id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14774v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14774v1 | Evaluating Numerical Reasoning in Text-to-Image Models | 2024-06-20T22:56:31 | 2024-06-20T22:56:31 | Ivana Kajić, Olivia Wiles, Isabela Albuquerque, Matthias Bauer, Su Wang, Jordi Pont-Tuset, Aida Nematzadeh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Text-to-image generative models are capable of producing high-quality images
that often faithfully depict concepts described using natural language. In this
work, we comprehensively evaluate a range of text-to-image models on numerical
reasoning tasks of varying difficulty, and show that even the most advanced
models have only rudimentary numerical skills. Specifically, their ability to
correctly generate an exact number of objects in an image is limited to small
numbers, it is highly dependent on the context the number term appears in, and
it deteriorates quickly with each successive number. We also demonstrate that
models have poor understanding of linguistic quantifiers (such as "a few" or
"as many as"), the concept of zero, and struggle with more advanced concepts
such as partial quantities and fractional representations. We bundle prompts,
generated images and human annotations into GeckoNum, a novel benchmark for
evaluation of numerical reasoning. | [
-0.6450158358,
-0.7507883906,
0.8648600578,
0.4987634718,
-0.5082787871,
-0.2995869815,
-0.1535764486,
-0.3653519452,
-0.4006504714,
0.4557495415,
-0.2786026001,
-0.4806334972,
-0.5920608044,
0.4440529644,
-0.4473797977,
0.8108893633,
0.2331992686,
0.0088767512,
-0.8570514321,
-0.1455096602,
-0.5623860359,
-0.4434657991,
-0.5687734485,
-0.4289209247,
0.1443692148,
0.1786487699,
1.0055502653,
0.4155831635,
0.7987219095,
0.3341726661,
-0.2606230378,
0.0998831615,
-0.3470112681,
-0.1190246046,
-0.1769222915,
-0.227137655,
-0.0041947919,
-0.1808394194,
0.4639325142,
0.825519681,
0.0368270911,
0.1182228848,
-0.2719101608,
0.6922098398,
-0.5319926739,
0.1590900272,
-0.4102309644,
0.1523272246,
0.1471145898,
0.0842952803,
-0.7975822091,
-0.4330428541,
0.1700176895,
-0.9520446658,
0.1854298711,
-0.1198661104,
0.9164123535,
0.4547868967,
-0.4679846764,
-0.5470362902,
-0.7361419797,
0.6143045425,
-0.5895855427,
0.084748596,
0.3165827394,
0.2971003652,
0.0622806363,
-0.734297812,
-0.3117453754,
-0.363283664,
-0.0639950633,
0.1159735024,
-0.3367971182,
-0.1118273288,
0.8033003807,
0.1849075407,
-0.5098435879,
-0.1597589999,
-0.4555243254,
0.1150668487,
0.6552411318,
0.2702763379,
0.5417296886,
-0.4038512707,
-0.291809231,
-0.2020350993,
-0.3354192674,
-0.1229416579,
0.1951223314,
-0.0880603492,
-0.0662969276,
0.5909016728,
-0.0333292447,
1.0238347054,
-0.1281362474,
0.0952457413,
-0.0846617892,
-0.1262163073,
-0.3589836955,
-0.3922704458,
0.9734663367,
0.330231607,
0.5422238708,
-0.1644439548,
-0.2103513181,
0.4065527618,
0.3372556567,
-1.0304925442,
-0.3195106089,
-0.0455346406,
-0.3195241094,
-0.5730169415,
0.06045302,
-0.5785921216,
-0.3278726637,
-0.1953025609,
0.5389279127,
-0.6436679363,
0.0777906552,
0.3291039765,
-0.4150149524,
0.0759782717,
0.6617627144,
-0.7802091837,
0.3434019983,
0.6767867208,
0.7367916107,
0.2063092142,
-0.0181827024,
-0.0970971361,
-0.2572848201,
-0.8636217713,
1.219632268,
-0.7635238171,
-0.7233514786,
-0.4844992757,
-0.2889231443,
0.1169186011,
-0.5537685752,
0.6471439004,
-0.5390967727,
0.0422168262,
-0.2656493485,
-0.3674566448,
-0.4063875973,
0.0488460883,
-0.78622967,
0.7591623068,
-0.0412177928,
-0.5551275015,
0.1673354208,
-0.509491086,
-0.5038736463,
0.2086204141,
-0.3601211607,
-0.4086959362,
0.5322604775,
0.1453930438,
0.2633939385,
-0.9097105861,
0.3988982141,
-0.3856312335,
-0.4556111991,
0.4467038512,
-0.6344239712,
0.6293972135,
0.2059373558,
-0.0478073806,
-0.3968138397,
-0.776491046,
0.1807946265,
0.368491143,
-0.1006114781,
-0.456377387,
-0.0512968004,
-0.2218882143,
0.2661849856,
-0.012787208,
-0.2296138257,
0.271736443,
-0.2225392461,
0.5343495011,
0.4011504054,
0.1468046755,
0.4831839204,
-0.2242705226,
0.4513513446,
-0.0384555236,
-0.1197110713,
-0.5005074739,
-0.8412527442,
-0.7655462027,
-0.0195759982,
0.4408849478,
0.536000371,
-1.0282075405,
-0.0941482186,
-0.4817755818,
-0.636341691,
-0.1211350486,
-0.0972597599,
0.6075789332,
0.3975025713,
0.1581783593,
-0.5382376909,
0.0559614785,
-0.8124623895,
-0.1088916287,
0.0622103661,
-0.2523748279,
0.5308070183,
0.8833999038,
0.0727793425,
0.6367357373,
-0.5431957245,
0.1029398143,
0.4361456633,
0.8063892126,
0.023167029,
0.3394400775,
0.6055387259,
-0.8731710315,
-0.3839746118,
0.2172536999,
-1.1527024508,
0.0902200863,
-0.3542123139,
-0.0802017748,
0.0883188322,
0.2059553862,
-0.6561437845,
0.7533394098,
0.2022220492,
-0.4717618227,
0.393551439,
-0.3577236533,
0.2042918503,
-0.6151669025,
0.1887524277,
0.5972447395,
-0.0306595098,
-0.6180310845,
0.1706297845,
0.0858894363,
-0.6248647571,
-0.2719244957,
0.4572196007,
-0.4758249521,
-0.3244709373,
-0.1593163759,
-0.1963412017,
0.3074397743,
0.3782773912,
0.3812462091,
0.8393769264,
0.3495391309,
-0.5235567093,
0.3782049119,
0.1532370746,
-0.4649817646,
0.6119978428,
-1.0877701044,
0.5132619739,
-0.3702878952,
0.0286854189,
-0.9241400957,
-0.4163699448,
0.0701012164,
-0.59542346,
0.0701703429,
-0.2814211249,
-0.5147619247,
-0.3642113209,
-0.0003170058,
0.7603365183,
0.6382858157,
-0.1498221755,
0.68330127,
-0.0361866169,
-0.304073602,
-0.2914036214,
-0.6436101198,
0.2130051404,
-0.0066911653,
-0.7488111258,
0.3116690516,
0.0633471385,
-0.6191583276,
0.2121618241,
0.2449493408,
-0.4215390682,
-0.0385176018,
0.3074690998,
0.3712594509,
-0.1808545291,
0.3172940612,
0.0092944801,
-0.2885766029,
0.2746137977,
-0.1901987493,
0.1791925579,
-0.3138044477,
-0.5103115439,
-0.1373819262,
0.3612083197,
0.7475833893,
-0.2525576651,
0.3904519379,
0.2243813276,
-0.6262919307,
0.0152498232,
-0.2911028862,
0.0346184075,
-0.3580474555,
0.30356282,
-0.5729630589,
-0.2736030519,
0.434630394,
-0.0832392499,
-0.1858250499,
0.7625475526,
0.4336151183,
0.0296718348,
1.2969049215,
0.2190214843,
0.4862047434,
-0.0921699256,
-0.3663483858,
-0.1160814092,
-0.397562474,
-0.3830813169,
-0.6522948742,
0.1622419506,
-0.2120220661,
-0.7224180102,
0.2572251558,
0.0368088596,
-0.5096645355,
0.1817025691,
-0.8309337497,
0.8222904205,
0.343727529,
0.3192501366,
0.3899539411,
0.2275969237,
-0.161752373,
-0.1774545014,
-0.5649920702,
-0.7792669535,
0.75122118,
0.159884721,
0.8737318516,
-0.0352272615,
0.2918107212,
0.3430972397,
0.5947502255,
-0.970080018,
0.5920581818,
-0.6291388869,
-0.4563437104,
-0.2957034111,
-0.5255622864,
-0.4902213812,
0.2360096574,
-0.2234626561,
-0.3459527791,
0.3329528868,
0.0419995151,
-0.4643943012,
0.1874884814,
-0.7392123342,
0.8919042945,
-0.4364711344,
-0.3896290958,
-0.0603835285,
-0.4792209268,
0.5478491783,
-0.1781048924,
0.416446507,
-0.1417960078,
-0.0773101151,
0.5094649792,
-0.5945991874,
0.8051495552,
-0.0368781798,
-0.0757636428,
0.5007932782,
0.260215342,
0.2125473619,
0.0497748889,
-0.2431476116,
0.1836598068,
-0.0311282314,
-0.4397156239,
-0.9501289725,
0.2101927251,
-0.8080704212,
-0.336288482,
-0.3741248846,
-0.3517809808,
0.077969946,
-0.1264206171,
0.5855204463,
0.7249400616,
-0.1190549061,
0.1285688877,
0.7332641482,
-0.3993375301,
0.088999629,
-0.0664379895,
-0.1195519492,
-0.6560456157,
1.1080938578,
0.0988373682,
0.3507173061,
0.2318374962,
0.0413176976,
-0.3151012063,
-0.2266581953,
-0.7443178892,
0.1268744469,
-1.0921055079,
-0.2782776058,
-0.2052590549,
-0.112491712,
0.1358561069,
-0.179672122,
0.0237456951,
-0.5169814229,
-0.5823023915,
0.3333753347,
0.3804609776,
0.8565216064,
0.1100873649,
-0.081704773,
-0.7332952619,
0.5052693486,
0.6958472133,
0.1930827349,
0.2717609107,
-0.7722094655,
0.0659733638,
0.1410156041,
-0.3196215034,
-0.9149286151,
0.1964880824,
0.2251593024,
0.0917567015,
0.4059714973,
-0.0815776959,
0.7889940143,
-0.6315318942,
0.6621466279,
0.5080579519,
-1.0900195837,
0.5884009004,
-0.2335330993,
0.2821778953,
0.2585670054,
0.4904042482,
-0.3948383629,
0.1472836137,
-0.631860137,
-0.4985745549,
0.3215712309,
0.2743597627,
0.4328528345,
-0.2115792334,
0.4754395187,
-0.104136534,
-0.1326311678,
-0.7017313242,
0.0633504018,
-0.4833569527,
-0.1073442772,
0.1737448871,
-0.2280205786,
0.0127779944,
-0.4488526285,
0.2956559062,
-0.1870184541,
0.4947176576,
-0.026284039,
-0.0373953953,
0.0178906098,
0.2903822362,
0.8932546377,
0.5095404387,
0.1296455115,
-0.0011147524,
0.364276737,
-0.2204974294,
0.411567241,
0.010718693,
-0.3625440598,
0.1272485554,
0.4179069102,
1.0449883938,
0.4537376165,
-0.5378252268,
0.4744163752,
-0.2214232385,
-0.5626264811,
-0.1624863297,
-0.1035161912,
0.1738260835,
-0.1215119064,
0.4339340627,
0.4940893352,
0.1871544123,
-0.3842000663,
-0.0700351521,
0.3260140121,
-0.3243003786,
-0.3274896443,
0.7242306471,
0.1970703751,
-0.3611473143,
0.8761186004,
-0.4291935265,
-0.3369558454,
1.1041173935,
0.5230417848,
0.6971021891,
0.3196652234,
0.4281215072,
0.4761609137,
0.1996742636,
-0.2898858786,
0.2289347202,
-0.0535856821,
-0.7134078145,
-0.6520513892,
-0.3674038351,
-0.6365012527,
-0.2958426476,
-0.8320193887,
0.2819838822,
-0.4721798897,
-0.499858588,
0.5649328232,
-0.4389538169,
-0.6424019933,
0.5010174513,
0.1400295198,
0.8907642961,
-0.8779653907,
0.2475347668,
1.0659958124,
-0.8015204072,
-0.6987662911,
-0.2987053692,
-0.426215142,
-0.7978422046,
0.9233238101,
0.2221099138,
0.0849004537,
0.1543626189,
-0.8544465899,
-0.2198925614,
0.8087432981,
0.5189531446,
-0.4389978647,
-0.1267570704,
0.2396822572,
0.7370294333,
-0.1313887089,
0.4706502557,
0.1693498194,
0.4390066862,
0.6849210262,
-0.6397386193,
-0.0263449792,
-0.4743471146,
0.532158792,
0.2222554684,
-0.3919117749,
0.9667476416,
-0.5878450871,
-0.4407247305,
0.2721057832,
0.4174774587,
0.2541593313,
0.4680092037,
0.4285439253,
1.0018489361,
0.5179740787,
-0.3728159964,
1.1568984985,
-0.1010240987,
0.4798513055,
0.604924202,
-0.1326687634,
0.7440693974,
0.0528463647,
-0.2807528377,
0.5347499847,
0.5902138352,
-0.2971991599,
0.4593858719,
0.3375809193,
-0.3758652508,
-0.7215024829,
-0.1432235539,
-0.2763037384,
0.1692143828,
0.5213860273,
-0.3743529022,
-0.3454484046,
0.1534379572,
-0.3102485836,
0.3041844964,
-0.3706115186,
0.876811862,
0.3002289236,
-0.6780944467,
0.6715695858,
0.129379034,
0.3612798154,
-0.0220238119,
-0.3883420229,
-0.0201375484,
-0.2587199509,
-0.2066912502,
-0.9556372762,
0.3074546754,
0.3235008717,
-0.2246100754,
0.0379151367,
0.9741128683,
0.0972414985,
-0.8773475289,
-0.2193237692,
0.3514638543,
0.3972836435,
-0.207703501,
-0.6096598506,
0.0456774384,
-0.1295368522,
0.1068811491,
0.0006418606,
0.8694545031,
-0.1831048429,
0.6618816853,
0.5814594626,
-0.1975371093,
-0.2351165414,
0.1945107132,
0.7188934684,
-0.7742368579,
-0.0651335493,
-1.0562494993,
0.4708039165,
-0.0763126239,
-0.3679823279,
0.2230744511,
0.3346170187,
0.5473914742,
-0.3880746663,
0.8718060255,
0.1320753396,
-0.1032936946,
-0.4328805208,
0.5278095007,
-0.4090805054,
0.0795031041,
-0.3612051606,
-0.6400367022,
-0.4912144542,
0.9821455479,
-0.6651411653,
0.0824275836,
0.3764922917,
0.4447998703,
-0.0028420414,
0.1255873889,
0.5773267746,
-0.2613811791,
-0.070426546,
0.6555842757,
1.1078730822,
-0.5114523768,
0.6506440639,
-0.2785356343,
-0.0640902221,
0.0794593692,
-1.0394698381,
-0.8667553663,
-0.3784990907,
-0.3041766584,
-0.2661004364,
-0.0301943589,
0.5030840039,
0.5850601792,
-0.4725041091,
0.0789825544,
-0.4096879363,
-0.0466203578,
0.0613981485,
-0.1983189285,
0.0918721482,
-0.1821693033,
-0.5932885408,
-0.3672032058,
0.4859409928,
0.5051705241,
-0.1802146882,
-0.0533089042,
0.4945107996,
0.1584091336,
0.7740452886,
0.3560265899,
-0.7276537418,
-0.0485442989,
0.1169087067,
-0.3589431345,
0.0327145234,
0.6160377264,
-0.7955809236,
0.5409175158,
0.4737634063,
0.5999393463,
0.5125834346,
0.4147673249,
0.384747833,
-0.373142153,
0.0832997188,
0.3936138749,
0.2065450847,
0.4766944647,
-0.0140276486,
0.5572306514,
0.3967696428,
-0.3782163262,
-0.7294346094,
0.051991906,
-0.6213825941,
-0.2969226241,
0.9653846025,
-0.2233232111,
-0.1394075006,
0.2977296412,
-0.2262060344,
-0.1528692842,
-0.1875721812,
0.5515407324,
0.916944325,
0.0235840101,
-0.2955819964,
-0.5515586734,
0.1802329868,
0.3443394899,
-1.0417659283,
-0.2820185423,
0.6064489484,
0.07623972,
0.5123488903,
0.4783477485,
-0.167987898,
0.6479241252,
0.2582538426,
-0.0403599888,
0.0094141429,
-0.2264594585,
-0.3412897885,
0.0635174662,
0.2735065222,
0.1709299535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14765v1 | ChatGPT as Research Scientist: Probing GPT's Capabilities as a Research Librarian, Research Ethicist, Data Generator and Data Predictor | 2024-06-20T22:30:06 | 2024-06-20T22:30:06 | Steven A. Lehr, Aylin Caliskan, Suneragiri Liyanage, Mahzarin R. Banaji | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR, cs.LG, I.2.7; K.4.0; K.4.1; K.4.2 | How good a research scientist is ChatGPT? We systematically probed the
capabilities of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 across four central components of the
scientific process: as a Research Librarian, Research Ethicist, Data Generator,
and Novel Data Predictor, using psychological science as a testing field. In
Study 1 (Research Librarian), unlike human researchers, GPT-3.5 and GPT-4
hallucinated, authoritatively generating fictional references 36.0% and 5.4% of
the time, respectively, although GPT-4 exhibited an evolving capacity to
acknowledge its fictions. In Study 2 (Research Ethicist), GPT-4 (though not
GPT-3.5) proved capable of detecting violations like p-hacking in fictional
research protocols, correcting 88.6% of blatantly presented issues, and 72.6%
of subtly presented issues. In Study 3 (Data Generator), both models
consistently replicated patterns of cultural bias previously discovered in
large language corpora, indicating that ChatGPT can simulate known results, an
antecedent to usefulness for both data generation and skills like hypothesis
generation. Contrastingly, in Study 4 (Novel Data Predictor), neither model was
successful at predicting new results absent in their training data, and neither
appeared to leverage substantially new information when predicting more versus
less novel outcomes. Together, these results suggest that GPT is a flawed but
rapidly improving librarian, a decent research ethicist already, capable of
data generation in simple domains with known characteristics but poor at
predicting novel patterns of empirical data to aid future experimentation. | [
-0.3720831275,
-0.6669790745,
0.7121431828,
-0.1644846648,
0.0430342816,
0.4192367494,
-0.1057561487,
-0.4077023566,
0.0613600835,
0.1318705231,
-0.1802058816,
0.0907119438,
-0.6809720397,
0.2368048131,
-0.5453727245,
1.3516677618,
0.3000825047,
0.2707598805,
-0.0150159895,
0.3759967089,
-0.3833922446,
-0.8064843416,
-0.8082511425,
-0.5268033147,
0.5416413546,
0.164261803,
0.9195872545,
0.1639876664,
0.469789207,
0.2495380044,
0.104754515,
-0.0853061229,
-0.8307131529,
0.1651704311,
-0.2303717881,
-0.5732253194,
-0.2331171185,
0.3316939473,
0.2483820468,
0.4887564182,
0.0517152399,
-0.0657640547,
0.0284878537,
0.7029875517,
-0.1148399934,
0.3082423806,
-0.5860079527,
0.2016605735,
-0.382204175,
-0.4543353319,
-0.3875586689,
-0.7537080646,
0.4152478874,
-0.7331640124,
0.841285646,
0.2879677415,
0.616550684,
0.0883866325,
-0.5812576413,
-0.3804893196,
-0.9712489247,
0.6607204676,
-0.2493089139,
0.2590489388,
0.494204849,
0.3839861751,
-0.2686929405,
-0.9233338833,
-0.5275282264,
-0.4885424078,
0.0553111397,
0.2601740062,
-0.0658442602,
-0.1877413839,
0.4893705249,
0.4191308916,
-0.7376820445,
-0.4480187893,
-0.7569171786,
-0.3259422779,
0.3527242839,
0.0060558482,
0.1526748836,
-0.0328764245,
-0.1354420185,
-0.2049271613,
-0.5963717103,
-0.1735209376,
0.5233924389,
0.104334332,
0.4719003141,
0.6341821551,
0.0909905434,
0.1090694889,
0.1077521294,
0.0817696899,
0.1840953082,
-0.4710732996,
0.1485420913,
0.2239599973,
0.7810017467,
0.0903347954,
0.3339630365,
-0.166793406,
0.0423635729,
0.0163126923,
0.5702890158,
-0.7683760524,
-0.8401819468,
0.1761816889,
-0.3361534178,
-0.4136221111,
0.1430549622,
-0.7111417055,
-0.5115384459,
-0.0629082099,
0.3443112373,
-0.6653926373,
-0.420335114,
-0.058854714,
-0.4907756746,
0.2154408693,
0.1496049911,
-0.9537408948,
0.2776466608,
0.6143963933,
1.0075944662,
-0.3781785369,
-0.3665566742,
-0.1971235722,
0.15656133,
-0.3204280436,
0.6840741038,
-0.4642230272,
-0.6810760498,
-0.1248365343,
-0.2071769238,
-0.0986272246,
-0.1187210083,
0.6497399211,
-0.4982325137,
0.3973141611,
-0.4906042814,
-0.505010128,
0.0894809961,
0.2289130241,
-0.5195833445,
0.9718818665,
0.2361754179,
-1.013361454,
0.5636121035,
-0.8019980788,
0.0100181093,
0.2667085528,
-0.0980377197,
-0.3224498332,
-0.133892104,
0.0026780281,
0.211798951,
-0.1471648961,
0.4688220322,
-0.4736932516,
-0.3552487195,
0.6802371144,
-0.5410062075,
0.6299428344,
0.2654557228,
-0.234600082,
-0.1922044307,
-0.5154737234,
0.0204264522,
0.0653057173,
-0.1802653074,
-0.023945,
0.1495425403,
0.1119707823,
-0.0679072738,
-0.0355600864,
-0.7431005836,
0.197492063,
-0.0225877874,
0.5148839951,
0.6989119053,
0.2143703848,
0.1575330496,
-0.503534317,
0.5640951991,
-0.6111356616,
-0.0022484255,
0.2610296607,
-0.8133314848,
-0.3133010566,
-0.0485377796,
0.2352955788,
0.3794824183,
-0.7771077156,
-0.1158959717,
-0.1018326655,
-0.8221273422,
-0.1490395963,
-0.3020287156,
0.1802983582,
0.6079640985,
0.3442547321,
-0.2900416553,
-0.4897613525,
-0.6937000155,
-0.5713136196,
-0.4096183181,
-0.3316287398,
0.050618615,
0.7067364454,
0.0216655154,
0.943919301,
-0.3739157915,
-0.0261519253,
0.0169658363,
0.3174758255,
0.4514972866,
0.4534046352,
0.257059902,
-0.9406754971,
-0.5103288293,
-0.0052736807,
-0.7832340598,
-0.0489610769,
0.363863945,
-0.0483564399,
-0.0068617277,
0.2199693471,
-0.8816478848,
0.3019214869,
0.10860122,
-0.557218492,
1.0677084923,
-0.2110347003,
0.3543074429,
-0.6512972713,
0.1927848905,
-0.211865291,
0.177749753,
-1.0912572145,
-0.2804567516,
-0.2298169583,
-0.2534130514,
0.0208002776,
0.3169668317,
-0.3772231042,
0.0071594925,
-0.325830251,
-0.3204541206,
-0.3085664809,
0.0124940723,
0.0990602076,
0.7228899598,
0.5268599987,
-0.3638378084,
0.2774747908,
0.3549417853,
-0.2575552166,
0.3162192702,
-0.7214621902,
0.3230916262,
0.0614706464,
0.4489412606,
-0.837038517,
-0.4810810387,
0.3489098251,
-0.5037916303,
0.193636179,
-0.2951050103,
-0.6198970079,
-0.5372804403,
-0.1990340054,
0.3106756508,
0.6799253821,
-0.188045308,
0.5208431482,
0.2210418135,
-0.5560876727,
-0.4609155953,
-0.4999773204,
-0.0517749637,
-0.3218549788,
-0.5859635472,
0.4892041683,
-0.1274450272,
-0.2408710718,
-0.0460405834,
-0.2297904938,
-0.1045923904,
-0.256675601,
0.0140174394,
0.3630517721,
-0.0808771402,
-0.0343750641,
-0.4921621978,
-0.2663639486,
0.4289383292,
0.0203959607,
0.5877681971,
-0.481726557,
-0.5299021602,
0.1709334105,
0.0534555204,
0.2626144886,
-0.0567591861,
0.4099695086,
0.9800738692,
0.1204165667,
0.3047142327,
-0.5819658041,
-0.52080369,
-0.4872846305,
0.3201016784,
-0.4422694147,
-0.9774557948,
0.5651857853,
0.254101634,
-0.0584886558,
0.2099329531,
0.4688402116,
0.1182379946,
0.8697371483,
0.4427027404,
0.1299543381,
0.2763256133,
-0.0971889421,
0.6126019359,
-0.5738835335,
-0.0465545878,
-0.5422340631,
0.0601225384,
-1.118467927,
-0.3752418756,
0.6745832562,
-0.179412961,
-0.5600861907,
-0.07785099,
-0.7574363351,
0.5448817015,
0.7751578093,
0.0502181277,
0.2671800256,
0.0338532776,
0.4409332573,
-0.0183558334,
-0.7377289534,
-0.633216083,
1.4223823547,
0.5255132914,
0.7972272038,
0.1002012342,
0.5056492686,
0.2813695073,
0.2117491663,
-0.5406464934,
0.3136734366,
0.372040838,
-0.8070296049,
-0.3172376454,
-0.3244099319,
-0.678504467,
0.3951140344,
0.0202429723,
-0.7184242606,
0.314165771,
0.4224923551,
0.0111311432,
0.276489675,
-0.6871421933,
0.7074747086,
-0.1055189967,
-0.5132721663,
-0.0228971969,
-0.728759408,
0.5498738289,
-0.2667136788,
0.1120833531,
-0.08838287,
0.2146582156,
0.6756782532,
-0.1356031448,
0.8527058363,
-0.4335370064,
0.2739377618,
0.1904747039,
0.4196273685,
0.4008349776,
0.1562308073,
-0.1346441805,
0.0431262888,
0.505695343,
-0.4894380569,
-0.3209776878,
0.3014890552,
-0.8126348853,
-0.7526977062,
-0.9374315739,
-0.5964424014,
-0.5665022135,
0.0814035311,
0.4674521983,
0.1419669986,
-0.4794502854,
0.1015649438,
0.6574227214,
-0.0074886261,
0.0309406277,
0.3909765482,
-0.1181399599,
-0.0920334831,
1.052059412,
0.0223576371,
0.2131289542,
0.0306935068,
0.3532094955,
-0.2318458706,
-0.5966855288,
0.0231887642,
0.0901971385,
-0.398509413,
0.0370490439,
-0.6574092507,
-0.4030660689,
-0.3233733177,
-0.117484875,
-0.305338949,
-0.3068032563,
0.0021397322,
-0.1663682461,
0.4508420825,
0.766633749,
-0.1564620137,
0.1521623433,
-0.2953591943,
0.0810798705,
0.2859495878,
0.089754127,
-0.1843875051,
-0.5435416102,
0.0022138376,
-0.0250096563,
-0.5995957255,
-0.9002280235,
0.4361384213,
0.1208832562,
0.453020215,
0.4073314667,
-0.0884872451,
0.3982040584,
-0.5579699874,
0.9943805337,
-0.0758693516,
-0.5289561749,
0.2874948978,
-0.7085746527,
-0.0347654112,
0.2427514642,
0.6827731133,
-0.5126889348,
-0.7073615193,
-0.7111959457,
-0.7309871912,
0.6289656162,
0.4961096346,
-0.0063078892,
-0.0065908036,
0.1639324874,
0.453787446,
0.193978563,
-0.9347155094,
0.0986956805,
-0.8475304842,
0.3245571256,
-0.1185108647,
-0.2647349238,
-0.2581092119,
-0.1995145828,
0.9124977589,
-0.2653134465,
0.6596210003,
0.2721688747,
0.4270822108,
0.1882738918,
0.3971158564,
0.2388465852,
0.9335176349,
-0.5765507221,
0.1708180904,
-0.2469594926,
-0.7370021939,
0.0963060334,
0.4437063634,
-0.0202730633,
-0.2260912955,
0.3631262481,
0.3593279719,
-0.3109471202,
-0.3002973199,
0.316601783,
-0.0720510781,
-0.4701683819,
-0.5497883558,
0.2277169377,
-0.0294715948,
0.1560295075,
0.7088029385,
0.1186368391,
0.2794935405,
-0.6489344835,
0.1548191309,
0.2592229247,
-0.0802089795,
-0.4773394465,
0.7487445474,
-0.0408664234,
0.0074940599,
0.7319791913,
-0.2200014293,
-0.4855771065,
0.4493543506,
0.6565112472,
0.5524410009,
-0.26701051,
0.5578770638,
0.3649635911,
0.175203383,
-0.2768925428,
0.2185915112,
0.225566268,
-0.9768061638,
-0.2443811893,
-0.4145777225,
-0.6334967613,
0.112563163,
-0.6254538298,
-0.0831902027,
-0.0077898437,
-0.2957330942,
0.2009017915,
0.1309686303,
-0.6468573213,
-0.1718892604,
-0.4057645798,
0.6283006072,
-0.7188090682,
0.8210626245,
0.3898463249,
-0.4492010772,
-0.7187752128,
0.0154891945,
0.3250544369,
-0.6439659595,
0.7149611115,
-0.0020395485,
0.1199246496,
-0.0641742796,
-0.4201895297,
-0.9138964415,
1.1151212454,
0.1956425905,
-0.3160883486,
-0.0820732415,
0.1347537339,
0.8452227116,
-0.2049433291,
0.639823854,
0.4803122282,
0.5414790511,
0.1029598489,
-0.9360854626,
-0.0057126526,
-0.344405055,
-0.0839515254,
0.0991286486,
-0.4849347174,
0.89756006,
-0.122424975,
-0.0063673318,
0.0636750758,
0.3954401314,
0.4065962434,
0.4186485708,
0.1596529782,
0.1662636697,
0.9104530811,
-0.1994252056,
1.2181631327,
-0.3064872324,
0.11529769,
0.9203329086,
-0.3955422938,
0.3478882313,
0.6189001799,
-0.2565438151,
0.2213715464,
0.8581203818,
-0.4581556916,
0.7117149234,
0.0806581527,
-0.3576856256,
0.0896733403,
0.0332286283,
-0.5015965104,
0.2371494472,
0.3893737793,
-0.334174782,
0.0939354002,
-0.0091572264,
-0.0596580282,
-0.3250864446,
-0.0603482649,
0.2634153366,
-0.0058603464,
-0.5955325961,
0.2605296671,
-0.3380795419,
0.239601329,
-0.7240769863,
-0.0516163521,
-0.048808977,
0.0409225188,
-0.1871297359,
-0.9934304357,
0.2580932677,
-0.0275679845,
-0.1078732088,
-0.3116564155,
0.9579637051,
-0.0569334663,
-0.1500999629,
-0.143259719,
0.7261996865,
0.5387017131,
-0.1249269396,
-0.4331613481,
-0.0764275342,
0.236244157,
-0.3939649463,
0.2482697666,
0.4414550662,
-0.0287533961,
0.825617671,
0.7482438087,
0.3479331732,
0.0055166613,
0.0289441794,
0.7510962486,
-0.739385426,
-0.1758752018,
-0.7114180326,
0.1319271028,
-0.1352623701,
-0.2956164777,
0.7790420055,
0.6660739779,
0.8038008213,
-0.1209421083,
0.9635640383,
-0.573935926,
0.6317206025,
-0.2823890448,
0.4874640703,
0.1453202963,
0.0266694091,
-0.1878075004,
-0.9247378111,
0.1355195493,
0.4522483349,
-0.6874861121,
0.303147614,
0.9288360476,
0.8628617525,
-0.2216092497,
0.5005772114,
0.0888743624,
0.3187025785,
0.7364424467,
0.1475258321,
0.9619784951,
-0.0101641333,
0.5951016545,
-0.2441885024,
-0.2992638052,
0.1069917604,
-0.6238933802,
-1.0873734951,
-0.5295439959,
-0.0030540023,
-0.3734813333,
0.1317778379,
0.4464341402,
0.5948939323,
-0.6164276004,
-0.0693670437,
-0.2236489207,
-0.2342874706,
-0.1429411918,
-0.340272963,
0.4507151246,
-0.2225166261,
-0.4858571589,
0.3542172909,
-0.1090271175,
-0.1192807183,
-0.2515121102,
-0.0722152665,
0.2872108817,
-0.184264034,
0.5720824599,
0.3249109089,
-0.6386040449,
-0.4503959119,
-0.0613633431,
0.0787193477,
-0.0905996114,
0.7530964613,
-0.5075678229,
0.5823720694,
0.2111735493,
0.4608236849,
0.913705647,
-0.0192746837,
0.9062154293,
-0.2967943847,
-0.236879468,
0.6516696811,
0.2055849135,
0.2706835568,
-0.4411104321,
0.951956749,
0.2955172956,
-1.2145572901,
-0.8282116055,
0.2035038173,
-0.8927464485,
-0.0823371932,
0.7875750661,
0.145764783,
0.0132399714,
-0.3512141109,
-0.3604597151,
-0.0103482241,
-0.6298177242,
1.0606557131,
0.7480784059,
-0.8715156913,
-0.0174005181,
-1.2737088203,
0.7987834215,
0.2876549065,
-0.5517463684,
0.0103656203,
0.5122253895,
0.4704021513,
0.2342083156,
0.8485571742,
-0.1327673942,
0.3197381794,
0.3249903619,
0.0402349941,
-0.0877456218,
0.083915405,
0.3441668451,
0.1857908517,
0.1328865588,
0.260145545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14764v1 | RE-AdaptIR: Improving Information Retrieval through Reverse Engineered Adaptation | 2024-06-20T22:28:11 | 2024-06-20T22:28:11 | William Fleshman, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) fine-tuned for text-retrieval have demonstrated
state-of-the-art results across several information retrieval (IR) benchmarks.
However, supervised training for improving these models requires numerous
labeled examples, which are generally unavailable or expensive to acquire. In
this work, we explore the effectiveness of extending reverse engineered
adaptation to the context of information retrieval (RE-AdaptIR). We use
RE-AdaptIR to improve LLM-based IR models using only unlabeled data. We
demonstrate improved performance both in training domains as well as zero-shot
in domains where the models have seen no queries. We analyze performance
changes in various fine-tuning scenarios and offer findings of immediate use to
practitioners. | [
0.068849735,
-0.5640432239,
0.4041002989,
-0.121188201,
-0.2681658268,
0.1149803326,
-0.3222028315,
-0.4345251918,
0.1457082629,
0.8131992817,
-0.3531134129,
-0.4758424461,
-0.5383353829,
0.2124954015,
-0.53101331,
0.8944633007,
-0.0522114001,
0.0243971907,
0.0073029394,
-0.2368863821,
-0.4427971542,
-0.4738253653,
-0.2935657501,
-0.4086773098,
0.4298248887,
0.7237528563,
0.4582048655,
0.5409070253,
0.6875978708,
0.1863032877,
0.1479308307,
0.2211007029,
-1.0172016621,
0.2762058079,
-0.568064332,
-0.5700445175,
-0.1960863918,
-0.0676967204,
0.710658133,
0.5525345802,
-0.223604545,
0.2857165933,
-0.0431565605,
1.0036739111,
-1.0833386183,
-0.1531971842,
-1.1631559134,
-0.1927574873,
0.1499549001,
-0.5800216198,
-0.8267535567,
-0.2190801203,
0.1319279671,
-0.8920143843,
0.3663258553,
0.2162931412,
0.6878647208,
0.3182481825,
-0.1932013631,
0.1011571139,
-0.9241221547,
0.938118577,
-0.5921653509,
0.7485989332,
0.3266809881,
0.3780958354,
-0.6924706101,
-0.8412646651,
-0.2331865728,
0.0145492582,
0.0930840448,
0.2432497591,
-0.4569534659,
-0.1039294973,
0.1323309243,
0.146810919,
-0.2258404642,
0.1314483434,
-0.4476195872,
0.075886026,
0.602032721,
0.003701851,
-0.0340400301,
0.2250616401,
-0.1194035113,
-0.1754414886,
-0.7397388816,
-0.4382549822,
0.0255981889,
0.6463011503,
0.3913388252,
0.6646214724,
-0.5101973414,
0.8372016549,
0.1121795401,
-0.2048929632,
0.2499341369,
-0.1841288209,
-0.4103612006,
-0.0523071066,
0.1994300783,
0.3361800909,
0.3530355394,
-0.5958316326,
-0.4330239296,
-0.6437616944,
0.4842174649,
-0.9479913116,
-0.2548566461,
-0.2071624994,
-0.5753273964,
-0.0682537183,
0.1255075634,
-0.6198997498,
-0.4159046113,
-0.3791418374,
0.7829914689,
-0.2960589826,
-0.084467411,
0.3071894944,
-0.4890190959,
0.393304497,
0.474137187,
-0.5963266492,
0.1603518724,
0.5877741575,
0.5640824437,
-0.08882875,
-0.109679088,
-0.6200606227,
0.2420542389,
-0.2672579587,
1.0511603355,
-0.8781676292,
-0.3934842348,
-0.1292862594,
0.3012770116,
-0.1455633193,
-0.9126199484,
0.6134048104,
-0.9171631336,
-0.0912191793,
-0.0217995495,
-0.5490806699,
-0.252571106,
0.2784752846,
-0.527854085,
0.7788107991,
0.1391702443,
-0.7787252069,
0.267211169,
-0.5108833313,
-0.4445534348,
-0.1858387589,
0.1818749309,
-0.3231769502,
0.4004919231,
0.2996356785,
0.0814207122,
-0.3986214995,
0.1760146767,
-0.3399959803,
-0.5911455154,
0.103646189,
-0.1969157457,
0.2713308632,
0.1982585937,
0.1322908252,
-0.0584159456,
-0.9581394196,
0.0124613196,
-0.0725596547,
-0.8115903735,
-0.5835603476,
-0.0451047122,
0.025364399,
-0.3569804728,
0.0266274437,
-0.6946679354,
0.4371762872,
-0.4787846804,
0.2487728447,
0.5480888486,
0.085721679,
0.5032967925,
-0.3388350904,
0.4049063921,
-0.1287850738,
-0.0662999228,
0.0162375085,
-0.1315651387,
-0.7662402391,
-0.2765966654,
0.5567017794,
0.6649782658,
-0.9594663978,
-0.0454880595,
-0.4392381907,
-0.5940495133,
-0.7017664313,
0.2780822217,
0.3262863755,
0.7085143328,
0.5734188557,
-0.2329951376,
-0.7528799772,
-0.9439893961,
-0.7601507306,
-0.1143171415,
-0.114548102,
0.5692455173,
0.4752654135,
-0.5556381345,
0.728944838,
-0.6933019161,
-0.2087583989,
-0.1311985999,
0.2041017562,
0.3037027717,
0.2757506669,
0.2769288123,
-0.7767133117,
-0.2104507387,
-0.0545683429,
-0.5779812336,
-0.050222192,
0.0222458187,
-0.214125976,
0.0970829725,
0.6064351797,
-0.1627252698,
0.5608515739,
0.1297352612,
0.0630079955,
0.3840826154,
-0.5293126106,
0.3370555043,
-0.9848436117,
0.3193810582,
-0.0229583494,
-0.2927848399,
-0.6638838649,
0.0892142355,
0.3005666435,
-0.172557354,
-0.4140309989,
0.6557598114,
-0.5470668674,
-0.2185017914,
-0.6147913337,
0.2420873046,
0.0323798768,
0.116486311,
-0.0721584558,
0.9721626043,
0.3388395011,
-0.7864986658,
0.094747059,
0.274621278,
-0.4971637428,
0.3250057399,
-0.4973106682,
0.2321381122,
-0.5522788763,
0.0367818438,
-0.985022068,
-0.1918181181,
0.0351084247,
-0.3297793269,
0.6053133607,
-0.3673964441,
-0.3506468236,
0.0156294964,
-0.4505814612,
0.4056446552,
0.447650373,
-0.9412167668,
0.6619493961,
0.3090716004,
0.0100870831,
-0.8302896023,
-0.6074234843,
0.2260063291,
-0.1156521887,
-0.3123461008,
0.5777207613,
-0.0056982934,
-0.1345802248,
-0.1563478559,
-0.25697124,
-0.2859375477,
0.368519932,
-0.0241558775,
0.0072957096,
-0.3746904135,
0.3562070727,
0.049524121,
0.0135897566,
-0.449636966,
-0.1818781495,
0.0104104746,
0.292792201,
-0.1631041616,
-0.3401795626,
0.0511708297,
0.4191616476,
-0.0609449372,
0.7899807692,
0.2114071697,
-0.3148591816,
-0.0401286781,
-0.7092395425,
-0.3308323026,
-0.4517386854,
0.5439730883,
-0.2567499578,
-0.9183738828,
0.2375822514,
-0.4248897731,
0.1098818183,
0.1044525057,
0.0451214053,
-0.0012949071,
0.6830028892,
1.0735560656,
-0.2289758176,
0.7262247205,
0.1786904335,
0.0856070593,
-1.024489522,
-0.2109858096,
-0.6360974312,
-0.3040742874,
-0.635645926,
-0.2377736419,
0.0630674288,
0.3609632254,
-0.2509674728,
0.4688547552,
-0.4070729017,
0.5584260225,
0.401589036,
0.4676443338,
0.5259046555,
0.276042074,
0.318849057,
0.0357851312,
-0.6307373047,
-0.2742260695,
1.321896553,
0.0986945257,
1.2831201553,
0.2749889195,
0.60788697,
0.2366878241,
0.6433304548,
-0.7776213884,
0.3573631942,
-0.4657627344,
-0.4965171516,
-0.042605985,
-0.4081597328,
-1.1547499895,
0.3224930465,
-0.4320412874,
-0.7422499657,
0.3572720587,
0.0878528357,
-0.1196572855,
0.1033069193,
-0.8228134513,
0.4230928421,
-0.1538317651,
-0.1722924113,
-0.1877961606,
-0.2861377299,
0.1140076891,
-0.541757524,
0.1004985273,
0.1324001551,
-0.1112130061,
0.9057920575,
0.101087369,
0.6870889664,
-0.1513596922,
0.1105287597,
0.0263351314,
0.0922035649,
0.5777441859,
-0.1519095153,
-0.6061894298,
-0.1720494181,
-0.0628024861,
-0.2289192975,
-0.7222610116,
0.7961747646,
-0.7226598263,
-1.1049450636,
-0.0074048671,
-0.6114364266,
-0.1462375969,
0.5003823638,
-0.0984827057,
0.2520059347,
-0.2636019289,
0.5378627777,
0.6751330495,
-0.5992535353,
0.1312838793,
1.0744360685,
-0.2731042802,
-0.3081932366,
0.6671285629,
0.1546019763,
0.158676073,
0.7975304723,
0.0711152926,
-0.1509684473,
-0.6419972181,
-0.1289319247,
0.36669752,
-0.797042191,
-0.478500694,
-0.5925760269,
-0.0015128807,
-0.5801758766,
0.0503518172,
-0.396146059,
-0.5137401223,
-0.5469192863,
-0.0925069526,
0.5845522881,
0.5652537942,
-0.0810172111,
0.2423345149,
-0.6695305109,
0.3912878036,
-0.0025704748,
0.3978182673,
-0.2016175836,
-1.3192164898,
-0.1920030862,
0.0449710079,
-0.1091209799,
-0.5984352231,
0.4403235912,
0.6035839915,
0.6198663116,
-0.1066772044,
0.3980320692,
0.928057909,
-0.5720661879,
0.1616061926,
-0.4004099071,
-0.4945359826,
0.6797268391,
-0.0148451887,
0.1671841443,
0.7533825636,
0.2894573212,
-0.0884778872,
-0.0401383303,
-0.1394377798,
-0.8410087824,
0.7735223174,
-0.0417926125,
0.208480373,
0.1748639643,
1.1066225767,
0.1034560874,
0.081638433,
-0.3621403575,
-0.148034811,
-0.0202936288,
-0.0688097998,
-0.1036046594,
-0.4399003983,
0.1389903873,
-0.3148426116,
0.9472319484,
-0.0695437416,
0.3261180818,
0.4404323697,
-0.3904208839,
-0.1566484421,
0.3818197548,
0.5485585928,
0.7769980431,
-0.5837118626,
0.0519545451,
0.3196181357,
-0.4043030143,
0.0834070072,
0.0797555745,
-0.2087848634,
-0.1085869223,
0.1109820083,
0.5216715336,
0.3881164193,
-0.7001862526,
0.221336171,
-0.3155102432,
0.0022513617,
-0.1390235275,
0.1941951364,
-0.0656568334,
0.4873154461,
0.4860109091,
-0.1621911228,
0.2495440096,
-0.6095249057,
0.5086997747,
0.5110860467,
-0.4845413566,
-0.0963349044,
0.4779836833,
-0.0329271853,
-0.5203783512,
0.9507145882,
0.3583242297,
-0.1222812086,
0.3066179752,
0.9558074474,
0.6986572742,
-0.1186319366,
-0.0606431551,
0.4108760953,
0.3816649616,
-0.2796659768,
0.1791354269,
0.1137834117,
-0.8709416389,
-0.2823388577,
-0.3862601221,
-0.3336447477,
0.07488437,
-0.867739737,
0.2853776217,
-0.3658890426,
-0.1996608377,
0.091958575,
-0.325137645,
-0.5133751035,
0.1578426063,
-0.3563852012,
1.3448815346,
-0.5991017818,
0.9227181673,
0.8101442456,
-0.236398235,
-0.3537495434,
0.0951878726,
-0.5017440915,
-0.9969613552,
0.9879279733,
0.0419246629,
-0.3796305656,
0.3138695061,
-0.7450428605,
-0.9962588549,
1.2384954691,
0.6310350299,
-0.518630445,
0.3016265333,
-0.0858386233,
0.5878056288,
-0.278416872,
0.308327049,
0.5937432647,
0.2418008298,
0.1358497888,
-0.7027525902,
-0.0293768439,
-0.0220815893,
0.0045323456,
0.1658143848,
-0.3840019405,
0.341432184,
-0.4327804446,
-0.340818584,
0.4026871324,
0.6122472286,
0.1230494976,
0.197445482,
0.1018221602,
0.4661994874,
0.7844238281,
0.1552797109,
1.0305970907,
-0.2551585138,
0.3126452863,
1.3363604546,
-0.2637477815,
1.2324887514,
0.6471907496,
0.2318664044,
0.2627130449,
0.3898175061,
-0.0654291138,
0.8226428032,
0.1216428578,
-0.109165296,
-0.4215376675,
-0.3310844898,
-0.2651278973,
0.3667384982,
0.18729195,
-0.5214236975,
-0.3645187914,
0.0572715253,
-0.2221667916,
-0.0128585706,
-0.276814878,
0.8631241918,
-0.0061731092,
-0.4773212373,
0.7099494338,
0.2720745206,
0.6503759027,
-0.1297606528,
-0.1673147827,
-0.4568522274,
0.5308201313,
-0.2215132266,
-0.679751277,
0.1368375719,
0.0210490227,
-0.3940163851,
0.1057842225,
1.1669405699,
-0.2260359824,
-0.5566749573,
0.4667423964,
0.2874723673,
0.3469138145,
-0.0671862885,
-0.6842516661,
-0.1531972289,
0.2434811741,
-0.2887981534,
0.5281044841,
0.4157348871,
0.0442729481,
0.9926505089,
0.5740001202,
-0.3131023049,
-0.166305989,
0.0355597474,
0.9956057668,
-0.9399895072,
0.2375674546,
-0.7459507585,
0.116142787,
0.2786682248,
0.0080066901,
0.5389515162,
0.6899013519,
0.8678864837,
-0.2543863058,
0.6511153579,
0.4230204523,
0.6320145726,
-0.5023123026,
0.6353443861,
-0.7686705589,
0.3299896121,
-0.2856330276,
-0.9195673466,
-0.6492925286,
0.4888979197,
-0.3132407069,
-0.035074234,
0.105106391,
1.1626461744,
-0.1776743084,
-0.2431496978,
0.4891579151,
0.3156675696,
0.2681866586,
0.3432325721,
0.7509842515,
-0.9193208814,
0.5632346869,
0.0714582279,
-0.1941110045,
-0.320756644,
-0.9582208991,
-0.8216792345,
-0.1938434988,
-0.3280688226,
-0.1971229613,
0.4946322739,
0.5965945125,
0.4084466994,
-0.7149865031,
0.0374946669,
0.2523804605,
0.1047095433,
0.2709579468,
-0.1590655446,
0.12917009,
-0.1518707424,
-0.4392683804,
0.6885704994,
0.2740114033,
0.0255679265,
0.4277570248,
0.1071789712,
-0.4117133021,
0.0002444887,
0.6176585555,
0.578532517,
-0.4876808822,
-0.6057879925,
0.1960544288,
0.2166990936,
0.2288454622,
0.6973839402,
-0.9885715246,
0.531606853,
0.4402810335,
1.0882315636,
0.5105618238,
0.3996584713,
0.5320833921,
-0.6639552712,
-0.0281849019,
-0.1235389709,
0.1269783229,
0.4584171772,
-0.2709015608,
0.5956337452,
0.0401605107,
-0.6518906951,
-0.8139554858,
0.1086110994,
-0.5617382526,
-0.3539737761,
1.2526049614,
-0.1044207513,
-0.2195090055,
-0.2301286161,
-0.1535311937,
0.3625112772,
-0.3119045794,
0.8812144399,
0.2919409871,
-0.1391913891,
-0.2160961181,
-0.3833815455,
-0.0082151685,
0.4163644314,
-0.5456823111,
0.2449931949,
0.286744535,
0.685533464,
0.0295696054,
0.4472825825,
-0.1117547154,
-0.1023913622,
-0.4673832953,
-0.0124589531,
-0.0403781608,
-0.2958296239,
-0.3713320792,
-0.2386858612,
0.4987013638,
-0.1071060598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14763v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14763v1 | A Learn-Then-Reason Model Towards Generalization in Knowledge Base Question Answering | 2024-06-20T22:22:41 | 2024-06-20T22:22:41 | Lingxi Zhang, Jing Zhang, Yanling Wang, Cuiping Li, Hong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large-scale knowledge bases (KBs) like Freebase and Wikidata house millions
of structured knowledge. Knowledge Base Question Answering (KBQA) provides a
user-friendly way to access these valuable KBs via asking natural language
questions. In order to improve the generalization capabilities of KBQA models,
extensive research has embraced a retrieve-then-reason framework to retrieve
relevant evidence for logical expression generation. These multi-stage efforts
prioritize acquiring external sources but overlook the incorporation of new
knowledge into their model parameters. In effect, even advanced language models
and retrievers have knowledge boundaries, thereby limiting the generalization
capabilities of previous KBQA models. Therefore, this paper develops KBLLaMA,
which follows a learn-then-reason framework to inject new KB knowledge into a
large language model for flexible end-to-end KBQA. At the core of KBLLaMA, we
study (1) how to organize new knowledge about KBQA and (2) how to facilitate
the learning of the organized knowledge. Extensive experiments on various KBQA
generalization tasks showcase the state-of-the-art performance of KBLLaMA.
Especially on the general benchmark GrailQA and domain-specific benchmark
Bio-chemical, KBLLaMA respectively derives a performance gain of up to 3.8% and
9.8% compared to the baselines. | [
-0.4158180058,
-0.8664929867,
0.7855358124,
-0.0876777917,
-0.1357204914,
-0.0666005611,
-0.3271337152,
-0.3219361603,
-0.063629128,
0.4866551459,
-0.5351132154,
-0.5703454018,
-0.4920509458,
-0.1767789572,
-0.1527283788,
0.7485285997,
-0.0629614443,
0.1375015676,
-0.2630025148,
0.0226105824,
-0.5686508417,
-0.4317355454,
-0.3973259628,
-0.2805235982,
0.4766199291,
0.7376577258,
0.624853909,
0.2215840369,
0.226439178,
0.3141978979,
-0.1018839702,
0.4155807793,
-0.3000112474,
0.4470825791,
-0.3595866859,
-0.7237951159,
-0.194410786,
-0.3015176058,
0.3541697562,
0.8567835093,
-0.0743750632,
0.2192361951,
-0.2610323429,
0.8072636724,
-0.5500799417,
0.3875108957,
-0.5328074694,
-0.2969166636,
0.1586052775,
0.0320735686,
-0.5836895704,
-0.5609423518,
0.4785793722,
-0.9094160795,
-0.0815452188,
-0.0215399247,
0.8354073167,
-0.08121939,
-0.6394900084,
-0.4417831302,
-0.4969633818,
0.7052633166,
-0.5722258091,
0.5996633172,
0.2599265277,
0.9735770822,
-0.2959395051,
-0.9453138709,
-0.5897121429,
-0.3552220464,
0.1046102718,
-0.0599364191,
-0.1399239302,
-0.0188674573,
0.0139178084,
0.2358474433,
-0.6069949269,
-0.3230767548,
-0.3696766198,
-0.223810792,
0.2649459541,
0.0611343533,
0.2793671489,
-0.0771432519,
-0.063780494,
-0.0639607385,
-0.7010441422,
0.3799386919,
-0.137871936,
0.2154975682,
0.4232000709,
0.4424603581,
-0.7357603312,
0.7724630237,
0.1337558776,
0.0013252244,
-0.0476925932,
-0.040596582,
-0.493861258,
-0.2999048233,
0.2431842834,
0.3336528242,
0.4305330515,
-0.4709127247,
0.1922103614,
0.0397824757,
0.2991311848,
-0.9747123122,
-0.4055907428,
0.1949284375,
-0.5499686599,
-0.0313709155,
-0.3427756727,
-0.7191579938,
-0.3289651573,
-0.3914992511,
0.6524244547,
-0.5017408729,
-0.4523780942,
0.3896367848,
-0.0902624354,
0.2930403054,
0.4328649938,
-0.8267074227,
0.1310214996,
0.4725507498,
0.3919568062,
0.2984006107,
0.1972505897,
-0.2410122901,
0.2041334063,
-0.5608641505,
0.816198349,
-0.4905987084,
-0.0448188186,
-0.243698433,
-0.1566778719,
0.084797509,
-0.7834364772,
0.1997392029,
-1.284017086,
0.3851825893,
-0.678642571,
-0.6243616939,
-0.7387539148,
0.3799522817,
-0.3638904393,
0.4678713679,
0.4830744565,
-0.342985779,
0.6055011749,
-0.6105784774,
-0.1422286481,
-0.0249375496,
-0.2216545194,
-0.0738350153,
-0.0053212144,
0.1876812726,
0.4000028372,
-0.6338100433,
0.6446654797,
-0.3460121155,
0.1141537428,
0.2260834873,
0.1603028774,
0.6184668541,
0.3536422849,
-0.3873970807,
0.0716224536,
-0.6174019575,
0.6237570643,
-0.0347012095,
-0.5749984384,
-0.4053611457,
-0.0734895393,
-0.2934439778,
0.482770592,
0.1044118553,
-0.3574406207,
0.2313602418,
-0.4814220071,
0.1767049879,
0.6015800834,
0.100553982,
0.6171199083,
-0.1752610654,
0.5241835117,
0.0495695919,
0.1289875656,
0.0640028566,
-0.6426067352,
-0.7621555328,
0.0169480052,
0.2153417766,
0.3180054426,
-0.7861593962,
0.0788052082,
-0.1576570421,
-0.5789973736,
-0.323812902,
0.3859138489,
0.3408714831,
0.9231889248,
0.6882950664,
0.0833092704,
-0.6446185112,
-1.1345331669,
-0.313921988,
-0.3928606212,
-0.2096778601,
0.2428097129,
0.2142236829,
-0.4043569565,
1.1790893078,
-0.5164397359,
-0.0362730473,
-0.3954719305,
-0.0163647514,
0.4720273912,
0.1284516007,
0.4063505232,
-0.964473784,
-0.3886485696,
0.034416113,
-0.8621180058,
-0.2832647264,
0.1780308485,
-0.4379566014,
0.0795726031,
0.4740219116,
-0.8258296251,
0.0681834295,
0.062487144,
-0.5099577308,
0.6276564002,
0.1060931832,
0.2749904096,
-1.0385023355,
0.2226784378,
-0.3045818806,
-0.0294412132,
-0.8215053082,
0.4852543771,
0.3113675416,
0.2301697433,
-0.2485190928,
0.357555449,
-0.4185933471,
0.2436773181,
-0.3555641174,
-0.0508996472,
0.2193242908,
0.5128258467,
0.0506849103,
0.4528899491,
0.3792804182,
-0.7596787214,
0.2315742522,
0.1705549359,
-0.4753267467,
0.1704930067,
-0.5441010594,
-0.1692998409,
-0.303750664,
0.1947129071,
-1.0280681849,
-0.3875089288,
0.1270022541,
-0.5829902291,
0.2978320718,
-0.0803001076,
-0.3604474962,
-0.2550293505,
0.046261847,
0.1937003136,
0.6129598618,
-0.4849920273,
0.8879902363,
0.4662624002,
-0.1449972242,
-0.4970198274,
-0.347617507,
-0.2240049243,
-0.1816154569,
-0.9768151045,
0.123561427,
-0.2248269469,
-0.3763148785,
-0.0861529931,
-0.3409584463,
-0.1761473268,
0.1779142171,
0.1040360257,
0.077471368,
-0.4919255972,
0.3456794322,
0.2069891244,
-0.0160532165,
0.3581104577,
-0.5865238905,
0.5396876931,
-0.3940601051,
0.0299283247,
0.2068843693,
0.4039107561,
0.4003522694,
0.1386324167,
0.769487381,
0.2930883169,
-0.522790134,
-0.1732132286,
-0.6400632262,
-0.2359269559,
-0.4643777311,
0.4848431051,
-0.4046279192,
-1.1599256992,
0.3591566086,
-0.3089770079,
0.1089682654,
0.5646107793,
0.821166575,
-0.2142637819,
0.8686777353,
0.5027683377,
0.1171933636,
-0.1462906897,
-0.2399303466,
0.2524809539,
-0.2950410843,
-0.6619294286,
-0.3048765361,
-0.1856657118,
-0.1191150174,
-0.5052213073,
0.389403224,
0.677154541,
-0.25193578,
0.3425620496,
-0.2471264601,
0.4323836565,
0.4828151464,
0.0612281561,
0.1928700805,
-0.1216257438,
-0.4722616076,
0.1471098065,
-0.5588147044,
-0.3194759488,
1.1514636278,
0.2231975198,
0.4894793332,
0.4497024417,
0.4655056298,
0.0873248279,
0.5839676261,
-0.7215892673,
0.636433959,
0.2746487558,
-0.808123827,
-0.3257334828,
-0.444552809,
-0.7592555285,
0.4449652135,
-0.0603665896,
-0.5931640863,
0.2467058003,
0.4284905195,
-0.3042834699,
0.0495415963,
-0.9926477671,
0.8462724686,
-0.029816458,
-0.086141482,
-0.2512530684,
-0.7495638728,
0.5845236182,
-0.1939633489,
0.3019060493,
0.0577820018,
0.0600123592,
0.6467757821,
-0.4922715425,
0.4290392399,
-0.5121477842,
-0.1153684929,
0.4712634087,
0.1297437102,
0.2381087542,
0.0541966222,
0.1379720867,
-0.1354881376,
-0.0248836521,
-0.328407824,
-0.8605384231,
0.4151737392,
-0.6222578883,
-0.9223988056,
0.0592813641,
-0.5686184764,
-0.6275961399,
0.3923399746,
0.2344367951,
0.054238677,
0.2551417351,
0.4105991423,
0.9534407258,
-0.1846843809,
0.0272385795,
0.7762223482,
-0.5260736346,
-0.3313302398,
0.6397410631,
0.0991323814,
0.2943126857,
0.7434563041,
0.3251581192,
-0.5092071891,
-0.4714895189,
-0.3845349252,
-0.0871363282,
-0.9477561116,
-0.420891434,
-0.920378983,
-0.1402324587,
-0.627512455,
-0.0156427901,
0.0980115309,
-0.7366673946,
0.0640147105,
-0.0169972721,
0.4019456208,
0.3257797956,
0.0723270923,
0.3562054634,
-0.7793619633,
0.6046513319,
0.6715849638,
0.1159662232,
0.1524458081,
-0.7007352114,
-0.3709251881,
-0.0462995321,
-0.331831485,
-1.1420462132,
0.1214288026,
0.1942971051,
0.8437297344,
0.4603942931,
-0.0131898643,
0.4842663109,
-0.3173748553,
0.2921222448,
0.0628357828,
-0.6808029413,
0.5937919021,
-0.3970659375,
0.4199718833,
0.6080939174,
0.5258560181,
-0.6600574851,
-0.249563396,
-0.3918176591,
-1.0388176441,
0.3803079724,
-0.0834568143,
-0.3257008791,
0.0174686816,
0.4312128425,
0.1015208289,
0.3499364257,
-0.6980635524,
-0.1788168401,
-0.1648936868,
-0.2017218322,
0.229739666,
-0.3538330197,
0.0700229034,
-0.2058763951,
0.810190618,
-0.2778834105,
0.1241133437,
-0.0199420936,
-0.6733134985,
-0.0877528265,
0.5613538027,
0.2605267763,
0.8443546295,
-0.1864857227,
0.0484956913,
0.0262373183,
-0.2573259473,
0.2302715033,
-0.0060714926,
-0.1639537215,
-0.2530755401,
0.2475018501,
0.2667972147,
0.1680888832,
-0.8748294115,
0.3663097918,
0.0786688626,
-0.4193638861,
-0.0210883971,
0.3314906359,
0.583973527,
0.500788331,
0.5298472643,
-0.036196012,
0.4119732082,
-0.4148161709,
0.3218888342,
0.4208855629,
0.1861295104,
-0.0530447178,
0.6316629648,
-0.2343179435,
0.1593681723,
0.5318524837,
0.0069316234,
-0.6038554311,
0.6326928139,
0.4021686912,
0.4802692235,
-0.3923898637,
0.2749822438,
0.3631881177,
0.3937073648,
0.1267637312,
0.6874856949,
-0.3811765611,
-0.6727986336,
-0.5072053075,
-0.6869565248,
-0.2310378402,
0.2788748145,
-0.5682739019,
0.0034523639,
-0.4860120714,
-0.0995610803,
0.0552456863,
-0.1390450448,
-0.5678848624,
0.5572921634,
-0.0410560034,
1.2860137224,
-0.7487295866,
0.7120140791,
0.7298325896,
-0.4035925567,
-0.9659994245,
-0.2071763128,
-0.2126173079,
-0.7934163809,
0.8763715029,
0.3376750052,
0.1329167783,
-0.2381287962,
-0.4035704136,
-1.0343183279,
1.1117447615,
0.3585492969,
-0.5617964268,
-0.3234718144,
0.0567890927,
0.5661413074,
-0.2071439624,
0.2224383652,
0.6463212967,
0.495124042,
0.0109006725,
-0.3924722373,
0.1724220216,
-0.4496279657,
-0.0783204213,
0.3580311239,
-0.4579903185,
0.6515643001,
-0.3653966188,
0.0283981804,
-0.0887108967,
0.8709620237,
0.631315887,
0.2712496519,
0.6565145254,
0.5315743685,
0.6429464221,
0.0177952684,
0.5532320738,
-0.0035116763,
0.046602916,
0.9504208565,
0.0614053905,
0.6957078576,
0.490265429,
-0.110013023,
0.8520607352,
0.7935308218,
0.370033145,
0.7889100313,
0.4803789258,
-0.2470797151,
-0.6038038731,
0.3004089892,
-0.5199973583,
0.2112863809,
0.6114063859,
-0.4133693874,
-0.4529422224,
-0.0213124584,
0.0005309053,
-0.0362161398,
-0.4351176918,
0.6623017788,
0.0575551465,
-0.8549774289,
0.6536985636,
0.1362244785,
0.1422871649,
-0.8450850248,
-0.0891840979,
-0.1397902071,
0.0545065105,
-0.1027314439,
-0.4851612449,
0.1917071193,
-0.1548965722,
-0.6526018977,
-0.0141628375,
0.9293906689,
-0.4904108942,
-0.3120461404,
0.4485926032,
0.5057324767,
-0.0250268765,
-0.247320354,
-0.4091390371,
-0.6000881195,
0.0095254518,
-0.4890114665,
0.3820407391,
0.421133101,
-0.382987529,
0.8923797607,
0.7314335108,
-0.0915492177,
0.2479737699,
-0.0291933287,
1.067710638,
-0.413665086,
-0.6798624396,
-0.6305052638,
0.4526718259,
0.0924841091,
0.0005533303,
0.5756376982,
0.3917913139,
0.5906871557,
-0.1731145233,
0.6870412827,
-0.2220050544,
0.6933999062,
-0.6192688346,
0.7639014125,
-0.6596038342,
0.0734599158,
-0.1781095266,
-0.6720076203,
-0.1673708409,
0.5090112686,
-0.2973924875,
0.2480823547,
0.609980762,
0.7468296885,
0.1591371298,
0.1831034124,
0.4057600498,
0.3662303388,
0.3230321109,
0.9020887613,
0.8681142926,
-0.1377632469,
0.7313325405,
-0.0675179884,
-0.4473964274,
-0.2058318704,
-0.6513477564,
-0.6116092205,
-0.6046746373,
0.0153960558,
-0.5406096578,
-0.0661915913,
0.7423554063,
0.7498534918,
-0.9467331171,
0.0253204871,
-0.1243683547,
-0.0071586124,
-0.0468316413,
-0.2620488107,
0.3582707047,
-0.5160936713,
-0.0661377385,
0.5137870312,
0.2357683033,
-0.3812123537,
-0.0401112586,
-0.1949265897,
-0.1850373,
0.0095142033,
0.6870546937,
0.396916002,
-0.6435827017,
-0.1027315035,
0.2475053966,
0.1491671205,
-0.2147377729,
0.9116624594,
-0.972237885,
0.5670243502,
0.4891957343,
1.1037250757,
0.3026497662,
-0.2272783816,
0.623226881,
-0.5806207657,
-0.4342705309,
0.0680025145,
0.3045196533,
0.0496180989,
-0.4182094932,
0.2736335099,
0.1083538607,
-0.5850490928,
-0.4344458878,
0.2882263362,
-0.7442353368,
-0.4968331754,
1.0313596725,
-0.1841611266,
-0.0335717946,
-0.4343805015,
-0.0535286404,
0.3437035382,
-0.2199395001,
0.8905667067,
0.8299142122,
-0.1065489501,
-0.1753996164,
-0.4139326513,
0.5197582841,
0.5686875582,
-1.0489429235,
-0.0224609245,
0.6604289412,
0.5596399307,
0.1739811301,
0.918248415,
-0.0605889671,
0.7099599838,
-0.4682585299,
-0.165171355,
-0.0435588397,
-0.5510544181,
-0.0281820893,
0.382676065,
0.1461308151,
-0.0183211584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14760v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14760v1 | An LLM Feature-based Framework for Dialogue Constructiveness Assessment | 2024-06-20T22:10:52 | 2024-06-20T22:10:52 | Lexin Zhou, Youmna Farag, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Research on dialogue constructiveness assessment focuses on (i) analysing
conversational factors that influence individuals to take specific actions, win
debates, change their perspectives or broaden their open-mindedness and (ii)
predicting constructive outcomes following dialogues for such use cases. These
objectives can be achieved by training either interpretable feature-based
models (which often involve costly human annotations) or neural models such as
pre-trained language models (which have empirically shown higher task accuracy
but lack interpretability). We propose a novel LLM feature-based framework that
combines the strengths of feature-based and neural approaches while mitigating
their downsides, in assessing dialogue constructiveness. The framework first
defines a set of dataset-independent and interpretable linguistic features,
which can be extracted by both prompting an LLM and simple heuristics. Such
features are then used to train LLM feature-based models. We apply this
framework to three datasets of dialogue constructiveness and find that our LLM
feature-based models significantly outperform standard feature-based models and
neural models, and tend to learn more robust prediction rules instead of
relying on superficial shortcuts (as seen with neural models). Further, we
demonstrate that interpreting these LLM feature-based models can yield valuable
insights into what makes a dialogue constructive. | [
-0.5576332211,
-0.5552437901,
0.527757585,
0.2481209934,
-0.2382860333,
0.2841172516,
-0.4175410867,
-0.4130576849,
0.4265156984,
0.4084275067,
-0.6165342927,
-0.2687928677,
-0.6423543096,
0.0605660416,
-0.2505522966,
0.909090519,
0.0722560063,
0.2814161181,
-0.2414756566,
-0.3943276703,
-0.4873571694,
-0.3378250003,
-0.2879646122,
-0.517482698,
0.6991887689,
0.0499543473,
0.6450542212,
0.2331472784,
0.4090779126,
0.3420015275,
-0.358340621,
-0.1479153484,
-0.5592400432,
0.126594156,
-0.2861331403,
-0.3218785226,
-0.3881859481,
0.3240988851,
0.2852278054,
0.6417908669,
-0.2132048607,
0.1354686469,
0.3196172714,
0.2072262615,
-0.450006336,
0.3184220791,
-0.9217418432,
0.0345987268,
0.1940650195,
-0.1906649917,
-0.1570420563,
-0.4339976311,
0.1745363474,
-0.2244897485,
0.2746907771,
-0.4065235257,
0.5698215365,
0.2561232746,
-0.1882751733,
-0.2588090897,
-0.5267995596,
0.5437904596,
-0.9831280708,
0.1787810475,
0.0300712325,
0.198611185,
0.0196417347,
-0.4995431006,
-0.6142680049,
-0.4082705677,
-0.0277360082,
0.1439771503,
0.108770974,
0.2454469502,
0.2980757356,
0.4750746191,
-0.0001230248,
0.2234383672,
-0.0172938388,
-0.3406817913,
0.5855544209,
0.2794702947,
-0.1082630754,
-0.313293606,
-0.5793032646,
0.1059958562,
-0.5103223324,
0.556286633,
0.074606508,
0.4922947884,
-0.0496790744,
0.4090347886,
-0.3637960255,
0.2519260943,
-0.012757441,
-0.2666142881,
0.1088056415,
-0.3666369617,
-0.2253801525,
-0.1287622601,
0.7892972827,
0.408665657,
-0.1141749918,
-0.1256598681,
-0.3854174018,
0.3309680223,
0.2556071877,
-1.0186326504,
-0.0675593838,
0.0571101345,
-0.5552119613,
-0.7846546769,
-0.0747628734,
-0.5277455449,
-0.5027420521,
-0.3927875459,
0.1887390763,
-0.0625847802,
-0.3852875829,
-0.1929138899,
0.1939683557,
0.1342694908,
0.6818240285,
-0.6849581599,
0.3394123018,
0.8510270715,
0.6366705298,
-0.2151372582,
0.0026053698,
-0.4449222684,
-0.5522748828,
-0.2942332327,
0.7281292081,
-0.752256453,
-0.1536566466,
0.0652517751,
-0.1105595008,
-0.0002091838,
-0.6034815907,
0.7398795485,
-0.3743520975,
0.2848814726,
-0.1527470201,
-0.4153898656,
-0.6963298917,
0.657353878,
-0.6787009239,
0.8259755373,
0.338586241,
-0.5887223482,
0.5214701891,
-0.4482714832,
-0.0243843738,
0.1395448446,
-0.446441263,
-0.357334733,
0.4515434504,
0.0449556112,
0.4923034906,
-0.5595639944,
0.791272223,
-0.6464649439,
-0.3227498233,
0.7948113084,
-0.782073915,
0.4726976752,
0.0949346051,
-0.4404388666,
0.3921066523,
-0.6549441218,
0.2061681002,
-0.1828917116,
-0.3598397672,
0.2067849189,
-0.0182547159,
-0.1415056437,
0.3632661402,
0.0876138061,
-0.6251084208,
-0.0267506726,
-0.4968107939,
0.5070201755,
0.6948167086,
0.0510963313,
0.2054751515,
-0.5218096375,
0.6817144156,
0.1600126326,
0.0226784684,
-0.15968135,
-0.5301988721,
-0.665478766,
-0.5218531489,
0.3256258965,
0.7485014796,
-0.6150785685,
0.5134990811,
-0.1980231404,
-0.4908713698,
-0.6533962488,
0.5682243705,
0.5649535656,
0.4506541193,
0.0795887187,
-1.0407983065,
-0.280590713,
-0.6493505836,
-0.1379263997,
-0.4431840479,
-0.1015172899,
0.538043499,
0.1926684529,
-0.030721657,
0.7027233243,
0.0309578795,
-0.1809443384,
-0.3813649118,
0.2742310762,
0.4386325181,
0.1022818089,
0.053160876,
-0.6152766347,
-0.1514932066,
-0.184264645,
-0.8112103939,
-0.2972832918,
-0.3803966641,
0.2089013904,
-0.1535208225,
0.2268916368,
-0.6436056495,
0.6625704765,
0.1965270042,
-0.3526923358,
0.3580830097,
0.3146954477,
0.1392679214,
-0.8229680061,
-0.0508410558,
0.0486415401,
-0.1656863838,
-0.4887241721,
-0.0079840738,
-0.3327054977,
-0.1741536707,
-0.4255252182,
0.3395335376,
-0.0381477103,
-0.0184229389,
-0.1871496588,
0.2294960022,
0.1345979571,
0.8528652191,
-0.025981091,
0.5926386714,
0.1097411439,
-0.1217546165,
0.3904754817,
0.268689394,
-0.606615603,
0.4655334055,
-0.6057391167,
0.2879648805,
0.1805600673,
-0.0268967766,
-1.0849876404,
0.1469059139,
0.0648845509,
-0.417678833,
0.1728685349,
-0.0651411191,
0.0627508014,
0.0134896394,
-0.502450943,
0.3620845973,
0.2172356099,
-0.3900248706,
1.0118855238,
0.0535536557,
-0.6888466477,
-0.6129951477,
-0.2054449469,
0.2762263715,
-0.3716698289,
-0.7364158034,
0.419537276,
-0.1686718762,
-0.2455596924,
-0.0922444314,
0.1421075463,
0.1136265099,
0.443696171,
0.4937696755,
0.2664805651,
-0.2542463541,
-0.2548475564,
-0.3374871314,
-0.1617184728,
0.2583995461,
0.2462133467,
0.3562705219,
-0.2912970781,
-0.3450092673,
-0.6533693075,
0.1743578911,
0.6664046645,
-0.1442764252,
0.3112723231,
0.5046573877,
-0.1011689827,
-0.0713607222,
-0.794739604,
-0.2773476541,
-0.4461728632,
0.5024664998,
-0.3637822866,
-1.1369831562,
0.8352489471,
-0.3518344164,
0.0911435187,
0.0928528458,
0.8522238731,
-0.1004989967,
0.9385160804,
0.6916148067,
-0.1695537865,
0.5725798011,
-0.0874050111,
0.4017443955,
-0.9890429974,
-0.4612255991,
-0.3406915367,
-0.3930327594,
-0.5948786736,
-0.5351428986,
0.181417942,
0.2885295749,
-0.0847716555,
0.0333717056,
-0.4014157355,
0.0830121636,
0.1647153646,
0.1475658119,
0.2700914443,
-0.1132719815,
-0.3004410267,
-0.280364424,
-0.5257325768,
-0.5701705813,
0.9140556455,
0.6766480207,
0.7197623253,
0.3125045598,
0.6082365513,
0.2793305218,
0.9147703052,
-1.2424343824,
0.7020200491,
0.2565625012,
-0.3107134998,
-0.1776252687,
-0.5140954852,
-0.4928196073,
0.2456947416,
-0.5662651658,
-0.5900672674,
0.0992991626,
-0.0771907195,
-0.3299292326,
0.1702200323,
-0.519230783,
0.7173813581,
-0.3616533875,
-0.5582606196,
-0.17800726,
-0.2431722879,
0.3770130575,
-0.0083381981,
0.0737859681,
-0.2646285594,
-0.0601080917,
0.6140964031,
-0.2024927586,
1.1071554422,
-0.3846780062,
-0.0141637409,
0.3512380421,
0.365624249,
0.3272102177,
0.362845242,
-0.1741473526,
0.2300561666,
-0.2246455401,
-0.1274326444,
-1.2557040453,
0.4162893295,
-0.6275137067,
-0.9276815057,
-0.1852864474,
-0.3469143808,
-0.2563993931,
-0.188338995,
-0.1809466481,
0.4780725241,
-0.6081691384,
0.1706273556,
0.5054035187,
-0.0600436032,
0.3302938938,
0.4778368175,
-0.289978236,
-0.776018858,
0.8856551647,
-0.131226927,
0.3108667731,
0.1006477028,
0.2965696454,
-0.3396731615,
-0.9131781459,
-0.2846631706,
-0.1349917203,
-0.6444637179,
-0.3454398811,
-0.2303140163,
-0.454424262,
-0.0414909348,
0.0079216147,
-0.1946169585,
-0.6402013898,
-0.1409971714,
-0.2922337949,
0.1486862004,
0.8257083893,
0.1489191055,
0.0336569659,
-0.5825360417,
-0.0309907626,
0.4363405108,
0.3870242834,
0.0299037602,
-0.776683867,
-0.0368308835,
-0.09267243,
-0.7127915621,
-0.5841881037,
0.3579338491,
0.2472109795,
0.5753502846,
0.5401959419,
-0.1781067848,
0.3074979782,
-0.2472795099,
1.0025680065,
0.4835810661,
-0.7737179399,
0.4184504151,
-0.1320305467,
0.0498539545,
0.902222991,
0.1714288294,
-0.2828315496,
-0.309043467,
-0.6752118468,
-0.4884805381,
0.2992361784,
0.1346226931,
0.4124625623,
0.0170898531,
0.3496246636,
0.0969281793,
0.3048003614,
-0.9090809226,
0.3558135629,
-0.5431314707,
-0.3391967416,
-0.0299301408,
-0.4343838692,
-0.4755751491,
-0.2462030351,
0.4610352814,
-0.5040460229,
0.2179546058,
0.1510007828,
0.0253493581,
0.0768179446,
0.5605808496,
0.5794821978,
0.4303342998,
-0.3276988864,
-0.0899357647,
0.4655549526,
-0.2251910865,
0.2866264284,
0.1155635417,
-0.1274183691,
-0.111606583,
0.5401381254,
0.8023707867,
0.3106348813,
-0.5848613381,
0.787266314,
-0.2862480283,
-0.2265123725,
-0.1498226523,
0.1772640944,
0.0389461331,
0.5569739342,
-0.047805436,
0.2972884476,
0.1169224828,
-0.6629087329,
0.0992654786,
0.4892178476,
-0.8281576037,
-0.3581498265,
0.1853583902,
0.6567564607,
-0.4741669893,
0.4731858373,
-0.2258114815,
-0.8611278534,
0.4740206897,
0.1701309383,
1.2314950228,
-0.0541540459,
0.1738830954,
0.1817406118,
0.1813843697,
0.3155916631,
0.4172390699,
-0.4742463827,
-1.0967504978,
-0.4979652166,
-0.6895325184,
-0.6113663912,
0.2404975295,
-0.7534793019,
0.0800969452,
-0.8658641577,
-0.314117372,
-0.0696213841,
0.1094796807,
-0.682700038,
0.13152951,
0.1965167075,
1.0268616676,
-0.6248334646,
0.6038079858,
0.3140521049,
-0.3035592437,
-0.7703918815,
-0.2752468586,
0.2234038115,
-0.831417799,
0.749388814,
0.3289943337,
-0.2814661562,
-0.5893896818,
-0.366789192,
-0.5453618169,
1.0374346972,
0.4017353356,
-0.6108911037,
0.0477018617,
0.1454071254,
0.5610659719,
-0.8755584359,
0.6352617741,
0.5284865499,
0.0788681433,
0.3086606562,
-0.9007672071,
0.1874629855,
-0.6404678822,
0.2284771502,
-0.1307386011,
-0.5515273809,
0.378143847,
-0.2990829349,
-0.0597233176,
0.2772636414,
0.7372124791,
0.1274451613,
0.4311167598,
0.618439734,
0.7298630476,
0.6119044423,
-0.2519060671,
0.6200315952,
-0.477948159,
0.1698813885,
1.2010298967,
-0.4569472671,
1.0684158802,
0.2631382346,
0.0928086713,
0.8258442283,
0.4305943251,
-0.0066153943,
0.564393878,
0.3896983266,
-0.6331133246,
-0.401812166,
-0.4461999536,
0.0142681748,
0.7988170385,
0.5434875488,
-0.5366499424,
-0.0350027271,
-0.0772665814,
-0.085261859,
0.3079788983,
-0.1394814998,
1.2267442942,
0.2947920263,
-0.6843693852,
0.6372767687,
-0.0831609368,
0.8125188947,
-0.4200785458,
-0.1878208816,
-0.2212113887,
-0.0431478322,
-0.2921622396,
-0.8495594263,
0.135324508,
0.0919856504,
-0.1538428515,
-0.2810289562,
0.6201885343,
-0.3576106727,
-0.4453544319,
0.4250267148,
0.5028705001,
-0.1391530335,
0.1076834723,
-0.9540022612,
0.2964007556,
0.1096591428,
-0.2947754264,
0.3145978749,
0.5781901479,
0.0083429776,
0.6710101962,
0.6092082262,
0.2772210836,
-0.4814156592,
0.4918908775,
1.234154582,
-0.8702530861,
-0.1849180162,
-0.5280700922,
0.6850645542,
-0.1840960234,
-0.4321028888,
0.1309423894,
0.2596693933,
0.7204702497,
0.5689280629,
0.7881113887,
0.1270977408,
0.5798573494,
-0.6673315167,
0.4753893018,
-0.1235401928,
0.6951505542,
-0.1180134639,
-0.96795398,
0.0880889595,
0.6769676805,
-0.3460800946,
0.2930217385,
0.4648759961,
1.1256976128,
0.1105753481,
0.5112068057,
0.3887224197,
0.2923989296,
0.5571684241,
0.7153336406,
1.3407365084,
-0.1022177413,
0.2467143685,
-0.3939034045,
-0.4636831284,
-0.0381084085,
-1.0114374161,
-1.1300826073,
-0.3162380755,
-0.3043858409,
-0.4795046449,
-0.4380228519,
1.0455981493,
0.6626779437,
-0.7036684155,
-0.1713456959,
0.1649468839,
0.0900941044,
-0.0438483581,
-0.2704800963,
-0.1017448604,
-0.3452223241,
-0.1095350906,
0.5400372148,
0.3945520818,
-0.2376942486,
-0.6162609458,
-0.1845488995,
0.159587428,
0.3544579744,
0.5977064967,
0.0374481045,
-0.9728733301,
-0.4505278766,
-0.1654840857,
-0.0363123454,
0.1630371809,
0.9654211998,
-0.9680330753,
0.5565732718,
0.2646284997,
0.7408299446,
0.4198580682,
-0.0045484421,
0.5798556805,
-0.4127955437,
0.1981352717,
0.619992137,
0.2808754742,
0.5760465264,
-0.3552318811,
0.4602712691,
0.3132963181,
-0.264950335,
-0.7234999537,
0.2657445371,
-1.1182552576,
0.1331791878,
0.6728180647,
-0.6007530689,
-0.0140021732,
-0.062837638,
-0.1313644499,
-0.1713750809,
-0.3351400197,
1.0600805283,
0.6779046655,
-0.2570371628,
-0.4278817177,
-0.3638601601,
0.5808001161,
0.6709130406,
-0.6485267878,
0.1182004735,
0.2387053818,
0.3408764005,
0.3432188928,
0.4106579721,
-0.1601620913,
0.3162861764,
-0.1555523872,
-0.098797366,
-0.2382911295,
-0.453502506,
-0.4804153442,
0.2402969748,
0.4724083543,
0.5718884468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15516v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15516v1 | System Description for the Displace Speaker Diarization Challenge 2023 | 2024-06-20T21:40:02 | 2024-06-20T21:40:02 | Ali Aliyev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper describes our solution for the Diarization of Speaker and Language
in Conversational Environments Challenge (Displace 2023). We used a combination
of VAD for finding segfments with speech, Resnet architecture based CNN for
feature extraction from these segments, and spectral clustering for features
clustering. Even though it was not trained with using Hindi, the described
algorithm achieves the following metrics: DER 27. 1% and DER 27. 4%, on the
development and phase-1 evaluation parts of the dataset, respectively. | [
-0.8857351542,
-0.9151104093,
0.1420563906,
0.2360845953,
-0.0845999196,
0.5479671359,
-0.0801388696,
-0.3699557185,
0.1296833605,
0.4850788414,
-0.5610865355,
-0.5307276845,
-0.5485543609,
0.0552944317,
-0.5871953368,
0.6004202962,
0.4576636851,
-0.0629544333,
-0.3315938413,
0.09035898,
-0.8350992203,
-0.5290231109,
-0.3337503374,
-0.334734261,
0.1461010575,
0.8859389424,
0.2738609016,
0.6260778308,
0.603504777,
0.503026247,
-0.561199367,
-0.0055595902,
-0.2809862792,
-0.1080906913,
0.1071277335,
0.0094764726,
-0.1905867755,
-0.1384409815,
0.751760304,
0.9720140696,
-0.7735155821,
-0.069442749,
-0.0646550953,
0.6095334291,
-0.217920512,
0.1747937053,
-0.6436626315,
0.3242284358,
-0.6198926568,
0.0007779693,
-0.3557547927,
-0.1750839949,
0.4078140259,
-0.1981147081,
0.7322472334,
-0.0692898408,
0.8585502505,
0.5431242585,
-0.1265837401,
0.0112790363,
-1.1053466797,
0.6352427006,
-0.3724096417,
0.6600036025,
0.3737475276,
0.493298471,
-0.1862890571,
-0.5769364238,
-0.8669202924,
0.0542034768,
0.070866175,
-0.1178301573,
-0.2070811391,
0.0265410729,
0.1243742779,
0.4737348855,
-0.5003638864,
0.3221019804,
-0.8126455545,
-0.1387303323,
0.7469167709,
0.0489796661,
0.3960604966,
-0.3030053675,
-0.5311777592,
-0.1418851167,
-0.2940961421,
-0.2980481684,
0.1743491143,
0.5083352923,
-0.2635399997,
0.3388828933,
-0.0371406041,
0.8300377727,
-0.0434938334,
-0.2437756062,
0.7280107737,
-0.1296558529,
-0.2155910879,
0.4628439844,
0.5969403386,
0.1099600494,
-0.0459434055,
-0.0437104627,
-0.012559847,
-0.2460340112,
0.2954234481,
-0.2319934964,
-0.3121552765,
0.06191561,
-0.3153418005,
-0.0534888655,
-0.120442085,
-1.3891195059,
-0.5682520866,
-0.2908275127,
0.0325266495,
-0.5668606758,
-0.4290234447,
0.1023296788,
-0.2842799127,
0.2020833492,
0.2616770267,
-1.2899280787,
0.6704834104,
0.5386357307,
0.857681632,
-0.3535895944,
-0.0786918923,
-0.098280862,
-0.208198607,
-0.1088478938,
0.7742130756,
-0.6456483006,
-0.8009492159,
-0.263803333,
-0.0043750284,
-0.0949480608,
-0.883046031,
0.3288100064,
-0.3443363905,
0.1357444227,
-0.0261665042,
-0.3170732856,
-0.0654956326,
0.1114977971,
-0.7063650489,
1.0206962824,
0.4320494831,
-0.6830015779,
0.2326477319,
-0.451184392,
0.0042884275,
0.4889230132,
-0.2657963634,
-0.6013636589,
-0.1445429623,
0.1582045108,
0.1941628903,
-0.0940993801,
0.1277151257,
-0.0092540244,
-0.4128088653,
-0.0832994133,
-0.3865339458,
0.673691988,
0.5000730753,
-0.3388327658,
-0.2538817823,
-1.1297981739,
-0.2460420728,
0.2396759391,
-0.5274490118,
-0.1004964113,
0.2857474685,
0.0270856712,
-0.0968142897,
0.1644271016,
-0.8023561835,
0.0394003354,
-0.7267913222,
0.3229635358,
0.7763749361,
0.2642943263,
0.1996645629,
0.2010517418,
0.66326648,
0.3100727797,
0.114266485,
0.2155282646,
-0.5395320654,
-0.9343728423,
-0.2971931994,
0.2249323577,
0.9024104476,
-0.7218195796,
0.5649815798,
-0.3125601411,
-0.748672843,
-0.3325904906,
-0.0038341237,
0.6611046195,
0.6032434106,
0.4171185493,
-0.0978489295,
-0.8230555654,
-1.1928064823,
0.6338011622,
-0.3657584488,
0.1746245325,
-0.1039784402,
0.1563172787,
-0.1455106288,
0.9398668408,
-0.4889875352,
-0.1628908664,
-0.1813569963,
0.0723130479,
-0.1404770166,
0.4749502242,
0.3233608007,
-1.3144524097,
-0.4661425054,
0.2359359115,
-0.4799933732,
-0.2133530676,
0.2740473151,
0.3519204259,
0.0017480529,
0.9374302626,
-0.0908179358,
0.6637954116,
0.4642400444,
-0.013196921,
0.3259619772,
-0.1064718813,
0.1891857386,
-1.1986100674,
-0.0499168746,
0.1901899129,
0.0467803739,
-0.7856889963,
-0.3813403845,
-0.4257957637,
-0.4738977551,
-0.6898754835,
0.1112821773,
-0.2849157155,
-0.0448267013,
0.0064336476,
0.5424864292,
-0.2818482518,
0.4706600308,
0.020011086,
0.7017889023,
0.3356598318,
-0.6996248364,
0.9268798828,
0.8316153288,
-0.6258909702,
0.7720226049,
-0.6480506659,
0.2526836097,
-0.1882704049,
-0.0378452986,
-1.206989646,
-0.0848288983,
0.1373755485,
-0.4365699291,
0.3202926517,
0.0542534664,
-0.1623342335,
-0.7745079398,
0.210387677,
0.4495663643,
0.4970491827,
-0.4822668135,
-0.0392494872,
0.804377377,
-0.3993644118,
-0.4516344965,
-0.7531059384,
0.3353133202,
-0.6997093558,
-0.3081509471,
0.925033927,
-0.0394668207,
-0.4929794371,
-0.251475811,
0.3143295944,
-0.056553755,
0.0681062266,
0.2378510386,
0.0465208627,
0.0767424777,
0.0747046545,
-0.482825011,
-0.3581598401,
-0.2853169441,
0.2846048474,
0.7310397625,
-0.0879060552,
-0.6188710928,
-0.6502104402,
0.5502377748,
0.5975160599,
-0.3958468735,
0.4713969529,
0.6679781675,
-0.5286629796,
0.0752620846,
-0.642500639,
0.2295786291,
-0.4986480772,
0.8082437515,
-0.3546974957,
-1.0148861408,
0.8040654659,
-0.1994835883,
-0.3200562298,
0.353730619,
0.5324560404,
0.2139168382,
1.128985405,
0.7972367406,
-0.07021676,
0.5922905207,
-0.0118996212,
0.458563596,
-0.9194138646,
-0.9780140519,
-0.9069458246,
-0.3992930353,
-0.7279450893,
-0.3421563506,
0.5821686983,
0.1637133807,
-0.011059124,
0.4604589045,
-1.028072238,
0.3230519295,
0.6022956967,
0.0857349411,
-0.237157464,
0.029529348,
0.0584791563,
-0.2471403331,
-0.4306294918,
-0.2016430944,
0.3339605927,
0.5085840225,
0.4219554067,
0.3304965794,
0.9440600276,
0.5383998156,
-0.3491300046,
-0.5883709192,
0.7443403006,
-0.1109805331,
-0.3137652874,
-0.7272429466,
-0.3072236776,
-1.0627803802,
-0.0192231834,
0.1344339848,
-1.19685781,
0.6675868034,
-0.2870188355,
-0.2863464057,
0.0964455903,
-0.795506537,
0.7492579818,
0.0538997501,
0.3861907423,
-0.208574295,
-0.7297480702,
0.0882285312,
-0.163901031,
0.253998667,
-0.1564410329,
0.3389748633,
0.9164428711,
-0.6544142365,
0.8048182726,
-0.5152587295,
-0.0640191585,
0.5006543398,
-0.1518893689,
0.0961742774,
-0.1315742284,
-0.1778249294,
0.0575548895,
0.022591196,
-0.3499881327,
-0.529548645,
0.5795040727,
-0.7167518735,
-0.7560341954,
-0.2309118062,
-0.022927776,
-0.3497779369,
-0.0687746778,
0.1876779348,
0.38481462,
-0.6988943815,
0.2985859215,
0.8901084065,
-0.4738121033,
0.7119432688,
0.5546091199,
-0.0577270724,
-0.6716415286,
1.1942894459,
0.0632898286,
0.2099351734,
0.3739685714,
0.029891897,
-0.3502121568,
-0.775277853,
-0.3918151855,
-0.0043659373,
-0.6089875698,
-0.119062528,
-0.4509646893,
-0.725341022,
-0.5815760493,
0.1474757791,
-0.4414601028,
-0.0816058218,
-0.3414554894,
-0.3290315568,
0.186932683,
0.8808775544,
-0.1949065328,
0.3876864314,
-0.6735648513,
0.1596971601,
0.5142986774,
0.1825404614,
-0.1715734005,
-0.6191619635,
-0.503235817,
-0.0223555826,
-0.4860591888,
-0.7999230027,
0.5250363946,
0.3618664742,
0.8083351851,
0.3038132191,
-0.1486777365,
0.9616684318,
-0.6678057909,
1.2509593964,
0.2242402881,
-0.8149290681,
0.9427122474,
-0.1721986681,
0.2645234466,
0.4433595538,
0.2690598071,
-0.8310844898,
-0.1674013138,
-0.6938408613,
-0.763692975,
0.920804143,
0.0519693233,
0.0963570252,
-0.5597983599,
0.1906718463,
-0.2021081448,
-0.0690160766,
-0.2288922817,
-0.3111525476,
-0.0577871092,
0.0198974684,
-0.1333159357,
-0.5371851921,
-0.0702350736,
-0.4716290534,
0.4076994359,
0.2822951078,
0.3642125726,
0.1936374009,
0.3947193623,
0.1932028532,
0.2409279495,
0.8585022688,
0.3425097466,
-0.2474409491,
0.1971521974,
0.4680419862,
-0.5626764297,
0.3419210315,
0.0791878402,
0.3843887746,
0.0030859122,
0.2558369935,
0.7872284055,
-0.0213833191,
-0.635025382,
0.4417881966,
-0.0023625919,
-0.3389781713,
-0.4839184284,
0.006733634,
0.0608547144,
0.2400402129,
0.4208754599,
0.0788804293,
-0.0017306142,
-0.1023922563,
0.6120508909,
0.0309924092,
-0.8255354762,
-0.3557930589,
0.4503542185,
0.4536550641,
-0.8928018212,
1.0095682144,
-0.4234445095,
-0.593206346,
0.6760310531,
0.7142919302,
0.7853719592,
-0.8199226856,
0.4027347565,
0.2408249974,
0.0273875576,
0.2183095515,
0.1381528676,
-0.0643692166,
-0.9146473408,
-0.19328022,
-0.8643675447,
-0.1883159429,
0.4208987951,
-0.6849122047,
0.5579888821,
-0.3818885684,
-0.0564430244,
0.2141482681,
-0.2006335109,
-0.3635880053,
0.3559386432,
0.6598643064,
0.6851636171,
-0.8732764721,
0.6636347175,
0.4872376621,
-0.2342469096,
-0.4200389385,
-0.3829598427,
0.4047976434,
-0.6896417737,
0.6527489424,
-0.2183481008,
-0.042146001,
0.1923250854,
-0.22642681,
-0.9019626379,
1.1118710041,
0.4092097282,
-0.5519223213,
0.1485810727,
0.3702861369,
0.5290126204,
-0.2208899558,
-0.0919763297,
0.7611089945,
0.5459994078,
0.4461944699,
-1.3867396116,
-0.5943180919,
-0.5870214105,
0.3082051873,
0.1622309536,
-0.799973011,
0.6843916774,
-0.0017094309,
-0.4152837694,
-0.0841366053,
0.649964273,
0.0658216923,
0.1601141691,
0.8222095966,
0.9403125048,
0.8113728166,
-0.0473974608,
0.3697997332,
0.0629931614,
0.2845133841,
0.9148703814,
-0.2614747882,
0.7859355211,
0.3730981052,
-0.6883050799,
0.6279698014,
0.9886825681,
0.006959423,
0.6400154829,
0.3799079359,
-0.6533238292,
-0.0628177375,
-0.3921120763,
-0.4860564172,
1.233971715,
0.6551898718,
-0.0087431334,
-0.2947821617,
0.4233331978,
-0.2839153111,
0.4554298818,
0.1576013118,
1.0030455589,
-0.1834711879,
-0.3952104449,
0.8288607001,
0.0380405411,
0.3681083918,
-0.2782699168,
-0.3459509611,
-0.2895803154,
0.065063104,
-0.1405469924,
-0.515837431,
0.7777217031,
-0.219340831,
-0.3477016687,
-0.410942167,
0.2950842977,
-0.4107894003,
-0.3748163283,
0.0691991299,
0.1945492923,
0.3727057874,
0.2302226126,
-0.6692758203,
0.2400791943,
0.3597338498,
0.007081416,
0.29604128,
0.6353586316,
-0.1126718521,
0.8749552965,
0.0853815079,
0.1394426227,
-0.030328609,
0.3899005949,
0.861315012,
-0.5584938526,
-0.3955391049,
-0.9576480985,
0.3848972619,
-0.1759024113,
-0.2234962434,
0.6535221934,
0.7053716183,
0.7640573978,
0.0522263013,
0.5752255321,
-0.4037172794,
0.8597893715,
-0.2524194717,
0.4524634778,
-0.396235019,
0.4363909662,
-0.4951332211,
-0.8884193301,
-0.178518489,
0.2934496999,
-0.1352662444,
0.0469583943,
0.5559265614,
0.9822990298,
0.0567804165,
-0.1537306011,
0.3599642217,
-0.1712190956,
0.5575014949,
0.3916642368,
0.7617101073,
-0.186357379,
0.5820146799,
-0.362139225,
-0.4142588973,
-0.3095345795,
-0.5665518045,
-0.4351020157,
-1.3492348194,
-0.6843516827,
-0.134257257,
-0.1738296151,
0.3356834948,
0.9255902767,
-0.8661744595,
-0.1584105939,
-0.2552854717,
0.1431944817,
-0.2446845621,
-0.2702329755,
0.3959804773,
-0.2029193193,
-1.0551896095,
0.8086817265,
0.4781141877,
0.2041832507,
-0.6053620577,
0.0330557898,
-0.4775297046,
-0.2778902352,
0.3057172298,
0.4261058569,
-0.7268593907,
-0.9326036572,
-0.2702967227,
0.0800578743,
0.0952648371,
0.3691344857,
-0.8025587797,
0.865688324,
0.5573561192,
0.3793869019,
0.419515729,
0.3878011405,
0.4371843636,
-1.1634780169,
0.7405892015,
0.2579197288,
0.0517807826,
0.5854382515,
-0.2077226788,
0.3960072994,
0.5781277418,
-0.7308903933,
-0.9362286925,
0.2408632189,
-0.9969254732,
0.1299421042,
0.8240794539,
0.0410693027,
-0.3808854818,
-0.440353632,
-0.2966360152,
0.2436287552,
0.0426955298,
0.9171136022,
0.8138810396,
-0.3730204999,
-0.4985373318,
-0.3338320255,
0.5508460999,
0.0984473228,
-0.4594701827,
0.0045482148,
0.327791065,
-0.0702172071,
0.7095327377,
0.7087395191,
-0.3455894589,
-0.1010896116,
0.2779850364,
0.4662632644,
0.0136963977,
-0.3783940375,
-0.07334847,
-0.0310395602,
-0.0611013547,
-0.7092490196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14747v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14747v1 | An Adapter-Based Unified Model for Multiple Spoken Language Processing Tasks | 2024-06-20T21:39:04 | 2024-06-20T21:39:04 | Varsha Suresh, Salah Aït-Mokhtar, Caroline Brun, Ioan Calapodescu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Self-supervised learning models have revolutionized the field of speech
processing. However, the process of fine-tuning these models on downstream
tasks requires substantial computational resources, particularly when dealing
with multiple speech-processing tasks. In this paper, we explore the potential
of adapter-based fine-tuning in developing a unified model capable of
effectively handling multiple spoken language processing tasks. The tasks we
investigate are Automatic Speech Recognition, Phoneme Recognition, Intent
Classification, Slot Filling, and Spoken Emotion Recognition. We validate our
approach through a series of experiments on the SUPERB benchmark, and our
results indicate that adapter-based fine-tuning enables a single
encoder-decoder model to perform multiple speech processing tasks with an
average improvement of 18.4% across the five target tasks while staying
efficient in terms of parameter updates. | [
-0.4174527526,
-0.5168088078,
0.2518521249,
0.1743980497,
0.0721223503,
-0.5735746026,
-0.3642814755,
-0.4020485282,
-0.3598380983,
0.6346770525,
-0.3774125874,
-0.0921099484,
-0.4784859121,
0.14034006,
-0.233103618,
0.6877509356,
0.3084050119,
-0.0675115511,
0.1895399541,
-0.3345929384,
-0.7544386983,
-0.2804089785,
-0.6741734147,
-0.4566524029,
0.2334434986,
0.7831425071,
0.4466120303,
0.4872729778,
0.353864342,
0.3280388415,
0.1221654341,
0.0864928663,
-0.3308698833,
0.3040026426,
-0.3307507932,
-0.3519108891,
-0.5482113361,
-0.0356654264,
0.7549253702,
0.5149224401,
-0.517821908,
0.2404874116,
0.296728313,
0.656391561,
-0.5582738519,
0.0918163806,
-0.9029408693,
-0.4418072701,
0.006129384,
0.113542363,
-0.3621890545,
0.0815881342,
-0.1268458664,
-0.4308882952,
0.3319185078,
-0.4572360516,
0.2313033789,
0.5809274912,
-0.0782620609,
-0.076634489,
-0.8022172451,
0.6468175054,
-0.8079856038,
0.6708459258,
0.0463525616,
0.2983927131,
-0.0675476715,
-0.5069031715,
-0.6030071974,
0.0950575322,
0.1202805117,
0.0260295477,
-0.4785726666,
0.277320534,
0.089550145,
0.1549206823,
-0.3324464262,
0.2884575129,
-0.1696674079,
0.001260886,
0.493948698,
0.0703997537,
0.353128463,
0.0748153105,
0.1640794873,
-0.0596427433,
-0.2159766257,
0.2754059136,
0.2052109241,
0.8130045533,
-0.0796627775,
0.3211923838,
-0.5282331109,
1.040692091,
0.1686843187,
-0.135075286,
0.0032110675,
-0.2593867481,
-0.386399895,
0.0376237817,
0.6468207836,
0.2308119088,
0.412512213,
-0.1997902542,
-0.0376869701,
0.1509270817,
0.4952457845,
-0.702188015,
-0.3290500343,
0.1221657991,
-0.1507064551,
0.0587377213,
-0.2227099091,
-0.4325268269,
-0.0639582798,
-0.5767464042,
0.4578087628,
-0.4741172791,
-0.222202152,
0.4031524658,
-0.0683680251,
-0.1168253124,
0.2870306969,
-1.0695152283,
0.4939901233,
0.3991352618,
0.6433228254,
-0.0599320196,
-0.5240478516,
-0.7055522799,
0.1067089736,
0.0471371859,
0.9543704391,
-0.8657966852,
-0.2432088703,
-0.2475298196,
0.1893533468,
-0.6680301428,
-0.4384798408,
0.6734677553,
-0.1194115952,
-0.3019498289,
0.0057093883,
-0.5658649206,
-0.2960992754,
-0.0896609649,
-0.4862066805,
0.7787857056,
-0.1870227754,
-0.3216090798,
0.0838644579,
-0.9219653606,
-0.4806387126,
0.0701430887,
0.098646909,
-0.2403219491,
0.3184978068,
0.4966864586,
0.7171422243,
-0.2174523175,
0.2551904023,
-0.2961452603,
-0.2695674598,
-0.0398535319,
-0.4773289263,
0.3825114369,
0.2972639203,
-0.1052159816,
0.2652064562,
-1.1666889191,
-0.0605070964,
-0.2738573849,
-0.7253677249,
-0.1274722815,
0.0179569609,
0.3295903802,
0.3091171086,
0.1871083528,
-0.6805104017,
0.1705579907,
-0.1902287751,
0.518230617,
0.3948811889,
-0.2994684875,
0.3770844042,
-0.1675306261,
0.2205579579,
0.1060552523,
0.0236693285,
-0.4714722931,
-0.3393054605,
-0.8751961589,
-0.1688029021,
0.198786974,
0.5585694909,
-0.1925777495,
0.5022699237,
-0.1272834986,
-0.7102845907,
-1.0388674736,
0.1528605819,
0.2984190881,
0.4767822325,
0.563657999,
-0.1304925233,
-0.3332256675,
-0.8253391981,
-0.5629391074,
0.2634470165,
-0.0476519279,
0.3425550163,
-0.0629256964,
-0.4180191755,
0.7182773948,
-0.2257092148,
-0.645865202,
-0.1076084748,
0.0914380997,
0.2517915368,
0.5834371448,
0.33641541,
-0.5720316768,
-0.4181693494,
0.3357424736,
-0.4910018146,
-0.0544937886,
-0.0942171961,
0.3796556592,
-0.0478231013,
0.5873925686,
-0.0528696254,
0.125001803,
0.7741150856,
-0.1146247089,
0.2654120922,
-0.5610542297,
0.0327184349,
-0.8031281233,
-0.1197388321,
0.1623344421,
-0.1619248539,
-1.1322886944,
0.0467258915,
0.2211201489,
-0.2678474486,
-0.2939386368,
0.3313013613,
-0.2213860005,
0.1691243351,
-0.6203463078,
-0.1309756637,
-0.1856588125,
0.4742626548,
-0.2219775766,
0.7891584635,
1.1499512196,
-0.9010282755,
0.2795465589,
-0.0272765867,
0.0527296029,
0.6446745992,
-0.7208537459,
0.421628058,
-0.1427626908,
-0.1690038741,
-1.1354330778,
-0.2358634174,
-0.2796878517,
-0.1670584381,
0.1954617649,
-0.2454481274,
-0.2123882324,
-0.3023029268,
0.2306996733,
0.2124245912,
0.1674281806,
-0.6495347619,
1.0373899937,
0.5181592703,
-0.3250534534,
-0.1388900131,
-0.36917907,
-0.1759202778,
-0.1197801605,
-0.6271297932,
0.2623197436,
-0.09840215,
0.2462847382,
-0.264649123,
-0.229569748,
-0.1258357167,
0.0613124408,
0.3936467171,
-0.2427327633,
-0.0686921105,
0.2632060349,
0.1557246894,
-0.1941105723,
-0.4147314429,
-0.4532116354,
0.4468839467,
-0.3275181949,
-0.3846984804,
-0.8221025467,
0.2819918394,
0.7808090448,
-0.2742603421,
0.2553054392,
0.7905266881,
-0.4242270887,
0.0617498606,
-0.9500942826,
-0.0522321388,
-0.4724758565,
0.4458301961,
-0.8400750756,
-0.9344002604,
0.5189161301,
-0.2139316946,
0.2771238089,
0.4715738893,
0.4446948171,
-0.0174726136,
1.0710114241,
0.7587398887,
-0.4590632021,
0.5852008462,
0.2021711171,
0.0041158134,
-0.9941450953,
0.1401526779,
-0.7409725785,
-0.172077626,
-0.5838750005,
-0.117609106,
0.4004848897,
0.0178914499,
-0.1320119202,
0.6122521162,
-0.5935671329,
0.3663534522,
0.7401911616,
0.2081924081,
0.2666222751,
-0.1635243148,
-0.0634310693,
0.2404702902,
-0.7711237669,
-0.4509774148,
0.9532167912,
0.2581266165,
0.8773235679,
0.0050598145,
0.4937226176,
-0.0064489907,
-0.1893478781,
-0.4927229881,
0.2538320124,
-0.7597045898,
-0.3739984334,
-0.6484180093,
-0.0882611573,
-0.8794631958,
0.5853303075,
-0.0415178798,
-0.8652845025,
0.2674172223,
0.4555290341,
-0.4225936532,
0.0739822462,
-0.9705987573,
0.8535659909,
0.0703335777,
0.009041464,
-0.6534140706,
-0.4034940898,
0.0212197956,
-0.2213178426,
0.3938174844,
-0.405236721,
0.5742054582,
0.6737968922,
0.2621847689,
0.8714009523,
-0.3038515747,
-0.0167686455,
0.0543617681,
-0.0468611754,
0.354886502,
0.0549898408,
-0.4979399741,
0.1369350553,
0.2087027878,
-0.282704711,
-0.3560217917,
0.6860439777,
-0.7586830258,
-0.4584319592,
0.09575212,
-0.7741675377,
-0.2851521671,
0.2997612953,
-0.1193861663,
0.5298238397,
-0.3797729909,
0.0622721054,
0.3717647493,
0.1291687042,
0.5985222459,
0.8114266396,
0.1447331458,
-0.1904653758,
0.9960458279,
0.0445151925,
0.3679812253,
0.1548788399,
0.2434385568,
-0.0736666247,
-0.5721045732,
-0.3987480998,
0.0437579937,
-0.4373663068,
-0.0212616213,
-0.7753658891,
-0.0163054112,
-0.7604997158,
0.1092976704,
-0.6815004349,
-0.0475265086,
-0.5654705167,
0.2861590683,
0.2569825351,
0.7670838237,
-0.304457128,
0.6058480144,
-0.7175635695,
0.8558003902,
0.8715360761,
0.7141693234,
-0.1816466898,
-0.8581153154,
-0.2403690815,
0.2013759613,
-0.4514138103,
-0.5368336439,
0.2024154663,
0.6947878599,
0.6666774154,
0.4244962931,
-0.2218170017,
0.9821817279,
-0.8019979,
0.3107215762,
0.1351892948,
-0.9423956871,
0.6589457393,
-0.3162204027,
0.7497835159,
0.5770383477,
-0.0517020002,
-0.6470986009,
-0.2231297344,
-0.4328404665,
-0.4513599873,
1.0053360462,
-0.0106170792,
0.2380781323,
0.2142834961,
0.261684835,
0.1847919226,
-0.2177841663,
-0.4164738953,
-0.2408591956,
-0.2150518894,
-0.0949750245,
-0.298364222,
-0.1350292563,
0.0640176386,
-0.5737900734,
0.6179364324,
-0.4517711997,
0.1245477796,
0.0724427849,
-0.2373743206,
-0.072179921,
0.7240893245,
0.4700069129,
0.288472712,
-0.2436973304,
-0.0068902425,
0.4192760587,
-0.3253916502,
-0.0582930669,
0.6762595773,
0.1480844915,
-0.0914196149,
-0.1171500981,
1.0663938522,
0.4419195354,
-0.3291732073,
-0.0468440093,
-0.2911891639,
-0.0352984481,
0.0799623057,
0.5467636585,
0.2506095469,
0.2851296365,
0.3071191609,
0.4861044586,
0.4067728817,
-0.4563755393,
0.2510710955,
0.3846678734,
-0.7001598477,
-0.457225889,
0.6543887258,
0.3154188693,
-0.5093744397,
0.3099054694,
-0.0189598966,
-0.2025046647,
0.2752737701,
0.7935507298,
0.5943496227,
-0.8677638769,
-0.2425010949,
0.3618234396,
0.1356586218,
-0.2015758455,
0.3542223275,
-0.1159671023,
-0.9192231297,
-0.2335325927,
-0.6767731309,
-0.3743250072,
0.0726385564,
-0.6948163509,
0.181319505,
0.1701503992,
-0.1264920533,
0.5274445415,
-0.590485692,
-0.8869330287,
0.4197160006,
0.2724442482,
0.6175020933,
-0.6985684633,
1.1435929537,
0.7593953609,
0.1360041797,
-0.8059071898,
-0.3099467754,
-0.0849026367,
-0.66279459,
0.0840280354,
0.2376538366,
-0.2933683693,
0.4324390292,
-0.0684367195,
-0.850099504,
0.611190021,
0.4457511902,
-1.0468863249,
0.0572085157,
0.0330394283,
0.4244988263,
-0.4033054709,
0.2208870202,
1.0724030733,
0.2658624053,
-0.2261289954,
-1.4336291552,
-0.2950077355,
-0.1466476172,
-0.0473530255,
0.0361278392,
-0.4502720237,
0.7097941041,
-0.2817650437,
-0.090113923,
-0.3040359914,
0.4647380412,
0.1165413558,
-0.0402750596,
0.7396479249,
0.4398649037,
0.7548137903,
0.082019724,
0.6436082721,
-0.3918563128,
0.3077803552,
1.2509822845,
-0.1288187057,
0.9291964769,
0.179738149,
-0.1945334971,
0.1366678774,
0.0371353067,
0.0984245539,
0.4340395629,
-0.0835849047,
-0.2282512188,
-0.4183942974,
-0.0791941881,
-0.1727785319,
0.8366456032,
0.4827457964,
0.0486251339,
-0.2636260092,
0.4076790214,
-0.4017162025,
-0.0318205692,
-0.4248022735,
1.0881780386,
0.1108011231,
-0.7065401673,
0.3562454283,
-0.0031122842,
0.9403630495,
-0.302382797,
0.0692242458,
0.1764171124,
0.3872541785,
-0.1168735325,
-0.6124843359,
0.2440365255,
-0.04640067,
-0.300473541,
-0.1508174837,
0.9736264348,
-0.5264629126,
-0.6246030927,
0.3313378096,
0.3676073849,
0.055748485,
-0.5476997495,
-0.557707727,
0.0696174279,
0.0050227246,
0.0111142425,
0.2481971681,
0.3753525317,
0.3896575868,
0.6027899384,
0.7482922673,
0.0507303253,
0.4109275937,
0.6460018754,
0.7548344135,
-0.6844998002,
-0.64771837,
-0.7740261555,
0.4635571837,
0.2651351392,
-0.3053689003,
0.4444594085,
0.2643401027,
0.7103439569,
-0.0924182162,
0.9572675824,
0.1773927212,
0.6876525283,
-0.2286859304,
0.5535206199,
-0.4596289694,
-0.1507980376,
-0.2553327382,
-0.5055593252,
-0.2960490286,
0.6260765791,
0.0029464429,
-0.1400754303,
0.2109121531,
0.597705245,
-0.3036684394,
0.2871831954,
0.6165289879,
0.0320666656,
0.3627738059,
0.3222914934,
0.215818271,
-0.642691493,
0.4080401659,
-0.2812814713,
-0.1478655785,
-0.1858998835,
-0.5216530561,
-0.7962369323,
-0.6628385782,
-0.267387867,
0.1099620312,
0.173664391,
0.6839266419,
1.0678807497,
-1.0342640877,
-0.3924337626,
-0.1853171885,
-0.2608278096,
-0.4757061899,
-0.2014001161,
0.0454799086,
-0.7851976156,
-0.900257051,
0.7374426723,
0.427747041,
-0.0865737423,
0.3041323721,
0.0794432759,
-0.0287567079,
-0.0362771749,
0.4943185151,
0.2953616679,
-0.8565832973,
-0.2587213218,
-0.1524545699,
0.2101043016,
0.1987382025,
0.7312240601,
-0.6831042767,
0.8457988501,
-0.0174561441,
0.6986169815,
0.5404916406,
0.0409208462,
0.6446394324,
-0.6023205519,
0.0380259156,
-0.0932472199,
0.4989610314,
0.351939559,
-0.2241457999,
0.1549534202,
-0.3009085059,
-0.9087002277,
-0.5292882919,
0.2043779641,
-1.1139611006,
-0.1324604601,
0.9156750441,
0.0721982569,
0.2493527085,
-0.3647586405,
-0.2470156401,
0.5772448182,
-0.5951915979,
0.6221067309,
0.5890425444,
-0.4920804203,
-0.2280753404,
-0.4401629865,
0.2455912232,
0.356987834,
-0.7780026793,
0.2656413019,
0.2224909514,
0.4974663258,
0.1350090057,
0.5857359171,
0.2773266733,
0.2795123458,
-0.1976575404,
0.2814041674,
-0.0638721734,
-0.4556611478,
-0.8162484765,
0.2072391063,
0.0518652275,
-0.3883388042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14745v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14745v2 | Relation Extraction with Fine-Tuned Large Language Models in Retrieval Augmented Generation Frameworks | 2024-06-20T21:27:57 | 2024-06-24T06:57:05 | Sefika Efeoglu, Adrian Paschke | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Information Extraction (IE) is crucial for converting unstructured data into
structured formats like Knowledge Graphs (KGs). A key task within IE is
Relation Extraction (RE), which identifies relationships between entities in
text. Various RE methods exist, including supervised, unsupervised, weakly
supervised, and rule-based approaches. Recent studies leveraging pre-trained
language models (PLMs) have shown significant success in this area. In the
current era dominated by Large Language Models (LLMs), fine-tuning these models
can overcome limitations associated with zero-shot LLM prompting-based RE
methods, especially regarding domain adaptation challenges and identifying
implicit relations between entities in sentences. These implicit relations,
which cannot be easily extracted from a sentence's dependency tree, require
logical inference for accurate identification. This work explores the
performance of fine-tuned LLMs and their integration into the Retrieval
Augmented-based (RAG) RE approach to address the challenges of identifying
implicit relations at the sentence level, particularly when LLMs act as
generators within the RAG framework. Empirical evaluations on the TACRED,
TACRED-Revisited (TACREV), Re-TACRED, and SemEVAL datasets show significant
performance improvements with fine-tuned LLMs, including Llama2-7B, Mistral-7B,
and T5 (Large). Notably, our approach achieves substantial gains on SemEVAL,
where implicit relations are common, surpassing previous results on this
dataset. Additionally, our method outperforms previous works on TACRED, TACREV,
and Re-TACRED, demonstrating exceptional performance across diverse evaluation
scenarios. | [
-0.4153825939,
-1.0681920052,
0.7264672518,
0.0205142759,
-0.2672357261,
0.0129583245,
-0.2679311037,
-0.6341534853,
-0.0593046211,
0.6601557136,
-0.4219642282,
-0.4802074134,
-0.5849565268,
0.3623486459,
-0.3533078134,
0.9598116279,
-0.1011070013,
-0.2230763435,
-0.3343122303,
-0.1381653547,
-0.425616771,
-0.4071678519,
-0.4313530326,
-0.3362655938,
0.5390006304,
0.3358077109,
0.4254752696,
0.6855102181,
0.4153886735,
0.271378696,
-0.1472837627,
0.6209062338,
-0.5996896625,
0.4097935259,
-0.4719682336,
-0.1334383637,
-0.3858439624,
-0.0335648656,
0.5938271284,
0.7723599076,
0.1731787473,
0.5092406273,
0.1099947691,
0.5828353763,
-0.9455652833,
0.3961470425,
-0.8350841999,
-0.1098960191,
-0.301812917,
-0.4310115576,
-0.5958462358,
-0.1617649794,
0.2472126782,
-0.7344756722,
0.2457219809,
0.2851622105,
1.0682457685,
0.2456092387,
-0.5363044143,
-0.2459396273,
-0.7940865159,
0.7386598587,
-0.5246266723,
0.6533370614,
0.3227149546,
0.005811471,
-0.5363159776,
-0.9124476314,
-0.316272229,
-0.3002051115,
-0.2072483152,
-0.0259631611,
-0.0573378094,
0.020560747,
0.4800657332,
0.446552217,
-0.1584780663,
0.0571009926,
-0.0635078326,
-0.0427048206,
0.4786633849,
0.0522852205,
0.2040531933,
-0.3452629447,
-0.3975488842,
0.1446064413,
-0.8242368698,
-0.1470461488,
0.0892313048,
0.4976527393,
0.198899731,
0.8165562749,
-0.2024463266,
0.6451829672,
0.2201345414,
-0.1232547015,
0.153425917,
-0.3340558708,
-0.214235127,
-0.1858455837,
0.74015522,
0.0477890633,
0.7916656137,
-0.3644305766,
-0.3546114564,
-0.1881660223,
-0.0507057682,
-0.8300362229,
-0.171912998,
-0.1704659611,
-0.4979373813,
-0.1444266438,
-0.0093649765,
-0.7463454008,
-0.3832006156,
-0.5037970543,
0.3011404276,
-0.4594676495,
-0.3804772198,
-0.1638524085,
0.0039338158,
0.3163536191,
0.2099674493,
-0.7285901904,
0.4464877844,
0.8421715498,
0.6201318502,
-0.2576701641,
-0.0552887134,
-0.9674108624,
0.3166677058,
-0.2077302933,
0.7486504912,
-0.790618062,
-0.2970072329,
0.0470265523,
0.0965871885,
-0.1411937028,
-0.6432796717,
0.5634495616,
-0.8309719563,
0.1697059572,
-0.2241758555,
-0.6561847925,
-0.030405568,
0.2931458354,
-0.7902982831,
1.0543059111,
0.233230114,
-0.8397616148,
0.2579675317,
-0.3740554154,
-0.5938734412,
-0.0823012069,
-0.1218929291,
-0.3659534752,
0.1897447705,
0.3953167796,
0.5562007427,
-0.6821382046,
0.2456256151,
-0.5008103251,
-0.2104838341,
-0.0322161317,
-0.1869935542,
0.6419069171,
0.3155231774,
0.019007666,
0.0323494561,
-0.9133028388,
-0.0678625703,
0.1032956839,
-0.2000075579,
-0.7020724416,
0.0424983017,
-0.1038700938,
0.1530219615,
0.2908357978,
-0.5002393723,
0.2079412192,
-0.6302877665,
0.2636773884,
0.6555922627,
0.4689567387,
0.4971565604,
0.13924703,
0.5170232654,
-0.0522901788,
-0.2193892747,
-0.1160455495,
-0.0511011407,
-0.5875147581,
-0.2896377146,
0.6803998351,
0.4506986737,
-0.940766573,
0.2374332249,
-0.436150074,
-0.1893178225,
-0.3350323737,
0.2701199949,
0.6096581221,
0.7803763747,
0.3230396807,
-0.0848113596,
-0.5664764047,
-0.8311948776,
-0.5221889019,
-0.1723563671,
0.0880843699,
0.4767378569,
0.3753103614,
-0.102790691,
1.0509228706,
-0.6541677713,
-0.1639810205,
-0.1307900697,
0.0889180824,
0.130887419,
0.3037940562,
0.4184510112,
-0.8335501552,
-0.4761661291,
0.1687813401,
-0.6164776683,
-0.39690274,
0.0656682998,
-0.1002641544,
0.236336574,
0.5727077723,
-0.6596572995,
0.3673405945,
0.2221995145,
-0.3829679787,
0.5807980299,
-0.0309252683,
0.0211246703,
-1.0467640162,
0.2122664601,
0.1941962987,
-0.549120903,
-0.3901412785,
0.0509402938,
-0.0060342941,
0.1070461571,
-0.3101413548,
0.6743022799,
-0.7921716571,
-0.3564782441,
-0.0528628528,
0.1227992624,
0.1044991463,
0.5033418536,
-0.0388481915,
0.8384364843,
0.2120103091,
-0.6290325522,
0.1689354181,
0.3550723493,
-0.0956210122,
0.2667011321,
-0.5548862815,
0.1334413886,
-0.0689387694,
-0.0606581792,
-0.6263943911,
-0.091384694,
0.1969811022,
-0.3063323796,
0.5643559098,
-0.4346802235,
-0.6394879818,
0.1492119879,
-0.2091894895,
0.3580939472,
0.2828504443,
-0.6523790359,
0.8543806076,
0.4375083745,
-0.2738017142,
-0.7205075026,
-0.1199459806,
-0.03469643,
-0.2324934751,
-0.4932224751,
0.2892352045,
0.3277950287,
-0.4073854089,
0.2606973052,
-0.2491352856,
-0.1077199951,
0.1944282502,
0.2121168077,
0.3244456649,
-0.2030259669,
0.167360127,
-0.0044838972,
-0.0998738706,
0.0953838304,
0.137166813,
0.5004950762,
-0.0519011319,
-0.0457485989,
-0.0706012323,
0.2405378073,
0.5715535283,
-0.5265190005,
0.7692633271,
0.5673891902,
-0.3813974559,
-0.1557191312,
-0.6221669316,
-0.1061650813,
-0.3966154158,
0.4891715944,
-0.723195076,
-0.9985179305,
0.5799572468,
-0.5130699873,
-0.0632300749,
0.5822201967,
0.2929596007,
0.0651091486,
0.9238775969,
0.6506276727,
-0.1278421581,
0.5649609566,
-0.1127270311,
-0.0698936582,
-1.120775342,
-0.1806095093,
-0.5631583929,
0.0783976987,
-0.721627295,
0.0171622969,
0.1857485622,
0.3348081112,
-0.3509796858,
0.1768583655,
-0.060060136,
0.3710606098,
0.2991867065,
-0.0387625024,
0.4718270302,
0.1992075443,
-0.0327550992,
-0.0565450191,
-0.4906104207,
-0.3776992559,
1.0559133291,
0.2791089714,
0.5974063873,
0.1289571524,
0.646504879,
0.1693317443,
0.4113551378,
-0.714969039,
0.5905653834,
-0.3344777822,
-0.269231379,
-0.1112840325,
-0.7274188995,
-1.2200403214,
0.1354573816,
-0.500959754,
-0.7293035388,
0.2362677306,
0.0012129114,
-0.1367096156,
0.029359743,
-0.8934355378,
0.6467597485,
-0.0233136192,
-0.6700391173,
0.0372704342,
-0.5486680269,
0.460336417,
-0.2395331115,
-0.0476416573,
-0.1015456691,
0.0517235138,
0.5775961876,
-0.3191085458,
0.4006285965,
-0.1924931854,
-0.0720667094,
0.1533171237,
0.1993030161,
0.7370723486,
0.0374244601,
-0.1633632183,
-0.0827644393,
0.1331793815,
-0.0885007754,
-0.7836377621,
0.861433804,
-0.6099899411,
-0.6185442209,
-0.2642768919,
-0.65384835,
-0.537756443,
0.4750705957,
-0.1034090146,
0.4607212842,
-0.1292586178,
0.3265172243,
0.6306542158,
-0.2784488499,
0.2907339036,
0.5184199214,
-0.4461826682,
-0.4773785472,
0.7231860757,
0.098492831,
0.1666626334,
0.3805609643,
-0.02093881,
-0.4369218051,
-0.4355241954,
-0.148676455,
0.4303002656,
-0.3629002869,
-0.4198580682,
-0.5994212031,
-0.2125543654,
-0.5655114055,
0.3984709084,
-0.2826064229,
-0.4279149771,
-0.4398814142,
-0.0113993501,
0.4081668258,
0.6984833479,
0.1920198798,
-0.0270894375,
-0.8265534043,
0.6115190983,
0.0489192083,
0.281085819,
-0.150123924,
-0.4247425199,
-0.0822336823,
-0.3104425073,
-0.0194848217,
-0.9344604611,
0.5021502376,
0.2823309898,
0.405300647,
0.1579184681,
0.0868917033,
1.0120112896,
-0.5865085125,
0.3757042289,
-0.2144478261,
-0.6559755802,
0.3867384791,
-0.3570298553,
-0.0561218746,
0.5530397892,
0.1408011019,
-0.0988700166,
-0.0267698746,
-0.7544648647,
-0.9649316669,
0.634852767,
0.2640134692,
-0.2296936065,
-0.0134422621,
0.9014884233,
-0.1226821095,
0.2973898947,
-0.4783411324,
-0.2616312504,
0.3780062795,
-0.2583791316,
0.0224660076,
-0.5230615735,
0.1151068062,
-0.1853117496,
0.6719895601,
0.0971212909,
0.0022917271,
0.3158181608,
-0.3678689301,
-0.1109927893,
0.2703554332,
0.2292173952,
0.6565986872,
-0.3366529644,
0.2063183933,
0.1880585998,
-0.2906936705,
-0.0982197896,
0.4653491378,
-0.1742131263,
-0.0879997611,
0.4954356253,
0.5539640784,
0.1335773468,
-0.5352934003,
0.424192965,
0.0057506184,
0.0680906326,
-0.3210318387,
-0.0252890047,
-0.1038422659,
0.3582210541,
0.2836710811,
-0.0947828367,
0.1674656123,
-0.4776974618,
0.3664046526,
0.6367267966,
-0.201468423,
-0.2736650109,
0.4891184568,
0.1454935372,
-0.2367581725,
0.6075194478,
-0.1703175753,
-0.3605322242,
0.3232808411,
0.6705737114,
0.8306224346,
0.027959859,
-0.1036590785,
0.359731853,
0.1887801588,
-0.0609175898,
0.0941366181,
-0.1617309451,
-0.8125142455,
-0.9741466045,
-0.661280632,
-0.0410704389,
0.2901008725,
-0.9366385341,
0.2102092206,
-0.3083446026,
-0.0249983855,
-0.0945607126,
0.3770960569,
-0.6889059544,
0.0732604638,
-0.0454172157,
0.8937528133,
-0.7536893487,
0.8252453208,
0.6707142591,
-0.3859713376,
-1.0790954828,
-0.0545246601,
-0.3326509893,
-0.5679686666,
0.7896522284,
-0.0882508755,
-0.2426208258,
0.2797074914,
-0.4898654819,
-0.8336154819,
1.0398015976,
0.7912945151,
-0.5935593247,
-0.0235110614,
-0.0334592946,
0.584984839,
-0.5158861876,
0.1653091311,
0.8464345932,
0.3237425387,
0.0395285673,
-0.7784329653,
0.16891931,
-0.211073488,
0.0813960135,
0.4844434857,
-0.3454272449,
0.5186523795,
-0.0069879973,
-0.3850672543,
0.1665959507,
0.8744004965,
0.5167173147,
0.3057019114,
0.5879793167,
0.6013281941,
0.648450017,
0.0326482542,
1.0082224607,
-0.2763497233,
0.3758964241,
1.3830316067,
-0.4250742495,
0.9065335393,
0.6889095902,
0.0556651577,
0.5515383482,
0.4305838048,
0.1917904764,
0.3787729442,
-0.1669787169,
-0.1383040398,
-0.3799020946,
-0.370806843,
-0.2496204078,
0.3387196362,
0.4494678974,
-0.5061173439,
-0.2321449816,
-0.243829757,
0.0075084632,
0.1752992421,
-0.3210292459,
0.9133928418,
0.1196169481,
-0.6844226122,
0.3859229684,
-0.1752068102,
0.2789885104,
-0.3458783925,
-0.4260822833,
-0.0785142258,
0.0694192648,
-0.199798584,
-0.6300088167,
-0.0004182805,
0.1480972767,
-0.3236869872,
-0.1089162678,
1.2040441036,
-0.5108887553,
-0.3880390525,
0.3099669516,
0.7457114458,
-0.048253376,
-0.014024538,
-0.527190268,
-0.0082204305,
0.0781436712,
-0.5099768639,
0.2963018417,
0.8038706183,
-0.2029652148,
0.5542684197,
0.7672764659,
0.3642994463,
-0.1728746891,
0.1445342451,
0.9284219742,
-0.6769939065,
0.0083051082,
-0.8628309965,
0.3001299798,
-0.1967903674,
-0.1823321432,
0.8313675523,
0.5681096315,
0.5134447217,
0.0529693551,
0.4505252242,
0.0448879115,
0.8310676217,
-0.6482806802,
0.3080461621,
-0.4270427823,
0.4821614325,
-0.4295535684,
-1.2159686089,
-0.294454366,
0.4067988396,
-0.4863804579,
0.0283669941,
0.5962033868,
0.7663711905,
-0.1254943013,
-0.264266938,
0.0777076483,
0.4192369878,
0.4441802502,
0.4237777889,
0.8725340366,
-0.3646637797,
0.5376520157,
-0.0397795141,
-0.0140324943,
0.1123898476,
-0.9424387813,
-0.758959949,
-0.492213577,
-0.2107069343,
-0.3623955548,
0.0620998554,
0.9021803141,
0.362714529,
-0.6222899556,
0.1615162641,
-0.1106960475,
0.1455375254,
0.0955160558,
-0.280061096,
0.5867294073,
-0.313593924,
-0.7066274285,
0.3594558537,
0.2073900402,
-0.1717897654,
-0.0331606343,
-0.0214177631,
-0.4038594663,
-0.2588652968,
0.7508608699,
0.3981066644,
-0.5328449607,
-0.5139989257,
-0.0817566365,
0.0674594864,
-0.1983359754,
0.6542794704,
-0.961833179,
0.336466521,
0.483708322,
0.8427344561,
0.62849617,
0.4260879755,
0.7285354733,
-1.0005420446,
0.0397167727,
0.1222810894,
0.4055666625,
0.2629215121,
-0.276886493,
0.7912899256,
0.1381043047,
-0.65026021,
-0.9790763855,
0.2412492186,
-0.9774441719,
-0.1439100206,
1.515073657,
-0.1386655569,
-0.2839184105,
-0.2601403296,
-0.1947128326,
0.4113226533,
-0.2973797917,
0.4302609563,
0.4748239815,
-0.2056086063,
-0.2187433988,
-0.4831543863,
0.4587868154,
0.4003596008,
-0.6781551838,
0.151769504,
0.6891014576,
0.3979883492,
0.1485800445,
0.3833865225,
-0.1856492013,
-0.0111446958,
-0.5330582857,
-0.1022297144,
-0.3234914243,
-0.307942152,
-0.1558876038,
0.3177382946,
0.2062403858,
-0.0895879641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14739v1 | Learning to Retrieve Iteratively for In-Context Learning | 2024-06-20T21:07:55 | 2024-06-20T21:07:55 | Yunmo Chen, Tongfei Chen, Harsh Jhamtani, Patrick Xia, Richard Shin, Jason Eisner, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce iterative retrieval, a novel framework that empowers retrievers
to make iterative decisions through policy optimization. Finding an optimal
portfolio of retrieved items is a combinatorial optimization problem, generally
considered NP-hard. This approach provides a learned approximation to such a
solution, meeting specific task requirements under a given family of large
language models (LLMs). We propose a training procedure based on reinforcement
learning, incorporating feedback from LLMs. We instantiate an iterative
retriever for composing in-context learning (ICL) exemplars and apply it to
various semantic parsing tasks that demand synthesized programs as outputs. By
adding only 4M additional parameters for state encoding, we convert an
off-the-shelf dense retriever into a stateful iterative retriever,
outperforming previous methods in selecting ICL exemplars on semantic parsing
datasets such as CalFlow, TreeDST, and MTOP. Additionally, the trained
iterative retriever generalizes across different inference LLMs beyond the one
used during training. | [
-0.0755194277,
-0.3705627322,
0.5985168815,
0.3413606882,
-0.1538895667,
0.1710382104,
-0.5041173697,
0.0947569907,
-0.0881901607,
0.4084868729,
-0.6025852561,
-0.349008888,
-0.488471508,
0.004743577,
-0.4565256238,
0.9960143566,
-0.1037834808,
-0.0172876604,
-0.1249284148,
0.0244956855,
-0.3599309623,
-0.3121271729,
-0.6288731694,
-0.5410301089,
0.1811766326,
0.5064117908,
-0.0060259104,
0.4492433071,
0.0067637758,
0.3648079038,
-0.0806060284,
-0.0028821281,
-0.9051698446,
0.1097692698,
-0.5298915505,
-0.2636337876,
0.6017636657,
-0.0797594637,
0.7918820381,
0.7250294089,
-0.5044658184,
-0.065348424,
0.1009573713,
0.5216872096,
-0.9004054666,
0.1788906902,
-0.9168989658,
0.2730540037,
-0.0620168746,
-0.6788254976,
-0.7834839225,
-0.2422420532,
0.4759182036,
-0.7486398816,
-0.1273276359,
0.2268480062,
0.757891953,
0.194386363,
-0.4769309759,
-0.5693920851,
-0.5704194307,
1.1158126593,
-0.3810402751,
0.3081403971,
0.4777191579,
0.4074394405,
-0.412389189,
-0.8693793416,
-0.2559953034,
-0.46937114,
0.0773514211,
0.0609906949,
0.0074220081,
-0.0089630038,
0.1267417669,
0.3885077238,
-0.2362724841,
-0.0857719854,
-0.2143731862,
-0.0737053528,
0.3936657012,
0.117712982,
-0.0910952911,
-0.1046214327,
-0.5841565132,
-0.3778797984,
-0.7501024008,
0.3626063168,
0.0363243073,
0.3134275675,
0.439445734,
0.4063765407,
-0.4109711349,
0.711173892,
0.0452239849,
-0.3192629814,
0.1749588549,
-0.2025359571,
0.0238540322,
0.1580767184,
0.3326971531,
-0.1731313914,
-0.2237918526,
-0.4895275235,
-0.4274035096,
-0.3004852533,
0.4023874402,
-0.6010109782,
-0.0561587512,
0.0271767937,
-0.233605206,
0.0008026675,
0.0281086639,
-0.5006770492,
0.0093301116,
-0.4638457596,
0.6518442035,
-0.5544146299,
0.0900607333,
0.1816614419,
-0.3516798615,
0.432918936,
0.1365735978,
-0.828774631,
0.4722889066,
0.6678478718,
0.5368279219,
-0.2423869222,
-0.3682090342,
-1.0624996424,
0.3225855529,
-0.4476997852,
0.6359502077,
-0.7523669004,
-0.4677041769,
0.0936552733,
0.0120576741,
-0.2147437483,
-0.675313592,
0.3804231286,
-0.7055743933,
-0.0140657518,
-0.5094131827,
-0.7247739434,
-0.1827344745,
0.4616259336,
-0.5692498684,
0.9760082364,
0.2878289223,
-0.3587706089,
0.6727076769,
-0.4631075561,
-0.295539856,
-0.0516202822,
-0.3286798,
-0.1952919513,
0.2211542577,
0.1028525606,
0.1376211494,
-0.259993732,
0.4777419865,
-0.3028745353,
-0.4272936881,
-0.112233527,
-0.1469803452,
0.807192266,
0.2176215798,
-0.3906305432,
0.2874940932,
-0.7837147117,
0.0934774503,
0.0311076008,
-0.8951355815,
-0.3221577406,
0.389927119,
-0.204425171,
0.3133814037,
0.0753867179,
-0.7108716369,
0.1751454026,
-0.5106922388,
0.4968578815,
0.8250089884,
0.0703283474,
0.7096511722,
0.024215987,
0.2349681556,
-0.0857859105,
-0.1239528358,
-0.1748582572,
0.3080709577,
-0.5511648059,
-0.3337180018,
0.0148164108,
0.270334512,
-1.0619943142,
0.1800757647,
-0.2419551015,
0.0086314017,
-0.2700690627,
0.2238455266,
0.5257978439,
0.7770849466,
0.278065145,
-0.0516112857,
-0.3750041425,
-0.6074151993,
-0.2691341937,
0.2124307901,
0.0517533198,
0.2725504637,
0.6683875918,
-0.0242998675,
1.007524848,
-0.1361323893,
-0.3711136281,
-0.2925972641,
0.0723101646,
0.1379707158,
0.4166535139,
0.1069475114,
-0.632065475,
-0.3635239899,
0.0473614484,
-0.5853309631,
0.2027291954,
-0.0083709806,
0.0015113364,
0.0484961383,
0.6623749137,
-0.0580023043,
0.232532531,
0.0711897686,
-0.161440596,
0.1528379172,
-0.2701110244,
-0.3271455169,
-0.8184213638,
0.1553489566,
-0.1277779639,
-0.2947302163,
-0.1044327095,
0.3214292824,
0.1726084948,
-0.0979686007,
-0.3246872425,
0.7767406702,
-0.4962176383,
-0.4752261043,
-0.1161780581,
0.0708625242,
0.0806212947,
0.6478024721,
0.1961581558,
0.8613237143,
0.3611073494,
-0.7097117305,
-0.0390267111,
0.3334618807,
-0.4677202106,
0.6161480546,
-0.3670575023,
-0.0679337382,
-0.4073312283,
0.4666729271,
-0.7203480005,
-0.1164121777,
-0.0480263345,
0.2358333319,
0.3036872149,
-0.0047278372,
-0.3764804304,
-0.31573385,
-0.4138866663,
0.2082373798,
0.0431336947,
-1.1619644165,
0.6112048626,
0.3187211156,
0.2331545353,
-0.8358137012,
-0.1002972573,
-0.0622301102,
-0.2038793415,
-0.1671478599,
0.5891946554,
-0.0666234642,
-0.1724682748,
-0.0209342036,
-0.2694150209,
-0.0134765059,
0.2872262597,
-0.2098161131,
-0.0880568773,
0.1149876565,
0.0210939329,
0.1170682833,
-0.3189761937,
-0.0751361921,
-0.6138473153,
0.4584543407,
-0.4181473851,
-0.3881155849,
-0.0404127873,
0.5744085908,
-0.2184893489,
-0.214305073,
0.2654138803,
0.3211669028,
-0.240842253,
-0.4933387041,
-0.2634343803,
-0.3147535622,
-0.5106066465,
0.3973073363,
-0.5884179473,
-1.0554279089,
0.2305546403,
-0.4467139244,
0.1788875461,
0.1520898342,
0.4213166833,
0.0494336411,
1.2797321081,
0.7382511497,
-0.1472888291,
0.6327754259,
-0.505450666,
0.1699943095,
-0.7993268967,
-0.500849247,
-0.4806817174,
-0.1266715527,
-0.3785248101,
-0.0191020165,
0.5346851945,
0.23070997,
-0.4856856763,
0.3111330867,
-0.3979533017,
0.7275907397,
0.8623310328,
0.2147548348,
0.3737281859,
0.1209629849,
-0.4604116976,
0.036676012,
-0.7927654386,
-0.1066591293,
0.8449383378,
-0.0418191776,
0.7125103474,
0.0519651361,
0.8798196316,
0.0022808167,
0.1979386657,
-0.9575002789,
0.3722420335,
-0.1141403094,
-0.211248368,
-0.116927512,
-0.3178355694,
-0.9394635558,
0.3490889668,
0.1875777841,
-1.2069481611,
0.2881232202,
0.1526825577,
-0.19138062,
-0.064998433,
-0.152981177,
0.7874113917,
-0.2151884586,
-0.5246371627,
-0.4446887672,
-0.8357328176,
0.1950803995,
0.2691983283,
-0.2518737614,
0.0247452985,
-0.0540646389,
0.3293326795,
-0.5380166769,
0.5145147443,
-0.3127007186,
0.0093698381,
0.2063601613,
0.2092840225,
0.5942156315,
0.0756402761,
-0.3513757885,
-0.3769997656,
0.1910949498,
-0.4834883213,
-0.4195925593,
0.707990706,
-0.6335735917,
-0.5320926905,
-0.4571879804,
-0.5603009462,
-0.3029127419,
0.1627563536,
0.3296798468,
0.6264016628,
-0.1957434267,
0.465449959,
0.7677850723,
-0.1370120198,
0.7602124214,
0.5722261667,
-0.0535859913,
-0.2293234318,
1.3302577734,
-0.0613618158,
-0.0077153002,
0.6940039992,
0.369589597,
-0.4987533987,
-0.4785036445,
-0.4735312462,
-0.1120669916,
-1.0735728741,
-0.1588341296,
-0.4854458869,
-0.1043293104,
0.2413262874,
-0.2979683578,
-0.387830615,
-0.0548798926,
-0.3976276219,
0.0055183144,
0.0653325617,
0.4593068063,
-0.0677644685,
0.3622073233,
-0.362054795,
0.0120773483,
0.2045795023,
0.3025515974,
-0.1035175025,
-0.3462348282,
-0.0706823394,
-0.3773637116,
-0.3203742504,
-0.4832015038,
0.5245558023,
0.5021142364,
0.5833485723,
0.364833504,
-0.0012753998,
0.8692017794,
-0.5944048166,
0.6022398472,
-0.2242964357,
-0.9051883221,
0.5252264142,
-0.1638924479,
0.2304109633,
1.0271934271,
0.4645524323,
-0.3109577298,
0.0489312522,
-0.3952088654,
-1.1488567591,
0.8149136901,
-0.2825073898,
0.1137768924,
-0.4996345639,
0.3786189556,
0.2407331169,
0.5007271171,
-0.5809992552,
0.2272416949,
-0.0822182223,
-0.1654102206,
0.1811298579,
-0.222682938,
-0.3867579103,
-0.2947900891,
0.8200689554,
-0.6286011934,
0.2366540432,
0.1005325019,
-0.5286024809,
0.1095756888,
0.1355002075,
0.2590322793,
0.7970070839,
-0.1297895759,
0.0655586123,
-0.0337940268,
0.2805023491,
0.1703799665,
0.1140807867,
-0.1961551458,
-0.1935614496,
-0.0539433621,
0.9429389834,
0.7964618206,
-1.1461259127,
0.703098774,
0.0031759085,
-0.139431417,
-0.5752695799,
0.0251816511,
-0.2865003943,
0.4473967552,
0.4897717237,
-0.3242743909,
0.5498206615,
-0.5022219419,
0.4750970006,
0.7126538754,
-0.285985738,
-0.0488477908,
0.5251401663,
-0.1519312114,
-0.0726369694,
0.7820822597,
-0.4521042705,
-0.3321070969,
0.3469313979,
0.975502789,
0.750524044,
0.2685374618,
0.3757902384,
0.4779235125,
-0.1758261621,
-0.5104774237,
0.4196363688,
-0.6126793027,
-0.4739308655,
-0.4540092051,
-0.7578800917,
-0.4800929725,
-0.0775404051,
-0.7664095163,
-0.0023569423,
-0.6124696136,
0.3769258559,
-0.5255803466,
0.0934534669,
-0.6351595521,
-0.1168033853,
-0.1135562956,
0.9754846692,
-0.326792866,
0.8259634972,
0.2833527625,
-0.4446670413,
-0.8519502878,
-0.0144501654,
0.2280406356,
-0.8837916851,
0.7310848832,
0.1870751232,
-0.0873371959,
0.3250549436,
-0.6285746098,
-1.220733285,
1.1076363325,
0.474557966,
-0.4220626652,
-0.1419326216,
-0.3694997132,
0.2326551378,
-0.4002486467,
0.215588659,
0.7395172119,
0.1490030289,
0.2888261974,
-0.5272147059,
-0.1124505326,
-0.1290322542,
0.5168235898,
0.0774996728,
-0.5231900215,
0.7255086303,
-0.0295467339,
-0.0889126956,
0.1767996252,
0.6212586761,
0.6036669016,
0.1851358861,
0.3638234138,
0.6587885618,
0.8032556772,
0.0916489288,
1.4265397787,
-0.1198628247,
0.3492594957,
1.4270619154,
-0.287763685,
1.0251766443,
0.7975042462,
0.1911424696,
0.5892939568,
0.7802990079,
0.3436532915,
1.0250262022,
0.3717529476,
-0.5091856718,
-0.0726843551,
-0.3513898253,
0.2266252786,
0.4848417938,
0.5362051725,
-0.2996634245,
-0.7544415593,
0.428157866,
0.0093263332,
0.172730118,
-0.3457488418,
1.1424365044,
0.01365624,
-0.9795582891,
0.4775457084,
0.0040730238,
0.4107295871,
-0.6619369984,
-0.1738470793,
-0.0746367276,
0.3864576817,
0.0884789154,
-0.5232434273,
0.2055164129,
-0.4436558783,
-0.0244968608,
-0.3989591897,
0.5814992189,
-0.6054636836,
-0.1031579971,
0.50089854,
0.2272327989,
-0.0937210768,
0.0059985467,
-0.7010461688,
0.0941516161,
-0.111769706,
-0.54252702,
0.5244296789,
0.1774852425,
-0.3222288191,
0.7601908445,
0.3001270592,
-0.1882882714,
0.2379975021,
-0.0322379619,
1.0398101807,
-0.4754099846,
-0.6354975104,
-0.5854769945,
0.3606517315,
-0.1543918401,
-0.2194530368,
0.3400300741,
0.365046382,
1.4054108858,
0.1799457222,
0.6216605306,
-0.1833114624,
0.2939376831,
-0.6166037321,
-0.0853045583,
-0.6383426189,
0.3926276267,
0.1532540619,
-0.9293435216,
0.1006712019,
0.8072146773,
-0.4553923607,
-0.1954189539,
0.7092525959,
0.7137456536,
-0.0860133916,
0.002516598,
0.0288239364,
-0.1135993451,
0.4245411456,
0.6105620861,
0.7133193016,
-0.1921871603,
0.3378327489,
-0.5198563337,
-0.0589375421,
-0.2147189826,
-1.0083782673,
-0.4727306962,
-0.7063413262,
0.1209906563,
-0.3604175448,
0.1663815975,
1.3318217993,
0.527802825,
-0.6187843084,
-0.4299986959,
-0.3399687707,
0.1077928841,
-0.3830354214,
-0.3056361675,
0.2035624236,
-0.9264935255,
-0.7679960132,
0.9403218031,
0.4205798209,
-0.6740182638,
-0.1260131299,
-0.2428850383,
-0.318234086,
-0.2732259929,
0.7743552923,
0.7056586146,
-0.6907756925,
-0.3228664994,
-0.0799308717,
0.0008408051,
0.1843988895,
1.0544756651,
-1.0841252804,
0.7761185169,
0.4561835229,
1.2861411572,
0.9704021215,
-0.2188187689,
0.6036276817,
-1.0024652481,
0.1699898094,
0.4068645537,
0.3885033727,
0.1685349494,
-0.1273756921,
0.505420208,
-0.0281657968,
-0.4311498702,
-0.7070134282,
0.1734462231,
-0.6899092793,
-0.4594728649,
1.0068888664,
-0.1649972349,
-0.4862790108,
0.0350128189,
-0.0794302449,
-0.1713626981,
-0.5228099227,
0.7935401797,
0.3152776957,
-0.1999299228,
-0.1597930938,
-0.4553148448,
0.6259649396,
0.5940838456,
-0.6868398786,
-0.2199929953,
0.5169123411,
0.4265505075,
-0.1683174968,
0.9252517819,
-0.1731149703,
0.1958264858,
-0.2326450348,
-0.3695771992,
0.2382377088,
-0.6086348295,
-0.4104833901,
0.2810952365,
0.1084806845,
0.0496737845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14737v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14737v1 | Dissecting the Ullman Variations with a SCALPEL: Why do LLMs fail at Trivial Alterations to the False Belief Task? | 2024-06-20T21:02:30 | 2024-06-20T21:02:30 | Zhiqiang Pi, Annapurna Vadaparty, Benjamin K. Bergen, Cameron R. Jones | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent empirical results have sparked a debate about whether or not Large
Language Models (LLMs) are capable of Theory of Mind (ToM). While some have
found LLMs to be successful on ToM evaluations such as the False Belief task
(Kosinski, 2023), others have argued that LLMs solve these tasks by exploiting
spurious correlations -- not representing beliefs -- since they fail on trivial
alterations to these tasks (Ullman, 2023). In this paper, we introduce SCALPEL:
a technique to generate targeted modifications for False Belief tasks to test
different specific hypotheses about why LLMs fail. We find that modifications
which make explicit common inferences -- such as that looking at a transparent
object implies recognizing its contents -- preserve LLMs' performance. This
suggests that LLMs' failures on modified ToM tasks could result from a lack of
more general commonsense reasoning, rather than a failure to represent mental
states. We argue that SCALPEL could be helpful for explaining LLM successes and
failures in other cases. | [
-0.5237378478,
-0.724345088,
1.0636142492,
-0.0354739949,
-0.0669045374,
0.0199073181,
-0.2703857422,
-0.1506845355,
0.3142354488,
0.3061075807,
-0.6121825576,
-0.2387031019,
-0.6427532434,
-0.0360729732,
-0.5671992302,
0.9539136887,
-0.1117615849,
-0.1444717646,
0.0614192896,
-0.0152278366,
-0.2266090363,
-0.3963777125,
-0.5329829454,
-0.6256199479,
0.7982575297,
0.4495108426,
0.7352336645,
0.4288296402,
0.638482213,
0.2597763836,
-0.1803130805,
0.379209578,
-0.3520745635,
0.0244888831,
-0.6151909828,
-0.8689803481,
-0.3213909268,
0.267572999,
0.6953206062,
1.0138198137,
0.0057757366,
-0.1306500733,
0.3570241332,
0.6286850572,
-0.5757381916,
-0.3080841303,
-1.0427256823,
0.1105188727,
-0.2098904997,
-0.1049996018,
-0.4152330458,
0.1628774405,
-0.0132610016,
-0.2396019846,
0.4851659238,
0.1351200342,
0.6803411245,
0.1931070685,
-0.4657049477,
-0.28731668,
-0.9382889867,
1.0320203304,
-0.7842425108,
0.229703933,
0.3790103495,
0.1484147757,
-0.4201484919,
-0.4218146205,
-0.6628690958,
-0.1904349476,
-0.0997004211,
-0.1605048925,
-0.3999359608,
0.1989356428,
0.4297828078,
0.3070108891,
-0.3652007878,
-0.0070721153,
-0.0169172585,
0.0753941983,
0.2972591817,
0.2502509356,
-0.0977981538,
-0.2529099882,
-0.0868341252,
-0.4966411591,
-0.593994379,
-0.1479656547,
0.2059120685,
0.1416288465,
0.104565613,
0.559902668,
0.0800229907,
0.521853447,
0.5018949509,
-0.2515855134,
-0.0499171279,
0.3313696682,
-0.4854978323,
-0.2299877256,
0.4500637949,
0.3789106309,
0.0221606269,
-0.0957334787,
-0.1886028051,
0.3082426786,
0.4722737372,
-0.355312109,
-0.2768483162,
0.375267446,
-0.5557081103,
-0.3775746524,
-0.0083778659,
-0.5340474844,
-0.5257003307,
-0.2192524076,
0.4185808003,
-0.5131525397,
-0.1938299686,
0.1365343034,
-0.2602991462,
0.1996505111,
0.5004793406,
-0.6020867229,
0.1901153922,
0.7581807375,
0.7258805633,
-0.2515725195,
-0.5221661329,
-0.1233629286,
0.1526533216,
-0.8501775861,
1.0603262186,
-0.4620369971,
-0.5186859369,
-0.0908646882,
-0.127363354,
-0.2528653145,
-0.6126610041,
0.5239990354,
-0.1076335609,
-0.0178366546,
-0.7553324103,
-0.6707865,
-0.2935670614,
0.2286657244,
-0.152283445,
0.6319137216,
-0.0285890624,
-0.9171741605,
0.0638277158,
-0.6176980734,
-0.4520378411,
-0.3037452996,
-0.5088512301,
-0.1369604915,
0.745555222,
-0.0997919813,
0.5108382702,
-0.0587646551,
0.2006643414,
-0.7031207085,
-0.546041131,
0.7427156568,
-0.5066798925,
0.697698772,
0.212049678,
-0.5715236664,
-0.0267678052,
-0.6248050332,
-0.0891427621,
0.2452100217,
0.0483783744,
-0.4167138636,
0.2739012837,
-0.1648135483,
-0.1901834011,
0.0302795265,
-0.5138539076,
0.315115571,
-0.4382332563,
0.0795987099,
1.1613094807,
-0.0996005237,
0.2578907311,
-0.5612243414,
0.1891722232,
0.163520053,
-0.0347210057,
0.0461840294,
-0.466090709,
-1.3748143911,
0.0382656716,
-0.0213144496,
0.3364485204,
-0.5930620432,
0.1249781698,
-0.0178502668,
-0.4592059553,
-0.1617617607,
0.1019510478,
0.5914937258,
0.4378089309,
0.1337821782,
-0.1296688914,
-0.5956656933,
-1.2289887667,
-0.5955941081,
-0.1542883813,
-0.1487815231,
0.2298856229,
0.5776786208,
-0.4546868503,
0.6724586487,
-0.6103994846,
-0.4633846581,
-0.1965819597,
0.3903799653,
0.5863448381,
0.4766983092,
0.5679984689,
-0.404889971,
-0.2224486768,
0.1179880351,
-0.7690376639,
0.2437941134,
-0.1765510738,
0.1105805561,
0.2176432014,
0.4222019911,
-0.7982645035,
0.6189501286,
0.3966154754,
-0.264798671,
0.7516703606,
-0.4124100208,
0.1237315387,
-0.8300806284,
-0.06894999,
0.0066432091,
-0.0717586502,
-0.6202995777,
0.1583553106,
0.1478726715,
0.3431600034,
-0.2946995199,
0.2134162784,
-0.2800094485,
-0.1343848854,
-0.7223419547,
-0.1537120342,
-0.2620073259,
0.5662014484,
-0.2232808769,
0.6206288934,
0.3488139212,
-0.6734267473,
0.1577754319,
0.1249605268,
-0.0904200822,
0.9323641658,
-0.6159152389,
0.5532708764,
-0.3525475562,
0.1147400439,
-1.0733976364,
-0.5444100499,
0.2853173912,
-0.3168054521,
0.2985108495,
-0.1652853489,
-0.2728915811,
-0.484765172,
-0.3414911032,
0.0016351151,
0.5681877732,
-0.6175345778,
0.5689279437,
0.1695481837,
0.2233905494,
-0.552788198,
-0.8554967642,
0.2655425072,
-0.3752290606,
-0.2759607732,
0.3461483717,
-0.3667219281,
-0.7567074895,
0.008477048,
-0.3029188216,
0.0189492907,
0.1447049379,
0.3258275092,
0.1426752806,
-0.1211133003,
-0.033724837,
0.1278920919,
0.0030787792,
0.213800475,
-0.1960097998,
0.3072618246,
-0.2660425603,
-0.8245877624,
-0.4318759441,
0.320764184,
0.3922198713,
0.3644257784,
0.4080582559,
0.3863245547,
-0.3936702311,
-0.4676804543,
-0.7525832057,
-0.2943160832,
-0.5369203687,
0.3697129786,
-0.6048117876,
-0.8006929755,
0.2236082107,
-0.1502019316,
0.076705128,
0.3259575665,
0.4503988922,
-0.7154752612,
0.9134913683,
0.6808418632,
0.1457980424,
0.1265932918,
-0.223591432,
0.2514702976,
-1.0245509148,
0.2208958566,
-0.4216161668,
-0.4543382525,
-0.4760567248,
-0.6291003823,
0.638141036,
-0.0018434663,
-0.0554410927,
0.2039542496,
-0.3527364433,
0.6917673349,
0.5508528948,
0.0901858211,
0.1530212462,
0.1733915061,
-0.2393904924,
-0.1140788868,
-0.5647346377,
-0.5794835091,
1.3851259947,
0.4088566601,
0.9032337666,
0.0928494334,
0.6236671209,
0.3975223303,
0.2733800411,
-0.5264781117,
0.6661537886,
-0.2465030998,
-0.5914399624,
-0.1093087792,
-0.0619273297,
-0.874928236,
0.5455597043,
0.034538541,
-0.8765022755,
0.3406241834,
0.5285009742,
-0.2906527817,
0.5375922918,
-0.3327950239,
0.4632378817,
-0.1824685931,
-0.1674623936,
-0.4948926568,
-0.2803488076,
0.437152952,
-0.1561248302,
0.3827819228,
0.0633438602,
0.2048418969,
0.9588997364,
0.003262036,
1.0828570127,
-0.0164661631,
-0.2281733155,
0.1426716149,
0.5665473938,
0.6843543053,
-0.0187214818,
0.1781817526,
0.113297157,
-0.0350180268,
-0.347825855,
-0.8672897816,
0.797924459,
-0.6627021432,
-1.0038987398,
-0.5667714477,
-0.8354610205,
-0.6725521088,
0.0965578407,
0.149814561,
0.2387707382,
-0.0438192114,
0.189002037,
0.8674036264,
-0.0860752389,
0.3832251132,
0.4639912844,
-0.4404520988,
-0.3197650909,
0.5423293114,
0.0680837184,
0.1363950521,
0.0272997487,
0.1106393561,
0.0710095763,
-0.7264549732,
0.0205051061,
0.3864251673,
-0.9740232825,
0.0523319952,
-0.4877308607,
-0.0407724567,
-0.2521009445,
-0.2778433561,
-0.5955319405,
-0.2824269533,
-0.1379707158,
-0.1218936592,
0.0385742486,
1.2005454302,
-0.6082357764,
0.2362458855,
-0.3476157486,
0.2485623509,
0.4017546177,
0.2355906963,
0.2252618521,
-0.7275778651,
-0.3138147891,
0.3410714567,
-0.5051011443,
-0.9590232372,
0.1762864739,
-0.2001672685,
0.4875929654,
0.6544283032,
-0.0248330068,
0.9431326985,
-0.569345057,
0.4711891413,
0.206901893,
-0.9394540191,
0.538246274,
-0.6312127709,
0.0156590585,
0.1051013693,
0.3481920063,
-0.4879494309,
-0.5101791024,
-0.6525374651,
-0.3025494218,
0.4922944903,
0.0408387892,
0.1376505643,
-0.1563681811,
0.3839465976,
0.1550575346,
0.101857461,
-0.5282577276,
-0.433847338,
0.090119794,
-0.0692084432,
-0.3999607861,
-0.5828016996,
-0.5040503144,
-0.3493746817,
0.5712422729,
-0.2055643499,
0.5618978739,
0.5581601858,
-0.0196664855,
-0.4494265914,
0.3045888245,
0.8091747761,
0.9099036455,
-0.4543912411,
0.5099737644,
0.1990397871,
-0.0712228343,
0.0928066149,
-0.2576141953,
-0.1292853951,
0.0679552853,
0.4382853508,
0.8466833234,
0.3328849077,
-0.4792226553,
0.3256734908,
0.1480521858,
-0.5174747705,
-0.4561728239,
0.0603147484,
0.0384568907,
0.5019454956,
0.575024128,
0.4456622601,
-0.0302069914,
-0.6407345533,
0.1254855096,
0.7248942852,
-0.215522036,
-0.3920182586,
0.5454805493,
-0.1953336,
-0.410467118,
0.370542109,
-0.1919693649,
-0.4647902548,
0.2869818509,
0.6211490035,
0.9069038033,
-0.1094281301,
0.2271970063,
-0.0579495803,
0.496350944,
-0.0344703794,
0.0243002083,
0.187681362,
-0.9726470709,
-0.3518283665,
-0.3486084342,
-0.7042219639,
0.485834837,
-0.5988888741,
-0.156832993,
-0.7455362082,
-0.1800314486,
-0.087843582,
-0.415994674,
-0.638379097,
0.1158838943,
0.1518714875,
0.6171722412,
-0.7711085677,
0.7338066697,
0.8235647082,
-0.2279913127,
-0.6296527982,
0.4197461009,
0.1606341749,
-0.7512810826,
0.7393749356,
-0.0793136656,
-0.1031613797,
-0.2954704463,
-0.5468097925,
-1.0111120939,
0.6434250474,
0.4273596108,
-0.6098380089,
-0.3016008139,
0.2539030313,
0.4681713283,
-0.2105754018,
0.1508008391,
0.394325912,
0.5365996957,
-0.0598703958,
-1.1305598021,
0.0025516348,
0.2387074828,
0.1694805324,
-0.0891008675,
-0.4868652225,
1.3033220768,
-0.3467514813,
0.0833458155,
0.0049956511,
0.7149056196,
0.2246539593,
0.2756814361,
0.5316294432,
0.7160041332,
0.7274776697,
0.22341232,
1.136731267,
-0.1287143081,
0.5500984788,
1.0240061283,
-0.2961032689,
0.9310467839,
0.6902214885,
-0.551664114,
0.4991804659,
0.2385054678,
0.035591498,
0.3292059004,
-0.0108794253,
0.0282045137,
-0.5127859116,
0.2336147875,
-0.1611581445,
0.6420378685,
0.4267043173,
-0.2442969829,
-0.3425371051,
0.2188389152,
0.245949775,
0.1127404124,
-0.2753611505,
0.2549150586,
0.3446241021,
-0.6543822289,
0.9449555278,
0.0703273863,
0.802488625,
-0.3697820902,
-0.0543266796,
-0.3054897487,
0.7390446663,
-0.1141096205,
-0.6257140636,
0.4967664778,
-0.1580383778,
-0.1238256544,
-0.2335546911,
0.8589621782,
0.0565316528,
-0.6867274642,
0.2161696255,
0.5154429078,
0.2763680816,
-0.3009509444,
-0.6965323091,
0.4003299773,
0.2495479137,
-0.3254236281,
0.5380488634,
0.2132726908,
0.2425939888,
0.7401562333,
0.5795816183,
0.1189605147,
-0.2697058916,
-0.3047973812,
0.6983196139,
-0.8764401078,
-0.2373039275,
-0.9695768952,
0.1546007991,
-0.0723356605,
-0.0683763549,
1.0544916391,
0.2146499455,
0.896866262,
-0.3253555,
0.861902535,
0.1225453913,
0.8910125494,
-0.4060227275,
0.8466023207,
-0.6760872006,
0.210668996,
-0.4843372703,
-0.813652575,
-0.0251836032,
1.0084059238,
-0.2912318408,
-0.0682448447,
1.2211669683,
0.6395439506,
-0.0847347453,
-0.1529586017,
0.67441082,
0.6654776931,
0.2549561858,
0.6416608095,
0.8119528294,
-0.3437208831,
0.4089357257,
-0.5513591766,
-0.2908339202,
-0.1629053801,
-0.8350331187,
-1.2500014305,
-0.635648191,
-0.3465850353,
-0.4312915802,
0.2304930985,
0.8676247001,
0.5490537286,
-0.7778154612,
-0.5005881786,
-0.2114338279,
0.1117951646,
-0.1651526242,
-0.1936771572,
0.269439131,
-0.3627379537,
-0.6312921047,
0.7475687265,
0.3456177115,
0.0640711784,
-0.2603171766,
0.1583923697,
-0.0369151533,
0.3723839819,
0.3904310465,
0.2007214576,
-1.1593005657,
-0.6736515164,
-0.1527308226,
0.2715254724,
-0.0397055522,
0.8350459337,
-0.6824628115,
-0.0362225212,
-0.1461602449,
0.5290911794,
0.2848845124,
-0.4828853011,
0.4685040116,
-0.2190664411,
0.049712114,
0.0083529186,
0.6322424412,
0.2091910541,
-0.0994149074,
0.2893913686,
0.5741889477,
-0.4414331019,
-1.1827079058,
0.4566170573,
-0.8758121729,
-0.6234641671,
1.3035843372,
-0.0563057065,
-0.3794442415,
0.0740685239,
-0.2601081133,
-0.1519850045,
-0.0227606595,
0.9885484576,
0.688172698,
-0.4273744524,
0.0030726057,
-0.3336749077,
0.3942709565,
0.7637105584,
-0.3114765882,
0.0877410993,
0.304751128,
0.5610647202,
0.3348217905,
0.5814028382,
0.2032932043,
0.1502359211,
0.1480882317,
-0.1875550896,
0.1024831906,
-0.185317874,
-0.1556616575,
0.0814688504,
0.3911455572,
-0.0628537834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14732v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14732v1 | TTQA-RS- A break-down prompting approach for Multi-hop Table-Text Question Answering with Reasoning and Summarization | 2024-06-20T20:55:38 | 2024-06-20T20:55:38 | Jayetri Bardhan, Bushi Xiao, Daisy Zhe Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Question answering (QA) over tables and text has gained much popularity over
the years. Multi-hop table-text QA requires multiple hops between the table and
text, making it a challenging QA task. Although several works have attempted to
solve the table-text QA task, most involve training the models and requiring
labeled data. In this paper, we have proposed a model - TTQA-RS: A break-down
prompting approach for Multi-hop Table-Text Question Answering with Reasoning
and Summarization. Our model uses augmented knowledge including table-text
summary with decomposed sub-question with answer for a reasoning-based
table-text QA. Using open-source language models our model outperformed all
existing prompting methods for table-text QA tasks on existing table-text QA
datasets like HybridQA and OTT-QA's development set. Our results are comparable
with the training-based state-of-the-art models, demonstrating the potential of
prompt-based approaches using open-source LLMs. Additionally, by using GPT-4
with LLaMA3-70B, our model achieved state-of-the-art performance for
prompting-based methods on multi-hop table-text QA. | [
-0.3660227656,
-0.9275000691,
0.8415390849,
0.1000968441,
-0.3346714079,
0.108962521,
0.344574213,
-0.1294775754,
0.1462926865,
0.3712124527,
-0.6740628481,
-0.3242608309,
-0.2945003808,
0.6209068894,
-0.3789978623,
0.9311336875,
-0.1647614837,
0.065527536,
-0.1965636164,
0.0339492634,
-1.0670150518,
-0.3440883756,
-0.5484707952,
-0.0159118697,
0.6055515409,
0.5707247257,
0.4454991519,
0.4413300455,
0.2052257508,
0.19464311,
-0.3830488026,
0.1827432066,
0.1261589825,
0.2944960892,
-0.0171105005,
-0.3632484376,
-0.5599047542,
-0.1386698186,
0.4878669083,
0.2578868866,
-0.0600739717,
0.226976946,
-0.1413818002,
0.7044967413,
-0.3952613175,
0.0820236504,
-0.4158842862,
0.0302482024,
-0.0124544501,
-0.3128006458,
-0.7202367187,
-0.6784940362,
0.0012211981,
-0.5244224668,
-0.1470232606,
-0.0329280943,
0.6382936239,
0.1433631182,
-0.7014170885,
-0.3675841093,
-0.4653344452,
0.4932559431,
-0.6506398916,
0.6039966345,
0.2483760267,
0.2618238032,
0.1314996332,
-0.5541149378,
-0.7362282276,
-0.4488297999,
-0.0248652697,
0.1550445557,
0.0877907872,
-0.1480944753,
0.3916504979,
0.0592540279,
-0.7635060549,
-0.2400754988,
-0.4656063616,
0.283254832,
0.0138387671,
0.1872500479,
0.5495175123,
-0.2084367424,
-0.5471420884,
0.1505924463,
-0.7356699705,
0.1103732139,
-0.2429307997,
0.5046902895,
-0.0596361011,
0.8155562282,
-0.395965457,
0.8833684325,
-0.1489985585,
-0.1520119756,
-0.0005315475,
-0.4162474275,
-0.1971040666,
-0.2116524577,
0.5732632875,
0.2510872185,
0.3768281937,
-0.3023052216,
-0.0388644822,
-0.076516293,
-0.0441133045,
-0.4377368391,
-0.1525163203,
0.4421505332,
-0.2424928397,
-0.2530097663,
-0.3138087988,
-0.9478638172,
-0.2909671366,
-0.2958499789,
1.027030468,
-0.4127838612,
-0.0132293152,
-0.1315138787,
-0.2820948958,
0.5057090521,
0.4773075581,
-0.6230301261,
0.1694224477,
0.2756561041,
1.0817998648,
-0.2635315955,
-0.366907537,
-0.9468791485,
0.4348982573,
-0.1565712094,
0.8150336146,
-0.4355040491,
-0.443274647,
-0.15691562,
-0.3074388802,
-0.178850621,
-0.2334549576,
0.2608923614,
-0.7897742987,
0.5000098348,
-0.6070913076,
-0.420906961,
-0.1352118105,
0.8108854294,
-0.8000712395,
0.9582265615,
-0.049412705,
-0.9885095954,
0.1123308018,
-1.0113968849,
-0.3832257092,
-0.0462817401,
-0.0521032289,
-0.2846767604,
-0.4381097257,
0.9366502166,
0.1445235163,
-0.2829923928,
0.1301412284,
-0.0349435024,
-0.2836354375,
0.3213246167,
-0.3062043488,
0.6973121762,
0.0525114685,
0.0071667242,
0.2383191884,
-0.4066837132,
0.1724739373,
0.1360693574,
-0.4511437118,
-0.0909406915,
-0.2403865904,
-0.4577025771,
0.4312106669,
-0.0340031236,
-0.2790595889,
0.3916578889,
-0.1074140668,
0.4356420934,
0.3646169305,
0.3816844821,
0.2586362958,
-0.6003068686,
0.8721173406,
0.0631597266,
0.0689452738,
-0.5648365617,
-0.6307163835,
-0.4262749851,
-0.2872186303,
0.4778338373,
0.9109514356,
-1.1418943405,
-0.0156944543,
0.0570213422,
-0.3981418312,
-0.3026296496,
-0.405770272,
0.4044736922,
1.0264595747,
0.9056298137,
0.3527584374,
-0.2979883552,
-0.3660261631,
-0.3201959729,
-0.1808131337,
-0.1662780643,
-0.1215177923,
0.5917260051,
0.2519658208,
1.0005962849,
-0.5058040023,
-0.1134940758,
-0.6808254123,
0.1208173037,
0.0507389531,
0.4386912286,
0.1473145336,
-0.6267303228,
-0.4429230094,
-0.3555509746,
-0.5064119697,
-0.106746994,
-0.0075200573,
-0.0479226671,
0.0111553082,
0.3154427409,
-0.8740497828,
0.4517000616,
0.1897492409,
-0.3839920163,
0.9804139137,
0.1349387318,
0.5362816453,
-1.3642470837,
0.1762279123,
-0.1170104519,
0.0373519212,
-0.7018477321,
0.0094018513,
0.0541826375,
-0.3243092895,
-0.5296728015,
0.545814693,
-0.5208026171,
-0.1672266871,
0.0967237428,
0.288795054,
0.3282011449,
0.5640009642,
0.304915905,
1.0382169485,
0.2850366235,
-0.8645831347,
0.1554726809,
0.804984808,
0.0780275762,
0.3237456083,
-0.9920289516,
0.2824813724,
-0.0608224347,
0.3625750244,
-1.1390568018,
-0.1138660982,
0.4212524891,
-0.5258882046,
0.1845525205,
-0.2150342613,
-0.2481844425,
-0.2054967135,
-0.5974081159,
0.6069664955,
0.3218956888,
-0.7267275453,
0.86918962,
-0.0018353579,
-0.4761158228,
-0.7432150245,
-0.6525927186,
0.0155143235,
-0.3353488743,
-0.5401847959,
0.2848625183,
-0.0841601416,
-0.2368441522,
-0.2679010034,
-0.0569202639,
-0.1910223067,
-0.1963325739,
-0.2422256768,
0.5045905709,
-0.0535849333,
0.1432813406,
0.290728122,
-0.0455212742,
0.0904833525,
0.0122413803,
0.4192244411,
-0.121461004,
-0.0933840871,
-0.6419121027,
0.4725337625,
0.4242176116,
-0.7065838575,
0.6421221495,
0.033297129,
-0.2079252154,
-0.0252190772,
-0.3406234086,
-0.3449703157,
-0.4089717269,
0.096542187,
-0.4282486141,
-0.7684475183,
0.5440052152,
-0.0511891246,
0.1750389785,
0.2040314376,
0.5574913025,
-0.2179108262,
0.7926476598,
0.1875212938,
0.3486846387,
0.1652249992,
0.1213089973,
-0.1122398078,
-0.516575098,
-0.4110230207,
-1.0786497593,
0.0881862491,
-0.0414917469,
-0.3280498683,
0.6497134566,
0.0565250553,
-0.4093496203,
0.0436065122,
-0.4772484004,
0.6531785727,
0.6528394222,
0.1971843094,
0.7742323279,
-0.3312074244,
-0.135207817,
0.2445165515,
-0.7174389958,
-0.287581712,
0.6396229267,
0.2625876367,
0.6820808053,
0.1478469074,
0.6680747867,
0.435751617,
-0.0024953396,
-0.7158393264,
0.5359889865,
0.4031914771,
-0.5092738271,
-0.5923138857,
-0.668499887,
-0.5356016755,
0.1581972837,
-0.10024295,
-0.7270749211,
-0.1634951085,
0.3202898204,
-0.3804632425,
0.3160196841,
-0.8250311017,
0.9531625509,
0.0005977733,
0.2298359871,
0.3218975067,
-0.8023918271,
0.7150433064,
0.146422267,
0.2775834799,
0.1149057224,
-0.0376055576,
0.8929797411,
-0.6312772036,
0.6832026839,
-0.2714844048,
-0.1209506616,
0.4128114879,
0.4303328395,
0.7001991272,
0.1125091091,
0.1679596603,
-0.2291922718,
0.3823131919,
-0.196255073,
-0.6829099059,
0.0678744838,
-0.5045378208,
-0.2639160752,
-0.3961092532,
-0.5048866272,
-0.6763982177,
0.0058565442,
0.3453525901,
0.7949066162,
0.2170417309,
-0.273489207,
0.8092995882,
-0.3077477515,
0.4155094922,
0.4421707392,
-0.3892926574,
-0.6613917947,
0.4827299714,
-0.0264471639,
0.1927195787,
0.744654417,
0.3150981963,
-0.8160623312,
-0.5313802958,
-0.8128038049,
0.2696726918,
-0.4962027371,
-0.5038593411,
-0.6868091822,
-0.0146166477,
-0.1836990863,
-0.1866941154,
0.0964838415,
-0.6381141543,
-0.1306564808,
-0.1690076292,
0.652299583,
0.5918596387,
0.2128628939,
0.3742799163,
-1.369756341,
0.7183353305,
0.6245542169,
0.3545120358,
0.2446725219,
-0.6865445375,
0.0638426915,
-0.381711036,
-0.0020384197,
-1.6735194921,
0.2656604648,
-0.1417338103,
0.1335408986,
-0.1349289566,
0.3094995022,
0.3863714337,
-0.5140890479,
0.8488564491,
0.1741498113,
-1.2501645088,
0.6743929386,
-0.5834077597,
0.5172996521,
0.5512305498,
0.3344075084,
-0.6640399694,
-0.3407669067,
-0.1297827959,
-0.5990431905,
0.7992352843,
0.0255358666,
-0.2637034357,
-0.0356439613,
0.3277769387,
0.2622042596,
0.1162641048,
-0.9797914028,
0.0283400305,
-0.0143659869,
-0.0370075703,
0.6742185354,
-0.4006654322,
0.0858070925,
-0.0009321266,
0.8260033131,
-0.0874084681,
0.2771474719,
0.1289787143,
-0.2136353105,
0.1625471562,
0.8235176802,
0.5219447017,
0.7677558661,
-0.1694873422,
0.0203519333,
0.3529471159,
-0.412399143,
0.3353664279,
0.028228119,
-0.5105089545,
0.0421025231,
0.1593322307,
0.4253458679,
-0.2443374395,
-0.5514014959,
0.2942145765,
-0.2443041801,
-0.2978784442,
0.1349439323,
-0.2021451592,
0.0932146087,
0.1725368351,
0.4320519865,
-0.3646940589,
0.2132025361,
-0.1507612318,
0.3768074811,
0.1039046571,
-0.196589604,
-0.0907796174,
0.7233858705,
0.2800432742,
-0.2705035508,
0.6437150836,
-0.1486729681,
-0.4661380351,
0.4999841154,
0.4845564067,
0.7179743648,
-0.292526871,
0.5439383984,
0.2864686251,
0.5057982206,
-0.131951496,
0.8286783695,
-0.1636403203,
-0.4994870722,
-0.8663154244,
-0.1898406744,
-0.9310293198,
0.1453572512,
-0.6279650331,
0.2824763954,
-0.2463502139,
0.0451766141,
-0.2169902027,
-0.2959143817,
-0.1859184653,
0.2635045648,
-0.1495825946,
1.1381533146,
-0.7271646261,
0.4489434659,
0.5347670913,
-0.7713187933,
-1.2079222202,
0.2016674727,
-0.128965497,
-0.3088265359,
0.3600854278,
0.2231697738,
-0.010641777,
0.1763743907,
-0.5304120779,
-0.7200022936,
0.971314311,
0.227837652,
-0.1445236504,
-0.449665457,
0.1220576912,
0.0709092245,
0.0859606043,
0.6340339184,
0.6149607301,
0.5111961961,
0.2905239165,
-0.9339258075,
0.2412469983,
-0.0241827611,
-0.2107595205,
0.3239541352,
-0.4106928408,
0.8349081278,
-0.444203794,
0.0666061938,
-0.0804944634,
0.6712239981,
0.92875278,
0.4112365246,
0.4994030297,
0.3570232689,
0.4289276004,
-0.0584443286,
0.492898196,
0.1015159786,
0.0901423916,
1.2471022606,
-0.2601510286,
0.9307889938,
0.3781238794,
-0.2951433361,
0.4594160914,
0.4736267924,
0.3232084811,
0.3290393054,
-0.1328408867,
-0.1277968884,
-0.0793786645,
0.0712881535,
-0.5059048533,
0.3672750592,
0.2114012241,
0.0037491363,
-0.6150267124,
0.0100547131,
-0.0058014435,
-0.1732631028,
-0.5348318219,
0.7561503053,
-0.0920022056,
-0.6588000059,
0.3895325959,
0.0469495133,
0.3493154645,
-0.64176929,
-0.2491502613,
-0.3496268094,
-0.6146418452,
-0.06510631,
-0.7964033484,
0.2943253815,
0.4257991016,
-0.1354131699,
-0.1274245083,
0.6414791942,
-0.5991491675,
-0.0227086265,
-0.0863457024,
1.0500078201,
0.1088556126,
-0.1929044127,
-0.5739082098,
-0.0612831637,
-0.0029383951,
-0.3469395936,
0.0949739739,
0.5868570805,
0.0423698761,
0.6098254919,
0.4446441531,
-0.3794805408,
-0.0128618702,
0.2007794976,
0.8843507767,
-0.8380353451,
-0.9899366498,
-0.7989006639,
0.7136034966,
0.3250901401,
-0.190131098,
0.5001538396,
0.3290354013,
0.2829909325,
-0.2688171864,
0.7041910887,
-0.0128973285,
1.0339441299,
-0.8403767347,
0.4031758904,
-0.436404407,
0.2379536182,
-0.4839591682,
-0.7724637985,
-0.2588618994,
0.0146344593,
-0.1673229784,
0.3531944156,
0.735910356,
0.5138032436,
0.3891506195,
0.168398276,
0.0756496117,
-0.1093218029,
0.2201283574,
0.4570230842,
1.1191645861,
-0.17658858,
0.978705585,
0.0511015654,
-0.3169947565,
0.1010596827,
-0.8657920957,
-1.019583106,
-0.5445947051,
-0.3074369729,
-0.5030235052,
-0.0574147962,
0.9939502478,
0.1542844921,
-0.7616201639,
0.1020864919,
0.0009140301,
0.3090567887,
-0.4174084663,
-0.2532573342,
0.5707075596,
-0.3413821161,
-0.2717121243,
0.6328845024,
0.1903621256,
0.2755034566,
-0.0502706617,
0.2713991106,
-0.2905085683,
0.0792284459,
0.5697965026,
0.4695168734,
-0.3344167471,
0.0079365959,
0.2718488574,
0.1758447886,
0.2543091178,
0.656185329,
-0.944288373,
0.0834137425,
0.5831586719,
0.7083038092,
0.3680097163,
0.503066659,
0.4376631379,
-0.9583402872,
-0.3921810091,
0.4417195916,
0.0761832148,
0.1712026745,
-0.2936929166,
0.396474719,
0.058972694,
-0.6553632021,
-0.7362978458,
0.2650306523,
-1.1368839741,
-0.2444830984,
1.0657473803,
0.195643872,
-0.1201932579,
-0.3627045751,
-0.4224489033,
0.3385301828,
-0.6498447061,
0.891191721,
0.3406717181,
-0.2906937599,
-0.5045152903,
-0.2945143282,
0.6503710747,
0.2747102678,
-1.2872182131,
0.1869969517,
0.5862764716,
0.0226546172,
-0.0658057109,
0.8717650175,
-0.1797945052,
0.5105150342,
-0.1529686302,
0.0953412205,
-0.4468950033,
-0.5375052691,
-0.394416213,
0.4633367658,
0.0210613795,
-0.408801049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14721v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14721v1 | 1+1>2: Can Large Language Models Serve as Cross-Lingual Knowledge Aggregators? | 2024-06-20T20:32:53 | 2024-06-20T20:32:53 | Yue Huang, Chenrui Fan, Yuan Li, Siyuan Wu, Tianyi Zhou, Xiangliang Zhang, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered significant attention due to their
remarkable ability to process information across various languages. Despite
their capabilities, they exhibit inconsistencies in handling identical queries
in different languages, presenting challenges for further advancement. This
paper introduces a method to enhance the multilingual performance of LLMs by
aggregating knowledge from diverse languages. This approach incorporates a
low-resource knowledge detector specific to a language, a language selection
process, and mechanisms for answer replacement and integration. Our experiments
demonstrate notable performance improvements, particularly in reducing language
performance disparity. An ablation study confirms that each component of our
method significantly contributes to these enhancements. This research
highlights the inherent potential of LLMs to harmonize multilingual
capabilities and offers valuable insights for further exploration. | [
-0.5444226265,
-0.7000589371,
0.480787009,
0.0824538991,
-0.2505363822,
0.4194275737,
-0.4213835895,
-0.8836154342,
0.2670155764,
0.5149832964,
-0.1974890381,
-0.2434736043,
-0.7378919721,
0.2119788677,
-0.3393386304,
0.4357160926,
0.1833263338,
0.3870224357,
-0.2169232965,
-0.4075294435,
-0.2514863312,
-0.4869539142,
-0.5963010788,
-0.5793550014,
0.6650612354,
0.285618782,
0.7708246708,
0.5093047023,
0.3560016155,
0.4161596596,
-0.3148003817,
0.5384612083,
-0.2960394025,
0.165639624,
-0.433791399,
-0.5433221459,
-0.5018160939,
-0.5153231025,
0.9398189783,
0.9394694567,
-0.2520779967,
-0.0264267717,
0.0624390692,
0.3676409721,
-0.621471405,
-0.1591827422,
-0.7434307337,
-0.1101835966,
-0.4010221362,
-0.1475817859,
-0.3795650899,
-0.1970056295,
-0.1625877172,
-0.4133769572,
-0.1786732525,
-0.0023742819,
0.441912204,
0.1183380112,
-0.4273240268,
-0.1999872625,
-0.7165978551,
0.9124813676,
-0.738198936,
0.6274248958,
0.2713126838,
0.2829626203,
0.2287662476,
-0.4091439247,
-0.409807384,
0.1801333725,
-0.3538267612,
-0.2267412841,
-0.0777647123,
-0.185289368,
0.1445955038,
0.5211820602,
-0.599616468,
0.5674226284,
-0.2284861058,
-0.2710063756,
0.5557316542,
0.227056548,
0.4045119286,
0.1490969062,
-0.0109687643,
0.1889098883,
-0.7854334712,
-0.0775049552,
0.3224969506,
0.5183451176,
-0.1028883755,
0.7533649802,
-0.3281670511,
0.9742082357,
-0.1538401693,
-0.2628314495,
0.3538397551,
-0.3885491192,
-0.1955676228,
0.089514561,
0.6468909979,
-0.0480424576,
0.1624983847,
-0.2382137328,
-0.165777877,
-0.277577281,
-0.1905068755,
-0.728091836,
0.1937912554,
0.1318003088,
-0.2869367003,
0.0706591085,
-0.3091613352,
-0.6829547286,
-0.4423891604,
-0.3437943459,
0.1226846352,
-0.5211493373,
-0.6265423894,
0.1592053473,
-0.1708352566,
0.1262089908,
0.3292636573,
-0.9409129024,
0.1099360362,
0.738491714,
0.7307930589,
-0.1735188961,
-0.4773823619,
-0.5849866271,
0.2426174581,
-0.3405569792,
0.743914783,
-0.7237922549,
-0.3337620497,
0.2952076793,
-0.1898774654,
0.1087491363,
-0.6436119676,
-0.0280539468,
-1.0932543278,
0.0793861374,
-0.447324574,
-0.5467439294,
-0.1274644434,
0.4908879995,
-0.5819768906,
0.9608390927,
0.0626882985,
-0.6497301459,
0.3398022056,
-0.4886569679,
-0.6024639606,
0.2994650006,
-0.1450587362,
0.0771611407,
0.1022079661,
0.4048022032,
0.3274223506,
-0.4319640696,
0.0612471327,
-0.1800572723,
-0.257815212,
0.3175107837,
-0.3008750975,
0.8077338338,
0.3132114708,
0.1504577398,
-0.0217518117,
-0.4988977313,
0.1202514991,
-0.0282512084,
-0.6024179459,
-0.717243433,
-0.3130435646,
-0.1475876868,
0.2613115907,
0.5998986363,
-0.3392755091,
0.234200418,
-0.396466136,
-0.1092771217,
0.5077646375,
-0.1757644713,
0.6227425933,
-0.3755826652,
0.7336108685,
0.2365000546,
-0.0594857335,
-0.1905761361,
-0.4021903872,
-0.6476436853,
-0.3777876198,
0.2495531738,
0.6319208741,
-1.1611769199,
0.1975553781,
-0.4157540202,
-0.547432363,
-0.6040348411,
0.7825692296,
0.369825393,
0.2765756249,
0.4982507527,
-0.0721440166,
-0.5263587832,
-0.8300457597,
-0.4296105206,
-0.1380212009,
-0.0206330549,
0.2755463421,
-0.0544748083,
-0.2515593767,
0.6227585077,
-0.3460763991,
-0.0851635858,
-0.4955854714,
0.0300263036,
0.4411249459,
0.1626624018,
0.6218824387,
-0.7439388633,
-0.6993229985,
0.530733943,
-0.8988360763,
-0.2648701072,
0.3659369648,
-0.1379472464,
0.4626910388,
0.4143194556,
-0.4115992188,
-0.2581360936,
0.7451031208,
-0.2655179203,
0.4631234407,
-0.1258785725,
0.3570472002,
-0.9530405402,
-0.079192467,
-0.0720641613,
-0.2107422501,
-0.6773976088,
0.1736310124,
0.0677212849,
0.3157019615,
-0.7459552288,
0.9026135206,
-0.6080946922,
-0.3043566942,
-0.280692935,
0.2228268981,
-0.0925047323,
0.1424012333,
0.0608694777,
0.7702074051,
0.7367728949,
-0.7153772712,
0.5734858513,
0.2567021549,
-0.6040740609,
0.6992541552,
-0.2978186607,
-0.2253004313,
-0.2562476993,
-0.1777558476,
-0.8281337023,
-0.286248982,
-0.1598112583,
-0.3326569498,
0.4873531461,
-0.2425430119,
-0.5333868265,
-0.0627043545,
-0.0270547066,
0.6427667141,
0.5451250672,
-0.7034618855,
0.8710907102,
0.5080271363,
-0.4075105488,
-0.8135169744,
-0.8631661534,
-0.0131411646,
-0.3625403941,
-0.7643745542,
-0.0927073583,
-0.0339991227,
-0.5954332948,
-0.1050254852,
0.353905648,
-0.0133121544,
0.0588502362,
-0.3426163495,
0.1798921824,
-0.3070368171,
0.5089575648,
0.1567498147,
0.2475369722,
-0.2046673596,
-0.2636140287,
0.8941301107,
0.1065481529,
-0.5350602865,
0.084633626,
0.5113598108,
0.6441882849,
-0.5740350485,
0.947219491,
0.6645570993,
-0.3843112588,
-0.1792170703,
-0.891669035,
-0.0192932617,
-0.4821922779,
0.3446488678,
-0.5375113487,
-1.1210787296,
0.8752746582,
-0.1589896679,
0.0686736777,
0.2633622587,
0.8245196939,
0.2192476541,
1.0351350307,
0.5787143111,
-0.3447637558,
0.6014352441,
-0.0522873029,
0.0989902467,
-0.8394879699,
-0.1240182221,
-0.5915331244,
-0.1252548993,
-0.4576884806,
-0.6688238978,
0.4040679932,
0.1719567478,
-0.2159840763,
-0.0713615119,
-0.0830896944,
0.5121405721,
0.2873634696,
-0.1774331033,
0.6860775352,
0.2613456547,
-0.2748858929,
0.1577995867,
-0.9980226159,
-0.3260060549,
0.8152318597,
0.2082015127,
1.0240886211,
0.4781377017,
0.5400152802,
-0.0029659206,
0.5016477704,
-0.5924987793,
0.4929694235,
-0.3749080598,
-0.6012285948,
-0.5954656601,
-0.5879318118,
-0.7675560713,
0.7695816159,
-0.0998419672,
-0.8348089457,
0.1414725333,
0.0214848015,
-0.1282411516,
0.3887254596,
-0.5024787784,
0.5798863769,
-0.503937602,
-0.6699075699,
-0.2945177555,
-0.1526063979,
0.5142737627,
-0.3458399177,
0.5662995577,
0.0014625032,
-0.1647552699,
0.3923611045,
-0.1198333129,
0.6705930233,
-0.0760890767,
-0.4586682916,
0.1973682642,
0.0884244516,
0.4318099618,
0.0432418995,
-0.5197877288,
0.412114501,
-0.3600814939,
-0.3475265205,
-0.4562020898,
0.8949612379,
-0.6792018414,
-0.6914464831,
-0.0791532919,
-0.8195095658,
-0.4144562483,
0.3109498024,
0.0786371529,
0.2014572918,
-0.0202697702,
0.1007722989,
0.541429162,
-0.2842786014,
0.4484591186,
0.8646025062,
-0.5860499144,
-0.3430104554,
0.5901685953,
0.2208960354,
0.4108961225,
0.4888368249,
0.0767417252,
-0.5682608485,
-0.5189470053,
-0.4557815194,
0.4406045675,
-0.8650000095,
-0.244887203,
-0.8873108625,
-0.0700767413,
-0.5438002348,
-0.0607874282,
-0.2886617482,
-0.1627075225,
-0.0450012162,
-0.0624261536,
0.3925212026,
0.5143420696,
-0.2475195527,
0.3988204002,
-1.1942270994,
0.1931712627,
0.2619389296,
0.5591890812,
0.2065347433,
-0.4992972612,
-0.6495301127,
0.1911956966,
0.0727471635,
-0.6458200812,
0.4493463337,
0.0847265273,
0.9025552273,
0.3996610045,
-0.1730356514,
0.8253520727,
-0.4186055958,
0.6953386664,
0.2275729477,
-0.8932467699,
0.276047051,
-0.4388390779,
0.4969035685,
0.2901721001,
0.5595128536,
-0.715295434,
-0.598567307,
-0.2092459351,
-0.8303681016,
0.6818544865,
-0.3057947457,
0.0127255078,
-0.0250251591,
-0.0498721488,
0.0025546055,
0.2350403666,
-0.6384634376,
-0.0133616477,
0.2173794359,
-0.0534472242,
-0.3751099408,
-0.3550982177,
-0.2561248243,
-0.1573537439,
0.8249786496,
-0.2765547335,
-0.2077852041,
-0.0958192497,
-0.3506270051,
-0.380984664,
0.3866750896,
0.3013401628,
0.8692941666,
0.2341028452,
0.1896595061,
0.4304402769,
-0.0404999517,
0.0479793213,
0.0887918174,
0.0463253856,
-0.113455981,
0.5081964135,
0.511058867,
-0.0448725261,
-0.7578590512,
0.1059027687,
-0.0111440038,
0.1207760572,
-0.1402644217,
0.0384363607,
0.3746114373,
0.5212305784,
0.4714122415,
-0.4187857807,
0.0147431409,
-0.5947562456,
0.0499312729,
0.6826964617,
0.0579114817,
0.0559474193,
0.4274980426,
0.1651477069,
-0.1546825767,
0.5092178583,
-0.0345695615,
-0.6189538836,
0.3836682737,
0.5268357992,
0.3455726206,
-0.623755157,
-0.0682127848,
0.229270786,
0.3137464523,
-0.2321088165,
0.3490895033,
0.0937799364,
-1.1470081806,
-0.852984786,
-0.7524332404,
-0.2877853811,
0.0212487858,
-0.4459365308,
0.2332703322,
0.0917934626,
-0.0076139211,
-0.0529439859,
-0.0688839629,
-0.6597704291,
0.0393361412,
0.2354772389,
0.9333814979,
-0.8796533346,
0.8522248864,
1.0052852631,
-0.2063883394,
-0.6054916382,
-0.2789381146,
-0.137074843,
-0.8731747866,
0.6378406286,
-0.1915479004,
-0.0438701138,
-0.1834834665,
-0.1101976484,
-0.9539989233,
0.894451499,
0.3212276697,
-0.5599764585,
0.2035441697,
0.5416564345,
0.6506205797,
-0.4452864826,
0.3112431765,
0.5543007851,
0.6730636358,
0.2386238724,
-1.0851298571,
-0.076530017,
-0.0971412584,
-0.1048667729,
0.3578658104,
-0.5913968086,
0.8975628614,
-0.036187917,
-0.0266394354,
-0.0022273099,
0.4407251179,
0.3181424439,
0.2004631013,
0.5454577208,
0.5771458745,
0.8416434526,
0.0053755622,
1.0940502882,
-0.6363683939,
0.0955948606,
1.06637609,
-0.5464246273,
0.636397779,
0.5954075456,
-0.0722343028,
0.2270196676,
0.4342008829,
0.1589867324,
0.3595000505,
-0.0293325074,
-0.477330327,
-0.6696383953,
-0.3299895227,
-0.4559182525,
0.6096894741,
0.4862092733,
-0.2926752269,
-0.3400167227,
0.0182885397,
-0.0804657042,
0.177711904,
-0.503954649,
0.8954308629,
0.016668817,
-0.9067035913,
0.5009803176,
0.0656578392,
0.8395255208,
-0.7200279832,
0.0399964191,
-0.3834682405,
0.2814317942,
-0.2310822308,
-0.7321616411,
0.3882972598,
-0.0516040698,
-0.1554467082,
-0.1916695237,
0.7870956659,
-0.8152090907,
-0.6913639307,
0.7207524776,
1.049025178,
0.0366084017,
0.0937715918,
-0.304546982,
0.151493758,
-0.0603771619,
-0.1169901714,
0.5356324911,
0.5739638209,
-0.0453736,
0.6984824538,
0.6725605726,
0.3875946403,
0.2728760242,
0.1901213378,
0.8344357014,
-0.3605107665,
-0.5199133754,
-0.930531621,
0.6356099844,
-0.2179045379,
0.0964750946,
0.8859498501,
0.729727149,
0.951995492,
-0.0274865814,
0.9327679873,
0.07596872,
0.701279819,
-0.5143466592,
0.7403060794,
-0.9013179541,
0.6114784479,
-0.0624029748,
-0.8842744827,
-0.2629422843,
0.3216347694,
-0.2295131683,
0.1208585128,
0.3772386014,
0.8129845262,
-0.0793933421,
-0.2818438709,
0.6480421424,
0.314665854,
0.4246973693,
0.4333161116,
1.0395133495,
-0.0302116293,
0.5051820278,
-0.0656742305,
-0.189008221,
-0.2068579495,
-0.6910393834,
-0.9010885358,
-0.3180212379,
-0.01465075,
-0.0852342322,
-0.0780002251,
0.5988788605,
0.5837478042,
-0.534656167,
-0.5300678015,
0.4287027717,
0.5981206894,
-0.1321870089,
-0.1725541502,
-0.0628426671,
-0.5186693668,
-0.9760289788,
0.4829875231,
0.1430125833,
-0.0116546992,
-0.4134823382,
-0.1901561767,
-0.4266078472,
0.0448727198,
0.7578649521,
0.1305344403,
-0.4447685182,
-0.0206419379,
-0.0034723321,
-0.0550131798,
-0.0811012536,
0.7197342515,
-0.5716410875,
0.2934896648,
0.6649466753,
0.6643331647,
0.3436552584,
-0.0943968371,
0.4858247638,
-1.0022493601,
0.3514452577,
0.1478843093,
0.7371326685,
0.500946641,
-0.4568420351,
0.4868287742,
-0.093162559,
-0.4088939726,
-0.8295773268,
0.3864693046,
-0.6889277697,
-0.4510728717,
1.328150034,
-0.0411180109,
0.0047111916,
-0.1041784734,
0.2099809498,
0.2038768381,
-0.1859712452,
0.5851166844,
0.9322481155,
-0.1257582903,
-0.3064616323,
-0.3183970749,
0.0963760167,
0.2379439473,
-0.7626270056,
0.1267489791,
0.6150307655,
0.3187880218,
0.506275773,
0.7316017747,
-0.2841522098,
0.1555996388,
-0.2530331612,
0.0550811887,
0.0048092525,
-0.236026302,
-0.442551136,
0.2588425577,
0.3753819764,
0.2594094574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14711v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14711v2 | MultiAgent Collaboration Attack: Investigating Adversarial Attacks in Large Language Model Collaborations via Debate | 2024-06-20T20:09:37 | 2024-06-26T16:05:20 | Alfonso Amayuelas, Xianjun Yang, Antonis Antoniades, Wenyue Hua, Liangming Pan, William Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MA | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown exceptional results on current
benchmarks when working individually. The advancement in their capabilities,
along with a reduction in parameter size and inference times, has facilitated
the use of these models as agents, enabling interactions among multiple models
to execute complex tasks. Such collaborations offer several advantages,
including the use of specialized models (e.g. coding), improved confidence
through multiple computations, and enhanced divergent thinking, leading to more
diverse outputs. Thus, the collaborative use of language models is expected to
grow significantly in the coming years. In this work, we evaluate the behavior
of a network of models collaborating through debate under the influence of an
adversary. We introduce pertinent metrics to assess the adversary's
effectiveness, focusing on system accuracy and model agreement. Our findings
highlight the importance of a model's persuasive ability in influencing others.
Additionally, we explore inference-time methods to generate more compelling
arguments and evaluate the potential of prompt-based mitigation as a defensive
strategy. | [
-0.6175351739,
-1.0194767714,
0.6510981917,
0.1486884356,
0.1452267617,
0.3341750801,
-0.2405457646,
-0.4059101343,
0.0893152729,
0.6629477143,
-0.4153360426,
-0.2025851756,
-0.8973324895,
0.1154995412,
-0.5113272667,
0.7698726058,
0.1186516508,
0.301371485,
-0.1049080342,
-0.2349796742,
-0.4541456401,
-0.9364967942,
-0.8038163781,
-0.3303781152,
0.7361679673,
0.0958075747,
0.8597750664,
0.3092387617,
0.7106139064,
0.5484088659,
-0.1117038503,
-0.0620225891,
-0.6564024687,
0.5602750182,
-0.1207240596,
-0.5369961262,
-0.3781510293,
0.1144963875,
0.548188448,
0.7584235072,
-0.1508098692,
-0.1716605276,
-0.0192440115,
0.2621060908,
-0.6638476849,
-0.1047164947,
-0.9609673023,
-0.0485568419,
-0.2678299546,
0.1086903214,
-0.6341687441,
-0.0989472345,
0.3255641758,
-0.2839484215,
0.0163486339,
-0.0418941267,
0.5278753638,
0.1136046648,
-0.2714276016,
-0.3866853416,
-0.6134006381,
0.5642324686,
-0.6860499382,
0.0253687203,
0.1573610604,
0.1536078304,
-0.5980479121,
-0.9186449051,
-0.4411279261,
-0.4978549182,
0.0872551203,
0.1274591088,
-0.6718640924,
0.1108724773,
0.2866768837,
0.0989532322,
-0.3741059899,
0.2959486842,
-0.0432229079,
-0.0337006003,
0.5123779178,
0.1822590381,
0.4844902754,
0.164039582,
-0.4130142331,
0.0596094541,
-0.588311851,
-0.2346541882,
0.5965486765,
0.219908759,
-0.1252642274,
0.4851088822,
0.0366150998,
0.5208137631,
0.0468409099,
0.2598391473,
-0.3368537128,
-0.4691735804,
-0.3618207276,
-0.0401888601,
1.125451684,
0.113640517,
0.0225961246,
-0.3519590497,
-0.0922728181,
0.2561420202,
0.3280692995,
-0.7806844711,
-0.3683153987,
0.1401435435,
-0.276283294,
-0.4357691705,
0.0315521397,
-0.8100335598,
-0.6628266573,
0.0472091772,
0.3581734002,
-0.0491591617,
-0.21871382,
-0.0559851304,
-0.231590122,
-0.196915105,
0.4531595111,
-0.544110775,
0.4417843819,
0.8628473878,
0.7719829679,
0.0695013031,
-0.5945677757,
-0.8079094291,
0.1475133747,
-0.6316055059,
0.6371596456,
-0.500679493,
-0.7138477564,
-0.2439363301,
-0.1155273318,
-0.1944036931,
-0.2240101248,
0.3564113379,
-0.7959079742,
0.2538605332,
-0.2741084993,
-0.5775381327,
0.0463557616,
0.6112115979,
-1.0186098814,
0.4094814062,
-0.4204886556,
-1.0334322453,
-0.1118399799,
-0.6791567206,
-0.1622355729,
0.1193955615,
-0.3410109878,
-0.2994740009,
-0.0277911071,
0.2599235475,
0.3252438903,
-0.5340416431,
0.0449302569,
-0.6147053242,
-0.074225314,
0.6982060671,
-0.6312735081,
0.851339519,
0.1410455853,
-0.2078230232,
0.3251490593,
-0.2122173756,
-0.3206216097,
0.3698037267,
-0.1722590327,
-0.4094479382,
0.0049027698,
-0.4265956283,
-0.1329983026,
0.2969527841,
-0.3399936259,
0.3385224938,
-0.4857442975,
0.3200128675,
0.7344834208,
0.3689780235,
0.3615486026,
-0.3106711209,
0.7165259719,
-0.491002053,
0.2574081123,
-0.0880891159,
-0.5750585198,
-0.5170217752,
-0.1413668692,
0.3033587933,
0.3221678138,
-0.9280283451,
-0.2572933733,
-0.083493419,
-0.5625337958,
-0.4267194867,
0.0589587279,
0.5334097743,
0.2039235234,
0.1204477474,
-0.228737548,
-0.3085124791,
-0.7067706585,
-0.3040532172,
-0.2596175671,
0.1962138712,
0.3357149363,
0.4250468314,
-0.0141702592,
0.6152999997,
-0.380397588,
0.34939906,
-0.4234606922,
0.4022414684,
-0.1489799768,
0.3966474235,
0.6264734864,
-0.784332037,
-0.7309353352,
-0.0669273064,
-0.7489770055,
0.104756698,
0.0183203667,
-0.1117234379,
0.1387469918,
0.6014993787,
-0.4770140648,
0.1718310416,
0.8803033829,
-0.3708366752,
0.6931654215,
-0.1100864336,
0.4534852207,
-1.0569970608,
-0.1121978611,
-0.1636612713,
0.0773560628,
-1.1551241875,
0.4019872546,
-0.4454390705,
-0.0561844707,
-0.3690140843,
0.2899012268,
-0.4319594204,
0.1729946882,
-0.2876307368,
0.2602923214,
-0.0154996207,
0.0392634124,
-0.2557691038,
0.740065515,
0.4365158379,
-0.2266940624,
0.6425504088,
0.0185706709,
-0.1464066058,
0.6544980407,
-0.7030391693,
0.6223560572,
0.3254831731,
0.2406373322,
-0.9534372091,
-0.1645063907,
0.3010792434,
-0.8124585152,
0.274083823,
-0.336943537,
-0.5544933677,
-0.2112417072,
-0.2882912457,
0.1928523332,
-0.2043291479,
-0.4720439911,
0.7406719923,
0.5187783241,
-0.1972563565,
-0.9642081261,
-0.5982942581,
0.7988421321,
-0.3988895714,
-0.8370514512,
0.1617682576,
-0.0911334008,
-0.8656212687,
-0.0754341856,
0.3635833263,
-0.1226964965,
0.4896883965,
0.104259856,
0.1532824934,
-0.1718003899,
-0.1728220135,
-0.4620861709,
0.0673335344,
0.3485705853,
0.115620859,
0.6482181549,
-0.1920399368,
-0.6067584753,
-0.31490466,
0.4710625112,
0.7530502677,
-0.3345737457,
1.0207973719,
0.4040323496,
-0.2888676524,
-0.131842047,
-0.6557424664,
-0.2260293365,
-0.5099096894,
0.6139070392,
-0.4229023457,
-0.8748319745,
0.6693041921,
-0.1671880931,
-0.0341531374,
0.1547724307,
0.5679297447,
0.222445339,
1.1621266603,
0.3939154446,
-0.3733865023,
0.3627525866,
-0.1880190969,
-0.0485564582,
-0.5853114724,
-0.1983720213,
-0.7716306448,
0.0823536143,
-0.5543676615,
-0.4509058893,
0.2572331429,
-0.1623096317,
-0.1932744831,
0.3095635176,
-0.1007307321,
0.3925241232,
0.4050902128,
-0.0836826339,
0.203722775,
-0.3356832564,
-0.1059656739,
0.0257466044,
-0.7738515735,
-0.338653028,
1.0490055084,
0.3865526617,
0.7075039148,
0.5556529164,
0.4626759291,
0.3595141172,
0.2790717781,
-0.6922612786,
0.6078436375,
-0.1120194346,
-0.5823715925,
-0.2658268213,
-0.5504487157,
-1.1485259533,
0.4648141563,
-0.4050500393,
-0.8232476711,
-0.0362305827,
-0.2198758572,
-0.3000483811,
0.5257684588,
-0.7451024055,
0.9644515514,
-0.3353878856,
-0.5190109015,
-0.4372337162,
-0.6295908689,
0.4428119361,
-0.1570409983,
0.195937857,
0.2715378702,
0.046624437,
0.6706018448,
-0.3167383671,
0.9004240632,
0.0295735262,
-0.1447744966,
0.2741591334,
0.1862034053,
0.7191880941,
-0.1059630439,
-0.2594371736,
-0.0000268976,
-0.2639312744,
-0.3353446424,
-0.5766916871,
0.7851451635,
-0.7721443176,
-0.8920103312,
-0.1964711994,
-0.5357117057,
-0.096798256,
0.0504579395,
0.0006420003,
0.4647645354,
-0.7349412441,
0.414817512,
0.5732328296,
-0.0556465536,
0.5378019214,
0.4558889866,
-0.1094818562,
-0.7143645883,
0.8122153878,
-0.0560148656,
0.8332263231,
0.2625486851,
0.3026482761,
-0.0366378687,
-0.6647310853,
-0.3410020173,
0.0284221414,
-0.7791329026,
-0.0400839709,
-0.668776989,
-0.0250702947,
-0.4142664373,
-0.1368908137,
-0.5235671997,
-0.0891655833,
-0.1036480144,
0.2731720507,
0.1103838682,
1.2437903881,
0.2564186752,
0.5081285238,
-0.7605268359,
-0.2451414764,
0.436226517,
-0.1730889082,
0.1742538512,
-0.3427897096,
-0.1958760619,
-0.1972520351,
-0.3607261479,
-1.3039734364,
0.2719726562,
-0.464112103,
0.8620773554,
0.3306435049,
-0.0126027083,
0.3820945919,
-0.1934013069,
0.8136244416,
0.1755674332,
-1.0691893101,
0.2074043602,
-0.3297049105,
0.1824952066,
0.3103838265,
0.2850013673,
-0.4125868976,
-0.4715230465,
-0.7599264383,
-0.4360869229,
0.5805842876,
0.3705930114,
-0.1135434806,
0.3171330094,
0.0471836589,
-0.4008972645,
0.1949645728,
-0.6892079115,
-0.3107783496,
0.1772257686,
0.2459024191,
0.1181052178,
-0.1129838526,
-0.5071703792,
0.2765116692,
0.4904790223,
-0.0457493924,
-0.1100627109,
0.0401072018,
0.0931630135,
-0.0790608451,
0.4201788902,
0.6976354122,
0.5390625596,
0.3243189752,
0.2802044451,
0.5761532187,
-0.3024694324,
0.0932447687,
0.3627535999,
0.1924446076,
-0.1822744906,
0.7266344428,
0.6736056805,
0.0101491045,
-0.2968547642,
0.6450382471,
-0.4730510414,
-0.2541793585,
0.0535591654,
-0.0945630446,
0.4409787357,
0.6865231991,
0.0303793475,
0.2283800989,
0.0432146601,
-0.4809603691,
0.0844869167,
0.8891010284,
-0.4136459827,
-0.2238933891,
0.3101311922,
0.1543067247,
-0.4523773789,
0.2206680477,
-0.2453630567,
-1.0745378733,
1.0078519583,
0.37274611,
0.7969913483,
-0.5661814213,
-0.0359962322,
-0.0457152538,
0.6258224845,
0.0199724603,
-0.3236508667,
0.3196470439,
-0.7230124474,
-0.4997398555,
0.014871168,
-0.8796699643,
0.4252375364,
-0.3710528314,
0.1508191824,
-0.491709888,
-0.3089964092,
0.2181459814,
0.2105450183,
-0.185984984,
-0.2637768984,
0.2744191587,
0.4636415243,
-0.6177951694,
0.7773376107,
0.7124509811,
-0.3725675941,
-0.5736557245,
0.1834054142,
0.2570368648,
-0.5154026151,
0.6140292883,
-0.0296245366,
-0.5016748309,
-0.3298713565,
-0.6991073489,
-0.7582073808,
0.7731757164,
0.5058354139,
-0.5934007168,
0.2202250361,
-0.018543018,
0.5216328502,
-0.4680582881,
0.188868776,
0.3872149289,
0.3929408789,
0.1761449575,
-0.9209429622,
0.1027712896,
-0.1041766182,
-0.2569473684,
0.1485258192,
-0.8069083691,
1.034915328,
-0.1982919574,
-0.0191575475,
0.1374317855,
0.6440804005,
0.1627204865,
0.252517432,
0.6944314837,
0.370124191,
0.7171761394,
0.229641214,
0.9098079205,
-0.2429321855,
0.222924307,
1.3560779095,
-0.4207900465,
0.6829957962,
0.3481705785,
-0.1507461816,
0.3628130257,
0.1378779113,
-0.1846528649,
0.1161892489,
0.4011527598,
-0.4180695713,
-0.281132251,
-0.2018821537,
-0.3932371736,
0.4654316008,
0.4898949862,
-0.314022094,
-0.101816088,
-0.0573154613,
0.4348839819,
0.3880025148,
0.0109295454,
0.8102989793,
0.0320030227,
-0.8395712376,
0.157292828,
0.1195480824,
0.4743836224,
-0.5388401747,
0.0475873165,
0.1716114879,
0.4046415687,
0.0480085984,
-0.5898007154,
-0.0250623506,
0.1015307158,
-0.0391843691,
0.2442549765,
0.5929039121,
-0.391367197,
-0.2312046736,
0.7466948628,
0.602224648,
-0.0791837201,
-0.0810048804,
-1.0572535992,
0.3271851838,
-0.1480616331,
-0.3136576712,
0.3828426301,
0.3162394166,
0.0871512741,
0.6628889441,
0.6311956048,
0.2322366834,
-0.1847255528,
0.308221668,
1.0816707611,
-0.0631515235,
-0.2316710949,
-1.3086805344,
0.0088113155,
-0.3922172487,
0.1431975663,
1.1140706539,
0.3392495811,
0.6436603665,
0.3753016591,
0.7944473624,
0.3061268032,
0.2830201983,
-0.3465619385,
0.9055617452,
-0.3391978145,
0.5603892207,
-0.4645499289,
-0.3071269095,
-0.2433828861,
0.2008365542,
-0.4512041509,
0.0383520424,
0.7348700762,
0.7020249963,
0.2766234279,
0.1877950579,
0.2502720654,
0.3726801872,
0.8310694695,
0.4160809815,
1.2361551523,
-0.1889772713,
0.7907574177,
-0.1960955411,
-0.245009914,
0.0443138182,
-0.886967659,
-1.2271714211,
-0.1694444269,
-0.2108490467,
-0.5999680161,
0.2318327725,
0.9392879009,
0.4299000502,
-0.6679755449,
-0.4795587659,
0.0083880546,
0.2838065028,
0.1608468294,
-0.1445455104,
0.1842662394,
-0.070409447,
-0.7696260214,
0.7494105697,
0.0290537197,
0.0604788698,
-0.6853269339,
-0.1144441664,
-0.5395627022,
0.4034314454,
0.2809509635,
0.1031266451,
-0.7894749045,
0.0162884817,
0.0653750226,
-0.2691884637,
-0.2043555379,
0.7853831053,
-0.1710686386,
0.6959968209,
0.4674520791,
0.9124042988,
0.1004381627,
0.0927866772,
0.7851451039,
-0.4478073418,
0.0153362472,
0.174751386,
0.4696804583,
0.5365677476,
-0.3478410244,
0.3596490324,
0.3954225183,
-0.8432204127,
-0.9353674054,
0.0950093344,
-0.449156791,
-0.6000816226,
0.9833853245,
-0.5582604408,
-0.1408247948,
-0.1730786413,
-0.2673519552,
0.1194804087,
-0.5011925101,
0.5842006803,
0.9495933652,
0.0804057568,
0.1652565151,
-0.5261297226,
0.2981951833,
0.4394798875,
-0.898940146,
0.0677469224,
0.3694581985,
-0.0591130145,
0.4517899156,
0.5411309004,
0.2505739629,
-0.0798398703,
0.3172977269,
-0.2051240951,
0.0501783118,
-0.5512790084,
-0.3929875493,
0.5316451788,
0.2147151381,
-0.0490269735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14709v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14709v1 | Factual Dialogue Summarization via Learning from Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T20:03:37 | 2024-06-20T20:03:37 | Rongxin Zhu, Jey Han Lau, Jianzhong Qi | cs.CL | cs.CL, F.2.2; I.2.7 | Factual consistency is an important quality in dialogue summarization. Large
language model (LLM)-based automatic text summarization models generate more
factually consistent summaries compared to those by smaller pretrained language
models, but they face deployment challenges in real-world applications due to
privacy or resource constraints. In this paper, we investigate the use of
symbolic knowledge distillation to improve the factual consistency of smaller
pretrained models for dialogue summarization. We employ zero-shot learning to
extract symbolic knowledge from LLMs, generating both factually consistent
(positive) and inconsistent (negative) summaries. We then apply two contrastive
learning objectives on these summaries to enhance smaller summarization models.
Experiments with BART, PEGASUS, and Flan-T5 indicate that our approach
surpasses strong baselines that rely on complex data augmentation strategies.
Our approach achieves better factual consistency while maintaining coherence,
fluency, and relevance, as confirmed by various automatic evaluation metrics.
We also provide access to the data and code to facilitate future research. | [
0.0030430728,
-0.5933214426,
0.8533447981,
-0.0538865775,
-0.3999324143,
0.3026916981,
-0.1497174054,
-0.3155017495,
0.1225503087,
0.4909613132,
-0.4410046041,
-0.6583306193,
-0.7784115672,
0.2521185577,
-0.2979163826,
1.2537385225,
0.0711430088,
0.0066673611,
-0.1541333944,
-0.3372456729,
-0.3925944865,
-0.4859093428,
-0.3169851303,
-0.204944104,
0.4395689964,
0.2026165426,
0.5906671882,
0.6551303267,
0.2939370871,
0.3852334321,
-0.1331387311,
0.3385323286,
-0.7853400707,
0.221272856,
-0.0737580508,
-0.5445603728,
-0.2811605334,
-0.0302221477,
0.7049142122,
0.6469913125,
-0.2513309419,
0.0573460907,
0.0977832526,
0.4007118046,
-0.6192083359,
0.6794044971,
-0.7377730012,
-0.0110033536,
0.3773093522,
-0.1350750625,
-0.3943010569,
-0.7941191792,
0.2669510245,
-0.6763408184,
0.3096078932,
0.00702604,
1.0055474043,
0.5077604651,
-0.7462463379,
-0.2556983232,
-0.8311293721,
0.8379995227,
-1.2038110495,
0.1675178707,
0.1744825393,
0.3421127498,
-0.0361602977,
-0.5361256599,
-0.7264583111,
-0.3998800516,
-0.391019702,
0.1851799488,
-0.1941616982,
0.1606570482,
0.3563286364,
0.1523589492,
-0.3941506147,
-0.10230048,
-0.3828457296,
-0.3470562696,
0.5966895819,
0.3439570665,
0.0411119014,
-0.088428922,
-0.0099429991,
-0.0426416919,
-0.7493029237,
-0.3261486292,
0.1395739317,
0.4306734502,
-0.487731874,
0.7030027509,
-0.4727027714,
0.4820702076,
0.263243109,
-0.6799363494,
0.1870772541,
-0.6270217299,
-0.2747765481,
0.470770359,
0.6518793106,
0.4312959313,
0.1191259623,
0.0703389719,
0.0016573759,
-0.0293908287,
0.0292738229,
-0.922775507,
-0.2596038282,
0.0417303257,
-0.0830191374,
-0.2943355143,
-0.003674068,
-0.2497945279,
-0.3964354396,
-0.823433578,
0.4422700703,
-0.4523998797,
-0.1067137122,
0.0932938978,
-0.2234169692,
-0.0461474732,
0.7666854858,
-0.8012279272,
0.1068808883,
0.7779452205,
0.9816290736,
0.2892882526,
0.0229667369,
-0.659920454,
0.3809867501,
-0.3726483881,
0.4102083743,
-0.1494910717,
-0.155437842,
-0.0352606326,
-0.0528741591,
-0.0433876887,
-0.6528685093,
0.1663010865,
-0.2014857382,
0.3179453611,
-0.3844692111,
-0.5310343504,
-0.2649584711,
0.4755439162,
-0.4149985313,
0.6930914521,
-0.0969174504,
-0.620708704,
0.3683105111,
-0.2361026406,
-0.3022981286,
-0.3195067942,
-0.2981248498,
-0.4634321928,
0.2690930367,
0.0904395357,
0.4550503492,
-0.0240429081,
0.6035549641,
-0.2736091018,
-0.2692989111,
0.0662546307,
-0.5805236697,
0.7701048255,
0.1468353868,
-0.3130458593,
-0.0437790975,
-0.7056527138,
-0.4335004389,
0.0751196072,
0.0132024065,
-0.3484375775,
-0.1526700407,
-0.7483827472,
0.2151094675,
0.21816957,
-0.5798072219,
0.0414932296,
-0.4917551875,
-0.0688917264,
0.5323870778,
0.1883335561,
0.2904707193,
-0.4945989251,
0.1939311624,
0.4719141722,
-0.106579639,
-0.3927618265,
-0.163804248,
-0.9951857924,
-0.5440237522,
0.243841961,
0.497100383,
-0.9494734406,
0.6021333933,
-0.427670598,
-0.4774154127,
-0.2875097096,
0.1775456816,
0.3812908232,
0.9652629495,
0.2607075572,
-0.1589659899,
-0.43042925,
-0.6990819573,
-0.0489076898,
-0.5037224293,
-0.1117412597,
0.1282244474,
0.3935409188,
0.00472883,
0.9334025979,
-0.8098076582,
-0.3499264419,
-0.4270813763,
0.5619287491,
0.2514469624,
0.2341515273,
0.5272029638,
-0.3412106633,
-0.7017369866,
-0.1758583933,
-1.0748375654,
-0.1272953451,
-0.2643674314,
-0.0163636189,
0.329662621,
0.2374685258,
-0.7688294053,
0.3787771463,
0.2575859427,
-0.0723924562,
0.6511380672,
-0.310367614,
0.2393090874,
-1.1769952774,
-0.1049097776,
0.1823585778,
-0.5646480322,
-0.6423458457,
-0.3054161668,
-0.1985045373,
0.0165349189,
-0.4944014549,
0.3986696303,
-0.2523637712,
0.1666423231,
-0.1044993103,
0.3863270283,
0.1896593124,
0.5251290798,
0.2883989513,
0.4677813053,
0.2635569572,
-0.5468840003,
0.4627962112,
0.4277325273,
-0.3937681913,
0.5171826482,
-0.6881383657,
-0.2961395085,
-0.3427322209,
0.6057379246,
-1.0174857378,
-0.2092903405,
0.283477664,
-0.0937576964,
0.3450969458,
-0.1554336846,
-0.4257277548,
0.2827970684,
-0.4573200643,
0.20843108,
0.676628828,
-0.4994277358,
0.6199483871,
0.242608577,
-0.626840055,
-0.6801231503,
-0.3351024389,
0.053531751,
-0.1659567207,
-0.3433278799,
-0.1102570891,
0.1668945402,
-0.4263632894,
-0.1436281055,
-0.4314234257,
-0.0256140381,
-0.0242482983,
0.2030446827,
0.4947433174,
-0.3232080042,
0.0135191912,
0.1246428415,
-0.0827723667,
0.044109486,
-0.0761010423,
0.2122599185,
0.1257095486,
-0.4305479527,
-0.8147997856,
0.0625342131,
0.4559293389,
0.1965033859,
0.9184495807,
0.3236342669,
-0.0776232779,
-0.0159795973,
-0.6326913834,
-0.3743944466,
-0.4081656933,
0.2098573446,
-0.0237807054,
-0.9727894068,
0.4103081226,
-0.2111109197,
0.4037827849,
0.4628149867,
0.4355955124,
-0.3380847573,
0.8297311068,
0.6764566898,
-0.1705247909,
0.3218600154,
-0.1366959661,
0.3469037712,
-0.2560354471,
-0.1881171763,
-0.3935717642,
-0.0655575097,
-0.2746876776,
-0.2702342272,
0.7095053792,
-0.1391071677,
-0.3003575802,
0.2559455335,
-0.0397253856,
0.4838178456,
0.2973761261,
0.02247894,
0.8188040853,
0.1019794568,
-0.0073523992,
-0.0069231866,
-0.712875545,
-0.5732621551,
0.9034566879,
0.2384586185,
0.7958979607,
0.3058104515,
0.7998477221,
0.2890991569,
0.302752465,
-0.5855320096,
0.4909433722,
-0.014433166,
-0.4070360661,
-0.405893594,
-0.7402612567,
-0.4833889604,
0.3222257793,
-0.3140684962,
-0.5508109927,
-0.017642498,
0.4594885111,
-0.618314445,
0.0420053974,
-0.743088305,
0.7825096846,
-0.0986015424,
-0.1030768305,
-0.39668414,
-0.8985192776,
0.714492321,
-0.1379753053,
-0.0254787263,
-0.3139518797,
0.2628598809,
0.3595389426,
-0.8215226531,
1.2152553797,
-0.1090432554,
-0.285995543,
0.2790082097,
0.034853559,
0.6171499491,
0.0767513812,
0.1880595386,
0.2930496931,
0.1820712239,
-0.2786014378,
-0.9383994937,
0.3496283591,
-0.7504188418,
-0.8350383043,
-0.5781282783,
-0.4978512526,
-0.1805730611,
-0.0576349758,
-0.0798530579,
0.6119084358,
-0.3253540397,
0.2130301744,
0.798364222,
-0.2696802616,
0.2613500953,
0.7396520376,
-0.1410678923,
-0.1407836825,
1.0195106268,
0.1412430853,
0.5204225779,
0.4710907638,
0.1652927548,
-0.5524994731,
-0.3081327379,
-0.5105677247,
0.4873352051,
-0.5379530191,
-0.2703338563,
-0.6889420152,
-0.4125728905,
-0.4954457879,
-0.0228029341,
-0.3641224802,
-0.7758868337,
-0.1124314442,
-0.2853738368,
0.3834157586,
0.5765407085,
-0.0474727228,
0.3822771907,
-1.0324071646,
0.6412004232,
0.3065442443,
-0.0793238059,
-0.098951079,
-0.746176064,
-0.3432905376,
0.4228865802,
-0.422214359,
-0.6163961291,
0.3571130335,
0.2780281007,
0.2412780374,
0.4646005332,
0.4506748319,
0.714302361,
-0.4485279024,
0.8532297611,
0.4674936831,
-0.9830127954,
0.337438345,
-0.396445334,
0.4733836651,
0.7606975436,
0.431668669,
-0.4496157467,
-0.7922838926,
-0.6288843155,
-0.497494638,
0.7876540422,
0.3336816728,
0.1500976831,
0.20381625,
0.1746096462,
0.2310649455,
0.4957506657,
-0.4464367032,
-0.1945223212,
-0.3790073991,
-0.6075028181,
-0.2506114841,
-0.2503516972,
-0.5052155256,
-0.2511247098,
0.9143294692,
-0.1922639906,
-0.1724759638,
-0.0564061701,
-0.2818816602,
0.2492603511,
0.2679221928,
0.778292954,
0.7328412533,
-0.2404294461,
0.2026256919,
0.4313159585,
-0.2980700135,
0.2904593349,
0.0067862384,
-0.2460337281,
0.494532764,
0.4617396593,
0.7917452455,
0.1598605365,
-0.7378053665,
0.6222054362,
-0.0829216465,
-0.2033223212,
-0.2579998374,
0.2494124025,
-0.0226623919,
0.3283140361,
0.1395101845,
-0.1225519106,
0.068501316,
-0.7418546677,
0.1086315066,
0.371860981,
-0.1254367381,
-0.2747748792,
0.3941624165,
0.3014996052,
0.2745528519,
0.5810974836,
-0.0770466924,
-0.2834157944,
0.4875577688,
0.3798618615,
0.7735046148,
-0.0857633948,
0.4882388115,
0.4180497527,
0.1714467704,
-0.1803547144,
-0.0680884793,
-0.332329005,
-0.6355769634,
-0.6394192576,
-0.4846392274,
-0.7426811457,
-0.0618302412,
-0.3810402453,
0.2844238281,
-0.4052886665,
0.0237443671,
-0.0601224191,
-0.0566280074,
-0.2873248756,
0.2116136104,
0.0505592078,
0.5383224487,
-0.8822775483,
0.7650888562,
0.0477225594,
-0.4171497822,
-0.9501222372,
-0.1173672453,
0.4131435752,
-0.6619541645,
0.60268718,
-0.0357677303,
-0.1842402965,
-0.2827726305,
-0.3593506217,
-0.6217956543,
1.2446118593,
0.8914710283,
-0.8082814217,
-0.0865702331,
0.4393262863,
0.6178022623,
-0.2622684538,
0.4226840436,
0.4628236592,
0.2884624302,
0.5808755159,
-1.0091613531,
0.0514708124,
0.0916607976,
-0.2784003913,
0.0982022211,
-0.5578691363,
0.2734915018,
-0.1988729388,
-0.2946200371,
0.0097718667,
0.6896779537,
0.3968189657,
0.4791826308,
0.3051255047,
0.5795634985,
0.719859004,
-0.1585037708,
0.688315928,
-0.404373318,
0.32368204,
1.5734804869,
-0.585793376,
0.5094559193,
0.2531314492,
0.0712322667,
0.4532560408,
0.2012200803,
0.0823479369,
0.44619295,
-0.1052636355,
-0.6216409802,
-0.176736176,
-0.3269916475,
-0.3209848106,
0.4099649787,
0.0148964562,
-0.2511772811,
-0.5782135725,
-0.4690389335,
0.239761591,
0.0186917167,
0.0122102853,
1.2814218998,
0.2649225593,
-0.6064885855,
0.6578099728,
-0.2293437719,
0.32684654,
-0.7694571018,
-0.3122951686,
-0.2609420717,
0.0337405168,
-0.1750537157,
-0.3373636603,
0.4896633625,
0.2148111165,
-0.0990431234,
-0.1118338034,
0.4239044189,
-0.8050680757,
-0.4763820767,
-0.275314182,
0.5647132993,
0.179777354,
0.056410756,
-0.3737876415,
0.008140998,
0.0098124649,
0.1691423655,
0.3917059898,
0.6068029404,
0.1426427513,
0.4857374132,
0.5745711327,
0.0767677575,
-0.1133229882,
0.1780180037,
0.8068230748,
-0.4999087751,
-0.4832796454,
-1.1217882633,
0.6485512853,
-0.3887355328,
0.0868159086,
0.9439567327,
0.6725471616,
0.5719650388,
-0.0383457616,
0.8746295571,
0.2612631619,
0.4301514328,
-0.5620490313,
0.8035993576,
-0.2760228217,
0.4052048922,
-0.2433820963,
-1.0814893246,
-0.284583509,
0.4824914634,
-0.2647306919,
-0.2380102575,
0.578840673,
0.9105744362,
-0.1535755694,
0.0850935355,
0.4712967277,
0.533295393,
0.2896613777,
0.2979128063,
0.9268734455,
-0.2757172585,
0.313968569,
-0.1553010195,
-0.168616727,
-0.1785887629,
-1.1401691437,
-0.9145871401,
-0.3803399503,
-0.6935090423,
-0.2342019677,
0.1843587607,
1.0688804388,
0.613362968,
-0.7804695964,
-0.2028920352,
0.127239719,
0.318182528,
0.0500515401,
-0.1894868016,
0.1177079603,
-0.3737383187,
-0.5683915615,
0.1534657627,
0.4715757966,
0.172059074,
-0.0056464672,
-0.168219015,
0.0146326711,
0.3693296611,
0.6892492771,
0.3663057685,
-0.6456624866,
-0.3924125135,
-0.4626843035,
-0.1097427905,
0.0597074255,
0.6700419784,
-0.8000323772,
0.3325003684,
0.3481864929,
0.5917246938,
0.4818988144,
0.3519239426,
0.762612164,
-0.8863266706,
0.1937170774,
0.0433727652,
0.3315021396,
0.2971465886,
-0.2702113688,
0.301502645,
0.3039889932,
-0.2565251887,
-0.7157111168,
0.1313475072,
-1.1023551226,
-0.0716159716,
0.9881081581,
-0.4913228452,
0.1440640986,
-0.3248586655,
-0.2464746982,
0.5281696916,
-0.4449960887,
1.133358717,
0.49684003,
-0.1008476019,
-0.0559279695,
-0.1931863725,
0.5223941803,
0.3415839374,
-0.7952381372,
0.1917732954,
0.9351049066,
0.3313684165,
0.1695956737,
0.4943121374,
0.0332862809,
0.085517481,
-0.0780865774,
-0.2770302892,
-0.1747798175,
-0.4257732034,
-0.2598030269,
0.1092983857,
-0.1177767068,
0.082419768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14703v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14703v1 | Do LLMs Have Distinct and Consistent Personality? TRAIT: Personality Testset designed for LLMs with Psychometrics | 2024-06-20T19:50:56 | 2024-06-20T19:50:56 | Seungbeen Lee, Seungwon Lim, Seungju Han, Giyeong Oh, Hyungjoo Chae, Jiwan Chung, Minju Kim, Beong-woo Kwak, Yeonsoo Lee, Dongha Lee, Jinyoung Yeo, Youngjae Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The idea of personality in descriptive psychology, traditionally defined
through observable behavior, has now been extended to Large Language Models
(LLMs) to better understand their behavior. This raises a question: do LLMs
exhibit distinct and consistent personality traits, similar to humans? Existing
self-assessment personality tests, while applicable, lack the necessary
validity and reliability for precise personality measurements. To address this,
we introduce TRAIT, a new tool consisting of 8K multi-choice questions designed
to assess the personality of LLMs with validity and reliability. TRAIT is built
on the psychometrically validated human questionnaire, Big Five Inventory (BFI)
and Short Dark Triad (SD-3), enhanced with the ATOMIC10X knowledge graph for
testing personality in a variety of real scenarios. TRAIT overcomes the
reliability and validity issues when measuring personality of LLM with
self-assessment, showing the highest scores across three metrics: refusal rate,
prompt sensitivity, and option order sensitivity. It reveals notable insights
into personality of LLM: 1) LLMs exhibit distinct and consistent personality,
which is highly influenced by their training data (i.e., data used for
alignment tuning), and 2) current prompting techniques have limited
effectiveness in eliciting certain traits, such as high psychopathy or low
conscientiousness, suggesting the need for further research in this direction. | [
-0.5001643896,
-0.5976584554,
0.7243365645,
0.5545961857,
-0.0219038092,
0.3581477702,
-0.2474932671,
-0.6224115491,
0.4709462523,
0.3533344567,
-0.7309138179,
-0.2048334479,
-0.2856808007,
0.3323387206,
-0.0967532247,
0.9622027278,
0.1909131259,
0.33162871,
-0.1741205454,
-0.5663120151,
-0.3634234965,
-0.7323200107,
-0.5648591518,
-0.4699376225,
1.157145977,
0.3679416478,
0.5380076766,
0.3815987408,
0.5018117428,
0.2088808268,
-0.2622972131,
0.0938932076,
-0.4608733058,
0.1580425948,
-0.2393149883,
-0.2687618136,
-0.7547080517,
0.2000879347,
0.4940465093,
0.7905101776,
0.1097966358,
0.4349333048,
0.1285386086,
0.6785084605,
-0.4268124402,
-0.2444011271,
-0.2057614475,
-0.221595794,
-0.1939331889,
0.1157488078,
-0.313886106,
-0.5391146541,
0.0150621282,
0.0234956834,
0.2077735066,
-0.0071119969,
0.6339020729,
0.0291899424,
-0.8476349115,
-0.0516598746,
-0.7816325426,
0.7532627583,
-0.5094894767,
0.2146528065,
0.3073454499,
0.3007014096,
-0.043619547,
-0.2453704923,
-0.5718885064,
-0.3407497406,
-0.2074130327,
0.0421742313,
0.5073375106,
-0.1099489108,
0.3241436183,
0.5873764753,
-0.7441583872,
0.4745396078,
0.0564420931,
-0.1513805091,
0.898882091,
0.4887110591,
-0.1138833612,
-0.0705673993,
-0.3188125789,
-0.1185462698,
-0.7888913155,
0.3264604211,
0.6761160493,
-0.1188930646,
0.0135099003,
0.4648218155,
-0.3144074976,
0.5259770155,
0.1950992495,
-0.4379428625,
0.2664941251,
-0.2582257092,
0.2122355998,
-0.2608325481,
0.7508542538,
0.2658065856,
0.2768019736,
-0.1169637367,
-0.194254458,
-0.0757846832,
0.1322728097,
-0.6683115959,
-0.2950296998,
0.4994425178,
-0.6220235825,
-0.5874803066,
0.0348809585,
-0.7209072113,
-0.6146658659,
0.017371837,
0.0678176209,
-0.3995437622,
-0.4199377596,
-0.2152615488,
-0.0975844488,
0.6145179868,
0.1221339107,
-1.1670351028,
0.0614410453,
0.5963608623,
0.4740203023,
-0.724352479,
-0.5154963732,
-0.4127638936,
-0.1512682438,
-0.2730832696,
0.7158378363,
-0.5598233342,
-0.4400995672,
-0.3458051383,
-0.1039707214,
0.2325509042,
-0.6042114496,
0.3740206957,
-0.2511480451,
-0.1074301898,
-0.8340991735,
-0.5675912499,
0.1077195778,
0.4485951364,
-0.4955891967,
0.9986086488,
0.4708863199,
-0.4940853119,
0.6686788201,
-0.3646099269,
-0.2397190928,
0.1302992105,
-0.303678453,
-0.3996962607,
0.1542706639,
-0.1360371858,
0.4210297465,
-0.0432931222,
0.0346771628,
-0.9179071188,
-0.2585227191,
1.0383130312,
-0.1617607176,
0.6991854906,
-0.0437304452,
-0.1020079404,
0.2029772252,
-1.037297368,
0.3281719387,
0.1286547035,
-0.4248440266,
-0.0499923229,
0.0504867919,
-0.0178859346,
0.2761563659,
0.4894575477,
-0.7967479825,
0.3926976919,
0.1306455284,
0.1103644446,
0.950407207,
0.0121732773,
0.0496063009,
-0.596452713,
0.4504730701,
-0.1308406591,
0.307136476,
0.2374907732,
-0.3411780596,
-0.7255541086,
-0.6843976378,
-0.101547882,
0.374753952,
0.1797679216,
0.9002189636,
0.0431509875,
-0.772816956,
-0.266048491,
0.218127355,
0.429210335,
0.2253932953,
0.0579604991,
-0.4215855896,
-0.4910675287,
-0.8252669573,
-0.2889478207,
-0.2032289058,
-0.1888917089,
0.3560366035,
0.4870251417,
-0.1647420526,
0.8337925076,
-0.5482670069,
0.1410552561,
-0.5433166027,
0.1600419879,
0.1519741714,
0.0926383808,
0.8508653045,
-0.5976436734,
-0.3775185347,
-0.2995023131,
-0.7482588887,
-0.192957595,
0.045908656,
0.0610755496,
-0.0362311862,
0.1809601933,
-0.186555028,
0.0790659785,
0.5539485216,
-0.5885737538,
0.948032856,
0.1059207693,
-0.0743321702,
-0.7553453445,
0.2280024886,
-0.2781376541,
-0.1385948211,
-0.5138711333,
0.1740815043,
0.009036229,
0.2046742737,
-0.2116516232,
0.8504393101,
-0.0548534952,
-0.2587588429,
-0.0984817669,
-0.3520262837,
0.0308274738,
0.4662458599,
-0.0558344796,
0.7795774341,
0.4315329492,
-0.649384439,
0.5256943107,
0.3346558213,
-0.1673118621,
1.2636033297,
-0.5265306234,
0.4274628758,
0.0381108783,
-0.0155242579,
-0.8906972408,
-0.2966068387,
-0.181893602,
-0.3247236609,
-0.0003513269,
0.2365887463,
-0.26499331,
-0.3290444613,
-0.3431441784,
-0.0187678002,
0.562977314,
-0.3916009963,
0.5827718377,
-0.167497009,
-0.2272094935,
-0.3664581478,
-0.470258534,
-0.2479078323,
-0.3475022614,
-0.332465589,
-0.0230931249,
-0.7846997976,
-0.3175337613,
-0.3377887309,
-0.1418364942,
-0.2072407901,
0.3591175377,
0.2241727859,
0.2891182601,
-0.1982902586,
-0.1006026566,
-0.4302837551,
0.0115121808,
0.1383657604,
0.1585711241,
0.5092130303,
-0.3970077634,
-0.3269543648,
-0.2742885649,
0.3553258479,
0.8153256178,
-0.2818283737,
0.5919732451,
0.6942566037,
0.2583132386,
0.0166308675,
-0.6597226262,
-0.3558336198,
-0.4228941798,
0.3046810627,
-0.556347847,
-1.0595316887,
0.8248439431,
0.0957817063,
-0.070313409,
0.0274104681,
0.5838378668,
-0.5384255052,
1.0211929083,
0.7199576497,
-0.1729855686,
0.355630368,
0.1863705963,
0.2013256103,
-0.9769863486,
-0.189877212,
-0.3157171905,
-0.699011445,
-0.6351345778,
0.296813488,
0.3109694719,
-0.1584706455,
-0.4818491936,
-0.2295353115,
-0.1902328581,
0.4510416389,
0.3090681136,
0.1667934656,
0.3666466177,
-0.4701980054,
-0.1568865031,
-0.2704873383,
-0.0363845378,
-0.6103336811,
1.2773957253,
0.2517237663,
0.7820836902,
0.3342624903,
0.7610363364,
0.0845616013,
0.4507859647,
-0.805878222,
0.7472478151,
0.0039611547,
-0.6018807888,
-0.3626090586,
-0.376301378,
-0.5913395286,
-0.0044660354,
-0.2650858462,
-0.9391158819,
0.1750936657,
0.2367416918,
-0.2972176969,
0.0837764964,
-0.4568901956,
0.7545787692,
-0.6889526248,
-0.3356173635,
0.091687046,
-0.6565436721,
0.411355406,
-0.2563449144,
-0.4170550406,
-0.4316392541,
0.1688728631,
0.4096969068,
-0.1713207066,
0.7185828686,
0.1635747403,
0.0917632058,
-0.1421564221,
0.3017425537,
0.4230052829,
0.0423904248,
-0.2064497024,
0.0018757075,
0.2421568483,
-0.4055576026,
-0.9307121634,
0.597104609,
-0.8741853237,
-0.3946185112,
-0.4055374861,
-0.3806717396,
-0.5198219419,
0.2336412519,
0.1562627554,
0.2462635636,
-0.6277378201,
0.1733868718,
0.7324497104,
-0.0198514331,
0.1547853351,
0.8565052152,
-0.4027944207,
-0.266200304,
0.8274294734,
-0.2076975703,
0.5725640655,
0.2177475691,
0.4064856172,
-0.1318146586,
-0.3560009599,
0.0456689708,
0.4281228483,
-0.5159429908,
0.1937853247,
-0.3853007555,
-0.3350713849,
-0.2685627937,
-0.2225818932,
-0.4323968291,
-0.0476675183,
0.0577912219,
-0.0634459928,
0.3818825781,
0.9979438186,
0.2263478041,
0.1193398461,
-0.4494873881,
0.2928637564,
0.7122061849,
0.4380208254,
-0.2897334397,
-0.3045211434,
0.2126800567,
-0.2566843629,
-0.4030661583,
-0.9300340414,
0.1852835268,
0.1668027639,
0.5127028823,
0.7664029598,
-0.2320282012,
0.280911088,
-0.0037529003,
0.7255179286,
-0.0666940212,
-0.6418058872,
0.2913459241,
-0.2836108506,
0.1659800559,
0.7191312909,
0.4557543099,
-0.6955404282,
-0.5710629225,
-0.6364554167,
-0.2986367941,
0.3165365756,
0.0412793756,
-0.1552756876,
0.0923125744,
0.4719952643,
0.2499755025,
0.3243797719,
-0.6275568604,
-0.4213071465,
-0.2347154915,
-0.2841020226,
-0.2300450802,
-0.5317947268,
-0.2402368188,
-0.4388408959,
0.2544112802,
-0.4526461065,
0.1498113126,
0.0254178718,
0.1691542119,
0.1625778526,
0.5264307857,
0.3888251185,
0.7944943309,
-0.6088747382,
0.2051866353,
0.1355905682,
-0.5505294204,
0.3990771174,
-0.3489774764,
-0.0383927152,
-0.2916671634,
0.1830542386,
0.4598186016,
0.0212049317,
-0.5132520795,
0.6218090057,
-0.1253405958,
-0.1664452404,
-0.3951601088,
0.2363179177,
0.0527834222,
0.2275863141,
0.157980755,
-0.1218278781,
-0.1022869945,
-0.6938410997,
0.0263213031,
0.4412819445,
-0.2452035844,
-0.4184852242,
0.3358284533,
0.2718887031,
-0.1568024755,
0.7537022829,
-0.4906907976,
-0.3836708963,
0.4914227724,
0.368988663,
0.8390510082,
-0.1648380756,
0.3796996772,
0.1428100169,
0.2303960323,
0.0314553306,
0.8196417093,
0.0480639227,
-1.0348160267,
-0.1132538691,
-0.7866454124,
-0.7572089434,
0.4616234899,
-0.7158929706,
0.0569611229,
-0.7342771888,
-0.0851130784,
-0.1853992045,
0.138141036,
-0.7090967298,
0.1213205382,
0.0091346111,
0.7299754024,
-0.8383943439,
0.7462891936,
0.7518210411,
-0.2816334963,
-0.8999043107,
-0.1040747762,
0.1624905169,
-0.812944293,
0.6028190255,
0.1117440835,
0.0281692725,
0.0105697839,
-0.6166231632,
-0.7549152374,
1.0866904259,
0.3073681593,
-0.1346043199,
0.1809915453,
0.1540263742,
0.5636992455,
-0.366967082,
0.3850806057,
0.7753638625,
0.5495713353,
0.1608001292,
-0.8317863345,
-0.0265538208,
-0.1717088819,
-0.0510630161,
-0.0909101591,
-0.9557019472,
0.6812801957,
-0.350450635,
0.2834434211,
0.3408560753,
0.6241549253,
0.5822638869,
0.0055164373,
0.4104180336,
0.4715288281,
1.0427459478,
-0.12571612,
0.8190500736,
-0.321857661,
0.2125930339,
1.0806660652,
-0.6955049038,
0.73825109,
0.4003733695,
-0.1781333536,
0.8269308209,
0.6775514483,
-0.2017124146,
0.19616054,
-0.1092416272,
-0.3484423161,
-0.4984615147,
-0.044662986,
0.0061462047,
0.8022171855,
0.1037541479,
-0.1974729002,
0.3175845444,
-0.0814941302,
0.0745637715,
-0.0413661487,
-0.0548841171,
0.5843222141,
-0.0664055049,
-0.5792632103,
0.2465423793,
-0.3288409114,
0.6213251352,
-0.9299530983,
0.3097088039,
-0.636770308,
0.2595119476,
-0.271576643,
-0.9923029542,
0.1215097159,
-0.1529062688,
-0.2208921015,
-0.4474528134,
0.4504397511,
-0.1458349228,
-0.1801588535,
0.0409988053,
0.6461364031,
0.1818363369,
-0.154316932,
-0.3767495453,
-0.1336822957,
-0.3611084521,
-0.2457913756,
0.589351058,
0.2040584981,
0.0631639138,
0.8996788263,
0.5824627876,
0.3222215474,
-0.1325877309,
0.0975910649,
0.5782848597,
-0.9093548059,
-0.4560455084,
-0.8582094908,
0.3297882676,
-0.184344545,
-0.6839892864,
0.8732551932,
0.4845432937,
0.5638433099,
-0.0817955136,
0.6037546396,
0.0055431984,
0.6516621113,
-0.3130200207,
0.6410836577,
-0.322434634,
-0.0961896479,
-0.0358332507,
-0.8781250119,
0.1388185918,
0.334176451,
-0.1163734496,
0.2776942253,
1.0383163691,
0.7226046324,
0.2454605401,
-0.1129157692,
0.4214473367,
0.2731840611,
0.2999886572,
0.5586961508,
0.9201120138,
0.2213288397,
0.1287768781,
-0.1679665595,
-0.3322539628,
-0.2217984945,
-0.6936452985,
-0.943500042,
-0.309566021,
-0.1889251173,
-0.2673762441,
-0.2680959105,
0.7878658175,
0.4934112132,
-0.4643412232,
-0.3114064634,
0.2387174219,
0.3011947274,
-0.4859271646,
-0.2479007989,
-0.118938379,
-0.1540632546,
-0.2564982176,
0.2171667367,
0.4686211348,
0.1366548091,
-0.8689731359,
-0.0985872671,
0.1718501151,
0.048052378,
0.4273641109,
0.4973337948,
-0.6135365367,
-0.7377870083,
0.4489038885,
-0.3485026062,
0.0926908478,
0.9817384481,
-0.4969631433,
0.2883914709,
0.3750494123,
0.1537719816,
0.1174717769,
-0.2189415246,
0.4720756114,
-0.8180215955,
0.0026950331,
0.2829101086,
0.3124567866,
0.2896626294,
-0.4681454599,
0.3272860944,
0.4170824587,
-0.7945833206,
-0.4584720433,
0.6572970748,
-1.2092956305,
0.0996216387,
1.2145522833,
-0.0735645294,
-0.1040947214,
-0.2238052487,
-0.1004748642,
-0.3244312406,
-0.0880532935,
0.8336284161,
0.8462755084,
-0.6397591829,
-0.2723948658,
-0.190914467,
0.5365686417,
0.4404061735,
-0.8146056533,
-0.0634616539,
0.2890366912,
0.6111251712,
-0.0004973731,
0.6320830584,
-0.0546596944,
0.2082246542,
-0.3023440838,
0.1471443772,
0.1202619895,
-0.1307159215,
-0.2342152148,
-0.0115084266,
0.5229770541,
0.1736166179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14701v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14701v1 | Speech Prefix-Tuning with RNNT Loss for Improving LLM Predictions | 2024-06-20T19:50:49 | 2024-06-20T19:50:49 | Murali Karthick Baskar, Andrew Rosenberg, Bhuvana Ramabhadran, Neeraj Gaur, Zhong Meng | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In this paper, we focus on addressing the constraints faced when applying
LLMs to ASR. Recent works utilize prefixLM-type models, which directly apply
speech as a prefix to LLMs for ASR. We have found that optimizing speech
prefixes leads to better ASR performance and propose applying RNNT loss to
perform speech prefix-tuning. This is a simple approach and does not increase
the model complexity or alter the inference pipeline. We also propose
language-based soft prompting to further improve with frozen LLMs. Empirical
analysis on realtime testset from 10 Indic languages demonstrate that our
proposed speech prefix-tuning yields improvements with both frozen and
fine-tuned LLMs. Our recognition results on an average of 10 Indics show that
the proposed prefix-tuning with RNNT loss results in a 12\% relative
improvement in WER over the baseline with a fine-tuned LLM. Our proposed
approches with the frozen LLM leads to a 31\% relative improvement over basic
soft-prompting prefixLM. | [
-0.3554490805,
-0.5434411168,
0.1880983114,
0.000558822,
-0.5604220033,
0.2168839276,
-0.6738179326,
-0.3645718694,
0.263056159,
0.4089761078,
-0.798301518,
-0.2604552507,
-0.3819678724,
0.4341053963,
-0.1054696664,
0.5876138806,
0.1055052653,
0.4157918096,
-0.1010599062,
0.0758889467,
-0.8036099672,
-0.3464584351,
-1.0450909138,
-0.7377781272,
0.5098906755,
0.7349338531,
0.582095027,
0.8174690008,
0.3311597109,
0.3010942638,
-0.4949375093,
0.2099243701,
-0.3674367964,
0.2432991862,
0.0782437176,
-0.5523552299,
-0.3584563732,
-0.1584040672,
0.7371085882,
0.6266168952,
-0.3067141771,
0.0208974276,
-0.0359229445,
0.6396735907,
-0.3030174971,
-0.2010881901,
-0.8657102585,
0.1225597337,
-0.4698090553,
-0.4894550145,
-0.1831397265,
-0.327691257,
-0.0331875458,
-0.257081002,
0.4761019051,
0.1819081157,
0.7560707927,
0.6102495193,
-0.2174833119,
-0.0579925664,
-0.7968131304,
0.6124489307,
-0.873932898,
0.7159653306,
0.3804967403,
-0.1733606756,
-0.2943125069,
-0.4942412376,
-0.3811526299,
-0.3400399983,
0.2306312025,
0.1072893143,
-0.0672593415,
0.334118247,
0.2586658895,
0.4140366316,
-0.4184181988,
0.5425261259,
-0.3651714027,
-0.5009515285,
0.7029982805,
0.4400786459,
-0.0668349266,
0.2413832843,
-0.2188979685,
0.0812659562,
-0.9106636643,
-0.0605998784,
0.4560792744,
0.524630487,
-0.015309969,
0.3868697584,
-0.1512577534,
0.7796847224,
0.1394970566,
-0.2174427807,
0.0710757524,
-0.0590331405,
-0.0961749628,
0.347181946,
0.1885200292,
0.3910547793,
0.6383519769,
-0.3553929329,
-0.2420013398,
0.0667207763,
-0.1487165093,
-0.6435899734,
-0.1356051862,
-0.2406141311,
-0.2580000758,
0.1263468564,
-0.1438550651,
-0.2266161144,
-0.4461993575,
-0.6777020693,
0.2937146723,
-0.5206555128,
-0.1603160352,
0.2975260317,
-0.2507565916,
0.4503960907,
0.4074629247,
-0.712074101,
0.5902943015,
0.7566564679,
0.7597994208,
-0.2365243137,
-0.0617111176,
-0.690474093,
-0.0839010552,
-0.3550836444,
0.989133358,
-0.3832897842,
-0.6039465666,
-0.1440786272,
-0.2877289057,
-0.0745619386,
-0.694575429,
0.7182645202,
-0.4780087769,
-0.2188780904,
-0.0651959702,
-0.7956212759,
-0.1165647432,
-0.0648371056,
-0.4028381407,
0.7129212022,
-0.3850562871,
-0.2687541246,
0.4365020692,
-0.4300596118,
-0.7003127337,
0.1199565902,
0.0722210258,
-0.5056304336,
0.5917490125,
0.1115767434,
0.1871430725,
-0.5777090192,
0.1164815724,
0.0429693162,
-0.4508690834,
0.5358229876,
-0.6579360366,
0.2545367479,
0.3203307092,
-0.105340682,
0.1928560138,
-0.4962280989,
0.3644961119,
-0.2760427296,
-0.4155379236,
-0.1466739476,
0.0879502147,
0.1072527394,
-0.4456015825,
-0.1307138652,
-0.5406323075,
0.1103444472,
-0.811467886,
0.4836901128,
0.8228429556,
-0.1398862749,
0.3279138505,
-0.1953301877,
0.6878687143,
-0.2470616847,
-0.0840372518,
0.1616388559,
-0.5532072186,
-0.97434026,
-0.1610481292,
0.8620517254,
0.4627383947,
-0.5717897415,
0.1509544998,
-0.1143384352,
-0.0905122533,
-0.594288826,
-0.0355167948,
0.4605201483,
0.6959269643,
0.2662342489,
-0.4781545103,
-0.7787279487,
-0.8937969208,
-0.5515578389,
0.026981188,
-0.0841819867,
0.1743065417,
-0.0675174892,
0.1740452945,
1.0210051537,
-0.3878758848,
-0.2476691902,
-0.3044400513,
0.1496521086,
0.3753191829,
0.5008763671,
-0.2096407115,
-0.8150057197,
-0.5453326106,
-0.4138208926,
0.0197449662,
-0.3041436076,
0.3262885213,
0.5974119902,
0.4016757309,
0.7201358676,
-0.496178627,
0.5964987874,
0.1521498859,
-0.4087324142,
0.4043497443,
-0.1776744425,
-0.1838451922,
-0.8561837077,
-0.3351280689,
-0.1411722749,
-0.2818707228,
-0.958635211,
-0.5366776586,
-0.0247733742,
-0.2528829575,
-0.5481203198,
0.6791542172,
-0.6920577884,
-0.0011361934,
-0.3469627798,
-0.1312075406,
-0.2280976921,
0.0605022945,
0.2572571933,
0.9821796417,
0.5669623017,
-0.8029056191,
0.0079358881,
0.1050362289,
-0.3158743083,
0.2025883645,
-0.7028010488,
0.3178716302,
-0.2950684726,
0.1649671644,
-0.6547154784,
-0.112157397,
0.2195520252,
-0.5207452178,
0.8091323376,
-0.220181331,
-0.306676507,
-0.2461142689,
-0.2028044909,
0.3306639493,
0.7363607883,
-0.3202080131,
0.5876230597,
0.0605109707,
-0.1886371076,
-0.3850209117,
-0.7358108163,
0.2630311549,
-0.6097047925,
-0.5041612983,
0.6805292368,
-0.2373738885,
-0.1474214047,
0.0657917261,
-0.2395977974,
0.1143913418,
0.0303597227,
0.3264517486,
0.0096542668,
-0.4901925027,
0.2490085512,
-0.3252520263,
-0.5375342965,
-0.2452236861,
-0.0927489698,
0.528902173,
-0.3207232952,
-0.1730082333,
-0.6285870671,
0.1403874457,
0.0661114305,
-0.0628886744,
0.2795158327,
0.5894855261,
-0.1296967566,
-0.1532198191,
-0.9465616345,
-0.5990790129,
-0.5299136639,
0.0749268904,
-0.4614586234,
-1.0228049755,
0.6194568276,
-0.2571371496,
-0.3932849765,
0.321675241,
0.4153371453,
0.0229588337,
0.7659364939,
0.7987697124,
-0.2098150849,
0.4891699255,
-0.145299986,
0.0306207165,
-0.9714574218,
-0.2890605032,
-0.6094735861,
-0.443041563,
-0.6558128595,
-0.491520226,
0.4864020348,
0.0455446057,
-0.2411557138,
0.0488756485,
-0.5098035932,
0.5758183599,
0.6257423162,
-0.0199321248,
0.3246076703,
0.1924560368,
0.0828973502,
-0.2233863026,
-0.9508196712,
-0.2178681195,
0.6808875799,
0.4092454612,
1.1743297577,
0.0598440506,
0.6360098124,
0.145888254,
0.2435563505,
-1.0320110321,
0.5736159682,
-0.2587525249,
-0.4486398995,
-0.42605564,
-0.423971653,
-0.9681552052,
-0.0305278879,
-0.0130972099,
-0.7668931484,
0.1603585333,
0.3049947917,
-0.4517523348,
0.14568156,
-0.472992301,
0.2461708188,
-0.2544651628,
-0.0769067705,
-0.170804888,
-0.7410753369,
0.0945584029,
0.394755125,
-0.1624339521,
-0.5882214308,
-0.3605451882,
0.7671561241,
-0.5757315159,
0.883423388,
-0.1005581617,
0.0524454601,
0.2653766572,
-0.1271770746,
0.6022006273,
0.1680895686,
-0.4806545973,
0.3235793114,
-0.5039121509,
0.1779200882,
-0.5615693331,
0.672533989,
-0.6235352755,
-0.8264398575,
-0.4581329525,
-0.6793729663,
-0.4344594181,
-0.073601,
0.5543774962,
0.8865882754,
0.0061601503,
0.126047954,
0.9511063099,
-0.0139604518,
0.5957645774,
0.949462831,
0.2241602689,
-0.5810033679,
0.7838014364,
0.2754624486,
0.182999894,
0.236585021,
0.4930867255,
-0.6377361417,
-0.9435801506,
-0.3979765475,
0.2656832635,
-0.5401890278,
-0.7728963494,
-0.1751802415,
-0.3121168017,
-0.4622091353,
-0.1478235424,
-0.3786197603,
-0.5073050857,
-0.6593691111,
-0.0016995518,
1.0369019508,
0.6191142201,
-0.3598395288,
0.2879888713,
-0.3742311597,
0.2876245677,
0.0677012652,
0.6836521626,
-0.2368011475,
-1.0140662193,
0.0022899352,
-0.1248072237,
0.0746629611,
-0.6470737457,
0.557523489,
0.8348402381,
0.3176114857,
0.2549721003,
0.2243741006,
1.1570951939,
-0.7547342181,
0.6237229109,
0.1814897209,
-0.9239450693,
0.4265504181,
-0.0419103727,
0.5132066011,
0.7147512436,
-0.1065789908,
-0.5250801444,
-0.2747940719,
-0.5322749019,
-0.9505272508,
0.7280581594,
0.0734125078,
0.3617698848,
0.1872651279,
0.6812488437,
0.0479887463,
0.1691677272,
-0.3246726692,
-0.6870833635,
0.0752823129,
0.1544854045,
-0.296816349,
-0.3824252486,
0.0706968531,
-0.4736902714,
0.8098729849,
-0.0311339553,
0.1622282565,
0.2334550023,
0.1782156974,
-0.4163380861,
0.3551087379,
0.8024512529,
0.3081364036,
-0.1817607433,
0.3027252257,
0.7151817679,
-0.2463838756,
0.1645549238,
0.0324190669,
-0.2719756961,
0.1568854749,
0.1881297678,
1.0862026215,
0.2549511194,
-0.4209447205,
-0.024006756,
-0.1702808291,
-0.1733087748,
-0.5404523015,
0.0611726567,
0.1537036598,
0.0488212071,
0.4010579288,
0.1360267997,
0.1928281039,
-0.4280727506,
0.2671395838,
0.5426179171,
-0.5800209641,
-0.1238822713,
0.7168068886,
0.1106132492,
-0.7037783861,
0.8256789446,
-0.0150083676,
-0.5949232578,
0.8220478892,
0.8811560273,
1.1191519499,
-0.5183546543,
-0.0938930959,
0.1035718471,
0.2413977683,
-0.0501161292,
0.4435881078,
0.0820419788,
-0.6808187366,
-0.5519224405,
-0.7238423228,
-0.5297010541,
0.2195192277,
-0.626908958,
0.5428013802,
-0.202504918,
-0.3164452314,
-0.077804774,
-0.0169949066,
-0.6190085411,
0.1654614657,
0.3413897753,
1.134298563,
-0.5434432626,
0.8694769144,
0.6824935079,
0.0275571607,
-1.087015748,
0.0291937366,
0.0816200674,
-0.7899227738,
0.7412558794,
0.067511186,
-0.4681937993,
0.4024094045,
-0.3656182587,
-1.2418866158,
0.9523245096,
0.5713954568,
-0.4700812399,
0.452445358,
0.2498267293,
0.4473649561,
-0.3545482755,
0.0685040206,
0.5053137541,
0.5909800529,
0.4314218462,
-1.2400401831,
-0.0586326793,
-0.0065446519,
0.2871928811,
0.3671651185,
-0.5300619602,
0.7101880312,
-0.3488205969,
-0.4490741491,
0.1268137991,
0.8104785681,
-0.0701415166,
0.5972670317,
0.4915436804,
0.4361009598,
0.5073617101,
-0.1416326612,
0.8052642941,
-0.1961786598,
0.0889183432,
1.1281799078,
-0.1833130568,
0.8709759116,
0.5016456246,
-0.0097915512,
0.1047353745,
0.7676487565,
0.1745450497,
0.5569941998,
0.6565532684,
-0.4105661213,
-0.2468248904,
-0.5267695189,
-0.4628668427,
0.4963264763,
0.639239192,
0.1844500601,
-0.0713077039,
0.1940219104,
0.0197482575,
0.0520024486,
-0.6616550684,
0.8927432299,
0.3913913369,
-0.5664658546,
0.9148360491,
0.1276762784,
0.8618536592,
-0.5247610807,
0.2007539123,
-0.312230736,
0.003255944,
-0.231962353,
-0.3451298177,
0.4168158472,
-0.1512420923,
-0.1632219553,
-0.3415689468,
1.0808581114,
-0.6397771239,
-0.4157468379,
-0.0637761727,
0.452840507,
0.3439128995,
0.0496273488,
-0.625235498,
0.3547457457,
-0.1358072013,
-0.2254272997,
0.1622074246,
0.1508621126,
0.0293177068,
0.941198945,
0.4809682071,
0.3101256788,
0.0325248688,
0.1870138496,
0.8460876942,
-0.8163970113,
-0.3066161573,
-0.8532207012,
0.4182726443,
0.2722257078,
-0.2350490689,
0.7424408793,
0.5998786688,
0.456214726,
-0.1726181805,
0.5181664824,
-0.0324387476,
0.6759173274,
-0.8787809014,
0.4672376513,
-0.4349067509,
0.3243338466,
0.1170458421,
-0.8122079968,
-0.5020874143,
0.273571372,
-0.2619257867,
-0.0224213302,
0.4723902047,
1.1781115532,
0.0697175413,
-0.1543297619,
0.6527355909,
0.0291693639,
-0.2250445932,
0.1243882328,
0.9057026505,
-0.3745542765,
0.257444948,
-0.1622478962,
0.1616020948,
-0.4166640639,
-1.025323391,
-0.7066537738,
-0.5280023813,
-0.6890746951,
-0.2152609378,
0.4153292477,
1.0242730379,
0.7201103568,
-0.8198086619,
-0.3615907431,
-0.053940475,
0.3145182729,
-0.129752636,
-0.1714919508,
0.2350351214,
-0.4639863372,
-0.51486063,
0.9080887437,
0.1191299856,
0.1382650733,
0.1113048792,
-0.2783062458,
0.0566756688,
0.1311600804,
0.3850430548,
0.5344768167,
-1.0236549377,
-0.3255208433,
-0.0583892204,
0.3838057518,
0.160366267,
1.1676508188,
-0.9214615226,
0.3257067502,
0.1983477622,
0.2897727787,
0.5913378596,
0.2516839206,
0.731477499,
-0.8882862926,
0.0785522982,
0.5616552234,
0.0505045392,
0.3947171867,
-0.320504576,
0.5842365026,
0.0164411161,
-0.4770973623,
-0.8258841038,
0.2780161202,
-0.7670616508,
0.0080527533,
1.2046657801,
0.4252489805,
0.0131157571,
-0.4172798693,
-0.0121314572,
0.2964659035,
-0.7258507013,
0.4139251709,
0.1870889813,
-0.633928597,
-0.3684121668,
-0.5555551052,
0.9782001376,
0.6369909048,
-0.3166831136,
0.059099663,
0.3670687079,
0.4483541846,
-0.1020555571,
0.6136353612,
0.2276159078,
0.0916661844,
-0.2488587499,
0.1200513393,
-0.1798382252,
-0.2099012434,
-0.8958043456,
-0.0857628584,
0.5392172337,
-0.0286622047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14695v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14695v1 | Depth $F_1$: Improving Evaluation of Cross-Domain Text Classification by Measuring Semantic Generalizability | 2024-06-20T19:35:17 | 2024-06-20T19:35:17 | Parker Seegmiller, Joseph Gatto, Sarah Masud Preum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent evaluations of cross-domain text classification models aim to measure
the ability of a model to obtain domain-invariant performance in a target
domain given labeled samples in a source domain. The primary strategy for this
evaluation relies on assumed differences between source domain samples and
target domain samples in benchmark datasets. This evaluation strategy fails to
account for the similarity between source and target domains, and may mask when
models fail to transfer learning to specific target samples which are highly
dissimilar from the source domain. We introduce Depth $F_1$, a novel
cross-domain text classification performance metric. Designed to be
complementary to existing classification metrics such as $F_1$, Depth $F_1$
measures how well a model performs on target samples which are dissimilar from
the source domain. We motivate this metric using standard cross-domain text
classification datasets and benchmark several recent cross-domain text
classification models, with the goal of enabling in-depth evaluation of the
semantic generalizability of cross-domain text classification models. | [
-0.4545004368,
-0.7363836169,
0.355707109,
0.2743334472,
-0.3407861292,
0.3328892589,
-0.0504004695,
-0.6256193519,
-0.1750665009,
0.2956876755,
-0.5658706427,
-0.9448228478,
-1.0472648144,
0.0598980002,
-0.8243933916,
0.8843878508,
-0.3108980656,
-0.1250593513,
-0.7440040708,
-0.3388511539,
-0.175052464,
-0.4248824418,
-0.4416202605,
-0.2290570289,
0.3851708174,
0.2518918216,
0.7445634007,
0.3646759093,
0.7943974733,
0.3180881739,
0.2055183649,
-0.1446912438,
-0.5459529161,
-0.2044699788,
-0.5164290071,
-0.1977198571,
-0.4687544703,
0.0956553966,
0.9897139072,
0.9966033101,
0.3594803512,
-0.0627316311,
0.1016964465,
0.7180235982,
-0.802809,
-0.1878405958,
-0.4513746202,
0.314286083,
-0.1086784378,
-0.2846271992,
-0.23170425,
-0.1337781698,
0.9507862926,
-0.9041916728,
0.7609200478,
-0.1627711952,
0.8348708749,
0.2276248932,
-0.1766389459,
-0.2742577493,
-0.7969979048,
0.9224104881,
-0.4668963253,
0.8159613609,
0.3463427722,
0.5053440332,
0.4310784936,
-0.8534907699,
-0.4201441407,
0.2365719974,
-0.2268716693,
-0.1549357027,
-0.3992929757,
-0.1399351209,
-0.0832286701,
0.7360015512,
-0.734852612,
-0.1419328898,
-0.2228546143,
-0.2290436625,
0.7358587384,
0.164110899,
0.3169601858,
0.5142657757,
-0.6433519721,
-0.1700997204,
-0.3270083368,
0.216030553,
0.2509728074,
0.2624171376,
-0.0246536583,
0.0373042896,
-0.4108116627,
0.5522458553,
-0.1955358833,
-0.2046255022,
0.311576128,
-0.4155640602,
-0.3281462789,
-0.0251537282,
0.5583174229,
0.2536872327,
0.1806279719,
-0.6150536537,
-0.1579899341,
0.0182911921,
0.4566065371,
-1.0798835754,
-0.0677871555,
0.0484169312,
-0.5822203755,
-0.2803494632,
0.3990300894,
-0.5693671107,
-0.12617594,
-0.017736027,
0.6808333397,
-0.5489398837,
-0.2947968245,
0.3998671472,
-0.3024373651,
0.2106253356,
0.4006620049,
-0.949542284,
0.8482319713,
1.0031204224,
0.9848575592,
-0.7402134538,
-0.5032967925,
-0.0654808879,
-0.1683299541,
-0.2627652884,
0.7485492229,
-0.6904098392,
-0.527744174,
0.0785499811,
-0.0033499994,
-0.0175917409,
-0.5017960668,
0.5900833011,
-0.5031237602,
0.2109391689,
0.006348554,
-0.7111689448,
-0.462505877,
0.4002635479,
-0.739948988,
0.7428950667,
0.7089858651,
-0.7489777803,
0.9037540555,
-0.4043171704,
-0.520994246,
-0.0627056509,
0.0994918123,
-0.3650375307,
0.1458823532,
0.0299131554,
0.495293498,
-0.543713212,
-0.0980814397,
-0.2629040778,
-0.5848382711,
0.0416569002,
-0.279869616,
0.4911291897,
0.0643302277,
-0.0546926484,
-0.0073640333,
-0.8234742284,
0.1469044536,
0.1062491611,
-0.2297548354,
-0.8896616101,
-0.0275337715,
-0.0839912668,
-0.1132892668,
0.030352151,
-0.5575995445,
0.0991237834,
-0.7282063365,
0.0230195746,
0.2567862272,
-0.1445683092,
0.8553636074,
-0.2732497156,
0.6780990362,
0.1192041263,
0.1101892516,
-0.1185632125,
-0.3338285089,
-0.4723778963,
-0.3119136393,
0.7626590133,
0.515404582,
-0.3745231628,
0.2944471836,
-0.499073863,
-0.7468083501,
-0.4431762099,
0.2302253693,
0.5225413442,
0.3156661093,
0.5921784639,
-0.6761803031,
-0.069638215,
-0.7753594518,
-0.5860637426,
0.174747169,
-0.0453102849,
0.1510630399,
0.3753687143,
-0.3602909148,
0.8265891671,
-0.361851573,
-0.2715971172,
-0.1368149221,
0.3185015321,
-0.1887130737,
0.5269773006,
0.7314946055,
-0.8601902723,
-0.4443111122,
0.1864021868,
-0.6865244508,
0.15982306,
0.1170755848,
-0.339397192,
0.1089597195,
0.0956070796,
-0.2356737256,
0.6388027668,
0.4763610363,
-0.6204800606,
0.1479321271,
0.1844597161,
0.2707613111,
-0.4281671047,
0.0246509556,
0.1544772685,
-0.0391405188,
-0.7150022388,
-0.0202814024,
0.1126424298,
0.2313426733,
-0.472631216,
0.8393298388,
-0.2316610217,
-0.1721920371,
-0.0897263065,
0.2299409658,
0.3454690576,
0.2806020975,
0.0498771518,
0.4340515733,
0.5912081003,
-0.9940795898,
0.2399647385,
0.4012496173,
-0.4213314652,
0.699023962,
-0.5880960226,
0.1025146097,
0.2037037462,
0.0672186539,
-1.1782593727,
0.139204368,
0.0741280243,
-0.6636068225,
0.3572767675,
0.0224580355,
-0.0599756129,
-0.1077368632,
-0.2503995299,
0.8023600578,
0.0720769316,
-0.5557024479,
0.4907843471,
0.1619215608,
-0.0814932659,
-0.7055749297,
-0.9292291999,
-0.2756719589,
-0.0142347487,
-1.0424085855,
0.8069654703,
0.0651179776,
-0.2048937976,
0.1563289165,
-0.4703356326,
-0.4062899053,
0.2769564092,
0.1292444468,
-0.0026630284,
-0.4849933982,
0.2066494524,
0.6200928092,
-0.0226481948,
0.4573134184,
-0.3762263656,
0.1751568913,
0.0254582614,
-0.3920409977,
-0.1737358421,
0.2667895257,
0.2011402249,
-0.2260351032,
0.4544080794,
0.3520020545,
-0.5317150354,
-0.7323753238,
-0.2142323107,
0.0493646041,
-0.3949261904,
0.3209157884,
-0.6899081469,
-1.0068436861,
0.4120299518,
-0.2308594584,
-0.1640338749,
0.687964499,
0.0067432346,
0.4303590655,
0.8955173492,
0.9632205367,
0.0474989004,
0.2132588029,
-0.5251910686,
-0.1074692085,
-0.3638315201,
-0.2026214898,
-0.71865201,
-0.4472584128,
-0.3311171234,
-0.4278689325,
-0.1958913356,
0.1129356995,
-0.0231766626,
0.1564807594,
-0.5279273391,
0.5048132539,
0.3415336013,
0.0393415056,
0.560113132,
0.2928647399,
-0.1770656854,
-0.1280047596,
-0.5490599275,
-0.4179282486,
1.0666171312,
0.7034088373,
0.5093697906,
-0.0939138681,
0.6970784068,
0.4872735739,
0.4981890023,
-0.8190200925,
0.2523266971,
-0.5463931561,
-0.431432873,
-0.6745896339,
-0.5013273954,
-0.7068216205,
0.2497362345,
-0.1363384277,
-0.249678582,
0.3161005676,
-0.2661038339,
-0.0872719511,
0.2763913274,
-0.373547405,
1.2331473827,
-0.179374665,
-0.2960891128,
-0.1607775688,
-0.4254151881,
0.2317235917,
-0.260381043,
0.0716559738,
-0.0735867247,
-0.3951627612,
0.8545438647,
-0.2704238296,
0.355047971,
-0.3792877793,
-0.3882296383,
0.3254798949,
0.2837622464,
0.1022590399,
0.058950115,
-0.0088177826,
0.5845355988,
0.0765344352,
-0.4357597828,
-0.8217333555,
0.6689055562,
-0.7225475311,
-0.281249702,
-0.2050792724,
-0.2776392698,
-0.5771194696,
0.2714451849,
0.4385187626,
0.3910401464,
-0.8743057251,
0.1939056516,
0.6544098258,
-0.2775422931,
0.1184593812,
0.5303121209,
-0.3365086913,
-0.3595153391,
0.9637405872,
-0.0180288777,
0.2918206751,
0.9512322545,
0.1611379534,
-0.3931146562,
-0.7976166606,
-0.3366615176,
-0.1627422869,
-0.7942386866,
-0.3189625144,
-0.7021927834,
-0.3546724319,
-0.2660932541,
-0.3648279309,
-0.1543858945,
-0.6364678144,
-0.1134577841,
-0.1431474388,
0.18264395,
0.6925261021,
0.1198467463,
0.297236532,
-0.8816797137,
0.221990183,
0.283788234,
0.8374487758,
-0.0970622003,
-0.7597403526,
-0.2538927794,
-0.2640682757,
-0.2108115256,
-0.5368158817,
0.1789499521,
0.2872372866,
0.5936979055,
0.2115652263,
-0.0215422679,
0.2089681476,
-0.2273929864,
0.5758820772,
0.0497915298,
-1.4361313581,
0.66347754,
-0.0204874892,
0.3362562954,
0.7676106691,
0.7754842043,
-0.2254362702,
-0.506732285,
-0.5690966845,
-0.7185917497,
0.6629679799,
-0.0027365384,
0.2429073602,
0.2756871581,
0.229869619,
0.739993453,
0.1020362601,
-0.1855391264,
-0.2046962082,
-0.4968716204,
-0.1052599326,
-0.1807652712,
-0.137364924,
0.1681351215,
-0.4999696314,
0.451756835,
-0.1506514698,
0.1822403669,
0.6440811753,
-0.2993278205,
-0.2021986693,
0.108992815,
0.5206739902,
0.9537643194,
-0.3085161746,
0.0526682921,
0.351715982,
-0.6448951364,
0.1795926243,
0.1580908149,
-0.1310936064,
0.2539965212,
0.6560155749,
0.6300762296,
0.5232357979,
-0.3574521244,
0.7692568302,
-0.2272614539,
-0.6418543458,
0.2216848135,
0.2244814336,
-0.3650791347,
0.1178800017,
0.382304728,
-0.0470545702,
0.501516521,
-0.3262135684,
0.3836846352,
0.2962276638,
-0.5395010114,
-0.1759395599,
0.4570059776,
0.3157572448,
-0.3068443537,
0.3067801297,
-0.0163090136,
-0.4849102795,
0.5779617429,
0.2798542082,
1.2721998692,
-0.1948487163,
0.3614963293,
0.497613728,
0.2753925025,
0.1448140442,
0.0971968025,
-0.194016397,
-0.8070445061,
-0.220856294,
-0.7207740545,
-0.6640635133,
-0.1252907962,
-0.576040864,
0.1167395487,
-0.8154890537,
0.0417718031,
0.1610404402,
0.1691447645,
-0.8096349835,
0.6460989118,
-0.1531033069,
1.4547460079,
-0.5565103292,
0.7077814937,
0.6018007994,
-0.2748996317,
-0.2981105447,
0.0919357091,
-0.2509649694,
-0.361856401,
0.625153482,
0.2852160037,
-0.3753950894,
-0.2507193089,
-0.5866333842,
-0.572126627,
1.2101541758,
0.0317580327,
-0.4511764944,
0.1797254831,
0.5738394856,
0.7126526237,
-0.782186985,
-0.125943318,
0.7585472465,
0.5440476537,
-0.2385929972,
-0.8493422866,
0.3145982623,
-0.2955316901,
0.0376926847,
0.181095466,
-0.3903899491,
0.7399659753,
-0.0500384681,
-0.5240596533,
0.0495782271,
0.781901598,
-0.2275844812,
0.8629375696,
0.5682379603,
0.5554588437,
0.6439307928,
-0.4091998935,
1.0843541622,
-0.0669339299,
0.4563633502,
0.8880872726,
-0.2282392979,
0.7297025323,
0.0325022899,
-0.3732796609,
0.5060087442,
0.1813670248,
-0.0670750365,
0.6189440489,
0.3579117656,
-0.1980380863,
-0.0864525288,
0.2982984185,
-0.4981684387,
0.4452869296,
0.3613283634,
-0.549554646,
-0.2813405991,
-0.0784229934,
-0.2720146477,
0.3636624217,
-0.1034863517,
0.7877158523,
-0.1017882377,
-0.5364031196,
0.7183403373,
0.1537992805,
0.7919527292,
-0.6143434644,
0.0593037084,
-0.3397304714,
0.3907728195,
-0.2531988621,
-0.8419740796,
0.6494445801,
-0.0882558972,
-0.4747963548,
-0.0702435076,
0.9721796513,
-0.2706098258,
-0.4959182739,
0.7731580734,
0.4329752922,
-0.0420168117,
-0.4150502384,
-0.6455011964,
0.2234098017,
-0.3562861383,
-0.0565558635,
0.2827222943,
0.9395616055,
0.3047479689,
0.4152192175,
0.319950521,
-0.3322970271,
-0.0150421839,
-0.045758754,
0.7147160172,
-0.7769048214,
-0.2506670654,
-0.6129530668,
0.3391110003,
-0.0522953495,
-0.8288816214,
0.6211400628,
0.6914483905,
1.3479437828,
-0.0741920546,
0.9381512403,
0.1750921309,
0.7756796479,
-0.3898290992,
0.7321369648,
-0.8048086762,
0.1323863417,
-0.4947978556,
-0.9981114864,
-0.2758827209,
0.4426605403,
-0.2242719382,
0.1133453473,
0.8074525595,
0.462333411,
-0.3128631413,
0.1838610619,
0.4899712503,
-0.2025386393,
0.0341457948,
0.6747949719,
0.8032220602,
-0.8026310205,
0.5141956806,
-0.5098454356,
-0.3323657513,
0.0737058148,
-0.6584615707,
-0.9505592585,
-0.557109952,
-0.3809013069,
-0.2474812418,
0.1202770993,
0.2089986652,
0.7329093814,
-0.9274947047,
0.0519400276,
-0.0841481313,
0.2573466301,
-0.2542208135,
-0.3120034933,
0.1597374082,
-0.3278444707,
-0.6912096143,
0.2784899771,
0.2270942479,
0.0503455661,
-0.4703069925,
-0.31236884,
0.0122866193,
0.192027986,
0.6775637269,
0.1746133715,
-0.5524311662,
-0.1381118149,
-0.078290537,
-0.2652561963,
-0.1274646223,
0.9044481516,
-0.65386796,
0.2232061774,
0.7845832705,
1.0079603195,
0.3713843226,
-0.0361248851,
0.5414258838,
-0.839040041,
-0.0590711385,
0.1626866758,
-0.0566692278,
0.3649411201,
-0.3396672606,
0.8534311056,
0.2183431685,
-0.3462022543,
-0.5835863352,
-0.1179446727,
-0.8961161971,
-0.5032283664,
0.8689118624,
-0.3729799688,
0.0508290939,
0.0896271318,
0.0756538287,
-0.005202061,
-0.0739935413,
0.4584703147,
1.028911829,
0.3140538335,
0.1387197822,
-0.3064498901,
0.645435214,
0.2838924527,
-0.8641592264,
-0.1507984102,
0.1371540129,
0.4002608657,
0.3114604056,
0.5406368375,
-0.2995636165,
0.2775853276,
0.2046308815,
-0.2590766549,
0.0976026207,
-0.7237409353,
-0.2871203125,
0.2858822346,
-0.3189376891,
-0.0009273691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14686v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14686v1 | A Contrastive Learning Approach to Mitigate Bias in Speech Models | 2024-06-20T19:20:00 | 2024-06-20T19:20:00 | Alkis Koudounas, Flavio Giobergia, Eliana Pastor, Elena Baralis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Speech models may be affected by performance imbalance in different
population subgroups, raising concerns about fair treatment across these
groups. Prior attempts to mitigate unfairness either focus on user-defined
subgroups, potentially overlooking other affected subgroups, or do not
explicitly improve the internal representation at the subgroup level. This
paper proposes the first adoption of contrastive learning to mitigate speech
model bias in underperforming subgroups. We employ a three-level learning
technique that guides the model in focusing on different scopes for the
contrastive loss, i.e., task, subgroup, and the errors within subgroups. The
experiments on two spoken language understanding datasets and two languages
demonstrate that our approach improves internal subgroup representations, thus
reducing model bias and enhancing performance. | [
-0.3472152948,
-0.3065893054,
0.079567723,
-0.0083326744,
-0.1878452152,
0.0408015177,
0.0661411807,
-0.2400531173,
-0.2564811409,
0.4044173956,
-0.535620451,
-0.3307448924,
-0.6484724283,
-0.4037046731,
-0.1372715384,
0.9291855097,
0.3202360868,
0.8445875049,
-0.208833009,
-0.3059915304,
-0.4416414499,
-0.5327755809,
-0.9733052254,
-0.9065468907,
0.2747737169,
0.3445273936,
0.2535896897,
0.466763109,
0.2416893393,
0.1471764147,
-0.3945902884,
-0.2072838396,
-0.8380775452,
-0.1482179612,
-0.1952830255,
-1.0032017231,
-0.0216569882,
0.2524001002,
0.7950220704,
1.072904706,
-0.4577305317,
-0.2273863405,
0.469881624,
0.7739545107,
-0.8137233853,
0.1380958855,
-0.7732689381,
0.4161178172,
-0.2761152685,
0.0646599233,
-0.309443444,
-0.3159164786,
0.2311367542,
-0.5928083658,
0.5456579328,
-0.1715359539,
0.3820207715,
0.2872421145,
-0.3978822827,
0.015947504,
-0.3664450943,
0.9279562831,
-0.8117628694,
0.2114114314,
0.5397347212,
0.4631904364,
0.2146001756,
-0.3793968856,
-0.4114089012,
0.0881700516,
-0.2574094832,
0.2893618643,
-0.2854199708,
0.1807702482,
0.1704746634,
0.3987894058,
-0.4423663318,
0.5190222263,
-0.5796493292,
-0.3416820765,
0.2220154107,
0.1335575581,
0.096006833,
0.0205598846,
-0.1646781117,
0.0574653223,
-0.7681821585,
0.0992421731,
0.4205463231,
0.6752140522,
-0.1576701999,
0.4158097208,
-0.1164592803,
0.3416177034,
0.1748714447,
0.0768591389,
0.4924511313,
-0.102022849,
-0.3523547053,
0.1569753438,
0.0494098663,
0.3803311288,
0.2663366199,
-0.0741866753,
-0.1847013086,
0.3902140856,
0.0413248464,
-0.5937435031,
-0.1665734947,
-0.1339570582,
-0.7607139945,
-0.2704053223,
-0.1566589326,
-0.8551285267,
-0.7441563606,
-0.4149417281,
0.4597351253,
-0.2401966304,
-0.1846410036,
-0.089826405,
-0.0978105515,
0.1047850177,
0.1925375164,
-1.0479552746,
0.7752150893,
0.5529458523,
0.7200484872,
-0.0872810036,
-0.0216335543,
-0.725943327,
0.3280638158,
-0.1171643734,
0.4089823067,
-0.6616261601,
-0.5105509162,
-0.0087921042,
-0.4424993396,
-0.13525787,
-0.9270424843,
0.3486066163,
-0.1953816861,
0.4983095229,
-0.1683222353,
-0.7344785333,
-0.4906915426,
-0.227014482,
-0.6062313914,
0.4851347804,
0.2415720075,
-0.8610540032,
0.6271545887,
-0.5334726572,
-0.3782852292,
-0.1415029913,
-0.3733671606,
-0.4372603595,
0.2633047402,
0.6365930438,
0.1704536974,
0.0506756641,
-0.1858092248,
-0.0058627198,
-0.5858981609,
-0.1657565683,
-0.2024980336,
0.8143060207,
0.1883671135,
-0.233082816,
0.1836458594,
-0.4225952327,
-0.1224723086,
-0.0360297523,
-0.043450322,
-0.5109536648,
0.0618827306,
-0.1622608602,
0.1550004333,
-0.2905664444,
-0.2992574573,
-0.3014904559,
-0.6933203936,
0.2767642736,
0.9409689903,
-0.0801398456,
0.7292667627,
-0.5618497133,
0.5320309997,
0.4780580103,
0.056689132,
-0.1270755976,
-0.1954274774,
-0.8415699005,
-0.2472664714,
0.2722014785,
0.5665445924,
-0.7377470136,
-0.129865706,
0.0866947323,
-0.2903010249,
-0.7937167287,
0.2131625712,
0.6989620328,
0.6997341514,
0.5312743187,
-0.3387950063,
-0.4503646493,
-1.0746891499,
-0.4983881712,
0.0786640346,
-0.3099682927,
0.3987800479,
0.258751452,
-0.1511096209,
0.5553785563,
-0.2894440293,
-0.5621845722,
-0.4254008234,
0.3493672013,
0.0129765291,
0.6764561534,
0.5618132353,
-0.828489244,
-0.3910267949,
-0.1022932082,
-0.3587355316,
-0.3422885537,
0.3056589663,
0.0993291736,
0.0377385393,
0.6177464724,
0.0388655588,
0.4363510907,
0.6535823345,
-0.0489459857,
-0.1120087132,
0.1221416146,
-0.0497077107,
-0.8175187707,
-0.2421194464,
0.3712675571,
-0.1742259413,
-0.733830452,
-0.2798785865,
-0.0300555825,
-0.0809903219,
-0.5921717286,
0.4895405173,
-0.1446971595,
0.0755864158,
-0.2702071071,
0.2448509336,
-0.1749375761,
0.4988636672,
-0.1711261272,
0.8374593854,
0.6573557854,
-0.7192772627,
-0.3334566355,
-0.0475184321,
-0.3235450089,
0.9215017557,
-0.5326429009,
0.0713595524,
-0.7258039713,
0.2617359161,
-0.8221808672,
-0.1303964555,
0.3401510417,
-0.4346371293,
0.3510581553,
-0.0338682942,
0.2852964103,
-0.104960449,
-0.1188633367,
0.5348438025,
0.5139451027,
-0.6722852588,
0.5905928016,
0.7318947911,
-0.2776312828,
-0.7158943415,
-0.8899818659,
-0.5550000072,
-0.5302641392,
-0.3114334643,
0.6788823009,
0.1261596829,
-0.5265458822,
-0.0708062798,
-0.4231444001,
-0.1365253925,
-0.0265363995,
-0.0180233624,
-0.219140321,
0.1210148707,
0.3898302019,
-0.1714420617,
-0.1054811627,
-0.2293994874,
-0.0543480888,
0.6020890474,
0.033484228,
-0.2707613111,
-0.7430274487,
0.4524702132,
0.0540283807,
-0.1619589031,
0.6387415528,
0.4145278931,
-0.5418794155,
-0.3632260263,
-0.5900530219,
-0.4148168266,
-0.4095808268,
0.4524691105,
-0.1956827044,
-0.823626101,
0.5884991884,
0.0106312456,
-0.0618305542,
0.4433504343,
0.2805930674,
-0.0622491054,
1.1762410402,
0.840955317,
-0.4707212746,
0.7455926538,
-0.0815642923,
0.0509998687,
-0.813007772,
-0.3919703066,
-0.7585934997,
-0.177997753,
-0.5889017582,
-0.6585831046,
0.4278509021,
0.0359569974,
-0.2197708935,
-0.352838099,
-0.1164771616,
0.6366739869,
0.695825696,
0.5402421951,
0.0456752852,
0.101175271,
-0.27153337,
-0.3644142747,
-0.7498627305,
-0.2470656335,
0.9721243382,
0.3981269002,
1.0047570467,
0.1571848541,
0.7367572188,
0.3880589902,
0.4439860284,
-0.4492750764,
0.1078848764,
-0.4404750466,
-0.5091106892,
-0.3645648658,
-0.789829433,
-0.7610846758,
0.774692595,
-0.071060665,
-0.7225115299,
0.3566666245,
0.4178518355,
-0.1293384433,
0.2222229391,
-0.7182084322,
0.5948835611,
0.1261294186,
-0.2207070142,
-0.636616528,
-0.6177177429,
0.4702403545,
-0.0275920182,
0.3883122504,
-0.0664606914,
0.1988278478,
0.8746571541,
-0.1551867574,
0.961596787,
-0.6314434409,
0.2258024514,
-0.0675126389,
-0.1111617684,
0.2357698232,
-0.2151838839,
-0.4401056767,
0.0441820547,
-0.598238349,
-0.729324162,
-0.6112520099,
0.4235178828,
-0.6364617944,
-0.5168588758,
-0.2126102149,
-0.5137485862,
-0.441267103,
0.0132748252,
0.2295327336,
0.2309437096,
-0.328173399,
0.2289135307,
0.7291936278,
-0.0942529738,
0.2514995933,
0.4408529699,
0.0132877612,
-0.4056264758,
0.6349010468,
0.0206874926,
0.5571770072,
0.102707766,
0.2922824621,
-0.2861286104,
-0.6097018719,
0.2640390396,
0.1388840526,
-1.0954316854,
-0.1131951809,
-0.3241415024,
-0.0655856133,
-0.4105142355,
0.0900821239,
0.0051801247,
-0.347625792,
-0.3696732819,
-0.1198253036,
-0.3806910813,
0.7614445686,
-0.3375881016,
0.7147241235,
-0.2678335309,
0.4202530086,
0.5787433982,
0.3520362079,
0.206006065,
-0.6426187754,
-0.2048976123,
0.1803985983,
-0.395632416,
-0.7212860584,
0.3906528652,
0.4366391003,
1.3104652166,
0.3109167516,
-0.2259601653,
0.5071109533,
-0.3437301219,
0.6738131642,
0.3620917499,
-1.433790803,
0.6680905223,
-0.0647679493,
0.4329387844,
0.5571851134,
0.332223624,
-0.6332014799,
-0.2712561786,
-0.4051226974,
-0.8031730056,
0.870043993,
0.2559145093,
0.1089336351,
0.2257981151,
0.2418902665,
0.1089077443,
0.3571293056,
-1.1115505695,
-0.305854708,
-0.3329922259,
-0.1877143979,
-0.2910257876,
-0.3159252405,
-0.3118685186,
-0.2218200564,
0.8579018712,
-0.1361085325,
-0.0529680662,
-0.016689809,
-0.2134566456,
-0.1633235812,
0.2569092214,
0.6410249472,
0.7060569525,
-0.0207513794,
0.0558819287,
0.2323355079,
-0.2801593542,
0.0422528759,
0.109497793,
-0.0560199991,
-0.2392674088,
0.2787174881,
0.8730716109,
0.139585942,
-0.3083718419,
0.4870031178,
-0.0017244703,
-0.1867588758,
0.2514964342,
0.0609202869,
-0.2053612024,
0.3231657147,
0.4939873219,
0.0161028784,
0.2642818093,
-0.4596212804,
0.1941277832,
0.4700365663,
-0.7244254351,
0.3078585267,
0.7001860142,
0.3653014004,
-0.027645478,
0.689588666,
0.2499268204,
-0.6018580794,
0.5982322693,
0.689043045,
0.6094245911,
-0.6928141713,
0.0801909938,
0.2134875208,
0.3648932874,
0.2346732914,
0.0354183428,
0.0700995177,
-0.716100812,
-0.0919504091,
-0.1544445455,
-0.5144793391,
0.0478879474,
-0.8632784486,
0.0090441694,
-0.1641454995,
-0.0150984162,
0.135774374,
-0.2379473895,
-0.6590502262,
0.3697130978,
0.3237104118,
0.6280344129,
-1.0753967762,
0.5897724032,
0.268561244,
-0.4121329784,
-0.4273214042,
0.4882461727,
0.2500479519,
-0.8128476143,
0.7280656099,
0.2822009921,
-0.1986785978,
-0.0926713198,
-0.3983765244,
-0.6438043118,
0.6692928672,
0.4449425936,
-0.6008371711,
0.2070671618,
0.0193787124,
0.353395313,
-0.5557121038,
0.0620750897,
0.4765281379,
0.1117811054,
-0.0494151153,
-0.9584249258,
-0.3119811416,
-0.0260405261,
0.117073141,
-0.1068675667,
-0.4045808315,
1.17172122,
-0.1256693751,
-0.1979525238,
-0.2584602237,
0.6346649528,
0.1205465645,
0.3457615972,
0.7960801125,
0.3765512407,
1.2413953543,
-0.1451102495,
0.8707822561,
0.2501854002,
0.1865975559,
1.3048659563,
-0.3763203025,
0.4341017902,
0.495139122,
-0.1089006215,
0.1746869534,
0.4720229506,
0.2047363818,
0.98510921,
0.7988940477,
-0.5694246888,
-0.1781022549,
-0.2217571139,
-0.4624761045,
0.5487762094,
0.6449226737,
-0.3947417438,
-0.3849998713,
0.3403480947,
-0.1201454401,
0.535761714,
-0.7682051063,
0.802850008,
0.0586636998,
-0.3502008021,
0.3721841574,
-0.1698233932,
0.6892868876,
-0.2800311446,
-0.1621481031,
-0.4431879222,
0.2841340005,
-0.1442863941,
-0.3648604155,
0.1266867071,
-0.3938804567,
-0.3778297901,
0.0439082384,
0.3314332664,
-0.6365819573,
-0.3745985627,
0.3619995117,
0.2918323874,
-0.1389512569,
0.0640138239,
-0.5852564573,
-0.0023130721,
0.1094624996,
0.2016002536,
0.1709695011,
0.0451659933,
-0.0910160467,
0.7578007579,
0.0814093128,
-0.0396439135,
-0.0252690352,
0.6118591428,
0.9492887855,
-0.3190848231,
-0.7218168378,
-0.7304868102,
0.5287804008,
-0.3336481154,
0.0665575266,
0.6291882396,
0.5065037012,
1.059601903,
0.0982641727,
0.9872863293,
0.4605457485,
1.0069115162,
-0.7521436214,
0.5198586583,
-0.5076648593,
0.3775501251,
-0.3001722693,
-0.6879718304,
-0.6241821647,
0.9394480586,
-0.2994981706,
0.4118740857,
0.5774769783,
0.8556727767,
-0.0199810509,
0.1474714726,
0.3458444476,
0.2492954582,
0.3374358416,
0.5276612043,
0.7596034408,
-0.2643535435,
0.2855203748,
-0.4137873948,
-0.3650601804,
0.0222649183,
-0.7214052677,
-1.025853157,
-0.2350525558,
-0.1408630162,
-0.1993881762,
0.3141210973,
0.6210474968,
0.9785575867,
-0.8410758972,
-0.3614386022,
-0.0964384452,
0.2724739611,
-0.2118518949,
-0.2100820988,
0.1135974824,
-0.4661733508,
-0.8413905501,
0.4281033874,
-0.2246297598,
0.1443233937,
-0.1318668723,
-0.1221452057,
0.0259002168,
0.0656007156,
0.310300082,
0.1161976531,
-0.7819131017,
0.0745196342,
-0.7027237415,
0.0556006841,
0.181148693,
1.0690851212,
-0.9697560072,
0.4346210659,
0.2618987858,
0.380485177,
0.5463123918,
0.058847934,
0.7933012843,
-0.8435218334,
0.4353387654,
0.4892059863,
0.2551872134,
0.57802701,
-0.2879917026,
0.4544332027,
0.0675998107,
-0.3806926012,
-0.6138055921,
0.2434826642,
-0.5143544674,
-0.3873218894,
0.6220138669,
-0.0489571653,
0.2672346532,
-0.0911719203,
-0.3265715837,
0.3797690868,
-0.3318787217,
0.8603033423,
0.6220787764,
-0.1546176523,
-0.3025868535,
-0.4203642309,
0.7215110064,
0.7062353492,
-0.7710879445,
0.0615797676,
0.5274115801,
0.0640816987,
-0.3117369115,
0.5385584831,
-0.1528779119,
0.2257418931,
-0.16516532,
-0.1092106998,
0.5453102589,
-0.2411870956,
-0.8698083758,
0.1838878244,
-0.1461788416,
-0.2017056644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14683v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14683v1 | TAGLAS: An atlas of text-attributed graph datasets in the era of large graph and language models | 2024-06-20T19:11:35 | 2024-06-20T19:11:35 | Jiarui Feng, Hao Liu, Lecheng Kong, Yixin Chen, Muhan Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In this report, we present TAGLAS, an atlas of text-attributed graph (TAG)
datasets and benchmarks. TAGs are graphs with node and edge features
represented in text, which have recently gained wide applicability in training
graph-language or graph foundation models. In TAGLAS, we collect and integrate
more than 23 TAG datasets with domains ranging from citation graphs to molecule
graphs and tasks from node classification to graph question-answering. Unlike
previous graph datasets and benchmarks, all datasets in TAGLAS have a unified
node and edge text feature format, which allows a graph model to be
simultaneously trained and evaluated on multiple datasets from various domains.
Further, we provide a standardized, efficient, and simplified way to load all
datasets and tasks. We also provide useful utils like text-to-embedding
conversion, and graph-to-text conversion, which can facilitate different
evaluation scenarios. Finally, we also provide standard and easy-to-use
evaluation utils. The project is open-sourced at
https://github.com/JiaruiFeng/TAGLAS and is still under construction. Please
expect more datasets/features in the future. | [
-0.0528903268,
-0.2351441979,
0.1743533164,
0.1200610399,
-0.0994243398,
0.39293769,
-0.2059383392,
-0.6295877695,
0.1133940294,
0.4854662418,
-0.1248872355,
-0.7108180523,
-0.4989356995,
0.0936454013,
-0.5023328066,
1.3864445686,
-0.2329947203,
0.0531116761,
-0.4216741323,
-0.2428862751,
-0.2626847923,
-0.1509733051,
-0.326287806,
-0.2664478123,
0.7272428274,
0.1402108818,
0.2818402946,
0.7548382878,
0.6660743952,
0.1536473185,
0.0190662164,
0.4235545099,
-0.5107057095,
0.0658693537,
-0.3017599285,
-0.0415551141,
-0.8747485876,
0.0923580825,
0.9739156365,
0.8291293979,
0.3031280935,
0.4766298532,
0.1221655533,
0.5449670553,
-0.6809911728,
0.2996082604,
-0.5556116104,
-0.3378151655,
-0.494225353,
-0.0511973351,
-0.7625742555,
-0.4642129838,
0.2660955489,
-0.7382891774,
0.0009390216,
0.3101497889,
0.9998283982,
0.1042641699,
-0.6231333017,
-0.6183251739,
-0.5588921309,
0.5754557848,
-0.014848426,
0.4945757389,
0.1720878333,
0.3978207707,
0.0704724416,
-1.1219249964,
-0.1670632809,
0.0483350828,
-0.1899736226,
-0.0049737603,
-0.4318434894,
-0.0510687828,
-0.0530615076,
0.1084966138,
-0.7875185609,
0.0814455971,
-0.3026165962,
-0.1776705682,
0.7524483204,
0.0003573772,
0.2237416655,
-0.0928795859,
-0.5938393474,
-0.2416529953,
-0.8438946605,
-0.2466673255,
0.3669980466,
0.4886675775,
0.0147150252,
0.495287776,
-0.1187098548,
1.0002219677,
-0.8978068829,
-0.0318279862,
0.6730073094,
-0.3642876148,
-0.0860440359,
-0.0249572378,
0.7855378985,
0.1957353503,
0.4700870812,
-0.5314098001,
-0.1927762181,
0.2636268735,
-0.0258070026,
-0.7793308496,
-0.3803553283,
-0.1115232632,
-0.2674858868,
-0.1886831522,
-0.1579398364,
-0.8897467852,
-0.5961469412,
0.0014454678,
0.1368563622,
-0.3770577013,
0.0084458729,
-0.0917713568,
-0.2672894895,
-0.1084536612,
0.2895074785,
-0.24088265,
0.5839363337,
0.6650179625,
0.8930935264,
-0.2290697992,
-0.3957109749,
-0.5348075628,
0.2660885453,
-0.433126986,
0.8701725006,
-0.8950299621,
-0.2564331889,
0.0879232958,
-0.0516504347,
-0.3529575467,
-0.3484578729,
1.026093483,
-0.4920216203,
-0.3065171242,
-0.2078830749,
-0.6079171896,
-0.070414111,
0.126433298,
-0.6707310677,
1.3241022825,
-0.0116006341,
-0.7036042213,
-0.0061772089,
-0.8843271136,
-0.4581872821,
0.3226982355,
-0.1218484715,
-0.1547152549,
-0.4187978208,
0.0438807644,
0.4116736948,
-0.7825841904,
0.1909860224,
-0.1853684932,
-0.0793222561,
0.310433358,
0.2390880138,
0.6389219761,
0.4100496769,
0.2188674659,
0.168860212,
-0.7818543911,
0.0307224616,
0.3614827096,
0.1531745195,
-0.6036285162,
0.2804288864,
0.3229357302,
-0.0171110816,
0.4287172258,
-0.8851674795,
0.3579761386,
-0.1821101755,
0.5343142748,
0.6252190471,
-0.1322634369,
0.1567797214,
-0.1437912881,
0.4519125819,
-0.1964198798,
-0.0941241086,
-0.4684349,
-0.646371305,
-0.4614526629,
-0.4159616232,
0.6492771506,
0.4261480272,
-0.7267796397,
0.2288881838,
-0.8844566941,
-0.9600501657,
-0.4311441481,
-0.0284004137,
0.716810286,
0.7172636986,
0.2164387703,
-0.2578413486,
-0.4469854832,
-0.6832027435,
-0.0859572664,
-0.0765500441,
0.3028472662,
0.4913623929,
0.7683161497,
0.0017006283,
1.0548243523,
-0.8852969408,
-0.4769355357,
-0.088222608,
0.1096452028,
-0.1525469273,
0.3050838709,
0.745233953,
-0.7105696797,
-0.5820105672,
0.3385789692,
-0.4708174765,
-0.1154224798,
0.3002892137,
-0.1226484701,
0.0886660963,
0.3060105443,
-0.3852599859,
0.1703264862,
0.6529432535,
-0.2318315953,
0.2687864304,
0.185448572,
-0.2616336644,
-1.1902469397,
0.5777165294,
0.1961704344,
-0.3309732676,
-0.464152813,
0.0069261235,
-0.0391400307,
-0.3236087859,
0.0743987262,
0.8173012137,
-0.3723932207,
-0.4412098527,
0.1145513877,
0.5154226422,
0.2222521156,
0.2216136158,
-0.2712362707,
0.8905680776,
0.7971205115,
-0.1898284703,
0.4850327969,
0.5001760721,
-0.3235550821,
0.397708565,
-0.8319512606,
0.3326037526,
-0.0287618209,
0.5889316797,
-1.1828751564,
-0.1553238928,
0.2638473213,
-0.544314146,
0.1852498949,
-0.4441809356,
-0.7003077269,
-0.3934111595,
-0.324837327,
0.1628312469,
0.2023166269,
-0.4327057898,
0.4331640005,
0.6793008447,
-0.063461557,
-0.7537871003,
-0.4030401111,
0.1229539216,
0.0672792718,
-0.4088014066,
0.5051694512,
-0.149030745,
0.2964842618,
0.5381152034,
0.1347005665,
-0.1477751583,
0.1270584911,
0.3704524934,
0.285443753,
0.0879736096,
0.3985361457,
-0.1054191887,
-0.1776522398,
-0.2509309053,
-0.5283850431,
0.7327445745,
-0.3115498126,
-0.068897672,
-0.0582797602,
0.0406954773,
0.2363649607,
-0.7894263864,
0.4281531274,
0.3697138727,
-0.5447732806,
-0.3793915212,
0.1730471402,
0.444671452,
-0.374260366,
0.493100971,
-0.4658767581,
-0.7285609841,
0.5931828022,
-0.4660898149,
0.1362728924,
0.6001130342,
0.4589276612,
-0.1526142508,
0.6843320727,
0.3757703304,
-0.1747141927,
0.249694258,
-0.3730061352,
0.0991469845,
-0.9574007988,
-0.3021230102,
-0.9221302271,
-0.3421240747,
-0.668422401,
-0.4313480854,
0.1111103371,
-0.1589204371,
-0.2223815173,
0.4764954746,
-0.6354240179,
0.5026040077,
0.0430125259,
-0.1563765407,
0.2228230983,
-0.0797462761,
0.0738863572,
0.0906082913,
-0.5184508562,
-0.6022641659,
1.3223930597,
0.2549997866,
0.7387184501,
-0.164365381,
0.6438705921,
0.5127834082,
0.5440779924,
-0.7585781813,
0.5431016684,
-0.3421300352,
-0.6410284638,
-0.0575108007,
-0.3531953096,
-1.2085949183,
-0.1545431167,
-0.0196969975,
-1.0274538994,
0.0763707235,
0.0553666241,
0.2174206674,
0.2445983887,
-0.8554979563,
1.0948531628,
0.0531046465,
-0.0295356773,
0.2212683856,
-0.7556273341,
-0.0678843483,
0.0714145079,
0.175046593,
-0.2831784785,
-0.1672706157,
0.9659596086,
0.0653955936,
0.7575038671,
-0.1400872767,
0.0379986316,
0.3498191237,
-0.0965007097,
0.5443850756,
-0.2762495875,
-0.1337920278,
-0.0442493223,
-0.0300540999,
-0.2814923227,
-0.3650374115,
0.795103848,
-0.8636677265,
0.2316273004,
-0.5028809309,
-0.7377453446,
-0.1829673052,
0.3736255765,
0.0241034944,
0.781431973,
-0.35319978,
0.1215517968,
0.4520733654,
-0.0995030403,
0.3023211062,
0.0529950373,
-0.5383204222,
-0.4236463606,
1.4465506077,
0.4493358433,
0.0871983841,
0.2778778076,
-0.1164271981,
-0.1948386878,
-0.5809131861,
-0.5381780267,
0.1953827292,
-0.8592967987,
-0.6101282835,
-0.5967533588,
-0.3136878014,
-0.3639528751,
0.0239830408,
-0.526001215,
-0.5074144602,
0.0470478088,
-0.1498464495,
0.5799558163,
0.8848566413,
0.3873367012,
0.3385523558,
-0.5110961199,
0.0396473296,
-0.1766227037,
0.5885103941,
0.0389576443,
-0.1152038276,
-0.5232777596,
-0.3344496787,
-0.214452073,
-0.9370065928,
0.2029515356,
0.5528815985,
0.3429204226,
-0.0256005116,
0.0882148296,
0.3238869905,
-0.6046622396,
0.4621467888,
-0.1207411885,
-0.8925319314,
0.4584900141,
-0.5937606096,
-0.2678857744,
0.4361322522,
0.6805563569,
-0.5881018639,
0.1075278446,
-0.4827398956,
-0.7617834806,
0.6161981225,
0.2588694394,
-0.1045873761,
0.2289493084,
0.2233972847,
0.0039325557,
0.2027021348,
-0.612357676,
-0.5486548543,
-0.0332553312,
-0.5199560523,
-0.1287726611,
-0.042706646,
-0.5385428071,
-0.1390365213,
0.664562881,
-0.3726226985,
0.1849422455,
0.1877065301,
-0.2996276021,
0.181066826,
0.1236110553,
0.148961857,
0.7489413619,
-0.3296518326,
0.2420708537,
-0.1192088127,
-0.4037667811,
-0.1455473602,
0.5588627458,
-0.2620753944,
0.0957355127,
0.2885065973,
0.883708477,
-0.2101345658,
-0.779658854,
0.3962557316,
0.3190233409,
0.2810693085,
-0.0349189639,
-0.314794451,
0.1483078599,
-0.0794898644,
0.4803859591,
-0.0350191109,
0.269764483,
-0.3555101454,
0.2017219812,
0.1403458416,
-0.3933744431,
-0.3753932118,
0.4493890703,
0.3501074016,
-0.0836049467,
0.1526168287,
-0.4651653171,
-0.5462709069,
0.4502893388,
0.6149597764,
0.7511683702,
-0.0200516395,
0.4357665777,
0.335170716,
0.4174084961,
0.5516102314,
0.0910253376,
0.2367174178,
-0.6958559752,
-0.3268862665,
-0.5498920679,
-0.4776858389,
-0.3431470692,
-0.49615556,
0.2128849477,
-0.2441833317,
-0.0250294656,
0.522129178,
0.2943674028,
-0.5588774085,
0.2189030647,
0.103052862,
0.9831482768,
-1.1272435188,
1.0910692215,
1.1739736795,
-0.323785156,
-0.3898914754,
-0.2805304527,
-0.145700112,
-0.8087892532,
0.685602963,
0.1440663338,
-0.1135449558,
0.4216302037,
-0.6644636393,
-0.8177958727,
1.1637825966,
0.367064327,
-0.1628569365,
0.0230757985,
0.1404743642,
0.5224559307,
-0.6909767389,
0.1744835824,
0.5184910297,
0.2728809714,
0.0396360122,
-0.8125354648,
0.0610005856,
-0.4985513687,
0.0271693822,
0.424361676,
-0.6831495166,
0.7208805084,
0.2537490726,
-0.2055118084,
0.0757236555,
0.5700420737,
0.0503867306,
0.4270970821,
0.3434530795,
0.8160145283,
1.117565155,
-0.4202945828,
1.2339932919,
-0.2562491,
0.6160719991,
1.1823549271,
-0.7412555218,
0.7504978776,
0.1022955552,
-0.1735326946,
0.7072606683,
0.6047760844,
-0.0931560099,
0.4078642726,
0.192333892,
0.0351733267,
-0.0768840462,
-0.9803743958,
-0.3960045278,
0.4981920421,
0.4342829287,
-0.2007610798,
-0.4772446156,
-0.1507768184,
0.1418573558,
0.158470735,
-0.0177636277,
0.3555129468,
-0.2183391601,
-0.1913515478,
0.1479382068,
0.0221776441,
0.1374490261,
-0.743727982,
0.0217729397,
-0.0753676221,
0.0404728353,
-0.2155002952,
-1.0693583488,
0.1180130839,
0.352547437,
-0.0791894272,
-0.3153262734,
1.0421960354,
-0.1521659195,
-0.468318373,
0.3969271183,
0.3929205239,
0.2023533434,
0.325427115,
-0.4602790773,
0.1953607053,
-0.2632962465,
-0.177634716,
0.2155897319,
0.3676780164,
-0.2691574693,
0.640856266,
0.437071681,
-0.0735334009,
-0.0115369223,
-0.0491798483,
1.2865231037,
-0.4208780229,
-0.2648258805,
-0.4201133251,
0.4234732389,
-0.4295387268,
-0.6194964647,
0.7049586177,
1.0586490631,
0.7974764109,
0.2804528177,
0.8142599463,
-0.3837604225,
0.6049429178,
-0.2597286105,
0.6861463785,
-0.4781159461,
-0.1738135964,
-0.4887755811,
-0.8385542035,
-0.2620064914,
0.2160222232,
-0.2395750582,
-0.1113824993,
0.5502573252,
0.445250541,
0.2532408535,
-0.0924098119,
-0.2202482373,
0.1223930418,
0.3957822919,
0.6215161681,
0.5849416852,
-0.7090886831,
0.7133561373,
0.0063629397,
-0.2087658942,
-0.0018259771,
-0.9463741183,
-0.7659660578,
-1.0455418825,
-0.4212715924,
-0.311542958,
0.1308898628,
0.7674759626,
0.4660135806,
-0.6340374351,
-0.2692040205,
0.1012617946,
0.3873995841,
0.0166632403,
-0.1298237592,
0.5914748311,
-0.183839798,
-0.9056038857,
0.3311706185,
0.3289887011,
-0.1761900485,
0.0846746564,
-0.083819963,
-0.5399367809,
-0.2072978616,
0.3093546331,
0.3509142995,
-0.1443192214,
-0.2301242501,
0.0618653335,
-0.2495555878,
0.251152277,
0.7397047281,
-0.6527562141,
0.676692307,
0.6462429166,
0.8083513379,
0.5091027617,
-0.1753128618,
0.2390790135,
-1.1904150248,
0.2784239948,
0.2567224801,
0.3821451366,
0.3586117327,
0.1682889014,
1.0279222727,
0.3265696764,
-0.4124174416,
-1.3172857761,
0.1331381947,
-1.3751077652,
0.0058179214,
0.8865214586,
-0.4913425744,
-0.1630235016,
0.1860438138,
-0.1135477349,
0.4641299546,
-0.204098016,
0.0748832896,
0.6261442304,
0.0842415243,
0.1745731086,
-0.4964040816,
0.4387735128,
0.0508391783,
-1.0237748623,
0.3117959797,
0.4830549657,
-0.061434295,
0.4512063563,
0.4600850642,
-0.014051728,
-0.1155138016,
-0.1117892563,
0.2618682384,
-0.0406129174,
-0.7631294727,
0.043279361,
0.1055903211,
0.037153244,
-0.209021017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14680v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14680v1 | Dravidian language family through Universal Dependencies lens | 2024-06-20T18:59:46 | 2024-06-20T18:59:46 | Taraka Rama, Sowmya Vajjala | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Universal Dependencies (UD) project aims to create a cross-linguistically
consistent dependency annotation for multiple languages, to facilitate
multilingual NLP. It currently supports 114 languages. Dravidian languages are
spoken by over 200 million people across the word, and yet there are only two
languages from this family in UD. This paper examines some of the morphological
and syntactic features of Dravidian languages and explores how they can be
annotated in the UD framework. | [
-0.4681417644,
-0.0852641389,
0.3560789526,
0.3277853429,
0.0796496943,
0.3253219128,
-0.1123961881,
-0.8275851607,
0.2565945387,
0.4536575377,
-0.4356467426,
-0.13924326,
-0.3692952096,
0.3537276387,
0.1227000207,
0.6227709651,
-0.213435635,
0.1168697998,
0.2793641388,
-0.8380367756,
-0.7359899282,
-0.3917723596,
-0.0021066645,
-0.2311152965,
0.6287454367,
0.6557279825,
0.8703101873,
0.835103929,
0.5451782942,
0.2669426203,
-0.2025526166,
-0.0409572273,
-0.0120889153,
0.5530098677,
-0.2976298928,
-0.7752068043,
-0.0989283621,
-0.1752531379,
0.7205210924,
1.0312296152,
-0.2605869472,
0.3102074564,
-0.1594009846,
1.0086158514,
-0.4206531644,
0.3161194324,
-0.1534415931,
0.0826045573,
-0.7425321341,
0.206535697,
-0.138142392,
0.017759461,
0.3114709854,
-0.3822550476,
-0.1113870963,
-0.2050737292,
0.5231420994,
0.3074711263,
-0.3797807992,
0.0541147441,
-0.8630056977,
0.7596952319,
-0.2164839655,
0.3736421764,
0.3320816755,
-0.0461584292,
-0.3482272029,
-0.4564463198,
-0.5859442353,
-0.1031001806,
-0.1405692548,
0.2314760387,
0.0168770216,
0.0765783414,
0.241508022,
0.6233983636,
-0.7658364773,
0.3101014793,
-0.4700248539,
0.1243108958,
0.5192722082,
0.2584905326,
0.7748551965,
-0.4479678869,
-0.2544632554,
0.1817723364,
-0.8216723204,
-0.1429770887,
0.5363693237,
0.1956597716,
-0.2052038163,
0.7177134752,
-0.1150255278,
1.0312865973,
-0.0770862326,
-0.2021302879,
-0.043680694,
-0.2774392664,
-0.0816450715,
-0.1413287669,
0.5753206015,
-0.1289902031,
0.6226232052,
-0.0875043646,
0.357206732,
0.139799878,
0.0028791868,
-0.324598819,
-0.1410069615,
0.062045116,
-0.3052204251,
0.1762102991,
-0.0113453204,
-0.9094381928,
-0.3526619673,
-0.3562702239,
-0.3485483825,
-0.462718755,
-0.9074065089,
0.0566970706,
-0.1338698715,
0.1832408905,
0.2144201696,
-1.3029518127,
0.262060523,
0.4622288048,
0.7152221799,
-0.0984692127,
-0.5705245137,
-0.013967989,
0.2809222043,
-0.0793738663,
1.1029242277,
-0.8400139809,
-0.4248579443,
0.1681774259,
-0.1758095324,
-0.2055260539,
-0.4960300326,
0.1322287619,
-0.2189389765,
0.0837975219,
-0.3846965432,
-0.3722908795,
-0.5301187634,
-0.3739601374,
-0.869541347,
0.981330514,
0.5639350414,
-0.861207962,
0.6685426235,
-0.3266035914,
-0.6214532256,
0.8288732767,
-0.5749456882,
0.0367075503,
0.2922338247,
-0.2681413591,
0.2646045983,
-0.0448145233,
0.2197622806,
-0.1364950389,
-0.2443057597,
-0.3149129748,
-0.1740008444,
1.2697764635,
0.2861360013,
-0.6169449687,
0.097000584,
-1.0725826025,
-0.3425893486,
-0.0482967384,
-0.5410998464,
-0.4616467655,
0.0168790314,
0.2606312931,
0.189133063,
-0.0969095826,
-0.6328738332,
0.7453432083,
-0.3368221223,
0.2090884298,
0.6177703142,
-0.1406197399,
0.3561112583,
0.0320286416,
0.8326850533,
0.1497198045,
-0.1014997289,
-0.1763284802,
-0.7773423791,
-0.7736284137,
-0.5635767579,
0.183027178,
0.6848427057,
-0.5473589301,
0.190698579,
-0.0561963208,
-0.0529067703,
-0.4525146484,
0.4034599662,
0.3294627964,
-0.0183332842,
0.0382829346,
-0.2804050744,
-0.9126988053,
-0.9386739731,
0.3383757174,
-0.6222416759,
0.386478126,
-0.1197147518,
0.5233647823,
-0.2652022541,
0.870727241,
-0.3089776933,
-0.6594337821,
-0.6326744556,
0.1123137698,
-0.1328053772,
0.05351004,
0.8081216216,
-0.7787287831,
-0.729677856,
0.3005446494,
-0.913459003,
0.0627448261,
0.120803982,
0.3290297985,
0.5606312156,
0.3754163384,
-0.4133715332,
0.7748600841,
0.830952704,
-0.2016918361,
0.4797271192,
-0.3263015747,
-0.0894446149,
-1.204228282,
-0.0448018797,
-0.0532493703,
-0.0615043528,
-0.5367888808,
0.1013994068,
-0.0593253225,
0.0993267372,
-0.4228343368,
0.5796281695,
-0.8008502722,
0.1401413381,
0.0907038078,
-0.0522059202,
-0.3486891389,
0.2406186014,
0.2316661179,
0.784334898,
0.8160256147,
-0.4043354094,
0.8947278261,
0.4445264041,
-0.2647785246,
0.9341554642,
-0.4712061584,
-0.3518209457,
-0.0879016593,
0.2660892904,
-1.0640285015,
-0.4823051691,
0.0617180988,
-0.1114880517,
0.5872163773,
-0.4925594926,
-0.6830915809,
-0.366333425,
-0.2298633158,
0.4479463995,
0.1426952183,
-0.4124074578,
0.4197601378,
0.6714139581,
-0.2656436563,
-0.8122465014,
-0.7422130704,
0.4721158147,
-0.2201343626,
-0.7443756461,
-0.2806021273,
0.0270269793,
-0.6456965804,
0.1699998528,
0.1114871576,
-0.1179615036,
-0.0964484513,
0.7086319923,
0.264831841,
-0.120620437,
0.0480916984,
-0.2445407957,
-0.2912251353,
-0.652332902,
-0.2578192651,
0.6004430652,
-0.2165969759,
-0.2474060059,
-0.5746158361,
0.6860737205,
0.5316662788,
-0.405806303,
0.6779739857,
0.3698644638,
-0.333928287,
-0.1620806307,
-0.6952312589,
0.3523102403,
-0.3962963223,
0.3352093101,
-0.7472301722,
-0.736905098,
0.8054765463,
0.1411088407,
-0.1045733243,
0.7030092478,
0.7152975202,
0.1837700009,
0.728433311,
0.9964358807,
-0.4581978619,
0.4117487371,
-0.1481257975,
-0.1009206027,
-0.8567714095,
-0.2901283205,
-0.4753390849,
0.053610716,
-0.937130928,
0.0622803457,
-0.0536436252,
0.0100787887,
0.3197053075,
0.8127273917,
-0.5185090899,
0.1714973003,
0.5370177627,
-0.5262950659,
0.3883763552,
0.1217092425,
-0.4244464636,
-0.3342027366,
-0.4012284577,
-0.3940806389,
0.7943294048,
0.2507745624,
0.9011083245,
0.3727899492,
0.6373776197,
0.1968963593,
0.0016574409,
-0.4314873219,
0.4926917255,
-0.3285721838,
-1.0307155848,
-0.105228126,
-0.2807120979,
-0.9153241515,
-0.0113599515,
0.2046269327,
-0.9922400117,
0.5103394985,
-0.3075664341,
-0.2591004968,
0.314106971,
-0.6226295829,
0.4922273755,
-0.136729449,
-0.0733305514,
-0.3860336244,
-0.7224318385,
0.1159325242,
0.1814803779,
-0.1252931803,
-0.2318727523,
0.2952629328,
0.7405589223,
-0.1715641469,
0.8814637065,
0.2228949666,
-0.1247902811,
0.2540868521,
0.0069642318,
-0.2267415673,
0.3857408464,
-0.1249922141,
0.2796142399,
0.0431119725,
-0.3696335554,
0.050897643,
0.7621423006,
-0.5990902781,
-0.4760329127,
-1.0294642448,
-0.7952130437,
-0.0869910643,
0.3994411826,
-0.0228631347,
0.5772651434,
-0.2191984951,
-0.1892873794,
0.6154199839,
-0.1256808043,
0.7105790973,
0.3123632967,
-0.387919426,
-0.3771798313,
0.6687650084,
0.3657785356,
0.1913256645,
0.1690247655,
-0.1878822595,
-0.197613582,
-0.3904271722,
-1.0880872011,
0.5797886848,
-0.6931295991,
0.0872273296,
-0.5646325946,
-0.0778402537,
-0.3947536647,
-0.0373729281,
-0.3279406428,
-0.6278470755,
-0.1567696035,
-0.2053692639,
0.5771718025,
1.5851495266,
-0.3093956709,
0.0729140788,
-0.4803121388,
0.5738106966,
0.4744541645,
0.7653874755,
-0.4066456258,
-0.3493896723,
-0.0529190525,
-0.1961533427,
0.0525911935,
-0.5712438822,
-0.0138054807,
0.2577850521,
0.8490837812,
0.4392899573,
-0.3235716522,
0.8387497663,
-0.6202173233,
0.6448075771,
0.3300018311,
-0.6578718424,
0.4011811018,
-0.4271917343,
0.1878277659,
0.7291460037,
0.2655054033,
-0.7121738195,
-0.5605040789,
-0.473873198,
-0.7039744854,
0.5555257797,
-0.1066564247,
0.0452855304,
0.0676923096,
0.5093638301,
0.3513769209,
-0.199381128,
-0.2597587407,
-0.7520051599,
0.2458120286,
-0.2867200673,
0.3495573997,
-0.6172040105,
0.0978012234,
-0.2990846634,
0.0914182588,
0.1128446534,
-0.1403453797,
-0.0234230105,
-0.2980822921,
-0.3513840735,
0.0990932733,
0.8159701824,
1.0676944256,
-0.1259244382,
0.2186934501,
-0.1899631321,
-1.0691998005,
0.2018431425,
0.132687524,
-0.2916576266,
0.2033829093,
0.3837895989,
0.6467605233,
-0.0548874438,
-0.4354161322,
0.0383162722,
-0.1858540773,
0.0851699263,
-0.6391767859,
0.0101506123,
0.2775551379,
0.1329207271,
0.4584456682,
0.0024170983,
-0.0509636886,
-0.8375167251,
0.5714529157,
0.348513931,
-0.6180693507,
-0.5678155422,
0.6718537807,
0.1852814257,
0.077659227,
0.6022012234,
-0.0819803104,
-0.6613718271,
0.2745659351,
0.2630743682,
0.6353859901,
-0.4841444194,
0.4413530529,
0.3172390163,
0.2571093142,
-0.173378855,
0.544724226,
0.3041109443,
-0.3590121567,
-0.5433270931,
-0.762724638,
-0.4936038852,
-0.3592637777,
-0.7667073011,
0.302085042,
-0.1483231485,
0.0272581037,
0.576695621,
0.0668617859,
-0.6347925663,
0.1049703509,
0.3198637366,
0.4741773307,
-0.8627404571,
1.0576119423,
1.0512769222,
-1.0449633598,
-0.5938519835,
-0.1316751689,
0.2721230686,
-1.0194993019,
1.1770918369,
0.0532122701,
-0.0984941944,
-0.0235288385,
0.0350481309,
-0.6574894786,
0.6147165298,
0.303735584,
-0.3612881005,
0.1710635871,
0.5114629865,
0.6593757272,
-0.3782413602,
0.017320957,
0.5594927073,
0.7955102324,
-0.2800476253,
-1.1499965191,
-0.0799843371,
-0.22665447,
0.2088375539,
0.4578220248,
-0.5354455709,
0.3521421254,
-0.5152572989,
-0.369555831,
0.1091721803,
0.6108592153,
-0.0614815615,
-0.263356775,
0.3251717389,
0.8156216145,
0.2890352607,
-0.0838877559,
0.8877641559,
-0.0716063678,
0.2304956913,
0.8256431818,
-0.4048444331,
0.5844532847,
0.5989894271,
-0.5399713516,
0.6572580934,
0.4178963304,
-0.1392874122,
0.0292658433,
0.4218568504,
-0.463609308,
0.2867846787,
-0.4487089515,
-0.2195359319,
0.7119783163,
0.2997900844,
0.1867515445,
-0.0757473931,
0.0983953997,
0.4053388834,
0.001055855,
-0.1073123887,
0.731577754,
0.1301496029,
-0.5686450005,
0.4531795084,
-0.5037522316,
0.5412372947,
-0.4995155036,
-0.2446148545,
-0.2560914755,
0.452893585,
-0.468408227,
-1.1261204481,
0.3487445414,
-0.0925447419,
-0.2917864025,
-0.0215421654,
0.4720439613,
-0.5111983418,
-0.5361272097,
0.7083169222,
0.4062245786,
-0.0398445912,
0.1540625244,
-0.1928147376,
0.0522410758,
0.1746560335,
-0.3846998513,
0.3413552046,
0.3852732182,
-0.2744050324,
0.7367370129,
0.2394688278,
0.5146164894,
0.4599595666,
0.2648697197,
0.4556494951,
-0.7682206631,
0.1115899011,
-0.6364752054,
0.603580296,
0.1839246303,
-0.7271694541,
0.8798474669,
0.2947697937,
0.7468838096,
0.0425152294,
0.964972198,
-0.5528698564,
0.2555170953,
0.2159093618,
0.5089834929,
-0.4510372579,
-0.0717922747,
-0.1196391508,
-1.0570220947,
-0.836640656,
0.4933760464,
0.1892635375,
-0.1209855974,
0.7107028961,
0.0385786965,
0.1630054712,
-0.0461323671,
0.480981797,
-0.016362479,
0.1899272949,
0.0988229886,
0.6866483688,
-0.0087893093,
0.467589736,
-0.6295901537,
-0.4312326312,
-0.0842986777,
-0.6025399566,
-0.7622612119,
-0.7147035599,
-0.3363902867,
-0.204735741,
-0.0005682742,
0.5140018463,
0.4830439091,
-1.0553950071,
-0.4163766205,
-0.0027805062,
0.119391568,
-0.1315584332,
-0.1318641305,
0.3248529434,
-0.1972649097,
-0.6685432196,
0.3783639371,
0.994641304,
-0.1681842953,
-0.6170827746,
0.2050010413,
-0.5216186643,
-0.4644351304,
0.2615668178,
0.6972468495,
-0.669008553,
-0.4910950661,
-0.042228803,
-0.3011946082,
0.059988454,
0.7580831051,
-0.3480392992,
0.6261627674,
0.6403190494,
0.0908160955,
0.2190293968,
-0.3344675004,
0.6214516163,
-0.2950670421,
0.5878776312,
-0.1169045419,
0.6339473128,
0.3759946525,
-0.1411448121,
0.9071351886,
0.4766840935,
-0.6134594679,
-0.6311587691,
0.7558262944,
-1.1628531218,
0.0741162822,
1.2246230841,
-0.3585158288,
0.2033302784,
-1.0472844839,
-0.1969334036,
0.2705396116,
-0.1199550256,
0.4907071888,
0.5901678205,
-0.1495794803,
-0.2156746686,
-0.8421795964,
0.3557502925,
0.1347363889,
-0.5773269534,
0.2114604414,
0.4229545891,
0.4209745228,
0.4746736288,
0.3750298321,
-0.1255672127,
0.1828084886,
0.0825633109,
0.4848615229,
0.148055926,
-0.5252528191,
-0.2741524875,
-0.2997334898,
0.1309658587,
0.0126638003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14678v1 | Bidirectional Transformer Representations of (Spanish) Ambiguous Words in Context: A New Lexical Resource and Empirical Analysis | 2024-06-20T18:58:11 | 2024-06-20T18:58:11 | Pamela D. Rivière, Anne L. Beatty-Martínez, Sean Trott | cs.CL | cs.CL | Lexical ambiguity -- where a single wordform takes on distinct,
context-dependent meanings -- serves as a useful tool to compare across
different large language models' (LLMs') ability to form distinct,
contextualized representations of the same stimulus. Few studies have
systematically compared LLMs' contextualized word embeddings for languages
beyond English. Here, we evaluate multiple bidirectional transformers' (BERTs')
semantic representations of Spanish ambiguous nouns in context. We develop a
novel dataset of minimal-pair sentences evoking the same or different sense for
a target ambiguous noun. In a pre-registered study, we collect contextualized
human relatedness judgments for each sentence pair. We find that various
BERT-based LLMs' contextualized semantic representations capture some variance
in human judgments but fall short of the human benchmark, and for Spanish --
unlike English -- model scale is uncorrelated with performance. We also
identify stereotyped trajectories of target noun disambiguation as a proportion
of traversal through a given LLM family's architecture, which we partially
replicate in English. We contribute (1) a dataset of controlled, Spanish
sentence stimuli with human relatedness norms, and (2) to our evolving
understanding of the impact that LLM specification (architectures, training
protocols) exerts on contextualized embeddings. | [
-0.3871052265,
-0.5057547092,
0.4298923016,
0.6731954813,
-0.3172177672,
0.0927130952,
-0.3534923196,
-0.5913058519,
0.3109814823,
0.0900079533,
-0.6919232011,
-0.1469106376,
-0.7829942107,
0.4965358078,
-0.3903742135,
0.5347675681,
-0.0806029961,
0.0805204809,
-0.1878678054,
-0.1615819335,
-0.4720596969,
-0.2936487198,
-0.0087424098,
-0.3969260156,
0.9221273065,
0.286931783,
1.1994160414,
0.4282816648,
0.6295604706,
0.2784897089,
-0.1590098739,
0.0137602901,
-0.3040270209,
0.2028142065,
-0.4163974226,
-0.2011943609,
-0.0531938113,
-0.1581427306,
0.6184026599,
1.0226927996,
0.0506615564,
0.0246962383,
0.1774012297,
0.5430247188,
-0.526709497,
0.1580356359,
-0.832267046,
0.0922114775,
-0.1031620577,
-0.139852196,
-0.2075794339,
-0.1393680274,
0.3486966193,
-0.201066494,
0.3687826395,
0.0692895353,
0.9901996851,
0.584929049,
-0.5570611954,
-0.3780277669,
-0.6802754402,
0.6733421683,
-0.3800572455,
0.6668791175,
0.044094678,
0.2028870732,
-0.2967945039,
-0.6333693862,
-0.6215247512,
-0.2248255461,
-0.2742424309,
0.1919529736,
-0.3189426363,
0.05735806,
-0.0937529579,
0.174800694,
-0.4750140011,
0.2750330865,
-0.4083584249,
-0.1499094218,
0.4143836498,
-0.1704551876,
-0.0127044311,
-0.473249644,
-0.6994813681,
-0.4062123597,
-0.9111425877,
-0.0304981358,
0.5539341569,
0.3712285459,
-0.0213670209,
0.6316463351,
0.1279909909,
0.5208538771,
-0.0864621177,
0.2172077298,
0.4597885907,
0.03816396,
-0.1718825847,
0.1474314928,
0.7169187665,
0.1945601702,
-0.0016473577,
-0.4867487848,
-0.1837085038,
0.1984300613,
0.2354712039,
-0.3498955667,
0.21714288,
0.068663612,
-0.2351778597,
-0.049670808,
0.4741005599,
-0.4957110584,
-0.2374311686,
-0.1149306297,
0.28769961,
-0.2199842185,
0.067838192,
0.3171104491,
-0.1774632484,
0.4620392323,
-0.0899538919,
-0.6865587831,
0.3057594895,
0.5280760527,
0.5018764734,
-0.2286473811,
-0.502939105,
0.1624143869,
0.1247069612,
-0.0339664593,
0.6358299851,
-0.5341768861,
-0.5306162834,
0.2257001549,
0.323395431,
-0.1271855235,
-0.470646441,
0.6175794601,
-0.675888598,
0.2928290367,
-0.3846351504,
-0.261726886,
-0.2394148558,
0.0731656179,
-0.8033703566,
1.1325303316,
-0.0106366184,
-0.6428681016,
0.2364710271,
-0.3116882443,
-0.5024470091,
0.0245174021,
-0.4619959891,
0.0477277786,
0.3027539849,
0.1359805167,
0.56867975,
-0.287954241,
0.4503145814,
0.0908111185,
-0.3521611691,
0.2609528899,
-0.5395163894,
0.5741071105,
-0.0228469092,
-0.4428885281,
-0.0924257487,
-0.4098268449,
-0.4204611182,
0.2787597477,
-0.2513703406,
-0.3979438841,
0.1693542004,
0.1911958754,
0.3694019318,
0.6904807687,
-0.6746620536,
-0.0946562365,
-0.527944684,
0.2193101943,
0.5653735995,
-0.2889534235,
0.3344785273,
-0.4364464283,
0.5275635719,
0.0100960853,
-0.0661362782,
-0.0915149823,
-0.5354368687,
-0.7485823631,
0.0113068372,
0.1901498437,
0.5437827706,
-0.4730870724,
0.598383069,
-0.5224963427,
-0.01961945,
-0.4609344006,
-0.1094019338,
0.2707802355,
0.367305547,
0.3709520698,
-0.0438492037,
-0.8636527658,
-1.31690979,
-0.0622882918,
-0.0817220286,
-0.2213312089,
0.2799173892,
0.5696468353,
-0.527959764,
1.1011917591,
-0.2746104896,
-0.2360602468,
-0.0884848908,
0.131862998,
0.1855379343,
0.1105164289,
0.610355556,
-0.7386345863,
-0.1345193237,
0.0046220864,
-0.3612950444,
-0.0142113008,
0.0474385172,
0.1389708817,
-0.0681760833,
0.5032145977,
-0.1383370161,
0.176366061,
0.839127481,
-0.3577512205,
0.1859712154,
-0.4334777892,
-0.0845658779,
-0.9178972244,
-0.0886090249,
-0.2497858256,
-0.1547994167,
-0.4003721774,
-0.0939088836,
0.2808118165,
0.3835796416,
-0.6490041614,
0.6264821887,
-0.4592554569,
-0.1591362655,
-0.0262485258,
0.4966731071,
-0.0587577447,
0.5682399273,
0.1438099891,
0.6848828793,
0.3423495889,
-0.3030446768,
0.3317288458,
0.1217010766,
-0.1850087941,
0.2920596898,
-0.8584941626,
0.0928585753,
-0.5526871681,
0.036400836,
-1.1411471367,
-0.1159606948,
0.069627367,
-0.0590736009,
0.1723593622,
0.258192867,
-0.6220458746,
-0.5340653658,
-0.3176769912,
0.5415465236,
0.3586044908,
-0.6469643116,
0.2318215221,
0.2548546791,
-0.0300769992,
-0.6588144302,
-0.794098556,
0.091598101,
-0.2195019871,
-0.7287768722,
0.7577884793,
0.1566721201,
-0.1395453513,
0.1028603464,
-0.2306297868,
0.0238770954,
-0.0559025966,
0.3932146728,
0.2992232144,
-0.0855693743,
0.1630458832,
0.2971219122,
0.2697371244,
0.1412702948,
0.0429252163,
0.534948051,
-0.52681005,
-0.4163968861,
0.0041031097,
0.2660141885,
0.5556349158,
0.1601736844,
0.680997014,
0.3673382103,
-0.423510015,
0.1953247637,
-0.6400248408,
-0.0526700392,
-0.4525015652,
0.4049299955,
-0.5534794331,
-1.0072442293,
0.9794746637,
0.1066498756,
-0.0269766785,
0.5894079804,
0.6514515281,
-0.2470279038,
0.807294488,
0.429254353,
0.0335180573,
0.2813672423,
-0.1349155009,
0.1233668625,
-0.9139113426,
-0.497751981,
-0.5448498726,
-0.6088534594,
-0.6979033351,
-0.6929470301,
0.3085223734,
-0.219355315,
-0.1515032053,
0.5055844188,
-0.2647337317,
0.64830935,
0.2537632287,
0.0603733324,
0.3533388078,
-0.0577165149,
-0.3566405773,
-0.1914386004,
-0.7072966099,
-0.6854037046,
0.9634839296,
0.5087170005,
0.6098626256,
0.3457544744,
0.5884544849,
0.348412782,
0.036577072,
-0.8778918982,
0.296810329,
-0.3294736743,
-0.3941539824,
-0.1390743107,
-0.1259122044,
-1.3472281694,
0.6944061518,
-0.1270219088,
-0.692858994,
0.5479071736,
-0.2793911099,
-0.2546162903,
0.0651285946,
-0.5087510943,
0.7541260719,
-0.3407292366,
-0.2749673128,
-0.0397720486,
-0.7893207073,
0.1937437952,
0.0745723769,
0.3421914577,
-0.2224839479,
-0.3667608202,
0.6348557472,
-0.1951147169,
0.827450335,
0.1451106817,
-0.3762020171,
0.0086870538,
0.2089281827,
0.3027632535,
-0.0556862243,
-0.0767618418,
0.4287525117,
0.1148638651,
-0.3474664092,
-0.4390714169,
0.5823261738,
-0.8174954057,
-0.6486580968,
-0.4281456769,
-0.754113853,
-0.389611274,
0.034144152,
0.2171195596,
0.1387770921,
-0.5609249473,
0.2189592123,
0.3394307494,
-0.0709261298,
0.463452667,
0.3284199238,
-0.1183200032,
0.2188713402,
0.4189422131,
-0.2993801832,
-0.0242356192,
0.5318059325,
0.2071854323,
-0.6796580553,
-0.2592008114,
-0.2095883787,
0.3408977091,
-0.4772976339,
-0.1417901367,
-0.2907094657,
-0.1228024438,
-0.2141452134,
-0.2882557511,
-0.3219444752,
-0.3304679394,
-0.2845665812,
-0.0766406581,
0.0814158991,
0.8548986316,
-0.0322148763,
0.4878975451,
-0.5332049727,
0.2280564755,
0.353672415,
0.1752964109,
-0.1424281597,
-0.71477139,
0.0857022703,
0.2219697982,
0.0409090742,
-1.3020461798,
0.1953867525,
0.2096519619,
0.698097229,
0.707523644,
-0.1458123326,
0.5713461041,
-0.5879641771,
0.598493278,
0.2146166563,
-0.8292158842,
0.4560248554,
-0.3167852461,
0.2015010715,
0.4651966393,
0.3550173342,
-0.7525652647,
-0.4335923791,
-0.492043525,
-1.0425623655,
0.7228196263,
0.2656883597,
0.4265623093,
-0.3729222417,
0.1469562054,
0.0769645423,
0.1538529098,
-0.7794952989,
-0.4807541668,
-0.1043323949,
-0.1473367065,
0.0500827804,
-0.3955149651,
-0.0316721126,
-0.3108114302,
0.3260397315,
0.0532789081,
0.1854137331,
0.3217891455,
-0.409273386,
0.1211536229,
0.33523947,
0.5342400074,
0.4363912046,
-0.472523421,
0.5598697662,
0.2348257452,
-0.3882877529,
0.0368712544,
0.1684056371,
0.1651706845,
0.3750930429,
0.29560256,
0.6651679873,
0.8212974072,
-0.8900101781,
0.6187766194,
0.0043115192,
-0.0207774453,
-0.1970337778,
-0.4092858136,
0.0553551577,
0.1975262314,
0.4008543491,
0.0002424388,
0.081054166,
-0.6344262362,
-0.0157773159,
0.4085624218,
-0.406247735,
-0.2695949972,
0.493693769,
0.142131865,
-0.1076540053,
0.2161845416,
-0.4260442853,
-0.6556248665,
0.6616739631,
0.485787034,
0.7777865529,
-0.1595802903,
0.1829011738,
0.1759036779,
0.4637424946,
-0.1895837486,
0.1694097072,
-0.1571462899,
-1.1464080811,
-0.1203805134,
-0.5732453465,
-0.253904283,
-0.1539719403,
-0.8214561939,
0.1976480931,
0.0212321132,
-0.1094805971,
-0.3480874598,
-0.420974195,
-0.9899428487,
-0.31884408,
0.2449023277,
0.582705915,
-1.0318328142,
0.7929029465,
0.9329141974,
-0.188270539,
-0.5825319886,
-0.0638459697,
-0.1756540388,
-0.9409692287,
0.8392840624,
-0.1110342145,
-0.5629204512,
-0.2563376427,
-0.1040650979,
-0.8805255294,
1.0288197994,
0.3702175021,
-0.6500505209,
-0.2102662325,
0.6193950772,
0.7128404379,
-0.3463810384,
0.2071982771,
0.8922921419,
0.4679732025,
0.453648448,
-0.9714321494,
0.1123397127,
-0.0454011224,
0.3355807364,
0.0092262393,
-0.3649374247,
0.8010011315,
-0.1038720533,
-0.4802596867,
-0.0868118182,
0.5363228917,
0.0006511885,
-0.1701671034,
0.3942806721,
0.396489799,
0.7558393478,
-0.2509407103,
0.8322957158,
-0.3698812723,
0.4386625886,
1.3441268206,
-0.1499737948,
0.8499720097,
0.9173049927,
-0.38682428,
0.6552906632,
0.5929060578,
0.0349722765,
0.4422740638,
0.2182161361,
-0.0815232322,
0.0473116487,
-0.1273126453,
-0.3978406191,
0.6517159343,
0.4439334571,
-0.4005510509,
-0.5547424555,
0.073344335,
-0.0211527683,
0.2441843152,
-0.0626084879,
0.3296533823,
-0.0986139327,
-0.4578663707,
0.5766584873,
0.1879512668,
0.9493634105,
-0.4029751718,
0.3848315179,
-0.4212473035,
-0.252263248,
-0.1631609648,
-0.7777150869,
0.4448539615,
-0.0423620678,
-0.1524358988,
-0.474429965,
0.3721792996,
-0.4388252497,
-0.5246546268,
0.5055538416,
0.8382224441,
0.201724112,
-0.0077250041,
-0.4740255773,
0.0615621544,
-0.0430943482,
-0.0223709084,
-0.1247977689,
0.3244439662,
-0.0864748657,
0.3428103626,
0.1559920609,
0.1429761201,
0.5037596822,
0.4584026039,
0.6575776339,
-0.6666162014,
-0.2116751075,
-0.7375650406,
0.1526924968,
0.2939396501,
-0.2590724528,
0.6221615672,
0.5101769567,
0.9756872654,
-0.1200142428,
0.3167833686,
-0.1544733346,
0.1097405329,
-0.1969665587,
0.3030236661,
-0.5560317039,
0.4734432697,
-0.1742067486,
-0.9820122719,
-0.3817180395,
0.7528243661,
-0.251172483,
-0.171281144,
0.8026235104,
0.800768733,
-0.138448894,
-0.0401456691,
0.3075943291,
0.2755666375,
-0.0404246561,
0.5027249455,
1.0810834169,
-0.5599322319,
0.4504540265,
-0.3482345045,
0.0155573031,
-0.282322228,
-0.831025362,
-0.6258588433,
-0.8287590146,
-0.0781420991,
0.0322223119,
-0.1048979834,
0.8651124239,
0.4280047715,
-0.6977781057,
-0.3741748929,
-0.0631110668,
0.4978781044,
-0.0571000464,
-0.2566064596,
0.4909168482,
-0.3139927685,
-1.0196620226,
0.4533764124,
0.1714342684,
0.1407671422,
-0.534103632,
-0.0265785847,
-0.0926085562,
0.0588326827,
0.6472941041,
0.1835931987,
-1.0118079185,
-0.5078739524,
0.1392220706,
-0.2267683893,
0.1889927685,
0.7536336184,
-0.9783691168,
0.4153356254,
0.4985743463,
0.4538804889,
0.2799023688,
-0.2009483725,
0.2864718735,
-1.0582102537,
0.675033927,
0.3181751966,
0.6940848231,
0.2059316188,
-0.1416025311,
0.241783455,
-0.039063219,
-0.090773657,
-0.5650150776,
0.4064627886,
-1.1905459166,
-0.3859750628,
1.1906627417,
0.252592206,
-0.0386117771,
-0.1555514932,
-0.0975720212,
0.1790292412,
-0.3023253679,
0.91629076,
0.6659290195,
-0.2734284103,
0.116868712,
-0.2287861705,
0.190508008,
0.4688124061,
-0.3465867937,
-0.2858159244,
0.4298487604,
0.0208148472,
0.2429944277,
-0.0024800664,
-0.1811307222,
0.0010389404,
-0.2956081629,
0.0706334561,
0.1714105308,
-0.3030031621,
-0.4489617348,
0.0766121149,
0.0131480973,
-0.3312381208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14673v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14673v1 | Insights into LLM Long-Context Failures: When Transformers Know but Don't Tell | 2024-06-20T18:50:44 | 2024-06-20T18:50:44 | Taiming Lu, Muhan Gao, Kuai Yu, Adam Byerly, Daniel Khashabi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit positional bias, struggling to utilize
information from the middle or end of long contexts. Our study explores LLMs'
long-context reasoning by probing their hidden representations. We find that
while LLMs encode the position of target information, they often fail to
leverage this in generating accurate responses. This reveals a disconnect
between information retrieval and utilization, a "know but don't tell"
phenomenon. We further analyze the relationship between extraction time and
final accuracy, offering insights into the underlying mechanics of transformer
models. | [
-0.4668393433,
-0.5947821736,
1.1685771942,
0.210178405,
0.0147449933,
0.1338380128,
-0.2619515657,
-0.5219240189,
-0.063211903,
0.4236453176,
-0.7806671858,
-0.2212174386,
-0.8478266597,
0.0280605052,
-0.6419131756,
0.7318317294,
-0.1252246648,
-0.2143172622,
-0.1121446043,
-0.0835686103,
-0.3884716332,
-0.5890958905,
-0.4889814258,
-0.4481989741,
0.4288030565,
0.4296529889,
0.7670313716,
0.5087199807,
0.4397170246,
0.1876552403,
-0.4186570644,
-0.1496141553,
-0.5778499246,
0.3213061392,
-0.2438292652,
-0.8196796179,
0.1423985213,
-0.1460539103,
0.6226965785,
0.823705256,
0.0441759862,
-0.0247138366,
-0.0516018607,
0.5473421216,
-0.5506680012,
0.1160149574,
-0.5914381742,
0.1473916173,
-0.3473609686,
-0.1636570245,
-0.6787953973,
-0.1549921483,
0.40231812,
-0.1945426613,
0.4309656918,
0.0127496189,
0.7239417434,
0.5019003749,
-0.7923849225,
-0.339617759,
-1.1508584023,
1.1224803925,
-0.2969136834,
0.3697495461,
0.4696620107,
0.5506035686,
-0.3089911938,
-0.6521266699,
-0.5959695578,
-0.1031817421,
-0.3171530068,
-0.0463050008,
-0.1374534667,
-0.1689442247,
0.5231814384,
0.1141153425,
-0.167059809,
0.2335294634,
-0.4575286508,
0.135284692,
0.2534253597,
0.0363510251,
-0.0484862924,
-0.3681590855,
-0.827472806,
-0.1703732312,
-0.917868793,
0.1495230347,
0.1433619261,
-0.2506399453,
-0.0676026419,
0.6727871895,
0.2867481411,
0.4754167199,
0.1715742499,
-0.1159790978,
-0.16657269,
0.1270529777,
-0.3636490107,
0.0196541864,
0.729657352,
0.2655405104,
-0.0169550702,
-0.291647017,
-0.5185425282,
-0.1678023487,
0.3658231795,
-0.4098587036,
0.3504796624,
0.2196983099,
-0.4255452752,
-0.2874405086,
0.2005157471,
-0.5333936214,
-0.2927232087,
-0.1230980381,
0.4231570363,
-0.2975702286,
0.018043384,
-0.0915024728,
-0.2472798079,
0.5148408413,
0.0614202619,
-0.841591835,
0.0658280849,
0.5095191598,
0.6574876308,
-0.3829941154,
-0.2253992707,
-0.2324329466,
0.2435843199,
-0.4166830778,
0.7402595878,
-0.4058909416,
-0.6433357596,
-0.0031871435,
0.3180935681,
-0.0879484117,
-0.7162353396,
0.6654203534,
-0.7343397141,
0.0826350898,
-0.4472281933,
-0.4092364311,
-0.0409056507,
-0.0288620871,
-0.8462556601,
0.9371128678,
0.1695296764,
-0.7718863487,
0.3064256608,
-0.5254343152,
-0.4700425565,
-0.2689674795,
-0.2097883821,
-0.2314836532,
0.5358105302,
0.1801673919,
0.4564853311,
-0.0885078683,
0.4810599685,
-0.1161491498,
-0.6361656189,
0.6638751626,
-0.6391859055,
0.5044163465,
0.0212055407,
-0.4860643446,
-0.0964521766,
-0.4291405082,
-0.560646534,
0.4855608046,
-0.2407736182,
-0.1723357141,
0.3229341209,
-0.2358307987,
0.307600826,
0.2372434735,
-0.5333253145,
0.1650848985,
-0.1717135459,
0.5593577623,
0.7083238959,
-0.3273333907,
0.6983342171,
-0.306199789,
0.4687972963,
0.1359459609,
0.0902820677,
-0.2078438103,
-0.0920859277,
-1.0142626762,
0.4203264713,
-0.0083698574,
0.3721919954,
-0.866332829,
0.228734687,
-0.3793825805,
-0.3668793142,
-0.2505005896,
-0.1137862056,
0.1986882389,
0.6537544131,
0.447781235,
0.0920614004,
-0.4686969519,
-1.1815257072,
-0.3272580802,
0.078040719,
-0.1052739695,
0.2701745033,
0.4820095301,
-0.4442678988,
0.9515241385,
-0.531709969,
-0.1607797146,
-0.4797018766,
-0.1229976043,
0.3614869118,
-0.0385255218,
0.3352340758,
-0.861961484,
-0.0053002601,
-0.349524051,
-0.9851598144,
0.0846472085,
-0.0851503164,
0.1805821955,
0.1609816551,
0.6784610152,
-0.9275380969,
0.4983801544,
0.8143774867,
-0.2382988483,
0.5852693319,
-0.0301204585,
-0.2623632848,
-0.9475172162,
-0.0139816105,
0.0570671037,
-0.2494661212,
-0.3312340081,
-0.2800704837,
0.2282772362,
0.0829725564,
-0.519900322,
0.5540347099,
-0.5721872449,
-0.3036102653,
-0.3870370686,
0.3298095167,
0.1118047833,
0.3423579335,
0.0843217596,
0.9458086491,
0.3509651423,
-0.698065877,
0.0263286941,
0.1056181639,
-0.4435468018,
0.5608304143,
-0.627116859,
0.1626752764,
-0.3637642562,
0.4849229157,
-0.8878792524,
-0.3794138134,
-0.0436302908,
-0.2903365195,
0.5968526006,
-0.3661532998,
-0.5237230659,
-0.4874267578,
0.0344881676,
0.4056553841,
0.4487510026,
-0.8639522791,
0.3005928993,
0.3815242648,
0.0250702798,
-0.9898555875,
-0.986715138,
-0.0695425719,
-0.3652643561,
-0.5796729922,
0.4969694614,
0.1391943693,
-0.4930031598,
-0.1681658775,
-0.6645238996,
0.0473715365,
0.2673149109,
0.3634638786,
0.0069476818,
-0.1252281666,
0.4386694133,
0.1145810932,
-0.2541812062,
0.5174053907,
0.0356818736,
0.5982714295,
-0.0008742168,
-0.6768293381,
-0.3036049306,
0.3185347319,
0.7648194432,
0.1846639663,
1.0411548615,
0.3890366852,
-0.2236639708,
-0.2586456835,
-0.6813980937,
-0.3682286143,
-0.4983938932,
0.2367416918,
-0.2491488606,
-0.8238691688,
0.5221731067,
-0.1733308583,
-0.225379765,
0.6822066307,
0.1752934754,
-0.3172476292,
0.8194578886,
0.6792404652,
-0.0070045502,
0.4006741941,
-0.2905808091,
0.3558988273,
-0.8596404195,
-0.3904283941,
-0.5094788671,
-0.3586592078,
-0.4151387513,
-0.362611264,
0.4118849933,
0.3082775474,
-0.1354330778,
0.375316143,
-0.2642225325,
0.6693726182,
0.3842533529,
-0.0450317562,
0.244756937,
-0.1768431515,
0.0635244921,
-0.0607183352,
-0.3796253502,
-0.6130821705,
0.8776925802,
0.4843702912,
0.8955352306,
0.1769178212,
0.495298624,
0.0408831649,
0.1323764175,
-1.007797718,
0.3010389805,
0.2215979546,
-0.493211329,
-0.3508889675,
-0.1875797212,
-1.1140563488,
-0.0264402479,
0.2565999925,
-0.7500951886,
0.147112608,
-0.2353142351,
-0.1136753485,
0.4225805998,
-0.6388952136,
0.5547690392,
-0.3157794774,
-0.0314289033,
0.1775010079,
-0.8401369452,
0.2041780353,
-0.2013266832,
0.2938636541,
-0.0551679209,
0.113241367,
0.7737879753,
-0.2102174312,
0.8334177136,
-0.0131895542,
-0.2351826131,
0.371660471,
0.2855415344,
0.7221878767,
0.0509864092,
0.0153542142,
0.3380188942,
-0.1565241218,
-0.2547273338,
-0.6487826109,
0.6771929264,
-0.7046660185,
-0.6482918262,
-0.3556903005,
-0.3437135816,
-0.2006663233,
0.1229105145,
0.7819495797,
0.1674858183,
-0.0726571158,
0.3039471507,
0.6937922239,
-0.2402045578,
0.8533069491,
0.1751412749,
-0.1231753305,
0.2339229584,
0.2197895646,
0.1078301743,
0.3942145407,
0.4442454875,
0.0129508264,
-0.4600913823,
-0.2816813588,
-0.3286304474,
0.3671656549,
-1.0882283449,
-0.0217137933,
-0.4554895163,
-0.5396311283,
0.0262296628,
-0.1098608822,
-0.4805348814,
-0.266423434,
-0.2982266843,
-0.4024750292,
0.0324335098,
1.2226907015,
0.2333578467,
0.6674503088,
-0.90106529,
0.091046609,
0.2065374553,
0.2410840839,
0.0811109692,
-0.5321515203,
-0.1946301907,
-0.0538981594,
-0.477314055,
-1.081163168,
0.413495034,
-0.295042336,
0.5825152397,
0.2016884238,
0.002814841,
0.3365392685,
-0.4064202607,
0.9880120158,
-0.0087578241,
-1.0639817715,
0.5697498918,
-0.220502466,
0.4274947345,
0.0494898818,
0.4862351716,
-0.4323240817,
-0.1565712243,
-0.5265714526,
-0.858884871,
0.8168199658,
0.0959508643,
0.2413629442,
-0.2230695039,
0.2981882393,
0.2721694708,
0.0823649094,
-0.9123795629,
-0.4925763607,
0.1283170283,
0.1539663821,
-0.2567364573,
-0.7146868706,
-0.2378108799,
0.1057219207,
0.2066210508,
-0.1279981881,
0.5646021366,
0.3437070549,
-0.5172080398,
-0.1753751934,
0.4828238785,
0.9118965864,
1.1029628515,
-0.1479150057,
0.4556850791,
0.2320763171,
-0.2544540465,
0.0664230138,
-0.128439784,
0.1505966336,
0.1299433857,
0.4771625996,
0.9401760697,
0.4639663398,
-0.5626852512,
0.6951400638,
-0.1802792996,
0.0273723993,
-0.8965264559,
-0.1321276128,
0.1852625012,
0.4390638471,
0.7863124609,
0.143122077,
-0.1126927733,
-0.3749107718,
0.0677813441,
0.3810410798,
-0.6475595236,
-0.4567250609,
0.6479777694,
-0.2023290545,
-0.3392496407,
0.6997008324,
0.2263981849,
-0.4523169994,
0.6429344416,
0.5900452137,
0.6778479218,
-0.1829766929,
0.0045760907,
-0.0694587156,
0.1925509423,
-0.1336150765,
-0.125194326,
-0.0818323791,
-0.7363930941,
-0.7054674625,
-0.4413529932,
-0.357932359,
0.3310955465,
-0.7873718739,
0.2676021755,
-0.2869145274,
-0.3955824375,
-0.3449091613,
-0.5097045898,
-0.8449183702,
0.0207994673,
0.184799403,
0.8643099666,
-0.7104035616,
0.6333331466,
0.1121279299,
0.015891457,
-0.7940465808,
0.3042912483,
-0.122948505,
-0.8454034925,
1.0362976789,
0.5574087501,
-0.2214917094,
-0.3371046782,
-0.7800595164,
-1.0530717373,
1.2876055241,
0.4002717137,
-0.7054868937,
-0.3162748516,
0.1229937896,
0.4744786322,
-0.0329992026,
0.4565732479,
0.6355527043,
0.5480613112,
0.2624835372,
-1.0866131783,
0.0433845147,
0.4315970838,
-0.2977429628,
0.3530631959,
-0.8152858615,
0.8050838709,
-0.4109981358,
-0.2532565296,
-0.278817147,
0.4633683264,
0.0266476329,
0.3903113604,
0.2687393427,
0.5707307458,
0.5310564041,
-0.2767607868,
1.4031717777,
-0.0492367148,
0.5763520002,
0.9053419828,
-0.1563720107,
0.777369082,
0.6181244254,
-0.0051357583,
0.5599223971,
0.4530404508,
0.1318235546,
0.4790301323,
-0.0913015604,
-0.1833984554,
-0.1812058389,
0.1645098329,
-0.1871722341,
0.5492842793,
0.6220445633,
-0.8530481458,
-0.2170875072,
-0.087467812,
0.1151187643,
-0.2861897051,
-0.0307678301,
0.5563601851,
0.5686260462,
-0.9018561244,
0.6324486732,
-0.0513537452,
0.5378701687,
-0.1896221489,
0.2344315797,
-0.2308571488,
0.1311885566,
-0.158942461,
-1.1083160639,
0.4449565113,
-0.3489298522,
-0.4125702679,
-0.279696852,
0.7666920424,
-0.0397171639,
-0.086615704,
0.7134045959,
0.584926486,
0.0804664269,
-0.0700834319,
-0.3269132972,
0.0999414846,
-0.0764427334,
-0.4691669643,
0.3167347908,
0.4451853931,
-0.1923991293,
0.9729930758,
0.3725506961,
-0.0426980741,
0.0650387108,
-0.0106583899,
0.6107683182,
-0.929540813,
0.0966784284,
-1.099678278,
0.3864527047,
-0.0224147383,
0.0541244186,
0.6624010801,
0.2329414934,
0.8915833235,
-0.178627789,
0.7219635844,
0.3070040643,
0.5003785491,
-0.6786463857,
0.601432085,
-0.361633271,
0.5275014043,
0.1280465573,
-1.1744065285,
-0.1631711125,
0.3723483682,
-0.6650506258,
0.1194530725,
0.8877014518,
0.481901288,
-0.2053669989,
0.0022501359,
0.3954727054,
0.4428331554,
0.4766682684,
0.5235927105,
1.3140372038,
-0.4212784171,
0.6975085139,
-0.267008245,
0.1464614123,
-0.4104859829,
-0.8226638436,
-0.8272183537,
-0.5712200999,
0.1941599399,
-0.3834444582,
-0.2703190446,
0.4659438729,
0.7018134594,
-0.5726240873,
-0.0523889177,
0.0761838779,
0.4622250199,
0.1942486018,
-0.3091913164,
0.495490104,
-0.2933988869,
-0.6759507656,
0.8020001054,
0.3161403537,
0.2726168931,
-0.2953028977,
0.106629394,
0.2598861754,
-0.0416778959,
0.5285932422,
0.2058288455,
-0.8593226075,
-0.3820285201,
0.1414944828,
-0.187102288,
0.2978388369,
0.827329278,
-0.8418159485,
0.0978225544,
0.3051317334,
0.384510994,
0.483994782,
0.0631146431,
0.690335691,
-0.87861377,
0.0808760747,
0.264113456,
0.5794178247,
0.4954957664,
-0.4721628726,
0.3595395088,
0.1927351356,
-0.8441772461,
-0.6797819734,
0.410795778,
-0.9720227718,
-0.383985281,
1.3381659985,
0.0519773737,
-0.5099848509,
-0.0642755032,
-0.0856722742,
0.0862826556,
-0.1860640198,
0.7099853754,
0.7719891667,
-0.1829216629,
-0.0859912038,
-0.6895154715,
0.4720262587,
0.3074477911,
-0.2030234188,
-0.2230280787,
0.2063215822,
0.6018481851,
0.3655970097,
0.3171483278,
0.0731087327,
-0.2116284519,
-0.2229612172,
-0.3155137897,
0.2592068315,
-0.4888358116,
-0.33812356,
0.14515616,
0.2746774554,
-0.040979322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14670v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14670v1 | Exploring Design Choices for Building Language-Specific LLMs | 2024-06-20T18:47:43 | 2024-06-20T18:47:43 | Atula Tejaswi, Nilesh Gupta, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Despite rapid progress in large language models (LLMs), their performance on
a vast majority of languages remain unsatisfactory. In this paper, we study
building language-specific LLMs by adapting monolingual and multilingual LLMs.
We conduct systematic experiments on how design choices (base model selection,
vocabulary extension, and continued fine-tuning) impact the adapted LLM, both
in terms of efficiency (how many tokens are needed to encode the same amount of
information) and end task performance. We find that (1) the initial performance
before the adaptation is not always indicative of the final performance. (2)
Efficiency can easily improved with simple vocabulary extension and continued
fine-tuning in most LLMs we study, and (3) The optimal adaptation method is
highly language-dependent, and the simplest approach works well across various
experimental settings. Adapting English-centric models can yield better results
than adapting multilingual models despite their worse initial performance on
low-resource languages. Together, our work lays foundations on efficiently
building language-specific LLMs by adapting existing LLMs. | [
-0.4786574841,
-0.6929725409,
0.3638459444,
0.3695619106,
-0.4317836463,
0.1455033273,
-0.7292798758,
-0.5581233501,
0.1673375219,
0.4216771722,
-0.210147664,
-0.4279489517,
-0.4078389406,
0.2944944203,
0.0613748021,
0.7913987041,
-0.2823356092,
0.0259297434,
-0.0575280003,
-0.303129673,
-0.6866226792,
-0.5983834267,
-0.6404148936,
-0.3811930418,
0.5626814961,
0.5642620325,
0.6898421049,
0.6392530203,
0.3718982339,
0.2889261842,
-0.1387027204,
0.2148255706,
-0.526389122,
-0.109139435,
-0.3905229568,
-0.6055021286,
-0.4832550287,
-0.3616984487,
0.5442754626,
0.7954366803,
0.1312927902,
0.5355162621,
0.351449281,
0.4987726212,
-0.6166343093,
0.1309661865,
-0.6227173209,
0.1009682566,
-0.1804044694,
-0.3172816634,
-0.6177084446,
0.1049954295,
0.0233621765,
-0.4677951932,
-0.1009335369,
0.0991505608,
0.3272947967,
0.1224212348,
-0.2793807089,
-0.4564586282,
-0.7617103457,
0.789756,
-0.7875755429,
0.6929884553,
0.0400065407,
-0.0561311394,
-0.3655386269,
-0.4265687764,
0.0591484681,
-0.3510655761,
0.0082293926,
0.0384192243,
-0.0771351606,
0.0515737422,
0.1710241884,
0.15015845,
-0.6212612987,
0.5732868314,
-0.2787947655,
-0.0155541394,
0.5350620151,
0.1175158098,
0.2617017329,
-0.0640906617,
-0.1840162426,
0.254106015,
-0.7755197287,
0.2609024048,
0.2487282753,
0.7450072169,
-0.1813464165,
0.5198922157,
-0.0606116168,
0.8353771567,
-0.1428536326,
-0.2539227307,
0.1966418624,
-0.4392039478,
-0.2703924477,
-0.063715741,
0.4265990555,
0.2566726804,
0.5761272311,
-0.3184343576,
-0.2937221825,
0.0291964933,
0.1714237481,
-0.7863416076,
0.0092890142,
0.1620041728,
-0.5306249857,
-0.0442064144,
-0.4823594391,
-0.293022275,
-0.2372460067,
-0.4451364875,
0.4325338304,
-0.2379515171,
-0.3846132457,
0.4752339721,
-0.0770327225,
0.1468491852,
0.2460748553,
-0.8374032378,
0.2278724015,
0.5279781818,
0.8887001872,
-0.523973465,
-0.4908736348,
-0.365190655,
0.1517376155,
-0.6530908346,
0.7148940563,
-0.4785663188,
-0.642998755,
0.1404961795,
0.1125233695,
0.0643490851,
-0.5748211145,
0.4451542199,
-0.4926504493,
0.1286378652,
-0.3410906494,
-0.4652510285,
0.005551246,
0.0704912618,
-0.6508059502,
0.6166447997,
0.0423230343,
-0.6191527843,
0.3688214421,
-0.8523128629,
-0.8237990737,
0.0970513895,
0.0041754418,
-0.0060511096,
0.6872877479,
-0.0827067196,
0.4064602256,
-0.4652343988,
-0.0097789336,
-0.1085367128,
-0.5342892408,
0.1005935818,
-0.2516939342,
0.6337965131,
0.3583588898,
-0.0208968371,
0.0946074426,
-0.8013681173,
-0.024637837,
0.0596514605,
-0.7280791402,
-0.467202872,
0.231767416,
-0.0763014853,
-0.0010923654,
0.5018451214,
-0.31414029,
0.1019103602,
-0.2530002296,
0.0961892158,
1.0476429462,
-0.3959491253,
0.6566126943,
-0.544631958,
0.7370922565,
-0.255528152,
0.0166331045,
-0.0533882603,
-0.2784457803,
-1.0062615871,
-0.4014952481,
0.4135774374,
0.4240865409,
-0.6033080816,
-0.013048145,
-0.2377054989,
-0.2590128779,
-0.4679217637,
0.350361824,
0.2230778784,
0.1527698636,
0.0444121547,
-0.4667660892,
-0.7170718312,
-0.8912171721,
-0.4829041958,
-0.2983207107,
0.1238177642,
0.3002365232,
0.223623842,
-0.1103193387,
0.7269670963,
-0.3891914487,
0.1692430973,
-0.5444094539,
-0.2805600762,
0.6213765144,
0.0494404994,
0.8745839,
-0.502080977,
-0.707606554,
0.2549631596,
-0.5541660786,
-0.25819242,
-0.1734965444,
-0.0827770382,
0.2942437232,
0.3567035198,
-0.3196338415,
0.1068906188,
0.7485665679,
-0.2791558802,
0.7698028684,
-0.3705355823,
-0.0998202115,
-1.2299133539,
-0.1371879876,
-0.1574090123,
-0.1427794844,
-0.7881401777,
0.2883456647,
0.0743281171,
0.1207270995,
-0.5685748458,
0.8868091106,
-0.8045998812,
-0.149533838,
-0.5793352127,
-0.1754099429,
-0.1635401994,
0.5588903427,
0.1038122624,
0.9159782529,
0.6567754745,
-0.8961014748,
0.0622375198,
-0.0449767038,
-0.6007617116,
0.200282082,
-0.5802906156,
0.1310553104,
-0.3064101934,
-0.1494181603,
-0.808293581,
-0.0292083677,
-0.123253867,
-0.189724654,
0.2760878801,
-0.1735710055,
-0.5442157984,
-0.1747292578,
-0.36025846,
0.2998948693,
0.4880280197,
-0.60781914,
0.7389819026,
0.3039883077,
-0.349817574,
-0.2474128157,
-0.7997965813,
0.1538501978,
-0.2228218764,
-0.6014335155,
0.3067791462,
-0.5496500731,
-0.3192451298,
-0.1462923884,
-0.1988428831,
0.1283747405,
0.4257324338,
0.0305050127,
0.077038154,
-0.4073983431,
0.2801046073,
-0.0633503646,
0.1530361325,
-0.1512093544,
-0.2679571509,
0.6297450662,
-0.070134677,
-0.2969512343,
0.1393444091,
0.4567272961,
0.7263621092,
-0.3123047352,
0.7046868801,
0.2679391205,
-0.35731709,
-0.548201263,
-0.5219001174,
0.0805526227,
-0.5218265057,
0.7555856109,
-1.0196663141,
-1.0014052391,
0.7027918696,
-0.2256436497,
0.4548519254,
0.0881552324,
0.9512465596,
0.060441561,
0.6565369964,
1.1310870647,
-0.1008668095,
0.7944725156,
0.1490387917,
0.1702445149,
-0.8184157014,
0.1297475845,
-0.3683646023,
-0.3857023418,
-0.8231583834,
-0.5220690966,
0.1353964508,
0.1045377329,
-0.0202610455,
0.6294968724,
-0.2252674252,
0.3620558977,
0.2015011907,
-0.1041882187,
0.4138332605,
0.1670948565,
-0.3765265346,
0.1946579069,
-1.012840867,
-0.5654681921,
1.2567507029,
0.3341629505,
0.8898002505,
0.4948616922,
0.5752049685,
0.0200549047,
0.4722949862,
-0.6567161083,
0.4561724365,
-0.5650012493,
-0.4969375134,
-0.200137198,
-0.2643942237,
-0.999404192,
0.4557705224,
0.0557738692,
-0.4577510357,
0.158593148,
-0.0616764091,
-0.1607529372,
0.1906863302,
-0.7892225385,
0.6087369919,
-0.5442398787,
-0.2655086517,
-0.2660132051,
-0.0195946675,
0.0334267318,
-0.48241207,
0.5892712474,
-0.0968341604,
-0.170864448,
0.5323482156,
0.0150768962,
0.6811598539,
0.1171741858,
-0.252677083,
0.1923464537,
0.0659356266,
0.5291296244,
0.0169486906,
-0.4755364358,
-0.0357797742,
-0.2911173105,
-0.4805137515,
-0.4606904685,
0.8076509833,
-0.8382805586,
-0.8749276996,
0.1009148806,
-0.7650964856,
-0.2945562005,
0.2334916145,
0.0651904419,
0.2901040912,
-0.4106996357,
0.1188475788,
0.4080370069,
-0.2486436963,
0.5196592808,
0.9515267015,
-0.4864321947,
-0.1323998868,
0.7821199894,
0.2936145365,
0.4125556648,
0.4162520468,
0.3009489775,
-0.1049045846,
-0.9052922726,
-0.5837770104,
0.1269594282,
-0.7195942998,
0.0662723035,
-0.2797014713,
-0.1669608802,
-0.2041891813,
-0.3662675917,
-0.4518157542,
-0.3395503759,
-0.5207436681,
-0.0762055144,
0.2752938271,
0.4762782753,
-0.0695592985,
-0.0570117645,
-0.568579495,
0.3057773709,
0.2767292857,
0.5382151008,
-0.0751044825,
-0.9554191828,
-0.5056738853,
-0.0985728204,
0.1702832133,
-0.60765028,
0.049379468,
0.2523702085,
0.7967807055,
-0.0849032551,
-0.1250635833,
0.6723846197,
-0.7942085862,
0.534059763,
0.1153893396,
-0.5611844063,
0.3075731397,
-0.1970534772,
0.626058042,
0.428189069,
0.1570809335,
-0.4972092807,
-0.1247541457,
0.0067733312,
-0.6806167364,
0.4208647907,
-0.0339999646,
0.4207172096,
0.0092630181,
0.4935864508,
0.2711237669,
0.0017023762,
-0.6662217975,
-0.2252381146,
0.1380855292,
0.0011227161,
-0.2734104693,
-0.2037237287,
0.1176526323,
-0.0134190414,
0.4039952457,
-0.3645493686,
0.1173632368,
-0.0626737401,
-0.4317434132,
-0.0804966912,
0.4564858973,
0.5086817145,
0.838593483,
0.0037661137,
0.1436668634,
0.6034727693,
0.0150091937,
0.2547110021,
-0.0833272636,
0.0009883586,
0.0875280425,
0.3989341557,
1.0050809383,
0.1734975427,
-0.6619256139,
0.0136338528,
-0.0517434254,
-0.0540872738,
-0.0959165022,
0.1865977347,
0.4545488358,
0.3504661024,
0.186711818,
-0.1551402062,
-0.1481842548,
-0.7262311578,
-0.0121524613,
0.6145987511,
0.0564189218,
-0.5012948513,
0.2788892388,
0.3024421632,
-0.6940736175,
0.1046271473,
-0.102760464,
-0.2730751038,
0.4891643524,
0.7522784472,
0.886049211,
-0.2878755033,
0.0367250629,
0.1465999186,
0.4648067951,
-0.0956471637,
0.5085539818,
0.0582935028,
-0.9367405772,
-0.8073721528,
-0.7642431855,
-0.2591326237,
-0.0226370227,
-0.3857936859,
0.466028899,
-0.5063408017,
-0.235095337,
-0.3186588585,
0.0415069498,
-0.898701787,
0.0839550346,
0.3927369416,
1.2455638647,
-0.6600189805,
0.6367812157,
1.0648914576,
0.0939413905,
-0.5010105968,
-0.3972842395,
-0.176343143,
-0.9213434458,
0.3352946639,
-0.3307201266,
-0.3317455649,
-0.1295358986,
-0.1919631958,
-1.0139335394,
0.9474429488,
0.5822905302,
-0.7520090342,
-0.0618241616,
0.4348633587,
0.6160977483,
-0.5279274583,
0.0000243668,
0.4042494893,
0.3213365972,
-0.1472218335,
-1.181494236,
0.0232119579,
-0.2017911673,
0.3002092838,
0.2360241115,
-0.893056035,
0.6320385337,
-0.3152572811,
-0.1925376654,
0.2667872608,
0.5050367713,
0.3098506629,
-0.2106762677,
0.4720705152,
0.3861363828,
0.6059252024,
0.3164450228,
0.9475640655,
-0.6746163368,
0.1639746577,
1.1477584839,
-0.17001912,
0.9095709324,
0.5277323723,
-0.0960050449,
0.337217778,
0.6726174951,
0.2406722307,
0.5318008661,
0.4744353592,
-0.1905946583,
-0.3010287881,
-0.316316098,
-0.3360981941,
0.6004446149,
0.3323668838,
-0.2394791692,
-0.1656765938,
-0.0215007514,
0.01350429,
-0.2616687715,
-0.3248577714,
0.5802205205,
0.176823929,
-0.6971325278,
0.6698491573,
0.3021075726,
0.7506596446,
-0.5864129663,
0.4883716702,
-0.4558783472,
0.1302425861,
-0.1343996972,
-0.6185982227,
0.1083322391,
0.1113980338,
-0.3576469719,
-0.4073777199,
0.7240633368,
-0.4286552966,
-0.681882143,
0.5804300308,
0.8535890579,
-0.0091728866,
0.1636903733,
-0.5008850098,
0.464143157,
0.1736672372,
-0.3976943493,
0.5852892995,
0.5145514011,
-0.0745771378,
0.5158318877,
0.8275856972,
0.3058052659,
0.0505630635,
0.2062676847,
0.8716940284,
-0.5560203195,
-0.3367468119,
-0.7986816764,
0.4576970935,
0.2505595982,
-0.3196213543,
0.743658483,
0.6437709332,
1.0491546392,
-0.0640634522,
0.8541921377,
0.242128551,
0.0937675983,
-0.5483973622,
0.4662907422,
-0.8066445589,
0.4110245705,
-0.2495051771,
-1.0718226433,
-0.2206639498,
0.3802703023,
0.0017266846,
-0.004626757,
0.6078413725,
0.7481952906,
-0.0227762461,
-0.1675154716,
0.5644750595,
0.2644529641,
0.3902283609,
0.7118637562,
0.6719287038,
-0.0558502264,
0.4489431977,
-0.1248057261,
-0.4318421185,
-0.2046536356,
-1.0621737242,
-0.9562465549,
-0.2716268599,
-0.3268163502,
0.1395180821,
0.1446143687,
0.8531898856,
0.7495033145,
-0.7488675714,
-0.7269399762,
0.0745103881,
0.2410662472,
0.0738850608,
-0.0993233249,
0.1944306642,
-0.5174985528,
-0.6563997269,
0.5244669914,
0.4771427214,
-0.0382935032,
-0.096236527,
-0.2878690362,
0.0388349704,
0.2614211142,
0.8991678953,
0.160476923,
-0.6940274239,
-0.4060061276,
0.3882832229,
0.0042065158,
0.1628445089,
0.9298464656,
-0.5085398555,
0.4843623936,
0.5405389071,
0.8016671538,
0.2979846001,
-0.3406351209,
0.7182796597,
-0.5097156167,
0.200696066,
-0.0588396266,
0.585850656,
0.2255505472,
0.0198198576,
0.449537307,
-0.0865088776,
-0.355126977,
-0.7888489962,
0.4654840529,
-0.5241429806,
-0.6158240438,
1.3918539286,
0.0340776742,
-0.019900864,
-0.1200314984,
-0.1291799247,
0.0601141118,
-0.0067758048,
0.6030832529,
1.052215457,
-0.2630220354,
-0.1352538019,
-0.4390241206,
0.2319501042,
0.5627290606,
-0.5456084609,
0.0709893852,
0.1309465766,
0.5610842109,
0.1434377283,
0.6630715132,
0.1161234751,
0.3164185882,
-0.2848645747,
-0.0796214044,
0.0770608634,
-0.4438917339,
-0.3829467595,
0.1612504423,
0.7832506895,
-0.0350989625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15513v1 | PKU-SafeRLHF: A Safety Alignment Preference Dataset for Llama Family Models | 2024-06-20T18:37:36 | 2024-06-20T18:37:36 | Jiaming Ji, Donghai Hong, Borong Zhang, Boyuan Chen, Josef Dai, Boren Zheng, Tianyi Qiu, Boxun Li, Yaodong Yang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | In this work, we introduce the PKU-SafeRLHF dataset, designed to promote
research on safety alignment in large language models (LLMs). As a sibling
project to SafeRLHF and BeaverTails, we separate annotations of helpfulness and
harmlessness for question-answering pairs, providing distinct perspectives on
these coupled attributes. Overall, we provide 44.6k refined prompts and 265k
question-answer pairs with safety meta-labels for 19 harm categories and three
severity levels ranging from minor to severe, with answers generated by
Llama-family models. Based on this, we collected 166.8k preference data,
including dual-preference (helpfulness and harmlessness decoupled) and
single-preference data (trade-off the helpfulness and harmlessness from
scratch), respectively. Using the large-scale annotation data, we further train
severity-sensitive moderation for the risk control of LLMs and safety-centric
RLHF algorithms for the safety alignment of LLMs. We believe this dataset will
be a valuable resource for the community, aiding in the safe deployment of
LLMs. | [
-0.1205624267,
-0.6214584708,
0.2529472411,
0.1665946245,
-0.26765275,
-0.0785699338,
0.0536674969,
-0.5767305493,
0.1616705656,
0.5657168627,
-0.3882918954,
-0.5711954236,
-0.6188187003,
-0.0420601256,
-0.1736606359,
1.3129462004,
0.0368797518,
-0.3177995384,
-0.0656333566,
0.0398902372,
-0.3242518604,
-0.7518280745,
-0.4624317586,
-0.0217077974,
1.2150611877,
0.530674994,
1.1810697317,
1.0162332058,
0.9176887274,
0.0680455044,
-0.1064060852,
-0.1898699552,
-0.451466471,
0.276014179,
-0.0787896886,
-0.157445237,
-0.8146657944,
-0.2164278775,
0.3205613792,
0.6406598687,
-0.3435108364,
0.1675002277,
0.0598544218,
0.4649319947,
-0.7368324995,
0.0945600197,
-0.555886209,
0.0897388607,
-0.2053016871,
-0.1597761065,
-0.360732466,
-0.717243731,
0.2724299729,
-0.5941695571,
-0.2215086669,
0.2738332748,
0.8055744767,
0.4154523611,
-0.7180088162,
-0.0652391538,
-0.1217875406,
0.7581094503,
-0.5961635709,
0.0532884486,
0.6312947869,
0.1248356849,
-0.466204077,
-0.2941442132,
-0.3069715202,
0.1175297424,
-0.2367447615,
-0.130583182,
0.0511117838,
0.2230071872,
-0.0083374968,
0.2513239682,
-0.7046450973,
0.4804370701,
-0.0218437724,
-0.6255766153,
0.9957146645,
0.3715150356,
0.3970841169,
-0.3501774669,
-0.457806319,
-0.2826317549,
-1.1519098282,
0.1257341653,
0.5419668555,
0.3419027627,
-0.3058763146,
0.6405233741,
-0.3653588295,
0.6316938996,
-0.2371499091,
-0.504034102,
0.4249878526,
-0.2976890802,
-0.118184045,
0.447670728,
1.0918759108,
0.9609367847,
0.2771525383,
-0.1189422682,
-0.0536962859,
-0.0028122843,
0.152156353,
-0.5544697642,
-0.3680759966,
0.1261879355,
-0.4285440743,
-0.8426673412,
-0.1360795051,
-0.9197539091,
-0.7505180836,
-0.1635785997,
0.2352474481,
-0.0313551053,
-0.5401220322,
0.1571884155,
0.2624694109,
0.4929772913,
0.1604722142,
-0.9591807723,
-0.099308461,
0.9059432745,
0.3344476223,
-0.1652875245,
-0.2565334141,
-0.6010913849,
0.418941021,
-0.3554371893,
0.6293756962,
-0.5048804283,
-0.4087467492,
0.1383777261,
0.3208186626,
0.0401579179,
-0.3597508967,
0.9168571234,
-0.4785718918,
-0.1631745249,
-0.4752921164,
-0.2063831538,
-0.3604706824,
0.0558670834,
-0.5453052521,
0.9205887914,
-0.0709191412,
-1.1315865517,
0.4865822792,
-0.2496695518,
-0.5454740524,
-0.182028085,
0.0298515316,
-0.5902378559,
-0.4491463304,
0.2298206091,
0.607888639,
-0.1422135532,
0.6063745022,
-0.8266142607,
-0.0659885257,
0.3416257203,
-0.4810067117,
0.8760243654,
0.1185120195,
-0.0660758466,
0.3553961217,
-0.5812036991,
-0.2987610102,
0.1981166601,
-0.5586711168,
-0.3568252027,
-0.0707263947,
0.152155906,
0.3117798865,
0.5340481997,
-0.5015739799,
0.0584980883,
-0.1160218269,
0.1940465569,
0.9192961454,
0.1602426618,
0.2882727683,
-0.5746209025,
0.3952195644,
0.1439636499,
0.7085407972,
0.0937379375,
-0.656861186,
-0.5776212811,
-0.1529780477,
0.2530420721,
0.7025043368,
-0.2909907401,
0.8556815982,
-0.2210009545,
-0.2809340954,
-0.4531939924,
0.2633698285,
0.5394439697,
0.8707102537,
0.1320563853,
-0.1607314348,
-0.4870970249,
-1.3181749582,
0.3290039301,
-0.5094120502,
0.2102514505,
0.0961236805,
0.1234900877,
-0.162541911,
0.7812303305,
-0.5750713348,
0.1855590343,
0.1469852477,
-0.1972471476,
0.0112880301,
0.5743245482,
0.4639041722,
-0.7261252999,
-0.2617553473,
-0.1383642703,
-0.7073664069,
-0.0290189795,
0.3548057675,
-0.6174286604,
0.2815331519,
0.1993472725,
-0.5276480317,
0.2496173829,
0.5801738501,
-0.3189549446,
0.2023220509,
0.165218845,
-0.0055299173,
-1.2081036568,
0.1416945904,
-0.0823588148,
-0.2111566216,
-0.5701926947,
0.1374838948,
0.17137748,
0.3802703619,
-0.674094975,
0.2300300896,
0.0759094879,
0.0155330673,
0.0759316459,
0.0810590312,
-0.2671208382,
0.3336316049,
0.1194744334,
0.8053438663,
0.7042355537,
-0.4205366671,
0.3866415024,
0.4171181917,
-0.13893345,
0.2581963837,
-0.4638015032,
0.3023352921,
-0.0859341472,
0.1777586788,
-0.7658154368,
-0.778499186,
0.6376165152,
-0.1803008169,
0.2200182825,
-0.2119140327,
-0.5771844983,
-0.0673566982,
-0.6653855443,
0.3907780051,
0.4501681626,
-0.4688297808,
0.1928629726,
0.9530123472,
-0.6185761094,
-1.1017005444,
-0.4993575513,
-0.005821581,
-0.6449151039,
-0.6546192169,
-0.1183542907,
-0.0653545931,
-0.2745376229,
-0.0127421031,
0.0184274074,
0.0726934448,
0.3405399024,
0.6076869369,
0.7511723638,
-0.1284963638,
0.1264858991,
0.1076840013,
-0.320366025,
0.0395646505,
0.4529861808,
0.2512755692,
-0.1492894143,
-0.0401554331,
-0.1810218096,
0.3792615533,
0.3059313893,
-0.1295780838,
0.8147602081,
0.1445884705,
-0.4122717977,
0.3764152825,
-0.4276320934,
-0.1128828973,
-0.4131321907,
0.1265356541,
0.1019302607,
-1.253495574,
0.2660349309,
0.3662328124,
0.4857080877,
0.4562237859,
0.3312060237,
-0.3448782563,
1.0257635117,
0.5529022217,
-0.5522966385,
0.0731767267,
0.4130573869,
0.2971831262,
-0.7194969654,
-0.2680414915,
-0.4277618229,
-0.2669591308,
-0.6054210067,
-0.1120138243,
0.3973192871,
0.2238101214,
-0.651439786,
0.3389748037,
-0.4577593803,
0.4024726748,
0.4062090218,
0.142924428,
0.4195891023,
0.0304682087,
0.0886653215,
0.0363406539,
-0.4645423293,
-0.7945679426,
1.421164155,
0.616625905,
0.9067776799,
0.2969932854,
0.6805918813,
-0.1343488991,
0.4213854671,
-0.8059355021,
0.6823526025,
-0.1353527606,
-0.7472872734,
-0.3852405846,
-0.3937421739,
-0.8981926441,
-0.117822662,
-0.3082160056,
-0.7362513542,
-0.0634909943,
0.282423079,
-0.6505506039,
0.1230878606,
-0.6382088065,
0.6614705324,
-0.4683153629,
-0.1964178383,
-0.1413616687,
-1.1285936832,
0.7005656362,
-0.3094510436,
0.1851163357,
-0.4931791127,
-0.2728134394,
0.8828651309,
-0.0828184858,
0.9135459661,
0.1187768281,
-0.4758381844,
0.2312372178,
0.0576827973,
0.3515069783,
0.1682865918,
-0.2379164994,
0.1481244862,
0.1398058385,
-0.1341723055,
-0.1073957607,
0.9118770361,
-0.7603515983,
-0.755269289,
-0.5953285098,
-0.7549320459,
-0.3506664038,
0.203415975,
-0.0789565295,
0.1850949675,
0.2447703779,
0.4501626492,
0.9378747344,
-0.3568104208,
0.596196115,
0.3931594789,
-0.335416913,
-0.5219826102,
0.6962509751,
-0.0617567375,
0.1398114711,
0.4403777421,
0.1673188806,
-0.5753954649,
-0.4079115987,
-0.4347198308,
0.2332134992,
-0.9674454927,
-0.4423860013,
-0.5793883801,
-0.2799921036,
-0.2352816314,
-0.1005221531,
-0.0181963444,
-0.5491449833,
-0.0918468609,
-0.5433146358,
0.7937986255,
0.6563209891,
-0.0612293705,
0.1240885258,
-0.8480735421,
0.1593152732,
0.2961633801,
0.4713131189,
-0.325230509,
-0.15799658,
0.2109357566,
-0.2045654207,
-0.2123496979,
-0.6711864471,
-0.0260915495,
-0.1831352711,
0.4914110899,
0.4217653573,
0.563390553,
0.3819229305,
-0.1217245683,
0.7286117673,
0.2927669585,
-0.3005294204,
0.4871504903,
-0.7462633848,
-0.2638539076,
0.796309948,
0.4825700819,
-0.4643778205,
-0.0345565975,
-0.2679628432,
-0.902528882,
0.5871334076,
0.0107964212,
0.0909258276,
0.1424094886,
0.3213913441,
0.2778143585,
0.0768680423,
-0.7084450126,
-0.3028217256,
0.116031684,
-0.6542158723,
0.0098008988,
-0.4347871542,
-0.6043456197,
-0.1127563789,
0.7967267632,
-0.152220875,
-0.1269904375,
-0.2391514331,
0.1239695475,
-0.4344932437,
0.3404693305,
0.3003585935,
0.2877555788,
-0.3298633993,
0.4054320455,
0.1547342986,
-0.579715848,
0.2901878059,
0.1238128915,
-0.2286360562,
-0.6605052948,
0.3119184375,
0.480609268,
0.2811368108,
-0.6366217732,
0.4790977538,
-0.1480443329,
-0.0774686858,
-0.0431806594,
0.4054009616,
0.3880225122,
-0.2713757157,
0.0023242938,
-0.2067005634,
0.0134862335,
-0.131307736,
0.2185554653,
0.4340266883,
-0.1521398574,
0.0017902054,
0.3525781035,
0.276847899,
-0.1810670346,
0.4114907682,
0.1997075081,
-0.2803941667,
0.5254166722,
0.1351296604,
0.6886897087,
-0.1674188524,
0.0888285041,
0.4220086038,
0.387778163,
0.0455842167,
0.2747411132,
0.1035478264,
-0.5705453157,
-0.0792872459,
-0.8394655585,
-0.3726226985,
0.4287426472,
-0.549873054,
0.2669453323,
-0.6006630659,
-0.2070851028,
-0.2565129697,
-0.2365714908,
-0.1620369554,
0.138733387,
0.0170698091,
0.6477465034,
-0.7900124192,
0.7950769663,
0.7309064269,
-0.3608435094,
-1.2203229666,
0.3127685189,
0.1576910317,
-0.6588107347,
0.3075980842,
0.2338264585,
-0.1575377733,
-0.2774047554,
-0.4847295582,
-1.0723619461,
1.1821633577,
0.5280094743,
-0.8753095269,
-0.0098523768,
0.3008533716,
0.1922388971,
0.0332430638,
-0.2943795323,
0.6774019599,
0.4499459863,
-0.0575553626,
-1.1476767063,
0.1551064253,
-0.1146728769,
-0.1439023912,
0.3536340892,
-0.8003983498,
0.3758419454,
-0.0610938184,
0.0431339666,
0.0164845511,
0.3787908852,
0.552919805,
0.2404111028,
0.6374866962,
0.6727958322,
0.5216010213,
-0.1466429979,
0.8336342573,
-0.281565398,
0.2033366412,
1.0219888687,
-0.2666341662,
1.0586630106,
0.7350187302,
-0.1847674698,
0.1135472134,
0.9910828471,
0.4589724839,
0.6294196248,
-0.0011614637,
-0.4309626818,
-0.4690351486,
-0.3288400471,
-0.5295058489,
0.2569595277,
0.1401784122,
-0.3233979046,
-0.1456650645,
-0.2730295658,
0.3331815004,
-0.3388780653,
-0.1840040535,
0.8293201327,
0.1505994052,
-0.7584924698,
0.3231766522,
-0.1994865537,
0.8374878764,
-0.4389536679,
0.0177140385,
-0.1746057719,
-0.0337148756,
-0.4582621157,
-1.4780861139,
0.2914726734,
0.022945825,
-0.0013545188,
0.0111864386,
0.8679980636,
-0.2387419045,
-0.3920410275,
0.2733666301,
-0.0366093405,
-0.0096747447,
0.5300731659,
-0.5427963138,
0.0988213718,
-0.2217868567,
-0.2409718782,
0.5296082497,
-0.04153933,
-0.3421019912,
0.6922444701,
0.5921915174,
-0.1317340881,
0.2717053294,
-0.0797118843,
0.8586547375,
-0.2916101813,
-0.3964450955,
-0.5849482417,
0.5596674085,
0.1661947221,
-0.3692527413,
0.4944934249,
0.3698390722,
0.6697719097,
0.0245008543,
0.780107975,
-0.0531238839,
0.4704962969,
-0.5264020562,
0.8859126568,
-0.3491988182,
0.1186100692,
-0.3098224699,
-0.6559084058,
-0.5927405953,
0.606313169,
-0.3668389022,
-0.1907275617,
0.2818968594,
1.2065753937,
0.1411980093,
0.3097826838,
0.0836201608,
-0.2101471126,
0.239038974,
0.8437905312,
1.0319640636,
-0.2104987055,
0.6058390737,
-0.7477413416,
-0.2204917818,
-0.2938371301,
-1.2935333252,
-0.7717778683,
-0.4463981092,
-0.5085820556,
-0.1494107544,
0.0046389038,
1.2023115158,
0.5659897923,
-0.9548079371,
-0.0177909173,
-0.0037690036,
0.0087672258,
0.1847379059,
-0.1527605951,
0.4739644825,
0.0706060082,
-0.1764602065,
0.2634291947,
0.2953511178,
0.1102078408,
-0.0865112841,
-0.2868798971,
-0.0620201305,
-0.3338582218,
0.4283145666,
0.2175492197,
-0.6872627139,
-0.7274515629,
-0.0288653895,
-0.3964269459,
0.0178617481,
0.4283349514,
-0.1519777775,
0.1247544214,
0.5180643201,
0.787997961,
-0.2808127701,
-0.096251063,
0.4007283151,
-0.3783178031,
0.0521045402,
0.0785860196,
0.512055099,
0.6036786437,
-0.8630846739,
0.5377119184,
-0.0883163363,
-0.6983733773,
-0.8436818719,
0.2383260578,
-1.0452013016,
0.1517923027,
1.3975894451,
-0.1752938628,
-0.0728058964,
-0.3613709807,
-0.5455992818,
0.4802819788,
-0.5355694294,
0.7970279455,
0.7786878943,
-0.1556348503,
-0.2997627556,
-0.4015198946,
0.6125012636,
0.5905794501,
-0.979652822,
0.3433197439,
0.600033164,
0.5705646276,
0.0474554487,
0.3773290217,
-0.3555750251,
0.3888902962,
-0.4512031078,
-0.1810091287,
0.0128196198,
-0.4755330682,
-0.6184567213,
0.2185414284,
0.4256515503,
-0.1393087506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14666v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14666v1 | Co-training for Low Resource Scientific Natural Language Inference | 2024-06-20T18:35:47 | 2024-06-20T18:35:47 | Mobashir Sadat, Cornelia Caragea | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scientific Natural Language Inference (NLI) is the task of predicting the
semantic relation between a pair of sentences extracted from research articles.
The automatic annotation method based on distant supervision for the training
set of SciNLI (Sadat and Caragea, 2022b), the first and most popular dataset
for this task, results in label noise which inevitably degenerates the
performance of classifiers. In this paper, we propose a novel co-training
method that assigns weights based on the training dynamics of the classifiers
to the distantly supervised labels, reflective of the manner they are used in
the subsequent training epochs. That is, unlike the existing semi-supervised
learning (SSL) approaches, we consider the historical behavior of the
classifiers to evaluate the quality of the automatically annotated labels.
Furthermore, by assigning importance weights instead of filtering out examples
based on an arbitrary threshold on the predicted confidence, we maximize the
usage of automatically labeled data, while ensuring that the noisy labels have
a minimal impact on model training. The proposed method obtains an improvement
of 1.5% in Macro F1 over the distant supervision baseline, and substantial
improvements over several other strong SSL baselines. We make our code and data
available on Github. | [
-0.2898049951,
-0.5428587794,
0.1381731629,
0.1991876066,
-0.2441305071,
-0.0153933847,
-0.3654188514,
-0.7340219617,
0.4040914774,
0.1059693024,
-0.6017801166,
-0.5217056274,
-0.4709730446,
0.3862951994,
0.0119667882,
1.2275824547,
0.0760178417,
0.2512931824,
-0.3165827096,
-0.1372903585,
0.1426427066,
-0.3706703484,
-0.6031482816,
-0.2326714396,
0.6530163884,
0.0943891779,
0.5409466624,
0.4095189571,
0.46268785,
0.2682159245,
-0.1698337495,
0.2794609666,
-0.440369904,
-0.2192435116,
-0.0664711818,
-0.4689680338,
-0.3107858002,
0.1394899487,
0.4107733071,
1.079657197,
0.2866562903,
0.2419397235,
0.0127251064,
0.4029980004,
-0.5620240569,
0.4596427083,
-0.5209581256,
0.3431749642,
-0.0346997567,
-0.2542957664,
-0.6656430364,
-0.3128687143,
0.4181482792,
-0.8630877733,
0.3642840683,
0.3078152537,
1.1314072609,
0.5741477609,
-0.1601625681,
-0.3471641541,
-0.5784361959,
1.2559347153,
-0.6764576435,
0.2922594845,
0.5512077212,
-0.0426846817,
-0.0327247567,
-0.4336188138,
-0.2048913538,
-0.3657886982,
-0.3477618992,
0.2033960521,
0.1795266569,
0.1233802438,
0.0359416008,
0.2603340149,
-0.1928759366,
0.1373293102,
-0.5186296105,
-0.2210252285,
0.784401834,
-0.3325961232,
0.072424978,
-0.105804652,
-0.3690391481,
-0.0698239654,
-0.3430437148,
-0.1599060893,
0.2744826674,
0.4060821235,
-0.3459999561,
0.4770595729,
-0.2382553816,
0.820538938,
0.2216922343,
-0.1206662208,
0.4173887968,
-0.5072630048,
-0.1610526592,
0.5011397004,
0.9837114215,
0.2317806631,
0.1877580583,
-0.4005458653,
0.2641924918,
-0.1314877123,
0.0330712125,
-0.6086786389,
-0.4261793196,
-0.128530845,
-0.067947574,
-0.493503511,
-0.0003145379,
-0.7785509825,
0.0118340068,
-0.4656036198,
0.4630842209,
-0.3617166281,
0.0365325473,
-0.2809516191,
0.0549871773,
-0.3863785267,
0.2232291847,
-1.0702457428,
0.2986913323,
0.4935004413,
0.9972656965,
-0.0346710347,
-0.1298250705,
-0.7082824111,
0.3554179966,
-0.0760446191,
0.5054893494,
-0.5683203936,
0.0518443435,
-0.3420616686,
-0.1643335521,
-0.2348201126,
-0.2710941732,
0.4791899621,
-0.7349741459,
0.3007983863,
0.0828078762,
-0.5992360711,
-0.0991451666,
-0.0154557135,
-0.8096243739,
1.1966016293,
0.0908033699,
-1.1083927155,
0.5798677206,
-0.7945657969,
-0.4216090143,
0.0025117104,
-0.0428027958,
-0.8125880361,
-0.2287986726,
0.1163230613,
0.4027472138,
-0.0003914297,
0.8118729591,
-0.6653441191,
-0.2980521023,
-0.1188124567,
-0.1443555802,
0.7603841424,
0.0961104631,
-0.3240848482,
-0.0272421092,
-0.9980840683,
-0.0219603796,
-0.315350771,
-0.1101469249,
-0.9254205823,
-0.1942903847,
-0.3063825071,
-0.0600019544,
0.1118251011,
-0.5719319582,
0.0193412472,
-0.8109552264,
0.312803179,
0.3764134645,
0.2184134573,
0.6726053357,
0.0820280463,
0.1080750823,
-0.2046446353,
0.0965692326,
0.424824506,
-0.4104668796,
-0.573117435,
-0.6518566012,
0.4783118069,
0.3373259306,
-0.6073355675,
0.7751476169,
-0.3138732612,
-0.4475814998,
-0.5669816136,
0.3349380791,
0.2916903794,
0.6232855916,
0.6495937705,
-0.1078737825,
-0.8292172551,
-0.7756173015,
-0.1171183214,
-0.1386137307,
-0.0220677052,
0.1774685085,
0.6567905545,
-0.0484786108,
1.2194070816,
-0.2910945714,
-0.2262915522,
0.0423581377,
0.8099249601,
0.1506061256,
0.4328701496,
0.2946404815,
-0.7574055195,
-0.4272309542,
-0.1949637085,
-0.8762930036,
-0.4548245668,
-0.2792212665,
-0.332180202,
0.1580208391,
0.5118854046,
-0.1136698425,
0.2458310574,
0.7207632661,
0.0088713886,
0.2632860243,
-0.240277946,
-0.2171438038,
-1.0294964314,
0.1557053924,
0.2585037351,
-0.1218210086,
-0.5727707148,
-0.4630647004,
-0.3188258708,
0.1574428529,
-0.3544501066,
0.454303503,
-0.6048237681,
0.0469491147,
-0.0627361983,
0.0792198032,
0.0243769977,
0.5297188759,
0.5825704932,
0.5764451027,
0.3683675826,
-0.6568707824,
0.0715159625,
0.1988627911,
-0.1498153806,
0.2275696844,
-0.4910879135,
-0.0593626909,
0.0203379337,
0.3775796294,
-0.6235887408,
-0.1179115325,
0.328414619,
-0.1577363759,
0.3062207103,
-0.1214208901,
-0.2538442016,
-0.2164053619,
-0.2302119881,
0.3293859065,
0.0334125571,
-0.6491954327,
0.3682748079,
0.2742924392,
-0.0244266111,
-0.525075376,
-0.7595450282,
0.0804135725,
-0.2179885954,
-0.5075839758,
0.3229245543,
0.1107716784,
-0.2801100016,
0.172001794,
-0.1455831975,
-0.285322547,
0.1890208572,
0.4238154888,
0.3033465445,
-0.0861376375,
0.2262740582,
0.3548587859,
-0.2026920319,
0.1113694087,
-0.3418051898,
0.0985085741,
-0.2694406211,
-0.1705102175,
-0.6514647603,
0.0477697812,
-0.0341745056,
-0.0268591102,
0.99152565,
0.7535236478,
-0.1572187543,
-0.1598436832,
-0.2967167795,
-0.2496207356,
-0.4127820134,
0.31935516,
-0.0589066632,
-0.8639246821,
-0.0449366868,
-0.2764885128,
-0.0133265704,
0.4821394384,
0.3454795182,
-0.1319518834,
0.4712351859,
0.5819622874,
-0.1424345076,
0.4290037453,
-0.4073688388,
0.2757352293,
-0.6542979479,
-0.2515404522,
-0.4233891964,
-0.140427202,
-0.4207066,
-0.5384700298,
0.3775315881,
0.3149695396,
-0.1681146473,
0.4033112228,
-0.4765348136,
0.2552072704,
0.7602065802,
0.1319493204,
0.4253118038,
0.2546977699,
-0.0928231478,
-0.113908425,
-0.8162238002,
-0.5082725286,
0.7551902533,
0.1550891995,
0.7909235954,
-0.2316562384,
1.1947745085,
0.2957268059,
0.5902554393,
-0.5451805592,
0.4410057068,
-0.1024621725,
-0.4915479422,
-0.4788455367,
-0.6954337955,
-0.7344014049,
0.0760554597,
-0.1968323886,
-0.7591362,
0.1648828536,
0.2935726047,
-0.4884473979,
0.2514309287,
-0.891295135,
0.7150499821,
-0.2470827848,
-0.7467067838,
-0.227377072,
-0.98528862,
0.2250524163,
-0.2483384907,
0.2735866904,
0.0367424563,
0.080597572,
1.0160448551,
-0.4929560125,
1.3614509106,
-0.3134659231,
-0.0143573256,
0.4881237745,
-0.2697442472,
0.5333644152,
0.2100660503,
-0.3624556959,
0.4427634776,
0.0876512602,
-0.3282046914,
-0.3584587872,
0.4508820176,
-0.7813129425,
-0.1838949919,
-0.5584952235,
-0.7036951184,
-0.0384346507,
0.0576709658,
0.1394577175,
0.1690565348,
-0.1113410741,
0.0142110586,
0.5009332299,
-0.1652668864,
0.4930449426,
0.331438601,
0.3247654736,
-0.5316611528,
0.8846568465,
0.0268014539,
0.395347625,
0.7501226068,
0.2528837323,
-0.1366658956,
-0.3877506256,
-0.2788149416,
0.2742157578,
-0.3271277845,
-0.1367598474,
-0.9058496356,
-0.2390461713,
-0.2146488428,
-0.3102601767,
-0.4027765691,
-0.414675802,
-0.5377978086,
-0.0207604766,
0.581356287,
0.3815754056,
-0.2562332451,
0.2393376231,
-0.6866183877,
0.3064917922,
0.1740985811,
0.2482419461,
-0.2157143205,
-0.4987354577,
-0.4976558089,
0.1053138226,
0.1194138378,
-0.5042567849,
0.4159035981,
0.6691172719,
0.2572147548,
0.2835006416,
0.3852894604,
0.8429119587,
-0.3190660477,
0.546043098,
0.2071962506,
-0.7653937936,
0.4784296453,
0.0688208789,
0.0532656945,
0.9374298453,
0.5510932207,
-0.1185728684,
-0.7595936656,
-0.5303490162,
-0.9486173987,
0.7673550248,
0.1928237528,
-0.1441811472,
0.0479628704,
0.3390573263,
0.2930888832,
0.1563521922,
-0.8077324033,
-0.023118468,
-0.0900495276,
-0.5546014905,
0.1110297814,
-0.0167045109,
-0.1142203435,
-0.4019308984,
1.0284495354,
-0.4193972349,
0.102945134,
0.4060865641,
-0.3338185847,
-0.2895952463,
0.1916022897,
0.3122600019,
0.2761287093,
-0.5176271796,
0.3356082439,
0.4487899244,
-0.4473346472,
-0.0293428209,
0.3485343754,
-0.4572967589,
0.0623718314,
0.5555077195,
0.9539182186,
0.5069770813,
-0.4486245811,
0.3565036356,
0.0941719636,
-0.1652973145,
-0.3639798462,
0.0406040773,
-0.0084310994,
0.2556679845,
0.2298820019,
0.3191634119,
0.08478266,
-0.1803319454,
0.4886497259,
0.3342364132,
-0.5520492792,
-0.5464397073,
0.7342272997,
0.2169725448,
0.0099349041,
0.2690786421,
-0.5689153075,
-0.3614034653,
0.4505153298,
0.3871291876,
0.5598444939,
0.0911808759,
0.3362772763,
0.6707051396,
0.1744274795,
-0.1816835254,
-0.1961044818,
-0.2392036468,
-0.39863047,
-0.8249108791,
-0.9806221128,
-0.4989722669,
-0.1367699206,
-0.7655838132,
0.334841013,
-0.2230120748,
-0.0387126729,
0.1472835839,
0.2902211249,
-0.3790912032,
0.3362020552,
0.3866499364,
0.5731040239,
-1.2069071531,
0.9495612979,
0.5652055144,
-0.2187804282,
-0.5137854218,
-0.0899324715,
-0.0451596566,
-0.4680630565,
1.1366444826,
0.2145558596,
-0.3352697492,
0.1070803851,
-0.6247320175,
-0.98268646,
0.9870099425,
0.3177546859,
-0.8123320937,
-0.076107353,
0.0628819689,
0.8920099139,
-0.1802113056,
0.3364968598,
0.147181198,
0.4249970317,
0.145636037,
-0.7193750143,
-0.056022808,
-0.2070763409,
-0.2874725759,
0.0544603541,
-0.7503348589,
0.2278215438,
-0.3961148262,
-0.0753445178,
0.1408916563,
1.1246943474,
0.2971092761,
0.7121482491,
0.6653422713,
0.6391350627,
0.9413182735,
0.0276129339,
0.6634637117,
-0.3081198633,
0.5847809911,
1.5403079987,
-0.2870943844,
0.6403459907,
0.7298900485,
-0.1776510477,
0.3974761665,
0.6400891542,
-0.5234550834,
0.6746560931,
0.2777843773,
-0.4098559022,
-0.108929731,
-0.4325651824,
-0.0902770534,
0.007787107,
0.0870509297,
-0.462087214,
-0.2496915907,
0.0681192502,
0.0900550559,
-0.0114513626,
0.0301707201,
0.7183738351,
0.1940790564,
-0.5028409958,
0.6003507376,
-0.2337851077,
0.7697538733,
-0.5923966765,
0.0676165745,
0.1595900059,
0.008952464,
-0.3486104608,
-0.2792882025,
0.4875917137,
0.1359468549,
-0.0756651834,
-0.1731211543,
0.3194643557,
-0.7289114594,
-0.6588498354,
0.46975106,
0.0349906906,
0.2587178648,
0.3850626647,
-0.5867423415,
-0.1446013749,
-0.0834989995,
-0.2988738716,
0.120528847,
0.3481086791,
-0.2002186477,
0.4858533442,
0.494700253,
0.2342856526,
0.2487951815,
0.2861737609,
0.7450095415,
-0.4112806916,
-0.2219034135,
-0.6937169433,
0.0879421681,
-0.2720938921,
-0.0635945052,
0.6848198771,
0.7257974148,
0.8204014897,
0.0095383525,
0.6664370298,
-0.3561279476,
0.331931591,
-0.4307545424,
0.6025699973,
-0.3245670497,
0.1905240417,
-0.3053435683,
-0.5334966183,
-0.6821495295,
0.568017602,
-0.7410461903,
-0.0926574841,
0.7061264515,
0.8118431568,
-0.0595646687,
0.3254398406,
-0.086404033,
0.2918868959,
0.0906486884,
0.4482513368,
0.4693943262,
-0.4332214594,
0.472382158,
-0.8121684194,
-0.0840274543,
-0.1244812831,
-0.946559608,
-1.0577116013,
-0.3208007812,
-0.8803964853,
-0.1253279448,
0.2368776798,
1.1109015942,
0.9532608986,
-1.0955712795,
0.0896803141,
-0.4056099951,
-0.1463476568,
-0.3776965439,
-0.2206179798,
0.7229086757,
-0.4685739279,
-0.7821081281,
0.4217248857,
0.1859925836,
-0.063019447,
-0.0307162292,
-0.1398826391,
-0.7344750166,
-0.3131348193,
0.4369063973,
0.2601006329,
-0.5287582278,
-0.2824211419,
-0.4336186349,
-0.079961665,
0.1240674257,
0.2869912684,
-0.676887691,
0.4907278717,
0.3295387328,
0.6265063882,
0.6830528378,
0.0805593506,
0.3286326528,
-0.9665727019,
0.4677892625,
0.2724497318,
-0.0823501945,
0.3012696803,
-0.4350571632,
0.7443036437,
0.4343605042,
-0.3569584787,
-0.7453430295,
-0.2553133965,
-1.0936864614,
0.0917801857,
0.9668595195,
-0.2570509315,
-0.6118680239,
-0.2160377949,
0.022073742,
0.758194983,
-0.4567784369,
1.0246533155,
0.4651120603,
-0.0660781041,
0.0021476897,
-0.5266227722,
0.51475811,
0.630926013,
-0.8493132591,
-0.1336717606,
0.2285887152,
0.0671480969,
0.4318739176,
0.1502607614,
0.0570253432,
-0.2745720148,
-0.204538703,
0.2694887519,
-0.0499612316,
-0.2557586432,
-0.1192318201,
0.2164793313,
-0.1935354918,
0.0029528725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14657v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14657v1 | OpenDebateEvidence: A Massive-Scale Argument Mining and Summarization Dataset | 2024-06-20T18:22:59 | 2024-06-20T18:22:59 | Allen Roush, Yusuf Shabazz, Arvind Balaji, Peter Zhang, Stefano Mezza, Markus Zhang, Sanjay Basu, Sriram Vishwanath, Mehdi Fatemi, Ravid Schwartz-Ziv | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce OpenDebateEvidence, a comprehensive dataset for argument mining
and summarization sourced from the American Competitive Debate community. This
dataset includes over 3.5 million documents with rich metadata, making it one
of the most extensive collections of debate evidence. OpenDebateEvidence
captures the complexity of arguments in high school and college debates,
providing valuable resources for training and evaluation. Our extensive
experiments demonstrate the efficacy of fine-tuning state-of-the-art large
language models for argumentative abstractive summarization across various
methods, models, and datasets. By providing this comprehensive resource, we aim
to advance computational argumentation and support practical applications for
debaters, educators, and researchers. OpenDebateEvidence is publicly available
to support further research and innovation in computational argumentation.
Access it here: https://huggingface.co/datasets/Yusuf5/OpenCaselist | [
-0.586399138,
-0.9008769989,
0.276104182,
0.0068114735,
-0.2289499342,
-0.1060597003,
-0.1954174191,
0.2375586182,
0.1162870079,
0.4690715373,
-0.1758793741,
-0.5804313421,
-0.3976027369,
0.005703235,
-0.2278537601,
1.1455819607,
-0.2764148414,
0.0940972641,
-0.7263225913,
-0.4444202185,
-0.2234123647,
-0.426968962,
-0.4220041931,
-0.1843341589,
0.5237612128,
0.783795774,
0.4915728569,
0.4162895679,
0.314498961,
0.3544579148,
0.0096270572,
0.0650543794,
-0.6443634629,
0.2560193837,
-0.7148706913,
0.0157029536,
-0.407312423,
-0.0692233592,
0.6299564838,
0.6861687303,
-0.1901640743,
0.1454718709,
-0.2994956374,
0.7359629273,
-0.9964505434,
0.0539759099,
-0.6224033833,
-0.1385337114,
-0.5160679221,
-0.096224159,
-0.318256706,
-0.8054126501,
0.1642078608,
-0.398560077,
0.1024203449,
-0.2590144575,
0.7745710015,
0.081154108,
-0.4053792655,
-0.3544536829,
-0.6583914161,
0.5211584568,
-0.6469022632,
-0.2039359361,
-0.0223253332,
0.3449349403,
-0.093512468,
-0.9374418259,
-0.4447512031,
0.368850857,
0.1997712106,
0.5059277415,
-0.6714252234,
0.3223904073,
0.2331249714,
0.6546364427,
-0.5074682832,
0.1817935109,
-0.5249073505,
0.1493353099,
0.6657934189,
0.3150867522,
0.1477594376,
-0.1024323627,
-0.1267467439,
-0.0497561954,
-0.5216525793,
0.0572615415,
0.7302570343,
0.0957132056,
-0.1911382824,
0.6737504601,
-0.3723111153,
0.6630294919,
-0.1640390903,
0.4356971383,
-0.1425087005,
-0.2618791163,
-0.2555598915,
0.4030176103,
1.0448126793,
0.4705691636,
0.0875004753,
0.1673247516,
0.2321093082,
-0.0226110816,
0.1090790853,
-1.1481457949,
-0.4118132591,
0.5582550764,
-0.6158220768,
-0.4042089581,
0.1348013431,
-1.3175531626,
-0.6927728653,
0.0081268977,
0.0428025275,
-0.0503199808,
-0.3189294636,
0.4045148194,
-0.5015842319,
-0.0559422709,
0.3436342478,
-0.7220144868,
0.4370602667,
0.9595507383,
1.0336654186,
-0.0911617726,
0.0572483391,
-0.3929239511,
-0.0508508496,
-0.6178373694,
1.3360880613,
-0.7657891512,
-0.3288823068,
0.0873518437,
-0.1117259637,
-0.0473214276,
-0.8509534597,
1.1048356295,
-0.3236198127,
0.331356883,
-0.2674300075,
-0.6604083776,
-0.1932308376,
0.0969021022,
-0.8047724962,
0.517390132,
-0.1938708127,
-1.003839016,
0.1640675515,
-1.1492818594,
-0.550544858,
0.2344506234,
-0.2475493997,
-0.338563621,
0.1788557917,
0.0807906762,
0.2776683867,
-0.6621192694,
0.2226491272,
-0.4049830139,
0.0148713998,
-0.1081303209,
-0.1345881224,
0.9524022937,
0.1954434514,
-0.1139812618,
0.3301246762,
-0.5674064755,
-0.4135968089,
0.1520601213,
0.0627826229,
-0.6923787594,
0.3208143413,
-0.3624250591,
0.0669418871,
0.1610855162,
-0.9936312437,
0.1508576572,
-0.5590175986,
0.4474955499,
0.9800605178,
0.3126474619,
0.0066419467,
-0.1175327152,
0.516151011,
0.1879345477,
-0.269688189,
-0.4464074969,
-0.4687652588,
-0.0346679986,
-0.2049923092,
0.3683941066,
0.4574404061,
-0.3682501614,
0.0559297912,
-0.4931746125,
-0.4272523522,
-0.4553880692,
-0.4168868065,
0.1983116865,
0.659445107,
0.2000840455,
-0.0235739965,
-0.7120650411,
-0.8289666772,
-0.3530372977,
-0.1658445448,
-0.0643813685,
0.5927328467,
0.6218729615,
0.1714952737,
1.0532661676,
-0.8705937862,
-0.1953293085,
-0.0552255549,
0.5235838294,
0.2452310622,
0.2469318211,
0.4554824531,
-0.3529058099,
-0.243886292,
0.1787700057,
-1.0644503832,
-0.0566673949,
-0.2054755092,
-0.2787018418,
0.1512254477,
0.536482811,
-0.4223953187,
0.3283648789,
0.140553996,
-0.5208634734,
0.6170233488,
0.0483631343,
0.2189291418,
-1.3109256029,
0.0005554733,
-0.0308595933,
0.208095625,
-0.1932919025,
0.1348438114,
-0.3860371113,
0.0116163976,
-0.129159525,
0.6321716309,
-0.007022744,
0.3950435221,
-0.1706537455,
0.3678819239,
-0.1590777636,
-0.1136324927,
-0.0321891494,
0.722338438,
0.543032527,
-0.155245766,
0.815818131,
0.4352143109,
-0.3355557024,
0.9628596902,
-0.985798955,
-0.224514693,
-0.1232855767,
0.6157186031,
-1.1596900225,
-0.5328631997,
-0.0783529356,
-0.3040842712,
-0.2220595926,
-0.3370651305,
-0.1425175369,
-0.5223221183,
-0.7271199822,
0.4533756673,
0.1351337582,
-0.8761506677,
0.4798502624,
0.6622434258,
-0.5615724325,
-0.5198386908,
-0.0537719466,
0.4167669415,
-0.2741391063,
-0.6887801886,
0.2757713795,
-0.1538394094,
-0.6476479173,
0.1475578099,
0.1353430897,
-0.1676774174,
-0.078139171,
0.4991361201,
0.2343524545,
-0.3978745639,
0.1602290571,
0.2227778137,
0.1113091037,
0.5267648101,
-0.1219993234,
0.2849455476,
-0.0788097754,
-0.1570342183,
0.0188785251,
0.7023831606,
0.5493528247,
0.0757329017,
0.4204671085,
0.0348232053,
-0.4204360843,
-0.2238887995,
-0.2643320858,
-0.0122550828,
-0.4330145717,
0.3170115054,
-0.345413506,
-0.747099936,
0.4717156589,
-0.309310317,
0.806899488,
0.6284302473,
0.7999516129,
0.2931882143,
1.0894683599,
-0.3547569215,
-0.0602168962,
-0.0571956374,
-0.1679348201,
0.1457740813,
-0.6642273068,
-0.0666193366,
-0.7576097846,
-0.4269759655,
-0.3093329072,
-0.2818060815,
-0.132243976,
-0.2233060598,
-0.3735111654,
-0.0414283201,
-0.436165154,
0.8326302171,
0.1245919019,
-0.2914052904,
0.2230947614,
-0.0215096958,
-0.2107472569,
-0.0713210255,
-0.415805757,
-0.5437104106,
1.1390972137,
0.2007941455,
0.6089766622,
0.3431336582,
0.6357948184,
0.4239060879,
0.2578463852,
-1.0143604279,
0.629698813,
-0.3790365458,
-0.7029551268,
-0.1642760932,
-0.633297205,
-1.1305429935,
0.2334936261,
-0.0351278931,
-0.6598815918,
0.1701652855,
0.0125916265,
-0.410493046,
0.7362743616,
-0.3491464257,
1.1538295746,
0.2491057664,
-0.6521949172,
-0.3540621102,
-0.2655927241,
0.7711643577,
0.2125048637,
0.1951709539,
0.0158384349,
0.2738544941,
1.0512827635,
-0.7290381789,
0.4368318319,
-0.2690059245,
-0.2776346803,
0.3776869178,
-0.0467448458,
0.0837282911,
0.1393904686,
-0.0220823698,
-0.0158632137,
-0.1306234598,
-0.4550736547,
-0.2339245379,
1.0371184349,
-0.676099658,
-0.5590507984,
-0.4158482254,
-0.217944622,
-0.0482072197,
0.0389760695,
0.2288252711,
0.7886750698,
-0.7814492583,
0.5231285691,
0.8941573501,
-0.1079529151,
0.5739964843,
0.2012802064,
0.143252179,
-0.8418717384,
1.1981041431,
0.1700032502,
-0.2595277727,
0.0010115388,
0.5550062656,
-0.4172483981,
-0.5542552471,
-0.5895547867,
0.1329554617,
-0.8358472586,
-0.346562475,
-0.9408887625,
-0.0856225714,
-0.4832261503,
-0.2490317076,
-0.3988594115,
-0.9230347872,
-0.0402770229,
-0.305190593,
0.4287455976,
0.881634593,
-0.1380890459,
0.0210180804,
-0.4814140797,
0.3425464034,
0.4245893061,
0.6204462647,
0.1085930988,
-0.38628003,
-0.1137390882,
-0.2505327761,
-0.7166390419,
-0.6184774637,
-0.158749789,
0.3140627146,
0.5232595205,
0.8390170336,
0.6025698185,
0.6387786865,
-0.3943750262,
1.2088356018,
0.1350578815,
-0.6907835603,
0.5932284594,
-0.4517834485,
0.2960037887,
0.5114301443,
0.559283793,
-0.1959832758,
-0.0240665339,
-0.739785254,
-1.1314078569,
0.6992332935,
-0.0314188898,
-0.0346493423,
-0.2948871851,
-0.0876098797,
0.1645829827,
-0.1076182798,
-0.2016677856,
-0.071019724,
-0.3718359768,
-0.3026463389,
0.2897307575,
-0.175250873,
-0.7023965716,
-0.1921381652,
0.6422255039,
-0.064360328,
-0.2055386305,
0.0368456095,
0.1628499925,
-0.0939614326,
0.3673247099,
0.9631305337,
0.6274265647,
-0.2051540315,
0.1229413375,
0.1053472459,
-0.6813079715,
-0.0039243158,
0.3284154534,
-0.1043549329,
0.2904227674,
0.3359472454,
0.6754657626,
0.0889263302,
-0.8704335093,
0.6163962483,
-0.4405001104,
-0.7476991415,
-0.322851032,
-0.2925418913,
0.2444923073,
0.016928032,
0.1677080989,
-0.1147184744,
0.4189803004,
-0.4625000656,
0.1765066534,
0.4099649191,
-0.3899720609,
-0.1915146708,
0.8141342998,
0.3780562878,
0.1907536685,
0.2333526313,
0.3518860638,
-0.1016234383,
0.557854116,
0.2755305767,
1.1765686274,
-0.2196470648,
0.4083485901,
0.7707694173,
-0.1721328348,
-0.0071714362,
0.2471132576,
-0.0730441213,
-0.258118391,
-0.213319689,
-0.4908869863,
-0.7151844501,
0.0490755476,
-0.5453458428,
0.1394436657,
-0.8515601158,
0.1474135667,
0.4202759862,
-0.1847112179,
0.0680631846,
-0.2191774249,
-0.0660109818,
1.0610378981,
-0.8496119976,
0.1911665052,
0.9017057419,
-0.3133715093,
-0.0645639077,
-0.0224805642,
0.1538291276,
-0.0120068043,
0.4154484272,
-0.0508622006,
-0.4366545081,
-0.3584568202,
-0.6484942436,
-0.026236482,
0.7164177299,
0.2073464692,
-0.1237016246,
0.2361556292,
-0.0696754381,
0.1985866725,
-0.5550382137,
0.457649231,
0.5663622618,
0.3734819293,
0.5489127636,
-0.3394840062,
0.0780433044,
-0.4294368327,
-0.3047526479,
0.2188915759,
-0.6243050694,
0.970682025,
-0.3964729011,
-0.194649294,
-0.0255571008,
0.6298036575,
0.1340776533,
0.5817591548,
0.299487114,
0.888486743,
0.60582304,
-0.1763590276,
0.6875009537,
0.1066028923,
0.0695357844,
1.4584144354,
-0.4781593084,
0.9264096022,
0.0092424443,
-0.0746852905,
0.7689270973,
0.6568968296,
0.1800263673,
0.2273054868,
0.3999162316,
-0.6193428636,
-0.1956796944,
-0.3294219971,
-0.5374162793,
0.3360031843,
0.5222951174,
-0.1310382634,
-0.7692373991,
-0.2732275128,
0.4362527132,
0.5138376951,
-0.4027518928,
1.1170374155,
-0.2948185802,
-0.8343818188,
0.6910400391,
-0.1589376181,
0.2367900908,
-0.3648824394,
-0.3308368027,
-0.2704864144,
0.3825574517,
-0.4564214051,
-0.9375317693,
0.114062801,
0.3033580184,
-0.0355423912,
0.0405808575,
0.5721313357,
-0.0914569274,
-0.2179816663,
0.0665713698,
0.1431366503,
0.208447516,
0.1541220546,
-0.4416410923,
-0.0824944526,
-0.3017802238,
-0.289996326,
0.2896791399,
0.6844556332,
-0.1034186706,
0.2490031719,
0.6192026734,
0.2203380466,
-0.1713544279,
0.1329980642,
1.2353864908,
-0.5423224568,
-0.3966769278,
-1.0194907188,
0.4983484149,
-0.7166156769,
-0.3789964914,
0.7266546488,
1.1333404779,
0.5132688284,
-0.0594767109,
1.0147352219,
-0.0287101958,
0.6449076533,
-0.1017291173,
0.6317905784,
-0.2362252772,
-0.0954305008,
-0.4329942167,
-0.4201729298,
-0.2534982264,
0.5596327782,
-0.2506778538,
-0.4266482294,
0.5434778333,
0.4403175116,
-0.1428066343,
0.670904696,
0.0145313982,
0.5169757009,
0.5153185725,
0.4658690691,
0.6815642715,
-0.3015813529,
0.5878351927,
0.1723854542,
-0.6153504252,
-0.4307367206,
-1.0590069294,
-1.0077171326,
-0.5085900426,
-0.5959913135,
-0.6037338972,
0.1371982992,
1.0265849829,
0.1679757237,
-1.1600850821,
-0.5529918671,
-0.1661222875,
0.3931541145,
-0.0897451788,
-0.2797493339,
0.2381053716,
-0.2140215933,
-0.548381567,
0.3270580769,
0.2074002922,
-0.3719544113,
-0.1586179882,
0.0601720884,
-0.4281438291,
0.7173308134,
0.8257888556,
0.7914600968,
-0.505585134,
-0.0293080304,
-0.5101241469,
0.2194715589,
0.0866725221,
1.132220149,
-0.676199317,
0.757579267,
0.7575269341,
0.6743353009,
0.1048362702,
0.3336276412,
0.6192791462,
-0.523878932,
-0.0675721467,
0.0764690563,
0.405818671,
0.1091721728,
0.1042075381,
0.5627450347,
0.2813301086,
-0.6763255,
-1.08335495,
0.0927499756,
-1.0089992285,
-0.3538739085,
0.8181983829,
-0.4928614199,
-0.1142000034,
-0.3082185686,
-0.3496977687,
-0.2332488298,
-0.7215911746,
0.7926038504,
0.886251092,
-0.0579339936,
0.0160131287,
-0.5187378526,
0.4808980227,
-0.0894922689,
-1.0770617723,
0.9777789116,
0.9158545136,
-0.1179613695,
0.1166318655,
0.4892617762,
-0.4613642097,
0.3647574782,
0.1303073764,
-0.1454221606,
0.0051521859,
-0.2603823841,
-0.4224282503,
0.8332516551,
-0.282577008,
-0.3071023524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14654v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14654v1 | Major Entity Identification: A Generalizable Alternative to Coreference Resolution | 2024-06-20T18:17:58 | 2024-06-20T18:17:58 | Kawshik Manikantan, Shubham Toshniwal, Makarand Tapaswi, Vineet Gandhi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | The limited generalization of coreference resolution (CR) models has been a
major bottleneck in the task's broad application. Prior work has identified
annotation differences, especially for mention detection, as one of the main
reasons for the generalization gap and proposed using additional annotated
target domain data. Rather than relying on this additional annotation, we
propose an alternative formulation of the CR task, Major Entity Identification
(MEI), where we: (a) assume the target entities to be specified in the input,
and (b) limit the task to only the frequent entities. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that MEI models generalize well across domains on
multiple datasets with supervised models and LLM-based few-shot prompting.
Additionally, the MEI task fits the classification framework, which enables the
use of classification-based metrics that are more robust than the current CR
metrics. Finally, MEI is also of practical use as it allows a user to search
for all mentions of a particular entity or a group of entities of interest. | [
-0.5596628785,
-0.7912008166,
0.5523093939,
-0.1395845413,
-0.3319064975,
-0.0235598888,
-0.7029735446,
-0.7003625035,
0.2461697757,
0.3363848925,
-0.6247876883,
-0.6334124804,
-0.9179551601,
0.2626031935,
-0.308850348,
0.985817194,
0.1146253273,
-0.1355320811,
-0.2810549736,
-0.1686699837,
-0.6768290997,
-0.7411316037,
-0.4607266784,
-0.3668144941,
0.6943467259,
0.700728178,
0.6054170728,
0.6464170218,
0.9236757755,
0.2140821815,
-0.0485369563,
0.5207617283,
-0.3317889869,
-0.057837829,
-0.4667694271,
-0.562105298,
-0.4563118517,
0.2585641742,
0.7438207269,
0.9549150467,
0.1619327515,
0.3164393008,
-0.1097450331,
0.3712362349,
-0.7382705212,
0.3410926163,
-0.957952261,
-0.1102482006,
-0.4727440476,
-0.1875226498,
-0.410066098,
0.1676781029,
0.4366211593,
-0.7871953249,
0.6555349827,
0.2469501495,
1.2703973055,
0.0167746302,
-0.2805582583,
-0.2954966426,
-1.0601191521,
1.1029855013,
-0.0044501298,
0.3825736046,
0.2848412991,
0.3289461732,
0.249304682,
-0.3309387267,
-0.2933515608,
-0.1342865229,
-0.020550631,
-0.0897089243,
-0.5179243088,
0.2024586052,
0.4182167947,
0.4198303819,
-0.3345505595,
0.219637543,
-0.2092718929,
-0.2724643648,
0.2970206738,
0.1858958304,
0.4171420932,
0.1128113344,
-0.4010911286,
0.5351709723,
-0.9792267084,
-0.1610668302,
0.0751949176,
0.3899523318,
0.2144400626,
0.6576206088,
-0.334118247,
0.5602564216,
0.2294389009,
-0.1902057528,
0.0777486637,
-0.1484378576,
-0.2999567389,
-0.1957834959,
0.4226862788,
0.7241228223,
0.5667951703,
-0.3742679656,
0.1374279857,
0.4138021171,
0.057887949,
-0.7696031332,
-0.212105155,
-0.1157217994,
-0.3693008423,
0.0077746585,
0.1419479102,
-0.5288130045,
-0.3005336225,
-0.5415515304,
0.0870661288,
-0.440918982,
-0.1771024764,
-0.3579183817,
-0.2222514898,
0.0141917365,
0.5278717279,
-0.7485184073,
0.4642309248,
0.7646750808,
0.9204468131,
-0.3427422643,
-0.1070768014,
-0.4966672957,
0.3502543867,
-0.3982739747,
0.9497984648,
-1.0589755774,
-0.7756062746,
-0.1180725768,
-0.059928149,
-0.2243033946,
-0.8881567121,
0.4915760458,
-0.6177105904,
-0.227556318,
-0.4559650719,
-0.6481792927,
-0.5559622645,
0.3550835848,
-0.5919880271,
0.5657659769,
0.0862137973,
-0.7736742496,
0.5367416143,
-0.5749915242,
-0.2306642085,
0.2156034261,
-0.4017247558,
-0.1780062616,
0.0215821452,
0.0935921893,
0.5641090274,
-0.7384431362,
0.3870563209,
-0.1899290532,
-0.3603185713,
0.1038145944,
0.0154839056,
0.4816861153,
0.0774497837,
0.1067606285,
0.2075464576,
-0.5399031043,
-0.5799139738,
0.046698831,
-0.2060769796,
-0.7538041472,
0.1734613925,
-0.3327799439,
-0.2129384279,
0.1033183336,
-0.5689895153,
0.5510544181,
0.1211558059,
0.2984999418,
0.3225860596,
0.2974212468,
0.7490105629,
-0.404422462,
0.3931746781,
0.5407764316,
-0.0179083422,
-0.2224388421,
-0.9362214804,
-0.8081878424,
-0.6886546016,
0.7744746804,
0.8298214078,
-0.4115409255,
0.2866562009,
-0.7716691494,
-0.608456552,
-0.309109658,
0.3062286377,
0.3438962996,
0.5850586295,
0.6792353392,
-0.3299437761,
-0.7876652479,
-1.311314106,
-0.400182724,
-0.1997849643,
-0.3403131664,
0.6138051152,
0.5260561109,
-0.3553310931,
1.1309378147,
-0.6389158368,
-0.7333084941,
-0.352404505,
0.1848724037,
0.1012985334,
0.6459761262,
0.4995315969,
-1.0022524595,
-0.263204813,
-0.0558066145,
-0.4055938721,
0.0102355583,
-0.2489100993,
-0.0776336715,
-0.4734166563,
0.1611879617,
-0.7974449396,
0.2425431162,
0.1016634554,
0.0107408855,
0.4168640077,
0.3409657776,
0.1733293682,
-0.7704378963,
0.280234158,
0.3728811145,
-0.1683793962,
-0.7740865946,
0.1493751854,
0.1403678358,
-0.0943182558,
-0.2086169273,
0.4863539636,
-0.5497969985,
0.119533971,
-0.0709210783,
0.1180700734,
-0.1250874549,
0.3983404636,
0.3454353809,
0.6328467727,
0.6603394747,
-1.2398802042,
0.1714944541,
0.3887915313,
-0.172470808,
0.7644722462,
-0.3607853353,
0.0040522194,
-0.2139690816,
0.3942828178,
-0.6154888272,
-0.280207634,
0.4600740373,
-0.630035162,
0.2683804035,
-0.5580382347,
-0.3466458917,
-0.2761854827,
-0.1222039014,
0.3106887639,
0.5329433084,
-0.5365256071,
0.9596813321,
0.443531245,
-0.0305712912,
-0.5024642348,
-0.6417083144,
0.1908629239,
-0.4910012186,
-0.3225924969,
0.7575789094,
-0.0898548663,
-0.3214297295,
0.0126736825,
-0.1157404855,
-0.4240001142,
0.2801026404,
0.6537302732,
0.7564713955,
-0.2619839311,
0.3124643266,
-0.0016200093,
-0.2953491211,
-0.2705429792,
-0.0259393901,
0.1629924625,
0.1519093812,
-0.1416833103,
-0.4653024375,
0.7130404711,
0.2067875415,
-0.5568553209,
0.4733144045,
0.474565804,
-0.8638818264,
-0.0229738764,
-0.7726157308,
0.0201979205,
-0.3472845554,
0.0444716513,
-0.6787954569,
-0.900660336,
0.5466936231,
-0.4274560213,
0.3588235676,
0.6793118715,
0.5203505158,
0.1855513453,
0.8653722405,
0.6801811457,
-0.3212447166,
0.3470975757,
-0.2173507065,
0.1804120243,
-1.2084026337,
0.0048461822,
-0.7056527138,
-0.3189752102,
-0.1036473215,
-0.6349024177,
0.0575722158,
0.441836834,
0.075861007,
0.5455558896,
-0.4907385111,
0.3604313433,
0.6938541532,
0.0487120189,
0.6372342706,
-0.184846282,
0.0631093308,
-0.0722302124,
-0.3212508559,
-0.615367651,
0.8187737465,
0.2973583639,
0.4059086442,
0.1809940636,
0.669532299,
0.3097183406,
0.7895089984,
-1.0466428995,
0.6454811096,
-0.1784705818,
-1.0559821129,
0.0387627296,
-0.4010478854,
-0.6947833896,
0.2168429792,
-0.286201179,
-1.0363957882,
0.3644650578,
0.2307497263,
-0.7296280265,
0.3911488652,
-0.5790650249,
0.5063942075,
0.6208075285,
0.2356936485,
-0.2580472231,
-0.195964694,
0.443990469,
0.0023179336,
0.2247635722,
-0.6110621691,
-0.3747449219,
0.8178741932,
-0.0201584287,
0.9442988634,
-0.1473026723,
0.4025595188,
0.699909687,
0.1633744836,
0.4042028189,
0.1724525094,
0.132181257,
0.3311165869,
-0.3190041184,
-0.0970782563,
-0.3501045406,
0.7337550521,
-0.443272084,
-0.8169286847,
-0.0873357058,
-0.4617296755,
-0.3112982512,
0.2976942956,
0.432849288,
0.3157039881,
-0.2908973098,
0.1483116448,
0.6387639046,
0.1640183032,
0.2697213292,
0.6566827297,
0.1770568192,
-0.1231803074,
0.8371559381,
0.3041192293,
-0.2367949933,
0.4915535152,
0.0081123076,
-0.0440173745,
-0.5089358687,
-0.5870056748,
0.1744823605,
-0.5950334668,
-0.5136159658,
-0.9353374839,
0.0905472264,
-0.3071593642,
-0.1698509753,
-0.2345027626,
-0.2641716301,
-0.660635829,
-0.0967144221,
0.2854082882,
0.2109664977,
-0.059880767,
0.2904905975,
-0.9491884708,
0.409588933,
0.3474875093,
0.1741072685,
-0.095783487,
-0.5003427863,
-0.0291950945,
-0.1739221066,
-0.1694179326,
-1.0569161177,
-0.0839573368,
0.6138677597,
0.5107144117,
0.7304445505,
0.1181822494,
0.7190508246,
-0.699637413,
0.9230863452,
0.3225302994,
-0.9863998294,
0.5377307534,
-0.2714286447,
-0.084428452,
0.5370651484,
0.7718350887,
-0.5599034429,
-0.1966731399,
-0.7038093209,
-0.6920095682,
0.1194608957,
0.0926105902,
0.1505531222,
-0.2570451796,
0.4615505338,
0.0649638623,
0.0691802725,
-0.3823296726,
-0.2929416895,
0.5627604723,
0.0470036045,
0.1178816408,
-0.4818947911,
-0.296079725,
-0.0661939383,
0.6637970805,
-0.0193284936,
0.3762291372,
0.5714811087,
-0.4873303771,
-0.2896576524,
0.3352897465,
0.348695308,
0.6435168982,
0.027560845,
0.2186281085,
0.3826592565,
-0.2659732401,
-0.1333149523,
-0.0430828631,
-0.3529036045,
0.425211966,
0.4460694194,
0.3593889177,
0.3524332643,
-0.648573041,
0.5391836762,
0.2992664874,
-0.2549619079,
-0.3207503557,
0.2708124816,
0.0588445663,
0.2449118644,
0.4978731275,
0.1193156838,
0.3565422297,
-0.4134027362,
0.2647251785,
0.3558807969,
-0.5288812518,
-0.2638748288,
0.6307038665,
0.3921508789,
-0.204397738,
0.6498464346,
-0.1860085428,
-0.5893439054,
0.5315705538,
0.2369297743,
0.7092587948,
-0.3374713361,
-0.0605906881,
0.5494238734,
0.1781355143,
-0.0953086689,
-0.035642527,
-0.1277644336,
-0.9571171403,
-0.3974205852,
-0.1800539047,
-0.6049020886,
-0.1267588735,
-0.8495357633,
0.3689608574,
-0.6442358494,
-0.6992166638,
0.5915373564,
-0.1082612276,
-0.9116844535,
0.2464322597,
0.3970097899,
0.9640058279,
-0.7822632194,
0.8472872376,
0.9820326567,
-0.540844202,
-0.42084378,
-0.3856222034,
0.227823168,
-0.4370087087,
0.5599012971,
0.3226262927,
0.1088697389,
0.0394919999,
-0.382253319,
-0.6140397191,
1.1180956364,
-0.01395832,
-0.8222767115,
-0.4237413108,
-0.3657181859,
0.1268556714,
-0.7617884278,
0.1374572068,
0.6890078187,
0.5569874644,
-0.1863839328,
-1.008665204,
0.0668557957,
0.0097955894,
0.0925573185,
0.1625152677,
-0.5246542096,
0.8018016219,
-0.3752737641,
-0.5274823308,
0.0541551262,
0.824397862,
0.1459179819,
0.2977725863,
0.884219408,
0.3887706101,
0.8440880775,
-0.160786137,
0.7378669977,
-0.2139055729,
0.5693132877,
1.2348839045,
-0.1644977629,
0.6070427299,
0.2546577454,
-0.0956678838,
0.2901504636,
0.824026525,
-0.5389466286,
0.1787061393,
0.1032894924,
-0.3045099378,
-0.6304608583,
-0.541500628,
-0.2781771719,
0.1778707653,
0.739369154,
-0.5358929634,
-0.393435508,
-0.0833583623,
0.0887327865,
-0.0730341226,
-0.4908452034,
0.5435400009,
0.130811587,
-0.3917971253,
0.0516977981,
0.1972521394,
0.7607720494,
-0.3784263134,
-0.1394440532,
0.1969835907,
0.0115903495,
-0.2980226278,
-0.3338556588,
0.2213474363,
0.2173354179,
-0.4999022186,
0.2529761493,
0.888076365,
-0.376390636,
-0.2718564868,
0.1751494855,
0.4852355123,
0.1681928486,
-0.4706369936,
-0.5371155739,
-0.0719923973,
-0.221337989,
-0.109983027,
0.0448122248,
0.1555624902,
-0.1980698109,
0.7176198363,
0.4721668959,
-0.0782498568,
-0.1013364941,
-0.1093756109,
0.8711487651,
-0.6574123502,
-0.3803426921,
-0.7997877002,
0.2408380061,
-0.1031412482,
-0.5660557151,
0.506629467,
0.5803776979,
0.6804940701,
-0.2213548422,
0.8103239536,
-0.1572022885,
1.0021791458,
-0.174092114,
0.0824812725,
-0.2268550545,
0.2121651024,
-0.2465118766,
-1.0851483345,
-0.6504428983,
0.3641844094,
-0.3823285997,
-0.2325242311,
0.569503665,
0.487652123,
-0.1701425314,
-0.023562301,
0.4324449897,
-0.1324027032,
0.3125290573,
0.5613081455,
0.7407149076,
-0.0390055068,
0.5098870397,
-0.3210327029,
-0.3261060417,
-0.4759748578,
-0.6105907559,
-0.9948346615,
-0.517536819,
-0.6920617223,
-0.0703976303,
-0.0239364225,
1.183265686,
0.8118955493,
-0.8789575696,
0.3093850315,
0.4338377118,
0.0962986648,
-0.3119141757,
-0.1766753644,
0.0518432781,
-0.119654201,
-1.0184664726,
0.3257586062,
0.140551582,
-0.1039130613,
0.1340937465,
0.4667663276,
-0.1000715047,
0.0670185238,
0.4786095917,
0.3247895837,
-0.9240979552,
-0.6665996313,
-0.1063293293,
0.0187407378,
0.141465947,
1.2505843639,
-0.3978813589,
0.0914645195,
0.1953734905,
0.7617607713,
-0.0193038341,
0.3433375657,
0.3585444093,
-0.5238505006,
0.0080462433,
0.3086690307,
0.4333943725,
0.1129697487,
-0.5103008747,
0.6363153458,
0.4605024159,
-0.1813312322,
-0.5716526508,
0.4538525939,
-1.2398432493,
-0.2276818007,
1.1908521652,
-0.4866594076,
-0.0625286549,
-0.2719518542,
-0.1648890823,
0.1458223313,
-0.5252870321,
0.3682022691,
0.82510221,
-0.1663445979,
0.0697192326,
-0.4812004566,
0.2814052701,
0.1368418783,
-0.3447853923,
0.1124548167,
0.6169254184,
0.6064976454,
0.5877940059,
0.6396331787,
-0.1132351235,
0.2440541685,
-0.1356096268,
0.1479248852,
0.0134055177,
-0.7058688998,
0.0398859233,
0.2027858198,
0.2811074555,
-0.3219696283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19415v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19415v1 | An Analysis of Multilingual FActScore | 2024-06-20T18:09:40 | 2024-06-20T18:09:40 | Kim Trong Vu, Michael Krumdick, Varshini Reddy, Franck Dernoncourt, Viet Dac Lai | cs.CL | cs.CL | FActScore has gained popularity as a metric to estimate the factuality of
long-form texts generated by Large Language Models (LLMs) in English. However,
there has not been any work in studying the behavior of FActScore in other
languages. This paper studies the limitations of each component in the
four-component pipeline of FActScore in the multilingual setting. We introduce
a new dataset for FActScore on texts generated by strong multilingual LLMs. Our
evaluation shows that LLMs exhibit distinct behaviors in both fact extraction
and fact scoring tasks. No LLM produces consistent and reliable FActScore
across languages with varying levels of resources. We also find that the
knowledge source plays an important role in the quality of the estimated
FActScore. Using Wikipedia as the knowledge source may hinder the true
FActScore of long-form text due to its limited coverage in medium- and
low-resource languages. We also incorporate three mitigations to our knowledge
source that ultimately improve FActScore estimation across all languages. | [
-0.2455511093,
-0.7109746933,
0.8233038187,
0.247468397,
-0.19838202,
0.0995400771,
-0.5278069377,
-0.6205058694,
0.2398235798,
0.3352908492,
-0.4609607458,
-0.6282635331,
-0.6203220487,
0.3576308489,
-0.1076375768,
1.3609472513,
0.0042950343,
-0.0150653375,
-0.651029408,
-0.4304885566,
-0.1601033658,
-0.6436766386,
-0.1637847126,
-0.2466373444,
0.7743494511,
0.7431698442,
0.6041493416,
0.4298679531,
0.5003985167,
0.2821207941,
0.005762992,
0.5218512416,
-0.4450551271,
0.3303437829,
-0.1709267646,
-0.5490056276,
-0.3004215956,
0.0755561218,
0.9087383151,
0.394680053,
-0.1335310936,
0.4477533996,
-0.0699442625,
0.4708444476,
-0.5634322166,
0.6843040586,
-0.3735194206,
-0.0608238988,
-0.5409071445,
0.1134500653,
-0.3560907245,
-0.4846610427,
-0.032341972,
-0.2166929841,
0.2462228537,
-0.072010085,
0.5483176112,
0.1116446853,
-0.7048664689,
-0.5180538893,
-0.6006167531,
0.9590409398,
-0.5479416251,
0.778331399,
0.0519485213,
0.2020803839,
0.1009935364,
-0.3288756609,
-0.6152556539,
-0.3251195848,
-0.1777404994,
0.0742878094,
-0.1757323593,
-0.4302960634,
0.2927415073,
0.0365811177,
-0.3330556154,
0.0366976671,
-0.5351529121,
-0.5662932992,
0.6740242839,
0.016926704,
0.2386179119,
-0.7321127653,
-0.6657543778,
0.2782479823,
-0.7570843697,
0.052344352,
0.3408703208,
0.4174516201,
-0.306355685,
0.6619651914,
0.0241583008,
0.3994158208,
-0.42127949,
-0.9755346775,
0.4258944094,
-0.5387054086,
0.2561036944,
0.3222006261,
0.8167845607,
0.366715759,
0.2220370471,
-0.2670246959,
0.0338046439,
-0.1267942041,
-0.2300169915,
-0.592751205,
0.1615250856,
0.127776131,
-0.0699864477,
0.0024274902,
-0.118679896,
-0.7240850925,
-0.4451875091,
-0.2780731916,
0.0394349955,
-0.381547451,
-0.3860763907,
-0.1413122118,
-0.1586833745,
0.0070705013,
0.1263417155,
-0.388407141,
0.1057817191,
0.5499618649,
1.0102158785,
-0.4625677764,
-0.6546676755,
-0.4668731391,
0.2280298471,
-0.2773045599,
1.0737491846,
-0.220705986,
-0.143472597,
-0.151724562,
-0.02615612,
0.1094285622,
-0.2241340876,
0.9138123989,
-0.5752782822,
0.2148584872,
-0.5520206094,
-0.6352559328,
-0.3881597817,
0.4947113991,
-0.9565800428,
1.0326211452,
-0.2698358595,
-0.9088969231,
0.3064149916,
-0.4208684266,
-0.5939496756,
-0.1696344465,
-0.2420172095,
-0.2691037059,
0.0725150332,
0.0585629791,
0.567809701,
-0.379565686,
0.4701305032,
-0.1821293086,
-0.04583003,
0.364079684,
-0.7942788005,
0.7451134324,
0.2395755798,
-0.0537937507,
-0.3733504415,
-0.8372141719,
-0.2099910378,
-0.044768136,
-0.6881818771,
-0.2568581104,
0.2049098313,
-0.1475264877,
0.3638322949,
0.467263341,
-0.8211000562,
-0.1820266843,
0.0614092201,
0.0148982825,
0.5876526237,
0.0301290136,
0.0151816448,
-0.1438323557,
0.3539012969,
0.2323649377,
0.0258011147,
0.0213031583,
-0.311250031,
-0.7849113345,
-0.4040510058,
0.203627795,
0.4943383038,
-0.7505332232,
-0.0353865884,
-0.5354115963,
-0.6150355935,
-0.1737737507,
0.3798146844,
0.3733182847,
0.6079474688,
0.3317315876,
0.0343422852,
-0.474047333,
-1.0402719975,
-0.3217280805,
-0.2400024384,
0.3988787234,
0.1534022093,
0.3535206616,
0.0792505592,
0.8936427832,
-0.5752199888,
-0.0320869945,
-0.3759277761,
0.0737429485,
0.4632210732,
-0.0836571231,
0.6957001686,
-0.690102458,
-0.4436532855,
-0.1759301275,
-0.9327807426,
0.029200064,
0.1186994314,
0.1332927495,
0.4561856091,
0.2930583656,
-0.8728280663,
-0.1851655543,
0.8697866797,
-0.1362725943,
0.839433074,
-0.1778119057,
0.2843750715,
-0.9802981019,
-0.0118645113,
0.18485789,
-0.2780900002,
-0.4296788573,
0.1967384517,
0.2501718998,
-0.1295233518,
-0.6767892838,
0.5207541585,
-0.4961737096,
-0.2148085684,
0.0155105852,
0.2554214299,
0.1528971344,
0.3447569311,
0.0965463892,
0.7761134505,
0.3572409749,
-0.6944289207,
0.7431476712,
-0.0151574947,
-0.7622238994,
0.6395611763,
-0.3056989014,
-0.1374428421,
-0.383741051,
0.1505138874,
-0.8480718136,
-0.0873836651,
-0.0501261652,
-0.2206533253,
0.2547142804,
-0.1854245961,
-0.5515266061,
-0.1320541352,
-0.3528299034,
0.1046939716,
0.1013113335,
-0.498750627,
0.4779618084,
0.5118803382,
-0.4233466089,
-0.7424206734,
-0.6278864741,
0.2316996008,
-0.2025937438,
-0.6982764602,
0.0039866176,
-0.2850857377,
-0.4015136659,
-0.0165045429,
-0.1891562641,
-0.1880016476,
-0.0497777387,
-0.0948654041,
0.2737331986,
-0.328120172,
0.4636426866,
-0.0797339901,
-0.0055219429,
0.2816325724,
0.0438588969,
0.1032448187,
0.0854554698,
-0.399990499,
-0.003800184,
0.4516240954,
0.773888588,
-0.2800680697,
0.8086256981,
0.5093817711,
-0.0434359461,
-0.2536124289,
-0.6660832763,
0.2076108158,
-0.3434399068,
0.5451548696,
-0.3961327374,
-0.6835954785,
0.4374655187,
0.1896740049,
0.1750354469,
0.7102268338,
0.6161113381,
-0.046592351,
0.6247707009,
0.3252485693,
-0.1685059369,
-0.099189803,
-0.0097929388,
0.176420182,
-0.3726711273,
-0.3136152923,
-0.6172527075,
0.0122736059,
-0.7513826489,
-0.4712858498,
0.7667712569,
-0.2386215329,
-0.0073129353,
0.0377852842,
0.3503219783,
0.5305188298,
0.341733247,
0.0711448714,
0.624771595,
0.2568082511,
-0.1889620721,
-0.2388284206,
-0.9350916147,
-0.3492660522,
1.0119539499,
0.3787275255,
0.4715441167,
0.589010179,
0.396538645,
0.4162398279,
0.2579452693,
-0.9117962122,
0.352914989,
-0.3328814209,
-1.0688803196,
-0.1638758332,
-0.6692955494,
-0.4044880271,
0.0981263071,
-0.1595450193,
-0.2088023126,
-0.1396350265,
-0.1094749719,
-0.0889151767,
0.2545832694,
-0.6938149929,
0.4627974629,
-0.4536577761,
-0.4370743036,
-0.2718086243,
-0.3905679286,
0.6047917604,
-0.2240512669,
0.793956697,
-0.3179668486,
0.0495241843,
0.7068552971,
-0.1264179051,
0.8809790015,
0.0027403911,
-0.4533806443,
0.427619189,
-0.001612395,
0.542113781,
0.2043495178,
-0.403587997,
0.556347549,
-0.1252601594,
-0.439070642,
-0.4518797994,
0.9080283642,
-0.7368333936,
-0.7355518937,
-0.7444645166,
-0.4706258178,
-0.4297536016,
0.2034582496,
0.1295011044,
0.6314829588,
-0.2730433047,
0.1497542262,
0.4624474645,
-0.0961390361,
0.4051372111,
0.9944401979,
0.0292297453,
-0.0893811658,
1.0870471001,
0.6172482371,
0.0726685822,
0.2690369189,
0.3337751329,
-0.5951884389,
-0.379681021,
-0.4468596876,
0.4974051118,
-0.9511420727,
-0.210950017,
-0.4885153472,
-0.2705019414,
-0.2172456384,
0.617646277,
-0.5074097514,
-0.5094020963,
0.066678077,
-0.4606921375,
0.3914142251,
0.7987989187,
-0.1446366608,
-0.335391283,
-1.1130337715,
0.2096328437,
0.4544957578,
0.3945338428,
-0.1710615754,
-0.2949176133,
-0.5856574178,
-0.0927475467,
0.0667990297,
-0.8096210361,
-0.1290483773,
0.2776395977,
0.6822113991,
0.2528531849,
0.1631566137,
0.3603302538,
-0.749024272,
0.8691852689,
0.3025759459,
-0.67585814,
0.0497739613,
-0.0474023521,
0.2032564133,
0.3361562192,
0.7724357247,
-0.5701252222,
-0.337043345,
-0.3351624012,
-0.4315720797,
0.6279845238,
0.0082004359,
0.3560267687,
-0.256249696,
0.1084895954,
0.3457849026,
0.2565880716,
-0.6901089549,
-0.4576521814,
-0.1264143586,
-0.0468582027,
-0.4180681407,
-0.6742334366,
-0.1921155006,
-0.1076636165,
0.6289563179,
-0.0737039447,
-0.0664906651,
0.0671103969,
-0.3366609216,
0.1165072098,
0.4885821939,
0.6768841743,
0.958288312,
-0.1505262852,
0.5444934964,
0.2803904116,
-0.5133966208,
0.1016960964,
0.0458601601,
-0.1732925922,
0.273604244,
0.8280533552,
0.7784191966,
0.4142492115,
-0.528852284,
0.418463856,
0.0772571713,
0.075494431,
-0.2971552312,
0.0818224251,
0.2776705325,
0.3024649024,
0.2942030728,
0.0496650115,
-0.0484394766,
-0.6418203712,
0.1576796174,
0.2605540752,
-0.274741441,
-0.5582453609,
0.1323161423,
0.4363868237,
0.2327776998,
0.4367592335,
-0.2631698251,
-0.6928238869,
0.3655079901,
0.5331864357,
0.3004454076,
-0.0238006376,
0.4802604914,
0.4363461733,
0.1968865693,
0.0550385416,
0.2140985131,
0.093540892,
-0.9834485054,
-0.8877726197,
-0.7274758816,
-0.2515977621,
-0.0236888714,
-0.1983081847,
0.4074178338,
-0.019522436,
-0.1555672586,
-0.0231155362,
0.3214254975,
-0.6289697289,
0.1566904485,
0.2777637243,
0.946605742,
-0.8541095853,
0.7045242786,
0.6453416348,
-0.3306894898,
-0.6897267103,
-0.0803692713,
0.2247760594,
-0.6729654074,
0.7730531693,
-0.18964836,
-0.4591688514,
-0.1804262847,
-0.2593587041,
-1.0620675087,
0.9824035764,
0.6712414622,
-0.3545332849,
-0.0373874344,
0.1698396951,
0.3416902721,
-0.1174801737,
0.1703004539,
0.4675268531,
0.7576228976,
-0.1036513373,
-0.7221722603,
-0.1280351877,
0.032669127,
-0.5254494548,
0.0598122217,
-0.9864676595,
0.9554162621,
-0.1862491369,
-0.3701304197,
-0.4437214732,
0.5728240609,
0.3368530273,
0.1236826852,
0.5210595131,
0.3585855067,
0.9318920374,
0.1839259118,
1.1838918924,
-0.4724593163,
0.5297245383,
0.9396706223,
-0.3279615343,
0.577383101,
0.3504469395,
-0.3756349087,
0.6363056302,
0.1861094385,
0.1988416016,
0.1214643046,
-0.3114259243,
-0.407892853,
-0.3559373021,
-0.4387522042,
-0.2430867255,
0.9477632046,
0.1633429676,
0.0082327686,
-0.5665733814,
-0.3498894572,
0.6140695214,
0.0536030568,
-0.1213037595,
0.4618869424,
-0.0193129349,
-0.6805436015,
0.3704736233,
0.1125654876,
0.3766113818,
-0.7113180161,
0.029394161,
-0.4349481463,
-0.1676634997,
-0.3359531164,
-0.9983562231,
0.2176767737,
0.4456379712,
-0.5253301859,
0.0994123891,
0.5753065944,
-0.4957007766,
-0.880428791,
0.2847115099,
0.8616490364,
0.2413600832,
0.1191279218,
-0.4249874949,
0.0644808114,
-0.0550407059,
-0.3799901903,
0.1639328748,
0.6842530966,
-0.0029637972,
0.5213429928,
0.6227795482,
0.3732272387,
-0.0155465379,
0.0044081123,
0.5837969184,
-0.5669445992,
-0.3505585194,
-0.8949052095,
0.3717936277,
-0.2251951993,
-0.2239839137,
1.1834672689,
0.7156759501,
0.5587214828,
0.0313535258,
0.9130326509,
-0.030252859,
0.6487467289,
-0.7511464357,
0.6456621885,
-0.5622826815,
0.2156963497,
-0.0483180359,
-1.0212806463,
-0.0826463774,
-0.0320892856,
-0.1312213987,
-0.1966493726,
0.9010293484,
0.4625869393,
-0.2949713767,
-0.0990560427,
0.3451119959,
0.4497091174,
0.200395599,
0.2124815732,
0.719763875,
-0.0799509808,
0.6400706172,
-0.240381062,
-0.116955176,
0.010972511,
-1.1948444843,
-0.6184840798,
-0.4699419439,
-0.1750225872,
-0.1043935269,
-0.1595989466,
0.6533487439,
0.5320132971,
-0.7615845203,
-0.4040225744,
0.6100497842,
0.6949238181,
0.1154187694,
-0.1970773339,
0.4709712267,
-0.5583450794,
-0.6356133223,
0.5235170722,
0.1961523741,
-0.4265955091,
-0.5151933432,
-0.1109414101,
-0.4007291198,
0.1174465194,
0.8604468703,
0.0554519817,
-0.3538091779,
-0.6269220114,
0.1138723269,
-0.1441567987,
0.054058101,
0.7608469725,
-0.4176846147,
0.4269047976,
0.4944937229,
0.3125622272,
0.3648377061,
-0.1185946018,
0.4533733428,
-1.0919326544,
0.1545393169,
-0.1556131989,
0.4299303591,
0.5703830719,
-0.2217376977,
0.2660053074,
0.433406949,
-0.2704980969,
-0.4158376157,
0.4581327736,
-0.5470608473,
-0.3652840257,
1.2712125778,
-0.278401792,
-0.2857810259,
-0.1942131817,
0.1466439664,
0.2543697059,
-0.3501625061,
0.5205472708,
1.2299265862,
-0.1724950075,
-0.1442009062,
-0.6478985548,
0.4803452492,
-0.119510144,
-0.5698752403,
0.0664733425,
0.7819549441,
0.5055655241,
0.5077709556,
0.4200016856,
-0.0318511687,
0.1161169186,
-0.2392615974,
-0.0711786598,
-0.1817320734,
-0.639950633,
0.134909898,
0.3608665764,
0.256380707,
0.2784228325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14644v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14644v1 | Unveiling the Spectrum of Data Contamination in Language Models: A Survey from Detection to Remediation | 2024-06-20T18:07:26 | 2024-06-20T18:07:26 | Chunyuan Deng, Yilun Zhao, Yuzhao Heng, Yitong Li, Jiannan Cao, Xiangru Tang, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data contamination has garnered increased attention in the era of large
language models (LLMs) due to the reliance on extensive internet-derived
training corpora. The issue of training corpus overlap with evaluation
benchmarks--referred to as contamination--has been the focus of significant
recent research. This body of work aims to identify contamination, understand
its impacts, and explore mitigation strategies from diverse perspectives.
However, comprehensive studies that provide a clear pathway from foundational
concepts to advanced insights are lacking in this nascent field. Therefore, we
present a comprehensive survey in the field of data contamination, laying out
the key issues, methodologies, and findings to date, and highlighting areas in
need of further research and development. In particular, we begin by examining
the effects of data contamination across various stages and forms. We then
provide a detailed analysis of current contamination detection methods,
categorizing them to highlight their focus, assumptions, strengths, and
limitations. We also discuss mitigation strategies, offering a clear guide for
future research. This survey serves as a succinct overview of the most recent
advancements in data contamination research, providing a straightforward guide
for the benefit of future research endeavors. | [
-0.5234677792,
-1.0544872284,
0.5885725021,
-0.1641660035,
0.0748075843,
0.4574871957,
-0.1724233776,
-0.6986294985,
-0.0197782628,
1.0961581469,
-0.2661701739,
-0.426810801,
-0.7464258671,
-0.0959860981,
-0.9524288177,
0.9090952277,
-0.1084311157,
-0.3221201003,
-0.4489751458,
0.1225598156,
-0.3726418912,
-0.6942617297,
-0.6451629996,
-0.1919030994,
0.6501786113,
0.6399642825,
0.3993190229,
0.9989421368,
0.5465365052,
0.3337173164,
-0.3292342424,
0.0520113669,
-0.7118635178,
0.4804257751,
-0.1470171213,
-0.5307095647,
-0.1803427786,
-0.0738218799,
0.7694036365,
1.2321172953,
-0.0375519581,
-0.0245510116,
0.252967149,
0.6902078986,
-1.1288986206,
-0.1164850295,
-0.7245717645,
-0.1061009318,
-0.6457266212,
-0.2294095755,
-0.4325537682,
-0.3810754716,
-0.0430543609,
-0.5720452666,
0.2761844397,
-0.1889651567,
0.6602482796,
0.2796625495,
-0.6131785512,
-0.1977180243,
-1.0475320816,
1.0398719311,
-0.5690667033,
0.3823383749,
0.7685038447,
0.1120848358,
-0.2898734212,
-0.9752556086,
-0.1674207449,
0.0643541142,
0.2247262001,
-0.2296514064,
-0.455930084,
-0.24254556,
0.1696701199,
0.2744871676,
-0.4077370465,
0.2494293898,
-0.4735698998,
-0.3760171533,
0.6002908945,
0.1953709424,
0.5120241642,
-0.0487645306,
-0.4364947975,
-0.0872154683,
-1.3519889116,
-0.2194584012,
0.6083990335,
0.1674043536,
0.1453226954,
0.3340483308,
-0.2305710912,
0.6627213359,
-0.3964374959,
0.1167208329,
0.2904910147,
-0.7568241358,
-0.1850369573,
-0.0935520455,
0.6912790537,
0.0443607792,
0.1960352212,
-0.1939715594,
-0.2130679488,
-0.1415804029,
0.3430590928,
-0.5290189385,
-0.2898837924,
0.3222799599,
-0.0570516735,
-0.5405539274,
-0.302982986,
-0.9864212871,
-0.7099716663,
-0.4870209694,
0.0255075898,
-0.2489352077,
-0.6019708514,
0.1668709666,
0.1213990599,
-0.1534573883,
0.2094935477,
-1.017616272,
0.2676736712,
1.0175341368,
0.3379426897,
-0.0852672905,
-0.1112429947,
-0.3087804317,
0.0741621852,
-0.3174901009,
0.9551551938,
-0.6429707408,
-0.6147675514,
0.4142770767,
-0.247306481,
0.1159203574,
-0.9827429056,
0.8316512704,
-0.5495842099,
0.1944206804,
-0.2841983736,
-0.8169350028,
-0.184130311,
0.1669441909,
-0.8315610886,
1.2582654953,
0.0171325058,
-1.0463916063,
0.4689848125,
-0.1118591949,
-0.3271673024,
0.123048678,
-0.1774730086,
-0.3043093979,
-0.1080940887,
-0.0913859978,
0.2637448311,
-0.2707770467,
0.4488149583,
-0.447578907,
-0.363547802,
0.3333300352,
-0.5994262099,
0.7486796379,
0.3862723708,
-0.1578187197,
0.0972626135,
-0.9239016771,
0.0275599752,
-0.0988664106,
-0.3308293521,
-0.5467395186,
0.0949925557,
0.2563607693,
0.1872425079,
0.027042862,
-0.3719064593,
-0.0556105115,
-0.127518326,
0.4043015242,
0.7497913837,
0.2197845131,
0.3560400009,
-0.4530647695,
0.509434104,
0.1627274752,
0.3636309505,
-0.1668030322,
-0.2938807607,
-0.721865952,
-0.3321546614,
0.3714372516,
0.2843923271,
-0.6365039349,
0.5981353521,
-0.4258392751,
-0.7301338911,
-0.5680924058,
0.0891050845,
0.2314473242,
0.4929149747,
0.3289440572,
-0.1729372293,
-0.7016536593,
-1.0014644861,
-0.2879295945,
0.0676736906,
0.0332770944,
0.3039047122,
0.62181741,
-0.3855133057,
1.1948783398,
-0.4769431651,
-0.11491514,
-0.1751591116,
0.0262734089,
-0.184158504,
0.4944870472,
0.1979427338,
-0.6884679198,
-0.4179305136,
-0.3348160386,
-0.7471922636,
-0.3537201583,
0.1637351662,
0.0125408173,
-0.1420147419,
0.9172420502,
-0.1042479426,
0.2329439223,
0.5513659716,
-0.1366386116,
0.5274948478,
0.0362573937,
0.1499570459,
-0.8335749507,
0.4203459322,
-0.1023706049,
-0.2684361041,
-1.0519832373,
-0.0665976256,
-0.0150007745,
0.2349437624,
-0.6243937612,
0.3636419475,
-0.3059649765,
0.0450767688,
-0.422364682,
0.4717516601,
0.1172275692,
-0.1231894046,
-0.1946614385,
0.6585711837,
0.5275050402,
-0.4120244682,
0.2738707662,
0.246219486,
-0.5673028827,
0.1981690228,
-0.5336897373,
0.1083999053,
0.0440316461,
0.2348958552,
-1.081720233,
-0.0285457149,
0.509141624,
-0.3309927881,
0.4005715251,
-0.376947701,
-0.6872139573,
0.2812460661,
-0.2714081109,
0.6315638423,
0.1424313933,
-0.4852793813,
0.0840151757,
0.7369502783,
-0.2728054523,
-0.7689769864,
-0.7195985317,
0.3273224831,
-0.4841065705,
-0.7147243023,
0.0316659696,
0.1376610696,
-0.658629179,
0.0423510261,
-0.0772218928,
-0.3936651647,
0.6740217209,
0.09770675,
0.1625230908,
-0.0191638283,
0.0987292826,
-0.1038172767,
-0.0681888238,
0.2186155468,
0.3328318596,
0.7544316053,
0.4451135993,
-0.5004752874,
-0.1730373502,
0.3648208678,
0.3174218833,
-0.3436836004,
0.7098562121,
0.1779633164,
-0.4362386465,
-0.1791613251,
-0.5101810098,
-0.1361575872,
-0.5407322049,
0.3662530184,
-0.0610168688,
-0.7251573205,
0.5131365657,
-0.2801224589,
-0.0987114087,
0.3337090015,
0.1428581923,
-0.1585929841,
0.4170666039,
0.7069094777,
-0.2040811777,
0.6464430094,
-0.2065493613,
0.1952052265,
-0.8570188284,
-0.1356207877,
-0.7884808779,
0.1306631714,
-0.6685723066,
-0.4114189446,
-0.0268167593,
0.0418360122,
-0.0773866251,
0.1127115116,
-0.1127143726,
0.4379070401,
0.2748610675,
-0.1827909499,
0.5772132874,
-0.1466258615,
0.0672354549,
-0.0578501709,
-0.4727501571,
-0.6743293405,
1.4220666885,
0.5071319342,
0.6939923167,
-0.030385999,
0.899240911,
0.3538187146,
0.264573127,
-0.2697725296,
0.3873731792,
-0.1247731596,
-0.9002683759,
-0.1559768319,
-0.6149896383,
-1.2760454416,
0.287992686,
-0.0989922732,
-0.804436028,
0.3466200531,
-0.1492650807,
0.1156006306,
0.3271152377,
-0.4297634363,
0.8511345387,
-0.1510100961,
-0.523304224,
-0.0822425187,
-0.5816833377,
0.7149963379,
-0.5118531585,
0.678188324,
-0.199596256,
0.0754817203,
0.7644716501,
-0.2163891345,
0.7734716535,
-0.0355266333,
-0.5899786353,
0.123902142,
0.0690084547,
0.4447337687,
-0.4009096622,
0.2951770723,
0.2444052696,
0.1029794142,
-0.3344368339,
-0.2382544875,
0.5295748711,
-0.5123614073,
-0.2705666423,
-0.4442794621,
-0.5437522531,
-0.5119555593,
0.2398893982,
0.3060945868,
0.2774372697,
-0.1433814615,
0.464504391,
0.9600742459,
-0.3756128848,
0.2528198063,
0.4774164259,
-0.4963060915,
-0.1502956003,
1.0106362104,
-0.0352772921,
0.6497907639,
0.186837703,
-0.0363775641,
-0.2905317843,
-0.7929512858,
0.0517784953,
0.2581316233,
-0.7363420129,
-0.0280312859,
-0.5345710516,
-0.1104683429,
-0.4083999097,
0.3151578605,
-0.599014163,
-0.0889703184,
-0.3681580126,
-0.0893487483,
0.2062779963,
0.7952321768,
-0.025334131,
0.37655586,
-0.7959131002,
0.0895735919,
-0.3523603678,
0.3885607421,
-0.211394757,
-0.5223725438,
-0.2981424332,
0.2064456493,
-0.1608956903,
-0.7181129456,
0.3053327203,
-0.0079399496,
0.741558373,
0.5668129921,
-0.0224634185,
0.4215420485,
-0.241674006,
0.6544924378,
-0.107945241,
-0.8336445093,
0.4631716609,
-0.5144081116,
-0.2466578335,
0.7133381367,
0.3144733608,
-1.1524614096,
-0.8546332717,
-0.655415535,
-1.3631913662,
0.4302194118,
0.1327671707,
-0.0378543325,
0.1681764722,
0.176161468,
-0.0103670182,
0.1642421782,
-0.3440407813,
-0.3645856977,
0.251069963,
-0.0778903663,
-0.0461381078,
-0.4719046652,
-0.368558526,
0.2100518495,
0.6412700415,
0.294680208,
-0.2197404504,
-0.2586920261,
-0.5424048305,
0.0476491041,
0.3176577091,
0.5147976279,
0.6856631041,
-0.0247840341,
0.1789533943,
-0.2083457559,
-0.7446248531,
0.1122637391,
-0.0529614724,
-0.2681489587,
-0.2613309324,
0.6579552293,
0.2784056664,
0.5837758183,
-0.8674532175,
0.4670442939,
-0.0708768144,
-0.0437142104,
-0.3367288709,
0.083408311,
0.1778229922,
-0.0850873888,
0.3676317036,
-0.1212290153,
0.2537955046,
-0.611092031,
0.6858101487,
0.1194017604,
-0.1699411571,
0.0606530532,
0.4674526155,
0.145200178,
0.2800363898,
0.6946200132,
0.1862185299,
-0.3346164227,
0.6484137774,
0.1845403761,
0.5601585507,
-0.2465688139,
-0.0799643695,
-0.005962274,
0.385330528,
0.0959497392,
0.2426441461,
0.3086513877,
-0.9585351944,
-0.5632490516,
-0.3557275534,
-0.4058576524,
0.5238703489,
-0.8957251906,
0.0011446908,
-0.2577832639,
0.036479339,
0.2076682299,
0.1558286399,
-0.3277294934,
0.1107079834,
0.2992292345,
0.9305410981,
-1.2545460463,
0.8377906084,
0.0997255445,
-0.496799022,
-0.4462910891,
0.0027214321,
0.3283210993,
-0.563844502,
0.6302736998,
-0.0612299182,
-0.0108693102,
-0.2074158341,
-0.3089995384,
-1.0996205807,
0.6863875985,
0.3014060259,
-0.4508410394,
0.4637072682,
0.5230923295,
0.5236676335,
0.1385161281,
0.1745765209,
1.0907019377,
0.6515932083,
-0.2150621414,
-0.5594444275,
-0.0476902947,
-0.1724468619,
-0.1374899298,
0.2569424212,
-0.2450217307,
0.5568894148,
0.4470256269,
-0.3108238876,
0.1245267466,
0.318187654,
0.1831987053,
0.2581583858,
0.5076208711,
0.6579464078,
0.9382373095,
-0.3203209937,
0.8196266294,
-0.2998173535,
0.3355172276,
1.354586482,
-0.4563965499,
0.823453784,
0.5328909159,
-0.4079833925,
0.2634531856,
0.8688904047,
-0.1526363045,
0.3905300796,
0.6451457739,
-0.5033775568,
0.1460781991,
-0.4056473374,
-0.3690364063,
0.7023287416,
0.5068746805,
-0.3696500957,
-0.3988981843,
0.1202035919,
0.3183363676,
0.1866349429,
0.0196004976,
0.7241668701,
-0.2332317978,
-0.5597114563,
0.4217118621,
-0.0944607705,
0.4597398639,
-0.4598771334,
0.0549979359,
-0.5468717217,
0.1362062097,
-0.4283085167,
-0.9955097437,
0.4659418762,
0.0813972801,
-0.1285026819,
-0.4664897919,
0.720212698,
-0.6300880313,
-0.0462169573,
0.6234353185,
0.7927010655,
0.513006866,
-0.2570738792,
-0.3327458501,
0.6077164412,
-0.1167707667,
-0.1077523828,
0.5529696345,
0.2148769051,
0.0352542438,
0.8493374586,
0.7238128781,
0.2173837274,
0.3251665831,
0.3380482197,
0.881360352,
-0.4951767027,
0.0392385945,
-0.7670815587,
0.4583309889,
0.1100905091,
-0.1327730715,
0.6750423908,
1.0136746168,
0.781771481,
0.3621403873,
0.9546635151,
0.2316886932,
0.6818612218,
-0.4428960681,
0.8038710356,
-0.3610947728,
0.593146503,
-0.1371606886,
-0.7149797082,
-0.2912864685,
0.1028370634,
-0.2135532647,
0.0887490064,
0.6239597201,
0.7103886008,
-0.1041089967,
0.0958711579,
0.1943508983,
0.2634630203,
0.6805182099,
0.28193748,
1.1508446932,
-0.2389754653,
0.6649733782,
-0.4186064899,
-0.1856619567,
-0.2475532293,
-0.792941153,
-0.1333185434,
-0.5807222724,
-0.3952969909,
-0.1845496148,
0.0833756998,
0.2386559695,
0.4019370973,
-0.7169777751,
-0.1748501509,
-0.1576259732,
0.2162836045,
-0.0903897509,
-0.2187323868,
0.4167447388,
-0.5136570334,
-0.8121992946,
0.5860615969,
-0.268402338,
-0.2846412063,
-0.3058570027,
0.5536512733,
-0.2802337408,
-0.1819832921,
0.4920313656,
0.4104075432,
-0.4104379416,
-0.4204176664,
-0.2730736136,
-0.4022351503,
0.0383417085,
0.8130732775,
-0.5097349286,
0.4314039946,
0.4609023929,
0.7718149424,
0.3539001048,
-0.1053159311,
0.5315465331,
-0.9472592473,
-0.336922437,
0.2447116673,
0.5070422292,
0.6023460031,
-0.4211599231,
0.6630610228,
0.3036542237,
-0.7270463109,
-1.0916606188,
0.2487077266,
-0.7855123878,
-0.3611083329,
1.4733303785,
-0.1667206436,
0.0179070663,
-0.5125920177,
0.1153361499,
0.307893604,
-0.0241293013,
0.8537899256,
0.965587616,
0.0001379015,
0.0184735917,
-0.9314450026,
0.3991881907,
0.2620535195,
-1.2824957371,
0.6268569231,
0.6699963212,
0.7175360322,
-0.0154268285,
0.4115589559,
-0.4048615396,
-0.0088359518,
-0.0007481029,
0.0891078934,
0.1742260605,
-0.2647907138,
-0.6667316556,
-0.0219721589,
-0.012050542,
-0.1721138656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14643v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14643v1 | Holistic Evaluation for Interleaved Text-and-Image Generation | 2024-06-20T18:07:19 | 2024-06-20T18:07:19 | Minqian Liu, Zhiyang Xu, Zihao Lin, Trevor Ashby, Joy Rimchala, Jiaxin Zhang, Lifu Huang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Interleaved text-and-image generation has been an intriguing research
direction, where the models are required to generate both images and text
pieces in an arbitrary order. Despite the emerging advancements in interleaved
generation, the progress in its evaluation still significantly lags behind.
Existing evaluation benchmarks do not support arbitrarily interleaved images
and text for both inputs and outputs, and they only cover a limited number of
domains and use cases. Also, current works predominantly use similarity-based
metrics which fall short in assessing the quality in open-ended scenarios. To
this end, we introduce InterleavedBench, the first benchmark carefully curated
for the evaluation of interleaved text-and-image generation. InterleavedBench
features a rich array of tasks to cover diverse real-world use cases. In
addition, we present InterleavedEval, a strong reference-free metric powered by
GPT-4o to deliver accurate and explainable evaluation. We carefully define five
essential evaluation aspects for InterleavedEval, including text quality,
perceptual quality, image coherence, text-image coherence, and helpfulness, to
ensure a comprehensive and fine-grained assessment. Through extensive
experiments and rigorous human evaluation, we show that our benchmark and
metric can effectively evaluate the existing models with a strong correlation
with human judgments surpassing previous reference-based metrics. We also
provide substantial findings and insights to foster future research in
interleaved generation and its evaluation. | [
-0.5711271167,
-0.5367170572,
0.3858139217,
0.6458963156,
-0.5222363472,
0.2750462294,
-0.2225728631,
-0.4785775244,
-0.5438292623,
0.0044373819,
-0.4917402267,
-0.3741366267,
-0.620341599,
0.0062191552,
-0.4210162461,
0.9646821618,
-0.002324322,
0.1414617449,
-0.6451676488,
-0.2753216624,
-0.5298497081,
0.0527412668,
-0.3018007576,
-0.4542097449,
0.0577694625,
0.2656968534,
0.6435636878,
0.2102309614,
0.8100309968,
0.2143333554,
0.2261996269,
0.2208267301,
-0.5140496492,
0.2381348461,
-0.3509604037,
0.2880828083,
-0.0774047077,
0.1371127367,
0.5133336782,
0.4161104262,
0.1523583829,
0.2956471741,
0.5088282824,
0.7561029196,
-0.7604401112,
0.0852602795,
-0.8508298993,
0.1571423262,
-0.2515649199,
-0.397272408,
-0.3232545853,
-0.4954074323,
-0.027644692,
-0.4763227999,
0.4345960617,
0.0242554191,
0.8201380968,
0.1462512463,
-0.1216676235,
-0.5664368868,
-0.54793185,
0.6417303681,
-0.6040423512,
0.2668923438,
0.2516729534,
0.1540502608,
-0.1389184594,
-0.9243504405,
-0.6980764866,
-0.3206798732,
0.219609499,
0.652300179,
-0.3988051414,
-0.0625494197,
-0.0205014534,
0.7166082859,
-0.5483355522,
0.1782247275,
-0.1837000996,
-0.1155908406,
0.6441380382,
0.0184202585,
0.3565311134,
-0.1368176788,
-0.5623559356,
-0.3682456613,
-0.5501353741,
-0.2691713274,
0.799464941,
0.0426685475,
-0.0472548157,
0.5092671514,
-0.2721390724,
0.4167871475,
0.0998871401,
0.1345679909,
0.0244427193,
-0.6813079715,
0.1647796184,
-0.0292499475,
1.1447843313,
0.7288196683,
-0.0165097602,
-0.3974819183,
-0.1186082661,
0.310914129,
0.4590156376,
-1.2038679123,
-0.0522048883,
-0.0259722415,
-0.643720448,
-0.30805704,
0.0844839364,
-0.9849430323,
-0.2481292188,
0.0373429172,
0.5350215435,
-0.5513197184,
-0.1285266727,
-0.2710106969,
0.0296527278,
0.0345355347,
0.2184400558,
-0.7342990637,
0.2422021478,
0.6822447181,
0.8591553569,
-0.2901697159,
-0.3009435833,
-0.4083032608,
-0.3345344365,
-0.3351262212,
0.880127728,
-0.2012283504,
-0.4198623598,
0.100235112,
-0.3257361054,
0.4898072779,
-0.6016491055,
0.7219851017,
-0.5831463337,
0.4161795974,
-0.1013431475,
-0.640098393,
0.0799035653,
0.1889614612,
-0.6240385771,
1.0691893101,
0.2144701183,
-0.8478637338,
0.7843856812,
-0.534065783,
-0.4498846531,
0.4857881069,
-0.2677769065,
-0.8219190836,
0.3320370018,
0.0455871373,
0.5356826782,
-0.9065902233,
0.5304803252,
-0.355530262,
-0.283239156,
-0.033287812,
-0.6891722083,
0.3610009551,
0.206004709,
-0.4305205047,
-0.0373795666,
-0.7940834165,
0.4257029295,
0.1749598533,
-0.3314034939,
-0.2309453338,
0.0066913287,
0.3321650028,
0.2024302781,
0.1866293699,
-0.7984522581,
-0.1079736352,
-0.075814262,
0.4537635148,
0.5357391238,
0.2249099463,
0.3510423899,
-0.1918816119,
0.3448495865,
0.0551818386,
0.1365963668,
-0.3523669541,
-0.4997992218,
-0.4901515245,
0.2216158658,
0.3866898715,
0.1234099716,
-0.798130095,
0.3743296862,
-0.329577148,
-0.8416681886,
-0.4294606447,
-0.1594112962,
0.8437227607,
0.6257809997,
0.5992583036,
-0.6703587174,
-0.1156338453,
-0.9669302702,
-0.4937909544,
-0.2090264708,
0.1186201274,
-0.026511183,
0.2714227438,
-0.093290545,
0.5780907273,
-0.0810543969,
-0.0652120113,
0.2157839388,
0.591317296,
-0.0396312736,
0.6082439423,
0.2581981122,
-0.7180196047,
-0.6366706491,
0.1380494833,
-0.5900226831,
-0.1226437464,
-0.2321923077,
-0.1692684144,
-0.0463078693,
0.6655391455,
-0.3229151368,
0.6788596511,
0.7403723598,
-0.2782739699,
0.6324197054,
-0.2995935082,
0.544857204,
-0.8962381482,
0.0368794501,
-0.1962499171,
-0.0794297457,
-0.2733063996,
0.2214489132,
0.2946335077,
-0.0574832968,
-0.1888757199,
0.5253852606,
-0.571074605,
-0.5034691095,
-0.1020002663,
-0.0026875506,
0.3515446782,
0.1249473616,
-0.4344919026,
1.0270315409,
0.0343470015,
-0.363563925,
0.0471141934,
0.3135724366,
-0.9398791194,
0.9438506961,
-0.5926252007,
0.289619416,
0.0367925838,
-0.0174661595,
-0.8926880956,
-0.2305683792,
-0.0719501004,
-0.2850446701,
0.1298491508,
0.326077342,
-0.7988941669,
-0.2604373395,
-0.1193943322,
0.6215646863,
0.6666588187,
-0.8349990845,
0.0036711323,
-0.0354077779,
-0.249541387,
-0.2764032185,
-0.4089611471,
0.3128679991,
0.0040270933,
-0.6535130739,
0.8493569493,
-0.4224301875,
-0.2408688217,
0.1958507448,
0.0876265615,
-0.0216543246,
-0.1260570139,
0.3053628504,
0.1099720523,
-0.1552298069,
0.2568354309,
0.2773469687,
-0.1119635254,
-0.1901897341,
-0.0506783128,
0.4990669787,
-0.2829216123,
-0.669238627,
-0.1973086447,
0.4118228257,
0.3468768299,
-0.2091290206,
0.1601953954,
0.7227304578,
-0.2167185992,
0.023941841,
-0.5264299512,
0.1667445749,
-0.4271931946,
0.504643321,
-0.2227735668,
-0.5066584945,
0.1125015616,
-0.3107566833,
0.2542434931,
0.6074028611,
0.7828299403,
-0.204695195,
0.8702452183,
0.3175470829,
0.6853855848,
0.3553329408,
0.0650141016,
0.2536329329,
-0.7904047966,
-0.283339709,
-0.1724765748,
-0.3226607144,
-0.3413902819,
-0.4205079377,
0.4229513407,
0.4325677752,
-0.013034977,
0.0638741925,
-0.6498707533,
0.516417861,
0.4859555364,
0.1434939057,
0.5306476951,
0.1126712561,
-0.2090594918,
-0.1424495578,
-0.5234567523,
-0.6694310904,
0.8572271466,
0.0328578092,
0.433321178,
-0.1385795474,
0.6260243654,
0.6228151917,
0.5920867324,
-0.5748633742,
0.4825522006,
-0.4003596306,
-0.2343456894,
0.1080104038,
-0.1496334225,
-1.0394750834,
0.2093529999,
-0.4360073805,
-0.2631051838,
0.0448174365,
0.1935270578,
-0.1663177162,
0.1512921751,
-0.526884377,
0.6845038533,
-0.2914325595,
-0.7402717471,
-0.3550973833,
-0.4905651212,
0.5073136091,
-0.1230192482,
0.0792502388,
-0.1573466659,
0.1535222381,
0.5048316121,
-0.6744945645,
0.1859757453,
0.0004183043,
0.0554895326,
0.3766395748,
-0.0481951609,
0.0249498859,
-0.1684477031,
-0.2497846335,
0.4177680612,
-0.1853228211,
-0.2703751326,
-0.3071834743,
0.8612094522,
-0.5772253275,
-0.0492119044,
-0.1323014349,
-0.5241271257,
-0.4130527675,
0.2512762547,
1.0481567383,
0.5476999879,
-0.620686233,
0.3235856891,
0.2430519164,
-0.3158673644,
0.6843541265,
-0.0681223571,
-0.230674535,
-0.6832761168,
0.9079962373,
0.0488534048,
0.4888186753,
0.1145190895,
0.1839711368,
-0.4120239615,
-0.6318535209,
-0.6737157106,
-0.1111672446,
-0.862894237,
-0.5035120845,
-0.419919312,
-0.1729792804,
0.0481924824,
-0.105081968,
-0.3416814208,
-0.0493985713,
-0.5160655975,
0.1684633195,
0.0717284828,
0.6940837502,
-0.0471666194,
0.3633018732,
-0.8032711148,
0.4753749073,
0.266138494,
0.4646102786,
0.1548279971,
-0.0871034786,
-0.312189877,
-0.1869429797,
-0.5644589067,
-0.6369031668,
0.1399265528,
0.38999632,
0.3115853071,
0.2068819255,
-0.0568833239,
0.8051627278,
-0.648417592,
0.6072402,
0.6754425168,
-0.9718663096,
0.3853730857,
-0.0775429383,
0.5374082923,
0.7373352051,
0.0419104658,
-0.1320308596,
-0.1742017716,
-0.7844093442,
-0.8530123234,
0.2461711317,
0.4616453648,
0.021583166,
0.016070595,
0.2891052067,
0.5627599359,
0.2378684133,
-0.5690236092,
0.4599632621,
-0.514033854,
-0.3419490755,
0.1503511816,
-0.1663680375,
0.0820236579,
0.0673153847,
0.5365152955,
-0.1502965689,
0.0830266327,
0.2065447867,
-0.2648653984,
-0.2222310752,
0.2892711759,
0.1840455234,
0.3784891963,
0.2087391764,
0.0485948212,
-0.2682351172,
-0.6243849397,
0.2520733178,
-0.0154523402,
-0.2851083279,
-0.0816084966,
0.621728003,
0.9676460028,
0.0522549748,
-0.6766142249,
0.7274848223,
-0.4629814327,
-0.2861639857,
0.049806647,
-0.0739137009,
-0.1160751656,
0.2869661748,
0.2546066046,
0.3360327482,
0.1551180929,
-0.4093178809,
0.0797515512,
0.4809629321,
-0.4992752373,
-0.4208219647,
0.63782686,
0.1951286644,
-0.3061283231,
0.630823195,
-0.4960034192,
-0.2178024501,
0.5706324577,
0.6059694886,
1.0675069094,
0.1303248852,
0.0632140189,
0.5572926402,
0.3614931107,
0.1493697017,
0.3934068382,
-0.281370759,
-0.5665302277,
-0.1851744056,
-0.7496217489,
-0.3584313095,
0.1926089972,
-0.7967819571,
0.1451885849,
-0.6020796299,
-0.3470794261,
-0.0923503041,
-0.1875838786,
-0.8437571526,
0.3401702344,
-0.062383458,
0.6936708093,
-0.5634467006,
0.3489202857,
0.4845939577,
-0.3935709894,
-0.2979901731,
0.4647290409,
-0.4677916765,
-0.7611681223,
0.6159245968,
0.2918205261,
-0.1101205647,
0.1787019074,
-0.3650551438,
-0.3163578212,
1.2058683634,
0.1663040072,
-0.6710529327,
0.232896015,
0.0004112942,
0.5429721475,
-0.2676671445,
0.2859047353,
0.3649070859,
0.3561335206,
-0.0806102157,
-0.5511461496,
0.0029809088,
-0.4462001026,
0.3819125891,
0.1484791189,
-0.7646552324,
0.8267812133,
-0.2137461603,
-0.6691148281,
0.5282606483,
0.671074152,
0.1694652885,
0.3764564991,
0.5997775793,
0.6247534156,
0.3545209169,
-0.1858685911,
1.0106850863,
-0.4354300499,
0.2523425221,
1.1415829659,
-0.3477183282,
0.8352816105,
0.4347579479,
-0.2342854738,
0.4491340816,
0.6691035032,
0.0363377742,
0.7882201076,
-0.0101359161,
-0.4058985412,
-0.0466469303,
-0.3159408867,
-0.4358608723,
0.4091424644,
0.246313706,
-0.3283727765,
-0.4908309281,
0.0597722083,
-0.2757877707,
0.2886014879,
-0.0273438618,
0.7474983335,
-0.2402429283,
-1.0241396427,
0.4267314374,
-0.0490682423,
0.5611324906,
-0.4344512224,
-0.1712122411,
0.0419249833,
0.1513541043,
-0.2297531664,
-0.9346129894,
0.1636388153,
0.1441795379,
-0.2546220124,
-0.2647278607,
0.923114717,
-0.30521065,
-0.3020839095,
0.3186620176,
0.2126102448,
-0.0792541802,
-0.0897944197,
-0.6192047596,
0.2578677535,
-0.1429821253,
-0.0663817599,
0.3336161971,
0.3192771971,
-0.0616329834,
0.0310216192,
0.8148062229,
-0.2534781396,
0.1752005666,
0.1629282087,
0.6537956595,
-0.2896894515,
-0.3909906447,
-0.8507406712,
0.502525568,
-0.1971196383,
-0.6250113249,
0.6015977263,
0.574757278,
0.7507972121,
-0.0867482722,
0.9903606176,
-0.0431564152,
0.0874252841,
-0.5296678543,
0.763923943,
-0.537594378,
-0.2094702423,
-0.437520504,
-1.1558526754,
-0.0407303348,
0.3347928822,
-0.1450213194,
-0.1161544994,
0.5766305327,
0.3743539751,
-0.1816202104,
0.2928642929,
0.4317208529,
0.0043633059,
0.3301322758,
0.1816479266,
1.2271188498,
-0.7114973664,
0.4101109803,
-0.3363508582,
-0.4215065539,
-0.1431806087,
-1.2961179018,
-0.4378061295,
-0.8077738285,
-0.3096676171,
-0.3309194744,
-0.1796744913,
0.4402990341,
0.6810239553,
-0.3137074411,
-0.0200941265,
-0.7572872043,
-0.4583262503,
0.0379275493,
-0.2352405041,
0.1264265031,
-0.3292931616,
-0.7073739171,
0.3450329304,
0.7580164671,
0.0950235426,
-0.7474502325,
-0.0720225126,
-0.0934830979,
0.1166150123,
0.818316102,
0.0892678201,
-0.6250235438,
0.0085366722,
-0.318523109,
-0.1475217342,
0.1386583894,
0.6849917769,
-0.8147371411,
0.7640240192,
0.6019256115,
0.6785334349,
0.5499947667,
0.0399160758,
0.2690991461,
-0.8804558516,
0.137217328,
0.4273675382,
0.3349768519,
0.6814200282,
-0.2924527824,
0.5723959804,
0.0289679486,
-0.7193309665,
-0.7440696955,
0.2832725644,
-0.6277605295,
-0.0650320426,
0.7253768444,
-0.2711302638,
0.167079106,
0.2289190143,
-0.1413814574,
0.2932141721,
-0.0022633863,
0.6356357336,
0.68808043,
-0.2001505047,
0.1473154426,
-0.2253728807,
0.0675862581,
0.4540908337,
-1.3045114279,
-0.1527739465,
0.5951083899,
-0.1773050129,
0.223704353,
0.7194197774,
-0.3776021898,
0.2476113141,
0.2889305949,
0.2042204142,
0.3286805451,
-0.1465370208,
-0.0855012462,
0.1764072925,
-0.0395682678,
-0.1375110894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14629v1 | Can LLMs Learn by Teaching? A Preliminary Study | 2024-06-20T18:00:17 | 2024-06-20T18:00:17 | Xuefei Ning, Zifu Wang, Shiyao Li, Zinan Lin, Peiran Yao, Tianyu Fu, Matthew B. Blaschko, Guohao Dai, Huazhong Yang, Yu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Teaching to improve student models (e.g., knowledge distillation) is an
extensively studied methodology in LLMs. However, for humans, teaching not only
improves students but also improves teachers. We ask: Can LLMs also learn by
teaching (LbT)? If yes, we can potentially unlock the possibility of
continuously advancing the models without solely relying on human-produced data
or stronger models. In this paper, we provide a preliminary exploration of this
ambitious agenda. We show that LbT ideas can be incorporated into existing LLM
training/prompting pipelines and provide noticeable improvements. Specifically,
we design three methods, each mimicking one of the three levels of LbT in
humans: observing students' feedback, learning from the feedback, and learning
iteratively, with the goals of improving answer accuracy without training and
improving models' inherent capability with fine-tuning. The findings are
encouraging. For example, similar to LbT in human, we see that: (1) LbT can
induce weak-to-strong generalization: strong models can improve themselves by
teaching other weak models; (2) Diversity in students might help: teaching
multiple students could be better than teaching one student or the teacher
itself. We hope that this early promise can inspire future research on LbT and
more broadly adopting the advanced techniques in education to improve LLMs. The
code is available at https://github.com/imagination-research/lbt. | [
-0.1971277297,
-0.6686341166,
0.6291469932,
-0.2504683733,
-0.2464007884,
0.3620225489,
-0.2268089801,
-0.3831445873,
-0.0968151093,
0.0623678565,
-0.5436737537,
-0.2082861066,
-0.4620209634,
-0.1309098601,
-0.2811815441,
1.0122095346,
0.1140205041,
0.7364276648,
-0.4275926054,
0.1086671352,
-0.7030318379,
-0.4362855852,
-0.7646402121,
-0.4949661493,
0.7455763221,
0.6698818803,
0.2563678622,
0.541215837,
0.267100364,
0.1527970135,
-0.010391809,
0.2293131649,
-0.6595892906,
-0.0387350284,
-0.2455242574,
-1.0438786745,
-0.2004666328,
0.2739000916,
0.749189198,
1.0465804338,
-0.3537348807,
-0.0691433251,
0.7341116071,
0.6907815337,
-0.2168201059,
-0.0973309577,
-0.6828415394,
0.0937534124,
0.2277670205,
-0.0683331266,
-0.4048200548,
-0.4577892125,
0.0223151464,
-0.3009596467,
0.3405748606,
-0.0605994314,
0.4007338881,
0.2317614108,
-0.5536597967,
-0.3690610528,
-0.5595378876,
0.6762673259,
-0.6402167082,
0.3379328251,
0.2487410009,
0.3536428511,
0.004435861,
-0.7583101392,
-0.2087930441,
-0.3539551497,
0.0099806022,
0.4817210734,
0.2516076565,
-0.0361883268,
0.5200554729,
0.3919098675,
-0.2374033928,
0.2126481235,
-0.6204980612,
0.0186692625,
0.3771371841,
0.1266001314,
0.0425122268,
-0.0449471883,
-0.6444346309,
-0.2183301896,
-0.6759558916,
0.240421325,
0.1618512869,
0.3211974204,
0.0713920966,
0.4157705307,
0.1174687669,
0.5504533648,
-0.0593013391,
0.04531046,
-0.3037169874,
-0.0353117101,
0.0710678771,
-0.1739984006,
0.3355914354,
0.3522553444,
0.2180927545,
-0.2574451268,
-0.2467550188,
0.1998108625,
0.2183782607,
-0.8021237254,
-0.3941437006,
-0.2303532064,
-0.2634176016,
-0.4363181889,
0.0467341095,
-0.6229202151,
-0.6057540178,
-0.4315483868,
0.6846907139,
-0.2561772764,
-0.380241245,
0.1368853748,
-0.1932117045,
0.2598984838,
0.5046963692,
-1.0124822855,
0.4783223867,
0.5419257879,
0.7200760841,
-0.2523960173,
-0.509657383,
-0.2840949595,
-0.0430205688,
-0.3573774397,
0.7464891672,
-0.1974750906,
-0.708012104,
-0.3638201058,
-0.2889039814,
-0.0791414306,
-0.7472780347,
0.2426494807,
-0.3260166049,
0.0917997807,
-0.5818530321,
-0.9119670391,
-0.0867078826,
0.5533332825,
-0.5067874789,
0.904538393,
0.0361719318,
-0.6365239024,
0.346072197,
-0.5990393162,
-0.1178560928,
-0.2331346571,
-0.2439409345,
-0.3192465305,
0.2142654061,
0.2469624579,
0.5780896544,
-0.2416194379,
0.1593753099,
-0.2162173837,
-0.5341316462,
0.4986639023,
-0.5331590772,
0.7063956857,
0.0347990915,
-0.1912267357,
-0.1767117381,
-0.4920935631,
0.037079107,
0.2125879675,
-0.5057276487,
-0.1167966574,
-0.1259786785,
-0.4020264447,
-0.1484989226,
-0.0083770156,
-0.2707324028,
0.7885094285,
-0.1689327657,
0.2411408722,
0.8208718896,
0.1984482408,
0.6161253452,
-0.9821368456,
0.7222151756,
-0.0212177038,
-0.0793335885,
-0.3854531646,
-0.380646497,
-0.8011745811,
-0.0850750729,
0.1891445667,
0.3699543774,
-0.7122416496,
-0.5057725906,
0.0333192647,
-0.5409449935,
-0.5768185258,
0.4948243797,
0.2749547958,
0.7882061005,
0.3464641571,
-0.3955864608,
-0.4946849644,
-0.2990947664,
-0.3876390159,
-0.1902478486,
-0.0222842619,
0.0856397524,
0.4453044236,
0.1844493151,
0.8429046869,
-0.5488264561,
0.1039716899,
-0.3258503377,
0.202863127,
0.2507570684,
0.3672615588,
0.4768230915,
-0.5461481214,
-0.5669218898,
-0.1275354475,
-0.7989165187,
0.0966423601,
-0.1722634286,
-0.0473692417,
-0.2069643736,
0.26169312,
-0.3193822503,
0.4022268951,
0.0012215957,
0.0021163498,
0.7175593376,
-0.2259640694,
0.118169345,
-1.0267472267,
-0.6287199855,
-0.2777946591,
-0.3403293192,
-0.5434135199,
-0.230650261,
0.1694198847,
-0.0339217968,
-0.5110381842,
0.4438947737,
-0.5706810951,
-0.1040154397,
-0.5685136318,
-0.0465149283,
0.0161720328,
0.4929013848,
0.1198952645,
0.5539652109,
0.8054608107,
-0.6667366028,
0.4608311355,
0.1137315556,
-0.3436700106,
0.750594914,
-0.6309780478,
0.3464479148,
-0.1495203972,
0.3869314194,
-0.759593308,
-0.0315898694,
0.19747217,
-0.5560017228,
0.2536961734,
-0.4003722668,
-0.3753095865,
-0.358272016,
-0.4160142243,
-0.1799318194,
0.7035852671,
-0.7139115334,
0.3389022052,
-0.3435576558,
0.0566077903,
-0.5922321677,
-0.672131598,
-0.2273609936,
-0.3131717741,
-0.3831409812,
-0.0599141084,
-0.3245761991,
-0.0998906642,
0.024287181,
-0.1532628089,
-0.0755461007,
0.4196813107,
0.1656184494,
0.3952629864,
-0.0943265557,
0.3694442511,
-0.0290022772,
0.0774276555,
0.1233515367,
-0.5050122142,
0.177039355,
-0.1891970038,
-0.7322629094,
-0.3465317488,
-0.0302561279,
0.1344700903,
-0.0907305479,
0.4819817543,
0.6254827976,
-0.2337093204,
-0.5138292313,
-0.3877234459,
-0.9376429915,
-0.4350574911,
0.2919451296,
-0.2384590656,
-0.865003109,
0.388979584,
-0.3575562239,
0.195320949,
-0.2854664624,
0.3714814484,
-0.6350906491,
0.7088618279,
0.7978885174,
0.1805474907,
0.5433863997,
-0.8030480146,
-0.4506388009,
-0.7421554923,
-0.1121401191,
-0.1021392345,
-0.6216156483,
-0.2541347444,
-0.5051462054,
0.3071915507,
0.4240745604,
-0.0147876618,
-0.0767528266,
-0.4549459815,
0.7591854334,
0.6822232008,
0.5185161829,
0.336137712,
-0.0666059405,
-0.2815290093,
-0.1953016371,
-0.8281505108,
-0.4199021757,
1.3182380199,
0.2783006132,
0.9034469724,
0.0059834193,
1.1277420521,
0.1073459089,
0.7116842866,
-0.8283375502,
0.4294418097,
0.2507231236,
-0.5631040931,
-0.2836534083,
-0.3718142211,
-0.847212851,
0.4011467695,
-0.1357263774,
-0.4219418764,
-0.0172236841,
0.2282577455,
-0.2754872441,
0.6785202026,
-0.7537992597,
0.7686744928,
-0.5937065482,
-0.6569982767,
-0.2190797627,
-0.64268893,
0.1834022552,
-0.0532712117,
0.1623270065,
0.0947840065,
0.0411790013,
0.7829887271,
-0.2092449665,
1.2614632845,
-0.5646603703,
-0.1407786906,
0.5910915732,
0.0758833811,
0.3604678512,
0.029831266,
-0.1452490389,
-0.4834731221,
-0.2059383839,
-0.6280911565,
-1.0440717936,
0.3252823353,
-0.6460462809,
-0.8009218574,
-0.1849716008,
-0.6826512814,
-0.3475539386,
0.042484615,
0.0953125432,
0.221142143,
0.0899996161,
0.0463644713,
0.891640842,
0.2206703126,
0.318063885,
0.6237418652,
-0.5319883227,
-0.2224369198,
0.8894062638,
0.2112567574,
0.6253005862,
0.2998511493,
0.5811038613,
-0.3670560122,
-0.5982744098,
-0.161368981,
0.1686450541,
-1.0692715645,
-0.2325010598,
-0.2481176406,
-0.0695207715,
-0.389496088,
-0.3869438469,
-0.1042277366,
-0.411814332,
-0.4806459844,
-0.4995032549,
0.3032101393,
1.2177610397,
-0.4169631004,
0.4586482346,
-0.6218331456,
0.0858312994,
1.0193778276,
-0.0398284309,
0.3047549427,
-0.6243954897,
-0.2317938656,
0.5243050456,
-0.7203886509,
-0.8587898612,
0.2153496593,
0.203928113,
0.6285759211,
0.3559937179,
-0.0134694371,
0.6566519141,
-0.3512842655,
0.615395546,
0.2939468622,
-0.603769362,
0.704895854,
-0.2731548548,
0.1882198751,
0.5170768499,
0.5561538339,
-0.4875574112,
-0.3770879209,
-0.6075239182,
-0.3498359621,
0.6303556561,
-0.2728344798,
0.415191859,
0.2155708075,
0.6590230465,
0.2614320517,
0.2041694969,
-0.9167993069,
-0.1213174984,
-0.3096106946,
-0.0659405291,
0.1396319419,
-0.1415662616,
-0.1524494737,
-0.457793504,
0.4913583398,
-0.2601063251,
0.1090524197,
0.0901002884,
-0.2191846222,
-0.0102321794,
0.353210032,
0.2082585096,
0.7928698659,
-0.1140189469,
0.4263924062,
0.6696969271,
-0.3705259264,
0.3743624687,
-0.2706296444,
0.065990746,
-0.4044118226,
0.4031800032,
0.7105915546,
0.4631730616,
-0.3676709831,
0.4409916699,
-0.0103947101,
-0.2668720186,
-0.0378251933,
0.3860605061,
0.4410837293,
0.5304225683,
0.6468548179,
-0.0786075294,
-0.0546397604,
-0.5200909376,
0.3462509811,
0.291769594,
-0.4230598509,
-0.3214359581,
0.7818945646,
-0.073681891,
-0.1671322286,
0.5854389668,
-0.0000250503,
-0.5236637592,
0.8084889054,
0.6163893342,
0.350164026,
-0.2582536042,
0.2059803456,
0.1723427922,
0.220986411,
-0.3219836354,
0.1394121945,
-0.530831933,
-0.8669569492,
-0.3639527857,
-0.3598432839,
-0.8735762239,
-0.2944824994,
-0.8673729897,
0.5454252362,
-0.4832832515,
0.0364279598,
-0.0086511532,
0.2014012784,
-0.4195967615,
0.1037003919,
0.2069836259,
0.629248023,
-0.7669559717,
1.1079928875,
1.0649398565,
-0.4726397991,
-1.0425980091,
-0.1155787706,
0.0237379186,
-0.8998743296,
0.6829798818,
0.3174957633,
-0.013937776,
0.2923452556,
-0.9001277089,
-0.2722478509,
1.4976408482,
0.5043791533,
-0.5327721834,
-0.2389597744,
0.0359835587,
0.3234488666,
-0.2828656435,
0.3497993946,
0.1094293669,
0.2427328825,
0.4424273968,
-0.7492666841,
-0.3251386285,
0.0873901993,
-0.1419527382,
-0.3444591761,
-0.5536231995,
0.7748970389,
-0.8106212616,
-0.0301935971,
-0.1088099107,
0.7359244823,
0.2785881758,
0.578364253,
0.5164639354,
0.5709907413,
0.9344910383,
0.0103398822,
0.7058427334,
0.2253822386,
0.4506112039,
1.1018717289,
-0.2579622865,
0.5819711089,
0.3651408851,
-0.39976421,
0.3115892708,
0.6323416233,
0.0183554068,
0.4500261247,
0.350099057,
-0.330053091,
-0.3754154146,
0.081746608,
-0.3255909681,
0.1472480446,
0.2613143921,
0.0293586049,
-0.1715327799,
0.6369099617,
-0.0139618516,
0.2465755939,
-0.4938621223,
0.7353618145,
0.3826902807,
-0.4842272997,
0.757642746,
-0.5955355763,
0.8907919526,
-0.4481339753,
-0.2008006722,
-0.3291543722,
0.118083939,
-0.1594916731,
-0.6620162725,
-0.0626704618,
-0.1751862764,
-0.1964304596,
-0.5798087716,
0.7374082208,
-0.5893120766,
-0.3158478141,
0.0890898556,
0.6736187935,
0.2075686902,
0.2564093769,
-0.4884923697,
-0.2474017143,
0.1090229899,
-0.1463837922,
0.4223493636,
0.2662052214,
0.1359494328,
0.8898115754,
0.5608531833,
0.2802281082,
0.2913348079,
0.0222965386,
1.0476357937,
-0.5362006426,
-0.0952948704,
-0.7844099998,
0.6710469723,
0.018385997,
0.2004138529,
0.8195222616,
0.3276687264,
0.9783845544,
-0.150556311,
0.7785248756,
0.2300516814,
0.7781199813,
-0.5407394171,
0.5971961617,
-0.5154553056,
0.5115766525,
-0.0335919261,
-0.7563385963,
-0.0589651577,
0.5134665966,
-0.321767956,
0.0773472264,
0.8164530396,
0.6438323259,
-0.0079042632,
0.1186521947,
0.6022590399,
0.0180698335,
0.3227975965,
0.5050517321,
1.3670414686,
-0.0085176872,
0.5206523538,
-0.5442762375,
-0.2686893642,
0.0285907574,
-0.5344023108,
-1.0352190733,
-0.4018366635,
-0.2975413203,
-0.0245254859,
0.248774156,
0.7502677441,
0.5494663119,
-0.3304775059,
-0.395342648,
-0.0559187494,
0.3694195449,
-0.3192509711,
-0.1336317211,
0.1388990134,
-0.4731574953,
-0.6727367043,
0.5136663914,
-0.2979890704,
0.5087000132,
-0.2748332918,
-0.2007613778,
-0.0630714521,
-0.1662380099,
0.2902425826,
0.1366330832,
-0.3586190939,
-0.0598406456,
0.1653832346,
0.0002753953,
-0.0548893735,
0.9510530233,
-0.9177240133,
0.3471951485,
0.0677565709,
0.6816455126,
0.6832485795,
-0.1437033415,
0.221050635,
-0.7437025309,
0.0953248069,
0.4454887807,
0.2372291982,
0.4195780456,
-0.2080842257,
0.6208082438,
0.4429788589,
-0.5741918683,
-0.8607666492,
0.3056747317,
-0.6675742865,
-0.2187899947,
0.9115217328,
-0.3744080663,
-0.0707696304,
0.0817999989,
-0.4034382403,
0.3628564179,
-0.0182346795,
0.819688499,
0.7374741435,
-0.2776131332,
-0.3685248792,
-0.8277906775,
0.2274993211,
0.5724240541,
-0.8449477553,
-0.0627923086,
0.3489052653,
0.5449552536,
-0.3189176619,
0.6670788527,
0.0293681771,
0.4282687306,
-0.1163164303,
-0.0084622139,
-0.1458642185,
-0.2764510214,
-0.3100485802,
-0.1180879325,
0.4712076485,
-0.0733024478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14563v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14563v1 | Model Merging and Safety Alignment: One Bad Model Spoils the Bunch | 2024-06-20T17:59:58 | 2024-06-20T17:59:58 | Hasan Abed Al Kader Hammoud, Umberto Michieli, Fabio Pizzati, Philip Torr, Adel Bibi, Bernard Ghanem, Mete Ozay | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Merging Large Language Models (LLMs) is a cost-effective technique for
combining multiple expert LLMs into a single versatile model, retaining the
expertise of the original ones. However, current approaches often overlook the
importance of safety alignment during merging, leading to highly misaligned
models. This work investigates the effects of model merging on alignment. We
evaluate several popular model merging techniques, demonstrating that existing
methods do not only transfer domain expertise but also propagate misalignment.
We propose a simple two-step approach to address this problem: (i) generating
synthetic safety and domain-specific data, and (ii) incorporating these
generated data into the optimization process of existing data-aware model
merging techniques. This allows us to treat alignment as a skill that can be
maximized in the resulting merged LLM. Our experiments illustrate the
effectiveness of integrating alignment-related data during merging, resulting
in models that excel in both domain expertise and alignment. | [
-0.2944256365,
-0.4192869067,
0.6374003291,
-0.1141440347,
-0.1712766886,
0.2785697877,
0.1399750262,
-0.7859007716,
-0.2375563383,
0.6715629697,
-0.4310202599,
-0.2304538041,
-0.6074368954,
-0.4020476937,
-0.7208327651,
1.0338314772,
-0.1242022067,
0.0217581559,
-0.4551791847,
0.054297708,
-0.5142094493,
-0.6201165915,
-0.5140957832,
-0.3973145187,
0.5827190876,
0.4036701322,
1.0791100264,
1.1601164341,
0.7058913112,
0.2165510654,
-0.0822539553,
0.4946897924,
-0.572001338,
0.1096711829,
-0.2913927138,
-0.1558604836,
-0.8585416079,
0.1258831024,
0.3352253437,
0.8665684462,
-0.3022738695,
-0.2465006709,
0.2119704634,
0.4101365507,
-0.6029769182,
-0.2394132763,
-0.545391798,
-0.2029392719,
-0.0843878537,
-0.2026644647,
-0.351944685,
-0.6783503294,
0.2330058366,
-0.5637497902,
0.0000183372,
0.1144491434,
0.8692327738,
0.5082320571,
-0.6870583296,
0.1042196825,
-0.9563534856,
0.8723863959,
-0.8648861647,
0.276219219,
0.0392927267,
0.2952134311,
-0.3013765216,
-0.0030469825,
-0.6083315611,
0.3359758854,
0.0200274326,
-0.131229192,
-0.1252434552,
-0.051834736,
-0.0461298153,
-0.1720118225,
-0.6645832658,
0.6388249397,
-0.5869860053,
-0.1041551605,
1.1260359287,
0.1884999424,
0.4735406935,
0.2246079147,
-0.6362587214,
-0.3472986519,
-0.9671868682,
-0.2132578045,
0.5338888764,
0.558914721,
-0.0435828865,
0.5905869603,
0.0571607947,
0.8656128645,
-0.0417624228,
-0.4144435227,
0.0456850715,
-0.6189872622,
-0.1930913776,
0.2156738937,
0.6911873221,
0.6529765129,
0.4644191265,
-0.2798132002,
-0.1622884423,
-0.0176250264,
0.5396799445,
-0.1967351139,
-0.1647326499,
0.2847572863,
-0.1979307532,
-0.7310575843,
-0.0939491689,
-0.501748085,
-0.4403200448,
-0.7881573439,
0.4184449017,
-0.452601999,
-0.2602421343,
0.3045121729,
0.1116063744,
0.339323014,
0.4273592532,
-0.7438642383,
0.0359149016,
1.065379858,
0.4497039616,
-0.3544339538,
-0.3326714933,
-0.4427294731,
0.5159396529,
-0.5720762014,
0.6899499297,
-0.27038607,
-0.4096267819,
0.0763054267,
-0.2174019963,
-0.1533523202,
-0.4123112857,
0.426874876,
-0.6166801453,
0.2983891964,
-0.1517477334,
-0.6014943123,
-0.2571172118,
0.0078748111,
-0.4977821708,
0.8409535885,
-0.1401219517,
-0.5676558614,
0.3716272712,
-0.1837664992,
-0.547732234,
-0.2965946496,
-0.1552554816,
-0.4865970314,
-0.042764809,
0.0679022148,
0.5042405128,
-0.1765149385,
0.3634181023,
-0.5818740129,
-0.1233632043,
0.4227657318,
-0.2685343325,
0.7082812786,
0.1481326073,
0.1813361645,
-0.0710907057,
-0.4792098999,
-0.0156496689,
-0.0518437661,
-0.288797766,
-0.4550737739,
-0.196822837,
0.0358450152,
0.4907423258,
0.3096897006,
0.1010073274,
0.4202764034,
-0.1207579896,
-0.0689036027,
0.6716673374,
-0.00184356,
0.9714734554,
-0.6833197474,
0.3743693829,
0.1338822693,
0.2015287429,
0.3172251284,
-0.5306563377,
-0.6994115114,
0.1580629796,
0.3950560987,
0.6693168879,
-0.4887824059,
0.5625583529,
-0.3428626657,
-0.6018465161,
-0.5977482796,
0.1724652797,
0.6111949682,
0.5207687616,
0.3047901094,
-0.3242184222,
-0.3109060228,
-0.9961953163,
-0.3788209856,
-0.1826875657,
0.1797530651,
-0.1426817775,
0.1408733875,
-0.1979489774,
0.9774421453,
-0.3923467696,
-0.0126144094,
-0.0274383165,
0.1020934507,
-0.2439581752,
1.1078310013,
0.6720575094,
-0.7447660565,
-0.3053833246,
0.3403596282,
-0.7655857801,
0.0209034309,
-0.0822264999,
-0.3979500532,
0.4803252816,
0.4686122835,
-0.8332205415,
0.2991798222,
0.5209430456,
0.0934101716,
0.4145572782,
-0.0612331219,
0.3159606755,
-1.2873568535,
-0.0948627666,
0.0049229511,
-0.1164646149,
-1.0582156181,
0.1183429062,
0.2217293978,
-0.0215688962,
-0.5736693144,
0.3608596027,
-0.5304298997,
-0.0238445476,
-0.31909886,
0.2502058446,
-0.0409141295,
0.1330578327,
-0.1002551913,
0.6047576666,
0.5207169652,
-0.6484856606,
0.077053003,
0.3068930805,
-0.1082008928,
0.341796428,
-0.1678930372,
0.3518453538,
-0.1164710298,
-0.2758434415,
-0.9282070398,
-0.5381749272,
0.111620605,
-0.2394465953,
0.8925449252,
-0.3308562338,
-0.2547125816,
-0.0229659192,
-0.0245438572,
0.4138405025,
0.6417825818,
-0.3895447552,
0.6332468987,
0.4614436328,
-0.4773512185,
-0.9068589807,
-0.8630380034,
-0.0436350778,
-0.5857490897,
-0.8545405269,
0.5427178144,
0.1053885445,
-0.3126060665,
0.1116036251,
-0.3374931216,
-0.1955484152,
0.1113448963,
-0.0477738567,
0.7250198722,
-0.1043478996,
0.0489420779,
0.343005836,
-0.0765099749,
-0.22193712,
-0.0686975569,
0.2652342618,
0.3909570277,
-0.468483448,
-0.5447079539,
0.4543192387,
0.9598277211,
-0.2086794972,
0.9741767645,
0.0421474017,
-0.4234585464,
-0.1430520415,
-0.748540163,
-0.122288771,
-0.4225744307,
0.182543993,
-0.046026472,
-0.6813682318,
0.3688497245,
-0.1231889725,
0.3757445514,
0.0947995484,
0.0108484942,
-0.40663746,
1.2282208204,
0.9423670769,
-0.0715609044,
0.2908743024,
0.1321165562,
0.8037129641,
-0.5444083214,
-0.4305931628,
-0.6747418046,
-0.3014674187,
-0.4695365429,
-0.6523470283,
0.0710823312,
0.3097832501,
-0.3707052469,
0.6503092647,
-0.3318110108,
0.5746449232,
0.2314490527,
-0.0196039267,
0.4659422934,
0.2079000026,
0.2584499419,
-0.1145917028,
-0.9038242102,
-0.8303807378,
1.0549920797,
0.2857907116,
0.8936257362,
0.2597460747,
0.9434025288,
-0.2222479284,
0.1619004309,
-0.6184327602,
0.6397343278,
-0.3427730501,
-0.2920749485,
-0.1986832023,
-0.355009377,
-0.5411893725,
0.1670654714,
-0.5090380907,
-0.5117490292,
0.3404842317,
0.3513685465,
-0.5915648341,
0.1349596083,
-0.6836653948,
0.6664118767,
-0.5409655571,
-0.2773914635,
-0.2198289633,
-0.6288028955,
0.773060441,
-0.5924317241,
0.4090440273,
-0.1488178521,
0.0756956264,
0.6334552169,
-0.3077321947,
0.6949718595,
0.2293860912,
-0.4362788498,
-0.0807940885,
0.3089344203,
0.5768227577,
-0.5875856876,
0.0375721864,
0.139555648,
-0.236533761,
-0.2436320335,
-0.7736802697,
0.7605927587,
-0.6569053531,
-0.8660417199,
-0.2459182739,
-0.7996812463,
-0.3805639744,
0.1500640512,
0.0442690626,
0.1600440145,
0.008629025,
-0.1604262888,
0.7304701209,
0.1223482788,
0.3373000324,
0.4803556502,
-0.1501217633,
-0.2095656246,
0.6546707153,
0.1872316301,
0.6098998785,
0.0031310003,
-0.2964636087,
-0.2106498331,
-0.7279894948,
-0.0697780102,
0.3825224936,
-0.8519957066,
-0.3762011826,
-0.5490513444,
-0.3150828183,
-0.5744704604,
-0.5049988031,
-0.5410212278,
-0.6175680757,
-0.3797706962,
-0.1960804909,
0.3116434216,
0.7445177436,
-0.0538301319,
0.4296030402,
-1.126155138,
-0.2723260522,
0.1394990087,
0.0759240389,
-0.0899263397,
-0.4278842211,
-0.1836700886,
0.0105980076,
-0.2702488899,
-0.8476447463,
0.4528590143,
-0.2555571496,
0.6370136738,
0.5283644199,
0.0336142704,
0.867488265,
-0.4397226274,
0.4512957335,
0.4394124448,
-0.7750781178,
0.348167032,
-0.3200140297,
-0.1825375855,
0.5040693283,
0.596457243,
-0.2428952754,
-0.5321418047,
-0.3996703923,
-0.7932190299,
0.6811526418,
0.1533412486,
-0.2074346691,
0.2878592312,
0.1825293303,
0.0807380676,
0.0365777425,
-0.4543219209,
0.008754394,
0.4774032235,
-0.3663474917,
0.0584516041,
-0.0167500172,
-0.6083722711,
-0.0257738996,
0.7486299872,
0.0515001975,
-0.1689167619,
-0.3027231991,
-0.0900630504,
-0.2830167413,
0.1962079406,
0.5749607682,
0.5156958103,
0.052472759,
0.1448784471,
0.0181963556,
0.0389629267,
0.1795560122,
0.0388605893,
-0.0450491048,
-0.3409146965,
0.3679327071,
0.4117648602,
0.3285301924,
-0.3905674815,
0.2774998844,
0.3264597058,
-0.2362405509,
0.2320540994,
0.3500496447,
0.3197025955,
0.296120733,
0.1710480303,
0.65768224,
-0.1447406411,
-0.3846707046,
0.2703637779,
0.5372952223,
0.0835054964,
-0.0123195685,
0.6486883759,
0.3726342916,
-0.2274441272,
0.4933104515,
0.2332778275,
-0.6359648108,
0.6375596523,
0.3748294711,
0.6958015561,
-0.5008609891,
-0.2537835538,
0.1365275234,
0.3870569766,
-0.4184636474,
0.0094716335,
0.3076792061,
-0.957107842,
-0.6060162783,
-0.1502625644,
-0.4142997861,
-0.2008937001,
-0.6349889636,
0.4190164804,
-0.0114061264,
-0.336076051,
-0.0289059579,
-0.461020112,
-0.54157722,
0.1713364124,
0.2078120708,
0.7180373073,
-1.13757658,
0.7462046146,
0.718588233,
-0.3478779495,
-1.1165658236,
0.3063171506,
0.1577959657,
-0.5593750477,
0.5551796556,
0.0122835971,
-0.1603231877,
-0.1299153119,
-0.5282886624,
-1.2107964754,
1.1324657202,
0.5263025165,
-0.8004558086,
-0.2656533122,
0.3112765253,
0.2400565743,
-0.5005223155,
-0.4474205375,
0.8369557858,
0.4250097871,
0.129277423,
-1.3387526274,
0.1662910283,
0.0600802042,
-0.027227439,
0.3876173794,
-0.4284163713,
0.7218651175,
-0.3814620674,
-0.4598517418,
-0.0468936451,
0.2667835951,
0.3800644577,
0.3112923503,
0.3762967587,
0.6978151798,
1.0024325848,
-0.1414172053,
0.8863573074,
-0.2962325215,
0.3787243068,
1.0390729904,
-0.658670187,
0.7702555656,
0.612682879,
0.0163468048,
0.1858272702,
0.548253119,
0.2931250632,
0.6121706367,
-0.382704854,
-0.0971969366,
-0.5187732577,
0.0798659548,
-0.3975707889,
0.4519377351,
-0.0135281393,
-0.2123732865,
-0.1905984133,
-0.2783029079,
0.2154593319,
0.0348451473,
-0.0236124899,
0.8595276475,
0.0621209517,
-0.9167072177,
0.4371373057,
-0.1716597676,
0.5423555374,
-0.2892029285,
0.0263663586,
-0.158036232,
0.0418860391,
-0.3620389998,
-1.0020229816,
0.5686596632,
-0.140340209,
-0.1821046919,
-0.3927436471,
0.8026951551,
-0.891785562,
-0.2223586142,
0.2911278605,
0.6141847968,
0.1107772589,
0.3705548346,
-0.4955029488,
0.1639356762,
-0.005948788,
0.2465961426,
0.5799663067,
0.0960243046,
-0.1967265904,
0.6658935547,
0.7330466509,
-0.0410887413,
-0.0454869755,
-0.1511936039,
0.9046933651,
-0.4572206736,
-0.3456660211,
-0.687900722,
0.8357002139,
-0.1859171689,
0.1013639942,
0.5564813614,
0.3964157999,
0.847976923,
-0.0689529255,
0.9291203618,
0.271746546,
0.2114687562,
-0.78498137,
1.027929306,
-0.6984038949,
0.4005278051,
-0.1303337812,
-1.0580250025,
-0.3768138587,
0.3909023404,
-0.3433021605,
0.0557727441,
0.5043301582,
0.9527183771,
-0.2264377177,
-0.2253622115,
0.3489055336,
-0.1315202564,
0.2242622524,
0.6362178922,
0.8255200386,
-0.4242707193,
0.4100620747,
-0.3186978102,
-0.1273197532,
-0.3422752023,
-1.1254999638,
-0.6629137397,
-0.3619704247,
-0.7205167413,
-0.2424046248,
0.107150875,
0.8656234145,
0.7821248174,
-0.5626603365,
-0.0891107693,
0.0756622329,
0.1394291669,
-0.1434246004,
-0.1809852868,
0.1575581282,
-0.1482544541,
-0.9006112814,
0.692858696,
0.2968373299,
0.5957133174,
0.0416979194,
-0.0855752379,
-0.0526505113,
0.2859417796,
0.2375747412,
0.2510724664,
-0.7683850527,
-0.2018993646,
-0.1333946288,
-0.4239187539,
-0.1347707361,
0.6960743666,
-0.3063404262,
0.3607067466,
0.5734987259,
0.746275723,
0.0033412785,
0.4690176547,
1.180182457,
-0.6436188817,
-0.1264627874,
0.0433787927,
0.4102114439,
0.5021542311,
-0.602550149,
0.5056391954,
-0.1006237864,
-0.6101410985,
-1.0969136953,
0.1963414699,
-1.0481169224,
-0.2541532218,
1.0576334,
0.1306529194,
0.111744374,
-0.0635712966,
0.0894843116,
0.484330833,
-0.1852121204,
0.7456065416,
0.7288600206,
-0.353264451,
-0.0016484495,
-0.2940030098,
0.5452902317,
0.5403313637,
-0.9113259315,
0.2008664608,
0.4442064762,
0.4459284544,
0.2927633226,
0.003178067,
-0.1267338246,
0.4802753925,
-0.241317004,
0.2100327015,
-0.03042241,
-0.5411253572,
-0.6836401224,
-0.0305403937,
0.1289118081,
0.0605967194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14562v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14562v1 | Whiteboard-of-Thought: Thinking Step-by-Step Across Modalities | 2024-06-20T17:59:45 | 2024-06-20T17:59:45 | Sachit Menon, Richard Zemel, Carl Vondrick | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | When presented with questions involving visual thinking, humans naturally
switch reasoning modalities, often forming mental images or drawing visual
aids. Large language models have shown promising results in arithmetic and
symbolic reasoning by expressing intermediate reasoning in text as a chain of
thought, yet struggle to extend this capability to answer text queries that are
easily solved by visual reasoning, even with extensive multimodal pretraining.
We introduce a simple method, whiteboard-of-thought prompting, to unlock the
visual reasoning capabilities of multimodal large language models across
modalities. Whiteboard-of-thought prompting provides multimodal large language
models with a metaphorical `whiteboard' to draw out reasoning steps as images,
then returns these images back to the model for further processing. We find
this can be accomplished with no demonstrations or specialized modules, instead
leveraging models' existing ability to write code with libraries such as
Matplotlib and Turtle. This simple approach shows state-of-the-art results on
four difficult natural language tasks that involve visual and spatial
reasoning. We identify multiple settings where GPT-4o using chain-of-thought
fails dramatically, including more than one where it achieves $0\%$ accuracy,
while whiteboard-of-thought enables up to $92\%$ accuracy in these same
settings. We present a detailed exploration of where the technique succeeds as
well as its sources of error. | [
-0.4010312557,
-1.0947127342,
1.1639533043,
0.2090794593,
-0.4170559645,
0.098089911,
-0.1606775075,
-0.3599009812,
-0.0147849917,
0.1937240511,
-0.7165887952,
-0.3885970414,
-0.6000438333,
-0.0017061025,
-0.0542714968,
0.6165799499,
-0.386734575,
0.0695403814,
-0.1228155345,
-0.0514929108,
-1.0178527832,
-0.2208402753,
-0.403054148,
-0.2117765397,
0.5153912902,
0.3955759704,
0.6561071277,
0.1947672814,
0.4856787324,
0.3105633855,
0.1771963835,
0.5311563611,
-0.3854562342,
-0.0266818311,
-0.3753718138,
-0.462569803,
-0.4615180492,
0.0629220232,
0.1663262248,
0.4112635255,
-0.0887899771,
0.1772907674,
-0.3609577715,
0.6117851138,
-0.9048375487,
0.267714411,
-0.7805500031,
0.225104928,
0.0708182082,
-0.210872218,
-0.6480308175,
-0.144919157,
0.1066281199,
-0.7559821606,
-0.2832913101,
0.012646962,
0.4100847244,
0.2355849147,
-0.6301947236,
-0.3919387758,
-0.5275920033,
0.5920499563,
-0.2648748457,
0.569535017,
0.4382681549,
0.24133946,
-0.1719396561,
-0.8359449506,
-0.9197719097,
-0.3636521697,
-0.096320577,
0.3336819708,
-0.1176140532,
0.0909725651,
0.7811521888,
-0.0978028029,
-0.3951791525,
-0.5106925368,
-0.5687153339,
-0.1136725098,
0.235781163,
-0.0676610321,
0.4781543314,
-0.1483776122,
-0.5060383677,
-0.1763914078,
-0.4687519968,
0.0956144482,
-0.1960766762,
0.0966333374,
0.0962164626,
0.322937578,
-0.1087897569,
0.8483905792,
-0.1722396761,
-0.2971901,
0.1547113657,
-0.3498736322,
-0.169194743,
-0.1101211384,
0.7362560034,
0.5081800222,
0.2815478444,
0.2276447266,
-0.2430858314,
0.2926796377,
0.2730787396,
-0.5891284347,
-0.473364085,
-0.0783916041,
-0.2976873517,
0.0675227046,
-0.0498655774,
-0.7023994327,
-0.1711817235,
-0.3678752184,
0.8359497786,
-0.5940921903,
-0.0995908976,
0.2131795585,
-0.2881116271,
-0.221306771,
0.7750542164,
-1.0610806942,
0.1801176518,
0.3197292089,
0.8160604239,
0.0717240646,
-0.4244474173,
-0.4199562669,
0.2208769917,
-0.5148747563,
0.7570471764,
-0.6829029322,
-0.231175825,
-0.2130436897,
-0.254137069,
-0.0943829417,
-0.1293022186,
0.3238208294,
-0.3660542667,
0.2227291763,
-0.574904263,
-0.0836301818,
-0.3256694674,
0.6119689941,
-0.6794193387,
0.8898830414,
-0.2757260799,
-0.6587051153,
0.4020289481,
-0.7515511513,
-0.470784992,
0.0130599448,
-0.4610822201,
0.1854856908,
0.0616638921,
0.6320249438,
0.302244097,
-0.2551699877,
0.1269268245,
-0.2222522497,
-0.3878580034,
0.2918714881,
-0.4968322515,
0.6910927296,
0.2385189086,
-0.5338510275,
0.1064853892,
-0.5680301785,
0.1998015642,
0.1414999515,
0.1093508229,
-0.3930049539,
-0.0966069922,
-0.3460301161,
0.7082774639,
0.1558894664,
-0.5182025433,
0.2133923024,
0.3034158051,
0.6481006742,
0.8303236961,
-0.1828517616,
0.2340328842,
-0.1220820099,
0.5125209689,
0.1048209071,
0.196900174,
-0.4590791762,
-0.7658004165,
-0.7091431618,
-0.3621223867,
-0.1274556071,
0.5753889084,
-1.3688012362,
-0.2366929054,
-0.0448620506,
-0.4875630736,
-0.5114191175,
0.1392660141,
0.5359405875,
0.6832315922,
0.448668927,
-0.0012395534,
-0.1121413186,
-0.7623731494,
0.0758852959,
-0.1435552835,
0.3923410475,
0.0400358923,
0.8711314797,
-0.0165367145,
0.3349496126,
-0.8565815091,
-0.0634820834,
-0.0898507386,
0.3425760269,
0.0612310469,
0.3554019332,
0.1178083643,
-0.893853724,
-0.3831427395,
0.0423588231,
-0.6699929237,
0.1635610163,
-0.3737593889,
-0.5585401058,
0.0444105417,
0.7682436705,
-0.8283244967,
0.5756877065,
0.3821334839,
-0.3327904642,
0.3751972318,
-0.4997232258,
0.4046396911,
-0.7805554867,
-0.110530138,
-0.0794716254,
-0.0431414954,
-0.5041508079,
0.0303715225,
0.2777979374,
-0.1222039536,
-0.2690941989,
0.4483106136,
-0.5352915525,
0.2551620901,
-0.1108117253,
0.4879922271,
0.0080665546,
0.7708551288,
0.0149519099,
0.6670750976,
0.499868691,
-0.2665248215,
0.52317065,
0.3533891737,
-0.4048586786,
0.5000318885,
-0.2490244359,
0.4330312312,
-0.3382672071,
0.3890480101,
-1.3072344065,
-0.065706104,
0.1630375832,
-0.0002892472,
0.0136466688,
0.2356309146,
-0.4454972148,
-0.7013503313,
-0.3322295547,
0.6173406839,
0.4598766565,
-0.6506330371,
0.6447659135,
0.2095433474,
-0.1218207851,
-0.6160460114,
-0.7264860868,
0.0506706052,
0.2071486562,
-0.5840713978,
0.2168152481,
-0.2403098643,
-0.1104608849,
-0.0665369928,
-0.0685047358,
-0.0077545792,
-0.1823297739,
0.1028301567,
0.5636464953,
0.0192661062,
0.3192098141,
0.0202923771,
-0.0520135276,
0.0863841251,
-0.3001915216,
0.3215655684,
-0.2738055289,
-0.6185792685,
-0.4409037232,
0.2009423077,
0.7706093192,
-0.4136108458,
0.1854181588,
0.4546346068,
-0.4341784418,
-0.4701744914,
-0.5706683993,
-0.0933190361,
-0.43618384,
0.3958380222,
-0.5238726139,
-0.6139674187,
0.3460252285,
0.1176916435,
-0.1369597018,
-0.0635019839,
0.5295362473,
-0.2558553219,
1.2184523344,
0.5469329953,
0.6142824888,
0.509944737,
-0.1737882346,
0.5033777356,
-0.5369504094,
-0.4581095576,
0.2017737776,
-0.5499735475,
-0.4257115722,
-0.6350310445,
0.4748078287,
-0.231880635,
-0.0442282148,
0.1118151248,
-0.4309233725,
0.7698798776,
0.6540153623,
0.4422740042,
0.3320425451,
-0.1062938422,
-0.4015676081,
-0.131299451,
-0.6900398135,
-0.3964204192,
0.6801942587,
-0.0386569314,
0.7566013336,
-0.1085323393,
0.4113855958,
-0.1143228635,
0.5446966887,
-0.7021551728,
0.9416995645,
-0.0921404213,
-0.6306244731,
-0.3099888563,
-0.2560103238,
-0.3432923853,
0.685306251,
-0.3584901989,
-0.7680516243,
-0.0969209373,
0.2792364657,
-0.3632055223,
0.4041608572,
-0.9527099729,
0.9981791973,
-0.3213787973,
-0.450215131,
-0.3346480429,
-0.5403037667,
0.6545277834,
-0.0876481384,
0.2831330895,
0.04037733,
0.1287270486,
0.6216409206,
-0.3713091016,
0.7096455097,
-0.0279354416,
-0.1482060552,
0.4449404776,
0.3212687373,
0.414401114,
-0.2103383094,
0.3416638076,
-0.2739560306,
-0.0919731259,
-0.2742765248,
-1.0778632164,
0.5297255516,
-0.3607250452,
-0.872402966,
-0.2935722172,
-0.8518710136,
-0.4153265059,
0.2921124697,
0.1161426753,
0.6176562905,
0.1438377351,
-0.2451713979,
0.445153445,
0.1903856397,
0.5356259346,
0.0440162607,
-0.3578521907,
-0.6646676064,
0.8976892233,
0.2150501758,
0.4997665882,
0.3384670019,
0.0988093391,
-0.3386800289,
-0.4113700092,
-0.374743551,
0.2371454686,
-1.2354879379,
-0.0438554212,
-0.5199066997,
0.1454036087,
0.080673568,
-0.3602356613,
-0.1234024987,
-0.4996539652,
0.1761398613,
-0.4137126803,
-0.0166876018,
0.8652182221,
0.0562330224,
-0.0753366724,
-0.6049792767,
0.4475419521,
0.8914577961,
0.1447263062,
0.3762797415,
-0.1604851186,
0.1186968684,
0.2692559958,
-0.6211909652,
-0.8820261955,
0.1101987511,
-0.2759978771,
0.397266537,
0.3233229518,
-0.2381979227,
1.1085469723,
-0.7344744802,
0.6994344592,
0.7998178601,
-1.1176472902,
0.8074949384,
-0.2036470175,
0.6380107999,
0.4957002401,
0.5044822693,
-0.5237779617,
-0.3870748281,
-0.4177188277,
-0.4348104,
0.5340335965,
0.1663586497,
0.1333478391,
-0.3481257558,
-0.0755519792,
0.0460617878,
0.1411345452,
-0.976758182,
0.1519109756,
-0.4887219071,
-0.1432290077,
0.2091689259,
-0.073711969,
-0.2972542644,
-0.5973991752,
0.4027264118,
-0.334771812,
0.1865803301,
0.3630782068,
-0.2934067845,
-0.1607499719,
0.2488712966,
1.0056275129,
1.2057577372,
-0.0358720943,
0.5519369841,
0.4625780582,
-0.4566288888,
0.1592942327,
-0.2450067103,
-0.0077193175,
-0.1946166605,
0.5697446465,
0.9375545382,
0.3844953179,
-0.7634539604,
0.6559542418,
-0.0759121031,
-0.3547398746,
0.1411203891,
-0.0382815115,
0.1633795202,
0.2741518021,
0.2624623179,
0.150613144,
-0.1204201654,
-0.8721688986,
0.012765999,
0.3619589508,
-0.5651214123,
-0.4460768998,
0.7545266151,
0.2655316293,
-0.145007059,
0.7706529498,
-0.2180700302,
-0.6229287982,
0.4310194254,
0.8755202889,
0.7237938046,
0.1249597445,
0.4331368506,
0.2707311511,
0.3625637293,
-0.1597876847,
0.7123088837,
-0.2547168732,
-0.7895582318,
-0.6334830523,
-0.0274767559,
-0.387168318,
-0.0227946583,
-0.2946841419,
0.2141286433,
-0.7396008372,
-0.3760412931,
0.0229051989,
-0.5403527617,
-0.4595804214,
0.1433337629,
0.6216298342,
1.0594408512,
-0.7777135968,
0.5211566687,
0.9151585102,
-0.5076568723,
-0.7848754525,
-0.0476870239,
-0.1614975631,
-0.7956854105,
1.1614300013,
0.3087419271,
-0.4788264632,
-0.2054957151,
-0.7336809039,
-0.5112501383,
1.3142133951,
0.4153139293,
-0.3650326431,
-0.0146355256,
-0.2351548225,
0.3910118937,
-0.2942515314,
0.4520462453,
0.2655903399,
0.5349599719,
0.4335154593,
-0.9639826417,
0.5344068408,
-0.253152132,
-0.0551347099,
0.3015000224,
-0.7806968689,
0.9903745055,
-0.7192704082,
-0.1481757909,
-0.4027588069,
0.5230389833,
0.3292259276,
0.2198286355,
0.6430367827,
0.5427325964,
0.9904237986,
-0.0636191517,
0.9020303488,
0.0326420255,
-0.021953363,
0.8430316448,
-0.2216562927,
0.8928748965,
0.671017468,
0.0648494363,
0.7440853119,
-0.0130506922,
0.2422203273,
0.6871828437,
-0.1037972346,
-0.2711859643,
-0.5334291458,
0.0703274012,
-0.0729886442,
0.3938339055,
0.3476966023,
0.0026616266,
-0.2622531652,
0.1589193791,
0.0240531303,
0.1281358004,
-0.4137206674,
0.3821282089,
0.2536817789,
-1.0025331974,
0.5424018502,
-0.4151515961,
0.4012933373,
-0.5410315394,
-0.4712696075,
0.1292454004,
0.0813915953,
0.0431512967,
-0.9156353474,
-0.2667627037,
-0.2601294518,
0.0154004283,
-0.6675854921,
0.6370167732,
-0.5379323959,
-0.5251200795,
0.1533198804,
0.5358421803,
-0.3194630146,
0.1815989912,
-0.6289966702,
0.0059624449,
0.0836016685,
-0.0266515967,
-0.0398297049,
0.7940185666,
-0.4182892442,
0.8477523923,
0.7494652271,
-0.0678143203,
-0.0052269129,
-0.0093968306,
0.8891354799,
-0.9008985758,
-0.6876724362,
-1.0519405603,
0.5627685189,
-0.2896413803,
-0.5085926056,
0.4457347393,
0.0193301309,
0.8375656009,
-0.2988193333,
0.504075706,
0.08974199,
-0.2428774089,
-0.8887505531,
0.6059532166,
-0.4931876659,
-0.2694198191,
-0.5792788267,
-0.602871716,
-0.2311450541,
0.8509908915,
-0.5850278735,
-0.0765478909,
1.5180982351,
0.6845100522,
-0.1040132046,
0.4336230755,
0.5131878257,
0.2082687616,
0.3390461206,
0.7859537005,
1.1151659489,
-0.1369247139,
0.5430811644,
-0.1977026165,
-0.3873522878,
0.2398215383,
-1.0609031916,
-1.1146800518,
-0.7655550838,
-0.0917416513,
-0.0196551848,
-0.0394542664,
0.9944970012,
0.680787921,
-0.4546012282,
-0.0620151758,
-0.0822328553,
0.1976228654,
-0.1344351321,
-0.1176088229,
0.2762009501,
-0.389133364,
-0.4135114253,
0.1787898093,
0.5246351361,
0.1234978884,
-0.07469403,
0.142494455,
-0.5617908835,
0.0308218841,
0.9225478768,
-0.1129329056,
-0.7821816802,
-0.4188229442,
-0.0668638349,
-0.2089510262,
-0.0903672129,
0.9685148001,
-0.6441509724,
0.8481602669,
0.632748425,
0.3467800319,
0.6338316202,
-0.2022242993,
0.5995292664,
-0.2495059222,
0.4029906392,
0.1519528776,
0.5997121334,
0.2476357669,
-0.1413960308,
0.3021848202,
0.2977540791,
-0.1545506418,
-0.6158502102,
0.3708954751,
-0.9521641135,
-0.3610396087,
0.803370297,
-0.039078895,
-0.4463343918,
0.2007180452,
-0.7109484673,
-0.1500831693,
-0.2132705897,
0.7778651714,
1.1851463318,
-0.2677767873,
-0.2725531757,
-0.7230408788,
0.4760004282,
0.4472928345,
-0.9434475899,
-0.0270465836,
0.5809301138,
-0.0541020632,
0.4731004536,
1.0383658409,
-0.0194558054,
0.6174513698,
0.094128862,
-0.0776040405,
-0.1442592293,
-0.5100678205,
0.2386220098,
0.1167440638,
-0.2409508824,
-0.0681059584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14561v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14561v1 | How to Compute the Probability of a Word | 2024-06-20T17:59:42 | 2024-06-20T17:59:42 | Tiago Pimentel, Clara Meister | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) estimate the probability distribution over sequences of
natural language; these distributions are crucial for computing perplexity and
surprisal in linguistics research. While we are usually concerned with
measuring these values for words, most LMs operate over subwords. Despite
seemingly straightforward, accurately computing probabilities over one unit
given probabilities over the other requires care. Indeed, we show here that
many recent linguistic studies have been incorrectly computing these values.
This paper derives the correct methods for computing word probabilities,
highlighting issues when relying on language models that use beginning-of-word
(bow)-marking tokenisers, e.g., the GPT family. Empirically, we show that
correcting the widespread bug in probability computations affects measured
outcomes in sentence comprehension and lexical optimisation analyses. | [
-0.0593256913,
-0.6803171039,
0.7700092793,
0.0053703347,
-0.3775993586,
-0.1519058943,
0.1546871364,
-0.4113385379,
0.0104264226,
0.1586455107,
-0.3415819407,
-0.3040645719,
-0.7699462771,
-0.2098847777,
-0.3501437306,
0.8496171236,
0.1056139395,
0.0932323188,
-0.0916357189,
-0.2038978934,
-0.2163150012,
-0.8561381102,
-0.4538605809,
-0.3946840167,
0.6074169278,
0.0263398234,
1.0551364422,
0.2715300918,
0.6125910878,
0.2433059663,
-0.1070990339,
-0.2767177224,
-0.4063036144,
-0.0732761249,
-0.2077860236,
-0.7704752684,
-0.2595140636,
0.2467560619,
0.2989502251,
1.0531637669,
-0.2266095281,
-0.3199014366,
-0.1136980653,
0.4740172327,
-0.5815284252,
0.197755456,
-0.778240025,
0.2951195538,
-0.4537225366,
-0.4362053573,
-0.4576867819,
-0.200748384,
0.0403093621,
-0.2842509449,
0.2752844691,
0.0699929819,
0.5201281905,
-0.0597955398,
-0.0650974363,
-0.5441231132,
-0.7075667381,
0.8349604011,
-0.8685150743,
0.182324931,
0.5320407152,
-0.0172875952,
-0.5880904198,
-0.5020925999,
-0.6167216301,
-0.4431647658,
0.0994513333,
-0.1653134227,
-0.3651299477,
0.2884373665,
0.3131844401,
0.4603398144,
-0.4437136054,
0.0571203604,
-0.1030278131,
-0.1148919687,
0.6836463213,
0.2026416212,
0.4612567127,
-0.1584336013,
-0.0716836751,
0.0613542162,
-0.8505963087,
0.0209423155,
0.6877200603,
0.3194996119,
0.2111952752,
0.962428689,
-0.0194943529,
0.738868773,
-0.2709790468,
-0.3232708871,
0.0613489114,
-0.3076698184,
-0.1567028612,
0.0350569524,
0.4765323699,
0.3040048778,
0.5816093683,
-0.3023322821,
-0.440397501,
0.0903009623,
0.1553905457,
-0.1768751591,
-0.4162271917,
0.1757394522,
0.1455870122,
-0.144108355,
-0.004907297,
-0.0826600492,
-0.4529227018,
-0.0647871047,
0.6160232425,
-0.7045583129,
-0.0821880773,
0.4365780056,
-0.2585119307,
0.0256136991,
0.0446352288,
-0.7008766532,
0.1550822556,
0.7570425868,
0.44726789,
0.2614430189,
-0.4197871089,
-0.5314795375,
-0.004639287,
-0.4964369833,
0.7139610648,
-0.4415887594,
-0.4831261635,
0.0516313799,
-0.169186756,
-0.090468362,
-0.1991345882,
0.5733475685,
-0.3688853085,
0.0472477116,
-0.1696764976,
-1.2147054672,
-0.0605366118,
-0.1149117351,
-0.4445463717,
0.4518713355,
0.0095226988,
-1.0752956867,
0.5033504367,
-0.3655349612,
-0.6135003567,
0.2700837553,
0.1406190693,
-0.0995249525,
0.7145046592,
-0.04462035,
0.2561459243,
0.1935138553,
0.0496907569,
-0.1395627707,
-0.4853905141,
0.5907921195,
-0.3701368868,
0.5953647494,
0.1590298414,
-0.1432004571,
0.1100657508,
-0.2495410442,
-0.1461495608,
-0.0633074343,
-0.1844262034,
-0.5170061588,
0.3635110557,
0.0221761465,
-0.0223451201,
-0.0039603566,
-0.5959451199,
0.3472473025,
-0.6061941981,
0.4162075222,
0.5316221118,
-0.0158495326,
0.3833574355,
-0.3584099412,
0.6254287958,
0.1190191507,
0.0373592265,
-0.0049781613,
-0.8118964434,
-0.3397442997,
-0.2341672331,
0.5537747145,
0.636089623,
-0.7203046679,
0.3796365261,
-0.1064091697,
-0.6655573249,
-0.3643089533,
-0.2023892999,
0.2802194953,
0.3871705532,
0.174131915,
-0.2256775349,
-0.4559512138,
-0.5742242932,
-0.8161830902,
-0.4701295197,
0.1181344613,
-0.1204489097,
0.3256454766,
0.0287718531,
1.1898400784,
-0.5975904465,
-0.17357485,
-0.5243297219,
0.5459131002,
0.1307190359,
0.3014742136,
0.2945009172,
-0.4909589589,
0.0058995797,
-0.2351755947,
-0.4379985929,
-0.2416970432,
-0.0159273315,
0.2085839212,
0.6449808478,
0.1978312284,
-0.7346081734,
0.8269750476,
0.3837507367,
-0.3470199704,
0.8711141944,
-0.3626012206,
0.0247285105,
-0.7317456007,
-0.1932992935,
0.1431028396,
-0.2092845589,
-0.6090359092,
0.358743757,
-0.1697202474,
0.4064772725,
-0.5796077251,
0.5438016057,
-0.36270684,
-0.038280692,
-0.421068579,
0.079310298,
-0.4428521991,
-0.0495175794,
-0.1577873528,
0.7464572191,
0.3369331956,
-0.4992703497,
0.3138217926,
-0.1589842588,
-0.5414512157,
0.3415194452,
-0.4260086715,
-0.0952371135,
-0.2441060841,
0.0853159204,
-1.1921044588,
-0.0993968397,
0.1743115038,
-0.4283141196,
0.2621849477,
-0.0410009623,
-0.5881914496,
-0.4334625602,
-0.3285450935,
0.4175594151,
0.5660035014,
-0.0338357352,
0.2689479291,
0.8505506516,
-0.1001397893,
-0.5989263058,
-0.8792882562,
0.1954972744,
-0.1205502748,
-0.4421984851,
0.1058967561,
0.1479571611,
-0.4619872868,
0.0525103956,
0.0438832045,
0.2079885453,
0.1447326243,
0.0949069411,
-0.0247468203,
0.04720008,
0.3273198307,
-0.4175887406,
-0.1161634102,
-0.1213583276,
-0.2452694327,
0.8329921961,
0.0869385302,
-0.747580409,
-0.0229389835,
0.1571647674,
0.0789554194,
-0.0381775238,
0.6076211929,
0.2941948175,
-0.6960792542,
-0.0323158875,
-0.6391332746,
-0.2300235033,
-0.3487030566,
0.4734798074,
-0.706117034,
-0.7164054513,
0.4889425635,
0.5723311901,
-0.017756464,
0.3758603632,
0.2082039118,
-0.1738321483,
0.912260592,
0.6685587168,
-0.0700561181,
0.186206758,
0.1404698938,
0.6304083467,
-0.6589001417,
0.1040560305,
-0.4625619352,
-0.1974570155,
-0.7049278617,
-0.4821849465,
0.4172297716,
0.3440630436,
0.216192767,
0.5777214766,
-0.1426565051,
0.3857615888,
0.6885972023,
-0.1777234972,
0.4273322225,
0.2367026955,
-0.4796739221,
-0.3641383052,
-0.711695075,
-0.5301620364,
0.9621393681,
0.2555673122,
1.0629965067,
0.0048924237,
0.8899609447,
0.1152621657,
0.4279148281,
-0.90287292,
0.7032495141,
-0.400083065,
-0.7000891566,
-0.5763521194,
-0.3162138462,
-1.2027338743,
-0.0273008235,
0.0690371841,
-1.0674338341,
0.002954467,
0.026584927,
-0.245992437,
0.5285206437,
-0.5471267104,
0.7449753284,
0.0340749361,
-0.0443633087,
-0.2118514031,
-0.2871918082,
0.3667909503,
0.0458831675,
0.459223479,
-0.1793864965,
0.005327567,
0.6334553957,
-0.6270378828,
0.6412867308,
-0.0070450134,
-0.3159985542,
0.4684183598,
0.2738977373,
0.3618698418,
-0.1375348568,
-0.1150430217,
-0.1045945212,
0.1194108427,
-0.4136505127,
-0.3359188139,
0.4465313852,
-0.3437602222,
-0.819005549,
-0.7629743814,
-0.6726744175,
-0.1660149843,
-0.2883616984,
0.5308994055,
0.4410636127,
-0.1871449351,
-0.2322711051,
0.4131423831,
-0.3582662344,
0.6198208928,
0.4118886888,
-0.4632920325,
-0.1900803149,
0.8530774117,
0.6496534348,
0.2828626037,
0.3347438574,
0.191224128,
-0.6013545394,
-0.389557153,
-0.2311161011,
0.1514715105,
-0.9461156726,
0.2013112456,
-0.5945795774,
-0.3309464455,
-0.3884199858,
-0.1242692396,
0.0543987192,
-0.5270261168,
-0.0198779032,
-0.2075584382,
0.3471114039,
0.6869084239,
-0.1413275152,
0.2871364951,
-0.698657155,
-0.0098836571,
0.2092591673,
0.1255104989,
-0.2192611694,
-0.5610638857,
0.1107756943,
0.0819165856,
-0.1269703805,
-1.2454365492,
0.3205130398,
0.1749565452,
0.7006481886,
-0.0409416631,
-0.1635599583,
0.5514109135,
-0.6381381154,
0.9375813007,
0.1839102656,
-0.9777425528,
0.3660193086,
-0.1989304572,
0.4889090061,
0.2073948979,
0.3027896583,
-0.8092122674,
-0.7070103884,
-0.852152288,
-0.8251344562,
0.3612040579,
0.141496405,
0.2161959857,
-0.4497760832,
0.1599008143,
0.0597741716,
0.15580751,
-0.5262625217,
-0.2523161173,
0.3192658722,
-0.3069730103,
-0.5126619935,
-0.4609378278,
0.0908320546,
-0.2641675174,
0.7594255209,
-0.0661396384,
0.0846435055,
0.1979267001,
-0.3986806273,
-0.2564891875,
0.4125686586,
0.7448952198,
0.9303927422,
-0.0175368823,
0.2500610352,
0.0145764165,
-0.5663950443,
0.1541178823,
0.1936317384,
-0.3086645603,
0.4306460619,
0.4923544824,
0.6853649616,
0.4879911542,
-0.5969411135,
0.4701503515,
0.144657433,
0.0730799362,
-0.1553500891,
-0.0117211053,
0.5343877077,
-0.3073301613,
0.5375015736,
-0.2419876456,
0.2505385876,
-0.836404562,
0.3142182827,
0.7708694339,
-0.2704462707,
-0.2355632633,
0.5108701587,
-0.1891516596,
-0.42056036,
0.4892999232,
-0.4118100405,
-0.6595813632,
0.6315101981,
0.4762718081,
0.8314920068,
-0.2187701166,
0.3927138448,
0.046101246,
0.5398442149,
-0.2879280746,
0.7087654471,
0.5963562727,
-0.9088600278,
-0.446998477,
-1.1110244989,
-0.3029944599,
-0.0193912927,
-0.0900783762,
0.158597067,
-0.0692717135,
-0.4815180302,
0.1931575388,
-0.0035206066,
-0.4684379697,
0.2118744701,
0.4511525333,
0.9800026417,
-0.6886126399,
0.7593744993,
0.7798354626,
-0.4800179899,
-1.015982151,
-0.1093283817,
-0.1759028882,
-0.6236786246,
0.4925404191,
0.0662758499,
-0.1061541811,
0.1337775588,
-0.3952065706,
-0.5790706277,
0.420994848,
0.2614682913,
-0.7559996843,
0.2476429045,
0.6875804663,
0.6550389528,
-0.1917123646,
0.2511146963,
0.5454216599,
0.4046733677,
0.0647838861,
-1.0314934254,
-0.2405664921,
0.3449189663,
0.1899516732,
0.2943809628,
0.2572190166,
0.9009239078,
-0.3907921612,
-0.2442680895,
0.0870350972,
0.5845180154,
0.4443177283,
0.1412027925,
0.4420517981,
0.9015433788,
0.7478709221,
-0.3209465146,
1.3497539759,
-0.3675309122,
0.4523480833,
0.9317169785,
-0.325286895,
0.8972916603,
0.7003923655,
-0.7346934676,
0.0988544077,
0.6766816378,
0.3579968512,
0.2352448404,
0.703558147,
-0.4442738295,
-0.0807192922,
0.2470727563,
-0.1491942108,
0.2810462117,
0.3022097051,
-0.2656504214,
-0.2351866961,
-0.0012803504,
-0.0232418962,
0.023818586,
-0.4378562272,
0.5680171847,
0.4884625971,
-0.6529875398,
0.3763351142,
0.2643690407,
0.7536264658,
-0.4355136156,
0.3155112565,
-0.4620903432,
0.2511464059,
-0.1513179541,
-1.1847180128,
0.4293853641,
-0.1632396728,
0.0158098787,
0.3248906434,
0.7926898003,
-0.4261567593,
-0.7970906496,
-0.0925716832,
0.6571364403,
0.5065393448,
-0.1906119138,
-0.3292463124,
-0.1951333135,
-0.3868916631,
-0.356924504,
0.3115232587,
0.3226442039,
-0.2331387252,
0.7871738076,
0.4929391742,
0.2783110142,
0.5691249371,
0.1684435755,
0.205694139,
-0.6076440215,
-0.5580990911,
-1.2119597197,
0.5141326189,
0.1268173307,
-0.438652724,
0.5886406302,
0.4011645615,
0.7196655273,
-0.3789989948,
0.6359757781,
-0.0607942268,
0.2443448752,
-0.4480738342,
0.7228910923,
-0.3564516902,
0.3308437169,
-0.2610716224,
-0.9407929778,
-0.5070977211,
0.5343800783,
-0.6485183835,
-0.1877760291,
0.7231392264,
0.7119163275,
0.1696701646,
0.1589334607,
0.4564206004,
0.1387581825,
0.1490554214,
0.5796355605,
0.7416972518,
-0.470928371,
0.0812131017,
-0.315821588,
-0.2231575698,
-0.2736051381,
-1.0451698303,
-0.3520939946,
-0.4783043563,
-0.4157389998,
-0.1323934942,
0.407862097,
0.770054996,
0.309057951,
-0.8845748305,
-0.3874484003,
-0.3067258298,
0.3235692978,
-0.2540921569,
-0.2136853337,
0.0957362652,
-0.7362368107,
-0.5423028469,
0.1216690466,
0.300224334,
0.0061344076,
-0.2679638267,
0.0293868352,
-0.3774322867,
0.4419700503,
0.4362600446,
0.219036296,
-0.8899052143,
-0.5443171263,
-0.3229107857,
-0.4459674656,
-0.0374783762,
0.4988096952,
-0.7798188329,
0.1521307528,
0.6529438496,
0.3933820724,
0.0001780134,
-0.1086956188,
0.7429607511,
-0.6778858304,
0.1493865252,
0.2871073186,
0.6321691871,
0.5756414533,
-0.2191626877,
0.6153120995,
0.5777224898,
-0.4343046546,
-0.9793360233,
0.6322701573,
-0.4794080555,
-0.3553715348,
1.0492026806,
-0.2307293415,
-0.3934735358,
-0.0714620575,
-0.0632304326,
0.1714837402,
0.2026133686,
0.4766600132,
1.1017795801,
-0.0012221762,
-0.078884013,
-0.4499994218,
0.6670404673,
0.5869171023,
-0.2253202349,
-0.2252557427,
0.1204441637,
0.4556770623,
0.1291862875,
0.5821462274,
-0.0611897483,
0.057210017,
0.1048750654,
0.2056153417,
0.5177032948,
-0.0556545593,
-0.3874115348,
0.2308317572,
0.2365533859,
0.017908318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14553v1 | xCOMET-lite: Bridging the Gap Between Efficiency and Quality in Learned MT Evaluation Metrics | 2024-06-20T17:58:34 | 2024-06-20T17:58:34 | Daniil Larionov, Mikhail Seleznyov, Vasiliy Viskov, Alexander Panchenko, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art trainable machine translation evaluation metrics like xCOMET
achieve high correlation with human judgment but rely on large encoders (up to
10.7B parameters), making them computationally expensive and inaccessible to
researchers with limited resources. To address this issue, we investigate
whether the knowledge stored in these large encoders can be compressed while
maintaining quality. We employ distillation, quantization, and pruning
techniques to create efficient xCOMET alternatives and introduce a novel data
collection pipeline for efficient black-box distillation. Our experiments show
that, using quantization, xCOMET can be compressed up to three times with no
quality degradation. Additionally, through distillation, we create an
xCOMET-lite metric, which has only 2.6% of xCOMET-XXL parameters, but retains
92.1% of its quality. Besides, it surpasses strong small-scale metrics like
COMET-22 and BLEURT-20 on the WMT22 metrics challenge dataset by 6.4%, despite
using 50% fewer parameters. All code, dataset, and models are available online. | [
-0.3287221789,
-0.0986426175,
0.4408054352,
-0.2022265643,
-0.6189002395,
0.3667992055,
-0.6001640558,
-0.0948599651,
0.1870091408,
0.1953983903,
-0.5316206813,
-0.3413265347,
-0.8323444724,
0.1858699769,
-0.3451929688,
0.968044579,
-0.0584457293,
-0.056406565,
0.104222253,
-0.4149492383,
-0.4886408448,
-0.409417063,
-0.6445915103,
-0.0625992864,
0.4887931943,
0.227898851,
0.8800577521,
0.8191232085,
0.7184393406,
0.3511738777,
0.0528326891,
0.4188069105,
-0.7875956893,
0.0191587694,
-0.0903236195,
-0.8498433232,
-0.2832668722,
0.0086905677,
0.5199501514,
0.6775943637,
-0.3070788383,
0.3339677751,
0.1863182187,
0.7276110649,
-0.6084219813,
-0.007117115,
-0.5541990995,
0.2252003551,
-0.0878280774,
-0.4677669108,
-0.3376195729,
-0.4828714728,
0.1187806427,
-0.705637157,
0.1146501899,
0.2596042156,
0.9243295789,
0.5438442826,
-0.3429697752,
-0.1017311662,
-0.5738905668,
1.1073940992,
-0.5424199104,
0.4358932674,
0.3264096975,
0.582021296,
0.1501288861,
-1.0029038191,
-0.3039103746,
-0.0184030831,
-0.0073138354,
0.3678988814,
-0.3825193644,
-0.1355551034,
0.040099211,
0.8311697841,
-0.6028229594,
0.0160504933,
-0.3602145314,
-0.0952242911,
0.4375451207,
0.162469089,
-0.153073296,
-0.1530104727,
-0.3436894417,
-0.6292657256,
-0.5240877271,
-0.042759046,
0.3209186196,
-0.1392379105,
0.1839441955,
0.4567204416,
-0.0316182934,
0.3523332775,
-0.1536086053,
-0.1552388966,
0.3985108733,
-0.5029116273,
-0.3522792757,
-0.0795911252,
0.991089344,
0.4678586721,
-0.1609362364,
-0.3528101146,
-0.4313180149,
0.1258167773,
0.3530018032,
-1.0614589453,
-0.3046594858,
0.3746224046,
-0.5559303761,
-0.2451290786,
0.2475633621,
-0.5718806982,
-0.1411187947,
-0.326218307,
0.714951992,
-0.4865905643,
0.0157322548,
0.4066458642,
-0.5138813853,
-0.388785094,
0.1500262469,
-0.3934853077,
0.2787267566,
0.5088367462,
0.998750627,
-0.0968966857,
0.0986051261,
-0.586854279,
-0.3003182411,
-0.3104411066,
0.2119459212,
-0.2991038263,
-0.4607596695,
-0.2612753808,
-0.0299311783,
0.3234052956,
-0.7558596134,
0.8664321899,
-0.4496405125,
0.1560085714,
-0.2033474594,
-0.4971583784,
0.011866211,
0.3610035479,
-0.6647519469,
0.9360899329,
0.4489600062,
-0.6827921867,
0.691069901,
-0.3970129192,
-0.0788628384,
0.1199488565,
-0.1167702749,
-0.6867907643,
0.6046319604,
0.1637098491,
0.154602766,
-0.5855538249,
0.2570146918,
-0.0078692567,
-0.5121509433,
0.4444811344,
-0.7350667715,
0.6570347548,
0.4663571715,
-0.3367209136,
-0.2571291924,
-0.9471197724,
0.2374873608,
0.0218984038,
-0.3778315783,
-0.6219076514,
-0.1394124478,
-0.3628938794,
0.3048227727,
0.1455768943,
-0.7780596614,
0.3068924248,
-0.2238836139,
0.5701514482,
0.5557774305,
-0.1737041473,
0.1727366,
-0.2449371368,
0.4420130849,
0.1473762095,
0.3252863288,
-0.1463035196,
-0.1212005466,
-0.8784731627,
-0.2197807133,
0.6751767397,
0.2156625539,
-1.1129995584,
0.6719634533,
-0.9569103122,
-0.5110569596,
-1.0145161152,
0.0123023633,
0.4159146845,
0.0948544815,
0.4061251283,
-0.4200136364,
-0.389008075,
-0.7466900349,
-0.0376535356,
0.1481585801,
-0.3176401556,
0.0740308091,
0.4934431314,
0.0863083228,
0.8103865385,
-0.7273871303,
-0.3528598845,
0.0033600812,
0.4145907164,
0.2407111675,
0.5315287709,
0.305978179,
-0.7940184474,
-0.4608856738,
0.2572361529,
-0.6946892738,
-0.0380715989,
-0.1203804761,
-0.0127650965,
-0.3727746308,
0.1587306857,
-0.2457999438,
0.3151925504,
0.8450753093,
-0.3172108531,
0.5053355694,
-0.4327132106,
0.6049054861,
-1.066031456,
-0.0107011553,
-0.0702912807,
-0.4352105558,
-0.3627710342,
-0.0531917475,
0.3068817556,
-0.011789727,
-0.4880265892,
0.1981256902,
-0.549855113,
0.2415569127,
-0.3272781074,
0.3186298609,
0.4132579565,
0.5001178384,
0.0114590367,
0.8738410473,
0.2278721333,
-0.2883764505,
0.1560225487,
0.338060528,
-0.7003405094,
0.5437951088,
-0.4858327508,
-0.0452398732,
-0.0206866041,
0.087130703,
-0.6281830668,
0.4037596583,
-0.1411103159,
-0.4964058995,
0.3172006905,
-0.2969406843,
-0.735082984,
-0.3272207379,
-0.478102088,
0.3999435306,
0.8234820366,
-0.6346885562,
-0.0733086169,
0.0140416725,
0.0712909922,
-0.5679124594,
-0.8575285673,
0.3644505739,
-0.3339337409,
-0.4137469232,
0.3940901458,
-0.1779544055,
0.0423002914,
0.0621090308,
-0.2735452354,
-0.0394872166,
-0.0713583902,
0.0956519321,
0.0966532975,
-0.2283637077,
0.084486261,
0.2201997191,
-0.2371893227,
-0.0322730318,
-0.8311750889,
0.2903398871,
0.1981631517,
-0.1465768665,
-0.5028575659,
0.0856071785,
0.4617962837,
-0.1087708995,
0.7245080471,
0.5316057801,
-0.0673515797,
-0.1820454448,
-0.437237978,
-0.2332502753,
-0.5031870008,
0.3472973406,
-0.3604189157,
-0.9111559987,
0.1797601879,
-0.1662693024,
0.1376218945,
0.2070001364,
0.2438644767,
-0.0118561201,
1.0895392895,
0.5081291199,
0.1336223036,
0.2937021852,
-0.7702088356,
0.0511176512,
-0.8544124365,
0.1653896123,
-0.4971010685,
-0.5856707096,
-0.612377286,
-0.490618974,
0.5598295331,
-0.1550755352,
0.1031667516,
0.5281419158,
-0.5608784556,
0.5108572841,
0.5589702725,
0.2250882536,
0.5462777019,
0.140612185,
0.107507728,
-0.2860773206,
-0.8304810524,
-0.4297932684,
1.0842126608,
0.17353715,
0.4935267866,
0.0169102065,
0.6539409757,
0.2848086357,
0.180447489,
-0.7058698535,
0.25193578,
-0.3918678164,
-0.5925222635,
-0.0794219673,
-1.0876107216,
-1.0624732971,
0.431396842,
-0.0640071481,
-0.4888682961,
0.4367548823,
0.0447403826,
-0.2728510499,
0.5821992755,
-0.6322577,
0.7555831671,
-0.1776871979,
-0.4950731695,
-0.2716920674,
-0.7281374931,
0.2547881603,
-0.4269450307,
0.1106919423,
-0.0337169133,
-0.1211423278,
0.8511548638,
-0.9508057833,
0.4377028644,
-0.2163868248,
-0.0723153725,
0.3502784073,
0.21371831,
0.3433367014,
-0.0178202614,
-0.2526467144,
0.2894045413,
0.2270056009,
-0.4005655646,
-1.0055212975,
0.4162678719,
-0.7951037288,
-0.1432389915,
-0.1477047652,
-0.4428072274,
-0.0643387735,
0.1233254597,
0.5229285955,
0.7119701505,
-0.0328096151,
0.5441333055,
0.53099823,
-0.1296130717,
0.1594049186,
0.3370970488,
0.2982883155,
-0.7421073914,
1.2477010489,
0.5244135857,
0.4571449757,
0.5974915028,
0.3321351111,
-0.3995761275,
-0.7832504511,
-0.4395878017,
-0.0081851427,
-0.6361396909,
-0.7206346989,
-0.2950659096,
0.0643632561,
0.2755109668,
-0.1602638662,
-0.6587753892,
-0.7800244093,
0.1986186355,
-0.0162826851,
0.1264122427,
0.3733237684,
-0.0565998927,
0.7692862153,
-1.1288212538,
0.076058194,
-0.1239392012,
0.4052539468,
-0.1106126457,
-0.6561632156,
-0.8305115104,
0.2976773679,
-0.3074506223,
-0.3022457361,
0.6043857932,
0.0423997641,
0.2149262428,
0.4930276573,
0.4463563263,
0.8083747625,
-0.2740604877,
0.8531330228,
0.4756599367,
-0.756329298,
0.3483197987,
0.1546515375,
0.2809361517,
0.9654510021,
0.4235402644,
-0.3167948127,
-0.4060305953,
-0.6748020649,
-0.7363649011,
0.5042356849,
0.7052875757,
-0.2037586719,
0.0374686606,
0.2892844379,
0.5839118958,
0.5685641766,
-0.4863490462,
-0.3102472126,
-0.235535875,
-0.2462912798,
-0.1304054409,
-0.0097274827,
-0.1612298191,
-0.0401568748,
0.6405363083,
0.0025936053,
-0.030475799,
0.2171726078,
-0.2930009961,
0.2417245954,
0.3622490168,
0.0302238353,
0.3908436,
-0.3673412502,
0.3493583202,
0.1228335798,
-0.6719459891,
0.4999290705,
-0.1133938879,
0.0180660915,
-0.0677919909,
0.0157503858,
0.7136310339,
-0.0127915489,
-0.6203038096,
0.6436710358,
-0.5336672068,
-0.3414119482,
-0.0068126209,
-0.0706067607,
-0.4615704417,
-0.0401964784,
0.2412860245,
0.0858533978,
0.2763465941,
-0.3166953921,
0.1080469191,
0.1202570051,
-0.5791351795,
-0.4408903718,
0.6709381938,
0.2613732219,
0.2036651373,
0.7925649285,
-0.4933713973,
-0.2447341233,
0.1915042102,
0.0939818099,
0.7649750113,
0.1501965821,
-0.1248199269,
0.3948009312,
0.4322345257,
-0.1436187327,
0.0779097378,
-0.3458568752,
-0.4155788422,
-0.7268995047,
-0.5992877483,
-0.3567633331,
-0.2801662683,
-0.7084943652,
0.2166233659,
-0.0259275101,
-0.4799661934,
-0.3209541142,
0.4813829064,
-0.6904240251,
0.4148821533,
-0.1718159318,
1.0281147957,
-0.6305109859,
0.8760115504,
0.1827531755,
-0.5797124505,
-0.5652082562,
-0.4709780514,
-0.0954713598,
-0.4756508768,
0.4255444109,
-0.0135813095,
-0.0461676382,
0.0458551832,
-0.2349298596,
-0.5253438354,
1.3636474609,
0.419901967,
-0.7926642895,
0.1369046569,
0.3525005281,
0.4390939772,
0.0901647583,
0.4446491003,
0.8634323478,
0.6635609865,
-0.0734741315,
-0.8017501831,
0.0058090901,
-0.2872286737,
-0.1330182105,
0.5444980264,
-0.7767038345,
0.3096666634,
0.0219134502,
-0.4696343839,
0.0788713917,
0.4917682409,
-0.1547970772,
0.104339689,
0.5813924074,
0.7918412685,
0.7140322328,
-0.427672714,
1.0119395256,
-0.2314932346,
0.3210567534,
0.8171241283,
-0.0136681832,
0.6314529181,
0.4744534492,
-0.2890094221,
0.2496730238,
0.458134383,
-0.0657234862,
0.4145495594,
0.1328946054,
-0.1320864558,
-0.0867845416,
-0.018237764,
-0.0635565445,
0.1300950348,
0.272715807,
-0.2338802367,
0.0410789214,
0.1106121317,
0.096028097,
-0.0999414027,
0.0301788915,
0.7413865924,
0.2508035004,
-0.6549931765,
0.8493185043,
-0.2407100797,
0.7407308817,
-0.868062079,
0.1666849554,
-0.2156678736,
0.1969326138,
-0.3057128191,
-0.8776521683,
0.3372838795,
-0.2443093807,
0.02354539,
-0.2836872041,
0.1247944757,
-0.4618487358,
-0.3424941301,
0.103439115,
0.6200371981,
0.2947159708,
-0.1977991909,
-0.3861834705,
0.1875474751,
0.1636501104,
-0.2350589633,
0.4166827202,
0.8448463082,
0.1814495921,
0.688146472,
0.5763350129,
0.4035382867,
0.1478227079,
-0.0007633046,
0.891985774,
-0.5993608832,
-0.4258467257,
-0.6330655813,
0.7177985907,
-0.2844649851,
-0.2945182323,
0.6772028804,
0.806450069,
0.7832931876,
0.1019662321,
0.801856935,
0.0064399056,
0.1962815821,
-0.469812721,
0.6276595592,
-0.818236053,
0.3501928747,
0.0754600763,
-0.8863024712,
-0.277939409,
0.1322411299,
0.0156802125,
-0.1971815228,
0.975641489,
0.6420900822,
-0.3227066696,
-0.1027716175,
0.7491867542,
0.0334193707,
0.5591475368,
0.5186393261,
0.7613246441,
-0.7646073699,
1.1635627747,
-0.3513477147,
-0.3577849865,
-0.0667167529,
-0.7793546319,
-0.4330595732,
-0.5632278323,
-0.681234777,
-0.1351083815,
0.1378102899,
0.8226209879,
0.9344906211,
-0.3298591077,
-0.2289782763,
0.0736931041,
-0.2337262183,
-0.5686331391,
-0.1841935515,
0.6176677942,
-0.3778863251,
-0.8586596847,
0.3373843431,
0.3459837139,
-0.0234261155,
-0.1627810746,
-0.0616739839,
0.5630009174,
-0.1083506495,
0.7256108522,
-0.1570057571,
-0.1671236902,
-0.1839008182,
-0.0563534945,
0.1874753982,
0.4477937222,
0.8599306941,
-0.8775548935,
0.618432045,
0.42028597,
0.6514084339,
0.5397306681,
-0.0280084517,
0.6522807479,
-1.0470956564,
-0.0015971919,
0.2243510634,
0.6319631338,
0.3096424937,
0.0252981074,
0.790393889,
0.0117018232,
-0.8061163425,
-0.8473141193,
-0.1343539506,
-1.0716809034,
-0.1606617868,
0.7925957441,
-0.3200125992,
-0.3050790131,
0.0267397724,
-0.4106449485,
0.1767454743,
-0.4062677026,
0.7410752773,
0.3898086846,
0.1444631219,
-0.1123462841,
-0.6288112998,
0.2876420021,
0.3209781349,
-0.633803308,
0.2168128192,
0.158514142,
0.1242644042,
0.2800033987,
0.1839199811,
-0.4012150168,
0.1530409157,
0.2795749307,
0.0436577164,
-0.1257037073,
-0.0635695234,
-0.2053553462,
0.2161051333,
0.179069832,
-0.3743413091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14550v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14550v1 | GraphReader: Building Graph-based Agent to Enhance Long-Context Abilities of Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T17:57:51 | 2024-06-20T17:57:51 | Shilong Li, Yancheng He, Hangyu Guo, Xingyuan Bu, Ge Bai, Jie Liu, Jiaheng Liu, Xingwei Qu, Yangguang Li, Wanli Ouyang, Wenbo Su, Bo Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Long-context capabilities are essential for large language models (LLMs) to
tackle complex and long-input tasks. Despite numerous efforts made to optimize
LLMs for long contexts, challenges persist in robustly processing long inputs.
In this paper, we introduce GraphReader, a graph-based agent system designed to
handle long texts by structuring them into a graph and employing an agent to
explore this graph autonomously. Upon receiving a question, the agent first
undertakes a step-by-step analysis and devises a rational plan. It then invokes
a set of predefined functions to read node content and neighbors, facilitating
a coarse-to-fine exploration of the graph. Throughout the exploration, the
agent continuously records new insights and reflects on current circumstances
to optimize the process until it has gathered sufficient information to
generate an answer. Experimental results on the LV-Eval dataset reveal that
GraphReader, using a 4k context window, consistently outperforms GPT-4-128k
across context lengths from 16k to 256k by a large margin. Additionally, our
approach demonstrates superior performance on four challenging single-hop and
multi-hop benchmarks. | [
-0.369702369,
-1.0121406317,
0.9596708417,
0.1170672402,
-0.2803260684,
0.4143102169,
-0.3591278791,
-0.7835140228,
0.1267112046,
0.6870361567,
-0.3738771975,
-0.5738030076,
-0.6342861056,
0.3585852683,
-0.1771578789,
0.9029595256,
-0.2819212973,
-0.5668255091,
-0.1561932117,
-0.0385532863,
-0.4830454588,
-0.3883593976,
-0.9364683032,
-0.5035207868,
0.8348042369,
0.2961775362,
0.7536060214,
0.5865675211,
0.0761130527,
0.4120076299,
-0.1491001248,
0.4458372593,
-0.7550378442,
0.5118660331,
-0.2654876113,
0.0274975915,
-0.6860122681,
-0.3164307773,
0.8561742306,
0.549025178,
0.3860059679,
-0.0133289434,
0.2448019385,
0.5018558502,
-0.391053468,
0.5997104645,
-0.1262468547,
-0.2336772531,
-0.157686919,
-0.2674353123,
-0.585285306,
-0.121657446,
0.1100809202,
-0.6561798453,
-0.1056745425,
-0.0925931334,
0.4591883719,
0.0372400023,
-0.8376185298,
-0.3556698263,
-0.5919778943,
0.3715616465,
-0.344424367,
0.4150476456,
0.3913075924,
0.4422276914,
-0.384398967,
-0.9040980339,
-0.4963257313,
-0.0084349001,
-0.1487663686,
0.0033119733,
-0.2032279372,
0.3639733791,
0.1751976162,
-0.1705551147,
-0.5537161231,
0.1239858121,
0.0162920468,
-0.3620682657,
0.4748278856,
0.1173088104,
0.3373290896,
-0.2468072325,
-0.029221857,
-0.0198820792,
-0.2427311689,
0.3131968677,
0.2432558239,
0.3343317807,
0.2598618865,
0.529707253,
-0.3841415942,
0.8905907869,
-0.2809349597,
-0.1116515249,
0.1846980155,
-0.2783564329,
-0.0643758848,
0.0483876877,
0.7097789049,
0.3417430818,
0.3138922453,
-0.2515556812,
-0.4152996838,
-0.1518617719,
-0.1116553247,
-1.1133198738,
0.0025787731,
0.3927147686,
-0.0546305589,
-0.1280883551,
-0.3219648898,
-0.8043349385,
-0.4170256257,
-0.2323719561,
0.0661930293,
-0.5152335763,
-0.0447017364,
0.1592090279,
-0.1820833534,
0.0297557749,
0.5271504521,
-0.6877481937,
0.4552284777,
0.9503457546,
1.1348592043,
-0.2088446319,
-0.5646010041,
-0.988709867,
0.2224413902,
-0.3382552564,
0.9217025042,
-0.658937037,
-0.4032410383,
-0.1063064933,
0.3070322275,
-0.1770162731,
-0.0507869571,
0.4377985001,
-0.8489601612,
-0.1619476676,
-0.0512403883,
-0.6515724659,
-0.0306144543,
0.4506126642,
-0.7637180686,
1.0701014996,
0.4599512517,
-0.7035117745,
0.2436406314,
-0.9010944963,
-0.6014872789,
0.3717952371,
-0.0771621093,
-0.0976872593,
-0.2365184575,
0.4652180076,
0.4239218235,
0.1417406499,
0.089299351,
-0.2560574114,
-0.5248090625,
0.1016528904,
-0.4871713221,
0.461180985,
0.0362536795,
-0.2512575984,
0.5120815635,
-0.5690641999,
0.2263197154,
0.3234989047,
-0.3786375225,
-0.2615616024,
0.1055131033,
0.1683239937,
0.0313745327,
0.2977577746,
-0.7397636771,
0.2922988236,
-0.3442878425,
0.7048106194,
0.9379321933,
-0.1375830621,
0.4340556562,
-0.0970505476,
0.8440802693,
-0.4251668453,
-0.1964721978,
-0.3381326497,
-0.1651942134,
-0.4496694505,
-0.4287866354,
0.1410612911,
0.49513641,
-0.9425201416,
0.367577076,
-0.5823422074,
-0.31213063,
-0.086195983,
0.2435460538,
0.0089787617,
0.442148,
0.2713661194,
0.0020646499,
-0.0097947204,
-0.4221074879,
-0.0855509341,
0.0372225009,
0.142282635,
0.6536605954,
0.4800415635,
-0.7392298579,
1.2210474014,
-0.781832099,
-0.2127548158,
-0.578116715,
-0.2161648422,
0.2069422305,
-0.0616041496,
0.4117259383,
-0.3370950818,
-0.7022740841,
0.4011149406,
-0.647478044,
-0.1088605449,
0.1169725433,
-0.3045624197,
0.2074459344,
0.7896918654,
-0.7062844038,
0.265578717,
0.7992478013,
-0.5734816194,
0.3803706765,
-0.3911102116,
-0.3028620183,
-1.1154329777,
0.1976310611,
-0.1845017672,
-1.068274498,
-0.3463024795,
0.1823923737,
-0.0207330417,
-0.380253166,
-0.1110493317,
0.8718659878,
-0.5970802903,
-0.1097113267,
-0.5666731,
0.4962091446,
0.2546510696,
0.3111575842,
-0.0896477178,
0.9295969605,
0.465904206,
-0.1802045703,
0.6701714396,
0.0599597581,
-0.3424028754,
0.1741663963,
-0.6790162325,
0.5265418887,
-0.3043974042,
0.8718625307,
-0.9511007071,
-0.2478663623,
0.2476180196,
-0.183792606,
0.30290851,
-0.2904576659,
-0.6226851344,
-0.4709087312,
0.0078616999,
0.5161083341,
0.0199398939,
-0.6109248996,
0.8256511688,
0.2807902694,
-0.5728906989,
-0.6865622401,
-0.1558396071,
0.4558109343,
0.1656785011,
-0.7951202393,
-0.0283170082,
-0.0797222629,
0.0040407279,
0.0263829231,
0.0614409968,
0.0708165988,
0.0045731021,
0.0948875248,
-0.0602488369,
-0.0979789421,
0.1442539841,
0.0981065482,
-0.3847360909,
0.0398151204,
-0.4277811348,
0.9250693321,
-0.1853576899,
-0.0422070026,
-0.2527806163,
0.5587890744,
0.675075531,
-0.3992846012,
0.3585859537,
0.2383862138,
-0.0329461209,
-0.5447456837,
-0.0249998402,
0.0875342712,
-0.5321580768,
0.711187005,
-0.6763573885,
-1.1130611897,
0.5442916155,
-0.306984365,
-0.1464855373,
0.2022190243,
0.176674366,
0.0342624821,
1.135281086,
0.6020925045,
-0.5138267875,
0.6435704231,
-0.3577136397,
0.2388686538,
-0.7111896873,
0.1936941594,
-0.2477820367,
-0.1780270487,
-0.3424575031,
-0.6032355428,
0.1988252699,
-0.2002903074,
-0.1664055735,
0.0851892903,
-0.4464938641,
0.9137035608,
0.2608962059,
0.082466051,
0.3171499074,
-0.2244095802,
-0.071660541,
0.4414668977,
-0.4569173455,
-0.466237545,
0.8197411895,
0.574154377,
0.7762598395,
0.1073075458,
0.6113244295,
0.2283740044,
0.2193332314,
-1.1836849451,
0.7083076835,
0.1621726602,
-0.3799141943,
-0.8105359077,
-0.4331528544,
-1.1791996956,
0.4146755338,
0.3646117151,
-0.7554077506,
-0.0573678948,
-0.0212525297,
0.0695763975,
0.2118353695,
-0.3966133595,
1.0610202551,
-0.3010715842,
-0.3142255545,
0.0239040982,
-0.5217356682,
-0.1920901537,
-0.2329442203,
0.1295609325,
-0.0454746,
-0.0219600722,
0.2728875577,
-0.5752210617,
0.7707327008,
-0.2561516762,
-0.2408451736,
0.3133188784,
0.3010298908,
0.9590185881,
0.118131943,
-0.047486987,
-0.0441937372,
0.1304458678,
-0.4237331748,
-0.7143349648,
0.5365005136,
-0.8462841511,
-0.494731158,
-0.6389968991,
-0.6594396234,
-0.19403781,
0.835727334,
0.1460013986,
0.7067587376,
-0.4094246924,
0.2035987228,
0.1327498853,
0.1415522695,
0.4090355635,
0.2896419466,
-0.5573329926,
-0.2812860906,
0.8528361917,
0.0447348021,
0.2605373859,
0.2829620838,
0.1722175777,
-0.4678451419,
-0.6500543356,
-0.663194716,
0.2137966603,
-0.8701565266,
-0.0116641996,
-0.719353497,
-0.2378683388,
-0.3205444813,
-0.2098896205,
-0.0789626613,
0.1895808727,
-0.1216087788,
-0.2111206502,
0.3688744903,
0.7181251645,
0.3608422875,
0.4553259015,
-0.5502688885,
0.0906581804,
0.2643076777,
0.5973729491,
-0.0894573405,
-0.1528218985,
-0.3051958084,
-0.0515517369,
-0.094847478,
-0.7057139277,
0.431102246,
0.0974436924,
0.1889638305,
0.3500919044,
0.0142417038,
0.5884504318,
-0.7406048179,
0.3693749905,
-0.3710429072,
-0.9332849383,
0.3082670271,
-0.7349366546,
0.5111933947,
0.652233243,
0.080640994,
-0.8383150697,
-0.4384573698,
0.0562797822,
-0.8552179933,
0.6639886498,
0.0481513403,
0.2420632392,
-0.0790677443,
0.3606159091,
-0.0511351153,
-0.1284283102,
-0.6276896596,
0.2727586627,
-0.290815115,
-0.191790089,
-0.7149812579,
-0.1790158004,
-0.1164255664,
-0.1816575825,
0.3660335839,
-0.8110848069,
0.1021599695,
0.3791705668,
-0.4339105189,
-0.026759658,
0.3479931056,
0.5548467636,
1.0184422731,
-0.3410440683,
0.1403435767,
0.0688631162,
-0.5659775138,
0.0217186473,
0.4336429834,
0.0053324662,
-0.1211252436,
0.4819580019,
0.8043864965,
-0.0526895858,
-0.8144930601,
0.5672886968,
-0.2858594358,
0.0673071593,
-0.3355773687,
-0.0606238171,
0.2112323046,
0.3621322215,
0.1447450221,
-0.4375691712,
0.1927630156,
-0.4880444705,
0.0790110156,
0.2777459621,
-0.4629866183,
-0.1213219389,
0.3213325441,
0.3078972697,
-0.3942091763,
0.8067872524,
-0.2562124133,
-0.6475804448,
0.6413809657,
0.8768995404,
0.7473364472,
0.1461612284,
0.1862173378,
-0.1937523335,
-0.0166658647,
0.1884302497,
0.0033400271,
-0.1057566181,
-0.7756854296,
-0.6560657024,
-0.4725576341,
-0.4372622073,
-0.0132126836,
-0.2164313346,
0.070202969,
-0.3294849694,
-0.3549301624,
0.0961454138,
0.2708075941,
-0.5354142189,
-0.0142506929,
-0.1029498726,
0.856382072,
-0.4196160138,
0.9260622263,
0.5146456957,
-0.0539472997,
-0.7055097818,
-0.012295532,
-0.1435247809,
-0.7204384208,
0.5006531477,
0.4500930607,
-0.5717445016,
0.2942160666,
-0.2411812693,
-0.7883769274,
1.0874108076,
0.2825809419,
-0.6157792807,
-0.2269120961,
0.129310295,
0.6679211855,
-0.3269542158,
0.2478951514,
0.4842490256,
0.3753882647,
0.0537741743,
-0.6856955886,
0.1213318706,
-0.223250851,
-0.2318736017,
0.562677443,
-0.7384436131,
0.6432216763,
-0.0850112215,
-0.193670094,
0.0379704162,
0.5398280025,
0.0894777402,
0.4942985177,
0.6308692098,
0.1841202527,
0.9171890616,
0.2473385781,
1.2916573286,
-0.5628806949,
0.4192174077,
1.2560199499,
-0.5199623704,
0.7366603613,
0.0229853783,
0.2020322829,
0.6330621839,
0.7377663255,
0.3169355392,
0.190459922,
0.0709737167,
-0.4620203972,
-0.1953792125,
-0.0558555387,
-0.1001242846,
0.4616561532,
0.2600049973,
-0.1811398417,
-0.2878095806,
-0.0459673144,
0.1558551192,
-0.0149262343,
-0.2343719155,
0.714953959,
0.1221434698,
-0.6524332166,
0.2008932084,
-0.0085887071,
0.284925878,
-0.6530636549,
0.0811019838,
-0.1236939505,
0.3497816026,
0.0687861666,
-1.0618468523,
-0.0996527597,
-0.0909928754,
-0.1431861669,
-0.2612452209,
0.9364860654,
-0.2290619165,
-0.3561066389,
0.7636624575,
0.4370697141,
0.0853594914,
-0.3199320734,
-0.5383089781,
0.1024474949,
-0.3077054024,
-0.3916874826,
0.1770544648,
0.6258534789,
-0.2539703846,
0.7695326805,
0.6623001695,
0.1187379807,
-0.4401810765,
0.0951913148,
1.053783536,
-0.821115911,
-0.776743114,
-0.8714438677,
0.1511883587,
-0.2474873364,
-0.1978163868,
0.5788328648,
0.7973380685,
0.5549385548,
0.4773649871,
0.8193808794,
0.391264379,
0.3365953565,
-0.2392901778,
0.8073955178,
-0.3303053975,
-0.2024567723,
-0.285574913,
-1.1074025631,
-0.0873409361,
0.45379287,
-0.4453619123,
0.1146794111,
0.6039419174,
0.4789104462,
-0.1011703312,
-0.1999704391,
0.1700919718,
0.1834840924,
0.9078964591,
0.5140453577,
0.7983114123,
0.0370540842,
0.4584081173,
0.2586715519,
-0.3717242777,
-0.2897994518,
-0.7281476855,
-1.1306965351,
-0.223251909,
0.2867631912,
-0.5921220779,
0.0602536947,
0.8132897615,
0.5131748915,
-0.2655284405,
-0.2868348956,
0.0888218135,
0.2520939112,
0.02837497,
-0.239272505,
0.5256864429,
-0.37163046,
-0.8571654558,
0.6874670386,
0.4135110974,
-0.0831301138,
-0.1412888914,
-0.1517152041,
0.174606204,
0.1643582284,
1.0915255547,
0.4651261866,
-0.3183309734,
-0.6871849298,
0.0792346299,
-0.299102217,
0.1711218208,
0.7606618404,
-0.6599019766,
0.8489637971,
0.6267414689,
0.8047983646,
0.7976682186,
0.1304294765,
0.5544028282,
-0.4520034194,
0.0695784912,
0.3408394754,
0.3115137517,
0.0513444021,
-0.572119534,
0.3941673338,
-0.0492070466,
-0.9445469975,
-0.7717908621,
0.2126462013,
-1.1513825655,
-0.4741716385,
1.1146796942,
0.0145516368,
-0.5198108554,
-0.2645705342,
-0.5241422057,
0.1301061362,
-0.6312704086,
0.2520389557,
0.8383458257,
-0.2827993929,
-0.0504327603,
-0.4855442345,
0.2665070593,
-0.1326642334,
-0.8518208861,
0.38971591,
0.7500810623,
0.524237752,
-0.0619846843,
1.0276346207,
0.2728110254,
0.0105277291,
-0.0956940278,
-0.2480133623,
-0.2889150083,
-0.4714381993,
-0.237709254,
0.1405924112,
0.1064341962,
0.2100555301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14546v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14546v1 | Connecting the Dots: LLMs can Infer and Verbalize Latent Structure from Disparate Training Data | 2024-06-20T17:55:04 | 2024-06-20T17:55:04 | Johannes Treutlein, Dami Choi, Jan Betley, Cem Anil, Samuel Marks, Roger Baker Grosse, Owain Evans | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | One way to address safety risks from large language models (LLMs) is to
censor dangerous knowledge from their training data. While this removes the
explicit information, implicit information can remain scattered across various
training documents. Could an LLM infer the censored knowledge by piecing
together these implicit hints? As a step towards answering this question, we
study inductive out-of-context reasoning (OOCR), a type of generalization in
which LLMs infer latent information from evidence distributed across training
documents and apply it to downstream tasks without in-context learning. Using a
suite of five tasks, we demonstrate that frontier LLMs can perform inductive
OOCR. In one experiment we finetune an LLM on a corpus consisting only of
distances between an unknown city and other known cities. Remarkably, without
in-context examples or Chain of Thought, the LLM can verbalize that the unknown
city is Paris and use this fact to answer downstream questions. Further
experiments show that LLMs trained only on individual coin flip outcomes can
verbalize whether the coin is biased, and those trained only on pairs
$(x,f(x))$ can articulate a definition of $f$ and compute inverses. While OOCR
succeeds in a range of cases, we also show that it is unreliable, particularly
for smaller LLMs learning complex structures. Overall, the ability of LLMs to
"connect the dots" without explicit in-context learning poses a potential
obstacle to monitoring and controlling the knowledge acquired by LLMs. | [
-0.2280125767,
-0.9979028702,
0.9641753435,
-0.2238666266,
-0.1141119972,
0.2519948184,
-0.4275802076,
-0.5340943336,
-0.2372928411,
0.4228208661,
-0.453715235,
-0.5464199781,
-0.62133044,
-0.2922841311,
-0.3699759543,
0.8847393394,
-0.0999237448,
0.0563344657,
-0.4694107473,
-0.0329359584,
-0.1177941412,
-0.7543109655,
-0.4790796936,
-0.5177568197,
0.4360468388,
0.6203096509,
0.4128361046,
0.4957340658,
0.2497698069,
0.3065832555,
-0.2507203817,
0.3668786883,
-0.5678804517,
-0.0709093809,
-0.3246742189,
-0.6619336009,
-0.1038762927,
0.0249116309,
0.6617745757,
1.234033227,
0.1120776385,
-0.2830875814,
0.4340853393,
0.6825076342,
-0.6095426679,
0.2063848376,
-0.8026592135,
-0.0902627334,
-0.1156748161,
-0.33272627,
-0.3743906319,
-0.2955409288,
0.1147654355,
-0.6064427495,
0.1302955151,
-0.110170655,
0.8366767764,
0.4422717988,
-0.5734410882,
-0.6393778324,
-0.8584967852,
0.5404394865,
-0.3746154308,
0.1805924624,
0.6001644731,
0.2074178308,
-0.4577403069,
-0.6191079021,
-0.4595072865,
-0.1220444664,
-0.3503898084,
-0.0438765436,
0.1703862697,
0.0681308433,
0.4968916774,
0.0857865214,
-0.1090899482,
0.1361810565,
-0.2865547836,
-0.0267867707,
0.424040705,
-0.1245389283,
0.0907361284,
0.0991820469,
-0.5763903856,
0.1738229245,
-1.0828227997,
0.3857344091,
0.2567820251,
0.3012907207,
-0.1826255918,
0.5511471629,
-0.1871498674,
0.3237686753,
0.2537898421,
-0.1369231641,
0.0557323433,
0.0099605341,
-0.0358598903,
0.1548882127,
0.6284435987,
0.0766037926,
0.0383332148,
-0.5736304522,
-0.1060200781,
-0.0957342535,
-0.0770538449,
-0.5306999683,
-0.0357209556,
0.1752946079,
-0.1203834936,
0.0290131606,
0.0261276476,
-0.4367240071,
-0.448852092,
-0.2811628282,
0.4995300174,
-0.4520436525,
0.0290282816,
-0.1119001955,
-0.0172161087,
0.2930858135,
0.2694251239,
-0.7887297869,
0.2610785663,
0.6416547894,
0.6884913445,
0.0815431699,
-0.3039922118,
-0.7996041179,
0.2330693156,
-0.458827883,
0.7286294699,
-0.3782941401,
-0.2958541214,
0.1194983944,
0.1109600663,
-0.1251888871,
-0.3684537411,
0.3848640025,
-0.5675415993,
0.004022391,
-0.4517350793,
-0.6136777997,
-0.069577314,
0.1079355255,
-0.3354958594,
1.0239117146,
-0.0665037483,
-0.8661535382,
0.5008662939,
-0.343008101,
-0.580316186,
-0.0056436048,
-0.7249698639,
-0.2600144744,
0.0047590504,
0.2925933003,
0.4440409541,
-0.0007577593,
0.3347826302,
-0.4390142858,
-0.4371024072,
0.5109805465,
-0.2363466024,
0.6330857277,
-0.01317624,
-0.6185904741,
-0.134013027,
-0.7910183668,
-0.2834165692,
-0.0565346293,
-0.4464526176,
-0.744145453,
0.2874519527,
-0.434327811,
0.2804965973,
-0.0397249162,
-0.567465663,
-0.0205195788,
-0.4538383186,
0.6720406413,
0.5931229591,
0.0019750914,
0.9767845273,
-0.0927271321,
0.1174978614,
-0.0392621271,
0.0273041707,
-0.0360217728,
-0.4628857672,
-0.8980203867,
-0.2635323405,
-0.1043469459,
0.3687568605,
-1.0067641735,
0.4520154893,
-0.1805014908,
-0.1475254148,
-0.0531083457,
-0.0579499491,
0.409080714,
1.0606672764,
0.3215717673,
0.1843128204,
-0.1973976046,
-0.4638797641,
-0.1175245941,
-0.1105441302,
0.1212757006,
0.2114391625,
0.5328826308,
0.2016212195,
1.0353082418,
-0.280465126,
-0.2443056852,
0.0340902284,
0.1084577292,
0.0797493607,
0.3429445624,
0.161778748,
-0.6259373426,
-0.1641941071,
0.1351863295,
-1.0273714066,
0.0887230039,
-0.1381073445,
-0.238922298,
0.0525688529,
1.190607667,
-0.3811007142,
0.5013518333,
0.2576166391,
-0.2547283173,
0.0890733153,
-0.3901751041,
-0.3529059887,
-0.7163429856,
-0.0340609513,
-0.4232385457,
-0.1239729971,
-0.6819040179,
-0.1439646482,
0.145897612,
0.2284933478,
-0.3724915683,
0.5517866611,
-0.6109822392,
-0.0984405056,
-0.194538787,
0.2872206271,
-0.0060181222,
0.5203430653,
0.3008261621,
0.585814774,
0.5802320838,
-0.7574260235,
-0.1344767809,
0.2056580931,
-0.624777317,
0.6043059826,
-0.2444303185,
0.1801820695,
-0.3075630665,
0.330947578,
-1.0690097809,
-0.2012987733,
0.1747807413,
-0.4067277312,
0.3040980697,
-0.3510568738,
-0.2451928407,
-0.1348226517,
-0.0381869785,
0.2991173565,
0.3316823542,
-0.8144580126,
0.5098157525,
0.3980588913,
-0.1231194213,
-0.7367275953,
-1.0144534111,
-0.0610449016,
-0.4178560972,
-0.5292300582,
0.1702926159,
0.003486003,
-0.3638448417,
0.0966975689,
-0.0068417885,
-0.192629233,
0.254358232,
0.6667100191,
0.2065882534,
-0.0348923542,
0.532369256,
0.1789344251,
0.022452604,
0.2807022035,
-0.3510714173,
0.1591745019,
-0.0949287042,
-0.6312460899,
0.1183392331,
0.3815445304,
0.2563800812,
0.0907593295,
0.7726994753,
0.3623265624,
-0.4431304336,
-0.6015161872,
-0.4899617434,
-0.3217014074,
-0.4767015874,
0.1027528867,
-0.3547186553,
-1.0875937939,
0.5160691738,
-0.2368369401,
-0.174248606,
0.3142401576,
0.5150247216,
-0.3385303319,
0.5425218344,
0.6556506157,
0.230884403,
0.401615262,
-0.396830976,
0.109163709,
-0.7895417213,
-0.5223254561,
-0.4015195072,
-0.0804274306,
-0.5538813472,
-0.47543329,
0.7030644417,
0.4063251019,
-0.226311639,
-0.0899363533,
-0.3141414821,
0.5919566154,
0.5683764815,
0.3355636001,
0.4353165329,
0.1001731008,
-0.4984817207,
0.3172106147,
-0.777316153,
-0.6121482253,
0.9913572073,
0.5054901242,
0.8140229583,
-0.2291235328,
0.6555102468,
-0.1382157803,
0.3275243938,
-0.6894037127,
0.4028256834,
0.0427084379,
-0.5892602205,
-0.4797671139,
-0.3588464558,
-0.8516381383,
0.2773239315,
-0.1576478928,
-0.6866029501,
0.6551557779,
-0.1336936802,
-0.5046272874,
0.3479720354,
-0.6071592569,
0.4251860976,
-0.2282181978,
-0.3989917934,
0.140891999,
-0.8241009116,
0.47209692,
-0.1096372306,
0.6812247634,
-0.2060683668,
-0.0884211361,
0.464265734,
-0.6925039887,
1.1860871315,
-0.0320582502,
-0.2863908112,
0.4962416887,
-0.219975099,
0.7650852799,
0.2070350349,
0.0861160606,
0.2822524905,
-0.3928536773,
-0.2122410685,
-0.4784813821,
0.6833362579,
-0.7900195122,
-0.3255041242,
-0.3403504491,
-0.5580555797,
-0.4015069306,
0.0182826929,
0.6678242087,
0.4281472266,
-0.1614698619,
0.0300359931,
0.8366568089,
-0.0361686796,
0.7160484195,
0.5150931478,
0.2015517205,
-0.2296318263,
0.5957180262,
0.2067803591,
0.4377573133,
0.6846546531,
0.1884001344,
-0.5538197756,
-0.6079807878,
-0.3015541434,
0.2558738291,
-1.1852496862,
0.0369678885,
-0.5456412435,
-0.3583725095,
0.0442962646,
-0.3286652565,
-0.2376437485,
-0.3793627918,
-0.1970662028,
-0.2794803381,
0.2184762657,
0.8646240234,
-0.2899742126,
0.2218509018,
-0.4006736577,
0.0794386193,
0.5792813301,
0.2615788281,
-0.1543493271,
-0.5278351903,
-0.3513854742,
0.0006300043,
0.0491010286,
-0.5833117962,
-0.0494481325,
0.0603438765,
0.6644554138,
0.4860855341,
0.3093968928,
0.5191035271,
-0.5969036222,
0.4858156145,
0.0835834369,
-0.7887243629,
0.4059614539,
-0.297447145,
-0.0797113478,
0.4638458192,
0.4584417939,
-0.1886565238,
-0.6339471936,
-0.388335228,
-0.8608083129,
0.635730803,
0.1075655892,
-0.1813210845,
-0.2145993412,
0.4548160136,
0.102110438,
0.0665871352,
-0.6861328483,
-0.1107500419,
-0.0221531559,
0.1626800299,
-0.160906598,
-0.1944118738,
-0.570233345,
0.0407711379,
0.2293447554,
-0.3511278629,
0.1810470074,
0.4740900397,
-0.3390910029,
-0.2121661752,
0.304399848,
0.4795423448,
0.7047774792,
-0.1553862542,
0.5896829367,
0.3454825282,
-0.3087848723,
0.1079515293,
0.1665638089,
-0.2845956087,
-0.2370778024,
0.6184203029,
0.6355152726,
0.1918277889,
-0.4430040419,
0.6389409304,
0.0697119385,
-0.2402287126,
-0.3573704064,
-0.1495933235,
0.1635197699,
0.5374678373,
0.4171827137,
-0.0912183449,
-0.0553283244,
-0.6364007592,
0.2171446979,
0.6156215668,
-0.576751411,
-0.2330249846,
0.5759641528,
0.1878280938,
0.2829021215,
0.4234466553,
-0.2175124139,
-0.2561534047,
0.5291193128,
0.1643807441,
0.8524968624,
0.0324157551,
-0.0396922417,
0.1685575992,
0.5070556402,
0.0396050513,
0.1731978804,
-0.2120874822,
-0.7295893431,
-0.6626691222,
-0.4089792371,
-0.4712887108,
0.1233586147,
-0.4819258153,
0.080769591,
-0.4742826521,
0.019044457,
-0.1287155449,
-0.2973784804,
-0.6701184511,
0.2034300417,
0.46445629,
0.6331200004,
-0.8819130659,
0.9285116196,
0.6112611294,
-0.4139485359,
-0.7333952785,
0.0829152837,
-0.0940540582,
-0.8493016362,
0.852075398,
0.0512453131,
-0.2577260137,
-0.3794735074,
-0.6150852442,
-0.8741230369,
1.1667437553,
0.3806823492,
-0.6300068498,
-0.2389825881,
0.4025647938,
0.3183504045,
-0.4422688782,
0.3675905764,
0.4635052681,
0.1564936042,
0.4181551039,
-0.8606325388,
0.1847675741,
0.2098564357,
-0.2581394613,
-0.0527109951,
-0.4773885012,
1.1010862589,
-0.5551905632,
-0.4150671363,
-0.129695341,
0.4820342958,
0.0301779564,
0.4376239777,
0.5368716121,
0.3520124853,
0.9782505631,
-0.1777276397,
0.9508540034,
-0.073748447,
0.0993877351,
1.3872181177,
-0.1835541576,
0.8070888519,
0.5408529639,
-0.0040147472,
0.6387739778,
0.5357895494,
0.6260945201,
0.7311940789,
0.0515056364,
-0.3077634871,
-0.2799682319,
-0.1535862982,
-0.3771555126,
0.280400455,
0.6932786107,
-0.15711236,
-0.3969248533,
0.0080465386,
0.1963339299,
0.108451575,
-0.3412443101,
0.8383307457,
0.3224847615,
-0.5004827976,
0.6654293537,
-0.3536031246,
0.4274162352,
-0.6026988029,
-0.0378247425,
-0.2826669812,
0.4258642495,
-0.3119481504,
-0.7801676393,
0.3963674605,
-0.3144943416,
0.020628538,
-0.2258676142,
0.7227979898,
-0.6291711926,
-0.299441278,
0.503157258,
0.54712075,
0.1612888426,
-0.3007316589,
-0.1524748355,
-0.212626785,
-0.3577702045,
-0.1661245227,
0.5084485412,
0.8780899644,
-0.3896638453,
0.5636913776,
0.6504982114,
0.0549356267,
0.1963077784,
-0.1051269248,
1.2894796133,
-0.5530222058,
-0.5635382533,
-0.8022776246,
0.4201574922,
-0.0336775444,
-0.0426139571,
0.6068753004,
0.3171960711,
1.0234127045,
0.1830741316,
0.9734165668,
0.1849786043,
0.5233806372,
-0.8104470968,
0.6487433314,
-0.3682761788,
0.3744053245,
-0.0485976599,
-0.5570577383,
-0.0237640105,
0.5066385865,
-0.6150767803,
-0.2400016189,
1.0030629635,
0.7412857413,
0.0581312329,
-0.1823036969,
0.4161021113,
0.2248610705,
0.2144662142,
0.7480916977,
1.2677470446,
-0.1857289672,
0.800770402,
-0.3356798887,
-0.3739183843,
-0.1097206995,
-0.9982296228,
-1.4073036909,
-0.5655878782,
-0.2796448469,
-0.2685343027,
0.0694215819,
0.5791481733,
0.7594159245,
-0.5658124685,
-0.1661060005,
-0.3169732392,
0.4833692312,
-0.0414626971,
-0.1410948485,
0.5517944098,
-0.6349130273,
-0.5711372495,
0.7074677944,
0.3049468994,
-0.0437601767,
-0.1992574632,
-0.1355277002,
-0.1157547832,
-0.014487193,
0.6428121328,
0.2945329249,
-0.7225579023,
-0.356902957,
-0.2094387859,
-0.2310019433,
-0.0818499923,
0.7888685465,
-0.7249323726,
0.3952245414,
0.4283313155,
0.4737627506,
0.5486159325,
-0.152344808,
0.3056694567,
-0.9357114434,
0.2805941403,
0.056511756,
0.423065722,
0.3878836334,
-0.4906124175,
0.4949383438,
0.2533257306,
-0.515882194,
-0.4858865738,
0.1904776096,
-0.5982019305,
-0.4349167049,
1.3792338371,
-0.3066575825,
-0.2763856947,
-0.4684736133,
0.0545005687,
0.1954278499,
-0.2386932373,
0.5781854987,
0.6207493544,
-0.104103677,
0.0737437457,
-0.6326276064,
0.8168162704,
0.0828527808,
-0.8698775768,
-0.001093979,
0.2958521247,
0.439262718,
0.1404048055,
0.8535172343,
-0.0700520873,
-0.0355284549,
0.0051624281,
-0.0044788211,
-0.1030127406,
-0.3413195908,
-0.3144830167,
0.1944485456,
0.1367596835,
-0.4374545515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14545v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14545v1 | Unmasking Database Vulnerabilities: Zero-Knowledge Schema Inference Attacks in Text-to-SQL Systems | 2024-06-20T17:54:33 | 2024-06-20T17:54:33 | Đorđe Klisura, Anthony Rios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relational databases are integral to modern information systems, serving as
the foundation for storing, querying, and managing data efficiently and
effectively. Advancements in large language modeling have led to the emergence
of text-to-SQL technologies, significantly enhancing the querying and
extracting of information from these databases and raising concerns about
privacy and security. Our research extracts the database schema elements
underlying a text-to-SQL model. Knowledge of the schema can make attacks such
as SQL injection easier. By asking specially crafted questions, we have
developed a zero-knowledge framework designed to probe various database schema
elements without knowledge of the database itself. The text-to-SQL models then
process these questions to produce an output that we use to uncover the
structure of the database schema. We apply it to specialized text-to-SQL models
fine-tuned on text-SQL pairs and generative language models used for SQL
generation. Overall, we can reconstruct the table names with an F1 of nearly
.75 for fine-tuned models and .96 for generative. | [
-0.1401407868,
-1.237604022,
0.6648259759,
-0.3037383854,
-0.1054423824,
0.0202107113,
0.1657869071,
-0.5334600806,
0.1263112873,
1.0245046616,
-0.5121329427,
-0.589240849,
-0.3051111102,
-0.1195356622,
-0.9627045989,
0.9544912577,
0.510496676,
-0.1950394958,
-0.470885843,
0.1317204684,
-0.2694152594,
-0.7721385956,
0.136694327,
0.046262335,
0.1153878868,
0.4956962466,
0.6207430363,
0.7077171206,
0.4061120152,
0.1420850307,
0.0234811753,
-0.2785987854,
-0.4262846708,
0.513921082,
-0.5038343668,
-0.4591658115,
-0.3244338334,
-0.4885708988,
0.1253769845,
0.9924331307,
-0.236819163,
0.1897246987,
-0.4031998515,
0.7382695675,
-0.9812523127,
-0.0445725657,
-1.0501884222,
0.1147026271,
-0.499270916,
-0.270245254,
-0.6967228651,
-0.148319155,
0.0047959769,
-0.4472026229,
0.314291209,
0.0620579608,
0.7275727987,
-0.0410861969,
-0.6602123976,
-0.1590292305,
-1.1033593416,
0.4212171435,
-0.4266877472,
0.3590110838,
0.2135772556,
0.3717285395,
-0.3004516363,
-0.4915210605,
-0.5690928102,
-0.0383918621,
-0.1525900066,
-0.226662904,
-0.1188474074,
0.1463510841,
0.4011417329,
0.6391444206,
-0.6360454559,
0.0138568878,
-0.2673074305,
-0.057794109,
0.5669283867,
0.0997022092,
0.3582944572,
-0.2436173409,
-0.41106686,
0.3266044557,
-1.0605304241,
-0.3627256453,
0.2005597055,
0.2751744986,
0.1604641229,
0.8688191175,
-0.5158355832,
0.9004328251,
-0.1189083159,
0.1660566181,
-0.2383810729,
-0.3155338764,
-0.6236503124,
-0.0073839813,
0.7316708565,
0.0804630443,
0.1437265873,
-0.7611407042,
0.042195417,
0.2146402299,
0.2628715336,
-0.7177789807,
-0.2549505532,
0.4916747212,
-0.1902787089,
-0.7091596723,
0.0582081042,
-0.9970998168,
-0.8191844821,
0.1740325093,
0.5866284966,
-0.4927449822,
-0.4191837609,
0.0481489077,
-0.2392180562,
0.3529073596,
0.1234348714,
-0.8889546394,
0.3503201902,
0.5193667412,
0.3185665905,
-0.0439318642,
0.1349764913,
-0.1519315988,
0.5813395977,
-0.3951884806,
0.7834696174,
-0.3281814158,
-0.7003427744,
0.0090132235,
-0.0591687188,
0.1402999014,
-0.2186991274,
0.2246323824,
-0.6129729748,
0.2487148941,
-0.1866881549,
-0.7607988715,
0.1501246542,
0.1177880764,
-0.5674672127,
0.8412799835,
0.3166410923,
-0.6990873814,
0.2694224417,
-0.68650949,
-0.521827817,
0.0959441885,
-0.2866025567,
-0.2679297924,
0.2406872958,
0.0918295905,
0.3766453266,
-0.5155391097,
-0.0955756381,
-0.4575462043,
-0.2918850482,
0.4230512977,
0.0364288948,
1.0557408333,
0.2226754129,
-0.2861682475,
-0.3151555359,
-1.0614489317,
0.1538482308,
0.4795532227,
0.1875539124,
-0.4200931191,
0.0535203181,
-0.3254777491,
-0.0303817336,
0.038220305,
-0.5419059992,
0.12984851,
-0.7241089344,
0.3165321052,
0.3345132768,
0.6704795361,
0.7740988731,
0.1521512866,
0.3482970893,
0.208776623,
0.291554451,
-0.5053574443,
-0.1587156504,
-0.586756587,
-0.0361017622,
0.3995113075,
0.7612271309,
-0.8041857481,
0.4507437348,
-0.0018327642,
-0.6559554935,
-0.1220046356,
-0.1057556942,
0.2497425228,
0.5845931172,
0.3583387434,
-0.275591433,
-0.3430039287,
-0.7900618911,
-0.6786631346,
0.0147714242,
-0.2831584513,
0.1839191914,
0.5921003819,
0.1062185541,
0.8520582318,
-0.8500577807,
-0.2939492166,
0.1731185615,
-0.2258706093,
-0.0060363356,
0.5036452413,
0.6245442033,
-0.3664134741,
-0.3343386948,
0.17984128,
-1.1489973068,
0.2691782117,
-0.0082745915,
-0.2176337987,
0.3322339654,
0.6230502725,
-0.7689858079,
0.6455776095,
-0.0646110028,
-0.6053264141,
0.5708090067,
-0.0259690266,
-0.1224540174,
-0.9388014078,
0.1140238792,
-0.254232496,
-0.0163369458,
-1.0480488539,
0.5097329021,
0.269723922,
-0.3664566875,
-0.258531183,
0.1852887422,
-0.8289220929,
-0.1046274081,
0.3832446635,
0.0356380008,
0.0666121095,
0.272834301,
-0.1906825453,
0.5588650107,
0.8350580931,
-0.570240736,
0.2310323268,
0.1092672497,
-0.3876749873,
0.9602307081,
-0.495672822,
0.2140490711,
-0.0043188692,
-0.2252438813,
-0.7894797921,
-0.5483720303,
0.3633072972,
-0.5358954668,
0.4454168081,
-0.3277893364,
-0.5028641224,
-0.0931997895,
-0.0895406082,
-0.0425790995,
0.2286251187,
-0.202422455,
0.7035639882,
0.5827637911,
0.0905528367,
-0.7742320299,
-0.7902786732,
0.2375815064,
-0.1733035296,
-0.3312822282,
0.1744193137,
0.1724042445,
-0.3631334901,
0.0253212135,
-0.2274720371,
-0.5224431753,
0.3272654116,
0.4864088893,
0.2494632751,
-0.2366064787,
0.1510264874,
0.4377219081,
-0.0837251097,
0.2949179709,
-0.3319963217,
0.2475220859,
0.2047116309,
-0.6961669326,
-0.2001028657,
0.5554465055,
0.6684922576,
-0.3415776789,
1.036645174,
-0.188049227,
-0.4983794391,
-0.2202802747,
-0.3582082391,
-0.42507568,
-0.3784782887,
0.3488021791,
-0.3731139004,
-0.5497594476,
0.5022705197,
-0.1440698355,
-0.0474956408,
0.5174913406,
0.08018931,
-0.1771713048,
0.6957934499,
0.6227509379,
0.3371120095,
0.2722308338,
-0.0040561603,
0.3354080617,
-0.1176841184,
-0.4670294523,
-0.7320725322,
0.5487576127,
-0.3604074121,
-0.3187022507,
0.172055766,
0.1267884225,
-0.4607780576,
0.4588956535,
-0.6687607765,
0.850815773,
0.2217337638,
0.1587002575,
0.6418747306,
0.259622097,
-0.0117070014,
0.112361446,
-0.3036252856,
-0.1940485984,
1.2925139666,
0.030348761,
0.6672555208,
0.3220639527,
0.6579937339,
0.3801054657,
-0.0190715063,
-0.3950322866,
0.5243626237,
0.1616551578,
-1.1200605631,
-0.374718219,
-0.3492132127,
-0.6793833375,
0.2589312494,
-0.5292916298,
-0.8648504019,
0.4106090665,
0.057047043,
-0.2507927418,
0.2880572975,
-0.9819191694,
0.7170741558,
-0.0455779321,
-0.348608315,
0.1648805141,
-0.7369199395,
0.6363598704,
-0.2367183119,
0.3026920855,
0.1829033792,
0.2161704302,
0.2838072181,
-0.5339233279,
0.7833641768,
-0.2014038712,
-0.1289525479,
0.1717173606,
0.6228829026,
0.4414901733,
0.1140454784,
-0.2075034082,
0.3542362452,
0.3076128364,
-0.4841522276,
-0.5531913638,
0.6562696099,
-0.4262369871,
-0.4862482548,
-0.4883061945,
-0.1943986714,
-0.2369655371,
0.5368494391,
0.2774768472,
0.0283641573,
-0.5003244281,
0.186267525,
0.9974246025,
-0.130654797,
0.1582477093,
0.7546499968,
-0.3147496581,
-0.0374429636,
0.7921369672,
0.2409555167,
0.3374335468,
0.5629636645,
-0.4222642481,
-0.1454572976,
-0.4410475492,
-0.5587105155,
0.1136191413,
-0.4633858204,
-0.5768682361,
-0.6847994328,
-0.2693650424,
-0.2908828259,
0.1333755255,
-0.208901763,
-0.9875098467,
-0.3828148842,
-0.2671238482,
0.4504327774,
0.7589688897,
0.3078026474,
0.4679844975,
-0.7108749151,
0.0536811203,
0.1196907461,
0.4773280025,
-0.2043920457,
-0.1891255081,
-0.0636610538,
-0.0536434278,
-0.201965332,
-1.690710783,
0.1163978577,
0.1823970824,
0.2683078349,
0.4867733419,
0.3432985842,
0.3099246025,
-0.3071641326,
0.7573240995,
0.0220812894,
-1.177803874,
0.6949099898,
-0.4517558217,
-0.3206474781,
0.4759805202,
0.1410094798,
-0.1872001737,
-0.227155894,
-0.5647118688,
-0.9654167891,
0.6061234474,
0.3653502762,
-0.0466294587,
0.2462204099,
0.6960132718,
0.015026222,
0.4404237866,
-0.7374095917,
-0.6104627848,
-0.2580003738,
0.3187587857,
0.3420764804,
-0.4563720524,
-0.3900543153,
-0.0935765207,
0.3492286205,
-0.0001773183,
0.3930824995,
-0.1744585484,
-0.2780469656,
-0.193439126,
0.4163175821,
0.2418158948,
0.5810768604,
-0.1861552447,
0.083616443,
0.239446938,
-0.3072426021,
-0.0294488184,
0.1364476085,
-0.3825491369,
-0.0406375937,
0.1253764778,
0.3957295716,
0.0667474344,
-0.4152558148,
0.5468215346,
-0.1385000348,
-0.2271051109,
-0.4404018819,
0.2049840391,
0.2248605341,
-0.1189395189,
0.3538405597,
0.0056789094,
0.1601933092,
-0.3903394341,
0.2789902389,
0.6568483114,
-0.5900859237,
-0.1146536469,
0.5815007687,
-0.0566659868,
-0.1740542501,
0.5003983378,
0.1393590719,
0.0107699353,
0.4341974258,
0.6049053073,
0.4174817502,
-0.7202953696,
0.2725969553,
0.0992321223,
0.5645859241,
0.2521586418,
0.4086391628,
-0.1700890064,
-0.4362167418,
-0.0924549773,
-0.3789913356,
-0.5070034862,
0.0147796776,
-0.8933625817,
0.186496824,
-0.4706904292,
0.1850465089,
0.2386430353,
-0.2454715371,
-0.2543352246,
0.1899201274,
-0.5017724037,
0.9495232701,
-1.0334217548,
0.7784071565,
0.4141501486,
-0.6490579844,
-0.3702077866,
-0.2634051144,
-0.107473053,
-0.5794175863,
0.0934733003,
-0.2583028376,
0.2755761147,
-0.0608857423,
-0.6559383273,
-0.7508237958,
0.9157919884,
0.7655115128,
-0.4285995066,
-0.2533644438,
0.6804564595,
0.4199803174,
-0.017323019,
0.1532353759,
0.6482232213,
0.2698672116,
-0.1205210984,
-0.3267460763,
0.1949544698,
-0.1103129312,
-0.1821236461,
0.446929872,
0.0354451798,
0.8572713137,
-0.3344857991,
-0.348867774,
-0.0926003531,
0.6706914902,
0.0120028332,
0.2516648769,
0.2850034833,
0.3663449883,
0.7394633293,
-0.2703613937,
0.9058218598,
-0.3430202007,
0.3522106707,
1.143886447,
-0.4652732909,
0.690518558,
0.6046424508,
-0.2140755653,
0.6854670048,
0.2042245269,
0.1097180098,
0.425024569,
0.1016391814,
-0.4014570713,
-0.2107401788,
0.0998414978,
-0.7167229056,
0.4006895125,
0.8069189787,
-0.4047802091,
-0.3456493318,
-0.3111867607,
0.1469122171,
0.0043371161,
0.2168684751,
0.9789994359,
-0.0028092652,
-0.1684562117,
0.2636597157,
0.0555618815,
-0.0509807207,
-0.5352088213,
-0.010466041,
-0.2506397069,
0.0457322486,
-0.378339678,
-0.7456567883,
0.4763730466,
-0.0792010576,
-0.2062307149,
0.2465600222,
1.0647270679,
-0.3160960674,
-0.1810318381,
0.1217948943,
0.6290314198,
-0.0899161249,
-0.6362374425,
-0.3810890019,
-0.322824508,
0.0308905169,
-0.2206851989,
0.6318318844,
0.6764550805,
-0.0318362564,
0.3868250549,
0.8245987892,
-0.0414737128,
-0.1459257901,
-0.3057057858,
0.8737749457,
-0.7004686594,
-0.431615293,
-0.9054816961,
0.4711919725,
-0.5067598224,
0.2247882634,
0.8575648069,
0.618874073,
0.4772542119,
-0.2940292656,
0.6388521791,
-0.0725327283,
0.7226270437,
-0.2458084226,
1.1970851421,
-0.4031973481,
0.5996156335,
-0.4587478042,
-0.6800016761,
-0.5753452182,
0.3173699379,
-0.0005442635,
-0.1232263297,
0.6445566416,
0.9813019037,
0.2425799072,
0.1526044011,
0.4301750064,
0.3557441831,
0.2788472474,
0.2217330635,
0.5801027417,
-0.597630918,
0.6320412159,
-0.3285599351,
-0.15527156,
-0.2166130841,
-0.9124298096,
-0.7503851056,
-0.4439770281,
-0.0456288531,
-0.8013902307,
0.3325301707,
0.1543170959,
0.4686491489,
-0.9680880904,
0.0190864149,
-0.302357018,
0.4589755535,
-0.1540199518,
-0.2803391516,
0.3742041886,
0.150136143,
-0.0270455796,
0.3611906767,
0.3915648162,
0.1312799156,
-0.3655922115,
0.4782084823,
-0.0331813879,
0.2947231829,
0.5101231337,
0.6576293111,
-0.300133884,
-0.0299400203,
0.1926106364,
-0.1556710303,
-0.2390265912,
0.6196575165,
-0.6953957081,
0.3995567858,
0.3279738128,
0.4402213097,
0.4673618674,
-0.1225813553,
0.5491729975,
-1.0423854589,
0.0019888412,
0.0251438282,
0.1167196035,
0.1865120381,
-0.7719548345,
0.5222678781,
0.3473717272,
-0.3892111778,
-1.331782937,
0.5000836849,
-0.8024586439,
-0.5473539233,
0.6750372648,
0.097533986,
-0.4010269344,
-0.5315870047,
0.1040408835,
0.1169189289,
-0.1888329685,
0.7186250687,
0.2439153939,
-0.0740285292,
-0.0717464313,
-0.2498149723,
0.6259328127,
0.2758746743,
-1.1206328869,
0.2670092881,
0.4396753907,
0.3889166713,
0.1899133176,
0.5810446739,
-0.4170414209,
0.2905803919,
0.1681920439,
0.2264334112,
-0.0284742787,
-0.2955676019,
-0.1961890012,
0.6124783158,
-0.1373836994,
0.0334462002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14544v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14544v1 | Prism: A Framework for Decoupling and Assessing the Capabilities of VLMs | 2024-06-20T17:54:03 | 2024-06-20T17:54:03 | Yuxuan Qiao, Haodong Duan, Xinyu Fang, Junming Yang, Lin Chen, Songyang Zhang, Jiaqi Wang, Dahua Lin, Kai Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Vision Language Models (VLMs) demonstrate remarkable proficiency in
addressing a wide array of visual questions, which requires strong perception
and reasoning faculties. Assessing these two competencies independently is
crucial for model refinement, despite the inherent difficulty due to the
intertwined nature of seeing and reasoning in existing VLMs. To tackle this
issue, we present Prism, an innovative framework designed to disentangle the
perception and reasoning processes involved in visual question solving. Prism
comprises two distinct stages: a perception stage that utilizes a VLM to
extract and articulate visual information in textual form, and a reasoning
stage that formulates responses based on the extracted visual information using
a Large Language Model (LLM). This modular design enables the systematic
comparison and assessment of both proprietary and open-source VLM for their
perception and reasoning strengths. Our analytical framework provides several
valuable insights, underscoring Prism's potential as a cost-effective solution
for vision-language tasks. By combining a streamlined VLM focused on perception
with a powerful LLM tailored for reasoning, Prism achieves superior results in
general vision-language tasks while substantially cutting down on training and
operational expenses. Quantitative evaluations show that Prism, when configured
with a vanilla 2B LLaVA and freely accessible GPT-3.5, delivers performance on
par with VLMs $10 \times$ larger on the rigorous multimodal benchmark MMStar.
The project is released at: https://github.com/SparksJoe/Prism. | [
-0.5633266568,
-0.5359130502,
0.5566396713,
0.4520348012,
-0.2664242983,
0.1281109899,
0.0367165692,
-0.6242189407,
-0.2708220184,
0.6534022093,
-0.4514026046,
-0.0396940224,
-0.2701174915,
0.0951257125,
-0.5143493414,
0.2221594453,
-0.061886806,
0.2984428704,
-0.4834390879,
-0.1131165326,
-0.4120037854,
-0.159339577,
-0.2178288549,
-0.451862365,
0.3467471302,
0.1271764189,
0.523211658,
0.3173698485,
0.7148885131,
0.4173834324,
0.0288199075,
0.194932133,
-0.4562270939,
-0.0105635151,
-0.5086609125,
-0.3049559593,
-0.4545534551,
-0.0569675639,
0.6827211976,
0.8040178418,
-0.1234023497,
0.3606875539,
0.2558904588,
0.7630610466,
-0.8486927152,
0.3663368821,
-0.5986133814,
0.1454480588,
-0.1152926385,
-0.1988341808,
-0.4769541025,
0.0929851979,
0.3306893706,
-0.5137217045,
-0.0347424932,
0.2636041045,
0.8599098325,
0.2399825752,
-0.1992209107,
0.2810579836,
-0.6812508106,
0.8160127401,
-0.1264522821,
0.5574777722,
0.0122119961,
0.6644567847,
0.2482792884,
-0.8667157292,
-0.6611123085,
0.057523407,
0.0320744552,
0.284347564,
-0.2484349012,
-0.0460533164,
0.1318923831,
0.5449399948,
-0.8741564155,
-0.2092762887,
-0.7019726634,
-0.2223490775,
0.3782468438,
0.3572225571,
0.3008568585,
-0.3029338717,
-0.7103651762,
0.071985431,
-0.6438849568,
0.0502159633,
-0.0735125467,
0.1168534681,
0.0091419294,
0.7833602428,
-0.5771945715,
0.8227338195,
-0.203227222,
-0.0740088671,
0.3375013471,
-0.4255414605,
-0.6816474199,
-0.2504009008,
0.4805730879,
0.654091239,
0.3038173914,
-0.1481418312,
-0.2851020396,
0.2187934518,
0.2669022977,
-0.703625679,
-0.3375850618,
0.2576777935,
-0.4704625905,
-0.236335516,
-0.2169074267,
-0.736245811,
-0.6426831484,
-0.6971276999,
0.5539934039,
-0.1296932548,
-0.4523597956,
0.3653878868,
-0.3208313286,
0.6976093054,
0.6903868318,
-0.6465253234,
0.0354233682,
0.8135489821,
0.5818946958,
-0.2879975736,
-0.3771199882,
-0.5138324499,
-0.1452531815,
-0.5018255711,
0.7690225244,
-0.511035502,
-0.0763066486,
-0.1757865399,
-0.0479701571,
-0.0241275094,
-0.7495337725,
-0.0445939042,
-0.4977817833,
0.435490489,
-0.3803381324,
-0.1639758497,
-0.188666746,
0.6000261307,
-0.5843652487,
0.9710578918,
0.398475796,
-0.6881694794,
0.6875375509,
-0.2738974094,
0.4267309904,
0.7381923795,
-0.4867274165,
-0.1069910601,
0.0399384052,
0.1972186565,
0.1365643442,
-0.6844579577,
0.258123219,
-0.3800840676,
-0.2529808581,
0.2026751935,
-0.3677123189,
0.9109292626,
0.1805350929,
-0.3462596834,
0.3684801757,
-0.98029387,
0.4315306842,
0.0562803037,
-0.3258802593,
-0.1334553808,
-0.013101276,
0.109979324,
0.1791541129,
0.2146772295,
-0.3377957642,
0.0535459109,
-0.4616657495,
0.216193825,
0.6644397378,
-0.2400597334,
0.5155425072,
0.107578136,
0.4308367968,
0.0589516088,
0.5437709093,
-0.0368672088,
-0.4979166687,
-1.0934402943,
-0.3246834278,
-0.0165614896,
0.7573716044,
-1.2554569244,
-0.1819811761,
-0.1290243417,
-0.3266247213,
-0.4431182146,
0.2895359397,
0.5482304692,
0.665151298,
0.5304769874,
-0.4182640612,
-0.4812076688,
-1.00139606,
-0.2055812925,
-0.287709862,
-0.2633316815,
-0.0001286494,
0.5432731509,
-0.0407761633,
1.2020941973,
-0.2797228396,
-0.1484290063,
-0.5796049237,
-0.1827590019,
0.004681617,
0.2045255154,
0.5195999742,
-1.1628465652,
-0.3975000381,
0.0772208348,
-1.1001149416,
-0.3396973312,
-0.0101511665,
-0.0759390146,
-0.0157012269,
0.4426145256,
-0.2607322037,
0.5887077451,
0.4546028376,
-0.6256955266,
0.7397474051,
-0.0180515405,
-0.0255390517,
-0.4992048442,
0.1364397258,
-0.1185798198,
-0.2484917045,
-0.6503243446,
0.2933944166,
0.1634802818,
-0.1864684075,
-0.8142296672,
0.6340084672,
-0.6505196095,
-0.3058016896,
-0.1381381303,
0.2823200524,
0.4438084066,
0.4761773348,
0.0484536402,
0.744913578,
0.8283293247,
-0.3642370999,
0.6908450127,
0.1002891958,
-0.6988433599,
0.8705747724,
-0.8152409196,
-0.4066395164,
-0.3500433862,
-0.303622365,
-0.7270967364,
-0.0147886723,
0.50023067,
-0.1089103147,
-0.1079226211,
-0.0392294414,
-0.1586987823,
-0.3445930779,
-0.2217654139,
0.3984264135,
0.3080836833,
-0.528308332,
0.9612030387,
0.2739413679,
-0.1926297992,
-0.6780717969,
-0.6891809106,
0.3532579839,
-0.1434994787,
-0.7527889609,
-0.0306660496,
-0.0788043365,
-0.7266207337,
0.0846267641,
-0.1058870181,
-0.1421300322,
0.04642836,
0.155084461,
0.4576073885,
-0.4070809782,
0.0123030255,
-0.3176796138,
-0.4931648076,
-0.0834982544,
-0.3884016275,
0.4592705071,
-0.6660236716,
-0.6269580126,
-0.0428516008,
0.3238282204,
0.7897782326,
-0.82903862,
0.6360840201,
0.4966904521,
-0.217776522,
-0.4111286402,
-0.5977114439,
0.2092308849,
-0.5226838589,
0.3909721375,
-0.4478640258,
-0.5780997872,
0.2838231325,
-0.044348985,
-0.0772305503,
-0.0020093957,
0.6726813316,
0.1183484718,
0.8138539791,
0.7230048776,
0.4203555584,
0.2844040096,
-0.258421123,
0.3252005279,
-0.9427270293,
-0.6864344478,
-0.0501890108,
-0.121944733,
0.0604446232,
-0.7765756249,
0.3300906122,
0.2588816881,
-0.1710021943,
0.0319134332,
-0.3462408185,
0.6915567517,
0.4449932873,
-0.1490211934,
0.5184090734,
-0.0844551101,
-0.0954853743,
-0.05804573,
-0.5102105737,
-0.481551379,
0.8610524535,
0.2830751836,
0.4907606542,
0.1597220302,
0.2289969474,
-0.0415399671,
0.2048806101,
-0.7123035789,
0.8990243673,
0.1758840084,
-0.4550400376,
-0.2549663186,
-0.3602284193,
-0.51828444,
1.2322547436,
-0.3502342999,
-0.928506434,
0.3507221639,
0.0565670319,
0.0822111219,
0.1762238443,
-0.6809741855,
1.0437015295,
-0.4361322522,
-0.6762526631,
0.0372442305,
-0.424721092,
0.4442049563,
-0.0099901855,
0.0397344269,
-0.2874318659,
0.0062556579,
0.1820527613,
-0.2275350988,
0.6427291036,
-0.0394102558,
-0.0552638508,
0.2225364,
0.1979097426,
-0.1433974802,
0.0185385942,
0.146192193,
0.1635002643,
-0.0174675789,
-0.3164594769,
-0.7257243395,
0.2393531501,
-0.2375737727,
-0.5324623585,
-0.2978148758,
-0.4352392852,
-0.3351922631,
0.5093196034,
0.1318746507,
0.7296774983,
-0.1114986241,
0.4120308161,
0.5679044724,
-0.2656652927,
0.2711354196,
0.6922240853,
-0.9540598392,
-0.2729320228,
1.0419642925,
-0.1746648401,
0.5060560107,
0.3527483046,
0.1800151914,
-0.3268236816,
-0.6039515734,
-0.5783262849,
-0.0306454767,
-0.8729045391,
0.0461460166,
-0.238730818,
-0.1125250161,
-0.0900678188,
-0.0705809891,
-0.4780852497,
-0.2036063224,
0.0905468091,
-0.0537795909,
-0.3328889906,
0.4417975247,
0.1256868988,
-0.1192554012,
-0.5155857801,
0.5459951758,
0.5495456457,
0.4034756422,
-0.1038796902,
-0.0173113327,
0.0539446399,
-0.1374553591,
-0.2289588451,
-0.6959067583,
0.4696744382,
0.0802292079,
0.6248478293,
0.5096210241,
-0.0099549424,
0.6502444744,
-0.4435742199,
0.9169467092,
0.4666133523,
-1.005739212,
0.4756993353,
-0.0867964625,
0.3141940534,
0.4255733192,
-0.0791866258,
-0.3846856058,
-0.4637826383,
-0.2018553019,
-0.9440021515,
0.4539279342,
0.2195210904,
-0.4284110665,
0.2769517899,
-0.1026820317,
-0.117419295,
0.3377669454,
-0.8205858469,
-0.0668587238,
-0.2562638819,
0.0051146178,
-0.0595891029,
-0.3168651462,
-0.4235908091,
-0.3952773213,
0.2011209875,
-0.2571472228,
-0.1488448679,
0.1147040054,
-0.3744170964,
0.2660755515,
0.1770250499,
0.3171468079,
1.1474809647,
0.0848142579,
0.2919768393,
0.1468061656,
-0.33991763,
-0.169252485,
-0.2756807804,
-0.1834371537,
-0.2516044974,
0.5529356003,
0.6859694719,
0.2581861913,
-0.9998711348,
0.7357241511,
-0.2289182097,
-0.291353941,
-0.0864947662,
-0.0041509741,
0.1020189375,
0.6114096045,
0.2333477587,
0.0608055033,
0.2502651811,
-0.4444452226,
0.1995411217,
0.3929631114,
-0.3346740007,
-0.078899242,
0.4910213053,
0.4313070178,
-0.0231997352,
0.677513361,
-0.0101037528,
-0.6780907512,
0.4710451066,
0.2616273463,
0.7476062775,
0.0224013776,
0.4246706665,
0.0145487888,
0.5732406974,
-0.0326019824,
0.4047121704,
-0.181515798,
-0.7410861254,
-0.3570052385,
-0.7458689213,
-0.4088280797,
-0.010874291,
-0.6146919727,
0.1532215774,
-0.2634332776,
0.2151928991,
-0.3348393142,
-0.1667856276,
-0.5661650896,
0.1543110758,
0.3778964579,
0.9383201599,
-0.7405420542,
0.5493961573,
0.3543877304,
-0.5140554309,
-0.6518620253,
-0.4140058756,
0.3497968912,
-0.8839885592,
0.888691783,
0.2876028419,
-0.4573406577,
-0.4032823145,
-0.2022181749,
-0.6595652103,
1.132189393,
0.5292111635,
-0.4111487865,
-0.009323285,
0.3129600883,
0.4768610299,
-0.2716175914,
0.0291920118,
0.6203353405,
0.4396619201,
0.2576938868,
-1.1956723928,
-0.2452389747,
-0.4730789363,
0.0621277951,
0.1591698229,
-0.3498420715,
1.0637600422,
-0.1175076514,
-0.5074948072,
-0.011301538,
0.4384303093,
0.1579681784,
0.4725958705,
0.3675117195,
0.432733953,
0.6552615166,
-0.2658786774,
0.8417612314,
-0.1753425151,
0.413043201,
0.8817107677,
-0.4082684219,
0.9181607366,
0.750227809,
0.0136759952,
0.26887995,
0.09740448,
-0.0834092423,
0.4864622355,
0.1668992192,
-0.2089570761,
-0.6533116102,
0.203797996,
-0.4831658006,
0.7146984339,
0.301068902,
-0.1415387243,
-0.4898129106,
0.2521807849,
-0.5669482946,
0.0463815555,
-0.4235247076,
0.5523197651,
0.1288089454,
-0.5254378915,
0.4752117097,
-0.4005942047,
0.2165237367,
-0.596773684,
-0.1421907991,
-0.0753744245,
0.5857110023,
-0.1908693314,
-0.8677885532,
0.3674193025,
-0.0420795046,
-0.0593880601,
-0.5061693192,
0.6695263386,
-0.4335104823,
-0.5387502909,
0.3753481209,
0.7213202119,
-0.0276600327,
-0.1854718179,
-0.7309042215,
0.4467277825,
-0.1144001856,
-0.3006187379,
0.2660425007,
0.3454248309,
0.0762408972,
1.2064914703,
0.5012849569,
0.1867191195,
0.0971808061,
0.091423057,
0.8750298619,
-0.3763390183,
-0.3700443506,
-0.6350841522,
0.9003098607,
-0.3022923768,
-0.2844069004,
0.8177497983,
0.5926544666,
0.8809894323,
-0.0911446139,
0.6172543764,
0.0127376132,
0.2862047851,
-0.7158760428,
0.6182172298,
-0.9400600791,
0.4873181581,
-0.2444605678,
-1.0495111942,
-0.4149864018,
0.7981694341,
-0.395039022,
-0.2723066807,
0.6736377478,
0.7123475671,
-0.0574754328,
-0.1347796768,
0.4886726737,
-0.1026210785,
0.6474729776,
0.6413958073,
1.0489610434,
-0.0720556751,
0.6351265311,
0.0030564773,
-0.4650624394,
-0.1207430139,
-0.8577797413,
-0.8134071827,
-0.6753737926,
-0.1913583428,
-0.0961547047,
-0.205034107,
0.3805067539,
0.4863844216,
-0.3535941839,
-0.1572571248,
-0.0073996922,
0.0595175475,
-0.2340038568,
-0.2618978024,
-0.0018686219,
-0.1856656075,
-0.5649900436,
0.4293059409,
0.8663294911,
-0.1797341704,
-0.6775537133,
-0.0278890599,
0.3608263433,
0.0735863596,
0.9314058423,
0.2811841071,
-0.8992167115,
-0.298882246,
0.0459262729,
-0.0810075253,
-0.1209804788,
0.6917482018,
-0.919359684,
0.8296406269,
0.7355175018,
0.3922178447,
0.2418839782,
-0.0406761393,
0.5906576514,
-0.1764630824,
0.2894620597,
0.197273612,
0.5848712325,
0.3213204741,
0.2314489633,
0.4896532595,
0.2838085592,
-0.1195260957,
-1.0434753895,
0.6698716879,
-1.2251224518,
-0.3968333006,
0.8899906874,
0.0696651638,
-0.3273646235,
-0.2790881395,
-0.4068532288,
-0.5865162015,
0.3168035448,
0.5419062376,
0.5966120958,
-0.1255037487,
-0.4337845445,
-0.3603763878,
0.2173446566,
0.1932099909,
-0.7059867978,
0.1599923074,
0.6071305275,
0.2420746684,
0.3379366398,
0.6463515759,
-0.3443992138,
0.3538142741,
0.3874005973,
-0.0862473175,
-0.4019587636,
-0.7537912726,
-0.2461607158,
0.6361929178,
-0.0880342126,
-0.1399368197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14532v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14532v1 | RL on Incorrect Synthetic Data Scales the Efficiency of LLM Math Reasoning by Eight-Fold | 2024-06-20T17:45:54 | 2024-06-20T17:45:54 | Amrith Setlur, Saurabh Garg, Xinyang Geng, Naman Garg, Virginia Smith, Aviral Kumar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Training on model-generated synthetic data is a promising approach for
finetuning LLMs, but it remains unclear when it helps or hurts. In this paper,
we investigate this question for math reasoning via an empirical study,
followed by building a conceptual understanding of our observations. First, we
find that while the typical approach of finetuning a model on synthetic correct
or positive problem-solution pairs generated by capable models offers modest
performance gains, sampling more correct solutions from the finetuned learner
itself followed by subsequent fine-tuning on this self-generated data
$\textbf{doubles}$ the efficiency of the same synthetic problems. At the same
time, training on model-generated positives can amplify various spurious
correlations, resulting in flat or even inverse scaling trends as the amount of
data increases. Surprisingly, we find that several of these issues can be
addressed if we also utilize negative responses, i.e., model-generated
responses that are deemed incorrect by a final answer verifier. Crucially,
these negatives must be constructed such that the training can appropriately
recover the utility or advantage of each intermediate step in the negative
response. With this per-step scheme, we are able to attain consistent gains
over only positive data, attaining performance similar to amplifying the amount
of synthetic data by $\mathbf{8 \times}$. We show that training on per-step
negatives can help to unlearn spurious correlations in the positive data, and
is equivalent to advantage-weighted reinforcement learning (RL), implying that
it inherits robustness benefits of RL over imitating positive data alone. | [
-0.3957817852,
-0.8994311094,
0.5303574204,
0.0652082115,
-0.0914770737,
-0.0427649915,
-0.1258109957,
-0.2962869406,
-0.0098566171,
0.4018638432,
-0.6708365083,
-0.0844058096,
-0.4777904153,
0.1692996323,
-0.4015114307,
1.1626656055,
0.1317678243,
0.4832360446,
-0.2526940703,
-0.2405782789,
-0.3959523439,
-0.6442258358,
-0.7717658281,
-0.5373713374,
0.7242982388,
0.5776429772,
0.6958422065,
0.7360447645,
0.6402752995,
0.2093743831,
0.1905176789,
0.3144216537,
-0.8982024789,
0.1119413674,
-0.171821788,
-0.8478559256,
-0.4788711369,
0.2996222675,
0.3707490265,
0.6076796651,
-0.1115190536,
0.3834560215,
0.0692752451,
0.7250000834,
-0.4669599533,
-0.1314379126,
-0.8339136243,
0.2050886154,
-0.0094660828,
-0.4266474843,
-0.4740675688,
-0.3237125576,
-0.2440396547,
-0.8129401207,
0.4649064541,
-0.1576613784,
0.6100981832,
0.4454846978,
-0.284243077,
-0.3860858679,
-0.8598347306,
0.942384541,
-0.7118838429,
0.3977820277,
0.2644046247,
0.4633381963,
-0.1383522153,
-0.4050973952,
-0.5578273535,
-0.2307254374,
0.0728975832,
0.1947817504,
0.2612856627,
-0.1965869516,
0.7376833558,
0.4285206199,
-0.1708529741,
0.1228732243,
-0.5075542331,
-0.3212468028,
0.9077827334,
0.4418802261,
0.1808850765,
0.0632340461,
-0.4087065458,
-0.3179047406,
-0.9927832484,
0.0852440298,
0.5708833933,
0.7218905687,
-0.1004752889,
0.9292234778,
0.1377778798,
0.5839157104,
0.3387316763,
-0.1955530494,
0.1382226497,
-0.3381597102,
-0.237015456,
-0.0115588903,
0.3809631467,
0.0433943532,
0.5095436573,
-0.0841484964,
-0.5559230447,
0.3546760976,
0.4609441161,
-0.8012889028,
-0.1564487666,
0.0156922136,
0.0029491694,
-0.4722832143,
-0.1539571583,
-0.4482423961,
-0.4049408436,
-0.956161797,
0.803149581,
-0.3260930777,
0.0240294412,
0.2530865073,
-0.0502085015,
0.1914257705,
0.497638762,
-0.5917218924,
0.3502446711,
0.7844780087,
0.5365429521,
0.069384791,
-0.1395207196,
-0.8428750634,
-0.4097971618,
-0.6757743955,
0.6999666691,
-0.0954101011,
-0.3272156715,
-0.2728544772,
-0.308811456,
0.0385493711,
-0.8280696273,
0.615732789,
-0.472933054,
0.0708215982,
-0.3214899898,
-0.5160766244,
0.0568052791,
0.5062606335,
-0.4624225795,
0.6517472863,
-0.0943778902,
-0.4569835961,
0.4404001534,
-0.3552076221,
-0.4356304705,
-0.3131746948,
-0.135313645,
-0.798327446,
0.2466788441,
-0.0125088608,
0.2488219738,
-0.2276296467,
0.03628603,
-0.7345940471,
-0.3929721415,
0.5082785487,
-0.6550084949,
0.7775583863,
0.2812211215,
-0.2227477133,
-0.1020216718,
-1.0374205112,
0.1037605628,
0.1430069953,
-0.242387265,
-0.3742273748,
-0.2736940682,
-0.5399045348,
0.2134523243,
-0.0771118626,
-0.6185725927,
0.1045169458,
-0.3459047675,
0.0948642567,
0.9536051154,
0.2135948986,
0.4795461595,
-0.6234225631,
0.4460608661,
0.0906989276,
0.0406411625,
0.1783188432,
-0.2055024058,
-0.9421011806,
-0.0821047425,
0.1972322464,
0.4566364884,
-0.5245215297,
-0.1027472243,
0.0234420188,
-0.4345373511,
-0.4295367301,
0.2257919461,
0.406588614,
0.8396283984,
0.6356990933,
-0.0912956148,
-0.4836319089,
-0.7937383056,
-0.5293365717,
0.2155854404,
0.0748205781,
0.3450941145,
0.4156734943,
0.0675495937,
0.6471287012,
-0.3900962174,
-0.1762232184,
-0.0072941049,
0.4136537313,
0.3059904575,
0.5322276354,
0.2671173811,
-0.6847708225,
-0.5825780034,
-0.2781727612,
-0.7039076686,
-0.0933786333,
-0.4514683783,
-0.2705652416,
-0.0105912983,
0.2158479989,
-0.5512984991,
0.3191328943,
0.1326013058,
-0.2334527224,
0.750539422,
-0.2554235458,
-0.0232226364,
-0.6315641403,
-0.1646433622,
0.2519068718,
-0.1876751482,
-0.627571404,
-0.0605259798,
0.0784144625,
-0.0408507623,
-0.3006297648,
0.437253356,
-0.2785473168,
-0.0597543381,
-0.0652300864,
0.0261532255,
-0.0441721417,
0.4520080984,
-0.2581831515,
0.9998295903,
0.2202352881,
-0.8220321536,
0.1846430004,
-0.0839352757,
0.105531849,
0.7854448557,
-0.5567432642,
0.0610200353,
-0.1249497756,
0.0034271819,
-0.8689119816,
-0.066498071,
0.0750474706,
-0.6274560094,
0.3356266618,
-0.0155299185,
-0.1982210577,
-0.226998046,
-0.3468129337,
0.4696623087,
0.5775036216,
-0.7143104672,
0.4757988751,
0.0202253256,
0.4600677788,
-0.6937409043,
-0.7943799496,
-0.3476925194,
-0.4754367769,
-0.4867209494,
0.0206575412,
-0.2601673901,
-0.5319622159,
-0.1380634755,
-0.4196824729,
-0.0139942039,
0.266784966,
0.0356660821,
0.2969970703,
-0.2584062517,
0.1437309831,
-0.2530842423,
-0.202118203,
0.3915362358,
-0.0829303712,
0.318061471,
-0.0328897424,
-0.4419183433,
-0.3811404705,
-0.227373898,
0.5742715597,
0.0419663675,
0.6138828397,
0.4266116321,
-0.1619709879,
-0.417660743,
-0.2511283457,
-0.5461321473,
-0.435983032,
-0.0804844722,
-0.5188003778,
-0.3765701652,
0.58705163,
0.113614507,
0.2407442927,
0.5644709468,
0.4376978576,
-0.1950844824,
1.2012938261,
0.1831212491,
0.475712657,
0.3280956745,
-0.6116185784,
0.2588676512,
-0.7905225158,
-0.0328738093,
-0.274900794,
-0.4069310129,
-0.5260984898,
-0.4127920568,
0.5100785494,
0.1582676619,
-0.7279186249,
0.1595013142,
-0.3250367343,
0.3442915082,
0.5252111554,
0.4582293332,
0.3333187401,
-0.025792148,
-0.0355720483,
-0.196054697,
-0.6672986746,
-0.145697996,
1.3504319191,
0.1881264746,
1.1209418774,
0.0942701772,
0.8188871741,
0.1269798428,
0.6221901774,
-0.9094712734,
0.3862528503,
-0.0846913382,
-0.4984264076,
-0.295019716,
-0.7068699002,
-0.6752948761,
0.2675742507,
-0.4721212089,
-0.0496540442,
0.1747428626,
0.5519756079,
-0.4157931507,
0.2837527394,
-0.8726606965,
0.6469714642,
-0.4053186178,
-0.7347294092,
-0.3388704658,
-0.4721429646,
0.5767963529,
-0.169904992,
0.3092319667,
0.0623040795,
0.2678299844,
0.4046613574,
-0.6698265672,
0.7913708091,
-0.254018724,
-0.2457283139,
0.4367925227,
0.4216536283,
0.7154909968,
0.2739754617,
0.0753894895,
-0.1312707216,
-0.2645371854,
-0.4620015323,
-1.1054435968,
0.5713381171,
-0.799693644,
-0.7324013114,
-0.2584584951,
-0.608340919,
-0.3608113527,
0.0519852042,
0.1006173342,
0.7744274735,
0.363547951,
0.1698358059,
0.7751312852,
0.0147971325,
-0.229463324,
0.4547143281,
-0.1763586998,
-0.3907720745,
1.0972384214,
0.3844440281,
0.7349521518,
0.3166704774,
0.3839875162,
-0.3932371438,
-0.2257815748,
-0.3955780566,
0.4126845598,
-0.6609016657,
-0.4905712306,
-0.2160928696,
-0.4237658083,
-0.1516158432,
-0.1459529251,
-0.6132113934,
-0.7109084725,
-0.3162150681,
-0.1618870497,
0.186598748,
0.5540845394,
-0.4971536696,
-0.166773662,
-0.4393523633,
0.3946321607,
0.3570742309,
0.1291311383,
0.195518285,
-0.8012273908,
-0.1803045571,
0.4837529063,
-0.4093487263,
-0.407156229,
0.1492331326,
0.0084015736,
0.4259710908,
0.1829497069,
0.2359230518,
0.9876995087,
-0.3702022135,
0.5375855565,
0.1315983236,
-0.5127160549,
0.1661535054,
-0.2715952694,
0.1028564274,
0.302726388,
0.4331658185,
-0.2940891087,
-0.3876196742,
-0.7922478318,
-0.5456116199,
0.3703017533,
0.0074644503,
0.2864921987,
0.1116053388,
0.6522613764,
0.1285484582,
-0.0471254252,
-0.7960939407,
-0.2879626751,
-0.2270731479,
-0.1474291682,
-0.0928077474,
-0.0531115569,
-0.3322658837,
-0.3210237026,
0.8886605501,
-0.08581613,
0.1440415531,
0.2628084421,
-0.0855891332,
-0.2973106503,
0.2464065999,
0.6743631959,
0.5427977443,
-0.1428490281,
0.352794826,
0.2696500719,
-0.2974128723,
0.3366524577,
-0.1806604713,
-0.1445786655,
-0.576974988,
0.3776680827,
0.5908613801,
0.0178044364,
-0.508554697,
0.2891477346,
-0.0026085915,
-0.3677699864,
-0.3116462231,
0.3312667608,
-0.165784806,
0.2080771029,
0.3091241419,
0.4081402123,
-0.0240131933,
-0.4646273255,
0.2351603359,
0.5934749842,
-0.176133424,
-0.4222985506,
0.5235579014,
-0.134546414,
-0.416637063,
0.72620821,
-0.2040888816,
-0.458747983,
0.7170788646,
0.8378307819,
0.4025610685,
0.0953161716,
0.2192947119,
0.8222003579,
-0.0372419171,
-0.0254753269,
0.1457297802,
-0.1529066861,
-0.9640015364,
-0.4544149339,
-0.5075312853,
-0.3666467071,
0.2156139314,
-0.7536486983,
0.3152707517,
-0.5471552014,
-0.1364518404,
-0.104617998,
0.0053586154,
-0.6929728985,
0.3789520264,
-0.0268630609,
0.698731184,
-0.7594287992,
0.4001757205,
0.505141139,
-0.5658587217,
-1.1785541773,
-0.1925255209,
0.0975666642,
-1.1133505106,
0.8538880944,
-0.0739719272,
-0.3449651599,
0.0802521259,
-0.5294557214,
-0.8655911088,
0.8711360693,
0.3422084749,
-0.3919948637,
0.199788928,
0.157842353,
0.7765985131,
-0.1560272574,
0.1389626116,
0.2940726578,
0.2270210534,
0.3134631515,
-0.5626796484,
0.0235530958,
-0.0348509848,
-0.2058102041,
0.2679253519,
-0.4684881866,
1.0876243114,
-0.5565112829,
-0.3405295014,
-0.0221233126,
0.3510533869,
0.3635543585,
0.2758229077,
0.4492481649,
0.9818435311,
0.579223752,
0.1430645138,
0.9980822206,
-0.2203453332,
0.5976151824,
1.0932890177,
0.043541085,
0.5841042399,
0.5442015529,
-0.360715121,
0.3766264617,
0.4823710322,
0.1581917703,
0.4649401307,
0.4046422839,
-0.213118434,
-0.6542388201,
0.0880413353,
-0.2486124337,
0.1171651259,
0.3237170279,
-0.1155782044,
-0.5356323719,
-0.1289059669,
-0.1351991296,
0.3822597563,
-0.4171514809,
0.4798516631,
0.3190537095,
-0.5526980758,
0.8139599562,
-0.2641739845,
0.5496233106,
-0.4859886467,
-0.2436233312,
-0.4101160169,
0.511397481,
-0.2722189128,
-0.7489354014,
0.4745517671,
-0.0909531936,
-0.173209697,
-0.1835363656,
0.6203634143,
-0.3374731243,
-0.4770387113,
-0.1112507805,
0.5022636056,
-0.0204508845,
0.3228530586,
-0.7048432231,
-0.2211883962,
-0.0348297469,
0.018085584,
0.4305492043,
0.5116009116,
0.0204945728,
0.7898509502,
0.8940954208,
0.2086338997,
0.0608265288,
0.1870982051,
0.6559994221,
-0.4260137081,
-0.2260177881,
-0.9017475843,
0.5222095251,
-0.0575969815,
-0.2618689537,
0.9215167761,
0.5829910636,
1.0207045078,
0.0661865026,
0.4420014322,
0.3053896427,
0.6876192093,
-0.5533812046,
0.2117121667,
-0.6839529872,
0.4201544225,
0.1407869309,
-0.7115930915,
-0.4840768874,
0.7083287835,
-0.6521129608,
-0.0237278137,
0.424403131,
0.8440324664,
-0.3563055396,
-0.1375810057,
0.3157265186,
0.3541526794,
0.4533973932,
0.3687107563,
0.8334803581,
-0.4563894272,
0.2499735206,
-0.3916705847,
-0.0393598713,
-0.0072723776,
-0.5789265633,
-0.6092700362,
-0.1961309463,
-0.0913490206,
-0.6846639514,
-0.0930879414,
0.9720350504,
0.4449670017,
-0.7121961713,
-0.2961359918,
-0.4996838272,
0.2238512039,
-0.2523652911,
-0.2935899198,
0.0553248972,
-0.8171055913,
-0.3806068003,
0.1106253713,
0.0080823908,
0.2532882094,
-0.4422726929,
-0.1954544038,
0.1479965597,
0.3522933424,
0.5163834691,
0.3795094788,
-0.3649552464,
-0.4188608825,
0.0213030353,
-0.2392388135,
0.2782987654,
0.9562829137,
-0.6970914602,
0.3911732435,
0.314545095,
0.7442374825,
0.5931931734,
0.2695941031,
0.6464676261,
-0.5330094099,
-0.0861007273,
0.2529357374,
0.1061508954,
0.3471274674,
-0.4970686734,
0.5436372757,
0.432398051,
-0.689941287,
-1.0114051104,
0.2762590647,
-0.6303934455,
-0.0689259917,
1.1421797276,
0.012938885,
-0.1955817789,
0.2696828246,
-0.1213221997,
0.0872922465,
-0.2151867896,
0.9550722837,
0.433075428,
-0.7339800596,
0.1579119414,
-0.4490298927,
0.5162204504,
0.5810860395,
-0.5083518624,
0.0542758442,
0.5560209751,
0.5152419209,
0.2337717414,
0.4369830191,
-0.0155082727,
0.2918242216,
0.1500972509,
-0.4637990892,
-0.1373762339,
-0.3673841953,
-0.2826503515,
-0.0936163887,
0.195342198,
0.1040374786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14517v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14517v1 | PostMark: A Robust Blackbox Watermark for Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T17:27:14 | 2024-06-20T17:27:14 | Yapei Chang, Kalpesh Krishna, Amir Houmansadr, John Wieting, Mohit Iyyer | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | The most effective techniques to detect LLM-generated text rely on inserting
a detectable signature -- or watermark -- during the model's decoding process.
Most existing watermarking methods require access to the underlying LLM's
logits, which LLM API providers are loath to share due to fears of model
distillation. As such, these watermarks must be implemented independently by
each LLM provider. In this paper, we develop PostMark, a modular post-hoc
watermarking procedure in which an input-dependent set of words (determined via
a semantic embedding) is inserted into the text after the decoding process has
completed. Critically, PostMark does not require logit access, which means it
can be implemented by a third party. We also show that PostMark is more robust
to paraphrasing attacks than existing watermarking methods: our experiments
cover eight baseline algorithms, five base LLMs, and three datasets. Finally,
we evaluate the impact of PostMark on text quality using both automated and
human assessments, highlighting the trade-off between quality and robustness to
paraphrasing. We release our code, outputs, and annotations at
https://github.com/lilakk/PostMark. | [
-0.166593641,
-0.896527946,
0.6802957654,
0.3287084401,
-0.8331777453,
0.0804546475,
0.132907182,
-0.3976993263,
0.106045939,
0.9110369682,
-0.2341537476,
-0.8169936538,
-0.9491047859,
-0.0261310805,
-0.6703933477,
0.7990868688,
-0.0859554484,
-0.2293722779,
-0.3310012221,
-0.291742295,
-0.2937057316,
-0.764359951,
-0.4353785217,
-0.1748263985,
0.3513393998,
-0.204554975,
0.628605783,
0.8561697602,
0.4031976163,
0.1775186211,
-0.3224653602,
0.2669500411,
-0.211781621,
0.2945771813,
-0.3502852023,
-0.3791838586,
-0.4633516967,
-0.2692933679,
0.658569932,
0.2145901322,
0.0925144628,
0.1914195716,
0.2936296165,
0.1320857704,
-0.907618165,
0.2061114758,
-0.9050415754,
-0.1463564932,
-0.4470690787,
-0.2075643092,
-0.286873728,
-0.1849798858,
-0.1686159968,
-0.3939283788,
-0.0708092079,
0.2827653885,
0.9518197775,
0.306461364,
-0.1921986341,
-0.3965990245,
-0.6750110388,
0.7949575782,
-1.0287708044,
0.1635321677,
0.6147703528,
0.0591412261,
-0.1024327949,
-0.7412217855,
-0.5330550671,
0.1212906018,
0.0020828508,
-0.0581356771,
-0.3286908567,
-0.1857075393,
0.2865146697,
0.37433213,
-0.3806736171,
-0.1105266511,
0.0468866527,
-0.3704805374,
0.3714526594,
0.2387289703,
0.4316129088,
-0.041716285,
-0.3690778911,
0.0843491182,
-0.9957758188,
0.0475980826,
0.3889814317,
0.2914312482,
0.056986697,
0.5418072343,
-0.2267250121,
0.6324757934,
-0.2017578781,
-0.027078012,
-0.1855208874,
-0.2039463371,
-0.0148270717,
0.0374724306,
0.9247042537,
0.191010043,
0.1121598259,
-0.1130676568,
-0.6147690415,
0.100191623,
0.1762012243,
-0.8470863104,
-0.2128003985,
0.0360219926,
-0.2996251881,
-0.3490296006,
0.1343518794,
-0.7303654552,
-0.5374100804,
-0.0971476361,
0.7363579273,
-0.104811281,
-0.2782017887,
0.187437728,
0.0850049406,
0.1860852093,
0.1013526097,
-0.7929801345,
0.468041718,
0.9799093604,
0.8980349898,
-0.2517059147,
-0.1966060251,
-0.8175305724,
0.4199714661,
-0.2963733673,
1.2157149315,
-0.7466087937,
-0.3837575614,
0.1933095902,
0.0309551191,
0.2106676996,
-0.6900734305,
0.3472605944,
-0.6436752677,
0.0829102248,
-0.1927499473,
-0.8507151008,
-0.0103620505,
0.3064907193,
-0.7380641103,
1.1474279165,
-0.1418928355,
-0.9819515944,
0.1964294314,
-0.2179831415,
-0.5010695457,
0.2813733816,
-0.072103411,
-0.7191982269,
0.1732515544,
0.4129210114,
0.4678881466,
-0.2536992729,
0.1469727904,
-0.3076601624,
-0.3903615773,
0.4710019827,
-0.1601051986,
0.4541863799,
-0.2719724774,
-0.4207769036,
0.1747721434,
-0.8066911101,
0.031391535,
0.1254212856,
-0.4591228366,
-0.5049419999,
0.1441502571,
0.0033954692,
0.0217806492,
0.4540362358,
-0.4848428667,
-0.2107039988,
-0.2176835537,
0.5487164855,
0.6604067683,
0.2554496527,
0.1871454418,
-0.5153422952,
0.6455485225,
-0.0733387098,
0.0922809765,
-0.2170587182,
-0.6671075821,
-0.3992395103,
-0.4660491943,
0.341909647,
0.5066532493,
-0.7217171192,
0.5658918023,
-0.2147718966,
-0.4693074524,
-0.4778268337,
0.4905440509,
0.457018286,
0.3889906108,
0.4993880987,
-0.1092574,
-0.2762019634,
-0.870095253,
-0.455126375,
-0.1146925688,
-0.2014632672,
0.0747182295,
0.4959458411,
-0.1479218602,
0.7753069997,
-0.556088686,
-0.1920198649,
-0.1810309589,
0.1658554077,
-0.0434406325,
0.3958834112,
0.2900218964,
-0.552306354,
-0.3213884234,
-0.2611644864,
-0.6371822357,
-0.4739928246,
0.1115297675,
-0.3305707872,
-0.1322159171,
0.6299535632,
-0.7486564517,
0.4380707145,
0.8610254526,
-0.4511305392,
0.6567183137,
-0.1897622645,
0.0771245584,
-1.0150258541,
0.2424913645,
-0.3653514683,
-0.3525446653,
-0.3610461652,
-0.0556384623,
0.178630963,
-0.2109356821,
-0.3260960281,
0.753290534,
-0.344959259,
0.0734162182,
-0.6733264327,
-0.1309325844,
0.309771657,
0.1775925159,
0.0755500272,
0.6029017568,
0.4798804522,
-0.3233799934,
0.2075962275,
0.189587146,
-0.5454410911,
0.7648773193,
-0.8892030716,
0.307720989,
0.0305739623,
0.1400376409,
-1.119566083,
0.157711193,
0.4189218879,
-0.1486809999,
0.049429249,
-0.2164713889,
-0.8640750647,
0.1053315997,
-0.3505868614,
0.1587252617,
0.5514690876,
-0.3679082692,
0.482480377,
0.2253100425,
-0.2904876173,
-0.2385463864,
-0.758138299,
0.3230489194,
-0.359295398,
-0.3859186769,
0.3931143284,
-0.0854709819,
-0.0773450807,
0.1343927085,
-0.2033501714,
-0.312058717,
0.3036781549,
0.3056870401,
0.0868408978,
-0.2521708906,
-0.2292157859,
0.1839972585,
-0.4165872633,
-0.0168402214,
-0.3609578609,
0.3908205628,
0.265953213,
-0.3773772418,
-0.5474147797,
0.5426568985,
0.6031833887,
-0.4954829514,
0.5806450248,
0.3079322577,
-0.7682004571,
-0.559543848,
-0.5503320694,
-0.1935700327,
-0.4938638806,
-0.0378054343,
-0.0807148069,
-0.7966701388,
0.4055590332,
0.029780155,
0.0941465124,
0.1141628399,
0.3101671934,
-0.1962055713,
0.6399935484,
0.4303358495,
-0.0155618582,
0.5419977903,
0.2191828787,
0.2248627245,
-0.7300508618,
0.0237705242,
-0.4557034671,
-0.1620986462,
0.0083150016,
-0.6134780049,
-0.2227190584,
0.496296078,
0.1014637575,
0.533968389,
-0.5160909295,
0.4366277456,
0.5876412392,
0.1136235967,
0.5181987882,
0.1261835098,
-0.0995500237,
-0.2340568453,
-0.2410801649,
-0.8702309132,
0.8866313696,
0.0373325832,
0.6780306697,
-0.2095689774,
0.8389548659,
0.32293576,
0.3837836087,
-0.3668857515,
0.6909558773,
0.0209474768,
-0.571577251,
-0.047463797,
-0.2445325851,
-0.9468386173,
0.1865621358,
-0.2953689396,
-0.6879320741,
-0.1737470627,
0.2100786418,
-0.3001415133,
0.4031476378,
-0.1761831939,
0.8283384442,
-0.1957015842,
-0.4373430014,
-0.0145760197,
-0.2731752992,
-0.1009347588,
-0.3167869747,
0.3834868371,
-0.4407289326,
-0.3455369174,
0.8307582736,
-0.4274185598,
0.7328172922,
-0.27839607,
-0.2748081088,
0.3347314894,
0.401384294,
0.7566611171,
0.037899401,
-0.0336299501,
0.2594925463,
0.1671614796,
-0.4650996327,
-0.4596633613,
0.562636137,
-0.2968689501,
-0.6600472331,
-0.2170731872,
-0.3340666294,
-0.2071785927,
0.3911944032,
0.2364079654,
0.5088421702,
0.1585433483,
0.2665959001,
0.6224890947,
-0.457185775,
0.5338262916,
0.5009893775,
-0.1255599856,
-0.7268440723,
1.0101928711,
0.1069151908,
0.0890218094,
0.4777455032,
0.4267136157,
-0.3535336852,
-1.1226785183,
-0.3851466179,
0.3466955721,
-0.8309428096,
-0.2795861959,
-0.6324615479,
-0.1925076246,
-0.063416101,
-0.3045399189,
-0.4535486996,
-0.1369042993,
-0.2144815773,
-0.003525926,
0.3285110295,
0.8188043237,
0.2361523211,
0.4599675238,
-0.8743937016,
0.3388537169,
0.347938031,
0.3065032661,
-0.0932226628,
-0.4883001745,
-0.0818768889,
-0.0622588657,
-0.2580358088,
-0.5499428511,
0.1033611223,
0.1693748087,
0.5761762261,
0.4846922457,
0.2526188195,
0.3798027337,
-0.455981195,
0.8706489801,
0.0339137875,
-1.1516396999,
0.5430793762,
-0.407589972,
0.5332467556,
0.4291844666,
0.1286443025,
-0.2140521854,
-1.0153264999,
-0.3732917309,
-0.9814431071,
0.3578788936,
0.1809286624,
0.4543420672,
-0.0236461312,
0.2668453157,
0.145809263,
0.4339278936,
-1.0086841583,
-0.1016439274,
-0.0622739866,
-0.2751660645,
0.0819926783,
-0.7402668595,
-0.0574789234,
0.0832680762,
0.3958898187,
0.1340561509,
-0.0477294661,
-0.0608269386,
-0.440766871,
0.2072537988,
0.2307932526,
0.4852669239,
0.7028297782,
0.0084165279,
0.5743680596,
0.0447924845,
-0.2206897885,
0.1796052009,
0.0309572183,
-0.3075564504,
0.2538545728,
0.9832462072,
0.4244927466,
0.5197132826,
-0.6277250051,
0.6120311022,
0.1321225911,
-0.3236842155,
0.1873060912,
-0.1363317668,
0.5173377991,
0.2609797716,
0.2852112949,
-0.4218557775,
-0.0584812239,
-0.1453262419,
0.2543790936,
0.2705304325,
-0.2691808343,
-0.5227456689,
0.8897329569,
0.0474345684,
-0.4752063751,
0.1650205106,
0.0475018956,
-0.6224812865,
0.2974102795,
0.5810294151,
0.8594706059,
-0.3726545274,
-0.0083745159,
0.1717533618,
0.3309008777,
-0.2337702811,
0.3751988709,
-0.2604061365,
-0.5600970984,
-0.2421171814,
-0.9414143562,
-0.4757086635,
0.1695134938,
-0.5704733729,
0.2499741465,
-0.8883082867,
-0.0527250133,
0.0085224984,
-0.4013722241,
-0.4125749171,
0.1068400964,
0.4214870334,
0.4805048704,
-0.8250974417,
0.8786303997,
0.6894949675,
0.0855105296,
-0.294714421,
0.1257212311,
-0.0706428587,
-0.796864152,
0.3607392609,
0.2924862206,
-0.2071944624,
0.0020702605,
-0.3345578015,
-0.7598481774,
0.8458927274,
0.4874489903,
-0.4440352619,
0.3128651679,
0.4249870181,
0.5417013764,
-0.0785035864,
-0.2585853338,
0.3169496953,
0.4001950622,
-0.1410945356,
-0.5070457458,
0.5698527694,
-0.1389698386,
0.0692608654,
0.1146839857,
-0.3440389037,
0.6687313318,
0.4573160112,
-0.2841499448,
0.0168571062,
0.2940474451,
0.2406936735,
0.0771278292,
0.4830394685,
0.5484684706,
0.6268369555,
0.0070730252,
0.8780385256,
-0.4099366367,
0.2746205628,
1.084482789,
-0.356390506,
1.1242130995,
0.4703530371,
-0.1321079433,
0.2946022153,
0.3974735141,
-0.1962008029,
0.7506536841,
0.4440329075,
-0.5484012365,
-0.3967500925,
-0.1723985821,
-0.2878144085,
0.1377908885,
0.433970809,
-0.3982588351,
-0.2523566484,
-0.0297843665,
0.1957924515,
0.3061432242,
-0.1012604535,
0.8858316541,
0.4418683648,
-0.3956562281,
0.5504481792,
-0.0380877554,
0.8798811436,
-0.6918686032,
0.1270793378,
-0.2875897884,
0.294782877,
-0.1845026612,
-0.6919716001,
0.6266136765,
-0.0148824239,
-0.0158539806,
-0.4577251673,
0.6329092383,
-0.6311406493,
-0.5507416129,
0.7287515402,
0.3533754945,
0.0131871803,
-0.3608664274,
-0.6570673585,
0.4724126458,
-0.3903617263,
-0.3221877813,
0.1626702994,
0.4505119026,
0.0086640008,
0.5477586985,
0.6646299362,
0.3545260131,
0.1568275988,
-0.0741842315,
0.6046280861,
-0.6355722547,
-0.5587857366,
-1.3086946011,
0.3524018228,
-0.0710783899,
-0.2260389328,
0.8826896548,
0.4420040846,
0.4625744224,
0.0245854389,
0.9070933461,
0.3348449171,
0.1985126287,
-0.5369404554,
0.8854447007,
-0.4328759909,
0.2256130874,
-0.6547958851,
-1.138314724,
-0.7139126658,
0.3821273148,
-0.2690034509,
-0.4861682951,
0.7922905684,
1.0654718876,
-0.0499640591,
-0.1894890517,
0.5108187795,
-0.2502974868,
0.5091008544,
0.4466484189,
1.1583201885,
-0.3248841763,
0.9240564704,
-0.1290067434,
-0.0670162365,
-0.1278918684,
-1.0132529736,
-1.1440988779,
-0.4039032161,
-0.7824024558,
-0.3645496368,
0.1086174026,
0.3739368916,
0.633464992,
-1.0412318707,
-0.0710397884,
0.0826169178,
0.1928073764,
-0.1362589747,
-0.1431630701,
0.5110442638,
-0.0377436243,
-0.5851281285,
0.2082360089,
0.537951529,
0.3049148917,
0.0615155883,
0.1482812017,
-0.1008189768,
0.3125168085,
0.3647502065,
-0.0420903824,
-0.6422481537,
-0.428558588,
-0.3078275025,
-0.1839683354,
0.0136259468,
0.9517508149,
-0.078992106,
0.4456523955,
0.4889467657,
0.9669145346,
0.4707508683,
0.0356591679,
0.4972293675,
-0.6592794657,
0.2492820174,
0.1612579823,
0.5758857131,
0.5710557103,
-0.1738547832,
-0.0336159281,
0.4567573369,
-0.3407439291,
-0.9519497156,
-0.2019773871,
-0.5906288624,
-0.3384293616,
1.2395976782,
-0.5760548711,
-0.1846439987,
-0.4052264988,
-0.2576228082,
-0.1260487884,
-0.205859825,
0.6911653876,
1.1525942087,
0.4924423993,
-0.1368811429,
-0.4616838694,
0.4740395844,
0.3762356937,
-0.8676888943,
0.2262222022,
0.2449955344,
0.6796053648,
-0.1450697333,
0.5912660956,
-0.2555190623,
0.0576052442,
0.1695558578,
0.1062936857,
-0.2091175616,
-0.0557414964,
-0.2936834991,
0.2731700242,
0.2584681809,
-0.395693332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14511v1 | Investigating Mysteries of CoT-Augmented Distillation | 2024-06-20T17:15:46 | 2024-06-20T17:15:46 | Somin Wadhwa, Silvio Amir, Byron C. Wallace | cs.CL | cs.CL | Eliciting "chain of thought" (CoT) rationales -- sequences of token that
convey a "reasoning" process -- has been shown to consistently improve LLM
performance on tasks like question answering. More recent efforts have shown
that such rationales can also be used for model distillation: Including CoT
sequences (elicited from a large "teacher" model) in addition to target labels
when fine-tuning a small student model yields (often substantial) improvements.
In this work we ask: Why and how does this additional training signal help in
model distillation? We perform ablations to interrogate this, and report some
potentially surprising results. Specifically: (1) Placing CoT sequences after
labels (rather than before) realizes consistently better downstream performance
-- this means that no student "reasoning" is necessary at test time to realize
gains. (2) When rationales are appended in this way, they need not be coherent
reasoning sequences to yield improvements; performance increases are robust to
permutations of CoT tokens, for example. In fact, (3) a small number of key
tokens are sufficient to achieve improvements equivalent to those observed when
full rationales are used in model distillation. | [
-0.7570213675,
-0.7267580032,
0.8109852076,
-0.3082074523,
-0.6585268974,
0.4853331447,
-0.1135701761,
-0.4449217319,
-0.0674032569,
0.3718259931,
-0.3014905155,
-0.1380320638,
-0.7773672342,
0.272705704,
-0.7101175189,
1.1797581911,
0.0783156678,
0.3129128814,
0.0374668427,
0.0613185354,
-0.5703785419,
-0.9238764644,
-0.6468607187,
-0.5621051788,
0.817227304,
0.1523074061,
0.4933938384,
0.5967536569,
0.2983701825,
0.2817961276,
-0.5178793073,
0.3718978763,
-0.465192616,
0.2115039378,
-0.1901831329,
-0.8979279995,
-0.1696181744,
0.2155613303,
0.4146983027,
0.7477592826,
0.1090978235,
0.1072779,
0.2499376088,
1.1256080866,
-0.803724885,
-0.3918688893,
-0.8452945948,
-0.1524824053,
0.1632012278,
-0.4317787886,
-0.5871903896,
-0.2156190723,
0.3613476157,
-0.1937758327,
0.5343981385,
0.1600178033,
0.654908061,
0.3901014924,
-0.4488749802,
-0.6347174644,
-0.8758277297,
0.5306044221,
-0.5180154443,
0.0967760012,
0.3654236197,
0.1608641297,
-0.2983059585,
-0.9050819874,
-0.7170418501,
-0.025004955,
-0.1784591675,
-0.2194167376,
0.161661461,
0.4320418239,
0.7688887119,
0.7381950021,
0.1128919721,
-0.2755327523,
-0.6443312764,
0.110217467,
0.3611646891,
0.1087148935,
-0.1254543364,
0.4042224288,
-0.5890500546,
-0.1397532821,
-0.5610937476,
0.1027225554,
0.3571644723,
0.1419240236,
0.0764418021,
0.8372986913,
-0.0566286482,
0.927244544,
0.4104183614,
0.1229777783,
-0.0304741003,
-0.3880551755,
-0.2657622099,
0.6148092747,
0.2426351607,
0.0195080731,
0.2832414508,
0.0200672485,
-0.2694669366,
0.2903256118,
0.1756766438,
-0.8847225308,
-0.6751402617,
0.2701500058,
-0.1834857613,
-0.3786840439,
0.1635263562,
-0.3091618717,
-0.32965675,
-0.8318480849,
0.340737462,
-0.3967682123,
-0.2966287434,
-0.0018599594,
-0.9716231227,
0.0075535695,
0.2714905143,
-1.1058701277,
0.1188074574,
0.8359815478,
0.8460863233,
-0.0316810422,
-0.0931908116,
-0.4435994327,
0.0127416709,
-0.5829411149,
0.9146798253,
-0.677706182,
-0.4696067572,
-0.5105062723,
-0.1770312637,
0.0134877255,
-0.7218735218,
0.0509576537,
-0.568713367,
-0.2165091336,
-0.9060242176,
-0.5611572266,
-0.0356702209,
0.1530109942,
-0.6422429085,
1.0751289129,
-0.2442574203,
-0.6623523831,
0.6176128983,
-0.5156162381,
-0.1585340798,
-0.3696803749,
-0.240429908,
-0.094313249,
0.6767394543,
0.0189158767,
-0.061423976,
-0.4340745211,
0.1399380565,
-0.2570751309,
-0.4754577577,
0.9367186427,
-0.9893948436,
0.7590744495,
0.4586094916,
-0.275201112,
-0.1848282665,
-0.7051842809,
-0.036666844,
-0.3590632379,
-0.3428148627,
-0.5434485674,
-0.3354284763,
-0.5475802422,
0.0677333772,
-0.0765079781,
-0.4496253133,
0.3015783727,
-0.1411503702,
0.3112234473,
0.8039197326,
0.3308250904,
0.423920393,
-0.6068624258,
0.3763645589,
0.3112131357,
-0.045720391,
-0.3562576771,
-0.6338976026,
-0.9627065659,
-0.514609158,
0.4556627572,
0.0139531577,
-0.8355603218,
-0.0570299588,
0.2768996656,
-0.4745151699,
-0.4970286489,
0.1927888542,
0.3600942194,
0.8667262197,
0.4438784122,
-0.1483408809,
-0.5381315947,
-0.5317869186,
-0.1626481712,
-0.2239172757,
0.1531381905,
-0.2669054568,
0.3359968066,
0.3093644977,
0.9849510193,
-0.6873090267,
0.2267710119,
-0.0739537328,
0.4829213619,
0.5457897186,
0.3290354609,
0.5155056119,
-0.9108124971,
-0.4877359867,
-0.1691190749,
-0.4093376696,
-0.1459946483,
-0.1277146786,
-0.4734543264,
0.1933499426,
0.2375301868,
-0.4395656586,
0.7136611342,
0.1836522669,
-0.3533340991,
0.7524471879,
-0.3366667032,
0.4713155329,
-0.6740494967,
-0.0985183567,
-0.3225849867,
-0.0267542191,
-0.5939333439,
-0.3406764865,
-0.1678609997,
0.2646212876,
-0.475620687,
0.1624320447,
-0.5648445487,
-0.0700728372,
-0.8697636724,
0.0197445899,
0.3892056346,
0.3970968127,
-0.0413548835,
0.9640223384,
0.488140434,
-0.9271286726,
0.4052452743,
0.0801115111,
-0.1228332222,
0.6128707528,
-0.4527741075,
0.2388608456,
-0.1942090094,
0.136805743,
-1.3467084169,
0.0504173227,
-0.1142849922,
-0.4391078055,
0.256526649,
-0.1296578199,
-0.1453208923,
-0.3716072738,
-0.2079805881,
0.555121243,
0.6328436136,
-0.9515895844,
0.516862154,
0.0791339502,
0.3218503892,
-0.6017492414,
-0.8291208148,
-0.268371284,
-0.5038818121,
-0.073557578,
0.0215699151,
0.0308326688,
-0.4953522682,
0.1000615582,
-0.5255162716,
-0.0358575769,
0.3154023588,
0.1391994804,
0.5989224315,
0.0387180038,
0.2914018035,
0.331367135,
-0.1715965122,
0.2450484633,
-0.3100316525,
0.5608549714,
-0.1730913222,
-0.2347240597,
-0.5218788385,
0.1031452939,
0.5976765752,
0.0935120881,
0.8704367876,
0.3393822312,
-0.1800172776,
-0.2029153258,
-0.6192494035,
-0.4657856524,
-0.5531343818,
-0.2052453011,
-0.6214109659,
-0.6725596786,
0.5473667979,
-0.3501235843,
-0.0673082992,
0.2457658052,
0.6185367703,
-0.3321304023,
1.0286051035,
0.0695331693,
0.4087105989,
0.5156912208,
-0.6156425476,
0.5068514943,
-1.1197006702,
-0.3106390238,
-0.5697776675,
-0.6022313237,
-0.4304302931,
-0.454310447,
0.4144681096,
0.5918043256,
-0.27546826,
0.2009575963,
-0.7711939216,
0.8063658476,
0.6157622933,
0.1783606559,
0.581430316,
-0.0834698379,
-0.3745184243,
0.4416974783,
-0.8254776001,
-0.5480501056,
1.2147256136,
0.1090095714,
0.7239201665,
-0.1633936912,
0.9168714285,
0.2719048262,
0.4837057292,
-0.5914484859,
0.3265656233,
-0.0170704927,
-0.8964660168,
-0.183848083,
-0.0962184668,
-0.7638189197,
0.3753826618,
-0.3415221572,
-0.5773316622,
0.4939636886,
0.6645780206,
-0.4729896784,
0.4050112069,
-0.7866620421,
0.3853197098,
-0.4932640791,
-0.561173141,
-0.320664674,
-0.4393942952,
0.3240386844,
-0.1093566567,
0.0700814649,
-0.151717484,
0.1334719211,
0.4242369235,
-0.9067652822,
0.6036887765,
-0.2303190827,
-0.0623849705,
0.9476572871,
-0.1698756516,
0.368614167,
0.0395073406,
-0.0375792049,
-0.0650817603,
0.2754889727,
-0.3567820489,
-0.8362063766,
0.6969926357,
-0.5940579772,
-1.0992051363,
-0.6747521162,
-0.4363255203,
-0.0810937211,
-0.2416568995,
0.2411848009,
0.4446899593,
0.3872362673,
0.3265703619,
0.768925488,
0.1683490872,
0.3865244389,
0.0031544026,
-0.3459068537,
-0.521782577,
0.4557776749,
0.1142133623,
0.8521274328,
0.0991562381,
0.1658886075,
-0.4319298267,
-0.6029234529,
-0.3818179071,
0.0177579727,
-0.9594669938,
-0.205388695,
-0.5156735182,
-0.1347663254,
-0.1416285187,
-0.2444757521,
-0.3760665357,
-0.7370273471,
-0.3372616172,
-0.5311123729,
0.7761355639,
0.6044466496,
-0.2139052153,
0.2110145837,
-0.6205244064,
0.4071082175,
0.4423560202,
0.112598829,
0.3860032856,
-0.4368286431,
-0.3317107558,
0.6058604121,
-0.409058392,
-0.7687660456,
0.0765283927,
-0.074516058,
0.4637416899,
0.3095450401,
0.3545699418,
1.2042651176,
-0.2794603705,
0.8047346473,
0.3794161677,
-0.8819525838,
0.4510016739,
0.0194095541,
0.2035244405,
0.7741197348,
0.3185345232,
-0.0482590757,
-0.5570126772,
-0.4369733334,
-0.8862190247,
0.5154240727,
0.1465737373,
0.0897567347,
-0.5532804132,
0.6938007474,
0.1156189442,
0.3469944894,
-0.36165905,
-0.4692412913,
-0.0098161977,
0.0224861205,
0.231928736,
-0.2529861927,
-0.1800330579,
-0.4882030785,
0.8345088363,
0.0059140176,
0.0614670329,
0.6173428893,
0.0296805091,
-0.0042227767,
0.0221783798,
0.3342602551,
0.6391449571,
-0.14692384,
0.4639759958,
0.457562834,
-0.3141490221,
0.4201324284,
-0.4254538417,
0.2127911299,
-0.0630669445,
0.0849911198,
0.937189877,
-0.0781269297,
-0.5970836282,
0.070890598,
-0.0775702,
-0.2184198499,
-0.3385752439,
0.6336653233,
0.0018833848,
0.516694963,
0.7089383006,
0.2610841393,
0.3314626813,
-0.9527933002,
0.0613165013,
0.3519799411,
-0.2930166721,
-0.0423730612,
0.8710212111,
0.1474600285,
-0.2496447414,
0.6789824367,
0.1811550558,
-0.4983380735,
0.9181101322,
0.5509058833,
0.8214589357,
0.0945252851,
-0.0730504543,
0.4424003363,
-0.0396236442,
-0.3238447011,
0.2072145343,
-0.6190237403,
-0.4717060328,
-0.3903620541,
-0.6747121811,
-0.4634737074,
-0.1969536096,
-0.8800811172,
0.5902130008,
-0.4417232871,
-0.4630921185,
0.105136551,
-0.4102004766,
-0.5802590847,
0.2035754621,
0.2788527012,
0.9155287743,
-0.7716708779,
0.9269740582,
0.3169211149,
-0.3026392162,
-0.9548498988,
-0.1810064912,
-0.2392538339,
-0.426078558,
0.6146585345,
0.1477062553,
-0.2654996216,
0.0099169854,
-0.3768967986,
-0.9178455472,
1.2940014601,
0.3163930774,
-0.845511198,
0.0153625719,
0.269664973,
0.8081727624,
-0.5753941536,
0.300437957,
0.8126105666,
0.2465360463,
0.7135427594,
-0.7527674437,
0.0638092756,
-0.1818019003,
0.1567873508,
0.4185342193,
-0.3500066996,
0.7704948783,
-0.501654923,
-0.0720391572,
0.1340662092,
0.4757098854,
0.6727185249,
0.7302204967,
0.4768957794,
0.4928932786,
0.9601002932,
-0.347407043,
1.1337280273,
-0.4017998874,
0.1301897615,
1.2962963581,
-0.2441775799,
0.5368276238,
1.0018650293,
-0.2025295198,
0.5700097084,
0.640448153,
0.2480400056,
0.8672602177,
0.2991617918,
-0.6248819828,
-0.2242743522,
0.003676259,
-0.3952741027,
0.0514142774,
0.5242187977,
-0.6556838155,
0.0639673248,
0.2791869938,
-0.1586751044,
0.1044395193,
-0.3843341768,
0.8779544234,
0.2874776125,
-1.1116052866,
1.0390299559,
-0.5483825207,
0.3944797218,
-0.3718978763,
-0.2071020156,
0.0181270707,
0.2677416503,
-0.1257644147,
-0.4834944308,
0.4617283046,
0.1695980877,
-0.1320873797,
-0.2127408832,
0.436165899,
-0.5438736677,
-0.31472826,
0.1747361422,
0.1728547364,
0.1916066408,
0.2357143164,
-0.3094378114,
-0.0076320991,
0.1103999987,
-0.3037753403,
0.2283551246,
0.7559931278,
0.1294146627,
0.4028220177,
0.957300663,
0.0384251513,
0.2965347767,
0.0706232563,
1.2813740969,
-0.4984472096,
-0.2043238729,
-1.1421604156,
0.6885353327,
-0.1614179909,
-0.2619808018,
0.5296241641,
0.7647951245,
0.8935684562,
-0.0334258862,
0.760042429,
0.1269541383,
0.1332460344,
-0.7202163339,
0.3839866519,
-0.2905366719,
0.7465164065,
-0.0346205011,
-1.0377291441,
0.0946282223,
0.4781101942,
-0.4314588308,
-0.1244705245,
0.9964137673,
0.5906462669,
0.3417080641,
0.2681229711,
0.2768301964,
0.1176702902,
0.4393592477,
0.3042083383,
1.1036652327,
-0.2449632138,
0.2168227136,
-0.5218611956,
-0.200543642,
0.0722417682,
-0.8070150614,
-1.1280986071,
-0.5853736401,
-0.3870564401,
-0.570592761,
0.2263126969,
1.2253395319,
0.2443672717,
-0.7971842885,
-0.0248538218,
-0.5371187329,
0.1593815833,
-0.1782648116,
-0.1533858031,
0.0898014903,
-0.5799443722,
-0.869310081,
0.1040150821,
0.1271029413,
0.405842483,
0.0631417409,
0.0028226716,
-0.4837407768,
0.2995415032,
0.3663449287,
0.0369036086,
-0.6294427514,
-0.2841647565,
0.0000705517,
0.2612108588,
0.0229239874,
1.0024194717,
-1.0790219307,
0.6342959404,
0.596824944,
0.2623287439,
0.8486084938,
0.2936721146,
0.6047515869,
-0.480320394,
0.3889615238,
0.1883531064,
0.4361047149,
0.0149062462,
-0.528069675,
0.6388229132,
0.1581928432,
-0.5101102591,
-1.1758230925,
0.114890486,
-0.813816011,
-0.4400280118,
0.9498134255,
-0.1918232739,
-0.3836579621,
-0.1531523168,
-0.5929136872,
0.5616611838,
-0.224039793,
1.1915568113,
0.960565269,
-0.547252059,
0.137902692,
-0.0958747864,
0.4266549349,
0.3501215875,
-0.3638295829,
0.1766745895,
0.4448905289,
0.2017983645,
0.3270028532,
0.495611608,
-0.1495286375,
0.3932470977,
0.189951539,
-0.4568061829,
-0.3377016783,
-0.4194827974,
-0.2066804767,
0.1033070162,
0.3973181844,
-0.2999230325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14508v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14508v1 | Evidence of a log scaling law for political persuasion with large language models | 2024-06-20T17:12:38 | 2024-06-20T17:12:38 | Kobi Hackenburg, Ben M. Tappin, Paul Röttger, Scott Hale, Jonathan Bright, Helen Margetts | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC | Large language models can now generate political messages as persuasive as
those written by humans, raising concerns about how far this persuasiveness may
continue to increase with model size. Here, we generate 720 persuasive messages
on 10 U.S. political issues from 24 language models spanning several orders of
magnitude in size. We then deploy these messages in a large-scale randomized
survey experiment (N = 25,982) to estimate the persuasive capability of each
model. Our findings are twofold. First, we find evidence of a log scaling law:
model persuasiveness is characterized by sharply diminishing returns, such that
current frontier models are barely more persuasive than models smaller in size
by an order of magnitude or more. Second, mere task completion (coherence,
staying on topic) appears to account for larger models' persuasive advantage.
These findings suggest that further scaling model size will not much increase
the persuasiveness of static LLM-generated messages. | [
-0.0465905704,
-0.826302886,
0.7531260252,
0.2576625645,
-0.3152313828,
-0.1796668768,
-0.4653068781,
0.1223081276,
0.3345027864,
0.6468079686,
-0.3623337746,
-0.4755151868,
-0.5891946554,
-0.153154999,
-0.553352654,
1.1280300617,
0.547935605,
0.0356048085,
-0.2009623498,
0.2368794084,
-0.2285436988,
-1.0251244307,
-0.4792777598,
-0.4874144793,
0.7562355995,
0.5960879326,
0.7456617355,
0.7951076627,
0.4498893917,
0.2155312598,
-0.3049378097,
-0.3577517271,
-0.8043032885,
0.0956812799,
-0.1179350391,
-0.9819360971,
-0.319665134,
0.2251004279,
0.9072129726,
0.5227871537,
-0.2557430863,
0.0988768339,
0.015200479,
0.5950855613,
-0.5243446827,
-0.1534599811,
-1.0633788109,
-0.2110246122,
-0.2505348921,
-0.1009527221,
-0.7432191968,
-0.2321750969,
0.116275087,
-0.3494800031,
0.1197367385,
0.1850933284,
0.8138232827,
-0.1901223511,
-0.8881710768,
-0.472777456,
-0.683852613,
0.8061269522,
-1.0284774303,
0.0559595786,
0.4436784685,
-0.0629657209,
-0.1201394871,
-0.5594730377,
-0.5610619187,
-0.5313870907,
-0.0324730724,
-0.3571221232,
-0.4181114435,
0.0497264937,
0.5234853625,
0.1976973265,
-0.3617568016,
0.5301057696,
-0.0556373261,
-0.2136651278,
0.8420615792,
0.4105139077,
0.2225214243,
-0.3524566889,
-0.2015955299,
-0.4694176316,
-0.8636686206,
0.1065487415,
0.6486817598,
0.3477974832,
-0.2085791528,
0.6777812243,
-0.0997820422,
0.4884106219,
0.3863303661,
-0.1920793205,
-0.3643005788,
-0.3347252309,
-0.2126839906,
0.0556196421,
0.9843899012,
0.457787931,
0.0864554793,
0.2671345174,
-0.2255687118,
0.0353849381,
-0.0512426868,
-0.9351091981,
-0.3841727078,
0.0482779555,
-0.7282748222,
-0.4748888612,
0.0028343389,
-0.8349916339,
-1.0178710222,
0.0278776158,
0.3347149193,
0.0791176185,
-0.7056826353,
0.3449774384,
-0.1058290079,
-0.0138686933,
0.1842820197,
-1.1346867085,
0.1044684649,
1.0037146807,
0.7240917683,
0.0547866561,
0.204811126,
-0.5707431436,
-0.1955620348,
-0.7645192742,
0.7245316505,
-0.732190311,
-0.2699398994,
0.1409639865,
-0.0154396631,
0.1695272475,
-0.5782312751,
0.4615068138,
-0.3710062802,
0.1412722319,
-0.4759254754,
-0.4522192776,
-0.0674211085,
0.3504257798,
-0.6033094525,
0.4824007154,
-0.423042953,
-0.6089596748,
0.5625018477,
-0.6525610089,
-0.4042626619,
-0.158095181,
-0.3525086045,
-0.4722546339,
0.4108358622,
-0.2430817336,
0.7227048874,
-0.5095803142,
0.5783622265,
-0.2412999868,
0.1453489661,
0.5246942043,
-0.7009190917,
0.7381879091,
0.2784198225,
-0.5204245448,
0.3029420078,
-0.6474790573,
-0.3704337478,
0.1459647119,
-0.49754408,
-0.4718726873,
0.2540022135,
-0.2055519223,
0.0682733431,
0.469557941,
-0.7323486805,
0.1651774943,
0.0782431588,
0.3293782175,
0.7888254523,
0.1463312507,
0.408769697,
-0.3138031662,
0.4340503216,
-0.1469556838,
-0.1807861626,
-0.1037611887,
-0.5827092528,
-0.6202412248,
-0.2475034297,
0.1141718179,
0.3083231151,
-0.0204079021,
0.12922135,
-0.4864335954,
-0.4947648346,
0.0914290547,
-0.0962883309,
0.2554291487,
0.1094057932,
-0.2326070517,
0.2581026256,
-0.4145263135,
-1.1154612303,
-0.5049520135,
-0.4666363895,
-0.3898435235,
0.2826530039,
0.5510911345,
0.1677958816,
0.6562157869,
-0.4745827615,
0.1904955804,
-0.0596229583,
0.4034250975,
0.355761081,
0.2866796553,
0.2951425314,
-0.8788887858,
-0.505471766,
0.1571282893,
-0.5322796106,
-0.2318507582,
-0.441612184,
0.1908509433,
0.0758612975,
0.4939371049,
-0.5456430912,
0.2390536964,
0.6116141677,
-0.6076849699,
0.5570118427,
-0.2334018648,
0.2314451784,
-0.9381427169,
-0.3178918362,
0.2286517173,
-0.1640984565,
-0.9156001806,
-0.071940437,
-0.0921215415,
0.076928407,
-0.2496591061,
0.2094877511,
-0.2099352777,
0.4859311283,
-0.4781096876,
-0.0630682632,
-0.1869992018,
-0.0287503824,
0.1088137403,
0.3568806648,
0.4010965526,
-0.6547025442,
0.358938396,
-0.280603081,
-0.2602515519,
0.5715938807,
-0.6806114316,
-0.0164447185,
-0.1640101522,
0.4010299146,
-1.4492460489,
-0.5201224089,
-0.2650478184,
-0.1189321354,
0.1002321988,
-0.1286342591,
-0.5023516417,
-0.347333163,
-0.1108965874,
-0.1527183652,
0.721213758,
-0.5437631011,
0.592659533,
0.3080522418,
0.0571345165,
-0.0133838691,
-0.6348042488,
0.1504283249,
-0.7452667356,
-0.5550865531,
-0.1838174611,
0.0570631847,
-0.7385994792,
-0.4278437197,
-0.106464304,
0.2433451712,
-0.1234959289,
0.3785907924,
0.0010057656,
-0.3762354255,
0.403703928,
-0.2635839581,
0.3124904335,
0.5045675039,
-0.1662096381,
0.6898640394,
-0.14702788,
-0.1317989975,
-0.6823168993,
0.3001101911,
0.8641269207,
0.2160214931,
0.7190099955,
0.0692973509,
-0.1487049013,
0.351136297,
-0.8292198777,
-0.5514742136,
-0.494304657,
0.534468174,
-0.3824524879,
-0.9460917711,
0.3924174309,
-0.2942020893,
0.4760625362,
0.7752200961,
0.6296714544,
0.1893486232,
1.2386438847,
0.4674845636,
-0.0575969443,
0.4403415024,
-0.0299243387,
0.1279746294,
-0.2700003386,
-0.2296122909,
-0.8927846551,
-0.2970363796,
-0.6958397031,
-0.3988320231,
0.0673308671,
-0.1249985099,
-0.5829279423,
0.0540057123,
-0.7046016455,
0.353323698,
0.3827742934,
-0.1139291525,
0.3116070032,
0.4809199572,
0.1677143425,
-0.2784208357,
-0.6909672022,
-0.6758363247,
1.2461994886,
0.6078696251,
0.8312312365,
0.2095076889,
0.4998369515,
0.3861321509,
0.5986584425,
-0.4597364664,
0.8273964524,
-0.2405895144,
-0.995375514,
-0.6833034158,
-0.6186350584,
-0.9995131493,
0.2576463521,
-0.607652247,
-0.7371782064,
0.2822758853,
0.1894569397,
-0.0518860444,
0.8537329435,
-0.4350536466,
0.5731651187,
-0.2691889703,
-0.2477592379,
-0.6950755715,
-0.3221077621,
0.2845345736,
-0.2464817315,
0.2711955011,
-0.3541811109,
-0.1014298871,
1.0600861311,
-0.4832332134,
1.1350530386,
-0.256079793,
-0.6534636021,
0.2228399366,
-0.0309722591,
1.0077074766,
-0.0169717763,
-0.1857491434,
-0.0719179139,
-0.1753726751,
-0.5030661225,
-0.4831365645,
0.6776338816,
-0.5617204905,
-1.0736478567,
-0.1076703668,
-0.5275802016,
0.348678261,
0.0344744883,
0.38828969,
0.3525628746,
-0.3056696057,
0.8182012439,
0.8200147152,
-0.0005288124,
0.2646246552,
0.5013233423,
-0.4159688056,
-0.2158526778,
1.0137891769,
0.1940965205,
0.6582534313,
0.4409597218,
0.733659029,
-0.165806219,
-0.3779431581,
0.0159648191,
0.3445151746,
-0.4547287226,
0.070526354,
-0.6039276123,
0.1662297547,
-0.3090873957,
-0.1678841263,
-0.484790802,
-0.5024325848,
-0.1786694378,
0.1092984602,
0.4936754107,
1.2103105783,
0.0191400088,
0.4892751873,
-0.270890981,
-0.0617701039,
0.5636165142,
0.0062789186,
-0.0554883778,
-0.8014276624,
-0.0942125991,
0.3519667387,
-0.2784506381,
-0.7945997119,
0.1082584262,
-0.1699605435,
0.2699938715,
0.7847476006,
0.2840571105,
0.3949026167,
-0.4152030945,
1.1055830717,
0.6571030021,
-0.7490559816,
0.3110236526,
-0.5273017883,
0.2206771225,
0.0172471348,
0.5787801743,
-0.2799822688,
-0.6664678454,
-0.9024577141,
-0.5288591385,
0.1514600962,
-0.1934318542,
0.769793272,
0.0154074449,
0.4020853341,
0.0158324707,
0.1786778569,
-0.920740962,
-0.1078389809,
-0.167754963,
0.1330916584,
-0.1694199741,
-0.5886611342,
-0.2824125588,
-0.0539016053,
0.472758472,
0.022858385,
-0.0755412206,
-0.0233051609,
0.5022085309,
-0.2533566952,
0.3882578611,
1.0518147945,
0.5833716393,
-0.0270626303,
0.2444218397,
0.0813249424,
-0.486273706,
0.4602996111,
-0.2589725256,
-0.222278893,
-0.0359265506,
0.4368641973,
0.9521651864,
-0.2811019719,
-0.3794382215,
0.2856016755,
0.0218932293,
-0.7698076367,
-0.089097403,
-0.0766407847,
0.4976575673,
0.2555445731,
0.6957679391,
-0.3723394275,
-0.1623111069,
-0.5727128983,
-0.2051288486,
0.8337512016,
-0.0777894408,
-0.4040505886,
0.9352362156,
0.1941146553,
-0.6230003238,
0.3626319468,
0.1523716301,
-0.2597097754,
0.5714424253,
0.6937322617,
0.3734599948,
-0.258812815,
0.1999562383,
0.4414297342,
0.3947366774,
-0.2878224552,
-0.2239252329,
0.1941898763,
-0.2705171406,
-0.3703371584,
-0.1879467517,
-0.4417258799,
0.631978035,
-0.3676840663,
-0.0448566116,
-0.6842027903,
-0.5740314722,
0.1566888541,
0.2386910468,
-0.1687051803,
0.2382101417,
0.0429834723,
0.6724131107,
-1.2529112101,
0.4354874492,
0.6325322986,
-0.0739816725,
-0.7153871655,
0.4185494483,
0.2302552909,
-0.2958661914,
0.6729465723,
0.0258617941,
0.1116243526,
-0.3280938268,
-0.9851167798,
-0.8564775586,
0.8864280581,
0.5539364219,
-0.8273037076,
0.0067450246,
0.0782336369,
0.4441031814,
-0.7819519639,
-0.2023297399,
0.3041920662,
0.5072562695,
0.136527583,
-0.8260795474,
0.4521673322,
0.0774441063,
-0.0571330227,
0.147115767,
-0.7659919262,
0.9132882953,
-0.2155288905,
-0.1506806463,
-0.0974438116,
1.0380032063,
0.2451290786,
0.2181238234,
0.9435485005,
0.1132928208,
1.0033650398,
0.1697957367,
1.2543202639,
-0.2340268642,
0.0328776352,
0.6401589513,
-0.3034918308,
0.8832949996,
0.4886777699,
-0.0737538114,
0.6467981935,
0.4891883731,
0.2960169613,
0.1610744596,
0.7460288405,
-0.5322524905,
-0.5644444823,
-0.3028207123,
-0.2396090478,
0.1588852555,
0.3929741979,
-0.3197650015,
0.1035020873,
0.0672034547,
0.508436799,
0.4762230217,
-0.1352130324,
0.5905811191,
0.0511569418,
-0.7415779233,
0.771787405,
-0.1525336802,
0.6869112849,
-0.4995067716,
-0.0391022898,
-0.0402480923,
0.13383542,
-0.1417275369,
-0.7267010808,
-0.1194806769,
0.0370316878,
-0.220171988,
-0.25364995,
0.5491803288,
-0.4476529062,
-0.2799853981,
-0.085343264,
0.094464086,
0.4728753567,
0.0356073454,
-0.2306080908,
0.189311415,
0.2638251483,
-0.6220498085,
0.47541821,
0.6118999124,
-0.2599189878,
0.7042958736,
0.9455074072,
0.2320160419,
-0.0448349752,
-0.0982023478,
0.926302433,
-0.3737946749,
-0.1345846951,
-1.1620103121,
0.4120489955,
-0.5368469357,
-0.0495315604,
1.0511511564,
0.7133837342,
0.3291139305,
-0.0287706461,
0.6446067691,
-0.003571938,
0.2961991429,
-0.3556467295,
0.6955057979,
-0.5699750781,
0.3182007074,
-0.0149394646,
-0.6155484915,
-0.2578826845,
0.5155684352,
-0.6365110278,
-0.035845574,
0.5192031264,
0.8514353633,
0.0834529623,
-0.1085781828,
0.5674696565,
0.4685772359,
0.5138306022,
0.3611068726,
0.5984962583,
0.3100987375,
0.7146819234,
0.1228170395,
-0.3212976158,
-0.207546562,
-1.0752924681,
-1.1668146849,
-0.5784261823,
-0.5592025518,
-0.7239040136,
-0.1318649948,
0.7504997849,
0.7668204904,
-0.3626618683,
-0.5564334393,
-0.1711111218,
0.0469781049,
0.1083774045,
-0.2126797736,
0.3740082085,
-0.0002320043,
-0.6213467121,
0.0491160937,
0.1339897811,
-0.0723369196,
-0.5709577799,
0.0246315002,
-0.4856947958,
0.6376135945,
0.5030895472,
0.4241313934,
-0.9000630379,
-0.2369018495,
-0.1278440654,
-0.4553078711,
-0.0271682907,
1.0402435064,
-0.3924633265,
0.1496163607,
0.5744513869,
0.2890688479,
0.482208252,
0.0144755142,
0.5900804996,
-0.5420563817,
0.1221806034,
-0.0838802755,
-0.0218522511,
0.3035955727,
-0.4568880796,
0.277361989,
0.1224012226,
-0.701397419,
-0.9546135068,
0.2881450355,
-0.4092312157,
-0.2597713172,
1.5453928709,
-0.1534540057,
-0.2519327402,
0.2025985718,
-0.3413609266,
-0.1683299392,
-0.5073271394,
0.5475679636,
0.9997416735,
0.0035567889,
-0.1423263848,
-0.6186310053,
0.3812148869,
0.6328800917,
-0.6597866416,
0.6271220446,
0.5903584957,
0.3061202466,
0.4416933656,
0.8894461989,
0.1790301055,
0.1645494252,
0.2720783949,
-0.2702965438,
0.2902791798,
-0.1221646741,
-0.427618593,
0.3289842904,
0.1834217608,
0.134346813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14504v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14504v1 | Translating Across Cultures: LLMs for Intralingual Cultural Adaptation | 2024-06-20T17:06:58 | 2024-06-20T17:06:58 | Pushpdeep Singh, Mayur Patidar, Lovekesh Vig | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLMs are increasingly being deployed for multilingual applications and have
demonstrated impressive translation capabilities between several low and high
resource languages. An aspect of translation that often gets overlooked is that
of cultural adaptation, or modifying source culture references to suit the
target culture. Cultural adaptation has applications across several creative
industries and requires intimate knowledge of source and target cultures during
translation. While specialized translation models still outperform LLMs on the
machine translation task when viewed from the lens of correctness, they are not
sensitive to cultural differences often requiring manual correction. LLMs on
the other hand have a rich reservoir of cultural knowledge embedded within its
parameters that can be potentially exploited for such applications. In this
paper we define the task of cultural adaptation and create an evaluation
framework to benchmark different models for this task. We evaluate the
performance of modern LLMs for cultural adaptation and analyze their cross
cultural knowledge while connecting related concepts across different cultures.
We also analyze possible issues with automatic adaptation including cultural
biases and stereotypes. We hope that this task will offer more insight into the
cultural understanding of LLMs and their creativity in cross-cultural
scenarios. | [
-0.2646302879,
-0.0665003881,
0.3700321317,
0.5479305983,
-0.0944793373,
0.3995466828,
-0.5348998308,
-0.7805456519,
-0.0711416528,
0.3795765638,
-0.6267059445,
-0.4689175785,
-0.5738917589,
0.3249852955,
-0.0937717408,
0.7939697504,
-0.5137856603,
0.4900352359,
-0.4697178304,
-0.5795478821,
-0.6241554022,
-0.4519876838,
-0.2792800665,
-0.4282188416,
0.0103140753,
0.4401673675,
0.3463810086,
0.3162753284,
0.7936877012,
0.284989506,
-0.01428275,
0.3583329022,
-0.673692584,
0.0799602196,
-0.6201568842,
-0.7623664737,
-0.4128991365,
0.0296928678,
0.5684354305,
0.5342658758,
0.2991631031,
0.6036660671,
0.1514463574,
0.470841676,
-0.5242737532,
-0.0293590091,
-0.6216076612,
0.4687825739,
-0.0527091511,
-0.3232421875,
-0.1815640032,
-0.4900192022,
-0.0310746562,
-0.4772353172,
-0.1157219261,
0.0526504181,
0.1755895764,
0.341483444,
-0.5776822567,
-0.5354364514,
-0.871342957,
0.735301137,
-0.3769960999,
0.3383084238,
0.1487691849,
0.2899897397,
-0.1122222692,
-0.6338157058,
-0.233671084,
-0.1132738367,
0.1160402596,
0.5018482804,
-0.1277792603,
-0.6036140323,
-0.093442142,
0.3840486109,
-0.3950279951,
0.2773550749,
-0.3657675385,
-0.0653014556,
0.6483976841,
0.4273327887,
0.4676163197,
0.0426223539,
-0.5843682289,
-0.0052387118,
-0.5797587037,
0.1177197695,
0.1442791522,
0.0270524193,
-0.3628702462,
0.1630965024,
-0.1906404346,
0.3143895566,
-0.023137683,
-0.3679483235,
0.2559640408,
-0.5185439587,
0.0320446603,
0.0268726852,
0.2702355683,
0.7258257866,
0.4807382226,
-0.239659667,
-0.1024744138,
-0.2905471325,
0.1638668329,
-0.5568497181,
0.3180668652,
-0.2115992308,
-0.7034116983,
-0.0477764979,
-0.2562026978,
-0.3649661839,
-0.5796243548,
-0.2586178184,
0.2356342524,
-0.0908912122,
-0.2015452981,
-0.1585414708,
-0.1018412337,
0.277795732,
0.3682593703,
-0.6607995629,
0.07888145,
0.414514631,
0.8777562976,
-0.6119884849,
-0.3126251101,
-0.0465900712,
0.2573083341,
-0.5095645785,
0.6142876744,
-0.2867948711,
-0.4996187389,
0.0616682023,
0.2612528801,
-0.0403132103,
-0.6514780521,
0.7974921465,
-0.4645684958,
0.181676805,
-0.4923434854,
-0.2123048902,
-0.4663510621,
0.4413986802,
-0.3751265109,
0.6852480769,
0.1542999446,
-0.3450543582,
0.4423470497,
-0.5441255569,
-0.3920178711,
0.1720730215,
0.0778384507,
0.1837777346,
0.3093804717,
0.2687736154,
0.2262757719,
-0.6479340196,
-0.1975281984,
-0.4411007464,
-0.5999381542,
0.3720691204,
-0.1864180416,
0.8916271925,
0.4681043923,
0.0518256836,
0.2547912002,
-0.5070732832,
-0.0907795206,
0.1510539204,
-0.4669526815,
-0.270858705,
-0.1377065778,
0.033122126,
0.5238566995,
0.2560183406,
-0.196830526,
0.1054784432,
0.0277298912,
0.455976069,
0.7470586896,
-0.232273981,
0.7539212108,
-0.4405967593,
0.911922276,
0.2362899929,
0.2248265743,
-0.0642989948,
-0.1662931591,
-0.6500772834,
-0.0905050635,
0.0518867038,
0.9555487633,
-0.9343820214,
-0.0395414159,
-0.4220182002,
-0.5998677611,
-0.6695381999,
0.6967148781,
0.1340743303,
0.3507214487,
0.1066989005,
-0.7654755712,
-0.3466556668,
-0.5603437424,
-0.538901329,
-0.0738445222,
-0.1134202182,
0.1734381914,
0.3539413214,
-0.2317202985,
0.4159677923,
-0.0523630157,
-0.6209429502,
-0.2667630017,
-0.1980705261,
0.3523037434,
0.3961676359,
0.7299309373,
-0.5563103557,
-0.6050898433,
0.3404694498,
-1.0275322199,
-0.3104271591,
-0.1967338324,
-0.2749603987,
0.345667094,
0.6852115989,
-0.052768141,
0.0853836611,
0.7462751865,
-0.0533865988,
0.3899764121,
-0.3482677937,
0.3801089227,
-1.0752483606,
-0.1266720593,
-0.0002672733,
-0.098509796,
-0.5266763568,
0.1531291902,
0.2053097486,
0.0406095907,
-0.6916143298,
0.5845169425,
-0.6780036092,
-0.3881682158,
-0.1145788133,
0.1399157643,
-0.033370886,
0.1628862768,
0.2154091597,
0.7799491286,
0.3211915791,
-0.3116511405,
0.5673654675,
0.1147121042,
-0.656974256,
1.0512185097,
-0.0795721635,
0.3600563109,
-0.058310736,
0.2563652396,
-0.7403480411,
0.2006056905,
0.3560166061,
-0.0862577558,
-0.0794595107,
-0.1691343635,
-0.5942727923,
-0.1593974382,
-0.0584954582,
0.5702351928,
0.4960736334,
-0.4807160795,
0.5235710144,
0.0175762661,
-0.2451911867,
-0.3672316372,
-0.8792154789,
0.2822007537,
-0.7101320028,
-0.8120427728,
0.3273335397,
-0.3119148612,
-0.4007222354,
-0.0768683478,
0.0468465462,
0.1848688275,
0.241743505,
-0.013602172,
-0.0109143173,
-0.5288529992,
0.0291577596,
-0.1528526992,
0.1551431865,
0.0736373812,
-0.4268409014,
0.0844652131,
-0.2100010514,
-0.4518277943,
-0.0506586879,
0.4192172587,
0.6359480023,
-0.278010428,
0.5137422085,
1.0353682041,
-0.2380276024,
-0.112430945,
-0.5035312176,
0.1715987772,
-0.3946254849,
0.5586258173,
-0.7783593535,
-0.4048483968,
0.8820226789,
-0.4405264258,
-0.273203373,
0.2601419687,
0.7741990685,
-0.2726181746,
0.545956552,
0.795930624,
-0.0611053556,
0.4670411348,
0.0828703046,
0.1168215424,
-0.767683208,
-0.1609330475,
-0.3032492399,
-0.5667615533,
-0.8982490897,
-0.7791273594,
0.5789521933,
0.256600827,
0.109190762,
0.1154238954,
-0.0382231548,
0.4005790949,
0.3993038237,
-0.2216729075,
0.6030313373,
-0.0234497767,
-0.1744116098,
-0.1552091539,
-0.8113469481,
-0.4335202277,
0.8901690245,
0.3753011227,
0.8493984938,
0.4748411775,
0.2181510776,
0.4188083708,
0.6614530087,
-0.6730309129,
0.3238015175,
-0.4998557568,
-0.4145873189,
0.0663263872,
-0.0368673317,
-0.2960193455,
0.4922447205,
-0.2411579192,
-0.5723441243,
0.2281336188,
-0.2269077599,
0.0568915084,
0.2055267245,
-0.6267736554,
0.7339850068,
-0.6733791828,
-0.372944653,
-0.2872743905,
-0.4675666094,
0.3619362712,
-0.5132617354,
0.4259341657,
-0.1958851218,
0.0159733389,
0.3209308088,
0.6091563106,
0.7641589642,
0.2203038335,
-0.2870627642,
-0.1056290269,
0.3129541576,
0.1126794294,
-0.1108145639,
-0.5213242769,
0.4425382316,
0.2884212136,
-0.2503899634,
-0.4427876174,
0.5622056723,
-0.8447918892,
-0.76192981,
-0.2014113218,
-1.1730592251,
-0.3804702461,
0.0096714003,
0.0518917143,
-0.1951423287,
-0.4209803045,
0.1268943846,
0.209301129,
-0.47210899,
0.3481161594,
0.6431989074,
-0.1870087385,
-0.3162696064,
0.5811687112,
0.1056914181,
0.5015544295,
0.2959983349,
-0.0578955486,
-0.2173166722,
-0.5941239595,
-0.9033521414,
-0.0202549268,
-1.3206923008,
0.1475482285,
-0.0626515448,
-0.0736812502,
-0.564167738,
-0.3518307507,
0.0258815102,
-0.3050795496,
-0.3737330139,
0.081181556,
0.1117402241,
0.6734775901,
-0.2057344764,
0.0600942597,
-0.8538577557,
0.0268149506,
-0.1386050582,
0.1636737883,
-0.3037834764,
-0.8052876592,
-0.5700128078,
-0.2580337226,
-0.3587282598,
-0.8206746578,
0.3479270637,
0.3451710641,
0.8988522291,
0.2201802582,
0.0150309158,
0.9254229069,
-0.4068495631,
0.6134647727,
0.0046043578,
-0.9395463467,
0.2129764557,
0.0382890292,
0.646148026,
0.4067425132,
0.6661834121,
-0.9825087786,
-0.201579228,
-0.0142070092,
-0.5390135646,
0.5243011117,
-0.3047927022,
0.3389788568,
0.408768028,
0.1960523576,
0.2657854557,
-0.0057319812,
-0.7311908007,
0.1784826815,
-0.1718327105,
-0.0694684982,
-0.2883840203,
-0.0618413649,
-0.3160615265,
-0.2968529761,
0.4544952512,
-0.3366108835,
-0.0645733029,
0.0149833104,
-0.7610548735,
-0.2506155372,
0.1966961324,
0.6285735369,
0.9952921271,
-0.0860383436,
-0.0277120154,
0.8295415044,
-0.1368774325,
0.1414067149,
-0.2153336406,
0.0352385826,
-0.3678463399,
0.5889276862,
0.7090331316,
-0.0938829556,
-0.5103827715,
0.0298032109,
-0.043961212,
0.2101357579,
-0.4309048355,
-0.009760825,
0.2831000388,
0.5831398368,
0.3497925401,
-0.1489615291,
0.0144884102,
-0.9351180792,
-0.1553785056,
0.3065667152,
-0.5855386853,
-0.2390211672,
0.4454840422,
0.4176139235,
-0.232982859,
0.3971219063,
0.0610755756,
-0.5220892429,
0.4061864316,
0.7130496502,
0.8804193139,
-0.3122135103,
-0.1416898221,
0.0402868241,
0.5730895996,
0.3242886364,
0.1462834924,
-0.0771435127,
-0.9082599282,
-0.3831862211,
-0.5669034719,
-0.4790289998,
-0.3262183964,
-0.633797884,
0.2344936132,
0.003642115,
-0.0409855209,
-0.5101018548,
-0.048242867,
-0.9828646779,
0.1851481348,
0.3271388113,
1.1698725224,
-1.0839090347,
0.9563359618,
1.0008454323,
-0.1069867238,
-0.0146572366,
0.0944147035,
0.0888027251,
-0.9707502127,
0.9558211565,
-0.2216738909,
-0.2473278046,
-0.1450148821,
0.0166312829,
-0.8378440738,
1.2073303461,
0.5483151674,
-0.3144288659,
0.28758654,
0.5092026591,
0.7412418723,
-0.7402452826,
0.2820287943,
0.5719671845,
0.5138129592,
-0.0582561493,
-1.1761138439,
0.0491215028,
-0.2021632493,
0.3385236561,
-0.4367320538,
-0.5972952843,
0.5199531317,
-0.1818116754,
0.0858810619,
0.1148598492,
0.697386384,
0.1504339129,
0.2646405697,
0.4961498678,
0.0647457764,
0.5449228287,
-0.0537066497,
0.7808577418,
-0.4543777406,
-0.0929838121,
0.9642281532,
-0.5047483444,
0.6146050096,
0.6555175185,
-0.0513469838,
0.3813658059,
0.8284619451,
-0.0668215603,
0.5103684068,
0.3711335063,
-0.1278930008,
-0.2289732099,
-0.5215849876,
-0.5379549861,
0.8271250725,
0.48266083,
-0.5442430973,
-0.0142092798,
0.1282530874,
-0.143089518,
0.2138400376,
-0.3381465375,
0.7839167714,
0.3214396834,
-0.731535852,
0.519790113,
0.1653820574,
0.6474425793,
-0.3858881891,
0.2178594023,
-0.5197384357,
0.3519621491,
-0.1509534568,
-0.7994711995,
0.3721537888,
-0.0767386034,
-0.2075349391,
-0.6746897101,
0.7494531274,
-0.3374446332,
-0.7386763096,
0.6844863892,
0.7620269656,
0.2825125456,
0.2852252722,
-0.6757203937,
0.3469114602,
-0.0144087719,
-0.0104814414,
0.3818894625,
0.5088183284,
-0.4868572056,
0.7255871296,
0.5248116255,
0.219763577,
0.0231188778,
0.1237363145,
0.2347488999,
-0.621255517,
-0.4762511253,
-0.5311338902,
0.3658324182,
0.1888527572,
-0.3416828215,
0.9043316841,
0.1346194446,
1.1799269915,
-0.3168568909,
0.7487012148,
0.1688000411,
-0.055024039,
-0.5340486169,
0.8360264897,
-0.784324646,
0.1644702554,
-0.1593972743,
-1.0143589973,
-0.0554120839,
0.2854573429,
-0.4299444556,
-0.0478655137,
0.6454550624,
0.592248857,
-0.0627253801,
0.0573626347,
0.3723388612,
0.1529064775,
0.1127666906,
0.6100065112,
1.1456272602,
-0.1342959851,
0.6371357441,
-0.3669198751,
-0.0862253755,
-0.0896343961,
-1.4044061899,
-0.4185317159,
-0.5240876079,
-0.2676831484,
-0.0361872651,
0.0575725585,
0.9602105021,
0.7972889543,
-0.7461385131,
-0.7223419547,
0.8496040106,
0.1707615256,
-0.5981086493,
-0.1386434287,
-0.0506830774,
-0.1029449627,
-0.9852280617,
0.6209607124,
0.3306387663,
-0.0204689279,
-0.488250792,
-0.1509643793,
0.1590935588,
0.0263623949,
0.7614469528,
-0.0586432666,
-0.7342284322,
-0.2138214409,
-0.0879657716,
-0.0233593378,
0.0509471707,
0.7101191878,
-0.4825911522,
0.4504700899,
0.6221923232,
0.7381566167,
0.5593032837,
-0.2566792369,
0.7515808344,
-0.5070853829,
0.2573336363,
0.0974173769,
0.3631209433,
0.5890247822,
-0.2125960141,
0.6708851457,
0.2311653793,
-0.3282519281,
-0.7303389311,
0.2481603026,
-0.7261430025,
-0.2631267905,
1.0907825232,
-0.4223254919,
0.1559847146,
0.0485004745,
0.1335784346,
0.2837916315,
0.2681906521,
0.6985033154,
1.0123226643,
0.0390332974,
-0.0541690364,
-0.9474700093,
0.0831531882,
0.5487977862,
-0.7164998055,
-0.3768557012,
0.1571980715,
0.6050636172,
0.0160244964,
0.499617666,
-0.1055946201,
0.2211613506,
-0.5466991067,
0.1719572097,
0.2743274271,
-0.0058284099,
-0.5115845799,
0.0079963729,
0.3052595556,
-0.0438978262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14503v1 | Overview of the CAIL 2023 Argument Mining Track | 2024-06-20T17:06:13 | 2024-06-20T17:06:13 | Jingcong Liang, Junlong Wang, Xinyu Zhai, Yungui Zhuang, Yiyang Zheng, Xin Xu, Xiandong Ran, Xiaozheng Dong, Honghui Rong, Yanlun Liu, Hao Chen, Yuhan Wei, Donghai Li, Jiajie Peng, Xuanjing Huang, Chongde Shi, Yansong Feng, Yun Song, Zhongyu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | We give a detailed overview of the CAIL 2023 Argument Mining Track, one of
the Chinese AI and Law Challenge (CAIL) 2023 tracks. The main goal of the track
is to identify and extract interacting argument pairs in trial dialogs. It
mainly uses summarized judgment documents but can also refer to trial
recordings. The track consists of two stages, and we introduce the tasks
designed for each stage; we also extend the data from previous events into a
new dataset -- CAIL2023-ArgMine -- with annotated new cases from various causes
of action. We outline several submissions that achieve the best results,
including their methods for different stages. While all submissions rely on
language models, they have incorporated strategies that may benefit future work
in this field. | [
-0.3206846714,
-0.694848299,
0.6564654708,
0.2209648192,
-0.2433171719,
-0.1542426199,
0.2277664244,
-0.5279182196,
-0.2277339995,
0.7111725211,
-0.5248008966,
-0.5652172565,
-0.3854772151,
-0.3475972414,
-0.4766345322,
1.5644080639,
-0.1386252791,
0.4033729136,
-0.046379175,
-0.3149789274,
-0.6085168123,
-0.5754552484,
-1.2016946077,
-0.3295095265,
0.7866927981,
0.3190342486,
0.3599932492,
0.7788838744,
0.2531349063,
0.2730766833,
-0.1659273207,
-0.2471835911,
-0.0979763716,
0.0250917487,
0.0378305577,
-0.4301480055,
-0.5092366934,
0.2036786228,
0.4847576916,
0.4880956709,
-0.2858433425,
0.0250412431,
-0.1053005978,
0.2123396248,
-0.4292398691,
0.1466709077,
-0.4755163193,
0.0696474165,
-0.4648815393,
-0.00427726,
-0.4380892515,
-0.0720677078,
0.1752893776,
-0.4758684933,
0.2745108604,
0.3382780254,
0.9642854333,
-0.0602807552,
-0.4922830462,
-0.6760924459,
-0.3118765056,
0.6742236614,
-0.9576534629,
-0.1465048641,
0.1620122194,
0.3118605316,
-0.3071691394,
-1.1220593452,
-0.3187670112,
-0.3725001514,
-0.1379446536,
0.173549518,
-0.0620213635,
0.4982886314,
0.2489542365,
0.3651053011,
-0.3879353702,
-0.0404297374,
-0.4363654554,
-0.440762341,
1.0378825665,
0.2088101506,
0.3466461897,
-0.0678148493,
-0.430896163,
-0.0608194023,
-0.610044539,
0.174365595,
0.6745563149,
0.1229566485,
-0.1778425574,
0.3329790533,
-0.0636955798,
0.6695972085,
-0.0551068522,
0.2513454854,
-0.1460063607,
-0.3616947532,
-0.1284939945,
0.327392906,
1.1447519064,
0.1733675748,
-0.1689639986,
0.0554915592,
-0.2799503207,
-0.3843157291,
-0.0640963092,
-0.4538296759,
-0.618940115,
0.4714606702,
-0.7750153542,
-0.2769857645,
-0.0050892346,
-0.8945687413,
-0.8374859095,
-0.1181092858,
0.3865358233,
-0.0411719158,
-0.129198283,
0.0810012966,
-0.3866914511,
0.4696456492,
0.4287276268,
-0.7012512088,
0.4935617447,
1.0294401646,
0.7513639331,
-0.0242253132,
-0.0091515798,
-1.2649327517,
-0.0392496176,
-0.3580889404,
1.0785659552,
-0.5219217539,
-0.417093426,
0.2265371382,
-0.0421930589,
-0.0562421568,
-0.5878807902,
1.2042256594,
-0.3818406165,
0.3971705735,
-0.5168708563,
-0.5296939611,
-0.3338952959,
0.2662299275,
-0.9335571527,
0.8669072986,
-0.2980189025,
-0.5545847416,
0.4951399863,
-1.2314733267,
-0.4779955149,
0.3055138588,
-0.2182848752,
-0.4179241955,
-0.2085034102,
0.0181251056,
0.1847081035,
-0.4107566476,
0.5426720977,
-0.3433036804,
-0.0657296106,
-0.2805140913,
-0.2978818417,
1.1015503407,
0.5323655009,
-0.4308924973,
0.2130703628,
-0.6238324642,
-0.4181375802,
-0.0035949275,
-0.3437528908,
0.1291589886,
0.5150791407,
0.1312912852,
0.4123626649,
0.4519316852,
-0.6693835258,
0.0895030946,
-0.0850419775,
0.5076565742,
0.8009066582,
0.3497489095,
-0.2042917311,
-0.2878241241,
0.5020778179,
0.1918919086,
0.2508104444,
-0.361461103,
-0.7434741855,
-1.1202501059,
0.3360354304,
0.5494698882,
0.5228798985,
-0.2433777303,
-0.066406168,
0.1796760261,
-0.3015977442,
-0.5102266669,
0.0297155827,
0.3353956342,
0.2169630677,
0.3006055057,
-0.2771800756,
-0.8584207892,
-0.9225001335,
-0.3825478852,
-0.6779723167,
0.3790658414,
0.3558136821,
0.5264789462,
0.3954985738,
0.7128126025,
-0.1432409734,
-0.1173786595,
-0.2276990116,
0.7529101372,
0.1771063805,
0.659455061,
0.4205753505,
-0.9729853868,
-0.328789264,
0.1892302632,
-0.7806623578,
-0.0710825324,
-0.4228489697,
-0.1680705696,
-0.0287539996,
0.6954599023,
-0.1958725005,
0.4573954344,
0.1125365645,
-0.5139945745,
0.3991042972,
0.147622034,
0.2467668653,
-0.9002007246,
-0.1849107593,
0.2042985409,
-0.1281677186,
-0.7521024942,
-0.0956011713,
-0.3861213326,
0.0653954819,
-0.5567160845,
0.4811847508,
-0.240193978,
0.2212706655,
-0.2183395773,
0.0394416712,
-0.105331637,
0.4008130133,
0.2390021384,
0.3388568461,
0.4370772839,
-0.3393007517,
0.5828031898,
0.1008347124,
-0.1762698293,
0.3855846524,
-0.7257902026,
0.2560223639,
0.1518315375,
0.2286753207,
-0.9060444832,
-0.2038905174,
0.2826251388,
-0.4509449601,
0.0183735546,
-0.4488975108,
-0.3007763028,
-0.2804639339,
-0.3143074512,
0.169721216,
0.178755343,
-0.4593946636,
0.7835883498,
0.5260674357,
-0.2432991713,
-0.5667187572,
-0.4131011963,
0.6438128948,
-0.6712185144,
-0.3083627522,
0.3243225217,
-0.2063284963,
-0.6210707426,
0.0323273763,
0.3802911341,
-0.0119213173,
0.2182194144,
0.3264496624,
0.1337800622,
-0.3665059209,
-0.1434285343,
-0.4187192917,
0.1900866628,
0.6747900844,
-0.0268908832,
0.5506176949,
-0.0953064412,
-0.3744242191,
-0.4168054163,
0.746617198,
0.1418832839,
-0.0844375268,
0.3366301954,
0.5584962964,
-0.50638026,
0.1815732569,
-0.5178642869,
0.3061652184,
-0.4944469631,
0.3041520417,
-0.2435474098,
-0.6223165393,
0.6212823391,
-0.0924714059,
0.8580746055,
0.7698839307,
0.7701746225,
0.0205325261,
1.5695977211,
0.4451631308,
-0.4157996774,
0.4604626,
-0.0225424878,
0.3297439516,
-0.7753732204,
-0.4795997143,
-0.672216773,
0.0154141076,
-0.3972522616,
-0.1956481487,
0.0094713457,
0.1065300778,
-0.4765103459,
0.3806482255,
-0.034316957,
0.2424515486,
0.7285293341,
-0.1968860328,
0.0464588292,
-0.5743170977,
-0.091816619,
0.3771829009,
-0.6380347013,
-0.6061027646,
0.8465771675,
0.440710485,
0.1107189879,
0.0505299866,
0.8238586187,
0.7737130523,
0.3855222762,
-0.6443197727,
0.7217856646,
0.0040659672,
-0.8564628959,
0.2128567845,
-0.0504378043,
-0.9040493369,
0.0914835557,
-0.2098179162,
-0.9309222102,
-0.0672499016,
-0.063832134,
-0.5580946803,
0.5035421252,
-0.5400534272,
0.9072602987,
-0.3982699215,
-0.4767334759,
-0.185830757,
-0.7321873307,
0.490950942,
0.3581997156,
0.2093895227,
-0.0550886728,
0.4109759033,
1.2723189592,
-0.5640521049,
0.563977778,
-0.5107676387,
-0.2056078315,
0.826508224,
-0.2230594903,
0.474804163,
0.1716850996,
-0.1239765584,
-0.3178315461,
0.1571150869,
-0.3677914739,
-0.3864690363,
0.6363386512,
-0.5847542882,
-0.9627407193,
-0.6156092286,
-0.5297659636,
-0.0970551893,
0.0545306429,
-0.0389584154,
0.6342312694,
-0.3139659762,
0.0602705665,
0.3165231347,
-0.0306164455,
0.7996993065,
0.1890880764,
0.0655788109,
-0.5274482369,
0.7968116403,
-0.2292332649,
-0.2049539834,
0.0649960414,
0.1759741157,
-0.4755405784,
-1.0064605474,
-0.4293014407,
-0.03506108,
-0.8157694936,
0.0228329208,
-0.784744978,
-0.2930415571,
-0.6338259578,
-0.0083084377,
-0.0953050479,
-0.2772507668,
-0.0971717015,
0.0497101732,
0.1081405431,
1.0564950705,
-0.156063661,
0.3569459915,
-0.6756873727,
0.2382941246,
0.3224554062,
0.1217237338,
-0.099594079,
-0.3650037348,
-0.3478441238,
0.15755032,
-0.553358078,
-0.652012825,
0.1446241289,
0.1215795875,
0.8200955391,
0.6304962039,
-0.0128220851,
0.9359766245,
-0.3746521473,
1.4646141529,
0.1548835039,
-0.7745380998,
0.8791052699,
-0.4365866184,
-0.4587044716,
0.5331761837,
0.1533549428,
-0.5394082665,
-0.0521933399,
-0.8892452717,
-0.6739732623,
0.706882596,
0.0312256031,
-0.2586525381,
0.0522634462,
0.4383945167,
-0.2458882928,
-0.1430372894,
-1.0138112307,
-0.1431519836,
0.0409068987,
-0.3226574063,
0.3062442243,
-0.1309961826,
-0.5419766307,
-0.0522423647,
0.753880024,
-0.0053124507,
0.1395085305,
0.0391968712,
0.1641132832,
0.0794892013,
0.0936541557,
0.4176439047,
0.3620803356,
-0.1198870391,
-0.0772047639,
0.4233189225,
-0.4351275265,
-0.1106141508,
0.2829155624,
0.0038417717,
-0.0742484257,
0.7815160155,
0.9998525381,
-0.2749464214,
-0.8256220818,
0.5122184157,
-0.2356785536,
-0.6379102468,
-0.5446614027,
0.1629815996,
-0.2291532159,
0.6161770821,
0.3864417672,
-0.0303419139,
0.600294292,
-0.8471426368,
0.2512843013,
0.3509673178,
-0.9096633792,
-0.2830553949,
1.0946301222,
0.1938921511,
-0.3892095089,
0.1490131617,
-0.0429808684,
-0.6675192714,
0.6651706696,
0.3558107615,
0.9127855897,
0.3823278546,
0.0212525316,
0.377199322,
-0.1770468056,
-0.0691650659,
0.0306063294,
-0.2763676941,
-0.3883185089,
-0.4382521808,
-0.3225474656,
-0.4967895448,
0.4294704795,
-0.7892555594,
0.6285840869,
-0.4602830708,
0.171831727,
0.1512108743,
0.5634617805,
-0.1920474768,
0.2003991455,
0.4944860041,
0.9617848396,
-0.8768485785,
0.7634578943,
0.8447667956,
-0.3364706933,
-0.6608231664,
-0.1450302154,
0.3064237237,
-0.590267241,
0.3899442255,
0.0233949106,
-0.0433230698,
-0.2982369363,
-0.9893610477,
-0.0438785069,
1.1241986752,
0.0600411706,
-0.2343171984,
0.0214349348,
0.0405826047,
0.3839139044,
-0.5029557347,
0.2373021692,
0.8281604648,
0.5440431237,
0.2646095753,
-0.525532186,
-0.2378360331,
-0.6566847563,
-0.4256903231,
-0.0214808546,
-0.838798821,
0.9518409371,
-0.1247722656,
-0.3203404546,
0.4919890463,
0.9758570194,
0.5322737098,
0.6057533622,
0.8226533532,
0.5608458519,
0.6252117157,
-0.2163186073,
0.8328744173,
-0.2020600289,
0.2184276283,
1.1996127367,
-0.4507229626,
0.5824050903,
0.3691400886,
-0.2098993212,
0.706346333,
1.1035419703,
-0.1091485396,
0.2980241776,
0.2102780938,
-0.5758597851,
-0.5745070577,
-0.6162166595,
-0.1754027009,
0.334189117,
0.3595684171,
-0.1485395432,
-0.2422272563,
-0.4210993946,
0.4249381423,
-0.0007016915,
-0.3098818064,
0.9480146766,
-0.1328247041,
-1.1839716434,
-0.0631612688,
0.0911883414,
0.2890814543,
-0.4163727164,
-0.5515266061,
-0.1433210671,
0.0651452243,
-0.0711347163,
-0.9256159067,
-0.1829816699,
0.1345435232,
0.2289146483,
0.0679213256,
0.6273159981,
-0.4041292965,
-0.3148230016,
0.2061104327,
0.0521349497,
0.197749123,
0.1547727287,
-1.0161041021,
-0.2892854214,
0.2247903198,
-0.1594047844,
0.2310793102,
0.6018865108,
-0.3816392422,
0.4070511758,
0.7116324306,
0.3230925202,
0.342852056,
0.229372099,
0.9365947247,
-0.8758780956,
-0.0997816995,
-0.9374668598,
0.4946726263,
-0.4732030034,
-0.4937925339,
0.5315236449,
0.8022491336,
0.2960935533,
0.5359166861,
0.9428215623,
-0.4686379433,
0.4043391943,
-0.6221145988,
0.317991823,
-0.3265703917,
0.1833619922,
-0.1013866514,
-0.3113231063,
-0.3232460022,
0.3704562485,
-0.049303256,
-0.0451277718,
0.5154241323,
0.6297411919,
0.2494701147,
0.4455200732,
-0.0413317867,
-0.0847405568,
0.904245019,
1.0271946192,
1.0622339249,
-0.9169040322,
0.7025445104,
-0.1637687832,
0.0835888907,
-0.0763158724,
-1.1024230719,
-0.7745741606,
-0.7679507732,
-0.5300225019,
-0.5317153335,
-0.001991746,
0.6728928089,
0.7342982292,
-1.1782605648,
-0.4373165369,
-0.347510159,
0.0502831638,
0.0017114743,
-0.1905931532,
0.4825012982,
-0.4994686842,
-0.7754326463,
0.3892430961,
0.1564088315,
-0.2732168734,
0.0371365845,
-0.2200787514,
-0.8707174063,
0.0546446741,
0.311409086,
0.5871499181,
-0.6818080544,
-0.580513835,
-0.3539798856,
0.3158140182,
0.148496449,
1.1220376492,
-0.5653826594,
0.4251320362,
0.3908896148,
0.3885556757,
0.5253952146,
0.2178413421,
0.7518302798,
-0.3311244249,
0.1199771315,
0.2154293507,
0.7690970302,
0.1084767431,
-0.0167782567,
0.6739025116,
0.1545850933,
-0.6879487038,
-0.8122436404,
-0.0248275027,
-1.0554170609,
0.0996948257,
1.1397684813,
-0.5751953125,
-0.1532509327,
-0.6339577436,
-0.3945786953,
0.3467915952,
-0.1848315299,
0.5560357571,
1.1107628345,
-0.4451102614,
-0.1924328804,
-0.825778842,
0.6074515581,
0.3987758756,
-0.738560915,
0.1028722227,
0.5947952867,
-0.114253439,
0.2262504846,
0.5071684718,
-0.5078051686,
0.4378719628,
0.1200532243,
-0.0702103078,
0.2493890226,
-0.2094634175,
-0.2810674012,
0.3422016799,
0.2480172068,
-0.2649682462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14500v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14500v1 | Improving Expert Radiology Report Summarization by Prompting Large Language Models with a Layperson Summary | 2024-06-20T17:01:55 | 2024-06-20T17:01:55 | Xingmeng Zhao, Tongnian Wang, Anthony Rios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Radiology report summarization (RRS) is crucial for patient care, requiring
concise "Impressions" from detailed "Findings." This paper introduces a novel
prompting strategy to enhance RRS by first generating a layperson summary. This
approach normalizes key observations and simplifies complex information using
non-expert communication techniques inspired by doctor-patient interactions.
Combined with few-shot in-context learning, this method improves the model's
ability to link general terms to specific findings. We evaluate this approach
on the MIMIC-CXR, CheXpert, and MIMIC-III datasets, benchmarking it against
7B/8B parameter state-of-the-art open-source large language models (LLMs) like
Meta-Llama-3-8B-Instruct. Our results demonstrate improvements in summarization
accuracy and accessibility, particularly in out-of-domain tests, with
improvements as high as 5% for some metrics. | [
-0.2626859844,
-0.2709698677,
0.6495258212,
0.0664748475,
-0.4754249156,
-0.1056898981,
-0.2608370185,
-0.4503058195,
0.2666321397,
0.4420461655,
-0.2452576309,
-0.4724617898,
-0.7436871529,
0.4304168224,
-0.1717743874,
1.0682002306,
0.1368656456,
0.3754402697,
-0.0121976295,
-0.1282723248,
-0.4646858573,
0.0516054556,
-0.6452980638,
-0.4409330189,
0.6832184196,
0.6185286045,
0.9418072701,
0.7160326242,
0.5432664156,
0.1400309205,
-0.0682793632,
0.2800159454,
-0.4032927155,
0.1529789418,
-0.0505361967,
-0.3779296279,
-0.701346457,
-0.2998074293,
0.4233753383,
1.0578389168,
-0.0847181305,
-0.0569763184,
0.0446820036,
0.6972472072,
-0.5809031725,
0.1982293874,
-0.2616622746,
-0.0928220004,
-0.0366396792,
-0.7922633886,
-0.6793653965,
-0.4024585485,
0.3502230644,
-0.548379302,
0.2870509326,
-0.0596410409,
0.5973610878,
0.0314139463,
-0.467397511,
-0.2700566947,
-0.6574030519,
0.5437239408,
-0.7501968145,
0.2207537889,
0.3406980634,
0.4141992033,
-0.070655033,
-0.7206045389,
-0.1904393733,
-0.3773137033,
-0.3548257947,
0.3839604557,
-0.4792196453,
0.1080120727,
0.3368319869,
0.0272108559,
-0.5128129125,
0.0113646388,
-0.3741181195,
-0.0511606298,
0.5579557419,
0.3458034098,
0.1884212792,
-0.162291348,
-0.1581610739,
-0.1551456153,
-0.9157606959,
-0.2592124343,
-0.1314964443,
0.4468241632,
-0.270667702,
0.4689441919,
-0.6552644968,
0.7270222902,
0.212602973,
-0.3341312706,
0.2168283612,
-0.1651060581,
-0.1397146583,
0.0384777784,
0.631043613,
0.7302120924,
0.2388190329,
0.0575560927,
-0.1538149863,
-0.2806559205,
-0.1450396478,
-0.8190233111,
-0.5518323779,
0.2314574569,
-0.8306694031,
-0.3465394676,
0.092353493,
-0.6800436974,
-0.4417720735,
-0.2815678716,
0.4334326684,
-0.4132789075,
-0.3307712376,
0.1898462623,
-0.0185308196,
0.1769728512,
0.6503663063,
-0.6336912513,
0.4304371178,
0.2375191003,
0.6305883527,
0.2433751076,
0.0030543988,
-1.0026195049,
0.4105852246,
-0.267133981,
1.1831040382,
-0.5759161115,
-0.6328544617,
-0.2417602539,
-0.2985379398,
0.0049656541,
-0.5735289454,
0.0007324131,
-0.2778005004,
0.4830934405,
-0.2707828283,
-0.3607652783,
-0.0469814464,
0.0654990599,
-0.2711497247,
0.7229056954,
0.0983455777,
-0.7495566607,
0.1753100455,
-0.5495845079,
-0.6028451324,
0.2284749299,
-0.3585241437,
-0.1900967807,
0.2518493533,
0.5692564845,
0.6792651415,
-0.1581938267,
0.224588722,
0.1241687462,
-0.1870476007,
0.1810799241,
-0.0044294265,
0.2778226137,
0.19405891,
0.0824492574,
0.2618019879,
-0.3770837784,
-0.0217590556,
-0.0030970273,
-0.0155386459,
-0.316822201,
-0.186635673,
-0.255328238,
0.0728714541,
-0.0154795516,
-0.1264163107,
0.1672089398,
-0.2691811025,
0.0446030311,
0.4225824773,
0.3099388182,
0.4116077721,
-0.6558705568,
0.587127924,
-0.0822917521,
0.1398762167,
-0.7970184088,
-0.3827345371,
-0.6170014143,
-0.4947336912,
0.4318045676,
0.3107708693,
-0.5632183552,
-0.0918711722,
-0.6016380191,
-0.3900205791,
-0.359775871,
-0.1393434256,
0.6019745469,
0.8693047762,
0.5402696729,
-0.2612526119,
-0.5124171972,
-0.9313871264,
-0.3207304776,
0.0242638104,
-0.3761273026,
0.2091754824,
0.2263048738,
-0.0620130263,
0.804302752,
-0.8007231355,
-0.4459451139,
-0.7719900012,
0.5054962039,
0.11261639,
0.1623697281,
0.3496766388,
-0.3538242579,
-0.7784733176,
-0.0222302955,
-0.6508583426,
-0.2853659391,
-0.1568817347,
0.1762330234,
0.2218679786,
0.8009091616,
-0.4377113879,
0.4881136715,
0.1688401103,
0.0321961381,
0.3031154275,
-0.548864007,
0.2383218408,
-1.1263282299,
0.220810771,
-0.0863964111,
-0.4180984199,
-0.6836104989,
-0.033911664,
0.1236598715,
-0.0134292869,
-0.2776468694,
0.3514192402,
-0.7921987176,
-0.0167010892,
-0.4137962162,
0.1000838578,
-0.078790918,
0.107357271,
0.4471571445,
0.4660033584,
0.5505055189,
-0.6528996825,
-0.1428547949,
0.4132257402,
-0.1418991238,
0.3706364632,
-0.797254324,
0.1640459448,
-0.5159999132,
0.6014676094,
-0.9195226431,
-0.6171187162,
0.039062351,
-0.611276865,
0.5135044456,
-0.1870351583,
-0.179354921,
-0.0158977415,
-0.3549748361,
0.1110064983,
0.5218104124,
-0.1424018145,
0.8584438562,
0.0985381082,
-0.5812113881,
-0.5183907151,
-0.5556297898,
0.5151702762,
0.0658740476,
-0.4304391444,
0.2701743841,
-0.102377668,
-0.359479934,
-0.1631911695,
0.0014520149,
-0.0453325547,
-0.1869404912,
-0.0788384154,
0.3580958545,
-0.2683555186,
-0.0230663754,
0.0156173883,
-0.2801586092,
0.0290134493,
0.2367838025,
0.4668653905,
0.0254070535,
-0.04787926,
-0.7030168176,
0.5348010659,
0.4222812057,
-0.1148965806,
0.3177044988,
0.208662197,
-0.2705874145,
-0.1144137979,
-0.4514774382,
-0.6602967381,
-0.362971276,
0.4184163511,
-0.3087455034,
-0.6375110745,
0.3713194132,
-0.1357957125,
0.0128674787,
0.2062627077,
0.4612668753,
-0.2685972154,
1.0920221806,
0.6682744622,
-0.0039143665,
0.1556421667,
-0.1012626365,
0.0835053548,
-0.7893518806,
-0.4314751923,
-0.463127166,
0.1312414408,
-0.2261153758,
-0.3927096426,
0.8195121884,
-0.281480521,
0.3891057968,
-0.0563614592,
-0.2359687388,
0.6517553329,
0.1306858808,
0.4583314657,
0.5100819468,
0.0341674499,
0.2299563587,
-0.1104148105,
-0.8712905645,
-0.408046484,
1.1574386358,
0.3428601921,
0.9988524318,
0.1743223071,
0.8469745517,
0.137575537,
0.4634869099,
-0.7554014921,
0.5401558876,
-0.0417036936,
-0.0464391448,
-0.1854538918,
-0.3332389891,
-0.8847286701,
0.1177289486,
-0.3515430689,
-0.1764127463,
-0.0638886914,
0.3324815035,
-0.870667994,
-0.206255734,
-0.4504588246,
0.1804151088,
0.1320991516,
-0.063992843,
-0.398562938,
-0.916102469,
0.4353547394,
0.2786027491,
0.3891591728,
0.0932995006,
-0.3033266664,
0.4492257833,
-0.4801929295,
0.892257452,
-0.0175980069,
0.0231318958,
-0.0959227607,
0.4555095434,
0.6929997206,
0.0584561266,
0.2494032383,
-0.2792307734,
-0.32352826,
-0.2592534423,
-0.6462578773,
0.5002833009,
-0.5903804302,
-0.4975295365,
-0.4446516931,
-0.6528776884,
-0.3750888407,
0.110480845,
0.4804244041,
0.8318625689,
-0.0989297852,
0.0644975156,
1.1195880175,
-0.2338710129,
0.1614520252,
0.775285542,
0.0396045782,
-0.3273825347,
0.5112678409,
-0.0308450535,
0.4294891953,
0.6208413839,
0.6028128862,
-0.1706418097,
-0.7891583443,
-0.2154547274,
0.3243021965,
-0.8652082682,
-0.4685031474,
-1.0008188486,
0.0213274788,
-0.58915627,
-0.308888495,
-0.0665159822,
-0.4211452007,
-0.093088977,
0.0384000391,
0.4906724095,
1.000048995,
-0.0471097939,
0.4023800492,
-0.7997028232,
0.3738205731,
0.2407161891,
0.0747517049,
0.1337880045,
-0.9146205783,
-0.2283469439,
-0.2499699146,
0.0368487835,
-0.8963716626,
0.4505639374,
0.2343107909,
0.4880697429,
0.4349889755,
0.2050412297,
0.7342415452,
-0.239737764,
0.5170841217,
0.4061399698,
-0.7751528025,
0.6574438214,
-0.8481913805,
0.6304955482,
0.4832251668,
0.3783506751,
-0.5177704096,
-0.5829539299,
-0.4783087671,
-0.8227612972,
0.5579112172,
-0.0336645171,
0.0179845057,
-0.062376067,
0.2621854246,
0.0714882687,
-0.1354798228,
-0.4121938944,
-0.0052589127,
0.0078601819,
-0.2936997712,
0.1011024714,
-0.3939404786,
-0.3721059263,
-0.0799665377,
0.5313712955,
-0.4896597564,
0.2231304199,
0.4630160332,
-0.2473176569,
-0.2598703206,
0.291086942,
0.9717292786,
1.0179761648,
-0.2063215077,
0.2934897542,
0.5369979739,
-0.3433040082,
-0.3240210116,
-0.3354269862,
-0.0103269164,
0.153012529,
0.7623032928,
0.3609650433,
0.3701617718,
-0.416246295,
0.6571694016,
-0.2342649251,
-0.3302494586,
-0.0669300333,
0.0833405629,
0.1065517962,
-0.0870060846,
0.6274616122,
0.2120007873,
0.2160645127,
-0.3101163507,
0.2878862321,
0.2046423107,
-0.2749209702,
-0.2636421621,
0.5305886865,
0.3251192868,
0.1506024301,
0.3322657049,
0.3337433636,
-0.1672032624,
0.4047273993,
0.4463886619,
0.6518059969,
-0.3263634741,
0.3156992495,
0.6797340512,
0.2511098385,
-0.401602,
0.2973859012,
0.0341685042,
-0.2463049144,
-0.6746321321,
0.2694796324,
-0.7011380196,
0.05271025,
-0.9819452763,
0.5044825077,
-0.6885318756,
0.1842253059,
0.1278275847,
-0.3132443726,
-0.2775233388,
0.2968256474,
0.0645368472,
1.108096838,
-0.7501723766,
0.6801655293,
0.5455706716,
-0.3534096479,
-0.9580415487,
0.1274277121,
-0.0872455314,
-0.6959953308,
0.7201758027,
0.0500944145,
-0.3720430434,
-0.0040802183,
-0.6547793746,
-0.7244978547,
1.087808013,
0.2181185037,
-0.4828801155,
0.0735469162,
-0.1474448293,
0.5009298325,
-0.5775696039,
0.7144380808,
0.1468666047,
0.4083418846,
0.1678640991,
-0.934528172,
0.3338179886,
-0.0707074255,
-0.2127489895,
0.0952160433,
-0.5436571836,
0.6257297993,
-0.6924841404,
-0.0912646577,
0.0004345184,
0.8510040641,
0.1446788311,
0.2019714415,
0.4228462875,
0.1215837002,
0.7918431759,
0.1393053383,
1.2160276175,
-0.2338193059,
-0.0928129926,
1.2693874836,
-0.2762863934,
0.7223560214,
0.271649003,
0.0724885389,
0.6724362969,
0.3600789905,
0.1864653528,
0.5133804083,
-0.1778469831,
-0.2638555467,
-0.5068255663,
-0.2609812617,
-0.5524958372,
0.2700113058,
0.255197823,
-0.3711358309,
-0.4466634989,
-0.1582369506,
0.368708998,
0.1142640188,
-0.3311894238,
0.9829395413,
0.1950573474,
-0.7959410548,
0.6722019315,
-0.0777022317,
0.4193068147,
-0.9079699516,
-0.0815231875,
-0.4817647636,
0.0924356356,
-0.5469095707,
-0.6306988597,
0.2877813578,
0.017694328,
-0.3440137804,
-0.1404311508,
0.4431259632,
-0.4681110084,
-0.1546077281,
-0.0157356281,
0.3693902791,
0.1280437261,
0.1711608917,
-0.3230476677,
-0.0079846773,
0.021879958,
-0.1378298551,
0.505428791,
0.1157471091,
-0.3218979537,
0.826077342,
0.5236467719,
0.1300406754,
-0.4427963793,
0.3380138874,
0.9448777437,
-0.6005995274,
-0.508284688,
-0.5153419971,
0.5066836476,
-0.0518112443,
-0.3122652769,
0.7046595216,
0.4397122562,
0.4464624524,
-0.0937021673,
0.8119508028,
0.1585368514,
0.7668993473,
-0.5832956433,
0.5502638221,
-0.2649505436,
0.2640612125,
-0.3489824533,
-0.4653244317,
-0.5678449869,
0.4659079611,
-0.2206380069,
0.0639715269,
0.8685516119,
0.9262632728,
-0.1217471808,
-0.0825741217,
0.3563967347,
0.3844134808,
0.0970261618,
0.4312660396,
0.741126895,
-0.1765586287,
0.6411693096,
-0.0347102471,
-0.54637748,
-0.430742234,
-0.9794409275,
-1.0432845354,
-0.1529887468,
-0.6520885229,
-0.4287659526,
0.0609534532,
0.9969362617,
0.7182047367,
-0.6207097173,
-0.203737691,
0.3326749802,
-0.261988163,
-0.1199593246,
-0.1676915437,
0.4827838242,
-0.2498654723,
-0.3798221946,
0.5299528241,
0.3399864435,
0.1432905644,
-0.054213237,
-0.1759874225,
0.3487338424,
0.0307146236,
0.5081358552,
0.1770973355,
-0.3855509162,
0.0113078719,
0.2488072366,
-0.1585185379,
0.0739623308,
0.9020742774,
-0.844999969,
0.4566862285,
0.5093849897,
0.100556083,
0.3128680289,
0.0302048083,
0.7206408978,
-0.6053370237,
0.0023686397,
0.3367410302,
0.1673886776,
0.476162076,
-0.5456830859,
0.2876228094,
-0.1037143096,
-0.3194920123,
-0.7503516078,
0.2763507068,
-1.0098999739,
-0.4136605561,
1.0864082575,
-0.0908866152,
-0.0162989739,
-0.3522334397,
-0.2549186945,
-0.0195669401,
-0.5090588927,
0.7900778651,
0.0804800987,
-0.5064444542,
-0.480427742,
-0.3515942693,
0.6150365472,
0.4607495964,
-0.7335998416,
0.0823876336,
0.4978184104,
0.6710404158,
-0.2439058274,
0.9951819181,
-0.174022615,
0.6652781963,
-0.4436944127,
0.0567561537,
-0.3900425136,
-0.3818173409,
-0.4764117897,
0.1121636257,
0.0740986168,
0.263010323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14498v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14498v1 | LLaSA: Large Multimodal Agent for Human Activity Analysis Through Wearable Sensors | 2024-06-20T17:00:34 | 2024-06-20T17:00:34 | Sheikh Asif Imran, Mohammad Nur Hossain Khan, Subrata Biswas, Bashima Islam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Integrating inertial measurement units (IMUs) with large language models
(LLMs) advances multimodal AI by enhancing human activity understanding. We
introduce SensorCaps, a dataset of 26,288 IMU-derived activity narrations, and
OpenSQA, an instruction-following dataset with 257,562 question-answer pairs.
Combining LIMU-BERT and Llama, we develop LLaSA, a Large Multimodal Agent
capable of interpreting and responding to activity and motion analysis queries.
Our evaluation demonstrates LLaSA's effectiveness in activity classification
and question answering, highlighting its potential in healthcare, sports
science, and human-computer interaction. These contributions advance
sensor-aware language models and open new research avenues. Our code repository
and datasets can be found on https://github.com/BASHLab/LLaSA. | [
0.1520767361,
-0.7036576867,
0.7744954228,
0.1329911947,
-0.1542935818,
0.3255427778,
0.0774345323,
-0.7210916877,
0.6012439728,
0.3084646761,
-0.7682960629,
-0.3183729053,
-0.5022959113,
-0.2294949293,
-0.3109695017,
0.6601032615,
-0.2187150717,
0.1477276236,
-0.3796522617,
-0.5150325298,
-0.3756715059,
-0.4264714122,
-0.3283910155,
-0.3841621578,
0.5137249827,
0.6011919379,
0.3850136399,
-0.1139404774,
0.395206511,
0.4313125312,
0.2052551806,
0.6976054311,
-0.1796580553,
0.5683823824,
0.5163905621,
-0.4685838223,
-0.5648886561,
-0.1162582785,
0.7956110239,
0.4619838595,
0.0950803906,
0.2718367577,
-0.2626090646,
0.2832198739,
-0.633539021,
0.2069311589,
0.1716276556,
-0.2008047551,
-0.1059753373,
0.0388774686,
0.0114841154,
0.1678507924,
-0.1101363674,
-0.6136456132,
-0.3445469439,
0.0334055685,
0.1967348903,
0.5263199806,
-0.392731905,
-0.3811669946,
-0.5724769235,
0.8394966125,
-0.38973248,
0.6019381285,
0.5262207389,
0.254722327,
-0.1233824119,
-0.6290000081,
-0.6927686334,
-0.4279505312,
0.1128720269,
0.0686813593,
-0.0747356191,
-0.2034069747,
-0.1509824991,
0.0520481393,
-0.5368600488,
0.1944921166,
-0.2569716871,
-0.1124335602,
0.8540421128,
0.3555449545,
0.3575040698,
-0.0573346466,
-0.457547605,
0.1514153779,
-0.557559371,
0.1636434048,
0.1630560756,
0.0683429986,
-0.3701627254,
0.7880990505,
-0.3856262863,
0.4740344286,
-0.3472390473,
-0.6158028841,
0.4873933792,
-0.353943795,
-0.286870718,
0.063854374,
0.6397940516,
0.1264042705,
-0.3817360699,
-0.5130130053,
-0.248243615,
-0.191890493,
0.2366687357,
-0.6535589099,
0.2649918497,
0.6428614259,
-0.2472505718,
-0.0949775726,
-0.0797810256,
-0.5941093564,
-0.8167393208,
-0.4963783622,
0.508305788,
-0.1696652025,
-0.1364022344,
0.2316753417,
0.07625328,
0.3784000874,
0.4791722,
-0.5611264706,
0.1264794618,
0.6408601999,
0.7694476247,
-0.1337676346,
-0.4941339791,
-0.6041623354,
0.1933418214,
-0.0830365792,
0.8354305029,
-0.5969434977,
-0.4461737573,
0.0287112948,
0.2115790397,
-0.1373119205,
-0.1349624842,
0.3805153072,
-0.5643599629,
0.0133576822,
-0.0863072425,
-0.3019129038,
-0.3343863189,
0.4846772552,
-0.6482658386,
1.1837605238,
0.0378317907,
-0.0670166537,
0.1571744531,
-1.2275356054,
-0.5823342204,
0.2379578501,
-0.1327691078,
-0.3004365861,
-0.1144784316,
0.2897382081,
0.5517249703,
-0.5388283134,
0.0155764977,
0.0653533861,
-0.2865380049,
0.7810789347,
-0.2975193858,
0.5465555787,
0.3382364511,
-0.2007208467,
0.3605236709,
-0.7445412278,
-0.3144336045,
-0.0367187299,
-0.4010729194,
0.0509969369,
0.2362937778,
0.0154918339,
-0.23714073,
0.5042725205,
-0.8533650041,
0.1391516626,
0.3014600277,
0.5183967352,
0.658628583,
-0.3004875481,
0.5005001426,
-0.446911037,
0.8834312558,
-0.3410303295,
0.2657160759,
-0.4205079675,
-0.7885354757,
-0.4957050979,
-0.7380877137,
-0.3229935765,
0.5433523655,
-0.6807578802,
0.0064808722,
-0.4146096706,
-0.6985884905,
-0.4880281389,
0.3514692783,
0.2906806767,
0.6427661777,
0.2309224159,
-0.1256758124,
-0.2255757451,
-0.3130323291,
0.1345961243,
-0.4005933702,
-0.0175900329,
0.5569411516,
0.4330207109,
-0.7585870028,
0.5974519849,
-0.348174572,
-0.1752730459,
-0.3648152649,
0.2220885456,
0.0868390501,
0.3041497767,
0.6690911055,
-0.77465868,
-0.1201470122,
0.0757124424,
-0.8690236807,
-0.1051788256,
-0.1900575906,
-0.1632633209,
-0.1011972949,
0.6313480735,
-0.7990649939,
0.2781926095,
0.7139103413,
-0.4292057455,
0.3468851745,
-0.078635335,
0.2893117368,
-1.1078214645,
0.2868463099,
-0.099915348,
-0.3922872245,
-0.8565960526,
0.2015650421,
-0.0479963347,
-0.1221832484,
-0.7047063708,
0.7942659259,
-0.3751106858,
-0.2862914205,
-0.4563503861,
-0.0923826024,
-0.0160262417,
0.3159240186,
-0.2909592688,
1.0179350376,
0.5081578493,
-0.8951001763,
0.7161738873,
0.4836315811,
-0.7430603504,
0.3416492343,
-0.5784016252,
0.4025331736,
-0.3370618224,
0.1098104715,
-1.2776279449,
-0.7763419151,
0.2503870726,
-0.4675395787,
0.1158988997,
0.094452396,
-0.6713405252,
-0.1596988887,
-0.5010852218,
0.6457870603,
0.111481823,
-0.5664118528,
0.955833137,
0.829502821,
-0.0612961352,
-0.6151806116,
-0.7846938968,
0.0432301648,
-0.3178194761,
-0.6268988848,
0.1866905093,
-0.535779953,
-0.3361408412,
-0.3524287641,
0.0952876955,
-0.2728582323,
0.2780215144,
0.4264963567,
0.4626631737,
-0.0609921254,
0.5957435966,
-0.1668862849,
0.0851275101,
-0.0189474784,
0.193343997,
0.6053219438,
-0.1916415691,
-0.4680596292,
-0.7339435816,
0.2847776115,
1.0117362738,
-0.104585439,
0.5627311468,
0.5503910184,
-0.1840938777,
0.4459463656,
-0.2717118859,
0.098631151,
-0.4980800748,
0.3430812359,
-0.074166216,
-0.9113544226,
0.3677100241,
-0.057403449,
0.2801107764,
-0.0617395304,
0.7861894369,
-0.4360699058,
0.7592301965,
0.3487247527,
-0.4000405371,
0.6830282807,
-0.1434464604,
0.0275562592,
-1.0596929789,
-0.4527749121,
-0.4126542509,
-0.8572922349,
-0.4437056184,
-0.652240634,
0.6953938603,
-0.5966425538,
-0.409207046,
0.1616124511,
-0.2102927566,
0.2768752277,
0.5204806328,
0.293617934,
0.0226872023,
-0.1981522739,
0.5521816611,
0.2317433357,
-0.3235013187,
-0.3943320811,
1.148567915,
0.3058713973,
1.1286990643,
0.6535615921,
0.4389839768,
0.4994383752,
0.4255083203,
-1.0532706976,
0.4874179065,
0.1781949103,
-0.7276254892,
-0.4765081108,
0.1536834091,
-1.1492400169,
0.3192569613,
-0.2064525485,
-0.7993227243,
0.1544304639,
-0.03216305,
-0.3945327401,
0.1189994588,
-0.774661541,
0.5174226165,
-0.7226720452,
-0.3730691671,
-0.1144262031,
-0.5463994741,
0.2545947433,
0.1232355759,
0.3681861162,
-0.4226035774,
-0.5530478954,
0.6966956854,
-0.0741489828,
1.1524772644,
-0.1191916391,
-0.131190002,
0.5207782984,
-0.166841045,
0.3426460326,
0.172510609,
-0.0974437222,
0.121792011,
-0.2154869884,
-0.3304157555,
-0.2608881593,
0.7256244421,
-0.8172117472,
-0.2684904337,
-0.4811397493,
-0.657782495,
-0.2831265032,
0.0283354353,
-0.3144869506,
0.2440779656,
-0.2620300055,
0.3240774572,
0.4632263184,
-0.0288342144,
0.605512917,
0.6321461201,
-0.0532125905,
-0.3051403761,
0.7976369858,
-0.2528645396,
-0.3322032392,
0.658139348,
0.1398228556,
-0.3185789287,
-0.4054938257,
-0.4781280756,
0.3898879588,
-0.4903861582,
-0.3804829717,
-0.3896502554,
0.2283523977,
-0.4309708178,
-0.0577394366,
-0.1230592057,
-0.2715290785,
-0.585540235,
-0.2159576863,
0.5140440464,
0.7521215081,
0.0621334128,
0.7028608322,
-0.835573554,
0.5447580814,
0.5978579521,
-0.0181545373,
-0.3280064464,
-0.4021770954,
-0.1377975643,
-0.0384869985,
-0.2401572466,
-0.8251412511,
0.3224627376,
0.3140614331,
0.7279709578,
0.5331270099,
-0.2167027295,
0.5934307575,
-0.240802139,
0.9520390034,
0.3948415518,
-0.6604596972,
0.3715766072,
-0.1297528744,
0.4042427838,
0.4003534615,
0.3188899159,
-0.6182442904,
0.0807006136,
-0.1414338946,
-0.6565254331,
0.8679874539,
0.0641411468,
0.2951673865,
0.1667337418,
0.2838078737,
0.1479426771,
0.2474755347,
-0.7222467661,
0.0146070123,
0.0421934426,
-0.3351795375,
-0.1413664818,
-0.2429893762,
-0.2804321647,
-0.1492865235,
0.5869687796,
-0.4571759999,
0.5161138177,
0.1970083565,
-0.4435624182,
-0.1697772741,
-0.0109041482,
0.8047986031,
0.5574194789,
0.003160788,
-0.027309237,
0.1626071483,
-0.7776767612,
0.0349685065,
0.1002260149,
-0.0350009017,
-0.2202570587,
0.5022648573,
0.5439046025,
0.3027125597,
-1.3246952295,
0.4575245976,
-0.2021475285,
0.1183248758,
-0.5028038621,
0.0319867842,
0.1353187114,
0.4781303704,
0.2653975487,
-0.1847053617,
0.1692911386,
-0.7384822965,
-0.0903596058,
0.4427990019,
-0.4712622464,
-0.5498732328,
0.7226162553,
0.3582271636,
-0.2076717764,
0.4432381094,
0.1446816027,
-0.1523955017,
0.6559156179,
0.0645783246,
0.8178616762,
-0.5198221803,
0.3227537572,
0.1902640164,
0.4498252273,
0.3750573993,
0.7548375726,
-0.3274476528,
-0.7797671556,
-0.4767125547,
-0.5384794474,
-0.6186423898,
0.0750897974,
-0.2451236844,
-0.0787828937,
-0.2341548502,
-0.0306458771,
0.0504037812,
-0.1532241106,
-0.6779477596,
0.1300905794,
0.2933315933,
0.4446058571,
-0.5844002962,
0.8401447535,
0.9426294565,
-0.428948164,
-0.0469145104,
-0.0793255121,
0.0188448168,
-1.2383936644,
0.6269180179,
0.2515237331,
-0.3427293599,
-0.6784043312,
-0.8045279384,
-0.9223463535,
1.6004658937,
0.4138459265,
-0.2464283705,
0.3083725274,
0.298189044,
0.4179971218,
-0.4093438983,
0.0485894047,
0.5544611216,
0.5872983932,
0.0519571938,
-0.7946568727,
-0.3064739406,
-0.0745669082,
-0.5715506673,
0.0197648685,
-1.008752346,
0.7157684565,
-0.2373740822,
0.082807593,
0.4680640697,
0.6816904545,
0.296785295,
0.7505167723,
0.3859271407,
0.3151937723,
1.0830404758,
0.1096045971,
1.1723675728,
-0.0736761391,
-0.1876960695,
0.9783230424,
-0.4137136042,
0.6363678575,
0.3360367715,
-0.129541114,
0.4730505347,
0.4199059904,
0.5499745607,
0.3946092725,
-0.2208950073,
-0.8855579495,
-0.2687752247,
-0.1853011698,
-0.0006416345,
1.0072776079,
0.6331281662,
-0.1618452519,
0.1207471192,
0.1566160321,
0.0724566579,
-0.244764924,
-0.2411408871,
0.6447523236,
-0.2361128032,
-0.6861199141,
0.0049241586,
-0.1086325049,
0.3868953586,
-0.9003814459,
-0.0732784644,
-0.2596653104,
-0.0297110807,
0.0107607227,
-0.8217325807,
-0.0299020242,
0.1223728806,
0.0915697291,
-0.2046473473,
0.6537110209,
-0.1073334813,
-0.5050415993,
0.1081497669,
0.5366287827,
0.3677931428,
0.051953841,
-0.5085113049,
0.1241444573,
-0.1697170287,
-0.1195270196,
0.4045181572,
0.2759886086,
-0.0804402456,
0.8822353482,
0.6553717256,
-0.4561116099,
0.1683263481,
-0.1475054324,
1.070237875,
-0.541975081,
-0.3948635459,
-0.3140270114,
0.6350141168,
0.0255467761,
-0.4678120911,
0.503039062,
0.533260107,
0.14039132,
0.0707289577,
0.7342882156,
-0.1568116695,
0.543515563,
-0.4439851046,
0.5565912724,
-0.713113904,
0.1904930174,
0.2808294296,
-0.519905746,
-0.2919506729,
0.5292813182,
0.0016905841,
-0.1311933547,
0.3692699373,
0.7548956275,
-0.1226327941,
-0.1303451359,
0.3698559701,
0.0483506247,
0.6126061082,
0.3162061572,
0.9388160706,
-0.4828654528,
0.4658820629,
0.1009270996,
-0.4252745211,
-0.4946755469,
-0.6682668328,
-0.7380387187,
-0.6476078033,
-0.1549121439,
0.0155690499,
-0.1631721705,
0.810918808,
0.7084333301,
-0.6186335087,
-0.4219998419,
0.2504006028,
0.0639697462,
-0.0893578008,
-0.0717860833,
0.1699502021,
-0.2846472263,
-1.0411784649,
1.1964949369,
0.1856210381,
-0.092086345,
-0.377859652,
-0.5631828308,
-0.4045178592,
0.1369838566,
0.987190187,
0.7374225855,
-0.6034069657,
-0.2259993106,
0.2154549658,
0.2808437645,
0.0331996344,
0.7887513041,
-0.715426743,
0.8033176661,
0.4500481784,
0.7106301188,
0.5147174597,
-0.1883403361,
0.0709334537,
-0.9876760244,
0.5417151451,
0.3711319268,
0.5743724704,
0.3631128073,
-0.3116437197,
0.7284563184,
-0.0331665874,
-0.6979099512,
-0.6189559102,
0.1512133777,
-1.3848326206,
-0.3559700251,
1.355063796,
0.0265180394,
-0.4631649256,
-0.2484799773,
-0.4291856587,
-0.0311506372,
-0.5027182102,
0.7820255756,
0.5139567256,
-0.6022691727,
-0.087181069,
-0.5594402552,
-0.0306670796,
0.1162810251,
-1.0906578302,
-0.1700495631,
0.7016910911,
-0.0815049335,
0.3024831414,
0.7424077392,
0.1685608923,
0.5372815132,
-0.3054647446,
-0.0657207891,
-0.0827346295,
-0.3053146303,
0.0250107534,
0.0211581644,
-0.0705645829,
-0.732676506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14497v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14497v1 | CodeRAG-Bench: Can Retrieval Augment Code Generation? | 2024-06-20T16:59:52 | 2024-06-20T16:59:52 | Zora Zhiruo Wang, Akari Asai, Xinyan Velocity Yu, Frank F. Xu, Yiqing Xie, Graham Neubig, Daniel Fried | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | While language models (LMs) have proven remarkably adept at generating code,
many programs are challenging for LMs to generate using their parametric
knowledge alone. Providing external contexts such as library documentation can
facilitate generating accurate and functional code. Despite the success of
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) in various text-oriented tasks, its
potential for improving code generation remains under-explored. In this work,
we conduct a systematic, large-scale analysis by asking: in what scenarios can
retrieval benefit code generation models? and what challenges remain? We first
curate a comprehensive evaluation benchmark, CodeRAG-Bench, encompassing three
categories of code generation tasks, including basic programming, open-domain,
and repository-level problems. We aggregate documents from five sources for
models to retrieve contexts: competition solutions, online tutorials, library
documentation, StackOverflow posts, and GitHub repositories. We examine
top-performing models on CodeRAG-Bench by providing contexts retrieved from one
or multiple sources. While notable gains are made in final code generation by
retrieving high-quality contexts across various settings, our analysis reveals
room for improvement -- current retrievers still struggle to fetch useful
contexts especially with limited lexical overlap, and generators fail to
improve with limited context lengths or abilities to integrate additional
contexts. We hope CodeRAG-Bench serves as an effective testbed to encourage
further development of advanced code-oriented RAG methods. | [
-0.3982562423,
-0.3506090641,
0.3615969419,
0.0335873552,
-0.1220335215,
0.0308616832,
-0.3835766912,
-0.5029317141,
-0.1589105725,
0.4173687696,
-0.14746584,
-0.0522864796,
-0.3334113657,
0.2183117867,
-0.7615166903,
1.0904538631,
0.0021062871,
0.1238878667,
-0.323869884,
-0.0942401662,
-0.8067143559,
-0.6464970708,
-0.1997191906,
-0.1701706648,
0.2353500873,
0.2659552693,
0.2433466613,
0.4597300291,
0.5597212315,
0.2497639954,
0.0243016612,
0.0105899218,
-0.6188214421,
0.5183810592,
-0.0132314721,
-0.3351641595,
-0.2225441039,
-0.199684009,
0.5243861675,
0.5933086872,
-0.1842895001,
0.3036459982,
0.2142661661,
0.7592638731,
-0.8644618392,
-0.0888095573,
-0.9092213511,
-0.107888557,
-0.3381344676,
-0.4312946796,
-0.4269624949,
-0.364736855,
-0.2621195614,
-0.2450932562,
0.294786185,
-0.1567942798,
0.6927918792,
0.3660256267,
-0.2874917388,
-0.5033861399,
-0.6034689546,
0.5927534103,
-0.3739433289,
0.2471573502,
0.429338932,
0.4610407948,
-0.0210519042,
-1.072794199,
-0.1456868351,
-0.2295112759,
-0.1859606802,
0.0180821475,
-0.133213982,
-0.4492202401,
0.5990080833,
0.5507451296,
-0.4123192132,
-0.3323260248,
-0.5601959229,
0.1532326341,
0.4617339671,
0.1270681322,
0.3108273149,
-0.4102746844,
-0.2353192568,
-0.2095098346,
-0.9214467406,
0.0827398375,
0.2056150585,
0.164627254,
0.1853917539,
0.5203956366,
-0.1396828443,
0.7781435251,
-0.1686574668,
0.2239888608,
0.2236406207,
-0.502928853,
0.0547480434,
-0.2200865448,
0.2132813632,
0.2306370884,
0.0105780223,
-0.2649972439,
-0.5259572864,
0.0781028345,
0.6534813046,
-0.9019501805,
-0.1101674512,
0.2019969076,
-0.4247591197,
-0.3664940596,
0.250190556,
-0.693633914,
-0.354716897,
-0.1738761067,
0.2762777805,
-0.3846440315,
-0.2488106042,
-0.2326471359,
-0.6694672704,
0.1901513338,
-0.029080132,
-0.5169667602,
0.128445223,
0.7823446393,
0.649792254,
-0.1265835911,
-0.0360413864,
-0.7266405821,
0.0211418886,
-0.5511196256,
0.8322701454,
-0.6930829287,
-0.5687105656,
0.1550153196,
-0.2121281773,
0.057967972,
-0.8943286538,
0.519765079,
-0.6124305129,
0.0587259233,
-0.3163174391,
-0.5095309019,
0.302377969,
0.1019378677,
-0.6929389834,
1.1927019358,
0.3207241893,
-0.7264806628,
0.3958540559,
-0.2303124815,
-0.2527189255,
0.374366492,
-0.5693230033,
-0.0968083665,
0.438744396,
0.0301932581,
0.1985514462,
-0.4705291092,
0.556571126,
-0.090579927,
-0.5851480365,
0.4264985323,
-0.0974832773,
0.4979065359,
0.4438020289,
-0.4076738656,
-0.1270837486,
-0.627797246,
0.3187385499,
0.0269311182,
-0.5558792949,
-0.3802443743,
0.0060303165,
0.1050451696,
0.1933328062,
0.1276960522,
-0.2352218181,
0.1149219945,
-0.1544110179,
0.1036535129,
0.4673256278,
0.1110156998,
0.3804173768,
-0.6482598782,
0.6913760304,
-0.306956768,
-0.299875468,
-0.6407656074,
-0.2488233894,
-0.4042908549,
-0.1637902409,
0.5003399849,
0.1131317914,
-0.8799290657,
0.0187952109,
-0.2287714779,
-0.4600489736,
-0.2703727782,
0.1085913405,
0.821886301,
0.5356804132,
0.3625084758,
-0.3028084934,
-0.7216071486,
-0.6692453027,
-0.5605650544,
0.1738158166,
-0.0280871689,
0.6368626356,
0.4021990597,
-0.1840377599,
0.8564659357,
-0.4513490498,
0.0664585605,
-0.3018684983,
0.1222377345,
0.2898700535,
0.4497190714,
0.6620636582,
-0.8509753942,
-0.5438476205,
0.0390486382,
-0.5815728307,
-0.4950708449,
0.2466973662,
-0.1072689518,
0.3355275989,
0.5745888352,
-0.3563254178,
0.2769217491,
0.4680403769,
-0.009617649,
0.719538033,
-0.1271596253,
0.2057385296,
-0.8730272651,
0.7400368452,
-0.3543103635,
-0.0223186575,
-0.5359122753,
0.7309081554,
0.4417561889,
-0.3563227952,
0.0508839265,
0.7805860639,
-0.4763632715,
-0.4414485097,
-0.4987309575,
0.149119705,
0.0124935834,
0.2115714997,
-0.0465642288,
1.1714907885,
0.2509961724,
-0.5936880708,
-0.2770764232,
0.0450726748,
-0.624846518,
0.3938308358,
-0.6418093443,
0.1777663827,
-0.0775061771,
0.5260167122,
-0.7668376565,
-0.6188774705,
-0.2127294242,
-0.3823695481,
0.4120395482,
-0.1822739094,
-0.3798794746,
-0.2493422925,
-0.3334773183,
0.4599969089,
0.7055672407,
-0.6220431924,
-0.0173982829,
0.486322701,
-0.1793504059,
-0.8380516768,
-0.3469487727,
-0.0483314693,
-0.1623025835,
-0.3195075989,
0.5620856881,
-0.08331763,
-0.4859822392,
0.0209695883,
-0.3709312081,
-0.1400090605,
0.1304683685,
0.1056848615,
0.0486940779,
-0.0634847954,
0.4265201986,
-0.0425624289,
-0.0572182201,
-0.036360193,
-0.2171550691,
0.5520746708,
-0.0358516164,
-0.2210863829,
0.4301998615,
0.260635823,
0.1541155577,
-0.4715768695,
0.2354150414,
0.5626336932,
-0.3382180333,
-0.5043185353,
-0.6173174381,
-0.0964183062,
-0.4602365792,
0.2866131365,
-0.4588049054,
-0.738333106,
0.3739869595,
-0.1003228799,
-0.0132926982,
0.3157840967,
0.4872221649,
0.1323970854,
0.8379303813,
0.4224711359,
0.1423982382,
0.5693793893,
-0.2514140904,
-0.0497183241,
-0.9173446298,
-0.1351890713,
-0.9863234162,
-0.2320528626,
-0.4134997725,
-0.5574915409,
0.4928441942,
0.5357149839,
-0.0740720704,
0.5411485434,
-0.5537516475,
0.3933230042,
0.4066486061,
0.1209239662,
0.3186733425,
0.0942311138,
-0.2227564752,
-0.0771433488,
-0.8529801369,
-0.4166185856,
1.1548883915,
-0.0000547884,
0.5290099978,
0.1473677903,
0.8705354333,
0.2690242827,
0.6244480014,
-0.2970715165,
0.3344260454,
-0.0692685544,
-0.7614477873,
0.1547976881,
-0.6129114628,
-1.0098309517,
0.2640818954,
0.1091219559,
-0.6052529812,
0.1790282577,
-0.0147675527,
-0.1269288659,
-0.2215089798,
-0.504537046,
0.9119266868,
-0.1349194646,
-0.7100012898,
-0.272659421,
-0.3376672268,
0.5652943254,
-0.3264598548,
0.3470668197,
0.1387397796,
-0.1309882849,
0.3026878238,
-0.4750938416,
0.3132333457,
-0.2724636197,
-0.1972267181,
0.4528668821,
0.1939160973,
0.3292809427,
0.0870354325,
-0.3946485221,
-0.3341203034,
-0.0006278558,
-0.2277609557,
-0.5826379061,
0.8089046478,
-0.2908600569,
-0.5949978232,
0.0878615379,
-0.6046556234,
-0.2793877125,
0.1672277153,
0.3211769164,
0.9180185795,
-0.0326614045,
0.6116439104,
0.2406579405,
-0.4104573727,
0.5226636529,
0.2683798373,
-0.3223476708,
-0.2750787139,
0.8591162562,
-0.038893871,
0.00460171,
0.1980333626,
0.0238125008,
-0.2389122248,
-0.3382671773,
-0.4784260988,
-0.1214111894,
-0.7931200862,
-0.5784793496,
-0.515688777,
-0.1206882149,
-0.2310613394,
-0.1072680652,
-0.0135015342,
-0.5448132753,
0.0710242316,
0.1448163986,
0.1802651137,
0.7118051648,
-0.0361138657,
-0.0594809987,
-0.9592956901,
0.2124663442,
0.0823766291,
0.3694208562,
0.0733396187,
-0.4636391103,
-0.3415952027,
-0.1108261943,
-0.2399865538,
-0.8668959737,
0.4091500938,
0.0739633814,
0.5886008143,
-0.2383244485,
0.1095133871,
0.7716838717,
-0.5789323449,
0.6521519423,
-0.2534027994,
-0.74180305,
0.4980539083,
-0.5687323213,
0.3687047958,
0.5563777089,
0.1456077397,
-0.1845284849,
-0.4589608908,
-0.5742714405,
-0.8646134138,
0.6844335794,
0.2598334849,
0.328566134,
-0.2849078774,
0.4988922179,
0.0614438914,
0.3353426754,
-0.6700307727,
0.1348267496,
0.0007069506,
0.0201731902,
0.0889752656,
-0.0978333503,
-0.1497939974,
-0.0627221912,
0.3941009045,
-0.1591981947,
0.2457924783,
0.1022772714,
-0.2200598568,
-0.1852746606,
0.3565648198,
0.5966021419,
0.8982562423,
-0.0917758569,
-0.1597899199,
-0.0412041098,
-0.1267943382,
-0.136348784,
0.2151190937,
-0.1180398986,
0.1244352087,
0.2916871309,
0.4471299946,
0.5404339433,
-1.0265556574,
0.5759832859,
-0.0808952153,
0.0295560248,
-0.3190511167,
0.41008991,
-0.085131593,
0.3109766245,
0.8493262529,
0.0452160463,
0.2423770875,
-0.5164493918,
0.6070970297,
0.5601427555,
-0.0874559283,
0.024049975,
0.702298522,
0.0738238096,
-0.2530504763,
0.3086486459,
-0.1720137596,
-0.3840713799,
0.8334618807,
0.6962383389,
0.7211505771,
0.1477396488,
-0.1148168892,
0.692220211,
-0.1021849737,
-0.1202815548,
0.1722390801,
-0.4215584695,
-0.39192608,
-0.3798612654,
-0.7207589746,
-0.1816873997,
-0.0743735433,
-0.7903316617,
0.2316921353,
0.0161992945,
-0.2368983328,
-0.3476840854,
0.0254916549,
-0.5939664245,
-0.0871727243,
-0.1356436461,
1.0043087006,
-0.1546050161,
0.8342356086,
0.7448233366,
-0.5149610639,
-0.7090848088,
0.188679263,
-0.2924008071,
-0.4200109243,
0.7766487002,
0.3270859718,
0.0356142223,
0.0246511418,
-0.4226531982,
-0.6959428191,
1.1249804497,
0.1480127871,
-0.3425938189,
-0.0535242297,
-0.4085101783,
0.7500143051,
-0.4254850745,
0.3291087747,
0.4064362049,
0.3017133176,
-0.2376837134,
-0.7758222818,
0.0080968915,
-0.6884806156,
0.3121365011,
0.2270145416,
-0.2085644454,
0.8942252398,
-0.0159064233,
-0.3919574916,
0.5151354074,
0.2271375358,
0.6415932178,
0.2198257148,
0.138574034,
0.4264166951,
0.4771219194,
-0.0106092542,
1.5673125982,
-0.9753486514,
0.2217879295,
1.0854057074,
-0.3719670177,
1.0954487324,
0.2876911461,
0.0104991198,
0.6431033015,
0.1737270355,
0.1850871742,
0.484200567,
0.1849545389,
-0.0968605354,
0.093921192,
-0.1908503175,
-0.8741995096,
0.3314994872,
0.4245286584,
-0.4740821123,
-0.3039723635,
-0.2050254196,
-0.3048455119,
0.3081026673,
-0.0502842925,
0.6439611316,
0.0050463439,
-1.2435801029,
0.7554163933,
0.1225876585,
0.4121012688,
-0.4340997934,
-0.1822214276,
-0.5712509751,
0.3288748264,
-0.1149384379,
-0.3252564371,
0.3409968913,
0.4197394252,
-0.0222600885,
-0.3960508108,
1.0436064005,
-0.3553484082,
-0.1147606224,
0.2475190908,
0.8667731881,
0.0166800693,
0.0267730411,
-0.4723372459,
0.3369244933,
-0.2791947722,
-0.1867481917,
0.5677441359,
0.3201889694,
0.1131920442,
0.2770926654,
0.4405409396,
-0.1776525974,
0.0711717606,
0.0470586531,
0.9729764462,
-0.4116278887,
-0.1552844793,
-0.4640821815,
0.532753706,
-0.1604170054,
-0.2900974154,
0.8537797928,
0.6117590666,
1.033845067,
-0.2129419893,
0.6275750399,
-0.5009487271,
0.5759321451,
-0.4117008448,
0.5464231968,
-0.7422124743,
0.4602171183,
-0.4068492651,
-1.0190452337,
-0.086820282,
0.5408946872,
-0.1333887577,
0.2891621292,
0.7375804782,
0.8815587163,
-0.0172143206,
-0.099644132,
0.1806110591,
-0.1982556283,
0.0625895932,
0.426384598,
0.9999318123,
-0.5493704081,
0.7402828336,
-0.1583055407,
-0.1300321966,
-0.2298945785,
-0.6682428718,
-0.5476628542,
-0.7138925791,
0.0968807414,
-0.4020398259,
0.184746787,
0.5923144221,
0.5154824257,
-0.4845580161,
-0.494340986,
-0.3882452548,
-0.0490528718,
-0.1460651159,
-0.2736849785,
0.0115955891,
-1.087752223,
-0.7956140041,
0.5681976676,
-0.0579778478,
-0.4483238459,
-0.0992458537,
-0.1469207853,
0.0369275808,
-0.1908647865,
0.5424056053,
0.3326376677,
-0.5019562244,
0.0411481373,
0.2254795581,
-0.6177684069,
-0.0323591009,
1.2790071964,
-1.0309504271,
0.3696271777,
0.682205379,
0.9772971869,
0.5996664762,
0.2705666423,
0.7777397037,
-1.0948919058,
0.0285374597,
0.1090059727,
0.4934356511,
0.0888732672,
-0.0805209205,
0.9736363888,
0.0214470308,
-0.6687862873,
-1.1387441158,
0.1765968651,
-0.2087629884,
-0.6581092477,
1.1713225842,
-0.0784425214,
0.0142054316,
0.0604269095,
-0.1663520485,
0.0489390455,
-0.0346790031,
0.7348601222,
0.5566861629,
-0.0979521498,
-0.1543596834,
-0.9398187995,
0.7196013331,
0.5940930247,
-0.9016127586,
0.0419290103,
0.8811790347,
0.0318615325,
0.1845469326,
0.8616700172,
-0.3819710314,
0.5949972272,
0.1570087224,
-0.08181265,
0.048228927,
-0.4666614234,
-0.4270039499,
0.3964258432,
0.1560643762,
0.3309041262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14496v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14496v1 | African or European Swallow? Benchmarking Large Vision-Language Models for Fine-Grained Object Classification | 2024-06-20T16:59:39 | 2024-06-20T16:59:39 | Gregor Geigle, Radu Timofte, Goran Glavaš | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recent Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) demonstrate impressive abilities
on numerous image understanding and reasoning tasks. The task of fine-grained
object classification (e.g., distinction between \textit{animal species}),
however, has been probed insufficiently, despite its downstream importance. We
fill this evaluation gap by creating \texttt{FOCI} (\textbf{F}ine-grained
\textbf{O}bject \textbf{C}lass\textbf{I}fication), a difficult multiple-choice
benchmark for fine-grained object classification, from existing object
classification datasets: (1) multiple-choice avoids ambiguous answers
associated with casting classification as open-ended QA task; (2) we retain
classification difficulty by mining negative labels with a CLIP model.
\texttt{FOCI}\xspace complements five popular classification datasets with four
domain-specific subsets from ImageNet-21k. We benchmark 12 public LVLMs on
\texttt{FOCI} and show that it tests for a \textit{complementary skill} to
established image understanding and reasoning benchmarks. Crucially, CLIP
models exhibit dramatically better performance than LVLMs. Since the image
encoders of LVLMs come from these CLIP models, this points to inadequate
alignment for fine-grained object distinction between the encoder and the LLM
and warrants (pre)training data with more fine-grained annotation. We release
our code at \url{https://github.com/gregor-ge/FOCI-Benchmark}. | [
-0.5808039904,
-0.5703385472,
0.2005137056,
-0.0857441574,
-0.2433536798,
-0.2107439339,
-0.1874903888,
-0.990260303,
-0.0084288586,
0.4483483732,
-0.2491440624,
-0.3357458711,
-0.3860967159,
0.1677888781,
-0.3794786632,
0.4343608916,
-0.1808408648,
0.2594635189,
-0.2946866155,
-0.4022097588,
-0.387319237,
-0.5357574821,
-0.5186045766,
-0.3614333868,
0.6685566902,
0.2792723477,
0.71291399,
0.8128440976,
0.6198961139,
0.2594000697,
-0.2148547471,
0.437928319,
-0.3517552316,
-0.1623416096,
-0.3512449265,
-0.3858828545,
-0.157083109,
-0.2261957824,
0.2675442696,
0.6305680871,
0.0249271784,
0.1406982839,
0.0840494856,
0.44525069,
-1.1486810446,
0.1400506943,
-0.7045832872,
0.2203902453,
-0.4714476168,
-0.0468988866,
-0.3492802978,
-0.054535877,
0.1322593838,
-0.5373512506,
0.2030729353,
0.0663924515,
1.284360528,
0.1303687543,
-0.2309952378,
-0.0772496462,
-0.4450699091,
0.7454721928,
-0.4833611548,
0.6055926681,
0.2677167654,
0.5068962574,
-0.0882080123,
-0.8174427152,
-0.5103731751,
-0.1115500107,
0.2696958184,
-0.041617278,
-0.1140025109,
0.1163629442,
0.2063947022,
0.6262238622,
-0.2648194134,
0.4742973447,
-0.4108590782,
-0.2870062292,
0.7058745027,
-0.0712283999,
-0.0725013167,
0.0709271356,
-0.3985802829,
-0.3673503697,
-0.6706434488,
0.3031890094,
0.1628691256,
0.5196877718,
0.1369026899,
0.7132893801,
-0.4993240833,
0.8116461635,
-0.0634514838,
0.0015699927,
0.3265508413,
0.1207980067,
-0.3101203144,
-0.1831794828,
0.5706909299,
0.7938824892,
0.4960585535,
-0.0530154854,
-0.4624908864,
0.1206745431,
0.2175207883,
-1.1160570383,
0.008960993,
0.0192939769,
-0.5910805464,
-0.0895028114,
0.1179496869,
-0.4800752997,
-0.412976712,
-0.3198330402,
0.686714232,
-0.3436653316,
0.2331740409,
0.2621645927,
-0.0246660747,
0.6196236014,
0.4187714159,
-0.9009714127,
0.3975250423,
0.9253188372,
0.8883185387,
-0.2467273027,
-0.4460536242,
-0.6742674112,
-0.3391297162,
-0.3807399273,
0.8703215122,
-0.568797946,
-0.1267522871,
0.4159119129,
0.3222542405,
0.1530638039,
-0.9070686102,
0.5162557364,
-0.3552054465,
-0.3191766441,
-0.470102489,
-0.6565007567,
-0.4383007586,
0.4851917028,
-0.4145620465,
0.9191359282,
0.0569060817,
-0.5337061882,
0.5354079008,
-0.183883667,
-0.2452723682,
0.0379249044,
-0.3147297502,
-0.2766515911,
0.0543693341,
0.2822814286,
0.7567879558,
-0.5239331126,
0.2013929039,
-0.9256036282,
-0.359236598,
0.2591967285,
-0.3838596344,
0.4852354228,
0.3106633127,
-0.0067092958,
0.0186053608,
-0.5730279684,
0.021486301,
0.1244511008,
-0.0085414974,
-0.3970858455,
0.0913812667,
0.0967536494,
0.0733490437,
0.121200718,
-0.6744066477,
0.1978607625,
-0.011145371,
0.4187666178,
0.5256083012,
-0.1614609808,
0.0636291727,
-0.3875619471,
0.1700938642,
-0.0228148755,
0.3650195003,
-0.1711442471,
-0.319127053,
-0.7481717467,
-0.155310154,
0.2268816233,
0.3600029051,
-0.8205705881,
0.1136238798,
-0.1107570753,
-0.4961203635,
-0.4303537905,
-0.0881436989,
0.4869789481,
0.4985212088,
0.3992423117,
-0.6181867719,
-0.2445828915,
-1.0583020449,
-0.0067967949,
0.2063242644,
-0.2024423927,
0.5871277452,
0.6262851357,
-0.3158202469,
0.721467793,
-0.6097446084,
-0.3667541742,
0.2274605185,
-0.0263559017,
-0.0781968236,
0.4062328935,
0.7755193114,
-0.8384430408,
-0.1537567526,
0.2465631366,
-0.7296416163,
-0.0605949275,
0.3136785924,
-0.0979522467,
0.1389685273,
0.5043594241,
-0.3341107368,
0.3335027695,
0.3266130686,
-0.1406385154,
0.5149148703,
-0.0687931702,
0.1761093587,
-0.6595106721,
0.0819271132,
0.0464403704,
-0.1959447414,
-0.4361974597,
0.2967031002,
0.1238727644,
-0.087186031,
-0.8388255835,
0.741286099,
-0.4753088355,
-0.457018286,
-0.1250308603,
0.2047914565,
0.0575196892,
0.4703834951,
0.424372375,
0.6347381473,
0.6675584316,
-0.6197865605,
0.1571659148,
0.2777969539,
-0.4524688423,
0.6323834658,
-0.565372169,
-0.0450820215,
0.0972713903,
0.0517552719,
-0.5154910684,
-0.2845534384,
0.0354931764,
-0.0597405955,
0.3501194417,
-0.1163232774,
-0.1868050694,
-0.5826129913,
-0.4183322787,
0.5879811049,
0.3029344678,
-0.7215419412,
0.3876354992,
0.4242721796,
0.0863833278,
-0.6618236303,
-0.8464936614,
-0.1658410877,
0.0841551721,
-0.5713779926,
0.2134722322,
0.1502258033,
-0.0429267436,
0.0147597212,
-0.3196446598,
-0.292329967,
0.0337671191,
0.141238004,
0.1038952991,
-0.5031645894,
0.0188663062,
-0.2865392864,
0.234827444,
-0.1464890093,
-0.4370461404,
0.438944608,
-0.3084797859,
-0.4639418423,
-0.1470968723,
0.1020330116,
0.5108264089,
-0.5043808222,
0.3850642741,
0.5946076512,
-0.4850601256,
-0.0691874027,
-0.6839606166,
-0.1242869645,
-0.4471872151,
0.4255339801,
-0.4414070547,
-0.8367340565,
0.5959690213,
0.1077700108,
-0.0476674885,
0.3789845109,
0.207443893,
-0.0286485013,
0.5220602751,
0.3433009684,
0.0217485894,
0.6547060609,
-0.7161374092,
-0.2570764124,
-0.8853527308,
-0.1638276875,
-0.5407948494,
-0.3921577334,
-0.5736604333,
-0.7350261211,
-0.0789424852,
0.1950584054,
-0.2147261649,
0.083505705,
-0.5164892673,
0.6591140032,
0.403557688,
0.2650375366,
0.0279733203,
-0.1202676222,
-0.0039106607,
0.2400244474,
-0.6276423931,
-0.4811559618,
0.9484932423,
0.391045481,
0.8395720124,
-0.3212236762,
0.6540467739,
0.2709001899,
0.3042919636,
-0.9659831524,
0.6356709003,
-0.7684744,
-0.3390724361,
-0.1119906977,
-0.2268356085,
-0.9980017543,
0.5170269012,
-0.2383624613,
-0.9286946058,
0.549177289,
0.2833273411,
-0.2456900924,
0.4500100911,
-0.68357265,
1.226333499,
-0.364606142,
-0.5017362237,
0.0455121733,
-0.5956479907,
0.3784874976,
0.1103272662,
0.0582172573,
-0.3414413035,
-0.0410780385,
0.610445261,
-0.7093905807,
0.7049151659,
-0.2855086923,
0.0332002677,
0.514295876,
0.0231758263,
0.2049735188,
-0.20410797,
0.0634972304,
0.4325660765,
0.0548763573,
-0.414631635,
-0.2742792964,
0.4484302998,
-0.6160537601,
-0.3004634976,
-0.3529449403,
-0.3140783012,
-0.088349402,
0.3860733211,
0.3892852366,
0.780426681,
-0.1429687738,
0.4944313467,
0.489543736,
-0.0005824814,
0.3110310733,
0.3883449137,
-0.4270469546,
-0.325648129,
0.9952017069,
0.1705769002,
0.2973662913,
0.7333520651,
0.1823587269,
-0.3048332632,
-0.7728375793,
-0.3881653249,
0.0985264257,
-0.7853979468,
-0.509798646,
-0.3521475494,
-0.3160251379,
-0.0270556416,
-0.3417494297,
-0.5017569065,
-0.1398140341,
-0.3500897288,
0.1899597496,
0.1853345335,
0.5800207853,
0.131372273,
0.2502348125,
-0.8785759211,
0.4194309115,
0.4996436238,
0.4137750864,
0.1402223706,
-0.4510381818,
-0.2148587704,
0.157954067,
-0.4884686768,
-0.6110108495,
0.1832534075,
0.4014833868,
0.4943209589,
0.704084754,
-0.0325292982,
0.9689704776,
-0.4886841774,
0.7169107795,
0.0234146733,
-0.9951525927,
0.2304915637,
-0.1091237217,
0.1682841927,
0.6198018789,
0.1619054675,
-0.6020978093,
-0.4839016795,
-0.2725226581,
-0.7996883392,
0.7096809149,
0.0037708275,
-0.2416405976,
-0.0427233689,
0.3011832535,
0.296241641,
0.2535441518,
-0.5254786015,
0.1192787066,
-0.1163240299,
-0.1138558388,
-0.1997160316,
-0.1596063823,
0.2401062697,
-0.2256878912,
0.5501058698,
-0.4285674989,
0.0620556958,
0.5126489401,
-0.3475576937,
0.1062799767,
-0.0057452191,
0.6431467533,
0.3767241538,
-0.3707570732,
0.1174526736,
0.1633496881,
-0.5520074964,
-0.0161526147,
0.2926670313,
-0.3209658563,
-0.2379145324,
0.5064539909,
0.9245755672,
0.2767454386,
-0.6898062825,
0.608017087,
-0.042491097,
-0.1613446474,
0.018888969,
0.0165326372,
-0.2456827015,
0.4050664306,
0.2471598685,
0.0801776797,
0.26182127,
-0.5924523473,
0.2065597773,
0.4892582297,
-0.3498475552,
-0.1929378808,
0.4891774654,
0.3912205696,
-0.3000662029,
0.3622751534,
-0.2609614134,
-0.5914134383,
0.6252600551,
0.267148912,
0.9711584449,
-0.040252652,
-0.0097753769,
0.2785274982,
0.1360948086,
-0.2623622715,
0.420050323,
-0.1419968158,
-0.8337424397,
-0.1399204731,
-0.6835644841,
-0.5744214654,
0.119697094,
-0.7861898541,
0.4088089764,
-0.2533412278,
-0.0150647955,
0.2201651335,
-0.0569357425,
-0.79237324,
0.2987284958,
0.4973755777,
1.3419718742,
-0.8663519621,
0.7143556476,
0.647454977,
-0.3140133619,
-0.6221920848,
-0.0395459421,
-0.2446431071,
-0.7765594125,
0.3588631451,
0.6324768662,
-0.1807572842,
-0.4243561924,
-0.5049515963,
-0.7041537762,
0.9234494567,
0.3471087217,
-0.7758122683,
0.1947169602,
-0.0706984103,
0.4608543515,
-0.5571015477,
0.2737841308,
0.5157423615,
0.2525956035,
0.2015535533,
-0.9338518977,
-0.1963949353,
-0.0020168147,
0.2065812647,
0.3557530344,
-0.8607359529,
0.9889829755,
-0.2144395709,
-0.0924051255,
0.2592692673,
0.5823955536,
-0.0852274075,
0.5694434047,
0.6040423512,
0.4265882969,
0.8212917447,
-0.2804062068,
1.009213686,
-0.0445252471,
0.3616492152,
1.1641448736,
-0.4940850437,
1.3170912266,
0.4928606749,
-0.1790234149,
0.215306893,
0.901325345,
-0.2941468954,
0.3912763,
0.1664737612,
0.2702539265,
-0.2874641418,
-0.2605374455,
-0.2794825137,
0.7477816939,
0.1972533911,
-0.0282983277,
-0.1593348831,
0.2644144893,
-0.3349843323,
-0.0289231874,
-0.6208434105,
0.5836139321,
0.095079653,
-0.6697759628,
0.9114819169,
-0.3689246476,
0.6904988885,
-0.6045978665,
0.2006345987,
-0.1910832822,
0.5540124178,
-0.1824487895,
-1.0291686058,
0.2214200795,
0.0506880097,
-0.0829025283,
0.1303042918,
0.5936086774,
-0.5454892516,
-0.3187263906,
0.3996179402,
-0.0047651855,
0.3321415484,
-0.1419235915,
-0.4974835515,
0.3208734095,
-0.1314322352,
0.0307208505,
0.1648967415,
0.4074726701,
-0.3764847815,
0.8023747206,
0.350910455,
0.0010607246,
0.0291994847,
0.0592652187,
0.7709615231,
-0.6455065608,
-0.3119309247,
-0.6396677494,
0.1740639806,
-0.0794696957,
-0.4396727979,
0.3863292933,
0.8599293232,
1.1431407928,
-0.3439070284,
0.2245108932,
-0.0617889911,
0.2130121589,
-0.7691470981,
0.3877368569,
-0.9738191962,
-0.1950684041,
-0.257843703,
-0.9251273274,
-0.3378980756,
0.5247449875,
-0.2261434495,
-0.1555625945,
0.5960015655,
0.6167630553,
-0.2787338793,
-0.1471738219,
0.429032594,
0.240898788,
0.2624682188,
0.6379900575,
0.9841746688,
-0.4727285504,
0.5576113462,
-0.4476562738,
0.0254953615,
-0.5845093727,
-0.9377366304,
-0.7412960529,
-0.5138944387,
-0.3923768103,
0.0789850131,
0.0612739101,
0.864213109,
0.9453172088,
-0.921425581,
-0.3003452718,
0.0926591977,
0.0483328551,
-0.3712864816,
-0.1897553355,
0.2217487246,
-0.1939051151,
-0.6687243581,
0.0200313665,
0.2489088774,
0.3375929892,
-0.0873995274,
-0.094756715,
-0.0532721803,
0.0317232609,
0.7733718157,
0.6177014709,
-1.0366306305,
-0.4979456067,
-0.0789409801,
-0.0157011263,
0.2001950443,
0.6558156013,
-0.4866527915,
0.5703293681,
0.2917364538,
0.8016810417,
0.640784502,
-0.0431180187,
0.3264915943,
-0.6006812453,
0.4672118425,
0.2788560688,
0.7112626433,
0.5004386306,
0.0663897991,
0.5113480687,
0.0231898259,
-0.6443216205,
-0.9824103713,
0.105761297,
-1.164409399,
-0.2651077807,
0.9705678225,
-0.2171748132,
-0.5920438766,
0.3249766231,
-0.4072430134,
0.0463197492,
-0.3069208264,
0.5056036711,
0.5030446649,
0.0981642678,
0.0561999343,
-0.4100136161,
0.3409250975,
0.0803586692,
-0.854575932,
0.0939886495,
0.5459366441,
0.1216030046,
0.2428755164,
0.2510324717,
0.124488838,
0.3817972541,
0.0144378413,
0.2191696614,
-0.0993755981,
-0.4714946151,
-0.3206126094,
0.115294829,
0.1736961454,
-0.8024157882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14492v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14492v1 | Does Object Grounding Really Reduce Hallucination of Large Vision-Language Models? | 2024-06-20T16:56:11 | 2024-06-20T16:56:11 | Gregor Geigle, Radu Timofte, Goran Glavaš | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large vision-language models (LVLMs) have recently dramatically pushed the
state of the art in image captioning and many image understanding tasks (e.g.,
visual question answering). LVLMs, however, often \textit{hallucinate} and
produce captions that mention concepts that cannot be found in the image. These
hallucinations erode the trustworthiness of LVLMs and are arguably among the
main obstacles to their ubiquitous adoption. Recent work suggests that addition
of grounding objectives -- those that explicitly align image regions or objects
to text spans -- reduces the amount of LVLM hallucination. Although intuitive,
this claim is not empirically justified as the reduction effects have been
established, we argue, with flawed evaluation protocols that (i) rely on data
(i.e., MSCOCO) that has been extensively used in LVLM training and (ii) measure
hallucination via question answering rather than open-ended caption generation.
In this work, in contrast, we offer the first systematic analysis of the effect
of fine-grained object grounding on LVLM hallucination under an evaluation
protocol that more realistically captures LVLM hallucination in open
generation. Our extensive experiments over three backbone LLMs reveal that
grounding objectives have little to no effect on object hallucination in open
caption generation. | [
-0.4793384373,
-0.6702249646,
0.6206094027,
-0.1144624949,
-0.5369009972,
-0.4992612898,
-0.1981520504,
-0.5546724796,
-0.0958753377,
0.586673677,
-0.2316154689,
-0.6285219193,
-0.3518663049,
0.1037185341,
-0.4633166194,
0.6244410872,
0.0427817293,
0.1631742418,
-0.5863231421,
-0.1344260573,
-0.6029320359,
-0.6375887394,
-0.294506222,
-0.2184504122,
0.3546068966,
0.0966893286,
0.7677269578,
0.6900512576,
0.7668078542,
0.1481723785,
-0.1637683809,
0.2875331342,
-0.6954236031,
-0.0603839122,
0.018958576,
-0.6251876354,
-0.1550997943,
-0.0618064851,
0.5051737428,
0.7478761673,
0.0574258305,
-0.156602636,
-0.085219577,
1.021625042,
-0.8545028567,
0.1112982109,
-0.7475915551,
0.5936270952,
0.2872675359,
-0.4764330685,
-0.5091572404,
0.1007056683,
0.0239828136,
-0.4172516167,
0.3902674019,
0.2761692107,
1.103069663,
0.5881712437,
0.2301342636,
-0.2661503851,
-0.6224295497,
0.6128593683,
-0.346940726,
0.4605710804,
0.3163116574,
0.2861202657,
0.0517447293,
-0.2785010338,
-0.5171850324,
-0.4240838885,
-0.114134334,
0.1859554946,
0.1479123533,
0.3006509244,
0.5490602851,
0.4382714927,
-0.3393239081,
0.0080493558,
-0.7830145359,
-0.1180091351,
0.1574015319,
0.0392130017,
0.234757483,
-0.244235754,
-0.3019168079,
0.005418384,
-0.7946269512,
0.0406883545,
-0.0636391342,
0.2323982567,
0.133687228,
1.0087161064,
-0.2866396904,
0.5729647279,
0.0031456326,
-0.0189283881,
0.0611435398,
0.0395319201,
-0.4409836233,
0.1313037127,
0.3662890494,
1.0919364691,
0.5927875638,
-0.617777586,
-0.1358054429,
0.3226056099,
0.3788222075,
-0.8016654253,
-0.1574332416,
0.3489638865,
-0.6869369745,
-0.4859970212,
0.5004157424,
-0.5046117902,
-0.655198276,
-0.4119001925,
0.2966041863,
-0.2530990243,
0.1847186238,
0.2828160822,
-0.1482783705,
0.6406099796,
0.4833190739,
-0.4474318624,
0.3695876896,
0.6608901024,
1.078633666,
-0.416354388,
-0.4495953321,
-0.855191052,
0.0029907855,
-0.6327360868,
0.6505890489,
-0.3537670374,
-0.1229125708,
0.0149527164,
0.1607395858,
0.1222391278,
-0.8012070656,
0.2682442367,
-0.3558696508,
0.0039653941,
-0.4618030787,
-0.1555043906,
-0.1910034716,
0.23931472,
-0.4245758057,
0.5531299114,
-0.358707875,
-0.6990987062,
0.500577569,
-0.1675392389,
-0.4051834941,
-0.3356843591,
-0.35954988,
-0.4983495772,
0.5376973748,
0.2949944735,
0.731541276,
-0.1683145911,
0.3151454329,
-0.275470078,
-0.7573526502,
0.208143726,
-0.200805217,
0.2561374605,
0.1221598014,
-0.5631792545,
0.190131411,
-0.5546506643,
-0.2880453467,
0.2501863837,
0.159135744,
-0.3739677966,
0.3629527092,
-0.1872624755,
0.1499056369,
-0.2311372906,
-0.2373885065,
-0.1339093,
-0.3421112895,
0.1664562672,
0.708029747,
-0.0651721731,
0.4924412966,
-0.3511994779,
0.0623631477,
0.1972716004,
-0.009762953,
-0.2808019817,
-0.2779372931,
-1.0470147133,
-0.011159189,
-0.4337140024,
0.3494399786,
-0.4660265446,
0.4198681116,
-0.1305494159,
-0.2124184817,
-0.3661425114,
-0.3003205657,
0.5263807774,
0.5192884207,
0.5646519661,
-0.3799465597,
-0.3619079888,
-1.0146341324,
0.0564110689,
-0.1202495024,
0.0007610333,
0.4052368104,
0.4272625744,
0.0341160893,
0.7034321427,
-0.4636977911,
-0.590880692,
0.1967341304,
-0.208575353,
-0.147029534,
0.3932922781,
0.6042672396,
-0.7566491961,
-0.0567383468,
0.0884873942,
-1.112629652,
0.0454293378,
-0.1931677014,
-0.0549676977,
0.4986306429,
0.6625238061,
-0.9672712684,
0.7415575385,
0.1612548232,
-0.1088556573,
0.5662966967,
-0.1205733865,
0.2885073423,
-0.4853601754,
0.0198293068,
-0.2103925645,
-0.0284646358,
-0.5170562863,
0.4417741597,
-0.0240228418,
-0.3025663793,
-0.5760422945,
0.2392819375,
-0.607699573,
-0.5719920397,
-0.2278064936,
0.3423196971,
-0.0353624001,
0.3310072422,
0.3770495653,
0.8521268368,
0.9241167903,
-0.6988017559,
-0.1116693318,
0.2388840914,
-0.3360568583,
0.518576622,
-0.6923313737,
0.2445961684,
-0.6324558854,
-0.078770794,
-0.9854642749,
-0.193874076,
0.5266991258,
-0.312158227,
0.0440110676,
0.1662761569,
-0.1673354506,
-0.2475359887,
-0.4377479553,
0.0766571611,
0.6497345567,
-0.5794371367,
0.2736674845,
0.0196161401,
0.4911483824,
-0.5571165085,
-0.860173285,
0.2843236327,
-0.2999735773,
-0.4542274177,
0.0585699305,
-0.1215883046,
-0.5282994509,
0.0045977347,
-0.5280646682,
0.2084961236,
0.1228879392,
0.3575722873,
0.0347890854,
-0.3031913638,
0.2211829722,
-0.2112482637,
0.0142062251,
0.2909418941,
-0.2639842629,
0.6518184543,
-0.3577280343,
-0.5705925226,
-0.4578847289,
0.1365757734,
0.7652714252,
-0.3260267675,
0.8283961415,
0.3693508208,
-0.5548899174,
-0.0836086497,
-0.6019225121,
-0.3505848646,
-0.388309896,
0.4238470197,
-0.7223399282,
-0.6776617765,
0.4230454862,
0.3378963768,
-0.2171489149,
0.3295609057,
0.3354433179,
-0.085613966,
0.7731950879,
0.2801809311,
0.1621715426,
0.0936036855,
-0.125140056,
0.1854389757,
-0.8552589417,
-0.3320218027,
-0.419388175,
-0.0866997838,
-0.1275038421,
-0.6464756131,
-0.0708958879,
0.2442959845,
0.0686949193,
-0.1430920959,
-0.7375590801,
0.7405288815,
0.0668523088,
0.421199441,
0.2951336801,
0.4313987494,
0.335467428,
-0.1524834484,
-0.5227689147,
-0.5774276257,
0.9112029076,
0.4406954944,
0.7851573825,
-0.2992690206,
0.6046729684,
0.2050094455,
0.1387169361,
-0.9149736762,
0.7553589344,
-0.1441882104,
-0.1741182804,
-0.4300204813,
-0.154317528,
-0.5478855371,
0.5498988032,
-0.1887291372,
-0.7211633921,
0.1738726348,
0.0677739158,
0.034869507,
0.3781419396,
-0.3801411092,
0.6584261656,
-0.1687221974,
-0.482131809,
-0.1036236733,
-0.5746750236,
0.5332794785,
-0.0106084216,
0.1342289746,
-0.0243930537,
0.079237096,
0.5371710062,
-0.2427306175,
0.9186977744,
-0.3385503292,
-0.2214745283,
0.3629491925,
0.0950170234,
0.526535213,
-0.0282580815,
0.2768286169,
0.1972141862,
-0.4613495767,
-0.2236905694,
-0.6302467585,
0.5947179794,
-0.6216854453,
-0.8627837896,
-0.1965459436,
-0.5798460841,
0.0597142205,
0.0868721008,
0.2715722322,
0.2850132287,
-0.0463697426,
0.6306143999,
0.9496191144,
-0.3110819757,
0.1103693172,
-0.0424906239,
-0.4686723948,
-0.3167717159,
0.7489566803,
0.0718287081,
0.5304489136,
0.3490114808,
0.1405030489,
0.0056381687,
-0.832795918,
-0.2918242812,
0.3423364758,
-1.1694821119,
-0.0021513933,
-0.7280083895,
-0.0693476424,
-0.2321419567,
-0.4453687966,
-0.2857118547,
-0.2376507074,
-0.474796772,
-0.1972338557,
0.0733290762,
0.3235029578,
0.3031903207,
0.0628799051,
-0.4894392192,
0.7737613916,
0.205344975,
0.2462399155,
0.080720529,
-0.4411056042,
-0.0292335544,
0.066819191,
0.2985471487,
-0.602391541,
0.1020939127,
0.1030403674,
0.4100427032,
0.6006609797,
0.181019038,
1.1283997297,
-0.645240128,
0.7609048486,
0.3111339211,
-0.9698832631,
0.4077788889,
-0.1785061061,
0.0927095339,
0.38830024,
-0.065860644,
-0.3216999173,
-0.6816757917,
-0.3082046509,
-0.5675606132,
0.5960703492,
0.4406515658,
0.2311464846,
-0.1117829084,
0.4769612849,
0.1937211603,
0.3870144188,
-1.0263421535,
-0.1327580363,
-0.2458791137,
0.2116871476,
-0.1102626771,
-0.2883404493,
-0.2755855024,
-0.3385185897,
0.2316503525,
-0.1573881358,
0.4022849798,
0.5372208953,
-0.394998014,
-0.382950902,
-0.1003515571,
0.9423739314,
0.629201293,
-0.4305063784,
0.420507133,
0.0923569128,
-0.2809675336,
-0.1350890249,
-0.310903579,
-0.4346601963,
0.0994079784,
0.3318168223,
1.0084275007,
-0.0609083287,
-0.7941578627,
0.4175921381,
0.2325879782,
-0.4393716455,
-0.3889067471,
0.1444426477,
-0.3087458909,
0.2193816304,
0.3372537792,
0.2395444065,
-0.0001091217,
-0.5762441754,
0.3068522215,
0.5739478469,
-0.6426007748,
-0.0144151999,
0.9849603772,
-0.1284974664,
-0.2686769068,
0.4409973323,
0.1731406003,
-0.3606010973,
0.8145528436,
0.5868533254,
1.0287283659,
0.1593013555,
0.1470328569,
0.2401658893,
0.8617962599,
-0.2518082559,
0.0109668234,
-0.0426643342,
-0.6290115714,
-0.1807841659,
-0.5166960359,
-0.1705587357,
0.1714195758,
-0.6300566196,
0.3625391126,
-0.3220669627,
0.4014507234,
-0.4477770627,
-0.6508956552,
-0.4953507483,
0.4218009114,
0.42534253,
0.5564995408,
-0.8401575685,
0.4229763448,
0.6869558096,
-0.5151978731,
-0.2565306723,
0.3976250589,
-0.5064224601,
-0.6802476645,
0.7623522878,
0.8264778256,
-0.2152739614,
-0.0074600512,
-0.7574203014,
-0.626562655,
0.9644411802,
0.0009600872,
-0.3156977892,
-0.0124713499,
0.4603959918,
0.4801177382,
-0.5941114426,
-0.1993970722,
0.334806174,
0.5308513045,
0.1666763127,
-0.6109713912,
0.3698219359,
0.0074541513,
0.0408327393,
0.0123126721,
-0.5703763962,
0.8284149766,
-0.4410175383,
-0.4615905583,
0.1039013192,
0.5626061559,
0.3168673217,
0.4836752713,
0.5291413665,
0.5278980732,
0.5790701509,
-0.2073214352,
0.941624999,
0.078499876,
0.2856348157,
0.8269172907,
-0.4369892478,
0.6899402738,
0.9849573374,
0.0661678165,
-0.1029481888,
0.417332679,
-0.0904472768,
0.6697627306,
0.2726353705,
0.364345938,
-0.3250668049,
-0.1074553728,
-0.5324987173,
0.242350921,
0.098597914,
-0.3168661296,
-0.0938423574,
0.3428597152,
-0.2944917083,
0.1315795034,
-0.4452789128,
0.6177119613,
0.0953862816,
-0.5881050825,
1.1249278784,
-0.2844003737,
0.2710324824,
-0.1041888222,
-0.1405548304,
-0.334769249,
-0.0010817415,
-0.2663576603,
-0.5281654,
0.3339952528,
-0.0548217893,
-0.080647409,
0.0432248078,
0.9059404731,
-0.3027810156,
-0.1085977703,
0.2662938237,
0.4054003656,
0.5171209574,
-0.4790380597,
-0.2347169369,
0.1844731271,
-0.0567684248,
-0.2740774751,
0.17504704,
0.3565664291,
-0.1191737577,
0.5965707898,
0.6067295671,
-0.051296562,
0.0549562275,
0.1724542528,
0.8916484118,
-0.6497982144,
-0.2740541399,
-0.7990403771,
0.6682393551,
-0.1062010303,
0.0871146619,
0.5746365786,
0.6995886564,
0.9418967366,
-0.6078922153,
0.6179785132,
-0.0207598303,
-0.1980921626,
-1.0817394257,
0.6263684034,
-0.8428002,
0.3630030751,
-0.3737089932,
-1.4385095835,
-0.7061411738,
0.8644316792,
-0.2951407731,
-0.2765049636,
1.0717775822,
0.7666266561,
-0.0606556647,
-0.4228497446,
0.7826101184,
0.1156448796,
0.0756009594,
0.2597611248,
1.0746113062,
-0.4039822221,
0.5097996593,
-0.4973984957,
0.0336067267,
-0.3133378327,
-0.6739945412,
-1.5693758726,
-0.317417711,
-0.2840940356,
-0.2589722276,
0.3928379416,
0.5873277783,
0.2692669332,
-0.8058366776,
-0.1639768928,
-0.5916125774,
-0.0001660432,
-0.1223545298,
-0.2243557721,
0.5915501118,
-0.4920416176,
-0.6080899239,
0.0966517478,
0.426907897,
0.1507739574,
-0.3414020836,
-0.2766337395,
0.2606054842,
-0.2023828775,
0.8364425898,
-0.0804711059,
-1.2819594145,
-0.6804586649,
0.3857227564,
-0.1065215319,
0.3657459319,
0.6286326647,
-0.6713243723,
0.4960102141,
0.3003894985,
0.5033535957,
0.2062987983,
0.2654147744,
0.1349258423,
-0.4353184402,
0.5737621784,
-0.0290566962,
0.2889240384,
0.1592624784,
-0.425058037,
0.5722533464,
0.4424626827,
-0.2043765187,
-1.096509099,
0.0966516286,
-0.9337106943,
-0.4291759431,
1.2608739138,
0.2590705156,
-0.2947874069,
0.1335164011,
-0.6321604252,
0.0733214915,
-0.0481044911,
1.0451859236,
0.728422761,
0.1858224869,
-0.4393171668,
-0.6445885301,
0.3235407174,
0.5233376622,
-0.9178993702,
0.3954772055,
0.862256825,
-0.3236072958,
0.2890489399,
0.3037652969,
0.0405941531,
0.3812839985,
-0.0749885514,
0.2516121566,
-0.311368227,
-0.7316851616,
-0.2542672157,
0.3524317741,
0.1017069891,
-0.3383686244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14491v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14491v1 | Instruction Pre-Training: Language Models are Supervised Multitask Learners | 2024-06-20T16:55:33 | 2024-06-20T16:55:33 | Daixuan Cheng, Yuxian Gu, Shaohan Huang, Junyu Bi, Minlie Huang, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | Unsupervised multitask pre-training has been the critical method behind the
recent success of language models (LMs). However, supervised multitask learning
still holds significant promise, as scaling it in the post-training stage
trends towards better generalization. In this paper, we explore supervised
multitask pre-training by proposing Instruction Pre-Training, a framework that
scalably augments massive raw corpora with instruction-response pairs to
pre-train LMs. The instruction-response pairs are generated by an efficient
instruction synthesizer built on open-source models. In our experiments, we
synthesize 200M instruction-response pairs covering 40+ task categories to
verify the effectiveness of Instruction Pre-Training. In pre-training from
scratch, Instruction Pre-Training not only consistently enhances pre-trained
base models but also benefits more from further instruction tuning. In
continual pre-training, Instruction Pre-Training enables Llama3-8B to be
comparable to or even outperform Llama3-70B. Our model, code, and data are
available at https://github.com/microsoft/LMOps. | [
-0.2676482499,
-0.5195580125,
0.6030635834,
0.2984903753,
-0.1719374806,
0.239773035,
-0.5429481268,
-0.2326011062,
0.1490617096,
0.6256184578,
-0.7390107512,
-0.5798043013,
-0.6544991732,
0.0682121813,
-0.3626525104,
1.1028017998,
0.0299016368,
0.1624295712,
-0.3209078312,
0.3374834955,
-0.3316799104,
-0.6395378113,
-0.2707681358,
0.0861631185,
0.6345173717,
0.5844743252,
0.2534737885,
0.4675824642,
0.2038665414,
0.3539114892,
0.4846121967,
0.1919927448,
-0.5216886997,
-0.0111612566,
0.3874995112,
-0.5039085746,
-0.7681273222,
0.2164443284,
0.5301168561,
0.8330600858,
-0.0991373137,
0.3747013807,
0.3711247444,
0.6047468185,
-0.8208710551,
0.2902318835,
-0.6231368184,
-0.0822226182,
-0.4157271683,
-0.2866382897,
-0.831502974,
-0.0927494168,
-0.0693406239,
-0.6891016364,
0.1784202158,
-0.0318340659,
0.5217244625,
0.4200870395,
-0.1423356533,
-0.2845866084,
-0.3836489618,
0.7492516041,
-0.5182673931,
0.6248688102,
0.6097865701,
-0.0643756911,
-0.0991603211,
-0.7047717571,
-0.3830640018,
-0.4777908027,
-0.1411792636,
0.1493290067,
0.130287081,
0.2960017025,
0.1263159364,
0.3782303035,
-0.5942486525,
0.1841858625,
-0.3490679562,
-0.0318674929,
0.1498008519,
-0.0076727755,
0.1254187077,
0.1637707949,
-0.4438852072,
0.0251531191,
-0.8516228795,
0.0740151554,
0.5484165549,
0.2632984817,
-0.1179120317,
0.4868786037,
-0.1332884431,
0.9645883441,
0.2409419268,
-0.1238927171,
0.483504653,
-0.3159781396,
-0.1844362766,
0.0831629112,
0.8066900373,
-0.1509346813,
0.2308850884,
-0.3415827751,
-0.1383102834,
0.1106398851,
0.6044492722,
-0.8687927127,
-0.2612932026,
0.1937601417,
-0.2408346385,
-0.1488008499,
-0.0324374363,
-0.3071686029,
0.1515648812,
-0.6072191596,
0.2542710304,
-0.2151007205,
-0.2269665003,
0.2866646945,
0.5450919867,
-0.1687096506,
0.140967682,
-1.0931332111,
0.2460252643,
0.724727869,
0.595960021,
-0.2539685369,
-0.6723371148,
-0.8157032728,
0.1559804231,
-0.5041686893,
0.7407836318,
-0.6079167128,
-0.2147049755,
0.078222312,
0.2129902095,
-0.24812828,
-0.4269980192,
-0.1214750409,
-0.6558523178,
0.025956234,
0.0700185001,
-0.437892735,
0.1636915654,
0.1765782982,
-0.7568618059,
0.9889828563,
0.1914927512,
-0.7370875478,
0.2018088549,
-0.7709808946,
-0.5012015104,
0.0480321161,
-0.0059960149,
-0.142078355,
0.0637230203,
0.2550343275,
0.8446332812,
-0.0670872703,
0.2243654728,
-0.371681422,
-0.3675152063,
0.0392136425,
-0.2756437063,
0.4996470213,
0.0832218006,
-0.2499491274,
0.4871963263,
-0.881044507,
0.1849227399,
-0.1393304467,
-0.6038104892,
-0.056854181,
-0.285292089,
-0.1991332769,
0.019927768,
0.4644976556,
-0.4349786639,
0.1655818671,
-0.3099407256,
0.2206532359,
0.790697515,
-0.4345516562,
0.528213799,
0.0852095112,
0.6519840956,
-0.0597482957,
0.0886101276,
-0.4999985397,
-0.1768281609,
-0.7251432538,
-0.3293150067,
0.2416175455,
0.6258312464,
-0.9441057444,
0.3742840886,
-0.3082393706,
-0.2886080146,
-0.761865139,
0.5076426864,
0.7980800271,
0.3428047001,
0.5681602359,
-0.342908293,
-0.7206682563,
-0.7436192632,
-0.1228794307,
0.1108085513,
-0.1875145882,
-0.1804443002,
0.2757998705,
-0.329500258,
0.5695097446,
-0.5480567813,
-0.2318762243,
-0.2957960069,
0.1620872766,
-0.0393733345,
0.4085890353,
0.1779473424,
-0.3416729867,
-0.5148316026,
-0.2692463398,
-0.5260108113,
0.0639725775,
0.2160145491,
-0.1386447251,
0.1996675432,
0.6580190659,
-0.4003423452,
0.0984597951,
0.9156201482,
0.2568995059,
0.6536626816,
-0.3230562508,
0.1845083982,
-1.2234169245,
-0.0700656474,
-0.3864104152,
-0.187289834,
-0.6630756259,
-0.1111992747,
0.2569556534,
-0.0647496507,
-0.5464634299,
0.0375388078,
-0.6825479865,
-0.0961952209,
-0.3890645802,
-0.2010730654,
-0.2939322293,
0.6612364054,
0.251105547,
0.9909202456,
0.4739116728,
-0.5554249287,
0.283706218,
0.0097919498,
-0.7182664871,
0.2397315353,
-0.5299206972,
0.5146617293,
-0.0196581651,
0.3510280252,
-0.7165794969,
-0.2788175344,
0.0430674218,
-0.1346033663,
0.3255066872,
-0.1184851825,
-0.5507351756,
-0.4295650423,
-0.155284524,
0.2563448846,
0.0189642143,
-0.6067459583,
0.5325770974,
0.3416566253,
-0.2146670818,
-0.9375033379,
-0.5183312297,
-0.2169096768,
0.1372684836,
-0.330457598,
0.3394126594,
-0.2972589433,
0.1761587262,
0.0520388186,
0.0285926647,
-0.2035860717,
0.0988759175,
0.4521953166,
0.3634318411,
-0.2665147781,
0.0890104994,
-0.1052396074,
-0.1872690767,
0.0560414568,
-0.3108189106,
0.7823983431,
-0.4072000682,
-0.4788224995,
-0.3340260684,
0.2592715919,
0.2454022467,
-0.5667797327,
0.6939017177,
0.6143929958,
-0.0484713987,
-0.1527076066,
-0.5664902925,
-0.300521642,
-0.4656870365,
0.7166690826,
-0.4098444879,
-1.1012049913,
-0.1610078514,
-0.1377232671,
0.2250316739,
-0.0863537714,
0.5184381008,
-0.1921684891,
0.8838571906,
0.7380523086,
0.1042872369,
0.5924497843,
-0.1673787981,
0.1690542251,
-0.7432148457,
-0.2893720567,
-0.2561462522,
-0.0178545248,
-0.3586180806,
-0.4351892769,
0.2089304179,
0.0574322864,
-0.2446151674,
0.4268012345,
-0.3048638701,
0.5959689021,
0.6558170319,
0.1076638922,
-0.0621651039,
-0.0283902083,
0.1073189229,
0.185450092,
-0.5808804631,
-0.5611791015,
1.4158848524,
0.1363701671,
0.633754015,
-0.260356158,
1.0124001503,
0.0361345261,
0.5485240817,
-0.5542943478,
0.525321126,
-0.3227748871,
-0.4359299839,
-0.1541562676,
-0.2587203681,
-0.9320809841,
0.0783913359,
-0.207921356,
-0.4963790476,
-0.3953159153,
0.5637413859,
-0.6434082985,
0.1413339376,
-1.1263848543,
1.1731705666,
-0.5380392671,
-0.3532086313,
-0.1881949604,
-0.6564198732,
0.4052550495,
-0.2184373885,
0.4306529462,
0.108757779,
0.0323542878,
0.7814533114,
-0.1760991812,
0.9954217076,
-0.1372394711,
-0.2074349374,
0.2638464868,
-0.0845539644,
0.2979107797,
-0.1556047201,
0.4166365564,
-0.0830514282,
-0.0413060896,
-0.5470190644,
-0.4988687932,
0.7391873002,
-0.7631244063,
-0.7904615402,
-0.0276089441,
-0.6256535053,
-0.5501176715,
0.1071994528,
0.0957672298,
0.305306375,
-0.084407039,
0.3386300802,
0.6485233307,
0.0113087958,
0.3947256505,
0.4846044183,
-0.2279247642,
-0.3571089804,
0.978120625,
-0.0676036924,
0.3599786162,
0.56401968,
-0.0877243131,
-0.1272467375,
-0.3665812314,
-0.5182448626,
-0.1602528393,
-0.6041170955,
0.0110441195,
-0.7910451889,
0.0227800142,
-0.4405127168,
0.0371482223,
-0.599011898,
0.005905109,
-0.333316952,
-0.2105625719,
0.0499147661,
0.8396641612,
-0.0525180325,
0.6595632434,
-0.9124497175,
0.3639451265,
0.5508495569,
0.362500608,
0.0329077281,
-0.4566699862,
-0.5127834678,
0.0617505051,
-0.149124667,
-0.8154911995,
0.1945150942,
0.1422863752,
0.4121861458,
0.4085079134,
-0.1621869802,
0.7898697257,
-0.9378899336,
0.6539000273,
0.2896451354,
-0.8600411415,
0.4024942517,
0.1038475633,
0.4124327302,
0.4557686746,
0.6700322628,
0.0561972782,
-0.2046962827,
-0.4463375807,
-0.7123836279,
0.8192324638,
-0.269608885,
0.3126587868,
0.0077824076,
-0.0483235046,
0.2649584413,
0.557174027,
-0.6836313605,
-0.1637079567,
-0.523874104,
-0.3294049799,
-0.4426554143,
-0.3499337733,
0.0592874847,
-0.107348755,
0.6203050613,
-0.1922534406,
0.0859233811,
-0.5076596737,
-0.5133969188,
0.1990867555,
0.4605337679,
0.7611077428,
0.5760716796,
-0.1749178469,
0.4162053466,
-0.003299498,
-0.5780935287,
0.1164408624,
0.1883694232,
0.3488361835,
-0.4462341368,
0.6062646508,
1.0883798599,
0.7468010783,
-0.5924155712,
0.5108739138,
0.0127167031,
-0.0710277334,
-0.2019270062,
0.0350577831,
0.4153082371,
0.0391737409,
0.2044122368,
0.0360011309,
-0.1781412512,
-0.4587315321,
0.1257483661,
0.287842989,
-0.1280824244,
-0.5093742013,
0.5309445858,
0.1533965319,
-0.2431528866,
0.4455346465,
-0.1918038279,
-0.4719035029,
0.2949038148,
0.5855380893,
0.5247223973,
-0.446506381,
0.2123674005,
0.2394187003,
0.3476653993,
-0.0891823694,
0.1549908221,
-0.4103222191,
-0.5155928135,
-0.8065928221,
-0.7009661794,
-0.1921731681,
0.461686641,
-0.7003605366,
0.0248392709,
-0.3536037207,
0.0494576767,
-0.0091745863,
-0.0887155756,
-0.9582498074,
0.1983538866,
0.0462869219,
0.3063132465,
-0.7373151183,
1.240506649,
0.680942297,
-0.402518034,
-0.8611608148,
-0.0582484752,
-0.2195285112,
-0.9424089789,
0.9273324013,
0.4947546422,
-0.2520770133,
0.1811248511,
-0.5954024792,
-0.7988203168,
0.672508359,
0.644287467,
-0.8761040568,
-0.2594939172,
0.1607564241,
0.3222226501,
-0.4460140765,
0.1988305151,
0.3930458724,
0.123025246,
-0.1882469803,
-0.8799908161,
-0.2586079836,
-0.1464721859,
-0.1617924571,
-0.0048518507,
-0.2353401184,
0.9203253984,
-0.394993335,
-0.0031307572,
-0.0726150721,
0.9045649767,
0.2010800391,
-0.0844908431,
0.7108106613,
0.5703163147,
0.5563656092,
0.0734755993,
0.9305909872,
-0.4968993068,
-0.1480821669,
1.4977384806,
-0.1045773849,
1.1150311232,
0.4823905528,
-0.2836694419,
0.5720703602,
0.5967122316,
0.3832019866,
0.608514607,
0.2117470354,
-0.3109903038,
-0.533854425,
0.0939837769,
-0.4208790958,
0.4271775782,
0.3582522869,
-0.1330145746,
0.0392821468,
0.3239057362,
0.0506227985,
0.1182515547,
-0.2829863727,
0.6460253,
0.0569563247,
-0.8363078237,
0.8011038899,
-0.1826900989,
0.8662568927,
-0.7556926608,
-0.0157642066,
0.0422548018,
0.2417630255,
-0.1825471818,
-0.4570009708,
-0.013659196,
0.1679875702,
-0.3569793701,
-0.4608082473,
0.3686659038,
-0.8160387874,
-0.35013327,
0.380073756,
0.3812161684,
0.2107358575,
-0.1576735824,
-0.4247416854,
0.1621321738,
-0.1074576229,
-0.3189810216,
0.6058428288,
0.1504020244,
0.1063499451,
0.4162210226,
0.8688779473,
0.0191204026,
0.4314614236,
0.1213883236,
0.8084558845,
-0.0644057989,
-0.3963870406,
-0.5727465153,
0.3886975348,
0.2020247281,
-0.1168971881,
0.6109830141,
0.5346195698,
1.3193972111,
-0.5784323812,
0.615223527,
0.2688653767,
0.4321759045,
-0.7075260878,
0.4609493613,
-0.4861680269,
0.0257622357,
-0.0512064658,
-0.815877378,
-0.0266530011,
0.4734498262,
-0.3804252446,
0.0967842564,
0.7723776698,
0.8825147152,
-0.0856734365,
-0.0217632465,
0.3767564595,
-0.0599091426,
-0.0020538128,
0.6126369834,
0.8462347388,
0.053433992,
0.5449858904,
-0.4428911507,
-0.2775362134,
0.0604469962,
-0.8236059546,
-1.1154659986,
-0.7406797409,
0.0434275493,
-0.0433355235,
0.1733548343,
1.112934947,
0.8141186237,
-0.8624652028,
-0.3596844971,
0.040592812,
-0.276483953,
-0.1307891607,
-0.077706553,
0.495536536,
-0.8938068748,
-0.7266085744,
0.8851642013,
0.0354431346,
-0.0340991765,
-0.3582471013,
-0.1837415397,
-0.2421054095,
-0.3258837163,
0.7766181231,
0.1151106358,
-0.6977495551,
0.0208860077,
0.1429588944,
-0.0557716116,
-0.1066852584,
0.920866549,
-0.7491774559,
0.3890223503,
-0.0654704049,
0.8594412804,
0.4732878804,
-0.2098402828,
0.3754372895,
-0.958065033,
0.424018234,
0.0655995235,
0.1470761895,
0.3436461091,
-0.1098086759,
0.1923320442,
-0.0186154172,
-0.3277054727,
-0.8824251294,
0.183943212,
-0.6451278329,
-0.1854838133,
0.9218477607,
-0.4708891511,
-0.2406803966,
0.126453802,
-0.0718930811,
0.3342708349,
-0.1899649948,
0.5976620913,
0.6109537482,
0.1096762195,
-0.2136689126,
-0.691470325,
0.5775949955,
0.5265529156,
-1.0397998095,
0.0590545386,
0.3535874486,
0.1169086024,
0.2310339808,
0.7576049566,
0.2169910818,
0.1324516982,
-0.1180414781,
0.2493073642,
-0.4959293008,
-0.7658507824,
0.1767414361,
0.3392668366,
0.0605937429,
-0.6086516976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14479v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14479v1 | On Layer-wise Representation Similarity: Application for Multi-Exit Models with a Single Classifier | 2024-06-20T16:41:09 | 2024-06-20T16:41:09 | Jiachen Jiang, Jinxin Zhou, Zhihui Zhu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Analyzing the similarity of internal representations within and across
different models has been an important technique for understanding the behavior
of deep neural networks. Most existing methods for analyzing the similarity
between representations of high dimensions, such as those based on Canonical
Correlation Analysis (CCA) and widely used Centered Kernel Alignment (CKA),
rely on statistical properties of the representations for a set of data points.
In this paper, we focus on transformer models and study the similarity of
representations between the hidden layers of individual transformers. In this
context, we show that a simple sample-wise cosine similarity metric is capable
of capturing the similarity and aligns with the complicated CKA. Our
experimental results on common transformers reveal that representations across
layers are positively correlated, albeit the similarity decreases when layers
are far apart. We then propose an aligned training approach to enhance the
similarity between internal representations, with trained models that enjoy the
following properties: (1) the last-layer classifier can be directly applied
right after any hidden layers, yielding intermediate layer accuracies much
higher than those under standard training, (2) the layer-wise accuracies
monotonically increase and reveal the minimal depth needed for the given task,
(3) when served as multi-exit models, they achieve on-par performance with
standard multi-exit architectures which consist of additional classifiers
designed for early exiting in shallow layers. To our knowledge, our work is the
first to show that one common classifier is sufficient for multi-exit models.
We conduct experiments on both vision and NLP tasks to demonstrate the
performance of the proposed aligned training. | [
-0.5074602962,
-0.1398407519,
0.5835838914,
-0.10183011,
-0.0848252773,
0.1243849918,
-0.2170965523,
-0.1988794357,
0.0748844892,
0.378644824,
-0.5183574557,
-0.454877466,
-0.4898479283,
-0.3922375143,
-0.552259326,
0.5027023554,
0.0010129318,
0.2292349637,
-0.3656940758,
-0.3285548985,
-0.5691096187,
-0.5863010287,
-0.5872275829,
-0.6875862479,
0.5965586305,
0.2173603773,
0.5887094736,
0.4132315516,
0.8093605638,
0.3739339113,
0.0627418905,
-0.1143833697,
-0.3626746237,
-0.1763249487,
0.0374141484,
-0.3350590169,
-0.0553016104,
0.1410971433,
0.4897691011,
0.7280248404,
-0.1899224967,
0.2581226528,
0.2987490892,
0.5867772102,
-0.581306994,
0.0775959119,
-0.5396124125,
0.4485092759,
0.0299878102,
-0.1046876684,
-0.6519024372,
-0.1681717932,
0.3302206993,
-0.6299362183,
0.4134757817,
-0.1104111001,
0.9096751213,
0.3516376019,
-0.2919931412,
-0.0163202286,
-0.8416669369,
0.9258676767,
-0.5368593335,
0.7012279034,
-0.3908043802,
0.7158513665,
0.2844804227,
-0.5624164939,
-0.6216116548,
-0.1619331837,
-0.3580333292,
0.5358189344,
-0.0204569157,
-0.1311581582,
0.105679743,
0.2365849316,
-0.3530393243,
0.3305228651,
-0.3878890574,
-0.1687016189,
0.3609326184,
-0.0042354004,
0.1010560319,
-0.0892536864,
-0.8720352054,
-0.6790899634,
-0.4116440117,
0.3477279842,
0.5167127848,
0.3515388072,
-0.2515820861,
0.2743230164,
0.2124782354,
0.2721983194,
0.1838029027,
0.108335264,
0.3602463901,
0.0601405241,
-0.2821989954,
0.1317264885,
0.8323489428,
0.2943574786,
0.1705848873,
-0.4338060319,
-0.1429905444,
0.1249400601,
0.6357117891,
-0.5504688025,
-0.2242662758,
0.0218532737,
-0.6982994676,
-0.4359805584,
0.3880788088,
-0.6541027427,
-0.2043887973,
-0.563118577,
0.5967542529,
-0.3787770271,
-0.3641784787,
-0.008676853,
-0.3532589674,
0.737613976,
-0.0112032751,
-0.6909838915,
0.6046699286,
0.7630895972,
0.6989099979,
-0.2869610488,
-0.3432230353,
-0.2982317209,
0.057234548,
-0.4563999176,
0.4124456942,
-0.6206567287,
0.2272856385,
-0.1041884869,
-0.1404338926,
-0.1162971407,
-0.55600667,
0.4592227042,
-0.8642196059,
0.210882619,
-0.0451070815,
-0.4105361402,
-0.5316333175,
0.1606748104,
-0.9150243998,
0.8815414906,
0.0646437705,
-0.6308525205,
0.3652179539,
-0.5237876177,
0.0697075427,
-0.2962783575,
-0.3193058372,
-0.837562263,
0.3132380247,
0.3404351175,
0.6545679569,
-0.0632782355,
0.1011142209,
-0.3575017452,
-0.4405491948,
0.0806752294,
-0.3863536119,
0.6879269481,
-0.0323982313,
-0.1203815117,
0.0872253478,
-0.6796603203,
0.040720176,
0.0385936834,
0.1614416689,
-0.5102640986,
-0.2063094378,
0.0234711803,
0.3415431082,
0.2203335315,
-0.5850721598,
0.0554611795,
-0.0445384793,
0.1923637539,
0.7744808197,
-0.0660662428,
0.7719228864,
-0.153096512,
0.2921634614,
0.726421535,
0.1426895708,
-0.0042957552,
-0.3993147612,
-0.5863352418,
-0.1927682906,
0.4024585783,
0.389336735,
-0.2988539934,
0.57924366,
-0.486089319,
-0.6703721881,
-0.6485635042,
-0.1128988191,
0.2179536819,
0.5740834475,
0.6122349501,
-0.6932178736,
-0.4766106904,
-1.1040149927,
-0.1879493743,
0.2141096443,
-0.0566736981,
0.0306657366,
0.3500906229,
-0.1564571112,
0.7593666315,
-0.3203857839,
-0.4639534056,
0.011788968,
-0.0317247175,
0.4977286458,
0.6098627448,
0.4834401011,
-0.7196555734,
-0.4232177734,
0.367215097,
-0.8578292727,
0.4741877317,
-0.4147778153,
-0.1018041894,
-0.4013905525,
0.444559902,
-0.5024974942,
0.3494217098,
0.5137386322,
0.2901349664,
0.1409306824,
-0.1368298084,
-0.0779554769,
-1.0390181541,
0.0011036948,
0.235527128,
-0.0029290083,
-0.7729476094,
0.1420843899,
0.3168768287,
-0.1892272383,
-0.3453289568,
0.1234966516,
-0.3682492971,
-0.2469679713,
0.0416816734,
0.1027987078,
0.0765793845,
0.8199608922,
0.1470820606,
0.5210927725,
0.8393768668,
-0.4970930517,
0.1603731215,
0.1967453957,
-0.2785637677,
0.4658507407,
-0.5582367182,
0.38364622,
-0.3168010116,
0.1860917509,
-0.8673942089,
0.0056029721,
0.039017234,
-0.2610376477,
0.4302091599,
-0.0424626246,
-0.1027293056,
-0.4011450112,
-0.4131624997,
0.5205540657,
0.6056460142,
-0.9035730362,
0.8715768456,
0.0341922119,
0.4559621513,
-0.8941066861,
-0.8255597353,
-0.2070188969,
-0.4091589749,
-0.6490287781,
0.6721894145,
0.2616136968,
0.1730811298,
0.1610401124,
-0.1826078892,
-0.2897247076,
-0.1557765901,
0.2728198469,
0.2042111307,
-0.6153975129,
-0.0315362029,
0.0988305584,
-0.2321522087,
0.197041437,
-0.1931745857,
0.6983155012,
-0.3163592219,
-0.6734806895,
-0.6525172591,
0.4077143073,
0.3360227346,
-0.3622309864,
0.8119112849,
0.8937345743,
-0.3807466924,
-0.0290877521,
-0.5102430582,
-0.2731854618,
-0.5247020721,
0.3216819763,
-0.576174438,
-0.3596177995,
1.0358524323,
-0.0689956099,
-0.1085473597,
0.6344394684,
0.296623677,
-0.2709187567,
0.8567290306,
0.7142480612,
-0.1794666499,
0.4161019921,
-0.746443212,
0.5188255906,
-0.9525997639,
-0.4684590995,
-0.2993506491,
-0.6778671741,
-0.4895140231,
-0.0615394115,
0.3574965298,
0.3070665598,
-0.3261677623,
0.5888062119,
-0.7941164374,
0.7131615281,
0.499896735,
0.3601759672,
0.0187453106,
0.1480406821,
-0.3268174231,
-0.0377271697,
-0.8024359941,
-0.3135592937,
0.7974501848,
0.4679004252,
0.6140531301,
-0.1048467308,
1.0490968227,
-0.1013326645,
0.1894226968,
-0.7055450678,
0.2589933276,
-0.3455386758,
-0.1859891117,
-0.1507664919,
-0.426450938,
-0.6351574063,
0.2225414962,
0.0576463081,
-0.4921509326,
0.6669022441,
-0.0296204146,
-0.4014801681,
0.6283210516,
-0.9483144879,
0.9298256636,
-0.070522204,
0.0331332646,
-0.2217031419,
-0.7750385404,
0.3624546826,
-0.0637121871,
-0.2131962031,
0.3829234838,
0.2410215288,
0.6350570321,
-0.2210578322,
0.7780970931,
-0.2559823096,
0.0419359133,
0.35454759,
-0.1013337001,
0.1901484132,
-0.180039376,
-0.1056510359,
0.497104764,
-0.211090669,
-0.2440589368,
-0.734949708,
0.7671381831,
-0.9888268113,
-0.2432436198,
-0.3024865687,
-0.4730250537,
0.0286315605,
0.1718149334,
0.274787426,
0.5658850074,
-0.0088749286,
0.3085640073,
0.5540744662,
-0.1359914988,
0.5529046655,
-0.1669049114,
0.1939988285,
-0.0893923268,
0.8837084174,
-0.0096049141,
0.1842482835,
0.5904502869,
0.2987360656,
-0.4496918321,
-0.3082720041,
-0.3660994768,
-0.0479519144,
-0.87124753,
-0.3830539882,
-0.4119202793,
-0.8358968496,
-0.1748736203,
-0.2241580039,
-0.4566235244,
-0.2214082479,
-0.2379174531,
-0.0053854864,
-0.0077066175,
0.892541945,
-0.0298666768,
0.5045233965,
-0.7079384327,
0.3032456934,
0.4496195912,
0.5131761432,
0.5526009202,
-0.4226947129,
-0.2698528171,
-0.1710022241,
-0.6575668454,
-0.7114027739,
0.0697458312,
0.2880407572,
0.7018890381,
0.6016697884,
-0.2167044282,
0.7505830526,
-0.4754982293,
0.7153666615,
0.6218061447,
-0.9413293004,
0.1045886055,
0.1059116945,
0.1608288735,
0.3995741606,
0.5218598843,
-0.4357679188,
-0.2678215802,
-0.6058981419,
-0.4886505008,
0.6563415527,
0.2167811245,
0.1887967438,
0.4198620617,
0.2029425651,
0.3123340011,
-0.1218384355,
-0.7380167246,
-0.2570143342,
-0.5585383773,
-0.384247452,
0.1570593864,
0.1847673953,
-0.0514601544,
-0.1429865509,
0.3066666126,
-0.0539032221,
0.6000175476,
-0.0048975213,
-0.0001066829,
-0.103982605,
0.18475613,
0.2751687169,
0.4605153203,
-0.2381160855,
0.3499162197,
0.357444346,
-0.4236257374,
0.1686916351,
-0.0807471871,
0.0618208833,
-0.0956828445,
0.4659166932,
0.5375242829,
0.1250436008,
0.0681017563,
0.699187696,
-0.1396492571,
-0.0445811711,
-0.3423884213,
0.0379054546,
0.1461943537,
0.382555604,
0.4193960428,
0.708953023,
0.066512309,
-0.2820035219,
0.3522964716,
0.5867158175,
-0.7050498724,
-0.381947726,
0.4875566065,
-0.1722565144,
-0.2435764372,
0.6893746257,
-0.0266313497,
-0.5521934032,
0.7822992206,
0.3545656204,
1.0488876104,
-0.2918436825,
0.1081002876,
0.4896201193,
0.2833012342,
-0.1101850718,
-0.141401127,
-0.018483229,
-0.8422554731,
-0.5764790177,
-0.3216709197,
-0.1853590608,
0.1894538254,
-0.9997528195,
0.4291788936,
-0.3075693548,
0.1083591953,
0.0276577137,
-0.1786342412,
-1.1864044666,
0.1864745319,
0.2807821631,
0.6931666732,
-0.9038930535,
0.7430722713,
0.3565708697,
-0.3399647474,
-0.9964701533,
-0.0937925428,
-0.4189224839,
-0.6971315742,
0.4001255333,
0.5824750662,
-0.2136978805,
-0.328230232,
-0.5661963224,
-0.6893110275,
1.3105089664,
0.3987058401,
-0.7276892066,
-0.0883791745,
0.412617296,
0.7109076977,
-0.7966820598,
0.4962458014,
0.3669762015,
0.2875917554,
-0.0765561759,
-0.5501567721,
0.0159832072,
-0.009503522,
0.2056007683,
0.1193515882,
-0.7049967647,
0.7437859774,
-0.1742872298,
-0.3151601851,
-0.0532433689,
0.6898187995,
0.0007934577,
0.362506777,
0.7494350672,
0.7773385644,
0.4794893265,
-0.0771139339,
0.8934001923,
-0.249639675,
0.5525494218,
0.97299546,
-0.123123616,
0.7277570963,
0.4199517071,
0.1013041064,
0.6091870666,
0.3136736155,
-0.1230134964,
0.845228374,
-0.0288030505,
0.3174035251,
-0.2200947851,
0.1063876525,
-0.4803493619,
0.5682980418,
0.0990414321,
-0.4836781919,
-0.2905678451,
-0.1495997459,
-0.6426725984,
0.0206765961,
-0.1968138367,
0.7526516318,
0.2479477376,
-0.3873669505,
0.3341287673,
-0.2381823808,
0.4853780568,
-0.4979155362,
-0.2004428059,
-0.0615477301,
0.1989124715,
-0.3697029948,
-0.7724382281,
0.3394654989,
-0.4655242264,
-0.2285963297,
-0.3176236749,
0.7262410522,
-0.4669911265,
-0.5366165042,
0.6024560332,
0.2697944641,
-0.0738492087,
0.0103299329,
-0.5548067689,
0.0061419103,
-0.2974863052,
-0.0448227338,
-0.0592914931,
0.3970769048,
0.1127669513,
0.3778599799,
0.4615316391,
-0.1205034778,
0.4912386239,
0.3948236704,
0.9624816179,
-0.6912973523,
-0.3852405846,
-0.6719529629,
0.5238811374,
-0.1862260699,
-0.2338806391,
0.4701112211,
0.6354664564,
0.9321119189,
-0.2910529077,
0.3357060552,
0.3207238913,
0.2873854339,
-0.4759892821,
0.563051939,
-0.5006833076,
0.1584885716,
-0.3198218346,
-1.4741352797,
-0.1790813953,
0.5444194078,
-0.0918542892,
0.1175657064,
0.682862103,
0.7871568799,
-0.8348247409,
0.0916325077,
0.2578721941,
0.0120672211,
0.4308567941,
0.6762839556,
1.0190919638,
-0.8214223981,
0.4266850948,
-0.6312955022,
0.0769533589,
0.1065355018,
-0.6890751719,
-0.7820771337,
-0.7640209794,
-0.2159019709,
-0.0391484275,
-0.4669819474,
0.433214128,
0.9218485951,
-0.9434725046,
-0.128118977,
0.019887127,
-0.0660952032,
-0.7579551339,
-0.2513750494,
0.6205256581,
-0.2057950646,
-0.4321718514,
0.2199862748,
0.1566308439,
-0.1308032125,
-0.7001743913,
-0.0555554889,
0.1463639587,
-0.1804451644,
0.436668545,
-0.2615067363,
-0.6309133172,
-0.6059759855,
0.0654149577,
-0.1064350083,
0.5372259617,
0.964681685,
-0.837287426,
0.3000205159,
0.578020215,
0.8100630641,
0.7332038879,
-0.1826563478,
0.2902223468,
-1.0862119198,
0.0599961951,
0.26114586,
0.2901166677,
0.4631722569,
-0.3273720145,
0.3897042274,
-0.3700086176,
-0.377227515,
-0.5331528783,
0.1231928393,
-1.4403010607,
0.1920146048,
0.5735804439,
-0.0234287828,
-0.2926044166,
0.1941422522,
0.1589298844,
0.3798385262,
-0.3751303554,
0.8040537238,
0.6654809713,
-0.0482284948,
-0.2988488972,
-0.2195332348,
0.1929170489,
0.3166606426,
-0.518453002,
-0.3656279147,
-0.30569157,
0.0773010626,
0.8381149173,
0.0259191711,
-0.148969993,
0.1224874035,
-0.1370664686,
0.031946592,
0.0513681211,
-0.570771575,
-0.4915964901,
0.3943485022,
-0.4317349494,
-0.4617976248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14473v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14473v1 | Data-Centric AI in the Age of Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T16:34:07 | 2024-06-20T16:34:07 | Xinyi Xu, Zhaoxuan Wu, Rui Qiao, Arun Verma, Yao Shu, Jingtan Wang, Xinyuan Niu, Zhenfeng He, Jiangwei Chen, Zijian Zhou, Gregory Kang Ruey Lau, Hieu Dao, Lucas Agussurja, Rachael Hwee Ling Sim, Xiaoqiang Lin, Wenyang Hu, Zhongxiang Dai, Pang Wei Koh, Bryan Kian Hsiang Low | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | This position paper proposes a data-centric viewpoint of AI research,
focusing on large language models (LLMs). We start by making the key
observation that data is instrumental in the developmental (e.g., pretraining
and fine-tuning) and inferential stages (e.g., in-context learning) of LLMs,
and yet it receives disproportionally low attention from the research
community. We identify four specific scenarios centered around data, covering
data-centric benchmarks and data curation, data attribution, knowledge
transfer, and inference contextualization. In each scenario, we underscore the
importance of data, highlight promising research directions, and articulate the
potential impacts on the research community and, where applicable, the society
as a whole. For instance, we advocate for a suite of data-centric benchmarks
tailored to the scale and complexity of data for LLMs. These benchmarks can be
used to develop new data curation methods and document research efforts and
results, which can help promote openness and transparency in AI and LLM
research. | [
-0.3893717527,
-0.950443387,
0.6438502669,
-0.0243110377,
0.1865358949,
0.0434515625,
-0.4602331817,
-0.4704868197,
-0.027046252,
0.5117889047,
-0.361810565,
-0.466678679,
-0.5874335766,
-0.0283872876,
-0.6962249279,
0.8917846084,
0.0185938664,
0.1132917777,
-0.7674555182,
-0.0648718625,
-0.3559163511,
-0.918484509,
-0.9402604699,
-0.5160704851,
0.6801237464,
0.7472891212,
0.523281455,
1.0493421555,
0.4043999016,
0.206709072,
0.0011146119,
-0.1288721263,
-0.5822144151,
0.2227741629,
-0.0590733401,
-0.7957695127,
-0.5143254399,
0.2832078934,
0.7542762756,
1.160562396,
0.0370218232,
0.1556157172,
0.0017555237,
0.8697339892,
-0.3312652707,
0.4701401293,
-0.5250139832,
-0.1143701226,
-0.5733273029,
0.0632041693,
-0.2567685246,
-0.3213830888,
0.1378787607,
-0.4204782546,
0.1175584495,
0.1521482617,
0.1728477925,
0.2888679802,
-0.168482691,
-0.1839740127,
-0.8506774902,
0.9513667822,
-0.7596927881,
0.3855478168,
0.4916417301,
0.1120258197,
-0.2556942999,
-0.5299075842,
-0.6458530426,
-0.1080609411,
0.2450236678,
-0.2779080272,
-0.1033596471,
-0.2188063711,
0.3906339407,
0.4202088714,
-0.4620908797,
0.4958054721,
-0.3159714937,
0.1897759438,
0.8555089235,
0.3719277382,
-0.0667643547,
0.4689675272,
-0.0220233519,
0.0185499191,
-1.0765666962,
-0.0536424592,
0.2417878509,
0.5627503991,
-0.16662696,
0.5640760064,
-0.4892990887,
0.6555737853,
0.0422950052,
0.0184192751,
0.5483256578,
-0.4563536346,
-0.0264082514,
-0.0533245467,
0.5817056298,
0.0660154745,
0.4001993835,
-0.2969288528,
-0.1838696152,
0.0238261651,
0.2745051086,
-0.7041604519,
-0.0466702841,
0.3676857948,
-0.3205367327,
-0.2017944306,
-0.1724727005,
-0.8697127104,
-0.6715959907,
-0.7243868709,
-0.0516652614,
-0.1935351342,
-0.2345921546,
-0.0656978339,
0.4103946984,
0.4170354903,
0.3565583527,
-0.8006894588,
0.3216801584,
1.0748873949,
0.5656751394,
-0.4541131258,
-0.4222146273,
-0.2246862054,
0.1450244635,
-0.4431141615,
0.6093705893,
-0.731370151,
-0.4155291319,
0.1816182435,
-0.0801554993,
0.0452979282,
-0.6303030252,
0.4739137292,
-0.2595019937,
0.1924295425,
-0.2204832435,
-0.858247757,
-0.0647945777,
0.4126631916,
-0.6797941923,
0.7432944179,
0.0275570583,
-0.7328799963,
0.4216578901,
-0.8076485395,
-0.7312472463,
0.0801881775,
-0.4014377594,
-0.3310588002,
0.1643172652,
-0.0493695028,
0.4229686856,
-0.5308212638,
0.5582689643,
-0.4987648726,
-0.252956003,
0.4054018557,
-0.5439816713,
0.527620554,
0.1868997365,
-0.2596584857,
-0.0193380192,
-0.6251695156,
-0.1817025244,
0.1444260478,
-0.1927431524,
-0.2871031463,
0.3418022096,
0.1097695008,
-0.0417882055,
0.4873119891,
-0.5514416099,
0.3233291805,
-0.3002005816,
0.5873995423,
0.7312310338,
-0.4409079552,
0.7378146052,
-0.358856976,
0.4762494266,
0.1519045383,
0.388864696,
-0.1581769288,
-0.2632253766,
-0.7198508978,
-0.0603942387,
0.3443677127,
0.2016388029,
-0.6299635768,
0.3309842348,
-0.2984457314,
-0.4286043346,
-0.5355275273,
0.118466489,
0.0563699938,
0.5871292949,
0.1726283133,
-0.3260327578,
-0.4339815676,
-0.9068664908,
0.0625537932,
-0.2521748543,
0.2059104741,
0.4558388889,
0.3244135976,
-0.2947942019,
0.9777620435,
-0.2300288528,
-0.1527403295,
-0.4855594635,
-0.0292009637,
0.2566634715,
0.5637998581,
0.3550781608,
-0.8565863967,
-0.3072107434,
-0.085717462,
-0.7566609979,
-0.0390171595,
0.3552078605,
0.0790359154,
0.232163772,
0.7067232132,
-0.5882234573,
0.3289389312,
0.5188480616,
-0.0814800933,
0.1503216177,
-0.071480006,
0.0106982393,
-0.9689865708,
0.3838242292,
0.0155175924,
0.0084950561,
-0.9896808863,
-0.2719263732,
-0.2315024436,
-0.1014541313,
-0.1702166498,
0.6872698069,
-0.2293724716,
-0.0386927463,
-0.3073836565,
-0.0217284951,
-0.2773341238,
0.156162262,
0.0356800817,
0.7114220858,
0.6405899525,
-0.5052182078,
0.2765160203,
0.1000814736,
-0.4169247746,
0.4132623672,
-0.7496650815,
0.3735723197,
-0.2037563473,
0.2911114991,
-0.6316446066,
-0.2200785428,
0.2267138064,
-0.4306867421,
0.2744959891,
-0.0171838757,
-0.7091687322,
-0.2425942272,
-0.2088611424,
0.7937343717,
0.1553641856,
-0.2402212769,
0.1988387704,
0.9151713252,
-0.415635556,
-0.3595137298,
-0.644499898,
0.0349565335,
-0.4840444028,
-0.247137323,
0.1663983017,
-0.1709001362,
-0.5379489064,
-0.0653055608,
0.2601071,
-0.1057232544,
0.2036245912,
0.3091286421,
0.1925931871,
-0.1662384719,
0.2015178055,
-0.3796452284,
-0.2773421109,
0.1808117181,
-0.31534639,
0.610673368,
0.1279040724,
-0.3845207989,
-0.1862481683,
0.3876034915,
0.5657689571,
-0.268178165,
0.690367341,
0.271808058,
-0.3726486862,
-0.1767911017,
-0.4532510638,
-0.0720913336,
-0.3522635102,
0.2708331645,
-0.0061613773,
-1.0650702715,
0.5162727237,
-0.0204806756,
0.1988992542,
0.3057782352,
0.6349548101,
-0.1684485078,
0.9594982862,
0.947804749,
-0.8884359002,
0.6850675941,
-0.2003788799,
0.289896518,
-0.8254744411,
-0.0531866029,
-0.7818168402,
-0.3624817729,
-0.6414160132,
-0.1888145804,
0.3835736215,
-0.2609346211,
-0.4153172076,
-0.1575319469,
-0.2280001342,
0.2190259099,
0.4752636552,
-0.1993502229,
0.2010030299,
-0.1740518212,
0.6223685741,
0.0552569702,
-0.7850139737,
-0.5139410496,
1.5147243738,
0.4184165597,
0.796386838,
-0.1675447077,
0.4281585813,
0.4425843656,
0.4320172668,
-0.7798780203,
0.3532864451,
-0.1535372585,
-0.6971251965,
-0.4565598071,
-0.3871617019,
-1.0440231562,
-0.2790951431,
0.0454960093,
-0.5669089556,
0.1455133408,
0.0314619057,
-0.0581865162,
0.0465147011,
-0.4720400572,
0.7947483063,
-0.1967905015,
-0.3587192595,
-0.3205498457,
-0.528511107,
0.1901237667,
-0.2122960985,
0.554092586,
-0.1681445092,
0.004172028,
0.7527968287,
-0.1192590222,
0.7902315855,
-0.2824395597,
-0.1213705689,
0.22730048,
-0.2988882661,
0.4878001809,
0.0455191918,
-0.2825615108,
0.2758282423,
-0.1425556391,
-0.3286666572,
-0.4554795921,
0.6715277433,
-0.682086587,
-0.5321971178,
-0.3091835976,
-0.8459069729,
-0.4398043454,
-0.0045826682,
-0.1055656224,
0.3423584998,
-0.2772016525,
0.3873967826,
0.8474235535,
-0.1104344875,
0.1573334336,
0.472553879,
-0.2514836192,
0.0163659398,
1.0127922297,
0.1939131916,
0.1166820377,
0.2988080382,
0.0479737669,
-0.2342731208,
-0.9311593175,
-0.3132850528,
0.1609905511,
-0.4526586533,
-0.0536750332,
-0.2558818758,
-0.2903359532,
-0.3448841274,
0.0704101846,
-0.6284256577,
-0.1659087539,
-0.3357278109,
0.0855463222,
0.5397888422,
0.8721567392,
0.1232995465,
0.1224508956,
-0.2915719748,
0.0350072645,
-0.0637748763,
0.3052891493,
0.111342974,
-0.4565865397,
-0.6928666234,
0.2062114924,
0.0207265839,
-0.0049763392,
0.2021405548,
-0.0800221786,
0.7012156248,
0.2856573462,
-0.1245678738,
0.3177898526,
-0.4141035676,
0.7626684904,
-0.1386524141,
-0.6289342046,
0.4466664195,
-0.3877700865,
0.1956050396,
0.9101264477,
0.2591522932,
-0.6872929931,
-0.1662552655,
-0.4599871635,
-0.8649341464,
0.759606123,
-0.0974629223,
0.15374282,
0.2560099065,
0.4379554391,
0.4297562242,
0.5090476274,
-0.3229046464,
-0.4368342757,
0.1738397926,
-0.310341686,
-0.4277592003,
-0.0015587658,
-0.1386099011,
-0.3341125846,
0.4071784914,
-0.2666633427,
0.1410592943,
-0.2823062837,
0.0697406754,
0.0630517602,
0.2426321357,
0.2959403098,
0.8833737969,
0.0739489719,
0.118067123,
-0.1184621677,
-0.4397326708,
0.0297500733,
0.2588578165,
-0.4511170983,
-0.393592,
0.3563750088,
0.5716622472,
-0.0941706672,
-0.6716293097,
0.4210550189,
-0.0556970052,
-0.0327580683,
-0.372235924,
0.0586565211,
-0.1350947767,
0.4088067412,
0.244173944,
-0.3974388838,
-0.0335606597,
-0.8181143403,
0.1235527173,
0.4026606977,
-0.2916894257,
-0.4143742025,
0.5591392517,
0.1454659253,
-0.1256242096,
0.7844120264,
0.283075273,
-0.2756927609,
0.7293787003,
0.1820299625,
0.7721397877,
-0.1232201532,
-0.0591335483,
-0.0150486138,
0.0527613573,
-0.0613394901,
0.20803608,
0.0216629468,
-0.7675410509,
-0.2473258227,
-0.4810227752,
-0.5869847536,
0.4600687027,
-0.5600013137,
0.191839695,
-0.4330149293,
0.0030940617,
0.2114664465,
0.2094695419,
-0.8230013251,
0.2330581695,
0.3863876462,
0.7363935113,
-0.7249997258,
1.2594772577,
0.5874026418,
-0.337002337,
-0.4400740266,
0.053033594,
-0.0221169218,
-0.8501662016,
0.4188717604,
-0.0054714638,
0.2001058906,
0.0295107383,
-1.0602452755,
-0.9404907227,
1.1098371744,
0.2611358166,
-0.4887090623,
0.0783062279,
0.4200028181,
0.7085665464,
-0.8294655085,
0.0401707329,
0.8532539606,
0.5756404996,
-0.0644867793,
-0.7071844339,
-0.2983950377,
-0.1901264787,
-0.1361679882,
0.0118555408,
-0.7142409086,
1.0205845833,
0.1271286309,
-0.0017669409,
0.0184472091,
0.5673835874,
0.0745444596,
0.514783442,
0.2916294634,
0.4830333591,
0.5508781672,
-0.0287591554,
0.9549722672,
-0.4500440061,
0.0089020152,
1.1314749718,
-0.5392827988,
0.7236907482,
0.6437992454,
-0.3699730635,
0.1599105895,
0.7249313593,
0.0688711032,
0.4064153433,
0.3746292293,
-0.1722612232,
0.167931214,
-0.536700666,
-0.4439068437,
0.5883856416,
0.5831632614,
-0.3119398654,
0.1196915358,
-0.0350137427,
0.1372003406,
-0.0159275457,
-0.3597138226,
0.7862244844,
0.1043736115,
-0.4162092805,
0.1833695322,
-0.0962070376,
0.4094729722,
-0.4796589613,
0.0457681566,
-0.5096483827,
0.2403750271,
-0.0463377647,
-1.0825532675,
0.3340243101,
0.2403101027,
-0.5717900395,
-0.2666620016,
0.3900508285,
-0.4147783518,
-0.4065658152,
0.2417284399,
0.7365343571,
0.3712348342,
0.0196953733,
-0.5947696567,
0.4840035439,
-0.1387742013,
-0.445543617,
0.600333333,
0.7059714198,
-0.2057356834,
0.7741712332,
0.4822894335,
0.1898330301,
-0.1525408775,
0.2700177133,
1.067569375,
-0.688804388,
-0.0573867559,
-0.8099434972,
0.1209164634,
0.2444129586,
-0.2666073442,
0.7385240197,
0.6414068937,
0.9343000054,
0.4117442966,
1.1968530416,
-0.2252597511,
0.6541467309,
-0.2863326073,
0.6714669466,
-0.387547493,
0.167724818,
-0.00122239,
-0.8805822134,
-0.1770926565,
0.1975830048,
-0.5905454159,
0.2365099937,
0.2131830007,
0.5494382381,
0.0896974951,
0.0649391338,
0.1687965989,
0.2900084257,
0.4339186549,
0.4501126707,
0.7209812403,
-0.1309610605,
-0.0468948334,
-0.1979241073,
-0.072653383,
-0.1876299977,
-0.5061483979,
-0.6818669438,
-0.6725683212,
-0.1704219282,
0.0940479562,
-0.1338495612,
0.7294490933,
0.5570663214,
-0.9037460089,
-0.5567141175,
-0.1604793519,
0.1730506867,
0.1922295541,
-0.2054272294,
0.1838345975,
-0.1955628097,
-0.903181076,
0.3659220934,
0.2116716355,
-0.1175597534,
-0.6796700954,
-0.0962301344,
-0.0830418542,
-0.0528798811,
0.6236166358,
0.414077431,
-0.4233628511,
-0.2367533296,
-0.1993431449,
-0.1925379485,
0.0506500416,
0.8075119257,
-0.7392898798,
0.3754494488,
0.2824339271,
0.8539580107,
0.4141686559,
0.0414369963,
0.8138052821,
-0.3735998571,
0.2694875002,
0.3307666183,
0.0709351078,
0.56856215,
-0.314270705,
0.7058793306,
0.1412284225,
-0.7605242133,
-0.866027236,
0.0107695581,
-0.7196085453,
-0.0415613465,
1.1096224785,
-0.0396237224,
-0.1240237504,
-0.2120145857,
0.1785679758,
0.1808554679,
-0.4278582633,
0.7826740146,
0.7939491272,
-0.3395332098,
-0.2049046457,
-0.8965418339,
0.5576723814,
0.2674225271,
-1.1736557484,
0.6025338769,
0.5174707174,
-0.0549627915,
-0.0618601553,
0.4876151979,
-0.2004506737,
-0.2351124138,
-0.07369636,
0.1106186211,
0.1221393198,
-0.4852842391,
-0.5226436853,
-0.0788000301,
0.3456481993,
-0.0247855093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14464v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14464v1 | A Review of Common Online Speaker Diarization Methods | 2024-06-20T16:26:03 | 2024-06-20T16:26:03 | Roman Aperdannier, Sigurd Schacht, Alexander Piazza | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Speaker diarization provides the answer to the question "who spoke when?" for
an audio file. This information can be used to complete audio transcripts for
further processing steps. Most speaker diarization systems assume that the
audio file is available as a whole. However, there are scenarios in which the
speaker labels are needed immediately after the arrival of an audio segment.
Speaker diarization with a correspondingly low latency is referred to as online
speaker diarization. This paper provides an overview. First the history of
online speaker diarization is briefly presented. Next a taxonomy and datasets
for training and evaluation are given. In the sections that follow, online
diarization methods and systems are discussed in detail. This paper concludes
with the presentation of challenges that still need to be solved by future
research in the field of online speaker diarization. | [
-0.814971745,
-0.7951645851,
0.6192384958,
0.0938634425,
0.0751942471,
0.1480547935,
-0.2461653352,
-0.8749988675,
0.5321218371,
0.2928390205,
-0.513379395,
-0.1321599782,
-0.3864092529,
0.2076304108,
-0.4931854904,
0.6499242187,
0.3682336211,
0.1553783864,
-0.1504818201,
0.0544382371,
-0.5893854499,
-0.6175060272,
-0.7970743775,
-0.4865352213,
0.2390718162,
0.5952451825,
0.3349651396,
0.657302916,
0.5601872802,
0.5124477744,
-0.3610940874,
0.089353472,
-0.070563212,
0.1875288039,
0.2484364957,
-0.3392343521,
-0.5616705418,
0.1381486654,
0.5047413707,
1.3893885612,
-0.4213902354,
-0.0547283702,
-0.4028651714,
0.2343579382,
-0.6268034577,
-0.2258132696,
-0.3213678002,
0.3976285756,
-0.4208436906,
-0.5460025072,
-0.3610422909,
-0.5642934442,
0.4662708044,
-0.6269648075,
0.6223727465,
-0.2183521837,
0.4941786826,
0.1440478265,
-0.20570153,
-0.2689987421,
-1.4005264044,
0.5977216363,
-0.5389693379,
0.5625322461,
0.9729045033,
0.6117760539,
0.0057301898,
-0.6533837318,
-0.4032360315,
0.0685081333,
-0.0341740847,
0.0291738678,
0.0254666973,
0.3152226508,
0.2500064671,
0.4263590276,
-0.1632965207,
0.0131305996,
-0.4637881219,
-0.3215125799,
0.4210112393,
-0.2582017183,
0.0530847497,
0.1360412091,
-0.2563399076,
0.2826367617,
-0.2958800197,
-0.2101648152,
0.4604647458,
0.3244381249,
-0.1294114143,
0.3702242672,
-0.2932023406,
0.8408234715,
0.4066064954,
-0.3207510114,
0.3880818784,
-0.3781814575,
0.2349649221,
0.715724349,
0.5790723562,
0.4823268056,
0.1800386608,
-0.0571217388,
-0.2820391655,
-0.2685492635,
-0.096149534,
-0.464695394,
-0.3049523532,
0.1842233241,
-0.401584506,
0.3165851831,
-0.1238274947,
-0.8054865003,
-0.3581659496,
-0.3703805804,
0.4621583223,
-0.1401755363,
-0.1158057973,
0.101500757,
-0.3398082256,
-0.1024102941,
0.3516502082,
-1.1998534203,
0.7553274035,
0.3576854467,
0.9155586958,
0.059532091,
0.2078071982,
-0.8183115125,
0.1822196841,
-0.1634050161,
0.8859156966,
-0.310171932,
-0.5969338417,
-0.036090523,
-0.1844439507,
0.1481937617,
-0.5148878694,
0.3413335979,
-0.4017964005,
0.3292852342,
-0.1630493253,
-0.8214040399,
0.3207243681,
-0.1115281805,
-0.4455166161,
0.7762984633,
-0.1184415519,
-0.9953357577,
0.2775188684,
-0.509493947,
-0.0605700836,
0.3757821321,
-0.3163911104,
-0.2330348045,
-0.2642829418,
0.279558152,
0.5528789759,
0.2949103117,
-0.1321372092,
0.129480958,
-0.4821150303,
0.1467775255,
-0.093967177,
0.6295540333,
0.3882183135,
-0.1577575058,
-0.3770084977,
-1.2450847626,
-0.1771075577,
0.0056719538,
-0.6917575598,
-0.4189187884,
0.6048052311,
-0.1172144413,
-0.5115458369,
0.088961266,
-0.7953125238,
-0.1915437728,
-0.6932435036,
0.4424147904,
0.5180769563,
0.3517546356,
0.2082566619,
-0.3671633601,
0.116951324,
-0.3049222827,
0.1835717559,
-0.2963243127,
-0.7757058144,
-0.8943706751,
0.1067344174,
0.1440920234,
0.6827000976,
-0.2935526669,
0.3767945468,
-0.1357244104,
-0.6335207224,
-0.3607742786,
-0.1098740473,
0.5268928409,
0.1893984377,
0.5018386245,
-0.5285280347,
-0.6990558505,
-0.6721250415,
0.120421119,
-0.451187551,
-0.1650058031,
0.2553468645,
-0.2901940346,
-0.1461599469,
1.0693559647,
-0.5039309859,
-0.1054512188,
-0.0188524872,
0.4836003184,
0.0886007473,
0.3033837676,
0.3583112657,
-0.6961530447,
-0.4619553685,
0.0889372155,
-0.223002553,
-0.2976769507,
-0.2068792582,
0.5171567798,
-0.1796189547,
0.7974932194,
-0.1986777037,
0.1843269467,
0.3650298417,
0.0904629529,
0.1401619166,
-0.3347817361,
0.1350336671,
-0.6190870404,
-0.287104398,
-0.0088519957,
-0.4297556579,
-0.9713448286,
-0.5336216092,
-0.5957469344,
0.0411384255,
-0.6609502435,
0.2035368979,
-0.5896880627,
-0.5150144696,
-0.155908227,
0.6948922873,
-0.2589661777,
0.1465949565,
0.0259599071,
0.5709651113,
0.2533213794,
-0.8769121766,
0.8783757687,
0.604578495,
-0.6447761655,
0.7824323773,
-0.2024561912,
0.6583304405,
-0.176721558,
0.0079547586,
-1.0539348125,
-0.2394485474,
0.2685110867,
-0.3888500929,
0.4355458319,
-0.2690238953,
-0.0620866641,
-0.259742707,
0.30035007,
0.6407924294,
-0.0179882497,
-0.2729048431,
0.0731719136,
0.7007234693,
-0.4343450367,
-0.1437427402,
-0.4452104867,
0.022086639,
-0.2903138995,
-0.2928995788,
0.4578828812,
-0.3869298995,
-0.7734407783,
-0.560202837,
0.275968492,
-0.4494942725,
-0.0920094252,
0.2263337672,
-0.1251019239,
-0.1280618161,
0.2775976658,
-0.528619945,
-0.3093487918,
-0.2072837055,
0.2643246949,
0.4217801094,
0.1540001929,
-0.4027334154,
-0.7073585987,
0.6010327339,
-0.1029390991,
0.0839884877,
0.464217931,
0.5615267754,
-0.3051558733,
0.0891378224,
-0.8058328629,
-0.0935924649,
-0.4987015426,
0.1005582362,
-0.1812281609,
-0.5823509693,
0.3371297419,
-0.1759887636,
-0.1585690081,
0.1585670263,
0.4082313776,
-0.3735987246,
0.624186635,
0.7697483301,
0.3231630325,
0.6982465386,
0.117103681,
0.2913932502,
-0.3898274302,
-0.4595005512,
-0.7925773263,
-0.0192709155,
-0.6366965771,
-0.1528372914,
0.2823605239,
0.1063125581,
0.1042103395,
0.5049698949,
-0.708270669,
0.6730954647,
0.5793511868,
0.0549384989,
0.4007505774,
0.0035972542,
0.0813398138,
-0.0696337819,
-0.2904375792,
-0.1082265377,
0.5171056986,
0.5470619202,
0.5645375848,
-0.1554064006,
0.5672020912,
0.5748387575,
-0.2120456845,
-0.8945378661,
0.6030867696,
0.4554769099,
-0.6593469381,
-0.5489746332,
-0.2907935977,
-0.9937576056,
-0.1734554172,
-0.0251686592,
-1.1080350876,
0.4865516126,
0.1512503177,
-0.6287423968,
0.2010843456,
-0.7923268676,
0.3324873745,
-0.2620298266,
0.5513532162,
-0.2124713063,
-1.057222724,
-0.1568348259,
-0.2891820371,
0.6773454547,
-0.1778509021,
0.1256350279,
1.3665057421,
-0.433829993,
0.7902998328,
-0.3172432482,
0.0101323137,
0.4825206697,
-0.2487166822,
0.1724313647,
-0.4888248742,
0.1304199398,
0.1918520182,
0.3750287592,
0.054217387,
-0.0899286568,
0.2505514622,
-1.0448120832,
-0.4358229935,
-0.1581925899,
0.2629490197,
-0.5048080683,
0.1059941947,
0.5129750371,
0.6304734349,
-0.2984271348,
0.0860736594,
0.8070514202,
-0.2473991066,
0.7783306241,
0.3074586689,
-0.1695725024,
-0.6182875037,
0.8782422543,
0.2148173749,
0.272069484,
0.6388608813,
0.0759520233,
0.0190469716,
-0.623002708,
0.0833045691,
0.2410172075,
-1.0566543341,
0.2274199724,
-0.6062155366,
-0.4439284801,
-0.3343848288,
0.0354177617,
-0.6207172275,
-0.6752632856,
-0.350165844,
-0.1942219734,
0.2621611357,
0.9552811384,
-0.1977860034,
0.9296654463,
-0.8974007368,
0.3947516382,
0.4912715554,
0.5527687669,
-0.2230336219,
-0.2992425561,
-0.6976686716,
-0.1097738966,
-0.5372156501,
-1.1768957376,
0.1561118364,
0.7013489604,
0.7645400167,
0.7908193469,
-0.1082727537,
0.6181160808,
-0.5516425967,
0.7633085847,
0.3194328547,
-0.8050644994,
0.8366473913,
-0.4725587964,
-0.1382610649,
0.2411379814,
0.5547754765,
-1.127524972,
-0.1630245447,
-0.3419391215,
-0.8601369858,
0.7655215263,
0.3035171926,
-0.0695766062,
-0.1818519384,
0.0510690361,
0.2442477793,
0.1098503917,
-0.3854113817,
-0.5443103313,
-0.2556688786,
0.6324357986,
-0.260738343,
-0.2025327981,
-0.0950633511,
-0.3985942006,
0.4508139789,
0.2542554438,
0.7340694666,
0.2202493846,
0.1041370556,
-0.4770025313,
0.3839467466,
0.4903326631,
0.7093865275,
-0.6317793131,
-0.0822316185,
0.1237165704,
-0.4283733964,
0.2657411993,
-0.3445691168,
-0.0160245728,
0.4193260968,
0.3281144202,
0.8034319282,
0.3590455949,
-0.4201162159,
0.5786698461,
-0.118804805,
-0.1692615151,
-0.7744804025,
-0.1387848556,
-0.0799127519,
-0.0332288854,
0.4524089098,
-0.0009951591,
-0.0744185671,
-0.4439902902,
0.2817685902,
-0.0273218155,
-0.4346799552,
-0.2853935659,
0.5181347728,
0.411903739,
-0.813741684,
0.7575774193,
0.1396158636,
-0.2519797981,
0.1511144638,
0.3311573565,
0.7009178996,
-0.8046324849,
0.2614707053,
0.2166684568,
-0.275139153,
0.0854645744,
0.147590667,
-0.3802417517,
-0.8294212818,
-0.300775975,
-0.6664848328,
-0.7007131577,
0.0947463736,
-0.5235875845,
0.257286638,
-0.5554237962,
-0.9447356462,
0.2339144349,
-0.2489767671,
-0.4005748928,
0.2945401669,
0.5823724866,
0.5015000105,
-0.954729259,
0.2341658324,
0.4009790719,
-0.0128805693,
-0.3029694855,
-0.2063404471,
0.1672998965,
-0.1837919801,
0.4627960622,
-0.1296580732,
0.0151361534,
0.0018587541,
-0.3892098367,
-0.9506270289,
0.5453409553,
0.0385903828,
-0.4949180484,
-0.1194034293,
0.3119918406,
0.3193869889,
-0.0594702847,
0.6329123378,
0.4624207318,
0.5580052733,
0.3701485693,
-1.3544846773,
-0.6240723729,
-0.1666876823,
-0.2252487689,
0.1897723377,
-0.5111290812,
0.8266639113,
-0.061106734,
-0.3845332265,
0.0182824302,
0.5270562172,
-0.2612879574,
0.3683394194,
0.5853914618,
0.2288527936,
0.8548601866,
-0.1975730956,
0.6141126156,
0.0558105856,
0.2112206668,
1.0615553856,
0.0665731281,
0.9075992107,
0.4759705663,
-0.791816175,
0.1522750705,
1.1098389626,
0.0195004493,
0.6374216676,
0.0956377909,
-0.3363079429,
-0.513335824,
-0.3429506421,
-0.6307731867,
0.5496259332,
0.2944940925,
0.1116679981,
-0.2773934603,
0.1760311127,
-0.3878397942,
-0.0972422361,
-0.3162487745,
0.9859540462,
0.125608772,
-0.3426371217,
0.5021604896,
0.0072050551,
0.310826242,
-0.3403674364,
0.024970185,
-0.220052734,
0.2545329034,
-0.419250071,
-0.4861704707,
0.30729267,
-0.1696476936,
-0.1526339054,
-0.4240359962,
0.3306472898,
-0.2004763186,
-0.1414048225,
0.4862972498,
0.5508201122,
0.7072579265,
0.3931999207,
0.0206843652,
-0.2096639425,
-0.3263069689,
-0.0717496499,
0.1273544878,
0.3136909306,
-0.0676994324,
0.8543335795,
0.3222129047,
0.5581600666,
0.5292425156,
0.3952767849,
0.453864634,
-0.4997030497,
-0.7585625052,
-0.4683210254,
0.1963155568,
0.2539386153,
-0.1172993705,
0.6877000928,
0.6218336225,
1.1479445696,
0.1125074476,
0.467787534,
0.1323533803,
1.1349964142,
-0.2317997366,
0.6682717204,
-0.3514209986,
0.2241251171,
-0.5078991652,
-0.9525042176,
-0.1394633204,
0.5839073062,
-0.1356327683,
-0.0409377404,
0.7039877176,
0.5048872828,
-0.0533021912,
0.1069737151,
0.4957933724,
0.0082941232,
0.1903042793,
0.1509509981,
0.9399764538,
-0.358679086,
0.4996855259,
-0.2537549138,
-0.1099094227,
-0.4045213461,
-0.5792688131,
-0.7020325065,
-0.7983893156,
-0.6250970364,
0.0665680617,
0.1589325368,
1.0843429565,
0.6793444157,
-1.0606384277,
-0.4702420235,
0.2878562212,
-0.1447774768,
-0.2073770314,
-0.0594831258,
0.1915083826,
-0.0160731487,
-0.5715082288,
0.8464949727,
0.0708607957,
0.4207723439,
0.1091237888,
-0.2137719691,
-0.2612627447,
0.0822631717,
-0.0043919836,
0.6418851614,
-0.527107954,
-0.385251075,
-0.6213248372,
-0.0869420692,
0.7521317601,
0.7586877942,
-0.6498106718,
0.8934777975,
0.6339917779,
0.1890848577,
0.7342243791,
0.2615436316,
0.3843295574,
-1.0459762812,
0.152933076,
0.234275803,
0.242732361,
0.6157547832,
-0.0624344125,
0.0835628808,
0.6739464402,
-0.65874964,
-0.6140986681,
-0.0490496308,
-0.8901857734,
0.1366194487,
0.770265758,
-0.1251363158,
0.2820705175,
-0.6782246828,
-0.1300623417,
0.6246221662,
-0.0818967596,
0.6305262446,
0.7758159637,
-0.3202072382,
-0.2133162618,
-0.5563762784,
0.6531998515,
-0.2176936865,
-0.5250924826,
-0.1697307378,
0.3402741551,
0.0245976392,
0.636777997,
1.1625289917,
0.3516325653,
-0.1094292402,
0.0833435729,
-0.0330172442,
0.2429084629,
-0.5774303675,
0.1069997475,
0.1208217144,
-0.0797558129,
-0.4971143603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14462v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14462v1 | Explicit and Implicit Large Language Model Personas Generate Opinions but Fail to Replicate Deeper Perceptions and Biases | 2024-06-20T16:24:07 | 2024-06-20T16:24:07 | Salvatore Giorgi, Tingting Liu, Ankit Aich, Kelsey Isman, Garrick Sherman, Zachary Fried, João Sedoc, Lyle H. Ungar, Brenda Curtis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being used in human-centered
social scientific tasks, such as data annotation, synthetic data creation, and
engaging in dialog. However, these tasks are highly subjective and dependent on
human factors, such as one's environment, attitudes, beliefs, and lived
experiences. Thus, employing LLMs (which do not have such human factors) in
these tasks may result in a lack of variation in data, failing to reflect the
diversity of human experiences. In this paper, we examine the role of prompting
LLMs with human-like personas and asking the models to answer as if they were a
specific human. This is done explicitly, with exact demographics, political
beliefs, and lived experiences, or implicitly via names prevalent in specific
populations. The LLM personas are then evaluated via (1) subjective annotation
task (e.g., detecting toxicity) and (2) a belief generation task, where both
tasks are known to vary across human factors. We examine the impact of explicit
vs. implicit personas and investigate which human factors LLMs recognize and
respond to. Results show that LLM personas show mixed results when reproducing
known human biases, but generate generally fail to demonstrate implicit biases.
We conclude that LLMs lack the intrinsic cognitive mechanisms of human thought,
while capturing the statistical patterns of how people speak, which may
restrict their effectiveness in complex social science applications. | [
-0.437574923,
-0.6710243225,
1.0550090075,
0.3425959647,
0.0487883911,
0.1776996255,
-0.3305619955,
-0.4319364727,
0.0023334117,
0.3863456249,
-0.5368804932,
-0.4173868895,
-0.3974941373,
0.2001765966,
-0.0439473428,
0.9645997882,
0.2219803929,
0.2217199206,
-0.295052141,
0.0792675018,
-0.2344561815,
-0.7431302071,
-0.6449421644,
-0.777628541,
0.9147723913,
0.3606485724,
0.7049946189,
0.1020752639,
-0.0518076047,
0.2591152489,
-0.1083660871,
0.1740455329,
-0.4912860692,
0.2645266652,
-0.2897797227,
-0.6577525735,
-0.1985510886,
0.303907901,
0.6450890899,
1.0184217691,
0.2294699252,
0.139439851,
0.1215140074,
0.4845981598,
-0.516618073,
0.3181961477,
-0.5157946348,
0.1430470347,
0.004614193,
-0.0714054778,
-0.4998927116,
-0.4428553581,
0.4445997477,
-0.2824590206,
0.1058171764,
0.0756123066,
0.3109774888,
0.0405815542,
-0.6539768577,
-0.3598388731,
-0.9524390101,
0.7858929634,
-0.8112148046,
0.0292421412,
0.3639515638,
-0.068440944,
-0.3913767636,
-0.1760242283,
-0.7411594391,
-0.4410626292,
-0.244393006,
-0.0181794818,
0.074976407,
0.1023177356,
0.5434567332,
-0.1654961109,
-0.2124524415,
0.2050354034,
-0.2590499818,
-0.1637182236,
0.6490683556,
0.3175217509,
0.0973349735,
-0.4106783569,
-0.1755729616,
-0.0271453708,
-0.8962647319,
0.1510480195,
0.6244945526,
0.3504860997,
-0.0761897489,
0.6073438525,
-0.0667994171,
0.3568020463,
0.2214722782,
-0.1221035644,
0.2980126441,
0.1811515391,
-0.163402319,
0.0185862537,
0.8659103513,
0.2967372537,
0.5893040299,
0.1421364397,
-0.0961803123,
0.2956922352,
0.1986380965,
-0.6183254719,
0.0414288938,
0.3045633733,
-0.2474994957,
-0.3987257481,
-0.0383602902,
-0.883949399,
-0.8363031149,
-0.4786842465,
0.0930391774,
0.0013435745,
-0.2486367226,
0.0317411125,
0.0559394211,
0.2983877659,
0.5794947743,
-0.7580051422,
0.3138199449,
0.6446608305,
0.5272190571,
-0.2416882813,
-0.2241284847,
-0.3506751657,
0.1322277337,
-0.395236671,
0.7275089025,
-0.7174062729,
-0.6536651254,
0.0541873984,
0.0199182536,
0.0989264324,
-0.5566846132,
0.5218557119,
-0.1614008993,
0.3198534846,
-0.9343498945,
-0.4354793727,
-0.0703811422,
0.0805632472,
-0.2530350387,
0.771751523,
-0.228687942,
-0.8441507816,
0.364251852,
-0.6582738757,
-0.3145067692,
0.1534018815,
-0.5539386272,
-0.0487295613,
0.2910316885,
0.0712726489,
0.7057697177,
-0.3670665026,
0.3943921328,
-0.657816112,
-0.3497753441,
0.6867364645,
-0.3460584283,
0.7336648107,
-0.0322462022,
-0.5616475344,
0.2193555385,
-0.3413191736,
-0.2942780852,
0.2758032084,
-0.3097878993,
-0.4282819033,
0.3697391152,
0.0500243492,
0.353510946,
0.0202101395,
-0.6198821664,
0.2157981545,
-0.2055006623,
0.4481408596,
1.1835086346,
0.0632911846,
0.4829755723,
-0.4137761891,
0.3055970967,
0.0991484746,
-0.0312734954,
0.0382288247,
-0.5813037157,
-0.8087964058,
0.0129678994,
-0.1026942655,
0.4481508434,
-0.4422977567,
0.1995164603,
-0.352404356,
-0.3973297179,
-0.403267622,
0.2014674991,
0.3616994321,
0.4997836947,
-0.1093074754,
-0.0986003205,
-0.5028755069,
-1.212203145,
-0.3475263417,
-0.4815042019,
-0.1728939414,
0.6659761667,
0.7516863346,
-0.3299391866,
0.9524295926,
-0.4377160668,
0.0185202211,
-0.2419812828,
0.3097495437,
-0.0712402016,
0.2291656733,
0.4240747094,
-0.7951241136,
-0.2775225341,
-0.2555112541,
-0.8292401433,
-0.3255408108,
-0.0759879947,
0.1039777398,
0.3098519146,
0.1911295652,
-0.7300189137,
0.1196198091,
0.4365134239,
-0.2801302671,
0.6356122494,
-0.1319184601,
0.0361605361,
-0.789095521,
0.1427428573,
0.383479774,
-0.1034296602,
-0.6591587067,
-0.2172797173,
-0.2058264315,
0.1291510761,
-0.5610583425,
0.8099627495,
-0.4774149656,
-0.2822511494,
-0.2231777459,
0.1878215224,
-0.0770082399,
0.4826242626,
0.284989655,
0.596481204,
0.3334699869,
-0.5757913589,
0.1282867938,
0.1313629597,
-0.3263770044,
0.7220169306,
-0.7570191622,
0.4471107423,
-0.6644172668,
0.5260509849,
-0.9236527681,
-0.5524049401,
0.2946077883,
-0.2830175459,
0.0359497182,
-0.0508096144,
-0.7141430378,
-0.3091186583,
-0.2848127484,
0.0760879517,
0.5944791436,
-0.2683850527,
0.6726222634,
0.5459743142,
-0.3550178409,
-0.3360746205,
-0.8239403963,
0.1350968182,
-0.296539098,
-0.3898935616,
-0.094273828,
-0.2170990855,
-0.7331360579,
-0.2285266519,
0.0732611418,
0.2688731551,
-0.1653167158,
0.5486460924,
0.3261843324,
-0.028736053,
0.0833833069,
-0.0039763548,
0.1962542683,
0.5283681154,
-0.006709219,
0.4428326488,
-0.2347601652,
-0.4972223043,
-0.2464399338,
0.4418908358,
0.7727096677,
0.1413012296,
0.7385998368,
0.2803411782,
-0.2989942729,
-0.1128754839,
-0.7881259322,
-0.2305826098,
-0.4581710398,
0.2651124299,
-0.1690256894,
-1.0089576244,
0.6083822846,
-0.1343547255,
0.141911298,
0.1465588063,
0.8234940767,
-0.2734956145,
1.246624589,
0.1255964041,
-0.0638281256,
0.227095902,
0.0767967775,
0.062947996,
-1.0101696253,
-0.344553262,
-0.508280158,
-0.3302644491,
-0.5630162954,
-0.316703856,
0.4202966392,
-0.5391751528,
-0.4690749049,
-0.3671939969,
-0.2523948848,
0.3315768838,
0.4033117592,
0.1760860384,
0.1387745142,
0.0004814339,
0.0656185821,
-0.2146533132,
-0.4434824586,
-0.7848654389,
0.9838318825,
0.3530535996,
0.880679369,
-0.0746461749,
0.3940084577,
0.3926472664,
0.5879299641,
-0.6433011889,
0.7438932657,
0.214022547,
-0.6910817623,
-0.1604186445,
-0.4138765335,
-0.8498719931,
0.4239397943,
-0.3528059125,
-0.8092811704,
0.403380096,
0.160837695,
-0.2067351639,
0.1429163218,
-0.6278775334,
0.4774428904,
-0.184391588,
-0.5662766695,
0.0410741828,
-0.6099774837,
0.5327361226,
-0.1795984358,
0.3886149228,
-0.2108183503,
-0.0555395521,
0.6348920465,
-0.0004522664,
1.3819506168,
-0.3532388806,
-0.3228436112,
0.1332712322,
0.1445030719,
0.6697286367,
0.1108006984,
-0.1986261159,
-0.0210152287,
-0.3747079372,
-0.335090965,
-0.5846253633,
0.8609805703,
-0.8972817063,
-0.9732246995,
-0.3444468975,
-0.5450000167,
-0.4191787541,
-0.0123582818,
0.1137694716,
0.0857278556,
-0.2605793774,
0.1201045066,
0.7586734295,
-0.4165343344,
-0.0080921063,
0.42857638,
-0.3012173772,
0.004046218,
0.4137957096,
0.0136859706,
0.4664589465,
-0.0109219765,
0.3148067594,
-0.2424622625,
-0.1845660657,
-0.1077597812,
0.3975387514,
-0.8238517642,
0.2652822137,
-0.7589645386,
-0.0255927984,
-0.3118876219,
-0.1083208099,
-0.1251275092,
0.0731419474,
-0.2019124627,
-0.2681010962,
0.1331080198,
1.0169343948,
0.1716248542,
0.1749743372,
-0.4642584622,
0.2219901532,
0.5717731714,
0.0061593768,
0.242634058,
-0.3384324312,
0.2257293463,
0.3805753291,
0.0726061687,
-1.0343042612,
0.1513604522,
-0.0987430662,
0.5648399591,
0.3313568234,
0.0210138801,
0.4459686279,
-0.5102552772,
0.7912121415,
-0.2021000683,
-0.8666296601,
0.4920322001,
-0.6194216013,
0.4184192121,
0.3921215832,
0.4887885451,
-0.5688280463,
-0.5427818298,
-0.2552084029,
-0.6789714098,
0.7115287185,
0.0757804587,
0.4645397067,
-0.1098560542,
0.4360600412,
0.1217571795,
0.2733048797,
-0.8965508342,
-0.4367747307,
0.0246481709,
0.0062105465,
-0.1134208515,
-0.473187834,
-0.1190832853,
-0.2221687883,
0.4676922858,
-0.2247285992,
0.115056783,
0.3008804917,
0.0842161328,
-0.3195613325,
0.4311611056,
0.6242439747,
0.4658274949,
-0.1023496166,
0.2253105938,
0.0904152617,
-0.2738788128,
0.3138997853,
-0.2891091406,
-0.4900179803,
-0.2034385651,
0.2427702248,
0.8777372241,
0.4409478605,
-0.7048919797,
0.3872796297,
-0.0019022374,
-0.1956252158,
-0.5100409389,
0.0836162716,
0.4154871106,
0.2542408109,
0.4498310387,
-0.0175161082,
-0.0169261973,
-0.8713225126,
-0.3359322548,
0.5679205656,
-0.1692172587,
-0.4578617215,
0.5622419119,
0.213259533,
-0.2449674606,
0.5299440622,
-0.0029661655,
-0.5735515356,
0.3739002645,
0.3847388923,
0.8865216374,
-0.1923343837,
0.3335410357,
0.1580674201,
0.3344122171,
-0.1037775502,
0.1802753955,
0.2479221821,
-0.8406870365,
-0.5577691197,
-0.5524656177,
-0.4917770624,
0.3484337926,
-0.4359580278,
0.0428820737,
-0.5663164258,
-0.3069950044,
0.1194622517,
-0.1176930219,
-0.7718979716,
-0.0013130789,
0.4440282285,
0.6429044604,
-1.0856841803,
0.4921059608,
0.7427347302,
-0.2472366095,
-0.6820790768,
0.1489303559,
0.2238498926,
-0.5439226627,
0.897531867,
0.0145189501,
-0.0739887804,
-0.2534752488,
-0.8224801421,
-0.6966370344,
0.6540055275,
0.5392520428,
-0.4367610812,
-0.1254179776,
0.3677559793,
0.7081712484,
-0.597235918,
0.0852848291,
0.3809795082,
0.8491916656,
0.1619603485,
-0.7142244577,
0.2867450714,
-0.18882972,
0.0780659467,
-0.2725366652,
-0.6435667276,
0.9081671834,
-0.3642689288,
-0.0693330467,
-0.2639552951,
0.5146682858,
0.5063816905,
0.1385280341,
0.6433037519,
-0.0239819288,
0.6790322661,
0.1077442318,
1.1778348684,
0.0940397084,
0.0411876291,
1.1221387386,
-0.8403474092,
0.6825175881,
0.4463748932,
-0.1780038327,
0.6353388429,
0.5906839967,
-0.0768235698,
0.1317162067,
0.2332778275,
-0.3378194869,
-0.3936105669,
-0.1757787764,
-0.0158575289,
0.3525373638,
0.5270018578,
-0.3758053184,
0.037127208,
-0.1106509417,
0.1288991123,
-0.020706173,
-0.2877836823,
0.633086741,
0.2449404448,
-0.8874585629,
0.2418713421,
-0.162256524,
0.6508194208,
-0.5647253394,
-0.0024762503,
-0.1710018367,
-0.0653119385,
-0.3956245482,
-0.8491678238,
-0.0249148663,
0.0619192906,
-0.2682832479,
-0.2555955648,
0.7036886811,
-0.1804226637,
-0.5050284266,
0.225437656,
0.6579041481,
0.1804508269,
-0.0985216051,
-0.5483599305,
0.087211661,
0.0967145041,
-0.629519999,
0.4691371024,
0.2785081863,
-0.2158728391,
0.7790026665,
0.7840089202,
0.2303353995,
-0.1039990261,
0.1926867068,
0.7228862047,
-0.5179376006,
-0.1368103474,
-0.975830853,
0.4042050242,
-0.1340013444,
0.0049338001,
0.8227831721,
0.3071844876,
0.6153810024,
-0.1682720929,
1.0973104239,
0.1521557868,
0.4175736606,
-0.2154568285,
0.6362281442,
-0.2831017077,
0.3557852805,
-0.5565745234,
-1.079584837,
0.0340408348,
0.5192010403,
-0.6043506861,
0.4600895047,
0.4070426226,
0.6001972556,
0.2440767288,
0.0547694862,
0.2350443006,
0.5744969249,
0.452396363,
0.5142110586,
0.9520283937,
0.2846547067,
0.0575890988,
0.0642210394,
-0.242349267,
-0.1135238856,
-0.7933282256,
-1.1651493311,
-0.4541447163,
-0.1765884608,
-0.2749024928,
-0.1608377099,
1.150442481,
0.6174519062,
-0.5754948854,
-0.1485005319,
0.0958024859,
0.1213054806,
0.4142372608,
-0.3204278052,
0.1620414704,
-0.0170786306,
-1.0032340288,
0.1307338327,
0.2247879654,
0.083338283,
-0.9057068825,
-0.0539423041,
0.0110220071,
0.3602406681,
0.6445313692,
0.241550684,
-1.0124332905,
-0.5015972853,
-0.0422254354,
-0.1781459451,
-0.1267964989,
0.7998211384,
-0.9159839153,
0.100168854,
0.3255754709,
0.2677383423,
0.2112043798,
-0.1537010223,
0.7516646385,
-0.6448708177,
0.0518694595,
0.3946050704,
0.4693455696,
0.6346818209,
-0.4006282687,
0.30635342,
0.1650079191,
-0.5241264701,
-0.8113708496,
0.3736941516,
-0.7650767565,
-0.3136576414,
1.5626516342,
-0.0338533185,
-0.2849434018,
-0.236612767,
-0.4230332077,
-0.2806537449,
-0.5827758312,
0.8262653947,
0.7845451236,
-0.2000645995,
0.0097082965,
-0.6875435114,
0.4458065033,
0.2852473557,
-0.8350375295,
0.2704431713,
0.7307462096,
0.4076006711,
0.1869601309,
0.7333799601,
0.0500764288,
-0.0565298274,
-0.1817376018,
-0.0259419754,
0.1656639725,
0.0165968742,
-0.2115403861,
0.0962846875,
0.1731017232,
0.5719918609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14459v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14459v1 | Healing Powers of BERT: How Task-Specific Fine-Tuning Recovers Corrupted Language Models | 2024-06-20T16:18:04 | 2024-06-20T16:18:04 | Shijie Han, Zhenyu Zhang, Andrei Arsene Simion | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models like BERT excel at sentence classification tasks due to
extensive pre-training on general data, but their robustness to parameter
corruption is unexplored. To understand this better, we look at what happens if
a language model is "broken", in the sense that some of its parameters are
corrupted and then recovered by fine-tuning. Strategically corrupting BERT
variants at different levels, we find corrupted models struggle to fully
recover their original performance, with higher corruption causing more severe
degradation. Notably, bottom-layer corruption affecting fundamental linguistic
features is more detrimental than top-layer corruption. Our insights contribute
to understanding language model robustness and adaptability under adverse
conditions, informing strategies for developing resilient NLP systems against
parameter perturbations. | [
-0.1654001772,
-0.9104392529,
0.3512486517,
0.0083333729,
-0.1510783136,
-0.2011243552,
-0.3354183137,
-0.6294503808,
-0.0631892607,
1.0046838522,
-0.5034591556,
0.1078175604,
-0.8531867266,
-0.0676627159,
-0.499162972,
1.6736981869,
0.5845530629,
0.2085553408,
-0.0507412516,
-0.0529971197,
-0.4868908525,
-0.5196467042,
-0.8314008117,
-0.2535231113,
0.4011979401,
0.4086027741,
0.934884131,
0.4750249088,
0.640794754,
0.3040690124,
0.0118153207,
0.0247809291,
-0.7904288173,
0.5298391581,
-0.1639802158,
-0.5847104788,
-0.3269910812,
-0.0102234976,
0.5123224854,
0.8166402578,
-0.187741518,
-0.2024070323,
0.300715059,
0.6748118997,
-0.359082669,
0.0296602361,
-1.3406666517,
-0.3013950288,
-0.125204131,
-0.1898558885,
-0.3876231611,
-0.1442077905,
0.2664200366,
-0.3709620833,
0.4165267348,
-0.1170210913,
1.0877373219,
0.6065214276,
-0.0443717688,
-0.1597692221,
-0.8874678612,
0.9569416642,
-0.8389422297,
0.1141960472,
0.6723803282,
0.0928823799,
-0.4327044189,
-0.8046588898,
-0.1882013977,
-0.2375078052,
0.1405047923,
-0.1690823585,
-0.2737739384,
0.3388821185,
0.3231474161,
0.3808484375,
-0.3337011635,
0.1179978177,
-0.3460010886,
-0.1560860574,
0.3887968063,
0.0296349097,
0.5793443322,
-0.2272833437,
-0.1056875661,
-0.1421168596,
-0.7023521066,
0.0106450589,
0.5562405586,
0.8024907708,
0.5206020474,
0.064462699,
0.2785116434,
0.8497533202,
-0.1207981333,
-0.0862001851,
-0.1942175478,
-0.3124521971,
-0.4504550397,
0.05233128,
0.3922206163,
0.0613148846,
0.4575325847,
-0.4058360457,
-0.2314008623,
-0.3924795687,
0.7593455315,
-0.5954185724,
-0.4831452668,
0.0665695965,
-0.5570305586,
-0.3386284709,
-0.0532181524,
-0.3029793799,
-0.5824113488,
-0.0677410215,
0.5600174665,
-0.6118184328,
-0.2751186192,
0.2746343613,
-0.1826426536,
-0.1920055598,
0.1745287776,
-1.3318676949,
0.2610951364,
0.7177003026,
0.4079621136,
0.3057014346,
-0.4336471558,
-0.5036295652,
-0.1936752051,
-0.0184309147,
0.7083291411,
-0.5708330274,
-0.052263435,
0.1671803892,
0.2649650574,
-0.0373122543,
-0.714248538,
0.8687263131,
-0.3693704009,
-0.086317353,
-0.7235151529,
-0.5225401521,
-0.0090482542,
0.1271845847,
-0.6231188178,
0.8103070259,
0.034931533,
-0.8487413526,
0.5126779079,
-0.3258840144,
-0.3931824565,
-0.0895632878,
0.2562142909,
-0.5769429207,
0.4649730921,
0.0502594374,
0.6337143779,
-0.0844689235,
0.1313557476,
-0.5194787383,
-0.1709439456,
-0.0493177697,
-0.5535064936,
1.025113225,
0.0150109529,
0.0772285014,
0.1337388903,
-0.9093130827,
0.044384975,
0.0796059743,
-0.320266068,
-0.7147923112,
0.4398274124,
0.086074613,
0.1517949998,
0.2026322335,
-0.6059961915,
0.4512111843,
-0.4707246125,
0.7793000937,
0.7326319218,
-0.0431533717,
0.2122455388,
-0.4879247248,
0.1702210605,
-0.1086758003,
0.1635949761,
-0.0543950573,
-0.4854506552,
-0.7064653039,
-0.1403672993,
0.4036048949,
0.5127860308,
-0.4977677166,
0.40406394,
-0.1065306067,
-0.7111513019,
-0.8512656689,
0.1850506663,
0.3582100868,
0.7684854865,
0.4186964035,
-0.3283379674,
-0.5073398352,
-1.158827424,
-0.426507026,
-0.3267090321,
-0.087053597,
0.2233540267,
0.4428451657,
-0.2552167177,
0.5588040352,
-0.0293270703,
-0.417021662,
-0.2441699356,
0.2430554181,
0.0197959058,
0.6151344776,
0.6799991131,
-0.4156238437,
-0.0255833659,
-0.2495675087,
-0.3453917503,
-0.2270026058,
-0.3582057357,
0.0188139826,
0.2641790807,
0.4553157687,
-0.2113102674,
0.2611252666,
0.664752841,
-0.5127534866,
0.8485199213,
-0.6079862118,
-0.0344003923,
-0.7741591334,
0.0372208953,
-0.4791011214,
-0.2906009257,
-0.7680287361,
0.0165672265,
-0.1595066041,
0.0965628251,
0.0289859101,
-0.0410507731,
-0.1887815595,
-0.0700434744,
-0.4452562332,
-0.0484431088,
-0.2122353464,
0.2389418036,
-0.2077028006,
0.5164997578,
0.6666949391,
-0.4927416742,
0.1064841077,
0.2888481915,
-0.4247446954,
0.2988768518,
-0.8113303781,
0.1042320952,
0.1263211817,
-0.1247670799,
-0.8959834576,
-0.3279986978,
-0.3719955981,
-0.3236850202,
0.5410473347,
-0.1001560912,
-0.766237855,
0.1331575662,
-0.1606095582,
0.054831259,
0.4834796786,
-0.4641603231,
0.3148723245,
0.4305665791,
-0.266321063,
-0.6374428868,
-0.7154702544,
0.0490714647,
0.0859635323,
-0.7462714911,
0.3036971092,
-0.017324388,
-0.3021375537,
0.0365405716,
-0.1077173203,
-0.2411614358,
0.5552812219,
0.2446140945,
-0.2066647708,
-0.1218288615,
0.3313752413,
0.293410033,
0.0924461335,
0.0559324473,
-0.0785254389,
0.5943997502,
-0.2786364257,
-0.241183877,
-0.1414572299,
0.2609065771,
0.8077600002,
-0.1678569764,
1.0149338245,
0.4394322932,
-0.5026807189,
-0.2538779676,
-0.5438545942,
-0.4227590561,
-0.4512345195,
0.527857244,
-0.0214930922,
-0.6961687207,
0.691480279,
0.3155313432,
0.3066424727,
0.3284876347,
0.5106752515,
-0.1712308973,
0.9128609896,
1.0751086473,
-0.3269572854,
0.6774208546,
0.0599995069,
0.2320838422,
-0.4582190514,
0.0680743977,
-0.6258348227,
-0.3203430772,
-0.5700011253,
0.2070448995,
0.2822526991,
0.4435516298,
-0.1973679066,
0.33948645,
-0.50740242,
0.4088460505,
0.8728064895,
0.199853465,
0.2092865407,
-0.0593542643,
0.056772463,
-0.1507838368,
-0.6903364062,
-0.6131262779,
0.8393253088,
0.3502476513,
0.5819627643,
-0.1900539696,
0.7395535111,
0.0439836234,
0.1072680652,
-0.5595881939,
0.2881104648,
-0.386280328,
-0.9125777483,
-0.5724278092,
-0.0472862646,
-1.1319752932,
0.0329583734,
-0.3777348101,
-0.8257210851,
0.1238436103,
0.3197832406,
-0.3639131784,
0.581148684,
-0.7396526933,
0.8076577783,
-0.1834380478,
-0.1436337382,
-0.2565644979,
-0.8423000574,
0.2329060286,
-0.1626845896,
-0.0496302769,
-0.0594670922,
0.3112234771,
0.7250536084,
-0.4959094226,
0.7794317007,
-0.2086151093,
-0.2604793012,
-0.2071994841,
0.2439476848,
0.240664199,
-0.0329898596,
-0.1203134656,
0.1245649904,
0.2209781706,
-0.7046915889,
-0.6906551719,
0.6481704712,
-0.7272154689,
-0.7140676379,
-0.1969730109,
-0.9811312556,
-0.5962591171,
0.2904080451,
0.2413045615,
0.2787270546,
0.0127740288,
0.4632493854,
0.6889786124,
-0.2246691585,
0.6778912544,
0.645773232,
0.1684791744,
-0.1581160873,
0.9080132246,
0.1881645471,
0.5190423131,
0.0135074742,
-0.1285571009,
0.3628073633,
-0.8402160406,
0.0189361051,
0.1137746498,
-0.3756672442,
-0.2608684897,
-0.2149647921,
-0.2007050514,
-0.2891217768,
-0.1460483819,
-0.4725667536,
-0.4727195203,
-0.4510356784,
-0.111030519,
0.239101544,
0.8647295833,
-0.2788571715,
0.0523946658,
-0.9617388844,
0.0446139351,
0.2991610169,
0.5242335796,
-0.1520740688,
-0.5732150674,
-0.2356210351,
0.1213351414,
-0.3431548476,
-0.694633007,
0.428599894,
0.507235527,
0.3589116633,
0.6472159028,
-0.0307904109,
0.6466571689,
-0.8071757555,
0.921153903,
-0.049068328,
-0.8684232831,
0.6243363619,
-0.5444406867,
0.1252553314,
0.5582823157,
0.0447711684,
-0.4293338954,
-0.8952097893,
-0.7998191118,
-0.948966682,
0.7343587875,
0.1688984334,
0.3786354661,
0.0119742732,
0.6468222141,
0.3394016027,
-0.0314711668,
-0.6561387181,
-0.1641259193,
-0.3674349487,
-0.0624001399,
-0.0500841215,
-0.5896731019,
-0.1072599068,
-0.3472245038,
0.6676440239,
0.1056197211,
0.397690177,
0.1639569402,
-0.1682054251,
-0.2184599489,
0.2296092808,
0.7198445201,
0.488940686,
-0.2492201924,
-0.0698300675,
-0.0170654729,
-0.5562081337,
-0.3232525885,
0.2475860119,
-0.0161679778,
-0.2314266413,
0.9065989852,
0.7720906138,
0.411436677,
-0.7353827357,
0.2018629611,
-0.0912414491,
-0.0434486941,
0.0107229957,
0.4085733891,
-0.103308551,
0.212233752,
0.5257029533,
0.3433327973,
0.0381771401,
-0.837046206,
0.3309529126,
0.7285476923,
-0.4370547533,
-0.4529061615,
0.6127934456,
0.0399578959,
-0.4523789883,
0.8493178487,
0.2466230094,
-0.5565266013,
0.4968560636,
0.6775890589,
0.7622032762,
-0.4135806859,
0.0854587555,
0.0475143977,
0.6153433323,
-0.1374727786,
0.3238826096,
0.0982737467,
-0.9583944678,
-0.2283570617,
-0.7037254572,
-0.146607995,
0.4393661618,
-1.0489991903,
-0.1632940471,
-0.4306435883,
-0.1059475318,
-0.0029389409,
-0.0030250535,
-0.2889147997,
0.2596908212,
-0.0465922542,
0.9175572991,
-0.8942697048,
1.0416868925,
0.5844323635,
-0.5267139077,
-0.6457619071,
0.2335609496,
-0.465205729,
-0.8852467537,
0.5677527189,
-0.1598486006,
0.1291658133,
-0.1320370287,
-0.7934011817,
-0.7056524754,
0.666379571,
0.966311276,
-0.4795385897,
-0.14710024,
0.0252219085,
0.8987491131,
0.143059209,
-0.0417391844,
0.8355439901,
0.3430306911,
-0.5662427545,
-1.4869172573,
-0.0190969184,
-0.1192426905,
-0.1326389611,
0.3529492617,
-0.2840205133,
0.6432061195,
-0.3020741343,
0.1881415695,
0.3348085284,
0.3247870803,
-0.193550691,
-0.2536789179,
0.5326689482,
0.7501626611,
0.9496784806,
-0.3752400875,
1.1171733141,
-0.4383513927,
0.3876487315,
0.7585913539,
0.1474276781,
1.0420469046,
0.4221545458,
0.0391656645,
0.5121486187,
0.3714575171,
-0.0891683996,
0.6830862761,
0.0363451131,
0.081309922,
-0.4760715663,
0.0661182031,
-0.1624356061,
0.5546846986,
0.4011042118,
-0.5864297152,
-0.2476958781,
0.3044973314,
0.0744184852,
-0.0445527174,
-0.4834684134,
0.7437899709,
-0.0980542377,
-0.6415108442,
0.7370226383,
-0.2741006911,
0.3473794758,
-0.5963223577,
-0.0255906489,
0.0207954925,
0.4029986262,
-0.2742819786,
-0.6325393915,
0.603813827,
-0.3161404431,
-0.5084596276,
-0.5090614557,
1.0361561775,
-0.3736786246,
-0.1941894144,
0.2978696823,
0.2288675606,
0.1021050736,
-0.0203561001,
-0.814817369,
0.1564903557,
-0.0148710757,
-0.1369974315,
0.5241869092,
0.2957617044,
0.3141484559,
0.8776458502,
0.2811582088,
0.3014546633,
0.082946226,
0.0380352624,
0.7380484939,
-0.3772732019,
-0.0193488225,
-0.7526636124,
0.5562906861,
0.0489049181,
-0.4398848712,
0.7252251506,
0.0812458917,
0.7788345218,
-0.1078398973,
0.6079841852,
0.0941268951,
0.5587320924,
-0.4711484909,
1.232932806,
-0.649076581,
0.214487046,
-0.3919395804,
-0.5059215426,
-0.5295108557,
0.5408268571,
-0.27622509,
0.0129756946,
0.6344752312,
0.573204577,
0.117570743,
0.0134922098,
0.4275002778,
0.7462265491,
0.3121726215,
0.3193879426,
0.362475127,
-0.2455394566,
0.6020325422,
-0.1887560487,
-0.1215554178,
-0.118375957,
-0.7908683419,
-0.7869878411,
-0.8748660684,
-0.1877690703,
-0.3774359822,
0.2065954506,
0.6097236872,
0.6992406249,
-1.0962902308,
0.07564684,
-0.4566676319,
0.1154376119,
-0.4103977084,
-0.2204174548,
0.2662685513,
-0.8568443656,
-0.6194140315,
0.3385129571,
0.2343221754,
-0.3012030423,
-0.2893093228,
0.362786144,
0.0467610471,
0.2271358669,
0.4510783553,
0.3823330998,
-0.8901276588,
-0.5691100359,
-0.2003799379,
0.0925927311,
-0.2318150252,
0.8608942628,
-0.6564444304,
0.5242254734,
0.3448448181,
0.7827914953,
-0.1577369124,
-0.2767542601,
0.8446438313,
-0.9652879834,
-0.0172168892,
0.516258955,
0.7132149339,
0.2246238291,
-0.2951228023,
0.1296619773,
0.1011637598,
-1.0465621948,
-1.3478829861,
0.3410706818,
-0.8751114607,
-0.4429783523,
1.0251579285,
-0.294505924,
0.2204202712,
-0.2008156031,
-0.3664425313,
0.0712923035,
-0.0505379513,
1.2549436092,
1.0739896297,
-0.238182649,
-0.0977582484,
-0.4203403294,
0.8787747622,
0.6581233144,
-0.491615802,
0.2433432341,
0.3015221953,
0.4768994153,
0.2185329199,
0.1401294768,
0.0369226411,
0.1571933925,
-0.1857236922,
-0.3010780513,
-0.0921512619,
-0.3654220402,
-0.4032475054,
0.2124150693,
0.3231026232,
0.0864962861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14434v1 | Towards Truthful Multilingual Large Language Models: Benchmarking and Alignment Strategies | 2024-06-20T15:59:07 | 2024-06-20T15:59:07 | Weihao Liu, Ning Wu, Wenbiao Ding, Shining Liang, Ming Gong, Dongmei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the era of large language models (LLMs), building multilingual large
language models (MLLMs) that can serve users worldwide holds great
significance. However, existing research seldom focuses on the truthfulness of
MLLMs. Meanwhile, contemporary multilingual aligning technologies struggle to
balance massive languages and often exhibit serious truthfulness gaps across
different languages, especially those that differ greatly from English. In our
work, we construct a benchmark for truthfulness evaluation in multilingual
scenarios and explore the ways to align facts across languages to enhance the
truthfulness of MLLMs. Furthermore, we propose Fact-aware Multilingual
Selective Synergy (FaMSS) to optimize the data allocation across a large number
of languages and different data types. Experimental results demonstrate that
our approach can effectively reduce the multilingual representation disparity
and enhance the multilingual capabilities of LLMs. | [
-0.2426051497,
-0.3608979285,
0.5331293941,
0.2637247443,
-0.0943004936,
0.3837548196,
-0.5474818349,
-0.5010556579,
-0.0394250751,
0.2087973058,
-0.4732411206,
-0.3508878052,
-0.3987360299,
0.1554526836,
-0.0134360706,
0.8488894701,
-0.0967782587,
0.4009893537,
-0.3878470957,
-0.8830116391,
-0.3599970341,
-0.6669051647,
-0.1843641996,
-0.3475296199,
0.5514971614,
0.3149332404,
0.9686267376,
0.6194987297,
0.5918271542,
0.2900087237,
0.0879703462,
0.4330663979,
-0.4051535726,
0.3485825956,
-0.4497683048,
-0.4382832348,
-0.3648509383,
-0.0276904125,
0.8107481003,
0.7356340885,
-0.2789250016,
0.2847800851,
-0.0117345629,
0.5856005549,
-0.7819671035,
0.1075538918,
-0.6092998981,
0.0536067635,
-0.3769787848,
0.182203114,
-0.2998789251,
-0.4036770463,
-0.0894156098,
-0.5849438906,
-0.0345639549,
0.2056284994,
0.6517444849,
0.1713463664,
-0.6242952943,
-0.0767233074,
-0.5610404611,
1.0903418064,
-0.8151756525,
1.1086916924,
0.0026721698,
0.5196247101,
0.134043023,
-0.3091126084,
-0.719373107,
-0.0742490366,
-0.0292310715,
0.0726465806,
0.0753692836,
-0.4328709841,
0.3255024552,
0.2520234883,
-0.7607419491,
0.2406940609,
0.1247729883,
-0.51232934,
0.7399994135,
0.126638785,
-0.0043373452,
0.3205122352,
-0.5033029914,
0.0983548909,
-0.7022730112,
-0.2892575562,
0.5756679773,
0.5591804385,
-0.3002924621,
0.5568230152,
-0.1578655094,
0.7173222899,
-0.2286132872,
-0.7763785124,
0.5561613441,
-0.7893799543,
0.1101906449,
0.0536417589,
0.6636177301,
0.5563365817,
0.1371746212,
-0.211386472,
-0.2621814907,
0.2111817151,
-0.1054805666,
-0.7556535006,
0.2905830741,
0.1065581217,
-0.415204525,
0.0066856951,
-0.2871862352,
-0.7401034236,
-0.6005698442,
-0.5002268553,
0.3096388876,
-0.2416287959,
-0.5805554986,
0.1711764932,
0.1550709456,
0.1744051725,
0.2266248018,
-0.6756868362,
0.1775122881,
0.6558722258,
0.628018856,
-0.1259768158,
-0.3856295347,
-0.3967726231,
0.3074174225,
-0.2583104372,
0.3860102892,
-0.4566303492,
-0.0734132826,
0.0474537611,
-0.2200503796,
-0.0346722156,
-0.5182977319,
0.7514036298,
-0.544179976,
0.2729785144,
-0.5710826516,
-0.576726675,
-0.2187502086,
0.5938948989,
-0.761013329,
0.8606956601,
-0.3449636102,
-0.6733498573,
0.2369994968,
-0.3377879262,
-0.5152602196,
-0.2743785977,
-0.1953209192,
-0.384732455,
0.0087156584,
0.0574901253,
0.333029449,
-0.2995376885,
0.6515012383,
-0.3665546477,
0.0040518106,
0.4263877571,
-0.786647737,
0.6625344753,
0.5173596144,
-0.171918273,
0.0060052304,
-0.6412795186,
-0.0363627337,
0.1285743266,
-0.2655572891,
-0.1761518419,
-0.0570666566,
0.1520807445,
0.4737436771,
0.5215898156,
-0.6333200932,
0.0874710083,
-0.1621962637,
0.0285703074,
0.5958527327,
-0.543566525,
0.0878756493,
-0.5486139655,
0.1987100095,
0.1629402936,
0.3072415888,
0.0287504699,
-0.2094501257,
-0.6228525639,
-0.2937940955,
0.4923498034,
0.5204581022,
-0.7555323243,
0.3857624829,
-0.494020611,
-0.3514989614,
-0.8884191513,
0.4375968277,
0.5228893161,
0.5037392974,
0.2537871003,
-0.2042150348,
-0.5337232947,
-1.2203115225,
-0.4048805833,
-0.0642174557,
0.5480835438,
-0.1045961902,
0.2768568099,
-0.0641629621,
0.6801788807,
-0.1591996551,
0.0401613116,
-0.1527413726,
-0.240939334,
0.1939381659,
0.3292429149,
0.6019533277,
-1.1583731174,
-0.5476488471,
0.1804957986,
-0.7738451362,
0.0080438647,
0.1422125101,
0.0499014594,
0.5060364604,
0.2751876712,
-0.5932561755,
-0.0187671129,
0.9401218295,
-0.1013332382,
0.6107729077,
-0.0469133668,
0.3326755762,
-1.0331288576,
0.3042705953,
0.0126403347,
-0.3615498245,
-0.5802087784,
0.1761870831,
0.1799495518,
0.1290048212,
-0.4906722009,
0.6971469522,
-0.6498196125,
-0.1974395514,
-0.0955751315,
0.2883912623,
0.1441289783,
0.2699610293,
-0.018702222,
0.7811219096,
0.5759435892,
-0.3817468286,
0.5446887612,
0.2021872103,
-0.4233785868,
0.7240620255,
-0.2189780325,
-0.1166618466,
-0.1189545766,
0.1803425103,
-0.7778068185,
0.0644926205,
-0.0663300157,
-0.2471203804,
0.4079572856,
0.0152632659,
-0.7742973566,
-0.1428513378,
-0.1902503818,
0.6032083035,
0.2683952153,
-0.7215796113,
0.629155457,
0.496543467,
-0.1911886036,
-0.9128465056,
-0.6520841718,
0.2189455628,
-0.2708736956,
-0.7101499438,
0.1798769832,
-0.41717875,
-0.5641520023,
-0.1573236436,
-0.2752005458,
0.202930361,
0.1615597159,
-0.1096411198,
0.363463223,
-0.374351263,
0.2063479275,
-0.3364855945,
-0.1431068927,
-0.3015666306,
-0.2987186015,
0.4773944914,
-0.3775048256,
-0.7246362567,
-0.2229762226,
0.3923145533,
0.6829203963,
-0.5756012201,
0.9244970679,
0.7406653166,
-0.3195164502,
0.1553300172,
-1.1113501787,
0.056100443,
-0.4312149584,
0.1855081618,
-0.5036305189,
-1.0471506119,
0.5525944829,
-0.1495915055,
0.3651548624,
0.238505438,
0.6517897248,
0.2287392914,
1.0355113745,
0.5127179623,
-0.3333449066,
0.0720726103,
0.2496960908,
0.3576940596,
-0.4611850679,
-0.1343086064,
-0.5668316483,
-0.2399748117,
-0.6459275484,
-0.5069271922,
0.3693822622,
-0.0761981234,
-0.1385661811,
-0.0606625937,
-0.0484396182,
0.4294161797,
0.3046221137,
-0.1437643021,
0.5189534426,
0.0499303341,
-0.3472392857,
-0.3046278656,
-0.7572276592,
-0.4509130716,
0.9967921376,
0.2339988202,
0.6138008237,
0.5467650294,
0.2889083326,
-0.1329129934,
0.2825841606,
-0.6480244994,
0.4452274442,
-0.266191572,
-0.756419003,
-0.1525884271,
-0.515525341,
-0.6222820878,
0.554428041,
-0.440248847,
-0.4827542603,
-0.1052314192,
-0.0365447551,
-0.1700777262,
0.4309218824,
-0.5822463632,
0.8808990121,
-0.6627885699,
-0.7214850187,
-0.3271284699,
-0.8189123273,
0.3113638163,
-0.3033009768,
0.6404231191,
-0.2757042348,
-0.2243263274,
0.511505127,
-0.1835572124,
0.6372031569,
-0.0085526099,
-0.399381578,
-0.0786197409,
-0.0173204765,
0.4602280855,
-0.267351985,
-0.4319225252,
0.3367148638,
-0.197072506,
-0.4880029559,
-0.5062549114,
0.9004771709,
-0.6061751246,
-0.7432207465,
-0.3332778513,
-0.8404638767,
-0.6870096922,
0.3860982955,
-0.1268893629,
0.3452117443,
-0.3756156564,
0.1216050684,
0.8116292357,
-0.0016732542,
0.5396723151,
1.0875496864,
-0.3588574827,
-0.4015737772,
0.9992493391,
0.1938609183,
0.3444805145,
0.4747751057,
0.0760087967,
-0.6428076029,
-0.4882465601,
-0.4460762739,
0.4169878364,
-0.6837409735,
-0.1945483088,
-0.5319663882,
0.0585564487,
-0.5471435785,
0.0789554268,
-0.5507782698,
-0.4247406423,
0.4426103532,
-0.0639687106,
0.1460824907,
0.3504779935,
-0.2294155508,
-0.0748048648,
-0.9476707578,
0.2486433536,
0.1430484504,
0.5756366849,
-0.0276251025,
-0.2832010984,
-0.4362792075,
0.1607653499,
-0.2682799101,
-0.4176510572,
0.0000916856,
0.0666079745,
0.9565302134,
0.2418391705,
0.0236108117,
0.6833105683,
-0.5084366798,
0.561563611,
0.5034438372,
-1.0109928846,
0.1750079989,
-0.2182031572,
0.2818377912,
0.7151953578,
0.4703728259,
-0.9087588191,
-0.1695875525,
-0.3676784039,
-0.5454746485,
0.4456182122,
0.0863627121,
-0.0936077833,
0.3536309898,
-0.1278112084,
0.484046489,
0.4314884543,
-0.7625136375,
-0.3320563138,
-0.0772802234,
-0.4979049861,
-0.3676254451,
-0.0153103573,
-0.5000879765,
-0.0511372834,
0.8130022287,
-0.2809376419,
-0.3321921229,
-0.082284756,
-0.1536299735,
-0.2411013246,
0.475276053,
0.6345775127,
0.8054054976,
0.153859362,
0.327290386,
0.2418787926,
-0.2004380524,
0.3823111355,
0.2712064385,
0.0182295088,
0.0032082121,
0.3766592741,
0.7216080427,
0.124101989,
-0.7777477503,
0.5928969383,
-0.0309259687,
0.033031065,
0.0732000098,
-0.1310236603,
0.349984616,
0.3021270633,
0.1007969379,
0.0990817547,
-0.1376175731,
-0.5118986368,
0.1033381,
0.6612379551,
-0.080371879,
-0.2369646728,
0.4934903383,
0.2871094048,
0.1860966533,
0.3531723022,
-0.0022857746,
-0.6482938528,
0.1953691542,
0.532992065,
0.4514997005,
-0.5973088145,
-0.0052218372,
0.2206596285,
0.355623275,
-0.3108055294,
0.2640154362,
0.1627128571,
-1.0912712812,
-0.5552011132,
-0.5151818395,
-0.3812564015,
0.0452308655,
-0.5250192881,
0.1953419,
-0.124558568,
-0.1678340733,
0.0874138325,
0.3206745386,
-0.6257836819,
0.0905196369,
0.4185782373,
0.9497736096,
-0.9522377849,
0.8592783809,
0.6893687248,
-0.0613745488,
-0.7098677158,
-0.1436122507,
0.4164112806,
-0.941298008,
0.4163176417,
0.2197445929,
-0.1812651306,
-0.404106468,
-0.4279350936,
-0.8740265965,
0.9288623929,
0.7650271058,
-0.9143893123,
0.3968853652,
0.3836270869,
0.4940192699,
-0.3007273376,
-0.0126655707,
0.3144779801,
0.8865852952,
0.1791594326,
-1.1672030687,
0.1393374801,
-0.2066656053,
-0.2281570882,
0.3176779151,
-1.1036075354,
0.6747808456,
-0.1776064932,
-0.2356154025,
0.0621125884,
0.6325962543,
0.3728946149,
0.4154191613,
0.5194378495,
0.7595095038,
1.0000532866,
-0.0135566825,
0.8818518519,
-0.4256310165,
0.222914964,
1.0709075928,
-1.0011129379,
0.5651683807,
0.4602358341,
-0.0814826861,
0.1823651195,
0.3871056437,
-0.0550901704,
0.4082105756,
0.0437405817,
-0.3748729527,
-0.4820860624,
-0.5840430856,
-0.5247855783,
0.3484057784,
0.2609804869,
0.1311796457,
-0.3729962409,
-0.0912482813,
0.2648540437,
0.2939424515,
-0.1777303368,
0.5683456659,
-0.0518627875,
-0.6778573394,
0.5355123878,
0.0136444103,
0.7440981865,
-0.707259059,
0.1274562329,
-0.217407003,
0.2030036151,
-0.3257427216,
-0.8828818798,
0.1726224869,
-0.0153072039,
-0.2871674001,
-0.2933548987,
0.5544152856,
-0.8671390414,
-0.4358172119,
0.3745819032,
0.8083751202,
-0.1201736555,
0.3082278371,
-0.7881835103,
0.4898627102,
-0.0072721108,
0.1238570586,
0.3618758917,
0.4965617657,
-0.0252763331,
0.8324179649,
0.638859868,
0.1057860702,
-0.1834020913,
0.2812849581,
0.6541858315,
-0.4782112837,
-0.3817574382,
-0.9319808483,
0.356726259,
-0.1346975863,
-0.1604696214,
1.1935706139,
1.0048247576,
0.8988568783,
0.1658726335,
0.8254458308,
0.2098602802,
0.5687867403,
-0.6181507111,
0.4983486235,
-0.7071888447,
0.2210897505,
-0.0550645366,
-0.9687722921,
-0.2661361694,
0.1697061658,
-0.12000411,
-0.0604829267,
0.5193718076,
0.8360187411,
-0.1193313822,
0.2173839658,
0.4693693221,
0.2792957127,
0.0879418701,
0.3825103641,
0.9569577575,
-0.2782945335,
0.3255327642,
-0.071767047,
-0.0356782451,
-0.1094012111,
-1.0097970963,
-0.5902501941,
-0.4944803417,
-0.3450745046,
-0.2735325098,
0.0481937937,
0.8915752769,
0.7076179385,
-0.8558908105,
-0.4358783662,
0.4756468832,
0.3614321947,
-0.2683419883,
-0.1474963576,
0.072851494,
-0.2316507697,
-0.5457292795,
0.4267273843,
0.2519935071,
0.1627179384,
-0.3110916317,
-0.2584159374,
-0.383166194,
-0.0182188153,
0.4883301258,
0.093839936,
-0.676684618,
-0.2313451022,
-0.0047525736,
-0.4020118415,
0.1148200259,
0.8563637733,
-0.4546987712,
0.4998554587,
0.2366668582,
0.6855316162,
0.1155541241,
-0.1232080013,
0.6028636098,
-0.8711748123,
0.1743052453,
0.156209439,
0.6331453323,
0.8157963753,
-0.1018009111,
0.5910339952,
0.2865372896,
-0.3360472023,
-0.8442553878,
0.2413687259,
-0.9569260478,
-0.3956598938,
1.0794011354,
-0.1115214974,
0.0605930798,
-0.1794824898,
0.0766915902,
0.2834484875,
-0.1412177086,
0.3845156431,
1.0117163658,
0.1257959306,
0.0732448995,
-0.4326228797,
0.3030805588,
0.4852043688,
-0.6557159424,
0.4110877216,
0.6825485826,
0.2249880582,
0.4215411246,
0.310356319,
-0.2044900358,
0.0321474709,
-0.1135163382,
0.0315482318,
0.0698200837,
-0.3514951766,
-0.3228581846,
0.0196319651,
0.1223753616,
0.1511380821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14425v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14425v2 | SynDARin: Synthesising Datasets for Automated Reasoning in Low-Resource Languages | 2024-06-20T15:49:28 | 2024-06-25T13:48:41 | Gayane Ghazaryan, Erik Arakelyan, Pasquale Minervini, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Question Answering (QA) datasets have been instrumental in developing and
evaluating Large Language Model (LLM) capabilities. However, such datasets are
scarce for languages other than English due to the cost and difficulties of
collection and manual annotation. This means that producing novel models and
measuring the performance of multilingual LLMs in low-resource languages is
challenging. To mitigate this, we propose $\textbf{S}$yn$\textbf{DAR}$in, a
method for generating and validating QA datasets for low-resource languages. We
utilize parallel content mining to obtain $\textit{human-curated}$ paragraphs
between English and the target language. We use the English data as context to
$\textit{generate}$ synthetic multiple-choice (MC) question-answer pairs, which
are automatically translated and further validated for quality. Combining these
with their designated non-English $\textit{human-curated}$ paragraphs form the
final QA dataset. The method allows to maintain the content quality, reduces
the likelihood of factual errors, and circumvents the need for costly
annotation. To test the method, we created a QA dataset with $1.2$K samples for
the Armenian language. The human evaluation shows that $98\%$ of the generated
English data maintains quality and diversity in the question types and topics,
while the translation validation pipeline can filter out $\sim70\%$ of data
with poor quality. We use the dataset to benchmark state-of-the-art LLMs,
showing their inability to achieve human accuracy with some model performances
closer to random chance. This shows that the generated dataset is non-trivial
and can be used to evaluate reasoning capabilities in low-resource language. | [
-0.4224584699,
-0.5803415179,
0.5462135077,
-0.0552563332,
-0.256383419,
0.0560338572,
-0.3490846157,
-0.075238511,
0.2291197926,
0.6286271214,
-0.6672593355,
-0.5994634032,
-0.1962889433,
0.6521607041,
-0.1761189103,
0.8548383117,
-0.2183985263,
0.2019540519,
-0.5851019621,
-0.5375409722,
-0.247877717,
-0.2976024449,
-0.6133373976,
-0.0503764674,
0.407179445,
0.6307986379,
0.5501231551,
0.6526002288,
0.3918239474,
0.3210925162,
-0.0641418993,
0.7033652663,
-0.1815723926,
0.3618728817,
-0.2202428132,
-0.6710916758,
-0.2790874243,
-0.0396284014,
0.5869190693,
0.5944190025,
-0.0184611622,
0.6233404875,
-0.0072653177,
0.5212780833,
-0.401521951,
0.0824494213,
-0.5424852371,
-0.285308063,
-0.3387212455,
0.0370095447,
-0.1632823646,
-0.4154826105,
-0.1268646866,
-0.6291827559,
0.0708437264,
0.2722007334,
0.8955866694,
0.4593400061,
-0.2549749017,
-0.2680446208,
-0.5383194685,
1.0688472986,
-0.8583121896,
0.0954207182,
0.4958648384,
0.5135678649,
-0.0285989381,
-0.5614342093,
-0.8905643225,
-0.1016691104,
-0.2862911224,
-0.0128082866,
0.1285520196,
-0.1075861901,
0.4713653326,
0.4901612103,
-0.8093086481,
-0.1077986285,
-0.4850032628,
-0.16152668,
0.7397184372,
0.3858729899,
0.4745775461,
-0.5808745027,
0.0233600996,
-0.2707199156,
-0.7669202685,
0.1854759306,
0.604912281,
0.442237705,
-0.1100130007,
0.7980116606,
-0.4877024889,
0.6105222702,
-0.1176809445,
-0.2959707975,
0.2317178398,
-0.7161989808,
-0.081920892,
-0.4339556396,
0.7927900553,
0.0875710398,
0.0578815117,
0.0192543101,
-0.3881957233,
0.1295670718,
-0.0201758351,
-0.7240806222,
-0.1328790933,
0.4248715639,
-0.4391821623,
-0.086399734,
-0.30497998,
-0.663503468,
-0.3236175776,
-0.4322309792,
0.2269213349,
-0.2548934221,
-0.0872919559,
0.0394878536,
0.0942502767,
0.0976752788,
0.0797777474,
-0.5223940015,
0.3744591773,
0.3862355053,
0.5285007358,
-0.2339954376,
-0.3814345598,
-0.5345121622,
-0.1027129665,
-0.3654308915,
0.9221653342,
-0.2630425692,
0.08802104,
-0.1410016268,
0.0361417644,
0.0462787859,
-0.7426843643,
0.6305413842,
-0.4768415689,
0.4317140281,
-0.3607445955,
-0.4259264469,
-0.1005340368,
0.4989103377,
-0.7940097451,
0.9913514853,
0.2946186662,
-0.7571767569,
0.1526690573,
-0.254075706,
-0.3739740551,
0.0417091772,
-0.2678565383,
-0.2480229437,
-0.2128603458,
0.5633769631,
0.0879314169,
-0.8174000382,
0.2421613336,
-0.0795272663,
-0.2514945865,
0.3729484975,
-0.3194691837,
0.7584289312,
0.2770398557,
-0.0028437199,
0.0549478941,
-0.8645631671,
0.2725325823,
-0.010731603,
-0.3761486113,
-0.36178267,
-0.1263956726,
-0.0198323112,
0.5160905123,
0.2725745142,
-0.5535389185,
-0.1354909986,
-0.5884718299,
0.2550131083,
0.5399923921,
0.085294053,
0.4041061997,
-0.6993535161,
0.8628213406,
0.0035486578,
0.1006087884,
-0.1073452532,
-0.3738728166,
-0.9269938469,
-0.2537769675,
0.4482401907,
0.7384713292,
-1.2335573435,
0.366310358,
-0.2066322416,
-0.4715356827,
-0.9758759737,
0.3595778048,
0.4116401672,
0.3777258396,
0.3538772762,
-0.1441889256,
-0.5778668523,
-1.0210158825,
-0.0884793326,
-0.29759866,
-0.1164501309,
0.5755254626,
0.299761802,
-0.045702111,
0.8326627612,
-0.2508300543,
-0.0266544633,
-0.5359723568,
0.0894630402,
0.4199485779,
0.4601103663,
0.2829981446,
-0.57150352,
-0.4826130271,
-0.1376501918,
-0.7593806982,
-0.329033643,
-0.1345573068,
-0.2483552247,
0.3355040848,
0.2473644465,
-0.674739182,
0.1700481027,
0.5943309069,
-0.0147459693,
0.6314951181,
-0.0172148794,
0.3768819273,
-1.3900401592,
0.2006392628,
-0.1201434582,
0.0306921396,
-0.4483580291,
0.0484412946,
-0.1793659627,
-0.3257613182,
-0.4449990094,
0.9013222456,
-0.1984553039,
-0.0306612682,
-0.1648786962,
0.263738513,
0.20363608,
0.520036757,
-0.0637015402,
0.9450063705,
0.3874297738,
-0.3890594542,
0.5503920317,
0.4242229164,
-0.5401527882,
0.6134673357,
-0.7708169222,
-0.0627425835,
-0.1722635031,
0.079026185,
-0.856833756,
-0.2809037864,
0.2751272023,
-0.3206838369,
-0.1899604499,
-0.2768168747,
-0.762507081,
-0.2768773735,
-0.0109927589,
0.685099721,
0.5021876097,
-0.3197561204,
0.5396559834,
0.4174243808,
-0.5636761189,
-0.4109476507,
-0.7008365393,
-0.0460727178,
-0.2129546702,
-0.9349659085,
-0.0160727128,
-0.1136083454,
-0.4578015208,
0.0653729215,
-0.0203959458,
-0.2250060588,
-0.0294298194,
-0.080837898,
0.2820150554,
-0.1629526615,
0.2318402082,
0.1682657748,
-0.1164314374,
-0.0023451466,
-0.172890991,
0.3887158334,
-0.0230960939,
-0.4462090135,
-0.4672086835,
0.4900449216,
0.4272871315,
-0.4686537683,
0.5489441156,
0.457551837,
-0.3320067525,
-0.675329268,
-0.4223514199,
-0.4436044395,
-0.4375998974,
0.1612945199,
-0.3661199212,
-0.7166108489,
0.7379088402,
0.133958593,
0.0601879954,
0.373549372,
0.5439382195,
-0.106537804,
0.8932436109,
0.0688532516,
0.1632577181,
-0.0484624393,
-0.1979109198,
0.2278756797,
-0.5901734829,
0.1152719334,
-0.6186683178,
-0.2577292323,
-0.9291494489,
-0.5787904859,
0.6187628508,
-0.0650591925,
-0.1103314161,
0.2450416982,
-0.1942801327,
0.4085649252,
0.8205177188,
0.019684827,
0.2719531953,
-0.05621925,
-0.0986846089,
0.0479887165,
-0.7982789874,
-0.7108991146,
1.2399488688,
-0.0329941027,
0.7673627138,
-0.0506038219,
0.829888463,
0.1360610723,
-0.0228260905,
-0.476364255,
0.6389793158,
-0.3285834491,
-0.4928070307,
-0.4983606935,
-0.6946402788,
-0.7231513262,
0.1682387739,
-0.1884301454,
-0.1623806357,
0.0434401482,
0.0161216427,
-0.4499207735,
0.1341415644,
-0.5791873336,
0.8626445532,
-0.1581784189,
-0.2972658575,
-0.2209871262,
-0.4519771934,
0.3453802466,
0.0065979548,
0.2004876882,
-0.238544479,
0.2165152282,
0.6974579096,
-0.4289168715,
0.6894599199,
-0.0450103171,
-0.0726189241,
0.6096348763,
0.1532508582,
0.6016948223,
0.3116060197,
-0.2251520455,
-0.0232147854,
0.2761776745,
-0.5569119453,
-0.6610558629,
0.5187289715,
-0.7594455481,
-0.6893308163,
-0.2912679017,
-0.8887637854,
-0.3369032443,
0.0714159012,
-0.0851662755,
0.3898242116,
0.0430889092,
-0.1683783382,
0.4496351779,
-0.5336441398,
-0.0460874327,
0.4538896382,
0.0902904868,
-0.5726982355,
1.0240933895,
0.04434935,
0.2421415746,
0.1478029341,
0.1484213322,
-0.2613813281,
-0.5484058261,
-0.6957352757,
0.3282818496,
-0.6673657298,
-0.252483815,
-0.2953248322,
-0.3053849339,
-0.268789351,
0.2448277175,
-0.225603655,
-0.6313518882,
-0.0756590813,
0.1127709672,
0.2167516798,
0.459035933,
-0.0090183727,
-0.0255638342,
-0.8598807454,
0.4604632854,
0.4550287426,
0.1325025558,
-0.2073456645,
-0.4098080397,
-0.3972765207,
0.2211549729,
-0.0448133834,
-0.4633143842,
0.3818570673,
-0.0778812245,
0.5695846081,
-0.0449902639,
0.3236864209,
0.3997358978,
-0.3074644506,
0.8425658345,
-0.2970359921,
-0.7435403466,
0.669300735,
-0.2687847018,
0.2925516963,
0.7297451496,
0.228263095,
-0.6635632515,
-0.6860972643,
-0.4723550975,
-0.7950978875,
0.8315192461,
0.3433381915,
-0.1365938783,
-0.1322021037,
0.1857935339,
0.2948057055,
0.2503372729,
-0.4463685751,
-0.3065881729,
0.0724037811,
-0.4575765431,
0.0968417376,
-0.2059876621,
-0.2406381369,
-0.0500994511,
0.7373850346,
-0.331374377,
-0.1221905276,
-0.028884897,
-0.122456938,
-0.0273728836,
0.3767851591,
0.2067981213,
0.7564697266,
-0.0374431498,
0.1057966724,
0.1828825176,
-0.1440132111,
0.3368538916,
0.3006817698,
-0.5856476426,
-0.0127966795,
0.2691223621,
0.5685360432,
-0.3491265476,
-1.0759042501,
0.429653734,
-0.1867040694,
0.0447838791,
-0.2172202319,
-0.0336305611,
-0.1195566505,
0.3508746624,
0.036203187,
-0.0068758936,
-0.0109896036,
-0.1521109045,
0.2478508353,
0.1768896133,
0.1459711492,
-0.2982834578,
0.3503833711,
0.2343717963,
0.1298694313,
0.7811251283,
-0.457316637,
-0.3258701861,
0.6308823824,
0.1365673542,
0.7048217654,
-0.0109895021,
0.49290061,
0.6267297268,
0.3198731542,
-0.1024730802,
0.6922169924,
-0.0504685715,
-0.7571405172,
-0.679033637,
-0.7557439208,
-0.4537415206,
0.1209918335,
-0.589138329,
0.144678399,
-0.17684789,
0.0141563099,
-0.3406094611,
0.2369361073,
-0.6614826322,
0.278565526,
0.0697521567,
0.8090023994,
-1.0760210752,
0.6919808984,
0.793979764,
-0.5272871256,
-0.7619217634,
-0.0606309809,
-0.2088367641,
-0.735637486,
0.6785663962,
-0.1660694182,
0.235166654,
-0.2418656945,
-0.3893358409,
-0.9528300166,
0.9803409576,
0.4702647626,
-0.2533005178,
0.1425045282,
0.5566151738,
0.6374630928,
-0.2389783263,
0.191447705,
0.5397024155,
0.4703797102,
-0.0622490086,
-0.8832747936,
0.1521816105,
-0.4334799945,
-0.0123198368,
-0.1296945363,
-0.5793671608,
0.9769850969,
-0.1489054263,
-0.4218756258,
0.4111662209,
0.5473340154,
0.700393796,
0.1519521177,
0.5264570713,
0.7181682587,
0.8492410183,
-0.1189672723,
1.0260198116,
-0.3570062518,
-0.0209819265,
1.0785899162,
-0.4342871606,
0.633498311,
0.5921426415,
-0.1862284839,
0.4774045646,
0.521933496,
0.0489791483,
0.4340482056,
0.4079747498,
-0.2128995508,
-0.6002969742,
-0.493929565,
0.0691723302,
0.4346527159,
0.1016188189,
-0.0951849818,
-0.2160952389,
-0.0844252929,
-0.2767026126,
0.3691774011,
-0.0837405249,
0.7555274963,
-0.0113206888,
-0.8500273228,
0.7129188776,
0.1259543747,
0.3845261335,
-0.4945029616,
0.0123842992,
-0.6726105213,
-0.0486877747,
-0.0135787614,
-0.7801784277,
0.3383089602,
0.1131888404,
-0.3194599152,
-0.1654771268,
0.416747421,
-0.7363290787,
-0.6876260042,
-0.0753927082,
0.9725114703,
0.1619851738,
0.2707768083,
-0.5379219651,
-0.0804376453,
-0.0485290326,
-0.016603997,
0.2351179421,
0.6869365573,
-0.2590469718,
0.7758303881,
0.694791019,
0.5065143704,
-0.1099858508,
0.1526024789,
0.8395043612,
-0.4093269706,
-0.533638835,
-0.37215361,
0.4261383712,
-0.071747154,
-0.2418399155,
0.6909218431,
0.5143333077,
1.049498558,
0.0090854447,
1.0097271204,
-0.1745443642,
0.835847199,
-0.5411089659,
0.6757167578,
-0.5762616396,
0.3808864951,
0.1831565797,
-0.650536418,
-0.0297055542,
0.3346908092,
-0.1923007667,
-0.1492637545,
0.7359201908,
1.0924409628,
0.0999856293,
-0.134539336,
0.2045764029,
0.1143402159,
0.1828489602,
0.7313920856,
0.9564634562,
-0.5843530297,
0.7869899869,
-0.4714872837,
-0.0450309739,
0.4089677632,
-0.5464634895,
-1.0426354408,
-0.7331796288,
-0.1552361995,
-0.4881456196,
-0.069232285,
0.9563026428,
0.5200481415,
-1.2363071442,
-0.3955319226,
0.1314497292,
0.4112517238,
-0.3322317302,
-0.2098873407,
0.5958496332,
-0.5267629027,
-0.861753881,
0.3601047695,
-0.0264222659,
-0.0608630069,
-0.4569615722,
-0.1559599489,
-0.0651258379,
0.0321786702,
0.270411849,
0.207217142,
-0.688801825,
-0.0733629912,
0.1654975265,
-0.1788279712,
-0.1609885097,
0.6166193485,
-0.7666438818,
0.3447309732,
0.7335707545,
0.9171369076,
0.0729064643,
0.0690021068,
0.7017940283,
-0.8994109631,
0.151014775,
0.4180466235,
0.356023401,
0.5079749227,
-0.0288371723,
0.3428237438,
0.1949276179,
-0.5225776434,
-0.8218942881,
0.2911728024,
-0.6595226526,
-0.0907811597,
1.2856060266,
-0.2382825762,
-0.3872735202,
-0.1371884048,
-0.1677632183,
0.1247142851,
-0.2633096576,
0.9746016264,
0.6453276277,
0.0965271667,
-0.2140447348,
-0.3128634691,
0.7289860845,
0.3579977155,
-1.142580986,
0.121710211,
0.5308589339,
0.1483466923,
0.081328921,
0.4299407601,
-0.0829038769,
0.4228976071,
-0.1069320738,
0.0958691165,
-0.0741959065,
-0.1403228939,
-0.0847625136,
0.0343098566,
0.0059182178,
-0.1336806417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14408v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14408v2 | FVEL: Interactive Formal Verification Environment with Large Language Models via Theorem Proving | 2024-06-20T15:31:05 | 2024-06-21T02:51:41 | Xiaohan Lin, Qingxing Cao, Yinya Huang, Haiming Wang, Jianqiao Lu, Zhengying Liu, Linqi Song, Xiaodan Liang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Formal verification (FV) has witnessed growing significance with current
emerging program synthesis by the evolving large language models (LLMs).
However, current formal verification mainly resorts to symbolic verifiers or
hand-craft rules, resulting in limitations for extensive and flexible
verification. On the other hand, formal languages for automated theorem
proving, such as Isabelle, as another line of rigorous verification, are
maintained with comprehensive rules and theorems. In this paper, we propose
FVEL, an interactive Formal Verification Environment with LLMs. Specifically,
FVEL transforms a given code to be verified into Isabelle, and then conducts
verification via neural automated theorem proving with an LLM. The joined
paradigm leverages the rigorous yet abundant formulated and organized rules in
Isabelle and is also convenient for introducing and adjusting cutting-edge
LLMs. To achieve this goal, we extract a large-scale FVELER3. The FVELER
dataset includes code dependencies and verification processes that are
formulated in Isabelle, containing 758 theories, 29,125 lemmas, and 200,646
proof steps in total with in-depth dependencies. We benchmark FVELER in the
FVEL environment by first fine-tuning LLMs with FVELER and then evaluating them
on Code2Inv and SV-COMP. The results show that FVEL with FVELER fine-tuned
Llama3- 8B solves 17.39% (69 -> 81) more problems, and Mistral-7B 12% (75 ->
84) more problems in SV-COMP. And the proportion of proof errors is reduced.
Project page: https://fveler.github.io/. | [
-0.2735084593,
-0.7858367562,
0.5759887695,
0.2666570544,
-0.0220395029,
0.0836618841,
-0.4172458947,
-0.5131527185,
-0.1554369777,
0.5980027914,
-0.43830809,
-0.6573216915,
-0.3498260379,
0.210991621,
-0.3425430059,
0.5067884326,
-0.5107522607,
-0.0914347619,
-0.2290051281,
0.0082565555,
-0.2123543322,
-0.419751972,
-0.4353885055,
-0.3123356998,
0.1900032461,
0.2895009816,
0.4142617583,
0.5374951959,
0.5107518435,
0.465487361,
0.0993746519,
0.4415106475,
-0.3013647795,
0.4577105939,
0.1253620535,
-0.6084261537,
-0.4924058616,
-0.4977353513,
0.5926341414,
0.1213826016,
0.0691441,
0.0106358472,
-0.0440988317,
0.4337887466,
-0.6037278771,
0.473849982,
-0.4512283802,
-0.0627517477,
-0.142793566,
-0.1107419282,
-0.397377193,
-0.5064927936,
-0.1057371497,
-0.6601234078,
-0.1824400425,
0.2128497958,
0.7398608327,
0.3379103541,
-0.4571755528,
-0.3359294832,
-0.9983372688,
0.7090677023,
-0.4760513902,
0.6308443546,
0.066809848,
0.6133881211,
-0.1445490271,
-0.7122123241,
-0.5663790703,
-0.2249902487,
0.1497509778,
-0.2832933962,
-0.3949334025,
0.0740391091,
0.7142031193,
0.5042766929,
-0.5061509609,
0.2315290868,
-0.2379766405,
-0.5366712213,
0.7163907886,
0.1435220093,
0.4261087775,
0.2097117901,
-0.1148058623,
-0.1718544513,
-1.0177128315,
0.1411012113,
0.1179198995,
0.0051584956,
0.0729742944,
0.4383170903,
-0.2101601958,
0.7508509159,
-0.2645769119,
-0.0698341802,
0.0137327109,
-0.2976242304,
-0.1879870743,
-0.1727534086,
0.7614115477,
0.3722668886,
0.3023872972,
-0.0340810902,
-0.6161035895,
-0.0535994433,
-0.1945834011,
-1.0375243425,
-0.11422427,
0.4028827846,
-0.2882456183,
-0.1289965212,
-0.1071508378,
-0.6590796709,
-0.2335133702,
-0.4309543669,
0.30246979,
-0.7740181088,
-0.0672432333,
0.1223251894,
0.3089140952,
0.550822556,
0.7598956227,
-0.6353202462,
0.3572646677,
1.0760303736,
0.8202289939,
0.1662162691,
-0.295470655,
-1.0693598986,
0.0403807871,
-0.2736787796,
0.4989959598,
-0.2587393224,
0.040800374,
0.3200540841,
-0.0706100538,
0.3214433193,
-0.2932374179,
0.4104521275,
-0.7122000456,
-0.055393599,
-0.3606616855,
-0.5088822246,
-0.2669093311,
0.6587459445,
-0.5654969811,
0.8884317875,
-0.0196095649,
-0.5223066211,
0.2326237857,
-0.7382549644,
-0.3488469124,
0.0080753798,
-0.2765138447,
-0.1164453551,
-0.1887690425,
0.3931375146,
0.3575066626,
-0.5313391685,
0.152339831,
-0.3241618276,
-0.4503704309,
0.3612673581,
0.0443055891,
0.8125151396,
0.1355149895,
-0.4189685583,
0.3629302084,
-0.8462156653,
-0.0122672021,
0.0884989128,
-0.0370222963,
-0.4371108711,
-0.1535304338,
-0.1310399175,
0.2509994805,
0.1806120723,
-0.7483858466,
0.3923138976,
-0.6191375256,
0.7649667859,
0.7394027114,
0.012679725,
0.2470749617,
-0.3622949719,
0.6160487533,
-0.0566118211,
0.1946914792,
-0.3189113438,
-0.31824404,
-0.9643746018,
-0.4497482777,
0.5309605002,
0.588388443,
-0.8997394443,
0.4482146204,
-0.2801093459,
-0.1712961346,
-0.354955107,
0.1230527088,
0.277205795,
0.1878300756,
0.3094221354,
0.103022173,
-0.5606750846,
-0.6297441125,
0.0267741233,
-0.1528531313,
-0.307359606,
0.0022881157,
0.8759936094,
-0.4523565173,
0.9352267981,
-0.3263910711,
-0.2930719256,
0.1428495347,
-0.0788230449,
0.0797443166,
0.4392367899,
0.6011400819,
-0.3615483046,
-0.1508709639,
0.2453822941,
-0.9047418833,
-0.0742731616,
0.1140829176,
-0.1020665243,
0.2946359813,
0.5677683949,
-0.2746424079,
0.23221609,
0.3700368702,
0.0157151055,
0.3313435912,
-0.4135232866,
0.2089666575,
-0.5455854535,
-0.0073898914,
-0.0520122126,
-0.4920526743,
-0.2044506818,
0.4825440347,
0.0044737845,
-0.1271670014,
-0.2948549688,
0.6676932573,
-0.5255079865,
-0.034822356,
-0.0217469372,
0.0359173045,
0.0566375069,
0.4234471917,
-0.1863410026,
0.5984905362,
0.7693867087,
-0.5913546681,
0.5893815756,
0.1808690578,
-0.3555260599,
0.4519500732,
-0.9673970938,
0.1680272669,
0.0692738742,
0.3403149545,
-0.7921894789,
-0.2517266273,
0.1471430659,
0.0179568734,
0.0009657643,
-0.3379796445,
-0.8703910708,
-0.2180540562,
-0.4127001464,
0.2647835612,
0.7341018915,
-0.6270774603,
1.105203867,
0.0862827972,
0.0305023137,
-0.4539075196,
-0.8001222014,
-0.0849157721,
0.0110284109,
-1.126418829,
0.1391839236,
-0.0080085378,
-0.7128270268,
-0.3370251954,
-0.054712005,
-0.0349539816,
0.0360696279,
0.4674929976,
0.071227707,
-0.313500762,
-0.1062756255,
0.2726785243,
-0.1391316503,
0.2748219967,
-0.507101357,
0.2363891006,
-0.5687465072,
-0.7393453717,
-0.345410943,
0.2146896571,
0.8574562669,
-0.5600928664,
0.2962100506,
0.3515706062,
-0.6271882653,
-0.5216211677,
-0.4565883577,
-0.344594568,
-0.4698417783,
-0.0943511128,
-0.4949648976,
-1.1512767076,
0.8966442943,
-0.209093973,
0.5463644266,
0.3061977327,
0.5392819047,
0.1924900264,
0.7664735913,
0.4923696816,
0.3631278276,
0.306217283,
-0.3335267305,
0.1078597233,
-0.5487682223,
-0.3398795426,
-0.5632061362,
-0.1783226877,
-0.5044872761,
-0.6967075467,
0.4267500043,
-0.0193488523,
-0.3380889595,
0.2392647266,
-0.4209894836,
0.4632884562,
0.4419449568,
0.1707797647,
0.6231991053,
-0.155499801,
-0.398378402,
-0.1910540462,
-0.4216542244,
-0.4907256067,
0.8503524661,
0.513382256,
0.6150427461,
0.3656749725,
0.9476714134,
0.2416136712,
0.3850793242,
-0.694417417,
0.8347473741,
0.0463951938,
-0.2660312951,
-0.1572290212,
-0.4488589764,
-0.6092069149,
0.1390931457,
-0.2017998993,
-0.7069023252,
0.103775911,
0.3915178776,
-0.3837788701,
0.0319164246,
-0.2948051989,
0.6611427069,
-0.4584499896,
-0.7215796709,
-0.0871197209,
-0.5349112153,
0.7037632465,
-0.0555646904,
0.3104668856,
-0.0089965425,
0.0456769429,
0.4285908043,
-0.9997579455,
0.6449119449,
-0.2325839251,
-0.5703125596,
0.0545073152,
0.4862282872,
0.750875473,
0.290207535,
-0.2799336314,
-0.0712867379,
-0.0314874798,
0.101814799,
-0.7285398841,
0.888943851,
-0.5293292403,
-0.3472223878,
-0.6215645671,
-0.2881874144,
0.0008838163,
0.5640387535,
0.0048308782,
0.4586524963,
-0.249607712,
0.0833688527,
0.9824042916,
-0.1773499846,
0.1855409592,
0.4437290132,
-0.9021410346,
-0.5167491436,
0.7534407973,
-0.0249401703,
-0.109993808,
0.506522119,
0.1333173364,
-0.3237574399,
-0.6145460606,
-0.4670380056,
0.1189512089,
-0.8935546279,
-0.2797534466,
-0.5031926036,
-0.0857553631,
-0.1026436463,
-0.2779782116,
-0.3219508827,
-0.3595016301,
0.1822475493,
0.3408816755,
0.8051487207,
0.5650780201,
-0.0476343557,
0.0400141776,
-0.762437582,
0.2115745693,
0.402936846,
0.4104171693,
-0.1759656817,
-0.1796317548,
0.2002807111,
0.1682643741,
-0.0334162116,
-0.4125635922,
0.0665018857,
0.0641995445,
0.3846392035,
0.3348833919,
0.2320456654,
0.4061204791,
-0.3893299103,
0.5836828947,
-0.0228675008,
-1.3923623562,
0.6104498506,
-0.4636397362,
0.0178150982,
0.5525266528,
-0.0138832554,
-0.2338530272,
-0.5225064754,
-0.5013030171,
-0.8227397203,
0.3729335964,
0.307577759,
-0.3687810898,
0.3908201158,
0.3700429201,
0.0400305018,
0.0123320408,
-0.548150301,
0.0771228522,
-0.1157940179,
0.024336094,
0.3182052672,
-0.0474601686,
-0.2729399502,
-0.2548764646,
0.5977767706,
-0.1486037523,
0.1933559924,
0.0378427058,
-0.279014051,
0.1689008623,
0.1071283147,
0.7543997169,
0.7050815821,
-0.1791675538,
0.1154500917,
0.0706405714,
0.0674557239,
0.2334410846,
0.331485182,
-0.3647613525,
0.0453762524,
0.5367348194,
0.7117737532,
0.2481374592,
-0.6684527397,
0.6069486141,
-0.243696183,
-0.4475839138,
-0.3864837289,
0.3044345379,
-0.1253235042,
0.3540058434,
0.1490081698,
0.0866303295,
0.0178995542,
-0.2998254895,
0.3272674978,
0.2762807906,
-0.0689771697,
-0.2137201428,
0.8324952126,
0.4498756826,
-0.3569687903,
0.6262874007,
-0.1805272251,
-0.5652408004,
0.482211709,
0.2831881344,
0.8644944429,
0.0654171333,
-0.1360158026,
0.317499727,
0.4854587913,
-0.2365292609,
0.3523973227,
-0.2485597581,
-0.3711499572,
-0.7458350062,
-0.5595867038,
-0.8944436908,
-0.1020912528,
-0.2871821523,
0.5112630725,
-0.7384442091,
0.2962137163,
0.0313685201,
-0.0886070356,
-0.5637908578,
-0.1945009083,
0.0173755437,
0.9749817848,
-0.7305867672,
0.7530583739,
0.7109788656,
-0.3263595402,
-0.6402069926,
0.074270986,
0.0705195889,
-0.6975044608,
0.589583993,
0.2567183077,
-0.4753712118,
-0.0782934204,
-0.4994246066,
-0.4994377792,
1.0264760256,
0.7256092429,
-0.8025280833,
0.1605529338,
-0.0722305104,
0.5772075653,
-0.2182414532,
0.2413245142,
0.2490321696,
0.6426486373,
0.4203016162,
-0.6676861644,
0.3228934407,
-0.230839625,
0.1236601397,
0.2987596989,
-0.4536373019,
0.6481526494,
-0.1695340276,
0.1677557081,
0.0428164303,
0.9865543246,
0.5272266865,
0.0760954022,
0.5643161535,
0.1385169625,
0.9562491775,
-0.3644021153,
0.7885928154,
-0.5125417113,
0.2338172793,
0.718759656,
-0.790245831,
0.6255514026,
0.3593035638,
-0.0996580869,
0.6741711497,
0.4324560761,
0.0485815965,
0.0470188446,
0.6509078145,
-0.2591795921,
-0.3050973713,
0.1750513166,
-0.4218891263,
0.5782383084,
0.2943951488,
-0.1545414329,
-0.2170639634,
0.1979313493,
0.0135505144,
0.1085288897,
-0.1537371725,
0.4989171624,
-0.1460826546,
-0.7402209044,
0.736954391,
0.1538150012,
0.5936457515,
-0.7492362857,
-0.3549853861,
-0.0854449272,
0.6161574125,
-0.2485186309,
-0.7108732462,
0.3601195812,
-0.0154001024,
0.0998158976,
-0.5657378435,
0.7998124361,
-0.398563534,
-0.4747212529,
0.1364786476,
0.3001573384,
0.013957792,
0.1029342413,
-0.3134007156,
0.6231867671,
0.0239629615,
-0.0386926159,
0.0890658349,
0.8045482635,
-0.3008202612,
0.80265522,
0.7818142176,
-0.0579679906,
-0.1537916064,
-0.1047864556,
0.9864122272,
-0.2865176499,
-0.6000420451,
-0.8870768547,
0.3859788775,
-0.2025234848,
-0.0878841281,
0.7993843555,
0.5177676678,
0.5852261782,
-0.0595928133,
0.7343981862,
-0.1255409271,
0.1290305257,
-0.7292225361,
0.5648428202,
-0.3709701896,
0.5815058351,
-0.3308683932,
-0.8379004598,
-0.7525699139,
0.9741538167,
-0.2246498317,
-0.1272999197,
0.4244268537,
0.7940719724,
-0.2366992384,
0.1036661416,
-0.0242630485,
0.1837189496,
0.6428050995,
0.6726450324,
0.9095628262,
-0.417093724,
0.3235526383,
-0.256285131,
-0.5422046185,
-0.3692497611,
-1.3117086887,
-0.8243455291,
-0.4331452549,
-0.6910895705,
-0.6679441929,
0.0675475076,
1.0049008131,
0.5151616335,
-0.6910305023,
-0.1794546843,
-0.2655099034,
0.4259895384,
-0.4426783621,
-0.1603336483,
0.110242255,
0.0868068561,
-0.5841256976,
0.3832232654,
0.3725697398,
-0.0093164379,
-0.6680337787,
-0.2300271392,
-0.014184664,
-0.0931374505,
0.6187212467,
0.5089125633,
-0.6366115808,
-0.3387676477,
0.060061615,
0.0370628387,
-0.0794464201,
0.9899552464,
-0.595302999,
0.3092224598,
0.7297927141,
0.5873152018,
0.5309286714,
-0.3666460514,
0.9160445333,
-0.6455492377,
0.0600046739,
0.2572069764,
0.6262125969,
0.1632231027,
-0.2312143147,
0.3992798924,
-0.0200265851,
-0.6620044708,
-1.1300079823,
0.2309912294,
-0.9053557515,
0.2487444729,
1.1249845028,
-0.3158203363,
-0.3140847087,
-0.1147264689,
-0.1424851418,
0.0129239438,
-0.4186151922,
0.3000806868,
0.7478225231,
-0.1804033667,
-0.2113900632,
-0.3375650048,
0.4209293425,
0.0533146039,
-0.8395537138,
0.3172908723,
0.7305500507,
0.4495671093,
0.1267576367,
0.5583037138,
-0.0385171026,
0.2617673278,
-0.2736778259,
0.1708446145,
-0.6054769754,
-0.3154427409,
-0.3260246217,
0.1358075291,
0.1916683912,
-0.1349028051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14394v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14394v1 | SEC-QA: A Systematic Evaluation Corpus for Financial QA | 2024-06-20T15:12:41 | 2024-06-20T15:12:41 | Viet Dac Lai, Michael Krumdick, Charles Lovering, Varshini Reddy, Craig Schmidt, Chris Tanner | cs.CL | cs.CL | The financial domain frequently deals with large numbers of long documents
that are essential for daily operations. Significant effort is put towards
automating financial data analysis. However, a persistent challenge, not
limited to the finance domain, is the scarcity of datasets that accurately
reflect real-world tasks for model evaluation. Existing datasets are often
constrained by size, context, or relevance to practical applications. Moreover,
LLMs are currently trained on trillions of tokens of text, limiting access to
novel data or documents that models have not encountered during training for
unbiased evaluation. We propose SEC-QA, a continuous dataset generation
framework with two key features: 1) the semi-automatic generation of
Question-Answer (QA) pairs spanning multiple long context financial documents,
which better represent real-world financial scenarios; 2) the ability to
continually refresh the dataset using the most recent public document
collections, not yet ingested by LLMs. Our experiments show that current
retrieval augmented generation methods systematically fail to answer these
challenging multi-document questions. In response, we introduce a QA system
based on program-of-thought that improves the ability to perform complex
information retrieval and quantitative reasoning pipelines, thereby increasing
QA accuracy. | [
-0.2276476026,
-0.6571093202,
0.4817710817,
0.2804053724,
-0.314576447,
0.6134259701,
-0.0360160284,
-0.4555546939,
0.1828801185,
0.4291362464,
-0.4459892809,
-0.5305046439,
-0.0478056893,
0.0960362628,
-0.6689232588,
0.879901886,
0.0509028845,
0.1806269139,
-0.2574430406,
-0.0029998175,
-0.4345061779,
-0.2997234166,
-0.7476670146,
0.1035966501,
0.0548859872,
0.266515106,
0.5437994003,
0.230988428,
0.7727226019,
0.3291637897,
0.2531288266,
0.2587045133,
-0.5382278562,
0.2374854386,
-0.1785970032,
-0.3737779558,
-0.2932116985,
-0.0625888109,
0.6092036963,
0.4385183752,
-0.140437156,
0.5103004575,
-0.1749373823,
0.7877438068,
-0.727453649,
0.2504086196,
-0.3472785652,
-0.1819883138,
-0.0205858853,
-0.3450682163,
-0.1800968051,
-0.682087481,
0.4717159867,
-0.6628350019,
0.1403615475,
0.2204740644,
0.8872211576,
0.1879248917,
-0.5536110401,
-0.5621080995,
-0.789478302,
0.5143316984,
-0.4958096147,
0.2862814367,
0.1044807881,
0.4960286319,
-0.0185943972,
-0.8053194284,
-0.4194600284,
-0.1490393579,
0.1667495072,
0.1651722938,
-0.1668725014,
-0.040766716,
0.3442423046,
0.2834566534,
-0.2929066718,
-0.3299813569,
-0.7244333625,
-0.2224705368,
0.632956624,
0.214975521,
0.0270970929,
-0.0378766172,
-0.4150738418,
-0.4366203845,
-0.7179823518,
0.1201314479,
0.3440872431,
0.1376449466,
0.1151045859,
0.3144516945,
-0.2100735903,
0.41711694,
-0.0638687834,
-0.0887402371,
0.0425173901,
-0.5073248148,
-0.3088821769,
-0.0140628507,
0.4521571696,
0.2010038346,
-0.0804041401,
-0.0008253693,
-0.4748763144,
-0.0991232172,
0.3507072628,
-0.6510435343,
0.0276056789,
0.6473391056,
-0.0692217723,
-0.3712544441,
0.2861683667,
-0.7926200628,
-0.0741002783,
-0.5456059575,
0.2708733082,
-0.3889756501,
0.2321489602,
0.0583391786,
-0.5272544622,
0.476693809,
0.1093268842,
-0.3813219666,
0.2490871102,
0.6670600772,
0.3997668624,
0.1390476376,
0.0546616875,
-0.6216754317,
0.1974501163,
-0.5454242826,
0.8453634977,
-0.5227544904,
-0.3843908012,
-0.0353078395,
-0.3105551898,
-0.0007054519,
-0.4630203545,
0.4566358626,
-0.7987207174,
0.2304243594,
-0.4199997783,
-0.6697176695,
0.1152128801,
0.2383593321,
-0.525681138,
0.9465747476,
0.4703795314,
-0.7883494496,
0.5440500975,
-0.7398030162,
-0.0528782979,
0.1335374564,
-0.3866802156,
-0.3793270588,
-0.1887684911,
0.2606987059,
0.0780051351,
-0.6450145245,
0.4114953279,
-0.4155022204,
-0.6101782918,
0.6180073619,
-0.4195896089,
0.4150891304,
0.2285413742,
-0.2703787386,
0.1579294652,
-0.7471442223,
0.1178997979,
0.0154034998,
-0.166150853,
-0.4373323321,
-0.1845549047,
0.042617254,
0.1027275771,
0.4162187576,
-0.5563017726,
0.0871749818,
-0.4799738824,
0.5541015863,
0.8500651121,
0.2267764509,
0.3053478897,
-0.4528930485,
0.6550384164,
0.0663752705,
0.3495813608,
-0.1943246126,
0.0554684326,
-0.6717019677,
-0.278003186,
0.5930828452,
0.5431630015,
-0.6162139773,
0.4248421788,
-0.1548249125,
-0.4035842419,
-0.3716357946,
0.0918896645,
0.3210208714,
0.4232036471,
0.1121077985,
-0.1174677387,
-0.4607182145,
-1.1526738405,
0.1648357362,
-0.0547028966,
-0.2099825591,
0.2697998881,
0.4441461861,
0.0144987181,
1.1265211105,
-0.7298076749,
0.1291424781,
-0.0725415573,
0.0577764474,
0.1543854922,
0.2959177196,
0.4363375008,
-0.8547878861,
-0.0203242917,
-0.4405361414,
-0.622101903,
0.142512098,
-0.6275795102,
-0.3467090726,
-0.2044528872,
0.3123049736,
-0.3225634694,
0.2790592611,
0.0600453578,
-0.3832490146,
0.5540271401,
-0.2280620039,
0.0929366574,
-1.1241278648,
0.3452708721,
-0.1463723034,
-0.1165494844,
-0.2486835867,
0.1086955518,
0.2937083542,
-0.5389345884,
-0.2337317467,
0.8502149582,
-0.3308256567,
-0.4448272288,
-0.1526379287,
0.6651313901,
0.2515357435,
0.4501031041,
-0.2470629662,
1.07092309,
0.5827587247,
-0.5999308228,
0.4997298121,
0.4701647162,
-0.3811769187,
0.5876817107,
-0.4614938796,
0.0570378564,
-0.0153195374,
0.4660434425,
-0.7095046639,
-0.1124991402,
0.0863729268,
-0.10656064,
0.2277300805,
0.3816863894,
-0.2551295459,
-0.6168935895,
-0.5377006531,
0.3034365177,
0.2029871047,
-0.530146122,
0.400074929,
0.3332433999,
-0.3549923897,
-0.7405272722,
-0.2854657471,
0.1471459568,
-0.0905750915,
-0.7696234584,
0.0627718344,
-0.0015693329,
-0.4861850142,
-0.1416110992,
-0.3969256878,
-0.0051171989,
0.3603572547,
0.1421684474,
0.86742419,
-0.0900561512,
0.4222145975,
0.2806958556,
-0.0770914927,
0.1079628915,
-0.3835138381,
0.181947276,
-0.3563180864,
-0.4607335627,
-0.2898136675,
0.1571226716,
0.3853504956,
-0.3921635449,
0.2401122749,
0.0868165046,
-0.150880143,
-0.4955150485,
-0.4121797681,
-0.1459769905,
-0.5010305047,
0.0699877366,
-0.3433882594,
-0.9516951442,
0.6554971337,
-0.1982200444,
0.3486591578,
0.5837622285,
0.4848796725,
-0.2389463633,
0.3501159251,
0.4839086831,
0.011433674,
0.3689678013,
-0.4280519783,
0.2890988886,
-0.5401213169,
-0.0923529193,
-0.5897249579,
-0.3883039355,
-0.4064458907,
-0.3869269192,
0.539659977,
0.2038591951,
-0.1431497186,
0.3144595623,
-0.3446705341,
0.5299425125,
0.5361489058,
0.1176624298,
0.1625034809,
-0.3162069023,
-0.1684631705,
0.5356272459,
-0.5696828961,
-0.6680952907,
1.4723309278,
0.3989387155,
0.6451430917,
-0.1906453222,
0.6698214412,
0.5130571723,
0.4124322534,
-0.4719856381,
0.3279161453,
0.2178299278,
-0.5693491101,
-0.5355898142,
-0.5503951907,
-0.5533232689,
-0.1290830225,
-0.0141365053,
-0.3033260703,
0.511629343,
-0.1205888614,
-1.0217586756,
-0.1553430706,
-0.5207026601,
0.627599895,
-0.1683656871,
-0.3028429151,
-0.0973631367,
-0.5712056756,
0.6768172383,
-0.6598746777,
0.0587508902,
-0.0647594258,
-0.0751326084,
0.7610159516,
-0.5305172205,
0.6105357409,
-0.0136525491,
-0.3140918612,
0.849229455,
-0.0631145388,
0.6035985947,
0.6409873962,
-0.0798059925,
-0.2197050601,
0.5458687544,
-0.5196829438,
-0.7258319855,
0.4394634366,
-0.4017808437,
-0.3901501,
-0.4738784432,
-0.4573871791,
-0.6211240888,
-0.1314698756,
-0.1647847295,
0.5122221708,
-0.4337387681,
0.1214148179,
0.4244270921,
-0.2741574645,
0.2221223414,
0.5796924233,
-0.1717607528,
-0.4596992433,
0.8029193282,
-0.1334280968,
0.011620691,
0.2326936871,
-0.0712628663,
-0.7137718797,
-0.2965375781,
-0.467048794,
0.1964077204,
-0.6755061746,
-0.3654540479,
-0.2748674452,
-0.1852656454,
-0.4270660877,
-0.2616974711,
-0.1444909275,
-0.6388553977,
-0.2422649413,
-0.3764974773,
0.2244024724,
0.372267127,
-0.1012441516,
-0.0765887499,
-1.2237416506,
0.3686274588,
0.3814898729,
0.3298101723,
-0.1485337168,
-0.2650287747,
-0.3914292157,
-0.0203699265,
-0.2765384316,
-0.6016078591,
0.1663817465,
-0.0447077341,
0.2466942072,
0.4900160432,
0.3014168143,
0.4970869422,
0.2039005607,
0.5166028142,
-0.0463970788,
-0.8114348054,
0.4868044853,
-0.284178257,
0.1816300899,
0.9625684619,
0.1723808348,
-0.4684625566,
-0.7281749845,
-0.8697914481,
-0.7344974875,
0.4878042042,
0.2454462498,
0.1534732431,
-0.2847355902,
0.5182667375,
0.1294498444,
0.4376871884,
0.0179714076,
0.1848696619,
-0.0815310404,
-0.0584639795,
0.3142804503,
-0.2515995502,
-0.281334877,
0.1082773432,
0.8144500256,
-0.4348786473,
0.0286163837,
0.2937224507,
0.1681260318,
-0.0426197127,
0.4752756059,
0.4775073528,
1.2199156284,
-0.4931932092,
-0.2710388303,
0.1790323257,
-0.2704015672,
0.1555478275,
0.1270950437,
-0.3905528188,
-0.0850573629,
0.1017620265,
0.52123487,
0.4301944077,
-1.2582722902,
0.5450220108,
-0.2237386107,
-0.1656024307,
-0.6387255192,
0.0462232605,
0.0551957637,
0.4096167386,
0.6741985679,
-0.1238409206,
0.0826627761,
-0.678806603,
0.6924851537,
0.1248383522,
-0.1800634414,
0.0406869575,
0.3804443479,
0.3806765676,
0.1973695755,
1.0767780542,
-0.0974412337,
-0.3404096067,
0.9584545493,
0.1652752906,
0.9878450632,
0.2597686052,
0.395414263,
0.3636395335,
-0.0149158016,
-0.1196638048,
0.7403056026,
-0.2357170284,
-0.4829775095,
-0.3127585351,
-1.0632522106,
-0.7361528277,
-0.0264350921,
-0.616333127,
0.3235113919,
-0.7000211477,
-0.2493685335,
-0.1866079867,
0.0857855752,
-0.536747396,
0.2939449847,
-0.0534215197,
1.2899316549,
-0.3601842523,
0.4963548779,
0.0992741138,
-0.5648483634,
-0.7584300637,
-0.2088972926,
-0.2795948088,
-0.4938113689,
0.5893546343,
-0.1941753477,
0.1797188371,
-0.2173973322,
-0.4135904014,
-0.8204346895,
1.291973114,
0.3351706266,
-1.0025801659,
-0.3439916074,
0.1258066744,
0.5823661685,
-0.2837589383,
0.1006648019,
0.6925473809,
0.6032368541,
0.3156391084,
-0.5269083977,
-0.0702215806,
-0.1560849398,
-0.2254019976,
0.3075003028,
-0.8587385416,
0.4412847459,
-0.2502173483,
-0.3742882907,
-0.0553721152,
0.9179214835,
0.5464494824,
0.5512940884,
0.2746076882,
0.3230380714,
0.993073225,
-0.1739778966,
1.1052831411,
-0.7785905004,
0.3360175788,
1.2668532133,
-0.3800401092,
0.8712279201,
0.2667441666,
-0.2189105004,
0.0416769385,
0.8868557215,
-0.328579843,
0.0028909289,
0.5534888506,
-0.3875804245,
-0.410081625,
0.0122863073,
-0.1611853838,
0.5153400898,
0.1515855044,
-0.3135435581,
-0.3458401263,
-0.0602656491,
-0.4369372129,
-0.0233371351,
-0.0985288844,
0.5894184709,
0.3139224648,
-0.391646713,
0.092889525,
0.1514181495,
0.2641725242,
-0.8227621317,
0.0942638516,
-0.5326267481,
-0.2259909213,
0.0807110891,
-0.5262964964,
0.4548523128,
0.232163161,
-0.0107905995,
-0.1284382194,
0.7052199244,
-0.0882509723,
-0.6597818732,
-0.059093792,
0.5711097717,
0.066632472,
-0.1280943602,
-0.662678659,
-0.3727162182,
-0.1441951245,
-0.4095928371,
0.3362462819,
0.4658058882,
-0.2959750295,
0.8391113281,
0.9859611988,
-0.1106995195,
-0.1693839878,
0.1084853187,
1.0831103325,
-0.8777332306,
-0.6440364718,
-0.3941545486,
0.1048819125,
-0.077607207,
-0.3389171064,
0.3612031937,
1.0777933598,
0.6252157688,
0.0860072151,
0.800417006,
0.1738084555,
0.5513153672,
-0.5513593554,
0.6431971788,
-0.3206376433,
0.5703495741,
-0.0026638652,
-0.9625606537,
0.066735588,
0.0354303047,
-0.2666122913,
-0.2875216603,
0.6808059216,
0.6665588021,
0.0924036428,
0.371750623,
0.213737309,
-0.0467331521,
0.2852075398,
0.3997634947,
0.7633615732,
-0.5272333622,
0.6297416091,
-0.1804221421,
-0.0562519357,
0.0718863308,
-0.5195872188,
-0.4266779125,
-0.4885237813,
-0.2797024548,
-0.2348528355,
-0.0103679113,
0.9640408754,
0.0524596497,
-0.7766287923,
-0.2204479724,
0.2842203677,
0.0579044819,
-0.1174315661,
-0.246836558,
0.6059797406,
-0.5503562093,
-0.6416802406,
0.6693837643,
0.6054767966,
0.0753490925,
-0.6070827246,
0.1689861268,
0.0661487132,
0.5448009968,
0.3082971275,
0.3102642596,
-0.0225156154,
-0.3298259974,
0.0985503644,
-0.3365888,
-0.1224025488,
0.8774625659,
-0.6695479751,
0.1919835955,
0.5358887911,
0.8974315524,
0.4075758755,
0.3792001307,
0.6529849768,
-0.4180871844,
-0.2777855694,
0.4053298831,
0.2013868541,
-0.1630778164,
-0.3463683724,
0.6006189585,
0.1790282726,
-0.3247331381,
-0.6618295312,
-0.2321422845,
-1.0673933029,
-0.3749067485,
0.754185617,
-0.0832322165,
-0.6499727368,
-0.0612166412,
-0.1237074062,
0.0750986561,
-0.6092275977,
1.0133320093,
0.6917423606,
0.021265367,
0.3010269105,
-0.4487251341,
0.6006114483,
0.1294570565,
-0.9681915045,
0.3254361749,
0.6874426007,
0.2830682099,
0.1505569369,
0.8215882778,
-0.1499951035,
0.6003417969,
0.191223368,
-0.0751400441,
-0.1580482125,
-0.347184211,
-0.1037337258,
0.4916853309,
-0.2106419653,
0.0235782173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14393v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14393v1 | Jailbreaking as a Reward Misspecification Problem | 2024-06-20T15:12:27 | 2024-06-20T15:12:27 | Zhihui Xie, Jiahui Gao, Lei Li, Zhenguo Li, Qi Liu, Lingpeng Kong | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs) has raised concerns
about their safety and reliability, particularly regarding their vulnerability
to adversarial attacks. In this paper, we propose a novel perspective that
attributes this vulnerability to reward misspecification during the alignment
process. We introduce a metric ReGap to quantify the extent of reward
misspecification and demonstrate its effectiveness and robustness in detecting
harmful backdoor prompts. Building upon these insights, we present ReMiss, a
system for automated red teaming that generates adversarial prompts against
various target aligned LLMs. ReMiss achieves state-of-the-art attack success
rates on the AdvBench benchmark while preserving the human readability of the
generated prompts. Detailed analysis highlights the unique advantages brought
by the proposed reward misspecification objective compared to previous methods. | [
-0.1247741729,
-0.4322532415,
0.5035387278,
0.2617559135,
0.1749400347,
0.4223007262,
-0.0709495246,
-0.2145933509,
0.5043019056,
0.3399965763,
-0.9383507967,
-0.4029030502,
-0.8186078668,
0.068498224,
-0.2416554242,
1.1317743063,
-0.2898983359,
-0.4745911658,
0.0449032448,
-0.2319642454,
-1.0193272829,
-0.4991434813,
-0.2668751776,
-0.0480553657,
0.8622427583,
0.583125174,
0.6797990203,
0.6347851753,
0.5850838423,
0.2891312838,
0.1770702899,
0.1685174257,
-0.3500874043,
0.2841078043,
-0.1828740835,
-0.6455490589,
-0.1802574396,
0.4715549946,
0.216906637,
0.2682875395,
-0.3048108518,
0.0689560324,
-0.1181884035,
0.7662442327,
-1.055277586,
-0.3894463181,
-0.6673212647,
0.0994144008,
-0.2224478573,
-0.1710591465,
-0.5899509788,
-0.6050156951,
-0.3057523966,
-0.4038297534,
-0.0299787112,
0.0756519511,
0.870241046,
0.639980197,
0.1593464911,
-0.2114761174,
-0.1569347531,
0.6838398576,
-0.4304504395,
0.1702200323,
0.4303937554,
0.5080144405,
-0.4582554102,
-0.3380384147,
-0.181631729,
-0.3288732469,
-0.1543953121,
-0.2682761848,
-0.3274712265,
-0.3006386161,
0.1751889884,
0.222723648,
-0.5726104975,
0.3878516555,
-0.1363448501,
-0.1544229984,
0.6100801826,
0.4254849553,
0.5512943268,
-0.0506629832,
-0.4970602989,
-0.2318883985,
-0.9126029611,
0.1567200571,
0.631890595,
0.3451761603,
-0.3360529542,
0.6310794353,
0.2773039937,
0.7322496772,
-0.0449943133,
0.103234157,
0.2778549194,
-0.2411577404,
-0.0696743429,
-0.1329664588,
0.7352608442,
0.3202204108,
0.301799953,
-0.5264074206,
-0.3586117923,
0.0147588933,
0.6650387645,
-0.3138324022,
-0.2535139918,
0.3926238716,
-0.2385827452,
-0.6849528551,
0.1527673453,
-0.6322538853,
-0.7356332541,
0.3399589658,
0.0913051218,
-0.4376881123,
0.0374024324,
-0.1865549237,
-0.5113393664,
-0.0221573468,
0.224972114,
-1.0022211075,
-0.1280684173,
0.8128253818,
1.035787344,
-0.1556403339,
-0.6618387699,
-0.8374403715,
0.1060270816,
-0.3148490489,
0.6421602964,
-0.1613638103,
-0.2550880611,
-0.229060024,
0.0083007887,
-0.1339085549,
-0.5211321115,
0.4030806422,
-0.5507833362,
-0.1019742414,
0.0001015285,
-0.3449064493,
0.2772485912,
0.5562405586,
-0.7650485039,
0.2403326631,
0.213872239,
-0.6452044249,
0.6278908849,
-0.3396229148,
-0.4434370697,
0.0993648022,
-0.0484427735,
-0.47364223,
0.0429465435,
0.1643377393,
0.1443559974,
-0.1307149827,
0.3220906854,
-0.2204065472,
-0.3607698977,
0.4350737631,
-0.3442577422,
0.7133800387,
0.2454546541,
-0.4138524234,
0.3831036389,
-0.262708962,
0.0305961929,
0.2262514234,
-0.4644177258,
-0.3383296132,
-0.0372547619,
-0.3025401235,
0.0489009023,
0.3161182702,
-0.6179435849,
0.3466260135,
-0.4363109171,
0.377006501,
1.01623559,
-0.138489455,
0.2384122014,
-0.3616655171,
0.5555568337,
-0.0807483792,
0.1589267254,
-0.2068997324,
-0.2180415541,
-0.2003404796,
-0.7000553012,
0.4732904136,
1.0179097652,
-0.3578137457,
0.7070863247,
-0.0018025188,
-0.75358814,
-0.6934310794,
0.2244692147,
0.7144801021,
0.0141194481,
0.2848696411,
-0.0622065105,
-0.5915945172,
-1.0481308699,
-0.6645428538,
-0.1810455471,
-0.102271609,
0.2854174972,
0.5969459414,
-0.2832291126,
0.7086738944,
-0.5422327518,
-0.3740572929,
-0.2783411443,
0.2030451298,
0.1775976866,
0.6835682392,
0.4366995096,
-0.5956717134,
-0.0859344453,
-0.5755715966,
-0.8550800681,
-0.1863809079,
-0.3034605086,
0.2508262694,
0.1480655968,
0.6049906611,
-0.3668024838,
0.4585888684,
0.6527924538,
-0.710303843,
0.6999197602,
-0.0623524226,
0.349242121,
-0.8031631708,
0.0654461756,
-0.0761554018,
-0.3254108131,
-0.2522530556,
0.3102403581,
0.2342531681,
-0.1093850136,
-0.5389992595,
0.2846460938,
-0.3560444713,
0.0098467087,
-0.275226295,
0.2905095518,
-0.2298626006,
0.2168420404,
-0.2665732503,
0.9158796668,
0.066777125,
-0.3184563518,
0.7542319298,
0.3222592175,
-0.3532927036,
0.4185103178,
-0.7329142094,
-0.1269986331,
0.2692304254,
0.2470935285,
-0.9496437311,
-0.1113589853,
0.4069450498,
-0.7825331688,
0.3594471216,
-0.1536289155,
-0.4554838836,
-0.2837212682,
-0.4576124549,
0.5806918144,
0.2352514118,
-0.7274721861,
0.1206450909,
0.5781232119,
-0.0119683454,
-0.9161853194,
-0.7331990004,
0.3672351837,
-0.4211940765,
-0.8029149175,
0.2647699416,
0.3722930849,
-0.2210770994,
-0.1036649868,
0.1855802536,
0.3088801205,
0.658855319,
0.6108791828,
0.356854558,
0.047539074,
-0.2798931301,
-0.373596549,
-0.2697888613,
0.1493721306,
0.0871465877,
0.4466207325,
-0.0810850784,
-0.410602361,
-0.5539417267,
0.4365162551,
0.5817778111,
-0.1012317091,
1.0793542862,
-0.029472487,
-0.1933887601,
-0.10774865,
-0.4539390504,
-0.1753960401,
-0.4780611694,
0.1487024873,
-0.2676885426,
-0.9266860485,
0.6182401776,
0.0482504405,
0.298301667,
0.1204118878,
0.3781631589,
0.1056061462,
0.7729182243,
0.6141644716,
-0.4435583949,
0.4919867218,
0.2215158343,
0.1230313629,
-0.7630883455,
-0.3229732215,
-0.5785425305,
-0.5234223008,
-0.3645974696,
-0.0891251564,
0.0793474689,
-0.0274932422,
-0.3301488757,
0.6401321888,
-0.3612525165,
0.5845816135,
0.625883162,
-0.0291141178,
-0.0938713774,
-0.3584755659,
-0.0383335836,
-0.2695965767,
-0.548743844,
-0.3972305357,
0.9336581826,
0.4866419733,
1.0802645683,
0.4745688736,
0.9228826165,
0.7072845101,
0.3445145488,
-0.4738607109,
0.2516018152,
0.0287689585,
-0.4413442314,
-0.348133266,
-0.4057231247,
-1.0550760031,
-0.0014177801,
-0.030771492,
-1.0596084595,
0.1996750832,
0.1490954012,
-0.613591969,
0.4287666082,
-0.7838223577,
1.2272548676,
-0.2097559571,
-0.2018072605,
-0.0460653491,
-0.8201045394,
0.6435407996,
-0.0340267047,
0.2772019804,
-0.0743689835,
0.056724567,
0.8393141031,
-0.6559815407,
0.9016206861,
-0.2577520609,
-0.0933955461,
-0.1290805787,
0.3967624605,
0.8290416002,
-0.0020759534,
0.2968745828,
-0.0583453402,
-0.413819164,
-0.3286351562,
-0.6253017783,
0.7190361023,
-0.5656074286,
-0.9924893379,
-0.4393955469,
-0.7436839938,
-0.1057352275,
-0.177724883,
0.1879628748,
-0.1960825026,
-0.1025831774,
-0.2226803899,
0.4221155941,
-0.6174351573,
0.2314201593,
0.4594279826,
0.1135079116,
-0.4006529748,
0.9084894657,
-0.3424659967,
0.4205537736,
0.1241197065,
-0.1629960835,
-0.0723051727,
-0.3765000105,
-0.5932677388,
0.2850949466,
-0.4619753361,
-0.6026231647,
-0.3540415168,
-0.086409308,
-0.5104334354,
-0.7175842524,
-0.5459343791,
-0.3368143439,
-0.0522300377,
-0.192395404,
0.2796183527,
0.5863791108,
-0.5983656049,
0.263725698,
-0.9835681319,
0.216923669,
0.1187704504,
0.1002085283,
-0.1454574019,
-0.7277501225,
-0.3622835279,
-0.1903117299,
-0.1557247788,
-1.1364011765,
0.584589541,
-0.4388881326,
0.5764663815,
0.0644726306,
0.0604171045,
0.5528360009,
-0.5089501143,
0.7883205414,
0.3495801985,
-0.9465079308,
0.9243222475,
-0.0549437776,
-0.1016306579,
0.5810075998,
-0.0492713936,
-0.7139217854,
-0.8186222315,
-0.744813621,
-1.0814141035,
0.7548962235,
-0.0034337775,
-0.2296960801,
-0.0402957387,
0.2019406706,
-0.2017003596,
0.1600314081,
-0.586494863,
-0.3267783225,
-0.0049790656,
-0.1703968346,
-0.1266477704,
-0.2782341838,
-0.3868119717,
0.3709552586,
0.5127180815,
0.3431635499,
0.042672243,
0.0123034883,
-0.3471396267,
-0.1550477594,
0.4637098908,
0.7938815355,
0.2436349392,
-0.3093707263,
0.0965891629,
-0.0774961561,
-0.3045111001,
0.6022405028,
-0.118101798,
0.0020858611,
-0.2328405678,
0.556291461,
0.5145382285,
0.1138293967,
-0.9353708625,
0.8050314188,
-0.1337140352,
-0.0129588721,
-0.2023176104,
0.2147229314,
-0.2871155441,
0.3679924607,
0.2645617723,
0.1054631174,
-0.2672292888,
-0.4604685605,
0.5095880032,
0.6147280931,
-0.4136263728,
0.0582185462,
0.7302535176,
0.2296024114,
-0.5157367587,
0.7870112062,
-0.162034601,
-0.7621862888,
0.7659294605,
0.5161136389,
0.9555757642,
-0.2363010049,
0.1369044781,
0.1086941287,
0.9003360271,
-0.1071659699,
-0.1367845535,
0.2012922764,
-0.7346129417,
-0.2207270265,
-0.2061406672,
-0.2466551811,
-0.1070289984,
-0.592681706,
0.1215707883,
-0.5993587971,
-0.0587734841,
-0.030441016,
-0.5629508495,
-0.0907915533,
-0.045459751,
0.1194020435,
1.1022106409,
-1.1095529795,
0.4035939276,
0.410466522,
-0.392100811,
-0.8214322925,
-0.0561812557,
0.3604009748,
-0.9217802882,
1.063798666,
0.1883156449,
-0.120017603,
-0.340927124,
-0.4902262688,
-0.6073770523,
0.8588033915,
0.3701357543,
-0.4704384804,
-0.0068427399,
-0.2390613258,
-0.0599702895,
-0.392649889,
-0.2845673263,
0.8864648938,
0.4795317948,
-0.1495425999,
-0.863401711,
0.5004071593,
-0.0698440671,
-0.4457903802,
0.6154473424,
-0.3050739467,
0.7945463061,
-0.7368150353,
-0.2258128822,
0.219991371,
0.4714746177,
0.8265188932,
0.1722461134,
0.5275686979,
0.9644907713,
0.7096102834,
-0.1887747347,
1.1348743439,
0.0774037912,
0.1458734125,
1.0643042326,
-0.0281176288,
0.5533648133,
0.7384568453,
-0.0787998363,
0.5163128376,
0.5598935485,
-0.2139845788,
0.7830946445,
0.5783357024,
0.0001762361,
-0.2519839704,
0.1407229155,
-0.3616069853,
0.0669025406,
0.4046052694,
-0.4701299369,
-0.2597852349,
0.0682153776,
0.1457433403,
0.1211619973,
-0.3124362826,
0.6357346773,
-0.0808910131,
-0.7807706594,
0.6238417625,
0.2280730754,
0.8469929099,
-0.556484282,
0.078162238,
-0.1554783881,
0.1833547801,
-0.3140702844,
-0.8899176717,
0.4123333693,
0.3231101036,
-0.2611667216,
-0.0892443657,
0.3287816942,
-0.0491362922,
0.1132737398,
0.2036553472,
0.3297474086,
0.1757965088,
-0.0985823348,
-0.7428823709,
0.1254203469,
0.1692538857,
-0.0671420246,
0.3706776798,
0.2403435707,
0.0214781556,
0.9710220098,
0.558894217,
0.170010373,
0.0233415607,
-0.1243390962,
0.7764052749,
-0.9200850129,
-0.6692532897,
-1.3442820311,
0.4742415547,
-0.0286243279,
-0.2421154678,
0.8434746861,
0.5899783969,
0.4927465916,
0.0575034432,
0.7672178745,
-0.1147965416,
0.5010610223,
-0.5117887259,
0.7595946193,
-0.5241107345,
0.5651033521,
-0.36957708,
-0.1971579194,
-0.3541091979,
0.4972282648,
-0.391084671,
-0.3611830771,
0.5688765049,
0.8260079622,
0.3074491322,
-0.152834639,
0.1611447036,
-0.1445992291,
0.3815000057,
0.9025894403,
1.0769109726,
-0.2675074339,
0.4378712177,
0.3359082043,
-0.4247401357,
-0.3235143721,
-0.6068956256,
-0.6461561322,
-0.2677132785,
-0.2429610938,
-0.7676835656,
0.3451866806,
0.6727771163,
0.3295798004,
-0.8300228119,
-0.0765310451,
0.0087694414,
0.630335927,
-0.2509306371,
-0.2045623064,
0.1552064121,
-0.6130368114,
-0.2150744945,
0.7019864917,
0.2828562558,
0.077465497,
-0.2631986737,
-0.106111899,
-0.1317105293,
-0.1452485174,
-0.0950312838,
0.6872366667,
-0.6560313702,
-0.3651357293,
-0.2434764653,
-0.3658931553,
-0.2015293688,
1.0150549412,
-0.8075918555,
-0.1219651476,
0.1750769913,
0.9456643462,
-0.2941098213,
0.2083149254,
0.9606517553,
-1.0543731451,
0.2467452735,
0.1546687931,
0.4380373657,
0.3083949387,
-0.4574331343,
0.5122443438,
0.3192156851,
-0.6703614593,
-1.1992673874,
0.5053467751,
-0.4736170769,
-0.5102932453,
0.8746170998,
-0.5168690085,
-0.485843122,
-0.1325560808,
0.1553849578,
-0.0017072234,
-0.5710177422,
0.9605430365,
0.6275889874,
0.1725473702,
-0.0385954231,
-0.1027065367,
0.5538620949,
0.5235402584,
-0.6672635078,
0.5738335848,
0.5886188745,
0.223268494,
0.4090828001,
0.1836684495,
-0.0924282074,
0.6300780177,
0.0686115324,
-0.0045495136,
-0.3939635754,
-0.3775154948,
-0.3813144863,
0.3048609495,
0.0681830347,
-0.5766048431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14373v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14373v2 | Artificial Leviathan: Exploring Social Evolution of LLM Agents Through the Lens of Hobbesian Social Contract Theory | 2024-06-20T14:42:58 | 2024-07-01T22:06:13 | Gordon Dai, Weijia Zhang, Jinhan Li, Siqi Yang, Chidera Onochie lbe, Srihas Rao, Arthur Caetano, Misha Sra | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.MA | The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) and advancements in Artificial
Intelligence (AI) offer an opportunity for computational social science
research at scale. Building upon prior explorations of LLM agent design, our
work introduces a simulated agent society where complex social relationships
dynamically form and evolve over time. Agents are imbued with psychological
drives and placed in a sandbox survival environment. We conduct an evaluation
of the agent society through the lens of Thomas Hobbes's seminal Social
Contract Theory (SCT). We analyze whether, as the theory postulates, agents
seek to escape a brutish "state of nature" by surrendering rights to an
absolute sovereign in exchange for order and security. Our experiments unveil
an alignment: Initially, agents engage in unrestrained conflict, mirroring
Hobbes's depiction of the state of nature. However, as the simulation
progresses, social contracts emerge, leading to the authorization of an
absolute sovereign and the establishment of a peaceful commonwealth founded on
mutual cooperation. This congruence between our LLM agent society's
evolutionary trajectory and Hobbes's theoretical account indicates LLMs'
capability to model intricate social dynamics and potentially replicate forces
that shape human societies. By enabling such insights into group behavior and
emergent societal phenomena, LLM-driven multi-agent simulations, while unable
to simulate all the nuances of human behavior, may hold potential for advancing
our understanding of social structures, group dynamics, and complex human
systems. | [
-0.495958358,
-0.8892123103,
0.5320648551,
-0.1480183154,
-0.0325357765,
0.7882114649,
-0.0055043059,
-0.4268830121,
0.6796811223,
0.5278712511,
-0.3246999979,
0.0034146898,
-0.3374805152,
0.0781137198,
-0.2743085027,
0.9655722976,
0.2846416533,
-0.1989874542,
-0.2199027687,
-0.0667326674,
0.3475307822,
-0.3660447598,
-0.8566126823,
-0.8029665947,
0.536529541,
-0.3096854389,
0.8827497363,
0.9010170698,
0.1926153004,
0.4334964752,
-0.4236139357,
0.286154151,
-0.5465724468,
0.1541475505,
-0.4951336682,
-0.2297232896,
-0.3309502006,
0.0485097095,
0.562273562,
0.4916427732,
-0.2973656654,
0.1784057915,
-0.0025847121,
0.4912557602,
-0.2466928214,
0.2825553715,
-0.7036773562,
-0.0623923726,
-0.102098003,
-0.2393883616,
-0.1843173355,
-0.4728788733,
0.2533842623,
-0.5373244882,
-0.0131418547,
0.3562568128,
0.5932280421,
0.3918678164,
-0.4818667769,
-0.1198620051,
-0.643204093,
0.2862701118,
-0.2704996169,
-0.0205348879,
0.1139682159,
0.2384329438,
-0.554933548,
-0.724324286,
-0.7052849531,
-0.7004672885,
0.2719175816,
0.3650376797,
0.0731298774,
0.0098567456,
-0.0175903514,
0.0937317461,
-0.4988680184,
-0.0089126015,
-0.5706620216,
-0.0684987232,
0.7401345968,
0.3074879944,
0.4491024613,
-0.1343310326,
-0.4565578401,
-0.0590279512,
-0.4518927336,
0.342613399,
0.6127482057,
0.1062015519,
-0.4335686862,
0.4336364865,
0.3004178107,
0.1879123002,
0.1533225328,
0.429317683,
-0.0105610751,
0.2184995562,
0.0664850771,
0.2059143484,
0.565748632,
0.0901141763,
0.4247023165,
-0.3469994366,
-0.2215122133,
0.3794561625,
0.7283149958,
-0.4268011153,
0.075655207,
0.1800929457,
-0.4120004773,
-0.6786850691,
-0.0118586877,
-0.799405694,
-0.8953261971,
-0.3291408718,
0.1955822855,
-0.0891615152,
-0.5212900639,
-0.0081916563,
-0.3328332007,
0.5876334906,
0.1284700036,
-0.6804643869,
0.4582436681,
0.7276270986,
0.710729301,
-0.327603519,
-0.7076618671,
0.0100855483,
0.4581656158,
-0.4756725729,
0.7593664527,
-0.3282316625,
-0.5059092045,
0.1573848426,
0.0733752921,
0.1863700002,
-0.2836502194,
-0.2610199749,
-0.7868958116,
-0.5033993721,
0.046200417,
-0.3322808743,
0.0838060975,
0.4136903286,
-0.5934870243,
0.7253964543,
0.1153143272,
-0.2265088856,
-0.0339819081,
-1.3295595646,
-0.2900882065,
0.5594581962,
-0.2532913089,
-0.0450308211,
0.2182134241,
-0.688368082,
0.2378145307,
-0.4957882762,
0.3467794955,
-0.8070119619,
-0.411008954,
0.63493222,
-0.1096524149,
0.9501556158,
0.1933945417,
-0.5087655783,
-0.0044307304,
-0.2201542854,
-0.0582315363,
0.5051172972,
-0.2827941775,
-0.1486828774,
0.3229875863,
-0.3984925747,
-0.0902537629,
0.4734861553,
-0.4649519324,
0.2183859199,
-0.4003719687,
0.8505933285,
1.2594017982,
0.2709713578,
0.6511275768,
-0.6645590067,
0.3969994783,
-0.251024574,
0.4969661534,
0.4821700454,
-0.2174779326,
-0.5177611709,
0.1424792707,
0.0795402527,
0.4326304197,
-0.9715316296,
0.1528264135,
-0.2846490741,
-0.4765917957,
-0.3441879451,
-0.2371034771,
0.1845879555,
-0.4905569851,
0.0210311897,
-0.1198169366,
-0.200948298,
-0.8500406146,
-0.4410926402,
-0.4300202429,
0.3104509711,
0.2595454454,
0.792720139,
-0.6682526469,
1.006444931,
-0.2050936222,
0.3485682607,
-0.124794282,
-0.0948997736,
-0.0622889586,
0.3908834755,
0.4195959568,
-0.9345833659,
-0.2933073938,
0.439514488,
-0.7913150787,
0.2231360078,
0.0622658692,
-0.2865344584,
-0.0422531106,
0.3222641945,
-0.5615825653,
0.4227208793,
0.3697605431,
-0.4452299178,
0.5408973098,
-0.3876978755,
0.0095574148,
-1.1490982771,
-0.2972791195,
-0.1887102127,
-0.0069153444,
-0.6301190853,
0.1382807642,
-0.1764299572,
0.0101344101,
-0.5058759451,
0.6744455099,
-0.4444255829,
-0.2223621905,
-0.2268542647,
0.345377326,
-0.2733221054,
0.497295171,
-0.5383781195,
0.6911758184,
0.381131798,
-0.8298137188,
0.5392202735,
0.0390662365,
0.0358674116,
0.4898977876,
-0.5632687211,
0.4243194759,
-0.389757961,
0.1005360112,
-0.5718330741,
-0.3753387034,
0.0036454883,
-0.4235828519,
0.0752070844,
0.2092404813,
-0.3645779192,
-0.3888406157,
-0.4068700075,
0.3725132942,
0.6264452934,
-0.2370539606,
1.0264523029,
0.7477846146,
-0.0774789527,
-0.2922389805,
-0.5128703117,
0.2330137044,
-0.3110891879,
-0.3877369165,
0.2770672143,
-0.3022392988,
-0.8506871462,
0.1713000387,
0.0022392629,
-0.0154007562,
0.1178407818,
0.4126772583,
0.2068245262,
0.0393852256,
-0.1840818226,
0.2815995812,
0.0853855014,
0.3682404459,
-0.3198746741,
0.6349721551,
-0.4620942175,
-0.1014562249,
-0.1114142165,
0.1293302476,
0.9527009726,
-0.0390070118,
0.6693392992,
0.0488537103,
-0.4695381522,
-0.4503484666,
-0.3542589843,
-0.0466104522,
-0.5347521901,
0.2306148708,
-0.2583870292,
-0.6454027891,
0.7981883883,
-0.4883048534,
0.1575044394,
0.3647866547,
0.5155975819,
-0.1168420315,
0.4637721181,
0.5459281802,
0.251265496,
0.6124240756,
-0.4839886129,
-0.1602218896,
-0.9423961043,
-0.3514969647,
-0.2460044771,
-0.2699182034,
-0.7486410141,
-0.0969277844,
0.483615905,
-0.3818600178,
-0.4665472507,
0.3960042,
-0.5339127183,
0.7272486687,
0.1600190699,
0.2607477903,
-0.1423666179,
-0.1048770472,
-0.1307223439,
0.4500350058,
-0.4062783718,
-0.7269331813,
0.9228732586,
0.1061083376,
0.5188199878,
0.3898104429,
0.7935654521,
1.0283931494,
0.6587867141,
-0.3534854054,
0.6875163317,
0.0762621164,
-0.7929176092,
-0.4634123743,
-0.3297472,
-1.3943589926,
0.3690080345,
-0.1915058345,
-0.8231812716,
0.2739872634,
-0.1266995519,
-0.4329693615,
0.2110640705,
-0.4729070365,
0.6587995291,
-0.2187469453,
-0.6475981474,
-0.2604084015,
-0.7283187509,
0.2869701087,
-0.0706941336,
0.4484072924,
-0.1502786279,
-0.1536245793,
0.6262268424,
-0.0688150376,
0.939465344,
0.0173044913,
-0.2204259336,
0.5048373938,
0.342328012,
0.7137070894,
0.0868500918,
-0.356672287,
0.003190153,
0.2581835389,
-0.4582978189,
-0.5129053593,
0.6968508959,
-1.2030869722,
-0.4952614307,
-0.3204799294,
-0.5600174665,
0.2474637181,
0.0575091541,
0.021710299,
0.2646444142,
-0.3365537822,
0.1500534713,
0.6200637817,
-0.0058741658,
0.6779615879,
0.3975529671,
-0.1325833052,
-0.8216007948,
0.7617365122,
0.3824672699,
0.4046797752,
-0.19013758,
0.3293010592,
-0.3935299516,
-0.3480107188,
-0.2201948017,
0.191802457,
-0.6002907157,
-0.0085062459,
-0.3893345296,
-0.226791665,
-0.2645303607,
-0.5012229681,
-0.2762076259,
0.2276411057,
-0.0344230756,
0.1334700435,
0.229797557,
1.1984208822,
-0.0471159816,
0.4334173203,
-0.3290655911,
0.2746077478,
0.2581925392,
0.0857474878,
-0.0962661505,
-0.4069972932,
-0.2972690761,
0.1623508334,
-0.3875687718,
-1.1909450293,
0.1089605242,
-0.1769531518,
0.6894314289,
0.3532311916,
0.3969717026,
0.5841742754,
-0.460442394,
0.830652833,
0.0323318504,
-0.9158553481,
0.0965960175,
-0.651304841,
-0.1261277199,
0.1205174923,
-0.0197624415,
-0.2543587089,
-0.4263162017,
-0.9586213827,
-0.7066832185,
0.3827537894,
0.1828515232,
0.3209556043,
0.0579658821,
0.9612955451,
-0.0141646136,
0.3432005942,
-1.0267705917,
-0.3033486903,
0.0360904112,
-0.1373544335,
-0.1094370931,
0.0314732678,
-0.3123834133,
-0.1159675419,
0.4095771313,
-0.1864954978,
0.3131933808,
0.229559198,
0.0646243989,
-0.2322394401,
0.1184977666,
0.7115239501,
0.7223957181,
0.3759918511,
0.3488637209,
0.4080632031,
-0.476803124,
0.6457795501,
-0.1069954112,
-0.1238298938,
-0.4755482674,
0.0442630798,
0.5470235944,
-0.0703471303,
-0.4087051451,
0.2325195372,
0.138355583,
-0.4371678233,
-0.9288985729,
0.2371228635,
0.0291862991,
1.0300338268,
0.5068089366,
0.0283603352,
-0.0992578566,
-0.767209053,
0.066892378,
0.6057488918,
-0.0693019331,
-0.4110699892,
0.6914181113,
0.0136597054,
-1.1942052841,
-0.0795408189,
-0.6706787944,
-0.4369884133,
0.9727550149,
0.6058125496,
0.9824846387,
-0.2365240753,
0.3708600998,
-0.3368910551,
0.7227697968,
-0.1275513768,
0.0349175632,
-0.0466945097,
-0.7201592922,
-0.2116217464,
-0.6155890226,
-0.6166750789,
0.0285957754,
-0.4682605863,
0.0162214693,
-0.6276270747,
-0.4644708931,
-0.1148183122,
0.1670986861,
-0.3465951979,
-0.3827723265,
0.0878409967,
0.5466607809,
-0.4319861829,
0.5875880718,
0.9594294429,
-0.0008604623,
-0.4463487267,
0.2159584016,
-0.0736880079,
-0.8163993359,
0.3214943111,
0.0717282221,
-0.3972925842,
0.4460062683,
-0.9384132624,
-0.8604969382,
1.2913722992,
0.6129842997,
-0.0523143075,
-0.0144091351,
0.0286258254,
0.5923017859,
-0.4923838675,
-0.2067629695,
0.5493573546,
0.6173231006,
-0.1645948589,
-0.4786623418,
0.0510894656,
-0.3719272017,
0.2681016028,
0.3317506909,
-0.9373922348,
0.8891535401,
-0.1731917858,
-0.0915145501,
0.1535178423,
0.5344480872,
0.2834296823,
0.6017127037,
0.5075063109,
0.0266053937,
0.4858076274,
0.1297387183,
0.9181784987,
-0.3855460882,
0.4663501084,
0.3531117737,
-0.6576673388,
0.4011746943,
0.4986103177,
-0.2439810783,
0.6401821971,
0.7745158672,
0.1058659181,
0.2506481707,
0.7503034472,
-0.2442285717,
-0.1125202328,
-0.1377521604,
-0.0757520571,
0.410402,
0.3557736874,
0.1677335948,
-0.003348683,
-0.0221164171,
-0.4499469101,
0.0094895922,
-0.3866887689,
0.9056206942,
0.1069111079,
-0.363309294,
0.2385067195,
-0.421566993,
0.3445585668,
-0.5603469014,
0.139103204,
-0.0548414513,
0.0494913533,
0.0335090868,
-0.3412125707,
0.0229882877,
-0.2952234149,
0.024307115,
-0.0987922624,
0.3623732924,
-0.1192702502,
0.1190102175,
0.5076022744,
0.4820087552,
0.4416654706,
0.4346739054,
-0.7920472026,
0.1438946873,
-0.3671221435,
-0.5905460715,
0.2970278263,
0.7066532373,
0.024098115,
0.8267830014,
0.7601969838,
0.1671972126,
0.11033912,
-0.5730032325,
0.8085290194,
-0.806650281,
-0.6336294413,
-1.3148883581,
0.501616478,
-0.4096236229,
-0.1001718044,
0.2113294452,
0.2221387327,
0.3420715332,
-0.0551538281,
0.7243612409,
-0.0585610159,
-0.2263441831,
-0.2823939919,
1.0341200829,
-0.5286101103,
-0.013773649,
-0.1137638912,
-0.935092926,
0.0903433338,
0.3961174488,
-0.233079657,
-0.1252549142,
0.7589716315,
0.5972870588,
0.3152545989,
-0.0937021971,
0.3674681187,
0.2703209817,
0.2552582026,
0.1683132648,
1.328954339,
0.0909408852,
0.2811962664,
0.3720206916,
-0.2681577802,
-0.1373628378,
-0.5016798973,
-0.8870141506,
-0.5829011202,
-0.188653633,
-0.5185669065,
0.1297613084,
1.333334446,
0.3901303709,
-0.1825746894,
-0.6830976009,
-0.0492658503,
0.2361756563,
-0.0838634521,
-0.2736555636,
-0.031966541,
-0.1828977168,
-0.6109669805,
0.3487925828,
0.4428001642,
0.6403546333,
-0.6666580439,
-0.450648427,
0.066581443,
0.616549015,
0.5610747933,
0.3438917696,
-0.8554677367,
-0.2349197716,
-0.1230368614,
-0.2065384239,
-0.3770927787,
0.7473201156,
-0.3083889484,
0.0122263068,
-0.0456799604,
0.7432397008,
0.2825404406,
-0.2803449333,
0.4156548083,
-0.1421239674,
0.23602359,
0.29817909,
0.2886137068,
-0.2049254924,
-0.5063784719,
0.5596253872,
0.3723539412,
-0.8756340742,
-1.2646598816,
0.2924099267,
-0.844899714,
-0.3190947175,
0.9992797375,
0.2152795196,
-0.7661091089,
-0.2938612998,
-0.0960082337,
0.4607508779,
-0.4261048138,
1.0997275114,
0.52408427,
-0.330232501,
-0.0260119289,
-0.7859633565,
0.4540454447,
0.0590813868,
-1.0204668045,
-0.0021188965,
0.1499037147,
0.0139780017,
0.5774871111,
0.5344993472,
0.2160195112,
0.1589029431,
0.1075021103,
0.2245911807,
-0.116516754,
-0.2778217196,
-0.2070918828,
0.3423018456,
-0.1558478773,
-0.0767269507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16953v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16953v1 | Validation of a new, minimally-invasive, software smartphone device to predict sleep apnea and its severity: transversal study | 2024-06-20T14:36:15 | 2024-06-20T14:36:15 | Justine Frija, Juliette Millet, Emilie Bequignon, Ala Covali, Guillaume Cathelain, Josselin Houenou, Helene Benzaquen, Pierre Alexis Geoffroy, Emmanuel Bacry, Mathieu Grajoszex, Marie-Pia d Ortho | eess.SP | eess.SP, cs.CL | Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is frequent and responsible for cardiovascular
complications and excessive daytime sleepiness. It is underdiagnosed due to the
difficulty to access the gold standard for diagnosis, polysomnography (PSG).
Alternative methods using smartphone sensors could be useful to increase
diagnosis. The objective is to assess the performances of Apneal, an
application that records the sound using a smartphone's microphone and
movements thanks to a smartphone's accelerometer and gyroscope, to estimate
patients' AHI. In this article, we perform a monocentric proof-of-concept study
with a first manual scoring step, and then an automatic detection of
respiratory events from the recorded signals using a sequential deep-learning
model which was released internally at Apneal at the end of 2022 (version 0.1
of Apneal automatic scoring of respiratory events), in adult patients during
in-hospital polysomnography.46 patients (women 34 per cent, mean BMI 28.7 kg
per m2) were included. For AHI superior to 15, sensitivity of manual scoring
was 0.91, and positive predictive value (PPV) 0.89. For AHI superior to 30,
sensitivity was 0.85, PPV 0.94. We obtained an AUC-ROC of 0.85 and an AUC-PR of
0.94 for the identification of AHI superior to 15, and AUC-ROC of 0.95 and
AUC-PR of 0.93 for AHI superior to 30. Promising results are obtained for the
automatic annotations of events.This article shows that manual scoring of
smartphone-based signals is possible and accurate compared to PSG-based
scorings. Automatic scoring method based on a deep learning model provides
promising results. A larger multicentric validation study, involving subjects
with different SAHS severity is required to confirm these results. | [
-0.3977591097,
-0.455521971,
0.5046805143,
-0.1353164017,
-0.5093412399,
-0.2057684809,
-0.0045451568,
-0.5315634608,
0.5634877682,
0.13453269,
-0.8459163904,
-0.4930886328,
-0.4889946282,
-0.0114204269,
-0.1555864364,
0.5716177821,
-0.0762613565,
0.1777439862,
0.115492247,
-0.3466977775,
-0.2964145243,
-0.5249830484,
-0.2405632436,
-0.2721534073,
0.1604986638,
0.2082036585,
0.4951300621,
0.1432228237,
0.6292191148,
0.1042902321,
-0.0163783263,
0.1055572182,
0.1735469997,
-0.0341561697,
0.7747080922,
-0.1356915981,
-0.5275327563,
0.0878265798,
0.6086850762,
0.7593885064,
-0.3890808225,
0.7321488261,
-0.0932730511,
0.7773799896,
-0.6891263127,
-0.2554403841,
-0.0043917284,
0.4671880007,
-0.2788183391,
0.1054187417,
-0.4079066217,
-0.4185816944,
0.2618891001,
-0.3454794884,
-0.0314481631,
-0.1694294512,
0.5797556043,
0.5611011982,
-0.4412095547,
-0.4853240252,
-1.1201313734,
0.5842368603,
-0.6488714814,
0.6157126427,
0.0503377467,
0.48559618,
0.1320371479,
-0.3819320798,
-0.3224259019,
-0.2987388074,
0.1152201891,
0.044539243,
-0.0262501407,
0.0486106053,
0.1718903333,
0.4216256738,
-0.877750814,
-0.2183293253,
-0.7010709643,
-0.4318481088,
1.0622817278,
0.1390835494,
0.3368593454,
-0.1666469574,
-0.319532156,
0.5594447255,
-0.399859041,
0.2392837554,
0.1697071642,
0.2555660903,
-0.3354027867,
0.6052201986,
-0.3023291826,
0.7635776997,
0.1406670213,
-0.4614043832,
0.6419932246,
-0.4256877303,
-0.1572199911,
0.8491866589,
0.6987727284,
0.0617488027,
-0.206764549,
0.084682554,
0.1237835363,
0.3283785582,
0.1828486472,
-0.4343067408,
-0.0958787203,
0.4304977059,
-0.7925152183,
-0.3292300701,
-0.0074162814,
-0.43275401,
-0.5052176118,
-0.3468329608,
0.3202781379,
-0.2613034844,
-0.2002676427,
0.3639888167,
0.1826225966,
0.0760544091,
0.3740699887,
-0.302610606,
0.2823296785,
0.1529075205,
1.0122689009,
-0.1952444166,
-0.1839432716,
-0.306351006,
-0.4588629305,
-0.3693296611,
0.6830080748,
0.0242681503,
-0.5636953712,
-0.2790539265,
-0.3041358888,
-0.406046927,
-0.2182783931,
1.1119304895,
-0.108001247,
0.1292745024,
0.0078458833,
-0.3430796564,
-0.1644535959,
-0.1831822097,
-0.6528121233,
0.7815336585,
-0.0304677784,
-0.3310873806,
0.3299174011,
-0.573505342,
-0.7195321918,
0.0189289004,
0.1571623236,
-0.6653990149,
0.0695314929,
-0.0342933163,
0.1447909027,
-0.0729164779,
-0.0182936117,
-0.2609916925,
-0.2258814722,
0.2170845866,
-0.3059745133,
0.6662587523,
0.3182759285,
-0.2186959088,
-0.1879765093,
-0.7595937252,
0.0985924527,
-0.2259149849,
-0.2496230304,
-0.0184831247,
-0.1201504394,
-0.3739275932,
0.3103221357,
0.0524223968,
-1.0551685095,
-0.1187077835,
0.192896232,
0.3215589225,
0.2084070891,
0.1962210834,
0.1645395011,
-0.4257441163,
0.5139666796,
-0.2519966364,
0.803217113,
-0.0192245431,
-0.8891299367,
-0.1831106097,
-0.3155054748,
0.4137077332,
0.4288742542,
0.0564520955,
0.7641713619,
-0.164524883,
-0.6563914418,
-0.7249209285,
0.0853939801,
0.3200274408,
0.7716189623,
0.0725443512,
-0.3834067583,
-0.7780441046,
-0.3164615333,
-0.2358101755,
-0.1337559968,
0.0855890736,
0.4392691553,
0.2315648645,
-0.3814466298,
0.487467736,
-0.6018722057,
-0.8828536272,
-0.1564548314,
0.3317270875,
0.0482228398,
0.3534907103,
0.1982078552,
-0.6576830149,
-0.456705153,
0.0306526907,
-0.8102483749,
-0.0850438401,
0.0917734578,
0.2461466789,
0.1497468352,
0.3636160791,
-0.5975773335,
0.8514004946,
0.5181888342,
-0.2702131867,
0.5931805372,
-0.0083155483,
-0.0438788198,
-0.3581086695,
-0.0038032127,
0.2884471118,
-0.2019459009,
-0.4928820431,
-0.1193197817,
-0.0757066756,
-0.5058632493,
-0.3486156762,
0.2430946827,
-0.1377958357,
0.0161963739,
-0.3957875669,
-0.1507158577,
-0.0452625193,
0.1188976839,
0.296957463,
0.1482972801,
0.2439731658,
-0.8246605396,
0.4351234436,
-0.0623836257,
-0.4254015982,
0.1970799714,
-0.6115428209,
0.0137132313,
0.1404155344,
0.5096161366,
-1.0805671215,
-0.2440550923,
-0.0118371462,
-0.8762090802,
-0.1479744911,
-0.0419136696,
0.1988168061,
-0.6173935533,
-0.3427010775,
0.5606696606,
0.4466663897,
-0.238627404,
1.1309783459,
0.6658895016,
-0.3296106756,
-0.256465584,
-0.4804647863,
-0.2294284999,
0.078400664,
-0.4438171983,
0.1296245456,
0.1212135851,
-0.0311186146,
-0.0786418393,
-0.4026019275,
0.2138459384,
-0.0208130907,
0.5660542846,
0.5445964336,
-0.2951139808,
0.2991621196,
0.0413711257,
-0.1784621328,
0.0555716641,
-0.1564945281,
0.4142952561,
-0.4486360848,
-0.4344573319,
-1.1758122444,
0.0754040778,
0.7763403058,
-0.1006975845,
0.123989813,
0.3385521173,
-1.0351873636,
0.0953130051,
-0.5763617158,
0.1411294341,
-0.3349106908,
-0.1749408245,
-0.4683181047,
0.0034976497,
0.6725912094,
-0.245133549,
-0.1224495843,
0.2941710651,
0.3647290766,
-0.140384227,
1.2630636692,
0.2879924178,
-0.0207717977,
0.2380944788,
-0.2014929056,
0.3200953603,
-1.1655560732,
-0.422299087,
-0.6419927478,
-0.3002402484,
-0.3476051092,
-0.0288409702,
0.7913155556,
-0.076658465,
-0.1967252642,
0.0856666937,
-0.5698811412,
0.1633087993,
0.2434777766,
0.6678514481,
0.3311864138,
-0.4251682758,
-0.1245789826,
0.1669312567,
-0.3763051629,
-0.3802669048,
1.4775369167,
0.3248815536,
0.7466195226,
-0.0033881154,
0.8189693093,
0.6443014145,
0.1326807141,
-0.9182940722,
0.3434584737,
-0.3536750376,
-0.5017952919,
-0.5156999826,
-0.1383848488,
-0.6469691396,
0.0814631134,
-0.1156761646,
-0.5431225896,
0.6402617693,
0.1041615456,
-1.1178239584,
0.0070499294,
-1.0229586363,
0.692815721,
-0.5257020593,
-0.1247040406,
0.0213742983,
-0.5174720287,
0.2416121662,
-0.0949588865,
0.3858297765,
-0.2087475657,
-0.0773543566,
0.712502718,
-0.378021121,
0.8122897148,
-0.4564179182,
0.0863496885,
0.3394035399,
-0.0157642141,
0.2569309175,
0.1253720969,
-0.4163644314,
0.179708913,
-0.0399395004,
-0.2358797342,
-0.3843236268,
0.6593452096,
-0.6783185601,
0.07312686,
-0.6154091954,
0.0540408194,
-0.0827716887,
0.2957545817,
0.4689474702,
0.4940653145,
-0.2993667722,
-0.0209307969,
0.6511402726,
0.1871646941,
0.0880496055,
0.2234864384,
0.0454039201,
-0.3086708486,
0.7246705294,
0.1653916538,
-0.1670177281,
0.0342815109,
0.7059592009,
-0.5828533173,
-0.5151877403,
-0.6327594519,
0.069509916,
-0.2919570208,
-0.3121969402,
-0.4761723578,
-0.3808081448,
-0.3644572198,
0.0319687948,
-0.5031100512,
-0.3905299604,
0.0740981176,
-0.3126168251,
-0.195999831,
0.4457592666,
-0.1153175533,
0.0835356414,
-0.5886970162,
0.6853753924,
0.3386164308,
0.2040891796,
-0.1840908229,
-0.3134978414,
0.0241750088,
0.2694730461,
-0.3143223226,
-0.5383044481,
0.0829449445,
0.4465665817,
0.3245679438,
0.4923076332,
0.4897347689,
0.633447051,
-0.2051578164,
0.8638911843,
0.4436625838,
-1.2920073271,
1.0604226589,
0.0713607222,
0.181273222,
0.618252635,
0.4984451234,
-0.4213559031,
0.0736893937,
-0.6150369048,
-0.5632149577,
0.6754366159,
0.0486322828,
-0.2502225339,
0.5126005411,
0.5723288655,
0.171771735,
0.2011097521,
-0.8058220744,
-0.111598298,
-0.243737191,
-0.2801706791,
-0.0825618356,
0.1118708998,
0.0025131663,
-0.675701201,
0.6139740944,
-0.1049222052,
0.2811352015,
0.877892077,
-0.1044955477,
-0.5510726571,
-0.1025151759,
0.5911219716,
0.6055124402,
-0.4437388182,
0.0370747596,
0.0482655391,
-0.8116329908,
0.2228971869,
0.1635242999,
-0.2615147531,
0.4790906012,
0.3088202775,
0.7428416014,
-0.3033128679,
-0.6688866019,
0.6580909491,
-0.247811377,
-0.2677771747,
-0.6696425676,
-0.2375881076,
-0.347441256,
-0.2899803817,
0.4357488453,
0.551885128,
0.4648330808,
-0.5746942163,
0.1127954945,
0.3476906121,
-0.6172494292,
-0.2889229059,
0.4682364762,
0.4460465908,
-0.3945287168,
0.1493204236,
-0.4441129863,
-0.4423660338,
0.6602951288,
-0.0274910536,
0.7125613093,
-0.9111778736,
0.3293993175,
0.5127460957,
0.4040956795,
-0.1039734185,
0.5656810403,
-0.2030037493,
-0.5097065568,
-0.1383977681,
-0.530993104,
-0.4919045568,
0.0601403639,
-0.8726713657,
0.3565360904,
-0.446586132,
-0.482422471,
0.6243311763,
0.3923770487,
-0.2482032776,
0.4405309856,
0.5337877274,
0.6232430339,
-0.8347748518,
0.5940949917,
0.8371558189,
-0.0282968432,
-0.5751667023,
0.2817167342,
0.2962523103,
-0.5848444104,
0.1333986968,
0.2165339291,
-0.5500016212,
-0.4028164446,
0.0534321107,
-0.5708645582,
0.9295658469,
0.1714154929,
-0.6439864635,
-0.0242841244,
0.2883800566,
0.6298258305,
-0.3225556612,
0.1606785059,
0.4365406632,
0.1538764387,
0.0492727645,
-1.3923331499,
0.1687675864,
-0.2008164227,
-0.1338643581,
0.3152579069,
-0.6002497077,
0.4039852917,
-0.6840378642,
-0.3564299941,
0.1393750012,
0.1455043405,
0.0709831789,
1.089648962,
0.4621302187,
0.5662329793,
1.1739879847,
0.091041401,
1.0590405464,
-0.330665946,
0.2205174267,
0.7979866862,
-0.5529119372,
0.8934208751,
0.1252573282,
-0.0939228684,
0.7289280295,
0.5848537683,
0.5012357831,
0.5515376329,
0.1601954103,
-0.5155488253,
-0.0887141973,
-0.1010333896,
-0.6451332569,
0.4657989442,
0.6293792725,
-0.2325103432,
-0.089420706,
0.7422771454,
-0.6191706061,
-0.1344654858,
-0.2982885242,
0.9532700181,
0.1376640797,
-0.5986675024,
0.7831041813,
-0.0613478087,
0.6163086891,
-0.6419650316,
0.3717363775,
0.1073346809,
0.4662019014,
-0.5312257409,
-0.2593786418,
0.4634273052,
-0.1881575435,
0.042679254,
0.073823832,
0.8164252043,
0.0649537072,
-0.578445971,
0.0704378709,
0.3359068036,
-0.1213806868,
-0.2056564391,
-0.4911196828,
0.1650419682,
-0.1596257389,
0.1014177948,
0.0656484812,
0.278532654,
0.183839947,
0.7236014009,
0.6233484149,
0.241874367,
0.1520514041,
-0.154253304,
0.4621219933,
-0.4950890541,
-0.6565369368,
-0.430614084,
0.2464636117,
0.0427437909,
-0.6348803043,
0.3253787458,
0.7454431653,
0.5360361934,
0.1796278954,
0.8444640636,
0.0420662202,
0.7893792391,
-0.3534360528,
0.4061803222,
-0.4086594284,
0.3663803041,
0.0150451493,
-0.2475576848,
-0.3024039567,
0.8043833971,
-0.4344681203,
-0.3160991967,
0.758711338,
0.2310388535,
-0.1353724301,
0.5894508958,
-0.1350734681,
-0.0940326154,
-0.0513070747,
0.4639056921,
0.7771443725,
-0.7896507382,
0.4705999494,
-0.6811854839,
-0.7116295099,
-0.4338964224,
-0.3677556813,
-0.3814320862,
-0.5230832696,
-0.8406484127,
-0.3729420602,
0.464994669,
0.7727491856,
1.0592525005,
-0.5776177049,
-0.1489858478,
-0.2318533361,
0.2384847701,
-0.6646556854,
-0.1259402186,
0.4842561185,
0.0479875468,
-0.3251878917,
0.2036269009,
0.0586116984,
0.1231592819,
0.0507717468,
-0.0969458818,
0.167001307,
-0.2195117027,
0.6104291677,
0.4167737067,
-0.5754362345,
0.2693155706,
0.19006975,
-0.0439958423,
-0.1374230087,
0.9059457183,
-0.7333713174,
0.3826556206,
0.3598610163,
0.2401777953,
0.2197725624,
0.0988441631,
0.1906048059,
-0.4711499214,
0.0530079491,
0.6607367396,
0.2936301827,
-0.1412411481,
-0.8008078337,
0.1067338288,
0.390062958,
-0.5372056365,
-1.151371479,
-0.0355001055,
-1.0517195463,
-0.2861915827,
0.948980689,
0.116406098,
-0.2864221036,
-0.5795249343,
-0.2435835004,
-0.1613197625,
-0.421741128,
0.9544887543,
0.4034003615,
-0.7845824361,
-0.055590421,
-0.3793909848,
0.8067104816,
0.1780816615,
-0.517585218,
-0.2587365508,
0.1828420758,
0.1593334228,
0.6363946199,
0.7005572915,
-0.4211043119,
1.0407034159,
0.077291958,
-0.0039713886,
-0.0525961667,
-0.124075897,
-0.5512744188,
0.0526435561,
-0.1533064693,
-0.976742208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14358v1 | The neural correlates of logical-mathematical symbol systems processing resemble that of spatial cognition more than natural language processing | 2024-06-20T14:31:09 | 2024-06-20T14:31:09 | Yuannan Li, Shan Xu, Jia Liu | q-bio.NC | q-bio.NC, cs.AI, cs.CL | The ability to manipulate logical-mathematical symbols (LMS), encompassing
tasks such as calculation, reasoning, and programming, is a cognitive skill
arguably unique to humans. Considering the relatively recent emergence of this
ability in human evolutionary history, it has been suggested that LMS
processing may build upon more fundamental cognitive systems, possibly through
neuronal recycling. Previous studies have pinpointed two primary candidates,
natural language processing and spatial cognition. Existing comparisons between
these domains largely relied on task-level comparison, which may be confounded
by task idiosyncrasy. The present study instead compared the neural correlates
at the domain level with both automated meta-analysis and synthesized maps
based on three representative LMS tasks, reasoning, calculation, and mental
programming. Our results revealed a more substantial cortical overlap between
LMS processing and spatial cognition, in contrast to language processing.
Furthermore, in regions activated by both spatial and language processing, the
multivariate activation pattern for LMS processing exhibited greater
multivariate similarity to spatial cognition than to language processing. A
hierarchical clustering analysis further indicated that typical LMS tasks were
indistinguishable from spatial cognition tasks at the neural level, suggesting
an inherent connection between these two cognitive processes. Taken together,
our findings support the hypothesis that spatial cognition is likely the basis
of LMS processing, which may shed light on the limitations of large language
models in logical reasoning, particularly those trained exclusively on textual
data without explicit emphasis on spatial content. | [
-0.4800181985,
-0.9065832496,
0.7662774324,
0.1391373128,
0.2858374417,
0.0541753545,
-0.1839337349,
-0.682249248,
0.2892415822,
0.3197457194,
-0.6355392933,
-0.4154667854,
-0.5611774325,
0.1534656286,
-0.199540779,
0.4367360771,
0.0961418152,
0.0682342499,
-0.4159179926,
-0.3238537908,
-0.7408173084,
-0.8340997696,
-0.6706728935,
-0.6402404904,
0.4272114336,
-0.2432010025,
0.9939191937,
0.2079098076,
0.8209825754,
0.461743772,
0.0062116254,
-0.0347735845,
-0.1647169739,
-0.0764967129,
-0.5413608551,
-0.4944857359,
-0.4805423021,
-0.0230962168,
0.1261258721,
1.0711532831,
-0.066556409,
-0.0591761991,
0.0150258569,
0.791434288,
-0.5926602483,
0.42484501,
-0.5585808754,
0.1907169968,
0.1583376229,
-0.4627119005,
-0.3163297772,
-0.5343962312,
0.2540908754,
-0.9281958342,
0.0603258051,
0.0862397552,
0.6670663953,
0.2765949368,
-0.2536636293,
-0.4979430735,
-0.6052882671,
0.7449022532,
-0.3660304248,
0.2866621017,
0.6269907951,
0.2448860854,
-0.0901977271,
-0.3835918903,
-0.5972152352,
-0.2014370412,
-0.4825629592,
-0.0101494296,
-0.5377597809,
0.0089296401,
0.5871034861,
-0.3079713285,
-0.5435923338,
-0.2667823136,
-0.6043758392,
-0.28845644,
0.5203258395,
0.220129177,
0.8413513303,
-0.2202092558,
-0.4554806054,
-0.0179030187,
-0.7332740426,
0.06144844,
0.0635701343,
0.3091958463,
-0.0494145863,
0.7637926936,
0.0010343296,
0.6817486882,
-0.187986061,
-0.0208859146,
0.1913219094,
-0.3389290273,
-0.2404556721,
-0.0213245712,
0.8126260042,
0.245594874,
0.7984577417,
-0.1787089109,
-0.1359621882,
0.5379459858,
0.3799000382,
-0.2939583063,
-0.3678727448,
-0.270727694,
-0.3499079645,
0.1983277649,
0.0383410789,
-0.2258568257,
-0.0837754011,
-0.8011693358,
0.3844285905,
-0.7307596803,
-0.0757333636,
0.4756456017,
-0.1688946933,
-0.2771650255,
0.2024771422,
-0.8214250803,
0.5236522555,
0.9819483161,
0.6321860552,
-0.0311421845,
-0.5783522129,
0.0136536593,
-0.0215183515,
-0.3749908507,
0.7305065989,
-0.8562602997,
0.1456778198,
-0.2735666335,
-0.2729429901,
-0.3118147552,
-0.8764742613,
0.4700080156,
-0.8550390601,
-0.064605698,
-0.8066635132,
-0.2021334618,
-0.5290701389,
0.1414057016,
-0.8706197739,
0.8732469082,
0.0274409577,
-0.6345871091,
0.4754449725,
-0.3817399442,
-0.4488086402,
-0.0142958518,
-0.669873178,
0.0172023475,
0.0727558732,
0.0524126589,
0.2759383917,
-0.2271552384,
0.3543926179,
-0.5846143365,
-0.4719515145,
0.5822989345,
-0.0056313933,
0.8911589384,
0.0655671209,
-0.4460144937,
-0.0834361389,
-0.5476985574,
0.1354707479,
0.1091348156,
-0.0986716673,
-0.7197437286,
0.2922166288,
-0.4930686355,
0.5237807631,
0.2573854327,
-0.2158571631,
-0.0292311627,
-0.328528285,
0.4993680716,
0.4895409346,
-0.2112992108,
0.8099943399,
-0.2232235372,
0.1119295135,
0.1152297258,
-0.3148504198,
0.1665138602,
-0.4621839523,
-0.555762291,
-0.4725344479,
-0.3648586571,
0.6636654735,
-0.8319007158,
0.6830278039,
-0.5290649533,
-0.0916223377,
0.0846007168,
-0.1439639032,
0.3107360899,
0.3550814688,
0.5062772632,
-0.0632082596,
-0.5737012625,
-0.932790041,
-0.5729624033,
0.0069612707,
0.0048022261,
0.3095346987,
0.6110256314,
0.1199041381,
0.9753940701,
-0.4684373438,
-0.3017610013,
0.0781457126,
0.0586425513,
0.3931958377,
0.2645887733,
0.7675905824,
-0.2220553011,
-0.3159712851,
0.1216048971,
-1.07497859,
-0.1805266887,
-0.1479251832,
-0.2880043089,
0.1220369563,
0.5859377384,
-0.8961873055,
0.6482645869,
0.1525956541,
-0.894210279,
0.1698171496,
-0.44300282,
0.3405231535,
-0.2160273194,
0.1159665138,
-0.3017953336,
0.3234981894,
-0.5975807905,
0.0147565249,
-0.0012345373,
-0.0418568887,
-0.0192234199,
0.2742690146,
-0.600530386,
-0.600019753,
-0.2456929684,
0.294360429,
0.059599977,
0.7762434483,
0.2712670863,
0.4893092513,
0.4643493593,
-0.4791329801,
0.1234278008,
-0.0844095498,
-0.4312828779,
0.3522083163,
-0.7101097703,
-0.0907710046,
-0.2068573684,
-0.0227593295,
-1.1042528152,
0.398868084,
0.1876383722,
-0.3461236358,
-0.1788573116,
0.4334919751,
-0.6105365753,
-0.1393616349,
0.0931365788,
0.6921045184,
0.4354205132,
-0.262291044,
0.5317729712,
0.1974855065,
-0.1667902023,
-0.2093214393,
-1.0215363503,
-0.1321569383,
-0.0378606431,
-0.6573915482,
0.0231627859,
0.316590637,
-0.4139719009,
0.1619280428,
-0.1080965847,
0.0237426423,
-0.0146140903,
0.2921122313,
0.4935311079,
-0.1638815999,
0.0065370984,
-0.1233570427,
-0.1548577398,
0.5628194213,
-0.269870013,
0.5105806589,
-0.0350844376,
-0.68360883,
-0.407030642,
0.0246593691,
0.7379874587,
-0.2653329968,
0.7765209079,
0.0551833771,
-0.6231688261,
0.0810226575,
-0.1582865715,
-0.2428514212,
-0.3668000996,
0.2741779387,
-0.6432108879,
-0.7336529493,
0.4384915531,
0.2422639281,
-0.2293648869,
0.4846039712,
0.3715908825,
-0.2852052748,
0.727301538,
0.125041157,
0.0646002516,
0.2632388771,
-0.3113683164,
0.4384358227,
-0.6025405526,
-0.4107644856,
-0.5079696774,
-0.8289527297,
-0.2063459158,
-0.7576600313,
0.2175398022,
-0.0032398344,
-0.7088399529,
0.446601212,
-0.5071845055,
0.5456941128,
0.1926410049,
0.0549463704,
0.2240411043,
0.6061630249,
-0.4434345365,
-0.4695031047,
-0.8217542768,
-0.2956908047,
0.9488065839,
0.035046231,
0.7111735344,
-0.0078158919,
0.2659772336,
0.1614219546,
0.0384503417,
-0.4635573626,
0.9182456732,
-0.3501228392,
-0.3841050565,
-0.2220880985,
-0.5101063251,
-1.0843359232,
0.5722897053,
-0.5534624457,
-0.7584071159,
0.3074005842,
-0.1695954651,
-0.3633360863,
0.4374198318,
-0.7683846354,
0.4854664803,
-0.2921519279,
-0.3444445133,
-0.623487711,
-0.1844289303,
0.3251494765,
0.2032565325,
0.522916615,
-0.0685552657,
-0.1513721496,
0.2981126904,
-0.2888987362,
0.8263567686,
0.0036070626,
-0.1910085976,
0.3510203063,
0.5155239105,
0.1728214622,
-0.1740598381,
-0.0003177233,
0.4918636382,
0.0191756636,
-0.3867706358,
-0.9753890634,
0.7829927206,
-1.0918017626,
-0.3508630991,
-0.6628497839,
-0.7903322577,
0.1131257638,
0.1949824542,
0.0418025479,
0.3191128373,
-0.0964574143,
-0.1560175866,
0.6051053405,
-0.2770401835,
0.30263713,
0.104855381,
-0.531231463,
-0.4472780228,
0.7290557027,
0.2437796891,
0.2314821184,
0.7755939364,
-0.2064543813,
-0.0826541558,
-0.2400759906,
0.2309990823,
0.2319152504,
-0.6305176616,
0.0037433037,
-0.5901619196,
-0.1683539599,
0.0915628821,
-0.5020934939,
-0.0780705512,
-0.5424132943,
0.0356413834,
0.0585331507,
0.1209864542,
0.716278851,
0.1090600267,
-0.1274228096,
-0.6450258493,
0.4929971099,
0.168358162,
0.1741802543,
0.3127287924,
-0.1409970671,
-0.1213888451,
0.4343609214,
0.0122439805,
-0.692317903,
0.2258244306,
0.0947481096,
0.5113797784,
0.3858077526,
-0.4822433889,
0.7508240938,
-0.5761367679,
0.5647451878,
0.571444273,
-0.7967905402,
0.1181566715,
-0.2675690651,
0.6811510921,
0.2823432982,
0.2777135074,
-0.365378201,
-0.1685017198,
-0.3488306403,
-0.3789223135,
0.6419796944,
0.4861674011,
-0.2525110543,
-0.3624740541,
0.3610844612,
-0.1027437821,
-0.0904508308,
-0.446285069,
-0.1209092066,
0.0158109665,
0.0390048213,
-0.1482165754,
0.2487862259,
-0.4056105912,
-0.5416939259,
-0.1513071358,
-0.0237273853,
0.5193500519,
0.1816193163,
-0.1576890051,
-0.0563525744,
0.1051949263,
0.5812906623,
0.6496497989,
0.2085810006,
0.4886719882,
0.2606133819,
-0.4536516964,
-0.0547258593,
-0.2300917357,
-0.2263077199,
-0.0896976739,
0.7860847712,
0.7716059685,
0.6165445447,
-0.5675171018,
0.1728454828,
-0.0645413473,
-0.3880751729,
-0.2432706654,
0.0864785835,
0.5071647763,
0.524138093,
0.1136487424,
0.6990560293,
0.1400630623,
-0.6909430027,
-0.0995352939,
0.6923779249,
0.0270640105,
-0.5439733863,
0.406924814,
-0.1201957911,
-0.2136464566,
0.8969564438,
-0.1146233305,
-0.521197319,
0.7777491212,
0.5222327113,
0.8009413481,
0.498098731,
-0.1046781316,
0.8167464733,
0.4670448303,
0.1580912322,
0.6358670592,
-0.2321548462,
-0.8397992849,
-0.4436022043,
-0.4653247893,
0.2963065505,
-0.3434984386,
-0.52459234,
-0.0422421433,
-0.6287549734,
-0.5646766424,
-0.0770195574,
-0.2845813036,
-0.8252975941,
0.3023942411,
0.3505049348,
0.7465437055,
-0.5818841457,
0.6477541327,
0.9798870087,
-0.2089533359,
-0.6411703825,
-0.4390517771,
-0.1900643259,
-0.6763280034,
1.2169728279,
-0.0659333244,
-0.3660137653,
-0.5646451712,
-0.318641752,
-1.1215426922,
1.1523190737,
0.5036596656,
-0.4883505404,
-0.2652052343,
0.7123798728,
0.8957516551,
-0.3184348345,
0.1954147667,
0.6171126366,
0.2744382322,
0.0512748659,
-0.7335457206,
0.2976082563,
-0.2115230858,
0.1290507168,
0.5611205101,
-0.3989121318,
0.9165915251,
-0.3254071474,
-0.5552458763,
-0.0701095089,
0.5044836998,
0.624347508,
0.1183665693,
0.2934085727,
1.0236110687,
0.5209609866,
-0.3889514804,
0.6945076585,
-0.481552273,
0.3421774507,
0.9725241661,
-0.2300468236,
0.8495483398,
0.7356046438,
-0.4062449038,
0.7345490456,
0.107076928,
0.3123254776,
0.4351547658,
0.2843574584,
-0.0011979912,
-0.2505415678,
0.4444104433,
-0.3254924715,
0.1981698424,
0.6580745578,
-0.2675336897,
-0.3878462613,
-0.3191882968,
-0.1143367887,
0.3312062621,
-0.2810922861,
0.5018062592,
0.3652223051,
-0.9279593229,
0.538156867,
-0.1835487336,
0.437980175,
-0.6344075799,
-0.0722121224,
0.1010832936,
0.1939056963,
-0.425473541,
-1.0081779957,
0.7984615564,
-0.2269881964,
-0.2566361129,
-0.5239881873,
0.98638767,
-0.3269684315,
-0.1105471477,
0.6604893208,
0.567540884,
-0.0274362769,
0.0273278467,
-0.8045623302,
0.0872684196,
-0.2437298596,
-0.1344590485,
0.2230799347,
0.6347908974,
-0.2618877888,
0.7103866339,
0.8310402632,
0.2174715549,
0.3198866546,
0.0336200446,
0.5377168059,
-0.9755757451,
-0.3142676055,
-0.949054122,
0.1369228363,
0.1661040038,
-0.0290626865,
0.4819210768,
0.3480890691,
0.9456965923,
-0.4120579362,
0.6709094644,
-0.1990093142,
-0.1326869875,
-0.4576513171,
0.735801518,
-0.3894695044,
0.241276592,
-0.2450458854,
-0.9743475318,
-0.3538927734,
0.8880660534,
-0.8877753615,
0.1245436519,
1.2023380995,
0.5565175414,
-0.1034042016,
0.2109154314,
0.3691235483,
0.028216064,
-0.0785512552,
1.009881258,
0.8922771215,
-0.3297654092,
0.1097362414,
-0.1628778428,
-0.1253534853,
0.1290919632,
-0.499674201,
-0.9968675971,
-0.4886278808,
-0.024337491,
-0.1869657487,
-0.1963575035,
0.7465562224,
0.3459582031,
-0.6539974809,
-0.4036886096,
-0.2165698558,
0.0841963291,
-0.4511861801,
-0.176039055,
0.3262214661,
-0.3242201805,
-0.5423151851,
-0.0542438887,
0.7712919712,
-0.2576419711,
-0.0810316727,
-0.0547826774,
-0.3092907369,
0.1133040711,
0.9792537093,
0.1771305054,
-0.7831942439,
-0.2250786275,
0.459338516,
-0.6685018539,
0.0723084956,
0.9656960964,
-0.8299170732,
0.2770626843,
1.0862944126,
0.5704270005,
0.1104653478,
-0.4329915941,
0.3263466358,
-0.0556153543,
0.1703558713,
0.0232550986,
0.6650004387,
0.0946142972,
-0.1714781672,
0.332135886,
0.3537219465,
-0.3795698285,
-0.2047994584,
0.3354353607,
-0.9228619337,
-0.3329578638,
0.8265784979,
0.1181134582,
-0.260877341,
0.0366259441,
-0.2233731598,
0.1165615842,
-0.0499529429,
0.760853827,
0.884303987,
-0.3925483227,
0.2241230011,
-0.3402299285,
0.1293692142,
0.7151401639,
-0.6970564127,
-0.3302955925,
0.5836564302,
0.2229858935,
0.5882399082,
0.5835795999,
-0.1550741494,
0.388133049,
0.091079779,
0.2058619261,
0.242759347,
-0.3397901654,
-0.1334776431,
0.4067201018,
-0.1856914461,
0.1305867136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14336v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14336v1 | Exploring Spatial Representations in the Historical Lake District Texts with LLM-based Relation Extraction | 2024-06-20T14:04:59 | 2024-06-20T14:04:59 | Erum Haris, Anthony G. Cohn, John G. Stell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Navigating historical narratives poses a challenge in unveiling the spatial
intricacies of past landscapes. The proposed work addresses this challenge
within the context of the English Lake District, employing the Corpus of the
Lake District Writing. The method utilizes a generative pre-trained transformer
model to extract spatial relations from the textual descriptions in the corpus.
The study applies this large language model to understand the spatial
dimensions inherent in historical narratives comprehensively. The outcomes are
presented as semantic triples, capturing the nuanced connections between
entities and locations, and visualized as a network, offering a graphical
representation of the spatial narrative. The study contributes to a deeper
comprehension of the English Lake District's spatial tapestry and provides an
approach to uncovering spatial relations within diverse historical contexts. | [
-0.5838069916,
-0.6509466171,
1.1215019226,
-0.1633659154,
0.0371132679,
-0.2428543717,
0.025805369,
-0.5698929429,
0.2885213196,
0.7527381182,
-0.7091315389,
-0.7139335871,
-0.585760951,
-0.1453204006,
-0.159924522,
0.5088813901,
-0.4132929444,
-0.0812592357,
0.0141704911,
-0.4139353931,
-0.6105129719,
-0.9884403944,
-0.1989789307,
-0.3468316793,
0.6937702894,
-0.0605228283,
0.8484243155,
0.7390423417,
0.703156054,
0.2557997406,
-0.3670421243,
0.3641217947,
-0.3418500721,
0.4290859699,
-0.4513214529,
-0.3123791516,
-0.3906806409,
0.006434449,
0.5866740942,
0.597558856,
0.3067456186,
0.0350327678,
-0.3300119638,
0.6802415252,
-0.693279922,
0.2065864503,
-0.5604783297,
0.4524491727,
-0.3195562959,
-0.4994136393,
-0.3312942386,
-0.1915466189,
0.0961751342,
-0.6130934954,
0.3994053304,
0.2870640755,
1.1188086271,
-0.2168274522,
-0.5712521076,
-0.4157387614,
-0.9923564196,
0.5784066319,
-0.3300360143,
0.179556936,
0.6879309416,
0.3740850389,
0.0213502888,
-0.6824994683,
-0.4293972254,
-0.0624132939,
-0.5121229887,
0.332315743,
-0.0707634613,
-0.666714251,
0.2869941294,
0.2052565366,
-0.3803126216,
0.0580991395,
-0.4974740148,
0.0767569765,
0.815033555,
0.5867609382,
0.7537554502,
-0.4950577915,
-0.5657792091,
-0.0913187489,
-1.1221075058,
-0.0765835196,
0.0278041456,
0.3802398145,
-0.0385291912,
0.6680564284,
0.5995184183,
0.2882301211,
-0.1232325062,
0.0185256563,
-0.0369812846,
-0.5184385777,
0.1994481832,
0.0115320338,
0.8517979383,
0.5496271253,
0.3233697712,
-0.3155997097,
-0.3311472237,
-0.4528818429,
0.3914084136,
-0.254214853,
-0.2371274978,
-0.2904648781,
-0.341157198,
0.0738761798,
0.2152026892,
-0.9098847508,
-0.3316730559,
-0.1677300334,
0.1667549908,
-0.5981761217,
-0.4832728803,
-0.3648976982,
-0.2962527275,
0.5397353172,
0.2860452831,
-1.1938664913,
0.2452617437,
0.6989657879,
0.9586034417,
-0.0679741427,
-0.7186694741,
-0.0627062842,
1.0560085773,
-0.418666333,
0.723541975,
-0.4202817678,
-0.669678688,
0.1962333173,
0.0425749756,
0.0891121477,
-0.6211972237,
0.4642000496,
-0.8724876642,
-0.0100702113,
-0.1357720941,
-0.2982651293,
-0.042384468,
0.1081918031,
-1.1461251974,
1.1463439465,
-0.0372299664,
-0.7022953033,
0.2248304933,
-0.4899999499,
-0.4444123209,
-0.0502950735,
-0.1968096942,
-0.2870055735,
0.1237047017,
0.8028326035,
0.3861909211,
0.2185339332,
0.3472646475,
-0.2094304115,
-0.0376148447,
0.0838460848,
0.1314052641,
0.5686224103,
0.1785787791,
-0.2614527047,
-0.1120239869,
-0.4995652437,
-0.4565883875,
0.0990523621,
-0.0080065215,
-0.5867083669,
0.2128153443,
-0.0439387038,
-0.1440430731,
0.3056307733,
-0.3011169434,
0.200085178,
-0.4315806031,
-0.1277186126,
0.5858299136,
0.1290636212,
1.1738734245,
-0.21870704,
0.5062773824,
0.3590648472,
-0.2712330222,
-0.410482496,
-0.1453119069,
-0.3098587394,
-0.1322790086,
-0.1318298578,
0.4264848232,
-0.7429969907,
0.4411781132,
-0.7002848387,
-0.5389746428,
-0.1951375604,
0.0234565046,
-0.214440003,
0.3199943006,
0.4176154733,
0.4424172938,
-0.6162984967,
-0.7566277981,
0.0922955275,
-0.3260390759,
0.0268080998,
0.5289319158,
0.3639889657,
-0.177599147,
1.2893639803,
-0.6623010039,
-0.5210021734,
-0.2905239165,
0.0172982328,
0.2189861536,
0.14199844,
0.7740896344,
-0.9519705176,
-0.3572228849,
0.4691701531,
-0.8114985824,
-0.1421840191,
-0.0483157299,
-0.5429394841,
-0.0176594686,
0.3880309165,
-0.6475221515,
0.6771346331,
0.2064541131,
-0.3999562263,
0.4148485363,
-0.3578359485,
0.1921788454,
-1.043598175,
-0.122240141,
-0.1194233298,
0.0447432846,
-0.306956619,
0.2033656389,
0.2086750269,
-0.285125643,
-0.2684105039,
0.5099480152,
-0.7172480226,
-0.2163650841,
0.215923816,
0.7361833453,
-0.0208048522,
0.1360592693,
0.4521545768,
0.2670396268,
0.3518371284,
-0.270779103,
0.3431773782,
0.3619697392,
0.0234400202,
0.1251360327,
0.0221547671,
0.0667352304,
-0.300262481,
0.0117079429,
-1.1236630678,
-0.0030770674,
-0.0556116775,
-0.1523490697,
0.2252444625,
-0.1538167596,
-0.8142063618,
-0.2167635858,
-0.1835591644,
0.5162310004,
0.227610901,
-0.6838139296,
1.0673835278,
0.6157984734,
-0.2045498192,
-0.0398377255,
-0.7168556452,
0.0718831494,
-0.4403594732,
-0.6760802269,
0.1732408106,
0.2022623867,
-0.5258833766,
0.0342564844,
0.1321612746,
-0.8049108386,
-0.0608139522,
0.4999088347,
0.6662410498,
-0.5326712132,
-0.1255586594,
-0.2856036425,
0.0280185826,
0.2840255201,
0.2640466094,
0.319501102,
0.345582366,
-0.2320803106,
-0.4706776738,
0.5959418416,
0.8052886724,
-0.0376163945,
0.6465626359,
0.4093223214,
-0.4126342237,
-0.1437077671,
-0.4038096666,
0.0790710151,
-0.3508115411,
0.2904810905,
-0.5938758254,
-0.8251799941,
0.6377855539,
-0.2023186833,
-0.0772258416,
0.7697930336,
0.2773911059,
-0.4520677924,
0.2479756027,
0.2851985097,
-0.2145613581,
0.1506985724,
-0.1973843426,
0.5199338794,
-0.6871907711,
-0.6044371724,
-0.3569031656,
-0.5031418204,
-0.048387479,
-0.1193324178,
0.3222046196,
0.3545254469,
-0.2278742194,
0.4158193767,
0.0179790929,
0.5039031506,
0.2087166458,
0.1056287438,
0.2516253591,
0.0866703019,
0.1272676885,
-0.6556529403,
-0.43099159,
-0.7817099094,
0.7447419763,
0.3355318308,
0.5610488057,
0.7167043686,
0.8564087749,
0.250025779,
0.4036206901,
-0.5376846194,
0.5273217559,
-0.1242531389,
-0.2072303593,
-0.251648128,
-0.2658241093,
-1.1376559734,
0.1804325283,
-0.2008364201,
-0.7681285143,
0.0344129466,
-0.2445047349,
-0.6133013368,
0.7482534647,
-0.7434523702,
0.4159635007,
-0.2372159511,
-0.2818383574,
0.0326884873,
-0.5765237808,
0.2352556437,
-0.2585322559,
0.7564331889,
0.0119032627,
0.0501368679,
0.2537764311,
-0.2803647816,
0.8235216141,
-0.0714523196,
-0.2905555665,
0.07674364,
0.6273403168,
0.2801859975,
-0.3478838503,
-0.0330488011,
0.17762959,
0.2146155238,
-0.1143290326,
-0.6820722222,
0.7789611816,
-1.0698086023,
-0.5115560293,
-0.1250348985,
-0.8558601737,
0.0219425168,
-0.2545971274,
-0.0921285823,
0.7234199643,
-0.240244776,
-0.3928246498,
0.3113185167,
-0.1142038852,
0.8228428364,
0.1810329705,
-0.8134709001,
-0.2847155631,
0.2369896322,
0.1967036724,
-0.1500287056,
0.7384132743,
-0.028402485,
-0.4616085887,
-0.4680912197,
0.0473236293,
0.2413043827,
-0.701960206,
-0.2170037031,
-0.2530484796,
-0.362755537,
-0.432400614,
-0.5267930031,
-0.0921755508,
-0.0834962428,
-0.5452951193,
-0.3308286369,
0.2355660051,
1.5848128796,
-0.0982393473,
0.1867235154,
-1.0933800936,
0.280515492,
-0.1559733152,
-0.1257877499,
0.2061382532,
-0.3212412596,
-0.2035835534,
-0.318933636,
-0.3163408041,
-1.0914355516,
0.8065766096,
-0.1920797974,
0.5144822001,
0.2737360001,
-0.0459281132,
0.9509450197,
-0.9679498672,
1.0389934778,
0.308640331,
-0.4135144949,
0.8764832616,
-0.0985777527,
0.3327944577,
-0.1119238809,
0.6182086468,
-0.1298831552,
-0.2680397332,
-0.5171713233,
-1.2955005169,
0.4483248293,
-0.0254778732,
0.2872766256,
-0.3654675484,
0.6790300608,
0.0931419432,
-0.6119248867,
-1.0466278791,
-0.2933840156,
0.1373025924,
-0.0126809124,
-0.1874357462,
-0.7762024999,
-0.0280105062,
-0.3152171969,
0.311366111,
0.5959417224,
-0.140090853,
0.3612014651,
-0.4886085689,
0.2377679348,
0.1283116043,
0.3379946053,
1.0491634607,
-0.0461820364,
0.7979587913,
0.2098523676,
-0.4009081423,
-0.078532137,
-0.161500141,
-0.081572406,
0.3572633862,
0.8939752579,
0.5866876245,
0.5873715281,
-0.2016720921,
0.4575924873,
0.2187543213,
-0.1327116936,
-0.43515715,
-0.2638443708,
0.2388706505,
0.6086489558,
0.850302279,
-0.1053339541,
-0.2487950474,
-0.4409470856,
0.2094157636,
0.2389304936,
-0.5399829149,
-0.2567744255,
0.4498476982,
-0.0264504198,
-0.5758959055,
0.6425220966,
0.2350953221,
-0.4794428945,
0.3192258477,
0.5910047889,
0.5956267715,
0.0514393188,
0.0312473923,
0.7775928378,
0.1741400659,
0.450392276,
-0.2682233155,
-0.0963705853,
-0.8255687356,
-0.219883427,
-0.7603214979,
0.1149730012,
-0.053738147,
-0.6827297211,
0.0622175373,
-0.2868087888,
-0.2843380868,
-0.2000997066,
-0.2851289213,
-0.3101427853,
-0.3358120918,
0.368463695,
0.8992639184,
-0.6630172133,
0.7709897161,
0.7200955749,
-0.2572694719,
-0.7128661275,
-0.0279681031,
-0.1633699983,
-0.6245063543,
1.6869584322,
-0.1981893182,
-0.4436126351,
-0.1216674298,
-0.4873557687,
-0.5315061212,
1.361795187,
0.0708108619,
-0.711301744,
0.1230039448,
0.3493483365,
0.5732482076,
-0.4571503997,
-0.1204014271,
0.3450711071,
0.2630411685,
0.2186483294,
-0.6628791094,
-0.172724396,
-0.0180210024,
0.2038429976,
0.4197123647,
0.1032842919,
0.4282608032,
-0.3350472748,
-0.6963306665,
0.3929553032,
0.8499385118,
0.2804099619,
0.2329286933,
0.0937334821,
0.6504981518,
0.6195055842,
-0.3184826672,
1.2879127264,
-0.1064444408,
0.503665626,
1.0698180199,
-0.5617175698,
1.1524356604,
0.8380470872,
-0.3702658117,
0.6472486258,
0.526106894,
0.1324875206,
0.794559896,
0.1552083045,
-0.821826756,
0.1132645383,
-0.0305098668,
-0.1275786906,
0.1843520403,
0.0230767187,
-0.4245122969,
-0.6675871611,
-0.2565681338,
0.1822929382,
0.5227438211,
-0.8218413591,
0.824441731,
0.0036471586,
-0.2587203681,
-0.16720213,
-0.4730599821,
0.2958175242,
-0.7981396317,
-0.2148050964,
-0.2467359453,
0.1607355177,
0.0129026538,
-1.2201197147,
0.6140553355,
-0.2543709278,
-0.5466038585,
-0.6884245872,
0.4938027263,
-0.6076091528,
-0.3716033399,
0.5849035382,
0.6243166327,
0.0756290555,
0.3733407557,
-0.0640957579,
0.1170537993,
-0.0704743639,
0.0235753059,
0.0986281931,
1.1458786726,
0.179021135,
0.1847131103,
0.4167616367,
0.3285297155,
0.0000818361,
0.1163391396,
0.5348511934,
-1.168300271,
-0.1914715469,
-1.3041074276,
0.3960371912,
0.0910960883,
0.0461159348,
0.7379480004,
0.7181930542,
0.4753495455,
-0.1395113617,
0.3372436762,
0.2097268701,
0.0857470483,
-0.6781642437,
0.7830141783,
-0.0771440417,
0.3704684973,
0.0576005653,
-0.6878842115,
-0.5838477015,
0.6578130722,
-0.5724298358,
-0.345757395,
0.8645089269,
0.6141098738,
0.0665277466,
0.1444205195,
0.4854998291,
0.3838083744,
0.0665042177,
0.4495351613,
1.4516912699,
-0.0878622532,
0.2888332009,
-0.0651349053,
-0.0112197092,
0.6831258535,
-0.8930122256,
-0.6798319817,
-0.9402562976,
0.0622479878,
-0.0862198547,
-0.0248992238,
0.324472934,
0.3714767992,
-0.5384001732,
-0.6271766424,
0.5969042182,
0.0042321943,
0.3804787993,
-0.3199212551,
0.8723164201,
-0.1999128461,
-0.5138942003,
0.2199718505,
0.7332945466,
0.2742934525,
-0.1414463669,
-0.1356045157,
-0.4013585448,
-0.7279620171,
0.8907369971,
-0.1194011495,
-0.708460629,
-0.3602344394,
-0.2427583784,
-0.1763967425,
0.2876546383,
0.9847964048,
-0.6403369308,
0.1696815342,
-0.049391266,
0.5831791759,
0.9791522622,
-0.2402208596,
0.7421781421,
-0.8161329031,
0.021613095,
0.0823730081,
0.7486245632,
0.4105941355,
-0.4185349643,
0.4586604536,
0.3091158569,
-0.31332919,
-0.2069173008,
-0.0669383258,
-1.0176352262,
-0.4130827487,
1.1773490906,
-0.2660552561,
-0.2147697061,
-0.1530155838,
-0.4767074883,
-0.0998846367,
0.1313605607,
0.623106122,
1.0262836218,
-0.2462951541,
-0.4461818039,
-0.5653017759,
-0.0764421672,
-0.1290651411,
-0.5743047595,
0.1049229428,
0.9865207672,
-0.0284678452,
0.4833132327,
0.6592903137,
-0.4226150513,
-0.3438883424,
-0.2225938886,
0.0193555038,
0.2270781845,
-0.0985223874,
0.0059518861,
0.5466986895,
-0.2620249093,
0.0751996264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14335v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14335v1 | Self-supervised Interpretable Concept-based Models for Text Classification | 2024-06-20T14:04:53 | 2024-06-20T14:04:53 | Francesco De Santis, Philippe Bich, Gabriele Ciravegna, Pietro Barbiero, Danilo Giordano, Tania Cerquitelli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite their success, Large-Language Models (LLMs) still face criticism as
their lack of interpretability limits their controllability and reliability.
Traditional post-hoc interpretation methods, based on attention and
gradient-based analysis, offer limited insight into the model's decision-making
processes. In the image field, Concept-based models have emerged as
explainable-by-design architectures, employing human-interpretable features as
intermediate representations. However, these methods have not been yet adapted
to textual data, mainly because they require expensive concept annotations,
which are impractical for real-world text data. This paper addresses this
challenge by proposing a self-supervised Interpretable Concept Embedding Models
(ICEMs). We leverage the generalization abilities of LLMs to predict the
concepts labels in a self-supervised way, while we deliver the final
predictions with an interpretable function. The results of our experiments show
that ICEMs can be trained in a self-supervised way achieving similar
performance to fully supervised concept-based models and end-to-end black-box
ones. Additionally, we show that our models are (i) interpretable, offering
meaningful logical explanations for their predictions; (ii) interactable,
allowing humans to modify intermediate predictions through concept
interventions; and (iii) controllable, guiding the LLMs' decoding process to
follow a required decision-making path. | [
-0.0930077583,
-0.5424477458,
0.7045225501,
0.0565667525,
-0.50612396,
-0.0255696084,
-0.0240952019,
-0.6136721373,
0.2328970581,
0.8107245564,
-0.4581635892,
-0.7386092544,
-0.629743576,
0.0846428648,
-0.5792286396,
1.0686224699,
-0.3351197541,
-0.2785455585,
-0.4647252858,
0.0412806682,
-0.3943541646,
-0.4994481206,
-0.3503169715,
-0.3535996377,
0.1592526883,
0.3789870441,
0.6394219995,
0.9005681872,
0.4873341918,
0.2399928272,
-0.0270475913,
0.0903144181,
-0.2110010982,
0.0311198737,
-0.3193388283,
-0.5236471891,
-0.3694064617,
0.2390979826,
0.3672752976,
0.3596347868,
-0.19528234,
-0.0037642906,
0.1340730786,
0.2644233704,
-0.282663554,
0.4194675684,
-0.5946564674,
0.2044516355,
0.2158076018,
-0.1865388751,
-0.5817481875,
0.1848681271,
0.2763943672,
-0.5940464735,
0.2771853805,
0.2238433063,
0.5618308783,
0.5309051871,
-0.2750138938,
-0.6456727386,
-0.6165493131,
0.7075205445,
-0.4229916036,
0.3407354355,
0.6158930659,
0.0322609395,
-0.0046152482,
-0.6846350431,
-0.4655304849,
-0.0479167663,
-0.297246933,
0.2525307834,
-0.0950271934,
0.0303231385,
-0.2860719264,
0.2902938426,
-0.3814613521,
0.38414222,
-0.2350246608,
-0.1381699592,
0.63427037,
0.2035637349,
0.3157866299,
-0.3390102684,
-0.6257584095,
0.3622658551,
-0.3411367834,
-0.1165485829,
-0.1915914416,
0.1315559298,
-0.36716941,
0.56262815,
-0.0756792501,
0.6469607353,
0.0461056307,
0.0243958198,
0.1048332229,
-0.0148381516,
-0.368704915,
0.0898454264,
0.827316761,
0.297701478,
0.2085463256,
-0.3233519197,
-0.1243681982,
0.0127924718,
0.3972451687,
-0.9195606112,
-0.3891465962,
0.2418297976,
-0.6585424542,
-0.5478014946,
-0.1416966468,
-0.6085596085,
-0.1964631975,
-0.3907214701,
0.4228924215,
-0.4290903509,
-0.2182186395,
0.4131400585,
0.0399820656,
0.0337549634,
0.6091090441,
-0.8603192568,
0.2452456802,
0.4446021616,
1.1028528214,
-0.3912005424,
-0.1215204075,
-0.019632332,
0.4948474467,
-0.5326243043,
0.9546052814,
-0.7992399335,
-0.3606971204,
-0.2519347966,
-0.1133006066,
0.0253065415,
-0.206103161,
0.4950300455,
-0.554620862,
0.1841108948,
0.3805916607,
-0.8855202198,
-0.1489283442,
0.1635003835,
-0.5026763082,
0.631572783,
-0.1984013319,
-0.9427652359,
0.1438455433,
-0.7662553787,
-0.335208416,
0.1864474267,
-0.3384032845,
-0.4693359435,
0.1911726445,
0.2716777027,
1.0855493546,
-0.3611859083,
0.2789647281,
-0.4421736002,
-0.2112788707,
0.3824220002,
-0.2649953961,
0.2885510027,
0.35247612,
-0.1503318548,
0.0708119199,
-0.69241184,
-0.2253255546,
0.1730212867,
-0.0163580291,
-0.5648130774,
0.1648910344,
-0.2434280366,
0.2908093631,
0.2310729921,
-0.4495063424,
0.0372724868,
-0.1226865575,
0.5613188744,
0.80314219,
-0.1216993853,
0.5843368769,
-0.0176758021,
0.6358647943,
0.2511407137,
-0.1737651974,
-0.4764284194,
-0.4500828087,
-0.658426404,
-0.6549044251,
0.2131428421,
0.4151439965,
-0.8586901426,
0.4739614129,
-0.3342710435,
-0.5319100618,
-0.5759406686,
0.173849225,
0.2605553269,
0.6862642169,
0.5119168758,
-0.0810308009,
-0.0265539866,
-0.9157737494,
-0.1674212813,
-0.0756489411,
-0.0455596,
0.1847516745,
0.659576416,
-0.4570909441,
1.0021095276,
-0.7558261752,
-0.5848665833,
-0.1402509809,
0.3514967859,
0.0843507424,
0.4692609012,
0.1710666567,
-0.8347355127,
-0.287525773,
-0.0353414677,
-1.0741127729,
-0.0117074167,
-0.3418097198,
0.1649516225,
-0.1122802868,
0.8322172165,
-0.3968294561,
0.5066925883,
0.474940151,
-0.4036181867,
0.4844245911,
-0.3747445643,
-0.2124957144,
-0.8774902225,
-0.2547255158,
0.4115973711,
-0.3118573129,
-0.5362448692,
0.0071641002,
0.24599424,
-0.0294326879,
-0.2203625441,
0.8072862625,
-0.4745162427,
-0.0511127673,
-0.4270238876,
-0.0150781143,
0.153716296,
0.34358266,
0.6056087017,
0.498621732,
0.620554328,
-0.6186788678,
0.1555933654,
0.4328558445,
-0.5118404031,
0.6892423034,
-0.6338331699,
0.1413881779,
-0.3660894632,
0.3750509024,
-0.9391376972,
-0.1204539761,
0.4545474052,
-0.4149463177,
0.3582750559,
-0.2456798106,
-0.3712034822,
-0.1345757544,
0.0154427066,
0.2505490184,
0.2158256024,
-0.7538082004,
0.8189883828,
0.3278567195,
-0.1383173466,
-0.4023416042,
-0.8909608126,
0.1439167112,
-0.3551661968,
-0.2466938198,
0.4885250926,
-0.1805167645,
0.0998975933,
0.3437608182,
0.0614223592,
-0.213857457,
0.1792570204,
0.4389727116,
0.3910224736,
0.0564219207,
0.6727315187,
0.2040011287,
-0.1721118987,
0.0877933502,
-0.5335373282,
0.0868684798,
-0.0250630975,
-0.0118453698,
-0.6851053238,
0.0607848167,
0.3314985633,
-0.4246817231,
0.7192098498,
0.5611440539,
-0.4545577765,
-0.3962132633,
-0.2266175747,
-0.040508084,
-0.4735785127,
0.3330671489,
-0.7700946331,
-1.1018574238,
0.2640479505,
-0.1998485029,
-0.1737172306,
0.5975347757,
0.4594644308,
-0.7052554488,
0.825855732,
0.6253854036,
0.0127446931,
0.2797231972,
-0.2923628092,
-0.0342780687,
-0.8040990233,
-0.2953927517,
-0.2951383293,
-0.0437072925,
-0.6176949739,
-0.524404645,
0.0437548868,
0.0424253158,
0.0041978694,
-0.0463815108,
-0.6219044328,
0.4241437912,
0.1310301572,
0.2608859539,
0.3728883266,
0.1559061855,
-0.1239006892,
-0.0895101056,
-0.5736609101,
-0.5991548896,
1.0784952641,
0.7552753091,
1.1468684673,
-0.2956569195,
0.6735329032,
0.5367130637,
0.6279380322,
-0.8618608713,
0.228333652,
-0.3781020343,
-0.6359969378,
-0.4526337385,
-0.4986048639,
-0.9003085494,
0.3986585438,
-0.3186413944,
-0.7677567005,
0.1052592248,
0.1503918469,
-0.0483617224,
0.3224990666,
-0.6054309011,
0.8284774423,
-0.3095035553,
-0.0553733036,
-0.3817444444,
-0.3818950355,
0.3680288196,
-0.3635353744,
0.7474321723,
-0.100178726,
-0.2342595011,
0.7533003092,
0.0060334057,
1.2058347464,
0.0333049409,
-0.2166804522,
0.3269028664,
0.1951647997,
0.2258117944,
-0.0850845352,
-0.0485390089,
0.3046097159,
-0.0602531247,
-0.3242183328,
-0.7237340212,
0.5236110687,
-0.8844749331,
-0.634106338,
-0.3753337562,
-0.4071968794,
-0.0098009584,
0.1153504103,
0.1093926057,
0.5172329545,
-0.1725810766,
0.0722170398,
0.63937819,
-0.1096960232,
0.1842808574,
0.4310007691,
-0.4349509478,
-0.2631559968,
1.0516941547,
0.0543345623,
0.1273915917,
0.5995486975,
0.2491370291,
-0.4156762958,
-0.7964723706,
-0.2581476271,
0.204230383,
-0.7972397804,
-0.1176981553,
-0.809592545,
-0.1545348465,
-0.1464220285,
-0.1786921322,
-0.1938616484,
-0.4177388549,
-0.8052603602,
-0.2565661073,
0.1887191087,
1.0058932304,
-0.0889550894,
0.6623764038,
-0.6026774645,
0.498605907,
0.318511039,
0.6302729845,
-0.0287942942,
-0.8793557882,
-0.5017057657,
-0.1642127335,
-0.0597350895,
-0.7444019318,
0.4207361937,
0.255531162,
0.3560093939,
0.4012140036,
0.117409654,
0.1849967688,
-0.3486857414,
0.2672045231,
0.2695054114,
-1.052649498,
0.6864231825,
-0.1436554044,
0.1815832704,
0.0333238766,
0.5838040113,
-0.4224413037,
-0.2150874287,
-0.5057969689,
-0.3673554361,
0.8155281544,
0.0562801436,
0.2811265886,
0.0755439028,
0.7031199336,
0.1893231124,
0.0779670477,
-0.7424039245,
-0.1412388235,
-0.5401340723,
-0.5628220439,
-0.4166179597,
-0.3545255959,
0.2116260529,
0.1073269174,
0.4317333102,
-0.4094670117,
0.1783212721,
0.3640328944,
-0.3402606845,
-0.0120949708,
0.2156357169,
0.1489340514,
0.3885213435,
-0.3481607139,
0.4139331281,
0.0374542773,
-0.216685459,
0.2985213995,
0.0698852837,
-0.1775400192,
-0.1609378308,
0.5020528436,
0.8060309887,
0.1586034,
-0.4171536565,
0.3767719865,
-0.3470945954,
-0.0689018741,
-0.1519758999,
0.0396779217,
0.2225905359,
0.2024291009,
0.3540472686,
-0.1323024035,
0.2633678913,
-0.466465801,
0.1669095308,
0.3730583191,
-0.5991066694,
-0.3436994553,
0.5820707083,
0.2626808882,
-0.080621466,
0.4110642374,
-0.1137905717,
-0.4668322802,
0.6213933825,
0.6063535213,
0.7878652215,
-0.3544172943,
0.6925581098,
0.0678350776,
0.367703259,
0.071100913,
-0.0205715634,
0.0297748465,
-1.195094943,
-0.3413212895,
-0.6574764848,
-0.4692157805,
0.0831755549,
-0.6791366339,
0.149665162,
-0.5137142539,
-0.0012200144,
0.3701748252,
-0.3439157307,
-0.7597423792,
0.827711463,
0.1585408747,
0.8728417754,
-0.8521882296,
0.9603303075,
0.8002955317,
-0.209210515,
-0.2198338807,
-0.0958451107,
-0.2680003941,
-0.8101047873,
0.7008919716,
0.2666602433,
-0.1695914418,
0.1691590101,
-0.7894561291,
-0.8240926266,
1.0136744976,
0.1368336529,
-0.4784527421,
-0.069623135,
0.0694906861,
0.7076485157,
-0.7534676194,
0.2282580286,
0.3373168111,
0.1565324068,
0.1921299696,
-0.5086422563,
0.0640119836,
0.008360683,
-0.0261235088,
-0.219152078,
-0.5061919093,
0.3747099042,
-0.3438076377,
-0.2369943261,
-0.1539640874,
0.9826022983,
-0.0324522518,
0.2799052298,
0.47941944,
0.5483182669,
0.6414479613,
0.2183402181,
1.1313070059,
-0.2541315854,
0.4402402043,
1.3193535805,
0.0891457126,
0.9134612083,
0.057482902,
-0.0033939965,
0.5891504288,
0.7664692402,
-0.1265955865,
0.6063918471,
0.0309501104,
0.1667228937,
-0.6886396408,
-0.310134232,
0.029187588,
0.7691907883,
0.8140738606,
-0.5737345219,
0.1136820093,
-0.06391,
-0.1490205377,
0.0050156093,
-0.4827453494,
0.6697478294,
0.3636965752,
-0.2176631093,
0.2539371252,
0.1352670789,
0.7622994184,
-0.2907985449,
0.0749648437,
0.152428031,
0.0783322975,
-0.2692497373,
-1.1149183512,
0.1263160259,
-0.2256977558,
-0.1841267496,
-0.2291088104,
0.9756984711,
-0.4888490736,
-0.7081624269,
0.440562129,
0.5995571613,
0.1757990569,
-0.0620278642,
-0.7381334305,
-0.1285782009,
-0.0636188462,
-0.116918169,
0.2145095915,
0.5696673393,
-0.0184408948,
1.0901986361,
0.3673579693,
-0.0913630649,
-0.3294172585,
-0.3249587417,
0.6379444599,
-0.8289041519,
-0.6968790889,
-0.8424297571,
0.2979106009,
0.2158778012,
-0.0169644058,
0.2101244479,
0.2276267111,
0.6684754491,
-0.0720426291,
1.0833590031,
0.4494036436,
0.4858878255,
-0.6754445434,
0.6264495254,
-0.6170970798,
0.0863605067,
-0.1801429838,
-0.5215539336,
-0.2490674108,
0.5967051983,
-0.3578393459,
-0.036294803,
0.4884496629,
0.2285984904,
-0.0854905471,
0.1394347847,
0.4807243049,
0.4137180448,
0.294934243,
0.1802992225,
0.9798290133,
0.0474878773,
0.4167830348,
-0.1459860057,
-0.3080934882,
-0.1756687164,
-0.9614101648,
-1.1766723394,
-0.6064502597,
-0.4902145565,
0.0612569228,
-0.1363982707,
0.681761384,
0.7043021321,
-0.6877996325,
-0.0556301922,
0.0803400129,
0.2721078992,
0.2608879209,
-0.1859125495,
0.6265329123,
-0.3208702505,
-0.5454622507,
0.1050510928,
0.3890769184,
0.3880393803,
-0.2858407795,
-0.0288069844,
0.0942393467,
0.1102526635,
0.6140027046,
-0.0978660062,
-0.8289894462,
-0.2544010282,
-0.1980056316,
-0.1010438278,
0.1270252168,
0.5213661194,
-0.7327846885,
0.6703132391,
-0.0806412324,
0.7705463171,
0.7414987683,
-0.0051347376,
0.5555771589,
-0.4333588183,
-0.1849724799,
0.1167771816,
0.4140476584,
0.4263846576,
-0.4493389726,
0.5225479603,
0.087224789,
-0.3672609627,
-0.4207084477,
0.0494118556,
-0.6111403704,
-0.6257399321,
0.9802234769,
-0.5827601552,
-0.0507952236,
-0.1605103463,
-0.0368576795,
0.1991412491,
-0.3164332211,
0.8666387796,
0.7545253634,
-0.0578061379,
-0.5921174884,
-0.299788028,
0.411108464,
0.2205815613,
-1.0246460438,
0.0543818101,
0.4173830152,
0.3031847775,
0.0678361282,
0.4412530065,
0.1385602057,
-0.091641821,
-0.3851495385,
0.1729026139,
-0.0102173649,
-0.4383700192,
-0.5276238322,
-0.0197146051,
0.0930593908,
-0.1174645722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14326v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14326v1 | medIKAL: Integrating Knowledge Graphs as Assistants of LLMs for Enhanced Clinical Diagnosis on EMRs | 2024-06-20T13:56:52 | 2024-06-20T13:56:52 | Mingyi Jia, Junwen Duan, Yan Song, Jianxin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Electronic Medical Records (EMRs), while integral to modern healthcare,
present challenges for clinical reasoning and diagnosis due to their complexity
and information redundancy. To address this, we proposed medIKAL (Integrating
Knowledge Graphs as Assistants of LLMs), a framework that combines Large
Language Models (LLMs) with knowledge graphs (KGs) to enhance diagnostic
capabilities. medIKAL assigns weighted importance to entities in medical
records based on their type, enabling precise localization of candidate
diseases within KGs. It innovatively employs a residual network-like approach,
allowing initial diagnosis by the LLM to be merged into KG search results.
Through a path-based reranking algorithm and a fill-in-the-blank style prompt
template, it further refined the diagnostic process. We validated medIKAL's
effectiveness through extensive experiments on a newly introduced open-sourced
Chinese EMR dataset, demonstrating its potential to improve clinical diagnosis
in real-world settings. | [
-0.3131534755,
-0.6383902431,
0.7326358557,
-0.1161354184,
-0.4706255496,
0.0006387245,
-0.0940383375,
-0.5381352901,
0.518601954,
0.3160037398,
-0.4196163118,
-0.8730064631,
-0.5686277151,
0.191049546,
-0.188235417,
0.9689808488,
-0.0748766735,
0.4317232668,
-0.386646539,
-0.1804874092,
-0.3209677935,
-0.3350405395,
-1.1440759897,
-0.5741323233,
0.7262841463,
0.3183721006,
0.931315124,
0.8597049117,
0.6837501526,
0.2316841185,
0.0449595116,
0.7010723948,
0.0495197698,
0.4209439456,
0.2513532937,
-0.5379528403,
-0.7591770291,
-0.4788116515,
0.329729706,
0.8960808516,
-0.1910615563,
-0.1538894027,
-0.092341952,
0.7199123502,
-0.2840226591,
0.1034110934,
0.3523051739,
0.5627374053,
-0.1938168257,
-0.3380509913,
-0.3722518682,
-0.5680897832,
-0.0279590413,
-0.7313525081,
0.0005909685,
-0.0564813614,
0.5822482705,
0.451572001,
-0.438265264,
-0.4246665537,
-0.6192451715,
0.3612425625,
-0.4580629766,
0.5435502529,
0.2977246642,
0.7875778675,
-0.1964689195,
-1.047385931,
-0.1498565972,
-0.1279616952,
-0.3380292654,
0.1697867066,
-0.4580200613,
0.0427390821,
-0.0650339797,
0.1605786532,
-0.5444263816,
0.2476396859,
-0.2761117518,
-0.3177967072,
0.2853553295,
0.5990387201,
0.6662016511,
-0.0645067543,
-0.0825867504,
0.2199053019,
-0.6442261934,
-0.3550615907,
-0.4030202627,
0.2235708982,
-0.2133401781,
0.5667834878,
-0.1607809216,
1.1829156876,
-0.0127211651,
-0.51725775,
0.3719545603,
0.0701687336,
-0.1085954159,
0.3221056163,
0.7395437956,
0.433537364,
0.0609671734,
-0.3364298046,
-0.0817572251,
0.1002148241,
-0.1206440479,
-0.6220110655,
-0.5452848673,
0.4532100856,
-0.9629018307,
-0.5153955817,
-0.5889151692,
-0.6295011044,
-0.8457335234,
-0.5151483417,
0.4267997146,
-0.6537660956,
-0.3394171298,
-0.0465112142,
-0.211013779,
-0.1711208224,
0.4022032917,
-0.4678967893,
0.2589669526,
0.5959893465,
0.6614983678,
0.1668272763,
0.0691703036,
-0.5090194345,
0.2052959502,
-0.3577493727,
0.9762480855,
-0.5604460239,
-0.2312093675,
0.0326969326,
-0.1124326065,
0.0124535207,
-0.7037882209,
0.2498024255,
-0.5436815619,
-0.0762156993,
-0.1894479543,
-0.5476107001,
0.2140656263,
0.4224432707,
-0.6103314757,
0.9506604075,
0.2425162196,
-0.5349620581,
0.6071830988,
-0.7006807923,
-0.5042676926,
0.2093254328,
-0.5022193193,
-0.2927522957,
-0.3839181662,
0.3493848145,
0.7129315138,
-0.6776752472,
0.361953944,
-0.1790649295,
-0.0451393798,
0.1983569264,
-0.1517064869,
0.6903364658,
0.5148078203,
0.1894932389,
-0.0235134587,
-0.8902024031,
0.0020700644,
0.1406713873,
-0.4240754843,
-0.6192279458,
0.046679806,
-0.1143546253,
0.1431788355,
0.3086293638,
-0.3886452317,
0.5130569339,
-0.4034285247,
0.1992820501,
0.3596495092,
-0.0138664981,
-0.0618525594,
-0.6809700131,
0.7023870945,
0.2923010588,
0.3774751723,
-0.0895492062,
-0.7654219866,
-0.7703761458,
-0.5897121429,
0.2972233295,
0.5406342149,
-0.7239049077,
0.4859857261,
-0.4429357946,
-0.6706447005,
-0.8383827209,
-0.0851131752,
0.4352457225,
0.7183514237,
0.4627601504,
0.1194346398,
-0.5287400484,
-0.8509020209,
-0.1081055328,
0.2082206607,
-0.2791166604,
0.4345726371,
0.0531864688,
-0.384234041,
0.763909936,
-0.5369294286,
-0.6904631257,
-0.4289419353,
-0.2352175117,
0.5251728892,
0.2433079928,
0.4826248288,
-0.73543787,
-0.6376860142,
0.4894113243,
-1.0263662338,
-0.3323768973,
0.3936035037,
0.1572057903,
-0.2311942726,
0.5456463695,
-0.3989389241,
0.2849740386,
0.4323163331,
-0.7477144599,
0.1169677898,
-0.6301404238,
0.2977340221,
-1.2997589111,
0.0463597141,
-0.1404543966,
-0.4069168568,
-0.5565139055,
-0.1840545088,
0.1469573826,
-0.4384262562,
0.0973384976,
0.2886113524,
-0.3481405079,
-0.1384034008,
0.0896217898,
0.3907350004,
0.0795616806,
-0.0527187586,
-0.3689902127,
0.4027789831,
0.5753470063,
-0.7637901306,
0.5349857807,
0.2414744198,
-0.1156298444,
0.6462430358,
-0.4283597767,
-0.1577178091,
-0.2609407306,
-0.0391629897,
-1.1091185808,
-0.150717631,
0.2698762119,
-0.5256417394,
0.6259406209,
-0.3094335198,
-0.7271393538,
-0.1392218918,
0.0879185647,
0.5404632092,
0.6107925177,
-0.7083576322,
1.094080925,
0.2361878306,
-0.0640861914,
-0.5048106313,
-0.9166901112,
-0.0776065439,
0.010664124,
-0.8184589744,
0.5058605075,
0.2151325345,
-0.2073720843,
0.3979261518,
0.4763047397,
-0.185786888,
-0.1437673718,
-0.0018192828,
0.3463073671,
-0.5643603802,
0.5577654839,
0.1499824524,
-0.5033980608,
-0.1390904635,
-0.2605858445,
0.6393519044,
0.0855193809,
-0.7323673368,
-0.3594635427,
0.2401618212,
0.8915940523,
-0.1411912888,
0.7617385983,
0.3328442872,
-0.535374105,
-0.0285827406,
-0.6055087447,
0.1772231013,
-0.4012161493,
0.2279711813,
-0.2924521267,
-0.6054012179,
0.7245849967,
-0.4282212555,
-0.2103169411,
0.3981072605,
0.413621515,
0.0322559923,
1.3284529448,
0.5608788133,
-0.2196440548,
-0.1619858146,
-0.0832477733,
0.4162291288,
-1.0064589977,
-0.6229605675,
-0.4721525908,
-0.0857840627,
-0.579690814,
-0.336894244,
0.8469050527,
-0.1622079611,
-0.153896898,
-0.3200849891,
-0.7977382541,
0.3880652785,
0.0068552759,
0.6469992399,
0.4860490859,
-0.0757854581,
-0.4963041246,
-0.3472985029,
-1.0150341988,
-0.2459203005,
1.2484043837,
0.1640577316,
0.6306908131,
0.3151451051,
0.7617161274,
0.4967271686,
0.7018501759,
-0.9781237245,
0.2885614634,
-0.5722454786,
-0.1687742919,
-0.0215838235,
-0.2808790207,
-1.1295496225,
0.2721175849,
-0.0174372308,
-0.3668628931,
0.0700983405,
0.3098858595,
-0.4645791352,
0.236798957,
-0.4331494868,
0.8894358873,
-0.2179795653,
0.1086256206,
-0.1618537903,
-0.3728584945,
0.2747083008,
0.0037843764,
0.5645808578,
0.0845705122,
-0.2990073562,
0.9426881075,
-0.535046041,
0.8078407645,
-0.2907785773,
0.2132507265,
-0.3149045408,
0.0906790867,
0.3809770644,
-0.3277706504,
0.1533739716,
-0.2708361149,
-0.1256791353,
-0.1425355077,
-0.7841358781,
0.6039068699,
-0.6686813235,
-0.1881290078,
-0.1412278116,
-0.3571671844,
-0.3690072596,
0.462615639,
0.0578986891,
0.9675430655,
0.1575652063,
-0.0438460521,
0.8836969733,
-0.427609235,
-0.3121794164,
0.8388710022,
-0.4392282069,
-0.4610632062,
0.8128447533,
0.267439872,
0.0906391516,
0.3791766763,
0.5131183267,
-0.04837678,
-0.3771198094,
-0.1934787631,
0.2864251435,
-1.0963162184,
-0.4667183161,
-0.6974008083,
-0.1161009669,
-0.2741749585,
-0.3268761933,
-0.3201677203,
-0.3069609106,
-0.2181662619,
0.1171865314,
0.7771699429,
0.7666894197,
-0.1794578284,
-0.0139758429,
-0.7588714957,
0.4672155678,
-0.2039945722,
0.440384537,
0.1041706875,
-0.4957225323,
-0.1849983037,
-0.291156143,
0.2196199596,
-0.8714606762,
0.4619779587,
-0.0903877243,
0.6423609853,
0.8386787176,
0.0115635777,
0.9748138189,
-0.4923549294,
0.374897331,
0.2375559509,
-0.424408108,
0.741247952,
-0.3233220577,
-0.0801625922,
0.1332141757,
0.5910599828,
-0.721532464,
-0.3775468171,
-0.4451045394,
-0.5634021163,
0.2210902274,
-0.3360518813,
-0.497458607,
-0.0917605013,
0.4986694753,
-0.3510707319,
-0.4226282537,
-0.2364711761,
-0.6726887822,
0.2256462723,
-0.843936801,
-0.0571780391,
-0.2862508893,
-0.274177134,
-0.5686950684,
0.4124311805,
0.1739080548,
0.4714201391,
0.6940191984,
0.0294426773,
-0.0096407849,
0.028414188,
0.3768058419,
0.6062085032,
0.1341445893,
0.0841119885,
0.0774727389,
-0.4454683363,
-0.0095571028,
0.2520447373,
0.1211779192,
0.1365565658,
0.3587203622,
0.1199209094,
0.5442219377,
-0.6529628634,
0.6043441296,
0.0377858356,
-0.0898237601,
-0.5284249187,
-0.2029835433,
0.2198145092,
0.4670614898,
0.2095121443,
-0.0015843207,
0.1411585659,
-0.1152140573,
0.3023229539,
0.3051080704,
-0.4401064217,
0.0631026104,
0.4833654463,
0.1034722999,
-0.4755415022,
0.7604942322,
-0.1169245839,
-0.4259993136,
0.7388871312,
0.6851266026,
0.3544491529,
-0.3540067375,
-0.1978659034,
0.0641777664,
0.5445312858,
0.1116419882,
0.3912696242,
0.0992328674,
-0.8704845905,
-0.5053207874,
-0.208979249,
-0.300093472,
0.3236402273,
-0.5746109486,
0.5869216323,
-0.3577732444,
-0.1083804071,
0.1735395491,
-0.3336084485,
-0.4938194752,
0.2078337818,
-0.0822828487,
0.9889161587,
-0.8949256539,
0.6455699801,
0.6969615817,
-0.5206375718,
-0.927210331,
-0.4615316391,
0.0614289604,
-1.0762786865,
0.8509146571,
0.0517541729,
0.2904775441,
0.0971454531,
-0.1160054803,
-0.7783856988,
1.4641461372,
0.1666226685,
-0.1849414259,
0.1950013191,
0.1250625849,
0.5723337531,
-0.4860675335,
0.1888185143,
0.5520939231,
0.5018712282,
-0.048319228,
-1.0234726667,
0.3156389594,
-0.3761830628,
-0.3184074759,
0.7616456151,
-0.2926431894,
0.7637732029,
-0.1263261139,
0.0733199045,
-0.031672474,
0.1396292597,
0.2271712422,
0.3090166152,
0.0913294405,
0.8742899895,
0.9657543302,
0.1152760163,
1.2836328745,
-0.5573730469,
-0.0553485304,
0.5291025639,
-0.0823133588,
0.6071308255,
0.2678417563,
-0.4066163898,
0.4397442043,
0.5241219997,
-0.1066736802,
0.3490882516,
-0.0998143628,
-0.5475929379,
-0.3664709032,
-0.362246573,
-0.5505279303,
0.0685559809,
0.7414414883,
-0.7813814878,
-0.4524887204,
0.0961888507,
0.090117611,
-0.1004098356,
-0.2644411027,
0.7420956492,
-0.1737014651,
-0.3516385257,
0.4113534391,
-0.0342039503,
0.4511527419,
-0.7127600908,
-0.4067832828,
-0.1093596816,
0.3807848394,
-0.3877772689,
-0.540299356,
0.1784178764,
-0.0528313145,
-0.1919112056,
0.1370216012,
1.2098908424,
-0.3466280401,
-0.4237243533,
0.1987768412,
0.482288748,
0.4833162129,
0.3938409984,
-0.4613167346,
-0.1286834031,
-0.1606670022,
0.0875683352,
0.4351429641,
0.7072950006,
0.2519825101,
1.0122175217,
0.6496952176,
0.2699428201,
-0.1457073838,
0.3220323622,
0.9892482162,
-0.3523358107,
-0.4481518269,
-0.8116001487,
0.4917849004,
-0.1497343779,
-0.1602229774,
0.3308108151,
0.5902497172,
0.2917285264,
-0.0367647707,
0.7769367099,
-0.0126669118,
0.732232213,
-0.5201326013,
1.117361784,
-0.545468986,
0.2686783373,
-0.027842043,
0.0236395821,
-0.6605238318,
0.6223606467,
-0.0964653865,
-0.0073567089,
0.6355467439,
0.814411521,
-0.1630062461,
-0.4553257525,
0.6301016212,
0.2314122766,
0.327647239,
0.6109607816,
0.7887938023,
-0.2853317261,
0.6317347884,
-0.3025327623,
-0.4648496211,
-0.2798103988,
-0.7473704219,
-0.8040043712,
-0.344273746,
-0.297303915,
-0.2920583785,
0.0806696713,
0.9426826835,
0.5421611667,
-0.3874210417,
0.2243073434,
0.006454715,
0.0628667101,
-0.117870599,
-0.2252617925,
0.5642721653,
-0.3280789554,
-0.0831087902,
0.4613080323,
0.2855593562,
-0.1440407783,
-0.1672178209,
-0.033872325,
0.2365676165,
-0.5665888786,
0.7064854503,
0.1007242054,
-0.7296257019,
0.1483352631,
-0.1236323044,
0.0079605803,
-0.0432591662,
0.8343749046,
-0.8930876255,
0.5745892525,
0.2461750209,
0.7752018571,
0.0610180609,
-0.4231404662,
0.5128840208,
-0.393756181,
0.0246242899,
0.3518436551,
0.5221712589,
0.1798096597,
-0.6088011265,
0.3769457638,
0.2199790925,
-0.3929752111,
-0.72699368,
0.0859404951,
-0.6886941195,
-0.1846455336,
0.9406906366,
-0.0954381824,
0.021179175,
-0.6458476186,
-0.0253489632,
0.4323000312,
-0.0727234781,
0.654222846,
0.3679327071,
-0.7273076177,
-0.0171862878,
-0.5701976418,
0.5115589499,
0.3494409621,
-0.7652404904,
-0.2057209164,
0.3742853105,
0.5531216264,
0.1148906425,
0.9052047729,
-0.4246344268,
0.6709614396,
-0.1713226438,
-0.087029703,
-0.4770962894,
-0.0021580369,
-0.2453847826,
-0.0521832742,
0.3444429338,
-0.0987457782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14322v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14322v2 | Mind the Privacy Unit! User-Level Differential Privacy for Language Model Fine-Tuning | 2024-06-20T13:54:32 | 2024-07-03T14:05:20 | Lynn Chua, Badih Ghazi, Yangsibo Huang, Pritish Kamath, Ravi Kumar, Daogao Liu, Pasin Manurangsi, Amer Sinha, Chiyuan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools for tackling
complex tasks across diverse domains, but they also raise privacy concerns when
fine-tuned on sensitive data due to potential memorization. While differential
privacy (DP) offers a promising solution by ensuring models are 'almost
indistinguishable' with or without any particular privacy unit, current
evaluations on LLMs mostly treat each example (text record) as the privacy
unit. This leads to uneven user privacy guarantees when contributions per user
vary. We therefore study user-level DP motivated by applications where it
necessary to ensure uniform privacy protection across users. We present a
systematic evaluation of user-level DP for LLM fine-tuning on natural language
generation tasks. Focusing on two mechanisms for achieving user-level DP
guarantees, Group Privacy and User-wise DP-SGD, we investigate design choices
like data selection strategies and parameter tuning for the best
privacy-utility tradeoff. | [
-0.4448276162,
-0.660051167,
0.4833098948,
0.1995059252,
-0.1144546568,
0.2411993742,
-0.2132522017,
-0.4209703505,
-0.2930231094,
0.6421937346,
-0.5906703472,
-0.7583540678,
-0.3179380894,
0.0836388692,
-0.2910038531,
0.8839023113,
0.2512460053,
-0.2120859623,
-0.0875012204,
0.1481816918,
-0.3435259163,
-0.749904871,
-0.7207592726,
-0.1567404717,
0.5493841171,
0.4156296551,
0.8406722546,
0.6722635627,
0.3972657621,
0.3219856918,
-0.1086939797,
0.1676144451,
-0.5434235334,
0.2095068991,
-0.3199474216,
-0.2974481285,
-0.6784195304,
0.0113669587,
0.5905089974,
0.6743603945,
-0.0966805667,
0.195725292,
0.1992479712,
0.8168365955,
-0.6969236135,
-0.07046967,
-0.6357016563,
-0.0140411193,
-0.1981439888,
-0.1542358696,
-0.3138903677,
-0.6068232656,
-0.0517636538,
-0.0984108448,
0.3484039009,
0.1342734545,
0.4950025082,
0.360504657,
-0.3503737152,
-0.0081947558,
-0.8103985786,
0.6209641695,
-0.7503029108,
0.5050053,
0.6281530261,
-0.0215968862,
-0.2806479633,
-0.3409089148,
-0.4097295702,
-0.38017416,
-0.1280323416,
-0.312651813,
-0.1901075989,
0.281539768,
0.4200243056,
0.6611600518,
-0.4432091415,
0.599838376,
0.0395281129,
-0.0836246684,
0.9665115476,
0.2916300297,
0.2789016962,
-0.0238600764,
-0.107023105,
0.0700772703,
-0.8114156127,
0.016546974,
0.8955928683,
0.3295394182,
-0.1321841031,
0.5501059294,
-0.5417422652,
0.5909346342,
0.1524313092,
-0.1064756811,
-0.0568681546,
-0.0779110789,
-0.2785927057,
-0.0894892365,
0.9024044871,
0.3565140069,
0.482714653,
-0.5467969179,
-0.3671393096,
0.0645826533,
0.2085400373,
-0.625736773,
-0.2326755077,
0.0934540331,
-0.1251269281,
-0.5005229115,
-0.1084741428,
-0.6221334338,
-0.4784224331,
-0.5205382705,
0.2241645455,
-0.165589273,
-0.2484387308,
0.2804283798,
0.1604663134,
-0.2420921326,
-0.1091785729,
-1.5320067406,
0.6610262394,
0.7585399747,
0.4809420109,
-0.4060899019,
-0.3023711741,
-0.4201574922,
0.312110424,
-0.2715310156,
0.3287495971,
-0.5945625305,
-0.609394908,
-0.0955663398,
-0.2575335205,
0.049754858,
-0.5235339403,
0.332126379,
-0.388507396,
0.2797711194,
-0.3369657993,
-0.5368254185,
0.2120353878,
-0.2043758929,
-0.3711648583,
0.8963673115,
0.2277646065,
-0.7474170327,
0.5981103778,
-0.6461051106,
-0.5388273001,
0.2197716087,
-0.2251367122,
-0.4073012769,
0.3808194697,
0.2212370038,
0.7096034884,
-0.0480029397,
0.3063111007,
-0.2902867198,
-0.1668854803,
0.4543463588,
-0.392986089,
0.6878972054,
0.4087386131,
-0.2067405134,
0.0742888078,
-0.9935619235,
-0.1208832264,
-0.0388411768,
-0.360131979,
-0.5299232006,
-0.0710407197,
-0.1247274205,
-0.004384493,
0.4613237083,
-0.5346011519,
0.0857770145,
-0.3401076496,
0.5513420105,
1.0018473864,
-0.0532966666,
0.7140030265,
-0.3214200437,
0.5666355491,
-0.1268459857,
0.2632914186,
0.2800137103,
-0.37646541,
-0.354246974,
-0.2175641656,
0.3778325617,
0.1891577244,
-0.1372619569,
0.6446383595,
-0.0104110613,
-0.2145193368,
-0.3442872763,
0.2952438593,
0.4392286837,
0.5073919892,
-0.0079334434,
-0.2421745658,
-0.1387366205,
-1.0796546936,
-0.3797507882,
-0.03457449,
-0.1885338426,
0.6353060007,
-0.0260916688,
-0.3850174546,
0.9402905703,
-0.6237402558,
-0.2543936968,
-0.2384704649,
-0.1819751412,
-0.0950489193,
0.4401890934,
0.4306242466,
-0.7861361504,
-0.4939268231,
-0.1102997884,
-0.4658679366,
-0.3691002131,
-0.017085975,
-0.286452502,
0.4347158074,
0.3112509251,
-0.4542585909,
0.461458236,
0.5673593879,
-0.25815925,
0.0397525467,
-0.5304535627,
-0.0346559435,
-1.0758112669,
-0.13741301,
0.0536668822,
-0.5424861312,
-0.7519681454,
0.3012444675,
0.1999235153,
-0.0776629746,
-0.4348827004,
0.4012557268,
-0.4311008453,
-0.2172069997,
-0.1981278658,
-0.0974837765,
-0.2374069989,
0.3266088068,
-0.2126478106,
0.7533499002,
0.6150690317,
-0.8183193803,
0.0276619997,
0.0171912443,
-0.0728413835,
0.3053371012,
-0.3630667031,
0.5463061333,
0.0502790622,
-0.180982098,
-0.9048530459,
-0.4425930381,
0.1465809196,
-0.1539227068,
0.5087637901,
0.0495662875,
-0.6875081658,
-0.1669036746,
-0.2759200633,
0.2794861495,
0.6113968492,
-0.5398624539,
0.2013723403,
0.7820144892,
-0.1758397818,
-0.5412778854,
-0.6567010283,
0.260779202,
-0.3927930295,
-0.6722728014,
0.3899449408,
-0.2095790058,
-0.3880776465,
-0.1711126268,
-0.2225932479,
-0.134753108,
0.4574615657,
0.3789158762,
-0.0024840317,
0.1225038096,
-0.0473282374,
0.3137073815,
-0.2503588796,
-0.0222067125,
0.0214818101,
0.6440578699,
-0.0733381212,
-0.1821625084,
-0.587655127,
0.4098674655,
0.133465603,
-0.0425187461,
0.5315937996,
0.1427749693,
-0.3518956602,
-0.3188973367,
-0.6148543954,
-0.1722856611,
-0.5702449679,
0.0685264245,
-0.4015339911,
-1.1138757467,
0.5208621025,
0.1016756669,
0.2431863993,
0.0723040476,
0.7713782191,
0.137801826,
0.9508980513,
0.989449501,
-0.4373266399,
0.3107415736,
0.1496765763,
0.2929715514,
-0.6570575237,
-0.0187955834,
-0.463244766,
-0.5325161815,
-0.8707901239,
0.1483332068,
0.0425675698,
0.106878683,
-0.0792645589,
0.3707161844,
-0.6796979308,
0.7466354966,
0.5333245397,
0.0895770639,
0.6544420123,
0.0858424753,
0.1918199956,
0.0044255727,
-0.3625575602,
-0.6589004397,
1.132750988,
0.3472030759,
1.129997015,
0.1784150153,
1.2255631685,
0.2734357119,
0.0088785272,
-0.4355275333,
0.8247705102,
-0.5803512931,
-0.4761716425,
-0.5384193659,
-0.5830318928,
-0.9383593798,
0.1248092651,
0.2111094147,
-1.1173778772,
0.0581042953,
0.3124002814,
-0.3742878139,
0.100802213,
-0.7377647161,
0.539116323,
-0.0363776535,
-0.4445967078,
-0.1187396273,
-0.6004971266,
0.4926046729,
-0.2472505718,
0.0048208674,
-0.2869341373,
0.0143569084,
0.3474220037,
-0.1586842388,
0.7790403962,
-0.2536181808,
-0.3499228656,
-0.2845961452,
0.2271847129,
0.1629107147,
0.6333468556,
-0.0899827778,
0.2307438254,
-0.2925777435,
0.0638005361,
-0.1679491997,
1.1379879713,
-0.6496123672,
-1.0229307413,
-0.1253819466,
-0.8124135137,
-0.2777518034,
0.2488581389,
0.3205580413,
0.1483573169,
-0.1908974499,
0.1310275495,
0.8207195997,
-0.383769244,
0.4861109853,
0.5921064019,
-0.1892362088,
0.1418371499,
0.720318675,
-0.0466892086,
0.4265989661,
0.4905302823,
0.4420130849,
-0.5375664234,
-0.5938975811,
-0.4985356629,
0.1096327305,
-0.3693336248,
-0.0742512494,
-0.6989508271,
-0.3237808049,
-0.4828651249,
-0.1039004326,
-0.3378836513,
-0.4603306651,
-0.4619741738,
-0.2612597942,
0.3040859699,
0.6629298925,
-0.2101040632,
0.1187651157,
-0.3908358216,
0.8784970641,
0.3141561449,
0.5450726748,
-0.4210736156,
-0.4055848718,
0.2086385041,
0.1273858845,
-0.2693280876,
-0.4330571592,
0.3068895042,
0.1141695082,
0.4611773789,
0.1265351325,
0.1866657883,
0.2911966443,
-0.5507407188,
0.6310039163,
-0.0113793714,
-0.8802087903,
0.3858814538,
-0.3166244924,
0.1354652941,
0.6089224219,
0.0168193225,
-0.4132291079,
-0.7635238767,
-0.5541551709,
-0.8632236719,
0.7458766103,
0.1837893873,
0.5592728853,
0.2107374519,
0.4530391097,
0.4167436063,
0.2524022758,
-0.6416687369,
-0.3183268607,
0.1528998762,
-0.0145888943,
-0.160783723,
-0.1256706566,
-0.2282553166,
-0.0784856975,
0.262032479,
0.0628153905,
-0.1133382544,
-0.1299232394,
0.173801139,
-0.2317508459,
0.5597707629,
0.6750911474,
0.765039742,
-0.2298860103,
0.0935718119,
-0.0024278769,
-0.4634878635,
0.2640300393,
0.1904286444,
-0.4444189668,
-0.1601305753,
-0.3445775807,
0.7114526033,
-0.0294419453,
-0.1730594784,
0.2405608743,
-0.4172880054,
-0.4013354182,
-0.0997003913,
0.6644750834,
0.309912771,
0.0040823598,
0.0502436645,
-0.1160213277,
0.2037412226,
-0.3228539824,
0.0541794598,
0.5271710157,
-0.0191903561,
-0.3411265612,
1.0303529501,
0.0116973771,
-0.6965584755,
0.280146569,
-0.1008451432,
0.0153579935,
0.2901001871,
0.3556256592,
1.1930863857,
-0.3612710536,
0.2415214926,
-0.246201992,
0.1533890814,
-0.114926964,
0.4148361087,
-0.1447775215,
-0.6457548141,
-0.0131284194,
-0.7161611915,
-0.4634930193,
0.4452854097,
-0.7509182692,
0.0425057113,
-0.6895912886,
-0.1616863608,
0.0208059158,
-0.0383968763,
-0.7207276225,
0.1893266886,
0.2307617813,
0.5096747875,
-0.4765628576,
0.9524163008,
0.345838964,
0.053656552,
-0.6238524914,
0.1770466864,
-0.0924854353,
-0.6383843422,
0.4858224094,
0.0119597763,
-0.27076599,
0.0556702279,
-0.2645278573,
-0.450085789,
0.8176623583,
0.7237833142,
-1.088355422,
0.1330948025,
0.8046477437,
0.6997174621,
-0.1741189063,
-0.5234332681,
0.701333344,
0.1658399701,
-0.3975405991,
-0.8332306743,
0.1819541752,
0.3172677755,
0.1047529727,
0.285546422,
-0.751491487,
0.7727026939,
-0.1190146357,
-0.3223747611,
-0.0691704676,
0.2215331346,
0.1781314909,
0.3504975736,
0.4916644692,
0.5807314515,
0.8719751835,
0.1397721916,
1.1339300871,
-0.3953356445,
0.0696160793,
1.052713871,
-0.5221291184,
0.5024257302,
0.3665322363,
-0.1946789324,
-0.0076385126,
0.4713070691,
0.2966368496,
0.6111528873,
0.4869781137,
-0.3965193927,
0.0335842669,
0.0299788211,
-0.400057286,
0.1856374592,
0.075967893,
-0.4352798164,
-0.0412042923,
-0.2926012576,
0.0142066739,
0.3409200311,
-0.2330159694,
1.0317608118,
0.2884937227,
-0.4937626719,
0.5332695842,
0.19705984,
0.6402193904,
-0.3900170922,
0.5314560533,
-0.5073290467,
0.2908467054,
-0.3330397904,
-0.7346295714,
0.1601033062,
0.3106724918,
-0.2109166533,
-0.3891328275,
0.6030127406,
-0.3457606435,
-0.3934589922,
0.2283294052,
0.309381932,
0.0413550213,
-0.0585928559,
-0.5645272136,
-0.1616999358,
0.0951055437,
-0.4690212309,
0.7536409497,
0.4872564077,
-0.0410093553,
0.6035766602,
0.6352348328,
0.1247898415,
0.1263490915,
0.647618413,
0.9711982012,
-0.6241757274,
-0.4994732738,
-1.3162544966,
0.278055191,
-0.010336305,
-0.5617488623,
0.8355039358,
0.5741047859,
0.9555316567,
0.0324138813,
0.8954988122,
0.2095738947,
0.5664212108,
-0.5630822778,
0.8069043756,
-0.4470791519,
0.5532945395,
-0.3092505634,
-1.0625700951,
-0.4464046955,
0.3954677284,
-0.1122064367,
-0.2147070318,
0.3301597536,
0.9592721462,
-0.1399927139,
0.1365679204,
0.5272678733,
-0.1476188898,
0.5012270808,
0.4948434234,
0.7600241899,
-0.065854758,
0.0767714083,
-0.5442162752,
-0.119059056,
0.1570336074,
-0.8787945509,
-1.201615572,
-0.3454091251,
-0.3141944408,
0.1181589738,
-0.0111316489,
0.6134053469,
0.7093282342,
-0.6039347649,
-0.3234495819,
-0.426532805,
-0.0636033416,
0.221313566,
-0.1709286273,
0.146938175,
-0.2840832472,
-0.8567075133,
0.4206239879,
0.4577821493,
0.1678596139,
-0.5603949428,
-0.0074907546,
0.313329339,
-0.0060792998,
0.250479579,
0.1671616137,
-0.6341186166,
-0.2105238587,
-0.07425908,
-0.4069029689,
0.0729201958,
0.8817036152,
-0.3618790507,
0.2841606736,
0.4959922433,
0.631316781,
0.3706810772,
0.2851875424,
0.6916521192,
-1.0522699356,
0.1994199008,
0.2880852222,
0.1618998647,
0.365868181,
-0.9151214361,
0.4036255181,
-0.3305774033,
-0.9921864867,
-1.0147634745,
0.4175746739,
-0.8643363118,
-0.2583646178,
1.2329484224,
-0.0582334436,
0.0334189758,
-0.0717624426,
-0.2068225294,
0.0910081342,
-0.7541091442,
0.9704229236,
0.4905824661,
-0.1830807179,
0.0190818515,
-0.4563167095,
0.8519545197,
0.2109476775,
-0.7415630221,
0.55972296,
0.36994645,
0.2508304119,
-0.2648257911,
0.774839282,
-0.0611000359,
-0.1352237761,
-0.3509449065,
-0.3031243384,
-0.2446684688,
-0.3207651675,
-0.4627058804,
0.1053064838,
0.1004133821,
-0.1940168291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14319v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14319v1 | LiveMind: Low-latency Large Language Models with Simultaneous Inference | 2024-06-20T13:52:30 | 2024-06-20T13:52:30 | Chuangtao Chen, Grace Li Zhang, Xunzhao Yin, Cheng Zhuo, Ulf Schlichtmann, Bing Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | In this paper, we introduce a novel low-latency inference framework for large
language models (LLMs) inference which enables LLMs to perform inferences with
incomplete prompts. By reallocating computational processes to prompt input
phase, we achieve a substantial reduction in latency, thereby significantly
enhancing the interactive experience for users of LLMs. The framework adeptly
manages the visibility of the streaming prompt to the model, allowing it to
infer from incomplete prompts or await additional prompts. Compared with
traditional inference methods that utilize complete prompts, our approach
demonstrates an average reduction of 59% in response latency on the MMLU-Pro
dataset, while maintaining comparable accuracy. Additionally, our framework
facilitates collaborative inference and output across different models. By
employing an LLM for inference and a small language model (SLM) for output, we
achieve an average 68% reduction in response latency, alongside a 5.5%
improvement in accuracy on the MMLU-Pro dataset compared with the SLM baseline.
For long prompts exceeding 20 sentences, the response latency can be reduced by
up to 93%. | [
-0.2574795485,
-1.1709250212,
0.8665428162,
0.2893731296,
-0.1580431908,
0.1458546519,
-0.5022808909,
-0.3319764733,
0.4522789419,
0.3460126817,
-1.0617568493,
-0.3328184485,
-0.229469955,
-0.1254591346,
-0.0078348257,
0.3063944578,
0.1911522597,
0.1637526453,
-0.4284826815,
-0.0141246887,
-0.4189961255,
-0.1991617382,
-1.0338791609,
-0.3632290661,
0.8907601833,
0.3990210295,
0.8104279041,
0.258694768,
-0.0569126569,
0.1997749805,
-0.1490664035,
0.1935678273,
-0.5388025045,
0.524086237,
0.2877396047,
-0.5321622491,
-0.5127376318,
-0.169664219,
0.5722856522,
1.1538348198,
-0.0558408462,
0.1589779109,
-0.0305601247,
0.3739750683,
-0.7163046002,
0.1935143918,
-0.2853776813,
0.3914798498,
0.0176980365,
0.2332959324,
-0.6311885118,
-0.280292809,
-0.0041459943,
-0.62157166,
0.0033341167,
-0.0135953743,
0.3523405194,
0.5959168673,
-0.0533891767,
0.2760329843,
-0.6556646228,
0.7036317587,
-1.2514233589,
0.3411313593,
0.3084985018,
0.4118977189,
-0.2287071943,
-0.8190662861,
-1.0178061724,
-0.0171202738,
0.0272952318,
0.2732256353,
0.0611472651,
0.2302247733,
0.4691018164,
0.204936415,
-0.496337235,
0.3917411566,
0.0748705789,
-0.2338524014,
0.4475650489,
0.1543789506,
0.1128951162,
-0.0602608658,
0.2134473175,
0.1628968269,
-0.8973872662,
0.0187529903,
0.2055906802,
0.4787653089,
-0.2917200625,
0.6576245427,
-0.3427804708,
0.954764843,
-0.2474368066,
-0.2572074831,
0.2029574662,
-0.1390295029,
-0.4233757555,
-0.1290737242,
0.9442833662,
0.1653139591,
0.0870368853,
-0.077951774,
-0.1495446265,
0.1087866724,
-0.0731968731,
-0.6603624821,
-0.1491991431,
0.5365974903,
-0.4368419051,
-0.0971261412,
-0.381021142,
-0.8310258389,
-0.6080816388,
-0.1584987044,
0.4355119169,
0.0383626223,
-0.15357095,
-0.0082616583,
0.2881658375,
0.0435704291,
0.809807539,
-0.5552324057,
0.2763977647,
0.6210538745,
0.9937250018,
-0.5123173594,
-0.249156028,
-1.1562281847,
-0.0368072316,
-0.0734838098,
0.7950239182,
-0.5198213458,
-0.1727218926,
0.0744649172,
0.0222943258,
-0.1380807161,
-0.3244572878,
0.3074469864,
-0.7720112801,
0.3788828254,
0.0560241565,
-0.7285653353,
-0.2472701222,
-0.0336080268,
-0.8828592896,
0.9372273684,
-0.198641032,
-0.5917416811,
0.179205671,
-0.6665563583,
-0.4858972132,
0.2876632512,
-0.3413129747,
-0.2024895251,
-0.0491997898,
0.2303726077,
0.6435323954,
-0.2174683213,
0.4622087181,
-0.8319416046,
-0.5773150325,
0.0423246212,
-0.6420148611,
0.7016434073,
0.1384823918,
-0.288685143,
0.366222769,
-0.7678496242,
-0.0272797756,
0.1009985656,
-0.3904848993,
0.0587931387,
0.3983961642,
-0.0642701089,
0.0798033401,
0.0938100293,
-0.6515443921,
0.1708763391,
-0.476072818,
0.3932909071,
0.518411696,
0.0301349983,
0.4600718021,
-0.2206931263,
0.6947209239,
-0.1543104202,
-0.0534241311,
-0.3898161352,
-0.6887921095,
-0.782623589,
-0.6662333012,
0.190101251,
0.7483999133,
-0.8989531398,
0.1775908768,
-0.3746396005,
-0.2444142699,
-0.8838086724,
0.0548767075,
0.2060648203,
0.3870287836,
0.1000112966,
0.1561674029,
-0.3184047639,
-0.6420243979,
-0.1888824701,
-0.071871303,
-0.3806086481,
0.4211805761,
0.0844968259,
-0.1161284819,
0.9391373396,
-0.6249434948,
0.2400206774,
-0.3502217829,
-0.0549476892,
0.8694466949,
0.2956889868,
0.156138435,
-0.6629439592,
-0.5317870975,
-0.5299113989,
-0.844771266,
-0.1985314935,
-0.1434141248,
0.035719417,
0.0943107456,
0.4906032681,
-0.7160134315,
0.5404150486,
0.666747272,
-0.2869473994,
0.368029952,
-0.1412556618,
0.0065421197,
-1.0693013668,
-0.2410256118,
-0.2191571146,
-0.599085927,
-0.5280568004,
-0.0028767141,
-0.1021192968,
-0.2398792803,
-0.5840386748,
0.9860431552,
-0.5410499573,
-0.1992368996,
-0.0180431195,
0.3383132219,
-0.0071609574,
0.7342249155,
0.1446389109,
1.1277450323,
0.5046514273,
-0.6183903217,
0.4730081558,
0.113673009,
-0.3874477148,
0.2479083836,
-0.7372632623,
0.0930867791,
0.1041116044,
0.2545958757,
-1.2561104298,
-0.469047904,
0.1976890713,
-0.5390281677,
0.2104935646,
-0.2183873355,
-0.878837347,
-0.4239073992,
-0.273307234,
0.2167828679,
0.6164737344,
-0.5100999475,
0.6685113907,
0.3358423114,
-0.4304279387,
-0.3367895782,
-0.8114430904,
0.0027596673,
0.0363114625,
-0.6838054657,
-0.0346126631,
-0.3293421865,
-0.3029409051,
-0.1018920913,
0.1578613222,
-0.0242600124,
0.2647892535,
0.5502079725,
0.3248159885,
-0.4791259468,
0.0247556008,
0.3922507763,
0.0114376731,
-0.0385259576,
-0.4268903434,
0.5036673546,
0.3398737311,
-0.7742117643,
-0.4862410128,
0.4382300079,
0.498249203,
0.0827706903,
1.2016094923,
0.3237280548,
-0.625361681,
-0.189286828,
-0.5251867771,
-0.3105736971,
-0.3929999173,
-0.1207618564,
-0.3687475622,
-1.3163315058,
0.7170075178,
-0.0064842226,
0.1509414613,
0.1606607288,
0.7820422053,
-0.2307784557,
0.9149977565,
0.3512133956,
0.1324676871,
0.529878974,
0.0968632177,
0.2801030576,
-0.7020527124,
-0.1368014216,
-0.2658061385,
-0.0425347053,
-0.2281373888,
-0.8538184166,
0.3185316324,
0.1024804637,
-0.1545932442,
-0.1042870507,
0.0350391045,
0.3303097785,
0.6311221123,
0.3141641319,
0.3721633255,
0.0859460086,
-0.6475424767,
-0.2568434775,
-0.8564029336,
-0.406763643,
0.7035800815,
0.3316782713,
0.8540208936,
0.3090839982,
0.2899660468,
0.6077307463,
0.279545635,
-0.8715459704,
0.5661162734,
0.1635418981,
-0.631604135,
-0.4751278162,
-0.4306210577,
-0.6656013131,
0.3216139376,
-0.2951320112,
-1.0812186003,
-0.2522825599,
0.2108424306,
-0.9333990216,
0.3807370067,
-0.7959193587,
0.8642365336,
0.1695090681,
-0.8299373388,
-0.1148560271,
-0.5869578719,
0.5202769041,
-0.2920449376,
0.2414820194,
-0.2445602566,
-0.0396927334,
0.8717958331,
-0.6801372766,
1.2298287153,
-0.3482736349,
-0.1657820195,
0.2059452236,
0.0474952944,
0.5314047933,
0.347871244,
-0.2048773617,
-0.0003445737,
-0.2327236831,
-0.4490825534,
-0.5830780268,
0.7897601128,
-0.5981385112,
-0.3349917829,
-0.1841730177,
-0.4699445665,
-0.443610549,
0.4110505581,
-0.031508889,
0.5091451406,
0.0182646047,
-0.1042721197,
0.8778188229,
-0.5538520217,
0.7322324514,
0.6086651087,
-0.4746045172,
-0.5696641803,
0.4845159352,
-0.1061715409,
0.3653274477,
0.4566023648,
-0.1089614928,
-0.4375884831,
-0.609099865,
-0.4798320234,
0.4833707511,
-0.6799632907,
-0.0076344288,
-1.0399304628,
-0.0522724725,
-0.5495596528,
-0.051784873,
-0.3974397779,
-0.3105026782,
-0.5077629089,
0.1621204019,
0.3598192632,
0.5931443572,
0.061645288,
0.9518184662,
-0.9886897206,
0.5116578341,
0.3395598829,
0.3341879249,
0.2371677309,
-0.7451979518,
-0.1035845131,
0.1114145145,
0.2772962153,
-0.8812933564,
0.351988107,
0.1660631299,
0.6225498319,
0.5097623467,
0.2729004622,
0.6800260544,
-0.6621079445,
1.0500330925,
0.1966191232,
-0.7734289765,
0.3633505404,
-0.3930585384,
0.6127067804,
0.5605848432,
0.1416750103,
-0.7841103077,
-0.3618856966,
-0.4690424204,
-0.7657837868,
0.7405361533,
0.1441443861,
-0.0977032706,
-0.0267198738,
0.261174202,
0.1766381115,
0.3606311977,
-0.5903173685,
-0.4842571914,
0.4499083459,
-0.2334696501,
-0.21572043,
-0.4240611792,
0.1099290624,
-0.2338721156,
0.6330607533,
-0.403976649,
0.5673992634,
-0.0704593882,
-0.3227196634,
-0.1542643607,
0.0788689852,
0.6776643991,
0.7122090459,
-0.217175141,
0.1536475867,
0.3676143289,
-0.346576035,
0.0083468603,
0.1725585908,
-0.3481334448,
0.111686185,
0.8661633134,
1.0444674492,
0.4541382194,
-0.7530834079,
0.5459886789,
-0.5545711517,
0.1794190258,
-0.5658125877,
0.0941715688,
0.5467019081,
0.4878925085,
0.3996942341,
0.0246511512,
-0.2560300529,
-0.1661190242,
0.1914494336,
0.2384417206,
-0.4538920224,
-0.3015525043,
0.9745759368,
0.1991840154,
-0.6016337872,
0.504445076,
-0.200773403,
-0.3491780758,
0.3261815608,
0.2912603915,
0.8099299669,
0.1154192165,
0.17241548,
0.2264026254,
-0.1232444793,
-0.0477304943,
0.4131788313,
-0.2546647489,
-0.7480524182,
-1.109783411,
-0.8091786504,
-0.6070455313,
0.3040415645,
-0.6000598073,
0.1370805949,
-0.292686671,
0.0063384431,
-0.033521425,
0.1397988945,
-0.4311423004,
-0.0238913801,
0.5129916668,
1.1725111008,
-0.855155468,
0.9889221191,
0.659645319,
-0.266748935,
-0.709854424,
-0.0048519853,
0.2841317058,
-0.7749361992,
0.4135475755,
0.2274133861,
-0.2085237354,
0.253896445,
-0.7455198765,
-0.5747994184,
0.9318562746,
0.5034303665,
-0.7398962975,
0.0762316212,
-0.319894433,
0.3988180757,
-0.4517931342,
0.5011636615,
0.3408104181,
0.3656505346,
0.4542859197,
-0.7414606214,
0.0445947237,
0.0004511513,
-0.3002383709,
0.0110211782,
-0.4133406579,
0.7163199186,
-0.3574225605,
-0.3150879145,
0.0379122421,
1.0444946289,
0.6462203264,
0.4781773984,
0.5003973842,
0.4820005894,
0.9935121536,
0.0964377299,
0.9220259786,
-0.1083380207,
0.3380323648,
1.5300091505,
-0.5073276162,
1.0446881056,
0.5800536871,
-0.4233378768,
0.1934331059,
1.0519533157,
0.4060929716,
0.4519398808,
0.1355365366,
-0.6090887785,
-0.595929563,
-0.0569258928,
-0.1246565282,
-0.074995622,
0.3598155379,
0.1263339669,
-0.1427391917,
0.0666387752,
0.4359197915,
-0.0968222842,
-0.0650560334,
0.7284648418,
0.198314473,
-0.8876697421,
0.459546715,
-0.2769719958,
0.856287837,
-0.4719250202,
-0.1113846973,
-0.6216359138,
0.1998892874,
-0.0094145257,
-0.5843251348,
0.0657925606,
0.0436543748,
-0.2846276462,
-0.2088188976,
0.5131582618,
-0.451415211,
-0.3980632424,
0.4946230054,
0.8140550256,
0.3396365345,
-0.2709660232,
-0.5939238071,
0.1480283886,
0.0390322804,
-0.410246551,
0.0907910168,
0.4843329489,
0.1494196206,
0.7955108285,
0.7677251697,
0.5199502707,
0.3366150856,
0.329937309,
0.8832331896,
-0.6599427462,
-0.4459082782,
-0.8620696068,
0.3593770564,
-0.2164805084,
0.215077728,
0.6530897617,
0.4443484545,
0.5139251351,
-0.2048545927,
0.8390237689,
-0.0450651944,
0.8244351745,
-0.6727291346,
0.9371429086,
-0.6849233508,
0.4773947001,
-0.0544002764,
-0.826892674,
-0.4505915344,
0.4999140203,
-0.2127692848,
-0.1139163151,
0.7176625729,
0.8397202492,
-0.12890248,
-0.1780897379,
0.6141664982,
0.2827689052,
0.2072210014,
0.5240598321,
0.8101792336,
-0.1887499392,
0.1427795291,
-0.0228144955,
-0.1189731881,
-0.2516756058,
-1.0000352859,
-1.1379326582,
-0.1992676258,
-0.3013856113,
-0.4804324806,
-0.0419614092,
1.0694820881,
0.7767295837,
-1.059925437,
-0.1066306159,
0.1740237772,
0.3540248573,
-0.0621474348,
-0.2051864564,
0.1753304899,
-0.1617092341,
-0.6647409797,
0.6694601774,
0.2811998725,
-0.0800388679,
-0.4777129889,
-0.3335576057,
-0.5387684107,
0.1011119261,
0.5681613088,
0.2683585882,
-0.8795772791,
-0.2541627288,
0.0363365598,
-0.0824231803,
-0.0828253105,
0.6698312759,
-1.0124607086,
0.4229384363,
0.6340135932,
0.829770565,
0.6196817756,
-0.2471832484,
0.6640582085,
-0.6932436824,
0.4009834826,
0.1743906438,
0.3418999314,
0.2964857817,
-0.3142583072,
0.3899640739,
0.5945281386,
-0.2571608722,
-0.8583795428,
0.253605783,
-1.0276777744,
-0.2293267846,
1.2114949226,
-0.4797092378,
-0.541400075,
-0.0610365942,
0.1348540485,
0.5291230679,
-0.5259739161,
0.1321574748,
0.6661685109,
-0.073806271,
-0.5820385814,
-0.9798386693,
0.296377182,
0.4398095906,
-0.9578720927,
0.0582610704,
0.7505316138,
0.0608787313,
-0.0859490484,
0.8594667315,
0.4779877067,
-0.0479845069,
0.0797262266,
0.0794124752,
-0.0214236174,
-0.2832235098,
-0.549601078,
0.2247590572,
0.0307132117,
-0.1570099145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14318v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14318v1 | The Fire Thief Is Also the Keeper: Balancing Usability and Privacy in Prompts | 2024-06-20T13:52:25 | 2024-06-20T13:52:25 | Zhili Shen, Zihang Xi, Ying He, Wei Tong, Jingyu Hua, Sheng Zhong | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | The rapid adoption of online chatbots represents a significant advancement in
artificial intelligence. However, this convenience brings considerable privacy
concerns, as prompts can inadvertently contain sensitive information exposed to
large language models (LLMs). Limited by high computational costs, reduced task
usability, and excessive system modifications, previous works based on local
deployment, embedding perturbation, and homomorphic encryption are inapplicable
to online prompt-based LLM applications.
To address these issues, this paper introduces Prompt Privacy Sanitizer
(i.e., ProSan), an end-to-end prompt privacy protection framework that can
produce anonymized prompts with contextual privacy removed while maintaining
task usability and human readability. It can also be seamlessly integrated into
the online LLM service pipeline. To achieve high usability and dynamic
anonymity, ProSan flexibly adjusts its protection targets and strength based on
the importance of the words and the privacy leakage risk of the prompts.
Additionally, ProSan is capable of adapting to diverse computational resource
conditions, ensuring privacy protection even for mobile devices with limited
computing power. Our experiments demonstrate that ProSan effectively removes
private information across various tasks, including question answering, text
summarization, and code generation, with minimal reduction in task performance. | [
-0.1244622618,
-0.8010131717,
0.4532234967,
0.2841273248,
-0.226145193,
0.4182177782,
0.1354787797,
-0.4673057497,
0.0837944224,
0.6630336642,
-0.7006735802,
-0.2696036696,
-0.2848324478,
0.3706990182,
-0.038741041,
0.9125946164,
0.3869673014,
-0.2542567551,
-0.1344407797,
0.2520922422,
-0.3422887921,
-0.3739177585,
-0.6583015323,
0.1610007733,
0.3750717044,
0.332488358,
1.0547744036,
0.6224991083,
0.6275451183,
0.3466628492,
-0.2872429788,
-0.1485141963,
-0.46937567,
0.6797832847,
-0.2588415146,
-0.4662230611,
-0.194064647,
-0.2911560535,
0.119383052,
-0.0693126321,
0.0313209221,
0.0070951488,
0.0238371938,
0.4558414519,
-0.8999952078,
-0.0154806897,
-0.3589311242,
0.0445211157,
-0.2379121631,
-0.3271566331,
-0.2490326166,
-0.7473743558,
0.0905485302,
-0.6382750273,
0.0322481357,
0.2265215218,
0.7102102637,
0.4921109378,
-0.2016481608,
0.0022142341,
-0.6487048864,
0.6059676409,
-0.6090274453,
0.1161093116,
0.6297483444,
0.653404355,
-0.3909500539,
-0.57018888,
-0.6594884992,
0.0132491458,
-0.2362792492,
0.044921238,
-0.2822825909,
0.2297178656,
0.109268941,
0.1742744297,
-0.7348024845,
-0.0718001798,
0.0146402819,
-0.555781126,
0.7470294237,
0.2709767222,
0.5561544299,
-0.2424353361,
-0.5728100538,
-0.0346477479,
-0.7069247961,
0.5159082413,
0.566626668,
0.122266531,
0.0282868538,
0.0471063666,
-0.3202035129,
0.3150782287,
0.0989283249,
-0.4279799163,
0.1518439502,
-0.3890037835,
0.016234044,
0.0488114767,
0.8980353475,
0.5703799725,
0.3109417558,
-0.4568480849,
0.0658128932,
-0.1822835803,
0.1927939355,
-0.8781166673,
-0.3248206377,
0.3743914962,
-0.4732354283,
-0.5572407246,
0.0046288637,
-0.9789947867,
-0.937499702,
0.2015336007,
0.2149571627,
0.1037578806,
-0.2665388584,
-0.1168230698,
-0.1385043561,
0.0524904393,
0.1903951466,
-0.7676400542,
0.1703444421,
0.5189164877,
0.8877759576,
-0.1165499464,
0.0795658082,
-0.6041890383,
0.1478072554,
0.0751465783,
0.3982997835,
-0.7647308707,
-0.8996870518,
-0.0447006412,
0.2453500926,
-0.0114991944,
-0.5030728579,
0.4013130069,
-0.7562656403,
0.2614860833,
-0.2023967057,
-0.4689981639,
-0.1429599524,
0.039407365,
-0.4899315238,
0.6461292505,
-0.1503821313,
-0.7713320851,
-0.1400472075,
-0.2354467213,
-0.3849172294,
0.3139704168,
-0.1397489309,
-0.4666649103,
0.0444534943,
0.0842797905,
0.4582693279,
-0.203603521,
0.1723202616,
-0.1903775483,
-0.4113635421,
0.3727169037,
-0.3182709217,
1.0086522102,
0.5410897732,
-0.3057839572,
0.4545658529,
-0.6916471124,
-0.2012197077,
-0.0237503778,
-0.1114882603,
-0.2878434658,
-0.2544481456,
-0.1177871525,
0.1979949623,
0.5058277845,
-0.9077742696,
-0.2554969192,
-0.3186273575,
0.2349158525,
0.8798521757,
0.313685894,
0.7921255231,
-0.2347636968,
0.9093266129,
-0.2854857743,
0.5362185836,
-0.5104806423,
-0.5773801804,
-0.032009162,
-0.7125614285,
-0.017445948,
0.9886650443,
-0.5460529923,
0.6756816506,
0.0747060552,
-0.5328961015,
-0.3926667869,
0.134027794,
0.7735734582,
0.659368515,
0.0007567524,
-0.2305233479,
-0.2729340792,
-0.7104800344,
-0.5818038583,
-0.0158204772,
-0.1274494976,
0.2678745985,
-0.0034597153,
-0.3152681589,
1.1738197803,
-0.4652910829,
-0.3854347169,
-0.1688541919,
-0.3853204548,
0.1239873394,
0.5125110745,
0.4842187166,
-0.7776168585,
-0.5217382908,
-0.3598354757,
-0.8231629133,
-0.4111586809,
-0.3679812253,
-0.3703065813,
-0.3085667491,
0.5377904177,
-0.6040469408,
0.8528267145,
0.1929427534,
-0.7820909023,
0.3830322027,
-0.2123457044,
0.0218984038,
-1.0089449883,
-0.0169217251,
-0.2289603055,
-0.4952284992,
-1.0630944967,
0.1841629595,
-0.0238749683,
-0.4702989459,
-0.7147285938,
0.9550862908,
-0.1771441847,
0.0977093056,
-0.3955381811,
-0.0608071499,
-0.0632108077,
0.3980161548,
-0.0732935444,
1.0092445612,
0.4191305935,
-0.7673036456,
0.2803502083,
0.5747904181,
-0.0214590728,
0.4336490929,
-0.6315707564,
0.165388301,
-0.0989814326,
0.3331530094,
-1.1407030821,
-0.499016881,
0.5385961533,
-0.4626063108,
-0.0677959323,
0.2728141248,
-0.5572813749,
0.0927173197,
-0.7188360095,
0.0728344247,
0.6104725599,
-0.7723155022,
0.8465961218,
0.3761787713,
-0.4516183436,
-0.3900813162,
-0.3100259304,
0.0909975022,
-0.2880858779,
-0.8576788902,
0.3885511756,
-0.212601468,
-0.3898308575,
-0.1972656995,
-0.322966367,
-0.1978788227,
0.7200571895,
0.5375655293,
0.2046281248,
0.5160342455,
-0.0940171704,
0.0845363513,
-0.4958408177,
0.0772008821,
0.4997248948,
0.495885998,
0.0597505011,
0.0347810164,
-1.13595891,
0.3258566558,
0.3551673889,
-0.3190382719,
0.9287766218,
0.3488298059,
-0.1794079542,
0.1527689248,
-0.2002634853,
-0.479459554,
-0.626640439,
-0.08785294,
-0.3090857863,
-0.986739397,
0.7635284066,
-0.2159134746,
0.5925058126,
-0.1132133827,
0.2764311433,
-0.1189071238,
0.8860159516,
0.3767844141,
-0.1270686835,
0.7375632524,
0.2951893806,
0.5299183726,
-0.5746762156,
-0.4254319668,
-0.4966235161,
-0.4367219508,
-0.329311341,
0.1750842333,
0.3593941033,
0.3444969654,
-0.2690156102,
0.5180838704,
-0.5211815834,
0.8551921248,
0.6349099278,
0.2334964275,
0.2791879475,
-0.3360776603,
0.2539690733,
-0.0074045854,
-0.1408349872,
-0.699663043,
0.7553824186,
0.2803641856,
0.8220623136,
0.4270808697,
0.8756085038,
0.4884937406,
-0.1629227698,
-0.120120801,
0.8518840671,
0.1921289265,
-0.6486458778,
-0.2823553681,
-0.3224157691,
-0.918615818,
0.5290775895,
0.1288964152,
-0.9442302585,
0.3432444036,
0.2236266583,
-0.8995863199,
0.167836532,
-0.7633110881,
0.78745085,
-0.1146594957,
-0.673027873,
-0.003402889,
-1.0164191723,
0.4033822417,
-0.0157721546,
0.4178575277,
-0.3585153222,
-0.1426809728,
0.5139568448,
-0.70912081,
0.976056397,
-0.4279063344,
-0.0797917098,
0.173799485,
0.5888732672,
0.8327106237,
0.4127019048,
0.0410620011,
-0.0695476457,
-0.070857428,
-0.2924960554,
-0.5473604798,
0.4888811111,
-0.3230074942,
-0.8624618649,
-0.5620689988,
-0.3263111711,
-0.0925637782,
0.0292842761,
0.4733138382,
0.2429097742,
0.0077738594,
0.2948594689,
0.6811931133,
-0.608171463,
0.9263568521,
0.3735870421,
-0.1839270294,
-0.4366125166,
0.8762937784,
-0.6150289178,
0.1669885516,
0.3329897523,
0.5062913895,
-0.51651299,
-0.1400164515,
-0.4836033583,
-0.129956767,
-0.5107774138,
-0.3053239584,
-0.6608031392,
-0.158154279,
-0.4101298451,
-0.6029415131,
0.0244538616,
-0.6056591272,
-0.610786736,
-0.1571167707,
0.6491424441,
0.0855192915,
0.0215332508,
0.9707285166,
-0.9479076862,
0.4066337049,
0.3727531731,
-0.1151641756,
-0.0979508385,
-0.6203740239,
0.2279576808,
-0.4220858514,
-0.2142105401,
-0.844820857,
0.4925253689,
0.2334854305,
0.3851959705,
0.6280941963,
0.5730790496,
0.2670501471,
-0.3748987317,
1.0167552233,
0.3675113022,
-0.7471259832,
0.313393414,
-0.2448501289,
0.4072403014,
0.8962035179,
0.0222643912,
-0.4906285107,
-0.49987185,
-0.5088282228,
-0.9279534221,
0.6264123321,
0.3448194265,
0.3716057837,
0.042486839,
0.0498731993,
0.2547309995,
0.4957167208,
-0.339171797,
-0.2081489861,
-0.0380456038,
-0.3415712118,
0.2406857014,
-0.2589145005,
0.0765036121,
0.0349999219,
0.4445357919,
0.3153392673,
0.1793904603,
-0.133221969,
-0.2218827158,
0.3888615072,
0.5372616053,
0.3899209201,
0.2338787019,
0.0167513564,
0.2278499156,
-0.1054485738,
-0.6401877999,
0.3029635251,
-0.0558396354,
-0.5356683135,
-0.0025626307,
0.3004367054,
0.6063270569,
0.3625603914,
-0.7816403508,
0.5992612839,
-0.367146641,
0.2464524955,
-0.2583202124,
0.6205683351,
-0.2146356106,
0.2673590481,
0.2612516582,
0.1859171391,
0.2428367883,
-0.5003931522,
0.21532166,
0.079422161,
-0.04494958,
-0.5701098442,
1.0168011189,
0.8269264698,
-0.6958824992,
0.2405973822,
-0.379499346,
-0.6793550849,
0.4001121521,
0.3483989239,
1.2077288628,
-0.824995935,
0.2903796434,
0.1281413883,
0.0005364978,
0.0263529867,
0.7339143753,
-0.5020933151,
-0.4575245678,
0.3813534677,
-0.4985798895,
-0.3904565573,
-0.2564825118,
-0.3561823964,
-0.293887198,
-1.1544222832,
-0.3197724819,
-0.3191352785,
-0.3939979076,
-0.4373243749,
0.0423389524,
-0.3567514122,
0.5645232797,
-0.5002295971,
0.2568521798,
0.0307560917,
-0.1589371562,
-0.270994693,
0.1338246018,
0.5255848169,
-0.4680280685,
0.2501122355,
0.4098763168,
-0.210316807,
-0.1032112613,
-0.2938748598,
-0.6873534918,
0.8454844356,
0.4622039199,
-1.010389924,
0.032688465,
-0.0378915183,
0.4148409367,
0.0156980418,
0.1339258254,
0.6184917092,
0.3317728639,
-0.1037591547,
-0.8360817432,
0.2576878965,
-0.2345051318,
-0.1895595044,
0.02942238,
-0.7250717878,
0.4788286686,
-0.1545246094,
-0.6039434075,
0.3409185708,
0.4599103332,
0.3550889492,
0.3853413463,
0.4570835531,
0.1837251931,
1.0909295082,
-0.0305431336,
0.9823432565,
-0.3538352847,
-0.2970775664,
1.1303378344,
-0.5715457201,
0.5623037815,
0.2736428082,
-0.0250840187,
0.3218174875,
0.6430755258,
0.2921516895,
1.0556532145,
0.2674123645,
-0.9203221798,
-0.2333206832,
-0.4859910309,
-0.3257612884,
0.1116498932,
-0.0028346006,
-0.3300234377,
-0.0984370559,
0.2986704409,
0.3621704876,
0.306489408,
-0.2203867137,
0.9539371133,
0.0650963038,
-0.2573252916,
0.2541529834,
-0.0588170663,
0.7643118501,
-0.4061475396,
0.4957910776,
-0.2405492216,
0.4223133326,
-0.3558755815,
-0.59773314,
0.3362257183,
0.429077208,
-0.0242162365,
-0.5037742853,
0.822437346,
-0.0872024074,
-0.0101789022,
0.1556572914,
0.1364025474,
0.3221065998,
-0.2073479146,
-0.5404267907,
0.1471842229,
0.0974831209,
-0.4250506163,
0.3369678855,
-0.0235862322,
-0.0456995815,
0.7271543145,
0.7628110051,
-0.241918087,
0.2796489,
0.0841884241,
0.8876164556,
-0.6375032067,
-1.1070075035,
-1.0457344055,
0.3913322687,
-0.329729557,
-0.542214036,
1.0695956945,
0.5311636329,
0.568937242,
-0.001639605,
0.7654421926,
0.1131958961,
0.6228829622,
-0.3046015799,
0.8769561648,
-0.0899709687,
0.3477624953,
-0.2835554779,
-0.8575339913,
-0.2920976877,
0.4230735898,
0.0150255226,
-0.2839259505,
0.3363684118,
0.9304466248,
0.4910436273,
0.4560188353,
0.2923231423,
-0.3350848556,
0.6085265279,
0.3957045376,
0.6897363663,
-0.0878581107,
0.4965678155,
-0.2011500001,
-0.3338755071,
-0.1321979612,
-0.6331244707,
-1.1983957291,
-0.2129579484,
-0.2597766519,
-0.072028622,
0.0920440704,
0.766667366,
0.6584512591,
-0.7684338093,
0.1704464555,
-0.1231224611,
-0.0946078598,
0.0067547988,
-0.2099258006,
0.2326144576,
0.0094344784,
-0.3288312852,
0.7849088311,
0.3266283274,
0.0294190887,
-0.1881454289,
-0.1880831867,
0.0908747315,
0.2176973224,
0.1721703708,
0.5986398458,
-0.7303868532,
-0.1644195616,
0.191619724,
-0.0197303239,
-0.2339915782,
0.515470624,
-0.61026752,
0.7971994281,
0.9149879217,
1.0301320553,
0.0034799271,
0.4541762173,
0.4672226012,
-1.0410032272,
0.2992537916,
0.1819214523,
0.1591688544,
0.3002572656,
-0.9670942426,
0.4454023838,
0.2402739078,
-0.4997967482,
-0.9437029958,
0.4318924546,
-0.5148903131,
-0.3283530474,
0.9080857038,
-0.3584716916,
-0.4181913733,
-0.4458088279,
-0.3358184695,
-0.0038758893,
-0.8790735006,
0.7210318446,
0.4668855071,
-0.144145757,
-0.2082909346,
-0.2965869308,
0.8031356931,
0.2042807788,
-1.0054693222,
0.3130081594,
0.2876435816,
0.0567635298,
0.2216250151,
0.6752970815,
-0.122968547,
0.5882120132,
-0.3204345405,
-0.0996809155,
-0.3889741004,
-0.6378654242,
-0.5269419551,
0.1302931756,
-0.4357122183,
-0.6013111472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14314v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14314v2 | Identifying User Goals from UI Trajectories | 2024-06-20T13:46:10 | 2024-06-30T12:33:48 | Omri Berkovitch, Sapir Caduri, Noam Kahlon, Anatoly Efros, Avi Caciularu, Ido Dagan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Autonomous agents that interact with graphical user interfaces (GUIs) hold
significant potential for enhancing user experiences. To further improve these
experiences, agents need to be personalized and proactive. By effectively
comprehending user intentions through their actions and interactions with GUIs,
agents will be better positioned to achieve these goals. This paper introduces
the task of goal identification from observed UI trajectories, aiming to infer
the user's intended task based on their GUI interactions. We propose a novel
evaluation metric to assess whether two task descriptions are paraphrases
within a specific UI environment. By Leveraging the inverse relation with the
UI automation task, we utilized the Android-In-The-Wild and Mind2Web datasets
for our experiments. Using our metric and these datasets, we conducted several
experiments comparing the performance of humans and state-of-the-art models,
specifically GPT-4 and Gemini-1.5 Pro. Our results show that Gemini performs
better than GPT but still underperforms compared to humans, indicating
significant room for improvement. | [
-0.1874296665,
-0.6508929133,
1.0377454758,
-0.1108596921,
0.0289494619,
0.0391730182,
0.094919391,
-0.0369419381,
0.2557512224,
0.600432992,
-0.8051232696,
-0.59471035,
-0.4018592536,
-0.0734961107,
-0.4466733336,
1.1653279066,
-0.2884034216,
-0.6893519759,
-0.570299983,
0.0664039478,
-0.4962048531,
-0.0228137802,
-0.4848365188,
-0.095066905,
0.7168180943,
0.3723577857,
0.847314477,
0.2600857913,
0.420638293,
0.3551532626,
0.5076279044,
0.0936017632,
-0.3424095809,
0.11510434,
-0.0226428267,
-0.0728029609,
-0.175376296,
0.0773096532,
0.2749429643,
0.3339340389,
0.1537918597,
0.2681156695,
0.4412462711,
0.4151208401,
-0.5752885938,
0.3919113576,
-0.0128971487,
0.0769011006,
-0.1026721969,
-0.0272608195,
0.0128338616,
-0.4866286814,
0.1154094413,
-1.0552190542,
-0.065549314,
-0.0747898221,
0.8654401898,
0.2851003706,
-0.4366258979,
-0.2834478319,
-0.571239531,
0.754835546,
-0.5326093435,
0.1852409244,
0.2051233202,
0.3772066236,
-0.4347297549,
-0.858733058,
-0.6431678534,
-0.5335370898,
-0.3717581034,
0.1731599867,
-0.3090470433,
0.1830515265,
0.318671912,
-0.3640214801,
-0.8549855351,
-0.3280986845,
-0.2638462186,
-0.3962981999,
0.4584473968,
0.3067694008,
0.4993498623,
-0.2575370967,
-0.4317801595,
-0.0672192276,
-0.0352314897,
0.4963644743,
0.3375641108,
-0.0249533542,
-0.2120034844,
0.6514977813,
-0.5285516381,
0.6101080775,
0.057549268,
-0.2855448723,
0.2250366062,
-0.501563251,
0.0599852502,
-0.5497789979,
0.7619563341,
0.7246212363,
0.2504098415,
-0.7931578755,
-0.3988911808,
-0.1234154627,
0.4022706747,
-0.4021104276,
-0.2485897541,
0.035279233,
-0.4469842017,
-0.0010866575,
0.3666782677,
-0.4373265505,
-0.4601791203,
-0.5718308091,
0.7626615763,
-0.3503700495,
-0.0560125485,
-0.4006399214,
-0.5816670656,
0.0757018328,
0.3116539419,
-0.5013726354,
0.4029419422,
0.983366847,
1.0534024239,
-0.411639452,
-0.48092103,
-0.538772285,
0.2163940221,
-0.1699222773,
0.5956568718,
-0.4680761993,
-0.4725975692,
-0.4830465615,
-0.2146060616,
-0.3608081341,
-0.1656701565,
0.5334946513,
-0.1687048525,
0.0726752132,
-0.4597764909,
-0.3478042781,
-0.1916574687,
0.4194546342,
-0.4000075161,
0.9414602518,
0.5568075776,
-0.6147328615,
0.3726142645,
-0.9462570548,
-0.4849222302,
0.1499266177,
0.0147674968,
-0.1632705927,
0.2220318466,
-0.0157138128,
0.508256495,
-0.2420219779,
0.1390272528,
-0.0967465639,
-0.4463552833,
0.1660474837,
-0.1788467318,
0.4938416779,
0.1431393921,
-0.2895331681,
0.369918555,
-0.495149523,
0.144951731,
-0.278847456,
0.0346548632,
-0.6813420057,
0.150436461,
-0.0382539295,
0.4069681466,
0.7167848945,
-0.7640266418,
-0.0287472196,
-0.1281142235,
0.2480494529,
0.7571305633,
0.1536024064,
0.3554269075,
-0.3568899333,
0.6260152459,
-0.1500642002,
0.5286242962,
0.2727297544,
-0.6589053869,
0.0179570187,
-0.0470646545,
-0.0824092999,
0.5079712868,
-0.895409584,
0.2466675788,
-0.4475482106,
-0.6224615574,
-0.0227641091,
0.279163003,
0.549271524,
0.9631584287,
0.3310360909,
-0.3413442969,
-0.112906523,
-0.9477687478,
-0.6357423067,
-0.5775901675,
-0.395560205,
0.5336382389,
0.5520250797,
-0.3400907218,
1.3017827272,
-0.4504221082,
-0.1587731689,
-0.3143217564,
0.4219976068,
0.1826701909,
0.2819941938,
0.6325747967,
-1.0106135607,
-0.6164727211,
0.2956315875,
-0.8782452941,
-0.2666611671,
-0.3693738878,
-0.247326225,
-0.4054949284,
0.0776147172,
-0.7113450766,
0.7159782648,
0.352193743,
-0.6221235991,
0.7233979106,
-0.3410457671,
0.4603962898,
-0.7602474093,
0.2833229303,
0.3795804083,
-0.1430267543,
-0.6842069626,
-0.3055009246,
0.1432796568,
0.0167910159,
-0.23490569,
0.8106867075,
-0.1137939468,
-0.4270851016,
-0.3484102488,
0.2119830996,
-0.0485122837,
0.6510330439,
0.0501760691,
0.7943550348,
0.2436607033,
-0.6234112978,
0.4835722148,
0.3359463215,
-0.3202430308,
0.6583790779,
-0.718500793,
0.0773776695,
0.0037975123,
0.1553404629,
-1.1581107378,
-0.3444215953,
0.430346638,
-0.540243268,
-0.5077959299,
0.1746880412,
-0.4520481229,
-0.7711274028,
-0.3094445169,
0.0454095118,
0.5249711275,
-0.3606113493,
0.7289512753,
0.1555995494,
-0.0163313448,
-0.4689222872,
-0.1048066318,
0.2223150283,
-0.5981850624,
-0.4325965643,
0.2744059265,
0.1613668203,
-0.2944499254,
-0.1760455072,
-0.1036792397,
0.1531000584,
0.3581702113,
0.6581203938,
0.2537811697,
0.2883352935,
-0.2532866895,
0.2376227826,
-0.1631999761,
0.3441836834,
-0.2710704803,
0.0145282168,
0.2511456907,
-0.1524309218,
-0.9230635762,
0.1161596999,
0.5642247796,
-0.0685956478,
0.3628957272,
0.7601772547,
-0.1990179271,
0.2988068163,
-0.240812853,
-0.0839503258,
-0.4846720695,
0.3780635893,
-0.8106479049,
-0.0737100095,
0.4834612012,
-0.221574381,
0.3208098412,
0.3170030117,
0.1112252921,
-0.4097437859,
1.2350790501,
0.438100189,
-0.0799469352,
0.5988587737,
-0.1376641989,
-0.2456800193,
-0.8347054124,
-0.2583960593,
-0.3663106561,
-0.8004344702,
-0.3665579855,
-0.0635673851,
0.7254039049,
-0.2053906322,
-0.1569064558,
0.838316381,
-0.3061828613,
0.1194503829,
0.9011486769,
0.4135976732,
-0.0574390255,
-0.1635369807,
-0.124328129,
0.0839971751,
-0.0643518865,
-0.7028907537,
1.1056975126,
0.0079494528,
0.6893254519,
-0.0129048787,
0.7074922323,
0.7547002435,
0.1421256512,
-0.4180635214,
0.789847672,
0.0100911064,
-0.3517982066,
-0.541521132,
-0.4577803612,
-1.0012999773,
0.0580900833,
0.1353907287,
-1.3416047096,
-0.0457827151,
0.1628969759,
-0.3293899,
-0.1328743994,
-0.6678243279,
1.4104751348,
-0.4662492871,
-0.3828326166,
-0.2110128701,
-0.9700686932,
-0.1089936271,
0.0249184575,
0.0280585643,
-0.3048945963,
-0.4344595075,
0.9556415081,
-0.2716528773,
0.5784102082,
-0.7013105154,
0.159258306,
0.257093966,
-0.0903554559,
0.8032194972,
-0.141227141,
-0.1524907798,
-0.0749524459,
0.1232008114,
-0.2794298232,
-0.8676680923,
0.6681865454,
-0.7133281827,
-0.6622723937,
-0.0574522093,
-0.5231512189,
-0.2838822007,
0.1588973403,
0.2001012117,
0.3678423166,
-0.4143196344,
-0.1344793588,
-0.1104713604,
-0.0651899949,
0.3208816946,
0.2831867635,
0.0398079567,
0.1061536819,
1.0007653236,
-0.2976583838,
0.1474805474,
0.6861168146,
0.3992039263,
-0.5872360468,
-0.5272904038,
-0.6396561861,
-0.0049088094,
-0.4623381495,
0.2179160267,
-0.5837825537,
0.2936882675,
-0.3949340284,
-0.2092435807,
0.0627094582,
-0.2543719411,
-0.49661991,
0.1562832445,
0.0299971439,
0.7045278549,
-0.0548894964,
0.4313504398,
-0.6011980176,
0.6623235941,
0.198043257,
-0.34510535,
-0.3389338255,
-0.3931533992,
-0.2590074241,
0.3810239434,
-0.6532146335,
-0.8844338059,
0.4267476797,
0.1155051887,
0.9238868356,
0.5637812614,
0.2295318544,
0.772799015,
-0.1508406252,
0.8101523519,
0.2510614991,
-0.8395810127,
0.7455179691,
-0.248750329,
0.3211054206,
0.542694509,
0.4200113416,
-0.5932088494,
-0.483084619,
-0.4220320582,
-0.4716904759,
0.6260644197,
0.5022577643,
0.1435237825,
0.1592952311,
0.6616248488,
0.3722268343,
0.1391995698,
-0.4396950603,
-0.0237577632,
-0.031952709,
-0.5871565342,
-0.3842936456,
0.3707587123,
0.0487419814,
-0.0643376857,
0.2434901297,
-0.3096684217,
0.3443745375,
-0.0153176431,
-0.1751348972,
0.067576021,
-0.1040563732,
0.2483596802,
0.9523070455,
0.0517446436,
-0.1853863299,
0.0321782008,
-0.6258953214,
0.1931718141,
0.1894616634,
-0.1923659146,
0.0418936573,
0.2816431224,
0.7451153994,
0.09521126,
-0.8337416649,
0.5146545768,
-0.2309389412,
0.1654473394,
-0.1982061416,
0.506793201,
-0.4242472947,
0.5642727017,
0.4364653528,
0.1208092794,
0.6655268669,
-0.4922178984,
0.0976962522,
0.6500447392,
-0.4989118278,
-0.6550496817,
0.9996817112,
0.1692234129,
-0.4606844187,
0.544269383,
-0.1445694417,
-0.3706641197,
0.9333896041,
0.2147079557,
0.9973151088,
0.0595604591,
0.4805319905,
0.300573349,
-0.0814487785,
0.030565694,
0.1251831949,
-0.791862309,
-0.3613179624,
0.001639201,
-0.5616698861,
-0.3825928271,
-0.3232702911,
-0.670009613,
0.1903732717,
0.1157611609,
-0.4455362558,
0.0470260195,
0.0167021807,
-0.7394274473,
0.4045063555,
-0.1462160349,
0.3168519139,
-0.642611444,
0.6950985193,
0.7743213177,
-0.1103914008,
-0.564737916,
0.4024913907,
0.1502273828,
-0.6238878369,
0.7740312815,
0.2449574769,
-0.1412180364,
-0.0066858591,
-0.0405544303,
-0.5651602745,
1.288685441,
0.1735361665,
-0.5525718331,
-0.5145480037,
0.1233363077,
0.5176081061,
-0.1542905122,
0.4986645281,
0.7411372066,
0.7221570611,
-0.033964511,
-1.0819033384,
-0.0586712658,
-0.0876402184,
0.0834965631,
0.2391636223,
-0.2392890453,
0.5726274252,
-0.4713252187,
-0.1157835722,
0.5263154507,
0.6693437696,
0.0004342941,
0.7223080993,
0.6720973253,
0.0882558748,
0.4621214569,
-0.1101712584,
1.1627042294,
-0.0958444998,
0.1182085201,
0.7051455975,
-0.0163394753,
0.5060338974,
0.5592965484,
-0.2455882132,
0.5071821213,
0.5646756887,
0.4563648105,
0.863858223,
-0.0398210175,
-0.0399674326,
-0.0361100137,
0.2724067867,
0.1357286125,
0.416547209,
0.3889787197,
-0.2678430378,
-0.0304300897,
0.5649517775,
-0.084732987,
0.1242790073,
-0.3152427077,
0.9971932769,
-0.3616314828,
-1.2304162979,
0.0682589486,
-0.0731985867,
0.4360888898,
-0.6297100186,
0.1098751575,
-0.1227730215,
0.2695665658,
-0.0886106789,
-0.9502895474,
0.0738893226,
0.0780730546,
0.1872794181,
-0.1897269338,
0.5099833012,
0.0058591887,
-0.3468716145,
0.1725486964,
0.3579050601,
0.3657246232,
-0.3282808065,
-0.886941731,
-0.2913651764,
0.2542452812,
-0.3756942749,
0.1927835941,
0.3120939136,
-0.2472714931,
0.859207809,
0.2191594392,
-0.1836042702,
-0.2784993649,
-0.2968347073,
0.5822055936,
-0.6796953678,
-0.7790772915,
-0.8208729029,
0.4265370667,
-0.1622930318,
-0.5278580785,
1.0755114555,
0.6902971864,
0.4654861987,
-0.2253462076,
0.9191159606,
-0.3888430595,
0.5305801034,
-0.149562031,
0.3241870999,
-0.74117589,
0.0930638388,
-0.5428783894,
-1.0256953239,
0.3154590428,
0.4749711752,
-0.6252199411,
0.2441752404,
0.2978264689,
0.814905405,
-0.150950551,
-0.1304727644,
0.4379288256,
-0.2457587123,
0.3039637208,
0.7939875126,
1.044639349,
-0.2100680619,
0.6674541235,
-0.3389546573,
-0.3585258722,
-0.0950203165,
-0.4656454623,
-0.7515197396,
-0.8364938498,
-0.4862728417,
-0.1441355944,
0.3969993591,
0.5178966522,
0.6067413688,
-0.5777056217,
-0.3380659223,
-0.4277533591,
0.0720252767,
-0.7555374503,
-0.1951903701,
0.2768253982,
-0.129530102,
-0.9041760564,
0.1885661036,
0.2375264019,
-0.02228898,
-0.1086089388,
-0.5332920551,
0.1605549157,
-0.0383934192,
0.2983385623,
0.6178690791,
-0.7848181725,
-0.529579103,
-0.1171334833,
-0.1450444609,
-0.1840689033,
0.7648347616,
-1.0140328407,
0.262473017,
0.3591319025,
0.0810939372,
0.5472362041,
0.64077425,
0.5168153048,
-0.811853528,
-0.2561653852,
0.2347683609,
0.0952179655,
0.0382374376,
-0.4006874263,
0.4401682913,
0.0060694059,
-0.5055598021,
-0.4429887235,
-0.1703856885,
-0.97050488,
-0.1524215937,
1.2146221399,
-0.4642064571,
-0.2008707076,
-0.3125896454,
-0.4947548509,
0.143079102,
-0.4675748944,
0.6460627317,
0.2914812863,
-0.5621730685,
0.0520342775,
-0.506503582,
0.4996545911,
-0.1198863685,
-1.0254254341,
-0.1525117606,
0.5821912289,
0.1889387965,
0.1286473572,
0.4368986189,
0.2665230334,
0.5680356026,
-0.1093324497,
-0.2405939102,
-0.034602534,
-0.3384312391,
0.4923161268,
0.187924087,
-0.2078367025,
-0.6278952956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14313v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14313v1 | Robust Few-shot Transfer Learning for Knowledge Base Question Answering with Unanswerable Questions | 2024-06-20T13:43:38 | 2024-06-20T13:43:38 | Riya Sawhney, Indrajit Bhattacharya, Mausam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Real-world KBQA applications require models that are (1) robust -- e.g., can
differentiate between answerable and unanswerable questions, and (2)
low-resource -- do not require large training data. Towards this goal, we
propose the novel task of few-shot transfer for KBQA with unanswerable
questions. We present FUn-FuSIC that extends the state-of-the-art (SoTA)
few-shot transfer model for answerable-only KBQA to handle unanswerability. It
iteratively prompts an LLM to generate logical forms for the question by
providing feedback using a diverse suite of syntactic, semantic and execution
guided checks, and adapts self-consistency to assess confidence of the LLM to
decide answerability. Experiments over newly constructed datasets show that
FUn-FuSIC outperforms suitable adaptations of the SoTA model for KBQA with
unanswerability, and the SoTA model for answerable-only few-shot-transfer KBQA. | [
-0.1893886626,
-0.9827728271,
0.7905775309,
0.002007171,
-0.0287649166,
-0.0949618518,
-0.0434389934,
-0.3568395972,
0.101711534,
0.5431625247,
-1.0479917526,
-0.2154627293,
-0.467464745,
0.0249728113,
-0.4330100715,
1.0196698904,
-0.0591123216,
-0.2059222311,
-0.4024045765,
-0.1340410411,
-0.4586972594,
-0.1618447602,
-0.3301355541,
-0.2467514127,
0.17931436,
0.8495274782,
0.411511898,
0.0118167726,
0.4922865927,
0.1644569188,
0.259309113,
0.1006650999,
-0.6080585718,
0.0883962438,
-0.1940818429,
-0.6952650547,
-0.3901758492,
-0.3924123943,
0.4110391736,
0.6932206154,
0.0896991342,
0.4258086979,
-0.0550704561,
0.5381017327,
-0.7969146967,
0.1740465313,
-0.6572540402,
-0.1147847399,
0.1005638838,
0.0029806204,
-0.3570650816,
-0.5110728145,
0.1938251108,
-0.8071474433,
-0.2962763011,
-0.2106725574,
0.544447422,
0.3219749629,
-0.4273112416,
-0.1584827006,
-0.6641325355,
0.4074080288,
-0.6411651969,
0.1404030174,
0.5183814764,
0.729586482,
-0.3184461594,
-0.6275057793,
-0.57625705,
-0.0739833713,
0.1524520963,
0.2754465342,
-0.3498769403,
-0.1369881928,
0.0978678092,
-0.3744512498,
-0.5778752565,
-0.2200847715,
-0.4210644662,
-0.313993156,
0.4220325053,
0.0599980801,
0.0798212737,
-0.1185431778,
-0.5680107474,
0.1637131423,
-0.4879032373,
0.3753623068,
-0.0219385643,
0.419061482,
0.0301288236,
0.5621174574,
-0.5683150887,
0.850128293,
0.0757348463,
-0.3213320374,
-0.3137624264,
-0.1792187542,
-0.1075575799,
-0.1800471395,
0.484516561,
0.0103595043,
0.388361603,
-0.3470177352,
-0.0131237479,
-0.310383141,
0.2023867071,
-0.7308676839,
-0.5845148563,
0.2647044659,
-0.1493193358,
-0.4437568784,
-0.0466517024,
-0.6703845859,
-0.279966116,
0.3151883781,
1.1860675812,
-0.4487015605,
-0.2026267052,
0.0191837214,
0.1221198067,
0.161074385,
0.6573275328,
-0.7632331252,
0.3597086668,
0.3155913949,
0.4633024037,
-0.2267950326,
-0.1397158355,
-0.6881514192,
0.1945126206,
-0.2839263082,
1.1561142206,
-0.2210242152,
-0.0082445731,
-0.3618583381,
0.0041168681,
-0.1194248125,
-0.3191697896,
0.119784303,
-0.7914118767,
0.2053448707,
-0.4359498024,
-0.6743887663,
-0.4299806356,
0.7424179316,
-0.3102550805,
0.8016825914,
0.5802761912,
-0.7465670109,
0.1222146004,
-0.5700212717,
-0.3163324594,
0.0700612664,
-0.0051323674,
-0.2833158374,
-0.1658524722,
0.0590768978,
0.2765107453,
0.021066241,
-0.0860928074,
-0.6275221109,
-0.330835253,
0.5532457232,
-0.3410780132,
0.8108175993,
0.1453658342,
-0.1761967689,
-0.183151111,
-0.813113153,
0.4560011625,
-0.0015842426,
-0.4025340378,
-0.0142059978,
-0.6500562429,
-0.2712573707,
0.3030159473,
0.2485677898,
-0.5842061639,
0.4120692909,
-0.2182541937,
0.0965252593,
0.4846197069,
0.3455898464,
0.6368831992,
-0.5135794282,
0.8055111766,
0.2180345356,
0.1443515718,
0.205353111,
-0.559735775,
-0.6559016705,
-0.1030880436,
0.4682094157,
0.8390304446,
-1.0964733362,
-0.0215001479,
-0.0953779817,
-0.5801562667,
-0.381921351,
0.2879218459,
0.1476357579,
1.2116978168,
0.5088873506,
-0.1312543601,
-0.3697231412,
-0.6394022107,
-0.1208618358,
-0.5919646025,
0.1299878359,
0.377494514,
0.5963332057,
0.1929499805,
1.0089808702,
-0.5373931527,
-0.2172439247,
-0.3681865633,
0.1368856579,
0.157439813,
0.2246367037,
0.4916750491,
-0.5257520676,
-0.4980859458,
-0.0709088892,
-0.7239525914,
0.0113409841,
-0.2060288489,
-0.3298704326,
0.1202236563,
0.18398875,
-0.8076866269,
0.5067694783,
0.1783454269,
-0.1786298305,
0.639097929,
0.1150607243,
0.3944564462,
-1.030385375,
0.3707401156,
-0.6000928283,
-0.6107121706,
-0.6406331062,
0.0378440209,
0.2136596143,
0.0372020602,
-0.9352375269,
0.6651411653,
-0.0366142392,
-0.0571571551,
-0.2857422829,
0.0503158644,
-0.0322255716,
0.7144112587,
-0.0888063759,
0.5895141363,
0.6802518964,
-0.7656440139,
0.6012052894,
0.6128351092,
-0.2001876235,
0.6549311876,
-0.3508126736,
0.4164193273,
-0.2236476243,
0.2120531648,
-1.1587921381,
-0.2730655968,
0.4138925374,
-0.6375113726,
0.243809849,
-0.6361419559,
-0.0566127039,
-0.2583621144,
-0.0490884297,
0.356831044,
0.5794366002,
-0.2452346534,
0.5301219225,
-0.0056678122,
-0.2338458598,
-0.6898790598,
-0.9160585403,
-0.3760210276,
-0.1789208651,
-0.6662807465,
0.0110238725,
-0.2429380715,
0.1024393663,
0.3282000422,
-0.3355759978,
-0.6526299715,
0.3607809842,
-0.0144586358,
0.3613472879,
-0.5410702229,
0.059820354,
0.0311510917,
0.053020753,
0.0183260851,
-0.3763979375,
0.000458211,
-0.2033827007,
-0.2549827099,
-0.07312648,
0.3121900558,
0.2568722665,
0.2255034,
0.6958742142,
0.5200787187,
-0.6079264879,
-0.1925721169,
-0.2889421582,
-0.3863789439,
-0.358117491,
0.2417188138,
-0.5085940361,
-1.1666443348,
0.6234170794,
-0.1017742753,
0.0425430983,
0.2066293955,
0.5472196937,
-0.6365451217,
0.5498987436,
0.6988558173,
0.1358130723,
-0.0532883853,
-0.0353767499,
0.0533079915,
-0.0919314846,
-0.2821733654,
-0.2745763958,
-0.3999480009,
-0.247973308,
-0.1777513176,
0.5386843681,
0.3014104068,
-0.2094068229,
0.4877470732,
0.1194415763,
0.554739058,
0.441198498,
0.2482863367,
0.4679517746,
-0.2442350835,
0.0086533781,
0.1086205244,
-0.9768511057,
-0.1126118377,
0.9859793186,
0.1212531999,
1.0315694809,
0.4475397468,
0.7371610403,
0.1058648452,
0.192103073,
-0.9806796908,
0.5330450535,
-0.1311609447,
-0.7812763453,
-0.4912547469,
-0.5563987494,
-0.555019021,
-0.1516508311,
-0.5790709257,
-0.9411730766,
0.057895042,
0.3716149032,
-0.8858339787,
0.3438023627,
-0.6802982688,
0.9226213694,
-0.1682907492,
-0.355445087,
0.3080111146,
-0.9612403512,
0.7188885212,
-0.3007913828,
-0.0679571629,
-0.0899632424,
0.0576969534,
0.6494728327,
-0.1850851625,
0.5777003169,
-0.2876547873,
0.194052428,
0.6484264731,
0.5246576071,
0.3505963087,
-0.0607001707,
0.1121732444,
-0.2496405244,
0.5354956985,
-0.4407332242,
-1.093672514,
0.508123219,
-0.6231895685,
-0.596824646,
-0.1220312715,
-0.5889342427,
-0.7058343887,
0.4921983778,
0.3788501918,
0.0809738263,
-0.0084992871,
0.1721052229,
0.8589824438,
0.1644357145,
0.2135957778,
0.4549752176,
-0.2018028051,
0.0019966385,
0.6839394569,
0.3098433614,
0.3140233159,
0.5562191606,
0.2395621985,
-0.5472379327,
-0.2876256704,
-0.5508717299,
-0.0786482319,
-0.940795064,
-0.6437729001,
-0.6615422964,
-0.4996318519,
-0.6417253017,
-0.0045187655,
-0.4581678212,
-0.9235790372,
-0.2982679009,
0.0565239564,
0.5139134526,
0.5038672686,
-0.0005333118,
0.2197674066,
-0.9448616505,
0.5245041847,
0.7764127254,
0.3551338017,
-0.3094333708,
-1.0709500313,
0.1203426272,
0.1002322137,
-0.3110708296,
-1.3008116484,
0.0519616976,
0.2627082467,
0.4570142031,
0.0607677326,
0.6520161629,
0.7057529092,
-0.089515999,
0.3629383147,
0.0834033489,
-0.6322497725,
0.6156384349,
-0.140966773,
0.320179075,
1.1829776764,
0.5935553908,
-0.211286664,
-0.0755348355,
-0.5948483944,
-0.3281273544,
0.7997083664,
0.1151110679,
-0.0125965057,
0.3457704782,
0.3382823467,
0.3188285828,
0.0700265616,
-0.7618008852,
-0.0921997651,
-0.2259248644,
-0.267254591,
0.6129696965,
0.0632372648,
-0.1158246398,
0.0188745875,
0.7596601844,
-0.5906531215,
0.3756192327,
0.187081039,
-0.4453389645,
-0.2550751865,
0.6567654014,
0.3886531591,
0.3484375775,
-0.3680481911,
0.3528041244,
0.4996301234,
-0.2774488032,
0.4263772368,
-0.0669357404,
-0.2778270841,
-0.4719265103,
0.2393741161,
0.4643887281,
0.1505530626,
-0.5164179802,
0.907261014,
-0.0520987101,
-0.5674012303,
0.0362916775,
0.249859646,
0.0402495489,
0.4163183868,
0.1307376474,
0.2963845432,
0.2439015359,
-0.4336017072,
0.3032686412,
0.3572811186,
-0.2831376493,
-0.2711741328,
0.4686080813,
0.0510581024,
-0.0510975793,
0.6854037642,
-0.1558914334,
-0.4354117215,
0.4523529708,
0.7115803361,
0.5685871243,
0.1523397118,
0.5288982987,
0.2729684114,
0.3999968767,
0.0348976739,
0.6113262773,
-0.3592631817,
-0.8015375137,
-0.2442035824,
-0.2410497814,
-0.609436512,
0.2540430427,
-0.7691471577,
0.4256695807,
-0.5240203142,
0.0188156236,
-0.2023255527,
-0.0197775438,
-0.6873304844,
0.1366581321,
0.0422834493,
1.1493645906,
-1.0186634064,
0.8311419487,
0.8677977324,
-0.4223476946,
-0.8565044999,
-0.0193551835,
-0.1093352437,
-0.9418599606,
0.2454802841,
-0.0673415214,
-0.0790933445,
0.2559779286,
-0.7856751084,
-0.9079793096,
1.2556141615,
0.7529118061,
-0.1938554198,
-0.0365000553,
0.143513307,
0.385525763,
0.0151938945,
0.1028899178,
0.5126298666,
0.3784733415,
0.5805075169,
-0.8353734016,
-0.0088253552,
0.0394757763,
-0.5933025479,
-0.1032928675,
-0.7227125764,
0.2239192724,
-0.615219593,
-0.0270483978,
0.3277724087,
0.7868400216,
0.4976254106,
0.3409486413,
0.5469928384,
0.3183923662,
0.7191201448,
0.0740530491,
0.6517909169,
-0.0093120709,
0.3096816242,
1.2399996519,
-0.0702270269,
1.0519880056,
0.5294058323,
-0.2371167094,
0.4147354662,
0.3739218414,
0.2530289888,
0.6553887129,
-0.0207221098,
-0.1934146732,
-0.6911820769,
0.010728335,
-0.0455613062,
0.8155065775,
0.1011511087,
0.3008167744,
-0.5711015463,
0.0413682498,
-0.1660583168,
-0.080385223,
-0.2336470485,
0.8297624588,
0.0429729708,
-0.8666667342,
0.4358641207,
-0.1489772201,
0.4498779476,
-0.804055512,
-0.1763846874,
-0.4251667857,
-0.1658147871,
-0.3979745507,
-1.1028151512,
0.4335655272,
0.1112359911,
-0.2330249399,
0.0374042802,
1.3661714792,
-0.5663310885,
-0.4178271592,
-0.2624238729,
0.9355344772,
0.2191214412,
0.0592627935,
-0.7200080752,
-0.6157847643,
-0.0311321281,
-0.1688444465,
0.4722168446,
0.4507847428,
-0.1613301337,
0.983525157,
0.3147582412,
-0.0962522998,
0.2723784149,
-0.2718321383,
0.8285089731,
-0.3848765194,
-0.6686701775,
-0.518859446,
0.4766030014,
0.6089488268,
-0.2400214672,
0.5013278127,
0.0610455908,
0.4765724838,
-0.2338112891,
0.7914608121,
-0.2464442849,
0.4337958992,
-0.5645805597,
0.8016645908,
-0.4375905097,
0.0921288654,
-0.1919142604,
-0.5845096707,
-0.2960048616,
0.6127660275,
-0.0305328965,
0.0588571504,
0.5527899265,
0.691467762,
-0.2402497977,
-0.0515518337,
0.6491151452,
0.0574237369,
-0.1194080561,
1.2147954702,
0.8699675798,
-0.5272783041,
1.0338209867,
-0.5598583221,
-0.2307230681,
-0.0871911347,
-1.0205093622,
-0.6420274973,
-0.3918447793,
-0.5770091414,
-0.4292982817,
-0.0360668078,
0.7620326281,
0.8147421479,
-1.0495090485,
0.2092425376,
0.045631893,
0.2004203498,
-0.0932422727,
-0.2516460121,
0.2730719447,
-0.129188925,
-0.0659977421,
0.4255470335,
0.2230318487,
0.2594583035,
-0.025781408,
0.2063251138,
-0.2360877693,
0.0185623616,
0.3148317933,
0.6776767373,
-0.381952554,
-0.4965353012,
0.5327412486,
-0.0307483431,
-0.1001310423,
0.3813884258,
-0.9878581762,
0.4845015407,
0.6172028184,
1.1503282785,
0.4069261253,
0.0200902391,
0.1512211859,
-1.0966252089,
-0.2267521918,
0.4029910862,
0.013374324,
0.1397188455,
-0.5436561108,
0.3271793425,
0.4252836406,
-0.3737467229,
-0.5652048588,
0.2013686299,
-1.3232542276,
-0.2415655404,
1.1254882812,
-0.3728889525,
-0.2989493608,
-0.2652673125,
0.0166719276,
0.1309671104,
-0.0224862508,
0.6238648295,
0.9075399637,
-0.6665096879,
-0.5134451389,
-0.2913415134,
0.2534691691,
0.3985280097,
-1.1685634851,
-0.2005642205,
0.3146124184,
0.7821824551,
-0.1592897624,
0.8793242574,
0.0031050362,
0.7851018906,
-0.0523463935,
-0.3193186522,
-0.245054543,
-0.5514309406,
-0.26366359,
0.374515295,
0.3140796721,
-0.3242588937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14312v1 | Infusing clinical knowledge into tokenisers for language models | 2024-06-20T13:43:03 | 2024-06-20T13:43:03 | Abul Hasan, Jinge Wu, Quang Ngoc Nguyen, Salomé Andres, Imane Guellil, Huayu Zhang, Arlene Casey, Beatrice Alex, Bruce Guthrie, Honghan Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study introduces a novel knowledge enhanced tokenisation mechanism,
K-Tokeniser, for clinical text processing. Technically, at initialisation
stage, K-Tokeniser populates global representations of tokens based on semantic
types of domain concepts (such as drugs or diseases) from either a domain
ontology like Unified Medical Language System or the training data of the task
related corpus. At training or inference stage, sentence level localised
context will be utilised for choosing the optimal global token representation
to realise the semantic-based tokenisation. To avoid pretraining using the new
tokeniser, an embedding initialisation approach is proposed to generate
representations for new tokens. Using three transformer-based language models,
a comprehensive set of experiments are conducted on four real-world datasets
for evaluating K-Tokeniser in a wide range of clinical text analytics tasks
including clinical concept and relation extraction, automated clinical coding,
clinical phenotype identification, and clinical research article
classification. Overall, our models demonstrate consistent improvements over
their counterparts in all tasks. In particular, substantial improvements are
observed in the automated clinical coding task with 13\% increase on Micro
$F_1$ score. Furthermore, K-Tokeniser also shows significant capacities in
facilitating quicker converge of language models. Specifically, using
K-Tokeniser, the language models would only require 50\% of the training data
to achieve the best performance of the baseline tokeniser using all training
data in the concept extraction task and less than 20\% of the data for the
automated coding task. It is worth mentioning that all these improvements
require no pre-training process, making the approach generalisable. | [
0.1834060103,
-0.4211935103,
0.7358756065,
-0.0986540467,
-0.4060885012,
0.0658956021,
-0.1390879899,
-0.4549944997,
0.3870883882,
0.5683583021,
-0.0066512921,
-0.6475142241,
-0.8308807611,
0.0447471552,
-0.1724342406,
0.9724878073,
-0.0109503064,
0.6783195734,
-0.5134696364,
-0.1291948259,
-0.5847991705,
-0.9104685783,
-0.533514142,
-0.4352768958,
0.2654849589,
0.3774908483,
0.4678148031,
0.7014423609,
0.6799923182,
0.2093071043,
-0.0276315864,
0.001615855,
-0.3265297413,
0.1519083381,
0.0194114652,
-0.7191336155,
-0.5027068853,
-0.2013279051,
0.2394029498,
0.8883052468,
-0.0390129946,
-0.268574208,
-0.2563903928,
0.3336162269,
-0.6509742141,
0.1791886389,
-0.6075754166,
0.0966378823,
-0.0108368965,
-0.2395560145,
-0.5415409207,
-0.1340858936,
0.2228041589,
-0.6732565165,
0.3237192631,
-0.1835356653,
0.7236254215,
0.1035879478,
-0.5680354238,
-0.8624271154,
-0.5676553249,
0.5324389338,
-0.8138104081,
0.5602398515,
0.3291811943,
0.3527885973,
0.0834101811,
-1.2218494415,
-0.5919488668,
-0.3465245962,
-0.5775273442,
0.0990635008,
-0.0314137526,
0.3368465006,
-0.0336524285,
0.3864639401,
-0.183419466,
0.1904094219,
-0.3342261314,
-0.4631032646,
0.2302724868,
0.3267559111,
0.511785686,
-0.3986192942,
-0.229608655,
0.1456642151,
-0.6607090831,
-0.0520666912,
-0.2649843395,
0.2657630444,
-0.040345896,
0.5519692898,
-0.1071332619,
0.4441891611,
0.0950828269,
-0.4311179519,
0.3376975656,
-0.5192475915,
-0.2178373784,
0.305326581,
0.7559064627,
0.2817932665,
-0.0331438333,
-0.4630440474,
-0.0611414053,
0.3984512091,
0.4255538285,
-1.1439471245,
-0.2857167125,
0.4535591602,
-0.5530874729,
-0.5880390406,
-0.1251379848,
-0.4989199042,
-0.3612385094,
-0.1366986334,
0.3730047047,
-0.611281693,
-0.082551226,
0.4394671619,
-0.2532556653,
-0.0407458358,
0.1035299227,
-0.9912434816,
0.4147593677,
0.6364639997,
0.5932642817,
-0.23487629,
0.278863132,
-0.5228942037,
0.3419151008,
-0.1936385781,
0.7115548849,
-0.6455292702,
-0.3633819818,
0.2105709761,
0.1438008845,
-0.0536821187,
-0.3522701859,
0.6460778713,
-0.5492678285,
0.2954445779,
0.0477992035,
-1.0088521242,
0.1793158799,
0.0861184299,
-0.5751455426,
0.7834778428,
0.1623657942,
-0.5352283716,
0.9252503514,
-0.8961238265,
-0.4734029174,
0.3485204279,
-0.331212312,
-0.3640533686,
0.1702581644,
0.4980998039,
0.5613074303,
-0.1127299964,
0.451083988,
-0.0142830862,
-0.2043384314,
0.1991682798,
-0.0279194713,
0.3865855634,
0.0609818287,
-0.1410517991,
0.0383636542,
-0.8392438889,
-0.1591278315,
-0.044113826,
-0.1805173159,
-0.5040210485,
-0.4279722571,
0.2161679417,
0.2473069727,
0.0736570731,
-0.9726668596,
0.2679109871,
-0.7794536352,
0.5914793015,
0.2941689789,
0.2614179254,
0.578174293,
-0.1884071082,
0.7139543295,
0.374817282,
0.1600325108,
-0.5035991073,
-0.442949146,
-0.6624295115,
-0.5798893571,
0.6778763533,
0.333421737,
-0.7641573548,
0.2217655033,
-0.5704144835,
-0.4759001136,
-0.9713312984,
-0.2134527266,
0.5198537111,
0.5991356969,
0.3472918272,
-0.2719249725,
-0.5238401294,
-0.768890202,
-0.1801057756,
-0.0163479988,
-0.0290561859,
0.2787602246,
0.5242987871,
-0.3839120269,
1.0303441286,
-0.6124687195,
-0.5305414796,
-0.3755766451,
-0.080580838,
0.1885870546,
0.5807862282,
0.2777677178,
-0.7238659859,
-0.6183490753,
0.355835259,
-0.7394441962,
-0.1201988608,
-0.190151453,
0.0637656227,
0.142920956,
0.7404056787,
-0.4767642021,
0.7476085424,
0.1895554215,
-0.5281814933,
0.2828363776,
-0.4224076569,
0.1305459589,
-1.1750079393,
0.2946918607,
-0.5385817885,
-0.4153334796,
-1.1017918587,
-0.0073223747,
0.2610269785,
-0.123440899,
-0.5079745054,
0.7389100194,
-0.2213159502,
0.5183476806,
-0.2064746618,
0.1754138619,
0.2287942469,
0.3397004306,
0.0291741882,
0.5150700212,
0.4710803628,
-0.4877289236,
-0.1148465872,
0.6323863268,
-0.2069045901,
0.3548747599,
-0.6887201071,
0.216358602,
-0.1940187514,
0.0653038099,
-1.1038726568,
-0.2937306166,
0.2117201537,
-0.7042515874,
0.2783192396,
-0.2274401933,
-0.5792954564,
-0.272880435,
0.0588370301,
0.4417066574,
0.4530031383,
-0.3911144137,
0.6494607329,
0.4964518845,
-0.0402612835,
-0.2470933348,
-0.7827656269,
0.1790513098,
-0.1052297577,
-0.3749691248,
0.7152850032,
0.1920756549,
0.2353214473,
0.1436487287,
0.0563508719,
-0.1445401311,
-0.125504151,
0.2296523899,
0.326552093,
-0.1645530313,
0.5412464738,
0.3311249912,
-0.3820772469,
-0.018344339,
-0.3034362495,
0.6410307288,
0.4184412062,
-0.5299041271,
-0.7234642506,
0.3676236868,
0.6738048792,
-0.1146421507,
1.0211416483,
0.566229701,
-0.4979657233,
0.2174045742,
-0.6885685325,
-0.2189344317,
-0.4103800952,
0.5402049422,
-0.3756464124,
-1.18303895,
0.50826478,
-0.0528982803,
-0.1727396697,
0.359256953,
0.8739573956,
0.1934746951,
1.2010165453,
0.6129096746,
-0.0255316552,
0.2242924273,
-0.0622384325,
0.4423314929,
-0.6661342382,
-0.3240960538,
-0.2945327461,
0.1703926772,
-0.3821776807,
-0.4493389726,
0.6551607847,
0.1889607459,
0.1468109637,
0.1350066662,
-0.5886880755,
0.2463367432,
0.1821340919,
0.2536229491,
0.3243878186,
-0.0148242749,
-0.5959210992,
-0.203747347,
-0.940602541,
-0.4879230559,
1.5715523958,
0.3106890023,
0.2975258529,
-0.2111466229,
0.6678344607,
0.2531344891,
0.718496263,
-0.8118422031,
0.1282019466,
-0.1101074517,
-0.3623462915,
-0.0368823223,
-0.0768269151,
-1.0642008781,
0.1563457847,
-0.1825674325,
-0.5790910721,
0.1498820782,
0.0171114448,
-0.57558918,
0.1822359562,
-0.7046894431,
0.8693873882,
0.1923991144,
0.0422015451,
-0.1491473466,
-0.4984071851,
0.0678457692,
-0.2153492719,
0.1724387109,
0.34232831,
-0.1988343298,
0.7061638832,
-0.792339623,
0.9400022626,
-0.4238236248,
-0.1043296754,
0.0796547234,
-0.157226786,
0.3426563144,
0.071929723,
0.0020095082,
-0.0492357425,
0.3861245513,
-0.3408527672,
-0.8846179843,
0.244879812,
-0.498842448,
-0.3749009967,
-0.1336296648,
-0.3737784028,
-0.424757272,
0.3017570972,
0.2015089393,
0.8313813806,
-0.2259362787,
0.1446056664,
0.1993899196,
-0.3055131733,
-0.0010103731,
0.6640246511,
-0.1918988079,
-0.8424546719,
0.6824762225,
-0.1749550551,
0.6073793769,
0.5521199703,
0.2614256442,
-0.3229938447,
-0.6403226852,
-0.2717197239,
0.3257330358,
-1.010617137,
-0.3375449777,
-1.1328340769,
-0.2684054971,
-0.7675268054,
-0.2640888095,
-0.0732206777,
-0.5571246147,
-0.0828266814,
-0.0669338256,
0.4587609172,
0.739710629,
0.1190023571,
0.6837399006,
-0.9487940669,
0.14430435,
-0.1164034829,
0.3207925856,
0.0879030153,
-0.4191380441,
-0.5903083086,
-0.1040008888,
-0.0460905284,
-0.5324175358,
0.3984057903,
0.0720097348,
0.49988693,
0.5570090413,
-0.2557342947,
0.7907277346,
-0.662914753,
0.7638177872,
0.2758258879,
-0.8840958476,
0.4863437414,
-0.1111607179,
0.2513398826,
0.7910246849,
0.4035380781,
-0.8904727697,
-0.5547077656,
-0.6321915984,
-0.5974269509,
0.5698632598,
0.2640372515,
0.1009575501,
-0.3615330458,
0.5615929365,
0.3757334948,
0.260125041,
-0.3600258231,
-0.2617404163,
0.0652710721,
-0.4203749299,
0.0004983224,
-0.3844379187,
0.0909582376,
-0.4938303232,
0.4623855352,
-0.1706473976,
0.6068117023,
0.4647629559,
-0.317107439,
0.163661629,
0.0664607435,
0.3686611354,
0.4214397371,
0.0071005435,
-0.1607258916,
0.0030725999,
-0.8868618011,
0.0819408521,
-0.0657347664,
-0.0859339908,
0.1867235899,
0.626003623,
0.8316973448,
0.388761133,
-0.7579213381,
0.7265473008,
-0.1858809739,
-0.2000516504,
-0.0222255401,
-0.0716615617,
0.0064134789,
-0.1622596234,
-0.1362272501,
0.0790328756,
0.1922509521,
-0.1795813441,
0.517513454,
0.2900357544,
-0.6417883039,
-0.3883194327,
0.8135958314,
-0.00510957,
-0.3129660487,
0.4197840095,
-0.1390812993,
-0.6270242929,
0.3644102216,
0.8727371097,
0.6836875677,
-0.11350739,
0.1885000467,
0.3068229258,
-0.177792877,
0.2534410655,
0.1984216273,
-0.0998355225,
-0.874073565,
-0.4513783455,
-0.5894839764,
-0.2731083333,
-0.0716417879,
-0.7357181907,
0.4245177805,
-0.0667347908,
-0.1969475448,
0.1489665061,
-0.1816697717,
-0.898406446,
0.235622406,
-0.0650402606,
0.8620758057,
-0.6481620669,
0.9834756851,
0.6463286281,
-0.4645168781,
-0.6125128269,
-0.2374994308,
-0.36021173,
-0.9800881743,
0.6895793676,
0.1799983233,
0.4444169104,
-0.0022707158,
-0.1186241433,
-0.7185524106,
1.0021402836,
0.07838507,
-0.2611707151,
-0.2214462161,
0.8864830732,
0.7891275287,
-0.7627103329,
0.3540897369,
0.7855663896,
0.1162059978,
0.1744311601,
-0.9574024081,
0.2605814338,
-0.4040301442,
-0.1069763526,
0.3435709476,
-0.0584128164,
0.3816963136,
0.0081749558,
-0.1924421042,
0.2606512606,
0.2982256711,
0.0260744803,
0.0301478356,
0.4547485113,
0.5776902437,
0.8857982755,
0.2270318866,
1.082198143,
-0.7178377509,
0.1388505399,
0.7698748708,
-0.2300457358,
0.5395920873,
0.6186916828,
-0.1317822039,
0.560960114,
0.0324910954,
0.141520068,
0.6502081156,
0.0910666063,
-0.3766434491,
-0.1265774965,
-0.3434952199,
-0.20000723,
0.5680132508,
0.437040329,
-0.6360271573,
-0.0090489043,
0.5062014461,
0.2290473878,
-0.0841773152,
-0.1747572273,
1.0520814657,
0.0490691513,
-0.599121809,
0.5774055719,
0.0363470465,
0.4645906985,
-0.7100419998,
0.0029479479,
-0.0686782748,
0.323048234,
-0.0222009867,
-0.2161445022,
0.3241989017,
-0.0956789106,
-0.0487301573,
-0.2012451738,
0.9073528647,
-0.4908436537,
-0.7063884735,
-0.0064675175,
0.4990419149,
-0.000254567,
0.0743628293,
-0.2673189342,
-0.1995055079,
-0.1682605892,
0.2340772748,
0.3451463878,
0.7145071626,
-0.0541443154,
0.455888778,
0.8245584965,
0.469086051,
-0.1826813519,
0.342412442,
1.1181411743,
-0.5410096049,
-0.8009483814,
-0.8377717137,
0.557960093,
-0.1929373294,
-0.2929716408,
0.5707333684,
0.5577291846,
0.423291415,
-0.1422298551,
0.586258173,
0.0899858028,
0.477506429,
-0.4418132007,
1.0085179806,
-0.3460187018,
-0.0049933773,
-0.3670380414,
0.0156506915,
-0.7004411817,
0.0865710825,
-0.3541341424,
-0.3384790719,
0.8170977235,
0.8529466987,
0.1147949994,
0.191781804,
0.418050766,
0.0992713347,
0.7251303792,
0.3328947127,
0.4717583656,
-0.6253452301,
0.2177563757,
-0.2794347405,
-0.2358759791,
0.0233403612,
-0.7239405513,
-1.1315933466,
-0.4697289765,
-0.1433991045,
-0.3937808275,
-0.0450112931,
0.9507569671,
0.8171411157,
-1.0450358391,
0.1510901749,
-0.1626231074,
-0.2429192662,
-0.0974090472,
-0.2211256474,
0.6511453986,
-0.7577625513,
-0.3788252771,
0.155706346,
0.3047831655,
-0.1685255468,
-0.1053851545,
0.0121070473,
0.1178644001,
-0.0825090855,
0.7277265191,
-0.4106734693,
-0.5292086005,
-0.0595025867,
0.074996002,
-0.0083295088,
0.4013217986,
1.2351065874,
-1.1602811813,
0.7004373074,
0.1068016663,
0.8565215468,
0.4098990858,
-0.2479927689,
0.7079117298,
-0.4730370939,
0.3371343315,
0.4370721281,
0.2539531589,
0.2274540514,
-0.6119504571,
0.2721719146,
0.3545695841,
-0.3515544832,
-0.9531968236,
-0.1269593388,
-0.5365731716,
-0.0296450239,
0.8429614902,
-0.0803219229,
-0.1203252077,
-0.3706941903,
-0.2769518495,
0.3711500168,
-0.2564236522,
0.6755033731,
0.5531615615,
-0.100596644,
0.3009838462,
-0.4459421337,
0.7987939119,
0.3708860874,
-0.7393457294,
-0.1254081875,
-0.0754704475,
0.2794138193,
0.1729723364,
1.0202233791,
-0.5969336033,
0.2157676518,
-0.0710209608,
0.082748659,
-0.0150604732,
-0.0455225967,
-0.3478643298,
0.2256442457,
-0.2627411783,
-0.0972819254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14307v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14307v2 | QuST-LLM: Integrating Large Language Models for Comprehensive Spatial Transcriptomics Analysis | 2024-06-20T13:37:10 | 2024-07-01T19:38:03 | Chao Hui Huang | q-bio.GN | q-bio.GN, cs.CL, cs.CV | In this paper, we introduce QuST-LLM, an innovative extension of QuPath that
utilizes the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) to analyze and
interpret spatial transcriptomics (ST) data. In addition to simplifying the
intricate and high-dimensional nature of ST data by offering a comprehensive
workflow that includes data loading, region selection, gene expression
analysis, and functional annotation, QuST-LLM employs LLMs to transform complex
ST data into understandable and detailed biological narratives based on gene
ontology annotations, thereby significantly improving the interpretability of
ST data. Consequently, users can interact with their own ST data using natural
language. Hence, QuST-LLM provides researchers with a potent functionality to
unravel the spatial and functional complexities of tissues, fostering novel
insights and advancements in biomedical research. QuST-LLM is a part of QuST
project. The source code is hosted on GitHub and documentation is available at
(https://github.com/huangch/qust). | [
-0.0479899794,
-1.0170456171,
1.1112226248,
0.0321353637,
-0.3230396211,
0.3574815989,
-0.1278108805,
-0.4507501423,
0.2694895566,
0.715847075,
-0.4465072751,
-1.0643565655,
-0.4715580344,
-0.031112574,
-0.6253515482,
0.681848824,
0.0669677854,
0.5807419419,
-0.2060740888,
-0.3960163593,
-0.0885381401,
-0.6130259633,
-0.3872047961,
0.1365674883,
0.6589670181,
0.3081046939,
0.7852774262,
0.7109140754,
0.6606653333,
0.3095444441,
-0.1659259498,
0.0627183244,
-0.5706241131,
0.2018924057,
-0.1019786,
-0.282509625,
-0.5608584881,
-0.3409827948,
0.8808053136,
0.7627091408,
-0.0198886525,
0.0961397588,
-0.1729858816,
0.5222274065,
0.058723174,
-0.1169425845,
-0.1022518575,
0.1949076951,
-0.2619324327,
-0.337290436,
0.0442891642,
-0.8563225269,
0.5468520522,
-0.481225282,
-0.0708751604,
0.1102182418,
0.6000863314,
0.2572128773,
-0.7073544264,
0.0906855538,
-0.752453804,
0.5248562098,
-0.8921503425,
0.4652212858,
-0.1690259725,
0.477566272,
-0.3106474876,
-0.8874459863,
-0.3076249063,
-0.2667973638,
-0.1712288558,
0.0992166698,
-0.163634181,
0.2416286469,
0.284162432,
0.4367915094,
-0.8122390509,
0.0022272135,
-0.5316710472,
-0.0136659788,
0.6416766644,
0.4287341535,
0.7252438068,
-0.1721167117,
-0.6549314857,
0.2094510496,
-0.787281096,
-0.0459767915,
-0.0725018755,
0.1610586196,
-0.341430068,
0.7057514787,
-0.0635794625,
0.309825182,
-0.4643592238,
0.2517625391,
0.140630424,
-0.4494996667,
-0.128699258,
0.0463561118,
1.0211038589,
0.0692907944,
-0.3548896313,
-0.0700074136,
0.0351672322,
-0.5062353015,
0.0863009468,
-0.5997391343,
-0.1658873111,
0.5555977225,
-0.4854763448,
-0.1198999435,
0.0746186301,
-1.098621726,
-0.4603260159,
-0.3487397432,
0.355235368,
-0.6920526624,
-0.123756066,
0.3567435145,
-0.1663613021,
0.4564846456,
0.4630634487,
-0.1905496716,
0.1615800112,
0.5348049402,
1.1099363565,
-0.4405043423,
-0.164373368,
-0.3810701668,
0.2770702243,
-0.1254299134,
0.9402285814,
-0.5243585706,
-0.6454974413,
-0.1693591028,
0.035404779,
0.0788030028,
-0.25891307,
0.7428680658,
-0.4319035113,
0.0452379659,
-0.4669416249,
-0.5316171646,
-0.4875206053,
0.1459030211,
-0.6474583745,
1.210703969,
0.4919211268,
-0.6854547858,
0.0088696759,
-0.9788743258,
-0.2681883276,
0.4533893466,
-0.2397626489,
-0.1670373231,
0.2731890082,
0.0759493113,
0.3027842343,
-0.3126278818,
0.5846748948,
-0.330806464,
-0.3616348505,
0.2634227872,
0.1665041,
0.744166255,
0.0937238336,
-0.1953750253,
0.7606648803,
-0.6228678823,
-0.1300530732,
0.1418482214,
-0.3479718268,
-0.1524056345,
-0.0098949447,
-0.0161797218,
0.1812670082,
0.4476913214,
-0.7331117988,
0.5745632648,
-0.3231432736,
0.5580964684,
0.4341162443,
0.0234776549,
0.6103463769,
-0.2766290307,
0.6488206983,
0.0632434487,
0.3452968299,
0.1069417894,
-0.252982825,
-0.3591781259,
-0.5524460673,
0.1901099086,
0.513926506,
-0.6832506061,
0.377512008,
-0.7220199108,
-0.6940194964,
-0.544261992,
-0.3402776122,
-0.0682712793,
0.4255361855,
0.5301250815,
-0.0244782493,
-0.8422140479,
-0.9280448556,
0.2138132602,
-0.0910699293,
-0.1632257849,
0.3886927962,
0.4316893816,
-0.5381242037,
0.8429881334,
-0.7376433611,
-0.1657136232,
-0.4596526325,
-0.1820269823,
0.164258793,
0.4355091751,
0.3658249974,
-0.3958123922,
-0.1286425889,
0.2036760598,
-0.7573820949,
-0.3929687738,
-0.0149067864,
-0.6760826707,
-0.2806822062,
0.54357934,
-0.72244519,
0.4633085728,
0.5997596383,
-0.638531208,
0.8471132517,
-0.0292628277,
0.3043248355,
-0.8254930973,
0.0534688681,
-0.083100833,
-0.3002345562,
-0.8392043114,
0.247428894,
-0.105884701,
0.0501547493,
-0.6637542248,
0.4861549139,
-0.119250752,
-0.4629399776,
0.0090862205,
-0.0303543005,
0.3213626444,
0.3554377854,
0.1288526952,
0.6834742427,
0.4360325038,
-0.1455950588,
0.2402347922,
0.6693526506,
-0.2585582733,
-0.094208613,
-0.8488664627,
-0.0506514758,
0.0156597029,
0.3537414074,
-0.9931272864,
-0.0701936409,
0.3137867749,
-0.3716557324,
0.0561747178,
-0.0987972617,
-0.8511813283,
-0.189414233,
-0.347112745,
0.4612965882,
0.4170005918,
-0.4434684515,
0.8884913325,
0.482719183,
-0.1521242261,
0.4432290494,
-0.6335225701,
0.0837018341,
-0.4633320868,
-0.7513106465,
0.1026065871,
-0.0134038441,
-0.1256400943,
-0.1532440782,
0.140053913,
-0.2826375067,
0.0710023269,
0.1951171607,
0.5368097425,
-0.4735777378,
0.0698489174,
0.1668571383,
0.1741476804,
0.1949598789,
-0.3563289344,
0.3558880091,
-0.0391014777,
-0.3639426529,
-0.341222465,
0.6767745018,
0.7551456094,
-0.2581259906,
0.4435078502,
0.6539422274,
-0.2237199396,
0.1554542184,
-0.1788129956,
-0.0198141523,
-0.4242979288,
0.586448431,
-0.1151866838,
-1.4190022945,
0.5435721874,
-0.4416903257,
0.0437907837,
0.4036426246,
0.4143008292,
-0.3395023644,
0.9085787535,
0.48657161,
0.2930369377,
0.137735635,
-0.1011038944,
0.3936333954,
-1.0724833012,
-0.1861223727,
-0.5717666149,
-0.3833665252,
-0.3431838751,
-0.8933056593,
0.6232867241,
-0.0288844388,
-0.5593279004,
0.0556316711,
-0.5415151119,
0.2254022658,
0.3742620945,
0.1195720583,
0.1498409063,
-0.2051437944,
-0.0729361922,
-0.1327828467,
-0.7149640322,
-0.6588465571,
0.7016822696,
0.7783455253,
0.5218571424,
0.455537051,
0.4711221457,
0.0981087685,
0.0155451437,
-0.9934639335,
0.6700364351,
-0.436252892,
-0.216155082,
-0.424685955,
-0.3269822598,
-0.8547406197,
0.28471452,
-0.2717066407,
-0.6876469851,
0.2768089175,
-0.130336076,
-0.7481655478,
0.5685351491,
-0.447625041,
0.7753276229,
-0.660841465,
-0.2302512825,
0.044464387,
-0.6491577625,
0.5814257264,
-0.2223675996,
0.2683112919,
-0.2468900681,
-0.25155738,
0.6858899593,
-0.1686190963,
0.8608412147,
-0.1220826209,
-0.1796745956,
0.0900820643,
0.478012234,
0.2095698714,
0.0490692966,
-0.0217762124,
0.7593230605,
0.4780893028,
-0.4489277005,
-0.4860410392,
0.6509556174,
-0.6666526198,
-0.4582699835,
-0.1744040698,
-0.6927354336,
-0.2645849288,
0.0788697004,
-0.006218479,
0.4134449661,
-0.1383627802,
0.074493967,
0.6442841887,
-0.7497988939,
-0.1083137691,
0.3632345796,
-0.6179746985,
-0.4402788877,
0.5705707073,
-0.1945151687,
-0.0238738544,
0.4489380717,
0.5802391171,
-0.5056931376,
-0.9810630083,
-0.0851402134,
0.3085876703,
-0.4624579847,
-0.2352154404,
-0.7936506271,
-0.2867650688,
-0.1926661283,
-0.1620341092,
-0.1300893575,
-0.358853966,
-0.2692868114,
-0.3302017748,
0.5532574058,
0.9130958915,
0.1309823245,
0.5563516021,
-1.6746273041,
0.1316380799,
-0.2266209126,
0.0986569375,
-0.2532613575,
-0.5664950609,
-0.4994980693,
-0.0002402108,
-0.1937511265,
-0.94735533,
0.6805031896,
0.1892408878,
0.3976782858,
0.1023131311,
-0.3283894956,
0.7487481236,
-0.5320667028,
1.0121109486,
0.1070466638,
-0.8106199503,
0.4540407658,
-0.7182608247,
0.6101664901,
0.2921297848,
0.1964927912,
-0.4576537609,
-0.454192996,
-0.2564507425,
-1.1028872728,
0.2678870559,
-0.1120289043,
-0.2138390392,
-0.030809693,
0.2568483651,
0.401586473,
-0.1013275981,
-0.411308527,
0.1378461272,
0.0237553511,
-0.4310202897,
0.1035551429,
-0.5718197823,
-0.1798742265,
-0.5342972875,
0.2968270481,
-0.1714602709,
0.2429265827,
0.5715069771,
-0.1339746267,
0.0078554461,
0.3002199829,
0.5717994571,
0.3173131049,
-0.1315757334,
0.1130448282,
0.3282378316,
-0.4703392386,
-0.1038200557,
-0.172163859,
-0.0286031514,
-0.0995815918,
0.752959311,
0.5230508447,
0.5924410224,
-0.8966806531,
0.395424217,
-0.1837327927,
-0.5921735168,
-0.4022275209,
-0.1831887364,
0.3208093941,
0.7390720844,
0.3300789595,
-0.2019981742,
0.6064609885,
0.019909149,
0.290153116,
0.2006341219,
-0.5099225044,
-0.5679374933,
0.5893354416,
0.1625090092,
0.345633328,
0.5142461658,
0.0659374222,
-0.7636858225,
0.4693817794,
0.1955880374,
0.9520033598,
-0.0179045592,
0.07618393,
0.5919837952,
0.0498965345,
0.208540678,
0.544639051,
0.4067437947,
-0.4966997802,
-0.7523953915,
-0.9193071127,
-0.0989890248,
-0.0264368542,
-0.4368864894,
0.1041282564,
-0.470923394,
-0.1298024356,
-0.267146945,
-0.0186826009,
-0.404110074,
-0.2189146876,
0.0966490209,
1.1542768478,
-0.6831147671,
1.1474322081,
0.8857662678,
-0.0641069189,
-0.6802551746,
-0.1785160303,
0.231979236,
-0.5162575245,
0.9603785872,
-0.1757676005,
0.0223383587,
0.0931356326,
-0.6308398843,
-1.0677363873,
1.25408113,
0.2023056149,
-0.90170151,
-0.11993175,
0.386302948,
0.7973909378,
-0.3669449389,
0.0016584083,
0.7671251893,
0.6817228794,
0.1809850782,
-0.5539290905,
0.2363317907,
0.1170671731,
0.0358140394,
0.4414684474,
-0.374530077,
0.6051992774,
-0.2310387045,
-0.3482370675,
0.294290781,
0.5892304182,
0.2322016358,
0.1107267439,
0.248090446,
0.5155951977,
0.5615736842,
-0.3666416705,
0.8213990927,
-0.2097009122,
0.1438440233,
1.0863448381,
-0.3925683498,
0.8969568014,
0.5946136713,
-0.3884358108,
0.3606562614,
0.6831616163,
-0.0747247934,
0.0619822182,
0.4421089292,
-0.2299412191,
-0.1802301556,
-0.1213668734,
-0.0794155449,
0.5512748361,
0.4948214591,
0.0659087002,
-0.235644415,
-0.224468872,
-0.2663942575,
-0.0292804893,
-0.2392785996,
0.7402737141,
0.1656731814,
0.1337220818,
-0.0198900439,
-0.4521194994,
0.4892197847,
-0.6379393935,
-0.301658988,
-0.2976540923,
-0.4344350398,
-0.4227029979,
-1.0502957106,
0.6130648255,
-0.309194535,
0.0518548191,
0.1185853109,
0.5201240182,
-0.532789886,
-0.306291163,
0.6058525443,
0.8338621259,
0.1379700005,
0.2387521714,
-0.645057559,
0.247003302,
0.1636801213,
-0.1016291529,
0.27277264,
0.7201288342,
-0.1759869754,
0.6020629406,
0.8971812129,
0.2896735072,
-0.1386329979,
0.0472532175,
0.9110841751,
-1.1682401896,
-0.185683772,
-0.8981665969,
0.7394469976,
0.0307438057,
0.0456844606,
0.6262965798,
0.688826561,
0.3886021376,
-0.0573861003,
0.819832027,
0.1621822417,
0.7234572172,
-0.5046569109,
0.7527349591,
-0.5451837182,
0.5202333331,
0.1449711472,
-0.6581540704,
-0.5468747616,
0.1977247596,
-0.366368711,
-0.2985923886,
0.9812842011,
0.5258787274,
0.1022852212,
0.0043738657,
0.4794245958,
0.454731971,
0.5598722696,
0.5463122725,
1.1442807913,
-0.0262547322,
0.334083885,
0.0624508373,
-0.1723729521,
-0.1661802083,
-0.6914798021,
-0.5796195865,
-0.4855557382,
-0.3305338323,
-0.212440595,
-0.208265841,
0.821279645,
0.5215203166,
-0.7600651383,
-0.2163660824,
0.3055990636,
-0.0538179092,
0.2023733705,
-0.2527835667,
0.6140462756,
0.0034147552,
-0.5028698444,
0.4772587419,
0.680654645,
0.2230582982,
-0.1093035564,
-0.0250137169,
-0.3216408491,
-0.0634140894,
0.8600424528,
0.2174516171,
-0.6062664986,
-0.2916403413,
0.0174204689,
-0.3188378215,
0.3236941397,
0.7580976486,
-0.4453380406,
0.1064149514,
0.6806793213,
0.7129670978,
-0.0216171034,
0.0825419277,
0.8360193372,
-0.3717321754,
-0.3023017347,
0.4185225964,
0.5558552146,
0.297213614,
-0.6598520875,
0.5772450566,
-0.1128097773,
-0.7328424454,
-0.6332031488,
0.1973250508,
-1.2375216484,
-0.3994850218,
1.4159235954,
-0.0785928965,
-0.4718451202,
-0.222789079,
-0.6829381585,
0.264913857,
-0.308799684,
0.417402029,
0.3242204487,
-0.1293314546,
-0.330429703,
-0.918892324,
0.4507304728,
0.0687645748,
-1.021696806,
-0.0098846834,
0.7317394614,
0.1684215665,
-0.3388808966,
0.5379216075,
-0.5317710638,
0.0739546344,
-0.5340842009,
0.175240472,
0.0483066589,
0.0712280422,
-0.6834123135,
-0.0454358645,
0.1493034214,
0.0337094516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14284v1 | VAIYAKARANA : A Benchmark for Automatic Grammar Correction in Bangla | 2024-06-20T13:09:29 | 2024-06-20T13:09:29 | Pramit Bhattacharyya, Arnab Bhattacharya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Bangla (Bengali) is the fifth most spoken language globally and, yet, the
problem of automatic grammar correction in Bangla is still in its nascent
stage. This is mostly due to the need for a large corpus of grammatically
incorrect sentences, with their corresponding correct counterparts. The present
state-of-the-art techniques to curate a corpus for grammatically wrong
sentences involve random swapping, insertion and deletion of words.
However,these steps may not always generate grammatically wrong sentences in
Bangla. In this work, we propose a pragmatic approach to generate grammatically
wrong sentences in Bangla. We first categorize the different kinds of errors in
Bangla into 5 broad classes and 12 finer classes. We then use these to generate
grammatically wrong sentences systematically from a correct sentence. This
approach can generate a large number of wrong sentences and can, thus, mitigate
the challenge of lacking a large corpus for neural networks. We provide a
dataset, Vaiyakarana, consisting of 92,830 grammatically incorrect sentences as
well as 18,426 correct sentences. We also collected 619 human-generated
sentences from essays written by Bangla native speakers. This helped us to
understand errors that are more frequent. We evaluated our corpus against
neural models and LLMs and also benchmark it against human evaluators who are
native speakers of Bangla. Our analysis shows that native speakers are far more
accurate than state-of-the-art models to detect whether the sentence is
grammatically correct. Our methodology of generating erroneous sentences can be
applied for most other Indian languages as well. | [
0.3361803889,
-1.0748460293,
0.2002447098,
0.6466953158,
-0.1309252679,
-0.0721134096,
-0.1424242705,
-0.0743572265,
0.1687996089,
0.1566791087,
-0.1020908654,
-0.3428381085,
-0.1557015479,
0.4429542422,
-0.5996053815,
0.4721781313,
0.010557726,
0.1076452732,
-0.2676190436,
0.1570034921,
-0.8378989697,
-0.3938981593,
-0.1942008436,
0.2010519058,
0.4134615362,
0.2808125913,
0.3565829098,
0.6676846147,
0.399699688,
0.3883402944,
-0.2197606117,
0.8432273269,
-0.3065828085,
0.0248883851,
-0.4339308143,
-0.6095438004,
-0.3370512128,
-0.5667685866,
0.5945282578,
0.4840033948,
-0.3090338111,
0.1637501419,
-0.128422603,
0.5965119004,
-0.889269948,
0.0988591611,
-0.7352554798,
-0.0956343487,
-0.5629456639,
-0.1156305149,
-0.4829595089,
-0.8864110708,
-0.6154153347,
-0.3543794155,
0.0355089009,
-0.0902732238,
1.1404036283,
0.3754707575,
-0.2564920783,
-0.3027185798,
-0.6214745641,
0.4884484708,
-0.7324727178,
0.0073663434,
0.5310532451,
0.4669616818,
-0.4501155317,
-0.3530284166,
-0.8348905444,
-0.0309778042,
-0.0507422239,
0.2291175723,
-0.0650414303,
-0.0125029385,
-0.019592138,
0.0593812242,
-0.6705824733,
-0.1432673633,
-0.5516017675,
-0.1734391302,
0.7907424569,
0.210706532,
0.2998407781,
-0.7074456811,
0.1382168829,
-0.0062302556,
-0.6647976637,
-0.0687137097,
0.8391169906,
0.6588456035,
0.2632419765,
0.6622694135,
-0.1660913229,
1.3418234587,
0.3429567516,
-0.2318796366,
0.2294904441,
-0.6427654028,
-0.3848428428,
0.3408706784,
0.4808002114,
0.4667375684,
0.5295069218,
-0.0449930951,
0.1901651621,
0.4928318262,
0.5721184611,
-0.2189685255,
-0.0439131632,
0.1741396487,
-0.1760704517,
-0.535402,
-0.2163985372,
-0.7947241068,
-0.4189390838,
-0.300527066,
0.2116921246,
-0.525116384,
-0.1989984065,
-0.1041154489,
0.3079067469,
0.1002978534,
0.1077085882,
-0.7831223011,
-0.0520556346,
0.3185036182,
0.7244369984,
0.3633979559,
-0.4696423113,
-0.4396046102,
0.0094284043,
-0.7004354596,
0.9198442698,
-0.3888368011,
-0.3756861091,
0.0993868411,
-0.3437179923,
-0.341917336,
-0.8343883753,
0.6763797402,
-0.0657570958,
-0.1942564994,
-0.163170293,
-0.5895931721,
-0.0625419915,
0.1759512424,
-0.1654968262,
0.880444169,
-0.000284121,
-0.4984906614,
0.3192842603,
-0.1246916428,
-0.4056882858,
0.1108558178,
-0.1588660926,
-0.5787761211,
0.0812858865,
0.2098236978,
0.4876963198,
0.1841812879,
1.0153739452,
0.0265671853,
-0.5998280644,
0.1784659624,
-0.2228706628,
0.9124649763,
0.1990210116,
-0.3865714669,
0.1604576409,
-1.1323246956,
0.2278285772,
-0.0400382876,
-0.2531285882,
-0.3908943534,
-0.0860367268,
0.2043397576,
0.1414537281,
-0.1062250361,
-0.5948476791,
0.2357136756,
-0.7286348939,
0.1450541019,
0.9001671672,
-0.0083709983,
0.0505440272,
-0.3950411677,
0.3203503489,
-0.0091668023,
-0.0385886244,
-0.2094632387,
-0.3071677685,
-0.7492110729,
-0.3335860968,
0.4176415503,
0.811668694,
-0.2911970615,
0.5703372359,
-0.1492159367,
-0.7081748843,
-1.0331798792,
0.3794480562,
0.6502511501,
0.4882563055,
0.2464959025,
0.1275889277,
-1.0348974466,
-1.0124708414,
-0.6933500767,
-0.5174787045,
0.7208872437,
-0.2142782509,
0.3913197517,
-0.1359621733,
1.1884949207,
-0.0337784961,
-0.1704788059,
0.0339217037,
0.0873276219,
0.0757408217,
0.2723986506,
0.275632143,
-0.9627757072,
-0.5152196884,
-0.041591458,
-0.7832337022,
-0.4720938504,
-0.3536589146,
-0.1427467167,
0.527778089,
0.5006152391,
-0.6752631068,
0.7160743475,
0.1307650954,
-0.269297123,
0.8145770431,
-0.2156314403,
-0.0714609027,
-1.2393995523,
0.1971212178,
-0.1533455402,
-0.443652153,
-0.2983952463,
0.2077214271,
0.1938135624,
0.2743404806,
-0.3010430932,
0.4812602699,
-0.2642920315,
0.3086617589,
-0.2456613779,
-0.0801671371,
-0.3928532302,
0.402071923,
-0.2753551006,
0.6121484041,
0.1121325716,
-0.5588757396,
0.6484956145,
0.2117468566,
-0.080115661,
0.795641005,
-0.437974751,
-0.3290493786,
-0.4008604288,
0.028649535,
-1.0802236795,
-0.4558340013,
0.2913192213,
-0.4464577436,
0.2471330315,
-0.0044816015,
-0.6087249517,
-0.2491528988,
0.0915897638,
0.0426567607,
0.3681035936,
-0.4697917104,
0.3356056511,
0.0792580098,
-0.1986831874,
-0.7278443575,
-0.6442922354,
0.2392303944,
-0.0224805474,
-0.5280246139,
0.0764930919,
-0.0258614849,
-0.5880255103,
-0.0341804959,
0.0963983312,
0.008640388,
-0.1402180642,
0.6723995805,
0.0702354014,
-0.0017964619,
0.2059074491,
0.0249063578,
-0.0034962341,
-0.2253175229,
-0.0566090681,
0.2713247538,
-0.3675313294,
-0.2907125056,
-0.4693948627,
0.04911948,
0.439771533,
-0.0081155496,
0.4667556882,
0.5130955577,
-0.4119904339,
-0.0136587638,
-0.6736065149,
0.4100673497,
-0.367226392,
0.4088451564,
-0.2363425493,
-0.219496578,
0.2301594168,
0.0837098062,
-0.0363607928,
0.3225078285,
0.7969496846,
-0.0086095119,
0.6640672088,
0.4561984241,
0.172544688,
0.0000678964,
0.2114600986,
0.6864813566,
-0.2637304366,
-0.272593081,
-0.327643007,
0.0895405561,
-0.7536597848,
-0.28994596,
0.0211876668,
0.1662380695,
-0.1131605059,
0.3280296922,
-0.4610902071,
0.5177794695,
0.4488060176,
-0.1654091179,
0.19591555,
0.0331917629,
-0.3665745258,
-0.1977085471,
-0.4674924612,
-0.7606778145,
0.8923959136,
-0.2460022867,
0.4475767612,
0.2883096635,
0.7981060743,
0.241296038,
0.0824040323,
-0.389010489,
0.6014806032,
-0.1103694066,
-0.6607782841,
0.0121333217,
-0.2984054387,
-0.7672407627,
0.1786856353,
0.0399016328,
-0.5461586714,
0.3096458912,
0.3695774674,
-0.5493953824,
0.2138618827,
-1.0492768288,
0.8601704836,
-0.1712882072,
-0.7573390603,
0.2020920068,
-0.7466571927,
0.5442612171,
-0.0944872946,
0.2641596198,
0.0434400812,
0.2712545991,
0.3020597994,
-0.6782707572,
1.0550614595,
-0.2595811784,
0.1228744984,
0.3598710299,
0.1091690734,
0.2049166262,
-0.0281300563,
-0.0231948514,
-0.282759726,
-0.1072439477,
-0.6323559284,
-0.4636122584,
0.672044754,
-0.7225148082,
-0.1454187632,
-0.7469211817,
-0.4117092788,
-0.2101508528,
0.1068733111,
0.3311316371,
0.2946007848,
-0.0880750492,
-0.2828982472,
0.2277752459,
-0.0376506634,
0.5586029291,
0.2758079171,
-0.5144812465,
-0.088952139,
1.1825768948,
0.3862663805,
-0.1806416065,
0.2980340123,
-0.0278651118,
-0.1430308521,
-0.5841550827,
-0.6721823812,
0.2285505235,
-0.6509490609,
-0.2962556779,
-0.5937936902,
-0.1910384297,
-0.5967274308,
-0.3460052609,
-0.3750075996,
-0.3579908013,
0.0091380654,
-0.1844429374,
0.2665341198,
0.7201225162,
-0.2634728551,
0.2898055613,
-0.5687230825,
0.0921397507,
0.3007586598,
-0.0496404693,
-0.1688000262,
-0.4335488975,
0.0395646729,
0.0043587335,
-0.3343332112,
-0.7852867246,
0.6656165719,
0.2670885623,
0.2823609412,
-0.0415908508,
-0.3853412867,
1.2676323652,
-0.4801040292,
0.6577264071,
0.0339857191,
-0.9313584566,
0.8688707352,
-0.4965818524,
0.3434652686,
0.6292793751,
0.1842026711,
-0.5594578981,
-0.3846981227,
-0.6754208803,
-1.0755627155,
0.242614001,
0.3613380194,
0.0781325474,
-0.2138177454,
0.5343578458,
0.1534705311,
0.2195830345,
-0.539740622,
-0.1026916578,
-0.3564034402,
-0.6070699692,
-0.0617216676,
-0.2342951298,
0.3628561795,
-0.3076889217,
1.0045461655,
0.065887697,
0.0646811053,
0.3463642597,
-0.4823457897,
-0.1797552556,
0.3329301178,
0.8439278603,
1.1662032604,
-0.3479016423,
-0.1325651258,
-0.1060404032,
-0.3981933594,
0.3347078264,
0.0947592705,
-0.4171898365,
0.4568077326,
0.3477209806,
0.5542692542,
0.1190280095,
-0.9883368015,
0.4216036499,
-0.0035902888,
0.2020095885,
-0.6635356545,
-0.1582367867,
0.1955785751,
-0.0765028,
0.2591904104,
0.4614319205,
-0.0578396618,
-0.4985753298,
0.1391204894,
-0.2801683545,
0.0901188254,
-0.1731705815,
0.3540000021,
0.1236260533,
-0.4659253061,
0.5243604779,
-0.5346564054,
-0.3192071319,
0.3967236578,
0.7048230767,
0.5441473126,
-0.5970384479,
0.4518553317,
0.7736255527,
0.273478508,
-0.0666099712,
0.4462602735,
0.441831857,
-0.373143822,
-0.6065036654,
-0.9674399495,
-0.1494142711,
-0.0881375372,
-0.4588917196,
0.3699347973,
-0.4951399267,
-0.0705770627,
0.0579219609,
-0.1462875158,
-0.1912885606,
0.2874182761,
0.0877771452,
0.4613001645,
-0.8930503726,
0.5261504054,
0.9318065643,
-0.5651600957,
-0.8132640719,
-0.2734067738,
0.2348228544,
-0.636420548,
0.8631476164,
-0.0205827169,
-0.1698515415,
-0.1266803741,
-0.4721426666,
-0.4285287559,
0.5180544853,
0.4196154475,
-1.0909858942,
-0.2198010832,
-0.0494865514,
0.6822942495,
-0.003276428,
0.2514956594,
0.3362347186,
0.4634613395,
-0.1756062657,
-1.0662564039,
-0.139129132,
-0.7660674453,
0.3805878162,
0.2180928141,
-0.5802795291,
0.83200562,
-0.0110489791,
0.0765800402,
0.385279119,
0.6093031764,
0.2363367528,
0.1754514128,
0.1984115988,
0.6693351865,
1.1205755472,
-0.0221193749,
1.0391795635,
0.2119768858,
0.1097882912,
1.076205492,
-0.3674086332,
0.9262137413,
0.5446881056,
-0.2552717328,
0.4588321447,
0.6384468675,
0.0735614747,
0.3503197134,
0.6342671514,
-0.0689965487,
-0.222584784,
-0.2311890274,
-0.2006026357,
0.752302289,
0.2066260278,
-0.0764846876,
-0.1977409869,
0.1658147424,
0.1954909861,
0.8264611363,
-0.3815463185,
0.5120613575,
-0.2302716076,
-0.6735417247,
0.8989289403,
0.3137840927,
0.6928667426,
-0.3744227886,
-0.1565456092,
-0.4105623066,
0.5276114941,
-0.4702524245,
-0.1467778236,
0.7217459679,
0.3585111201,
-0.1870170236,
-0.0011009759,
0.8093890548,
-0.5623509884,
-0.885586679,
-0.2114863098,
0.4844733775,
0.2477748543,
0.112736553,
-0.3562546074,
0.105030477,
-0.0835742801,
0.5348883867,
0.1188660562,
-0.0994995758,
-0.2952790558,
0.2879968286,
0.4354839921,
0.4154937267,
0.5902175903,
-0.0566257201,
0.2156475335,
-0.7059728503,
-0.6862299442,
-0.8862766623,
0.4985910952,
-0.3541870415,
-0.5290641785,
0.9672005773,
0.5330936909,
0.9393273592,
-0.0221620072,
0.9108718634,
-0.134285599,
0.7259354591,
-0.5159178972,
0.50529778,
-0.3756393194,
-0.1040822268,
-0.2887463868,
-1.0098090172,
-0.5747459531,
0.9592694044,
-0.3593119681,
0.0035779884,
0.7235383391,
1.0835341215,
0.0355879702,
0.1028390303,
0.2152998745,
0.6612704396,
0.0940067545,
0.458224982,
0.8459941745,
-0.6450180411,
0.4671049714,
-0.2379884571,
-0.0140219042,
-0.654705286,
-0.6664733291,
-0.6761705279,
-0.7107822299,
-0.4367062747,
-0.4574960768,
0.8390850425,
1.0452324152,
0.6341665387,
-0.736053884,
-0.3275848627,
-0.384067446,
0.1274124384,
-0.3338800371,
-0.2581608295,
0.4066460133,
-0.4709942937,
-0.6979540586,
0.551928699,
0.2970786095,
-0.2907839119,
-0.0743471235,
0.1832462847,
-0.9229229689,
0.0652455091,
0.3758604228,
0.4058612883,
-0.8022227287,
-0.0442483872,
-0.1493633986,
-0.2527039349,
-0.0239406731,
0.5888096094,
-0.7039710283,
0.7367041111,
0.4675531387,
0.7518751025,
0.0832571536,
0.0471193157,
0.4717214704,
-0.8637881279,
0.022056181,
0.2699380815,
0.0669451803,
0.7923364639,
-0.2682700753,
0.4067662358,
0.5313087106,
-0.5128091574,
-1.1618950367,
-0.0657589808,
-0.7989146113,
-0.143837899,
1.0229542255,
-0.0699637756,
-0.8127661943,
-0.3301475048,
-0.5112501383,
0.4387598932,
-0.0582673326,
0.8993145227,
0.8185223341,
0.1265614927,
0.2490597516,
-0.3331919312,
0.3201752007,
0.8719996214,
-0.6267692447,
0.0603701435,
0.5270444751,
0.1402950138,
0.3896356523,
0.5512058139,
-0.0374812074,
0.7456017733,
0.1552219838,
0.0204233676,
-0.2599583864,
-0.3193336129,
-0.432059437,
0.0844636708,
-0.0726023167,
-0.0479621775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14282v1 | Learning to Plan for Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models from Knowledge Graphs | 2024-06-20T13:07:38 | 2024-06-20T13:07:38 | Junjie Wang, Mingyang Chen, Binbin Hu, Dan Yang, Ziqi Liu, Yue Shen, Peng Wei, Zhiqiang Zhang, Jinjie Gu, Jun Zhou, Jeff Z. Pan, Wen Zhang, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Improving the performance of large language models (LLMs) in complex
question-answering (QA) scenarios has always been a research focal point.
Recent studies have attempted to enhance LLMs' performance by combining
step-wise planning with external retrieval. While effective for advanced models
like GPT-3.5, smaller LLMs face challenges in decomposing complex questions,
necessitating supervised fine-tuning. Previous work has relied on manual
annotation and knowledge distillation from teacher LLMs, which are
time-consuming and not accurate enough. In this paper, we introduce a novel
framework for enhancing LLMs' planning capabilities by using planning data
derived from knowledge graphs (KGs). LLMs fine-tuned with this data have
improved planning capabilities, better equipping them to handle complex QA
tasks that involve retrieval. Evaluations on multiple datasets, including our
newly proposed benchmark, highlight the effectiveness of our framework and the
benefits of KG-derived planning data. | [
-0.4101662636,
-0.5946242809,
0.7655358315,
-0.1510868371,
-0.0461574085,
0.2142393291,
-0.0246810336,
-0.2590997517,
0.1915559918,
0.6105570793,
-0.4755730331,
-0.4649886489,
-0.3438251019,
0.0173654761,
-0.2460372746,
0.472784102,
-0.1606326103,
0.0148317451,
-0.1269134283,
0.1074422821,
-0.5136313438,
-0.31500265,
-0.7253533006,
-0.4492333829,
0.8035458326,
0.5891028047,
0.6907169819,
0.3884984851,
0.0870805904,
0.1544560939,
-0.1018084586,
0.7516878247,
-0.6157681942,
0.207048431,
-0.12809591,
-0.4340748489,
-0.3662787974,
-0.2949440479,
0.5818969607,
0.8710622191,
-0.1700176895,
0.1294171065,
-0.1592281759,
0.8287184834,
-0.6880628467,
0.601543963,
-0.6381228566,
0.0360754989,
0.1375169307,
-0.3087955117,
-0.4124201536,
-0.480555594,
0.2211969793,
-0.5964899659,
-0.0804319903,
-0.0259998329,
0.3713263273,
-0.0139373671,
-0.5412636399,
-0.3073510528,
-0.7965226173,
0.2311772257,
-0.5780615807,
0.4075781405,
0.5361440182,
0.6293953657,
-0.4103602171,
-0.9143334627,
-0.5518716574,
0.1704047769,
-0.1857639104,
-0.0533363856,
-0.0226148963,
0.2097484469,
0.4998287559,
0.0373569727,
-0.4105508626,
-0.072050415,
-0.404281646,
-0.0849166438,
0.557534337,
0.1931158304,
0.1458977312,
-0.1700327992,
-0.0110691451,
-0.185366869,
-0.8990464807,
-0.0056564799,
0.234011665,
0.4925217628,
0.3023800552,
0.7878286839,
-0.8660549521,
0.7820951343,
-0.3028288484,
-0.1733362228,
0.1162284687,
-0.1732948869,
-0.1830495894,
-0.1074140146,
0.3697474301,
0.2305310965,
0.6168224216,
-0.5545410514,
-0.3555049002,
-0.462934792,
0.0205798969,
-0.9695322514,
-0.6013439298,
0.0563109033,
0.143748045,
-0.0339543521,
-0.2745474279,
-0.6027995348,
-0.3124815822,
-0.4607098997,
0.5712502003,
-0.5197524428,
-0.1582774669,
0.2246481776,
-0.0949331447,
0.0176990237,
0.2752896249,
-0.7362727523,
0.0828949139,
0.5171768069,
0.3029088676,
0.1766842306,
-0.1484375745,
-0.7544539571,
0.6236441135,
-0.5810683966,
0.8511449099,
-0.6020098329,
-0.3169129193,
0.2581818998,
-0.1937706321,
0.0000186698,
-0.6509423256,
0.4063937962,
-1.0309076309,
0.1837183386,
-0.5825078487,
-0.4733950496,
-0.3171491027,
0.6981511116,
-0.6437772512,
0.9579230547,
0.2358692735,
-0.4774517417,
0.3102609813,
-0.3967299759,
-0.5251969695,
0.1226666644,
-0.1432822347,
-0.1070141867,
-0.4175301194,
0.6291942596,
0.578062892,
-0.2334655225,
0.318356961,
-0.1221873984,
-0.1827653944,
-0.1595125645,
-0.0974656716,
0.31731233,
0.1929379702,
0.1811942905,
0.2889083624,
-0.7804023027,
0.5528430939,
0.0604419708,
-0.6110173464,
-0.185776189,
0.252584517,
-0.5079773664,
0.2311936021,
0.1943575889,
-0.2629430592,
0.4279355407,
-0.4854851067,
0.3089655936,
0.4674981534,
0.0876396894,
0.4654791653,
-0.3288192451,
0.6045777798,
-0.2623516917,
0.0971548483,
0.1195745692,
-0.2345384061,
-0.4537184536,
-0.0787242353,
0.0347368494,
0.3674362302,
-1.2197101116,
-0.0325428583,
-0.4516093731,
-0.6767007709,
-0.1576690674,
0.057155557,
0.3280887306,
0.5728815794,
0.6468903422,
0.0389555879,
-0.3922234178,
-0.6745144129,
-0.1935318708,
-0.1631174535,
-0.0553219356,
0.3590082228,
0.1005104408,
0.0170045141,
0.9891701341,
-0.8787543774,
-0.1538522094,
-0.6098879576,
-0.0687523037,
0.091050826,
-0.0026808844,
0.2616801262,
-0.9764107466,
-0.5370060205,
-0.1919714808,
-0.3660686612,
-0.0745351985,
0.2507520616,
-0.3523879647,
-0.2467786968,
0.5577086806,
-0.6716371179,
0.1279934943,
0.237207666,
-0.2788316905,
0.6829835176,
-0.1157006919,
0.010477053,
-1.0859134197,
-0.0626137406,
-0.3775081933,
-0.2911792099,
-0.5917001963,
0.0974363834,
0.2521890402,
-0.0506657884,
-0.3836798072,
0.5778040886,
-0.4289139211,
-0.2506696582,
-0.1498329639,
0.3628279567,
0.0526934043,
0.5613675117,
-0.2140105069,
0.8720912933,
0.2501589358,
-0.6647994518,
0.3384800255,
0.5122635365,
-0.2963676155,
0.2185919285,
-0.3239756823,
0.038321767,
-0.1787854284,
0.281378001,
-0.9236501455,
-0.2547648549,
0.1875610352,
-0.236012131,
0.5124816298,
-0.49406901,
-0.7628777027,
-0.4203037322,
-0.1436111033,
0.2941823006,
0.2335978597,
-0.5662918687,
0.913436532,
0.4145753682,
-0.2476202548,
-0.5221226215,
-0.2310510874,
-0.074432157,
-0.0298137199,
-0.4332941771,
0.2502958477,
0.145579949,
-0.025533881,
0.0197067149,
-0.1383147687,
-0.0779740959,
0.0836255252,
-0.0691068172,
0.0638414323,
0.0018313571,
0.3808556497,
0.075403966,
-0.0169371907,
0.1853123903,
-0.3195968866,
0.9370183945,
0.4703880847,
-0.2621162534,
0.0283084847,
0.0175069477,
0.2902568579,
-0.445436269,
0.5152903199,
0.2586003542,
-0.3710513115,
-0.1325552166,
-0.6186578274,
-0.1512662321,
-0.462290138,
0.5010105371,
-0.5780259967,
-0.7620301843,
0.4478551149,
-0.3600350916,
0.0216259211,
0.1949855536,
0.1445512921,
0.0373862721,
1.1219670773,
0.4572372437,
-0.1109561995,
0.366151005,
-0.3399895728,
0.1682413369,
-0.959918499,
-0.4548614025,
-0.4568060338,
-0.3128677607,
-0.448213011,
-0.6081987023,
0.3786907792,
0.3246317804,
-0.2983313203,
0.0114515591,
-0.1213480011,
0.6258530617,
0.360552907,
0.0133603588,
0.3662029207,
0.1026915461,
-0.3581098616,
0.3163119555,
-0.8053606153,
-0.4821226001,
1.2484271526,
-0.0345637277,
0.5037525892,
0.0935466215,
0.519059062,
-0.3188867867,
0.2324765623,
-0.4858510494,
0.8534001112,
-0.0384289138,
-0.5520470738,
-0.658454597,
-0.6625760794,
-0.8738019466,
0.3970020115,
-0.1154818088,
-0.6608180404,
-0.1164942756,
-0.0652498156,
-0.2634890676,
0.4043524563,
-0.7043130398,
0.5511850119,
-0.1485045999,
-0.0972673818,
-0.2804898918,
-0.2869885862,
0.0296125431,
-0.0634655058,
-0.0087665385,
-0.3185217083,
0.0975708365,
0.6995473504,
-0.1594011486,
0.5710103512,
-0.4514042437,
-0.1110587567,
0.4209907651,
0.2345523238,
0.9724417329,
-0.1175687537,
-0.2689551413,
-0.6063768864,
0.1661218405,
-0.5114377737,
-0.6968323588,
0.5763440728,
-0.5514679551,
-0.5933019519,
0.1703621596,
-0.9362792969,
-0.8851345181,
0.4607694745,
-0.3192872405,
0.5269111991,
0.0417672209,
-0.0246259458,
0.4802532196,
-0.2757707536,
0.1803760976,
0.6178370118,
-0.5531848073,
-0.4059564173,
0.7622304559,
0.520440042,
0.4450243711,
0.6215283871,
0.1035269573,
-0.5032827854,
-0.8590854406,
-0.2087026685,
0.2431535125,
-0.8621137738,
-0.2806252837,
-0.6365207434,
-0.1355556995,
-0.6361731887,
0.1707384437,
-0.1102899611,
-0.5671579838,
0.0880430862,
-0.4068533182,
0.307151109,
0.7273383141,
0.1831213683,
0.2013577074,
-0.5506241918,
0.2853631079,
0.4832083881,
0.3334577084,
0.0913912505,
-0.1678669453,
-0.0958152562,
0.0723326802,
-0.234402284,
-0.626064837,
0.5091315508,
-0.0764446855,
0.5255658031,
0.0225691106,
0.3355436027,
0.9908401966,
-0.3613338172,
0.2620277107,
-0.2947912216,
-0.2108822167,
0.5861160755,
-0.4035597444,
0.3056376874,
0.5321790576,
0.6142535806,
-0.3738472164,
-0.1369995773,
-0.3948652744,
-1.0915994644,
0.568590343,
0.0315688886,
0.0039281296,
-0.0157341957,
0.6996179819,
-0.0815604627,
0.3923976719,
-0.4372307062,
-0.1046100557,
0.3682857752,
-0.1825165004,
-0.1131954268,
-0.591293335,
-0.2146927416,
-0.2378151268,
0.6615649462,
-0.4915286005,
0.0147292335,
0.0977876112,
-0.0451768413,
-0.1645370424,
0.2096031159,
0.1294469237,
0.9911189079,
-0.1076653451,
0.2313109487,
0.5092844963,
-0.256873101,
-0.1593403369,
0.3932607472,
-0.3097298443,
-0.501842916,
0.2241667807,
0.4048518836,
0.2131776959,
-0.8012204766,
0.1545509845,
0.0459569804,
-0.0381103866,
-0.2977226675,
0.1550244689,
0.3644051552,
0.6558493972,
0.4852068424,
-0.4528702199,
0.0000568229,
-0.4203534424,
0.1779070795,
0.4048042595,
-0.3125818372,
-0.0468368791,
0.2893446982,
-0.1672818512,
-0.0747353286,
0.6708287597,
-0.3541632295,
-0.6438912153,
0.3966509104,
0.5061320066,
0.3279112279,
-0.0627406687,
0.2747545242,
0.484634608,
0.1364195943,
-0.1037343666,
0.7279231548,
0.0037996648,
-0.6604837179,
-0.5637334585,
-0.5224013925,
-0.1205356121,
0.0044230111,
-0.3430460989,
0.3078130782,
-0.2756713331,
0.1977262944,
-0.4022290707,
0.3681857884,
-0.6395398378,
0.325884372,
-0.0366870165,
1.0313376188,
-0.3717859685,
0.8553596139,
0.5945187211,
-0.3411141336,
-1.4746652842,
0.0187542699,
-0.5256415009,
-0.9949691892,
0.6170393825,
-0.0127340155,
-0.0574880727,
0.3505941629,
-0.1266929507,
-1.000967145,
1.5076783895,
0.3912063241,
-0.6330820918,
-0.4163550138,
0.4040521085,
0.4245125055,
-0.1129602268,
0.1478675455,
0.4975198209,
0.402456522,
0.4789885283,
-0.7441086769,
0.0752940178,
0.2613327503,
-0.3423705399,
0.4813966751,
-0.4018076062,
0.5908180475,
-0.434844017,
-0.2357064933,
-0.1057792231,
0.5499417186,
0.2281264514,
0.3301619291,
0.4500119984,
0.5635339618,
0.9538067579,
-0.0645328462,
0.9895223975,
-0.2136155069,
0.0983367562,
1.2402954102,
-0.2033772469,
1.0676279068,
0.3284299672,
-0.1703152359,
0.2069633305,
0.5182635784,
0.3351908028,
0.7205519676,
0.1266596317,
-0.0369625948,
-0.4126082659,
-0.1232948452,
-0.1798635125,
0.1538292319,
0.3373222053,
-0.1800384223,
-0.4613907933,
-0.0851134285,
0.0275694765,
0.0700096637,
-0.4495183229,
0.7194529176,
-0.1212578267,
-0.7525154948,
0.3892805576,
-0.2439638823,
0.0783996433,
-0.6087378263,
0.0994197205,
-0.2235838175,
0.0784003511,
-0.1579262316,
-1.1164855957,
0.0273276642,
-0.2601932883,
0.0485252663,
-0.1509392709,
0.794912219,
-0.591573298,
-0.2711699605,
0.4479044378,
0.6489440799,
-0.0904677287,
-0.3351207078,
-0.3534630239,
-0.3513009846,
0.0212632436,
-0.3173797131,
0.3859513998,
0.7057523727,
-0.1603110135,
1.0111408234,
0.5916892886,
0.1655060649,
0.1751119941,
0.278649658,
1.1845310926,
-0.534006536,
-0.3318006992,
-0.4912786484,
0.3125973046,
-0.0566211306,
0.0143117541,
0.500330925,
0.8471593261,
1.0363940001,
0.1883753091,
0.5340654254,
0.098981224,
0.7764585018,
-0.6291100979,
0.429243505,
-0.4028338492,
0.4175210595,
-0.0706242248,
-0.9439864755,
-0.3006247282,
0.3172672689,
-0.8521196842,
0.0297183022,
0.2983690798,
0.8417663574,
0.0922258049,
-0.1613665223,
0.3751426637,
0.0598880462,
0.8621086478,
0.5702916384,
0.8277857304,
-0.160381332,
0.8955305219,
-0.3840968311,
0.1468318552,
-0.125466153,
-0.4700499177,
-0.8177281618,
-0.6000305414,
-0.0335121974,
-0.0298331585,
0.1344072521,
0.8807623386,
0.514910996,
-0.4024072587,
-0.0475845337,
0.0473792218,
0.127945289,
0.0747211203,
-0.1350420415,
0.5477191806,
-0.4931379557,
-0.4473834038,
0.4962920547,
0.0078773769,
0.0378033146,
-0.1956099868,
-0.1646838039,
-0.4131711125,
-0.0889933184,
0.8466876149,
0.232766971,
-0.3624269664,
-0.448058188,
-0.0201516468,
-0.0684604719,
-0.1934058666,
0.6329148412,
-0.9744664431,
0.5154790878,
0.5528169274,
0.6453536153,
0.7683930993,
-0.0408857167,
0.5824927688,
-0.8515931368,
-0.1742002666,
0.5071070194,
0.2171338946,
0.2118234783,
-0.1250465512,
0.7360669374,
-0.2668662369,
-0.4584515989,
-0.720539093,
0.3629665375,
-0.7104834318,
-0.3329572678,
1.349774003,
0.0356675796,
0.0204478279,
-0.126915127,
-0.5012198687,
0.3333222866,
-0.0337731987,
0.8341704607,
0.6241199374,
-0.1969998926,
0.0878395066,
-0.6925959587,
0.5520889163,
0.1714156568,
-0.8290883899,
0.3261050284,
0.6152971983,
0.329800427,
0.0868765712,
0.7534824014,
-0.1534490585,
0.0312620103,
-0.4904130399,
-0.2145974338,
-0.2097542286,
-0.4215137362,
0.3363517523,
0.5360705256,
0.4396541715,
0.0689487308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14277v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14277v1 | Augmenting Query and Passage for Retrieval-Augmented Generation using LLMs for Open-Domain Question Answering | 2024-06-20T12:59:27 | 2024-06-20T12:59:27 | Minsang Kim, Cheoneum Park, Seungjun Baek | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has received much attention for
Open-domain question-answering (ODQA) tasks as a means to compensate for the
parametric knowledge of large language models (LLMs). While previous approaches
focused on processing retrieved passages to remove irrelevant context, they
still rely heavily on the quality of retrieved passages which can degrade if
the question is ambiguous or complex. In this paper, we propose a simple yet
efficient method called question and passage augmentation via LLMs for
open-domain QA. Our method first decomposes the original questions into
multiple-step sub-questions. By augmenting the original question with detailed
sub-questions and planning, we are able to make the query more specific on what
needs to be retrieved, improving the retrieval performance. In addition, to
compensate for the case where the retrieved passages contain distracting
information or divided opinions, we augment the retrieved passages with
self-generated passages by LLMs to guide the answer extraction. Experimental
results show that the proposed scheme outperforms the previous state-of-the-art
and achieves significant performance gain over existing RAG methods. | [
-0.7048559785,
-1.058036685,
0.543815434,
-0.1195786893,
-0.5019230843,
0.1530124247,
0.0134282997,
-0.4970546365,
0.3369935155,
0.8964565396,
-0.6336376667,
-0.1361422241,
-0.0989326909,
0.2641019523,
0.0662160516,
0.8406024575,
-0.1267004013,
-0.0534528159,
-0.4724907279,
-0.195947811,
-0.3947630525,
-0.2803510725,
-0.5490167141,
-0.1271318346,
0.3357979357,
0.368542552,
0.4209896326,
0.3532142043,
0.3161072433,
0.1643152982,
-0.3555225134,
0.8170354366,
-0.4498895109,
0.477173388,
-0.4673598111,
-0.2603253126,
-0.5629904866,
-0.2426175624,
0.6889272332,
0.725609839,
0.0951842666,
0.37461555,
0.0669978485,
0.60733217,
-0.8153886199,
-0.1615493,
-0.7943105698,
-0.0080741206,
-0.1917179525,
-0.8355900645,
-0.2944441438,
-0.3017325401,
-0.0791559517,
-0.6079413295,
0.1447719485,
0.0872620046,
0.5143237114,
0.2365078628,
-0.4464889169,
-0.3803185225,
-0.7322092056,
0.6203482747,
-0.5268853903,
0.3011199236,
0.229220137,
0.2412645221,
-0.1897994429,
-0.8717133403,
-0.566814363,
-0.1486887485,
-0.02656723,
0.3178689182,
0.1484912336,
-0.223947987,
0.2194260508,
0.5602265,
-0.5661420822,
-0.230722934,
-0.4133925736,
-0.0312635489,
0.5993723869,
0.212119028,
0.3329079449,
-0.2297830582,
-0.5975345969,
-0.052374199,
-0.9899368882,
0.0618947148,
0.1939145923,
0.3304160237,
0.6163080931,
0.8218998909,
-0.3798647821,
0.6245785952,
0.2674815953,
-0.0285328738,
0.1533919722,
-0.4880696237,
-0.0396296121,
-0.2403479367,
0.3287317753,
-0.0657826141,
0.0390468761,
-0.162444368,
-0.2800994515,
-0.7859963775,
0.3752066195,
-0.8053393364,
0.1350046545,
0.2877341807,
-0.1152834147,
0.1672207415,
0.0668468624,
-0.7358154058,
-0.1846758723,
-0.3110212088,
0.6730997562,
-0.4052177072,
-0.2282962501,
-0.0950282887,
-0.1069411486,
0.3500136435,
0.4518713057,
-0.4094827175,
0.1812185943,
0.4542860687,
0.3526545167,
-0.2280022055,
-0.0457350425,
-1.005440712,
0.2551784515,
-0.4243372083,
0.7540796399,
-0.4991296232,
-0.4576984048,
0.0019247123,
-0.3182691634,
-0.0116826482,
-0.8722676635,
0.5510433912,
-1.3012096882,
0.3273883164,
-0.2300656289,
-0.5425542593,
0.009273448,
0.3971684277,
-0.6448683739,
1.1804887056,
0.1263734251,
-0.5335144997,
-0.009126219,
-0.6005539298,
-0.3071987629,
0.3988879621,
-0.132469207,
-0.0787123665,
0.0709301755,
0.7456429601,
0.1593320966,
-0.2456471324,
-0.2215679884,
0.1076027453,
-0.20166789,
0.2523962855,
-0.2588321865,
0.6772598624,
0.3759547472,
0.0211868044,
-0.1872494817,
-0.5539190769,
0.4087192118,
0.1915226579,
-0.5764861703,
-0.5795990229,
-0.1748795807,
-0.4644675851,
0.0704426542,
0.5349878669,
-0.7628897429,
0.2530058026,
-0.6250373721,
-0.1181222498,
0.4898205698,
0.6987535357,
0.6518591046,
-0.2753981948,
0.7631053925,
0.1124329567,
0.0869768485,
-0.22856085,
-0.5214365721,
-0.5982613564,
-0.1466970891,
0.3723807335,
0.4542194903,
-1.2920542955,
0.1281117946,
-0.0938693658,
-0.2083636373,
-0.7027517557,
0.194274202,
0.4195398986,
0.5837190747,
0.7788050771,
-0.0880336091,
-0.3807268441,
-0.3603072762,
-0.4474520385,
0.0063932682,
-0.0147832055,
0.5387298465,
0.4060383141,
0.2233515829,
1.0163037777,
-0.8178358078,
-0.2206864804,
-0.1424592584,
-0.0794500187,
-0.0494853705,
0.3634229004,
0.1792259365,
-1.028345108,
-0.5552368164,
-0.1734662056,
-0.469699204,
-0.2750053704,
0.1217917278,
-0.4200173616,
0.1267417818,
0.5933454633,
-0.5691384673,
0.3954027295,
0.0689927563,
-0.2073238641,
0.6520572305,
-0.18227157,
0.3018383086,
-1.1071184874,
0.0139632486,
-0.4525101781,
-0.2603992522,
-0.523227036,
0.5567283034,
0.2062383294,
-0.0501710922,
-0.597707212,
0.9029224515,
-0.746348381,
0.0647272766,
-0.320767343,
0.483335346,
0.1917707175,
0.4714093208,
-0.1224529669,
1.0916631222,
0.1907556504,
-0.7438860536,
0.051318597,
0.4564403296,
-0.0954425558,
0.4570144117,
-0.3906617165,
0.5336371064,
-0.3453969061,
0.1399499029,
-0.9314087629,
-0.1554283202,
0.2905550301,
-0.5983763933,
0.2667053342,
-0.1452463716,
-0.2610452473,
-0.1540075988,
-0.348218143,
0.6193668246,
0.6093851328,
-0.8473616242,
0.7108313441,
0.277823478,
-0.4680007696,
-0.6413018703,
-0.4281356633,
-0.1240172908,
0.0649065897,
-0.6808252931,
0.5627937913,
-0.0743172765,
-0.1924088746,
0.1626322865,
-0.30205971,
-0.0766014308,
-0.250400424,
-0.1902938485,
0.1596178859,
-0.3076587617,
0.1248724982,
0.418943733,
0.2669228017,
0.0379800163,
-0.2885197103,
0.536993444,
0.3790266812,
-0.4240167737,
0.2992431521,
0.6635035872,
0.2383231372,
-0.8575831652,
0.6022703648,
0.3824033141,
-0.2119818479,
-0.5575697422,
-0.4336524606,
-0.2386678457,
-0.4869503379,
-0.0379269347,
-0.7178501487,
-1.0187716484,
0.3118425906,
-0.1058680937,
0.1035850942,
0.4258616567,
0.498639971,
-0.1288331747,
0.97998631,
0.1189895123,
0.4683192968,
0.3362863064,
-0.269647032,
0.0735649616,
-1.259303093,
-0.2908569872,
-0.4904729128,
0.1032373235,
-0.2182753682,
-0.9276498556,
0.8280702829,
0.3904817998,
-0.0280573256,
-0.0267362557,
-0.2705262899,
0.3791291118,
0.6684483886,
0.3951816857,
0.575964272,
0.1448690444,
-0.1620602161,
0.1577335447,
-0.5340553522,
-0.4581968188,
1.1066288948,
0.0034327188,
0.7019358873,
0.2638385296,
0.9126332998,
0.1599527299,
0.0996377319,
-0.3616411984,
0.7463579774,
0.0834662765,
-0.6698874831,
-0.4666566551,
-0.6288004518,
-0.9978444576,
0.5651934147,
-0.1992472559,
-0.4378722608,
0.0968215019,
0.0095879445,
-0.4366432726,
0.2471863627,
-0.3230654895,
0.3328352273,
0.0097723687,
-0.3374423683,
0.0574193038,
-0.5120874047,
0.4794607759,
-0.1952056885,
-0.1714488566,
0.2011381835,
-0.2994624972,
0.507604003,
-0.5382178426,
0.3011352122,
-0.3271736503,
-0.2810465395,
0.7760282755,
0.037027996,
0.6637567282,
0.0873606652,
-0.0914864764,
-0.4436013401,
-0.0457329787,
-0.3092565835,
-0.9310930371,
0.5547876954,
-0.3897302449,
-0.8581715822,
-0.1419997066,
-0.587197721,
-0.5608431101,
0.0898170397,
-0.0327548049,
0.5903389454,
-0.0300230309,
0.1140855551,
0.8333469033,
-0.3568176031,
0.178799212,
0.5604737997,
-0.3435455561,
-0.7599523664,
0.7996168137,
0.1226318628,
0.4549421966,
0.5881791711,
0.1212898195,
-0.7754923105,
-0.7033190727,
-0.7141010761,
0.3114887774,
-0.6015418172,
-0.2586187124,
-0.686668992,
-0.2987564504,
-0.7347379327,
0.2910691202,
0.0927683413,
-0.6192649007,
-0.272105068,
0.1421164721,
0.2441456318,
0.3228514194,
0.0928804502,
-0.0256583281,
-1.0776718855,
0.7421547771,
0.4959229231,
0.0897764862,
-0.0221678745,
-0.7172781825,
-0.1600008011,
0.2095281035,
-0.4847533703,
-0.8457042575,
0.2663468122,
0.254186511,
0.571236074,
-0.0617611334,
0.474668473,
0.8058798313,
-0.5483577847,
0.9030690193,
-0.2571026981,
-0.5023030043,
0.6167057753,
-0.200185284,
0.2766170204,
0.5251291394,
0.3319638669,
0.0643988252,
-0.482989639,
-0.4389079213,
-0.8787184954,
0.6233186126,
0.3917402625,
0.1446738243,
-0.0445794351,
0.5803151131,
0.0651688203,
0.157715261,
-0.3106972575,
-0.3033675849,
0.1429965794,
0.0651810914,
0.1218695492,
-0.1635068655,
-0.0676918849,
-0.0867840424,
0.8398013711,
-0.2204849273,
0.1259435266,
0.6472051144,
-0.2357877195,
-0.3793422282,
0.4366886318,
0.3176094294,
0.6618321538,
-0.2864398658,
-0.0576087385,
0.2270279825,
-0.5781236291,
0.1763825417,
0.2192428708,
-0.505894959,
-0.1106077358,
-0.036061015,
0.5112920403,
-0.4857895374,
-0.7793106437,
0.3646686971,
0.1395906508,
-0.1458005905,
-0.154076755,
0.1151402071,
-0.1807591319,
0.4473825991,
0.7190873027,
-0.170067057,
0.2404341698,
-0.6210296154,
0.2249993384,
0.5894614458,
-0.1263840795,
0.1102973893,
0.7456626296,
0.1469273865,
-0.3428061008,
0.2905502915,
-0.2510304749,
-0.356203258,
0.323458612,
0.6154949069,
0.8920292854,
-0.1931285411,
0.1630545408,
0.2453275919,
0.2221883684,
0.3255749047,
0.8498683572,
-0.2543146908,
-0.5220290422,
-0.7508106232,
-0.7933180332,
-0.5783002973,
0.2049370855,
-0.6537027955,
-0.1637946516,
-0.0132514508,
0.0155841075,
-0.3149609268,
0.0617917702,
-0.3602780998,
0.5215827227,
-0.1391733736,
1.0759122372,
-0.1354724169,
0.5448870063,
0.9921828508,
-0.6130965352,
-0.8723115325,
0.353045702,
-0.6724175811,
-0.5001682639,
0.4365688562,
-0.2845586538,
-0.2420811802,
0.2193691432,
-0.2407964915,
-0.7830159664,
0.9978379011,
0.16954647,
-0.037054982,
-0.135905236,
0.3708777428,
0.5382789969,
-0.292322129,
0.2294447422,
0.3509801626,
0.2678836584,
0.2719968557,
-0.5892130136,
0.2603530288,
-0.1927620322,
-0.0842774436,
0.4746403992,
-0.2440347224,
0.9264548421,
-0.1372383833,
-0.2147927731,
0.3462327421,
0.8505765796,
0.448417753,
0.357889235,
0.6435505748,
0.4263605177,
0.5604709983,
0.1569394171,
0.8917145729,
-0.2689967752,
0.063019976,
1.1471723318,
-0.1914503574,
1.0968877077,
0.5426574349,
-0.0546474904,
0.3763609529,
0.3710892498,
0.6461520791,
0.5551233888,
0.0937070549,
-0.5854170918,
-0.2667556703,
-0.0460381657,
-0.4256923199,
0.3379542828,
0.2886891067,
-0.2942883968,
-0.3584969342,
0.1639128923,
-0.2735407948,
0.2153601944,
-0.5135585666,
0.9963620901,
0.0283854026,
-1.2570995092,
0.6959090829,
-0.0447070226,
0.1598152071,
-0.4674829245,
-0.2519170642,
-0.5080379248,
-0.0162263438,
-0.0663803667,
-0.8953562975,
0.2127273679,
0.0522009656,
-0.0571000017,
-0.2834780216,
0.9611934423,
-0.7121474743,
-0.1678177118,
-0.0275639798,
1.0655546188,
0.2055404037,
-0.4590958357,
-0.4627096355,
-0.3967168033,
0.0055851471,
-0.3169344664,
0.3008988202,
0.5948289633,
0.0114964396,
0.3917302191,
0.5909591317,
0.114964731,
0.357353121,
0.0319444463,
1.1244215965,
-0.6213035583,
-0.3085124791,
-0.4225226939,
0.5555996895,
-0.1266977042,
-0.261213243,
0.8771432042,
0.6098371148,
0.7203249931,
-0.1621340215,
0.6391479969,
-0.0001416434,
1.0026128292,
-0.8181898594,
0.364089936,
-0.9442275167,
0.3875516057,
-0.1526507139,
-0.9688725471,
-0.0144704962,
-0.0004537704,
-0.1823914349,
0.0200068336,
0.5040104985,
0.9892495275,
-0.0315554626,
-0.0237094499,
0.2303360403,
-0.066407159,
0.2115977108,
0.3181542456,
1.0667680502,
-0.3955192268,
0.8170333505,
-0.2381134629,
-0.1693722308,
-0.1111345068,
-0.4928068817,
-0.7401149869,
-0.557757616,
-0.2016870677,
-0.4179213941,
0.0500617065,
0.8441215754,
0.3049491048,
-0.539429307,
0.092690967,
0.0281520095,
0.0734836087,
-0.2514969707,
-0.2549115419,
0.4684146643,
-0.6681997776,
-0.8876200318,
0.7852071524,
0.0957352147,
-0.0916804001,
-0.4826432765,
0.0280038379,
-0.4133184254,
0.4661447704,
0.7985346317,
0.3023922741,
-0.5593270063,
-0.1241583079,
0.3510929346,
-0.0246318057,
0.1123152822,
0.8288280964,
-0.9445082545,
0.5156627893,
0.7652514577,
0.808932364,
0.6399487257,
0.5899541974,
0.4317346811,
-1.1232979298,
-0.3985651433,
0.5828744173,
0.1070275903,
0.122720845,
-0.3017281294,
0.5701693892,
0.0454607047,
-0.5623979568,
-0.7863171101,
0.2428513765,
-0.8908656836,
-0.3891175985,
1.255926013,
-0.0958627164,
-0.2235485613,
-0.1857745647,
-0.5922304392,
0.075371854,
-0.1233316883,
0.3183945715,
0.1278022826,
-0.3469334245,
-0.0264103897,
-0.4029385746,
0.4450102746,
0.4417484105,
-0.866850853,
-0.1565196067,
0.6108068824,
0.0704304874,
0.2211776227,
0.750379622,
-0.3799292445,
0.3051718175,
-0.1383939981,
-0.1427133679,
-0.2357911766,
-0.2368871272,
-0.0769602135,
0.6364353895,
0.0105104558,
-0.4412468672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14275v1 | Step-Back Profiling: Distilling User History for Personalized Scientific Writing | 2024-06-20T12:58:26 | 2024-06-20T12:58:26 | Xiangru Tang, Xingyao Zhang, Yanjun Shao, Jie Wu, Yilun Zhao, Arman Cohan, Ming Gong, Dongmei Zhang, Mark Gerstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) excel at a variety of natural language
processing tasks, yet they struggle to generate personalized content for
individuals, particularly in real-world scenarios like scientific writing.
Addressing this challenge, we introduce Step-Back Profiling to personalize LLMs
by distilling user history into concise profiles, including essential traits
and preferences of users. Regarding our experiments, we construct a
Personalized Scientific Writing (PSW) dataset to study multiuser
personalization. PSW requires the models to write scientific papers given
specialized author groups with diverse academic backgrounds. As for the
results, we demonstrate the effectiveness of capturing user characteristics via
Step-Back Profiling for collaborative writing. Moreover, our approach
outperforms the baselines by up to 3.6 points on the general personalization
benchmark (LaMP), including 7 personalization LLM tasks. Our extensive ablation
studies validate the contributions of different components in our method and
provide insights into our task definition. Our dataset and code are available
at \url{https://github.com/gersteinlab/step-back-profiling}. | [
-0.2542947829,
-0.5098275542,
0.6712508798,
0.2802206278,
0.2943074703,
0.575699091,
-0.2556807995,
-0.3493479788,
0.1871092916,
0.8220821619,
-0.6964952946,
-0.8671668768,
-0.420170337,
0.4652850032,
-0.6236346364,
1.3953728676,
-0.0512633584,
-0.1377838552,
-0.4670694768,
-0.0725008994,
-0.1616747528,
-0.5097737908,
-0.7010284066,
-0.4320420027,
1.0538774729,
0.5929459929,
0.3078233898,
0.5823256373,
0.4520328641,
0.3085603416,
-0.0581153035,
0.0373320282,
-0.6877993941,
0.5597406626,
-0.2611271143,
-0.1815394908,
-0.3751677871,
0.1522839665,
0.5711228848,
0.9232086539,
-0.0166070219,
0.3537061512,
0.0432920344,
0.6019476056,
-0.3975919485,
-0.1934480965,
-0.3010014296,
-0.009712711,
-0.3629403114,
-0.3035999238,
-0.5097492933,
-0.645804584,
0.0109913088,
-0.6415502429,
0.9005332589,
0.2715961039,
0.4365017414,
-0.0625998229,
-0.4260261059,
-0.3779027164,
-0.9364647269,
0.7763355374,
-0.7266591787,
0.2342013866,
0.3296830952,
0.0788225085,
-0.0980060324,
-0.9450627565,
-0.5283809304,
-0.4575315118,
-0.2232177556,
-0.1243474782,
0.0976334885,
-0.1466457695,
0.4467228651,
0.3900023699,
-0.5941103697,
0.17852889,
-0.5899358988,
-0.3281238973,
0.7045711279,
0.3567890823,
0.1310758889,
0.2659752965,
-0.1136737466,
-0.0486978255,
-0.6012942791,
0.138715446,
0.6421152353,
0.4474568665,
0.0815438926,
0.6603945494,
-0.3828728199,
0.4019759297,
0.141988188,
-0.2177452296,
0.2661392391,
-0.7984797955,
0.1047541499,
0.0311786085,
0.8688189387,
0.2279460579,
0.1773704141,
-0.2913089395,
0.0600454323,
-0.434976697,
0.2078431547,
-1.1535525322,
-0.519207716,
0.0830609128,
-0.2595151663,
-0.3295896649,
0.0866268799,
-0.8018432856,
-0.8474602699,
-0.2262773216,
-0.0194952097,
-0.3366317451,
0.1540641338,
-0.09420266,
-0.0940966606,
-0.3997774124,
0.3853057027,
-1.0004427433,
0.6404793859,
0.6944907308,
1.117256999,
-0.4271363616,
-0.611324966,
-0.798992753,
0.2395693809,
0.0391381681,
0.4337139428,
-0.5771617293,
-0.6355668306,
-0.1008849815,
-0.253760159,
0.2332503796,
-0.3375181556,
0.3055189848,
-0.4643926024,
0.409783572,
-0.6790067554,
-0.3655239344,
-0.027386548,
-0.0043233773,
-0.5197451115,
1.0475075245,
0.1269638985,
-0.7386289835,
0.5546423793,
-0.6523923874,
-0.6374297142,
0.1378777176,
-0.0879770741,
-0.534981668,
0.1813135296,
0.0290317945,
0.7398078442,
0.0291084163,
0.3789346516,
-0.4394429624,
-0.3388992846,
0.073257044,
0.176711604,
0.5407497883,
0.1382192671,
-0.0055426876,
0.2700993419,
-1.1290224791,
-0.399496913,
0.0028140375,
-0.6307884455,
-0.3157846034,
0.0452229716,
0.0636661202,
0.2582956553,
0.5108610988,
-0.9437709451,
0.2524923682,
-0.2213982493,
0.3931752741,
0.5976256132,
-0.0075647589,
0.2830035985,
-0.3171561658,
0.4992148876,
-0.1097527817,
-0.3560604155,
-0.3320206106,
-0.2333309948,
-0.4101038575,
-0.4040756524,
0.0150070349,
0.4343279898,
-0.1397791654,
0.531390667,
-0.073186107,
-0.3663395643,
-0.3846971691,
0.6787021756,
0.5539024472,
1.0484038591,
0.362610817,
-0.3927296102,
-0.6172773838,
-0.8379791975,
-0.4443241656,
-0.1167364269,
-0.4221332669,
0.3804946244,
0.5012922287,
-0.1866912842,
0.8849708438,
-0.8145748377,
-0.2004728019,
-0.3152124584,
0.5138314366,
0.2295838594,
0.2256670892,
0.201721549,
-0.6177894473,
-0.5503307581,
0.0344143361,
-0.3902567327,
-0.456734091,
-0.3705684841,
-0.0034049219,
-0.115085654,
0.5544235706,
-0.3500474393,
0.1320498437,
0.5751433969,
-0.573202312,
0.5423497558,
-0.3400821388,
0.2194791436,
-1.112413764,
0.6020231843,
0.4592218995,
-0.3133004606,
-0.7253175974,
-0.1247289404,
-0.1922878623,
0.0254799593,
-0.1646980792,
0.508769989,
-0.3431051373,
0.0119303484,
-0.2009247094,
-0.0354205333,
0.0273301937,
0.2300233245,
-0.0488192923,
0.5505626202,
0.2402047664,
-0.3711557388,
0.2039881498,
0.4568039477,
0.0360138044,
0.4153074622,
-0.6319612265,
0.3826882839,
-0.110974513,
0.3585652709,
-1.315071702,
-0.3410895765,
0.0345466025,
-0.2025821209,
0.1974643916,
0.0701466501,
-0.4979474843,
-0.1959950477,
-0.6267969012,
0.0335374214,
0.3594302535,
-0.4313367903,
0.6328710318,
-0.0322077051,
-0.6211084723,
-0.328535974,
-0.4887025058,
0.2649519444,
-0.2528300285,
-0.6670220494,
0.6722661853,
-0.4248334169,
-0.3100849688,
-0.3048973382,
0.0097358581,
0.0999355242,
0.0253395438,
0.4566046596,
0.139409408,
-0.0028380796,
-0.0956936479,
0.1262021065,
-0.0580536649,
-0.0161324181,
0.1865146905,
0.6936756372,
0.0877266526,
-0.0773526803,
-0.4378779829,
0.5176159739,
0.3541157544,
-0.1330104619,
0.6153766513,
0.8914190531,
-0.0092854481,
-0.1577860564,
-0.6400192976,
-0.3291137516,
-0.5146973133,
0.3630881011,
-0.1551355869,
-1.1631102562,
0.6436505318,
-0.0370542631,
0.4389475882,
0.2286056578,
0.7437585592,
-0.3109205067,
0.861661613,
0.9526988268,
-0.1650066972,
0.391557157,
0.1191150174,
0.1143839359,
-0.7883201241,
-0.3847240806,
-0.6257929802,
-0.6497814655,
-0.3369434774,
0.1903716773,
0.0590861626,
-0.0404884666,
-0.2189555019,
0.2586288452,
-0.4859420359,
0.3689505458,
0.6561726332,
-0.0778836831,
0.6659951806,
-0.1562824696,
0.0282576885,
-0.1640450805,
-0.0738360658,
-0.6064072251,
1.1058313847,
0.2662072778,
0.809712708,
-0.2200752348,
1.2028881311,
0.3470708132,
0.3338491619,
-0.4592649937,
0.6347946525,
-0.2399409264,
-0.4822022319,
-0.481320858,
-0.3836513162,
-0.6118381023,
0.1871581525,
-0.046278432,
-0.8660975099,
0.0271427426,
0.5972440839,
-0.5457427502,
0.1597432196,
-0.6052601337,
0.6339432597,
-0.1664968729,
-0.4215510488,
-0.2055656165,
-0.9583339691,
0.3225003481,
-0.3585470617,
0.0297276527,
-0.0426918417,
-0.1372589916,
0.8312739134,
-0.2440523952,
1.111472249,
-0.1247705817,
0.1515773535,
-0.3196449876,
0.2241420895,
0.5398388505,
0.094490923,
-0.0703057349,
0.1544641703,
0.0115541564,
-0.0809375867,
-0.2293037623,
1.1791650057,
-0.4581166804,
-0.5433780551,
-0.427038908,
-0.544316709,
-0.3553914428,
0.3878305256,
0.3510524631,
0.0131497802,
-0.3271489143,
0.2087919265,
0.5661748648,
-0.0912414044,
0.5680086017,
0.8301954269,
-0.2131031752,
-0.2527181208,
0.8471184969,
-0.1463225782,
-0.0415494032,
0.2805608809,
0.4801721573,
-0.247287944,
-1.1143757105,
-0.1146495789,
0.5154834986,
-0.5259303451,
0.2073425651,
-0.8702076674,
0.0992853716,
-0.5089923143,
-0.4398604333,
-0.165465489,
-0.1672190875,
-0.6611605287,
-0.1427085549,
0.2084992379,
0.8376503587,
0.2296769917,
0.2729618847,
-0.6333067417,
0.4997902811,
-0.0975256115,
0.1730130464,
-0.1781170219,
-0.4876468778,
-0.1848020256,
-0.3354517817,
-0.4480952322,
-0.5754872561,
0.5405567288,
0.4438433945,
0.3844064176,
0.1870612204,
-0.2697432339,
0.5254548192,
-0.6058950424,
0.8047686219,
0.2329414636,
-0.9126957655,
0.4944116175,
-0.1717639416,
0.2638925314,
1.0774565935,
0.6863245368,
-0.9168683887,
-0.4454104304,
-0.2302316129,
-1.0410456657,
0.5857409239,
-0.1406719685,
0.0100648487,
0.4628604352,
0.5485388637,
0.6438698173,
0.4082673192,
-0.6359104514,
-0.0079231001,
0.0550533645,
-0.2472518086,
-0.6218147278,
-0.1964211613,
-0.301980257,
-0.3505354822,
0.4813949764,
-0.1708385348,
-0.5040256381,
0.203711763,
0.0112315537,
-0.1310012937,
0.1136901453,
0.6752416492,
0.9586529136,
-0.3158988655,
0.1114535257,
-0.0328492671,
-0.6457917094,
-0.1832483262,
0.2588291168,
-0.3129507005,
-0.1504875869,
0.4549203217,
0.4130484462,
0.1154519171,
-0.5171383619,
0.3236447871,
-0.0407022424,
-0.2592763305,
-0.2496827543,
0.2117417604,
0.3209252357,
0.1061614454,
0.3588360548,
0.2179442942,
0.3728871047,
-0.4368825555,
0.065730013,
0.2389222682,
-0.1191461384,
-0.7286198735,
0.8134377599,
0.1978422701,
-0.3745075166,
0.4845998883,
0.1163220704,
0.0022304808,
0.1269145012,
0.5479207635,
0.9172484875,
-0.2553005219,
0.320880115,
0.2024560422,
-0.1796645075,
-0.1198436841,
0.1925995946,
-0.234286055,
-0.5071768165,
-0.3590098917,
-0.8465796709,
-0.606652379,
0.1146578118,
-0.6387712359,
0.3530407846,
-0.6753411293,
0.0247040931,
0.4357144833,
0.1354825497,
-0.6744865179,
0.0278262738,
0.036943946,
0.4374830425,
-1.1218467951,
0.6898174286,
0.6793842316,
-0.2784981728,
-0.0832211524,
-0.2083797306,
0.4734757543,
-0.4972904921,
0.7453051209,
0.1136776879,
-0.3216099143,
-0.03669383,
-0.6026607752,
-0.7385770679,
1.3322947025,
0.151714325,
-0.9580830336,
-0.1636461467,
0.0446995981,
0.9436815977,
-0.5193135142,
-0.0884744823,
0.7163648605,
0.3653745055,
0.3795379996,
-0.6392167807,
0.2993130088,
-0.1407783031,
-0.0581472889,
0.0765467137,
-0.5573544502,
0.8992243409,
-0.3671590388,
-0.0894120038,
-0.0277094338,
0.6244071722,
0.3684018254,
0.6889973283,
0.2757273614,
0.3849515915,
0.9395471811,
0.2147513181,
0.9805244803,
-0.1760489494,
-0.027630819,
1.1843183041,
-0.5907293558,
0.6778547764,
0.6946630478,
-0.1334157437,
0.469627738,
0.3632734716,
-0.2119560689,
0.3789301217,
0.3437770009,
-0.2675649822,
0.0667057633,
0.0688933358,
-0.1137727499,
0.1415610611,
-0.065647535,
-0.6832434535,
-0.0533093847,
-0.0478235073,
0.415445298,
0.1950361133,
0.0131587945,
0.7826185822,
-0.0132247219,
-0.562846899,
-0.0099934433,
-0.0325320438,
0.8620542288,
-0.7694866061,
0.0864189267,
-0.3653356135,
0.1469945759,
-0.5411034226,
-0.8176862597,
0.2380045801,
0.1926050037,
-0.3976774216,
-0.7562975883,
0.5129543543,
-0.5027740002,
-0.5549599528,
-0.0031380553,
0.3249687552,
0.163716495,
0.017493315,
-0.2411418408,
0.0834078267,
0.1374425888,
-0.5271844864,
0.4656949043,
-0.1872552782,
-0.0221817363,
0.7121738791,
0.8448059559,
0.4980507195,
-0.0862823129,
0.2788431346,
0.8828514814,
-0.9022631645,
-0.4002765119,
-1.2030171156,
0.5818965435,
-0.2725352049,
-0.8887919784,
1.036329627,
0.9299815893,
0.8725281954,
-0.076593332,
0.9402691722,
0.0464006253,
1.001337409,
-0.3198591173,
0.7178711891,
-0.309222132,
0.3826512396,
-0.2873348296,
-0.8232640624,
-0.419772625,
0.0854662955,
-0.2181666195,
0.0856880695,
0.5569944382,
0.6213744879,
0.1096145958,
-0.0870998204,
0.1448099315,
0.1960511953,
0.7798498273,
0.2779818773,
0.6632482409,
0.2932873964,
0.3634036183,
-0.5500149131,
-0.3162476122,
-0.2338750958,
-1.0572789907,
-1.158810854,
-0.6641236544,
-0.5572579503,
-0.2894629836,
-0.0787390918,
0.6456195712,
0.5205965042,
-1.1384055614,
-0.2898156643,
0.0070466008,
-0.2670848668,
-0.000172881,
-0.1748197377,
0.1233846843,
-0.0212843828,
-0.6749758124,
0.4972713292,
0.4056311846,
-0.1289686263,
-0.722168982,
0.0074414858,
0.1595842093,
-0.0798005313,
0.4861107469,
0.6519137025,
-0.5829388499,
-0.1574418843,
0.0417726859,
-0.0880397037,
0.230987981,
1.2837631702,
-0.5479661226,
0.4518759549,
0.6933742166,
0.3384135365,
0.9223011732,
0.4202389121,
0.575643003,
-1.0264343023,
-0.4234032631,
0.5345116258,
0.2147193551,
0.5848950148,
-0.6991541386,
0.2304838002,
0.2068466097,
-0.7818393707,
-0.8045082688,
-0.0075367317,
-1.156948328,
-0.1180546805,
1.0450314283,
-0.2547731698,
0.215764448,
-0.1176642329,
-0.3484370708,
-0.0151183829,
-0.5897108316,
0.9613065124,
0.8916293979,
-0.6458368897,
0.0094581861,
-0.2280500382,
0.5733233094,
0.0307957027,
-0.8611717224,
0.2184164226,
0.7371836305,
0.5546129346,
0.2488930672,
0.7187886834,
0.1064232737,
-0.1908108592,
-0.1612705439,
0.0275338013,
-0.5923482776,
-0.4477951229,
-0.379879117,
0.5745744705,
-0.031839259,
0.1357617676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14267v1 | On the Evaluation Practices in Multilingual NLP: Can Machine Translation Offer an Alternative to Human Translations? | 2024-06-20T12:46:12 | 2024-06-20T12:46:12 | Rochelle Choenni, Sara Rajaee, Christof Monz, Ekaterina Shutova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While multilingual language models (MLMs) have been trained on 100+
languages, they are typically only evaluated across a handful of them due to a
lack of available test data in most languages. This is particularly problematic
when assessing MLM's potential for low-resource and unseen languages. In this
paper, we present an analysis of existing evaluation frameworks in multilingual
NLP, discuss their limitations, and propose several directions for more robust
and reliable evaluation practices. Furthermore, we empirically study to what
extent machine translation offers a {reliable alternative to human translation}
for large-scale evaluation of MLMs across a wide set of languages. We use a
SOTA translation model to translate test data from 4 tasks to 198 languages and
use them to evaluate three MLMs. We show that while the selected subsets of
high-resource test languages are generally sufficiently representative of a
wider range of high-resource languages, we tend to overestimate MLMs' ability
on low-resource languages. Finally, we show that simpler baselines can achieve
relatively strong performance without having benefited from large-scale
multilingual pretraining. | [
-0.3437885344,
-0.3722350895,
0.2597109973,
0.5314450264,
0.103754282,
0.0005929613,
-0.7237673998,
-0.4399840236,
-0.1500780284,
0.4935693741,
-0.6305904984,
-0.0706727058,
-0.618388474,
0.5803050995,
-0.1880073398,
1.1904617548,
-0.2160298377,
0.5788353682,
-0.229009375,
-0.599401176,
-0.4150598049,
-0.8474379778,
-0.6352484226,
-0.4818385839,
0.440440923,
0.2897935808,
0.8224534988,
0.1860305667,
0.759814024,
0.311914444,
0.1000014842,
0.1795195937,
-0.3605854511,
-0.1953211129,
-0.0957758799,
-0.4997816682,
-0.2808622718,
0.2716367245,
0.9182493687,
0.9524242878,
0.0512214862,
0.4773962498,
0.235846892,
0.804874599,
-0.6521532536,
-0.0415807702,
-0.4753779173,
0.4766740501,
0.0523051322,
-0.1030944735,
-0.5097292066,
-0.192931518,
0.1025346667,
-0.2546993196,
-0.2427269369,
0.0880613253,
0.6658456922,
0.099012427,
-0.2866508961,
-0.2860668898,
-0.7253896594,
1.1154227257,
-0.5976396203,
0.5854109526,
0.5941372514,
0.5476459861,
0.0910135731,
-0.3985777199,
-0.3219084144,
-0.6018413305,
-0.0910390094,
0.1071596667,
-0.1357135624,
-0.2331731468,
0.2159544826,
0.3482506275,
-0.6989549398,
0.1621666402,
-0.1254379898,
-0.0317020454,
0.4449363053,
0.0823334754,
0.4617976844,
-0.2513590455,
-0.610512495,
-0.1854398847,
-0.5939552188,
0.0417281091,
0.3631194234,
0.4115998149,
0.0438925587,
0.6464087367,
0.2047010362,
0.6199102402,
-0.4712843895,
-0.1992170215,
0.3225871623,
-0.6946262717,
-0.405947566,
-0.2754799128,
0.8455548882,
0.4902327657,
0.3913338184,
-0.4791704714,
-0.3038089275,
0.1295256615,
0.1855669469,
-0.6239545345,
0.2187900096,
0.0772138089,
-0.7374805808,
0.1159023866,
-0.2065410167,
-0.5810072422,
-0.2937701643,
-0.1235013306,
0.3744353056,
-0.3576183617,
-0.3548927605,
0.2188857198,
-0.1013955623,
0.1433920711,
-0.0627254769,
-0.6986830235,
0.5638154149,
0.4133334756,
0.8000093102,
-0.2839599252,
-0.7956366539,
-0.6398146152,
-0.36207816,
-0.5646893978,
0.3413290679,
-0.4285123348,
-0.2156365067,
0.0011694744,
0.1050166637,
-0.18677634,
-0.8001220226,
0.5367911458,
-0.572420001,
0.2653510869,
-0.2512595057,
-0.2478225678,
-0.1969069093,
0.5094180107,
-0.6696742177,
1.0317115784,
0.149606958,
-0.4844701588,
0.4277814031,
-0.8019117117,
-0.4151535928,
-0.0744933039,
0.1141734943,
-0.2792267203,
0.0218913201,
0.1546707898,
0.3659258187,
-0.394122988,
0.2314339727,
-0.2913030088,
-0.5180171728,
0.2921513915,
-0.7161036134,
0.9584286213,
0.5048668981,
-0.4515378475,
0.0906135142,
-0.5517663956,
0.3766936362,
0.063944146,
-0.6173497438,
-0.2161281705,
-0.283447206,
0.3861573935,
0.63389045,
0.0577141643,
-0.1890803427,
-0.0313137248,
-0.5698203444,
0.1396315396,
0.4486186206,
-0.5093957782,
0.6399282813,
-0.1924593002,
1.1568921804,
-0.4090871513,
0.1251818836,
-0.210399121,
-0.5008991361,
-0.9554860592,
-0.0094108991,
0.5105626583,
0.7193095088,
-0.9328274131,
0.3095139563,
-0.3089041412,
-0.3366641402,
-0.972430408,
0.5683681369,
0.7622398734,
0.0288429838,
0.4348912239,
-0.3740460873,
-0.7385174632,
-0.888898015,
-0.5762465,
0.0985414609,
-0.0599625669,
0.005515866,
0.544900775,
-0.3648306429,
0.4667491913,
0.1720573902,
-0.2622874081,
-0.6268180013,
-0.0632156432,
0.2649451494,
0.3910860419,
0.6246159673,
-0.7430698276,
-0.5241064429,
0.1935476363,
-0.7239773273,
0.0586189106,
-0.208056435,
0.0485517383,
0.3555966914,
0.2125755697,
-0.4547092915,
0.0343305804,
1.0339679718,
-0.1963909566,
0.6293152571,
-0.4430248141,
0.2412410975,
-0.7731769681,
0.3334994018,
-0.0683634281,
-0.4771643281,
-0.5919004083,
0.4848603904,
0.0354573876,
-0.2013164759,
-0.5948156714,
0.7465939522,
-0.431286633,
-0.4006363153,
-0.2413374782,
0.2405095845,
0.1389308423,
0.322393924,
0.1510789394,
0.7282806039,
0.200905174,
-0.5734326839,
0.2170753628,
0.0192224998,
-0.6419565678,
0.4357043803,
-0.431370616,
0.085783951,
-0.0392809696,
0.2433783561,
-0.6505485773,
0.2428139597,
0.2066758275,
-0.2383991331,
0.1865292937,
-0.0266951844,
-0.6339820623,
-0.3620345294,
-0.2193842381,
0.2705545425,
0.306150943,
-0.4542064667,
0.140107289,
0.3286974132,
-0.2112513781,
-0.9347973466,
-0.9307560921,
0.5385151505,
-0.3258742988,
-0.4437000155,
-0.0306357872,
-0.1519721597,
-0.3519803584,
-0.2040807754,
0.0661792159,
-0.1748409718,
0.3927337527,
-0.0999840274,
0.126045078,
-0.2573804557,
0.2505098879,
-0.3830864727,
-0.2969149649,
-0.0937765241,
-0.4314389229,
0.5643517375,
-0.5977978706,
-0.6247455478,
-0.1796186715,
0.56485039,
0.2590251565,
-0.4505645931,
0.6157847047,
0.8895059228,
-0.4708454907,
-0.0447996445,
-0.3948339224,
-0.0327395983,
-0.3421097696,
0.640019536,
-0.5705201626,
-0.6046894193,
0.2883482575,
-0.1043604985,
0.1039623171,
0.5594039559,
0.8185366392,
-0.2021179944,
1.1017615795,
0.6714347005,
0.0361920409,
0.2496371567,
-0.3974845707,
0.2297849953,
-0.4577332437,
0.069217205,
-0.5826611519,
-0.3149281144,
-0.6446934342,
-0.5600914359,
0.3636035025,
0.4323094189,
0.1159871891,
0.5075438619,
-0.0762482807,
0.4772425294,
0.4610707164,
-0.3143479228,
0.5431523323,
-0.0796010271,
-0.1882428229,
-0.3177829981,
-1.0238645077,
-1.0036206245,
1.0223232508,
0.4238829613,
0.2711774707,
0.0975422636,
0.3420395255,
0.0752440095,
0.6426748037,
-0.8202895522,
0.1095585749,
-0.3296953142,
-0.8421564698,
-0.4189954102,
-0.4907744229,
-1.0237927437,
0.6279860735,
-0.4084169269,
-0.4416033924,
-0.2220797539,
-0.0329541862,
-0.2478161752,
0.2752846777,
-0.9592133164,
1.2914978266,
-0.6450151801,
0.0026405726,
-0.164885059,
-0.5385389328,
0.3398616612,
-0.3379641771,
0.6120170951,
0.0042683701,
0.1198388934,
0.6583808661,
-0.2307510227,
0.5881823301,
-0.0570163243,
-0.1103765443,
0.1292555183,
0.0187802352,
0.2659830749,
-0.1187193319,
-0.3843553364,
0.21043244,
0.2239977419,
-0.4473432302,
-0.7286394238,
0.4708279371,
-0.5007324219,
-0.2435434312,
-0.2251753658,
-0.4876194894,
-0.4209727943,
0.3175993562,
0.212735787,
-0.0088370172,
-0.3068885505,
0.090882495,
-0.0313527025,
-0.4376421869,
0.5112905502,
0.3831629753,
-0.4402344823,
-0.2038454413,
1.0241584778,
0.0182076655,
0.3396831155,
0.231560722,
0.3560648859,
-0.6114349961,
-0.3834629655,
-0.990206182,
-0.1203883588,
-0.8054347634,
0.1073622704,
-0.5228715539,
0.2120888382,
-0.1881013811,
0.0048513766,
-0.5999245048,
-0.4479688108,
0.2808271348,
-0.0079507427,
-0.2075689882,
0.5124329329,
0.0044701579,
0.0187293142,
-0.9523506761,
0.2455156744,
0.0471093841,
0.2074076384,
-0.0410618596,
-0.4330486655,
-0.5851633549,
0.1949256957,
-0.209888652,
-0.5752714276,
0.3708379865,
0.2819969654,
0.6971866488,
0.1704462767,
-0.1572074294,
0.8042705655,
-0.7735906243,
0.6078049541,
0.4545807838,
-0.9433857203,
0.2240751982,
-0.0026432262,
0.2917222083,
0.714928329,
0.6367560625,
-0.8714952469,
-0.3237095475,
-0.324742943,
-0.5892400742,
0.5061826706,
0.2144055814,
0.4107485712,
0.1398483515,
-0.0047765081,
0.2750279903,
0.3836376369,
-1.0805599689,
-0.3087579608,
-0.0819582641,
0.072504051,
-0.7096402049,
-0.0650026575,
-0.1858950257,
-0.078615725,
0.3754366338,
-0.1047125012,
-0.0166982524,
-0.1237544045,
-0.4114204049,
-0.0093178581,
0.6419735551,
0.4110483229,
0.923827529,
-0.1258198172,
0.1465005577,
0.4143192172,
-0.046307683,
0.3432382643,
0.0043397043,
0.0086049596,
0.1612772197,
0.5745213628,
0.6305905581,
0.3811506331,
-0.906643033,
0.5732448697,
0.1107931286,
0.1694978774,
-0.1811655611,
-0.3751557469,
0.1922859997,
0.1006743014,
0.1123291478,
0.2433545291,
0.1697204262,
-0.748234868,
0.2181335241,
0.4460331798,
-0.6736211777,
-0.2373464853,
0.5294333696,
0.1641915441,
-0.4397607446,
0.4558894634,
-0.3587902784,
-0.4991444051,
0.4370156825,
0.5568366051,
0.7861053944,
-0.2847566605,
0.1360063702,
0.089436613,
0.7377602458,
-0.1967577338,
0.2361139357,
0.0713363662,
-0.7137272954,
-0.8923341036,
-0.7709574699,
-0.2969131768,
0.1784575135,
-0.610090673,
0.3110794127,
-0.026906766,
-0.4008807838,
-0.1545442641,
0.1439405531,
-0.9322811365,
0.1853318065,
0.026358854,
0.9174271226,
-0.7599031329,
0.8002214432,
0.8767539859,
-0.3188559413,
-0.277146101,
-0.3032764494,
-0.1796961576,
-0.6751697659,
0.739692986,
0.3636927605,
-0.3171678483,
-0.2924802899,
0.2496394515,
-0.4114227593,
0.4744851887,
0.8166057467,
-0.3500828147,
0.0512026288,
0.2150521427,
0.6974191666,
-0.3470342755,
0.3484757245,
0.590526402,
0.8338711262,
-0.5800337195,
-1.3183802366,
-0.2583751678,
-0.2862582505,
0.0641913116,
-0.1791091859,
-0.3243560791,
0.4865193665,
-0.2345780581,
-0.2932460606,
0.0632905215,
0.1656435728,
0.1419169456,
0.2995963395,
0.5873739123,
0.2516650259,
0.5086912513,
0.1705814004,
1.4740571976,
-0.2532531321,
0.434099555,
1.1430720091,
-0.1823261976,
1.0221437216,
0.5785810351,
-0.5077267289,
0.0405170545,
0.7533938885,
0.1093137339,
0.2217111886,
0.3321442604,
0.1335994899,
-0.4647753835,
-0.2226404697,
-0.3462397158,
0.7692708373,
-0.0049594739,
-0.2991459668,
-0.2134507746,
0.0504057035,
0.0428080894,
0.3563403785,
-0.1941193342,
0.4378745258,
0.2718496025,
-0.7671456337,
0.9429941773,
0.4579688311,
0.7247342467,
-0.5613329411,
-0.0565896295,
0.0591761135,
0.2052575201,
-0.1011181995,
-0.3701299429,
0.5524736047,
0.1185172275,
-0.0504519083,
-0.7532966733,
0.4677934349,
-0.4121823907,
-0.7963609695,
0.637839973,
0.9755323529,
0.3482528329,
-0.1481947452,
-0.9030899405,
-0.1041167676,
-0.2034164965,
-0.3369950056,
0.446298182,
0.1140691638,
-0.0534643866,
0.8320561647,
0.7085898519,
0.2076912373,
0.0365466587,
0.1840215027,
0.3569982648,
-0.4758200049,
-0.2515971065,
-1.0180141926,
0.285312444,
0.2236964852,
-0.4392047226,
0.9979092479,
0.5666207075,
1.1386870146,
-0.1228353828,
0.8145629168,
0.3719219565,
0.2320468724,
-0.6359547377,
0.7921636105,
-0.7526689768,
0.1002061963,
-0.4295195341,
-1.1541413069,
-0.3797529638,
0.8138750196,
-0.1423787773,
0.2179597318,
0.6996443272,
0.3223643899,
0.0129516991,
-0.1929979175,
0.6522478461,
-0.1332897842,
0.0858997554,
0.3775754273,
1.0648349524,
-0.5281700492,
0.7629335523,
-0.1516474336,
-0.2074225247,
-0.1037441716,
-0.9309293628,
-0.762280941,
-0.4640986621,
0.1424563378,
-0.2091707736,
-0.1821335852,
0.9316210151,
0.6836325526,
-0.9044943452,
-0.7059878707,
0.455167979,
0.3000620306,
-0.6539151073,
-0.1482747644,
0.2295229137,
-0.6440498829,
-1.0298085213,
0.649923563,
0.3093845546,
-0.0770233721,
-0.6932184696,
-0.4423046112,
-0.1818643361,
-0.2878289521,
0.8414173722,
0.0708882958,
-0.6897290945,
0.0977367088,
0.1781874895,
-0.1058087647,
0.0939557701,
0.8273583651,
-0.3506842852,
0.6215674281,
0.1808621287,
0.9040777683,
0.3013546467,
-0.302508235,
0.8025693893,
-0.6465811729,
0.315196842,
0.3779984713,
0.441812396,
0.4445782602,
0.1679210514,
0.5943307281,
-0.0549115352,
-0.2078626454,
-0.9542607069,
0.3124210238,
-0.2516788542,
-0.2349105775,
1.146138072,
-0.5510114431,
0.1147794202,
-0.2885137498,
0.0700052604,
-0.0357808582,
0.2950180769,
0.5563820601,
1.0006492138,
0.0537403524,
0.0062756282,
-1.0780775547,
0.5502806902,
0.7409166098,
-0.6740433574,
-0.1307560503,
0.1264887899,
0.0571980812,
0.4063310027,
0.8727525473,
-0.1678132862,
0.1950484812,
-0.195282802,
0.1642281264,
0.3675194383,
-0.4716176987,
-0.5509610772,
-0.0316141173,
0.3400154412,
-0.0538044088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14230v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14230v1 | Raising the Bar: Investigating the Values of Large Language Models via Generative Evolving Testing | 2024-06-20T11:51:00 | 2024-06-20T11:51:00 | Han Jiang, Xiaoyuan Yi, Zhihua Wei, Shu Wang, Xing Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Warning: this paper contains model outputs exhibiting unethical information.
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved significant breakthroughs, but their
generated unethical content poses potential risks. Measuring value alignment of
LLMs becomes crucial for their regulation and responsible deployment. Numerous
datasets have been constructed to assess social bias, toxicity, and ethics in
LLMs, but they suffer from evaluation chronoeffect, that is, as models rapidly
evolve, existing data becomes leaked or undemanding, overestimating
ever-developing LLMs. To tackle this problem, we propose GETA, a novel
generative evolving testing approach that dynamically probes the underlying
moral baselines of LLMs. Distinct from previous adaptive testing methods that
rely on static datasets with limited difficulty, GETA incorporates an
iteratively-updated item generator which infers each LLM's moral boundaries and
generates difficulty-tailored testing items, accurately reflecting the true
alignment extent. This process theoretically learns a joint distribution of
item and model response, with item difficulty and value conformity as latent
variables, where the generator co-evolves with the LLM, addressing
chronoeffect. We evaluate various popular LLMs with diverse capabilities and
demonstrate that GETA can create difficulty-matching testing items and more
accurately assess LLMs' values, better consistent with their performance on
unseen OOD and i.i.d. items, laying the groundwork for future evaluation
paradigms. | [
-0.0434831642,
-0.7913994193,
0.5378662944,
0.2471363097,
-0.2063671052,
0.2775978148,
-0.18577075,
-0.5305821896,
-0.1317105442,
0.360509038,
-0.5779120326,
-0.1849492639,
-0.6125989556,
-0.0479336381,
-0.2229484469,
1.0680546761,
0.067620337,
-0.0656450689,
-0.0373047031,
-0.5007197857,
-0.4271064401,
-0.2522029579,
-0.4883707762,
-0.2600534856,
0.4210119545,
0.1248069555,
0.8793412447,
0.6610723734,
0.3602591455,
0.2721221149,
-0.3390310109,
0.0906572491,
-0.7080069184,
0.2225369066,
-0.3485669196,
-0.2620066702,
-0.5166498423,
0.0278547276,
0.3001764119,
0.4487451911,
-0.2764289081,
0.4733865261,
0.0102907056,
0.5137174726,
-0.744820118,
0.01854196,
-0.8346176744,
0.0866302326,
-0.12897636,
-0.4236083925,
-0.3927480876,
-0.6810436845,
0.2331118733,
-0.4684259295,
-0.1105921045,
0.1061620265,
1.062617898,
0.2635676265,
-0.4803274274,
-0.5483155251,
-0.7062251568,
1.0016046762,
-0.664719522,
0.4506273568,
-0.0084908148,
0.1563530266,
-0.1397226751,
-0.6675658226,
-0.6305148005,
-0.4065079987,
0.4858900905,
0.1358375847,
-0.1288516223,
-0.3615435362,
0.0455946811,
0.5872362256,
-0.337551713,
0.293766439,
-0.1428644508,
0.209465757,
0.6021699309,
0.2105891258,
0.6604598761,
-0.0614318438,
-0.3000531793,
-0.2646896839,
-0.8689618707,
0.1401447654,
0.5164279342,
0.3412119746,
-0.2376649976,
0.6428130269,
0.2946599424,
0.6205990314,
0.2733941674,
0.2826109529,
0.3775477707,
-0.5581065416,
-0.2049682587,
0.2236572504,
0.6313185692,
0.4347084761,
0.4765484929,
0.1665646881,
-0.0712556168,
-0.2214128971,
0.5777931809,
-0.8067139983,
-0.1828773171,
0.0122936955,
-0.3940876722,
-0.6728998423,
-0.3179076314,
-1.1011612415,
-0.5494689345,
-0.3261048496,
0.2861844599,
-0.3935683072,
-0.2602705657,
0.1924082339,
0.1915753186,
0.4677224159,
0.0860575065,
-0.9856410027,
-0.3127635121,
0.6193863153,
0.7312563062,
-0.0517791025,
-0.1661203057,
-0.7414417267,
-0.0404118076,
-0.6774047017,
0.5791612864,
-0.7344914079,
-0.3524220586,
-0.0417241193,
0.1363413185,
0.1989201605,
-0.3297199905,
0.3996835053,
-0.7445325851,
0.254188925,
-0.3301906586,
-0.3594044447,
0.2760892808,
0.2021108121,
-0.4919025004,
1.0182396173,
0.3644365072,
-0.5551939607,
0.698246181,
-0.6502763033,
-0.1843535006,
0.2743302286,
-0.2725172937,
-0.5930857658,
0.1125459746,
0.2700089514,
0.2753534615,
-0.4269884527,
0.3682093024,
-0.6276343465,
-0.1508442014,
0.3132179379,
-0.6530408859,
1.1038429737,
0.1131481603,
-0.5946250558,
0.1957515925,
-0.6152890921,
0.2640423179,
0.2546640337,
-0.4213797152,
-0.5046021342,
0.2452646494,
-0.1951909959,
0.168792069,
0.1743147373,
-0.4018736482,
0.0469970778,
-0.4176199734,
0.2626328766,
1.2871996164,
-0.0419201553,
0.1683456004,
-0.3973816931,
0.5163668394,
-0.3758303821,
0.34837237,
0.301692158,
-0.3410924971,
-0.6949664354,
0.0248579942,
0.0710445791,
0.4730546176,
-0.4338956177,
0.8696276546,
-0.5259290338,
-0.6077088714,
-0.6301091909,
0.1930527985,
0.3160876632,
0.1979723722,
0.1753514111,
-0.2333972752,
-0.1579223424,
-0.5892637372,
-0.21582371,
-0.3971278667,
-0.2100189626,
0.2693789005,
0.301848501,
-0.1930141151,
0.4890585244,
-0.3224573135,
0.0800526217,
0.1319177747,
0.1609583348,
0.0622024462,
0.3219839633,
0.65015167,
-0.6446792483,
-0.134213984,
0.2967861295,
-0.8080940247,
-0.3975067139,
-0.03442581,
-0.0490871519,
0.0597613864,
0.3454806209,
-0.0709580332,
-0.0014838375,
0.8674786091,
-0.6983188987,
0.5147944689,
-0.212441653,
0.3531677127,
-1.1750694513,
-0.0975058526,
-0.197577998,
-0.0711243898,
-0.1745819598,
0.2420031279,
0.1991665065,
-0.0053146984,
-0.3304981589,
0.3663603365,
-0.5624145269,
-0.0767702013,
-0.1826621145,
0.0870123729,
-0.0049534691,
0.0547747351,
-0.3745546639,
0.8491570354,
0.3877928257,
-0.719884634,
0.4952536523,
0.1869792193,
-0.5439556837,
0.8772915602,
-0.4880179763,
0.2898981273,
-0.1147080064,
-0.0534652583,
-0.6332927346,
0.0622685105,
-0.0258353073,
-0.2398349047,
0.0807616264,
-0.1840186417,
-0.3103558421,
0.0322138406,
-0.3805281222,
0.6706322432,
0.7532820702,
-0.7993254662,
0.6108465791,
0.3418982923,
-0.3986094892,
-0.7594764829,
-0.3546206057,
0.0519713461,
-0.3881328702,
-0.6911914349,
0.0557094999,
-0.3819156885,
-0.3564915359,
-0.0699000061,
-0.1094871536,
0.2367779166,
0.2095504552,
-0.0064259903,
0.3929173946,
-0.4312894642,
0.2753131092,
0.0892872214,
0.2498358935,
0.1013638526,
-0.1396531612,
0.6427446008,
-0.4196562469,
-0.3324589133,
0.0366368629,
-0.0619232878,
0.6799519062,
-0.3438858688,
0.5105864406,
0.2981557548,
-0.2467104644,
-0.4128126502,
-0.3519552052,
0.1355252564,
-0.5547813773,
0.4313840568,
-0.1937303841,
-0.8560860753,
0.3563479483,
-0.0108105009,
0.3491367698,
0.4047577381,
0.6865715384,
0.1402923465,
0.8371082544,
0.6101195216,
0.1648489237,
0.470448494,
0.1243348196,
0.4234751463,
-0.7944356799,
-0.214750737,
-0.4522325099,
-0.1052982882,
-0.7643167973,
-0.5520503521,
0.295062691,
0.1350254565,
-0.4762667418,
0.0790003389,
-0.5165047646,
0.6834397316,
-0.0469322018,
-0.0514842495,
0.4772973657,
-0.1161047369,
0.0161346849,
0.0072298665,
-0.2632932663,
-0.6651617289,
1.2177217007,
0.3131820858,
0.8937011361,
0.2832348645,
0.1341954917,
0.430411458,
0.7163109779,
-0.6638624668,
0.2691999674,
-0.1973387897,
-0.4631380737,
-0.4243091047,
-0.4355021119,
-1.0553991795,
0.2329221666,
-0.003065085,
-0.8008318543,
0.4311938882,
0.1456478685,
-0.3394754529,
0.4539240897,
-0.3799223602,
0.6939100027,
-0.67441535,
-0.3130341768,
-0.0627731979,
-0.3943571448,
0.3587484658,
-0.3315501511,
0.1054276377,
-0.3596202731,
0.0255235434,
0.5603733659,
-0.1207883954,
0.6765081882,
0.1107614934,
-0.6465026736,
0.0564765669,
0.2122549564,
0.4996468127,
0.1745610982,
-0.1658740193,
0.0416260436,
0.1007642224,
-0.4718672633,
-0.5288062692,
0.8547008634,
-0.5960613489,
-0.5163627863,
-0.5350466371,
-0.6751711965,
-0.2949697971,
0.0996942967,
0.1587731242,
0.1569861323,
-0.4353068173,
0.2383837402,
0.8467440009,
-0.4852321148,
0.1120426878,
0.6294389367,
-0.233251676,
-0.1153354794,
0.7741668224,
-0.2399337143,
0.6852989197,
-0.0171831921,
0.4675290883,
-0.322014451,
-0.527541697,
-0.6847296357,
-0.0371566489,
-0.7026258111,
-0.0971741378,
-0.4419765472,
-0.1113810688,
-0.2893514335,
-0.4254227281,
-0.5493416786,
0.1432734728,
-0.2239852697,
-0.3131619692,
0.521743238,
0.595136106,
-0.0390524939,
-0.063086994,
-0.6785693169,
0.1457259357,
0.4123528302,
0.441444546,
-0.0292783175,
-0.6313405633,
0.3693353534,
0.1724939793,
-0.3400084972,
-0.6702887416,
0.1910077631,
-0.0329268314,
0.3497706354,
0.4208114445,
0.0381377824,
0.701253891,
-0.3886115551,
0.7924827337,
0.0787629783,
-1.0950123072,
0.3297999501,
-0.3014671206,
-0.0152307283,
0.4908950627,
0.2231675386,
-0.5669462085,
-0.3484583497,
-0.4146050215,
-0.884322226,
0.3997226954,
0.2299314141,
0.5979847312,
0.0798712894,
0.3756082654,
0.1996698231,
-0.0090251928,
-0.8039188981,
0.1162430495,
-0.1420508027,
-0.425611943,
-0.0201052576,
-0.1172046065,
-0.2717297375,
-0.0022611974,
0.5336252451,
-0.1504319459,
0.0407657363,
-0.0391918048,
-0.0300541222,
-0.42459777,
0.5784230828,
0.229021892,
0.9879925847,
-0.3052568734,
0.0606401339,
0.2876625955,
-0.3169354498,
0.5431312323,
0.1359371692,
-0.1022034436,
-0.4559043348,
0.3257748783,
0.7184099555,
-0.0155633753,
-0.8827664256,
0.5323515534,
0.0109337745,
0.0472299084,
-0.3959308565,
0.0403819643,
0.2003121525,
0.2611531019,
0.0865500495,
-0.4873508513,
-0.2446651161,
-0.8331059813,
0.282684207,
0.3625740409,
-0.5878760219,
-0.2826273739,
0.5324418545,
0.1694092751,
-0.3628837764,
0.6859810352,
-0.3122225702,
-0.2122665197,
0.7303462625,
0.5650471449,
0.8203286529,
-0.5507082343,
0.2306534648,
-0.0105163576,
0.5558086634,
-0.0438614748,
0.4447306395,
0.206757009,
-0.9295881987,
-0.3809369802,
-0.8046374917,
-0.2388716787,
0.4012448192,
-0.659666121,
0.0090514831,
-0.3536775708,
0.1050360128,
-0.0057385266,
-0.3695150912,
-0.4776172042,
0.1782028973,
-0.1971624196,
0.4410583973,
-0.7349404693,
0.3620099127,
0.4114184976,
-0.2353613228,
-0.5319181085,
0.299490571,
-0.0604797825,
-1.1794476509,
0.5581216812,
0.0124823805,
-0.2895063162,
-0.0724789128,
-0.5228298903,
-0.8761759996,
1.0904871225,
0.5173479915,
-0.743973434,
0.0093089696,
-0.0304246712,
0.652464807,
-0.341604352,
0.0575714596,
0.5435118079,
0.4894933403,
-0.1400568038,
-0.5979550481,
0.3447683156,
-0.3398505747,
0.043271251,
0.4489626586,
-0.5657379031,
0.5810617805,
-0.3103286326,
-0.3814840019,
0.0987256989,
0.4114934802,
0.5040959716,
0.3391880989,
0.7791357636,
0.5222660899,
0.8007096648,
-0.0450579971,
1.0990043879,
-0.083984293,
0.3251735568,
1.0783883333,
-0.6104978919,
0.5383498073,
0.4076182842,
-0.0371560678,
0.4506784379,
0.6540347338,
-0.2605819106,
0.2994346321,
0.7932694554,
-0.1453823596,
-0.1956078857,
-0.1911805719,
-0.2846054733,
0.2695538998,
0.2287409157,
-0.4182786942,
-0.1522727013,
-0.0838253647,
0.08388751,
0.0527446754,
-0.1476914287,
0.5573885441,
0.0112844184,
-0.5924573541,
0.6228730083,
-0.1145366281,
0.6333867311,
-0.6336992383,
-0.0167742968,
-0.1168692634,
0.1544702351,
0.1094379947,
-0.8023090363,
0.2266141027,
0.2557827532,
0.2122956067,
-0.1471435726,
0.2825739682,
-0.288487047,
-0.6435137987,
0.7080700994,
0.4719718993,
-0.0931532308,
0.1950676292,
-0.6854774952,
0.0123224575,
-0.0730568469,
-0.2527540624,
0.253567785,
0.4669698775,
-0.1876839697,
0.6858391166,
0.7565777302,
0.1012221873,
0.2311958522,
0.1916420609,
0.596462965,
-0.7075966001,
-0.3641250134,
-0.9271768928,
0.3257369399,
-0.0783121288,
-0.658362031,
0.3251923919,
0.376106441,
0.8542490005,
0.2176208496,
0.6865755916,
-0.0817009881,
-0.1284404099,
-0.7966240048,
0.8680366278,
-0.6352812052,
0.2666799426,
-0.1755045503,
-0.9365067482,
0.1505292803,
0.2781211734,
-0.0987452269,
0.2377549708,
0.6804328561,
0.7128174305,
-0.1766970754,
-0.0358484574,
0.250205487,
0.2930804789,
0.5773978829,
0.6526296735,
1.2237552404,
-0.2082141191,
0.5095061064,
0.0607891493,
-0.4500421286,
0.1011848077,
-1.1091485023,
-0.7618278265,
-0.4636826813,
-0.3010805547,
-0.5461328626,
0.3419944048,
0.7758950591,
0.4088528454,
-0.6122370958,
-0.1826030016,
-0.149795264,
-0.0295568537,
-0.3900069594,
-0.3038741052,
0.5013045669,
-0.3178473115,
-0.7944759727,
0.45568946,
0.3417783976,
0.1620007157,
-0.2977213562,
-0.1335235685,
-0.1014989838,
0.3797231913,
0.4644109607,
0.0836451948,
-0.5479522347,
-0.6048106551,
-0.1771419495,
0.0657846481,
0.1219400764,
0.8386561871,
-0.0799593851,
0.6852459311,
0.3865593672,
1.0191649199,
0.1912723929,
-0.1173818782,
0.888443768,
-0.4430162907,
-0.3856392205,
0.3600356281,
0.2852627337,
0.3593100309,
-0.6092427373,
0.4686054289,
-0.0595361553,
-0.7442905903,
-1.013633728,
0.4281471372,
-1.0377354622,
-0.2526651025,
1.0105711222,
-0.1606323868,
0.0060312804,
-0.0497751795,
0.2144168019,
0.3279849589,
-0.2167219669,
1.3314423561,
0.783234179,
0.1241848245,
0.0973167121,
-0.5653208494,
0.5239318013,
0.6468046904,
-1.2556660175,
0.4037604034,
0.4923432469,
0.6612146497,
0.1554185003,
0.3872182667,
-0.5441629887,
0.3209832907,
-0.4401380122,
0.0083067557,
0.2064181715,
0.0953788236,
-0.4501098692,
0.0537735708,
0.1816799343,
-0.0113852695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14213v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14213v1 | Complexity of Symbolic Representation in Working Memory of Transformer Correlates with the Complexity of a Task | 2024-06-20T11:27:29 | 2024-06-20T11:27:29 | Alsu Sagirova, Mikhail Burtsev | cs.CL | cs.CL | Even though Transformers are extensively used for Natural Language Processing
tasks, especially for machine translation, they lack an explicit memory to
store key concepts of processed texts. This paper explores the properties of
the content of symbolic working memory added to the Transformer model decoder.
Such working memory enhances the quality of model predictions in machine
translation task and works as a neural-symbolic representation of information
that is important for the model to make correct translations. The study of
memory content revealed that translated text keywords are stored in the working
memory, pointing to the relevance of memory content to the processed text.
Also, the diversity of tokens and parts of speech stored in memory correlates
with the complexity of the corpora for machine translation task. | [
-0.1399815977,
-0.2756466568,
0.4022354782,
0.0733853653,
-0.2923889756,
0.0480885804,
-0.3326349258,
-0.4987370074,
-0.0209769774,
0.4431398213,
-0.2717044652,
-0.1737586558,
-1.095238924,
0.3607277572,
-0.5575418472,
0.8170450926,
-0.2646044791,
0.0092616184,
-0.1157987118,
-0.3502224684,
-1.0804499388,
-0.7496700287,
-0.3693845272,
-0.6685842872,
0.2814347148,
-0.0697319955,
0.9099979997,
0.7139776945,
0.657384336,
0.3946199715,
-0.334120512,
-0.0174961835,
-0.5848747492,
0.4612788558,
-0.3695390821,
-1.1053057909,
-0.1071839705,
-0.1598848552,
0.5676707625,
0.5907227993,
0.137404874,
0.019706659,
-0.0811731741,
0.4456109107,
-0.3734825552,
0.7099055052,
-0.5483039618,
0.1549888849,
-0.1067254841,
-0.0747552365,
-0.5599182248,
0.0872307271,
0.0875921994,
-0.1661739051,
0.3676913977,
0.0204553623,
0.997988224,
0.4378001094,
-0.4571327567,
-0.2809201181,
-1.3094934225,
0.7611015439,
-0.46897614,
0.4512700438,
0.314529866,
0.3542835116,
0.0134789087,
-0.604822278,
-0.658567369,
-0.0847985595,
-0.6297563314,
0.0541583709,
-0.5298835039,
0.1356993765,
0.4182678163,
0.4287739694,
-0.1945769191,
-0.1604677141,
-0.7804877758,
-0.1743002087,
0.3778314292,
0.3689036965,
0.4533692002,
-0.4261881113,
0.1159973368,
-0.4877308309,
-0.3058836162,
-0.0369870663,
-0.0212864298,
0.1052247211,
0.05883402,
0.8311539888,
0.0920876563,
0.5457243919,
-0.0814540461,
-0.2077561319,
0.2692483068,
-0.2435107231,
-0.2822572589,
0.1138844043,
0.8281193376,
-0.0703294501,
0.3185354769,
-0.3466225266,
-0.4890080094,
0.0742724091,
0.8470762372,
-0.6654481888,
0.0202382859,
-0.2492864728,
-0.6167439222,
0.1731431186,
0.3308592737,
-0.0636806339,
0.2662028968,
-0.3830607831,
0.4118452668,
-0.4705504477,
-0.0483274646,
0.0045647589,
-0.4182178676,
-0.0953553244,
0.074508734,
-0.8735347986,
0.2958700061,
0.6717004776,
0.807192862,
-0.2565937936,
-0.3115128875,
-0.2826965749,
0.2980189025,
-0.3343480229,
0.3918329477,
-0.8370172381,
-0.3657639623,
-0.0121781444,
0.5116998553,
-0.3330752552,
-0.7857371569,
0.8032466769,
-0.5667299032,
-0.0389013216,
-0.203958407,
-0.4766396284,
-0.4716959,
-0.0599501505,
-1.3045874834,
1.2704892159,
0.2807511091,
-0.4531448185,
-0.049168814,
-0.4858938754,
-0.7549359202,
-0.0353327841,
-0.1132131144,
-0.1553025544,
0.8151486516,
-0.1715502888,
0.7007709146,
-0.1564078927,
0.1732008755,
0.547405839,
-0.6185181141,
0.6021270752,
-0.1758749634,
0.3302080035,
0.0025771642,
-0.3134466708,
-0.0387078598,
-0.3231531382,
-0.6780901551,
0.3560108542,
-0.3190828562,
-0.4866061211,
0.0751649886,
-0.112451978,
0.297347188,
0.3476785719,
-0.5978522897,
-0.1508211344,
-0.47338292,
0.4742470384,
0.3520073593,
-0.2594415247,
0.6408849359,
-0.1584718227,
0.4800225794,
0.4212563336,
-0.2600739002,
-0.346375972,
-0.743457377,
-0.776625216,
0.4667851031,
0.2055099905,
0.4622987211,
-0.5932163,
0.1381758302,
-0.6339191794,
-0.6150152683,
-0.5363068581,
-0.0561895147,
0.3691248596,
0.2603544891,
0.3578694761,
-0.0788984001,
-0.5515989065,
-1.1105058193,
-0.2181467712,
-0.0989469215,
-0.254984498,
-0.1188852564,
0.8471170068,
-0.322314471,
0.6009081006,
-0.5867286921,
-0.3163156211,
-0.3755170703,
0.4021181166,
0.538574934,
0.3067376018,
0.1646292508,
-0.9230059981,
-0.3355541229,
0.0127769532,
-0.5545178652,
0.1625694036,
-0.3358856142,
-0.1257573813,
0.2044409513,
0.2650676966,
-1.17280972,
0.3995860219,
0.449184984,
-0.2719008029,
0.2056248337,
-0.4839431345,
0.0789101496,
-0.9249848723,
0.0488841049,
-0.2040922493,
-0.1382458359,
-0.7503958941,
-0.2002550513,
0.2322441638,
-0.1594459713,
-0.1640254855,
0.2901085019,
-0.5076120496,
-0.0654310212,
-0.5003117323,
-0.037849199,
0.0113942334,
0.47664693,
0.2600937784,
0.8616275191,
0.2148150355,
-0.4356246889,
0.1085641235,
0.3751468062,
0.0902127698,
0.362737596,
-0.744800806,
-0.0816142187,
-0.3230920732,
-0.0805390626,
-0.7051510811,
0.1137488484,
-0.0452709682,
-0.3300926089,
0.4090911448,
0.0514691621,
-0.9064293504,
-0.3808403611,
0.3762714267,
0.3723654747,
0.8261422515,
0.0191466287,
0.7687014937,
0.3500835896,
-0.0288648941,
-0.1482900232,
-0.8727818727,
0.0468968563,
0.196077466,
-0.4533196092,
0.9533779025,
0.2957915068,
0.1147475019,
0.1489144117,
-0.3603179753,
-0.0346397795,
-0.3225992322,
0.4608478546,
0.2976108491,
-0.2059993893,
0.1779612452,
0.0146945408,
-0.4101731479,
0.3643503785,
-0.0335077718,
0.5969640017,
-0.1458242536,
-0.1747434288,
-0.2599937618,
0.4650827646,
0.8139796257,
-0.2168910503,
1.0034427643,
0.6723784208,
-0.7393668294,
0.0597012788,
-0.1334135383,
-0.1966162175,
-0.4295978546,
0.458432585,
-0.2983575761,
-0.8774129152,
0.6110237837,
0.1691601276,
-0.0931751281,
0.9225165248,
0.6078453064,
-0.1648612618,
1.0228847265,
0.5947855711,
-0.1452721506,
0.2536297739,
-0.2202279568,
0.6814380288,
-0.7338991165,
-0.4524452984,
-0.5788177848,
-0.6202356815,
-0.5718314052,
-0.6846461892,
0.0586557314,
-0.0225339942,
-0.1745415032,
0.9300962687,
-0.7671519518,
0.3282570839,
0.5606213212,
-0.0612034835,
0.2909716666,
-0.1422168314,
0.0004896504,
-0.3000234365,
-0.4039078355,
-0.682813108,
0.6761782765,
0.3743973374,
0.6134310365,
-0.2188625634,
0.5119211078,
0.1399251074,
-0.1150707528,
-0.797488451,
0.5325189233,
-0.3083990812,
-0.4464971125,
-0.1137850881,
-0.3417998552,
-1.1419284344,
0.0190396141,
-0.1063094661,
-0.6593158245,
-0.0886678621,
-0.1786885262,
0.0451897271,
0.2800236344,
-0.3833092451,
0.752910614,
-0.0946659446,
0.2202417552,
-0.4873325527,
-0.5968263745,
-0.0580124669,
0.2288177907,
-0.1369846612,
0.2013438046,
0.0555398911,
1.2337075472,
-0.1496975124,
0.7633911371,
0.1539232582,
-0.0502389595,
0.0758582577,
0.1419870406,
0.6178073287,
-0.4080025554,
-0.039060507,
0.4121051729,
-0.0156038925,
-0.0893980116,
-0.6729075909,
0.2656111121,
-0.6729541421,
-0.6220466495,
-0.5855867267,
-0.8242172599,
0.2227575779,
0.355170697,
0.170171544,
0.0580288097,
-0.0089146039,
0.3243424296,
0.7001088262,
-0.1111324131,
0.4415926039,
0.0543321334,
0.1043132395,
0.0208982807,
0.7455646396,
0.3942151964,
0.1641429216,
0.8611651063,
-0.0693218336,
0.034950275,
-0.4564859569,
-0.2217244655,
0.2983195484,
-0.9529768229,
-0.3212878108,
-0.8123880625,
-0.5245110989,
0.1456569582,
-0.0747931898,
-0.4801226258,
-0.3633265197,
-0.3301550448,
-0.2565705478,
0.4021764398,
1.0301316977,
0.3625861406,
0.4264641106,
-1.1072592735,
0.5432334542,
-0.0690417737,
0.2240660191,
0.0728585273,
-0.4418727756,
-0.8176454306,
0.2236488461,
-0.3271321654,
-1.0648453236,
0.6775549054,
-0.1509511769,
0.6777830124,
0.2449021637,
-0.1568471938,
0.4537525773,
-0.5272090435,
0.7445937991,
0.0437586904,
-0.9770960808,
0.374009192,
0.0824760422,
0.5340310335,
0.2255432606,
0.4509748816,
-0.541244626,
-0.5565600991,
-0.6306591034,
-0.4659133255,
0.7753213048,
0.7188681364,
0.6154510379,
-0.1857088506,
0.1264164895,
0.0674569681,
0.1134484112,
-0.5410762429,
-0.4624090493,
-0.2539276183,
-0.1369729191,
-0.1196454242,
-0.2950038612,
-0.0250672437,
-0.4732794464,
0.242402181,
0.2606160641,
1.014174819,
-0.1674004793,
-0.2702832222,
-0.0333057977,
0.3041054308,
0.463993907,
0.2739028931,
-0.0597228482,
0.4531490803,
0.3078499436,
-0.6909926534,
0.1002152413,
-0.1408971995,
-0.0713825226,
0.6205902696,
0.4069268703,
0.9863454103,
0.4667097926,
-0.7602611184,
0.2411375195,
0.0388843417,
-0.0254876483,
-0.2233166248,
0.3155303895,
0.550809145,
0.0704132244,
0.5177249312,
0.3211278617,
0.0481459349,
-0.6321851015,
0.1443030238,
0.0721902028,
-0.5768145323,
-0.5203790069,
0.5943399072,
-0.2271647602,
-0.5423608422,
0.7621804476,
-0.0897526219,
-0.929412663,
0.6038492918,
1.0215420723,
0.8662709594,
-0.2175907046,
0.0433042906,
0.4062016606,
0.4859611392,
-0.2537154555,
0.3585295975,
0.1077331975,
-0.4925269485,
-0.4447723329,
-0.7097871304,
-0.2388233095,
-0.4285589755,
-0.6685223579,
0.0086007202,
0.0100357123,
-0.2704705894,
-0.244670257,
-0.3874491751,
-0.8584188223,
0.2675538063,
0.1096802205,
0.6929162145,
-0.7001276016,
0.8777835965,
0.5480878949,
-0.4599094093,
-0.8248175979,
-0.2782662809,
-0.620516777,
-0.6187517643,
1.1419353485,
0.2761459649,
0.083961159,
-0.309769392,
0.0334655456,
-0.8595625758,
1.1031844616,
0.5270273089,
-0.5318434238,
-0.2363769561,
0.7877241373,
0.7790817618,
-0.3327857852,
0.2031703144,
0.4632470012,
0.5781875253,
0.260266304,
-1.0204011202,
0.5157681108,
-0.4496254325,
0.3400295973,
0.4682477415,
-0.1148889065,
1.0457150936,
0.1325391978,
-0.5955676436,
-0.4206364453,
0.7855012417,
-0.1939350069,
-0.1265769154,
0.1253296882,
0.5108332038,
0.5933808684,
-0.1918997169,
1.0319429636,
-0.3886834383,
0.1620847285,
0.8235917687,
0.1558493823,
1.0258456469,
0.5216776729,
-0.0349138603,
0.7714095712,
0.1389336735,
-0.2955576777,
0.3390056491,
-0.0314933881,
-0.0370266065,
0.0677727908,
-0.0337355621,
-0.0066401693,
0.4607926011,
0.3464576304,
-0.8848672509,
-0.1000059545,
0.1896083653,
0.1553430408,
-0.0684364215,
-0.0343487673,
0.7828173637,
0.3247323036,
-0.9137233496,
0.6910059452,
0.3398771584,
0.3878543973,
-0.3790829182,
-0.2765422165,
0.1239315867,
0.0611053295,
-0.2039302438,
-0.9819910526,
1.0697021484,
-0.2221893221,
-0.416723609,
-0.5111421943,
0.8528288007,
-0.3034440577,
-0.4641000926,
0.4869309068,
0.3352948129,
0.0080355005,
-0.4435240328,
-0.2905635834,
0.0779830888,
-0.3216673732,
-0.2915287018,
0.1713916957,
0.645570755,
-0.008414641,
0.5744608045,
0.4170211852,
-0.1761299372,
0.1763421744,
-0.1788184047,
0.8507091999,
-0.963756144,
-0.3535620272,
-0.9885082841,
0.5818040967,
0.0071129976,
-0.0876412317,
0.6910002828,
0.5332455039,
0.833155036,
-0.5047690868,
0.6402772665,
-0.1541782916,
-0.197014451,
-0.2324213684,
0.7933303714,
-0.2215444148,
-0.0723773763,
-0.1475279927,
-0.8452029824,
-0.1935243905,
0.6860941052,
-0.1915996671,
-0.2516306639,
1.161636591,
0.6444683671,
-0.2389705032,
0.2366760671,
0.3707593679,
0.050325308,
-0.0403488129,
0.6539800167,
0.4195166528,
-0.7970734835,
0.7882925868,
-0.3068583906,
0.3142445982,
-0.0791922286,
-0.4694719017,
-1.0691119432,
-1.0141189098,
-0.0207453575,
-0.3589014113,
-0.2384088486,
0.5565475821,
0.551420629,
-0.7323032022,
-0.3751161993,
-0.0944702625,
0.2097656131,
-0.6134085655,
-0.2006557435,
0.2863101959,
-0.2970885634,
-0.8326445222,
0.1025043428,
0.4393444061,
0.1793589741,
-0.3483418822,
-0.2572345138,
0.0728537664,
0.1525347829,
0.777852416,
-0.1356545836,
-0.6312862635,
-0.0957080498,
0.4237573147,
-0.3461020589,
0.4066667259,
0.7700049877,
-0.6719810963,
0.3079375625,
0.8248086572,
0.7310847044,
0.7934164405,
-0.5168843269,
0.8584051132,
-0.4767805934,
0.0055846241,
0.4008824825,
0.5720523,
0.1886915863,
-0.4132397473,
0.377089113,
0.1097868979,
-0.2055502832,
-0.5380259156,
0.189556241,
-1.0611304045,
-0.0757062063,
0.787317872,
-0.0993574709,
-0.4126757681,
-0.1158453524,
-0.2279802263,
0.6103748083,
-0.3165478408,
0.7262344956,
0.739877224,
0.057072863,
-0.4508018792,
-0.7479802966,
0.2161049694,
0.3900667429,
-0.4616314471,
-0.004628621,
0.0524154492,
-0.2235081792,
0.5669478178,
0.1119207367,
-0.2062269449,
0.0629566535,
0.113474533,
-0.1567456871,
0.0740468204,
-0.2447545826,
0.1015341282,
0.4517942071,
-0.1213323176,
-0.0428366922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14197v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14197v1 | On the Representational Capacity of Neural Language Models with Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2024-06-20T10:59:02 | 2024-06-20T10:59:02 | Franz Nowak, Anej Svete, Alexandra Butoi, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.FL | The performance of modern language models (LMs) has been improved by
chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning, i.e., the process of generating intermediate
results that guide the model towards a final answer. A possible explanation for
this improvement is that CoT reasoning extends an LM's computational power, as
RNNs and transformers with additional scratch space are known to be Turing
complete. Comparing LMs to Turing machines, however, introduces a category
error - Turing machines decide language membership, whereas LMs define
distributions over strings. To bridge this gap, we formalize CoT reasoning in a
probabilistic setting. We present several results on the representational
capacity of recurrent and transformer LMs with CoT reasoning, showing that they
can represent the same family of distributions over strings as probabilistic
Turing machines. | [
-0.42178756,
-0.4563975632,
0.9719401002,
-0.0247412957,
-0.2549151778,
0.3785798848,
-0.5055178404,
-0.4959956706,
0.1782195568,
0.703219831,
-0.25129655,
-0.1233542785,
-0.6423253417,
0.0563047454,
-0.5838424563,
0.7320077419,
-0.2528676689,
-0.0492957756,
-0.2760832012,
-0.1951923221,
-0.3237851858,
-0.7388452291,
-0.4702956676,
-0.3733144403,
0.5667268634,
0.0356043465,
1.0225588083,
0.2449996769,
0.5080128312,
0.3014483452,
-0.088526763,
0.2121112943,
-0.1392392963,
0.3069692552,
-0.3041597903,
-0.7354605794,
-0.4505661726,
-0.2227698863,
0.7227324843,
0.8114705682,
-0.1752606779,
-0.1879592538,
-0.125601247,
0.6896311641,
-0.755171001,
-0.0166247282,
-0.7628668547,
-0.0114229191,
0.127935499,
-0.1242549345,
-0.8196194172,
-0.4819957018,
0.0812944546,
-0.2661322653,
0.2065168619,
0.0751651824,
0.3771233559,
-0.1042176932,
-0.2011536509,
-0.1279971153,
-1.0647579432,
0.6619378328,
-0.549497962,
0.4870158434,
0.3453184664,
0.3770821989,
-0.324590534,
-0.6220267415,
-0.7405133247,
-0.4186533391,
-0.2067861408,
-0.1638669372,
0.0095198154,
0.2350908816,
0.1389458776,
0.4655264318,
-0.3625499308,
-0.2299720496,
-0.258681953,
0.1353092194,
0.5732421279,
-0.0555190928,
0.2321561277,
0.2450301349,
-0.4073469937,
-0.1262118816,
-0.7176685929,
-0.1715269387,
0.1248780712,
0.1241575703,
0.1880168468,
0.5754038095,
0.2796580791,
0.981820941,
-0.1616075635,
0.2534401119,
-0.1186866015,
-0.2197856754,
-0.2572195232,
0.1871752739,
0.739615798,
-0.0798326284,
0.6606190205,
-0.3428787887,
-0.3109728396,
0.0409224369,
0.533590436,
-0.1937931627,
-0.1090186685,
0.147844106,
-0.3296016455,
-0.0841624066,
0.2318556309,
-0.2137798369,
-0.3752585649,
-0.2065358907,
0.3229010999,
-0.5345503688,
-0.5482087135,
0.4087870717,
-0.2701937258,
-0.2066129148,
0.0722848848,
-0.9306232929,
0.5939198136,
0.6833677888,
0.675029099,
0.0202362314,
-0.0783830211,
0.0423515551,
0.0533451475,
-0.698931694,
0.7316507101,
-0.7698341012,
-0.0062153386,
-0.0963130146,
-0.1040690839,
-0.2764864564,
-0.5751978159,
0.0917664021,
-0.6503628492,
-0.2509904206,
-0.2628198564,
-0.6123329997,
-0.1060269624,
0.0620338768,
-0.8635511994,
0.592959106,
0.4184810221,
-0.6588035226,
0.2457648367,
-0.1386113912,
-0.3017456234,
0.0001436417,
-0.4148576856,
-0.1731541455,
0.3835990727,
-0.1630126983,
0.279897362,
-0.4755986035,
0.5469167829,
-0.3460716307,
-0.4919146299,
0.9266189337,
-0.6078191996,
0.4171400666,
0.3235175014,
-0.3718150854,
0.1624069065,
-0.6796092987,
0.0403159298,
-0.0687186643,
-0.2755634785,
-0.1856413931,
0.3413209021,
-0.2354128063,
0.193783924,
0.0470350422,
-0.3847017884,
0.2900761366,
-0.4451908469,
0.5952914953,
0.6849161983,
-0.3631091118,
0.6866240501,
-0.3015899956,
0.5000470877,
0.1622133404,
-0.0496457852,
-0.0204902608,
-0.6165465713,
-0.7899483442,
-0.0503923371,
0.495082289,
0.1797344685,
-0.7488880157,
0.4828408659,
-0.1467992067,
-0.2428445816,
-0.5013679266,
-0.2180682272,
0.2405556738,
-0.0587841645,
0.1283579022,
-0.3494458497,
-0.7747042179,
-0.8401200771,
-0.143431291,
-0.2634638548,
-0.0644982383,
0.02891583,
0.3191853166,
0.0222331323,
0.831887722,
-0.2433463782,
0.1144627109,
-0.7222059369,
-0.0184993688,
0.4154189527,
0.4464235008,
0.1666973978,
-0.6395180821,
-0.010862465,
-0.040853899,
-0.7220973372,
0.3440805674,
-0.4396255016,
-0.2020093948,
0.3284964859,
0.2587636709,
-0.7632502913,
0.5503207445,
0.4251579344,
-0.3916282058,
0.6028693318,
-0.5996299982,
0.0336722173,
-0.716766715,
-0.2937093079,
-0.3718741834,
-0.3698091209,
-0.4625271261,
0.1176544577,
-0.1035880819,
0.0476382077,
-0.1903933585,
0.2312464714,
-0.3290501833,
-0.5337259769,
-0.2978385985,
0.4041396677,
-0.190202564,
0.279679507,
0.4023319483,
0.8975422382,
0.5757687092,
-0.7671534419,
0.1537984014,
-0.2529617846,
-0.4377127886,
0.1357003301,
-0.5428600311,
-0.0473667048,
-0.214191705,
0.5823221803,
-0.9657876492,
0.0110127358,
-0.0847714469,
-0.3013321161,
0.057846006,
0.2425158918,
-0.6374287605,
-0.5449275374,
0.0094269263,
0.7387516499,
0.5462626815,
-0.516520381,
0.4985530674,
0.2712897956,
0.3286588788,
-0.5486211181,
-0.7858575583,
-0.0361080542,
0.1364651173,
-0.4295938313,
0.4041276574,
0.3012474775,
-0.3622618914,
0.1734945178,
-0.1219787374,
0.0250066146,
-0.0310970247,
-0.0749450698,
0.0970407352,
-0.2963761687,
0.5598580837,
-0.1582269669,
-0.1563810408,
0.0700187758,
-0.6649593711,
0.9733219743,
-0.4195912182,
-0.4613137245,
-0.0441318043,
0.2543190122,
0.4115301669,
-0.1220631376,
1.0627813339,
0.2531716228,
-0.4839663804,
-0.2438875586,
-0.2504662871,
-0.2413834631,
-0.4152023792,
0.0908965245,
-0.3943471611,
-0.7836099267,
0.6212272644,
0.2124509215,
-0.2224265039,
0.5778377056,
0.4289025664,
-0.2618508041,
0.9859417677,
0.3234358132,
0.292496115,
0.281342268,
-0.5571938157,
0.5058258176,
-0.9805753231,
-0.2434135675,
-0.2670445144,
-0.4443677068,
-0.8677733541,
-0.7706624866,
-0.0303897932,
0.3496032655,
-0.6403870583,
0.7062166929,
-0.6657435894,
0.5613387823,
0.6756384969,
0.1405715793,
0.1280704439,
-0.0158276279,
-0.3236736059,
0.4009167552,
-0.9162713289,
-0.7692196369,
0.9091133475,
0.3164774179,
0.8001148105,
0.0528058708,
0.7068535686,
0.0972377285,
0.2660161257,
-0.3458524048,
0.7181723714,
-0.3228109181,
-0.6250248551,
-0.0930517986,
-0.3855657578,
-1.009883523,
0.2237050235,
-0.1431358755,
-1.0615228415,
0.3355215192,
0.0805014223,
-0.1533709764,
0.985086143,
-0.3385864794,
0.4743491411,
-0.0546932742,
-0.0881804079,
-0.4308929443,
-0.3808685243,
0.49049595,
0.2374031693,
0.0379787795,
0.037125051,
0.0204425696,
0.8065029383,
-0.6722456813,
0.6336856484,
0.1102984846,
-0.1785479784,
0.9271926284,
0.2837241292,
0.4080099463,
-0.1219852269,
-0.0886489674,
0.0538768992,
-0.1090019941,
-0.2254747599,
-0.6927646995,
0.6387473345,
-0.5928910375,
-0.6400871873,
-0.5235494375,
-0.615103662,
-0.2688639462,
-0.164571926,
0.1782099307,
0.387799114,
0.1971616596,
0.307012856,
0.6047208309,
-0.2458236665,
0.4174797237,
-0.2348834723,
-0.6342861056,
-0.4529086649,
0.7382401824,
0.3204393983,
0.7107316256,
0.3859986067,
0.047196351,
-0.4402171075,
-0.2630394995,
-0.3419248462,
0.0801816508,
-0.9066600204,
-0.1053033397,
-0.4395756125,
-0.5917175412,
0.0180169549,
-0.2042301446,
-0.2771995664,
-0.8276408315,
0.1529540569,
-0.2817709148,
0.4345305562,
0.8344352245,
0.220973447,
0.3535405397,
-0.5448973179,
0.2687920928,
0.3127875924,
0.7107877731,
0.3874955177,
-0.2365178317,
-0.0956740901,
0.2108163536,
-0.4396339357,
-0.896325171,
0.0662878826,
-0.1138964891,
0.5135167837,
0.1833925247,
-0.082042478,
0.5192663074,
-0.4375108182,
0.7852252126,
0.5088540316,
-0.7648947835,
0.3760403693,
-0.1540987939,
0.1496091336,
0.1989663392,
0.3160174489,
-0.3184328973,
-0.8591057062,
-1.0340902805,
-0.6602000594,
0.4079714119,
0.5054987669,
0.0475685336,
-0.5915678144,
0.2080128789,
0.0306941681,
0.1325924993,
-0.5949404836,
-0.0003330965,
0.0162963066,
-0.3248172998,
-0.1372263283,
-0.1652066857,
0.3193178773,
-0.253683567,
0.4973581135,
0.0396007858,
0.694665432,
0.2054676712,
-0.0412792265,
-0.1019810438,
0.4212556481,
0.5695720911,
0.9771062136,
-0.2201230377,
0.7124841809,
0.2014968395,
-0.2520142198,
0.4901023209,
-0.4968636632,
0.1050402969,
0.1015983969,
0.6159905791,
0.9461746812,
0.3643297255,
-0.7644232512,
0.2355583757,
0.0403557196,
-0.0756393373,
-0.3441149592,
0.3445315957,
0.4430678487,
0.2184556276,
0.2248713672,
0.4473041296,
-0.0375152603,
-0.9126042724,
0.3400424719,
0.2823700309,
-0.3910914958,
-0.176658839,
0.7057987452,
-0.1780881137,
-0.6206929088,
0.6537038684,
-0.1628437936,
-0.5603603721,
0.8641654253,
0.900182128,
0.9077230692,
-0.1404726654,
0.1881952584,
0.4888965487,
0.1570360363,
-0.4582274258,
0.4998850226,
-0.1166363657,
-0.8550698757,
-0.4863223433,
-0.6831870079,
-0.2183493078,
-0.0653995648,
-0.5153259039,
0.0813515782,
-0.6612393856,
-0.487650454,
-0.2286433876,
-0.4613344073,
-0.5212281942,
0.2793089449,
0.26568681,
0.8625931144,
-0.4130374789,
0.8589148521,
0.2135691047,
-0.4458010197,
-0.6701613069,
-0.0252270717,
-0.7473282814,
-0.5798516273,
0.7069246769,
0.2765205204,
-0.3406926394,
-0.3725524843,
-0.2195750028,
-0.9395483732,
0.811347425,
0.5321846008,
-1.1134691238,
0.1291013956,
0.3350123763,
0.744736135,
-0.6835064292,
0.2991133332,
0.7176419497,
0.1167804897,
-0.0259590261,
-0.8495394588,
0.0866588503,
0.1809127629,
0.3272604346,
0.4246816337,
-0.1161791235,
0.9244480729,
-0.4458402991,
-0.2263338715,
-0.0875161439,
0.753333509,
0.7370945215,
0.0510066561,
0.608677268,
0.4955638051,
0.8201506734,
-0.2199453861,
1.4867782593,
-0.242954582,
0.2307609618,
1.2202234268,
-0.0945769325,
1.1923273802,
0.4182900786,
-0.5532884598,
0.8889684677,
0.4881684184,
0.4763790965,
0.3961848617,
0.6949284077,
-0.4107098877,
-0.5657680631,
0.1880634874,
-0.2035802454,
0.0810847282,
0.2851451039,
-0.7083576918,
0.0749167129,
0.0413035378,
-0.4083544612,
0.380315423,
-0.321516037,
0.7292538285,
0.4110825956,
-0.876414597,
0.9998804331,
-0.1677162796,
0.2718049288,
-0.2371515185,
0.0590277091,
0.1066255793,
0.4432708323,
-0.0389938578,
-1.2535349131,
0.5668347478,
-0.0168375503,
-0.2061237246,
-0.0770956725,
0.7039732933,
-0.496373266,
-0.8079298735,
0.46474123,
0.1200583577,
0.2543996572,
0.1344565302,
-0.2539661229,
0.0227620453,
-0.4576999843,
-0.1116919443,
0.2144462764,
0.3577143848,
-0.3807150424,
0.8338891864,
0.2237406522,
0.3286549449,
0.1714302748,
0.4507250786,
0.690476656,
-0.6735898256,
-0.2953880429,
-1.0210648775,
0.3455328643,
-0.0636942685,
0.0123509346,
0.1177282557,
0.3436329663,
0.82431674,
-0.2153451294,
0.7240415812,
-0.0690691546,
-0.1082406566,
-0.5501847267,
0.6445968151,
-0.1675642133,
0.2646558285,
0.0270615853,
-0.865955174,
-0.2156369537,
0.9810380936,
-0.4431287944,
0.154346481,
0.9790300727,
0.5591968298,
-0.1302628219,
0.2459884584,
0.3756100237,
0.0620868616,
0.217594251,
0.9057704806,
1.0435699224,
-0.5810086727,
0.2081329376,
-0.0291415416,
-0.0011407047,
0.158940956,
-0.6866603494,
-0.6811553836,
-0.935395956,
-0.1650056541,
-0.3549049497,
0.0067250193,
0.9954789281,
0.5734742284,
-0.8617984056,
-0.3464344442,
-0.7915825844,
0.4769608676,
-0.6091265082,
-0.1530014277,
0.2820971906,
-0.6937221885,
-0.253377974,
0.092179127,
0.2168719172,
-0.2000648677,
-0.4047028422,
-0.3122033477,
-0.2352794409,
0.561850667,
0.7297564745,
-0.2637085021,
-1.0218603611,
-0.4178237915,
-0.1817620695,
0.0532771908,
0.1321839243,
1.0250285864,
-1.0020376444,
0.4387327433,
0.7066447735,
0.4287739992,
0.4236581326,
-0.3532031476,
0.88652426,
-0.625654161,
0.1048696563,
0.3495972455,
0.7236495018,
0.1165341362,
-0.1321085691,
0.4548799992,
-0.0153053589,
-0.4718894362,
-0.7722625136,
0.540450573,
-0.7806673646,
-0.4948654473,
1.0602289438,
-0.1177228913,
-0.3557663858,
0.0406827815,
-0.2090926319,
0.3163849413,
0.0308333505,
0.6739782095,
0.7228429317,
-0.0996830538,
-0.3409357667,
-0.3370754421,
0.4671731889,
0.2155307084,
-0.5787319541,
0.333136797,
-0.0584494732,
-0.0043839836,
0.3491630256,
0.8180858493,
-0.1637073159,
0.3036716282,
0.015777912,
-0.0265412182,
0.3364045918,
-0.6679059267,
-0.0914260074,
0.1781547964,
0.2629339099,
-0.0011324238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14192v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14192v1 | Timo: Towards Better Temporal Reasoning for Language Models | 2024-06-20T10:52:14 | 2024-06-20T10:52:14 | Zhaochen Su, Jun Zhang, Tong Zhu, Xiaoye Qu, Juntao Li, Min Zhang, Yu Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reasoning about time is essential for Large Language Models (LLMs) to
understand the world. Previous works focus on solving specific tasks, primarily
on time-sensitive question answering. While these methods have proven
effective, they cannot generalize to a wider spectrum of temporal reasoning
tasks. Therefore, we propose a crucial question: Can we build a universal
framework to handle a variety of temporal reasoning tasks? To that end, we
systematically study 38 temporal reasoning tasks. Based on the observation that
19 tasks are directly related to mathematics, we first leverage the available
mathematical dataset to set a solid foundation for temporal reasoning. However,
the in-depth study indicates that focusing solely on mathematical enhancement
falls short of addressing pure temporal reasoning tasks. To mitigate this
limitation, we propose a simple but effective self-critic temporal optimization
method to enhance the model's temporal reasoning capabilities without
sacrificing general task abilities. Finally, we develop Timo, a model designed
to excel in temporal reasoning at the 7B and 13B scales. Notably, Timo
outperforms the counterpart LLMs by 10.0 and 7.6 in average accuracy scores and
achieves the new state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance of comparable size.
Extensive experiments further validate our framework's effectiveness and its
generalization across diverse temporal tasks. The code is available at
https://github.com/zhaochen0110/Timo. | [
-0.1281760931,
-0.7189614773,
0.9278073907,
0.6111099124,
-0.2282586843,
0.1202748343,
-0.1768467873,
-0.752728045,
-0.2806167006,
0.3471491039,
-0.7205686569,
-0.3482840657,
-0.3231737912,
0.2118802965,
-0.1510401517,
0.7139396071,
0.1049493924,
-0.1047538817,
0.1332539171,
-0.1847002208,
-0.254486233,
-0.2490942776,
-0.9704212546,
-0.7007405758,
0.6969664693,
0.1926631182,
0.600233376,
0.748321414,
0.3179575801,
0.2595448494,
-0.1946246326,
0.3250793815,
-0.0347707868,
0.2177572846,
-0.361310333,
-0.5378640294,
-0.5558322668,
-0.2548910081,
0.4560277164,
0.6239439249,
-0.1940524727,
0.1809978783,
-0.1397773027,
0.3468853831,
-0.4653889239,
0.0734945163,
-0.5598074794,
0.2302383035,
-0.26907897,
-0.114262931,
-0.3025357425,
-0.2304107547,
-0.1306540966,
-0.8096877933,
0.0302397683,
0.3290604949,
0.6542862058,
0.4152751267,
-0.4287837744,
0.1707474142,
-0.9938879609,
1.0058050156,
-0.7160055041,
0.5890951157,
0.1672701389,
0.4743224382,
0.1061054468,
-0.5916081667,
-0.5822600722,
-0.355306685,
0.3843981028,
-0.0229491871,
-0.1432422251,
-0.0002558451,
0.43812567,
0.1249421835,
-0.5853804946,
0.1168380678,
0.1292279214,
-0.0974619761,
0.2424837053,
0.2470587492,
0.2812389135,
-0.0879324079,
-0.1697093844,
0.0971113518,
-0.5402908921,
0.0521738641,
0.379037112,
0.0479709022,
0.0653852075,
0.1704177856,
0.0219217818,
0.4952538013,
-0.1792717427,
-0.0178503189,
-0.2801402509,
-0.2707760334,
-0.2225372791,
-0.3749655783,
0.6184407473,
0.2258834541,
0.5834094286,
-0.372430563,
-0.2520700991,
0.071586445,
0.2264466137,
-0.6481227279,
0.1946785152,
0.3183681965,
-0.0605220422,
-0.2738879621,
-0.2876414955,
-0.5589209795,
0.1206900626,
-0.3931437731,
0.1996727437,
-0.4839995503,
-0.1665602773,
0.2324164957,
0.0631185621,
-0.213189289,
0.5504370332,
-0.6396127343,
0.2726543248,
0.6484502554,
0.6141855121,
0.2326915115,
-0.4852707088,
-0.5705707073,
0.4652249515,
-0.6157967448,
0.8617997766,
-0.6368774176,
-0.3729285598,
-0.2561305761,
-0.3039483428,
0.0271989591,
-0.5488836765,
0.6259743571,
-0.5926956534,
0.2931526303,
-0.2157653123,
-0.1655815691,
0.0737237483,
0.2899242043,
-0.5214136839,
1.1983619928,
0.1940302551,
-0.3229437768,
0.1786220521,
-0.7612084746,
-0.4512757063,
-0.1438412517,
-0.0222587176,
-0.2911260724,
0.1626470387,
0.5764052868,
0.2141814828,
-0.8211737871,
0.736186564,
-0.538056314,
-0.3227782249,
0.5935264826,
-0.0827743411,
0.7651597857,
0.7803001404,
-0.3874366581,
0.0487309843,
-0.5007306933,
0.183028385,
0.2430926412,
-0.0086347815,
-0.2062418461,
-0.1190904602,
0.0547265336,
0.0466565005,
0.1506466717,
-0.5675160289,
0.2668030858,
-0.4073687196,
0.8064858317,
0.9774431586,
-0.1707843393,
0.536937952,
-0.4967567623,
0.5750608444,
-0.1180583909,
0.7256234884,
-0.0634117573,
-0.1637293696,
-0.5056006908,
-0.0970885828,
0.2762500048,
0.5356240273,
-0.8291532397,
0.2617074251,
-0.3890877068,
-0.2749093473,
-0.2057905793,
0.2686861753,
0.5593569279,
0.4917477965,
0.1547534019,
0.0638585612,
-0.4289816916,
-0.6704133153,
-0.4569818676,
-0.2831711173,
-0.0993079618,
0.2734531164,
0.497518152,
-0.1048052013,
0.8478677273,
-0.5443349481,
-0.15313977,
-0.3971349299,
0.0284135379,
0.2491645217,
0.252649188,
0.7839066386,
-0.6013971567,
-0.0549089424,
0.0173568223,
-0.8728673458,
-0.4892816246,
-0.2445471436,
-0.0438110828,
0.1519982666,
0.3732334673,
-0.3858191669,
-0.0910206884,
0.2124080062,
-0.2926872969,
0.3258014023,
-0.0567659028,
0.1768441647,
-0.9877055883,
0.1073673293,
0.0221878607,
-0.2455369532,
-0.3611826897,
0.2647102773,
-0.1123171076,
-0.3931795657,
-0.2450612783,
1.1276490688,
-0.1463971287,
0.0726372972,
-0.1859416962,
0.0022220358,
0.2113718987,
0.550098896,
-0.2866100967,
0.5927875042,
0.3385354877,
-0.5809854269,
0.3213119507,
-0.3353713453,
-0.3131482899,
0.3743836284,
-0.8613879681,
0.396481961,
-0.0016058458,
0.0298751127,
-0.6954205036,
0.0121922409,
0.2647440434,
-0.5722258091,
0.2450223863,
-0.3326455951,
-0.849529922,
-0.3205751479,
-0.0921601504,
0.5014592409,
0.2651270628,
-0.5186352134,
0.9064123034,
0.149660334,
-0.0012248664,
-0.651714921,
-0.7507607937,
0.0600535385,
-0.260394752,
-0.7086564898,
0.4355311096,
-0.334423393,
-0.6435092688,
0.0869396403,
-0.5164942145,
-0.1135941967,
0.218692407,
0.0067033437,
0.1812471598,
-0.1955052614,
0.3560050428,
0.1529306918,
-0.3091114461,
0.0536165982,
-0.6882365942,
0.5147359967,
-0.1716884673,
-0.234769091,
-0.4198963642,
0.1888997406,
0.4891979992,
-0.2576230168,
0.4636650085,
0.4202388227,
-0.4747546613,
-0.4826368093,
-0.7677227259,
-0.0886587724,
-0.4577144086,
-0.0747119486,
-0.6974137425,
-0.9653018117,
0.6703866124,
-0.1045188531,
0.0943189636,
0.456543684,
0.1506359577,
-0.2932138145,
0.9241425991,
0.4466748834,
-0.0087714847,
0.7795937657,
-0.358997941,
0.0301066302,
-0.6533212662,
-0.2514413297,
-0.5999959707,
-0.1315980703,
-0.0962899923,
-0.3402525485,
0.3021195829,
-0.0000742147,
-0.4494456649,
0.2087726742,
-0.4471938312,
0.4367051721,
0.4592504203,
0.0441286787,
0.3413294852,
-0.0196934231,
-0.2410670966,
-0.0750056282,
-0.5300226808,
-0.5029354692,
0.9364537597,
0.2219175398,
0.7551055551,
0.103558287,
0.4806268215,
0.3401992023,
0.2398152351,
-0.3844611943,
0.635042727,
-0.2912785113,
-0.933334589,
-0.4983769357,
-0.8294904232,
-0.8742782474,
0.0946823955,
0.1643283814,
-0.6967915297,
-0.0658794194,
0.0500612371,
-0.4628533125,
0.371742785,
-0.6713846326,
1.0424445868,
-0.4837333262,
-0.4195468426,
-0.3917195201,
-0.4372739196,
0.0815872625,
-0.0338330902,
0.4970256388,
-0.5104141235,
-0.1470363587,
0.5409084558,
-0.4351260066,
0.8402733207,
-0.0834887028,
0.0595339574,
0.5164235234,
0.4838564098,
0.2091007978,
0.3295597136,
-0.1317952126,
0.100197196,
0.3897871375,
-0.4741427898,
-1.1670911312,
0.7410357594,
-0.7972406149,
-0.5971726179,
-0.5305694342,
-0.688380301,
-0.0585778207,
-0.0307997707,
-0.076154463,
0.6312564611,
0.0489812493,
-0.1484464854,
0.5275975466,
0.0837723464,
0.5152081251,
0.7112063766,
-0.4398421347,
-0.4797002375,
0.5556712747,
0.1279135197,
0.0521747954,
1.015666604,
0.5669133663,
-0.3978253901,
-0.4226604402,
-0.3023542762,
0.4294307828,
-0.5868558884,
-0.0684092343,
-0.4902270734,
-0.0121159572,
-0.5368026495,
0.0859842673,
-0.2803008258,
-0.7489385009,
0.0571608171,
0.1317282766,
0.3258226216,
0.5165569186,
-0.0860909522,
0.3946511447,
-0.7248133421,
0.369083941,
0.394937098,
0.3549135327,
-0.0145695126,
-0.6455726027,
0.0161698852,
-0.2912412286,
-0.287715584,
-0.5478951335,
0.2021185011,
0.0161554143,
0.6338644028,
0.4096132219,
0.0670398101,
0.7673238516,
-0.4777680933,
0.3689087629,
-0.0450422131,
-1.2287911177,
1.0263413191,
-0.4410216808,
0.4146104753,
0.0652597025,
0.0916595608,
-0.5403942466,
-0.3336967826,
-0.7832647562,
-0.4351086915,
0.6007233858,
0.2720217407,
-0.0160370227,
0.0671369955,
0.7633885741,
0.0543526746,
-0.0186334047,
-0.8498646617,
0.1054401621,
-0.0537214316,
-0.1305095404,
-0.0882870331,
-0.1292757243,
-0.0792951062,
-0.0398289487,
0.3982279301,
-0.2466055006,
0.2030545175,
0.1655406058,
-0.0853234455,
-0.3302475214,
0.5350922942,
0.3828538656,
0.8467459083,
-0.1562152803,
0.2147101462,
0.3575890958,
-0.0956131965,
0.0703477412,
0.2713850141,
-0.0983482301,
-0.2311654538,
0.6903793812,
0.3547196984,
0.29406932,
-0.6234673262,
0.0853315741,
-0.0953352079,
0.1524910331,
-0.3655554056,
0.207258001,
-0.1316545904,
0.6250283718,
0.3263406157,
-0.0329653062,
-0.0667156577,
-0.7404121161,
-0.1567558646,
0.1545640528,
-0.0193448439,
-0.5215488076,
1.0134952068,
0.1757115573,
-0.4123722017,
0.5514297485,
-0.1345609277,
-0.4215766788,
0.7650876045,
0.5178286433,
0.8796826005,
-0.3658650517,
0.0365833193,
0.2255674601,
0.4647649825,
-0.1501281857,
0.5571575761,
-0.282938242,
-0.7875288725,
-0.7577336431,
-0.5656951666,
-0.4544237256,
-0.018125413,
-0.337366879,
-0.0559978858,
-0.7755237222,
-0.5290699601,
-0.0188143291,
0.2058287263,
-0.4806393981,
0.2981763482,
-0.1314180642,
0.6784181595,
-0.6366505027,
0.8947893977,
0.7563064098,
-0.478798151,
-0.4540018439,
-0.067791149,
-0.1129284352,
-0.9085581899,
0.9248945117,
-0.0743172839,
-0.4574719369,
-0.1950035542,
-0.5277770162,
-0.6931213737,
0.9352542758,
0.7643508315,
-0.6546699405,
-0.2974337339,
0.036236465,
0.7173408866,
-0.2064991891,
0.2220333815,
0.1297422796,
0.3714220226,
0.194958657,
-0.9059411883,
0.0144299623,
-0.2566850781,
0.1596642286,
0.35147506,
-0.7854542732,
0.4628833234,
-0.4537463486,
-0.1745284796,
0.2399565727,
0.6553685665,
0.2796589136,
0.6656262875,
0.6588872671,
0.7387396097,
0.5680055618,
-0.3861764371,
1.3840255737,
-0.3233516216,
0.0747641772,
1.0240226984,
-0.3150547445,
0.3065266311,
0.3009227216,
-0.3285156786,
0.3111188412,
0.6309537888,
0.2595980465,
0.2340908647,
0.108913511,
-0.2379639149,
-0.8546490073,
-0.4029970467,
-0.2208802253,
0.1384547353,
0.1972621828,
0.0499812998,
-0.115314953,
0.000449075,
0.1440218538,
0.2916598022,
-0.0966221914,
0.2944191396,
0.3524055183,
-0.6895158887,
0.0363627113,
0.0770750567,
0.1105158702,
-0.7662599087,
0.118240051,
-0.4925644994,
0.5227462649,
0.1599520594,
-0.8532619476,
0.4664184451,
0.1158090904,
-0.1228447631,
-0.5700226426,
0.395648092,
0.0923506767,
-0.46958372,
0.6005260944,
0.6933889985,
0.0140183484,
-0.267008841,
-0.7221609354,
0.147153914,
-0.2345962524,
-0.0251374766,
0.1348270178,
0.8740406632,
-0.1747973561,
1.1631002426,
0.6457422972,
0.1732908934,
-0.1985207945,
0.7457846403,
0.6174554825,
-0.9188734293,
-0.4742597938,
-0.9299135804,
0.0062120492,
0.0787335038,
-0.512242794,
0.3993539512,
0.6270605326,
0.9276878238,
0.1372893006,
0.4145212471,
0.2033077031,
0.6264384985,
-0.8169415593,
0.1752095073,
-0.8875141144,
0.5296344161,
-0.1247850955,
-0.9819931984,
-0.5408141017,
0.4845970869,
-0.484715879,
0.2720175087,
0.7802377343,
0.5531004071,
0.0755285993,
0.0329057574,
0.3928961754,
0.2024549246,
0.4169487059,
0.9189128876,
1.3653593063,
-0.1664398164,
1.0270911455,
-0.4057151377,
0.0456921533,
0.12429443,
-0.8939713836,
-1.1145795584,
-0.4848115146,
-0.2804752588,
-0.1155676991,
0.5185193419,
0.916162014,
0.6759679317,
-0.5035406351,
-0.3119510412,
0.1444337964,
0.2381203771,
-0.4032912254,
-0.2166541219,
0.1451693773,
-0.4430256188,
-0.9031214714,
0.3999027014,
0.4293049574,
-0.0029813016,
0.186624065,
0.0686586648,
0.1131371781,
-0.0607833974,
0.4669178426,
0.2661652863,
-0.9629656672,
-0.5037795901,
0.3690140843,
0.0636063144,
0.0354697965,
1.1379128695,
-0.6058477163,
0.407517761,
0.3990229666,
0.4845458865,
0.7685572505,
-0.3604332805,
0.5324084759,
-0.6278171539,
-0.0547633618,
0.4294635952,
0.598656714,
0.1733946949,
-0.2138106078,
0.862754643,
0.4735911787,
-0.4998396933,
-0.7965611219,
0.3534574211,
-1.0334333181,
-0.5841778517,
0.7999500036,
0.0420948602,
-0.2621162832,
0.0062556155,
0.0120264729,
0.4268779457,
-0.5512241125,
1.002097249,
0.7462579012,
-0.283411622,
-0.4402408898,
-0.5479702353,
0.0684341416,
0.5900861621,
-0.929207623,
-0.0293205306,
0.2042991519,
0.5077859163,
0.1618946642,
0.680996716,
-0.2121606022,
0.3047021329,
-0.1179253832,
-0.0727726817,
-0.4035036862,
-0.7172574997,
-0.175787583,
0.0153839011,
0.113834776,
0.1131728813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14191v1 | Temporal Knowledge Graph Question Answering: A Survey | 2024-06-20T10:51:06 | 2024-06-20T10:51:06 | Miao Su, ZiXuan Li, Zhuo Chen, Long Bai, Xiaolong Jin, Jiafeng Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Knowledge Base Question Answering (KBQA) has been a long-standing field to
answer questions based on knowledge bases. Recently, the evolving dynamics of
knowledge have attracted a growing interest in Temporal Knowledge Graph
Question Answering (TKGQA), an emerging task to answer temporal questions.
However, this field grapples with ambiguities in defining temporal questions
and lacks a systematic categorization of existing methods for TKGQA. In
response, this paper provides a thorough survey from two perspectives: the
taxonomy of temporal questions and the methodological categorization for TKGQA.
Specifically, we first establish a detailed taxonomy of temporal questions
engaged in prior studies. Subsequently, we provide a comprehensive review of
TKGQA techniques of two categories: semantic parsing-based and TKG
embedding-based. Building on this review, the paper outlines potential research
directions aimed at advancing the field of TKGQA. This work aims to serve as a
comprehensive reference for TKGQA and to stimulate further research. | [
-0.3033560812,
-1.1436519623,
0.8419474959,
0.1365022063,
-0.1946672946,
0.775834918,
0.3301144242,
-0.5528678298,
0.0421429314,
0.3366752863,
-0.6017523408,
-0.6084493399,
-0.5062968731,
-0.1879703552,
-0.041471079,
0.229118064,
-0.5326990485,
-0.0852297843,
-0.3481041789,
-0.2538996637,
-0.5955684185,
-0.4721327424,
-0.6710056663,
-0.5355275273,
0.7136619091,
0.2104403377,
0.3906368017,
0.556196332,
-0.1367984414,
0.1335717589,
-0.2030321956,
-0.0783901885,
-0.1050468087,
0.2548847198,
-0.0080547081,
-0.3257054985,
-0.3332614601,
-0.2007817924,
0.5137835145,
1.1014988422,
0.066622138,
0.5956369638,
-0.2325585634,
0.4421000481,
-0.6477765441,
0.397795558,
-0.1315144897,
0.4034605622,
-0.0824206024,
-0.3376420438,
-0.3291029632,
-0.6125759482,
0.2533054054,
-0.6987039447,
-0.0686606318,
0.1297657043,
0.7864138484,
0.2386067808,
-1.1141873598,
-0.202180475,
-0.6477552652,
0.5429216623,
-0.4802397192,
0.713703692,
0.3000613153,
0.8044065833,
-0.0001985463,
-1.0318181515,
-0.3991624415,
-0.0478114225,
0.1240631118,
0.1557822675,
-0.1256234795,
-0.0127631351,
0.0978456736,
0.0293462519,
-0.6014040112,
-0.1608498544,
-0.1557342857,
-0.4544408023,
0.1271403432,
0.4650722742,
0.2898564339,
-0.4349117577,
-0.1941342503,
0.1619343162,
-0.2266284376,
0.4361127615,
0.2183635086,
-0.17570135,
0.3676473498,
0.665678978,
-0.6664798856,
0.8754752278,
0.0197580699,
-0.0302602202,
0.0011791652,
-0.4341133237,
0.0177599974,
0.0698738992,
0.2613755167,
0.6725686789,
-0.0285178572,
-0.7051408291,
0.3566684127,
-0.0121371774,
0.304033041,
-0.4927172661,
-0.1942998767,
0.4746282399,
-0.4576998055,
-0.3820709586,
-0.3561790586,
-0.7146866322,
-0.1027240232,
-0.2073481977,
0.5307154655,
-0.1719315201,
-0.5411117077,
-0.1568182558,
-0.5293495655,
0.4371338189,
0.4464238882,
-0.3280346394,
0.1150092036,
0.8106210828,
0.3780251145,
0.2679941058,
0.1489116997,
-0.1022865996,
0.5714380741,
-0.5168071389,
0.8049600124,
-0.5940994024,
-0.3155325949,
-0.0298490096,
0.2688021362,
-0.1619164944,
-0.3930295706,
0.1172650754,
-1.2832608223,
0.1471181065,
-0.71482265,
-0.7306332588,
-0.4025317729,
0.7340299487,
-0.2855943441,
0.854747057,
0.6202346683,
-0.791411221,
0.6463572979,
-0.4942175746,
0.0050250203,
0.2291977555,
-0.0497544259,
0.0324551947,
-0.5193796158,
0.2060599029,
0.34880656,
-0.0797394514,
0.4635147154,
-0.370231837,
0.1409202218,
0.2249845713,
0.3117050827,
0.7740233541,
0.341858536,
-0.0322156437,
-0.36435166,
-0.4296574593,
0.7085817456,
-0.0361936651,
-0.206294179,
-0.4046826661,
0.1312651187,
-0.3563673496,
0.2861632407,
0.3778617978,
-0.9114359617,
0.402821362,
-0.094603695,
0.7347239256,
0.3583244979,
0.7065204978,
0.3794231713,
-0.2805461884,
0.5918499231,
0.1449990124,
0.3564479947,
0.4192286432,
-0.5668900013,
-0.3699617684,
0.5936522484,
0.3357153833,
0.5210204124,
-1.3302179575,
-0.0567342751,
-0.3630826771,
-0.8146452308,
-0.151750043,
-0.2752442062,
0.407894522,
1.08968997,
0.4034415483,
-0.1671085358,
-0.248190701,
-0.8515375257,
-0.1646292806,
-0.8369982839,
0.0807266906,
0.7394040227,
0.3401800394,
0.1740884036,
1.1263526678,
-0.7711487412,
0.3955596089,
0.1623194218,
0.2189183384,
-0.080775477,
-0.0231471844,
0.7460311651,
-0.7280350924,
-0.3499384522,
-0.0403939001,
-0.8264734149,
-0.2100437582,
0.4522050321,
-0.3395106494,
0.0453741811,
0.5984671712,
-0.3796030581,
0.1956183761,
0.1701221168,
-0.6543728113,
0.3742868602,
0.5362507105,
0.4737009704,
-0.9747744203,
0.0993456468,
-0.7999192476,
-0.1345878243,
-0.8710064292,
-0.0066780522,
0.1433202624,
-0.0149847772,
-0.40600124,
0.7495411038,
0.1373646259,
-0.1555773616,
0.0736457035,
-0.043650385,
0.0944755971,
0.5717659593,
-0.1661414057,
0.2128074616,
0.1261722893,
-0.6210406423,
0.5091148615,
0.5015504956,
-0.1720404029,
0.1248200536,
-0.5720620155,
0.3961504996,
-0.2275167853,
0.2166709155,
-1.0971249342,
-0.2191358805,
0.7474563718,
-0.7026404738,
0.5127846003,
-0.6936364174,
-0.5882106423,
-0.5282512903,
0.0208196025,
0.6026652455,
0.367113024,
-0.3658786416,
0.6999084949,
0.3055966496,
-0.1564818174,
-0.8514410257,
-0.4956816137,
-0.1568425596,
-0.2311939597,
-0.7758909464,
0.1516384333,
0.2729846835,
-0.4324083924,
0.5375294089,
-0.5533571839,
-0.4312821031,
0.1177478358,
-0.1350337267,
0.0013592939,
-0.3867571056,
0.3205040991,
0.0338134393,
-0.0401027501,
0.3104655147,
-0.6800540686,
0.5255941749,
0.2954731286,
0.1030525044,
0.3227198422,
0.3745060861,
0.0823518559,
0.0061666151,
0.6077608466,
0.7443172336,
-0.094098404,
0.2072425485,
-0.5518389344,
0.32364133,
-0.4070598483,
0.2540613115,
-0.1568624377,
-1.3385653496,
0.5747532845,
0.018197922,
0.0519597642,
0.5132021904,
0.5289746523,
-0.5241798162,
0.5427228212,
0.436686784,
0.240912661,
0.1927976459,
-0.1514273882,
0.092531085,
-0.7066306472,
-0.6811808348,
-0.6207711101,
-0.1946966052,
-0.4825802743,
-0.2045745552,
0.5443533659,
0.3310272098,
-0.5384209156,
0.075006865,
-0.3503526151,
-0.0365162864,
0.2573643625,
0.3349860311,
0.230368048,
-0.4491236508,
-0.0144089591,
0.2919379175,
-0.8182802796,
-0.3789920211,
0.9403576851,
0.1769569814,
0.4009395838,
0.2689201236,
0.4355629683,
0.0866089538,
0.1590087414,
-0.8082093,
0.6552339196,
0.1549178958,
-0.8266733885,
-0.6408911943,
-0.6218075752,
-0.9135128856,
-0.118976444,
0.2916863263,
-0.8087849021,
0.1306684613,
0.2382768989,
-0.1074567065,
0.4817370474,
-0.7785770893,
1.1454113722,
-0.0416486859,
0.1674372256,
0.0497679003,
-0.9489793777,
0.3324057758,
0.0130141629,
-0.1609627753,
-0.4138353765,
-0.4625534713,
1.0381184816,
-0.3935869038,
0.4861600101,
-0.6860377192,
0.0995445773,
0.663734436,
0.1829095036,
0.0197610371,
-0.0763067603,
0.3807268441,
0.0797643587,
0.8507559896,
-0.7083384395,
-0.9326989055,
0.2364790291,
-0.838265419,
-0.6959758401,
-0.1285981238,
-0.4470078349,
-0.8798606396,
0.2458963245,
-0.0390598252,
0.5934329629,
0.0415795334,
-0.0063820058,
0.5551922917,
-0.2993064523,
0.4332563281,
0.4529998302,
-0.213282913,
-0.2625736892,
0.5038326383,
0.404912293,
0.4078605771,
0.944819212,
0.289475292,
-0.4559381008,
-0.4614903629,
-0.3026503026,
0.152291432,
-0.9258736372,
-0.1506997943,
-1.0323629379,
-0.2319087684,
-0.6651476622,
0.1416910291,
0.0486327596,
-1.0025279522,
0.0413304977,
0.0912832469,
0.5316215754,
0.5583367944,
0.5554776788,
0.103356272,
-0.9235013723,
0.3973426819,
0.6764174104,
0.3578649461,
0.3221925795,
-0.1223250106,
0.068510592,
-0.2539066076,
-0.3353634775,
-1.0945762396,
-0.2057500333,
-0.2037439197,
0.7457812428,
-0.0558663756,
0.3148397207,
0.7449846268,
-0.4456453919,
1.0752592087,
-0.2183791995,
-0.3502349257,
0.3819516301,
-0.5592238307,
0.366877377,
0.3562402129,
0.6820606589,
-0.9883711338,
-0.2790100574,
-0.7276468873,
-0.7489454746,
0.5619843006,
0.0285744891,
-0.2196952105,
0.1384954751,
0.4993702173,
-0.0815412626,
0.537710011,
-0.0775504857,
-0.4145876765,
-0.5761910677,
0.0598642491,
0.1047043875,
-0.2736437619,
-0.0694874153,
-0.0301755033,
0.267349869,
0.0072030714,
0.6294379234,
0.1023825109,
-0.1614661515,
-0.2117987573,
0.5359966159,
-0.1032366231,
0.8676406145,
-0.2355524302,
-0.0209415536,
0.1998113841,
-0.4867357016,
0.2780028284,
-0.0271057691,
-0.291512996,
-0.1539493501,
0.5541583896,
0.2582620382,
-0.0497521907,
-0.1416604072,
0.2447237521,
0.1885001808,
-0.5173681974,
-0.3732285202,
-0.0254359003,
0.3081260324,
0.4452890456,
0.3780007362,
-0.4718211293,
-0.010456617,
-0.4587887824,
-0.1217884496,
0.0518814549,
-0.1640411317,
-0.0492553785,
0.5731219053,
-0.1097045168,
-0.0515365936,
0.7002218366,
-0.0128776655,
-0.7669585943,
0.835261941,
0.0324720591,
0.6122323871,
0.0134942336,
0.298470974,
0.2441225201,
0.0859899297,
0.5220699906,
0.5769233108,
-0.4229649603,
-0.7233752012,
-0.4033717215,
-0.4622275531,
-0.4609793127,
-0.0795637146,
-0.6479279995,
-0.2371110469,
-0.2616023123,
-0.3582047224,
0.204668045,
0.2966772616,
-0.5167055726,
0.0586132407,
-0.0092322696,
1.1225582361,
-0.6162884831,
0.4368421733,
0.9517532587,
-0.1569909304,
-0.9192016721,
-0.0288285911,
-0.2029272318,
-0.6649366021,
0.7640935183,
-0.4234730899,
0.3004644811,
0.0406064205,
-0.6342160106,
-0.8048487306,
1.577952981,
-0.1434825957,
0.3069384396,
-0.5243571401,
0.4332157969,
0.4029064178,
0.1604567468,
-0.1597008109,
0.5490047932,
0.6248832941,
0.3390419781,
-0.8298966885,
0.0038404183,
-0.1505940557,
-0.2280124724,
0.5730065703,
-0.8650399446,
0.4030372202,
0.3169292212,
-0.2033697516,
0.1462858021,
0.4662205875,
0.0468713269,
0.8108544946,
0.5054165125,
0.4964387119,
0.4465719163,
-0.4257175028,
0.8678634167,
-0.0616875142,
0.2268968523,
0.7470984459,
0.1103794277,
0.1877890974,
0.4515545368,
-0.5107732415,
0.3287859261,
1.1668766737,
0.1462980509,
0.5265780091,
0.0082028136,
-0.2369990051,
-0.5178599358,
-0.3240532577,
-0.4804217219,
0.0314172283,
0.4202900827,
0.055190701,
-0.6638892293,
-0.0483763851,
0.0042083641,
-0.4231408238,
-0.6645894647,
0.7240638137,
-0.0094315214,
-0.609551847,
0.0446510129,
-0.0267417263,
-0.2699268162,
-0.6991400719,
-0.1000696868,
-0.051200144,
-0.3295345902,
0.007897459,
-1.249663353,
0.2233445495,
-0.2322671562,
-0.1608307362,
-0.2919966877,
0.7401753664,
-0.1315089464,
-0.0872648507,
0.0777338669,
0.8473100066,
-0.1120654345,
0.35928455,
-0.6008825898,
-0.4662884772,
-0.3354492188,
-0.2533026934,
0.1429949105,
0.6925477386,
-0.2833877504,
0.863409102,
0.0936711803,
-0.4017051756,
0.4493157864,
-0.1108053848,
0.9742818475,
-0.659334898,
-0.6147531867,
-0.2575094402,
0.1177322194,
0.299159646,
-0.0893222615,
0.7650706172,
0.3056574166,
0.8138177991,
-0.016047582,
0.5296946168,
-0.6066492796,
0.6546735764,
-0.6324040294,
0.409342885,
-0.5124334097,
-0.319637984,
-0.4716966748,
-0.6459661722,
0.0096125975,
-0.2746066153,
-0.46707353,
0.1266568452,
0.744822681,
0.4562388361,
0.237122789,
0.1642596126,
0.1328163892,
0.1477546543,
0.19742392,
0.8511306643,
1.3106215,
-0.2054811716,
0.831781745,
-0.4915047288,
0.1890335381,
0.1502723545,
-0.7166081071,
-0.8184372187,
-0.7201803923,
-0.3477923274,
-0.5481607318,
0.1904185563,
0.5737025738,
0.2930193841,
-0.5708889961,
0.293630749,
0.5159620047,
0.0681638047,
-0.1169205233,
-0.2304742932,
0.708386898,
-0.1489783227,
-0.2027740926,
0.0479943641,
-0.0322846398,
0.0309914593,
0.184548676,
0.1923488677,
-0.1371790618,
-0.6000087261,
0.5182830691,
0.5500850081,
-0.5309390426,
-0.6775583625,
0.5243356824,
0.2140694857,
-0.0070352824,
0.9954277277,
-0.6678967476,
0.507150352,
0.7081345916,
0.9111124277,
0.7138019204,
0.110722661,
0.2262407541,
-0.7892023325,
-0.4264262915,
0.5005226135,
-0.059985619,
-0.156453833,
-0.4171752334,
0.5971434116,
0.4417985678,
-0.5620410442,
-0.443787396,
0.3784094751,
-1.3019704819,
-0.3961813152,
1.0120944977,
-0.0040784832,
-0.3094042838,
-0.8711040616,
0.2268201262,
0.5865346193,
0.029482482,
0.4669389129,
1.0404462814,
-0.464443475,
-0.1262209117,
-0.774364531,
0.3064449728,
-0.0665846094,
-0.5498080254,
-0.0351444259,
0.4105272889,
0.5350987911,
0.1140955463,
0.8962185979,
-0.4894887805,
0.4875022173,
0.0690457299,
-0.4161773026,
-0.4686125219,
-0.0750904083,
0.1622883528,
0.4778211117,
0.0848246589,
-0.0939055532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14189v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14189v1 | In Tree Structure Should Sentence Be Generated | 2024-06-20T10:49:08 | 2024-06-20T10:49:08 | Yaguang Li, Xin Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative models reliant on sequential autoregression have been at the
forefront of language generation for an extensive period, particularly
following the introduction of widely acclaimed transformers. Despite its
excellent performance, there are always some issues that we face today. For
example, problems such as hallucinations and getting trapped in a logic loop
may occur. To enhance the performance of existing systems, this paper
introduces a new method for generating sequences in natural language, which
involves generating the targeted sentence in a tree-traversing order. The paper
includes an illustration of the theoretical basis and validity of the approach,
as well as a comparison of its fundamentals with the diffusion model in graphic
generation. Finally, a module called SenTree is introduced for generating an
approximating binary tree. It is already available at
https://github.com/arklyg/sentree. Additionally, a joint training framework
based on this approach is proposed, incorporating the intrinsics of generative
adversarial networks. | [
0.0089009479,
-1.0905526876,
0.3905089498,
0.2282384932,
-0.3076426685,
-0.02070277,
0.1658811271,
-0.4213396013,
-0.0305266418,
0.3010193408,
-0.4261421263,
-0.2624023855,
-0.570189476,
0.2200266868,
-0.9141149521,
0.9779285789,
0.225098595,
-0.409196794,
0.1998092681,
-0.0593492873,
-0.4566676319,
-0.4882737398,
-0.6225739717,
-0.1533838212,
0.3745785952,
0.0423966087,
1.0612536669,
0.7254188657,
0.249404341,
0.4532956183,
-0.1543549299,
0.1235644594,
-0.0456126891,
0.6081593037,
0.062580727,
-0.2416561246,
-0.1572475135,
-0.1972139925,
0.7887326479,
0.6827976704,
-0.2255942971,
-0.2296341062,
-0.0421788543,
0.746315062,
-0.2433184832,
0.0796208456,
-0.6440896392,
0.299911201,
-0.2562070191,
-0.229207024,
-0.529517889,
-0.6258597374,
0.2470432818,
-0.5369369984,
0.3637361825,
0.0953330249,
0.7675121427,
0.1847880185,
-0.3987250328,
-0.3257904649,
-0.7617874742,
0.2350232452,
-0.6552007794,
0.0719014034,
-0.1589381993,
0.2793033123,
-0.3708155453,
-0.761469245,
-0.3347796798,
-0.2086533308,
-0.1766517609,
0.1235833243,
-0.3161751926,
-0.0705995262,
0.4018814862,
0.5150589347,
-0.7573007941,
-0.1715582758,
-0.1851845533,
0.196251601,
0.7219134569,
0.320612967,
0.4972951114,
-0.6245305538,
-0.0094452268,
-0.4125971496,
-0.8203510046,
0.0248386879,
0.5768843889,
0.2424326241,
0.0749497265,
0.7239319086,
-0.1155892238,
0.7647244334,
0.2596353889,
0.2994236946,
0.1160291582,
-0.4132229388,
-0.2912130356,
0.0343002938,
1.0939253569,
-0.0490303449,
0.3215901554,
-0.0403660871,
-0.2137782723,
0.4943203926,
0.5249698162,
-0.7941835523,
-0.5159787536,
-0.0264568124,
-0.2998203933,
-0.7496169209,
-0.1065633297,
-0.6257171631,
0.2226180881,
-0.1017646641,
-0.0303734839,
-0.716930151,
-0.3499423862,
-0.2055790126,
0.0386229791,
-0.1257092953,
0.1218158752,
-0.9745986462,
0.326202333,
0.421690762,
0.7237035632,
0.0795915872,
-0.1289926022,
-0.731759727,
0.1904353499,
-0.5637086034,
0.639744699,
-0.5946440697,
-0.4793624282,
-0.1019058302,
-0.3378811777,
0.034965992,
-0.3674417436,
0.2007341981,
-0.3934269249,
0.6753370762,
0.427023977,
-0.3173621893,
-0.1923685521,
-0.1039025262,
-0.3868104219,
1.0440713167,
0.2659699619,
-1.0241274834,
0.2857635915,
-0.7608802319,
-0.9051353931,
0.2832066119,
-0.3704473078,
-0.5163748264,
0.1995443404,
0.2306360155,
0.2853742242,
-0.005918554,
0.7084887624,
-0.0700231642,
0.0446363464,
0.041580487,
-0.4122257829,
0.9387446642,
0.4237530529,
-0.3369585276,
0.2388377786,
-0.6690120101,
0.1748456806,
0.1622376591,
-0.4369861484,
-0.0996280834,
0.3335324824,
-0.0483581647,
0.1251436919,
-0.2902635932,
-0.3358513117,
0.1766217202,
-1.0833947659,
0.6337765455,
0.7423889637,
0.1682005078,
0.4491510987,
-0.0002952581,
0.4969799817,
0.170263201,
-0.022193104,
-0.5034511089,
-0.4912705123,
-0.6180874109,
0.2414250821,
0.1231440753,
0.4684906602,
-0.7889600396,
0.7594193816,
-0.1511669308,
-0.1459897012,
0.0035694356,
-0.2057038844,
0.4181042612,
0.2141367942,
0.0914831981,
-0.6193462014,
-0.7564603686,
-0.6915647984,
0.2042752206,
-0.5917010903,
0.1559567451,
0.2065368593,
0.2762105167,
-0.1368847191,
0.975194931,
-0.598523736,
0.4056407511,
-0.1317094415,
0.4504060149,
0.1516381204,
0.4745125771,
0.4351164401,
-0.6956644654,
-0.2420763671,
-0.0057095126,
-0.9257488251,
0.0246550813,
-0.1760381907,
-0.3405676782,
0.5225150585,
0.2099975944,
-0.7249348164,
0.3781645298,
0.3211764395,
-0.2381655425,
0.3759858906,
-0.1551898122,
-0.1615539193,
-1.3454488516,
0.2081855983,
-0.194317922,
-0.4959095418,
-0.352527082,
0.121978052,
-0.4138645828,
-0.3844393194,
-0.1679954678,
0.0474928394,
-0.4826665223,
-0.3778847754,
-0.2695810199,
-0.0568278618,
-0.0357475281,
0.4660561383,
0.0018956366,
0.5329310298,
0.6692031026,
-0.7482001185,
0.3645721674,
0.3900612295,
-0.3094225824,
0.424071312,
-0.5879530907,
0.0416542403,
-0.275731504,
0.3580494523,
-0.7447196841,
-0.0784929469,
0.4508221447,
-0.5630699396,
0.4407115877,
0.0031356355,
-0.547072947,
-0.7404161692,
0.1579768211,
0.3188337684,
0.7149771452,
-0.3320141733,
0.3295046091,
0.1614596844,
-0.0718420148,
-0.2845594287,
-0.4416843951,
0.3171866238,
-0.4043738842,
-0.8900004029,
0.3825876415,
-0.1893675625,
-0.1710822582,
0.0710319877,
0.2770317197,
0.2614181042,
0.3368094563,
0.2909935415,
-0.014779198,
-0.3867407441,
0.025639765,
-0.1460352093,
-0.1311401874,
0.1411314011,
-0.4136846662,
0.396455884,
-0.0222505033,
-0.0429574773,
-0.1864973456,
0.6315119863,
0.2304259688,
-0.1102486178,
0.114200376,
0.1170199811,
-0.1930433065,
-0.3191495538,
0.1832601279,
-0.0270515811,
-0.5050649643,
0.2686590552,
-0.4265200794,
-0.6575198174,
-0.0210623126,
0.158590138,
0.236385867,
0.506906271,
0.623945415,
0.0214430746,
1.2011274099,
0.6206377745,
0.0382987261,
0.6323952675,
-0.3094600439,
0.3198769391,
-0.4712330401,
0.1606776118,
-0.2764967382,
0.0806243718,
-0.5625892282,
-0.1137416288,
0.260923624,
0.364682287,
-0.3252904713,
0.7063912749,
-0.7683063149,
0.1218374521,
0.6125460863,
-0.1354334354,
0.2406920791,
0.2658565342,
-0.3371045887,
0.2695052624,
-1.010964036,
-0.6286504269,
0.6116757989,
0.0371568948,
0.4916008115,
0.1213978082,
0.8516092896,
0.2809491158,
0.4902789891,
-0.5394697785,
0.7099104524,
-0.1647437662,
-0.2656337619,
-0.2372648567,
-0.4483277798,
-1.4388122559,
0.2143703699,
-0.0406439006,
-0.6069737077,
-0.2051808983,
0.2284853309,
-0.3984770179,
-0.0310111735,
-0.6592924595,
0.7587612867,
-0.2719308436,
-0.124435544,
-0.1835259944,
-0.8267167807,
0.5913136601,
0.2274125814,
-0.10663113,
0.1134556755,
0.5847131014,
0.5998607874,
-0.7888184786,
0.736895442,
-0.0066242558,
-0.07800062,
0.6417637467,
0.3301183879,
0.6343430281,
-0.1220102757,
0.20788683,
-0.5374837518,
-0.3561257124,
-0.0339469835,
-0.6774787307,
0.4788149297,
-0.5491594672,
-0.7552814484,
-0.5427651405,
-0.5052915215,
0.1270359159,
0.04952012,
0.2794571221,
0.7857940793,
-0.4843738377,
-0.1627491415,
0.2175377756,
-0.2569588125,
0.9239184856,
0.0934526324,
-0.339414835,
-0.5495115519,
0.5494087338,
0.1453744471,
0.2344079167,
0.3386809826,
0.2202772349,
-0.1639722884,
-0.6005663276,
-0.7346276641,
-0.0585667305,
-0.4767830372,
-0.3170983791,
-0.833850801,
-0.5239245296,
-0.4524611235,
-0.078928493,
0.0443941467,
-0.4932750762,
-0.1857833564,
-0.1849758029,
0.7345817685,
1.1880732775,
-0.0087684589,
0.3968646526,
-0.8601491451,
0.2996502221,
0.2018150389,
0.0706953183,
0.2105104327,
-0.1892118156,
-0.0933236107,
-0.0182053298,
-0.6912271976,
-0.8753415346,
0.6210823655,
0.1360111386,
0.358710438,
0.1722859591,
-0.2159282565,
0.6159204245,
-0.9926252365,
0.5555506945,
0.3730256557,
-0.7196881175,
0.9943767786,
-0.5593363643,
0.3019464314,
0.0874101892,
0.0289918669,
-0.5406045914,
-0.77451998,
-1.1872864962,
-0.9765034914,
0.7568708062,
0.7269426584,
0.2448291779,
-0.5838154554,
-0.0018677064,
-0.0618873537,
0.2072049528,
-0.8758196235,
-0.1882344931,
-0.3623253107,
-0.3212611675,
0.0615117997,
0.0311512761,
0.2037677914,
-0.0331470594,
0.579603374,
0.0761794746,
0.1888271123,
0.1986997277,
-0.1898172945,
-0.3638606071,
0.0844529644,
0.2342770398,
0.4937562048,
0.038226705,
0.1214486659,
-0.3893710077,
-0.0945688859,
0.2881632447,
0.063704662,
-0.6648697853,
0.1624089628,
0.2028915435,
0.918830514,
-0.0453070551,
-0.3006134629,
0.3128753006,
0.1289245635,
-0.1097260788,
-0.1743464172,
0.2591935098,
-0.0661398619,
0.2778245807,
0.2018129826,
0.2971663475,
0.2174682617,
-0.7410583496,
0.6045616269,
0.4593699276,
0.082979694,
-0.4192935824,
0.7259507179,
0.3929273188,
-0.7473959923,
0.7778837681,
-0.248402223,
-0.608682096,
0.6036626101,
0.7236754894,
1.0471806526,
-0.2579404414,
0.4011217356,
0.6366895437,
0.1144963056,
-0.204484418,
0.1472021788,
-0.2837817967,
-0.5956964493,
-0.5799886584,
-0.686968863,
0.0429499932,
-0.2914489806,
-0.1300086677,
0.1095809415,
-0.4644677341,
-0.0916136801,
-0.0195600875,
-0.172421813,
-0.2269325405,
0.3641962707,
0.3812202811,
0.4101357162,
-0.8302302957,
0.82562989,
0.3428287208,
-0.4815118313,
-0.6455513835,
0.0166724399,
-0.4055185616,
-0.4654791653,
0.8637012839,
0.3504699469,
-0.1110698283,
0.2244666666,
-0.2479368597,
-0.9674554467,
0.8251405358,
-0.006407876,
-0.4383799136,
-0.1193531007,
-0.155557245,
0.5668321252,
-0.6071187854,
0.2103332579,
0.0792210549,
0.0905385911,
0.3310579956,
-0.3614225984,
0.1564259827,
-0.4931072295,
0.4580900669,
0.5498200059,
-0.2628725469,
0.5805601478,
-0.1657276005,
-0.9334833026,
0.2111865878,
0.8980795741,
0.297178328,
-0.1664101332,
0.6338409185,
0.8211491108,
0.6526384354,
0.0394247286,
1.1749544144,
-0.2946038544,
-0.069182016,
1.3186534643,
-0.2360209376,
0.6579151154,
0.0435364917,
-0.3984130025,
0.8445528746,
0.7476189733,
0.1174534038,
0.5264809132,
0.6012066603,
-0.2127793431,
0.0196083151,
0.1051451191,
-0.3663250208,
0.1651266962,
0.2822777927,
-0.615745008,
-0.3723656833,
-0.152993992,
-0.1627140045,
0.1717395186,
-0.0786573589,
0.759773314,
0.094493039,
-1.0280314684,
0.5156915784,
0.0088670608,
0.485237658,
-0.3755410016,
-0.1084105074,
-0.21558249,
-0.1134622768,
-0.1090997756,
-0.7212597132,
0.6774063706,
0.1171971634,
-0.0212532822,
-0.6068632007,
0.4837859273,
-0.4356543422,
-0.8112114072,
0.1227443665,
0.4664275348,
0.2681238353,
0.3726936579,
-0.6636302471,
-0.4589710832,
-0.0960362405,
-0.2661177516,
-0.1291052699,
0.6083850861,
-0.2625616491,
0.3340655267,
0.5800207257,
-0.161115706,
0.2479837686,
0.3569298387,
0.707103014,
-0.7379233241,
-0.6671932936,
-1.0512491465,
0.5061741471,
-0.0213588439,
-0.2432704419,
0.586004436,
0.7087313533,
0.5083934069,
0.2474517077,
0.722153008,
-0.51432693,
0.1815532446,
-0.5080557466,
0.1802554578,
-0.2455317974,
-0.0709746331,
-0.3731099367,
-1.1744641066,
-0.289303124,
0.634213388,
-0.0310942363,
-0.0049082735,
0.9019395113,
0.7436643839,
-0.0505547747,
0.0918793827,
0.1422475576,
0.2974215448,
0.2463238239,
0.8293011189,
1.0434449911,
-0.5584528446,
0.4909323156,
-0.0633379444,
0.1616518646,
0.1194168329,
-0.7469152808,
-0.5714409351,
-0.5692320466,
-0.5425570011,
-0.4750205576,
0.1442270577,
0.6440278292,
0.6777405739,
-0.5348663926,
-0.2740079761,
-0.9299232364,
0.0342961624,
-0.0002521015,
-0.2356012315,
0.2917646468,
-0.4991599917,
-0.5828694105,
0.4488423765,
0.4513848424,
0.4648866057,
-0.2192415893,
-0.0096468721,
-0.4931849837,
-0.1447340399,
0.6710985303,
0.054967355,
-0.6850011349,
-0.4098257422,
-0.2998318374,
-0.1892277449,
0.5142142773,
0.9691061378,
-1.1267051697,
0.1925821602,
0.7061415911,
0.3659933507,
0.5424189568,
0.2378025204,
1.0158458948,
-0.8596513867,
-0.0174714364,
0.2705971003,
0.3397573531,
0.5469509959,
-0.3641179502,
0.6126117706,
0.2824910879,
-0.3261470199,
-0.5637702942,
0.6410143375,
-0.5868580937,
-0.2463122457,
0.8601235747,
0.1284878999,
-0.355165422,
-0.014605849,
-0.1069582403,
0.5083172917,
-0.2229918838,
0.4966957867,
0.5001342893,
-0.0602057502,
-0.1010148004,
0.0495750792,
0.4461560547,
0.5637512207,
-0.9110944271,
0.1796874255,
0.8844767809,
-0.085364759,
0.3167152107,
0.7391546965,
-0.1064888611,
0.1117830649,
0.0472905114,
-0.0796411783,
0.2226551026,
-0.4212703407,
-0.2701742947,
0.1897918284,
0.0973157585,
-0.1549565643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14177v1 | SimulSeamless: FBK at IWSLT 2024 Simultaneous Speech Translation | 2024-06-20T10:34:46 | 2024-06-20T10:34:46 | Sara Papi, Marco Gaido, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper describes the FBK's participation in the Simultaneous Translation
Evaluation Campaign at IWSLT 2024. For this year's submission in the
speech-to-text translation (ST) sub-track, we propose SimulSeamless, which is
realized by combining AlignAtt and SeamlessM4T in its medium configuration. The
SeamlessM4T model is used "off-the-shelf" and its simultaneous inference is
enabled through the adoption of AlignAtt, a SimulST policy based on
cross-attention that can be applied without any retraining or adaptation of the
underlying model for the simultaneous task. We participated in all the Shared
Task languages (English->{German, Japanese, Chinese}, and Czech->English),
achieving acceptable or even better results compared to last year's
submissions. SimulSeamless, covering more than 143 source languages and 200
target languages, is released at: https://github.com/hlt-mt/FBK-fairseq/. | [
-0.2105159163,
-0.4719021618,
0.5643483996,
0.7904845476,
-0.6236496568,
0.3792219758,
-0.2521212995,
-0.5782958865,
0.141282931,
0.2449102849,
-0.9704465866,
-0.4088955224,
-0.5431078672,
0.1042003036,
-0.5811092854,
0.9632830024,
-0.7998139858,
0.5249676108,
-0.6189755797,
-0.2679485977,
-0.5970936418,
-0.0407908596,
-0.2536589503,
-0.4630573094,
0.2458248138,
0.3449527323,
0.7266000509,
0.4204623997,
0.4775331318,
0.3053367138,
0.4342689812,
-0.1171120629,
-0.4679972529,
0.1553236395,
-0.2934297919,
-0.1141918972,
-0.3898060024,
0.1528505683,
1.0349911451,
0.5517258048,
0.0297670569,
0.2319578379,
0.187552616,
0.1349383295,
-0.4059270024,
-0.0278831236,
-0.2669398487,
0.185668543,
-0.4112631083,
-0.0552729331,
-0.3592999279,
-0.1602674723,
-0.0322543867,
-0.60034585,
-0.061079409,
0.2381828725,
0.7894048095,
0.4673058391,
-0.391084522,
-0.1643390208,
-0.4266497791,
1.1612619162,
-0.5548609495,
0.7298035026,
0.222890988,
0.1701460332,
-0.1582666487,
-1.174497962,
-0.277590543,
-0.1955116391,
0.067358911,
0.6528918147,
-0.051020734,
0.133491084,
-0.0232620817,
0.2194572389,
-0.6099209189,
-0.0983681679,
-0.2657190561,
-0.3472140133,
0.9147874117,
0.3581658006,
0.3152817488,
0.1119948402,
-0.7478071451,
0.1548871845,
-0.1426232606,
0.0192074757,
0.1799964309,
0.2174265683,
-0.4772132635,
0.404240787,
-0.3414219916,
0.4964459538,
-0.3220597208,
-0.0492645614,
0.3798473179,
-0.9792664051,
-0.1525475681,
0.0876874402,
0.9377451539,
0.1250790805,
-0.1254971474,
-0.2490768582,
-0.1853903383,
-0.034890119,
0.3164881468,
-0.66501683,
0.1153909266,
0.4179166257,
-0.4911220968,
-0.2324441522,
0.1243432239,
-0.6610257626,
0.1162967831,
-0.4948134422,
0.622138381,
-0.3925884962,
-0.1752594858,
-0.1602874845,
0.0103442688,
-0.0149042141,
0.538887918,
-0.1775297076,
0.518410027,
0.6770212054,
0.7755800486,
-0.603476584,
-1.0113133192,
-0.6254072785,
0.2188676149,
-0.0553297922,
0.4723253548,
-0.1607630849,
-0.2874873579,
-0.2306724489,
-0.0864243358,
-0.0814420059,
-0.1752702445,
0.9605336785,
0.0768626928,
-0.0282525681,
-0.3415216208,
-0.4616847634,
-0.0413484573,
-0.1801827252,
-0.4806897938,
1.0807359219,
-0.0774786845,
-0.7149840593,
0.2467417121,
-0.5740917921,
-0.523401916,
0.3850790858,
-0.1784448475,
-0.4565333426,
0.2115580291,
-0.010702244,
0.2409654558,
-0.3046949208,
0.5443156362,
-0.398077637,
-0.5094543695,
0.1060570851,
-0.5191707015,
0.8400487304,
0.26401034,
-0.4822493196,
0.3737914562,
-0.3340865374,
0.1518505216,
0.2042773664,
-0.0789501071,
-0.0716437772,
-0.0841497034,
0.3339380622,
0.3952863514,
0.5752897263,
-0.7808631659,
-0.0564548783,
-0.099498108,
0.0617762432,
0.6397797465,
-0.1577623039,
0.2874157727,
-0.1225855425,
0.6207016706,
0.1873767674,
0.5161461234,
0.1367957592,
-0.6260743141,
-0.526198864,
-0.3846628368,
0.5031710267,
0.50639081,
-0.9388480783,
-0.1958478242,
-0.1987299174,
-0.4274922907,
-0.8702913523,
-0.1235079244,
0.4625728428,
-0.042460002,
0.3062489033,
-0.1885017455,
-0.6746715903,
-0.885024488,
-0.7013799548,
0.2020991445,
0.4395951033,
-0.0606206693,
0.3468035161,
-0.2134618312,
0.6091660261,
-0.0073598856,
-0.2381822616,
-0.1652568579,
0.2784322202,
-0.1647869051,
0.4739293754,
0.6006574631,
-0.9108093977,
-0.7313271165,
0.0421430953,
-0.6681654453,
-0.3749310076,
0.0435745716,
-0.2696029842,
0.1412821263,
0.4505541623,
-0.4786710441,
0.6670975685,
1.0476125479,
-0.29711923,
0.4962916076,
0.1055101454,
0.4158738852,
-1.1555838585,
-0.1802084446,
-0.4400414824,
-0.6712907553,
-0.5645928979,
0.0620771609,
0.1957254261,
-0.0268738307,
-0.4815089405,
0.6322007179,
-0.4213655889,
-0.2538796365,
-0.0458793007,
0.4423237741,
-0.3220742345,
-0.0085805515,
-0.2992650568,
0.9331502318,
0.410594523,
-0.1252391636,
0.3671203852,
0.2907610834,
-0.1297978759,
0.5620622635,
-0.2347766161,
-0.0509321317,
0.2715629041,
0.4250579774,
-1.0551949739,
-0.3679748178,
0.2414793521,
-0.41564399,
0.1871026456,
0.4347530603,
-0.3966519535,
-0.6039075851,
-0.2730852664,
0.4366334677,
0.1708375961,
-0.4249762893,
0.6982540488,
0.4355069399,
-0.3575710654,
-0.7855574489,
-0.7972986102,
0.131996721,
0.1851837039,
-0.6275853515,
0.3252792358,
-0.2762231231,
-0.0078999801,
0.3864132464,
-0.420547992,
-0.0500352271,
0.079375945,
0.3735057712,
0.1032480448,
-0.3074919581,
-0.3846064806,
0.5135235786,
-0.0401297584,
-0.196739912,
-0.3826558888,
0.5291522741,
-0.2042588443,
-0.6077091694,
-0.7553853989,
0.8537997007,
0.3909504414,
-0.2051301301,
0.4658200443,
0.7440789342,
-0.1686743051,
-0.1334187686,
-0.4305127561,
-0.1044276804,
-0.4219870567,
0.3615753055,
-0.5881850123,
-1.2055801153,
0.4231027365,
-0.2416969091,
0.4215270281,
0.3002496958,
0.7760022879,
-0.3083027899,
0.9981989264,
0.1831736416,
0.2660822868,
0.336486429,
0.3822301328,
0.2533475757,
-0.4977984726,
-0.1259060651,
-0.4436591864,
-0.3881617785,
-0.4895890951,
-0.5708338618,
0.1699973941,
-0.0160135422,
0.2656600773,
0.2726213634,
0.048191648,
0.2877270877,
0.5248537064,
-0.1553398073,
0.1952141672,
-0.0450595506,
-0.4263736606,
-0.5063430071,
-0.6762664318,
-0.0999301895,
0.6252480149,
0.286341995,
0.5098026395,
-0.1154188067,
1.1155568361,
0.0635828823,
0.2793166041,
-0.6431757808,
0.7233694196,
-0.4432087243,
-0.5472764969,
-0.1793646067,
-0.4622875452,
-0.7269056439,
0.5055299401,
0.1186992228,
-0.4784465134,
-0.2572458982,
0.2244465053,
0.0872665122,
-0.0350069106,
-0.4760477245,
1.020794034,
-0.4013374448,
-0.4642985165,
-0.3584468663,
-0.836202383,
0.4303261042,
-0.3324792385,
0.2861176431,
-0.4633301497,
-0.1360138357,
0.6053078771,
0.0169453453,
0.6106581688,
-0.1870864779,
0.0753757581,
0.2027589232,
0.0137175787,
0.4114981294,
-0.1123423874,
0.0533797145,
0.5923318267,
0.1753710061,
-0.3955885172,
-0.198273614,
0.6854518056,
-0.6434354782,
-0.3217877448,
-0.585847497,
-1.0013422966,
-0.3753761053,
0.5076437593,
0.2216709703,
0.3341290057,
-0.5600422621,
0.3473286927,
0.2029210627,
0.0121926581,
0.3636493981,
0.4042402804,
-0.4927962422,
-0.7171663046,
0.9021741152,
0.2793402672,
0.4294689,
0.0363650322,
0.1771600395,
-0.4031017125,
-0.5777677894,
-0.4293263853,
0.4283545911,
-0.5057846904,
-0.3717541397,
-0.7867637277,
-0.2721440494,
-0.6775919795,
-0.1939283162,
-0.5795974731,
-0.5182497501,
-0.0304931421,
0.1279488057,
-0.0481122211,
0.7655829191,
-0.1671477407,
0.4681739807,
-0.6916428804,
0.4908538461,
-0.1538200378,
0.2926605344,
-0.4286661446,
-0.4119986892,
-0.5306599736,
0.097002238,
-0.3316151202,
-0.5908882022,
0.1041061133,
0.152089268,
0.8991125226,
-0.3058947623,
0.135928303,
1.0544842482,
-0.6679438949,
0.8923110962,
0.281750977,
-1.3133111,
0.2911064625,
-0.3803989589,
0.6683831811,
0.7981461883,
0.3041898012,
-0.5871085525,
-0.9576441646,
-0.6887915134,
-0.9531056285,
1.2177211046,
0.4840099514,
0.0157167129,
0.5477129221,
-0.0627237037,
0.2242156565,
0.539234817,
-0.6524329185,
-0.2116319388,
-0.2436891645,
-0.8025176525,
0.156232506,
-0.4188594818,
-0.1046228185,
-0.264262259,
1.0444551706,
-0.0022236772,
0.2377687693,
0.0461672992,
-0.0743044689,
-0.294414252,
0.0618972257,
0.8078249693,
0.4280014932,
0.0305332728,
0.0563664585,
0.2691144049,
-0.8180024624,
0.0791389048,
0.2248143554,
-0.3345637619,
0.1725589484,
0.4310100377,
1.0837603807,
0.7625251412,
-0.3788699806,
0.6900376678,
-0.3183788657,
-0.4660107493,
-0.190574497,
-0.3186882138,
0.1878374964,
0.4054632783,
0.0323631205,
0.0824175104,
0.2270040065,
-0.1002780125,
0.5653959513,
0.2016382962,
-0.5553770661,
-0.3043895364,
0.7468091846,
0.3359840512,
0.0008971479,
0.0758710131,
-0.0709374696,
-0.5844556093,
0.0488993637,
0.7683032155,
1.1832854748,
-0.8834142089,
0.1115774363,
0.2658672929,
0.4793295264,
-0.0974111408,
0.6608381271,
-0.1051526219,
-0.2617467642,
-0.5943848491,
-0.8972340226,
-0.3859905303,
-0.2127991319,
-0.7259249687,
0.4703975618,
-0.0194049757,
-0.0257837754,
-0.1611680537,
-0.0117068673,
-0.4295955598,
-0.0002351699,
0.0346741118,
0.8023630381,
-1.0454376936,
0.9363893867,
0.8820622563,
-0.2029990703,
-0.7967694998,
0.4016338587,
0.235879153,
-0.6017625332,
0.2885995507,
0.0188900679,
-0.2039540559,
0.2842275798,
-0.6778229475,
-1.0069992542,
1.0849430561,
0.6971825361,
-0.4969826937,
0.1749953032,
0.3823265433,
0.1767934561,
-0.1890651882,
-0.1970853359,
0.4830861688,
0.7762087584,
0.0805990249,
-1.4443018436,
-0.0969106257,
0.2193830162,
-0.0306359231,
0.1625087559,
-0.857932508,
0.8690574169,
0.1823548079,
-0.2936786711,
0.2603828013,
1.0182019472,
0.4148961306,
0.6115303636,
0.4038178921,
0.496501416,
0.3800266981,
-0.4573291242,
1.0288562775,
0.2158979177,
0.4663268328,
1.4980825186,
-0.326482296,
0.7846153378,
0.8781483173,
-0.1941124648,
-0.0161023196,
0.3492065668,
0.4031403065,
0.5362046957,
-0.1824479699,
-0.3071645498,
-0.2561384737,
-0.4686302245,
-0.2285294086,
0.6613324881,
0.1981254518,
0.2119651735,
-0.3817262948,
0.5206362605,
0.0952498391,
-0.0218700469,
-0.0928251967,
0.703684032,
0.5867605805,
-0.7097651362,
0.2851331234,
-0.1015739292,
0.4211817384,
-0.9611991644,
0.120425716,
-0.0499219336,
0.2871722877,
-0.1572951227,
-1.0448226929,
0.3421071768,
-0.2092004269,
0.1009116918,
-0.5136702657,
0.5160933733,
-0.956246078,
-0.3647040725,
0.5969075561,
0.2180461586,
0.1816710085,
0.1856281906,
-1.0466257334,
0.8175137043,
0.3625722528,
-0.1279922873,
0.192980364,
0.6137863994,
-0.3480690122,
0.2339396924,
0.3749630749,
0.1441664994,
0.4943045974,
0.2289621681,
0.619042635,
-0.3574763238,
-0.6301484704,
-0.5802152157,
0.667057991,
-0.2610991597,
0.0355709046,
1.116345048,
0.6278311014,
0.8363793492,
-0.1812053621,
0.7462537289,
-0.1710959226,
0.562600255,
-0.4424316883,
0.6354427934,
-0.9246752262,
-0.5544753075,
-0.4748302102,
-0.8355226517,
-0.13352561,
0.3401837945,
0.0345680714,
-0.1504385024,
1.1495509148,
0.1529773474,
-0.3195855618,
0.3388385773,
0.611315906,
0.3506275713,
0.1152127832,
0.2599519193,
0.8346478939,
-0.7570660114,
0.3186095059,
-0.4966542721,
-0.1701499671,
-0.2801287472,
-0.9511023164,
-0.4729795158,
-0.8437077999,
-0.4009335339,
-0.2793659866,
0.0591506213,
0.9471895695,
0.443831265,
-0.9821870327,
-0.4771557748,
0.2068819255,
-0.1825214326,
-0.2649612427,
-0.1565363109,
-0.0871708915,
-0.3692458272,
-0.9343098998,
0.5665518641,
0.522672832,
0.1165851057,
-0.0364875607,
-0.1898621917,
-0.4594851136,
-0.0173982084,
0.4769632518,
-0.1852424145,
-0.9779630899,
-0.1558042914,
-0.245393917,
-0.0958770365,
-0.2748436332,
0.756598711,
-0.2913148105,
0.5171341896,
0.5595110655,
0.7832512856,
0.705018878,
0.0563885197,
0.6612912416,
-0.9451578856,
0.7154778838,
0.3076228499,
0.3164916635,
0.1953991652,
-0.1991319656,
0.5690461397,
0.4141398072,
-0.6008672118,
-1.0499761105,
0.1661971956,
-1.1636916399,
-0.0461162552,
0.8990161419,
-0.1183318868,
-0.198397249,
-0.1558443308,
-0.328872472,
0.4129881263,
-0.3428040743,
-0.0371529758,
0.9116235375,
-0.0859213173,
-0.1055197492,
-1.0917924643,
0.4153432548,
0.6886327863,
-0.8479591012,
0.1295459419,
0.4051749706,
0.1128703803,
0.0177663714,
0.8715263009,
-0.2851602733,
0.3469635844,
0.1133652851,
0.089138709,
0.1331688464,
-0.4333554804,
-0.1772676408,
-0.0941991732,
-0.0550303571,
-0.1723458469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14171v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14171v1 | Ranking LLMs by compression | 2024-06-20T10:23:38 | 2024-06-20T10:23:38 | Peijia Guo, Ziguang Li, Haibo Hu, Chao Huang, Ming Li, Rui Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We conceptualize the process of understanding as information compression, and
propose a method for ranking large language models (LLMs) based on lossless
data compression. We demonstrate the equivalence of compression length under
arithmetic coding with cumulative negative log probabilities when using a large
language model as a prior, that is, the pre-training phase of the model is
essentially the process of learning the optimal coding length. At the same
time, the evaluation metric compression ratio can be obtained without actual
compression, which greatly saves overhead. In this paper, we use five large
language models as priors for compression, then compare their performance on
challenging natural language processing tasks, including sentence completion,
question answering, and coreference resolution. Experimental results show that
compression ratio and model performance are positively correlated, so it can be
used as a general metric to evaluate large language models. | [
-0.428471148,
-0.5677004457,
0.727065444,
-0.0069279969,
-0.4176865816,
0.0028588569,
-0.6558853984,
-0.4581429362,
0.1346160173,
0.5077688694,
-0.3547556698,
-0.4535606205,
-0.8623383045,
0.2711846232,
-0.3976426721,
0.7088348866,
0.2418880165,
0.219515726,
-0.4357590377,
0.0628695264,
-0.457500577,
-0.9636906981,
-0.7155885696,
-0.364713341,
0.222533837,
0.152848497,
0.8392675519,
0.5556823015,
0.7627934217,
0.4037554562,
-0.0996503457,
-0.0292413849,
-0.7571864724,
-0.0027727135,
-0.045860447,
-0.5768387318,
-0.4033178091,
0.0819960237,
0.7498986125,
0.8460154533,
-0.1835802197,
0.3874209523,
-0.0746535957,
0.6275010705,
-0.6096728444,
-0.0372141935,
-0.6708229184,
0.0800067112,
0.1280617565,
-0.6737968922,
-0.7131938338,
-0.7291616797,
-0.1536125541,
-0.1430676281,
0.175451532,
0.1473721564,
0.6492293477,
0.3449108601,
-0.3489747643,
-0.3470746577,
-0.6480053067,
0.8240139484,
-0.900804162,
0.5299363732,
0.4726197422,
0.1696777791,
0.0322045833,
-0.2500155568,
-0.6135852337,
-0.3827343881,
-0.0547669604,
-0.130055666,
-0.167363897,
0.2499248683,
0.4635364115,
0.7228653431,
-0.7857826948,
0.4285780787,
-0.3881562352,
-0.2152067274,
0.7039600015,
0.1175009981,
0.1815981865,
-0.0398949161,
-0.0443133712,
-0.092509158,
-0.9120846987,
-0.0254732259,
0.6183499098,
0.1502455622,
0.0581407174,
0.7052688003,
-0.2051827759,
0.9935433865,
-0.141288057,
-0.4710032046,
0.3631510735,
-0.2784354091,
-0.4493219554,
0.0309457239,
0.6466283202,
0.2843551934,
0.3741367161,
-0.411039114,
-0.2058397233,
0.1905174255,
0.3164465427,
-0.9350163341,
-0.0168998111,
0.0146314725,
-0.5063360929,
-0.0642878339,
-0.0550605878,
-0.3258365691,
-0.2816513479,
-0.5871762037,
0.5614587069,
-0.1186080575,
-0.0339724347,
0.4582892358,
-0.031032078,
0.0690798759,
0.3261438608,
-0.6919903755,
0.3957713544,
0.6423066854,
0.896129787,
0.0759404376,
0.0247851573,
-0.5205548406,
-0.1529682726,
-0.6289278269,
0.5964761972,
-0.5415501595,
-0.3988833129,
-0.0467214212,
-0.1570139676,
0.1247987673,
-0.6206978559,
1.0000532866,
-0.6839653254,
0.1283351481,
0.1509663761,
-0.9471373558,
-0.3146354556,
0.280877322,
-0.5701070428,
0.6517127752,
-0.0419134162,
-0.6082801819,
-0.0301511213,
-0.2656226456,
-0.2825344503,
-0.0016951049,
0.1050808579,
-0.0582088903,
0.4290574491,
0.1742393076,
0.8836537004,
-0.6257612109,
0.2327294648,
-0.2174593359,
-0.4079877734,
0.1484299302,
-0.3853408992,
0.4859783053,
0.1707987338,
0.2156469524,
0.051402092,
-0.6661598682,
0.0996197611,
0.1171822175,
-0.6171449423,
-0.3964757919,
-0.0459329858,
-0.5325649977,
0.2850146592,
0.3957239389,
-0.3336583376,
0.4625124335,
-0.4861084819,
0.4074749351,
0.7116474509,
-0.0165320486,
0.4573356509,
-0.2344839275,
0.4610057771,
-0.2791242898,
0.0736136064,
-0.1228578091,
-0.1070184782,
-1.0729607344,
0.063134335,
0.4989961982,
0.4830661416,
-0.5612723827,
0.7035139203,
-0.8612072468,
-0.6393917799,
-0.4410192072,
0.1499486864,
0.3349607289,
0.4592606425,
0.3166199923,
-0.3876101375,
-0.4483109713,
-0.8169826269,
-0.1330050826,
-0.2927962244,
-0.2854091525,
0.3301610053,
0.2037170529,
0.0240044128,
0.3860733211,
-0.6440503001,
0.0917431861,
-0.3476822078,
0.3686647713,
0.6639684439,
0.4158166647,
0.3039604127,
-0.5388368964,
-0.1223907396,
-0.3196494877,
-0.6033800244,
-0.1695233434,
0.1817851812,
0.0825149119,
0.2206049562,
0.4206358492,
-0.6464654803,
0.3640168905,
0.7746802568,
-0.2820448875,
0.6796257496,
-0.3456681967,
0.4740204811,
-0.7150292397,
-0.0267218817,
-0.0695076138,
-0.458206445,
-0.577060163,
0.1243415996,
0.1111155376,
-0.1740167886,
-0.2981323898,
0.2468588203,
-0.633392036,
-0.2749485373,
-0.1450397968,
0.1121103019,
-0.1138061509,
0.5540209413,
0.1993700415,
0.7112836242,
0.4123326838,
-0.8486575484,
0.4172773659,
-0.1090687811,
-0.8458999991,
0.2284973264,
-0.6161110401,
0.3330259025,
-0.4592960179,
0.122350812,
-0.8006879687,
0.2542600036,
-0.1925075054,
-0.4618849754,
0.5147922039,
-0.2268431038,
-0.7699938416,
-0.5398049355,
-0.3124835491,
0.4548053741,
0.6475455761,
-0.2914189994,
-0.0019204785,
0.327911973,
-0.2924273312,
-0.533744514,
-0.6458687782,
0.2383024991,
-0.3924193382,
-0.5709610581,
0.4840342104,
-0.624671042,
-0.0905937925,
-0.1765191704,
0.0637103915,
0.0237641409,
0.043366991,
0.1127057672,
0.3234601319,
-0.2370611876,
0.410023272,
-0.4332678914,
0.0702261403,
-0.0738053247,
-0.1901338696,
0.8314462304,
0.0875589922,
-0.0893727019,
-0.3030610383,
0.0666795745,
0.2876544297,
-0.0722926036,
0.7957811356,
0.1167295873,
-0.2792628109,
0.1397698224,
-0.7535116076,
-0.0025800043,
-0.4094331861,
0.1609125882,
-0.3734731674,
-1.1610594988,
0.2821635306,
0.0037696806,
-0.0944533721,
0.4309130311,
0.5249533057,
0.327365011,
1.0433759689,
0.7700368762,
-0.3468852639,
0.3879334927,
-0.2223660797,
0.3181110024,
-0.5975379944,
0.1009410471,
-0.854055047,
-0.2181240469,
-0.2765536606,
-0.5517991781,
0.1967925131,
0.6444997787,
-0.459192127,
0.4301507771,
-0.4801353812,
0.7182568312,
0.1911057532,
-0.0275002569,
0.5015724301,
-0.0909941494,
0.214685902,
-0.0311946385,
-0.5142326355,
-0.4866686761,
1.0415295362,
0.4211558104,
0.844579339,
0.41308707,
0.557525754,
0.3514931798,
0.2621954679,
-1.0619026423,
0.4576053917,
-0.1026733071,
-0.2946247756,
-0.4510309398,
-0.8648045659,
-0.9451307654,
0.153725341,
-0.3156856298,
-0.8805559278,
-0.1564197242,
-0.1780272424,
-0.2926072776,
0.1604824215,
-0.6277509332,
0.5812644958,
-0.2242887616,
0.1237190142,
-0.4651522934,
-0.4125864506,
0.5278322101,
-0.0243178122,
0.4092564881,
-0.087862663,
-0.151881814,
0.9504547715,
-0.3912473917,
0.3929500282,
0.1744913906,
0.0553685464,
0.0545179993,
0.2594098151,
0.3534809649,
-0.034048371,
-0.1666473001,
0.272972703,
-0.0799928978,
-0.2769405544,
-0.9286586046,
0.6433433294,
-0.6974467635,
-0.6469199657,
-0.1183094978,
-0.3082088232,
-0.1714424044,
0.2068524063,
0.4250812531,
0.5531188846,
0.0171876065,
0.2704016864,
0.650190115,
-0.3515443206,
0.4809187949,
0.519425869,
-0.2631958425,
-0.3482634127,
0.6115510464,
0.326998204,
0.3427341282,
0.7909111381,
0.1418121308,
-0.4019032419,
-0.9268632531,
-0.1527492702,
0.2851257622,
-0.8480305672,
-0.5506545305,
-0.6019921899,
-0.3430349231,
-0.6612327099,
0.043283198,
-0.1879480183,
-0.4839797914,
-0.0455058478,
-0.2012845129,
0.0911223814,
0.8496367931,
0.1478938609,
0.2547903359,
-0.8997540474,
0.2675645649,
0.2445843369,
0.3741532266,
0.1698104739,
-0.7790618539,
-0.3199705482,
-0.1289183497,
-0.2885196805,
-0.7977167368,
0.4560829997,
0.2468384206,
0.5624126196,
0.463253051,
0.096727401,
0.8010210991,
-0.6603368521,
0.9868362546,
0.3952719569,
-1.0631667376,
0.4381738901,
0.2164118886,
0.2630620897,
0.3695138991,
0.736220181,
-0.4777335823,
-0.1442431808,
-0.6645953655,
-0.7074630857,
0.4087308347,
0.1000389084,
0.240075171,
-0.0451833829,
0.2729282975,
-0.0071319551,
0.3215952814,
-0.851041615,
-0.2704412937,
0.2247608602,
-0.0180903617,
-0.7127249241,
-0.5259921551,
0.1097264811,
-0.3080576956,
0.6751869917,
0.0477693193,
0.4249058068,
0.1012727544,
-0.4373637438,
0.0663457662,
0.4309048057,
0.5218940377,
0.6689452529,
-0.1796061099,
0.419431299,
0.2486103326,
-0.1985048205,
0.1933134645,
-0.2034758627,
0.3527085185,
-0.0778367072,
0.7505096793,
0.8163434267,
0.3361098766,
-0.700391531,
0.6786223054,
-0.2641052902,
0.0196539238,
-0.1345735788,
0.0322291479,
0.0487810113,
-0.0662792847,
0.2483412772,
-0.2204633355,
0.2981616855,
-0.6170816422,
-0.1774653941,
0.3621235192,
-0.1543952227,
-0.1159487292,
0.0823173225,
-0.0864411816,
-0.3009922504,
0.7489600182,
-0.0826946273,
-0.5132578015,
0.4144707322,
0.4294959009,
0.5442516208,
-0.2842289805,
-0.0868760273,
0.6265716553,
0.3515518606,
-0.3823260367,
0.0594370775,
-0.2720662057,
-0.7393200397,
-0.8928753734,
-0.9973437786,
-0.0983130559,
0.2760799527,
-0.4960145652,
0.3968367577,
-0.3542903662,
-0.1985350102,
0.1066779867,
0.2513016164,
-0.7902392149,
0.2991864085,
0.293286413,
1.1581497192,
-0.5502712727,
0.744890213,
0.2681542933,
-0.2875207365,
-0.8735369444,
-0.3078736067,
-0.2635981739,
-0.5685173273,
0.647762239,
0.2728349864,
-0.02379716,
-0.0067599155,
-0.5778993368,
-1.0208638906,
0.8057587147,
0.703089118,
-0.5789746642,
-0.070313558,
-0.0454885848,
0.6060234308,
-0.3365905881,
0.4381967187,
0.3819693029,
0.2795225978,
0.1739804745,
-1.0492662191,
-0.1098901555,
-0.2273475975,
-0.0921176076,
0.3969994187,
-0.2471074611,
0.8163759112,
-0.0508377068,
-0.4761181772,
0.1255203485,
0.4739314914,
-0.1303918511,
-0.2014809102,
0.5217267275,
0.8297125101,
0.7812345028,
0.1299672574,
1.1316684484,
-0.315133512,
0.5193409324,
0.9907454848,
0.117535606,
1.067188859,
0.1207439601,
-0.4605909884,
0.3967238069,
0.6661031842,
0.3277881145,
0.320546478,
0.5213723183,
-0.0612162687,
-0.5187594295,
-0.103203252,
-0.4949585199,
0.2294213176,
0.2584024966,
-0.4538702667,
-0.0632655621,
-0.3070713878,
0.0180444401,
0.1194219887,
-0.6727258563,
0.8663994074,
0.2152448744,
-0.7306690812,
1.1684113741,
0.0697074831,
0.8449293375,
-0.5652213693,
0.1769588739,
-0.0415096916,
-0.2686926723,
-0.2500050068,
-0.8947174549,
0.3360039592,
0.0892589763,
-0.3822287023,
-0.1967499554,
0.5159688592,
-0.4013243318,
-0.5547610521,
0.1628780216,
0.2564204931,
0.5621015429,
-0.0818752572,
-0.3428666294,
0.1217174307,
-0.3354726732,
-0.2372823209,
0.2908868194,
0.1970823407,
0.2408230454,
0.8023770452,
0.6178885698,
0.301202029,
-0.0314880945,
0.1303413063,
0.631208241,
-0.8138833046,
-0.567769289,
-1.0790046453,
0.0279207602,
-0.1521807313,
0.0516852885,
0.580868721,
0.5890942812,
0.9069372416,
0.0167897008,
0.5464772582,
0.1431633681,
0.4523793161,
-0.8710220456,
0.457374543,
-0.4589494467,
0.2457772791,
-0.305778116,
-1.0659813881,
-0.3888635039,
0.5716087818,
-0.4862022698,
-0.1387506425,
0.6019910574,
0.6475946307,
-0.0013683219,
-0.1471552402,
0.6164767146,
0.3231936097,
0.0899356678,
0.9542110562,
0.8023298979,
-0.2028173655,
0.4054930508,
-0.0804235414,
-0.2099080533,
-0.0662510097,
-1.1006984711,
-0.9345294237,
-0.5328329206,
-0.1763118654,
-0.1588036418,
-0.120785363,
0.9746541977,
0.8890287876,
-0.4945555329,
-0.2699937522,
0.0728584677,
0.2907279432,
0.0609786361,
-0.1875529289,
0.2359351069,
-0.2214549035,
-0.6876807213,
0.3195359707,
0.2729943991,
0.096395418,
-0.3537230492,
-0.2329123169,
0.0312947407,
0.1313389689,
0.7757416368,
-0.0229262952,
-0.5719662905,
-0.3122793436,
-0.3996492922,
-0.0383035392,
0.0606640652,
0.8127322197,
-0.8636779785,
0.2362241149,
0.7975397706,
0.6036482453,
0.4452373981,
0.038827993,
0.5077098012,
-0.6102496386,
0.2103954703,
0.2009783536,
0.4326053858,
0.509663403,
-0.4707400799,
0.6866272092,
-0.0997220576,
-0.7930257916,
-0.8063516617,
0.3271914423,
-0.8400925398,
-0.3942892551,
1.1062479019,
-0.3346022964,
-0.0066261077,
0.2836858928,
-0.0824819952,
0.1460619718,
-0.2606807947,
0.6378048658,
0.960934937,
-0.0992521644,
-0.3574638665,
-0.5719419718,
0.4124191999,
0.1157917976,
-0.508769989,
-0.0305907894,
0.463734597,
0.0154902721,
0.2643233538,
0.5419465899,
-0.0278768968,
-0.1977379173,
-0.3317924738,
0.038545426,
0.0871962309,
-0.2805953324,
-0.6420243979,
0.2941240072,
0.4472635686,
0.4120695591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14167v1 | Definition generation for lexical semantic change detection | 2024-06-20T10:13:08 | 2024-06-20T10:13:08 | Mariia Fedorova, Andrey Kutuzov, Yves Scherrer | cs.CL | cs.CL | We use contextualized word definitions generated by large language models as
semantic representations in the task of diachronic lexical semantic change
detection (LSCD). In short, generated definitions are used as `senses', and the
change score of a target word is retrieved by comparing their distributions in
two time periods under comparison. On the material of five datasets and three
languages, we show that generated definitions are indeed specific and general
enough to convey a signal sufficient to rank sets of words by the degree of
their semantic change over time. Our approach is on par with or outperforms
prior non-supervised sense-based LSCD methods. At the same time, it preserves
interpretability and allows to inspect the reasons behind a specific shift in
terms of discrete definitions-as-senses. This is another step in the direction
of explainable semantic change modeling. | [
-0.5146170259,
-0.5462408662,
0.5611825585,
0.0620940514,
-0.4283154309,
-0.3850653172,
-0.3000785708,
-0.5008679628,
0.16177091,
0.3350934684,
-0.6237328649,
-0.5876218081,
-0.53753829,
0.3619852364,
-0.7944275141,
0.8336194754,
-0.3072615862,
-0.3755064905,
0.0391564146,
-0.1349654049,
-0.4276440442,
-0.1408777833,
-0.3349876702,
-0.5151415467,
0.7474015951,
0.0577073544,
0.7145397067,
0.6870948076,
0.3180437684,
0.2922306359,
-0.3671364784,
0.0800614282,
-0.0338523984,
0.2543581426,
-0.3870889843,
-0.2610465884,
-0.1447148621,
-0.0956496596,
0.7659049034,
0.9835433364,
-0.1278674453,
0.0624695234,
-0.0414223857,
0.3982674479,
-0.8324106932,
0.3302233517,
-1.1529949903,
0.0307686068,
-0.4249828756,
-0.3511117101,
-0.2632471025,
-0.0103749027,
0.066060774,
-0.5491628051,
0.5341881514,
-0.4665527344,
0.8866752982,
0.2398132831,
-0.3392174542,
-0.5251203179,
-0.563678503,
0.6046109796,
-0.6329557896,
0.7176332474,
0.133554548,
0.4089700878,
-0.1634622961,
-0.9193839431,
-0.8268018961,
-0.208874166,
0.0141519243,
0.1147754937,
-0.1483996212,
-0.0780711845,
0.3534885049,
0.1335259378,
-0.10845761,
0.0418217368,
-0.1278201342,
-0.3476894796,
0.5018565655,
0.2517288327,
0.1066154763,
-0.293515116,
-0.3202151954,
-0.2229878753,
-0.8596878052,
-0.1007531807,
-0.1066704914,
0.3467324078,
-0.017605463,
0.5550259948,
-0.5303491354,
0.7019153833,
0.0451002978,
-0.0003105338,
0.262334913,
-0.6405724287,
-0.3265880048,
0.4546794295,
0.2225441486,
0.5604007244,
0.1534350961,
-0.1518648267,
-0.2791021466,
0.6054152846,
-0.0267167818,
-0.8404303193,
-0.2390394062,
-0.205652222,
-0.316862464,
-0.4395089149,
0.0429024659,
-0.4326225221,
-0.4104212821,
-0.6409586668,
0.0139049459,
-0.4536691904,
-0.3630417585,
0.3465220034,
-0.2199936509,
0.4058350921,
0.3181381524,
-0.9854519963,
0.0706228465,
0.4829526544,
0.5362423062,
-0.360247463,
-0.1772819012,
-0.1014815122,
0.1189816371,
-1.027510643,
0.8608188629,
-0.2553240061,
-0.4497965872,
0.0293887202,
0.1101609543,
0.1770772785,
-0.6785941124,
-0.0951838121,
-0.6256184578,
0.011590044,
-0.4308675826,
-0.4665334225,
0.1190828308,
0.1699224263,
-0.3062909544,
1.0990546942,
0.3084838986,
-0.742094934,
1.183598876,
-0.4787476957,
-0.2646448612,
0.4226179123,
-0.0265641157,
-0.1047321036,
0.3380486965,
-0.0392174684,
0.3384726346,
0.0533529669,
0.4977835715,
0.1328710169,
-0.0012233225,
0.3844235241,
-0.0700027123,
0.480989188,
0.4793792963,
-0.2198682576,
0.1200113595,
-0.8312279582,
0.139515996,
-0.0005302493,
-0.3936811984,
-0.617970705,
0.4388816655,
0.1852548271,
0.1798682213,
0.2366744429,
-0.7022061944,
-0.1907373667,
-0.5309663415,
0.5195585489,
0.7127552629,
0.0970410556,
0.2060611099,
0.1132417694,
0.1015622914,
0.5191977024,
-0.0341765508,
-0.2920197248,
-0.3808290362,
-0.8123979568,
0.1012077332,
0.3595743477,
0.1294251829,
-0.7871361375,
0.647053957,
-0.2336896807,
-0.3734598756,
-0.1287844032,
-0.0180029459,
0.0592466742,
0.5525411963,
0.5304973125,
-0.1616618484,
-0.4326922596,
-0.7857337594,
-0.1866278648,
-0.2379853874,
-0.1450136304,
-0.0467105545,
0.514520824,
-0.692075491,
1.3097504377,
-0.5489808917,
0.0780404434,
-0.1588950157,
-0.0086616436,
-0.2157099396,
0.1028226241,
0.3691703677,
-0.8568331599,
-0.0047044293,
0.0526030138,
-0.714196384,
-0.7605121732,
-0.3007401526,
0.0718515962,
0.0986191258,
1.034906745,
-0.2506436706,
0.5268346667,
0.3275944293,
-0.6406664848,
0.7481992245,
-0.0178915784,
-0.0592687465,
-1.2358636856,
-0.2043336034,
-0.3148281276,
-0.1893491,
-0.5896821618,
0.3425869346,
0.1568091214,
0.0210311338,
-0.7372518778,
0.4989388883,
-0.2946306467,
-0.2708152831,
-0.2023676038,
0.705219388,
-0.0158347841,
-0.1603342891,
0.1926901191,
0.3519791663,
0.4332516491,
-1.0050854683,
0.4699080586,
0.252826184,
-0.5742617249,
0.5717263222,
-0.5887153149,
-0.2837954164,
-0.2633131742,
0.1215987653,
-0.9362889528,
-0.0593004264,
-0.0726966634,
-0.3316172063,
-0.1671601832,
0.3664311171,
-0.4409579933,
-0.2613545954,
-0.0102038924,
0.4731824398,
0.084346503,
-0.6044331789,
0.1630758792,
0.1383846849,
0.2237687111,
0.1040358394,
-0.8533517718,
0.2203753889,
-0.2561094761,
-0.6000431776,
0.7867003679,
-0.0261044819,
-0.6428455114,
0.2083170861,
-0.1903542578,
0.2907927036,
0.301039964,
0.1752541214,
0.1060084477,
-0.1894486994,
0.6508350372,
0.1992694438,
-0.2789584696,
0.058067251,
-0.0264230948,
0.6218984723,
0.1670797616,
-0.1985608935,
-0.240926519,
0.237761423,
0.2239648551,
-0.2786494493,
0.6417229176,
0.6567834616,
-0.5651627183,
-0.2885919511,
-0.3229168952,
-0.2645957768,
-0.4306499064,
0.2377558202,
-0.5473116636,
-0.8981499076,
0.7115417123,
-0.2529249191,
0.0307986606,
0.7042393684,
0.820957005,
0.2822143734,
0.9565848112,
0.4770608842,
0.4234363735,
0.6345584989,
0.0612502769,
0.1430497915,
-0.9688786268,
-0.1321773827,
-0.3112792671,
-0.1720433384,
-0.9211159348,
-0.3857136667,
0.4403757155,
0.2508043349,
-0.2303672284,
0.3878400922,
-0.482965529,
0.2152604163,
0.1251082122,
-0.0728937909,
0.2403618991,
-0.2434597164,
-0.3468821645,
-0.0752948076,
-0.2630391717,
-0.276175797,
0.8288015723,
-0.0018158382,
0.5953920484,
0.1612355113,
0.8700585961,
0.3613089621,
0.1895257235,
-0.7969765663,
0.7514243722,
0.00523081,
-0.0541212037,
-0.1020399705,
-0.2234602422,
-1.1244841814,
0.2903331518,
-0.349830091,
-0.6352042556,
0.2064021528,
-0.0154452734,
0.0516040958,
0.0392002687,
-0.3670275807,
0.661994338,
0.1552632451,
0.0734156966,
-0.4406626225,
-0.2633258998,
0.2789127231,
-0.2691727281,
-0.0550212339,
-0.3820622861,
-0.1575242728,
0.8616636395,
-0.6583173871,
0.6118471622,
-0.2495097965,
-0.2987063825,
0.3468890488,
0.3004809022,
0.2491962016,
-0.0164523553,
-0.1020302922,
0.0879999995,
0.4065054953,
-0.1320547611,
-0.4133705497,
0.8541508913,
-0.3848129511,
-0.294474721,
-0.2649765313,
-0.5313410759,
-0.0129803615,
0.2142883986,
0.3365604877,
0.6281152964,
-0.3090860844,
-0.001902065,
0.3943529725,
-0.4100506306,
0.4627564251,
0.6693223119,
-0.4473218322,
0.2835494876,
0.5755916238,
-0.0470662266,
0.4867494702,
0.1399205327,
0.4970101714,
-0.3720299602,
-0.3600215614,
-0.3203386664,
-0.017289076,
-0.7709418535,
-0.071267724,
-0.0994947255,
-0.1911788434,
-0.4355309904,
-0.4201898873,
-0.204824239,
-0.2145867348,
-0.143943429,
0.0054946598,
0.3196662962,
0.6881076694,
-0.0968584418,
0.2103183717,
-0.2577347159,
0.5549435616,
0.2879742384,
0.1565185934,
-0.2640713453,
-0.2499773353,
-0.1110539064,
0.1732842177,
-0.1276863515,
-0.9845827222,
0.4257175922,
0.4191677272,
0.4322170913,
0.6615096331,
-0.0638800934,
0.6522403955,
-0.3901597857,
1.0627105236,
0.2194241285,
-1.0443233252,
0.8816914558,
-0.1523750275,
0.8618553877,
0.1708050072,
-0.0598561876,
-1.0292454958,
-0.3624403775,
-0.3725086451,
-0.7364311814,
0.4162048697,
-0.2269401103,
0.2523091137,
-0.6735126972,
0.467854321,
0.042938713,
0.0787485763,
-0.2708170116,
0.0364433564,
-0.1977559626,
-0.0362340957,
-0.084648028,
-0.3155979514,
0.0348096378,
-0.1460530907,
0.2526388168,
-0.3102919459,
0.3001470268,
0.3181098402,
-0.3312168717,
-0.0051017758,
0.4435760379,
0.5701627135,
0.8812562823,
0.0852192044,
0.4475080371,
0.2782408893,
-0.4415267706,
-0.1862245351,
-0.1913805753,
-0.3216838539,
0.2059656531,
0.4732765257,
0.6646201611,
0.5303418636,
-0.7319321036,
0.3185510933,
0.2289007455,
-0.2881602943,
-0.3115932345,
-0.0420054086,
0.0426145643,
-0.0445654429,
0.1519791037,
-0.2147923559,
0.023679249,
-0.5957399011,
0.4464556873,
0.4299661815,
-0.3844819367,
-0.4060693681,
0.6677212715,
-0.1804324687,
0.1801407039,
0.7218325138,
-0.4188835323,
-0.4618086517,
0.4719513953,
0.8366163373,
0.7323672175,
-0.3859968185,
0.2756890059,
0.2540677786,
-0.1623718888,
0.1162872091,
0.083740972,
-0.4177613556,
-1.5551557541,
-0.1751411259,
-0.9381937981,
-0.0187503733,
0.052512385,
-0.8989301324,
0.457775414,
-0.3567733765,
-0.1893007457,
0.4240200222,
-0.4566991925,
-0.5726637244,
0.2722143233,
0.472258538,
0.9296985865,
-1.0048518181,
0.7731801271,
0.5897144675,
-0.07397715,
-0.5443810821,
-0.0542072169,
0.0453226045,
-0.8631273508,
0.8288835287,
-0.0379282981,
-0.2891138494,
0.0844016522,
-0.3333880603,
-0.6232982278,
1.1518981457,
-0.1513093561,
-0.504178822,
0.0381363928,
0.2844285071,
0.7751236558,
-0.3724721372,
-0.0421965159,
0.8971871734,
0.5421285033,
0.1560805887,
-0.7130070925,
-0.00897648,
-0.0599848479,
0.3949804008,
0.5635095239,
0.1685731709,
0.8565424681,
-0.2145567685,
-0.6977140307,
-0.0042075496,
0.5065500736,
-0.0049028546,
0.3786327839,
0.7069994211,
0.6395393014,
0.5477607846,
-0.3556648195,
0.9395697117,
-0.5090867877,
0.2581851482,
0.8002027273,
-0.1492138505,
0.8124681711,
0.5025390387,
-0.1228936315,
0.6870979071,
0.8393881917,
0.1106318608,
0.7096199989,
0.3241482079,
-0.4468653798,
-0.4563581347,
-0.3556528389,
-0.3456509113,
0.6866833568,
0.7448194027,
-0.5229492188,
-0.8593143821,
0.0709479377,
-0.0168107729,
0.155151546,
-0.7055311203,
0.928556025,
-0.0833559036,
-0.5747340918,
0.8639385104,
0.2349007726,
0.5251868367,
-0.5861101747,
0.1237018853,
-0.0253994111,
0.3019783199,
-0.1714172661,
-0.812118113,
0.6175137162,
-0.3041498661,
-0.1045053676,
-0.2849555612,
0.6386129856,
-0.6098354459,
-0.4904346168,
0.4546888173,
0.4919809401,
0.1655113399,
0.0128314979,
-0.6007755399,
0.186773017,
-0.2501915097,
-0.0156511329,
0.334194392,
0.3895887434,
-0.7618083358,
0.3442587852,
0.512327373,
0.2405294031,
0.2105390877,
0.3600950241,
0.8285162449,
-0.5743159652,
-0.574709475,
-0.6545180678,
0.0237428453,
0.2574179173,
-0.539040029,
0.4957389534,
0.2990169823,
0.9911607504,
0.0186921507,
0.5805640221,
-0.3909516633,
0.2867025435,
-0.666983068,
0.435701102,
-0.4957306683,
0.1457486749,
-0.1712754965,
-0.9473814368,
-0.3794939518,
0.5278957486,
-0.2772055864,
-0.2547349334,
0.8324372768,
0.9509526491,
0.0891349167,
-0.0490457229,
0.3101581931,
0.331145376,
0.395757854,
0.4517084658,
0.6773033142,
-0.2197964638,
-0.0752651021,
-0.0498790592,
-0.1507798433,
-0.005725598,
-0.9816781282,
-0.3809756935,
-1.1484071016,
-0.4529445171,
-0.3087927401,
0.0438747928,
0.5443133116,
0.3667010367,
-0.967361927,
0.0652418882,
-0.4055261612,
-0.005988027,
-0.486382097,
-0.2960339487,
0.3651308417,
-0.5372266173,
-0.4581777453,
0.5351582766,
0.0369276591,
-0.1919732094,
-0.3710727096,
0.1341989636,
-0.0429055505,
0.167843014,
1.042335391,
0.0324114785,
-0.9329929352,
-0.7638904452,
-0.418905437,
-0.0034414427,
-0.2980564237,
0.8340411186,
-1.07418859,
0.58641994,
0.6486930251,
0.1132555604,
0.535428226,
0.0045704828,
0.1449489444,
-0.6595421433,
0.3068071306,
-0.3028140366,
0.2664173841,
0.4668161571,
0.14371939,
0.3630721271,
0.4880902171,
-0.1416374892,
-0.6016351581,
0.6042888165,
-1.0441646576,
-0.2575859129,
1.2669812441,
0.1239833087,
-0.1042810231,
-0.0843143612,
0.1043676063,
0.2174997628,
0.0780425146,
0.8043946028,
0.4139981866,
-0.170678705,
0.1015304625,
-0.3171862662,
0.7374343276,
-0.1119410843,
-0.5919960737,
0.1446892768,
0.602686882,
0.5083166361,
0.3327015042,
0.389349252,
-0.4450521469,
0.2177384496,
-0.0864820778,
0.1893021166,
0.0752306059,
-0.152353242,
-0.0984999537,
-0.1867762804,
0.0101505015,
-0.1143119782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14164v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14164v1 | A Data-Driven Guided Decoding Mechanism for Diagnostic Captioning | 2024-06-20T10:08:17 | 2024-06-20T10:08:17 | Panagiotis Kaliosis, John Pavlopoulos, Foivos Charalampakos, Georgios Moschovis, Ion Androutsopoulos | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Diagnostic Captioning (DC) automatically generates a diagnostic text from one
or more medical images (e.g., X-rays, MRIs) of a patient. Treated as a draft,
the generated text may assist clinicians, by providing an initial estimation of
the patient's condition, speeding up and helping safeguard the diagnostic
process. The accuracy of a diagnostic text, however, strongly depends on how
well the key medical conditions depicted in the images are expressed. We
propose a new data-driven guided decoding method that incorporates medical
information, in the form of existing tags capturing key conditions of the
image(s), into the beam search of the diagnostic text generation process. We
evaluate the proposed method on two medical datasets using four DC systems that
range from generic image-to-text systems with CNN encoders and RNN decoders to
pre-trained Large Language Models. The latter can also be used in few- and
zero-shot learning scenarios. In most cases, the proposed mechanism improves
performance with respect to all evaluation measures. We provide an open-source
implementation of the proposed method at https://github.com/nlpaueb/dmmcs. | [
0.0928488895,
-0.4648218453,
0.8544707298,
0.0308003351,
-0.9406549931,
0.1690438688,
0.2493557185,
0.0953538939,
0.0738512129,
0.4094042182,
-0.7823365927,
-1.0763715506,
-0.5958405137,
0.513782382,
-0.4485851228,
0.9132415652,
-0.1482248157,
0.4532574117,
-0.3793325424,
0.1303665489,
-0.6102128029,
-0.224602133,
-0.6841063499,
-0.0566031486,
0.4916436672,
0.0964637846,
0.7763761282,
1.2449543476,
0.888907671,
0.1425791979,
0.09538614,
0.5883122087,
-0.2000876218,
0.2285120189,
0.1758823544,
-0.5026717186,
-0.4670788646,
-0.1549675316,
0.580291152,
0.5472549796,
-0.2532504797,
-0.2895299196,
-0.3492928445,
0.8203089833,
-0.3423644006,
0.7989467978,
-0.1597506255,
0.2855761647,
-0.03309948,
-0.9971167445,
-0.5649968982,
-0.3190736473,
-0.0582419671,
-0.8518961668,
0.3263031244,
0.0541510582,
0.7427707911,
0.6551962495,
-0.3190296888,
-0.4971867204,
-0.4564943612,
0.401920408,
-0.6472601295,
0.2313203663,
0.3156138659,
0.4624894857,
-0.0948284417,
-0.8212409616,
-0.3573503494,
-0.043110162,
-0.4700620174,
0.6417685747,
-0.338432163,
0.2799586058,
0.2383614033,
0.3405439854,
-0.6702427268,
0.0196837224,
-0.2353051454,
-0.0749963075,
0.6013915539,
0.7188129425,
0.2495538443,
-0.3351880908,
-0.2039843202,
-0.2247905731,
-0.7923719287,
-0.3900012076,
-0.3308858275,
0.1270978898,
-0.2422727793,
0.4916150868,
-0.3697479665,
0.9489631057,
0.2085833699,
-0.3713310063,
0.3976466358,
-0.4932959676,
-0.2675282359,
0.18886967,
0.6469528079,
0.7985380292,
-0.0459065065,
-0.1862182319,
-0.373403132,
0.2286740094,
0.0698233843,
-0.8032879233,
-0.3168485463,
0.1476077586,
-0.7741394043,
-0.8257642984,
-0.0347713344,
-0.7517492771,
-0.8183797598,
-0.1209950522,
-0.0025574849,
-0.3769535422,
-0.0248655472,
0.4026389122,
-0.1538608521,
0.1141732708,
0.0699526966,
-0.5485521555,
0.1921585798,
0.2446017414,
1.0228978395,
0.0012696075,
0.3113884926,
-0.9823606014,
0.1977464557,
-0.4874685407,
0.8161167502,
-0.6438270807,
-0.5714040399,
0.1119570881,
-0.0038924236,
-0.0850225016,
-0.5444760323,
0.3624660373,
-0.5827538967,
0.0339721031,
0.0523721948,
-0.5138860345,
-0.0638760179,
0.0546695553,
-0.8825551271,
0.2671613395,
0.1921473593,
-0.7740312219,
0.4496265352,
-0.7042152882,
-0.8274818659,
0.3601226211,
-0.5703034401,
-0.6915434003,
0.0229690205,
0.8156511188,
0.8085193038,
-0.4189577699,
0.2689890265,
0.1565260589,
-0.3948103189,
0.0887167305,
-0.3847586513,
0.3980674744,
0.2440751195,
-0.1862144023,
0.0428213514,
-0.9460918903,
-0.1302006394,
0.5521125793,
-0.3948532045,
-0.0826637372,
0.4335203767,
-0.4517106414,
-0.0962000787,
-0.1773243099,
-0.4959565401,
0.2291011363,
-0.7274321914,
0.5390625596,
0.4067688584,
0.3799307644,
0.1801758409,
-0.4479456842,
0.8941349983,
0.3666531444,
0.0273302905,
-0.6316528916,
-0.5185647011,
-0.3484565318,
-0.5214583278,
0.2039472014,
0.535428524,
-1.2555546761,
0.3959052563,
-0.3169817328,
-0.3025055528,
-0.8744856119,
-0.4218319356,
0.5749056339,
0.850646615,
0.405641377,
-0.0827637017,
-0.380076468,
-0.6036702394,
0.4159756005,
-0.0158616938,
0.0290744845,
0.5376809835,
-0.1474706531,
-0.358392477,
0.5943038464,
-0.8528330326,
-0.641377449,
-0.2122729868,
-0.0183247458,
0.3439943492,
0.3428542018,
0.608735919,
-0.7265886664,
-0.3925692737,
0.2409098148,
-0.8539068103,
-0.1473107487,
-0.5047547817,
0.0813337788,
0.4406836629,
0.7016809583,
-0.5977714062,
0.8803249598,
0.5583690405,
-0.2340034544,
0.5285571218,
-0.5005467534,
0.1825612932,
-1.1685805321,
0.1224129871,
-0.0622195005,
-0.3461442292,
-0.2811303437,
-0.0308291465,
0.1438545585,
-0.1000780389,
-0.1118669659,
0.2274160534,
-0.6335992217,
0.3300347924,
-0.3308410645,
0.2591679394,
0.3923477232,
0.0225513931,
0.2101391107,
0.4999203384,
0.9856042266,
-0.5027609468,
0.626075983,
0.5227577686,
-0.3262901306,
0.4575845897,
-0.5880535245,
0.147367835,
-0.5166483521,
0.353795886,
-0.9003602266,
-0.1323901117,
0.4437245131,
-0.4329962432,
0.6121047139,
-0.2421792895,
-0.7926781774,
-0.5538959503,
0.07905031,
0.4417753816,
0.6283319592,
-0.7028990984,
0.1704088598,
-0.0898081064,
-0.0741978586,
-0.2597935796,
-0.6300681233,
0.2064328492,
-0.0282542612,
-0.5134290457,
0.3982065916,
-0.1231252104,
0.1577777714,
-0.0444218628,
-0.1072195172,
-0.154789418,
0.1154460087,
0.2265100777,
0.4506175518,
-0.1140990555,
0.2575609386,
0.5318216085,
-0.37510553,
0.1520956755,
-0.2514281869,
0.4031077027,
0.3056516945,
-0.1942280084,
-0.6777467132,
0.5842763186,
0.4934998453,
-0.6002104282,
0.4594014883,
0.2408771366,
-0.2930389941,
-0.2612624168,
0.1302627176,
-0.2876576185,
-0.4980012178,
0.3829577565,
-0.2205935866,
-0.3909050226,
0.3702142239,
-0.0407572649,
-0.263063103,
0.1891272366,
0.5727760792,
-0.2256950289,
1.673157692,
0.4811830819,
0.2949849665,
0.0200463086,
-0.2152092308,
0.5121729374,
-0.4594705403,
-0.3719785213,
-0.1821491718,
-0.08323057,
-0.2349407822,
-0.2899221182,
0.5032229424,
-0.2094864249,
0.4876272976,
-0.0883961692,
-0.9934672117,
0.3344950974,
0.2945367396,
0.4016363621,
0.4706251323,
-0.0111022973,
-0.2969839573,
0.0017988526,
-0.8191192746,
-0.3124976754,
1.0556838512,
0.1381841302,
0.9031491876,
-0.2770729065,
0.8398141861,
0.3105324507,
0.256722182,
-0.9396618009,
0.3959354162,
-0.4144484401,
-0.2648009658,
0.2041994184,
-0.4960196316,
-1.1260607243,
-0.3034861088,
-0.009971993,
0.017571114,
0.03354818,
0.2448363751,
-0.6202673316,
0.0014585445,
-0.5644236207,
0.5244405866,
-0.0376236364,
0.2833225429,
-0.1573508233,
-0.82581985,
0.0564428344,
-0.1344871819,
-0.0029689879,
0.2753945887,
0.2150136381,
0.7174026966,
-0.2350947559,
0.6878032684,
-0.404961437,
-0.1147820577,
-0.0164019726,
0.1779117435,
0.3609271646,
0.3394061029,
0.1946159601,
-0.104724437,
0.3492233455,
-0.1366881877,
-0.7898514271,
0.3937994242,
-0.1312508881,
-0.4854311049,
-0.3739739954,
-0.7089316845,
-0.10841728,
0.4361099303,
0.288184613,
0.9299475551,
0.1505961716,
-0.0752300397,
0.5742955208,
-0.3543199897,
0.364539355,
0.667368412,
0.0158977546,
-0.2779773772,
0.7545769215,
-0.2277278751,
0.0969515592,
0.611664474,
0.1262432337,
-0.075470075,
-1.1486775875,
-0.495764941,
0.4796159565,
-0.802113533,
-0.8178380132,
-0.2003866136,
-0.0855336338,
-0.3229865432,
-0.2547458708,
-0.1081065238,
0.043341279,
-0.6473587751,
-0.226663515,
0.4295111299,
0.7487995028,
0.0459437035,
0.2467553318,
-1.0695747137,
0.4838705063,
-0.3079403937,
0.5032923818,
-0.2494325042,
-0.1441389471,
-0.4380563498,
0.0615207516,
-0.0657587498,
-0.8754043579,
0.6166796684,
0.058483053,
0.4871086776,
0.6858295798,
0.3847310543,
0.5056357384,
-0.7621135712,
0.4912047982,
0.2828581929,
-0.6735547185,
0.9136226177,
-0.1301715821,
0.2251712084,
0.1760166287,
0.2680156827,
-0.2800579369,
-0.4448489547,
-0.1686711758,
-0.3799459636,
0.5979891419,
-0.0333415009,
-0.1018730775,
-0.3900718689,
0.5359364748,
0.0968766063,
0.0524936132,
-0.123427093,
-0.3769090772,
-0.1482231766,
-0.7034048438,
-0.0699200705,
-0.0669406652,
-0.4369021654,
-0.3555538058,
0.1758293211,
-0.4045869708,
0.5203089714,
0.7406585813,
-0.0624715462,
-0.0946594179,
-0.2249129862,
0.5873453021,
0.3380319178,
-0.2707425058,
-0.1435252875,
-0.6734411716,
-0.6002966166,
-0.0046101799,
0.4729723632,
-0.023999963,
0.257106483,
0.2281546146,
0.7459605932,
-0.2924084067,
-0.8460085392,
0.6604306102,
-0.3893333673,
-0.5798165798,
0.1060639471,
-0.1629468799,
-0.2550460398,
0.1881000996,
0.2137908936,
0.0738486648,
0.2236396819,
-0.0457892045,
0.5227794051,
0.2674805522,
-0.3330157995,
-0.3515764177,
0.679910779,
0.2982472181,
0.033221785,
0.9219351411,
-0.2951832116,
-0.2333576083,
0.5280203819,
0.578694582,
0.7883891463,
0.1670827717,
0.54582268,
0.1308788508,
0.195971787,
0.2823174,
0.4092648327,
-0.0476783477,
-0.4783380628,
-0.6056636572,
-0.318969667,
0.0424460098,
-0.2093388289,
-0.8464200497,
0.2728435397,
-0.5338453054,
0.0413834453,
0.1201115176,
-0.1305910498,
-0.6059724092,
0.5587818623,
0.4576694667,
0.8487049341,
-0.374476105,
0.8381900191,
0.5674716234,
-0.4022119641,
-0.6884580255,
0.0063656801,
-0.0813575089,
-1.0394380093,
0.3902085423,
0.2425181717,
-0.0270143561,
0.3362555802,
-0.3860818744,
-0.6171277761,
1.2715713978,
0.270167172,
-0.4627403319,
-0.3344216049,
0.0397160351,
0.5102279782,
-0.5886062384,
-0.1420113593,
0.6977276206,
0.3474165797,
0.0122662932,
-0.7365517616,
0.5223009586,
-0.3538426459,
-0.3300003111,
0.0210663453,
-0.1471078843,
0.254093945,
-0.5664904714,
-0.7336965799,
0.3062449992,
0.1267335564,
-0.011861586,
0.471070081,
0.1673052758,
0.4853153825,
0.7059764266,
-0.1974207163,
1.5157951117,
-0.3195598125,
0.1827589869,
0.5419465303,
-0.130088836,
0.1454700679,
0.3291287124,
0.0490408652,
0.3651911318,
0.5491678715,
-0.2879854441,
1.1753497124,
0.268920958,
-0.1263266504,
0.0055246898,
-0.046518907,
-0.308576256,
0.4121030867,
0.3743441701,
-0.9618880153,
-0.3169090152,
0.2026910931,
-0.0262056701,
0.2186618745,
-0.3387719095,
0.973613143,
-0.0285063125,
-0.3777609766,
1.0195173025,
-0.1192116365,
0.2945985198,
-0.4157195091,
-0.1810588986,
-0.2588312924,
0.0048897555,
-0.3452485204,
-0.7794927955,
0.3687253892,
-0.1705083698,
-0.3670601249,
-0.2040168792,
0.2798600197,
-0.2900005877,
-0.4769281447,
0.0905279517,
0.3344645202,
0.1013074294,
0.0049456428,
-0.4405336976,
0.0728508607,
0.1634121686,
0.1628939211,
-0.0915527269,
0.2542824745,
0.2524138391,
0.5623857975,
0.3842275739,
0.1588270813,
0.0002910295,
0.4271977842,
1.0134599209,
-0.5033395886,
-0.4708510041,
-0.5262269974,
0.4379210174,
0.1348586828,
-0.0139295803,
0.3587098122,
0.3365455568,
0.415515542,
-0.1974224001,
0.76680094,
0.0787581727,
0.4640853405,
-0.7469470501,
1.0160820484,
-0.5954569578,
0.1189537793,
-0.0631725416,
-0.4065469503,
-0.8893641233,
0.3921149075,
0.0707707107,
-0.3722417653,
0.9414611459,
0.8765105605,
0.3036550879,
-0.1866092533,
0.3756509423,
0.0144530535,
0.5267215371,
0.5167546272,
0.3455797732,
-0.2678095102,
0.6982379556,
-0.2611441612,
-0.4515496194,
0.0434092358,
-0.6626015306,
-0.9712136388,
-0.4725289643,
-0.694722116,
-0.3523907661,
-0.0006987883,
0.2685665786,
0.7594101429,
-0.4513103962,
0.4261335731,
-0.2798407376,
-0.032974381,
-0.4667876363,
-0.185783416,
0.5855540037,
-0.3078844845,
-0.6218054891,
0.6290819049,
0.3165797591,
0.1223987788,
-0.0781315491,
-0.1104231849,
0.4068838656,
-0.0187884085,
0.4111912549,
-0.103727214,
-0.3885544538,
0.1318254173,
0.1462414116,
-0.1035003588,
0.3700889945,
0.7259176373,
-0.9090386033,
0.9583789706,
0.138122052,
0.6587411165,
0.3049880564,
-0.0514088944,
0.6105977297,
-0.827711761,
-0.021744227,
0.5343158841,
0.1654493809,
0.3693172634,
-0.5929626822,
0.1374758333,
0.3612284362,
-0.2516694367,
-0.8584451675,
0.208518222,
-1.1157214642,
-0.0799128264,
0.917481184,
-0.1962412,
-0.0891761184,
0.1389545202,
-0.3533221483,
0.295573324,
-0.1959952712,
0.7440017462,
0.0974952653,
-0.0580062494,
-0.2255542427,
-0.0920244753,
0.6710569263,
0.1673591286,
-0.6497828364,
0.0286694635,
0.5648958683,
0.092019476,
0.0404019132,
0.453607589,
-0.5032801032,
0.7108612061,
-0.127858907,
-0.1901988387,
-0.4200441837,
-0.1990355551,
-0.5353515148,
-0.1602189392,
-0.2709160447,
-0.6457691789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14162v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14162v1 | DIRAS: Efficient LLM-Assisted Annotation of Document Relevance in Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-06-20T10:04:09 | 2024-06-20T10:04:09 | Jingwei Ni, Tobias Schimanski, Meihong Lin, Mrinmaya Sachan, Elliott Ash, Markus Leippold | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) is widely employed to ground responses
to queries on domain-specific documents. But do RAG implementations leave out
important information or excessively include irrelevant information? To allay
these concerns, it is necessary to annotate domain-specific benchmarks to
evaluate information retrieval (IR) performance, as relevance definitions vary
across queries and domains. Furthermore, such benchmarks should be
cost-efficiently annotated to avoid annotation selection bias. In this paper,
we propose DIRAS (Domain-specific Information Retrieval Annotation with
Scalability), a manual-annotation-free schema that fine-tunes open-sourced LLMs
to annotate relevance labels with calibrated relevance probabilities. Extensive
evaluation shows that DIRAS fine-tuned models achieve GPT-4-level performance
on annotating and ranking unseen (query, document) pairs, and is helpful for
real-world RAG development. | [
-0.6018494964,
-0.4941906929,
0.5158225298,
0.0262197461,
-0.4724750817,
-0.0298633892,
0.0200019889,
-0.4116773903,
0.4405029416,
0.5417011976,
-0.3454548419,
-0.3340333402,
-0.5487405658,
0.0960375145,
-0.2962597311,
1.0488584042,
0.0910843536,
-0.1229780689,
-0.3038504422,
-0.5083097816,
-0.3140360117,
-0.5900082588,
-0.4649278224,
-0.1350388825,
0.7649989724,
0.3845004141,
0.6229784489,
0.8128117919,
0.9286251068,
0.072374396,
-0.2759948075,
0.6149246097,
-0.5015038252,
0.4480170906,
-0.3104391992,
-0.2718237936,
-0.732771337,
0.2642172575,
0.807616353,
0.6479038596,
0.1912038773,
0.4738456011,
-0.0130779911,
0.7946874499,
-0.7147837877,
-0.0347545929,
-0.8518216014,
-0.2712570727,
-0.5307158232,
-0.7823976278,
-0.3608015776,
-0.3869046271,
-0.0834389627,
-0.9326270819,
0.4167610109,
0.410132885,
0.8835772276,
0.3917866349,
-0.2612704635,
-0.3024670184,
-0.4878839552,
0.5031558275,
-0.1709876209,
0.4413128495,
0.6285273433,
0.4912667572,
-0.072439909,
-0.7016044259,
-0.462939918,
-0.1146431342,
-0.1602957994,
-0.182723701,
0.2056879103,
-0.0161628481,
0.4881432354,
0.5491725802,
-0.2184147686,
-0.0939094201,
-0.185726285,
-0.0890040174,
0.3508121967,
-0.0824077055,
-0.0629831627,
-0.061147742,
-0.2936762273,
-0.0741855428,
-1.0165554285,
-0.3131210208,
0.370480895,
0.5659728646,
0.266194582,
0.7513132691,
-0.2273812443,
0.6458743215,
0.1549549699,
-0.0468489639,
0.2767644823,
-0.2556908727,
-0.0090719052,
-0.342159152,
0.3149402142,
0.1054385751,
-0.0334609821,
-0.5957752466,
-0.4384749234,
-0.2373432666,
0.4569238722,
-0.8678638935,
0.0735930875,
0.0794096515,
-0.2182748318,
-0.1944504082,
-0.1797799468,
-0.6844326854,
-0.5339558125,
-0.2971780002,
0.6242309213,
-0.2719476819,
0.1424117237,
-0.5873411298,
-0.1787987947,
-0.0330963433,
0.5543054938,
-0.6858142018,
0.2174310833,
0.7068127394,
0.7850280404,
-0.1139360145,
0.0327493027,
-0.9952668548,
0.3292820156,
-0.6007031202,
0.9819714427,
-0.6167185903,
-0.3810356855,
-0.0299451761,
-0.2324636579,
0.2131133825,
-0.5578258038,
0.9425576329,
-1.0337263346,
-0.1583254933,
-0.4249854684,
-0.5793204308,
-0.0988772362,
0.1559325904,
-0.7866404653,
1.0492565632,
0.3606888354,
-0.9357396364,
0.6534802914,
-0.462357223,
-0.3265589178,
0.3724986613,
-0.2476405799,
-0.1911403388,
-0.0336879268,
0.1547866464,
0.3986837864,
-0.6546106339,
0.297408849,
-0.0144008584,
-0.4906174242,
0.0407381281,
-0.0459862463,
0.1635130197,
0.4107720554,
-0.1124682724,
0.0298462678,
-0.7761346698,
-0.0869721994,
-0.0368245393,
-0.3341656327,
-0.4844253957,
-0.1618498266,
-0.0957780257,
-0.046914611,
0.3708560467,
-0.302852869,
0.2786746621,
-0.1805947572,
-0.2731793225,
0.6028417349,
0.2162975371,
0.6122114062,
-0.5266848207,
0.4736607373,
-0.1954872757,
-0.0726513043,
-0.1523810178,
-0.5101530552,
-0.7605924606,
-0.67920959,
0.5315418243,
0.162699163,
-0.7611095309,
0.159287855,
-0.4339409173,
-0.6089040637,
-0.4187841415,
0.1919339895,
0.3341709673,
0.6841043234,
0.4446224272,
-0.2816762328,
-0.4232067466,
-0.9471253157,
-0.3373319507,
0.0624474101,
-0.0836880133,
0.6377981901,
0.1645253748,
-0.3415690958,
0.8708980083,
-0.4077910781,
-0.6473658085,
0.0520800129,
0.2959466577,
0.1515671611,
0.158540532,
0.5822066069,
-0.9452500939,
-0.2802236974,
-0.0662932768,
-0.5023973584,
-0.4661982358,
0.0513128676,
-0.2349862754,
0.1744067818,
0.1021639258,
-0.5638619065,
0.356747061,
0.0800385922,
-0.045384679,
0.1321986765,
-0.3875674307,
0.4455322921,
-0.870939672,
0.4702521563,
0.1213816255,
-0.122462213,
-0.4099247158,
0.2473110855,
0.3818762004,
-0.0219608247,
0.0220752396,
0.8099337816,
-0.4395498037,
-0.3614444137,
-0.3029357493,
0.6291915178,
0.0084985569,
0.165142864,
-0.1558566689,
1.3185917139,
0.288600862,
-0.7532209158,
-0.2290367484,
0.1509943455,
0.186593771,
0.5541493297,
-0.1656725556,
0.1988684386,
-0.0306629948,
0.2210226804,
-0.6606664658,
-0.2119650394,
0.1261027306,
-0.2695017457,
0.5015483499,
-0.3317249417,
-0.7463380098,
-0.0052668699,
-0.4824883044,
0.336035043,
0.2527591586,
-0.7836088538,
0.6094918847,
0.7755282521,
-0.0408974849,
-0.7052533031,
-0.1647380441,
0.1223008782,
-0.2636095881,
-0.2984990478,
0.4023714066,
-0.0911618769,
-0.2220136821,
-0.2253912985,
-0.2420305461,
-0.1948233396,
0.1973737925,
0.4650071561,
0.1107591987,
0.0248805508,
0.2479059398,
0.2021140456,
-0.149345383,
-0.3870977759,
-0.0888176337,
0.2235181034,
-0.0422905982,
-0.2102320343,
0.0220780447,
0.1466031075,
0.2682555914,
-0.3154566884,
0.4128457308,
0.4056481719,
-0.4149031639,
-0.2458023578,
-0.7474120259,
0.020361932,
-0.4141466618,
-0.1546386182,
-0.6390578151,
-0.9509136081,
0.5461925864,
-0.2199311107,
0.1240684092,
0.8444983363,
0.2973908186,
0.0690206662,
0.5326239467,
0.5799928308,
0.1426712126,
0.3320996761,
-0.2346486747,
0.1911816597,
-1.2036937475,
-0.1004346088,
-0.8406442404,
-0.0534415431,
-0.5640135407,
-0.8915057182,
0.324409157,
0.2892383635,
-0.1723005325,
0.2918623686,
-0.6797865033,
0.3030339777,
0.5935618877,
-0.2608958185,
0.3577738404,
0.132333979,
-0.145910278,
-0.1187261492,
-0.4993677139,
-0.6872499585,
1.3440113068,
0.0844142288,
0.6199054122,
0.2377531379,
0.8007019758,
0.574886322,
0.6447172165,
-0.4014961123,
0.6429727674,
-0.0345380083,
-0.5545505881,
-0.1528958082,
-0.4471906126,
-0.7909058928,
0.3838013709,
-0.20003739,
-0.6541031599,
0.2321173847,
0.0062284861,
-0.2630965114,
0.1378158331,
-0.3852545619,
0.2080231309,
0.0964371338,
-0.4901270568,
-0.2384648919,
-0.4417178333,
-0.0438544489,
-0.592348218,
0.2393127233,
-0.243823126,
-0.3245480955,
0.8111220002,
-0.1615876704,
0.3678588271,
-0.1235463321,
-0.0418467261,
0.4057631493,
0.343542099,
0.5424777269,
0.1854801923,
-0.2569847405,
0.2026812732,
-0.1602821201,
-0.0604648627,
-0.3675852418,
0.9039081931,
-0.4061625302,
-0.7289022803,
-0.608445704,
-0.7357586622,
-0.3304828703,
0.3544318974,
-0.088969104,
0.2849160433,
0.2248114496,
0.0676978678,
0.7424824834,
0.1260745078,
0.0555230454,
0.4709880054,
-0.1703184843,
-0.4736628532,
0.9234514832,
0.503277421,
-0.2545399964,
0.4270420671,
-0.0524966642,
-0.2406314462,
-0.4985424578,
-0.5735323429,
0.2865262926,
-0.9325115085,
-0.57479316,
-0.809083581,
-0.0537728518,
-0.3413296938,
-0.3080921471,
-0.0871217847,
-0.8736436963,
-0.427062273,
-0.1045816988,
0.5658342838,
0.6885783076,
-0.1699308306,
-0.0519575477,
-0.5335233212,
0.6837592125,
0.1132018194,
0.6186493635,
-0.1536513716,
-0.698487699,
-0.265560627,
-0.1704575121,
-0.2873136997,
-0.5706881881,
0.1126997769,
0.1988429576,
0.6828235984,
-0.0489015095,
0.1300778836,
0.4818373024,
-0.4781278074,
0.7092421055,
-0.3738613129,
-0.5934592485,
0.6774202585,
-0.4844896793,
-0.1947441995,
0.6352185011,
0.379614532,
0.0238781404,
-0.255448103,
-0.6013470292,
-1.0891871452,
0.6776993871,
0.1314320266,
-0.0230588932,
-0.2934217155,
0.7890059948,
0.2825727463,
0.0939258486,
-0.3579597771,
-0.4015011191,
0.3018882275,
0.0679067001,
0.0957574248,
-0.6749224067,
-0.2800937593,
0.0128012253,
1.0182275772,
-0.2385593951,
0.0607219301,
0.3260886371,
-0.1071757451,
-0.3763536513,
0.0789023563,
0.4478771091,
0.7709976435,
-0.4755981863,
0.0759330988,
0.1577785313,
-0.4198592007,
0.16396375,
0.3379523158,
-0.4569930732,
0.1135394573,
0.0253791008,
0.4433114529,
0.0648181513,
-0.5736246109,
0.3668423295,
-0.1032477841,
0.1793412715,
-0.1076944917,
0.0734469816,
-0.2394330353,
0.301722616,
0.8036686182,
-0.1212538183,
0.3075696826,
-0.1020048633,
0.389914006,
0.5411290526,
-0.1956574023,
0.0806703717,
0.9875705242,
0.1589659601,
-0.2937415242,
0.0733776763,
-0.2296151519,
-0.1648547053,
0.2868405282,
0.2728265524,
0.8916158676,
0.1256902963,
-0.0582582578,
0.4030822515,
0.2568911612,
0.0710386634,
0.0800444409,
-0.4432012737,
-0.1565556228,
-0.0562745742,
-0.8182274699,
-0.7138524055,
-0.237927705,
-0.5123311281,
0.1540080309,
-0.3481970429,
-0.3777821064,
0.2210366726,
0.3369887769,
-0.7027567625,
0.4299682379,
-0.1737857312,
1.0000796318,
-0.3139818311,
0.8122267723,
0.6514964104,
-0.7457568645,
-0.4621082246,
0.1319981515,
-0.3989706933,
-0.5290791392,
1.102463007,
0.0401566513,
-0.3147013187,
0.0089521678,
-0.0838758051,
-1.0266584158,
1.3384319544,
0.376457274,
-0.1984692216,
0.2360779643,
0.024113996,
0.5829290152,
-0.3673842251,
0.404902637,
0.1965013891,
0.2686494887,
0.0096361451,
-0.8110787272,
0.1209734902,
-0.1611690372,
0.1777451038,
0.1800933629,
-0.5599220991,
0.6951787472,
-0.0846253633,
-0.2141789496,
0.2092037946,
0.6291174293,
0.2296092659,
0.3740420341,
0.2354274988,
0.6410694122,
0.853186667,
-0.1082287654,
1.1462521553,
-0.5644954443,
0.2981359065,
1.0484443903,
-0.361001879,
0.7866793871,
0.4896638393,
0.0135216732,
0.0000950473,
0.5280079246,
0.3765112758,
0.5516161919,
0.224455893,
-0.3651691079,
-0.117412217,
-0.3591113985,
-0.5110582709,
-0.0472442321,
0.4184596241,
-0.3887941539,
-0.2778645158,
-0.4758066535,
-0.0813295394,
0.03160882,
-0.1948153824,
0.7864669561,
-0.017409049,
-0.6265843511,
0.5854037404,
0.0949137658,
0.4493934512,
-0.4819613993,
-0.2121770382,
-0.5698626637,
-0.1017710716,
-0.0583563522,
-0.6652445197,
0.0799922645,
0.1388738006,
-0.2361350805,
0.0258567967,
0.9047320485,
-0.0687815174,
-0.2871730328,
0.2434268594,
0.4029392004,
0.2126606107,
-0.1011062339,
-0.1973695755,
0.0593366101,
-0.3078687191,
-0.4255210757,
0.6405850053,
0.6850176454,
-0.327676475,
0.7483528852,
0.6895056367,
0.1749261469,
-0.0455001332,
0.1867188513,
1.0407888889,
-0.5355658531,
-0.1967867315,
-0.2721222937,
0.0239163451,
-0.1786890924,
-0.2049621046,
0.774859488,
0.5910225511,
0.6137014031,
0.2078640908,
0.6221956015,
0.0209270306,
0.8879973292,
-0.238092795,
0.8226997256,
-0.6842290163,
0.5211135149,
-0.2171769887,
-1.2167619467,
-0.6022694111,
0.56573838,
-0.2593631744,
0.1368637085,
0.2779944241,
0.7555289865,
0.039457351,
-0.2416398972,
0.364503324,
-0.1440445781,
0.2624376714,
-0.1134744138,
0.3638657629,
-0.4966596961,
0.1431888193,
-0.401563406,
-0.175974384,
-0.4354737401,
-0.8478932381,
-0.6623559594,
-0.7089514732,
-0.2229322642,
-0.2754044831,
0.231333524,
0.7156473994,
0.4942098856,
-0.5582279563,
0.0939221978,
0.3931413293,
0.0134014878,
0.1175038218,
-0.1810845882,
0.6168042421,
-0.7205449939,
-0.4937400222,
0.3935801983,
0.4246501923,
-0.1248273775,
-0.083620958,
0.0590382591,
-0.3202147186,
0.2864061594,
0.3778594732,
0.1757619083,
-0.6503511667,
-0.4353131354,
-0.3195700943,
-0.2951722443,
0.1139112115,
0.7001259923,
-0.9285630584,
0.539290309,
0.293854326,
0.9439103603,
0.425549835,
0.2147220522,
0.1484255344,
-0.9570575953,
0.2008548379,
0.3469374478,
0.2949831188,
0.5227627754,
-0.5303837061,
1.1242138147,
0.1103534326,
-0.7199120522,
-0.960052073,
-0.1417123526,
-0.9337888956,
0.1160807163,
1.240252614,
-0.0650544763,
0.0115292287,
0.1721727103,
-0.3390067816,
0.2887205482,
-0.2605389059,
0.730822444,
0.2876351774,
-0.0170164648,
0.0935144275,
-0.7186815143,
0.6497809291,
0.364043057,
-0.6171523929,
0.1551051587,
0.7225681543,
-0.0235639177,
0.3773246109,
0.8590601087,
0.0089677228,
0.2539735436,
-0.0277118236,
0.0199409276,
-0.0130841024,
-0.3955623507,
-0.113164179,
0.2623656094,
0.5989300013,
-0.0240612384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14155v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14155v1 | Aligning Large Language Models with Diverse Political Viewpoints | 2024-06-20T09:53:23 | 2024-06-20T09:53:23 | Dominik Stammbach, Philine Widmer, Eunjung Cho, Caglar Gulcehre, Elliott Ash | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models such as ChatGPT often exhibit striking political
biases. If users query them about political information, they might take a
normative stance and reinforce such biases. To overcome this, we align LLMs
with diverse political viewpoints from 100,000 comments written by candidates
running for national parliament in Switzerland. Such aligned models are able to
generate more accurate political viewpoints from Swiss parties compared to
commercial models such as ChatGPT. We also propose a procedure to generate
balanced overviews from multiple viewpoints using such models. | [
-0.5047848821,
-0.4006489515,
0.6407297254,
0.027828414,
-0.4891405404,
0.1485122293,
-0.3660449982,
-0.1910338104,
0.2943909466,
0.85391289,
-0.6578546762,
-0.2953482866,
-0.6786344051,
-0.1571792811,
-0.2518491447,
1.0488357544,
0.3036475778,
0.2526390254,
-0.057439886,
-0.2359872162,
-0.135780558,
-0.6129072905,
-0.3540348709,
-0.7528108954,
0.4800724685,
0.3620480001,
0.876979053,
0.3508955538,
0.4457655549,
0.2723142803,
-0.0746872351,
0.1571034044,
-0.5601655245,
0.0790634379,
-0.6652644873,
-0.3430432677,
-0.2313906997,
-0.0202037487,
0.7947323918,
0.498559624,
-0.2450227588,
-0.17134206,
0.0901618376,
0.867665112,
-0.5362212062,
0.0688762218,
-0.708183825,
-0.1809030622,
-0.2427854091,
0.0310234856,
-0.3948450089,
-0.6195834875,
0.3171277344,
-0.1142368168,
-0.1037507281,
0.0021597624,
0.8612638116,
-0.030124845,
-0.7474253774,
-0.1599689424,
-0.5654620528,
0.8286697865,
-0.9456139207,
0.2506921887,
-0.0899519101,
0.3391056061,
-0.2058136761,
-0.115588747,
-0.553527832,
0.1299049556,
0.0410566106,
0.2467966974,
-0.039925281,
0.0002859891,
0.167261526,
0.2394212782,
-0.3993755877,
0.2784740329,
-0.12819767,
-0.0691989288,
0.7081793547,
0.1618571579,
0.1300989985,
-0.5358635783,
-0.551037848,
0.1051702052,
-0.832238555,
-0.2022259086,
0.9731581211,
0.6292465329,
-0.21702227,
0.9324606061,
-0.2835048735,
0.985974133,
0.4545707107,
0.1024194956,
0.0620727316,
-0.3165914416,
-0.1954578757,
0.1198471412,
1.0150078535,
0.6573674679,
0.3325814903,
0.3438329101,
-0.20846425,
0.0107093612,
0.0841852054,
-0.8411819935,
0.0041403524,
0.2692340314,
-0.3868621886,
-0.3935011029,
0.2477606386,
-0.9353502989,
-0.9828842878,
-0.4718234241,
0.0234889034,
-0.2122812867,
-0.5465505719,
0.2686300874,
-0.0426318757,
0.4584633112,
0.5889817476,
-0.9823443294,
0.1134353057,
0.8943417668,
0.6463803053,
-0.2028406709,
0.1399791539,
-0.408277005,
0.1563818008,
-0.2450080812,
0.9871323109,
-0.8190888166,
-0.0701023266,
0.1799026579,
-0.0601747446,
0.0529768206,
-0.5260930657,
0.4384089708,
-0.6466521025,
0.6132629514,
-0.6392635107,
-0.6702802777,
-0.1062985733,
0.5061365366,
-0.7489897609,
0.7657116652,
-0.0220251475,
-1.1741021872,
0.2942920625,
-0.6485687494,
-0.0965743065,
-0.1881915629,
-0.3950764835,
-0.1705387235,
0.1805527657,
0.2774783373,
0.4988154173,
-0.2607732415,
0.6457107067,
-0.3492344618,
0.1567750424,
0.3996500969,
-0.1892803013,
0.9858993292,
0.2189688385,
-0.2464962453,
0.531613946,
-0.6510877609,
-0.1920020431,
-0.300471127,
-0.4331006408,
-0.2598660886,
0.444822818,
0.2817848325,
0.4887265861,
0.353146553,
-0.5595568419,
0.3686793447,
-0.5981262326,
0.590246141,
0.9631865621,
-0.1247787178,
0.5528333187,
-0.3991795182,
0.4029831886,
0.2335921228,
-0.2433149964,
0.1338107437,
-0.3108884096,
-0.5645000339,
-0.1293078959,
0.3556014001,
0.8774600625,
-0.2805441618,
0.5492008924,
-0.4216758013,
-0.3928273618,
-0.3190640807,
0.0312768593,
-0.0000369146,
0.2189070433,
-0.2411339879,
-0.2274310142,
-0.6466524601,
-1.3318665028,
-0.4974399507,
-0.3975549638,
-0.1641763747,
0.3954193294,
0.5747163296,
-0.1488480419,
0.9081924558,
-0.1283593774,
0.0745389834,
-0.1661934108,
0.0027418013,
0.2933397889,
0.2810253799,
0.3288837671,
-0.7266767025,
-0.585586369,
0.4594601393,
-0.3570614755,
-0.198012203,
-0.0201039277,
-0.3221020699,
0.1130221039,
0.137048915,
-0.4756530225,
-0.1455327719,
0.7461542487,
-0.2398268431,
0.2669152021,
0.2971473038,
0.3061876893,
-1.5584079027,
-0.2513137758,
0.2123769075,
-0.5524898767,
-0.4322301745,
-0.1208017245,
-0.0091916341,
0.0071004224,
-0.5492325425,
0.5084485412,
-0.3929304183,
0.1160604805,
-0.2076267302,
0.5221998096,
-0.1259961873,
-0.1091470644,
0.2444260567,
0.558219254,
0.4531176388,
-0.002195722,
0.4896776378,
0.0464894772,
-0.7283409238,
0.7537125945,
-0.4142320454,
0.1483643204,
-0.172208339,
0.236845538,
-1.2193373442,
-0.626550436,
0.0240843296,
-0.0987945274,
0.3513680995,
-0.251989156,
-0.3752759993,
-0.020505758,
-0.2045326978,
-0.034511108,
0.3768148124,
-0.4722489417,
0.6933221221,
0.7265890241,
-0.2668701112,
-0.7943743467,
-0.4839290082,
0.208186388,
-0.3484221697,
-0.7714782357,
0.1213553771,
0.2384190112,
-0.6247714758,
0.0502909794,
0.0294563659,
0.0493762046,
-0.4419235289,
0.0126595441,
0.2287406325,
-0.3339070678,
-0.0657045394,
-0.2557981312,
0.2708899677,
-0.1939670891,
-0.2366444021,
0.7613067627,
-0.3002096117,
-0.49651438,
-0.4982947409,
0.5799138546,
0.7210741639,
-0.1471007317,
0.7080105543,
0.0541795865,
-0.2568135858,
0.051107917,
-0.9591882229,
0.0108607206,
-0.4368738234,
0.4114044905,
0.0425136611,
-1.2187767029,
0.8583689332,
-0.1194487736,
0.3387553394,
0.5661460757,
0.936760366,
0.0777181536,
1.1076524258,
0.6998288631,
-0.4209047854,
0.5595021844,
0.3275121152,
0.4248249829,
-0.5728969574,
-0.2620179355,
-0.6606448889,
-0.2484202683,
-0.825535953,
-0.3483153582,
-0.1244556829,
-0.2003593147,
-0.5188509226,
0.0448449738,
-0.652130425,
0.433668077,
0.3043132722,
0.0582249761,
-0.040461462,
0.1687985808,
-0.0481371842,
-0.2807310224,
-0.6245545149,
-0.9022263885,
0.8396709561,
0.1806564033,
1.1993473768,
0.1794205308,
0.7218008637,
-0.066835545,
0.5565410256,
-0.6562073827,
0.3369053304,
-0.1574207991,
-0.9087026119,
-0.1359798461,
-0.3750687242,
-0.3414556086,
0.3408848941,
-0.1760520339,
-0.7867056131,
0.2827025056,
0.0154412845,
-0.3165290058,
0.6397002935,
-0.5814577937,
0.7770989537,
-0.3589473665,
-0.4880124032,
-0.1841497123,
-0.6962661147,
0.6072244048,
-0.0640848726,
0.3285162151,
-0.3257895112,
-0.2231779695,
0.641049087,
-0.2111022472,
1.1186993122,
-0.1039903983,
-0.2860370874,
0.1350930482,
-0.3072008193,
0.3728498518,
-0.1088457406,
-0.5006093979,
0.167832613,
-0.1505806297,
-0.2607422769,
-0.307695508,
0.8911201954,
-0.8771646023,
-1.0336703062,
-0.5479357839,
-0.6421578526,
-0.0313975923,
0.1964635551,
0.2175275534,
0.041904591,
-0.5620477796,
0.3060495257,
0.5537170768,
-0.0924136639,
0.0864207447,
0.3244545758,
-0.2958289683,
-0.5351542234,
0.3987044096,
0.1152724922,
0.5375891328,
0.2956777513,
0.216141507,
-0.4476200044,
-0.3062407076,
-0.3435922563,
0.233409062,
-0.636531949,
-0.2204448134,
-0.4013085067,
-0.2764061093,
-0.1750263572,
-0.2825059295,
-0.4354060292,
-0.6133889556,
-0.007078419,
0.0128249256,
0.2852021456,
0.8312054276,
-0.0138494279,
0.6991391778,
-0.3347651064,
0.1141784191,
0.2734047174,
0.4256024063,
-0.4702152312,
-0.5140083432,
0.0814156681,
0.2427422255,
-0.4338130057,
-1.0770840645,
0.0539323501,
0.0601417422,
0.4979878962,
0.7750719786,
0.0275869276,
0.6755952835,
-0.7747591734,
1.1038542986,
0.473844856,
-0.8070733547,
0.730728507,
-0.5926264524,
0.1887461394,
0.5127283335,
0.3214456141,
-0.4319669604,
-0.6796110868,
-0.5166772604,
-0.693616569,
0.6714351773,
-0.0485422052,
0.478738606,
-0.1561925262,
0.2114008367,
0.0831866711,
0.2311931998,
-0.9358501434,
0.0882868618,
-0.2655252516,
-0.1903183311,
0.1441778839,
-0.4381005168,
-0.7102118134,
-0.1317171901,
0.9019291997,
-0.1175346896,
-0.0909798667,
-0.1244636849,
0.3821457922,
-0.1814881712,
0.5018706918,
0.6618095636,
1.0620609522,
-0.0327802487,
0.1791152954,
-0.1576167047,
0.0499575697,
0.1720073074,
-0.0408359244,
-0.1328524053,
0.0786583796,
0.2618160844,
0.7640625238,
0.0105294976,
-0.4552540481,
0.5051482916,
0.0275401901,
-0.3261111677,
-0.1609817892,
0.1260579675,
0.7595075965,
0.3970157504,
0.0041001099,
0.2004258186,
-0.3345261216,
-0.8174735904,
0.0953850895,
1.044988513,
-0.3919575512,
-0.141092211,
0.7894209623,
0.2774072289,
-0.4259449542,
0.4537329376,
0.2880991101,
-0.8092980981,
0.4933719337,
0.4439362288,
0.7827365398,
-0.5166593194,
0.0017353942,
0.4086359441,
0.4190145135,
-0.2622801065,
0.3684864938,
0.3311783671,
-0.8957317472,
-0.6364185214,
-0.6139390469,
-0.5698716044,
0.1683748513,
-0.5648820996,
0.5686224699,
-0.4916887283,
-0.4070664048,
0.2752133012,
0.2547160983,
-0.3781385124,
-0.1519087702,
0.1219910011,
0.7603130341,
-1.2234009504,
0.8540396094,
0.5659742951,
-0.0740276426,
-0.5274060965,
0.0113506475,
0.2027959228,
-0.7766439915,
0.4202310741,
0.0232070163,
-0.1574264914,
-0.4725216925,
-0.7945838571,
-0.6556802392,
0.4195110202,
0.7368547916,
-0.9396516681,
0.1914117485,
0.0844637007,
0.1741449088,
-0.6567839384,
-0.0760120675,
0.2900807559,
0.6882939935,
0.1295473576,
-0.7770702243,
-0.0919422656,
-0.1048380062,
-0.2270752937,
0.3642648757,
-0.8312241435,
0.7965707183,
0.0744992495,
-0.1635217369,
-0.2401098758,
0.437374413,
0.1761609763,
-0.2148494124,
0.5064632297,
0.4477755129,
0.8935406804,
-0.1685339659,
0.9514086246,
-0.4783917665,
0.1755628586,
1.1224198341,
-0.7067205906,
0.7684220672,
0.6368656754,
-0.1772879958,
0.552115798,
0.9097938538,
0.0077107409,
0.5012799501,
0.1921297759,
-0.575861752,
-0.5305775404,
-0.0623152852,
-0.3637073338,
0.2946294844,
0.3835876584,
-0.1332608312,
-0.338255614,
-0.3809417188,
0.1206127033,
0.4035829008,
-0.0782494247,
0.7472311854,
0.1632272601,
-0.8340390325,
0.1754816473,
0.0160431042,
0.590554297,
-0.6663051844,
0.0288572274,
0.0559492856,
0.1143797562,
-0.4602693021,
-1.1226438284,
0.3675082624,
0.1550892889,
-0.3278308809,
-0.2598323524,
0.575170815,
-0.5549008846,
-0.7431551814,
0.1215939596,
0.503308475,
0.0355454683,
0.1527710259,
-0.6877864599,
0.0763889179,
0.3023206294,
-0.3304746747,
0.4262176454,
0.6655793786,
-0.1658671051,
0.4375911951,
0.5249795318,
0.2511121631,
-0.0868734047,
0.1044046581,
1.0441198349,
-0.4609375596,
-0.4483433664,
-1.3309007883,
0.4659587145,
-0.5372215509,
-0.131886512,
0.7784851193,
1.0225926638,
0.6323727965,
0.1467930526,
0.934026897,
-0.0331074223,
0.4889818132,
-0.4420393705,
0.8253218532,
-0.4465375543,
0.2609043717,
-0.1180861145,
-0.8974135518,
-0.2403780371,
1.0264338255,
-0.4479406476,
-0.0937113091,
0.333255589,
0.8940003514,
-0.3313101828,
-0.013459933,
0.0898145512,
0.1652213633,
0.2120988518,
0.4589389265,
1.1367291212,
0.1525105089,
0.1491200477,
-0.0953664854,
-0.1119344011,
-0.0077637671,
-1.3970160484,
-1.0236270428,
-0.3738926053,
-0.3650640547,
-0.3540280461,
-0.0585324615,
0.9179764986,
0.8332311511,
-0.9097476602,
-0.6217694879,
0.3834649324,
0.3082403839,
0.3307637572,
-0.2413816899,
0.3978891373,
-0.0328022428,
-0.8148648739,
-0.1194004714,
0.3485654294,
-0.2156027406,
-0.3838384449,
0.1063461453,
-0.4680196047,
0.3977254927,
0.5268297791,
-0.0154795526,
-1.0023008585,
-0.7591019869,
-0.2758786976,
-0.252622962,
0.4217149019,
0.6987624764,
-0.3941736817,
0.4294419587,
0.5654408932,
0.364502728,
0.4951039553,
0.3685510755,
0.7583620548,
-0.5154096484,
0.2939049006,
0.326653868,
0.262675941,
0.6419625878,
-0.2701825202,
0.3284084201,
-0.1658021361,
-0.6053743958,
-0.7735777497,
0.3926491439,
-1.2062491179,
-0.0292119104,
1.1738073826,
0.1367420703,
-0.1523614228,
0.2786151171,
-0.3110080063,
0.0556459911,
-0.3131581247,
0.4822745025,
1.3996317387,
-0.3049313128,
-0.130102694,
-0.9868273139,
0.4073163867,
0.162248224,
-0.6868265271,
0.3150451779,
0.7370380759,
0.5320025682,
-0.0485197715,
0.7983798385,
-0.333951503,
-0.0171550568,
-0.3020966947,
-0.1450755149,
0.6253945827,
0.1558809727,
-0.4462969601,
0.1375987828,
0.066310294,
0.2701563239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14154v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14154v1 | Watching the Watchers: A Comparative Fairness Audit of Cloud-based Content Moderation Services | 2024-06-20T09:52:10 | 2024-06-20T09:52:10 | David Hartmann, Amin Oueslati, Dimitri Staufer | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | Online platforms face the challenge of moderating an ever-increasing volume
of content, including harmful hate speech. In the absence of clear legal
definitions and a lack of transparency regarding the role of algorithms in
shaping decisions on content moderation, there is a critical need for external
accountability. Our study contributes to filling this gap by systematically
evaluating four leading cloud-based content moderation services through a
third-party audit, highlighting issues such as biases against minorities and
vulnerable groups that may arise through over-reliance on these services. Using
a black-box audit approach and four benchmark data sets, we measure performance
in explicit and implicit hate speech detection as well as counterfactual
fairness through perturbation sensitivity analysis and present disparities in
performance for certain target identity groups and data sets. Our analysis
reveals that all services had difficulties detecting implicit hate speech,
which relies on more subtle and codified messages. Moreover, our results point
to the need to remove group-specific bias. It seems that biases towards some
groups, such as Women, have been mostly rectified, while biases towards other
groups, such as LGBTQ+ and PoC remain. | [
-0.5711351037,
-0.1921745837,
0.3426740766,
-0.1153674573,
-0.2266301662,
0.1055263504,
0.2558816075,
-0.6505909562,
0.3157378435,
0.5115206242,
-0.8741257191,
0.0261365827,
-0.9842057824,
0.2339106947,
-0.6975638866,
1.3680127859,
0.1551898569,
0.3106337786,
0.0630490854,
-0.0286740549,
-0.4488342404,
-0.2272918075,
-0.6069110036,
0.077400133,
0.5766670704,
0.0592480004,
0.634321034,
0.7337477207,
0.3735639155,
0.2991508543,
-0.1958124638,
0.0341070928,
-0.8661882877,
0.1231115535,
-0.3644713759,
-0.5495054126,
-0.2203360647,
0.1143516377,
0.2377652973,
0.0543371066,
-0.1039120778,
0.3606588244,
0.1710859537,
0.579348743,
-0.9871662259,
-0.1243214086,
-0.6442232728,
0.2808383405,
-0.2589602768,
0.0251970384,
0.0271709003,
-0.3950103521,
0.1869625598,
-0.5898509026,
0.4902514517,
0.1209307313,
0.4428203106,
0.5035690665,
-0.3097459078,
-0.5134294033,
-0.6446064115,
0.974545598,
-0.3149738014,
0.5791048408,
0.7092293501,
0.2558251619,
0.4812023342,
-0.5504629016,
-0.4659848809,
0.3699569106,
0.0784954801,
0.2910655737,
-0.4843352139,
-0.3296732903,
0.1571041048,
0.4986970425,
-0.2027986646,
0.2862465382,
-0.5320256948,
-0.5074239969,
0.693718195,
0.3048965335,
-0.0158671644,
-0.1598102748,
-0.070859611,
-0.1201208979,
-0.3373096883,
0.2565701306,
1.0422713757,
0.0651929826,
-0.2339485586,
0.36283952,
-0.0998135507,
-0.0152496183,
0.280495584,
-0.0551072434,
0.0364901386,
-0.1199475676,
-0.0536262654,
0.4618948996,
0.3398952186,
0.9560447335,
0.1005639508,
-0.2203054577,
-0.0014258316,
0.5031763315,
0.5839042068,
-0.8320729136,
-0.2603627443,
0.3301733732,
-0.5796899199,
-0.1962528378,
0.2002572119,
-0.9232134223,
-1.1216906309,
-0.1083286405,
0.1326546073,
0.204157427,
-0.2029635608,
-0.2764480114,
-0.4147578478,
0.064446114,
0.3982510865,
-0.6900594831,
0.4226781428,
0.9360730648,
0.8709767461,
-0.4942968488,
0.0889918283,
-1.0437101126,
-0.0442479663,
-0.2628813386,
0.3287368119,
-0.4097156227,
-0.1441066265,
0.2668143213,
0.0754593164,
0.5765274167,
-0.4011311531,
0.7796202302,
-0.5521536469,
0.1836658865,
-0.7141705155,
-0.5114868879,
-0.2006692737,
0.1395617574,
-0.7072733045,
0.4144474268,
-0.0743105486,
-0.787342608,
0.8667208552,
-0.4385303557,
-0.0576993488,
0.225331828,
-0.4388604462,
-0.5490950942,
0.0753350556,
0.2893203795,
0.2780306935,
-0.1463342756,
0.272105813,
-0.4474466145,
-0.3980822563,
0.2005511671,
-0.4087100029,
0.7848129272,
0.1653662175,
-0.9046753049,
0.2175418884,
-0.2413923442,
-0.1554589421,
-0.1067052707,
0.2759221494,
-0.1257560104,
0.4814459085,
0.2665500939,
0.3275819421,
-0.3144115806,
-0.7473820448,
-0.6446992755,
-0.0029450599,
0.5895656347,
1.3293147087,
-0.1563242823,
0.0298744198,
-0.6249164939,
0.6600927711,
0.1519479007,
0.6190286279,
0.1219018474,
-0.473294884,
-0.6419080496,
-0.3086826503,
-0.2443992645,
0.2538279593,
-0.4130690992,
0.0429565497,
-0.218082726,
-0.4426698983,
-0.5697566867,
0.2500893772,
0.5681369901,
0.1605408043,
0.2123271972,
-0.5484817624,
-0.4684970677,
-1.0824875832,
-0.4776870608,
-0.094682768,
0.1272105277,
0.4345515966,
0.4971901178,
-0.2823983431,
0.7247984409,
-0.1089072004,
-0.4737887383,
0.3358923793,
-0.2042579204,
-0.1561095864,
0.2403533757,
0.4290459454,
-1.0587103367,
-0.4931141138,
-0.2498545796,
-0.347383827,
-0.2907798886,
0.4952037036,
0.3601099551,
0.0973713547,
0.3702458441,
0.4894582927,
0.4340730011,
0.9568789005,
-0.704123199,
0.3857908845,
0.4839510024,
0.6071527004,
-0.5476789474,
-0.0965860114,
-0.1647738516,
-0.4144193828,
-0.5460712314,
-0.1312442422,
-0.1411121637,
0.0644661114,
-0.6717626452,
0.1569175571,
-0.1696729362,
-0.2589346468,
-0.1485804766,
0.233595565,
-0.0841922462,
0.3129443824,
-0.0988686904,
0.6928511858,
0.40071702,
-0.6297827959,
0.4097352624,
0.3352141082,
-0.5431754589,
0.830421567,
-0.3150965869,
0.2055791765,
-0.2555469871,
0.2945974469,
-0.5286000967,
0.0017591829,
0.3770911396,
-0.2600678205,
-0.5786052942,
-0.2946199179,
-0.3220507801,
-0.0000667146,
-0.6951579452,
0.5121939182,
0.2911435664,
-0.5492839217,
0.4280583262,
0.7475897074,
-0.247534439,
-0.6548979282,
-0.8538258672,
-0.1554298103,
-0.4074760675,
-0.1429170221,
0.2524058521,
-0.1299028099,
-0.5569949746,
0.0609016344,
-0.4439896941,
0.0427506194,
0.1604116261,
0.6918070316,
-0.1963439435,
-0.0134691093,
-0.3210233748,
-0.2037500292,
0.1292708963,
0.2325840443,
-0.0342828296,
0.4770614505,
-0.1092537045,
-0.4995203316,
-0.7121152282,
0.5922319293,
0.402374357,
-0.0794431791,
0.5359142423,
0.7094591856,
-0.2960966229,
-0.2060242593,
-0.9330408573,
-0.2536946833,
-0.4567396343,
0.0790258721,
0.1584812105,
-1.127617836,
0.8027794957,
0.7331799865,
0.2615935206,
0.413323164,
0.2481188327,
0.0804160163,
1.1135953665,
0.6616799235,
-0.0142958481,
0.6860194802,
0.146573171,
0.1322888434,
-0.4111281037,
-0.2691392601,
-0.6755839586,
-0.244090721,
-0.8057672977,
-0.137224555,
0.3759044111,
-0.0656709373,
-0.3409325182,
-0.0476756617,
-0.2988725305,
0.3219602704,
0.2050619572,
0.1666981578,
0.4560291469,
-0.1100713983,
0.2539067566,
-0.5675151348,
-0.4232170284,
-0.435372442,
0.9973874688,
0.4095902741,
0.4659780264,
0.4830430746,
0.0741962343,
0.9422062635,
0.8664409518,
-0.5960262418,
0.1166297793,
-0.4454985857,
-0.7086538672,
0.0492317155,
-0.4323651195,
-0.3877478242,
0.2566073537,
-0.1852627397,
-0.7349898219,
0.2766446769,
0.2857612967,
-0.0753925592,
0.6000079513,
-0.3743198216,
0.5813766718,
-0.1987275481,
-0.8115128875,
-0.4515752196,
-0.0737607926,
0.36652264,
-0.1988267154,
0.4245162308,
-0.0873232037,
-0.1491177231,
0.9915939569,
-0.4610709548,
0.7372193336,
-0.2706513107,
-0.2077591121,
0.1549887955,
0.1630050987,
0.3913219273,
0.1049735025,
0.0148488125,
0.3096372187,
0.2179049999,
-0.2767289877,
-0.3254261911,
0.6763436198,
-0.6961605549,
-0.4567281008,
-0.5799182653,
-0.0811730027,
-0.3889144957,
0.2101660818,
0.0716569051,
0.4614994228,
-0.226594761,
0.6291207671,
0.6812490821,
-0.0122844456,
0.3715564311,
0.5524240136,
-0.3671419024,
-0.5515767932,
0.6119074821,
-0.0408449396,
0.1491925567,
0.0478912182,
0.0758039653,
-0.3423990309,
-0.6587282419,
-0.3756605983,
-0.2583440542,
-0.6411460042,
-0.0678051859,
-0.8004795909,
0.1537617594,
-0.4426556528,
-0.2378240675,
-0.2854757905,
0.1343337744,
0.2256741375,
-0.043556843,
0.2212686688,
0.7410724163,
-0.1268507093,
0.5186628103,
-0.2697148323,
0.4758225977,
0.6460834146,
0.7237610817,
-0.1870421171,
-0.4572108984,
-0.0415625907,
-0.1218705177,
-0.3903170824,
-0.7748275995,
0.0993081853,
-0.2618851364,
0.3626608551,
0.7974970937,
-0.0319067948,
0.8170520067,
-0.2561418414,
0.9368115067,
0.260719955,
-1.2284790277,
0.1829750985,
-0.3405413032,
-0.1342029572,
0.6720914245,
0.4220024645,
-0.8825761676,
-0.496075511,
-0.5405005813,
-0.3969829679,
0.9002190828,
0.3858851492,
-0.0631749779,
0.203768298,
0.0465331487,
0.2332971394,
0.6572995782,
-0.8211864829,
-0.6044043899,
-0.5209416747,
0.1845409125,
-0.3901884258,
-0.1382033676,
-0.2997567952,
0.2401134521,
0.7130005956,
-0.0722218007,
-0.0370525606,
0.3609399199,
0.0135452934,
-0.5333438516,
0.1581894457,
0.2990502119,
0.8050561547,
-0.2269048244,
-0.0498777777,
-0.0424845703,
-0.6476905346,
-0.2977679968,
-0.2138555944,
-0.4512530863,
-0.1215652972,
0.3578443825,
0.5310025811,
0.0611167997,
-0.9052670598,
0.7785517573,
-0.2956864536,
-0.1487556547,
-0.3103115857,
0.1405034214,
-0.3441957235,
0.1314547658,
0.2517513335,
-0.1197575927,
0.4078575969,
-0.6576931477,
0.1349579841,
0.5583250523,
-0.9416891336,
0.0129110366,
0.7841658592,
0.1175822839,
-0.2633696795,
0.2737461925,
0.1432424933,
-0.7052937746,
0.617775321,
0.1682452261,
0.9193671346,
-0.0685596913,
0.13260445,
0.0341901183,
0.5782403946,
0.059523508,
0.0920230672,
-0.2613299787,
-0.8082289696,
-0.2290468663,
-0.4047422111,
-0.5980551243,
0.3729751706,
-0.9750751257,
0.0036578008,
-0.6877545714,
-0.1932890117,
0.2346976101,
0.2093621194,
-0.8307060599,
0.2959274352,
0.1812776476,
0.6815815568,
-0.8862053752,
-0.0967255086,
0.3756512105,
-0.0374408476,
-0.2806428075,
-0.005985233,
0.599403739,
-0.3943248093,
0.1119278073,
0.3020385802,
-0.549529314,
-0.5222330689,
-0.5548808575,
-0.3599157929,
0.7940325141,
0.179708302,
-0.7632935643,
0.4058676958,
-0.0255819969,
0.5887807012,
-0.2292387933,
0.379738301,
0.1335103065,
0.4377209544,
-0.574406743,
-0.9648683071,
0.0236797053,
-0.1001779214,
-0.170264408,
0.1248679683,
-0.83475703,
0.5890232921,
0.4387921989,
-0.3683033288,
-0.4749865234,
0.3716557026,
-0.0740305781,
0.4898509681,
0.8850412369,
0.1308502257,
0.3789755404,
0.0944957286,
0.9184553623,
0.1891385615,
-0.1027826443,
1.0061573982,
-0.1280347854,
0.4444781244,
0.6302118301,
-0.1406710446,
0.2954188585,
0.2488775402,
-0.0870489553,
0.5483282804,
0.1849734783,
-0.0912546664,
-0.2089362442,
-0.6734241247,
-0.2753005922,
0.3405551016,
0.2476847172,
-0.3644871712,
0.0705224723,
-0.2563560009,
0.0646763667,
0.4847559333,
-0.9536944628,
0.7359742522,
-0.0303756855,
-0.8524968028,
-0.0452323817,
0.3211116791,
0.8924156427,
-0.6381985545,
0.3036338687,
-0.0215240698,
0.169080466,
-0.4040747881,
-0.5551766157,
0.4172874987,
0.5578706264,
-0.1673429906,
-0.6559281945,
0.1898844838,
0.1870845109,
0.2133314908,
0.6085810661,
0.472274214,
0.0133285373,
-0.19589293,
-0.701947391,
0.5468826294,
-0.0150098158,
0.2634928226,
0.1639956236,
-0.2281709462,
-0.2005929053,
0.6109440327,
0.6097176075,
0.0985793024,
0.2895897925,
0.072078988,
0.5416057706,
-0.3764786422,
-1.0482405424,
-0.702041626,
0.1806595474,
-0.1758808196,
-0.6576707363,
0.7958111167,
0.7219350338,
1.2837728262,
0.2189585567,
0.6481933594,
-0.1813894361,
0.5083931684,
-0.3494910002,
0.5369166136,
-0.5368524194,
-0.1604063809,
-0.4845237732,
-0.8645946383,
0.0861773714,
0.1983320564,
-0.2163158953,
-0.1611917615,
0.5548392534,
0.7947413325,
-0.0852248445,
0.6226633191,
0.0754386261,
0.2644303441,
0.5761384368,
0.1443889588,
0.8951104283,
-0.4264117181,
0.696100533,
-0.3811104298,
-0.0898572206,
-0.0639506131,
-1.0633358955,
-0.8476567864,
-0.6565883756,
-0.2936927378,
-0.3648653924,
0.2569592595,
0.630251348,
0.8127695322,
-1.2752215862,
0.0621392392,
0.1652180105,
0.0698688924,
-0.6986960769,
-0.2169491798,
0.1316429973,
0.5567014813,
-0.8371337056,
0.1583770066,
0.176569432,
-0.4887653887,
-0.5099838972,
0.0265015755,
0.2071674019,
0.0660624281,
0.3578476012,
0.1209254041,
-0.9093661904,
-0.1953455657,
-0.4330189526,
-0.071890004,
-0.2008635551,
1.0991516113,
-0.3435890377,
0.3161335886,
0.3442536592,
0.8389315605,
0.6156076193,
0.0890249535,
0.3069328666,
-0.2300174683,
-0.1283449084,
0.2232613117,
0.2817762196,
0.2568815947,
-0.3231111467,
0.1503641754,
0.1160871238,
-0.4413869381,
-0.9800445437,
0.3447937071,
-0.7393859029,
0.0244589224,
0.6671335697,
0.0671797767,
0.1423644125,
-0.508448422,
-0.0081681795,
0.1499976516,
-0.6037110686,
0.9110749364,
0.8255746961,
0.0431040041,
-0.1569811553,
-0.8263796568,
0.7640430331,
0.6296272874,
-0.6861783266,
0.0739137083,
0.8217585683,
0.4266189635,
0.0892254636,
0.498691082,
-0.1861692965,
0.3417439759,
-0.2415359616,
-0.4406889379,
-0.0894338042,
-0.2992269993,
-0.7244740129,
0.2914873064,
-0.5880763531,
0.1397748739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14144v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14144v1 | Finding Safety Neurons in Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T09:35:22 | 2024-06-20T09:35:22 | Jianhui Chen, Xiaozhi Wang, Zijun Yao, Yushi Bai, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) excel in various capabilities but also pose
safety risks such as generating harmful content and misinformation, even after
safety alignment. In this paper, we explore the inner mechanisms of safety
alignment from the perspective of mechanistic interpretability, focusing on
identifying and analyzing safety neurons within LLMs that are responsible for
safety behaviors. We propose generation-time activation contrasting to locate
these neurons and dynamic activation patching to evaluate their causal effects.
Experiments on multiple recent LLMs show that: (1) Safety neurons are sparse
and effective. We can restore $90$% safety performance with intervention only
on about $5$% of all the neurons. (2) Safety neurons encode transferrable
mechanisms. They exhibit consistent effectiveness on different red-teaming
datasets. The finding of safety neurons also interprets "alignment tax". We
observe that the identified key neurons for safety and helpfulness
significantly overlap, but they require different activation patterns of the
shared neurons. Furthermore, we demonstrate an application of safety neurons in
detecting unsafe outputs before generation. Our findings may promote further
research on understanding LLM alignment. The source codes will be publicly
released to facilitate future research. | [
0.1926083416,
-0.5938054919,
0.6078258157,
0.1973242015,
0.0288712867,
0.1361360848,
-0.1402873099,
-0.5136703253,
-0.0172689613,
0.116762273,
-0.4467543066,
-0.2741033733,
-0.7265675664,
-0.2313769311,
-0.3441494107,
0.9127780795,
0.0413340218,
-0.1509411782,
0.0612989627,
-0.0226840358,
-0.3037672937,
-0.6095199585,
-0.7779522538,
-0.5375660062,
0.8644213676,
0.0504611433,
0.719820559,
0.7070925236,
0.3735543191,
0.4371536076,
-0.4350039065,
-0.2403483838,
-0.4654633999,
0.018792972,
-0.2666525543,
-0.3945809603,
-0.7823799849,
-0.1757155061,
0.6482067704,
0.4580759704,
-0.2765568793,
-0.3862296045,
0.5426059961,
0.2637780011,
-0.6288494468,
0.1174682826,
-0.8120396733,
-0.1506479084,
-0.0293811094,
-0.5608255863,
-0.6172235608,
-0.4272325933,
-0.018739434,
-0.3415204883,
-0.0809696168,
0.0001497168,
0.7311528325,
0.3740804791,
-0.3673951924,
-0.1561680883,
-0.3293403983,
0.9228729606,
-0.7557444572,
-0.0203866865,
0.0963310674,
-0.0591077432,
-0.6020368338,
-0.3359687626,
-0.5173479915,
-0.1217666939,
-0.3051232398,
-0.2907271087,
-0.2380792201,
0.2845477164,
0.2869090736,
-0.1899429411,
-0.388954401,
0.6345464587,
-0.156582728,
-0.3721298575,
0.7312668562,
0.1994403154,
0.7496749163,
-0.0674218163,
-0.4504853785,
-0.2583208084,
-0.918699801,
-0.0610784404,
0.5400111079,
0.3421419263,
-0.3685210049,
0.3302510679,
0.048018612,
0.5634304285,
-0.3697544932,
-0.1503093392,
0.3815814257,
-0.3759948313,
-0.1893404871,
0.4983311594,
0.9919567108,
0.4826914072,
0.510322392,
-0.0918584317,
-0.2131786346,
-0.2039685249,
0.5119922161,
-0.4544630945,
-0.1337173879,
0.1183093712,
-0.3987256587,
-0.7194561362,
-0.3003971279,
-0.6603149176,
-0.4819767773,
-0.1833300591,
0.4643872976,
-0.3637802899,
-0.5502788424,
0.285589844,
0.0960276797,
0.2875152826,
-0.1179289073,
-1.2566291094,
-0.1107832268,
0.8345215321,
0.8632983565,
-0.1715853959,
-0.5902067423,
-0.401730299,
0.4293592274,
-0.33495453,
0.5426848531,
-0.1626197398,
-0.0227285307,
0.1452988833,
0.2869387269,
-0.2667833865,
-0.2614406347,
0.4752391577,
-0.6103943586,
-0.5454744101,
-0.1587948799,
-0.2453601956,
-0.1269741505,
0.1698421389,
-0.6691119075,
0.4086966217,
-0.4583298266,
-0.8124964833,
0.3882389963,
-0.6389986277,
-0.6178351045,
-0.2590031922,
-0.2115872651,
-0.3837325275,
-0.0266427919,
-0.1338824481,
0.5798919797,
0.0752771944,
0.4744764566,
-0.4674519002,
-0.1324785054,
0.5771843791,
-0.6519389749,
1.0038619041,
-0.0277654901,
-0.4050862789,
0.5758910775,
-0.5185179114,
0.0180598348,
0.1618601233,
-0.4404863417,
-0.4905935228,
0.1826565564,
-0.1464775801,
0.2432243675,
0.18328242,
-0.2748616636,
-0.0373821557,
-0.142206803,
0.5472326875,
1.1251325607,
0.0390732177,
0.5370839238,
-0.2255652994,
0.1931669563,
-0.0432320945,
0.3730530143,
0.0738552585,
-0.4165831506,
-0.4115411639,
-0.0188100226,
0.1313068271,
0.4458674192,
-0.405218482,
0.778403461,
-0.3048272729,
-0.1533453166,
-0.263884455,
-0.0322125927,
0.5626877546,
0.3114697635,
0.2340094,
-0.0058847344,
-0.2607616484,
-1.0183235407,
-0.3197230697,
-0.2352157086,
0.0839796811,
-0.1896645874,
0.4004880786,
-0.0938518271,
0.5713551641,
-0.2247361541,
0.2760023177,
-0.1255630106,
0.2888616025,
0.1186598018,
0.9406241179,
0.4750950933,
-0.5882146358,
-0.0616556741,
0.1139527187,
-0.9403740764,
-0.0808845088,
-0.3286986053,
-0.1832723022,
0.4166019559,
0.8443622589,
-0.6063351631,
0.3554661572,
0.641659379,
-0.243358463,
0.3184610903,
-0.3164612055,
0.0135400286,
-0.902967751,
0.0682727844,
-0.137724027,
0.0480458029,
-0.6977843046,
-0.0450426415,
0.1787142903,
0.4032012522,
-0.5530115962,
0.2104356587,
-0.5909748077,
-0.2265986204,
-0.3224109411,
0.1012642309,
-0.2438283563,
0.3596279919,
-0.2393149436,
0.7029006481,
0.5408638716,
-0.5635341406,
0.0608980097,
0.0793728828,
-0.6843036413,
0.0893415138,
-0.6994438767,
-0.0321885534,
-0.1109896153,
0.0622934513,
-0.8588684201,
-0.4257207811,
0.3092948496,
-0.1505559385,
0.694457233,
-0.3042958379,
-0.6139386296,
0.0842063352,
-0.1063802764,
0.531745851,
0.6008838415,
-0.5988524556,
0.3019655645,
0.6889410615,
-0.3126218319,
-0.9030848145,
-0.6886090636,
0.0214802306,
-0.2174418569,
-0.6679656506,
0.2133401483,
0.1140163988,
-0.3506597579,
-0.0249370486,
-0.1268537939,
0.192258507,
0.486650914,
0.3369467258,
0.2979534566,
-0.1145605147,
0.2488436252,
0.1970600188,
-0.2970563471,
0.2860800624,
0.19124192,
0.6766476631,
-0.0786577389,
-0.3187294602,
-0.300018996,
0.1685521156,
0.7102662325,
-0.0558012314,
0.9963135123,
0.0632408485,
-0.4316543043,
-0.1915472597,
-0.2562007308,
-0.3535538018,
-0.5635102987,
0.4531382024,
0.0709460154,
-0.7614777684,
0.3753791451,
0.0206626207,
0.0879671201,
0.3349637687,
0.4649373293,
-0.050186865,
1.0822217464,
0.4765621424,
-0.1052482873,
0.4464424551,
0.1556285918,
0.5638573766,
-0.7008166313,
-0.5661419034,
-0.3409252167,
-0.4760062993,
-0.4976942539,
-0.2428545058,
0.4100935161,
0.2408321053,
-0.3312455118,
0.3338194489,
-0.4285914302,
0.6981293559,
0.3770033419,
-0.0337489732,
0.1600461751,
0.0330599919,
-0.2372149676,
0.1420402229,
-0.7743708491,
-0.4510973394,
0.6110787988,
0.5834617615,
0.9725115299,
0.1147895604,
0.4548462927,
-0.0738556534,
0.2647537589,
-0.6148897409,
0.7617815137,
0.0036185135,
-0.6607111692,
-0.3300153017,
-0.4056045115,
-0.9482768178,
0.0136866299,
-0.5835086703,
-0.8898721337,
0.0770162717,
0.2735229135,
-0.5185013413,
0.5257658362,
-0.7657800317,
0.8944647312,
-0.7555034161,
-0.5848237276,
-0.5065332055,
-0.8157551289,
0.3771268129,
-0.0913842767,
0.1485142559,
-0.2371003926,
0.1217241213,
0.619905293,
0.0970774144,
1.1127151251,
0.1198615134,
-0.3280315399,
0.0024026076,
0.0266586822,
0.5118963122,
-0.3675951362,
-0.0677934811,
0.3826599717,
-0.3371809125,
-0.2330939621,
-0.3610219657,
1.054125309,
-0.3675259054,
-0.6226509809,
-0.5941470861,
-0.9805567265,
0.0281296894,
0.2916761935,
0.2002550662,
0.1754001975,
0.0430220626,
0.2650254071,
0.6917515993,
-0.5018405914,
0.9280227423,
0.2238249928,
-0.0419901051,
-0.0141259488,
0.6659522653,
0.2001833469,
0.3017024994,
0.0733451396,
-0.0629481673,
-0.3204826117,
-0.8814674616,
-0.1799489856,
0.2757084072,
-0.7027671337,
-0.1328919679,
-0.610534668,
-0.44130072,
-0.1628465354,
-0.1756100506,
-0.2605939507,
-0.2861458063,
-0.1866897196,
-0.4907889962,
0.3818570375,
0.8207249045,
-0.3837280869,
0.3321410418,
-0.9775257111,
-0.1795054376,
0.3128828704,
0.5891758204,
0.2495072037,
-0.0177691635,
-0.1437306553,
-0.0695933402,
-0.2617737055,
-0.734046042,
0.1403519064,
-0.3251941204,
0.7134051919,
0.4236716628,
0.0115099037,
0.3233993351,
-0.6398186684,
0.4712516963,
0.6392285824,
-0.920391202,
0.2813625336,
-0.4346896708,
-0.1963974983,
0.2385022342,
0.4365619123,
-0.1694637388,
-0.0575946048,
-0.5167089105,
-1.0627800226,
0.6829505563,
0.2679548562,
0.0998889431,
-0.0862677172,
0.2590737641,
-0.160489127,
-0.0138792042,
-0.7296686769,
0.0200672671,
0.2787289917,
-0.2087174505,
-0.0168550555,
-0.5496562719,
-0.5313401222,
0.1202261969,
0.5748749375,
-0.1567858011,
0.1271743774,
-0.1308323592,
0.1559803635,
-0.2429313511,
0.4862563312,
0.8650041223,
0.5434830785,
-0.0711625591,
0.2905643582,
0.1131890491,
-0.0692195147,
0.281524539,
-0.2038812041,
-0.0508853532,
-0.3153168261,
0.6025915742,
0.7039507031,
0.4015210271,
-0.4864777029,
0.5370375514,
0.1237533763,
-0.028609179,
-0.2577492893,
0.5326344967,
0.178446278,
0.4034934938,
-0.0327858217,
0.1754194945,
-0.1101232618,
-0.6343906522,
0.2931501865,
0.684885025,
-0.283867836,
-0.4262486398,
0.6359081268,
0.1960487962,
-0.4114586711,
0.4235475063,
0.1761348397,
-0.4724708796,
0.808573842,
0.5540060401,
0.9451375008,
-0.3405643702,
-0.0169014614,
0.385505259,
0.5669714212,
-0.368796438,
0.143060565,
0.5175062418,
-0.8625995517,
-0.6919900179,
-0.5020000935,
-0.0650502965,
0.2613812089,
-0.4654871523,
0.0868212208,
-0.4084799886,
-0.1619696617,
0.0866991356,
-0.8307169676,
0.0272602886,
0.0645542815,
0.0720242187,
0.7725252509,
-0.9644760489,
0.8748013973,
0.4577507675,
-0.2441795468,
-0.7759245038,
0.3677021265,
0.075268358,
-0.8442158699,
0.6046529412,
0.1342073679,
-0.2865522504,
-0.2106870115,
-0.8832995296,
-0.7203306556,
1.0005025864,
0.5119566917,
-0.9102517962,
-0.3073270917,
0.0647253767,
0.4357866049,
-0.2195834666,
-0.1805643886,
0.5943058133,
0.4181247652,
-0.1445820928,
-0.8130140901,
0.4322547615,
-0.1151929125,
-0.2228986323,
0.5245494246,
-0.4670933485,
0.7667773962,
-0.3079071641,
-0.1255257428,
-0.0233495254,
0.2116358429,
0.3911313117,
0.3270838559,
0.6133832335,
0.4779434502,
0.6085690856,
-0.0707352087,
1.0593504906,
-0.3098419607,
0.1869109124,
1.0028237104,
-0.0808184743,
0.8769687414,
0.8110961318,
0.2203750461,
0.3987370729,
0.2588087022,
0.2031938136,
0.6900372505,
0.3158595264,
-0.3452932835,
-0.4217820466,
-0.098603487,
-0.2176830024,
0.0554469302,
0.335087508,
-0.5507508516,
-0.0085349223,
-0.3846810758,
0.2757583261,
-0.2648963332,
-0.2758715153,
0.7307841182,
0.2978780866,
-0.7571901679,
0.5353890657,
-0.3420312107,
0.5718960762,
-0.5630497932,
-0.1364518702,
0.1405256391,
0.3140914142,
-0.3512654603,
-1.2802040577,
0.5475463867,
-0.1665233374,
-0.0937236324,
-0.2921364009,
0.7605056763,
-0.4312693477,
0.0351800136,
0.8778851032,
0.0512001663,
-0.0248387475,
0.3281058669,
-0.4491332769,
0.2206771225,
-0.0073878206,
-0.1041626036,
0.6162734032,
0.2732803524,
-0.1527989209,
0.5374801755,
0.6979192495,
0.0337360986,
0.2177709341,
-0.08144328,
0.8372808695,
-0.5968290567,
-0.3511783779,
-1.0323953629,
0.7744195461,
-0.1935246438,
-0.0486147739,
0.3595046401,
0.028632503,
0.5384404063,
-0.0001220828,
0.8003870249,
0.0008120854,
-0.080293715,
-0.94219625,
1.3628783226,
-0.5904015303,
0.4113132954,
-0.1364645511,
-0.735006094,
-0.5410800576,
0.5457479954,
-0.3550981581,
-0.1931782365,
0.7208524942,
1.1340138912,
-0.1828952134,
-0.0180897824,
0.3339639008,
0.5570778847,
0.298235476,
0.6037166715,
1.0599000454,
-0.2059265822,
0.6592561007,
-0.1371582001,
-0.2762281299,
-0.1899584234,
-1.3749704361,
-0.7920907736,
-0.4472566843,
-0.3560414016,
-0.5657923222,
0.1305721849,
0.7580941916,
0.6213460565,
-0.8046291471,
-0.0574322604,
-0.376005739,
0.2124307901,
-0.008533515,
-0.133596167,
0.3265606165,
-0.5160866976,
-0.390743494,
0.624987185,
0.2998484373,
0.1270533204,
0.1310117692,
-0.1548263878,
-0.2013913393,
-0.0504929386,
0.3655988574,
0.2973539531,
-0.5164338946,
-0.6328282356,
-0.2648583055,
-0.2430915385,
-0.1459970474,
0.7246240377,
0.0305980444,
0.1444844455,
0.802298665,
0.6769706011,
-0.0976187959,
-0.3678655922,
0.8461937904,
-0.6452698112,
0.1257225871,
0.0219590552,
0.6723120213,
0.3080086112,
-0.2995462418,
0.595318079,
-0.0660270602,
-0.819223702,
-0.8462567329,
0.3005422354,
-0.9749842286,
-0.1901579201,
1.3632647991,
-0.2686784267,
-0.339025408,
-0.167524159,
0.1006063744,
0.4133903384,
-0.1876702756,
0.9308790565,
0.6044709086,
0.007205761,
-0.0934606194,
-0.5213537812,
0.6536484361,
0.5370641351,
-0.7769338489,
0.1309714615,
0.323877871,
0.3496552408,
0.4779871106,
0.2367498279,
-0.2640132308,
0.2963237464,
-0.154444024,
0.2615623772,
0.2640590072,
-0.5072966814,
-0.7120978236,
0.1883136928,
-0.0276877303,
-0.288372606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14137v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14137v1 | MACAROON: Training Vision-Language Models To Be Your Engaged Partners | 2024-06-20T09:27:33 | 2024-06-20T09:27:33 | Shujin Wu, Yi R. Fung, Sha Li, Yixin Wan, Kai-Wei Chang, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large vision-language models (LVLMs), while proficient in following
instructions and responding to diverse questions, invariably generate detailed
responses even when questions are ambiguous or unanswerable, leading to
hallucinations and bias issues. Thus, it is essential for LVLMs to proactively
engage with humans to ask for clarifications or additional information for
better responses. In this study, we aim to shift LVLMs from passive answer
providers to proactive engaged partners. We begin by establishing a
three-tiered hierarchy for questions of invalid, ambiguous, and personalizable
nature to measure the proactive engagement capabilities of LVLMs. Utilizing
this hierarchy, we create PIE, (ProactIve Engagement Evaluation) through GPT-4o
and human annotators, consisting of 853 questions across six distinct,
fine-grained question types that are verified by human annotators and
accompanied with well-defined metrics. Our evaluations on \benchmark indicate
poor performance of existing LVLMs, with the best-performing open-weights model
only achieving an Aggregate Align Rate (AAR) of 0.28. In response, we introduce
MACAROON, self-iMaginAtion for ContrAstive pReference OptimizatiON, which
instructs LVLMs to autonomously generate contrastive response pairs for
unlabeled questions given the task description and human-crafted criteria.
Then, the self-imagined data is formatted for conditional reinforcement
learning. Experimental results show MACAROON effectively improves LVLMs'
capabilities to be proactively engaged (0.84 AAR) while maintaining comparable
performance on general tasks. | [
-0.6207350492,
-0.9699348807,
0.4797818959,
0.0342147574,
-0.1143392026,
0.0980261341,
-0.0954682752,
-0.6823154092,
0.4953331649,
0.698178947,
-0.6686654687,
-0.1437920928,
-0.2736239433,
0.1305689514,
-0.1130218506,
0.9547275901,
-0.2177556604,
-0.0482543297,
-0.1243323833,
-0.2236406356,
-0.1987123638,
-0.2534226775,
-0.7690684199,
0.1055410877,
0.855009675,
0.4747376144,
0.755543232,
0.1660086513,
0.6228600144,
0.3813204765,
-0.0121851712,
0.3538020253,
-0.4737761021,
0.1839473546,
-0.227726236,
-0.2559267581,
-0.505337894,
0.1532872468,
0.2112893462,
0.7182586789,
-0.2847768962,
0.3080201745,
0.0907307193,
0.8900409341,
-1.0443011522,
0.0163116977,
-0.5208266973,
0.3450275958,
-0.0108535392,
0.1374317557,
-0.2388673276,
-0.2884788513,
0.180914849,
-0.8931919336,
-0.0494649522,
0.0317850076,
0.6122581363,
0.3056081235,
-0.4353302121,
-0.3212159276,
-0.5104539394,
0.5732808709,
-0.5243403316,
0.3673269451,
0.557090044,
0.2521457076,
-0.0703580901,
-0.7408863902,
-0.5484640598,
-0.6018384099,
0.0178070832,
0.675842464,
-0.1082575992,
0.2018904984,
0.0987168327,
0.3237167895,
-0.594709754,
-0.1374144107,
-0.1849956661,
-0.1280202866,
0.7478551865,
0.2871664464,
0.1615989506,
0.0646045953,
-0.141663447,
0.1173771694,
-0.1269322187,
0.491073221,
0.3479230702,
-0.2420158982,
0.0186185706,
0.8594366312,
-0.3209472299,
0.5780262947,
0.522007823,
0.3274300396,
0.1020997018,
-0.3339286447,
-0.3182302117,
-0.0135315685,
0.8409947157,
0.3714874387,
0.3212304711,
-0.039382115,
-0.1538614035,
0.2156852484,
0.6368622184,
-0.6830239296,
-0.4073985815,
0.3043335378,
-0.267026633,
-0.5098914504,
-0.0315279253,
-0.3767842054,
-0.176531747,
-0.0157250464,
0.4061561525,
-0.2481072098,
-0.5042600632,
0.1460483223,
0.1425185949,
-0.1688880622,
0.4376633167,
-1.2881133556,
0.5524946451,
0.3536057472,
0.4901453853,
-0.229603976,
-0.2048297077,
-0.73596102,
0.2171996534,
-0.7674497962,
0.4011718333,
-0.5953449011,
-0.3043661416,
-0.0537598096,
0.0719147995,
-0.1292833835,
-0.6274108887,
0.3884266019,
-0.5664463043,
0.2979437113,
-0.3112970889,
-0.402887404,
0.0617505759,
0.7674337029,
-0.6179646254,
0.9875051975,
0.2020268887,
-0.9974592924,
0.2374741584,
-0.894749403,
-0.0223053936,
0.2488582432,
-0.3665017784,
-0.3886983395,
0.1008699015,
0.5135545135,
0.452613622,
0.07935296,
0.161150828,
-0.1614588499,
-0.1970486343,
0.410639137,
-0.0716169402,
0.4150885046,
0.0367370546,
-0.3225297332,
0.4501815736,
-0.4727451801,
-0.1798594743,
0.0725709572,
-0.302719146,
-0.4369203448,
-0.0784636885,
-0.1769896448,
0.1252176017,
0.2011824101,
-0.6647875905,
0.1243089214,
-0.6506229639,
0.1347944438,
0.83825773,
0.0546951555,
0.4386183619,
-0.0262434762,
0.7767874002,
0.275518477,
0.5671879649,
0.269457072,
-0.5104089975,
-0.8798584938,
-0.0071921539,
-0.0481702462,
0.3249606192,
-1.1414381266,
0.0198183451,
0.0673916489,
-0.3483144343,
-0.5841170549,
0.2008157074,
0.3352573812,
0.9332891107,
0.3990534544,
-0.4880957603,
-0.3423762321,
-1.0047422647,
-0.0126085253,
-0.1972672343,
0.2439989448,
0.5468137264,
0.5848763585,
-0.2923234403,
0.9777727723,
-0.2645503283,
-0.1385463178,
-0.4726978838,
0.0953320116,
0.0121578369,
0.4780992568,
0.3380604982,
-1.114847064,
-0.6762638688,
0.1982108057,
-0.8066239953,
0.2415167689,
-0.0047212648,
-0.0769720301,
-0.0365708321,
0.3049734533,
-0.3554319143,
0.3512527049,
0.7300226092,
-0.1658648401,
0.6610911489,
-0.15977709,
0.1832892299,
-0.9414670467,
0.0202562902,
0.0601603724,
-0.2263194174,
-0.6383939385,
-0.1841089576,
0.1614576429,
-0.3143168092,
-0.7000784874,
0.731413126,
-0.4102470279,
-0.1685629338,
0.0355206393,
0.2132918239,
-0.2825371623,
0.4858082831,
0.3622810245,
0.9727445841,
0.6148107648,
-0.6697497964,
0.4807367921,
0.2070314288,
-0.3578742743,
0.3026283979,
-0.7183917165,
0.015142628,
-0.0177790821,
0.0081420187,
-0.8035850525,
-0.3023441434,
0.5765562057,
-0.3269361556,
-0.1155419424,
0.0044613732,
-0.0887022391,
-0.3461280763,
-0.4388314784,
0.708078146,
0.2355018407,
-0.4136306047,
0.6536490321,
0.2059997171,
-0.1407949924,
-0.8603380919,
-0.5689896345,
0.1283046454,
-0.0263743475,
-0.6301273108,
0.272995472,
-0.2914573848,
-0.2122317106,
0.1463704109,
-0.1014053449,
0.1300614923,
0.1862614751,
0.1832688451,
0.204278931,
-0.0568630621,
-0.0080904989,
-0.2030689418,
-0.269420743,
0.0225764774,
-0.0777508318,
0.4365781248,
-0.2531233132,
-0.3415166736,
-0.6380805373,
0.3813676536,
0.3018679917,
-0.7297794819,
0.6263927817,
0.7015160322,
0.004209748,
0.1333093047,
-0.6891630888,
-0.2698403299,
-0.536008954,
0.399800539,
-0.5860394239,
-1.0668656826,
0.4614087343,
-0.0814143717,
0.0239821728,
0.0974524766,
0.5046370625,
-0.3755607903,
1.405346632,
0.7562779188,
0.2597271502,
0.6817476749,
-0.3911874592,
-0.0396998189,
-1.1655455828,
-0.2363651693,
0.207811147,
-0.3775912225,
-0.559122026,
-0.2438201904,
0.4310911894,
0.2107798755,
-0.193573609,
0.156873703,
-0.4494011998,
0.356762886,
0.4848473668,
0.1391267329,
-0.1511971503,
-0.3827127814,
-0.378239125,
-0.1175214127,
-0.6533949971,
-0.2999643981,
0.8933270574,
0.2239271253,
0.7077758312,
0.2236391753,
0.8888494372,
-0.0177772604,
0.2825175524,
-0.7367214561,
0.7350194454,
0.1372910589,
-0.4637409449,
-0.4047715068,
-0.3372475505,
-0.9648398161,
0.1961316019,
-0.3020500839,
-0.8587415814,
0.3633546233,
0.3710699677,
-0.2682575583,
0.0354429223,
-0.4259773195,
1.2007836103,
-0.5094473958,
-0.6690847278,
-0.230816707,
-0.6162847877,
0.4463682771,
0.0766292587,
0.0688541532,
-0.0615707673,
-0.2402141839,
0.6905090213,
-0.1712067425,
0.7524719834,
0.0351362266,
0.0918617174,
0.0764410421,
0.5066562891,
0.6460972428,
0.2671369314,
-0.0616862848,
-0.2347527742,
-0.3100357354,
-0.3700438142,
-0.8151910305,
0.4508289993,
-0.7172200084,
-0.7153342962,
-0.3696970642,
-0.4682827294,
-0.4072072506,
-0.1032015383,
0.0411198549,
0.3961509466,
-0.2088549733,
0.1710193753,
0.5832356811,
0.0642445534,
0.5129030347,
0.4493988454,
-0.2907112241,
-0.5285963416,
0.5485795736,
-0.2136787176,
0.4797194302,
0.2812131047,
0.3175232112,
-0.1742279232,
-0.4718120992,
-0.4333469868,
0.2718550265,
-0.5221911669,
0.215336591,
-0.7396622896,
0.0320423208,
-0.3485487998,
-0.4347575903,
-0.5779220462,
-0.2158173174,
-0.3474159837,
-0.1810303181,
-0.1246165708,
0.5200538635,
-0.1943856329,
-0.0817374438,
-0.6309207678,
0.3319066167,
0.719250977,
-0.0497418419,
-0.0381341428,
-0.1589490324,
-0.4429901242,
0.1391007751,
-0.2505403757,
-0.922003746,
0.4548926353,
0.0250104591,
0.8024927378,
0.5631809831,
0.1627650261,
0.8115898371,
-0.4045600891,
0.9988495708,
0.5127442479,
-0.8807542324,
0.9966858625,
-0.0803720579,
0.0332512558,
0.6436623931,
0.6528518796,
-0.5508922935,
-0.5725728273,
-0.6217532158,
-0.6455373168,
0.6222771406,
0.3821993768,
0.0860760435,
-0.3197783828,
0.4588727951,
-0.2011987865,
0.2355520129,
-1.094214201,
-0.013553625,
-0.3495135009,
-0.2072845995,
-0.1178925782,
-0.3493068814,
-0.2952313721,
-0.2518283129,
0.4567291737,
-0.2681950331,
0.0156661738,
0.4260281622,
-0.0350652747,
-0.0745969787,
0.1206996441,
0.6809697747,
0.6749728918,
-0.3264716566,
0.2585460842,
0.1667199582,
-0.5426123738,
0.002703659,
-0.3520418704,
0.1903095096,
-0.3736096621,
0.4148303866,
0.7488084435,
0.097331211,
-0.7827775478,
0.5153389573,
-0.3066342473,
-0.1886922568,
-0.2492609322,
0.4183748662,
0.0370494425,
0.2808679342,
-0.0156612415,
0.0262067374,
0.2019879818,
-0.9066488743,
0.0120041417,
0.5482437015,
-0.8615882397,
-0.159567073,
0.7401660085,
0.5249611139,
-0.4838026464,
0.4342314899,
-0.2393886596,
-0.6121210456,
0.4965034425,
0.3958691955,
0.8581132293,
-0.2831776142,
0.4198595285,
0.2756934166,
0.2011617422,
0.1622686386,
0.1558075994,
-0.5440377593,
-1.0401376486,
-0.2110161036,
-0.2806282938,
-0.5223861933,
-0.1180110797,
-0.7786599398,
-0.0875350237,
-0.2414395511,
-0.1815665662,
-0.1511924416,
0.1063889712,
-0.413443625,
0.3409454823,
-0.0585993268,
0.5754641891,
-0.5965507627,
0.8209351301,
0.9511781931,
-0.8003348112,
-0.7397249937,
-0.0121994782,
-0.1425321698,
-0.825262785,
1.1793841124,
0.1345599741,
-0.3532222211,
-0.0110028638,
-0.4396898448,
-0.6359899044,
1.137081027,
0.1462854892,
-0.6796408296,
0.099252753,
0.1433871835,
0.3817422986,
-0.5845094919,
0.5086711645,
0.2249235958,
0.1773904413,
0.2426133752,
-1.0172708035,
-0.3236409128,
-0.3517959118,
0.1138954088,
0.115153268,
-0.5501557589,
0.8000133634,
-0.3626681268,
0.011600784,
0.003132615,
0.4898861051,
0.2250553817,
0.2906477749,
0.6592715383,
0.4309541881,
0.6143738627,
0.15655303,
1.0436375141,
-0.2067956775,
0.2454779893,
0.994392395,
-0.3924371898,
1.0681661367,
0.7538759708,
0.28216061,
0.4055646658,
0.7533838153,
0.2616826594,
0.7545113564,
-0.0294319056,
-0.3729729652,
-0.6151340604,
-0.0913587585,
-0.231296286,
0.4100154936,
0.2335304469,
-0.1825069785,
0.1348473132,
0.3441704512,
-0.3094849288,
0.1280905604,
-0.4241533875,
0.9807767272,
-0.127388224,
-0.6962162852,
0.3352278769,
-0.2934169173,
0.5270167589,
-0.6121992469,
0.0313305296,
-0.5088970065,
0.2496087551,
-0.0332603604,
-0.8675690889,
0.0170176346,
-0.1583575755,
0.0613950416,
0.0121871913,
0.469384551,
-0.316067785,
-0.608744204,
0.323630482,
0.3179166615,
0.0683372319,
0.0710060596,
-1.0485510826,
0.0496389978,
0.0702626929,
-0.4814356267,
0.1999180168,
0.1635376811,
0.04100677,
1.117218852,
0.7277590632,
0.171623975,
-0.14494057,
0.1703131497,
0.9048094749,
-0.5010227561,
-0.5621723533,
-0.6600546241,
0.8908384442,
-0.3278389871,
-0.4266976416,
0.7189377546,
0.5049154758,
0.8029599786,
-0.0442705899,
0.3581969142,
0.27468279,
0.2453066558,
-0.6121698618,
0.3388574719,
-0.807043016,
0.2965317965,
-0.3137938976,
-0.9670850039,
-0.0879594535,
0.9564236999,
-0.4210344553,
-0.0543658063,
0.5771687627,
0.7433955073,
-0.141214937,
-0.1168796048,
0.5794901848,
-0.0579152107,
0.5363450646,
0.6814132929,
1.2305389643,
-0.2233729064,
0.3682305217,
-0.5662564635,
-0.2009858638,
-0.3452484608,
-0.6492264271,
-1.0468822718,
-0.6413236856,
-0.5538877845,
0.0593432449,
0.3089109957,
0.8203586936,
0.8487753272,
-0.5529488921,
-0.3805736005,
-0.3999011815,
-0.1933069974,
-0.2452064604,
-0.1809169948,
0.308653295,
-0.447827369,
-0.5774695873,
0.3593248427,
0.5566468239,
0.1007684991,
-0.4709717929,
-0.2991619408,
-0.1892541796,
0.0554462671,
0.6945364475,
0.1538221091,
-0.8659507036,
-0.3076174259,
0.0772042349,
-0.0393221751,
0.0973558798,
0.6760414839,
-0.8667845726,
0.6883842945,
0.0084540453,
0.5985757709,
0.8592762351,
0.0943974331,
0.3636373281,
-0.4928875268,
0.2579025626,
0.7253722548,
0.2361870557,
0.136793375,
-0.3187909126,
0.6322703958,
0.0111209583,
-0.65257442,
-0.6764436364,
0.4603271782,
-1.0988787413,
-0.1956491023,
0.9852771163,
-0.1088531464,
-0.1046427786,
-0.110004738,
-0.5384454727,
-0.0323956124,
-0.1240045726,
0.7107809186,
0.4600230455,
-0.590354681,
-0.6559579372,
-0.506518364,
0.6932349801,
0.6882997751,
-0.881172359,
-0.0949139073,
0.3569383621,
0.0955740809,
0.1909484863,
0.7332876921,
0.2500621974,
0.4868344069,
-0.064233385,
0.0912948027,
-0.284003973,
-0.2553452253,
0.0575133935,
0.0976739004,
0.0970779136,
-0.4295279682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14129v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14129v1 | Towards Event-oriented Long Video Understanding | 2024-06-20T09:14:19 | 2024-06-20T09:14:19 | Yifan Du, Kun Zhou, Yuqi Huo, Yifan Li, Wayne Xin Zhao, Haoyu Lu, Zijia Zhao, Bingning Wang, Weipeng Chen, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM | With the rapid development of video Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs),
numerous benchmarks have been proposed to assess their video understanding
capability. However, due to the lack of rich events in the videos, these
datasets may suffer from the short-cut bias that the answers can be deduced
from a few frames, without the need to watch the entire video. To address this
issue, we introduce Event-Bench, an event-oriented long video understanding
benchmark built on existing datasets and human annotations. Event-Bench
includes six event-related tasks and 2,190 test instances to comprehensively
evaluate video event understanding ability. Additionally, we propose Video
Instruction Merging~(VIM), a cost-effective method that enhances video MLLMs
using merged, event-intensive video instructions, addressing the scarcity of
human-annotated, event-intensive data. Extensive experiments show that the
best-performing model, GPT-4o, achieves an overall accuracy of 53.33,
significantly outperforming the best open-source model by 41.42%. Leveraging an
effective instruction synthesis method and an adaptive model architecture, VIM
surpasses both state-of-the-art open-source models and GPT-4V on the
Event-Bench. All code, data, and models are publicly available at
https://github.com/RUCAIBox/Event-Bench. | [
-0.4244332314,
-0.6575040221,
0.6249633431,
0.2273458987,
-0.546600461,
-0.2400372028,
-0.565820992,
-0.3805859089,
-0.3943163753,
0.3921978176,
-0.7761713266,
-0.5991834402,
-0.5888616443,
-0.3886221945,
-0.606552124,
0.879250288,
-0.3671390116,
0.0634709299,
-0.3168685436,
-0.447342217,
-0.2441525161,
-0.446190685,
-0.4366283119,
-0.2330761701,
0.2405740023,
0.2348209769,
0.3700895011,
1.0031861067,
0.5325970054,
0.2513451278,
0.0569445379,
0.2011907995,
-0.4456179738,
-0.1929940879,
-0.1472068727,
-0.3405390978,
-0.4850754142,
-0.1752270758,
0.7147721052,
0.5243769884,
-0.0750099272,
0.3918149471,
0.0774796829,
0.6634727716,
-0.8971973062,
0.2340740561,
-0.4217116535,
0.2655337453,
-0.258454591,
-0.0969583616,
-0.4150248766,
0.0979822353,
-0.07411699,
-0.6142601967,
0.551941514,
-0.3790324926,
0.5831543803,
0.5420294404,
-0.2807942033,
0.4034039378,
-0.7775872946,
0.7517957687,
-0.3498811126,
0.8481498957,
0.5315228701,
0.619028151,
-0.0835917592,
-0.6173715591,
-0.461702615,
0.3138648272,
0.3691748679,
0.1804068983,
-0.028533509,
0.2194174677,
0.3332163692,
-0.0464123487,
-0.8514515162,
0.2413467318,
-0.1657331586,
0.3280401826,
0.6499089599,
0.2823858261,
0.0844711214,
-0.2772383988,
-0.4664869308,
-0.1949360371,
-0.3735193908,
0.1316640079,
0.0563763343,
-0.1115137562,
-0.2489197403,
0.3678103387,
-0.2295286208,
0.8407216072,
-0.3250112534,
-0.1192704514,
0.1823135465,
-0.4995954335,
-0.7241164446,
-0.043776691,
0.5065853596,
0.6930778623,
0.2734262645,
-0.083203271,
0.0403176956,
0.081355527,
0.1701896489,
-1.0681673288,
-0.2351522595,
0.1660715491,
-0.5399780869,
0.0782867372,
0.0387185253,
-0.8255035877,
-0.5558120608,
-0.4105259776,
0.3955002725,
-0.3378092647,
0.0419276468,
0.0491736382,
-0.241920054,
0.3657586873,
0.6755791306,
-0.6058893204,
0.2569304705,
0.7799727321,
0.5935706496,
-0.2589079738,
-0.5461018085,
-1.1998710632,
0.3386368155,
-0.1862196624,
0.4174182415,
-0.3806361854,
-0.1047886461,
-0.0180979557,
0.169048354,
0.0795445368,
-0.3573297262,
0.443575114,
-0.3718088865,
-0.0959668383,
0.0840776339,
-0.4888063967,
-0.3179402947,
0.272875756,
-0.4808259308,
0.8682439327,
-0.2744095027,
-0.1937502027,
0.5888059735,
-0.5572746992,
-0.3139605224,
-0.1983821094,
-0.3888231218,
-0.3793177903,
0.0832026973,
0.5661097169,
0.4533395171,
-0.1861061007,
0.3569282293,
-0.5368031859,
-0.3147703409,
0.2425119281,
-0.622749269,
0.0150246872,
-0.0981500149,
-0.486705333,
-0.0077360179,
-1.0063900948,
-0.161827758,
-0.2040187567,
0.0951944664,
-0.1201888025,
0.2514472604,
0.0621103793,
0.1715632826,
-0.0586147048,
-0.3277927637,
0.0194606539,
0.1107208207,
0.3284883499,
0.8668335676,
-0.1166582257,
0.4392835498,
0.1853953749,
0.4073176086,
-0.0261189621,
0.5372610092,
-0.538143754,
-0.3931475282,
-0.5769158006,
-0.1342515051,
-0.2010537237,
0.1955103874,
-0.4010842443,
-0.012152697,
-0.3199776411,
-0.1287121773,
-0.4669345915,
0.5622117519,
0.4646542072,
0.3666406572,
0.6204146147,
-0.4846641123,
-0.607617557,
-0.715562284,
-0.1834269762,
-0.1552031934,
0.0021057888,
0.400344193,
0.2806986272,
-0.068335779,
0.6603944302,
-0.3921160698,
-0.1974023134,
0.0409445688,
0.5299246907,
0.147408694,
0.1385603249,
0.4507979751,
-0.7757080197,
-0.3722122908,
0.3320766687,
-0.9464454055,
0.3157871962,
-0.0857648179,
0.0708518922,
0.1830364317,
0.4871156812,
-0.4277876318,
1.0021810532,
0.4820902944,
-0.2424944788,
0.3059696853,
-0.1845369488,
0.4925458431,
-0.6812043786,
-0.1176242307,
0.0131812375,
-0.3412315547,
-0.4543982148,
-0.0481273308,
0.1960757375,
-0.2388636619,
-0.618155539,
0.4147963524,
-0.3880619705,
-0.5048468709,
-0.4265289307,
0.2924586833,
0.1908662766,
0.5144549012,
0.2452709824,
0.4704085588,
0.3720303178,
-0.4362481833,
0.4705140293,
0.1335389167,
-0.7000406384,
0.4036484361,
-0.248434335,
-0.0202734247,
-0.3191865683,
0.2220870107,
-0.8627790809,
-0.5539113879,
-0.231686905,
-0.3625236154,
0.2659645677,
-0.8305324912,
-0.0863366798,
-0.2640895844,
-0.1766683161,
0.4139794707,
0.5822088122,
-0.7927113175,
0.6223689318,
0.0573911965,
-0.1260101199,
-0.8586832285,
-0.7984321713,
0.094576478,
-0.2038451582,
-0.8333867788,
0.352324605,
-0.0248576812,
-0.1787048876,
0.0413041413,
-0.2614278495,
-0.3936798275,
-0.1797710061,
0.4541830719,
0.1895340979,
-0.3875365555,
0.3251188397,
-0.388117075,
0.1094909161,
0.0223160721,
-0.1131812781,
0.2234512866,
0.1361444443,
-0.6806960106,
-0.8071411848,
0.4530180991,
0.7204597592,
-0.3454141319,
0.4417282641,
1.0819972754,
-0.3967231214,
-0.124161385,
-0.7221802473,
-0.0424615331,
-0.3631263971,
0.7703812718,
-0.1610319763,
-0.5846728683,
0.4928914905,
0.2472136915,
0.0074484381,
0.028475346,
0.4013174474,
-0.3563072979,
1.0605013371,
0.4190080464,
0.0264455304,
0.8820158839,
-0.2164245993,
-0.1600232273,
-0.6080300212,
-0.1669209301,
-0.191158399,
-0.3863162696,
-0.0996739715,
-0.9591073394,
0.3124637902,
0.2630580664,
-0.339119792,
0.1289136857,
-0.1362133771,
0.6997293234,
0.0638955235,
0.1503642499,
0.2162856609,
-0.2344484031,
0.6842420697,
-0.1138661131,
-0.5768164396,
-0.0839379579,
0.9567470551,
0.3082946837,
0.860496819,
0.0890412778,
0.6121885777,
0.0853023306,
0.1278137118,
-0.3955419362,
0.3996670246,
-0.220055759,
-0.3492680788,
-0.3677734733,
-0.3298869729,
-0.7717985511,
0.1262260228,
-0.0052297385,
-1.0125547647,
0.1435332447,
0.1128305122,
-0.3053238094,
0.3448905349,
-0.829605639,
1.3300421238,
-0.4277043939,
-0.8096466064,
-0.5064974427,
-0.5059258342,
0.4853601754,
0.0778442845,
0.5721533895,
-0.1596840918,
-0.0091154082,
0.7270461321,
-0.4805655479,
0.6957162619,
-0.247664392,
0.4027087092,
0.4177891016,
-0.137773186,
0.7955072522,
0.2665975094,
0.2259630263,
-0.3683645427,
-0.2478311658,
-0.3333332539,
-0.9950621724,
0.6529793739,
-0.8236493468,
-0.4867219925,
0.0843469948,
-0.3270965219,
-0.0373836681,
-0.2563284934,
-0.19256109,
0.800100863,
-0.2843822241,
0.3416262865,
0.6808371544,
-0.1147520915,
0.6899482608,
0.6041516662,
-0.3187924623,
-0.4565040767,
0.7297295928,
-0.1878374368,
0.1347786486,
0.4375546873,
-0.2162701935,
-0.0392252393,
-0.6361487508,
-0.7291839719,
-0.1613184363,
-0.8088815212,
-0.1485402286,
-0.5723283887,
0.0473834835,
-0.1552983075,
-0.2133308202,
-0.6532491446,
-0.2176153064,
-0.267198205,
-0.3948991299,
0.5180098414,
0.4647391737,
-0.0477824658,
0.2464303374,
-1.117759943,
0.4535619617,
0.7014548779,
0.5217813253,
0.0433496982,
-0.5987443924,
-0.447524488,
-0.2859578431,
-0.2580038607,
-0.8515946269,
0.2123192102,
0.3074371517,
0.5196976066,
0.6596184969,
-0.2650501728,
1.242435813,
-0.4926787913,
0.8102998137,
0.4024906158,
-0.9342186451,
0.7051984668,
-0.3537947536,
0.3193786144,
0.5648565888,
0.2973333001,
-0.4394268095,
-0.0205853358,
-0.5357964039,
-0.7974006534,
0.8419617414,
0.2599887252,
-0.2510119081,
0.19153364,
0.1175146475,
0.0772839338,
-0.0381642319,
-0.6010676622,
0.088806279,
-0.2327064127,
0.0507926419,
-0.4403107464,
0.0827485397,
-0.1672540456,
-0.2929867804,
0.475846529,
-0.0666604191,
-0.0568356514,
0.0869216248,
-0.5254485607,
-0.2624494731,
0.3391718864,
0.5180046558,
0.9399055243,
-0.6087009311,
0.1457335353,
0.4022452533,
-0.3701678813,
0.0935549587,
0.349601537,
0.4524765909,
0.0134289358,
0.5413182974,
1.0610779524,
0.4950862825,
-0.8183438182,
0.7459738851,
-0.1349939555,
-0.0695585608,
-0.1143446714,
0.050285764,
-0.086179696,
0.4355787933,
0.3258374631,
-0.2373246551,
0.1171769947,
-0.7644129395,
0.5011156201,
0.1885923594,
-0.6467274427,
-0.4119983613,
0.6992653012,
0.4491194189,
-0.2234797329,
0.6933826804,
-0.1277887374,
-0.4018168151,
0.6747299433,
0.0399006009,
0.7734880447,
-0.0136100128,
0.0630421117,
0.4052586854,
0.1683799922,
0.0199224949,
0.1956961751,
-0.3719707727,
-0.3022581339,
-1.0308641195,
-0.5884616375,
-0.3590988517,
0.2708157003,
-0.9099505544,
0.4517114758,
-0.0056037288,
-0.0682002604,
0.1964627802,
-0.2688788474,
-0.8870731592,
0.1575876474,
0.433904618,
0.9455802441,
-0.9062348604,
0.9246897697,
0.6310028434,
-0.2753231525,
-0.3508573472,
-0.4864171147,
-0.0422749408,
-0.5662023425,
0.5069736838,
0.2219451815,
0.3881396055,
-0.4288026989,
-0.1865510643,
-0.4766625166,
1.1297926903,
0.1609113067,
-0.6607578993,
0.0021268316,
0.0437575579,
0.2972866893,
-0.1309358329,
0.3690391481,
0.6790812016,
0.5540152192,
-0.0099080568,
-0.8637344837,
-0.4732550085,
-0.054308679,
-0.3132843375,
0.6140127182,
-0.3973428905,
0.5893520117,
-0.1862230152,
0.0624613687,
-0.0483138114,
0.8056157827,
-0.0344913527,
0.8334820271,
0.4115614593,
0.6662650704,
0.4633882344,
-0.0424894243,
0.9330601096,
0.0701578483,
0.1999084353,
1.5603932142,
-0.0924432501,
0.8031259775,
0.5211822987,
-0.3393268287,
0.3049567342,
0.4853521585,
0.1142561659,
0.4329815209,
-0.0751755983,
-0.2919479907,
-0.774597764,
0.0955907553,
-0.4097776115,
0.7170826793,
0.2832355499,
-0.443387419,
-0.4275996685,
0.3184824586,
-0.4838137031,
-0.0550252609,
-0.6209260821,
0.8980708122,
0.0073668649,
-0.7196310759,
0.3535361886,
-0.275436461,
0.1240704134,
-0.7454241514,
-0.0734780952,
-0.0964439958,
0.4398491681,
-0.1866018921,
-0.9814460278,
0.1164242625,
0.5332384706,
-0.3358462155,
-0.0817485899,
0.4905569851,
-0.5234392881,
-0.1477980018,
0.353967607,
0.3432429433,
0.3374104798,
-0.1653720886,
-0.3169274628,
0.5321090221,
-0.13761729,
-0.103394188,
0.7603952885,
0.4449058771,
-0.1914061755,
0.3876039088,
0.2837574482,
-0.4894299209,
0.0083000399,
0.3465949595,
0.6050710678,
-0.7047948837,
-0.4174143672,
-0.951382339,
0.6123893857,
-0.206040889,
-0.1637767553,
0.4175640941,
0.6337034702,
0.8361925483,
-0.0092562819,
0.7039303184,
0.3224526048,
-0.1359969527,
-0.494286865,
0.3338758349,
-0.6162831783,
-0.2489598244,
-0.2357122451,
-0.7581753135,
-0.0878904313,
0.2278704941,
-0.2604372501,
-0.2877294123,
0.3971534371,
0.4869232774,
-0.4185140133,
0.2946378887,
0.3871041238,
0.07277821,
0.2898321152,
0.736148417,
0.9204116464,
-0.4011277556,
0.9111425281,
-0.2797207236,
-0.4507706761,
-0.5286059976,
-1.0776234865,
-0.9393847585,
-0.498344928,
-0.3054285347,
-0.0289650392,
0.5409126282,
0.8575316668,
0.9879072905,
-0.4627979696,
-0.2835867405,
0.0547915511,
0.0823378488,
-0.3703880906,
-0.171541363,
0.4567241073,
-0.1861954629,
-0.7257214189,
0.5953599215,
0.4847233295,
-0.1068674326,
0.048749987,
-0.1487142444,
-0.0730234683,
-0.1246113852,
0.7224990129,
0.4346895516,
-0.559692204,
-0.5097084641,
-0.2155630887,
0.243435055,
0.1338421553,
0.8130559325,
-0.7054460049,
0.8745217323,
0.4696629941,
0.8151200414,
1.2840203047,
-0.0059155636,
0.6289442778,
-0.8890405893,
0.2909984291,
-0.0753320381,
0.588175416,
0.3116834164,
-0.0694933087,
0.7265725136,
0.1003479511,
-0.4911134541,
-1.0510560274,
0.2185014933,
-1.2598754168,
-0.1762365252,
0.9934925437,
-0.1603101045,
-0.4424102008,
0.2112132907,
0.110262461,
0.4950628281,
-0.1019918099,
0.6287306547,
0.7361716032,
-0.4004662633,
-0.4107598662,
-0.757267952,
0.4069189727,
0.2758616507,
-0.8021096587,
0.4373387992,
0.3557364941,
-0.0111905672,
-0.2412312031,
0.2954175174,
0.0813918039,
0.9494332671,
-0.1651141495,
0.2582333684,
-0.300578922,
-0.5631281734,
-0.330840528,
0.0736077949,
-0.1964642107,
-0.4076890349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14117v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14117v1 | An Investigation of Prompt Variations for Zero-shot LLM-based Rankers | 2024-06-20T09:03:18 | 2024-06-20T09:03:18 | Shuoqi Sun, Shengyao Zhuang, Shuai Wang, Guido Zuccon | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | We provide a systematic understanding of the impact of specific components
and wordings used in prompts on the effectiveness of rankers based on zero-shot
Large Language Models (LLMs). Several zero-shot ranking methods based on LLMs
have recently been proposed. Among many aspects, methods differ across (1) the
ranking algorithm they implement, e.g., pointwise vs. listwise, (2) the
backbone LLMs used, e.g., GPT3.5 vs. FLAN-T5, (3) the components and wording
used in prompts, e.g., the use or not of role-definition (role-playing) and the
actual words used to express this. It is currently unclear whether performance
differences are due to the underlying ranking algorithm, or because of spurious
factors such as better choice of words used in prompts. This confusion risks to
undermine future research. Through our large-scale experimentation and
analysis, we find that ranking algorithms do contribute to differences between
methods for zero-shot LLM ranking. However, so do the LLM backbones -- but even
more importantly, the choice of prompt components and wordings affect the
ranking. In fact, in our experiments, we find that, at times, these latter
elements have more impact on the ranker's effectiveness than the actual ranking
algorithms, and that differences among ranking methods become more blurred when
prompt variations are considered. | [
-0.2110975981,
-0.7660834193,
0.8414003253,
0.3041597903,
-0.1051024497,
0.0868409947,
-0.0156743675,
-0.5130908489,
0.342307061,
0.3248519599,
-0.4909830987,
-0.5301952958,
-0.8176391721,
0.71081388,
0.1896652877,
0.923029542,
0.022245219,
0.1863119751,
-0.0449167937,
-0.1995532811,
-1.0920703411,
-0.4393294752,
-0.4906213284,
-0.3102591932,
1.318857193,
0.7666296959,
0.617256403,
0.6572006941,
0.4143631458,
0.2128648907,
-0.3024539351,
-0.4386325479,
-0.6701182723,
0.7173194289,
-0.1311408281,
-0.941088438,
-0.2186560333,
0.417447716,
0.6096903086,
0.6900538206,
0.148652494,
0.1525607407,
-0.030675428,
0.269099474,
-0.8125035763,
-0.0216250215,
-0.5683845878,
0.1057116166,
-0.3078463674,
-0.6294007301,
-0.5251200795,
-0.2216129303,
0.0818312466,
-0.29620713,
0.2191165388,
0.0650565848,
0.6625062823,
0.0940309018,
-0.4133675694,
-0.2640088201,
-0.5905713439,
0.9711440206,
-0.7161306143,
-0.1371792704,
0.0759296343,
0.407012254,
-0.1595716774,
-0.1423306018,
-0.2294519395,
-0.352240026,
0.0541714542,
0.219293952,
0.0877473056,
0.3185360134,
0.619145453,
0.5073174834,
-0.5579417348,
0.7536861897,
-0.1414729059,
-0.0323961973,
0.4783671796,
0.3970335424,
0.3677071035,
-0.4177615047,
-0.0882846117,
0.0072003384,
-1.0300079584,
0.5636028647,
0.316965878,
0.694880724,
0.1074315757,
0.8388857841,
-0.5716550946,
0.684879601,
0.2235706896,
-0.1428537518,
-0.1382618099,
-0.0236325134,
-0.2729075551,
0.2537800074,
0.4875518382,
0.6588652134,
-0.1434179693,
-0.0954432935,
-0.4075087905,
-0.0718012601,
-0.0534846745,
-0.9969524145,
0.0930336788,
0.1196349338,
-0.2136136144,
-0.5599983335,
0.0321343616,
-0.4497296512,
-0.805998683,
-0.155091837,
0.8890271187,
0.0047473153,
0.326385349,
-0.2089336067,
-0.3737125695,
0.7380409837,
0.4924926758,
-0.7894214392,
-0.1143496707,
0.6984266639,
0.8909578323,
-0.4691598117,
-0.3530829549,
-0.9147822857,
-0.3802559972,
-0.5111707449,
0.8236177564,
-0.8415237069,
-0.811142683,
0.1559174359,
0.061633952,
-0.2774038017,
-0.487486124,
0.487966001,
-0.3930779696,
0.4248333275,
-0.827560544,
-0.6865898967,
0.0730771646,
0.1640328318,
-0.4776436388,
0.9260818958,
-0.1286301315,
-0.3948349059,
0.6257665157,
-0.4463623464,
-0.2530150414,
0.3756636679,
-0.3715256453,
0.0305402018,
0.4314801395,
0.0799420327,
0.4860660136,
-0.2610014379,
-0.2266112864,
-0.1181569174,
-0.9266548753,
0.4298980534,
-0.4241199791,
0.6333696246,
-0.1118478477,
-0.5116712451,
0.1885756552,
-0.4587424994,
-0.1612192839,
0.0595401637,
-0.2021078914,
-0.0901407674,
-0.2396209091,
-0.382411629,
0.1253400594,
0.113483198,
-0.6362921596,
0.4891125262,
-0.2944895923,
0.0444946662,
0.864352107,
0.4565273523,
0.4299057722,
-0.6799272299,
0.9611160755,
-0.2147289664,
0.2541028857,
-0.6126226187,
-0.8478622437,
-0.7720282674,
-0.287564069,
0.3563455045,
0.7789371014,
-0.572860837,
0.2287172526,
0.1315449774,
-0.5212334991,
-0.5361588597,
-0.1467107385,
0.3753871322,
0.4216435552,
0.2446937263,
-0.2532797158,
-0.0689250305,
-0.713535428,
-0.4108397961,
-0.150093779,
0.0295325834,
0.5837942362,
0.1578469425,
0.2692826986,
0.9912103415,
-0.5662157536,
0.031878937,
-0.5167361498,
0.3804856539,
0.5975516438,
0.08680325,
0.5924727917,
-0.2936734259,
-0.617038846,
-0.4844671488,
-0.5307196379,
-0.6254333854,
-0.2534417808,
0.1031792313,
0.2569740713,
0.1886488348,
-0.511202395,
0.4728836119,
0.3114874959,
-0.3400069177,
0.8674253225,
-0.1319578588,
0.4450226426,
-0.7057765722,
-0.1370179951,
-0.0359444618,
0.1194354892,
-0.7393843532,
0.2879863679,
-0.0995419994,
-0.0426842459,
-0.5212385654,
0.473814249,
-0.3559086025,
0.0088933213,
-0.24499695,
0.2368478626,
0.0207308102,
0.2926406264,
-0.3791335523,
1.130381465,
0.678257823,
-0.6347841024,
0.0755122304,
-0.1719480306,
-0.1737318039,
0.8874700069,
-0.9143866301,
0.0142659061,
-0.1876965016,
0.0917658359,
-1.4304363728,
-0.0333321877,
0.3252879977,
-0.3617718518,
0.4260363579,
-0.2490847707,
-0.3080880642,
0.0763312429,
-0.8225873709,
0.3338887095,
0.4042933583,
-0.2558928132,
-0.0890459493,
-0.0981914848,
-0.3633749187,
-0.8607504368,
-0.3419018686,
0.3012927771,
-0.3369787633,
-0.2805985212,
0.3159330189,
-0.5233817697,
-0.2328826934,
-0.4403022826,
-0.3717062175,
0.3841649294,
0.2868077159,
0.3828319013,
0.3805073798,
-0.1952944547,
-0.1113008931,
-0.0772118196,
-0.0976791158,
-0.0988945663,
0.1330150813,
0.3746947646,
0.2002748698,
-0.525404036,
-0.5374829173,
0.2478972971,
0.5347034335,
-0.1433865428,
0.6689533591,
0.158493489,
0.3301314712,
-0.1413898617,
-0.6756734848,
-0.1837382466,
-0.4654816687,
-0.1005900204,
-0.2373134047,
-1.1103053093,
0.7252889872,
0.1326789856,
0.1388246119,
0.4805421233,
0.3537740707,
-0.1680563539,
0.9383625984,
0.6370472908,
-0.0264868066,
0.6229703426,
0.0694803968,
0.0536779761,
-0.8058686256,
-0.1313294619,
-0.7643044591,
-0.7743625045,
-0.9894186854,
-0.4412420988,
0.2816469967,
0.3023968339,
-0.0579807684,
0.0135627799,
-0.4518438578,
0.6357138753,
0.3286955953,
-0.2529028356,
0.1616838723,
-0.1851207912,
-0.3610107899,
-0.0493249446,
-0.6306663156,
-0.3144448698,
1.0729213953,
0.1127182022,
0.6104623079,
0.3007121682,
0.8978678584,
0.4728672206,
0.0767271146,
-1.1301366091,
0.578917563,
0.2104400098,
-0.3119034171,
-0.5131001472,
-0.3150734603,
-1.2246730328,
0.3231022656,
-0.1138140485,
-0.8968349695,
0.3473645151,
-0.3555476964,
-0.410183996,
-0.0631099716,
-0.3978108168,
0.6574579477,
-0.0953162238,
-0.237328738,
0.2276237458,
-0.5683512092,
0.0500781424,
0.1862208396,
-0.2353267223,
-0.1866208166,
-0.05318214,
0.5281602144,
-0.2891948223,
0.9418811798,
-0.2934438586,
-0.2029810846,
0.113262549,
0.0996660069,
0.6291652322,
0.1710450947,
-0.4030112922,
0.2129867524,
-0.0669122711,
-0.4395751357,
-0.6766550541,
0.810982883,
-0.8500047922,
-1.1305015087,
-0.6697197556,
-0.4541663527,
-0.105884023,
0.1478997171,
0.4289701879,
0.5828348994,
-0.1480794549,
0.2879660428,
0.7938085794,
-0.5092043877,
0.5928449631,
0.8679367304,
-0.2775632143,
-0.1187369823,
0.721611619,
0.6930178404,
0.1722179949,
0.6270258427,
0.2294930518,
-0.2298997045,
-0.5781538486,
-0.5239881277,
0.3033645451,
-0.6176704764,
-0.0960808098,
-0.2291234583,
-0.0763898119,
-0.3239885271,
-0.295521915,
0.2181351781,
-0.6619874835,
-0.2903422713,
-0.2281959057,
0.4524593353,
1.0008392334,
0.2016629726,
0.2787955701,
-0.3337756097,
-0.0590019152,
0.4028802216,
0.3607194424,
-0.1967433095,
-0.7156330347,
-0.0334706642,
-0.4142921269,
-0.1192500442,
-1.1984733343,
-0.0620988011,
-0.1700918972,
0.9139953256,
0.4131733775,
0.0596591868,
0.4067720473,
-0.3816297352,
1.5251973867,
-0.0059452844,
-0.7317195535,
0.4406229258,
-0.6574947834,
0.5984099507,
0.5753524303,
0.1807894111,
-0.823364079,
-0.5928034186,
-0.2590013742,
-0.7759518027,
0.9551343918,
0.1293035001,
0.138761133,
-0.1308379173,
0.6690676808,
0.2956314087,
0.1867456585,
-0.4854842126,
-0.7006533742,
0.0711833984,
0.4058813751,
-0.2291350067,
-0.6726604104,
0.0628774092,
-0.0045713969,
0.4399785399,
0.1245401651,
0.1299662888,
0.1909635663,
-0.2138672918,
-0.0469372049,
0.6659293175,
0.9834638238,
0.6973307133,
-0.315808773,
0.0945864022,
0.258870095,
-0.2372330129,
0.1853353083,
-0.127113983,
-0.4990230501,
0.2714869082,
0.3486824036,
0.9028815031,
0.4352918565,
-0.3781422675,
0.5302847028,
0.0396566465,
0.0354101509,
0.1789822876,
0.2985733747,
-0.4250293672,
0.1903996319,
0.5162121654,
-0.18000561,
0.1392481327,
-0.4793590009,
-0.0414440744,
0.3737386465,
-0.5090776086,
-0.3551355898,
0.3551815152,
0.1421673,
-0.5583380461,
0.2640387118,
-0.3887377381,
-0.1235126033,
0.636282146,
0.4858312905,
0.8480756879,
-0.6018927693,
0.5654124618,
0.0008719245,
0.1575444043,
-0.0250369422,
0.2420451343,
-0.0788755193,
-0.3042212427,
-0.5653246045,
-0.4441789091,
-0.7772393823,
0.168533355,
-0.613188386,
0.453260541,
-0.4680199623,
-0.2187902927,
-0.1410956681,
0.248559013,
-0.6179733276,
-0.1214702427,
0.1592946053,
0.7759360671,
-0.6609988809,
0.1952510029,
0.7784299254,
-0.5879773498,
-0.8138354421,
0.259601742,
0.2830385268,
-0.6409109831,
0.5575762391,
0.3771952987,
-0.1621640623,
-0.0973760337,
-0.3310611546,
-0.8497686982,
1.3295917511,
0.1932044476,
-0.3037420511,
0.1124973446,
0.3867241442,
0.5406970978,
-0.3931736052,
0.9300125241,
0.156284824,
0.3227634728,
0.2967986763,
-0.9943491817,
0.0532296821,
-0.0158243831,
0.1852298975,
-0.0060797846,
-0.6156767607,
0.9865186214,
-0.0899722874,
-0.2626497447,
0.2092237324,
0.1247388348,
0.529361248,
0.5070381761,
0.1922545135,
0.1619156301,
0.756329298,
0.0401604846,
1.0127097368,
-0.3915244043,
0.2065885961,
0.7992573977,
-0.6813560724,
0.7761364579,
0.3078252673,
-0.0289867558,
0.6631366014,
0.6539892554,
-0.1106162965,
0.2442547977,
0.3745486438,
-0.2608103454,
-0.164284721,
-0.4630695879,
-0.3690782189,
0.5081525445,
0.0569173209,
-0.2649923265,
-0.4078079462,
-0.2598354518,
0.1374128461,
-0.2931161523,
-0.3845355511,
0.6419590116,
0.0850870311,
-0.727186203,
0.5428002477,
0.2004273087,
0.7434154153,
-0.5719473362,
-0.0926640928,
-0.5437783003,
-0.4655545354,
-0.1267086565,
-0.7657979131,
-0.4464940429,
0.1648435295,
-0.3002559245,
-0.4566690028,
0.6045123339,
0.0759693906,
-0.3249465823,
0.0203511901,
0.8063046336,
0.4035918713,
-0.0438522361,
-0.5510265827,
0.0762046427,
-0.2696193159,
-0.3345637023,
0.6437733769,
0.5363160372,
-0.1269934028,
0.2901007831,
0.5349898338,
0.0496128388,
-0.0355943367,
0.3691443801,
0.6351091266,
-0.7866428494,
-0.4956724644,
-0.8989936113,
0.4180348814,
-0.0963287279,
-0.3126298189,
1.092925787,
0.443947196,
0.3532820642,
0.1035991386,
0.4898637235,
0.1932826042,
0.3257279098,
-0.4073421061,
0.647331655,
-0.4039724767,
0.6386064887,
-0.2745393813,
-1.1062031984,
-0.3924440742,
0.1076771766,
-0.4756172001,
0.1048440784,
0.6401587129,
0.8566515446,
0.5951449275,
-0.222999692,
0.7300384641,
0.1383448243,
0.3505785763,
0.1935873628,
1.0235540867,
-0.0632612333,
0.3279757798,
0.1222564802,
-0.3152926862,
-0.5653599501,
-0.873801887,
-0.8530538082,
-0.0890536532,
-0.2629850209,
0.0451080501,
0.1416489482,
0.9085242152,
0.2671257257,
-0.6427513957,
-0.3443139791,
0.2234977484,
0.5197706819,
-0.3442419469,
-0.2914592028,
0.0221193247,
-0.5979329348,
-0.6928742528,
0.7371003628,
0.4721013904,
-0.3174875677,
-0.274815321,
0.1345852911,
0.0892711729,
0.5413933396,
0.7595081329,
0.235430479,
-0.9680414796,
-0.5299496651,
0.4924355447,
-0.1938729584,
0.1762273014,
0.9086783528,
-0.7914063931,
0.4583718479,
0.7439219356,
0.2872332335,
-0.0221030414,
0.1251161695,
0.4622996449,
-0.9476374388,
-0.2747095525,
0.0417083576,
0.1778678447,
0.2326685786,
-0.4959957302,
0.2324810326,
0.3951592743,
-0.7853250504,
-0.8704972267,
0.4031258523,
-1.0815219879,
-0.3192458153,
1.5074580908,
-0.0230226237,
0.2004369646,
-0.0481966212,
-0.1806757599,
0.0690281913,
-0.711214602,
0.8232733011,
0.88477391,
-0.5741443634,
-0.3893273473,
-0.6195579767,
0.4295508564,
0.5254611373,
-0.2702027261,
-0.1932724118,
0.5156785846,
0.3181170225,
0.1209440157,
0.4862918854,
0.0749715939,
0.0802080482,
-0.453066051,
-0.256124258,
-0.1049111709,
-0.2255496383,
-0.9832572937,
0.3496035337,
0.4608189762,
0.0342974886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14115v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14115v1 | Take the essence and discard the dross: A Rethinking on Data Selection for Fine-Tuning Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T08:58:58 | 2024-06-20T08:58:58 | Ziche Liu, Rui Ke, Feng Jiang, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data selection for fine-tuning Large Language Models (LLMs) aims to select a
high-quality subset from a given candidate dataset to train a Pending Fine-tune
Model (PFM) into a Selective-Enhanced Model (SEM). It can improve the model
performance and accelerate the training process. Although a few surveys have
investigated related works of data selection, there is a lack of comprehensive
comparison between existing methods due to their various experimental settings.
To address this issue, we first propose a three-stage scheme for data selection
and comprehensively review existing works according to this scheme. Then, we
design a unified comparing method with ratio-based efficiency indicators and
ranking-based feasibility indicators to overcome the difficulty of comparing
various models with diverse experimental settings. After an in-depth
comparative analysis, we find that the more targeted method with data-specific
and model-specific quality labels has higher efficiency, but the introduction
of additional noise information should be avoided when designing selection
algorithms. Finally, we summarize the trends in data selection and highlight
the short-term and long-term challenges to guide future research. | [
-0.5393379927,
-0.8415785432,
0.5457894802,
-0.1592679173,
-0.474970758,
0.0901292264,
-0.4552991986,
-0.316211015,
-0.0754727349,
0.5663437247,
-0.5080664754,
-0.4651761353,
-0.4052167833,
0.2597754002,
-0.431677103,
0.6953848004,
-0.1641869694,
0.0872280374,
-0.0460387953,
0.1545562297,
-0.3668762743,
-0.1676361114,
-0.7846536636,
-0.4674041271,
0.4945300817,
0.4844863415,
0.7008678913,
0.8617162108,
0.7255311012,
0.2284683883,
-0.2745960057,
0.4963270128,
-0.7285858393,
0.2625063658,
0.0707776472,
-0.4055962265,
-0.312672019,
0.0627956167,
0.7128509283,
0.8529003859,
0.1311925203,
0.2386493534,
0.1258409023,
0.859605372,
-0.4343456328,
-0.0631981269,
-0.8125383258,
0.0654940382,
-0.228437826,
0.0557813533,
-0.2954657078,
-0.2801913321,
-0.0547896065,
-0.2560233474,
0.1925946027,
0.1931368411,
0.7795657516,
0.2428241819,
-0.1621739417,
-0.0162572432,
-0.7413294911,
0.9830660224,
-0.8205640912,
0.5673732758,
0.3838990033,
0.1505163014,
-0.1233324558,
-0.6066200137,
-0.1838536263,
-0.5213212371,
0.2198795825,
-0.1772130728,
0.0504759662,
-0.0595630184,
0.1159981266,
0.7503062487,
-0.5486112237,
0.5129079223,
-0.3747095764,
-0.2486227155,
0.7118135095,
0.1587792486,
-0.0498734079,
0.1372590959,
-0.1219531968,
-0.0779852271,
-0.8938951492,
-0.2406606972,
0.3651737571,
0.6924090385,
0.1785289645,
0.4264342785,
-0.6590165496,
0.8751616478,
-0.0675870031,
-0.3290352225,
0.373393476,
-0.2341053486,
-0.4629108906,
-0.4046595693,
0.741948843,
0.1191667169,
0.2815239131,
-0.1896307468,
-0.5753396749,
-0.1713757664,
0.142462641,
-0.7898741364,
-0.1169410795,
0.2477908731,
-0.5464369059,
-0.2615772188,
-0.1214024872,
-0.8028858304,
-0.1018007323,
-0.8304787278,
0.0454359688,
-0.1245627329,
-0.3671809733,
0.2873298824,
0.229901433,
-0.1235142648,
0.3282034993,
-0.7314650416,
0.0327148549,
0.7810857892,
0.6501027942,
-0.403308481,
-0.3849552572,
-0.3569375575,
-0.0751408488,
-0.5727857947,
0.907968998,
-0.8518723249,
-0.3404080272,
-0.0104467282,
-0.2031161189,
0.0164849535,
-0.7058444023,
0.8167635202,
-0.504625082,
-0.1240334287,
-0.1582883298,
-0.5734024644,
-0.1130842566,
-0.0688760951,
-0.7952924967,
1.1604493856,
0.2075158209,
-0.6447470784,
0.7945661545,
-0.0435174406,
-0.5037642121,
-0.0918626487,
-0.1995725185,
-0.6727429032,
0.2025107145,
0.1766235083,
0.6014763117,
-0.5239239335,
0.5151436329,
-0.5382145047,
-0.5342963934,
0.2024517506,
-0.4745316803,
0.3233731985,
0.7602697611,
-0.0417624488,
-0.0447341837,
-0.8905280828,
0.1220723093,
0.0195939001,
-0.6445978284,
-0.1890588105,
-0.0226596203,
-0.0980172753,
0.1435485184,
0.1243373901,
-0.2553709149,
0.1977669746,
-0.3010545373,
0.4794949591,
0.7258123755,
-0.225602597,
0.5063755512,
-0.5465334058,
0.4083951414,
-0.2941763401,
0.2426725477,
0.2476160675,
-0.0491802357,
-0.7741580606,
-0.3513191044,
0.6630340219,
0.3044011295,
-0.4035217762,
0.4681996107,
-0.1815406531,
-0.5421376824,
-0.7973645926,
0.4180568755,
0.1671344936,
0.1388139427,
0.1593097895,
-0.1168507412,
-0.5560141802,
-0.9358669519,
-0.0163037982,
0.0027768039,
0.1806971878,
0.3706596196,
0.3071050346,
-0.0715638399,
0.7294008136,
-0.4130870402,
-0.0394827053,
-0.6077247262,
-0.307387948,
0.3018388748,
0.3347307146,
0.4501447082,
-0.5666754842,
-0.4510534108,
0.0529239774,
-0.3384506702,
-0.2163942605,
-0.0377954729,
-0.1392814964,
-0.039602723,
0.5163595676,
-0.3011811972,
0.1418499798,
0.3307684362,
-0.0197994858,
0.3016896248,
-0.162277773,
0.3596595228,
-0.7386192083,
0.0563048236,
0.0064678984,
-0.1316419393,
-0.501922071,
-0.1099738032,
0.3372496367,
-0.0231541935,
-0.3035002053,
0.5189518929,
-0.4555075467,
-0.0112745417,
-0.4799641669,
0.1303073764,
-0.1911383718,
0.2657977939,
-0.1166857257,
0.7499953508,
0.7836823463,
-0.7855035067,
0.2854133844,
0.0371376872,
-0.634113431,
0.2455471605,
-0.3033285141,
0.2209299058,
-0.1031540334,
-0.0546091124,
-0.8704211712,
0.0075618764,
-0.052339498,
-0.2763556838,
0.63682127,
-0.1384741515,
-0.6608240008,
-0.4371240735,
-0.3250922561,
0.0265159085,
0.362408936,
-0.3938413858,
0.0296656732,
0.5528600812,
-0.3731456995,
-0.2924172878,
-0.5299216509,
0.1569211334,
-0.5225488544,
-0.4179490209,
0.1421788335,
-0.0844223648,
-0.324837327,
-0.4674938023,
-0.3474639952,
0.0406014174,
0.3732834458,
-0.2915901244,
0.2386856526,
-0.056201838,
0.0683509037,
0.2622648478,
-0.2978795469,
-0.3589891493,
-0.0035190736,
0.2890662253,
0.3213095069,
-0.265526861,
-0.5620608926,
0.1597914994,
0.2978430688,
-0.354352355,
0.2681982517,
0.4320803285,
-0.0265022479,
-0.4049830139,
-0.7731441855,
-0.3128476143,
-0.4193155468,
0.4438817799,
-0.4859128892,
-0.9759039283,
0.1834556311,
-0.3220093846,
0.3122263849,
0.2671743035,
0.5371981263,
0.2243331373,
1.1397697926,
0.6095657349,
-0.3579757214,
0.6870951056,
-0.1430874318,
0.1627951711,
-0.783470571,
0.0600729361,
-0.9298504591,
-0.3972210586,
-0.4140436947,
-0.1215457767,
-0.0671742558,
0.1868631542,
-0.244222343,
0.2055607587,
-0.4204944968,
0.3627992272,
0.1709989011,
0.1470107585,
0.4559908211,
0.3237442076,
-0.0055680675,
-0.0537398458,
-0.5397361517,
-0.7097652555,
1.2461330891,
0.4408978224,
0.9350991845,
-0.1168104261,
0.5033994317,
0.1248311773,
0.2181874663,
-0.6318783164,
0.6246667504,
-0.4279102087,
-0.50735569,
-0.381213814,
-0.5778455734,
-1.0283272266,
0.5287962556,
-0.0631135479,
-0.5035561919,
0.0133370869,
-0.2097909302,
-0.4399259686,
0.2262252569,
-0.4688029587,
0.4306429923,
-0.2066909224,
-0.2625109553,
-0.3766184151,
-0.2622764409,
0.1528516561,
-0.3186692595,
0.377512157,
-0.4959539473,
-0.0376151986,
0.7878441811,
-0.0835225359,
0.5523185134,
-0.1083196402,
-0.2773715258,
0.086039111,
0.169029817,
0.6236873269,
0.1743803769,
-0.4871652126,
0.0037633276,
-0.1651855409,
-0.0746892989,
-0.2288627774,
0.7303491235,
-0.5781334043,
-0.5062217116,
0.0411226936,
-0.4114757478,
-0.4841854572,
0.2356557399,
-0.0999841765,
0.4471997619,
-0.0576944873,
0.5280398726,
0.6637900472,
-0.0477418713,
0.1469736844,
0.6423524022,
-0.2474385649,
-0.4779373705,
0.8945792913,
0.2376426309,
0.412931174,
0.2743764222,
0.0631287172,
-0.0954359919,
-1.1782255173,
-0.3657081127,
0.2573666275,
-0.5243878365,
-0.3238118291,
-0.4868345261,
-0.064643845,
-0.3545041978,
0.0336418301,
-0.6137341857,
-0.2045926601,
-0.4169271886,
-0.1214883253,
0.2362363786,
0.4862348139,
-0.0515924618,
0.0836828798,
-0.3828960359,
0.5140716434,
0.0834726691,
0.52592206,
0.0030609292,
-0.794592917,
-0.2954664528,
0.0161474403,
-0.2368176281,
-0.2932332456,
0.3593919575,
0.212456122,
0.9140149355,
0.3596151769,
-0.1590593308,
0.6698694825,
-0.307952702,
0.3691323102,
-0.2438971996,
-0.3035922945,
0.6080213189,
-0.1164699197,
-0.0429601744,
0.9662359357,
0.0664178059,
-0.322525382,
-0.5224570036,
-0.4831571579,
-0.9596652389,
0.7068324089,
0.1824995726,
0.0665573403,
0.2329723686,
0.5068348646,
0.5667117834,
0.2308566272,
-0.4012624621,
-0.4478771389,
0.4008690417,
-0.0731744021,
-0.1652157605,
-0.2204944193,
0.159600094,
-0.3554793596,
0.6522562504,
-0.1285338849,
-0.0925541669,
-0.0386348478,
-0.1654680818,
-0.2677536607,
0.3539704382,
0.1632064283,
0.9199568629,
-0.1101528481,
-0.1562457681,
0.2581319809,
-0.4908000529,
-0.094090648,
0.1441793889,
-0.3794433475,
0.0222942568,
0.1800329536,
1.0257036686,
0.3522196412,
-0.5866550803,
0.0499009229,
-0.0259288605,
-0.3077278733,
0.1229399592,
0.3460856974,
-0.1118936911,
0.2768124938,
0.262010932,
-0.3490890861,
0.0969482735,
-0.4705970883,
0.116966106,
0.5318211317,
-0.1092060059,
-0.0040351162,
0.3310675621,
0.1657993793,
-0.1458322853,
0.6477270722,
-0.0392978527,
-0.0905204639,
0.4836866856,
0.2808940411,
0.6428554654,
-0.0644540712,
0.0323192813,
0.3685840964,
0.2504573762,
-0.4962983727,
0.3867685199,
0.0606361106,
-0.5749719739,
-0.5159211159,
-0.8639266491,
-0.2124734223,
0.6610799432,
-0.6726689935,
0.3872621953,
-0.19152987,
-0.0911358967,
-0.1276490539,
0.4993379414,
-0.6685823798,
0.3210528493,
0.3009941578,
0.9435005784,
-0.7420185804,
0.8891134262,
0.3928150535,
0.0414358266,
-0.6103973985,
-0.0156122306,
-0.0848887414,
-0.7350369692,
0.308573246,
-0.0520603545,
0.2696118653,
0.047341682,
-0.5650398731,
-1.0802856684,
1.1336038113,
0.5115745068,
-0.8036577702,
0.1477658749,
-0.0570910312,
0.3639601767,
-0.4447257817,
0.0856833011,
1.0848907232,
0.5174262524,
0.2835037708,
-1.1299085617,
-0.1937711686,
0.0680485219,
0.100045763,
0.3193705082,
-0.7671993375,
0.8155232668,
-0.0451096967,
-0.2198490649,
0.2669802308,
0.5917375684,
0.3315649033,
0.0910021439,
0.4226006567,
0.4784286022,
0.7986578345,
-0.1038279012,
0.7379478812,
-0.2246981859,
0.5060060024,
0.9045475125,
-0.4809738696,
0.8777539134,
0.4151104987,
-0.7065091729,
-0.123880662,
1.1075322628,
-0.2705552876,
0.7021137476,
0.3436373174,
0.0215765722,
-0.5043037534,
0.0620050468,
-0.4778037965,
0.3626592755,
0.3044610918,
-0.306858927,
-0.307952404,
-0.0987934843,
-0.0447986424,
-0.2498395592,
-0.4614807963,
0.9520304203,
0.2196885645,
-0.5828844309,
0.7136500478,
0.0649941117,
0.6599449515,
-0.4343812764,
0.2659157217,
-0.4317935109,
0.0547213182,
-0.0878304541,
-0.7774373293,
0.0735067874,
-0.0133125773,
0.0327746719,
-0.2581646144,
0.8656992316,
-0.3812095821,
-0.5079597831,
0.0914459527,
0.6249468923,
0.2889204621,
-0.1769388765,
-0.8506706357,
0.512524426,
0.2327496707,
-0.4498529136,
0.4054504633,
0.508262217,
0.1933921874,
0.7507833242,
0.6559752226,
0.478092134,
-0.4142815471,
0.4828278124,
0.9106060266,
-0.7002951503,
-0.4010264277,
-0.8417896032,
0.3550578952,
0.0072063743,
-0.2749674022,
0.4720844626,
0.611415267,
0.9409316182,
0.201034829,
0.9025606513,
0.1059263125,
0.9089211226,
-0.6825131774,
0.5228711963,
-0.603364408,
0.4143509865,
-0.2746774852,
-0.9868532419,
-0.3569525182,
0.6165398955,
-0.3856445551,
0.2328805178,
0.6380198002,
0.9533854723,
-0.0931724608,
0.1061122045,
0.4150182903,
0.1156375408,
0.1828880459,
0.4606179893,
0.8137506247,
-0.132290557,
0.4222997129,
-0.1922980249,
-0.1627105922,
-0.3277393281,
-0.6224393249,
-0.8880933523,
-0.5626886487,
-0.304148525,
0.0106236646,
-0.074612394,
0.7630242705,
0.7086704969,
-0.7485120893,
-0.227254793,
0.1551929116,
0.1969658434,
-0.1011283249,
-0.0921813101,
0.3417981267,
-0.4546999335,
-0.7830028534,
0.6078332663,
0.2607047558,
0.0581264719,
-0.2462434322,
0.0544790179,
0.1354974061,
-0.1121578366,
0.4471306801,
-0.0577497073,
-0.603261292,
0.0477117822,
-0.3187391758,
-0.2612898648,
0.1623724699,
0.9703400731,
-0.6211087704,
0.0748211145,
0.4722221196,
0.7056416869,
0.3269353509,
-0.3289046884,
0.3920893073,
-0.2079689354,
-0.0051881038,
0.079485856,
0.3547019064,
0.3432482183,
-0.1964014918,
0.510112524,
-0.0611160472,
-0.7325491905,
-1.0766130686,
0.1673530936,
-0.6571257114,
-0.4888409674,
1.5565353632,
0.2543221712,
-0.0896441117,
-0.2206257284,
-0.4519995451,
0.1428075135,
-0.4687542319,
0.885956049,
0.6669710875,
0.0050159376,
-0.0191249289,
-0.9397152066,
0.6230924129,
0.2955645025,
-0.6761232018,
0.4551489055,
0.4794136882,
0.2917169929,
-0.488820374,
0.3106151223,
-0.0970843211,
-0.0557405278,
-0.3607982695,
-0.3916739523,
-0.0723767877,
-0.3963626027,
-0.4456590414,
0.1745768785,
0.5790101886,
0.2533504367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14106v1 | EasyECR: A Library for Easy Implementation and Evaluation of Event Coreference Resolution Models | 2024-06-20T08:40:21 | 2024-06-20T08:40:21 | Yuncong Li, Tianhua Xu, Sheng-hua Zhong, Haiqin Yang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Event Coreference Resolution (ECR) is the task of clustering event mentions
that refer to the same real-world event. Despite significant advancements, ECR
research faces two main challenges: limited generalizability across domains due
to narrow dataset evaluations, and difficulties in comparing models within
diverse ECR pipelines. To address these issues, we develop EasyECR, the first
open-source library designed to standardize data structures and abstract ECR
pipelines for easy implementation and fair evaluation. More specifically,
EasyECR integrates seven representative pipelines and ten popular benchmark
datasets, enabling model evaluations on various datasets and promoting the
development of robust ECR pipelines. By conducting extensive evaluation via our
EasyECR, we find that, \lowercase\expandafter{\romannumeral1}) the
representative ECR pipelines cannot generalize across multiple datasets, hence
evaluating ECR pipelines on multiple datasets is necessary,
\lowercase\expandafter{\romannumeral2}) all models in ECR pipelines have a
great effect on pipeline performance, therefore, when one model in ECR
pipelines are compared, it is essential to ensure that the other models remain
consistent. Additionally, reproducing ECR results is not trivial, and the
developed library can help reduce this discrepancy. The experimental results
provide valuable baselines for future research. | [
-0.5873945951,
-0.3078670502,
0.5927869081,
-0.2341023237,
-0.2673538327,
-0.2306858152,
-0.6059330106,
-0.5899295211,
-0.272788316,
0.4248000979,
-0.299190402,
-0.690343082,
-0.7143219709,
0.2439529747,
-0.6229082346,
1.1800072193,
-0.0100047393,
-0.0083905915,
-0.0747767687,
-0.3374442458,
0.1137287095,
-0.8447768092,
-0.6906683445,
-0.3272309601,
0.5752431154,
0.5249099135,
0.3267403245,
0.8574661613,
0.9753855467,
0.2865915895,
-0.3912811279,
0.0810387433,
-0.2636672854,
0.0328660794,
-0.2757835984,
-0.1448655277,
-0.4657866061,
-0.4661575854,
0.406799525,
0.6424708962,
-0.5010716319,
0.3511607945,
0.2655373514,
0.6037255526,
-0.7555785775,
0.2292001694,
-0.6358166933,
-0.2491292655,
-0.3475250602,
0.2219552249,
-0.2930384874,
-0.1301430613,
0.2479869425,
-0.523332715,
0.8688933253,
0.2468277365,
0.5794849396,
0.171793431,
-0.4514329433,
-0.673699379,
-1.131478548,
0.7610087991,
-0.5391760468,
0.4325115085,
-0.2517591119,
0.4510110617,
0.088702336,
-1.1388437748,
-0.6302936077,
0.2890345752,
-0.1155256703,
-0.2555477321,
-0.4134539068,
0.3040033579,
0.2957156301,
0.479239285,
-0.4302410185,
-0.0848314613,
-0.4160090685,
-0.2193702757,
0.2205404639,
0.4016874135,
-0.0903464258,
-0.3419561684,
0.0391018204,
0.0197318066,
-0.4885241091,
0.0122980308,
0.0218821131,
0.617197156,
-0.0590916462,
0.4735349119,
-0.312659651,
0.4962719679,
0.4951295257,
0.1825936884,
0.0022745109,
-0.4271887243,
0.0623893328,
0.1805157959,
0.5907821059,
0.3970451951,
-0.1581006348,
-0.1917590648,
0.0027701785,
0.1951903105,
-0.0382592864,
-1.1041662693,
-0.3238539398,
0.4197128415,
-0.5403994918,
0.1784227788,
0.102055639,
-0.6884211898,
-0.280095011,
-0.5493641496,
0.051372271,
-0.2058777958,
0.0834841579,
-0.0127459308,
-0.155769214,
0.1941984445,
0.3905480206,
-0.2504047751,
0.6651087999,
1.0655847788,
0.6254358292,
-0.1733251512,
-0.1017762944,
-0.6787309647,
0.0469926223,
0.2733488679,
1.0137233734,
-0.4101762772,
-0.2965769172,
-0.1369630545,
0.2156414092,
0.1630766392,
-0.5974009633,
1.1886159182,
-0.2945753634,
-0.1178392991,
-0.1463621408,
-0.8243493438,
-0.0714340359,
0.0872471407,
-0.7716780305,
0.7517338395,
-0.5039645433,
-0.9234838486,
0.5521408319,
-0.4888115525,
0.1488863528,
0.1253254861,
-0.2433896214,
-0.4930291772,
-0.0789849311,
0.0229103509,
0.2843028307,
-0.426171422,
0.2193487883,
-0.219811365,
-0.1040906161,
-0.0982709527,
0.0036292719,
0.3331954777,
0.2993027866,
-0.2349409461,
0.2836146653,
-1.0146204233,
0.0099806804,
-0.3736176193,
-0.0241062846,
-0.7637112737,
0.4229901731,
0.339731425,
0.0555615686,
0.2605388761,
-0.7574484944,
0.1296741962,
-0.0838684291,
0.1856419295,
0.3063002229,
-0.0516263768,
0.4320872426,
-0.2340515852,
-0.029725885,
0.1260553449,
0.0312105753,
-0.2161246091,
-0.2504229546,
-0.9994294643,
-0.423353523,
0.246275872,
0.3893209994,
-0.2264813185,
0.5836542845,
-0.388736099,
-0.8199079633,
-0.460514605,
0.2421250939,
0.4514213502,
0.3986291289,
0.3449085951,
-0.4437386394,
-0.9245398045,
-0.8588345051,
-0.1793884188,
-0.0444499552,
-0.2272995263,
0.167658031,
0.5563907027,
-0.1233736947,
1.0420387983,
-0.2198600769,
-0.3277367353,
-0.3105983138,
0.5100787878,
0.5197218657,
0.4497685432,
0.234163776,
-0.571438849,
-0.4516141713,
0.1637662798,
-0.3444452882,
0.0298511796,
0.2692997158,
-0.0151182488,
-0.1822798103,
0.063165471,
-0.3436038792,
0.4632749856,
0.5672721863,
-0.4045804739,
0.6687841415,
-0.0708736405,
0.3508035839,
-0.7757229805,
0.3702367842,
-0.0943259224,
-0.3131740689,
-0.6310141087,
0.2434511483,
0.1636122465,
-0.1274367273,
-0.6537162662,
0.5632252693,
-0.3209055662,
0.3012955189,
-0.2488265932,
-0.0051651979,
-0.0440083034,
0.1064045727,
0.3771109581,
0.3502646983,
0.5488653779,
-1.0256954432,
0.3584294319,
0.4747106135,
-0.5544218421,
0.7942390442,
-0.8442738056,
0.5276466608,
-0.1370930821,
0.3155390918,
-0.593072772,
-0.0735385865,
0.0986264125,
-0.1146353707,
0.001367491,
-0.5048465133,
-0.2004065514,
-0.2910375595,
-0.0666818619,
0.416885674,
0.1322312504,
-0.7795494795,
0.823372066,
0.1853512973,
-0.3303561211,
-0.4083375633,
-0.4483620226,
-0.13966766,
-0.1674654633,
-0.5011212826,
0.499774605,
-0.4930703044,
-0.3182528615,
0.1366120726,
-0.128173992,
-0.3355098963,
-0.6269533038,
0.4749492109,
0.157272175,
-0.106127508,
-0.1150506735,
-0.2210670412,
-0.3480890691,
-0.2460746467,
-0.0105889374,
0.1956569254,
-0.4728478789,
-0.5469211936,
-0.433806479,
0.5160529017,
0.4722119868,
-0.0421173275,
0.6831516623,
0.2461190373,
-0.5747560859,
-0.0507651679,
-0.8865548372,
-0.1234288067,
-0.4316230118,
0.2047401369,
-0.5625265837,
-1.0159693956,
0.7207657695,
-0.1506354958,
0.3297872245,
0.3059412539,
0.626704216,
0.1174976379,
1.0155614614,
0.5178049803,
0.2780304849,
0.2152801454,
-0.1687524021,
0.0817519575,
-1.0507221222,
-0.0527515151,
-1.041852951,
-0.1496874541,
-0.3373152018,
-0.4350637197,
0.2277454734,
0.1672462672,
-0.4095972478,
0.4594802856,
-0.7956189513,
0.5771077275,
0.3132993877,
-0.0896913186,
0.7372618318,
-0.2764352262,
-0.0348418653,
-0.2917410135,
-0.7109165788,
-0.8490666151,
0.9493641853,
0.082399942,
0.8066456914,
0.0082907891,
0.8351172209,
0.331176728,
0.5310583711,
-0.8556239009,
0.2762526572,
-0.3218187094,
-0.7901029587,
-0.0220568217,
-0.3412668109,
-0.9483653307,
-0.0174866784,
0.0974738449,
-0.8132109642,
0.8221987486,
0.2648525834,
-0.430449903,
0.5440359116,
-0.3652074933,
0.8569911122,
0.1255587339,
-0.2631120384,
-0.0474034101,
-0.3485766053,
0.1798747331,
0.1730152816,
0.6894287467,
-0.0952036157,
0.111181207,
0.8800157309,
-0.4502283633,
0.649825573,
0.0366701372,
0.3736391664,
0.7217110395,
0.2509886324,
0.8158516288,
-0.2623831928,
-0.4673041701,
0.3816825151,
0.3739973009,
-0.2257816344,
-0.3712447286,
0.8827903867,
-0.7205883861,
-0.2744809389,
-0.3142387569,
-0.0358022526,
0.2945722938,
-0.0340750813,
0.3867444694,
0.6213729382,
-0.6583116651,
0.3585799634,
0.427557826,
0.3489620984,
0.4609588087,
0.6623407006,
-0.1159626022,
-0.5003722906,
0.5055059195,
0.0156471021,
-0.0584315509,
0.2108125389,
-0.101252161,
-0.0474657565,
-0.3965390623,
-0.3604316115,
-0.0131618576,
-0.7096704245,
-0.3914140165,
-0.7707470655,
-0.0405702069,
-0.1729865372,
-0.278491497,
-0.8072741032,
-0.6327472925,
-0.1196338683,
-0.1775940359,
0.4175043404,
0.4732578397,
-0.3811495304,
0.3687386215,
-0.9703799486,
0.1214732379,
0.3221491277,
0.3207466602,
-0.0320759676,
-0.3257186711,
-0.4274398685,
-0.3508332074,
-0.4424753487,
-0.6366584301,
0.2992584109,
0.5911880136,
0.4072545767,
0.5903537273,
0.3736498356,
0.6939944029,
-0.6071195602,
0.6915889382,
0.3040423691,
-1.2436625957,
0.5863185525,
-0.0208082572,
0.0764697045,
0.7752990127,
0.2451634556,
-0.7966637611,
-0.4056605399,
-0.7250310183,
-1.1401426792,
0.4408858716,
0.2715076506,
-0.2300245017,
-0.3488183618,
0.5096339583,
0.4409132302,
0.0590259843,
-0.3949807286,
-0.5808057189,
0.0247009508,
-0.0786483139,
0.1534547508,
-0.0498257093,
-0.2613716722,
-0.1005929485,
0.5041897297,
-0.0589610972,
0.3133100271,
0.6322185993,
-0.0381615758,
-0.3077486753,
0.8912989497,
-0.1633145809,
0.6093329191,
-0.3423410952,
0.447201848,
0.3338129222,
-0.1915286332,
0.1519690305,
0.2453231364,
-0.1312884092,
0.2082926482,
0.1003889889,
0.4882686734,
0.3218095303,
-0.6624708176,
0.3672094941,
-0.2631190419,
0.1001566052,
-0.3856678903,
0.0323166959,
-0.0195870101,
0.2022945136,
0.6920593381,
0.104892239,
0.569344759,
-0.4119801223,
0.5417500734,
0.024334833,
-0.7237137556,
-0.3775512874,
0.6441847682,
0.6240922213,
-0.2440920323,
0.5299245119,
-0.4508595467,
-0.5612677336,
0.6674827337,
0.2928399146,
0.7245326638,
-0.2574900687,
-0.3309570849,
0.9094081521,
0.2291526049,
0.0065944837,
0.0759847015,
0.1211471707,
-0.7943289876,
-0.6188492179,
-0.713168323,
-0.8644705415,
-0.0783991888,
-1.0342273712,
0.4776742756,
-0.3291884065,
-0.3887611926,
-0.0265644211,
-0.1138841659,
-1.2674740553,
-0.0058855396,
0.3372600377,
1.1278558969,
-0.5261517167,
0.5355311632,
0.7239798307,
-0.0872519836,
-0.5811945796,
-0.5883982778,
0.2238949984,
0.09842325,
0.5106092691,
0.0019920939,
-0.1252172142,
0.0532515347,
-0.4145076573,
-0.681483686,
1.0985584259,
-0.0233703293,
-1.3020666838,
-0.0505642556,
-0.0965915918,
0.3931349814,
-0.7631350756,
0.4505156577,
0.6149936318,
0.6146469712,
0.134313941,
-1.2279624939,
0.00407233,
-0.2014266253,
-0.2893695235,
0.4164603651,
-0.5478679538,
0.5779093504,
-0.2560613453,
-0.4069748521,
0.3172319233,
0.8583536148,
0.4663953483,
0.7239839435,
0.4605742097,
0.6092101932,
0.8007930517,
-0.3312107027,
0.9801377654,
-0.6113519073,
0.8108308315,
1.5236535072,
-0.3880013824,
0.8457991481,
0.4386515617,
-0.120691523,
0.5879281759,
0.3116490841,
0.1607037634,
0.4960140884,
0.1177398488,
-0.5649806857,
-0.4602098167,
-0.2752744853,
-0.3994280398,
-0.0798903704,
0.4651376307,
-0.0975796282,
-0.3604180813,
-0.2251752764,
-0.0636663809,
-0.1038179547,
-0.5628583431,
0.5998848081,
0.0921628922,
-0.104759559,
-0.0986740291,
0.0213974006,
0.8933073282,
-0.6438684464,
0.0271164905,
0.1397918612,
0.4427045286,
-0.2983450592,
-0.350918293,
0.7177218795,
0.3859437704,
-0.4217869639,
0.2526362538,
0.7445321679,
-0.3083252907,
-0.6152992249,
0.4117692709,
0.6187425256,
0.1511234939,
-0.1141927913,
-0.5029186606,
0.2294589728,
-0.2959914804,
-0.3508978784,
0.1252284795,
0.542894721,
0.3084195852,
0.4675758481,
0.6686749458,
0.1490010172,
-0.0119511681,
-0.0611374676,
0.7400701046,
-0.8095950484,
-0.2209540904,
-0.517323792,
0.7093097568,
0.0148803778,
-0.3215244114,
0.2388247699,
0.886579752,
0.6930172443,
0.0634353682,
0.8460900784,
-0.4600972533,
0.9802763462,
-0.0078956941,
0.3710954785,
-0.0851242393,
0.251933217,
-0.2335274518,
-0.8955134749,
-0.4108091891,
0.5690572858,
-0.3215132952,
-0.3147301972,
0.803886354,
0.7716450691,
-0.3339363039,
-0.1139223874,
0.1676116884,
0.3543144166,
0.327398926,
0.492775172,
0.8030934334,
-0.4166257381,
0.9307252765,
-0.4487168789,
-0.3047870696,
-0.1730225831,
-1.3251984119,
-0.4121674895,
-0.539789021,
-0.7314887047,
-0.2381426245,
0.3252774775,
1.330940485,
0.8134166002,
-1.2866439819,
-0.3413708508,
-0.0127114132,
0.1006944329,
-0.412707597,
-0.2664925456,
0.4173780084,
0.082519725,
-0.9832838178,
0.1710014045,
-0.0200323481,
-0.3153262138,
0.1470850557,
-0.1558914483,
0.2934561074,
0.1333535761,
0.4381709099,
0.4426381886,
-0.6085119247,
-0.5354706049,
-0.2340276688,
-0.1155386716,
0.0117346141,
1.1717090607,
-0.624725163,
0.2978413403,
0.3539370596,
0.188636288,
0.5907907486,
-0.1762751192,
0.3387408555,
-0.4728761315,
-0.0116125662,
0.1771880835,
0.5650675893,
0.3468836248,
-0.2626814544,
0.6143752933,
-0.0055697146,
-0.813441813,
-0.551546216,
0.130345583,
-1.3395704031,
0.2284227759,
0.7625327706,
-0.2526563108,
-0.0551554859,
-0.3756917119,
-0.4362206161,
0.3167599738,
-0.7079814076,
0.8257102966,
0.8618542552,
-0.5663864017,
-0.2341565341,
-0.0611604974,
0.2792942524,
-0.1758025289,
-0.4377213418,
0.3873156905,
0.6278181672,
0.6193898916,
0.3562367857,
0.4476843476,
-0.0499391071,
0.300588131,
-0.1689196527,
0.8089707494,
-0.031812761,
-0.2563679516,
-0.2409836948,
0.3710662127,
0.1373084486,
0.3002141416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14099v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14099v2 | Let Guidelines Guide You: A Prescriptive Guideline-Centered Data Annotation Methodology | 2024-06-20T08:24:57 | 2024-07-02T15:38:17 | Federico Ruggeri, Eleonora Misino, Arianna Muti, Katerina Korre, Paolo Torroni, Alberto Barrón-Cedeño | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce the Guideline-Centered annotation process, a novel data
annotation methodology focused on reporting the annotation guidelines
associated with each data sample. We identify three main limitations of the
standard prescriptive annotation process and describe how the
Guideline-Centered methodology overcomes them by reducing the loss of
information in the annotation process and ensuring adherence to guidelines.
Additionally, we discuss how the Guideline-Centered enables the reuse of
annotated data across multiple tasks at the cost of a single human-annotation
process. | [
-0.4815301597,
-0.6403986812,
0.7688468099,
0.1262280643,
-0.7575543523,
-0.2455228865,
-0.182312876,
-0.3980497718,
0.3681714535,
1.2346383333,
-1.0501060486,
-0.9452541471,
-0.4354892075,
0.054264307,
-0.2847768962,
1.4938730001,
-0.31531775,
0.3529888988,
-0.2474658489,
-0.19847247,
-0.6737169623,
-0.7293717265,
-0.2258027494,
-0.3407380283,
0.8914029598,
1.0870183706,
0.4733418226,
0.7835118175,
0.9998440146,
-0.0553425737,
0.3209823072,
0.0340403616,
-0.3271665871,
0.4603382051,
0.085519433,
-0.4143107235,
-0.5836091638,
0.6325927377,
0.2369118482,
1.2386491299,
-0.3879314959,
0.5813375711,
-0.1361710131,
0.5683642626,
-0.7218722701,
-0.1055463925,
-0.0954255611,
0.0354488492,
-0.8581818342,
-0.5294246674,
-0.2874987721,
-1.0614560843,
0.4205103517,
-1.044459939,
0.3098915219,
0.0912883952,
0.3955484629,
0.4276461601,
-0.0897042975,
-0.5314235687,
-0.7940647602,
0.4641408324,
-0.4069271386,
-0.0467867404,
0.6921058893,
0.693328619,
0.1624729931,
-1.1171860695,
-0.3354385197,
-0.0269306451,
-0.2170822024,
-0.3102752268,
0.4229309261,
0.1204039454,
0.4605569839,
0.0866565704,
-0.3133178055,
-0.1158785,
-0.4389799237,
-0.2747561038,
0.9671562314,
-0.0884809867,
-0.2686036527,
0.0604590103,
-0.3677594364,
0.2316234708,
-0.8058509827,
-0.1904802769,
0.2224551588,
0.4465906024,
0.3911584914,
0.4797774851,
-0.3085024953,
0.5014014244,
0.0892264247,
-0.1327880919,
0.4596413672,
-0.7280445099,
-0.0107589187,
0.3189840019,
0.293474555,
0.8956310153,
0.5808380246,
-0.1260683239,
0.0416912809,
-0.0806107298,
0.4530731738,
-0.638610065,
-0.3585788906,
-0.2475954294,
-0.5748743415,
-0.11500182,
-0.0315963365,
-0.5389383435,
-0.6282827854,
-0.7027307153,
0.2467372417,
-0.1186735705,
-0.0051314719,
-0.1370597035,
-0.2307868451,
0.2796905935,
0.6563450694,
-0.6730195284,
0.604074955,
0.5801796913,
0.7091864944,
0.0836285576,
0.0508954301,
-0.4620644748,
0.0654037073,
-0.2983048856,
1.0565983057,
-0.6432284117,
-0.5365812182,
-0.1244977564,
0.1588077843,
0.2717855871,
-0.2687716484,
1.1051262617,
-0.0952105895,
-0.0686539635,
-0.7609404325,
-0.5900785327,
-0.4335082471,
-0.0161572434,
-0.739838779,
0.4145215154,
0.0230495743,
-0.7143146396,
1.0308715105,
-0.6501747966,
-0.3710183501,
0.2532470524,
-0.1441206932,
-0.3255273104,
-0.1921728253,
0.0745070428,
0.5288459659,
-0.3640841544,
0.1763637364,
-0.5035271645,
-0.3449806869,
-0.1855426878,
0.0684023723,
0.6611449122,
0.32405141,
-0.08819855,
0.4677404761,
-0.8505195379,
0.0488751121,
-0.2577206194,
0.0565200932,
-0.2979018688,
0.0587311648,
0.4151680171,
-0.0347467512,
0.2224498391,
-0.4404306412,
0.5806655884,
0.5573195219,
0.1025362536,
0.7449245453,
0.2684892416,
0.5881416202,
-0.3878965676,
0.6269676089,
-0.2749286592,
0.5959840417,
-0.3180530071,
-0.3766822815,
-0.4681929648,
0.0570911579,
0.143844977,
0.402666986,
-0.1041169539,
0.1680453569,
0.0880261809,
-0.6385933161,
-0.580208838,
0.11230921,
0.1248312816,
0.8697576523,
0.3397109509,
-0.4965991676,
-0.9300315976,
-1.1714144945,
0.1906842142,
0.2438728064,
0.1905370653,
-0.0479061194,
0.3627465069,
-0.1466132551,
0.966144383,
-0.4337820113,
-0.5442003012,
-0.1290562749,
0.209707737,
0.15977934,
0.6285549402,
0.4548350573,
-0.970974803,
-0.3480228484,
-0.4193502367,
-0.705354929,
-0.4496493638,
-0.0116088074,
-0.1654334068,
-0.0763114393,
0.6652669311,
-0.0205025245,
0.8443027139,
0.1721078157,
-0.3538559973,
0.4624853134,
-0.2077918947,
0.1453275532,
-0.6648716927,
0.2598404884,
0.1702857018,
-0.3083262742,
-0.5413976908,
-0.4626625478,
0.0336191244,
0.1988196373,
0.2350303382,
0.0014588513,
-0.2007730901,
0.3676521778,
-0.007170951,
0.0657928959,
0.1037176326,
0.089639537,
0.1020497307,
0.3912694454,
0.4628299773,
-0.6024853587,
0.6564930081,
0.4510259628,
0.0455924235,
1.2300564051,
-0.3843842149,
0.2406936735,
-0.558131218,
0.621391952,
-0.8219704628,
-0.2912094295,
0.5520498157,
-0.2896366715,
0.0978827253,
-0.1815656573,
-0.3544864357,
-0.19096753,
-0.47206828,
0.2186690271,
0.3241792321,
-0.2706091702,
0.4259689152,
0.2068901211,
-0.1622338742,
-0.5648798347,
-0.9267607927,
-0.0499514341,
-0.4147372842,
-0.3880093098,
0.3020924628,
-0.3019930124,
-0.2090751827,
0.0360558257,
-0.1572757363,
-0.3509715199,
0.1182760522,
0.7050850987,
0.0532188974,
0.0241033603,
0.2464878559,
-0.2997385859,
-0.4343091249,
0.2019887269,
-0.2841235399,
0.1679456681,
0.3150014877,
-0.3819282949,
-0.7702748775,
0.810567379,
0.263648659,
-0.1902523637,
0.3430367708,
0.568161726,
-0.3327615559,
-0.0093191024,
-0.7596764565,
-0.0855195671,
-0.371704042,
-0.0774905011,
-0.3334566653,
-0.415364325,
0.6570364237,
-0.0941730365,
0.3111332655,
0.5019154549,
-0.0304741357,
-0.2630167007,
0.8061353564,
0.9516741633,
0.2739978135,
0.4856480956,
-0.0089772446,
0.1336072385,
-0.919128716,
-0.6019268632,
-0.6931137443,
-0.2302265763,
-0.4712256193,
-0.0597320683,
0.0717499033,
0.4646426737,
-0.1613407284,
0.1521026492,
-0.913905859,
0.3472922444,
0.7565047145,
0.1162175983,
0.2924187481,
-0.4091306627,
0.143017292,
0.0087389434,
-0.4857427776,
-0.9606618285,
1.5996563435,
0.2572556138,
1.0680059195,
-0.2336376458,
1.0309227705,
0.3288160861,
0.7460963726,
-0.4980711341,
0.4081518948,
0.1258182228,
-0.8259996772,
-0.1644500643,
0.0125031332,
-0.5376495123,
-0.3694971502,
-0.3037850559,
-0.7829900384,
0.0393173844,
0.2631871104,
-0.4941633344,
0.008083486,
-1.0416792631,
0.8103830814,
-0.0647671297,
-0.0987791494,
0.0734519437,
-0.7775025964,
-0.1370174885,
-0.2331719697,
0.1242166236,
-0.3123388588,
-0.069839403,
1.0658237934,
-0.5502122641,
0.8024810553,
-0.6409235001,
0.3231090009,
0.4056156278,
-0.6262262464,
0.297057718,
0.1428486705,
-0.0060510216,
-0.1472742409,
0.1624197513,
-0.466555804,
-0.2805518806,
0.2869274616,
-0.1399237514,
-0.5610396266,
-0.3758182228,
-0.2809416354,
-0.025794087,
0.4116445482,
0.4561392367,
0.0684350505,
-0.1563146263,
0.2069416493,
0.3609728217,
0.4802421331,
0.2147394419,
0.3298613131,
-0.1293949634,
-0.3088909686,
0.3286686242,
0.6947285533,
-0.0344811343,
-0.1738221496,
0.1537379026,
-0.4282363355,
-0.9258232713,
-0.0986740217,
-0.0453604199,
-1.1128799915,
0.0525794253,
-0.085978508,
0.1523902416,
-0.5533069372,
-0.4685864449,
0.0531343743,
-0.3191777468,
-0.2651673555,
-0.35533306,
0.7051482201,
0.9675709605,
-0.2002721727,
0.4160055816,
-0.2995185852,
0.0196964126,
0.1430290341,
0.5335018039,
-0.5233201981,
0.0772441924,
-0.316134274,
-0.1203863919,
-0.0797801688,
-0.8583427668,
-0.1401163042,
-0.1062525958,
0.8827055097,
0.375077188,
0.1223461926,
0.6822633743,
-0.3791410923,
0.645991087,
0.2122094035,
-0.7287591696,
0.766955018,
-0.4192162156,
0.1101663336,
1.1006932259,
0.4492370188,
-0.5623981953,
0.1615617871,
-0.5365993381,
-0.8572560549,
0.3821598589,
-0.0855999738,
-0.3249225914,
0.3543636203,
1.07444489,
0.2301374674,
0.4548062384,
-0.2956545353,
-0.3957405686,
-0.3746252358,
-0.2242108583,
-0.1624774486,
-0.1529697925,
-0.5158127546,
-0.284956485,
0.3353018463,
-0.3624054492,
-0.1276447773,
0.5954193473,
0.1228706837,
-0.094173573,
0.0576754101,
0.4384033978,
1.1428004503,
-0.4860897958,
-0.0010693705,
0.0326935537,
-0.7552928925,
-0.0866476074,
0.5271888375,
-0.3571833074,
-0.0302341301,
0.4776059091,
0.4340979755,
-0.1187933907,
-0.1537454575,
0.4135071337,
-0.2551329732,
-0.2613818049,
-0.7731859684,
0.0627667829,
-0.1746409088,
0.1751237661,
0.7120328546,
0.1091303006,
0.1301868707,
-0.474524498,
0.6356881261,
0.1053292304,
-0.4644975662,
-0.2014641464,
0.6138033271,
0.3639306128,
-0.2311965674,
0.3179617822,
-0.049408704,
-0.1347991228,
0.473312974,
0.230588302,
0.8454150558,
-0.1936571151,
0.1153355911,
0.3587657511,
0.2584442198,
-0.1973304749,
0.4071288109,
-0.3890059888,
-0.2363620251,
-0.5236641169,
-0.1941795647,
-0.6041703224,
-0.375451386,
-1.0591813326,
0.2365388721,
-0.9750686288,
-0.329823494,
0.6068587899,
0.106677793,
-0.6898761392,
0.4185058177,
0.1850161254,
1.1009221077,
-0.5663231015,
0.8006384373,
0.6641455293,
-0.7521307468,
-0.9059997797,
-0.1150155291,
0.2615650296,
-0.5556369424,
0.5292962193,
0.3344254196,
-0.1335825175,
-0.3845417798,
-1.0139132738,
-0.62597543,
1.3331706524,
0.0381705686,
-0.5467256308,
-0.2407422066,
-0.1618518233,
0.4114377499,
-0.7121789455,
0.0944374651,
0.9992696047,
0.8872992396,
0.1760053337,
-1.0367234945,
0.2171295583,
-0.1781817824,
-0.4963077009,
0.0172091816,
-0.2697327137,
0.7724120021,
-0.413782686,
-0.1484833062,
0.0301376209,
0.0850931033,
-0.0291924495,
0.6643790603,
0.4785008132,
0.3372475207,
1.0467752218,
-0.276060313,
0.9315543175,
0.1390143335,
0.1520785242,
1.1432616711,
-0.3090512455,
0.4370383024,
0.6198822856,
0.2783991694,
0.5640684962,
0.7251235247,
-0.0743562803,
0.44823578,
0.2160031348,
-0.1264106482,
-0.1129893363,
-0.5092757344,
-0.2707967162,
0.1317058653,
0.3353445232,
-0.2813310325,
-0.2074663788,
-0.1152744815,
0.3641474247,
0.1924866587,
-0.4747115076,
0.5803565979,
-0.1471112072,
-0.6916074753,
0.2255592942,
-0.4160839021,
0.4488289356,
-0.8277981281,
-0.2687666118,
0.1269062907,
0.1660161018,
-0.7381302714,
-0.8086595535,
0.5044497252,
-0.0617218092,
-0.3205630481,
-0.5239900947,
0.5139959455,
-0.2219498456,
-0.3078703284,
0.0730307251,
0.0266550966,
-0.1996736676,
-0.1156343743,
-0.389228642,
-0.124083817,
0.0192105472,
-0.384550333,
-0.3324995041,
0.544644475,
-0.3761500716,
0.6839137077,
0.7061673999,
0.1274235398,
-0.128227964,
0.1409605294,
0.8831475377,
-0.9953665733,
-0.4176689088,
-0.5076819062,
0.4528905749,
-0.3485419452,
-0.4793512225,
0.783208847,
0.2148188502,
0.7277596593,
0.3643675745,
1.0575633049,
-0.1329678744,
0.8883152008,
-0.3977907896,
0.4223154187,
-0.3014771044,
0.0739717335,
-0.305036217,
-0.8505567312,
-0.824755311,
0.819778204,
-0.5280109644,
0.0955436751,
0.7292212844,
0.4286094308,
0.4579998851,
0.2547700703,
-0.1495461017,
-0.1958230138,
0.5085278153,
0.519374907,
0.5269927979,
0.1304041743,
0.375772953,
-0.4784935415,
-0.5823158026,
-0.2918891609,
-0.9165322781,
-0.6957786083,
-0.5610706806,
-0.3292348981,
-0.379260093,
-0.0534473546,
0.8596388102,
1.45370543,
-0.5078037381,
0.0936558098,
-0.3147270381,
0.0197029561,
-0.2466870248,
-0.1682253033,
0.341098845,
-0.1966563314,
-0.3492511809,
-0.257411629,
0.0872966722,
0.1696005017,
-0.4977682233,
-0.0784797594,
-0.166621387,
-0.1306476444,
0.0423801914,
0.269505918,
-0.1962648928,
-0.4065237641,
-0.1797115207,
-0.0079577947,
0.0270871539,
1.1695802212,
-0.5797357559,
0.7405930161,
0.1841015071,
0.2201341242,
0.6063116193,
0.0613702461,
0.649721086,
-0.674818933,
0.2131044418,
0.611422658,
0.1078147218,
0.3316286504,
-0.3734303415,
0.7740867734,
-0.0076864138,
-0.6990286708,
-0.5158254504,
0.3893417716,
-1.2945736647,
0.0390308127,
0.8543962836,
-0.2859744728,
-0.2190864682,
-0.4889083505,
-0.5465595722,
0.119925417,
-0.411243856,
0.3290124536,
0.6657532454,
-0.5063539147,
-0.2987344861,
-0.6154586077,
1.0316462517,
0.0170283075,
-0.7654701471,
0.2677304745,
0.7598044276,
0.4407850206,
0.496720165,
0.9424540997,
0.0524056926,
0.1769788712,
0.0721161291,
0.0380710699,
-0.1657469422,
-0.4229183495,
-0.1611875743,
0.1472288072,
0.3621831834,
-0.5088752508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14092v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14092v1 | Seamless Language Expansion: Enhancing Multilingual Mastery in Self-Supervised Models | 2024-06-20T08:13:30 | 2024-06-20T08:13:30 | Jing Xu, Minglin Wu, Xixin Wu, Helen Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Self-supervised (SSL) models have shown great performance in various
downstream tasks. However, they are typically developed for limited languages,
and may encounter new languages in real-world. Developing a SSL model for each
new language is costly. Thus, it is vital to figure out how to efficiently
adapt existed SSL models to a new language without impairing its original
abilities. We propose adaptation methods which integrate LoRA to existed SSL
models to extend new language. We also develop preservation strategies which
include data combination and re-clustering to retain abilities on existed
languages. Applied to mHuBERT, we investigate their effectiveness on speech
re-synthesis task. Experiments show that our adaptation methods enable mHuBERT
to be applied to a new language (Mandarin) with MOS value increased about 1.6
and the relative value of WER reduced up to 61.72%. Also, our preservation
strategies ensure that the performance on both existed and new languages
remains intact. | [
-0.1404843479,
-0.9354683757,
0.2375892997,
0.3843031228,
0.0031162293,
0.3478960097,
-0.3815728128,
-0.4220900834,
0.2494839281,
0.6514636278,
-0.2291445732,
-0.2902877033,
-0.3370863497,
-0.0936682448,
-0.3993240893,
0.9881687164,
0.1511232257,
-0.1298319846,
0.0516544431,
-0.1816530526,
-0.3851973414,
-0.7035970092,
-0.4819301665,
-0.3170520663,
0.4156024456,
0.5185565948,
0.579924345,
0.7400401235,
0.3777417839,
0.3500332236,
-0.0672113448,
0.1056232154,
-0.3905006945,
0.2971140742,
-0.2496152669,
-0.4037854671,
-0.8255600929,
-0.2544760108,
0.8706323504,
0.8371841311,
-0.3990497887,
0.2162713408,
0.281921953,
0.9600280523,
-0.7338386774,
0.1362388283,
-0.530965507,
0.1209206954,
-0.0964526162,
-0.1736038625,
-0.3510363996,
-0.2503829002,
0.3953614533,
-0.6202914119,
-0.0162538681,
-0.4844256341,
0.283108145,
0.2441810668,
-0.3886618316,
0.0269060247,
-0.9476795197,
0.8807486892,
-0.64266783,
0.6821630001,
0.1291656047,
0.2008691728,
-0.2248163372,
-0.6579374075,
-0.1873177886,
-0.2958485186,
0.264161557,
0.279858917,
-0.2883552313,
-0.0868583322,
0.0103889359,
0.4077472091,
-0.3207367957,
0.1741881818,
-0.5829839706,
-0.3049334288,
0.8926941752,
-0.0629191026,
0.2826414108,
-0.1289179921,
-0.1128920242,
-0.1103816405,
-0.5473490357,
0.1475063711,
0.2002574056,
0.6302858591,
-0.1776763201,
0.4800751805,
-0.2186305076,
0.6876055002,
-0.0679282472,
-0.4050950706,
0.3889036477,
-0.4604528844,
-0.1320322901,
0.024121521,
0.5109379888,
-0.1272750795,
0.3773871064,
-0.0284467898,
0.1846772283,
-0.2152546644,
0.2255333364,
-0.3738376796,
-0.2720548511,
0.1441359967,
-0.4721005261,
-0.1900746524,
-0.3454955816,
-0.5243145227,
-0.1956121176,
-0.4050035775,
0.4054296017,
-0.5549083352,
-0.6114467382,
-0.0467208102,
-0.0473571643,
0.2828675508,
0.4146940708,
-1.0432705879,
0.2128560394,
0.4516731799,
0.6829338074,
-0.4326649606,
-0.8092611432,
-0.5419846177,
0.3229946196,
-0.5186151266,
0.5781397223,
-0.2315837741,
-0.3058114946,
0.1909069866,
0.1772742867,
-0.0516132042,
-0.3826325536,
0.5025058985,
-0.4065442979,
0.2194903046,
-0.0667994618,
-0.4486983716,
-0.2626928985,
-0.0224357452,
-0.5284215212,
1.0013380051,
0.3382388651,
-0.4876196682,
0.0912166834,
-0.7780739069,
-0.8433741927,
-0.0483466983,
0.165895924,
-0.1537924558,
0.3614827991,
0.2711150944,
0.3682362437,
0.0824626759,
0.212466076,
-0.2634838521,
-0.0558880866,
0.0863604173,
-0.4855622351,
0.9259226918,
0.2147656828,
-0.1036831737,
0.0736234337,
-0.7288624644,
0.2381515801,
-0.0613726377,
-0.6423265338,
-0.4037926197,
0.0010276758,
0.0328781717,
-0.0383788534,
0.5323184729,
-0.2537154555,
0.2306857407,
-0.4866363108,
0.368921876,
0.6671738625,
-0.2166565061,
0.6287354231,
-0.0858749449,
0.6296770573,
0.1066505685,
0.37795192,
-0.3888242543,
-0.2897076905,
-1.1871879101,
-0.0860562176,
0.5056698322,
0.6768754125,
-0.7214735746,
0.4964500666,
-0.4140848219,
-0.5675645471,
-0.7161528468,
0.4633664489,
0.1724495739,
0.2153660804,
0.4549234509,
-0.5674613714,
-0.4581121802,
-1.0298194885,
-0.1962579787,
-0.2159968168,
0.2102190852,
0.0256468374,
0.1835650653,
-0.2174017876,
0.8580343723,
-0.3098664284,
-0.3035099208,
-0.3280504346,
-0.175162822,
0.2470508963,
0.7248120904,
0.4756655991,
-0.5658193827,
-0.5512019992,
0.2455698997,
-0.9083436728,
0.1333855093,
-0.0932660177,
-0.0578800887,
0.3294168413,
0.5913723707,
0.0204795171,
0.359962672,
0.9590501189,
0.1333184987,
0.5553190112,
-0.7133356333,
0.0617579259,
-1.277151227,
-0.3909773231,
-0.1321828067,
-0.2697164416,
-1.073938489,
0.2633598149,
0.1586580426,
-0.0760487691,
-0.6569035053,
0.6125496626,
-0.665060401,
-0.1351421326,
-0.5879086852,
0.2732633352,
-0.2251181453,
0.4549271166,
0.0748148784,
0.5817857981,
1.0616234541,
-0.6822382212,
0.2179941535,
0.1889107227,
-0.1089320853,
0.2943221927,
-0.5161480904,
-0.0514760613,
-0.0351453125,
0.0392483547,
-0.8138065338,
-0.2291007042,
0.074415192,
-0.3154348433,
0.3538318574,
-0.3481414616,
-0.1856357604,
-0.161141783,
-0.0784148872,
0.4044619501,
0.5179738402,
-0.7751149535,
0.9404459596,
0.4950363934,
-0.3605442643,
-0.4702108204,
-0.8884212971,
0.2594568431,
-0.2913534641,
-0.5197945237,
0.263969034,
-0.249741599,
-0.0531550609,
-0.0180659797,
0.0882400125,
-0.3338662088,
0.1841031611,
0.0626080781,
0.0928600952,
-0.3996764719,
0.0259597786,
0.4649512172,
0.0152497459,
-0.2113215476,
-0.2599219978,
0.4509499073,
-0.1445954889,
-0.3817069829,
-0.5644385219,
0.3930411935,
0.6132150292,
-0.4505972564,
0.5584665537,
0.6547308564,
-0.2573100328,
-0.0746158436,
-0.5748310089,
0.0407238081,
-0.5145279765,
0.4478446245,
-0.636461854,
-1.1559156179,
0.4102634192,
-0.0175959859,
0.0973094404,
0.3423725963,
0.6415728927,
0.0188185982,
0.6641092896,
1.0356929302,
-0.4002981484,
0.7861225009,
-0.0337247141,
0.1507880986,
-1.0640577078,
0.1748297065,
-0.1634215266,
0.1814832538,
-0.8787370324,
-0.5089683533,
0.3111314476,
0.1555157751,
0.2665095627,
0.6618994474,
-0.332365036,
0.3414268792,
0.7167403102,
0.1238887087,
0.3190136552,
0.3731124997,
0.2243265212,
-0.0646182448,
-0.9344370961,
-0.1503357142,
1.2559331656,
0.3840278387,
0.8286147118,
0.4438878596,
0.9091881514,
0.4810315967,
0.2317277491,
-0.5663976073,
0.3044429421,
-0.3019144833,
-0.5383641124,
-0.629581213,
-0.352942884,
-1.0644093752,
0.549818635,
-0.2756684422,
-0.7249466181,
0.0081409626,
0.2833225429,
-0.41629228,
-0.0211643651,
-0.7047588825,
0.5273962021,
-0.6092920303,
-0.6027310491,
-0.5155003071,
-0.3829799592,
0.3706651032,
-0.5032840371,
0.3053578734,
-0.0382963195,
0.2237462103,
0.7680923939,
0.0839450881,
0.788869679,
-0.0393331647,
-0.4722279906,
0.3268739879,
0.0977238342,
0.2317961156,
-0.2296440601,
-0.135297209,
0.2222594023,
0.0992602408,
-0.5884395242,
-0.7332316041,
0.7623586655,
-0.6330144405,
-0.9483950138,
-0.1391588598,
-0.677448988,
-0.1265040487,
0.340713501,
-0.3812912107,
0.3289033771,
-0.415392369,
0.1747039706,
0.3265830874,
-0.3847236931,
0.4699513316,
0.7037296891,
-0.3950597942,
-0.5984460115,
0.9376837611,
0.2364445776,
0.5351822972,
0.1059223264,
0.5328868628,
-0.3605157435,
-0.5418451428,
-0.5854870677,
0.2565403581,
-0.685136795,
0.1556222737,
-0.6383330226,
-0.2323547155,
-0.9156547189,
-0.0063236868,
-0.4748501182,
-0.7441284657,
-0.2344362289,
0.1995053142,
0.3223775923,
0.5228708982,
-0.4350965023,
0.5233151913,
-0.9227423072,
0.1522641629,
0.3512340188,
0.1792706549,
0.1386836618,
-0.9974995852,
-0.4925897419,
0.1136566252,
-0.2372108102,
-0.6908485293,
0.440231353,
0.4756851494,
0.7451203465,
0.2912665904,
-0.1096327454,
0.9999864101,
-0.6093621254,
0.6286209822,
0.068646796,
-1.1116980314,
0.5780152082,
-0.4209829569,
0.3463994563,
0.3020963669,
0.2223903537,
-0.5432258844,
-0.3347250819,
-0.632396698,
-0.530731678,
0.4102409184,
0.1382373869,
0.3983832002,
0.2473113537,
0.4210428894,
-0.0688790008,
-0.0022301367,
-0.9388129711,
-0.2563908696,
-0.2573952675,
-0.0344886258,
-0.3440812528,
-0.1767696291,
-0.0196476206,
-0.4661926925,
0.6308120489,
-0.2971308529,
-0.1054566428,
0.1845560372,
-0.2498326153,
0.1760198921,
0.3784808517,
0.4684641659,
0.5406088233,
0.1954912841,
-0.0104415156,
0.3946049511,
-0.0326328874,
0.2034184933,
-0.0623510703,
0.0906945542,
-0.3316877186,
0.5657791495,
0.5115362406,
0.1800412089,
-0.4952714443,
0.2966447473,
0.2308056653,
-0.207123369,
-0.4265978336,
0.3496780097,
0.2251990587,
0.4167198241,
0.1129001528,
-0.1769177467,
0.145667389,
-0.8004747629,
0.2686779797,
0.3693223596,
-0.4568202794,
-0.2756629586,
0.5839105844,
0.0897343233,
-0.3736041188,
0.4311843216,
0.0725419223,
-0.641369164,
0.2104083151,
0.9126476645,
0.744838357,
-0.749717772,
0.1235737056,
0.4223830402,
0.4083971083,
-0.1346136779,
0.2107520998,
-0.1747220159,
-0.9071030617,
-0.4865297973,
-0.4444014132,
-0.2151261121,
-0.2089046836,
-0.7423853874,
0.0504385903,
-0.2658436,
-0.0520028025,
-0.104128398,
-0.2580810785,
-0.3754242957,
0.0955909044,
0.0105148843,
0.8176703453,
-1.0799276829,
1.2748441696,
0.3393407762,
-0.2955241203,
-0.6196071506,
-0.1660213023,
-0.1780826598,
-0.8298407197,
0.4386861026,
-0.365871489,
-0.1815116405,
0.124975197,
-0.1349028796,
-1.2764109373,
0.7885441184,
0.3170625865,
-0.4007213712,
0.2783318162,
0.2333626896,
0.9118624926,
-0.3092043102,
-0.1477975398,
0.6411536932,
0.3021448553,
-0.1642056257,
-0.9666282535,
-0.2143148482,
0.0037125594,
-0.072582148,
0.0211505592,
-0.6745786071,
0.7894790173,
-0.3098275661,
-0.0814252347,
0.1997686177,
0.9813440442,
0.0764457732,
-0.1023112908,
0.5708663464,
0.2035637498,
0.8050878644,
0.1670871824,
0.7589300275,
-0.3634976745,
0.2843008935,
1.4717561007,
-0.3338499963,
1.0058506727,
0.4634643197,
-0.0454879403,
0.4869303107,
0.4862764776,
-0.1344567686,
0.3002843261,
0.0938378349,
-0.1753102988,
-0.3295667768,
-0.3967209458,
-0.3836598396,
0.8618909121,
0.2016525567,
-0.2647175789,
0.0029613995,
0.1086423472,
-0.1589903384,
0.0285446551,
-0.0584653392,
0.6659590602,
-0.0793140903,
-0.7319645286,
0.6012756824,
-0.0745893121,
0.5037178993,
-0.4757723808,
0.0687143058,
-0.3519779742,
0.1996510476,
-0.2428482324,
-0.5876842737,
0.198162362,
-0.2366439551,
-0.0589851551,
0.0324127376,
0.6329671144,
-0.828892827,
-0.8040888906,
0.5640577674,
1.0485221148,
0.1818291247,
0.1753181815,
-0.6633588672,
-0.053783685,
0.3479491174,
0.1107577458,
0.2575649619,
0.2617829144,
-0.2764911652,
1.0466967821,
0.8245008588,
0.3091793954,
0.3450420797,
0.2386256605,
0.6767411232,
-0.6737380624,
-0.3615680337,
-0.7556917667,
0.3594774902,
0.1346083283,
-0.0045586959,
1.1213482618,
0.714494586,
0.7681437731,
-0.1371509582,
0.9763495326,
0.0452691652,
0.4409023523,
-0.464353323,
0.6107205153,
-0.9396913648,
-0.0938410237,
-0.7698095441,
-0.8903176188,
-0.3698288798,
0.5339098573,
0.0498718619,
-0.155719772,
0.5516492128,
0.6996577978,
-0.1620893925,
-0.2008499056,
0.6076519489,
-0.0041999021,
0.4002582729,
0.2605189979,
1.0002464056,
-0.5184685588,
0.3125746548,
-0.2827933133,
-0.4998376071,
0.1951202899,
-0.9103693962,
-0.8416730165,
-0.5935800076,
-0.5586891174,
-0.2165711075,
-0.0544315763,
0.7092108727,
0.9362672567,
-0.7274340391,
-0.7041676044,
0.3718405664,
0.076121971,
-0.2963983119,
-0.133983016,
0.4933758974,
-0.414671272,
-0.7546992302,
0.8939409852,
0.3619356453,
0.2606913149,
-0.5194479823,
-0.0484340191,
-0.1527246982,
-0.1178122982,
0.9444658756,
0.5186938047,
-0.8853521943,
-0.2149280161,
-0.0397701934,
0.4293481112,
0.1554629356,
0.6931167841,
-0.4591042101,
0.6181871295,
0.199961096,
0.8266863823,
0.4479191005,
0.0532377288,
0.7454539537,
-0.5049008727,
0.2976711094,
-0.3565395772,
0.4128118753,
0.4232712984,
-0.0709606484,
0.5256326795,
-0.0249676071,
-0.4762687981,
-0.5992379785,
0.2832705081,
-0.8051657081,
-0.2313097268,
0.9788187742,
-0.0253689978,
-0.2927688956,
-0.0809079856,
-0.1097503826,
0.3713066578,
-0.164266333,
0.8599821329,
0.5819070935,
-0.3300245404,
-0.1944059283,
-0.3320296109,
0.2773790956,
0.4884869158,
-0.8899599314,
0.3674547374,
0.3276902735,
0.3608242273,
0.3507333398,
0.677336812,
-0.0418195799,
0.2235907316,
-0.2295098305,
0.1666982472,
0.2588641047,
-0.514020443,
-0.6229448915,
0.005728995,
0.3338750899,
-0.0863888785
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.