960829854,
-0.0765949264,
-0.5615047812,
-0.1817371994,
0.1921007931,
-0.1852079183,
0.3721195459,
0.0456812121,
0.7358660698,
-0.8162706494,
-0.0620072447,
-0.4884847403,
-0.2634646893,
0.4665994942,
0.2262125313,
0.8158278465,
-0.3298807144,
-0.4593197107,
-0.2143166512,
-0.2262286246,
-0.0524449386,
0.4156572521,
0.2503736019,
0.0025833366,
0.7836995125,
-0.2227875292,
0.7093177438,
0.0249743443,
0.4294263124,
0.3152685463,
-0.6865620613,
-0.4431665838,
-0.0694644004,
0.6564637423,
0.4586505592,
0.235802263,
-0.5277573466,
-0.3382176161,
0.4283336103,
0.4469099045,
-0.7648950219,
-0.1369480789,
0.2192978561,
-0.7483561635,
-0.2389558256,
-0.0072366102,
-0.2663186193,
-0.0977991074,
-0.3829556108,
0.2086573094,
-0.4637513161,
-0.0842179954,
0.1741807759,
-0.4358010292,
0.2413670868,
-0.0967394635,
-1.1179599762,
0.3623995781,
0.8111441135,
1.0261769295,
-0.3293982446,
-0.3717637062,
-0.2393101454,
0.0229288433,
-0.4754136801,
0.5869412422,
-0.6724575162,
-0.3729034364,
-0.2733731866,
0.0471402779,
-0.6068739891,
-0.6116783619,
0.4504712522,
-0.471488744,
0.0067060841,
-0.2664712071,
-0.6734939814,
-0.1918638051,
0.2562991083,
-0.6162548661,
0.6108931899,
0.1420524418,
-0.4982153773,
0.5486418605,
-0.645640552,
-0.6177186966,
0.1493078172,
-0.3879927099,
-0.1778110564,
0.6645395756,
0.0743725374,
0.4571349323,
0.052058693,
0.5601043701,
-0.1830141991,
-0.283780843,
0.0362251066,
-0.0596842989,
0.417691946,
0.1812430769,
-0.3411089778,
0.4290558398,
-0.5512632132,
0.241751954,
-0.0208102856,
-0.5143635273,
-0.5589791536,
0.1347034723,
-0.1370227784,
0.0288899988,
0.3827623129,
-0.3115092218,
0.3926056027,
-0.9663274288,
0.6640875936,
0.7111780643,
-0.0186130442,
0.8283209205,
0.0789677426,
0.6729437113,
0.0645395666,
-0.1780053675,
-0.1143558919,
-0.4294388592,
-0.5696169138,
0.1102731973,
0.5204125047,
0.6123668551,
-0.6909114122,
0.363168776,
-0.4757244885,
-0.2886869013,
-0.2442232668,
0.1953595281,
0.6446683407,
0.1096465588,
0.3423371315,
-0.291538775,
-0.5835061669,
-1.3565340042,
-0.4721105695,
0.1197076961,
-0.2308725715,
0.0496844314,
0.525170207,
-0.2559056878,
0.5484963655,
-0.3022708297,
-0.041982241,
-0.3125832677,
0.2188810557,
0.1236563325,
0.4706099331,
0.4520340562,
-0.88045609,
-0.4246657491,
0.5454568863,
-1.110401988,
0.1710249931,
-0.168261677,
0.0077038514,
-0.1414097697,
0.5603215098,
-0.4707373977,
0.1685497463,
0.6799833179,
-0.1568626016,
0.288117677,
-0.1634298712,
0.004977054,
-1.352363348,
0.165157333,
-0.1287190765,
0.0050696926,
-0.6824823022,
0.4626895189,
-0.0159265902,
-0.0857135952,
-0.2991939187,
0.1809441596,
-0.5902516842,
-0.4479341507,
-0.1889941841,
0.04669144,
-0.1308245063,
0.4590965211,
-0.2592117786,
0.8751971722,
0.4237814248,
-0.6664780378,
0.252142787,
0.1543213278,
-0.2470563352,
0.2772714198,
-1.1011519432,
0.1929294169,
-0.2234247178,
0.1521754265,
-1.0204179287,
-0.2840043604,
0.0355460532,
-0.3785445094,
0.1174458712,
-0.1560835391,
-0.1664263755,
-0.2084110975,
-0.1235552281,
0.5152869225,
-0.1035064831,
0.0617227927,
0.6570367813,
0.1079273224,
-0.0983061939,
-0.5867529511,
-1.0445371866,
0.1355156451,
-0.0741889551,
-0.8409510851,
0.6224422455,
0.0417224988,
-0.2438273579,
0.1571610719,
-0.4818794131,
-0.1358164698,
0.195503056,
0.2405667156,
-0.054339461,
-0.5912010074,
0.2637640536,
0.2691367269,
0.0026520339,
0.0442674756,
-0.5659475327,
0.764169693,
-0.5962022543,
-0.2582491636,
-0.211102441,
0.362531513,
0.3141754866,
-0.3362600803,
0.5584514737,
0.4948188066,
-0.3894293904,
-0.1547594815,
-0.1168587953,
-0.1497837305,
-0.442699194,
0.8627675772,
-0.538836658,
-0.8900113702,
0.8078942895,
0.0521554127,
-0.1532616317,
0.8215625882,
0.4231254458,
-0.0018396277,
1.1307120323,
0.4655970037,
-0.0610137694,
0.5004405975,
-0.3184457123,
-0.0487542152,
-0.768548429,
0.013531981,
-0.3107479215,
-0.7446706891,
-0.8128327131,
-0.0983826667,
0.1536359638,
0.0256809872,
0.1306648254,
0.6301353574,
-0.5179187655,
0.7504882812,
0.3647978604,
0.037412256,
0.2008512914,
0.0765826479,
-0.5196890235,
0.073803857,
-0.5002784133,
-0.549759984,
1.2805666924,
0.2133396417,
0.2145508528,
-0.0841479078,
0.5849602222,
0.4526317716,
0.0819928721,
-0.9717976451,
0.5702884197,
-0.6644142866,
-0.3703093529,
-0.1982276738,
-0.6470832229,
-1.1992558241,
0.482547164,
0.1286943853,
-0.3545311093,
0.184943229,
0.0560010821,
-0.1592183709,
0.0808923468,
-0.8555740714,
1.0304361582,
-0.1827333719,
0.1877728254,
-0.2212104499,
-0.6602537632,
0.4031126499,
0.2133364975,
-0.2804936767,
0.4618455172,
-0.0600352138,
0.6397445798,
-0.1726118773,
0.8718511462,
-0.0925049856,
0.0915814862,
0.1800341457,
0.0249506421,
0.3718365729,
-0.3484045267,
-0.0058283182,
0.1868784577,
-0.0538202524,
-0.4214722812,
-0.8727942705,
0.6520607471,
-0.6994537711,
-0.4515829384,
-0.0849261433,
-0.4892575741,
-0.1906297952,
0.3208745718,
0.4305199981,
0.1773649007,
-0.5177358389,
0.4248858392,
0.4032104313,
0.0588598773,
0.2408822328,
-0.0462109484,
-0.2864832282,
-0.6652978659,
1.0034840107,
0.2692170143,
0.3177027106,
0.3965133727,
0.1830441058,
-0.1420795023,
-0.8717830777,
-0.5735310912,
0.002355041,
-0.7183320522,
0.0598133951,
-0.7227371335,
-0.2896314859,
-0.2157354206,
-0.0110507058,
-0.2146413773,
-0.7264056206,
-0.002676137,
-0.3354191184,
-0.4893548489,
0.9088940024,
0.3810500503,
0.5803410411,
-0.7074654102,
0.1861220747,
0.3294681609,
0.1405468732,
-0.1773734093,
-0.3662314415,
-0.2891791463,
0.0399975367,
-0.4135357738,
-0.9806416631,
0.0862738118,
0.2370809764,
0.7975969911,
0.2366453111,
-0.6781024337,
0.3558444679,
-0.4829904437,
0.7566702962,
0.1091373116,
-0.9811918736,
0.5777025819,
-0.5874450803,
0.3251093626,
0.469124496,
0.2340417951,
-0.6938605905,
-0.14423576,
-0.4114334583,
-0.8270808458,
0.2094765902,
0.2537660599,
0.3186945021,
-0.0970570669,
0.4861775041,
-0.1443495303,
0.5821526647,
-0.8538182974,
0.0571063384,
-0.2133570313,
-0.0573858619,
0.082420662,
-0.0901505277,
-0.0691866428,
-0.0081172884,
0.2356690913,
-0.2434711307,
0.2536209226,
0.0959100425,
-0.3708414137,
0.0931895524,
0.4541955292,
0.7614451647,
0.5152084231,
-0.059664093,
-0.0129800374,
0.1690441668,
-0.3048796952,
0.0008758385,
0.0124668842,
-0.3582790792,
-0.1140530109,
0.6115387678,
1.0742682219,
0.3634614348,
-0.1880677193,
0.4928115308,
0.2518205345,
-0.4041846097,
0.136545077,
0.0291469023,
0.0691545233,
0.291072309,
-0.0424157865,
0.3651296198,
0.4368263185,
-0.5242016912,
0.1366724819,
0.3443853855,
-0.2359102219,
-0.7636352181,
0.5019569993,
-0.0463352017,
-0.0669195056,
0.6308231354,
-0.0362266898,
-0.7393689156,
0.8154919147,
0.7050730586,
1.348248601,
-0.4641265273,
0.2680309117,
0.1618032753,
0.5956673026,
0.100490585,
0.2369290888,
-0.1428395808,
-0.7294335961,
-0.6801390052,
-0.7038007975,
-0.2001001239,
-0.0726538971,
-0.6130881906,
-0.080973275,
-0.5722290277,
-0.3306442797,
-0.01259783,
-0.3265684545,
-0.4894543886,
0.2288244665,
-0.0498272516,
0.5902354121,
-1.0171848536,
0.5865076184,
1.1041201353,
-0.5450959802,
-0.6122574806,
-0.0609056801,
-0.4106644988,
-0.7020862699,
0.9974081516,
0.2412830293,
0.0769223198,
-0.2886695266,
-0.351210624,
-0.6421280503,
1.051029563,
0.5210304856,
-0.3751298189,
-0.4873104393,
0.4275166094,
0.9962852001,
-0.4374015629,
-0.0692136437,
0.5091460943,
0.5982888341,
-0.1350178421,
-0.8301274776,
-0.0061112964,
-0.4581907094,
0.4273376763,
0.1986528784,
-0.5918066502,
0.9895852804,
0.2256132513,
-0.4091936052,
-0.1247973666,
0.7114970088,
-0.170316726,
0.3681535721,
0.4212094247,
0.6076503396,
0.624625504,
-0.0312724523,
1.1736044884,
-0.2225255817,
0.0219669044,
1.3117845058,
0.0709535629,
0.7650542855,
0.2956130207,
-0.1872579306,
0.4148137569,
0.4568624198,
-0.1357135475,
0.3040030003,
0.4667711258,
-0.0180463437,
-0.224228248,
0.082566753,
-0.559479773,
0.6608703732,
0.3100810945,
-0.8972110152,
-0.3437761664,
-0.0635755658,
-0.2210247666,
0.1832755953,
-0.2278148085,
0.7562501431,
0.1571727097,
-0.6420981884,
0.5305193067,
0.2232463509,
0.241789937,
-0.7529562116,
0.0023968264,
-0.2740488946,
0.041576162,
-0.2379965633,
-0.3895714581,
0.8453907967,
-0.4072289765,
-0.4274836779,
-0.1063613594,
0.8051376939,
-0.3498663604,
-0.469942838,
0.3542300165,
0.4423802197,
0.1028525829,
-0.4509908259,
-0.6014905572,
-0.0083255805,
-0.0104710339,
-0.2721925676,
0.3257796168,
0.2682934701,
-0.3372551799,
0.3919734657,
0.676537931,
0.0733376294,
0.4837377369,
0.0509083867,
1.002717495,
-0.6848849058,
-0.4782721698,
-1.0062582493,
0.3662289083,
-0.04676231,
-0.4448180497,
0.799256444,
0.6863102317,
0.7965462804,
-0.281611532,
0.705927074,
0.2286142409,
-0.2282863706,
-0.6505243778,
0.529301405,
-0.5658702254,
-0.0053828508,
-0.2032929212,
-1.2878500223,
-0.4662466943,
0.4736669362,
-0.6196442246,
0.1468649656,
0.8650007844,
0.6082989573,
-0.19778198,
0.2020618021,
0.4603324831,
0.3354747593,
0.1435505897,
0.4170664847,
0.6981619,
-0.5472502708,
0.4838129878,
0.1983222216,
-0.1027631611,
0.0531942062,
-0.7715198994,
-0.8047587872,
-0.5422450304,
0.0203353222,
-0.0853373259,
0.1797857583,
0.6869397759,
0.5787806511,
-0.9777305722,
-0.1825540066,
-0.615029037,
-0.0745454505,
-0.3468847871,
-0.199477613,
0.4463862181,
-0.7150616646,
-0.7812590003,
1.0449881554,
0.3699016869,
0.0136690233,
-0.1492531449,
0.1803515851,
0.0567711554,
0.0288086161,
0.6753649116,
0.0374093056,
-0.6118767262,
-0.132381767,
0.0991443172,
-0.0923811644,
0.0961812437,
0.9762259722,
-0.2964169383,
0.4225592613,
0.8230077624,
1.1249914169,
0.430760473,
0.0535403714,
0.7823764682,
-0.8929510117,
-0.0908940956,
0.0757642463,
0.434997201,
0.1829872131,
-0.3364152014,
0.6388741136,
0.3898569643,
-0.5656293631,
-0.5631985664,
0.4588503838,
-0.8496983647,
-0.0635898262,
0.8554062843,
-0.1777658612,
-0.3289062679,
0.3029372394,
0.0022424215,
0.1666524112,
-0.0932439268,
0.4646973014,
0.9342466593,
0.2092726231,
0.4123709202,
-0.5146791935,
0.1473310292,
0.9002289176,
-0.6814293265,
-0.1388868839,
0.4627027512,
0.3320735991,
0.2505536675,
0.3672834635,
0.0162903648,
0.1047980785,
0.0731653646,
-0.0301766284,
-0.0168402009,
-0.422372967,
-0.5866410732,
0.3676512837,
-0.3049511015,
-0.4091418684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13362v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13362v1 | VisualRWKV: Exploring Recurrent Neural Networks for Visual Language Models | 2024-06-19T09:07:31 | 2024-06-19T09:07:31 | Haowen Hou, Peigen Zeng, Fei Ma, Fei Richard Yu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Visual Language Models (VLMs) have rapidly progressed with the recent success
of large language models. However, there have been few attempts to incorporate
efficient linear Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) architectures into VLMs. In
this study, we introduce VisualRWKV, the first application of a linear RNN
model to multimodal learning tasks, leveraging the pre-trained RWKV language
model. We propose a data-dependent recurrence and sandwich prompts to enhance
our modeling capabilities, along with a 2D image scanning mechanism to enrich
the processing of visual sequences. Extensive experiments demonstrate that
VisualRWKV achieves competitive performance compared to Transformer-based
models like LLaVA-1.5 on various benchmarks. To facilitate further research and
analysis, we have made the checkpoints and the associated code publicly
accessible at the following GitHub repository:
\href{https://github.com/howard-hou/VisualRWKV}{https://github.com/howard-hou/VisualRWKV}. | [
-0.1212388501,
-0.7564894557,
0.3883320093,
0.2710196972,
-0.3070191741,
-0.0730707645,
0.0202627257,
-0.3010860085,
-0.2201949805,
0.4386594296,
-0.5551748872,
-0.4667721093,
-0.4143443704,
-0.0655860752,
-0.5032755733,
0.5239223838,
0.2018879354,
0.289393425,
-0.3299984634,
-0.2710998058,
-0.4547266662,
-0.119666107,
-0.486089617,
-0.42419222,
1.1817281246,
0.2451754957,
0.4553400576,
0.6393507719,
0.4415921867,
0.382712692,
0.1210674867,
0.015870342,
-0.6981396675,
0.4923409224,
-0.009548963,
-0.1573237181,
0.1207517907,
-0.2333640605,
0.7037824392,
0.4383975565,
-0.3304802477,
0.07476677,
-0.2471439987,
0.6219244599,
-0.5027519464,
0.3288094997,
-0.4358846545,
0.2341226041,
-0.4066492617,
0.0593504049,
-0.5137451887,
-0.3606506884,
0.4841732681,
-0.4979506135,
0.0499599427,
0.0349306129,
0.5746946931,
0.038967371,
-0.4254797399,
0.2240310013,
-0.5117471218,
1.0166577101,
-0.6559851766,
0.764916122,
-0.029881252,
0.4808246493,
-0.1099143848,
-1.3232470751,
-0.6534211636,
-0.3409803212,
0.0475395583,
0.2125214338,
-0.3998946846,
-0.1675243527,
0.353848666,
0.2526865304,
-0.8651772738,
-0.1451836675,
-0.5176611543,
0.0723967999,
0.1737723202,
0.4874420464,
0.1598074436,
-0.2728650868,
-0.6428340077,
-0.2739718556,
-0.1623865217,
0.3553781509,
-0.3006125391,
0.2265046537,
-0.2138228863,
0.5761592388,
-0.191514045,
1.0816630125,
-0.3530043662,
-0.1211128607,
0.39045012,
-0.3414408267,
-0.2535192966,
-0.5924281478,
0.8065659404,
0.2183819264,
0.2994520366,
0.201684773,
-0.3001538813,
-0.0452053957,
0.5108919144,
-0.5925869346,
-0.4240063429,
-0.2354321629,
-0.6527441144,
-0.6193878651,
-0.1183341742,
-0.7495902777,
-0.3963851631,
-0.3409730792,
0.3851688802,
-0.5918081999,
-0.2386897653,
0.1193635464,
-0.3034285009,
0.5692222118,
0.4782470465,
-0.576120317,
-0.1543572098,
0.6202762723,
0.6089778543,
-0.0633065775,
-0.5475360155,
-0.4447072148,
-0.1294650435,
-0.0961455032,
0.7052440047,
-0.7609069943,
-0.2984942794,
-0.0066588195,
-0.1381397098,
0.0431539714,
-0.1314047873,
0.0445763431,
-0.5826609731,
0.2574904859,
-0.1797204912,
-0.0631401315,
-0.419169277,
0.4678498507,
-0.647611618,
1.0667321682,
0.2013152838,
-0.6778411269,
0.0011541161,
-0.2278513312,
-0.5002503395,
0.2324213684,
-0.4904910922,
-0.5038840771,
0.2015550882,
0.1555557698,
0.3579974473,
-0.2727911174,
-0.1395934671,
-0.4209690392,
-0.2029701918,
0.2564295828,
-0.5452073216,
0.4691870213,
0.3352965713,
0.0260072947,
0.461930424,
-0.8762986064,
0.2956179678,
0.4294795692,
-0.4199794829,
-0.3373862505,
-0.2149380893,
0.3850211501,
0.2419917881,
0.1972094774,
-0.4491800666,
0.3544337451,
-0.0871439278,
0.4787785113,
0.8899290562,
-0.2509482503,
0.0672336444,
-0.3066511452,
0.6296909451,
-0.0034195031,
0.4450826943,
-0.6150193214,
-0.6784908175,
-0.6715785861,
-0.4060674012,
0.1287128329,
0.5985887647,
-1.2204807997,
-0.3747841418,
-0.2919933498,
-0.3159548938,
-0.1550084054,
0.0283073038,
0.5683014989,
0.4766900837,
0.2161096483,
-0.3963437974,
-0.711135149,
-0.9314065576,
-0.0708661154,
-0.0445994325,
0.1968080401,
0.4596522152,
0.306979388,
-0.3727819026,
0.8135880232,
-0.3325240314,
-0.0924491286,
-0.4523741603,
0.3386343122,
0.2346263528,
0.254255563,
0.4515601695,
-0.7583625913,
-0.3124223948,
0.108785592,
-0.9589599371,
0.1190087274,
-0.0605006926,
0.0206903201,
-0.0422072783,
0.5635166764,
-0.3451498747,
0.4382335246,
0.7011168599,
-0.2112107724,
0.6241204143,
-0.0523274392,
0.0569266677,
-0.9664783478,
-0.0349512585,
0.126326099,
-0.5903701186,
-0.669418931,
0.1812645942,
0.0024531826,
-0.2926041782,
-0.6231532693,
0.3050580025,
-0.381683141,
-0.2269887775,
-0.1586343646,
-0.1525321454,
0.1853482276,
0.5442500114,
0.0175074153,
0.4925704598,
0.6082898974,
-0.1224455759,
0.7008413076,
0.16817981,
-0.5291964412,
0.1361198723,
-0.7882124782,
0.0420323573,
-0.3787750006,
-0.0476962961,
-1.0022749901,
0.1038166881,
0.4373102188,
-0.3247538209,
0.1841662079,
-0.2384546697,
-0.0538547747,
-0.3403604031,
-0.2678391635,
0.6059384942,
0.4555880725,
-0.4949701726,
0.9453245401,
0.1051652655,
-0.1041784957,
-0.7364665866,
-0.7024952173,
0.0604048781,
0.1584115177,
-0.812469542,
-0.1077091023,
0.0951849893,
-0.0118435193,
-0.0648367405,
0.0623618253,
0.0631567389,
-0.247228846,
0.28751266,
0.3787603378,
-0.5298339128,
0.0314423963,
-0.5894058943,
-0.2435349673,
-0.0578942895,
-0.5379246473,
0.4560215175,
-0.4531617761,
-0.3324694633,
-0.4011331797,
0.4344222844,
0.7642097473,
-0.6069705486,
0.4389496744,
0.7976106405,
-0.1263590753,
-0.1796650887,
-0.6962580681,
-0.0728360042,
-0.4806908071,
0.5995889306,
-0.3309568763,
-0.9075932503,
0.1872413903,
-0.0723484084,
-0.092168197,
-0.1366289556,
0.4589238167,
-0.3757601678,
0.7674329877,
0.6337663531,
0.1006263569,
1.0384485722,
-0.0750845,
0.0320654176,
-0.5099354982,
-0.3338775635,
-0.0148559399,
-0.2381275594,
-0.2980220616,
-0.8060224652,
0.4738870263,
-0.1241811141,
-0.1950055063,
0.0782269984,
-0.2411906123,
0.5020939708,
0.6601936817,
0.2937620282,
0.1226973757,
0.3482530415,
-0.4207181036,
-0.1216006726,
-0.9847514629,
0.1187440455,
0.8750122786,
0.4655435681,
1.2655636072,
-0.0197002459,
0.4023021758,
0.3887120187,
-0.0391486436,
-0.6566182375,
0.645966351,
-0.2966964841,
0.1072023287,
-0.3663267791,
-0.5035214424,
-0.9876477122,
0.4795976579,
-0.4017593265,
-0.1641991735,
0.23952353,
0.2566688359,
-0.1896173805,
0.1449757218,
-0.4996903837,
1.0750259161,
-0.5549926162,
-0.5206685066,
-0.1799132526,
-0.5853055716,
0.4306789339,
0.364184469,
0.0669171214,
0.2388507575,
0.3163562417,
0.2376747727,
-0.2504913509,
0.9005371332,
-0.1484563351,
0.130651921,
0.0278546009,
0.0476440899,
0.7155330181,
0.0267247204,
0.3449932933,
0.3004323244,
-0.2287664115,
-0.3878388405,
-0.5884636641,
0.6795579791,
-0.5569781661,
-0.4306440353,
-0.6727992892,
-0.5570414662,
0.0768719465,
0.4646685123,
-0.1393292844,
0.7641174793,
0.0242850911,
0.4817689061,
0.9291110635,
-0.3597609699,
0.3177317381,
0.4041422606,
-0.8581565619,
-0.5983217955,
0.9022111893,
-0.2249775231,
0.1927006245,
0.3238461316,
0.3712684214,
-0.1140692011,
-0.7184112668,
-0.3777272701,
0.1129531637,
-0.7404822707,
-0.0882582739,
-0.5058296323,
-0.156027928,
-0.3917326033,
0.0572351478,
-0.4740681052,
-0.2711520195,
-0.0416448116,
0.1769285649,
0.4905825853,
1.0108777285,
0.019761581,
-0.1733147204,
-0.8788148165,
0.5560671091,
0.7993788719,
0.4386562407,
0.1121247411,
-0.3073357642,
-0.3098997474,
-0.1135013774,
0.0930610895,
-0.5337069631,
0.2657572031,
-0.0037057092,
0.6672177315,
0.3872224689,
-0.2780822515,
0.7888317704,
-0.6455135345,
0.7009714246,
0.4742651582,
-0.6149624586,
0.4113995433,
-0.5489099026,
0.7886966467,
0.1819826066,
0.1002665907,
-0.7627674341,
-0.1641591191,
0.100794889,
-0.8753775954,
0.4483805597,
0.109425135,
-0.0748773664,
0.0529630557,
0.2450827062,
-0.0030852344,
0.0655474514,
-0.9280733466,
-0.3774004877,
-0.6999500394,
-0.1423103958,
0.2378181368,
-0.4931194186,
0.0454560854,
-0.1820213348,
0.3931821585,
0.030991096,
0.1606004685,
0.224395141,
-0.3124136329,
0.1606942862,
0.136313349,
0.9296408892,
0.6604124308,
0.0044731693,
0.07385654,
0.0194081906,
-0.5353344083,
-0.1115250811,
-0.0129633565,
-0.0751487613,
0.0445280671,
0.4879125655,
0.8637698889,
0.6032797694,
-0.6511999965,
0.4851230383,
-0.5318895578,
-0.0797719061,
-0.5396931171,
-0.2378868014,
0.1022149548,
0.7988589406,
0.2628665268,
0.0751983076,
-0.1356775463,
-0.2744924724,
0.4359832108,
0.4942505062,
-0.3908560276,
0.0468046926,
0.587293148,
0.2409933954,
-0.2809768915,
0.949341476,
0.0899576843,
-0.4310251474,
0.2173541486,
0.5077303648,
0.6202864647,
-0.1499982327,
0.0779314488,
0.2662782669,
0.253659755,
0.0714234635,
0.5314288139,
-0.0279355813,
-0.6690235734,
-0.3665029407,
-0.5412923694,
-0.1028586328,
0.0750178471,
-0.7331593633,
0.2562287152,
-0.5194053054,
-0.0975919664,
-0.0742850751,
-0.8496865034,
-0.5846694112,
-0.0815406889,
0.6860099435,
0.85814327,
-0.4128138423,
1.1768637896,
0.6318458915,
-0.3356132209,
-0.3280112743,
-0.4855417907,
0.1600310206,
-1.0145521164,
0.8301474452,
0.1258621216,
-0.44975546,
0.0596422553,
-0.4026938081,
-0.8784472346,
1.1431456804,
-0.0175885856,
-0.7663134933,
-0.0855608061,
0.1832922846,
0.33284536,
-0.3045085073,
0.0620808862,
0.0881395787,
0.4218611717,
0.2002605647,
-0.5060173869,
-0.2251338661,
-0.4806062281,
0.6454190612,
0.0320083611,
-0.3588889539,
1.0605195761,
-0.4069929421,
-0.1188461632,
0.1427406371,
0.8478671908,
0.2829067409,
0.1731457412,
0.5640696287,
0.7576338053,
0.3420893848,
-0.0674865544,
1.1506105661,
0.0727629736,
0.2731773555,
1.2703127861,
-0.1947654486,
0.813098371,
0.6144661307,
-0.1105476692,
0.6328938007,
0.1446111798,
-0.3228888214,
0.6767745018,
0.2027692944,
-0.3138887286,
-0.4727362394,
0.1274372041,
-0.538462162,
0.3336490095,
0.1877794117,
-0.5201842785,
-0.3143085539,
0.4624050856,
-0.5084050894,
-0.0005819317,
-0.2572150528,
0.7555044889,
0.1569066048,
-0.191839546,
0.5609047413,
-0.0943232924,
0.6514102817,
-1.0268445015,
-0.4229774177,
-0.1517474949,
0.2024702281,
0.0560936593,
-0.7572571039,
0.0034249136,
-0.2391516268,
-0.5208863616,
-0.4942930341,
0.760251224,
-0.59405303,
-0.678332746,
0.2979467809,
0.3583100438,
-0.2280804217,
0.2216747552,
-0.7880910039,
0.3909690678,
0.0770277902,
-0.3571834266,
0.3382644951,
0.2361800522,
0.1325066388,
0.9527580738,
0.8739652038,
-0.3847671449,
0.4525454938,
0.4372609854,
0.8643089533,
-0.9268698692,
-0.3267741501,
-0.7350586653,
0.7482181191,
0.2080813199,
-0.1247978285,
0.8853462338,
0.4797857702,
0.9570489526,
-0.4107148051,
0.7880623937,
0.0499977469,
0.2110506743,
-0.5924386382,
0.6977671981,
-0.5973599553,
0.1192147806,
-0.0292820297,
-0.3896084428,
-0.3177488446,
0.792529583,
0.0203445014,
-0.0344964266,
0.5113502145,
0.9495871067,
-0.0360109732,
0.0944191888,
0.5077438951,
0.2874645591,
0.1754760444,
0.5458218455,
1.1661260128,
-0.2626788616,
0.6781690717,
-0.4136078656,
-0.0725929439,
-0.078381218,
-1.0089873075,
-0.8543900251,
-0.5560050607,
-0.1911646873,
-0.3118713498,
0.2722893953,
0.7006452084,
0.6966952682,
-0.6397747993,
-0.3010868132,
-0.0452947356,
0.2654213309,
-0.3630737066,
-0.2260103077,
-0.2677286267,
-0.2896129489,
-0.3744930327,
0.5965334177,
0.3334187865,
0.021674633,
-0.3319327831,
0.0779343769,
-0.4094670117,
-0.2622916698,
0.9636119008,
0.4841062725,
-0.8300955296,
-0.3031107187,
-0.027436167,
-0.1433554441,
0.0647539645,
1.153881073,
-1.0791578293,
0.7885575294,
0.6740283966,
0.6457192898,
0.628290832,
-0.1286411136,
0.7135302424,
-0.7019255757,
0.1425288171,
0.1145791635,
0.4104316533,
0.1624847054,
0.0238579493,
0.1219981238,
0.3544235528,
-0.3443484604,
-0.6934096217,
0.4356621802,
-1.1225773096,
-0.2469522804,
0.9141557813,
-0.1537512243,
-0.2628030777,
-0.0732377246,
-0.0885926262,
-0.0272445437,
-0.2688319981,
0.4937011003,
0.3761874735,
-0.0054589137,
-0.9138441682,
-0.5985321403,
0.0824251473,
0.2204321176,
-0.3922866285,
-0.0299703162,
0.5355424881,
0.4365382493,
-0.1300431788,
0.2662598789,
-0.159946993,
0.6081920266,
0.0192703009,
0.1776915789,
-0.7740318775,
-0.3345039189,
-0.7429136634,
0.1879606247,
-0.1501193792,
-0.2242432833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13361v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13361v1 | Improving Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual Transfer via Progressive Code-Switching | 2024-06-19T09:06:24 | 2024-06-19T09:06:24 | Zhuoran Li, Chunming Hu, Junfan Chen, Zhijun Chen, Xiaohui Guo, Richong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Code-switching is a data augmentation scheme mixing words from multiple
languages into source lingual text. It has achieved considerable generalization
performance of cross-lingual transfer tasks by aligning cross-lingual
contextual word representations. However, uncontrolled and over-replaced
code-switching would augment dirty samples to model training. In other words,
the excessive code-switching text samples will negatively hurt the models'
cross-lingual transferability. To this end, we propose a Progressive
Code-Switching (PCS) method to gradually generate moderately difficult
code-switching examples for the model to discriminate from easy to hard. The
idea is to incorporate progressively the preceding learned multilingual
knowledge using easier code-switching data to guide model optimization on
succeeding harder code-switching data. Specifically, we first design a
difficulty measurer to measure the impact of replacing each word in a sentence
based on the word relevance score. Then a code-switcher generates the
code-switching data of increasing difficulty via a controllable temperature
variable. In addition, a training scheduler decides when to sample harder
code-switching data for model training. Experiments show our model achieves
state-of-the-art results on three different zero-shot cross-lingual transfer
tasks across ten languages. | [
-0.1511173695,
-0.6997491121,
0.2749926746,
0.3646988273,
-0.2343153358,
0.1726384312,
-0.3223830163,
-0.3557980657,
-0.2285815924,
0.4003982842,
-0.3342223465,
-0.2574072778,
-0.3610810339,
0.1894628704,
-0.3449596763,
1.0491234064,
-0.4877584279,
0.059079133,
0.1186944395,
0.1317551881,
-0.6291180849,
-0.2779527903,
-0.5109534264,
-0.6504791975,
0.2836659551,
0.6325619221,
0.7878190279,
0.4608562887,
0.3504699469,
0.1977263838,
0.1220011786,
-0.2824068666,
-0.6376473308,
-0.0376215316,
-0.360585928,
-0.6841505766,
-0.4102027416,
-0.2041626871,
0.3873759806,
0.743268609,
-0.1290011257,
-0.1103215218,
-0.1072787866,
0.7021542788,
-0.5859730244,
0.1556538492,
-0.669675529,
0.5097039342,
-0.3596099019,
-0.4230285585,
-0.5046687126,
0.0019114293,
-0.1726240665,
-0.4884198904,
0.251876235,
-0.42608127,
0.8195124269,
-0.2284658402,
-0.3508847356,
-0.1167843714,
-0.9533430338,
0.8044064641,
-0.5623987913,
0.6345604658,
0.3202968836,
0.1799181402,
0.4016308188,
-0.5590816736,
-0.5582776666,
-0.3614458442,
0.2963769138,
0.1093618795,
-0.2788720131,
-0.121387288,
0.0786857828,
0.1294828355,
-0.4941839874,
-0.1321616322,
-0.4504840672,
-0.1448729336,
0.4904702604,
0.1457614154,
0.5859284401,
0.1412726641,
-0.2580160201,
-0.2020913959,
-0.7113418579,
0.142364949,
0.2746703923,
0.4872631431,
-0.099957183,
0.3612778187,
-0.3912593722,
0.8683758378,
0.3504427373,
-0.1517922282,
0.6277512908,
-0.6440817118,
-0.1961381882,
0.0069413185,
0.2847759128,
0.3398084342,
0.3293687999,
-0.4590959251,
-0.2104752511,
0.1237867624,
0.1962319613,
-0.8062107563,
-0.4000291526,
-0.0414218307,
-0.3193621635,
-0.3661780059,
-0.1444114745,
-0.7877714634,
0.0790728629,
-0.3652848899,
0.3845848441,
-0.661645174,
-0.4496018589,
0.4899298549,
-0.1400020272,
0.3340528607,
0.2065514475,
-0.7881195545,
0.1550540626,
0.1944852471,
0.8959003091,
-0.4004890025,
-0.4293323457,
-0.5797758102,
0.1740662605,
-0.5118472576,
0.5737211704,
-0.898285985,
-0.5990764499,
0.033339899,
0.2074734271,
-0.2653412521,
-0.3980041444,
-0.0439407341,
-0.554002285,
0.3589678705,
0.0645503253,
-0.2304666638,
0.0471896343,
0.3685461283,
-0.4005663395,
0.9521821737,
0.1952854246,
-0.4878723919,
0.1776943207,
-0.3819451034,
-0.6723473072,
0.1085366234,
-0.016328685,
-0.4502017498,
0.0069797067,
0.0955905542,
0.2259234935,
0.2113998979,
0.018636426,
-0.0900493339,
-0.5932055712,
0.072582081,
-0.4072474539,
0.6563379169,
0.0898364559,
-0.5869032741,
-0.1853268594,
-0.6619263887,
0.1724348664,
-0.0739023015,
-0.5924493074,
-0.4654487073,
-0.3854619563,
0.1966220886,
0.4222516716,
0.2116355002,
-0.391510725,
0.5338140726,
-0.1179183647,
0.1079851016,
0.4373544753,
-0.2063915581,
0.7982779145,
-0.3456851542,
0.975538671,
0.1639728099,
0.1446701139,
-0.2708863318,
-0.5120620728,
-0.6807433963,
0.1825547814,
0.4502078295,
0.9622440338,
-1.6146445274,
0.0619888045,
-0.1816182435,
-0.4164675176,
-0.4600646794,
0.4334054589,
0.6501016617,
0.4055395424,
0.4470086098,
-0.5637175441,
-0.1725550294,
-0.426438868,
-0.1836194694,
-0.0260732695,
-0.0594249479,
0.1092542857,
0.303253144,
-0.1436965019,
0.7555992603,
-0.4429628551,
-0.1208046898,
-0.465412885,
0.2638210952,
0.1682008207,
0.5969811082,
0.2726497054,
-0.8319228292,
-0.8633391857,
0.2924689949,
-0.3862453401,
-0.2690358758,
-0.5836958885,
-0.1384332776,
0.2786309421,
0.8034457564,
-0.2654847205,
0.2068730593,
0.6372345686,
-0.3903940916,
0.6964015961,
-0.255756259,
0.254756391,
-0.6467077136,
0.1318318397,
-0.1713362932,
-0.1601608247,
-0.9975990057,
0.2168379724,
0.3430942595,
-0.2248411179,
-0.9655251503,
0.4381768405,
-0.6149433255,
0.2949538231,
-0.1684338152,
-0.2253015637,
0.1185452268,
0.6143246293,
0.1730125993,
0.7374332547,
0.6247528791,
-0.6048820615,
0.2689187527,
-0.0641298369,
-0.0175916832,
0.6580230594,
-0.3435100019,
0.3579958081,
0.0339949876,
0.0456546135,
-0.9983336329,
0.3548533916,
0.4354784489,
-0.1699591726,
0.6475375295,
-0.2829026878,
-0.1398808211,
-0.1019963846,
-0.1895852387,
0.708782196,
0.4471439123,
-0.2811555266,
0.3681587875,
-0.008173096,
-0.3620616496,
-0.293374896,
-1.0145173073,
0.4348509908,
-0.0368543714,
-0.3679764867,
0.8148726821,
-0.1548020691,
0.1128425226,
0.0617659241,
-0.0598417334,
-0.2261375487,
-0.3859805465,
-0.2353654653,
0.3886495531,
-0.0738969594,
0.1080264598,
0.0438970998,
-0.1231238544,
-0.2390588373,
-0.2653018534,
0.6469385028,
-0.0700313449,
-0.2205285281,
-0.028365029,
0.3687753975,
0.2559973001,
-0.1478918195,
0.2430954576,
0.7588247657,
-0.0718019381,
-0.0846152529,
-0.1195860505,
0.0079705855,
-0.4562988281,
0.5933982134,
-0.6892626882,
-0.6544394493,
0.3740176558,
-0.1275940239,
0.0348393209,
-0.0145632355,
0.4559445083,
0.2780792415,
0.9702854753,
0.9653725624,
-0.0349998698,
0.7374853492,
-0.1845521629,
0.185953334,
-0.4264546633,
-0.0197925735,
-0.279376626,
-0.2914942205,
-0.5317337513,
-0.906737268,
0.1396913677,
0.1389386803,
-0.147548601,
0.5153343678,
-0.4406858385,
0.4939471781,
0.0831224471,
0.2694569826,
0.3625994027,
0.1595094353,
-0.1248368099,
-0.1539999098,
-0.8207079172,
0.091081664,
0.9545255303,
0.2600547075,
0.9793717861,
0.0708337203,
0.5992942452,
0.1762687564,
0.1348154247,
-0.5718644857,
0.6184856296,
-0.5311173797,
-0.4587420821,
-0.3019097745,
-0.6622223258,
-0.8666142821,
0.1215778068,
0.043772541,
-0.3593750298,
0.5142490864,
-0.0400714204,
-0.0771825761,
0.4508209527,
-0.6697320342,
0.6251490712,
-0.2609469891,
-0.5533495545,
-0.0564057082,
-0.5385712385,
0.5122513771,
-0.1800738424,
0.2172852159,
0.1601859927,
-0.1998940408,
0.3360376954,
-0.0370820872,
1.0062156916,
-0.2468669862,
-0.4169837534,
0.051790528,
0.4644910991,
0.2919846475,
-0.2749799788,
-0.1440766305,
0.3691831827,
-0.283818543,
-0.491994381,
-0.4673197567,
0.3584809303,
-0.5609804988,
-0.2820293605,
-0.2688415647,
-0.5441988111,
-0.289750427,
0.1665651351,
0.3006382883,
0.2347843498,
-0.0176966172,
0.0337252431,
0.6041378379,
-0.4188221693,
0.4649088681,
0.8069801927,
-0.3984069526,
-0.1619303524,
1.3564082384,
0.218696177,
0.5906034112,
0.5166209936,
-0.0091087511,
-0.0189075358,
-0.4089778662,
-0.697426796,
-0.1392200142,
-0.403612107,
-0.2480095327,
-0.234637484,
-0.1947157234,
-0.2591733634,
-0.4352037311,
-0.4391561151,
-0.2583940923,
-0.2437589318,
0.1525910497,
0.1388739198,
0.1133819818,
-0.1617388427,
0.1886444092,
-0.8248032928,
0.5403029919,
0.3636862934,
0.577973187,
-0.2879349887,
-0.7057247162,
-0.323151201,
-0.0349720493,
-0.2912978232,
-1.0542019606,
0.5374016762,
0.5121834278,
0.2646299899,
0.310746789,
0.052579768,
0.7557138205,
-0.5554305315,
0.6816208959,
0.5577109456,
-1.1514780521,
0.303366214,
-0.239628315,
0.833494544,
0.6665717959,
0.2632500529,
-0.8048774004,
-0.4336738586,
-0.2258080542,
-0.9924327135,
0.641982317,
0.1063715667,
0.5100110173,
0.0592776276,
0.3348037004,
0.2119449526,
0.2308624238,
-0.8857806325,
0.0414091572,
-0.4087614417,
0.2122672349,
0.075715147,
0.1699615419,
0.1450424343,
-0.5077863336,
0.5169330239,
-0.3365210891,
0.2739961743,
0.1366036534,
-0.2626739442,
-0.3068814874,
0.512124002,
0.4789239168,
0.6194449067,
-0.1101296842,
0.0621006154,
0.3169292212,
-0.5785769224,
0.3360488415,
0.0282728001,
-0.3512076139,
0.3169234395,
0.2475733608,
0.7986834049,
0.4387682974,
-0.5281664133,
0.3820699453,
0.1241547093,
-0.3113056719,
0.2122469395,
0.1107603535,
-0.0111132553,
-0.0385003984,
0.220810771,
0.1783281118,
0.0851405859,
-0.8790286779,
0.4244406819,
0.1252719462,
-0.443187505,
-0.329724282,
0.361913085,
0.3362413943,
-0.334656179,
0.7534305453,
-0.3520186245,
-0.4981838167,
0.5936477184,
0.7871629596,
0.7509303093,
-0.5478747487,
0.5105286837,
0.0671634153,
0.179348588,
-0.15617688,
0.4468717277,
-0.1705028415,
-0.8061103225,
-0.5345876813,
-0.2894349396,
-0.4596908987,
-0.1893240362,
-0.7676256895,
0.4334030747,
-0.1058631167,
-0.064592354,
-0.4248240292,
-0.1394992173,
-0.872943759,
0.2190691382,
0.3127588034,
1.0243468285,
-0.8548157811,
1.2054703236,
0.5877808928,
-0.3326993883,
-0.4537095726,
0.1704904139,
-0.3278102279,
-0.9399942756,
0.5704482198,
-0.0282140076,
-0.1046813577,
-0.1439823657,
-0.3519403338,
-0.3258237541,
0.9571627975,
0.393139571,
-1.0720163584,
-0.1487533748,
0.3186779916,
0.6122231483,
-0.3421791792,
0.3404661715,
0.6570423841,
0.4162406921,
0.1461863518,
-0.9727730155,
0.0943667218,
-0.5487644672,
0.0825266838,
0.1745906919,
-0.5275824666,
1.0732632875,
-0.3180621266,
-0.1992799491,
-0.2188494205,
0.3199739456,
0.0937300473,
0.5219902396,
0.771034658,
0.3432382643,
0.3239943683,
0.2330583036,
0.7470318675,
-0.5801771879,
0.2664291561,
0.9752568603,
-0.4920908213,
1.0527626276,
0.6018043756,
-0.2667494118,
0.6207857132,
0.3398697078,
-0.1265291274,
0.7139182687,
0.3363425732,
-0.2039967477,
-0.2453158796,
0.1389817148,
-0.6872279644,
0.4662331343,
0.1534114182,
-0.1263649315,
-0.4753573835,
0.2632024586,
0.2267039418,
-0.1469354779,
-0.1921022832,
0.5979180336,
-0.0760628358,
-0.5931797624,
0.8180305362,
0.2310890704,
1.0087627172,
-0.7873361111,
-0.1962596774,
-0.4967581928,
0.0312031638,
-0.1483985335,
-0.8798609972,
0.4212091565,
0.0740991831,
-0.0436052494,
-0.6229884028,
0.716204524,
-0.8662890196,
-0.7056053877,
0.4818710089,
0.606764853,
0.2055502534,
-0.0419055149,
-0.89307338,
0.1041962281,
0.2229579538,
-0.1100030169,
0.6388815641,
0.4521332979,
0.0132286493,
0.2851232588,
0.6503237486,
0.2759930789,
0.02270988,
0.2406139672,
0.9431667924,
-0.7565817833,
-0.6919606328,
-0.6736556888,
0.3972314,
0.172050029,
-0.3686181307,
0.4715205431,
0.3854888976,
0.9519717097,
-0.1663609594,
0.7897673249,
-0.1023159996,
-0.0177869666,
-0.5680155754,
0.6438099742,
-0.6013646126,
0.3477939069,
-0.4324262142,
-0.7009070516,
-0.2867439687,
0.4584327042,
-0.2626225352,
0.0278284773,
0.5116106868,
0.9106619954,
-0.2625419497,
-0.3946585953,
0.5511276126,
0.1223299056,
0.3506163359,
1.0679980516,
0.4162316024,
-0.4946226776,
1.0192445517,
-0.4479266703,
-0.3318776786,
-0.1740940809,
-0.9887871742,
-0.5826274753,
-0.4127289653,
-0.7000794411,
-0.4230245054,
0.5739213824,
0.2963232994,
0.7058838606,
-0.7461152673,
-0.4968664348,
-0.3314858079,
-0.0012102682,
-0.5979781747,
-0.3525992036,
0.0867621079,
-0.5614309311,
-0.6829568744,
0.3631528616,
0.2813931704,
-0.1733884513,
-0.3299425542,
-0.1253412962,
-0.1090647131,
0.1162803993,
0.6325455904,
0.5081729293,
-0.1756166667,
-0.1971737593,
0.2260920852,
-0.2024050057,
0.1283322871,
0.9437989593,
-0.7859457135,
0.7197400331,
0.6297569871,
0.6288797259,
0.5353035331,
-0.3071652353,
0.7421214581,
-0.8311573863,
0.0217397362,
0.0028866108,
0.0445586592,
0.3678664565,
-0.3484295309,
0.3418150246,
0.4025096595,
-0.2527631223,
-0.8319275975,
0.1601549834,
-0.7808511853,
-0.6069068313,
1.3641201258,
-0.163107574,
0.0130715631,
-0.4367580414,
-0.1703708768,
0.132991612,
-0.272698909,
0.9842846394,
0.6361686587,
-0.2702318728,
-0.376064539,
-0.4835295975,
0.3644070029,
0.62019521,
-0.6702892184,
-0.0564812683,
0.1354945749,
0.4780966341,
0.2358130664,
0.8865622282,
-0.2392726243,
0.5139934421,
0.1336313188,
0.295278877,
-0.0418406241,
-0.3994642496,
-0.5981495976,
0.2641234398,
-0.4212840199,
-0.3464664221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13357v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13357v1 | Transferable speech-to-text large language model alignment module | 2024-06-19T09:04:43 | 2024-06-19T09:04:43 | Boyong Wu, Chao Yan, Haoran Pu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | By leveraging the power of Large Language Models(LLMs) and speech foundation
models, state of the art speech-text bimodal works can achieve challenging
tasks like spoken translation(ST) and question answering(SQA) altogether with
much simpler architectures. In this paper, we utilize the capability of Whisper
encoder and pre-trained Yi-6B. Empirical results reveal that modal alignment
can be achieved with one layer module and hundred hours of speech-text
multitask corpus. We further swap the Yi-6B with human preferences aligned
version of Yi-6B-Chat during inference, and discover that the alignment
capability is applicable as well. In addition, the alignment subspace revealed
by singular value decomposition(SVD) also implies linear alignment subspace is
sparse, which leaves the possibility to concatenate other features like
voice-print or video to expand modality. | [
0.009901694,
-0.6637557745,
0.4238595366,
0.127003774,
-0.1729474962,
0.0254230443,
-0.2497584522,
-0.5065899491,
0.0696868896,
0.5783174634,
-0.7571702003,
-0.3216174543,
-0.3936168849,
-0.0969292372,
-0.3952492177,
0.8483838439,
0.3279325962,
-0.0316505544,
-0.18101421,
-0.1489206553,
-0.753403008,
-0.3720462918,
-0.2346312106,
-0.0575654618,
0.6019671559,
0.2419769317,
0.7829393148,
0.5968945622,
0.3666701019,
0.3058858812,
0.0297114979,
0.2330044359,
-0.3620439768,
-0.0199054331,
-0.2338530868,
-0.4381669462,
-0.7520000935,
-0.2954143882,
0.8193592429,
0.707903862,
-0.0262875967,
0.0834650621,
-0.0238201041,
0.3590175211,
-0.305739224,
0.1465246975,
-0.6871024966,
-0.3783780038,
-0.2837093174,
0.0757992566,
-0.5623911023,
-0.3134003878,
0.4648920298,
-0.5542250276,
-0.3031409383,
0.0640143082,
0.8316330314,
0.4100989103,
-0.7469881773,
-0.1297462583,
-0.8106684685,
0.8618069887,
-0.9622845054,
0.6241445541,
0.195370242,
0.3446354866,
0.0468253121,
-0.6453097463,
-0.9009379148,
0.1173844635,
0.0230706036,
0.1093043759,
-0.0066603092,
0.4170122445,
0.138076961,
0.1787070781,
-0.6489234567,
0.2154681087,
-0.3366531432,
-0.3325083852,
0.543710947,
0.125166446,
0.5148233175,
-0.4482378364,
-0.4233959615,
-0.0459023342,
-0.3628988862,
0.0929176286,
0.3305179179,
0.4758202732,
-0.3273911774,
0.6049656868,
0.1059910804,
0.9488444328,
0.1066335365,
-0.5903400779,
0.5385231972,
-0.5362330675,
-0.2572984695,
0.1941179037,
0.7597768903,
0.1876042485,
-0.100289017,
-0.1823605299,
-0.0120052686,
-0.0156725105,
0.4348708093,
-0.5217964053,
0.3014480472,
0.1121003106,
-0.4958165884,
0.0009658428,
-0.090480648,
-0.609115541,
-0.0788376853,
-0.4670287967,
0.8571377397,
-0.3724235594,
-0.3045687675,
0.3518015146,
0.0775863752,
0.5928472281,
0.4334874153,
-0.999622643,
0.0305271298,
0.684019506,
0.7688321471,
-0.427437216,
-0.2456337512,
-0.3875086904,
0.528036952,
-0.2485705763,
0.5119028687,
-0.4993957877,
-0.0707460046,
0.1854448318,
0.0200849269,
-0.3387892544,
-0.2665677667,
0.6318696737,
-0.490540266,
0.4707102478,
-0.0382662602,
-0.6143621802,
-0.383387208,
0.0461081713,
-0.5485254526,
0.8945816755,
0.1716930568,
-0.5663025379,
-0.0971867517,
-0.3671463132,
-0.3694113493,
-0.0994389951,
-0.123942405,
-0.2536742091,
0.0271704849,
0.1437360197,
0.3941212893,
-0.2199394852,
0.2570004761,
-0.2159211934,
-0.1763977557,
0.4762882292,
-0.5866064429,
0.676505506,
0.2358409017,
-0.2673204839,
0.3842174113,
-0.6869159341,
0.0945785642,
-0.4240743816,
-0.2578959167,
-0.1719851196,
-0.0641069189,
0.277059257,
0.1515698284,
0.5425673127,
-0.4605646729,
0.2469257116,
-0.4400296211,
0.5642837286,
0.6156303883,
-0.2990615666,
0.6353930831,
-0.4306413233,
0.3978744745,
-0.0936427042,
0.1919346005,
-0.1027470529,
-0.4234794378,
-0.6750452518,
-0.5329073668,
0.356387198,
0.6133647561,
-0.707917273,
0.6181973815,
-0.5942703485,
-0.4668942988,
-0.9341597557,
-0.0564146526,
0.4212779105,
0.6180885434,
0.2715238929,
-0.0389410444,
-0.3146885931,
-1.2002586126,
0.1119414344,
-0.2927681804,
0.0426750071,
0.1620869488,
0.0006450755,
-0.1913783848,
0.7793803811,
-0.3001022339,
-0.2395811528,
-0.3412113488,
-0.022559287,
0.2781389058,
0.5038083792,
0.4912184179,
-0.8724985123,
-0.3775001168,
0.2470122576,
-0.402251482,
-0.2957776785,
-0.1861081421,
-0.1391820461,
0.1688671708,
0.3940520883,
-0.8013131022,
0.3174400032,
0.7858294249,
-0.2384121716,
0.3448322117,
0.052524142,
0.3257536292,
-1.6189812422,
0.1258461773,
-0.3976399302,
-0.4021374583,
-0.920401752,
-0.2326302081,
0.2094209194,
-0.0522632599,
-0.3995132446,
0.3617191017,
-0.4376439154,
-0.2920374274,
-0.3859657347,
0.2606332898,
0.0296703037,
0.4757319093,
0.0397425853,
0.7843950391,
0.4263378084,
-0.2850393057,
0.3467911184,
0.5652320385,
-0.5237631798,
0.4905027151,
-0.5387738943,
0.3832785487,
-0.0091475416,
0.0930408537,
-1.1885639429,
-0.2479543835,
0.0582227819,
-0.4612278938,
0.3639928102,
-0.2620265484,
-0.2667874396,
0.1910405308,
-0.1311750561,
0.5555476546,
0.5550060868,
-0.4205001891,
0.9188191891,
0.3257860541,
-0.5858832598,
-0.6615605354,
-0.5398671627,
0.1309620738,
-0.1901733875,
-0.90348351,
0.6674841046,
-0.1775709987,
0.0432689823,
-0.1218320131,
-0.006249181,
-0.0703380555,
-0.3751453161,
0.2945008278,
0.6519969702,
-0.4422122538,
0.1244712546,
0.1604170054,
0.1086914614,
-0.3068395853,
-0.0654829666,
0.5314782262,
0.0806575716,
-0.4891235232,
-0.682376802,
0.587792635,
0.870557189,
-0.222163409,
0.461025238,
0.4457182288,
-0.4828801751,
-0.035230238,
-0.8710196614,
0.125438869,
-0.4484801888,
0.6166993976,
-0.2382656187,
-1.0508458614,
0.3125054836,
0.1298006475,
0.2224931866,
0.1570899338,
0.5277376771,
-0.0238635391,
1.0548475981,
0.7162892818,
-0.3671105802,
0.5574617982,
0.2957926393,
0.3446807861,
-0.8055461049,
-0.3408502936,
-0.6641667485,
-0.4206138849,
-0.1797043979,
-0.550167501,
0.2865855098,
-0.0130486637,
-0.0489152484,
0.4177671969,
-0.3671380281,
0.0238426551,
0.2695654333,
0.0194566008,
0.2740296423,
-0.155379802,
0.2996979654,
-0.280457288,
-0.4334252775,
-0.414326638,
0.6923205256,
0.3354582787,
0.7987558842,
0.4099954069,
0.3079848886,
-0.0219130609,
0.0280730389,
-0.9474858642,
0.4822506011,
-0.2232776135,
-0.5806734562,
-0.3439526856,
-0.1738059223,
-0.5201749206,
0.1535021365,
-0.3066176474,
-0.8956604004,
0.2786296904,
-0.104881987,
-0.4093324244,
0.0224292763,
-0.9636448622,
0.8672206402,
-0.3737916052,
-0.1649244279,
-0.196207121,
-0.7060669065,
0.1834004521,
-0.0898883194,
0.2713424265,
-0.0106332824,
-0.2311557829,
0.8066956401,
-0.2745759487,
1.022143364,
0.0501824021,
-0.2867158055,
0.1029195786,
-0.195925191,
0.3339433372,
-0.3312306702,
0.0010023019,
-0.0592541434,
0.13824898,
-0.1842287481,
-0.8289487958,
0.5770912766,
-0.9193308353,
-0.7149655223,
-0.250760287,
-0.9055104256,
-0.4604061544,
0.2124052644,
-0.0161628891,
0.6922172904,
-0.0435278937,
0.3878448606,
0.7461944818,
-0.1774211377,
0.4584224522,
0.388081789,
-0.2870283723,
-0.5962576866,
0.8324486613,
0.127944231,
0.5900518298,
0.675457418,
0.1573257595,
-0.5685433149,
-0.7166228294,
-0.5594189167,
0.2890071571,
-0.397488147,
-0.2002310902,
-0.7349479198,
-0.5194864273,
-0.6909467578,
-0.4050340354,
-0.419451952,
-0.4316117465,
-0.3277495205,
-0.1305182427,
0.2200290114,
0.5694529414,
0.1373035014,
0.3707284033,
-1.0389614105,
0.3332177103,
0.5708828568,
-0.1109378412,
-0.2161643207,
-0.9723801613,
-0.1188548952,
0.1350882649,
-0.0191834848,
-0.8866318464,
0.3375507295,
0.3130752146,
0.4721340537,
0.5374742746,
0.0066851373,
1.0059124231,
-0.3773917258,
0.8960356712,
0.4558964968,
-1.0775762796,
0.2430437505,
-0.5437785387,
0.3208738565,
0.4162607491,
0.1768587828,
-0.6515513659,
-0.0156947933,
-0.2066876888,
-0.55492419,
0.6045630574,
0.0166571531,
0.279533416,
0.383084774,
0.4566705525,
0.2944546044,
0.1431711167,
-0.6106284857,
-0.0203223564,
-0.3309187889,
-0.7257481217,
-0.0264935642,
-0.2066807598,
-0.040236406,
-0.2212427855,
0.534748137,
-0.3323435783,
0.2230175138,
0.0993361995,
-0.1826667041,
0.2048674077,
0.4946480095,
0.6557822227,
0.596984148,
-0.0465983525,
0.2825618982,
0.0146516273,
-0.4022224844,
0.1323127747,
0.2057406306,
-0.1274922639,
-0.1927699,
0.4690124393,
0.8746030927,
0.4410497248,
-0.7414613962,
0.6780695319,
0.1677329838,
-0.1881733984,
-0.1075496152,
0.0035305596,
0.5394533873,
0.4617648125,
0.3135070205,
-0.1641136706,
0.045114655,
-0.7296302915,
-0.0133061409,
0.600369513,
-0.5914416909,
-0.5675527453,
0.5939195752,
0.2347242236,
-0.4691365361,
0.4330815673,
0.2815952599,
-0.5196933746,
0.2055491954,
0.8203735948,
0.7059844732,
-0.2943637371,
0.1513248235,
0.0271949228,
0.2291983068,
0.0018668625,
0.2685538828,
0.0338046253,
-0.9087687731,
-0.7012382746,
-0.5487819314,
-0.3863869607,
0.1032046527,
-0.7542185187,
0.2274933457,
-0.1449768394,
-0.0877443627,
0.2181354761,
-0.2218322903,
-0.4124104977,
-0.0353292339,
0.1475128829,
0.6141210198,
-0.584685266,
1.0899283886,
0.6901313663,
-0.1825055033,
-0.9806945324,
-0.199588716,
0.1302152425,
-0.81428653,
0.514300108,
0.0878151506,
-0.2078846544,
0.0662393793,
-0.4567842782,
-0.8524113894,
1.1650028229,
0.624368012,
-0.704059422,
-0.3178768158,
0.2549608052,
0.3732388914,
-0.4235987663,
0.0678886697,
0.3115318716,
0.4167096317,
0.1529520005,
-1.3912285566,
-0.0942088068,
-0.1562003642,
-0.0017755628,
0.1153696626,
-0.8096939325,
0.5598990917,
0.0125905639,
-0.215539366,
0.232962355,
0.9095161557,
-0.2279662341,
0.0622143745,
0.6597168446,
0.4820865691,
0.5827633739,
0.0877201483,
0.4661978185,
0.007580115,
-0.0796971992,
1.0057266951,
-0.461890012,
1.0372322798,
0.5801932216,
-0.025597427,
0.4179544151,
0.2225441486,
0.3302882314,
0.5677596331,
-0.3144104183,
-0.4830980897,
-0.5545821786,
-0.2782345116,
-0.2653189003,
0.6680300832,
0.3745160699,
0.0336730964,
0.0518867038,
0.032112848,
-0.1875738055,
0.1001384482,
-0.2085809261,
0.9865282178,
0.0772476196,
-0.6727892756,
0.3223141134,
-0.1829534024,
0.9705581665,
-0.9986010194,
-0.0096313749,
0.1370761693,
0.0518719181,
-0.2420343608,
-0.5746166706,
0.2858094275,
-0.3387120962,
-0.3735066652,
-0.2774138153,
0.9432523251,
-0.7372130752,
-0.164855808,
0.1506470144,
0.5710519552,
-0.0671103746,
0.1654708683,
-0.4044306278,
0.1965098083,
0.2367101014,
-0.0630245581,
0.5914023519,
0.3227908909,
0.0888447091,
0.6111838818,
0.6106094718,
-0.0258248914,
0.3275200725,
0.074170135,
0.8140137196,
-0.6716319323,
-0.4255051911,
-0.5468127728,
0.5027691126,
-0.0422076583,
-0.334644407,
0.6112369299,
0.4808255136,
0.5494351387,
-0.0860568881,
0.9149931073,
-0.075700447,
0.5761172175,
-0.7232170701,
0.6318718791,
-0.3132851124,
-0.0163679067,
-0.361017257,
-0.920135498,
-0.0245439615,
0.6032760143,
-0.0200305618,
-0.3260987997,
0.6595222354,
0.9931936264,
0.0664434209,
0.0426915959,
0.5481799245,
0.090356037,
0.3146159947,
0.5353913903,
0.8266499043,
-0.3964440227,
0.7034659982,
-0.077355966,
-0.3308662176,
-0.0804671124,
-0.8322458267,
-0.8600056171,
-0.9905831218,
-0.3544794321,
-0.1847035885,
-0.0129161468,
0.9220017195,
0.7265037894,
-0.3829815388,
-0.2553139925,
0.5930628777,
0.0039603082,
-0.2193989903,
-0.2211193889,
0.5071965456,
-0.1164320037,
-0.8646459579,
0.6316286922,
0.5071402788,
0.0998600349,
-0.205468744,
0.0050473646,
-0.334066093,
0.1278771609,
0.62915802,
0.0828038827,
-0.6998177171,
-0.7906222939,
0.2667523324,
-0.1762472689,
0.0006159057,
0.7836853266,
-0.4559858739,
0.3922612667,
0.6587747335,
1.0197389126,
0.358137548,
0.0511840321,
0.7388526797,
-0.5549769998,
0.0647233129,
0.1671727598,
0.2917358577,
0.3647092283,
-0.1564078629,
-0.0108230989,
0.0817951187,
-0.6064409614,
-0.7332977057,
0.2722804546,
-1.8105698824,
0.010420843,
1.2059950829,
0.0409795344,
-0.2911590934,
-0.3834378421,
-0.5366966128,
0.3092658818,
-0.2961679101,
0.5436493754,
0.6745350957,
0.0279115364,
-0.3248755932,
-0.4689446986,
0.3950533867,
0.4127168059,
-0.8697974682,
0.1089465544,
0.5574491024,
0.3745585382,
0.2148746997,
0.6713390946,
-0.3190751076,
0.1344677061,
-0.2263504267,
0.1844927073,
-0.0585136525,
0.057909932,
-0.3021947443,
0.0960653871,
0.0831448138,
-0.2474915236
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.