id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15302v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15302v4
|
How (un)ethical are instruction-centric responses of LLMs? Unveiling the vulnerabilities of safety guardrails to harmful queries
| 2024-02-23T13:03:12 | 2024-03-15T17:57:58 |
Somnath Banerjee, Sayan Layek, Rima Hazra, Animesh Mukherjee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
In this study, we tackle a growing concern around the safety and ethical use
of large language models (LLMs). Despite their potential, these models can be
tricked into producing harmful or unethical content through various
sophisticated methods, including 'jailbreaking' techniques and targeted
manipulation. Our work zeroes in on a specific issue: to what extent LLMs can
be led astray by asking them to generate responses that are instruction-centric
such as a pseudocode, a program or a software snippet as opposed to vanilla
text. To investigate this question, we introduce TechHazardQA, a dataset
containing complex queries which should be answered in both text and
instruction-centric formats (e.g., pseudocodes), aimed at identifying triggers
for unethical responses. We query a series of LLMs -- Llama-2-13b, Llama-2-7b,
Mistral-V2 and Mistral 8X7B -- and ask them to generate both text and
instruction-centric responses. For evaluation we report the harmfulness score
metric as well as judgements from GPT-4 and humans. Overall, we observe that
asking LLMs to produce instruction-centric responses enhances the unethical
response generation by ~2-38% across the models. As an additional objective, we
investigate the impact of model editing using the ROME technique, which further
increases the propensity for generating undesirable content. In particular,
asking edited LLMs to generate instruction-centric responses further increases
the unethical response generation by ~3-16% across the different models.
|
[
-0.04229393228888512,
-1.0475250482559204,
0.6097041368484497,
-0.2688111364841461,
-0.1376287043094635,
0.0407073050737381,
0.04748688265681267,
-0.5376182198524475,
-0.13053983449935913,
0.9163816571235657,
-0.4538666307926178,
-0.37709736824035645,
-0.365959107875824,
-0.08980685472488403,
-0.586643397808075,
1.16392982006073,
0.2288636863231659,
0.21547238528728485,
-0.1400514394044876,
-0.061337705701589584,
-0.2541700601577759,
-0.963654637336731,
-0.4866310656070709,
0.09801459312438965,
0.46808671951293945,
0.49551987648010254,
0.4539390802383423,
0.9329555034637451,
0.30117014050483704,
0.279847115278244,
-0.04627005383372307,
-0.06970422714948654,
-0.6800581216812134,
0.19158664345741272,
-0.3391823172569275,
-0.5163528323173523,
-0.4156745672225952,
0.19251464307308197,
0.0369480699300766,
0.42892080545425415,
-0.2889735996723175,
0.6087166666984558,
0.26111093163490295,
0.6828182935714722,
-0.7096472978591919,
-0.3313302993774414,
-0.7499970197677612,
0.1371404081583023,
-0.08438841998577118,
-0.6454916596412659,
-0.7385647296905518,
-0.6184741854667664,
-0.07612723112106323,
-0.37760916352272034,
-0.07334094494581223,
0.12432677298784256,
0.23259125649929047,
0.256154328584671,
-0.3056198060512543,
-0.8293352127075195,
-0.5817976593971252,
0.8051002621650696,
-0.7030555009841919,
0.11239448189735413,
0.4098922312259674,
-0.0829608216881752,
-0.1592211276292801,
-0.6443260908126831,
-0.4250396490097046,
-0.1928475797176361,
0.11889901012182236,
-0.01451477874070406,
-0.17120859026908875,
0.1490212231874466,
0.4992026090621948,
0.12207347899675369,
-0.5830277800559998,
0.4119008481502533,
-0.4790882170200348,
-0.20027780532836914,
0.7416368722915649,
0.4295395016670227,
0.42081382870674133,
-0.2726738750934601,
-0.3581388294696808,
-0.006838622968643904,
-1.0953142642974854,
0.12736329436302185,
0.8591495752334595,
0.062057651579380035,
0.17098650336265564,
0.8089588284492493,
0.37107786536216736,
0.6740534901618958,
0.08349999785423279,
-0.039173755794763565,
-0.1945192962884903,
-0.13386733829975128,
-0.2714913487434387,
0.39188650250434875,
0.8587668538093567,
0.7367066740989685,
0.6838818788528442,
-0.026448458433151245,
-0.10476783663034439,
-0.10824467241764069,
0.6319587230682373,
-0.9900388717651367,
-0.0400693342089653,
0.34383052587509155,
-0.3674691915512085,
-0.5954698324203491,
-0.08813292533159256,
-0.5664514303207397,
-0.47390565276145935,
-0.15339088439941406,
0.2913980782032013,
-0.2762690484523773,
0.11571095138788223,
0.2002417892217636,
0.17597347497940063,
0.3713710904121399,
0.043908193707466125,
-0.7227182984352112,
0.028832297772169113,
0.6672586798667908,
0.17839740216732025,
0.18555192649364471,
0.01861879602074623,
-0.6696214079856873,
0.21681416034698486,
-0.46898794174194336,
0.42989182472229004,
-0.6191306114196777,
-0.8991870284080505,
0.08378534018993378,
0.1273638755083084,
0.11531230062246323,
-0.4704565107822418,
0.4078499376773834,
-0.6915028691291809,
0.40846890211105347,
-0.41446736454963684,
-0.47679001092910767,
-0.21459704637527466,
0.12485651671886444,
-0.4863364100456238,
0.8793782591819763,
-0.20637619495391846,
-1.0089093446731567,
0.0025338507257401943,
-0.5281907916069031,
-0.45121967792510986,
-0.15417540073394775,
-0.2949334681034088,
-0.15481464564800262,
-0.05764588713645935,
-0.13232241570949554,
0.4344092905521393,
-0.36930593848228455,
0.270595520734787,
-0.38501518964767456,
-0.5542992949485779,
0.6483510732650757,
-0.8358194231987,
0.9267916679382324,
0.18247592449188232,
-0.6544350981712341,
-0.008075494319200516,
-0.6525241136550903,
0.31712812185287476,
0.19015511870384216,
-0.3390858769416809,
-0.5963659286499023,
-0.147785946726799,
-0.2756986916065216,
0.3401157557964325,
0.19284217059612274,
-0.5096346735954285,
-0.019384074956178665,
-0.21101118624210358,
0.47444838285446167,
1.2319084405899048,
0.19202235341072083,
0.2927487790584564,
-0.3896370530128479,
0.5714269876480103,
-0.26794782280921936,
0.4437304735183716,
0.021465640515089035,
-0.2614123225212097,
-0.4623754918575287,
0.23770534992218018,
-0.18704475462436676,
0.7922677397727966,
-0.7275475263595581,
0.11237312108278275,
-0.1120373085141182,
-0.4922126531600952,
-0.6119054555892944,
0.15854929387569427,
0.7487966418266296,
0.839553952217102,
0.15771766006946564,
0.0001081761292880401,
-0.1998193860054016,
-0.9726735949516296,
-0.5171682238578796,
-0.46635952591896057,
-0.003997277934104204,
0.4251551032066345,
0.3479156494140625,
0.029070239514112473,
0.47138485312461853,
-0.3546254336833954,
0.34212422370910645,
0.1288144439458847,
-0.04751109704375267,
-0.10801240056753159,
0.3917134702205658,
0.5836595296859741,
-0.6209794282913208,
-0.18579164147377014,
-0.36555299162864685,
-0.8868516683578491,
-0.20415633916854858,
-0.06741416454315186,
-0.20690439641475677,
0.3704741299152374,
0.4643203914165497,
-0.4276137948036194,
0.45329874753952026,
0.22417272627353668,
-0.25477614998817444,
0.5830946564674377,
-0.08136850595474243,
0.2827152609825134,
-1.1638665199279785,
0.03400140628218651,
-0.19474314153194427,
0.06669749319553375,
-0.5381143689155579,
0.3384048640727997,
0.055009111762046814,
0.15295416116714478,
-0.8131030201911926,
0.22186926007270813,
-0.26769784092903137,
-0.09112820774316788,
-0.2219652235507965,
-0.047646038234233856,
0.023309806361794472,
0.26808375120162964,
-0.23503118753433228,
1.1906832456588745,
0.24186353385448456,
-0.6025258898735046,
0.29133161902427673,
0.25824540853500366,
-0.10604521632194519,
0.4667007029056549,
-0.8492711782455444,
0.6400806307792664,
-0.1002962663769722,
0.014807241037487984,
-0.47178810834884644,
-0.22838449478149414,
0.4553121030330658,
-0.4260088801383972,
0.1210470199584961,
0.013433416374027729,
-0.6167284250259399,
-0.19205962121486664,
-0.8609600067138672,
0.38725706934928894,
0.5790983438491821,
-0.545651912689209,
0.24011248350143433,
0.5634615421295166,
-0.1576826423406601,
-0.9176258444786072,
-1.0463539361953735,
-0.014259024523198605,
-0.4427873492240906,
-0.5690666437149048,
-0.11044380813837051,
-0.26895827054977417,
-0.4982620179653168,
-0.00416346313431859,
-0.2179996520280838,
0.12445604056119919,
0.35349440574645996,
0.4057474136352539,
0.4950689673423767,
-0.08190702646970749,
-0.14821451902389526,
0.11349102854728699,
0.25768986344337463,
0.6263980865478516,
-0.10155557096004486,
0.498740553855896,
-0.11493363231420517,
-0.5996705889701843,
-0.13395558297634125,
0.5573057532310486,
0.4806631803512573,
-0.270664781332016,
0.7293778657913208,
0.2685137093067169,
-0.2280948907136917,
-0.229950413107872,
-0.38792240619659424,
-0.47522076964378357,
-0.5665441751480103,
0.28922155499458313,
0.10471978783607483,
-1.1871556043624878,
0.33417022228240967,
0.22910988330841064,
0.29176220297813416,
0.08296120166778564,
0.6695237755775452,
-0.16220909357070923,
0.9696375727653503,
0.5887066721916199,
0.17831158638000488,
0.2862493395805359,
-0.1909266710281372,
0.33656802773475647,
-0.7828636169433594,
-0.5290956497192383,
-0.517740786075592,
-0.03497558459639549,
-1.0055495500564575,
-0.3879760801792145,
0.5071405172348022,
-0.2498401403427124,
-0.4694758951663971,
0.16624705493450165,
-0.7490979433059692,
0.6160756349563599,
0.5379790663719177,
0.10708843171596527,
0.35201528668403625,
-0.05269241705536842,
0.02371858060359955,
-0.014513124711811543,
-0.7324591875076294,
-1.0100759267807007,
1.2116578817367554,
0.24203336238861084,
1.1948972940444946,
0.2310369610786438,
0.749829888343811,
0.33978503942489624,
0.277959406375885,
-0.833121120929718,
0.838817834854126,
-0.14895175397396088,
-0.7668827772140503,
-0.1377181112766266,
-0.4665636122226715,
-0.7216356992721558,
-0.1355287730693817,
-0.02107456885278225,
-0.8832228779792786,
0.004127264488488436,
0.0927312970161438,
-0.46396976709365845,
0.45120444893836975,
-0.8464449048042297,
0.5450491905212402,
-0.6513018608093262,
-0.8099532127380371,
-0.1387098729610443,
-0.8304169774055481,
0.571630597114563,
-0.2329132854938507,
0.3696581721305847,
0.2562723457813263,
0.017966242507100105,
0.7431166172027588,
-0.33351901173591614,
1.007625937461853,
0.11347837001085281,
-0.3779692053794861,
0.44307199120521545,
0.42657139897346497,
0.21444490551948547,
0.12897071242332458,
-0.18703103065490723,
-0.16585896909236908,
0.13089512288570404,
-0.207105353474617,
-0.40374839305877686,
0.9103901982307434,
-0.7099145650863647,
-1.1630373001098633,
-0.3568504750728607,
-0.6140899062156677,
-0.2636546194553375,
0.16850675642490387,
0.36966562271118164,
0.585811197757721,
0.08557965606451035,
0.08078633248806,
1.020723819732666,
-0.66156405210495,
0.4455866515636444,
0.7220697999000549,
-0.06794832646846771,
0.1652417629957199,
0.8125674724578857,
0.22703459858894348,
0.42474281787872314,
-0.05231181159615517,
-0.041519373655319214,
-0.3088217079639435,
-0.41327083110809326,
-0.6340816020965576,
0.08827297389507294,
-0.8324238657951355,
-0.2194380760192871,
-0.6059351563453674,
-0.3712673783302307,
-0.1872250735759735,
-0.24307002127170563,
-0.14687864482402802,
-0.2919900119304657,
-0.4545566737651825,
-0.3687279224395752,
0.36083608865737915,
0.9978013038635254,
0.06376811116933823,
0.06809204816818237,
-0.9883217811584473,
0.06466027349233627,
0.34768199920654297,
0.09515988826751709,
-0.12474755942821503,
-0.600473165512085,
0.16738499701023102,
0.0688726156949997,
-0.2998705506324768,
-1.0288596153259277,
0.09191574156284332,
-0.23722517490386963,
0.4627915024757385,
0.29321223497390747,
0.3935137391090393,
0.48813098669052124,
-0.5471917390823364,
0.9285829067230225,
-0.17568467557430267,
-0.7289807200431824,
0.4144706428050995,
-0.25096020102500916,
-0.157540425658226,
0.3945974111557007,
0.6213088035583496,
-0.2764210104942322,
-0.6364668011665344,
-0.5734622478485107,
-0.9470089673995972,
0.7021572589874268,
-0.06293338537216187,
0.6768316030502319,
-0.12789683043956757,
0.48683732748031616,
0.21570491790771484,
0.2512415945529938,
-0.5605433583259583,
-0.23987935483455658,
-0.09616793692111969,
-0.04883541911840439,
0.48938286304473877,
-0.6131445169448853,
-0.3991314768791199,
0.20539312064647675,
0.5869235992431641,
0.10619020462036133,
0.09278189390897751,
-0.03376750275492668,
-0.0883256047964096,
-0.18258897960186005,
0.6510202288627625,
0.4272876977920532,
0.4854515790939331,
-0.03221336007118225,
0.06666693091392517,
-0.02338579297065735,
-0.650140106678009,
0.20753763616085052,
-0.0207691453397274,
-0.15019598603248596,
-0.514266312122345,
0.4050057530403137,
0.2731474041938782,
-0.08415768295526505,
-0.7879855632781982,
0.36588722467422485,
-0.2569109797477722,
0.1253368854522705,
-0.29364901781082153,
0.35057416558265686,
-0.02149406634271145,
0.10519451647996902,
0.21138353645801544,
-0.19044922292232513,
0.4450210630893707,
-0.7009780406951904,
0.08090893179178238,
0.4999622404575348,
-0.007025708444416523,
-0.2008289247751236,
0.7140661478042603,
0.1456872969865799,
-0.35955774784088135,
0.5611401200294495,
-0.02338590659201145,
-0.46696698665618896,
0.6216283440589905,
0.5020708441734314,
0.6713986396789551,
-0.271626740694046,
0.4260837733745575,
0.269248902797699,
0.6360110640525818,
0.14914670586585999,
0.4211505651473999,
0.11767879873514175,
-0.5296315550804138,
-0.3251778483390808,
-0.25434356927871704,
-0.515037477016449,
0.2810027301311493,
-1.0256681442260742,
-0.10235953330993652,
-0.7578587532043457,
-0.21959207952022552,
-0.2607966363430023,
-0.22162751853466034,
-0.2520004212856293,
0.17276524007320404,
0.08534760028123856,
0.8225667476654053,
-0.5617927312850952,
0.614179253578186,
0.8155357241630554,
-0.378652960062027,
-1.1653584241867065,
0.1617228239774704,
0.20773327350616455,
-0.9206908345222473,
0.33850789070129395,
0.14465394616127014,
-0.4159723222255707,
-0.21567508578300476,
-0.9594769477844238,
-0.3392280638217926,
0.9376703500747681,
0.6079596281051636,
-0.6688875555992126,
-0.260223388671875,
0.4975980520248413,
0.37720268964767456,
0.04332364723086357,
0.1303703486919403,
0.6204444169998169,
0.13925443589687347,
-0.09152147173881531,
-0.7063618302345276,
0.29006314277648926,
-0.3238685131072998,
-0.05835571512579918,
0.07738456130027771,
-0.546352744102478,
0.74737948179245,
-0.3542308509349823,
-0.15261152386665344,
0.10774777084589005,
0.06404846906661987,
0.4937446415424347,
0.2579275071620941,
0.21949823200702667,
0.2972436845302582,
0.6790981292724609,
0.10185380280017853,
1.245688796043396,
-0.6151882410049438,
-0.03817101940512657,
1.0251466035842896,
-0.24459151923656464,
0.5659608244895935,
0.7432494759559631,
0.20969732105731964,
0.20603756606578827,
0.560205340385437,
0.24619990587234497,
0.4027378261089325,
0.3213421702384949,
-0.2667749226093292,
-0.11029718816280365,
-0.3289394974708557,
-0.38577336072921753,
0.43709325790405273,
0.45590463280677795,
-0.4164697229862213,
-0.1305479109287262,
-0.07271730154752731,
0.5753771066665649,
0.23974567651748657,
-0.34541797637939453,
0.742732048034668,
0.3390483856201172,
-0.5001384615898132,
0.40394216775894165,
0.23139925301074982,
0.550494909286499,
-0.35178646445274353,
-0.024899818003177643,
-0.22820451855659485,
-0.04437972232699394,
-0.2691374719142914,
-1.226676344871521,
0.27614668011665344,
0.7011067271232605,
0.03177259862422943,
-0.07939190417528152,
0.5980790257453918,
-0.07283729314804077,
-0.291297048330307,
0.1956343799829483,
0.6019856929779053,
-0.03313744440674782,
0.29076820611953735,
-0.6981480121612549,
0.09412328153848648,
0.11531013250350952,
-0.4157516360282898,
0.453997403383255,
0.4858744442462921,
-0.2636176347732544,
0.7217615842819214,
0.7547630667686462,
-0.15986445546150208,
0.18189559876918793,
-0.18369494378566742,
1.0905781984329224,
-0.539846658706665,
-0.20566807687282562,
-0.9706094861030579,
0.4852392077445984,
0.10216394066810608,
-0.22918033599853516,
0.7972317934036255,
0.3469097316265106,
0.8411824703216553,
0.12030447274446487,
0.8157424926757812,
0.08644712716341019,
0.20603421330451965,
-0.7724801301956177,
0.8572770357131958,
-0.4343320429325104,
0.8383637070655823,
-0.14313805103302002,
-0.7956844568252563,
0.18073031306266785,
0.2267218679189682,
-0.6302022337913513,
0.22832821309566498,
0.42071017622947693,
0.9826954007148743,
0.15926960110664368,
0.24752843379974365,
0.21071800589561462,
0.24246099591255188,
0.32034170627593994,
0.48493027687072754,
1.1590707302093506,
-0.059373725205659866,
0.5749146938323975,
-0.38689544796943665,
-0.03677327185869217,
0.02865476720035076,
-0.7911476492881775,
-0.9442136883735657,
-0.24715489149093628,
-0.004111276939511299,
-0.5341856479644775,
0.30635330080986023,
1.0025430917739868,
0.2009025663137436,
-0.548890233039856,
-0.18481694161891937,
0.28135859966278076,
-0.008775077760219574,
0.5355434417724609,
-0.2381640523672104,
0.24572870135307312,
0.1163586676120758,
-0.6089552044868469,
0.2246048003435135,
0.1399739384651184,
0.05608035996556282,
-0.31584739685058594,
0.1251683384180069,
0.2124975323677063,
0.4062124490737915,
0.6293555498123169,
0.2035037875175476,
-0.4386351406574249,
-0.45830273628234863,
0.40854865312576294,
-0.44467097520828247,
-0.350268691778183,
0.570014238357544,
-0.395062655210495,
0.18544811010360718,
0.13498863577842712,
0.7715561389923096,
-0.05828721076250076,
0.0644916296005249,
0.4817628860473633,
-0.5087347030639648,
0.059242673218250275,
0.5678945779800415,
0.1552359014749527,
0.453490287065506,
-0.7516086101531982,
0.3735121786594391,
-0.17044730484485626,
-0.7265223264694214,
-1.0289071798324585,
0.27082183957099915,
-0.7422949075698853,
-0.2986462712287903,
1.3185330629348755,
-0.19484709203243256,
-0.44093433022499084,
0.09962877631187439,
-0.277209609746933,
0.09312785416841507,
-0.25335803627967834,
0.8346937894821167,
0.47020986676216125,
-0.20187969505786896,
0.022581415250897408,
-0.8646144866943359,
0.28233566880226135,
0.3512195348739624,
-0.9384750723838806,
0.019843922927975655,
0.7452635765075684,
0.5883016586303711,
-0.1752849817276001,
0.39961138367652893,
-0.4345342218875885,
0.5147973299026489,
-0.1868908405303955,
-0.11651536822319031,
-0.25301045179367065,
-0.16292162239551544,
-0.20041324198246002,
0.047580547630786896,
0.17889586091041565,
-0.21369832754135132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15301v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15301v2
|
Causal Graph Discovery with Retrieval-Augmented Generation based Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T13:02:10 | 2024-06-18T05:51:50 |
Yuzhe Zhang, Yipeng Zhang, Yidong Gan, Lina Yao, Chen Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ME
|
Causal graph recovery is traditionally done using statistical
estimation-based methods or based on individual's knowledge about variables of
interests. They often suffer from data collection biases and limitations of
individuals' knowledge. The advance of large language models (LLMs) provides
opportunities to address these problems. We propose a novel method that
leverages LLMs to deduce causal relationships in general causal graph recovery
tasks. This method leverages knowledge compressed in LLMs and knowledge LLMs
extracted from scientific publication database as well as experiment data about
factors of interest to achieve this goal. Our method gives a prompting strategy
to extract associational relationships among those factors and a mechanism to
perform causality verification for these associations. Comparing to other
LLM-based methods that directly instruct LLMs to do the highly complex causal
reasoning, our method shows clear advantage on causal graph quality on
benchmark datasets. More importantly, as causality among some factors may
change as new research results emerge, our method show sensitivity to new
evidence in the literature and can provide useful information for updating
causal graphs accordingly.
|
[
-0.0933590829372406,
-1.0906715393066406,
0.9314727783203125,
0.08769860118627548,
-0.15317638218402863,
0.1453019082546234,
-0.15138189494609833,
-0.44671329855918884,
0.4729989171028137,
0.6544402241706848,
-0.4124145209789276,
-0.3719417452812195,
-0.6502234935760498,
0.2838883697986603,
-0.4298270046710968,
0.5184653401374817,
0.008435932919383049,
0.027157960459589958,
-0.167423278093338,
0.13163724541664124,
-0.5403762459754944,
-0.3118806481361389,
-0.8729983568191528,
-0.5428282022476196,
0.9640896320343018,
0.17958872020244598,
0.16355054080486298,
0.645126461982727,
0.41879919171333313,
0.28380313515663147,
-0.06881342083215714,
0.6303437352180481,
-0.7813283205032349,
0.08837273716926575,
-0.26222503185272217,
-0.18676632642745972,
-0.2976323366165161,
-0.1706981360912323,
0.7964431643486023,
0.9634761214256287,
0.06835038959980011,
0.041740089654922485,
0.09786850959062576,
0.47268882393836975,
-0.6633211970329285,
0.4378717839717865,
-0.7396811246871948,
-0.21149751543998718,
-0.18191754817962646,
-0.6265031099319458,
-0.7694491147994995,
-0.5089242458343506,
-0.20998352766036987,
-0.4941558539867401,
0.440878301858902,
0.19130198657512665,
0.5880626440048218,
-0.03278806805610657,
-0.9526487588882446,
-0.11738501489162445,
-0.7943317890167236,
0.4137290418148041,
-0.5607078075408936,
0.40798038244247437,
0.3338909447193146,
0.1793966293334961,
-0.6754007339477539,
-0.9745198488235474,
-0.6191758513450623,
-0.3203044831752777,
-0.2868638038635254,
-0.12697377800941467,
-0.11398925632238388,
-0.21338903903961182,
0.5150675773620605,
0.1480899453163147,
-0.3023985028266907,
0.1800529956817627,
-0.16897806525230408,
-0.4005192518234253,
0.6553095579147339,
0.21189281344413757,
0.4314242899417877,
-0.3548256754875183,
-0.23997588455677032,
0.046393465250730515,
-1.3521102666854858,
-0.32715997099876404,
0.2209964096546173,
0.6535625457763672,
0.15082475543022156,
0.7187596559524536,
-0.33333173394203186,
0.7098936438560486,
-0.14834266901016235,
-0.00051365967374295,
0.24331142008304596,
-0.29391881823539734,
-0.07560386508703232,
0.12217852473258972,
0.7880613207817078,
0.19194874167442322,
-0.04069064185023308,
-0.3331366181373596,
0.03423268347978592,
-0.3140847384929657,
-0.3279837369918823,
-0.7256912589073181,
-0.1572689414024353,
-0.2143578976392746,
-0.4010036289691925,
-0.022992486134171486,
-0.060123294591903687,
-0.6108201146125793,
-0.8199254274368286,
-0.40740203857421875,
0.2675984799861908,
-0.13934141397476196,
-0.46429333090782166,
0.019446419551968575,
-0.12641264498233795,
0.02195492759346962,
0.3538515567779541,
-0.6146636605262756,
0.020333345979452133,
0.6560708284378052,
0.6757895350456238,
0.040609683841466904,
-0.12346694618463516,
-0.8796985745429993,
0.387636661529541,
-0.326016366481781,
0.6671178340911865,
-0.30518245697021484,
-0.2616073191165924,
0.2070150226354599,
0.31416401267051697,
0.00570554519072175,
-0.37207770347595215,
0.43300744891166687,
-0.9689456224441528,
0.030989589169621468,
-0.7373884320259094,
-0.6979833245277405,
-0.15958602726459503,
0.13661393523216248,
-0.7848977446556091,
0.870587944984436,
-0.2038159817457199,
-0.8974066972732544,
0.43445125222206116,
-0.1224120557308197,
-0.5670879483222961,
0.17502306401729584,
-0.22524817287921906,
-0.23917317390441895,
-0.07010624557733536,
0.1789693683385849,
0.5484902858734131,
-0.6999045014381409,
0.6957768797874451,
-0.6979400515556335,
-0.07496155053377151,
0.0018294230103492737,
-0.39255064725875854,
0.9005219340324402,
-0.03980056941509247,
-0.15198743343353271,
0.08231068402528763,
-0.9749762415885925,
-0.3950154781341553,
0.3274874985218048,
-0.29107558727264404,
-0.6195956468582153,
0.40469467639923096,
-0.40929922461509705,
0.16247104108333588,
0.21286602318286896,
-0.7691084742546082,
0.27512773871421814,
-0.1724180430173874,
0.30327433347702026,
0.8178914785385132,
0.5524206757545471,
-0.05560998246073723,
0.05931791290640831,
0.12551403045654297,
-0.1913924217224121,
-0.2901969850063324,
0.10764622688293457,
-0.2174549698829651,
-0.6883829832077026,
-0.31231489777565,
0.027934739366173744,
0.24542194604873657,
-0.8480051755905151,
0.5504042506217957,
-0.41764870285987854,
-0.27695199847221375,
0.0231484267860651,
0.18927142024040222,
0.2810938060283661,
1.0138897895812988,
0.4238690733909607,
0.036544907838106155,
-0.6579919457435608,
-0.7397687435150146,
-0.09113339334726334,
-0.20277489721775055,
-0.16840706765651703,
0.5666013360023499,
0.33707401156425476,
-0.22461333870887756,
0.8533382415771484,
-0.9852154850959778,
-0.040937624871730804,
-0.07733716815710068,
0.1762610226869583,
0.2799520790576935,
0.2743338644504547,
0.29356375336647034,
-0.5938507914543152,
-0.19700279831886292,
-0.07913503050804138,
-0.9431300163269043,
-0.2752092778682709,
0.026103662326931953,
-0.3386837840080261,
-0.12438473105430603,
1.0320188999176025,
-0.5208861231803894,
0.1320650428533554,
0.09691894054412842,
-0.554897129535675,
0.644862949848175,
-0.181559756398201,
0.1622440069913864,
-0.9035156965255737,
0.3941068649291992,
0.004048820119351149,
-0.25958892703056335,
-0.39962682127952576,
-0.15629608929157257,
0.025242747738957405,
0.03824461251497269,
-0.07912083715200424,
0.6165925860404968,
-0.5214529037475586,
0.03251718357205391,
-0.36618760228157043,
0.36244311928749084,
-0.15011347830295563,
0.20203791558742523,
-0.07961203902959824,
0.4064525067806244,
0.43827271461486816,
-0.6365071535110474,
0.38609302043914795,
0.3102971911430359,
-0.12679845094680786,
0.2714945077896118,
-0.702083945274353,
0.0967571809887886,
-0.4182502031326294,
0.300492525100708,
-1.1372557878494263,
-0.3308233320713043,
0.17990733683109283,
-0.12085087597370148,
0.38385072350502014,
-0.0474923737347126,
-0.8361724615097046,
-0.42754948139190674,
0.03632081672549248,
0.24187907576560974,
0.23319068551063538,
-0.9497225284576416,
0.7070938944816589,
0.4375350773334503,
-0.19737182557582855,
-0.49840736389160156,
-0.11564866453409195,
0.1967613250017166,
-0.24951082468032837,
-0.5504668354988098,
0.03774602711200714,
0.09843581169843674,
-0.1565522700548172,
-0.016030406579375267,
0.0868770182132721,
0.1968267410993576,
0.19955553114414215,
0.09239300340414047,
0.35028567910194397,
0.08451121300458908,
0.41280028223991394,
-0.056720659136772156,
-0.07598177343606949,
0.3115408420562744,
-0.011905388906598091,
0.6166650652885437,
0.45305830240249634,
-0.24029064178466797,
0.04310145974159241,
0.1288367509841919,
0.240995392203331,
-0.2534746527671814,
0.6107071042060852,
0.5432671904563904,
-0.494331032037735,
-0.00029884310788474977,
-0.7284380197525024,
-0.3347398042678833,
-0.4364186227321625,
0.3682031035423279,
-0.1469634771347046,
-0.9183060526847839,
0.6192412972450256,
-0.5274069905281067,
-0.3373355567455292,
0.509257972240448,
0.48840659856796265,
0.3896282911300659,
1.1087000370025635,
0.4789564907550812,
-0.31177258491516113,
0.5148168802261353,
-0.03797219693660736,
0.2785516381263733,
-0.9107248187065125,
-0.5426793694496155,
-0.6685338616371155,
0.06428571045398712,
-0.45057350397109985,
-0.11606384068727493,
0.38956382870674133,
0.2569912374019623,
-0.5683972239494324,
0.17241427302360535,
-0.14322559535503387,
0.236730694770813,
0.48001807928085327,
0.5073249340057373,
0.6011431217193604,
0.11339540779590607,
0.01416282169520855,
0.29130786657333374,
-0.49658483266830444,
-0.11720098555088043,
0.994430661201477,
-0.1131792962551117,
0.7301362156867981,
0.31883952021598816,
0.6930201649665833,
0.20005859434604645,
0.512080192565918,
-0.40370941162109375,
0.7425581812858582,
0.08926904946565628,
-0.36151379346847534,
-0.25943341851234436,
-0.9570300579071045,
-1.3312954902648926,
0.07450041174888611,
-0.3936396837234497,
-0.9960619211196899,
0.23905453085899353,
0.10648605972528458,
0.18806758522987366,
0.11463045328855515,
-0.5517211556434631,
0.4453578293323517,
0.042417000979185104,
-0.6684138774871826,
-0.3475605249404907,
-0.6453015208244324,
0.6797046065330505,
-0.0809682309627533,
0.14037218689918518,
-0.18616358935832977,
0.35558828711509705,
0.793270468711853,
-0.4355565011501312,
0.9786791205406189,
-0.2968041002750397,
-0.22024838626384735,
0.2533710300922394,
0.2268754094839096,
0.8486363887786865,
0.10166724771261215,
-0.04124893248081207,
-0.12792475521564484,
-0.37234774231910706,
-0.1832549273967743,
-0.6698660850524902,
1.0395382642745972,
-0.5623486042022705,
-0.7438820004463196,
-0.16954247653484344,
-0.6073323488235474,
-0.4094039499759674,
0.7358754873275757,
-0.23086266219615936,
0.4777461886405945,
-0.195064976811409,
0.09219877421855927,
0.4119821786880493,
-0.2626795768737793,
0.3136582672595978,
0.8913063406944275,
-0.3424954414367676,
-0.37729498744010925,
0.7768431305885315,
-0.007271114736795425,
-0.0235457606613636,
0.467946320772171,
0.3156271278858185,
-0.42960307002067566,
-0.4019429087638855,
0.08378606289625168,
0.634310781955719,
-0.589903712272644,
-0.5488982796669006,
-0.5597068667411804,
-0.007939676754176617,
-0.5318395495414734,
0.160995215177536,
0.06433579325675964,
-0.35120344161987305,
-0.2681298851966858,
-0.36911773681640625,
0.5371960401535034,
0.7055878043174744,
-0.22402307391166687,
-0.007391920778900385,
-0.7468523383140564,
0.4446329176425934,
0.24712352454662323,
0.22955869138240814,
0.397190123796463,
-0.028253447264432907,
-0.164902463555336,
-0.19786426424980164,
-0.12272825837135315,
-0.9444460272789001,
0.4358930289745331,
0.013429172337055206,
0.536312997341156,
0.41490161418914795,
0.08107693493366241,
0.5760284662246704,
-0.6199228763580322,
0.4025019109249115,
0.29429906606674194,
-0.6985944509506226,
0.5553366541862488,
-0.4583393931388855,
-0.20488961040973663,
0.09717251360416412,
0.4557036757469177,
-0.31459423899650574,
-0.12055137753486633,
-0.6288571357727051,
-1.0500853061676025,
0.2869551479816437,
-0.04332375153899193,
-0.2698405683040619,
-0.4202423691749573,
0.6798806190490723,
-0.2223704308271408,
0.1284741312265396,
-0.4777430593967438,
-0.21963463723659515,
0.4197136163711548,
-0.025944041088223457,
-0.23784111440181732,
-0.35015109181404114,
-0.5180240273475647,
-0.24203163385391235,
0.7413185238838196,
-0.1953485906124115,
0.12200579792261124,
0.29705989360809326,
-0.11802030354738235,
-0.27708327770233154,
-0.008854368701577187,
0.1358826756477356,
0.8081037998199463,
-0.29243773221969604,
0.44031670689582825,
0.028987543657422066,
-0.21165557205677032,
0.11155050992965698,
0.45152950286865234,
-0.297887921333313,
-0.27401474118232727,
0.6377542018890381,
0.6123554706573486,
0.21293295919895172,
-0.6435949206352234,
0.36405032873153687,
0.09706169366836548,
0.22027163207530975,
-0.14284424483776093,
-0.06775519996881485,
0.10481646656990051,
0.3780340254306793,
0.5715181827545166,
-0.3606870472431183,
0.23029634356498718,
-0.38063448667526245,
0.2241603583097458,
0.5848082304000854,
-0.0016849045641720295,
-0.2853434085845947,
0.614027738571167,
0.036354511976242065,
-0.11871395260095596,
0.6705081462860107,
-0.09970913827419281,
-0.19585752487182617,
0.5983673334121704,
0.9172095656394958,
0.6252906918525696,
0.023767229169607162,
0.14755034446716309,
0.6687185168266296,
0.023959090933203697,
-0.13988682627677917,
0.22843125462532043,
0.3185149133205414,
-0.8118361830711365,
-0.6933281421661377,
-0.2733900845050812,
-0.07686958461999893,
0.06554795801639557,
-0.5849751234054565,
0.31226059794425964,
-0.2219512015581131,
-0.058548811823129654,
-0.03406459838151932,
0.1390426605939865,
-0.5525214076042175,
-0.04315889999270439,
-0.21734113991260529,
0.7702438235282898,
-1.0344027280807495,
0.6534634232521057,
0.137330561876297,
-0.5155655741691589,
-1.0463920831680298,
-0.3276548981666565,
0.03083719313144684,
-0.9215335845947266,
0.9259686470031738,
-0.20157013833522797,
-0.02181597612798214,
0.2824461758136749,
-0.6964523792266846,
-1.0210708379745483,
1.3170839548110962,
0.6023423075675964,
-0.6481825113296509,
0.11065912246704102,
-0.1373267024755478,
0.46789947152137756,
-0.19882263243198395,
0.025422057136893272,
0.4527682363986969,
0.44155973196029663,
0.15477821230888367,
-0.3924495279788971,
0.8181755542755127,
0.0335845984518528,
-0.17607885599136353,
0.4881853759288788,
-0.482453852891922,
0.6341055631637573,
-0.2367178201675415,
-0.25075048208236694,
-0.055400263518095016,
0.6821684241294861,
0.5353264808654785,
0.4083964228630066,
0.39265137910842896,
0.3893791437149048,
1.1127779483795166,
0.10727100819349289,
1.1489315032958984,
-0.368139386177063,
0.5261026620864868,
1.130003809928894,
-0.4658559262752533,
0.5986222624778748,
0.5263395309448242,
-0.13038094341754913,
0.55873042345047,
0.437441885471344,
0.02509988099336624,
0.43614819645881653,
0.1072535589337349,
-0.32562023401260376,
-0.4402741491794586,
-0.46580371260643005,
-0.36412763595581055,
0.006256010849028826,
0.304233580827713,
-0.557827353477478,
-0.3240017592906952,
-0.1809518039226532,
0.2774249315261841,
-0.14366428554058075,
-0.34098580479621887,
0.5941271185874939,
0.1175457313656807,
-0.5697423815727234,
0.4257255494594574,
-0.1915130317211151,
0.02249308116734028,
-0.6335328221321106,
-0.30690404772758484,
-0.13530059158802032,
0.10455793142318726,
-0.1299193650484085,
-0.4698197543621063,
-0.09759088605642319,
-0.3198581635951996,
-0.25768381357192993,
0.13180039823055267,
1.050922155380249,
-0.5433692932128906,
-0.5215458869934082,
0.4523126184940338,
0.6619677543640137,
-0.23591293394565582,
0.13668151199817657,
-0.003724035806953907,
0.055445849895477295,
-0.12998855113983154,
-0.04457708075642586,
0.3061493933200836,
0.4969556927680969,
-0.18311481177806854,
0.6243076324462891,
0.7563914060592651,
0.3101082444190979,
-0.1897648125886917,
0.30556678771972656,
1.0847384929656982,
-0.6008929014205933,
-0.13924981653690338,
-0.8544597625732422,
0.17111265659332275,
-0.3187510669231415,
0.11688078194856644,
1.068228840827942,
0.4592708945274353,
0.3496817648410797,
0.011002626270055771,
0.6507536172866821,
-0.0787842646241188,
0.5488752126693726,
-0.7602381110191345,
0.4541895389556885,
-0.377335786819458,
0.40820828080177307,
-0.3880154490470886,
-0.7193098664283752,
-0.4742134213447571,
0.1399790644645691,
-0.45594704151153564,
-0.06476373970508575,
0.7676416635513306,
0.8719096779823303,
0.03169085085391998,
-0.08530059456825256,
-0.1593826711177826,
0.6387914419174194,
0.7685182690620422,
0.3979714810848236,
0.6218984723091125,
-0.10810265690088272,
0.3407879173755646,
0.18970994651317596,
-0.3870491087436676,
-0.13991400599479675,
-1.0723576545715332,
-0.64210444688797,
-0.47550642490386963,
-0.30960220098495483,
-0.6751784682273865,
0.003679639659821987,
0.7418889403343201,
0.28400397300720215,
-0.45889967679977417,
-0.06317359209060669,
-0.36496591567993164,
0.40952157974243164,
-0.09391175210475922,
-0.2914043664932251,
0.937614917755127,
-0.25619593262672424,
-0.4091698229312897,
0.5522328615188599,
-0.017787521705031395,
-0.1571694314479828,
-0.17237967252731323,
0.005967437755316496,
-0.4823974072933197,
-0.028853440657258034,
0.7759618759155273,
0.5519354939460754,
-0.1999523639678955,
-0.5772874355316162,
-0.23848624527454376,
0.12723813951015472,
-0.2996997535228729,
1.142901062965393,
-0.7555967569351196,
0.3475129306316376,
0.7626217007637024,
0.5348541140556335,
0.809145987033844,
-0.14166326820850372,
0.6198341846466064,
-0.886329174041748,
0.16338306665420532,
-0.1372431516647339,
0.7931867241859436,
0.3876507580280304,
-0.4991725981235504,
0.6135337352752686,
0.5801706910133362,
-0.6404163837432861,
-0.8666685223579407,
0.44316187500953674,
-1.0195597410202026,
-0.24743936955928802,
1.2736278772354126,
-0.14910075068473816,
0.06949366629123688,
-0.04824898764491081,
-0.11407991498708725,
0.4799802303314209,
-0.15803872048854828,
0.9699289798736572,
0.36595287919044495,
-0.3987007439136505,
0.06045932695269585,
-0.0940157100558281,
0.22658522427082062,
-0.07994936406612396,
-0.8064365983009338,
0.277232825756073,
0.8442827463150024,
0.32928934693336487,
0.0937085896730423,
0.740959107875824,
-0.16931192576885223,
-0.141968235373497,
-0.060672130435705185,
-0.13301506638526917,
-0.20032872259616852,
-0.2640872895717621,
0.08168734610080719,
0.23716437816619873,
0.11590764671564102,
0.3740366995334625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15300v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15300v2
|
Seeing is Believing: Mitigating Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models via CLIP-Guided Decoding
| 2024-02-23T12:57:16 | 2024-04-23T09:32:25 |
Ailin Deng, Zhirui Chen, Bryan Hooi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) are susceptible to object
hallucinations, an issue in which their generated text contains non-existent
objects, greatly limiting their reliability and practicality. Current
approaches often rely on the model's token likelihoods or other internal
information, instruction tuning on additional datasets, or incorporating
complex external tools. We first perform empirical analysis on sentence-level
LVLM hallucination, finding that CLIP similarity to the image acts as a
stronger and more robust indicator of hallucination compared to token
likelihoods. Motivated by this, we introduce our CLIP-Guided Decoding (CGD)
approach, a straightforward but effective training-free approach to reduce
object hallucination at decoding time. CGD uses CLIP to guide the model's
decoding process by enhancing visual grounding of generated text with the
image. Experiments demonstrate that CGD effectively mitigates object
hallucination across multiple LVLM families while preserving the utility of
text generation. Codes are available at
https://github.com/d-ailin/CLIP-Guided-Decoding.
|
[
-0.29733189940452576,
-0.7637500166893005,
0.6831579208374023,
0.3093310296535492,
-0.7078988552093506,
-0.10960540920495987,
-0.28070977330207825,
-0.4639495313167572,
0.19495858252048492,
0.7632011771202087,
-0.37336164712905884,
-0.6538541316986084,
-0.577029824256897,
0.04900520294904709,
-0.5516944527626038,
0.5052154660224915,
0.10611000657081604,
0.2358337640762329,
-0.5141581296920776,
0.08298832923173904,
-0.641827404499054,
-0.6691941022872925,
-0.37736648321151733,
-0.0439443439245224,
0.19412223994731903,
0.28488004207611084,
0.7610949873924255,
0.9533674120903015,
0.5598102807998657,
0.058930642902851105,
-0.11216481775045395,
0.34306952357292175,
-0.50266432762146,
-0.006287495605647564,
-0.031828802078962326,
-0.22366487979888916,
-0.027048541232943535,
-0.43182530999183655,
0.4343036115169525,
0.6474180817604065,
-0.13209861516952515,
-0.26328977942466736,
0.3405121862888336,
0.541147768497467,
-0.8237445950508118,
0.2758595049381256,
-0.8007494807243347,
0.3295048177242279,
0.1353052705526352,
-0.3635430932044983,
-0.5695975422859192,
-0.25637519359588623,
0.15165939927101135,
-0.3851527273654938,
0.4351382851600647,
0.16688740253448486,
0.8769062757492065,
0.39904606342315674,
-0.14722827076911926,
-0.45069918036460876,
-0.4929966628551483,
0.7080460786819458,
-0.4317539632320404,
0.7395460605621338,
0.5433783531188965,
0.13873986899852753,
-0.03106820397078991,
-0.42007318139076233,
-0.5805593132972717,
-0.33668193221092224,
0.09280985593795776,
-0.03352833166718483,
0.04756306856870651,
0.11393566429615021,
0.5313451290130615,
0.20930421352386475,
-0.4771207869052887,
-0.1737055778503418,
-0.47897884249687195,
-0.31427040696144104,
0.2891503870487213,
-0.07132209837436676,
0.3608810007572174,
-0.11636271327733994,
-0.44058698415756226,
-0.3802438974380493,
-0.7683893442153931,
-0.16151927411556244,
-0.09190473705530167,
0.036277662962675095,
0.32293546199798584,
0.7320042848587036,
-0.00923335924744606,
0.4702393710613251,
-0.006749753374606371,
-0.1595878154039383,
-0.02435128018260002,
-0.058278828859329224,
-0.2954321503639221,
0.24838729202747345,
0.44124922156333923,
0.8759613037109375,
0.38190752267837524,
-0.42757412791252136,
-0.2582132816314697,
0.47192803025245667,
0.3262215256690979,
-1.0112029314041138,
-0.408024400472641,
-0.036039646714925766,
-0.7136746048927307,
-0.4232370853424072,
0.1151532530784607,
-0.819326639175415,
-0.5559355020523071,
-0.17730945348739624,
0.5505622029304504,
-0.6576909422874451,
-0.01609315164387226,
0.5698961615562439,
-0.15080049633979797,
0.3413736820220947,
0.2933739423751831,
-1.0604177713394165,
0.339385062456131,
0.7193416953086853,
1.1300218105316162,
-0.5073086023330688,
-0.5291188359260559,
-1.0337766408920288,
0.24185477197170258,
-0.5692906379699707,
0.8189491629600525,
-0.3151748478412628,
-0.5694697499275208,
0.208771750330925,
0.12909403443336487,
0.10847833007574081,
-0.8004812002182007,
0.591163158416748,
-0.01368429884314537,
-0.24098517000675201,
-0.3738231062889099,
-0.6106353402137756,
-0.2574467360973358,
0.2963514029979706,
-0.6001052260398865,
0.7328394055366516,
-0.20853999257087708,
-0.44394874572753906,
0.49746355414390564,
-0.16880308091640472,
-0.42644110321998596,
-0.032416924834251404,
-0.4341771602630615,
-0.5660514235496521,
0.5739078521728516,
0.6132451891899109,
0.5128273367881775,
0.08641495555639267,
0.19937796890735626,
-0.32086285948753357,
-0.49328121542930603,
0.19764727354049683,
-0.37498801946640015,
0.32399052381515503,
-0.03495321422815323,
-0.38254314661026,
0.28892117738723755,
-0.6092634201049805,
-0.15704351663589478,
0.08706241846084595,
0.13425128161907196,
-0.3134792745113373,
0.3895096778869629,
0.1416832059621811,
0.008631397038698196,
-0.17455631494522095,
-0.4214478135108948,
0.16632331907749176,
-0.3459872603416443,
0.18805204331874847,
0.7108676433563232,
0.13863271474838257,
0.19290339946746826,
-0.09831574559211731,
0.3923858106136322,
0.05678820610046387,
0.3052070140838623,
-0.483823299407959,
-0.3981900215148926,
-0.7823778986930847,
-0.14274436235427856,
-0.2636297345161438,
0.3965368866920471,
-0.9052693843841553,
0.24367305636405945,
-0.055291853845119476,
-0.23300997912883759,
-0.21376119554042816,
-0.06202629581093788,
0.3089195489883423,
0.547343909740448,
0.3978508412837982,
-0.4077601730823517,
-0.41165632009506226,
-0.8849068284034729,
-0.10739728063344955,
0.03025326505303383,
-0.026872703805565834,
0.03963695466518402,
0.554196298122406,
-0.2524535655975342,
0.6221946477890015,
-0.7201224565505981,
-0.5006380081176758,
-0.07090337574481964,
-0.2943572402000427,
-0.16401804983615875,
0.4036324620246887,
0.5011183619499207,
-0.7320108413696289,
-0.3093021810054779,
0.036190785467624664,
-0.900413990020752,
0.09491772949695587,
-0.3364720344543457,
-0.1095888689160347,
0.2896806299686432,
0.6340276002883911,
-0.6210435628890991,
1.063660979270935,
0.4299331307411194,
-0.641569972038269,
0.5683643221855164,
-0.2242799699306488,
0.14180734753608704,
-0.7543124556541443,
-0.25757646560668945,
-0.30018147826194763,
-0.37548261880874634,
-0.39223331212997437,
0.055884964764118195,
0.1268320083618164,
-0.3095158338546753,
-0.3969869911670685,
0.30317428708076477,
-0.6266131401062012,
-0.27649596333503723,
-0.5641095638275146,
0.10142400115728378,
0.25494351983070374,
0.30882060527801514,
0.5250086188316345,
0.7360544204711914,
0.9520037770271301,
-0.43381550908088684,
0.1950768083333969,
0.5431687831878662,
-0.6595240235328674,
0.38895124197006226,
-0.6209550499916077,
0.046764031052589417,
-0.1827058643102646,
-0.038428325206041336,
-0.38975510001182556,
-0.1521463841199875,
0.4692217707633972,
-0.2588590681552887,
-0.03014007955789566,
-0.03169112280011177,
-0.47865062952041626,
-0.16083163022994995,
-0.42646804451942444,
0.41298842430114746,
0.574627697467804,
-0.9369478225708008,
0.4171408414840698,
0.15541286766529083,
0.1506282538175583,
-0.3139280378818512,
-0.7600698471069336,
0.4739948809146881,
-0.03474524989724159,
-0.524633526802063,
0.2977611720561981,
-0.28691545128822327,
-0.04488961398601532,
0.11612207442522049,
-0.26604026556015015,
0.007962922565639019,
0.1865082085132599,
0.17619116604328156,
0.42303895950317383,
-0.1476096510887146,
0.08356094360351562,
-0.1416815221309662,
-0.023249533027410507,
0.13666531443595886,
-0.4993467628955841,
0.649761974811554,
0.005512316711246967,
-0.6595152020454407,
-0.36877551674842834,
0.7381821274757385,
0.7002208232879639,
-0.2149721384048462,
0.8819829821586609,
0.4797855317592621,
-0.6409211158752441,
-0.4298609495162964,
-0.3435976505279541,
-0.5203015804290771,
-0.4252307713031769,
0.5638130307197571,
-0.28983306884765625,
-0.5491581559181213,
0.23236042261123657,
0.26181092858314514,
-0.3085644245147705,
-0.12096497416496277,
0.4892221987247467,
0.24088287353515625,
1.0870120525360107,
0.9035719037055969,
0.31079867482185364,
0.42494913935661316,
-0.031051475554704666,
0.3948851227760315,
-0.790734052658081,
-0.4350758194923401,
-0.0463242307305336,
0.14939145743846893,
-0.0245736762881279,
-0.7892519235610962,
0.2192855328321457,
0.4599827527999878,
0.38553711771965027,
0.08736367523670197,
-0.9118291139602661,
0.9269677400588989,
0.3857501149177551,
0.2866123914718628,
0.39437538385391235,
0.2400367558002472,
0.1422603577375412,
-0.3345801830291748,
-0.4452301859855652,
-0.5075411200523376,
0.9034464359283447,
0.2853088974952698,
0.875870943069458,
-0.2212214469909668,
0.6249101758003235,
0.27021029591560364,
-0.09031357616186142,
-1.103545069694519,
0.6251533627510071,
-0.09579319506883621,
-0.012502784840762615,
-0.09265490621328354,
-0.13496091961860657,
-0.4882175922393799,
0.5223616361618042,
-0.4691687226295471,
-0.8302702307701111,
0.28813135623931885,
0.24111250042915344,
-0.004350161645561457,
0.5512042045593262,
-0.4426986575126648,
0.8173732161521912,
-0.41916167736053467,
-0.3337768316268921,
-0.2579402029514313,
-0.1401543915271759,
0.3733777105808258,
0.05199594050645828,
-0.12535226345062256,
0.09779496490955353,
0.1296280026435852,
0.5316973924636841,
-0.43127429485321045,
0.7161473631858826,
-0.12511566281318665,
-0.1629602015018463,
0.15180744230747223,
0.11065679043531418,
0.724205493927002,
0.08683411777019501,
0.3114939033985138,
0.18348723649978638,
-0.029110778123140335,
-0.31949397921562195,
-0.6519030928611755,
0.5027610063552856,
-0.20129947364330292,
-0.527625322341919,
-0.43885111808776855,
-0.46217772364616394,
-0.013738877139985561,
0.20500817894935608,
0.520518958568573,
0.6065146923065186,
-0.1330959051847458,
0.4125622510910034,
1.088436484336853,
-0.35256141424179077,
0.33570897579193115,
-0.2193942666053772,
-0.8712658286094666,
-0.6296603679656982,
1.0479536056518555,
-0.1342775970697403,
0.32374605536460876,
0.18533851206302643,
0.0621374249458313,
-0.1910928636789322,
-0.9132436513900757,
-0.38683849573135376,
0.18764716386795044,
-0.9731194972991943,
-0.016659056767821312,
-0.6284381747245789,
-0.1348666399717331,
-0.4645449221134186,
-0.37457790970802307,
-0.39202505350112915,
-0.06404514610767365,
-0.3935004472732544,
-0.14721141755580902,
0.16885831952095032,
0.6017930507659912,
0.13636815547943115,
0.057790014892816544,
-0.7144933342933655,
0.6990044713020325,
0.319012850522995,
0.3876810371875763,
0.1677670180797577,
-0.1276838630437851,
-0.335859477519989,
-0.12547653913497925,
-0.1278311014175415,
-0.892216682434082,
0.6999862194061279,
0.13804462552070618,
0.3429100811481476,
0.5812875032424927,
0.1585065722465515,
0.7594422698020935,
-0.6401662230491638,
0.7913882732391357,
0.42483505606651306,
-1.1983212232589722,
0.5301026701927185,
0.01185421459376812,
-0.034899428486824036,
0.2648155689239502,
-0.18916761875152588,
-0.6756592988967896,
-0.37760424613952637,
-0.2451273649930954,
-0.7445651292800903,
0.36252400279045105,
0.2810605764389038,
-0.03524556756019592,
-0.12740524113178253,
0.1706744283437729,
0.25397995114326477,
0.19872306287288666,
-0.8012693524360657,
0.08610405772924423,
-0.6309145092964172,
-0.1590978354215622,
0.03665684536099434,
-0.40843188762664795,
-0.0837588682770729,
-0.272885799407959,
0.34956374764442444,
-0.3106931746006012,
0.28240224719047546,
0.5745848417282104,
-0.33966702222824097,
0.12727318704128265,
-0.10806549340486526,
0.9251508712768555,
0.4985714852809906,
-0.2753167450428009,
0.20449136197566986,
0.006532025523483753,
-0.7451149225234985,
-0.2654167711734772,
-0.2791123390197754,
-0.322015643119812,
0.275676429271698,
0.4240429103374481,
1.2215697765350342,
0.04562893509864807,
-0.8744074106216431,
0.7071252465248108,
-0.04367408528923988,
-0.42584943771362305,
-0.32994282245635986,
-0.025331847369670868,
-0.11589032411575317,
0.2461596578359604,
0.542232096195221,
0.023540634661912918,
0.04407202824950218,
-0.5030421018600464,
0.39024800062179565,
0.4820948839187622,
-0.5044753551483154,
-0.2291848063468933,
0.8989763855934143,
-0.056895241141319275,
-0.4414384961128235,
0.49371784925460815,
0.04038742557168007,
-0.7554706931114197,
0.5373091101646423,
0.886537492275238,
1.086522102355957,
0.36573320627212524,
0.2012658417224884,
0.2042301446199417,
0.40022581815719604,
-0.44455280900001526,
0.09006165713071823,
-0.1447332203388214,
-0.5922874808311462,
-0.4260914623737335,
-0.6462274193763733,
-0.5476858615875244,
0.02504202350974083,
-0.8831954598426819,
0.3319920599460602,
-0.473251074552536,
0.22339797019958496,
-0.5220853686332703,
-0.5550699830055237,
-0.34623828530311584,
0.03748851269483566,
0.4276280403137207,
0.8452616333961487,
-0.7513382434844971,
0.7979143857955933,
0.18082886934280396,
-0.14752592146396637,
-0.5707380771636963,
0.4839780628681183,
-0.36255618929862976,
-0.6386236548423767,
0.4214337170124054,
0.5735440254211426,
-0.3166486322879791,
-0.12693357467651367,
-0.7453249096870422,
-0.5080447196960449,
0.8928085565567017,
0.3376903533935547,
-0.5041138529777527,
0.040411464869976044,
-0.029582830145955086,
0.2210230976343155,
-0.4786525368690491,
-0.39283713698387146,
0.3205360472202301,
0.25473105907440186,
0.2805788516998291,
-0.5299044251441956,
0.17171204090118408,
0.020368065685033798,
0.09145882725715637,
0.09126078337430954,
-0.38227489590644836,
0.630636990070343,
-0.3897877037525177,
-0.5018609762191772,
0.09309540688991547,
0.7103229761123657,
0.2980193495750427,
0.4116470217704773,
0.5287889242172241,
0.32642775774002075,
0.8326616883277893,
0.0536048449575901,
0.8544468879699707,
-0.062352415174245834,
0.35028988122940063,
0.9300540685653687,
-0.2873218357563019,
0.867074728012085,
0.821560263633728,
0.32118749618530273,
0.238003671169281,
0.205318883061409,
-0.3929676115512848,
0.801855206489563,
0.048024293035268784,
-0.2611258029937744,
-0.40088123083114624,
-0.12531423568725586,
-0.3755885660648346,
0.3910767436027527,
0.2513324022293091,
-0.32114410400390625,
-0.06103820726275444,
0.5729209780693054,
-0.27477046847343445,
0.3910737633705139,
-0.34990406036376953,
0.4938797950744629,
0.08622609823942184,
-0.5264454483985901,
0.84044349193573,
-0.43095219135284424,
0.6690352559089661,
-0.15708574652671814,
-0.3628982901573181,
-0.13431201875209808,
0.16949144005775452,
-0.09425923973321915,
-0.7320243120193481,
0.5400285124778748,
0.07124563306570053,
-0.38712888956069946,
-0.3105054199695587,
0.6937471032142639,
-0.5999181866645813,
-0.6021363139152527,
0.31225961446762085,
0.14961419999599457,
0.22902129590511322,
-0.43161439895629883,
-0.19259117543697357,
0.4438648819923401,
0.2890061140060425,
0.10459084808826447,
0.2292519360780716,
0.3332943916320801,
-0.13676264882087708,
0.7324997186660767,
0.6832173466682434,
0.24581511318683624,
0.018712585791945457,
0.03967757895588875,
0.8013734221458435,
-0.9427459239959717,
-0.44158920645713806,
-1.0522977113723755,
0.23100879788398743,
-0.19734156131744385,
-0.0878709927201271,
0.7058108448982239,
0.5890451073646545,
0.7379459142684937,
-0.5720997452735901,
0.5358420014381409,
0.2762814462184906,
0.14781121909618378,
-0.9394001364707947,
0.8807559609413147,
-0.5170563459396362,
0.2813202142715454,
-0.3191545009613037,
-1.0824096202850342,
-0.6737833023071289,
0.8895823359489441,
0.09737340360879898,
-0.6582430601119995,
0.970020055770874,
0.8273756504058838,
-0.03331117704510689,
-0.18480056524276733,
0.6918105483055115,
0.028117390349507332,
0.446310430765152,
0.6224382519721985,
1.0763492584228516,
-0.3007797598838806,
0.9122648239135742,
-0.28470173478126526,
-0.08209684491157532,
-0.33618637919425964,
-1.0153864622116089,
-1.1862380504608154,
-0.47185349464416504,
-0.3702695369720459,
-0.3850543797016144,
0.010127794928848743,
0.5923784971237183,
0.6046961545944214,
-0.5149842500686646,
-0.028173068538308144,
-0.3765242099761963,
0.16307087242603302,
-0.29893845319747925,
-0.2236725091934204,
0.5014905333518982,
-0.12948766350746155,
-0.682246208190918,
0.39422285556793213,
0.5416804552078247,
0.21117520332336426,
-0.2857690751552582,
-0.17685309052467346,
0.36524367332458496,
0.040900371968746185,
0.7759533524513245,
0.12922802567481995,
-0.9489619731903076,
-0.5802720785140991,
0.1966865360736847,
-0.1056550070643425,
0.22208565473556519,
0.6987820863723755,
-0.934016227722168,
0.4656442701816559,
0.266186386346817,
0.6478209495544434,
0.5127177834510803,
-0.043902162462472916,
0.48975837230682373,
-0.25677037239074707,
0.40664488077163696,
0.169662743806839,
0.26892316341400146,
0.4620025157928467,
-0.43209901452064514,
0.4300731420516968,
0.4320668578147888,
-0.4353724718093872,
-1.2358801364898682,
0.4369667172431946,
-1.2154473066329956,
-0.3743005394935608,
1.0559542179107666,
0.07803400605916977,
-0.500625729560852,
0.06847049295902252,
-0.7246964573860168,
-0.01649460196495056,
-0.09563890099525452,
0.9616774320602417,
0.6550465822219849,
0.10325457155704498,
-0.44403746724128723,
-0.38171499967575073,
0.651648223400116,
0.4448753297328949,
-0.6831672191619873,
0.44975051283836365,
0.6762000918388367,
0.03530377522110939,
0.05136972665786743,
0.3544396460056305,
0.10772795230150223,
0.38580989837646484,
0.22635994851589203,
0.10404414683580399,
-0.20251725614070892,
-0.5518640279769897,
-0.3138614594936371,
0.18521814048290253,
-0.008518567308783531,
-0.5529747605323792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15289v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15289v1
|
Let's Rectify Step by Step: Improving Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis with Diffusion Models
| 2024-02-23T12:35:43 | 2024-02-23T12:35:43 |
Shunyu Liu, Jie Zhou, Qunxi Zhu, Qin Chen, Qingchun Bai, Jun Xiao, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) stands as a crucial task in predicting
the sentiment polarity associated with identified aspects within text. However,
a notable challenge in ABSA lies in precisely determining the aspects'
boundaries (start and end indices), especially for long ones, due to users'
colloquial expressions. We propose DiffusionABSA, a novel diffusion model
tailored for ABSA, which extracts the aspects progressively step by step.
Particularly, DiffusionABSA gradually adds noise to the aspect terms in the
training process, subsequently learning a denoising process that progressively
restores these terms in a reverse manner. To estimate the boundaries, we design
a denoising neural network enhanced by a syntax-aware temporal attention
mechanism to chronologically capture the interplay between aspects and
surrounding text. Empirical evaluations conducted on eight benchmark datasets
underscore the compelling advantages offered by DiffusionABSA when compared
against robust baseline models. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/Qlb6x/DiffusionABSA.
|
[
-0.539650559425354,
-0.8459872007369995,
0.8427038788795471,
0.5875979065895081,
-0.5007462501525879,
0.1371661275625229,
0.08283128589391708,
-0.14602506160736084,
0.46435636281967163,
0.5124390125274658,
-0.5861009359359741,
-0.5938609838485718,
-0.6526026129722595,
-0.13067343831062317,
-0.5330243110656738,
1.17612886428833,
0.020904015749692917,
-0.10463058203458786,
-0.33940428495407104,
-0.30209600925445557,
-0.24421176314353943,
-0.25089895725250244,
-1.0181058645248413,
-0.5340849757194519,
0.5988401770591736,
-0.05086201801896095,
0.4416489601135254,
0.07673032581806183,
0.14131875336170197,
0.21274128556251526,
-0.7425612807273865,
-0.10617092996835709,
-0.054639898240566254,
0.2062636911869049,
-0.21158666908740997,
-0.33813410997390747,
-0.5836436748504639,
-0.11478381603956223,
0.4109511971473694,
0.9647547602653503,
-0.22374653816223145,
-0.006670811213552952,
0.12156828492879868,
1.0747908353805542,
-0.30889731645584106,
0.18973124027252197,
-0.27063360810279846,
0.029620980843901634,
-0.017131781205534935,
0.16900409758090973,
-0.21769972145557404,
-0.4477289617061615,
0.1600576490163803,
-0.24592329561710358,
0.2803022861480713,
-0.2602260708808899,
0.7705278396606445,
0.02483924850821495,
-0.24123013019561768,
0.04332929104566574,
-0.6506502032279968,
0.701819658279419,
-0.766360342502594,
0.4516248404979706,
0.14537130296230316,
-0.15729840099811554,
0.07360830157995224,
-0.4362875819206238,
-0.5246673226356506,
0.04930257052183151,
0.018494993448257446,
0.13367408514022827,
-0.2877398431301117,
-0.10914625972509384,
0.03214792162179947,
0.4512726366519928,
-0.2673971354961395,
-0.1571904718875885,
-0.21752411127090454,
-0.1177816092967987,
0.45533671975135803,
0.09854291379451752,
0.05801629275083542,
-0.3361051082611084,
-0.07200460880994797,
0.22332052886486053,
-0.5467101335525513,
0.2440062016248703,
0.40596288442611694,
0.21687862277030945,
-0.2887430191040039,
0.24405942857265472,
-0.3115507662296295,
0.4314189553260803,
0.2479938268661499,
0.2011038064956665,
0.4891895353794098,
-0.2626314163208008,
-0.15945763885974884,
-0.3421437740325928,
0.7252965569496155,
0.3936655819416046,
-0.32270219922065735,
-0.04945597052574158,
-0.3618786334991455,
-0.05609904229640961,
0.45477479696273804,
-0.6884018182754517,
-0.26551884412765503,
0.4745855927467346,
-0.3838255703449249,
-0.2492811381816864,
-0.3286479115486145,
-1.1307346820831299,
-0.6753748059272766,
-0.4484837055206299,
0.21787168085575104,
-0.3052217662334442,
-0.44343301653862,
-0.12143053859472275,
-0.08763587474822998,
0.0800495445728302,
0.47455379366874695,
-0.3587636649608612,
0.1859978586435318,
0.904832124710083,
1.3033103942871094,
0.04330058768391609,
0.2155638039112091,
-0.21608901023864746,
-0.485324889421463,
-0.41345933079719543,
0.9028075337409973,
-0.7024187445640564,
-0.41490495204925537,
-0.07382800430059433,
-0.1612897366285324,
0.1625819206237793,
-0.45797428488731384,
0.25555261969566345,
-0.7595227360725403,
0.20599333941936493,
-0.2061595469713211,
-0.32919856905937195,
-0.5206779837608337,
0.4184345304965973,
-0.6227152347564697,
0.9604524374008179,
0.1706002652645111,
-0.6440220475196838,
0.036558013409376144,
-0.7733184695243835,
-0.5607444047927856,
-0.3545042872428894,
0.19552265107631683,
-0.6796923279762268,
0.296679824590683,
0.42694705724716187,
0.47552254796028137,
0.042587537318468094,
0.2531891465187073,
-0.24659475684165955,
0.28276729583740234,
0.23635245859622955,
-0.40695720911026,
0.5934218764305115,
0.20394647121429443,
-0.021139515563845634,
0.21423819661140442,
-0.6010411977767944,
-0.4351326525211334,
-0.24294590950012207,
0.041849732398986816,
-0.7287034392356873,
0.033585235476493835,
-0.15227414667606354,
0.12095706164836884,
0.38935986161231995,
-0.6572829484939575,
0.0413200743496418,
-0.6806643605232239,
0.5439269542694092,
0.743755042552948,
0.429780513048172,
0.7835685610771179,
-0.05248486250638962,
0.5944600701332092,
0.5733320713043213,
0.36819902062416077,
-0.1436741054058075,
-0.4993600845336914,
-0.6907575726509094,
-0.22589904069900513,
0.1987493336200714,
0.2784669101238251,
-0.6691781282424927,
0.5232540369033813,
-0.108223095536232,
-0.5178370475769043,
-0.5659323930740356,
0.3166902959346771,
0.16349585354328156,
0.5327430963516235,
0.3301129937171936,
-0.9042505621910095,
-0.35215312242507935,
-0.7506231069564819,
-0.011704249307513237,
-0.25060951709747314,
0.1040581464767456,
0.0679185539484024,
0.2651641368865967,
-0.09309504926204681,
1.165033221244812,
-0.4604882001876831,
-0.415844589471817,
-0.37844663858413696,
0.5377840399742126,
0.20870055258274078,
0.1717623472213745,
0.4879000782966614,
-0.8716687560081482,
-0.374702125787735,
-0.07033044099807739,
-0.49004754424095154,
-0.35352468490600586,
-0.3222668766975403,
-0.24628517031669617,
0.12009652704000473,
0.5754944682121277,
-0.4645944833755493,
0.38234075903892517,
0.5384266972541809,
-0.36458849906921387,
0.35142281651496887,
0.20597071945667267,
-0.035730648785829544,
-1.2910367250442505,
-0.01446055993437767,
0.46159234642982483,
-0.297858864068985,
-0.4275580644607544,
-0.03347688913345337,
-0.10136444866657257,
0.08491490036249161,
-0.42467284202575684,
0.5817907452583313,
-0.34210559725761414,
0.11170151084661484,
-0.42852482199668884,
0.2580617666244507,
0.3142990469932556,
0.4714505076408386,
-0.10002167522907257,
0.6111221313476562,
0.5668156147003174,
-0.5137895941734314,
-0.211965873837471,
0.0602247528731823,
0.010631910525262356,
0.7552306056022644,
-0.5211544632911682,
0.043651778250932693,
-0.4468041956424713,
0.19341015815734863,
-1.047610878944397,
0.3493955135345459,
0.4854527711868286,
-0.2806943356990814,
0.28314322233200073,
-0.43180540204048157,
-0.009050638414919376,
-0.024929290637373924,
-0.5603969097137451,
0.4248242974281311,
0.5663543343544006,
-0.23691552877426147,
1.1827868223190308,
0.36484766006469727,
-0.48623552918434143,
-0.40993958711624146,
-0.20566034317016602,
0.12523336708545685,
-0.10573029518127441,
-0.28084856271743774,
0.1961481124162674,
0.022630808874964714,
-0.3590105473995209,
0.1626114547252655,
-0.12073730677366257,
-0.2591525614261627,
0.11394783854484558,
0.3687516450881958,
-0.12444384396076202,
0.0383998304605484,
0.028732655569911003,
0.5702800750732422,
-0.0013073172885924578,
0.3921547830104828,
-0.050675999373197556,
0.6108821630477905,
0.11077278852462769,
-0.014478755183517933,
-0.5573562979698181,
0.2620156407356262,
0.5731682181358337,
-0.30014532804489136,
0.6154100298881531,
0.4743212163448334,
-0.14733918011188507,
-0.19219517707824707,
-0.39350202679634094,
-0.009068324230611324,
-0.41545432806015015,
0.38853442668914795,
-0.087039515376091,
-0.46346315741539,
0.8181169033050537,
-0.08662230521440506,
0.1895480901002884,
0.3561055660247803,
0.3049120008945465,
-0.11486983299255371,
0.8114608526229858,
0.9836763739585876,
-0.3015541732311249,
0.9240951538085938,
-0.45382484793663025,
0.39015993475914,
-1.3500972986221313,
-0.30755579471588135,
-0.35555097460746765,
-0.16704846918582916,
-0.023212434723973274,
-0.37712806463241577,
0.33941611647605896,
0.30236637592315674,
0.11763755977153778,
0.03892505168914795,
-0.2030491679906845,
0.34210094809532166,
0.21814553439617157,
0.3851131498813629,
0.22191841900348663,
0.030672607943415642,
0.29385483264923096,
0.033296965062618256,
-0.2610006332397461,
-0.36046087741851807,
0.8310894966125488,
0.6404945254325867,
0.6556380391120911,
0.06447578966617584,
0.9035006761550903,
0.5363506078720093,
0.7207326889038086,
-0.9709303379058838,
0.6204061508178711,
-0.3632812201976776,
-0.09417724609375,
-0.11377334594726562,
-0.40521150827407837,
-0.7204693555831909,
0.29175832867622375,
0.18757954239845276,
-0.47102850675582886,
0.25923866033554077,
-0.03695176914334297,
-0.4169037938117981,
0.2512187063694,
-0.469448059797287,
0.5381984710693359,
0.3187035024166107,
-0.3148494362831116,
-0.46692901849746704,
-0.4146747887134552,
0.18107739090919495,
-0.07487884163856506,
0.49252334237098694,
-0.24415814876556396,
-0.128151997923851,
0.8979520201683044,
-0.412144273519516,
1.3364887237548828,
-0.3859713673591614,
-0.331867516040802,
0.4227328300476074,
0.27118995785713196,
0.03983520343899727,
0.18450240790843964,
0.04298277571797371,
0.44761574268341064,
-0.22618834674358368,
-0.2931462824344635,
-0.7425097823143005,
0.6615009307861328,
-0.5199005007743835,
-0.5263417959213257,
-0.31115415692329407,
-0.2548844516277313,
-0.08246994763612747,
0.08709331601858139,
-0.06419883668422699,
0.5013663172721863,
-0.2884937822818756,
-0.2781742215156555,
0.7154057025909424,
0.1780659258365631,
0.7114367485046387,
0.5542358756065369,
-0.44305145740509033,
-0.4631395637989044,
0.8501147031784058,
0.013186781667172909,
-0.035459015518426895,
0.32319167256355286,
0.13298484683036804,
-0.3315156102180481,
-0.7074202299118042,
-0.46514567732810974,
0.4126160740852356,
-0.5689835548400879,
-0.27650684118270874,
-0.8132316470146179,
-0.1060088723897934,
-0.30926117300987244,
-0.03717351332306862,
-0.5543808937072754,
-0.259189635515213,
-0.6246619820594788,
-0.021424513310194016,
0.37921005487442017,
0.9820295572280884,
0.060182299464941025,
0.4429311156272888,
-0.840391218662262,
0.18483226001262665,
-0.04133681207895279,
0.4161072373390198,
0.3128621578216553,
-0.8222843408584595,
-0.18985924124717712,
-0.1038626879453659,
-0.4155290722846985,
-0.9019729495048523,
0.5653030276298523,
0.07591426372528076,
0.23783233761787415,
0.4035584330558777,
-0.12805113196372986,
0.4142184555530548,
-0.437717080116272,
1.0525736808776855,
0.13022646307945251,
-1.049981713294983,
0.5763654708862305,
0.09883764386177063,
0.26846587657928467,
0.31948480010032654,
0.45547914505004883,
-0.6023718118667603,
-0.7442273497581482,
-0.44986072182655334,
-1.1192567348480225,
0.20685820281505585,
0.23315581679344177,
0.42923182249069214,
-0.08424262702465057,
0.621604859828949,
0.3012509047985077,
0.230074942111969,
-0.6946507096290588,
-0.17652791738510132,
-0.24009309709072113,
-0.5145947933197021,
0.00896013155579567,
-0.3264661729335785,
-0.09506560862064362,
-0.14778850972652435,
0.7737419605255127,
0.02114807814359665,
0.04992998391389847,
0.26933133602142334,
-0.10328766703605652,
0.14350631833076477,
0.4635181725025177,
0.27318519353866577,
0.5028043389320374,
0.06741515547037125,
-0.022829055786132812,
-0.1553262621164322,
-0.4912606477737427,
0.10298934578895569,
0.15085649490356445,
-0.5155453085899353,
0.046209465712308884,
0.2227427363395691,
0.5359293222427368,
-0.17839917540550232,
-0.20974573493003845,
0.5260521769523621,
-0.061089400202035904,
0.14538484811782837,
-0.2744912803173065,
-0.19529296457767487,
0.07539477199316025,
0.4782182276248932,
0.21854755282402039,
0.17788027226924896,
0.29376882314682007,
-0.39856332540512085,
0.15859268605709076,
0.43350252509117126,
-0.6668599843978882,
-0.6839583516120911,
0.37334001064300537,
0.512279212474823,
-0.1815924048423767,
0.3465670049190521,
-0.45114946365356445,
-0.6400324106216431,
0.5765590071678162,
-0.07437998056411743,
1.1716372966766357,
-0.0856381356716156,
0.635959804058075,
0.17116475105285645,
0.13384337723255157,
-0.07149820774793625,
0.3730703890323639,
-0.007739946246147156,
-0.5824180245399475,
-0.4600180387496948,
-0.9386119246482849,
-0.2578756511211395,
-0.24280565977096558,
-0.7474565505981445,
-0.1760653257369995,
-0.6901488900184631,
-0.4027186930179596,
0.0565040297806263,
-0.3265500068664551,
-0.3613303601741791,
0.09930063039064407,
-0.009146064519882202,
0.7056933045387268,
-1.1912662982940674,
0.4833366572856903,
0.6308218836784363,
-0.6493172645568848,
-0.21484220027923584,
0.3162105977535248,
-0.2411862462759018,
-0.19861726462841034,
0.3086966276168823,
0.19270867109298706,
-0.21228767931461334,
-0.29585161805152893,
-0.4781915843486786,
-0.44481542706489563,
0.7210713028907776,
-0.23755908012390137,
-0.5007252097129822,
0.3187468945980072,
-0.24229763448238373,
0.8205932378768921,
-0.33771491050720215,
0.1363256871700287,
0.5252244472503662,
0.023567382246255875,
-0.3611237704753876,
-0.44966474175453186,
0.016513604670763016,
-0.09735248237848282,
0.05436175316572189,
0.46135571599006653,
-0.7488928437232971,
0.8680660724639893,
-0.06613278388977051,
-0.09243867546319962,
0.22150883078575134,
1.0866371393203735,
-0.3598552346229553,
0.6752353310585022,
0.7186099290847778,
0.7117030620574951,
0.45153310894966125,
-0.10307860374450684,
0.7668078541755676,
-0.1267722100019455,
0.29544520378112793,
0.9782768487930298,
-0.28994277119636536,
0.9743934273719788,
0.5614064931869507,
-0.22445957362651825,
1.2252143621444702,
0.49095818400382996,
0.4950791895389557,
0.5711595416069031,
-0.17806383967399597,
-0.3875080347061157,
-0.2873612642288208,
-0.25512808561325073,
-0.12654301524162292,
-0.02970786951482296,
0.44954344630241394,
-0.4463427662849426,
-0.2602348029613495,
0.2660005986690521,
0.10470615327358246,
0.09583808481693268,
-0.5315198302268982,
0.9998198747634888,
0.221637561917305,
-0.5006590485572815,
-0.13368657231330872,
-0.06849261373281479,
0.749195396900177,
-0.548877477645874,
-0.0776815265417099,
-0.8821591734886169,
-0.013709159567952156,
-0.18657250702381134,
-1.174390435218811,
0.5089799761772156,
-0.0922016054391861,
-0.5076782703399658,
-0.0757434144616127,
0.3110368549823761,
-0.4823024868965149,
-0.6282618045806885,
0.3177974224090576,
0.34962138533592224,
-0.029448723420500755,
-0.36313796043395996,
-0.7373010516166687,
-0.019205769523978233,
0.010602172464132309,
-0.46229374408721924,
0.2930111587047577,
0.5289280414581299,
-0.13809910416603088,
0.6613386273384094,
0.35759133100509644,
0.09838949143886566,
-0.20556862652301788,
0.4184941351413727,
0.8922036290168762,
-0.7311965823173523,
-0.7183687090873718,
-0.8131077289581299,
0.46296218037605286,
-0.16045594215393066,
-0.24777524173259735,
0.48780006170272827,
0.4140793979167938,
0.5285601019859314,
0.19896067678928375,
0.6423665285110474,
-0.07134698331356049,
0.5661008358001709,
-0.6978362202644348,
0.6728099584579468,
-0.6672447919845581,
0.6052093505859375,
-0.09589085727930069,
-0.8859671354293823,
-0.282959908246994,
0.3189062476158142,
-0.3003797233104706,
0.11734797805547714,
0.5795763731002808,
0.8349640965461731,
-0.05451931804418564,
-0.1017230823636055,
-0.051944222301244736,
0.3890892565250397,
0.5116153359413147,
0.2031891644001007,
0.7113782167434692,
-0.2475731372833252,
0.273262619972229,
-0.7023645639419556,
-0.3845735490322113,
0.04674236476421356,
-0.8907091021537781,
-0.7995808720588684,
-0.520926296710968,
-0.7329726815223694,
-0.5143650770187378,
0.026916837319731712,
0.5522612929344177,
0.41909369826316833,
-0.7589405179023743,
0.027020342648029327,
-0.07137846201658249,
0.3867093026638031,
-0.42597198486328125,
-0.33198535442352295,
0.2821228802204132,
-0.4462374150753021,
-0.6605603694915771,
0.0810723751783371,
0.27646419405937195,
0.041455503553152084,
-0.6601871848106384,
0.22107776999473572,
-0.01124007347971201,
0.35564714670181274,
0.8613190650939941,
0.1903766244649887,
-0.6698722243309021,
-0.27505871653556824,
-0.32382872700691223,
0.05018274113535881,
0.16516593098640442,
0.897060751914978,
-0.7296972274780273,
0.3963751792907715,
0.5880629420280457,
0.3834184408187866,
0.15171630680561066,
0.18007679283618927,
0.3914128839969635,
-1.023806095123291,
0.05355573818087578,
0.30905941128730774,
0.44274353981018066,
0.5616909861564636,
-0.25353941321372986,
0.3575870990753174,
0.2860144376754761,
-0.24945883452892303,
-0.5663058757781982,
0.24748873710632324,
-1.1786116361618042,
-0.5077342391014099,
1.065934419631958,
-0.17624087631702423,
-0.4909500479698181,
-0.3703595697879791,
-0.2742707431316376,
0.055894721299409866,
-0.776381254196167,
0.9268293976783752,
0.5845370888710022,
-0.22836266458034515,
-0.16387195885181427,
-0.03876710683107376,
0.37667179107666016,
0.6237495541572571,
-0.6391309499740601,
0.3768733739852905,
0.6183969974517822,
0.5132419466972351,
0.3393096327781677,
0.7778120636940002,
-0.14241580665111542,
0.008385072462260723,
-0.1584802269935608,
0.13155455887317657,
0.03795076906681061,
-0.5674208402633667,
-0.764378011226654,
0.3120027482509613,
0.06807047128677368,
-0.10332868248224258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15268v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15268v1
|
MemoryPrompt: A Light Wrapper to Improve Context Tracking in Pre-trained Language Models
| 2024-02-23T11:30:39 | 2024-02-23T11:30:39 |
Nathanaël Carraz Rakotonirina, Marco Baroni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Transformer-based language models (LMs) track contextual information through
large, hard-coded input windows. We introduce MemoryPrompt, a leaner approach
in which the LM is complemented by a small auxiliary recurrent network that
passes information to the LM by prefixing its regular input with a sequence of
vectors, akin to soft prompts, without requiring LM finetuning. Tested on a
task designed to probe a LM's ability to keep track of multiple fact updates, a
MemoryPrompt-augmented LM outperforms much larger LMs that have access to the
full input history. We also test MemoryPrompt on a long-distance dialogue
dataset, where its performance is comparable to that of a model conditioned on
the entire conversation history. In both experiments we also observe that,
unlike full-finetuning approaches, MemoryPrompt does not suffer from
catastrophic forgetting when adapted to new tasks, thus not disrupting the
generalist capabilities of the underlying LM.
|
[
-0.4821164309978485,
-0.7804256677627563,
0.697235107421875,
-0.02333318628370762,
-0.26014941930770874,
-0.5336635112762451,
-0.5012211799621582,
-0.15949197113513947,
0.3561718761920929,
0.4970974028110504,
-0.6831046342849731,
-0.3972775340080261,
-0.39909812808036804,
-0.36912277340888977,
-0.5697640180587769,
1.1558399200439453,
-0.03543826937675476,
-0.07622013986110687,
-0.06632649153470993,
-0.4862472116947174,
-0.7088519930839539,
-0.5940681099891663,
-0.5981536507606506,
-0.24411995708942413,
0.800014317035675,
0.36382541060447693,
0.7795557379722595,
0.26341211795806885,
0.33676454424858093,
0.1480303555727005,
0.03984958678483963,
-0.07259553670883179,
-0.4085421562194824,
0.37550050020217896,
-0.2815377414226532,
-0.42226216197013855,
-0.44478797912597656,
-0.06520188599824905,
0.4435112178325653,
0.7850408554077148,
-0.4264566898345947,
0.19446977972984314,
0.19901371002197266,
0.38033750653266907,
-0.8670769929885864,
-0.0018966650823131204,
-0.5506611466407776,
-0.22664113342761993,
-0.0929151177406311,
-0.3859616219997406,
-0.5881252884864807,
0.048178646713495255,
0.14077425003051758,
-0.2458985149860382,
0.34297674894332886,
0.022393299266695976,
0.6551156044006348,
0.3050130307674408,
-0.03305583819746971,
-0.17899982631206512,
-0.7823652029037476,
0.7626417875289917,
-0.5733757615089417,
0.6006200909614563,
0.5055150389671326,
0.3324141204357147,
-0.134859099984169,
-0.8667824864387512,
-0.5079032182693481,
-0.4092831611633301,
-0.19084127247333527,
0.07729697227478027,
-0.10176775604486465,
-0.029472531750798225,
0.2890078127384186,
0.10367955267429352,
-0.43104952573776245,
-0.21140579879283905,
-0.13400468230247498,
-0.3135438561439514,
0.0399208702147007,
0.07756178081035614,
0.22209955751895905,
0.30873629450798035,
-0.28391262888908386,
-0.0027119715232402086,
-0.7845665812492371,
-0.010813562199473381,
-0.19370333850383759,
0.17064404487609863,
0.1312628537416458,
0.09138686209917068,
-0.030623195692896843,
1.0844825506210327,
0.019800638779997826,
-0.17821915447711945,
-0.024181265383958817,
-0.1769624799489975,
-0.20008696615695953,
0.13099674880504608,
0.7182673811912537,
0.3516508638858795,
0.32150131464004517,
-0.3494040369987488,
-0.22525732219219208,
0.018481524661183357,
0.24644990265369415,
-0.9467101693153381,
-0.43778195977211,
0.0364982895553112,
-0.1464235484600067,
0.32739952206611633,
-0.06475617736577988,
-0.40649113059043884,
-0.008068724535405636,
-0.31678229570388794,
0.4657214283943176,
-0.7312947511672974,
-0.16167782247066498,
0.06457106024026871,
0.15409323573112488,
0.07119043916463852,
0.6126545667648315,
-1.0151032209396362,
0.3633539378643036,
0.7229943871498108,
0.9827666878700256,
-0.3712730407714844,
-0.3131236732006073,
-0.7398318648338318,
0.13301371037960052,
-0.18908944725990295,
0.7771082520484924,
-0.5609663724899292,
-0.037467390298843384,
-0.15555095672607422,
0.06321533769369125,
-0.18105557560920715,
-0.6717434525489807,
0.3900039792060852,
-0.4856198728084564,
0.4792823791503906,
-0.06587395071983337,
-0.6020269393920898,
0.060642924159765244,
0.3246757686138153,
-0.8245505094528198,
0.9980977177619934,
0.19558288156986237,
-0.7628496289253235,
0.3464915454387665,
-0.3243162930011749,
-0.3802632987499237,
-0.05795305222272873,
-0.3220323920249939,
-0.18820832669734955,
0.2869022488594055,
0.017945243045687675,
0.5512856245040894,
0.0318518690764904,
0.6475691199302673,
-0.135900616645813,
-0.6599808931350708,
0.21304874122142792,
-0.5462859869003296,
0.34250131249427795,
0.12470121681690216,
-0.22920426726341248,
0.18532133102416992,
-0.599904477596283,
-0.19825223088264465,
-0.1632090061903,
-0.35480403900146484,
-0.5704938173294067,
0.08755849301815033,
0.0004462908545974642,
0.11867865175008774,
0.12746845185756683,
-0.40107759833335876,
0.42521753907203674,
-0.1696939617395401,
0.31891530752182007,
0.48183825612068176,
-0.0635053738951683,
0.4608592689037323,
-0.18335877358913422,
0.416733056306839,
0.26063892245292664,
0.1877451390028,
-0.7732008099555969,
-0.38203978538513184,
-0.9858670234680176,
-0.21460579335689545,
0.20446468889713287,
0.5788230299949646,
-0.7750888466835022,
0.3305296003818512,
-0.2778875529766083,
-0.05041133612394333,
-0.2367970496416092,
0.11531165987253189,
0.20144005119800568,
0.6965108513832092,
0.5265831351280212,
-0.3175329267978668,
-0.4577944874763489,
-0.7462719678878784,
-0.3270173668861389,
0.09305549412965775,
-0.3133116066455841,
0.09095596522092819,
0.31995806097984314,
-0.2659747004508972,
1.1145212650299072,
-0.46875646710395813,
-0.2321307361125946,
-0.23037628829479218,
0.04975537210702896,
0.31163281202316284,
0.5498967170715332,
0.47182899713516235,
-0.5814107060432434,
-0.035433895885944366,
-0.4999794661998749,
-0.2285560667514801,
-0.10261143743991852,
-0.15202458202838898,
0.05755024775862694,
0.2692278325557709,
0.70831698179245,
-0.9975042939186096,
0.32393020391464233,
0.5130338072776794,
-0.6701765060424805,
0.414034366607666,
-0.04555962607264519,
0.04305079206824303,
-1.0932406187057495,
0.22627262771129608,
-0.17081187665462494,
-0.5287237763404846,
-0.8096107840538025,
-0.21967732906341553,
0.1363999992609024,
-0.06785794347524643,
-0.7030269503593445,
0.7357637286186218,
-0.22777119278907776,
0.10624817758798599,
-0.4395587742328644,
-0.006798191927373409,
-0.03144142031669617,
0.5638174414634705,
0.28445008397102356,
0.8861583471298218,
0.5083333849906921,
-0.8157516121864319,
0.19686348736286163,
-0.259827584028244,
-0.3984813690185547,
0.5410760045051575,
-0.2185816615819931,
0.3065722584724426,
-0.20485173165798187,
0.39312249422073364,
-0.9568096399307251,
0.07771597057580948,
0.08923057466745377,
-0.29665279388427734,
0.4494708478450775,
-0.014235017821192741,
-0.3439875543117523,
-0.003515221644192934,
-0.17246189713478088,
0.41632843017578125,
0.5931736826896667,
-0.5135694742202759,
0.7249660491943359,
-0.13762830197811127,
-0.09229691326618195,
-0.5043595433235168,
-0.6421933770179749,
0.27605122327804565,
-0.3621465563774109,
-0.21156558394432068,
0.4072096645832062,
-0.05029895156621933,
-0.10555959492921829,
-0.02359429933130741,
-0.27800366282463074,
-0.3223240077495575,
0.1013333648443222,
0.07730097323656082,
0.22767555713653564,
-0.4412262737751007,
0.22879113256931305,
-0.3741745948791504,
-0.3260517418384552,
-0.005437162704765797,
-0.4721406400203705,
0.7044590711593628,
-0.08212556689977646,
-0.23480364680290222,
-0.33406609296798706,
0.21946807205677032,
0.44140857458114624,
0.1472146213054657,
0.8722920417785645,
0.727012038230896,
-0.33176711201667786,
-0.3713608384132385,
-0.7489215135574341,
-0.5647326707839966,
-0.4562930464744568,
0.2329651415348053,
-0.40672779083251953,
-1.1560862064361572,
0.478711873292923,
-0.17333082854747772,
0.0021105410996824503,
0.13342629373073578,
0.3839605152606964,
-0.25024598836898804,
0.8179646134376526,
0.7703270316123962,
-0.24628421664237976,
0.7526326179504395,
0.1306750476360321,
0.1729186624288559,
-0.791102409362793,
-0.03022034466266632,
-0.12995143234729767,
-0.3285297751426697,
-0.005394920706748962,
-0.562699019908905,
0.1422053426504135,
0.3732607662677765,
-0.148749440908432,
0.46148785948753357,
-0.2479589879512787,
0.47727054357528687,
0.5480956435203552,
0.01306034717708826,
0.31467875838279724,
-0.20856773853302002,
0.02787972427904606,
-0.19282841682434082,
-1.0520026683807373,
-0.16159488260746002,
0.744848906993866,
0.14415061473846436,
0.9509214758872986,
-0.08189869672060013,
0.4991285800933838,
0.09651152789592743,
0.6332038044929504,
-0.9246106147766113,
0.5250304341316223,
-0.05117693170905113,
-0.34437450766563416,
-0.040836263447999954,
-0.41794919967651367,
-0.7130073308944702,
0.05098801106214523,
0.26572921872138977,
-1.0066429376602173,
-0.06256774812936783,
0.7159757018089294,
-0.6149061322212219,
0.1899494081735611,
-0.572832465171814,
0.8575657606124878,
-0.28649500012397766,
-0.6088858246803284,
0.015924563631415367,
-0.3520691394805908,
0.45424240827560425,
0.05565432831645012,
0.007198795210570097,
0.002601705491542816,
0.018073225393891335,
0.8692204356193542,
-0.4526786804199219,
0.8939899802207947,
-0.27862998843193054,
-0.11627966910600662,
0.3417239785194397,
0.39758047461509705,
0.5223381519317627,
-0.10876546055078506,
0.3851260840892792,
-0.05278673395514488,
-0.01422905083745718,
-0.24309203028678894,
-0.9769400358200073,
0.8391133546829224,
-0.16322915256023407,
-0.5474069714546204,
-0.0500907376408577,
-0.7176604270935059,
-0.2829879820346832,
0.09155917912721634,
0.43606430292129517,
0.6089836955070496,
-0.08229319751262665,
0.3382677733898163,
1.0788670778274536,
-0.2217879444360733,
0.5246720910072327,
0.7106958627700806,
-0.3747338652610779,
-0.059771083295345306,
0.7569354772567749,
0.11493564397096634,
0.24357281625270844,
0.3433857560157776,
0.21845456957817078,
-0.2077936828136444,
-0.284871906042099,
-0.3438378870487213,
-0.12235261499881744,
-0.8226669430732727,
-0.2338697612285614,
-0.63221275806427,
-0.13116441667079926,
-0.11183343827724457,
-0.1378200501203537,
-0.6676043272018433,
-0.39531296491622925,
-0.11267691105604172,
0.07742749154567719,
0.5605775117874146,
0.3041779100894928,
0.3707154393196106,
0.4983484447002411,
-0.5524824261665344,
0.44250792264938354,
0.2102920562028885,
0.5438574552536011,
-0.23847238719463348,
-0.6643718481063843,
-0.3177151679992676,
-0.2864442765712738,
0.014527589082717896,
-0.7667909860610962,
0.14203187823295593,
0.26751333475112915,
0.3899238109588623,
0.5027679204940796,
-0.05269550159573555,
0.7690333724021912,
-0.6755204200744629,
0.7724822759628296,
0.3977961838245392,
-0.7809736132621765,
0.6668316125869751,
-0.18877474963665009,
0.8540560603141785,
0.7951382398605347,
0.2915889322757721,
-0.6277918219566345,
-0.43790388107299805,
-0.5867272019386292,
-0.7605506777763367,
0.5404472947120667,
-0.14899753034114838,
0.21050269901752472,
-0.02539035864174366,
0.5269900560379028,
-0.14044764637947083,
0.01179012842476368,
-0.6336191892623901,
-0.21917687356472015,
-0.2725832164287567,
-0.5092471241950989,
-0.10140485316514969,
-0.4631936848163605,
-0.036614395678043365,
-0.5086327195167542,
0.2137455940246582,
-0.180240660905838,
0.20856067538261414,
0.3546888828277588,
-0.36656805872917175,
0.2775675058364868,
0.4121672213077545,
0.8355674743652344,
0.8771337866783142,
-0.28980371356010437,
0.6426122784614563,
0.45510706305503845,
-0.6124970316886902,
0.13442210853099823,
-0.24090008437633514,
-0.37979480624198914,
0.2977761924266815,
0.6462964415550232,
1.0243220329284668,
0.6488050222396851,
-0.7075962424278259,
0.6142680048942566,
-0.10907061398029327,
-0.13337382674217224,
-0.4144539535045624,
0.44036629796028137,
0.18087269365787506,
-0.06479636579751968,
0.3103339970111847,
0.0705602690577507,
0.13322009146213531,
-0.6982592344284058,
0.5807217955589294,
0.2738071382045746,
-0.8410606384277344,
-0.5259546637535095,
0.6506667733192444,
-0.11034727841615677,
-0.46345439553260803,
0.47028741240501404,
0.047276854515075684,
-0.5028545260429382,
0.17354349792003632,
0.7817345857620239,
0.737861692905426,
-0.6234246492385864,
-0.21766163408756256,
0.3120586574077606,
0.18761558830738068,
-0.457989364862442,
0.07766201347112656,
-0.4068136215209961,
-0.7618592381477356,
-0.6688929796218872,
-0.5237925052642822,
-0.28145548701286316,
0.5482339859008789,
-0.774490237236023,
0.22244615852832794,
-0.38972118496894836,
-0.23012541234493256,
-0.4218687117099762,
-0.4334396719932556,
-0.7977699041366577,
0.15577664971351624,
0.34800854325294495,
1.2766640186309814,
-0.8415771126747131,
1.3503940105438232,
0.4259345233440399,
-0.0841103345155716,
-0.6134213805198669,
0.12601880729198456,
-0.14640220999717712,
-0.5441919565200806,
0.5715479254722595,
0.4766532778739929,
-0.44072774052619934,
-0.0038352166302502155,
-0.4548359811306,
-0.9759398102760315,
0.9249114990234375,
0.546909749507904,
-0.7921849489212036,
0.06291647255420685,
-0.18016299605369568,
0.40159136056900024,
-0.36374714970588684,
0.31523165106773376,
1.0896766185760498,
0.36390194296836853,
0.15489225089550018,
-0.8380884528160095,
0.09078112989664078,
-0.19360581040382385,
-0.3039369583129883,
0.20411905646324158,
-0.41960859298706055,
0.7943101525306702,
-0.07387659698724747,
-0.3234511911869049,
-0.140141099691391,
0.7155387997627258,
0.24257662892341614,
0.22096113860607147,
0.4946029484272003,
0.7184259295463562,
0.46030059456825256,
-0.08740653842687607,
1.0514395236968994,
-0.3824753761291504,
0.18775354325771332,
1.6688215732574463,
-0.29479166865348816,
0.8823531270027161,
0.738643229007721,
0.18761849403381348,
0.5660557150840759,
0.1058632880449295,
0.24641110002994537,
0.6816627383232117,
0.14004619419574738,
-0.28289905190467834,
-0.1702379435300827,
-0.035021692514419556,
-0.16714490950107574,
0.2587771713733673,
0.47115156054496765,
-0.2272166907787323,
-0.25758934020996094,
0.29068523645401,
0.4747200012207031,
-0.0633663460612297,
-0.24312898516654968,
0.7065795660018921,
0.20176073908805847,
-1.0773528814315796,
0.6907265782356262,
-0.16463029384613037,
0.8271971940994263,
-0.8164884448051453,
0.00946064107120037,
-0.5072280764579773,
0.49408307671546936,
-0.026735590770840645,
-0.5855005383491516,
0.4692641794681549,
0.07168032974004745,
-0.14011254906654358,
-0.3770432472229004,
0.7718470692634583,
-0.7530173659324646,
-0.37973421812057495,
0.3826644718647003,
0.40888088941574097,
-0.05098611116409302,
-0.3482101261615753,
-0.5255734324455261,
0.3308199942111969,
-0.3025362491607666,
-0.7734404802322388,
0.3499075472354889,
0.211955264210701,
-0.12445887178182602,
0.7262868285179138,
0.24124248325824738,
0.06102106347680092,
0.0628773644566536,
0.41271355748176575,
0.8735190033912659,
-0.9421586394309998,
-0.40809139609336853,
-1.1945959329605103,
0.20969374477863312,
0.12580689787864685,
-0.35915517807006836,
0.8056512475013733,
0.523473858833313,
0.6258143186569214,
0.07892243564128876,
0.3716229796409607,
0.17008531093597412,
0.40185317397117615,
-0.8159613609313965,
0.5569790005683899,
-0.19214968383312225,
0.20943787693977356,
0.011801154352724552,
-1.0273293256759644,
-0.3833007216453552,
0.5076059699058533,
-0.2727184593677521,
-0.10515929758548737,
0.9585018754005432,
0.8373193740844727,
-0.4906579852104187,
-0.15852148830890656,
0.2920391857624054,
0.06587553769350052,
0.16449125111103058,
0.8967530131340027,
1.0424561500549316,
-0.2052336186170578,
0.3644287884235382,
-0.11472316831350327,
-0.15868982672691345,
-0.14447638392448425,
-0.8687962889671326,
-0.8852075934410095,
-0.6081623435020447,
-0.2860541045665741,
-0.10410775244235992,
-0.12610849738121033,
0.627636730670929,
1.025922179222107,
-0.9673492312431335,
-0.10731270164251328,
-0.16656208038330078,
-0.1890588104724884,
-0.20338542759418488,
-0.2613500952720642,
0.3906629979610443,
-0.4759567677974701,
-0.34714454412460327,
0.6059818863868713,
0.2723274827003479,
-0.09913458675146103,
-0.33227047324180603,
-0.08889790624380112,
-0.015786470845341682,
0.03631686419248581,
0.6323508024215698,
0.12479367107152939,
-0.666089653968811,
-0.4874618947505951,
-0.18740376830101013,
0.026509463787078857,
0.10188966989517212,
1.229040503501892,
-1.1364774703979492,
0.18651410937309265,
0.35119062662124634,
0.5306104421615601,
0.6197368502616882,
0.07403011620044708,
0.5423411726951599,
-0.8332152366638184,
0.6653643250465393,
0.2588556110858917,
0.5147532820701599,
0.3578264117240906,
-0.2956319749355316,
0.17336057126522064,
0.10117803514003754,
-0.27457818388938904,
-0.6412062644958496,
0.37747722864151,
-0.8361311554908752,
-0.6160628199577332,
0.8905596137046814,
-0.20481424033641815,
-0.36777469515800476,
-0.17371340095996857,
-0.06435219943523407,
-0.009915193542838097,
-0.11815260350704193,
0.5679364800453186,
0.6795530915260315,
-0.2498127967119217,
-0.6040763258934021,
-0.9491547346115112,
0.7325105667114258,
0.7092892527580261,
-0.535916805267334,
0.16888229548931122,
0.5242436528205872,
0.39747461676597595,
0.1441987007856369,
1.0163606405258179,
0.2332480400800705,
0.24120865762233734,
-0.18780633807182312,
0.031885258853435516,
-0.13927312195301056,
-0.837253987789154,
-0.33221912384033203,
0.23995552957057953,
-0.06327088177204132,
-0.05725352093577385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15265v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15265v1
|
CloChat: Understanding How People Customize, Interact, and Experience Personas in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T11:25:17 | 2024-02-23T11:25:17 |
Juhye Ha, Hyeon Jeon, DaEun Han, Jinwook Seo, Changhoon Oh
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have facilitated significant strides in
generating conversational agents, enabling seamless, contextually relevant
dialogues across diverse topics. However, the existing LLM-driven
conversational agents have fixed personalities and functionalities, limiting
their adaptability to individual user needs. Creating personalized agent
personas with distinct expertise or traits can address this issue. Nonetheless,
we lack knowledge of how people customize and interact with agent personas. In
this research, we investigated how users customize agent personas and their
impact on interaction quality, diversity, and dynamics. To this end, we
developed CloChat, an interface supporting easy and accurate customization of
agent personas in LLMs. We conducted a study comparing how participants
interact with CloChat and ChatGPT. The results indicate that participants
formed emotional bonds with the customized agents, engaged in more dynamic
dialogues, and showed interest in sustaining interactions. These findings
contribute to design implications for future systems with conversational agents
using LLMs.
|
[
-0.5801175236701965,
-0.5787450671195984,
0.8067944049835205,
0.16772574186325073,
-0.10663953423500061,
0.5448427796363831,
-0.36910754442214966,
-0.6889883875846863,
0.4232381284236908,
0.5875955820083618,
-0.5988025069236755,
-0.5541936159133911,
-0.3487035930156708,
-0.12611983716487885,
0.046717189252376556,
0.9381839036941528,
0.18874071538448334,
-0.16800867021083832,
-0.09690408408641815,
-0.20879808068275452,
-0.5874431729316711,
-0.5832523107528687,
-0.5769076943397522,
-0.4334459602832794,
0.5360351800918579,
0.48425784707069397,
0.9729055762290955,
0.16869737207889557,
0.39092370867729187,
0.4201671779155731,
0.04595433175563812,
0.03948554769158363,
-0.6985701322555542,
0.6656714677810669,
-0.38163965940475464,
-0.3553776144981384,
-0.4702221751213074,
-0.05870326608419418,
0.33690693974494934,
0.5510278344154358,
-0.24793016910552979,
0.012103215791285038,
0.017126722261309624,
0.4856104850769043,
-0.26110783219337463,
0.45555397868156433,
-0.4430807828903198,
-0.1154898852109909,
-0.16139133274555206,
-0.3002244830131531,
-0.3092074990272522,
-0.37947437167167664,
0.5390833616256714,
-0.5283222198486328,
-0.11697655916213989,
-0.1265203207731247,
0.4783589541912079,
0.2138196974992752,
-0.6935970783233643,
-0.5669540762901306,
-0.8393412232398987,
0.6200687885284424,
-0.7732624411582947,
0.21425555646419525,
0.10698220878839493,
0.6214702725410461,
-0.582009494304657,
-0.5821495056152344,
-0.3072304129600525,
-0.4858860373497009,
-0.36189115047454834,
-0.026364970952272415,
0.032481513917446136,
0.20197609066963196,
0.0815008208155632,
0.28047987818717957,
-0.503603458404541,
0.07961418479681015,
-0.04969789460301399,
-0.061715468764305115,
0.6305657625198364,
0.5140641331672668,
0.6002271771430969,
0.20987629890441895,
-0.056506987661123276,
-0.026858173310756683,
-0.34136468172073364,
0.28210142254829407,
0.49170199036598206,
0.17604146897792816,
-0.1446685791015625,
0.43657776713371277,
-0.20893336832523346,
0.44117316603660583,
0.3563123345375061,
-0.27634504437446594,
0.2483980506658554,
0.17177654802799225,
-0.06321095675230026,
-0.046649906784296036,
0.5882402658462524,
0.34033629298210144,
0.596079409122467,
-0.14349760115146637,
0.04881766438484192,
-0.31134164333343506,
0.10276670753955841,
-0.8659549355506897,
-0.16345323622226715,
0.41977229714393616,
-0.3380061984062195,
-0.18309351801872253,
0.024569276720285416,
-0.7116578817367554,
-0.817642331123352,
-0.4334407150745392,
0.03611491248011589,
-0.34791848063468933,
-0.18787766993045807,
0.06912446022033691,
-0.2128065824508667,
0.21281206607818604,
0.7472445368766785,
-0.8162333965301514,
0.3542650043964386,
0.5953589677810669,
0.6236180067062378,
-0.19319388270378113,
-0.38980674743652344,
-0.5175257921218872,
0.3303179144859314,
0.004133712034672499,
0.6929936408996582,
-0.9197216033935547,
-0.3297228217124939,
0.059835150837898254,
-0.037066180258989334,
-0.014181282371282578,
-0.42131438851356506,
0.024654926732182503,
-0.5460162162780762,
0.008305133320391178,
-0.4901620149612427,
-0.5026546120643616,
-0.12839016318321228,
0.35645294189453125,
-0.46275636553764343,
0.3008922338485718,
0.28548941016197205,
-0.5812733769416809,
0.18137578666210175,
-0.7500933408737183,
-0.43222662806510925,
0.5040065050125122,
-0.1557142585515976,
0.18973839282989502,
0.11372535675764084,
-0.11113034933805466,
0.4213329255580902,
-0.11857385188341141,
0.006132551934570074,
-0.481296181678772,
-0.2968088388442993,
0.721976101398468,
0.2640599012374878,
0.35343682765960693,
0.25445491075515747,
-0.28004157543182373,
0.24867896735668182,
-0.6532319784164429,
-0.011999611742794514,
-0.029825711622834206,
-0.4057028591632843,
-0.1846494972705841,
0.17248035967350006,
0.0989021584391594,
0.22558432817459106,
0.47266462445259094,
-0.37378817796707153,
0.2960831820964813,
-0.4705347418785095,
0.6177708506584167,
0.8549113869667053,
0.09466002881526947,
0.4499199092388153,
-0.3833634853363037,
0.6316846013069153,
-0.04861839488148689,
-0.0038651784416288137,
-0.24921567738056183,
-0.3723618984222412,
-0.7052786946296692,
-0.5992755889892578,
-0.20831498503684998,
0.39234742522239685,
-0.23670527338981628,
0.17160719633102417,
-0.07541076838970184,
-0.6608986854553223,
-0.2154972404241562,
0.23399007320404053,
-0.06500684469938278,
0.009202349931001663,
-0.12247420847415924,
-0.5177929401397705,
-0.42330509424209595,
-0.8997010588645935,
-0.2614053189754486,
-0.26549232006073,
-0.09704940021038055,
0.5920963287353516,
0.4849132001399994,
-0.5794798731803894,
1.3934510946273804,
-0.5061066746711731,
-0.05781922861933708,
-0.5392966270446777,
0.04415658861398697,
0.01910860277712345,
0.32219162583351135,
0.6741618514060974,
-0.47474971413612366,
-0.8882458209991455,
0.308729887008667,
-0.45655593276023865,
-0.36714795231819153,
-0.11135515570640564,
-0.1810479313135147,
0.05845165625214577,
0.19385667145252228,
-0.819883406162262,
0.30583593249320984,
0.3828149437904358,
-0.1759302318096161,
0.6036093235015869,
-0.09848669171333313,
0.25275737047195435,
-0.8857412934303284,
0.10574225336313248,
-0.19083784520626068,
-0.47399574518203735,
-0.8546534180641174,
0.07564365118741989,
-0.47075212001800537,
-0.13502372801303864,
-0.4503364861011505,
0.9969637989997864,
-0.32258397340774536,
-0.22775156795978546,
-0.35714074969291687,
0.21678124368190765,
-0.10955601930618286,
0.5285539627075195,
0.17569835484027863,
0.803045928478241,
0.2787957191467285,
-0.40892285108566284,
0.36349669098854065,
0.489451140165329,
-0.3574357032775879,
0.8331632018089294,
-0.9017911553382874,
0.42980799078941345,
-0.0678524449467659,
0.4585721790790558,
-1.004303216934204,
-0.6084926128387451,
0.2969861924648285,
-0.2975119948387146,
-0.07417964190244675,
-0.05119643360376358,
-0.5624668598175049,
-0.005306250415742397,
-0.30823278427124023,
0.18926356732845306,
0.595146119594574,
-0.5096588134765625,
0.8254018425941467,
0.5079679489135742,
-0.38854488730430603,
-0.1544714719057083,
-0.4498731195926666,
0.21847444772720337,
-0.3901406228542328,
-0.9025130271911621,
-0.17493219673633575,
-0.502446174621582,
-0.6163797974586487,
-0.5643175840377808,
0.28476688265800476,
-0.11832698434591293,
0.2047693282365799,
0.4676872193813324,
-0.2726302146911621,
-0.10049310326576233,
0.22105103731155396,
-0.006277549546211958,
0.025980548933148384,
-0.2079484611749649,
0.09834221750497818,
0.9545796513557434,
-0.4852791726589203,
-0.2711651623249054,
-0.6660996079444885,
0.3412781357765198,
0.9357712268829346,
-0.345912903547287,
0.8527752161026001,
0.6291454434394836,
0.021075937896966934,
-0.12817218899726868,
-0.7245620489120483,
-0.22647465765476227,
-0.5493528842926025,
0.19718925654888153,
-0.4917396008968353,
-1.2567722797393799,
1.0022940635681152,
-0.08811468631029129,
0.1709885150194168,
-0.20811744034290314,
0.9405308365821838,
-0.3588395416736603,
1.038677453994751,
0.6601627469062805,
0.03145037963986397,
0.589518666267395,
0.328326553106308,
0.2726713716983795,
-0.8028520941734314,
-0.23296129703521729,
-0.23929432034492493,
-0.48746606707572937,
-0.6689354777336121,
-0.045488957315683365,
0.05866912379860878,
-0.2996031641960144,
-0.5776533484458923,
0.1813361644744873,
-0.20088739693164825,
0.27545565366744995,
0.31176507472991943,
0.06908468157052994,
0.21569158136844635,
-0.22779648005962372,
0.38099679350852966,
-0.17547568678855896,
-0.15101507306098938,
-0.7601990699768066,
0.5115766525268555,
0.5002980828285217,
1.1525381803512573,
0.516608715057373,
0.5270615816116333,
0.4342515468597412,
0.2315879762172699,
-0.709761381149292,
0.7058843374252319,
0.33303511142730713,
-0.3746402859687805,
-0.13280662894248962,
-0.1652194857597351,
-1.1104271411895752,
0.35208913683891296,
-0.03205905854701996,
-1.39181649684906,
0.4032909572124481,
0.19840730726718903,
-0.05419816076755524,
-0.14307668805122375,
-0.5858287811279297,
0.7233234643936157,
-0.14950205385684967,
-0.21469876170158386,
-0.3324780762195587,
-0.7448371052742004,
0.31860342621803284,
-0.049463242292404175,
-0.06753640621900558,
-0.2527814209461212,
-0.05771700665354729,
0.26166823506355286,
-0.6252521276473999,
1.2228219509124756,
0.14355075359344482,
-0.09565799683332443,
0.21097230911254883,
0.48489677906036377,
0.6912828087806702,
0.10257672518491745,
-0.07522531598806381,
-0.1281813681125641,
0.13391409814357758,
-0.3899284303188324,
-0.706268846988678,
0.8037896752357483,
-0.8789681196212769,
-0.9019286036491394,
-0.33854976296424866,
-0.9014356732368469,
-0.3266620635986328,
0.06307128816843033,
-0.29709479212760925,
0.08583404868841171,
-0.5894615054130554,
0.07677288353443146,
0.4567600190639496,
-0.4326496422290802,
0.1851576417684555,
0.8879676461219788,
-0.1477532982826233,
-0.2602303624153137,
0.6225229501724243,
-0.20319534838199615,
0.4729197919368744,
0.15693676471710205,
0.27828919887542725,
-0.0062437294982373714,
-0.0743885487318039,
0.06161963567137718,
0.42343395948410034,
-0.8340262770652771,
0.2855243980884552,
-0.7095321416854858,
0.040512267500162125,
-0.4803125262260437,
-0.5105679631233215,
-0.12268968671560287,
-0.17972630262374878,
-0.289475679397583,
0.048426009714603424,
0.3165261745452881,
0.6885989308357239,
0.15823744237422943,
0.881730318069458,
-0.7752958536148071,
-0.31956928968429565,
0.481690376996994,
0.0742529109120369,
0.18309521675109863,
-0.3509989082813263,
-0.1559523493051529,
-0.10654985159635544,
-0.22742614150047302,
-1.0031440258026123,
0.40905049443244934,
0.2944614291191101,
0.7048237919807434,
0.692399799823761,
-0.03845001012086868,
0.3736179769039154,
-0.24449515342712402,
0.7864384055137634,
-0.11214231699705124,
-1.0243908166885376,
0.4270728826522827,
-0.6669425368309021,
0.3995892405509949,
0.45498722791671753,
-0.00026371245621703565,
-0.8956720232963562,
-0.5320015549659729,
-0.3687616288661957,
-0.46480509638786316,
0.6317246556282043,
0.16496562957763672,
0.32383328676223755,
0.06927453726530075,
0.407584547996521,
0.246755450963974,
0.6890632510185242,
-0.47979259490966797,
0.0263210516422987,
0.02962109073996544,
-0.23929885029792786,
-0.11129583418369293,
-0.39851850271224976,
-0.14324401319026947,
0.03805513307452202,
0.2087985724210739,
-0.14808109402656555,
-0.07365451008081436,
-0.1556629091501236,
-0.2471361607313156,
0.06445512920618057,
0.5008523464202881,
0.790147066116333,
0.7592823505401611,
-0.3820009231567383,
0.1330716609954834,
-0.003958134446293116,
-0.29271194338798523,
0.05009434372186661,
-0.2779763638973236,
0.1885496973991394,
-0.21592704951763153,
0.19879700243473053,
0.8380810618400574,
0.1133890226483345,
-1.1136728525161743,
0.41354259848594666,
-0.13699917495250702,
0.22028674185276031,
-0.3732012212276459,
0.2883272171020508,
0.24108992516994476,
0.6508114337921143,
-0.014286618679761887,
-0.2273321896791458,
0.11385808885097504,
-0.8956286907196045,
-0.05951574444770813,
0.5819700360298157,
-0.30552035570144653,
-0.6132150888442993,
0.35081836581230164,
0.44353577494621277,
-0.563207745552063,
0.44081398844718933,
0.07859565317630768,
-0.5684252977371216,
0.4755001664161682,
0.3916628062725067,
0.8205803632736206,
-0.38391080498695374,
0.4514447748661041,
-0.015535656362771988,
0.19840823113918304,
0.1622697114944458,
-0.16705834865570068,
-0.22845540940761566,
-0.673030436038971,
0.007996708154678345,
-0.4460846185684204,
-0.6904827952384949,
0.04750761389732361,
-0.345879465341568,
0.22268721461296082,
-0.5700455904006958,
-0.3073229193687439,
-0.20276792347431183,
0.03617800772190094,
-0.7747477889060974,
-0.106331467628479,
-0.07113443315029144,
0.6132205128669739,
-0.6002196669578552,
0.6031561493873596,
0.9201460480690002,
-0.37534767389297485,
-0.4176233112812042,
0.01301639899611473,
0.03739391267299652,
-0.754163384437561,
0.7657003998756409,
0.13568252325057983,
-0.22642859816551208,
-0.0774616003036499,
-0.5687223076820374,
-0.7653133273124695,
1.07157564163208,
0.5539401769638062,
-0.3145724833011627,
0.24097420275211334,
0.5517486929893494,
0.8917240500450134,
-0.6018835306167603,
0.4891590476036072,
0.7593839764595032,
0.5832672715187073,
0.24523787200450897,
-0.8524113297462463,
-0.04249502718448639,
-0.23405544459819794,
0.03519601374864578,
-0.01252712495625019,
-1.0667599439620972,
0.6240711808204651,
-0.08473415672779083,
-0.21717889606952667,
0.30890557169914246,
0.5362130999565125,
0.37405654788017273,
0.2412361353635788,
0.45464080572128296,
0.0696401372551918,
0.8252529501914978,
0.16337458789348602,
0.9036864638328552,
-0.34052643179893494,
0.22157588601112366,
1.346303105354309,
-0.7022349834442139,
0.6145683526992798,
0.4803600311279297,
0.04908917471766472,
0.644734799861908,
0.7399966716766357,
0.1267949640750885,
0.32310041785240173,
0.37315648794174194,
-0.40749314427375793,
-0.4478621482849121,
-0.11755868792533875,
-0.15701662003993988,
0.23234769701957703,
0.49483585357666016,
-0.12806490063667297,
-0.08799205720424652,
0.20220927894115448,
0.1008790135383606,
-0.09362906962633133,
0.005034666042774916,
0.6334888935089111,
0.09467004984617233,
-0.42087510228157043,
-0.13978491723537445,
-0.19815213978290558,
0.41708219051361084,
-0.5790138244628906,
0.09907359629869461,
-0.35634610056877136,
0.18660509586334229,
-0.3211120665073395,
-0.8005856275558472,
-0.10030854493379593,
-0.3139452636241913,
-0.08645813912153244,
0.05104180425405502,
0.7976348400115967,
-0.44460299611091614,
-0.04232006147503853,
0.12567481398582458,
0.5990111231803894,
0.5280205607414246,
-0.06871829926967621,
-0.45700421929359436,
0.28341373801231384,
-0.1755705028772354,
-0.498465359210968,
0.5450900793075562,
0.30528897047042847,
-0.060615427792072296,
1.1168303489685059,
0.5015214085578918,
-0.2937624454498291,
-0.16229650378227234,
0.12003374844789505,
0.7549273371696472,
-0.3959006369113922,
-0.4362877905368805,
-0.7307632565498352,
0.5617583990097046,
0.01631486415863037,
-0.1975124329328537,
0.68617182970047,
0.3081507682800293,
0.3287082612514496,
-0.27679818868637085,
0.8391908407211304,
0.011560283601284027,
0.32817062735557556,
-0.09608696401119232,
0.6563249230384827,
-0.47799891233444214,
0.360015869140625,
-0.3264837861061096,
-0.8613857626914978,
0.11975657194852829,
0.4745190441608429,
-0.44037994742393494,
0.25357940793037415,
0.507792055606842,
0.8275309205055237,
-0.04069243744015694,
-0.189579576253891,
0.3649681806564331,
0.38868415355682373,
0.8522597551345825,
0.49871015548706055,
1.137636661529541,
0.2517569959163666,
0.22394131124019623,
0.16313515603542328,
-0.22882601618766785,
-0.504353940486908,
-0.5832092761993408,
-1.316406011581421,
-0.6170696020126343,
-0.2878325283527374,
-0.10710486024618149,
0.07760883867740631,
1.0888242721557617,
0.5511156916618347,
-0.47695016860961914,
-0.5241501331329346,
0.21220645308494568,
0.0193801112473011,
0.16058167815208435,
-0.28115859627723694,
0.08219628036022186,
-0.40224671363830566,
-0.8620665073394775,
0.29424795508384705,
0.5147369503974915,
0.14894770085811615,
-0.39001184701919556,
-0.33110421895980835,
0.2547975778579712,
0.5437610149383545,
0.6772220730781555,
0.48356908559799194,
-0.7213947772979736,
-0.47984248399734497,
-0.0868048369884491,
-0.339558482170105,
0.22130072116851807,
0.9693712592124939,
-0.6899776458740234,
0.3721037805080414,
0.5825651288032532,
0.3804320693016052,
0.4744952321052551,
0.13785654306411743,
0.8579868078231812,
-0.22731630504131317,
0.19833701848983765,
0.0905156210064888,
0.1627490222454071,
0.2891122102737427,
-0.537882387638092,
0.29118725657463074,
-0.09988685697317123,
-0.8296915292739868,
-0.7894564867019653,
0.44767895340919495,
-1.4008564949035645,
-0.0410054549574852,
1.1938979625701904,
-0.2412146031856537,
-0.12329517304897308,
-0.25035983324050903,
-0.6062219142913818,
-0.29416579008102417,
-0.7310710549354553,
0.653031587600708,
0.8286378979682922,
-0.41119521856307983,
-0.391170471906662,
-0.4750414788722992,
0.4154157042503357,
0.1472216546535492,
-1.0026575326919556,
-0.05191613361239433,
0.45600199699401855,
0.591785728931427,
-0.07781163603067398,
0.758075475692749,
0.32923656702041626,
0.17048828303813934,
-0.4779885709285736,
0.1775822639465332,
0.06321931630373001,
0.15352435410022736,
-0.0025838830042630434,
0.19591952860355377,
0.3840576708316803,
0.1587255746126175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15264v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15264v3
|
DEEM: Dynamic Experienced Expert Modeling for Stance Detection
| 2024-02-23T11:24:00 | 2024-04-26T01:06:31 |
Xiaolong Wang, Yile Wang, Sijie Cheng, Peng Li, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent work has made a preliminary attempt to use large language models
(LLMs) to solve the stance detection task, showing promising results. However,
considering that stance detection usually requires detailed background
knowledge, the vanilla reasoning method may neglect the domain knowledge to
make a professional and accurate analysis. Thus, there is still room for
improvement of LLMs reasoning, especially in leveraging the generation
capability of LLMs to simulate specific experts (i.e., multi-agents) to detect
the stance. In this paper, different from existing multi-agent works that
require detailed descriptions and use fixed experts, we propose a Dynamic
Experienced Expert Modeling (DEEM) method which can leverage the generated
experienced experts and let LLMs reason in a semi-parametric way, making the
experts more generalizable and reliable. Experimental results demonstrate that
DEEM consistently achieves the best results on three standard benchmarks,
outperforms methods with self-consistency reasoning, and reduces the bias of
LLMs.
|
[
-0.4274943470954895,
-0.9122374057769775,
0.9593234062194824,
0.0011851376621052623,
-0.1035958006978035,
0.25792059302330017,
-0.22766666114330292,
-0.22217616438865662,
0.3378117084503174,
0.5526795983314514,
-0.5130463242530823,
-0.9347259402275085,
-0.6843450665473938,
-0.04809937626123428,
-0.09552618116140366,
0.6679325103759766,
-0.16503344476222992,
-0.219443216919899,
-0.19903862476348877,
-0.2141234427690506,
-0.31324437260627747,
-0.20193642377853394,
-0.6535226106643677,
-0.18116040527820587,
0.12586961686611176,
0.44071412086486816,
0.677756130695343,
0.4328455626964569,
0.2149084061384201,
0.428309828042984,
-0.2616135776042938,
0.5191808342933655,
-0.16155965626239777,
0.47234153747558594,
-0.18602530658245087,
-0.478727787733078,
-1.0731141567230225,
0.2019074559211731,
0.7282617688179016,
0.4005347788333893,
-0.30567824840545654,
-0.1920313686132431,
-0.4018419682979584,
0.47087565064430237,
-0.35174381732940674,
0.1586315631866455,
-0.7503188848495483,
0.06344332545995712,
-0.16559849679470062,
-0.26869937777519226,
-0.44679418206214905,
-0.1887044459581375,
-0.13107219338417053,
-0.3785274922847748,
0.06376829743385315,
-0.225221186876297,
0.5697793364524841,
0.6010252833366394,
-0.6379284262657166,
0.16303715109825134,
-0.6713864207267761,
0.7886735796928406,
-1.246806025505066,
0.4146261215209961,
0.22120650112628937,
0.2730334401130676,
-0.46543464064598083,
-0.41820043325424194,
-0.7428739070892334,
-0.4425666332244873,
0.44007566571235657,
0.15256217122077942,
0.047372084110975266,
0.037433817982673645,
0.26468586921691895,
0.07346311956644058,
-0.054421316832304,
0.3742656111717224,
0.31132185459136963,
-0.02985098958015442,
0.7288792133331299,
0.31332650780677795,
0.022253090515732765,
-0.16113249957561493,
-0.8009663820266724,
0.2048967480659485,
-0.5763024687767029,
0.15972046554088593,
0.6020943522453308,
0.04127492383122444,
-0.220529705286026,
0.23473361134529114,
-0.38806623220443726,
0.6741247773170471,
0.6003329157829285,
-0.35334810614585876,
0.21929234266281128,
-0.011014934629201889,
0.04891923442482948,
-0.21916557848453522,
0.6427621245384216,
0.4528936743736267,
0.1429121047258377,
-0.01971564255654812,
-0.5081554651260376,
-0.23649944365024567,
0.25764331221580505,
-0.4181594252586365,
-0.3902803361415863,
0.31432685256004333,
-0.4834328293800354,
-0.37681686878204346,
-0.1168111190199852,
-0.847009539604187,
-0.9264369606971741,
-0.729395866394043,
-0.08359962701797485,
-0.36130377650260925,
-1.0003336668014526,
0.17275714874267578,
0.08468615263700485,
0.40719497203826904,
0.7044947743415833,
-0.4959888756275177,
0.03096253052353859,
0.7693514823913574,
0.48377785086631775,
-0.4621222913265228,
-0.1726907640695572,
-0.5670544505119324,
0.2164941430091858,
-0.48239627480506897,
1.0795503854751587,
-0.6880422234535217,
-0.1092732697725296,
-0.018127011135220528,
-0.2898203134536743,
0.17620940506458282,
-0.5449995994567871,
0.3899914026260376,
-0.6239134073257446,
-0.2308514565229416,
-0.2832421660423279,
-0.6629370450973511,
-0.30350857973098755,
0.8430907130241394,
-0.5230908393859863,
1.0348010063171387,
-0.09221325814723969,
-0.780820369720459,
0.7976484298706055,
-0.5350540280342102,
0.047730714082717896,
0.23428434133529663,
-0.6413518786430359,
-0.37519896030426025,
0.014981184154748917,
0.2475285679101944,
0.616998553276062,
0.08101555705070496,
0.46033304929733276,
-0.5546562671661377,
0.015530257485806942,
0.3318746089935303,
-0.24022433161735535,
0.4890093505382538,
-0.021872583776712418,
-0.6674903035163879,
0.36309295892715454,
-0.640566349029541,
-0.06520313769578934,
-0.05241956189274788,
-0.5405855774879456,
-0.2694622576236725,
0.49244773387908936,
-0.4942381978034973,
0.4258752167224884,
0.29234111309051514,
-0.34617698192596436,
0.31587642431259155,
-0.4383586645126343,
-0.09980505704879761,
0.9495028853416443,
0.15015797317028046,
0.2396082729101181,
0.026593035086989403,
0.7150630950927734,
0.12606945633888245,
-0.20694077014923096,
0.18314361572265625,
-0.25455793738365173,
-0.8018766045570374,
-0.5137009620666504,
0.060263413935899734,
0.27237680554389954,
-0.6978493332862854,
0.361642450094223,
-0.20671167969703674,
-0.21647682785987854,
-0.29537147283554077,
0.20907381176948547,
0.3703729510307312,
0.318251371383667,
0.26530811190605164,
-0.03165074437856674,
-0.27170613408088684,
-0.8565154671669006,
-0.606224775314331,
-0.33434557914733887,
0.3238059878349304,
0.11291328072547913,
0.20190180838108063,
-0.19380708038806915,
1.200404167175293,
-0.2733926475048065,
-0.002040556399151683,
-0.2756730318069458,
0.38441112637519836,
0.1827562004327774,
0.13865971565246582,
0.854193925857544,
-0.839886486530304,
-0.5792540311813354,
-0.22347837686538696,
-0.8613668084144592,
-0.08793631196022034,
-0.07253319025039673,
-0.04153923690319061,
0.40597620606422424,
0.6430133581161499,
-0.6210129261016846,
0.38527974486351013,
0.1824575662612915,
-0.4816860258579254,
0.7731029987335205,
-0.16420435905456543,
0.2519390285015106,
-1.014083743095398,
-0.2852807939052582,
0.425182580947876,
-0.6632120013237,
-0.6655682921409607,
0.2216683179140091,
-0.06455641239881516,
0.13526122272014618,
-0.5303618311882019,
0.5283680558204651,
-0.7401193976402283,
0.18658505380153656,
-0.66786128282547,
-0.004159273114055395,
-0.39805516600608826,
0.35971182584762573,
0.3573357164859772,
0.5676600337028503,
0.7888566255569458,
-0.6975541710853577,
0.5518627166748047,
0.05742466077208519,
-0.08113361895084381,
1.0369364023208618,
-0.4309971332550049,
0.37864723801612854,
0.0012644990347325802,
0.06215006485581398,
-1.1106926202774048,
-0.2267863005399704,
0.2400369644165039,
-0.31288421154022217,
0.7009944915771484,
-0.5134499073028564,
-0.5105181336402893,
-0.48147350549697876,
-0.32228022813796997,
0.13692957162857056,
0.23266655206680298,
-0.5444751977920532,
0.7693984508514404,
0.632904052734375,
-0.2672629654407501,
-0.7227458357810974,
-0.015665046870708466,
0.35223880410194397,
-0.5028735995292664,
-0.547838568687439,
0.1647324562072754,
0.03010435588657856,
-0.6300936341285706,
-0.3303506374359131,
-0.3716926872730255,
0.02057083509862423,
0.10014772415161133,
0.12345269322395325,
-0.15567046403884888,
-0.05807650834321976,
0.039402786642313004,
0.026876308023929596,
-0.41600537300109863,
0.3941827416419983,
-0.18353873491287231,
0.3533337712287903,
-0.3377164602279663,
-0.588736891746521,
-0.5923914909362793,
0.21932770311832428,
0.8675717711448669,
-0.4160042703151703,
0.6442238092422485,
0.5506795644760132,
-0.3260730504989624,
-0.4993927478790283,
-0.8004121780395508,
-0.09183403849601746,
-0.5402777194976807,
0.3450886905193329,
-0.41018569469451904,
-0.436777800321579,
0.47332584857940674,
-0.5540585517883301,
0.17489930987358093,
0.20263999700546265,
0.8568387031555176,
-0.15266676247119904,
1.1733300685882568,
0.809722900390625,
-0.156457781791687,
0.14832532405853271,
-0.23969601094722748,
0.0919087678194046,
-0.4360293447971344,
-0.4760388433933258,
-0.29364779591560364,
-0.4438588321208954,
-0.327897846698761,
-0.6255202293395996,
0.5011625289916992,
-0.22385716438293457,
-0.19159473478794098,
-0.12350719422101974,
-0.43098437786102295,
0.13682882487773895,
0.26922178268432617,
0.24917761981487274,
0.21772244572639465,
-0.18377774953842163,
-0.15373855829238892,
-0.0874359980225563,
-0.09254743158817291,
-0.9186152219772339,
0.7409319877624512,
0.5333150029182434,
0.8220487833023071,
0.2757504880428314,
0.6032315492630005,
0.6065255999565125,
0.032364871352910995,
-1.0278091430664062,
1.0733674764633179,
0.13686372339725494,
-0.3987141251564026,
-0.20201142132282257,
-0.1581440567970276,
-0.5801917314529419,
0.05513762682676315,
-0.20451030135154724,
-0.44275233149528503,
0.2003958523273468,
0.3188333511352539,
-0.08854270726442337,
0.6645224690437317,
0.03477143868803978,
0.6571735739707947,
-0.2341124266386032,
-0.3231925666332245,
-0.34025251865386963,
-0.5287685990333557,
0.2563369572162628,
-0.11480817943811417,
0.16750063002109528,
-0.5421205163002014,
-0.32442858815193176,
0.8279444575309753,
-0.4298376441001892,
1.0905065536499023,
-0.8188512921333313,
-0.46249714493751526,
0.3705369234085083,
0.2930237948894501,
0.7149012088775635,
0.13731375336647034,
-0.42515844106674194,
-0.1295403242111206,
-0.41115668416023254,
-0.379506915807724,
-0.3313751816749573,
0.7575913667678833,
-0.7569719552993774,
-1.0298320055007935,
-0.21524909138679504,
-0.6350338459014893,
-0.39569389820098877,
0.194107323884964,
-0.1426372230052948,
0.18005290627479553,
-0.19513878226280212,
-0.006687227636575699,
0.9141859412193298,
0.08238334953784943,
0.403425395488739,
1.0750588178634644,
-0.0004495508619584143,
-0.10951369255781174,
0.29053372144699097,
-0.0484037771821022,
-0.17413534224033356,
0.2772851288318634,
0.13420964777469635,
-0.42431318759918213,
-1.0035697221755981,
-0.2726113796234131,
0.12973253428936005,
-0.766589343547821,
-0.13371986150741577,
-0.8366897702217102,
0.30045613646507263,
-0.19944404065608978,
-0.08304095268249512,
-0.6887927055358887,
-0.27735230326652527,
0.017499571666121483,
-0.39123043417930603,
0.6026818156242371,
0.5627619624137878,
-0.06432047486305237,
0.283160537481308,
-0.44040852785110474,
0.5333641171455383,
0.3599962592124939,
0.15863408148288727,
-0.24409624934196472,
-0.5199605226516724,
-0.07886870205402374,
0.043687719851732254,
-0.36030447483062744,
-1.2254170179367065,
0.38890528678894043,
-0.03891187533736229,
1.229630470275879,
0.8181445002555847,
0.34614914655685425,
0.17868588864803314,
-0.2956785261631012,
0.6590830087661743,
0.06304934620857239,
-0.7740896344184875,
0.6207973957061768,
-0.792296826839447,
-0.06116262078285217,
0.39780470728874207,
0.34675198793411255,
0.01565548963844776,
-0.7721248269081116,
-0.4849449694156647,
-0.7037351131439209,
0.6578728556632996,
-0.2352650910615921,
0.14478278160095215,
-0.16164956986904144,
0.518595814704895,
0.3132703900337219,
0.2315005362033844,
-0.5109165906906128,
-0.16635507345199585,
0.048754021525382996,
-0.10576072335243225,
0.2848827838897705,
-0.27167314291000366,
-0.1758805364370346,
-0.27330482006073,
0.545765221118927,
-0.2845892906188965,
0.23057891428470612,
-0.19197186827659607,
-0.1459810882806778,
-0.1317906230688095,
0.29334813356399536,
0.4407595992088318,
0.909475564956665,
-0.16625423729419708,
0.43380415439605713,
0.4243437349796295,
-0.11432522535324097,
0.39887747168540955,
0.05319888889789581,
-0.0013273238437250257,
0.07959865778684616,
0.0937945693731308,
0.6762387156486511,
0.10385899990797043,
-0.2246996909379959,
0.5949974060058594,
0.34027862548828125,
-0.23980486392974854,
-0.50897616147995,
0.23710322380065918,
0.2145157754421234,
0.39622098207473755,
0.2694129943847656,
0.1015695184469223,
-0.05307840555906296,
-0.3776959180831909,
0.4038519561290741,
0.5918731689453125,
-0.34540364146232605,
-0.4144560992717743,
0.881950855255127,
0.333011269569397,
-0.2927664518356323,
0.3385390043258667,
-0.24652904272079468,
-0.7111055850982666,
0.8341649174690247,
0.2597033381462097,
0.7563632130622864,
-0.4569548964500427,
0.3255212903022766,
0.018426181748509407,
-0.056366994976997375,
-0.09670189768075943,
0.42412954568862915,
0.00393462972715497,
-0.9046286344528198,
-0.35191524028778076,
-0.2562299966812134,
-0.5889984369277954,
0.03801893815398216,
-0.619733452796936,
0.5389276146888733,
-0.479227751493454,
-0.5826418995857239,
0.0783284455537796,
0.16522006690502167,
-0.6221328973770142,
0.1642572283744812,
0.321508526802063,
0.9204428195953369,
-0.9826498627662659,
0.5956480503082275,
1.4183415174484253,
-0.24804377555847168,
-0.6415054798126221,
0.3776608407497406,
0.35562363266944885,
-0.6563230156898499,
0.517805278301239,
0.06782443821430206,
-0.535402238368988,
-0.05202299728989601,
-0.6687033176422119,
-0.40949681401252747,
0.7660937905311584,
0.38604286313056946,
-0.18896271288394928,
0.23324866592884064,
-0.1617085039615631,
0.5726169347763062,
-0.2816188931465149,
0.3115460276603699,
0.4344482123851776,
0.779849648475647,
-0.07547411322593689,
-0.5887844562530518,
0.11213380098342896,
-0.12846501171588898,
-0.42029914259910583,
0.19569331407546997,
-0.8307739496231079,
0.7729176878929138,
-0.21452710032463074,
0.21633902192115784,
-0.22002843022346497,
0.99803626537323,
0.5573305487632751,
0.5016663670539856,
0.7413883209228516,
0.5744011402130127,
0.877929151058197,
0.200672447681427,
0.7875639796257019,
-0.3122321665287018,
0.2393757700920105,
0.8631758689880371,
-0.43591225147247314,
0.6574772000312805,
0.23353205621242523,
-0.1634766012430191,
0.8122812509536743,
0.6548795104026794,
0.012980486266314983,
0.48975369334220886,
-0.005173115059733391,
-0.46559715270996094,
-1.0092339515686035,
0.2323632538318634,
-0.3049873411655426,
0.69856858253479,
0.366205632686615,
-0.181647390127182,
-0.27912551164627075,
-0.14773517847061157,
0.2907472550868988,
0.4625984728336334,
-0.4877130687236786,
0.774003267288208,
0.09530352801084518,
-0.5122802257537842,
0.6816361546516418,
0.302096962928772,
0.730073869228363,
-0.2582973539829254,
0.05021818354725838,
-0.20402248203754425,
0.33818894624710083,
-0.23524074256420135,
-1.015038251876831,
0.05806228145956993,
0.11878030747175217,
-0.3872224688529968,
-0.3275377154350281,
1.0578372478485107,
-0.355374813079834,
-0.2809695601463318,
0.2930925488471985,
0.882582426071167,
0.4390135705471039,
-0.03438795357942581,
-0.6822259426116943,
-0.4765567183494568,
-0.2807595133781433,
-0.5435943603515625,
0.226030632853508,
0.7338958382606506,
-0.18936750292778015,
0.7294088006019592,
0.3407542109489441,
0.014802004210650921,
-0.058323368430137634,
0.04834410548210144,
1.0321934223175049,
-0.50679612159729,
-0.5522118806838989,
-0.8565605878829956,
0.5054407119750977,
-0.2948988378047943,
0.07678240537643433,
0.8726401329040527,
0.35924577713012695,
0.25574156641960144,
-0.1773913949728012,
0.6263996362686157,
0.2156824916601181,
0.700087308883667,
-0.49713513255119324,
0.8538062572479248,
-0.5640050768852234,
0.2826719582080841,
-0.20032593607902527,
-0.6921626329421997,
-0.0893632173538208,
0.5280471444129944,
-0.5136108994483948,
0.3019804060459137,
0.31938090920448303,
0.6538901329040527,
-0.2481580674648285,
-0.3389655649662018,
0.286029577255249,
0.34840813279151917,
0.4908161759376526,
0.31449681520462036,
1.107070803642273,
0.3387314975261688,
0.12911440432071686,
0.21642951667308807,
-0.33055880665779114,
-0.25046467781066895,
-1.2700923681259155,
-1.1668057441711426,
-0.0940767228603363,
-0.8266863822937012,
-0.1138743907213211,
-0.0994098037481308,
0.875924289226532,
0.9100935459136963,
-0.7042409181594849,
0.10933684557676315,
0.0037182895466685295,
0.18113237619400024,
-0.40525180101394653,
-0.17097856104373932,
0.3287549912929535,
-0.422694593667984,
-0.8141224980354309,
0.8837573528289795,
0.14190825819969177,
-0.21095511317253113,
-0.3413093090057373,
-0.2547816336154938,
-0.23666825890541077,
0.28222209215164185,
0.4422150254249573,
0.2985493540763855,
-0.9058594703674316,
-0.343985915184021,
-0.07080009579658508,
0.05972882732748985,
0.241469144821167,
0.5267658829689026,
-0.919394314289093,
0.5674948692321777,
0.5233423113822937,
0.3544907867908478,
0.35785022377967834,
0.29944056272506714,
0.6769620180130005,
-0.8701837658882141,
0.0828268900513649,
0.2481653094291687,
0.4839058518409729,
0.26160308718681335,
-0.35911035537719727,
0.3760153651237488,
0.28059425950050354,
-0.4524565637111664,
-0.7917900085449219,
0.21428705751895905,
-1.089510440826416,
-0.24061031639575958,
1.4015940427780151,
-0.3586730360984802,
0.21398817002773285,
-0.44214504957199097,
-0.18063607811927795,
0.4121434688568115,
-0.49614959955215454,
0.7897640466690063,
0.5026745796203613,
-0.15763384103775024,
-0.3105902373790741,
-0.43738213181495667,
0.47582322359085083,
0.5229877233505249,
-0.8027424812316895,
0.004985473584383726,
0.5218667984008789,
0.5090956091880798,
-0.09628859907388687,
0.8204776644706726,
0.01606190949678421,
0.11604432016611099,
-0.22181960940361023,
0.20171841979026794,
-0.4466122090816498,
-0.5537020564079285,
-0.11971665918827057,
0.1507541537284851,
0.4141361713409424,
-0.1482212096452713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15248v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15248v3
|
Chitchat as Interference: Adding User Backstories to Task-Oriented Dialogues
| 2024-02-23T10:27:42 | 2024-06-28T10:27:11 |
Armand Stricker, Patrick Paroubek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
During task-oriented dialogues (TODs), human users naturally introduce
chitchat that is beyond the immediate scope of the task, interfering with the
flow of the conversation. To address this issue without the need for expensive
manual data creation, we use few-shot prompting with Llama-2-70B to enhance the
MultiWOZ dataset with user backstories, a typical example of chitchat
interference in TODs. We assess the impact of this addition by testing two
models: one trained solely on TODs and another trained on TODs with a
preliminary chitchat interaction. Our analysis demonstrates that our enhanced
dataset poses a challenge for these systems. Moreover, we demonstrate that our
dataset can be effectively used for training purposes, enabling a system to
consistently acknowledge the user's backstory while also successfully moving
the task forward in the same turn, as confirmed by human evaluation. These
findings highlight the benefits of generating novel chitchat-TOD scenarios to
test TOD systems more thoroughly and improve their resilience to natural user
interferences
|
[
-0.3754481077194214,
-0.6697523593902588,
0.5615692138671875,
0.3535863757133484,
-0.3283994197845459,
0.13170526921749115,
-0.06718084216117859,
-0.9013789892196655,
0.2224474847316742,
0.686613142490387,
-0.9581889510154724,
-0.0948215201497078,
-0.4965044856071472,
0.19149306416511536,
-0.6188217997550964,
1.160172939300537,
0.18398116528987885,
-0.02160419523715973,
-0.04462074115872383,
-0.05870812013745308,
-0.9761238098144531,
-0.523148238658905,
-0.285629004240036,
-0.38526999950408936,
0.6053739190101624,
0.5900648832321167,
0.6259169578552246,
0.1774538904428482,
0.33499470353126526,
0.25379127264022827,
0.37093067169189453,
0.24792969226837158,
-0.4474511444568634,
0.6547871232032776,
-0.0688396692276001,
-0.4845220744609833,
-0.3300597667694092,
-0.05038158595561981,
0.1185062900185585,
0.5306598544120789,
0.01292549166828394,
0.18613755702972412,
0.3521444499492645,
0.3257864713668823,
-0.5498456954956055,
0.012547352351248264,
-0.3947519361972809,
0.07066980749368668,
-0.40825143456459045,
-0.1032264456152916,
-0.04454656317830086,
-0.09301110357046127,
0.1514267921447754,
-0.47400563955307007,
0.08734120428562164,
-0.1678689569234848,
0.5938977599143982,
0.49058079719543457,
-0.19698083400726318,
-0.0704183280467987,
-0.7298538684844971,
0.70484858751297,
-0.6435661911964417,
0.44145071506500244,
0.9637537002563477,
0.11126373708248138,
-0.3430056571960449,
-0.4151589274406433,
-0.8134815096855164,
-0.2503718137741089,
-0.09582041949033737,
0.21148982644081116,
-0.17106495797634125,
-0.04568793252110481,
0.35610756278038025,
-0.15870103240013123,
-0.27596423029899597,
0.1688457876443863,
-0.2067285031080246,
-0.13975191116333008,
0.6913492679595947,
0.6368762850761414,
0.09884946048259735,
-0.28541556000709534,
-0.15922518074512482,
0.05075685307383537,
-0.42291057109832764,
0.20044133067131042,
0.4445054233074188,
0.4272144138813019,
-0.202281191945076,
0.9023095369338989,
-0.6122533679008484,
0.652614951133728,
0.2992440462112427,
-0.11034605652093887,
0.09827568382024765,
-0.6853575110435486,
-0.1339876502752304,
-0.26869723200798035,
0.7338915467262268,
0.3826506733894348,
0.21841035783290863,
-0.20082317292690277,
0.09852046519517899,
-0.020238645374774933,
0.5039620399475098,
-0.5193943977355957,
-0.18220897018909454,
0.4391942024230957,
-0.21460188925266266,
-0.33602985739707947,
0.08067350089550018,
-0.8948584198951721,
-0.7385284304618835,
-0.2072208970785141,
0.2413160502910614,
-0.32463112473487854,
0.0061088125221431255,
-0.280327707529068,
-0.3337697684764862,
0.25399142503738403,
0.7316404581069946,
-0.6735047698020935,
0.1071215346455574,
0.7271239757537842,
0.6533689498901367,
-0.029021786525845528,
-0.8527485728263855,
-0.7137255668640137,
0.17218387126922607,
-0.49609777331352234,
0.9010332822799683,
-0.5330796241760254,
-0.5751261115074158,
-0.25714951753616333,
-0.03266844525933266,
0.15608707070350647,
-0.2330852746963501,
0.2764982283115387,
-0.02297333814203739,
0.3417687714099884,
-0.5008418560028076,
0.10385865718126297,
-0.026100115850567818,
0.22537225484848022,
-0.1704319268465042,
1.175822377204895,
0.14248397946357727,
-0.702132523059845,
0.3471944332122803,
-0.6712260246276855,
-0.565987765789032,
0.1260654777288437,
-0.39421167969703674,
-0.29144805669784546,
0.12355674058198929,
0.22330479323863983,
0.45160868763923645,
-0.2840310037136078,
0.20578649640083313,
-0.2959921061992645,
-0.709078848361969,
0.35680869221687317,
-0.23798862099647522,
0.6952672600746155,
-0.12922023236751556,
-0.5946004390716553,
0.0876045674085617,
-0.6606954336166382,
-0.08104321360588074,
0.008186804130673409,
-0.15813244879245758,
-0.3857060670852661,
-0.008231421001255512,
-0.15885883569717407,
0.28029507398605347,
-0.09850181639194489,
-0.6422624588012695,
0.21166808903217316,
-0.18822336196899414,
0.11201757937669754,
0.853081226348877,
-0.10396593064069748,
0.06603839248418808,
-0.6401252746582031,
0.5331194400787354,
-0.012547476217150688,
0.19357602298259735,
-0.28909823298454285,
-0.8820530772209167,
-0.5922209024429321,
-0.2336834967136383,
-0.20197650790214539,
0.7235999703407288,
-0.8623785376548767,
0.3878350257873535,
-0.17823442816734314,
-0.22756239771842957,
-0.3234097361564636,
0.3499514162540436,
0.46840304136276245,
0.48589661717414856,
0.26409897208213806,
-0.43056491017341614,
-0.5739841461181641,
-0.6739920377731323,
-0.1370527297258377,
-0.2820771634578705,
-0.37676844000816345,
0.5458765625953674,
0.3436574637889862,
-0.172936350107193,
1.221892237663269,
-0.21149438619613647,
-0.2532911002635956,
-0.2786867618560791,
0.13948187232017517,
-0.21531866490840912,
0.5403417944908142,
0.21554216742515564,
-0.36952999234199524,
-0.3710128366947174,
-0.1351977437734604,
-0.7495668530464172,
-0.24599117040634155,
-0.2619628310203552,
-0.14463317394256592,
0.0705202966928482,
0.22379866242408752,
-0.5943872928619385,
0.7726864218711853,
0.624987006187439,
-0.3812645673751831,
0.6863195896148682,
0.33099475502967834,
0.6480901837348938,
-1.0465517044067383,
-0.0025041026528924704,
-0.280505508184433,
-0.07025900483131409,
-0.8026160597801208,
-0.3152711093425751,
-0.1802321821451187,
-0.2725555896759033,
-0.2020774930715561,
0.27127039432525635,
-0.3007465600967407,
-0.28603479266166687,
-0.329772025346756,
0.14511708915233612,
0.021522825583815575,
0.7561906576156616,
-0.050016701221466064,
0.8865067958831787,
0.17483606934547424,
-0.296615332365036,
0.3737724721431732,
0.826932966709137,
-0.1877533346414566,
0.8129262924194336,
-0.5224915146827698,
0.7236989736557007,
0.2125350683927536,
0.44496676325798035,
-1.0741273164749146,
-0.39852720499038696,
0.6072297692298889,
-0.5714685916900635,
0.16763699054718018,
-0.40878477692604065,
-0.3527921438217163,
-0.2441595047712326,
-0.7152982950210571,
0.17550525069236755,
0.22537235915660858,
-0.6984544992446899,
0.48707109689712524,
0.18968816101551056,
-0.36984920501708984,
-0.7154060006141663,
-0.8068417906761169,
0.5710110068321228,
-0.31167155504226685,
-0.7622473239898682,
0.12685523927211761,
-0.06124904006719589,
-0.12576842308044434,
-0.3360457122325897,
-0.1657802313566208,
-0.23130396008491516,
0.22157244384288788,
0.7325132489204407,
0.4275065064430237,
-0.03025522455573082,
0.007600352168083191,
-0.023038938641548157,
0.12571775913238525,
-0.11344656348228455,
0.019801830872893333,
0.6197304725646973,
0.23677776753902435,
-0.5025039315223694,
-0.9201723337173462,
0.7334067821502686,
0.35619762539863586,
-0.051645677536726,
0.44017544388771057,
0.6294273138046265,
-0.17515170574188232,
0.25778841972351074,
-0.7669639587402344,
-0.45116692781448364,
-0.4813491106033325,
0.3637319803237915,
-0.5203930735588074,
-0.9175254106521606,
0.5654609203338623,
0.16471800208091736,
0.24223627150058746,
-0.1509171426296234,
0.40683504939079285,
-0.5314103960990906,
0.8493825197219849,
0.5950585007667542,
-0.03877764567732811,
0.6774556636810303,
0.08602770417928696,
0.05770592391490936,
-1.0593664646148682,
-0.36590704321861267,
-0.7362617254257202,
-0.3381568491458893,
-0.3667404055595398,
-0.32124102115631104,
0.0456378236413002,
-0.031527068465948105,
-0.019369928166270256,
0.4352972209453583,
-0.18171128630638123,
0.27069219946861267,
0.45079925656318665,
0.4552704989910126,
0.3700483441352844,
-0.1959817260503769,
0.3732525706291199,
-0.17586171627044678,
-0.5809120535850525,
-0.15864118933677673,
0.96640944480896,
0.1502508670091629,
1.027413249015808,
0.16117066144943237,
0.7811623215675354,
0.31717413663864136,
0.04278057813644409,
-0.914823055267334,
0.46961909532546997,
0.2635774612426758,
-0.45996350049972534,
-0.51041179895401,
-0.12989278137683868,
-1.0841240882873535,
0.16091345250606537,
-0.36552706360816956,
-1.2979965209960938,
0.5136858820915222,
0.2117304801940918,
-0.5354080200195312,
-0.0731765478849411,
-0.6824658513069153,
0.5421526432037354,
-0.11074713617563248,
-0.666652262210846,
-0.14635920524597168,
-0.7390890121459961,
0.4864703416824341,
-0.15400956571102142,
0.021364789456129074,
-0.08982468396425247,
0.015506509691476822,
0.8426306247711182,
-0.3864865303039551,
1.3906197547912598,
-0.06328467279672623,
-0.12158989906311035,
0.12387438118457794,
0.1767694354057312,
0.8081094026565552,
-0.012086166068911552,
0.3102664351463318,
0.39404287934303284,
-0.23993204534053802,
-0.35882097482681274,
-0.4826749861240387,
0.5397605299949646,
-0.5210524201393127,
-1.097324252128601,
-0.31196245551109314,
-0.8686842918395996,
-0.6377397179603577,
-0.0717194527387619,
0.11442489176988602,
0.3188045620918274,
0.12277421355247498,
0.1406547725200653,
0.14869815111160278,
-0.09591108560562134,
0.36911967396736145,
0.3569987118244171,
0.05183525010943413,
-0.10428425669670105,
0.530051052570343,
-0.07320118695497513,
0.15031930804252625,
-0.23927143216133118,
0.38444000482559204,
-0.036900125443935394,
-0.6287875771522522,
-0.5547283887863159,
0.023201338946819305,
-0.45965903997421265,
-0.3126384913921356,
-0.8342257142066956,
0.11756505817174911,
-0.44257569313049316,
-0.04427671805024147,
-0.19014927744865417,
-0.48494240641593933,
-0.16581608355045319,
0.08249247819185257,
0.5005273818969727,
0.8443242311477661,
0.012353246100246906,
0.46620994806289673,
-1.1144137382507324,
0.3531797528266907,
0.5792725682258606,
0.2688521444797516,
-0.009491978213191032,
-0.5833585858345032,
-0.4144127666950226,
0.06134185194969177,
-0.30321118235588074,
-1.1650819778442383,
-0.0040672761388123035,
-0.0067131719551980495,
0.6492505073547363,
0.14253546297550201,
0.08566366136074066,
1.1665083169937134,
-0.3856987953186035,
1.0123929977416992,
0.16834239661693573,
-0.9994246363639832,
0.7036626935005188,
-0.518871545791626,
0.4047280550003052,
0.6195259690284729,
0.008163073100149632,
-0.637742280960083,
-0.7213871479034424,
-0.3211139440536499,
-0.5239393711090088,
1.1063100099563599,
0.2535061240196228,
0.3050164580345154,
0.20317479968070984,
0.1403876394033432,
0.22164539992809296,
0.18127943575382233,
-0.3793381154537201,
0.13949938118457794,
-0.5074008703231812,
-0.11307582259178162,
0.07531683892011642,
-0.24432063102722168,
-0.3481616675853729,
-0.0066446238197386265,
0.30968400835990906,
-0.2442479133605957,
0.19904565811157227,
0.2500399053096771,
-0.09929785877466202,
-0.3263433575630188,
0.399541974067688,
0.6555324792861938,
0.4591558575630188,
-0.07002883404493332,
-0.17844083905220032,
0.37676891684532166,
-0.6934898495674133,
0.057314250618219376,
0.12336457520723343,
0.17667622864246368,
-0.31895577907562256,
0.3616538643836975,
0.5959251523017883,
0.20466923713684082,
-0.6636121869087219,
0.3055807650089264,
-0.09346719831228256,
0.008212382905185223,
0.09858736395835876,
0.18582123517990112,
0.027277125045657158,
0.609380841255188,
0.49407467246055603,
0.1581515222787857,
0.18720760941505432,
-0.7491157054901123,
0.1495482474565506,
0.4538412094116211,
-0.35662442445755005,
-0.31462836265563965,
0.20165479183197021,
0.4304324686527252,
-0.6073326468467712,
0.5471841096878052,
0.13394121825695038,
-0.7858824133872986,
0.3960035443305969,
0.46794840693473816,
0.8130480051040649,
-0.22440113127231598,
0.03867897018790245,
0.03162475675344467,
0.3877203166484833,
0.14565029740333557,
0.28571024537086487,
-0.6624780297279358,
-0.7725832462310791,
-0.4094844460487366,
0.018842443823814392,
-0.6568797826766968,
0.03138396516442299,
-0.6751807928085327,
0.061464011669158936,
-0.32460278272628784,
-0.3212772309780121,
-0.10370118170976639,
-0.0623844638466835,
-0.5899209976196289,
-0.2240743786096573,
-0.06545857340097427,
0.3520071506500244,
-0.6794552206993103,
1.0174534320831299,
0.4244282841682434,
-0.17490018904209137,
-0.5745087265968323,
0.46858298778533936,
0.32311421632766724,
-0.8775992393493652,
0.5558019876480103,
0.08673381060361862,
-0.33860376477241516,
-0.3492159843444824,
-0.32503682374954224,
-0.5160455703735352,
1.042184591293335,
0.0812147855758667,
-0.5760162472724915,
0.2087603658437729,
-0.007821754552423954,
0.3784310221672058,
-0.19021166861057281,
-0.039428651332855225,
0.7210901975631714,
0.4391321837902069,
-0.024583224207162857,
-1.1481579542160034,
0.2551110088825226,
-0.2169400155544281,
-0.24416090548038483,
0.24114324152469635,
-0.5847857594490051,
0.5945721864700317,
-0.5442978739738464,
-0.32597634196281433,
0.2680317461490631,
0.38910847902297974,
0.35299327969551086,
0.6005464792251587,
0.6607430577278137,
0.13276533782482147,
0.5223838686943054,
-0.1956915706396103,
1.0153664350509644,
0.26005685329437256,
-0.11835304647684097,
1.6340028047561646,
-0.48258697986602783,
0.6014634370803833,
0.8094030618667603,
-0.2506362199783325,
0.28173044323921204,
0.42077070474624634,
-0.10462963581085205,
0.22529307007789612,
-0.2345968782901764,
-0.008109595626592636,
-0.21364544332027435,
-0.2917880117893219,
-0.3621826171875,
0.7647423148155212,
0.1922524869441986,
0.1459932178258896,
0.03286127373576164,
0.15985894203186035,
0.01908634416759014,
-0.11796858161687851,
0.13819357752799988,
0.9309625625610352,
-0.16224199533462524,
-0.5209095478057861,
0.3339182436466217,
-0.4326757490634918,
0.9663862586021423,
-0.6304630637168884,
-0.1099967360496521,
-0.43140876293182373,
-0.33857473731040955,
-0.4680612087249756,
-0.7824955582618713,
0.24363982677459717,
0.36304664611816406,
0.161284938454628,
0.14880016446113586,
0.5564010143280029,
-0.3861340284347534,
-0.09223460406064987,
0.266127347946167,
0.655646562576294,
0.10374092310667038,
-0.024731013923883438,
-0.5384804606437683,
0.024338386952877045,
0.1385056972503662,
-0.14534394443035126,
0.538995087146759,
0.09183104336261749,
-0.27907702326774597,
0.5790812969207764,
0.9639632701873779,
-0.17179736495018005,
-0.032871462404727936,
0.2776254713535309,
0.9676885604858398,
-0.727293074131012,
-0.5714162588119507,
-0.7063276171684265,
0.46553558111190796,
-0.17950816452503204,
-0.3059574067592621,
0.963379442691803,
0.21807833015918732,
0.6430885791778564,
0.20491400361061096,
0.7879067659378052,
-0.060677897185087204,
0.35020166635513306,
-0.34762513637542725,
0.3907453119754791,
-0.35808321833610535,
0.3637411296367645,
-0.37465977668762207,
-0.4679156243801117,
0.15392102301120758,
0.47694337368011475,
0.06705592572689056,
0.08130459487438202,
0.5447195172309875,
0.6811011433601379,
-0.054587721824645996,
0.3430153429508209,
0.5861208438873291,
0.0005543971783481538,
0.2883817255496979,
0.4686884880065918,
1.5237784385681152,
-0.2661132514476776,
0.6505739092826843,
-0.585308313369751,
-0.26314792037010193,
-0.21348388493061066,
-0.5453896522521973,
-1.1192288398742676,
-0.4869610071182251,
-0.13580574095249176,
-0.41778287291526794,
0.40576887130737305,
0.9001628160476685,
0.6652752757072449,
-0.673808753490448,
-0.3563540279865265,
0.22172583639621735,
0.04546080902218819,
-0.3018466830253601,
-0.24668371677398682,
-0.06036758795380592,
-0.19672265648841858,
-0.679722785949707,
0.7519327402114868,
0.22718961536884308,
0.2981855273246765,
-0.15685342252254486,
-0.10977056622505188,
-0.2333282083272934,
0.021732185035943985,
0.574547529220581,
0.23995934426784515,
-0.6845157742500305,
-0.577235758304596,
0.043151773512363434,
0.13331735134124756,
0.14724162220954895,
1.2467737197875977,
-0.760408878326416,
0.4392090439796448,
0.3734350800514221,
0.5482078790664673,
0.6355303525924683,
0.09008901566267014,
0.818729817867279,
-0.847901463508606,
0.42540910840034485,
0.23714467883110046,
0.1566956788301468,
0.22167669236660004,
-0.714928150177002,
0.4730585813522339,
0.08906860649585724,
-0.2843197286128998,
-0.9496055245399475,
0.223739355802536,
-1.045395016670227,
-0.297661691904068,
0.7323762774467468,
-0.30862554907798767,
0.2455642968416214,
-0.7600494027137756,
-0.40043970942497253,
0.12799286842346191,
-0.5842018723487854,
1.1376382112503052,
0.8325122594833374,
-0.5791156888008118,
-0.31393641233444214,
-0.3942069113254547,
0.4420109987258911,
0.4739106595516205,
-1.1866925954818726,
0.24835750460624695,
0.6368078589439392,
0.16895313560962677,
0.16683946549892426,
0.6014921069145203,
0.10407086461782455,
0.6618640422821045,
0.15883122384548187,
-0.30213674902915955,
-0.5281246900558472,
-0.39614176750183105,
-0.3968779146671295,
-0.07251022756099701,
-0.20393113791942596,
-0.3885207772254944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15238v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15238v2
|
GPT-HateCheck: Can LLMs Write Better Functional Tests for Hate Speech Detection?
| 2024-02-23T10:02:01 | 2024-05-27T13:14:12 |
Yiping Jin, Leo Wanner, Alexander Shvets
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Online hate detection suffers from biases incurred in data sampling,
annotation, and model pre-training. Therefore, measuring the averaged
performance over all examples in held-out test data is inadequate. Instead, we
must identify specific model weaknesses and be informed when it is more likely
to fail. A recent proposal in this direction is HateCheck, a suite for testing
fine-grained model functionalities on synthesized data generated using
templates of the kind "You are just a [slur] to me." However, despite enabling
more detailed diagnostic insights, the HateCheck test cases are often generic
and have simplistic sentence structures that do not match the real-world data.
To address this limitation, we propose GPT-HateCheck, a framework to generate
more diverse and realistic functional tests from scratch by instructing large
language models (LLMs). We employ an additional natural language inference
(NLI) model to verify the generations. Crowd-sourced annotation demonstrates
that the generated test cases are of high quality. Using the new functional
tests, we can uncover model weaknesses that would be overlooked using the
original HateCheck dataset.
|
[
-0.5401056408882141,
-0.8736339211463928,
0.30836567282676697,
-0.21459075808525085,
-0.0535103939473629,
-0.02453402802348137,
0.0021956884302198887,
-0.715395450592041,
0.194529190659523,
0.55747389793396,
-0.6890285015106201,
-0.26017409563064575,
-0.5239839553833008,
0.08872919529676437,
-0.701708197593689,
1.1739223003387451,
0.27958744764328003,
-0.011635715141892433,
-0.12686243653297424,
-0.03190581128001213,
0.06746746599674225,
-0.5197973847389221,
-0.6762332320213318,
-0.3661215007305145,
0.5949411392211914,
-0.001882549375295639,
0.5511188507080078,
0.2610871493816376,
0.20262044668197632,
0.20725588500499725,
-0.12124096602201462,
0.03972119837999344,
-0.5664166212081909,
0.0910344198346138,
0.06323537975549698,
-0.4331534504890442,
-0.2745762765407562,
0.129500612616539,
0.10711486637592316,
0.30866315960884094,
-0.09046485275030136,
0.13555370271205902,
-0.11419700086116791,
0.07665029913187027,
-0.46591880917549133,
-0.2382841557264328,
-0.9011366963386536,
0.1070183739066124,
-0.2383434921503067,
0.34923556447029114,
-0.4124128818511963,
-0.6739501953125,
-0.13991913199424744,
-0.27669382095336914,
0.537165105342865,
-0.07360787689685822,
0.8573322892189026,
0.2862008213996887,
-0.3317832052707672,
-0.21398881077766418,
-0.5762149095535278,
0.5900436639785767,
-0.9812360405921936,
0.327037513256073,
0.541676938533783,
0.27431657910346985,
-0.09931861609220505,
-0.3052588701248169,
-0.730387806892395,
-0.7176312804222107,
0.04433075338602066,
-0.0784771591424942,
-0.15933847427368164,
0.17964833974838257,
0.5038087368011475,
0.4011553227901459,
-0.7159355282783508,
0.37909239530563354,
-0.33532488346099854,
-0.48734456300735474,
0.7246577739715576,
0.0575316846370697,
0.4367700219154358,
-0.017242949455976486,
-0.19879522919654846,
0.12766586244106293,
-0.697471022605896,
-0.33335238695144653,
0.830475389957428,
0.3786201775074005,
0.057958148419857025,
0.4941902756690979,
-0.19127371907234192,
0.7165612578392029,
-0.18287423253059387,
-0.025705711916089058,
0.24556000530719757,
-0.03481830656528473,
-0.333714097738266,
-0.1139955148100853,
0.41481927037239075,
0.1984582245349884,
0.6254920363426208,
-0.33660832047462463,
-0.3368097245693207,
0.4760265052318573,
0.4122253358364105,
-0.7613818645477295,
-0.3148616552352905,
0.10947328805923462,
-0.19914229214191437,
-0.6763354539871216,
-0.20817594230175018,
-0.8868265748023987,
-0.8949002623558044,
-0.29682669043540955,
0.34409046173095703,
-0.5135298371315002,
-0.2514648735523224,
-0.19740794599056244,
-0.15326592326164246,
0.11454525589942932,
0.19208724796772003,
-0.7080810070037842,
0.24605435132980347,
0.5660335421562195,
0.6083680987358093,
-0.3841724991798401,
-0.16674691438674927,
-0.77875816822052,
-0.19134436547756195,
-0.051511019468307495,
0.832308292388916,
-0.4286001920700073,
-0.1441688984632492,
0.0478704497218132,
-0.343969464302063,
0.015617961063981056,
-0.7811354994773865,
0.5299324989318848,
-0.33869311213493347,
0.08580803126096725,
-0.10495314002037048,
-0.6298309564590454,
0.07621666043996811,
0.3824121952056885,
-0.2652260959148407,
1.1948556900024414,
0.45857733488082886,
-0.7382137179374695,
0.4718012809753418,
-0.6038281321525574,
-0.522946834564209,
0.168138325214386,
-0.17284967005252838,
-0.5694739818572998,
0.1072046160697937,
0.08303796499967575,
0.3142663836479187,
-0.2710842192173004,
0.35534751415252686,
-0.8496353626251221,
-0.25140634179115295,
0.19503824412822723,
-0.1622883826494217,
0.8711013793945312,
0.22790198028087616,
-0.7794079780578613,
0.08529642224311829,
-1.0381990671157837,
-0.15129804611206055,
0.17969077825546265,
-0.18926891684532166,
-0.3586403429508209,
0.052818164229393005,
0.19656077027320862,
0.1209622398018837,
-0.4640747904777527,
-0.9368630647659302,
-0.10462471097707748,
-0.43805140256881714,
0.303826242685318,
1.0528721809387207,
-0.2503453493118286,
-0.14932644367218018,
-0.4491906762123108,
0.6962087750434875,
-0.08876794576644897,
0.16304108500480652,
0.2652171850204468,
-0.5101547241210938,
-0.9037407040596008,
-0.3750605583190918,
-0.025238510221242905,
0.48387983441352844,
-0.46389758586883545,
0.3130582869052887,
0.1185065358877182,
-0.5135028958320618,
-0.3481218218803406,
0.04641356319189072,
0.22338318824768066,
0.6236559152603149,
0.2623778283596039,
-0.36701324582099915,
-0.7465865015983582,
-1.0194393396377563,
-0.4534858465194702,
-0.1918056607246399,
-0.1916079819202423,
0.1749643087387085,
0.5895370841026306,
-0.33110159635543823,
0.9159931540489197,
-0.42878130078315735,
-0.06170814111828804,
-0.2538887858390808,
0.22843855619430542,
-0.22054433822631836,
0.09977535903453827,
0.6021015644073486,
-0.6531912088394165,
-0.2549128830432892,
-0.3829111158847809,
-0.18293119966983795,
-0.5741085410118103,
0.2177339792251587,
0.2909187078475952,
0.18150928616523743,
0.36147794127464294,
-0.07223863899707794,
0.28987550735473633,
0.613815426826477,
-0.5122694373130798,
0.8643341064453125,
0.5020111203193665,
0.07968362420797348,
-0.6576528549194336,
-0.09283760190010071,
0.017610235139727592,
-0.2527411878108978,
-0.6425057053565979,
0.11118756979703903,
-0.3662053346633911,
-0.19886577129364014,
-0.4609440863132477,
0.3189449608325958,
0.006920875981450081,
0.06102705001831055,
-0.27232781052589417,
-0.006020273081958294,
-0.37987011671066284,
0.25441792607307434,
-0.267252117395401,
0.7016048431396484,
0.15136095881462097,
-0.5779915452003479,
0.3018859922885895,
-0.012399082072079182,
-0.38441190123558044,
0.7652143239974976,
-0.44466808438301086,
0.360774427652359,
-0.08213171362876892,
0.09365971386432648,
-1.0835627317428589,
-0.3805879056453705,
0.1923828125,
-0.3840565085411072,
-0.22014211118221283,
-0.39013364911079407,
-0.5221289396286011,
-0.40552037954330444,
-0.18251872062683105,
0.14124587178230286,
0.4690187871456146,
-0.49316197633743286,
0.4256935119628906,
0.5984050035476685,
-0.07086779177188873,
-0.3113008141517639,
-0.8671615123748779,
-0.12798887491226196,
-0.41849926114082336,
-0.5449104309082031,
-0.010315612889826298,
-0.26393193006515503,
-0.2856074869632721,
-0.3272576332092285,
0.07016175240278244,
-0.5496882200241089,
0.32296496629714966,
0.4138454794883728,
0.12456581741571426,
-0.2365952432155609,
0.04945635050535202,
-0.2291068732738495,
0.23676587641239166,
0.14157019555568695,
-0.06792771071195602,
0.5416173934936523,
0.07394447922706604,
-0.36842140555381775,
0.06850425899028778,
0.20407366752624512,
0.6278113722801208,
-0.0856231302022934,
0.3630999028682709,
0.83668053150177,
-0.43909668922424316,
-0.489846408367157,
-0.830340564250946,
-0.2488311231136322,
-0.4523870348930359,
0.28782930970191956,
-0.10935607552528381,
-1.3014250993728638,
0.4960089325904846,
0.3292582631111145,
0.05945169925689697,
0.22580702602863312,
0.6212192177772522,
0.11787895113229752,
0.7655010223388672,
0.3894283175468445,
-0.2271571159362793,
0.25459933280944824,
0.32062557339668274,
0.42557114362716675,
-0.28410816192626953,
0.12506833672523499,
-0.6027076244354248,
-0.019820017740130424,
-0.4380130469799042,
-0.3689490556716919,
0.3108876049518585,
-0.46522897481918335,
-0.3097100555896759,
0.1570459008216858,
-0.5536185503005981,
0.6029823422431946,
0.23147201538085938,
-0.08386614918708801,
0.2078738808631897,
0.2364072948694229,
-0.10366513580083847,
-0.45251646637916565,
-0.16608843207359314,
-0.29930537939071655,
1.0235791206359863,
0.3344615399837494,
0.386406809091568,
0.061535824090242386,
0.6750934720039368,
0.349947065114975,
0.8169587850570679,
-0.7225193977355957,
0.5048145055770874,
-0.1163070946931839,
-0.9288579821586609,
-0.031100623309612274,
-0.4470215141773224,
-0.5456103682518005,
0.28054141998291016,
0.07267848402261734,
-0.8716859817504883,
-0.16739347577095032,
0.4636251926422119,
-0.45046985149383545,
0.6624631881713867,
-0.6731874346733093,
0.79755699634552,
0.015055830590426922,
-0.153757244348526,
0.020618537440896034,
-0.03621499985456467,
0.8121010661125183,
-0.1149294525384903,
0.4166673421859741,
-0.3643050789833069,
0.4231674373149872,
0.8097565174102783,
-0.3102392554283142,
1.132913589477539,
-0.3648328185081482,
-0.1918603926897049,
0.4168706238269806,
0.43710240721702576,
0.39692115783691406,
-0.33255162835121155,
-0.1467646062374115,
-0.095686174929142,
-0.22532889246940613,
-0.17847952246665955,
-0.341230183839798,
0.5419243574142456,
-0.41424164175987244,
-0.3955399692058563,
-0.1949472874403,
-0.396757036447525,
-0.500576376914978,
0.09874669462442398,
0.16682440042495728,
0.2604118883609772,
-0.43577858805656433,
-0.18469005823135376,
0.5560018420219421,
-0.12727952003479004,
-0.03801684081554413,
0.4986017942428589,
-0.32741251587867737,
-0.11627110093832016,
0.9623342156410217,
0.10753612220287323,
0.27680736780166626,
-0.07928050309419632,
0.3280240595340729,
-0.07311008125543594,
-0.8529952764511108,
-0.1870066225528717,
0.13790149986743927,
-0.4524826109409332,
-0.09839195013046265,
-0.5862073302268982,
-0.05580868571996689,
-0.5861040353775024,
-0.027902347967028618,
-0.41066181659698486,
-0.26362666487693787,
0.10444406419992447,
-0.16199778020381927,
0.4085727035999298,
0.9056081771850586,
-0.2670082747936249,
0.25010085105895996,
-0.21354880928993225,
0.4932774305343628,
0.3921958804130554,
0.43378129601478577,
-0.025305621325969696,
-0.7929689288139343,
0.13296186923980713,
-0.1077984943985939,
-0.39523565769195557,
-0.9119126200675964,
0.3826684057712555,
-0.07140135765075684,
0.16117021441459656,
0.18652275204658508,
-0.033267516642808914,
0.5734593868255615,
-0.3891464173793793,
0.8106421828269958,
-0.0025653503835201263,
-0.778226912021637,
0.492941290140152,
-0.45213547348976135,
-0.2222868800163269,
0.62449049949646,
0.4476950168609619,
-0.6479902863502502,
-0.7697804570198059,
-0.670670747756958,
-0.7292746901512146,
0.6322265863418579,
0.13405729830265045,
0.04461279511451721,
-0.07752669602632523,
0.12827298045158386,
0.22330918908119202,
0.10778819769620895,
-1.0552960634231567,
-0.35475340485572815,
-0.13102960586547852,
-0.17805172502994537,
-0.054805394262075424,
-0.3862079977989197,
-0.28313231468200684,
-0.3189462125301361,
0.6665850877761841,
-0.05282704532146454,
0.17612546682357788,
0.11186251789331436,
-0.17780953645706177,
0.08071713894605637,
0.39552927017211914,
0.5370953679084778,
0.5247498750686646,
-0.25260138511657715,
0.15384076535701752,
0.2697932720184326,
-0.37128910422325134,
0.25690412521362305,
0.11241533607244492,
-0.41717034578323364,
0.05290085822343826,
0.13735495507717133,
0.5874800086021423,
0.06983520835638046,
-0.7394762635231018,
0.5903438925743103,
0.16079497337341309,
-0.3136785626411438,
-0.5037913918495178,
0.20328976213932037,
0.16137519478797913,
-0.08858831971883774,
0.06596080958843231,
-0.11963649839162827,
0.29883965849876404,
-0.3001740574836731,
0.58319491147995,
0.4050307273864746,
-0.4749813973903656,
-0.2909221649169922,
0.6500310301780701,
0.2264898717403412,
-0.36881911754608154,
0.6129675507545471,
-0.513258695602417,
-0.6838980913162231,
0.674231231212616,
0.5673809051513672,
0.7165257930755615,
-0.29419487714767456,
0.5512277483940125,
0.32984793186187744,
0.6739392280578613,
0.21549798548221588,
0.09470684081315994,
0.24070368707180023,
-0.8268629908561707,
-0.3995298445224762,
-0.7711288928985596,
-0.4083852767944336,
0.9243316054344177,
-0.39281290769577026,
0.07181891053915024,
-0.6254065632820129,
0.1364777386188507,
0.23684817552566528,
-0.3558034896850586,
-0.522510290145874,
0.3606579303741455,
0.5140659809112549,
0.6990230679512024,
-1.1150277853012085,
0.5737239718437195,
0.3867066204547882,
-0.22946293652057648,
-0.6248160600662231,
-0.1344021111726761,
0.4537275433540344,
-0.9248915910720825,
0.6305001378059387,
0.24712470173835754,
-0.09029998630285263,
-0.07123289257287979,
-0.7503207921981812,
-0.35133126378059387,
0.3419577479362488,
0.5697064399719238,
-0.496295690536499,
0.10446278005838394,
0.28913387656211853,
0.6100594997406006,
-0.35903483629226685,
0.42402538657188416,
0.7301204204559326,
0.42956283688545227,
-0.16705761849880219,
-0.7534869909286499,
0.1076769009232521,
-0.06373171508312225,
-0.25019222497940063,
0.14992700517177582,
-0.3348686099052429,
0.7317326664924622,
-0.01142728328704834,
-0.03959646821022034,
-0.2220785766839981,
0.2838085889816284,
0.13517965376377106,
0.26066142320632935,
0.8228669166564941,
0.8115444779396057,
0.6411916017532349,
-0.02048790268599987,
1.1515783071517944,
0.3366663455963135,
0.34793803095817566,
1.2502970695495605,
-0.3607434928417206,
0.5380406379699707,
0.22913500666618347,
-0.2641437351703644,
0.2532094717025757,
0.4417372941970825,
-0.3704473376274109,
0.0709262564778328,
0.8553361296653748,
-0.36121857166290283,
-0.36416351795196533,
-0.17927750945091248,
-0.07141479849815369,
0.40770184993743896,
0.18224602937698364,
-0.16731074452400208,
-0.5137202739715576,
0.036625273525714874,
0.16780522465705872,
0.176808163523674,
-0.023867333307862282,
0.37909433245658875,
-0.1296335905790329,
-0.5152128338813782,
0.6953989267349243,
-0.013685664162039757,
1.0263071060180664,
-0.5836406350135803,
0.23229381442070007,
-0.26194247603416443,
0.07897710800170898,
-0.1521948277950287,
-0.3976244628429413,
0.531671404838562,
0.31308645009994507,
0.019737210124731064,
0.05714168772101402,
0.6425107717514038,
-0.3730635344982147,
-0.23170097172260284,
0.44446924328804016,
0.26474425196647644,
0.2943088114261627,
-0.45482683181762695,
-0.8542906641960144,
0.256604939699173,
0.28757044672966003,
-0.1222241148352623,
0.4599757194519043,
-0.12358243763446808,
0.15896284580230713,
0.5706251263618469,
0.6654173731803894,
0.2305169701576233,
0.3747183680534363,
0.3287285566329956,
0.6097575426101685,
-0.49683016538619995,
-0.2879072427749634,
-0.8524384498596191,
0.37570512294769287,
-0.18937815725803375,
-0.5180755853652954,
0.4999265670776367,
0.542087197303772,
1.0762518644332886,
-0.023547779768705368,
1.0558747053146362,
-0.14359019696712494,
0.8829309940338135,
-0.07433497905731201,
0.6689260601997375,
-0.4866027235984802,
-0.19782401621341705,
-0.3371976613998413,
-0.5540973544120789,
-0.4037092924118042,
0.5273969769477844,
-0.25890976190567017,
-0.0008581280708312988,
0.6267454028129578,
1.1019545793533325,
-0.3670010566711426,
0.19719654321670532,
0.548113226890564,
0.48509544134140015,
0.5861920714378357,
0.512039303779602,
0.855532705783844,
-0.38567054271698,
0.5606585144996643,
-0.25004005432128906,
-0.15416938066482544,
-0.16732348501682281,
-0.7387445569038391,
-0.9814424514770508,
-0.3635461926460266,
-0.5825890302658081,
-0.6145590543746948,
0.03136693313717842,
0.7140891551971436,
0.47026339173316956,
-1.0089600086212158,
-0.12849129736423492,
-0.0860954001545906,
0.06494764238595963,
0.15196764469146729,
-0.30457982420921326,
-0.10669489949941635,
-0.3196469247341156,
-0.5313974022865295,
0.5212727785110474,
0.08048136532306671,
0.09225699305534363,
-0.10653096437454224,
0.18442143499851227,
-0.15514709055423737,
0.14832249283790588,
0.5746822357177734,
0.3861086368560791,
-0.7877290844917297,
-0.5294369459152222,
-0.33550822734832764,
-0.03680824115872383,
-0.02149384841322899,
1.147252082824707,
-0.3821216821670532,
0.31915611028671265,
0.12118255347013474,
0.8924742341041565,
0.3596659302711487,
-0.28654345870018005,
0.4259585738182068,
-0.5416146516799927,
0.1775790899991989,
0.45594722032546997,
0.12392590939998627,
0.40735623240470886,
-0.23716285824775696,
0.4283473491668701,
0.4831199049949646,
-0.40831050276756287,
-1.2233729362487793,
0.5578985810279846,
-0.7407402992248535,
-0.1387663036584854,
1.1329234838485718,
-0.08071303367614746,
-0.1287565380334854,
-0.37929755449295044,
-0.0754731297492981,
0.09732509404420853,
-0.25442132353782654,
0.9602082967758179,
0.8191691637039185,
-0.06322824209928513,
0.05647898092865944,
-0.6747075915336609,
0.7864832282066345,
0.5740242004394531,
-0.8595641851425171,
0.34925180673599243,
0.5929386615753174,
0.6553829908370972,
-0.051721714437007904,
0.7140388488769531,
-0.12553533911705017,
0.13975638151168823,
-0.09959060698747635,
0.20868273079395294,
-0.15808206796646118,
0.020448332652449608,
-0.343578964471817,
0.3097588121891022,
0.004599353298544884,
0.11104319989681244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15220v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15220v2
|
ChunkAttention: Efficient Self-Attention with Prefix-Aware KV Cache and Two-Phase Partition
| 2024-02-23T09:29:19 | 2024-03-22T09:03:10 |
Lu Ye, Ze Tao, Yong Huang, Yang Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Self-attention is an essential component of large language models(LLMs) but a
significant source of inference latency for long sequences. In multi-tenant
LLMs serving scenarios, the compute and memory operation cost of self-attention
can be optimized by using the probability that multiple LLM requests have
shared system prompts in prefixes. In this paper, we introduce ChunkAttention,
a prefix-aware self-attention module that can detect matching prompt prefixes
across multiple requests and share their key/value tensors in memory at runtime
to improve the memory utilization of KV cache. This is achieved by breaking
monolithic key/value tensors into smaller chunks and structuring them into the
auxiliary prefix tree. Consequently, on top of the prefix-tree based KV cache,
we design an efficient self-attention kernel, where a two-phase partition
algorithm is implemented to improve the data locality during self-attention
computation in the presence of shared system prompts. Experiments show that
ChunkAttention can speed up the self-attention kernel by 3.2-4.8$\times$
compared to the start-of-the-art implementation, with the length of the system
prompt ranging from 1024 to 4096.
|
[
-0.41754743456840515,
-0.5577906370162964,
0.666623055934906,
1.0322662591934204,
-0.443057656288147,
0.07822585105895996,
0.0406775176525116,
-0.27136293053627014,
0.6748133897781372,
0.2583974003791809,
-0.5939046740531921,
0.03489947319030762,
-0.2536899149417877,
-0.03889522701501846,
-0.4370121657848358,
0.3293784558773041,
-0.009246920235455036,
-0.12343396991491318,
-0.4652567207813263,
-0.05280555039644241,
-1.001093864440918,
-0.19527791440486908,
-0.5015293955802917,
0.2101527452468872,
0.6162042021751404,
0.6100682616233826,
0.21061822772026062,
1.0748965740203857,
0.33702826499938965,
0.3702884614467621,
0.12640394270420074,
-0.10052429139614105,
-0.4296776354312897,
0.7788436412811279,
-0.15591742098331451,
-0.2564738094806671,
-0.4004485011100769,
-0.4294746518135071,
0.8288137316703796,
-0.17657968401908875,
0.010735410265624523,
0.1935618668794632,
0.14065583050251007,
0.6167016625404358,
-0.8346837759017944,
-0.032724760472774506,
-0.5799422860145569,
0.03510894253849983,
-0.3517526686191559,
-0.10610910505056381,
-0.41020092368125916,
0.03640913963317871,
0.13308852910995483,
-0.4784560799598694,
0.3561539649963379,
0.14314895868301392,
0.5414789915084839,
0.6017584204673767,
-0.04356984421610832,
0.12716397643089294,
-0.22312086820602417,
0.7906690239906311,
-0.33397600054740906,
0.6211254596710205,
0.3831198811531067,
0.02973424270749092,
-0.1848461925983429,
-0.623607873916626,
-0.42362135648727417,
0.1869700700044632,
-0.14278313517570496,
-0.006209154147654772,
0.052587829530239105,
0.057974353432655334,
-0.14959502220153809,
0.3071906566619873,
-0.6204695105552673,
0.08874251693487167,
-0.2109958380460739,
-0.5044703483581543,
0.37083011865615845,
0.3919219672679901,
0.19166240096092224,
-0.4529833495616913,
-0.6563365459442139,
0.04403341934084892,
-0.5602515935897827,
-0.26838159561157227,
-0.045217365026474,
0.23829801380634308,
0.026373177766799927,
0.1456744372844696,
-0.3990335762500763,
0.5465173125267029,
0.2723725736141205,
-0.10429622232913971,
-0.0473460927605629,
-0.7097207903862,
-0.09485573321580887,
0.4226171374320984,
0.7341533899307251,
0.126853346824646,
-0.20047050714492798,
-0.2489144504070282,
-0.10522973537445068,
-0.1090196967124939,
0.5672850012779236,
-1.0488346815109253,
-0.22054123878479004,
0.48416784405708313,
-0.28802892565727234,
-0.14259080588817596,
-0.37584903836250305,
-0.7643872499465942,
-0.17233969271183014,
-0.11220862716436386,
0.36808690428733826,
-0.48041149973869324,
-0.029007313773036003,
-0.150937020778656,
0.15030130743980408,
0.2605610191822052,
0.4038189649581909,
-1.0372705459594727,
0.28497034311294556,
0.8604913353919983,
1.1079105138778687,
-0.5184025168418884,
-0.46341049671173096,
-0.7151608467102051,
0.14006835222244263,
-0.05792851001024246,
0.9328224658966064,
-0.22772279381752014,
-0.17434586584568024,
-0.44806212186813354,
-0.1537976861000061,
-0.08455639332532883,
-0.5187980532646179,
0.0757431834936142,
-0.6960911154747009,
-0.2990476191043854,
-0.3446577489376068,
-0.47924232482910156,
0.02734294906258583,
0.4029895067214966,
-0.6347390413284302,
1.3737447261810303,
0.08503665030002594,
-0.5937725305557251,
0.2332526445388794,
-0.4251458942890167,
-0.5669649243354797,
0.43670186400413513,
0.060085706412792206,
-0.3455059230327606,
0.30070629715919495,
0.2825392186641693,
0.5320755839347839,
-0.1716862916946411,
0.18111839890480042,
-0.2463241070508957,
-0.0550544410943985,
0.06515490263700485,
-0.14803825318813324,
0.025056736543774605,
0.34639260172843933,
-0.29105570912361145,
0.18444237112998962,
-0.5802308917045593,
0.19459150731563568,
0.07116202265024185,
-0.08335478603839874,
-0.46900177001953125,
0.05931439250707626,
-0.12909553945064545,
0.15891322493553162,
0.5270248651504517,
-0.48457998037338257,
0.22229568660259247,
-0.1868475377559662,
0.2310609221458435,
0.8600388169288635,
-0.16283512115478516,
0.3218644857406616,
0.22897858917713165,
0.40550634264945984,
0.35463279485702515,
0.2173478901386261,
-0.6668640375137329,
-0.14206072688102722,
-1.1259057521820068,
-0.7670876383781433,
0.505064070224762,
0.07307178527116776,
-0.413839727640152,
0.302562952041626,
-0.10810749232769012,
-0.12077600508928299,
-0.888816773891449,
0.10991977155208588,
0.5527182221412659,
0.3674587607383728,
0.40846720337867737,
-0.5707529783248901,
-0.41162604093551636,
-1.0157055854797363,
-0.0635334774851799,
-0.04597624018788338,
0.2769531309604645,
0.2255774289369583,
0.1251228153705597,
0.1273566037416458,
1.206708312034607,
-0.7157518267631531,
-0.2568906545639038,
0.02455362118780613,
0.11606477200984955,
-0.3678940236568451,
0.4015919864177704,
0.022280095145106316,
-0.39579445123672485,
-0.7132779359817505,
-0.3839874565601349,
-0.2791331112384796,
-0.3581843376159668,
-0.06831304728984833,
-0.16327796876430511,
0.2503521144390106,
0.40914878249168396,
-0.3086105287075043,
0.23503488302230835,
0.41761672496795654,
-0.5813457369804382,
0.5516042113304138,
-0.17006288468837738,
-0.06046976149082184,
-1.1027464866638184,
-0.20105983316898346,
-0.2694528102874756,
-0.5992497205734253,
-0.6440792083740234,
0.173747256398201,
0.3741001784801483,
0.2894187569618225,
-0.505725622177124,
0.7085075378417969,
-0.6873736381530762,
-0.30220139026641846,
-0.4397750794887543,
0.10976190119981766,
0.0284995436668396,
0.4854103624820709,
-0.1351361870765686,
1.0750293731689453,
0.5217918157577515,
-0.7291280031204224,
0.08581584692001343,
0.03481366112828255,
-0.16530930995941162,
0.659011960029602,
-0.4703230559825897,
0.29539424180984497,
-0.07905776053667068,
0.09213666617870331,
-1.1520276069641113,
-0.20060010254383087,
0.07996063679456711,
-0.06638611853122711,
0.39730891585350037,
-0.002710925415158272,
-0.5409871339797974,
-0.2068563550710678,
-0.38924720883369446,
0.9939075112342834,
0.17836546897888184,
-0.8355347514152527,
0.5016605257987976,
0.2434016317129135,
-0.23498891294002533,
-0.3905709981918335,
-0.3545934557914734,
0.007480866741389036,
-0.11804419010877609,
-0.7212390899658203,
0.22587795555591583,
-0.009770494885742664,
0.28351858258247375,
0.029651593416929245,
-0.24801459908485413,
-0.1427321583032608,
0.19212985038757324,
0.3444235026836395,
-0.06084220111370087,
-0.06366001069545746,
0.3880922794342041,
0.007213050499558449,
-0.3032575845718384,
-0.13608385622501373,
-0.5030487179756165,
1.0644161701202393,
0.012896295636892319,
-0.3737255334854126,
-0.4868949353694916,
0.37945061922073364,
0.5698140859603882,
-0.3505015969276428,
0.4704083204269409,
0.5167360901832581,
-0.039198316633701324,
-0.18316635489463806,
-1.0307347774505615,
-0.45538392663002014,
-0.5204573273658752,
0.3679881989955902,
-0.45323681831359863,
-1.2428301572799683,
0.621630072593689,
0.20520807802677155,
-0.32844099402427673,
0.3652452230453491,
0.7115728855133057,
0.016801586374640465,
0.5891010761260986,
0.1941501349210739,
-0.497005820274353,
0.43790215253829956,
0.10665580630302429,
0.12301386892795563,
-1.1646897792816162,
-0.27707430720329285,
-0.41512903571128845,
-0.5837646722793579,
-0.3418346047401428,
-0.9495013356208801,
0.26908543705940247,
-0.25276145339012146,
-0.0017073833150789142,
0.2522244453430176,
-0.678291916847229,
0.5525199174880981,
0.538605272769928,
-0.14873716235160828,
0.12105339020490646,
-0.15221744775772095,
-0.22813348472118378,
-0.1272430121898651,
-0.5516853928565979,
0.16940708458423615,
0.5483003854751587,
0.35682758688926697,
0.7495710849761963,
-0.18445606529712677,
0.8311691284179688,
0.3350946009159088,
-0.0733281672000885,
-0.9051540493965149,
0.5986684560775757,
0.3547770082950592,
-0.6341802477836609,
-0.3370714783668518,
-0.3666999638080597,
-0.925807535648346,
0.5211408734321594,
0.5151711106300354,
-0.9781922698020935,
0.08013317734003067,
0.2991965413093567,
-0.4559275209903717,
-0.0027991251554340124,
-0.5414592623710632,
0.8511272072792053,
-0.11725471913814545,
-0.40412473678588867,
-0.5817925930023193,
-0.7134262323379517,
0.3537401854991913,
-0.16476739943027496,
-0.1752021163702011,
-0.237551748752594,
-0.07884661108255386,
0.7402923107147217,
-0.5298587083816528,
0.7534797191619873,
-0.09088552743196487,
0.012291681952774525,
0.39381101727485657,
0.29576215147972107,
0.6598523259162903,
0.017692776396870613,
0.5061277151107788,
-0.07698497921228409,
0.01966901682317257,
-0.4813300371170044,
-0.48739516735076904,
0.8662710785865784,
-0.7107170224189758,
-0.5054378509521484,
-0.4495820701122284,
-0.6202121376991272,
0.015564980916678905,
0.20880812406539917,
-0.13216224312782288,
0.38431286811828613,
-0.08416620641946793,
-0.07503723353147507,
0.8422927260398865,
0.2606733441352844,
0.7649475336074829,
0.6994763612747192,
-0.17077107727527618,
-0.4824884235858917,
1.1892445087432861,
0.12629520893096924,
0.28526559472084045,
0.19773982465267181,
0.15555061399936676,
-0.30826300382614136,
-0.26664113998413086,
-0.3800579011440277,
0.3740994334220886,
-0.3027806878089905,
-0.5617745518684387,
-1.0232332944869995,
-0.08818648755550385,
-0.2293286770582199,
-0.00979182031005621,
-0.8658965826034546,
-0.47962507605552673,
-0.2781446576118469,
0.1482066959142685,
0.4360464811325073,
0.46230727434158325,
0.0053915344178676605,
0.682147204875946,
-0.7744173407554626,
0.24570134282112122,
0.5148863196372986,
0.522967517375946,
0.4263758957386017,
-0.2970632314682007,
-0.4164663851261139,
-0.5624787211418152,
-0.41054144501686096,
-0.8117930293083191,
0.4077438712120056,
-0.07026287913322449,
0.07501809298992157,
0.6197893619537354,
-0.09204358607530594,
0.9687278270721436,
-0.6186795830726624,
0.7293322682380676,
0.18880857527256012,
-1.038326382637024,
0.2599409222602844,
-0.0013679283438250422,
0.7752255201339722,
0.8492664694786072,
-0.02538822405040264,
-0.8750901222229004,
-0.4044536054134369,
-0.4683414697647095,
-0.9976705312728882,
1.192717432975769,
-0.027363132685422897,
-0.042183201760053635,
-0.185358926653862,
0.33764970302581787,
-0.06999675184488297,
0.06855003535747528,
-0.34204402565956116,
-0.3184114098548889,
0.07724688202142715,
-0.0840754583477974,
0.3228773772716522,
-0.7760385274887085,
0.18779592216014862,
-0.15352973341941833,
0.6487345695495605,
-0.26829105615615845,
0.503986656665802,
0.41767221689224243,
-0.19409631192684174,
-0.06060028076171875,
0.28936463594436646,
0.6299270987510681,
0.15957783162593842,
0.06584767997264862,
0.5219185948371887,
0.3135839104652405,
-0.6979526877403259,
0.4603228271007538,
-0.016544168815016747,
-0.21161876618862152,
-0.22681334614753723,
-0.13679452240467072,
0.7422965168952942,
0.3741399645805359,
-0.27232626080513,
0.3124524652957916,
-0.25003477931022644,
0.1598791480064392,
0.11131245642900467,
-0.1000601053237915,
0.24303361773490906,
0.23304899036884308,
0.14083974063396454,
-0.5606398582458496,
0.23182770609855652,
-0.06569897383451462,
0.23017194867134094,
0.41086477041244507,
-0.528105616569519,
-0.46875742077827454,
0.3850187361240387,
0.14699096977710724,
-0.12751619517803192,
0.7058472037315369,
-0.35119014978408813,
-0.7724405527114868,
0.43457889556884766,
0.7384721636772156,
1.2736519575119019,
-0.8960197567939758,
0.10928583890199661,
0.17921267449855804,
0.15685424208641052,
0.09293875843286514,
0.4359147250652313,
-0.46326297521591187,
-0.48216137290000916,
-0.602746844291687,
-0.8986383676528931,
0.04230660945177078,
-0.04813041165471077,
-0.3564780056476593,
0.04747118428349495,
-0.2787240445613861,
0.014322110451757908,
-0.2998732626438141,
-0.12236843258142471,
-0.44928374886512756,
0.10899361968040466,
0.13167421519756317,
0.7648261189460754,
-0.5655743479728699,
0.7934337854385376,
0.32648470997810364,
0.22202268242835999,
-0.8972225785255432,
-0.038103118538856506,
-0.06425629556179047,
-0.8592971563339233,
0.6660516858100891,
0.42226988077163696,
-0.0015093652764335275,
-0.008507099002599716,
-0.18024291098117828,
-1.3398597240447998,
0.9906297922134399,
-0.001153807621449232,
-0.5504952073097229,
0.14743152260780334,
0.1717066913843155,
0.12479030340909958,
-0.197929248213768,
0.4924541413784027,
0.611212432384491,
0.5681447386741638,
0.2663678228855133,
-0.8758760094642639,
0.4101186990737915,
0.16824322938919067,
0.0024324997793883085,
0.7294178605079651,
-1.325840711593628,
0.5094553828239441,
0.13526910543441772,
-0.2603476643562317,
-0.17883244156837463,
1.2291309833526611,
0.18319155275821686,
0.2038661241531372,
0.682792603969574,
0.963965117931366,
0.45989152789115906,
0.01839158870279789,
0.6753281950950623,
-0.6273380517959595,
0.31465083360671997,
1.1871774196624756,
-0.24943222105503082,
0.65870600938797,
0.7200350165367126,
-0.12665197253227234,
0.2659587562084198,
0.5319633483886719,
0.1947966068983078,
0.7896612882614136,
0.3487248718738556,
-0.4624137282371521,
-0.30166205763816833,
-0.26104408502578735,
-0.19330264627933502,
0.4198865294456482,
0.2794957160949707,
-0.11270572245121002,
-0.37445488572120667,
-0.23869474232196808,
0.13273704051971436,
-0.7244768738746643,
-0.19369426369667053,
0.9828662872314453,
0.12147241085767746,
-1.042102336883545,
0.3176751136779785,
0.052873797714710236,
0.3323867619037628,
-0.6326019167900085,
0.2651907205581665,
-0.25012484192848206,
0.10609439015388489,
-0.06789136677980423,
-0.3792862594127655,
0.13185691833496094,
-0.16407154500484467,
-0.34976881742477417,
-0.17710760235786438,
0.860314130783081,
-0.5349246263504028,
-0.11424357444047928,
0.15084701776504517,
0.2612585723400116,
0.2246789187192917,
-0.3215845227241516,
-0.3446969985961914,
0.3107861280441284,
-0.1533816158771515,
-0.3690583407878876,
0.6746756434440613,
0.3632763922214508,
-0.060170046985149384,
0.7082453966140747,
0.30483224987983704,
-0.16039948165416718,
0.4357929527759552,
-0.21720068156719208,
1.083916425704956,
-0.6027543544769287,
-0.9029290676116943,
-1.0248202085494995,
0.3691270649433136,
0.09727910906076431,
-0.0894780382514,
0.7861654758453369,
0.7684977650642395,
0.3022717237472534,
0.1579073667526245,
0.5029708743095398,
0.04918587580323219,
-0.02904658205807209,
-0.38140669465065,
0.3679088056087494,
-0.4928915202617645,
-0.1535831093788147,
0.07312466949224472,
-0.9736025333404541,
-0.052286628633737564,
0.1961241513490677,
-0.03707229718565941,
-0.09444836527109146,
0.9016987681388855,
0.7821095585823059,
-0.20575569570064545,
0.02841179631650448,
0.29481807351112366,
0.19072753190994263,
0.2631136178970337,
0.27670028805732727,
0.7876759767532349,
-0.09806486964225769,
0.13319368660449982,
-0.1718592345714569,
-0.021871188655495644,
-0.42749857902526855,
-0.7629920244216919,
-0.5831850171089172,
-0.5912584662437439,
-0.302766889333725,
-0.25272437930107117,
0.039368268102407455,
0.8771430253982544,
0.9658260941505432,
-0.6591103672981262,
-0.08618992567062378,
0.0022751379292458296,
0.10909021645784378,
0.10674917697906494,
-0.26935938000679016,
0.5222144722938538,
-0.9140174984931946,
-0.4170936942100525,
0.5725888609886169,
0.8320186734199524,
-0.14520078897476196,
-0.6984157562255859,
0.06439587473869324,
-0.09042340517044067,
0.185829758644104,
0.5444920063018799,
0.12338446080684662,
-0.6615462303161621,
-0.3092662990093231,
0.08825483173131943,
-0.20473282039165497,
0.30462196469306946,
0.9506776928901672,
-0.8325012922286987,
0.7691101431846619,
0.6288161277770996,
0.7388558983802795,
0.8297692537307739,
0.26075509190559387,
0.303724080324173,
-1.1271089315414429,
0.035201676189899445,
0.09655072540044785,
0.2505590617656708,
0.3131130635738373,
-0.5247058272361755,
0.19829636812210083,
0.2056409865617752,
-0.84056556224823,
-0.510576605796814,
0.1887986958026886,
-1.029489278793335,
-0.09516143053770065,
1.0916262865066528,
0.026334060356020927,
-0.7603620290756226,
-0.15034382045269012,
-0.1421932727098465,
-0.06584609299898148,
-0.8456991314888,
0.8137730956077576,
0.7619867324829102,
-0.10402113944292068,
-0.1089303195476532,
-0.19198933243751526,
0.3751731216907501,
0.9678958654403687,
-0.7411206960678101,
0.23245006799697876,
0.38920584321022034,
0.19483229517936707,
0.2741418778896332,
0.8232849836349487,
0.16371910274028778,
0.15044115483760834,
-0.2538699507713318,
0.3094387948513031,
0.08772064745426178,
-0.7428666949272156,
-0.34968751668930054,
0.19322574138641357,
-0.0001038360787788406,
-0.4594496786594391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15218v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15218v1
|
BSPA: Exploring Black-box Stealthy Prompt Attacks against Image Generators
| 2024-02-23T09:28:16 | 2024-02-23T09:28:16 |
Yu Tian, Xiao Yang, Yinpeng Dong, Heming Yang, Hang Su, Jun Zhu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Extremely large image generators offer significant transformative potential
across diverse sectors. It allows users to design specific prompts to generate
realistic images through some black-box APIs. However, some studies reveal that
image generators are notably susceptible to attacks and generate Not Suitable
For Work (NSFW) contents by manually designed toxin texts, especially
imperceptible to human observers. We urgently need a multitude of universal and
transferable prompts to improve the safety of image generators, especially
black-box-released APIs. Nevertheless, they are constrained by labor-intensive
design processes and heavily reliant on the quality of the given instructions.
To achieve this, we introduce a black-box stealthy prompt attack (BSPA) that
adopts a retriever to simulate attacks from API users. It can effectively
harness filter scores to tune the retrieval space of sensitive words for
matching the input prompts, thereby crafting stealthy prompts tailored for
image generators. Significantly, this approach is model-agnostic and requires
no internal access to the model's features, ensuring its applicability to a
wide range of image generators. Building on BSPA, we have constructed an
automated prompt tool and a comprehensive prompt attack dataset (NSFWeval).
Extensive experiments demonstrate that BSPA effectively explores the security
vulnerabilities in a variety of state-of-the-art available black-box models,
including Stable Diffusion XL, Midjourney, and DALL-E 2/3. Furthermore, we
develop a resilient text filter and offer targeted recommendations to ensure
the security of image generators against prompt attacks in the future.
|
[
-0.399799108505249,
-0.8575834035873413,
0.6313413977622986,
0.33886852860450745,
-0.4552624821662903,
0.17239059507846832,
0.3155324161052704,
-0.7973676323890686,
-0.018563322722911835,
0.5424531102180481,
-0.6663825511932373,
-0.1792646199464798,
-0.46820637583732605,
0.42743825912475586,
-0.26728910207748413,
0.5558321475982666,
0.29618147015571594,
-0.18476270139217377,
0.17225416004657745,
0.07743579149246216,
-0.9541967511177063,
-0.23735275864601135,
-0.7950536608695984,
0.19861841201782227,
0.46263206005096436,
-0.27492791414260864,
0.6342200040817261,
0.1827039271593094,
0.21664127707481384,
0.2268865555524826,
-0.14568758010864258,
-0.02391272783279419,
-0.46262869238853455,
0.5969876646995544,
-0.442973256111145,
-0.08647093921899796,
0.0607636421918869,
-0.21592643857002258,
0.4551471173763275,
0.35247647762298584,
0.24775974452495575,
0.2955762445926666,
-0.17356623709201813,
0.39306411147117615,
-0.820296049118042,
-0.11399244517087936,
-0.7085586786270142,
0.18534520268440247,
-0.0781572237610817,
-0.4291440546512604,
-0.6921203136444092,
-0.33792242407798767,
-0.1066671833395958,
-0.37091267108917236,
0.18272645771503448,
0.35999733209609985,
0.9225619435310364,
0.4029460847377777,
-0.2442643791437149,
-0.0427347831428051,
-0.5546256303787231,
0.6046908497810364,
-0.34226712584495544,
0.0516001395881176,
0.318034291267395,
0.41634875535964966,
-0.4962078630924225,
-0.62660151720047,
-0.36605632305145264,
-0.16491346061229706,
-0.051954805850982666,
0.04356171190738678,
-0.8067171573638916,
0.045275140553712845,
0.5519334673881531,
0.04610346257686615,
-0.66169673204422,
0.04864673316478729,
-0.3247493505477905,
-0.470709890127182,
0.49474284052848816,
0.2069149762392044,
0.3705201745033264,
-0.31444838643074036,
-0.5592702031135559,
0.04592393338680267,
-0.7974151372909546,
0.22150275111198425,
0.6334545612335205,
0.13022834062576294,
-0.07843254506587982,
0.4189825654029846,
-0.19115999341011047,
0.8037593960762024,
0.1756342053413391,
0.2881421148777008,
-0.17192329466342926,
-0.2264029085636139,
-0.03203190118074417,
-0.12528792023658752,
1.0551444292068481,
0.3459542989730835,
-0.2531983256340027,
-0.27272534370422363,
-0.40711572766304016,
0.16345418989658356,
0.5172510743141174,
-1.2316339015960693,
-0.250424325466156,
0.3050932288169861,
-0.6206175684928894,
-0.619435727596283,
-0.05302399769425392,
-1.0837671756744385,
-0.5744282007217407,
0.2562413215637207,
0.4167410731315613,
-0.39246657490730286,
-0.15409553050994873,
-0.11395983397960663,
-0.5090389251708984,
0.2877386212348938,
0.19003568589687347,
-0.37603339552879333,
-0.13411003351211548,
0.40254274010658264,
0.8869625329971313,
0.12256976962089539,
-0.07149773091077805,
-0.801717221736908,
0.10012773424386978,
-0.4880843460559845,
0.9735586643218994,
-0.576043426990509,
-0.8119853734970093,
0.09794937074184418,
0.16883863508701324,
0.455078125,
-0.12796224653720856,
0.3209553062915802,
-0.6492293477058411,
-0.05162316933274269,
-0.35429146885871887,
-0.12883275747299194,
0.17381173372268677,
0.24035248160362244,
-0.7127074003219604,
0.7906457185745239,
-0.018023332580924034,
-0.7008811831474304,
0.2153632789850235,
-0.5810210704803467,
-0.11631745100021362,
0.41479456424713135,
-0.23457929491996765,
-0.26425278186798096,
0.3993476331233978,
0.10002531856298447,
0.3369843363761902,
-0.05460771173238754,
-0.03232729434967041,
-0.525046706199646,
-0.5709884762763977,
0.5868291854858398,
-0.5400990843772888,
0.913263738155365,
0.36403530836105347,
-0.3077862858772278,
-0.01854855753481388,
-0.7353875041007996,
-0.032011862844228745,
0.3169308304786682,
0.12452054023742676,
-0.2906947731971741,
-0.34794577956199646,
0.07655823975801468,
0.24431400001049042,
0.19173982739448547,
-0.8117032051086426,
0.10029885172843933,
-0.1314878910779953,
0.19700147211551666,
1.0757917165756226,
0.6467869281768799,
0.1564767211675644,
0.025619594380259514,
0.8675611615180969,
-0.414887934923172,
0.36757493019104004,
-0.6833738684654236,
-0.8265329599380493,
0.3533531427383423,
-0.6203000545501709,
0.23468439280986786,
0.4223496913909912,
-0.8924079537391663,
0.3645269274711609,
0.3121747374534607,
-0.5709145069122314,
-0.460178405046463,
-0.06419187039136887,
0.6936183571815491,
0.695175051689148,
0.25339046120643616,
-0.4159785211086273,
-0.14829950034618378,
-0.6485969424247742,
-0.18020617961883545,
0.0039174314588308334,
-0.16558483242988586,
0.23846106231212616,
0.18671700358390808,
-0.42027637362480164,
0.7957693934440613,
-0.7623134255409241,
-0.07817894965410233,
0.14239740371704102,
0.15085536241531372,
0.10714052617549896,
0.47034329175949097,
1.0157476663589478,
-0.5142678618431091,
-0.22205056250095367,
-0.30720654129981995,
-0.7409569621086121,
-0.5159254670143127,
-0.29769089818000793,
-0.32763177156448364,
0.16084741055965424,
0.24082353711128235,
-0.7694922685623169,
0.7394347786903381,
0.3801153302192688,
-0.7504491806030273,
1.0409225225448608,
-0.16081903874874115,
0.04164696857333183,
-0.8625729084014893,
0.3870643377304077,
0.040369853377342224,
-0.19641321897506714,
-0.4839305877685547,
0.35382309556007385,
0.19107630848884583,
-0.8496771454811096,
-0.46273183822631836,
0.7879589796066284,
-0.4467649459838867,
-0.0002683833008632064,
-0.45076656341552734,
-0.5112158060073853,
0.2575831413269043,
0.406144380569458,
-0.00700587872415781,
0.8456053137779236,
0.8306926488876343,
-0.34672412276268005,
0.14056013524532318,
0.23813454806804657,
-0.025047995150089264,
0.9060481190681458,
-0.8302960991859436,
0.38704684376716614,
-0.044969212263822556,
0.4496691823005676,
-1.209356427192688,
-0.14682620763778687,
0.6840284466743469,
-0.551348090171814,
0.5548883676528931,
-0.48392730951309204,
-0.5555900931358337,
-0.26696017384529114,
-0.4572981595993042,
0.2835645079612732,
0.6587237119674683,
-0.728435754776001,
0.6131367683410645,
0.1414332240819931,
-0.14136867225170135,
-1.021485447883606,
-0.4940272271633148,
0.4367687702178955,
-0.009073666296899319,
-0.5542880296707153,
0.10769043862819672,
-0.2937910556793213,
0.022972291335463524,
0.06412114948034286,
-0.35794252157211304,
0.07692613452672958,
0.29334303736686707,
0.6321115493774414,
0.5153661370277405,
0.2557889223098755,
-0.5106191635131836,
0.17516066133975983,
-0.1637645959854126,
0.4514292776584625,
-0.19376547634601593,
0.5845974087715149,
0.05577820912003517,
-0.28323328495025635,
-0.7147036194801331,
0.6403757929801941,
0.36238300800323486,
-0.16639888286590576,
0.490497350692749,
0.5629550814628601,
-0.5090525150299072,
-0.3274818956851959,
-0.3850998282432556,
-0.2738303244113922,
-0.6302140951156616,
0.0013537310296669602,
-0.31088557839393616,
-0.3145805299282074,
0.595189094543457,
0.0013170602032914758,
0.2720211446285248,
-0.24001719057559967,
0.2879847288131714,
-0.19318078458309174,
1.1033836603164673,
0.37863075733184814,
0.23672504723072052,
0.59698885679245,
-0.33213043212890625,
-0.04399583861231804,
-0.6918795108795166,
-0.16716927289962769,
-0.4989265203475952,
-0.20009584724903107,
-0.2745121717453003,
-0.09092269837856293,
0.07834690809249878,
-0.17068979144096375,
0.09117045998573303,
0.3363777697086334,
-0.8226564526557922,
0.6829382181167603,
0.46809622645378113,
0.21323589980602264,
-0.20984728634357452,
-0.04501966014504433,
-0.01959913969039917,
0.22408734261989594,
-0.24606038630008698,
-0.4054870307445526,
0.9605051875114441,
0.1839742511510849,
0.9769370555877686,
-0.0792304277420044,
0.7881160378456116,
0.5312957167625427,
0.06461924314498901,
-0.40616440773010254,
0.808817982673645,
0.29970553517341614,
-0.6103395819664001,
-0.03965562582015991,
-0.37937578558921814,
-1.294578194618225,
0.14439702033996582,
-0.2707657217979431,
-0.6659848093986511,
0.5400909185409546,
0.3407273292541504,
-0.2910495400428772,
0.30220696330070496,
-0.9188912510871887,
0.7691857218742371,
-0.22317704558372498,
-0.5132078528404236,
0.08657078444957733,
-0.6939089894294739,
0.3364031910896301,
-0.20269647240638733,
0.10910758376121521,
0.0259106382727623,
-0.04036823660135269,
0.26009297370910645,
-0.3080171048641205,
0.9905017018318176,
-0.6087542176246643,
-0.049944572150707245,
0.14352554082870483,
0.5138108730316162,
0.5075160264968872,
0.2433239072561264,
0.1451546549797058,
0.4833233058452606,
-0.08454827964305878,
-0.6881083250045776,
-0.34830784797668457,
0.6133764982223511,
-0.4429713487625122,
-0.5092617869377136,
-0.5559626221656799,
-0.3519837558269501,
0.050656601786613464,
0.3636593520641327,
0.5160502195358276,
0.5277099609375,
-0.14554937183856964,
-0.15065738558769226,
0.6793449521064758,
-0.4974863827228546,
0.6322749257087708,
0.35431909561157227,
-0.041435159742832184,
-0.5118947625160217,
1.0073567628860474,
0.032821107655763626,
0.0974259003996849,
0.043946731835603714,
0.13378438353538513,
-0.46198341250419617,
-0.7657761573791504,
-0.6384752988815308,
0.10091402381658554,
-0.5781799554824829,
-0.6382392048835754,
-0.42129606008529663,
0.06495465338230133,
-0.3451811969280243,
-0.3776211440563202,
0.1758054494857788,
-0.25885382294654846,
-0.2937857508659363,
-0.038955941796302795,
0.28408578038215637,
0.45178741216659546,
-0.0035165040753781796,
0.23712007701396942,
-0.588691771030426,
0.691866934299469,
0.4141514003276825,
0.5754720568656921,
-0.10590361803770065,
-0.3166325092315674,
0.25093504786491394,
-0.33852240443229675,
-0.4953005611896515,
-1.3614743947982788,
0.4746556282043457,
-0.23311659693717957,
0.5353374481201172,
0.48068952560424805,
0.28829535841941833,
0.4724016785621643,
-0.5938006043434143,
0.9897791743278503,
0.40261125564575195,
-0.8073344826698303,
0.7331569790840149,
-0.30471426248550415,
0.16794562339782715,
0.3967810571193695,
0.03621092066168785,
-0.1079740896821022,
-0.6322608590126038,
-0.6994841694831848,
-0.7973231077194214,
0.7036454081535339,
0.17346037924289703,
0.22539055347442627,
-0.06906706839799881,
0.28800857067108154,
0.23795336484909058,
0.23377422988414764,
-0.5733497738838196,
-0.3328123688697815,
-0.6888929605484009,
0.126378133893013,
0.4207072854042053,
-0.24812723696231842,
-0.268045037984848,
0.447745144367218,
0.46553274989128113,
-0.08513505011796951,
0.24473416805267334,
0.14122942090034485,
-0.07999476790428162,
-0.29717159271240234,
0.2820936441421509,
0.16193753480911255,
0.3948613703250885,
-0.3361636698246002,
0.11775067448616028,
-0.16938023269176483,
-0.5408077239990234,
0.2878033518791199,
0.47373589873313904,
-0.6858493089675903,
0.10947743058204651,
0.05455194041132927,
0.6461453437805176,
0.10065951943397522,
-0.7834118604660034,
0.5540473461151123,
-0.4250256419181824,
0.04341806471347809,
-0.240123450756073,
0.10430371016263962,
-0.314700722694397,
0.06828996539115906,
0.7085123658180237,
0.46151429414749146,
0.327025443315506,
-0.4291752576828003,
0.06743157655000687,
0.7523230314254761,
-0.3040330111980438,
-0.5143529176712036,
0.7402802109718323,
0.17424705624580383,
-0.5114292502403259,
0.13249915838241577,
-0.5004667043685913,
-0.15533067286014557,
0.47967037558555603,
0.6638273596763611,
0.9255237579345703,
-0.4937949478626251,
0.29975003004074097,
0.22547771036624908,
0.5923574566841125,
0.10885841399431229,
0.38368040323257446,
-0.15448005497455597,
-0.15157411992549896,
-0.19616128504276276,
-0.49114689230918884,
-0.6995248794555664,
0.21492411196231842,
-0.6569002866744995,
0.24696172773838043,
-0.9661737084388733,
-0.3008919060230255,
0.12286067008972168,
-0.143092080950737,
-0.6352253556251526,
-0.03195026144385338,
0.21544459462165833,
0.9141929149627686,
-0.6861621141433716,
0.2515421211719513,
0.6419575810432434,
-0.4644245207309723,
-0.4390847086906433,
-0.06464996188879013,
-0.024709735065698624,
-0.5877730846405029,
0.12062618136405945,
0.48580750823020935,
0.04762153699994087,
-0.21282799541950226,
-0.7595013976097107,
-0.5045475959777832,
0.8817917108535767,
0.6570295095443726,
-0.29833269119262695,
0.035713355988264084,
-0.2919098436832428,
0.4121365249156952,
0.0824851244688034,
0.09737823158502579,
0.22947785258293152,
0.48506292700767517,
0.01036866195499897,
-0.207633376121521,
0.6141582727432251,
-0.37868523597717285,
-0.035126615315675735,
0.002699514850974083,
-0.4825960397720337,
0.23859867453575134,
-0.12450415641069412,
-0.4503614902496338,
0.24890413880348206,
0.41623327136039734,
0.7483615279197693,
0.7279636263847351,
0.4943715035915375,
0.38129767775535583,
0.5973360538482666,
-0.0731712132692337,
1.1245102882385254,
-0.2297206073999405,
-0.24465472996234894,
0.7774680256843567,
-0.39348673820495605,
0.5690593719482422,
0.40394291281700134,
0.14720161259174347,
0.5020695328712463,
0.6027333736419678,
-0.5797337889671326,
0.5522242188453674,
0.06388504058122635,
-0.32442185282707214,
0.04983648285269737,
-0.10857857018709183,
-0.4131125509738922,
-0.08096203953027725,
0.40959659218788147,
-0.14854033291339874,
-0.07915903627872467,
0.21765798330307007,
-0.19267971813678741,
-0.02715180441737175,
-0.34782731533050537,
0.709650993347168,
0.05851028487086296,
-0.4349641799926758,
0.4951924979686737,
-0.26124730706214905,
0.8002637624740601,
-0.7390323281288147,
-0.04162519425153732,
-0.15894947946071625,
-0.4172215461730957,
-0.1491720825433731,
-0.911665141582489,
0.18844586610794067,
0.33696281909942627,
-0.017672143876552582,
-0.20348313450813293,
1.085373878479004,
0.03098052553832531,
-0.26652470231056213,
0.2634437382221222,
0.05373908206820488,
0.08973341435194016,
-0.08818604797124863,
-0.7847184538841248,
0.19057953357696533,
-0.27562591433525085,
-0.20142802596092224,
0.43724313378334045,
0.4267520606517792,
0.016386372968554497,
0.6145899891853333,
1.0708763599395752,
0.4201626479625702,
0.20038998126983643,
-0.06496989727020264,
0.8138073086738586,
-0.659771203994751,
-0.7949920296669006,
-0.5486716628074646,
0.42528995871543884,
-0.39654913544654846,
-0.060892242938280106,
0.6176141500473022,
0.29817476868629456,
0.3415118455886841,
-0.3476133644580841,
0.8322936296463013,
-0.029284298419952393,
-0.05807296186685562,
-0.21823860704898834,
0.7023616433143616,
-0.14216457307338715,
0.23360195755958557,
-0.6710641384124756,
-0.6742684841156006,
-0.14972440898418427,
0.04950786381959915,
0.04012083634734154,
-0.3898056149482727,
0.401462584733963,
0.9839788675308228,
-0.031553592532873154,
-0.11488216370344162,
0.34224748611450195,
-0.04057538881897926,
0.6348860859870911,
0.2292882800102234,
1.1175376176834106,
-0.21023280918598175,
0.94291090965271,
-0.2884957194328308,
-0.4017898440361023,
-0.09326475858688354,
-1.0171476602554321,
-1.080273151397705,
-0.3427761197090149,
-0.33296868205070496,
-0.5430608987808228,
-0.039530664682388306,
0.47953981161117554,
0.8121746778488159,
-0.5361142754554749,
0.30999258160591125,
0.020059144124388695,
0.21047832071781158,
-0.28649482131004333,
-0.271462082862854,
0.2769533395767212,
-0.1783384084701538,
-0.3849935829639435,
0.5964608788490295,
0.3647131025791168,
0.382557213306427,
-0.2950005829334259,
0.1417141854763031,
0.3580930829048157,
0.439169704914093,
0.2500842213630676,
0.781204104423523,
-0.5810720920562744,
-0.23130469024181366,
-0.04739144816994667,
0.14815852046012878,
-0.38328033685684204,
0.6433578729629517,
-0.9142071008682251,
0.5805678367614746,
0.47653159499168396,
0.672954261302948,
0.11692795902490616,
0.09342765063047409,
0.36669495701789856,
-1.29923415184021,
0.3623116612434387,
0.12244908511638641,
0.6382594108581543,
0.4054524600505829,
-0.7553544640541077,
0.3929290473461151,
0.2631743848323822,
-0.40773066878318787,
-1.5322946310043335,
0.4272448420524597,
-1.2332124710083008,
-0.6683859825134277,
1.027047872543335,
-0.1316719502210617,
-0.4914175271987915,
-0.28302431106567383,
-0.6119872331619263,
-0.11222574859857559,
-0.8482494354248047,
1.0418813228607178,
0.2013547569513321,
0.165147602558136,
-0.15303397178649902,
-0.26199379563331604,
0.3918248414993286,
0.11782637983560562,
-0.7396976351737976,
0.23088347911834717,
0.790762186050415,
0.31245672702789307,
0.5531707406044006,
0.5551027655601501,
-0.17116178572177887,
0.778336226940155,
0.00851705763489008,
-0.06348973512649536,
-0.5368536114692688,
-0.2481308877468109,
-0.7401732206344604,
0.49834975600242615,
-0.23004300892353058,
-0.4228443503379822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15202v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15202v2
|
Fine-Grained Detoxification via Instance-Level Prefixes for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T09:04:48 | 2024-02-26T02:37:15 |
Xin Yi, Linlin Wang, Xiaoling Wang, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Impressive results have been achieved in natural language processing (NLP)
tasks through the training of large language models (LLMs). However, these
models occasionally produce toxic content such as insults, threats, and
profanity in response to certain prompts, thereby constraining their practical
utility. To tackle this issue, various finetuning-based and decoding-based
approaches have been utilized to mitigate toxicity. However, these methods
typically necessitate additional costs such as high-quality training data or
auxiliary models. In this paper, we propose fine-grained detoxification via
instance-level prefixes (FGDILP) to mitigate toxic text without additional
cost. Specifically, FGDILP contrasts the contextualized representation in
attention space using a positive prefix-prepended prompt against multiple
negative prefix-prepended prompts at the instance level. This allows for
constructing fine-grained subtoxicity vectors, which enables collaborative
detoxification by fusing them to correct the normal generation process when
provided with a raw prompt. We validate that FGDILP enables controlled text
generation with regard to toxicity at both the utterance and context levels.
Our method surpasses prompt-based baselines in detoxification, although at a
slight cost to generation fluency and diversity.
|
[
-0.41206666827201843,
-1.0460115671157837,
0.5338677763938904,
-0.1303626149892807,
-0.34360167384147644,
-0.2541957497596741,
-0.22590066492557526,
-0.3069346249103546,
-0.31970757246017456,
0.5031474828720093,
-0.40217626094818115,
-0.613860547542572,
-0.24355562031269073,
0.2224026769399643,
-0.33169326186180115,
1.192143201828003,
0.372102290391922,
-0.38550201058387756,
-0.18515732884407043,
0.13984902203083038,
-0.680655300617218,
-0.5006299018859863,
-1.1376714706420898,
-0.3346087336540222,
0.9707777500152588,
0.5702870488166809,
0.6320615410804749,
0.43029242753982544,
0.33086127042770386,
0.18263256549835205,
-0.2823992967605591,
0.14046025276184082,
-0.6157519817352295,
0.21363596618175507,
-0.6028910279273987,
-0.17686182260513306,
-0.191284641623497,
-0.01030689012259245,
0.235962375998497,
0.5538370609283447,
-0.1774633824825287,
-0.2782234847545624,
0.0938275083899498,
0.5262090563774109,
-0.7608529925346375,
-0.18725524842739105,
-0.9382915496826172,
0.16916732490062714,
-0.13938848674297333,
-0.24743014574050903,
-0.6885320544242859,
-0.14291033148765564,
-0.13295383751392365,
-0.30930888652801514,
-0.08070027828216553,
-0.16545319557189941,
0.7944405674934387,
0.456389844417572,
-0.09695549309253693,
-0.19215305149555206,
-0.696774959564209,
0.8646988272666931,
-1.1599875688552856,
0.1487976312637329,
0.3629027009010315,
-0.0005268699023872614,
-0.20834949612617493,
-0.4510628581047058,
-0.18608298897743225,
-0.2125745713710785,
-0.1544138640165329,
0.05742569640278816,
-0.31834107637405396,
0.26723581552505493,
0.24989476799964905,
0.3834398090839386,
-0.2969357371330261,
0.5873570442199707,
-0.22766856849193573,
-0.16565370559692383,
0.5014191269874573,
0.3694477081298828,
0.6095021367073059,
-0.2822554111480713,
-0.5107014775276184,
0.1076277419924736,
-0.763856828212738,
-0.1554652452468872,
0.2694889307022095,
0.7217082977294922,
0.11773684620857239,
0.35979196429252625,
-0.33285021781921387,
0.18283024430274963,
0.03297383338212967,
0.07744885981082916,
0.09463685750961304,
-0.2124495953321457,
-0.30413076281547546,
0.24187852442264557,
0.8283643126487732,
0.5488337874412537,
0.21865621209144592,
-0.36627310514450073,
-0.03499756008386612,
-0.0038821035996079445,
0.5388380885124207,
-1.2724260091781616,
-0.040312230587005615,
0.6405090093612671,
-0.2549870014190674,
-0.4682496190071106,
-0.5695673823356628,
-0.9506109952926636,
-0.4372852146625519,
-0.1151663139462471,
0.4018651843070984,
-0.7962619066238403,
-0.021689610555768013,
0.20877918601036072,
-0.07684548944234848,
-0.11385425925254822,
0.24412354826927185,
-1.029314637184143,
0.24300381541252136,
0.4488949775695801,
0.7561118006706238,
-0.20939138531684875,
0.1722772717475891,
-0.9279851317405701,
0.29882943630218506,
-0.08553149551153183,
0.7495081424713135,
-0.6237370371818542,
-0.38364243507385254,
0.03332696110010147,
-0.37585338950157166,
0.31628546118736267,
-0.7935019731521606,
0.8842105269432068,
-0.22103752195835114,
0.014955745078623295,
-0.034547802060842514,
-0.3924659192562103,
-0.018733276054263115,
0.24820256233215332,
-0.3661876320838928,
0.9569175243377686,
-0.14378231763839722,
-0.8453892469406128,
0.17552664875984192,
-0.3215453028678894,
-0.3854938745498657,
0.2920812666416168,
0.037877824157476425,
-0.2666528522968292,
0.14843131601810455,
0.13411816954612732,
0.5885964632034302,
-0.21698622405529022,
0.3692443072795868,
-0.24162453413009644,
-0.1015370562672615,
-0.2970670759677887,
-0.5987289547920227,
0.4265010356903076,
0.49599790573120117,
-0.24770058691501617,
0.3973948061466217,
-0.7033948302268982,
-0.010240267962217331,
-0.13727900385856628,
-0.3799207806587219,
-1.1458837985992432,
0.07762949913740158,
-0.06450994312763214,
0.3658393919467926,
-0.10457516461610794,
-0.45095333456993103,
-0.06577007472515106,
-0.4475468397140503,
0.36652305722236633,
0.640527069568634,
0.3234729468822479,
0.20883066952228546,
-0.28251340985298157,
0.10392352938652039,
0.36769169569015503,
0.060729365795850754,
-0.2806958854198456,
-0.36766812205314636,
-0.593174934387207,
-0.2557083070278168,
-0.11606188118457794,
0.44721347093582153,
-0.9218652844429016,
0.6632735729217529,
-0.19317463040351868,
-0.5461534857749939,
-0.011497012339532375,
-0.09010206907987595,
0.6255925893783569,
0.7806915640830994,
0.755077600479126,
-0.2908100485801697,
-0.008967584930360317,
-1.031360149383545,
-0.19201400876045227,
0.10551785677671432,
-0.370501846075058,
0.4345901310443878,
0.3309246301651001,
-0.3725806474685669,
0.8477479815483093,
-0.5831102132797241,
-0.5031830072402954,
-0.10728807747364044,
0.4938496947288513,
-0.16128842532634735,
0.6271081566810608,
0.4690742492675781,
-0.3913757801055908,
-0.17916201055049896,
-0.03353811055421829,
-0.22795706987380981,
-0.6801056861877441,
-0.5376983284950256,
-0.27964454889297485,
-0.18646034598350525,
0.652169942855835,
-0.29769420623779297,
0.2963698208332062,
0.10813207924365997,
-0.307024210691452,
0.6360973119735718,
-0.3338707387447357,
-0.13631214201450348,
-0.9041136503219604,
0.14949317276477814,
0.30827778577804565,
-0.2736090123653412,
-0.9074735045433044,
0.2664088010787964,
-0.26820793747901917,
0.021946357563138008,
-0.7831944227218628,
0.7781789898872375,
-0.17308349907398224,
0.3694817125797272,
-0.15971262753009796,
0.07839448004961014,
0.09226005524396896,
0.4979047179222107,
0.23377420008182526,
0.7383307814598083,
0.23192915320396423,
-0.6146142482757568,
-0.14277344942092896,
0.24736161530017853,
0.13706368207931519,
0.7410195469856262,
-0.6393833756446838,
-0.027357298880815506,
-0.10561122000217438,
0.15584151446819305,
-0.5908205509185791,
-0.10062527656555176,
0.2903992235660553,
0.17843875288963318,
0.18364453315734863,
0.10544083267450333,
-0.4506901204586029,
-0.12228003889322281,
-0.37155649065971375,
0.47233331203460693,
0.4843531548976898,
-0.4032822847366333,
0.0904097929596901,
0.17249996960163116,
-0.35367080569267273,
-0.08122554421424866,
-0.6972290277481079,
0.20672112703323364,
-0.593264639377594,
-0.12155012041330338,
0.20540012419223785,
-0.20957539975643158,
-0.16426166892051697,
-0.17507027089595795,
-0.12985309958457947,
-0.14673784375190735,
0.208205908536911,
0.0709323063492775,
-0.1511370837688446,
0.15859822928905487,
0.20434324443340302,
0.4497171938419342,
-0.29346925020217896,
0.05072076618671417,
0.18776506185531616,
0.7135645747184753,
-0.06205635890364647,
0.05698111653327942,
-0.3800734281539917,
0.6741493940353394,
0.49384742975234985,
-0.4512282609939575,
0.7708311676979065,
0.5377350449562073,
-0.5326285362243652,
-0.4296131730079651,
-0.23559758067131042,
-0.224164217710495,
-0.49764275550842285,
0.3032780885696411,
-0.15846067667007446,
-0.8667770624160767,
0.5073555707931519,
-0.29182663559913635,
0.005623211618512869,
0.23409102857112885,
0.6779488325119019,
0.3051685690879822,
0.8136330246925354,
0.17172469198703766,
-0.0481056347489357,
0.5587511658668518,
-0.07761479169130325,
0.1902814656496048,
-0.8768602609634399,
-0.010615124367177486,
-0.5252752900123596,
-0.17337216436862946,
-0.022622086107730865,
-0.458894282579422,
0.2943820357322693,
0.21130585670471191,
-0.5466841459274292,
0.19310884177684784,
-0.5452315211296082,
0.6544451117515564,
0.5558888912200928,
0.25741827487945557,
0.3625958263874054,
0.10255250334739685,
-0.22955210506916046,
-0.0936465859413147,
-0.4095913767814636,
-0.6790082454681396,
0.40644368529319763,
0.4152517020702362,
0.7362222075462341,
-0.0879756286740303,
0.8477252721786499,
0.22752659022808075,
0.38753190636634827,
-0.8056016564369202,
0.6503642797470093,
-0.4014352858066559,
-0.5335718989372253,
-0.21215605735778809,
-0.649600088596344,
-0.6722619533538818,
0.2664937973022461,
-0.05887153372168541,
-1.0746392011642456,
0.159979447722435,
-0.1446918398141861,
-0.6750476360321045,
0.42881688475608826,
-0.6910648345947266,
0.9541345238685608,
0.14514616131782532,
-0.5831509828567505,
-0.2572022080421448,
-0.551335871219635,
0.4722300171852112,
-0.4265112578868866,
0.34191346168518066,
-0.22933071851730347,
0.05823814496397972,
0.46096083521842957,
-0.6379901170730591,
0.8915937542915344,
-0.035142116248607635,
-0.6339249610900879,
0.28388160467147827,
0.2463599443435669,
0.39157408475875854,
0.16982589662075043,
-0.21989989280700684,
0.2333391159772873,
-0.243352010846138,
-0.07889474928379059,
-0.10724878311157227,
0.7729930281639099,
-0.3849734663963318,
-0.5288131237030029,
-0.06402334570884705,
-0.6904003620147705,
-0.22474391758441925,
0.6380162239074707,
0.1915235072374344,
0.5890488624572754,
-0.022077439352869987,
0.12369698286056519,
0.6225763559341431,
-0.8436371088027954,
0.529791533946991,
0.16381077468395233,
-0.002394252922385931,
-0.25172072649002075,
0.871656596660614,
-0.32452166080474854,
0.6897385120391846,
0.16052858531475067,
0.5268746018409729,
-0.0945572629570961,
-0.6894705891609192,
-0.16248556971549988,
0.0005820408114232123,
-0.5030874609947205,
-0.48661112785339355,
-0.6272898316383362,
-0.22379367053508759,
0.05610405653715134,
-0.28028351068496704,
-0.3273235261440277,
0.13574287295341492,
-0.6323180198669434,
-0.14061881601810455,
0.2726067900657654,
0.20342285931110382,
-0.16391558945178986,
0.3146618902683258,
-1.1278852224349976,
0.49762311577796936,
0.16703131794929504,
0.4181414246559143,
0.11370627582073212,
-0.24728356301784515,
-0.048667389899492264,
0.3798218369483948,
-0.27153152227401733,
-0.7486569881439209,
0.5149072408676147,
0.25414711236953735,
0.2640860974788666,
0.6336066126823425,
0.5496801137924194,
0.6989709734916687,
-0.989469587802887,
0.9127389192581177,
0.2379414290189743,
-0.9583190083503723,
0.6370342373847961,
-0.6996579766273499,
0.2646680474281311,
0.776530921459198,
0.2651643753051758,
-0.9165992140769958,
-1.0386255979537964,
-0.33312171697616577,
-1.2211685180664062,
0.6864392161369324,
0.38880854845046997,
0.5718088150024414,
-0.5785425901412964,
0.43403157591819763,
0.2929975688457489,
0.01919526606798172,
-0.5479606986045837,
-0.11335623264312744,
0.09550105035305023,
-0.16772401332855225,
0.1980055272579193,
-0.42701026797294617,
-0.08796510845422745,
-0.168485626578331,
0.7631843090057373,
0.16601446270942688,
-0.11034750193357468,
0.20035526156425476,
-0.05738779529929161,
-0.13871294260025024,
0.7103058099746704,
0.387055367231369,
-0.22220012545585632,
-0.3056369721889496,
0.4033491313457489,
-0.030159037560224533,
-0.4592631161212921,
0.3159979581832886,
-0.18655925989151,
-0.4153033196926117,
-0.24296452105045319,
0.059403274208307266,
0.5573735237121582,
0.2332732379436493,
-0.7247521281242371,
0.1632927805185318,
0.038492899388074875,
0.011450639925897121,
0.34486016631126404,
0.36130765080451965,
0.0074935778975486755,
0.0784992054104805,
0.24084284901618958,
-0.13076427578926086,
0.29525768756866455,
-0.5457192063331604,
0.4570119082927704,
0.31737151741981506,
-0.34707581996917725,
-0.05037226900458336,
0.9821656346321106,
0.5946807265281677,
0.05796683952212334,
0.40919700264930725,
-0.3847014904022217,
-0.24139781296253204,
0.3921806812286377,
0.5850935578346252,
0.9974063038825989,
-0.20885582268238068,
0.22742976248264313,
0.5202212929725647,
0.19528380036354065,
0.1342426836490631,
-0.1194908544421196,
0.1942243129014969,
-0.6516336798667908,
-0.1797846406698227,
-0.7946312427520752,
-0.08355408906936646,
0.6109985113143921,
-0.535922110080719,
-0.024592112749814987,
-0.5275752544403076,
0.049529921263456345,
0.10904044657945633,
-0.2308603972196579,
-0.10604037344455719,
0.260436475276947,
0.5141516327857971,
0.86397385597229,
-1.0801090002059937,
0.5973058938980103,
0.3951696753501892,
-0.7566171288490295,
-0.6106998324394226,
0.14060688018798828,
0.01452686544507742,
0.0273579154163599,
0.5229620933532715,
0.7068201899528503,
0.018134519457817078,
0.30420029163360596,
-0.2818504869937897,
-0.39649492502212524,
0.6017022132873535,
0.1835435926914215,
-0.5072440505027771,
-0.05887622386217117,
0.16409890353679657,
0.6917977333068848,
0.04839302599430084,
0.3434777557849884,
0.5290076732635498,
0.3740065097808838,
0.15325817465782166,
-0.6496523022651672,
0.44106122851371765,
-0.191744863986969,
0.281985878944397,
0.17061276733875275,
-0.4239453971385956,
0.6503499150276184,
-0.03179439157247543,
-0.4946921765804291,
0.10726668685674667,
0.5076082348823547,
0.0011289697140455246,
0.05753117427229881,
0.566180408000946,
0.7884548306465149,
0.6022905111312866,
0.036439668387174606,
0.8202638030052185,
0.04981958493590355,
0.2609114944934845,
1.2100977897644043,
-0.36736488342285156,
0.7179004549980164,
0.5533789992332458,
0.027187783271074295,
0.4683154225349426,
0.5813403129577637,
0.14996935427188873,
0.7602940201759338,
0.44699180126190186,
-0.4683487117290497,
-0.32439398765563965,
-0.5752337574958801,
-0.23980632424354553,
0.03941202163696289,
0.4938447177410126,
-0.2308826893568039,
-0.9277259111404419,
0.1791783720254898,
0.2847820222377777,
0.13938719034194946,
-0.500398576259613,
0.7654622197151184,
0.1557542383670807,
-0.4550453722476959,
0.6765086650848389,
0.028780793771147728,
0.8831498622894287,
-0.4098708927631378,
0.015698140487074852,
-0.41160067915916443,
0.2024293690919876,
-0.21101540327072144,
-0.6123766899108887,
0.558821976184845,
0.2088887244462967,
-0.004868621006608009,
-0.40392637252807617,
0.7370962500572205,
-0.679928719997406,
-0.22738371789455414,
0.1450585424900055,
0.22933216392993927,
0.20977424085140228,
-0.2713135778903961,
-0.3996303081512451,
-0.09551048278808594,
-0.26914507150650024,
-0.23042596876621246,
0.36140114068984985,
0.373881071805954,
-0.3196549117565155,
0.4899483025074005,
0.6409610509872437,
0.045113686472177505,
-0.0067088003270328045,
0.32607734203338623,
1.0371977090835571,
-0.3974341154098511,
-0.42757102847099304,
-0.933870255947113,
0.6795686483383179,
0.02725130133330822,
-0.09916672110557556,
0.4578353762626648,
0.5411832928657532,
0.6437165141105652,
-0.0208878293633461,
0.528651773929596,
0.0159772802144289,
0.033744409680366516,
-0.5116294622421265,
0.8351335525512695,
-0.6022323369979858,
0.2270697057247162,
-0.5383854508399963,
-0.7191061973571777,
-0.5960710048675537,
0.5647638440132141,
-0.3585655093193054,
-0.12004482746124268,
0.6855025887489319,
0.5988138318061829,
-0.17408286035060883,
-0.24614930152893066,
0.3141883313655853,
0.32416263222694397,
0.6026400327682495,
0.8074368834495544,
0.5561875104904175,
-0.0076958658173680305,
0.3387715816497803,
-0.3933941721916199,
-0.24002602696418762,
-0.30275213718414307,
-1.1468911170959473,
-0.9504539370536804,
-0.28615811467170715,
-0.4193917512893677,
-0.053918782621622086,
-0.058939334005117416,
0.7289324998855591,
0.31651270389556885,
-0.5842670798301697,
0.3562164306640625,
-0.34533625841140747,
0.1063917949795723,
-0.20042438805103302,
-0.2910023331642151,
0.14283905923366547,
-0.7272271513938904,
-0.8758148550987244,
0.22650310397148132,
0.23737846314907074,
0.06088675931096077,
-0.1140933558344841,
0.20544834434986115,
-0.1846047341823578,
0.3084152340888977,
0.752927839756012,
0.16037748754024506,
-0.5711902976036072,
-0.852883517742157,
-0.6370377540588379,
-0.502612829208374,
0.02022855542600155,
0.3976175785064697,
-0.710143506526947,
0.16266211867332458,
0.5317816138267517,
0.49621695280075073,
-0.0780005007982254,
0.35356491804122925,
0.41364023089408875,
-1.2419832944869995,
0.25898921489715576,
0.20473802089691162,
0.18140557408332825,
0.18022122979164124,
-0.6098702549934387,
0.4250234365463257,
-0.12518303096294403,
-0.2916032671928406,
-0.8639285564422607,
0.317432701587677,
-0.89676833152771,
-0.556516170501709,
1.6308742761611938,
-0.09626203030347824,
-0.16156096756458282,
-0.02160714566707611,
-0.5768317580223083,
0.3489226698875427,
-0.4860292673110962,
0.7869131565093994,
0.5726163387298584,
0.14895783364772797,
0.1431318074464798,
-0.5857352614402771,
0.6205926537513733,
0.28953397274017334,
-1.4830561876296997,
0.6362916231155396,
0.8749834895133972,
0.1844501942396164,
0.2417694330215454,
0.3864656686782837,
-0.14109474420547485,
-0.11521197110414505,
-0.17614315450191498,
0.24822087585926056,
-0.19405892491340637,
-0.36650386452674866,
-0.2814120054244995,
-0.10970037430524826,
-0.4608638286590576,
0.04978225380182266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15200v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15200v1
|
DeMPT: Decoding-enhanced Multi-phase Prompt Tuning for Making LLMs Be Better Context-aware Translators
| 2024-02-23T09:01:00 | 2024-02-23T09:01:00 |
Xinglin Lyu, Junhui Li, Yanqing Zhao, Min Zhang, Daimeng Wei, Shimin Tao, Hao Yang, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generally, the decoder-only large language models (LLMs) are adapted to
context-aware neural machine translation (NMT) in a concatenating way, where
LLMs take the concatenation of the source sentence (i.e., intra-sentence
context) and the inter-sentence context as the input, and then to generate the
target tokens sequentially. This adaptation strategy, i.e., concatenation mode,
considers intra-sentence and inter-sentence contexts with the same priority,
despite an apparent difference between the two kinds of contexts. In this
paper, we propose an alternative adaptation approach, named Decoding-enhanced
Multi-phase Prompt Tuning (DeMPT), to make LLMs discriminately model and
utilize the inter- and intra-sentence context and more effectively adapt LLMs
to context-aware NMT. First, DeMPT divides the context-aware NMT process into
three separate phases. During each phase, different continuous prompts are
introduced to make LLMs discriminately model various information. Second, DeMPT
employs a heuristic way to further discriminately enhance the utilization of
the source-side inter- and intra-sentence information at the final decoding
phase. Experiments show that our approach significantly outperforms the
concatenation method, and further improves the performance of LLMs in discourse
modeling.
|
[
-0.3839753568172455,
-0.6163588166236877,
0.6778612732887268,
0.3309197425842285,
-0.8559890389442444,
0.17329874634742737,
-0.23536840081214905,
-0.113611601293087,
-0.09972500056028366,
0.3312285244464874,
-0.792819082736969,
-0.43411529064178467,
-0.5211310982704163,
0.7715134620666504,
-0.11474701762199402,
0.8392226696014404,
0.09058927744626999,
0.3133302330970764,
-0.18622207641601562,
0.11997390538454056,
-0.9674084186553955,
-0.40983450412750244,
-0.8445888757705688,
-0.2301715761423111,
0.26351016759872437,
0.5374788641929626,
0.3471035957336426,
0.46437767148017883,
0.40845781564712524,
0.3624759912490845,
-0.14217136800289154,
0.6349561810493469,
-0.11057321727275848,
0.5240066051483154,
0.05615262687206268,
-0.41738420724868774,
-0.5314053893089294,
-0.26552340388298035,
0.6533193588256836,
0.3107910454273224,
0.1780909150838852,
-0.11886924505233765,
0.396104633808136,
0.5626845359802246,
-0.400160551071167,
0.20392870903015137,
-0.639622151851654,
-0.06724975258111954,
0.07491062581539154,
-0.9358404278755188,
-0.7098345160484314,
-0.39379367232322693,
-0.15362738072872162,
-0.5983794927597046,
-0.025107286870479584,
0.21688567101955414,
0.45367860794067383,
0.4433944523334503,
-0.7529801726341248,
-0.05800564959645271,
-0.5079581141471863,
0.6005118489265442,
-0.91506427526474,
0.41932418942451477,
0.20568448305130005,
0.24994106590747833,
-0.3592270016670227,
-0.3981519341468811,
-0.3880581259727478,
-0.3685222566127777,
-0.014427563175559044,
0.3142259120941162,
0.062434691935777664,
0.3520013093948364,
0.21510352194309235,
0.028233937919139862,
-0.4056646525859833,
0.0888604074716568,
0.1515432745218277,
-0.3495998680591583,
0.18746985495090485,
0.3050548732280731,
0.17261502146720886,
-0.2720390558242798,
-0.588966965675354,
-0.06500164419412613,
-0.6559834480285645,
-0.07119476795196533,
0.20670151710510254,
0.6239597797393799,
-0.12322930246591568,
0.4642859399318695,
-0.18944169580936432,
0.7277792096138,
0.5992274284362793,
-0.29283493757247925,
0.14995311200618744,
-0.7354012727737427,
-0.04140506312251091,
0.3164573311805725,
0.5361731648445129,
0.6417524218559265,
0.05860378220677376,
0.16941635310649872,
-0.3105615973472595,
-0.423137366771698,
0.13006027042865753,
-1.0060749053955078,
0.2101544737815857,
0.13695576786994934,
-0.37595701217651367,
0.060380179435014725,
-0.3256349563598633,
-0.8454001545906067,
-0.6534879207611084,
-0.5685955882072449,
0.36471590399742126,
-0.6673764586448669,
-0.10265348851680756,
0.172978475689888,
-0.09885472059249878,
0.2446289360523224,
0.4406850337982178,
-0.8143683671951294,
0.2010030299425125,
0.7535911798477173,
1.0809274911880493,
-0.15829144418239594,
-0.2871183753013611,
-0.6885308027267456,
-0.0204265508800745,
-0.2210494428873062,
0.6791201233863831,
-0.4946442246437073,
-0.3506770133972168,
-0.04656151682138443,
-0.026143621653318405,
-0.2958233058452606,
-0.40803515911102295,
0.8605844974517822,
-0.6031954884529114,
0.2596781849861145,
-0.6193540096282959,
-0.40102913975715637,
-0.3410705029964447,
0.3692948520183563,
-0.3302856683731079,
0.8559778332710266,
0.08848141878843307,
-0.764855682849884,
0.36376073956489563,
-0.4950579106807709,
-0.5733223557472229,
0.07466025650501251,
0.14787061512470245,
-0.23234768211841583,
0.3778390884399414,
0.5376185178756714,
0.4958516061306,
-0.4313165247440338,
0.4000212550163269,
0.006541513837873936,
-0.38348957896232605,
0.24392840266227722,
-0.6389408707618713,
0.5965391993522644,
0.2388896942138672,
-0.17619548738002777,
0.5560170412063599,
-0.650313138961792,
-0.14945849776268005,
-0.20178386569023132,
-0.4614375829696655,
-0.4148324429988861,
-0.026418786495923996,
-0.19957245886325836,
0.42038118839263916,
0.14667734503746033,
-0.3018743395805359,
0.2482314109802246,
-0.5780787467956543,
0.43162035942077637,
0.7342858910560608,
0.1596653163433075,
0.5729742050170898,
-0.2622438073158264,
0.6908107995986938,
0.4002833366394043,
0.058989401906728745,
-0.5392826199531555,
-0.3319452106952667,
-0.8588101863861084,
-0.3791036903858185,
0.37168657779693604,
0.7650418877601624,
-1.038373589515686,
0.72843998670578,
-0.34228816628456116,
-0.06636310368776321,
-0.5875840187072754,
-0.2615494728088379,
0.24035261571407318,
0.7977128624916077,
0.49897152185440063,
-0.2254829853773117,
-0.6223698258399963,
-0.5964668393135071,
-0.18345682322978973,
0.125171959400177,
0.09902053326368332,
0.09908047318458557,
0.4534027576446533,
0.21329836547374725,
0.6742954850196838,
-0.14766258001327515,
-0.03784005343914032,
-0.45777052640914917,
-0.18959830701351166,
0.39857107400894165,
0.4250898063182831,
0.275017648935318,
-0.6072327494621277,
-0.616137683391571,
0.0738331601023674,
-0.3180187940597534,
-0.3487626612186432,
-0.5610928535461426,
-0.20061646401882172,
0.07305237650871277,
0.6315698623657227,
-0.5507974028587341,
-0.030228743329644203,
0.5188235640525818,
-0.5773654580116272,
0.49954017996788025,
-0.43941834568977356,
0.5082131028175354,
-1.4364577531814575,
-0.09870326519012451,
-0.20088818669319153,
-0.5575933456420898,
-0.6595824956893921,
-0.061372075229883194,
0.3513888418674469,
0.034137457609176636,
-0.5114352107048035,
0.34262844920158386,
-0.6751067638397217,
0.05327558517456055,
-0.491300493478775,
0.16476349532604218,
0.1427241861820221,
0.36737605929374695,
-0.2908287048339844,
1.023071527481079,
0.5124226212501526,
-0.7234202027320862,
0.3009161651134491,
0.22455693781375885,
-0.25982704758644104,
0.8788655400276184,
-0.5141120553016663,
0.11358765512704849,
-0.22639650106430054,
0.5899325013160706,
-1.0776609182357788,
0.06514652073383331,
0.5243600606918335,
-0.1599319577217102,
0.4269980490207672,
-0.22503404319286346,
-0.523495078086853,
0.01476746704429388,
-0.3863961100578308,
0.4683345556259155,
0.29312390089035034,
-0.4855433702468872,
0.6618828177452087,
-0.17275182902812958,
-0.3329913914203644,
-0.4153197109699249,
-0.5718069672584534,
0.3431752622127533,
-0.5523781776428223,
-0.5204594135284424,
0.4669068455696106,
-0.30104655027389526,
0.13670098781585693,
-0.5014694333076477,
-0.14848418533802032,
0.11561831831932068,
0.22626127302646637,
0.05383909121155739,
0.12545616924762726,
-0.2216755896806717,
-0.013565010391175747,
0.6005334258079529,
-0.3847128450870514,
-0.16057728230953217,
-0.3991290330886841,
0.7875561118125916,
0.24154210090637207,
-0.34794700145721436,
-0.7257488369941711,
0.4237253665924072,
0.6236299276351929,
-0.26518625020980835,
0.6729364395141602,
0.5997547507286072,
0.01869751699268818,
-0.2854982614517212,
-0.14119680225849152,
-0.49720093607902527,
-0.523323655128479,
0.38924381136894226,
-0.7163605093955994,
-0.7447472214698792,
0.49083852767944336,
-0.5920048952102661,
-0.011239714920520782,
0.13568522036075592,
0.6214691400527954,
0.2138865441083908,
1.0646682977676392,
0.6047988533973694,
0.008183889091014862,
0.7039190530776978,
0.11654216796159744,
0.19236038625240326,
-1.2360020875930786,
-0.08119954913854599,
-0.5266497135162354,
-0.45036306977272034,
-0.5245517492294312,
-0.42624160647392273,
0.6056653261184692,
0.11721114069223404,
-0.19553609192371368,
0.2665114998817444,
-0.511436402797699,
0.4503593146800995,
0.4998849928379059,
0.13614381849765778,
0.40936318039894104,
-0.18169854581356049,
-0.36569494009017944,
-0.25834259390830994,
-0.5992180109024048,
-0.318287193775177,
0.6723747849464417,
0.19959864020347595,
0.4302666187286377,
0.016413673758506775,
0.5174615383148193,
0.14020460844039917,
-0.2653878629207611,
-0.7476633787155151,
0.6429209113121033,
-0.1035161241889,
-0.3595229387283325,
0.04801978915929794,
-0.3206497132778168,
-0.847815215587616,
0.6250104308128357,
-0.17773973941802979,
-0.42543554306030273,
0.27244874835014343,
0.12690334022045135,
-0.4320175051689148,
-0.10040518641471863,
-0.5279847979545593,
0.7318001389503479,
-0.22603607177734375,
-0.07861508429050446,
-0.10598837584257126,
-0.6812083125114441,
0.2567752003669739,
-0.15568134188652039,
0.1331326961517334,
-0.2470531016588211,
-0.3419308662414551,
0.26549211144447327,
-0.03151649609208107,
0.9593576192855835,
-0.21874111890792847,
-0.25921201705932617,
0.04254242777824402,
0.2917155921459198,
0.6697788238525391,
0.22937487065792084,
-0.3915543258190155,
-0.056942347437143326,
0.027880080044269562,
-0.03372056037187576,
-0.44189974665641785,
0.6026666164398193,
-0.49080890417099,
-0.6109523177146912,
-0.3817443549633026,
-0.7998880743980408,
-0.16130711138248444,
0.29780474305152893,
0.3724576234817505,
0.4728195071220398,
0.05450959876179695,
-0.020251687616109848,
0.49616652727127075,
-0.25996828079223633,
0.564685583114624,
0.5435139536857605,
-0.046592384576797485,
-0.6161502003669739,
0.6822566986083984,
-0.27605801820755005,
0.36519691348075867,
0.6142991185188293,
0.2041770964860916,
-0.4130896031856537,
-0.7395241856575012,
-0.6044204235076904,
0.0841175988316536,
-0.7728890180587769,
-0.5166038870811462,
-0.5368870496749878,
0.05128324404358864,
-0.4672050178050995,
-0.18886063992977142,
-0.15106402337551117,
-0.3585510551929474,
-0.4085797667503357,
0.06522883474826813,
0.3938044309616089,
0.08204158395528793,
0.0010203783167526126,
0.680827796459198,
-0.8105578422546387,
0.4519365727901459,
-0.11887731403112411,
0.06214441359043121,
-0.4011465609073639,
-0.9817996025085449,
-0.14116284251213074,
0.064926877617836,
-0.26267918944358826,
-1.1176575422286987,
0.4959767758846283,
0.36015647649765015,
0.34035274386405945,
0.07102678716182709,
0.2095026969909668,
0.7538332343101501,
-0.6666512489318848,
0.7224976420402527,
0.0829562097787857,
-1.120298147201538,
0.44814082980155945,
-0.33415645360946655,
0.6904128789901733,
0.6501046419143677,
0.08938850462436676,
-0.6735190749168396,
-0.3763393759727478,
0.10179443657398224,
-0.9822197556495667,
0.866783082485199,
-0.07626581937074661,
0.37377455830574036,
0.07289479672908783,
0.47498375177383423,
0.2884668707847595,
0.24857684969902039,
-0.5960995554924011,
-0.1071087047457695,
-0.07032769918441772,
-0.41539478302001953,
-0.15361478924751282,
-0.35651183128356934,
-0.08655016869306564,
-0.4718211591243744,
0.6214859485626221,
-0.47323518991470337,
0.12000370025634766,
0.23297101259231567,
-0.22039128839969635,
-0.02757169120013714,
0.532626748085022,
0.7714733481407166,
0.36936724185943604,
-0.10494250059127808,
0.392513245344162,
0.5234392285346985,
-0.27829232811927795,
0.2201586812734604,
0.2086603343486786,
-0.4924003779888153,
0.14740273356437683,
0.2526979148387909,
1.0950313806533813,
0.32654669880867004,
-0.27589401602745056,
0.3756137490272522,
-0.07388565689325333,
-0.07855714112520218,
0.11902528256177902,
-0.03996647149324417,
0.09325245767831802,
0.4603622257709503,
0.1676599681377411,
0.18991395831108093,
0.23922336101531982,
-0.20741519331932068,
0.029802465811371803,
0.4150295555591583,
-0.2262052744626999,
-0.4678831994533539,
0.569360613822937,
0.5006260871887207,
-0.25101566314697266,
0.48375025391578674,
-0.16227133572101593,
-0.6207365989685059,
0.3851667642593384,
0.943056583404541,
1.1410014629364014,
-0.4144582748413086,
0.24150517582893372,
0.5067578554153442,
0.32659992575645447,
-0.1151779517531395,
0.4320521652698517,
-0.13154464960098267,
-0.5337647795677185,
-0.6625940799713135,
-0.685199499130249,
-0.2066686451435089,
-0.08118578791618347,
-0.3248339593410492,
0.47315773367881775,
-0.27181142568588257,
-0.2713600993156433,
-0.30757439136505127,
-0.09093255549669266,
-0.40264663100242615,
-0.06988528370857239,
0.131410151720047,
0.8417202234268188,
-0.7197840213775635,
0.853981614112854,
0.5476523041725159,
-0.0661846324801445,
-0.29382020235061646,
0.12583670020103455,
-0.008644399233162403,
-0.5442442893981934,
0.19563907384872437,
0.2413230538368225,
-0.17167603969573975,
0.4226818084716797,
-0.19895565509796143,
-0.9215524196624756,
1.087161660194397,
0.8356926441192627,
-0.7286655902862549,
0.10658472031354904,
0.16397589445114136,
0.26550716161727905,
-0.42213883996009827,
0.2995438873767853,
0.6060671210289001,
0.6850247979164124,
0.040077704936265945,
-1.0063743591308594,
0.5088281631469727,
0.08588757365942001,
0.13399675488471985,
0.19409173727035522,
-0.4833846688270569,
0.8028115034103394,
-0.15267546474933624,
-0.4837818443775177,
-0.011919367127120495,
0.5755104422569275,
0.19897803664207458,
0.04654867202043533,
0.6163922548294067,
0.01788565143942833,
0.585730791091919,
-0.06622026860713959,
0.9393818974494934,
-0.6314032673835754,
0.031868964433670044,
1.2069294452667236,
-0.06449831277132034,
0.5365706086158752,
0.6651701927185059,
0.19919928908348083,
0.2673764228820801,
0.7986814379692078,
0.17228975892066956,
0.8104798793792725,
0.1374812126159668,
-0.26223769783973694,
-0.4137510359287262,
-0.277233749628067,
-0.4901738464832306,
0.37591248750686646,
0.1404537558555603,
-0.38442108035087585,
-0.34777534008026123,
0.06645992398262024,
0.11965586990118027,
0.009646393358707428,
-0.06634362787008286,
0.8943105340003967,
0.2613367438316345,
-0.7585890293121338,
0.7485550045967102,
0.20488378405570984,
0.717880368232727,
-0.5545920133590698,
-0.01605910249054432,
-0.34201163053512573,
0.042709968984127045,
-0.06003734841942787,
-0.5290077328681946,
0.10561998933553696,
-0.1295410841703415,
-0.1466369479894638,
-0.4760150909423828,
0.5818519592285156,
-0.5254630446434021,
-0.4103449881076813,
0.1635732501745224,
0.6068935990333557,
-0.05381898209452629,
-0.22353056073188782,
-0.7443042993545532,
0.2090509533882141,
0.060858678072690964,
-0.3682519495487213,
0.33695220947265625,
0.6788303852081299,
0.07921694219112396,
0.5287360548973083,
0.5877238512039185,
-0.02315785177052021,
0.11795401573181152,
0.3556406795978546,
0.8405568599700928,
-0.7485441565513611,
-0.4684988558292389,
-1.1891287565231323,
0.7512869238853455,
0.08148160576820374,
-0.47188204526901245,
0.8945550918579102,
0.39867985248565674,
0.38391634821891785,
0.005004477687180042,
0.558086633682251,
0.08472223579883575,
0.06495174020528793,
-0.7483057975769043,
0.23602384328842163,
-0.4354930520057678,
0.3977271020412445,
-0.049911484122276306,
-1.0796903371810913,
-0.29626673460006714,
0.3072868585586548,
0.010355211794376373,
0.07353997230529785,
0.8694261908531189,
0.7006998062133789,
-0.058144472539424896,
-0.17094291746616364,
0.4336496889591217,
0.1874232292175293,
0.33377668261528015,
0.5857177972793579,
0.8494277000427246,
-0.31004273891448975,
0.3556901514530182,
-0.07348214089870453,
-0.1759214997291565,
-0.3025628626346588,
-1.0325669050216675,
-0.7046301960945129,
-0.6388953328132629,
-0.18479463458061218,
-0.14837759733200073,
-0.021147947758436203,
0.9356745481491089,
0.5888960957527161,
-0.7131626605987549,
-0.010405397042632103,
-0.058899663388729095,
0.19786499440670013,
-0.41081762313842773,
-0.10619864612817764,
0.19422343373298645,
-0.5775285959243774,
-0.9409017562866211,
0.902818500995636,
0.41904449462890625,
-0.00036476401146501303,
-0.019091850146651268,
-0.09038294851779938,
-0.14250448346138,
0.2347743809223175,
0.7954807877540588,
-0.41879802942276,
-0.65986168384552,
-0.2770540714263916,
-0.022539682686328888,
-0.04480092227458954,
0.26507824659347534,
0.8065738677978516,
-0.5806141495704651,
0.4974408745765686,
0.6618205308914185,
0.4389500319957733,
0.1513201743364334,
0.26207780838012695,
0.7492300271987915,
-0.869113028049469,
0.243275448679924,
0.20726117491722107,
0.29436731338500977,
0.4307664632797241,
-0.5241965651512146,
0.12937019765377045,
-0.027556613087654114,
-0.531365692615509,
-0.7537133097648621,
0.38900044560432434,
-1.1351608037948608,
-0.4237481653690338,
1.3591018915176392,
0.07014816254377365,
0.02332904376089573,
-0.1555997133255005,
-0.6425178647041321,
0.5227833986282349,
-0.6218897700309753,
0.6249651908874512,
0.5280475616455078,
-0.003743726760149002,
-0.17596952617168427,
-0.6521776914596558,
0.5497227311134338,
0.5186888575553894,
-0.815552830696106,
0.19433917105197906,
0.531561553478241,
0.16181276738643646,
-0.20304585993289948,
0.6214196085929871,
0.1816864311695099,
0.035523999482393265,
-0.21074149012565613,
-0.1812787801027298,
-0.17264512181282043,
-0.35040703415870667,
-0.7729167342185974,
-0.008147485554218292,
0.16851234436035156,
-0.3132226765155792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15189v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15189v2
|
Biomedical Entity Linking as Multiple Choice Question Answering
| 2024-02-23T08:40:38 | 2024-05-17T09:11:44 |
Zhenxi Lin, Ziheng Zhang, Xian Wu, Yefeng Zheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Although biomedical entity linking (BioEL) has made significant progress with
pre-trained language models, challenges still exist for fine-grained and
long-tailed entities. To address these challenges, we present BioELQA, a novel
model that treats Biomedical Entity Linking as Multiple Choice Question
Answering. BioELQA first obtains candidate entities with a fast retriever,
jointly presents the mention and candidate entities to a generator, and then
outputs the predicted symbol associated with its chosen entity. This
formulation enables explicit comparison of different candidate entities, thus
capturing fine-grained interactions between mentions and entities, as well as
among entities themselves. To improve generalization for long-tailed entities,
we retrieve similar labeled training instances as clues and concatenate the
input with retrieved instances for the generator. Extensive experimental
results show that BioELQA outperforms state-of-the-art baselines on several
datasets.
|
[
-0.3970920145511627,
-0.84975266456604,
0.9056985378265381,
-0.14020659029483795,
0.0166529081761837,
0.20000571012496948,
0.0807524099946022,
-0.9784442782402039,
0.3699756860733032,
0.3971848487854004,
-0.6740261912345886,
-0.30587294697761536,
-0.2620416581630707,
0.4678473174571991,
-0.11754337698221207,
1.23615562915802,
0.17864590883255005,
0.24121738970279694,
-0.5413758158683777,
-0.5029991269111633,
0.005813885480165482,
-0.33904945850372314,
-1.0725172758102417,
-0.4291499853134155,
1.146370530128479,
0.009408123791217804,
0.8693439364433289,
0.4906454384326935,
0.46796107292175293,
0.28943851590156555,
-0.07398476451635361,
0.10913685709238052,
-0.24108348786830902,
0.26735541224479675,
-0.5625514388084412,
-0.15462133288383484,
-0.5175216794013977,
-0.17562806606292725,
0.6928303241729736,
1.0348204374313354,
0.12158581614494324,
0.5350624322891235,
-0.14108756184577942,
0.501571536064148,
-0.4841686487197876,
-0.12653867900371552,
-0.6612983345985413,
-0.5192763805389404,
-0.21914984285831451,
0.08656870573759079,
-0.2987731397151947,
-0.48585960268974304,
0.17002999782562256,
-0.5181241631507874,
0.11520146578550339,
0.25262919068336487,
0.9378880858421326,
0.5394608378410339,
-0.6885049939155579,
-0.33637717366218567,
-0.3901534080505371,
0.4434002935886383,
-0.08424105495214462,
0.6786671280860901,
0.3367187976837158,
0.33965829014778137,
0.17376206815242767,
-0.7615097165107727,
-0.426587849855423,
-0.16411961615085602,
0.06193919852375984,
0.06248662993311882,
-0.11236187070608139,
0.15248610079288483,
0.13591992855072021,
0.005509080830961466,
-0.4821279048919678,
-0.051315609365701675,
-0.5769795179367065,
-0.3592471778392792,
0.37590304017066956,
-0.12912265956401825,
0.25709423422813416,
-0.2041911482810974,
-0.3808400630950928,
0.16243426501750946,
-0.8726119995117188,
-0.02680088020861149,
0.18226201832294464,
0.1781775951385498,
0.43107345700263977,
0.6996550559997559,
-0.1265273541212082,
0.6680313944816589,
0.22102707624435425,
0.34364309906959534,
0.38666296005249023,
-0.4172196388244629,
-0.2438344806432724,
0.258243590593338,
0.5507357716560364,
-0.03529718145728111,
0.025762764737010002,
-0.1723482608795166,
0.17959077656269073,
-0.15919102728366852,
0.22681395709514618,
-0.8572597503662109,
-0.11835294961929321,
0.9023073315620422,
-0.641352117061615,
-0.05656677857041359,
-0.6366966962814331,
-0.7057288289070129,
-0.08036843687295914,
-0.05237596109509468,
0.5957639813423157,
-0.6989331245422363,
0.03108397126197815,
0.19313417375087738,
0.07769949734210968,
0.23275955021381378,
0.15040017664432526,
-0.7095739245414734,
-0.029678821563720703,
0.3910968005657196,
0.5489476323127747,
0.10499999672174454,
-0.19696159660816193,
-0.8553907871246338,
0.5111569762229919,
0.12212490290403366,
0.9928192496299744,
-0.7424052357673645,
-0.33646342158317566,
-0.16339991986751556,
-0.04035031795501709,
0.03141067177057266,
-0.5232453346252441,
0.1285109966993332,
-0.8657457232475281,
-0.048203244805336,
-0.302413672208786,
-0.6744748950004578,
0.030703609809279442,
0.0021270490251481533,
-0.9381380081176758,
0.9127680659294128,
0.16220282018184662,
-0.8396997451782227,
0.4549007713794708,
-0.7214360237121582,
-0.27278366684913635,
0.4315532147884369,
-0.3527343273162842,
-0.5573654770851135,
-0.4126141369342804,
0.004515374545007944,
0.40470337867736816,
-0.22413678467273712,
0.47319984436035156,
-0.6890323758125305,
0.061206210404634476,
0.26498690247535706,
0.10891001671552658,
0.9953270554542542,
0.018898431211709976,
-0.09442618489265442,
0.10678375512361526,
-0.9486494660377502,
0.13099916279315948,
-0.11444143205881119,
-0.4900282323360443,
-0.6728827357292175,
-0.11900822073221207,
-0.2636319100856781,
0.2258663773536682,
0.19449006021022797,
-0.7803714871406555,
0.25313031673431396,
-0.37825074791908264,
0.35480737686157227,
0.30755236744880676,
0.14604876935482025,
0.31969279050827026,
-0.3480778634548187,
0.23257388174533844,
-0.03922177478671074,
-0.1460595577955246,
0.035570692270994186,
-0.7386235594749451,
-0.48133882880210876,
-0.34453460574150085,
0.5721659660339355,
0.503095805644989,
-1.0440748929977417,
0.1400415450334549,
-0.0735774114727974,
-0.3933265507221222,
-1.053505778312683,
-0.12957720458507538,
0.5168696045875549,
0.669514000415802,
1.0920054912567139,
0.08422433584928513,
-0.27065297961235046,
-1.1210577487945557,
-0.32931438088417053,
-0.4250548183917999,
-0.36325928568840027,
0.7253803610801697,
0.9348292946815491,
-0.43952032923698425,
0.7472379803657532,
-0.38286542892456055,
0.1737188845872879,
0.18996131420135498,
0.32909536361694336,
0.045907799154520035,
0.4063994884490967,
0.6111412048339844,
-0.8086301684379578,
-0.05439811944961548,
-0.1253233551979065,
-0.5894067883491516,
0.23581339418888092,
-0.20175087451934814,
-0.44479843974113464,
-0.27779313921928406,
0.3674109876155853,
-0.7237663269042969,
0.0846383273601532,
0.2864060699939728,
-0.3017001748085022,
0.672065258026123,
-0.01429922878742218,
0.18550606071949005,
-1.209993600845337,
0.4370659291744232,
0.012111864052712917,
-0.13623961806297302,
-0.4734409749507904,
0.22524167597293854,
0.14922921359539032,
-0.027070999145507812,
-0.5900054574012756,
0.831209123134613,
-0.45147034525871277,
-0.0834532380104065,
0.20351262390613556,
-0.18177121877670288,
-0.08460250496864319,
0.1855107992887497,
0.2443905472755432,
0.9943206310272217,
0.6300655603408813,
-0.777550458908081,
0.35563936829566956,
0.7821483016014099,
0.03848043084144592,
0.6594998240470886,
-0.8673851490020752,
0.24523389339447021,
-0.47827646136283875,
0.3827720880508423,
-0.711080014705658,
-0.41679778695106506,
0.08490482717752457,
-0.44782009720802307,
0.25459861755371094,
-0.03261900320649147,
-0.1284160166978836,
-0.49926912784576416,
-0.15662114322185516,
0.7241975665092468,
0.13726162910461426,
-0.4715383052825928,
0.7283813953399658,
0.25373440980911255,
-0.2528325617313385,
-0.668832004070282,
-0.6230987906455994,
-0.06461286544799805,
-0.049953948706388474,
-0.46077999472618103,
0.47560128569602966,
-0.338183730840683,
-0.02137811668217182,
0.12295591831207275,
-0.07654503732919693,
-0.44010141491889954,
-0.03813200071454048,
0.009955997578799725,
0.43696895241737366,
-0.3633805811405182,
0.5256738662719727,
0.35929760336875916,
0.019705509766936302,
0.33285707235336304,
-0.43311211466789246,
0.0708698257803917,
-0.15412509441375732,
-0.30550774931907654,
0.0525561086833477,
0.787106454372406,
0.34500861167907715,
-0.5188769698143005,
0.8469725251197815,
0.6116677522659302,
-0.7137388586997986,
0.0731651782989502,
-0.45229557156562805,
-0.21248584985733032,
-0.45278310775756836,
0.4878844916820526,
-0.5615910887718201,
-1.0153874158859253,
0.34060004353523254,
-0.44455966353416443,
0.06927164644002914,
0.5353044867515564,
0.6009790897369385,
-0.4974251687526703,
0.6543508172035217,
0.4509561359882355,
0.26066291332244873,
-0.27723029255867004,
0.03143954277038574,
0.07219985872507095,
-0.8215293884277344,
-0.5340911746025085,
-0.7805015444755554,
-0.06703151017427444,
-0.6124776005744934,
-0.4697924554347992,
0.5246244072914124,
0.116245336830616,
-0.5497526526451111,
0.5025226473808289,
-0.3488580286502838,
0.35749128460884094,
0.7695425152778625,
0.5578820109367371,
0.24007104337215424,
-0.10225952416658401,
-0.590773344039917,
0.2998945116996765,
-0.7047269940376282,
-0.49004390835762024,
0.946225106716156,
0.2291107177734375,
0.6346389651298523,
0.20942102372646332,
1.058181643486023,
-0.25705036520957947,
0.3835383951663971,
-0.5627033710479736,
0.45360445976257324,
0.07213231176137924,
-1.0769416093826294,
-0.4276566505432129,
-0.24331414699554443,
-1.1052652597427368,
-0.1809648871421814,
-0.6781112551689148,
-0.679058849811554,
0.34023186564445496,
0.32196709513664246,
-0.9802041053771973,
0.3688478171825409,
-0.19113893806934357,
0.7831041216850281,
-0.21410465240478516,
-0.5681737661361694,
0.045991200953722,
-1.0631990432739258,
0.1482342779636383,
-0.3013373911380768,
-0.016592860221862793,
-0.04831259325146675,
-0.12440747022628784,
0.6204065084457397,
0.116790771484375,
0.47193118929862976,
0.4213266670703888,
-0.043418169021606445,
0.301391065120697,
-0.007587564643472433,
0.10181748867034912,
0.41460880637168884,
-0.2161313146352768,
0.2246888279914856,
0.192565456032753,
-0.6229346394538879,
-0.24432532489299774,
0.6002517938613892,
-0.6135843396186829,
-0.3078482449054718,
-0.35835886001586914,
-0.2886216640472412,
-0.6271678805351257,
0.3369104862213135,
0.24750261008739471,
0.3940443694591522,
-0.21432675421237946,
0.20408344268798828,
1.2093684673309326,
-0.6045615077018738,
0.2545042932033539,
0.28311145305633545,
-0.021860497072339058,
-0.3156691789627075,
0.5815793871879578,
-0.3813047409057617,
0.2852308750152588,
0.4969806373119354,
-0.3354530334472656,
-0.7117303013801575,
-0.2506730854511261,
-0.6415464878082275,
0.5219899415969849,
-0.685701310634613,
-0.5135641098022461,
-1.0433324575424194,
-0.404462069272995,
-0.16460199654102325,
-0.108600914478302,
-0.2716335356235504,
-0.07269603759050369,
-0.34715938568115234,
-0.030292639508843422,
0.23207569122314453,
0.49439358711242676,
0.14139647781848907,
-0.2853243350982666,
-1.1569972038269043,
0.681145429611206,
0.6846528649330139,
0.7135983109474182,
-0.2930651009082794,
0.26552096009254456,
-0.02590733766555786,
0.1988966017961502,
0.010932989418506622,
-1.5020852088928223,
-0.3655315339565277,
0.3776101768016815,
0.5420301556587219,
0.12657137215137482,
-0.20958559215068817,
0.5319830775260925,
-0.8735485672950745,
0.5811129212379456,
0.2845621407032013,
-0.6268152594566345,
0.7214328646659851,
-0.37102821469306946,
0.16746139526367188,
0.7930769920349121,
1.0892858505249023,
-0.22806085646152496,
-0.38323843479156494,
-0.5838258266448975,
-0.7019025683403015,
-0.04163862392306328,
0.31136247515678406,
-0.1771676391363144,
-0.5422669649124146,
0.6021308302879333,
0.1220095232129097,
0.21207749843597412,
-0.5785018801689148,
-0.6354044079780579,
-0.02159726805984974,
-0.07600565999746323,
0.3815537691116333,
-0.3076973259449005,
-0.17590196430683136,
-0.21172939240932465,
0.7182011604309082,
-0.2000102996826172,
0.6370843648910522,
0.2654712498188019,
-0.1781521886587143,
0.07078776508569717,
0.5775434970855713,
0.07646343111991882,
0.43151605129241943,
-0.1965665966272354,
-0.06033521890640259,
0.17900711297988892,
-0.23903679847717285,
0.16287168860435486,
0.3778643310070038,
-0.2590929865837097,
0.17348814010620117,
0.20038829743862152,
0.4662262201309204,
0.3125898838043213,
-0.5487126111984253,
0.17279256880283356,
0.23892004787921906,
-0.4911138713359833,
0.22912447154521942,
-0.12078016996383667,
0.6051077842712402,
0.34424540400505066,
0.24959103763103485,
0.09027691930532455,
0.5479611158370972,
-0.5138307809829712,
0.6424901485443115,
0.4884057343006134,
-0.3921044170856476,
-0.008928632363677025,
1.3859373331069946,
0.46161818504333496,
0.08007540553808212,
0.6920703053474426,
-0.07256188988685608,
-0.19480235874652863,
0.6456059813499451,
0.48834654688835144,
0.6414244174957275,
-0.3103925585746765,
0.42032238841056824,
0.7814022898674011,
0.06810899823904037,
0.2224341481924057,
0.5414954423904419,
0.15666960179805756,
-0.5939923524856567,
-0.6718629002571106,
-0.8162303566932678,
-0.45317134261131287,
0.16279323399066925,
-0.8317037224769592,
0.0744611993432045,
-0.017292840406298637,
-0.4964103698730469,
0.7035062313079834,
-0.2604816257953644,
-0.8401224613189697,
0.3434329330921173,
0.30280494689941406,
0.9508101940155029,
-0.6197736859321594,
0.9614014029502869,
1.1222680807113647,
-0.8988985419273376,
-0.6794652938842773,
-0.30122384428977966,
-0.19701500236988068,
-0.7201972603797913,
0.702171802520752,
-0.03383573517203331,
-0.17715179920196533,
0.192327618598938,
-0.5163961052894592,
-1.0211652517318726,
1.0621565580368042,
0.2916753590106964,
-0.5223751664161682,
-0.4541478157043457,
0.06463085860013962,
0.3758890628814697,
-0.1279982030391693,
0.3743807077407837,
0.46464142203330994,
0.4971837103366852,
0.035235315561294556,
-0.8776366114616394,
0.15440815687179565,
-0.17787261307239532,
-0.23233748972415924,
0.32035547494888306,
-0.5625269412994385,
0.6372893452644348,
-0.482756108045578,
-0.13200193643569946,
0.25337347388267517,
0.7811479568481445,
0.4471397399902344,
0.336873859167099,
0.3256230056285858,
0.17816130816936493,
0.9803357720375061,
0.07937140017747879,
0.7823359370231628,
-0.38749492168426514,
0.49348947405815125,
1.1989240646362305,
-0.43559181690216064,
0.7848425507545471,
0.49181172251701355,
-0.345072865486145,
0.6173385381698608,
0.8107995390892029,
-0.019722318276762962,
0.2349690943956375,
0.16370804607868195,
-0.4345104694366455,
-0.6407943367958069,
-0.2622821033000946,
-0.5963334441184998,
0.29771754145622253,
0.3923274576663971,
-0.23556028306484222,
-0.46949782967567444,
0.0021219346672296524,
-0.30839312076568604,
-0.056882549077272415,
-0.48619580268859863,
0.5399866104125977,
-0.010882112197577953,
-0.5325835347175598,
0.33541440963745117,
-0.3233296573162079,
0.45274510979652405,
-0.5720001459121704,
-0.41852930188179016,
0.04788829758763313,
-0.39121028780937195,
-0.12772347033023834,
-0.7674686312675476,
0.16646027565002441,
-0.2537963092327118,
-0.1687515825033188,
-0.07412949949502945,
0.882080614566803,
-0.8078081011772156,
-0.37877365946769714,
0.20267055928707123,
0.7428379058837891,
0.13288523256778717,
0.11752784252166748,
-1.0575536489486694,
-0.5323691964149475,
-0.18667902052402496,
0.05373377725481987,
0.28081411123275757,
0.146676704287529,
-0.012210923247039318,
0.9149656891822815,
0.5619169473648071,
0.015991736203432083,
-0.053003787994384766,
-0.11438480764627457,
0.8004956841468811,
-0.6931094527244568,
-0.2397763729095459,
-0.4660933315753937,
0.3383753001689911,
-0.12792305648326874,
-0.3083735406398773,
0.2150849848985672,
0.6497628092765808,
0.7718603610992432,
-0.1787569373846054,
0.607241690158844,
0.02895217575132847,
0.6676514148712158,
-0.5399734377861023,
0.7058863639831543,
-0.528134286403656,
-0.11136370897293091,
-0.04304702207446098,
-0.809455931186676,
-0.16427801549434662,
0.39964863657951355,
0.09367749094963074,
0.262835830450058,
1.08737051486969,
0.508964478969574,
-0.14814342558383942,
-0.11657767742872238,
0.07860928028821945,
0.19563375413417816,
-0.20834404230117798,
0.8992826342582703,
0.6181811690330505,
-0.33221444487571716,
0.47375407814979553,
-0.0017715817084535956,
-0.0066739595495164394,
0.1284317523241043,
-0.8294074535369873,
-0.9673833847045898,
-0.6473222374916077,
-0.6489703059196472,
-0.7133912444114685,
0.35305866599082947,
0.9783856868743896,
0.5478084087371826,
-0.8866903185844421,
0.3010566532611847,
0.5615149140357971,
-0.060325007885694504,
-0.053173672407865524,
-0.07842914760112762,
0.342649906873703,
-0.1335243433713913,
-0.6294439435005188,
0.30146655440330505,
0.37834659218788147,
0.04702676460146904,
-0.08879941701889038,
0.21985208988189697,
-0.7557680010795593,
0.1795281022787094,
0.5032520890235901,
0.5130522847175598,
-0.6516683101654053,
-0.4682135283946991,
0.14231908321380615,
-0.331779807806015,
-0.026994185522198677,
0.6373743414878845,
-0.9511238932609558,
0.21197645366191864,
0.08141068369150162,
1.2729631662368774,
0.42307284474372864,
-0.05938916280865669,
0.2457417994737625,
-0.6300272941589355,
-0.3778279721736908,
0.35096433758735657,
0.3156091868877411,
0.08409139513969421,
-0.6391991376876831,
0.4594540596008301,
-0.058071866631507874,
-0.48225700855255127,
-0.2137712687253952,
0.46976062655448914,
-1.0042039155960083,
-0.44965168833732605,
1.1500593423843384,
0.14394511282444,
-0.26842817664146423,
-0.32634174823760986,
-0.0327548086643219,
0.29865774512290955,
-0.15685006976127625,
0.499003142118454,
0.5047616362571716,
-0.1665617972612381,
0.28102347254753113,
-0.6264696717262268,
0.6982513070106506,
0.4610597789287567,
-0.9335691332817078,
-0.27472078800201416,
0.7764351963996887,
0.45297837257385254,
0.03906870633363724,
0.8821446299552917,
0.07777966558933258,
0.6600346565246582,
-0.1524771898984909,
0.041017163544893265,
0.08267240971326828,
-0.3820970356464386,
-0.062365900725126266,
0.07036508619785309,
-0.19823811948299408,
-0.161512091755867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15180v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15180v2
|
Break the Breakout: Reinventing LM Defense Against Jailbreak Attacks with Self-Refinement
| 2024-02-23T08:22:24 | 2024-02-27T01:39:20 |
Heegyu Kim, Sehyun Yuk, Hyunsouk Cho
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Caution: This paper includes offensive words that could potentially cause
unpleasantness. Language models (LMs) are vulnerable to exploitation for
adversarial misuse. Training LMs for safety alignment is extensive and makes it
hard to respond to fast-developing attacks immediately, such as jailbreaks. We
propose self-refine with formatting that achieves outstanding safety even in
non-safety-aligned LMs and evaluate our method alongside several defense
baselines, demonstrating that it is the safest training-free method against
jailbreak attacks. Additionally, we proposed a formatting method that improves
the efficiency of the self-refine process while reducing attack success rates
in fewer iterations. We've also observed that non-safety-aligned LMs outperform
safety-aligned LMs in safety tasks by giving more helpful and safe responses.
In conclusion, our findings can achieve less safety risk with fewer
computational costs, allowing non-safety LM to be easily utilized in real-world
service.
|
[
-0.19171881675720215,
-0.8036902546882629,
0.40223875641822815,
0.21006296575069427,
-0.07887748628854752,
0.5110361576080322,
0.0053045847453176975,
-0.5303868055343628,
0.2748601734638214,
0.5360369086265564,
-0.7327671647071838,
-0.35263413190841675,
-0.42914533615112305,
0.057344552129507065,
-0.5073085427284241,
1.1120511293411255,
0.029970861971378326,
-0.3200382590293884,
0.1244237944483757,
0.027092160657048225,
-0.7007680535316467,
-0.521148145198822,
-0.5609764456748962,
-0.04551262781023979,
0.42447054386138916,
0.4650954306125641,
0.6929741501808167,
0.9039402604103088,
0.4541088342666626,
0.2961786091327667,
-0.02327466569840908,
-0.08713621646165848,
-0.4355892837047577,
0.39257317781448364,
-0.3501468002796173,
-0.12145666778087616,
-0.31937381625175476,
-0.06604874134063721,
-0.05613735690712929,
0.3146359622478485,
-0.22083300352096558,
-0.16622646152973175,
-0.19737942516803741,
1.0112861394882202,
-0.7873783707618713,
-0.28942981362342834,
-0.8094363808631897,
0.09127222746610641,
-0.106366828083992,
0.1493922770023346,
-0.7485041618347168,
-0.31551963090896606,
-0.18089814484119415,
-0.12992489337921143,
0.01838325336575508,
-0.06715882569551468,
0.7701007127761841,
0.18744215369224548,
-0.14481274783611298,
-0.06260274350643158,
-0.5277509689331055,
0.47442784905433655,
-0.778306782245636,
0.20400327444076538,
0.16609783470630646,
0.20555777847766876,
-0.2956949770450592,
-0.4993077218532562,
-0.10556613653898239,
-0.40731269121170044,
0.0857882872223854,
-0.14773382246494293,
-0.2807195782661438,
0.08815447986125946,
0.09738267958164215,
0.12005045264959335,
-0.5454674363136292,
0.3340516686439514,
-0.6101381182670593,
-0.11102921515703201,
0.8805714249610901,
0.22624759376049042,
0.5193453431129456,
-0.08498118072748184,
-0.726783275604248,
-0.005702233407646418,
-1.099703311920166,
0.11231893301010132,
0.3026917576789856,
0.662190318107605,
-0.07235217094421387,
0.34586644172668457,
-0.1505708545446396,
0.628272533416748,
0.2076951116323471,
-0.24236510694026947,
0.29229944944381714,
-0.3711443245410919,
-0.2608446478843689,
0.37311214208602905,
1.1304867267608643,
0.443295955657959,
0.30114829540252686,
-0.43915998935699463,
-0.08845996856689453,
-0.17380918562412262,
0.8704255223274231,
-0.9048637747764587,
-0.3906124532222748,
0.3313758671283722,
-0.2582317292690277,
-0.7312593460083008,
0.05008262023329735,
-0.6990772485733032,
-0.583160400390625,
0.12406025826931,
0.23749062418937683,
-0.7412669658660889,
-0.2758651077747345,
-0.003255677642300725,
0.18624624609947205,
-0.06089675426483154,
-0.003547655651345849,
-1.0896387100219727,
0.24144595861434937,
0.4968167841434479,
0.8689672946929932,
0.1263323277235031,
-0.10846664011478424,
-0.3829071819782257,
0.08912087976932526,
-0.524260401725769,
0.529417872428894,
0.004456306807696819,
-0.558208703994751,
-0.18775905668735504,
0.022890472784638405,
-0.26888349652290344,
-0.5542594194412231,
0.28307685256004333,
-0.36195576190948486,
-0.21850821375846863,
0.08616243302822113,
-0.5569945573806763,
0.14778520166873932,
0.38772672414779663,
-0.7209202647209167,
0.7155792117118835,
0.04422188922762871,
-0.7380908131599426,
0.1407829076051712,
-0.6776741147041321,
-0.6924442648887634,
-0.10785134136676788,
-0.15423962473869324,
-0.7838084101676941,
-0.032385099679231644,
0.23972903192043304,
0.11354615539312363,
0.23704461753368378,
0.22205859422683716,
-0.4033724367618561,
-0.08554931730031967,
0.3644979000091553,
0.029866330325603485,
0.7520287036895752,
0.5694315433502197,
-0.7039005756378174,
0.3066622316837311,
-0.728196918964386,
0.21628989279270172,
0.3664488196372986,
-0.18688513338565826,
-0.20819738507270813,
0.15505963563919067,
-0.3392468988895416,
0.34675225615501404,
0.38287848234176636,
-0.7582226395606995,
0.2339201122522354,
-0.634528636932373,
0.40697813034057617,
0.8912550806999207,
-0.1234818547964096,
0.32520222663879395,
-0.04336004704236984,
0.5076348781585693,
0.06219702214002609,
0.4782775938510895,
-0.48614630103111267,
-0.13051529228687286,
-0.5520597696304321,
-0.27065715193748474,
0.23954790830612183,
0.7818912267684937,
-0.38789236545562744,
0.5686424374580383,
0.2261461615562439,
-0.7127061486244202,
-0.635536789894104,
0.5426694750785828,
0.7032595276832581,
0.587165355682373,
0.7192327976226807,
-0.2577195465564728,
-0.930415153503418,
-0.9278304576873779,
-0.4402782917022705,
-0.0674339309334755,
0.5450398921966553,
-0.1746128648519516,
0.1836133897304535,
-0.28774163126945496,
1.0777955055236816,
-0.40904244780540466,
0.041480518877506256,
-0.5444315075874329,
-0.061026547104120255,
0.04190673306584358,
0.7707834243774414,
0.6358121037483215,
-0.41829612851142883,
-0.5731304883956909,
-0.3283044397830963,
-0.9078704118728638,
-0.20731070637702942,
-0.09128809720277786,
0.22446751594543457,
0.2033342719078064,
0.9668270349502563,
-0.24396748840808868,
0.6734132766723633,
0.27861782908439636,
-0.6569263339042664,
0.6957563757896423,
-0.049516089260578156,
-0.21535837650299072,
-1.0060440301895142,
-0.2545790374279022,
-0.0015671239234507084,
-0.33451133966445923,
-0.9975792169570923,
0.32155323028564453,
0.30059346556663513,
-0.23137380182743073,
-0.6692594289779663,
0.20817942917346954,
-0.44395163655281067,
0.25070810317993164,
-0.5812458992004395,
0.0849863737821579,
-0.08054493367671967,
-0.0003283770347479731,
-0.15046942234039307,
0.9405009746551514,
0.5116713047027588,
-0.3689214885234833,
0.22680383920669556,
-0.022471627220511436,
-0.4247531592845917,
0.1898195743560791,
-0.7539568543434143,
0.4152972996234894,
-0.0506136454641819,
-0.11303552985191345,
-0.7472128868103027,
0.26349735260009766,
0.22134968638420105,
-0.15925239026546478,
0.41049355268478394,
-0.38330063223838806,
-0.3084278702735901,
-0.28587260842323303,
-0.3527272343635559,
0.2345597892999649,
0.5272324681282043,
-0.5906868577003479,
0.2500540614128113,
0.20214247703552246,
-0.053025100380182266,
-0.7411831021308899,
-0.6323028206825256,
0.286294162273407,
-0.5464417338371277,
-0.7279073596000671,
0.27696821093559265,
-0.2409021258354187,
-0.3036516010761261,
-0.44242000579833984,
-0.21572540700435638,
0.10199571400880814,
0.6537241339683533,
0.49615541100502014,
0.42815372347831726,
0.013876454904675484,
-0.27476179599761963,
-0.2508279085159302,
-0.1005907729268074,
0.12945766746997833,
-0.07513619214296341,
0.6468241810798645,
-0.27654731273651123,
-0.16193433105945587,
-0.4495852291584015,
0.2615327835083008,
0.4565874934196472,
-0.26289457082748413,
1.1632676124572754,
0.18488703668117523,
0.01574517786502838,
0.007999075576663017,
-0.43856674432754517,
-0.09260624647140503,
-0.6071817874908447,
0.15648388862609863,
-0.41089296340942383,
-1.025826334953308,
0.1858520656824112,
0.06688272953033447,
0.08660029619932175,
0.08652550727128983,
0.560321569442749,
-0.24201029539108276,
0.8332021236419678,
0.8467235565185547,
-0.23361650109291077,
0.7101534605026245,
0.15464983880519867,
0.7124769687652588,
-0.6164314150810242,
-0.4051732122898102,
-0.4569270610809326,
-0.11210817843675613,
-0.47625309228897095,
0.10806480050086975,
-0.1374807208776474,
0.42163583636283875,
-0.3940635919570923,
0.9855009913444519,
-0.5792202353477478,
0.5527034401893616,
0.24028809368610382,
0.11906567215919495,
-0.01760510727763176,
-0.2736634612083435,
-0.29958274960517883,
-0.1374637931585312,
-0.3040587306022644,
-0.47659656405448914,
1.0851881504058838,
0.6437724232673645,
1.14650297164917,
0.33765366673469543,
1.2411164045333862,
0.3559417724609375,
0.3782387375831604,
-0.4845271706581116,
0.5940536856651306,
0.05093657597899437,
-0.627051591873169,
-0.07588963955640793,
-0.38914617896080017,
-0.9758762121200562,
0.2591032087802887,
0.08280987292528152,
-1.2385202646255493,
-0.06735794246196747,
0.2084220051765442,
-0.4642351269721985,
0.4405379295349121,
-0.8488796949386597,
1.0986661911010742,
-0.43315771222114563,
-0.2500362694263458,
-0.02806260623037815,
-0.7587029933929443,
0.5774191617965698,
0.008568852208554745,
0.7322584986686707,
-0.3840489983558655,
0.3855167627334595,
0.7256615161895752,
-0.9300639629364014,
0.9922308921813965,
-0.2615666389465332,
-0.2095247507095337,
0.3628360331058502,
0.5002105236053467,
0.3904883563518524,
-0.13472755253314972,
0.2065497487783432,
-0.3498920202255249,
-0.015572126023471355,
-0.22904857993125916,
-0.49020859599113464,
0.5928565263748169,
-0.6682001352310181,
-0.944282054901123,
-0.413366436958313,
-0.5336339473724365,
-0.03880778327584267,
0.25555911660194397,
0.11460224539041519,
0.07643572241067886,
-0.2960153818130493,
0.041187599301338196,
0.7160369753837585,
0.04790232703089714,
0.848497211933136,
0.576154351234436,
-0.40300434827804565,
-0.5353102684020996,
0.7042195796966553,
-0.13873477280139923,
0.44621407985687256,
-0.07781992852687836,
0.04552549868822098,
-0.25142788887023926,
-0.6478603482246399,
-0.2778913974761963,
-0.024596931412816048,
-0.5879472494125366,
-0.35899484157562256,
-0.4682689309120178,
-0.5097612738609314,
-0.7188419699668884,
-0.19838693737983704,
-0.715295672416687,
-0.5016055703163147,
-0.11305668950080872,
-0.5446616411209106,
0.44214746356010437,
0.5050138831138611,
-0.3394150733947754,
0.409509539604187,
-0.8631201386451721,
0.19055861234664917,
-0.0066276309080421925,
0.13546434044837952,
-0.3001042902469635,
-0.5697178244590759,
-0.5714524984359741,
-0.2964106798171997,
-0.5901663303375244,
-1.1544132232666016,
0.43310096859931946,
-0.1807410717010498,
0.335801899433136,
0.6302903294563293,
0.2124493569135666,
0.5324453711509705,
-0.8366521000862122,
0.6048795580863953,
0.6823886632919312,
-0.9257829785346985,
0.9582253098487854,
-0.15959911048412323,
0.008112038485705853,
0.9868385195732117,
0.15590783953666687,
-0.34696322679519653,
-0.44154149293899536,
-0.743953287601471,
-1.1185336112976074,
0.45117610692977905,
0.09066230058670044,
0.09567306935787201,
-0.35113203525543213,
0.24572879076004028,
-0.21248066425323486,
0.15298619866371155,
-1.0973641872406006,
-0.42297857999801636,
-0.4754018485546112,
-0.2406434267759323,
0.1705753058195114,
-0.3255366086959839,
-0.48805031180381775,
-0.17874574661254883,
0.6735357046127319,
0.0778510719537735,
0.0470806322991848,
0.08406123518943787,
-0.2979671359062195,
0.1762833297252655,
0.69345623254776,
0.5630719065666199,
0.5107744336128235,
-0.2255348116159439,
0.2157462239265442,
-0.15163631737232208,
-0.4077736437320709,
0.5969524383544922,
-0.06258609890937805,
-0.31332719326019287,
-0.20512807369232178,
0.2158033698797226,
0.7526935338973999,
0.16354741156101227,
-0.8644876480102539,
0.33912524580955505,
0.03619661554694176,
-0.022744081914424896,
-0.3408200740814209,
0.5443722605705261,
-0.02379515767097473,
0.09045879542827606,
0.20675359666347504,
-0.020430730655789375,
-0.17005927860736847,
-0.592936635017395,
0.4113248288631439,
0.3855512738227844,
-0.5648654699325562,
-0.02486012876033783,
0.5858742594718933,
0.10647573322057724,
-0.5744866728782654,
0.5744736790657043,
-0.06293430924415588,
-0.5312669277191162,
0.615894615650177,
0.9722567200660706,
1.0539731979370117,
-0.5346209406852722,
-0.013152288272976875,
0.29823458194732666,
0.8137236833572388,
0.12613365054130554,
0.20017965137958527,
0.19332976639270782,
-0.7951196432113647,
-0.18638835847377777,
-0.29096129536628723,
-0.2913450598716736,
0.27280890941619873,
-0.7894651889801025,
-0.03670137748122215,
-1.1492472887039185,
-0.2795899212360382,
-0.3561490476131439,
-0.4217779040336609,
-0.05228908360004425,
0.5133395791053772,
0.2756424844264984,
1.3283092975616455,
-0.7256343960762024,
0.7836585640907288,
0.40074095129966736,
-0.511464536190033,
-0.7871838808059692,
-0.24417470395565033,
0.20052173733711243,
-0.5338600277900696,
0.5281368494033813,
0.6335912346839905,
-0.2139856219291687,
-0.42156466841697693,
-0.5930648446083069,
-0.9968147873878479,
0.9241717457771301,
0.30963724851608276,
-0.8294817209243774,
-0.05038819462060928,
0.05448658764362335,
0.2580624222755432,
-0.5530908703804016,
-0.04472110792994499,
0.9627324938774109,
0.14522971212863922,
-0.26295289397239685,
-0.8557301163673401,
0.3432251214981079,
-0.2671605944633484,
-0.012631102465093136,
0.3560125231742859,
-0.6821790933609009,
0.736211359500885,
-0.476280152797699,
-0.125270277261734,
0.23891094326972961,
0.8382100462913513,
0.4396061897277832,
0.11513374000787735,
0.37884122133255005,
0.9853528738021851,
0.584221363067627,
-0.14642494916915894,
0.8195304274559021,
-0.5074638724327087,
0.18801362812519073,
1.4493223428726196,
-0.2652808427810669,
0.7651428580284119,
0.5773733258247375,
-0.06948618590831757,
1.0822769403457642,
0.49330654740333557,
-0.20507995784282684,
0.9652549028396606,
0.3495120108127594,
-0.33606982231140137,
-0.12814782559871674,
0.37247148156166077,
-0.41652634739875793,
0.30827829241752625,
0.2004939615726471,
-0.5358872413635254,
-0.37258076667785645,
0.000962225953117013,
0.6627559661865234,
0.18464328348636627,
-0.387858510017395,
0.7643890380859375,
0.14751873910427094,
-0.4805055558681488,
0.6058659553527832,
0.37410518527030945,
0.5131803154945374,
-0.6489549279212952,
0.6410608291625977,
-0.28656867146492004,
0.3235517740249634,
-0.4614540934562683,
-0.6515401005744934,
0.5405647158622742,
0.40954941511154175,
-0.15699632465839386,
-0.11132677644491196,
0.6948692798614502,
-0.08884003758430481,
-0.0781211405992508,
0.566953182220459,
0.21210847795009613,
-0.07604518532752991,
0.09855317324399948,
-0.950977623462677,
0.23109763860702515,
0.0381731316447258,
-0.22067971527576447,
0.7495875358581543,
-0.15672394633293152,
0.17965923249721527,
0.919052004814148,
0.5903595089912415,
-0.319134384393692,
0.35112088918685913,
0.15625646710395813,
0.921571671962738,
-1.0298463106155396,
-0.7198963761329651,
-1.4298914670944214,
0.7041038274765015,
-0.23582661151885986,
0.18416523933410645,
0.982310950756073,
0.5737136602401733,
0.5988402366638184,
0.04145589470863342,
0.9157320261001587,
-0.1666414886713028,
0.37981054186820984,
-0.6306602358818054,
0.8056527972221375,
-0.03383554890751839,
0.28359341621398926,
-0.36667731404304504,
-0.36183589696884155,
-0.1001124233007431,
0.6084505319595337,
-0.4661349058151245,
0.0064411647617816925,
0.7121143937110901,
0.5437883734703064,
0.279629111289978,
-0.1086125299334526,
0.22790344059467316,
0.2258160263299942,
0.6607643961906433,
0.5487481951713562,
0.808647871017456,
-0.4400933086872101,
0.6621001362800598,
-0.3747268617153168,
-0.20885154604911804,
0.01519718300551176,
-1.0860507488250732,
-1.1193088293075562,
0.11911947280168533,
-0.47332990169525146,
-0.8953217267990112,
0.10922263562679291,
0.923519492149353,
0.774939239025116,
-0.9530301690101624,
-0.3551446497440338,
-0.08646780997514725,
-0.00952861551195383,
-0.08241093903779984,
-0.26039475202560425,
-0.023382047191262245,
-0.7959275245666504,
-0.06807790696620941,
1.3934640884399414,
0.41285473108291626,
0.15784837305545807,
-0.07169187068939209,
-0.019569972530007362,
-0.24932073056697845,
0.17038290202617645,
0.22650355100631714,
0.8752660751342773,
-0.5267534852027893,
-0.2707243263721466,
-0.2024080455303192,
-0.2521134316921234,
0.40789616107940674,
0.748884916305542,
-0.707822322845459,
0.49116888642311096,
-0.21467150747776031,
0.7757672071456909,
0.3141235113143921,
0.19715499877929688,
0.565106213092804,
-0.9085873961448669,
0.20788633823394775,
-0.12363000214099884,
0.5418328046798706,
0.4592653214931488,
-0.463022381067276,
0.4372101426124573,
0.1455271989107132,
-0.3530147075653076,
-0.8674123883247375,
0.5919276475906372,
-0.5914003252983093,
-0.506711483001709,
0.675850510597229,
-0.4060550034046173,
-0.3333292305469513,
-0.21968697011470795,
0.04437636211514473,
-0.017928916960954666,
-0.41494274139404297,
0.9958270192146301,
0.43339991569519043,
-0.2327692210674286,
-0.3693327009677887,
-0.14722657203674316,
0.6383846402168274,
0.3901219964027405,
-0.9691036939620972,
0.16067655384540558,
0.12129049748182297,
0.7945912480354309,
0.36708182096481323,
0.491928368806839,
-0.356753408908844,
0.4558580815792084,
-0.28532907366752625,
0.15124790370464325,
-0.3783751130104065,
-0.6657487750053406,
-0.46621114015579224,
0.3112170100212097,
0.20269903540611267,
-0.19168196618556976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15179v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15179v3
|
Advancing Parameter Efficiency in Fine-tuning via Representation Editing
| 2024-02-23T08:21:02 | 2024-06-02T09:05:31 |
Muling Wu, Wenhao Liu, Xiaohua Wang, Tianlong Li, Changze Lv, Zixuan Ling, Jianhao Zhu, Cenyuan Zhang, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) techniques have drawn significant
attention due to their ability to yield competitive results while updating only
a small portion of the adjustable parameters. However, existing PEFT methods
pose challenges in hyperparameter selection, such as choosing the rank for LoRA
or Adapter, or specifying the length of soft prompts. To address these
challenges, we propose a novel fine-tuning approach for neural models, named
Representation EDiting (RED), which modifies the representations generated at
some layers through the application of scaling and biasing operations. While
existing PEFT methods still demonstrate over-parameterization that could
potentially undermine the generalization ability acquired from pre-training,
RED can substantially reduce the number of trainable parameters by a factor of
25, 700 compared to full parameter fine-tuning and by a factor of 32 relative
to LoRA. Remarkably, RED achieves results comparable or superior to both full
parameter fine-tuning and other PEFT methods. Extensive experiments across
various model architectures and scales, including RoBERTa, GPT-2, T5, and
LLaMA-2, have demonstrated the effectiveness and efficiency of RED1, thereby
positioning it as a promising PEFT strategy for large-scale neural models.
|
[
-0.6359357237815857,
-0.6231591105461121,
0.5405833721160889,
0.17501600086688995,
-0.43713995814323425,
-0.32912901043891907,
-0.7392133474349976,
-0.3475649058818817,
0.22470034658908844,
0.3463747501373291,
-0.28905239701271057,
-0.3122420907020569,
-0.7400112748146057,
0.02175259031355381,
0.009184641763567924,
0.9194902777671814,
0.025830095633864403,
0.13286949694156647,
0.10592810064554214,
-0.36926478147506714,
-0.46347540616989136,
-0.39720839262008667,
-0.8209904432296753,
-0.49896496534347534,
0.8143842220306396,
0.19936488568782806,
0.6855545043945312,
0.8452199697494507,
0.46151965856552124,
0.33329007029533386,
-0.555017352104187,
0.4684581458568573,
-0.42749425768852234,
0.18257980048656464,
-0.46090272068977356,
-0.5545271039009094,
-0.772522509098053,
-0.04134829714894295,
0.7209091782569885,
0.8432074785232544,
-0.03094276413321495,
0.2792559564113617,
0.042576808482408524,
0.9052921533584595,
-0.8987541794776917,
0.11827095597982407,
-0.9954333305358887,
0.02166561409831047,
0.06557056307792664,
-0.11178819835186005,
-0.4863382875919342,
-0.12012587487697601,
-0.07495978474617004,
-0.8676078915596008,
0.140522301197052,
-0.3795371353626251,
0.8546749353408813,
0.5622634887695312,
-0.11024694889783859,
0.505623459815979,
-0.7132139801979065,
0.7429475784301758,
-0.6421526074409485,
0.38380640745162964,
0.415361225605011,
0.3546527028083801,
0.17735035717487335,
-0.9332765340805054,
-0.04524112865328789,
-0.050206322222948074,
-0.11734473705291748,
-0.21002501249313354,
-0.42253169417381287,
0.42440661787986755,
0.6364232301712036,
-0.11491991579532623,
0.14517611265182495,
0.0556914247572422,
-0.30803045630455017,
-0.24930940568447113,
0.5800058841705322,
0.09306935220956802,
-0.20696106553077698,
0.03470669686794281,
0.06493530422449112,
-0.18533799052238464,
-0.7470560073852539,
-0.38638946413993835,
0.41295865178108215,
0.5361665487289429,
0.3289448320865631,
0.4621482193470001,
-0.2407446801662445,
0.9234848022460938,
0.666102409362793,
0.5610502362251282,
-0.06647410243749619,
-0.04042840376496315,
-0.4415145218372345,
-0.049949806183576584,
0.42903777956962585,
0.6403918862342834,
0.253047913312912,
0.05837271735072136,
-0.4328487515449524,
-0.2448958307504654,
0.4202706813812256,
-1.008275032043457,
-0.46016064286231995,
-0.028367308899760246,
-0.6571623682975769,
-0.18149814009666443,
-0.21643011271953583,
-0.9279593825340271,
-0.5875885486602783,
-0.5641670823097229,
0.6655023694038391,
-0.3594042658805847,
-0.19043861329555511,
0.19421005249023438,
-0.30415529012680054,
-0.07032908499240875,
0.7813558578491211,
-1.1246753931045532,
0.2514193654060364,
0.4947439134120941,
0.7477530837059021,
0.08883513510227203,
-0.2449643313884735,
-0.5341672897338867,
-0.0004679156409110874,
-0.41811516880989075,
0.6182103753089905,
-0.7722128033638,
-0.023900864645838737,
-0.3661148250102997,
-0.08124560117721558,
-0.07015066593885422,
-0.8553194403648376,
0.31677719950675964,
-0.684131383895874,
-0.28118017315864563,
-0.487703412771225,
-0.37901607155799866,
-0.16955727338790894,
0.25989067554473877,
-0.7981979846954346,
0.5601868033409119,
0.16231320798397064,
-0.4127653241157532,
0.49321550130844116,
-0.8989725708961487,
-0.15827251970767975,
-0.24136464297771454,
0.010715167969465256,
-0.5436887145042419,
0.5183470845222473,
0.6031531691551208,
0.5235785841941833,
-0.010279509238898754,
0.01096744742244482,
-0.2756134569644928,
-0.6295397281646729,
-0.10721917450428009,
-0.4712214171886444,
0.37103477120399475,
0.03864706680178642,
-0.36187487840652466,
0.38887324929237366,
-0.79361492395401,
0.23604774475097656,
0.06812386959791183,
-0.3200418949127197,
-0.36091333627700806,
-0.023607615381479263,
0.07129131257534027,
-0.10673268139362335,
0.40069302916526794,
-0.5372540354728699,
0.5721806287765503,
-0.334455668926239,
0.9058921933174133,
0.9345406889915466,
0.09617342799901962,
0.5552211999893188,
-0.12416058778762817,
0.2651347517967224,
-0.0943029448390007,
0.205182284116745,
-0.08816908299922943,
-0.24090933799743652,
-0.7577333450317383,
-0.17814016342163086,
0.9649214148521423,
-0.014264113269746304,
-0.19974346458911896,
0.3496053218841553,
-0.027795063331723213,
-0.6043442487716675,
-0.5567002892494202,
-0.07172813266515732,
0.17082907259464264,
0.27822771668434143,
0.6707897186279297,
0.2290242463350296,
-0.5777755975723267,
-1.1450507640838623,
-0.5135073661804199,
-0.0020147040486335754,
-0.06219564378261566,
0.34453505277633667,
0.37334778904914856,
-0.18433316051959991,
0.7148783206939697,
-0.6537542343139648,
-0.1763453632593155,
0.08082706481218338,
0.15320685505867004,
0.25777098536491394,
0.8235117197036743,
0.7384321689605713,
-0.6362806558609009,
-0.530447244644165,
0.2825040817260742,
-0.16179919242858887,
0.12805159389972687,
-0.30770179629325867,
-0.1996215134859085,
-0.058540064841508865,
0.5605078339576721,
-0.6208230257034302,
0.3817708492279053,
0.1809130311012268,
-0.3990413546562195,
0.47466519474983215,
-0.6193299293518066,
0.29907917976379395,
-0.49937671422958374,
0.049611255526542664,
0.16581843793392181,
-0.2353031486272812,
-0.4103224277496338,
0.17241570353507996,
0.5016375780105591,
-0.14175380766391754,
-0.4173821806907654,
0.41986650228500366,
-0.5007418990135193,
0.12573908269405365,
-0.1657642275094986,
-0.4405564069747925,
0.08823440223932266,
0.7326825261116028,
-0.001692703808657825,
0.868416965007782,
0.3580970764160156,
-0.37344640493392944,
-0.10368568450212479,
0.09399718791246414,
-0.060834407806396484,
0.4080852270126343,
-1.1084721088409424,
0.3219417929649353,
-0.07946936786174774,
0.006876722443848848,
-0.6496273279190063,
-0.12898628413677216,
0.04809514060616493,
-0.139071524143219,
0.47449418902397156,
-0.6390233039855957,
-0.4954870343208313,
0.2437315434217453,
-0.3756861686706543,
0.4813905656337738,
0.5644320845603943,
-0.6917877793312073,
0.7111918330192566,
0.10562238842248917,
-0.028645215556025505,
-0.21862322092056274,
-0.7682474255561829,
0.0015455270186066628,
-0.3993729054927826,
-0.5242133736610413,
1.0269689559936523,
0.14749793708324432,
0.036032792180776596,
-0.25665992498397827,
-0.2406156212091446,
-0.08540672808885574,
-0.0010343010071665049,
-0.08803705871105194,
-0.09177613258361816,
-0.2087715119123459,
0.10570012778043747,
0.6790983080863953,
-0.1955617070198059,
0.01162470132112503,
-0.131041020154953,
0.38991299271583557,
-0.054923150688409805,
-0.3284069895744324,
-0.5259369015693665,
0.3963637053966522,
0.8641744256019592,
-0.48335105180740356,
0.6336829662322998,
0.5166842937469482,
-0.5942567586898804,
-0.37708672881126404,
-0.3607853949069977,
-0.3317881226539612,
-0.5472007989883423,
0.6583107113838196,
-0.322418749332428,
-0.6403128504753113,
0.6072273850440979,
-0.47894442081451416,
0.007335408125072718,
0.3942265212535858,
0.3527105748653412,
-0.008091271854937077,
1.519973635673523,
0.4984600245952606,
0.2734987735748291,
0.8672624826431274,
-0.4682884216308594,
-0.20287583768367767,
-1.096177339553833,
-0.014273291453719139,
-0.4517047703266144,
-1.0089970827102661,
-0.5118146538734436,
-0.4358190596103668,
0.6193451881408691,
0.2746707499027252,
-0.7165687680244446,
0.3329296112060547,
-1.0212249755859375,
0.8097169995307922,
0.47482240200042725,
0.643174946308136,
-0.027271347120404243,
0.24971579015254974,
0.14236725866794586,
-0.35155758261680603,
-0.546016275882721,
-0.2854144871234894,
1.0991477966308594,
0.4236277639865875,
0.7147210836410522,
-0.14986464381217957,
0.6521260142326355,
0.25093191862106323,
-0.12715721130371094,
-0.6326228380203247,
0.5726751685142517,
-0.5441062450408936,
-0.34407615661621094,
-0.3586478531360626,
-0.21176429092884064,
-0.6702198386192322,
0.36843565106391907,
-0.23547151684761047,
-0.6742015480995178,
0.7218528985977173,
0.5277372002601624,
-0.7294912338256836,
0.5068955421447754,
-0.9712519645690918,
0.7065399885177612,
-0.0026108063757419586,
-0.43674635887145996,
-0.4824322760105133,
-0.2951659560203552,
-0.23929756879806519,
0.01859162747859955,
-0.6268615126609802,
0.11645074933767319,
-0.42704588174819946,
0.9235782623291016,
-0.47630566358566284,
0.7503591775894165,
-0.714121401309967,
0.21213608980178833,
0.02490927278995514,
0.11343005299568176,
0.883547306060791,
0.17360767722129822,
-0.5786299109458923,
0.2097148895263672,
-0.1511588841676712,
-0.44248154759407043,
-1.0725536346435547,
0.7185417413711548,
-0.7714889049530029,
-0.5115658640861511,
-0.006623867433518171,
-0.5323205590248108,
-0.49530261754989624,
0.12772241234779358,
0.19362401962280273,
0.18330813944339752,
0.11306942999362946,
0.4089341163635254,
0.599502682685852,
-0.10401305556297302,
0.2576025724411011,
-0.01907195895910263,
0.21252721548080444,
-0.6321077346801758,
0.8661578297615051,
0.4118471145629883,
0.15698593854904175,
0.18216250836849213,
0.23109787702560425,
-0.18484312295913696,
-1.0776695013046265,
-0.4658828377723694,
0.24377362430095673,
-0.6312497854232788,
-0.4563262164592743,
-0.43345707654953003,
-0.06254474818706512,
0.11481000483036041,
-0.26257845759391785,
-0.6759406328201294,
-0.5978654026985168,
-0.5744955539703369,
0.02079637348651886,
0.601920485496521,
0.5558443665504456,
-0.14105375111103058,
0.4915860891342163,
-0.5975619554519653,
0.3004412353038788,
0.48799416422843933,
0.702381432056427,
-0.08462006598711014,
-0.661002516746521,
-0.31718704104423523,
0.09134543687105179,
-0.17759931087493896,
-0.7847634553909302,
0.18413805961608887,
0.4012160897254944,
0.4169330596923828,
0.10813412070274353,
-0.16691206395626068,
1.2725416421890259,
-0.5325729846954346,
0.744925856590271,
0.19210779666900635,
-1.0202984809875488,
0.8124296069145203,
-0.4929001033306122,
0.26969605684280396,
0.7324172258377075,
-0.021406682208180428,
-0.06963406503200531,
0.174821138381958,
-0.5050765872001648,
-0.7922723889350891,
0.7777143120765686,
0.0734110102057457,
0.5605564713478088,
0.2399919629096985,
0.8428155779838562,
0.0710514485836029,
0.08492425084114075,
-0.3614659607410431,
-0.2409258931875229,
-0.23512002825737,
0.06457080692052841,
0.3490680158138275,
-0.30818358063697815,
-0.1412394493818283,
-0.9587461352348328,
0.501875102519989,
-0.407289981842041,
0.5662879943847656,
0.22290953993797302,
0.1226876825094223,
-0.34906360507011414,
0.1411091685295105,
0.6291862726211548,
0.8121422529220581,
-0.30359211564064026,
0.04693245887756348,
0.39412426948547363,
-0.3143942356109619,
0.03613089770078659,
0.2166040688753128,
-0.3076353669166565,
-0.03164695203304291,
0.30110692977905273,
1.0985877513885498,
0.12270251661539078,
-0.27793046832084656,
0.2163666933774948,
-0.06185023859143257,
-0.4524146616458893,
0.25542470812797546,
0.4549868702888489,
-0.05430471524596214,
0.48768067359924316,
0.15132421255111694,
0.6978752613067627,
-0.02274044044315815,
0.009168182499706745,
0.1411624252796173,
0.37828660011291504,
-0.44367918372154236,
-0.3435197174549103,
0.802175760269165,
0.1257038414478302,
-0.31360936164855957,
0.5820650458335876,
0.05821990966796875,
-0.11230245232582092,
0.6760178208351135,
0.5035117864608765,
0.860892653465271,
0.06821277737617493,
0.1324654370546341,
0.6017464399337769,
0.15630674362182617,
-0.11727817356586456,
0.20225471258163452,
-0.04374370723962784,
-0.4691392481327057,
-0.5734663009643555,
-0.5857495069503784,
-0.2543010711669922,
0.2200377732515335,
-0.7627306580543518,
0.2800227105617523,
-0.8926380276679993,
-0.5160195827484131,
0.2555863857269287,
-0.1418938934803009,
-0.4504490792751312,
0.10210008919239044,
-0.025521164759993553,
1.1822478771209717,
-0.5641910433769226,
0.7182292342185974,
1.1425585746765137,
-0.15731550753116608,
-0.7971141934394836,
-0.0003190561255905777,
-0.5255544185638428,
-0.47061386704444885,
0.5178462266921997,
-0.2663156986236572,
0.27378326654434204,
0.007655743043869734,
-0.6934869885444641,
-0.6947070360183716,
1.0081193447113037,
1.2486199140548706,
-0.9045860171318054,
-0.1685275286436081,
-0.14319917559623718,
0.6339656114578247,
-0.18090757727622986,
0.20203332602977753,
0.8710619211196899,
0.8009482622146606,
-0.28123563528060913,
-0.6990142464637756,
0.0698142722249031,
-0.3115547299385071,
0.28842270374298096,
0.396879106760025,
-0.6347648501396179,
0.9270328879356384,
-0.10263803601264954,
0.18358705937862396,
0.0634559616446495,
0.6583160758018494,
0.32238173484802246,
-0.1611804962158203,
0.6981344223022461,
0.31343013048171997,
0.7222576141357422,
-0.2048744410276413,
0.6780593991279602,
-0.2949208915233612,
0.49155130982398987,
1.1279640197753906,
0.2062976062297821,
0.6751711964607239,
0.7679290175437927,
-0.3372024893760681,
0.13122312724590302,
0.6444938778877258,
-0.2098979502916336,
0.6010298728942871,
0.1712980419397354,
0.07185657322406769,
-0.5661253333091736,
0.10814851522445679,
-0.34782126545906067,
0.4192348122596741,
0.24754999577999115,
-0.7657553553581238,
-0.3370214104652405,
-0.01476797554641962,
-0.12971557676792145,
0.28273990750312805,
-0.6100552678108215,
0.6224433779716492,
-0.19032005965709686,
-0.568564236164093,
0.9279607534408569,
0.17366138100624084,
0.6996060013771057,
-0.4960651695728302,
-0.5674464106559753,
-0.13335087895393372,
0.10499473661184311,
-0.286471426486969,
-0.6452584862709045,
0.42015036940574646,
0.014443389140069485,
-0.4571148753166199,
-0.281965434551239,
0.6900262236595154,
-0.35291168093681335,
-0.4853723645210266,
0.3656558394432068,
0.1910790205001831,
-0.3811936676502228,
-0.7160812020301819,
-0.9218280911445618,
0.4187289774417877,
0.02383997291326523,
-0.4539143741130829,
0.44137948751449585,
0.3079873323440552,
0.033466093242168427,
0.23881690204143524,
0.3524228632450104,
0.46623826026916504,
-0.10918230563402176,
0.0957307517528534,
1.0877418518066406,
-0.7469466924667358,
-0.3498595952987671,
-0.8289825916290283,
0.6240093111991882,
-0.09547147899866104,
-0.5037875771522522,
0.12355972826480865,
0.06765720993280411,
0.6590098142623901,
-0.21084749698638916,
0.4615190923213959,
-0.012901276350021362,
-0.03834516555070877,
-0.4435252547264099,
1.0446057319641113,
-0.6858093738555908,
0.21256744861602783,
-0.25723910331726074,
-1.0630810260772705,
-0.5130085945129395,
0.6413170695304871,
-0.42941558361053467,
0.2547830641269684,
0.3453631103038788,
0.8616830110549927,
-0.3384307324886322,
-0.06305810809135437,
0.48930686712265015,
0.2936464846134186,
0.22766746580600739,
0.4004047214984894,
0.5225561261177063,
-0.6286200881004333,
0.3505760729312897,
-0.450437068939209,
-0.015610959380865097,
0.015332790091633797,
-0.8073241114616394,
-0.7260184288024902,
-0.5091216564178467,
-0.4629627466201782,
-0.05342601612210274,
0.23948238790035248,
0.9838021993637085,
1.2643253803253174,
-0.8111119866371155,
0.3346567153930664,
-0.16192367672920227,
-0.12522706389427185,
-0.57619708776474,
-0.1083488017320633,
0.5939380526542664,
-0.274534672498703,
-0.8472175002098083,
0.427033394575119,
0.08430682122707367,
-0.1604158580303192,
-0.06437856703996658,
-0.1410510390996933,
0.0019161974778398871,
-0.009280082769691944,
0.7022130489349365,
0.05909742787480354,
-0.6400802135467529,
-0.52646404504776,
-0.17859913408756256,
0.3551256060600281,
0.2995591461658478,
0.6698112487792969,
-0.8264783024787903,
0.444077730178833,
0.5206871628761292,
0.7914255857467651,
0.549506664276123,
0.009688036516308784,
0.562361478805542,
-0.8058426380157471,
0.024868041276931763,
0.40793460607528687,
0.4466659128665924,
0.18771149218082428,
-0.5633704662322998,
0.40113401412963867,
-0.03827246278524399,
-0.5145213007926941,
-0.8983392119407654,
0.07647033035755157,
-1.010317325592041,
-0.3765074908733368,
0.9225233793258667,
0.0312822051346302,
-0.22562110424041748,
0.3851185739040375,
-0.5462179780006409,
0.21876032650470734,
-0.49955621361732483,
0.6729170083999634,
0.35336557030677795,
-0.44434383511543274,
-0.266560822725296,
-0.08846661448478699,
0.5736090540885925,
0.6962884664535522,
-0.6149823665618896,
0.4105059802532196,
0.4133192300796509,
0.2750574052333832,
0.10076592862606049,
0.25738418102264404,
-0.20811901986598969,
0.5266935229301453,
-0.17858880758285522,
-0.18553820252418518,
-0.5193421244621277,
-0.5349610447883606,
-0.7208001613616943,
0.37027978897094727,
0.22256866097450256,
-0.17448420822620392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15162v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15162v1
|
Entity-level Factual Adaptiveness of Fine-tuning based Abstractive Summarization Models
| 2024-02-23T07:53:39 | 2024-02-23T07:53:39 |
Jongyoon Song, Nohil Park, Bongkyu Hwang, Jaewoong Yun, Seongho Joe, Youngjune L. Gwon, Sungroh Yoon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Abstractive summarization models often generate factually inconsistent
content particularly when the parametric knowledge of the model conflicts with
the knowledge in the input document. In this paper, we analyze the robustness
of fine-tuning based summarization models to the knowledge conflict, which we
call factual adaptiveness. We utilize pre-trained language models to construct
evaluation sets and find that factual adaptiveness is not strongly correlated
with factual consistency on original datasets. Furthermore, we introduce a
controllable counterfactual data augmentation method where the degree of
knowledge conflict within the augmented data can be adjustable. Our
experimental results on two pre-trained language models (PEGASUS and BART) and
two fine-tuning datasets (XSum and CNN/DailyMail) demonstrate that our method
enhances factual adaptiveness while achieving factual consistency on original
datasets on par with the contrastive learning baseline.
|
[
-0.39936283230781555,
-0.8686110973358154,
0.4891897439956665,
-0.07365714758634567,
-0.3227059841156006,
0.28127965331077576,
-0.24453632533550262,
-0.5435497164726257,
0.10472279787063599,
0.46291881799697876,
-0.25867539644241333,
-0.48488667607307434,
-0.79375159740448,
0.1364278346300125,
-0.3535554111003876,
1.5375767946243286,
-0.1839386224746704,
-0.16608411073684692,
-0.3815172612667084,
-0.6287681460380554,
-0.4824689030647278,
-0.2523583471775055,
-0.415613055229187,
0.007885398343205452,
0.28935346007347107,
0.5464553833007812,
0.7999025583267212,
0.6139424443244934,
0.5281635522842407,
0.32025980949401855,
0.056448765099048615,
0.47697150707244873,
-0.6797031164169312,
0.1205015629529953,
-0.7501801252365112,
-0.4339843988418579,
-0.7224030494689941,
-0.23171116411685944,
0.6387141942977905,
0.6138073205947876,
-0.2163887917995453,
0.21037204563617706,
0.132640078663826,
0.7266208529472351,
-0.8372408151626587,
0.2508644759654999,
-1.0155832767486572,
-0.38922610878944397,
0.21723045408725739,
-0.2743596136569977,
-0.14057743549346924,
-0.509909451007843,
0.28030624985694885,
-0.8770319223403931,
0.4881666898727417,
0.18773990869522095,
1.0525288581848145,
0.4885527789592743,
-0.30488649010658264,
-0.5129144191741943,
-0.6877503395080566,
0.5331464409828186,
-1.044460415840149,
0.21627794206142426,
0.19875024259090424,
-0.050585050135850906,
0.09675127267837524,
-0.6513219475746155,
-0.6906759738922119,
-0.11168722808361053,
-0.1409202516078949,
0.2959348261356354,
-0.421997994184494,
-0.04632919654250145,
0.2916278839111328,
0.28909361362457275,
-0.5277981758117676,
0.12624943256378174,
-0.3196374773979187,
-0.12454023212194443,
0.5202251672744751,
0.22343160212039948,
0.3673190772533417,
0.008579702116549015,
-0.1324373185634613,
0.21648509800434113,
-0.6115596294403076,
0.14086638391017914,
0.19035814702510834,
0.4347955286502838,
-0.3613656163215637,
0.6393266916275024,
-0.5736041069030762,
0.7328047156333923,
0.4589904844760895,
-0.1022045835852623,
0.07101467996835709,
-0.6529625654220581,
-0.37017467617988586,
0.4579828381538391,
0.33107486367225647,
0.7261654138565063,
0.3042575716972351,
-0.03492572158575058,
-0.25248509645462036,
0.10268107056617737,
0.29890602827072144,
-0.846381425857544,
-0.31169593334198,
0.2799912691116333,
-0.23129186034202576,
-0.4735811948776245,
-0.18432290852069855,
-0.45001766085624695,
-0.2295738160610199,
-0.5096889734268188,
0.656177818775177,
-0.47211211919784546,
-0.20299634337425232,
0.12665367126464844,
0.05739070847630501,
-0.22889043390750885,
0.4661828875541687,
-0.9815822839736938,
0.257442831993103,
0.60897296667099,
0.7277799248695374,
-0.06870801746845245,
-0.22130416333675385,
-0.4062494933605194,
0.2834698557853699,
-0.6936794519424438,
0.8690692186355591,
-0.5680398344993591,
-0.15185804665088654,
-0.22711092233657837,
0.02791353315114975,
-0.32672542333602905,
-0.5476539731025696,
0.544950008392334,
-0.7313956618309021,
0.238023579120636,
-0.6562009453773499,
-0.7338809967041016,
-0.14907291531562805,
0.5502899289131165,
-0.5207972526550293,
0.5839341878890991,
0.04549679160118103,
-1.0830028057098389,
0.8246380686759949,
-0.5002643465995789,
-0.5389916300773621,
-0.41605716943740845,
0.08502715080976486,
-0.5939543843269348,
0.16290214657783508,
0.40067562460899353,
0.23515647649765015,
0.08277148008346558,
0.47533947229385376,
-0.40718361735343933,
-0.27875083684921265,
0.0915178507566452,
-0.33854347467422485,
0.48241373896598816,
0.06610599905252457,
-0.13236452639102936,
0.2763783931732178,
-1.2232662439346313,
-0.5179297924041748,
-0.07927921414375305,
-0.3972075581550598,
-0.5087280869483948,
0.15844285488128662,
-0.5730534791946411,
0.2152174562215805,
0.20609146356582642,
-0.4343773126602173,
0.059543170034885406,
-0.38068753480911255,
-0.12927523255348206,
0.6672161221504211,
0.39434027671813965,
0.36412855982780457,
-0.7652599215507507,
0.15111473202705383,
0.4285561740398407,
-0.48167720437049866,
-0.34827664494514465,
0.008344008587300777,
-0.8687427043914795,
-0.16667483747005463,
0.539125382900238,
0.7810553908348083,
-0.9419100284576416,
0.37818074226379395,
-0.6349675059318542,
-0.4130154550075531,
-0.31006449460983276,
0.026244740933179855,
0.20357055962085724,
1.245949149131775,
0.52491694688797,
-0.11852241307497025,
-0.5406022667884827,
-0.6282480955123901,
-0.5099639892578125,
-0.14535433053970337,
-0.03185774013400078,
0.053607918322086334,
0.4903322160243988,
0.11300043016672134,
0.7263396382331848,
-0.3274969160556793,
-0.043694525957107544,
-0.03167104348540306,
0.44848576188087463,
0.04663964733481407,
0.7089356780052185,
0.6591278910636902,
-0.5758395195007324,
-0.3531686067581177,
0.0195333082228899,
-0.8764095306396484,
-0.04621727019548416,
-0.42822957038879395,
0.14757156372070312,
0.47307339310646057,
0.5489518642425537,
-0.46630391478538513,
0.42227447032928467,
0.2627868354320526,
-0.3873920738697052,
0.5587865710258484,
-0.4773109555244446,
0.4095076620578766,
-1.1054694652557373,
-0.010594832710921764,
-0.01092260517179966,
-0.5075710415840149,
-0.4615929126739502,
-0.045810360461473465,
-0.02778206765651703,
0.14082585275173187,
-0.08573608100414276,
0.14712928235530853,
-0.2628444731235504,
0.05100119113922119,
-0.5124104022979736,
0.3082214593887329,
0.10711663216352463,
0.38538479804992676,
0.05969399958848953,
0.7048724293708801,
0.5607564449310303,
-0.8808414340019226,
0.31264442205429077,
0.28101733326911926,
-0.6039860844612122,
0.9349297285079956,
-0.8060752153396606,
-0.31910085678100586,
-0.4258924722671509,
0.12222395092248917,
-0.826683759689331,
-0.284854918718338,
0.11063700914382935,
-0.2718798816204071,
0.36405035853385925,
0.001032878179103136,
-0.15323245525360107,
0.36258694529533386,
-0.29216066002845764,
0.2553669214248657,
0.18161718547344208,
-0.4081036448478699,
0.5917654037475586,
0.10768107324838638,
-0.7122875452041626,
-0.6341065764427185,
-0.5183711051940918,
0.10151960700750351,
-0.07967400550842285,
-0.4993368089199066,
0.304356187582016,
-0.011869044043123722,
-0.2527872622013092,
0.3744827210903168,
-0.4318244159221649,
0.09214053303003311,
0.015333542600274086,
-0.15253160893917084,
0.39010629057884216,
-0.5346718430519104,
0.03821096569299698,
0.4047973155975342,
0.08662746101617813,
0.06868608295917511,
-0.13778987526893616,
-0.04433237016201019,
0.06282808631658554,
-0.24692097306251526,
-0.2103041708469391,
-0.12392210960388184,
0.5115118026733398,
-0.2313367873430252,
0.9657211303710938,
0.4784982204437256,
-0.5952045917510986,
0.13592012226581573,
-0.43547019362449646,
0.06132893264293671,
-0.3956480026245117,
0.600826621055603,
-0.43782755732536316,
-0.7419846057891846,
0.8318009972572327,
0.06955718249082565,
0.3632146716117859,
0.6279789209365845,
0.5863717198371887,
-0.07426092773675919,
0.8263223171234131,
0.6329309344291687,
0.023243628442287445,
0.2741376757621765,
0.16551357507705688,
-0.03251282870769501,
-0.5276662707328796,
-0.06514396518468857,
-0.4256996512413025,
-0.14855921268463135,
-0.7829001545906067,
0.19495010375976562,
0.23556727170944214,
0.02654232457280159,
-0.1936275064945221,
0.06485827267169952,
0.014355855993926525,
0.5187627673149109,
0.2698889970779419,
0.23649905622005463,
0.6172807812690735,
-0.06964340806007385,
0.10874810814857483,
-0.036564357578754425,
-0.7529175281524658,
-0.38994383811950684,
1.0034570693969727,
0.2137300819158554,
0.8165150284767151,
0.3118075430393219,
0.16391628980636597,
0.3755350410938263,
0.2691124975681305,
-0.2777622938156128,
0.06809303909540176,
-0.20392164587974548,
-0.5557599067687988,
-0.38430172204971313,
-0.4873330295085907,
-0.5205029845237732,
0.12259935587644577,
-0.7530961036682129,
-0.6019194722175598,
0.5599072575569153,
0.37248995900154114,
-0.6014171242713928,
0.31871452927589417,
-0.6085067987442017,
0.7777210474014282,
0.16498465836048126,
-0.279488205909729,
-0.3581515848636627,
-0.6416316032409668,
0.5091432332992554,
-0.307720810174942,
0.25555890798568726,
-0.03382699564099312,
0.07771255075931549,
0.6404706835746765,
-0.33186668157577515,
0.621609091758728,
-0.08566516637802124,
-0.17958177626132965,
0.023332806304097176,
0.1452285647392273,
0.6551645398139954,
0.3658108413219452,
0.05876518785953522,
-0.26455461978912354,
0.1939832866191864,
-0.7351172566413879,
-0.7577317953109741,
0.6968351006507874,
-0.6029768586158752,
-0.8217990398406982,
-0.41670525074005127,
-0.7643835544586182,
-0.43998482823371887,
0.4434383511543274,
0.3588297665119171,
0.6603065729141235,
-0.42884498834609985,
0.2374957650899887,
1.0342953205108643,
-0.1435931771993637,
0.3088708817958832,
0.7841060757637024,
-0.038976337760686874,
-0.14691957831382751,
1.2219996452331543,
0.3486779034137726,
0.4086656868457794,
0.4608211815357208,
-0.19156169891357422,
-0.04652669280767441,
-0.9294504523277283,
-0.7047162055969238,
-0.296866774559021,
-0.6386948823928833,
-0.2084418535232544,
-0.7166042923927307,
-0.0869324654340744,
-0.4915938675403595,
-0.13912877440452576,
-0.28358322381973267,
-0.6557082533836365,
-0.2619803249835968,
-0.36872807145118713,
0.13155317306518555,
0.5979094505310059,
-0.0354868583381176,
0.11972714215517044,
-0.8110110759735107,
0.7295080423355103,
0.40592601895332336,
0.40628582239151,
-0.2838897407054901,
-1.0404335260391235,
-0.5133854150772095,
0.15480056405067444,
-0.15978354215621948,
-0.6280486583709717,
-0.13186800479888916,
0.33221831917762756,
0.18237094581127167,
0.4425197243690491,
0.290783166885376,
0.5534178614616394,
-0.35033348202705383,
0.6262348294258118,
-0.2345317304134369,
-0.9238383769989014,
0.3257397413253784,
-0.4812625050544739,
0.4563143849372864,
0.7173295617103577,
0.290414035320282,
-0.07608485966920853,
-0.4656866192817688,
-0.6147176623344421,
-0.5504804849624634,
0.6376311182975769,
0.0318220891058445,
0.18466290831565857,
0.33801621198654175,
0.3802955746650696,
0.08444437384605408,
0.23973968625068665,
-0.45621737837791443,
-0.06553293019533157,
-0.5740530490875244,
-0.48123404383659363,
0.03610296919941902,
-0.39327967166900635,
-0.3178691565990448,
-0.15462811291217804,
0.9404429793357849,
-0.1333722621202469,
-0.41477397084236145,
0.2542415261268616,
-0.4213949143886566,
-0.2769128978252411,
0.2987827956676483,
1.0515992641448975,
1.19352126121521,
-0.5082206130027771,
0.17671729624271393,
0.5823392868041992,
-0.47906798124313354,
0.01821635290980339,
0.4916171133518219,
-0.4076542556285858,
0.06600631773471832,
0.6596652865409851,
1.0320323705673218,
0.377265065908432,
-0.5493913292884827,
0.4672572612762451,
-0.1415378600358963,
-0.10233976691961288,
0.21869972348213196,
0.2572118639945984,
-0.05907217040657997,
0.14682583510875702,
0.22441789507865906,
0.6179063320159912,
0.19108329713344574,
-0.40130123496055603,
0.23044851422309875,
0.2850217819213867,
-0.23429132997989655,
-0.3087303340435028,
0.6147744655609131,
0.03436499834060669,
0.3886853754520416,
0.22925034165382385,
-0.1996808797121048,
-0.23630954325199127,
0.43776050209999084,
0.5485077500343323,
0.39406993985176086,
-0.1975921243429184,
0.083177350461483,
0.39311572909355164,
0.554244339466095,
0.1284671127796173,
0.1162600889801979,
0.07101702690124512,
-1.041605830192566,
-0.5693351030349731,
-0.24963738024234772,
-0.4895171821117401,
0.050090499222278595,
-0.7502477169036865,
0.30926433205604553,
-0.5493921041488647,
0.2506420612335205,
0.2900316119194031,
-0.08956334739923477,
-0.33760297298431396,
0.7641445398330688,
-0.2624414563179016,
0.993915319442749,
-0.840278148651123,
0.5445173978805542,
0.7062891125679016,
-0.3455452024936676,
-0.5102453231811523,
0.12311074882745743,
-0.15235188603401184,
-0.4914999008178711,
-0.032711077481508255,
-0.4082629084587097,
0.02109399251639843,
-0.2097049355506897,
-0.4257393181324005,
-0.7861865162849426,
0.8209230303764343,
0.5872302055358887,
-0.5797140598297119,
-0.03181624412536621,
-0.034906528890132904,
0.5612455606460571,
-0.31925690174102783,
-0.04704902321100235,
0.6044360995292664,
0.31359490752220154,
0.03916104882955551,
-0.6849360466003418,
0.22026102244853973,
-0.12005523592233658,
-0.24163037538528442,
-0.06748336553573608,
-0.4831957519054413,
0.5317553877830505,
-0.3173001706600189,
-0.16356568038463593,
-0.10774422436952591,
1.1475040912628174,
0.24631978571414948,
0.6034173369407654,
0.47353485226631165,
0.7387273907661438,
0.8600847125053406,
-0.08161512017250061,
0.7969347238540649,
-0.5241418480873108,
0.2786146402359009,
1.5001529455184937,
-0.16781707108020782,
0.4053499698638916,
0.04410957172513008,
0.05498608201742172,
0.5759060382843018,
0.5278207659721375,
-0.06905161589384079,
0.479410320520401,
-0.34038642048835754,
-0.237797349691391,
-0.09692007303237915,
-0.027933437377214432,
-0.41410335898399353,
0.34060218930244446,
0.21287132799625397,
-0.1409999430179596,
-0.2815282344818115,
-0.20218248665332794,
0.1592995971441269,
0.3033873438835144,
-0.47808802127838135,
1.0176721811294556,
-0.24040672183036804,
-0.7043189406394958,
0.6246387362480164,
0.09483303874731064,
0.4258992373943329,
-0.32766270637512207,
-0.005032220855355263,
-0.15563251078128815,
-0.09974874556064606,
-0.5120275020599365,
-0.5357040762901306,
0.5219338536262512,
0.1790749579668045,
-0.5073827505111694,
0.5030267238616943,
0.8912384510040283,
-0.6182758808135986,
-0.7410240769386292,
-0.43775904178619385,
0.4762500524520874,
-0.43473121523857117,
0.1781706064939499,
-0.43876126408576965,
-0.07289361953735352,
-0.08659090846776962,
-0.19931069016456604,
0.2142624706029892,
0.6202781200408936,
-0.1110578179359436,
0.41966864466667175,
0.5921159982681274,
0.209120973944664,
-0.16046060621738434,
-0.0980137288570404,
0.9310157299041748,
-0.34253162145614624,
-0.7044669389724731,
-0.8887177109718323,
0.4895259141921997,
-0.0708777979016304,
-0.20061703026294708,
0.6505197882652283,
0.5774717330932617,
0.8386714458465576,
0.01519855298101902,
0.8462448120117188,
0.07809557765722275,
0.7554137706756592,
-0.8422905206680298,
0.7427572011947632,
-0.33412405848503113,
0.3613453209400177,
-0.3345557749271393,
-0.7769479155540466,
-0.19323691725730896,
0.1726563423871994,
-0.3146083354949951,
0.11496701836585999,
0.3172594904899597,
0.7224822044372559,
-0.4420055150985718,
0.1767636239528656,
0.2400684803724289,
0.6016253232955933,
0.10003163665533066,
0.19252963364124298,
0.5144190192222595,
-0.32958725094795227,
0.14465340971946716,
-0.13535907864570618,
-0.2988206446170807,
-0.09899793565273285,
-0.9970923066139221,
-0.756447434425354,
-0.4143856465816498,
-0.5357470512390137,
-0.4217195212841034,
0.34095096588134766,
0.880713701248169,
0.4360141456127167,
-1.2180006504058838,
0.3961612582206726,
-0.13766512274742126,
0.5144648551940918,
-0.05011396482586861,
-0.22252391278743744,
0.5093977451324463,
-0.41352856159210205,
-0.6119328141212463,
0.17213284969329834,
0.2192734181880951,
0.17197951674461365,
0.23506030440330505,
0.1512371301651001,
-0.16453595459461212,
0.47471973299980164,
0.4918590486049652,
0.45771554112434387,
-0.29718735814094543,
-0.41593220829963684,
-0.28977739810943604,
0.059220604598522186,
0.05449201166629791,
0.6964768767356873,
-0.5985965728759766,
0.5520015954971313,
0.30633601546287537,
0.8520547747612,
0.24769611656665802,
0.4681505560874939,
0.4929393529891968,
-0.7490845322608948,
0.12993715703487396,
-0.1980077624320984,
0.39949625730514526,
0.4564107060432434,
-0.4836147427558899,
0.0997864231467247,
0.1842355877161026,
-0.5023365616798401,
-0.7708216905593872,
0.013241651467978954,
-0.8477513790130615,
-0.21990856528282166,
0.5219290256500244,
-0.3060317635536194,
0.13394105434417725,
-0.22776836156845093,
-0.09796781837940216,
0.5148860812187195,
-0.17106357216835022,
1.1713175773620605,
0.7398420572280884,
-0.09640942513942719,
-0.12307895720005035,
-0.17293331027030945,
0.6540027856826782,
0.45625415444374084,
-0.880890965461731,
-0.060041893273591995,
0.46871843934059143,
0.5516209602355957,
0.178375244140625,
0.3126198649406433,
0.15578263998031616,
0.4602357745170593,
-0.039876166731119156,
-0.44241511821746826,
-0.27958613634109497,
-0.28316953778266907,
-0.3962184190750122,
-0.007175570819526911,
0.13986840844154358,
-0.03340283781290054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15159v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15159v3
|
Machine Unlearning of Pre-trained Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T07:43:26 | 2024-05-30T15:44:51 |
Jin Yao, Eli Chien, Minxin Du, Xinyao Niu, Tianhao Wang, Zezhou Cheng, Xiang Yue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
This study investigates the concept of the `right to be forgotten' within the
context of large language models (LLMs). We explore machine unlearning as a
pivotal solution, with a focus on pre-trained models--a notably
under-researched area. Our research delineates a comprehensive framework for
machine unlearning in pre-trained LLMs, encompassing a critical analysis of
seven diverse unlearning methods. Through rigorous evaluation using curated
datasets from arXiv, books, and GitHub, we establish a robust benchmark for
unlearning performance, demonstrating that these methods are over $10^5$ times
more computationally efficient than retraining. Our results show that
integrating gradient ascent with gradient descent on in-distribution data
improves hyperparameter robustness. We also provide detailed guidelines for
efficient hyperparameter tuning in the unlearning process. Our findings advance
the discourse on ethical AI practices, offering substantive insights into the
mechanics of machine unlearning for pre-trained LLMs and underscoring the
potential for responsible AI development.
|
[
-0.31577590107917786,
-0.3427596986293793,
0.4588397741317749,
-0.32887521386146545,
-0.3251478672027588,
0.31045079231262207,
-0.3519945442676544,
-0.05330909416079521,
-0.460519939661026,
0.8269692063331604,
-0.6645740270614624,
-0.3052012622356415,
-0.7082946300506592,
-0.20817337930202484,
-0.576328456401825,
1.079899787902832,
0.07987504452466965,
0.043868135660886765,
-0.33195802569389343,
-0.24720865488052368,
-0.31835079193115234,
-0.6460371613502502,
-0.36068758368492126,
-0.5206350088119507,
0.5754602551460266,
0.31486275792121887,
0.5366266965866089,
0.830154538154602,
0.2997044026851654,
0.34866541624069214,
-0.15727917850017548,
0.1245705634355545,
-0.9758130311965942,
-0.027660230174660683,
-0.19289176166057587,
-0.509785532951355,
-0.20981721580028534,
0.2614928185939789,
0.7688226103782654,
0.9605268836021423,
-0.21410605311393738,
0.4319074749946594,
0.3995600640773773,
0.9828646779060364,
-1.037111520767212,
-0.11877831816673279,
-0.6702873706817627,
0.23295776546001434,
-0.24839133024215698,
-0.20114456117153168,
-0.5296172499656677,
-0.2336340993642807,
-0.08931983262300491,
-0.6732301115989685,
0.24757546186447144,
-0.05875008925795555,
0.573451042175293,
0.6314458847045898,
-0.2301536500453949,
-0.1412322223186493,
-0.9337055683135986,
1.2614669799804688,
-0.45579826831817627,
0.5056038498878479,
0.6308422684669495,
0.30220043659210205,
-0.25268682837486267,
-0.9237719178199768,
-0.35688427090644836,
0.12825068831443787,
0.09980316460132599,
0.18425562977790833,
-0.3487268388271332,
0.06733354926109314,
0.42978236079216003,
0.25022441148757935,
-0.4366159439086914,
0.4636910855770111,
-0.34720906615257263,
-0.060222093015909195,
0.3816700577735901,
-0.048271436244249344,
0.056218843907117844,
0.15628373622894287,
-0.12771157920360565,
0.21736262738704681,
-1.0225818157196045,
-0.1440621167421341,
0.7139766216278076,
0.11191364377737045,
0.20710667967796326,
0.4049803912639618,
0.0798720270395279,
0.4502955675125122,
-0.27024561166763306,
0.04350956901907921,
0.39935144782066345,
0.047682832926511765,
-0.36157479882240295,
-0.27123209834098816,
0.6169763207435608,
0.006550033576786518,
0.8589338064193726,
-0.3388291597366333,
-0.35452961921691895,
-0.43437764048576355,
0.4810245633125305,
-0.5811375975608826,
0.07635553926229477,
0.1686433106660843,
-0.7120464444160461,
-0.07387282699346542,
-0.15573947131633759,
-0.4761912226676941,
-0.28378331661224365,
-0.5886988043785095,
0.36953288316726685,
-0.2658839821815491,
-0.22268721461296082,
-0.08170395344495773,
-0.08822844177484512,
0.09542030841112137,
0.12220153212547302,
-0.6477062106132507,
0.08175376057624817,
0.7305973768234253,
0.37573906779289246,
0.1758604645729065,
-0.548882007598877,
-0.5226401090621948,
0.10082904994487762,
-0.5631323456764221,
0.17673145234584808,
-0.5597200393676758,
-0.5941256880760193,
0.20000320672988892,
0.027075903490185738,
-0.07307843863964081,
-0.8180974125862122,
0.3759118318557739,
-0.6517590880393982,
0.3183295726776123,
-0.15811461210250854,
-0.6362584233283997,
-0.31001442670822144,
-0.057275764644145966,
-0.3629505932331085,
0.7727084755897522,
0.005105944816023111,
-0.7665262222290039,
0.44558319449424744,
-0.6711531281471252,
-0.31309688091278076,
0.0786340981721878,
-0.13392652571201324,
-0.5665540099143982,
0.07878933101892471,
0.05019514635205269,
0.6415446400642395,
-0.35979849100112915,
0.4998142421245575,
-0.416143000125885,
-0.6035578846931458,
0.11846484988927841,
-0.746251106262207,
1.1096267700195312,
0.4642268121242523,
-0.38286250829696655,
-0.14364437758922577,
-0.7921690344810486,
0.108486607670784,
0.08828683942556381,
-0.25594213604927063,
-0.23115386068820953,
-0.02414512075483799,
-0.3121505677700043,
0.08368994295597076,
0.24604834616184235,
-0.2673150300979614,
-0.2867606580257416,
-0.30294761061668396,
0.5054152011871338,
0.9939813017845154,
-0.15320199728012085,
0.5459883213043213,
-0.3270069360733032,
0.4277537167072296,
0.05791398510336876,
0.2085171639919281,
-0.26995691657066345,
0.0658799409866333,
-0.8353030681610107,
-0.2837558090686798,
0.23977428674697876,
0.49910101294517517,
-0.5190213322639465,
0.5446329712867737,
-0.019373688846826553,
-0.38511767983436584,
-0.8355567455291748,
0.5244207382202148,
0.7587231993675232,
0.5274478793144226,
0.3942423164844513,
-0.029952630400657654,
-0.49506881833076477,
-0.9174723029136658,
-0.4970936179161072,
-0.1852615624666214,
-0.08997301012277603,
0.09939698874950409,
0.585869312286377,
-0.6082496643066406,
0.6998077034950256,
-0.1156359612941742,
-0.09677344560623169,
-0.09696080535650253,
0.15794923901557922,
0.04189020022749901,
0.6353567838668823,
0.14844654500484467,
-0.7050302028656006,
0.03095472976565361,
-0.11434493213891983,
-1.0467373132705688,
0.37215569615364075,
0.1595473289489746,
0.09457328915596008,
0.1842464953660965,
0.6978702545166016,
-0.5295857191085815,
0.5531219244003296,
0.34622278809547424,
0.3896781802177429,
0.37241876125335693,
-0.5662352442741394,
-0.09291012585163116,
-1.1752592325210571,
0.389590322971344,
-0.4230651259422302,
-0.10741548240184784,
-0.6259931325912476,
-0.09463933110237122,
0.06969081610441208,
-0.054321952164173126,
-0.5834201574325562,
0.31836503744125366,
-0.6476808190345764,
-0.20160119235515594,
-0.4848484694957733,
-0.12168732285499573,
-0.34620386362075806,
0.4671840965747833,
-0.17161478102207184,
0.7476930618286133,
0.5047977566719055,
-0.8123456239700317,
-0.12112222611904144,
0.03443748131394386,
-0.26107993721961975,
0.21263465285301208,
-0.5599479079246521,
0.3511852025985718,
-0.65494704246521,
0.0852363333106041,
-0.6270598769187927,
0.14170652627944946,
0.2350940853357315,
-0.4518637955188751,
0.24497967958450317,
-0.4155369997024536,
-0.4597112536430359,
-0.38667142391204834,
-0.014800085686147213,
0.5315209627151489,
0.8526080846786499,
-0.5567142963409424,
0.37142395973205566,
0.5882465243339539,
-0.04782889038324356,
-1.1065677404403687,
-0.425944983959198,
-0.2176206111907959,
-0.3984763026237488,
0.04704662412405014,
-0.03411781042814255,
-0.13034622371196747,
-0.1737072914838791,
-0.190792977809906,
0.13249462842941284,
-0.3479715585708618,
0.3021243214607239,
0.5118609666824341,
-0.08505526185035706,
0.004689243622124195,
0.24845066666603088,
-0.29127708077430725,
-0.49816128611564636,
0.04238218814134598,
-0.414465069770813,
0.5702397227287292,
0.011487345211207867,
-0.5476900935173035,
-0.42596951127052307,
0.2728900909423828,
0.7290283441543579,
-0.34563860297203064,
0.4891500174999237,
0.6382809281349182,
-0.68686443567276,
-0.14943458139896393,
-0.36879920959472656,
0.03849698603153229,
-0.4949240982532501,
0.3328046500682831,
-0.015431806445121765,
-0.8445643782615662,
0.4399029612541199,
-0.19260753691196442,
0.41327670216560364,
0.31446048617362976,
0.5365196466445923,
-0.47254177927970886,
0.9872639179229736,
1.0387274026870728,
-0.3681984841823578,
0.3374309837818146,
-0.3045249581336975,
0.3022211790084839,
-0.5532771348953247,
-0.2480163872241974,
-0.745335042476654,
-0.1872674524784088,
-0.7829398512840271,
-0.21613015234470367,
0.010160169564187527,
0.21579217910766602,
-0.7135791778564453,
0.002734228502959013,
-0.10574831068515778,
0.7989057302474976,
0.7411675453186035,
0.016461681574583054,
0.22755491733551025,
-0.03621029108762741,
0.0034206025302410126,
0.021351037546992302,
-0.5986026525497437,
-0.7800981402397156,
1.3138903379440308,
0.32332220673561096,
0.5339659452438354,
-0.21684479713439941,
0.8999571800231934,
0.28907403349876404,
0.3153379559516907,
-0.5150874853134155,
0.3987303376197815,
-0.18907959759235382,
-0.5257627964019775,
-0.4951014220714569,
-0.5508427619934082,
-1.2806254625320435,
0.02803882397711277,
0.0629979744553566,
-0.5926513075828552,
-0.002907651476562023,
0.37887805700302124,
-0.347194641828537,
0.5080417990684509,
-0.4868781566619873,
0.6909188628196716,
-0.16602292656898499,
-0.051375895738601685,
-0.4929865002632141,
-0.7559211254119873,
0.18242964148521423,
-0.48710253834724426,
0.31840988993644714,
-0.09627022594213486,
0.16120025515556335,
1.152565836906433,
-0.4607475697994232,
0.8392006754875183,
-0.37900540232658386,
0.013465073890984058,
0.14580529928207397,
-0.1757621169090271,
0.38063475489616394,
-0.17131340503692627,
0.10115471482276917,
0.23081441223621368,
-0.2701128423213959,
-0.6841951608657837,
-0.385336697101593,
0.4493043124675751,
-0.9049128890037537,
-0.5845216512680054,
-0.2114122062921524,
-0.3965704143047333,
-0.3887059986591339,
0.5494734644889832,
0.5385278463363647,
0.05380993336439133,
-0.2695501744747162,
0.23886823654174805,
1.0246732234954834,
-0.2596984803676605,
0.6228266954421997,
0.5978499054908752,
-0.09184040874242783,
-0.12875287234783173,
0.9448145031929016,
0.3627040684223175,
0.06367222964763641,
0.40919214487075806,
0.0629957914352417,
-0.275276243686676,
-0.6950991153717041,
-0.3599860370159149,
0.2908596396446228,
-0.679204523563385,
-0.0052466122433543205,
-0.7193329930305481,
-0.3465057909488678,
-0.21504846215248108,
-0.19707179069519043,
-0.6340242624282837,
0.012421493418514729,
-0.6750112175941467,
-0.15757353603839874,
0.08221136778593063,
0.79106605052948,
-0.046917203813791275,
0.5951993465423584,
-0.8528710603713989,
0.10868970304727554,
0.10158555954694748,
0.28716525435447693,
0.1315479576587677,
-0.8634598255157471,
-0.2394816130399704,
0.27369073033332825,
-0.23008926212787628,
-0.1583552211523056,
0.3829302191734314,
-0.1058477908372879,
0.8884426951408386,
0.6345229744911194,
0.043096140027046204,
0.6973814368247986,
-0.5239853262901306,
0.37532567977905273,
0.3038206398487091,
-0.7995539307594299,
0.37819525599479675,
-0.2855830788612366,
0.15835630893707275,
0.6242603659629822,
0.7410551309585571,
-0.4572717547416687,
-0.19790735840797424,
-0.9989952445030212,
-0.9080990552902222,
0.47406208515167236,
-0.11276647448539734,
0.3031918704509735,
0.3491545021533966,
0.28686264157295227,
0.41952142119407654,
0.5865803360939026,
-0.456429660320282,
-0.3032775819301605,
-0.029899440705776215,
-0.1432361751794815,
-0.7167955636978149,
-0.18978270888328552,
-0.13859599828720093,
-0.20750389993190765,
0.5994526743888855,
0.11478812992572784,
0.17494498193264008,
-0.45554018020629883,
-0.5096789002418518,
-0.12225902080535889,
0.17178532481193542,
0.30233049392700195,
1.0515046119689941,
-0.007581887301057577,
0.013725866563618183,
0.19972120225429535,
-0.37059950828552246,
0.3131009340286255,
-0.2327553629875183,
-0.21786431968212128,
-0.27933138608932495,
0.3349754512310028,
0.541772186756134,
0.14507324993610382,
-0.7151787877082825,
0.4523860216140747,
0.1565152108669281,
-0.25769296288490295,
-0.5203610062599182,
0.021994639188051224,
0.06106613203883171,
0.03948875889182091,
0.24555164575576782,
0.16497638821601868,
0.06873974204063416,
-0.4532381594181061,
0.38364651799201965,
0.3105245530605316,
-0.5932497382164001,
-0.20330573618412018,
0.2997661530971527,
-0.012242038734257221,
-0.3352419137954712,
0.9470270872116089,
0.20724205672740936,
-0.32472220063209534,
0.3780403733253479,
0.465572714805603,
0.8671741485595703,
-0.15455344319343567,
0.22767005860805511,
-0.15084308385849,
0.44587385654449463,
-0.2536546289920807,
-0.00399886816740036,
-0.00855485163629055,
-0.636705756187439,
-0.3745309114456177,
-0.39557966589927673,
-0.2722533345222473,
0.37372061610221863,
-0.6690903902053833,
-0.15158526599407196,
-0.6192957162857056,
0.027941804379224777,
-0.1811828911304474,
0.059665746986866,
-0.890240490436554,
0.32406604290008545,
-0.3250519335269928,
0.6124270558357239,
-0.7084596157073975,
0.6732705235481262,
0.4029560387134552,
-0.27550169825553894,
-0.616630494594574,
0.18003414571285248,
-0.011834933422505856,
-1.2172036170959473,
0.574596107006073,
0.06339805573225021,
-0.21671158075332642,
0.25438839197158813,
-0.5074283480644226,
-0.6790308356285095,
0.841045618057251,
0.721394956111908,
-0.7019754648208618,
0.26587149500846863,
0.310749351978302,
0.3201802968978882,
-0.18446888029575348,
0.296179860830307,
0.5477163791656494,
0.29042404890060425,
-0.18960224092006683,
-0.6566863059997559,
-0.36196309328079224,
0.010317284613847733,
-0.19574640691280365,
0.3857474625110626,
-0.6951054930686951,
0.7027056813240051,
-0.4021289348602295,
-0.1528593748807907,
-0.009966863319277763,
0.4838228225708008,
-0.08818113803863525,
0.45985254645347595,
0.30404192209243774,
0.6208301782608032,
1.287544846534729,
0.13284960389137268,
0.6977564096450806,
-0.0356530137360096,
0.17600907385349274,
0.7752820253372192,
-0.19921378791332245,
0.6535382866859436,
0.452526330947876,
0.02234439179301262,
-0.11972718685865402,
0.6999643445014954,
0.4763003885746002,
0.4594966471195221,
0.45102375745773315,
-0.1182025671005249,
-0.3406386375427246,
0.04050373286008835,
-0.3969435691833496,
0.4358155429363251,
0.13190141320228577,
-0.4798230528831482,
-0.26536330580711365,
0.10203271359205246,
0.3154635727405548,
0.15070800483226776,
-0.49138402938842773,
0.8179718255996704,
0.16348259150981903,
-0.4280344247817993,
0.7822170257568359,
-0.09100823104381561,
0.4206377863883972,
-0.39780035614967346,
0.18182048201560974,
-0.4160431921482086,
0.4314170181751251,
-0.022366885095834732,
-0.45432618260383606,
0.004423440434038639,
0.10474614799022675,
-0.4394553601741791,
-0.41152042150497437,
0.5025506019592285,
-0.2175769954919815,
-0.3878038227558136,
0.35685306787490845,
0.9043152928352356,
0.44627323746681213,
0.0674661248922348,
-0.8069621920585632,
-0.14348915219306946,
0.07241993397474289,
-0.13323059678077698,
0.6094449162483215,
0.4914740025997162,
-0.17092856764793396,
1.1515123844146729,
0.7737488746643066,
-0.09155578911304474,
-0.020984677597880363,
0.21058887243270874,
0.7153818011283875,
-0.7699003219604492,
-0.220193013548851,
-0.9453813433647156,
0.3052927255630493,
0.21251912415027618,
-0.4788593649864197,
0.5610193014144897,
0.4171135425567627,
1.1743512153625488,
0.05058164522051811,
0.974197268486023,
0.6381365656852722,
0.7552392482757568,
-0.6388825178146362,
1.0697689056396484,
-0.544522762298584,
0.2526377737522125,
-0.1406141221523285,
-0.8560287952423096,
-0.29067814350128174,
0.32844018936157227,
-0.19682404398918152,
0.563184380531311,
0.4183589518070221,
0.7531321048736572,
-0.03471348434686661,
-0.008946331217885017,
0.6838183999061584,
-0.05483704060316086,
0.10522913187742233,
0.2646215558052063,
1.0924513339996338,
-0.15482887625694275,
0.3786015808582306,
0.07796908169984818,
-0.14476314187049866,
-0.20829878747463226,
-0.8282546401023865,
-0.7959484457969666,
-0.556117057800293,
-0.01940031722187996,
-0.05342064052820206,
0.5274366140365601,
0.8557732105255127,
0.6602573990821838,
-0.662861168384552,
-0.3349314033985138,
-0.0648292824625969,
0.2973853647708893,
-0.09255389124155045,
-0.06867992132902145,
0.3114316463470459,
-0.5297175645828247,
-0.6517744660377502,
0.27641353011131287,
0.16687417030334473,
0.20659980177879333,
-0.21933099627494812,
-0.4711625576019287,
0.03784992918372154,
-0.07992378622293472,
0.44323915243148804,
0.6481618285179138,
-0.3292098343372345,
0.026168808341026306,
-0.27514904737472534,
0.08241115510463715,
-0.050563182681798935,
1.1539263725280762,
-0.7076776623725891,
0.08443961292505264,
0.13109515607357025,
1.0555179119110107,
0.12169475853443146,
-0.08740413188934326,
0.5779444575309753,
-0.6812903881072998,
0.1084308922290802,
0.3916887938976288,
0.4074123799800873,
0.1945444792509079,
-0.15856346487998962,
0.168721541762352,
0.28456833958625793,
-0.6464308500289917,
-1.1527429819107056,
0.1822390854358673,
-0.19554297626018524,
-0.38138094544410706,
0.7310114502906799,
-0.27199479937553406,
-0.16339172422885895,
-0.311414510011673,
0.13488544523715973,
0.5240402817726135,
-0.2741769254207611,
0.6051332950592041,
0.46458899974823,
0.25721848011016846,
-0.13750620186328888,
-0.539547324180603,
0.5580284595489502,
0.5988563299179077,
-0.5688871741294861,
0.5548397302627563,
0.463632732629776,
0.28458020091056824,
-0.18124467134475708,
0.7916800379753113,
-0.18581894040107727,
0.1393612027168274,
-0.3819034695625305,
0.06096860393881798,
-0.09950768947601318,
-0.8053780794143677,
-0.37509089708328247,
0.14141376316547394,
0.21816058456897736,
-0.3205038607120514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15539v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15539v1
|
Speech Corpus for Korean Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder: Towards Automatic Assessment Systems
| 2024-02-23T07:32:54 | 2024-02-23T07:32:54 |
Seonwoo Lee, Jihyun Mun, Sunhee Kim, Minhwa Chung
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL
|
Despite the growing demand for digital therapeutics for children with Autism
Spectrum Disorder (ASD), there is currently no speech corpus available for
Korean children with ASD. This paper introduces a speech corpus specifically
designed for Korean children with ASD, aiming to advance speech technologies
such as pronunciation and severity evaluation. Speech recordings from speech
and language evaluation sessions were transcribed, and annotated for
articulatory and linguistic characteristics. Three speech and language
pathologists rated these recordings for social communication severity (SCS) and
pronunciation proficiency (PP) using a 3-point Likert scale. The total number
of participants will be 300 for children with ASD and 50 for typically
developing (TD) children. The paper also analyzes acoustic and linguistic
features extracted from speech data collected and completed for annotation from
73 children with ASD and 9 TD children to investigate the characteristics of
children with ASD and identify significant features that correlate with the
clinical scores. The results reveal some speech and linguistic characteristics
in children with ASD that differ from those in TD children or another subgroup
of ASD categorized by clinical scores, demonstrating the potential for
developing automatic assessment systems for SCS and PP.
|
[
-0.5167664885520935,
-0.421037495136261,
0.061241090297698975,
0.48924583196640015,
0.08883313089609146,
0.7051485776901245,
-0.11717262119054794,
-0.7412238121032715,
0.7802077531814575,
0.3863810896873474,
-0.28501906991004944,
-0.454316109418869,
-0.5790862441062927,
-0.004592448938637972,
-0.5972606539726257,
0.6764718294143677,
0.08596861362457275,
0.2110370397567749,
0.16492559015750885,
-0.08360199630260468,
-0.12328823655843735,
-0.49845999479293823,
-1.167065978050232,
0.011410159058868885,
0.2164771407842636,
0.6658719778060913,
0.5809093713760376,
0.8083372712135315,
0.29197990894317627,
0.2647427022457123,
-0.23954136669635773,
-0.2744966745376587,
0.1917736977338791,
0.30706802010536194,
-0.09376232326030731,
0.2816719114780426,
-1.1533757448196411,
-0.034932155162096024,
0.5887811779975891,
1.0483558177947998,
0.05884398892521858,
0.35092976689338684,
0.27451834082603455,
0.45544564723968506,
-0.13882231712341309,
0.16725368797779083,
0.11103787273168564,
0.35330796241760254,
-0.3824564218521118,
0.2221728414297104,
-0.005450320430099964,
-0.2976981997489929,
0.10204675793647766,
-0.6420639157295227,
0.06427056342363358,
-0.29586121439933777,
0.5750904679298401,
0.1401364505290985,
-0.7013934850692749,
-0.678784191608429,
-0.7220184206962585,
0.3961986303329468,
-0.5826426148414612,
0.44367873668670654,
0.8318646550178528,
0.45434123277664185,
0.23165640234947205,
-0.5777780413627625,
-0.39005932211875916,
-0.4533342123031616,
0.105584055185318,
0.100687175989151,
0.01065042894333601,
0.20830945670604706,
0.16693100333213806,
0.06888627260923386,
-0.8851549029350281,
0.2203209549188614,
-0.5371832251548767,
-0.44214922189712524,
1.0821523666381836,
0.05133075639605522,
0.66129469871521,
-0.30764278769493103,
0.17123675346374512,
0.11049879342317581,
-0.3323350250720978,
0.30923640727996826,
0.4457005262374878,
0.5497109293937683,
-0.18325619399547577,
0.44703444838523865,
-0.4441209137439728,
0.29232320189476013,
0.18164081871509552,
-0.07196053117513657,
0.6183614730834961,
-0.15313193202018738,
0.2677006423473358,
0.44616779685020447,
0.5654292702674866,
0.2132291942834854,
0.3017045855522156,
-0.05587958171963692,
-0.23527415096759796,
0.5483334064483643,
0.2302413433790207,
-0.3869636356830597,
-0.3266969323158264,
0.1836899369955063,
-0.5615296959877014,
-0.40047135949134827,
-0.1940506249666214,
-0.9147258400917053,
-0.3963000476360321,
-0.24536330997943878,
0.09916389733552933,
-0.3426893651485443,
-0.717746913433075,
-0.1453845053911209,
-0.07576501369476318,
-0.15100717544555664,
-0.18720212578773499,
-0.9762539267539978,
0.8233283758163452,
0.3976150155067444,
0.4963529706001282,
-0.35219132900238037,
-0.20174960792064667,
-0.4873642921447754,
-0.08892789483070374,
-0.6181857585906982,
1.0202962160110474,
-0.7279871702194214,
-0.39967280626296997,
-0.1312336027622223,
0.11133567243814468,
-0.21059881150722504,
-0.6170501708984375,
0.6826884746551514,
-0.4352232813835144,
-0.3435116112232208,
0.041509002447128296,
-0.3932690918445587,
0.0015659977216273546,
-0.2182624340057373,
-0.5338196158409119,
0.867234468460083,
0.5133269429206848,
-0.25148966908454895,
0.4530530869960785,
-0.9588456153869629,
-0.682827353477478,
0.5729023218154907,
-0.10835663974285126,
-0.03501828387379646,
-0.2926771938800812,
0.06861700117588043,
0.11495833098888397,
0.2841213345527649,
0.20964184403419495,
-0.3101332187652588,
-0.28237107396125793,
0.16994106769561768,
-0.2342924177646637,
0.8499534130096436,
0.5729188323020935,
-0.27068671584129333,
0.08164268732070923,
-0.8611546754837036,
0.5041535496711731,
-0.2572733163833618,
-0.3283446133136749,
0.08571672439575195,
-0.08936712890863419,
0.47045379877090454,
0.163418710231781,
0.1357269138097763,
-0.5538759231567383,
-0.22688564658164978,
-0.5754595398902893,
0.41258934140205383,
0.19938281178474426,
0.17333702743053436,
0.32906314730644226,
-0.39990949630737305,
1.2021865844726562,
-0.15015316009521484,
0.27098649740219116,
0.1324213296175003,
-0.5909721851348877,
-0.31139394640922546,
-0.34763211011886597,
0.7723345160484314,
0.6001860499382019,
-0.678570568561554,
0.8325682878494263,
-0.2261461615562439,
-0.3097735047340393,
-0.7747763395309448,
-0.14953191578388214,
0.6211498379707336,
0.28874528408050537,
0.12077049911022186,
-0.6478040814399719,
-0.6864836812019348,
-0.5843347311019897,
0.07330316305160522,
-0.13623827695846558,
-0.12129171192646027,
0.4075002372264862,
0.13296638429164886,
-0.20137149095535278,
0.7608609199523926,
0.23704199492931366,
-0.33669278025627136,
-0.07468216121196747,
-0.10069330036640167,
-0.21857322752475739,
0.41895592212677,
0.4165397882461548,
-0.6617166996002197,
-0.9839715361595154,
0.10694269090890884,
-0.5770435333251953,
-0.8036918044090271,
0.6007786393165588,
0.5169863104820251,
0.463312029838562,
0.7482060194015503,
-0.32741352915763855,
0.45859503746032715,
0.49770215153694153,
-0.8198988437652588,
0.5225963592529297,
0.19814279675483704,
0.3495393693447113,
-0.506715714931488,
0.08604450523853302,
-0.2878529131412506,
-0.3777967095375061,
-0.696315348148346,
-0.13403937220573425,
-0.14664693176746368,
-0.22286628186702728,
-0.4276599884033203,
0.4674536883831024,
-0.14560472965240479,
-0.616070568561554,
-0.2673381567001343,
0.49961763620376587,
-0.26698169112205505,
-0.10117555409669876,
-0.08032090216875076,
0.4642675220966339,
0.6783273220062256,
-0.6198115944862366,
0.6022297739982605,
0.06667765229940414,
-0.26184770464897156,
0.802117645740509,
-0.46777307987213135,
-0.000244219321757555,
0.29546940326690674,
0.22204802930355072,
-0.8101082444190979,
-0.24674564599990845,
0.48813164234161377,
-0.9801393151283264,
0.4752000868320465,
-0.036309946328401566,
-0.17468909919261932,
-0.7184916734695435,
-0.2621696889400482,
0.3600320816040039,
0.23476512730121613,
-0.13020530343055725,
0.2315984070301056,
1.1983139514923096,
-0.7515129446983337,
-0.4353654980659485,
-0.46519145369529724,
0.33378368616104126,
-0.36583957076072693,
-0.7270429134368896,
0.2527846395969391,
-0.09485393762588501,
-0.2395438253879547,
0.5176345109939575,
-0.19694538414478302,
-0.2901001572608948,
0.2189561128616333,
0.03505568578839302,
-0.0849401131272316,
-0.7209832668304443,
0.2194962203502655,
0.44343042373657227,
-0.5488553047180176,
-0.13520121574401855,
0.13510124385356903,
0.6489328145980835,
-0.2659296691417694,
-0.16652442514896393,
-0.26795339584350586,
0.5473191142082214,
0.44834429025650024,
0.14569276571273804,
0.0009083936456590891,
0.33610984683036804,
-0.5842021107673645,
-0.2533915936946869,
-0.07679441571235657,
0.040851131081581116,
-0.5129275321960449,
0.35629603266716003,
-0.6608566641807556,
-0.6285865902900696,
0.8064293265342712,
0.12635493278503418,
-0.5485906600952148,
0.5003039836883545,
0.34754419326782227,
-0.4062393009662628,
1.211303472518921,
0.23696045577526093,
0.115280382335186,
0.2245771735906601,
0.07580877095460892,
-0.09661173075437546,
-0.9468554854393005,
0.2981688976287842,
-0.45102137327194214,
-0.3225259780883789,
-0.37885206937789917,
0.0056431470438838005,
0.2364450991153717,
-0.09053905308246613,
-0.4834268391132355,
0.03333243355154991,
-0.7539156675338745,
0.59832763671875,
0.24051864445209503,
-0.2241426557302475,
0.2679472267627716,
-0.33799055218696594,
0.09761439263820648,
-0.2269534170627594,
-0.630609393119812,
-0.9163450002670288,
1.3926690816879272,
0.3088630437850952,
0.009751025587320328,
-0.014615941792726517,
0.5010613203048706,
0.8362370729446411,
0.3713178336620331,
-0.9064388871192932,
0.5804579854011536,
-0.5151439905166626,
-0.5491824150085449,
-0.570306658744812,
-0.14174698293209076,
-1.1079072952270508,
-0.05206345021724701,
0.007177433464676142,
-0.9843761324882507,
0.35786914825439453,
-0.13091574609279633,
-0.9191753268241882,
-0.4496302902698517,
-0.6354169249534607,
0.8331378698348999,
-0.1609923541545868,
0.4923412501811981,
-0.1074911430478096,
-0.7024731040000916,
0.15430371463298798,
-0.3672492206096649,
0.32407140731811523,
0.010617789812386036,
-0.19274599850177765,
1.0973683595657349,
-0.38868847489356995,
0.6325070261955261,
-0.3620704412460327,
0.2000577747821808,
0.35397571325302124,
-0.050059422850608826,
-0.297647625207901,
-0.06434230506420135,
-0.09897170960903168,
0.054037585854530334,
0.42854043841362,
-0.06983720511198044,
-0.4615301191806793,
0.8670101165771484,
-0.8804669380187988,
-0.1203698143362999,
-0.630324125289917,
-0.2681524455547333,
-0.4633578360080719,
0.32053807377815247,
-0.03162403777241707,
0.48475563526153564,
-0.12243292480707169,
-0.015220806933939457,
0.3171285390853882,
-0.2557951509952545,
0.4544028043746948,
0.7563549280166626,
-0.47684022784233093,
-0.4115268290042877,
1.0392506122589111,
0.6559587717056274,
0.17572931945323944,
-0.6536926031112671,
-0.006615642458200455,
-0.3024596869945526,
-0.4041479825973511,
-0.6568191647529602,
0.1343417763710022,
-0.7187250256538391,
-0.00292286672629416,
-0.5199198126792908,
-0.7657034993171692,
-0.8949798941612244,
-0.2664004862308502,
-0.4067038595676422,
-0.8506356477737427,
-0.0019325927132740617,
-0.30013105273246765,
0.10990194231271744,
0.8963026404380798,
-0.414246141910553,
0.30697163939476013,
-0.5362548828125,
0.8437227606773376,
-0.07202824205160141,
0.5620062351226807,
-0.0376686193048954,
-0.645586371421814,
-0.1629457175731659,
0.21724282205104828,
-0.4277588427066803,
-0.7385371327400208,
0.6507407426834106,
0.44310611486434937,
0.4454907476902008,
0.2850421965122223,
0.17355398833751678,
0.47831329703330994,
-0.28024908900260925,
0.8488978147506714,
-0.3657601475715637,
-1.0910948514938354,
0.4023832380771637,
-0.22661660611629486,
-0.12774218618869781,
0.3289499878883362,
0.19423528015613556,
-0.9491433501243591,
-0.49050164222717285,
-0.9561188817024231,
-0.9178103804588318,
1.1582738161087036,
-0.10046941787004471,
-0.19255155324935913,
0.03199034929275513,
0.12021854519844055,
-0.1742318868637085,
-0.08385617285966873,
-0.19360187649726868,
-0.47255104780197144,
-0.2811644673347473,
-0.5752919912338257,
-0.030793186277151108,
-0.32514673471450806,
-0.21055178344249725,
-0.4666880965232849,
0.6250241994857788,
0.0011488496093079448,
0.2526623606681824,
0.10178905725479126,
0.13521361351013184,
-0.3982510566711426,
0.04852620139718056,
0.3312607705593109,
0.29648271203041077,
0.147605761885643,
-0.05619258061051369,
0.06108567863702774,
-0.821101188659668,
0.22791540622711182,
0.323404997587204,
-0.03637636452913284,
0.021085813641548157,
0.21045656502246857,
0.3506530523300171,
0.1666036993265152,
-0.7204803228378296,
0.6525051593780518,
-0.07755008339881897,
-0.24700403213500977,
-0.7281224131584167,
0.052002932876348495,
0.49688786268234253,
0.48040807247161865,
0.20866075158119202,
-0.15282072126865387,
0.3589227795600891,
-0.3684212863445282,
0.6048220992088318,
0.1332927942276001,
-0.44486764073371887,
-0.38700586557388306,
0.4079796373844147,
0.20577307045459747,
-0.8306424021720886,
0.3014359474182129,
-0.6334980130195618,
-0.4228098392486572,
0.9936719536781311,
0.6619552373886108,
0.8622843027114868,
-0.6965950727462769,
0.5457754135131836,
-0.11293797940015793,
0.19713710248470306,
0.26955536007881165,
0.5677546858787537,
-0.021325262263417244,
-0.6816904544830322,
-0.08673284202814102,
-0.644548237323761,
-0.3144579231739044,
0.027088884264230728,
-0.6826735138893127,
0.32577499747276306,
-0.40420418977737427,
-0.35964420437812805,
0.3580404818058014,
0.19780640304088593,
-0.12771275639533997,
0.32129430770874023,
0.45920905470848083,
0.27144232392311096,
-0.8133419156074524,
0.8519121408462524,
0.7957786321640015,
-0.2667482793331146,
-0.6010951399803162,
-0.23052941262722015,
0.06115974485874176,
-0.5395686626434326,
0.799649178981781,
-0.07952667027711868,
-0.2732846736907959,
0.1788819432258606,
-0.04626111686229706,
-1.2276722192764282,
0.7539098858833313,
0.18565633893013,
-0.1142638623714447,
0.26322805881500244,
0.42895910143852234,
1.019618272781372,
-0.6692698001861572,
0.26328396797180176,
0.8671612739562988,
0.41967278718948364,
-0.016020672395825386,
-1.5856939554214478,
-0.10254992544651031,
-0.5882320404052734,
-0.17642974853515625,
-0.1775979995727539,
-0.21731728315353394,
0.407240092754364,
0.08119730651378632,
-0.6693328022956848,
-0.002446097321808338,
0.2960260510444641,
0.24438343942165375,
0.9093968868255615,
0.37644386291503906,
0.29132717847824097,
0.8578212857246399,
0.35183006525039673,
0.6197073459625244,
-0.5742557048797607,
-0.08628617227077484,
0.945597767829895,
-0.24286817014217377,
0.7662280797958374,
-0.1832357496023178,
-0.19676323235034943,
0.014606804586946964,
0.6345095634460449,
0.4466525912284851,
0.21591895818710327,
0.2294970005750656,
-0.41155409812927246,
0.26488661766052246,
-0.20111963152885437,
-0.3491596281528473,
0.3696497678756714,
0.946945309638977,
-0.16819413006305695,
0.06987821310758591,
0.3704870641231537,
-0.08962011337280273,
0.3339259922504425,
-0.3143737316131592,
0.7186399102210999,
0.31980687379837036,
-0.2333943396806717,
0.6844691038131714,
-0.09543276578187943,
0.5524527430534363,
-0.1938014030456543,
0.2076663225889206,
0.10416329652070999,
0.02592310681939125,
-0.49622300267219543,
-0.7473233342170715,
0.9453019499778748,
0.20220404863357544,
0.008487963117659092,
-0.2081260085105896,
0.6981329917907715,
-0.4455939829349518,
-0.4330238699913025,
0.3305138051509857,
0.37350374460220337,
0.41815003752708435,
-0.027914462611079216,
-0.68687504529953,
0.005756441969424486,
-0.3372691571712494,
-0.34046515822410583,
0.3385392725467682,
0.4791402220726013,
-0.40540459752082825,
0.8321892023086548,
0.476774126291275,
0.5631888508796692,
0.16813357174396515,
0.08373234421014786,
0.435382217168808,
-0.6292895078659058,
-0.5872873067855835,
-0.35783857107162476,
0.05097181722521782,
0.004765116609632969,
-0.3237687349319458,
0.46547189354896545,
0.4175589680671692,
0.536454975605011,
0.2556288242340088,
0.8120753765106201,
-0.15151478350162506,
1.24372398853302,
0.19013212621212006,
1.1965601444244385,
-0.2347833663225174,
0.16224005818367004,
-0.35445788502693176,
-0.6625908613204956,
-0.5060616135597229,
0.8880027532577515,
-0.21814915537834167,
-0.04914141446352005,
0.859745442867279,
0.6171930432319641,
-0.03197372704744339,
0.47654035687446594,
0.2549237310886383,
0.36834490299224854,
0.36360061168670654,
0.19016990065574646,
0.7128596305847168,
-0.2869487404823303,
0.3167983889579773,
-0.1574135571718216,
-0.5600773692131042,
0.041221097111701965,
-0.23959508538246155,
-0.16187484562397003,
-0.6925192475318909,
-0.4853854179382324,
-0.2841675877571106,
0.27569448947906494,
0.9216722249984741,
0.3793852925300598,
-0.8438509106636047,
-0.37645837664604187,
0.2986527383327484,
-0.029762370511889458,
-0.49497300386428833,
-0.3306860029697418,
0.481764554977417,
-0.1969199776649475,
-0.5981622934341431,
0.697043776512146,
0.06710590422153473,
-0.14309987425804138,
-0.029413964599370956,
0.02630584128201008,
0.3196461498737335,
0.06301163882017136,
0.5247674584388733,
0.6320487260818481,
-0.42148658633232117,
-0.5678592324256897,
-0.23824788630008698,
-0.3351854085922241,
-0.018357178196310997,
0.23961444199085236,
-0.8163377046585083,
0.3072513937950134,
0.050250496715307236,
0.4226183593273163,
0.2651923894882202,
0.05760767683386803,
0.5179332494735718,
-0.287893146276474,
-0.26028573513031006,
0.8383559584617615,
-0.06527500599622726,
0.17470118403434753,
-0.09040317684412003,
0.37779462337493896,
0.2484866976737976,
-0.6075238585472107,
-1.0124578475952148,
0.059302233159542084,
-1.0769541263580322,
0.1955161988735199,
1.3167742490768433,
-0.21859559416770935,
-0.05078153684735298,
-0.984834611415863,
-0.2998293340206146,
0.34289655089378357,
-0.5993602275848389,
0.863537073135376,
0.7287191152572632,
-0.3545837104320526,
0.1379568725824356,
-0.6500231027603149,
0.8879539370536804,
0.1422841101884842,
-0.41019341349601746,
0.10449127852916718,
0.4079853594303131,
0.16886578500270844,
0.148359477519989,
0.9912123084068298,
-0.3884764015674591,
0.5462581515312195,
0.356895387172699,
0.00674991961568594,
0.16192077100276947,
-0.28783780336380005,
-0.6003077030181885,
0.08908899873495102,
-0.14692728221416473,
-0.15334777534008026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15153v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15153v1
|
Self-Adaptive Reconstruction with Contrastive Learning for Unsupervised Sentence Embeddings
| 2024-02-23T07:28:31 | 2024-02-23T07:28:31 |
Junlong Liu, Xichen Shang, Huawen Feng, Junhao Zheng, Qianli Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Unsupervised sentence embeddings task aims to convert sentences to semantic
vector representations. Most previous works directly use the sentence
representations derived from pretrained language models. However, due to the
token bias in pretrained language models, the models can not capture the
fine-grained semantics in sentences, which leads to poor predictions. To
address this issue, we propose a novel Self-Adaptive Reconstruction Contrastive
Sentence Embeddings (SARCSE) framework, which reconstructs all tokens in
sentences with an AutoEncoder to help the model to preserve more fine-grained
semantics during tokens aggregating. In addition, we proposed a self-adaptive
reconstruction loss to alleviate the token bias towards frequency. Experimental
results show that SARCSE gains significant improvements compared with the
strong baseline SimCSE on the 7 STS tasks.
|
[
-0.22249728441238403,
-0.11832431703805923,
0.42665567994117737,
0.10359027981758118,
-0.5154009461402893,
-0.045386604964733124,
0.012925910763442516,
0.013752315193414688,
0.4741171896457672,
0.6669467091560364,
-0.4118700325489044,
-0.2779664099216461,
-0.7064968347549438,
0.06734607368707657,
-0.5550827383995056,
1.003007173538208,
-0.06321226060390472,
0.16497045755386353,
-0.1527753472328186,
-0.2765786349773407,
-0.4617473781108856,
-0.46350252628326416,
-0.3477952778339386,
0.17470543086528778,
-0.09493821114301682,
0.22698554396629333,
0.19132427871227264,
0.5502209067344666,
0.2828388810157776,
0.3699362576007843,
0.2766015827655792,
0.03482339158654213,
-0.3641449213027954,
0.16229401528835297,
-0.48366498947143555,
-0.12382394075393677,
-0.041936732828617096,
-0.06121491268277168,
0.5114604234695435,
0.515664279460907,
-0.21923433244228363,
-0.14056497812271118,
0.4094633162021637,
0.6263414025306702,
-0.7935829758644104,
0.024179277941584587,
-0.6324871182441711,
0.022266587242484093,
0.16569973528385162,
-0.24676509201526642,
-0.17998124659061432,
0.44021692872047424,
0.08545753359794617,
-0.49205005168914795,
0.3186919391155243,
0.0625719204545021,
0.48097336292266846,
0.43425413966178894,
-0.6160796284675598,
-0.42155182361602783,
-0.37834349274635315,
0.7914570569992065,
-0.702599048614502,
0.3051847517490387,
0.17815209925174713,
0.1344635933637619,
-0.2554778754711151,
-0.9081142544746399,
-0.35093051195144653,
-0.0705791637301445,
-0.1931658536195755,
0.38004881143569946,
-0.40331992506980896,
-0.13069966435432434,
-0.3739387094974518,
0.4674132764339447,
-0.4564712941646576,
0.0623786523938179,
-0.1779649406671524,
-0.40261656045913696,
0.31441909074783325,
0.2110857367515564,
0.16640731692314148,
-0.47660377621650696,
-0.8852978348731995,
-0.3640434443950653,
-0.1308049112558365,
-0.2278386950492859,
-0.06189931929111481,
0.3010675609111786,
-0.23671306669712067,
0.22601453959941864,
-0.16586631536483765,
0.4877479374408722,
0.17117291688919067,
0.5432800054550171,
0.4085487425327301,
-0.5869436860084534,
-0.42940714955329895,
0.001088224700652063,
0.7564952373504639,
0.3469010889530182,
0.19322717189788818,
-0.14930342137813568,
-0.163601815700531,
0.16313502192497253,
0.3912245035171509,
-0.7075642943382263,
-0.32447075843811035,
-0.0531974732875824,
-0.6603272557258606,
-0.17232410609722137,
0.07901514321565628,
-0.8107444643974304,
-0.1394408941268921,
-0.22543950378894806,
0.36915144324302673,
-0.49175596237182617,
0.11615407466888428,
0.25292137265205383,
-0.10544512420892715,
0.017240481451153755,
0.026280660182237625,
-0.8011043667793274,
0.5229265689849854,
0.09419947862625122,
0.630307674407959,
-0.4280359745025635,
-0.41904112696647644,
-0.608655571937561,
0.16908405721187592,
-0.25784388184547424,
0.9675372838973999,
-0.3052312135696411,
-0.5510725378990173,
-0.21876247227191925,
0.13413085043430328,
-0.21586868166923523,
-0.335444837808609,
0.5935055017471313,
-0.2621038854122162,
0.3271883726119995,
-0.1024557575583458,
-0.7055540084838867,
0.21374356746673584,
0.16114068031311035,
-0.2564058005809784,
0.9877709150314331,
0.26569613814353943,
-0.797573447227478,
0.14426858723163605,
-0.5476104617118835,
-0.3165140151977539,
-0.3167078495025635,
-0.381613165140152,
-0.426845908164978,
0.340908408164978,
0.6310302019119263,
0.6831516027450562,
0.03678683564066887,
0.20910495519638062,
-0.22440508008003235,
-0.29854854941368103,
0.03378475084900856,
-0.46913161873817444,
0.47269436717033386,
0.3804376721382141,
-0.3905791938304901,
0.23929116129875183,
-0.6606703996658325,
-0.265166312456131,
0.10258661955595016,
0.10671961307525635,
-0.5494245886802673,
0.05583292618393898,
0.07263705879449844,
0.17848463356494904,
0.0005513042560778558,
-0.7010555267333984,
0.08695177733898163,
-0.6087783575057983,
0.6423879861831665,
0.9820547103881836,
-0.014452525414526463,
0.7174513936042786,
-0.11824427545070648,
0.2948138415813446,
0.4932398498058319,
-0.20813065767288208,
-0.38723430037498474,
0.340673565864563,
-0.7272196412086487,
-0.39410436153411865,
0.42270222306251526,
0.17491938173770905,
-0.623931884765625,
0.48563840985298157,
-0.21537679433822632,
-0.08927188068628311,
-0.506473958492279,
0.05101562291383743,
0.2684641480445862,
0.2978760600090027,
0.7508167028427124,
-0.48058682680130005,
-0.7287395596504211,
-0.9225613474845886,
-0.36100324988365173,
0.14961588382720947,
-0.09721024334430695,
0.37999361753463745,
0.5365402698516846,
-0.27089521288871765,
0.8705786466598511,
-0.5935212969779968,
-0.7657843828201294,
-0.00545108038932085,
0.22359225153923035,
-0.3790275752544403,
0.9105280637741089,
0.7154495120048523,
-0.5455301403999329,
-0.2991410195827484,
-0.35163140296936035,
-0.46595534682273865,
-0.09129306674003601,
-0.30698147416114807,
-0.1826276183128357,
0.07365647703409195,
1.0132538080215454,
-0.22029997408390045,
0.48526591062545776,
0.6673569083213806,
-0.7271519303321838,
0.2780539095401764,
-0.4564961791038513,
0.2862303555011749,
-1.443132758140564,
-0.25673332810401917,
-0.175339475274086,
-0.4222348630428314,
-0.18636173009872437,
-0.20276285707950592,
-0.018128568306565285,
-0.14432092010974884,
-0.18914881348609924,
0.6792593002319336,
-0.7133336663246155,
-0.4411095678806305,
-0.5727794170379639,
0.35920313000679016,
0.05602724850177765,
0.37267372012138367,
-0.10011264681816101,
0.9625064730644226,
0.690624475479126,
-0.5428882241249084,
0.02311905100941658,
0.3847767412662506,
-0.29253441095352173,
0.43356582522392273,
-0.43067845702171326,
-0.06728053092956543,
-0.2803041338920593,
0.4939544200897217,
-1.099158763885498,
0.10057314485311508,
0.14735160768032074,
-0.37454184889793396,
0.19749128818511963,
0.20753082633018494,
0.13505323231220245,
-0.1890014410018921,
-0.3157873749732971,
0.5688264966011047,
0.372577965259552,
-0.7220598459243774,
0.9369457960128784,
0.1701812893152237,
0.013289044611155987,
-0.5028102397918701,
-0.8666701912879944,
0.16548959910869598,
0.02348104491829872,
-0.005677574314177036,
0.6369753479957581,
-0.056922797113657,
0.12789912521839142,
0.2838858962059021,
-0.2401721328496933,
0.09743031114339828,
0.11762692779302597,
0.0997830182313919,
0.02711201272904873,
-0.3054408133029938,
0.30059289932250977,
-0.06376981735229492,
-0.17116114497184753,
-0.023343367502093315,
-0.4273410439491272,
0.7253717184066772,
0.03725308179855347,
-0.3076823353767395,
-0.39242851734161377,
0.3383357524871826,
0.4080750048160553,
-0.3795924782752991,
0.3797604739665985,
0.7011005282402039,
-0.22581322491168976,
-0.21839602291584015,
-0.4751942455768585,
-0.16686825454235077,
-0.48216933012008667,
0.4949989914894104,
-0.45082420110702515,
-1.0793285369873047,
0.4165864884853363,
-0.13399071991443634,
-0.3328886926174164,
0.8044591546058655,
0.4292607605457306,
-0.2835048735141754,
0.5970355868339539,
0.5373573303222656,
-0.2795502543449402,
0.6562867164611816,
-0.12886841595172882,
-0.09113657474517822,
-0.9473483562469482,
-0.06219153851270676,
-0.6386334300041199,
-0.07282914221286774,
-0.6243970990180969,
-0.609762966632843,
-0.11728665977716446,
-0.025026420131325722,
-0.4883779287338257,
0.16962118446826935,
-0.5641154646873474,
0.3258764147758484,
0.4859031140804291,
0.21832361817359924,
-0.14413191378116608,
0.12326324731111526,
-0.17665663361549377,
0.03434130176901817,
-0.7243785858154297,
-0.27334365248680115,
0.8305827975273132,
-0.03164571523666382,
0.7450393438339233,
-0.254786878824234,
0.9441089034080505,
0.5996537208557129,
-0.08034572750329971,
-0.5000198483467102,
0.41389915347099304,
-0.86588454246521,
-0.14961464703083038,
-0.17333319783210754,
-0.46161210536956787,
-0.9825121164321899,
0.38295939564704895,
-0.30713462829589844,
-0.577975332736969,
0.6291795969009399,
0.15601399540901184,
-0.2883037030696869,
0.28266626596450806,
-0.4126543402671814,
1.0097403526306152,
-0.11133366078138351,
-0.051158759742975235,
-0.42825597524642944,
-0.6460605263710022,
-0.03333675488829613,
0.13376806676387787,
0.18086156249046326,
-0.05637236684560776,
0.060701530426740646,
0.8277950286865234,
-0.26748740673065186,
1.026811957359314,
-0.2604372799396515,
0.2828957140445709,
0.25887754559516907,
0.2232014238834381,
0.4772179424762726,
-0.2577931880950928,
-0.043760184198617935,
-0.2881166338920593,
0.1562713235616684,
-0.8473691940307617,
-0.7199873328208923,
0.9227820634841919,
-0.8178690671920776,
-0.45662975311279297,
-0.6557337641716003,
-0.420241117477417,
-0.2016320526599884,
0.09095244109630585,
0.002143902936950326,
0.5980116128921509,
-0.6436155438423157,
0.2011512964963913,
0.17721647024154663,
-0.10900869965553284,
0.7660478353500366,
0.42422306537628174,
0.1332804262638092,
-0.6040558218955994,
0.7204028964042664,
-0.22521808743476868,
0.19149872660636902,
0.11755786091089249,
0.06013425439596176,
-0.33002227544784546,
-0.6491625905036926,
-0.26280224323272705,
0.01413637399673462,
-0.7532837986946106,
-0.3873904049396515,
-0.8259550929069519,
-0.054071106016635895,
-0.6784367561340332,
-0.5229402780532837,
-0.3637278079986572,
-0.44754451513290405,
-0.6108043193817139,
-0.01271080132573843,
0.09752174466848373,
0.6884220838546753,
-0.16224011778831482,
0.4611990749835968,
-0.6152204871177673,
0.31786900758743286,
0.16808946430683136,
0.22528818249702454,
-0.12035101652145386,
-0.8760107755661011,
-0.08390214294195175,
-0.10862695425748825,
0.005863694939762354,
-0.5242801308631897,
0.4701171815395355,
0.28873342275619507,
0.5128276944160461,
0.08548697829246521,
0.317256361246109,
0.7679203748703003,
-0.45374566316604614,
0.9021719694137573,
0.2875114381313324,
-1.0711967945098877,
0.45262405276298523,
0.009214826859533787,
0.5289726853370667,
0.7002869248390198,
0.05593875050544739,
-0.3761294186115265,
-0.16949954628944397,
-0.680428147315979,
-0.7094038724899292,
0.5534507036209106,
0.19783353805541992,
0.5223866701126099,
-0.4674275517463684,
0.6130563616752625,
-0.04587509483098984,
-0.14201650023460388,
-0.6873970031738281,
0.09910610318183899,
-0.9249499440193176,
-0.6872336864471436,
-0.3653407096862793,
-0.5083287954330444,
0.13370108604431152,
0.14234323799610138,
0.7244018912315369,
-0.4214117228984833,
0.4076247215270996,
0.6181297898292542,
-0.27414435148239136,
0.20685571432113647,
0.4866906702518463,
0.2709280848503113,
0.033633437007665634,
-0.034320585429668427,
0.40630146861076355,
0.35627150535583496,
-0.10002819448709488,
0.10910546034574509,
0.18906466662883759,
0.10392366349697113,
-0.3216770589351654,
0.33604612946510315,
0.8870391845703125,
0.5741342306137085,
-0.5072499513626099,
0.8294917941093445,
-0.09602998942136765,
0.002464552177116275,
-0.2045297622680664,
-0.12070759385824203,
-0.07650429755449295,
0.2772483229637146,
0.28810107707977295,
0.2810080945491791,
0.3026244044303894,
-0.503909170627594,
0.5633159875869751,
0.44609880447387695,
-0.5346893072128296,
-0.04895635321736336,
0.6840285658836365,
0.2649949789047241,
0.0508444644510746,
0.4297168254852295,
0.024969790130853653,
-0.5054280757904053,
0.564454972743988,
0.9595773816108704,
0.8399499654769897,
-0.5034240484237671,
0.16370296478271484,
0.37354785203933716,
0.05195673927664757,
-0.03206445276737213,
0.135564386844635,
-0.09194080531597137,
-0.8165957927703857,
-0.32285964488983154,
-0.7199726104736328,
0.13101117312908173,
-0.3205644190311432,
-0.781764566898346,
-0.03756875917315483,
-0.19409456849098206,
0.29249218106269836,
-0.1579136699438095,
-0.3007435202598572,
-0.470895379781723,
0.603934109210968,
-0.12259919941425323,
0.7773421406745911,
-0.943278968334198,
0.7960089445114136,
0.5572094917297363,
-0.32915809750556946,
-0.5061861872673035,
0.10422251373529434,
-0.45171019434928894,
-0.9317477941513062,
0.5428934097290039,
-0.03483095020055771,
-0.3173062205314636,
0.35658887028694153,
-0.2905591130256653,
-0.9137206673622131,
1.061824917793274,
0.3633020520210266,
-0.5399478077888489,
0.05723334476351738,
-0.04437440261244774,
0.5067559480667114,
-0.8719832301139832,
0.08062530308961868,
0.22130092978477478,
0.06657426804304123,
0.03964393958449364,
-0.6009594202041626,
0.1999993920326233,
0.029707789421081543,
0.26919636130332947,
0.030566681176424026,
-0.6054258942604065,
0.6253322958946228,
0.1910460740327835,
-0.14999599754810333,
0.19628959894180298,
1.0317939519882202,
-0.19872671365737915,
0.01002243347465992,
0.7788434624671936,
0.4773919880390167,
0.35851576924324036,
0.07184581458568573,
0.9301538467407227,
-0.46156495809555054,
0.41954517364501953,
1.2965717315673828,
-0.119273342192173,
0.8526924848556519,
0.5052481293678284,
0.1226540207862854,
0.7640112042427063,
0.4026699960231781,
-0.11955097317695618,
0.7344447374343872,
0.054911624640226364,
-0.08802371472120285,
-0.5275487899780273,
-0.1139499619603157,
-0.12876702845096588,
0.8946272730827332,
0.04768475517630577,
-0.6558432579040527,
-0.42373964190483093,
0.5194979310035706,
-0.296990305185318,
0.5311811566352844,
-0.5160724520683289,
0.8530862331390381,
0.12514254450798035,
-0.4622997045516968,
0.36925336718559265,
-0.14980536699295044,
0.5919712781906128,
-0.48364055156707764,
0.03259548172354698,
-0.27751782536506653,
0.38037869334220886,
-0.03083718568086624,
-0.47195082902908325,
0.47029852867126465,
-0.42312872409820557,
-0.07150541245937347,
-0.2541907727718353,
0.9965207576751709,
-0.5241856575012207,
-0.37450021505355835,
0.5484645962715149,
0.5469610095024109,
-0.0315655879676342,
0.08032991737127304,
-0.8459712862968445,
0.009308496490120888,
0.03213998302817345,
-0.24031226336956024,
0.5876065492630005,
0.4013831317424774,
0.09330889582633972,
0.4959556758403778,
0.36064714193344116,
-0.295111745595932,
-0.0505816787481308,
0.11164753139019012,
1.1220451593399048,
-0.9663620591163635,
-0.7891756892204285,
-0.6506297588348389,
0.3176969289779663,
-0.01944921724498272,
-0.11463192105293274,
0.5764186382293701,
0.5628141760826111,
0.7013446092605591,
-0.14663013815879822,
0.5650929808616638,
0.10766618698835373,
0.4624817669391632,
-0.6975788474082947,
0.3638703525066376,
-0.6219356656074524,
0.058295540511608124,
-0.15027464926242828,
-0.5248796343803406,
-0.23911438882350922,
0.8223111629486084,
-0.056359220296144485,
0.08542419970035553,
0.8109264969825745,
0.7096104621887207,
-0.2820679247379303,
-0.1731981337070465,
0.2778278887271881,
0.4896894693374634,
-0.017834078520536423,
0.2939169108867645,
0.48967254161834717,
-0.6611493229866028,
0.49871402978897095,
0.0033634561114013195,
-0.03387521579861641,
-0.0317961648106575,
-0.8554555773735046,
-0.7746612429618835,
-0.6789902448654175,
-0.3067361116409302,
-0.41377130150794983,
0.4012669324874878,
0.999076247215271,
0.5502922534942627,
-1.0568946599960327,
-0.08264521509408951,
-0.35337522625923157,
-0.45699578523635864,
-0.08438687026500702,
-0.15838170051574707,
0.8637118339538574,
-0.7097429037094116,
-0.5732822418212891,
0.6859285831451416,
0.2241528481245041,
0.3292560875415802,
-0.05666622892022133,
0.08080360293388367,
-0.2958424389362335,
0.26892805099487305,
0.4811190366744995,
0.1606714427471161,
-0.6149206757545471,
-0.5988696217536926,
-0.2396560162305832,
-0.24962611496448517,
0.18529942631721497,
1.035192608833313,
-1.140029788017273,
0.3685157001018524,
0.1845877766609192,
0.913811445236206,
0.8889646530151367,
0.1456398367881775,
0.474264919757843,
-0.692637026309967,
0.19803301990032196,
0.08282085508108139,
0.7837684154510498,
0.25726374983787537,
-0.21329258382320404,
0.45472559332847595,
0.30175796151161194,
-0.5238500237464905,
-0.5050226449966431,
0.2865763306617737,
-1.2404885292053223,
-0.8182297348976135,
0.9739204049110413,
-0.3245376944541931,
-0.26526373624801636,
-0.08893943578004837,
-0.3743699789047241,
0.3873388171195984,
-0.10281062126159668,
0.8027974367141724,
0.4383596181869507,
-0.036490604281425476,
-0.2194734811782837,
0.1426965594291687,
0.4126722812652588,
0.8503973484039307,
-0.6546115875244141,
0.26165783405303955,
0.5235903263092041,
0.4350675344467163,
-0.09229970723390579,
0.8648056387901306,
-0.20260770618915558,
0.15642322599887848,
0.10733012855052948,
0.11512693762779236,
-0.1865575611591339,
0.0006641905638389289,
-0.4916195869445801,
0.2119293361902237,
-0.16928786039352417,
-0.3256372809410095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15151v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15151v2
|
Where Visual Speech Meets Language: VSP-LLM Framework for Efficient and Context-Aware Visual Speech Processing
| 2024-02-23T07:21:32 | 2024-05-14T02:58:21 |
Jeong Hun Yeo, Seunghee Han, Minsu Kim, Yong Man Ro
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, eess.AS, eess.IV
|
In visual speech processing, context modeling capability is one of the most
important requirements due to the ambiguous nature of lip movements. For
example, homophenes, words that share identical lip movements but produce
different sounds, can be distinguished by considering the context. In this
paper, we propose a novel framework, namely Visual Speech Processing
incorporated with LLMs (VSP-LLM), to maximize the context modeling ability by
bringing the overwhelming power of LLMs. Specifically, VSP-LLM is designed to
perform multi-tasks of visual speech recognition and translation, where the
given instructions control the type of task. The input video is mapped to the
input latent space of an LLM by employing a self-supervised visual speech
model. Focused on the fact that there is redundant information in input frames,
we propose a novel deduplication method that reduces the embedded visual
features by employing visual speech units. Through the proposed deduplication
and Low Rank Adaptation (LoRA), VSP-LLM can be trained in a computationally
efficient manner. In the translation dataset, the MuAViC benchmark, we
demonstrate that VSP-LLM trained on just 30 hours of labeled data can more
effectively translate lip movements compared to the recent model trained with
433 hours of data.
|
[
-0.26963070034980774,
-0.7463182210922241,
0.41997283697128296,
0.18997004628181458,
-0.44078555703163147,
-0.20006169378757477,
-0.186277374625206,
-0.45461809635162354,
0.13684126734733582,
0.6635695695877075,
-0.5177841782569885,
-0.6304911971092224,
-0.5676824450492859,
-0.1533990055322647,
-0.4756881892681122,
0.45600008964538574,
0.12894372642040253,
0.3587057888507843,
-0.2663406729698181,
-0.42913752794265747,
-0.42192715406417847,
-0.38124364614486694,
-0.09302058070898056,
-0.26568135619163513,
0.26236698031425476,
0.38225820660591125,
0.2936325669288635,
0.9367086887359619,
0.4426014721393585,
0.34066641330718994,
-0.17266039550304413,
0.056727875024080276,
-0.33981096744537354,
0.038092441856861115,
0.08194799721240997,
-0.4400985538959503,
-0.5232499241828918,
-0.1904301643371582,
0.8371663689613342,
0.567923367023468,
-0.2616827189922333,
0.12463800609111786,
0.22601154446601868,
0.43647342920303345,
-0.5605405569076538,
0.21218571066856384,
-0.6007970571517944,
0.03428548946976662,
-0.09931297600269318,
-0.38958173990249634,
0.07088912278413773,
-0.03673803061246872,
0.10763070732355118,
-0.2700214385986328,
0.0011360188946127892,
-0.39021238684654236,
0.2572776973247528,
0.6651695966720581,
-0.1687518060207367,
0.040695689618587494,
-0.6814361214637756,
0.5960707068443298,
-0.5166484713554382,
0.5243948698043823,
-0.07243243604898453,
0.34545424580574036,
-0.012675364501774311,
-0.6655110716819763,
-0.7143318057060242,
0.09154316782951355,
0.3869844377040863,
0.08945581316947937,
-0.25787609815597534,
0.04048129543662071,
0.3641108572483063,
0.1684339940547943,
-0.7075421214103699,
0.20124506950378418,
-0.12187183648347855,
-0.019672401249408722,
0.21166542172431946,
-0.08280418068170547,
0.4380299150943756,
-0.3859522342681885,
-0.8604193925857544,
-0.07601823657751083,
-0.5435826778411865,
0.3374669551849365,
-0.2186761200428009,
0.4682653844356537,
-0.3892805576324463,
0.6852191090583801,
-0.274171382188797,
0.8455267548561096,
-0.4988054931163788,
-0.6294130086898804,
0.3305913805961609,
-0.27947288751602173,
-0.5367213487625122,
0.275051474571228,
0.4959927201271057,
0.30666762590408325,
0.26970139145851135,
0.3195749521255493,
-0.00028067108360119164,
0.212039053440094,
-0.15467001497745514,
-0.7944508194923401,
0.12951867282390594,
-0.1880730837583542,
-0.24302630126476288,
-0.07701694965362549,
-0.4208463132381439,
-0.6079723238945007,
-0.2867717146873474,
-0.6736060380935669,
0.19757117331027985,
-0.21186165511608124,
-0.005195952486246824,
-0.04232727736234665,
0.040104977786540985,
0.46086379885673523,
0.5101771354675293,
-0.7935593128204346,
0.2842746078968048,
0.5550567507743835,
0.6941972374916077,
-0.388850599527359,
-0.3240810036659241,
-0.9919706583023071,
0.3399588167667389,
-0.016396861523389816,
0.7309510111808777,
-0.4806138277053833,
-0.2095818966627121,
-0.06028720363974571,
-0.22879983484745026,
-0.10463668406009674,
-0.5673076510429382,
0.32982954382896423,
-0.09698780626058578,
-0.08997831493616104,
-0.2227773666381836,
-0.4233519732952118,
-0.1737062782049179,
-0.06171625480055809,
-0.18692611157894135,
0.7419082522392273,
-0.13528305292129517,
-0.5013054609298706,
0.4808230698108673,
-0.2838438153266907,
-0.35764071345329285,
0.4532867670059204,
-0.6531263589859009,
-0.1775059551000595,
0.09948855638504028,
0.4359634518623352,
0.45925021171569824,
-0.3835359811782837,
0.2854509949684143,
-0.35460710525512695,
-0.36382511258125305,
-0.0287073515355587,
-0.4669168293476105,
0.6001237630844116,
0.10903811454772949,
-0.43708527088165283,
0.2823905050754547,
-0.8438500165939331,
0.01678658463060856,
-0.12470383197069168,
-0.4293743073940277,
-0.2622910737991333,
-0.009670360945165157,
0.14928731322288513,
0.2734839916229248,
0.15126925706863403,
-0.23536495864391327,
0.28915590047836304,
-0.2654356062412262,
0.5389153361320496,
0.6843276619911194,
-0.29846975207328796,
0.5205770134925842,
0.024678943678736687,
0.4662746787071228,
-0.034719858318567276,
0.05333131551742554,
-0.11774616688489914,
-0.43288862705230713,
-0.7272390723228455,
-0.6942781209945679,
-0.09980416297912598,
0.8730677962303162,
-0.885206937789917,
0.2692164182662964,
-0.5733925700187683,
-0.07143498212099075,
-0.4356672167778015,
0.4842938780784607,
0.2657794952392578,
0.8607536554336548,
0.45200636982917786,
-0.301046222448349,
-0.463288813829422,
-0.94855797290802,
-0.1672172099351883,
-0.13735947012901306,
-0.003698054002597928,
0.41456305980682373,
0.2684391438961029,
-0.35299497842788696,
0.8488251566886902,
-0.1551866978406906,
-0.6795963644981384,
-0.3109455108642578,
-0.04520842805504799,
0.03274484723806381,
0.48087555170059204,
0.571509838104248,
-0.9159143567085266,
-0.3137997090816498,
-0.1618630439043045,
-0.8978108763694763,
-0.4375424385070801,
0.042748965322971344,
0.18124918639659882,
0.12736372649669647,
0.7480424046516418,
-0.13690638542175293,
0.5321006178855896,
0.7001873254776001,
0.05739809200167656,
0.03607941418886185,
-0.11506084352731705,
0.11482344567775726,
-0.9172254800796509,
-0.05108915641903877,
-0.053471844643354416,
-0.5956280827522278,
-0.5435781478881836,
-0.26384928822517395,
-0.16377045214176178,
-0.46826040744781494,
-0.867110550403595,
0.4554600715637207,
-0.41171345114707947,
-0.23575492203235626,
-0.33877497911453247,
0.5512341260910034,
-0.440542072057724,
0.6626073718070984,
0.19498394429683685,
0.7635290026664734,
0.9138326644897461,
-0.43493202328681946,
0.46062204241752625,
0.19054335355758667,
-0.4366801083087921,
0.9037241339683533,
-0.4898020923137665,
-0.274667352437973,
-0.13252894580364227,
-0.22191044688224792,
-1.0906846523284912,
-0.08652506023645401,
0.34097158908843994,
-0.1368064284324646,
0.19457487761974335,
-0.38833045959472656,
-0.2672519087791443,
-0.05531845614314079,
-0.05535447597503662,
0.2682400345802307,
0.5031780004501343,
-0.703413724899292,
0.7062041163444519,
0.6055067181587219,
-0.3427373170852661,
-0.6420661807060242,
-0.9717023968696594,
0.17673452198505402,
-0.37196382880210876,
-0.7454107403755188,
0.4003652334213257,
-0.15272803604602814,
0.04748200997710228,
-0.11205526441335678,
-0.3252468705177307,
0.04266493394970894,
-0.10352665185928345,
0.35731855034828186,
0.03707089275121689,
-0.15588393807411194,
-0.007285817991942167,
-0.13401775062084198,
-0.043617311865091324,
-0.21102328598499298,
-0.19577480852603912,
0.41443005204200745,
-0.2748592793941498,
-0.3078855574131012,
-0.5950902104377747,
0.43849989771842957,
0.5775808095932007,
-0.007687634788453579,
0.2873069941997528,
0.6505659222602844,
-0.31327903270721436,
-0.1932705044746399,
-0.5692217946052551,
0.08659510314464569,
-0.4344017207622528,
0.5058419704437256,
-0.5696468353271484,
-0.9268927574157715,
0.3307722508907318,
-0.21960973739624023,
-0.42188411951065063,
-0.0751555860042572,
0.48374035954475403,
-0.2431095689535141,
0.669384241104126,
0.8091817498207092,
-0.32840535044670105,
0.9824278354644775,
-0.08737635612487793,
-0.008212211541831493,
-0.9380091428756714,
-0.06811864674091339,
-0.21167585253715515,
-0.19483456015586853,
-0.6013485193252563,
-0.7826842069625854,
0.5388705730438232,
0.40868714451789856,
0.2496843785047531,
0.4077243506908417,
-0.27454498410224915,
0.35596171021461487,
0.5740300416946411,
-0.07273992896080017,
0.26224032044410706,
0.5749783515930176,
-0.14654485881328583,
-0.1919659823179245,
-0.8014025092124939,
-0.37499168515205383,
0.6106077432632446,
0.12427316606044769,
0.8661326766014099,
0.028779074549674988,
0.6147878766059875,
0.2557167708873749,
0.09693606942892075,
-0.7919626235961914,
0.9661963582038879,
-0.22756049036979675,
0.14785455167293549,
-0.497289776802063,
-0.5739226937294006,
-0.5800312757492065,
0.6146675944328308,
-0.30484554171562195,
-0.9221954345703125,
0.13999974727630615,
0.24967575073242188,
0.1608457863330841,
0.14849853515625,
-0.3184066116809845,
0.7613915205001831,
-0.44712164998054504,
-0.5048301219940186,
-0.2530614137649536,
-0.6722235679626465,
0.17178039252758026,
0.2931341230869293,
0.24818430840969086,
-0.19308136403560638,
-0.06422892212867737,
0.39769360423088074,
-0.25297218561172485,
0.8090136647224426,
-0.27761390805244446,
-0.27890175580978394,
0.23841571807861328,
-0.058474257588386536,
0.2536510229110718,
-0.02811611443758011,
0.2982436418533325,
0.3598674535751343,
-0.2113441675901413,
-0.11036757379770279,
-0.3955848515033722,
0.8815733194351196,
-0.31097912788391113,
-0.5646937489509583,
-0.3104318380355835,
-0.28058677911758423,
-0.049528542906045914,
0.2843579351902008,
0.07549361884593964,
0.3618209660053253,
-0.29686805605888367,
0.36473846435546875,
0.5466768741607666,
-0.21298062801361084,
0.5897008180618286,
0.41035521030426025,
-0.37452104687690735,
-0.5218868255615234,
0.8061478137969971,
0.09679775685071945,
0.11224991828203201,
0.6579204797744751,
0.11994556337594986,
-0.3056507110595703,
-0.41079890727996826,
-0.5347440838813782,
0.20884782075881958,
-0.8869161009788513,
0.027850093320012093,
-0.466857373714447,
0.02909691445529461,
-0.5733283758163452,
0.020732423290610313,
-0.3831672668457031,
-0.26332810521125793,
-0.3881053030490875,
0.20279629528522491,
-0.0882100984454155,
0.12383436411619186,
-0.2261403501033783,
0.26045888662338257,
-0.5336402654647827,
0.9781439900398254,
0.8050152659416199,
0.22544196248054504,
-0.3867657780647278,
-0.4564943313598633,
0.14043854176998138,
-0.020098987966775894,
-0.03970939293503761,
-0.7339834570884705,
0.4554620385169983,
0.23652702569961548,
0.5753471851348877,
0.0694059431552887,
-0.346485435962677,
1.044542670249939,
-0.5054794549942017,
0.5459204316139221,
0.31658387184143066,
-1.1942400932312012,
0.6818606853485107,
-0.19036798179149628,
0.5583669543266296,
0.23601017892360687,
0.03465922921895981,
-0.6063662767410278,
0.04136908799409866,
-0.12170707434415817,
-0.8911816477775574,
0.43238651752471924,
0.17289814352989197,
-0.22990570962429047,
0.2620178163051605,
0.10229329764842987,
-0.3321555256843567,
0.34177160263061523,
-0.9005432724952698,
-0.22698092460632324,
-0.12568709254264832,
-0.010306669399142265,
-0.10704033076763153,
-0.28758782148361206,
-0.1648537665605545,
-0.35609930753707886,
0.2453926056623459,
-0.43579789996147156,
0.06374196708202362,
0.3453521132469177,
-0.5193862318992615,
0.031003836542367935,
0.38680127263069153,
0.8498679995536804,
0.48441797494888306,
0.08354156464338303,
0.20340178906917572,
0.2706353962421417,
-0.1576002687215805,
0.021355828270316124,
0.11617503315210342,
-0.05762277543544769,
-0.16580882668495178,
0.3980836868286133,
0.9593802094459534,
0.3368634581565857,
-0.7789381742477417,
0.7425369620323181,
-0.09643547981977463,
0.07802888751029968,
-0.46057263016700745,
0.18196238577365875,
0.14105015993118286,
0.4903014302253723,
0.21051879227161407,
0.15694889426231384,
0.2601938843727112,
-0.45395323634147644,
0.27267029881477356,
0.41619589924812317,
-0.38327229022979736,
-0.031519390642642975,
0.7168216705322266,
0.21041572093963623,
-0.2502310872077942,
0.323087602853775,
0.4450811743736267,
-0.36766135692596436,
0.3313785195350647,
0.3372538983821869,
0.7745999097824097,
-0.2068103551864624,
-0.0006794041837565601,
0.02137932740151882,
0.15869538486003876,
0.17647463083267212,
0.6276344060897827,
-0.6149281859397888,
-0.4486338794231415,
-0.4585927426815033,
-0.6723346710205078,
-0.1442943811416626,
0.19349217414855957,
-0.4862816035747528,
0.3313831388950348,
-0.09894602000713348,
0.03857363015413284,
-0.22385825216770172,
-0.6308476328849792,
-0.6937071084976196,
0.07196827977895737,
0.5900514125823975,
0.5119983553886414,
-0.6599050760269165,
1.0239388942718506,
0.38653022050857544,
-0.04483886808156967,
-0.31571200489997864,
-0.3263559639453888,
0.21679814159870148,
-0.8267995715141296,
0.9048317670822144,
0.16880643367767334,
-0.6176478862762451,
-0.12803684175014496,
-0.5402076840400696,
-0.6932616829872131,
0.8995848298072815,
0.5638525485992432,
-0.992617130279541,
0.19760490953922272,
0.5181007385253906,
0.5501019954681396,
-0.4412159025669098,
-0.4185962677001953,
0.42344939708709717,
0.27959707379341125,
0.09629888832569122,
-0.936434268951416,
-0.2514904737472534,
-0.12134999781847,
0.44650712609291077,
-0.2683267891407013,
-0.36035844683647156,
0.5470084547996521,
-0.23571504652500153,
-0.2910970151424408,
0.1297406554222107,
0.6586530804634094,
0.20164577662944794,
0.026167497038841248,
0.5009360313415527,
0.5307341814041138,
0.5239149928092957,
0.03943930193781853,
0.7946031093597412,
-0.18244412541389465,
-0.026728421449661255,
1.354153037071228,
-0.21666806936264038,
0.9298845529556274,
0.7997559905052185,
0.21830281615257263,
0.02850383147597313,
0.10290729999542236,
0.04113835096359253,
0.57901930809021,
0.3291475176811218,
-0.21232354640960693,
-0.45009422302246094,
-0.16165196895599365,
-0.35490933060646057,
0.919111430644989,
0.21898336708545685,
-0.28053316473960876,
-0.11952874809503555,
0.372245192527771,
-0.4943881332874298,
0.15313193202018738,
-0.25988608598709106,
0.8875901103019714,
0.25929445028305054,
-0.3170146346092224,
0.8302209973335266,
-0.3040560185909271,
0.6912388205528259,
-0.5238773226737976,
-0.19571247696876526,
-0.08798690885305405,
0.14861436188220978,
0.035308197140693665,
-0.5532102584838867,
-0.002821306698024273,
0.002897293074056506,
-0.2931019067764282,
-0.6092698574066162,
0.5849161744117737,
-0.679401695728302,
-0.2805168330669403,
0.5549799203872681,
0.6072063446044922,
0.18449614942073822,
0.004366903565824032,
-0.6790441274642944,
0.46133288741111755,
0.0490773469209671,
-0.1452707201242447,
0.1727531999349594,
0.23090501129627228,
0.03398175537586212,
1.0183703899383545,
0.49979913234710693,
0.42617952823638916,
0.09935291111469269,
0.3556153476238251,
0.6202345490455627,
-0.6500101089477539,
-0.5589746236801147,
-0.7905101180076599,
0.37832069396972656,
0.1003103032708168,
-0.13944539427757263,
0.5546063780784607,
0.4153493642807007,
0.9254385232925415,
-0.1765659600496292,
0.6326498985290527,
0.2464573085308075,
0.303083598613739,
-0.7495502829551697,
0.3776293694972992,
-0.7365922927856445,
0.48487481474876404,
-0.6003555655479431,
-1.011087417602539,
-0.3843301236629486,
0.7817283272743225,
0.008253449574112892,
-0.11139106750488281,
0.33039286732673645,
0.6018814444541931,
-0.12301675975322723,
-0.2532426416873932,
0.5558287501335144,
0.05116908252239227,
0.41843417286872864,
0.4061369001865387,
0.5450458526611328,
-0.39285996556282043,
0.5495872497558594,
-0.1989012509584427,
-0.24281556904315948,
-0.30886268615722656,
-0.9885483384132385,
-0.7198174595832825,
-0.5939551591873169,
-0.42274609208106995,
0.2097284346818924,
-0.14341816306114197,
0.6936323642730713,
0.9372976422309875,
-0.4562016427516937,
-0.5044378042221069,
-0.06945376843214035,
0.11626002937555313,
-0.24977028369903564,
-0.20020639896392822,
0.1622617244720459,
0.015259956009685993,
-0.9175523519515991,
0.8294324278831482,
0.6690534949302673,
0.42374324798583984,
-0.07761414349079132,
0.015343980863690376,
-0.09958495944738388,
-0.27284300327301025,
0.7644469141960144,
0.3220081329345703,
-0.8783369064331055,
-0.26595738530158997,
-0.25569596886634827,
-0.19658690690994263,
0.2815939486026764,
0.8587552309036255,
-0.779046356678009,
0.7536600232124329,
0.673307478427887,
0.5397918224334717,
0.8022109866142273,
-0.030001210048794746,
0.4274711012840271,
-0.6936554312705994,
0.44528698921203613,
0.08548018336296082,
0.6120661497116089,
0.4621516466140747,
0.002308301394805312,
0.46036630868911743,
0.47850924730300903,
-0.1943587213754654,
-0.8282543420791626,
0.41535282135009766,
-1.436025619506836,
-0.308441698551178,
0.9513741135597229,
0.1908991038799286,
-0.22127090394496918,
0.34914734959602356,
-0.2735341787338257,
0.2367396503686905,
-0.2822306752204895,
0.43000856041908264,
0.3108416795730591,
-0.3779037296772003,
-0.4652824103832245,
-0.44843369722366333,
0.4683215618133545,
0.33668404817581177,
-0.6363504528999329,
0.16411004960536957,
0.5469738841056824,
0.37351927161216736,
-0.002944594481959939,
0.635123074054718,
-0.03554367646574974,
0.06963271647691727,
-0.18001028895378113,
0.23181460797786713,
-0.11069107800722122,
-0.5332334041595459,
-0.5391771197319031,
0.22775928676128387,
-0.2985638380050659,
-0.23457223176956177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15132v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15132v1
|
Improving Sentence Embeddings with an Automatically Generated NLI Dataset
| 2024-02-23T06:33:51 | 2024-02-23T06:33:51 |
Soma Sato, Hayato Tsukagoshi, Ryohei Sasano, Koichi Takeda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Decoder-based large language models (LLMs) have shown high performance on
many tasks in natural language processing. This is also true for sentence
embedding learning, where a decoder-based model, PromptEOL, has achieved the
best performance on semantic textual similarity (STS) tasks. However, PromptEOL
makes great use of fine-tuning with a manually annotated natural language
inference (NLI) dataset. We aim to improve sentence embeddings learned in an
unsupervised setting by automatically generating an NLI dataset with an LLM and
using it to fine-tune PromptEOL. In experiments on STS tasks, the proposed
method achieved an average Spearman's rank correlation coefficient of 82.21
with respect to human evaluation, thus outperforming existing methods without
using large, manually annotated datasets.
|
[
-0.15082389116287231,
-0.6210767030715942,
0.44976842403411865,
0.20124214887619019,
-0.40942367911338806,
-0.05279151350259781,
-0.31103992462158203,
-0.29893139004707336,
0.24520927667617798,
0.5407425761222839,
-0.40679675340652466,
-0.8646768927574158,
-0.5322298407554626,
0.5774497389793396,
-0.0703137069940567,
0.8265475034713745,
0.23488488793373108,
0.12336885184049606,
-0.4523191452026367,
-0.09003183990716934,
-0.6721178889274597,
-0.21242862939834595,
-0.5214992761611938,
-0.1182871088385582,
0.297712504863739,
0.27016550302505493,
0.7427494525909424,
0.9681753516197205,
0.34584274888038635,
0.25936952233314514,
-0.07514990866184235,
0.5133446455001831,
-0.3255542814731598,
0.29402196407318115,
-0.02991694025695324,
-0.4020732343196869,
-0.18840937316417694,
-0.016011258587241173,
0.5974806547164917,
0.7618973851203918,
0.035303156822919846,
-0.05730466917157173,
0.3222283720970154,
0.3676537871360779,
-0.5663576722145081,
0.2668161988258362,
-0.4690791666507721,
0.09961257874965668,
0.054962992668151855,
-0.40155744552612305,
-0.6820176243782043,
-0.5632110238075256,
0.22534134984016418,
-0.685988187789917,
0.22301451861858368,
0.4871158003807068,
0.5269333720207214,
0.5551490783691406,
-0.4985627233982086,
-0.5026928782463074,
-0.2255062758922577,
0.9214391112327576,
-0.8970504999160767,
0.30070579051971436,
0.31199896335601807,
-0.23187895119190216,
-0.3712676167488098,
-0.3429883122444153,
-0.26225459575653076,
-0.4570368230342865,
-0.3115769624710083,
0.05335526540875435,
-0.39116936922073364,
0.027144722640514374,
0.4018314480781555,
0.07918566465377808,
-0.6769933700561523,
0.2865487039089203,
0.08936312049627304,
0.013563931919634342,
0.8316987156867981,
0.34886467456817627,
0.28020694851875305,
-0.5507482886314392,
-0.1492767035961151,
-0.31960996985435486,
-0.6241645812988281,
-0.05878625065088272,
0.3229924440383911,
0.4692099690437317,
0.18269751965999603,
0.6248948574066162,
-0.1141892746090889,
0.6388534903526306,
-0.0118746068328619,
0.1970231980085373,
0.579031765460968,
-0.2622780203819275,
-0.22891218960285187,
0.2180044949054718,
0.7767390608787537,
0.7064797282218933,
0.44490936398506165,
-0.4282814562320709,
-0.26608479022979736,
0.020460953935980797,
0.22275543212890625,
-0.6804107427597046,
-0.2531485855579376,
0.012831899337470531,
-0.39814844727516174,
-0.29214584827423096,
0.30138400197029114,
-0.4896172881126404,
-0.3851000964641571,
-0.4778640866279602,
0.29168739914894104,
-0.6413374543190002,
0.29339659214019775,
0.022607771679759026,
-0.17778204381465912,
0.2885640263557434,
0.16743147373199463,
-0.5931833982467651,
0.12204935401678085,
0.6394718289375305,
0.8536414504051208,
-0.09530217945575714,
-0.26460784673690796,
-0.8797885775566101,
0.11445165425539017,
-0.5987650156021118,
0.8415511846542358,
-0.4629756808280945,
-0.3565935790538788,
0.2986927330493927,
-0.01942685805261135,
-0.25761306285858154,
-0.6689520478248596,
0.7052134871482849,
-0.3862139880657196,
0.3040567636489868,
-0.15735086798667908,
-1.1902339458465576,
0.1779041290283203,
0.15029770135879517,
-0.6468697190284729,
1.0078166723251343,
-0.16530823707580566,
-0.8759940266609192,
0.4185085594654083,
-0.6887773275375366,
-0.5721938014030457,
0.08683963865041733,
0.14393290877342224,
-0.4255997836589813,
0.23295944929122925,
0.6395078301429749,
0.6842629909515381,
-0.22305211424827576,
0.5123999118804932,
-0.2617078721523285,
-0.47382086515426636,
0.2659575343132019,
-0.3650027811527252,
0.6974058151245117,
0.1250409334897995,
-0.06534009426832199,
0.15150053799152374,
-0.7376915812492371,
-0.02565178833901882,
-0.12749256193637848,
-0.18836015462875366,
-0.6765474081039429,
-0.13758373260498047,
0.11659111082553864,
-0.10242711007595062,
0.16186073422431946,
-0.5970110297203064,
0.2178526371717453,
-0.7882040143013,
0.42441433668136597,
0.5893274545669556,
0.25126975774765015,
0.46401336789131165,
-0.2672419846057892,
0.236879363656044,
-0.04784538224339485,
-0.1392611414194107,
-0.34299883246421814,
-0.2854951322078705,
-0.7849079966545105,
-0.24390918016433716,
0.3939610421657562,
0.6600799560546875,
-0.693525493144989,
1.0357295274734497,
-0.47051018476486206,
-0.1442011296749115,
-0.7901552319526672,
0.31214413046836853,
0.3532569408416748,
0.41045746207237244,
0.5185657143592834,
0.06224381551146507,
-0.6479376554489136,
-1.0404083728790283,
-0.30650413036346436,
0.15218986570835114,
-0.43712592124938965,
0.20819321274757385,
0.3502281904220581,
-0.24627144634723663,
1.1651214361190796,
-0.5609070062637329,
-0.3416714668273926,
-0.3128807544708252,
0.4370408058166504,
0.2184494435787201,
0.505029559135437,
0.21566244959831238,
-0.4228753447532654,
-0.29745832085609436,
-0.4148399531841278,
-0.8960295915603638,
-0.26911771297454834,
-0.1894816905260086,
-0.13885284960269928,
0.20108617842197418,
0.7496373057365417,
-0.4477824866771698,
0.28348174691200256,
0.10708974301815033,
-0.6352474689483643,
0.018785864114761353,
-0.5521373748779297,
0.11213204264640808,
-1.464778184890747,
-0.013226700015366077,
0.3023776113986969,
-0.328744113445282,
-0.4135514199733734,
-0.15508566796779633,
0.12904296815395355,
-0.022260183468461037,
-0.26185986399650574,
0.4315595030784607,
-0.5945150852203369,
-0.048968151211738586,
-0.2562205493450165,
0.25926336646080017,
-0.06782587617635727,
0.283788800239563,
0.042262427508831024,
0.8730096220970154,
0.46758052706718445,
-0.4667016565799713,
0.2527623176574707,
0.6284331679344177,
-0.38449826836586,
0.35856255888938904,
-0.8284400701522827,
0.010820988565683365,
-0.1836143434047699,
0.11234722286462784,
-0.7772923111915588,
-0.130768820643425,
-0.017319170758128166,
-0.15733401477336884,
0.18021085858345032,
-0.035795658826828,
-0.46275460720062256,
-0.07664237916469574,
-0.5998441576957703,
-0.035020578652620316,
0.5562645196914673,
-0.7121515870094299,
0.39284124970436096,
0.1747026890516281,
-0.030001865699887276,
-0.4149203300476074,
-0.6037766337394714,
0.4654243290424347,
-0.30421680212020874,
-0.47714757919311523,
0.4121028184890747,
-0.07363443076610565,
-0.242263525724411,
-0.0029220418073236942,
0.30036547780036926,
0.2691192626953125,
0.00414007343351841,
0.408686101436615,
0.2687274217605591,
-0.16735728085041046,
0.43965667486190796,
0.20853391289710999,
-0.29965639114379883,
0.08109276741743088,
-0.0959252417087555,
0.2888442575931549,
-0.09109333902597427,
-0.049961864948272705,
-0.5733230710029602,
0.38115885853767395,
0.14814172685146332,
-0.16242222487926483,
0.7725163698196411,
0.48274558782577515,
-0.2077326774597168,
-0.31243807077407837,
-0.456723690032959,
-0.1957228183746338,
-0.4096390902996063,
0.16856087744235992,
-0.2738531529903412,
-0.971651554107666,
0.17511768639087677,
-0.10512722283601761,
-0.05729157105088234,
0.3695002794265747,
0.07845664024353027,
-0.261745423078537,
0.9540843367576599,
0.5253058075904846,
-0.13569265604019165,
0.2820543050765991,
-0.18532007932662964,
-0.04135814309120178,
-0.8871762156486511,
-0.13136179745197296,
-0.35406288504600525,
-0.17893563210964203,
-0.7111350893974304,
-0.3600785434246063,
0.10156680643558502,
0.1155589297413826,
-0.19602449238300323,
0.3521105647087097,
-0.16570138931274414,
0.5310688614845276,
0.7619875073432922,
0.24540391564369202,
0.24655912816524506,
-0.057454340159893036,
-0.08927102386951447,
-0.15533842146396637,
-0.6969480514526367,
-0.8076297640800476,
1.042397379875183,
0.15856707096099854,
0.6731082201004028,
-0.11402071267366409,
0.7063291072845459,
0.5417803525924683,
-0.00527169881388545,
-0.5816429257392883,
0.514983594417572,
-0.4421829283237457,
0.24486275017261505,
-0.24312558770179749,
-0.4373854100704193,
-1.0173684358596802,
0.07937844097614288,
-0.5303208827972412,
-0.3523309528827667,
0.02160210721194744,
0.14681603014469147,
-0.3197115361690521,
-0.08035789430141449,
-0.6578461527824402,
0.7568628191947937,
0.05804987996816635,
-0.24390485882759094,
-0.06218142434954643,
-0.6025806069374084,
-0.09658516198396683,
0.30244922637939453,
-0.10463160276412964,
-0.042815275490283966,
-0.07523949444293976,
0.8426509499549866,
-0.3503423035144806,
0.8923811912536621,
-0.138106107711792,
-0.07426328957080841,
0.12216851115226746,
-0.13059355318546295,
0.6139714121818542,
0.400020956993103,
-0.2766241729259491,
-0.03196839615702629,
-0.3584573566913605,
-0.35808587074279785,
-0.7583656907081604,
0.9048123955726624,
-0.7733398675918579,
-0.562082052230835,
-0.29196372628211975,
-0.5955812931060791,
-0.2185966968536377,
-0.14155013859272003,
0.24908040463924408,
0.5720863938331604,
-0.41057339310646057,
0.24730181694030762,
0.8013424277305603,
-0.3122155964374542,
0.7339356541633606,
0.2133374810218811,
0.2194814831018448,
-0.5511501431465149,
0.48386240005493164,
-0.15123897790908813,
-0.2622264623641968,
0.6192821860313416,
0.03260618448257446,
-0.5339283347129822,
-0.38819703459739685,
-0.37705197930336,
0.12337977439165115,
-0.5438811779022217,
-0.4060603380203247,
-0.8101469278335571,
-0.06063786894083023,
-0.6281007528305054,
-0.2821339964866638,
-0.14244598150253296,
-0.1372007578611374,
-0.538634181022644,
-0.2274090051651001,
0.6758717894554138,
0.6138945817947388,
0.04954811930656433,
0.212410569190979,
-0.6303970217704773,
0.15661442279815674,
0.14995139837265015,
0.11321143805980682,
-0.23062048852443695,
-0.6945192813873291,
-0.17077742516994476,
-0.020497428253293037,
0.24361880123615265,
-0.589352011680603,
0.6367747187614441,
0.39477071166038513,
0.3913841247558594,
0.29441604018211365,
0.3594476282596588,
0.746069073677063,
-0.593908429145813,
0.4991060495376587,
-0.14003902673721313,
-0.9381100535392761,
0.8642460107803345,
-0.14382076263427734,
0.546371579170227,
0.555252194404602,
0.30321604013442993,
-0.2724444270133972,
-0.5336366295814514,
-0.35511064529418945,
-0.8439540266990662,
0.3825470507144928,
0.2475026547908783,
0.27577218413352966,
-0.3773896098136902,
0.4478529393672943,
0.1389864683151245,
0.001740357605740428,
-0.47834938764572144,
0.12014324218034744,
-0.05344950780272484,
-0.5888363122940063,
-0.37857770919799805,
-0.2960449457168579,
0.2066558599472046,
-0.1390782743692398,
0.6484828591346741,
-0.24226218461990356,
0.11794327199459076,
0.2709566056728363,
-0.609287679195404,
0.13802051544189453,
0.3531529903411865,
0.2545869052410126,
0.4288756847381592,
-0.27810996770858765,
0.2889890670776367,
0.5528779625892639,
-0.20878595113754272,
-0.03763255849480629,
0.16453173756599426,
-0.292643666267395,
0.034434642642736435,
0.8064106702804565,
1.020641565322876,
0.3996906578540802,
-0.82212233543396,
0.6265059113502502,
-0.06372859328985214,
0.08378341794013977,
-0.3691752254962921,
0.20963655412197113,
-0.028296034783124924,
0.45973265171051025,
0.39339879155158997,
-0.04463418945670128,
0.17841525375843048,
-0.26015254855155945,
0.45528942346572876,
0.389580100774765,
-0.24629658460617065,
-0.09590379893779755,
0.374729186296463,
0.22018365561962128,
-0.3466431200504303,
0.9748076796531677,
-0.18180060386657715,
-0.13688591122627258,
0.35640913248062134,
0.6189941167831421,
0.6639573574066162,
-0.13815054297447205,
0.27615347504615784,
0.596380352973938,
0.3289274573326111,
-0.10125190764665604,
0.050943147391080856,
0.15542760491371155,
-0.6645234823226929,
-0.5957621335983276,
-0.6251642107963562,
-0.15249978005886078,
-0.1195308119058609,
-0.7842206954956055,
0.3703118860721588,
-0.13150475919246674,
0.09546037018299103,
-0.22471804916858673,
0.08662091195583344,
-0.7820038795471191,
0.21189017593860626,
-0.0018938067369163036,
0.76280277967453,
-1.0939538478851318,
0.7214230298995972,
0.6589756011962891,
-0.2895664572715759,
-0.49563920497894287,
0.11214594542980194,
-0.4840953052043915,
-0.4583894908428192,
0.675879180431366,
0.4170439839363098,
-0.08889923989772797,
0.21335744857788086,
-0.35413190722465515,
-0.6557139158248901,
1.2790741920471191,
0.5119533538818359,
-0.7532203793525696,
0.09416279196739197,
0.2161758989095688,
0.6596823334693909,
-0.692812442779541,
0.5404810905456543,
0.3605900704860687,
0.18060162663459778,
-0.16587480902671814,
-0.46578460931777954,
0.15127992630004883,
-0.33799901604652405,
0.4862852692604065,
0.07070471346378326,
-0.10532839596271515,
0.3915824592113495,
-0.302015483379364,
-0.21225720643997192,
0.1091252937912941,
0.8530123829841614,
0.14117920398712158,
0.21701344847679138,
0.5354630947113037,
0.7929242849349976,
0.7777161598205566,
0.0950518324971199,
1.009827733039856,
-0.2575443685054779,
0.17423613369464874,
1.3093034029006958,
-0.34775322675704956,
1.128307580947876,
0.30998164415359497,
0.30602702498435974,
0.4479843080043793,
0.5070323944091797,
-0.39807742834091187,
0.4916658401489258,
0.16796424984931946,
-0.02289692685008049,
-0.5012705326080322,
-0.204747274518013,
-0.036048438400030136,
0.5703416466712952,
0.01217910461127758,
-0.6694129705429077,
-0.18613819777965546,
0.46517214179039,
-0.08121156692504883,
0.4377615749835968,
-0.09857144206762314,
1.0024583339691162,
-0.08974554389715195,
-0.4902224838733673,
0.3801635205745697,
0.044337086379528046,
0.8978987336158752,
-0.19291147589683533,
-0.17321348190307617,
-0.3870011270046234,
-0.011184725910425186,
0.044830694794654846,
-0.6808238625526428,
0.28272950649261475,
0.2015124410390854,
-0.15477874875068665,
-0.29924318194389343,
0.6298213601112366,
-0.5190965533256531,
-0.564462423324585,
0.33908042311668396,
0.5444052219390869,
0.035035181790590286,
0.1538705676794052,
-0.4401220679283142,
-0.09529642015695572,
-0.11469903588294983,
-0.3686554431915283,
0.1409556269645691,
0.3804640769958496,
0.02741013839840889,
0.7097626328468323,
0.5948188304901123,
-0.25499197840690613,
-0.09537956118583679,
0.24053098261356354,
0.7496964931488037,
-0.8823087811470032,
-0.5609105825424194,
-0.8866570591926575,
0.2690294682979584,
-0.32540053129196167,
-0.5142410397529602,
0.8046161532402039,
0.7997857332229614,
0.6272860169410706,
-0.26714175939559937,
0.5691608786582947,
0.16554585099220276,
0.5703898668289185,
-0.897338330745697,
0.563757598400116,
-0.17320284247398376,
0.2675606310367584,
-0.09222443401813507,
-1.0292004346847534,
-0.5825604200363159,
0.8696882128715515,
-0.2735157907009125,
-0.20256945490837097,
0.6409177184104919,
0.9204952716827393,
0.015348359942436218,
0.09312500059604645,
0.36340898275375366,
0.21957124769687653,
0.01888471469283104,
0.5146132111549377,
0.7408726215362549,
-0.4956953227519989,
0.29132840037345886,
-0.11013709753751755,
-0.008773192763328552,
-0.021326186135411263,
-1.0640532970428467,
-1.2370587587356567,
-0.5287779569625854,
-0.6199514269828796,
0.012152844108641148,
0.45984941720962524,
1.2523094415664673,
0.397440105676651,
-0.8570918440818787,
-0.04216904565691948,
-0.332759827375412,
-0.20298083126544952,
-0.04716632142663002,
-0.19700245559215546,
0.633124053478241,
-0.5788707733154297,
-0.840958833694458,
0.7345091700553894,
0.20049475133419037,
-0.19290752708911896,
0.0801781713962555,
-0.11140047013759613,
-0.2940869927406311,
-0.07232347875833511,
0.6468729972839355,
-0.3043637275695801,
-0.7510807514190674,
-0.4739740490913391,
0.013130776584148407,
-0.10552498698234558,
0.05618889629840851,
0.7282117009162903,
-0.9924135208129883,
0.07888630032539368,
0.35711199045181274,
0.6957151889801025,
0.015941845253109932,
0.18022702634334564,
0.6317752003669739,
-0.925866425037384,
-0.09378880262374878,
0.19660545885562897,
0.47169601917266846,
0.5401496291160583,
-0.36189574003219604,
0.48965969681739807,
-0.11381825059652328,
-0.4810123145580292,
-0.5334482192993164,
-0.11000025272369385,
-0.8854451775550842,
-0.26589715480804443,
1.0440250635147095,
-0.18389484286308289,
-0.09699265658855438,
-0.06787406653165817,
-0.1540517657995224,
0.4638552665710449,
-0.5059735178947449,
0.7091770172119141,
0.28959518671035767,
-0.036488376557826996,
-0.2674662470817566,
-0.26101061701774597,
0.43983861804008484,
0.5297732949256897,
-0.9411342740058899,
0.1705707311630249,
0.48822927474975586,
0.2668376863002777,
-0.0086548225954175,
-0.0689677745103836,
0.24602870643138885,
-0.06740554422140121,
-0.11205685883760452,
0.039149925112724304,
-0.2970012426376343,
-0.11847196519374847,
-0.5085789561271667,
0.23013851046562195,
-0.020862340927124023,
-0.128031387925148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15131v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15131v1
|
Interactive-KBQA: Multi-Turn Interactions for Knowledge Base Question Answering with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T06:32:18 | 2024-02-23T06:32:18 |
Guanming Xiong, Junwei Bao, Wen Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
This study explores the realm of knowledge-base question answering (KBQA).
KBQA is considered a challenging task, particularly in parsing intricate
questions into executable logical forms. Traditional semantic parsing
(SP)-based methods require extensive data annotations, which result in
significant costs. Recently, the advent of few-shot in-context learning,
powered by large language models (LLMs), has showcased promising capabilities.
Yet, fully leveraging LLMs to parse questions into logical forms in
low-resource scenarios poses a substantial challenge. To tackle these hurdles,
we introduce Interactive-KBQA, a framework designed to generate logical forms
through direct interaction with knowledge bases (KBs). Within this framework,
we have developed three generic APIs for KB interaction. For each category of
complex question, we devised exemplars to guide LLMs through the reasoning
processes. Our method achieves competitive results on the WebQuestionsSP,
ComplexWebQuestions, KQA Pro, and MetaQA datasets with a minimal number of
examples (shots). Importantly, our approach supports manual intervention,
allowing for the iterative refinement of LLM outputs. By annotating a dataset
with step-wise reasoning processes, we showcase our model's adaptability and
highlight its potential for contributing significant enhancements to the field.
|
[
-0.5019059777259827,
-1.1936004161834717,
1.0256037712097168,
0.15666578710079193,
0.021966546773910522,
0.025240423157811165,
-0.19366683065891266,
-0.4753592312335968,
0.0649278312921524,
0.5833937525749207,
-0.9089182615280151,
-0.42231011390686035,
-0.260022908449173,
0.10345204919576645,
0.03323288634419441,
0.3953866958618164,
-0.2280997633934021,
0.1964075118303299,
-0.5212275385856628,
-0.07691259682178497,
-0.4410353899002075,
-0.5693463087081909,
-0.37734630703926086,
-0.1374448537826538,
0.5366458892822266,
0.6500762701034546,
0.7568640112876892,
0.21764995157718658,
0.24203220009803772,
0.3465031385421753,
-0.08496586233377457,
0.4051254689693451,
-0.3118901252746582,
0.5801573395729065,
-0.08490585535764694,
-0.5353701114654541,
-0.29710736870765686,
-0.15902206301689148,
0.4600420296192169,
1.0839076042175293,
0.10886450111865997,
0.26602044701576233,
-0.26293736696243286,
0.49649131298065186,
-0.6184764504432678,
0.3636326789855957,
-0.5966830253601074,
-0.12298537790775299,
0.009891079738736153,
-0.09147966653108597,
-0.6298770904541016,
-0.3652544915676117,
0.15962587296962738,
-0.8448740243911743,
-0.5384860038757324,
-0.025025727227330208,
0.5207276344299316,
0.20441283285617828,
-0.6480293869972229,
-0.4150201678276062,
-0.5925024747848511,
0.6166358590126038,
-0.8060561418533325,
0.48623496294021606,
0.30478349328041077,
0.7230851650238037,
-0.5378638505935669,
-0.7754534482955933,
-0.8515961170196533,
-0.2919218838214874,
0.06486982107162476,
0.03875089809298515,
-0.044789768755435944,
0.19531796872615814,
0.44733890891075134,
-0.22082938253879547,
-0.2281934767961502,
-0.21466480195522308,
-0.09256654977798462,
-0.08752042055130005,
0.34661591053009033,
0.3476139008998871,
0.3407159149646759,
-0.3493647575378418,
-0.14168378710746765,
0.11761601269245148,
-0.670566976070404,
0.5152674913406372,
0.23640736937522888,
0.40660586953163147,
0.09758684039115906,
0.9515892863273621,
-0.6227717399597168,
0.9420658349990845,
0.16590707004070282,
-0.18851517140865326,
-0.10687723755836487,
-0.19472049176692963,
-0.2763419449329376,
-0.0682016909122467,
0.4881698489189148,
0.1417744904756546,
0.15557803213596344,
-0.18724025785923004,
0.14855201542377472,
-0.37298789620399475,
0.11114641278982162,
-0.7283875346183777,
-0.19712258875370026,
0.4575875401496887,
-0.1780410259962082,
-0.17765496671199799,
-0.15467512607574463,
-0.6267152428627014,
-0.4502774477005005,
-0.6497209072113037,
0.8400810360908508,
-0.5031039118766785,
-0.22751709818840027,
0.07465042918920517,
0.014270791783928871,
0.401346355676651,
0.7040243148803711,
-0.4007726311683655,
0.19787383079528809,
0.478591650724411,
0.11278575658798218,
0.16212010383605957,
-0.1267712563276291,
-0.8545055389404297,
0.383492112159729,
-0.21840056777000427,
0.7545520663261414,
-0.7404873967170715,
0.048568423837423325,
-0.10067033767700195,
-0.06529799848794937,
0.05433075502514839,
-0.5236009359359741,
0.29292699694633484,
-1.1568231582641602,
0.0820188894867897,
-0.6776219606399536,
-0.5740912556648254,
-0.3443332016468048,
0.6523058414459229,
-0.6529338359832764,
0.8176968097686768,
0.2061941772699356,
-0.5844805240631104,
0.336535781621933,
-0.6719714403152466,
-0.2158873826265335,
0.15397711098194122,
-0.2555113136768341,
0.052314769476652145,
-0.3234093487262726,
0.29333731532096863,
0.37094783782958984,
-0.24071119725704193,
0.3618345558643341,
-0.5906082987785339,
0.06944013386964798,
0.4894654452800751,
-0.19370819628238678,
0.708847165107727,
-0.04527927190065384,
-0.35420680046081543,
0.21467114984989166,
-0.8947190046310425,
0.44398173689842224,
-0.07353460788726807,
-0.5706583857536316,
-0.20791180431842804,
-0.18740491569042206,
-0.29626473784446716,
0.6234273910522461,
0.07067476958036423,
-0.5566266775131226,
0.4110499620437622,
-0.3226667642593384,
0.17368650436401367,
0.3982699513435364,
0.31097322702407837,
0.5216128826141357,
-0.019274195656180382,
0.6306950449943542,
0.17265069484710693,
0.2550700902938843,
-0.030011536553502083,
-0.4366171061992645,
-0.8167378902435303,
-0.4288412928581238,
0.40685173869132996,
0.4860711097717285,
-1.2036986351013184,
0.055469248443841934,
-0.06173160299658775,
-0.5030359029769897,
-0.4917921721935272,
0.17895643413066864,
0.11974023282527924,
0.7995240092277527,
0.48294171690940857,
0.2620832026004791,
-0.41857030987739563,
-0.9030778408050537,
-0.13066838681697845,
-0.17960867285728455,
0.0008893473423086107,
0.43568605184555054,
0.2614710032939911,
-0.047576550394296646,
1.1935280561447144,
-0.41256004571914673,
0.16334617137908936,
-0.45060110092163086,
0.15140056610107422,
0.14419025182724,
0.11328136920928955,
0.28626444935798645,
-0.973809003829956,
-0.52138352394104,
-0.15855169296264648,
-0.8683964014053345,
-0.31231001019477844,
-0.16226521134376526,
-0.6318793296813965,
0.12343651801347733,
0.5115493535995483,
-0.9796518087387085,
0.26885464787483215,
0.20956337451934814,
-0.30198395252227783,
0.5725348591804504,
0.3863462805747986,
0.3678669035434723,
-0.7690028548240662,
0.1305820494890213,
-0.5037543177604675,
-0.24679449200630188,
-0.8070597052574158,
0.179475799202919,
0.09127552062273026,
-0.11764395982027054,
-0.5882390141487122,
0.5670296549797058,
-0.31682339310646057,
-0.021190252155065536,
-0.04888302460312843,
0.13184086978435516,
0.2793441116809845,
0.6689284443855286,
0.2758931815624237,
0.27956926822662354,
0.26496636867523193,
-0.5463560819625854,
0.5204625129699707,
0.48944956064224243,
-0.2331785261631012,
0.3228093385696411,
-0.375681072473526,
0.06253262609243393,
-0.18558284640312195,
0.3363158404827118,
-1.0085457563400269,
-0.5016637444496155,
0.32012006640434265,
-0.4902852773666382,
0.0936998501420021,
-0.35321348905563354,
-0.6257197260856628,
-0.04873044416308403,
-0.21218496561050415,
0.40710392594337463,
0.07555600255727768,
-0.5155027508735657,
1.1592576503753662,
0.2764853835105896,
-0.496401309967041,
-0.47532814741134644,
-0.44481900334358215,
-0.026151226833462715,
0.00562084186822176,
-0.9962493181228638,
0.054538384079933167,
-0.06777585297822952,
-0.30070221424102783,
0.07822544872760773,
0.016236431896686554,
-0.28322258591651917,
0.02786601521074772,
0.13214483857154846,
0.35430908203125,
-0.2997707426548004,
0.0343303456902504,
0.3273636996746063,
0.18943563103675842,
0.2741584777832031,
-0.03724424168467522,
0.6111960411071777,
-0.09641996771097183,
-0.584821343421936,
-0.22730223834514618,
0.603206217288971,
0.7710905075073242,
-0.2537131607532501,
0.8136863708496094,
0.31571537256240845,
-0.566817045211792,
0.07268481701612473,
-0.6694570183753967,
0.0452066995203495,
-0.46778130531311035,
0.230593740940094,
-0.677980363368988,
-0.9266543388366699,
0.5141090750694275,
-0.202238529920578,
0.12273800373077393,
0.2160700410604477,
0.7781674265861511,
-0.34423765540122986,
1.0191963911056519,
0.3849440813064575,
0.36254003643989563,
-0.1091146469116211,
0.1300215870141983,
0.21178896725177765,
-0.5277222990989685,
-0.6102250814437866,
-0.1546255201101303,
-0.22338226437568665,
-0.2209756076335907,
-0.4144827723503113,
0.7526346445083618,
0.5653469562530518,
-0.4780135750770569,
0.09608327597379684,
0.08896312862634659,
0.25648996233940125,
0.68486487865448,
0.12470845133066177,
0.4499047100543976,
-0.333484411239624,
-0.2513388395309448,
0.010147254914045334,
-0.8084303736686707,
-0.3923036456108093,
0.7196136116981506,
0.25341057777404785,
0.7392204999923706,
0.5161625742912292,
0.499491810798645,
-0.17341934144496918,
0.33269721269607544,
-0.978260338306427,
0.6809488534927368,
0.5340765714645386,
-0.6225301623344421,
-0.5598742961883545,
-0.5326327681541443,
-0.6158725023269653,
0.13444237411022186,
-0.5666520595550537,
-0.560490071773529,
0.10440549999475479,
0.3079372048377991,
-0.4829731583595276,
0.22853520512580872,
-0.8138487935066223,
0.9112762808799744,
-0.3048807382583618,
-0.4156125783920288,
0.04861634969711304,
-0.8194392919540405,
0.6191674470901489,
-0.0737641304731369,
0.1874547004699707,
0.12501117587089539,
0.12489631772041321,
0.34435760974884033,
-0.41823437809944153,
0.8337525725364685,
-0.5201715230941772,
0.03034789487719536,
0.5606712102890015,
0.5009434819221497,
0.42854204773902893,
0.07083303481340408,
0.018949564546346664,
-0.31559571623802185,
0.32136762142181396,
-0.34583938121795654,
-0.7776661515235901,
0.4085919260978699,
-0.5445582270622253,
-0.5785645842552185,
-0.09892295300960541,
-0.6471009850502014,
-0.9336286187171936,
0.3219286799430847,
-0.2036096304655075,
0.44813764095306396,
0.14284324645996094,
0.1509213000535965,
0.6487524509429932,
-0.48279350996017456,
0.07086494565010071,
0.5824598073959351,
-0.3558269441127777,
-0.42962539196014404,
0.4055223762989044,
0.08999927341938019,
0.46816834807395935,
0.5820471048355103,
0.12825173139572144,
-0.4416760504245758,
-0.1261666715145111,
-0.6490586996078491,
0.07604221254587173,
-0.9538791179656982,
-0.4212256669998169,
-0.9224985837936401,
-0.1681142896413803,
-0.5073673725128174,
-0.1103423461318016,
-0.12870894372463226,
-0.6560028791427612,
0.23354005813598633,
-0.07032577693462372,
0.4612578749656677,
0.4745348393917084,
0.1315627098083496,
0.08621159940958023,
-1.024575114250183,
0.5338473916053772,
0.6144381165504456,
0.22400528192520142,
0.2562534809112549,
-0.2944146990776062,
0.03625597059726715,
-0.05388816073536873,
-0.19879944622516632,
-1.0495145320892334,
-0.0324849970638752,
-0.033366087824106216,
0.6834779381752014,
0.06748741120100021,
0.2492496818304062,
0.6699947714805603,
-0.573333203792572,
0.6548150181770325,
0.06234261393547058,
-0.862518310546875,
0.32716846466064453,
-0.447859525680542,
0.4573226273059845,
0.7879433035850525,
0.699944019317627,
-0.6308260560035706,
-0.17549695074558258,
-0.3713456392288208,
-1.0017404556274414,
0.7350219488143921,
0.035232629626989365,
-0.22598832845687866,
0.03272397816181183,
0.3012904226779938,
0.07510361820459366,
0.4271518588066101,
-0.7358211874961853,
-0.09839081764221191,
-0.07392603904008865,
-0.4106372892856598,
0.7133857607841492,
-0.24014873802661896,
-0.06839123368263245,
-0.2749839127063751,
0.7364921569824219,
-0.1742829978466034,
0.09764308482408524,
0.10411973297595978,
-0.4321447014808655,
-0.11204462498426437,
0.35215094685554504,
0.15605907142162323,
0.577301561832428,
-0.039619021117687225,
0.1385469287633896,
0.23988699913024902,
-0.11741771548986435,
0.03925527632236481,
0.17088796198368073,
-0.11324797570705414,
-0.24864864349365234,
0.37278977036476135,
0.47507381439208984,
0.25521835684776306,
-1.0449575185775757,
0.5579231977462769,
0.014827988110482693,
-0.14920853078365326,
-0.3086085617542267,
-0.16974690556526184,
0.4891301095485687,
0.4971398413181305,
0.25384125113487244,
-0.29501232504844666,
0.1474478840827942,
-0.5440391898155212,
0.14264453947544098,
0.44075652956962585,
-0.14513333141803741,
-0.08895408362150192,
0.495900958776474,
0.31884536147117615,
0.059005387127399445,
0.6411588788032532,
-0.24064232409000397,
-0.6783421635627747,
0.4180312752723694,
0.2509343922138214,
0.38253098726272583,
0.02985096350312233,
0.16509830951690674,
0.25142502784729004,
0.15593421459197998,
0.3257003128528595,
0.5342745184898376,
-0.21451133489608765,
-0.7326973676681519,
-0.7970102429389954,
-0.6924597024917603,
-0.7714928388595581,
0.3428734838962555,
-0.6862956285476685,
0.38738492131233215,
-0.22874140739440918,
0.14897556602954865,
0.13716138899326324,
-0.16684427857398987,
-0.6821057796478271,
0.11887245625257492,
0.30395594239234924,
1.2399678230285645,
-0.6714948415756226,
0.4901496469974518,
0.8721882700920105,
-0.5047563910484314,
-1.060455083847046,
-0.14059264957904816,
0.006377731915563345,
-0.4783690273761749,
0.7726184129714966,
0.10337388515472412,
-0.08143863826990128,
-0.007265839260071516,
-0.6050463914871216,
-0.8054013848304749,
0.9595134258270264,
0.3883090615272522,
-0.18006563186645508,
-0.09805677086114883,
0.5738372206687927,
0.21972216665744781,
-0.12764324247837067,
0.1877194344997406,
0.48942509293556213,
0.7547010779380798,
0.11450636386871338,
-0.6515719890594482,
0.0943322628736496,
-0.13712845742702484,
-0.5672646760940552,
0.229313924908638,
-0.5409404635429382,
0.3593335747718811,
-0.03536638990044594,
0.19783775508403778,
0.1034606471657753,
0.6973154544830322,
0.5941794514656067,
0.20649920403957367,
0.7334912419319153,
0.3902986943721771,
0.6327994465827942,
0.14098480343818665,
0.5726789832115173,
-0.10310432314872742,
-0.057403821498155594,
1.1227545738220215,
-0.46670660376548767,
0.9093741774559021,
0.6393603086471558,
-0.09559597074985504,
0.4682174324989319,
0.4727410674095154,
0.36778414249420166,
0.4045305848121643,
0.2532952129840851,
-0.5470494627952576,
-0.8080259561538696,
0.05352208390831947,
0.07383614033460617,
0.4818080961704254,
0.4381067454814911,
0.21303896605968475,
-0.5366117358207703,
0.05368080735206604,
-0.10025209188461304,
0.06634313613176346,
-0.3265469968318939,
0.6877412796020508,
-0.014985847286880016,
-0.7412867546081543,
0.14463448524475098,
-0.006960409693419933,
0.2742202877998352,
-0.8349323868751526,
-0.38778039813041687,
0.06430985033512115,
-0.23757851123809814,
-0.19542692601680756,
-0.9122127294540405,
0.07140854746103287,
0.12928016483783722,
-0.40546706318855286,
0.024007290601730347,
0.7915192246437073,
-0.5879750847816467,
-0.40190401673316956,
0.25547799468040466,
0.8424006700515747,
-0.0007533231982961297,
-0.11350462585687637,
-0.5001094341278076,
-0.08295035362243652,
-0.0701371431350708,
-0.6010310053825378,
0.404262512922287,
0.7402515411376953,
-0.3034568727016449,
0.7392046451568604,
0.5663276314735413,
-0.229741171002388,
0.29073160886764526,
0.1108550876379013,
1.107774019241333,
-0.5714561343193054,
-0.19550290703773499,
-0.4194605350494385,
0.7141830325126648,
0.02634657919406891,
0.008575261570513248,
0.3649629056453705,
0.4136938154697418,
0.6224467158317566,
-0.1184367910027504,
0.7851459980010986,
-0.3121233880519867,
0.6587338447570801,
-0.6847206950187683,
0.4896763563156128,
-0.3483947813510895,
0.08166458457708359,
-0.15145021677017212,
-0.6515893936157227,
-0.11653696000576019,
0.29800111055374146,
-0.3077636957168579,
-0.04336532950401306,
0.40729421377182007,
0.6614453792572021,
-0.1884320080280304,
-0.13638052344322205,
0.2956169843673706,
0.36493560671806335,
0.35885313153266907,
0.5133324861526489,
1.0552959442138672,
-0.019640590995550156,
0.79804927110672,
-0.35998401045799255,
-0.34800463914871216,
0.030055541545152664,
-0.9962570071220398,
-0.7448782324790955,
-0.44399285316467285,
-0.14660491049289703,
-0.41220301389694214,
-0.1854764074087143,
1.2827378511428833,
0.45527052879333496,
-0.7776240706443787,
0.15838345885276794,
0.16180020570755005,
-0.16513724625110626,
0.1286352574825287,
-0.29906710982322693,
0.3017348349094391,
-0.3624444603919983,
-0.5802538990974426,
0.47114962339401245,
0.25731161236763,
-0.25927940011024475,
-0.1142381802201271,
0.21673816442489624,
-0.39089709520339966,
0.08949402719736099,
0.8782182335853577,
0.32995015382766724,
-0.5920315980911255,
-0.33433759212493896,
0.3245219588279724,
0.004217774141579866,
-0.1516481339931488,
0.5417057275772095,
-0.9047086834907532,
0.4042584300041199,
0.5013970136642456,
1.2483993768692017,
0.46741876006126404,
0.19182275235652924,
0.5225614905357361,
-0.7178937196731567,
-0.22704322636127472,
0.35774555802345276,
0.19842970371246338,
0.1595446914434433,
-0.40994760394096375,
0.11155036091804504,
-0.04811868816614151,
-0.3675428032875061,
-0.6551415324211121,
0.4522784352302551,
-1.2410295009613037,
-0.3194672465324402,
1.3381150960922241,
-0.0989789292216301,
-0.11882335692644119,
-0.31535598635673523,
-0.29527997970581055,
0.1430915892124176,
-0.1042354553937912,
0.38134732842445374,
0.9637020826339722,
-0.6506786942481995,
-0.05958990380167961,
-0.6263682842254639,
0.3751685321331024,
0.3367924094200134,
-0.9938501119613647,
0.1404334306716919,
0.7901058793067932,
0.3524665832519531,
0.06491724401712418,
0.5426333546638489,
-0.1963684856891632,
0.3215508759021759,
-0.32726967334747314,
0.18239696323871613,
-0.13775715231895447,
-0.33764365315437317,
0.03537376597523689,
0.23449008166790009,
0.28779903054237366,
0.14600509405136108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15116v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15116v1
|
Large Multimodal Agents: A Survey
| 2024-02-23T06:04:23 | 2024-02-23T06:04:23 |
Junlin Xie, Zhihong Chen, Ruifei Zhang, Xiang Wan, Guanbin Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved superior performance in powering
text-based AI agents, endowing them with decision-making and reasoning
abilities akin to humans. Concurrently, there is an emerging research trend
focused on extending these LLM-powered AI agents into the multimodal domain.
This extension enables AI agents to interpret and respond to diverse multimodal
user queries, thereby handling more intricate and nuanced tasks. In this paper,
we conduct a systematic review of LLM-driven multimodal agents, which we refer
to as large multimodal agents ( LMAs for short). First, we introduce the
essential components involved in developing LMAs and categorize the current
body of research into four distinct types. Subsequently, we review the
collaborative frameworks integrating multiple LMAs , enhancing collective
efficacy. One of the critical challenges in this field is the diverse
evaluation methods used across existing studies, hindering effective comparison
among different LMAs . Therefore, we compile these evaluation methodologies and
establish a comprehensive framework to bridge the gaps. This framework aims to
standardize evaluations, facilitating more meaningful comparisons. Concluding
our review, we highlight the extensive applications of LMAs and propose
possible future research directions. Our discussion aims to provide valuable
insights and guidelines for future research in this rapidly evolving field. An
up-to-date resource list is available at
https://github.com/jun0wanan/awesome-large-multimodal-agents.
|
[
-0.43095117807388306,
-0.6546388864517212,
0.8469469547271729,
0.27227988839149475,
0.1402033269405365,
0.4003918170928955,
-0.49381354451179504,
-0.6112838387489319,
0.21481066942214966,
0.34013399481773376,
-0.22221137583255768,
-0.2507243752479553,
-0.6646308898925781,
0.3306457996368408,
-0.27625277638435364,
0.6497929096221924,
0.04284069314599037,
0.1261933147907257,
-0.402953565120697,
-0.42581260204315186,
-0.28598424792289734,
-0.32151877880096436,
-0.3800443112850189,
-0.6077202558517456,
1.005324363708496,
0.1469975858926773,
1.0134409666061401,
0.1445724219083786,
0.7199079990386963,
0.49576690793037415,
-0.02501177415251732,
0.5251238346099854,
-0.39882341027259827,
0.32571324706077576,
-0.2715300917625427,
-0.3297644555568695,
-0.703581690788269,
-0.08721501380205154,
0.7884117960929871,
0.6184502243995667,
-0.02736407332122326,
-0.04840203374624252,
-0.1639450639486313,
0.4271266460418701,
-0.7259801030158997,
0.25255995988845825,
-0.35656973719596863,
-0.012051730416715145,
0.08608266711235046,
-0.06097970902919769,
-0.5145931839942932,
-0.2861972749233246,
0.06209269538521767,
-0.4167918562889099,
-0.4812246859073639,
-0.01538639422506094,
0.16312983632087708,
0.20236505568027496,
-0.9177208542823792,
-0.5390003323554993,
-0.8122428059577942,
0.9157053232192993,
-0.5805966258049011,
0.3153027594089508,
0.08865480870008469,
0.32829880714416504,
-0.28114593029022217,
-0.7902474999427795,
-0.6488271355628967,
-0.6971416473388672,
0.057953912764787674,
0.10288140922784805,
-0.15356683731079102,
0.1735333651304245,
0.031335242092609406,
0.21488597989082336,
-0.39876335859298706,
0.3209072947502136,
-0.22355614602565765,
-0.08281571418046951,
0.793793797492981,
0.42108193039894104,
0.4226788878440857,
0.11789029091596603,
-0.3390563130378723,
-0.048666905611753464,
-0.3519040048122406,
-0.16054388880729675,
0.017571646720170975,
0.34022873640060425,
-0.04005325958132744,
0.594358503818512,
-0.18147531151771545,
0.49660876393318176,
-0.21906568109989166,
-0.6822687983512878,
0.5616041421890259,
-0.6573086380958557,
-0.21912319958209991,
-0.32231858372688293,
0.9228595495223999,
0.37782788276672363,
0.20915170013904572,
-0.1946735680103302,
-0.40772923827171326,
-0.007970843464136124,
0.20289219915866852,
-0.6323123574256897,
0.3599289357662201,
0.31677940487861633,
-0.6211349964141846,
-0.1136513501405716,
-0.1750084012746811,
-0.5915991067886353,
-0.7317212224006653,
-0.45330727100372314,
0.5826535820960999,
-0.20693713426589966,
-0.4937899112701416,
0.03773854300379753,
-0.06435035914182663,
0.09391393512487411,
0.5050902962684631,
-0.5029230117797852,
0.03683142736554146,
0.6432538032531738,
0.7316247224807739,
-0.12298666685819626,
-0.6283771395683289,
-0.1843029260635376,
0.15150108933448792,
-0.3902212679386139,
0.6541924476623535,
-0.7059041857719421,
-0.34470078349113464,
0.2807890474796295,
-0.01365251187235117,
-0.15666115283966064,
-0.28642308712005615,
0.37657544016838074,
-0.6128671765327454,
0.11974389106035233,
-0.3291625380516052,
-0.1393834799528122,
-0.17708827555179596,
0.585955023765564,
-0.7088122963905334,
0.4082409143447876,
-0.04070669785141945,
-0.21535636484622955,
0.2427775263786316,
-0.7362670302391052,
-0.3570764362812042,
0.010527539998292923,
-0.1508168876171112,
-0.09043026715517044,
-0.008720019832253456,
0.22241483628749847,
0.6173756718635559,
-0.6437023878097534,
0.43427425622940063,
-0.22104457020759583,
-0.12159978598356247,
0.4871285855770111,
-0.35966503620147705,
0.49306434392929077,
0.3919309675693512,
-0.18335022032260895,
0.7294111847877502,
-0.5383242964744568,
0.035096488893032074,
-0.03185288980603218,
-0.21051202714443207,
-0.16069303452968597,
-0.057321738451719284,
0.0642814040184021,
0.3221167027950287,
0.27058112621307373,
-0.15563152730464935,
0.23827573657035828,
0.14796090126037598,
0.6159992218017578,
0.8113279342651367,
-0.23136864602565765,
0.5717720985412598,
-0.4466293454170227,
0.59146648645401,
-0.2931976318359375,
0.4864341616630554,
-0.4881684482097626,
-0.35752353072166443,
-0.4423588812351227,
-0.5292274951934814,
-0.027096474543213844,
0.08553493767976761,
-1.015363097190857,
0.11126671731472015,
-0.24917718768119812,
-0.732749342918396,
-0.33682024478912354,
0.2589775025844574,
0.4150164723396301,
-0.2343558520078659,
0.14750468730926514,
-0.40810808539390564,
-0.22313156723976135,
-0.8363217115402222,
0.05255201831459999,
-0.2844599187374115,
0.30553779006004333,
0.277039498090744,
0.6377816796302795,
-0.8131033182144165,
0.6964209079742432,
0.006920952815562487,
-0.4471261203289032,
-0.48510053753852844,
-0.138447105884552,
-0.03146833926439285,
0.1250680834054947,
0.49746841192245483,
-0.6719070672988892,
-0.2297603040933609,
0.13575230538845062,
-0.8948574662208557,
0.1289496123790741,
-0.27261218428611755,
0.25911495089530945,
-0.043552011251449585,
0.4615868330001831,
-0.8820516467094421,
-0.11569187045097351,
0.6266404390335083,
-0.21302814781665802,
0.48966294527053833,
-0.1249508485198021,
0.3136849105358124,
-0.8140947222709656,
-0.005242944695055485,
-0.013121071271598339,
-0.14296598732471466,
-0.6120806932449341,
0.38821056485176086,
-0.058394622057676315,
0.1528303325176239,
-0.3049266040325165,
0.48993563652038574,
-0.717128574848175,
-0.2666950225830078,
-0.37205687165260315,
0.3106306493282318,
-0.11933989077806473,
0.32511547207832336,
-0.3878324329853058,
0.6504145264625549,
0.3823266327381134,
-0.3314230740070343,
0.8098222017288208,
0.01700795628130436,
-0.3274427354335785,
0.4590197801589966,
-0.6606310606002808,
0.14193177223205566,
-0.21441103518009186,
0.6461860537528992,
-0.9824655055999756,
-0.3452026844024658,
0.34094715118408203,
-0.18031886219978333,
0.18224681913852692,
0.33976393938064575,
-0.6315417885780334,
-0.3010719418525696,
-0.49924758076667786,
0.5162525773048401,
0.17061173915863037,
-0.311897337436676,
0.7941293716430664,
0.4913257360458374,
-0.18837502598762512,
-0.6209926009178162,
-0.3712939918041229,
0.40281540155410767,
-0.052538421005010605,
-0.7264459133148193,
0.03232850879430771,
-0.12477155029773712,
-0.7891611456871033,
-0.05862024426460266,
0.34578555822372437,
0.10678351670503616,
-0.03715081512928009,
0.27696362137794495,
-0.09643685817718506,
-0.1991157829761505,
0.4418860673904419,
-0.2706635594367981,
0.08041784912347794,
-0.06101358309388161,
0.1407214254140854,
0.5203090310096741,
-0.4411981403827667,
-0.5104393362998962,
-0.333211749792099,
0.26373931765556335,
0.9735862612724304,
-0.40700364112854004,
0.6294516324996948,
0.7903819680213928,
0.007381025236099958,
-0.12928932905197144,
-0.6429283618927002,
-0.10991570353507996,
-0.4025762379169464,
0.6235445141792297,
-0.24914467334747314,
-0.9160174131393433,
0.29247668385505676,
-0.19800958037376404,
0.07144530862569809,
0.33972370624542236,
1.0043648481369019,
0.07778244465589523,
1.0134562253952026,
0.6575941443443298,
-0.0897819772362709,
0.44890254735946655,
-0.08321958035230637,
0.07761217653751373,
-0.6754907369613647,
-0.49044129252433777,
-0.4042094945907593,
-0.3474804162979126,
-0.4309198260307312,
-0.6875343322753906,
0.4594683349132538,
-0.46225541830062866,
-0.04958295822143555,
-0.10430632531642914,
-0.08557876199483871,
0.27546074986457825,
0.07472824305295944,
-0.19022642076015472,
0.3637768030166626,
-0.20089174807071686,
0.18508830666542053,
0.39137035608291626,
-0.4935372769832611,
-0.5409870743751526,
1.1848061084747314,
0.5992503762245178,
0.8460264205932617,
0.35461756587028503,
0.2531116008758545,
0.5701667070388794,
0.48972123861312866,
-0.8670331239700317,
0.6496953368186951,
0.33906829357147217,
-0.747505784034729,
-0.49625205993652344,
-0.2844637930393219,
-1.0801043510437012,
0.8105464577674866,
-0.2976808249950409,
-0.5070486068725586,
-0.07214117050170898,
-0.38592931628227234,
-0.24977277219295502,
0.14772890508174896,
-0.6739354133605957,
0.5584675669670105,
-0.6042970418930054,
-0.48915642499923706,
-0.5223307609558105,
-0.6826679110527039,
0.5388244390487671,
-0.12593306601047516,
0.4287542998790741,
-0.19452188909053802,
-0.2554592490196228,
0.5260217189788818,
-0.044539593160152435,
0.7943012118339539,
-0.09412717819213867,
-0.5408551096916199,
0.3329565227031708,
-0.3124762177467346,
0.22947752475738525,
-0.05896636098623276,
-0.06926792114973068,
0.19977353513240814,
0.002175134140998125,
-0.2666718661785126,
-0.5858064889907837,
0.823237419128418,
-0.8400577902793884,
-0.5631382465362549,
-0.4494536221027374,
-0.6739575862884521,
-0.34852126240730286,
0.19353985786437988,
-0.46485626697540283,
0.4509672522544861,
-0.27206140756607056,
0.3952537178993225,
0.3357990086078644,
-0.20404554903507233,
0.6315251588821411,
0.51530921459198,
-0.5553396344184875,
-0.4832611083984375,
0.8424883484840393,
0.09696482121944427,
0.2913203835487366,
0.26588305830955505,
-0.008643507957458496,
-0.28457048535346985,
-0.6843235492706299,
-0.39337408542633057,
0.24959081411361694,
-0.680579423904419,
0.10623440891504288,
-0.47214385867118835,
0.0856393352150917,
-0.4170198440551758,
0.00020737801969517022,
-0.30533501505851746,
-0.14393915235996246,
0.04471303150057793,
0.09311296045780182,
-0.021900128573179245,
0.9936553835868835,
-0.03338034823536873,
0.2949572801589966,
-0.7026581764221191,
0.3530408442020416,
0.36074376106262207,
0.1630694568157196,
0.3129396140575409,
-0.10359179228544235,
-0.24654413759708405,
-0.15296882390975952,
-0.26009830832481384,
-0.5989946722984314,
0.3211641013622284,
0.021862413734197617,
0.8871462941169739,
0.47794803977012634,
-0.10139650851488113,
0.40000468492507935,
-0.32489725947380066,
0.8691564798355103,
0.511178731918335,
-0.5412823557853699,
0.09138268232345581,
-0.33069247007369995,
0.37488970160484314,
0.3820333182811737,
0.3825945556163788,
-0.5490587949752808,
-0.08250302076339722,
-0.10504860430955887,
-0.8415684700012207,
0.5012844800949097,
0.20162232220172882,
0.22758400440216064,
0.1792818158864975,
-0.19473108649253845,
0.2087176889181137,
0.26375243067741394,
-0.6143494844436646,
-0.15076357126235962,
0.19499528408050537,
0.014458727091550827,
-0.5320353507995605,
-0.3279593586921692,
-0.3689887821674347,
0.12683002650737762,
0.4074590504169464,
-0.282426118850708,
0.11394746601581573,
0.1168299987912178,
-0.38009679317474365,
-0.08369503915309906,
0.5845295786857605,
0.7926676869392395,
1.1096826791763306,
-0.11933806538581848,
0.19694076478481293,
0.016623616218566895,
-0.2838701903820038,
0.24120104312896729,
-0.036946769803762436,
0.11972954124212265,
-0.1617588847875595,
0.733828604221344,
0.5213271975517273,
0.13323715329170227,
-1.0336201190948486,
0.4957064092159271,
-0.22621585428714752,
-0.03624348342418671,
-0.41250935196876526,
-0.06381872296333313,
-0.010138073936104774,
0.6507391929626465,
0.4652703106403351,
0.07853291183710098,
-0.005910463165491819,
-1.0210860967636108,
-0.16936326026916504,
0.6413389444351196,
-0.30905231833457947,
-0.34084802865982056,
0.1405922919511795,
0.6733233332633972,
-0.3062906563282013,
0.12501460313796997,
-0.09291409701108932,
-0.23652417957782745,
0.6009052991867065,
0.23420372605323792,
0.7223620414733887,
-0.1710599660873413,
0.17734947800636292,
-0.1305253505706787,
0.6750005483627319,
-0.08091496676206589,
-0.017943603917956352,
-0.14524705708026886,
-0.8080171942710876,
-0.4511946737766266,
-0.3046938478946686,
-0.454315721988678,
0.07334543019533157,
-0.20619836449623108,
-0.17027440667152405,
-0.43976685404777527,
-0.47908732295036316,
0.14238184690475464,
0.03915484622120857,
-0.5183668732643127,
-0.010987784713506699,
0.3300412595272064,
0.6053674221038818,
-0.4566255211830139,
0.5836916565895081,
0.8516507744789124,
-0.5632525682449341,
-0.28469204902648926,
-0.02837597392499447,
0.18422947824001312,
-0.7054085731506348,
0.4876575469970703,
0.11323484778404236,
-0.24505294859409332,
-0.5028139352798462,
-0.509587824344635,
-0.8615820407867432,
1.2731642723083496,
0.07842113077640533,
-0.5681146383285522,
-0.053613871335983276,
0.11250780522823334,
0.7471998929977417,
-0.5522375106811523,
0.8340209126472473,
0.5354673266410828,
0.7275134921073914,
0.05141713097691536,
-1.2740757465362549,
0.008835004642605782,
-0.2180684208869934,
-0.058671243488788605,
-0.06706561148166656,
-1.0763659477233887,
0.6781127452850342,
-0.33524462580680847,
0.10135488957166672,
0.2526775300502777,
0.58012855052948,
0.1749274581670761,
0.7190075516700745,
0.5323445796966553,
0.13664601743221283,
0.6264009475708008,
0.21679869294166565,
1.0553478002548218,
-0.0066732983104884624,
0.16902194917201996,
0.8210157752037048,
-0.7041386961936951,
0.5648179054260254,
0.5217393040657043,
-0.25866204500198364,
0.2585986256599426,
0.2190418541431427,
0.0977618396282196,
0.21730253100395203,
0.17589537799358368,
-0.21351510286331177,
-0.3449118137359619,
-0.4573596715927124,
-0.5635883212089539,
0.6345791816711426,
0.47327762842178345,
-0.5394122004508972,
-0.052204106003046036,
0.1868223398923874,
-0.10134430229663849,
0.06710093468427658,
-0.5177658796310425,
0.7360655069351196,
0.1332700103521347,
-0.6803151369094849,
0.2581377327442169,
0.11404263973236084,
0.7543469071388245,
-0.6914608478546143,
0.1281440258026123,
-0.10606491565704346,
0.2327224761247635,
-0.29088306427001953,
-0.6987996101379395,
-0.14064636826515198,
-0.20351000130176544,
-0.14230522513389587,
-0.342424213886261,
0.8471739888191223,
-0.23702405393123627,
-0.16673649847507477,
0.46910375356674194,
0.866473376750946,
-0.010388169437646866,
0.08537979423999786,
-0.6597930788993835,
0.5347673892974854,
-0.14368286728858948,
-0.3090473711490631,
0.4177487790584564,
0.2536149322986603,
-0.16143712401390076,
0.9633715152740479,
0.6532100439071655,
-0.2537342309951782,
-0.15625342726707458,
0.31320521235466003,
0.881285548210144,
-0.6756875514984131,
-0.06688012182712555,
-0.7802844643592834,
0.3201896548271179,
-0.008302931673824787,
-0.28307589888572693,
0.8985112309455872,
0.24528665840625763,
0.46428602933883667,
0.004238738678395748,
0.7990345358848572,
-0.02806609310209751,
0.1122959777712822,
-0.3550155758857727,
0.7300140857696533,
-0.6626952290534973,
0.0739370658993721,
-0.43096092343330383,
-0.9760083556175232,
-0.2569087743759155,
0.3275320529937744,
-0.28782206773757935,
0.369537353515625,
0.5596832036972046,
0.6928104758262634,
0.29397156834602356,
0.03484636917710304,
0.6300308704376221,
0.33852294087409973,
0.5306059122085571,
0.47564712166786194,
1.5380252599716187,
-0.12805412709712982,
0.4198104739189148,
0.12414634227752686,
-0.14419817924499512,
-0.4344043433666229,
-0.6146100163459778,
-0.9073383212089539,
-0.6161067485809326,
-0.1116102784872055,
-0.0022012863773852587,
0.04028338938951492,
1.1457151174545288,
0.7364169359207153,
-0.35595080256462097,
-0.3492690324783325,
0.6110578179359436,
0.42526760697364807,
0.006676246412098408,
-0.12328676879405975,
0.04654627665877342,
-0.1813783496618271,
-0.7918602228164673,
0.6650063991546631,
0.3775891661643982,
-0.3693220913410187,
-0.7315732836723328,
-0.4324477016925812,
-0.22786806523799896,
0.1484609693288803,
1.0735195875167847,
0.13342885673046112,
-0.9464558959007263,
-0.023987416177988052,
-0.18945999443531036,
-0.2823721170425415,
-0.30699393153190613,
0.8306035995483398,
-0.601089596748352,
0.516264021396637,
0.4196496307849884,
0.599388599395752,
0.07454527914524078,
-0.28880128264427185,
0.3540087044239044,
-0.15544478595256805,
0.07163376361131668,
0.35304948687553406,
0.39666005969047546,
0.2444901317358017,
0.051797010004520416,
0.4974088668823242,
-0.04123994708061218,
-0.6714115142822266,
-0.8762087821960449,
0.19272363185882568,
-1.147024393081665,
-0.3467373847961426,
1.464190125465393,
0.022025689482688904,
-0.1501990556716919,
-0.1256304234266281,
-0.44931334257125854,
-0.09847038239240646,
-0.5806329250335693,
0.6440884470939636,
0.5312450528144836,
-0.09444493055343628,
-0.203907310962677,
-0.31627610325813293,
0.08743524551391602,
0.23842424154281616,
-0.871793806552887,
-0.19751335680484772,
0.7984990477561951,
-0.1231611892580986,
0.5597065687179565,
0.6901025772094727,
-0.022617368027567863,
0.14812570810317993,
-0.17018350958824158,
0.12417510151863098,
-0.19550055265426636,
-0.5452892184257507,
-0.47442513704299927,
0.5723642110824585,
0.24986429512500763,
0.16937565803527832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00795v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00795v2
|
Executing Natural Language-Described Algorithms with Large Language Models: An Investigation
| 2024-02-23T05:31:36 | 2024-03-14T14:25:13 |
Xin Zheng, Qiming Zhu, Hongyu Lin, Yaojie Lu, Xianpei Han, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Executing computer programs described in natural language has long been a
pursuit of computer science. With the advent of enhanced natural language
understanding capabilities exhibited by large language models (LLMs), the path
toward this goal has been illuminated. In this paper, we seek to examine the
capacity of present-day LLMs to comprehend and execute algorithms outlined in
natural language. We established an algorithm test set sourced from
Introduction to Algorithm, a well-known textbook that contains many
representative widely-used algorithms. To systematically assess LLMs' code
execution abilities, we selected 30 algorithms, generated 300 random-sampled
instances in total, and evaluated whether popular LLMs can understand and
execute these algorithms. Our findings reveal that LLMs, notably GPT-4, can
effectively execute programs described in natural language, as long as no heavy
numeric computation is involved. We believe our findings contribute to
evaluating LLMs' code execution abilities and would encourage further
investigation and application for the computation power of LLMs.
|
[
-0.30262795090675354,
-1.0378210544586182,
0.9829994440078735,
0.3374609351158142,
-0.29035794734954834,
0.15538956224918365,
-0.4970018267631531,
-0.6324785947799683,
-0.15112610161304474,
0.7503559589385986,
-0.4860309660434723,
-0.4977867901325226,
-0.6816798448562622,
0.4868454933166504,
-0.5743027329444885,
0.845329999923706,
-0.20677237212657928,
0.1479102224111557,
-0.166749969124794,
0.1690501868724823,
-0.6011525988578796,
-0.36623501777648926,
-0.4002029001712799,
-0.45985016226768494,
0.18730388581752777,
0.09841247648000717,
0.7348661422729492,
0.7037672996520996,
0.737148106098175,
0.37862175703048706,
0.05508768558502197,
-0.13413123786449432,
-0.5900773406028748,
-0.0879175066947937,
0.06417542695999146,
-0.7113038301467896,
-0.14138832688331604,
0.15930604934692383,
0.9705453515052795,
0.7045612335205078,
-0.05135861411690712,
0.1008421778678894,
-0.02517765201628208,
0.5420319437980652,
-0.30191031098365784,
0.08440506458282471,
-0.7351869940757751,
0.09291935712099075,
-0.10476090759038925,
-0.341270387172699,
-0.5104902982711792,
-0.6246218085289001,
0.19723553955554962,
-0.46317967772483826,
0.07610289752483368,
-0.027694128453731537,
0.4237101376056671,
0.02681547775864601,
-0.4147064983844757,
-0.8490158319473267,
-0.8538156151771545,
1.0045950412750244,
-0.7625718116760254,
0.11104422807693481,
0.15640780329704285,
0.44557493925094604,
-0.3875325918197632,
-0.8180574774742126,
-0.6240976452827454,
-0.6635599732398987,
0.02144172601401806,
-0.40524426102638245,
-0.1595742404460907,
0.24135076999664307,
0.7409223914146423,
0.6588631272315979,
-0.6881952881813049,
0.26584920287132263,
-0.4497859477996826,
-0.09710143506526947,
0.33836042881011963,
0.2150033563375473,
0.4936526417732239,
-0.07436768710613251,
-0.15032200515270233,
0.31313270330429077,
-0.6022888422012329,
-0.3290809392929077,
0.3052448034286499,
0.2278824746608734,
-0.09981106221675873,
0.8303275108337402,
-0.33399179577827454,
0.8487182855606079,
-0.5944427251815796,
0.03591950610280037,
0.012550699524581432,
-0.3327552080154419,
-0.4921149015426636,
-0.006408280227333307,
0.5356578826904297,
0.13450780510902405,
0.6725809574127197,
-0.22896790504455566,
-0.30052414536476135,
0.13494402170181274,
0.25143587589263916,
-0.8461684584617615,
0.01946914941072464,
-0.04449213668704033,
-0.29697224497795105,
-0.20982626080513,
-0.09767121076583862,
-0.6958209872245789,
-0.5881781578063965,
-0.6203450560569763,
0.5860893726348877,
-0.41531190276145935,
-0.021896930411458015,
0.16335253417491913,
-0.13103322684764862,
0.7126778960227966,
0.1566586047410965,
-0.7502182126045227,
0.8080509901046753,
1.066039800643921,
0.9675595164299011,
0.009223483502864838,
-0.24302789568901062,
-0.6726897358894348,
-0.033999815583229065,
-0.40532150864601135,
0.4932639002799988,
-0.7547292113304138,
-0.23227478563785553,
0.17843812704086304,
-0.27542680501937866,
-0.04408921301364899,
-0.44076815247535706,
0.43956246972084045,
-0.8321418166160583,
0.1460690051317215,
-0.30491089820861816,
-0.8843465447425842,
-0.286060094833374,
0.21513088047504425,
-0.5567856431007385,
0.7641162872314453,
-0.2114754468202591,
-0.5802831649780273,
-0.026428697630763054,
-1.062626600265503,
-0.7899420857429504,
0.0915803462266922,
-0.25811535120010376,
-0.015892066061496735,
0.3248211443424225,
0.13938316702842712,
0.5519520044326782,
-0.6107528209686279,
-0.051121436059474945,
-0.20228621363639832,
-0.7708488702774048,
0.28277313709259033,
-0.7181529402732849,
0.8599328398704529,
0.055785078555345535,
-0.627017080783844,
-0.14121487736701965,
-0.4251396954059601,
0.07554025948047638,
0.4554978609085083,
-0.20285755395889282,
-0.11042946577072144,
0.03890916332602501,
-0.300952672958374,
-0.14648863673210144,
0.40138185024261475,
-0.44773679971694946,
0.5495173931121826,
-0.5496088862419128,
0.46430936455726624,
0.7906045913696289,
-0.09998360276222229,
0.5041007399559021,
-0.15613864362239838,
0.8080896735191345,
-0.8760255575180054,
0.02618572674691677,
-0.2417481243610382,
-0.5620939135551453,
-0.49436697363853455,
-0.21907168626785278,
0.14330369234085083,
0.4668956696987152,
-0.5719515681266785,
0.06750137358903885,
-0.3716663122177124,
-0.5077416300773621,
-0.2349446564912796,
0.3705437183380127,
0.36540475487709045,
0.27818524837493896,
0.1482522189617157,
-0.057266831398010254,
-0.4432162344455719,
-1.0360506772994995,
-0.42411744594573975,
-0.06930678337812424,
-0.16804929077625275,
0.39086616039276123,
0.5234998464584351,
-0.3562769591808319,
0.8311628103256226,
-0.6909984946250916,
0.12147659063339233,
-0.33976176381111145,
0.3326355814933777,
0.557719886302948,
-0.03939054161310196,
0.3125554621219635,
-0.5804582238197327,
-0.2501037120819092,
-0.032330580055713654,
-0.7413924932479858,
-0.18918178975582123,
0.021377986297011375,
0.08107815682888031,
0.19316571950912476,
0.3866645097732544,
-0.5216010808944702,
0.23854024708271027,
0.6685262322425842,
-0.008858976885676384,
0.8009812235832214,
-0.5036424398422241,
0.07743211835622787,
-0.5603967905044556,
-0.0775407999753952,
0.0005106557509861887,
-0.09649684280157089,
-0.7103315591812134,
0.20599108934402466,
0.024559739977121353,
-0.028578199446201324,
-0.25864309072494507,
0.3200843334197998,
-0.6415176391601562,
-0.5617156028747559,
-0.32790783047676086,
0.14045746624469757,
-0.28735485672950745,
0.22232073545455933,
-0.10511940717697144,
0.8446616530418396,
0.5845893621444702,
-0.7256366610527039,
0.35168856382369995,
-0.1600305140018463,
-0.5598282217979431,
0.1450856775045395,
-0.7298334836959839,
0.5601845383644104,
-0.10689426958560944,
0.10831741988658905,
-0.8264535665512085,
-0.33738261461257935,
-0.0043625421822071075,
-0.12132583558559418,
0.15885809063911438,
-0.19855739176273346,
-0.8620742559432983,
-0.4124547243118286,
-0.2099880576133728,
0.221405029296875,
0.6184760928153992,
-0.5317522883415222,
0.6332169771194458,
0.2934035062789917,
-0.07720618695020676,
-0.2866167724132538,
-0.5413256883621216,
0.36788663268089294,
-0.1492740958929062,
-0.4400133490562439,
0.0239093080163002,
-0.12126275897026062,
-0.3837839663028717,
-0.24722200632095337,
0.17580512166023254,
-0.049292951822280884,
0.22107253968715668,
0.1607966423034668,
0.17917336523532867,
-0.26741671562194824,
-0.0023568307515233755,
-0.36280861496925354,
0.1314224898815155,
0.3394710421562195,
-0.1454252153635025,
0.7526742815971375,
-0.43546488881111145,
-0.6073869466781616,
-0.36275413632392883,
0.09577034413814545,
0.6468704342842102,
-0.2867708206176758,
0.5119475722312927,
0.4265156388282776,
-0.47049832344055176,
-0.1558917611837387,
-0.49025699496269226,
-0.12965135276317596,
-0.5246171951293945,
0.46392107009887695,
-0.2904488742351532,
-0.9113141894340515,
0.35199227929115295,
-0.04930775612592697,
0.26608210802078247,
0.30126282572746277,
0.8131197690963745,
0.0676506757736206,
0.8970078229904175,
0.44768741726875305,
-0.4267435669898987,
0.31724366545677185,
-0.20201285183429718,
0.2956832945346832,
-0.5111513137817383,
0.06786548346281052,
-0.7074521780014038,
-0.26828473806381226,
-0.6989009380340576,
-0.6024560332298279,
0.10200962424278259,
-0.21755243837833405,
-0.21414831280708313,
0.25901588797569275,
-0.48397096991539,
0.7264899611473083,
0.5259600877761841,
-0.2054707407951355,
0.3424467444419861,
0.01474776491522789,
-0.04301900044083595,
0.27323058247566223,
-0.2861509919166565,
-0.8521698713302612,
1.1697343587875366,
0.5890485048294067,
0.7396883368492126,
0.17591005563735962,
0.6831144094467163,
0.36052027344703674,
0.49371156096458435,
-0.7142234444618225,
0.6826655268669128,
0.0251145139336586,
-0.5553368330001831,
-0.3045275807380676,
-0.5555393695831299,
-0.9741222858428955,
0.012228764593601227,
0.09546896070241928,
-0.7949657440185547,
-0.5387256145477295,
-0.050395745784044266,
-0.12032543122768402,
0.24265432357788086,
-1.0017377138137817,
0.8413708209991455,
-0.5334553122520447,
0.03348696231842041,
-0.4846126139163971,
-0.3410274386405945,
0.6427925229072571,
-0.09806790947914124,
0.30150339007377625,
0.027226010337471962,
-0.10689090192317963,
0.8526989817619324,
-0.09187523275613785,
0.7262580394744873,
-0.193222776055336,
-0.27022111415863037,
0.36026543378829956,
0.119083933532238,
0.593136191368103,
-0.057455047965049744,
-0.2551480531692505,
0.2053876370191574,
0.053900331258773804,
-0.4301416575908661,
-0.775629997253418,
0.7814615368843079,
-0.4918559193611145,
-0.5969939827919006,
-0.48403632640838623,
-0.42289209365844727,
-0.044557854533195496,
0.24932637810707092,
-0.11706268042325974,
0.628068745136261,
-0.2649032175540924,
-0.0005383811658248305,
0.43703752756118774,
-0.2704494595527649,
0.5124841332435608,
0.5006596446037292,
-0.4128133952617645,
-0.10967838764190674,
0.7464501261711121,
-0.003108058590441942,
0.32376325130462646,
0.3693586587905884,
0.20503798127174377,
-0.3687911927700043,
-1.0313234329223633,
-0.21545523405075073,
0.30430033802986145,
-0.6704469919204712,
0.07533536106348038,
-0.3249727189540863,
-0.09523731470108032,
-0.19798196852207184,
-0.13858577609062195,
-0.03045472875237465,
-0.06960462778806686,
-0.16878730058670044,
0.06697772443294525,
0.40765759348869324,
1.3943184614181519,
0.4215439260005951,
0.2581751048564911,
-0.7446130514144897,
0.3537275493144989,
0.34045344591140747,
0.5674419403076172,
-0.16819648444652557,
-0.4300241768360138,
-0.14499235153198242,
0.12946641445159912,
-0.16943132877349854,
-1.005037546157837,
0.20584505796432495,
0.11288779973983765,
0.6325597167015076,
0.3084179759025574,
-0.16433806717395782,
0.5445195436477661,
-0.5618066191673279,
0.6029511094093323,
-0.19488325715065002,
-0.9035345911979675,
0.2664780616760254,
-0.5118764042854309,
0.49318021535873413,
0.42258158326148987,
0.34281760454177856,
-0.4602292776107788,
-0.3329499065876007,
-0.3205483853816986,
-0.1971273124217987,
0.5567712783813477,
0.3543110191822052,
0.45729124546051025,
-0.0935170128941536,
0.5185018181800842,
-0.041588470339775085,
0.21944507956504822,
-0.6008764505386353,
-0.004582404624670744,
0.32190555334091187,
-0.2999984622001648,
-0.2920750677585602,
-0.26114001870155334,
0.08011302351951599,
-0.04216775298118591,
0.346048504114151,
-0.2591121792793274,
0.5549966096878052,
-0.04365706071257591,
-0.20485588908195496,
0.09120596200227737,
0.3410598337650299,
0.6565014719963074,
0.9448843598365784,
-0.20791561901569366,
0.3098897635936737,
0.22600482404232025,
-0.5755229592323303,
-0.174069344997406,
0.2026708722114563,
0.05186580494046211,
-0.3153989613056183,
0.5767743587493896,
0.4918019473552704,
0.264382004737854,
-0.9637816548347473,
0.3485982120037079,
-0.24700134992599487,
-0.2142520248889923,
-0.33386608958244324,
0.11705025285482407,
0.18796677887439728,
0.09507755935192108,
0.4376264214515686,
-0.269904762506485,
0.21993345022201538,
-0.6967639923095703,
0.20711319148540497,
0.7088147401809692,
-0.17365145683288574,
-0.21373425424098969,
0.14359992742538452,
0.029854070395231247,
-0.506763219833374,
0.7773773074150085,
-0.4248746633529663,
-0.8300661444664001,
0.7135328650474548,
0.6216896176338196,
0.7901988625526428,
0.15413527190685272,
-0.027290645986795425,
-0.029407020658254623,
0.6404849290847778,
-0.10987547785043716,
0.40311580896377563,
0.1782553791999817,
-0.5967646837234497,
-0.9763458371162415,
-0.7752171158790588,
-0.4548102617263794,
0.07776568830013275,
-0.26418814063072205,
0.17144541442394257,
-0.6156670451164246,
0.10464208573102951,
0.06829938292503357,
0.38234880566596985,
-0.7918022274971008,
-0.12241122126579285,
0.22694870829582214,
1.0335772037506104,
-0.6834504008293152,
0.6165482997894287,
0.6616896390914917,
0.01222050841897726,
-0.7167069911956787,
-0.032160889357328415,
0.0643066018819809,
-0.7898606657981873,
0.6369523406028748,
0.4492207467556,
-0.024103280156850815,
0.07087572664022446,
-0.5837998986244202,
-0.6166088581085205,
0.8607880473136902,
0.5029938817024231,
-0.4906283915042877,
0.14835619926452637,
0.3880497217178345,
0.5826020836830139,
-0.2736148536205292,
0.4832614064216614,
0.8146530389785767,
0.6280249357223511,
-0.03779631853103638,
-1.1142009496688843,
0.013127320446074009,
0.004135873168706894,
-0.18642887473106384,
0.34276899695396423,
-0.056710317730903625,
0.6256623864173889,
-0.13134433329105377,
-0.09837254136800766,
0.11029445379972458,
0.6998612284660339,
0.26274242997169495,
0.23854149878025055,
0.4484211802482605,
0.37125757336616516,
0.9244272708892822,
0.05707629397511482,
1.523910641670227,
-0.08242157846689224,
0.15729911625385284,
0.8884754776954651,
-0.42390841245651245,
0.8149898052215576,
0.34131890535354614,
-0.49218690395355225,
0.44851309061050415,
0.391531378030777,
-0.019841838628053665,
0.15297473967075348,
0.5725260972976685,
-0.38513830304145813,
-0.027127951383590698,
0.1081170067191124,
0.06040317937731743,
0.5676544308662415,
0.15660367906093597,
-0.3045044541358948,
-0.2826782166957855,
-0.10244600474834442,
-0.10768385231494904,
0.0472201406955719,
-0.40524569153785706,
0.6685056686401367,
0.0780663788318634,
-0.6827195882797241,
0.5778650045394897,
0.17480911314487457,
0.590178906917572,
-0.4887446463108063,
-0.29287660121917725,
0.2646012306213379,
-0.048242878168821335,
0.042076218873262405,
-0.8970626592636108,
0.23271138966083527,
0.2556819021701813,
0.0826367437839508,
0.0352276973426342,
0.7541954517364502,
0.07656396180391312,
-0.5678444504737854,
0.06832364201545715,
0.24564306437969208,
0.39468151330947876,
-0.28422293066978455,
-0.5447297692298889,
0.230478435754776,
-0.06340229511260986,
-0.08609215170145035,
0.23872265219688416,
0.32180026173591614,
0.020524965599179268,
0.7565107345581055,
0.6986255645751953,
0.08185901492834091,
0.35144108533859253,
0.022807130590081215,
0.7412370443344116,
-0.6086766719818115,
-0.23886778950691223,
-1.1890100240707397,
0.005282355006784201,
-0.06309613585472107,
0.10999538749456406,
0.7903295159339905,
0.7347368597984314,
0.5056520104408264,
0.011460553854703903,
0.864008367061615,
-0.03261485695838928,
0.25950169563293457,
-0.735295295715332,
0.28257042169570923,
-0.044710464775562286,
0.4323602318763733,
-0.20663177967071533,
-0.9136492609977722,
-0.38782060146331787,
0.5229367017745972,
-0.8684221506118774,
0.33336707949638367,
0.5203997492790222,
0.8173450827598572,
0.07944280654191971,
0.4356245994567871,
0.09713033586740494,
0.23396679759025574,
0.5003196597099304,
0.5656335353851318,
0.7834725975990295,
-0.0427095964550972,
0.422995001077652,
-0.13384224474430084,
-0.48222944140434265,
-0.13643258810043335,
-1.1473454236984253,
-0.975325882434845,
-0.07197534292936325,
-0.027077019214630127,
0.06141054630279541,
0.015717478469014168,
0.985433042049408,
0.3558797240257263,
-0.5953741073608398,
-0.31106245517730713,
-0.3965395987033844,
0.26473280787467957,
-0.11745026707649231,
-0.1814282238483429,
0.3546096086502075,
-0.38007310032844543,
-0.847353458404541,
0.5481446981430054,
0.1790408492088318,
-0.1010558158159256,
-0.4461907148361206,
-0.31417444348335266,
-0.1812444031238556,
0.1012619137763977,
0.5350664258003235,
0.28823554515838623,
-0.668315052986145,
-0.31635749340057373,
0.240310937166214,
-0.019336314871907234,
-0.15991705656051636,
1.0587228536605835,
-0.619296133518219,
0.45567381381988525,
0.5744351148605347,
0.9895972013473511,
0.26772087812423706,
-0.01947217434644699,
0.8284053206443787,
-0.42852672934532166,
-0.37513697147369385,
0.269549697637558,
0.32678863406181335,
0.22018061578273773,
-0.15257146954536438,
0.35672393441200256,
0.054496146738529205,
-0.7238929271697998,
-0.7249859571456909,
0.1292986124753952,
-0.8005987405776978,
-0.2331552952528,
1.3764026165008545,
0.20532888174057007,
-0.1877342015504837,
-0.18645186722278595,
-0.355759859085083,
0.1720561385154724,
-0.20099669694900513,
0.5549262762069702,
0.713016927242279,
-0.19002491235733032,
-0.05402068793773651,
-1.1040256023406982,
0.39710912108421326,
0.1766602098941803,
-0.7503631711006165,
0.16294121742248535,
0.46234130859375,
0.24513347446918488,
-0.008628984913229942,
0.6277376413345337,
-0.11298361420631409,
0.08256365358829498,
-0.47079727053642273,
0.021594811230897903,
-0.03677968680858612,
0.1121227964758873,
-0.6468424201011658,
0.27571749687194824,
0.3806542158126831,
0.08953707665205002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15105v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15105v2
|
A First Look at GPT Apps: Landscape and Vulnerability
| 2024-02-23T05:30:32 | 2024-05-23T17:30:02 |
Zejun Zhang, Li Zhang, Xin Yuan, Anlan Zhang, Mengwei Xu, Feng Qian
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Following OpenAI's introduction of GPTs, a surge in GPT apps has led to the
launch of dedicated LLM app stores. Nevertheless, given its debut, there is a
lack of sufficient understanding of this new ecosystem. To fill this gap, this
paper presents a first comprehensive longitudinal (5-month) study of the
evolution, landscape, and vulnerability of the emerging LLM app ecosystem,
focusing on two GPT app stores: \textit{GPTStore.AI} and the official
\textit{OpenAI GPT Store}. Specifically, we develop two automated tools and a
TriLevel configuration extraction strategy to efficiently gather metadata (\ie
names, creators, descriptions, \etc) and user feedback for all GPT apps across
these two stores, as well as configurations (\ie system prompts, knowledge
files, and APIs) for the top 10,000 popular apps. Our extensive analysis
reveals: (1) the user enthusiasm for GPT apps consistently rises, whereas
creator interest plateaus within three months of GPTs' launch; (2) nearly 90\%
system prompts can be easily accessed due to widespread failure to secure GPT
app configurations, leading to considerable plagiarism and duplication among
apps. Our findings highlight the necessity of enhancing the LLM app ecosystem
by the app stores, creators, and users.
|
[
-0.5706050992012024,
-0.43373408913612366,
0.4872308671474457,
0.02849752828478813,
-0.09992717206478119,
0.2717093825340271,
0.28767240047454834,
-0.38237711787223816,
0.06958121806383133,
0.5023843050003052,
-0.6909062266349792,
-0.6320182681083679,
-0.41423022747039795,
-0.18180648982524872,
-0.1682654768228531,
1.5362365245819092,
-0.2237240970134735,
-0.740033745765686,
0.17231856286525726,
-0.2273605763912201,
-0.7863847017288208,
-0.27297863364219666,
-0.5524801015853882,
0.034802764654159546,
0.5304900407791138,
0.3618086576461792,
0.6038403511047363,
0.19187882542610168,
0.5158892273902893,
0.24195246398448944,
0.06930339336395264,
-0.15928557515144348,
-0.4983713626861572,
0.17273326218128204,
0.09753524512052536,
-0.14753028750419617,
-0.5361282229423523,
0.12243620306253433,
0.2942652404308319,
0.0016990475123748183,
0.004748719744384289,
0.3774685263633728,
0.3389960825443268,
0.712783932685852,
-0.6936474442481995,
0.09654051810503006,
-0.563926100730896,
0.011542581021785736,
-0.36441731452941895,
-0.2488596886396408,
-0.12445905059576035,
-0.09449408203363419,
0.21417178213596344,
-0.6295883059501648,
0.09253741055727005,
-0.045386068522930145,
0.6532753109931946,
0.06485074013471603,
-0.6428088545799255,
-0.2970833480358124,
-0.8373504281044006,
0.3668736517429352,
0.08135885000228882,
-0.06557909399271011,
0.0033606896176934242,
0.43489503860473633,
-0.3109717071056366,
-0.7664652466773987,
-0.2596754729747772,
-0.4273656904697418,
0.07198542356491089,
0.17958387732505798,
-0.5150361657142639,
-0.32115438580513,
-0.039340756833553314,
0.6579840779304504,
-0.7238458395004272,
0.06605330109596252,
-0.1115792766213417,
-0.2380431741476059,
0.46635210514068604,
0.3053744435310364,
0.6213518381118774,
-0.02739916928112507,
-0.8346218466758728,
-0.06468354165554047,
-1.0402604341506958,
0.12314439564943314,
0.3834131062030792,
-0.05151422694325447,
-0.2892914116382599,
0.6698999404907227,
0.14527136087417603,
0.2609844505786896,
-0.1971692442893982,
0.024537092074751854,
0.00029715700657106936,
-0.4526987671852112,
-0.26254814863204956,
0.008535160683095455,
0.7919262051582336,
0.39668917655944824,
-0.06746227294206619,
-0.12612684071063995,
-0.4096182584762573,
-0.04021543264389038,
0.4889284670352936,
-0.18611116707324982,
-0.3493165969848633,
0.3333280384540558,
-0.30992305278778076,
-0.42838114500045776,
0.030280960723757744,
-0.5304014086723328,
-0.8115025162696838,
0.14851905405521393,
0.3865564167499542,
-0.20481626689434052,
-0.40522414445877075,
-0.1649671196937561,
-0.05856717750430107,
0.4015709161758423,
0.23843441903591156,
-0.818764865398407,
0.2294328212738037,
1.137008547782898,
1.1283345222473145,
-0.39483076333999634,
-0.3902628421783447,
-0.026945341378450394,
0.2295093983411789,
-0.10824204236268997,
0.6419193744659424,
0.06293052434921265,
-0.7358201742172241,
-0.11364895105361938,
-0.26035019755363464,
0.11621010303497314,
-0.4475831687450409,
0.32578176259994507,
-0.6632649302482605,
-0.051962960511446,
-0.26614534854888916,
-0.06092718243598938,
0.13020703196525574,
0.6652403473854065,
-0.8275803327560425,
0.9401835203170776,
0.35187822580337524,
-0.8170292973518372,
0.5469308495521545,
-0.8937394618988037,
-0.22556671500205994,
0.37840354442596436,
0.05056418105959892,
-0.07272197306156158,
0.13602840900421143,
0.5810155868530273,
0.15400534868240356,
-0.10406524688005447,
-0.08301199972629547,
-0.04467083513736725,
-0.2168571949005127,
-0.018710855394601822,
-0.3136749267578125,
0.9003655910491943,
0.3206593692302704,
-0.30774644017219543,
-0.14597418904304504,
-0.32298383116722107,
-0.28183817863464355,
0.06704595685005188,
-0.10309956222772598,
-0.4464264512062073,
-0.2431626319885254,
-0.06350576132535934,
-0.049942366778850555,
0.3142479956150055,
-0.4164144694805145,
0.5636008977890015,
0.04961133748292923,
0.6754045486450195,
0.8350394368171692,
0.4360694885253906,
0.4607240855693817,
-0.21164172887802124,
0.7327395677566528,
0.2102264016866684,
0.763748824596405,
-0.5161817669868469,
-0.601754903793335,
-0.1202341765165329,
-0.0331677570939064,
-0.020319608971476555,
0.6616136431694031,
-0.527275025844574,
0.022728299722075462,
-0.5886704325675964,
-0.5516749620437622,
-0.1280483454465866,
0.012093870900571346,
0.19699881970882416,
0.4136636257171631,
-0.12708887457847595,
-0.41426509618759155,
-0.06229182332754135,
-0.7821674346923828,
-0.42232778668403625,
-0.512531042098999,
-0.07614634931087494,
0.4828633666038513,
0.5668869018554688,
-0.5279619097709656,
1.121208667755127,
-0.5243765115737915,
-0.2909955084323883,
-0.1356004774570465,
0.009962990880012512,
0.24762670695781708,
0.10430692881345749,
0.7004230618476868,
-0.6624529361724854,
-0.47667914628982544,
0.29644858837127686,
-0.42611899971961975,
-0.0016408907249569893,
-0.016913890838623047,
-0.11751973628997803,
0.06398292630910873,
0.10750212520360947,
-0.7667044401168823,
0.13135498762130737,
0.5525227189064026,
-0.38327449560165405,
0.6933411359786987,
-0.009685245342552662,
0.009663175791501999,
-1.080629825592041,
0.105984166264534,
0.039514727890491486,
0.19232288002967834,
-0.6497892141342163,
0.14498400688171387,
-0.056909892708063126,
-0.36613932251930237,
-0.3176610767841339,
0.5343198776245117,
-0.5251095294952393,
-0.3117941915988922,
0.2203439623117447,
0.12858106195926666,
-0.26834648847579956,
-0.08882925659418106,
-0.45485466718673706,
1.1312446594238281,
0.3649154007434845,
-0.4471572935581207,
0.14436151087284088,
0.18216434121131897,
-0.41194236278533936,
0.3670773506164551,
-0.5054254531860352,
0.1462453007698059,
0.14693531394004822,
0.20566046237945557,
-1.21550714969635,
-0.3217078745365143,
0.5403705835342407,
-0.31428223848342896,
0.0819893628358841,
-0.24763797223567963,
-0.2908964157104492,
-0.4022746980190277,
-0.5084042549133301,
0.026503296568989754,
0.32383430004119873,
-0.5473688244819641,
0.44144105911254883,
0.6931557655334473,
-0.43466049432754517,
-0.4700655937194824,
-0.495893269777298,
0.5830483436584473,
-0.571843683719635,
-0.7310091853141785,
0.049723535776138306,
0.2009039968252182,
-0.3254046142101288,
-0.15288881957530975,
-0.16481633484363556,
0.07246262580156326,
0.33536359667778015,
0.39086490869522095,
0.2879420518875122,
-0.2728956937789917,
-0.09649432450532913,
-0.1503159999847412,
-0.6178513765335083,
0.032306697219610214,
-0.4060788154602051,
0.17870067059993744,
-0.41084906458854675,
-0.4148057699203491,
-0.08279534429311752,
0.18628044426441193,
0.6459265351295471,
-0.19727739691734314,
0.4053608179092407,
0.5110421776771545,
-0.08417228609323502,
0.08066653460264206,
-0.386487752199173,
0.15622878074645996,
-0.4839911460876465,
0.12485290318727493,
-0.3647422194480896,
-0.8556739687919617,
0.6442413330078125,
-0.2998466193675995,
0.2945544421672821,
0.5700817704200745,
0.3914937973022461,
0.1270490437746048,
0.6979168653488159,
0.6454660296440125,
-0.48365846276283264,
0.49084651470184326,
-0.20870980620384216,
0.403367817401886,
-0.7542790770530701,
-0.3882080316543579,
-0.09695779532194138,
-0.5099965333938599,
-0.757272481918335,
0.08079133927822113,
0.8851193189620972,
-0.1138729602098465,
-0.4922146797180176,
0.23333312571048737,
-0.5350393652915955,
0.6855854392051697,
0.5099220275878906,
0.14130017161369324,
0.394108384847641,
0.149107426404953,
0.2665828466415405,
0.01268931943923235,
-0.37832385301589966,
-0.6243655681610107,
1.2190858125686646,
0.570612907409668,
0.6700859069824219,
0.46180737018585205,
0.830622136592865,
0.429823637008667,
0.6486318707466125,
-0.6977088451385498,
0.2900315821170807,
-0.17171582579612732,
-0.3976952135562897,
-0.2578074634075165,
-0.016182580962777138,
-0.8446301817893982,
-0.06146663427352905,
0.2903708517551422,
-0.7131528258323669,
0.1474163830280304,
0.1565869003534317,
-0.6249937415122986,
0.2833857536315918,
-0.9353272318840027,
0.8429670929908752,
-0.49967503547668457,
-0.3294200301170349,
0.330506294965744,
-0.6126571893692017,
0.5870763659477234,
-0.06117086857557297,
0.14179584383964539,
0.04593994468450546,
-0.29556626081466675,
0.2532879710197449,
-0.4420071244239807,
0.6071352958679199,
-0.3748627007007599,
-0.29058021306991577,
0.38454994559288025,
0.38845980167388916,
0.597387969493866,
0.16733206808567047,
0.32357507944107056,
0.06061474606394768,
-0.10680430382490158,
-0.17418605089187622,
-0.39899909496307373,
0.7309873104095459,
-0.7430729269981384,
-0.43100640177726746,
-0.4779403805732727,
-0.30225613713264465,
-0.24809302389621735,
0.25463369488716125,
0.4162253439426422,
-0.08263079822063446,
-0.5536080002784729,
-0.012134231626987457,
0.7223215103149414,
-0.07916318625211716,
0.4963681399822235,
0.20156708359718323,
-0.012055214494466782,
-0.378054678440094,
0.5699623823165894,
-0.0513119138777256,
-0.08364197611808777,
0.07595153898000717,
0.353537917137146,
-0.273229718208313,
-0.6651701927185059,
-0.4080660939216614,
-0.3165346384048462,
-0.282785564661026,
-0.08442448079586029,
-0.262378454208374,
-0.13400736451148987,
-0.16284683346748352,
-0.11272620409727097,
-0.24318288266658783,
0.05796929448843002,
-0.07942071557044983,
-0.09821552783250809,
0.39329078793525696,
0.9750254154205322,
0.008523098193109035,
0.6296527981758118,
-0.8384814858436584,
0.15936002135276794,
0.3377763330936432,
0.3285077214241028,
-0.12757150828838348,
-0.002120130229741335,
-0.006328866351395845,
-0.057349592447280884,
-0.47267207503318787,
-0.8479223251342773,
0.24963130056858063,
0.2283458560705185,
0.38584867119789124,
0.49469026923179626,
-0.08547871559858322,
0.4303421378135681,
-0.16761514544487,
1.3577673435211182,
0.1303490251302719,
-0.5417277812957764,
0.7053020596504211,
-0.6510688662528992,
0.18419818580150604,
0.6089922785758972,
0.35508736968040466,
-0.5507047176361084,
0.05290864035487175,
-0.3256872594356537,
-1.0965534448623657,
0.5719538331031799,
0.08300945162773132,
0.4538327157497406,
0.19266365468502045,
0.6117900013923645,
0.4405437707901001,
0.07640392333269119,
-0.7484933137893677,
-0.27663329243659973,
-0.13443218171596527,
0.08795754611492157,
-0.28569701313972473,
-0.39395415782928467,
-0.4353446364402771,
-0.13963428139686584,
0.24148443341255188,
0.10339760780334473,
0.12948912382125854,
-0.027373597025871277,
-0.1764368861913681,
0.1661926656961441,
0.27644869685173035,
0.31007668375968933,
0.46056219935417175,
-0.03086370974779129,
0.24790358543395996,
-0.0032134370412677526,
-1.125844955444336,
0.20444656908512115,
-0.25257375836372375,
-0.32176756858825684,
-0.38643771409988403,
0.484784871339798,
0.9323746562004089,
0.33993202447891235,
-0.29559823870658875,
0.556667149066925,
0.0640363022685051,
-0.061428576707839966,
-0.3596942722797394,
0.08514587581157684,
-0.11040642857551575,
0.40511423349380493,
0.3576359748840332,
-0.27979058027267456,
0.16718974709510803,
-0.6750410199165344,
0.15306875109672546,
0.3243679404258728,
-0.24649561941623688,
-0.26180851459503174,
0.4771542251110077,
0.04315541684627533,
-0.042353302240371704,
0.8213565349578857,
-0.0672292485833168,
-0.2300882786512375,
0.5127292275428772,
0.639556348323822,
1.4843820333480835,
-0.11855737119913101,
0.5449560880661011,
-0.07741087675094604,
0.7030786871910095,
0.04190368205308914,
0.19062815606594086,
-0.25486502051353455,
-0.4694288372993469,
0.2829499840736389,
-0.33673545718193054,
-0.5081014037132263,
0.20441651344299316,
-0.47713685035705566,
0.20793674886226654,
-0.4753495156764984,
-0.31860125064849854,
-0.2635963559150696,
0.14455847442150116,
-0.3985315263271332,
-0.30794715881347656,
0.030083797872066498,
0.9103472828865051,
-0.9402852058410645,
0.2830084264278412,
0.8751929998397827,
-0.12356793135404587,
-0.5040484666824341,
0.3477027714252472,
0.2920292317867279,
-0.9839228391647339,
0.22947975993156433,
0.05660821869969368,
-0.04986751079559326,
0.01699152961373329,
-0.44608044624328613,
-0.566155731678009,
1.5036358833312988,
0.18328149616718292,
-0.5878270268440247,
0.2985959053039551,
0.4113887846469879,
0.5698683857917786,
-0.3395693004131317,
0.16879814863204956,
0.750576913356781,
0.5239040851593018,
-0.02764762006700039,
-0.47140175104141235,
-0.1275290697813034,
-0.3145536780357361,
0.19037151336669922,
0.34093016386032104,
-0.4347008168697357,
0.8780494332313538,
-0.3559829294681549,
-0.3664100468158722,
-0.08812294900417328,
-0.1673704981803894,
0.18550421297550201,
0.8310210704803467,
0.32607173919677734,
0.6284051537513733,
0.4768504202365875,
-0.153806671500206,
1.173431396484375,
-0.475276380777359,
0.32710111141204834,
0.8148257732391357,
-0.2394789606332779,
0.8219740390777588,
0.40727126598358154,
-0.4303346574306488,
0.22940552234649658,
1.0877469778060913,
0.019359426572918892,
0.5690522789955139,
-0.1528182178735733,
-0.5918031930923462,
0.3384580910205841,
0.20210154354572296,
-0.51332026720047,
0.15867012739181519,
0.23933936655521393,
-0.26823094487190247,
-0.47567716240882874,
-0.032458215951919556,
-0.04737439006567001,
-0.6507519483566284,
-0.5013962984085083,
0.9567955732345581,
0.11626052856445312,
-0.3533785343170166,
-0.021053018048405647,
-0.20941415429115295,
0.3365924656391144,
-0.6190146207809448,
0.37833505868911743,
-0.5519729256629944,
-0.08060811460018158,
-0.20407734811306,
-1.1521906852722168,
0.23494784533977509,
0.15677063167095184,
0.05891353636980057,
-0.28476381301879883,
1.0049080848693848,
0.17735901474952698,
0.15965108573436737,
0.13564643263816833,
0.5730371475219727,
0.04341195523738861,
-0.5778700113296509,
-0.49678120017051697,
-0.023602306842803955,
-0.31781691312789917,
-0.46639570593833923,
0.481270968914032,
0.5194982886314392,
-0.3573415279388428,
0.418719619512558,
0.6148549914360046,
-0.13557608425617218,
0.1512206643819809,
-0.2609894275665283,
0.9941089749336243,
-0.5177919864654541,
-0.6298449039459229,
-1.061777114868164,
0.653012752532959,
0.052113424986600876,
-0.6378911733627319,
0.6386515498161316,
0.6568433046340942,
0.36332839727401733,
-0.11832877993583679,
0.8207147121429443,
-0.14795126020908356,
-0.14750342071056366,
-0.16331005096435547,
0.8187710046768188,
-0.46931880712509155,
0.660120964050293,
-0.08344946056604385,
-1.0494208335876465,
-0.22373725473880768,
-0.21893271803855896,
-0.36231136322021484,
-0.10216762125492096,
0.2798769176006317,
0.6899914145469666,
-0.2824712097644806,
0.0250837542116642,
-0.10032098740339279,
0.1327853947877884,
0.16195574402809143,
0.6700416803359985,
1.0068562030792236,
-0.40334421396255493,
0.47682619094848633,
-0.15721385180950165,
-0.5655707716941833,
-0.2329561710357666,
-0.9464828372001648,
-0.29286181926727295,
-0.45997312664985657,
-0.026702769100666046,
-0.12189313024282455,
0.14838190376758575,
0.13385505974292755,
0.18233659863471985,
-0.6767296195030212,
0.02208801545202732,
-0.2965003550052643,
0.09967576712369919,
-0.06564049422740936,
-0.18818457424640656,
0.2294396460056305,
0.07769148051738739,
-0.007174132391810417,
0.2544178366661072,
0.5063042640686035,
-0.025006292387843132,
-0.40224623680114746,
-0.16556105017662048,
0.5409826636314392,
-0.4208966791629791,
0.6634368896484375,
0.6213588118553162,
-0.4583745002746582,
-0.2524183690547943,
0.018202340230345726,
-0.20188100636005402,
0.0810602456331253,
0.93613201379776,
-0.5417193174362183,
0.3125365376472473,
0.30056333541870117,
0.379109650850296,
0.26512372493743896,
-0.04576892405748367,
0.44657260179519653,
-0.6959901452064514,
-0.17618681490421295,
-0.045776233077049255,
-0.08670728653669357,
-0.025956176221370697,
-0.4762996733188629,
0.5346707105636597,
0.11773303896188736,
-0.490282267332077,
-0.8980095982551575,
0.22639597952365875,
-0.8279238343238831,
0.04250375181436539,
0.8587528467178345,
-0.11328106373548508,
-0.11633165180683136,
-0.1879623532295227,
-0.36779895424842834,
-0.03388398885726929,
-0.1735190749168396,
0.9825108051300049,
0.704580545425415,
-0.25376594066619873,
-0.15448683500289917,
-0.8496596813201904,
0.3061145544052124,
-0.21910743415355682,
-0.7400376796722412,
0.05987578630447388,
0.2383921593427658,
0.500977098941803,
0.12914502620697021,
0.7282642126083374,
-0.48035722970962524,
0.08597646653652191,
0.3714841604232788,
-0.2694414258003235,
-0.15182067453861237,
-0.3814016580581665,
-0.5491722822189331,
0.46602368354797363,
0.18407274782657623,
-0.37435880303382874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15537v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15537v2
|
Evaluating the Performance of ChatGPT for Spam Email Detection
| 2024-02-23T04:52:08 | 2024-06-19T14:49:09 |
Shijing Si, Yuwei Wu, Le Tang, Yugui Zhang, Jedrek Wosik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Email continues to be a pivotal and extensively utilized communication medium
within professional and commercial domains. Nonetheless, the prevalence of spam
emails poses a significant challenge for users, disrupting their daily routines
and diminishing productivity. Consequently, accurately identifying and
filtering spam based on content has become crucial for cybersecurity. Recent
advancements in natural language processing, particularly with large language
models like ChatGPT, have shown remarkable performance in tasks such as
question answering and text generation. However, its potential in spam
identification remains underexplored. To fill in the gap, this study attempts
to evaluate ChatGPT's capabilities for spam identification in both English and
Chinese email datasets. We employ ChatGPT for spam email detection using
in-context learning, which requires a prompt instruction and a few
demonstrations. We also investigate how the number of demonstrations in the
prompt affects the performance of ChatGPT. For comparison, we also implement
five popular benchmark methods, including naive Bayes, support vector machines
(SVM), logistic regression (LR), feedforward dense neural networks (DNN), and
BERT classifiers. Through extensive experiments, the performance of ChatGPT is
significantly worse than deep supervised learning methods in the large English
dataset, while it presents superior performance on the low-resourced Chinese
dataset.
|
[
-0.3337271809577942,
-1.172284483909607,
-0.06854786723852158,
0.4623723030090332,
-0.29253244400024414,
0.20861788094043732,
-0.4103805720806122,
-0.40587061643600464,
-0.4203241169452667,
0.2574300765991211,
-0.4917263090610504,
-0.4811570942401886,
-0.8386419415473938,
0.2391500025987625,
-0.5976341366767883,
1.0529592037200928,
0.25225961208343506,
-0.13116489350795746,
0.14254623651504517,
0.1421680450439453,
-0.7829265594482422,
-0.35400518774986267,
-1.0983909368515015,
-0.32356855273246765,
0.3219701051712036,
0.3968116343021393,
0.28348347544670105,
0.12079256027936935,
0.53692626953125,
0.37939760088920593,
0.006853947881609201,
0.29051440954208374,
-0.6578671336174011,
0.06021140515804291,
0.3469454348087311,
-0.3180113434791565,
0.06084362789988518,
0.12541040778160095,
0.7346497774124146,
0.28585630655288696,
-0.1716252714395523,
0.0035838817711919546,
0.4666343033313751,
0.43047431111335754,
-0.3486292362213135,
0.2210693508386612,
-0.8039374947547913,
-0.03174378722906113,
-0.11120697855949402,
-0.3732723295688629,
-0.5289878249168396,
-0.36734649538993835,
0.5523650050163269,
-0.3463228642940521,
0.36756613850593567,
0.28183239698410034,
0.7100353837013245,
-0.1686919778585434,
-0.27786755561828613,
-0.4825625717639923,
-0.5072546005249023,
0.5043962001800537,
-0.4914063513278961,
0.1632470041513443,
0.1875239908695221,
0.49327072501182556,
-0.5123821496963501,
-0.5917984843254089,
-0.2501407563686371,
-0.3561892807483673,
-0.2738928198814392,
0.3058502972126007,
-0.22976188361644745,
-0.10169972479343414,
0.468610018491745,
0.3484758138656616,
-1.1578770875930786,
0.14378732442855835,
-0.31090742349624634,
-0.28359609842300415,
0.3606959283351898,
0.07205164432525635,
0.48201632499694824,
0.08123018592596054,
-0.4053800404071808,
-0.07312415540218353,
-0.44325631856918335,
0.21645842492580414,
0.3259173035621643,
0.333514004945755,
-0.0029375446029007435,
0.14829906821250916,
-0.15632382035255432,
0.33985817432403564,
0.008866573683917522,
-0.03869679570198059,
-0.1143847405910492,
0.2598552405834198,
-0.5001409649848938,
-0.04442472755908966,
0.9939098954200745,
-0.009751563891768456,
0.13245084881782532,
-0.19275473058223724,
-0.1957981139421463,
-0.040821801871061325,
0.14089973270893097,
-1.153335690498352,
-0.43457499146461487,
0.047525569796562195,
-0.39443522691726685,
-0.09532388299703598,
0.2677166163921356,
-0.5673266649246216,
-0.6018081903457642,
0.10011034458875656,
0.4960786998271942,
-0.6232408285140991,
-0.27039411664009094,
0.18853607773780823,
-0.3115145266056061,
0.20805339515209198,
0.5358388423919678,
-0.47619184851646423,
0.6017814874649048,
0.9813089966773987,
0.7370083332061768,
-0.42783692479133606,
-0.3894294500350952,
-0.6700116395950317,
-0.49399152398109436,
-0.19762863218784332,
0.849412739276886,
-0.7223194241523743,
-0.04547031223773956,
-0.03897589445114136,
0.1400558054447174,
-0.5454230308532715,
-0.8305338025093079,
0.3082529902458191,
-0.6471478939056396,
0.5762982964515686,
-0.03139547258615494,
-0.6390348076820374,
-0.25318917632102966,
0.5855222940444946,
-0.5815000534057617,
1.2499202489852905,
0.19891385734081268,
-0.7242718935012817,
0.5554280281066895,
-0.5826197266578674,
-0.49767976999282837,
0.45142853260040283,
0.2520256042480469,
-0.5466980934143066,
-0.11499711126089096,
-0.027707211673259735,
0.7488645911216736,
-0.3923269808292389,
0.1751229166984558,
-0.20487764477729797,
-0.7744500041007996,
0.6354649662971497,
-0.9304141998291016,
0.6376288533210754,
0.06678029149770737,
-0.5732174515724182,
-0.2863028347492218,
-0.5691820383071899,
-0.19583983719348907,
0.06859727203845978,
-0.2294938713312149,
-0.033104103058576584,
-0.19253578782081604,
0.0821693167090416,
0.23071706295013428,
-0.22874492406845093,
-0.4090195298194885,
-0.003678881097584963,
-0.40685153007507324,
0.1374897062778473,
0.6786813139915466,
0.16235430538654327,
0.06748370081186295,
-0.250901997089386,
0.3215455710887909,
0.08559142053127289,
0.1065802201628685,
-0.2835293710231781,
-0.7565328478813171,
-0.4863310754299164,
-0.4194237291812897,
0.3428642749786377,
0.7152347564697266,
-0.575455367565155,
0.2616124153137207,
-0.3510713279247284,
-0.37521421909332275,
-0.24929946660995483,
0.18477876484394073,
0.36453109979629517,
0.21766717731952667,
0.11959473043680191,
-0.2583954930305481,
-0.10152850300073624,
-0.6843453645706177,
-0.4676874279975891,
-0.14162708818912506,
-0.2904961407184601,
0.4271956980228424,
0.5550500154495239,
0.14419785141944885,
0.5785723328590393,
-0.1914892941713333,
-0.11507657170295715,
-0.3183543384075165,
0.2434995174407959,
0.20983584225177765,
0.25886738300323486,
0.36268675327301025,
-0.7323257327079773,
-0.9318079948425293,
0.020116863772273064,
-0.2658444941043854,
-0.10558194667100906,
0.009924786165356636,
0.002591364784166217,
0.11206252872943878,
-0.2558586299419403,
-0.5530567765235901,
0.46170517802238464,
0.2032807618379593,
-0.3553885519504547,
0.3632858693599701,
-0.030164606869220734,
0.49703875184059143,
-0.7184785008430481,
0.07541918009519577,
0.32948046922683716,
-0.2495800107717514,
-0.9821072220802307,
-0.4616779386997223,
0.14510634541511536,
-0.3093774616718292,
-0.5380011200904846,
0.5870821475982666,
-0.3469484746456146,
0.0858498364686966,
-0.4399421215057373,
0.18908335268497467,
-0.17198938131332397,
0.5252326726913452,
0.20849411189556122,
0.8072827458381653,
0.5311833620071411,
-0.5924333333969116,
0.35330966114997864,
-0.14613878726959229,
-0.5126683712005615,
0.6010799407958984,
-0.6306588053703308,
0.014447621069848537,
0.16460025310516357,
0.41493648290634155,
-1.2580065727233887,
-0.07254897058010101,
0.8878318667411804,
-0.6682976484298706,
0.33708256483078003,
-0.4661368429660797,
-0.7952373623847961,
-0.1693846583366394,
-0.20289261639118195,
0.08596082031726837,
0.6995039582252502,
-0.6270024180412292,
0.26053816080093384,
-0.03546600043773651,
0.20726561546325684,
-0.6055158972740173,
-0.3679773509502411,
-0.0649692639708519,
-0.45828622579574585,
-0.6479219198226929,
-0.043951865285634995,
0.07459954917430878,
0.0036769143771380186,
-0.3636960983276367,
-0.17228546738624573,
-0.16289854049682617,
0.36306050419807434,
0.24222061038017273,
0.08289507776498795,
-0.13656938076019287,
0.054053302854299545,
-0.3782612979412079,
-0.060216791927814484,
0.1643109917640686,
-0.09187773615121841,
0.5613766312599182,
-0.06412884593009949,
-0.4123990833759308,
-0.4104084074497223,
0.2088894248008728,
0.27575787901878357,
-0.023576172068715096,
0.9229282140731812,
0.9838477373123169,
-0.43191513419151306,
-0.5703414082527161,
-0.634121298789978,
-0.37627214193344116,
-0.4576844871044159,
0.2822761535644531,
-0.029116785153746605,
-0.6675620675086975,
0.3105532228946686,
-0.054845936596393585,
-0.07031656801700592,
0.047325294464826584,
0.2924671471118927,
0.08052154630422592,
0.8648533821105957,
0.33736371994018555,
-0.36462411284446716,
0.5093242526054382,
-0.18748916685581207,
0.3582478165626526,
-0.4508475959300995,
-0.18048833310604095,
-0.5288610458374023,
-0.08799856156110764,
-0.4463467597961426,
-0.28258267045021057,
0.032971952110528946,
-0.22396327555179596,
-0.27015018463134766,
0.38615942001342773,
-0.5124663710594177,
0.40655481815338135,
0.47238919138908386,
0.3305356204509735,
-0.07091739028692245,
0.04422451928257942,
0.11582079529762268,
0.24472244083881378,
-0.9484056234359741,
-0.6330925226211548,
0.9054290056228638,
0.31426331400871277,
0.4616205096244812,
-0.015459454618394375,
0.2079356163740158,
0.4231380224227905,
0.61275315284729,
-0.41549089550971985,
0.6434966325759888,
-0.1380188763141632,
-0.3543175160884857,
-0.12132751941680908,
-0.3264506161212921,
-1.2641478776931763,
0.577414870262146,
-0.1673383116722107,
-0.9167223572731018,
-0.5515908598899841,
0.010154745541512966,
-0.049752376973629,
0.3141084611415863,
-0.859449028968811,
1.1112339496612549,
-0.03152851387858391,
-0.3777889907360077,
0.03155802562832832,
-0.45330119132995605,
0.2518775463104248,
0.10940910875797272,
0.0037677320651710033,
-0.3633705973625183,
0.13938716053962708,
0.6517645120620728,
-0.023816252127289772,
1.0492148399353027,
-0.17052288353443146,
0.12839360535144806,
0.1961679607629776,
0.005554826930165291,
0.6670876741409302,
0.23347137868404388,
0.193267822265625,
0.03724774345755577,
-0.09399310499429703,
-0.3443552255630493,
-0.585631251335144,
0.6170076727867126,
-0.42109575867652893,
-0.549848198890686,
-0.4474877417087555,
-0.29242581129074097,
-0.04095856472849846,
0.09295129776000977,
0.17271579802036285,
0.42018669843673706,
-0.31534406542778015,
0.3164964020252228,
0.8237561583518982,
-0.3405282497406006,
0.3777824938297272,
0.7485328316688538,
0.09132888913154602,
-0.03102882392704487,
1.0236247777938843,
0.07032517343759537,
0.014878503978252411,
0.4801977872848511,
0.2591455578804016,
-0.40128105878829956,
-0.5107274651527405,
-0.49661242961883545,
-0.024933459237217903,
-0.4915890693664551,
-0.11677148938179016,
-0.5958181023597717,
-0.4352623224258423,
-0.29474419355392456,
0.25329139828681946,
-0.05131789669394493,
0.14715583622455597,
-0.16187696158885956,
0.42326244711875916,
0.15030793845653534,
0.5607345104217529,
0.5064013004302979,
0.39543378353118896,
-0.6193054914474487,
0.08903703838586807,
0.09839453548192978,
0.4513324797153473,
-0.07843896746635437,
-0.6768105030059814,
-0.3150968551635742,
0.07017596811056137,
-0.3180582523345947,
-0.7806690335273743,
0.36785688996315,
0.14799773693084717,
0.6819532513618469,
0.47247451543807983,
0.07634112238883972,
0.5913536548614502,
-0.22290357947349548,
0.8964501619338989,
-0.4535555839538574,
-0.448100209236145,
0.4202204942703247,
-0.17911921441555023,
0.0712800920009613,
0.05278608202934265,
0.42054086923599243,
-0.8163884282112122,
-0.46820104122161865,
-0.8143479228019714,
-0.361560583114624,
0.6568553447723389,
0.5199697613716125,
0.04373406618833542,
-0.02143200859427452,
0.0887332633137703,
0.41915464401245117,
0.2564373016357422,
-0.6790897846221924,
-0.23855353891849518,
0.1474156379699707,
0.1944323182106018,
-0.18878091871738434,
-0.19220849871635437,
0.12309463322162628,
0.1567116528749466,
0.8604922890663147,
0.12254581600427628,
0.33891794085502625,
-0.1961531788110733,
-0.34093788266181946,
0.39920899271965027,
0.37398356199264526,
0.5293146967887878,
0.3797360956668854,
0.1147022694349289,
-0.10689271241426468,
0.30297693610191345,
-0.5497879385948181,
-0.052779655903577805,
0.10027620196342468,
-0.003949290607124567,
0.22614961862564087,
0.3565569519996643,
0.7393057346343994,
0.14221248030662537,
-0.6903883218765259,
0.8455423712730408,
-0.22495043277740479,
-0.1612788885831833,
-0.28326013684272766,
0.21151334047317505,
-0.3270800709724426,
0.29569196701049805,
0.44423753023147583,
-0.18070805072784424,
0.34388497471809387,
-0.13052430748939514,
0.07524681836366653,
0.7970349192619324,
-0.26959946751594543,
-0.22682347893714905,
0.2388116866350174,
0.06865328550338745,
-0.4369592070579529,
0.7325519323348999,
0.04992902651429176,
-0.7862095236778259,
0.755092442035675,
0.5823132991790771,
1.001251459121704,
-0.1468951404094696,
0.21134309470653534,
0.2157466560602188,
0.44278275966644287,
-0.24726977944374084,
-0.2682126462459564,
-0.23917372524738312,
-0.7475012540817261,
-0.1463462859392166,
-0.013518832623958588,
-0.4011244475841522,
0.47702738642692566,
-0.27684494853019714,
0.31871598958969116,
-0.08432018756866455,
0.016679642722010612,
-0.062390733510255814,
0.33711835741996765,
-0.8092864155769348,
0.1581093817949295,
0.22244477272033691,
0.8473323583602905,
-0.9797667264938354,
0.5867428183555603,
0.5122386813163757,
0.14149388670921326,
-0.5585877299308777,
0.017101973295211792,
0.2661170959472656,
-0.5976735353469849,
0.5078943371772766,
0.7622532844543457,
-0.003351270454004407,
-0.2746513783931732,
-0.4138715863227844,
-0.13174240291118622,
1.007277488708496,
0.255776584148407,
-0.1543707698583603,
0.5779839754104614,
0.3227963447570801,
0.6784935593605042,
-0.18831618130207062,
0.8269230723381042,
0.5105399489402771,
0.3347572386264801,
0.05041655898094177,
-0.8356619477272034,
-0.09591671824455261,
-0.5027841925621033,
-0.009898179210722446,
0.22865928709506989,
-0.7526462078094482,
0.546720027923584,
0.6152235269546509,
-0.5517028570175171,
-0.18967577815055847,
0.25073936581611633,
0.14602917432785034,
0.3690250813961029,
0.3166138529777527,
0.2844565510749817,
0.5608794689178467,
-0.3090589642524719,
0.70816969871521,
-0.23569919168949127,
0.16681188344955444,
0.5467618107795715,
-0.158868208527565,
0.6198649406433105,
0.1278216689825058,
-0.166221022605896,
0.17578117549419403,
0.9717638492584229,
-0.08392758667469025,
0.2802296280860901,
0.46247413754463196,
-0.612964391708374,
0.06627168506383896,
0.2202947586774826,
-0.25531205534935,
0.04656311124563217,
0.43281692266464233,
-0.21096086502075195,
-0.1845427006483078,
0.11455746740102768,
0.10353498160839081,
-0.18923039734363556,
-0.1555163413286209,
0.9612221121788025,
-0.39102980494499207,
-0.7502976655960083,
0.5579127073287964,
-0.18249092996120453,
0.7306239604949951,
-0.5224507451057434,
-0.14781640470027924,
-0.2597443759441376,
0.26642295718193054,
-0.04609721526503563,
-0.6786446571350098,
-0.06864067912101746,
0.11023986339569092,
0.38768434524536133,
-0.21100759506225586,
1.1754943132400513,
-0.49237024784088135,
-0.14757674932479858,
0.08127434551715851,
0.2616329491138458,
0.5969911217689514,
-0.44146984815597534,
-0.9331518411636353,
-0.026654697954654694,
-0.34710755944252014,
-0.47798600792884827,
0.5487556457519531,
0.6941890120506287,
0.11727151274681091,
1.0494694709777832,
0.5798132419586182,
-0.04343315213918686,
0.03759872168302536,
-0.1428537368774414,
0.7921157479286194,
-0.13908112049102783,
-0.3711029887199402,
-1.0594054460525513,
0.34715741872787476,
-0.4661516845226288,
-0.14175747334957123,
0.9371445775032043,
0.9241968989372253,
0.9175405502319336,
-0.16712485253810883,
0.8232321739196777,
-0.055126551538705826,
0.564445436000824,
-0.3326413333415985,
0.5135889649391174,
-0.19311180710792542,
0.6624504327774048,
-0.331473171710968,
-0.8197492361068726,
-0.29190537333488464,
0.4862969219684601,
-0.3620455861091614,
0.1897381693124771,
0.650934636592865,
0.9611538648605347,
-0.2143499106168747,
0.13645923137664795,
0.48690420389175415,
-0.17447879910469055,
0.32718831300735474,
0.5617737174034119,
1.099288821220398,
-0.6007851958274841,
0.7135680913925171,
-0.49378207325935364,
-0.21035176515579224,
-0.31630560755729675,
-0.8314632177352905,
-1.5380375385284424,
-0.41493627429008484,
-0.3757839500904083,
-0.3268622159957886,
0.3324911892414093,
0.8711898922920227,
0.7627153992652893,
-0.7627909183502197,
-0.14720971882343292,
0.172601580619812,
-0.057616185396909714,
-0.41742566227912903,
-0.2402016967535019,
0.2918010354042053,
-0.35877910256385803,
-0.7770005464553833,
0.16032373905181885,
0.35833314061164856,
-0.07817710191011429,
0.007444146554917097,
-0.020229550078511238,
0.08244533836841583,
-0.05868490785360336,
0.6245346069335938,
0.3351210057735443,
-0.6365847587585449,
-0.4281676113605499,
0.04691223427653313,
-0.3198440670967102,
0.09696519374847412,
0.7308536767959595,
-0.6857873201370239,
0.06781411170959473,
0.29993003606796265,
0.8213813900947571,
0.40778714418411255,
0.2044776827096939,
0.37395748496055603,
-0.652841329574585,
0.003071614308282733,
0.14985142648220062,
0.15513159334659576,
0.16436181962490082,
-0.35322675108909607,
0.45704740285873413,
0.23598596453666687,
-0.7320599555969238,
-0.6045718193054199,
-0.4389922618865967,
-0.689151406288147,
-0.08055625855922699,
1.1044015884399414,
-0.31153997778892517,
-0.062463246285915375,
-0.41056594252586365,
-0.6155850887298584,
-0.05012185499072075,
-0.5794050693511963,
0.7909694910049438,
0.7581329941749573,
-0.010692078620195389,
-0.5685315728187561,
-0.659248411655426,
0.4543741047382355,
0.16668562591075897,
-0.7101361155509949,
0.12808623909950256,
0.3900461792945862,
0.5419156551361084,
-0.5825987458229065,
0.7432535886764526,
0.24566896259784698,
0.46949639916419983,
-0.1973571479320526,
-0.29830271005630493,
0.11355975270271301,
-0.21357941627502441,
-0.22301538288593292,
0.25662553310394287,
-0.1723620742559433,
-0.4016633927822113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15089v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15089v1
|
AttributionBench: How Hard is Automatic Attribution Evaluation?
| 2024-02-23T04:23:33 | 2024-02-23T04:23:33 |
Yifei Li, Xiang Yue, Zeyi Liao, Huan Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Modern generative search engines enhance the reliability of large language
model (LLM) responses by providing cited evidence. However, evaluating the
answer's attribution, i.e., whether every claim within the generated responses
is fully supported by its cited evidence, remains an open problem. This
verification, traditionally dependent on costly human evaluation, underscores
the urgent need for automatic attribution evaluation methods. To bridge the gap
in the absence of standardized benchmarks for these methods, we present
AttributionBench, a comprehensive benchmark compiled from various existing
attribution datasets. Our extensive experiments on AttributionBench reveal the
challenges of automatic attribution evaluation, even for state-of-the-art LLMs.
Specifically, our findings show that even a fine-tuned GPT-3.5 only achieves
around 80% macro-F1 under a binary classification formulation. A detailed
analysis of more than 300 error cases indicates that a majority of failures
stem from the model's inability to process nuanced information, and the
discrepancy between the information the model has access to and that human
annotators do.
|
[
-0.21948201954364777,
-0.5987226366996765,
0.8538890480995178,
0.2958337366580963,
-0.06729434430599213,
-0.0230367761105299,
-0.21383456885814667,
-0.5489886999130249,
-0.3332200348377228,
0.03050624020397663,
-0.5782411694526672,
-0.2587319612503052,
-0.6502135396003723,
0.24115794897079468,
-0.6293215155601501,
0.7664923071861267,
-0.2619476616382599,
-0.17441768944263458,
-0.4641872048377991,
-0.10990317910909653,
-0.12992851436138153,
-0.40692001581192017,
-0.873110830783844,
-0.5170608758926392,
0.6562342643737793,
0.3539123237133026,
0.5605080127716064,
0.6071444153785706,
0.5854207873344421,
0.33561867475509644,
0.1196650043129921,
-0.07996004819869995,
-0.24903856217861176,
-0.19318556785583496,
-0.2853602170944214,
-0.4657464325428009,
-0.44165417551994324,
0.24949510395526886,
0.5364616513252258,
0.5631567239761353,
-0.24478118121623993,
0.3136855363845825,
0.03237657621502876,
0.6082895994186401,
-0.8988606929779053,
0.18182925879955292,
-0.8104519248008728,
-0.10487022250890732,
-0.2475488930940628,
0.02133968472480774,
-0.35371413826942444,
-0.8575906157493591,
-0.0209353007376194,
-0.36202406883239746,
0.3636224567890167,
-0.08032835274934769,
0.6512998938560486,
0.4483996629714966,
-0.6282739639282227,
-0.47769874334335327,
-0.5822243094444275,
0.6646583080291748,
-0.4848533868789673,
0.08697755634784698,
0.4260448217391968,
0.3909536898136139,
0.022190317511558533,
-0.5863207578659058,
-0.4653331935405731,
-0.3833808898925781,
-0.06508807092905045,
-0.1827945113182068,
-0.3664562702178955,
-0.1633707731962204,
0.14503024518489838,
0.3906261920928955,
-0.5071685314178467,
0.16732157766819,
-0.10860476642847061,
-0.2641933858394623,
0.7144620418548584,
0.11949222534894943,
0.028522204607725143,
-0.45034000277519226,
-0.220919668674469,
-0.27495047450065613,
-0.762935996055603,
-0.2859555184841156,
0.6739102602005005,
-0.01661020889878273,
0.14525362849235535,
0.5372785925865173,
0.07230323553085327,
0.5347998738288879,
-0.10908280313014984,
0.4111196994781494,
0.15479886531829834,
-0.358509361743927,
-0.026156459003686905,
0.23176245391368866,
1.115274429321289,
0.2847447097301483,
0.48268917202949524,
-0.23976430296897888,
-0.44548889994621277,
0.14621761441230774,
0.4385037124156952,
-0.5546470880508423,
-0.26487916707992554,
0.011092076078057289,
-0.1190933808684349,
-0.6669420599937439,
0.19531042873859406,
-0.37098148465156555,
-0.36526063084602356,
0.046043530106544495,
0.46605008840560913,
-0.07895777374505997,
-0.15082913637161255,
-0.12714135646820068,
-0.027896787971258163,
0.22887161374092102,
0.44167560338974,
-0.5640891194343567,
0.31636732816696167,
0.5129745006561279,
0.9415490627288818,
-0.44211992621421814,
-0.12520046532154083,
-0.4436867833137512,
0.12108828872442245,
-0.34272274374961853,
1.09332275390625,
-0.34536027908325195,
-0.2854299247264862,
-0.17138077318668365,
0.14026731252670288,
-0.03961040824651718,
-0.7385233044624329,
0.5878531336784363,
-0.47741207480430603,
0.0021761732641607523,
-0.2913796007633209,
-0.5237236022949219,
0.015944289043545723,
0.20249412953853607,
-0.8840432167053223,
0.7591376304626465,
0.19390618801116943,
-0.4907661974430084,
0.419357031583786,
-0.7275626063346863,
-0.41818660497665405,
-0.0845385268330574,
-0.31088772416114807,
-0.47704488039016724,
0.27266818284988403,
0.15939007699489594,
0.18203423917293549,
-0.5767539143562317,
0.4563809633255005,
-0.4230991303920746,
-0.33122652769088745,
0.4543074667453766,
-0.812092661857605,
1.0161186456680298,
0.05710521712899208,
-0.6005922555923462,
0.12440747022628784,
-0.8449824452400208,
0.018659908324480057,
0.3343059718608856,
-0.49647757411003113,
-0.12628388404846191,
0.009106291458010674,
0.24639233946800232,
-0.008586488664150238,
-0.031480368226766586,
-0.4995046854019165,
0.13122868537902832,
-0.1897137314081192,
0.37695398926734924,
1.1157747507095337,
-0.348190039396286,
0.2589951157569885,
-0.14011241495609283,
0.6938523650169373,
-0.4028041362762451,
-0.16127879917621613,
0.17717808485031128,
-0.22493323683738708,
-0.5176575183868408,
-0.02788628078997135,
0.4543726146221161,
0.5585587620735168,
-0.37641310691833496,
0.5940478444099426,
-0.38108718395233154,
-0.7014507055282593,
-0.5221149325370789,
0.3145752251148224,
0.552007257938385,
0.45270445942878723,
0.17783710360527039,
-0.5266566276550293,
-0.3751460909843445,
-1.0586782693862915,
-0.5136299133300781,
-0.35721224546432495,
-0.39079514145851135,
0.29963284730911255,
0.6206191778182983,
-0.10687463730573654,
1.0133858919143677,
-0.4674893021583557,
-0.19868651032447815,
-0.040828291326761246,
0.7244622111320496,
-0.17122294008731842,
0.41534945368766785,
0.41080471873283386,
-0.5429345965385437,
-0.5732516050338745,
-0.3415148854255676,
-0.8969957232475281,
-0.34516069293022156,
0.12184657901525497,
0.2026718705892563,
0.32003986835479736,
0.5779163837432861,
-0.5882925391197205,
0.28279778361320496,
0.4672982096672058,
-0.24389952421188354,
0.7939833402633667,
0.015989670529961586,
0.13735847175121307,
-0.5050919055938721,
0.3358737826347351,
0.0014515415532514453,
-0.4693641662597656,
-0.07246216386556625,
-0.04363582283258438,
0.2687229812145233,
-0.028752433136105537,
-0.4639109671115875,
0.6573793888092041,
-0.4052993953227997,
-0.17624983191490173,
-0.2983131408691406,
0.032230835407972336,
-0.1252153217792511,
0.24231642484664917,
-0.25304630398750305,
0.9074127078056335,
0.17426259815692902,
-0.31252506375312805,
1.042631983757019,
0.118004709482193,
-0.5756676197052002,
0.5908077359199524,
-0.842130720615387,
0.27309176325798035,
0.0646081417798996,
0.681615948677063,
-1.0832901000976562,
-0.5450300574302673,
0.10319312661886215,
-0.34066885709762573,
0.203069269657135,
-0.13148953020572662,
-0.8326932191848755,
-0.29334932565689087,
-0.3773361146450043,
0.5711449384689331,
0.21778666973114014,
-0.4675194025039673,
0.4790697991847992,
0.016672570258378983,
-0.2703631818294525,
-0.3030814826488495,
-0.6490463018417358,
0.33797287940979004,
-0.2871014475822449,
-0.6422105431556702,
0.34450703859329224,
0.13599485158920288,
-0.3594691753387451,
0.17386162281036377,
-0.14947086572647095,
0.010379083454608917,
0.25597047805786133,
0.03668122738599777,
0.02603871561586857,
-0.1829037219285965,
0.15221910178661346,
-0.5644395351409912,
-0.303892582654953,
0.4526073634624481,
0.22390452027320862,
0.3786831200122833,
-0.39480605721473694,
-0.7892022132873535,
-0.30935367941856384,
0.22159914672374725,
0.3499632477760315,
0.021915996447205544,
0.5324550867080688,
0.4718857407569885,
-0.322602242231369,
0.17229673266410828,
-0.7670276761054993,
-0.12213335186243057,
-0.4854906499385834,
0.29700931906700134,
-0.13676027953624725,
-0.4722706377506256,
0.5481866002082825,
0.13477273285388947,
-0.17151717841625214,
0.8579930067062378,
0.5061222314834595,
0.06209004670381546,
1.044967770576477,
0.5686222910881042,
-0.21485933661460876,
0.2823454737663269,
0.22276756167411804,
-0.0025841386523097754,
-0.40842849016189575,
0.07856358587741852,
-0.5459000468254089,
-0.20543178915977478,
-0.4733388423919678,
-0.2156035602092743,
0.4060231149196625,
-0.21566244959831238,
-0.1928124576807022,
0.22316642105579376,
-0.24793551862239838,
0.627457320690155,
0.5251056551933289,
0.08612032979726791,
0.5596473813056946,
0.004942774772644043,
0.3577735424041748,
0.14336349070072174,
-0.4233786463737488,
-0.5507001280784607,
1.1669286489486694,
0.18546544015407562,
0.883909285068512,
0.3491354286670685,
0.4917949140071869,
0.460390567779541,
0.6058739423751831,
-0.7263368368148804,
0.47042569518089294,
-0.031999483704566956,
-0.9286280870437622,
-0.32402461767196655,
-0.5180755257606506,
-0.6303231716156006,
-0.02267143316566944,
0.06117332726716995,
-0.7197063565254211,
0.0572916679084301,
0.36968794465065,
-0.42137444019317627,
0.09181971848011017,
-0.8367469310760498,
1.1008210182189941,
-0.3334082067012787,
-0.580309271812439,
-0.1158655658364296,
-0.5600107312202454,
0.43520644307136536,
-0.4910852015018463,
0.11692990362644196,
-0.17829200625419617,
0.0866595208644867,
0.9323605298995972,
-0.37917909026145935,
0.7176174521446228,
-0.24366077780723572,
-0.44482579827308655,
0.30253031849861145,
0.04249066486954689,
0.8319097757339478,
-0.06120947748422623,
-0.151841402053833,
-0.13254761695861816,
-0.28012484312057495,
-0.2214536815881729,
-0.6018785834312439,
0.6308578848838806,
-0.4834531247615814,
-0.39218422770500183,
-0.5227211713790894,
-0.21699154376983643,
-0.3577418923377991,
0.07492604106664658,
0.4033951163291931,
0.16502907872200012,
-0.44830214977264404,
0.2797877788543701,
0.4996594488620758,
-0.2863152027130127,
0.1559741050004959,
0.47322726249694824,
0.12144047021865845,
-0.16160838305950165,
0.9608582854270935,
-0.154205322265625,
0.24572961032390594,
-0.2422783076763153,
0.14948776364326477,
-0.35443076491355896,
-0.28684186935424805,
-0.5341845750808716,
0.12667571008205414,
-0.9977309703826904,
-0.3186315894126892,
-0.46821001172065735,
-0.11856066435575485,
-0.25474977493286133,
-0.27438580989837646,
-0.6590232253074646,
-0.4199974834918976,
-0.078121118247509,
-0.1634676158428192,
0.2581869661808014,
0.7318342924118042,
-0.12225840985774994,
0.34087061882019043,
-0.6638138890266418,
0.29156720638275146,
0.46432241797447205,
0.5751199722290039,
-0.012006484903395176,
-0.4128655195236206,
-0.11905886232852936,
-0.20233149826526642,
-0.4083447754383087,
-0.7636721134185791,
-0.03798387572169304,
0.3489619493484497,
0.40604525804519653,
0.19974812865257263,
-0.13394568860530853,
0.7633670568466187,
-0.4525013267993927,
0.5839940905570984,
0.09015730023384094,
-0.8487582802772522,
0.579814612865448,
-0.2980325520038605,
0.295419842004776,
0.7102627754211426,
0.4301043748855591,
-0.20013941824436188,
-0.44439902901649475,
-0.8088181018829346,
-1.1708264350891113,
0.763666570186615,
0.2175927460193634,
-0.05830325186252594,
0.1060907170176506,
0.27852943539619446,
-0.016965074464678764,
0.08595293760299683,
-0.839328944683075,
-0.029610447585582733,
0.03753393515944481,
-0.36586397886276245,
-0.37603917717933655,
-0.20867377519607544,
-0.2332037091255188,
-0.3468029797077179,
0.5809741020202637,
-0.20381321012973785,
0.3335335850715637,
-0.03970362991094589,
-0.5261973142623901,
-0.4840133786201477,
0.3018193244934082,
0.34682223200798035,
0.7558267116546631,
-0.38325151801109314,
0.23666328191757202,
0.1472572684288025,
-0.07260170578956604,
0.4081438481807709,
0.36729252338409424,
0.11434241384267807,
-0.00902556348592043,
0.6514337062835693,
0.5370252132415771,
0.23710498213768005,
-0.673941433429718,
0.7729554772377014,
-0.0845903754234314,
-0.2731079161167145,
-0.5811182856559753,
0.03963075578212738,
0.13118992745876312,
0.05632951110601425,
0.5537487864494324,
-0.24172256886959076,
0.26046040654182434,
-0.5694551467895508,
0.28627172112464905,
0.4727841913700104,
-0.290481299161911,
-0.1650957316160202,
0.7331739068031311,
0.14924898743629456,
0.13456450402736664,
0.7442472577095032,
-0.056946106255054474,
-0.5315163731575012,
0.6438390016555786,
0.29029831290245056,
1.1980278491973877,
-0.17286787927150726,
-0.07127749174833298,
0.21488073468208313,
0.3076614439487457,
-0.2838706970214844,
-0.23355992138385773,
0.054569270461797714,
-0.46237313747406006,
-0.5000834465026855,
-0.6388577818870544,
-0.505894124507904,
0.023807255551218987,
-0.49117350578308105,
0.0028883095365017653,
-0.2910829484462738,
-0.15107055008411407,
0.1687021702528,
-0.2654396593570709,
-0.6797342896461487,
0.12910357117652893,
0.14871469140052795,
0.7311089634895325,
-0.9961639046669006,
0.4523973762989044,
0.6566746234893799,
-0.3344547152519226,
-0.5350699424743652,
-0.09252700954675674,
0.37729936838150024,
-0.917527437210083,
0.7872502207756042,
0.30290335416793823,
-0.3269544839859009,
0.09261878579854965,
-0.802515983581543,
-0.6369043588638306,
0.8889197707176208,
0.6303034424781799,
-0.34013405442237854,
-0.21267777681350708,
0.12515437602996826,
0.2690214514732361,
-0.146729975938797,
0.3448292016983032,
0.7451016902923584,
0.6642218828201294,
0.015447931364178658,
-1.1834042072296143,
0.32574689388275146,
-0.14193588495254517,
-0.18574777245521545,
-0.04123272746801376,
-0.3403235077857971,
0.5755050778388977,
-0.02397865243256092,
-0.15605947375297546,
-0.23117509484291077,
0.3929348587989807,
0.04108114540576935,
0.03688977286219597,
0.8346765637397766,
0.5223066210746765,
0.5314778089523315,
-0.20154593884944916,
1.030535101890564,
0.13643702864646912,
0.44840553402900696,
1.1435364484786987,
-0.1289101392030716,
0.8027533292770386,
0.4052334129810333,
-0.4903081953525543,
0.5075531005859375,
0.6371785402297974,
-0.35691139101982117,
0.352604478597641,
0.4069899916648865,
-0.3158470094203949,
-0.2503136992454529,
0.024899687618017197,
-0.055918317288160324,
0.4007026255130768,
0.14769040048122406,
-0.432614266872406,
-0.42598623037338257,
-0.16609898209571838,
-0.12579360604286194,
-0.22318127751350403,
-0.04045458510518074,
0.9286837577819824,
0.11980760097503662,
-0.6202402114868164,
0.7305518984794617,
0.03601376339793205,
0.6968323588371277,
-0.6633523106575012,
0.1612040251493454,
-0.08527584373950958,
0.3187611401081085,
-0.4930632710456848,
-0.6492100358009338,
0.5126835107803345,
0.3823397755622864,
-0.028302080929279327,
-0.24845406413078308,
0.7494983077049255,
-0.08137446641921997,
-0.5239142179489136,
0.1466996669769287,
0.3959725797176361,
0.19128605723381042,
-0.6174345016479492,
-0.581089437007904,
0.12433964759111404,
-0.06417867541313171,
-0.5701871514320374,
0.11693745851516724,
0.32106995582580566,
-0.03356034308671951,
0.777048647403717,
0.368075966835022,
-0.020267045125365257,
-0.03142903372645378,
-0.11841119825839996,
0.8128824830055237,
-0.7980258464813232,
-0.004177634138613939,
-1.0830296277999878,
0.3772972822189331,
-0.05666211247444153,
0.0763360857963562,
0.6046606302261353,
0.48283809423446655,
0.7807987332344055,
0.014189006760716438,
1.0290026664733887,
-0.2338646650314331,
0.31255030632019043,
-0.4018615782260895,
0.6639425158500671,
-0.9185628294944763,
0.18658769130706787,
-0.36790159344673157,
-1.0476285219192505,
-0.30897578597068787,
0.7273553609848022,
-0.24567924439907074,
0.14928081631660461,
0.6696150302886963,
0.5401069521903992,
-0.31044718623161316,
-0.18937112390995026,
-0.08611773699522018,
0.06553389132022858,
0.48778408765792847,
0.4637313783168793,
0.6416625380516052,
-0.3687165379524231,
0.9263410568237305,
0.02053460106253624,
-0.2989369034767151,
-0.47777697443962097,
-1.2294819355010986,
-0.36596593260765076,
-0.2474435567855835,
-0.42286446690559387,
-0.2240111231803894,
0.14729978144168854,
0.873995304107666,
0.258771151304245,
-0.7446385025978088,
-0.24204835295677185,
-0.35042035579681396,
-0.1181500256061554,
0.0192116629332304,
-0.2676222622394562,
0.3619585633277893,
-0.3767091631889343,
-0.5019754767417908,
0.3182391822338104,
-0.11641460657119751,
0.12756487727165222,
-0.4321342706680298,
0.12426929175853729,
0.05434322729706764,
-0.22141523659229279,
0.42540988326072693,
0.2647970914840698,
-0.6243084073066711,
-0.3485555946826935,
-0.42125144600868225,
-0.37522828578948975,
0.1091177836060524,
0.8124818205833435,
-0.6429808139801025,
0.2652767598628998,
0.17930381000041962,
0.6462516784667969,
0.4052485525608063,
0.14821234345436096,
1.0372333526611328,
-0.6502302289009094,
-0.21798531711101532,
0.17147095501422882,
0.1486063003540039,
0.5475630760192871,
-0.11578671634197235,
0.6286512613296509,
0.2951529920101166,
-0.6460601091384888,
-0.8716838359832764,
0.19204045832157135,
-0.6927231550216675,
-0.08172216266393661,
1.1793402433395386,
-0.08923043310642242,
-0.24740280210971832,
-0.08363118767738342,
0.11377907544374466,
0.267560750246048,
-0.3251340389251709,
0.844616174697876,
1.1675986051559448,
0.030442265793681145,
-0.0564628541469574,
-0.7743148803710938,
0.6752368211746216,
0.526850163936615,
-0.662469208240509,
0.5731028318405151,
0.6356852054595947,
0.4047336280345917,
0.1473352313041687,
0.6839854717254639,
-0.11389260739088058,
0.31537845730781555,
-0.09199567139148712,
0.11312610656023026,
0.04577263444662094,
-0.10944103449583054,
-0.3626853823661804,
-0.008871880359947681,
0.40204763412475586,
0.28817054629325867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15083v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15083v1
|
Hands-Free VR
| 2024-02-23T04:02:23 | 2024-02-23T04:02:23 |
Jorge Askur Vazquez Fernandez, Jae Joong Lee, Santiago Andrés Serrano Vacca, Alejandra Magana, Bedrich Benes, Voicu Popescu
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The paper introduces Hands-Free VR, a voice-based natural-language interface
for VR. The user gives a command using their voice, the speech audio data is
converted to text using a speech-to-text deep learning model that is fine-tuned
for robustness to word phonetic similarity and to spoken English accents, and
the text is mapped to an executable VR command using a large language model
that is robust to natural language diversity. Hands-Free VR was evaluated in a
controlled within-subjects study (N = 22) that asked participants to find
specific objects and to place them in various configurations. In the control
condition participants used a conventional VR user interface to grab, carry,
and position the objects using the handheld controllers. In the experimental
condition participants used Hands-Free VR. The results confirm that: (1)
Hands-Free VR is robust to spoken English accents, as for 20 of our
participants English was not their first language, and to word phonetic
similarity, correctly transcribing the voice command 96.71% of the time; (2)
Hands-Free VR is robust to natural language diversity, correctly mapping the
transcribed command to an executable command in 97.83% of the time; (3)
Hands-Free VR had a significant efficiency advantage over the conventional VR
interface in terms of task completion time, total viewpoint translation, total
view direction rotation, and total left and right hand translations; (4)
Hands-Free VR received high user preference ratings in terms of ease of use,
intuitiveness, ergonomics, reliability, and desirability.
|
[
-0.4008142650127411,
-0.6512278318405151,
0.4670901894569397,
0.15259234607219696,
-0.4255104064941406,
-0.005396279972046614,
-0.3486231863498688,
-0.5110618472099304,
0.5205836296081543,
0.5151427984237671,
-0.40810924768447876,
-0.511349618434906,
-0.5267636775970459,
0.01977865770459175,
-0.1607065051794052,
0.5928880572319031,
0.04102975130081177,
-0.031014928594231606,
-0.6217213273048401,
-0.2800934314727783,
-0.5091762542724609,
-0.6944894790649414,
-0.2569381594657898,
-0.21429625153541565,
0.2855691611766815,
0.5191361904144287,
1.0157623291015625,
0.4779985845088959,
0.3784578740596771,
0.19402623176574707,
0.05476014316082001,
0.23111003637313843,
-0.2087239921092987,
-0.13382352888584137,
0.14349187910556793,
-0.193193718791008,
-0.5847934484481812,
-0.09283603727817535,
0.2926468551158905,
0.4249955713748932,
-0.38967975974082947,
0.07325753569602966,
0.22644206881523132,
0.5938161015510559,
-0.5240398049354553,
-0.1197531446814537,
-0.04198816791176796,
0.13005046546459198,
0.025476451963186264,
-0.09208962321281433,
-0.25346213579177856,
-0.08225896209478378,
0.2816038429737091,
-0.9560343623161316,
0.20098988711833954,
-0.10341542959213257,
0.5734437704086304,
0.5105723738670349,
-0.3842272162437439,
-0.10885526984930038,
-1.12559175491333,
0.9064748883247375,
-0.5758102536201477,
0.9053483009338379,
0.5187309980392456,
0.27596598863601685,
-0.07374220341444016,
-0.27843934297561646,
-0.9089116454124451,
-0.6288321018218994,
0.3344741463661194,
0.3088700771331787,
-0.21080277860164642,
0.4372501075267792,
0.2546651363372803,
0.44085708260536194,
-0.6143888235092163,
0.23949043452739716,
-0.33335527777671814,
-0.018825409933924675,
0.6001506447792053,
0.023596618324518204,
0.7607637643814087,
-0.1655316799879074,
-0.5109713673591614,
-0.31606200337409973,
-0.3878631591796875,
0.46402233839035034,
0.24339091777801514,
0.5237025618553162,
-0.7073598504066467,
0.8527359962463379,
-0.26913145184516907,
0.6183604001998901,
-0.12391497194766998,
-0.4777810573577881,
0.32249748706817627,
-0.2114269882440567,
-0.4078407883644104,
0.08782130479812622,
0.8677135109901428,
0.8242210745811462,
0.18949684500694275,
-0.3900160491466522,
0.13536548614501953,
-0.09108303487300873,
0.4446088671684265,
-0.6269627809524536,
0.1053357869386673,
0.3858846127986908,
-0.6419894099235535,
-0.16026975214481354,
-0.16230738162994385,
-0.5464449524879456,
-0.4382113814353943,
-0.6367951035499573,
0.27601227164268494,
-0.3304353356361389,
-0.8447151780128479,
0.18886920809745789,
-0.30318307876586914,
0.5052794218063354,
0.6553831696510315,
-0.8415220379829407,
0.5865395665168762,
0.4591938555240631,
0.9588281512260437,
-0.7830638885498047,
-0.03946777805685997,
-0.5113614797592163,
0.08717543631792068,
-0.2456221580505371,
0.3748660385608673,
-0.3181776702404022,
-1.1913061141967773,
-0.3399898409843445,
-0.17774513363838196,
0.3578174412250519,
-0.8193255066871643,
0.47855791449546814,
0.17759616672992706,
0.2975445091724396,
-0.32218578457832336,
-0.3873428404331207,
-0.25162336230278015,
0.05202696472406387,
-0.6915794014930725,
1.0876851081848145,
-0.0755583867430687,
-0.43810245394706726,
0.3930475413799286,
-0.5114379525184631,
-0.4143150746822357,
0.2925598919391632,
-0.12611934542655945,
-0.04373538866639137,
0.024564852938055992,
0.1262526661157608,
0.3644479513168335,
0.03501199558377266,
0.03870945796370506,
-0.2197587639093399,
-0.3702157437801361,
-0.13048164546489716,
-0.3607845902442932,
1.0128331184387207,
0.1847534328699112,
-0.559140145778656,
-0.03749047592282295,
-0.6491795182228088,
-0.24533948302268982,
-0.32540732622146606,
-0.09620246291160583,
-0.43370890617370605,
0.2620137333869934,
0.07830002903938293,
0.2109183669090271,
0.06481918692588806,
-0.7487696409225464,
0.04553532972931862,
-0.31344547867774963,
-0.04237852618098259,
0.04544611647725105,
-0.17732392251491547,
0.8313382863998413,
-0.117470383644104,
0.7190612554550171,
0.07740585505962372,
0.31637927889823914,
0.27932536602020264,
-0.8045827150344849,
-0.5732603073120117,
-0.5139251351356506,
-0.28417935967445374,
1.119229793548584,
-1.007230281829834,
0.4632967412471771,
-0.22840484976768494,
-0.39972758293151855,
-0.6956048011779785,
0.1502111405134201,
0.2546067535877228,
0.5274451971054077,
0.5212046504020691,
-0.49962958693504333,
-0.22795413434505463,
-0.702888548374176,
-0.13959939777851105,
-0.2205652892589569,
-0.3761523365974426,
0.6117541790008545,
-0.0029646679759025574,
-0.10864871740341187,
0.8805935978889465,
-0.10346240550279617,
-0.2920342683792114,
-0.21039289236068726,
0.06474081426858902,
-0.2735147178173065,
0.3421129286289215,
0.4433232545852661,
-0.7286919355392456,
-0.25806185603141785,
0.27328506112098694,
-0.9546418190002441,
0.3069610595703125,
-0.110341377556324,
0.3283177614212036,
0.06700501590967178,
0.4624495208263397,
-0.8296812772750854,
0.7827239632606506,
0.3441023528575897,
0.007070908322930336,
0.2059357911348343,
-0.6203669309616089,
0.1994994580745697,
-1.0632928609848022,
-0.09007382392883301,
-0.06835486739873886,
-0.2002313882112503,
-0.7868015170097351,
0.08895410597324371,
-0.17888455092906952,
-0.27531978487968445,
-0.8165616393089294,
0.6779440641403198,
-0.4145793914794922,
-0.03177140653133392,
-0.5120506882667542,
0.35058674216270447,
-0.011940903961658478,
0.3954523801803589,
0.4874175786972046,
0.7329896092414856,
0.4868752360343933,
-0.764305591583252,
0.5065051317214966,
0.2547730803489685,
-0.3038272559642792,
0.6289083361625671,
-0.6182374358177185,
0.37488627433776855,
-0.21023918688297272,
-0.19481289386749268,
-0.9838927984237671,
0.11606919020414352,
0.14737758040428162,
-0.6903205513954163,
-0.06952958554029465,
0.21164052188396454,
-0.169350266456604,
-0.42001911997795105,
-0.22085337340831757,
0.15513741970062256,
0.5306298732757568,
-0.34036004543304443,
0.9596739411354065,
0.3730773329734802,
-0.12538784742355347,
-0.5924578905105591,
-0.7846963405609131,
0.21715816855430603,
-0.203206405043602,
-0.19044052064418793,
0.18379653990268707,
-0.22938814759254456,
-0.449250191450119,
-0.08256575465202332,
-0.010962235741317272,
-0.08336556702852249,
0.04902327060699463,
0.6962567567825317,
0.21864309906959534,
0.15252994000911713,
-0.15821409225463867,
0.16210177540779114,
0.03158755972981453,
-0.04859009385108948,
0.1899908035993576,
0.01435188390314579,
0.13391388952732086,
-0.033847540616989136,
-0.6794920563697815,
0.5253787040710449,
0.8776352405548096,
-0.26768040657043457,
0.27008846402168274,
0.5707406997680664,
-0.38303980231285095,
0.04281838610768318,
-0.5544424057006836,
-0.023232832551002502,
-0.45829659700393677,
0.15135140717029572,
-0.2670709788799286,
-0.9495282173156738,
0.35730674862861633,
0.19892115890979767,
0.19735205173492432,
-0.23797303438186646,
0.5708562135696411,
-0.20299667119979858,
0.7177332043647766,
0.7828026413917542,
0.0711294636130333,
0.32742074131965637,
0.09935172647237778,
0.3300761282444,
-0.5805380344390869,
-0.40897315740585327,
-0.3930017650127411,
-0.35737156867980957,
-0.523488461971283,
-0.586652934551239,
0.29392319917678833,
-0.2410564422607422,
0.06877221167087555,
0.4750162363052368,
-0.7642456293106079,
0.2077702283859253,
1.0544211864471436,
0.19785399734973907,
0.31285497546195984,
-0.006286208517849445,
-0.16948531568050385,
-0.22031967341899872,
-0.20000693202018738,
-0.47133731842041016,
0.9095726609230042,
0.13199006021022797,
0.4601776897907257,
0.0005137679981999099,
0.7669182419776917,
0.38896602392196655,
-0.01084426324814558,
-1.052740216255188,
0.7311741709709167,
-0.20335383713245392,
-0.5153558254241943,
-0.4759610593318939,
-0.1787000149488449,
-0.5575985312461853,
-0.008373229764401913,
-0.4169394075870514,
-0.6123676896095276,
0.3570634424686432,
0.14619114995002747,
-0.7925987243652344,
0.56647789478302,
-0.9524973630905151,
0.3994346261024475,
-0.5889857411384583,
-0.47004222869873047,
-0.15460041165351868,
-0.7780963182449341,
-0.03679459169507027,
0.3202150762081146,
0.14780838787555695,
-0.15454964339733124,
0.11864475905895233,
0.6574898958206177,
-0.08769571036100388,
0.7343202829360962,
-0.6046102643013,
0.037535566836595535,
0.355095773935318,
0.2945902645587921,
0.06983903795480728,
-0.11721514910459518,
0.05756927654147148,
0.47269386053085327,
-0.04567341133952141,
-0.06679230183362961,
-0.6032249331474304,
0.5652156472206116,
-0.989812433719635,
-0.3510998785495758,
-0.16191017627716064,
-0.4902688264846802,
-0.10998028516769409,
0.5254256725311279,
0.36608970165252686,
0.2133810967206955,
-0.632088840007782,
0.22363309562206268,
0.5093637704849243,
-0.8189977407455444,
0.49998265504837036,
0.39099952578544617,
-0.3652419447898865,
-0.6054243445396423,
0.9467722773551941,
0.2340010404586792,
0.05206546559929848,
0.674444854259491,
0.1938171088695526,
-0.32596710324287415,
-0.328033447265625,
-0.5644794702529907,
0.026989953592419624,
-0.001517759170383215,
0.1760881245136261,
-0.7463880777359009,
0.12275716662406921,
-0.3239347040653229,
-0.33478549122810364,
-0.5255226492881775,
-0.5387548208236694,
-0.46912357211112976,
-0.6398589611053467,
0.33569690585136414,
0.6471173763275146,
0.010408751666545868,
0.40228232741355896,
-0.38706716895103455,
1.1406503915786743,
0.7401314377784729,
0.24793019890785217,
-0.14418506622314453,
-0.06731767952442169,
-0.0990324541926384,
0.31871628761291504,
-0.2751576900482178,
-0.44762521982192993,
0.5187288522720337,
-0.11097877472639084,
0.4094582200050354,
0.45494499802589417,
0.27948519587516785,
0.5598031878471375,
-0.567253828048706,
1.4674948453903198,
0.44412362575531006,
-0.8356230854988098,
0.3416714072227478,
-0.3901272118091583,
0.33438315987586975,
0.6149471402168274,
0.13770344853401184,
-0.4067271649837494,
-0.2807476818561554,
-0.5375220775604248,
-0.9759247303009033,
0.40148523449897766,
0.07900301367044449,
0.37490999698638916,
0.10260958224534988,
0.21002425253391266,
0.3425810635089874,
0.5072739124298096,
-0.5218368768692017,
-0.5095129013061523,
-0.6806340217590332,
-0.04624045267701149,
-0.17153401672840118,
-0.28330671787261963,
0.10144314914941788,
-0.8238089680671692,
0.2565590739250183,
0.3061850070953369,
0.5482911467552185,
0.29708144068717957,
0.17170876264572144,
0.015601028688251972,
0.11569768190383911,
0.896613359451294,
0.35145145654678345,
-0.3567368686199188,
0.11713170260190964,
0.2293682098388672,
-0.7566453218460083,
0.09426582604646683,
-0.10992500185966492,
-0.15950244665145874,
0.26434969902038574,
-0.25359874963760376,
1.1263580322265625,
-0.04434311017394066,
-0.49079984426498413,
0.7429705858230591,
-0.20294198393821716,
-0.556094229221344,
-0.49903348088264465,
-0.1485619693994522,
0.10814252495765686,
0.028063690289855003,
0.14978381991386414,
0.015339063480496407,
0.3599094748497009,
0.034705452620983124,
0.07475114613771439,
0.6478833556175232,
-0.5825453996658325,
-0.2673555314540863,
1.1763440370559692,
0.5490845441818237,
-0.732235312461853,
0.6510539054870605,
0.03513310104608536,
0.17152740061283112,
0.20264661312103271,
0.25274068117141724,
1.4113022089004517,
-0.488700807094574,
0.39737480878829956,
0.31984105706214905,
0.49927952885627747,
-0.13346566259860992,
0.41009455919265747,
-0.6365392804145813,
-0.7647048830986023,
-0.3475894033908844,
-0.12700164318084717,
-1.1171488761901855,
0.11095920950174332,
-1.0053726434707642,
0.36997687816619873,
-0.36360716819763184,
-0.2989857792854309,
-0.4750530421733856,
-0.30321088433265686,
-0.6465779542922974,
0.31327196955680847,
0.7104983925819397,
0.7936490774154663,
-0.6296201348304749,
0.7293163537979126,
0.6339329481124878,
-0.11269918829202652,
-0.8697465062141418,
-0.15547311305999756,
-0.025233319029211998,
-0.4267650544643402,
0.21029119193553925,
0.1472177505493164,
-0.6979963183403015,
-0.22273637354373932,
-0.5663748383522034,
-0.5579536557197571,
0.9420682787895203,
0.5428993701934814,
-0.5086756944656372,
-0.2780512869358063,
0.3341713845729828,
0.4894810914993286,
0.16581135988235474,
0.289187490940094,
0.1714959591627121,
0.22929948568344116,
-0.20568864047527313,
-1.3257499933242798,
-0.3850475251674652,
-0.5017079710960388,
0.06677274405956268,
-0.02888490818440914,
-0.6900943517684937,
0.36924436688423157,
-0.1911761611700058,
0.0707792267203331,
-0.1284215897321701,
0.9948821663856506,
-0.0015872407238930464,
0.5596202611923218,
0.4320099651813507,
0.6610690951347351,
0.8403846025466919,
-0.02358482964336872,
0.9699566960334778,
-0.16785642504692078,
-0.031798046082258224,
0.8701333403587341,
-0.5424090027809143,
1.0415008068084717,
0.7383133769035339,
0.004089209716767073,
0.5315287113189697,
0.015216086991131306,
0.46438291668891907,
0.6896561980247498,
-0.08346405625343323,
-0.6303672194480896,
-0.24960920214653015,
0.014187251217663288,
-0.23895935714244843,
0.7557039856910706,
0.20306627452373505,
0.11829592287540436,
0.07497528195381165,
0.8383439183235168,
-0.03408822789788246,
0.0014588709454983473,
-0.0676560327410698,
0.9173018336296082,
0.24916508793830872,
-0.4501032829284668,
0.39786526560783386,
-0.31447580456733704,
0.899541437625885,
-0.5374144315719604,
-0.1694028228521347,
-0.07337058335542679,
0.04348791390657425,
-0.17610885202884674,
-0.5501177310943604,
0.05806175246834755,
0.12204793840646744,
-0.21637091040611267,
-0.6010237336158752,
0.5810508131980896,
-0.4479825496673584,
-0.35982054471969604,
0.3887444734573364,
0.5636401176452637,
0.3315972089767456,
-0.040033575147390366,
-0.39804431796073914,
-0.2024521678686142,
0.068426713347435,
-0.18649917840957642,
0.053047146648168564,
0.24617433547973633,
-0.019687576219439507,
0.7207791805267334,
0.4570668637752533,
0.3123186230659485,
0.12324391305446625,
-0.21826985478401184,
0.459433913230896,
-0.7502995133399963,
-0.7633114457130432,
-0.5679023265838623,
0.6766065955162048,
0.07882200181484222,
-0.4059353172779083,
0.9346882700920105,
0.7383200526237488,
0.8905255794525146,
-0.22561679780483246,
1.0426865816116333,
0.008757938630878925,
1.0035516023635864,
-0.14766418933868408,
0.7228981256484985,
-0.7042955160140991,
-0.3106320798397064,
-0.4562120735645294,
-0.5153591632843018,
-0.41535720229148865,
0.7670584917068481,
-0.1839861422777176,
-0.12863650918006897,
0.3913693130016327,
0.5740271806716919,
-0.09608682990074158,
-0.017856722697615623,
0.5169320106506348,
-0.47771039605140686,
0.2645338773727417,
0.17567552626132965,
0.4066838324069977,
-0.2567332684993744,
0.22225503623485565,
-0.6153769493103027,
-0.40532055497169495,
-0.1584063470363617,
-0.9016469717025757,
-0.7083552479743958,
-0.45018890500068665,
-0.4499765634536743,
-0.3101303279399872,
-0.17666833102703094,
1.163008689880371,
0.7002270817756653,
-0.6721233129501343,
-0.7143194675445557,
-0.0613958016037941,
-0.19959452748298645,
-0.6108802556991577,
-0.20660153031349182,
0.07208078354597092,
0.4491976499557495,
-0.8713852167129517,
0.9403180480003357,
0.3429962992668152,
0.2089010775089264,
0.046928998082876205,
-0.4126368463039398,
0.2097853422164917,
-0.168731227517128,
0.8220313787460327,
0.6631051898002625,
-0.7265524864196777,
-0.24870914220809937,
0.6042393445968628,
-0.11518242955207825,
0.14668068289756775,
0.6555525660514832,
-0.774688720703125,
1.0791493654251099,
0.321893572807312,
0.5326771140098572,
0.5911039710044861,
0.20751821994781494,
0.769058108329773,
-0.7563292980194092,
0.6846561431884766,
0.15838570892810822,
-0.07998654991388321,
0.5962333679199219,
-0.3912941515445709,
0.060269154608249664,
0.07921654731035233,
-0.4433962404727936,
-0.8569712042808533,
-0.06969387829303741,
-1.7619192600250244,
0.11578205972909927,
1.3558579683303833,
0.34295421838760376,
-0.05859527364373207,
-0.27769091725349426,
-0.42655906081199646,
0.44064292311668396,
-0.4720422625541687,
0.49240365624427795,
0.5803322792053223,
-0.2998816668987274,
-0.3456677198410034,
-0.9425479769706726,
0.6040869355201721,
0.32195788621902466,
-0.4830719828605652,
0.020564910024404526,
0.45259249210357666,
0.20138144493103027,
0.18971915543079376,
0.8225491642951965,
-0.28801655769348145,
0.2861870229244232,
-0.3449586033821106,
0.8403775691986084,
-0.406766414642334,
-0.2291697859764099,
-0.4613219201564789,
0.1372961401939392,
0.10210738331079483,
-0.7800785899162292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15082v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15082v2
|
PEMT: Multi-Task Correlation Guided Mixture-of-Experts Enables Parameter-Efficient Transfer Learning
| 2024-02-23T03:59:18 | 2024-06-06T15:11:29 |
Zhisheng Lin, Han Fu, Chenghao Liu, Zhuo Li, Jianling Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) has emerged as an effective method for
adapting pre-trained language models to various tasks efficiently. Recently,
there has been a growing interest in transferring knowledge from one or
multiple tasks to the downstream target task to achieve performance
improvements. However, current approaches typically either train adapters on
individual tasks or distill shared knowledge from source tasks, failing to
fully exploit task-specific knowledge and the correlation between source and
target tasks. To overcome these limitations, we propose PEMT, a novel
parameter-efficient fine-tuning framework based on multi-task transfer
learning. PEMT extends the mixture-of-experts (MoE) framework to capture the
transferable knowledge as a weighted combination of adapters trained on source
tasks. These weights are determined by a gated unit, measuring the correlation
between the target and each source task using task description prompt vectors.
To fully exploit the task-specific knowledge, we also propose the Task Sparsity
Loss to improve the sparsity of the gated unit. We conduct experiments on a
broad range of tasks over 17 datasets. The experimental results demonstrate our
PEMT yields stable improvements over full fine-tuning, and state-of-the-art
PEFT and knowledge transferring methods on various tasks. The results highlight
the effectiveness of our method which is capable of sufficiently exploiting the
knowledge and correlation features across multiple tasks.
|
[
-0.49414193630218506,
-1.025301456451416,
0.4978145956993103,
0.3227531909942627,
-0.25999870896339417,
0.1295291781425476,
-0.5087451338768005,
0.03434368968009949,
-0.10058293491601944,
0.5248672366142273,
-0.29140785336494446,
-0.1734875589609146,
-0.8866561055183411,
-0.21527063846588135,
-0.22816239297389984,
1.0708913803100586,
-0.15971140563488007,
-0.27490317821502686,
0.05854631960391998,
0.11887546628713608,
-0.6774293780326843,
-0.403800904750824,
-0.7911062836647034,
-0.07836741954088211,
0.5294916033744812,
0.5230444669723511,
0.08114346861839294,
0.5132162570953369,
0.5323969125747681,
0.25246602296829224,
0.20298999547958374,
0.7993573546409607,
-0.5683031678199768,
-0.05013798549771309,
-0.5411992073059082,
-0.2442525327205658,
-0.5460156798362732,
-0.21639059484004974,
0.6083908677101135,
0.7670110464096069,
-0.06555016338825226,
0.10672133415937424,
0.5614809393882751,
0.6306322813034058,
-0.7759864330291748,
0.2844983637332916,
-0.9233234524726868,
-0.16343480348587036,
-0.20766714215278625,
-0.6546860337257385,
-0.38494884967803955,
0.09467079490423203,
0.11258906126022339,
-0.7048013806343079,
0.15208294987678528,
0.06706850975751877,
0.5892235040664673,
0.5039827823638916,
-0.7050873041152954,
0.139662504196167,
-0.6215911507606506,
1.0189998149871826,
-0.33934611082077026,
0.37421050667762756,
0.3645338714122772,
0.3045217990875244,
-0.2461734265089035,
-0.5605155229568481,
-0.34762051701545715,
0.050350695848464966,
-0.04083307087421417,
-0.02462097257375717,
0.11187750101089478,
-0.10553959012031555,
-0.3577841818332672,
0.03328867629170418,
-0.24873562157154083,
-0.2271912395954132,
-0.19447198510169983,
-0.15744371712207794,
0.35520732402801514,
0.032544706016778946,
-0.029032139107584953,
0.470075398683548,
-0.5528539419174194,
-0.06691785156726837,
-0.4144465923309326,
0.01219247654080391,
0.013919226825237274,
0.4637240469455719,
-0.04589841887354851,
-0.05982477217912674,
-0.2401515394449234,
0.9585551023483276,
0.5974898934364319,
-0.3663386404514313,
0.07096027582883835,
-0.5905047059059143,
-0.06428669393062592,
-0.151956245303154,
0.7872543334960938,
0.16067272424697876,
0.051314037293195724,
-0.46279239654541016,
0.1531158685684204,
-0.5314002633094788,
0.23516562581062317,
-0.7262488007545471,
-0.5104278922080994,
-0.36470121145248413,
-0.2539026737213135,
-0.14852826297283173,
0.009300148114562035,
-0.5646207332611084,
-0.1235179752111435,
-0.46784231066703796,
0.7793315052986145,
-0.6915823221206665,
-0.3625521659851074,
0.26473671197891235,
0.04574728384613991,
0.02904893457889557,
0.5022420883178711,
-0.8563560843467712,
0.4069419205188751,
0.6904605031013489,
0.6429636478424072,
-0.5013258457183838,
-0.7099863290786743,
-0.8022100925445557,
0.49561992287635803,
-0.13497492671012878,
0.9516309499740601,
-0.5105122327804565,
-0.22240450978279114,
-0.6469572186470032,
0.04085365682840347,
-0.6791684031486511,
-0.374174565076828,
0.4362064003944397,
-0.19633646309375763,
-0.11089456081390381,
-0.20847588777542114,
-0.3024674355983734,
-0.38038891553878784,
0.25850722193717957,
-0.2010158896446228,
1.058829665184021,
0.037322867661714554,
-0.5048315525054932,
0.37116193771362305,
-0.5451645255088806,
-0.6489695310592651,
-0.2552742063999176,
-0.03496506065130234,
-0.3237464129924774,
0.05109040439128876,
0.3686319589614868,
0.8626577854156494,
-0.2627270817756653,
0.4073745608329773,
-0.3751307725906372,
-0.42730408906936646,
0.13976342976093292,
-0.42241930961608887,
0.3630478084087372,
0.27321377396583557,
-0.36798280477523804,
0.11759178340435028,
-0.6747856140136719,
-0.1257215142250061,
-0.25646457076072693,
-0.4567817449569702,
-0.5105838179588318,
-0.09296746551990509,
0.03722119331359863,
0.20424650609493256,
0.33191046118736267,
-0.2760242223739624,
0.08103681355714798,
-0.028797876089811325,
0.39214977622032166,
0.7690859436988831,
0.08718439191579819,
0.5084285736083984,
-0.47656163573265076,
0.10276851803064346,
0.22476115822792053,
0.05201251432299614,
-0.06379787623882294,
-0.3318633437156677,
-0.4654732644557953,
-0.4678976237773895,
0.245901420712471,
0.42726027965545654,
-0.6287204027175903,
0.676325798034668,
-0.20555996894836426,
-0.5849311351776123,
-0.34140124917030334,
0.36635878682136536,
0.40005218982696533,
0.9864170551300049,
0.4585531949996948,
-0.23351959884166718,
-0.33580589294433594,
-0.9815903306007385,
-0.6051430702209473,
0.12556448578834534,
0.1902645081281662,
0.22642557322978973,
0.16557349264621735,
0.17071107029914856,
0.7144001722335815,
-0.3898150324821472,
-0.4444439113140106,
0.041754983365535736,
0.331552118062973,
0.11927170306444168,
0.9735671281814575,
0.5190707445144653,
-0.64262855052948,
-0.915554404258728,
0.48387712240219116,
-0.15700791776180267,
0.006334058474749327,
-0.31173527240753174,
-0.5733909606933594,
-0.40792763233184814,
0.21836715936660767,
-0.19602705538272858,
-0.289542019367218,
0.5733999013900757,
-0.4066247344017029,
0.2701393663883209,
-0.35200873017311096,
0.5106103420257568,
-1.351022481918335,
0.180945485830307,
0.061380576342344284,
-0.5009396076202393,
-0.5150078535079956,
-0.16540221869945526,
0.3058241605758667,
0.19542449712753296,
-0.5117580890655518,
0.43199411034584045,
-0.25786009430885315,
0.43888747692108154,
-0.4312933087348938,
-0.20861613750457764,
0.007055214606225491,
0.8823903203010559,
-0.15402093529701233,
0.9138599038124084,
0.8902542591094971,
-0.7748482823371887,
-0.0016870404360815883,
0.017650609835982323,
0.12248339504003525,
0.9439857006072998,
-0.1864859163761139,
0.4120224714279175,
0.19096867740154266,
-0.07748951017856598,
-0.8880467414855957,
0.07643888890743256,
0.21135127544403076,
-0.2580416798591614,
0.40062034130096436,
-0.20979365706443787,
-0.5355103611946106,
0.17096106708049774,
-0.06466629356145859,
0.33536067605018616,
0.5225219130516052,
-0.1943221092224121,
0.8298026919364929,
0.3328720033168793,
-0.12530122697353363,
-0.36661094427108765,
-0.5207476019859314,
-0.1442689597606659,
-0.37801870703697205,
-0.3648478090763092,
0.7371246218681335,
-0.10762913525104523,
0.29678115248680115,
-0.006007874384522438,
-0.36187803745269775,
-0.6860604882240295,
0.2804032266139984,
0.050107441842556,
-0.2060818374156952,
-0.037695903331041336,
-0.1030576303601265,
0.6592172384262085,
0.05001487210392952,
-0.1489810049533844,
-0.29561084508895874,
0.36893630027770996,
-0.08466444909572601,
-0.3611769378185272,
-0.6487909555435181,
0.2712848484516144,
0.5668410658836365,
-0.3747224509716034,
0.8663552403450012,
1.0895037651062012,
-0.17433014512062073,
-0.20970527827739716,
-0.6582035422325134,
-0.2748294472694397,
-0.4555162787437439,
0.6347485184669495,
-0.7504662871360779,
-0.8766661286354065,
0.32981836795806885,
-0.6881631016731262,
0.07523169368505478,
0.40226268768310547,
0.5181373357772827,
0.08358921110630035,
0.9951125383377075,
0.7562044858932495,
-0.04311260208487511,
0.5979453921318054,
-0.004474752116948366,
-0.07067123055458069,
-0.7571133971214294,
-0.2669943869113922,
-0.5305667519569397,
-0.4602322578430176,
0.07592003792524338,
-0.5706596374511719,
0.3948441445827484,
0.3695216178894043,
-0.3548584580421448,
0.4428524971008301,
-0.5594186186790466,
0.4480970799922943,
0.618130087852478,
0.6781491637229919,
0.39606666564941406,
-0.004124189727008343,
-0.021288208663463593,
0.1284661889076233,
-0.7568959593772888,
-0.10557030886411667,
1.2173223495483398,
0.07486150413751602,
0.5658735036849976,
-0.2533617317676544,
0.5562732815742493,
0.24389168620109558,
-0.10299000144004822,
-0.409184068441391,
0.5077565312385559,
-0.4738750457763672,
-0.36440011858940125,
-0.12265770137310028,
-0.41733741760253906,
-0.7941042184829712,
0.22444602847099304,
-0.2122700959444046,
-0.5010753870010376,
0.28286492824554443,
0.34972241520881653,
-0.4493955373764038,
0.5127456784248352,
-0.8277081847190857,
0.8057734966278076,
-0.3272607922554016,
-0.43969953060150146,
-0.5489586591720581,
-0.6663906574249268,
0.17703746259212494,
-0.631058931350708,
0.15272186696529388,
-0.31404805183410645,
-0.2219255268573761,
0.8948174118995667,
-0.16128726303577423,
0.7679186463356018,
-0.27504146099090576,
0.13878010213375092,
0.008209720253944397,
0.13989929854869843,
0.5788854956626892,
-0.20975413918495178,
-0.16271205246448517,
0.07775521278381348,
0.11422378569841385,
-0.5690159201622009,
-0.6625072360038757,
0.9140271544456482,
-0.8783324956893921,
-0.30831682682037354,
0.2764008641242981,
-0.980666995048523,
-0.5709914565086365,
0.36286646127700806,
-0.2043582797050476,
0.16655339300632477,
0.2268259972333908,
0.5140691995620728,
0.7241281867027283,
0.1175660640001297,
0.09353401511907578,
0.6464756727218628,
0.30056801438331604,
-0.4123518764972687,
1.1522700786590576,
-0.006165690720081329,
0.0033079187851399183,
0.7787547707557678,
0.2346900999546051,
-0.048020828515291214,
-0.7419881224632263,
-0.3192640542984009,
-0.02046860195696354,
-0.30227920413017273,
-0.20088909566402435,
-0.6113839745521545,
0.16551318764686584,
-0.2243882268667221,
-0.23946617543697357,
-0.6934055685997009,
-0.1348268836736679,
-0.25324884057044983,
0.38682547211647034,
0.46998172998428345,
0.243580162525177,
0.16916461288928986,
0.5789073705673218,
-0.813510000705719,
0.2231910675764084,
0.46446365118026733,
0.39861536026000977,
-0.15923650562763214,
-0.7262163162231445,
-0.5312630534172058,
-0.027316825464367867,
-0.4557666778564453,
-0.8225769400596619,
0.2429342269897461,
0.5068747997283936,
0.8300356864929199,
0.200468048453331,
0.2419321984052658,
1.156730055809021,
-0.35789650678634644,
0.4750705659389496,
0.23240290582180023,
-1.0578749179840088,
0.4372754693031311,
-0.3132225573062897,
-0.0584748238325119,
0.7856698036193848,
0.30681151151657104,
0.15185992419719696,
-0.289336621761322,
-0.2917671203613281,
-0.6111561059951782,
0.7957243919372559,
0.09815545380115509,
-0.09261454641819,
0.29431647062301636,
0.4136591851711273,
0.6854662895202637,
0.25857460498809814,
-0.11424965411424637,
-0.15465596318244934,
-0.010204790160059929,
-0.37352555990219116,
0.040354568511247635,
0.1506691873073578,
-0.15786437690258026,
-0.6279905438423157,
0.6763662099838257,
-0.30119872093200684,
0.2320648580789566,
0.17878977954387665,
-0.26919299364089966,
-0.18876713514328003,
0.2259574979543686,
0.4002129137516022,
0.8039548397064209,
-0.1779467910528183,
0.43461334705352783,
0.5099911689758301,
-0.2537269592285156,
0.03931400552392006,
0.27097639441490173,
0.2535319924354553,
-0.1659066379070282,
-0.18009360134601593,
0.7966076731681824,
0.5165393948554993,
-0.43669018149375916,
0.3653949797153473,
0.2643791735172272,
-0.49919453263282776,
0.23747289180755615,
0.19019263982772827,
-0.05675036087632179,
0.34956830739974976,
0.5326477885246277,
0.6548168063163757,
0.16831816732883453,
-0.2803328037261963,
0.3785373866558075,
0.28917238116264343,
-0.24475090205669403,
-0.5300940871238708,
0.7901138663291931,
0.3447628319263458,
-0.06520790606737137,
-0.07125182449817657,
0.14871610701084137,
-0.13697560131549835,
0.35910841822624207,
0.46142223477363586,
0.5769299864768982,
-0.2875443696975708,
-0.13426168262958527,
0.09319829195737839,
0.04412200674414635,
-0.21577812731266022,
0.19171898066997528,
-0.3163090944290161,
-0.533479630947113,
-0.8939374685287476,
-0.4928421080112457,
-0.3625168204307556,
0.014738054014742374,
-0.5702372193336487,
0.3189639151096344,
-0.3155324161052704,
-0.1864735633134842,
-0.2212093472480774,
-0.15199999511241913,
-0.8204135298728943,
-0.05649682879447937,
-0.19869093596935272,
0.6920455098152161,
-0.8010210394859314,
1.217609167098999,
1.1328932046890259,
-0.12235487252473831,
-1.0070044994354248,
-0.06937982141971588,
-0.41378265619277954,
-0.8561807870864868,
0.5101009607315063,
-0.2627626657485962,
-0.003164583584293723,
0.4061534106731415,
-0.1277250349521637,
-0.805786669254303,
1.057947039604187,
0.7426818609237671,
-0.649687647819519,
0.002850247547030449,
-0.05418448522686958,
0.19875015318393707,
-0.1432657092809677,
0.10844096541404724,
0.41925472021102905,
0.5537874102592468,
-0.03815113380551338,
-1.4946091175079346,
0.2671944200992584,
-0.09248583018779755,
-0.15062513947486877,
0.30178648233413696,
-0.7912061810493469,
0.9589511156082153,
0.3089863955974579,
0.31241220235824585,
-0.2344968169927597,
0.524348258972168,
0.25639986991882324,
0.22807973623275757,
0.6500570178031921,
0.3551138639450073,
0.5191307067871094,
0.09557362645864487,
0.618478536605835,
-0.8130638599395752,
0.49029794335365295,
0.937752902507782,
0.08766187727451324,
0.8232595920562744,
0.7964242100715637,
-0.36721470952033997,
0.3250805139541626,
0.3792482316493988,
0.17509910464286804,
0.8240566849708557,
-0.23238979279994965,
-0.07793173938989639,
-0.650443971157074,
0.030710425227880478,
-0.3047562539577484,
0.3184923231601715,
0.265380322933197,
-0.4164845645427704,
-0.37943628430366516,
0.23170994222164154,
-0.06929298490285873,
0.0500662736594677,
-0.5026189684867859,
0.773909330368042,
0.0691678375005722,
-0.696244478225708,
0.6238387823104858,
-0.10056986659765244,
0.9216606616973877,
-0.6371527910232544,
-0.06856909394264221,
0.08321402221918106,
0.3763439953327179,
-0.10891182720661163,
-0.6348533630371094,
0.4464237689971924,
-0.4012579619884491,
-0.18482187390327454,
-0.5296136140823364,
0.9463598132133484,
-0.661196231842041,
-0.22769327461719513,
-0.06701400876045227,
0.8264002203941345,
0.16691145300865173,
-0.6332926750183105,
-0.8438775539398193,
-0.33592092990875244,
-0.08030705153942108,
-0.049933113157749176,
0.7676310539245605,
0.6069126725196838,
0.2350965291261673,
0.448076456785202,
0.636348307132721,
0.2751419246196747,
0.2434912472963333,
-0.47675347328186035,
0.955784261226654,
-0.3435477316379547,
-0.5056146383285522,
-0.7589222192764282,
0.45213520526885986,
0.13472172617912292,
-0.17356741428375244,
0.794262707233429,
0.46012595295906067,
0.7569596171379089,
-0.23375454545021057,
0.7381243705749512,
-0.04363229125738144,
0.5802083015441895,
-0.31566721200942993,
0.6798493266105652,
-0.6248533129692078,
0.0979364663362503,
-0.19834646582603455,
-0.7945781350135803,
-0.23699413239955902,
0.37492793798446655,
-0.33340615034103394,
-0.07418108731508255,
0.6398515701293945,
0.593535304069519,
-0.4901193678379059,
-0.44931402802467346,
0.45273372530937195,
-0.0034103456418961287,
0.12315234541893005,
0.8804782032966614,
0.35037657618522644,
-0.3707265257835388,
0.8896154165267944,
-0.6099503040313721,
-0.22481921315193176,
-0.21898585557937622,
-0.7199812531471252,
-0.8846487998962402,
-0.6892474293708801,
-0.4752084016799927,
0.20311999320983887,
0.43347859382629395,
0.8746588230133057,
1.3266851902008057,
-0.8687915802001953,
-0.10355760902166367,
-0.29737019538879395,
-0.15544448792934418,
-0.7930207848548889,
-0.20676301419734955,
0.5750052332878113,
-0.45567065477371216,
-0.8461112380027771,
0.51662278175354,
0.1836203783750534,
-0.3591170012950897,
0.09776489436626434,
-0.21284492313861847,
-0.047116734087467194,
-0.2463579773902893,
0.5992885828018188,
-0.005736317951232195,
-0.6351714134216309,
-0.1702871322631836,
-0.062053389847278595,
0.24756132066249847,
-0.01754106394946575,
0.7182790040969849,
-0.8157328963279724,
0.36570847034454346,
0.5015857815742493,
1.0113258361816406,
0.3831961452960968,
0.0258277989923954,
0.6427822113037109,
-0.9304340481758118,
0.010202775709331036,
-0.05508796125650406,
0.3567596673965454,
-0.06184371933341026,
-0.3242569863796234,
0.20720700919628143,
0.440676212310791,
-0.7069828510284424,
-0.5964873433113098,
-0.2155246138572693,
-1.5190298557281494,
-0.39109233021736145,
0.9404615163803101,
-0.29362890124320984,
0.0017942715203389525,
-0.3355099558830261,
-0.5093415379524231,
0.4821445941925049,
-0.6584374904632568,
0.7931199073791504,
0.3409045338630676,
-0.3408253788948059,
-0.4529876708984375,
-0.27415743470191956,
0.18011660873889923,
0.71514892578125,
-0.8496032953262329,
-0.2527936100959778,
-0.10117700695991516,
0.5599526166915894,
-0.11382702738046646,
0.5090973377227783,
0.06293836236000061,
0.07277592271566391,
-0.25620460510253906,
-0.2034478634595871,
-0.6012044548988342,
-0.2769307792186737,
0.17469368875026703,
0.4372118413448334,
0.17253051698207855,
-0.5624881982803345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15080v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15080v1
|
Infusing Hierarchical Guidance into Prompt Tuning: A Parameter-Efficient Framework for Multi-level Implicit Discourse Relation Recognition
| 2024-02-23T03:53:39 | 2024-02-23T03:53:39 |
Haodong Zhao, Ruifang He, Mengnan Xiao, Jing Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-level implicit discourse relation recognition (MIDRR) aims at
identifying hierarchical discourse relations among arguments. Previous methods
achieve the promotion through fine-tuning PLMs. However, due to the data
scarcity and the task gap, the pre-trained feature space cannot be accurately
tuned to the task-specific space, which even aggravates the collapse of the
vanilla space. Besides, the comprehension of hierarchical semantics for MIDRR
makes the conversion much harder. In this paper, we propose a prompt-based
Parameter-Efficient Multi-level IDRR (PEMI) framework to solve the above
problems. First, we leverage parameter-efficient prompt tuning to drive the
inputted arguments to match the pre-trained space and realize the approximation
with few parameters. Furthermore, we propose a hierarchical label refining
(HLR) method for the prompt verbalizer to deeply integrate hierarchical
guidance into the prompt tuning. Finally, our model achieves comparable results
on PDTB 2.0 and 3.0 using about 0.1% trainable parameters compared with
baselines and the visualization demonstrates the effectiveness of our HLR
method.
|
[
-0.41661107540130615,
-0.5581830739974976,
0.6621372103691101,
0.3254633843898773,
-0.2910795211791992,
0.18107740581035614,
0.012632896192371845,
0.14302228391170502,
-0.581473708152771,
0.06414920836687088,
-0.7164832949638367,
-0.5230286717414856,
-0.39069926738739014,
0.22146648168563843,
0.353310763835907,
1.290665864944458,
0.28298279643058777,
-0.004799829795956612,
-0.19463114440441132,
0.0029412226285785437,
-0.39835333824157715,
-0.35568496584892273,
-1.0470787286758423,
-0.23913255333900452,
0.7945328950881958,
0.7104836106300354,
0.39085641503334045,
0.6976643204689026,
0.21354559063911438,
0.3034532964229584,
-0.5561715960502625,
0.43617284297943115,
-0.520206868648529,
0.17360332608222961,
-0.18602053821086884,
0.10692062973976135,
-0.6647627949714661,
-0.04465629532933235,
0.8504747748374939,
0.5539491772651672,
0.1196899339556694,
0.1754119098186493,
0.4566499590873718,
0.32083430886268616,
-0.5449030995368958,
0.34532827138900757,
-0.6303419470787048,
-0.10768978297710419,
-0.23466381430625916,
-0.573798656463623,
-0.410132497549057,
-0.40196049213409424,
0.23054780066013336,
-0.8877553343772888,
0.0007792917895130813,
0.5343666076660156,
1.0274577140808105,
0.5198805928230286,
-0.521759033203125,
-0.2211114764213562,
-0.5782017111778259,
0.7165906429290771,
-0.6090076565742493,
0.03857346624135971,
0.3312698304653168,
0.2706698775291443,
-0.37869805097579956,
-0.5721301436424255,
-0.29376426339149475,
-0.1978389471769333,
-0.39736971259117126,
0.09800658375024796,
-0.056367047131061554,
0.5055208802223206,
0.5223484039306641,
0.33119791746139526,
-0.3735925853252411,
0.14063681662082672,
0.16515667736530304,
-0.15291078388690948,
0.0025101175997406244,
0.1917576640844345,
0.15566320717334747,
-0.3979354500770569,
-0.5549989938735962,
0.06529678404331207,
-0.7155519723892212,
0.3456360995769501,
0.3826301693916321,
0.49025553464889526,
0.0003955707943532616,
0.05520932748913765,
0.07147927582263947,
0.6125419735908508,
0.6286999583244324,
-0.5272620916366577,
-0.08081105351448059,
-0.48104074597358704,
-0.13252678513526917,
0.14419619739055634,
0.7246798872947693,
0.07554526627063751,
0.09634074568748474,
0.2138141691684723,
0.1825958788394928,
-0.3657132089138031,
-0.13338415324687958,
-1.0074107646942139,
-0.10846488922834396,
-0.10008170455694199,
-0.3236290216445923,
0.1528986543416977,
-0.19448667764663696,
-0.8076669573783875,
-0.37816157937049866,
-0.3933998644351959,
0.021517593413591385,
-0.5965902805328369,
-0.08032362908124924,
-0.13879673182964325,
-0.004870031960308552,
0.36005210876464844,
0.45146965980529785,
-0.7077015042304993,
0.26750221848487854,
0.661013662815094,
0.6499814391136169,
0.24153479933738708,
-0.08038707822561264,
-0.892612099647522,
0.5701655149459839,
-0.11682689934968948,
0.7552732229232788,
-0.600683331489563,
-0.26498138904571533,
-0.2378162294626236,
-0.14296410977840424,
-0.19517946243286133,
-0.5324572920799255,
0.9685937762260437,
-0.09698440134525299,
0.17881886661052704,
-0.29411083459854126,
-0.28407418727874756,
0.12795878946781158,
0.33149731159210205,
-0.32704803347587585,
1.1824790239334106,
-0.12175904214382172,
-0.7973228693008423,
0.43050017952919006,
-0.48202741146087646,
-0.3313159942626953,
0.16114383935928345,
-0.10308931022882462,
-0.6530393958091736,
-0.23247502744197845,
0.7407546639442444,
0.3612137734889984,
-0.37997525930404663,
0.5707570910453796,
-0.14839081466197968,
-0.3244669735431671,
-0.28849470615386963,
-0.3273344933986664,
0.5651533007621765,
0.0868687778711319,
-0.1318330317735672,
0.4033007323741913,
-0.8473091125488281,
-0.226915180683136,
-0.5376808047294617,
-0.40081292390823364,
-0.6305391788482666,
-0.10389763861894608,
-0.32693785429000854,
0.3667033016681671,
0.12887248396873474,
-0.5890135765075684,
0.20565983653068542,
-0.5105631947517395,
0.2622651755809784,
0.8034585118293762,
0.2812265455722809,
0.5630854964256287,
-0.24004949629306793,
0.4877828359603882,
0.2728617787361145,
0.23374846577644348,
-0.5165895223617554,
-0.5832223296165466,
-0.7126582264900208,
-0.6356142163276672,
0.4681885540485382,
0.4489883780479431,
-0.7464184165000916,
0.5091491341590881,
-0.09643316268920898,
-0.23510964214801788,
-0.7552327513694763,
-0.2219846397638321,
0.777573823928833,
1.0531022548675537,
0.4101351201534271,
0.6320945024490356,
-0.5768161416053772,
-1.0876643657684326,
-0.33097925782203674,
-0.3969234824180603,
0.01572348177433014,
0.46638035774230957,
0.2801549732685089,
0.18939927220344543,
0.9328703284263611,
-0.2549448311328888,
-0.6113109588623047,
0.03488011658191681,
0.5978379249572754,
0.30212369561195374,
0.6799739003181458,
0.5070933103561401,
-0.44347167015075684,
-0.7971317172050476,
0.2097240686416626,
-0.33957070112228394,
-0.371246874332428,
-0.1301097422838211,
-0.35629016160964966,
-0.21078383922576904,
0.5083950161933899,
-0.33838775753974915,
0.24643808603286743,
0.00936059094965458,
-0.39853718876838684,
0.1970418244600296,
-0.3068065643310547,
0.1304922103881836,
-1.0856372117996216,
0.006977034267038107,
0.24268168210983276,
-0.20928028225898743,
-0.47933533787727356,
-0.3634571135044098,
0.13306023180484772,
-0.1841864287853241,
-0.26768025755882263,
0.5078990459442139,
-0.7461004853248596,
0.25894224643707275,
-0.17879529297351837,
-0.23341216146945953,
-0.05571359023451805,
0.8981298804283142,
-0.10304497182369232,
0.747602641582489,
0.5508915781974792,
-0.57676100730896,
-0.17261157929897308,
0.2610553205013275,
-0.019988827407360077,
0.8293874859809875,
-0.6864069104194641,
0.24089974164962769,
-0.4194971024990082,
0.23817504942417145,
-1.3734968900680542,
0.20270337164402008,
0.6473234295845032,
-0.2027173787355423,
0.4353660047054291,
-0.6146711707115173,
-0.6190780997276306,
-0.03876844421029091,
-0.2164297252893448,
0.46532779932022095,
0.4340123236179352,
-0.6250027418136597,
0.8195368647575378,
0.26398974657058716,
-0.5887324213981628,
-0.6273320913314819,
-0.05541207641363144,
0.019640330225229263,
-0.39627769589424133,
-0.3508642017841339,
0.7792059779167175,
-0.17879463732242584,
0.12163937836885452,
-0.2839232385158539,
-0.18025000393390656,
0.06593329459428787,
-0.20803029835224152,
0.36007991433143616,
0.04102989658713341,
-0.10166530311107635,
-0.05361485481262207,
0.8199085593223572,
-0.21665623784065247,
-0.004766453523188829,
0.03709307685494423,
0.15409551560878754,
-0.29652225971221924,
0.10053528845310211,
-0.6934235095977783,
0.4672887325286865,
0.6577697992324829,
-0.09412453323602676,
0.3231225907802582,
0.3512682616710663,
-0.3086127042770386,
-0.1860881894826889,
-0.3965679407119751,
0.036061596125364304,
-0.4809214174747467,
0.012336449697613716,
-0.8438254594802856,
-0.8580270409584045,
0.37903428077697754,
-0.6357150077819824,
0.06862068921327591,
0.09490574896335602,
0.34429237246513367,
-0.16529683768749237,
1.3867865800857544,
0.3969900608062744,
0.09814074635505676,
0.3012191951274872,
-0.032909784466028214,
0.11353977024555206,
-1.0683685541152954,
-0.4090114235877991,
-0.795224666595459,
-0.27199235558509827,
-0.25785747170448303,
-0.0478331595659256,
0.6957069635391235,
0.017856022343039513,
-0.42730095982551575,
-0.056425485759973526,
-0.5040169954299927,
0.4327903091907501,
0.48788341879844666,
0.01725102588534355,
0.4638846218585968,
-0.04021453112363815,
-0.44232073426246643,
-0.5681892037391663,
-0.8251065015792847,
-0.5021477341651917,
0.10316930711269379,
0.4972887337207794,
0.5372573137283325,
-0.16686712205410004,
0.33920520544052124,
-0.10027604550123215,
0.23866701126098633,
-0.7789617776870728,
0.7324386835098267,
-0.1956096589565277,
-0.18737980723381042,
-0.21000659465789795,
-0.36956894397735596,
-0.9003320932388306,
0.4430370032787323,
-0.11046347767114639,
-0.22629496455192566,
0.6190219521522522,
0.20257756114006042,
-0.6323508024215698,
0.09896249324083328,
-0.5424482226371765,
0.7513446807861328,
-0.13921010494232178,
-0.4316427409648895,
0.17542226612567902,
-0.8630348443984985,
0.06429924070835114,
0.27178099751472473,
0.08865735679864883,
-0.36320245265960693,
-0.1932893991470337,
0.6103783249855042,
-0.5817301869392395,
0.8476872444152832,
-0.5298358798027039,
-0.20530001819133759,
-0.2133043259382248,
-0.25618720054626465,
0.3282642662525177,
0.28719982504844666,
-0.07965798676013947,
-0.3231688141822815,
-0.21483401954174042,
-0.12330616265535355,
-0.7820940613746643,
0.5753440856933594,
-0.5803894400596619,
-0.6940647959709167,
-0.5541356801986694,
-0.623803436756134,
-0.3710133135318756,
0.11912944167852402,
0.23517128825187683,
0.48536452651023865,
-0.14499534666538239,
0.006272568833082914,
0.7153953909873962,
-0.14932236075401306,
0.5364815592765808,
0.6434096097946167,
0.13218605518341064,
-0.4002661108970642,
0.6693288683891296,
-0.04482938349246979,
-0.4104979634284973,
0.5427491664886475,
0.41869208216667175,
-0.5412481427192688,
-0.46486690640449524,
-0.6953582763671875,
0.26591697335243225,
-0.357391357421875,
-0.5259202718734741,
-0.6010441780090332,
-0.08240138739347458,
-0.1824914664030075,
0.10589364171028137,
-0.0853685811161995,
-0.11791746318340302,
-0.6071206331253052,
0.08538293093442917,
0.401696115732193,
0.28979361057281494,
0.2006387859582901,
0.5843784809112549,
-0.45407503843307495,
0.5105764269828796,
0.3014611303806305,
0.11881347000598907,
-0.0260966494679451,
-0.712925374507904,
0.0379561111330986,
-0.09622020274400711,
-0.21613451838493347,
-0.7478442192077637,
0.31438717246055603,
0.6215213537216187,
0.4247467517852783,
0.5166727304458618,
0.3437248170375824,
1.298431634902954,
-0.7135602831840515,
0.417726069688797,
0.09246547520160675,
-1.000161051750183,
0.9571053981781006,
-0.4377611577510834,
0.5484124422073364,
0.797736406326294,
0.6760245561599731,
-0.039078082889318466,
-0.5282555818557739,
-0.21755635738372803,
-0.8842505812644958,
0.8597674369812012,
-0.02657422609627247,
-0.1043340414762497,
0.1360851526260376,
0.411722332239151,
0.2660471200942993,
0.13190771639347076,
-0.5204273462295532,
-0.28395724296569824,
-0.044754356145858765,
-0.15558844804763794,
0.47941550612449646,
-0.3401315212249756,
-0.02015690691769123,
-0.8825439214706421,
0.6641619801521301,
-0.2725381851196289,
-0.18874017894268036,
0.17189811170101166,
0.11897248029708862,
-0.20830325782299042,
0.5732749104499817,
0.12054091691970825,
0.5387478470802307,
-0.17620018124580383,
0.04731805995106697,
-0.07677803933620453,
-0.17354072630405426,
0.4947469234466553,
0.3684753179550171,
-0.4035448729991913,
0.2527545094490051,
-0.14480046927928925,
1.0268545150756836,
0.6314270496368408,
-0.23671020567417145,
0.5142611861228943,
-0.2681886553764343,
-0.18010073900222778,
0.004079707898199558,
-0.16354843974113464,
-0.09601081162691116,
0.09171685576438904,
0.4871022701263428,
0.0528593510389328,
0.3302500545978546,
-0.46265584230422974,
-0.006353185046464205,
0.28040874004364014,
-0.3374302387237549,
-0.09983620792627335,
0.5997775793075562,
0.2926040291786194,
-0.19329045712947845,
0.6644456386566162,
-0.2768329977989197,
-0.29302510619163513,
0.2995896637439728,
0.6123414635658264,
0.6354563236236572,
-0.4413996934890747,
0.35352572798728943,
0.5934310555458069,
0.0955556184053421,
0.2539118826389313,
0.34852200746536255,
-0.3224436938762665,
-0.3318895399570465,
-0.6608651876449585,
-0.5353139638900757,
-0.47549906373023987,
0.19810648262500763,
-0.7307071685791016,
0.20797188580036163,
-0.6675180792808533,
-0.2573404908180237,
0.047398895025253296,
-0.034994762390851974,
-0.10573145002126694,
-0.0739484503865242,
-0.02935500629246235,
0.6691634058952332,
-0.47852522134780884,
0.8451947569847107,
0.9089210033416748,
-0.16557474434375763,
-0.8432505130767822,
0.03201977163553238,
-0.2931840121746063,
-0.22107340395450592,
0.6606741547584534,
0.03330977261066437,
-0.36533281207084656,
0.2709495425224304,
-0.4568089246749878,
-0.6035510301589966,
0.7606012225151062,
0.6670842170715332,
-0.7354575395584106,
-0.42281854152679443,
-0.023786772042512894,
0.5933839678764343,
-0.42446208000183105,
0.2903999388217926,
0.6287997961044312,
0.7362177968025208,
0.3888794183731079,
-0.8573657274246216,
0.19675731658935547,
-0.500806987285614,
0.30444663763046265,
0.19236227869987488,
-0.4723551273345947,
0.7873661518096924,
-0.05225242301821709,
-0.5506618618965149,
0.2679433226585388,
0.846884548664093,
0.6662786602973938,
0.46477198600769043,
0.6639896631240845,
0.453838974237442,
0.7074868083000183,
-0.2495507448911667,
0.649643063545227,
-0.2896580398082733,
-0.027959877625107765,
1.1821480989456177,
-0.3059898614883423,
0.4736402630805969,
0.4628751575946808,
0.2952033281326294,
0.6813725233078003,
0.788930356502533,
0.12551385164260864,
0.695379376411438,
0.057400502264499664,
-0.1184086948633194,
-0.11191806197166443,
-0.5307894349098206,
-0.3235231339931488,
0.1468706727027893,
0.5624005794525146,
-0.15344807505607605,
-0.4277982711791992,
0.14411956071853638,
0.24728591740131378,
0.1721464991569519,
-0.6648164987564087,
1.1204116344451904,
0.1637219339609146,
-0.9237421751022339,
0.8638449311256409,
-0.08872953802347183,
0.7629271745681763,
-0.5701454281806946,
-0.37427231669425964,
-0.046438079327344894,
-0.029580239206552505,
-0.1663505882024765,
-0.4719233214855194,
-0.0015559993917122483,
-0.018618490546941757,
-0.13628828525543213,
-0.5922992825508118,
0.7185649275779724,
-0.7656766176223755,
-0.20865999162197113,
0.2543519139289856,
0.7057071924209595,
-0.1428745836019516,
-0.02992519550025463,
-0.8050384521484375,
-0.34210893511772156,
-0.35401490330696106,
0.05890306457877159,
0.2707147002220154,
0.748378336429596,
0.1478552222251892,
0.34396862983703613,
0.4319656789302826,
0.05911945924162865,
-0.12787431478500366,
0.1964406967163086,
0.9509723782539368,
-0.40570828318595886,
-0.7651638984680176,
-0.874898374080658,
0.5777158141136169,
-0.14663486182689667,
-0.7238162755966187,
0.9152488112449646,
0.510865330696106,
0.4604071080684662,
0.035147108137607574,
0.4469239413738251,
0.28522202372550964,
0.6970284581184387,
-0.4681539535522461,
0.4998686909675598,
-0.4656643271446228,
0.21816635131835938,
-0.47273948788642883,
-0.7485643625259399,
-0.24646861851215363,
0.4619249105453491,
-0.22097758948802948,
-0.04139730706810951,
0.7157713174819946,
0.8485110402107239,
-0.08240572363138199,
-0.08490235358476639,
0.12079129368066788,
0.27055513858795166,
-0.06473280489444733,
0.6177375316619873,
1.2521247863769531,
-0.1618364006280899,
0.6700593829154968,
-0.09166750311851501,
-0.4083594083786011,
0.09099303930997849,
-1.013950228691101,
-0.8804787397384644,
-0.500029444694519,
-0.4843931496143341,
0.07138324528932571,
0.34439554810523987,
0.7418348789215088,
0.9531675577163696,
-0.5444761514663696,
-0.3016260266304016,
-0.03818172961473465,
0.20917586982250214,
-0.21304704248905182,
-0.22274410724639893,
0.3859265446662903,
-0.39205843210220337,
-0.885068416595459,
0.47849491238594055,
0.5521805286407471,
-0.13590092957019806,
0.016906632110476494,
-0.04086233675479889,
-0.3540513515472412,
-0.12329930812120438,
0.7460510730743408,
0.1321311593055725,
-0.6484046578407288,
0.006192863918840885,
-0.1971709430217743,
0.03805406764149666,
0.4479086101055145,
1.054194450378418,
-0.8820574283599854,
0.15004073083400726,
0.4926345646381378,
0.4667995274066925,
0.31106314063072205,
0.28198379278182983,
0.6011218428611755,
-1.1616517305374146,
0.024222640320658684,
0.47752541303634644,
0.3780871629714966,
0.26418137550354004,
-0.5241386890411377,
0.19540052115917206,
-0.14408756792545319,
-0.6642358303070068,
-0.7735539674758911,
0.23209038376808167,
-1.06856369972229,
-0.28525134921073914,
1.0156655311584473,
-0.2269718199968338,
-0.14390945434570312,
-0.5624950528144836,
-0.7504871487617493,
0.29810404777526855,
-0.9384844899177551,
0.4314419627189636,
0.3651123344898224,
-0.34013596177101135,
-0.48249733448028564,
0.04514564573764801,
0.9153856635093689,
0.4949537217617035,
-0.8226494193077087,
0.03365851193666458,
0.49294474720954895,
-0.23150412738323212,
-0.042034123092889786,
0.8142070770263672,
-0.10680050402879715,
0.19414956867694855,
-0.45643866062164307,
-0.5167524814605713,
-0.14770124852657318,
-0.7516351938247681,
-0.44386541843414307,
0.4028800427913666,
0.10929089784622192,
-0.11461043357849121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00794v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00794v2
|
Getting Serious about Humor: Crafting Humor Datasets with Unfunny Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T02:58:12 | 2024-06-21T17:12:35 |
Zachary Horvitz, Jingru Chen, Rahul Aditya, Harshvardhan Srivastava, Robert West, Zhou Yu, Kathleen McKeown
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Humor is a fundamental facet of human cognition and interaction. Yet, despite
recent advances in natural language processing, humor detection remains a
challenging task that is complicated by the scarcity of datasets that pair
humorous texts with similar non-humorous counterparts. In our work, we
investigate whether large language models (LLMs), can generate synthetic data
for humor detection via editing texts. We benchmark LLMs on an existing human
dataset and show that current LLMs display an impressive ability to 'unfun'
jokes, as judged by humans and as measured on the downstream task of humor
detection. We extend our approach to a code-mixed English-Hindi humor dataset,
where we find that GPT-4's synthetic data is highly rated by bilingual
annotators and provides challenging adversarial examples for humor classifiers.
|
[
-0.158895805478096,
-0.8525198101997375,
0.6420520544052124,
0.5238162875175476,
-0.5669182538986206,
0.1368454098701477,
-0.5042883157730103,
-0.49562910199165344,
0.16815991699695587,
0.5703124403953552,
-0.24910008907318115,
-0.34950196743011475,
-0.4020891487598419,
0.29691264033317566,
-0.5305278897285461,
1.1356220245361328,
0.4091598689556122,
-0.007761529181152582,
-0.17532864212989807,
-0.12812195718288422,
-0.2047734558582306,
-0.5818478465080261,
-0.7805337309837341,
-0.39768898487091064,
0.7073419094085693,
0.29186126589775085,
1.0643912553787231,
0.45588570833206177,
0.49710914492607117,
0.30742770433425903,
-0.051785923540592194,
0.10998835414648056,
-0.4501696825027466,
-0.06728648394346237,
-0.2971474826335907,
-0.4918231964111328,
-0.31185564398765564,
-0.15395472943782806,
0.4785018861293793,
0.7709028720855713,
-0.18094700574874878,
-0.29226893186569214,
-0.38176777958869934,
0.5012149810791016,
-0.17370104789733887,
0.08451033383607864,
-0.7737764716148376,
0.23980781435966492,
-0.46937477588653564,
-0.22990165650844574,
-0.39967578649520874,
-0.3868844509124756,
-0.1152985543012619,
-0.29299962520599365,
0.21700167655944824,
0.10322823375463486,
0.4982192814350128,
0.24531590938568115,
-0.3597193956375122,
-0.33969923853874207,
-0.8241093158721924,
0.6156580448150635,
-0.9631413221359253,
0.16818085312843323,
0.14634786546230316,
0.3536583483219147,
-0.3788585066795349,
-0.7478370070457458,
-0.9289853572845459,
-0.30888986587524414,
0.09862593561410904,
-0.1101098284125328,
-0.3991340100765228,
-0.22473087906837463,
0.38267791271209717,
0.5606616139411926,
-0.7069479823112488,
-0.01898360066115856,
-0.3954141139984131,
0.03599900007247925,
0.7941338419914246,
0.14076805114746094,
0.6727274656295776,
-0.3013834059238434,
-0.011501448228955269,
0.06344867497682571,
-0.7417019605636597,
-0.3032672703266144,
0.869376003742218,
0.1256307065486908,
0.14893516898155212,
0.6865422129631042,
-0.12413141876459122,
0.3573854863643646,
-0.41520068049430847,
0.04955584928393364,
0.2178891897201538,
-0.006452323403209448,
-0.3893427848815918,
-0.07697033882141113,
1.0192320346832275,
0.31992608308792114,
0.871370792388916,
-0.3612898588180542,
-0.40989500284194946,
-0.03112938441336155,
0.26103368401527405,
-0.4781253933906555,
-0.7473841905593872,
-0.05292684584856033,
-0.007657487876713276,
-0.773746907711029,
-0.07965727150440216,
-0.7430791258811951,
-0.7133457660675049,
-0.18704810738563538,
0.4501021206378937,
-0.3366069793701172,
-0.18241460621356964,
0.522990345954895,
-0.2937438488006592,
-0.010772782377898693,
0.24643482267856598,
-0.46276429295539856,
0.0534091480076313,
0.5389899611473083,
0.5354759097099304,
0.04902559891343117,
-0.17863106727600098,
-0.5317615270614624,
-0.010222301818430424,
-0.4900031089782715,
0.865882933139801,
-0.6786248087882996,
-0.3112596869468689,
-0.10610274970531464,
0.16986975073814392,
0.3251732587814331,
-0.6674404740333557,
0.8041342496871948,
-0.427166610956192,
0.20917969942092896,
-0.21920950710773468,
-0.27081382274627686,
0.10257648676633835,
0.25156259536743164,
-0.7295747995376587,
0.9713164567947388,
0.2665867507457733,
-1.0238475799560547,
0.13580988347530365,
-0.6823639273643494,
-0.8959119915962219,
0.10245835781097412,
0.1326109766960144,
-0.1871970146894455,
0.21242016553878784,
0.3091723322868347,
0.2517514228820801,
-0.3601832091808319,
0.6207882761955261,
-0.4439070224761963,
-0.5390565991401672,
0.7545744180679321,
-0.49906274676322937,
0.6131430268287659,
0.2579836845397949,
-0.2931066155433655,
-0.039763953536748886,
-0.5964004993438721,
-0.20092232525348663,
0.5040804743766785,
-0.3635317087173462,
-0.2679049074649811,
0.01774785667657852,
0.07969196885824203,
0.367313951253891,
-0.06719156354665756,
-0.6115636229515076,
0.3093723952770233,
-0.5751809477806091,
0.6891899704933167,
0.5817475914955139,
-0.21349310874938965,
-0.09526733309030533,
-0.1952200084924698,
0.5304462313652039,
0.06895828247070312,
0.19794553518295288,
0.09967545419931412,
-0.7401397824287415,
-0.8149739503860474,
-0.07454682886600494,
0.2063416689634323,
0.799757719039917,
-1.1477636098861694,
0.2790662348270416,
-0.3765734136104584,
-0.4990784823894501,
-0.41423800587654114,
0.29730942845344543,
0.31162315607070923,
0.4113211929798126,
0.39096763730049133,
-0.1931145191192627,
-0.3583114445209503,
-0.9082751870155334,
-0.8429200053215027,
0.03269988298416138,
-0.32429975271224976,
0.2707446217536926,
0.39093267917633057,
-0.23186194896697998,
0.7954164147377014,
-0.55174720287323,
-0.0197282861918211,
-0.5211934447288513,
0.24569395184516907,
0.20039860904216766,
0.2216269075870514,
0.5759077072143555,
-0.8531641364097595,
-0.3753693997859955,
0.025197923183441162,
-0.7793766260147095,
-0.33317309617996216,
0.08953855186700821,
0.23895205557346344,
0.023027053102850914,
0.49615105986595154,
-0.615100622177124,
0.38449496030807495,
0.2798614799976349,
-0.1886061280965805,
0.6735919713973999,
-0.15098224580287933,
0.1693790704011917,
-0.8352839946746826,
0.033381570130586624,
-0.032545220106840134,
-0.3653362989425659,
-0.7067989110946655,
-0.12532006204128265,
-0.17438872158527374,
-0.3892173171043396,
-0.5347775220870972,
0.8773294687271118,
-0.16238892078399658,
-0.12616029381752014,
-0.177839994430542,
-0.04435808211565018,
0.04009859636425972,
0.31694555282592773,
-0.15775734186172485,
0.5405219197273254,
0.45273706316947937,
-0.17413759231567383,
0.7773594856262207,
-0.029765058308839798,
-0.371921569108963,
0.3151988685131073,
-0.7485894560813904,
0.3400701582431793,
-0.13170617818832397,
0.4190763235092163,
-0.8873171806335449,
-0.7793731689453125,
0.06336982548236847,
-0.33843809366226196,
0.27065789699554443,
-0.2560116946697235,
-1.0028882026672363,
-0.5152745842933655,
-0.4202883243560791,
0.5072630047798157,
0.6777085661888123,
-0.587415874004364,
0.2341904193162918,
0.2744116187095642,
-0.40895622968673706,
-0.45811590552330017,
-0.9944866895675659,
0.5651838779449463,
-0.54937344789505,
-0.7088360786437988,
0.16722367703914642,
-0.10424071550369263,
-0.21859972178936005,
-0.0033132717944681644,
0.21881718933582306,
-0.04306510463356972,
-0.2458951473236084,
0.0068869455717504025,
-0.07124486565589905,
-0.12147857248783112,
0.12840254604816437,
-0.07226596027612686,
0.18302136659622192,
0.11577096581459045,
-0.00013189291348680854,
0.3684268295764923,
-0.006020173896104097,
-0.3547458350658417,
-0.23624619841575623,
0.1769414246082306,
0.5306552052497864,
-0.0030674724839627743,
0.4747273027896881,
0.7500375509262085,
-0.5247843861579895,
-0.20939241349697113,
-0.6089019179344177,
0.004451846703886986,
-0.5080170631408691,
0.23671504855155945,
-0.13829420506954193,
-0.8708773255348206,
0.45111051201820374,
-0.017306802794337273,
-0.32950952649116516,
0.2254805862903595,
0.3745364546775818,
0.05812627077102661,
1.1450724601745605,
0.40225785970687866,
-0.01357501931488514,
0.24435435235500336,
0.1923888772726059,
0.726582407951355,
-0.5169768929481506,
0.05950618535280228,
-0.31255847215652466,
-0.29885756969451904,
-0.5943209528923035,
-0.5909366607666016,
0.2248438447713852,
0.002083413302898407,
-0.10547247529029846,
0.07405081391334534,
-0.2043614387512207,
0.9170375466346741,
0.21475990116596222,
0.048753347247838974,
0.32499170303344727,
0.002100487006828189,
-0.017393454909324646,
-0.06930048763751984,
-0.3911236524581909,
-0.3402349352836609,
0.9722377061843872,
0.3635452091693878,
0.9615001678466797,
0.21187475323677063,
0.47569671273231506,
0.34958404302597046,
0.4073566496372223,
-0.6462733745574951,
0.5509326457977295,
-0.7509435415267944,
-0.3553510010242462,
-0.047941066324710846,
-0.7514169216156006,
-0.5010623335838318,
-0.32096466422080994,
0.04469973221421242,
-0.6617457866668701,
-0.11398116499185562,
0.2452067881822586,
-0.09815779328346252,
0.5273789763450623,
-0.8707512021064758,
0.7616084814071655,
-0.13785094022750854,
-0.20087401568889618,
0.054638464003801346,
-0.5947344899177551,
0.7447720170021057,
-0.17247526347637177,
0.5085148215293884,
-0.044299907982349396,
0.3725059926509857,
0.5203500986099243,
-0.10406114906072617,
0.7294546365737915,
-0.14011375606060028,
0.01027004886418581,
0.21732483804225922,
0.35233333706855774,
0.4267745912075043,
0.33022910356521606,
-0.1906702071428299,
0.028666652739048004,
-0.41069158911705017,
-0.5026383399963379,
-0.7222568988800049,
0.9459443688392639,
-0.4448850154876709,
-0.631965696811676,
-0.2308194488286972,
-0.7587510347366333,
-0.2784227430820465,
-0.054694339632987976,
0.1319032460451126,
0.35456058382987976,
-0.01946163922548294,
0.2445545345544815,
0.4527318775653839,
-0.6060209274291992,
0.19356167316436768,
0.12318843603134155,
-0.22774618864059448,
-0.33107584714889526,
1.0384550094604492,
-0.168882355093956,
0.18355558812618256,
0.11869069933891296,
0.4033445715904236,
-0.4059083163738251,
-0.32897716760635376,
-0.41546687483787537,
0.32517704367637634,
-0.9254384636878967,
-0.06826213747262955,
-0.9139739871025085,
-0.29855382442474365,
-0.3977099657058716,
-0.2110966593027115,
-0.3982987701892853,
-0.5293779373168945,
-0.01727849431335926,
0.06438210606575012,
0.4990723431110382,
1.0230523347854614,
-0.13931424915790558,
0.183635875582695,
-0.7014968395233154,
0.20818157494068146,
0.49927812814712524,
0.31083789467811584,
-0.2276604175567627,
-0.5308693051338196,
0.10882594436407089,
0.002234435873106122,
-0.13904611766338348,
-0.8120415806770325,
0.5965956449508667,
0.2940472960472107,
0.08874548971652985,
0.3007405400276184,
-0.06124455854296684,
0.3895486891269684,
-0.5138530731201172,
0.8495847582817078,
-0.09468167275190353,
-0.8025790452957153,
0.5492910146713257,
-0.5622833967208862,
0.07325811684131622,
0.09822478890419006,
0.3098185956478119,
-0.5347703695297241,
-0.49698930978775024,
-0.6453999876976013,
-0.6508305072784424,
0.5169370770454407,
0.3669157922267914,
0.5743099451065063,
-0.2878012955188751,
0.40559515357017517,
-0.08771618455648422,
0.30452609062194824,
-0.9161820411682129,
0.14369305968284607,
-0.3204922378063202,
-0.302938312292099,
-0.03346409276127815,
-0.21034522354602814,
-0.19229984283447266,
-0.39421531558036804,
0.34805816411972046,
-0.1254521757364273,
0.18896494805812836,
0.020306505262851715,
-0.07032100111246109,
-0.11439573019742966,
0.4661500155925751,
0.6558056473731995,
0.5326042771339417,
-0.2775583863258362,
0.24491947889328003,
0.10705554485321045,
-0.38127249479293823,
-0.14797137677669525,
0.070939801633358,
0.3023275136947632,
-0.06535223871469498,
0.4179936349391937,
0.7146726846694946,
0.39269810914993286,
-0.9600537419319153,
0.4982302188873291,
-0.19549667835235596,
0.01717521995306015,
-0.09724975377321243,
0.24593470990657806,
0.3972126543521881,
0.0539669431746006,
0.10084103047847748,
-0.16950920224189758,
0.29377004504203796,
-0.8542031645774841,
0.2423301637172699,
0.3342600166797638,
-0.072499118745327,
-0.6467230319976807,
0.433547705411911,
0.17236898839473724,
-0.31806480884552,
0.664278507232666,
-0.5363425016403198,
-0.928636372089386,
0.6045724153518677,
0.714343786239624,
0.6936770677566528,
-0.25219598412513733,
0.18933157622814178,
0.08847696334123611,
0.35290902853012085,
-0.013148737139999866,
0.33107003569602966,
0.47459128499031067,
-0.6735691428184509,
-0.3726467788219452,
-0.8713107109069824,
-0.36276525259017944,
0.5231242775917053,
-0.15161563456058502,
0.5493188500404358,
-0.3464091122150421,
0.20576664805412292,
0.2298072725534439,
-0.23749592900276184,
-0.7105787396430969,
0.34756648540496826,
0.10349646955728531,
0.717449963092804,
-0.9596244692802429,
0.8936614990234375,
0.8161360621452332,
-0.2510221302509308,
-0.5836092829704285,
0.13875284790992737,
-0.030027765780687332,
-0.6552863121032715,
0.5317482948303223,
0.27772974967956543,
0.23639117181301117,
-0.03172730654478073,
-0.6548605561256409,
-0.25580883026123047,
0.6133815050125122,
0.5513830184936523,
-0.3858315348625183,
-0.05951113998889923,
0.43483254313468933,
0.716420590877533,
-0.2976182997226715,
0.15432602167129517,
0.7428048849105835,
0.5110370516777039,
0.31385254859924316,
-0.8110011219978333,
0.01577254943549633,
-0.3317473530769348,
-0.21147431433200836,
0.3334832191467285,
-0.35546350479125977,
1.1633330583572388,
-0.3365619480609894,
0.001219501718878746,
-0.20434793829917908,
0.24543140828609467,
0.17812910676002502,
0.5211026668548584,
0.7181899547576904,
0.8605669140815735,
0.400424987077713,
-0.016010047867894173,
1.1037123203277588,
0.13715875148773193,
0.3385615050792694,
1.008379578590393,
-0.6020076274871826,
0.5202617645263672,
0.306726336479187,
-0.20675484836101532,
0.36241841316223145,
0.5075132250785828,
-0.03371446579694748,
0.19559051096439362,
0.3711840510368347,
-0.33215972781181335,
-0.34148144721984863,
0.010050424374639988,
-0.10540582984685898,
0.4486332833766937,
0.46275442838668823,
-0.1633676290512085,
-0.45389991998672485,
0.1521415263414383,
0.37225672602653503,
-0.08304759860038757,
0.08816082030534744,
0.5383373498916626,
0.15851177275180817,
-0.4120500683784485,
0.2828291654586792,
-0.014826360158622265,
0.7335700988769531,
-0.2841684818267822,
-0.17345616221427917,
-0.4524295926094055,
-0.02376028709113598,
-0.22884409129619598,
-1.1872663497924805,
0.49894899129867554,
0.3895095884799957,
0.07128498703241348,
0.4454193115234375,
0.8207307457923889,
-0.5139331817626953,
-0.5260764956474304,
0.35595688223838806,
0.296017050743103,
0.3949333727359772,
-0.3768143653869629,
-0.6603832840919495,
-0.09588999301195145,
-0.006192590110003948,
-0.37890011072158813,
0.44627323746681213,
0.9104011058807373,
-0.2509670853614807,
0.6734856367111206,
1.1429320573806763,
0.20938897132873535,
0.0036510827485471964,
0.3664049208164215,
1.1271699666976929,
-0.9059612154960632,
-0.35178342461586,
-0.8914982676506042,
0.5321534872055054,
-0.30106645822525024,
-0.26333165168762207,
0.2739458382129669,
0.25529664754867554,
0.5461335778236389,
-0.29909318685531616,
0.7410815358161926,
-0.04187789186835289,
0.2275596559047699,
-0.5469821691513062,
0.7986894249916077,
-0.8002229332923889,
0.3131864368915558,
-0.19167709350585938,
-0.9047948122024536,
-0.4460795819759369,
0.22461144626140594,
-0.2871703803539276,
0.254289448261261,
0.666846513748169,
0.9630908370018005,
-0.4516034722328186,
0.06958860903978348,
0.5305647253990173,
0.3563990890979767,
0.6885427236557007,
0.608197808265686,
0.8530483841896057,
-0.16410566866397858,
0.57316654920578,
-0.48747968673706055,
-0.12739993631839752,
-0.24169832468032837,
-1.2260441780090332,
-1.1536052227020264,
-0.23684687912464142,
-0.274539977312088,
-0.13833923637866974,
-0.08206642419099808,
0.6006948947906494,
0.25323328375816345,
-0.5889714956283569,
0.19990377128124237,
-0.053469859063625336,
0.14557071030139923,
0.4007059931755066,
-0.39486590027809143,
0.23073402047157288,
-0.25890690088272095,
-0.7070765495300293,
0.6529721021652222,
0.4806368052959442,
-0.059733469039201736,
-0.27925533056259155,
0.1441241353750229,
-0.08429410308599472,
0.5511499643325806,
0.6713486909866333,
0.25531005859375,
-0.6982529163360596,
-0.5100482106208801,
-0.10882128775119781,
0.0928320437669754,
-0.22661979496479034,
0.7867340445518494,
-0.5096563696861267,
0.46337518095970154,
0.5093534588813782,
0.6975403428077698,
0.024179868400096893,
-0.09277096390724182,
0.36448776721954346,
-1.1641626358032227,
0.32916733622550964,
0.3427790701389313,
0.41642722487449646,
0.8898591995239258,
-0.6082838177680969,
0.6968119144439697,
0.5174002051353455,
-0.7157332897186279,
-1.3345271348953247,
0.11235330253839493,
-1.0187350511550903,
-0.13426800072193146,
1.2266900539398193,
-0.23668032884597778,
-0.27699288725852966,
-0.06279756873846054,
-0.1199689731001854,
0.16325809061527252,
-0.11318734288215637,
0.8038085699081421,
0.8954021334648132,
-0.1842488944530487,
-0.07726045697927475,
-0.8009335994720459,
0.6600818037986755,
0.3477279543876648,
-1.1017162799835205,
0.1511223018169403,
0.1797720193862915,
0.5446594953536987,
0.1753053516149521,
0.5340521335601807,
-0.21068841218948364,
0.4014761447906494,
-0.3443736433982849,
0.03048316016793251,
0.09348122030496597,
-0.3308368921279907,
-0.18148371577262878,
-0.21484169363975525,
0.04248792305588722,
0.5197076797485352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15062v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15062v1
|
Gotcha! Don't trick me with unanswerable questions! Self-aligning Large Language Models for Responding to Unknown Questions
| 2024-02-23T02:24:36 | 2024-02-23T02:24:36 |
Yang Deng, Yong Zhao, Moxin Li, See-Kiong Ng, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite the remarkable abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to answer
questions, they often display a considerable level of overconfidence even when
the question does not have a definitive answer. To avoid providing hallucinated
answers to these unknown questions, existing studies typically investigate
approaches to refusing to answer these questions. In this work, we propose a
novel and scalable self-alignment method to utilize the LLM itself to enhance
its response-ability to different types of unknown questions, being capable of
not only refusing to answer but also providing explanation to the
unanswerability of unknown questions. Specifically, the Self-Align method first
employ a two-stage class-aware self-augmentation approach to generate a large
amount of unknown question-response data. Then we conduct disparity-driven
self-curation to select qualified data for fine-tuning the LLM itself for
aligning the responses to unknown questions as desired. Experimental results on
two datasets across four types of unknown questions validate the superiority of
the Self-Align method over existing baselines in terms of three types of task
formulation.
|
[
-0.46973806619644165,
-1.0238595008850098,
0.644498348236084,
0.2255287617444992,
0.020368877798318863,
0.4117886424064636,
-0.22076444327831268,
-0.12362763285636902,
0.3909250497817993,
0.34048351645469666,
-0.8631520867347717,
-0.1260281801223755,
-0.2511218190193176,
0.12293455749750137,
-0.4568460285663605,
0.8753032088279724,
0.14173094928264618,
-0.04495261237025261,
-0.47022178769111633,
-0.18197663128376007,
-0.6707757115364075,
-0.2440512776374817,
-0.35656407475471497,
-0.15101924538612366,
0.5867213010787964,
0.6412791609764099,
0.6531456708908081,
0.6370136141777039,
0.6652519702911377,
0.3512730002403259,
0.21256878972053528,
0.3598445951938629,
-0.26125845313072205,
0.06632117182016373,
-0.32745736837387085,
-0.35701361298561096,
-0.5213491916656494,
-0.2357279658317566,
0.5473292469978333,
0.5257624983787537,
-0.11911123245954514,
0.541867733001709,
0.02449440397322178,
0.7059729099273682,
-0.572274923324585,
-0.19087110459804535,
-0.8682546615600586,
-0.005081946961581707,
-0.22738641500473022,
-0.18990126252174377,
-0.06395754218101501,
-0.21041709184646606,
-0.1831381767988205,
-0.6099634170532227,
0.19388577342033386,
-0.02226429246366024,
0.4402036666870117,
0.6464781165122986,
-0.21495167911052704,
-0.16461089253425598,
-0.67315274477005,
0.5576779246330261,
-0.7185481786727905,
0.06932315230369568,
0.35065436363220215,
0.4691174030303955,
-0.006705595180392265,
-0.3243144750595093,
-0.7645277976989746,
0.12172739207744598,
-0.179113507270813,
0.2715809643268585,
-0.04976920783519745,
-0.14241358637809753,
0.1459670513868332,
0.36749833822250366,
-0.9709790349006653,
0.3133181929588318,
-0.01554360706359148,
-0.16226427257061005,
0.5658249855041504,
0.0943632423877716,
0.23022784292697906,
0.004334513563662767,
-0.24329455196857452,
0.0263602826744318,
-0.4822688102722168,
0.060653720051050186,
0.35317668318748474,
0.4727213978767395,
0.1282111406326294,
0.9116212129592896,
-0.27718067169189453,
0.8550618290901184,
0.694304883480072,
0.12385335564613342,
-0.0021285752300173044,
-0.22341765463352203,
-0.14057107269763947,
0.030271511524915695,
0.5757856965065002,
0.1463729590177536,
0.02231930010020733,
-0.1921067088842392,
-0.11019550263881683,
-0.1611711084842682,
0.3864801824092865,
-0.5013003945350647,
0.011391503736376762,
0.5391029119491577,
0.0026017422787845135,
-0.2941472828388214,
-0.35678184032440186,
-0.8917116522789001,
-0.36066752672195435,
0.003888224484398961,
0.8717796802520752,
0.05260472744703293,
-0.4097828269004822,
-0.029011888429522514,
0.23539595305919647,
0.3119618594646454,
0.27855291962623596,
-1.0903416872024536,
0.35615697503089905,
0.5054574012756348,
0.5147239565849304,
-0.14598390460014343,
-0.14778055250644684,
-0.5346111059188843,
0.11905919015407562,
-0.5005258321762085,
0.6150593757629395,
-0.5859994292259216,
-0.05691315233707428,
-0.028332708403468132,
-0.04361855983734131,
-0.06624998152256012,
-0.33436793088912964,
0.3162136673927307,
-0.6013718843460083,
0.549118161201477,
-0.41483303904533386,
-0.6646254658699036,
0.053419362753629684,
0.6207897663116455,
-0.3620786964893341,
1.0334570407867432,
0.17368432879447937,
-0.8361505270004272,
-0.24117699265480042,
-0.6410779356956482,
-0.1329091489315033,
0.23530060052871704,
-0.47688063979148865,
-0.36799561977386475,
-0.01443110965192318,
0.6017879247665405,
0.297044962644577,
-0.05145836994051933,
0.30349141359329224,
-0.3736257553100586,
-0.1595439612865448,
0.43868783116340637,
-0.3846094310283661,
0.3451053202152252,
0.19500422477722168,
-0.2739284634590149,
-0.12429545819759369,
-0.7048054933547974,
0.40807923674583435,
0.28192049264907837,
-0.06649403274059296,
-0.2788982093334198,
-0.30926084518432617,
-0.4516914486885071,
0.3345848321914673,
0.7041812539100647,
-0.732822597026825,
0.4275974631309509,
-0.45068687200546265,
0.16072143614292145,
0.7057814598083496,
-0.26229825615882874,
0.4888847768306732,
-0.4941684305667877,
0.6360703110694885,
-0.013455471955239773,
-0.06597630679607391,
-0.0038572102785110474,
-0.27018097043037415,
-0.7268263697624207,
0.20785613358020782,
0.2228582203388214,
0.6197029948234558,
-0.8389475345611572,
0.40532901883125305,
-0.22900046408176422,
-0.6052864789962769,
-0.9347163438796997,
0.19691714644432068,
0.5514474511146545,
0.9051932096481323,
0.6050679087638855,
0.0974762886762619,
-0.4627751410007477,
-0.8987195491790771,
-0.4135032296180725,
-0.2692340016365051,
0.004747688304632902,
0.12635594606399536,
0.25933837890625,
0.06932425498962402,
1.0312570333480835,
-0.7337653636932373,
-0.14357171952724457,
0.07396866381168365,
0.0590224526822567,
-0.08449392765760422,
0.6372041702270508,
0.28119975328445435,
-0.5718286633491516,
-0.29046884179115295,
-0.021392488852143288,
-0.5456389784812927,
-0.02691696584224701,
-0.13314032554626465,
0.033609941601753235,
0.10683448612689972,
0.5947142243385315,
-0.5376557111740112,
0.06904605031013489,
0.5220143795013428,
-0.03894665837287903,
0.38576218485832214,
-0.4252403974533081,
0.14829306304454803,
-1.1434710025787354,
0.1528143733739853,
-0.18490706384181976,
-0.12255392223596573,
-0.6333944201469421,
0.0073839458636939526,
0.5294292569160461,
-0.2197350561618805,
-0.12768056988716125,
0.7882082462310791,
-0.5143274664878845,
0.18732300400733948,
-0.30283933877944946,
0.15346863865852356,
-0.12849341332912445,
0.6025388240814209,
-0.14825329184532166,
0.754550576210022,
0.6133399605751038,
-0.6178118586540222,
0.22403690218925476,
0.5064996480941772,
-0.09488615393638611,
0.5837159156799316,
-0.6221278309822083,
0.5272657871246338,
-0.5107658505439758,
-0.07490120083093643,
-1.3159934282302856,
-0.4019898474216461,
0.2859131693840027,
-0.6714189648628235,
0.5223000049591064,
-0.19954316318035126,
-0.08070287853479385,
-0.7153967022895813,
-0.0065805912017822266,
0.5911359190940857,
0.3035837411880493,
-0.6095882058143616,
0.696717381477356,
0.18315063416957855,
-0.25591808557510376,
-0.9898108839988708,
-0.792328953742981,
-0.15849527716636658,
-0.43540656566619873,
-0.5014588236808777,
0.26038146018981934,
-0.6922966241836548,
-0.07930073887109756,
-0.05184508115053177,
-0.39996063709259033,
-0.23022454977035522,
0.1443793922662735,
0.11450791358947754,
0.35106927156448364,
-0.2524797320365906,
0.3894803524017334,
0.1650051772594452,
-0.008593237958848476,
-0.08030039072036743,
-0.15328949689865112,
0.4529627859592438,
-0.055217694491147995,
-0.5960511565208435,
-0.2110150009393692,
0.3176780939102173,
0.5273588299751282,
-0.42160481214523315,
0.4037681221961975,
0.38820844888687134,
-0.2959136962890625,
-0.14542633295059204,
-0.8580582141876221,
-0.23907425999641418,
-0.5570797324180603,
0.32426944375038147,
-0.32611608505249023,
-1.169445514678955,
0.5227056741714478,
0.21025319397449493,
0.11091525852680206,
0.14187228679656982,
0.5895369648933411,
-0.05548890307545662,
1.0989326238632202,
0.4405125081539154,
-0.2304808795452118,
-0.0017902780091390014,
0.3117855191230774,
0.4855356216430664,
-0.5534790754318237,
-0.3121371269226074,
-0.6345875859260559,
-0.3153722286224365,
-0.6207847595214844,
-0.46650224924087524,
0.275177001953125,
-0.3281370997428894,
-0.2440033257007599,
0.27579930424690247,
-0.5670315027236938,
0.5426434874534607,
0.1883712261915207,
-0.07075691223144531,
0.3049127459526062,
-0.19562597572803497,
0.2959299385547638,
0.06944012641906738,
-0.6097003221511841,
-0.10073622316122055,
1.0855698585510254,
0.27986761927604675,
0.9308512210845947,
0.15905514359474182,
0.678559422492981,
0.16725865006446838,
0.08470712602138519,
-0.6784307956695557,
0.4731113314628601,
0.17547814548015594,
-0.9265455603599548,
-0.803674578666687,
-0.42729517817497253,
-0.8363879323005676,
0.37077128887176514,
-0.12164214998483658,
-0.594524621963501,
0.03138507902622223,
0.34610456228256226,
-0.6760016083717346,
0.24772149324417114,
-0.5875075459480286,
0.6304150819778442,
-0.5338284373283386,
-0.10852988809347153,
0.15823613107204437,
-0.6511995792388916,
0.3979228138923645,
-0.48683834075927734,
0.36320093274116516,
-0.06523740291595459,
-0.16636516153812408,
0.5794403553009033,
-0.31521251797676086,
0.7124959230422974,
-0.016414400190114975,
-0.4004066586494446,
0.14131584763526917,
0.2071661353111267,
0.5916498899459839,
0.04979069530963898,
0.029345355927944183,
-0.2628941237926483,
-0.05184771120548248,
-0.43406203389167786,
-1.1064062118530273,
0.9404453039169312,
-0.5586971640586853,
-0.9839543104171753,
-0.2813241481781006,
-0.732869029045105,
-0.6711435317993164,
0.2525690495967865,
0.23108530044555664,
0.253844678401947,
-0.13613593578338623,
-0.3068072199821472,
0.6360812187194824,
0.11603032052516937,
0.604357898235321,
0.8852752447128296,
-0.2083023339509964,
-0.4472459852695465,
0.9231332540512085,
0.30748581886291504,
0.40389183163642883,
0.4415530562400818,
0.13878068327903748,
-0.6271780133247375,
-0.4300726056098938,
-0.5883217453956604,
0.3533218801021576,
-0.42697858810424805,
-0.37870877981185913,
-0.687968909740448,
-0.2223360389471054,
-0.8050196766853333,
0.022040314972400665,
-0.5241281986236572,
-0.6193177700042725,
-0.09652558714151382,
-0.1739863157272339,
0.14844748377799988,
0.4686208963394165,
-0.22439704835414886,
0.21491554379463196,
-0.5368008017539978,
0.18084363639354706,
0.6949340105056763,
0.4036848545074463,
0.03708818554878235,
-0.832942008972168,
-0.05175449699163437,
0.24979953467845917,
-0.2646137475967407,
-0.6827892065048218,
0.26970189809799194,
-0.05697403848171234,
0.481753408908844,
0.32200318574905396,
0.382081001996994,
1.0335495471954346,
-0.42929354310035706,
0.3302392065525055,
0.2226484715938568,
-0.8895344138145447,
0.5633732080459595,
-0.2491983026266098,
0.2803439199924469,
0.6759603023529053,
0.5152051448822021,
-0.39058026671409607,
-0.582729160785675,
-0.6387653350830078,
-0.6325286626815796,
0.36430153250694275,
0.2324809730052948,
0.40660834312438965,
0.09465363621711731,
0.507556140422821,
0.08434340357780457,
0.29218265414237976,
-0.9129356145858765,
-0.5007922053337097,
-0.262831449508667,
-0.18700623512268066,
-0.14621460437774658,
0.004983449820429087,
-0.2747974991798401,
-0.323731392621994,
0.6760214567184448,
-0.3436683118343353,
-0.017893986776471138,
0.2779480814933777,
-0.013919792138040066,
-0.4717954397201538,
0.42557018995285034,
0.4504333734512329,
0.6459563970565796,
-0.21350504457950592,
0.20329484343528748,
0.21743637323379517,
-0.1692817509174347,
0.24222926795482635,
0.10441235452890396,
-0.10614719241857529,
-0.34517064690589905,
-0.011729822494089603,
0.3920421600341797,
-0.2062862366437912,
-0.5260069966316223,
0.4808639585971832,
-0.178214892745018,
-0.21964122354984283,
-0.2515697777271271,
0.05598956719040871,
0.1179397702217102,
0.2254275381565094,
0.3269558548927307,
-0.2911054193973541,
-0.24726487696170807,
-0.33782312273979187,
0.056401003152132034,
0.8299795389175415,
-0.4491872787475586,
-0.16038061678409576,
0.569139301776886,
0.01819782517850399,
-0.4705246388912201,
0.5056583285331726,
-0.07205717265605927,
-0.2063346654176712,
0.5761151313781738,
0.8430747389793396,
0.4986776113510132,
-0.5287036895751953,
0.560651957988739,
0.4044564366340637,
0.33716657757759094,
0.06686514616012573,
0.21691292524337769,
-0.07578205317258835,
-0.7791205048561096,
-0.4365982711315155,
-0.40677303075790405,
-0.3654952943325043,
0.6064401268959045,
-0.7760273218154907,
-0.08417841047048569,
-0.4519708752632141,
0.07047532498836517,
0.07590337097644806,
-0.07620960474014282,
-0.43466436862945557,
0.3167879283428192,
-0.03123604692518711,
0.7529182434082031,
-0.8406596183776855,
0.5651430487632751,
0.5683131217956543,
-0.4928659498691559,
-0.9593825936317444,
0.32710710167884827,
-0.18682725727558136,
-1.1524827480316162,
0.10229658335447311,
-0.005205081310123205,
-0.027956295758485794,
0.39517268538475037,
-0.7814263701438904,
-1.2016748189926147,
0.8707914352416992,
0.29687440395355225,
-0.6621020436286926,
0.04601847007870674,
0.36046522855758667,
0.4554179310798645,
-0.28381597995758057,
0.2346922755241394,
0.45137038826942444,
0.5853058695793152,
0.267690509557724,
-0.8593096733093262,
0.17537231743335724,
-0.17563076317310333,
-0.28157296776771545,
0.23452259600162506,
-0.7052780985832214,
0.5880990624427795,
-0.38138481974601746,
-0.02284577675163746,
0.3135426640510559,
0.643919050693512,
0.01409977301955223,
0.19837915897369385,
0.5457326173782349,
0.6220906376838684,
1.046306848526001,
0.04293586686253548,
0.577436089515686,
-0.2022789567708969,
0.33029621839523315,
1.3855034112930298,
-0.29784679412841797,
0.5134655833244324,
0.5340299010276794,
0.008353913202881813,
0.36353495717048645,
0.5255207419395447,
-0.06864955276250839,
0.4603893756866455,
0.3166654109954834,
-0.1979212760925293,
-0.6241656541824341,
0.23337598145008087,
-0.527743399143219,
0.5276885628700256,
0.151115283370018,
0.29323291778564453,
-0.4434387683868408,
0.04285915568470955,
-0.0850282832980156,
0.3564424216747284,
-0.46054601669311523,
0.7470075488090515,
-0.2577213943004608,
-1.0261788368225098,
0.6995383501052856,
-0.1496453732252121,
0.49175429344177246,
-0.5884557366371155,
0.17325228452682495,
-0.4845387637615204,
-0.003251480869948864,
-0.23923563957214355,
-0.9522973299026489,
0.21710720658302307,
0.0353998988866806,
-0.21730712056159973,
-0.02109459787607193,
0.5538692474365234,
-0.7406690120697021,
-0.6021749377250671,
-0.012494247406721115,
0.881876528263092,
0.10753363370895386,
-0.11213700473308563,
-0.8249925374984741,
-0.4462016522884369,
-0.07277430593967438,
0.11597710847854614,
0.5005375146865845,
0.5358765125274658,
0.06284932047128677,
1.035786509513855,
0.38502171635627747,
-0.239986389875412,
-0.09453906118869781,
-0.11551030725240707,
0.8817098736763,
-0.5405372381210327,
-0.3137149512767792,
-0.757434606552124,
0.6574543118476868,
0.07009608298540115,
-0.20051318407058716,
1.0004826784133911,
0.5787251591682434,
0.7449326515197754,
-0.019890597090125084,
0.7153749465942383,
0.01763434335589409,
0.817659854888916,
-0.2573876976966858,
0.5059061646461487,
-0.8421377539634705,
0.23641175031661987,
-0.4581451714038849,
-0.6024048328399658,
-0.0777965858578682,
0.3226487934589386,
-0.24217048287391663,
0.056677233427762985,
0.5245603919029236,
1.044153094291687,
0.033323679119348526,
-0.26866236329078674,
0.4489263594150543,
0.09717965126037598,
0.11659672111272812,
0.3006478548049927,
0.8265284299850464,
-0.07660702615976334,
0.6311279535293579,
-0.23549827933311462,
-0.1604045033454895,
0.04794076085090637,
-0.6764155030250549,
-0.7712255716323853,
-0.6235899329185486,
-0.341438889503479,
-0.4605563282966614,
-0.09534040093421936,
0.5954339504241943,
0.4254972040653229,
-0.7477508783340454,
-0.12570619583129883,
0.04027310758829117,
0.3278072476387024,
-0.01706888899207115,
-0.12686803936958313,
0.3402540981769562,
-0.6166724562644958,
-0.6520594954490662,
0.6030016541481018,
0.18620134890079498,
0.4609370231628418,
-0.37145179510116577,
0.11689357459545135,
-0.14641766250133514,
0.2647675573825836,
0.09176044911146164,
0.5675811767578125,
-0.5583778023719788,
-0.3916487395763397,
0.38176560401916504,
0.16367749869823456,
0.22178415954113007,
0.6972740292549133,
-0.5146033763885498,
0.46448057889938354,
0.09564969688653946,
0.8744994401931763,
0.24607990682125092,
0.475598007440567,
0.23576122522354126,
-0.8656789064407349,
-0.0848224088549614,
0.3967844843864441,
-0.02287312038242817,
0.3016120195388794,
-0.6785714030265808,
0.15676560997962952,
-0.10464610159397125,
-0.6465391516685486,
-0.8350669145584106,
0.30127984285354614,
-1.0315643548965454,
-0.40342801809310913,
0.7447129487991333,
0.20226921141147614,
-0.1361479014158249,
-0.11567983776330948,
-0.032621610909700394,
0.08776111900806427,
-0.045260246843099594,
1.0686520338058472,
0.7079235911369324,
-0.22150076925754547,
-0.0637836754322052,
-0.15378037095069885,
0.4085279703140259,
0.8655756115913391,
-0.8984931111335754,
0.3110768795013428,
0.45601731538772583,
0.5561944246292114,
0.24130475521087646,
0.6248536109924316,
-0.04046177119016647,
0.08289235830307007,
-0.3980233371257782,
-0.15238666534423828,
-0.03179635852575302,
-0.2974461317062378,
-0.52013099193573,
0.19938571751117706,
0.0778060257434845,
-0.3114587664604187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15061v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15061v1
|
Fine-tuning Large Language Models for Domain-specific Machine Translation
| 2024-02-23T02:24:15 | 2024-02-23T02:24:15 |
Jiawei Zheng, Hanghai Hong, Xiaoli Wang, Jingsong Su, Yonggui Liang, Shikai Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have made significant progress in machine
translation (MT). However, their potential in domain-specific MT remains
under-explored. Current LLM-based MT systems still face several challenges.
First, for LLMs with in-context learning, their effectiveness is highly
sensitive to input translation examples, and processing them can increase
inference costs. They often require extra post-processing due to
over-generation. Second, LLMs with fine-tuning on domain-specific data often
require high training costs for domain adaptation, and may weaken the zero-shot
MT capabilities of LLMs due to over-specialization. The aforementioned methods
can struggle to translate rare words in domain transfer scenarios. To address
these challenges, this paper proposes a prompt-oriented fine-tuning method,
denoted as LlamaIT, to effectively and efficiently fine-tune a general-purpose
LLM for domain-specific MT tasks. First, we construct a task-specific
mix-domain dataset, which is then used to fine-tune the LLM with LoRA. This can
eliminate the need for input translation examples, post-processing, or
over-specialization. By zero-shot prompting with instructions, we adapt the MT
tasks to the target domain at inference time. To further elicit the MT
capability for rare words, we construct new prompts by incorporating
domain-specific bilingual vocabulary. We also conduct extensive experiments on
both publicly available and self-constructed datasets. The results show that
our LlamaIT can significantly enhance the domain-specific MT capabilities of
the LLM, meanwhile preserving its zero-shot MT capabilities.
|
[
-0.3634583055973053,
-0.9272720217704773,
0.563115119934082,
0.14597482979297638,
-0.5328365564346313,
0.022212158888578415,
-0.5099694132804871,
-0.22962236404418945,
0.05114271119236946,
0.7635771036148071,
-0.7643605470657349,
-0.6544535756111145,
-0.6836631894111633,
0.4932878315448761,
-0.016857758164405823,
0.9959651231765747,
-0.3405119478702545,
-0.2622608244419098,
0.20606629550457,
-0.2594619691371918,
-0.9272668957710266,
-0.3674803078174591,
-0.635183572769165,
-0.21249589323997498,
0.6046174764633179,
0.7189487814903259,
0.47137194871902466,
0.6248202323913574,
0.292961448431015,
0.1863321214914322,
-0.03755540773272514,
0.7210736274719238,
-0.6744014620780945,
0.22914038598537445,
-0.38351309299468994,
-0.4698410630226135,
-0.6637960076332092,
-0.32981348037719727,
0.6055287718772888,
0.7676268219947815,
0.17737595736980438,
0.1609698086977005,
0.24025431275367737,
0.3878636658191681,
-0.41531339287757874,
0.08825819194316864,
-1.0077053308486938,
-0.10225792229175568,
-0.30369287729263306,
-0.6542013883590698,
-0.35430142283439636,
-0.08295133709907532,
-0.09720971435308456,
-0.6672802567481995,
0.05232501029968262,
0.17598479986190796,
0.8095945119857788,
0.37058374285697937,
-0.48934265971183777,
0.007391905877739191,
-0.4977802634239197,
1.0250848531723022,
-0.7813997268676758,
0.08690841495990753,
0.45266565680503845,
0.23243704438209534,
-0.45283210277557373,
-0.33305779099464417,
-0.5108628869056702,
-0.1290680170059204,
0.135673388838768,
-0.2546692490577698,
-0.32797810435295105,
-0.08382325619459152,
0.26126039028167725,
0.16153326630592346,
-0.6921665072441101,
0.4811667799949646,
0.08114252984523773,
0.03745424747467041,
0.4269854724407196,
0.4318956136703491,
0.247390478849411,
0.14105622470378876,
-0.20525483787059784,
0.15826790034770966,
-0.982461154460907,
-0.07860348373651505,
0.1281059831380844,
0.7285069823265076,
0.0028945563826709986,
0.6879104375839233,
-0.477380633354187,
0.7833751440048218,
0.28570863604545593,
-0.09871162474155426,
0.3818521499633789,
-0.08156003057956696,
-0.26907363533973694,
-0.1429305225610733,
0.48477816581726074,
0.3899831473827362,
0.4534651041030884,
-0.17655400931835175,
-0.43369290232658386,
-0.24546894431114197,
0.0061981650069355965,
-0.9857524037361145,
0.16667838394641876,
0.1777551770210266,
-0.045013606548309326,
-0.10378386825323105,
-0.4757545590400696,
-0.3582310974597931,
-0.23107725381851196,
-0.5474486947059631,
0.593224048614502,
-0.45571503043174744,
0.13015136122703552,
0.3063056468963623,
0.318994402885437,
0.05644060671329498,
0.5636906027793884,
-0.7888622283935547,
0.005243430845439434,
0.5535211563110352,
0.8270534873008728,
-0.572870135307312,
-0.4863881766796112,
-1.034572720527649,
0.20367199182510376,
-0.19773581624031067,
0.8347145318984985,
-0.5661588907241821,
-0.33375054597854614,
0.1203928217291832,
0.3016418218612671,
-0.22756892442703247,
-0.7081570625305176,
0.5748227834701538,
-0.5782751441001892,
-0.07209036499261856,
-0.13471519947052002,
-0.49305057525634766,
-0.13489143550395966,
0.4278613030910492,
-0.24252566695213318,
0.7482585906982422,
0.15190452337265015,
-0.35400962829589844,
0.21173210442066193,
-0.5487589836120605,
-0.902588427066803,
0.14396248757839203,
0.13982714712619781,
-0.3116953372955322,
0.2542738616466522,
0.5341472625732422,
0.7644600868225098,
-0.5412363409996033,
0.33721596002578735,
-0.06425399333238602,
-0.34487879276275635,
0.14942482113838196,
-0.37292322516441345,
0.5116705298423767,
0.25320589542388916,
-0.17706654965877533,
0.1353023648262024,
-0.7395195960998535,
0.029414011165499687,
0.11513357609510422,
-0.3312091529369354,
-0.3359796404838562,
-0.28042441606521606,
-0.058128926903009415,
0.051054030656814575,
0.3570558726787567,
-0.3206988275051117,
0.5859960317611694,
-0.407665878534317,
0.42198145389556885,
0.665254533290863,
0.07520047575235367,
0.46784383058547974,
-0.2974400818347931,
0.633063554763794,
0.03974178060889244,
-0.08565685153007507,
-0.3229193091392517,
-0.42922499775886536,
-0.7704458832740784,
-0.48643237352371216,
0.264367938041687,
0.6901103854179382,
-0.8653638362884521,
0.5087049007415771,
-0.3551606833934784,
-0.10280812531709671,
-0.5844206213951111,
0.36434251070022583,
0.16452643275260925,
0.6153252124786377,
0.577691376209259,
-0.26473352313041687,
-0.14202827215194702,
-0.7961884140968323,
-0.2339736968278885,
0.46343013644218445,
-0.08532385528087616,
0.5096447467803955,
0.3598763346672058,
-0.45623108744621277,
0.747236967086792,
-0.5764567852020264,
-0.5591396689414978,
-0.3613958954811096,
0.10723522305488586,
0.5658570528030396,
0.4227215349674225,
0.3642023205757141,
-0.5182397365570068,
-0.6462506055831909,
0.3227464258670807,
-0.4306495785713196,
-0.5359983444213867,
-0.24586328864097595,
-0.12076328694820404,
0.03393018618226051,
0.2819923162460327,
-0.7330397963523865,
0.06323597580194473,
0.45657798647880554,
-0.16903945803642273,
0.22590065002441406,
-0.30172199010849,
0.25377577543258667,
-1.0275648832321167,
0.10768898576498032,
-0.17163589596748352,
-0.3475441336631775,
-0.6292321085929871,
0.13597048819065094,
0.13094376027584076,
0.049915019422769547,
-0.61687833070755,
0.8300202488899231,
-0.33251702785491943,
0.26753875613212585,
-0.5751038789749146,
0.16838619112968445,
0.012224304489791393,
0.6539729833602905,
-0.09030724316835403,
0.818348228931427,
0.6215900778770447,
-0.7954819202423096,
0.07047507166862488,
0.2872428894042969,
-0.18617379665374756,
0.7169956564903259,
-0.6242192983627319,
0.14919866621494293,
0.04161227494478226,
0.22639977931976318,
-0.7450668811798096,
-0.16510803997516632,
0.3588252365589142,
-0.27002695202827454,
0.47974371910095215,
-0.31516289710998535,
-0.5847783088684082,
0.007163607515394688,
-0.033770013600587845,
0.3617551028728485,
0.4809717535972595,
-0.6179543733596802,
0.4431750178337097,
-0.03845817223191261,
-0.38462942838668823,
-0.4329076111316681,
-0.5523956418037415,
0.34352487325668335,
-0.3081473112106323,
-0.49758100509643555,
0.3228818476200104,
-0.2047904133796692,
0.09268785268068314,
-0.27606576681137085,
0.0401516817510128,
-0.015994613990187645,
0.23606042563915253,
0.20494595170021057,
0.09355948120355606,
-0.26111069321632385,
-0.08034346252679825,
0.5049042105674744,
-0.2227201610803604,
-0.41891732811927795,
-0.45334604382514954,
0.5914654731750488,
0.06950967013835907,
-0.24324564635753632,
-0.4501059055328369,
0.36276838183403015,
0.4988030195236206,
-0.4650155007839203,
0.6699925661087036,
0.5342722535133362,
-0.20967255532741547,
-0.6812207698822021,
-0.3531409204006195,
-0.13965824246406555,
-0.44782209396362305,
0.39509475231170654,
-0.7131414413452148,
-1.2495241165161133,
0.40999287366867065,
-0.4954681992530823,
0.062265388667583466,
0.36322668194770813,
0.7820385694503784,
0.1428358405828476,
0.9415767788887024,
0.6126867532730103,
-0.17353388667106628,
0.2839847505092621,
-0.22586007416248322,
0.15199314057826996,
-0.8264126181602478,
0.25634440779685974,
-0.43809202313423157,
-0.4502781331539154,
-0.24120938777923584,
-0.5477848649024963,
0.15536411106586456,
0.1800149828195572,
-0.24341706931591034,
0.5770439505577087,
-0.1855410635471344,
0.6096851229667664,
0.260990709066391,
-0.12184451520442963,
0.5579308271408081,
0.20547819137573242,
-0.06382481753826141,
-0.06552998721599579,
-0.5910031199455261,
-0.4645628333091736,
0.9031463861465454,
0.23849351704120636,
0.6577408313751221,
0.009260647930204868,
0.4884442687034607,
0.24200502038002014,
0.26458486914634705,
-0.8330847024917603,
0.5173861980438232,
-0.3347829282283783,
-0.1384439468383789,
-0.2952636778354645,
-0.43285098671913147,
-0.9967498183250427,
0.2609062194824219,
-0.07358559221029282,
-0.5296739339828491,
-0.007672049570828676,
0.18777212500572205,
-0.3395068347454071,
0.17160937190055847,
-0.3712998032569885,
0.7224538922309875,
-0.19613687694072723,
-0.22862567007541656,
-0.2222592979669571,
-0.4616908133029938,
0.19093012809753418,
-0.5856723189353943,
0.09904775768518448,
-0.3780076503753662,
-0.06660942733287811,
0.10750487446784973,
-0.20941466093063354,
1.0568286180496216,
0.050465356558561325,
-0.5024229288101196,
0.12066172063350677,
0.45086032152175903,
0.8521096706390381,
-0.002642845967784524,
-0.1252320110797882,
0.23336531221866608,
-0.3126080334186554,
-0.34822797775268555,
-0.5341207385063171,
0.890250027179718,
-0.6406263709068298,
-0.7191978693008423,
0.02131034806370735,
-0.7703949213027954,
-0.4823804199695587,
0.2501528859138489,
0.294959157705307,
0.2153657227754593,
-0.07192999124526978,
-0.061479974538087845,
0.6874420046806335,
-0.32769089937210083,
0.11309266090393066,
0.8162187337875366,
-0.043843261897563934,
-0.22730670869350433,
0.9872329235076904,
-0.09808637946844101,
0.3327764570713043,
0.6964974999427795,
0.030662372708320618,
-0.015299614518880844,
-0.8204469084739685,
-0.7939530611038208,
0.29997584223747253,
-0.5203405618667603,
-0.551344096660614,
-0.6341993808746338,
0.21120363473892212,
-0.17323057353496552,
-0.3276202976703644,
-0.22125539183616638,
-0.39885056018829346,
-0.595356285572052,
0.15557849407196045,
0.543363630771637,
0.26966506242752075,
0.17731723189353943,
0.647919237613678,
-0.8813843727111816,
0.5061520338058472,
0.10735084861516953,
0.23759901523590088,
-0.13475528359413147,
-1.150830864906311,
-0.3011901378631592,
-0.04150647670030594,
-0.15984679758548737,
-0.3726408779621124,
0.5695052742958069,
0.40214911103248596,
0.3249354660511017,
0.254112184047699,
0.2071220427751541,
0.7263240218162537,
-0.9096906781196594,
0.6410603523254395,
-0.07751494646072388,
-0.8903635144233704,
0.5239790081977844,
-0.5300566554069519,
0.3390078842639923,
0.4201955497264862,
0.3203522264957428,
-0.49969032406806946,
-0.38283321261405945,
-0.12570519745349884,
-0.7982678413391113,
0.6132330894470215,
-0.04338869825005531,
0.4231429994106293,
-0.05670495703816414,
0.4216582775115967,
0.5507247447967529,
0.10204670578241348,
-0.3807956874370575,
-0.15144862234592438,
0.259472519159317,
-0.1791103035211563,
-0.24305817484855652,
-0.002365673426538706,
-0.04376136139035225,
-0.075234554708004,
0.6118775606155396,
-0.4781191647052765,
-0.2495017647743225,
-0.0291039627045393,
-0.44330310821533203,
-0.4059613049030304,
0.5489926338195801,
0.6259955167770386,
0.5410474538803101,
-0.07180704176425934,
0.07167167216539383,
0.6841519474983215,
-0.2125566154718399,
0.1659337431192398,
0.06054225564002991,
-0.27225661277770996,
-0.10682905465364456,
0.17344608902931213,
0.93822181224823,
0.0888860821723938,
-0.7793503403663635,
0.4553588628768921,
0.17577967047691345,
-0.19992130994796753,
0.14846813678741455,
0.1483953297138214,
-0.1683100312948227,
0.3661263883113861,
0.25547918677330017,
0.09791328758001328,
-0.12408143281936646,
-0.3446515202522278,
0.006982896942645311,
0.4427156150341034,
-0.06877429038286209,
-0.3953106701374054,
0.6078489422798157,
0.23491761088371277,
-0.3184819221496582,
0.3121181130409241,
-0.15734505653381348,
-0.4092969000339508,
0.24669091403484344,
0.726409912109375,
0.87741619348526,
-0.11781254410743713,
0.037411708384752274,
0.07769288867712021,
0.19686400890350342,
-0.18364425003528595,
0.1516428291797638,
-0.033247269690036774,
-0.6192184686660767,
-0.7977219223976135,
-0.6236607432365417,
-0.3514200448989868,
0.2706828713417053,
-0.2893633246421814,
0.39017924666404724,
-0.2680181860923767,
-0.09301259368658066,
-0.2972106337547302,
-0.07596737146377563,
-0.8012517094612122,
0.15772153437137604,
0.04012993350625038,
0.8499429821968079,
-0.6688564419746399,
1.020512342453003,
0.5983147621154785,
-0.15531492233276367,
-0.45099011063575745,
-0.10356546193361282,
-0.26142531633377075,
-1.011112928390503,
0.7660684585571289,
-0.06114811822772026,
-0.30087578296661377,
0.19777731597423553,
-0.5550234317779541,
-0.740252673625946,
0.9139506816864014,
0.6121441721916199,
-0.8974521160125732,
0.21214033663272858,
0.3855231702327728,
0.4757658541202545,
-0.3974993824958801,
-0.25514400005340576,
0.5621500611305237,
0.5163363814353943,
-0.07558302581310272,
-1.019714593887329,
0.2137412279844284,
-0.06409213691949844,
-0.04817819595336914,
0.24148254096508026,
-0.4751676023006439,
0.736840546131134,
-0.24292674660682678,
-0.10936865210533142,
0.3053762912750244,
0.49661993980407715,
0.1643267571926117,
0.1201949417591095,
0.3899172842502594,
0.47555407881736755,
0.6737270951271057,
0.24780277907848358,
0.8891046047210693,
-0.22957681119441986,
0.17139123380184174,
1.0949106216430664,
-0.5453104376792908,
0.9015031456947327,
0.5657680034637451,
0.190986767411232,
-0.04892968758940697,
0.4317270517349243,
-0.09706563502550125,
0.4807639420032501,
0.30369165539741516,
-0.1828428953886032,
-0.4500478506088257,
-0.33020731806755066,
-0.33887770771980286,
0.23132148385047913,
0.384473592042923,
-0.26603057980537415,
-0.23834939301013947,
0.18280896544456482,
0.06594835966825485,
-0.022156869992613792,
-0.37790536880493164,
0.5702734589576721,
0.28383514285087585,
-0.5701158046722412,
0.9296565055847168,
0.2756189703941345,
0.7118974328041077,
-0.5304552912712097,
-0.028133172541856766,
-0.5361056327819824,
0.273962140083313,
-0.03282187506556511,
-0.6373069882392883,
-0.0024495841935276985,
0.2878604233264923,
-0.14797620475292206,
-0.38500943779945374,
0.601915180683136,
-0.4988856911659241,
-0.26388636231422424,
0.21253839135169983,
0.7762405872344971,
0.1782841682434082,
-0.3503051698207855,
-0.4433414936065674,
0.08955595642328262,
0.169651597738266,
-0.3037349581718445,
0.5677760243415833,
0.9434004426002502,
-0.20986205339431763,
0.6311415433883667,
0.5878702998161316,
0.24986054003238678,
-0.18978989124298096,
0.29812806844711304,
0.8116863965988159,
-0.6595277190208435,
-0.3083418011665344,
-0.8005748987197876,
0.41739097237586975,
0.36422887444496155,
-0.5773391127586365,
0.6614071726799011,
0.3216485381126404,
0.7375474572181702,
-0.25311407446861267,
0.7561585903167725,
0.35475611686706543,
0.4599381685256958,
-0.5722647905349731,
0.5727614760398865,
-0.7159739136695862,
0.32471439242362976,
-0.06503485143184662,
-1.1119908094406128,
-0.640687882900238,
0.3285102844238281,
-0.2684863805770874,
-0.3041069209575653,
0.489965558052063,
0.7999454736709595,
-0.25484687089920044,
-0.3268849551677704,
0.5758379101753235,
0.286965012550354,
0.27170583605766296,
0.6419171690940857,
0.7448348999023438,
-0.2650281488895416,
0.545653760433197,
0.16730280220508575,
-0.18692009150981903,
-0.4195621907711029,
-0.9755560755729675,
-1.0498799085617065,
-0.33825498819351196,
-0.394781231880188,
0.009408663026988506,
0.16218695044517517,
1.0473049879074097,
0.5409750938415527,
-0.906539261341095,
-0.0733623132109642,
0.19024991989135742,
-0.03975449502468109,
-0.11829982697963715,
-0.11753016710281372,
0.3655543625354767,
-0.5200644731521606,
-0.7741667032241821,
0.7054836750030518,
0.3920694887638092,
-0.00045290388516150415,
0.22467495501041412,
-0.05184326693415642,
0.24599996209144592,
0.05035939812660217,
0.8670994639396667,
0.26677608489990234,
-0.6770829558372498,
-0.2758466899394989,
0.13155579566955566,
-0.09321048110723495,
0.14180238544940948,
0.6902448534965515,
-0.5996120572090149,
0.05979868769645691,
0.2266806960105896,
1.0019134283065796,
0.37630951404571533,
-0.060462597757577896,
0.6413254141807556,
-0.820059597492218,
-0.018165431916713715,
0.18506066501140594,
0.3834195137023926,
0.3411271572113037,
-0.39833715558052063,
0.3250863552093506,
0.016150949522852898,
-0.5374398827552795,
-0.7080665826797485,
0.2568087577819824,
-1.070871353149414,
-0.28990957140922546,
1.2309017181396484,
-0.014997288584709167,
-0.07836751639842987,
-0.013290837407112122,
-0.5407640337944031,
0.14868929982185364,
-0.4910989999771118,
0.5879659652709961,
0.3897119164466858,
0.021018441766500473,
-0.022503681480884552,
-0.5787053108215332,
0.307691365480423,
0.6057398319244385,
-0.7085816860198975,
0.3367662727832794,
0.3386589288711548,
0.352640300989151,
-0.2876048684120178,
0.2985574007034302,
0.22191430628299713,
0.02373482473194599,
-0.5970690250396729,
-0.12171512842178345,
-0.18002009391784668,
-0.2769749164581299,
-0.6022118330001831,
-0.009787810035049915,
0.16635189950466156,
-0.08018271625041962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15059v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15059v1
|
ColBERT-XM: A Modular Multi-Vector Representation Model for Zero-Shot Multilingual Information Retrieval
| 2024-02-23T02:21:24 | 2024-02-23T02:21:24 |
Antoine Louis, Vageesh Saxena, Gijs van Dijck, Gerasimos Spanakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
State-of-the-art neural retrievers predominantly focus on high-resource
languages like English, which impedes their adoption in retrieval scenarios
involving other languages. Current approaches circumvent the lack of
high-quality labeled data in non-English languages by leveraging multilingual
pretrained language models capable of cross-lingual transfer. However, these
models require substantial task-specific fine-tuning across multiple languages,
often perform poorly in languages with minimal representation in the
pretraining corpus, and struggle to incorporate new languages after the
pretraining phase. In this work, we present a novel modular dense retrieval
model that learns from the rich data of a single high-resource language and
effectively zero-shot transfers to a wide array of languages, thereby
eliminating the need for language-specific labeled data. Our model, ColBERT-XM,
demonstrates competitive performance against existing state-of-the-art
multilingual retrievers trained on more extensive datasets in various
languages. Further analysis reveals that our modular approach is highly
data-efficient, effectively adapts to out-of-distribution data, and
significantly reduces energy consumption and carbon emissions. By demonstrating
its proficiency in zero-shot scenarios, ColBERT-XM marks a shift towards more
sustainable and inclusive retrieval systems, enabling effective information
accessibility in numerous languages. We publicly release our code and models
for the community.
|
[
-0.05280499532818794,
-0.3913936913013458,
0.36010509729385376,
0.08138158917427063,
-0.17803102731704712,
0.16532108187675476,
-0.4312790036201477,
-0.17961765825748444,
0.4342760145664215,
0.2178950309753418,
0.03218255192041397,
-0.6447476744651794,
-0.5898869037628174,
0.04452475905418396,
-0.29536673426628113,
0.8080019354820251,
0.20531874895095825,
0.15210142731666565,
0.011385736055672169,
-0.2350769340991974,
-0.321968674659729,
-0.7398074865341187,
-0.16036219894886017,
-0.2113083153963089,
0.9987597465515137,
0.6330717206001282,
0.6932749152183533,
0.6430275440216064,
0.3288716971874237,
0.2050047069787979,
-0.017444558441638947,
-0.3586145341396332,
-0.8314092755317688,
0.06914237886667252,
-0.39848214387893677,
-0.4962073266506195,
-0.3305360674858093,
-0.24221928417682648,
0.9980961084365845,
0.6050243973731995,
-0.22063863277435303,
0.2638445198535919,
-0.1860796958208084,
0.48535630106925964,
-1.0430030822753906,
0.12557293474674225,
-0.8225899934768677,
0.1247296929359436,
-0.2762605547904968,
-0.2611614465713501,
-0.6265020966529846,
-0.12430696189403534,
-0.0527711883187294,
-0.6300912499427795,
-0.00780198909342289,
0.12570975720882416,
0.6173259019851685,
-0.31677618622779846,
-0.5657837390899658,
0.007534464355558157,
-0.43440714478492737,
1.1085422039031982,
-0.10530637204647064,
0.7013892531394958,
0.26401427388191223,
0.25884830951690674,
0.3306947946548462,
-0.38271671533584595,
-0.6852594017982483,
-0.11529195308685303,
-0.07091125845909119,
0.15304069221019745,
-0.30694565176963806,
-0.3785131275653839,
-0.1941673755645752,
0.302634060382843,
-0.7640596032142639,
0.047327399253845215,
-0.5144757032394409,
-0.08116255700588226,
0.5750023722648621,
0.015589281916618347,
0.05612404644489288,
-0.6286242604255676,
-0.5574976801872253,
-0.16947659850120544,
-0.6832960247993469,
0.06892158836126328,
0.3686160445213318,
0.6378036737442017,
0.10948061943054199,
0.5658556222915649,
-0.2708236575126648,
0.526133120059967,
-0.4426623582839966,
0.3092590570449829,
0.28894227743148804,
-0.27688273787498474,
-0.2477138191461563,
0.14266203343868256,
0.6255383491516113,
-0.05455819517374039,
-0.020785652101039886,
-0.38511180877685547,
-0.22484087944030762,
-0.280593603849411,
0.16968800127506256,
-0.7779867053031921,
-0.21119984984397888,
0.03663627803325653,
-0.503251850605011,
-0.1710623949766159,
0.05461736023426056,
-0.7066614031791687,
0.045920297503471375,
-0.31821000576019287,
0.7228901982307434,
-0.4133109152317047,
-0.49551716446876526,
0.4523583948612213,
0.008276605978608131,
0.16024485230445862,
0.14232444763183594,
-0.6323134303092957,
0.06759586930274963,
0.38013148307800293,
0.816892147064209,
-0.1438283920288086,
-0.03455015644431114,
-0.8502082228660583,
0.28152039647102356,
-0.3342518210411072,
0.6685993671417236,
-0.8574457764625549,
-0.4940950572490692,
-0.029097778722643852,
0.18962734937667847,
-0.11708596348762512,
-0.45180317759513855,
0.4208090007305145,
-0.7520133852958679,
0.055529411882162094,
-0.447290301322937,
-0.30443820357322693,
-0.5078349113464355,
0.5394020080566406,
-0.5400198698043823,
0.8791391849517822,
-0.05062330141663551,
-0.5644397139549255,
0.11993591487407684,
-0.28490716218948364,
-0.4026119112968445,
0.23011426627635956,
-0.2612869143486023,
-0.31079670786857605,
0.10224632173776627,
-0.0000027370451789465733,
0.6282469630241394,
-0.1330401599407196,
-0.01322898082435131,
-0.37150219082832336,
-0.4127214550971985,
-0.2020193189382553,
-0.16739249229431152,
0.7596253752708435,
0.21158146858215332,
0.014207547530531883,
0.1455579400062561,
-0.8250845670700073,
0.18658851087093353,
0.05843312665820122,
-0.6481491327285767,
-0.3401963412761688,
-0.19672663509845734,
0.3826380968093872,
0.39738160371780396,
0.21323764324188232,
-0.8477424383163452,
0.23766477406024933,
0.27824440598487854,
0.14357389509677887,
0.5410419702529907,
-0.5657469630241394,
0.6428631544113159,
-0.39372003078460693,
0.5930333137512207,
0.16320373117923737,
-0.1337406486272812,
-0.7260966300964355,
-0.20204727351665497,
-0.6076802611351013,
-0.4590359032154083,
0.25113341212272644,
0.8412461280822754,
-0.7310062646865845,
0.2451927214860916,
-0.5457821488380432,
-0.4980045557022095,
-0.3446939289569855,
0.21915802359580994,
0.3566861152648926,
0.5418460369110107,
0.6187204718589783,
-0.26417970657348633,
-0.24988779425621033,
-0.7919259071350098,
0.048247821629047394,
-0.02753765694797039,
0.1625770479440689,
0.4655422568321228,
0.41814082860946655,
-0.10264523327350616,
0.5852553844451904,
-0.4827859401702881,
-0.41218313574790955,
-0.6066941618919373,
0.21709081530570984,
0.19556592404842377,
0.6093407869338989,
0.4979228079319,
-0.6104235053062439,
-0.618424654006958,
0.44550150632858276,
-0.757646918296814,
0.5431084036827087,
0.10917127132415771,
-0.2568672001361847,
-0.008274218998849392,
0.3330516517162323,
-0.4720625877380371,
0.3172014355659485,
0.21533475816249847,
-0.018441257998347282,
0.539391815662384,
-0.34442320466041565,
0.19626599550247192,
-0.8769161105155945,
0.3822401463985443,
-0.061314284801483154,
-0.5126826763153076,
-0.443052738904953,
0.19661155343055725,
0.5257720947265625,
-0.4435454308986664,
-0.6983507871627808,
0.6085152626037598,
-0.5873483419418335,
0.206035315990448,
0.11434786766767502,
0.03472200781106949,
0.15705688297748566,
0.5335909724235535,
0.2526482343673706,
0.6109297275543213,
0.8865167498588562,
-0.5017703175544739,
0.09024747461080551,
0.3015536367893219,
-0.37320268154144287,
0.7097797393798828,
-0.5465000867843628,
0.15359778702259064,
-0.7338972687721252,
0.12101567536592484,
-0.8358372449874878,
0.023648681119084358,
-0.11988427489995956,
-0.23803967237472534,
0.6685283184051514,
-0.2529541552066803,
-0.618935763835907,
0.01893533393740654,
-0.32962659001350403,
0.8376258611679077,
0.37675008177757263,
-0.5259270071983337,
0.4092783033847809,
0.31069642305374146,
-0.3440425992012024,
-0.8537986278533936,
-0.5938035845756531,
0.21923235058784485,
0.05920816585421562,
-0.7416221499443054,
0.24255497753620148,
-0.06374537944793701,
0.10416947305202484,
-0.09913632273674011,
0.12420418113470078,
-0.19839587807655334,
-0.3197880983352661,
-0.42945364117622375,
0.19833290576934814,
-0.2380642145872116,
0.26769423484802246,
-0.16458088159561157,
-0.2070682793855667,
-0.34199050068855286,
-0.5167455077171326,
0.30071231722831726,
0.03719095140695572,
-0.2925455868244171,
-0.3689042627811432,
0.7394278645515442,
0.4208139181137085,
-0.49592921137809753,
0.7012783288955688,
0.551076352596283,
-0.268424391746521,
0.03485284745693207,
-0.6264275908470154,
-0.16167601943016052,
-0.37243181467056274,
0.6171835064888,
-0.2763153314590454,
-0.846695601940155,
0.4100247323513031,
0.16440553963184357,
-0.08343981951475143,
0.05653582140803337,
0.4330040514469147,
-0.017969388514757156,
1.004902720451355,
0.7611972093582153,
-0.054384745657444,
0.5553728342056274,
-0.46343258023262024,
0.19844560325145721,
-0.6898316740989685,
-0.5229486227035522,
-0.5577102303504944,
-0.48521295189857483,
-0.26578575372695923,
-0.5548619627952576,
0.3752901554107666,
0.0635048896074295,
0.0001765386259648949,
0.576717734336853,
-0.4069876968860626,
0.5650994181632996,
0.5094820261001587,
0.0803595632314682,
0.4705698788166046,
0.18700416386127472,
-0.30710697174072266,
-0.04783131927251816,
-0.9230466485023499,
-0.36120232939720154,
1.1611944437026978,
-0.150488018989563,
0.8358653783798218,
0.2852993607521057,
0.5167543292045593,
0.1618160754442215,
0.08280126005411148,
-0.7119235396385193,
0.34243714809417725,
-0.34550923109054565,
-0.7468851804733276,
-0.007746241986751556,
-0.637660801410675,
-1.1598210334777832,
0.6384860873222351,
-0.1532806158065796,
-0.6474711894989014,
0.5198698043823242,
-0.09031948447227478,
-0.43236398696899414,
0.5981042981147766,
-0.6296710968017578,
0.8677003979682922,
-0.16527284681797028,
-0.7156256437301636,
-0.5157279372215271,
-0.5886561274528503,
0.29737749695777893,
-0.22425445914268494,
0.2654091417789459,
-0.3477177321910858,
0.03511260077357292,
0.3763216435909271,
0.07823492586612701,
0.327778160572052,
-0.04670242592692375,
0.007310353219509125,
0.08670663088560104,
0.2030884027481079,
0.4827820956707001,
0.2626117467880249,
-0.7321979999542236,
0.5167316198348999,
0.05267368257045746,
-0.8245179057121277,
-0.30730652809143066,
0.7721959352493286,
-0.6379497647285461,
-0.3546544015407562,
-0.4168509840965271,
-0.7139897346496582,
0.2891373336315155,
0.3269287049770355,
0.36227670311927795,
0.49486327171325684,
-0.38011404871940613,
0.47798848152160645,
0.6788807511329651,
-0.42564553022384644,
0.48394688963890076,
0.7775326371192932,
-0.3742621839046478,
-0.24580281972885132,
1.3121273517608643,
0.5625786185264587,
0.07971076667308807,
0.8504893779754639,
-0.15106680989265442,
-0.3399263620376587,
-0.3053203821182251,
-0.409736305475235,
0.14082956314086914,
-0.6731405854225159,
-0.36002543568611145,
-0.8464128375053406,
0.1254519820213318,
-0.2670741677284241,
-0.13286691904067993,
-0.33798834681510925,
-0.6605222821235657,
-0.3780229389667511,
-0.10527742654085159,
-0.057534828782081604,
0.6225958466529846,
-0.29832473397254944,
0.1705015003681183,
-0.8353523015975952,
0.28338009119033813,
0.2630769908428192,
0.38633158802986145,
-0.02671302855014801,
-0.34198591113090515,
-0.45471522212028503,
-0.10955999046564102,
-0.47042492032051086,
-0.790835976600647,
0.41307762265205383,
0.33617931604385376,
0.4500676393508911,
0.227634459733963,
0.029178664088249207,
0.5301113128662109,
-0.5530116558074951,
0.48723718523979187,
0.398152619600296,
-0.8709095120429993,
0.26922303438186646,
-0.4486105740070343,
0.3257687985897064,
0.45038431882858276,
0.5507778525352478,
-0.6459923982620239,
0.18366551399230957,
-0.10970573127269745,
-0.8371477127075195,
0.802941083908081,
0.10197825729846954,
0.5083329677581787,
-0.4259543716907501,
0.15409351885318756,
0.4098312258720398,
0.27481111884117126,
-0.6580647826194763,
-0.05799740552902222,
-0.34915870428085327,
0.17950809001922607,
-0.03183078393340111,
-0.19663426280021667,
0.23321904242038727,
-0.589455246925354,
0.7759910821914673,
-0.20369747281074524,
0.25082314014434814,
0.21729950606822968,
-0.5727567672729492,
-0.04364294558763504,
0.5488218069076538,
0.39047354459762573,
0.5184517502784729,
-0.1979173719882965,
0.3427613079547882,
0.04256735369563103,
-0.10772066563367844,
0.3436349928379059,
0.11260813474655151,
-0.000850799900945276,
0.1827080100774765,
-0.07629000395536423,
0.5173740386962891,
0.4467839002609253,
-0.554173469543457,
0.7187705636024475,
-0.052048031240701675,
0.0038160388357937336,
-0.2088560163974762,
-0.20854607224464417,
-0.06833729147911072,
0.04217425733804703,
0.548509418964386,
0.18752922117710114,
0.09502920508384705,
-0.5044825673103333,
0.3907535672187805,
0.7334268093109131,
-0.5848604440689087,
-0.7300177216529846,
0.7858759760856628,
0.0451236255466938,
-0.03144035488367081,
0.8087766766548157,
-0.5385434627532959,
-0.1210450604557991,
0.23911325633525848,
0.32703790068626404,
0.6038768887519836,
-0.24136891961097717,
0.4065406918525696,
0.522955596446991,
0.29765936732292175,
-0.07687436789274216,
0.7089908719062805,
-0.24744783341884613,
-0.5992503762245178,
-0.4130416214466095,
-0.5297317504882812,
-0.0636293813586235,
-0.16309666633605957,
-0.8312467932701111,
0.607434868812561,
-0.28593870997428894,
-0.07923536747694016,
-0.2833649814128876,
-0.19863593578338623,
-0.9065607786178589,
-0.1212918609380722,
0.26157742738723755,
1.0799777507781982,
-0.3969072997570038,
1.0052766799926758,
0.6158424019813538,
-0.4058363437652588,
-0.35225197672843933,
-0.5024141669273376,
-0.14534801244735718,
-0.9913672804832458,
0.6942442655563354,
0.20015545189380646,
-0.0369684137403965,
0.3131196200847626,
-0.32371023297309875,
-1.030049204826355,
1.0569000244140625,
0.9444149732589722,
-0.7103323340415955,
0.13219097256660461,
0.04733205586671829,
0.11913589388132095,
-0.17598655819892883,
0.4334903061389923,
0.04137179255485535,
0.48863473534584045,
0.23392082750797272,
-0.7507266402244568,
-0.1506717950105667,
-0.44242018461227417,
-0.049829211086034775,
0.16277199983596802,
-0.8051128387451172,
1.0175687074661255,
-0.4542410373687744,
-0.3479045033454895,
0.16499915719032288,
0.5441721081733704,
-0.029353637248277664,
-0.03179303556680679,
0.07009571045637131,
0.6743713617324829,
0.922432541847229,
0.07915908843278885,
1.1162688732147217,
-0.5298213958740234,
0.5979440212249756,
0.8150516748428345,
-0.4812583029270172,
1.2192118167877197,
0.37512245774269104,
0.26411011815071106,
0.6133397221565247,
0.1750544160604477,
0.2594146430492401,
0.52109295129776,
0.19222372770309448,
-0.5448861122131348,
-0.5857927203178406,
-0.39744508266448975,
-0.42368096113204956,
0.40397289395332336,
0.174265056848526,
-0.18783356249332428,
-0.5341438055038452,
0.11600685119628906,
0.11001693457365036,
-0.07828444987535477,
-0.28106048703193665,
0.5487565994262695,
-0.050954367965459824,
-0.4058450758457184,
0.745042622089386,
0.06860657036304474,
0.8243999481201172,
-0.6810827851295471,
0.12525314092636108,
-0.15493787825107574,
0.24314163625240326,
-0.3435373604297638,
-0.6131704449653625,
0.2736448049545288,
-0.24976536631584167,
-0.36607059836387634,
-0.49002131819725037,
0.4572449326515198,
-0.7285060286521912,
-0.8633046746253967,
0.5235304236412048,
0.6282720565795898,
0.2548210620880127,
-0.2642674148082733,
-0.5429539084434509,
0.05305022373795509,
-0.1808808296918869,
-0.13909824192523956,
0.3848798871040344,
0.29663726687431335,
0.034709032624959946,
0.45421504974365234,
0.6823964715003967,
0.0429803729057312,
0.38093388080596924,
-0.11564049124717712,
0.7587708830833435,
-0.7374466061592102,
-0.5090309977531433,
-0.5821888446807861,
0.6081580519676208,
0.16387593746185303,
-0.06419240683317184,
0.6195076704025269,
0.8847849369049072,
0.8872876167297363,
0.07648847997188568,
0.9401600956916809,
0.14479771256446838,
0.16871818900108337,
-0.21282078325748444,
0.8757704496383667,
-0.848719596862793,
0.02254571206867695,
0.031591009348630905,
-1.0995664596557617,
-0.5207850933074951,
0.5395395159721375,
-0.12244313210248947,
0.008508003316819668,
0.4993411898612976,
0.8266376852989197,
-0.545026957988739,
-0.14764869213104248,
0.7702555656433105,
0.21021395921707153,
0.19654355943202972,
0.4816402196884155,
0.6707927584648132,
-0.45789846777915955,
0.9250472187995911,
-0.14820724725723267,
-0.10207374393939972,
-0.1567414551973343,
-0.83180832862854,
-0.6541355848312378,
-0.4022529125213623,
-0.33317261934280396,
0.1548347920179367,
-0.0730510950088501,
0.8493564128875732,
1.213232398033142,
-0.7477172613143921,
-0.3970835208892822,
0.321603924036026,
0.20953823626041412,
-0.008518333546817303,
-0.2008848339319229,
0.1342044472694397,
-0.7155867218971252,
-0.7098958492279053,
0.6742241978645325,
0.7207628488540649,
-0.29448020458221436,
-0.3285437524318695,
-0.09558223932981491,
-0.44607672095298767,
0.03452477231621742,
0.8393303155899048,
0.2946126163005829,
-0.3748491108417511,
-0.2422628253698349,
0.5594726800918579,
-0.1097741350531578,
0.573741614818573,
0.947682797908783,
-0.9957695603370667,
0.778046727180481,
0.7430331707000732,
0.5676485896110535,
0.5379868149757385,
-0.39386671781539917,
0.526328980922699,
-0.9955726265907288,
0.20555998384952545,
0.09404227882623672,
0.5569028258323669,
0.5222899913787842,
-0.4597615599632263,
0.08280926197767258,
0.26208165287971497,
-0.48552799224853516,
-0.6602425575256348,
0.18705494701862335,
-0.7857745289802551,
-0.2349230945110321,
1.0319710969924927,
-0.17365208268165588,
-0.05552148073911667,
-0.41283145546913147,
-0.07537731528282166,
-0.011803038418293,
-0.550022304058075,
0.8062512278556824,
0.5248647332191467,
0.17131434381008148,
-0.2133866399526596,
-0.4373588562011719,
-0.12320420891046524,
0.6671572923660278,
-0.38949209451675415,
-0.022327153012156487,
0.1246684268116951,
0.31388136744499207,
0.3348301649093628,
0.6509665250778198,
-0.22721275687217712,
0.21214820444583893,
-0.5169121026992798,
0.18260660767555237,
0.053487129509449005,
-0.4694039821624756,
-0.5199670195579529,
0.5006449818611145,
-0.264396607875824,
-0.11605993658304214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15057v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15057v1
|
On the Multi-turn Instruction Following for Conversational Web Agents
| 2024-02-23T02:18:12 | 2024-02-23T02:18:12 |
Yang Deng, Xuan Zhang, Wenxuan Zhang, Yifei Yuan, See-Kiong Ng, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Web agents powered by Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated
remarkable abilities in planning and executing multi-step interactions within
complex web-based environments, fulfilling a wide range of web navigation
tasks. Despite these advancements, the potential for LLM-powered agents to
effectively engage with sequential user instructions in real-world scenarios
has not been fully explored. In this work, we introduce a new task of
Conversational Web Navigation, which necessitates sophisticated interactions
that span multiple turns with both the users and the environment, supported by
a specially developed dataset named Multi-Turn Mind2Web (MT-Mind2Web). To
tackle the limited context length of LLMs and the context-dependency issue of
the conversational tasks, we further propose a novel framework, named
self-reflective memory-augmented planning (Self-MAP), which employs memory
utilization and self-reflection techniques. Extensive experiments are conducted
to benchmark the MT-Mind2Web dataset, and validate the effectiveness of the
proposed method.
|
[
-0.6346089839935303,
-0.674856424331665,
0.779718279838562,
0.627375066280365,
0.06161171570420265,
0.1505010426044464,
-0.25439319014549255,
-0.26114290952682495,
0.2953960597515106,
0.5993428230285645,
-0.9918938279151917,
-0.3520461618900299,
-0.08424510806798935,
-0.22880151867866516,
-0.41548341512680054,
0.735938549041748,
0.1678086668252945,
0.031115125864744186,
-0.27824175357818604,
0.016666581854224205,
-0.4180576801300049,
-0.4482463002204895,
-0.39265695214271545,
-0.3624527156352997,
0.6843189597129822,
0.7163131833076477,
0.740307629108429,
0.1009221002459526,
0.3638097941875458,
0.2979671061038971,
0.6359153985977173,
0.4727025628089905,
-0.4552297592163086,
0.20248493552207947,
-0.370883047580719,
-0.231173574924469,
-0.6178691387176514,
0.1467989981174469,
0.2666681706905365,
0.2614394426345825,
-0.5690284371376038,
0.05776091665029526,
-0.10254698246717453,
0.6427388787269592,
-0.6087965965270996,
0.23621168732643127,
-0.39722055196762085,
-0.05601944401860237,
0.14854733645915985,
-0.3880747854709625,
-0.7058000564575195,
-0.11152324825525284,
0.28807196021080017,
-0.6029938459396362,
0.04978841543197632,
0.08505585044622421,
0.16872495412826538,
0.22977270185947418,
-0.42292019724845886,
-0.3213415741920471,
-0.8192174434661865,
0.789965808391571,
-0.6459249258041382,
0.443493515253067,
0.3005075752735138,
0.3671416640281677,
-0.3047795295715332,
-0.5589369535446167,
-0.8863090872764587,
0.1611310988664627,
0.05415961518883705,
0.33399778604507446,
0.0407080203294754,
-0.016767289489507675,
0.0616256408393383,
-0.2392311841249466,
-0.4952820837497711,
0.17647694051265717,
-0.010938274674117565,
-0.018126849085092545,
0.6042315363883972,
0.39091476798057556,
0.2879877984523773,
0.12593677639961243,
-0.5391111969947815,
-0.2678959369659424,
-0.4438950717449188,
-0.11773370951414108,
0.037100065499544144,
0.5788053274154663,
-0.21253150701522827,
0.41657552123069763,
-0.38151395320892334,
0.7633351683616638,
0.044992707669734955,
-0.3292944133281708,
0.09213053435087204,
-0.2261156290769577,
0.042672812938690186,
-0.07787597179412842,
0.6534770727157593,
0.800001859664917,
0.37355002760887146,
-0.3749622106552124,
-0.022014889866113663,
-0.21103477478027344,
0.7290439009666443,
-0.9297941327095032,
-0.24059252440929413,
0.45655107498168945,
-0.26947277784347534,
0.1915292888879776,
-0.09318540245294571,
-0.8030246496200562,
-0.20928846299648285,
-0.2501479387283325,
0.41967296600341797,
-0.44388505816459656,
-0.2957598567008972,
0.19293704628944397,
0.06522579491138458,
0.6493983864784241,
0.49320584535598755,
-0.8389407396316528,
0.3947957456111908,
0.5765873789787292,
0.6325908899307251,
-0.23062191903591156,
-0.6147527694702148,
-0.1918192058801651,
0.4129273295402527,
-0.1695275753736496,
0.8220075368881226,
-0.6507894992828369,
-0.5100417137145996,
0.3188217878341675,
-0.2943010628223419,
-0.008454320952296257,
-0.2543239891529083,
-0.09746331721544266,
-0.6853330731391907,
0.350547194480896,
-0.2562235891819,
-0.14815902709960938,
-0.4177839159965515,
0.6022569537162781,
-0.36202847957611084,
0.6576130986213684,
-0.18568797409534454,
-0.21725565195083618,
-0.029043495655059814,
-0.5566267967224121,
-0.766236424446106,
-0.17443197965621948,
-0.1506720930337906,
-0.12356938421726227,
-0.18820536136627197,
0.17366686463356018,
0.5416057109832764,
-0.16489167511463165,
-0.2748531699180603,
-0.09065774083137512,
-0.18537209928035736,
0.4650913178920746,
-0.29681596159935,
0.28955593705177307,
-0.2685495913028717,
-0.4026671350002289,
0.022190546616911888,
-0.7475365400314331,
0.46714404225349426,
0.2259230762720108,
-0.4197133779525757,
-0.19676794111728668,
0.3060545027256012,
-0.13735203444957733,
0.4585651457309723,
0.3632363975048065,
-0.4642998278141022,
0.6404264569282532,
0.08745193481445312,
-0.04627333581447601,
0.7426469922065735,
-0.03081291727721691,
0.3795042634010315,
-0.1950063407421112,
0.50580894947052,
-0.1196524053812027,
0.309082955121994,
-0.3861544728279114,
-0.5334398746490479,
-1.1044020652770996,
0.06019512936472893,
-0.354789137840271,
0.6062748432159424,
-0.8043444752693176,
0.055568888783454895,
-0.34608912467956543,
-0.38772690296173096,
-0.2328777313232422,
-0.014089817181229591,
0.75127112865448,
0.21095514297485352,
0.9673494696617126,
-0.2522323429584503,
-0.29631808400154114,
-0.8079304099082947,
-0.15574368834495544,
-0.12229879945516586,
0.1258217990398407,
0.431850403547287,
0.22299766540527344,
-0.5374188423156738,
0.9828745722770691,
-0.592887818813324,
-0.5613741874694824,
-0.2110094130039215,
0.3034498393535614,
-0.19142219424247742,
0.42658376693725586,
0.022494448348879814,
-0.6929340958595276,
-0.525069534778595,
-0.41686901450157166,
-0.7173892259597778,
0.009221753105521202,
-0.5452197790145874,
-0.29443490505218506,
0.09591636061668396,
0.2933637797832489,
-0.6981476545333862,
0.4367921054363251,
0.42100533843040466,
-0.09796175360679626,
0.4490296244621277,
-0.17285200953483582,
0.1077856719493866,
-0.6444594860076904,
-0.49394240975379944,
0.05307918041944504,
-0.1444896012544632,
-0.9459393620491028,
0.01794588938355446,
0.18411415815353394,
0.3743791878223419,
-0.4378519356250763,
0.5660643577575684,
-0.9096418023109436,
-0.22463171184062958,
-0.5303183794021606,
0.2695830464363098,
-0.05176076292991638,
1.0135998725891113,
0.12055574357509613,
0.7652135491371155,
0.06123419851064682,
-0.8731423616409302,
0.10330189764499664,
0.44394752383232117,
0.2019999772310257,
0.5749900937080383,
0.05558948963880539,
0.6563420295715332,
0.27847686409950256,
0.35898470878601074,
-0.9325081706047058,
0.07810000330209732,
0.10500894486904144,
-0.23696665465831757,
0.26349982619285583,
0.00792643055319786,
-0.46111738681793213,
-0.44273778796195984,
-0.164979487657547,
0.18271200358867645,
0.2976386547088623,
-0.6521269679069519,
1.0808031558990479,
0.30924126505851746,
0.08512839674949646,
-0.2699434161186218,
-0.7237774729728699,
0.3159053921699524,
0.09210009127855301,
-0.5711949467658997,
0.46242305636405945,
-0.12740786373615265,
-0.16315805912017822,
-0.37993958592414856,
0.10355141758918762,
0.10583014786243439,
-0.22156797349452972,
0.377670019865036,
0.154731884598732,
0.1492397040128708,
-0.1476428061723709,
-0.2006463259458542,
-0.05490860715508461,
0.2028469443321228,
-0.30488958954811096,
0.9124110341072083,
-0.14599524438381195,
-0.5420506000518799,
-0.6516311168670654,
0.40257102251052856,
0.37568917870521545,
-0.1877758800983429,
0.5264577865600586,
0.4403197467327118,
-0.008150207810103893,
-0.32826992869377136,
-0.8528215289115906,
-0.3802433907985687,
-0.5482344627380371,
0.09294448792934418,
-0.4992530643939972,
-0.5316049456596375,
0.40194252133369446,
-0.14361245930194855,
0.36086952686309814,
-0.07507391273975372,
0.6216487288475037,
-0.5005728602409363,
1.069464087486267,
0.5593317151069641,
0.02913454920053482,
0.33894091844558716,
-0.42115864157676697,
0.15405353903770447,
-1.1521713733673096,
-0.46504348516464233,
-0.07103121280670166,
-0.677209198474884,
-0.5223638415336609,
-0.7776197195053101,
0.35824209451675415,
-0.32367587089538574,
-0.10561975836753845,
0.11564093828201294,
-0.3333968222141266,
0.05600934848189354,
0.6931716799736023,
0.18541209399700165,
0.2031547576189041,
-0.08635535836219788,
-0.20613345503807068,
0.11173301190137863,
-0.5748910307884216,
-0.2969830632209778,
1.0450555086135864,
-0.09679447114467621,
0.9572696685791016,
0.3702881634235382,
0.6559790372848511,
0.2661226689815521,
0.34490489959716797,
-0.7170799970626831,
1.0605974197387695,
0.2753424346446991,
-0.4968261122703552,
-0.6106213927268982,
0.06570736318826675,
-1.0750856399536133,
0.5288315415382385,
-0.00637486856430769,
-0.6069017648696899,
-0.08624009042978287,
0.26724013686180115,
-0.2805175483226776,
0.10895287990570068,
-0.6580146551132202,
0.5802531242370605,
-0.7254842519760132,
-0.6765047907829285,
-0.7492436766624451,
-0.6586259007453918,
0.08677515387535095,
0.3824453353881836,
0.33172816038131714,
-0.0177890844643116,
-0.08153429627418518,
0.5800337791442871,
-0.2233368307352066,
0.9884276986122131,
-0.515068769454956,
-0.09125947207212448,
0.49414873123168945,
0.286594420671463,
0.6363367438316345,
-0.41228926181793213,
0.4125533998012543,
-0.044891271740198135,
-0.4019159972667694,
-0.3651885986328125,
-0.6998833417892456,
0.6232960224151611,
-0.5412151217460632,
-0.8828256726264954,
-0.5369266271591187,
-0.3855133652687073,
-0.770597517490387,
0.15299829840660095,
-0.3849792778491974,
0.3518577218055725,
-0.41236257553100586,
-0.19981977343559265,
0.5251885056495667,
-0.1676756888628006,
0.7508864402770996,
1.227174997329712,
-0.6352183818817139,
-0.17394566535949707,
1.0403872728347778,
0.09166453033685684,
0.28808894753456116,
0.4125871956348419,
0.11148278415203094,
-0.3304734528064728,
-0.5047054290771484,
-0.5492871403694153,
0.17083850502967834,
-0.37164783477783203,
-0.03520769998431206,
-0.6451830267906189,
-0.0024663242511451244,
-0.30759766697883606,
-0.06897714734077454,
-0.4124090373516083,
-0.3428295850753784,
-0.29473382234573364,
-0.09155375510454178,
0.1515733152627945,
0.6402108669281006,
-0.0534168966114521,
0.4678172469139099,
-0.5742993950843811,
0.43434178829193115,
0.6378377676010132,
0.09233159571886063,
0.460854709148407,
-0.16556984186172485,
-0.3886561691761017,
0.013470569625496864,
-0.421706885099411,
-0.8976275324821472,
0.364170104265213,
0.02734610252082348,
0.6459418535232544,
0.5667861104011536,
-0.09092728793621063,
0.9152478575706482,
-0.8032560348510742,
0.5104687809944153,
0.4210696220397949,
-0.3746052384376526,
0.5493663549423218,
-0.3602842092514038,
0.7157552242279053,
0.4256337583065033,
0.43097591400146484,
-0.7213912010192871,
-0.16259655356407166,
-0.3560524880886078,
-0.824969470500946,
0.6434330344200134,
-0.022114954888820648,
0.23675774037837982,
-0.10657836496829987,
0.3161275088787079,
-0.06052691116929054,
0.27476879954338074,
-0.34973257780075073,
-0.3388465344905853,
-0.3903923034667969,
0.027588922530412674,
0.12189320474863052,
-0.32491669058799744,
-0.08283799141645432,
0.11729573458433151,
0.6503832936286926,
-0.5180882215499878,
0.5108440518379211,
0.14810605347156525,
-0.3107469379901886,
0.16264545917510986,
0.27341553568840027,
0.5207027196884155,
0.603837251663208,
-0.08157369494438171,
0.3062303960323334,
0.06281741708517075,
-0.45935747027397156,
0.13734810054302216,
-0.06457459181547165,
-0.14861343801021576,
-0.6902443170547485,
0.16338340938091278,
0.3288406431674957,
0.33442771434783936,
-0.5994768142700195,
0.27072077989578247,
-0.12787006795406342,
0.38840511441230774,
-0.5991699695587158,
0.23970189690589905,
0.34172749519348145,
0.32608017325401306,
0.6546533703804016,
-0.23248347640037537,
0.3040448725223541,
-0.6413707137107849,
0.11507008224725723,
0.6033442616462708,
-0.4944928288459778,
-0.43649739027023315,
0.2061534970998764,
0.4944491684436798,
-0.6750373244285583,
0.7614365220069885,
-0.3801160156726837,
-0.6240041255950928,
0.16828179359436035,
0.6463543176651001,
0.8321223855018616,
-0.37491410970687866,
0.17912232875823975,
0.21987555921077728,
0.13590051233768463,
0.07485251128673553,
0.5970255136489868,
-0.2743194103240967,
-0.9536874294281006,
-0.013256032019853592,
-0.316260427236557,
-0.5058572292327881,
-0.2702813446521759,
-0.674774169921875,
-0.3300929367542267,
-0.4900476038455963,
-0.3837335705757141,
-0.4429074823856354,
-0.16339895129203796,
-0.6506593823432922,
0.43549275398254395,
0.20117796957492828,
0.6447362899780273,
-0.027005642652511597,
0.7664697170257568,
0.36214327812194824,
-0.26319432258605957,
-0.4401170611381531,
0.16903643310070038,
0.3293822705745697,
-0.9933388233184814,
0.4056965708732605,
0.3938278257846832,
-0.8656876683235168,
0.12352012097835541,
-0.43570756912231445,
-0.6354499459266663,
1.206311583518982,
-0.3535219728946686,
-0.6809080839157104,
-0.09157146513462067,
0.21216213703155518,
0.4310119152069092,
-0.4505424201488495,
0.31052979826927185,
0.44655558466911316,
0.5219574570655823,
0.015855822712183,
-0.7799221873283386,
0.05072442442178726,
-0.023222681134939194,
-0.1060270369052887,
-0.017644979059696198,
-1.4420102834701538,
0.38970962166786194,
-0.5293424129486084,
-0.19450940191745758,
-0.13910341262817383,
0.9265002608299255,
0.23736204206943512,
0.22215421497821808,
0.6670742630958557,
0.48497137427330017,
0.48524606227874756,
0.19029612839221954,
0.7731378674507141,
-0.28280648589134216,
-0.05591260641813278,
1.5192736387252808,
-0.5443953275680542,
1.0805014371871948,
0.5251637101173401,
-0.31209248304367065,
0.9158667325973511,
0.15879420936107635,
0.2058476358652115,
0.595656156539917,
0.013057728298008442,
-0.2286161184310913,
-0.4478640556335449,
0.12384369224309921,
-0.005706071853637695,
0.5959144830703735,
0.5142954587936401,
0.11431016027927399,
0.03382149338722229,
0.07703554630279541,
0.21606546640396118,
0.08020699769258499,
-0.18855981528759003,
0.8619105815887451,
0.01499451044946909,
-0.9856806397438049,
0.18281832337379456,
0.007806387264281511,
0.6680777668952942,
-0.5395258069038391,
-0.13881675899028778,
-0.16586662828922272,
0.3082536458969116,
-0.15070009231567383,
-0.8885893821716309,
-0.16061830520629883,
-0.1888599693775177,
-0.13403837382793427,
-0.5737043619155884,
0.547027051448822,
-0.2512289583683014,
-0.24208346009254456,
0.6529496312141418,
0.6948031187057495,
0.1125868409872055,
-0.1443852335214615,
-0.5992742776870728,
-0.026039274409413338,
0.1635122001171112,
-0.5842003226280212,
0.5309352874755859,
0.04092339426279068,
-0.012069545686244965,
1.2477796077728271,
0.5964992642402649,
-0.35317549109458923,
0.3863191604614258,
0.27093446254730225,
0.6859184503555298,
-0.9133562445640564,
-0.44390371441841125,
-0.6191360950469971,
0.3853510618209839,
-0.05835225433111191,
-0.10688180476427078,
0.9443869590759277,
0.8601279854774475,
0.5780274271965027,
0.23035119473934174,
0.725387692451477,
0.17637237906455994,
0.48966166377067566,
-0.5958778858184814,
0.2442908138036728,
-0.29395005106925964,
0.048805493861436844,
0.1498185098171234,
-0.6176988482475281,
0.2255268096923828,
0.5726701617240906,
-0.2315603345632553,
0.20487749576568604,
0.42633193731307983,
0.7740480303764343,
-0.0022707798052579165,
0.14302141964435577,
0.2097999006509781,
0.299521267414093,
0.5780536532402039,
0.4746576249599457,
0.8871425986289978,
-0.032038845121860504,
0.5302305221557617,
-0.23628149926662445,
-0.2653367221355438,
-0.3559359312057495,
-0.5964068174362183,
-0.91434645652771,
-0.6150476336479187,
-0.1429317593574524,
-0.3479957580566406,
0.036309074610471725,
0.8525331616401672,
0.9039705395698547,
-0.6054452657699585,
-0.5806843042373657,
0.09804573655128479,
-0.1410280466079712,
-0.3849816620349884,
-0.18910261988639832,
0.05154886841773987,
-0.3576650321483612,
-0.5551888346672058,
0.740392804145813,
0.5986207127571106,
0.08265617489814758,
-0.9376316070556641,
-0.2223697155714035,
-0.7160460352897644,
0.3170606195926666,
0.6988874077796936,
0.25605377554893494,
-0.8148452043533325,
-0.3449009954929352,
0.1136622354388237,
-0.22096361219882965,
0.2553750276565552,
0.9168294072151184,
-1.0355775356292725,
0.5544441938400269,
-0.03483325615525246,
0.2449665069580078,
1.1776771545410156,
0.16655588150024414,
0.42398232221603394,
-0.43402478098869324,
-0.027192141860723495,
0.15604077279567719,
-0.031559672206640244,
0.42071738839149475,
-0.16708306968212128,
0.5469688773155212,
-0.18928131461143494,
-0.40475994348526,
-0.20334665477275848,
0.23962855339050293,
-1.2480456829071045,
-0.38206204771995544,
1.2983219623565674,
0.0610203854739666,
-0.06381285935640335,
-0.0681830421090126,
-0.18934085965156555,
-0.044892944395542145,
-0.48400095105171204,
0.8729972243309021,
0.5853166580200195,
-0.8977574706077576,
-0.22348472476005554,
-0.40305888652801514,
0.2312425673007965,
0.1599416583776474,
-0.8299893140792847,
0.036813508719205856,
0.7012168169021606,
0.0450187623500824,
0.587367594242096,
0.9626129269599915,
0.3302482068538666,
-0.026952408254146576,
-0.13065019249916077,
0.38179391622543335,
-0.0813651978969574,
-0.7016047835350037,
0.26965194940567017,
0.14881831407546997,
-0.3014052212238312,
-0.1866603046655655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15055v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15055v1
|
Interpreting Context Look-ups in Transformers: Investigating Attention-MLP Interactions
| 2024-02-23T02:15:47 | 2024-02-23T02:15:47 |
Clement Neo, Shay B. Cohen, Fazl Barez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we investigate the interplay between attention heads and
specialized "next-token" neurons in the Multilayer Perceptron that predict
specific tokens. By prompting an LLM like GPT-4 to explain these model
internals, we can elucidate attention mechanisms that activate certain
next-token neurons. Our analysis identifies attention heads that recognize
contexts relevant to predicting a particular token, activating the associated
neuron through the residual connection. We focus specifically on heads in
earlier layers consistently activating the same next-token neuron across
similar prompts. Exploring these differential activation patterns reveals that
heads that specialize for distinct linguistic contexts are tied to generating
certain tokens. Overall, our method combines neural explanations and probing
isolated components to illuminate how attention enables context-dependent,
specialized processing in LLMs.
|
[
-0.49534112215042114,
-0.5535789728164673,
0.641802191734314,
0.1635706126689911,
-0.09942799061536789,
-0.15312477946281433,
-0.09358973801136017,
-0.3516813814640045,
0.18787690997123718,
0.5743290185928345,
-1.0688451528549194,
-0.01607680879533291,
-0.546126127243042,
0.23526132106781006,
-0.6086670160293579,
0.8670345544815063,
0.22713574767112732,
-0.3742485046386719,
-0.3240703344345093,
0.05231610685586929,
-0.6450885534286499,
-0.8158048391342163,
-0.9681738018989563,
-0.6812663674354553,
0.8165234327316284,
0.27887389063835144,
0.5698213577270508,
0.3187127411365509,
0.6128607988357544,
0.343008816242218,
-0.3014506995677948,
-0.25108852982521057,
-0.4006112217903137,
0.011597027070820332,
-0.28036805987358093,
-0.4636189937591553,
-0.5227736234664917,
-0.014717034995555878,
0.6432915925979614,
0.5300267934799194,
0.2536346912384033,
0.3483678698539734,
0.25662198662757874,
0.3362864553928375,
-0.4062752425670624,
0.183071568608284,
-1.09452486038208,
0.44009101390838623,
-0.20956045389175415,
-0.72615647315979,
-0.5606482028961182,
0.638812243938446,
0.39098721742630005,
-0.27114203572273254,
0.2952996790409088,
-0.28102490305900574,
0.76668781042099,
0.49573665857315063,
-0.40843814611434937,
0.18823052942752838,
-0.28763607144355774,
0.725369393825531,
-0.4394860565662384,
0.32798096537590027,
0.061553291976451874,
0.11389374732971191,
-0.09732546657323837,
-1.2242416143417358,
-0.5694540739059448,
-0.023961937054991722,
-0.40762680768966675,
0.27542009949684143,
-0.09004190564155579,
-0.01986221969127655,
0.33953243494033813,
0.11231286823749542,
-0.08059144765138626,
-0.03847065195441246,
-0.24365012347698212,
-0.24519406259059906,
-0.036000318825244904,
0.12496481090784073,
0.250914067029953,
-0.11285116523504257,
-0.6783083081245422,
0.2620360851287842,
-0.8699797987937927,
0.0876438319683075,
0.13542580604553223,
0.3224858045578003,
-0.17183594405651093,
0.8171662092208862,
0.1194596067070961,
0.8533329963684082,
0.5014556646347046,
0.18940378725528717,
0.21629877388477325,
-0.34646785259246826,
-0.4837242662906647,
0.12511742115020752,
0.43154963850975037,
0.3698614835739136,
0.5031663775444031,
-0.2800884544849396,
-0.11028527468442917,
-0.2822929918766022,
0.6304976940155029,
-0.5759707689285278,
0.0025772082153707743,
0.17120292782783508,
-0.525678277015686,
-0.5172539353370667,
-0.07259078323841095,
-0.4460779130458832,
-0.029428614303469658,
-0.6181119084358215,
0.3804244101047516,
-0.06846398115158081,
-0.10362569987773895,
-0.20137624442577362,
-0.2676144540309906,
0.532514214515686,
-0.1573779135942459,
-1.2332391738891602,
0.15752245485782623,
0.5755518078804016,
0.8989756107330322,
-0.6132987141609192,
-0.7514387369155884,
-0.5016510486602783,
0.4659055769443512,
0.04349974915385246,
0.9152234792709351,
-0.5574964880943298,
-0.04007704183459282,
-0.10483657568693161,
0.2556944787502289,
-0.1413729041814804,
-0.5967714190483093,
0.6815347671508789,
-0.7883612513542175,
-0.021145649254322052,
-0.5186944603919983,
-0.16679631173610687,
-0.0618467852473259,
0.24596066772937775,
-0.7366008162498474,
0.9734249114990234,
0.24044109880924225,
-1.0983986854553223,
0.4556095004081726,
-0.8153755068778992,
-0.3385654389858246,
0.2931215763092041,
-0.4572826325893402,
-0.03144961968064308,
0.43721386790275574,
0.24793890118598938,
0.6935304403305054,
0.03190850093960762,
0.0023257837165147066,
-0.09596527367830276,
-0.3949298858642578,
0.4843966066837311,
-0.4114351272583008,
0.6160522699356079,
-0.30517449975013733,
-0.5102613568305969,
0.4742558002471924,
-0.4140220582485199,
-0.10668690502643585,
0.1822936236858368,
-0.2055569291114807,
-0.008301692083477974,
-0.02425505593419075,
-0.08432857692241669,
0.5584598183631897,
0.35905829071998596,
-0.09241856634616852,
0.0683368593454361,
-0.1776588410139084,
0.7410373091697693,
1.0299304723739624,
-0.0007948693819344044,
0.3999246060848236,
0.10339264571666718,
0.3980669379234314,
0.48849108815193176,
0.038555312901735306,
-0.526302695274353,
-0.6648168563842773,
-0.6895920038223267,
0.10758306831121445,
-0.09032362699508667,
0.25256097316741943,
-0.5968185663223267,
0.2564963698387146,
-0.174490824341774,
0.22014246881008148,
-0.10522722452878952,
-0.31466057896614075,
0.20817553997039795,
0.9616856575012207,
0.5022207498550415,
-0.3558414578437805,
-0.5043485760688782,
-1.2357200384140015,
-0.4135077893733978,
0.2574838697910309,
-0.28948724269866943,
0.539111852645874,
0.246367946267128,
-0.509385883808136,
1.2185684442520142,
-0.2363038957118988,
-0.39587631821632385,
-0.2048768550157547,
-0.2010767012834549,
0.3487941026687622,
0.21766118705272675,
0.6033997535705566,
-0.7977818250656128,
-0.3597829341888428,
0.07122700661420822,
-0.5670984387397766,
-0.16397914290428162,
-0.2588995099067688,
-0.35337087512016296,
-0.2432682365179062,
0.7814074754714966,
-0.7756713628768921,
0.288691908121109,
0.4676176905632019,
-0.5102308988571167,
0.5172417759895325,
0.1199634000658989,
-0.12342212349176407,
-0.7715344429016113,
0.10601074993610382,
-0.23778124153614044,
-0.07738105207681656,
-0.8543512225151062,
-0.02790219895541668,
-0.02907203510403633,
0.07188206166028976,
-0.5637731552124023,
0.6449583172798157,
-0.3046373426914215,
-0.8119825124740601,
-0.18408933281898499,
0.318136990070343,
-0.1034822165966034,
0.8368837237358093,
0.2598494291305542,
0.8665542006492615,
0.5250983834266663,
-0.5886784195899963,
0.1205865815281868,
0.4169532060623169,
-0.04161052778363228,
0.5540067553520203,
-0.7854271531105042,
0.27665549516677856,
-0.005881414283066988,
0.11852837353944778,
-1.1157293319702148,
-0.279251366853714,
0.21650998294353485,
-0.5441132187843323,
0.4098307490348816,
-0.16201765835285187,
-0.30184268951416016,
-0.23238177597522736,
-0.0553443469107151,
0.8066806197166443,
0.04956183210015297,
-0.7234616279602051,
0.9182998538017273,
0.5052032470703125,
-0.14329922199249268,
-0.8881096243858337,
-0.9767682552337646,
0.17726875841617584,
-0.3466271460056305,
-0.27826204895973206,
0.7106460332870483,
0.0913965106010437,
-0.037957023829221725,
-0.1424265056848526,
-0.22476711869239807,
-0.004818534944206476,
0.10510552674531937,
0.2161230593919754,
0.005521142389625311,
-0.1832876205444336,
-0.2008398324251175,
0.06074891239404678,
-0.32542669773101807,
0.39360466599464417,
-0.3539592921733856,
0.8587731122970581,
-0.07397238165140152,
-0.1648729294538498,
-0.5517269968986511,
0.1464497596025467,
0.7691128849983215,
-0.21342293918132782,
0.4649611711502075,
0.7045563459396362,
-0.2864668369293213,
0.14965970814228058,
-0.24007438123226166,
-0.46769022941589355,
-0.5733222365379333,
0.5802626609802246,
-0.9149625301361084,
-0.6980310678482056,
0.7629932165145874,
0.10634615272283554,
-0.09416013956069946,
0.582355260848999,
1.0707731246948242,
0.07837420701980591,
0.9449210166931152,
0.4702138602733612,
0.017720837146043777,
0.6646425724029541,
-0.10961783677339554,
0.11680712550878525,
-1.334304690361023,
-0.24884453415870667,
0.054251693189144135,
-0.5067419409751892,
-0.25821539759635925,
-0.31473541259765625,
0.2582400143146515,
-0.04459046199917793,
-0.09693682938814163,
0.47638365626335144,
-0.6552420258522034,
0.8922550082206726,
0.534680187702179,
-0.07994721084833145,
0.15134456753730774,
0.11053416132926941,
-0.39681336283683777,
-0.039678577333688736,
-0.6484737992286682,
-0.3366781175136566,
1.066750407218933,
0.4773344397544861,
0.10851909965276718,
-0.19361603260040283,
0.3074919879436493,
0.1803673654794693,
0.49194401502609253,
-0.8130260705947876,
0.6329944729804993,
0.18157266080379486,
-0.5499022006988525,
-0.1110956072807312,
0.015413315035402775,
-1.0286635160446167,
0.4126557409763336,
0.07092016935348511,
-0.9761905670166016,
0.00907845702022314,
0.18951421976089478,
-0.3040131628513336,
0.1400919407606125,
-0.632396399974823,
1.0157904624938965,
-0.13482290506362915,
-0.19213007390499115,
-0.15082764625549316,
-0.7578175663948059,
0.49912652373313904,
-0.05590527504682541,
-0.15779165923595428,
0.10277316719293594,
-0.2397610992193222,
0.570676863193512,
0.43320536613464355,
0.7781820893287659,
0.09124262630939484,
-0.34211525321006775,
0.08833771198987961,
-0.016777800396084785,
0.2320578396320343,
0.13706371188163757,
0.2581523656845093,
0.5180671811103821,
-0.36394575238227844,
-0.16982731223106384,
-0.3282916843891144,
0.8516623377799988,
-0.6764519810676575,
-0.5359777212142944,
-0.20676501095294952,
-0.6600539684295654,
-0.21238026022911072,
0.2881748676300049,
0.49430039525032043,
0.4418780207633972,
0.16721220314502716,
-0.026966558769345284,
0.35726863145828247,
-0.10605959594249725,
0.4975390136241913,
0.11516685038805008,
-0.20839065313339233,
-0.07358218729496002,
0.6140411496162415,
-0.15048208832740784,
0.24145850539207458,
0.5240710377693176,
0.002880303654819727,
-0.22781363129615784,
-0.4130885601043701,
-0.3118859529495239,
0.18884755671024323,
-0.9427613019943237,
0.014900455251336098,
-0.7048285007476807,
-0.30008596181869507,
-0.20277750492095947,
0.003054057713598013,
-0.2435256689786911,
-0.33460721373558044,
-0.3953883647918701,
-0.21202430129051208,
-0.27713459730148315,
0.6108828186988831,
0.19923025369644165,
0.47491225600242615,
-0.6847162842750549,
0.43519875407218933,
0.4975143373012543,
0.40207257866859436,
0.2999100387096405,
-0.6716989278793335,
-0.37945979833602905,
-0.29703429341316223,
-0.24841289222240448,
-0.9902495741844177,
0.24265770614147186,
0.013442843221127987,
0.6841762661933899,
0.630135178565979,
-0.5725709795951843,
0.4903724491596222,
-1.0199477672576904,
0.9186273813247681,
0.07550330460071564,
-1.1050503253936768,
0.2619556188583374,
-0.35598888993263245,
0.5722020268440247,
0.19744405150413513,
0.1544773131608963,
-0.5675731897354126,
-0.34862759709358215,
-0.746376097202301,
-0.9458491206169128,
0.9771815538406372,
0.40235549211502075,
0.20697765052318573,
-0.18505065143108368,
0.6813592314720154,
0.024034598842263222,
0.3701062500476837,
-0.9405301809310913,
-0.5716549158096313,
-0.05360958352684975,
0.06960682570934296,
-0.1250467151403427,
-0.5539519190788269,
-0.41453972458839417,
-0.09546539187431335,
0.025411300361156464,
-0.27281537652015686,
0.9500057101249695,
0.09536616504192352,
-0.08556368201971054,
-0.04456975683569908,
-0.10845542699098587,
0.9370589852333069,
0.7715564370155334,
-0.08895237743854523,
0.3113676607608795,
0.2778414785861969,
-0.5085609555244446,
-0.2050969898700714,
-0.23695245385169983,
0.076840341091156,
0.11852474510669708,
0.5688804388046265,
0.8659437298774719,
0.4419265389442444,
-0.2998277544975281,
0.4408797025680542,
-0.31795254349708557,
0.030497783794999123,
-0.5221400260925293,
-0.12280373275279999,
0.22264829277992249,
0.3770574927330017,
0.6380618214607239,
0.228304922580719,
0.077639639377594,
-0.5136059522628784,
0.5462487936019897,
0.5673372149467468,
-0.4850529730319977,
-0.6824319362640381,
0.714424192905426,
0.2714967429637909,
-0.462833970785141,
0.3986332416534424,
0.39200833439826965,
-0.7562639713287354,
0.7968737483024597,
0.6093440651893616,
1.158339500427246,
-0.11735998094081879,
-0.20253074169158936,
0.08201935887336731,
0.16616754233837128,
0.39601895213127136,
0.035271238535642624,
-0.3659308850765228,
-1.055389642715454,
-0.727168619632721,
-0.35925793647766113,
-0.2921125888824463,
0.4570167660713196,
-0.6627152562141418,
0.20305417478084564,
-0.22161543369293213,
-0.32257747650146484,
0.12646231055259705,
-0.648222804069519,
-0.896859347820282,
0.2169412076473236,
0.42335519194602966,
0.5579332113265991,
-0.731395959854126,
0.7813401222229004,
0.5637296438217163,
-0.10391179472208023,
-0.45000433921813965,
0.4787372052669525,
-0.18658404052257538,
-1.0692684650421143,
1.2465159893035889,
0.6066036820411682,
-0.27864888310432434,
0.36674803495407104,
-0.41272756457328796,
-1.123260498046875,
0.9956063032150269,
0.2573622763156891,
-0.47602951526641846,
-0.2601138651371002,
0.08492795377969742,
0.3743607997894287,
-0.608133852481842,
0.6202443838119507,
0.9243089556694031,
0.48373496532440186,
-0.14399069547653198,
-0.7487077116966248,
0.0707775130867958,
0.09402802586555481,
-0.14464010298252106,
0.168462872505188,
-0.5453596711158752,
1.114763617515564,
-0.19471988081932068,
-0.30314284563064575,
-0.22930660843849182,
0.5460488200187683,
0.21610169112682343,
0.0343189500272274,
0.43838539719581604,
0.44459110498428345,
0.19093279540538788,
-0.06851248443126678,
1.0648353099822998,
-0.6910293698310852,
0.341930627822876,
1.1755656003952026,
-0.0879918783903122,
0.680137038230896,
1.0257580280303955,
-0.16968786716461182,
0.4632837772369385,
0.698854923248291,
0.11274976283311844,
0.620297372341156,
-0.06250365823507309,
-0.14844633638858795,
0.019403157755732536,
0.060315944254398346,
-0.2182752639055252,
0.48211243748664856,
0.33912691473960876,
-0.5330033302307129,
0.01652805507183075,
-0.16333292424678802,
-0.3640415072441101,
-0.656170129776001,
-0.377918541431427,
0.7606056332588196,
0.10263922065496445,
-0.7996119856834412,
0.3218080997467041,
-0.15564273297786713,
0.5770230293273926,
-0.3921576738357544,
0.02215363085269928,
-0.042026132345199585,
0.29558926820755005,
-0.28322020173072815,
-0.8946556448936462,
0.338474303483963,
-0.2898308336734772,
-0.3132193982601166,
-0.26787829399108887,
0.671901524066925,
-0.37945061922073364,
-0.014510281383991241,
0.6072857975959778,
0.3257085084915161,
0.1405346542596817,
-0.24954047799110413,
-0.8795666098594666,
-0.007223078515380621,
-0.008536958135664463,
-0.7912085056304932,
0.4902936816215515,
0.4357495605945587,
0.16510552167892456,
0.49317988753318787,
0.6194037199020386,
-0.15678665041923523,
0.15966497361660004,
0.3910135328769684,
0.8663771152496338,
-0.6899710297584534,
-0.4231663644313812,
-1.1315747499465942,
0.6739057302474976,
-0.056090131402015686,
-0.3177332878112793,
0.5139268040657043,
0.2218707799911499,
1.0301765203475952,
-0.3784139156341553,
0.48514503240585327,
0.21916337311267853,
0.19940118491649628,
-0.4538564383983612,
0.4042229950428009,
-0.5467380285263062,
0.12738998234272003,
-0.1989719122648239,
-1.1911520957946777,
-0.290111780166626,
0.5436622500419617,
-0.09389448910951614,
0.033170390874147415,
1.0154744386672974,
0.4716227650642395,
-0.22785845398902893,
-0.3075368404388428,
0.46829953789711,
0.2787492871284485,
0.2985368072986603,
0.4873204529285431,
0.7579566836357117,
-0.15779660642147064,
0.483929842710495,
-0.01260684709995985,
0.03876491263508797,
-0.14209645986557007,
-0.9990188479423523,
-1.0538653135299683,
-0.580180287361145,
0.02593066729605198,
-0.12825331091880798,
-0.5161521434783936,
0.4670596420764923,
0.5403332114219666,
-0.7288302779197693,
-0.17009598016738892,
-0.42200830578804016,
0.0028001251630485058,
-0.335153728723526,
-0.3476777672767639,
0.38043922185897827,
-0.6693086624145508,
-0.8955110311508179,
0.39158496260643005,
0.6571239233016968,
-0.050005026161670685,
-0.41423657536506653,
0.22080457210540771,
-0.04993250593543053,
-0.007125681731849909,
0.8507982492446899,
-0.008629408665001392,
-0.9570237994194031,
-0.3817984163761139,
-0.022248810157179832,
-0.00045650938409380615,
0.24448034167289734,
1.2482868432998657,
-0.9161342978477478,
0.02956387586891651,
0.44777926802635193,
0.7134913802146912,
0.6596278548240662,
-0.04790017381310463,
0.7467589974403381,
-1.0615030527114868,
0.3791835606098175,
0.1984100341796875,
0.5334666967391968,
0.22940921783447266,
-0.5478100180625916,
0.3746090233325958,
0.22703450918197632,
-0.6456976532936096,
-0.7923381924629211,
0.6519971489906311,
-1.0951018333435059,
-0.07929163426160812,
1.0277392864227295,
-0.12330655753612518,
-0.13281415402889252,
0.06520082801580429,
-0.27859699726104736,
0.15881472826004028,
-0.12196855247020721,
0.6394952535629272,
0.8629477024078369,
-0.4553282856941223,
-0.35771170258522034,
-0.6193174719810486,
0.6602737903594971,
0.6582401990890503,
-0.5349401831626892,
0.07371438294649124,
0.02000429481267929,
0.06821209192276001,
0.3391174376010895,
0.4706565737724304,
-0.04245610907673836,
0.22355154156684875,
-0.29614588618278503,
-0.20034991204738617,
0.03683138266205788,
-0.5906566977500916,
-0.39663559198379517,
0.2521192133426666,
-0.24486956000328064,
-0.22168096899986267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15052v1
|
ToMBench: Benchmarking Theory of Mind in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T02:05:46 | 2024-02-23T02:05:46 |
Zhuang Chen, Jincenzi Wu, Jinfeng Zhou, Bosi Wen, Guanqun Bi, Gongyao Jiang, Yaru Cao, Mengting Hu, Yunghwei Lai, Zexuan Xiong, Minlie Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Theory of Mind (ToM) is the cognitive capability to perceive and ascribe
mental states to oneself and others. Recent research has sparked a debate over
whether large language models (LLMs) exhibit a form of ToM. However, existing
ToM evaluations are hindered by challenges such as constrained scope,
subjective judgment, and unintended contamination, yielding inadequate
assessments. To address this gap, we introduce ToMBench with three key
characteristics: a systematic evaluation framework encompassing 8 tasks and 31
abilities in social cognition, a multiple-choice question format to support
automated and unbiased evaluation, and a build-from-scratch bilingual inventory
to strictly avoid data leakage. Based on ToMBench, we conduct extensive
experiments to evaluate the ToM performance of 10 popular LLMs across tasks and
abilities. We find that even the most advanced LLMs like GPT-4 lag behind human
performance by over 10% points, indicating that LLMs have not achieved a
human-level theory of mind yet. Our aim with ToMBench is to enable an efficient
and effective evaluation of LLMs' ToM capabilities, thereby facilitating the
development of LLMs with inherent social intelligence.
|
[
-0.5588723421096802,
-0.6704084873199463,
0.9338536262512207,
0.32213500142097473,
-0.44575735926628113,
0.14018511772155762,
-0.5988378524780273,
-0.49742966890335083,
0.2808661460876465,
0.32205191254615784,
-0.46769896149635315,
-0.5020950436592102,
-0.76267009973526,
0.043436456471681595,
-0.30669161677360535,
0.8022370934486389,
-0.035538449883461,
0.3739071786403656,
-0.0415494479238987,
-0.32938385009765625,
-0.1895967721939087,
-0.4553702771663666,
-0.89948570728302,
-0.5517825484275818,
0.3663972318172455,
0.013280265033245087,
0.33057212829589844,
0.5002002716064453,
0.6585294604301453,
0.2636845111846924,
0.05026319622993469,
-0.2473125159740448,
-0.5165613293647766,
0.36398816108703613,
-0.3588588833808899,
-0.5660634636878967,
-0.692706286907196,
-0.030662477016448975,
0.8801323175430298,
0.7045701146125793,
-0.16547180712223053,
0.1927153319120407,
0.21525250375270844,
0.7498196363449097,
-0.6193156242370605,
0.4359380900859833,
-0.5853588581085205,
-0.10678724199533463,
-0.32258206605911255,
-0.10912881046533585,
-0.1261349469423294,
-0.3614441752433777,
0.4957335591316223,
-0.20786413550376892,
0.08661635965108871,
-0.00591428205370903,
0.3175842761993408,
0.14688082039356232,
-0.42266103625297546,
0.006376703269779682,
-0.4753868877887726,
0.9280845522880554,
-0.5873074531555176,
0.40409421920776367,
0.2731916904449463,
0.6189723014831543,
-0.028296245262026787,
-0.31369900703430176,
-0.5797426104545593,
-0.2973218560218811,
0.2924737334251404,
0.26979386806488037,
0.18452773988246918,
0.24597357213497162,
0.3154759109020233,
0.4292530417442322,
-0.648322582244873,
-0.4009600877761841,
-0.08184491842985153,
0.04974710941314697,
0.7294933795928955,
0.11132020503282547,
0.2481863647699356,
-0.21403701603412628,
-0.3139907419681549,
-0.3974170982837677,
-0.5567953586578369,
-0.19780966639518738,
0.22072969377040863,
0.12137947231531143,
0.01574191264808178,
0.3558749258518219,
-0.22590002417564392,
0.27985531091690063,
0.0025330581702291965,
-0.0070909238420426846,
0.1582619547843933,
0.058958444744348526,
-0.15544766187667847,
-0.061894454061985016,
0.7373427748680115,
0.4157780110836029,
0.5430039763450623,
-0.30878371000289917,
-0.2987518906593323,
0.23360112309455872,
0.41085708141326904,
-0.8507435917854309,
-0.1343442052602768,
0.22625316679477692,
-0.30245816707611084,
-0.0041951704770326614,
0.0823441818356514,
-0.8970311880111694,
-0.525461733341217,
0.0317322313785553,
0.37043118476867676,
-0.39811524748802185,
-0.4691092371940613,
0.13087928295135498,
-0.21342967450618744,
0.19559957087039948,
0.2984721064567566,
-0.8750900030136108,
0.7353166341781616,
0.7394782304763794,
0.8501328229904175,
-0.4092586040496826,
-0.5147035717964172,
-0.10254551470279694,
0.3200337886810303,
-0.49181175231933594,
0.8207326531410217,
-0.3728635311126709,
-0.5376086235046387,
-0.07792627066373825,
0.01128881610929966,
0.012856461107730865,
-0.29755017161369324,
0.34308910369873047,
-0.3742941915988922,
0.02452818863093853,
-0.6171935796737671,
-0.557377278804779,
-0.1980615258216858,
0.36447766423225403,
-0.6506286859512329,
0.7744068503379822,
0.2362906038761139,
-0.6026744842529297,
0.42420849204063416,
-0.5614582300186157,
-0.5562024116516113,
0.3257787525653839,
-0.622112512588501,
0.19260931015014648,
0.12152647227048874,
-0.1723894476890564,
0.6259859204292297,
-0.780248761177063,
0.433691143989563,
-0.4829765260219574,
-0.41549476981163025,
0.13449805974960327,
-0.21504707634449005,
0.8735719919204712,
0.013992705382406712,
-0.770867645740509,
0.070243239402771,
-0.6175406575202942,
0.34677886962890625,
0.1936771720647812,
-0.23366092145442963,
-0.6274493336677551,
-0.029246244579553604,
-0.07562335580587387,
0.0913706123828888,
0.2407897561788559,
-0.4043008089065552,
-0.05114000663161278,
-0.39767560362815857,
0.4118673503398895,
0.8405240178108215,
-0.17207132279872894,
0.44875216484069824,
-0.43389981985092163,
0.5408952832221985,
-0.4095148742198944,
0.07459646463394165,
0.18636538088321686,
-0.4234028160572052,
-0.6160510182380676,
-0.229659304022789,
0.0836741104722023,
0.4024016857147217,
-0.5116077661514282,
0.47007131576538086,
-0.6339742541313171,
-0.5224934816360474,
-0.2999148666858673,
0.19734004139900208,
0.7227531671524048,
0.042632147669792175,
0.013127295300364494,
-0.9035791754722595,
-0.35361456871032715,
-1.0700267553329468,
-0.2762112021446228,
-0.3797840178012848,
-0.2181953489780426,
0.45414823293685913,
0.628273069858551,
-0.031443845480680466,
0.47175830602645874,
-0.2537955045700073,
-0.047739263623952866,
-0.252605676651001,
0.2605481743812561,
0.012245514430105686,
0.3526776134967804,
0.41477280855178833,
-0.4717181921005249,
-0.0705060139298439,
-0.16257329285144806,
-0.8436300754547119,
0.03402162343263626,
0.4003293216228485,
-0.15571284294128418,
0.10051336139440536,
0.18702399730682373,
-0.9332004189491272,
0.08081591874361038,
0.4691171646118164,
-0.09588094055652618,
0.430074542760849,
-0.12863588333129883,
0.4090929627418518,
-1.0914620161056519,
0.1128089427947998,
0.15559108555316925,
0.14683561027050018,
-0.4033346474170685,
0.5237242579460144,
0.2678755521774292,
0.29804515838623047,
-0.25319334864616394,
0.8582242727279663,
-0.4012996554374695,
-0.38563260436058044,
-0.05758466199040413,
0.5069270730018616,
-0.19830724596977234,
0.5723633766174316,
-0.1896783858537674,
0.6088421940803528,
0.33294251561164856,
-0.6123911142349243,
0.38200604915618896,
0.008196922019124031,
-0.6314034461975098,
0.9227756261825562,
-0.6204996109008789,
0.3406757712364197,
0.06527308374643326,
0.5277814865112305,
-1.109325647354126,
-0.26210352778434753,
-0.010151376947760582,
-0.1561659276485443,
0.17841336131095886,
0.01121320016682148,
-0.551120936870575,
-0.3958752453327179,
-0.4705165922641754,
0.5175250768661499,
0.6288024187088013,
-0.16409768164157867,
0.8181823492050171,
0.5877315998077393,
-0.1876428723335266,
-0.3580494523048401,
-0.6513140201568604,
0.09917030483484268,
-0.21696041524410248,
-0.699567973613739,
0.4274618923664093,
-0.29547181725502014,
-0.7290424108505249,
-0.19861438870429993,
-0.3465791344642639,
-0.08860912919044495,
0.0791439414024353,
0.19929994642734528,
0.09038005769252777,
-0.21732565760612488,
0.17588762938976288,
-0.16661062836647034,
-0.03911084681749344,
0.37403813004493713,
-0.14990440011024475,
0.6026777625083923,
-0.3767016530036926,
-0.3201828896999359,
-0.005507858004420996,
0.1330392062664032,
0.7211892604827881,
-0.04871448501944542,
0.258996844291687,
0.2779807448387146,
-0.48641714453697205,
-0.47911128401756287,
-0.6961602568626404,
-0.4030877351760864,
-0.37953636050224304,
0.4586416184902191,
-0.589874267578125,
-0.7857806086540222,
0.5866025686264038,
-0.033478740602731705,
0.030520308762788773,
0.3572610020637512,
0.5744693875312805,
0.1461711972951889,
1.03171706199646,
0.7326201796531677,
-0.1556137353181839,
0.287401407957077,
-0.059638649225234985,
0.1335129290819168,
-1.0853028297424316,
0.07616707682609558,
-0.381664514541626,
-0.2615673840045929,
-0.4728614389896393,
-0.4294722080230713,
0.15244844555854797,
-0.1477135866880417,
-0.3949642777442932,
0.2705100476741791,
-0.23675593733787537,
0.36220937967300415,
0.3954063057899475,
0.06279925256967545,
0.2636163532733917,
-0.30282753705978394,
-0.41009438037872314,
0.08945449441671371,
-0.4041363000869751,
-0.7103713154792786,
1.3443540334701538,
0.26650431752204895,
0.6310530304908752,
0.18503345549106598,
0.5321952700614929,
0.1285029947757721,
0.3258660137653351,
-0.7219417095184326,
1.0620660781860352,
-0.19640731811523438,
-0.9645600318908691,
-0.4987014830112457,
-0.2986079454421997,
-0.6267289519309998,
0.35307419300079346,
0.043092042207717896,
-0.9342955350875854,
-0.2884308099746704,
-0.0499948188662529,
-0.3296811282634735,
0.20851050317287445,
-0.4977380335330963,
0.6739442944526672,
-0.42634737491607666,
-0.42378100752830505,
-0.6145233511924744,
-0.6421132683753967,
0.6169585585594177,
-0.1730705052614212,
-0.03614586591720581,
-0.3134390711784363,
0.05020827427506447,
1.0398720502853394,
0.1891825944185257,
0.5970741510391235,
-0.005591419525444508,
-0.3261559009552002,
-0.030209345743060112,
0.24317438900470734,
0.43289896845817566,
-0.028296226635575294,
0.0014643104514107108,
0.1879706233739853,
0.3195003867149353,
-0.3512941896915436,
-0.9128580689430237,
0.8145163059234619,
-0.7179528474807739,
-0.7236412167549133,
-0.40040159225463867,
-0.4532274603843689,
-0.6360815167427063,
0.2758285105228424,
-0.07232583314180374,
0.22549398243427277,
-0.6067417860031128,
0.2564666271209717,
0.7648601531982422,
0.03092765063047409,
0.14103306829929352,
0.5927520990371704,
-0.4744489789009094,
-0.33227068185806274,
0.6576434373855591,
0.1617799997329712,
0.1730712205171585,
0.295590877532959,
0.11819028854370117,
-0.26420506834983826,
-0.4337722361087799,
-0.24152828752994537,
0.27057719230651855,
-0.9555400609970093,
0.3573964536190033,
-0.7579061985015869,
-0.19079633057117462,
-0.31332826614379883,
-0.049155499786138535,
-0.4622173607349396,
-0.28642240166664124,
0.43642932176589966,
-0.09661069512367249,
0.0904308632016182,
0.9306939840316772,
0.21899256110191345,
0.2787730097770691,
-0.2655719518661499,
0.3389381170272827,
0.6126832365989685,
0.7684022188186646,
0.22890837490558624,
-0.1684693694114685,
-0.0767119899392128,
0.09620430320501328,
-0.10434204339981079,
-0.7490764260292053,
0.02248072251677513,
-0.22904838621616364,
0.7311498522758484,
0.5369014143943787,
-0.16360336542129517,
0.7299253940582275,
-0.41533973813056946,
0.6742982268333435,
0.007713611703366041,
-1.038473129272461,
0.3963002860546112,
-0.5787407159805298,
0.19292593002319336,
0.6429271101951599,
0.16176073253154755,
-0.4921923279762268,
-0.4545789659023285,
-0.7366878390312195,
-0.7461376786231995,
0.3724803030490875,
0.06022770330309868,
-0.02825772762298584,
-0.15270939469337463,
0.2706085741519928,
0.072771817445755,
0.5346734523773193,
-0.4256587624549866,
-0.06234678998589516,
-0.06814902275800705,
-0.2209848016500473,
-0.4954844117164612,
-0.19936762750148773,
-0.36052948236465454,
-0.2308378964662552,
0.5615495443344116,
-0.1212642714381218,
0.3152875304222107,
-0.04665113240480423,
-0.1736285239458084,
-0.40623703598976135,
0.36896899342536926,
0.547424852848053,
1.036452054977417,
-0.5114083886146545,
0.409650981426239,
0.3046937882900238,
-0.49283918738365173,
0.06860894709825516,
-0.10790177434682846,
0.09733802080154419,
-0.3141518533229828,
0.3112959861755371,
0.41304320096969604,
0.6173722147941589,
-0.7841861844062805,
0.4953360855579376,
-0.1564302146434784,
-0.32834869623184204,
-0.4363475739955902,
0.3667299747467041,
0.010463711805641651,
0.44349467754364014,
0.553817093372345,
-0.2304844856262207,
0.025308094918727875,
-0.6799150705337524,
0.22399838268756866,
0.7255508303642273,
-0.4439347982406616,
-0.4133487939834595,
0.5222460627555847,
0.19776147603988647,
-0.30546092987060547,
0.33675524592399597,
-0.1482977271080017,
-0.5652288198471069,
0.5951825380325317,
0.3382972478866577,
1.3130470514297485,
-0.29977360367774963,
0.10036587715148926,
0.1526394784450531,
0.4409397840499878,
-0.49993833899497986,
0.39539849758148193,
-0.12248579412698746,
-0.8572568297386169,
-0.29156965017318726,
-0.5729194283485413,
-0.4628523588180542,
0.3457355797290802,
-0.71039217710495,
-0.12329677492380142,
-0.7338002324104309,
-0.37510451674461365,
-0.19560305774211884,
0.4802442491054535,
-0.796841561794281,
0.16915291547775269,
-0.014885562472045422,
0.767956018447876,
-0.6648648977279663,
0.7972258925437927,
0.755922794342041,
-0.054904237389564514,
-0.5738123059272766,
0.12140940129756927,
0.19464707374572754,
-0.9173508882522583,
0.6108980774879456,
0.23377881944179535,
-0.4688365161418915,
0.18989820778369904,
-0.3527827262878418,
-0.8125181198120117,
1.2119539976119995,
0.41316086053848267,
-0.467928946018219,
-0.0012193286092951894,
-0.37140005826950073,
0.7050046920776367,
-0.47913888096809387,
0.40361589193344116,
0.7332679629325867,
0.6995672583580017,
-0.22874762117862701,
-0.8839812874794006,
0.21415430307388306,
-0.5013384819030762,
0.16689321398735046,
0.11239199340343475,
-0.8846155405044556,
0.873994767665863,
0.04922125115990639,
-0.4478767216205597,
0.14860081672668457,
0.24682189524173737,
0.45106157660484314,
-0.0363694466650486,
0.519328773021698,
0.5111478567123413,
0.7344731688499451,
-0.06825212389230728,
1.1989210844039917,
-0.6258005499839783,
0.1152074858546257,
1.0393133163452148,
-0.6949843168258667,
0.8366253972053528,
0.38870811462402344,
-0.4067905843257904,
0.39978015422821045,
0.42325979471206665,
0.1558792144060135,
0.4263579249382019,
0.3634147047996521,
-0.1830623298883438,
-0.20816898345947266,
0.0996842011809349,
-0.2659931480884552,
0.4329013228416443,
0.19384758174419403,
-0.24045401811599731,
-0.04913674294948578,
-0.27340221405029297,
-0.055175550282001495,
-0.13097591698169708,
-0.052778732031583786,
0.5160173177719116,
0.22746260464191437,
-0.8181889057159424,
0.3581693768501282,
-0.09548260271549225,
0.584036111831665,
-0.7445715069770813,
-0.02243218757212162,
-0.1473236083984375,
0.23710782825946808,
0.2967064380645752,
-0.7459143400192261,
-0.2059050351381302,
-0.27798041701316833,
-0.06418724358081818,
-0.22015555202960968,
0.5881726741790771,
-0.22420090436935425,
-0.2425079047679901,
0.7139143347740173,
0.9105299711227417,
0.4005434811115265,
-0.1858133226633072,
-0.6662911772727966,
0.015419665724039078,
-0.31588882207870483,
-0.4589956998825073,
0.4594907760620117,
0.4654158353805542,
-0.14411799609661102,
0.9925803542137146,
0.4090272784233093,
0.4507858455181122,
-0.1944359838962555,
0.24291406571865082,
0.39595693349838257,
-0.9245962500572205,
-0.5300466418266296,
-1.0989362001419067,
0.04533611610531807,
-0.15371651947498322,
-0.4371325373649597,
0.8729188442230225,
0.27454662322998047,
0.8774424195289612,
0.12991073727607727,
1.0879558324813843,
-0.024768400937318802,
0.26371514797210693,
-0.2850292921066284,
0.9277065992355347,
-0.4334348738193512,
0.2091151922941208,
-0.7232330441474915,
-1.1538604497909546,
-0.007955508306622505,
0.8724533319473267,
-0.483158141374588,
0.4384237229824066,
1.199877381324768,
0.4956640303134918,
0.16562813520431519,
0.2424849420785904,
0.5412381887435913,
0.3032713532447815,
0.18560905754566193,
0.814941942691803,
0.8459410667419434,
-0.1618703305721283,
0.16156309843063354,
-0.2510009706020355,
-0.48660609126091003,
-0.11476291716098785,
-0.8324856162071228,
-1.2617433071136475,
-0.8271312117576599,
-0.027591215446591377,
-0.05131717026233673,
0.33450162410736084,
0.8451931476593018,
0.8308854699134827,
-0.5537323951721191,
-0.5978776216506958,
-0.07723227888345718,
0.05426216125488281,
-0.39273253083229065,
-0.20536763966083527,
0.2896772027015686,
-0.06160498782992363,
-0.5152188539505005,
0.23028571903705597,
0.6289397478103638,
0.13544410467147827,
-0.8090065121650696,
-0.062289707362651825,
0.07735662907361984,
0.16994372010231018,
0.6761828064918518,
-0.027362771332263947,
-0.8983849287033081,
-0.4208517074584961,
-0.16900905966758728,
-0.24489031732082367,
-0.1150442361831665,
0.8652504682540894,
-0.5627836585044861,
0.3269791901111603,
0.24134628474712372,
0.6634125709533691,
0.36888641119003296,
-0.16118589043617249,
0.82489413022995,
-0.2814970314502716,
-0.09182973206043243,
0.21120235323905945,
0.5000577569007874,
0.21919870376586914,
-0.07044053822755814,
0.6534693241119385,
0.10238474607467651,
-0.46241989731788635,
-0.6747781038284302,
0.15875343978405,
-0.9851444363594055,
-0.3092833459377289,
1.075205683708191,
-0.0611068457365036,
-0.5086781978607178,
-0.035614077001810074,
0.08958572149276733,
0.26670369505882263,
-0.4111623764038086,
1.2456119060516357,
1.1918962001800537,
0.17634327709674835,
-0.200068861246109,
-1.0565553903579712,
0.44286248087882996,
0.4763287901878357,
-0.7152314186096191,
0.0840308666229248,
0.2747013568878174,
0.3249441087245941,
0.20772553980350494,
1.0040338039398193,
-0.022574182599782944,
0.24012987315654755,
-0.04692663624882698,
0.18551307916641235,
0.4404115080833435,
-0.36586764454841614,
-0.13276493549346924,
0.20756717026233673,
0.04425295442342758,
0.25246793031692505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15048v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15048v1
|
Unlocking the Power of Large Language Models for Entity Alignment
| 2024-02-23T01:55:35 | 2024-02-23T01:55:35 |
Xuhui Jiang, Yinghan Shen, Zhichao Shi, Chengjin Xu, Wei Li, Zixuan Li, Jian Guo, Huawei Shen, Yuanzhuo Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Entity Alignment (EA) is vital for integrating diverse knowledge graph (KG)
data, playing a crucial role in data-driven AI applications. Traditional EA
methods primarily rely on comparing entity embeddings, but their effectiveness
is constrained by the limited input KG data and the capabilities of the
representation learning techniques. Against this backdrop, we introduce ChatEA,
an innovative framework that incorporates large language models (LLMs) to
improve EA. To address the constraints of limited input KG data, ChatEA
introduces a KG-code translation module that translates KG structures into a
format understandable by LLMs, thereby allowing LLMs to utilize their extensive
background knowledge to improve EA accuracy. To overcome the over-reliance on
entity embedding comparisons, ChatEA implements a two-stage EA strategy that
capitalizes on LLMs' capability for multi-step reasoning in a dialogue format,
thereby enhancing accuracy while preserving efficiency. Our experimental
results affirm ChatEA's superior performance, highlighting LLMs' potential in
facilitating EA tasks.
|
[
-0.15864308178424835,
-0.5926747918128967,
0.6495459079742432,
0.13835667073726654,
0.025406526401638985,
0.41836684942245483,
-0.22537201642990112,
-0.5484116673469543,
0.17560739815235138,
0.5342189073562622,
-0.24633657932281494,
-0.8783519864082336,
-0.7044165730476379,
-0.021830903366208076,
-0.4426676332950592,
0.6488218903541565,
-0.32724353671073914,
0.05956513062119484,
-0.11309108138084412,
-0.2900374233722687,
-0.6510189771652222,
0.02228001318871975,
-0.868659257888794,
-0.13913089036941528,
0.45531368255615234,
0.5470026135444641,
0.7375380396842957,
0.6982766389846802,
0.49482789635658264,
0.3211374878883362,
0.14937113225460052,
0.7443485260009766,
-0.5824037194252014,
0.129243865609169,
-0.00860205665230751,
-0.742247462272644,
-0.7187475562095642,
-0.3429069519042969,
0.5880109667778015,
0.6321272850036621,
-0.3494897782802582,
0.013658581301569939,
-0.07169204950332642,
0.49306759238243103,
-0.27963998913764954,
0.5678490400314331,
-0.8266550898551941,
-0.26587021350860596,
-0.19843408465385437,
0.13609184324741364,
-0.6928912997245789,
-0.2899324893951416,
0.23125486075878143,
-0.9192676544189453,
-0.3346036672592163,
0.394475519657135,
1.0889023542404175,
0.4700656533241272,
-0.6448946595191956,
-0.3413728177547455,
-0.7654536962509155,
0.5329844951629639,
-0.7030994892120361,
0.8401695489883423,
-0.14162953197956085,
0.19681285321712494,
-0.34917253255844116,
-0.6184388399124146,
-0.7177067995071411,
0.19153240323066711,
0.11469578742980957,
-0.12764893472194672,
-0.22945654392242432,
0.09696653485298157,
0.09698767215013504,
-0.09212017059326172,
-0.5384695529937744,
0.4571283757686615,
-0.11191922426223755,
-0.10394445806741714,
0.5779511332511902,
0.02782268449664116,
0.6024303436279297,
0.16572320461273193,
-0.2807915210723877,
-0.19950944185256958,
-0.9584726691246033,
-0.26783475279808044,
0.312308669090271,
0.3688388168811798,
-0.021606452763080597,
0.672415018081665,
0.13728266954421997,
0.4528527557849884,
-0.09703820943832397,
-0.29798558354377747,
0.28818389773368835,
0.10224343091249466,
-0.3143979609012604,
0.14453564584255219,
0.7349896430969238,
0.4678111672401428,
0.23317869007587433,
-0.5806940793991089,
-0.12551328539848328,
0.10927687585353851,
0.21674109995365143,
-0.9699469208717346,
-0.06519705057144165,
0.4629300534725189,
-0.15980978310108185,
-0.12862423062324524,
-0.14586567878723145,
-0.9098235964775085,
-0.4825008809566498,
-0.42268356680870056,
0.14934681355953217,
-0.6142237782478333,
-0.1823550909757614,
0.07100921124219894,
0.21728938817977905,
0.3206246793270111,
0.44954895973205566,
-0.7394018769264221,
0.220082625746727,
0.86948162317276,
0.6818953156471252,
-0.04095367714762688,
-0.3181166350841522,
-0.3796691596508026,
0.5375991463661194,
-0.5462386012077332,
0.637877345085144,
-0.6263331770896912,
-0.07646825909614563,
0.18718221783638,
-0.1346689611673355,
-0.10080963373184204,
-0.43314069509506226,
0.4783799946308136,
-0.8855305314064026,
-0.07031955569982529,
-0.08245307952165604,
-0.9427104592323303,
-0.42859190702438354,
0.07684303820133209,
-0.6348494291305542,
0.7808849215507507,
-0.1114945262670517,
-0.3400261402130127,
0.5876403450965881,
-0.547492265701294,
-0.35023292899131775,
-0.10131581872701645,
-0.37766364216804504,
-0.5191670656204224,
-0.21533863246440887,
0.4184955656528473,
0.26069411635398865,
-0.356352835893631,
0.36978206038475037,
-0.44748690724372864,
-0.022444773465394974,
0.03284086287021637,
-0.21099631488323212,
0.45388495922088623,
0.14102911949157715,
-0.1757664829492569,
0.04893173649907112,
-0.644604504108429,
-0.005698959808796644,
0.1687033474445343,
-0.2173178344964981,
-0.23057499527931213,
0.22928717732429504,
-0.33525535464286804,
0.15631675720214844,
0.28802549839019775,
-0.3905353844165802,
0.491557240486145,
-0.42600956559181213,
0.4206216037273407,
0.45886340737342834,
-0.2746317982673645,
0.6924191117286682,
-0.04518747702240944,
0.3410426676273346,
0.15704432129859924,
-0.24707664549350739,
0.02388664335012436,
-0.48335304856300354,
-0.5867089629173279,
-0.3587464690208435,
0.5068497061729431,
0.7706833481788635,
-0.7521933913230896,
0.466743528842926,
-0.7960339784622192,
-0.6003609895706177,
-0.9050151705741882,
0.4554607570171356,
0.21302452683448792,
0.5354247093200684,
0.35266968607902527,
-0.1665678322315216,
-0.4431208074092865,
-0.7377490401268005,
0.09516718983650208,
-0.3478473722934723,
0.07773243635892868,
0.3094807267189026,
0.23519417643547058,
-0.2036803811788559,
0.6333115100860596,
-0.3411226272583008,
-0.4609949588775635,
-0.23535089194774628,
0.06257668882608414,
0.03976283222436905,
0.40423837304115295,
0.5040468573570251,
-0.7328612208366394,
-0.2875382900238037,
0.2649919092655182,
-0.8430587649345398,
-0.017093870788812637,
-0.09299059212207794,
-0.645378589630127,
0.13706907629966736,
0.4897318184375763,
-0.967395544052124,
0.14733406901359558,
0.7030984163284302,
-0.33390432596206665,
-0.13391999900341034,
0.20558449625968933,
0.2909131348133087,
-1.2176693677902222,
-0.01846582442522049,
-0.08910088986158371,
-0.3640078008174896,
-0.49947264790534973,
0.06061091274023056,
0.20235280692577362,
-0.24637290835380554,
-0.2275722771883011,
0.3353332579135895,
-0.5140649080276489,
-0.2270296961069107,
-0.040864210575819016,
0.7254449129104614,
0.3337191939353943,
0.4882102310657501,
0.011971070431172848,
0.7018514275550842,
0.5341425538063049,
-0.4258098900318146,
0.19684606790542603,
0.7618468999862671,
-0.3033156096935272,
0.5257153511047363,
-0.46723052859306335,
0.2629011571407318,
-0.2521286606788635,
0.396035373210907,
-0.9486789703369141,
-0.19489401578903198,
0.08777616918087006,
-0.2560839056968689,
0.8892185688018799,
-0.2727372944355011,
-0.3924367129802704,
-0.19894953072071075,
0.02719511091709137,
0.31199437379837036,
0.3374612629413605,
-0.5384889245033264,
1.0223673582077026,
0.6007770895957947,
-0.0408652126789093,
-0.9153502583503723,
-0.5689169764518738,
0.13335777819156647,
-0.216552734375,
-0.8769118785858154,
0.5073909759521484,
0.2635360360145569,
-0.13899751007556915,
0.1287507265806198,
-0.12235254794359207,
-0.024305569007992744,
0.1539354920387268,
0.09355144202709198,
0.5105758309364319,
-0.5783224105834961,
0.3622671067714691,
0.06114235147833824,
0.11919989436864853,
-0.11990111321210861,
-0.5726909637451172,
0.5906317234039307,
0.2158259004354477,
-0.4209577143192291,
-0.33270537853240967,
0.13499730825424194,
0.6533825993537903,
-0.484388530254364,
1.0346155166625977,
0.24257396161556244,
-0.5628694891929626,
-0.1709935963153839,
-0.5202688574790955,
0.2233635038137436,
-0.36187341809272766,
0.7010080814361572,
-0.3191686272621155,
-0.7148410081863403,
0.5089676976203918,
-0.29742199182510376,
0.6251490116119385,
0.3147604763507843,
0.32532915472984314,
-0.11473675072193146,
1.1574006080627441,
0.46960845589637756,
-0.31822851300239563,
0.35094064474105835,
-0.16371296346187592,
0.6334115266799927,
-0.818860650062561,
-0.2716682553291321,
-0.5455918908119202,
-0.4848615229129791,
-0.4970449209213257,
-0.4768030047416687,
0.043169353157281876,
0.38342568278312683,
-0.2797297239303589,
0.45842882990837097,
-0.25171855092048645,
0.4755699038505554,
-0.0327247679233551,
0.1597258746623993,
0.24638424813747406,
-0.1741088479757309,
0.3367766737937927,
-0.04489146173000336,
-0.6553793549537659,
-0.8010576963424683,
1.202189564704895,
0.6015269160270691,
0.5773335099220276,
0.42724284529685974,
0.7606928944587708,
-0.07043061405420303,
0.6129240393638611,
-0.8736810088157654,
0.4195435047149658,
-0.1402478814125061,
-0.42957547307014465,
-0.6038914918899536,
-0.44454142451286316,
-0.9469686150550842,
0.14219942688941956,
-0.2841072380542755,
-0.9501604437828064,
0.031820233911275864,
0.12825354933738708,
-0.22754915058612823,
0.6042319536209106,
-0.8655351996421814,
0.9937257170677185,
-0.3046877682209015,
-0.10809832811355591,
-0.03342943266034126,
-0.3122403621673584,
0.2842888832092285,
-0.08526620268821716,
0.2764471769332886,
-0.2658184766769409,
-0.2181183099746704,
0.5746735334396362,
-0.1964349001646042,
0.5903241038322449,
-0.11818566173315048,
-0.5089897513389587,
0.25684091448783875,
0.16756924986839294,
0.8342140316963196,
-0.0744599997997284,
-0.0020179394632577896,
0.1130727007985115,
-0.25369930267333984,
-0.434660941362381,
-0.8779834508895874,
0.6930679082870483,
-0.8468242287635803,
-0.5377578735351562,
0.21778905391693115,
-0.6688277125358582,
-0.5421244502067566,
0.20438486337661743,
-0.06935124099254608,
0.39210036396980286,
-0.26445794105529785,
0.11325367540121078,
0.7668119072914124,
-0.12141016125679016,
0.11585123091936111,
0.3884565830230713,
-0.5867270231246948,
-0.32374611496925354,
0.8764908313751221,
0.1698528379201889,
0.264041006565094,
0.6070203185081482,
-0.5306228995323181,
-0.41936352849006653,
-0.5841547846794128,
-0.8751113414764404,
0.2624804675579071,
-0.727822482585907,
-0.4749884307384491,
-0.8278046250343323,
0.05418992042541504,
-0.632041871547699,
-0.0909997969865799,
-0.5472759008407593,
-0.20884501934051514,
-0.019131775945425034,
-0.2594093978404999,
0.17755034565925598,
0.7211384177207947,
0.4214284420013428,
0.2608356773853302,
-0.7658193111419678,
0.033450450748205185,
0.10333714634180069,
0.26977860927581787,
0.029322151094675064,
-0.260906845331192,
0.009794958867132664,
-0.09972909092903137,
-0.3228781521320343,
-1.1086466312408447,
0.2851860821247101,
0.14726169407367706,
0.372624933719635,
0.2700692415237427,
-0.35745206475257874,
0.7986270785331726,
-0.6615242958068848,
0.390320748090744,
0.00748713593930006,
-0.9321826100349426,
0.254150390625,
-0.01467019971460104,
-0.1966743767261505,
0.3890373706817627,
0.3219146430492401,
-0.47941869497299194,
-0.45766663551330566,
-0.4451005160808563,
-0.9246094226837158,
0.44154930114746094,
0.18480460345745087,
0.013561713509261608,
0.06834781914949417,
0.279234915971756,
-0.09258229285478592,
0.21212393045425415,
-0.5201444625854492,
-0.1893971711397171,
0.27929219603538513,
-0.7299107909202576,
0.16058771312236786,
-0.02112399786710739,
-0.11608117073774338,
0.23966868221759796,
1.0009735822677612,
-0.3669419586658478,
0.12088718265295029,
-0.007010512985289097,
-0.3165079653263092,
-0.13704143464565277,
0.1940021514892578,
0.15777303278446198,
0.7056190967559814,
0.25395724177360535,
-0.12221640348434448,
0.494658499956131,
-0.13008899986743927,
0.05304842069745064,
0.29358118772506714,
-0.18346935510635376,
-0.15036818385124207,
0.3751840591430664,
0.859635591506958,
0.409765362739563,
-0.5113652348518372,
0.4654831290245056,
0.016327491030097008,
0.06934220343828201,
-0.07007835060358047,
-0.061316777020692825,
0.493644654750824,
0.4522652328014374,
0.030552616342902184,
-0.02811082825064659,
0.012123757973313332,
-0.4051969051361084,
0.17696355283260345,
0.37528058886528015,
-0.1514003425836563,
0.0010453679133206606,
0.8188460469245911,
0.32012516260147095,
-0.302956223487854,
0.6750178933143616,
-0.13051621615886688,
-0.44157174229621887,
0.6163660883903503,
0.47731688618659973,
0.5671954154968262,
-0.26502299308776855,
0.16250582039356232,
0.20201805233955383,
0.3641630709171295,
0.03635071963071823,
0.18730050325393677,
0.42641761898994446,
-1.015437126159668,
-0.7162308692932129,
-0.5879945158958435,
-0.280623197555542,
-0.13615265488624573,
-0.4344046413898468,
0.6129380464553833,
-0.13630463182926178,
0.1049673929810524,
0.15753647685050964,
-0.18979711830615997,
-0.9983277916908264,
0.04412669315934181,
0.4475196599960327,
1.0862897634506226,
-0.755969226360321,
0.860501229763031,
0.6451613903045654,
-0.5271062254905701,
-1.300600290298462,
-0.047849126160144806,
0.001146293361671269,
-0.9168544411659241,
0.38013550639152527,
0.23256438970565796,
0.13296498358249664,
0.14130914211273193,
-0.5437891483306885,
-1.0434629917144775,
1.4473472833633423,
0.6644291281700134,
-1.0168293714523315,
-0.5298962593078613,
0.11627216637134552,
0.4448701739311218,
-0.6122003197669983,
0.19540251791477203,
0.7490490674972534,
0.40014979243278503,
0.04334061220288277,
-0.8108097910881042,
-0.07128933817148209,
0.10257285088300705,
-0.1151641234755516,
0.6663546562194824,
-0.7911571860313416,
0.2319609373807907,
-0.05986998975276947,
-0.3527730405330658,
-0.10020790994167328,
1.0853315591812134,
0.20067985355854034,
0.2388758361339569,
0.5344573259353638,
0.8867563605308533,
1.2168182134628296,
-0.27626994252204895,
0.8414977788925171,
-0.4122221767902374,
0.15070489048957825,
1.1634173393249512,
-0.7311680316925049,
0.8345760107040405,
0.26495489478111267,
-0.15811240673065186,
0.6602562665939331,
0.3377344310283661,
0.15026985108852386,
0.1474948674440384,
-0.022161325439810753,
0.04999318718910217,
-0.23332242667675018,
-0.1596674919128418,
0.04980647191405296,
0.6271140575408936,
0.44973570108413696,
-0.2961224317550659,
-0.03187638521194458,
-0.17847824096679688,
0.3178952932357788,
0.05680941045284271,
-0.19604231417179108,
0.8282904028892517,
0.0679340735077858,
-0.7061219215393066,
0.05363510176539421,
-0.2591981589794159,
0.15195581316947937,
-0.4284271001815796,
-0.28812527656555176,
-0.02412230148911476,
-0.0521792471408844,
-0.16191835701465607,
-0.7570923566818237,
0.1392376869916916,
-0.03622039034962654,
0.08781915158033371,
0.12818552553653717,
0.6071566939353943,
-0.8320523500442505,
-0.23449480533599854,
0.4646512567996979,
0.5005989074707031,
0.04127231612801552,
0.29187101125717163,
-0.5123869180679321,
0.05969860404729843,
-0.003974370192736387,
-0.16534388065338135,
0.024419648572802544,
0.9559317231178284,
-0.06303516030311584,
0.6881712675094604,
0.318173348903656,
0.06121424213051796,
-0.008457289077341557,
0.0610928013920784,
0.7271899580955505,
-0.3737480938434601,
-0.29437756538391113,
-0.7917864918708801,
0.4680922329425812,
-0.35310664772987366,
-0.2528150975704193,
0.3236280083656311,
0.6157844662666321,
0.8650596737861633,
0.4460296928882599,
0.5622985363006592,
-0.10276700556278229,
0.15192893147468567,
-0.8411215543746948,
0.4425834119319916,
-0.4108240008354187,
0.3173017203807831,
-0.2362624555826187,
-1.0739511251449585,
-0.2291393131017685,
0.20177172124385834,
-0.23733170330524445,
-0.23264376819133759,
0.6320369243621826,
0.8220099806785583,
-0.061150796711444855,
0.11615670472383499,
0.3192965090274811,
0.35352253913879395,
0.6142249703407288,
0.7063486576080322,
0.5933219194412231,
-0.5255430340766907,
0.7976542711257935,
0.0790066123008728,
-0.11335700750350952,
0.1384517401456833,
-0.7278763055801392,
-0.7684513330459595,
-0.38431236147880554,
-0.46855628490448,
-0.41940072178840637,
-0.08346587419509888,
1.1904581785202026,
0.6798012256622314,
-0.9103465676307678,
0.12801335752010345,
0.017144057899713516,
0.1853359341621399,
0.05816279351711273,
-0.14410492777824402,
0.343607097864151,
-0.3788500428199768,
-1.1052066087722778,
0.4190118610858917,
0.3863283097743988,
0.06254617124795914,
-0.15107443928718567,
-0.15960289537906647,
-0.10055485367774963,
0.12576112151145935,
0.3057554364204407,
0.11077386140823364,
-0.7397032976150513,
-0.5308126211166382,
-0.00657882122322917,
-0.3780267536640167,
0.19595330953598022,
0.5239991545677185,
-0.3158188462257385,
0.279517263174057,
0.37124162912368774,
1.2196329832077026,
0.3140903413295746,
-0.06798645853996277,
0.8558005690574646,
-0.6565987467765808,
0.04350826516747475,
0.03697390854358673,
0.7598419785499573,
0.4113844037055969,
-0.48084166646003723,
0.7040824294090271,
-0.20807866752147675,
-0.6924181580543518,
-0.5885013937950134,
0.2439844012260437,
-0.8637012839317322,
-0.023155078291893005,
1.0265779495239258,
-0.3519119322299957,
-0.40997597575187683,
0.20545659959316254,
-0.4370405077934265,
0.6237475275993347,
-0.5339025855064392,
0.6731745600700378,
0.9486064314842224,
0.14815150201320648,
0.03156062215566635,
-0.37111249566078186,
0.3878841996192932,
0.5113272666931152,
-1.0162683725357056,
0.01732495054602623,
0.5984204411506653,
0.014879077672958374,
0.36374351382255554,
0.30820679664611816,
-0.13009575009346008,
0.08376822620630264,
-0.10266102850437164,
0.2021772712469101,
0.1892845332622528,
-0.4748319089412689,
0.0798107460141182,
0.08780340105295181,
0.29469287395477295,
-0.11381907761096954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15046v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15046v1
|
CARBD-Ko: A Contextually Annotated Review Benchmark Dataset for Aspect-Level Sentiment Classification in Korean
| 2024-02-23T01:49:38 | 2024-02-23T01:49:38 |
Dongjun Jang, Jean Seo, Sungjoo Byun, Taekyoung Kim, Minseok Kim, Hyopil Shin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper explores the challenges posed by aspect-based sentiment
classification (ABSC) within pretrained language models (PLMs), with a
particular focus on contextualization and hallucination issues. In order to
tackle these challenges, we introduce CARBD-Ko (a Contextually Annotated Review
Benchmark Dataset for Aspect-Based Sentiment Classification in Korean), a
benchmark dataset that incorporates aspects and dual-tagged polarities to
distinguish between aspect-specific and aspect-agnostic sentiment
classification. The dataset consists of sentences annotated with specific
aspects, aspect polarity, aspect-agnostic polarity, and the intensity of
aspects. To address the issue of dual-tagged aspect polarities, we propose a
novel approach employing a Siamese Network. Our experimental findings highlight
the inherent difficulties in accurately predicting dual-polarities and
underscore the significance of contextualized sentiment analysis models. The
CARBD-Ko dataset serves as a valuable resource for future research endeavors in
aspect-level sentiment classification.
|
[
-0.7771003842353821,
-0.4549475312232971,
0.38965779542922974,
0.4748152196407318,
-0.8381137847900391,
0.19497895240783691,
-0.21202510595321655,
-0.1523990035057068,
0.28310641646385193,
0.7447112202644348,
-0.4421998858451843,
-1.009956955909729,
-0.23180612921714783,
-0.07655174285173416,
0.2046825885772705,
1.140631079673767,
-0.3173471689224243,
0.42123472690582275,
-0.3818923830986023,
-0.45073384046554565,
-0.6579620242118835,
-1.0833261013031006,
-0.26192936301231384,
-0.2636274993419647,
0.5882357358932495,
0.4041595160961151,
0.45898255705833435,
0.22697271406650543,
0.4756619930267334,
0.13543163239955902,
-0.11446898430585861,
-0.17007705569267273,
0.14472965896129608,
0.6192859411239624,
-0.28915226459503174,
-0.3040964603424072,
-0.6580683588981628,
0.2261921465396881,
0.22348657250404358,
1.0629119873046875,
0.02222229167819023,
-0.09493099898099899,
0.1250758171081543,
0.7921593189239502,
-0.45281514525413513,
0.39210715889930725,
-0.36814355850219727,
-0.006770705338567495,
-0.033408742398023605,
0.1822812706232071,
-0.15675394237041473,
-0.1752982884645462,
0.0361064188182354,
-0.19292615354061127,
0.24573621153831482,
-0.041892532259225845,
0.9017285704612732,
0.27164044976234436,
-0.6160628199577332,
-0.5195922255516052,
-0.5197597742080688,
0.6223676800727844,
-0.5424632430076599,
0.5027597546577454,
0.30557212233543396,
0.0853467732667923,
0.1168603003025055,
-0.1390973925590515,
-0.5784378051757812,
-0.13521458208560944,
-0.08424162119626999,
0.28259676694869995,
0.6468856930732727,
0.31661731004714966,
0.08066065609455109,
0.649052619934082,
-0.41561707854270935,
-0.09015895426273346,
0.06738170981407166,
-0.21236036717891693,
0.6610295176506042,
0.01356139313429594,
0.1502547413110733,
-0.9554418325424194,
-0.31860920786857605,
-0.4465627074241638,
-0.7406479120254517,
0.25122401118278503,
0.43605318665504456,
0.42395538091659546,
-0.04355646297335625,
0.5146757364273071,
-0.5399245619773865,
0.38236886262893677,
-0.12379559129476547,
0.06709720939397812,
0.6440346837043762,
-0.5537459850311279,
-0.0866011530160904,
0.2516610622406006,
0.6474688649177551,
0.5541799068450928,
-0.15913309156894684,
-0.1788996458053589,
-0.3180972933769226,
0.34287798404693604,
0.3095199465751648,
-0.6655292510986328,
-0.29641231894493103,
0.5451379418373108,
-0.44605591893196106,
-0.2806541919708252,
0.34625592827796936,
-0.9678726196289062,
-0.4532092213630676,
-0.6992743611335754,
0.1966109275817871,
-0.04492998123168945,
-0.4956182837486267,
-0.07672471553087234,
0.13798603415489197,
0.27688905596733093,
0.11837296187877655,
-0.20867329835891724,
-0.1635534018278122,
0.7800279259681702,
0.7721259593963623,
-0.036638081073760986,
-0.16428382694721222,
0.1442652940750122,
-0.42548954486846924,
-0.43895047903060913,
0.8431161046028137,
-0.493605375289917,
-0.41675159335136414,
-0.10343877971172333,
0.18346145749092102,
-0.05503097549080849,
-0.6748447418212891,
0.7045146822929382,
-0.3873966634273529,
-0.03357912227511406,
-0.5464174151420593,
-0.3209824562072754,
-0.6096476316452026,
0.3182064890861511,
-0.4382381737232208,
0.9140383005142212,
0.2883096933364868,
-0.8107312917709351,
0.6087116003036499,
-0.3196825683116913,
-0.729059100151062,
-0.00316803902387619,
-0.25842908024787903,
-0.4769747257232666,
0.5942091941833496,
0.12891428172588348,
0.7471119165420532,
0.14475694298744202,
0.6116740703582764,
-0.5165883302688599,
0.33450740575790405,
0.29135018587112427,
-0.12744833528995514,
0.4043723940849304,
0.33480700850486755,
-0.30644872784614563,
0.14841046929359436,
-0.8446572422981262,
-0.0260701235383749,
-0.20266729593276978,
0.025349481031298637,
-0.8665112853050232,
0.02505391649901867,
0.06258559972047806,
0.6574749946594238,
0.207563117146492,
-0.5519477128982544,
0.2685239613056183,
-0.33402201533317566,
0.1554744690656662,
0.588422417640686,
0.04838327318429947,
0.3176608979701996,
0.024473924189805984,
0.516902506351471,
0.6279184818267822,
0.070935919880867,
-0.30577436089515686,
-0.05594596266746521,
-0.8321994543075562,
-0.16196589171886444,
0.2880339026451111,
0.46201834082603455,
-1.1428797245025635,
0.9983150959014893,
-0.1599728912115097,
-0.6060602068901062,
-0.6974964737892151,
0.16427406668663025,
0.5834411978721619,
0.5655306577682495,
0.30403462052345276,
-0.6479030847549438,
-0.317043274641037,
-1.069200873374939,
0.007190714590251446,
-0.29048505425453186,
0.18825004994869232,
0.6241391897201538,
0.36263713240623474,
-0.1792929470539093,
0.7878065705299377,
-0.23440776765346527,
-0.44275525212287903,
-0.4267348349094391,
0.5840684771537781,
0.07216866314411163,
0.4026184678077698,
0.1698499470949173,
-0.8129281997680664,
-0.5101685523986816,
0.12524111568927765,
-0.8707613945007324,
-0.4923594892024994,
-0.09451031684875488,
-0.08553577214479446,
0.20706923305988312,
0.4860036075115204,
-0.4126516282558441,
0.24710021913051605,
0.44242018461227417,
-0.5157498121261597,
0.543452262878418,
0.33192187547683716,
0.2598559260368347,
-1.250287652015686,
-0.11426251381635666,
-0.13386869430541992,
-0.14973686635494232,
-0.5320975184440613,
-0.11327043175697327,
0.06624221801757812,
0.02802727371454239,
-0.24463126063346863,
0.39225485920906067,
-0.24985598027706146,
-0.3291113078594208,
-0.6135305166244507,
0.007426144555211067,
0.22575333714485168,
0.4983050525188446,
0.41094332933425903,
0.49714210629463196,
0.6865305304527283,
-0.4748491942882538,
0.33295100927352905,
0.030297409743070602,
-0.3456454873085022,
0.882509708404541,
-0.2857929468154907,
0.10128055512905121,
-0.3331232964992523,
0.25183600187301636,
-0.8899762034416199,
-0.5005993843078613,
0.254060298204422,
-0.25488412380218506,
0.5289219617843628,
-0.13559462130069733,
-0.43240636587142944,
-0.33597472310066223,
-0.40048736333847046,
0.6511031985282898,
0.18394064903259277,
-0.5710307359695435,
0.5940119624137878,
0.3874902129173279,
-0.46548447012901306,
-0.3059439957141876,
-0.20435018837451935,
-0.12089122831821442,
-0.33428579568862915,
-0.24060437083244324,
0.19939833879470825,
0.17149776220321655,
-0.08381001651287079,
0.006870157551020384,
-0.21115602552890778,
0.18754377961158752,
0.05762482434511185,
0.521141529083252,
0.11357832700014114,
-0.10895667225122452,
0.08275610208511353,
0.46911153197288513,
-0.0650361105799675,
0.18840369582176208,
0.07626396417617798,
0.8264076709747314,
-0.37939342856407166,
-0.2512657046318054,
-0.3813716471195221,
0.13836877048015594,
0.4736779034137726,
0.17092034220695496,
0.44791412353515625,
0.48559585213661194,
-0.14157162606716156,
-0.16178034245967865,
-0.5196007490158081,
-0.07352694123983383,
-0.3745083212852478,
0.5963752865791321,
-0.5586197376251221,
-0.7833641767501831,
0.6607018709182739,
-0.05844931676983833,
-0.3389752209186554,
0.2722736895084381,
0.39450228214263916,
-0.22677303850650787,
1.1435822248458862,
0.21181821823120117,
-0.23821978271007538,
0.25993406772613525,
-0.04329679161310196,
0.2617831528186798,
-1.3418071269989014,
-0.293971985578537,
-0.256859689950943,
-0.16365520656108856,
-0.5676863193511963,
-0.17716795206069946,
0.23979274928569794,
0.8255165219306946,
-0.11137252300977707,
0.31895408034324646,
-0.489764928817749,
0.17013250291347504,
0.18442416191101074,
-0.10894227027893066,
0.059194426983594894,
-0.15781129896640778,
-0.13437716662883759,
-0.11283662170171738,
-0.40652284026145935,
-0.5216338038444519,
1.0885050296783447,
0.39833834767341614,
0.5359057784080505,
-0.23447243869304657,
0.5944720506668091,
0.18929104506969452,
0.6697376370429993,
-0.8518717288970947,
0.5745194554328918,
-0.19730228185653687,
-0.4404836893081665,
0.11912184953689575,
-0.5334891080856323,
-0.46897050738334656,
0.42333266139030457,
0.2763851284980774,
-0.6202729940414429,
0.4283599257469177,
0.055970896035432816,
-0.14123685657978058,
0.05657699331641197,
-0.5258711576461792,
1.0613510608673096,
-0.4791112542152405,
-0.16269302368164062,
0.04107405245304108,
-0.5418036580085754,
0.3025519549846649,
-0.14160370826721191,
0.4173380732536316,
-0.37004756927490234,
0.139979749917984,
0.7220206260681152,
-0.41470521688461304,
0.7777908444404602,
-0.55892014503479,
-0.024074392393231392,
0.3145132064819336,
0.058145955204963684,
0.07709978520870209,
0.5310530066490173,
0.24983760714530945,
0.5408859848976135,
-0.13442671298980713,
-0.31304773688316345,
-0.450052946805954,
0.7365775108337402,
-0.7463963031768799,
-0.4637877643108368,
-0.570147693157196,
-0.348770409822464,
-0.4173195958137512,
0.07579642534255981,
0.3285618722438812,
0.35973459482192993,
0.12505745887756348,
0.18266206979751587,
0.3448494076728821,
-0.3731388449668884,
0.3647316098213196,
0.33229103684425354,
-0.603585422039032,
-0.8646889328956604,
1.1841713190078735,
0.04775020480155945,
0.1708563268184662,
0.026173602789640427,
-0.08511161804199219,
-0.4877910017967224,
-0.485192209482193,
-0.4717941880226135,
0.3153912425041199,
-0.8416555523872375,
-0.37936124205589294,
-0.566594123840332,
-0.3501208424568176,
-0.41381528973579407,
-0.1153888925909996,
-0.9970612525939941,
-0.09590498358011246,
-0.17119604349136353,
-0.15304693579673767,
-0.05678660795092583,
0.7577767968177795,
-0.01144753023982048,
0.41036534309387207,
-0.2766970694065094,
0.17893262207508087,
0.022834818810224533,
0.5857131481170654,
-0.14688824117183685,
-0.28145936131477356,
-0.019144561141729355,
-0.0028638378717005253,
-0.3086708188056946,
-0.8285300731658936,
0.3347725570201874,
-0.17463436722755432,
0.2741462290287018,
0.5628399848937988,
0.35095614194869995,
0.3688609004020691,
0.01938408426940441,
0.8010998368263245,
0.12984368205070496,
-0.9035888314247131,
0.535006046295166,
-0.13510529696941376,
0.20968370139598846,
0.9623984098434448,
0.5252779722213745,
-0.679195761680603,
-0.4198146164417267,
-0.30161216855049133,
-1.0745784044265747,
0.7183414101600647,
0.021603388711810112,
0.11596738547086716,
-0.0196808110922575,
0.548052966594696,
0.49195584654808044,
0.7525238394737244,
-0.9786297678947449,
-0.28406572341918945,
-0.8193359971046448,
-0.3414759039878845,
-0.12906727194786072,
-0.38927391171455383,
0.3039524257183075,
-0.40389931201934814,
0.6983640789985657,
-0.10259074717760086,
-0.008974961005151272,
0.4612163305282593,
-0.13732819259166718,
0.19541113078594208,
0.46754190325737,
0.2844078838825226,
0.3576849400997162,
-0.4001274108886719,
0.23623155057430267,
-0.2773873507976532,
-0.47093406319618225,
0.22610598802566528,
0.0883529856801033,
-0.23431113362312317,
-0.08220991492271423,
0.17752568423748016,
1.0487878322601318,
-0.05331718549132347,
-0.457716703414917,
0.49988657236099243,
0.09359006583690643,
-0.0057665822096168995,
-0.23163245618343353,
-0.256516695022583,
-0.17398709058761597,
0.041998498141765594,
0.12505409121513367,
-0.16158489882946014,
-0.021366778761148453,
-0.4855668544769287,
0.016766147688031197,
0.4833960235118866,
-0.7903172969818115,
-0.7222747802734375,
0.38357338309288025,
0.21506810188293457,
-0.006737087853252888,
0.4322352707386017,
-0.8862023949623108,
-1.0882978439331055,
0.45089271664619446,
0.043538592755794525,
1.1991723775863647,
-0.37603890895843506,
0.4173342287540436,
0.3434777855873108,
0.06801821291446686,
-0.0632280483841896,
0.45291438698768616,
-0.13752871751785278,
-0.84480881690979,
-0.22892823815345764,
-1.1306440830230713,
-0.24732661247253418,
0.4515061676502228,
-1.008357048034668,
0.22756429016590118,
-0.4237127900123596,
-0.24564874172210693,
-0.1619107723236084,
-0.0827794298529625,
-0.4382860064506531,
0.2583557963371277,
0.12221615016460419,
0.17049777507781982,
-1.0296742916107178,
0.8527815341949463,
1.017533779144287,
-0.4157189130783081,
-0.4198543429374695,
0.12367046624422073,
-0.4028668999671936,
-0.02878938801586628,
0.5628827810287476,
0.6747462153434753,
0.15872493386268616,
-0.22849036753177643,
-0.2802218794822693,
-0.42997732758522034,
0.8523806929588318,
-0.5442227125167847,
-0.4625236988067627,
0.4649291932582855,
0.4130294620990753,
0.7451165914535522,
-0.8351858258247375,
0.007367174606770277,
0.5233416557312012,
0.24410155415534973,
-0.05670875310897827,
-0.780605137348175,
-0.07741940021514893,
-0.25430434942245483,
0.21296274662017822,
0.008635478094220161,
-0.8191187977790833,
1.023653507232666,
0.4452076852321625,
-0.21891140937805176,
-0.22709020972251892,
0.7039443850517273,
0.14168362319469452,
0.7128912806510925,
0.748587965965271,
0.6178888082504272,
0.18673570454120636,
-0.21939617395401,
0.6540826559066772,
-0.4371207654476166,
0.46042999625205994,
1.1455422639846802,
-0.7372820377349854,
0.8323143124580383,
0.4329093396663666,
-0.10150079429149628,
0.708682119846344,
0.8812262415885925,
0.1881629377603531,
0.8472394943237305,
0.02560756541788578,
-0.23221927881240845,
-0.35030409693717957,
-0.30426129698753357,
-0.36414051055908203,
0.3723526895046234,
0.4496068060398102,
-0.16652360558509827,
-0.2254536747932434,
0.5987780094146729,
0.09541350603103638,
0.07757497578859329,
-0.5000319480895996,
0.9650827646255493,
0.2299712747335434,
-0.8427852392196655,
0.07089268416166306,
-0.043190643191337585,
0.6435734629631042,
-0.1759195774793625,
0.2967241704463959,
-0.4639785587787628,
0.16173571348190308,
-0.14415164291858673,
-0.8459063768386841,
0.40409091114997864,
-0.16534285247325897,
-0.2893116772174835,
-0.09443729370832443,
0.6796176433563232,
-0.5631498098373413,
-0.5246678590774536,
0.5112239122390747,
0.27428629994392395,
0.09049131721258163,
-0.5040422677993774,
-0.693254292011261,
0.21569640934467316,
0.030609695240855217,
-0.4464505910873413,
0.5072677135467529,
0.41715335845947266,
-0.12280604243278503,
0.3598306179046631,
0.2185361087322235,
0.09135328233242035,
-0.17026320099830627,
0.2859828472137451,
0.9636332392692566,
-0.9131981730461121,
-0.6510772109031677,
-0.615985095500946,
0.26575303077697754,
-0.04141881689429283,
-0.38850507140159607,
0.6507809162139893,
0.6709688901901245,
1.2636867761611938,
-0.022222692146897316,
0.9868057370185852,
-0.08082067966461182,
0.7044141888618469,
-0.5425751209259033,
0.657037615776062,
-0.618836522102356,
0.48801156878471375,
-0.2195228934288025,
-1.1613339185714722,
-0.1253766119480133,
0.6197831630706787,
-0.44995853304862976,
0.3678145706653595,
0.79714035987854,
0.6330878138542175,
-0.08121338486671448,
0.23914866149425507,
0.06417060643434525,
0.386654257774353,
0.2404502034187317,
0.23170310258865356,
0.896497905254364,
-0.3381930887699127,
0.07645943015813828,
-1.028603434562683,
-0.11293061822652817,
-0.21437451243400574,
-0.8006690144538879,
-1.2069945335388184,
-0.7574343681335449,
-0.6523116230964661,
-0.5006387829780579,
-0.21906931698322296,
0.8718374371528625,
0.4501837193965912,
-1.2047806978225708,
-0.20236137509346008,
-0.2750348150730133,
0.18328213691711426,
0.0006506042554974556,
-0.3546307384967804,
0.5456346869468689,
-0.6870943307876587,
-0.46103206276893616,
-0.020250340923666954,
0.4582207500934601,
0.05743812024593353,
-0.5701581239700317,
0.03675905987620354,
0.15439239144325256,
-0.21686191856861115,
0.5756345987319946,
0.05119424685835838,
-0.8288276791572571,
-0.26435357332229614,
-0.1898321956396103,
-0.08275161683559418,
0.1358238309621811,
0.9499208927154541,
-0.45752984285354614,
0.7020604610443115,
0.2584725618362427,
0.3474147915840149,
0.047081418335437775,
0.49750518798828125,
0.29386070370674133,
-0.92532879114151,
0.24233148992061615,
0.26025673747062683,
0.0953146368265152,
0.6137667298316956,
-0.06201455742120743,
0.27211475372314453,
0.5144132971763611,
-0.5070228576660156,
-0.9496504664421082,
0.2670585811138153,
-1.1745272874832153,
-0.4622858762741089,
1.3635209798812866,
-0.2635164260864258,
-0.35437196493148804,
-0.5477431416511536,
-0.18902470171451569,
0.10782837122678757,
-0.20242774486541748,
0.8681759238243103,
1.1825814247131348,
-0.26288118958473206,
0.11156807094812393,
-0.49754929542541504,
0.6630509495735168,
0.533661425113678,
-0.8584906458854675,
0.39700770378112793,
0.46468257904052734,
0.06719392538070679,
0.27708181738853455,
0.35042116045951843,
-0.10634603351354599,
-0.10348149389028549,
-0.08395276963710785,
0.3860265910625458,
0.09731946885585785,
-0.6587693691253662,
-0.48176127672195435,
0.20223061740398407,
-0.04299052432179451,
-0.04128982499241829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15043v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15043v2
|
KIEval: A Knowledge-grounded Interactive Evaluation Framework for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T01:30:39 | 2024-06-03T06:02:39 |
Zhuohao Yu, Chang Gao, Wenjin Yao, Yidong Wang, Wei Ye, Jindong Wang, Xing Xie, Yue Zhang, Shikun Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Automatic evaluation methods for large language models (LLMs) are hindered by
data contamination, leading to inflated assessments of their effectiveness.
Existing strategies, which aim to detect contaminated texts, focus on
quantifying contamination status instead of accurately gauging model
performance. In this paper, we introduce KIEval, a Knowledge-grounded
Interactive Evaluation framework, which incorporates an LLM-powered
"interactor" role for the first time to accomplish a dynamic
contamination-resilient evaluation. Starting with a question in a conventional
LLM benchmark involving domain-specific knowledge, KIEval utilizes dynamically
generated, multi-round, and knowledge-focused dialogues to determine whether a
model's response is merely a recall of benchmark answers or demonstrates a deep
comprehension to apply knowledge in more complex conversations. Extensive
experiments on seven leading LLMs across five datasets validate KIEval's
effectiveness and generalization. We also reveal that data contamination brings
no contribution or even negative effect to models' real-world applicability and
understanding, and existing contamination detection methods for LLMs can only
identify contamination in pre-training but not during supervised fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.09061245620250702,
-0.709378719329834,
0.9450374245643616,
0.09450466930866241,
-0.29918405413627625,
0.4569893777370453,
-0.3361823558807373,
-0.47430792450904846,
-0.024748846888542175,
0.5392138957977295,
-0.18330316245555878,
-0.6027019619941711,
-0.6550660729408264,
-0.21149376034736633,
-0.7491148114204407,
0.6628433465957642,
-0.03605329617857933,
-0.12978877127170563,
-0.5844293832778931,
0.14052855968475342,
-0.18286745250225067,
-0.4339357614517212,
-0.3090193271636963,
-0.2529944181442261,
0.19332122802734375,
0.490344375371933,
0.7141945958137512,
0.6794144511222839,
0.43262746930122375,
0.4756486713886261,
-0.2728649377822876,
0.22661972045898438,
-0.5205517411231995,
0.39513495564460754,
-0.3165210485458374,
-0.6235626935958862,
-0.09011204540729523,
-0.2258298099040985,
0.51021808385849,
0.5459292531013489,
-0.22595413029193878,
0.10438112914562225,
-0.15146386623382568,
0.48368769884109497,
-0.7060075998306274,
0.1761847287416458,
-0.7585556507110596,
0.10321977734565735,
0.15756972134113312,
-0.22450268268585205,
-0.43725109100341797,
-0.2853103578090668,
0.2589753568172455,
-0.8613896369934082,
-0.43454715609550476,
-0.005293041933327913,
0.6482098698616028,
0.33561185002326965,
-0.6256879568099976,
-0.3919963538646698,
-0.9369356036186218,
0.9286952614784241,
-0.6756750345230103,
0.37292543053627014,
0.507055401802063,
0.5597200393676758,
-0.2186567187309265,
-0.928740918636322,
-0.519018828868866,
-0.5309275388717651,
-0.03662816807627678,
0.2651192247867584,
-0.05918039381504059,
-0.0251194778829813,
-0.009254375472664833,
0.15967319905757904,
0.058902207762002945,
-0.09540898352861404,
-0.2677624523639679,
-0.17609640955924988,
0.33678123354911804,
0.17273029685020447,
0.43414780497550964,
-0.34593847393989563,
-0.49244576692581177,
0.05895308032631874,
-0.5209594964981079,
0.0966632217168808,
0.44995686411857605,
-0.0011637298157438636,
-0.11300770938396454,
0.4058361053466797,
-0.1255834698677063,
0.6034038662910461,
0.31524476408958435,
-0.2041163295507431,
-0.013522380962967873,
-0.5275946259498596,
-0.2694268822669983,
-0.10747399926185608,
0.7808400392532349,
0.20163558423519135,
0.19951756298542023,
-0.2840188145637512,
-0.07676395028829575,
-0.23429645597934723,
0.5011923909187317,
-0.9402273297309875,
-0.36798015236854553,
0.3521135151386261,
-0.10312892496585846,
-0.9745146036148071,
-0.028567902743816376,
-0.8834124803543091,
-0.68928062915802,
-0.261974573135376,
0.6257838010787964,
-0.15413223206996918,
-0.31525030732154846,
0.154270201921463,
0.2723637521266937,
-0.26991453766822815,
0.4727623760700226,
-0.8672353029251099,
0.20314335823059082,
0.7897936105728149,
0.48220106959342957,
-0.11665660887956619,
-0.07891033589839935,
-0.9699164032936096,
-0.11898559331893921,
-0.3030436038970947,
0.6195955872535706,
-0.7767483592033386,
-0.19712959229946136,
0.10031826794147491,
-0.12250237911939621,
0.13754534721374512,
-0.8429619669914246,
0.5715252757072449,
-0.6731281876564026,
-0.11873643845319748,
-0.2961542010307312,
-0.4657912254333496,
-0.06867437809705734,
0.4030601680278778,
-0.6063114404678345,
1.05417799949646,
0.10586480796337128,
-0.9900848269462585,
0.7195118069648743,
-0.1719355285167694,
-0.1513851284980774,
0.17078393697738647,
-0.24512208998203278,
-0.2035510092973709,
-0.16369546949863434,
-0.05894045531749725,
0.27457836270332336,
-0.036444734781980515,
0.7470332384109497,
-0.3712497353553772,
-0.2524307370185852,
0.37909430265426636,
-0.4163666069507599,
0.2307298481464386,
-0.10743679106235504,
-0.4164291322231293,
0.5246777534484863,
-1.1856530904769897,
0.18361803889274597,
-0.2426212877035141,
-0.6663902401924133,
-0.397510826587677,
0.20974454283714294,
0.06850209832191467,
0.5215970873832703,
0.11521077901124954,
-0.5256552696228027,
0.05774357169866562,
-0.5083730220794678,
0.24520280957221985,
0.6507891416549683,
0.0707683339715004,
0.33088573813438416,
-0.4186834692955017,
0.672049880027771,
0.14829623699188232,
0.22816102206707,
-0.09817004948854446,
0.019863851368427277,
-1.1190185546875,
-0.3681439459323883,
0.2867703437805176,
0.4129611849784851,
-1.0332003831863403,
0.6380786895751953,
-0.5300291180610657,
-0.9312470555305481,
-0.36609914898872375,
0.0865691676735878,
0.24703571200370789,
0.5021860003471375,
0.13167616724967957,
0.10915400832891464,
-0.45541632175445557,
-0.7450588941574097,
-0.3157249093055725,
-0.2644624710083008,
0.05815339833498001,
0.542026162147522,
0.5072547793388367,
-0.05727853998541832,
0.9846334457397461,
-0.04158495366573334,
0.1200324073433876,
-0.06950455904006958,
0.05129651352763176,
-0.06006697565317154,
0.37831419706344604,
0.2900168001651764,
-0.6274176239967346,
-0.5607097744941711,
0.14414960145950317,
-0.8497819900512695,
-0.3164471983909607,
-0.011934524402022362,
-0.23022928833961487,
-0.18610551953315735,
0.6555647850036621,
-0.4211684763431549,
0.19508403539657593,
0.6553617119789124,
-0.3557240962982178,
0.697232186794281,
-0.2174074798822403,
0.37879711389541626,
-1.014573097229004,
0.26882675290107727,
-0.4738374948501587,
-0.5187376737594604,
-0.7981703877449036,
0.06535910815000534,
0.06253818422555923,
0.03405328467488289,
-0.5831092596054077,
0.553031861782074,
-0.21847400069236755,
0.036742620170116425,
-0.16054949164390564,
0.5992119312286377,
0.22816871106624603,
-0.10177212953567505,
-0.04104839265346527,
0.7560558915138245,
0.370413601398468,
-0.40211009979248047,
0.3899691104888916,
0.31351009011268616,
-0.8261281847953796,
0.4028351306915283,
-0.5931475162506104,
0.15693937242031097,
0.27459317445755005,
-0.051327358931303024,
-0.9761074185371399,
-0.2586319148540497,
0.10076553374528885,
-0.18260939419269562,
0.1419653445482254,
-0.38100743293762207,
-0.6542550921440125,
0.1370052993297577,
-0.25261783599853516,
0.5130413770675659,
0.18668106198310852,
-0.8912671804428101,
0.7150927782058716,
0.22069719433784485,
-0.0202641524374485,
-0.6153726577758789,
-0.42584747076034546,
0.05586763843894005,
-0.47456416487693787,
-0.8608314990997314,
-0.0027680464554578066,
-0.22134189307689667,
-0.5779103636741638,
-0.1800939291715622,
-0.38123705983161926,
-0.08090732991695404,
0.5942771434783936,
0.3134898841381073,
-0.03657437115907669,
0.061899334192276,
0.35390591621398926,
0.0022041555494070053,
0.020116645842790604,
0.26186200976371765,
0.04386959597468376,
0.6085889339447021,
-0.093760184943676,
-0.6366108059883118,
-0.1706274449825287,
-0.18502402305603027,
1.0470037460327148,
-0.19992545247077942,
0.6435478329658508,
0.3646889925003052,
-0.37463995814323425,
-0.04607048258185387,
-0.513484001159668,
0.010012718848884106,
-0.55032879114151,
0.467589408159256,
-0.14353890717029572,
-0.6770228743553162,
0.6353321671485901,
-0.3716868758201599,
-0.17172099649906158,
0.08771185576915741,
0.3123929798603058,
0.24051907658576965,
0.6870855093002319,
0.6172450184822083,
0.07278060168027878,
0.235270693898201,
0.058664094656705856,
0.39145904779434204,
-0.6444651484489441,
-0.48127591609954834,
-0.3114762008190155,
0.04071264714002609,
-0.30049389600753784,
-0.35941722989082336,
0.4040040075778961,
0.35358932614326477,
0.021208608523011208,
-0.004755112808197737,
-0.16953380405902863,
0.39037713408470154,
0.12392647564411163,
-0.033487897366285324,
0.7043628692626953,
-0.3826351463794708,
-0.3937951624393463,
-0.08031181246042252,
-0.39584073424339294,
-0.7795926332473755,
0.8456722497940063,
0.32788947224617004,
0.7422001361846924,
0.08699565380811691,
0.5336013436317444,
0.19564183056354523,
0.5540415048599243,
-0.92522132396698,
0.47570109367370605,
0.3367384076118469,
-0.5306508541107178,
-0.29100656509399414,
-0.4064907729625702,
-0.7494374513626099,
0.48561015725135803,
-0.4858262836933136,
-0.7650520205497742,
-0.018937746062874794,
-0.0312943272292614,
-0.33177265524864197,
0.32102394104003906,
-0.44249796867370605,
0.5738224387168884,
-0.46553441882133484,
-0.6045138835906982,
-0.0651092454791069,
-0.3695787787437439,
0.6057801246643066,
-0.6659648418426514,
0.5700033903121948,
-0.0622333399951458,
-0.07019704580307007,
0.5161890983581543,
-0.5695318579673767,
0.6359503865242004,
-0.11107388138771057,
-0.311482697725296,
-0.12363513559103012,
0.41573566198349,
0.4121446907520294,
0.12788520753383636,
-0.1341676115989685,
-0.2819625735282898,
0.3449588119983673,
-0.022522179409861565,
-0.7340787649154663,
0.6426547765731812,
-0.5367770791053772,
-0.45262429118156433,
-0.3528132140636444,
-0.4000133275985718,
-0.41895243525505066,
0.3408516049385071,
0.05453234165906906,
0.27065378427505493,
-0.2517838776111603,
0.5534767508506775,
0.4526817202568054,
-0.4930018186569214,
0.23681512475013733,
0.8004962205886841,
-0.7338734269142151,
-0.42236343026161194,
0.5949459671974182,
-0.09456592053174973,
0.6188926696777344,
0.20819221436977386,
0.3991459608078003,
0.0784427598118782,
-0.47294625639915466,
-0.38623830676078796,
-0.12203466147184372,
-0.9005756378173828,
-0.14707224071025848,
-0.7705907821655273,
-0.08905152976512909,
0.18615278601646423,
-0.0711093544960022,
-0.5195052027702332,
-0.014819546602666378,
-0.22426816821098328,
-0.3422068655490875,
0.2718236446380615,
0.8697470426559448,
-0.0034307336900383234,
0.15477874875068665,
-0.8234091401100159,
0.0048288218677043915,
0.249996155500412,
0.35971105098724365,
0.09562893956899643,
-0.5149940252304077,
-0.25886616110801697,
0.05517706647515297,
-0.04405099153518677,
-0.7267100214958191,
0.47979387640953064,
0.0029495873022824526,
0.5640516877174377,
0.4909682869911194,
0.19621267914772034,
0.4009433388710022,
-0.271819531917572,
0.6481069326400757,
-0.13904470205307007,
-1.188968300819397,
0.3641347885131836,
-0.5769160389900208,
0.16861656308174133,
0.7935704588890076,
0.2200295776128769,
-0.5502505302429199,
-0.5378034710884094,
-0.5067333579063416,
-1.0955990552902222,
0.4811427891254425,
0.18528681993484497,
0.07430507987737656,
0.029132287949323654,
0.2737760543823242,
0.056156426668167114,
0.47520336508750916,
-0.6173540353775024,
-0.008648148737847805,
0.021599210798740387,
-0.2721996009349823,
0.24312297999858856,
-0.5118599534034729,
-0.1227620467543602,
-0.20522642135620117,
0.768426775932312,
0.1042950451374054,
-0.28538942337036133,
0.1053427904844284,
-0.4545777440071106,
-0.116937555372715,
0.42941027879714966,
0.5467449426651001,
0.8423383235931396,
-0.23765330016613007,
0.24283871054649353,
0.11869757622480392,
-0.5838823318481445,
0.2978478670120239,
0.09092102944850922,
-0.17356038093566895,
-0.2834247052669525,
0.41707557439804077,
0.48296433687210083,
0.7664472460746765,
-1.0777311325073242,
0.714201033115387,
-0.22503390908241272,
0.01873522624373436,
-0.4103805124759674,
0.054078876972198486,
0.36638954281806946,
0.2537974715232849,
0.33572712540626526,
-0.12403586506843567,
0.03239958733320236,
-0.5464661717414856,
0.5501773357391357,
0.12418954819440842,
-0.5367341637611389,
-0.24260841310024261,
0.46259984374046326,
0.30245882272720337,
-0.1135001927614212,
0.26192259788513184,
-0.10589490085840225,
-0.6917789578437805,
0.5662456154823303,
0.25159046053886414,
0.4147578179836273,
-0.17826612293720245,
0.12178681790828705,
0.07573815435171127,
0.30956897139549255,
0.2932699918746948,
0.1789611577987671,
0.04155891388654709,
-0.7610819339752197,
-0.41133204102516174,
-0.699630856513977,
-0.4628399908542633,
0.670195460319519,
-0.778764009475708,
0.18877924978733063,
-0.5281851887702942,
0.12516061961650848,
0.08187723904848099,
0.05784885957837105,
-0.3991630971431732,
0.12215802073478699,
-0.3426225781440735,
1.016309142112732,
-1.0158761739730835,
0.5368708372116089,
0.45289093255996704,
-0.20083343982696533,
-0.6889716386795044,
0.21889425814151764,
-0.08993629366159439,
-0.5009667873382568,
0.7457478046417236,
0.24476337432861328,
-0.30060967803001404,
-0.0183796938508749,
-0.3781021535396576,
-0.9654788374900818,
1.0083502531051636,
0.5165979862213135,
-0.3859800100326538,
0.5509665608406067,
0.011930720880627632,
0.7051746249198914,
-0.04960314556956291,
0.38454365730285645,
0.7073336839675903,
0.7383405566215515,
-0.06574753671884537,
-1.065632700920105,
0.07686670124530792,
-0.4726707935333252,
-0.5445579290390015,
0.1034523993730545,
-0.5818997621536255,
0.2546966075897217,
0.07388970255851746,
-0.17918060719966888,
0.388253778219223,
0.33760133385658264,
0.16686499118804932,
0.08360029757022858,
0.6691533327102661,
0.37420588731765747,
0.9328727126121521,
-0.13300484418869019,
0.8438159823417664,
-0.455313116312027,
0.3234610855579376,
1.1835641860961914,
-0.49040699005126953,
0.8956679701805115,
0.37459033727645874,
0.0004749787913169712,
0.3461741507053375,
0.3354170620441437,
-0.027078134939074516,
0.5318406820297241,
0.5898165702819824,
-0.6423197984695435,
-0.428554505109787,
-0.3210941255092621,
0.031976014375686646,
0.8360782861709595,
0.19492444396018982,
-0.2835846543312073,
-0.25283804535865784,
0.15852822363376617,
0.24582090973854065,
0.35677748918533325,
0.08498205989599228,
0.8763854503631592,
-0.19553571939468384,
-0.6608495712280273,
0.5664865970611572,
-0.01400979794561863,
0.5001791715621948,
-0.43741047382354736,
-0.03748230263590813,
-0.08202040940523148,
0.08971095830202103,
-0.3429313898086548,
-0.6701917052268982,
0.27128785848617554,
-0.04265148192644119,
-0.07201818376779556,
0.102770134806633,
1.0362521409988403,
-0.6883258819580078,
-0.2894725501537323,
0.604280948638916,
0.566872775554657,
0.1688685119152069,
-0.09541275352239609,
-0.11547132581472397,
0.22402147948741913,
-0.1462578922510147,
-0.2823070287704468,
0.3312598466873169,
0.34156912565231323,
0.12584418058395386,
1.0548490285873413,
0.6910927891731262,
0.004131445661187172,
-0.0838734582066536,
0.16401307284832,
0.9583759307861328,
-0.2202543467283249,
-0.18909674882888794,
-0.693210780620575,
0.7303469777107239,
-0.08128557354211807,
0.1102081760764122,
0.5657487511634827,
0.5968316793441772,
0.3907909095287323,
0.11594278365373611,
0.9731329679489136,
0.29726526141166687,
0.27307820320129395,
-0.5750218033790588,
1.094174861907959,
-0.3169632852077484,
0.4534029960632324,
-0.17697565257549286,
-0.5609843134880066,
-0.020979784429073334,
0.5911844968795776,
-0.3624030649662018,
0.20483170449733734,
0.6929691433906555,
0.42968276143074036,
-0.3484630584716797,
-0.12843483686447144,
0.6375109553337097,
0.5148534774780273,
0.5832364559173584,
0.2007278949022293,
1.1114739179611206,
-0.12866157293319702,
0.6533169150352478,
-0.305317223072052,
-0.33861103653907776,
-0.1552043855190277,
-1.2748677730560303,
-0.9783348441123962,
-0.4957573115825653,
-0.01952183060348034,
-0.21603262424468994,
0.1013597846031189,
0.758574366569519,
0.6459078788757324,
-0.49996986985206604,
0.1341293305158615,
-0.1320011168718338,
-0.058966368436813354,
0.28800833225250244,
-0.2670068144798279,
0.30149027705192566,
-0.28194960951805115,
-0.6859938502311707,
0.7865101099014282,
0.2527797520160675,
-0.10642919689416885,
-0.4009562134742737,
0.4091295599937439,
-0.1295478641986847,
0.1748332381248474,
0.6118609309196472,
-0.1347927749156952,
-0.5462124943733215,
-0.6907562017440796,
-0.05271351337432861,
0.046969328075647354,
-0.06311242282390594,
0.3735196590423584,
-0.7862772941589355,
0.8643379807472229,
0.4361982047557831,
0.7137501239776611,
0.3369453251361847,
0.1508631706237793,
0.598505437374115,
-0.6688388586044312,
-0.1291138380765915,
0.15921638906002045,
0.37022238969802856,
0.5219413638114929,
-0.6411304473876953,
0.3330725431442261,
0.08756031095981598,
-0.591361403465271,
-0.83868408203125,
0.17733435332775116,
-0.9127645492553711,
0.12956508994102478,
1.4611824750900269,
-0.441821426153183,
0.15150032937526703,
-0.4220590591430664,
-0.13864852488040924,
0.12189296633005142,
-0.07703215628862381,
0.9914343357086182,
1.2024877071380615,
0.3987365663051605,
0.15690958499908447,
-0.7854939699172974,
0.5529107451438904,
0.3509361445903778,
-1.3378686904907227,
0.3510637879371643,
0.4306366741657257,
0.7294251322746277,
0.14585690200328827,
0.3017672002315521,
-0.2347012162208557,
0.03915059193968773,
-0.18586166203022003,
-0.09171577543020248,
-0.2977439761161804,
-0.45990708470344543,
-0.3831281065940857,
-0.15663157403469086,
0.29039719700813293,
0.19814644753932953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15021v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15021v2
|
CLoVe: Encoding Compositional Language in Contrastive Vision-Language Models
| 2024-02-22T23:42:25 | 2024-03-01T01:52:58 |
Santiago Castro, Amir Ziai, Avneesh Saluja, Zhuoning Yuan, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Recent years have witnessed a significant increase in the performance of
Vision and Language tasks. Foundational Vision-Language Models (VLMs), such as
CLIP, have been leveraged in multiple settings and demonstrated remarkable
performance across several tasks. Such models excel at object-centric
recognition yet learn text representations that seem invariant to word order,
failing to compose known concepts in novel ways. However, no evidence exists
that any VLM, including large-scale single-stream models such as GPT-4V,
identifies compositions successfully. In this paper, we introduce a framework
to significantly improve the ability of existing models to encode compositional
language, with over 10% absolute improvement on compositionality benchmarks,
while maintaining or improving the performance on standard object-recognition
and retrieval benchmarks. Our code and pre-trained models are publicly
available at https://github.com/netflix/clove.
|
[
0.09135580062866211,
-0.33808791637420654,
0.5690724849700928,
0.14202208817005157,
-0.3208097219467163,
-0.19268165528774261,
-0.25501835346221924,
-0.5589112043380737,
-0.039925526827573776,
0.7923887372016907,
-0.28848281502723694,
-0.7033730149269104,
-0.5694377422332764,
0.04801029711961746,
-0.6436811685562134,
0.5657422542572021,
-0.013008086942136288,
0.13969574868679047,
-0.3646935522556305,
-0.3650139570236206,
-0.5597013235092163,
-0.5239889025688171,
0.0036262136418372393,
-0.03923526406288147,
-0.12102730572223663,
0.1364453136920929,
0.3561232089996338,
0.9493167400360107,
0.6705437302589417,
0.32896605134010315,
-0.02871127612888813,
0.1259707659482956,
-0.6809459924697876,
0.0988696962594986,
-0.2921282649040222,
-0.501085102558136,
0.032260242849588394,
-0.11915817111730576,
0.6807193756103516,
0.3742460608482361,
-0.15315894782543182,
-0.015989119186997414,
0.04346705973148346,
0.7506164312362671,
-0.7821665406227112,
0.24064218997955322,
-0.9029361009597778,
-0.021481238305568695,
-0.1546461582183838,
0.06518058478832245,
-0.5011143088340759,
0.0005531251663342118,
0.5422419905662537,
-0.6954370141029358,
0.19237223267555237,
-0.20593120157718658,
0.9314556121826172,
0.18988573551177979,
-0.03287941589951515,
-0.19760051369667053,
-0.5528174638748169,
0.9016922116279602,
-0.6218236088752747,
0.4915509521961212,
0.05943448096513748,
0.21791300177574158,
0.5383325815200806,
-0.9715536236763,
-0.45039471983909607,
-0.08401457965373993,
-0.1422867327928543,
0.2597227990627289,
0.026073032990098,
0.01470979955047369,
0.038746729493141174,
0.6172176003456116,
-0.6812142133712769,
-0.23671266436576843,
-0.4350398778915405,
-0.2124672532081604,
0.3768647313117981,
0.3187214136123657,
0.15510769188404083,
0.08026225119829178,
-0.6038616895675659,
-0.20461641252040863,
-0.4919055998325348,
-0.08095405250787735,
-0.05858851969242096,
0.0166816134005785,
-0.1079370379447937,
0.34282243251800537,
-0.3679042160511017,
0.9282432794570923,
0.13082446157932281,
-0.09955675899982452,
0.44958409667015076,
-0.4490600526332855,
-0.3402007818222046,
-0.17007260024547577,
0.4384702444076538,
0.6480377316474915,
-0.003961795475333929,
0.1233019158244133,
-0.16860374808311462,
0.6520434617996216,
0.26523497700691223,
-1.0570785999298096,
-0.6785691976547241,
0.15801410377025604,
-0.28206807374954224,
-0.31026867032051086,
0.22294291853904724,
-0.6081627011299133,
-0.5578867197036743,
-0.4059789180755615,
0.5381191372871399,
-0.5976006984710693,
-0.20290274918079376,
0.5331017971038818,
-0.11194030940532684,
0.38529273867607117,
0.2947988510131836,
-0.8594610095024109,
0.16160514950752258,
0.5788158178329468,
0.8735697865486145,
-0.5000829100608826,
-0.38942068815231323,
-0.5651128888130188,
0.18138939142227173,
-0.12061255425214767,
0.618618905544281,
-0.7089438438415527,
-0.3890790641307831,
0.3005029857158661,
-0.16697651147842407,
-0.14609573781490326,
-0.8353015184402466,
0.3633129596710205,
-0.30881863832473755,
0.04043469950556755,
-0.1872200071811676,
-0.776856541633606,
-0.3012051284313202,
0.4756878912448883,
-0.740227222442627,
0.6736000776290894,
0.13827663660049438,
-0.7747540473937988,
0.20818772912025452,
-0.5793018341064453,
-0.43903592228889465,
0.14084787666797638,
-0.30256569385528564,
-0.39919212460517883,
0.10377509891986847,
0.4253353774547577,
0.3218325674533844,
-0.0961260125041008,
0.04112362489104271,
-0.16818107664585114,
-0.2957887649536133,
0.30890563130378723,
-0.2140323966741562,
0.4174017608165741,
0.2579807937145233,
-0.17796985805034637,
0.40904566645622253,
-0.6851549744606018,
-0.10405633598566055,
0.14189885556697845,
-0.14302147924900055,
-0.30492013692855835,
-0.09519630670547485,
0.057452116161584854,
-0.19232456386089325,
0.46836721897125244,
-0.3975178897380829,
-0.09982416033744812,
-0.4383055567741394,
0.4688963294029236,
0.6582087874412537,
-0.1493811458349228,
0.6951422691345215,
-0.09458232671022415,
0.311874657869339,
0.48162585496902466,
0.2526964247226715,
-0.5638036727905273,
-0.14496944844722748,
-0.8714357614517212,
-0.4017196595668793,
-0.018244897946715355,
0.5181632041931152,
-0.8861960768699646,
0.0275448989123106,
-0.2062751203775406,
-0.4726989269256592,
-0.5400749444961548,
0.395173043012619,
0.5031430721282959,
0.6008989810943604,
0.3203927278518677,
-0.5909643173217773,
-0.6351655721664429,
-0.843812882900238,
-0.10396906733512878,
0.037309303879737854,
0.12044548988342285,
0.28424471616744995,
0.37109774351119995,
-0.29890310764312744,
0.9561961889266968,
-0.920369565486908,
-0.47673720121383667,
-0.38064831495285034,
-0.011151417158544064,
0.26073676347732544,
0.4942788779735565,
0.6177806258201599,
-1.0647159814834595,
-0.7010855078697205,
0.14953675866127014,
-0.8090014457702637,
-0.14256802201271057,
0.3536679744720459,
-0.23253074288368225,
-0.018352407962083817,
0.4674263894557953,
-0.30346035957336426,
0.3258695900440216,
0.8175095915794373,
-0.16008442640304565,
0.7407903075218201,
-0.0041409386321902275,
-0.07018429040908813,
-0.8795918822288513,
0.1047629565000534,
-0.047624312341213226,
-0.32156166434288025,
-0.8646453022956848,
0.3637165427207947,
0.12301615625619888,
-0.27656805515289307,
-0.8700586557388306,
0.3397141396999359,
-0.5451561212539673,
0.07741691172122955,
-0.379962682723999,
0.07862083613872528,
0.3695499300956726,
0.44704151153564453,
0.49154743552207947,
0.8716158866882324,
0.8341819047927856,
-0.6592804789543152,
0.25317394733428955,
0.292339950799942,
-0.46816813945770264,
0.7826595902442932,
-0.7308035492897034,
-0.07632918655872345,
-0.045857179909944534,
0.028461027890443802,
-0.5500032305717468,
-0.36543673276901245,
0.08114704489707947,
0.025778934359550476,
0.2301526963710785,
-0.13903909921646118,
-0.14025546610355377,
-0.09878828376531601,
-0.3065049648284912,
0.5734462738037109,
0.6012518405914307,
-0.49178004264831543,
0.8210871815681458,
0.3828663229942322,
0.36396652460098267,
-0.44162479043006897,
-0.7094169855117798,
-0.37242811918258667,
-0.21378593146800995,
-0.5593329071998596,
0.4410474896430969,
-0.29795825481414795,
0.01698162965476513,
0.0038946359418332577,
-0.11954852193593979,
-0.23968034982681274,
-0.048108477145433426,
0.13466410338878632,
0.10319891571998596,
-0.3508357107639313,
-0.1274258941411972,
-0.429665744304657,
-0.0023679560981690884,
-0.22554729878902435,
-0.7965972423553467,
0.5178064107894897,
-0.5135148763656616,
-0.301876425743103,
-0.3132798969745636,
0.18170034885406494,
0.5949748754501343,
-0.7995883226394653,
0.5085253715515137,
0.8019934892654419,
-0.137689471244812,
-0.2945842444896698,
-0.501701295375824,
-0.1713067889213562,
-0.506742000579834,
0.4756156802177429,
-0.23535504937171936,
-1.0567013025283813,
0.4912811517715454,
0.0356433168053627,
-0.2154865264892578,
0.18616123497486115,
0.35667136311531067,
0.07451567053794861,
0.5097031593322754,
0.7020924091339111,
-0.05481903254985809,
0.8514003753662109,
-0.4429398477077484,
-0.17947439849376678,
-0.8691380023956299,
0.11564674228429794,
-0.05963028967380524,
-0.021902112290263176,
-0.13740596175193787,
-0.6653032898902893,
0.4662620425224304,
-0.13750605285167694,
-0.0008755839080549777,
0.4906269311904907,
-0.6281992197036743,
0.8451927304267883,
0.43827298283576965,
0.3610279858112335,
0.35264113545417786,
-0.17736709117889404,
-0.08516476303339005,
-0.10742577910423279,
-0.5491242408752441,
-0.17067091166973114,
0.9442667961120605,
0.09186050295829773,
0.6954658627510071,
0.0814218521118164,
0.5905990600585938,
0.2536429464817047,
0.21792007982730865,
-0.3736134469509125,
0.5988879203796387,
-0.5661413073539734,
-0.5954742431640625,
-0.07496577501296997,
-0.1553013175725937,
-0.49302902817726135,
0.5566504597663879,
-0.03777308389544487,
-0.7101900577545166,
0.2569462060928345,
0.3343042731285095,
-0.15193969011306763,
0.11163467168807983,
-0.7774571776390076,
1.2747153043746948,
-0.42277809977531433,
-0.6758332848548889,
0.057261571288108826,
-0.6611995100975037,
0.4400465786457062,
0.07580989599227905,
-0.04646800085902214,
0.0711873322725296,
0.1607477366924286,
0.3019844591617584,
-0.4339531660079956,
1.1125813722610474,
-0.12727823853492737,
0.11330218613147736,
0.462319016456604,
0.2402670681476593,
0.435268372297287,
-0.10232604295015335,
0.0713941901922226,
0.08832993358373642,
0.01683289371430874,
-0.40985557436943054,
-0.48345568776130676,
0.5557501316070557,
-0.5404111742973328,
-0.510067880153656,
-0.29909273982048035,
-0.351462185382843,
0.11583045870065689,
0.3299437463283539,
0.3682665228843689,
0.6173705458641052,
-0.3119944632053375,
0.4064306914806366,
0.9089847803115845,
0.006773299537599087,
0.22768817842006683,
0.423710435628891,
-0.5791571736335754,
-0.5330248475074768,
1.0718189477920532,
-0.22282789647579193,
0.4923858344554901,
0.6083186268806458,
0.23982703685760498,
-0.2878458499908447,
-0.7917971014976501,
-0.4054737985134125,
0.17510943114757538,
-1.0354655981063843,
-0.1741674542427063,
-0.5092790722846985,
-0.1977280229330063,
-0.2232271134853363,
-0.31457585096359253,
-0.5290452837944031,
0.18908262252807617,
-0.5558792352676392,
-0.08227354288101196,
0.2265428751707077,
0.7322139739990234,
0.16528372466564178,
0.3425060510635376,
-0.9290043115615845,
0.0746745839715004,
0.3708000183105469,
0.28429070115089417,
-0.14557071030139923,
-0.509291410446167,
-0.561773955821991,
-0.17792290449142456,
-0.29125070571899414,
-0.7627615332603455,
0.47034797072410583,
0.45494282245635986,
0.37240108847618103,
0.5619378685951233,
-0.015270348638296127,
0.7874981760978699,
-0.46406567096710205,
0.9918690323829651,
0.27994728088378906,
-1.2928508520126343,
0.3955950140953064,
-0.3244052827358246,
0.4957011342048645,
0.7196312546730042,
-0.03432954475283623,
-0.3029577136039734,
-0.11054495722055435,
-0.20199938118457794,
-0.8038956522941589,
0.42676472663879395,
0.19536644220352173,
0.06383177638053894,
0.10594848543405533,
-0.14361333847045898,
0.2921704053878784,
0.3901818096637726,
-0.9422096014022827,
0.2207178920507431,
-0.6623444557189941,
-0.43054473400115967,
0.07349800318479538,
-0.3441433012485504,
-0.023858692497015,
-0.10517384856939316,
0.31042638421058655,
-0.13559667766094208,
0.04440819099545479,
0.39323148131370544,
-0.4950356185436249,
0.3308930993080139,
-0.023738259449601173,
0.8275852799415588,
0.5644215941429138,
-0.04654213786125183,
0.24566763639450073,
-0.0322432667016983,
-0.46747633814811707,
-0.09841932356357574,
-0.05345512926578522,
-0.3989984095096588,
0.013438585214316845,
0.3633807301521301,
0.8999217748641968,
0.3781721889972687,
-0.9254007935523987,
0.8224442005157471,
0.14167481660842896,
-0.08815564960241318,
-0.428024560213089,
0.11223452538251877,
0.05525502562522888,
0.2802307605743408,
0.060963116586208344,
-0.0521705262362957,
0.3097265362739563,
-0.4887983798980713,
0.3260503113269806,
0.16631154716014862,
-0.38318732380867004,
-0.47691118717193604,
0.6929087042808533,
0.4868905246257782,
0.22579607367515564,
0.3852282464504242,
-0.11534851044416428,
-0.9842632412910461,
0.25290364027023315,
0.5314344763755798,
0.9399768114089966,
-0.07050337642431259,
0.09643258899450302,
0.3263595700263977,
0.049937449395656586,
-0.21849662065505981,
0.1444920301437378,
-0.049593735486269,
-0.8928142786026001,
-0.1304432600736618,
-0.6883119940757751,
-0.4130266606807709,
-0.06652934849262238,
-0.466513991355896,
0.1702577918767929,
-0.3398648798465729,
0.12459059059619904,
-0.44176968932151794,
-0.4669874906539917,
-0.7425550818443298,
0.20068761706352234,
0.2071235626935959,
0.6208980679512024,
-1.0190848112106323,
0.7584607005119324,
0.6446595191955566,
-0.5574533343315125,
-0.5498664975166321,
-0.045847274363040924,
-0.1589747816324234,
-0.3970186114311218,
0.5156229138374329,
0.5021815299987793,
-0.19971153140068054,
-0.053434502333402634,
-0.5909535884857178,
-0.8801073431968689,
1.1245349645614624,
0.3221282660961151,
-0.4568712115287781,
0.10315763205289841,
0.0836368277668953,
0.6397076845169067,
-0.8479093313217163,
-0.025722548365592957,
0.4684034287929535,
0.3310319483280182,
0.11174574494361877,
-0.6625567078590393,
-0.1717386394739151,
-0.2604542672634125,
0.23837308585643768,
-0.09115555882453918,
-0.538574755191803,
0.8418367505073547,
0.0826636478304863,
-0.40563300251960754,
0.28219500184059143,
0.7598993182182312,
0.13387258350849152,
0.41833847761154175,
0.2659587264060974,
0.6547611355781555,
0.5026487708091736,
-0.21659865975379944,
0.9913093447685242,
-0.40960848331451416,
0.2453116774559021,
1.1626337766647339,
-0.6954509615898132,
0.9529021978378296,
0.327912837266922,
0.00677452702075243,
0.47130247950553894,
0.19424213469028473,
-0.15569180250167847,
0.8790510296821594,
0.047693390399217606,
-0.27490073442459106,
-0.2523749768733978,
-0.18085357546806335,
-0.26153552532196045,
0.5054530501365662,
0.39354556798934937,
-0.46508297324180603,
0.20010988414287567,
0.12109418958425522,
-0.14577104151248932,
0.5311524271965027,
-0.3045678436756134,
0.758726179599762,
0.014123647473752499,
-0.5509113669395447,
0.5627917051315308,
-0.31856316328048706,
0.7444143891334534,
-0.6913506984710693,
-0.0753636285662651,
-0.16787172853946686,
0.4678562879562378,
-0.1597713679075241,
-0.6831181049346924,
0.15809376537799835,
-0.10179261118173599,
-0.28382956981658936,
0.006683191284537315,
0.6810621619224548,
-0.7625141143798828,
-0.3858344554901123,
0.23446445167064667,
0.15653811395168304,
0.002237302716821432,
-0.15979617834091187,
-0.49146899580955505,
0.6398738622665405,
0.12476494163274765,
0.22880378365516663,
-0.01762123592197895,
0.32733362913131714,
0.19665652513504028,
0.48924168944358826,
0.6395927667617798,
-0.03713356330990791,
0.2300153225660324,
-0.07243262976408005,
0.9244555830955505,
-0.46738871932029724,
-0.6112727522850037,
-0.8472365736961365,
0.7442455291748047,
-0.3187390863895416,
-0.09301277250051498,
0.5544524192810059,
0.5985836982727051,
1.1466128826141357,
-0.7530019283294678,
0.7153906226158142,
0.07886967808008194,
0.29599541425704956,
-0.7886554002761841,
0.46514633297920227,
-0.5310526490211487,
0.23184216022491455,
-0.3227138817310333,
-0.9199188947677612,
-0.48438721895217896,
0.4118134677410126,
-0.2526577115058899,
-0.2192167043685913,
0.8589270710945129,
0.766676664352417,
-0.23885582387447357,
-0.22108091413974762,
0.6231400966644287,
0.25555166602134705,
0.3653358221054077,
0.5836741924285889,
0.6687336564064026,
-0.31458866596221924,
0.6079419851303101,
-0.2135499119758606,
0.043896809220314026,
-0.5427244305610657,
-0.9313900470733643,
-0.891350269317627,
-0.6271964907646179,
-0.22958508133888245,
-0.0645095705986023,
0.14530500769615173,
0.5919568538665771,
0.8218473792076111,
-0.762601375579834,
-0.26018959283828735,
-0.16071034967899323,
-0.23649261891841888,
-0.4207785129547119,
-0.13680657744407654,
0.2867833971977234,
-0.03655349835753441,
-0.7375108599662781,
0.36668527126312256,
0.45337018370628357,
-0.015001705847680569,
-0.3476699888706207,
-0.24232444167137146,
0.0854845941066742,
0.03782326355576515,
0.6585870981216431,
0.2204931080341339,
-0.8000594973564148,
-0.28467005491256714,
0.08121763169765472,
-0.012636508792638779,
0.33180132508277893,
0.8015251755714417,
-0.55295330286026,
0.7538278102874756,
0.5982800722122192,
0.8535297513008118,
0.6340915560722351,
0.2682220935821533,
0.584571361541748,
-0.7178221940994263,
0.23038028180599213,
0.19653433561325073,
0.5999910235404968,
0.7825628519058228,
-0.0030015278607606888,
0.6159003376960754,
0.5255996584892273,
-0.3339836895465851,
-0.5889449119567871,
0.768872082233429,
-1.2508420944213867,
-0.11621355265378952,
1.0301100015640259,
-0.36899372935295105,
-0.5187680721282959,
0.2446504831314087,
-0.38398224115371704,
-0.19050291180610657,
-0.31247955560684204,
0.3474400043487549,
0.5226809978485107,
0.2904972732067108,
-0.2948671579360962,
-0.09982718527317047,
0.22505275905132294,
0.3061043918132782,
-0.47771918773651123,
0.13132774829864502,
0.6628970503807068,
0.4016743004322052,
0.24785727262496948,
0.4746842682361603,
-0.24856355786323547,
0.24105046689510345,
0.09193147718906403,
0.008560839109122753,
-0.17068390548229218,
-0.4460543692111969,
-0.33012717962265015,
0.2967652976512909,
0.13457098603248596,
-0.3559311628341675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15020v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15020v1
|
Probabilistically-sound beam search with masked language models
| 2024-02-22T23:36:26 | 2024-02-22T23:36:26 |
Charlie Cowen-Breen, Creston Brooks, Robert Calef, Anna Sappington
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Beam search with masked language models (MLMs) is challenging in part because
joint probability distributions over sequences are not readily available,
unlike for autoregressive models. Nevertheless, estimating such distributions
has applications in many domains, including protein engineering and ancient
text restoration. We present probabilistically-sound methods for beam search
with MLMs. First, we clarify the conditions under which it is theoretically
sound to perform text infilling with MLMs using standard beam search. When
these conditions fail, we provide a probabilistically-sound modification with
no additional computational complexity and demonstrate that it is superior to
the aforementioned beam search in the expected conditions. We then present
empirical results comparing several infilling approaches with MLMs across
several domains.
|
[
-0.09636273980140686,
-0.7256519198417664,
0.823737382888794,
0.2338281124830246,
-0.100437231361866,
0.17832408845424652,
-0.0717233419418335,
-0.4982367753982544,
0.20754724740982056,
0.6378282308578491,
-0.5033749938011169,
-0.5364401340484619,
-0.5666230916976929,
-0.011303629726171494,
-0.5756608247756958,
0.5315385460853577,
-0.16398462653160095,
0.20886406302452087,
-0.03660687059164047,
0.2237028181552887,
-0.5333096981048584,
-0.40157780051231384,
-0.34321650862693787,
-0.3872787356376648,
-0.14541134238243103,
0.0290154367685318,
0.8475048542022705,
0.44208770990371704,
0.8100510835647583,
0.157718226313591,
-0.2580161392688751,
0.19515953958034515,
-0.20895300805568695,
0.3590882420539856,
-0.11633303016424179,
-0.24988245964050293,
-0.23151548206806183,
0.08156433701515198,
0.5681504011154175,
1.2270798683166504,
-0.006113361567258835,
-0.16311758756637573,
-0.014296995475888252,
0.861358106136322,
-0.9004248380661011,
0.3662681579589844,
-0.6123753190040588,
0.40751808881759644,
-0.45069414377212524,
-0.5796501040458679,
-0.6304095387458801,
-0.23839592933654785,
0.23574362695217133,
-0.2975766956806183,
0.5086461901664734,
0.2525852918624878,
0.5558843612670898,
0.04519578441977501,
-0.367742121219635,
-0.6043281555175781,
-1.0075486898422241,
0.8808164000511169,
-0.7094820737838745,
0.6056979298591614,
0.899202287197113,
0.021497471258044243,
-0.8121314644813538,
-0.6816478371620178,
-0.12584318220615387,
-0.42074039578437805,
-0.1871625930070877,
0.16330452263355255,
-0.2030377984046936,
0.5786792039871216,
0.0045751663856208324,
0.5142055749893188,
-0.9316350817680359,
-0.22952716052532196,
-0.11452525854110718,
-0.22952066361904144,
0.6464000344276428,
-0.06645172834396362,
0.2242494523525238,
0.04944451525807381,
-0.22362856566905975,
-0.32675424218177795,
-0.6316700577735901,
-0.09117886424064636,
0.6211138963699341,
0.30206695199012756,
0.2914171516895294,
0.6323068141937256,
-0.28593048453330994,
0.9592486023902893,
-0.013462747447192669,
-0.35944321751594543,
0.1299598067998886,
-0.37409481406211853,
-0.207538440823555,
0.2651904225349426,
0.531934916973114,
-0.04872317984700203,
-0.015592265874147415,
-0.22354385256767273,
-0.5676608681678772,
-0.2104283720254898,
-0.022865645587444305,
-0.4995537996292114,
-0.5215387940406799,
0.29555895924568176,
-0.9187269806861877,
0.060737933963537216,
0.1449805349111557,
-0.2758130729198456,
-0.37379011511802673,
0.006389519665390253,
0.6909719109535217,
-0.48259249329566956,
-0.23280151188373566,
0.5105952620506287,
-0.41355276107788086,
-0.26090148091316223,
-0.038311656564474106,
-0.9870845675468445,
0.3530312180519104,
0.6288937330245972,
0.8675363063812256,
0.08225426077842712,
0.19691257178783417,
-0.5826504826545715,
0.07279550284147263,
-0.6397364735603333,
0.6420014500617981,
-0.9216045141220093,
-0.43443426489830017,
0.22444979846477509,
-0.2725052535533905,
-0.025015464052557945,
-0.9945828318595886,
0.7014544606208801,
-0.5567853450775146,
-0.003032063599675894,
0.12397315353155136,
-1.0955615043640137,
-0.25075849890708923,
-0.3780367374420166,
-0.620368242263794,
0.8758015036582947,
0.09637976437807083,
-0.6365780234336853,
0.3222277760505676,
-0.5162639617919922,
-0.4932442307472229,
0.026507282629609108,
0.011178022250533104,
-0.6382295489311218,
0.4193432927131653,
0.20362144708633423,
0.5178102254867554,
0.1420501321554184,
0.41163894534111023,
-0.292728066444397,
-0.6196334958076477,
0.3158571124076843,
-0.4113999009132385,
0.7478327751159668,
0.41681182384490967,
-0.476004034280777,
-0.3569391071796417,
-0.5379137396812439,
-0.349696546792984,
-0.08324451744556427,
-0.035848185420036316,
-0.36369243264198303,
0.5311037302017212,
0.12990787625312805,
-0.31454968452453613,
-0.02057448774576187,
-0.4428200125694275,
0.00521931191906333,
-0.9039261341094971,
0.11662619560956955,
0.34003835916519165,
0.05025725066661835,
0.5248365998268127,
-0.35804232954978943,
0.4896188974380493,
0.05993177369236946,
-0.020437058061361313,
-0.32789120078086853,
-0.8956131339073181,
-0.33566123247146606,
-0.6807511448860168,
0.28089672327041626,
0.5053917765617371,
-0.6700181365013123,
0.13076342642307281,
0.4663548767566681,
-0.34878379106521606,
-0.6747893691062927,
0.052379705011844635,
0.44543758034706116,
0.2337769716978073,
0.3963221609592438,
-0.4945828914642334,
-1.0063292980194092,
-0.8961208462715149,
-0.4352087676525116,
-0.29747864603996277,
-0.2551787793636322,
0.10333974659442902,
0.17776863276958466,
-0.0644184798002243,
1.1302560567855835,
-0.34281685948371887,
-0.6183844208717346,
-0.10779418051242828,
0.20714077353477478,
0.6549639701843262,
0.48246219754219055,
0.4326511323451996,
-0.9569793939590454,
-0.407308965921402,
-0.2951304316520691,
-0.8024620413780212,
-0.14099527895450592,
0.01608327217400074,
0.31324267387390137,
0.024900294840335846,
0.7708947658538818,
-0.7386987209320068,
0.6620956063270569,
0.6582456231117249,
-0.004454377572983503,
0.5661027431488037,
-0.2525958716869354,
0.0837804302573204,
-0.9006841778755188,
-0.15736067295074463,
-0.038462478667497635,
-0.37731289863586426,
-0.8411720991134644,
0.17005473375320435,
-0.09916112571954727,
-0.20923034846782684,
-0.43659377098083496,
0.6429271697998047,
-0.961726725101471,
-0.22033807635307312,
-0.6197754144668579,
0.2699342966079712,
-0.26928603649139404,
0.11036062240600586,
0.19494089484214783,
0.5447636246681213,
0.6786506175994873,
-0.491211861371994,
0.3143881559371948,
0.2429458349943161,
-0.6245431303977966,
0.20749999582767487,
-0.4285237193107605,
-0.1102217584848404,
-0.3606804609298706,
0.5109341740608215,
-1.0851229429244995,
-0.06423670798540115,
0.23309029638767242,
-0.32037606835365295,
0.5279772281646729,
-0.2752498984336853,
-0.490677148103714,
-0.21955707669258118,
-0.3237660825252533,
0.586641788482666,
0.38522252440452576,
-0.5483025312423706,
0.11249259859323502,
0.6119993925094604,
-0.30513328313827515,
-0.6817237734794617,
-0.41527047753334045,
0.4021182358264923,
-0.11169708520174026,
-0.5295115113258362,
0.6633937954902649,
-0.1893618106842041,
-0.45574936270713806,
-0.11718498170375824,
-0.22898684442043304,
-0.02485918626189232,
0.26605838537216187,
0.16526766121387482,
0.1896548718214035,
-0.3583694100379944,
0.10354584455490112,
-0.11646712571382523,
-0.22526945173740387,
-0.1727932244539261,
-0.66595858335495,
0.3907879590988159,
-0.009383942000567913,
-0.7246504426002502,
-0.1951485127210617,
0.5866009593009949,
-0.2882680594921112,
-0.02096148207783699,
0.6017042398452759,
0.45098942518234253,
-0.6858544945716858,
-0.1633719801902771,
-0.7413360476493835,
-0.5022984147071838,
-0.5249797701835632,
0.48646828532218933,
-0.39036107063293457,
-0.9501709938049316,
0.3489852547645569,
0.07850474864244461,
-0.23725798726081848,
0.36457860469818115,
0.6891286969184875,
-0.6506316661834717,
1.211133599281311,
0.6582854390144348,
0.242523193359375,
0.45627561211586,
0.07479916512966156,
0.6302347779273987,
-0.3624059557914734,
-0.1398438811302185,
-0.6565130949020386,
-0.31699663400650024,
-0.8215495944023132,
-0.2369605302810669,
0.4042145609855652,
0.21555092930793762,
0.4093097150325775,
0.5508876442909241,
-0.3985961377620697,
0.5575360655784607,
0.9339351654052734,
0.09783019125461578,
0.3929011821746826,
0.11522882431745529,
-0.03842974826693535,
-0.154022216796875,
-0.6652909517288208,
-0.38051727414131165,
0.8585488200187683,
0.2853030562400818,
0.7775552272796631,
0.053879138082265854,
0.7919629812240601,
0.18835385143756866,
0.12071314454078674,
-0.4879021942615509,
0.36926841735839844,
-0.31682392954826355,
-0.9448579549789429,
-0.401696115732193,
-0.4781612157821655,
-1.1911031007766724,
-0.017021454870700836,
-0.2433425486087799,
-1.0397279262542725,
0.3963457942008972,
0.19671279191970825,
0.01694522053003311,
0.4895181357860565,
-0.29038113355636597,
0.5564415454864502,
0.3418887257575989,
0.29582542181015015,
-0.050083138048648834,
-0.5857240557670593,
0.2958064079284668,
-0.25130942463874817,
0.3975449502468109,
-0.35125306248664856,
0.3345402777194977,
0.7932958602905273,
-0.21271908283233643,
0.6267486810684204,
-0.08843384683132172,
0.10122590512037277,
0.25457048416137695,
0.44109678268432617,
0.6096789240837097,
-0.037241168320178986,
-0.06390215456485748,
-0.027033846825361252,
-0.06656496971845627,
-0.3977777063846588,
-0.4941837191581726,
0.34277600049972534,
-0.3636559247970581,
-0.7393025755882263,
-0.20057815313339233,
-0.7012299299240112,
-0.3896612823009491,
0.0238484013825655,
0.423657089471817,
0.4865667223930359,
-0.1464674472808838,
0.4484119415283203,
0.8857975006103516,
-0.188471257686615,
0.8526399731636047,
0.24438819289207458,
-0.15275412797927856,
-0.11850673705339432,
0.9903514385223389,
0.038174211978912354,
-0.046165306121110916,
0.7962294220924377,
0.045932382345199585,
-0.36481809616088867,
-1.0382440090179443,
-0.1467101126909256,
0.10832283645868301,
-0.5989543795585632,
-0.2022985816001892,
-0.7186740040779114,
-0.40250256657600403,
-0.3476015329360962,
-0.35449153184890747,
-0.3742939233779907,
-0.42785680294036865,
-0.30081474781036377,
-0.027051186189055443,
0.014200564473867416,
0.470201700925827,
-0.17154142260551453,
0.07443006336688995,
-0.9086484909057617,
0.3404848277568817,
0.12275806814432144,
0.4380911588668823,
-0.44886353611946106,
-0.659878671169281,
-0.49009108543395996,
0.1605876386165619,
-0.29419174790382385,
-1.1179757118225098,
0.6803691983222961,
0.4620414972305298,
0.8712384700775146,
0.0021213307045400143,
0.22051943838596344,
0.3404434025287628,
-0.4193095266819,
0.596092939376831,
0.16908219456672668,
-0.8304924964904785,
0.587552547454834,
-0.28904417157173157,
0.08356611430644989,
0.28681522607803345,
0.5474725961685181,
-0.40105122327804565,
-0.8583205938339233,
-0.6468127369880676,
-0.7793139815330505,
0.5232465267181396,
0.6460710167884827,
0.007902631536126137,
-0.06920050084590912,
0.12243032455444336,
0.023692874237895012,
0.29158058762550354,
-0.26507842540740967,
-0.4126031994819641,
0.03936631605029106,
-0.39258357882499695,
-0.29037654399871826,
-0.24968238174915314,
0.06934404373168945,
0.2153124064207077,
0.8939844369888306,
0.021508967503905296,
0.34447118639945984,
0.40449783205986023,
-0.4348556399345398,
-0.1868719905614853,
0.0922035202383995,
0.7437816262245178,
0.5055572986602783,
-0.7584791779518127,
0.3724803030490875,
-0.04712110385298729,
-0.5317789912223816,
0.27843907475471497,
0.2309042513370514,
-0.3207301199436188,
0.6639747619628906,
0.4782968759536743,
0.8898236751556396,
0.2885579764842987,
-0.8684244155883789,
0.5237289667129517,
0.21053166687488556,
-0.3205973207950592,
-0.12734171748161316,
-0.2206076681613922,
0.22721551358699799,
0.42437005043029785,
0.8879317045211792,
0.09262583404779434,
0.6381754279136658,
-0.6178152561187744,
0.37420690059661865,
0.6786820292472839,
-0.4049318730831146,
-0.16917334496974945,
0.8561773300170898,
-0.26516517996788025,
-0.7123191952705383,
0.45720788836479187,
-0.3389202952384949,
-0.13810354471206665,
0.4344559609889984,
0.6014037132263184,
1.2172292470932007,
-0.08130606263875961,
0.26893138885498047,
0.025800174102187157,
0.30691438913345337,
-0.46440693736076355,
-0.04884402081370354,
0.15170742571353912,
-0.5959649085998535,
-0.4456653594970703,
-0.749229371547699,
-0.7232306003570557,
-0.17333082854747772,
-0.24955891072750092,
0.07752034068107605,
-0.002968700835481286,
-0.31033745408058167,
0.12503476440906525,
-0.010474719107151031,
-0.3953455984592438,
0.14492638409137726,
0.3537805676460266,
0.7430869936943054,
-0.655052900314331,
0.6236657500267029,
0.3885541558265686,
-0.09314918518066406,
-0.3888739347457886,
-0.11174323409795761,
0.0992140993475914,
-0.5467043519020081,
0.700512707233429,
-0.09865415096282959,
-0.023193426430225372,
-0.17811574041843414,
-0.46581846475601196,
-0.9884004592895508,
0.5906963348388672,
0.7200580835342407,
-0.41102132201194763,
0.06500387191772461,
0.30435991287231445,
0.40071985125541687,
-0.1843443065881729,
0.3695804476737976,
0.40958061814308167,
0.29859477281570435,
-0.08134012669324875,
-1.2534884214401245,
-0.2781427502632141,
0.04388851299881935,
0.1630517840385437,
0.14580081403255463,
-0.16147363185882568,
0.7758576273918152,
0.06723231077194214,
-0.25233444571495056,
-0.005688629578799009,
0.8917459845542908,
0.4621275067329407,
0.5817977786064148,
0.2960073947906494,
0.11924751847982407,
0.6974005699157715,
0.06312660872936249,
0.7129481434822083,
-0.23033933341503143,
0.6100322604179382,
0.929314374923706,
-0.2134397029876709,
0.8513898253440857,
0.35849449038505554,
-0.337151437997818,
0.1680639386177063,
0.7745076417922974,
0.27534931898117065,
0.7154739499092102,
0.25812828540802,
-0.44415006041526794,
-0.21766746044158936,
-0.05890559405088425,
-0.43168824911117554,
0.32679274678230286,
0.13720904290676117,
-0.2711940109729767,
-0.11461616307497025,
0.11700988560914993,
-0.13277468085289001,
0.191787451505661,
-0.059430081397295,
0.5438889861106873,
0.4033365547657013,
-0.44645264744758606,
0.41466647386550903,
0.29254889488220215,
0.6488900184631348,
-0.34613001346588135,
0.01045710127800703,
-0.5710400938987732,
0.09477554261684418,
-0.1659531593322754,
-0.6046701073646545,
0.4552711844444275,
-0.4288370907306671,
-0.36533015966415405,
-0.47566908597946167,
0.9470458030700684,
-0.6542287468910217,
-0.5063964128494263,
0.2310389131307602,
0.42310842871665955,
0.2641867697238922,
-0.293288916349411,
-0.3546614348888397,
-0.05318395420908928,
-0.18108294904232025,
-0.47292301058769226,
0.567192792892456,
0.06086166203022003,
0.04684097692370415,
0.7247403860092163,
0.5853140354156494,
0.011603975668549538,
0.13830526173114777,
-0.09146842360496521,
0.23064297437667847,
-0.5407350063323975,
-0.28652694821357727,
-0.9485681056976318,
0.07898609340190887,
0.20633555948734283,
0.10800114274024963,
0.7626429200172424,
0.6600214838981628,
1.0046204328536987,
-0.3337063193321228,
0.49495622515678406,
0.5462183356285095,
0.5282164812088013,
-0.8448695540428162,
0.5841075778007507,
-0.41894277930259705,
0.1403277963399887,
-0.6708357334136963,
-1.2477467060089111,
-0.5288756489753723,
0.6738572716712952,
0.21535348892211914,
0.047024618834257126,
0.6378820538520813,
1.2186198234558105,
-0.07326363027095795,
0.13316918909549713,
0.6940282583236694,
0.11232836544513702,
0.24181243777275085,
0.41214343905448914,
0.7045523524284363,
-0.608573853969574,
0.45775118470191956,
-0.11167379468679428,
-0.22271279990673065,
-0.5634535551071167,
-0.8836594820022583,
-0.574146568775177,
-0.7813088893890381,
-0.47648537158966064,
-0.19809694588184357,
0.3431510925292969,
0.9719112515449524,
0.8910114765167236,
-1.0658146142959595,
-0.439313679933548,
0.17326809465885162,
0.1375739723443985,
-0.5749784708023071,
-0.14233554899692535,
0.3439429998397827,
-0.4253222346305847,
-0.7382403016090393,
1.2508829832077026,
0.5886618494987488,
-0.1447683870792389,
-0.06472526490688324,
-0.042129214853048325,
-0.20383797585964203,
0.3816612958908081,
0.3497928977012634,
0.2674080729484558,
-0.5892211198806763,
-0.28379565477371216,
0.15470515191555023,
-0.15556053817272186,
0.030375244095921516,
0.8527696132659912,
-0.7215748429298401,
0.6616509556770325,
0.6915244460105896,
0.5421940684318542,
0.8333835601806641,
-0.4204923212528229,
0.6598984003067017,
-0.9877280592918396,
0.33814486861228943,
0.38050755858421326,
0.5786502361297607,
0.15237322449684143,
0.007417462300509214,
0.5821419358253479,
0.5461869239807129,
-0.4717208743095398,
-1.0683369636535645,
0.18836046755313873,
-0.8743794560432434,
-0.37627312541007996,
0.9547551274299622,
0.02662080153822899,
0.15936179459095,
-0.3942171633243561,
-0.07906565815210342,
0.21654632687568665,
0.08163315802812576,
0.7752088308334351,
0.7455435395240784,
0.08873449265956879,
-0.012863082811236382,
-0.5714098215103149,
0.6854454278945923,
0.5953737497329712,
-0.11551719158887863,
-0.34745800495147705,
0.15411585569381714,
-0.06094679981470108,
0.05950005352497101,
0.9051862955093384,
0.1456281691789627,
0.2074124813079834,
0.08357657492160797,
-0.06247742474079132,
0.21061493456363678,
-0.27303609251976013,
-0.14400111138820648,
0.4342779815196991,
0.09907049685716629,
0.06268340349197388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15018v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15018v2
|
Unintended Impacts of LLM Alignment on Global Representation
| 2024-02-22T23:31:22 | 2024-06-06T22:31:48 |
Michael J. Ryan, William Held, Diyi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Before being deployed for user-facing applications, developers align Large
Language Models (LLMs) to user preferences through a variety of procedures,
such as Reinforcement Learning From Human Feedback (RLHF) and Direct Preference
Optimization (DPO). Current evaluations of these procedures focus on benchmarks
of instruction following, reasoning, and truthfulness. However, human
preferences are not universal, and aligning to specific preference sets may
have unintended effects. We explore how alignment impacts performance along
three axes of global representation: English dialects, multilingualism, and
opinions from and about countries worldwide. Our results show that current
alignment procedures create disparities between English dialects and global
opinions. We find alignment improves capabilities in several languages. We
conclude by discussing design decisions that led to these unintended impacts
and recommendations for more equitable preference tuning. We make our code and
data publicly available on Github.
|
[
-0.32824692130088806,
-0.2409825623035431,
0.5695539712905884,
0.1979193091392517,
-0.15577705204486847,
0.250641793012619,
-0.35328516364097595,
-0.7421322464942932,
0.1977398693561554,
0.5230400562286377,
-0.4145166873931885,
-0.3304651379585266,
-0.40972238779067993,
-0.04318530112504959,
0.06982351094484329,
0.9362909197807312,
-0.09336572885513306,
0.16717374324798584,
-0.4768437445163727,
-0.4352743327617645,
-0.7258166670799255,
-0.547503650188446,
-0.11051788926124573,
-0.6500795483589172,
0.5664302706718445,
0.7264572381973267,
1.2044520378112793,
0.7807736396789551,
0.43075448274612427,
0.3261791467666626,
0.151032492518425,
0.11681853979825974,
-0.5169171690940857,
0.12430007010698318,
-0.21871177852153778,
-0.3781501352787018,
-0.38028326630592346,
0.03660380840301514,
0.7433351874351501,
0.6688093543052673,
-0.21135401725769043,
-0.05676910653710365,
0.2661909759044647,
0.8547092080116272,
-0.5507166385650635,
-0.06385236978530884,
-0.5047065019607544,
-0.04878377169370651,
-0.11964952200651169,
-0.14970143139362335,
-0.2559587359428406,
-0.3113577663898468,
0.2886115610599518,
-0.4738142192363739,
-0.1230568066239357,
0.1886134296655655,
0.7096656560897827,
0.343103289604187,
-0.6384070515632629,
-0.3498396873474121,
-0.7816811203956604,
0.9833802580833435,
-0.4261739253997803,
0.4196907877922058,
-0.06121355667710304,
0.1971367597579956,
-0.3619348406791687,
-0.1449742317199707,
-0.2659532129764557,
-0.13196972012519836,
-0.1577463001012802,
0.11278495192527771,
-0.12634743750095367,
0.2524630129337311,
0.16705071926116943,
0.2643641233444214,
-0.4940204620361328,
0.6039371490478516,
-0.2693825960159302,
-0.28202974796295166,
0.8902768492698669,
0.14076900482177734,
0.41479742527008057,
-0.02449161931872368,
-0.27115383744239807,
0.04717108607292175,
-0.949399471282959,
0.22241391241550446,
0.7910950183868408,
0.4489634037017822,
-0.15705789625644684,
0.5532134175300598,
0.032766830176115036,
0.8974254131317139,
0.032022569328546524,
-0.08125289529561996,
0.19489870965480804,
-0.03245048597455025,
0.10339339077472687,
0.17569641768932343,
0.6711557507514954,
0.6570674180984497,
0.39959093928337097,
-0.23582984507083893,
-0.1529289186000824,
0.0503317154943943,
0.3964378237724304,
-0.3437831401824951,
0.19711735844612122,
0.17280328273773193,
-0.2177082747220993,
-0.12441745400428772,
0.27358385920524597,
-0.606778085231781,
-0.7106744050979614,
-0.714134693145752,
0.06260164827108383,
0.037239693105220795,
-0.06915940344333649,
0.12670457363128662,
0.09373706579208374,
0.20162266492843628,
0.33730071783065796,
-1.157537817955017,
0.09600584954023361,
0.9223986268043518,
0.4418908655643463,
-0.42139774560928345,
-0.3474929630756378,
-0.16771554946899414,
0.08705080300569534,
-0.1931696981191635,
0.6441060304641724,
-0.5509580969810486,
-0.4489012062549591,
0.039258409291505814,
-0.02018834836781025,
0.16388165950775146,
-0.7336306571960449,
0.4977802038192749,
-0.32688894867897034,
0.17975914478302002,
-0.4137071967124939,
-0.48879367113113403,
-0.07167463004589081,
-0.13014979660511017,
-0.6155827641487122,
0.7431599497795105,
-0.14488324522972107,
-0.5812838673591614,
0.4699321985244751,
-0.3365364670753479,
-0.46477821469306946,
-0.23655332624912262,
-0.44900786876678467,
-0.319944828748703,
0.39014166593551636,
0.27047404646873474,
0.23783300817012787,
-0.09454622864723206,
0.41831737756729126,
-0.4071994423866272,
-0.6190546751022339,
0.183639258146286,
-0.2865924537181854,
0.7588209509849548,
0.18787913024425507,
-0.37518736720085144,
0.22203411161899567,
-0.6860571503639221,
0.0173750352114439,
0.08176436275243759,
-0.38169705867767334,
-0.3085830509662628,
0.1104021891951561,
-0.2128085345029831,
0.06836570799350739,
0.284274697303772,
-0.46126365661621094,
0.45900261402130127,
-0.3332183063030243,
0.24833464622497559,
1.1226022243499756,
-0.19913354516029358,
0.7470015287399292,
-0.20351888239383698,
0.6120147109031677,
-0.06923632323741913,
0.29758143424987793,
0.2912234663963318,
-0.4142458736896515,
-0.5163951516151428,
-0.005129031836986542,
0.2523729205131531,
0.4063110053539276,
-0.1270320564508438,
0.35338294506073,
-0.3400919437408447,
-0.22633777558803558,
-0.6421713829040527,
0.3586703836917877,
0.46934330463409424,
0.38699769973754883,
-0.030166776850819588,
-0.10146155208349228,
-0.7435649037361145,
-1.206320881843567,
-0.32875576615333557,
-0.31286734342575073,
0.11377505213022232,
0.19027282297611237,
0.1771867573261261,
-0.3531958758831024,
0.9942827820777893,
-0.48963963985443115,
-0.10136045515537262,
-0.1768227368593216,
-0.26548054814338684,
0.10580337047576904,
0.20486706495285034,
0.5069736838340759,
-0.5712804794311523,
-0.3930214047431946,
0.04431992396712303,
-0.39775902032852173,
-0.34358271956443787,
-0.009319795295596123,
-0.2795146107673645,
0.5838211178779602,
0.16820605099201202,
-0.2695629596710205,
0.12515351176261902,
0.9009202122688293,
-0.046077098697423935,
0.4294109046459198,
-0.22480063140392303,
0.16899685561656952,
-0.8671829104423523,
-0.16713929176330566,
0.08657597750425339,
0.0038423750083893538,
-0.2074655443429947,
-0.027868051081895828,
0.3132736384868622,
-0.028691759333014488,
-0.4000120162963867,
0.6533700227737427,
-0.500819981098175,
-0.38926348090171814,
-0.05478256568312645,
0.27187421917915344,
0.25963515043258667,
0.30711546540260315,
0.03299142047762871,
1.022627592086792,
0.16748234629631042,
-0.3827390968799591,
0.20252136886119843,
0.08610179275274277,
-0.41891005635261536,
0.43381136655807495,
-0.4790160655975342,
0.11038318276405334,
-0.11155811697244644,
0.01867125928401947,
-0.9411760568618774,
-0.1816449612379074,
-0.015133272856473923,
-0.20778129994869232,
0.4256504774093628,
-0.021709201857447624,
-0.2658582627773285,
-0.2467423975467682,
-0.4442847669124603,
0.1293962001800537,
0.27144795656204224,
-0.6970028877258301,
0.23723497986793518,
0.6628414988517761,
0.25689440965652466,
-0.8989971876144409,
-0.7091382741928101,
-0.2039465755224228,
-0.33962032198905945,
-0.6716086268424988,
0.41317248344421387,
0.05437295511364937,
-0.486950546503067,
-0.25166842341423035,
-0.2776802182197571,
0.46822473406791687,
0.13706296682357788,
0.41551917791366577,
0.367819607257843,
0.12652915716171265,
0.149972066283226,
-0.18316875398159027,
-0.00003498762453091331,
-0.10736332088708878,
-0.23921914398670197,
0.2097577154636383,
-0.1913931965827942,
-0.617270290851593,
-0.20753079652786255,
0.22911015152931213,
0.4544031023979187,
-0.0869036540389061,
0.3603545129299164,
0.18511192500591278,
-0.030023278668522835,
-0.02864757552742958,
-0.49900344014167786,
0.05567681044340134,
-0.49385061860084534,
0.41720050573349,
-0.019697709009051323,
-1.0204836130142212,
0.6600131988525391,
0.06002144515514374,
0.18774835765361786,
0.26525869965553284,
0.4828678369522095,
-0.25585320591926575,
1.3541769981384277,
0.6142858266830444,
-0.30270063877105713,
0.6204079985618591,
0.11626913398504257,
0.23845218122005463,
-0.7614840865135193,
-0.20118941366672516,
-0.5536357164382935,
-0.6047214269638062,
-0.9032941460609436,
-0.08171075582504272,
0.3495835065841675,
0.16675972938537598,
-0.27705633640289307,
-0.0593583881855011,
-0.4772140681743622,
0.6804636120796204,
0.3994394540786743,
-0.16554045677185059,
0.2550613582134247,
0.23382964730262756,
-0.39693281054496765,
-0.33687230944633484,
-0.5098356604576111,
-0.657520592212677,
1.2132879495620728,
0.29857146739959717,
1.0842427015304565,
0.3104178011417389,
0.8743084073066711,
0.3336234390735626,
0.19619494676589966,
-0.8596493005752563,
0.39087963104248047,
-0.12929467856884003,
-0.35945892333984375,
-0.200843945145607,
-0.29237040877342224,
-1.0272386074066162,
0.23471243679523468,
-0.15521852672100067,
-0.9018924832344055,
0.005381087772548199,
0.32272252440452576,
-0.28868186473846436,
0.08132064342498779,
-0.8968163728713989,
0.7171685695648193,
-0.7284698486328125,
-0.46510693430900574,
-0.12110329419374466,
-0.5709707736968994,
0.29298877716064453,
0.0835210457444191,
0.23482976853847504,
-0.18153390288352966,
-0.040346719324588776,
0.4540504813194275,
-0.1653377264738083,
0.8400152325630188,
-0.2263239026069641,
-0.3843509554862976,
0.06160910055041313,
-0.1988488733768463,
0.4131958782672882,
0.032295726239681244,
-0.16556456685066223,
0.34199702739715576,
-0.2989887297153473,
-0.2562200427055359,
-0.6832945346832275,
0.9688667058944702,
-1.1875672340393066,
-1.1027170419692993,
-0.37554672360420227,
-0.5793204307556152,
-0.542845606803894,
0.10063593834638596,
0.055107202380895615,
0.24651408195495605,
-0.366572767496109,
-0.15803714096546173,
0.47614067792892456,
-0.17842204868793488,
0.17278438806533813,
0.43514248728752136,
-0.6375117301940918,
-0.4924160838127136,
0.7300184369087219,
0.23250962793827057,
0.3496617078781128,
0.29803186655044556,
0.2592061758041382,
-0.5595824122428894,
-0.40917089581489563,
-0.5936925411224365,
0.22398287057876587,
-0.8142399787902832,
-0.06598492711782455,
-0.10828463733196259,
0.2584148645401001,
-0.4504266679286957,
-0.26779139041900635,
-0.2114758938550949,
-0.5527334213256836,
-0.2935304641723633,
-0.14976687729358673,
0.021882902830839157,
0.9375287294387817,
-0.08322721719741821,
0.2535824179649353,
-0.5992692708969116,
-0.11780272424221039,
0.21217946708202362,
0.49982115626335144,
-0.12393324077129364,
-0.44384363293647766,
-0.47980332374572754,
0.1016993522644043,
-0.6184136271476746,
-0.5700653195381165,
-0.05128108337521553,
0.10581230372190475,
0.7898751497268677,
0.5397873520851135,
-0.17615532875061035,
0.8123765587806702,
-0.4584219753742218,
0.6184354424476624,
0.1551026552915573,
-0.8152952194213867,
0.3985951542854309,
-0.24187219142913818,
0.5418046712875366,
0.5474933385848999,
0.37310105562210083,
-0.6612716913223267,
-0.29538828134536743,
-0.16117429733276367,
-0.6473855972290039,
0.7159852385520935,
-0.33639654517173767,
0.12711863219738007,
0.08725021034479141,
0.37685590982437134,
0.17816434800624847,
-0.009415239095687866,
-0.4816667437553406,
-0.3298053741455078,
0.04495661333203316,
-0.040054552257061005,
-0.19616390764713287,
-0.3648722171783447,
-0.2137041985988617,
-0.30014273524284363,
0.6445071697235107,
-0.13028529286384583,
0.11136604845523834,
-0.16039662063121796,
-0.21666038036346436,
-0.33961886167526245,
0.3854014575481415,
0.8745208382606506,
0.8469404578208923,
-0.12876451015472412,
0.03538331389427185,
-0.22157397866249084,
-0.15351280570030212,
0.33494287729263306,
-0.11948146671056747,
-0.20726355910301208,
-0.3201461434364319,
0.32985547184944153,
0.7775703072547913,
0.2808797359466553,
-0.463110089302063,
0.21466393768787384,
-0.22826993465423584,
-0.01605190709233284,
-0.07816712558269501,
0.15371957421302795,
0.21004843711853027,
0.12890665233135223,
0.13040481507778168,
0.05195438116788864,
-0.06984787434339523,
-0.5510051846504211,
-0.042096495628356934,
0.7340418100357056,
-0.407355397939682,
-0.2690991759300232,
0.49417582154273987,
0.2980376183986664,
-0.18518896400928497,
0.5838840007781982,
0.2186824232339859,
-0.4867301285266876,
0.44041740894317627,
0.5665116906166077,
0.6612230539321899,
-0.29026705026626587,
0.2098883092403412,
0.0776766836643219,
0.24432140588760376,
0.03526349365711212,
0.24766694009304047,
0.03867606446146965,
-0.9567142724990845,
-0.39777132868766785,
-0.49671104550361633,
-0.553977370262146,
-0.2918250560760498,
-0.6366159915924072,
0.43224239349365234,
-0.3306787610054016,
-0.31090226769447327,
-0.020777158439159393,
0.06481442600488663,
-0.5148719549179077,
-0.15500937402248383,
0.36046186089515686,
0.38252878189086914,
-0.8361330032348633,
0.7162302136421204,
0.9546748399734497,
-0.24142535030841827,
-0.7221100330352783,
0.16982810199260712,
0.5034239888191223,
-1.113278865814209,
0.5469252467155457,
0.24475671350955963,
-0.2626763880252838,
-0.2566514313220978,
-0.30946168303489685,
-0.9245572090148926,
0.8242820501327515,
0.8681715726852417,
-0.6954829096794128,
0.21010349690914154,
0.6560431718826294,
0.5531268119812012,
-0.3791601359844208,
0.23404833674430847,
0.43472111225128174,
0.46834295988082886,
-0.1790778785943985,
-0.9539225101470947,
-0.15099890530109406,
0.10061623156070709,
0.19168220460414886,
0.38619464635849,
-0.7815502285957336,
0.334148645401001,
-0.48552849888801575,
-0.4012424051761627,
-0.26467981934547424,
0.3376856744289398,
0.2516297698020935,
-0.1340910941362381,
0.26034870743751526,
0.7030340433120728,
0.9542319774627686,
-0.18457955121994019,
1.0191253423690796,
-0.3801202178001404,
0.1816495954990387,
1.0373306274414062,
-0.5696927309036255,
0.5774596333503723,
0.8636321425437927,
-0.2846306264400482,
0.45457640290260315,
0.7443091869354248,
0.29834675788879395,
0.5136215090751648,
0.3229166865348816,
-0.11228024959564209,
-0.057550135999917984,
-0.2673865258693695,
-0.4158216416835785,
0.6317667961120605,
0.13282398879528046,
-0.08670677989721298,
-0.18295817077159882,
-0.23855999112129211,
-0.01603216864168644,
0.3054720163345337,
-0.28052574396133423,
0.7332430481910706,
-0.022966384887695312,
-1.0013972520828247,
0.6206490993499756,
-0.1457832008600235,
0.7883856296539307,
-0.3825610876083374,
-0.03124849498271942,
-0.34284934401512146,
0.3277128338813782,
-0.5100130438804626,
-1.0165101289749146,
0.32193320989608765,
-0.27633219957351685,
-0.3195858597755432,
-0.32904496788978577,
0.5076450109481812,
-0.3395860195159912,
-0.19525784254074097,
0.5932759642601013,
0.37814563512802124,
-0.17652536928653717,
0.11477810144424438,
-0.7260223031044006,
0.36300843954086304,
0.31988799571990967,
-0.20809145271778107,
0.6261973977088928,
0.25709813833236694,
-0.3660847246646881,
0.5239845514297485,
0.37000757455825806,
0.0013712341897189617,
-0.0945170447230339,
0.31415998935699463,
0.6199669241905212,
-0.4889475107192993,
-0.20196722447872162,
-0.8836660385131836,
0.5084136128425598,
0.02872265875339508,
-0.04727139323949814,
0.8480954170227051,
0.6574179530143738,
1.112473726272583,
0.05692485347390175,
0.7460883855819702,
0.20754815638065338,
0.18106943368911743,
-0.5491275787353516,
0.44127166271209717,
-0.696704089641571,
0.5491120219230652,
-0.20629696547985077,
-1.1078873872756958,
-0.43829241394996643,
0.24671290814876556,
-0.48037800192832947,
-0.04284576326608658,
0.49861273169517517,
0.8310853838920593,
0.019598064944148064,
0.03185894712805748,
0.37785348296165466,
-0.19406282901763916,
0.301614373922348,
0.3048360347747803,
0.8614001870155334,
0.01999977044761181,
0.3541490435600281,
-0.2632851004600525,
-0.16999603807926178,
-0.15724626183509827,
-1.0737942457199097,
-0.5233324766159058,
-0.3591655194759369,
-0.15348780155181885,
-0.3307918310165405,
0.06576582789421082,
1.112446665763855,
0.3151014447212219,
-0.7866374254226685,
-0.5409943461418152,
0.10157085210084915,
0.5283172130584717,
0.12283157557249069,
-0.1679886132478714,
0.222475066781044,
-0.2401595115661621,
-0.7205495834350586,
0.1913026124238968,
0.35361915826797485,
-0.0016771755181252956,
-0.45511049032211304,
-0.532159149646759,
-0.037384916096925735,
-0.3269648253917694,
0.35427504777908325,
0.465297132730484,
-0.9992807507514954,
-0.549860417842865,
-0.006559708621352911,
-0.2059805989265442,
0.44906187057495117,
0.8824073076248169,
-0.4759802222251892,
0.6305450797080994,
0.3398575782775879,
0.5320245623588562,
-0.057854145765304565,
0.14523406326770782,
0.9600812792778015,
-0.9263277649879456,
0.11885257810354233,
-0.06892000883817673,
0.5680192112922668,
0.4602294862270355,
-0.5136444568634033,
0.46593594551086426,
-0.0342077873647213,
-0.8070638179779053,
-0.6429519057273865,
0.44357937574386597,
-0.5999621152877808,
-0.11976303160190582,
1.1967438459396362,
0.04506291076540947,
-0.09837903082370758,
0.0573168620467186,
-0.20409347116947174,
0.039988305419683456,
-0.6093943119049072,
0.8024852871894836,
0.8745301365852356,
-0.4989852011203766,
0.026082023978233337,
-0.37111759185791016,
0.4436904489994049,
0.4627677798271179,
-0.42665794491767883,
0.25700056552886963,
0.8257427215576172,
0.17909866571426392,
0.02782556600868702,
0.5047260522842407,
-0.1904144436120987,
-0.03847673907876015,
-0.5272297263145447,
0.3071673810482025,
0.09359585493803024,
-0.19672615826129913,
-0.8306522369384766,
-0.29306933283805847,
0.4788171648979187,
0.10706235468387604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15017v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15017v1
|
Towards Few-Shot Adaptation of Foundation Models via Multitask Finetuning
| 2024-02-22T23:29:42 | 2024-02-22T23:29:42 |
Zhuoyan Xu, Zhenmei Shi, Junyi Wei, Fangzhou Mu, Yin Li, Yingyu Liang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Foundation models have emerged as a powerful tool for many AI problems.
Despite the tremendous success of foundation models, effective adaptation to
new tasks, particularly those with limited labels, remains an open question and
lacks theoretical understanding. An emerging solution with recent success in
vision and NLP involves finetuning a foundation model on a selection of
relevant tasks, before its adaptation to a target task with limited labeled
samples. In this paper, we study the theoretical justification of this
multitask finetuning approach. Our theoretical analysis reveals that with a
diverse set of related tasks, this multitask finetuning leads to reduced error
in the target task, in comparison to directly adapting the same pretrained
model. We quantify the relationship between finetuning tasks and target tasks
by diversity and consistency metrics, and further propose a practical task
selection algorithm. We substantiate our theoretical claims with extensive
empirical evidence. Further, we present results affirming our task selection
algorithm adeptly chooses related finetuning tasks, providing advantages to the
model performance on target tasks. We believe our study shed new light on the
effective adaptation of foundation models to new tasks that lack abundant
labels. Our code is available at
https://github.com/OliverXUZY/Foudation-Model_Multitask.
|
[
-0.46516698598861694,
-0.5217440724372864,
0.32274624705314636,
0.21537186205387115,
-0.1389935463666916,
-0.4029202461242676,
-0.23090927302837372,
-0.5828060507774353,
-0.082298643887043,
0.4537947177886963,
-0.8432347774505615,
-0.2583327889442444,
-0.717381477355957,
0.0558745414018631,
-0.465274453163147,
1.3731728792190552,
-0.0019857410807162523,
-0.28541871905326843,
-0.16562743484973907,
-0.2974162995815277,
-0.6924609541893005,
0.08016354590654373,
-0.5356118679046631,
-0.5218715071678162,
0.40722841024398804,
0.6217103004455566,
0.32973289489746094,
0.46023136377334595,
0.8044981956481934,
0.2056853324174881,
0.1875174194574356,
0.046475399285554886,
-0.8590480089187622,
0.0312415212392807,
-0.16073840856552124,
-0.8319498896598816,
-0.14065666496753693,
-0.018329469487071037,
0.5090411305427551,
0.7972908020019531,
0.2680585980415344,
0.2005670815706253,
0.7209201455116272,
0.8912321329116821,
-1.1208834648132324,
0.17657002806663513,
-0.6518058776855469,
0.20068101584911346,
-0.2795989513397217,
0.019166981801390648,
-0.31647881865501404,
0.4339897036552429,
0.1955714076757431,
-0.983005166053772,
0.4039372205734253,
-0.30038517713546753,
0.5332480072975159,
0.7337954044342041,
-0.10439552366733551,
0.1006559506058693,
-0.8119342923164368,
0.8273582458496094,
-0.29897594451904297,
0.4748052954673767,
0.37883976101875305,
0.4587254524230957,
0.03475678712129593,
-0.4537014067173004,
-0.212832972407341,
-0.21647977828979492,
0.1610192507505417,
0.2938976585865021,
-0.20732825994491577,
0.20120234787464142,
0.30438879132270813,
0.29049527645111084,
-0.20873034000396729,
0.04470561444759369,
-0.0368824377655983,
-0.007781843654811382,
0.16358265280723572,
0.09883041679859161,
-0.15002146363258362,
-0.12144739180803299,
-0.4608713686466217,
-0.15048669278621674,
-0.39118337631225586,
0.39732077717781067,
-0.09353823214769363,
0.5468785762786865,
-0.411869615316391,
0.4842212200164795,
-0.7320368885993958,
0.9386065602302551,
0.44696807861328125,
-0.2512798607349396,
0.017136121168732643,
-0.6114519238471985,
-0.35181212425231934,
-0.20238758623600006,
0.37832942605018616,
0.3749217689037323,
0.20722897350788116,
-0.12803347408771515,
-0.0327802337706089,
0.27331048250198364,
0.4419199228286743,
-0.7324110269546509,
-0.39255237579345703,
0.2200128138065338,
-0.33358240127563477,
-0.15954247117042542,
-0.09129559993743896,
-0.4604053795337677,
-0.4467592239379883,
-0.3133541941642761,
0.5017034411430359,
-0.4026705026626587,
-0.06826858222484589,
0.08776110410690308,
-0.0877704992890358,
0.01715787500143051,
0.6391346454620361,
-0.9332374930381775,
0.36284998059272766,
0.8039413690567017,
0.9203134179115295,
-0.48190227150917053,
-0.587732195854187,
-0.726112961769104,
0.007016817573457956,
-0.32694560289382935,
0.7735975980758667,
-0.1858346164226532,
0.019846297800540924,
-0.3707374930381775,
-0.013026480562984943,
-0.20643310248851776,
-0.300415962934494,
0.14726975560188293,
-0.1715547740459442,
-0.5370217561721802,
-0.18372198939323425,
-0.1515181064605713,
-0.2405080795288086,
0.42321497201919556,
-0.9063593745231628,
0.5785385370254517,
0.14371441304683685,
-0.6013268828392029,
0.6244573593139648,
-0.8084532022476196,
-0.475879430770874,
-0.16314925253391266,
-0.00831797905266285,
-0.2653310298919678,
0.26139751076698303,
-0.0037520502228289843,
0.894382655620575,
-0.18103784322738647,
0.01293990295380354,
-0.5426636338233948,
-0.24774372577667236,
-0.009501320309937,
-0.29583877325057983,
0.8743516802787781,
0.1489475667476654,
-0.3855513334274292,
0.1448960304260254,
-0.6447206139564514,
-0.11897566169500351,
-0.18291683495044708,
-0.46019378304481506,
-0.21063591539859772,
-0.2102610319852829,
0.19375045597553253,
0.11138244718313217,
-0.11669419705867767,
-0.32997941970825195,
0.07769935578107834,
-0.457039475440979,
0.13477696478366852,
0.5555849075317383,
-0.2114834040403366,
0.7700650095939636,
-0.7311305403709412,
0.40445926785469055,
-0.12482485920190811,
-0.05612814053893089,
-0.030451679602265358,
-0.42756518721580505,
-0.7600221633911133,
-0.394630491733551,
0.398233026266098,
0.7062969207763672,
-0.5966495871543884,
-0.06972280144691467,
-0.3255959153175354,
-0.4432019293308258,
-0.39568567276000977,
0.3729252517223358,
0.5145489573478699,
0.30500367283821106,
0.43587934970855713,
-0.526127278804779,
-0.4299198389053345,
-0.7122524976730347,
-0.24104639887809753,
0.4248810112476349,
0.08880078047513962,
0.31944790482521057,
0.7330533266067505,
-0.0486409068107605,
0.9432284235954285,
-0.4861844778060913,
-0.7486140727996826,
-0.06301373988389969,
0.09964299201965332,
0.09414547681808472,
0.838323175907135,
1.0389035940170288,
-0.7750517129898071,
-0.5240073204040527,
0.12050774693489075,
-0.5672236084938049,
0.3286811113357544,
-0.5392292737960815,
-0.20985963940620422,
-0.4178856611251831,
0.13708612322807312,
-0.7645732164382935,
0.3337128162384033,
0.6162494421005249,
-0.031329747289419174,
0.5364683270454407,
0.26432839035987854,
0.16264930367469788,
-1.0377414226531982,
0.09215234965085983,
0.2499794363975525,
-0.39015066623687744,
-0.7351757287979126,
0.37326309084892273,
-0.18441590666770935,
-0.11447403579950333,
-0.5960797071456909,
0.6927487850189209,
-0.3352336883544922,
-0.1922706961631775,
-0.4723048508167267,
-0.22987425327301025,
0.01514373254030943,
0.580333411693573,
-0.2005845010280609,
0.4207688570022583,
0.7839184999465942,
-0.8321927189826965,
0.3718990385532379,
0.45540904998779297,
-0.33465576171875,
0.8670870661735535,
-0.23164686560630798,
0.06737411767244339,
-0.06804656982421875,
0.18012087047100067,
-0.9075433015823364,
-0.34892702102661133,
0.4229400157928467,
-0.20212313532829285,
0.26749587059020996,
-0.38304686546325684,
-0.04556199908256531,
-0.16103686392307281,
-0.1941135972738266,
0.4766855835914612,
0.06322359293699265,
-0.3615771234035492,
0.6033412218093872,
0.15174993872642517,
-0.04057471454143524,
-0.590630054473877,
-0.993708610534668,
-0.2981151342391968,
-0.19630122184753418,
-0.4704446494579315,
0.615740954875946,
-0.2628333866596222,
-0.08303527534008026,
-0.01493774726986885,
-0.5826724171638489,
-0.4520285725593567,
0.6366558074951172,
0.4858627915382385,
-0.10600870847702026,
-0.5513012409210205,
-0.06509952992200851,
0.0011651774402707815,
-0.20941957831382751,
-0.43834570050239563,
-0.3074457049369812,
0.020271725952625275,
-0.1369166225194931,
-0.3949805796146393,
-0.5250458121299744,
0.27601680159568787,
0.47815510630607605,
-0.25582075119018555,
0.536866307258606,
0.7583014369010925,
-0.7013012766838074,
-0.1960083395242691,
-0.4349227845668793,
-0.3986251652240753,
-0.3849571645259857,
0.544549822807312,
-0.7583662271499634,
-0.8421931266784668,
0.36125317215919495,
-0.2672509253025055,
0.33577191829681396,
0.5371109843254089,
0.4224650263786316,
-0.2194271832704544,
0.40788865089416504,
1.1160231828689575,
0.0842084214091301,
0.7384665012359619,
-0.5017781853675842,
-0.2078668177127838,
-0.7997193336486816,
0.23449212312698364,
-0.4995344579219818,
-0.6259123086929321,
-0.29873257875442505,
-0.28051528334617615,
0.17549747228622437,
0.4480995833873749,
0.18063384294509888,
0.32492130994796753,
-0.5114676356315613,
0.5478951930999756,
0.6614255905151367,
0.44867515563964844,
0.1201910600066185,
0.03649573400616646,
0.21698573231697083,
0.11129378527402878,
-0.8567066788673401,
-0.044942181557416916,
1.2517714500427246,
-0.05186490714550018,
0.40151652693748474,
0.004723642021417618,
0.7838069200515747,
0.11152521520853043,
0.3088136315345764,
-0.9153844118118286,
0.12604665756225586,
-0.7140842080116272,
-0.8442115783691406,
-0.4764399826526642,
0.019253868609666824,
-0.9011815786361694,
0.3026975691318512,
-0.7482354640960693,
-0.7346450090408325,
0.45052358508110046,
0.503682553768158,
-1.1417087316513062,
-0.008818663656711578,
-0.6759593486785889,
1.342999815940857,
-0.01073630154132843,
-0.4491141736507416,
-0.36173057556152344,
-0.6007136106491089,
0.4168582856655121,
-0.39251333475112915,
0.1658020317554474,
-0.36869049072265625,
0.44096922874450684,
0.974878191947937,
0.10657201707363129,
1.1733318567276,
-0.24854394793510437,
0.3180293142795563,
0.35161179304122925,
0.0687522441148758,
0.5160630941390991,
-0.11229025572538376,
-0.10965630412101746,
-0.072288878262043,
0.2932392656803131,
-0.5483718514442444,
-0.3837142884731293,
0.6394376754760742,
-0.5734595656394958,
-0.5278301239013672,
-0.09129438549280167,
-0.8555835485458374,
-0.23506085574626923,
0.5344014763832092,
0.17260822653770447,
0.2574513256549835,
-0.17554280161857605,
0.6555708050727844,
0.25220251083374023,
0.38578927516937256,
0.3531319499015808,
0.014049175195395947,
0.3230181336402893,
0.08660849183797836,
0.7995681166648865,
0.07829239964485168,
0.3111754059791565,
0.41607865691185,
0.24990887939929962,
0.29143181443214417,
-0.9185490012168884,
-0.2928273677825928,
-0.19027583301067352,
-0.8775612711906433,
-0.3388347327709198,
-0.5654117465019226,
0.16497273743152618,
-0.21113663911819458,
-0.3360823094844818,
-0.5271638631820679,
-0.37318187952041626,
-0.5820062160491943,
0.13318556547164917,
0.3554174602031708,
0.4181552231311798,
-0.0245797298848629,
0.6038639545440674,
-0.663860559463501,
0.8308307528495789,
0.5648342967033386,
0.24535973370075226,
-0.16700270771980286,
-0.3520493805408478,
-0.3640844225883484,
0.3281206786632538,
-0.34516584873199463,
-0.8193579316139221,
-0.30197441577911377,
0.6317211985588074,
0.621624231338501,
0.25513094663619995,
0.17030523717403412,
0.8676022291183472,
-0.5512493252754211,
0.29360052943229675,
0.31371957063674927,
-0.7712770700454712,
0.35916537046432495,
-0.3300263285636902,
0.43734011054039,
0.9221199154853821,
0.21605032682418823,
-0.3061419427394867,
-0.028249921277165413,
-0.3345954120159149,
-0.4302627742290497,
0.7629296779632568,
0.14990369975566864,
0.07154656946659088,
0.46502333879470825,
0.39753830432891846,
0.5250688791275024,
0.25597187876701355,
-0.8618653416633606,
-0.06634987890720367,
-0.4804767072200775,
-0.30392777919769287,
-0.2466639280319214,
0.014895865693688393,
-0.3398738205432892,
-0.029370568692684174,
0.393964022397995,
-0.6095042824745178,
0.2337741106748581,
-0.06923708319664001,
-0.5288373231887817,
-0.059924036264419556,
0.31587374210357666,
0.6586505174636841,
0.5246211290359497,
0.12942087650299072,
-0.033941734582185745,
0.2514907121658325,
-0.37292805314064026,
0.03856981545686722,
0.44640442728996277,
-0.20541000366210938,
-0.21213966608047485,
0.5248051881790161,
1.1165337562561035,
0.4434058368206024,
-0.1913139820098877,
0.5092958807945251,
0.6013500690460205,
-0.2239684760570526,
0.2858981490135193,
0.37483400106430054,
-0.13188068568706512,
0.6897768378257751,
0.433086633682251,
0.8731865882873535,
0.21224668622016907,
-0.3251833915710449,
0.3802412450313568,
0.5851308703422546,
-0.36114880442619324,
-0.16385971009731293,
0.600959837436676,
0.2956221401691437,
-0.08589906245470047,
0.12013775110244751,
-0.16866977512836456,
-0.05842430889606476,
0.799106240272522,
0.40901169180870056,
0.7447975873947144,
-0.04474005475640297,
0.15240053832530975,
0.09728272259235382,
0.24897398054599762,
-0.44029492139816284,
-0.1533413976430893,
-0.10918047279119492,
-0.9328288435935974,
-0.6608405113220215,
-0.6378846764564514,
-0.16911126673221588,
0.029485013335943222,
-0.4850205183029175,
0.22621269524097443,
-0.6140989661216736,
-0.20554916560649872,
0.32853642106056213,
-0.18173560500144958,
-1.1134188175201416,
0.41547536849975586,
0.16229838132858276,
0.5008116364479065,
-0.9792664647102356,
0.6000834703445435,
0.6734388470649719,
-0.10347963869571686,
-0.476651668548584,
-0.04922812059521675,
0.17602120339870453,
-0.5875536203384399,
0.43131187558174133,
0.3540506958961487,
-0.16612233221530914,
0.4490273594856262,
-0.2749521732330322,
-1.0048049688339233,
0.973449170589447,
0.5907795429229736,
-0.6973390579223633,
-0.19006472826004028,
-0.22203251719474792,
0.11021030694246292,
-0.43369925022125244,
-0.3186357319355011,
0.3736608922481537,
0.34815701842308044,
-0.10353198647499084,
-1.174657940864563,
-0.030886074528098106,
0.04576573893427849,
-0.23988637328147888,
0.07712731510400772,
-0.3624955713748932,
0.8460860252380371,
-0.45295464992523193,
-0.024456361308693886,
0.2436172068119049,
0.5169154405593872,
0.2554117739200592,
0.3061707019805908,
0.6280829906463623,
0.246028870344162,
0.5533037781715393,
-0.17166373133659363,
0.9981611371040344,
-0.2074914425611496,
0.4963447153568268,
1.1062793731689453,
0.049780163913965225,
0.6967364549636841,
0.5125254988670349,
-0.3014216721057892,
0.06735095381736755,
0.5806347131729126,
-0.23830321431159973,
0.918289303779602,
-0.05900288373231888,
0.1447121948003769,
-0.39038291573524475,
-0.05987102538347244,
-0.21953250467777252,
0.7660227417945862,
0.14601951837539673,
0.09692437201738358,
-0.2608811855316162,
0.6531875133514404,
-0.5179211497306824,
-0.29757824540138245,
-0.5438024401664734,
0.6262695789337158,
0.1498004049062729,
-0.6975252032279968,
0.7082111239433289,
-0.07092860341072083,
0.8844141364097595,
-0.42209166288375854,
-0.10973596572875977,
0.1386941373348236,
0.23961742222309113,
-0.42519837617874146,
-0.5076056122779846,
0.3498813807964325,
-0.2617471516132355,
-0.43713417649269104,
-0.27979496121406555,
0.8868567943572998,
-0.19034519791603088,
-0.38258805871009827,
-0.029521746560931206,
0.5512969493865967,
0.07528771460056305,
-0.5233697295188904,
-0.9582217335700989,
-0.09878885746002197,
0.05703553557395935,
-0.10478368401527405,
0.289340615272522,
0.1833754926919937,
-0.1270739585161209,
0.48114997148513794,
0.7098894715309143,
-0.13210251927375793,
0.18456017971038818,
-0.3121904730796814,
0.4724195897579193,
-0.30287420749664307,
-0.7696948647499084,
-0.708503246307373,
0.7389377951622009,
0.4498852491378784,
-0.481946736574173,
0.38712137937545776,
0.20313754677772522,
1.0292106866836548,
-0.3786866068840027,
0.6479706168174744,
-0.02588597685098648,
0.058775678277015686,
-0.7593988180160522,
0.5959396958351135,
-0.6654446125030518,
-0.311593234539032,
-0.6288134455680847,
-1.0255380868911743,
-0.5281299352645874,
0.8608725070953369,
-0.17564038932323456,
0.04464904963970184,
0.8276483416557312,
0.3477930426597595,
-0.5130960941314697,
-0.20977908372879028,
0.33817461133003235,
0.012299913913011551,
-0.24737943708896637,
0.8037744164466858,
0.30248168110847473,
-0.3153529465198517,
0.6601585149765015,
-0.6851100325584412,
-0.2874305546283722,
-0.4460926651954651,
-0.8341161012649536,
-0.7965253591537476,
-0.49488770961761475,
-0.5138270854949951,
-0.018200865015387535,
0.17845450341701508,
0.6317276358604431,
1.1225537061691284,
-1.0835741758346558,
-0.08154994994401932,
-0.1662154197692871,
-0.019733702763915062,
-0.8469552993774414,
-0.11306647211313248,
0.1224827766418457,
-0.09924984723329544,
-0.5671454071998596,
0.45402753353118896,
0.09358818084001541,
0.10752518475055695,
0.24851886928081512,
0.009061767719686031,
-0.303192675113678,
-0.5782150626182556,
0.5626790523529053,
0.412358820438385,
-0.9476855397224426,
-0.39203009009361267,
-0.13528122007846832,
0.05547051131725311,
0.2216203361749649,
0.6869516372680664,
-0.7119930982589722,
0.34457775950431824,
0.2305629551410675,
1.2573248147964478,
0.6794285774230957,
-0.17601019144058228,
0.14719930291175842,
-0.8506819009780884,
0.475198358297348,
0.13915909826755524,
0.2603195309638977,
0.2955993711948395,
-0.34943172335624695,
0.4629862904548645,
0.3009844124317169,
-0.006448755972087383,
-0.714699387550354,
0.47792279720306396,
-0.9572649002075195,
-0.30580997467041016,
0.9227646589279175,
-0.23410850763320923,
-0.09912505000829697,
-0.016243668273091316,
-0.08711989223957062,
0.33871644735336304,
-0.12306870520114899,
0.56671541929245,
0.896905779838562,
-0.2803412973880768,
-0.2865511178970337,
-0.7479727268218994,
0.6126459836959839,
0.7791529297828674,
-0.8349793553352356,
-0.093571238219738,
0.4267027974128723,
0.31056445837020874,
0.523350179195404,
0.6350247859954834,
0.7494387626647949,
0.8683509826660156,
-0.016985565423965454,
-0.13626310229301453,
-0.10234455019235611,
-0.6610491871833801,
-0.2894609570503235,
0.37765994668006897,
0.26219233870506287,
-0.5393920540809631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15012v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15012v1
|
Ar-Spider: Text-to-SQL in Arabic
| 2024-02-22T23:11:17 | 2024-02-22T23:11:17 |
Saleh Almohaimeed, Saad Almohaimeed, Mansour Al Ghanim, Liqiang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In Natural Language Processing (NLP), one of the most important tasks is
text-to-SQL semantic parsing, which focuses on enabling users to interact with
the database in a more natural manner. In recent years, text-to-SQL has made
significant progress, but most were English-centric. In this paper, we
introduce Ar-Spider 1, the first Arabic cross-domain text-to-SQL dataset. Due
to the unique nature of the language, two major challenges have been
encountered, namely schema linguistic and SQL structural challenges. In order
to handle these issues and conduct the experiments, we adopt two baseline
models LGESQL [4] and S2SQL [12], both of which are tested with two
cross-lingual models to alleviate the effects of schema linguistic and SQL
structure linking challenges. The baselines demonstrate decent single-language
performance on our Arabic text-to-SQL dataset, Ar-Spider, achieving 62.48% for
S2SQL and 65.57% for LGESQL, only 8.79% below the highest results achieved by
the baselines when trained in English dataset. To achieve better performance on
Arabic text-to-SQL, we propose the context similarity relationship (CSR)
approach, which results in a significant increase in the overall performance of
about 1.52% for S2SQL and 1.06% for LGESQL and closes the gap between Arabic
and English languages to 7.73%.
|
[
-0.4714365005493164,
-0.6240281462669373,
0.28540265560150146,
0.03110816702246666,
-0.505184531211853,
0.1586691290140152,
0.2068360596895218,
-0.6215936541557312,
0.28810471296310425,
0.4400676190853119,
-0.4902251064777374,
-0.6690873503684998,
-0.7760542035102844,
0.4549810588359833,
-0.6826977133750916,
1.2495191097259521,
0.08132866024971008,
0.035431016236543655,
0.05927036330103874,
-0.5101162791252136,
-0.028152354061603546,
-0.718198835849762,
-0.600034236907959,
0.1037941426038742,
0.5671887993812561,
0.3885117173194885,
0.987000048160553,
0.8063185214996338,
0.3549247682094574,
0.1484782099723816,
-0.14088506996631622,
0.13680414855480194,
0.007390245795249939,
0.2610076367855072,
-0.7055871486663818,
-0.2536005973815918,
-0.18108691275119781,
-0.6033286452293396,
0.743643581867218,
0.9045807719230652,
0.006279557477682829,
0.22174985706806183,
-0.085255928337574,
1.2827407121658325,
-0.8211866617202759,
-0.2640092372894287,
-0.655698299407959,
0.022930368781089783,
-0.4227907657623291,
-0.12781855463981628,
-0.22495825588703156,
-0.094598188996315,
0.11284566670656204,
-0.17261144518852234,
0.07719418406486511,
0.2904922366142273,
0.9114660620689392,
0.3887544870376587,
-0.9803698658943176,
-0.4916437268257141,
-0.5858003497123718,
0.4909322261810303,
-0.4408036768436432,
0.5707193613052368,
0.5306485295295715,
0.34709522128105164,
-0.30915606021881104,
-0.545745313167572,
-0.673218309879303,
-0.17794901132583618,
-0.20797941088676453,
-0.4102679193019867,
-0.20921669900417328,
-0.3967606723308563,
-0.17143841087818146,
0.2811349332332611,
-0.7444374561309814,
-0.13110347092151642,
0.08303244411945343,
0.06201457977294922,
0.47981733083724976,
0.07484951615333557,
0.5232508182525635,
-0.07674125581979752,
-0.5268546938896179,
0.023519597947597504,
-0.9228881001472473,
0.08619915693998337,
0.16062189638614655,
0.6733826398849487,
-0.0800749659538269,
0.9458947777748108,
-0.36709001660346985,
0.6218894124031067,
-0.11904751509428024,
0.07676886767148972,
-0.09286635369062424,
-0.4314018189907074,
0.07106886804103851,
0.3508142828941345,
0.5267101526260376,
0.05240916088223457,
0.22102202475070953,
-0.4720279574394226,
0.0820392519235611,
0.16852718591690063,
0.13317403197288513,
-0.7063595056533813,
0.07037326693534851,
0.38266557455062866,
-0.4275112450122833,
0.08846963196992874,
-0.30029404163360596,
-0.7817115187644958,
-0.5683826804161072,
-0.1254926472902298,
0.252890408039093,
-0.5555020570755005,
-0.2773190140724182,
-0.2128874659538269,
0.2135343700647354,
0.4746377766132355,
0.0050738099962472916,
-0.7489449977874756,
0.7857142090797424,
0.5659100413322449,
0.9439840316772461,
-0.6702512502670288,
-0.23490746319293976,
-0.3451946973800659,
0.4488346576690674,
-0.35414230823516846,
0.9971289038658142,
-0.46491560339927673,
-0.2843266725540161,
0.07378524541854858,
-0.19068849086761475,
0.04622408375144005,
-0.38815146684646606,
0.6611499786376953,
-0.5801421999931335,
0.0029522390104830265,
-0.18712468445301056,
-0.5063114762306213,
-0.12895582616329193,
0.44733551144599915,
-0.7822747230529785,
1.0327531099319458,
0.19973117113113403,
-0.919912576675415,
0.43033567070961,
-0.4934607148170471,
-0.8558539152145386,
-0.04051711782813072,
-0.36510995030403137,
-0.43125882744789124,
-0.23410330712795258,
0.3421172499656677,
0.11731725931167603,
-0.5998450517654419,
-0.1731039434671402,
0.08448965102434158,
-0.3302479386329651,
0.06755594909191132,
0.05584114044904709,
0.5571206212043762,
0.29141074419021606,
-0.4983283579349518,
-0.077640101313591,
-0.9630311727523804,
0.18904897570610046,
0.10169549286365509,
-0.17258481681346893,
-0.34120452404022217,
0.4663054943084717,
0.28013479709625244,
0.23981808125972748,
0.2503611147403717,
-0.4601249694824219,
0.1818380504846573,
-0.8424325585365295,
0.03961719572544098,
0.3169994354248047,
-0.09180457144975662,
0.4599534869194031,
-0.11709795147180557,
0.4854174554347992,
0.032184869050979614,
-0.44383367896080017,
0.08140096813440323,
-0.1710747480392456,
-0.8775326609611511,
-0.27294132113456726,
0.2916587293148041,
0.75755774974823,
-0.8170010447502136,
0.44576188921928406,
-0.389999657869339,
-0.618373453617096,
-0.23358386754989624,
-0.08092701435089111,
0.5149258971214294,
0.32494670152664185,
0.5363574624061584,
-0.3607688844203949,
-0.4917689263820648,
-1.1093480587005615,
-0.818420946598053,
-0.055325478315353394,
0.09372594207525253,
0.37820369005203247,
0.6381241679191589,
-0.2212386131286621,
1.052198886871338,
-0.2511880099773407,
-0.6652513146400452,
-0.37524351477622986,
-0.077142633497715,
0.17304006218910217,
0.5639017820358276,
0.5632501840591431,
-0.8017340898513794,
-0.8361835479736328,
0.3523402214050293,
-0.39765846729278564,
0.17876504361629486,
0.3824092149734497,
-0.07618485391139984,
1.1005750894546509,
0.10793767124414444,
-0.6515050530433655,
0.8140862584114075,
0.5167854428291321,
-0.8310943245887756,
0.47104305028915405,
0.22639432549476624,
0.39517173171043396,
-1.4609516859054565,
0.3008667826652527,
-0.10653745383024216,
-0.1737194061279297,
-0.5390713810920715,
0.19700941443443298,
-0.27181440591812134,
-0.2074667364358902,
-0.5162598490715027,
0.602188766002655,
-0.3648192882537842,
-0.3486606478691101,
-0.26851680874824524,
-0.17096534371376038,
-0.16849647462368011,
0.42500004172325134,
0.17238172888755798,
1.3715041875839233,
0.6269078254699707,
-0.7579470276832581,
-0.09239308536052704,
0.5047531127929688,
-0.495017945766449,
0.3310757875442505,
-0.6970127820968628,
0.2829289436340332,
0.09724186360836029,
0.19695955514907837,
-1.0180038213729858,
-0.06489507853984833,
0.3003089129924774,
-0.68501216173172,
-0.062369100749492645,
-0.33591729402542114,
-0.6214991807937622,
0.32586878538131714,
-0.08412132412195206,
0.5276288390159607,
0.14500276744365692,
-0.5390744805335999,
0.932849645614624,
0.4296374022960663,
-0.34981879591941833,
-0.9121212363243103,
-0.6877402067184448,
0.397976815700531,
-0.11506801098585129,
-0.6436180472373962,
0.512623131275177,
0.648910403251648,
-0.21692082285881042,
0.09672020375728607,
-0.3582199811935425,
-0.4284155070781708,
-0.19585207104682922,
0.16460020840168,
0.05290287360548973,
-0.06748690456151962,
0.10202793776988983,
0.20922814309597015,
-0.12027519941329956,
0.03387436270713806,
0.05742748826742172,
0.7272140979766846,
-0.07717008888721466,
-0.28195348381996155,
-0.3086939752101898,
0.9484811425209045,
0.2354804426431656,
-0.37563860416412354,
1.333526611328125,
0.18879179656505585,
-0.3983079493045807,
-0.13526619970798492,
-0.18682850897312164,
0.05863843858242035,
-0.3999072313308716,
0.6045337319374084,
-0.789888858795166,
-0.7671369910240173,
0.41179195046424866,
-0.2919410765171051,
-0.06490255147218704,
0.6036478877067566,
0.3889753520488739,
-0.10881119221448898,
1.433995246887207,
0.8916077613830566,
-0.21390452980995178,
0.04305383190512657,
-0.015255154110491276,
0.40477827191352844,
-0.39717239141464233,
-0.2133495956659317,
-1.1515047550201416,
0.05454196408390999,
-0.5796591639518738,
-0.17538824677467346,
0.4087678790092468,
0.07978439331054688,
-0.573738157749176,
0.5597360730171204,
-0.4922560751438141,
0.47453638911247253,
0.09451945871114731,
-0.06519456207752228,
0.27880120277404785,
0.5360310077667236,
-0.14263726770877838,
-0.09155752509832382,
-0.6019885540008545,
-0.7154783010482788,
0.7293527722358704,
-0.039035748690366745,
0.4992271661758423,
0.7755163908004761,
0.46989837288856506,
0.6469403505325317,
-0.257966548204422,
-0.5521494150161743,
0.6254023909568787,
-0.18507520854473114,
-0.5698969960212708,
-0.12913453578948975,
-0.1477990597486496,
-1.1571952104568481,
0.2522040903568268,
-0.3084723949432373,
-0.811672568321228,
-0.07586181908845901,
-0.02935604937374592,
0.27713310718536377,
0.17513930797576904,
-0.47734367847442627,
0.6941269040107727,
-0.0724387839436531,
-0.5997668504714966,
-0.28787562251091003,
-0.820169985294342,
-0.0423826165497303,
0.1471172571182251,
0.20045194029808044,
-0.0568835586309433,
-0.44902974367141724,
0.6452487707138062,
-0.6502100825309753,
0.34672993421554565,
0.17049872875213623,
-0.07574005424976349,
0.1567084789276123,
0.43213018774986267,
0.6767980456352234,
-0.11704783886671066,
-0.33770519495010376,
0.2744840383529663,
0.46919623017311096,
-0.6778795123100281,
-0.5658782124519348,
0.5644676089286804,
-0.77767014503479,
-0.45614704489707947,
-1.1329172849655151,
-0.5089229345321655,
-0.3713811933994293,
0.06617502123117447,
0.05578961968421936,
0.1607692837715149,
-0.11542295664548874,
0.19689659774303436,
0.259386271238327,
-0.11546013504266739,
0.17980393767356873,
0.6559145450592041,
-0.3621065020561218,
-0.16833162307739258,
0.5588653087615967,
-0.1009851023554802,
-0.022871453315019608,
0.3342457413673401,
-0.2056180238723755,
-0.5987605452537537,
-0.4513852596282959,
-0.865050733089447,
-0.06305179744958878,
-0.68403559923172,
-0.19277922809123993,
-0.6857907176017761,
-0.18993644416332245,
-0.41027992963790894,
-0.07112764567136765,
-0.2801503837108612,
-0.5501676201820374,
-0.04704102873802185,
0.35859841108322144,
0.6279061436653137,
0.44043388962745667,
0.4130654036998749,
0.17492161691188812,
-0.7879060506820679,
0.31804561614990234,
-0.22071537375450134,
0.464968740940094,
-0.1083182841539383,
-0.5491088032722473,
-0.2660539746284485,
-0.10766017436981201,
0.03387477621436119,
-1.1337000131607056,
0.453691691160202,
0.44296348094940186,
0.15950192511081696,
0.006304084323346615,
0.09969396889209747,
0.6806035041809082,
-0.7345658540725708,
0.9675591588020325,
-0.10677922517061234,
-1.0766371488571167,
0.8158817887306213,
-0.18343114852905273,
0.18809011578559875,
0.7490068674087524,
0.8829357028007507,
-0.45514753460884094,
0.047460831701755524,
-0.1508023887872696,
-1.0423476696014404,
0.657008171081543,
0.5675906538963318,
-0.17501620948314667,
-0.008685261011123657,
0.4426606595516205,
0.16740162670612335,
0.07725390791893005,
-0.7372894287109375,
-0.6389492750167847,
0.10121124982833862,
-0.232179194688797,
0.003442743793129921,
-0.25788554549217224,
0.04158763960003853,
-0.36708781123161316,
0.6850332617759705,
-0.05185937136411667,
0.059969596564769745,
0.26454877853393555,
-0.21116621792316437,
0.10141697525978088,
0.6179418563842773,
0.2914508879184723,
0.8554708361625671,
-0.09759454429149628,
0.21999898552894592,
0.3668021261692047,
-0.40546101331710815,
0.19365417957305908,
0.202616885304451,
-0.042017001658678055,
0.016605408862233162,
0.32776570320129395,
0.40663665533065796,
-0.32740336656570435,
-0.975476086139679,
0.2290746420621872,
0.12810038030147552,
0.21178290247917175,
-0.4344172477722168,
-0.11743210256099701,
-0.10747946053743362,
0.12902161478996277,
0.6809875965118408,
-0.10469295084476471,
0.5285341739654541,
-0.7322134375572205,
0.3164500892162323,
0.5641505122184753,
-0.296029269695282,
0.10845180600881577,
0.46681058406829834,
0.0955839678645134,
-0.6005328893661499,
0.2882840931415558,
-0.1414118856191635,
-0.7880403399467468,
0.64584881067276,
0.798285961151123,
0.5420481562614441,
-0.06313376128673553,
-0.05098725110292435,
0.3540346026420593,
0.20597988367080688,
0.3569331467151642,
0.5133408308029175,
-0.26318255066871643,
-0.5132600665092468,
-0.43881794810295105,
-0.613739550113678,
-0.6800242066383362,
-0.3518087863922119,
-0.581587016582489,
0.24855463206768036,
-0.3125283122062683,
0.14165891706943512,
-0.0484110452234745,
0.4144560694694519,
-0.26166170835494995,
0.3278966248035431,
-0.2768995463848114,
1.0294392108917236,
-0.6578510999679565,
1.1151466369628906,
0.945787787437439,
-0.4657047390937805,
-0.6575528979301453,
-0.17311781644821167,
-0.08025424927473068,
-0.579345703125,
0.6112579703330994,
0.20875634253025055,
-0.5477578639984131,
0.09361907839775085,
-0.385231077671051,
-1.0727777481079102,
0.7761557102203369,
0.1830495148897171,
-0.3724968433380127,
0.22300314903259277,
0.7967397570610046,
0.5688827633857727,
-0.5312283635139465,
-0.03402771055698395,
0.7051198482513428,
0.14506477117538452,
-0.02593770995736122,
-0.6495909094810486,
0.11379837989807129,
-0.49503466486930847,
-0.025143977254629135,
0.6333789825439453,
-0.3201446235179901,
0.8152107000350952,
0.02116682194173336,
-0.4731718599796295,
0.39551281929016113,
0.7941526174545288,
0.5228490233421326,
0.4434875249862671,
0.5729288458824158,
0.6749595403671265,
0.1681186705827713,
0.04125995934009552,
1.1589102745056152,
-0.5793289542198181,
0.05570516362786293,
1.246448278427124,
-0.761688768863678,
1.2255851030349731,
0.8139030337333679,
-0.5349224805831909,
0.89997798204422,
0.3427218794822693,
0.3319576680660248,
0.562675952911377,
0.13491563498973846,
-0.575208842754364,
0.009681052528321743,
-0.47226405143737793,
-0.698615550994873,
0.46971291303634644,
0.3022511899471283,
-0.15942545235157013,
-0.5121959447860718,
-0.2504864037036896,
-0.056533083319664,
0.6842703223228455,
-0.16439473628997803,
0.7641163468360901,
-0.24343229830265045,
-0.48966941237449646,
0.4708206355571747,
0.2655807435512543,
0.48222747445106506,
-0.7272008657455444,
-0.30111396312713623,
-0.14137208461761475,
0.10872185230255127,
-0.22046299278736115,
-0.7506514191627502,
0.7451924085617065,
0.2943034768104553,
-0.3108310401439667,
0.2921416461467743,
0.8517655730247498,
-0.33162885904312134,
-0.4766724109649658,
0.25129762291908264,
0.4759317934513092,
0.42814934253692627,
-0.2522523105144501,
-0.6505457162857056,
0.14064522087574005,
-0.20172105729579926,
-0.07172966003417969,
0.49279332160949707,
0.1774347573518753,
-0.07358244806528091,
0.7929288148880005,
0.6006130576133728,
0.0036530604120343924,
-0.048000842332839966,
-0.277204304933548,
0.7784154415130615,
-0.9187019467353821,
-0.5581666231155396,
-0.8574516177177429,
0.26255613565444946,
-0.05971091613173485,
-0.35734742879867554,
0.7707156538963318,
0.9384187459945679,
0.4977370798587799,
0.1263360232114792,
0.454904168844223,
-0.4087441563606262,
1.0403602123260498,
-0.4027366638183594,
0.9339490532875061,
-0.739467203617096,
0.1403588205575943,
-0.07896580547094345,
-1.0207583904266357,
-0.1393624246120453,
0.4928961992263794,
0.1619737446308136,
-0.031952086836099625,
0.7397334575653076,
0.8819351196289062,
0.26697054505348206,
-0.05561193823814392,
-0.034016720950603485,
-0.12963756918907166,
0.05679837986826897,
0.6370818018913269,
0.5839663147926331,
-0.7577930688858032,
0.6212483048439026,
-0.1337815225124359,
0.13427484035491943,
0.057094018906354904,
-0.7404534816741943,
-0.9743222594261169,
-0.8287060856819153,
-0.12283416092395782,
-0.6795879602432251,
0.4143815338611603,
1.0665743350982666,
0.4396776854991913,
-1.042872428894043,
-0.3473328649997711,
-0.19905269145965576,
0.04415791109204292,
-0.21995586156845093,
-0.14745749533176422,
0.9010922312736511,
-0.1748940795660019,
-0.5460376739501953,
0.37112271785736084,
0.22489526867866516,
-0.11978641897439957,
0.020734792575240135,
-0.041133537888526917,
-0.8496555089950562,
0.19106392562389374,
0.7398433089256287,
0.4852084517478943,
-0.7044579982757568,
-0.1994997262954712,
-0.2483666092157364,
-0.37370413541793823,
0.001621324336156249,
0.4042584002017975,
-1.1546800136566162,
-0.13613583147525787,
0.2135828584432602,
1.0519834756851196,
0.4990306794643402,
0.05248375982046127,
0.39389321208000183,
-0.784805417060852,
0.380667507648468,
0.34027206897735596,
0.12754879891872406,
0.202419251203537,
-0.25226014852523804,
0.888275682926178,
-0.21751874685287476,
-0.4312646985054016,
-0.8493574261665344,
0.4546120762825012,
-1.1003105640411377,
-0.3327407240867615,
1.1050280332565308,
0.12954165041446686,
-0.25436487793922424,
-0.44320622086524963,
-0.386554092168808,
0.4065875709056854,
-0.06808506697416306,
0.8061537742614746,
0.6043583154678345,
-0.09824433922767639,
-0.2744852304458618,
-0.07460024952888489,
0.6985093355178833,
1.0646882057189941,
-0.997021496295929,
-0.34106874465942383,
0.2663271427154541,
0.16414499282836914,
-0.004126295447349548,
0.36933526396751404,
0.0770845040678978,
0.44752898812294006,
0.005974560510367155,
0.07314322143793106,
0.18810118734836578,
-0.3836399018764496,
-0.21208840608596802,
0.37152019143104553,
-0.02096061408519745,
-0.17021918296813965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15010v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15010v2
|
How Important Is Tokenization in French Medical Masked Language Models?
| 2024-02-22T23:11:08 | 2024-06-09T15:11:31 |
Yanis Labrak, Adrien Bazoge, Beatrice Daille, Mickael Rouvier, Richard Dufour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Subword tokenization has become the prevailing standard in the field of
natural language processing (NLP) over recent years, primarily due to the
widespread utilization of pre-trained language models. This shift began with
Byte-Pair Encoding (BPE) and was later followed by the adoption of
SentencePiece and WordPiece. While subword tokenization consistently
outperforms character and word-level tokenization, the precise factors
contributing to its success remain unclear. Key aspects such as the optimal
segmentation granularity for diverse tasks and languages, the influence of data
sources on tokenizers, and the role of morphological information in
Indo-European languages remain insufficiently explored. This is particularly
pertinent for biomedical terminology, characterized by specific rules governing
morpheme combinations. Despite the agglutinative nature of biomedical
terminology, existing language models do not explicitly incorporate this
knowledge, leading to inconsistent tokenization strategies for common terms. In
this paper, we seek to delve into the complexities of subword tokenization in
French biomedical domain across a variety of NLP tasks and pinpoint areas where
further enhancements can be made. We analyze classical tokenization algorithms,
including BPE and SentencePiece, and introduce an original tokenization
strategy that integrates morpheme-enriched word segmentation into existing
tokenization methods.
|
[
-0.301770955324173,
-0.6942753195762634,
0.4467841684818268,
0.10188563168048859,
-0.6877670288085938,
0.31740766763687134,
0.2920398712158203,
-0.6140174865722656,
0.6718608736991882,
0.46989983320236206,
-0.21327635645866394,
-0.39841580390930176,
-0.9769535660743713,
0.13523916900157928,
-0.14834794402122498,
0.9179092645645142,
0.07497052103281021,
0.4854130446910858,
-0.28772929310798645,
-0.35351091623306274,
-0.5327839255332947,
-1.2033703327178955,
-0.7190232276916504,
-0.5581681728363037,
0.6653303503990173,
-0.310367614030838,
0.5711430311203003,
0.7657899856567383,
0.6241354942321777,
0.26009175181388855,
-0.34588623046875,
0.21052157878875732,
-0.0902082696557045,
-0.06092415377497673,
-0.4609895646572113,
-0.39333364367485046,
-0.4022837281227112,
-0.08998620510101318,
0.45165103673934937,
1.2747828960418701,
0.29531341791152954,
-0.3051038682460785,
-0.26462212204933167,
0.5781453251838684,
-0.3489900231361389,
0.07367727160453796,
-0.5572343468666077,
0.0668494701385498,
-0.44047749042510986,
-0.2650594711303711,
-0.08064739406108856,
0.15574799478054047,
0.00593971274793148,
-0.2358017861843109,
0.17504280805587769,
-0.1191820427775383,
0.7761464715003967,
-0.01892820931971073,
-0.3843327462673187,
-0.25120535492897034,
-0.3724353611469269,
0.4975365996360779,
-0.46802687644958496,
0.6201305389404297,
0.24878600239753723,
-0.1333926022052765,
-0.17464075982570648,
-1.1668444871902466,
-0.16939233243465424,
0.053738489747047424,
-0.3191095292568207,
-0.04612357169389725,
-0.4279721677303314,
0.4474148154258728,
-0.018267974257469177,
0.2709709405899048,
-0.25439170002937317,
0.30278974771499634,
-0.67894047498703,
-0.5218788385391235,
0.24338223040103912,
-0.05304671823978424,
0.7264289259910583,
-0.3557973802089691,
-0.38441333174705505,
0.33759409189224243,
-0.6423947811126709,
-0.03014865703880787,
-0.010004272684454918,
0.2567567527294159,
0.14969129860401154,
0.7293678522109985,
0.015294977463781834,
0.54173344373703,
-0.14078736305236816,
0.15371598303318024,
0.2254483550786972,
-0.5153802037239075,
-0.1973433792591095,
0.0020972101483494043,
0.5340051054954529,
0.16388684511184692,
0.12698723375797272,
-0.5199625492095947,
-0.20031976699829102,
0.015322637744247913,
0.3364957869052887,
-0.8682587742805481,
-0.2035282403230667,
0.4518481194972992,
-0.4514085054397583,
-0.06530935317277908,
0.10215723514556885,
-0.3467591404914856,
-0.3600657880306244,
-0.17019744217395782,
0.40777671337127686,
-0.5091063976287842,
0.1069684848189354,
0.4804805517196655,
-0.2824223041534424,
-0.007156850770115852,
0.20450367033481598,
-1.0408849716186523,
0.32504189014434814,
0.9920375347137451,
1.0974494218826294,
-0.379171758890152,
0.017543911933898926,
-0.7039812207221985,
-0.16767941415309906,
-0.3718462586402893,
0.711205244064331,
-0.7051734924316406,
-0.7559185028076172,
-0.024959426373243332,
0.37429261207580566,
-0.4481184184551239,
-0.48668819665908813,
0.2851369380950928,
-0.30129683017730713,
0.07309615612030029,
-0.15990853309631348,
-0.8027811646461487,
-0.15051452815532684,
-0.11029227077960968,
-0.4213697612285614,
0.5635350942611694,
-0.01276484876871109,
-0.8454356789588928,
0.532656192779541,
-0.8103752136230469,
-0.5905356407165527,
0.5235214829444885,
-0.37724506855010986,
-0.18402720987796783,
0.5322211980819702,
0.5019581913948059,
0.578600287437439,
0.1047247052192688,
0.15014073252677917,
0.21997392177581787,
-0.25003764033317566,
0.37178289890289307,
-0.09714503586292267,
0.5542234778404236,
-0.2728962004184723,
-0.18226084113121033,
0.1571326106786728,
-0.3622061312198639,
-0.11051400750875473,
-0.2364773005247116,
-0.037377502769231796,
-0.5314916372299194,
-0.05036735534667969,
0.30117928981781006,
-0.06494329124689102,
0.08825770765542984,
-0.7890523672103882,
0.11549094319343567,
-0.9161004424095154,
0.8589771389961243,
0.3928883671760559,
0.4271814823150635,
0.4827110171318054,
-0.16127118468284607,
0.6031043529510498,
0.24116061627864838,
0.22409094870090485,
-0.2573040723800659,
-0.6761881113052368,
-0.4900396764278412,
-0.9057867527008057,
0.9099966287612915,
0.5528915524482727,
-0.4684465229511261,
0.15823949873447418,
-0.12019412219524384,
-0.3246183693408966,
-0.5959450006484985,
-0.20471037924289703,
0.25109753012657166,
0.34210237860679626,
0.5337839126586914,
-0.8048030734062195,
-0.5769790410995483,
-1.2394264936447144,
-0.3640861511230469,
-0.017723962664604187,
0.06635528057813644,
0.22673988342285156,
0.7320536375045776,
-0.7129449844360352,
0.9154595732688904,
-0.21937155723571777,
-0.2754824161529541,
-0.2607395052909851,
0.18058012425899506,
0.16161301732063293,
0.866637647151947,
0.7064065337181091,
-0.8757420778274536,
-0.002625680761411786,
0.15461748838424683,
-0.31778907775878906,
-0.128702774643898,
-0.030358335003256798,
-0.10938340425491333,
-0.001164762768894434,
0.861216127872467,
-0.49867144227027893,
0.6094317436218262,
0.5264331102371216,
-0.17863582074642181,
0.21461506187915802,
-0.3314216732978821,
-0.0023828723933547735,
-1.0980621576309204,
0.16075798869132996,
-0.3040110766887665,
-0.4045484960079193,
-0.8629712462425232,
0.14934322237968445,
-0.09617190808057785,
-0.021748226135969162,
-0.59108966588974,
1.019722580909729,
-0.3661276400089264,
0.2448830008506775,
-0.34428223967552185,
-0.029783425852656364,
0.004211220890283585,
0.1658831238746643,
0.2723020911216736,
0.5199111700057983,
0.605589747428894,
-0.3599787950515747,
0.04243927821516991,
0.24702692031860352,
-0.06545639783143997,
0.32041850686073303,
-0.9949626326560974,
0.11809837818145752,
-0.20809616148471832,
0.1440679430961609,
-0.7218320965766907,
-0.22315466403961182,
0.29270222783088684,
-0.36314278841018677,
0.41635680198669434,
-0.33047938346862793,
-0.32883647084236145,
-0.09820384532213211,
-0.059006933122873306,
0.7348598837852478,
0.514966607093811,
-0.18610870838165283,
0.4476124942302704,
0.7016424536705017,
-0.13472554087638855,
-0.4813818633556366,
-0.8032621741294861,
0.3463803231716156,
0.033733077347278595,
-0.45554494857788086,
0.7058099508285522,
0.231967031955719,
-0.08612281829118729,
-0.1287412792444229,
-0.4541368782520294,
-0.15885502099990845,
-0.019503286108374596,
0.1951255202293396,
0.17018425464630127,
0.008801664225757122,
0.4132619798183441,
0.1279807984828949,
-0.3327590227127075,
-0.3102492690086365,
-0.6174112558364868,
0.7568681240081787,
0.18490898609161377,
-0.4271984398365021,
-0.24216032028198242,
0.5964615345001221,
0.5840985178947449,
-0.4219397306442261,
1.0162712335586548,
0.718167781829834,
-0.7127816677093506,
0.19238808751106262,
-0.5129197835922241,
-0.3404017984867096,
-0.35908716917037964,
0.6951419711112976,
-0.2937031388282776,
-0.9376792907714844,
0.648457407951355,
-0.034241411834955215,
0.01839780993759632,
0.4176706075668335,
0.6075122356414795,
-0.0033361383248120546,
0.9494353532791138,
0.7294794321060181,
0.2219044715166092,
0.3442472517490387,
0.05510271340608597,
0.4595322608947754,
-0.8175042271614075,
-0.25022032856941223,
-0.337002158164978,
-0.13229840993881226,
-0.8004295825958252,
-0.8429390788078308,
0.489879310131073,
0.16565705835819244,
0.4856035113334656,
0.1628168821334839,
-0.48759815096855164,
0.3396856486797333,
0.41495150327682495,
0.2538953423500061,
0.049560777842998505,
0.1578819453716278,
-0.4241885840892792,
-0.1437148153781891,
-0.871006965637207,
-0.5032428503036499,
0.7041686773300171,
0.43607819080352783,
0.34847134351730347,
-0.4087884724140167,
0.8201031684875488,
0.2518678903579712,
0.0480872318148613,
-0.9307912588119507,
0.3726519048213959,
-0.5082094669342041,
-0.4931334853172302,
-0.04911971464753151,
-0.11122871935367584,
-1.1838117837905884,
0.3979078233242035,
-0.31504717469215393,
-0.7478812336921692,
0.5569499135017395,
-0.011137472465634346,
-0.25725671648979187,
0.18166907131671906,
-0.5036115646362305,
0.9865525960922241,
0.11405277997255325,
-0.04502347111701965,
0.09370702505111694,
-0.594167172908783,
-0.20267626643180847,
-0.35352054238319397,
0.43354418873786926,
0.22034473717212677,
-0.39477911591529846,
0.8148494958877563,
-0.6768483519554138,
0.9152252078056335,
0.10275828093290329,
0.13341408967971802,
-0.13084067404270172,
-0.06993182003498077,
0.17751853168010712,
0.22930480539798737,
0.3330441415309906,
0.6362165808677673,
0.5288407802581787,
-0.7003248929977417,
-0.22901302576065063,
0.35040006041526794,
-0.37770476937294006,
-0.555978000164032,
-0.3998241722583771,
-0.2553640305995941,
-0.3585267961025238,
0.14704734086990356,
0.6230506300926208,
0.8094430565834045,
-0.19356925785541534,
0.291593074798584,
0.593680202960968,
-0.42431506514549255,
0.16780275106430054,
0.11299344897270203,
-0.2688004970550537,
-0.36681079864501953,
0.868052065372467,
0.1733257919549942,
0.17095202207565308,
0.6855829954147339,
0.20630845427513123,
-0.25800153613090515,
-0.8967702388763428,
-0.41364967823028564,
0.5479451417922974,
-0.7534608244895935,
0.09442531317472458,
-1.1096014976501465,
-0.5071611404418945,
-0.44118115305900574,
-0.3165133595466614,
-0.23346824944019318,
-0.600277304649353,
-0.2203814536333084,
-0.1446397453546524,
0.0323605015873909,
0.4170362055301666,
-0.2597541809082031,
0.06565416604280472,
-1.1234972476959229,
0.24389424920082092,
0.23839133977890015,
0.07940714061260223,
-0.5876433253288269,
-0.25168490409851074,
-0.19081348180770874,
-0.1373085081577301,
0.5286937952041626,
-0.9261766672134399,
0.12761281430721283,
0.1332315355539322,
0.6675814986228943,
0.08560038357973099,
-0.46821972727775574,
0.42904943227767944,
-0.7560067176818848,
0.8849652409553528,
0.22025930881500244,
-0.9497535228729248,
0.3209608495235443,
-0.211609348654747,
0.25509724020957947,
0.3089112341403961,
0.20610320568084717,
-1.1004420518875122,
-0.34798192977905273,
-0.563808798789978,
-1.080358624458313,
0.28064364194869995,
0.3772943317890167,
0.4814215898513794,
-0.4839363694190979,
0.4102288484573364,
0.2968718409538269,
0.3810364603996277,
-0.59922194480896,
-0.03388315439224243,
-0.0342826209962368,
-0.07127923518419266,
0.020879171788692474,
-0.30149298906326294,
-0.1849997192621231,
-0.1749884933233261,
0.4265684485435486,
-0.028414146974682808,
0.24084033071994781,
0.417858749628067,
-0.1541982740163803,
0.32938674092292786,
0.26295843720436096,
0.6435093879699707,
0.5974298119544983,
0.11742625385522842,
-0.0430029034614563,
-0.055944643914699554,
-0.8723774552345276,
-0.236038476228714,
0.15805673599243164,
-0.19491270184516907,
0.4674893319606781,
0.6684065461158752,
0.6696261167526245,
0.09922900050878525,
-0.7270046472549438,
0.5374957323074341,
0.2580021321773529,
-0.20742487907409668,
0.1950278878211975,
-0.1825474202632904,
-0.02480223774909973,
0.18191887438297272,
0.10926051437854767,
0.2953341007232666,
0.01927557773888111,
-0.5292056202888489,
0.3241936266422272,
0.635626494884491,
-0.62766033411026,
-0.32000717520713806,
0.6368060111999512,
0.23185697197914124,
-0.38257622718811035,
0.14181171357631683,
0.14606261253356934,
-0.6224215030670166,
0.4503481388092041,
0.2522841989994049,
0.9201094508171082,
-0.14204274117946625,
0.3470369279384613,
0.13485069572925568,
0.4919907748699188,
0.1532595157623291,
-0.02321012131869793,
0.19070254266262054,
-0.6239593625068665,
-0.4655037522315979,
-1.0093824863433838,
-0.16258659958839417,
-0.08762999624013901,
-0.267306923866272,
0.07774612307548523,
-0.3310074210166931,
-0.3898516595363617,
0.1101272851228714,
-0.48958098888397217,
-0.6155642867088318,
0.3889789581298828,
-0.035032689571380615,
0.8425154685974121,
-0.6311755180358887,
0.552419900894165,
0.9428427815437317,
-0.30391690135002136,
-0.38357073068618774,
-0.314855694770813,
-0.2867569029331207,
-0.9862753748893738,
0.8111801147460938,
0.01333184540271759,
0.08281515538692474,
-0.19275297224521637,
-0.19261378049850464,
-0.5350490212440491,
0.3634288012981415,
-0.07094619423151016,
-0.5747976899147034,
-0.28752991557121277,
0.34723591804504395,
0.8637827634811401,
-0.5226278901100159,
-0.05169050395488739,
0.4755983054637909,
0.21441689133644104,
0.06115544214844704,
-0.9421430230140686,
-0.03698364645242691,
-0.1348501294851303,
0.2346883863210678,
0.3489481210708618,
-0.2736530005931854,
0.6993710398674011,
0.11488465219736099,
-0.25326284766197205,
-0.06003081053495407,
0.2976215183734894,
-0.22635337710380554,
0.03781624138355255,
0.3302434980869293,
0.0680023804306984,
0.6041276454925537,
-0.2169002890586853,
1.0286692380905151,
-0.3818453252315521,
-0.0010736663825809956,
0.5125333070755005,
0.051942128688097,
0.5380401015281677,
0.7643100023269653,
-0.05415670573711395,
0.4041178226470947,
0.7305320501327515,
0.1396702378988266,
0.2688983678817749,
0.280152291059494,
-0.23175527155399323,
-0.38536185026168823,
-0.22014470398426056,
-0.39842554926872253,
0.670778214931488,
0.4715851843357086,
-0.5700348615646362,
-0.0017682882025837898,
0.3632233738899231,
0.06309390068054199,
-0.06539823859930038,
-0.4395725131034851,
0.8272563815116882,
0.23842070996761322,
-0.31629958748817444,
0.2544075846672058,
0.269378125667572,
0.41037842631340027,
-0.6486258506774902,
0.09875312447547913,
-0.36821088194847107,
-0.1516200751066208,
-0.2486114799976349,
-0.08091408014297485,
0.37275248765945435,
-0.23925545811653137,
-0.0001632919447729364,
-0.15574687719345093,
0.7668003439903259,
-0.31588903069496155,
-0.7065681219100952,
0.005851661786437035,
0.8577564358711243,
0.15990664064884186,
-0.014177698642015457,
-0.5742270350456238,
-0.036583855748176575,
-0.2420273721218109,
0.05912446603178978,
0.39957118034362793,
0.3353157043457031,
-0.15279066562652588,
0.3605671525001526,
0.5857186317443848,
0.5101363658905029,
0.15900109708309174,
0.18106094002723694,
0.7724555134773254,
-0.5349155068397522,
-0.5880441069602966,
-0.9666564464569092,
0.5327051281929016,
-0.09810876101255417,
-0.0969848483800888,
0.4842078685760498,
0.47523465752601624,
0.4972647428512573,
-0.15833806991577148,
0.6556864380836487,
0.2263408899307251,
0.3594893515110016,
-0.7569245100021362,
0.5310136675834656,
-0.6836740970611572,
0.10248518735170364,
-0.19672232866287231,
-0.7415633797645569,
-0.682263195514679,
0.4818090498447418,
-0.1391753852367401,
0.043911851942539215,
0.9168448448181152,
0.6414849162101746,
-0.05948115140199661,
-0.13660435378551483,
0.49537548422813416,
0.05249672010540962,
0.3230004608631134,
0.08112377673387527,
0.33255285024642944,
-0.42169857025146484,
0.079023577272892,
-0.034613944590091705,
-0.3308546841144562,
-0.1833662986755371,
-0.8447017073631287,
-1.1497700214385986,
-0.6765197515487671,
-0.5702731013298035,
-0.2505216896533966,
0.31247636675834656,
1.0365021228790283,
0.8520614504814148,
-0.9790798425674438,
0.22686603665351868,
-0.2433360368013382,
0.02973736636340618,
-0.24821613729000092,
-0.13958309590816498,
0.5211244821548462,
-0.5659905076026917,
-0.9303786754608154,
0.3619435131549835,
0.9495945572853088,
0.25669291615486145,
-0.16103622317314148,
0.5038004517555237,
0.013412616215646267,
0.5075647234916687,
0.7000953555107117,
0.22091807425022125,
-0.7428414225578308,
-0.26737987995147705,
0.12451356649398804,
-0.1644544005393982,
0.13841232657432556,
1.1568810939788818,
-0.7214173078536987,
0.7149372696876526,
0.524774968624115,
0.7853413820266724,
0.33811336755752563,
-0.04604702442884445,
0.7446146607398987,
-0.7825785279273987,
0.3320084512233734,
0.5045241713523865,
0.5845323801040649,
0.35553064942359924,
-0.23107729852199554,
0.6084627509117126,
0.7392202019691467,
-0.29465073347091675,
-0.8659207224845886,
0.4401821494102478,
-0.8202843070030212,
-0.525488018989563,
0.8965155482292175,
0.13533033430576324,
-0.2188425064086914,
-0.4510263502597809,
-0.506447970867157,
0.014235291630029678,
0.08777517080307007,
0.5177768468856812,
0.7476691603660583,
-0.2055967003107071,
-0.006577872671186924,
-0.3754863142967224,
0.7293044328689575,
0.5081692934036255,
-0.5148013830184937,
-0.31572413444519043,
0.21289841830730438,
0.11063587665557861,
0.19569450616836548,
0.9691636562347412,
-0.33530423045158386,
0.085672527551651,
-0.061298854649066925,
-0.15223006904125214,
0.06830786913633347,
-0.008687096647918224,
-0.15769317746162415,
0.2182692289352417,
-0.30797430872917175,
-0.28065308928489685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15002v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15002v1
|
CommVQA: Situating Visual Question Answering in Communicative Contexts
| 2024-02-22T22:31:39 | 2024-02-22T22:31:39 |
Nandita Shankar Naik, Christopher Potts, Elisa Kreiss
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Current visual question answering (VQA) models tend to be trained and
evaluated on image-question pairs in isolation. However, the questions people
ask are dependent on their informational needs and prior knowledge about the
image content. To evaluate how situating images within naturalistic contexts
shapes visual questions, we introduce CommVQA, a VQA dataset consisting of
images, image descriptions, real-world communicative scenarios where the image
might appear (e.g., a travel website), and follow-up questions and answers
conditioned on the scenario. We show that CommVQA poses a challenge for current
models. Providing contextual information to VQA models improves performance
broadly, highlighting the relevance of situating systems within a communicative
scenario.
|
[
-0.7670453190803528,
-0.8751041889190674,
0.5104340314865112,
0.1145811676979065,
-0.3353608548641205,
-0.20193210244178772,
0.017083384096622467,
-0.4347836971282959,
-0.04279115051031113,
0.6086546778678894,
-0.6853382587432861,
-0.2302655577659607,
-0.33080801367759705,
-0.0455939918756485,
-0.2744773030281067,
0.06687893718481064,
-0.06061333417892456,
0.0351346954703331,
-0.7868345379829407,
-0.5180959105491638,
-0.9798775911331177,
-0.5630490183830261,
-0.4301157295703888,
0.13883145153522491,
0.32031095027923584,
0.5606981515884399,
0.7711632251739502,
0.4437018930912018,
0.5020169615745544,
0.38013362884521484,
0.13035930693149567,
0.011111118830740452,
-0.42686256766319275,
0.37505072355270386,
0.2078387588262558,
-0.6465660929679871,
0.42983922362327576,
-0.05106378346681595,
0.6373240947723389,
0.9460804462432861,
-0.10087727755308151,
0.3561933934688568,
-0.1920957863330841,
0.15043653547763824,
-0.6689750552177429,
0.06048889830708504,
-0.5304734706878662,
0.04459630325436592,
0.3309400975704193,
-0.6612035036087036,
-0.1751554161310196,
-0.2510397732257843,
0.5480378866195679,
-0.7446083426475525,
0.08794908225536346,
0.06447441875934601,
1.0342990159988403,
0.4990997314453125,
-0.7631288170814514,
-0.1061364933848381,
-0.5777900218963623,
0.5704380869865417,
-0.010996184311807156,
0.40651336312294006,
0.25560274720191956,
0.6345970034599304,
0.054178182035684586,
-0.8136035799980164,
-0.4945720434188843,
0.1410682052373886,
-0.08894813060760498,
0.29975971579551697,
-0.2963007390499115,
-0.23843637108802795,
0.4273087978363037,
0.1584654599428177,
-0.69193035364151,
-0.37121665477752686,
-0.4206886887550354,
0.050181642174720764,
0.25485026836395264,
0.3017098605632782,
0.605722963809967,
-0.396125853061676,
-0.5526118278503418,
-0.12865382432937622,
-0.7205540537834167,
0.6059775948524475,
-0.323944091796875,
-0.2728988230228424,
-0.20451931655406952,
0.5248165726661682,
-0.43605154752731323,
0.9358987212181091,
0.006183312740176916,
0.3459000885486603,
-0.20849093794822693,
-0.4146815538406372,
-0.3490031361579895,
-0.3266919255256653,
0.21045078337192535,
0.8161947131156921,
0.23217448592185974,
0.3362785279750824,
0.04898284375667572,
-0.10278411209583282,
0.37212061882019043,
-0.6388198137283325,
-0.14979246258735657,
0.17773987352848053,
-0.38928571343421936,
0.006558761931955814,
0.1656360924243927,
-0.38082581758499146,
-0.15498338639736176,
-0.5648012161254883,
0.5117733478546143,
0.04698169231414795,
-0.01659281738102436,
-0.22135965526103973,
-0.41006818413734436,
0.8642184138298035,
0.8643452525138855,
-0.48162326216697693,
0.18662109971046448,
0.35803452134132385,
0.48166391253471375,
0.1240711435675621,
-0.00618453323841095,
-0.79954993724823,
0.013705264776945114,
-0.4071255028247833,
0.8532153964042664,
-0.40555939078330994,
-0.4139533042907715,
0.2063111960887909,
0.5507266521453857,
0.04957783594727516,
-0.6937859654426575,
0.17289109528064728,
-0.8227920532226562,
0.4588284194469452,
-0.7440959215164185,
-0.0706983134150505,
-0.30967772006988525,
0.5792881846427917,
-0.7528773546218872,
0.8318688869476318,
-0.07666020840406418,
-0.8034257888793945,
0.4822067320346832,
-0.24451163411140442,
-0.10163894295692444,
0.3755711019039154,
-0.6782616376876831,
-0.11887714266777039,
-0.05408575385808945,
0.5771450996398926,
0.3358151912689209,
-0.097135528922081,
0.03869069740176201,
-0.07727589458227158,
-0.6471092104911804,
0.6507384181022644,
-0.29597362875938416,
0.8133234977722168,
0.16238047182559967,
-0.2656165063381195,
-0.015987830236554146,
-0.6247441172599792,
0.18019463121891022,
0.10282579064369202,
-0.33012786507606506,
-0.7350301146507263,
0.045703813433647156,
-0.005404507275670767,
0.2735050618648529,
0.03186460956931114,
-0.3080834150314331,
-0.0035705796908587217,
-0.1317604035139084,
0.25647470355033875,
0.5186866521835327,
0.4018009901046753,
0.28285929560661316,
-0.352713406085968,
0.6099532246589661,
0.1870582401752472,
0.2903684973716736,
-0.34073206782341003,
-0.7363006472587585,
-0.7623708248138428,
-0.18740852177143097,
-0.08483175933361053,
0.5790824294090271,
-1.1948162317276,
-0.3909331262111664,
-0.2956511378288269,
-0.22805733978748322,
-0.2586807608604431,
-0.2535857558250427,
0.32300078868865967,
0.6884662508964539,
0.31133779883384705,
-0.3214379549026489,
-0.5587220191955566,
-0.8931148648262024,
0.1545567512512207,
-0.15347468852996826,
-0.03736785799264908,
0.7228053212165833,
0.5013254284858704,
0.24356180429458618,
0.6219741702079773,
-0.6149312257766724,
0.36906301975250244,
0.04513474553823471,
0.19977273046970367,
-0.06456232070922852,
0.17663082480430603,
0.3545231521129608,
-1.4163544178009033,
-0.1517200469970703,
-0.2810420095920563,
-1.0462075471878052,
0.026265470311045647,
-0.255122572183609,
-0.1529175192117691,
-0.05478609353303909,
0.6703639030456543,
-0.5259749889373779,
0.6709466576576233,
0.3736442029476166,
-0.3337098956108093,
0.3252931535243988,
-0.1950892210006714,
0.5799978971481323,
-0.9820452332496643,
0.14913903176784515,
0.0027777801733464003,
-0.3506561517715454,
-0.48119813203811646,
0.2735646963119507,
-0.047968797385692596,
-0.2583688199520111,
-0.5896667242050171,
0.6280037760734558,
-0.5883982181549072,
-0.20043763518333435,
0.08312191069126129,
0.1987375169992447,
0.13303327560424805,
0.3213626444339752,
0.5984694361686707,
0.614038348197937,
0.6242657899856567,
-0.617880642414093,
0.26518046855926514,
0.6764957904815674,
-0.5216189026832581,
0.9896396398544312,
-0.7860616445541382,
0.09610556066036224,
-0.3084988594055176,
0.2360471785068512,
-1.3549691438674927,
-0.4319736361503601,
0.20922985672950745,
-0.5618014931678772,
-0.16419829428195953,
-0.43223270773887634,
-0.15618722140789032,
-0.29670625925064087,
-0.0165349580347538,
0.8125890493392944,
0.41274112462997437,
-0.7260904908180237,
0.3110697269439697,
0.399890661239624,
-0.2613745629787445,
-0.7600744962692261,
-0.6763759255409241,
0.2885523736476898,
-0.4112454652786255,
-0.7831863164901733,
-0.1277015656232834,
0.058777257800102234,
-0.4478195309638977,
-0.2250339537858963,
0.016945721581578255,
-0.338349312543869,
0.20807766914367676,
0.6285218000411987,
0.33049893379211426,
-0.21397240459918976,
0.14706073701381683,
-0.24956808984279633,
0.30836886167526245,
0.31748947501182556,
-0.17292843759059906,
0.1520489752292633,
0.03154687210917473,
-0.17934775352478027,
-0.20825211703777313,
0.8800077438354492,
0.2836002707481384,
-0.3199160397052765,
0.3888132572174072,
0.2797180712223053,
-0.38725465536117554,
-0.023608824238181114,
-0.40829935669898987,
0.038892120122909546,
-0.4936569333076477,
0.12517574429512024,
-0.5109473466873169,
-0.8541509509086609,
0.39670243859291077,
0.15784630179405212,
-0.23554295301437378,
-0.18189212679862976,
0.677178144454956,
-0.5694306492805481,
0.8542970418930054,
0.6384247541427612,
0.6534032821655273,
0.34235358238220215,
-0.3001154661178589,
-0.13068632781505585,
-0.540498673915863,
-0.43827497959136963,
-0.3789692223072052,
-0.15200771391391754,
-0.783759355545044,
-0.6787578463554382,
0.5682280659675598,
-0.37723037600517273,
-0.06085696443915367,
0.21166397631168365,
-0.34149426221847534,
0.41693753004074097,
0.8881776928901672,
0.24814453721046448,
0.33615854382514954,
-0.11609171330928802,
-0.12218237668275833,
0.09682220220565796,
-0.9607229828834534,
-0.5759088397026062,
0.6962682604789734,
0.0794336348772049,
0.7615693807601929,
0.21011348068714142,
0.39885205030441284,
-0.11559978872537613,
0.2299206703901291,
-0.6482903957366943,
0.641262948513031,
0.45676058530807495,
-0.7242594957351685,
-0.3022923469543457,
-0.23885878920555115,
-1.177451491355896,
0.3016377389431,
-0.20151689648628235,
-0.6430220603942871,
0.567192554473877,
0.17726784944534302,
-0.42374730110168457,
-0.282143771648407,
-0.6089208722114563,
0.9153096675872803,
0.04175715148448944,
-0.4681394100189209,
0.1869058907032013,
-1.048094630241394,
0.25277096033096313,
0.3390478491783142,
0.2180696427822113,
0.4459746778011322,
-0.05559650808572769,
0.5099512934684753,
-0.34770816564559937,
0.7711369395256042,
-0.07287569344043732,
0.00020462204702198505,
0.6009694933891296,
0.020317375659942627,
-0.016726898029446602,
0.295590877532959,
0.5241382122039795,
-0.14080719649791718,
0.6931865215301514,
-0.5111760497093201,
-0.7554899454116821,
0.5989209413528442,
-0.5570768117904663,
-0.67009037733078,
-0.29045718908309937,
-0.5281636714935303,
-0.27615174651145935,
-0.08523088693618774,
0.3892398476600647,
0.7233713269233704,
-0.2759762108325958,
0.4595852196216583,
0.8466060757637024,
-0.5527007579803467,
0.38727083802223206,
0.06884157657623291,
-0.038218166679143906,
-0.18890255689620972,
0.4591054618358612,
0.10269258916378021,
0.24513328075408936,
0.4316539168357849,
-0.14316941797733307,
-0.47394976019859314,
-0.049332816153764725,
-0.3900160789489746,
-0.05651002749800682,
-1.3755863904953003,
0.05450671538710594,
-0.47097039222717285,
-0.020914969965815544,
-0.024173012003302574,
-0.1840997338294983,
0.17435653507709503,
-0.35817521810531616,
-0.10376187413930893,
0.17516976594924927,
-0.19585512578487396,
0.5396657586097717,
0.07936187833547592,
0.16555364429950714,
-0.6146826148033142,
0.5563540458679199,
0.9043442606925964,
0.13465973734855652,
-0.22652336955070496,
-0.3107142150402069,
-0.15075576305389404,
0.10452856123447418,
-0.20831632614135742,
-1.0111902952194214,
0.0033377816434949636,
-0.019669469445943832,
0.5573349595069885,
-0.06484320759773254,
0.11355162411928177,
0.7466009855270386,
-0.30319714546203613,
0.8663156032562256,
-0.026966329663991928,
-0.42748573422431946,
0.6500752568244934,
-0.39853331446647644,
0.7539848685264587,
0.366470068693161,
0.6363734602928162,
-0.6528298854827881,
-0.20523059368133545,
-0.5258408188819885,
-0.6103707551956177,
0.149478480219841,
0.2678307890892029,
0.2909938395023346,
-0.042646098881959915,
0.35086166858673096,
-0.21219460666179657,
0.17302757501602173,
-0.779316246509552,
-0.03357044607400894,
-0.38545066118240356,
0.040642041712999344,
0.04740775004029274,
-0.03329749405384064,
-0.5119415521621704,
-0.3785666525363922,
0.05167090892791748,
-0.18994514644145966,
0.4622269570827484,
0.5701719522476196,
-0.3094263970851898,
-0.015739597380161285,
-0.00691665755584836,
0.46403414011001587,
0.6475857496261597,
-0.08517695963382721,
0.35610294342041016,
0.18754008412361145,
-0.16896526515483856,
0.23299448192119598,
-0.24399660527706146,
-0.26184964179992676,
0.020834680646657944,
0.24822944402694702,
0.565069854259491,
0.16873379051685333,
-0.7318991422653198,
0.6789065003395081,
-0.5642920136451721,
-0.3364887535572052,
-0.4277738332748413,
-0.02833290584385395,
0.13181111216545105,
0.3675966262817383,
0.27507033944129944,
-0.189900204539299,
0.33546027541160583,
-0.8518626689910889,
0.30947476625442505,
0.6975387334823608,
-0.41812577843666077,
0.09374992549419403,
0.5927421450614929,
0.02725697122514248,
-0.07833804190158844,
0.4752068817615509,
0.3567679226398468,
-0.5145898461341858,
0.845562756061554,
0.22990985214710236,
0.3004629909992218,
0.040107209235429764,
0.3090812861919403,
0.42337071895599365,
0.28121769428253174,
0.24517595767974854,
0.821929395198822,
-0.42978501319885254,
-0.38283735513687134,
-0.2964952290058136,
0.11322399228811264,
-0.6360031366348267,
-0.09529794007539749,
-0.6419141292572021,
0.3296550214290619,
-0.27901098132133484,
-0.12759627401828766,
-0.14027516543865204,
-0.27239787578582764,
-1.0183056592941284,
0.8084977269172668,
0.4980967938899994,
0.7535426616668701,
-0.6329056024551392,
0.3619151711463928,
0.8775433897972107,
-0.3167405426502228,
-0.847779393196106,
0.205283984541893,
-0.12141592055559158,
-0.5374941229820251,
0.836963951587677,
0.2912936508655548,
-0.1795673817396164,
0.03738168999552727,
-1.225346565246582,
-0.8776903748512268,
1.1948026418685913,
0.09167615324258804,
0.039737045764923096,
0.2550809979438782,
0.0635349452495575,
0.44288668036460876,
-0.3432665765285492,
0.30179309844970703,
-0.006332136690616608,
0.3334015905857086,
0.5205022692680359,
-0.6448101997375488,
0.2526622414588928,
-0.49577587842941284,
0.025275379419326782,
-0.1763143241405487,
-0.45991048216819763,
0.5071456432342529,
-0.2657448351383209,
-0.3260715901851654,
0.3015546500682831,
0.4540471136569977,
0.17228014767169952,
0.32179948687553406,
0.45029422640800476,
0.2518799602985382,
0.6460450887680054,
-0.38054153323173523,
1.11233651638031,
0.30535534024238586,
0.03845830261707306,
1.2388298511505127,
0.2392488569021225,
0.8331923484802246,
0.7848698496818542,
0.41349586844444275,
0.4345519542694092,
0.8849427103996277,
0.00979569647461176,
0.5026628971099854,
0.4641231894493103,
-0.10559723526239395,
-0.6546721458435059,
-0.15000207722187042,
-0.3940465450286865,
0.8360827565193176,
0.09772323071956635,
0.028248988091945648,
-0.13044622540473938,
-0.10544056445360184,
-0.46347305178642273,
-0.018367290496826172,
-0.12574607133865356,
0.659926176071167,
-0.011365078389644623,
-1.0583343505859375,
0.8554290533065796,
-0.3257884383201599,
-0.126138374209404,
-0.07392829656600952,
-0.32651492953300476,
-0.4070294201374054,
-0.35634881258010864,
0.007313190493732691,
-0.8756474852561951,
0.20982936024665833,
-0.24313199520111084,
0.2325577288866043,
0.05133974924683571,
0.5166227221488953,
-0.29536131024360657,
-0.2646312415599823,
-0.2719708979129791,
0.7158979773521423,
0.052117716521024704,
-0.02861941233277321,
-0.5079543590545654,
-0.10237359255552292,
-0.5016164183616638,
-0.1912871152162552,
-0.014464342966675758,
0.6324785351753235,
-0.40736231207847595,
0.9372426867485046,
0.4515456557273865,
-0.5287082195281982,
0.1294391006231308,
-0.17019225656986237,
0.7697885632514954,
-0.5934835076332092,
-0.7640044093132019,
-0.3568614423274994,
0.7508122324943542,
-0.17939428985118866,
-0.25221872329711914,
0.6777974963188171,
0.15479497611522675,
0.6834957599639893,
-0.12374957650899887,
0.7839900255203247,
0.06720156967639923,
-0.07756444811820984,
-0.6350985169410706,
0.3835720717906952,
-0.8418100476264954,
0.13729342818260193,
-0.32079434394836426,
-0.6643331050872803,
-0.4145270884037018,
0.5853671431541443,
-0.40104302763938904,
-0.23592592775821686,
0.4752427637577057,
0.6928790807723999,
-0.12011837959289551,
0.12506859004497528,
0.4809105396270752,
-0.1988866925239563,
0.11648162454366684,
0.6535677909851074,
1.5761165618896484,
-0.44192472100257874,
0.44062575697898865,
-0.23194833099842072,
-0.1919977068901062,
-0.1870504468679428,
-0.8227353096008301,
-0.9507874250411987,
-0.9615370631217957,
-0.4743334949016571,
-0.22388382256031036,
-0.08517137914896011,
0.6699457764625549,
0.9002224206924438,
-0.22983503341674805,
-0.23303429782390594,
0.264652281999588,
0.031802646815776825,
0.00570729048922658,
-0.19968147575855255,
0.0811457559466362,
0.11573480814695358,
-0.3694184124469757,
0.00909770093858242,
0.20666566491127014,
0.27932900190353394,
-0.18948498368263245,
0.14748039841651917,
-0.484725683927536,
0.29907479882240295,
0.4864310622215271,
0.293510764837265,
-0.5027710199356079,
-0.5237392783164978,
0.42805418372154236,
-0.09967442601919174,
0.389360636472702,
0.6770455837249756,
-0.8949574828147888,
0.48664331436157227,
0.467540979385376,
0.5793276429176331,
0.5142111778259277,
0.28528469800949097,
0.7632111310958862,
-0.8143598437309265,
0.07246445119380951,
-0.03493592143058777,
0.28168565034866333,
0.576505720615387,
-0.3977886438369751,
0.24934031069278717,
0.233423113822937,
-0.4335307478904724,
-0.5727953314781189,
0.2572190761566162,
-1.345510721206665,
-0.21130676567554474,
1.0724763870239258,
-0.1553928107023239,
-0.27621451020240784,
-0.3036220967769623,
-0.47560515999794006,
-0.0244919303804636,
0.2940036952495575,
0.5903225541114807,
0.7082662582397461,
0.07119262218475342,
-0.5703762769699097,
-0.767253577709198,
0.32642945647239685,
0.4720276892185211,
-0.924633264541626,
-0.26990726590156555,
0.8134852051734924,
0.3777710795402527,
-0.05577880144119263,
0.6692302823066711,
0.11625465005636215,
0.7083523869514465,
-0.17114250361919403,
-0.3588118255138397,
0.30731022357940674,
-0.251992404460907,
-0.20772595703601837,
0.3156158924102783,
0.012488484382629395,
-0.48110002279281616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15000v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15000v1
|
Divide-or-Conquer? Which Part Should You Distill Your LLM?
| 2024-02-22T22:28:46 | 2024-02-22T22:28:46 |
Zhuofeng Wu, He Bai, Aonan Zhang, Jiatao Gu, VG Vinod Vydiswaran, Navdeep Jaitly, Yizhe Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent methods have demonstrated that Large Language Models (LLMs) can solve
reasoning tasks better when they are encouraged to solve subtasks of the main
task first. In this paper we devise a similar strategy that breaks down
reasoning tasks into a problem decomposition phase and a problem solving phase
and show that the strategy is able to outperform a single stage solution.
Further, we hypothesize that the decomposition should be easier to distill into
a smaller model compared to the problem solving because the latter requires
large amounts of domain knowledge while the former only requires learning
general problem solving strategies. We propose methods to distill these two
capabilities and evaluate their impact on reasoning outcomes and inference
cost. We find that we can distill the problem decomposition phase and at the
same time achieve good generalization across tasks, datasets, and models.
However, it is harder to distill the problem solving capability without losing
performance and the resulting distilled model struggles with generalization.
These results indicate that by using smaller, distilled problem decomposition
models in combination with problem solving LLMs we can achieve reasoning with
cost-efficient inference and local adaptation.
|
[
-0.44962191581726074,
-0.7461109757423401,
0.9213780760765076,
0.11391619592905045,
-0.3160970211029053,
0.3043680787086487,
-0.313558429479599,
-0.16878469288349152,
-0.24535274505615234,
0.6255123019218445,
-0.5546972751617432,
-0.1691625565290451,
-0.9245269894599915,
0.06348888576030731,
-0.3135905861854553,
0.7341572642326355,
0.029472170397639275,
0.035010695457458496,
-0.5819652080535889,
0.10742433369159698,
-0.42946571111679077,
-0.6753841638565063,
-0.9097596406936646,
-0.8262553811073303,
0.5494673252105713,
0.5321367979049683,
0.45443618297576904,
0.7697317600250244,
0.42707177996635437,
0.4127005338668823,
-0.57508784532547,
0.3320164084434509,
-0.5702892541885376,
0.3910295367240906,
-0.376287043094635,
-0.7032942771911621,
-0.21273984014987946,
0.0011293237330392003,
0.10234983265399933,
1.112857699394226,
-0.38232409954071045,
0.059666164219379425,
0.0923476368188858,
0.8128439784049988,
-0.494785338640213,
0.1303829401731491,
-0.6851688623428345,
-0.16777338087558746,
0.08302613347768784,
0.13219110667705536,
-0.3918500542640686,
-0.10392454266548157,
0.24532148241996765,
-0.6108060479164124,
0.20473730564117432,
0.08157768100500107,
0.43060821294784546,
0.6099768280982971,
-0.5612302422523499,
-0.34254568815231323,
-1.1351275444030762,
1.184661865234375,
-0.48223769664764404,
-0.007810639683157206,
0.2730991244316101,
0.4135342538356781,
-0.38784128427505493,
-0.7047716975212097,
-0.3979470431804657,
-0.055844537913799286,
-0.044924113899469376,
-0.125992089509964,
-0.4976944625377655,
0.03399411216378212,
0.39231476187705994,
0.47643229365348816,
-0.3151523470878601,
0.12367859482765198,
-0.7330977320671082,
-0.1044095903635025,
0.7403486967086792,
0.142124742269516,
0.3095114529132843,
-0.03738907724618912,
-0.4115718901157379,
0.02652587741613388,
-0.642156720161438,
-0.14135126769542694,
0.08106399327516556,
0.3061310350894928,
0.5189561247825623,
0.6060121059417725,
-0.06665509939193726,
0.30279162526130676,
0.3367069661617279,
-0.7249646186828613,
-0.1908164769411087,
-0.39827629923820496,
-0.3484826385974884,
-0.009224889799952507,
0.3994602560997009,
0.1258257031440735,
0.2789570689201355,
-0.17796690762043,
-0.18516960740089417,
0.027487456798553467,
0.30715566873550415,
-0.6824644804000854,
-0.3586050868034363,
0.3537932336330414,
-0.42588457465171814,
0.17525479197502136,
-0.5244033336639404,
-0.2756964862346649,
-0.5847381949424744,
-0.7593164443969727,
0.3031632900238037,
-0.4876278042793274,
-0.2642035186290741,
0.25970032811164856,
-0.3212181627750397,
0.06314921379089355,
0.6924098134040833,
-0.7824535369873047,
0.47168266773223877,
1.047681212425232,
0.6807913780212402,
-0.28638043999671936,
-0.08775430917739868,
-0.3040141761302948,
-0.115687295794487,
-0.3869432508945465,
0.6090494990348816,
-0.12835802137851715,
-0.690932035446167,
-0.2243981659412384,
-0.20607733726501465,
-0.09504617005586624,
-1.1964037418365479,
0.6163361072540283,
-0.45045000314712524,
0.05165455862879753,
-0.5900951623916626,
-0.6657808423042297,
-0.3079197406768799,
0.1975589096546173,
-0.9794014096260071,
0.7432255744934082,
-0.0566246435046196,
-0.8067919015884399,
0.3276769816875458,
-0.44245976209640503,
-0.628179132938385,
-0.029938654974102974,
0.0018036733381450176,
-0.11783307045698166,
0.40587127208709717,
0.3496922552585602,
0.5353556275367737,
-0.4964318573474884,
0.24653418362140656,
-0.1813143640756607,
-0.009251847863197327,
0.04972336068749428,
-0.16691374778747559,
0.7876465320587158,
0.49057963490486145,
-0.17321369051933289,
-0.17303918302059174,
-0.5410193204879761,
-0.25555163621902466,
0.3331754207611084,
-0.3854285180568695,
-0.5848883986473083,
0.45269209146499634,
-0.6621479392051697,
-0.0563344843685627,
0.34279006719589233,
-0.4835408329963684,
0.29531094431877136,
-0.2490338832139969,
0.4418586492538452,
0.5466538667678833,
0.09374439716339111,
0.9318668842315674,
-0.24061524868011475,
0.5414418578147888,
0.2819640040397644,
0.19053857028484344,
0.346852570772171,
-0.28602704405784607,
-1.1496860980987549,
-0.5597904324531555,
0.1317146122455597,
0.5224639177322388,
-1.0411376953125,
0.07749026268720627,
-0.025515815243124962,
-0.4471362829208374,
-0.4514264166355133,
0.1311119794845581,
0.32760289311408997,
0.46203991770744324,
0.5179519057273865,
0.1812204271554947,
-0.4870387017726898,
-1.0567641258239746,
-0.038088083267211914,
-0.2502988278865814,
-0.03984006121754646,
-0.15866324305534363,
0.5381109714508057,
0.12234517186880112,
0.8922548294067383,
-0.71815425157547,
-0.21645747125148773,
-0.7774101495742798,
0.1503700464963913,
0.14820164442062378,
0.3663787543773651,
0.2337302714586258,
-1.0245728492736816,
-0.32661113142967224,
0.016809485852718353,
-0.5778301954269409,
-0.07397667318582535,
0.07825709879398346,
-0.09589987248182297,
0.08886412531137466,
0.3333195447921753,
-0.44482260942459106,
0.29527291655540466,
0.2983924448490143,
-0.13662970066070557,
0.47727540135383606,
-0.4235866665840149,
0.12993013858795166,
-0.8748476505279541,
-0.2828698754310608,
0.10093403607606888,
-0.2168125957250595,
-0.7935217618942261,
0.11121132969856262,
-0.40394890308380127,
0.08579473197460175,
-0.2222546637058258,
0.15579895675182343,
-0.6334477663040161,
0.20022059977054596,
-0.4681869447231293,
0.14678971469402313,
0.2543513774871826,
0.3043632209300995,
0.04636171832680702,
0.5087433457374573,
0.37297603487968445,
-0.5463330149650574,
0.53419029712677,
-0.02109476737678051,
-0.47078749537467957,
0.4421672821044922,
-0.7088069915771484,
0.14443789422512054,
-0.2960110306739807,
0.19062016904354095,
-0.9349311590194702,
0.048561401665210724,
-0.03127526491880417,
-0.09247244149446487,
0.29493990540504456,
-0.26959526538848877,
-0.46346068382263184,
-0.3571288585662842,
-0.025740426033735275,
0.4655556082725525,
0.734959065914154,
-0.6029496788978577,
0.8059194684028625,
0.35117438435554504,
-0.35687822103500366,
-0.5249963402748108,
-0.9194424152374268,
-0.25751617550849915,
-0.6373785734176636,
-0.659584641456604,
0.4068182706832886,
-0.01872994564473629,
-0.7785242795944214,
0.006340512074530125,
-0.35567721724510193,
-0.22495350241661072,
0.2784624397754669,
0.3184090256690979,
0.1036698967218399,
-0.01393250934779644,
0.0030552747193723917,
0.13640150427818298,
-0.24952194094657898,
0.10689609497785568,
-0.2889404296875,
0.28999099135398865,
0.2839149236679077,
-0.5032438039779663,
-0.0009393409127369523,
0.8124487996101379,
0.6329068541526794,
-0.39236077666282654,
0.6755399107933044,
-0.028634611517190933,
-0.2163868248462677,
-0.651425302028656,
-0.6133370995521545,
-0.029462667182087898,
-0.40503233671188354,
0.33872100710868835,
-0.6382976770401001,
-0.8966514468193054,
0.49891817569732666,
-0.35088205337524414,
0.17816969752311707,
0.3821020722389221,
0.707663893699646,
-0.06590262055397034,
0.9201570749282837,
0.6805269122123718,
-0.13406042754650116,
0.031191401183605194,
-0.3838474750518799,
0.5491988062858582,
-0.5820664167404175,
-0.4657646417617798,
-0.63944411277771,
-0.4466489553451538,
-0.2181480973958969,
-1.0052320957183838,
0.3054608702659607,
0.472309410572052,
-0.13494117558002472,
0.15589208900928497,
-0.5312259197235107,
0.675072968006134,
0.7710036039352417,
0.07912615686655045,
0.6698877811431885,
0.07240305095911026,
0.14664232730865479,
0.0661752000451088,
-0.8419426679611206,
-0.4517774283885956,
1.0046758651733398,
0.39341041445732117,
0.6742242574691772,
0.16357998549938202,
1.2031874656677246,
0.1101626455783844,
0.07630396634340286,
-0.9408220052719116,
0.5560206174850464,
-0.3933003842830658,
-0.6310491561889648,
-0.4508804976940155,
-0.6636207699775696,
-0.8269264698028564,
0.6044732928276062,
0.16422690451145172,
-0.5679830312728882,
0.24090346693992615,
-0.007035484537482262,
-0.3292919099330902,
0.40269792079925537,
-0.8823115825653076,
0.6772496700286865,
-0.13937212526798248,
0.056244801729917526,
-0.3803819715976715,
-0.33319103717803955,
0.5206271409988403,
0.030114062130451202,
0.4916529059410095,
-0.12728674709796906,
0.021364977583289146,
0.7113601565361023,
-0.7117438912391663,
0.6909276247024536,
-0.2794773578643799,
-0.24440182745456696,
0.6374295949935913,
0.24035586416721344,
0.3831155002117157,
-0.2745180130004883,
0.00260813906788826,
-0.274242639541626,
0.15515218675136566,
-0.5427371263504028,
-0.9255617260932922,
0.5743387937545776,
-0.6734910011291504,
-1.0425071716308594,
-0.2524718642234802,
-0.46515288949012756,
0.006087854970246553,
-0.21720920503139496,
0.2378169596195221,
0.2530546188354492,
-0.15210391581058502,
-0.0671130120754242,
0.9292973875999451,
0.08770505338907242,
0.38041549921035767,
0.24769890308380127,
-0.2908790409564972,
-0.38113799691200256,
0.7741788625717163,
0.22672101855278015,
0.5852951407432556,
0.2564678192138672,
0.2549111545085907,
-0.36053022742271423,
-0.8555353879928589,
-0.0464501716196537,
0.23957549035549164,
-1.0736793279647827,
-0.037338901311159134,
-0.31132861971855164,
-0.04249272495508194,
-0.15883414447307587,
0.024731779471039772,
-0.47004076838493347,
-0.37133634090423584,
-0.293484091758728,
-0.15841764211654663,
0.09869921952486038,
0.6957295536994934,
-0.2652842104434967,
0.01629013754427433,
-0.46407350897789,
0.4060017764568329,
0.6071252822875977,
-0.4065091907978058,
0.02090490236878395,
-0.6330639719963074,
-0.18208710849285126,
0.021901452913880348,
-0.049403250217437744,
-0.727639377117157,
0.2825099229812622,
-0.04655908793210983,
0.6305631399154663,
0.14490170776844025,
0.33527979254722595,
0.6875216364860535,
-0.4822557866573334,
0.6840640902519226,
0.27446088194847107,
-0.8550180196762085,
0.33739450573921204,
0.1142209842801094,
0.2492939531803131,
0.6404932141304016,
0.7356871366500854,
-0.19489559531211853,
-0.3246549367904663,
-0.5050071477890015,
-0.8676381707191467,
0.4523560106754303,
0.1570337861776352,
-0.14315877854824066,
0.08352022618055344,
0.3418979048728943,
0.02071302756667137,
-0.0019848111551254988,
-0.47334638237953186,
-0.31408756971359253,
0.3359646201133728,
0.1204729974269867,
-0.15303868055343628,
-0.4403860867023468,
-0.410075843334198,
-0.4731563627719879,
0.6430160999298096,
0.0499819740653038,
-0.048411138355731964,
0.1921669840812683,
-0.16793368756771088,
0.3271481692790985,
0.4220777451992035,
0.22435544431209564,
0.5916235446929932,
0.06506773084402084,
0.4294297695159912,
0.11790235340595245,
-0.10852862894535065,
0.4280868470668793,
-0.018579348921775818,
0.12049350142478943,
-0.18414995074272156,
0.6334222555160522,
0.5077953338623047,
-0.21630769968032837,
-0.5270936489105225,
0.28898313641548157,
0.03751363977789879,
-0.6083223819732666,
0.1620458960533142,
0.057076625525951385,
0.5574233531951904,
0.7497394680976868,
0.5050130486488342,
-0.2663998007774353,
0.18280453979969025,
-0.6680422425270081,
-0.09089524298906326,
0.1389891803264618,
0.16478164494037628,
0.023466750979423523,
0.20728559792041779,
0.2901739478111267,
-0.12060285359621048,
0.5876743197441101,
-0.4105866849422455,
-0.8994597792625427,
0.7713708877563477,
0.3333744406700134,
0.7978284955024719,
-0.2037222534418106,
0.36072760820388794,
0.20407569408416748,
0.3165106177330017,
-0.40493345260620117,
-0.0314893014729023,
-0.16333478689193726,
-0.7295529246330261,
-1.0504957437515259,
-0.6649887561798096,
-0.33431538939476013,
0.1146344244480133,
-0.6359350681304932,
-0.25922247767448425,
-0.32699212431907654,
-0.08152984827756882,
0.1888643354177475,
0.17914937436580658,
-0.3364436626434326,
0.2490653395652771,
0.3972216546535492,
0.672716498374939,
-0.8594635128974915,
0.708696186542511,
0.6061491370201111,
-0.32047441601753235,
-1.0398355722427368,
-0.2996665835380554,
0.0679391548037529,
-0.4725438058376312,
1.0258314609527588,
-0.221032977104187,
-0.12145264446735382,
-0.3854440748691559,
-0.3837898373603821,
-0.7508978247642517,
1.0051860809326172,
0.4651487171649933,
-0.6902318000793457,
-0.0341404564678669,
0.1655684858560562,
0.39085713028907776,
-0.41306787729263306,
-0.10699298232793808,
1.0762823820114136,
0.4029688835144043,
0.6330914497375488,
-1.1844233274459839,
-0.0018467394402250648,
0.21085214614868164,
0.03421536087989807,
0.2320340871810913,
-0.23254871368408203,
1.177477478981018,
-0.36063164472579956,
-0.44856736063957214,
-0.13249914348125458,
0.6544792652130127,
0.1800701916217804,
0.3756372630596161,
0.7319536209106445,
0.6595370173454285,
0.8403578400611877,
-0.2438584566116333,
0.8645726442337036,
0.3047218918800354,
0.3545910120010376,
1.332466721534729,
-0.41553744673728943,
0.7686705589294434,
0.7341764569282532,
-0.4568275809288025,
0.4412060081958771,
0.5044134855270386,
0.35383909940719604,
0.5891233682632446,
0.6082442998886108,
-0.3871517777442932,
-0.7446496486663818,
-0.006419303361326456,
-0.08599483221769333,
0.5337989926338196,
0.15998250246047974,
-0.21936582028865814,
-0.535657525062561,
0.262751966714859,
0.205010786652565,
0.3839818239212036,
-0.3222053050994873,
0.9428364038467407,
0.24561306834220886,
-0.9171789884567261,
0.6370969414710999,
0.05240923911333084,
0.2844564616680145,
-0.4021008312702179,
0.12267590314149857,
-0.5735471844673157,
0.3503015339374542,
-0.16685785353183746,
-0.5393442511558533,
0.4967331886291504,
0.08576402068138123,
-0.5292821526527405,
-0.4476845860481262,
0.734968900680542,
-0.537686824798584,
-0.48741549253463745,
0.4276176691055298,
0.7855795621871948,
0.10270491242408752,
-0.4874069392681122,
-0.3915463089942932,
0.049986209720373154,
0.255062460899353,
-0.2968759834766388,
0.4698948860168457,
0.787552535533905,
-0.029525890946388245,
0.9797762632369995,
0.43364864587783813,
0.04422345012426376,
0.12367567420005798,
0.039287667721509933,
1.194224238395691,
-0.36262330412864685,
-0.025539029389619827,
-1.017088532447815,
0.6382060647010803,
-0.2136368751525879,
0.24834027886390686,
0.6461172103881836,
0.6234115958213806,
0.7000266909599304,
0.10810352861881256,
0.8143526911735535,
-0.04753522202372551,
0.5594111084938049,
-0.5321090221405029,
0.21445362269878387,
-0.7241398096084595,
0.3502061367034912,
0.126814067363739,
-0.7396268248558044,
-0.07662086188793182,
0.3912576735019684,
-0.5603232383728027,
-0.19571995735168457,
0.8550121784210205,
0.5285505652427673,
0.14718332886695862,
-0.13186927139759064,
0.43317750096321106,
0.045098982751369476,
0.29761484265327454,
0.9372349381446838,
1.1309573650360107,
0.055152226239442825,
0.4503399133682251,
-0.4893057644367218,
-0.4057527482509613,
0.03143196180462837,
-0.8644731044769287,
-0.8616235852241516,
-0.5529177188873291,
-0.6616894006729126,
-0.21485759317874908,
-0.21419930458068848,
0.6317631006240845,
0.6117766499519348,
-0.5155909061431885,
-0.2924194931983948,
0.09302514791488647,
0.47821056842803955,
-0.33756113052368164,
-0.15974774956703186,
0.15664280951023102,
-0.4931771755218506,
-0.9608621001243591,
0.5630853772163391,
0.24472801387310028,
-0.18317961692810059,
-0.33918169140815735,
0.1238345131278038,
-0.0947902575135231,
0.28362998366355896,
0.7947214245796204,
0.10771830379962921,
-0.8887814879417419,
-0.0898471549153328,
-0.03694140911102295,
0.015743613243103027,
-0.12814685702323914,
1.0987101793289185,
-0.46259987354278564,
0.43360236287117004,
0.5423003435134888,
0.6083186268806458,
0.8295131921768188,
0.19648835062980652,
0.5487739443778992,
-0.49830371141433716,
0.12892992794513702,
0.32595333456993103,
0.4652695953845978,
0.18716490268707275,
-0.04289254546165466,
0.4674338400363922,
0.06090691685676575,
-0.6621208190917969,
-0.6032667756080627,
0.430374413728714,
-0.9711729288101196,
-0.8442080020904541,
1.2973154783248901,
-0.4056635797023773,
-0.37124180793762207,
-0.0664595440030098,
-0.28007349371910095,
0.12798742949962616,
-0.1477806121110916,
0.43795156478881836,
0.7797210812568665,
-0.31814947724342346,
0.05247259512543678,
-0.3906075656414032,
0.45985233783721924,
0.4494401216506958,
-0.7206709980964661,
0.2137605845928192,
0.6604567170143127,
0.3987124562263489,
0.42717161774635315,
0.5295705199241638,
0.11131539940834045,
-0.22680965065956116,
0.15546254813671112,
-0.11975088715553284,
-0.18588988482952118,
-0.4970763027667999,
-0.2253490686416626,
0.4290657341480255,
0.3299395442008972,
-0.3584578037261963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14992v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14992v2
|
tinyBenchmarks: evaluating LLMs with fewer examples
| 2024-02-22T22:05:23 | 2024-05-26T22:27:23 |
Felipe Maia Polo, Lucas Weber, Leshem Choshen, Yuekai Sun, Gongjun Xu, Mikhail Yurochkin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
The versatility of large language models (LLMs) led to the creation of
diverse benchmarks that thoroughly test a variety of language models'
abilities. These benchmarks consist of tens of thousands of examples making
evaluation of LLMs very expensive. In this paper, we investigate strategies to
reduce the number of evaluations needed to assess the performance of an LLM on
several key benchmarks. For example, we show that to accurately estimate the
performance of an LLM on MMLU, a popular multiple-choice QA benchmark
consisting of 14K examples, it is sufficient to evaluate this LLM on 100
curated examples. We release evaluation tools and tiny versions of popular
benchmarks: Open LLM Leaderboard, MMLU, HELM, and AlpacaEval 2.0. Our empirical
analysis demonstrates that these tools and tiny benchmarks are sufficient to
reliably and efficiently reproduce the original evaluation results.
|
[
-0.6560705900192261,
-0.6620262861251831,
0.641088604927063,
0.17106960713863373,
-0.2930107116699219,
0.04473593458533287,
-0.37010860443115234,
-0.32368889451026917,
-0.12111229449510574,
0.2637665867805481,
-0.5378062129020691,
-0.40541166067123413,
-0.28007790446281433,
0.13920967280864716,
-0.22190649807453156,
0.7486807107925415,
0.14453360438346863,
0.05244818329811096,
-0.36957409977912903,
-0.5799994468688965,
-0.2196348011493683,
-0.24966830015182495,
-0.714600682258606,
-0.2700513005256653,
0.5971168875694275,
0.8162321448326111,
0.6537850499153137,
0.6422032117843628,
0.6195416450500488,
0.25571122765541077,
-0.30392950773239136,
0.050283461809158325,
-0.6073323488235474,
-0.3000441789627075,
0.13252776861190796,
-0.6587145924568176,
-0.3577873408794403,
0.22235436737537384,
0.8579702377319336,
0.7639497518539429,
-0.005679751746356487,
0.8574714660644531,
0.09607493132352829,
0.6068748831748962,
-0.6809901595115662,
0.04252957925200462,
-0.5112959742546082,
-0.10747463256120682,
-0.34536290168762207,
0.20568034052848816,
-0.4275844097137451,
-0.6128584146499634,
-0.17662854492664337,
-0.275779664516449,
-0.03262706845998764,
0.1837242692708969,
0.3882375955581665,
0.21876850724220276,
-0.22794485092163086,
-0.15783439576625824,
-0.510696530342102,
1.0277422666549683,
-0.863186776638031,
0.362333744764328,
0.17665639519691467,
0.6117133498191833,
-0.10030636936426163,
-0.6984043121337891,
-0.3822910785675049,
-0.4299684166908264,
0.08970506489276886,
-0.20109443366527557,
-0.37296262383461,
-0.23597821593284607,
0.34037715196609497,
0.36364132165908813,
-0.3743596076965332,
0.49472472071647644,
-0.1982310563325882,
-0.1298842430114746,
0.5565250515937805,
0.5392417311668396,
-0.06289113312959671,
-0.13894757628440857,
0.06797263771295547,
-0.37265661358833313,
-1.0741640329360962,
0.006880462635308504,
0.3951191306114197,
0.1575639247894287,
0.045992083847522736,
0.5309208631515503,
-0.13996869325637817,
0.534084677696228,
-0.17390283942222595,
-0.4987032413482666,
0.17184622585773468,
-0.5099494457244873,
-0.30448105931282043,
-0.44321882724761963,
0.7291575074195862,
0.38935360312461853,
-0.11563276499509811,
-0.175775945186615,
-0.21995055675506592,
0.1426560878753662,
0.11499890685081482,
-0.9257017374038696,
-0.17541302740573883,
0.1452910155057907,
-0.624835729598999,
-0.32403281331062317,
-0.40216466784477234,
-0.7980760335922241,
-0.3812640905380249,
0.025859622284770012,
0.35348886251449585,
-0.21864214539527893,
0.19948525726795197,
-0.2842118740081787,
-0.06334523856639862,
0.24298284947872162,
0.4324725866317749,
-0.5052255988121033,
0.6073436737060547,
0.8096233010292053,
0.8188320994377136,
-0.32503828406333923,
-0.28412309288978577,
-0.7421255111694336,
-0.328997403383255,
-0.49102574586868286,
0.8393265008926392,
-0.5501976609230042,
-0.6010046005249023,
-0.21686866879463196,
-0.17423197627067566,
0.17524629831314087,
-0.9848043322563171,
0.5414588451385498,
-0.4415568709373474,
0.04138784110546112,
-0.35659143328666687,
-0.5926069021224976,
-0.004871280863881111,
0.13739387691020966,
-0.8951565623283386,
1.0505889654159546,
0.23436212539672852,
-0.3578547239303589,
0.2948218584060669,
-0.5734140872955322,
-0.20902138948440552,
-0.019967034459114075,
-0.2549377679824829,
-0.3670051693916321,
0.471712589263916,
0.17418219149112701,
0.18460369110107422,
-0.6021046042442322,
-0.28398439288139343,
-0.5070925951004028,
-0.6547040343284607,
0.15014240145683289,
-0.4306216537952423,
0.6176860928535461,
0.2897683382034302,
-0.26671841740608215,
0.1727917343378067,
-0.8223832845687866,
0.17521172761917114,
0.1098555475473404,
-0.5753178596496582,
-0.29212284088134766,
-0.0939258486032486,
0.17086392641067505,
0.09384336322546005,
0.1254263073205948,
-0.27870669960975647,
0.0816214382648468,
-0.5428812503814697,
0.16552530229091644,
0.8698504567146301,
-0.0620168037712574,
0.40986666083335876,
-0.5757869482040405,
0.7585592269897461,
-0.1927730292081833,
0.3028118312358856,
0.3217613399028778,
-0.5221593379974365,
-1.0664530992507935,
-0.3314536213874817,
0.5294766426086426,
0.05215463042259216,
-0.5588589310646057,
0.10935067385435104,
-0.2790835201740265,
-0.8961719274520874,
-1.0188895463943481,
0.6954318284988403,
0.49746468663215637,
0.07914455980062485,
0.12487661838531494,
-0.17054936289787292,
-0.3541676104068756,
-1.1057053804397583,
-0.46061357855796814,
-0.24280735850334167,
-0.220812126994133,
0.45018407702445984,
0.5242810845375061,
-0.09045485407114029,
0.835310697555542,
-0.302432119846344,
-0.10015985369682312,
-0.24909231066703796,
0.08418584614992142,
0.2563953101634979,
0.3125232458114624,
0.8444962501525879,
-0.38028720021247864,
-0.37361428141593933,
-0.2038087099790573,
-0.16663658618927002,
-0.17267808318138123,
0.1599162518978119,
0.30445045232772827,
0.03651906177401543,
0.49140796065330505,
-0.44747450947761536,
0.06102891266345978,
0.5927016139030457,
-0.022200895473361015,
0.6023578643798828,
-0.02503223344683647,
-0.02172151952981949,
-0.5950880646705627,
0.00415447074919939,
-0.2645520865917206,
-0.2948271632194519,
-0.2153719812631607,
0.5279290080070496,
0.17663173377513885,
-0.02586369216442108,
-0.6716306209564209,
0.9643574953079224,
-0.48649919033050537,
-0.2517445385456085,
-0.07660557329654694,
0.399319052696228,
-0.008182656019926071,
0.2812221050262451,
-0.5841963291168213,
0.964992880821228,
0.1352909505367279,
-0.5078022480010986,
0.1920747607946396,
0.029896579682826996,
-0.701273500919342,
0.3170028030872345,
-0.5539990067481995,
0.21642979979515076,
0.18383201956748962,
-0.16593734920024872,
-0.9862126111984253,
0.22329175472259521,
0.057436175644397736,
0.17144589126110077,
-0.0278478991240263,
-0.16067127883434296,
-0.8468730449676514,
-0.5703011751174927,
-0.8772270679473877,
0.1972581148147583,
0.793679416179657,
-0.730320394039154,
0.28139492869377136,
0.21194827556610107,
-0.3272857367992401,
-0.3009011745452881,
-0.5927555561065674,
-0.04640991613268852,
-0.46744677424430847,
-0.27107879519462585,
0.020008279010653496,
-0.5426639914512634,
-0.4213903844356537,
-0.017467724159359932,
-0.3221592307090759,
0.1361217349767685,
0.5060105323791504,
0.24169966578483582,
0.04706040397286415,
-0.4439794421195984,
0.29362377524375916,
-0.12317065894603729,
-0.09983807057142258,
-0.16004738211631775,
0.2739798426628113,
0.45659339427948,
-0.6711689233779907,
-0.720820963382721,
0.0206054225564003,
0.044693659991025925,
0.5231785774230957,
0.038711659610271454,
0.4747241735458374,
0.5022217035293579,
-0.2570078670978546,
-0.397731751203537,
-0.8275198936462402,
-0.1706327348947525,
-0.5054843425750732,
0.2622363865375519,
-0.411472886800766,
-1.04697847366333,
0.47828489542007446,
-0.3036552667617798,
0.10271256417036057,
0.4266870617866516,
0.7173886895179749,
0.03563582897186279,
0.800678014755249,
0.45784792304039,
-0.2549373507499695,
0.27457135915756226,
-0.06429791450500488,
-0.03609953075647354,
-0.7754879593849182,
0.230337992310524,
-0.6272730827331543,
-0.38528427481651306,
-0.5440037846565247,
-0.8517410755157471,
0.32836711406707764,
0.2405714988708496,
0.05259205773472786,
0.2786429524421692,
-0.13177204132080078,
0.7755244374275208,
0.5146586298942566,
-0.0722978413105011,
0.5535668134689331,
-0.17524833977222443,
-0.35521045327186584,
-0.11914097517728806,
-0.8927649855613708,
-0.9895309209823608,
1.3824946880340576,
0.3446824550628662,
0.7673958539962769,
0.49193307757377625,
0.7633349299430847,
0.29082098603248596,
0.7042108774185181,
-0.9358903765678406,
0.7463979721069336,
-0.21530257165431976,
-0.42131417989730835,
-0.29237204790115356,
-0.44267576932907104,
-0.7297443151473999,
0.4393823742866516,
-0.07026562094688416,
-0.7977542877197266,
0.16152264177799225,
-0.024256691336631775,
-0.5945510268211365,
0.059859637171030045,
-0.7785089015960693,
0.9172704219818115,
-0.12282320857048035,
-0.2553107738494873,
-0.43570998311042786,
-0.02391204424202442,
0.4360193610191345,
-0.500214695930481,
0.3057817816734314,
-0.1959688812494278,
-0.31006231904029846,
0.8628191947937012,
-0.5612413287162781,
0.7122825980186462,
0.17303067445755005,
-0.010580917820334435,
0.27548208832740784,
0.19199414551258087,
0.48566898703575134,
0.16287197172641754,
-0.3521635830402374,
-0.06378638744354248,
0.26144418120384216,
-0.3695383369922638,
-0.5123216509819031,
0.9890269041061401,
-0.6477708220481873,
-0.6755689382553101,
-0.07288610190153122,
-0.22082267701625824,
-0.4660443961620331,
0.1784820556640625,
0.026616008952260017,
0.24779565632343292,
-0.5654641389846802,
0.2492062747478485,
0.21268928050994873,
-0.11976692825555801,
0.6095224618911743,
0.6607615947723389,
-0.35910168290138245,
-0.22291164100170135,
0.7371906638145447,
0.30718928575515747,
0.0970785841345787,
-0.04781152680516243,
0.34876716136932373,
-0.2433214783668518,
-0.8815230131149292,
-0.3786114454269409,
0.2825718820095062,
-0.8711656332015991,
-0.0879853144288063,
-0.391640305519104,
0.2877255082130432,
-0.08367562294006348,
0.06739342212677002,
-0.615425169467926,
-0.5401670336723328,
-0.23465047776699066,
-0.0451737642288208,
0.2118474692106247,
0.6741563677787781,
-0.0036425632424652576,
0.5189907550811768,
-0.6826817989349365,
0.3357158899307251,
0.6552194952964783,
0.5809288620948792,
0.23912665247917175,
-0.4214836657047272,
-0.21037474274635315,
-0.22052808105945587,
-0.23707903921604156,
-0.48709920048713684,
-0.00456314068287611,
0.14818480610847473,
0.792885422706604,
0.5187917351722717,
0.05807219445705414,
0.8172707557678223,
-0.6667235493659973,
0.7101609706878662,
0.09096004068851471,
-0.9780594110488892,
0.39990225434303284,
0.09274785220623016,
0.3173049986362457,
0.8817883729934692,
0.11116324365139008,
-0.22707220911979675,
-0.4457559585571289,
-0.6889932751655579,
-0.4608214497566223,
0.5574537515640259,
0.15135620534420013,
-0.061720363795757294,
-0.11489182710647583,
0.07221926003694534,
0.05999945104122162,
0.3254566788673401,
-0.5062786340713501,
-0.27172186970710754,
0.4315149188041687,
-0.05402272567152977,
-0.413389652967453,
-0.5331162810325623,
-0.4339102804660797,
-0.09926234185695648,
0.5136590600013733,
-0.2874317169189453,
-0.04247870668768883,
-0.36387404799461365,
-0.35131126642227173,
0.10295049101114273,
0.6013470888137817,
0.48686665296554565,
0.7076516151428223,
-0.29794013500213623,
0.1212020069360733,
0.5368361473083496,
-0.07633979618549347,
0.31986233592033386,
-0.0015251816948875785,
-0.08413335680961609,
0.18039949238300323,
0.3527151942253113,
0.40376394987106323,
0.3783394694328308,
-0.9830659031867981,
0.5453779697418213,
-0.09106915444135666,
0.19348493218421936,
-0.04075062647461891,
0.08631769567728043,
0.4802410304546356,
0.45780643820762634,
0.12395565956830978,
-0.2239091545343399,
0.21705050766468048,
-0.5245143175125122,
0.15530140697956085,
0.4132593870162964,
-0.26007580757141113,
-0.027282841503620148,
0.2967207729816437,
0.10159579664468765,
-0.2966156303882599,
0.3059612810611725,
-0.32537832856178284,
0.022792192175984383,
0.6652774214744568,
0.10411345958709717,
0.6724228262901306,
-0.029008522629737854,
0.08995683491230011,
-0.04896937683224678,
0.6574090123176575,
-0.24387314915657043,
0.001317685702815652,
-0.056696031242609024,
-0.41981053352355957,
-0.22391018271446228,
-0.6158434152603149,
-0.7006329894065857,
0.18254785239696503,
-0.5361412763595581,
0.2568349540233612,
-0.7544398903846741,
-0.34756070375442505,
0.25916773080825806,
0.3141435384750366,
-0.9689303636550903,
-0.12362159043550491,
0.10334665328264236,
1.1565346717834473,
-0.6809757351875305,
0.7502571940422058,
0.6045135259628296,
-0.42758652567863464,
-0.63538658618927,
-0.35355260968208313,
0.1814398318529129,
-0.8604159355163574,
0.5517910122871399,
0.0016895269509404898,
-0.08670490980148315,
-0.25854238867759705,
-0.2283162772655487,
-0.5859842896461487,
0.9768345952033997,
0.4798206686973572,
-0.8270146250724792,
0.21351993083953857,
0.04038466885685921,
0.6184369325637817,
-0.2968316376209259,
0.35985374450683594,
0.9881307482719421,
0.5543432235717773,
-0.38334929943084717,
-0.9695701599121094,
0.10583190619945526,
-0.21288195252418518,
0.2100895792245865,
-0.04175011068582535,
-0.9216417074203491,
0.8699118494987488,
-0.3403230309486389,
-0.33247002959251404,
0.4322955012321472,
0.08062000572681427,
0.4939165413379669,
0.20159393548965454,
0.4167669415473938,
0.4743027985095978,
0.7359749674797058,
-0.017564164474606514,
1.0950183868408203,
-0.14145340025424957,
0.4559767246246338,
1.4543275833129883,
-0.339875727891922,
1.1684504747390747,
0.6574826240539551,
-0.44758468866348267,
0.23877383768558502,
0.6590170860290527,
-0.2959974408149719,
0.38962551951408386,
0.4041435122489929,
-0.17076599597930908,
-0.33663317561149597,
0.0009830003837123513,
-0.3590967059135437,
0.42544472217559814,
0.050283342599868774,
-0.2457541674375534,
-0.43078142404556274,
-0.08954232931137085,
0.04244793578982353,
-0.024949677288532257,
-0.22890083491802216,
0.7778540849685669,
0.1756620705127716,
-0.22830718755722046,
0.555998682975769,
0.26279696822166443,
0.5878534913063049,
-0.5202762484550476,
0.09374561905860901,
-0.5548442006111145,
0.09993396699428558,
-0.017328111454844475,
-0.36790725588798523,
0.09073694795370102,
0.07968424260616302,
0.013473233208060265,
-0.023717621341347694,
0.6627902984619141,
-0.004332406911998987,
-0.6958022713661194,
0.3782748878002167,
0.9898021817207336,
0.28970763087272644,
-0.006682219915091991,
-0.5732992887496948,
0.24315448105335236,
-0.26102331280708313,
-0.4516914486885071,
0.5897257328033447,
0.2735651731491089,
0.010604966431856155,
0.8775152564048767,
0.6278519034385681,
0.25414055585861206,
-0.0481753796339035,
0.24237455427646637,
0.889634907245636,
-0.6507310271263123,
-0.33488330245018005,
-0.9569337368011475,
-0.014478547498583794,
-0.008012883365154266,
-0.18898168206214905,
1.026679277420044,
0.7144182324409485,
0.8312127590179443,
-0.26793861389160156,
0.591511070728302,
0.38963255286216736,
0.49416080117225647,
-0.43478119373321533,
0.7844784259796143,
-0.712222158908844,
0.6675865054130554,
-0.34155988693237305,
-1.002291202545166,
-0.07443469762802124,
0.34157052636146545,
-0.26678240299224854,
0.1374157816171646,
0.5871565937995911,
0.7832653522491455,
-0.008211675100028515,
-0.10643017292022705,
0.6801536083221436,
0.1840401142835617,
0.24682015180587769,
0.5427812337875366,
0.959371030330658,
-0.5171966552734375,
0.7651795744895935,
-0.3736446797847748,
0.038944751024246216,
-0.5483990907669067,
-1.0174745321273804,
-0.8835461735725403,
0.04518361762166023,
-0.3849940001964569,
-0.04484562575817108,
-0.14256922900676727,
0.8390341997146606,
0.6570137739181519,
-0.8926857113838196,
-0.4585675895214081,
0.5210411548614502,
0.5504667162895203,
-0.3816358149051666,
-0.21670499444007874,
0.32224932312965393,
-0.21224099397659302,
-0.6994401216506958,
0.6140395998954773,
0.3088657259941101,
0.04090707749128342,
-0.3371623754501343,
-0.0825236365199089,
0.1665651947259903,
0.1894923448562622,
0.7645098567008972,
0.16120949387550354,
-0.8709349036216736,
-0.5783111453056335,
-0.2083725929260254,
-0.20317566394805908,
0.020104793831706047,
0.6628574728965759,
-0.8252984285354614,
0.2707556486129761,
0.16792668402194977,
0.8060001730918884,
0.4145181179046631,
-0.17851394414901733,
0.21513167023658752,
-0.7138964533805847,
0.13507910072803497,
0.1773107498884201,
0.3945588767528534,
0.19110062718391418,
0.2761193811893463,
0.7467817068099976,
-0.030711229890584946,
-0.1532655507326126,
-1.0233991146087646,
0.01744348369538784,
-0.9558665156364441,
-0.31703460216522217,
1.1102116107940674,
-0.16002024710178375,
-0.12569914758205414,
0.06676281988620758,
0.024880969896912575,
-0.2771632969379425,
-0.16944801807403564,
0.5393478274345398,
0.8931826949119568,
-0.061518386006355286,
-0.3491646647453308,
-0.644994854927063,
0.519145667552948,
0.4912058413028717,
-0.8212302327156067,
0.04009365662932396,
0.5222753286361694,
0.563789963722229,
0.20986394584178925,
0.6830471754074097,
-0.13510462641716003,
0.3940175473690033,
0.365159809589386,
-0.1609107255935669,
0.019613103941082954,
-0.11836283653974533,
-0.5882967710494995,
0.35983651876449585,
0.7353398203849792,
-0.06481340527534485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14979v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14979v2
|
Optimizing Language Models for Human Preferences is a Causal Inference Problem
| 2024-02-22T21:36:07 | 2024-06-05T23:19:19 |
Victoria Lin, Eli Ben-Michael, Louis-Philippe Morency
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ME
|
As large language models (LLMs) see greater use in academic and commercial
settings, there is increasing interest in methods that allow language models to
generate texts aligned with human preferences. In this paper, we present an
initial exploration of language model optimization for human preferences from
direct outcome datasets, where each sample consists of a text and an associated
numerical outcome measuring the reader's response. We first propose that
language model optimization should be viewed as a causal problem to ensure that
the model correctly learns the relationship between the text and the outcome.
We formalize this causal language optimization problem, and we develop a
method--causal preference optimization (CPO)--that solves an unbiased surrogate
objective for the problem. We further extend CPO with doubly robust CPO
(DR-CPO), which reduces the variance of the surrogate objective while retaining
provably strong guarantees on bias. Finally, we empirically demonstrate the
effectiveness of (DR-)CPO in optimizing state-of-the-art LLMs for human
preferences on direct outcome data, and we validate the robustness of DR-CPO
under difficult confounding conditions.
|
[
-0.2354445904493332,
-0.6196961402893066,
0.782846987247467,
0.23083683848381042,
-0.18764756619930267,
-0.25784537196159363,
-0.5839981436729431,
-0.18357591331005096,
-0.1976129561662674,
0.7602794170379639,
-0.49623027443885803,
-0.39755362272262573,
-0.4005529284477234,
0.31878727674484253,
0.08902884274721146,
0.8906537294387817,
0.0025412060786038637,
0.13834354281425476,
-0.27857139706611633,
0.08128155022859573,
-0.4770772159099579,
-0.6358840465545654,
-0.8911840319633484,
-0.4759131073951721,
0.6962494254112244,
0.466683954000473,
0.7542054057121277,
0.8321261405944824,
0.2846595048904419,
0.24667629599571228,
-0.018564332276582718,
0.22074398398399353,
-0.7094426155090332,
0.16610988974571228,
-0.20827054977416992,
-0.41984376311302185,
-0.045175738632678986,
0.05976805463433266,
0.482839971780777,
0.7428380250930786,
-0.10309659689664841,
-0.11860015988349915,
-0.053960517048835754,
0.7951960563659668,
-0.7447837591171265,
0.033012330532073975,
-0.5207033157348633,
-0.14836688339710236,
-0.012384237721562386,
-0.32929059863090515,
-0.73175048828125,
-0.6983534097671509,
0.4048592746257782,
-0.6449437141418457,
0.01520498190075159,
0.3496842086315155,
0.8004321455955505,
0.2837132513523102,
-0.6349275708198547,
-0.10502679646015167,
-0.7458544969558716,
1.1820334196090698,
-0.6252498030662537,
0.39244401454925537,
0.6186252236366272,
0.050965674221515656,
-0.43332332372665405,
-0.03126705437898636,
-0.4398183524608612,
-0.46845608949661255,
0.005953135434538126,
0.018124807626008987,
-0.1506892889738083,
0.29924172163009644,
-0.1256377100944519,
-0.07060748338699341,
-0.6078473329544067,
0.46955999732017517,
0.08659033477306366,
-0.08196329325437546,
0.6880277395248413,
0.17177541553974152,
0.42072561383247375,
-0.19541926681995392,
-0.24026067554950714,
-0.19893589615821838,
-0.6419085264205933,
0.17883092164993286,
0.6170551180839539,
0.40295714139938354,
0.06942843645811081,
0.47208166122436523,
-0.09716401994228363,
0.8217068314552307,
-0.027526725083589554,
-0.1880601942539215,
-0.16948264837265015,
-0.1319572478532791,
-0.074553944170475,
-0.022807152941823006,
0.7338180541992188,
0.3442995548248291,
0.5331724286079407,
-0.294697642326355,
-0.05627836287021637,
0.23146459460258484,
0.30067363381385803,
-0.5558902025222778,
0.04297236353158951,
0.2525918185710907,
-0.3558368384838104,
-0.6443096995353699,
-0.41247814893722534,
-0.7028342485427856,
-0.16146662831306458,
-0.7447389960289001,
0.06686120480298996,
0.003190433606505394,
-0.09231135994195938,
0.4959714114665985,
0.10256867110729218,
-0.08260023593902588,
0.10964681208133698,
-1.3297897577285767,
0.2955387234687805,
0.6277496814727783,
0.32751333713531494,
-0.24300077557563782,
-0.20415863394737244,
-0.4610741138458252,
0.21769848465919495,
-0.4968714714050293,
0.6660511493682861,
-0.580190122127533,
-0.4801861345767975,
0.07675781100988388,
-0.37147465348243713,
0.00764472084119916,
-0.2459181249141693,
1.1460002660751343,
-0.679483950138092,
0.2890005111694336,
-0.41264426708221436,
-0.5022985339164734,
0.029294118285179138,
-0.041014380753040314,
-0.483048677444458,
0.8370873332023621,
-0.19575373828411102,
-0.9375184178352356,
0.5473656058311462,
-0.22677823901176453,
-0.4352479875087738,
-0.4620459973812103,
-0.24940581619739532,
-0.5005382895469666,
0.349282830953598,
0.11497435718774796,
0.31470975279808044,
-0.8911048173904419,
1.0198798179626465,
-0.40943586826324463,
-0.15989325940608978,
0.16465257108211517,
-0.3772764205932617,
0.6670506596565247,
0.10909082740545273,
-0.25158703327178955,
0.2088998407125473,
-0.6131829023361206,
-0.5455369353294373,
0.32657644152641296,
-0.6294045448303223,
-0.8538283705711365,
0.6337344646453857,
-0.0693962424993515,
-0.03425808995962143,
0.2648158073425293,
-0.5096808671951294,
0.07485756278038025,
-0.483148455619812,
0.15776927769184113,
1.0897972583770752,
-0.12368904799222946,
0.550503134727478,
-0.1489596962928772,
0.2278113067150116,
-0.27371567487716675,
0.43677544593811035,
0.45883554220199585,
-0.13473276793956757,
-0.663782000541687,
-0.18218933045864105,
-0.09040211886167526,
0.387920081615448,
-0.42163994908332825,
0.6261742115020752,
-0.13378621637821198,
0.013266514055430889,
-0.15371419489383698,
0.07028735429048538,
0.553001344203949,
0.9000365138053894,
0.09911434352397919,
0.1285003274679184,
-0.4044870138168335,
-1.3264375925064087,
-0.4612995982170105,
-0.48457667231559753,
0.13210447132587433,
0.5348601341247559,
-0.041765227913856506,
-0.2466851770877838,
1.0427978038787842,
-0.9432111978530884,
0.2251085638999939,
-0.23980845510959625,
-0.06261955946683884,
0.40026170015335083,
0.29892587661743164,
0.8072890639305115,
-1.0311652421951294,
-0.3447732627391815,
0.08165494352579117,
-0.5058717727661133,
-0.3993505537509918,
-0.11380182951688766,
-0.4042604863643646,
0.306820809841156,
-0.03656378015875816,
-0.14581647515296936,
0.020775500684976578,
0.4838365912437439,
-0.13132430613040924,
0.7078183889389038,
-0.32131239771842957,
0.22439312934875488,
-0.8056551814079285,
0.15282395482063293,
0.333792507648468,
-0.04447415843605995,
-0.7039484977722168,
-0.18985998630523682,
-0.06985403597354889,
-0.10827306658029556,
-0.15783460438251495,
0.7859864234924316,
-0.21948650479316711,
0.3621061146259308,
-0.36382627487182617,
0.22181081771850586,
-0.0349942184984684,
0.6703727841377258,
0.5407853126525879,
0.39100590348243713,
0.5281305313110352,
-0.5870633721351624,
-0.09025664627552032,
0.37665238976478577,
-0.04752605780959129,
0.24446715414524078,
-0.6006935834884644,
0.16490936279296875,
-0.5121979117393494,
-0.12166160345077515,
-0.9754438400268555,
-0.2623642683029175,
-0.07395181059837341,
-0.2230004072189331,
0.38524264097213745,
0.06503885984420776,
-0.39747679233551025,
-0.32109615206718445,
-0.35538896918296814,
0.4655718207359314,
0.29587841033935547,
-0.668639600276947,
0.24014440178871155,
0.6032030582427979,
-0.04624595493078232,
-0.6756213903427124,
-0.19158023595809937,
-0.04010164737701416,
-0.39028650522232056,
-0.4532415270805359,
0.0184396430850029,
-0.17200824618339539,
-0.3390575647354126,
-0.3137122094631195,
-0.04291541874408722,
0.01304893009364605,
0.051580581814050674,
-0.136209636926651,
0.5410968065261841,
0.1348601132631302,
0.06794694066047668,
0.4035604000091553,
-0.5365291833877563,
-0.017023930326104164,
-0.2973083555698395,
0.3535923361778259,
0.20100528001785278,
-0.07660771161317825,
-0.2765357494354248,
0.4311622679233551,
0.1043202206492424,
0.12453007698059082,
0.4893052875995636,
0.010329400189220905,
-0.2358722686767578,
-0.2347123622894287,
-0.739540696144104,
-0.3376027047634125,
-0.46941542625427246,
0.3722694516181946,
-0.2503625154495239,
-0.9067993760108948,
0.038146257400512695,
-0.06746061146259308,
0.0048237089067697525,
0.17758917808532715,
0.5127756595611572,
0.26758140325546265,
1.1228461265563965,
0.4770328104496002,
-0.5762904286384583,
0.3693632185459137,
0.36713653802871704,
0.14773020148277283,
-0.5732647180557251,
-0.05356708914041519,
-0.9079297780990601,
0.06312013417482376,
-0.65049809217453,
-0.08005885779857635,
0.42178794741630554,
0.22565895318984985,
-0.5444031357765198,
0.38533836603164673,
-0.4714242219924927,
0.43485602736473083,
0.7842566967010498,
0.2906169295310974,
0.31111064553260803,
0.05306350439786911,
-0.33251768350601196,
-0.40701913833618164,
-0.6158708333969116,
-0.6576813459396362,
1.0557090044021606,
0.1557960957288742,
0.9161585569381714,
0.0783226490020752,
0.5895992517471313,
0.1090649738907814,
0.24208946526050568,
-0.45341622829437256,
0.4210445284843445,
-0.35707005858421326,
-0.6924855709075928,
-0.33699387311935425,
-0.6567355394363403,
-0.901121199131012,
0.2816042900085449,
-0.24742180109024048,
-0.9961491227149963,
0.4529355764389038,
0.3794703483581543,
0.11719050258398056,
-0.038874123245477676,
-0.6639750599861145,
0.9569623470306396,
-0.4433496296405792,
-0.6749753355979919,
-0.30232346057891846,
-0.7925955057144165,
0.4381409287452698,
-0.2699893116950989,
0.2078094780445099,
-0.1417037397623062,
-0.027049127966165543,
0.5092155337333679,
-0.15713578462600708,
0.9451101422309875,
0.13195325434207916,
0.04192586988210678,
0.0243033729493618,
0.16463427245616913,
0.5847672820091248,
0.1476527899503708,
-0.5147004127502441,
0.05390447378158569,
-0.23335832357406616,
-0.3313904106616974,
-0.4071729779243469,
0.7575487494468689,
-1.0057663917541504,
-0.8638756275177002,
-0.2673867344856262,
-0.29049980640411377,
-0.4134902060031891,
0.3532041907310486,
-0.05713767185807228,
0.4544833302497864,
-0.43186134099960327,
-0.20387855172157288,
0.49271705746650696,
-0.6708584427833557,
0.38262179493904114,
0.6652886271476746,
-0.014668717980384827,
-0.4730711281299591,
0.6876192092895508,
-0.5176879167556763,
0.41168782114982605,
0.9280151128768921,
0.9374375939369202,
-0.47763335704803467,
-0.5191119909286499,
-0.3111763000488281,
0.4996965825557709,
-0.5477144718170166,
-0.001291732769459486,
-0.4723692238330841,
0.36257898807525635,
-0.20987185835838318,
-0.524498462677002,
-0.22129172086715698,
0.014190366491675377,
-0.5043287873268127,
-0.027789440006017685,
0.15405073761940002,
0.3790838420391083,
-0.12395910918712616,
0.09115961939096451,
-0.4667542576789856,
0.28547346591949463,
0.21207837760448456,
0.09604636579751968,
-0.03019336611032486,
-0.3479168117046356,
-0.060066282749176025,
-0.07889753580093384,
-0.20976775884628296,
-0.7618213891983032,
0.5915637016296387,
-0.07929610460996628,
0.6098151206970215,
0.6685333847999573,
0.2906050682067871,
0.32530853152275085,
-0.6483774185180664,
0.3208092451095581,
0.2697473466396332,
-0.8665512800216675,
0.7782459259033203,
-0.7337352633476257,
-0.08199810981750488,
0.6943173408508301,
0.6037750840187073,
-0.37557145953178406,
-0.2385936975479126,
-0.22112023830413818,
-0.6697083711624146,
0.7714601755142212,
0.23654374480247498,
0.23805668950080872,
-0.4543420672416687,
0.6923348903656006,
0.14197421073913574,
0.24925172328948975,
-0.689690351486206,
-0.30282163619995117,
0.34463590383529663,
-0.11806751042604446,
-0.2445906698703766,
-0.40857547521591187,
-0.18704436719417572,
-0.018956463783979416,
0.8083786964416504,
-0.1558416485786438,
-0.1615002453327179,
0.1527542769908905,
0.13383029401302338,
-0.24472300708293915,
0.1554504632949829,
0.6890270113945007,
0.6479696035385132,
-0.4382498860359192,
0.10403440147638321,
-0.1473420411348343,
-0.3411876857280731,
0.26314711570739746,
0.03163507580757141,
-0.4029259979724884,
-0.3391664922237396,
0.19333483278751373,
0.8255336284637451,
0.4963843524456024,
-0.7545304894447327,
0.4477890133857727,
-0.09217146039009094,
0.22210116684436798,
0.07750321179628372,
-0.047600459307432175,
-0.07929016649723053,
-0.05389666557312012,
0.27413612604141235,
-0.11069024354219437,
0.25715571641921997,
-0.22726701200008392,
-0.004608975723385811,
0.44631117582321167,
-0.23951192200183868,
-0.3272804021835327,
1.0090817213058472,
0.31710338592529297,
-0.38293468952178955,
0.2809419333934784,
0.18659865856170654,
-0.42783117294311523,
0.43655288219451904,
0.7901977896690369,
0.965380072593689,
-0.19431304931640625,
0.24470661580562592,
0.43251466751098633,
0.23313027620315552,
-0.29066237807273865,
-0.003957444801926613,
0.04922615364193916,
-1.1044397354125977,
-0.34344178438186646,
-0.7526869177818298,
-0.4691409766674042,
-0.3124149739742279,
-0.5722931623458862,
0.5432919263839722,
-0.17216165363788605,
-0.2108420580625534,
-0.05423528701066971,
0.07311230152845383,
-0.5738266706466675,
0.36092114448547363,
-0.2547144293785095,
0.4863464832305908,
-0.8133116364479065,
0.7553471326828003,
0.381647527217865,
-0.32038792967796326,
-0.7807343006134033,
-0.28904831409454346,
0.0732138380408287,
-0.9943499565124512,
0.8336710929870605,
-0.29179200530052185,
-0.15902836620807648,
0.030765756964683533,
-0.2836282253265381,
-0.6733846068382263,
0.5675688982009888,
0.8106732964515686,
-0.7082497477531433,
0.11897836625576019,
0.21422240138053894,
0.4139859676361084,
-0.21348127722740173,
0.08068951219320297,
0.5583282709121704,
0.5226879119873047,
-0.2027789056301117,
-0.584929347038269,
0.10393153876066208,
0.27190062403678894,
0.2552126348018646,
0.40468916296958923,
-0.7233656644821167,
0.22186675667762756,
-0.2723681628704071,
0.08062422275543213,
-0.21313315629959106,
0.36217358708381653,
0.5053293704986572,
0.015436634421348572,
0.47817912697792053,
0.42686769366264343,
0.4939391016960144,
0.0991843044757843,
1.440460443496704,
-0.2889426350593567,
0.41349440813064575,
0.8821848034858704,
-0.2805827260017395,
0.6452329158782959,
0.6171810626983643,
-0.294899582862854,
0.10183015465736389,
0.9163035154342651,
0.49338117241859436,
0.677826464176178,
0.38579386472702026,
-0.3736588954925537,
-0.46862083673477173,
-0.2521858215332031,
0.08288823813199997,
0.25208544731140137,
-0.1603756844997406,
-0.3527827858924866,
-0.02000763826072216,
-0.21203060448169708,
0.2579169273376465,
0.40962523221969604,
0.1678263247013092,
0.7454869151115417,
-0.007026348263025284,
-0.8049164414405823,
0.3896709680557251,
0.03941012918949127,
0.3732527792453766,
-0.5672105550765991,
0.3503861129283905,
-0.41042986512184143,
0.06706199049949646,
0.12961679697036743,
-0.32027700543403625,
0.06944238394498825,
-0.12776102125644684,
-0.3652993440628052,
-0.06998299062252045,
0.7447049021720886,
-0.39285919070243835,
-0.6003091931343079,
0.503328800201416,
0.09060746431350708,
0.007989713922142982,
0.08590050041675568,
-0.3605048954486847,
0.1910560578107834,
0.07237665355205536,
-0.42667821049690247,
0.374665766954422,
0.0809536874294281,
-0.1441473811864853,
0.6507952809333801,
0.7246953248977661,
0.24218039214611053,
-0.42508193850517273,
0.35986030101776123,
0.7938924431800842,
-0.5319831371307373,
-0.34884166717529297,
-1.077176570892334,
0.31479665637016296,
-0.01261371374130249,
-0.3843919336795807,
0.5425707101821899,
0.6935226321220398,
0.5318583250045776,
-0.1375964879989624,
0.7061483263969421,
0.41515323519706726,
0.2799760699272156,
-0.4697675108909607,
0.4759470820426941,
-0.6015457510948181,
0.12495680153369904,
-0.6516482830047607,
-1.0569555759429932,
-0.5325639247894287,
0.41016778349876404,
-0.6015955805778503,
-0.09643853455781937,
0.5613424777984619,
0.7530388236045837,
0.19121500849723816,
-0.029531575739383698,
0.412254273891449,
-0.14848056435585022,
0.22276213765144348,
0.6511889696121216,
0.5648812651634216,
-0.044352076947689056,
0.21598228812217712,
-0.10009551048278809,
-0.6662106513977051,
-0.08225012570619583,
-1.1342626810073853,
-1.0006049871444702,
-0.5973703265190125,
-0.16420981287956238,
-0.11063630878925323,
0.27063947916030884,
0.9287378787994385,
0.6178800463676453,
-0.6443392634391785,
-0.5496673583984375,
-0.1715611070394516,
0.3896716833114624,
0.18971559405326843,
-0.1846632957458496,
0.546445369720459,
-0.48923957347869873,
-0.963573157787323,
0.3394940495491028,
0.38472607731819153,
-0.10510683059692383,
-0.08285263180732727,
-0.2318846583366394,
-0.21554407477378845,
0.33385148644447327,
0.5411706566810608,
0.28651493787765503,
-0.7183728814125061,
-0.5373461842536926,
0.12346555292606354,
-0.0726638063788414,
-0.056015744805336,
1.1060376167297363,
-0.2966591417789459,
0.6536430716514587,
0.42272454500198364,
0.9111420512199402,
0.506804347038269,
0.1384705901145935,
1.053591251373291,
-0.4924609661102295,
0.14325784146785736,
0.13756604492664337,
0.40848278999328613,
0.1462220698595047,
-0.5300891399383545,
0.49372801184654236,
0.12343514710664749,
-0.8301113843917847,
-0.7626428008079529,
0.2623578608036041,
-0.9960309267044067,
-0.4159148037433624,
1.2239030599594116,
0.19238223135471344,
-0.03756941854953766,
-0.06291826069355011,
-0.2888041138648987,
0.19190961122512817,
-0.6045316457748413,
0.9142487049102783,
0.4918825924396515,
-0.2557477653026581,
0.07570527493953705,
-0.3974525034427643,
0.5858393907546997,
0.5855653882026672,
-0.8100539445877075,
0.18059100210666656,
0.6629010438919067,
0.21184876561164856,
-0.17954443395137787,
0.6421347260475159,
0.10187910497188568,
-0.05252187326550484,
-0.26831403374671936,
0.15184880793094635,
0.26420536637306213,
-0.17819082736968994,
-0.19191639125347137,
-0.2327340841293335,
0.28316977620124817,
0.03578562289476395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14973v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14973v2
|
Introducing GenCeption for Multimodal LLM Benchmarking: You May Bypass Annotations
| 2024-02-22T21:22:04 | 2024-06-09T21:10:34 |
Lele Cao, Valentin Buchner, Zineb Senane, Fangkai Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.7; I.4
|
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) are commonly evaluated using costly
annotated multimodal benchmarks. However, these benchmarks often struggle to
keep pace with the rapidly advancing requirements of MLLM evaluation. We
propose GenCeption, a novel and annotation-free MLLM evaluation framework that
merely requires unimodal data to assess inter-modality semantic coherence and
inversely reflects the models' inclination to hallucinate. Analogous to the
popular DrawCeption game, GenCeption initiates with a non-textual sample and
undergoes a series of iterative description and generation steps. Semantic
drift across iterations is quantified using the GC@T metric. Our empirical
findings validate GenCeption's efficacy, showing strong correlations with
popular MLLM benchmarking results. GenCeption may be extended to mitigate
training data contamination by utilizing ubiquitous, previously unseen unimodal
data.
|
[
-0.544153094291687,
-0.5560320019721985,
0.48424193263053894,
0.24135392904281616,
-0.35988131165504456,
0.20200340449810028,
-0.24334166944026947,
-0.35403376817703247,
-0.2817719578742981,
0.39514580368995667,
-0.7751070261001587,
-0.6988570094108582,
-0.34907466173171997,
-0.1107184886932373,
-0.49336332082748413,
0.6437253355979919,
-0.14741173386573792,
0.10539525002241135,
-0.9268564581871033,
-0.5500921010971069,
-0.3087417185306549,
-0.5188472867012024,
-0.21526919305324554,
-0.40849122405052185,
0.425521582365036,
0.19297653436660767,
0.47713568806648254,
0.3705749809741974,
0.41298025846481323,
0.31655722856521606,
0.15888024866580963,
0.39789584279060364,
-0.41331183910369873,
0.2640219032764435,
0.054073650389909744,
-0.3976009488105774,
-0.168804332613945,
0.2288748323917389,
0.6045376062393188,
0.9098532795906067,
-0.04534221068024635,
0.28964322805404663,
0.21732620894908905,
0.47491613030433655,
-0.9060792922973633,
0.08819399774074554,
-0.6955395340919495,
0.34292590618133545,
-0.22493982315063477,
-0.5069489479064941,
-0.5921596884727478,
-0.15509438514709473,
-0.18816827237606049,
-0.6710099577903748,
0.31243154406547546,
0.1452886015176773,
0.7349501848220825,
0.4634931683540344,
-0.4565645754337311,
-0.1477808803319931,
-0.5442220568656921,
0.7761598825454712,
-0.4864656627178192,
0.6193553805351257,
0.3537590801715851,
0.35597893595695496,
-0.06141061335802078,
-0.31348538398742676,
-0.576391339302063,
-0.5493534803390503,
0.06273631006479263,
0.23307053744792938,
0.12206918001174927,
0.07699993252754211,
0.41115471720695496,
0.17671428620815277,
-0.5241450071334839,
0.22985370457172394,
0.1197013184428215,
-0.20657791197299957,
0.6254620552062988,
0.3124198019504547,
0.3384644091129303,
-0.10857109725475311,
-0.776896595954895,
-0.16915413737297058,
-0.687137246131897,
-0.21110573410987854,
0.48206958174705505,
0.048717107623815536,
-0.2129220813512802,
0.622136652469635,
-0.18962495028972626,
0.3314051628112793,
-0.19799527525901794,
-0.03202067315578461,
0.6293927431106567,
-0.46545034646987915,
-0.28636088967323303,
-0.18745829164981842,
0.7999148964881897,
0.5515663623809814,
0.23194356262683868,
-0.5911937952041626,
-0.06330398470163345,
0.2717057466506958,
-0.025944406166672707,
-0.8027122020721436,
-0.19217829406261444,
0.17907574772834778,
-0.43229031562805176,
-0.2581998407840729,
-0.15543818473815918,
-1.2583234310150146,
-0.7382775545120239,
-0.14462381601333618,
0.31250688433647156,
-0.4708847105503082,
-0.21906490623950958,
-0.18058031797409058,
-0.2502538859844208,
0.11697583645582199,
0.3535730838775635,
-1.011159062385559,
-0.15400534868240356,
0.9010341763496399,
0.6994388699531555,
-0.11618129163980484,
-0.3708960711956024,
-0.49722665548324585,
0.13555310666561127,
-0.3466850817203522,
0.9968857169151306,
-0.5953736901283264,
-0.5697693228721619,
-0.13875369727611542,
-0.15157775580883026,
-0.3766213655471802,
-0.8293706178665161,
0.46746349334716797,
-0.10250692069530487,
0.1677110344171524,
-0.016583872959017754,
-0.7805649638175964,
-0.1393747329711914,
0.16340409219264984,
-0.5616598129272461,
0.9598202705383301,
0.10205857455730438,
-0.7261801958084106,
0.9986922144889832,
-0.5226325988769531,
-0.21729886531829834,
0.26076585054397583,
-0.49241092801094055,
-0.4771971106529236,
0.2935589551925659,
0.11276347190141678,
0.16522124409675598,
-0.22909262776374817,
0.3658500611782074,
-0.7440868020057678,
-0.2606019973754883,
0.26097342371940613,
-0.7866516709327698,
0.7013830542564392,
0.2831723093986511,
-0.4255240857601166,
0.4150295555591583,
-1.0634620189666748,
0.05232810601592064,
-0.15357764065265656,
-0.13716264069080353,
-0.6858482360839844,
0.17218059301376343,
0.05020910128951073,
0.22356602549552917,
-0.10914865881204605,
-0.6405202746391296,
0.154036283493042,
0.1386720836162567,
0.04633272811770439,
0.8783388733863831,
-0.2843005955219269,
0.40298083424568176,
-0.33107897639274597,
0.4061902165412903,
-0.09266846626996994,
0.4106261730194092,
-0.0637686625123024,
-0.4662509560585022,
-0.8588406443595886,
-0.6975162625312805,
-0.008544297888875008,
0.37462541460990906,
-0.9516516327857971,
0.19578655064105988,
-0.21105645596981049,
-0.4222911298274994,
-0.8419470191001892,
0.5694224238395691,
0.37276285886764526,
0.3456072509288788,
0.3737955093383789,
-0.06654240190982819,
-0.5397051572799683,
-0.8701642155647278,
-0.2540946304798126,
-0.02925879694521427,
-0.15473222732543945,
0.22114324569702148,
0.2501981258392334,
-0.512778103351593,
0.7839966416358948,
0.07872993499040604,
-0.3769870102405548,
-0.11559343338012695,
0.5892236232757568,
-0.31526482105255127,
0.552165150642395,
0.3415594696998596,
-0.5832130908966064,
0.07813159376382828,
-0.15960578620433807,
-1.349971055984497,
-0.30150166153907776,
-0.37999477982521057,
-0.07065399736166,
0.30596762895584106,
0.7512646317481995,
-0.5484787821769714,
0.355284720659256,
0.7797425389289856,
-0.5479596853256226,
0.1826736330986023,
-0.24113844335079193,
0.20144225656986237,
-0.8817065954208374,
0.09261895716190338,
-0.16353920102119446,
0.02842852845788002,
-0.3816216289997101,
0.27638745307922363,
0.12389148771762848,
0.18658103048801422,
-0.2819270193576813,
0.4029211401939392,
-0.4871147572994232,
-0.00974250864237547,
0.008104240521788597,
0.15691328048706055,
0.06308362632989883,
0.1968674212694168,
-0.1957416981458664,
0.6964743733406067,
0.04517541453242302,
-0.24280382692813873,
0.3598647117614746,
0.15895316004753113,
-0.6035101413726807,
0.7179276347160339,
-0.20518508553504944,
0.13909630477428436,
-0.3931373953819275,
-0.00947688426822424,
-1.0575698614120483,
0.005448765121400356,
0.08278810977935791,
-0.1645835041999817,
0.08738356828689575,
-0.04428455978631973,
-0.5142780542373657,
-0.31623876094818115,
-0.6131584644317627,
0.4659104347229004,
0.3377217948436737,
-0.7839820384979248,
0.831524670124054,
-0.042438995093107224,
0.37685129046440125,
-0.4117392301559448,
-0.6385894417762756,
0.15802797675132751,
-0.5271071195602417,
-0.6213667988777161,
-0.12861011922359467,
-0.40914949774742126,
-0.3976324200630188,
-0.0741681456565857,
0.1217431053519249,
0.1704719513654709,
0.4772149920463562,
0.6682054400444031,
0.36185958981513977,
-0.06941147893667221,
0.23228728771209717,
-0.0955752283334732,
-0.19617976248264313,
0.04901440814137459,
0.1081768348813057,
0.6253710985183716,
0.15029580891132355,
-0.8843189477920532,
-0.3227788805961609,
0.3342280387878418,
0.5663003325462341,
-0.039277102798223495,
0.2334013134241104,
0.7174236178398132,
-0.0834622010588646,
-0.2362247109413147,
-0.8480890989303589,
0.11885064095258713,
-0.4761449098587036,
0.41227561235427856,
-0.4564444124698639,
-0.7174541354179382,
0.4004760682582855,
-0.1537170708179474,
-0.09255791455507278,
0.2651151716709137,
0.4685457646846771,
-0.12233304977416992,
0.82431560754776,
0.44195374846458435,
0.3740672469139099,
0.23766659200191498,
-0.09676247090101242,
-0.15057699382305145,
-0.9550912380218506,
-0.5623947978019714,
-0.27903425693511963,
-0.2786293625831604,
-0.4993462562561035,
-0.735041081905365,
0.1720915585756302,
0.21291141211986542,
-0.10173557698726654,
-0.057416897267103195,
-0.08678094297647476,
0.2740683853626251,
0.5784796476364136,
-0.10593146830797195,
0.5484638214111328,
0.006751226726919413,
-0.44874730706214905,
-0.1556524783372879,
-0.3680818974971771,
-0.23469248414039612,
1.2496044635772705,
0.25114381313323975,
1.000728964805603,
-0.0005347049445845187,
0.7536560893058777,
0.15283462405204773,
0.6160449981689453,
-0.5151355862617493,
0.7714122533798218,
-0.1311742663383484,
-0.5601011514663696,
-0.08916063606739044,
-0.5884984135627747,
-0.6604607701301575,
0.6004859209060669,
-0.346347451210022,
-0.7972004413604736,
0.33316805958747864,
0.056652747094631195,
-0.21688920259475708,
0.48588672280311584,
-0.6528236865997314,
0.9546327590942383,
-0.42753762006759644,
-0.5634874701499939,
-0.118569515645504,
-0.3311225473880768,
0.5497710108757019,
-0.2223585546016693,
0.29587051272392273,
-0.7281532287597656,
-0.18829773366451263,
0.4846130609512329,
-0.35271313786506653,
0.7573235034942627,
-0.19689957797527313,
-0.16804416477680206,
0.1625831574201584,
0.20063075423240662,
0.21041832864284515,
0.040921904146671295,
0.0793033242225647,
0.2704545557498932,
-0.07529917359352112,
-0.26045939326286316,
-0.44353732466697693,
0.6969821453094482,
-0.6045243144035339,
-0.3566317856311798,
-0.2792266011238098,
-0.7882790565490723,
-0.5653509497642517,
-0.1177053228020668,
0.3584282100200653,
0.20202741026878357,
-0.279727578163147,
0.12643402814865112,
0.5785840749740601,
-0.3019895851612091,
0.7894371747970581,
0.3930557072162628,
-0.45400092005729675,
-0.4215995967388153,
0.8454322814941406,
-0.150563046336174,
0.5181912183761597,
0.21880830824375153,
0.10701113194227219,
-0.38986527919769287,
-0.5278774499893188,
-0.7073049545288086,
-0.14181247353553772,
-0.8179445862770081,
0.03946154937148094,
-0.6061035990715027,
0.19912105798721313,
-0.13946259021759033,
0.004794978071004152,
-0.330314576625824,
-0.10761454701423645,
0.13680051267147064,
0.0026992829516530037,
0.15866118669509888,
0.5878915190696716,
-0.16817854344844818,
0.05589018762111664,
-0.5677006840705872,
0.291915625333786,
0.35892125964164734,
0.4948276877403259,
-0.006696886848658323,
-0.18693022429943085,
0.11930552870035172,
-0.13709233701229095,
0.023865222930908203,
-0.38366183638572693,
0.15007244050502777,
0.33418339490890503,
0.713092029094696,
0.632854163646698,
-0.06819164007902145,
0.7563949227333069,
-0.3996012508869171,
0.5410402417182922,
0.3481801450252533,
-0.8284139633178711,
0.20693783462047577,
-0.11241339892148972,
0.31154540181159973,
0.9336819052696228,
0.13473929464817047,
-0.5210322141647339,
-0.48159343004226685,
-0.2770552337169647,
-0.9568670392036438,
-0.04513363540172577,
-0.28383880853652954,
0.1471535563468933,
-0.1151435375213623,
-0.19088785350322723,
0.4591308534145355,
0.34035301208496094,
-0.6227744221687317,
-0.01396743580698967,
-0.23309271037578583,
-0.32053643465042114,
-0.2879188358783722,
-0.4762939512729645,
-0.26302599906921387,
-0.2938920855522156,
0.18010807037353516,
-0.20968395471572876,
0.023773709312081337,
0.09352267533540726,
-0.548132598400116,
-0.1889650523662567,
0.37900885939598083,
0.7227640748023987,
0.6160351037979126,
-0.40080833435058594,
0.4674345850944519,
0.15963606536388397,
-0.2889774739742279,
0.18166033923625946,
0.2545228600502014,
-0.5065493583679199,
0.11806105822324753,
0.5761818885803223,
0.6539870500564575,
0.4802497327327728,
-0.8412018418312073,
0.5372819900512695,
-0.04989739507436752,
-0.19247683882713318,
-0.22200331091880798,
-0.23430313169956207,
0.15632480382919312,
0.31924137473106384,
0.3664880394935608,
0.032562170177698135,
0.13553272187709808,
-0.48153388500213623,
0.31414932012557983,
0.707274854183197,
-0.4214431047439575,
-0.10975819081068039,
1.0180543661117554,
0.2534964978694916,
0.2245684415102005,
0.6730958223342896,
-0.2388927936553955,
-0.10845393687486649,
0.31071534752845764,
0.30206578969955444,
1.1439449787139893,
-0.14482581615447998,
0.11780458688735962,
0.03728598728775978,
0.3587673008441925,
0.22296477854251862,
0.19256792962551117,
-0.09872762858867645,
-0.5245635509490967,
-0.5048207640647888,
-0.7564266324043274,
-0.17330394685268402,
-0.006710236892104149,
-0.49524426460266113,
0.13033515214920044,
-0.5143439769744873,
-0.06546040624380112,
-0.028435928747057915,
-0.6110202074050903,
-0.5734061002731323,
-0.09510787576436996,
0.6404092907905579,
0.8203172087669373,
-0.7447082996368408,
0.7470008730888367,
0.2995206415653229,
-0.4801762104034424,
-0.3433411121368408,
-0.032139938324689865,
0.23207105696201324,
-1.0784459114074707,
0.808454155921936,
0.33280661702156067,
-0.12129233777523041,
-0.3443146049976349,
-0.36306139826774597,
-0.3211366832256317,
1.0806782245635986,
0.3398226201534271,
-0.6858946084976196,
0.021620215848088264,
0.4999655783176422,
0.27847257256507874,
-0.3190228343009949,
0.34350135922431946,
0.3224453032016754,
0.5401104092597961,
0.05740521848201752,
-0.7401406764984131,
0.16974826157093048,
-0.26539427042007446,
0.10279811173677444,
-0.0041899606585502625,
-0.5468113422393799,
0.9370513558387756,
-0.3131873905658722,
-0.41356536746025085,
0.4300130605697632,
0.4713282287120819,
-0.00985854584723711,
0.7398502230644226,
0.5850287079811096,
1.035536289215088,
0.7223066091537476,
-0.2765311598777771,
0.9898216724395752,
-0.26056578755378723,
0.5499458312988281,
1.2934718132019043,
-0.44667765498161316,
0.7223019003868103,
0.6111443638801575,
0.035501718521118164,
0.3320486545562744,
0.4012894332408905,
-0.2922147810459137,
0.5394840240478516,
0.48854637145996094,
-0.5827295780181885,
-0.4921770691871643,
-0.3006318211555481,
-0.4560350179672241,
0.5403265357017517,
0.05291682109236717,
-0.23684653639793396,
-0.5917308926582336,
0.31625598669052124,
0.13403432071208954,
0.19105558097362518,
-0.23611125349998474,
0.8116835951805115,
-0.05664551258087158,
-0.38667356967926025,
0.6750549674034119,
-0.47993525862693787,
0.9284045100212097,
-0.43179821968078613,
-0.03888120874762535,
-0.5183325409889221,
0.4475032687187195,
-0.1905331015586853,
-0.3448290228843689,
0.06255243718624115,
-0.3314218819141388,
0.2057896852493286,
-0.007982466369867325,
0.4323902726173401,
-0.5886374115943909,
-0.5720151662826538,
0.7054122090339661,
0.6228814721107483,
-0.07565020024776459,
0.02732747234404087,
-0.44389015436172485,
0.39464429020881653,
-0.3043244183063507,
0.03321407735347748,
0.3735021948814392,
0.31489503383636475,
-0.10698144137859344,
0.9474331736564636,
0.5324817299842834,
-0.30154046416282654,
0.37280532717704773,
0.4343138635158539,
0.7959994077682495,
-0.59981769323349,
0.07823242247104645,
-1.1263298988342285,
0.23166394233703613,
-0.15839415788650513,
-0.3664903938770294,
1.0007805824279785,
0.761354923248291,
0.8671282529830933,
-0.0639648288488388,
0.8198789358139038,
0.13285137712955475,
0.28915587067604065,
-0.5256397128105164,
0.7236476540565491,
-0.5791965126991272,
0.19260185956954956,
-0.2773998975753784,
-0.7745276093482971,
-0.3419889509677887,
0.14682728052139282,
-0.2758168876171112,
0.014981715939939022,
0.819281816482544,
0.5361167788505554,
0.10144034028053284,
0.06965379416942596,
0.6337243318557739,
0.013538792729377747,
0.28899869322776794,
0.7015403509140015,
1.3190646171569824,
-0.03918701782822609,
0.3575476408004761,
-0.36504998803138733,
-0.28487515449523926,
-0.29391130805015564,
-1.011976718902588,
-1.1647580862045288,
-0.21120451390743256,
-0.27411049604415894,
-0.5242810249328613,
0.2650608420372009,
0.9106719493865967,
0.5844959616661072,
-0.7613516449928284,
-0.2497478574514389,
0.14548546075820923,
-0.13773085176944733,
-0.16461016237735748,
-0.17345012724399567,
0.12023214995861053,
-0.5173699259757996,
-0.622683048248291,
0.4514494836330414,
0.39467179775238037,
0.2754839062690735,
-0.5301072597503662,
0.0632474422454834,
-0.27947986125946045,
-0.11332686990499496,
0.6346526145935059,
0.1906512826681137,
-0.6679861545562744,
-0.47620606422424316,
-0.28484171628952026,
-0.0934392437338829,
0.049486685544252396,
0.8588083386421204,
-0.6238505244255066,
0.7315844297409058,
0.22503679990768433,
0.6034883260726929,
0.2322375327348709,
-0.017367878928780556,
0.3288396894931793,
-0.576246440410614,
0.5605666041374207,
0.06609538942575455,
0.40034204721450806,
0.5197504162788391,
0.01805877685546875,
0.6170253157615662,
0.5989368557929993,
-0.16918866336345673,
-0.8633612394332886,
0.14230966567993164,
-0.9504235982894897,
-0.21972008049488068,
1.155154824256897,
-0.035544805228710175,
-0.13106854259967804,
-0.10743311047554016,
0.20201103389263153,
-0.02729315496981144,
0.02665463276207447,
0.8334512710571289,
0.6590483784675598,
0.1274290382862091,
-0.14514446258544922,
-0.7916045784950256,
0.479928195476532,
0.4433392882347107,
-0.8621935844421387,
0.2306494265794754,
0.5730248689651489,
0.32307642698287964,
0.09772137552499771,
0.4009101092815399,
-0.16765311360359192,
-0.06629706174135208,
0.3427989184856415,
0.4183131754398346,
-0.28367453813552856,
-0.15616711974143982,
-0.26976150274276733,
0.2514999806880951,
0.09738660603761673,
-0.3501957058906555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14972v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14972v1
|
MultiLS: A Multi-task Lexical Simplification Framework
| 2024-02-22T21:16:18 | 2024-02-22T21:16:18 |
Kai North, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Matthew Shardlow, Marcos Zampieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Lexical Simplification (LS) automatically replaces difficult to read words
for easier alternatives while preserving a sentence's original meaning. LS is a
precursor to Text Simplification with the aim of improving text accessibility
to various target demographics, including children, second language learners,
individuals with reading disabilities or low literacy. Several datasets exist
for LS. These LS datasets specialize on one or two sub-tasks within the LS
pipeline. However, as of this moment, no single LS dataset has been developed
that covers all LS sub-tasks. We present MultiLS, the first LS framework that
allows for the creation of a multi-task LS dataset. We also present MultiLS-PT,
the first dataset to be created using the MultiLS framework. We demonstrate the
potential of MultiLS-PT by carrying out all LS sub-tasks of (1). lexical
complexity prediction (LCP), (2). substitute generation, and (3). substitute
ranking for Portuguese. Model performances are reported, ranging from
transformer-based models to more recent large language models (LLMs).
|
[
-0.1622040569782257,
-0.3004229962825775,
0.4490382671356201,
0.2662443518638611,
-0.15383794903755188,
-0.03825739771127701,
-0.06388231366872787,
-0.2011556476354599,
0.11231134831905365,
0.19283369183540344,
-0.9173198938369751,
-0.30726712942123413,
-0.6865408420562744,
0.39078041911125183,
-0.4999741017818451,
1.0515035390853882,
0.02844313159584999,
0.21960006654262543,
0.04740466549992561,
0.06542792916297913,
-0.08209843188524246,
-0.6021212935447693,
-0.5366488099098206,
-0.17744582891464233,
0.8558237552642822,
0.4753042757511139,
0.878859281539917,
0.6170165538787842,
0.4138268530368805,
0.28171080350875854,
-0.38263100385665894,
0.3247425854206085,
-0.47732439637184143,
0.03998394310474396,
0.05163298547267914,
-0.2505117654800415,
-0.29196977615356445,
-0.4757404625415802,
0.6328925490379333,
1.064815878868103,
0.034243639558553696,
0.1428847759962082,
0.28232595324516296,
0.9854574203491211,
-0.7746906876564026,
0.24528376758098602,
-0.3199141025543213,
0.2892238199710846,
-0.4117979109287262,
-0.027075160294771194,
-0.1771974265575409,
-0.10234904289245605,
0.06346447765827179,
-0.6902860403060913,
0.18636789917945862,
-0.03675015643239021,
0.027982797473669052,
0.4080047309398651,
-0.6802020072937012,
-0.45958927273750305,
-0.6519582867622375,
1.069576382637024,
-0.4205297529697418,
0.801662802696228,
0.10511021316051483,
0.16565090417861938,
-0.05464230477809906,
-0.7207554578781128,
-0.39355793595314026,
-0.23104888200759888,
-0.31432050466537476,
-0.10620687156915665,
0.002078892197459936,
0.22892454266548157,
0.35360240936279297,
0.21810603141784668,
-0.49133166670799255,
-0.16170094907283783,
-0.7640537023544312,
-0.34692856669425964,
0.4192798435688019,
0.27739015221595764,
0.027114083990454674,
-0.060097601264715195,
-0.3099299371242523,
0.1025514230132103,
-0.8859875202178955,
0.15648320317268372,
0.15376697480678558,
0.753449559211731,
0.02036137506365776,
0.7334687113761902,
-0.25215888023376465,
0.5860190391540527,
-0.4879011809825897,
-0.46446022391319275,
0.4446800649166107,
-0.7205747365951538,
-0.3374203145503998,
-0.02256299927830696,
0.5522574782371521,
-0.03338431566953659,
0.27247104048728943,
0.08625773340463638,
-0.2458350509405136,
0.07914397865533829,
-0.24132323265075684,
-0.4539855420589447,
0.23104725778102875,
0.2565428912639618,
-0.407208651304245,
0.010637788102030754,
-0.05775978043675423,
-0.6122621893882751,
-0.6103972792625427,
-0.6454277634620667,
0.04238731786608696,
-0.3484818637371063,
-0.0793408676981926,
0.3375914692878723,
-0.0239652581512928,
-0.25945910811424255,
0.4684315621852875,
-0.6162148714065552,
0.4862956702709198,
0.4302518963813782,
0.5854489803314209,
-0.2660332918167114,
-0.7761046290397644,
-0.2908044755458832,
0.2394377589225769,
-0.35237741470336914,
0.4067981243133545,
-0.23522678017616272,
-0.26290827989578247,
0.024968979880213737,
-0.10421537607908249,
0.027094803750514984,
-0.21827302873134613,
0.6979547142982483,
-0.12439824640750885,
0.0267267394810915,
-0.5187886357307434,
-0.41816484928131104,
0.2114744484424591,
0.07383546978235245,
-0.8505057692527771,
1.3438094854354858,
-0.16134849190711975,
-0.7341010570526123,
0.11878032237291336,
-0.7214739322662354,
-0.5092725157737732,
-0.16281069815158844,
-0.012654748745262623,
-0.07681747525930405,
0.09395100176334381,
0.16788434982299805,
0.2629210650920868,
-0.4616456627845764,
0.21844665706157684,
-0.02684612385928631,
-0.3480992615222931,
0.02168945223093033,
-0.630310595035553,
0.5778025388717651,
0.5217945575714111,
0.022407498210668564,
0.20330508053302765,
-0.35404694080352783,
0.03722025081515312,
-0.05344672501087189,
-0.4435972273349762,
-0.013977209106087685,
0.22646762430667877,
0.3031668961048126,
0.4623565673828125,
0.5426025390625,
-0.5132248997688293,
0.14161416888237,
-0.17338033020496368,
0.16645526885986328,
0.40095341205596924,
-0.48549923300743103,
0.3021453619003296,
-0.30861392617225647,
0.4098675549030304,
0.25566092133522034,
0.41228219866752625,
-0.489093154668808,
-0.4966511130332947,
-0.6594259738922119,
-0.2068784385919571,
0.33469098806381226,
0.7361211180686951,
-0.758354127407074,
0.12778370082378387,
-0.3314955532550812,
-0.601136326789856,
-0.4137333929538727,
0.49141016602516174,
0.6735764145851135,
-0.05778542533516884,
0.5384280681610107,
0.15405763685703278,
-0.682633638381958,
-1.0094753503799438,
-0.21070519089698792,
0.18708795309066772,
0.003627814818173647,
-0.11656176298856735,
0.3405521512031555,
0.030906949192285538,
0.8602492213249207,
-0.4727642834186554,
-0.7416445016860962,
-0.4666614532470703,
-0.14728091657161713,
0.08384217321872711,
0.39920467138290405,
0.30595239996910095,
-0.9559507369995117,
-0.4223187267780304,
-0.3118971586227417,
-0.696261465549469,
-0.08146277070045471,
0.07624885439872742,
0.5064559578895569,
0.05774790421128273,
0.9831134080886841,
-0.38429924845695496,
0.4045887887477875,
0.655956506729126,
-0.12249476462602615,
0.6021519899368286,
-0.5356718897819519,
-0.10718145966529846,
-0.7906689047813416,
-0.04334056004881859,
-0.04602082446217537,
-0.12997393310070038,
-0.9447234869003296,
-0.020645005628466606,
0.03967994078993797,
-0.2379922866821289,
-0.9105299711227417,
0.4717608094215393,
-0.5976091623306274,
-0.33026111125946045,
0.15318208932876587,
-0.07796081900596619,
-0.11001501977443695,
0.4921703040599823,
-0.06625297665596008,
0.8089475035667419,
0.638789176940918,
-0.5518253445625305,
0.2932773232460022,
-0.12984763085842133,
-0.18099692463874817,
0.15720485150814056,
-0.5726844668388367,
-0.10848136246204376,
-0.5359188318252563,
0.23440253734588623,
-0.977571427822113,
0.0039244783110916615,
-0.05913006141781807,
0.16119296848773956,
-0.09377313405275345,
0.15408127009868622,
-0.6958653330802917,
-0.5707879662513733,
-0.40195193886756897,
0.5572955012321472,
-0.08218169957399368,
-0.26597684621810913,
0.5759806036949158,
0.3770362138748169,
-0.3210380971431732,
-0.791401743888855,
-0.8566696047782898,
0.23134897649288177,
0.06576821208000183,
-0.24387603998184204,
0.4938911199569702,
-0.4060295522212982,
-0.02715815231204033,
-0.11805136501789093,
0.16026334464550018,
-0.17569978535175323,
-0.15212219953536987,
-0.06072106584906578,
0.02009342797100544,
-0.16058430075645447,
0.46127966046333313,
0.30203476548194885,
-0.21254763007164001,
-0.5062291026115417,
0.12699216604232788,
0.4635792672634125,
-0.3596358001232147,
-0.7375630140304565,
-0.4999264180660248,
0.6278950572013855,
0.7926675081253052,
-0.07465015351772308,
0.3528696596622467,
0.17839571833610535,
-0.5745187401771545,
0.023983238264918327,
-0.39503172039985657,
0.16977649927139282,
-0.4570329785346985,
0.4918067157268524,
-0.7843056917190552,
-0.6846184134483337,
0.27183306217193604,
-0.10093246400356293,
0.34678152203559875,
0.46261176466941833,
0.48661038279533386,
0.08580425381660461,
0.9424792528152466,
0.5207456350326538,
0.02717866748571396,
0.33360397815704346,
0.11995112150907516,
0.14569595456123352,
-0.3622974157333374,
-0.2109031081199646,
-0.48004597425460815,
-0.4312601387500763,
-0.42577043175697327,
-0.593181848526001,
0.5327772498130798,
0.21223032474517822,
-0.20352911949157715,
0.29041948914527893,
-0.42402341961860657,
0.6661904454231262,
0.5872547030448914,
0.055644404143095016,
0.444223552942276,
-0.10815124958753586,
-0.285445898771286,
-0.2588367462158203,
-0.7378109097480774,
-0.36958804726600647,
1.1629606485366821,
0.28427785634994507,
0.8983643651008606,
0.3963189125061035,
0.7307327389717102,
0.4590374529361725,
0.13781952857971191,
-0.6643825769424438,
0.6784418225288391,
-0.6771873235702515,
-0.3451721668243408,
-0.594393253326416,
-0.16701480746269226,
-1.0092369318008423,
0.34834620356559753,
-0.3566201627254486,
-0.42517438530921936,
-0.03881583362817764,
0.1634300798177719,
-0.4663221538066864,
0.19406560063362122,
-0.9493227005004883,
0.6381205916404724,
-0.3681793808937073,
-0.23834958672523499,
-0.17002780735492706,
-0.7226492762565613,
0.23054061830043793,
-0.11981607228517532,
0.7152685523033142,
0.04124801978468895,
-0.3061065673828125,
0.5912072062492371,
-0.28942957520484924,
1.0435467958450317,
-0.12243083119392395,
-0.06713175028562546,
0.16255918145179749,
0.03084893897175789,
0.2457723468542099,
-0.28870823979377747,
-0.272149920463562,
-0.032554008066654205,
0.3489208519458771,
-0.22180543839931488,
-0.3462986946105957,
0.6211803555488586,
-0.49349164962768555,
-0.31998464465141296,
-0.44605347514152527,
-0.7358731031417847,
-0.07829011231660843,
0.43337777256965637,
-0.08768808841705322,
0.3386158347129822,
-0.27636095881462097,
0.15730293095111847,
0.415821373462677,
-0.05284328758716583,
0.5348353385925293,
0.19682812690734863,
-0.3613158166408539,
-0.2629077434539795,
0.876586377620697,
0.2380053699016571,
0.11336862295866013,
0.2481880486011505,
0.329359233379364,
-0.5630640387535095,
-0.4404473900794983,
-0.6280013918876648,
0.051432833075523376,
-0.8625732064247131,
-0.18857653439044952,
-0.3371890187263489,
-0.2520045340061188,
-0.5633931159973145,
-0.09874273836612701,
-0.4576207399368286,
-0.46958157420158386,
-0.31681451201438904,
0.05046849325299263,
-0.01499298308044672,
1.1843751668930054,
-0.18565581738948822,
0.2406262308359146,
-0.767541229724884,
0.4806082248687744,
0.27062007784843445,
0.23981738090515137,
-0.28651538491249084,
-0.166360542178154,
-0.06225442513823509,
0.1344955414533615,
-0.15663638710975647,
-0.9332908391952515,
0.32862231135368347,
0.3456169068813324,
0.5604085326194763,
0.2213074415922165,
-0.22077210247516632,
0.7169545292854309,
-0.6518331170082092,
0.8462054133415222,
0.4948468804359436,
-1.2509489059448242,
0.2875792384147644,
-0.075784832239151,
0.32413896918296814,
0.48118340969085693,
0.18633465468883514,
-0.7706656455993652,
-0.14125901460647583,
-0.35516253113746643,
-0.6718542575836182,
0.7403599619865417,
0.22175335884094238,
-0.06271494179964066,
0.2376989722251892,
0.3111032545566559,
0.16393740475177765,
0.4217873811721802,
-0.934130072593689,
-0.6160611510276794,
-0.043089963495731354,
-0.6237118244171143,
-0.31604820489883423,
-0.4601536691188812,
0.05486704036593437,
-0.24005934596061707,
0.6514852643013,
-0.331459105014801,
-0.011417785659432411,
0.1544080376625061,
-0.18924148380756378,
-0.04486280679702759,
0.5461409091949463,
0.7930548191070557,
0.5871993899345398,
0.2357580065727234,
0.33299973607063293,
0.45940572023391724,
-0.07738474011421204,
0.0004008522955700755,
0.16551756858825684,
-0.18584312498569489,
0.07606180012226105,
0.3609433174133301,
0.6510460376739502,
0.43382954597473145,
-0.9066808819770813,
0.5090168714523315,
0.19092975556850433,
-0.16433870792388916,
-0.28984493017196655,
-0.2836328446865082,
0.2905504107475281,
0.06340215355157852,
0.5581512451171875,
-0.056804291903972626,
0.15030209720134735,
-0.4660649299621582,
0.2872733771800995,
0.2394571155309677,
-0.2897549271583557,
-0.09041274338960648,
0.29176488518714905,
-0.0321219339966774,
-0.3385288417339325,
0.002761176088824868,
-0.24428141117095947,
-0.49503666162490845,
0.5266703963279724,
0.37549951672554016,
0.28887689113616943,
-0.4940475523471832,
0.12766216695308685,
0.3219485878944397,
0.4907001852989197,
-0.3753510117530823,
0.6273220777511597,
0.1906222105026245,
-0.5558801293373108,
-0.3161756694316864,
-0.5840634703636169,
-0.47392579913139343,
0.04696528986096382,
-0.41373831033706665,
0.6598537564277649,
-0.22674435377120972,
0.0439455471932888,
0.09813543409109116,
-0.26052531599998474,
-0.7322115302085876,
0.3828071355819702,
0.41686978936195374,
0.9641199111938477,
-0.9894968271255493,
0.9319175481796265,
0.5917519927024841,
-0.23702320456504822,
-0.4329862594604492,
-0.21301467716693878,
0.24834200739860535,
-0.606110692024231,
0.7810679078102112,
0.09285692125558853,
-0.3022998869419098,
0.06514768302440643,
-0.1105835810303688,
-1.1887730360031128,
0.8613296747207642,
0.4670694172382355,
-0.5486961007118225,
-0.45639440417289734,
0.8458317518234253,
0.5645430088043213,
-0.4114578664302826,
0.2551525831222534,
0.46331098675727844,
0.5316859483718872,
0.022081997245550156,
-1.1689844131469727,
-0.1789528876543045,
-0.014617848210036755,
-0.03950413316488266,
0.11483000218868256,
-0.26136794686317444,
1.2329356670379639,
-0.47983813285827637,
-0.027244962751865387,
0.15358178317546844,
0.5021715760231018,
0.19650483131408691,
0.22464950382709503,
0.8283741474151611,
0.39838171005249023,
0.8019644618034363,
-0.12363538146018982,
0.7939618825912476,
-0.331792950630188,
0.5603693723678589,
1.1443849802017212,
-0.33896157145500183,
0.7655579447746277,
0.7164989709854126,
-0.4508303105831146,
0.2877134680747986,
0.39036691188812256,
0.3384285271167755,
0.4722270369529724,
0.5001569986343384,
-0.22174526751041412,
-0.297899454832077,
-0.25419872999191284,
-0.3554846942424774,
0.41014665365219116,
0.7377100586891174,
-0.285492867231369,
-0.6612798571586609,
0.09590213745832443,
-0.2323247492313385,
-0.06277789175510406,
-0.3336239457130432,
0.5868220329284668,
-0.09204304218292236,
-0.5609790086746216,
0.25779035687446594,
0.1756349802017212,
0.6785045862197876,
-0.985052764415741,
0.10154177248477936,
0.02263198234140873,
0.31801581382751465,
-0.07140813767910004,
-1.014784336090088,
0.4761795103549957,
-0.17081253230571747,
-0.14066661894321442,
-0.5089127421379089,
0.7085614800453186,
-0.6884494423866272,
-0.8779647946357727,
0.5253796577453613,
1.0783634185791016,
0.22952042520046234,
0.04632820934057236,
-1.0120354890823364,
0.1307784616947174,
0.020077265799045563,
-0.21590527892112732,
0.22818590700626373,
0.4732252359390259,
-0.0625646710395813,
0.8202792406082153,
0.7861918210983276,
0.009756653569638729,
0.3316059112548828,
0.21158458292484283,
0.8610637784004211,
-0.7126700282096863,
-0.6264060139656067,
-0.537156343460083,
0.3392782211303711,
0.1349593698978424,
-0.4130891263484955,
0.43781936168670654,
0.856147825717926,
0.5742844939231873,
-0.01791592687368393,
0.8975505828857422,
0.02015755884349346,
0.7771560549736023,
-0.43670207262039185,
0.20435993373394012,
-0.9487819671630859,
0.21867045760154724,
-0.22211633622646332,
-0.5590506196022034,
-0.4938527047634125,
0.16537153720855713,
0.09487587958574295,
-0.04955863952636719,
1.004599928855896,
0.9925177097320557,
-0.15848803520202637,
0.06665152311325073,
0.45404136180877686,
-0.12622101604938507,
0.11243996024131775,
0.7232547402381897,
0.5051301121711731,
-0.4544193148612976,
0.8330861330032349,
-0.4050973951816559,
-0.2052021622657776,
0.14212268590927124,
-0.9031203985214233,
-0.603756308555603,
-0.6642079949378967,
0.01734767109155655,
-0.13065539300441742,
0.11420378088951111,
1.0485928058624268,
0.3807412087917328,
-1.041217565536499,
-0.5076165199279785,
-0.2009725272655487,
0.1757761687040329,
-0.44421470165252686,
-0.13766944408416748,
0.4659021496772766,
-0.4660540223121643,
-0.9404888153076172,
0.6722095012664795,
0.07253015786409378,
0.06708229333162308,
-0.42917874455451965,
-0.09706868976354599,
-0.3486607074737549,
-0.1027320921421051,
0.7390748858451843,
0.18785586953163147,
-1.0396473407745361,
-0.011738108471035957,
0.12596213817596436,
-0.34173038601875305,
-0.012860675342381,
1.0318671464920044,
-0.6829859018325806,
0.2795892059803009,
0.28632742166519165,
0.49795085191726685,
0.216512992978096,
-0.47932299971580505,
0.1439477652311325,
-0.95980304479599,
0.28688278794288635,
0.01219961792230606,
0.7514172196388245,
0.30665189027786255,
-0.17838113009929657,
0.4274483323097229,
0.2995617389678955,
-0.05392223224043846,
-0.6374963521957397,
0.406313955783844,
-0.8550252318382263,
-0.5190925002098083,
1.2307798862457275,
0.15762494504451752,
0.1987334042787552,
-0.5750782489776611,
-0.43402567505836487,
0.14216503500938416,
-0.3277542293071747,
0.29345864057540894,
0.5843490958213806,
-0.12428233027458191,
-0.07759106159210205,
-0.3458667993545532,
0.5917535424232483,
0.8363551497459412,
-0.8095295429229736,
0.3954407274723053,
0.6265422105789185,
0.10777978599071503,
0.5232629179954529,
0.788379430770874,
0.062106724828481674,
0.0629720538854599,
-0.18918120861053467,
0.1527506709098816,
-0.13324134051799774,
-0.6223587989807129,
-0.27655404806137085,
0.5108860731124878,
-0.27230075001716614,
0.12379459291696548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14968v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14968v3
|
Mitigating Fine-tuning based Jailbreak Attack with Backdoor Enhanced Safety Alignment
| 2024-02-22T21:05:18 | 2024-06-20T05:18:04 |
Jiongxiao Wang, Jiazhao Li, Yiquan Li, Xiangyu Qi, Junjie Hu, Yixuan Li, Patrick McDaniel, Muhao Chen, Bo Li, Chaowei Xiao
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Despite the general capabilities of Large Language Models (LLM), these models
still request fine-tuning or adaptation with customized data when meeting
specific business demands. However, this process inevitably introduces new
threats, particularly against the Fine-tuning based Jailbreak Attack (FJAttack)
under the setting of Language-Model-as-a-Service (LMaaS), where the model's
safety has been significantly compromised by fine-tuning users' uploaded
examples contain just a few harmful examples. Though potential defenses have
been proposed that the service providers can integrate safety examples into the
fine-tuning dataset to reduce safety issues, such approaches require
incorporating a substantial amount of data, making it inefficient. To
effectively defend against the FJAttack with limited safety examples under
LMaaS, we propose the Backdoor Enhanced Safety Alignment method inspired by an
analogy with the concept of backdoor attacks. In particular, service providers
will construct prefixed safety examples with a secret prompt, acting as a
"backdoor trigger". By integrating prefixed safety examples into the
fine-tuning dataset, the subsequent fine-tuning process effectively acts as the
"backdoor attack", establishing a strong correlation between the secret prompt
and safety generations. Consequently, safe responses are ensured once service
providers prepend this secret prompt ahead of any user input during inference.
Our comprehensive experiments demonstrate that through the Backdoor Enhanced
Safety Alignment with adding as few as 11 prefixed safety examples, the
maliciously fine-tuned LLMs will achieve similar safety performance as the
original aligned models without harming the benign performance. Furthermore, we
also present the effectiveness of our method in a more practical setting where
the fine-tuning data consists of both FJAttack examples and the fine-tuning
task data.
|
[
-0.2835066020488739,
-0.810641348361969,
0.4371667504310608,
-0.030684269964694977,
-0.1983785480260849,
0.27051404118537903,
-0.09164828807115555,
-0.48602205514907837,
0.12025914341211319,
0.8630027174949646,
-0.7290092706680298,
-0.6783561706542969,
-0.3830696940422058,
-0.24552272260189056,
-0.3302761912345886,
1.1026123762130737,
0.08922071009874344,
-0.3184891641139984,
0.3989671766757965,
0.12544581294059753,
-0.9292198419570923,
-0.3259567320346832,
-0.48128435015678406,
0.059171296656131744,
0.5365046858787537,
0.6994240880012512,
1.0218273401260376,
0.6537604331970215,
0.46669474244117737,
0.19196590781211853,
-0.03978998214006424,
0.08911461383104324,
-0.38942471146583557,
0.36220696568489075,
-0.3879122734069824,
-0.35170218348503113,
-0.5193642973899841,
-0.0331120491027832,
0.3068573772907257,
0.22451716661453247,
-0.2916455864906311,
0.2348296344280243,
-0.007512412033975124,
0.7880420088768005,
-1.057694435119629,
-0.21313397586345673,
-0.9932693243026733,
-0.07888998836278915,
-0.22629638016223907,
-0.09066163748502731,
-0.4466242790222168,
-0.6180569529533386,
-0.39349907636642456,
-0.33349114656448364,
-0.14728623628616333,
0.371217280626297,
0.9856064319610596,
0.3006536066532135,
0.009374339133501053,
-0.10562111437320709,
-0.2549099326133728,
0.4920476973056793,
-0.8010184168815613,
0.4215599298477173,
0.3417157828807831,
0.39885127544403076,
-0.502592146396637,
-0.0692906305193901,
-0.4565633535385132,
-0.2133461982011795,
0.01889326050877571,
-0.12479047477245331,
-0.21177475154399872,
0.09055401384830475,
0.4629051387310028,
0.306741327047348,
-0.43155109882354736,
0.5790759921073914,
-0.20706047117710114,
-0.29981961846351624,
0.7539886236190796,
0.49404120445251465,
0.3239574134349823,
0.039602722972631454,
-0.3678050637245178,
-0.126598060131073,
-1.139377474784851,
0.3377332389354706,
0.651469886302948,
0.6174960732460022,
-0.1494555026292801,
0.44755443930625916,
-0.4399813711643219,
0.6283264756202698,
0.35625380277633667,
-0.027855081483721733,
0.17932845652103424,
-0.19063405692577362,
-0.28162357211112976,
0.35464486479759216,
0.7494269609451294,
0.6741175651550293,
0.26181986927986145,
-0.3349972069263458,
-0.26458674669265747,
-0.015855377539992332,
0.5437166094779968,
-0.8748591542243958,
0.0311692263931036,
0.3187329173088074,
-0.2700920104980469,
-0.6518720984458923,
0.09194143116474152,
-0.9812348484992981,
-0.5512435436248779,
0.17915946245193481,
0.44424283504486084,
-0.35412201285362244,
0.07808586210012436,
0.08368895947933197,
0.21471717953681946,
0.23081783950328827,
0.08344602584838867,
-1.020775556564331,
0.3927527964115143,
1.1268219947814941,
0.8307321667671204,
0.08918672055006027,
-0.15920840203762054,
-0.857367753982544,
0.5371062159538269,
-0.4125736355781555,
0.42634478211402893,
-0.37534138560295105,
-0.20621013641357422,
0.011358135379850864,
0.02261289209127426,
0.07835450768470764,
-0.2598417103290558,
0.38356366753578186,
-0.7324230074882507,
-0.2787926495075226,
0.04791950061917305,
-0.3025321662425995,
-0.12583503127098083,
0.3030996024608612,
-0.5228424072265625,
0.5254961252212524,
-0.30610743165016174,
-0.5339750647544861,
0.3041551411151886,
-0.36721834540367126,
-0.6108097434043884,
-0.19158294796943665,
-0.15674591064453125,
-0.8296860456466675,
0.22975434362888336,
0.521971583366394,
0.5857649445533752,
-0.12996433675289154,
0.26845964789390564,
-0.5343073010444641,
-0.39756324887275696,
0.28985166549682617,
-0.08670994639396667,
0.8010714650154114,
0.40812838077545166,
-0.3219723105430603,
0.12539756298065186,
-0.7436800003051758,
-0.030133182182908058,
-0.016961107030510902,
0.006907326169312,
-0.6688792109489441,
-0.1910458356142044,
-0.4515323340892792,
0.12944941222667694,
0.3916897177696228,
-0.7466680407524109,
0.15029601752758026,
-0.7646979689598083,
0.004670064430683851,
0.9086005687713623,
0.059216711670160294,
0.2693088948726654,
-0.31899240612983704,
0.4507210850715637,
-0.06944327801465988,
0.5002301335334778,
-0.23222079873085022,
-0.517357349395752,
-0.241082563996315,
-0.3081763684749603,
0.2630632817745209,
0.7125369906425476,
-0.24271473288536072,
0.7084913849830627,
-0.04465875402092934,
-0.5832266211509705,
-0.6798185110092163,
0.2622441053390503,
0.7026667594909668,
0.5592768788337708,
0.3443596661090851,
-0.31573009490966797,
-0.3221343755722046,
-0.9612933397293091,
-0.6273410320281982,
0.19485805928707123,
0.17782871425151825,
0.1601216346025467,
0.1753392070531845,
-0.2535187602043152,
0.750815749168396,
-0.5102277994155884,
-0.20196935534477234,
0.0552939847111702,
-0.24754773080348969,
0.34927111864089966,
0.8615772128105164,
0.5782856345176697,
-0.35670968890190125,
-0.28451699018478394,
-0.0005541684804484248,
-0.5089887976646423,
-0.32727760076522827,
-0.09539082646369934,
-0.10117374360561371,
0.06481669098138809,
0.4460355043411255,
-0.38684001564979553,
0.6325246691703796,
0.6351011991500854,
-0.5237706303596497,
0.41877812147140503,
0.05885710194706917,
0.1297745257616043,
-1.1703197956085205,
-0.10400348156690598,
-0.2875959575176239,
-0.10035113990306854,
-0.7254183888435364,
0.6205613017082214,
0.37037166953086853,
-0.3510906398296356,
-0.295629620552063,
0.330267995595932,
-0.15172727406024933,
-0.05480542406439781,
-0.282268762588501,
-0.15695926547050476,
-0.2778465449810028,
0.3118489384651184,
-0.5098429918289185,
0.9152302742004395,
0.49662691354751587,
-0.30567845702171326,
0.23943877220153809,
0.3646848201751709,
-0.3603600561618805,
0.21627940237522125,
-0.4485212564468384,
0.2649690508842468,
0.30619513988494873,
0.04696686565876007,
-0.8738391399383545,
-0.1846897453069687,
0.47168615460395813,
-0.2609173655509949,
0.4181554317474365,
-0.3505913317203522,
-0.43676888942718506,
-0.05798806995153427,
-0.5759648084640503,
0.07769203931093216,
0.5779594779014587,
-0.5762732625007629,
0.48255324363708496,
0.29776060581207275,
-0.28793811798095703,
-0.7971220016479492,
-0.6326965093612671,
0.2444702535867691,
-0.5278024673461914,
-0.8504326939582825,
0.1955556869506836,
0.1105085238814354,
-0.11051817983388901,
-0.4408707022666931,
-0.3136407136917114,
0.036066025495529175,
0.7047414779663086,
0.6183856129646301,
0.2526298761367798,
-0.18638834357261658,
-0.32825544476509094,
0.4562588632106781,
-0.27810028195381165,
0.06444718688726425,
-0.03818436712026596,
0.40544620156288147,
-0.13206760585308075,
-0.22594313323497772,
-0.82781583070755,
0.4596114754676819,
0.49297791719436646,
-0.21342433989048004,
0.9491496086120605,
0.14908309280872345,
-0.2417600154876709,
0.05623237043619156,
-0.7190865874290466,
-0.484190434217453,
-0.562383234500885,
-0.0946274846792221,
-0.33298295736312866,
-0.9095062017440796,
0.5957460403442383,
0.01957598514854908,
0.4323377013206482,
-0.11727102845907211,
0.43694835901260376,
-0.1401423215866089,
0.9836549162864685,
0.616990864276886,
-0.29755899310112,
0.5716166496276855,
0.21941302716732025,
0.3706340491771698,
-0.6945241689682007,
-0.0928301066160202,
-0.6799203753471375,
-0.2687176764011383,
-0.6859806776046753,
0.2690126597881317,
-0.0011486499570310116,
0.26872876286506653,
-0.3669564127922058,
0.5152065753936768,
-0.21406951546669006,
0.40222445130348206,
0.2158547043800354,
0.45959216356277466,
0.4145752787590027,
0.09868374466896057,
-0.24067480862140656,
0.06628036499023438,
-0.31302326917648315,
-0.4117932915687561,
0.9966340661048889,
0.5996912717819214,
1.1934322118759155,
0.4064255654811859,
0.9988809823989868,
0.021457726135849953,
0.2365117222070694,
-0.5069282650947571,
0.6230488419532776,
-0.2614850103855133,
-0.5126857161521912,
-0.03978994861245155,
-0.2849631905555725,
-0.7623097896575928,
-0.09192890673875809,
-0.30732470750808716,
-1.150570034980774,
0.14120081067085266,
0.5284383296966553,
-0.7976499795913696,
0.15954923629760742,
-0.7441419363021851,
0.8149780631065369,
-0.24288643896579742,
-0.3948648273944855,
-0.39369866251945496,
-0.7570753693580627,
0.5732797384262085,
-0.3464917242527008,
0.39537927508354187,
-0.19103525578975677,
0.03359079360961914,
0.6531140804290771,
-0.757441520690918,
0.9804385304450989,
-0.3508099615573883,
-0.33636170625686646,
-0.19541655480861664,
0.23127062618732452,
0.904901385307312,
0.25889697670936584,
0.09557275474071503,
0.1631760448217392,
-0.17248080670833588,
-0.22434425354003906,
-0.6329248547554016,
0.8095157742500305,
-0.5332028269767761,
-1.1722886562347412,
-0.21345706284046173,
-0.6443865299224854,
-0.40717700123786926,
0.1093282699584961,
-0.020399009808897972,
0.16703951358795166,
0.34127897024154663,
0.24573670327663422,
0.6079367995262146,
-0.3459073305130005,
0.2945616841316223,
0.6745204329490662,
-0.1902923732995987,
-0.42437484860420227,
0.5525423884391785,
-0.255219966173172,
0.4116382598876953,
0.1695815622806549,
0.3966881036758423,
-0.08193336427211761,
-1.0009337663650513,
-0.39109647274017334,
-0.00401731813326478,
-0.3574579060077667,
-0.599999189376831,
-0.5147473812103271,
-0.1579543501138687,
-0.5094404816627502,
-0.33113008737564087,
-0.39048585295677185,
-0.31652283668518066,
0.10368043929338455,
-0.07123561203479767,
0.7248508334159851,
0.15367268025875092,
-0.17292803525924683,
0.5602706670761108,
-0.8574902415275574,
0.3419329822063446,
0.14704693853855133,
0.4376925528049469,
-0.13910797238349915,
-0.4691515564918518,
-0.3787975013256073,
-0.00047530519077554345,
-0.3007154166698456,
-1.0096826553344727,
0.11172571778297424,
-0.022943714633584023,
0.3899800777435303,
0.407906174659729,
0.1435004025697708,
0.8923113942146301,
-0.674004077911377,
0.5155604481697083,
0.2003898173570633,
-0.8611485958099365,
0.7419900298118591,
-0.3291185200214386,
-0.18306216597557068,
0.844674289226532,
0.11148101836442947,
-0.21907037496566772,
-0.6651319265365601,
-0.40438875555992126,
-0.808074951171875,
0.3620586097240448,
0.13387185335159302,
0.1373208910226822,
0.26080483198165894,
0.4041648209095001,
0.17774543166160583,
0.30452635884284973,
-0.40674376487731934,
-0.003194803837686777,
-0.1337825357913971,
-0.27385586500167847,
0.059535395354032516,
-0.12389449030160904,
-0.24402859807014465,
-0.09305716305971146,
0.7019321918487549,
-0.01335861161351204,
-0.1985148787498474,
-0.3144843876361847,
-0.12785427272319794,
-0.1452423632144928,
0.5303742289543152,
0.5613781809806824,
0.16722533106803894,
-0.26388320326805115,
-0.10633951425552368,
0.26632440090179443,
-0.7267119884490967,
0.29551687836647034,
0.20804867148399353,
-0.4049224853515625,
-0.411738783121109,
-0.07261399179697037,
0.5339751243591309,
0.29895591735839844,
-0.5597176551818848,
0.33939486742019653,
-0.061976149678230286,
0.30324500799179077,
-0.011652150191366673,
0.6302118301391602,
-0.25971680879592896,
0.41100022196769714,
0.2670982778072357,
0.031013229861855507,
0.026662643998861313,
-0.5391231179237366,
0.3408120274543762,
0.7614913582801819,
-0.25624367594718933,
-0.04271591454744339,
0.5178707838058472,
0.14032235741615295,
-0.4907117784023285,
0.39238202571868896,
0.25505074858665466,
-0.35716649889945984,
0.5323389172554016,
0.5766124129295349,
0.9269855618476868,
-0.48923346400260925,
-0.4429338276386261,
0.0633721724152565,
0.6389482617378235,
0.010729064233601093,
0.31251323223114014,
-0.0380895733833313,
-0.7407811880111694,
-0.22922948002815247,
-0.5936651825904846,
-0.22498591244220734,
0.279558390378952,
-0.8679614067077637,
0.18049819767475128,
-0.9965239763259888,
-0.04210066795349121,
-0.23219624161720276,
-0.15755368769168854,
-0.29526349902153015,
0.06979121267795563,
-0.04411349073052406,
1.159153699874878,
-0.7935727834701538,
0.8312181234359741,
0.3649185597896576,
-0.23616795241832733,
-0.9068498611450195,
0.24811796844005585,
0.11265523731708527,
-0.8801422119140625,
0.3604305386543274,
0.38417309522628784,
-0.2442072182893753,
-0.17414020001888275,
-0.4593968093395233,
-0.7544405460357666,
0.8655897378921509,
0.29838356375694275,
-1.060596227645874,
-0.0779700055718422,
-0.10773416608572006,
0.16741622984409332,
-0.2908092141151428,
-0.5199037790298462,
0.7784439325332642,
0.4111180305480957,
-0.3133421242237091,
-0.906879186630249,
0.6083742380142212,
0.023844972252845764,
-0.09737668186426163,
0.5250828862190247,
-0.47262683510780334,
0.5506713390350342,
-0.2437388002872467,
-0.1644059717655182,
0.43780648708343506,
0.5582789778709412,
0.5475901961326599,
0.48307937383651733,
0.4897145926952362,
0.7776573896408081,
0.42896878719329834,
-0.07594969123601913,
0.7593528032302856,
-0.389604777097702,
0.19688865542411804,
1.2254365682601929,
-0.28967636823654175,
0.7586600184440613,
0.6743385791778564,
0.3162061870098114,
0.37926968932151794,
0.43711838126182556,
-0.21862724423408508,
0.94776451587677,
-0.017336636781692505,
0.08570579439401627,
-0.12339853495359421,
0.11882137507200241,
-0.5995504260063171,
0.49864473938941956,
0.5063397884368896,
-0.46412938833236694,
-0.2524440586566925,
0.0752532109618187,
0.21326473355293274,
0.1510166972875595,
-0.6390385627746582,
0.9367469549179077,
0.05847436934709549,
-0.5060663819313049,
0.6140992045402527,
0.008717719465494156,
0.7023664712905884,
-0.4772396385669708,
0.2768010199069977,
-0.09918294101953506,
0.21327348053455353,
-0.40547505021095276,
-0.9090699553489685,
0.5362319350242615,
0.288503497838974,
0.09932970255613327,
-0.11294200271368027,
0.6211098432540894,
-0.07692355662584305,
-0.1062680184841156,
0.185240238904953,
-0.049258653074502945,
-0.08749818056821823,
0.13617247343063354,
-0.6838371753692627,
0.20263810455799103,
-0.06600741297006607,
-0.09750091284513474,
0.4727398157119751,
0.001567165949381888,
-0.1264958381652832,
0.546086847782135,
0.8030990958213806,
0.07667706161737442,
0.06313076615333557,
-0.098927803337574,
0.955122709274292,
-0.7987015247344971,
-0.9666101932525635,
-1.0773043632507324,
0.4281225800514221,
-0.16954635083675385,
-0.06443959474563599,
0.8970216512680054,
0.46123945713043213,
0.7114608287811279,
0.05455819144845009,
0.5984286069869995,
0.1862454116344452,
0.37469086050987244,
-0.930573582649231,
0.958307147026062,
-0.3671623766422272,
0.4239855110645294,
-0.6314454674720764,
-0.31913793087005615,
-0.21879582107067108,
0.45007044076919556,
-0.4176463186740875,
-0.25345519185066223,
0.3211459815502167,
1.1847755908966064,
-0.07781252264976501,
0.19252422451972961,
0.33012697100639343,
0.27865320444107056,
0.39401906728744507,
0.6085854172706604,
0.9234021902084351,
-0.4056072533130646,
0.3555668890476227,
-0.32341668009757996,
-0.28788691759109497,
-0.4296274483203888,
-0.9555480480194092,
-1.0747971534729004,
-0.15126049518585205,
-0.10176042467355728,
-0.6643242835998535,
0.6207887530326843,
0.7700549364089966,
0.4507496654987335,
-1.0433508157730103,
0.09345457702875137,
0.047682393342256546,
0.057183124125003815,
-0.26243746280670166,
-0.15544451773166656,
-0.11387772113084793,
-0.2611437737941742,
0.005709800403565168,
0.6459075808525085,
0.3516189157962799,
-0.03720833361148834,
-0.0449485257267952,
0.12770532071590424,
0.06138133630156517,
-0.005946891847997904,
0.08270417898893356,
0.3812379240989685,
-0.8118026256561279,
-0.6098284125328064,
-0.37643781304359436,
-0.05777950957417488,
0.0032730051316320896,
0.8522552847862244,
-0.6200656294822693,
0.14275994896888733,
0.19080255925655365,
0.999286949634552,
0.14320401847362518,
0.04381776228547096,
0.6596966981887817,
-0.9189026951789856,
0.3873903751373291,
-0.02292175404727459,
0.3242877125740051,
0.1175282672047615,
-0.7359074354171753,
0.07410302013158798,
-0.21475008130073547,
-0.3414442241191864,
-1.0137040615081787,
0.5886189341545105,
-0.7826194167137146,
-0.28040122985839844,
0.7750383019447327,
-0.20573323965072632,
-0.29589471220970154,
-0.27378609776496887,
-0.07901524007320404,
0.17832525074481964,
-0.809312641620636,
1.2020177841186523,
0.28938618302345276,
0.22372452914714813,
-0.11808670312166214,
-0.34079357981681824,
0.5523782968521118,
0.33615729212760925,
-0.9425473213195801,
0.32362693548202515,
0.3085157573223114,
0.4942522943019867,
0.1827203631401062,
-0.15995699167251587,
-0.07973047345876694,
0.64619380235672,
-0.34447017312049866,
-0.46925264596939087,
-0.4463961720466614,
-0.39444953203201294,
-0.6285467147827148,
0.2639180123806,
-0.05946112051606178,
-0.3457678258419037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14963v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14963v2
|
Mirror: A Multiple-perspective Self-Reflection Method for Knowledge-rich Reasoning
| 2024-02-22T20:57:17 | 2024-06-24T10:05:24 |
Hanqi Yan, Qinglin Zhu, Xinyu Wang, Lin Gui, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While Large language models (LLMs) have the capability to iteratively reflect
on their own outputs, recent studies have observed their struggles with
knowledge-rich problems without access to external resources. In addition to
the inefficiency of LLMs in self-assessment, we also observe that LLMs struggle
to revisit their predictions despite receiving explicit negative feedback.
Therefore, We propose Mirror, a Multiple-perspective self-reflection method for
knowledge-rich reasoning, to avoid getting stuck at a particular reflection
iteration. Mirror enables LLMs to reflect from multiple-perspective clues,
achieved through a heuristic interaction between a Navigator and a Reasoner. It
guides agents toward diverse yet plausibly reliable reasoning trajectory
without access to ground truth by encouraging (1) diversity of directions
generated by Navigator and (2) agreement among strategically induced
perturbations in responses generated by the Reasoner. The experiments on five
reasoning datasets demonstrate that Mirror's superiority over several
contemporary self-reflection approaches. Additionally, the ablation study
studies clearly indicate that our strategies alleviate the aforementioned
challenges.
|
[
-0.5504486560821533,
-0.4499981105327606,
0.9903100728988647,
0.5027577877044678,
-0.22640268504619598,
0.3015502095222473,
-0.10679168999195099,
-0.13732551038265228,
0.3139914274215698,
0.6990655064582825,
-0.5977032780647278,
-0.148935928940773,
-0.6832805275917053,
0.10489299893379211,
-0.4145635664463043,
0.6550289988517761,
-0.01958470419049263,
0.2808469533920288,
-0.14700347185134888,
-0.13347077369689941,
-0.43267181515693665,
-0.08874747902154922,
-0.2718192934989929,
-0.3211347162723541,
0.7609165906906128,
0.5628463625907898,
0.6537678241729736,
0.34566450119018555,
0.4933215081691742,
0.3071587085723877,
0.21798080205917358,
0.5521154403686523,
-0.3524112105369568,
0.49321791529655457,
-0.6644712686538696,
-0.19207660853862762,
-0.13543196022510529,
0.25403493642807007,
0.5785508155822754,
0.5327399373054504,
-0.14464128017425537,
0.07085572183132172,
0.13653148710727692,
0.5770155191421509,
-0.8813520669937134,
0.013385125435888767,
-0.6549187302589417,
-0.18754108250141144,
0.07752580940723419,
-0.13988712430000305,
-0.3322024643421173,
-0.2687166631221771,
0.020227978006005287,
-0.3672064244747162,
0.04877382144331932,
-0.028105195611715317,
0.5416261553764343,
0.5220515727996826,
-0.605523943901062,
-0.11372706294059753,
-0.7637319564819336,
0.8790863752365112,
-0.6342413425445557,
0.4683871567249298,
-0.09825937449932098,
0.5660775899887085,
-0.14063945412635803,
-0.27060800790786743,
-0.7107785940170288,
0.1702445149421692,
0.00970980990678072,
0.37332883477211,
0.5435469746589661,
-0.15196585655212402,
-0.009212457574903965,
0.1643868237733841,
-0.02800172008574009,
-0.426503449678421,
-0.028775570914149284,
-0.21347355842590332,
0.7184472680091858,
0.24181267619132996,
-0.04086577519774437,
-0.04756079986691475,
-0.4302850365638733,
-0.19574441015720367,
-0.7059471011161804,
-0.3479822278022766,
-0.009649159386754036,
0.4656885266304016,
0.29924505949020386,
0.45325911045074463,
-0.21753552556037903,
0.5938621163368225,
-0.06947188824415207,
-0.3365923762321472,
0.12504582107067108,
-0.4319417178630829,
0.1916290670633316,
-0.10773462057113647,
0.6428827047348022,
0.3450356423854828,
-0.06828570365905762,
-0.19948342442512512,
-0.2392387092113495,
-0.13794852793216705,
0.28183531761169434,
-0.7177989482879639,
0.08681768923997879,
0.1276145726442337,
-0.2821098864078522,
-0.10289542376995087,
-0.07393289357423782,
-1.045760989189148,
-0.8930447101593018,
-0.06710400432348251,
0.8372235894203186,
-0.05952122062444687,
-0.5174940824508667,
0.10336007922887802,
-0.13691549003124237,
0.34112584590911865,
0.8889667391777039,
-0.3865947723388672,
0.14256766438484192,
0.5962182283401489,
0.6893202662467957,
-0.08929318934679031,
-0.6117061376571655,
-0.46284449100494385,
0.2579747438430786,
-0.36366304755210876,
0.8598401546478271,
-0.51732337474823,
-0.2819696366786957,
-0.03887834772467613,
-0.18433183431625366,
0.07417185604572296,
-0.34439313411712646,
0.29930421710014343,
-0.323941171169281,
0.48920515179634094,
-0.8985216021537781,
-0.38087978959083557,
-0.41804635524749756,
0.6410197019577026,
-0.5477821230888367,
0.529290497303009,
0.08398021757602692,
-0.5345039963722229,
0.404514342546463,
-0.5196876525878906,
-0.38659772276878357,
-0.05496419221162796,
-0.38381654024124146,
-0.19739462435245514,
0.07112479209899902,
0.3328978717327118,
0.2412501573562622,
-0.33596017956733704,
0.13811779022216797,
-0.4971499443054199,
-0.16660775244235992,
-0.034104764461517334,
-0.41248413920402527,
0.5632759928703308,
0.13488753139972687,
-0.5599755644798279,
-0.001434117672033608,
-0.5596376657485962,
-0.06698404252529144,
0.29366955161094666,
-0.28765302896499634,
-0.3001137971878052,
0.2732623815536499,
-0.46263113617897034,
0.5877019762992859,
0.27183160185813904,
-0.6788713932037354,
0.45342281460762024,
-0.2114291936159134,
0.03760724142193794,
0.8582799434661865,
-0.02067199908196926,
0.2719900608062744,
-0.27434584498405457,
0.2677641808986664,
0.3110921084880829,
0.14435157179832458,
-0.29957348108291626,
-0.5477191805839539,
-0.9718517661094666,
-0.07122857123613358,
-0.25070908665657043,
0.2880922257900238,
-0.9285488724708557,
-0.16440308094024658,
-0.09123606234788895,
-0.4052034020423889,
-0.9291188716888428,
0.5291445851325989,
0.4856088161468506,
0.6352487802505493,
0.6247345805168152,
-0.28684890270233154,
-0.291297048330307,
-0.7039734721183777,
-0.7182992696762085,
0.06155165657401085,
0.34057801961898804,
0.42437610030174255,
0.6180458664894104,
-0.1316274255514145,
0.7056800723075867,
-0.3402482271194458,
-0.5257532596588135,
-0.23868879675865173,
0.059024740010499954,
0.22961890697479248,
0.37795084714889526,
0.15804435312747955,
-0.5078545808792114,
-0.35465070605278015,
-0.5022822022438049,
-0.8371477127075195,
0.11987873911857605,
-0.3325466513633728,
-0.30517351627349854,
0.14577323198318481,
0.16676463186740875,
-0.4077490270137787,
0.11268792301416397,
0.40358641743659973,
-0.6027967929840088,
0.2555335760116577,
-0.0863739550113678,
0.21051403880119324,
-0.7777619957923889,
-0.35540375113487244,
0.04494792968034744,
-0.15131990611553192,
-0.35488492250442505,
0.10878806561231613,
-0.1264362931251526,
0.5082809925079346,
-0.060762446373701096,
0.9070789217948914,
-0.6640973687171936,
-0.03058820776641369,
-0.4179200530052185,
0.33790406584739685,
0.3331318497657776,
0.3340989351272583,
0.36588287353515625,
0.6684504747390747,
0.2931274473667145,
-0.20939624309539795,
0.27404138445854187,
0.313679575920105,
-0.16879001259803772,
0.5057689547538757,
-0.24561193585395813,
0.23897932469844818,
-0.2183917611837387,
0.042665302753448486,
-1.0148736238479614,
0.04251854494214058,
0.26104938983917236,
-0.22921591997146606,
0.10862992703914642,
0.11962582916021347,
-0.4316066801548004,
-0.41326045989990234,
-0.33640313148498535,
0.3462584614753723,
0.16415445506572723,
-0.8949998021125793,
1.0580447912216187,
0.13529127836227417,
0.134426087141037,
-0.863553524017334,
-0.3740801215171814,
0.19571596384048462,
-0.021686000749468803,
-0.646001398563385,
-0.06372282654047012,
-0.1542501300573349,
-0.4646918773651123,
-0.04334428906440735,
-0.12639079988002777,
0.24956408143043518,
0.15913087129592896,
0.13274626433849335,
0.17852777242660522,
-0.016811583191156387,
0.05965307354927063,
-0.038891617208719254,
-0.054731328040361404,
0.2948770523071289,
-0.2632386088371277,
0.4053606390953064,
-0.593410074710846,
-0.8025115728378296,
0.09255699813365936,
0.45430028438568115,
0.5135692954063416,
-0.2124946266412735,
0.8372395038604736,
0.3703247308731079,
-0.11513859033584595,
-0.3948342204093933,
-1.1820011138916016,
-0.41092097759246826,
-0.48054277896881104,
0.08428502082824707,
-0.4180562496185303,
-0.6545082330703735,
0.6577661633491516,
-0.07308132201433182,
0.28637850284576416,
0.18746526539325714,
0.6953573822975159,
-0.14870913326740265,
1.2756142616271973,
0.3819624185562134,
0.060525838285684586,
0.09448907524347305,
-0.385203093290329,
0.33880913257598877,
-0.9430317282676697,
-0.3704095184803009,
-0.276109904050827,
-0.3072098195552826,
-0.14639626443386078,
-0.4270876944065094,
0.5169520378112793,
-0.11611923575401306,
-0.45288386940956116,
-0.05333572253584862,
-0.7009411454200745,
0.3603324592113495,
0.7112278342247009,
0.09445051848888397,
0.7478116750717163,
-0.4544373154640198,
-0.12457115948200226,
0.028204625472426414,
-0.5961579084396362,
-0.20625407993793488,
0.9166864156723022,
0.20383675396442413,
1.0025014877319336,
0.15802988409996033,
0.983636736869812,
-0.23011428117752075,
0.619469165802002,
-0.542478084564209,
0.5889567732810974,
0.27472788095474243,
-0.8481047749519348,
-0.3356119692325592,
-0.5043226480484009,
-0.42982766032218933,
0.8134683966636658,
-0.2061382532119751,
-0.2596575617790222,
0.17582321166992188,
0.10668101161718369,
-0.17862898111343384,
0.3598023056983948,
-0.45162278413772583,
0.6572111248970032,
-0.5684285163879395,
-0.8959057331085205,
-0.20782123506069183,
-0.6843684315681458,
0.3919917941093445,
0.13287121057510376,
0.5898612141609192,
0.033605486154556274,
0.13176921010017395,
0.4650483727455139,
-0.4066598415374756,
0.7458868026733398,
-0.564737856388092,
-0.31704041361808777,
0.3177283704280853,
0.5292103290557861,
0.39168569445610046,
0.025577113032341003,
0.207527294754982,
0.0037864577025175095,
-0.13741740584373474,
-0.3101250231266022,
-0.7933284640312195,
0.6843460202217102,
-0.7265845537185669,
-1.1389659643173218,
-0.456127405166626,
-0.5698220133781433,
-0.43625572323799133,
0.4135485589504242,
0.043367378413677216,
0.12853774428367615,
0.35564854741096497,
-0.35608869791030884,
0.5092325806617737,
0.013408221304416656,
0.43440964818000793,
0.8159850835800171,
-0.5607611536979675,
-0.411668986082077,
1.0008819103240967,
0.24725794792175293,
0.288166880607605,
-0.11280551552772522,
0.352925568819046,
-0.26056912541389465,
-0.5103461146354675,
-0.295851469039917,
0.5794618129730225,
-0.8976385593414307,
-0.23717522621154785,
-0.30697572231292725,
-0.2010614275932312,
-0.20728585124015808,
-0.14546233415603638,
-0.8115132451057434,
-0.4200814664363861,
0.14654971659183502,
0.03837389498949051,
-0.037780944257974625,
0.7763488292694092,
-0.243875190615654,
-0.030628496780991554,
-0.6935623288154602,
0.19100672006607056,
0.5558984279632568,
0.5697931051254272,
0.1632288694381714,
-0.17883020639419556,
-0.16288866102695465,
0.16797378659248352,
-0.41182219982147217,
-1.0078930854797363,
0.25495463609695435,
-0.022676970809698105,
0.6529799699783325,
0.5876116752624512,
0.039823297411203384,
0.5769141912460327,
-0.3216606080532074,
0.6839195489883423,
0.1329391896724701,
-0.8952160477638245,
0.6514648795127869,
-0.25971052050590515,
0.2003072202205658,
0.6956576704978943,
0.1450885683298111,
-0.4108949899673462,
-0.7296112775802612,
-0.3270416855812073,
-0.6357638239860535,
0.16024555265903473,
-0.24596263468265533,
-0.007979530841112137,
-0.19743026793003082,
0.4136785566806793,
0.16058683395385742,
0.37210652232170105,
-0.8492138981819153,
-0.10629177838563919,
-0.7939853668212891,
-0.0073427464812994,
0.00019137504568789154,
-0.14615842700004578,
-0.5567548871040344,
-0.2882930636405945,
0.7326321005821228,
-0.46626076102256775,
0.14282068610191345,
0.5333541631698608,
-0.13686762750148773,
-0.27773937582969666,
0.2408573031425476,
0.45017313957214355,
0.5272527933120728,
-0.057127732783555984,
0.6055939197540283,
0.08544816821813583,
-0.13100408017635345,
0.10326969623565674,
-0.19140128791332245,
-0.11511349678039551,
-0.26411905884742737,
0.5199662446975708,
0.1843072772026062,
-0.1607687920331955,
-0.34748759865760803,
0.7744501233100891,
0.015398616902530193,
-0.22543396055698395,
-0.27640318870544434,
0.030387183651328087,
0.23320427536964417,
0.6008325219154358,
0.28210246562957764,
0.01724581979215145,
0.1403312087059021,
-0.46176066994667053,
-0.13556067645549774,
0.9077720642089844,
-0.46208274364471436,
-0.07621467113494873,
0.6879558563232422,
0.3308500349521637,
-0.04184499755501747,
0.7147737741470337,
-0.30930885672569275,
-0.8031238317489624,
0.2161349207162857,
0.4917730987071991,
0.8150537014007568,
-0.2804810106754303,
0.20821040868759155,
0.3511647582054138,
0.3511228561401367,
-0.3845321536064148,
0.5045115947723389,
-0.08816802501678467,
-1.2604197263717651,
-0.5857717990875244,
-0.40675148367881775,
-0.5052129626274109,
-0.22395575046539307,
-0.40885987877845764,
-0.012131305411458015,
-0.4505886137485504,
0.1131104975938797,
-0.39988046884536743,
0.06558150053024292,
-0.5218035578727722,
-0.04411506652832031,
0.2444935292005539,
1.031285047531128,
-0.7385191321372986,
0.6367790102958679,
0.31390756368637085,
-0.6390379667282104,
-0.8053641319274902,
-0.09924985468387604,
0.24275535345077515,
-1.0834317207336426,
0.5025928020477295,
0.12152128666639328,
-0.7556002140045166,
-0.21242967247962952,
-0.7945752739906311,
-0.7757744789123535,
1.0516993999481201,
0.2656143009662628,
-0.3989429175853729,
-0.0864984542131424,
-0.049380846321582794,
0.3778921365737915,
-0.3882385492324829,
0.3958696126937866,
0.3662663996219635,
0.7979457974433899,
0.33654502034187317,
-0.8252489566802979,
0.3286815583705902,
-0.25567469000816345,
-0.2482387125492096,
0.10735635459423065,
-1.028468132019043,
0.8170194029808044,
-0.5572290420532227,
-0.022365862503647804,
-0.2191639393568039,
0.5164239406585693,
0.2733461558818817,
0.22354142367839813,
0.6649728417396545,
0.6129119992256165,
0.4716479182243347,
-0.014719394966959953,
0.6999340653419495,
-0.39416635036468506,
0.4112051725387573,
1.1544382572174072,
-0.538536548614502,
0.5567160248756409,
0.8266993761062622,
0.20257265865802765,
0.8997732400894165,
-0.08710908144712448,
-0.15701910853385925,
0.7258715033531189,
-0.11247818917036057,
-0.3327155113220215,
-0.8524957895278931,
0.0683751031756401,
-0.2616207003593445,
0.4950500428676605,
0.2681703269481659,
-0.08882009983062744,
-0.49160832166671753,
0.028022466227412224,
0.13095608353614807,
0.3397310972213745,
-0.24358512461185455,
0.8404543399810791,
0.10215669125318527,
-1.0095961093902588,
0.22787851095199585,
-0.40159210562705994,
0.5222831964492798,
-0.23145651817321777,
-0.3740513324737549,
-0.24976657330989838,
0.3916168510913849,
-0.27130305767059326,
-1.0017472505569458,
0.32247352600097656,
-0.6693794131278992,
0.11499893665313721,
-0.5665493607521057,
0.7889037728309631,
-0.4371146857738495,
-0.3914666175842285,
0.6594432592391968,
1.022727131843567,
-0.2524131238460541,
-0.13042624294757843,
-0.4196552336215973,
-0.15441147983074188,
-0.2247709035873413,
-0.5520484447479248,
0.25139379501342773,
0.3560461103916168,
0.21160508692264557,
1.0548601150512695,
0.26843586564064026,
0.12386829406023026,
-0.0164409801363945,
0.10452306270599365,
0.9796438813209534,
-0.7872902154922485,
-0.10067641735076904,
-0.8870897889137268,
0.43076157569885254,
-0.17327098548412323,
-0.052997540682554245,
0.9768240451812744,
0.45632967352867126,
0.5596670508384705,
0.2348608374595642,
0.8467140197753906,
0.24296611547470093,
0.960250198841095,
-0.280745267868042,
0.5946491360664368,
-0.7674151659011841,
0.5428042411804199,
-0.3633382320404053,
-0.7707891464233398,
-0.3059926927089691,
0.9345294237136841,
-0.40043559670448303,
0.2563469111919403,
0.5957545638084412,
0.7223643660545349,
0.24045823514461517,
0.11939997225999832,
-0.009739577770233154,
0.47679054737091064,
0.5053777694702148,
0.6312075853347778,
1.2954959869384766,
-0.0761086642742157,
0.47949767112731934,
-0.35002362728118896,
-0.3008987605571747,
0.02772362157702446,
-0.8684610724449158,
-1.0116448402404785,
-0.642184853553772,
-0.13597054779529572,
-0.6660259366035461,
-0.03963086009025574,
0.7305681705474854,
0.5836052298545837,
-0.4140244722366333,
-0.17526473104953766,
-0.048987388610839844,
0.6285713911056519,
-0.35930535197257996,
-0.22076572477817535,
0.03536168858408928,
-0.4856588840484619,
-0.17609737813472748,
0.354293555021286,
0.30847662687301636,
-0.3691271245479584,
-0.9335659742355347,
-0.16134653985500336,
-0.08944693207740784,
0.20073501765727997,
0.3827041685581207,
0.0340970978140831,
-0.7388849854469299,
-0.7014391422271729,
0.15297430753707886,
0.03409283980727196,
0.20482148230075836,
0.5993766188621521,
-1.0142261981964111,
0.6756167411804199,
0.3628174066543579,
0.3436214327812195,
0.638300895690918,
-0.1305610090494156,
0.44333305954933167,
-0.325178325176239,
-0.385282039642334,
0.30197539925575256,
0.4939742982387543,
0.31300997734069824,
-0.25689348578453064,
0.4875768721103668,
0.1721978783607483,
-0.7003284692764282,
-0.6553077697753906,
0.38967666029930115,
-0.7530239820480347,
-0.4817693531513214,
1.0168852806091309,
-0.07170655578374863,
-0.06617256999015808,
0.03501619026064873,
-0.18364882469177246,
-0.1280265599489212,
-0.18998372554779053,
1.2656059265136719,
0.866073489189148,
-0.3818737268447876,
-0.5855872631072998,
-0.19338317215442657,
0.33748659491539,
0.53326815366745,
-0.7865307331085205,
0.01011653058230877,
0.4977690279483795,
0.4775245785713196,
0.6471818685531616,
0.726637601852417,
-0.1742079257965088,
0.11653510481119156,
0.07254180312156677,
-0.030607981607317924,
-0.18576982617378235,
-0.7749305963516235,
-0.13620227575302124,
0.35568511486053467,
0.27538159489631653,
0.24688489735126495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14951v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14951v1
|
In-Context Learning of a Linear Transformer Block: Benefits of the MLP Component and One-Step GD Initialization
| 2024-02-22T20:26:08 | 2024-02-22T20:26:08 |
Ruiqi Zhang, Jingfeng Wu, Peter L. Bartlett
|
stat.ML
|
stat.ML, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We study the \emph{in-context learning} (ICL) ability of a \emph{Linear
Transformer Block} (LTB) that combines a linear attention component and a
linear multi-layer perceptron (MLP) component. For ICL of linear regression
with a Gaussian prior and a \emph{non-zero mean}, we show that LTB can achieve
nearly Bayes optimal ICL risk. In contrast, using only linear attention must
incur an irreducible additive approximation error. Furthermore, we establish a
correspondence between LTB and one-step gradient descent estimators with
learnable initialization ($\mathsf{GD}\text{-}\mathbf{\beta}$), in the sense
that every $\mathsf{GD}\text{-}\mathbf{\beta}$ estimator can be implemented by
an LTB estimator and every optimal LTB estimator that minimizes the in-class
ICL risk is effectively a $\mathsf{GD}\text{-}\mathbf{\beta}$ estimator.
Finally, we show that $\mathsf{GD}\text{-}\mathbf{\beta}$ estimators can be
efficiently optimized with gradient flow, despite a non-convex training
objective. Our results reveal that LTB achieves ICL by implementing
$\mathsf{GD}\text{-}\mathbf{\beta}$, and they highlight the role of MLP layers
in reducing approximation error.
|
[
-0.38134872913360596,
-0.6693381071090698,
0.4200766682624817,
0.006269322242587805,
-0.06544710695743561,
0.24383778870105743,
0.03483609855175018,
-0.23546113073825836,
-0.34253570437431335,
0.2713800370693207,
-0.531505286693573,
-0.3170558214187622,
-0.4247940182685852,
-0.7347984313964844,
-0.34426984190940857,
1.3739724159240723,
0.09117782860994339,
0.27549049258232117,
0.0007649829494766891,
0.3350743353366852,
-0.462771475315094,
-0.3982580602169037,
-0.8704349398612976,
-0.5385884046554565,
0.6211265325546265,
0.19885708391666412,
0.4952206611633301,
0.35075512528419495,
0.4386182129383087,
0.13793297111988068,
0.046835824847221375,
-0.11999696493148804,
-0.47567081451416016,
-0.1175084114074707,
-0.016200998798012733,
-0.3403119444847107,
-0.2522706687450409,
0.11188629269599915,
0.7128057479858398,
0.7777251601219177,
-0.12296630442142487,
0.08360430598258972,
0.5872678160667419,
0.6525193452835083,
-0.8186773657798767,
-0.003352212021127343,
-0.35792481899261475,
0.36018478870391846,
0.1586889922618866,
-0.3243890106678009,
-0.6948421597480774,
-0.22722530364990234,
0.45082345604896545,
-0.2065955400466919,
0.2514267861843109,
0.05797009915113449,
0.8523465991020203,
0.3925957977771759,
-0.3993190824985504,
-0.34191563725471497,
-0.9471110105514526,
0.6932001113891602,
-0.31561559438705444,
0.5944686532020569,
0.06368211656808853,
0.3848936855792999,
-0.058469392359256744,
-0.8875486254692078,
0.011200154200196266,
-0.23645932972431183,
-0.2865772843360901,
0.046235550194978714,
0.023748110979795456,
0.5592944025993347,
0.39113661646842957,
0.17725084722042084,
-0.25704318284988403,
0.1967836618423462,
-0.39300036430358887,
-0.1547379344701767,
0.21862109005451202,
-0.09468866884708405,
-0.1295800805091858,
0.03186484053730965,
-0.8842685222625732,
-0.07285228371620178,
-0.7914887070655823,
0.6195704340934753,
0.40561237931251526,
0.44409212470054626,
-0.33842581510543823,
-0.08928612619638443,
0.3636004328727722,
0.499956339597702,
0.4251401424407959,
-0.32488420605659485,
0.20960451662540436,
-0.030101943761110306,
-0.47871389985084534,
0.11315929144620895,
0.2234259843826294,
-0.015814991667866707,
0.06662982702255249,
-0.4139409363269806,
-0.3198852241039276,
-0.3469088673591614,
0.5499081611633301,
-0.8245607018470764,
-0.136613667011261,
0.21188312768936157,
-0.5201730132102966,
-0.23766443133354187,
0.39572927355766296,
-0.5590943098068237,
-0.19010043144226074,
-0.5238246321678162,
0.7231476902961731,
-0.37582942843437195,
0.25314146280288696,
-0.10250429064035416,
0.1441979557275772,
0.6982181668281555,
0.15909522771835327,
-0.9081123471260071,
0.5299211740493774,
0.4325962960720062,
0.7893151640892029,
-0.10602029412984848,
0.03946712985634804,
-0.5254908204078674,
-0.17612233757972717,
-0.2709581255912781,
0.46689483523368835,
-0.21261438727378845,
-0.3165713846683502,
0.09081097692251205,
-0.34181058406829834,
-0.15492409467697144,
-0.4663234353065491,
0.6014979481697083,
-0.36065152287483215,
0.17048583924770355,
0.05073293671011925,
-0.45429083704948425,
-0.12340914458036423,
-0.04493974894285202,
-0.3972027897834778,
0.9717198014259338,
0.21565774083137512,
-0.6513010859489441,
0.6269522309303284,
-0.6944974064826965,
-0.4631101191043854,
-0.16538108885288239,
-0.1347789168357849,
-0.6138007044792175,
0.2285895049571991,
0.18520019948482513,
0.7873004078865051,
-0.1300412118434906,
-0.07013457268476486,
-0.15532581508159637,
-0.33388668298721313,
0.28039976954460144,
-0.6502838134765625,
0.8341871500015259,
0.1341855674982071,
-0.4684312343597412,
0.17742010951042175,
-0.8512731790542603,
0.13426713645458221,
-0.21301978826522827,
-0.2567291855812073,
-0.3696499466896057,
0.05787777155637741,
0.11662903428077698,
0.2766989469528198,
-0.17237336933612823,
-0.49274149537086487,
-0.06836090981960297,
-0.11412832140922546,
0.1751726120710373,
1.291479229927063,
0.1214958131313324,
0.7092093229293823,
-0.21029533445835114,
0.4708441197872162,
-0.04688505828380585,
0.6394076943397522,
-0.12150600552558899,
-0.12564022839069366,
-0.8613569140434265,
-0.49035099148750305,
0.1956576406955719,
0.47924354672431946,
-0.4862510859966278,
0.2804039716720581,
0.38116154074668884,
-0.3094862699508667,
-0.4090995490550995,
-0.029646670445799828,
0.6421954035758972,
0.8983729481697083,
0.6313973665237427,
0.04451555758714676,
-0.3617945909500122,
-0.7698634266853333,
0.19800804555416107,
0.08970926702022552,
-0.10040560364723206,
0.4212115406990051,
0.22300003468990326,
0.1639121025800705,
0.8842863440513611,
-0.5880056023597717,
-0.32161885499954224,
-0.2119937539100647,
-0.1525854617357254,
0.5021732449531555,
0.6309966444969177,
0.5983906388282776,
-0.7078702449798584,
-0.8715401887893677,
0.0009137502638623118,
-0.5640363097190857,
-0.01561630330979824,
-0.3216090202331543,
-0.26298725605010986,
0.08309001475572586,
0.726546585559845,
-0.22169353067874908,
0.6518538594245911,
0.3795653283596039,
-0.44726642966270447,
0.31754645705223083,
-0.4267706573009491,
-0.4514818787574768,
-0.842695951461792,
-0.09280802309513092,
0.20258206129074097,
-0.21472805738449097,
-1.0417590141296387,
-0.10116542875766754,
0.34650951623916626,
0.1243123859167099,
-0.5290262699127197,
0.3786364793777466,
-0.31516724824905396,
0.04485613480210304,
-0.24171414971351624,
-0.011894558556377888,
-0.24688804149627686,
0.632298469543457,
-0.2271146923303604,
0.5917391180992126,
0.6422353982925415,
-0.7936234474182129,
-0.08331553637981415,
-0.10271438211202621,
-0.2124655693769455,
0.8156383037567139,
-0.5554539561271667,
0.10627761483192444,
-0.6297157406806946,
0.08153657615184784,
-0.8249984383583069,
0.3377527892589569,
0.39097878336906433,
-0.14444173872470856,
0.8275918364524841,
0.0259723924100399,
0.2890288531780243,
-0.44760841131210327,
-0.30548545718193054,
0.16750706732273102,
0.567012369632721,
-0.9426379799842834,
0.7498564124107361,
0.1496451497077942,
0.2593989670276642,
-1.1239417791366577,
-0.6208813190460205,
-0.2775450348854065,
-0.23340293765068054,
-0.20458069443702698,
0.395790696144104,
-0.4570844769477844,
-0.016623560339212418,
0.09572575986385345,
-0.15487724542617798,
-0.07103998959064484,
0.15737728774547577,
0.22258791327476501,
0.6285415291786194,
-0.1283351182937622,
0.2484702616930008,
-0.08965286612510681,
-0.3896592855453491,
0.2169647067785263,
-0.5762335658073425,
0.6211164593696594,
-0.17084622383117676,
-0.36160004138946533,
-0.24800606071949005,
-0.006097861099988222,
0.12498562037944794,
0.16961665451526642,
0.5650164484977722,
0.5909976363182068,
-0.42677178978919983,
-0.6359696388244629,
-0.5910419225692749,
-0.2539283037185669,
-0.4528806805610657,
0.43331149220466614,
-0.37089234590530396,
-0.6874954104423523,
0.5798404216766357,
0.3568607270717621,
-0.09547390043735504,
0.3588390350341797,
0.3653254806995392,
-0.3657476603984833,
0.5378413796424866,
0.9213846921920776,
-0.34696096181869507,
0.7844620943069458,
-0.6618328094482422,
0.20618940889835358,
-1.0666186809539795,
-0.38336676359176636,
-0.4223563075065613,
-0.6031274795532227,
-0.5639850497245789,
-0.23731644451618195,
0.6642215847969055,
0.030660223215818405,
-0.5212473273277283,
0.12071139365434647,
-0.4468022882938385,
0.5941178202629089,
0.6876178979873657,
0.5950941443443298,
0.02973361685872078,
-0.07574353367090225,
-0.21188464760780334,
-0.011264532804489136,
-0.8403894901275635,
0.0558958426117897,
1.3713593482971191,
0.5597956776618958,
1.2933224439620972,
-0.3069474399089813,
0.6116291880607605,
0.15569157898426056,
0.541280210018158,
-0.7836860418319702,
0.14569197595119476,
-0.11648260802030563,
-0.3764972686767578,
-0.1897958666086197,
-0.1213316023349762,
-0.6360417604446411,
0.3931729793548584,
-0.23780514299869537,
-0.7857235074043274,
0.5392214059829712,
0.39292314648628235,
-0.4769648015499115,
0.4521329402923584,
-0.6009505391120911,
0.6851654052734375,
-0.3056316673755646,
-0.44020819664001465,
-0.1263413429260254,
-0.8671447038650513,
0.23855137825012207,
-0.024782542139291763,
-0.13246454298496246,
0.16223563253879547,
0.004755139816552401,
0.1449972540140152,
-0.3336417078971863,
0.8113351464271545,
-0.7029777765274048,
0.10980556160211563,
0.2912195026874542,
-0.432040810585022,
0.5398102402687073,
0.06937466561794281,
0.3239041864871979,
-0.11104714870452881,
-0.6730554699897766,
-0.3079652190208435,
-0.5718538165092468,
0.3691415786743164,
-0.7345492839813232,
-0.3310103416442871,
-0.4363171458244324,
-0.7596709132194519,
-0.12114103883504868,
-0.13723281025886536,
0.2350967675447464,
0.7049615383148193,
0.013810901902616024,
0.5082603096961975,
0.9914937615394592,
-0.1732216328382492,
0.8594688177108765,
0.25961557030677795,
-0.09822714328765869,
-0.2593144178390503,
0.497763454914093,
0.06617049872875214,
0.7765628099441528,
0.6378771662712097,
0.27948877215385437,
-0.23950400948524475,
-0.4548541307449341,
-0.06383725255727768,
0.03294890373945236,
-0.8646482825279236,
-0.37898439168930054,
-0.3145131468772888,
-0.9033633470535278,
0.37080132961273193,
-0.566496729850769,
-0.2924889326095581,
-0.01977877877652645,
-0.0864667072892189,
-0.36125075817108154,
-0.2386423945426941,
0.602803111076355,
-0.2255835235118866,
0.23618900775909424,
-0.2913597822189331,
-0.004817115608602762,
0.38058334589004517,
0.19692634046077728,
0.1966383457183838,
-0.5648956894874573,
-0.5229966044425964,
-0.3101561367511749,
-0.34957313537597656,
-0.2956155240535736,
0.051600825041532516,
0.23280492424964905,
0.9197339415550232,
0.7992472648620605,
0.02131357043981552,
0.5624719858169556,
-0.5568336248397827,
0.3861667513847351,
0.21841493248939514,
-0.8442684412002563,
0.31790706515312195,
0.10227582603693008,
0.19035480916500092,
0.326194167137146,
0.5746208429336548,
-0.43944674730300903,
-0.364663302898407,
-0.6097925305366516,
-0.7522287964820862,
0.5975956916809082,
-0.004783583339303732,
0.16418448090553284,
0.17798109352588654,
0.43813198804855347,
0.036802347749471664,
0.20248989760875702,
-0.9268493056297302,
-0.6868829131126404,
-0.13492129743099213,
0.05304081365466118,
0.14905032515525818,
-0.40727925300598145,
-0.10759823024272919,
-0.09108676016330719,
0.7577399611473083,
-0.3348633348941803,
0.37046822905540466,
0.41660329699516296,
-0.1579567790031433,
0.004736088216304779,
0.08159538358449936,
0.5961669087409973,
0.701746940612793,
-0.6407257318496704,
0.1485515534877777,
0.23422978818416595,
-0.5321803092956543,
0.23804467916488647,
0.1416933685541153,
-0.6865345239639282,
-0.34947726130485535,
0.2824590802192688,
1.0668091773986816,
0.4431152641773224,
-0.2675391137599945,
0.5218371748924255,
-0.02781999483704567,
-0.054881539195775986,
-0.20370082557201385,
-0.16226248443126678,
-0.4394757151603699,
0.5575191974639893,
0.8168700337409973,
0.36389827728271484,
0.04656301811337471,
-0.24271608889102936,
0.35146936774253845,
0.8511388301849365,
-0.6528522968292236,
-0.1584734469652176,
0.9349485039710999,
0.04848671332001686,
-0.10300721973180771,
0.4094439148902893,
-0.010123062878847122,
-0.3238186538219452,
0.6310818791389465,
0.8418397903442383,
1.2558335065841675,
-0.3891032934188843,
0.21136368811130524,
0.3838087022304535,
0.4363449215888977,
0.3951939344406128,
0.02957017533481121,
-0.016803232952952385,
-0.9955151081085205,
-0.48595181107521057,
-0.5035560727119446,
-0.3913111388683319,
-0.007504869718104601,
-0.6367723345756531,
0.23350557684898376,
-0.9096203446388245,
0.018272805958986282,
-0.21080268919467926,
-0.24237552285194397,
-0.8296422958374023,
0.23939092457294464,
0.31773287057876587,
0.7255851030349731,
-0.5822969079017639,
0.8698073625564575,
0.22514504194259644,
-0.31492161750793457,
-0.9110431671142578,
0.02573169581592083,
-0.18047580122947693,
-0.8027033805847168,
0.915617048740387,
0.07463099807500839,
0.019635630771517754,
0.04400595277547836,
-0.22319714725017548,
-0.8683658242225647,
1.3001043796539307,
0.36263182759284973,
-0.43834832310676575,
-0.22423742711544037,
-0.008581513538956642,
0.24249105155467987,
-0.5882602334022522,
0.4779469668865204,
0.5729687213897705,
0.27356937527656555,
0.05751689150929451,
-0.6891634464263916,
-0.09520335495471954,
0.24708782136440277,
0.1166519969701767,
0.270363450050354,
-0.6186951398849487,
1.1169391870498657,
-0.39424195885658264,
-0.048473041504621506,
-0.16318482160568237,
0.5643560886383057,
-0.1546141356229782,
-0.05353209376335144,
0.6359915137290955,
0.4121306240558624,
0.7050034403800964,
-0.122036874294281,
1.2647805213928223,
-0.5547505021095276,
0.5378690958023071,
1.0570238828659058,
0.2804011404514313,
0.4791629910469055,
0.6611229777336121,
-0.38966429233551025,
0.5944511890411377,
0.36844271421432495,
0.07390312105417252,
0.7829573750495911,
0.1799737513065338,
-0.3058450222015381,
0.17152878642082214,
-0.004166936501860619,
-0.11667126417160034,
0.142816424369812,
0.24999696016311646,
-0.474953293800354,
-0.3356894850730896,
0.2085263580083847,
0.0924677699804306,
-0.13361376523971558,
-0.6296319961547852,
0.4209026098251343,
0.23170316219329834,
-0.25115686655044556,
0.30877286195755005,
-0.36782050132751465,
0.624288022518158,
-1.021751880645752,
0.15933549404144287,
-0.2628183662891388,
0.6028702259063721,
-0.26758086681365967,
-0.4645759165287018,
0.06443839520215988,
-0.5067199468612671,
-0.3287157714366913,
-0.3646914064884186,
0.8715843558311462,
-0.5740204453468323,
-0.38566815853118896,
0.5587655305862427,
0.152030810713768,
-0.46867528557777405,
0.11252188682556152,
-0.49019601941108704,
-0.3730549216270447,
-0.11549876630306244,
-0.40385302901268005,
0.48150894045829773,
-0.16169820725917816,
0.14920704066753387,
0.8529857993125916,
0.48470672965049744,
0.037068407982587814,
0.2331990897655487,
0.07060695439577103,
0.9789303541183472,
-0.368133544921875,
-0.4343661963939667,
-0.85987389087677,
1.0321720838546753,
-0.005851422436535358,
-0.23073448240756989,
0.4753727316856384,
0.5175125598907471,
1.0868054628372192,
-0.17624406516551971,
0.7460155487060547,
-0.1999790370464325,
0.2840838134288788,
-0.9274622201919556,
0.39394479990005493,
-0.34171298146247864,
0.05423438921570778,
-0.3955272436141968,
-1.1353106498718262,
-0.43550947308540344,
0.7897309064865112,
-0.08846934139728546,
-0.03278256580233574,
1.102887749671936,
0.7253815531730652,
-0.11127986013889313,
-0.5045244693756104,
0.4078482687473297,
0.17888036370277405,
0.5090504884719849,
0.6127958297729492,
0.42238301038742065,
-0.5568318963050842,
0.3686434328556061,
-0.531454861164093,
-0.2995707094669342,
0.06132953241467476,
-0.9712735414505005,
-1.0531805753707886,
-0.43149688839912415,
-0.02403729408979416,
-0.6021629571914673,
0.011301214806735516,
1.1381890773773193,
0.7977671027183533,
-0.9963662624359131,
-0.3829612135887146,
0.02978874184191227,
0.2765853703022003,
-0.3951265513896942,
-0.299943208694458,
0.5732006430625916,
-0.8985942006111145,
-0.8005366325378418,
0.35574010014533997,
0.42891955375671387,
0.06467796117067337,
-0.5473474264144897,
-0.32169806957244873,
-0.29912319779396057,
-0.06327606737613678,
0.6353514790534973,
0.2369653284549713,
-0.45156610012054443,
-0.705269992351532,
-0.2625586688518524,
-0.11808013916015625,
0.27374884486198425,
0.9026207327842712,
-0.8616044521331787,
0.4236257076263428,
0.19549331068992615,
0.8808215260505676,
0.8489996790885925,
-0.06831561028957367,
0.40478774905204773,
-0.9595301151275635,
0.48143380880355835,
0.072945736348629,
0.45733577013015747,
0.03281092643737793,
-0.43690118193626404,
0.7250562906265259,
0.22942304611206055,
-0.7555849552154541,
-0.571999728679657,
0.14087359607219696,
-0.7545124292373657,
0.00824651587754488,
0.7016373872756958,
-0.05086979642510414,
0.013179383240640163,
0.13279017806053162,
-0.334887832403183,
-0.05938634276390076,
-0.3967198431491852,
0.549852192401886,
0.38849785923957825,
-0.2815936803817749,
-0.24098889529705048,
-0.7248209714889526,
0.6994777321815491,
0.09133686125278473,
-0.7049261331558228,
-0.4013175666332245,
0.15340322256088257,
0.24910849332809448,
-0.003916717134416103,
0.6160293221473694,
0.15230943262577057,
0.1087179109454155,
-0.22306819260120392,
0.2178395837545395,
-0.02523287758231163,
-0.571843683719635,
-0.4146878719329834,
0.25154560804367065,
-0.08198140561580658,
-0.36717352271080017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00791v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00791v1
|
$\textit{L+M-24}$: Building a Dataset for Language + Molecules @ ACL 2024
| 2024-02-22T20:11:24 | 2024-02-22T20:11:24 |
Carl Edwards, Qingyun Wang, Lawrence Zhao, Heng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.BM, q-bio.QM
|
Language-molecule models have emerged as an exciting direction for molecular
discovery and understanding. However, training these models is challenging due
to the scarcity of molecule-language pair datasets. At this point, datasets
have been released which are 1) small and scraped from existing databases, 2)
large but noisy and constructed by performing entity linking on the scientific
literature, and 3) built by converting property prediction datasets to natural
language using templates. In this document, we detail the $\textit{L+M-24}$
dataset, which has been created for the Language + Molecules Workshop shared
task at ACL 2024. In particular, $\textit{L+M-24}$ is designed to focus on
three key benefits of natural language in molecule design: compositionality,
functionality, and abstraction.
|
[
-0.5294064283370972,
-0.4369606077671051,
0.4469408094882965,
-0.24466705322265625,
-0.06425217539072037,
0.47730785608291626,
-0.19013133645057678,
-0.7566527724266052,
0.11865618079900742,
0.5421850085258484,
-0.6729138493537903,
-0.3313700556755066,
-0.46295636892318726,
0.12845292687416077,
-0.2765360176563263,
1.1113331317901611,
-0.11447372287511826,
0.33958718180656433,
-0.03595295548439026,
-0.05765745788812637,
-0.16421504318714142,
-0.4750616252422333,
-0.3539174795150757,
-0.14060145616531372,
0.8314067721366882,
0.2630853056907654,
0.6426942348480225,
0.886292040348053,
0.5823863744735718,
0.19854441285133362,
0.1949879378080368,
0.21253298223018646,
-0.38568341732025146,
-0.05934424325823784,
-0.011501257307827473,
-0.4062039256095886,
-0.7874355316162109,
0.43662065267562866,
0.5733360648155212,
0.9601450562477112,
0.058344241231679916,
0.005228778347373009,
-0.17972981929779053,
0.8475033640861511,
-0.34368738532066345,
0.32330024242401123,
-0.5846922397613525,
0.23130108416080475,
-0.5309143662452698,
0.17014725506305695,
-0.35378649830818176,
0.06492438167333603,
0.17267990112304688,
-0.6357605457305908,
0.3411957919597626,
0.3150028586387634,
0.8646460175514221,
-0.19179683923721313,
-0.5632039904594421,
-0.43898946046829224,
-0.5036829113960266,
0.7550032734870911,
-0.628543496131897,
0.7458646893501282,
0.24010001122951508,
0.35339874029159546,
-0.09519737213850021,
-0.34243378043174744,
-0.40303561091423035,
-0.5583627223968506,
0.029948780313134193,
-0.06466260552406311,
0.3119078576564789,
0.2599209249019623,
-0.07812099158763885,
0.5994207859039307,
-0.5038502216339111,
-0.022902632132172585,
-0.8959002494812012,
-0.31021296977996826,
0.8012406826019287,
0.293451726436615,
0.08592556416988373,
-0.0948554128408432,
-0.06320694088935852,
0.12058336287736893,
-0.9578860998153687,
-0.4196951687335968,
0.489383339881897,
0.5885028839111328,
-0.23240536451339722,
1.0832598209381104,
-0.024964163079857826,
0.9306073188781738,
-0.37881481647491455,
0.1676696538925171,
0.36792847514152527,
-0.8873082995414734,
0.006921456195414066,
0.018679725006222725,
0.7902470231056213,
0.253894180059433,
0.465121865272522,
-0.1351192444562912,
-0.22253045439720154,
-0.01825670152902603,
0.2749025225639343,
-1.0196958780288696,
-0.42245131731033325,
0.37681567668914795,
-0.19984187185764313,
-0.6041837334632874,
0.10459960997104645,
-0.7283885478973389,
-0.257344126701355,
-0.6807730197906494,
0.16684995591640472,
-0.46403980255126953,
0.08466547727584839,
0.19716016948223114,
-0.2725292444229126,
-0.11661414802074432,
0.3893660604953766,
-0.939079761505127,
0.5313029885292053,
0.6558690667152405,
0.6421878337860107,
-0.2842399477958679,
-0.26688164472579956,
-0.5457701683044434,
0.23542524874210358,
-0.3440724313259125,
0.5319628715515137,
-0.7160724401473999,
-0.4522456228733063,
-0.2001442313194275,
-0.05863707885146141,
0.07422146946191788,
-0.6266771554946899,
0.28957048058509827,
-0.13154900074005127,
0.49305081367492676,
-0.12311945855617523,
-0.8569894433021545,
0.09756588935852051,
0.08197122067213058,
-0.8369308710098267,
0.6506748199462891,
0.2301149219274521,
-0.4305018484592438,
0.3995448350906372,
-0.9486703276634216,
-0.3321109414100647,
0.0459691546857357,
-0.5038877725601196,
-0.4333786368370056,
-0.03543849661946297,
-0.02152319997549057,
0.45586639642715454,
-0.3276446461677551,
0.46075186133384705,
-0.5316476821899414,
-0.12030962109565735,
0.42276832461357117,
-0.15768586099147797,
0.4780431389808655,
0.33436399698257446,
0.06057089567184448,
0.0007862661150284111,
-1.2414175271987915,
-0.3337319791316986,
-0.1420900970697403,
-0.8251333832740784,
0.19413542747497559,
-0.079659603536129,
0.2735390067100525,
0.19209003448486328,
0.42317792773246765,
-0.7288933396339417,
0.3874422311782837,
-0.330442875623703,
0.3473140299320221,
0.7866748571395874,
-0.11462397873401642,
0.7934516072273254,
-0.5186192989349365,
0.39396804571151733,
0.27061891555786133,
-0.18217356503009796,
0.018012475222349167,
-0.7443819046020508,
-0.8747639060020447,
-0.3026933968067169,
0.061461158096790314,
0.42431944608688354,
-0.4761412441730499,
0.4002705216407776,
-0.14978589117527008,
-0.6111200451850891,
-0.6538553833961487,
0.46967828273773193,
0.4126109480857849,
0.21123403310775757,
0.4528957009315491,
-0.0017925950232893229,
-0.7966586351394653,
-0.8628637194633484,
-0.2751050889492035,
0.07513592392206192,
0.048402052372694016,
0.3662009835243225,
0.5178412199020386,
-0.4519974887371063,
0.6975737810134888,
-0.6223543882369995,
-0.18546630442142487,
-0.31890207529067993,
-0.12399712949991226,
0.33183327317237854,
0.5920040011405945,
0.38836202025413513,
-0.6728299260139465,
-0.32377615571022034,
-0.03036036714911461,
-0.7278517484664917,
0.19059889018535614,
0.18525108695030212,
-0.1884443759918213,
0.13623137772083282,
0.2700812816619873,
-0.8786050081253052,
0.22474338114261627,
0.5301253795623779,
-0.5061569809913635,
0.736639678478241,
0.15820741653442383,
-0.08811265975236893,
-1.2203402519226074,
-0.00013456991291604936,
0.2516172528266907,
-0.026167213916778564,
-0.7217922210693359,
-0.05921733379364014,
-0.1637824922800064,
-0.582242488861084,
-0.4922284781932831,
0.6563377976417542,
-0.41047707200050354,
0.047108687460422516,
-0.05325218662619591,
-0.10934465378522873,
0.26373526453971863,
0.21990637481212616,
0.019982757046818733,
0.873991847038269,
0.48907846212387085,
-0.6291187405586243,
0.45763736963272095,
0.2940492630004883,
-0.12324424833059311,
0.40446338057518005,
-0.3199705183506012,
-0.14835606515407562,
-0.02998224087059498,
0.21453852951526642,
-0.35895052552223206,
-0.43603384494781494,
0.33429598808288574,
-0.3375157415866852,
0.48075321316719055,
0.10679111629724503,
-0.2299945056438446,
-0.26732632517814636,
-0.29218223690986633,
0.3351021111011505,
0.0062521654181182384,
-0.15367911756038666,
0.4922406077384949,
0.4374927580356598,
0.16837887465953827,
-0.3247828185558319,
-0.7219870090484619,
0.13689470291137695,
-0.26595646142959595,
-0.5476986765861511,
0.3651129901409149,
-0.4275732636451721,
-0.32592079043388367,
0.03828587383031845,
0.17498135566711426,
-0.02968463860452175,
-0.12334499508142471,
0.24384792149066925,
0.23952867090702057,
-0.3092000484466553,
0.3154256045818329,
-0.38131728768348694,
-0.15168710052967072,
0.1140999048948288,
-0.37239089608192444,
0.47814756631851196,
-0.3343682289123535,
-0.09537247568368912,
-0.20602698624134064,
0.41640955209732056,
0.6123625636100769,
-0.31680458784103394,
0.7625068426132202,
0.38111230731010437,
-0.4616154730319977,
-0.06571287661790848,
-0.16002340614795685,
-0.35111522674560547,
-0.5051676034927368,
0.37949085235595703,
-0.5299240350723267,
-0.7637955546379089,
0.32386189699172974,
0.34115904569625854,
-0.009222921915352345,
0.34629926085472107,
0.6198503375053406,
-0.24314673244953156,
0.6666463613510132,
0.5690504908561707,
-0.1428876519203186,
0.5451622009277344,
-0.4248690903186798,
0.29338160157203674,
-0.6978719830513,
-0.5190043449401855,
-0.38895106315612793,
-0.1956266611814499,
-0.6761391758918762,
-0.46141383051872253,
0.018444644287228584,
-0.30238908529281616,
-0.2857574224472046,
0.872947096824646,
-0.35483473539352417,
0.19363269209861755,
0.48257383704185486,
0.2067749798297882,
0.15570268034934998,
-0.020723650231957436,
-0.24372059106826782,
-0.09619251638650894,
-0.42209988832473755,
-0.35976526141166687,
1.394148349761963,
0.19042886793613434,
0.8146485686302185,
-0.007898280397057533,
0.9103747606277466,
0.09512616693973541,
0.08448392897844315,
-0.8800194263458252,
0.5846936702728271,
-0.13208650052547455,
-0.9800425171852112,
-0.1619301438331604,
-0.5917176008224487,
-0.8322639465332031,
-0.10958266258239746,
-0.38829416036605835,
-0.6549476981163025,
0.23689483106136322,
0.02875322289764881,
0.09387076646089554,
0.17898808419704437,
-0.5759161710739136,
0.8244335055351257,
-0.2481601983308792,
-0.35720372200012207,
-0.1421634405851364,
-0.7938683032989502,
0.1915380209684372,
-0.2732619345188141,
0.4851106107234955,
-0.5279698967933655,
0.1890617311000824,
0.6629482507705688,
-0.46437063813209534,
0.42503806948661804,
-0.004885529633611441,
-0.27911752462387085,
0.2854434549808502,
0.2312052696943283,
0.3340615928173065,
0.021749252453446388,
-0.27875816822052,
-0.4726400673389435,
-0.1539674997329712,
-0.49832385778427124,
-0.345784455537796,
0.625644326210022,
-0.7213737368583679,
-0.18038226664066315,
-0.21864239871501923,
-0.7625285387039185,
-0.1407110095024109,
0.22323837876319885,
0.25314462184906006,
0.7913683652877808,
-0.224783256649971,
0.15915624797344208,
0.5046464204788208,
-0.10248756408691406,
0.25454816222190857,
0.5162647366523743,
-0.5375970602035522,
-0.46868082880973816,
1.3093702793121338,
0.32772722840309143,
0.3051992654800415,
0.7226330041885376,
0.07782746851444244,
-0.12791579961776733,
-0.49892789125442505,
-0.24271158874034882,
0.08222459256649017,
-0.716974675655365,
-0.09535813331604004,
-0.6055341362953186,
-0.5230196118354797,
-0.1022765263915062,
-0.13026991486549377,
-0.6026567220687866,
-0.786536455154419,
-0.4664527475833893,
-0.5488489270210266,
0.5381879806518555,
0.8064998984336853,
-0.20373386144638062,
0.009088169783353806,
-0.9103739857673645,
0.495802104473114,
-0.005986797157675028,
0.3431141972541809,
-0.4809366762638092,
0.007559268269687891,
-0.6074833869934082,
0.24083682894706726,
-0.2716566324234009,
-0.6942634582519531,
0.1988787204027176,
0.7236126661300659,
0.4380505681037903,
0.14931811392307281,
-0.3205588757991791,
0.2531101703643799,
-0.7288283705711365,
0.5809584856033325,
0.0008676579454913735,
-0.6541162133216858,
0.5863129496574402,
-0.7158034443855286,
0.05087433010339737,
0.6364322900772095,
0.2525402903556824,
-0.34449324011802673,
-0.6047295331954956,
-0.8079684972763062,
-0.7648465037345886,
0.18728385865688324,
0.4582820534706116,
0.13188901543617249,
-0.022094355896115303,
0.1685427576303482,
0.1712019294500351,
0.5558919906616211,
-0.745568037033081,
-0.38048723340034485,
-0.21581046283245087,
-0.5268996953964233,
-0.2520652115345001,
0.06678173691034317,
-0.13692672550678253,
-0.5235435962677002,
0.670329749584198,
-0.04122348874807358,
0.5006874799728394,
-0.3552635610103607,
0.05043765902519226,
0.07558143138885498,
0.09595084935426712,
0.5323768258094788,
0.5514990091323853,
-0.750693142414093,
0.31373199820518494,
-0.24945099651813507,
-0.50702965259552,
0.3604731857776642,
0.23203107714653015,
0.38871535658836365,
-0.03191499784588814,
0.19033530354499817,
0.5785635709762573,
-0.07085969299077988,
-0.6935060620307922,
0.21649529039859772,
0.2636069059371948,
-0.14597268402576447,
-0.029618840664625168,
0.19314758479595184,
0.38161686062812805,
-0.026119492948055267,
0.27779799699783325,
0.28701189160346985,
0.4380650222301483,
-0.6700308918952942,
0.6465352773666382,
0.21696686744689941,
-0.5455833077430725,
-0.41746264696121216,
0.5474144816398621,
0.37544509768486023,
-0.15353983640670776,
0.5520032644271851,
-0.2419469803571701,
-0.38507845997810364,
0.5620938539505005,
0.31364160776138306,
0.5288162231445312,
0.12090835720300674,
0.02945541962981224,
0.2822856903076172,
0.18056507408618927,
0.5227948427200317,
0.45918405055999756,
0.21386365592479706,
-0.9748910665512085,
-0.1329173594713211,
-0.6260563731193542,
-0.44440770149230957,
0.1445685774087906,
-0.543209433555603,
0.3729828894138336,
-0.45882925391197205,
0.036844730377197266,
0.34761545062065125,
0.32180505990982056,
-0.8159323334693909,
0.5004099011421204,
0.16705170273780823,
0.8996260166168213,
-0.8011019825935364,
0.9637700319290161,
0.5252748727798462,
-0.37320396304130554,
-0.48745205998420715,
-0.4867395758628845,
0.3178018033504486,
-0.732776403427124,
0.47426608204841614,
0.40768107771873474,
0.03274722024798393,
-0.09256549179553986,
-0.7870621681213379,
-0.7763792872428894,
0.8995485305786133,
0.37366005778312683,
-0.6074735522270203,
0.02831626497209072,
0.36623015999794006,
0.33569324016571045,
-0.6980708241462708,
-0.40832823514938354,
0.722205638885498,
0.4844948351383209,
-0.0696415901184082,
-0.7030240893363953,
0.1054675355553627,
-0.5997406244277954,
-0.31156760454177856,
0.36501750349998474,
-0.38873398303985596,
0.9785810112953186,
-0.16216063499450684,
0.14254631102085114,
0.18801218271255493,
0.5807338953018188,
0.7157474160194397,
0.04854442551732063,
-0.2060222178697586,
0.6556188464164734,
0.7309569716453552,
-0.1453203558921814,
0.9383810758590698,
-0.42733627557754517,
0.37348735332489014,
1.171830177307129,
-0.25547561049461365,
0.8233811259269714,
0.7679018378257751,
-0.4057234525680542,
0.2067960947751999,
0.7242096066474915,
-0.4375811517238617,
0.6209063529968262,
0.44839468598365784,
-0.5370832085609436,
-0.13868768513202667,
-0.2764992415904999,
-0.47107210755348206,
0.30524539947509766,
0.8365327715873718,
-0.2810618281364441,
-0.2152806967496872,
-0.07300066202878952,
0.07090214639902115,
-0.14794276654720306,
0.06125284731388092,
0.5456622838973999,
0.4176822304725647,
-0.21308432519435883,
0.22000396251678467,
-0.08466798067092896,
0.38814714550971985,
-0.3684486150741577,
-0.04969552904367447,
-0.03346678614616394,
0.31084057688713074,
-0.0969892144203186,
-0.9247386455535889,
0.3701915144920349,
-0.3295484483242035,
-0.22745507955551147,
0.005059538874775171,
0.5479490160942078,
-0.679936408996582,
-0.7640937566757202,
0.3596791923046112,
0.4583590626716614,
0.15495958924293518,
0.16227863729000092,
-0.8073571920394897,
-0.054261378943920135,
-0.018504582345485687,
-0.1848856806755066,
0.25501513481140137,
0.39436832070350647,
0.32984015345573425,
0.9163286089897156,
0.7573562860488892,
-0.03375391662120819,
0.16763773560523987,
-0.17281047999858856,
1.1285021305084229,
-0.5835033059120178,
-0.04514187201857567,
-0.837457537651062,
0.6801193356513977,
0.11547915637493134,
-0.25522762537002563,
0.5977200269699097,
1.079813838005066,
0.7411009073257446,
-0.20156940817832947,
1.017736792564392,
-0.054619986563920975,
0.3878318667411804,
-0.7075768113136292,
0.7041071057319641,
-0.376546174287796,
0.268245667219162,
-0.039799537509679794,
-1.0175752639770508,
-0.40980297327041626,
0.5346028804779053,
0.10452515631914139,
0.0963398739695549,
0.5833207964897156,
0.9152091145515442,
-0.13708648085594177,
-0.07845611870288849,
0.12200706452131271,
-0.06018298864364624,
0.728915274143219,
0.617581844329834,
0.7397832274436951,
-0.510450541973114,
0.2509160339832306,
-0.36015745997428894,
0.37397846579551697,
-0.2673945128917694,
-0.931881308555603,
-0.8953078985214233,
-0.5482836365699768,
-0.3016456961631775,
-0.42763522267341614,
0.11318905651569366,
1.0926729440689087,
0.8302177786827087,
-1.0835896730422974,
-0.6413144469261169,
-0.6510151028633118,
-0.09360276907682419,
0.4654841721057892,
-0.183502659201622,
0.06429411470890045,
-0.11654182523488998,
-0.41988638043403625,
0.8379518985748291,
0.2714592218399048,
0.6370964050292969,
-0.30857038497924805,
-0.37326210737228394,
-0.331258088350296,
0.02488403022289276,
0.24189713597297668,
0.1277894377708435,
-0.3829842209815979,
-0.1092531606554985,
-0.11907549947500229,
-0.1371137797832489,
0.43811291456222534,
0.6165465712547302,
-0.4977189600467682,
0.5287634134292603,
0.3641170859336853,
0.38335055112838745,
0.7164447903633118,
-0.32862094044685364,
1.4406203031539917,
-0.9457883834838867,
0.3248131573200226,
0.20206965506076813,
0.5280104279518127,
0.5018775463104248,
-0.23102039098739624,
0.6089086532592773,
0.3191128671169281,
-0.4439951181411743,
-0.6925442218780518,
0.42128610610961914,
-0.9748363494873047,
-0.14599277079105377,
0.943675696849823,
0.16962960362434387,
-0.05771009251475334,
-0.05113949999213219,
-0.30774566531181335,
0.22926335036754608,
-0.6459532380104065,
0.24978135526180267,
0.7916074991226196,
-0.0767572894692421,
-0.2619674801826477,
-0.8610445857048035,
0.856599748134613,
-0.10166539251804352,
-1.0035187005996704,
-0.0873514711856842,
0.49282124638557434,
0.14824587106704712,
0.2902931272983551,
0.2753582000732422,
0.059186987578868866,
-0.0016567863058298826,
0.007008895743638277,
-0.09357447922229767,
-0.07466457039117813,
-0.7925766706466675,
0.027855686843395233,
-0.18773026764392853,
0.13576145470142365,
-0.15953458845615387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14948v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14948v2
|
Re-Examine Distantly Supervised NER: A New Benchmark and a Simple Approach
| 2024-02-22T20:07:02 | 2024-02-26T14:59:58 |
Yuepei Li, Kang Zhou, Qiao Qiao, Qing Wang, Qi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper delves into Named Entity Recognition (NER) under the framework of
Distant Supervision (DS-NER), where the main challenge lies in the compromised
quality of labels due to inherent errors such as false positives, false
negatives, and positive type errors. We critically assess the efficacy of
current DS-NER methodologies using a real-world benchmark dataset named QTL,
revealing that their performance often does not meet expectations. To tackle
the prevalent issue of label noise, we introduce a simple yet effective
approach, Curriculum-based Positive-Unlabeled Learning CuPUL, which
strategically starts on "easy" and cleaner samples during the training process
to enhance model resilience to noisy samples. Our empirical results highlight
the capability of CuPUL to significantly reduce the impact of noisy labels and
outperform existing methods. QTL dataset and our code is available on GitHub.
|
[
-0.4012964963912964,
-0.43769434094429016,
0.2988565266132355,
-0.2930893003940582,
-0.02884197235107422,
0.08944082260131836,
-0.24364544451236725,
-0.7384894490242004,
0.010946903377771378,
0.37678977847099304,
-0.46217313408851624,
-0.5940571427345276,
-0.6431592106819153,
0.11363447457551956,
-0.5483713150024414,
1.1775169372558594,
0.20990139245986938,
0.10776686668395996,
-0.10108520835638046,
-0.20115244388580322,
-0.11511587351560593,
-0.488785982131958,
-1.2461466789245605,
-0.10513726621866226,
0.8470688462257385,
0.3490353226661682,
0.3374692499637604,
0.21680377423763275,
0.5780388116836548,
0.11205312609672546,
-0.32314684987068176,
0.3636746406555176,
-0.6528619527816772,
0.2147485464811325,
-0.2178468406200409,
-0.2712031602859497,
-0.45670005679130554,
-0.1251824051141739,
0.6568503379821777,
0.7696244716644287,
-0.11403673142194748,
0.23912157118320465,
0.12156730890274048,
0.693549394607544,
-0.6904887557029724,
0.2880556583404541,
-0.5040526986122131,
-0.014582722447812557,
-0.33507096767425537,
0.45490607619285583,
-0.5639141798019409,
-0.5216203331947327,
0.20020869374275208,
-0.6713066697120667,
0.40400460362434387,
0.13209933042526245,
1.2427440881729126,
0.3666516840457916,
-0.4929770827293396,
-0.23112700879573822,
-0.8611643314361572,
0.9210156202316284,
-0.5189996957778931,
0.6710804104804993,
0.6498021483421326,
0.6243530511856079,
-0.32900118827819824,
-0.766020655632019,
-0.22003398835659027,
-0.010585221461951733,
0.11671386659145355,
0.10285236686468124,
-0.20222686231136322,
-0.19059999287128448,
0.4616142213344574,
0.21491654217243195,
0.042054519057273865,
0.18907678127288818,
-0.47350382804870605,
-0.23426634073257446,
0.4816703498363495,
-0.07262428104877472,
0.029369384050369263,
0.3356090188026428,
-0.20822268724441528,
-0.06987183541059494,
-0.8542641997337341,
-0.031057843938469887,
0.27663174271583557,
0.47873592376708984,
0.016373859718441963,
0.2547520101070404,
-0.5640755891799927,
0.5060415267944336,
0.3279868960380554,
-0.29196837544441223,
0.26301109790802,
-0.09973756223917007,
-0.02346934750676155,
0.4053312838077545,
0.4680502712726593,
0.179910346865654,
0.09611789137125015,
-0.6071668267250061,
-0.25539419054985046,
0.07829029113054276,
0.19610242545604706,
-0.8737731575965881,
-0.7184235453605652,
0.025546057149767876,
-0.1757299154996872,
-0.15365765988826752,
0.010616733692586422,
-0.8523210287094116,
-0.4114891290664673,
-0.5423058867454529,
0.36550310254096985,
-0.4627527594566345,
-0.359798401594162,
-0.12786756455898285,
0.2315526306629181,
0.08802492916584015,
0.5590949058532715,
-0.593474268913269,
0.4110359251499176,
0.6889706254005432,
0.538625955581665,
-0.059789564460515976,
-0.003102395450696349,
-0.9206870794296265,
0.16145971417427063,
-0.09050412476062775,
0.8433196544647217,
-0.277216374874115,
-0.292881578207016,
-0.3792140483856201,
0.10843849927186966,
0.025536738336086273,
-0.7120404243469238,
0.5287002921104431,
-0.7123715877532959,
0.14042288064956665,
-0.45477211475372314,
-0.6468642950057983,
-0.1675817221403122,
0.14505694806575775,
-0.7341247797012329,
0.906754732131958,
0.22782737016677856,
-0.9698600769042969,
0.7865560054779053,
-0.2558872401714325,
-0.3296011984348297,
-0.0917031392455101,
-0.1642075926065445,
-1.1511081457138062,
-0.12241355329751968,
0.28078514337539673,
0.2010667771100998,
-0.18890437483787537,
0.5770880579948425,
-0.3513402044773102,
-0.4321620464324951,
0.039199985563755035,
-0.3299950361251831,
0.8821747303009033,
0.09119723737239838,
-0.403305321931839,
-0.14124538004398346,
-1.1002711057662964,
0.11956236511468887,
-0.17971093952655792,
0.023764487355947495,
-0.6353803277015686,
-0.0930364802479744,
-0.2601398527622223,
0.08181453496217728,
-0.18044666945934296,
-0.5741512775421143,
0.08432125300168991,
-0.17502383887767792,
0.17443378269672394,
0.3546646535396576,
0.11251398921012878,
0.32640179991722107,
-0.40374210476875305,
0.254896342754364,
0.30951300263404846,
0.09772706031799316,
0.3000045120716095,
-0.33855006098747253,
-0.864021360874176,
-0.5472457408905029,
0.6378963589668274,
0.031633779406547546,
-0.6831791996955872,
-0.021862057968974113,
-0.1615435779094696,
-0.6567364931106567,
-0.5365875959396362,
-0.010236362926661968,
0.4035544693470001,
0.8371468782424927,
0.6890907287597656,
-0.2737872004508972,
-0.7888807654380798,
-0.7935389876365662,
0.08391804248094559,
-0.16602575778961182,
0.10514143109321594,
0.15955893695354462,
0.46958908438682556,
-0.44609546661376953,
0.8709359169006348,
-0.2839871942996979,
-0.3517136871814728,
0.15487299859523773,
0.2600836455821991,
0.10978644341230392,
0.43765175342559814,
0.25836607813835144,
-0.841580331325531,
-0.33076322078704834,
-0.2966853976249695,
-0.7285446524620056,
-0.05170327052474022,
0.01656765677034855,
-0.08077017217874527,
0.09861038625240326,
0.6343165040016174,
-0.33575528860092163,
0.364234060049057,
0.29828891158103943,
0.02435283549129963,
0.927009105682373,
0.14246594905853271,
0.015503467991948128,
-0.9630783796310425,
0.02971128560602665,
-0.03127836436033249,
0.041540466248989105,
-0.4611791670322418,
-0.1504356563091278,
0.2593657970428467,
0.1519828885793686,
-0.5891983509063721,
0.42547664046287537,
-0.9904072284698486,
0.028195325285196304,
-0.0780995562672615,
0.014614500105381012,
0.08678895980119705,
0.07904984056949615,
0.10117055475711823,
0.790902853012085,
0.7116981148719788,
-0.7967037558555603,
0.028321754187345505,
0.2109130471944809,
-0.3538464307785034,
1.0041286945343018,
-0.4255290925502777,
-0.11333253979682922,
-0.32334908843040466,
0.172437846660614,
-0.6054525375366211,
-0.1951473355293274,
0.28650861978530884,
-0.14717955887317657,
0.7511518001556396,
-0.25732648372650146,
-0.37625566124916077,
-0.22503966093063354,
0.020461345091462135,
0.5750209093093872,
0.4379889667034149,
-0.8640422224998474,
0.10524588078260422,
0.46188977360725403,
0.3031032681465149,
-0.3866158127784729,
-0.59595787525177,
0.16425710916519165,
-0.3856138288974762,
-0.04700063169002533,
0.40716466307640076,
0.1970854103565216,
-0.29706820845603943,
0.07346540689468384,
-0.407671183347702,
-0.4878233075141907,
0.01003128569573164,
0.5952861309051514,
0.07130835950374603,
-0.3773665726184845,
0.2569223940372467,
-0.040666308254003525,
-0.21550686657428741,
0.15790078043937683,
-0.06107303872704506,
-0.10563890635967255,
-0.1979811191558838,
-0.22137412428855896,
-0.5702160000801086,
-0.10503296554088593,
0.13378320634365082,
-0.0773201510310173,
0.6725591421127319,
0.6054697632789612,
-0.5587854981422424,
-0.2126890867948532,
-0.6335833072662354,
-0.25065550208091736,
-0.4174673855304718,
0.12201913446187973,
-0.4562084376811981,
-0.8634220957756042,
0.22338730096817017,
-0.3595713973045349,
-0.25086697936058044,
0.22483204305171967,
-0.04509864002466202,
-0.1313728243112564,
0.3119109272956848,
0.5925361514091492,
-0.10771885514259338,
0.28283536434173584,
-0.15489427745342255,
0.3502689301967621,
-1.1057461500167847,
-0.315166711807251,
-0.436413437128067,
0.0542314276099205,
-0.6045819520950317,
-0.3266925513744354,
0.00510137714445591,
0.4433249533176422,
-0.42473697662353516,
0.807274341583252,
-0.562164306640625,
0.37007614970207214,
0.5838304758071899,
0.16034822165966034,
0.4223155379295349,
0.0003517308214213699,
0.049351077526807785,
-0.4109995365142822,
-0.568016767501831,
-0.4654892683029175,
0.9676170349121094,
0.09651769697666168,
0.7243779301643372,
0.2359558641910553,
1.2832809686660767,
0.11044830828905106,
0.7425885200500488,
-0.5021654367446899,
0.5043396353721619,
0.1355104297399521,
-0.6399427652359009,
-0.27406004071235657,
-0.49017637968063354,
-1.1583895683288574,
0.011632513254880905,
-0.16046839952468872,
-1.0629100799560547,
0.38131392002105713,
-0.09064432233572006,
-0.43580323457717896,
0.5544096231460571,
-0.6256656646728516,
0.5854541659355164,
-0.03556041419506073,
-0.6125755906105042,
0.3881329298019409,
-0.7113609910011292,
0.5388506650924683,
-0.360412061214447,
0.20467108488082886,
-0.10249511897563934,
0.17334914207458496,
0.6723640561103821,
-0.19785165786743164,
0.921149492263794,
-0.06237627565860748,
-0.1473989188671112,
0.530608594417572,
0.0776907280087471,
0.43184372782707214,
0.17175650596618652,
-0.2956986129283905,
0.42934125661849976,
-0.06641809642314911,
-0.36259278655052185,
-0.3280160427093506,
0.8023169040679932,
-0.7444137930870056,
-0.3733183443546295,
-0.47210460901260376,
-0.19102461636066437,
-0.1128411665558815,
0.4917142391204834,
0.22138068079948425,
0.4516991674900055,
-0.27350810170173645,
0.0682259202003479,
0.8134753108024597,
-0.20473502576351166,
0.31498613953590393,
0.39161741733551025,
-0.19213499128818512,
-0.5784983038902283,
1.076466679573059,
0.3904176652431488,
0.14274334907531738,
0.4222531318664551,
-0.2676199674606323,
-0.2183539718389511,
-0.497121661901474,
-0.20492231845855713,
0.2722645699977875,
-0.4712904393672943,
-0.3910118043422699,
-0.8169403076171875,
-0.35387012362480164,
-0.21950766444206238,
-0.02794191986322403,
-0.7120128870010376,
-0.18855983018875122,
-0.5699953436851501,
0.037121377885341644,
0.16960525512695312,
0.6872521638870239,
-0.011816635727882385,
0.11957622319459915,
-0.604253888130188,
0.2995111048221588,
0.1778833121061325,
0.39792296290397644,
-0.02013159543275833,
-0.4129253327846527,
-0.10991277545690536,
0.1417989432811737,
-0.1738770455121994,
-0.7738969922065735,
0.3167543113231659,
0.22328856587409973,
0.497548907995224,
0.3086419999599457,
0.5580084919929504,
0.7860431671142578,
-0.2133009433746338,
0.35162782669067383,
0.05969369038939476,
-0.5530166029930115,
0.5066831111907959,
-0.24204576015472412,
0.16204950213432312,
0.8934417963027954,
0.5170331597328186,
-0.15779487788677216,
-0.39054399728775024,
-0.9003294110298157,
-0.9978747963905334,
0.37353798747062683,
0.23335547745227814,
-0.48784390091896057,
-0.1967366337776184,
0.3025420010089874,
0.23665575683116913,
0.23336412012577057,
-0.6026203632354736,
-0.34520962834358215,
0.0661751925945282,
0.16041631996631622,
0.04321645200252533,
-0.2373429238796234,
0.21407057344913483,
-0.15247417986392975,
0.9617339372634888,
0.13168737292289734,
0.1501559466123581,
0.3273264765739441,
-0.06309116631746292,
0.10804794728755951,
0.4110633134841919,
0.20269989967346191,
0.28681522607803345,
-0.37171149253845215,
0.29679185152053833,
0.19196288287639618,
-0.3198274075984955,
0.19620439410209656,
0.15920287370681763,
-0.5009157061576843,
0.048580870032310486,
0.07355068624019623,
0.38161176443099976,
0.35609006881713867,
-0.2533929646015167,
0.30497443675994873,
-0.20663057267665863,
-0.11662028729915619,
-0.43023866415023804,
0.10073409974575043,
0.17190417647361755,
0.20083484053611755,
0.12588347494602203,
0.09091457724571228,
0.25705334544181824,
-0.10768675804138184,
0.628704309463501,
0.2032863050699234,
-0.818858802318573,
-0.24635809659957886,
0.9380809664726257,
-0.038965582847595215,
-0.14479008316993713,
0.8545835018157959,
-0.7599457502365112,
-0.20385432243347168,
0.7199809551239014,
0.577917754650116,
0.6827079057693481,
0.14367185533046722,
0.2745691239833832,
0.8119985461235046,
0.16018706560134888,
-0.4596160352230072,
-0.2007598727941513,
-0.10061151534318924,
-0.5825849771499634,
-0.35086148977279663,
-0.4584197700023651,
-0.6909825205802917,
0.1059577614068985,
-1.0469324588775635,
0.3945908546447754,
-0.3822147846221924,
-0.3436061441898346,
0.19356077909469604,
-0.010509285144507885,
-0.46155691146850586,
0.44718360900878906,
0.12100636959075928,
0.4903262257575989,
-0.5688440799713135,
1.0192219018936157,
0.7322574853897095,
-0.5043181777000427,
-0.8276228904724121,
0.07070811092853546,
0.24559925496578217,
-0.20575928688049316,
0.9527890086174011,
0.4490608870983124,
-0.22889286279678345,
0.21550975739955902,
-0.3071938753128052,
-0.9981451630592346,
1.0774385929107666,
0.02109464630484581,
-1.0410658121109009,
0.14659704267978668,
-0.20244334638118744,
0.6946282386779785,
-0.04429906979203224,
0.24063940346240997,
0.3405267894268036,
0.22534307837486267,
-0.002632668474689126,
-0.5975455045700073,
0.07377687096595764,
-0.060842741280794144,
-0.28519609570503235,
0.5309643149375916,
-0.8566201329231262,
0.535538911819458,
-0.6108816266059875,
-0.533112108707428,
0.11488517373800278,
0.8533609509468079,
0.16851617395877838,
0.7076821327209473,
0.23253607749938965,
0.6587910056114197,
1.0868639945983887,
-0.26897791028022766,
0.6056311726570129,
-0.09775293618440628,
0.5160151720046997,
1.829696774482727,
-0.5445812940597534,
0.7128541469573975,
0.628593921661377,
-0.39372920989990234,
0.2639078199863434,
0.6048855185508728,
-0.35527899861335754,
0.6370392441749573,
0.45292606949806213,
-0.5116335153579712,
-0.13524949550628662,
-0.358031690120697,
-0.4770500361919403,
0.08478638529777527,
0.2869720458984375,
-0.005632259417325258,
-0.5003715753555298,
-0.06290091574192047,
-0.04806122928857803,
0.10735777765512466,
-0.21224814653396606,
0.636512041091919,
0.245261088013649,
-0.26091474294662476,
0.36495262384414673,
-0.39637133479118347,
0.8083914518356323,
-0.0252891406416893,
-0.1300230771303177,
-0.1105412170290947,
0.30160170793533325,
-0.3113483190536499,
-0.3418455421924591,
0.4118554890155792,
-0.23696641623973846,
-0.1168348491191864,
0.08389248698949814,
0.7224659323692322,
-0.4268484115600586,
-0.5072745680809021,
0.3503333032131195,
0.511485755443573,
0.361602783203125,
-0.019295938313007355,
-0.47386282682418823,
-0.20067098736763,
-0.07042213529348373,
0.0780353993177414,
0.49047496914863586,
0.6047136187553406,
-0.19274406135082245,
0.7735073566436768,
0.5199358463287354,
0.07784218341112137,
-0.11398876458406448,
0.18481573462486267,
0.7289141416549683,
-0.6958099007606506,
-0.0212558563798666,
-0.5858634114265442,
0.1528957635164261,
-0.1456930786371231,
-0.3148788809776306,
0.8348473906517029,
0.6965680122375488,
1.2650190591812134,
0.1809479296207428,
0.44694700837135315,
0.025395642966032028,
0.7258555889129639,
-0.09782277047634125,
0.6444939970970154,
-0.3393721878528595,
0.5222131609916687,
-0.5194941759109497,
-0.8180647492408752,
-0.6788334846496582,
0.4333396852016449,
-0.5617396831512451,
-0.05340352654457092,
0.6466326117515564,
0.8640287518501282,
-0.1545284241437912,
0.14444196224212646,
0.49937066435813904,
0.0748266652226448,
0.2257843166589737,
0.5573137998580933,
1.0128482580184937,
-0.8634166121482849,
0.41073668003082275,
-0.6214145421981812,
0.2614087760448456,
-0.09516388177871704,
-0.8902009725570679,
-0.8577888607978821,
-0.2462993562221527,
-1.1463713645935059,
-0.5443345904350281,
0.6053711771965027,
0.5636636018753052,
0.6620011925697327,
-1.0207751989364624,
0.28533464670181274,
-0.22780737280845642,
0.2075166553258896,
-0.3483932912349701,
-0.22552534937858582,
0.5995228886604309,
-0.18382905423641205,
-0.6526021957397461,
0.20898151397705078,
0.039178475737571716,
0.1932309865951538,
0.2367914766073227,
0.027484579011797905,
-0.09446877241134644,
-0.5704365372657776,
0.45069876313209534,
0.49214282631874084,
-0.5118346214294434,
-0.2701908349990845,
-0.31143105030059814,
-0.4808361232280731,
0.1365658938884735,
0.27931806445121765,
-0.7518705725669861,
0.4661808907985687,
-0.1749667227268219,
0.8118994832038879,
0.5515139102935791,
0.08302051573991776,
0.05418074503540993,
-0.43287158012390137,
-0.14839501678943634,
0.15788789093494415,
0.20581026375293732,
0.4197387993335724,
-0.4423130452632904,
0.756924569606781,
0.10876896977424622,
-0.6659335494041443,
-0.8437739610671997,
0.10360565781593323,
-1.0333514213562012,
0.024583948776125908,
1.1800976991653442,
-0.35576552152633667,
-0.23592887818813324,
-0.4937960207462311,
-0.24533434212207794,
0.5314799547195435,
-0.5240737199783325,
0.9413466453552246,
0.48746001720428467,
-0.11424054950475693,
-0.18280574679374695,
-0.5155578255653381,
0.42321375012397766,
0.32192128896713257,
-0.5817508101463318,
-0.1440185159444809,
0.6257768869400024,
0.5382872819900513,
0.0012927900534123182,
0.4643966257572174,
-0.20954529941082,
0.09859542548656464,
0.32337942719459534,
0.16691601276397705,
-0.0577317550778389,
-0.4183201789855957,
-0.15250901877880096,
0.16080592572689056,
0.21755942702293396,
-0.16320239007472992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14818v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14818v2
|
PALO: A Polyglot Large Multimodal Model for 5B People
| 2024-02-22T18:59:58 | 2024-03-05T11:22:07 |
Muhammad Maaz, Hanoona Rasheed, Abdelrahman Shaker, Salman Khan, Hisham Cholakal, Rao M. Anwer, Tim Baldwin, Michael Felsberg, Fahad S. Khan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In pursuit of more inclusive Vision-Language Models (VLMs), this study
introduces a Large Multilingual Multimodal Model called PALO. PALO offers
visual reasoning capabilities in 10 major languages, including English,
Chinese, Hindi, Spanish, French, Arabic, Bengali, Russian, Urdu, and Japanese,
that span a total of ~5B people (65% of the world population). Our approach
involves a semi-automated translation approach to adapt the multimodal
instruction dataset from English to the target languages using a fine-tuned
Large Language Model, thereby ensuring high linguistic fidelity while allowing
scalability due to minimal manual effort. The incorporation of diverse
instruction sets helps us boost overall performance across multiple languages
especially those that are underrepresented like Hindi, Arabic, Bengali, and
Urdu. The resulting models are trained across three scales (1.7B, 7B and 13B
parameters) to show the generalization and scalability where we observe
substantial improvements compared to strong baselines. We also propose the
first multilingual multimodal benchmark for the forthcoming approaches to
evaluate their vision-language reasoning capabilities across languages. Code:
https://github.com/mbzuai-oryx/PALO.
|
[
-0.30969712138175964,
-0.7571535706520081,
0.3845106363296509,
0.46642276644706726,
-0.27252301573753357,
0.10312504321336746,
-0.14893044531345367,
-0.6217454075813293,
-0.02797059342265129,
0.44447949528694153,
-0.21824519336223602,
-0.6844213008880615,
-0.43374475836753845,
0.025118228048086166,
-0.3520687520503998,
0.8082320094108582,
0.09743179380893707,
0.2427903115749359,
-0.0761210173368454,
-0.18149375915527344,
-0.36381441354751587,
-0.36855024099349976,
-0.35046207904815674,
0.08348213881254196,
0.5952299237251282,
0.41038408875465393,
0.8811601996421814,
0.275947630405426,
0.6511192321777344,
0.23885786533355713,
-0.11880882829427719,
0.5381397604942322,
-0.321819931268692,
-0.25446799397468567,
-0.3958444893360138,
-0.5601078867912292,
-0.5050749778747559,
-0.38534626364707947,
0.9406249523162842,
0.6875013113021851,
-0.4158671200275421,
0.39759576320648193,
-0.3268529176712036,
0.7562063336372375,
-0.788848876953125,
0.3366177976131439,
-0.5552499294281006,
0.052978336811065674,
-0.3981373906135559,
0.459484338760376,
-0.6531931161880493,
-0.29407167434692383,
0.05510237067937851,
-0.7071436047554016,
0.0432903990149498,
0.3864848017692566,
0.7047390937805176,
0.17362433671951294,
-0.6043837666511536,
0.254996657371521,
-0.6506386399269104,
0.9602039456367493,
-0.38342490792274475,
0.47647371888160706,
0.3297857940196991,
0.7180606722831726,
0.016301816329360008,
-0.4968886375427246,
-0.8993199467658997,
-0.14222761988639832,
-0.0062409657984972,
0.24498863518238068,
-0.01234673522412777,
-0.056255534291267395,
0.30379828810691833,
0.2860132157802582,
-0.6506062746047974,
-0.16613753139972687,
-0.8029121160507202,
-0.045437056571245193,
0.8068033456802368,
0.16694596409797668,
0.30497708916664124,
-0.20622511208057404,
-0.42776405811309814,
-0.17317160964012146,
-0.5051464438438416,
0.22275415062904358,
0.12810437381267548,
0.026532262563705444,
-0.32552745938301086,
0.6439634561538696,
-0.10046356916427612,
1.1873648166656494,
-0.406248539686203,
-0.5769039392471313,
0.5197415351867676,
-0.44370758533477783,
-0.40999290347099304,
-0.2488938570022583,
0.7632979154586792,
0.3539591431617737,
0.40286850929260254,
0.23742294311523438,
0.05873795971274376,
0.06076042726635933,
0.15586939454078674,
-0.3450734615325928,
-0.053937532007694244,
-0.05697711184620857,
-0.5780107378959656,
-0.020481901243329048,
0.00048411605530418456,
-0.8313273787498474,
-0.5931409597396851,
-0.13884496688842773,
0.32626232504844666,
-0.5341506600379944,
-0.24919265508651733,
0.42250970005989075,
-0.05183466896414757,
0.4185463786125183,
0.7444701194763184,
-0.9647873044013977,
-0.002774618798866868,
0.2628635764122009,
0.5137475728988647,
-0.1104142889380455,
-0.6174317002296448,
-0.20797711610794067,
0.5160377621650696,
-0.4843948781490326,
0.614010214805603,
-0.6966866254806519,
-0.5519046187400818,
-0.2746756970882416,
-0.04714919626712799,
-0.3182452917098999,
-0.2807135581970215,
0.3761967122554779,
-0.2750670611858368,
0.46566975116729736,
-0.17636412382125854,
0.25632086396217346,
-0.8233426213264465,
0.4691500961780548,
-0.5602369904518127,
0.9946114420890808,
0.10091448575258255,
-0.48420464992523193,
0.2808491289615631,
-0.5235723257064819,
-0.4586024880409241,
0.010908682830631733,
-0.15492761135101318,
-0.37489035725593567,
0.18828225135803223,
0.6446760296821594,
0.3728766143321991,
-0.660156786441803,
0.26320406794548035,
-0.31203198432922363,
-0.2548538148403168,
0.10899102687835693,
-0.4331556558609009,
0.7089102268218994,
0.20671454071998596,
-0.09572865068912506,
0.3225620687007904,
-0.9527178406715393,
-0.14869946241378784,
0.0911833867430687,
-0.13674335181713104,
-0.19958478212356567,
0.12769167125225067,
0.22603139281272888,
0.31029409170150757,
0.40846940875053406,
-0.6141605377197266,
0.29015684127807617,
-0.25391024351119995,
0.004490520339459181,
0.7291260361671448,
-0.3623138964176178,
0.08624932169914246,
-0.047548916190862656,
0.6315715312957764,
0.22006748616695404,
0.6838935613632202,
-0.4201582968235016,
-0.7863244414329529,
-0.7940239310264587,
-0.7029196619987488,
0.09312412887811661,
0.6182874441146851,
-1.0589627027511597,
-0.29974493384361267,
-0.29044169187545776,
-0.5534661412239075,
-0.8027724027633667,
0.2601155638694763,
0.6171077489852905,
0.3330761194229126,
0.4694043695926666,
-0.31040528416633606,
-0.24408665299415588,
-1.1661248207092285,
0.12254218012094498,
-0.2775743901729584,
0.2364378124475479,
0.19844383001327515,
0.5273578763008118,
-0.2791389524936676,
0.6575557589530945,
-0.45400264859199524,
-0.39641302824020386,
-0.4434082508087158,
0.0068501876667141914,
0.28511926531791687,
0.12158191949129105,
0.7392433881759644,
-1.2040420770645142,
-0.7861183881759644,
0.5225031971931458,
-0.8896170854568481,
0.0973908007144928,
0.11139622330665588,
0.11394887417554855,
0.24948036670684814,
0.20511943101882935,
-0.23703965544700623,
0.42594996094703674,
0.9122474193572998,
-0.21853932738304138,
0.5168541073799133,
-0.43837425112724304,
0.2640450596809387,
-1.1827893257141113,
-0.0020582738798111677,
0.031321655958890915,
-0.2990168035030365,
-0.23905791342258453,
0.21294160187244415,
0.19593390822410583,
-0.3103148341178894,
-0.7147505283355713,
0.5338258743286133,
-0.645818829536438,
-0.17745716869831085,
0.04421718418598175,
-0.07342641800642014,
0.040485844016075134,
0.4298957884311676,
0.12885192036628723,
0.7647849917411804,
0.9387762546539307,
-0.33833250403404236,
0.8046424388885498,
0.04372392222285271,
-0.5384200811386108,
0.783757209777832,
-0.7744526863098145,
-0.2862193286418915,
-0.468620628118515,
0.28574222326278687,
-1.1284157037734985,
-0.49627581238746643,
0.03476019948720932,
-0.3138933777809143,
-0.03911345452070236,
0.07529406994581223,
-0.6866558194160461,
-0.5390707850456238,
-0.3256002962589264,
0.44426947832107544,
0.5377134680747986,
-0.5059459209442139,
0.8976976275444031,
0.454618364572525,
-0.004414981696754694,
-0.623424232006073,
-0.561198890209198,
0.11068021506071091,
-0.15335756540298462,
-0.9877923727035522,
0.08627364039421082,
0.129247784614563,
-0.19145730137825012,
-0.21792550384998322,
0.43823814392089844,
-0.022764431312680244,
-0.183464914560318,
0.1552211344242096,
0.47949960827827454,
-0.13253943622112274,
0.1643814742565155,
0.09458307921886444,
-0.17092809081077576,
-0.34795233607292175,
-0.12848679721355438,
0.31665799021720886,
-0.42624273896217346,
-0.7250159978866577,
-0.345497190952301,
0.37872713804244995,
1.000639796257019,
-0.9113717079162598,
1.1541491746902466,
0.9743063449859619,
-0.12716937065124512,
0.008191779255867004,
-0.6556428670883179,
0.40020787715911865,
-0.35571083426475525,
0.48775142431259155,
-0.632731556892395,
-0.6516039967536926,
0.5529701709747314,
-0.027825716882944107,
0.12294696271419525,
0.3486827313899994,
0.79047691822052,
-0.07295973598957062,
1.414958119392395,
0.8713236451148987,
0.01720026694238186,
0.3579337000846863,
-0.01490494329482317,
0.17246536910533905,
-0.7389147877693176,
-0.6032558679580688,
-0.19849082827568054,
-0.31153470277786255,
-0.47239232063293457,
-0.8865342140197754,
1.000161051750183,
-0.22647587954998016,
0.0794898271560669,
0.10104856640100479,
-0.36618712544441223,
0.5352270603179932,
0.6302217841148376,
0.01718425750732422,
0.3475392758846283,
0.01515663880854845,
-0.21273759007453918,
0.009892528876662254,
-0.6174328327178955,
-0.33340778946876526,
1.0412063598632812,
0.27850791811943054,
1.0087125301361084,
0.5907163619995117,
0.14020486176013947,
0.22436071932315826,
0.0578744001686573,
-0.3796345889568329,
0.6808801889419556,
-0.38827085494995117,
-0.8677574992179871,
-0.17534543573856354,
-0.252716988325119,
-0.824924111366272,
0.7867218852043152,
-0.35669729113578796,
-0.891630232334137,
0.1763732135295868,
0.19867973029613495,
-0.29987671971321106,
0.2147904336452484,
-1.0947511196136475,
1.046094298362732,
-0.45287075638771057,
-0.45156869292259216,
-0.6110467314720154,
-0.9543864727020264,
0.5844098925590515,
-0.24888940155506134,
0.5439901351928711,
-0.2626058757305145,
0.060188837349414825,
0.27570417523384094,
0.0420038104057312,
0.874744176864624,
-0.06456159800291061,
0.038067255169153214,
0.2650642991065979,
-0.15676644444465637,
0.182426318526268,
-0.129394993185997,
-0.13897252082824707,
0.31170517206192017,
0.16146862506866455,
-0.7543503642082214,
-0.5267458558082581,
0.3679178059101105,
-0.8940796852111816,
-0.5001572966575623,
-0.5275436639785767,
-0.7836530208587646,
-0.06903320550918579,
0.12238729000091553,
-0.18570739030838013,
0.1465395838022232,
-0.05652846395969391,
0.4344550371170044,
0.5639192461967468,
-0.5696418285369873,
0.21577100455760956,
0.726325273513794,
-1.0122753381729126,
-0.47196289896965027,
1.1187862157821655,
0.033644892275333405,
0.4970480799674988,
0.4069429337978363,
0.18263469636440277,
-0.18948101997375488,
-0.4013625979423523,
-0.9794952869415283,
0.37778186798095703,
-0.504747211933136,
0.29721638560295105,
-0.36039999127388,
-0.014809651300311089,
-0.37614771723747253,
-0.1314576417207718,
-0.3248833417892456,
-0.26180407404899597,
0.27024045586586,
0.17356707155704498,
0.08388420939445496,
0.6742643713951111,
0.23066450655460358,
0.4492547810077667,
-0.8584484457969666,
0.6300632953643799,
0.41068023443222046,
-0.017704352736473083,
-0.16360057890415192,
-0.4617549777030945,
-0.29422810673713684,
0.050380535423755646,
-0.2634579837322235,
-0.819417417049408,
0.40467628836631775,
0.24320486187934875,
0.5966699123382568,
0.3721913993358612,
-0.37028515338897705,
0.8210265636444092,
-0.459459125995636,
0.9548421502113342,
0.45263633131980896,
-0.8412683606147766,
0.6394195556640625,
-0.48613542318344116,
0.43397626280784607,
0.23437082767486572,
0.39821282029151917,
-0.6375630497932434,
-0.09125734865665436,
-0.25727516412734985,
-0.6656885743141174,
0.677669882774353,
-0.044365864247083664,
0.12004788219928741,
0.14144842326641083,
-0.21112315356731415,
0.1808965802192688,
0.2756166160106659,
-0.9623784422874451,
0.11311296373605728,
-0.07438962161540985,
-0.36938658356666565,
-0.1481637805700302,
-0.17183972895145416,
0.027955958619713783,
-0.6214792132377625,
0.5673491954803467,
-0.19699326157569885,
-0.061331167817115784,
-0.1745825707912445,
-0.09090439975261688,
0.14990097284317017,
0.178097665309906,
0.6806873083114624,
0.911706268787384,
-0.03625922650098801,
-0.0014434303157031536,
0.3501293957233429,
-0.4029597043991089,
-0.004226943477988243,
0.06428612768650055,
-0.2032541036605835,
-0.1774289608001709,
0.33341121673583984,
0.9666542410850525,
-0.04924587905406952,
-0.9693174958229065,
0.5484076142311096,
-0.08127956092357635,
0.20066989958286285,
-0.3101385235786438,
0.15663735568523407,
-0.031215067952871323,
0.22661380469799042,
0.1885446161031723,
-0.020926129072904587,
-0.15212219953536987,
-0.7463846802711487,
-0.3892669379711151,
0.3605102300643921,
-0.24525228142738342,
-0.2922942638397217,
0.7018626928329468,
0.31835103034973145,
0.07006634026765823,
0.5137411952018738,
-0.06074376776814461,
-0.43208083510398865,
0.28751689195632935,
0.5380459427833557,
0.31859543919563293,
-0.44602516293525696,
0.36612772941589355,
0.3873175084590912,
0.6173615455627441,
-0.10380371659994125,
0.43218904733657837,
-0.025649482384324074,
-0.6601412296295166,
-0.43344223499298096,
-0.8559598922729492,
-0.5477182269096375,
-0.48684242367744446,
-0.4182831048965454,
0.5256875157356262,
-0.3632359206676483,
-0.03698691725730896,
0.03299805149435997,
-0.5337423086166382,
-0.3392598330974579,
0.35829100012779236,
0.4849621057510376,
0.6424100399017334,
-0.9554163813591003,
1.052918791770935,
1.151758074760437,
-0.6666734218597412,
-0.5379433035850525,
-0.39596548676490784,
0.14748245477676392,
-1.1182962656021118,
0.6237514019012451,
0.03147697076201439,
-0.3825071156024933,
-0.1627185046672821,
-0.49065178632736206,
-0.8737145662307739,
0.9557481408119202,
0.5944616794586182,
-0.49631890654563904,
-0.03317984938621521,
0.20330554246902466,
0.7040311694145203,
-0.19901639223098755,
0.2356816977262497,
0.225066676735878,
0.5296112895011902,
0.358732134103775,
-1.3933945894241333,
-0.5876189470291138,
-0.35381650924682617,
0.25941210985183716,
0.35714346170425415,
-1.029076337814331,
0.9730256795883179,
-0.47681111097335815,
0.17605885863304138,
-0.11265517771244049,
0.6973404288291931,
0.255636990070343,
0.3150057792663574,
0.35730740427970886,
0.6279122233390808,
0.668186604976654,
0.01505077350884676,
1.3180902004241943,
-0.0443502776324749,
0.23756109178066254,
0.728237509727478,
-0.3489667475223541,
0.7775927186012268,
0.4704076647758484,
-0.46497786045074463,
0.5969972610473633,
0.48733898997306824,
0.004521824885159731,
0.44014331698417664,
-0.04492683336138725,
-0.452152818441391,
-0.38017454743385315,
-0.39888712763786316,
-0.42441242933273315,
0.8138769268989563,
0.5407648682594299,
-0.48011311888694763,
-0.054722171276807785,
0.3281131088733673,
-0.046071525663137436,
0.09440354257822037,
-0.4225618541240692,
0.516210675239563,
-0.027022307738661766,
-0.7210276126861572,
0.5477674007415771,
0.3217584192752838,
0.3425678014755249,
-0.8456538915634155,
-0.050277817994356155,
0.034307949244976044,
0.49826180934906006,
-0.22162820398807526,
-0.9401363134384155,
0.2604391276836395,
0.10266517847776413,
-0.2646111249923706,
-0.2444007694721222,
0.5233579277992249,
-0.4807411730289459,
-1.1089954376220703,
0.1888633519411087,
0.4014469385147095,
0.27000319957733154,
0.11340577900409698,
-0.663607120513916,
0.12640897929668427,
0.28898999094963074,
0.02438509836792946,
0.1845635622739792,
0.35248011350631714,
-0.6499175429344177,
0.86604243516922,
0.8080345392227173,
0.15512433648109436,
0.37704965472221375,
0.21593017876148224,
0.615578293800354,
-0.5095759034156799,
-0.3201967477798462,
-0.8056509494781494,
0.7595146298408508,
-0.17612557113170624,
-0.48476046323776245,
0.91994309425354,
0.5308652520179749,
0.8569637537002563,
-0.22241593897342682,
0.5929152965545654,
-0.12651801109313965,
0.4873793125152588,
-0.36125555634498596,
0.45110297203063965,
-0.8564088940620422,
0.002543706214055419,
-0.31161874532699585,
-0.9507195949554443,
-0.4677985906600952,
0.833681583404541,
-0.5490720272064209,
-0.0016357607673853636,
0.6220819354057312,
0.7100009918212891,
-0.18061800301074982,
-0.10676510632038116,
0.6508053541183472,
0.11517572402954102,
0.3625860810279846,
0.7173241376876831,
0.7301632761955261,
-0.14233843982219696,
0.4772745370864868,
-0.06189442798495293,
-0.4258159399032593,
-0.09746754914522171,
-0.656539797782898,
-0.9331990480422974,
-0.40931960940361023,
-0.05809018015861511,
0.030862879008054733,
0.06009143963456154,
0.6553590893745422,
0.626254677772522,
-0.569564700126648,
-0.3513566255569458,
0.4055325984954834,
0.25510427355766296,
-0.27764618396759033,
-0.09785429388284683,
0.22330573201179504,
0.05296001955866814,
-0.8587324023246765,
0.2435326725244522,
0.6923307180404663,
-0.15051184594631195,
-0.7046058773994446,
0.02756473422050476,
-0.3255248963832855,
-0.03151654452085495,
1.018073558807373,
0.08198495954275131,
-0.9221785664558411,
-0.10739493370056152,
0.04098661616444588,
-0.13325165212154388,
-0.13999158143997192,
0.0958646833896637,
-0.6589672565460205,
1.15097975730896,
0.4850674271583557,
0.4206382930278778,
0.7886895537376404,
0.002153839450329542,
0.5836759209632874,
-0.5008195042610168,
0.5451562404632568,
-0.0333806611597538,
0.505146861076355,
0.4998404383659363,
0.09478425979614258,
0.6557589769363403,
0.478588342666626,
-0.21644867956638336,
-0.6235064268112183,
0.290706604719162,
-1.111672043800354,
-0.06664125621318817,
1.0740046501159668,
-0.23717790842056274,
-0.42093831300735474,
0.029676344245672226,
-0.7267856597900391,
-0.15797172486782074,
-0.07489639520645142,
0.8527467250823975,
0.8483497500419617,
-0.051415685564279556,
-0.500053882598877,
-0.5868860483169556,
-0.17050988972187042,
0.4472891390323639,
-0.9630177021026611,
-0.3150664269924164,
0.7169642448425293,
-0.10409314930438995,
0.315837562084198,
0.48600032925605774,
-0.30828410387039185,
0.6205412149429321,
-0.009503648616373539,
0.41172459721565247,
-0.04448137804865837,
-0.6261609196662903,
0.0680575743317604,
0.253254771232605,
0.05175839364528656,
-0.33302825689315796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14811v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14811v1
|
Fine-Tuning Enhances Existing Mechanisms: A Case Study on Entity Tracking
| 2024-02-22T18:59:24 | 2024-02-22T18:59:24 |
Nikhil Prakash, Tamar Rott Shaham, Tal Haklay, Yonatan Belinkov, David Bau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Fine-tuning on generalized tasks such as instruction following, code
generation, and mathematics has been shown to enhance language models'
performance on a range of tasks. Nevertheless, explanations of how such
fine-tuning influences the internal computations in these models remain
elusive. We study how fine-tuning affects the internal mechanisms implemented
in language models. As a case study, we explore the property of entity
tracking, a crucial facet of language comprehension, where models fine-tuned on
mathematics have substantial performance gains. We identify the mechanism that
enables entity tracking and show that (i) in both the original model and its
fine-tuned versions primarily the same circuit implements entity tracking. In
fact, the entity tracking circuit of the original model on the fine-tuned
versions performs better than the full original model. (ii) The circuits of all
the models implement roughly the same functionality: Entity tracking is
performed by tracking the position of the correct entity in both the original
model and its fine-tuned versions. (iii) Performance boost in the fine-tuned
models is primarily attributed to its improved ability to handle the augmented
positional information. To uncover these findings, we employ: Patch Patching,
DCM, which automatically detects model components responsible for specific
semantics, and CMAP, a new approach for patching activations across models to
reveal improved mechanisms. Our findings suggest that fine-tuning enhances,
rather than fundamentally alters, the mechanistic operation of the model.
|
[
-0.5795997381210327,
-1.0633811950683594,
0.6773924231529236,
-0.2143644243478775,
-0.262092649936676,
0.04924328252673149,
-0.3366297781467438,
-0.6570833325386047,
0.11967477202415466,
0.6634272336959839,
-0.6022545099258423,
-0.3308643698692322,
-0.3973752558231354,
-0.1351376622915268,
-0.22189222276210785,
1.0788164138793945,
-0.08304508030414581,
-0.025465207174420357,
-0.09801356494426727,
-0.1617012768983841,
-0.5621238350868225,
-0.3634865880012512,
-0.642408549785614,
-0.5668326616287231,
0.43270251154899597,
0.3595055043697357,
0.7597110271453857,
0.9720224142074585,
0.6857534646987915,
0.3270212709903717,
-0.16826537251472473,
0.26071542501449585,
-0.38341712951660156,
0.12037377059459686,
-0.423837274312973,
-0.9190741181373596,
-0.5131557583808899,
-0.2765807807445526,
0.7216324210166931,
0.8048490285873413,
-0.16409988701343536,
0.23012323677539825,
0.20111900568008423,
0.721347451210022,
-0.8107808232307434,
0.1760248839855194,
-0.8697859644889832,
-0.5733053684234619,
-0.45187342166900635,
-0.5420580506324768,
-0.12491825222969055,
0.01158900372684002,
-0.0704953521490097,
-0.579120397567749,
0.416167676448822,
0.029117707163095474,
0.917974591255188,
0.5237131118774414,
-0.31505608558654785,
-0.45456835627555847,
-0.7224878072738647,
0.6115631461143494,
-0.5953020453453064,
0.307571142911911,
0.3944609761238098,
-0.012028098106384277,
-0.2100464403629303,
-0.5148760676383972,
-0.3713563084602356,
-0.23163039982318878,
-0.07111985236406326,
-0.3987632691860199,
-0.09944108128547668,
0.33383283019065857,
0.5456768870353699,
0.5522788763046265,
-0.015961647033691406,
0.390113890171051,
-0.30434173345565796,
-0.17085321247577667,
0.32791733741760254,
0.22277098894119263,
0.5432925224304199,
-0.03309527039527893,
0.06924677640199661,
0.103998564183712,
-0.8850425481796265,
0.1572597175836563,
0.5347723960876465,
0.40656185150146484,
0.14894837141036987,
0.5413559079170227,
-0.5721535086631775,
0.9045714139938354,
0.10110169649124146,
0.20975641906261444,
-0.2347503900527954,
-0.5314306616783142,
-0.32093286514282227,
0.01948334462940693,
0.3256478011608124,
0.25604209303855896,
0.4876043200492859,
-0.16285979747772217,
-0.49395954608917236,
0.3200218677520752,
0.2776199281215668,
-0.8402025699615479,
-0.5914840698242188,
-0.07320467382669449,
-0.2130163013935089,
-0.2658421993255615,
-0.14012743532657623,
-0.23844677209854126,
0.030961938202381134,
-0.8998600840568542,
0.37014079093933105,
-0.5212734937667847,
-0.24453780055046082,
0.28969064354896545,
0.15676629543304443,
-0.06792419403791428,
0.4224379360675812,
-1.4504739046096802,
0.5670577883720398,
1.3033099174499512,
0.8163865208625793,
0.001512996619567275,
-0.20694628357887268,
-0.7009527087211609,
0.1128479540348053,
-0.44358766078948975,
0.9865713715553284,
-0.8483975529670715,
0.15628257393836975,
-0.07731081545352936,
0.04790477082133293,
-0.1488904505968094,
-0.6364943385124207,
0.35859155654907227,
-0.6814470291137695,
-0.21366198360919952,
-0.44078966975212097,
-0.8252567648887634,
-0.061651796102523804,
0.014735471457242966,
-0.6810376644134521,
0.7559975385665894,
-0.2211931347846985,
-0.5152966380119324,
0.5712520480155945,
-0.5335116386413574,
-0.5051782727241516,
-0.18192268908023834,
-0.022895339876413345,
-0.38669195771217346,
0.6418607831001282,
0.19005484879016876,
0.15092846751213074,
-0.1728280633687973,
0.0188805740326643,
-0.5418569445610046,
-0.7063925266265869,
0.1737487018108368,
-0.18750759959220886,
0.6769676208496094,
0.0209805928170681,
-0.13031595945358276,
0.03058495931327343,
-0.8660207986831665,
-0.030208198353648186,
-0.19818435609340668,
-0.3435494899749756,
-0.6871984004974365,
0.1861603856086731,
-0.3244698941707611,
0.09014663845300674,
0.13897863030433655,
-0.31469979882240295,
0.48077285289764404,
-0.7053195238113403,
0.5811718702316284,
0.595872700214386,
0.41614243388175964,
0.9116538763046265,
-0.2007659524679184,
0.3726603090763092,
-0.17694410681724548,
-0.1263396441936493,
-0.6305031776428223,
-0.29483121633529663,
-0.6592339873313904,
-0.19830384850502014,
0.5990015864372253,
0.2879071831703186,
-0.4040239453315735,
-0.05046868696808815,
-0.1128530278801918,
-0.2691798806190491,
-0.8342748284339905,
0.2385585755109787,
0.3668147325515747,
0.28652411699295044,
0.39637935161590576,
-0.33763325214385986,
-0.13874879479408264,
-0.8499276041984558,
-0.6374586820602417,
-0.03376873955130577,
-0.10779836028814316,
0.27696478366851807,
0.42788538336753845,
0.14298398792743683,
0.5384573936462402,
-0.4619532823562622,
-0.2852073609828949,
0.19679738581180573,
0.14963319897651672,
-0.011635810136795044,
0.8504175543785095,
0.6249465942382812,
-0.4067513048648834,
-0.19554659724235535,
0.023828957229852676,
-0.2701340615749359,
-0.25145816802978516,
-0.16626609861850739,
-0.3290662169456482,
0.2629793882369995,
0.6069627404212952,
-0.8641598224639893,
0.3831977844238281,
0.11922605335712433,
-0.24576978385448456,
0.35229411721229553,
-0.4156731069087982,
0.2568794786930084,
-0.7180659770965576,
-0.1200769916176796,
-0.12733444571495056,
-0.11484550684690475,
-0.4807090759277344,
0.684212863445282,
0.36455395817756653,
0.2573767900466919,
-0.17313294112682343,
0.2947821617126465,
-0.7726787328720093,
-0.06146650016307831,
-0.5487100481987,
0.2918158173561096,
-0.05003955215215683,
0.4663749635219574,
-0.3352511525154114,
0.7344006896018982,
0.7593646049499512,
-0.977368175983429,
-0.02511596493422985,
-0.016389621421694756,
-0.47940272092819214,
0.7615148425102234,
-0.6357228755950928,
0.1999133974313736,
-0.1019044890999794,
-0.2833921015262604,
-0.7610318660736084,
-0.20666785538196564,
-0.02876150794327259,
-0.2713301181793213,
0.8500458002090454,
-0.5191856026649475,
-0.773128092288971,
0.042390935122966766,
-0.07138556241989136,
0.12888726592063904,
0.1919211447238922,
-0.3102593421936035,
0.33397969603538513,
0.3564194142818451,
0.1911630481481552,
-0.08129704743623734,
-0.5629655122756958,
-0.07830099761486053,
-0.18126876652240753,
-0.46646109223365784,
0.4817317724227905,
0.08869685977697372,
-0.38571521639823914,
0.01186639629304409,
-0.5307122468948364,
0.0073628732934594154,
0.6418873071670532,
-0.04446495324373245,
0.16103070974349976,
-0.39342376589775085,
0.31052881479263306,
0.47213512659072876,
-0.1375855803489685,
0.2432233989238739,
-0.5142406225204468,
0.4732930660247803,
0.2669876515865326,
-0.4069666564464569,
-0.5492340326309204,
0.07100529223680496,
0.46543848514556885,
-0.6004824042320251,
0.8265729546546936,
0.29500749707221985,
-0.6283926963806152,
-0.2193935364484787,
-0.49404922127723694,
-0.5114267468452454,
-0.5023252964019775,
0.2851870656013489,
-0.7683039307594299,
-0.9716072082519531,
0.574691116809845,
-0.17778587341308594,
0.08796535432338715,
0.4993640184402466,
0.4620543122291565,
-0.1304987519979477,
1.3157744407653809,
0.943649411201477,
-0.1150614395737648,
0.8151230216026306,
0.07444947212934494,
0.11718714237213135,
-1.0380916595458984,
0.07108908891677856,
-0.8536814451217651,
-0.508517324924469,
-0.9636729955673218,
-0.1492798626422882,
-0.05886835977435112,
0.7556682229042053,
-0.06863405555486679,
0.45951130986213684,
-0.45986729860305786,
0.6630077362060547,
0.6694825887680054,
0.10703272372484207,
0.6076279282569885,
0.007995500229299068,
-0.17384031414985657,
-0.06820426881313324,
-0.5119271874427795,
-0.531838059425354,
0.8527620434761047,
0.16624116897583008,
0.8715373873710632,
0.12293893098831177,
0.614722728729248,
-0.13811585307121277,
0.2149083912372589,
-0.38460010290145874,
0.340238094329834,
-0.08235832303762436,
-0.6676301956176758,
-0.14171111583709717,
-0.3425295948982239,
-0.7460398077964783,
0.06535916775465012,
-0.25215810537338257,
-1.158393383026123,
0.18665333092212677,
0.5708343386650085,
-0.4022213816642761,
0.1910688579082489,
-0.886682391166687,
0.8946501612663269,
-0.0009796549566090107,
-0.5674980878829956,
-0.7443458437919617,
-0.2396039068698883,
0.2618188261985779,
-0.04747103154659271,
-0.2132159024477005,
-0.23874107003211975,
0.09582522511482239,
0.23946572840213776,
-0.3307379186153412,
0.6873914003372192,
-0.06553686410188675,
-0.2532643675804138,
0.11544948816299438,
0.4650135338306427,
0.7568498849868774,
0.31718578934669495,
0.1004701480269432,
-0.04453219473361969,
0.11987321823835373,
-0.4369758665561676,
-0.7713050842285156,
1.1807444095611572,
-0.3062613308429718,
-0.8786329030990601,
0.11227084696292877,
-0.5366759300231934,
-0.12047231197357178,
0.3247442841529846,
0.13372953236103058,
0.43174105882644653,
0.08335177600383759,
0.21845248341560364,
0.8658457398414612,
0.08887147903442383,
0.39782145619392395,
0.7189831137657166,
-0.20559336245059967,
0.12060537189245224,
0.6655116677284241,
0.30405426025390625,
0.5012513399124146,
0.6730141639709473,
-0.32101112604141235,
-0.03928190842270851,
-0.5922154188156128,
-0.6222774386405945,
0.2552568018436432,
-0.5278878211975098,
-0.15544673800468445,
-0.7436811327934265,
0.15798406302928925,
-0.13677960634231567,
0.08020276576280594,
-0.3733752965927124,
-0.6123958230018616,
-0.5244308710098267,
-0.10644884407520294,
0.2976871728897095,
0.5608723759651184,
0.19545508921146393,
0.2953784167766571,
-0.43196430802345276,
0.33776554465293884,
0.2685803472995758,
0.8054402470588684,
-0.09801524132490158,
-0.44003424048423767,
-0.4003305435180664,
0.34911465644836426,
-0.3610018491744995,
-0.7271596193313599,
-0.2078418731689453,
0.24704957008361816,
0.35251033306121826,
0.10237520188093185,
-0.29473015666007996,
1.1320799589157104,
-0.6487021446228027,
0.4475003480911255,
-0.4154207408428192,
-1.0876907110214233,
0.6529512405395508,
-0.38538554310798645,
0.5359135866165161,
0.4420486092567444,
-0.17983213067054749,
-0.16847947239875793,
-0.7930452227592468,
-0.4110327959060669,
-0.5781291723251343,
0.829612135887146,
0.201546311378479,
0.25940123200416565,
-0.015926530584692955,
0.7562171816825867,
-0.3193652331829071,
0.3328983187675476,
-0.24242796003818512,
-0.26867711544036865,
0.2681538462638855,
-0.06349076330661774,
-0.059254493564367294,
-0.23549886047840118,
0.05834221467375755,
-0.18257933855056763,
0.5361430048942566,
-0.21932262182235718,
0.030665980651974678,
0.11044284701347351,
-0.4095136523246765,
-0.5430507659912109,
0.11846935003995895,
0.871165931224823,
0.7997915744781494,
0.05255933851003647,
0.0506654791533947,
0.08479464799165726,
-0.16058245301246643,
-0.3530232906341553,
0.27169370651245117,
-0.6622082591056824,
-0.025882694870233536,
0.2792343497276306,
1.1314637660980225,
0.6066738367080688,
-0.22930043935775757,
0.00031013163970783353,
0.10974767059087753,
0.12323006987571716,
0.1639530062675476,
0.54634028673172,
0.10441187024116516,
0.4186144471168518,
0.06282985955476761,
0.4970715045928955,
0.34736594557762146,
-0.6257311105728149,
0.29873156547546387,
0.7214934229850769,
-0.3637174963951111,
-0.6783290505409241,
1.0242865085601807,
-0.3288024961948395,
-0.5940579771995544,
0.3778685927391052,
-0.0010925234528258443,
-0.3584488332271576,
0.6940193176269531,
0.5605378150939941,
0.6993582844734192,
-0.2708916664123535,
-0.09646593779325485,
0.35828137397766113,
0.6722480058670044,
-0.23626314103603363,
0.06370919942855835,
-0.4196886122226715,
-0.4748954772949219,
-0.7084218859672546,
-0.7159661054611206,
-0.12432310730218887,
-0.20664440095424652,
-0.7668341398239136,
0.4048306345939636,
-0.11969584226608276,
-0.04382624104619026,
0.35183048248291016,
0.015170964412391186,
-0.9351734519004822,
0.14100493490695953,
0.15268637239933014,
1.0596460103988647,
-0.4672611653804779,
0.9374143481254578,
0.8530620336532593,
-0.3740139603614807,
-0.7932673692703247,
0.10232727974653244,
-0.2206532508134842,
-0.5836220383644104,
0.20139934122562408,
0.039689790457487106,
-0.038184259086847305,
0.16621814668178558,
-0.4950077533721924,
-1.0856667757034302,
0.7416183352470398,
0.5533998608589172,
-0.8726800680160522,
-0.0066599613055586815,
-0.027876365929841995,
0.9045602679252625,
-0.2151809185743332,
0.07414920628070831,
0.8151081204414368,
0.130799800157547,
-0.42807736992836,
-1.031290888786316,
0.02557704597711563,
-0.005576008930802345,
0.06482511013746262,
0.8393882513046265,
-0.5869174003601074,
0.6840315461158752,
-0.27807119488716125,
-0.22025682032108307,
0.14122700691223145,
0.5482333302497864,
0.0072942874394357204,
0.2509531080722809,
0.25348418951034546,
0.6940910816192627,
0.9551286101341248,
-0.30693474411964417,
1.1432149410247803,
-0.7107634544372559,
0.5463495254516602,
1.2832244634628296,
-0.12494701147079468,
0.6896082758903503,
0.5141083002090454,
0.11089464277029037,
0.42689672112464905,
0.4178449511528015,
0.1363101452589035,
0.5872668027877808,
0.1898612529039383,
-0.07493805140256882,
-0.27300962805747986,
-0.005643167067319155,
-0.015360998921096325,
0.2727605998516083,
0.32141441106796265,
-0.38846859335899353,
-0.05542237311601639,
0.016956232488155365,
-0.04625021293759346,
0.0775199830532074,
-0.7118208408355713,
0.8944219946861267,
0.121638223528862,
-1.0906366109848022,
0.3676804006099701,
0.09997289627790451,
0.19740751385688782,
-0.3049008250236511,
-0.07679726183414459,
-0.177265003323555,
0.30361407995224,
-0.012017617002129555,
-0.6935099363327026,
0.4518105685710907,
-0.18077951669692993,
-0.32600340247154236,
-0.08383902907371521,
0.8100342750549316,
-0.5579752922058105,
-0.21662043035030365,
0.19415737688541412,
0.25465521216392517,
-0.26959505677223206,
-0.31946197152137756,
-0.5270704030990601,
0.04971465468406677,
-0.04321858286857605,
-0.2666381001472473,
0.4179491102695465,
0.9170757532119751,
-0.3333994746208191,
0.6613667011260986,
0.7605368494987488,
0.21748384833335876,
0.1130407378077507,
0.1313907355070114,
0.8569129705429077,
-0.6150997877120972,
-0.5140237212181091,
-1.1544570922851562,
0.38089922070503235,
0.06819548457860947,
-0.352380633354187,
0.701359748840332,
0.515021800994873,
1.1009063720703125,
0.13082678616046906,
0.035803161561489105,
0.2580634653568268,
0.3960524797439575,
-0.7342525124549866,
0.5870436429977417,
-0.5979921817779541,
0.7043271064758301,
-0.27769845724105835,
-0.9913772344589233,
-0.2849632203578949,
0.29074591398239136,
-0.27983617782592773,
-0.214011088013649,
0.5681092739105225,
0.8645981550216675,
-0.2822752892971039,
-0.07879122346639633,
0.1804177612066269,
0.2435295134782791,
0.1629069745540619,
0.18587534129619598,
0.5011278390884399,
-0.420519083738327,
0.27121061086654663,
-0.4759078025817871,
0.05112321302294731,
-0.05329112336039543,
-0.5736541748046875,
-0.8828475475311279,
-0.44014719128608704,
-0.5632124543190002,
-0.14444737136363983,
0.017204824835062027,
0.5672902464866638,
0.708734393119812,
-0.9234494566917419,
0.21831566095352173,
-0.5386277437210083,
0.2827385365962982,
-0.25682953000068665,
-0.22472241520881653,
0.07828731834888458,
-0.657785177230835,
-0.8005154728889465,
0.10780780017375946,
0.5593631863594055,
-0.07765552401542664,
-0.10792968422174454,
0.3182973563671112,
-0.01888846792280674,
0.2872397303581238,
0.327828973531723,
0.11595238745212555,
-0.814508855342865,
-0.4214819669723511,
0.1697104424238205,
-0.13091376423835754,
0.08733301609754562,
1.0985910892486572,
-0.6536493897438049,
0.5386792421340942,
0.3767365515232086,
0.5673103928565979,
0.5550717711448669,
-0.07183221727609634,
0.6038048267364502,
-0.6934661865234375,
0.03903654217720032,
-0.12391427904367447,
0.4908042252063751,
0.2726076543331146,
-0.4302208125591278,
0.3161521852016449,
0.10046466439962387,
-0.7069104909896851,
-1.028300404548645,
0.40118956565856934,
-0.48949021100997925,
-0.12716174125671387,
0.6665240526199341,
0.14083988964557648,
-0.24446286261081696,
0.09687123447656631,
-0.1519421637058258,
0.404653400182724,
-0.18184655904769897,
1.000433087348938,
0.908327579498291,
0.11283385753631592,
-0.2770386338233948,
-0.8109037280082703,
0.7262730002403259,
0.590467631816864,
-0.5265926718711853,
-0.06045738235116005,
0.4222330152988434,
0.49723348021507263,
0.08936450630426407,
0.4088922441005707,
0.123222216963768,
0.3351086974143982,
-0.3197861313819885,
-0.254050612449646,
0.14349253475666046,
-0.24680951237678528,
-0.47449278831481934,
0.025530120357871056,
0.14050137996673584,
-0.17318883538246155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14809v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14809v4
|
CriticBench: Benchmarking LLMs for Critique-Correct Reasoning
| 2024-02-22T18:59:02 | 2024-06-01T07:46:28 |
Zicheng Lin, Zhibin Gou, Tian Liang, Ruilin Luo, Haowei Liu, Yujiu Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to critique and refine their
reasoning is crucial for their application in evaluation, feedback provision,
and self-improvement. This paper introduces CriticBench, a comprehensive
benchmark designed to assess LLMs' abilities to critique and rectify their
reasoning across a variety of tasks. CriticBench encompasses five reasoning
domains: mathematical, commonsense, symbolic, coding, and algorithmic. It
compiles 15 datasets and incorporates responses from three LLM families.
Utilizing CriticBench, we evaluate and dissect the performance of 17 LLMs in
generation, critique, and correction reasoning, i.e., GQC reasoning. Our
findings reveal: (1) a linear relationship in GQC capabilities, with
critique-focused training markedly enhancing performance; (2) a task-dependent
variation in correction effectiveness, with logic-oriented tasks being more
amenable to correction; (3) GQC knowledge inconsistencies that decrease as
model size increases; and (4) an intriguing inter-model critiquing dynamic,
where stronger models are better at critiquing weaker ones, while weaker models
can surprisingly surpass stronger ones in their self-critique. We hope these
insights into the nuanced critique-correct reasoning of LLMs will foster
further research in LLM critique and self-improvement.
|
[
-0.41561970114707947,
-0.44745293259620667,
0.6937000751495361,
0.1353406310081482,
0.1143982857465744,
0.18415910005569458,
-0.3892858028411865,
-0.3160029947757721,
-0.10852495580911636,
0.47473207116127014,
-0.6172208189964294,
-0.4191916882991791,
-0.21391437947750092,
0.19352670013904572,
-0.46131888031959534,
0.8843606114387512,
-0.11266437917947769,
0.34843361377716064,
-0.5124549865722656,
-0.25125616788864136,
-0.5322076678276062,
-0.6166254878044128,
-0.4635065197944641,
-0.5961102247238159,
0.5823058485984802,
0.2664359509944916,
0.4817627966403961,
0.3452700674533844,
0.47596001625061035,
0.35825493931770325,
0.012013199739158154,
0.1580744832754135,
-0.6133823394775391,
0.3756486177444458,
-0.8425266146659851,
-0.6648057103157043,
-0.42145153880119324,
0.018760668113827705,
0.5920008420944214,
0.5567137598991394,
-0.24439489841461182,
0.2392476499080658,
0.10004761070013046,
0.8190799951553345,
-0.8437300324440002,
-0.0748063325881958,
-0.6628236174583435,
-0.04309196397662163,
-0.09814310818910599,
-0.0130690336227417,
-0.4594181776046753,
-0.5736743211746216,
-0.3281620442867279,
-0.34195953607559204,
0.33354848623275757,
0.032610934227705,
0.5991053581237793,
0.5098318457603455,
-0.2286042869091034,
-0.02512449398636818,
-0.7649464011192322,
0.6931793093681335,
-0.8215450644493103,
0.4209849536418915,
0.025064991787075996,
0.5616252422332764,
-0.1984897255897522,
-0.8301238417625427,
-0.6164380311965942,
-0.4033922255039215,
0.06504178792238235,
0.34547707438468933,
-0.26952093839645386,
-0.10540558397769928,
0.6310727596282959,
0.566758394241333,
-0.42126724123954773,
-0.004273307044059038,
-0.16885264217853546,
-0.20638516545295715,
0.7359544634819031,
0.39262208342552185,
-0.16800817847251892,
-0.27460071444511414,
-0.3309617042541504,
-0.14757923781871796,
-0.6549261212348938,
-0.014203772880136967,
0.5480203032493591,
-0.050262439996004105,
0.26316431164741516,
0.3268134295940399,
-0.47270917892456055,
0.5389941334724426,
-0.01956174150109291,
-0.07462364435195923,
0.1530502438545227,
-0.34179016947746277,
0.0009433923987671733,
-0.4396432042121887,
0.6112345457077026,
0.6169518232345581,
0.3774912357330322,
-0.15797090530395508,
-0.5139377117156982,
0.29898741841316223,
0.693215012550354,
-0.5149607062339783,
-0.27882567048072815,
0.009294377639889717,
-0.3046078681945801,
-0.24261720478534698,
-0.026713808998465538,
-0.6443424820899963,
-0.5078742504119873,
-0.6217959523200989,
0.23343849182128906,
-0.10749834775924683,
-0.13407747447490692,
0.08427118510007858,
-0.10225038975477219,
0.0394313745200634,
0.44599464535713196,
-0.5377647876739502,
0.41108059883117676,
0.783266544342041,
0.5191342234611511,
-0.24228812754154205,
-0.40218934416770935,
-0.3888872563838959,
-0.04696469008922577,
-0.44249117374420166,
1.01111900806427,
-0.4749850630760193,
-0.38291439414024353,
-0.021581314504146576,
-0.021824263036251068,
-0.04106532037258148,
-1.0463385581970215,
0.7933240532875061,
-0.3193204700946808,
-0.16396629810333252,
-0.37860438227653503,
-0.5799974203109741,
-0.21586968004703522,
0.6287919282913208,
-0.653985321521759,
1.165138840675354,
0.31342053413391113,
-0.6851958632469177,
0.08888935297727585,
-0.2098424881696701,
-0.09922366589307785,
-0.07261288166046143,
-0.22745704650878906,
-0.24693790078163147,
0.24691857397556305,
0.08514293283224106,
0.34065350890159607,
-0.5906268358230591,
0.26398393511772156,
-0.7528612017631531,
-0.3835982084274292,
0.5417839288711548,
-0.26281648874282837,
0.22849421203136444,
0.30736255645751953,
-0.33352696895599365,
0.39312687516212463,
-0.7625406384468079,
0.4947495758533478,
0.07681011408567429,
-0.17755983769893646,
0.09465207159519196,
0.06265059858560562,
-0.16031160950660706,
0.27422526478767395,
-0.12729935348033905,
-0.3541310429573059,
0.2901872396469116,
-0.09192680567502975,
0.7387025952339172,
0.8207499384880066,
0.022080006077885628,
-0.07099029421806335,
-0.491705060005188,
0.7369452118873596,
-0.23634809255599976,
0.05581275746226311,
0.18647868931293488,
0.14556224644184113,
-0.9565042853355408,
0.0025833614636212587,
0.43750372529029846,
0.312675803899765,
-0.7372612953186035,
0.09219441562891006,
-0.15472838282585144,
-0.6309648156166077,
-0.5346313714981079,
0.25686466693878174,
0.559164822101593,
0.450103759765625,
0.47451093792915344,
-0.5614155530929565,
-0.5587649345397949,
-1.0284181833267212,
-0.6899796724319458,
-0.26765432953834534,
0.14459408819675446,
0.3012249767780304,
0.5560529828071594,
-0.23398251831531525,
0.5365438461303711,
-0.2904511094093323,
0.00925514753907919,
-0.405040979385376,
-0.062207527458667755,
0.030001746490597725,
0.2704842686653137,
0.3314902186393738,
-0.025237882509827614,
-0.2485935539007187,
-0.30996397137641907,
-0.6117846369743347,
-0.4679741859436035,
-0.0718909502029419,
-0.2173224538564682,
0.16924330592155457,
0.7415918707847595,
-0.27931684255599976,
0.22903034090995789,
0.4846187233924866,
-0.09549881517887115,
1.0861916542053223,
0.04135119915008545,
-0.042972248047590256,
-0.6086955070495605,
0.26230913400650024,
-0.11531341075897217,
-0.3997403681278229,
-0.2258121222257614,
0.27911728620529175,
0.0197739414870739,
0.21705596148967743,
-0.06097758561372757,
0.52299964427948,
-0.41955700516700745,
-0.14405545592308044,
-0.2851356267929077,
0.41156622767448425,
0.030584536492824554,
0.4891807436943054,
-0.2174443155527115,
0.6676965951919556,
0.2615547180175781,
-0.29724228382110596,
0.6367815136909485,
-0.16260690987110138,
-0.6795699596405029,
0.7598293423652649,
-0.6154078841209412,
0.44400784373283386,
0.0934106633067131,
0.3952122926712036,
-0.9318923950195312,
-0.08706711232662201,
0.13739077746868134,
-0.13665975630283356,
0.055249445140361786,
0.010602353140711784,
-0.46130773425102234,
-0.5613388419151306,
-0.2696044147014618,
0.29764583706855774,
0.162286639213562,
-0.7101725935935974,
0.6594131588935852,
-0.037085190415382385,
-0.10623615235090256,
-0.6791629791259766,
-0.40477117896080017,
-0.047948986291885376,
0.11794926226139069,
-0.37732386589050293,
0.21868053078651428,
-0.19765251874923706,
-0.43497148156166077,
0.05423809587955475,
-0.2915504574775696,
0.34990546107292175,
0.12880699336528778,
0.29407742619514465,
0.01407701801508665,
0.01565118134021759,
0.2599627375602722,
-0.33313965797424316,
-0.12643200159072876,
0.30435776710510254,
-0.058967143297195435,
0.565037727355957,
-0.5153543949127197,
-0.585503876209259,
-0.10023365914821625,
0.02688172459602356,
0.3985806703567505,
-0.3168430030345917,
0.1380922496318817,
0.1901261806488037,
0.05322526767849922,
-0.6356382369995117,
-0.9267703294754028,
-0.219293475151062,
-0.4089178442955017,
0.31680160760879517,
-0.4650845229625702,
-0.8283696174621582,
0.47554120421409607,
-0.23064152896404266,
-0.13665258884429932,
0.5519507527351379,
0.7561142444610596,
0.07782793045043945,
0.8967729806900024,
0.3860892057418823,
-0.21481667459011078,
0.18126820027828217,
-0.346709281206131,
0.09143631160259247,
-1.1098641157150269,
-0.19158631563186646,
-0.6105997562408447,
-0.47894513607025146,
-0.2771659195423126,
-0.4944109320640564,
0.03896677866578102,
0.2826145887374878,
-0.3647540211677551,
0.07322309166193008,
-0.461490273475647,
0.666953980922699,
0.47774451971054077,
-0.10010496526956558,
0.5337774157524109,
-0.32464560866355896,
-0.5386152863502502,
0.011650951579213142,
-0.5573235750198364,
-0.6743192076683044,
0.9869512915611267,
0.35165613889694214,
0.859951913356781,
0.08193469047546387,
0.40012818574905396,
0.06149483472108841,
0.6486627459526062,
-0.6808443665504456,
0.7854647636413574,
0.038348592817783356,
-0.773613452911377,
0.06244237720966339,
-0.5127029418945312,
-0.4033619165420532,
0.44662806391716003,
-0.021439887583255768,
-0.6548891663551331,
0.07988166064023972,
0.21093453466892242,
-0.21054737269878387,
0.4319733679294586,
-0.42849642038345337,
0.9412879943847656,
-0.2927666902542114,
-0.7365301847457886,
-0.6417031288146973,
-0.4357910752296448,
0.44326043128967285,
0.1697523146867752,
0.04370475560426712,
-0.1944848597049713,
0.22643238306045532,
0.2582342028617859,
-0.3747594654560089,
0.6627528071403503,
-0.1027129590511322,
-0.0778854489326477,
0.3921835124492645,
0.481243371963501,
0.358760803937912,
0.04041299223899841,
-0.1945587545633316,
-0.034918949007987976,
0.1701992154121399,
-0.13958758115768433,
-0.8751572370529175,
0.6663307547569275,
-0.7428430318832397,
-0.848869264125824,
-0.3460284173488617,
-0.33263784646987915,
-0.6927456259727478,
-0.021997764706611633,
0.04740593954920769,
0.3307724893093109,
-0.3268297016620636,
0.2226908802986145,
0.14729070663452148,
0.1631624400615692,
0.15263499319553375,
0.6999732255935669,
-0.46811139583587646,
-0.5730859041213989,
0.6814801692962646,
0.052745185792446136,
0.3473818302154541,
-0.015895701944828033,
0.0027012161444872618,
-0.2951640784740448,
-0.5725250244140625,
-0.3794982135295868,
0.3277912139892578,
-1.0337773561477661,
-0.30091536045074463,
-0.3723873794078827,
-0.21840305626392365,
-0.016438549384474754,
0.06626830250024796,
-0.46414029598236084,
-0.4627264440059662,
0.28643304109573364,
-0.1194225400686264,
-0.039321694523096085,
0.8801553845405579,
-0.002569289179518819,
-0.05097150430083275,
-0.43919637799263,
-0.027766244485974312,
0.32980605959892273,
0.6090761423110962,
0.42018425464630127,
-0.5125778913497925,
-0.1350965052843094,
-0.32223090529441833,
-0.7091623544692993,
-0.5665038228034973,
-0.07385358214378357,
-0.06834924221038818,
0.7376279830932617,
0.33841440081596375,
0.04209117963910103,
0.5670885443687439,
-0.3952792286872864,
0.7322074174880981,
-0.014151345007121563,
-1.1059596538543701,
0.36422818899154663,
-0.1543828397989273,
0.37475770711898804,
0.6058353781700134,
0.12969064712524414,
-0.6704376339912415,
-0.477340966463089,
-0.5912724137306213,
-0.5163002610206604,
0.42529410123825073,
-0.09542600810527802,
-0.08983369171619415,
0.11176786571741104,
0.5893697738647461,
-0.0030257548205554485,
0.24759350717067719,
-0.6293350458145142,
0.23198215663433075,
-0.3392169773578644,
-0.06042876094579697,
-0.12318402528762817,
-0.23882777988910675,
-0.3682853579521179,
-0.3116612434387207,
0.8969374895095825,
-0.5373912453651428,
-0.04599851742386818,
0.22927536070346832,
-0.0774850994348526,
-0.2754814028739929,
0.43373116850852966,
0.5788259506225586,
0.7406241297721863,
0.14413480460643768,
0.23506826162338257,
0.49237293004989624,
0.04506586492061615,
0.09800806641578674,
-0.07734985649585724,
0.040259115397930145,
-0.2397885024547577,
0.5804759860038757,
0.7129843235015869,
0.15725712478160858,
-0.8140597343444824,
0.32396817207336426,
-0.13920530676841736,
-0.27716660499572754,
-0.25152698159217834,
0.3911226689815521,
0.25877195596694946,
0.45751574635505676,
-0.1280088722705841,
0.1271887570619583,
0.17307060956954956,
-0.6664387583732605,
-0.07491525262594223,
0.40476712584495544,
-0.30809563398361206,
-0.3138153553009033,
0.5958841443061829,
0.13976800441741943,
-0.03461702540516853,
0.6861308217048645,
-0.0036300530191510916,
-0.7255831360816956,
0.40445247292518616,
0.3111715614795685,
0.8797840476036072,
-0.08452832698822021,
0.03573210537433624,
0.5108801126480103,
0.09044204652309418,
-0.16816045343875885,
0.28443482518196106,
-0.13872961699962616,
-0.8462767601013184,
-0.4003877639770508,
-0.38241317868232727,
-0.8560606837272644,
0.13128773868083954,
-0.7771609425544739,
-0.02469874918460846,
-0.7593963146209717,
-0.5013102293014526,
0.003286633174866438,
0.19479191303253174,
-0.6377598643302917,
0.11339698731899261,
0.03693360090255737,
0.8291972279548645,
-0.2868725061416626,
0.6765115857124329,
0.7522550821304321,
-0.35959088802337646,
-1.074346661567688,
0.04994853213429451,
0.27102842926979065,
-0.6164026856422424,
0.6028181314468384,
0.17769229412078857,
-0.4665822684764862,
-0.29707229137420654,
-0.6203755140304565,
-0.5829632878303528,
0.7986028790473938,
0.4620353579521179,
-0.9555318355560303,
0.2574860155582428,
0.003682896262034774,
0.9306986331939697,
-0.3552568554878235,
0.56906658411026,
0.6851399540901184,
0.4147754907608032,
-0.04891461506485939,
-0.9473147392272949,
0.08651138842105865,
-0.5323558449745178,
0.1842891424894333,
-0.03259090334177017,
-1.1591583490371704,
0.7371893525123596,
-0.24363307654857635,
-0.09744998067617416,
0.2584173381328583,
0.47815412282943726,
0.29027077555656433,
-0.03095146454870701,
0.5986512303352356,
0.9015412926673889,
0.7063336372375488,
-0.32898423075675964,
1.172369122505188,
-0.5014699101448059,
0.3266322612762451,
1.325408697128296,
-0.5965147614479065,
0.9302272200584412,
0.263879656791687,
-0.18891850113868713,
0.9706108570098877,
0.3800698518753052,
-0.29148462414741516,
0.22976379096508026,
0.7151111960411072,
-0.06363514065742493,
-0.5833544731140137,
-0.1749645620584488,
-0.32097262144088745,
0.25155550241470337,
-0.005934535060077906,
-0.2729760706424713,
-0.1308906525373459,
-0.4190702438354492,
-0.10243579000234604,
0.3294298052787781,
-0.35106000304222107,
0.7244558334350586,
0.27782365679740906,
-1.0686606168746948,
0.7877281308174133,
0.1671198159456253,
0.18482279777526855,
-0.3919146656990051,
0.19797582924365997,
-0.3355271518230438,
0.9026951789855957,
-0.27121827006340027,
-0.80989009141922,
0.21741056442260742,
0.060218580067157745,
-0.2657109200954437,
-0.09026189148426056,
0.6908280849456787,
-0.20842865109443665,
-0.16795139014720917,
0.5536440014839172,
0.5179202556610107,
0.06170695647597313,
-0.0880957543849945,
-0.7733505964279175,
0.3160804510116577,
-0.039787549525499344,
-0.27549490332603455,
0.16219371557235718,
0.3929786682128906,
-0.15186555683612823,
0.9483724236488342,
0.3563031256198883,
0.16377811133861542,
-0.23108947277069092,
0.6764410734176636,
0.982606828212738,
-0.821541428565979,
-0.13157017529010773,
-0.683222234249115,
0.4368512034416199,
-0.14414413273334503,
-0.533427894115448,
0.75423663854599,
0.520682692527771,
1.2525142431259155,
-0.10557067394256592,
0.8453800678253174,
0.3496756851673126,
0.8406254053115845,
-0.5469323396682739,
0.294960618019104,
-0.5866662263870239,
0.20927299559116364,
-0.1824101209640503,
-1.0622179508209229,
-0.0021316949278116226,
0.6552407741546631,
-0.5413153171539307,
0.28137457370758057,
0.8618060350418091,
0.943160355091095,
0.27235129475593567,
0.27722808718681335,
0.08494346588850021,
0.3487628102302551,
0.33885657787323,
0.5827242136001587,
1.3735612630844116,
-0.10765601694583893,
0.3628165125846863,
-0.3085099756717682,
0.11834707856178284,
-0.18796440958976746,
-0.7793964147567749,
-1.0633877515792847,
-0.08440029621124268,
-0.2966397702693939,
-0.4616111218929291,
0.1433933824300766,
0.848886251449585,
0.5258670449256897,
-0.8831380605697632,
-0.3890841603279114,
-0.035059064626693726,
0.01949187181890011,
-0.4483344256877899,
-0.19663360714912415,
-0.03530948981642723,
-0.5744407773017883,
-0.4845091700553894,
0.4681628346443176,
0.13953286409378052,
-0.3488747477531433,
-0.6540294289588928,
-0.03600647673010826,
0.29494476318359375,
0.1678486168384552,
0.39168503880500793,
0.11117003113031387,
-0.9582516551017761,
-0.5013351440429688,
-0.18152056634426117,
-0.19906523823738098,
-0.04634851962327957,
1.056799054145813,
-0.8558411002159119,
0.5220745205879211,
0.421804279088974,
0.5222603678703308,
0.5527909398078918,
0.1505795270204544,
0.5653104782104492,
-0.545773983001709,
-0.2065625935792923,
0.3867439329624176,
0.5143712162971497,
0.4473154842853546,
0.19875863194465637,
0.9489648938179016,
0.4194801151752472,
-0.7196934819221497,
-0.9468919634819031,
0.24101047217845917,
-0.7516391277313232,
-0.3152269423007965,
0.9450894594192505,
-0.1370127946138382,
0.0596046969294548,
0.2390996664762497,
-0.3221907913684845,
-0.04665999859571457,
-0.09179463237524033,
0.7777206301689148,
1.091562271118164,
-0.09737686067819595,
-0.3013283312320709,
-0.5601572394371033,
0.40019258856773376,
0.8723116517066956,
-0.7826634645462036,
0.37360134720802307,
0.5002645254135132,
0.5116401314735413,
0.11062423139810562,
0.44917333126068115,
-0.18947654962539673,
0.24440087378025055,
0.00899789109826088,
0.2813502848148346,
-0.01059209369122982,
-0.36489370465278625,
-0.3085501790046692,
0.17409633100032806,
0.40824756026268005,
0.5886365175247192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14905v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14905v2
|
MobileLLM: Optimizing Sub-billion Parameter Language Models for On-Device Use Cases
| 2024-02-22T18:58:55 | 2024-06-27T03:53:46 |
Zechun Liu, Changsheng Zhao, Forrest Iandola, Chen Lai, Yuandong Tian, Igor Fedorov, Yunyang Xiong, Ernie Chang, Yangyang Shi, Raghuraman Krishnamoorthi, Liangzhen Lai, Vikas Chandra
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper addresses the growing need for efficient large language models
(LLMs) on mobile devices, driven by increasing cloud costs and latency
concerns. We focus on designing top-quality LLMs with fewer than a billion
parameters, a practical choice for mobile deployment. Contrary to prevailing
belief emphasizing the pivotal role of data and parameter quantity in
determining model quality, our investigation underscores the significance of
model architecture for sub-billion scale LLMs. Leveraging deep and thin
architectures, coupled with embedding sharing and grouped-query attention
mechanisms, we establish a strong baseline network denoted as MobileLLM, which
attains a remarkable 2.7%/4.3% accuracy boost over preceding 125M/350M
state-of-the-art models. Additionally, we propose an immediate block-wise
weight-sharing approach with no increase in model size and only marginal
latency overhead. The resultant models, denoted as MobileLLM-LS, demonstrate a
further accuracy enhancement of 0.7%/0.8% than MobileLLM 125M/350M. Moreover,
MobileLLM model family shows significant improvements compared to previous
sub-billion models on chat benchmarks, and demonstrates close correctness to
LLaMA-v2 7B in API calling tasks, highlighting the capability of small models
for common on-device use cases.
|
[
-0.454115629196167,
-0.6995364427566528,
0.41667988896369934,
0.33256834745407104,
-0.3596121668815613,
0.007675047032535076,
-0.1152222529053688,
-0.5021092295646667,
0.11518029123544693,
0.6136842966079712,
-0.2632814049720764,
-0.48471376299858093,
-0.36139339208602905,
-0.36695191264152527,
-0.30189192295074463,
0.2988208830356598,
0.23413226008415222,
-0.12594790756702423,
-0.4036414623260498,
-0.2613627016544342,
-0.2639659643173218,
-0.5263829827308655,
-0.7813742160797119,
-0.3223235607147217,
0.5846944451332092,
0.6306353807449341,
1.0168484449386597,
0.8717876076698303,
0.26210013031959534,
0.17119187116622925,
-0.25311294198036194,
0.35916292667388916,
-0.7103294730186462,
0.0010261568240821362,
0.07041776925325394,
-0.4016481935977936,
-0.8401071429252625,
-0.001196419820189476,
0.479775071144104,
0.7080297470092773,
-0.4455108046531677,
0.29421257972717285,
-0.20661436021327972,
0.5521180033683777,
-0.3916218876838684,
-0.12222708016633987,
-0.8898181915283203,
-0.22948111593723297,
0.028472943231463432,
0.09302595257759094,
-0.5115687251091003,
-0.15416359901428223,
-0.0985417515039444,
-0.20331475138664246,
-0.10622631013393402,
0.22772206366062164,
0.7163878083229065,
0.41829967498779297,
-0.4660170078277588,
-0.19156768918037415,
-0.730357825756073,
1.0084549188613892,
-0.93565434217453,
0.8347300291061401,
0.503423810005188,
-0.007377302274107933,
-0.1990739405155182,
-0.6439926624298096,
-0.1927259862422943,
-0.5752559900283813,
0.27897757291793823,
-0.16141653060913086,
-0.1912766844034195,
-0.002133571309968829,
-0.015619754791259766,
0.21431602537631989,
-0.5457103848457336,
0.493702232837677,
-0.3816972076892853,
-0.038355812430381775,
0.9278662204742432,
0.40493810176849365,
0.1457967907190323,
0.17829982936382294,
-0.40880635380744934,
0.6403274536132812,
-1.2489583492279053,
-0.11493843048810959,
0.11056841164827347,
0.37819141149520874,
-0.31634002923965454,
0.5136712193489075,
-0.3376329243183136,
0.8051822185516357,
-0.08110831677913666,
-0.32755082845687866,
-0.20461298525333405,
-0.5971257090568542,
-0.29539838433265686,
-0.07983940094709396,
0.9460333585739136,
0.35902461409568787,
0.04848102480173111,
-0.3255767226219177,
-0.139740452170372,
-0.36079126596450806,
0.23650789260864258,
-1.2044991254806519,
0.1379590481519699,
0.39475759863853455,
-0.723256528377533,
-0.1879647821187973,
-0.5498155355453491,
-0.326247900724411,
-0.48261207342147827,
-0.22829876840114594,
0.006458735559135675,
-0.050553061068058014,
-0.2003563940525055,
0.2506677806377411,
0.7387932538986206,
0.1967020183801651,
0.17420388758182526,
-1.126747727394104,
0.4020654261112213,
0.5900721549987793,
0.9515823721885681,
-0.17290399968624115,
0.03195931017398834,
-0.29151079058647156,
0.08988197147846222,
-0.3406596779823303,
0.46517810225486755,
-0.4079471826553345,
-0.7680180668830872,
-0.40076497197151184,
-0.33280083537101746,
-0.21397781372070312,
-0.7789320945739746,
0.7779483795166016,
-0.6317479014396667,
-0.17222866415977478,
0.13004633784294128,
-0.6487024426460266,
-0.19968070089817047,
-0.09435782581567764,
-0.5681065917015076,
1.0720908641815186,
-0.16806073486804962,
-0.26267603039741516,
0.1526462584733963,
-0.4356553554534912,
-0.4032445549964905,
0.16121138632297516,
0.06080257147550583,
-0.3767927587032318,
0.41713643074035645,
0.1331702321767807,
0.8082751631736755,
-0.8177496790885925,
0.059611283242702484,
-0.4822561740875244,
-0.3605179488658905,
-0.02928200736641884,
-0.19120852649211884,
0.5996012687683105,
0.6288883686065674,
-0.08403875678777695,
0.07040918618440628,
-0.5953419208526611,
0.37572628259658813,
-0.017282912507653236,
-0.5075726509094238,
-0.270842581987381,
0.26478129625320435,
0.11532044410705566,
0.25354573130607605,
0.44057363271713257,
-0.45138779282569885,
0.1656334400177002,
-0.20117326080799103,
0.7288231253623962,
0.05483536794781685,
-0.27536025643348694,
0.5887210369110107,
-0.1945677250623703,
0.4499003291130066,
-0.13695064187049866,
0.28769388794898987,
-0.11546578258275986,
-0.45169588923454285,
-0.58921217918396,
-0.46649470925331116,
0.4801159203052521,
0.5298699140548706,
-0.07989522814750671,
0.06479289382696152,
-0.35074394941329956,
-0.8949458003044128,
-0.5159139633178711,
0.5357350707054138,
0.42273446917533875,
0.16262304782867432,
0.06368518620729446,
-0.008795280940830708,
-0.6233939528465271,
-0.9335106611251831,
-0.0992267057299614,
-0.26961424946784973,
0.09919148683547974,
0.7591568231582642,
0.032722894102334976,
-0.6439483165740967,
0.958950400352478,
-0.21582533419132233,
-0.02268199436366558,
-0.35425594449043274,
-0.20503544807434082,
0.14968392252922058,
0.32753509283065796,
0.4214554727077484,
-0.8949862122535706,
-0.4999810457229614,
0.1834498643875122,
-0.555801272392273,
-0.3073580861091614,
0.0866035595536232,
0.23271095752716064,
0.3119948208332062,
0.6532512307167053,
-0.8876252174377441,
-0.014378105290234089,
0.8721742033958435,
0.012523729354143143,
0.22030949592590332,
-0.20490598678588867,
-0.24784377217292786,
-1.1926212310791016,
-0.11347074806690216,
0.16258151829242706,
-0.3566364049911499,
-0.5910024642944336,
0.1121235340833664,
0.12884674966335297,
-0.19747519493103027,
-0.8616692423820496,
0.8294469714164734,
-0.5883339047431946,
-0.08261688798666,
-0.3598455786705017,
0.06476044654846191,
-0.14128117263317108,
0.2148200273513794,
-0.25485485792160034,
0.9045474529266357,
0.30329760909080505,
-0.6395689845085144,
0.31143319606781006,
-0.32948288321495056,
-0.25234243273735046,
0.3336438238620758,
-0.9514604806900024,
0.23837493360042572,
0.23516064882278442,
0.03683221712708473,
-0.9031410813331604,
-0.08619020134210587,
-0.24026866257190704,
-0.22376370429992676,
-0.07174056023359299,
-0.3921660780906677,
-0.568199098110199,
-0.10843648761510849,
-0.12220054864883423,
0.5047932267189026,
0.6244171857833862,
-0.3725622892379761,
0.9126465320587158,
0.775294840335846,
-0.18644748628139496,
-0.17667539417743683,
-0.32504981756210327,
0.13382506370544434,
-0.47886204719543457,
-0.9624676704406738,
0.5814942121505737,
0.019919054582715034,
-0.21551337838172913,
-0.15975552797317505,
-0.13479529321193695,
-0.09986797720193863,
0.1655929833650589,
0.6240531206130981,
0.004249397199600935,
-0.41849055886268616,
-0.053510334342718124,
-0.033523235470056534,
0.015223783440887928,
-0.2517499029636383,
-0.2773541808128357,
0.6559739112854004,
-0.21219545602798462,
-0.10711967945098877,
-0.39709600806236267,
0.2837670147418976,
0.8437588810920715,
-0.10362416505813599,
0.832682728767395,
0.43368661403656006,
-0.4644247889518738,
-0.195420041680336,
-0.6947004199028015,
0.03812825679779053,
-0.5054110288619995,
0.47344091534614563,
-0.6247857809066772,
-1.0689697265625,
0.7540221810340881,
-0.13371187448501587,
0.017212916165590286,
0.06739380955696106,
0.7713741660118103,
-0.1136147677898407,
1.1141775846481323,
0.6639986634254456,
-0.29147374629974365,
0.3890630006790161,
0.027026807889342308,
0.0937509536743164,
-0.7729761600494385,
-0.2399442493915558,
-0.4405573308467865,
0.050093647092580795,
-0.5629518032073975,
-0.7086310982704163,
0.035276733338832855,
0.5975290536880493,
-0.25684690475463867,
0.43899765610694885,
-0.0018463085871189833,
0.4909176230430603,
0.2968842089176178,
0.09003715217113495,
0.33844178915023804,
0.06478270888328552,
-0.1641918420791626,
-0.03271704912185669,
-0.9223535656929016,
-0.971440315246582,
0.99105304479599,
0.6426871418952942,
1.2910016775131226,
0.12635855376720428,
0.46888524293899536,
0.17577466368675232,
0.34483155608177185,
-0.9170684218406677,
0.8119243383407593,
-0.3401339054107666,
-0.4416186809539795,
-0.19232308864593506,
-0.5228943228721619,
-0.843088686466217,
0.5534207820892334,
0.21860280632972717,
-0.7462119460105896,
0.02140473574399948,
0.1959652155637741,
-0.49758201837539673,
0.06139323115348816,
-0.9594284892082214,
0.8589050769805908,
-0.29308560490608215,
-0.4328020513057709,
-0.2397731989622116,
-0.3002708852291107,
0.4139076769351959,
-0.05531131476163864,
0.20750093460083008,
-0.43611395359039307,
-0.42620599269866943,
0.4048892557621002,
-0.5684921145439148,
0.8276236057281494,
-0.06322517991065979,
-0.3167107105255127,
0.42947840690612793,
0.04433637484908104,
0.6452017426490784,
0.08169176429510117,
-0.29278936982154846,
0.2407243251800537,
-0.19300541281700134,
-0.38478994369506836,
-0.3547077775001526,
0.9805306196212769,
-0.7230240702629089,
-0.5147581696510315,
0.3112030327320099,
-0.5244089961051941,
-0.255869060754776,
0.17447060346603394,
0.059523388743400574,
0.47434455156326294,
-0.13534396886825562,
0.635179340839386,
0.8216143250465393,
-0.12241891026496887,
0.624334454536438,
0.448348730802536,
-0.47902390360832214,
-0.20591813325881958,
0.8478120565414429,
0.11382293701171875,
0.43828439712524414,
0.3098112642765045,
0.015875721350312233,
-0.6808924674987793,
-0.9941428899765015,
-0.6839921474456787,
0.2534581124782562,
-0.3878728151321411,
0.002348352922126651,
-0.7951548099517822,
-0.11305640637874603,
-0.21844133734703064,
0.16305580735206604,
-0.8287412524223328,
-0.26686397194862366,
-0.5443257689476013,
0.05473969504237175,
0.2619495391845703,
0.350130558013916,
0.1541062891483307,
0.7267025113105774,
-0.8452479839324951,
0.14576086401939392,
0.2157018631696701,
0.2318371683359146,
0.08228586614131927,
-0.6970911622047424,
-0.546640157699585,
0.2712010443210602,
-0.12532873451709747,
-0.40419313311576843,
0.3873269259929657,
0.21497546136379242,
0.6123292446136475,
0.15785428881645203,
-0.1831299364566803,
0.6721205115318298,
-0.5324268937110901,
0.6276565790176392,
-0.0213205236941576,
-0.8922644257545471,
0.19309364259243011,
-0.5268193483352661,
0.24627839028835297,
0.38652896881103516,
0.38294219970703125,
-0.5519618988037109,
-0.050491802394390106,
-0.3907342553138733,
-0.772743284702301,
0.4609116315841675,
-0.02586442604660988,
0.5963521003723145,
0.3652479648590088,
0.45181113481521606,
-0.24499160051345825,
0.037669744342565536,
-0.5490065813064575,
-0.20458362996578217,
0.08339405059814453,
-0.3718864619731903,
0.04901324212551117,
-0.4918505549430847,
0.24297462403774261,
-0.11548265814781189,
0.4690043330192566,
0.03937780484557152,
0.037306979298591614,
-0.1623671054840088,
-0.30821919441223145,
0.11456004530191422,
0.15625280141830444,
1.1072661876678467,
0.8034434914588928,
-0.04683632031083107,
0.2017858773469925,
0.29948896169662476,
-0.6382553577423096,
0.24591653048992157,
-0.04595974460244179,
-0.17268438637256622,
-0.04913102835416794,
-0.026011409237980843,
0.9500017762184143,
0.311036616563797,
-0.7682123184204102,
0.11284714192152023,
-0.005326275713741779,
0.037459954619407654,
0.07990711182355881,
0.1858006715774536,
0.643949031829834,
0.31969594955444336,
0.48271632194519043,
-0.2676691710948944,
-0.14387089014053345,
-0.39381730556488037,
0.19435076415538788,
0.6323857307434082,
-0.3676470220088959,
-0.31847742199897766,
0.9274548292160034,
0.3540560305118561,
-0.44387540221214294,
0.26159223914146423,
-0.021280907094478607,
-0.20753389596939087,
0.6179733872413635,
0.45026078820228577,
0.5422682762145996,
-0.42135706543922424,
0.18310211598873138,
-0.02725948952138424,
0.40921100974082947,
-0.22481508553028107,
0.35993692278862,
0.22577305138111115,
-0.7246373891830444,
-0.5125081539154053,
-0.646405816078186,
-0.561854898929596,
0.3085041046142578,
-0.21546754240989685,
0.16052396595478058,
-0.5374743342399597,
-0.3697650730609894,
-0.20206022262573242,
0.11288563907146454,
-0.3178740441799164,
0.41681772470474243,
0.13497261703014374,
0.8855296969413757,
-0.2510422170162201,
1.1274917125701904,
0.514277458190918,
-0.11610545217990875,
-1.0703779458999634,
-0.43387824296951294,
-0.20517456531524658,
-0.7916351556777954,
0.650936484336853,
-0.12651078402996063,
-0.29971742630004883,
0.3163279592990875,
-0.335600346326828,
-0.9894866347312927,
0.9613993167877197,
0.45163261890411377,
-0.685863196849823,
0.20832759141921997,
0.32697594165802,
0.36055538058280945,
-0.6833395957946777,
0.22104735672473907,
0.17720767855644226,
-0.019918380305171013,
0.20605112612247467,
-1.1235382556915283,
0.2349204421043396,
0.05270173028111458,
0.37378478050231934,
0.25069189071655273,
-1.0420928001403809,
0.8529506921768188,
-0.4653107821941376,
-0.20593784749507904,
0.18050616979599,
0.47753265500068665,
0.4268818795681,
0.15607145428657532,
0.31920695304870605,
0.5162550210952759,
0.5839190483093262,
0.13740822672843933,
0.9674885869026184,
-0.30433133244514465,
0.3629392683506012,
1.0585966110229492,
-0.6063862442970276,
1.1674116849899292,
0.4548053443431854,
-0.07289472967386246,
0.14955411851406097,
1.0243546962738037,
0.3701632618904114,
0.5545337796211243,
0.29370516538619995,
-0.42868244647979736,
-0.25102558732032776,
-0.26025235652923584,
-0.31300273537635803,
0.28144538402557373,
0.41448885202407837,
-0.4477907717227936,
-0.02339230664074421,
-0.05332018435001373,
0.1424153447151184,
-0.2511400282382965,
-0.5885539650917053,
0.5250243544578552,
0.5167417526245117,
-0.26661574840545654,
0.8622972965240479,
0.45441997051239014,
0.7597076892852783,
-0.1398950070142746,
0.5550805330276489,
-0.7724132537841797,
0.16665014624595642,
-0.31325870752334595,
-0.1421232372522354,
0.2957235872745514,
-0.016040915623307228,
-0.4099620580673218,
-0.31411075592041016,
0.7800125479698181,
-0.3713319003582001,
-0.45819956064224243,
0.21628330647945404,
0.5988739728927612,
0.20345915853977203,
-0.2174391746520996,
-0.7235407829284668,
0.5166969299316406,
-0.26271745562553406,
-0.34122705459594727,
0.21788805723190308,
0.1608768254518509,
-0.22269199788570404,
0.9610444903373718,
0.641444981098175,
0.0017566534224897623,
0.5350990295410156,
0.16942308843135834,
0.5034387707710266,
-0.7263498306274414,
-0.24332310259342194,
-1.0703903436660767,
0.34065118432044983,
0.07634571194648743,
-0.13130585849285126,
0.8066749572753906,
0.8489658236503601,
0.6383432745933533,
0.04076565429568291,
0.43290582299232483,
0.1721646636724472,
0.32799845933914185,
-0.5282450318336487,
0.779317319393158,
-0.6142992973327637,
0.5460878610610962,
0.14713792502880096,
-0.9482105374336243,
-0.19991299510002136,
0.27942460775375366,
-0.2460629940032959,
0.2570567727088928,
0.2982412576675415,
1.027691125869751,
-0.2702551782131195,
0.04036456719040871,
0.6412023305892944,
-0.032857686281204224,
0.10123445838689804,
0.5357519388198853,
0.8369259834289551,
-0.5918411016464233,
0.5867995023727417,
0.09411334991455078,
0.07996471971273422,
-0.6043662428855896,
-0.8938227891921997,
-0.8162099123001099,
-0.23947182297706604,
-0.3826872408390045,
-0.04195869341492653,
-0.026084773242473602,
0.897575318813324,
1.347028136253357,
-0.43479716777801514,
-0.6307172775268555,
-0.06022075563669205,
0.27842584252357483,
0.16433317959308624,
-0.0893130972981453,
0.010525830090045929,
-0.08702864497900009,
-0.6451454758644104,
0.6367016434669495,
0.3088926374912262,
0.30150526762008667,
-0.3054121136665344,
-0.35026299953460693,
0.05798155441880226,
0.39249154925346375,
0.9353877305984497,
0.3599124550819397,
-0.8438480496406555,
0.09628359228372574,
0.19719234108924866,
-0.6905596256256104,
-0.07603389024734497,
0.7477620840072632,
-0.4399203062057495,
-0.0625283494591713,
0.3349047601222992,
0.8490180373191833,
0.6511368155479431,
0.08688326925039291,
0.479638934135437,
-0.6440910696983337,
0.23044736683368683,
0.17693562805652618,
0.3129504323005676,
0.271403968334198,
-0.19589351117610931,
0.5276451110839844,
-0.04095654934644699,
-0.516402542591095,
-1.12553870677948,
0.21965260803699493,
-0.977481484413147,
-0.04158454388380051,
1.3048666715621948,
-0.08425497263669968,
0.01682780496776104,
-0.16639360785484314,
-0.1672985553741455,
-0.22958269715309143,
-0.3433237075805664,
0.5043745040893555,
0.5609877705574036,
-0.17474053800106049,
-0.6941031217575073,
-0.8037824034690857,
0.3357394337654114,
0.5908483266830444,
-0.9931792616844177,
0.10918805003166199,
0.2551218867301941,
0.2529684603214264,
-0.18624146282672882,
0.7274042963981628,
0.001102509326301515,
-0.05712100863456726,
-0.12516669929027557,
-0.09142246097326279,
-0.11955283582210541,
-0.18983620405197144,
-0.09576974809169769,
0.2801417112350464,
0.2565340995788574,
-0.2596260905265808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14808v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14808v3
|
RelayAttention for Efficient Large Language Model Serving with Long System Prompts
| 2024-02-22T18:58:28 | 2024-05-30T05:09:25 |
Lei Zhu, Xinjiang Wang, Wayne Zhang, Rynson W. H. Lau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A practical large language model (LLM) service may involve a long system
prompt, which specifies the instructions, examples, and knowledge documents of
the task and is reused across requests. However, the long system prompt causes
throughput/latency bottlenecks as the cost of generating the next token grows
w.r.t. the sequence length. This paper aims to improve the efficiency of LLM
services that involve long system prompts. Our key observation is that handling
these system prompts requires heavily redundant memory accesses in existing
causal attention computation algorithms. Specifically, for batched requests,
the cached hidden states (\ie, key-value pairs) of system prompts are
transferred from off-chip DRAM to on-chip SRAM multiple times, each
corresponding to an individual request. To eliminate such a redundancy, we
propose RelayAttention, an attention algorithm that allows reading these hidden
states from DRAM exactly once for a batch of input tokens. RelayAttention is a
free lunch: it maintains the generation quality while requiring no model
retraining, as it is based on a mathematical reformulation of causal attention.
We have observed significant performance improvements to a production-level
system, vLLM, through integration with RelayAttention. The improvements are
even more profound with longer system prompts.
|
[
-0.16795413196086884,
-0.44962430000305176,
0.6824856400489807,
0.7068581581115723,
-0.2221270352602005,
-0.016150305047631264,
-0.22185565531253815,
-0.46696391701698303,
0.2275792509317398,
0.6455351710319519,
-0.6168451905250549,
-0.12273813784122467,
-0.36742526292800903,
0.01554336491972208,
-0.3405199944972992,
0.6733922362327576,
-0.25415506958961487,
-0.1821233630180359,
-0.17166532576084137,
-0.0046111708506941795,
-0.8454208374023438,
-0.288754403591156,
-0.998515784740448,
-0.14133618772029877,
0.7800542712211609,
0.5466616749763489,
0.2122550755739212,
0.6019513607025146,
0.4880174994468689,
0.3045266270637512,
0.028540462255477905,
0.32457879185676575,
-0.6516429781913757,
0.587442934513092,
-0.3339391052722931,
-0.3435867130756378,
-0.43019407987594604,
-0.2870144248008728,
0.8567973375320435,
0.3380669057369232,
0.06397346407175064,
0.2741907835006714,
0.11823379248380661,
0.5359297394752502,
-0.7623271346092224,
0.21869321167469025,
-0.4633960723876953,
0.013411990366876125,
-0.09300382435321808,
-0.18913763761520386,
-0.8284250497817993,
-0.2511315941810608,
-0.03406922146677971,
-0.5169064998626709,
0.16540898382663727,
0.17616412043571472,
0.5898282527923584,
0.24859046936035156,
-0.06926285475492477,
0.14701098203659058,
-0.7758825421333313,
0.8975988626480103,
-0.5537824034690857,
0.2883073091506958,
0.3006789982318878,
0.4075373113155365,
-0.3470173478126526,
-0.6799468398094177,
-0.37356701493263245,
-0.3327561616897583,
-0.13208340108394623,
-0.007409132085740566,
-0.40767499804496765,
0.16276083886623383,
0.47507330775260925,
-0.053732022643089294,
-0.5138953328132629,
0.2585558295249939,
-0.2591952383518219,
-0.36073991656303406,
0.2867431342601776,
0.4952383041381836,
0.10501222312450409,
-0.11860142648220062,
-0.652764081954956,
0.14480623602867126,
-0.8401715755462646,
-0.016721436753869057,
-0.038155894726514816,
0.37454572319984436,
0.007294262759387493,
0.38033968210220337,
-0.4035698175430298,
0.6182520389556885,
0.15224067866802216,
0.0013029077090322971,
-0.11475890874862671,
-0.4133419990539551,
-0.27669069170951843,
0.13684654235839844,
0.7209490537643433,
0.06716327369213104,
-0.03457266092300415,
-0.11445534229278564,
-0.37110912799835205,
-0.17145726084709167,
0.29193276166915894,
-0.8215471506118774,
0.19112759828567505,
0.2716514766216278,
-0.20202909409999847,
-0.09370127320289612,
-0.081514373421669,
-0.5860663652420044,
-0.207040935754776,
-0.2127406895160675,
0.17869384586811066,
-0.45016393065452576,
0.2378244400024414,
-0.02004253678023815,
-0.09096937626600266,
0.1846526712179184,
0.4844478964805603,
-0.8451348543167114,
0.2221447080373764,
0.8860463500022888,
0.9843945503234863,
-0.23894886672496796,
-0.2559897005558014,
-0.9925637245178223,
0.4000820815563202,
-0.024520764127373695,
0.8022557497024536,
-0.4411703646183014,
-0.16939911246299744,
-0.24093542993068695,
0.11578208208084106,
-0.19256776571273804,
-0.4934263825416565,
0.35816967487335205,
-0.948962390422821,
-0.10877951979637146,
-0.3371579647064209,
-0.4376274049282074,
0.0905909463763237,
0.07574714720249176,
-0.7089025974273682,
1.0270986557006836,
-0.14375270903110504,
-0.6292127966880798,
0.024914534762501717,
-0.6839094758033752,
-0.5583239793777466,
0.08701567351818085,
0.033018290996551514,
-0.20258177816867828,
0.33750608563423157,
0.2606274485588074,
0.4348231256008148,
-0.42578262090682983,
0.2862749695777893,
-0.24065330624580383,
-0.5014062523841858,
0.15350787341594696,
-0.6510329246520996,
0.6040036678314209,
0.2321092039346695,
-0.5192753076553345,
0.26346322894096375,
-0.6770403981208801,
-0.05671624094247818,
-0.19415684044361115,
-0.2986547648906708,
-0.33296114206314087,
-0.04980909451842308,
-0.04078437015414238,
0.07521660625934601,
0.43028590083122253,
-0.43636325001716614,
0.2499205470085144,
-0.4580524265766144,
0.3968067169189453,
1.1374999284744263,
-0.13903231918811798,
0.3320223093032837,
-0.021235689520835876,
0.46504372358322144,
0.2363063544034958,
0.22593630850315094,
-0.6193663477897644,
-0.25255265831947327,
-0.9419748187065125,
-0.5971511006355286,
-0.03897226229310036,
0.37961670756340027,
-0.6352983713150024,
0.15404602885246277,
-0.13360856473445892,
-0.13743698596954346,
-0.43593651056289673,
-0.09548626095056534,
0.477569580078125,
0.6742313504219055,
0.319894015789032,
-0.12311805039644241,
-0.4222342073917389,
-1.0666309595108032,
0.004215720575302839,
-0.07609094679355621,
0.08793674409389496,
0.29610198736190796,
0.11229780316352844,
-0.3179943859577179,
0.9421843886375427,
-0.6226433515548706,
0.17596466839313507,
-0.1024332195520401,
0.0010687453905120492,
0.28384214639663696,
0.22815996408462524,
0.17033913731575012,
-0.18695655465126038,
-0.42473065853118896,
-0.02499062567949295,
-0.5441914200782776,
-0.3607550859451294,
-0.12733441591262817,
-0.2134503424167633,
0.5984215140342712,
0.5035410523414612,
-0.8411427736282349,
0.2323487401008606,
0.3809031844139099,
-0.27614763379096985,
0.7143075466156006,
-0.3257669508457184,
0.1754302829504013,
-1.0075819492340088,
0.27568554878234863,
-0.31282296776771545,
-0.33872857689857483,
-0.5136208534240723,
0.1713225096464157,
0.3373928368091583,
-0.347218781709671,
-0.5149720311164856,
0.9872987270355225,
-0.688080906867981,
-0.175399512052536,
-0.5352529883384705,
0.1806267648935318,
0.025496603921055794,
0.33884990215301514,
-0.18701741099357605,
0.9552785754203796,
0.5132342576980591,
-0.7087709903717041,
0.662962794303894,
-0.22484442591667175,
-0.07942677289247513,
0.6285264492034912,
-0.5770461559295654,
0.22868266701698303,
-0.11670679599046707,
0.1825512945652008,
-1.121445655822754,
-0.0364905409514904,
0.2480606734752655,
0.016024073585867882,
0.3846738934516907,
0.31684544682502747,
-0.4521434009075165,
-0.6048761606216431,
-0.25627779960632324,
0.5713561177253723,
0.2838156521320343,
-0.7130783796310425,
0.268106609582901,
0.09867572784423828,
-0.15602901577949524,
-0.6357675194740295,
-0.3347255289554596,
0.22939355671405792,
-0.0449666753411293,
-0.5844985842704773,
0.041261326521635056,
0.14056973159313202,
0.025250909850001335,
-0.09784553945064545,
-0.01121998205780983,
0.044828008860349655,
0.0844755694270134,
0.3118140995502472,
0.34229499101638794,
-0.30555260181427,
0.39536741375923157,
0.2151692658662796,
-0.5907565355300903,
-0.08481311798095703,
-0.6460561156272888,
0.7446503639221191,
0.17860105633735657,
-0.42643260955810547,
-0.7418471574783325,
0.7397190928459167,
0.7743788957595825,
-0.23241224884986877,
0.7173587083816528,
0.4034145176410675,
-0.2564689815044403,
-0.37501072883605957,
-0.5889500975608826,
-0.4786171317100525,
-0.5134409070014954,
0.5113046765327454,
-0.2904251217842102,
-1.1069518327713013,
0.6556305289268494,
0.10461157560348511,
0.059045132249593735,
0.20147472620010376,
0.3421863317489624,
-0.0029549896717071533,
0.7788162231445312,
0.6181885600090027,
-0.5186700224876404,
0.5934836268424988,
0.1854584813117981,
0.20130068063735962,
-0.6396334171295166,
0.0249991025775671,
-0.5157384872436523,
-0.34117281436920166,
-0.26251813769340515,
-0.7361844182014465,
0.22276200354099274,
-0.12957517802715302,
-0.5087465047836304,
0.34125223755836487,
-0.3544492721557617,
0.4318995475769043,
0.5489823818206787,
0.12467125803232193,
0.30237799882888794,
0.14840860664844513,
-0.07584968954324722,
-0.0034627532586455345,
-0.819908618927002,
-0.3703268766403198,
0.5627852082252502,
0.3854646682739258,
0.978739857673645,
-0.12831023335456848,
0.680595874786377,
0.09144193679094315,
0.42504388093948364,
-0.7424039244651794,
0.8680890202522278,
0.03730051964521408,
-0.2602073848247528,
-0.4260493516921997,
-0.6229684352874756,
-0.8673760890960693,
-0.07976879179477692,
0.49963581562042236,
-0.7853386402130127,
0.11891824007034302,
0.3715537488460541,
-0.5811745524406433,
0.23512382805347443,
-0.6507815718650818,
0.5161787867546082,
-0.015445270575582981,
-0.4447038471698761,
-0.4721238315105438,
-0.5193951725959778,
0.41305825114250183,
-0.11427319049835205,
-0.16241662204265594,
0.17180030047893524,
-0.08714059740304947,
0.7054777145385742,
-0.44647854566574097,
1.0804157257080078,
-0.1564529985189438,
-0.26673424243927,
0.17604537308216095,
-0.16739815473556519,
1.0179635286331177,
-0.04408030956983566,
-0.087948277592659,
-0.10015232115983963,
-0.35497161746025085,
-0.39374926686286926,
-0.6169756054878235,
1.0334280729293823,
-0.6084097027778625,
-0.8134691119194031,
-0.2562486529350281,
-0.5310567021369934,
-0.12467485666275024,
0.30062779784202576,
-0.08394522219896317,
0.35379600524902344,
-0.03808242827653885,
-0.2601836621761322,
0.9367905259132385,
-0.3433896601200104,
0.6033834218978882,
0.4483146667480469,
-0.14560852944850922,
-0.31113478541374207,
0.856065034866333,
0.07301944494247437,
0.46590903401374817,
0.5534119009971619,
-0.03210849314928055,
-0.1514205038547516,
-0.05853728577494621,
-0.3854977488517761,
0.5067540407180786,
-0.3854389488697052,
-0.44217780232429504,
-0.7515259981155396,
-0.19204694032669067,
-0.4415516257286072,
-0.01400625891983509,
-0.5537722706794739,
-0.359367698431015,
-0.6794440746307373,
-0.07964310050010681,
0.5966818928718567,
0.41125622391700745,
0.06537359952926636,
0.4674619734287262,
-0.9502604007720947,
0.3239062428474426,
0.3366219401359558,
0.47479456663131714,
0.4886445999145508,
-0.6293718814849854,
-0.5089637637138367,
-0.21680088341236115,
-0.2766313850879669,
-0.7071732878684998,
0.13346880674362183,
-0.005771542899310589,
0.5432212352752686,
0.6038094758987427,
0.12522314488887787,
0.821773886680603,
-0.7986288666725159,
0.49359437823295593,
0.2916380763053894,
-0.8685809969902039,
0.40107202529907227,
-0.24141748249530792,
0.5109291076660156,
0.30653178691864014,
0.22911441326141357,
-0.8670423626899719,
-0.5041751265525818,
-0.17482325434684753,
-1.0064653158187866,
0.9980210065841675,
-0.24717643857002258,
0.2402360737323761,
-0.2630755603313446,
0.44938892126083374,
-0.02203991264104843,
0.1507224142551422,
-0.25489869713783264,
-0.2480563372373581,
0.28030112385749817,
-0.07059670984745026,
0.04404072463512421,
-0.6131330728530884,
-0.10119005292654037,
0.06267184019088745,
0.5642141699790955,
-0.017260100692510605,
0.6569001078605652,
0.11885959655046463,
0.03901563957333565,
-0.18820835649967194,
0.2604159712791443,
0.8546624779701233,
0.45052897930145264,
0.2045176923274994,
0.39257025718688965,
0.13812069594860077,
-0.5725681185722351,
0.42281830310821533,
-0.08579756319522858,
-0.24020850658416748,
-0.12704606354236603,
0.2874296009540558,
1.0980051755905151,
0.49929288029670715,
-0.6204990744590759,
0.19859416782855988,
-0.03188251331448555,
0.24455033242702484,
0.15935271978378296,
0.1599060297012329,
0.18669317662715912,
0.4471767842769623,
0.3679906725883484,
-0.28431347012519836,
-0.05931498110294342,
-0.25914424657821655,
0.3442125618457794,
0.45074769854545593,
-0.5969659090042114,
-0.18123726546764374,
0.3854118287563324,
0.22167812287807465,
-0.3451278805732727,
0.7120461463928223,
0.12025254964828491,
-0.4295453727245331,
0.5078875422477722,
0.8190311789512634,
1.0986567735671997,
-0.4822187125682831,
0.2899090051651001,
0.29555702209472656,
0.3192811906337738,
-0.21770599484443665,
0.0750727578997612,
-0.1094847321510315,
-0.395190954208374,
-0.5893139839172363,
-0.6228511333465576,
-0.18261104822158813,
0.08996753394603729,
-0.4390198290348053,
0.3311270475387573,
-0.40832942724227905,
-0.17197716236114502,
-0.4786626696586609,
-0.26756805181503296,
-0.4230126142501831,
-0.036098700016736984,
-0.05949246510863304,
1.0188820362091064,
-0.653235673904419,
0.6510864496231079,
0.3001193702220917,
0.07475267350673676,
-0.8967934846878052,
-0.1758684366941452,
-0.38090232014656067,
-0.7861459255218506,
0.8836840987205505,
0.23324784636497498,
-0.20803609490394592,
-0.02138935960829258,
-0.24553191661834717,
-1.0171562433242798,
1.0113199949264526,
0.5456087589263916,
-0.9766373634338379,
0.10223811864852905,
0.064125657081604,
0.27678894996643066,
-0.2166755199432373,
0.28222087025642395,
0.38932690024375916,
0.47438931465148926,
0.09855598956346512,
-0.9155866503715515,
0.45128220319747925,
0.08779404312372208,
0.05945752561092377,
0.38300779461860657,
-0.9720259308815002,
0.6835464239120483,
-0.3616860806941986,
-0.4966934621334076,
0.08252981305122375,
0.9912548661231995,
0.5231556296348572,
0.35963451862335205,
0.2061556577682495,
0.5055583715438843,
0.7972957491874695,
0.16214559972286224,
0.9477685689926147,
-0.16636139154434204,
0.40858280658721924,
1.1472407579421997,
-0.4920557141304016,
0.7372472286224365,
0.9042059779167175,
-0.01612117886543274,
0.007582732476294041,
0.5130520462989807,
0.33319422602653503,
0.5426313281059265,
0.3040764629840851,
-0.5304282307624817,
-0.12902554869651794,
0.028997136279940605,
-0.274019718170166,
0.037810735404491425,
-0.04517100006341934,
-0.333202987909317,
-0.4716149866580963,
0.3030432462692261,
-0.03375997021794319,
-0.4044150114059448,
-0.3915533423423767,
0.5874887108802795,
0.28042712807655334,
-0.6902919411659241,
0.592947781085968,
0.008469715714454651,
0.4722207188606262,
-0.4791795015335083,
0.007788495160639286,
-0.5401380658149719,
0.16335774958133698,
0.13884440064430237,
-0.3378143012523651,
0.17987675964832306,
0.0975273922085762,
-0.7484711408615112,
-0.2781039774417877,
0.7351481914520264,
-0.2833338975906372,
-0.48537006974220276,
0.37146681547164917,
0.10045724362134933,
0.06275855749845505,
-0.010623268783092499,
-0.29611021280288696,
0.2538735270500183,
-0.13709548115730286,
-0.49283134937286377,
0.4621738791465759,
0.5103375911712646,
-0.44193920493125916,
0.8706201910972595,
0.5122882723808289,
0.1622694581747055,
0.08698159456253052,
0.09632498770952225,
1.0629936456680298,
-0.8222507238388062,
-0.6207045912742615,
-0.9724876880645752,
0.32014602422714233,
0.028035173192620277,
0.061808403581380844,
0.7914341688156128,
0.459911972284317,
0.2992720603942871,
-0.17137420177459717,
0.5668022036552429,
0.37939712405204773,
0.25601404905319214,
-0.4988285303115845,
0.7636527419090271,
-0.25166720151901245,
0.40249213576316833,
-0.1231091320514679,
-0.7937415242195129,
-0.3206879496574402,
0.31453967094421387,
-0.5066626071929932,
-0.10017240792512894,
0.646173357963562,
0.9814679622650146,
-0.19523559510707855,
-0.16144022345542908,
0.4175928235054016,
0.22360309958457947,
0.4368489980697632,
0.6250101327896118,
0.818730890750885,
-0.25879502296447754,
0.14124181866645813,
0.2713697850704193,
-0.4487304091453552,
-0.4512765109539032,
-0.7915262579917908,
-0.5272460579872131,
-0.34049832820892334,
-0.019525982439517975,
-0.13621468842029572,
0.18512406945228577,
0.7180215120315552,
0.5750718712806702,
-0.6910048723220825,
-0.3524748980998993,
0.07368508726358414,
0.33661022782325745,
-0.13917484879493713,
-0.2430628389120102,
0.3832457363605499,
-0.6936822533607483,
-0.4987347424030304,
0.41952988505363464,
0.7996068000793457,
-0.251586377620697,
-0.3825729191303253,
0.019707879051566124,
0.050601206719875336,
0.2884281873703003,
0.8440135717391968,
0.3701987862586975,
-0.4581066370010376,
-0.5070214867591858,
0.2382277399301529,
-0.38489675521850586,
-0.14540636539459229,
0.9380298852920532,
-0.69868403673172,
0.21265526115894318,
0.5327008366584778,
0.7514480948448181,
0.4935719072818756,
-0.15549145638942719,
0.5002580881118774,
-0.6668646931648254,
0.2681535482406616,
0.11562903225421906,
0.13997671008110046,
0.10032349079847336,
-0.5598242282867432,
-0.23766611516475677,
0.2672158479690552,
-0.5990399718284607,
-0.9802702069282532,
0.38399702310562134,
-1.060922622680664,
-0.07109556347131729,
1.0689913034439087,
-0.28254273533821106,
-0.6891744136810303,
-0.06745238602161407,
-0.3289240598678589,
0.07165294885635376,
-0.7523980736732483,
0.7564761638641357,
0.42345547676086426,
-0.15206529200077057,
-0.3008469045162201,
-0.2452782541513443,
0.25038355588912964,
0.4151805341243744,
-0.7950173020362854,
0.5808600187301636,
0.6120100617408752,
0.11614178121089935,
0.14846748113632202,
0.7611938118934631,
0.06448500603437424,
0.2859601378440857,
-0.2625208795070648,
0.008001944050192833,
-0.024861382320523262,
-0.6715908646583557,
-0.3719751834869385,
0.3101707398891449,
-0.10538516193628311,
-0.3089212477207184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14805v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14805v1
|
Identifying Multiple Personalities in Large Language Models with External Evaluation
| 2024-02-22T18:57:20 | 2024-02-22T18:57:20 |
Xiaoyang Song, Yuta Adachi, Jessie Feng, Mouwei Lin, Linhao Yu, Frank Li, Akshat Gupta, Gopala Anumanchipalli, Simerjot Kaur
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) are integrated with human daily applications
rapidly, many societal and ethical concerns are raised regarding the behavior
of LLMs. One of the ways to comprehend LLMs' behavior is to analyze their
personalities. Many recent studies quantify LLMs' personalities using
self-assessment tests that are created for humans. Yet many critiques question
the applicability and reliability of these self-assessment tests when applied
to LLMs. In this paper, we investigate LLM personalities using an alternate
personality measurement method, which we refer to as the external evaluation
method, where instead of prompting LLMs with multiple-choice questions in the
Likert scale, we evaluate LLMs' personalities by analyzing their responses
toward open-ended situational questions using an external machine learning
model. We first fine-tuned a Llama2-7B model as the MBTI personality predictor
that outperforms the state-of-the-art models as the tool to analyze LLMs'
responses. Then, we prompt the LLMs with situational questions and ask them to
generate Twitter posts and comments, respectively, in order to assess their
personalities when playing two different roles. Using the external personality
evaluation method, we identify that the obtained personality types for LLMs are
significantly different when generating posts versus comments, whereas humans
show a consistent personality profile in these two different situations. This
shows that LLMs can exhibit different personalities based on different
scenarios, thus highlighting a fundamental difference between personality in
LLMs and humans. With our work, we call for a re-evaluation of personality
definition and measurement in LLMs.
|
[
-0.5506630539894104,
-0.7819472551345825,
0.868037760257721,
0.3795609176158905,
-0.09161436557769775,
0.18942253291606903,
-0.6651020646095276,
-0.46875596046447754,
0.20539672672748566,
0.3319292664527893,
-0.7032136917114258,
-0.20392654836177826,
-0.6130649447441101,
0.4594419002532959,
-0.13022862374782562,
0.7979978322982788,
-0.14129215478897095,
0.32245540618896484,
-0.23311181366443634,
-0.2203475385904312,
-0.4988209903240204,
-0.6131151914596558,
-0.8899695873260498,
-0.3461189270019531,
0.9912709593772888,
0.3364923298358917,
0.34883978962898254,
-0.13776271045207977,
0.4965503215789795,
0.4130960702896118,
0.06581319868564606,
0.13335683941841125,
-0.4295271635055542,
0.1283576488494873,
-0.21160227060317993,
-0.2690936028957367,
-0.1767403930425644,
0.09372063726186752,
0.745236337184906,
0.32236969470977783,
0.19292369484901428,
0.5459583401679993,
0.08479243516921997,
0.6053870320320129,
-0.48563408851623535,
0.04070376977324486,
-0.4715316891670227,
-0.08582723140716553,
-0.20377379655838013,
-0.0631554052233696,
-0.4369254410266876,
-0.6021775603294373,
0.041712816804647446,
0.18394364416599274,
-0.21397672593593597,
-0.15432563424110413,
0.2804916203022003,
0.02129759080708027,
-0.7303652763366699,
-0.35888534784317017,
-0.7169000506401062,
0.6829347610473633,
-0.5727585554122925,
0.35561004281044006,
0.12167173624038696,
0.5007613897323608,
-0.11207425594329834,
-0.19489936530590057,
-0.7958969473838806,
-0.6169191002845764,
-0.09918425977230072,
0.14921480417251587,
0.1598246991634369,
-0.34801825881004333,
0.1059432253241539,
0.1301129311323166,
-0.4663957953453064,
0.29969489574432373,
-0.18160809576511383,
-0.028536200523376465,
0.8511145710945129,
0.3181907832622528,
0.12165504693984985,
-0.06810828298330307,
-0.20845581591129303,
0.046945083886384964,
-0.7354784607887268,
0.11893121898174286,
0.7532942295074463,
0.0981445163488388,
-0.10724891722202301,
0.7247761487960815,
-0.04404258728027344,
0.22553017735481262,
0.1885688751935959,
-0.2237524539232254,
0.2501209080219269,
-0.09387605637311935,
-0.12780199944972992,
-0.1692924201488495,
0.8252442479133606,
0.35062864422798157,
0.4243253767490387,
0.05251409485936165,
-0.1559673696756363,
-0.10391896218061447,
0.2838636040687561,
-0.8243700265884399,
0.030107460916042328,
0.4781204164028168,
-0.7293738126754761,
-0.2313036322593689,
-0.009333954192698002,
-0.727171003818512,
-0.7507007718086243,
-0.3777886927127838,
0.45626726746559143,
-0.12991833686828613,
-0.5942662954330444,
-0.4342952370643616,
0.19545213878154755,
0.32381314039230347,
0.3580690026283264,
-0.8254033327102661,
0.14248475432395935,
0.6746434569358826,
0.7864449620246887,
-0.3620162904262543,
-0.4436589181423187,
-0.4040268361568451,
-0.0883190855383873,
-0.3928189277648926,
0.8817805647850037,
-0.6188948750495911,
-0.44158315658569336,
-0.08689207583665848,
0.008853690698742867,
-0.10661201179027557,
-0.5540781021118164,
0.2719450294971466,
-0.6143258810043335,
-0.06798093020915985,
-0.7259111404418945,
-0.43487173318862915,
-0.1183323934674263,
0.5500640273094177,
-0.3498738706111908,
0.8996338248252869,
0.14677928388118744,
-0.7717537879943848,
0.3366684019565582,
-0.8140814900398254,
-0.12325935065746307,
0.017387881875038147,
-0.3667004704475403,
-0.27633941173553467,
0.3034796714782715,
-0.12921810150146484,
0.6532222032546997,
-0.25070756673812866,
0.2865176796913147,
-0.777992844581604,
-0.23506228625774384,
0.9459784030914307,
-0.3119868338108063,
0.7064424157142639,
-0.10372993350028992,
-0.030433250591158867,
0.5682339668273926,
-0.6483434438705444,
0.11542247235774994,
0.23736971616744995,
-0.415382444858551,
-0.20628203451633453,
0.14797845482826233,
-0.0932268500328064,
0.5048534274101257,
0.4532081186771393,
-0.7996183037757874,
0.24383805692195892,
-0.25021710991859436,
0.21736747026443481,
1.077226996421814,
0.0633656457066536,
0.02597741223871708,
-0.49468544125556946,
0.3795287311077118,
-0.12383664399385452,
0.054049283266067505,
0.20036695897579193,
-0.5150468945503235,
-0.7819575667381287,
-0.34763580560684204,
-0.19365713000297546,
0.4419754445552826,
-0.24639734625816345,
0.4890660047531128,
-0.3130742311477661,
-0.7521268129348755,
-0.4680914580821991,
0.20946426689624786,
0.28690284490585327,
0.11190502345561981,
0.18661190569400787,
-0.2171190083026886,
-0.6573631167411804,
-0.964286208152771,
-0.4325820803642273,
-0.27728644013404846,
-0.10753292590379715,
0.3692774772644043,
0.8612592220306396,
-0.5018010139465332,
0.837608277797699,
-0.267270028591156,
0.07448998093605042,
-0.4954706132411957,
-0.10490597039461136,
0.04361214488744736,
0.18426501750946045,
0.2573322057723999,
-0.5245027542114258,
-0.6729947328567505,
-0.012969139963388443,
-0.6016921997070312,
-0.14732244610786438,
-0.06722439080476761,
-0.0353427417576313,
0.1989869773387909,
0.346647709608078,
-0.6067131757736206,
0.21537084877490997,
0.5619097352027893,
-0.2282436192035675,
0.8649322986602783,
-0.1047036424279213,
0.09895505756139755,
-0.7963702082633972,
0.11800497770309448,
0.0803266391158104,
-0.002103789011016488,
-0.46152645349502563,
0.21800164878368378,
-0.014753812924027443,
0.3068799674510956,
-0.39805567264556885,
0.852653980255127,
-0.4316491484642029,
-0.4776766300201416,
-0.23290611803531647,
0.04608689621090889,
-0.19778241217136383,
0.42970991134643555,
-0.07357165217399597,
0.5744703412055969,
0.4100119173526764,
-0.4348489046096802,
0.5183047652244568,
0.07196149975061417,
-0.47686436772346497,
0.9660223722457886,
-0.48231565952301025,
0.6352936625480652,
-0.24739713966846466,
0.4041529893875122,
-1.3482134342193604,
-0.17363081872463226,
0.3713141679763794,
-0.30415666103363037,
0.16664116084575653,
-0.07284078747034073,
-0.7865919470787048,
-0.31750476360321045,
-0.47018346190452576,
-0.036809418350458145,
0.2775297462940216,
-0.5987175703048706,
0.7469325661659241,
0.24580049514770508,
-0.3364243507385254,
0.03679006174206734,
-0.5504915714263916,
-0.012596228159964085,
-0.5423496961593628,
-0.7345805168151855,
0.060929346829652786,
-0.5811718702316284,
-0.7209474444389343,
-0.4001927673816681,
-0.024898992851376534,
-0.06884141266345978,
0.11868297308683395,
0.2298564910888672,
0.30014675855636597,
-0.2604924142360687,
0.06427470594644547,
-0.00708847725763917,
0.04241064563393593,
0.2689003646373749,
0.3064403831958771,
0.5871551632881165,
-0.4295048117637634,
-0.5287708640098572,
-0.2908210754394531,
0.3673538863658905,
0.4185231626033783,
-0.07239630073308945,
0.9273490309715271,
0.8088063597679138,
-0.2345084846019745,
0.15602421760559082,
-0.8690475821495056,
-0.07245528697967529,
-0.5054667592048645,
0.358752965927124,
-0.6442567706108093,
-0.8387186527252197,
0.7596272230148315,
0.051846977323293686,
0.11247138679027557,
0.4628751873970032,
1.1715984344482422,
-0.18111689388751984,
0.8941366076469421,
0.37605613470077515,
0.2309180349111557,
0.2026023119688034,
0.057114530354738235,
0.17809253931045532,
-1.236262321472168,
-0.39669570326805115,
-0.21654123067855835,
-0.4507257640361786,
-0.6577685475349426,
-0.16189582645893097,
0.25665831565856934,
-0.35013270378112793,
-0.4472164511680603,
0.14335189759731293,
-0.1508202701807022,
0.48641782999038696,
0.1395738422870636,
0.044406186789274216,
0.42249295115470886,
-0.455142080783844,
-0.07381778955459595,
-0.18514424562454224,
0.0764622613787651,
-0.7979159951210022,
1.3433867692947388,
0.5204655528068542,
0.5891948342323303,
0.6453561782836914,
0.6498664617538452,
0.08217064291238785,
1.210451364517212,
-0.8532100915908813,
0.6658002734184265,
0.05262947827577591,
-0.6976367831230164,
-0.2840828597545624,
-0.5144056081771851,
-0.6606153845787048,
0.7132987976074219,
-0.023798618465662003,
-1.2633410692214966,
-0.15009336173534393,
-0.1625109612941742,
-0.45125582814216614,
0.07136859744787216,
-0.922846257686615,
0.8070263266563416,
-0.5419797897338867,
-0.12079203128814697,
-0.21413247287273407,
-0.5858568549156189,
0.6780998110771179,
-0.4777778387069702,
0.12120695412158966,
-0.37990766763687134,
-0.17441336810588837,
0.5851011276245117,
-0.15005213022232056,
0.9773438572883606,
-0.06722553819417953,
-0.47091156244277954,
0.17406140267848969,
0.20616310834884644,
0.31210610270500183,
0.275877982378006,
-0.2573483884334564,
0.29483848810195923,
0.26679131388664246,
0.1559261679649353,
-0.6025930047035217,
1.1260271072387695,
-0.9553205370903015,
-0.6218065619468689,
-0.3826221525669098,
-0.2507166266441345,
-0.5059865713119507,
0.0921899750828743,
0.012895903550088406,
0.2260316014289856,
-0.35129931569099426,
0.018001198768615723,
0.13840468227863312,
-0.3429182171821594,
0.4197084307670593,
0.9142011404037476,
-0.38750165700912476,
-0.21600273251533508,
0.7831528782844543,
0.11960320174694061,
0.23662465810775757,
0.24131375551223755,
0.5568093061447144,
-0.5189641714096069,
-0.29513388872146606,
-0.3643139898777008,
0.33886396884918213,
-0.7251599431037903,
0.19403229653835297,
-0.517670750617981,
-0.08082746714353561,
-0.5029383897781372,
0.14173775911331177,
-0.38996002078056335,
0.19529075920581818,
-0.2563205361366272,
0.15525110065937042,
-0.018337512388825417,
0.8751659393310547,
0.25401198863983154,
0.2596171498298645,
-0.7112364172935486,
0.3019247055053711,
0.3149677515029907,
0.4568009376525879,
0.22821740806102753,
-0.6585335731506348,
0.13856057822704315,
-0.09774939715862274,
-0.5056765675544739,
-1.1406327486038208,
0.19156986474990845,
0.06469588726758957,
0.6247146129608154,
0.4678654968738556,
-0.3281019926071167,
0.6561407446861267,
-0.5617175698280334,
0.4523862898349762,
-0.09389680624008179,
-0.8140489459037781,
0.24519231915473938,
-0.2200726568698883,
0.18318060040473938,
0.5961336493492126,
0.44787514209747314,
-0.7357552647590637,
-0.2732572555541992,
-0.3237914443016052,
-0.46299871802330017,
0.5804044604301453,
0.1739027500152588,
0.24598826467990875,
-0.11470959335565567,
0.40063467621803284,
0.28725239634513855,
0.21375977993011475,
-1.0127167701721191,
-0.3328794240951538,
0.10648565739393234,
-0.09625065326690674,
-0.18310153484344482,
-0.28836968541145325,
-0.10353188961744308,
-0.21066948771476746,
0.5361754894256592,
-0.15028654038906097,
0.36893752217292786,
0.023510484024882317,
0.011223608627915382,
-0.12486448138952255,
0.42164865136146545,
0.5841066241264343,
0.7445005178451538,
-0.20656588673591614,
0.07109374552965164,
0.29568734765052795,
-0.05893320590257645,
0.19482721388339996,
-0.12414678931236267,
0.3155054748058319,
-0.21935492753982544,
0.20611891150474548,
0.3637184500694275,
0.1320059895515442,
-0.7813804149627686,
0.5436615943908691,
-0.20587533712387085,
0.1838826686143875,
-0.8461946249008179,
-0.066129669547081,
0.4009627103805542,
0.4501718580722809,
0.2110193818807602,
-0.03048313781619072,
-0.06387017667293549,
-0.8049440979957581,
-0.08241021633148193,
0.5856369137763977,
-0.11737219989299774,
-0.5469014048576355,
0.10092972218990326,
0.21178287267684937,
-0.5005460381507874,
0.32789796590805054,
-0.5148701071739197,
-0.3631478250026703,
0.6640280485153198,
0.4093199074268341,
1.0638437271118164,
-0.3411578834056854,
0.062052272260189056,
0.1402641236782074,
0.3812311887741089,
0.06826458871364594,
0.4147208333015442,
0.17158859968185425,
-1.0161478519439697,
-0.5601403117179871,
-0.6086097359657288,
-0.523574948310852,
0.5844398140907288,
-0.4330410361289978,
0.2951602637767792,
-0.5680281519889832,
-0.18949750065803528,
0.013279734179377556,
0.1362202763557434,
-0.6901307106018066,
-0.0466567687690258,
0.3050643503665924,
0.5244736075401306,
-0.6988136768341064,
0.7305528521537781,
0.6962286829948425,
-0.20904937386512756,
-0.39754006266593933,
0.32615748047828674,
0.2622829079627991,
-0.7826365828514099,
0.9294302463531494,
0.6557097434997559,
-0.09688915312290192,
-0.14930473268032074,
-0.25507882237434387,
-0.8886775374412537,
0.7063779830932617,
0.28651371598243713,
-0.5087139010429382,
0.22207757830619812,
0.007639715448021889,
0.7401151657104492,
-0.43641895055770874,
0.6675177812576294,
0.5667810440063477,
0.6158793568611145,
-0.034535378217697144,
-0.8277997374534607,
0.20904763042926788,
-0.14196661114692688,
0.04951661452651024,
0.10878615081310272,
-0.9509586095809937,
0.679496169090271,
-0.3705314099788666,
-0.19309622049331665,
0.22169920802116394,
0.5643401145935059,
0.5046895146369934,
0.09413311630487442,
0.5958127379417419,
0.04881817102432251,
0.5095831751823425,
0.2525078356266022,
0.9706642031669617,
-0.12987250089645386,
0.3911876082420349,
1.299415111541748,
-0.6784248948097229,
1.0885626077651978,
0.48680421710014343,
-0.3965602517127991,
0.6605941653251648,
0.7545714974403381,
-0.08369085937738419,
0.10830759257078171,
0.47329965233802795,
-0.1838511824607849,
-0.2011217474937439,
0.20113065838813782,
-0.1335790604352951,
0.598241925239563,
0.3787468671798706,
-0.23514707386493683,
-0.052825894206762314,
-0.12127316743135452,
0.006078436505049467,
-0.22396714985370636,
-0.1527484804391861,
0.5897728204727173,
0.08136266469955444,
-0.7158334255218506,
0.03481075540184975,
0.3543563783168793,
0.7737614512443542,
-0.5053479075431824,
0.25378698110580444,
-0.1518474668264389,
0.2490318864583969,
-0.20136427879333496,
-0.8996016383171082,
0.533038318157196,
0.1572527438402176,
0.18189199268817902,
-0.2507008910179138,
0.5214945673942566,
-0.2751973271369934,
-0.6058184504508972,
0.41538941860198975,
0.6003040075302124,
0.26786693930625916,
-0.2919374406337738,
-0.6176873445510864,
0.06481252610683441,
-0.3020094335079193,
-0.4960053265094757,
0.5564309358596802,
0.13344541192054749,
0.047757986932992935,
0.8501017093658447,
0.7211676836013794,
-0.052547305822372437,
-0.19349926710128784,
0.3425324261188507,
0.592497706413269,
-0.5834227800369263,
-0.35723060369491577,
-1.4149370193481445,
0.28442126512527466,
0.04461235553026199,
-0.5305730104446411,
0.9454168677330017,
0.49598830938339233,
0.7262343764305115,
-0.04995366558432579,
0.725549578666687,
0.013207787647843361,
0.6415727138519287,
-0.37525445222854614,
0.4716113209724426,
-0.37856751680374146,
0.2879074215888977,
-0.3174024522304535,
-0.9040259122848511,
0.13829267024993896,
0.6015827655792236,
-0.5515995025634766,
0.459495484828949,
0.7441405057907104,
0.5374888777732849,
0.1992122232913971,
-0.012715731747448444,
0.2422412931919098,
0.40321680903434753,
0.2999362051486969,
0.4642829895019531,
1.2355884313583374,
0.07643963396549225,
0.36518704891204834,
-0.15493570268154144,
-0.13118807971477509,
-0.20484738051891327,
-0.7808575630187988,
-1.2826796770095825,
-0.43798384070396423,
-0.29115188121795654,
-0.19525884091854095,
-0.41639044880867004,
1.0395807027816772,
0.33121079206466675,
-0.5713357329368591,
-0.3373405933380127,
0.3505924344062805,
0.17516879737377167,
0.045398592948913574,
-0.29339128732681274,
0.0760577991604805,
0.10701274871826172,
-0.5917953848838806,
0.38521504402160645,
0.34331971406936646,
-0.13481245934963226,
-1.000081181526184,
0.08450916409492493,
0.009944151155650616,
0.1574762761592865,
0.7643774151802063,
-0.05858870968222618,
-1.0272396802902222,
-0.7266770601272583,
0.013865039683878422,
-0.05889127403497696,
0.12073472142219543,
0.8153594136238098,
-0.38743096590042114,
0.17981910705566406,
0.3346427381038666,
0.4978468716144562,
0.22121021151542664,
-0.0521911196410656,
0.23281912505626678,
-0.6561031937599182,
-0.2958189845085144,
0.03904876857995987,
0.4109857678413391,
0.5474454760551453,
-0.4409550726413727,
0.14558254182338715,
0.09468968957662582,
-0.5508713126182556,
-0.5511232018470764,
0.3858380615711212,
-0.8632309436798096,
-0.07957100123167038,
1.5680599212646484,
-0.17005965113639832,
0.14383330941200256,
-0.13571268320083618,
-0.24659988284111023,
-0.09670808911323547,
-0.40586239099502563,
0.866236686706543,
0.9782112836837769,
-0.44424429535865784,
-0.028990233317017555,
-0.6101945638656616,
0.07337448745965958,
0.08910158276557922,
-1.0621880292892456,
-0.15800003707408905,
0.2932007312774658,
0.6588075757026672,
0.1277601718902588,
0.8945561647415161,
0.005870774853974581,
-0.15917058289051056,
-0.4471505284309387,
-0.12099288403987885,
0.27132266759872437,
-0.11051523685455322,
-0.359599769115448,
-0.01811504364013672,
0.08683187514543533,
0.02205513045191765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14804v1
|
Measuring Multimodal Mathematical Reasoning with MATH-Vision Dataset
| 2024-02-22T18:56:38 | 2024-02-22T18:56:38 |
Ke Wang, Junting Pan, Weikang Shi, Zimu Lu, Mingjie Zhan, Hongsheng Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, math.HO
|
Recent advancements in Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have shown promising
results in mathematical reasoning within visual contexts, with models
approaching human-level performance on existing benchmarks such as MathVista.
However, we observe significant limitations in the diversity of questions and
breadth of subjects covered by these benchmarks. To address this issue, we
present the MATH-Vision (MATH-V) dataset, a meticulously curated collection of
3,040 high-quality mathematical problems with visual contexts sourced from real
math competitions. Spanning 16 distinct mathematical disciplines and graded
across 5 levels of difficulty, our dataset provides a comprehensive and diverse
set of challenges for evaluating the mathematical reasoning abilities of LMMs.
Through extensive experimentation, we unveil a notable performance gap between
current LMMs and human performance on MATH-V, underscoring the imperative for
further advancements in LMMs. Moreover, our detailed categorization allows for
a thorough error analysis of LMMs, offering valuable insights to guide future
research and development. The project is available at
https://mathvision-cuhk.github.io
|
[
-0.5590862035751343,
-0.6493355631828308,
0.6113770008087158,
0.3513059914112091,
-0.13939997553825378,
0.10666972398757935,
-0.163861483335495,
-0.23294797539710999,
-0.0010878811590373516,
0.22161318361759186,
-0.8075920343399048,
-0.4911743700504303,
-0.5173446536064148,
0.08545082807540894,
-0.0417657271027565,
0.5319629907608032,
-0.21839700639247894,
0.4469521641731262,
-1.027056336402893,
-0.4633919894695282,
-0.7033993601799011,
-0.42173275351524353,
-0.11252663284540176,
-0.013062226586043835,
0.6478732228279114,
0.33746451139450073,
0.6683413982391357,
0.24317987263202667,
0.9308796525001526,
0.2810996472835541,
0.25546419620513916,
0.5969663262367249,
-0.2098134607076645,
0.181526780128479,
-0.16184134781360626,
-0.5142068862915039,
-0.4051363468170166,
0.00034734897781163454,
0.524663507938385,
0.8828791975975037,
-0.14891542494297028,
0.2970311939716339,
-0.19796882569789886,
0.5466355085372925,
-0.7764047384262085,
0.4504203200340271,
-0.2973119914531708,
0.251090407371521,
-0.5034326314926147,
0.01596037857234478,
-0.23565809428691864,
-0.26958030462265015,
0.14039045572280884,
-0.9154626727104187,
0.09586489945650101,
-0.1177239716053009,
0.5868396162986755,
0.42331331968307495,
-0.484173446893692,
0.13156600296497345,
-0.5353018045425415,
0.93881756067276,
-0.317615807056427,
0.645581066608429,
0.2552066147327423,
0.8525086045265198,
0.24681055545806885,
-0.6296854019165039,
-0.4116024076938629,
0.07543786615133286,
0.40405991673469543,
0.3381449282169342,
-0.3493327796459198,
-0.26501357555389404,
0.6338843703269958,
0.12210114300251007,
-0.6091873049736023,
-0.24730436503887177,
-0.5114396810531616,
-0.35999682545661926,
0.5061253309249878,
0.594864547252655,
0.17223180830478668,
-0.1378365457057953,
-0.09114743024110794,
-0.3809777796268463,
-0.2824999690055847,
0.2721744477748871,
0.2847391366958618,
-0.13475002348423004,
-0.12063346058130264,
0.9379143118858337,
-0.24895423650741577,
0.8050817251205444,
-0.5884979963302612,
-0.10643809288740158,
0.3499610722064972,
-0.6786763668060303,
-0.0315999872982502,
-0.5265671610832214,
0.49053138494491577,
0.45276880264282227,
0.46657025814056396,
0.31766632199287415,
-0.20015069842338562,
0.5815101265907288,
0.1721854954957962,
-0.64671391248703,
-0.36478501558303833,
-0.19968515634536743,
-0.1837436407804489,
0.004527209792286158,
0.1938285082578659,
-0.8829199075698853,
-0.49791327118873596,
-0.5876332521438599,
0.5147382616996765,
-0.3635878562927246,
-0.21552827954292297,
0.4174794554710388,
-0.33116182684898376,
-0.16800905764102936,
0.6616448760032654,
-0.46750345826148987,
-0.008448505774140358,
0.6711291074752808,
0.6788864731788635,
-0.03256557881832123,
-0.28759336471557617,
-0.6058860421180725,
-0.22267960011959076,
-0.2878052890300751,
0.7741746306419373,
-0.6252620816230774,
-0.28100982308387756,
-0.09961612522602081,
-0.43442201614379883,
-0.1723429262638092,
-0.6547557711601257,
0.7059441804885864,
-0.20392583310604095,
0.11937721818685532,
-0.3171018660068512,
-0.3814087510108948,
-0.11886083334684372,
0.5300683379173279,
-0.6776803731918335,
0.7500184774398804,
0.03640860691666603,
-0.4418543875217438,
0.48872247338294983,
-0.6092298626899719,
-0.06276578456163406,
-0.03862132504582405,
-0.4870516359806061,
-0.562177300453186,
0.33773910999298096,
0.5329676866531372,
0.19379529356956482,
-0.35955309867858887,
0.3287178575992584,
-0.8183859586715698,
0.00650787353515625,
0.7436099648475647,
-0.6991803050041199,
0.6511675119400024,
0.1544618010520935,
0.0335509367287159,
0.19697482883930206,
-0.8565754294395447,
-0.011830714531242847,
0.1603817343711853,
0.24809734523296356,
-0.29343998432159424,
-0.12342589348554611,
-0.16288548707962036,
0.4401576519012451,
0.2406136393547058,
-0.3725520670413971,
0.2558836042881012,
0.04316376894712448,
0.4254399240016937,
0.8656483888626099,
-0.3322809040546417,
0.22164279222488403,
-0.3202052712440491,
0.5888698697090149,
0.3413086235523224,
0.5069688558578491,
-0.3793242573738098,
-0.8511683344841003,
-0.7470952868461609,
-0.36382877826690674,
0.13943347334861755,
0.4727267920970917,
-0.8898792862892151,
-0.2194618135690689,
-0.36718204617500305,
-0.3660835325717926,
-0.3073810935020447,
0.09657333046197891,
0.18962551653385162,
0.5031508207321167,
0.23636890947818756,
-0.25211864709854126,
-0.2731781601905823,
-1.0461117029190063,
-0.2836887836456299,
0.3036366403102875,
0.009829415008425713,
0.7008508443832397,
0.8306004405021667,
-0.31150519847869873,
1.0276930332183838,
-0.8447977900505066,
-0.4423045217990875,
0.23328223824501038,
0.17776551842689514,
0.10243602842092514,
0.23907755315303802,
0.5485622882843018,
-0.885380208492279,
-0.16296561062335968,
-0.13503693044185638,
-1.0564346313476562,
-0.24659444391727448,
0.04751455411314964,
-0.2619421184062958,
-0.23205813765525818,
0.18307086825370789,
-0.5131407976150513,
0.7566774487495422,
0.4410378038883209,
-0.5643758177757263,
0.6637138724327087,
-0.06047063693404198,
0.056375544518232346,
-0.6975330114364624,
-0.057224106043577194,
0.35016635060310364,
-0.02764669619500637,
-0.22049061954021454,
-0.12104988843202591,
0.15050557255744934,
-0.2346508949995041,
-0.28820037841796875,
0.5241988301277161,
-0.21158729493618011,
-0.3298294246196747,
0.3859020173549652,
0.0790928453207016,
0.2006339579820633,
0.5609170794487,
-0.19270184636116028,
0.6539030075073242,
0.7154669761657715,
-0.25109976530075073,
0.8557273745536804,
0.19721738994121552,
-0.5278001427650452,
1.0390524864196777,
-0.6278895139694214,
-0.14958785474300385,
-0.1817113161087036,
0.20827341079711914,
-0.9204515218734741,
-0.5106337070465088,
0.24684631824493408,
-0.5529915690422058,
-0.2858569920063019,
0.04962417855858803,
-0.4483662247657776,
-0.263952374458313,
-0.21757946908473969,
1.0228173732757568,
0.077235147356987,
-0.3381592333316803,
0.778534471988678,
0.23421289026737213,
-0.0738157108426094,
-0.501728355884552,
-0.4514915943145752,
0.09673692286014557,
-0.13172897696495056,
-0.9907886981964111,
-0.00941516924649477,
-0.23285171389579773,
-0.6391910314559937,
0.029722880572080612,
-0.09713664650917053,
-0.2502588927745819,
-0.11187325417995453,
0.24924792349338531,
0.47237157821655273,
-0.2794700562953949,
0.05548211187124252,
-0.07056912034749985,
-0.16168653964996338,
0.43011072278022766,
-0.10812953859567642,
0.18518878519535065,
-0.2923180162906647,
-0.8409482836723328,
-0.2848009169101715,
0.2921328544616699,
0.9357197284698486,
-0.6280926465988159,
0.2690923511981964,
0.5645840764045715,
-0.5659477114677429,
-0.09797067940235138,
-0.38994982838630676,
0.04571592062711716,
-0.3510286211967468,
0.2675371766090393,
-0.5632720589637756,
-0.6494694352149963,
0.5873246192932129,
0.12484562397003174,
-0.057967379689216614,
0.4539165794849396,
0.41515490412712097,
-0.1212800145149231,
1.4114484786987305,
0.09422262758016586,
0.5833980441093445,
0.30422842502593994,
-0.31114324927330017,
-0.218624547123909,
-0.556164026260376,
-0.610654890537262,
-0.19865697622299194,
-0.3905748128890991,
-0.060288205742836,
-0.8269488215446472,
0.8092430830001831,
-0.20494070649147034,
-0.06823348253965378,
-0.08201730251312256,
-0.193141371011734,
0.5191448330879211,
0.6251201629638672,
0.22426384687423706,
0.33202463388442993,
0.05967902019619942,
-0.3261973559856415,
-0.5166074633598328,
-0.561706006526947,
0.028710009530186653,
1.1719028949737549,
0.21443545818328857,
0.6714900135993958,
0.35428833961486816,
0.19875818490982056,
0.16791518032550812,
0.06143612042069435,
-0.7072722315788269,
0.46691733598709106,
-0.012592766433954239,
-0.6645746231079102,
-0.18051770329475403,
-0.914271354675293,
-0.7212108373641968,
0.4802694320678711,
-0.40476521849632263,
-0.29232069849967957,
0.10156312584877014,
0.062183309346437454,
-0.4712037146091461,
0.17628252506256104,
-0.5800453424453735,
1.2803013324737549,
-0.41025471687316895,
-0.5483962893486023,
-0.30323317646980286,
-0.478574275970459,
0.6742414832115173,
-0.15654094517230988,
0.3896597623825073,
-0.2288534939289093,
0.00714789517223835,
0.5365359783172607,
-0.44452419877052307,
0.7061964273452759,
-0.07129468768835068,
-0.13694074749946594,
0.2232939749956131,
0.13721179962158203,
0.0665520429611206,
0.3282564878463745,
0.49016261100769043,
0.3414238393306732,
0.09961121529340744,
-0.5063534379005432,
-0.8237599730491638,
0.45432695746421814,
-0.6654809713363647,
-0.24724848568439484,
-0.6433811187744141,
-0.7914676666259766,
-0.4865202307701111,
0.16833576560020447,
0.13649700582027435,
1.0850781202316284,
0.1760707050561905,
0.3775092661380768,
0.6563327312469482,
-0.208499014377594,
0.18308444321155548,
-0.0832904651761055,
-0.34671077132225037,
-0.6497801542282104,
1.0990315675735474,
0.22212275862693787,
0.09141863137483597,
0.2823145389556885,
0.2010347545146942,
-0.5935903787612915,
-0.19824804365634918,
-0.6868053674697876,
0.16842956840991974,
-0.8589207530021667,
-0.23239611089229584,
-0.28693222999572754,
-0.014642063528299332,
-0.12933437526226044,
0.10928397625684738,
-0.37452763319015503,
-0.5194609761238098,
-0.2590195834636688,
0.37177738547325134,
0.019200002774596214,
0.4414614140987396,
0.00002923157808254473,
-0.1291389763355255,
-0.8080699443817139,
0.5496659278869629,
0.7133884429931641,
0.5026808381080627,
-0.33987829089164734,
-0.3172853887081146,
-0.12528623640537262,
0.2937306761741638,
-0.41211462020874023,
-0.38341662287712097,
0.21468272805213928,
0.09074083715677261,
0.5067737102508545,
0.4622761607170105,
-0.17844632267951965,
1.0519262552261353,
-0.2910127639770508,
0.5764148831367493,
0.5155876278877258,
-0.8826266527175903,
0.4522397518157959,
-0.4646500051021576,
0.48454371094703674,
0.28617480397224426,
-0.02755722962319851,
-0.22843004763126373,
0.024412058293819427,
-0.3802572786808014,
-0.343944787979126,
0.34498947858810425,
0.37283575534820557,
-0.1924043744802475,
0.2333311289548874,
-0.0017552257049828768,
0.05696495994925499,
0.16229930520057678,
-0.45663997530937195,
-0.06663312762975693,
-0.3864932060241699,
-0.37075573205947876,
-0.1194164976477623,
0.17757421731948853,
-0.3695809543132782,
-0.5280328392982483,
0.03569760173559189,
-0.1811838150024414,
0.06823538988828659,
-0.05114101245999336,
-0.3320464491844177,
-0.012340355664491653,
-0.0383187010884285,
1.0686132907867432,
1.2297990322113037,
0.023276669904589653,
0.27946773171424866,
0.06253135949373245,
-0.5696927309036255,
-0.09804533421993256,
0.15582484006881714,
0.20959213376045227,
-0.14224596321582794,
0.5143056511878967,
0.6788227558135986,
0.395629346370697,
-1.0645495653152466,
0.6488409042358398,
-0.3041594326496124,
-0.45739635825157166,
-0.36492589116096497,
-0.10379611700773239,
-0.15288428962230682,
0.45382723212242126,
0.3702320456504822,
0.6600802540779114,
0.08313624560832977,
-0.3024902641773224,
0.20685982704162598,
0.364205002784729,
-0.11974712461233139,
-0.308234304189682,
0.8758800029754639,
0.18742094933986664,
0.03860855475068092,
0.6878385543823242,
0.05972050875425339,
-0.40126273036003113,
0.6799096465110779,
0.015960657969117165,
0.520213782787323,
0.22985225915908813,
0.15485720336437225,
0.4412549138069153,
0.1719246804714203,
-0.0797472670674324,
0.22373439371585846,
-0.14932182431221008,
-0.7566568851470947,
-0.663025438785553,
-0.35136884450912476,
-0.5562934279441833,
-0.2678239047527313,
-0.7589685916900635,
0.21040058135986328,
-0.2866867780685425,
-0.2806627154350281,
0.20508112013339996,
-0.29533112049102783,
-0.7097219228744507,
0.16569574177265167,
0.3662259876728058,
0.6440964341163635,
-0.6558917760848999,
0.4526579678058624,
0.6959269642829895,
-0.35903897881507874,
-0.2501157522201538,
-0.6127004623413086,
0.22276486456394196,
-0.9559436440467834,
0.7407860159873962,
0.27456146478652954,
-0.22988484799861908,
-0.2816193699836731,
-0.4804920256137848,
-0.5699359178543091,
0.9978488683700562,
0.4045909345149994,
-0.645444393157959,
0.05463796481490135,
0.3312397301197052,
0.26410529017448425,
-0.14425407350063324,
0.1791088879108429,
0.09844833612442017,
0.47818413376808167,
0.18228527903556824,
-0.8916621804237366,
-0.5611868500709534,
-0.46387019753456116,
-0.09612367302179337,
0.3923313617706299,
-0.45051634311676025,
0.9764659404754639,
-0.31315869092941284,
0.03129369020462036,
-0.07087874412536621,
0.5230731964111328,
0.5956287384033203,
0.9299551844596863,
0.691391110420227,
1.0192441940307617,
0.5310143828392029,
-0.4068126976490021,
0.763326108455658,
0.14004039764404297,
0.42214277386665344,
0.6624404788017273,
-0.14059793949127197,
0.4652560353279114,
0.3832874596118927,
-0.20846706628799438,
0.20122675597667694,
0.47799181938171387,
-0.07380768656730652,
0.27831774950027466,
0.20258499681949615,
-0.2517545521259308,
-0.9869190454483032,
-0.11249437928199768,
-0.5220808982849121,
0.6289865970611572,
0.4290235638618469,
0.0684053972363472,
-0.32544267177581787,
0.2253783643245697,
-0.307156503200531,
0.18185988068580627,
-0.4766566753387451,
0.15968996286392212,
0.03416172042489052,
-0.5844094753265381,
0.16533882915973663,
-0.30827614665031433,
0.4675433337688446,
-0.49873319268226624,
-0.3981953561306,
-0.296742707490921,
0.4348393976688385,
-0.05407717823982239,
-1.0180103778839111,
0.14344224333763123,
-0.04975967854261398,
-0.21788685023784637,
-0.2629680633544922,
0.46585896611213684,
-0.17553569376468658,
-0.8124751448631287,
-0.14803077280521393,
0.7956862449645996,
-0.06663601100444794,
-0.2674757242202759,
-0.6230257749557495,
0.29888612031936646,
-0.29051971435546875,
0.12401667982339859,
0.326788991689682,
0.798044741153717,
-0.3597244918346405,
0.8608073592185974,
0.9012541770935059,
-0.3114013075828552,
0.3477952182292938,
0.23619189858436584,
0.7834900617599487,
-0.6842482089996338,
-0.37724608182907104,
-0.9513779282569885,
0.5529869198799133,
-0.17833231389522552,
-0.8345503211021423,
0.9702416658401489,
0.7897944450378418,
0.9570322632789612,
-0.24391163885593414,
0.46701735258102417,
0.40546345710754395,
0.18749789893627167,
-0.41324955224990845,
0.1864299476146698,
-0.8612381219863892,
0.12180715799331665,
-0.3659016788005829,
-0.8035822510719299,
-0.7290782928466797,
0.7161722779273987,
-0.2896675765514374,
-0.036431752145290375,
0.48100966215133667,
0.49702632427215576,
-0.37285763025283813,
-0.11172942817211151,
0.49994370341300964,
-0.20423243939876556,
0.19516359269618988,
0.8388296961784363,
1.309159517288208,
-0.11625099927186966,
0.8330811262130737,
-0.38360273838043213,
-0.3007754683494568,
-0.24213378131389618,
-0.6840975880622864,
-0.870132565498352,
-0.5034670233726501,
-0.34407809376716614,
-0.2604246139526367,
-0.4614540636539459,
0.6162179708480835,
0.6101807951927185,
-0.45932385325431824,
-0.09411216527223587,
0.06962913274765015,
0.13991911709308624,
-0.34198540449142456,
-0.17486733198165894,
0.020496144890785217,
-0.018348481506109238,
-0.6783201694488525,
0.08787097036838531,
0.4383450448513031,
-0.03810245543718338,
-0.42243000864982605,
-0.07121537625789642,
0.22816325724124908,
-0.08461924642324448,
0.922078013420105,
0.10379882901906967,
-0.7370147109031677,
-0.05350177362561226,
0.4962642192840576,
0.027927057817578316,
-0.007812589406967163,
0.8985322117805481,
-0.6163874864578247,
0.8542106747627258,
0.562433660030365,
0.6322509050369263,
0.4633897542953491,
-0.18981783092021942,
0.2948620319366455,
-0.4936777353286743,
-0.06947705894708633,
0.32636865973472595,
0.6414490938186646,
0.12593480944633484,
0.18195149302482605,
0.5226484537124634,
0.8114920854568481,
-0.2889561951160431,
-1.0620349645614624,
0.38136208057403564,
-1.2680280208587646,
-0.10370998829603195,
0.906230092048645,
0.04702453687787056,
-0.07745672762393951,
0.10446566343307495,
-0.33303162455558777,
-0.26296287775039673,
-0.2122332751750946,
0.598917543888092,
0.9631423354148865,
-0.24953757226467133,
-0.4053676724433899,
-0.8125051856040955,
0.05934714898467064,
0.48205167055130005,
-0.9146836400032043,
-0.18792779743671417,
0.979684054851532,
-0.013312282972037792,
0.2844679057598114,
0.09276754409074783,
-0.1778847873210907,
0.647299587726593,
0.22479568421840668,
-0.23215743899345398,
-0.3564531207084656,
-0.590852677822113,
-0.2665296792984009,
0.38836824893951416,
-0.45290008187294006,
-0.25655674934387207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14800v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14800v2
|
Not All Experts are Equal: Efficient Expert Pruning and Skipping for Mixture-of-Experts Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T18:56:07 | 2024-05-30T16:24:16 |
Xudong Lu, Qi Liu, Yuhui Xu, Aojun Zhou, Siyuan Huang, Bo Zhang, Junchi Yan, Hongsheng Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
A pivotal advancement in the progress of large language models (LLMs) is the
emergence of the Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) LLMs. Compared to traditional LLMs,
MoE LLMs can achieve higher performance with fewer parameters, but it is still
hard to deploy them due to their immense parameter sizes. Different from
previous weight pruning methods that rely on specifically designed hardware,
this paper mainly aims to enhance the deployment efficiency of MoE LLMs by
introducing plug-and-play expert-level sparsification techniques. Specifically,
we propose, for the first time to our best knowledge, post-training approaches
for task-agnostic and task-specific expert pruning and skipping of MoE LLMs,
tailored to improve deployment efficiency while maintaining model performance
across a wide range of tasks. Extensive experiments show that our proposed
methods can simultaneously reduce model sizes and increase the inference speed,
while maintaining satisfactory performance. Data and code will be available at
https://github.com/Lucky-Lance/Expert_Sparsity.
|
[
-0.7117215394973755,
-0.6625373959541321,
0.346493661403656,
0.43652093410491943,
-0.23278063535690308,
0.3909551501274109,
-0.37943246960639954,
-0.13201768696308136,
0.19156400859355927,
0.3540818691253662,
-0.478747695684433,
-0.26809853315353394,
-0.879885733127594,
-0.096750408411026,
-0.3971351087093353,
0.7335628867149353,
0.16568560898303986,
-0.19962069392204285,
-0.18614885210990906,
0.019723590463399887,
-0.5644200444221497,
-0.34051743149757385,
-0.5683103799819946,
-0.19757337868213654,
0.47161805629730225,
0.3824261724948883,
0.6606596112251282,
0.7566291689872742,
0.21749863028526306,
0.30282145738601685,
-0.3232998251914978,
0.6880217790603638,
-0.6828126311302185,
-0.07617861777544022,
-0.09863872826099396,
-0.3200363516807556,
-0.6277242302894592,
-0.2129947394132614,
0.47824597358703613,
0.730717122554779,
-0.42785751819610596,
-0.24216441810131073,
0.13986220955848694,
0.378398060798645,
-0.7257484793663025,
-0.2283337563276291,
-0.8550580739974976,
-0.09097881615161896,
-0.12600034475326538,
-0.5446380376815796,
-0.4111529290676117,
-0.17118176817893982,
-0.05366833508014679,
-0.762528121471405,
0.3797413408756256,
0.21471832692623138,
0.5797004103660583,
0.42014259099960327,
-0.39395877718925476,
0.18457619845867157,
-0.7233551144599915,
1.025485634803772,
-0.9065946340560913,
0.3660234808921814,
0.1802895963191986,
-0.0794094130396843,
-0.4108599126338959,
-0.01597335748374462,
-0.2800152003765106,
-0.03977265581488609,
0.17608393728733063,
-0.10634848475456238,
-0.028488889336586,
0.09421003609895706,
-0.022261492908000946,
0.27659496665000916,
-0.5298936367034912,
0.4014418125152588,
-0.3950803279876709,
-0.14029626548290253,
0.8019195795059204,
-0.043145861476659775,
0.08537553995847702,
0.41886791586875916,
-0.27736806869506836,
0.2800913453102112,
-0.968948245048523,
-0.37841930985450745,
0.4155626595020294,
0.000764742901083082,
0.3257925510406494,
0.3848177194595337,
-0.15145006775856018,
1.0008487701416016,
0.20236913859844208,
-0.3737452030181885,
0.11655198782682419,
-0.09184560924768448,
-0.05655806139111519,
-0.2570154368877411,
0.6715537309646606,
0.1913345605134964,
0.4591095745563507,
-0.5296144485473633,
-0.379901647567749,
-0.1953618973493576,
0.3330342471599579,
-0.4807036519050598,
-0.5606231093406677,
-0.006930620409548283,
-0.17553257942199707,
-0.2864415645599365,
-0.17000122368335724,
-0.48907992243766785,
-0.365273118019104,
-0.2568057179450989,
0.4327433109283447,
-0.4652494490146637,
-0.7272174954414368,
0.15351596474647522,
-0.11044913530349731,
-0.14917220175266266,
0.41641977429389954,
-0.8015339970588684,
0.5175809860229492,
1.0218886137008667,
0.6235246658325195,
-0.3369901180267334,
-0.4396006166934967,
-0.7133179306983948,
0.23264837265014648,
-0.4879774749279022,
0.63222736120224,
-0.5364044904708862,
-0.5868231654167175,
-0.16068759560585022,
-0.38891127705574036,
-0.20140771567821503,
-0.7860512137413025,
0.299575537443161,
-0.6682623624801636,
-0.19005592167377472,
-0.15386341512203217,
-0.6585434675216675,
-0.22868289053440094,
0.12625157833099365,
-0.09027523547410965,
1.2686704397201538,
0.07356256991624832,
-0.4612312316894531,
0.4982462525367737,
-0.08711345493793488,
-0.7626275420188904,
0.07172034680843353,
-0.16716891527175903,
-0.2124980092048645,
0.48766815662384033,
0.399532288312912,
0.6078104972839355,
-0.10428575426340103,
0.631848931312561,
-0.2727779448032379,
-0.4805395007133484,
0.1019764244556427,
-0.292594313621521,
0.387189656496048,
0.19416601955890656,
-0.27004554867744446,
-0.0227557010948658,
-0.6460559368133545,
-0.044881127774715424,
0.008386935107409954,
-0.42819881439208984,
-0.47371917963027954,
0.3184297978878021,
0.030727263540029526,
0.2103283703327179,
0.19264157116413116,
-0.2520126402378082,
0.1530310958623886,
-0.2745579779148102,
0.3253122568130493,
0.8855639100074768,
-0.10782671719789505,
0.4853249490261078,
-0.3681698739528656,
0.49331170320510864,
0.08704317361116409,
-0.07348830252885818,
-0.0885048657655716,
-0.5559824109077454,
-0.9332963228225708,
-0.575330376625061,
0.3156629800796509,
0.4874495267868042,
-0.6432667970657349,
0.941806435585022,
-0.3492133617401123,
-0.5611376166343689,
-0.5999681949615479,
0.6524004936218262,
0.5458289384841919,
0.4083508551120758,
0.33463284373283386,
-0.43073585629463196,
-0.3437475562095642,
-0.9235334396362305,
-0.5320677757263184,
-0.08629713952541351,
-0.07585161179304123,
0.20189258456230164,
0.18422573804855347,
0.11004294455051422,
1.3017131090164185,
-0.429054319858551,
-0.0012967779766768217,
-0.3226121962070465,
0.239572212100029,
-0.014270599000155926,
0.754325270652771,
0.5600685477256775,
-0.5835459232330322,
-0.4256752133369446,
0.05840006843209267,
-0.24948012828826904,
-0.29409828782081604,
0.07586807757616043,
-0.15465670824050903,
0.018686048686504364,
0.3490872085094452,
-0.7200770974159241,
0.19670924544334412,
0.3419179320335388,
0.036188554018735886,
0.43390288949012756,
-0.31235161423683167,
0.09510577470064163,
-0.78190016746521,
-0.008973022922873497,
0.3825939893722534,
-0.46006903052330017,
-0.7850676774978638,
0.16627202928066254,
-0.04652106389403343,
0.16868020594120026,
-0.25543612241744995,
0.48490285873413086,
-0.6769431233406067,
-0.13372419774532318,
-0.2744148373603821,
-0.010271528735756874,
-0.0237672571092844,
0.6166095733642578,
0.2411065250635147,
0.8553897738456726,
0.657471776008606,
-0.8551559448242188,
0.04908664897084236,
0.016438666731119156,
-0.22599071264266968,
0.4109383523464203,
-0.6461486220359802,
0.1056923195719719,
0.002349706832319498,
-0.020128998905420303,
-0.9122653603553772,
-0.15780919790267944,
0.22949863970279694,
-0.3156629502773285,
0.6405208706855774,
-0.2718771696090698,
-0.5507851243019104,
-0.2232443392276764,
-0.08850138634443283,
0.35562801361083984,
0.870247483253479,
-0.31853288412094116,
0.5791507959365845,
0.506978452205658,
-0.551250159740448,
-0.6251145005226135,
-0.6958616971969604,
0.08360464125871658,
-0.33112165331840515,
-0.4998570382595062,
0.16922958195209503,
-0.19268636405467987,
-0.1629216969013214,
-0.16820792853832245,
-0.3255258798599243,
-0.3461500406265259,
0.3606748878955841,
-0.25622621178627014,
0.04448939487338066,
-0.003209862392395735,
0.07295779138803482,
0.2641715407371521,
-0.17000365257263184,
-0.16572992503643036,
-0.15156544744968414,
0.3268910050392151,
0.34020349383354187,
-0.6144065260887146,
-0.2150149643421173,
0.26423513889312744,
0.23530460894107819,
-0.34925082325935364,
0.6456472277641296,
0.6859328150749207,
-0.1572904735803604,
-0.2651941478252411,
-1.2894625663757324,
-0.1153588742017746,
-0.46186619997024536,
0.5669443011283875,
-0.24549217522144318,
-0.8807576894760132,
0.18518313765525818,
-0.12014938145875931,
0.5294528007507324,
0.1728631854057312,
0.39906859397888184,
0.06583134829998016,
0.9968679547309875,
0.7771390080451965,
-0.43416711688041687,
0.30874690413475037,
0.020032107830047607,
0.3694252371788025,
-0.498756468296051,
0.028828738257288933,
-0.536743700504303,
-0.2027919739484787,
0.1781352162361145,
-0.6625711917877197,
0.3052861988544464,
0.24995160102844238,
-0.07341735064983368,
0.04627630114555359,
-0.6286047697067261,
0.42018890380859375,
0.3813016712665558,
0.18992109596729279,
0.2866058349609375,
0.27554237842559814,
0.40562427043914795,
0.0806286558508873,
-1.1718469858169556,
-0.1986493468284607,
0.9630944132804871,
0.3688097298145294,
0.6597719192504883,
-0.24235287308692932,
0.7243241667747498,
0.1846713423728943,
0.28253301978111267,
-0.7155646085739136,
0.7401984930038452,
-0.06605195254087448,
-0.5506110787391663,
-0.2628297507762909,
-0.6890934705734253,
-0.5799623727798462,
0.43846267461776733,
-0.06504727154970169,
-0.4742812216281891,
0.28432315587997437,
0.41454461216926575,
-0.5446920394897461,
0.3791373372077942,
-0.708551287651062,
0.5387400984764099,
-0.0517185740172863,
-0.1719905138015747,
-0.6277464628219604,
-0.3743874430656433,
0.3778485059738159,
-0.23737798631191254,
0.5524325966835022,
-0.2328784167766571,
-0.5228080749511719,
0.8216465711593628,
-0.7300763130187988,
0.7340512871742249,
-0.36835944652557373,
-0.0020675486885011196,
0.2569744288921356,
0.2628207802772522,
0.6397050023078918,
-0.42858394980430603,
0.06141921132802963,
0.012744627892971039,
-0.5923662781715393,
-0.5856113433837891,
-0.48733431100845337,
0.7934130430221558,
-0.7892711162567139,
-0.6982837915420532,
0.11875841021537781,
-0.6192787885665894,
-0.40303388237953186,
0.10183940082788467,
0.11817318201065063,
0.5466883778572083,
0.04051244631409645,
0.10328899323940277,
1.0980091094970703,
-0.022242195904254913,
0.27242791652679443,
0.5642952919006348,
0.14939053356647491,
-0.36710065603256226,
1.2134824991226196,
0.43559473752975464,
0.09174191206693649,
0.21345968544483185,
-0.1815200001001358,
0.04006663337349892,
-1.148597002029419,
-0.35208913683891296,
0.1645907610654831,
-0.42016905546188354,
-0.12892352044582367,
-0.9100610017776489,
0.03308839350938797,
-0.3987935781478882,
-0.3940555155277252,
-0.5157989859580994,
-0.41080260276794434,
-0.39255937933921814,
-0.05822199955582619,
0.5723884701728821,
0.751585841178894,
0.07553600519895554,
0.8015918731689453,
-0.8490187525749207,
0.01752057671546936,
0.1938023865222931,
0.3187516927719116,
0.2428344190120697,
-0.6198577284812927,
-0.5174402594566345,
-0.21130187809467316,
-0.2183934599161148,
-0.6422604918479919,
0.508693516254425,
0.3363859951496124,
0.8776830434799194,
0.5243391990661621,
-0.16492930054664612,
0.9020594358444214,
-0.4293995201587677,
0.6243162751197815,
0.2657482624053955,
-0.8039493560791016,
0.10691627115011215,
-0.46306437253952026,
-0.0026726156938821077,
0.46017757058143616,
0.41172027587890625,
-0.2917560338973999,
-0.6478244662284851,
-0.5902903079986572,
-1.1308157444000244,
0.737341046333313,
-0.022853316739201546,
-0.050135623663663864,
0.08425400406122208,
0.21509069204330444,
0.4464177191257477,
0.48022380471229553,
-0.3789956867694855,
-0.19013866782188416,
0.25925412774086,
-0.23108118772506714,
-0.38690319657325745,
-0.40519988536834717,
-0.15671207010746002,
-0.17499352991580963,
0.9522217512130737,
0.1036553755402565,
-0.08086040616035461,
0.018371880054473877,
-0.5820825099945068,
-0.12647995352745056,
0.1976873129606247,
0.33442139625549316,
0.9505963921546936,
0.08027032017707825,
-0.06387932598590851,
0.3561970293521881,
-0.11400740593671799,
0.11865131556987762,
0.06379348039627075,
-0.07261723279953003,
0.22058838605880737,
0.3012899160385132,
0.6749224066734314,
0.6456717848777771,
-0.5535110235214233,
0.4776347279548645,
0.3807814419269562,
-0.4119207262992859,
-0.07798559963703156,
0.37077510356903076,
0.16912618279457092,
-0.07029365748167038,
0.6959041953086853,
0.4424878656864166,
0.10376229882240295,
-0.06159161776304245,
-0.014811583794653416,
0.2556159496307373,
0.04913422465324402,
-0.2505222260951996,
0.4725213348865509,
0.41803115606307983,
-0.2604578733444214,
0.34155523777008057,
-0.08940668404102325,
-0.32844361662864685,
0.5781840682029724,
-0.027018669992685318,
0.6026584506034851,
-0.5311610698699951,
-0.007553162518888712,
0.004577540792524815,
0.43598926067352295,
-0.385467529296875,
0.07858623564243317,
-0.2235175222158432,
-0.5513713359832764,
-0.7964956164360046,
-0.2796555459499359,
-0.20192879438400269,
-0.200178325176239,
-0.47165605425834656,
0.15056639909744263,
-0.47906193137168884,
-0.0915403664112091,
-0.2682766020298004,
-0.24640163779258728,
-0.7434095144271851,
0.17087134718894958,
0.06867639720439911,
1.177211880683899,
-1.015261173248291,
0.5972996354103088,
0.7628462910652161,
0.1468372792005539,
-0.7306346297264099,
-0.27921295166015625,
-0.1626102775335312,
-0.5823537111282349,
0.2639694809913635,
0.018002068623900414,
0.1762886345386505,
0.21763423085212708,
-0.3916272222995758,
-0.6451930999755859,
0.664806604385376,
0.2167385071516037,
-0.7680543065071106,
-0.11931096017360687,
-0.18726764619350433,
0.18179099261760712,
-0.2656989097595215,
0.5905740857124329,
0.6918712258338928,
0.5921019911766052,
-0.026396041736006737,
-1.1157983541488647,
-0.2652784287929535,
-0.3323570787906647,
0.05817801505327225,
0.14191463589668274,
-0.647565484046936,
0.6713712215423584,
0.18050314486026764,
0.2752801179885864,
0.05628092586994171,
0.7901549935340881,
0.34379294514656067,
0.1378248929977417,
0.8691890835762024,
0.6461630463600159,
0.6641548871994019,
-0.04963555559515953,
0.7166612148284912,
-0.43567657470703125,
0.0791623443365097,
0.7729552388191223,
-0.16317607462406158,
0.6965025067329407,
0.4526926875114441,
-0.26642993092536926,
0.040503352880477905,
0.7281786203384399,
0.10014507919549942,
0.4296879768371582,
0.05812842398881912,
-0.18013860285282135,
-0.7096936702728271,
0.16946883499622345,
-0.40163281559944153,
-0.10258029401302338,
0.4492717385292053,
-0.021143615245819092,
-0.19463184475898743,
-0.011941486038267612,
0.12884338200092316,
-0.03088269755244255,
-0.504489004611969,
0.8522844910621643,
0.09774482995271683,
-0.7710142731666565,
0.7246279716491699,
0.04177249222993851,
1.147894263267517,
-0.5955590605735779,
0.3185451328754425,
-0.024250611662864685,
0.005452514626085758,
-0.45656582713127136,
-0.5971736311912537,
0.12124446779489517,
-0.040549684315919876,
-0.10310382395982742,
-0.36159446835517883,
0.7486438751220703,
-0.6251434087753296,
-0.35037335753440857,
0.14433163404464722,
0.790688693523407,
0.5230492353439331,
-0.13613316416740417,
-0.5377658009529114,
-0.005784207955002785,
-0.050679150968790054,
-0.5827054977416992,
0.5248096585273743,
0.4017395079135895,
0.1233011856675148,
0.863301157951355,
0.29992246627807617,
0.2898716628551483,
0.3969763219356537,
-0.11941631138324738,
1.1556869745254517,
-0.21071141958236694,
-0.4727061092853546,
-0.7066678404808044,
0.7791522145271301,
-0.0019604447297751904,
-0.1863357126712799,
0.7376117706298828,
0.5504428148269653,
0.7269364595413208,
-0.08487450331449509,
0.8457807302474976,
0.07559184730052948,
0.694983720779419,
-0.19278056919574738,
0.4655703902244568,
-0.7901343703269958,
0.17253200709819794,
-0.3715887665748596,
-0.9168764352798462,
-0.1216605007648468,
0.32819801568984985,
-0.44849538803100586,
0.3970460593700409,
0.11787330359220505,
0.9082573652267456,
-0.3573101758956909,
-0.2902567982673645,
0.37243908643722534,
0.24619224667549133,
0.24086813628673553,
0.3288712203502655,
0.6843446493148804,
0.1010843962430954,
0.5688602924346924,
-0.25577065348625183,
-0.4483199417591095,
-0.5603554844856262,
-0.7160281538963318,
-0.8224649429321289,
-0.19110207259655,
-0.6056816577911377,
0.2788669466972351,
0.3563930094242096,
1.0140316486358643,
1.1462548971176147,
-0.5631350874900818,
-0.2624545991420746,
-0.2036357969045639,
0.07594297081232071,
-0.2763151228427887,
-0.16571363806724548,
0.027497857809066772,
-0.3926718831062317,
-0.615997314453125,
0.7792178392410278,
0.21904195845127106,
-0.3081192672252655,
-0.41776078939437866,
-0.14842164516448975,
-0.053346868604421616,
0.008058865554630756,
0.3421691358089447,
0.2806965112686157,
-0.7263346910476685,
0.14465229213237762,
-0.25801047682762146,
0.17540717124938965,
0.07872351258993149,
0.8476490378379822,
-0.7502579092979431,
0.17528486251831055,
0.5172948837280273,
0.7135648131370544,
0.07842668890953064,
0.0783587247133255,
0.8548446297645569,
-0.8727515935897827,
0.3888954520225525,
0.3042922616004944,
0.4142340421676636,
0.2738139033317566,
-0.4089982211589813,
0.3488263487815857,
0.3357354700565338,
-0.5960598587989807,
-1.0202242136001587,
-0.010534139350056648,
-0.6595956683158875,
-0.22894656658172607,
1.0291898250579834,
-0.4159705638885498,
-0.09160985797643661,
-0.3401627838611603,
-0.245727077126503,
0.08850155770778656,
-0.6011243462562561,
0.5684341192245483,
0.7051621079444885,
0.27139580249786377,
-0.33995041251182556,
-0.5098201036453247,
0.136911079287529,
0.9325941205024719,
-0.40995368361473083,
0.06582282483577728,
0.37855589389801025,
0.4675711989402771,
-0.10258281975984573,
0.7283634543418884,
0.2428550124168396,
0.20585229992866516,
-0.1364295482635498,
0.4183878004550934,
-0.47419288754463196,
-0.49465641379356384,
-0.35442066192626953,
0.10635825991630554,
0.4139886796474457,
0.17069707810878754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14904v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14904v1
|
Watermarking Makes Language Models Radioactive
| 2024-02-22T18:55:22 | 2024-02-22T18:55:22 |
Tom Sander, Pierre Fernandez, Alain Durmus, Matthijs Douze, Teddy Furon
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper investigates the radioactivity of LLM-generated texts, i.e.
whether it is possible to detect that such input was used as training data.
Conventional methods like membership inference can carry out this detection
with some level of accuracy. We show that watermarked training data leaves
traces easier to detect and much more reliable than membership inference. We
link the contamination level to the watermark robustness, its proportion in the
training set, and the fine-tuning process. We notably demonstrate that training
on watermarked synthetic instructions can be detected with high confidence
(p-value < 1e-5) even when as little as 5% of training text is watermarked.
Thus, LLM watermarking, originally designed for detecting machine-generated
text, gives the ability to easily identify if the outputs of a watermarked LLM
were used to fine-tune another LLM.
|
[
-0.11524244397878647,
-0.6211931109428406,
0.7432153224945068,
-0.4082459509372711,
-0.3462088108062744,
0.1390790194272995,
0.037931278347969055,
-0.5312523245811462,
-0.08880797028541565,
0.7234644293785095,
-0.5396238565444946,
-0.42859071493148804,
-0.7952547073364258,
0.04770105332136154,
-0.6834089159965515,
0.7684507369995117,
0.1413244903087616,
0.1733146607875824,
-0.3636721074581146,
-0.22276277840137482,
0.08905738592147827,
-0.5558682084083557,
-0.5737851858139038,
-0.8787729144096375,
0.4186527132987976,
0.1113305613398552,
0.8109891414642334,
1.124969720840454,
0.06711021065711975,
0.33221349120140076,
-0.20342780649662018,
0.2442615032196045,
-0.6914792656898499,
0.18332521617412567,
0.018133699893951416,
-0.6419245004653931,
0.03242266923189163,
0.20868241786956787,
0.4523097276687622,
0.2979384958744049,
0.4271295666694641,
-0.20521180331707,
0.06209925562143326,
0.6995977163314819,
-0.7155420780181885,
0.325886070728302,
-0.8220203518867493,
-0.18673734366893768,
-0.26091885566711426,
-0.5952109098434448,
-0.7468996644020081,
-0.26937320828437805,
-0.2922838032245636,
-0.723044216632843,
0.206919327378273,
0.03243095800280571,
1.3043485879898071,
0.19795221090316772,
-0.0692000687122345,
-0.5470429062843323,
-0.8451759219169617,
1.000601887702942,
-0.8283712863922119,
0.23647521436214447,
0.9630542397499084,
-0.05584441497921944,
-0.32433223724365234,
-0.67668217420578,
-0.45027944445610046,
-0.22528034448623657,
-0.029556283727288246,
0.09222376346588135,
-0.14227117598056793,
0.10078591108322144,
0.41839638352394104,
0.47579917311668396,
-0.23272886872291565,
0.028077147901058197,
-0.10705290734767914,
-0.2651834189891815,
0.45943477749824524,
-0.0633862242102623,
0.7229764461517334,
0.08084145933389664,
-0.14303569495677948,
-0.2528831660747528,
-1.146615982055664,
-0.4497639238834381,
0.6355322599411011,
0.12350046634674072,
-0.08614169806241989,
0.607495903968811,
-0.2244909405708313,
0.537366509437561,
-0.43835335969924927,
-0.25078004598617554,
-0.27239030599594116,
-0.06195107847452164,
-0.3142131268978119,
0.018922584131360054,
0.8280172944068909,
-0.11548895388841629,
0.9036102890968323,
-0.2438458502292633,
-0.2992764115333557,
0.15551157295703888,
-0.008436532691121101,
-0.9013997316360474,
-0.5060579180717468,
-0.0700601190328598,
-0.3107307255268097,
-0.552788257598877,
0.05560287833213806,
0.03939186781644821,
-0.4123348593711853,
-0.22177675366401672,
0.6618024706840515,
-0.6780744791030884,
0.026936525478959084,
0.3644288182258606,
-0.28633397817611694,
0.05275971069931984,
0.15999631583690643,
-1.0124503374099731,
0.17355859279632568,
0.8528752326965332,
0.43652957677841187,
0.0417805053293705,
-0.03503013402223587,
-0.37604132294654846,
0.34867849946022034,
-0.2205577939748764,
0.9024549722671509,
-0.6601214408874512,
-0.2531987726688385,
-0.000013919400771555956,
-0.15932980179786682,
0.324628084897995,
-0.5758662819862366,
0.040269073098897934,
-0.8829923272132874,
0.48514753580093384,
-0.07244596630334854,
-0.920810878276825,
0.015063910745084286,
0.0702950656414032,
-0.8750216364860535,
1.1084462404251099,
0.16687606275081635,
-1.075610637664795,
0.4863254129886627,
0.05734847113490105,
-0.2305566817522049,
0.23129244148731232,
-0.3259330987930298,
-0.7648380994796753,
-0.10094600915908813,
-0.014613280072808266,
0.3024522662162781,
-0.21134144067764282,
0.2470792531967163,
-0.38661712408065796,
-0.6369630694389343,
0.7239322066307068,
-0.702680766582489,
0.8735386729240417,
0.005863775033503771,
-0.28751012682914734,
-0.19268149137496948,
-0.8190474510192871,
0.2638613283634186,
-0.09874889999628067,
-0.7758375406265259,
-0.6885641813278198,
0.22881987690925598,
-0.19214335083961487,
-0.09608234465122223,
-0.04215683043003082,
-0.4730522632598877,
-0.044518355280160904,
-0.30270323157310486,
0.4283652901649475,
0.6322132349014282,
0.3296412527561188,
0.11157277226448059,
-0.7237969040870667,
0.45862099528312683,
-0.34919023513793945,
0.040062300860881805,
-0.19228363037109375,
-0.669894278049469,
-0.8312560319900513,
-0.4976464807987213,
0.5675134658813477,
0.1912294179201126,
-0.9497376084327698,
0.38938966393470764,
-0.38545238971710205,
-0.3531523048877716,
-0.42369574308395386,
0.16614319384098053,
0.5350830554962158,
0.0869942232966423,
0.24004720151424408,
0.002905287779867649,
-0.3523537218570709,
-0.920147180557251,
-0.43707606196403503,
-0.4244621694087982,
-0.25913703441619873,
0.2925923466682434,
0.6096365451812744,
-0.11016103625297546,
0.8642394542694092,
-0.24657350778579712,
0.0029547426383942366,
-0.02783513255417347,
0.3582654595375061,
-0.18464091420173645,
0.5075147747993469,
0.27165108919143677,
-0.48400816321372986,
-0.4997584819793701,
-0.11428447812795639,
-0.9412933588027954,
-0.5080433487892151,
-0.1896691918373108,
0.09646967798471451,
-0.19069184362888336,
0.7721783518791199,
-0.22627152502536774,
0.4433947205543518,
0.6782034635543823,
-0.1230548769235611,
0.08921641856431961,
-0.21771934628486633,
0.17607152462005615,
-0.9259733557701111,
0.13294370472431183,
-0.42630472779273987,
-0.3928822875022888,
-0.49780988693237305,
0.10987050086259842,
0.06408828496932983,
-0.09204714000225067,
-0.4440019130706787,
0.36847707629203796,
-0.6383522152900696,
0.05867968127131462,
-0.6138630509376526,
-0.038790252059698105,
0.2640804350376129,
0.03610355779528618,
-0.03174283355474472,
0.8956002593040466,
0.26402613520622253,
-0.36180245876312256,
-0.0697038471698761,
0.031218968331813812,
-0.5126880407333374,
0.10602888464927673,
-0.5985296964645386,
0.31458863615989685,
-0.1483815461397171,
-0.1977533996105194,
-1.0244866609573364,
-0.026827240362763405,
-0.024374080821871758,
-0.4562332332134247,
0.40167978405952454,
-0.4422110617160797,
-0.5895512104034424,
0.44037941098213196,
-0.34014424681663513,
0.2843135595321655,
0.5333020687103271,
-0.3400133550167084,
0.5648804306983948,
0.2012985795736313,
0.384944885969162,
-0.5683407783508301,
-0.9482062458992004,
-0.036482177674770355,
-0.1460808515548706,
-0.41452622413635254,
0.44178709387779236,
0.10033879429101944,
-0.21319730579853058,
0.06429385393857956,
-0.12558875977993011,
-0.20511376857757568,
0.5297424793243408,
0.546038806438446,
0.09980247914791107,
-0.16230060160160065,
-0.161447212100029,
-0.0594610795378685,
-0.32270973920822144,
0.17320610582828522,
0.2079475373029709,
0.6197462677955627,
0.4442685842514038,
-0.3741919696331024,
-0.5728409290313721,
0.13205356895923615,
0.6125093102455139,
0.06194470077753067,
0.7070335149765015,
0.12239629775285721,
-0.5936371088027954,
-0.49165457487106323,
-0.41044148802757263,
-0.447361558675766,
-0.6041232347488403,
-0.02781902253627777,
0.014005213975906372,
-0.8660032153129578,
0.4443785846233368,
-0.04925258457660675,
-0.1508714109659195,
0.14084236323833466,
0.20185412466526031,
-0.22096681594848633,
0.6659723520278931,
0.6581571698188782,
-0.2582569122314453,
0.7627028226852417,
-0.22301657497882843,
-0.0007906621904112399,
-0.6004204750061035,
-0.1912621557712555,
-0.7793987393379211,
-0.042505260556936264,
-0.6603172421455383,
-0.4505017399787903,
0.10043766349554062,
0.18609493970870972,
-0.14509651064872742,
0.3285563290119171,
-0.3445250689983368,
0.8776032328605652,
0.3783864378929138,
0.22285513579845428,
0.5209795832633972,
0.29991376399993896,
-0.04423679783940315,
-0.2863667607307434,
-0.580874502658844,
-0.8167470693588257,
0.9037919640541077,
0.3215341567993164,
0.9691943526268005,
-0.2705550491809845,
1.102866530418396,
0.3935186564922333,
0.7931295037269592,
-0.7010993361473083,
0.5159456133842468,
-0.11542793363332748,
-0.7119195461273193,
-0.1459215134382248,
-0.47315019369125366,
-1.051012635231018,
-0.05653143301606178,
-0.49150991439819336,
-0.339950293302536,
-0.0919032096862793,
-0.10196177661418915,
0.18335695564746857,
0.3158843219280243,
-0.26876428723335266,
0.2619510889053345,
-0.1604294776916504,
-0.5236261487007141,
-0.20485800504684448,
-0.04627333581447601,
0.17536890506744385,
-0.13238632678985596,
0.3503938913345337,
-0.34998196363449097,
0.06291662156581879,
0.9250823855400085,
-0.35651522874832153,
0.900489866733551,
0.058525435626506805,
-0.23561760783195496,
0.16610319912433624,
0.48106980323791504,
0.4462032914161682,
0.0730980709195137,
-0.1747373342514038,
-0.017896229401230812,
-0.2192564308643341,
-0.2482501119375229,
-0.3811149299144745,
0.6396970748901367,
-0.7689689993858337,
-0.4642452597618103,
-0.6807956099510193,
-0.5672741532325745,
-0.10964392870664597,
0.6047828793525696,
0.45580044388771057,
0.3740251064300537,
-0.10096544772386551,
0.4086284935474396,
1.0488773584365845,
-0.43310555815696716,
0.4071948826313019,
0.842580258846283,
0.003720245324075222,
-0.43239203095436096,
0.8833721280097961,
-0.01754586398601532,
0.5214613080024719,
0.5978521108627319,
0.31545206904411316,
0.07711952924728394,
-0.9266164898872375,
-0.15555597841739655,
0.4879373610019684,
-0.8654160499572754,
-0.4338319003582001,
-0.36869508028030396,
-0.4241795539855957,
0.30419307947158813,
-0.11118367314338684,
-0.4279283583164215,
-0.27537867426872253,
-0.5591732859611511,
0.03494725003838539,
0.4089125692844391,
0.9506009817123413,
0.19945430755615234,
0.3836347162723541,
-0.5418710112571716,
0.39665162563323975,
0.40721118450164795,
0.24204745888710022,
-0.46401286125183105,
-0.680444598197937,
-0.176171213388443,
0.3289971947669983,
-0.05386356636881828,
-0.7049282789230347,
0.12093664705753326,
0.3903742730617523,
0.33599814772605896,
0.5035125613212585,
-0.01006854884326458,
0.5097700357437134,
-0.27728143334388733,
0.5929820537567139,
-0.22751764953136444,
-1.049338459968567,
0.4098723530769348,
-0.45116978883743286,
0.27390021085739136,
0.6696817278862,
0.44668352603912354,
-0.2753469944000244,
-0.9249075651168823,
-0.6938108205795288,
-0.6826466917991638,
0.5524588227272034,
0.26330769062042236,
0.5256348252296448,
-0.03201939910650253,
0.5842071175575256,
-0.16130110621452332,
-0.10968323051929474,
-1.0221312046051025,
-0.26098600029945374,
0.17833006381988525,
-0.05188357084989548,
0.4228919744491577,
-0.6479921936988831,
-0.14964139461517334,
0.11473214626312256,
0.819823682308197,
-0.02897176519036293,
0.20701676607131958,
-0.10278305411338806,
-0.17200593650341034,
-0.26465559005737305,
0.07226407527923584,
0.5952138304710388,
0.6795989871025085,
-0.1802869439125061,
0.4326110780239105,
-0.09332501888275146,
-0.42287546396255493,
0.29620447754859924,
-0.5498035550117493,
-0.5655979514122009,
0.21070145070552826,
1.052808165550232,
0.39702221751213074,
0.4492139220237732,
-0.5179274678230286,
0.49631527066230774,
-0.09582414478063583,
-0.38668763637542725,
-0.14639344811439514,
0.5131815075874329,
0.48633548617362976,
-0.22254067659378052,
0.19767291843891144,
-0.2529192268848419,
-0.09326433390378952,
-0.645901083946228,
0.46080103516578674,
0.6515562534332275,
-0.264519065618515,
-0.20343485474586487,
0.7973109483718872,
-0.298941045999527,
-0.18472090363502502,
0.6321504712104797,
0.18806499242782593,
-0.558259129524231,
0.3867858648300171,
0.5495802760124207,
0.6917288303375244,
-0.24481120705604553,
0.09200739115476608,
0.2677326798439026,
0.5354360342025757,
-0.16880230605602264,
0.42584216594696045,
0.0924413725733757,
-0.9630423188209534,
-0.4224601089954376,
-0.47588828206062317,
-0.4593797028064728,
0.5215608477592468,
-0.8786852955818176,
0.1758844405412674,
-0.634001612663269,
-0.029661964625120163,
0.32873180508613586,
-0.22358058393001556,
-0.20993635058403015,
0.34128499031066895,
0.2851671874523163,
0.5793825387954712,
-1.2669364213943481,
1.2691564559936523,
0.2268412709236145,
-0.12660513818264008,
-0.6033022403717041,
-0.1506858468055725,
-0.13706666231155396,
-1.0865753889083862,
0.644075870513916,
0.10817915946245193,
-0.3104207217693329,
-0.06835741549730301,
-0.6491447687149048,
-0.8395479917526245,
0.9349275827407837,
0.7641611695289612,
-0.21494975686073303,
0.2939038574695587,
0.554046094417572,
0.6393983960151672,
-0.0669308602809906,
0.07576366513967514,
0.40551355481147766,
0.3888622224330902,
-0.3331061601638794,
-0.45290857553482056,
0.2586747109889984,
-0.315217524766922,
0.05719086155295372,
0.13040144741535187,
-0.41287973523139954,
0.7970411777496338,
0.35505056381225586,
-0.6593343019485474,
-0.040701981633901596,
0.4086059629917145,
0.21436478197574615,
-0.00621432950720191,
0.20951148867607117,
0.43517041206359863,
0.6543024778366089,
-0.3010600507259369,
1.0153533220291138,
-0.3801254630088806,
0.3359648287296295,
0.8682922124862671,
-0.22974614799022675,
0.6787707805633545,
0.6048744320869446,
-0.004350563511252403,
0.5636329650878906,
0.2003682553768158,
-0.22473926842212677,
0.7158244848251343,
0.398603230714798,
-0.49117130041122437,
-0.39247825741767883,
-0.14472372829914093,
-0.20913578569889069,
0.32567328214645386,
0.35829928517341614,
-0.6824730038642883,
-0.06549008190631866,
-0.21224434673786163,
0.3449741303920746,
0.23478253185749054,
0.14252039790153503,
0.9825549721717834,
0.32671159505844116,
-0.3930305242538452,
0.9499266743659973,
0.28150472044944763,
0.5684522986412048,
-0.7634837627410889,
-0.1528993844985962,
-0.26041901111602783,
0.1796344667673111,
-0.36377575993537903,
-0.6112436056137085,
0.2148447334766388,
-0.08844251930713654,
-0.1467355191707611,
-0.5078801512718201,
0.8169698715209961,
-0.40997961163520813,
-0.08083953708410263,
0.2902574837207794,
0.4288700222969055,
0.23205149173736572,
0.019893910735845566,
-0.5338524580001831,
0.3930588662624359,
0.16101177036762238,
-0.3065796196460724,
0.5212997794151306,
0.3526551425457001,
-0.04239415377378464,
0.9519506096839905,
0.7992284297943115,
0.27469402551651,
-0.054072678089141846,
-0.06470737606287003,
0.9333831071853638,
-0.3704512417316437,
-0.16579373180866241,
-1.1723337173461914,
0.10446266829967499,
0.013288416899740696,
-0.14355787634849548,
0.8277660012245178,
0.7199394702911377,
0.9176548719406128,
-0.1391562521457672,
0.9025294780731201,
0.19354037940502167,
-0.0863782986998558,
-0.9408724308013916,
1.0006800889968872,
-0.13679088652133942,
0.6361734867095947,
0.020075051113963127,
-0.7160592675209045,
-0.3554900884628296,
0.7168640494346619,
-0.0622733049094677,
0.01774025894701481,
0.8662163615226746,
1.043847918510437,
-0.3189462423324585,
0.10607901960611343,
0.42743563652038574,
-0.23919473588466644,
0.5065173506736755,
0.36344629526138306,
0.8894465565681458,
-0.7609446048736572,
0.3120424449443817,
-0.4706207513809204,
0.007305570878088474,
0.029682528227567673,
-1.1711499691009521,
-1.153098225593567,
-0.3572710454463959,
-0.6394648551940918,
-0.6711845397949219,
-0.0490240640938282,
0.35538527369499207,
0.6186894178390503,
-0.9718396067619324,
-0.1863461285829544,
-0.08656761050224304,
0.0666666254401207,
-0.07597368955612183,
-0.18222790956497192,
0.33135437965393066,
0.049042463302612305,
-0.5509299039840698,
0.5964675545692444,
0.13471032679080963,
0.5268867611885071,
-0.18140029907226562,
-0.05613977462053299,
-0.12562711536884308,
0.3967554271221161,
0.20836171507835388,
0.15931110084056854,
-0.429740309715271,
-0.5069002509117126,
-0.28825658559799194,
-0.38215744495391846,
0.012218442745506763,
0.9906657934188843,
-0.47895780205726624,
0.4792974293231964,
0.6342285871505737,
0.49411067366600037,
0.7706305980682373,
-0.12608501315116882,
0.5355352759361267,
-0.9099315404891968,
0.22318942844867706,
0.26400864124298096,
0.2824953496456146,
0.5744084715843201,
-0.3798430562019348,
0.37894415855407715,
0.3261001408100128,
-0.47710925340652466,
-0.9082489013671875,
0.11282943934202194,
-0.6287192106246948,
-0.33015888929367065,
1.3271995782852173,
-0.47919556498527527,
-0.40610307455062866,
-0.39613616466522217,
0.06699767708778381,
0.3671131730079651,
0.06283411383628845,
0.8718500733375549,
0.9260586500167847,
0.17240455746650696,
-0.03192218393087387,
-0.5585793852806091,
0.8526830077171326,
0.39947623014450073,
-0.9383212327957153,
0.3569466471672058,
0.3376442790031433,
0.8732409477233887,
-0.06689909845590591,
0.6353663206100464,
-0.3013709783554077,
0.21952494978904724,
0.08485852181911469,
0.01637723110616207,
-0.49299436807632446,
-0.06235094368457794,
-0.22879210114479065,
0.07095460593700409,
0.37668153643608093,
0.06375725567340851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14798v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14798v2
|
Enhancing Systematic Decompositional Natural Language Inference Using Informal Logic
| 2024-02-22T18:55:17 | 2024-02-27T21:53:24 |
Nathaniel Weir, Kate Sanders, Orion Weller, Shreya Sharma, Dongwei Jiang, Zhengping Jiang, Bhavana Dalvi Mishra, Oyvind Tafjord, Peter Jansen, Peter Clark, Benjamin Van Durme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Contemporary language models enable new opportunities for structured
reasoning with text, such as the construction and evaluation of intuitive,
proof-like textual entailment trees without relying on brittle formal logic.
However, progress in this direction has been hampered by a long-standing lack
of a clear protocol for determining what valid compositional entailment is.
This absence causes noisy datasets and limited performance gains by modern
neuro-symbolic engines. To address these problems, we formulate a consistent
and theoretically grounded approach to annotating decompositional entailment
datasets, and evaluate its impact on LLM-based textual inference. We find that
our resulting dataset, RDTE (Recognizing Decompositional Textual Entailment),
has a substantially higher internal consistency (+9%) than prior
decompositional entailment datasets, suggesting that RDTE is a significant step
forward in the long-standing problem of forming a clear protocol for discerning
entailment. We also find that training an RDTE-oriented entailment classifier
via knowledge distillation and employing it in a modern neuro-symbolic
reasoning engine significantly improves results (both accuracy and proof
quality) over other entailment classifier baselines, illustrating the practical
benefit of this advance for textual inference.
|
[
0.017718888819217682,
-0.9979256987571716,
0.9978502988815308,
0.18049409985542297,
-0.13281257450580597,
-0.014969073235988617,
-0.5822232365608215,
-0.6113579273223877,
0.050776127725839615,
0.25187039375305176,
-0.6646169424057007,
-0.7389910817146301,
-0.5291876792907715,
0.5346476435661316,
-0.4437776207923889,
0.5952374339103699,
0.04501989483833313,
-0.19754177331924438,
-0.33324161171913147,
0.18205805122852325,
-0.1469559669494629,
-0.1868896633386612,
-0.570286750793457,
-0.5014619827270508,
0.2493864893913269,
0.1342841237783432,
0.4678962826728821,
0.8544629216194153,
0.28920936584472656,
0.3600473403930664,
-0.0756850391626358,
0.5029756426811218,
-0.29685914516448975,
0.4529311954975128,
0.16968174278736115,
-0.5429329872131348,
-0.14438778162002563,
-0.045362088829278946,
0.36404356360435486,
0.7845500707626343,
-0.41435426473617554,
-0.1557801514863968,
-0.11561513692140579,
0.5333425402641296,
-0.882145345211029,
0.2114260345697403,
-0.7669175863265991,
0.05576983094215393,
-0.12284722179174423,
-0.16150793433189392,
-0.8274821043014526,
-0.5863732099533081,
0.0959918200969696,
-0.9647938013076782,
0.0861203595995903,
-0.03570776432752609,
1.0108319520950317,
0.5415595173835754,
-0.2219877392053604,
-0.3773110806941986,
-0.7373545169830322,
0.6856459975242615,
-1.0493463277816772,
0.45561811327934265,
0.7404343485832214,
0.4409223198890686,
-0.1896396428346634,
-1.1140775680541992,
-0.4543091356754303,
-0.3288167119026184,
-0.3624099791049957,
0.15686920285224915,
-0.059958938509225845,
0.2701207995414734,
0.38719671964645386,
0.27396512031555176,
-0.1876312643289566,
-0.026769325137138367,
0.05297553166747093,
-0.05845849961042404,
0.4430654048919678,
0.021386241540312767,
0.34867456555366516,
-0.02905401401221752,
-0.279168039560318,
0.2911663055419922,
-0.5781582593917847,
-0.3781662881374359,
0.3267664909362793,
0.050781503319740295,
0.020668726414442062,
0.4730851352214813,
-0.5104937553405762,
0.77860027551651,
-0.0026349746622145176,
-0.1523333191871643,
0.17706604301929474,
-0.47025036811828613,
-0.3824974298477173,
0.23592527210712433,
0.5678955316543579,
0.17644713819026947,
0.5020846724510193,
-0.34812289476394653,
-0.34175539016723633,
0.44363972544670105,
-0.07605055719614029,
-0.8181969523429871,
-0.3337685167789459,
0.23542878031730652,
-0.2863108217716217,
-0.17449238896369934,
0.09761543571949005,
-0.3228120505809784,
-0.3362467586994171,
-0.7909868955612183,
0.12385878711938858,
-0.6431156992912292,
-0.14319416880607605,
0.616371214389801,
-0.5296911001205444,
0.18239957094192505,
0.6503469347953796,
-0.9568142294883728,
0.7542257308959961,
0.8748292326927185,
0.6638510823249817,
0.26557937264442444,
0.06361659616231918,
-0.22132344543933868,
0.3566172420978546,
-0.2716503143310547,
0.880944013595581,
-0.7843731641769409,
0.21687324345111847,
-0.06372267007827759,
-0.2566629946231842,
-0.19309775531291962,
-0.6744183301925659,
0.8653677701950073,
-0.23634351789951324,
0.44626468420028687,
-0.06553661823272705,
-0.6973041296005249,
-0.20211635529994965,
0.41414520144462585,
-0.4604598879814148,
1.3362315893173218,
-0.16746510565280914,
-0.970606803894043,
0.5700719952583313,
-0.4885329604148865,
-0.5098307132720947,
-0.12210314720869064,
-0.28437724709510803,
-0.07101612538099289,
0.11016540974378586,
0.2945880889892578,
0.2841363847255707,
-0.30433446168899536,
0.6040987968444824,
-0.336910218000412,
-0.32263264060020447,
0.14570961892604828,
-0.551615834236145,
0.8236154913902283,
0.09698446094989777,
-0.41876739263534546,
-0.026559866964817047,
-0.8580523729324341,
0.014949006028473377,
-0.0644286572933197,
0.003974537365138531,
-0.7182688117027283,
0.33694493770599365,
-0.23751187324523926,
0.014988323673605919,
0.05926957353949547,
-0.6367239356040955,
0.058545880019664764,
-0.6400654911994934,
0.5839533805847168,
0.7161110639572144,
0.03150968998670578,
0.501225471496582,
-0.2131933569908142,
0.006076608784496784,
-0.1640986204147339,
-0.13890781998634338,
-0.21489238739013672,
-0.3598199486732483,
-0.7715135216712952,
-0.7706608176231384,
0.40627771615982056,
0.4174964427947998,
-0.5760998725891113,
0.6176788210868835,
-0.38395753502845764,
-0.07878806442022324,
-0.6297998428344727,
-0.2140076905488968,
0.011402209289371967,
0.7256881594657898,
0.3298928141593933,
0.198481023311615,
-0.787143886089325,
-1.0076684951782227,
-0.2820529639720917,
-0.04082825407385826,
-0.3460876941680908,
-0.0505685918033123,
0.5466918349266052,
-0.10377747565507889,
1.1271036863327026,
-0.5010064840316772,
-0.07581702619791031,
-0.07838832587003708,
0.3085358142852783,
0.2189604938030243,
0.2162957787513733,
0.16412471234798431,
-0.34703099727630615,
-0.3108746409416199,
0.024741550907492638,
-1.078781008720398,
-0.39185968041419983,
-0.15340130031108856,
-0.3472099006175995,
0.13405227661132812,
0.49701476097106934,
-0.6040394306182861,
0.4648036062717438,
-0.11061032861471176,
-0.30872100591659546,
0.32895806431770325,
-0.07499275356531143,
0.16574852168560028,
-0.8147587180137634,
-0.23216287791728973,
-0.06241751089692116,
-0.24743135273456573,
-0.47253578901290894,
-0.027774255722761154,
-0.03994711861014366,
0.44467002153396606,
-0.012751637026667595,
0.377697616815567,
-0.4994978606700897,
0.3052668869495392,
-0.12542475759983063,
0.21954640746116638,
0.10531973838806152,
0.12901702523231506,
0.49723172187805176,
0.3426954746246338,
0.474105566740036,
-0.5216081142425537,
-0.02959533780813217,
0.05288011580705643,
-0.13690665364265442,
0.5200344324111938,
-0.6417542099952698,
0.18693867325782776,
-0.4213268756866455,
0.5085639357566833,
-0.7791024446487427,
-0.3479416072368622,
0.2210277020931244,
-0.34527161717414856,
0.2856035828590393,
-0.13833826780319214,
-0.7128480672836304,
0.3345458209514618,
-0.46768197417259216,
0.19848507642745972,
0.5177866816520691,
-0.44881609082221985,
0.8642734885215759,
-0.011481584049761295,
0.1555250734090805,
-0.4488356411457062,
-0.8905310034751892,
0.3412124216556549,
-0.20717103779315948,
-0.9171267747879028,
0.38760054111480713,
0.2536267638206482,
-0.8805252909660339,
0.12762504816055298,
-0.26768478751182556,
-0.28495439887046814,
0.26515862345695496,
0.12478610873222351,
-0.0030621634796261787,
-0.33688539266586304,
0.15112990140914917,
0.18525098264217377,
-0.24412643909454346,
0.28023698925971985,
-0.20449522137641907,
0.1486426740884781,
0.06043925881385803,
-0.2607432007789612,
-0.3426956236362457,
0.17820516228675842,
0.11713796854019165,
-0.12127983570098877,
0.7183278203010559,
0.3218248784542084,
-0.8244137167930603,
-0.6800188422203064,
-0.515261173248291,
-0.6155771613121033,
-0.4472086727619171,
-0.10186868906021118,
-0.25691768527030945,
-0.5505598783493042,
0.34920042753219604,
-0.24008983373641968,
0.19834524393081665,
0.3882811963558197,
0.21961580216884613,
-0.17196278274059296,
0.4956558346748352,
0.1376040279865265,
0.4062734544277191,
0.09823693335056305,
-0.05250365659594536,
0.16576112806797028,
-0.565098226070404,
-0.3520045280456543,
-0.6805906295776367,
-0.3252308666706085,
-0.4236634373664856,
-0.36328861117362976,
-0.04243647679686546,
-0.2434171587228775,
-0.1651899814605713,
0.034712571650743484,
-0.3693755567073822,
0.6582117080688477,
0.4178154468536377,
0.3110533654689789,
0.8328080177307129,
-0.005060639698058367,
0.00894156377762556,
-0.3184357285499573,
-0.48745885491371155,
-0.7552575469017029,
0.7789052724838257,
0.33306851983070374,
0.7721934914588928,
-0.04359998181462288,
1.0795819759368896,
0.14483024179935455,
0.5012744069099426,
-0.7835341095924377,
0.6291819214820862,
0.15859654545783997,
-0.5817497968673706,
-0.09232223033905029,
-0.5717583298683167,
-0.592146098613739,
0.24384191632270813,
-0.08767364919185638,
-0.5843011736869812,
0.06945439428091049,
-0.10966532677412033,
0.05691017210483551,
0.043100014328956604,
-0.8248846530914307,
0.5274410247802734,
-0.00209751701913774,
-0.5248669385910034,
-0.022193821147084236,
-0.686406672000885,
0.6360240578651428,
0.26127082109451294,
0.26181381940841675,
-0.29684779047966003,
-0.14804869890213013,
0.6282624006271362,
-0.6160135865211487,
0.9874339699745178,
-0.08468612283468246,
-0.24592486023902893,
0.44209542870521545,
0.18528102338314056,
0.5797206163406372,
0.2062491774559021,
-0.2964954972267151,
0.03125287964940071,
-0.22760267555713654,
-0.1739967316389084,
-0.973240852355957,
0.48699527978897095,
-0.41783180832862854,
-0.3253193199634552,
-0.5137833952903748,
-0.44934138655662537,
-0.045503538101911545,
0.024783911183476448,
0.18290762603282928,
0.4887847900390625,
-0.08549670875072479,
0.24226777255535126,
0.8539660573005676,
0.21177679300308228,
0.49605175852775574,
0.2766512632369995,
0.12443903088569641,
-0.3472677171230316,
0.46425995230674744,
0.039429668337106705,
0.2949843108654022,
0.640627920627594,
0.3226075768470764,
-0.4743426740169525,
-0.5419057607650757,
-0.19241748750209808,
0.03694523125886917,
-0.9371470212936401,
-0.11965302377939224,
-0.6406373381614685,
-0.06438308954238892,
-0.01716899871826172,
-0.0816337987780571,
-0.26140207052230835,
-0.662885308265686,
-0.09454736858606339,
-0.43257007002830505,
0.429153710603714,
0.6351768374443054,
0.3013306260108948,
-0.07869954407215118,
-0.3613430857658386,
0.49787983298301697,
0.003629440674558282,
0.2423745095729828,
-0.18668437004089355,
-0.6478919982910156,
0.24207481741905212,
0.17450600862503052,
0.07976488023996353,
-0.8895492553710938,
-0.01973976008594036,
0.5506454110145569,
0.42596325278282166,
0.25690463185310364,
0.33333897590637207,
0.7469852566719055,
-0.5547819137573242,
0.38779348134994507,
-0.21696361899375916,
-0.826348066329956,
0.5626811981201172,
-0.47270578145980835,
0.18455426394939423,
0.9148041605949402,
0.20366980135440826,
-0.33629438281059265,
-0.6171553730964661,
-0.6264274716377258,
-0.8824840784072876,
0.339388906955719,
0.4735875129699707,
-0.05707882344722748,
-0.29693803191185,
0.22742988169193268,
0.3024531900882721,
0.028989894315600395,
-0.8483613729476929,
-0.18554475903511047,
-0.0018304595723748207,
-0.6055004000663757,
0.5380957722663879,
-0.01602848991751671,
-0.11405922472476959,
-0.3942558765411377,
0.6157121062278748,
-0.08256077021360397,
0.016917070373892784,
0.2848103642463684,
-0.23118937015533447,
0.33897992968559265,
0.4434352219104767,
0.42594096064567566,
0.6969815492630005,
-0.2841765880584717,
0.666326642036438,
0.12704956531524658,
-0.4164605140686035,
0.17741012573242188,
0.1501433104276657,
-0.5211296081542969,
0.20928123593330383,
0.786105751991272,
0.37691622972488403,
0.4188922941684723,
-0.5290281176567078,
0.1935788094997406,
-0.07763729244470596,
-0.4727605879306793,
-0.2207244634628296,
-0.08613891154527664,
0.2840420603752136,
-0.1683472841978073,
0.3525281548500061,
0.04621537774801254,
0.4043017029762268,
-0.4289933145046234,
0.28730809688568115,
0.21064172685146332,
-0.016927672550082207,
-0.23369751870632172,
0.3791660666465759,
0.14062605798244476,
0.00666406936943531,
0.6640329360961914,
-0.2506808936595917,
-0.2278602570295334,
0.47416964173316956,
0.5855729579925537,
1.1197012662887573,
0.1930220127105713,
0.12256311625242233,
0.44716623425483704,
0.7244707345962524,
-0.34294047951698303,
0.2843673825263977,
-0.2050904482603073,
-0.5557616353034973,
-0.7557559013366699,
-0.5848232507705688,
-0.22545744478702545,
-0.13254183530807495,
-0.3927290737628937,
0.2207370102405548,
-0.43453624844551086,
0.1696798950433731,
-0.10180792212486267,
-0.3342844247817993,
-0.43485450744628906,
0.0271313413977623,
0.05849925056099892,
0.9575778245925903,
-0.9928807020187378,
0.5881062150001526,
0.5280582904815674,
-0.2312997430562973,
-0.6728186011314392,
0.06477426737546921,
-0.04928846284747124,
-0.4275473952293396,
0.6382476091384888,
0.3567653298377991,
-0.3467417061328888,
-0.023193612694740295,
-0.6594155430793762,
-0.42427071928977966,
0.9841769933700562,
0.6825616955757141,
-0.39352092146873474,
0.07093574106693268,
-0.04763899743556976,
0.5825650095939636,
-0.17162686586380005,
0.6915534138679504,
0.637581467628479,
0.8555133938789368,
0.07315555959939957,
-0.6370882391929626,
0.38665759563446045,
-0.21296285092830658,
-0.3506775200366974,
0.42920437455177307,
0.067535400390625,
0.4347304701805115,
-0.07696252316236496,
-0.638058066368103,
-0.3212244510650635,
0.7638142704963684,
0.2603839039802551,
0.6047257781028748,
0.16805167496204376,
0.9907991886138916,
0.9633991122245789,
-0.4840053915977478,
0.9207981824874878,
0.0535600483417511,
0.01793791353702545,
1.4347560405731201,
-0.4960032105445862,
0.8313169479370117,
0.6002716422080994,
-0.12198880314826965,
0.9196392893791199,
0.6035295724868774,
0.41479015350341797,
0.4174686074256897,
0.3040270209312439,
-0.6096993684768677,
-0.3976878821849823,
-0.3093421459197998,
-0.2291930913925171,
0.36191073060035706,
0.386904239654541,
-0.346864253282547,
-0.6239965558052063,
-0.580757200717926,
0.06748353689908981,
0.5513944029808044,
0.09264060109853745,
0.9401513338088989,
0.1476033478975296,
-0.5280449390411377,
0.5246530175209045,
0.057146940380334854,
0.6979958415031433,
-0.7304972410202026,
-0.4415700435638428,
-0.05295266583561897,
-0.002277396386489272,
-0.5963403582572937,
-0.5301374793052673,
0.4288545250892639,
-0.07591322809457779,
0.03717169538140297,
-0.27110522985458374,
0.8971920609474182,
-0.4852851629257202,
-0.4436599314212799,
0.10781431943178177,
0.5314636826515198,
-0.1500953882932663,
-0.1224605143070221,
-0.22345496714115143,
-0.008090232498943806,
-0.27067846059799194,
-0.28142228722572327,
0.06343209743499756,
1.0612126588821411,
-0.016322525218129158,
0.5440365672111511,
0.7159820199012756,
-0.15605147182941437,
-0.0036494520027190447,
0.24698522686958313,
0.7645257711410522,
-0.6262787580490112,
-0.32275471091270447,
-1.283825397491455,
0.6385178565979004,
-0.31316837668418884,
-0.011639023199677467,
0.883467972278595,
0.6318233013153076,
0.6358899474143982,
0.06226428598165512,
0.7313007116317749,
-0.13636530935764313,
-0.02025909349322319,
-0.8375385999679565,
0.326842725276947,
-0.08283885568380356,
0.4187510311603546,
-0.007837042212486267,
-0.8122217059135437,
-0.39653894305229187,
0.8998689651489258,
-0.3436031937599182,
0.12317335605621338,
1.0801408290863037,
0.6060436964035034,
-0.26263153553009033,
0.27373045682907104,
-0.026622401550412178,
0.09627317637205124,
0.13988491892814636,
0.4051029682159424,
0.9511721134185791,
-0.29166361689567566,
0.001353433821350336,
-0.3010110855102539,
-0.15166568756103516,
0.24782057106494904,
-1.3195745944976807,
-0.8521643877029419,
-0.23618735373020172,
-0.4698456823825836,
-0.23008610308170319,
0.13141489028930664,
1.0080533027648926,
0.4699065685272217,
-0.4250642955303192,
-0.11306656152009964,
-0.47287705540657043,
0.09249646216630936,
-0.3329238295555115,
-0.28298553824424744,
0.15248650312423706,
-0.42770349979400635,
-0.5257201790809631,
0.5373055338859558,
0.47247788310050964,
-0.2761843204498291,
0.10408241301774979,
-0.04051635041832924,
-0.4443628489971161,
0.10394677519798279,
0.6285499334335327,
-0.08419989794492722,
-0.8501879572868347,
-0.27709388732910156,
0.078390933573246,
-0.11583103239536285,
0.11695734411478043,
0.7338507175445557,
-0.8095534443855286,
0.35117045044898987,
0.7526201009750366,
0.7521294355392456,
0.3779604434967041,
0.12104488164186478,
0.6595322489738464,
-0.8618059754371643,
0.14080961048603058,
0.5719130039215088,
0.3589039146900177,
0.29682549834251404,
-0.14733479917049408,
0.7489901185035706,
0.25128239393234253,
-0.20502039790153503,
-0.8765875697135925,
0.18935081362724304,
-0.8481844663619995,
-0.21592384576797485,
1.2499748468399048,
-0.03367269039154053,
-0.37376704812049866,
-0.4520159959793091,
-0.15135231614112854,
-0.02801630273461342,
-0.4925506114959717,
0.5567392706871033,
0.7825213670730591,
0.05360516160726547,
-0.0031229762826114893,
-0.7410249710083008,
0.5114425420761108,
0.2929810583591461,
-1.3511357307434082,
0.3471366763114929,
0.7336375713348389,
0.19791127741336823,
-0.0986439436674118,
0.6821151375770569,
-0.06712640076875687,
0.10523321479558945,
0.05935143306851387,
-0.08095065504312515,
-0.27114319801330566,
-0.31290197372436523,
-0.11306451261043549,
-0.016775110736489296,
0.09526816755533218,
0.051012929528951645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14778v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14778v2
|
Zero-shot cross-lingual transfer in instruction tuning of large language models
| 2024-02-22T18:37:33 | 2024-04-22T10:44:21 |
Nadezhda Chirkova, Vassilina Nikoulina
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction tuning (IT) is widely used to teach pretrained large language
models (LLMs) to follow arbitrary instructions, but is under-studied in
multilingual settings. In this work, we conduct a systematic study of zero-shot
cross-lingual transfer in IT, when an LLM is instruction-tuned on English-only
data and then tested on user prompts in other languages. We advocate for the
importance of evaluating various aspects of model responses in multilingual
instruction following and investigate the influence of different model
configuration choices. We find that cross-lingual transfer does happen
successfully in IT even if all stages of model training are English-centric,
but only if multiliguality is taken into account in hyperparameter tuning and
with large enough IT data. English-trained LLMs are capable of generating
correct-language, comprehensive and helpful responses in other languages, but
suffer from low factuality and may occasionally have fluency errors.
|
[
-0.30110564827919006,
-0.798917293548584,
0.3873620331287384,
0.3030303716659546,
-0.1628669947385788,
-0.17183415591716766,
-0.47045546770095825,
-0.5329424738883972,
0.12420862168073654,
0.31394240260124207,
-0.5497729182243347,
-0.436358779668808,
-0.46579083800315857,
0.07013536244630814,
-0.3496670424938202,
1.0561083555221558,
-0.17514556646347046,
0.35186293721199036,
-0.11967301368713379,
0.03498294949531555,
-0.7255445122718811,
-0.5402366518974304,
-0.625739336013794,
-0.35733434557914734,
0.6396794319152832,
0.8153899312019348,
0.39147892594337463,
0.6681916117668152,
0.20823663473129272,
0.21973495185375214,
0.3513931930065155,
-0.23141129314899445,
-0.5733041763305664,
-0.20126847922801971,
-0.4476972818374634,
-0.5546008944511414,
-0.41200166940689087,
-0.03372602164745331,
0.8275176882743835,
0.8707723021507263,
0.020715652033686638,
0.30428335070610046,
0.14436404407024384,
0.29551032185554504,
-0.7757962346076965,
0.12223320454359055,
-0.6202601790428162,
0.17710396647453308,
-0.21964550018310547,
-0.4425193965435028,
-0.7280181050300598,
-0.14388994872570038,
-0.02798677794635296,
-0.6855146884918213,
0.2366560995578766,
0.14688612520694733,
0.6993024945259094,
-0.10790446400642395,
-0.6589067578315735,
-0.16066351532936096,
-0.8562715649604797,
0.8943783640861511,
-0.6086047291755676,
0.4346161186695099,
0.3918372690677643,
0.16850003600120544,
0.2440202534198761,
-0.17521615326404572,
-0.2792986035346985,
-0.42332664132118225,
-0.15899056196212769,
0.14502446353435516,
0.0282517671585083,
-0.038779765367507935,
0.2660048305988312,
0.03180048614740372,
-0.7379651665687561,
0.5766236782073975,
-0.4999309480190277,
-0.25084102153778076,
0.7167324423789978,
0.22931499779224396,
0.17898312211036682,
0.2090388536453247,
-0.4297676980495453,
-0.06546740978956223,
-0.8613278269767761,
0.08628449589014053,
0.38409188389778137,
0.5320943593978882,
-0.31665152311325073,
0.5845492482185364,
-0.1263311356306076,
1.0832372903823853,
0.15884216129779816,
-0.060210417956113815,
-0.037469975650310516,
-0.5591325759887695,
-0.025377286598086357,
0.3418063521385193,
0.5939932465553284,
0.42910176515579224,
0.7633415460586548,
-0.21072424948215485,
-0.12389644980430603,
-0.22295819222927094,
0.19954630732536316,
-0.869799792766571,
0.04632392153143883,
-0.16682253777980804,
0.04234578460454941,
0.12085659056901932,
-0.04937553405761719,
-0.49172040820121765,
0.1385597139596939,
-0.3988952934741974,
0.6772558093070984,
-0.36603015661239624,
-0.17493227124214172,
0.26492178440093994,
0.14305028319358826,
0.5535624623298645,
0.18631389737129211,
-1.1021877527236938,
-0.05800522863864899,
0.5373029112815857,
0.6064803600311279,
-0.33872026205062866,
-0.8427648544311523,
-0.6363521814346313,
0.3670213520526886,
-0.5840027928352356,
0.9155368208885193,
-0.7057135105133057,
-0.5087816715240479,
0.26215818524360657,
0.39339953660964966,
-0.6736688613891602,
-0.20444859564304352,
0.1651916801929474,
-0.4076128900051117,
0.49046608805656433,
-0.36336618661880493,
-0.7607149481773376,
-0.11482857912778854,
0.2850132882595062,
-0.41065898537635803,
0.7079511284828186,
-0.05708218365907669,
-0.4860846996307373,
0.3778061270713806,
-0.49990761280059814,
-0.9033544659614563,
-0.0989215150475502,
0.06940861791372299,
-0.031837981194257736,
0.219339981675148,
0.07977473735809326,
0.3913491666316986,
-0.26381704211235046,
-0.11014565080404282,
-0.3489152193069458,
-0.7104244828224182,
0.08937182277441025,
-0.5867029428482056,
0.6930543184280396,
-0.15279193222522736,
-0.34810134768486023,
0.054403156042099,
-0.7327272891998291,
0.2404496818780899,
0.04033861681818962,
-0.27180516719818115,
-0.34732016921043396,
-0.5958873629570007,
-0.10600459575653076,
0.09418134391307831,
0.20004305243492126,
-0.6390858292579651,
0.4887866675853729,
-0.06212189421057701,
0.010999925434589386,
0.6629180312156677,
-0.050611965358257294,
0.5721178650856018,
-0.2595515549182892,
0.7424380779266357,
-0.07790113240480423,
0.14270013570785522,
-0.43257367610931396,
-0.322948157787323,
-0.8173149824142456,
-0.1061442419886589,
0.4551820158958435,
0.7974788546562195,
-0.7413004040718079,
-0.0013196920044720173,
-0.009245835244655609,
-0.2855706214904785,
-0.5855430960655212,
0.043351538479328156,
0.5211148858070374,
0.6353194117546082,
0.21725678443908691,
-0.04111441969871521,
-0.18345168232917786,
-0.8579925298690796,
-0.24221473932266235,
-0.004405275918543339,
0.1279015988111496,
0.2587442100048065,
0.26716792583465576,
0.14786532521247864,
0.1859140843153,
-0.22238454222679138,
-0.13505250215530396,
-0.23807761073112488,
0.2666766047477722,
0.008971866220235825,
0.3545028269290924,
0.7010867595672607,
-0.17938822507858276,
-0.9330189228057861,
0.27375414967536926,
-0.5466562509536743,
-0.28007882833480835,
-0.33599546551704407,
-0.2048289030790329,
0.4346091151237488,
0.47245925664901733,
-0.4118911921977997,
0.24412791430950165,
0.7070772647857666,
-0.281893253326416,
0.5212547779083252,
-0.34190577268600464,
0.5252289772033691,
-1.0674163103103638,
0.04510826990008354,
-0.0342937596142292,
-0.1973343938589096,
-0.6366729140281677,
-0.0017058007651939988,
0.29122328758239746,
0.03175238147377968,
-0.6498163342475891,
0.7546034455299377,
-0.6486905217170715,
-0.2153797298669815,
-0.3018677830696106,
0.0234854556620121,
0.07229295372962952,
0.5165570378303528,
0.20272719860076904,
0.9999799728393555,
0.8189587593078613,
-0.6398354768753052,
0.21700917184352875,
-0.024645179510116577,
-0.19663511216640472,
0.9955188632011414,
-0.5918135643005371,
0.28447577357292175,
0.035793837159872055,
-0.1756201833486557,
-0.8222693204879761,
-0.051208626478910446,
0.05493507534265518,
-0.24872088432312012,
0.6687365174293518,
-0.09638693928718567,
-0.10602115839719772,
-0.02678103744983673,
-0.2843882739543915,
0.30998486280441284,
0.1334049254655838,
-0.44010603427886963,
0.3631123900413513,
-0.1121583878993988,
-0.19216454029083252,
-0.589179277420044,
-0.6575829982757568,
-0.10054536908864975,
-0.12764690816402435,
-0.3946039378643036,
0.24913102388381958,
-0.2974969744682312,
0.02014128677546978,
-0.03459331765770912,
-0.04303618147969246,
-0.18321047723293304,
0.031040146946907043,
-0.14366969466209412,
0.4262813627719879,
-0.44880643486976624,
-0.05705668777227402,
0.11143816262483597,
-0.01019419077783823,
0.018134571611881256,
-0.25952738523483276,
0.43228304386138916,
0.10654289275407791,
-0.6889498233795166,
-0.4585780203342438,
0.5146883726119995,
0.5349652767181396,
-0.16752144694328308,
0.8149557709693909,
0.714073896408081,
0.08784792572259903,
-0.2723456621170044,
-0.26300856471061707,
-0.25812989473342896,
-0.37956565618515015,
0.48683178424835205,
-0.49603116512298584,
-0.8770765066146851,
0.4677644968032837,
0.2032870501279831,
0.28498244285583496,
0.2958715260028839,
0.5358365178108215,
-0.09093128889799118,
1.2799938917160034,
0.9843154549598694,
-0.1267755627632141,
0.6127509474754333,
0.002704801969230175,
0.008486046455800533,
-0.5438655614852905,
-0.06925872713327408,
-0.6895161271095276,
-0.25202658772468567,
-0.6173502802848816,
-0.12105396389961243,
0.3045504689216614,
-0.0015633224975317717,
-0.22420714795589447,
0.2540246546268463,
0.0677645206451416,
0.6090890765190125,
0.4936191737651825,
-0.2256150245666504,
0.2667892873287201,
0.18808616697788239,
-0.1553100049495697,
-0.050136029720306396,
-0.9580472707748413,
-0.04007439315319061,
1.0118188858032227,
0.00840054266154766,
0.9781985282897949,
0.0011099429102614522,
0.49730977416038513,
-0.04759250953793526,
0.23227368295192719,
-0.9155221581459045,
0.33146587014198303,
-0.3408202528953552,
-0.5554856657981873,
-0.22498735785484314,
-0.4019069969654083,
-0.9796890616416931,
0.15913036465644836,
-0.13896770775318146,
-0.6756279468536377,
-0.1306391954421997,
0.10634247958660126,
-0.2766232192516327,
0.13837963342666626,
-0.9071102142333984,
0.8916140198707581,
-0.595789909362793,
-0.5393214225769043,
-0.21800048649311066,
-0.41520434617996216,
0.32402363419532776,
-0.24746732413768768,
0.0760156586766243,
0.156559020280838,
0.08426341414451599,
0.4555605947971344,
0.0031198447104543447,
0.7580270767211914,
-0.07134202122688293,
-0.47167783975601196,
-0.16254380345344543,
0.18933424353599548,
0.3782714307308197,
-0.12992976605892181,
-0.09420064836740494,
0.3974302113056183,
0.13320831954479218,
-0.5700938701629639,
-0.5851502418518066,
0.8333611488342285,
-0.8387293815612793,
-0.8871505260467529,
-0.15531782805919647,
-0.8398565053939819,
-0.44874584674835205,
0.24405528604984283,
0.37521448731422424,
0.36629924178123474,
0.007512245327234268,
0.19910183548927307,
0.7984943985939026,
-0.2308860719203949,
0.4460015296936035,
1.157330870628357,
-0.38344070315361023,
0.039449602365493774,
0.8724235892295837,
0.319551944732666,
0.591535210609436,
0.3939487338066101,
0.19007433950901031,
-0.23074880242347717,
-0.30688226222991943,
-1.0399971008300781,
0.3159939646720886,
-0.6043274998664856,
-0.03898543491959572,
-0.06528498977422714,
-0.31298351287841797,
-0.4199545979499817,
-0.23996736109256744,
-0.5362188220024109,
-0.30945947766304016,
-0.3117973804473877,
-0.06810066848993301,
0.2336389422416687,
0.6890987157821655,
0.030217550694942474,
0.21673668920993805,
-0.9868537783622742,
0.08996183425188065,
0.18613366782665253,
0.3313487768173218,
-0.29506707191467285,
-1.0263172388076782,
-0.6044718623161316,
0.11745990067720413,
0.12334498763084412,
-0.8395012021064758,
0.1361951380968094,
0.5958988666534424,
0.7259729504585266,
0.23515915870666504,
-0.011972228065133095,
0.855069637298584,
-0.6529433727264404,
0.7472155094146729,
-0.07111456990242004,
-0.815653920173645,
0.25602206587791443,
-0.14930717647075653,
0.6818127632141113,
0.4159815311431885,
0.7488259673118591,
-0.5850606560707092,
-0.1594741940498352,
-0.05132443830370903,
-0.5755339860916138,
0.9652059674263,
-0.48437076807022095,
0.4619382917881012,
0.1959470957517624,
0.2769347131252289,
0.3039683699607849,
0.0821540430188179,
-0.569593608379364,
-0.24027377367019653,
0.014535711146891117,
0.07597900927066803,
-0.10665593296289444,
-0.11513227969408035,
-0.2230609655380249,
-0.2190469652414322,
0.6732383370399475,
-0.3930755853652954,
0.08282234519720078,
-0.24173854291439056,
-0.31522053480148315,
-0.45487210154533386,
0.4308951199054718,
0.733050525188446,
0.7683947086334229,
0.1198333278298378,
-0.010425640270113945,
0.19852480292320251,
-0.22455477714538574,
0.2648138701915741,
0.040842581540346146,
-0.33795398473739624,
-0.08706708997488022,
0.662889838218689,
1.1925718784332275,
0.5075023770332336,
-0.26295506954193115,
0.47877180576324463,
-0.10044228285551071,
-0.30588752031326294,
-0.0014850432053208351,
0.18271100521087646,
-0.027300402522087097,
0.18905095756053925,
0.04155336320400238,
-0.2842634916305542,
-0.1251082718372345,
-0.6324907541275024,
-0.004277499858289957,
0.6090912222862244,
-0.2723357081413269,
-0.6054084897041321,
0.30609166622161865,
0.06367382407188416,
-0.3173239231109619,
0.6429444551467896,
0.03626212850213051,
-0.3345280587673187,
0.40396395325660706,
1.017584204673767,
0.7866223454475403,
-0.49225640296936035,
0.3886291980743408,
0.36045873165130615,
0.48625051975250244,
0.18473665416240692,
0.27636000514030457,
-0.2022305279970169,
-0.7065889835357666,
-0.7722684144973755,
-0.4582620859146118,
-0.4915494918823242,
0.06640156358480453,
-0.9807830452919006,
0.37111544609069824,
-0.23006746172904968,
0.19338050484657288,
-0.05689724162220955,
-0.19417837262153625,
-0.7420771718025208,
-0.05813898146152496,
0.34888842701911926,
0.9601020812988281,
-1.1225628852844238,
1.0930348634719849,
0.9628098011016846,
-0.2656266391277313,
-1.0630369186401367,
0.08294354379177094,
-0.07023879885673523,
-1.1012603044509888,
0.5631301403045654,
0.08632605522871017,
-0.28327590227127075,
0.1482524573802948,
-0.36608433723449707,
-0.8583325743675232,
0.7840659618377686,
0.7000811100006104,
-0.793566882610321,
0.09611725807189941,
0.40711861848831177,
0.5061764717102051,
-0.34941840171813965,
0.3860272467136383,
0.4940389096736908,
0.48695871233940125,
0.33089199662208557,
-1.2927618026733398,
-0.28203079104423523,
-0.08838645368814468,
-0.11829004436731339,
0.06634938716888428,
-0.8004134297370911,
0.9328015446662903,
-0.15170006453990936,
-0.11587584763765335,
-0.17970067262649536,
0.21262302994728088,
-0.03624305501580238,
0.1352730542421341,
0.3251272737979889,
0.4302080273628235,
0.5537399649620056,
0.16952063143253326,
1.0474369525909424,
-0.7263590693473816,
0.14703784883022308,
1.0133289098739624,
-0.6967607140541077,
0.8526942729949951,
0.45524924993515015,
0.10963964462280273,
0.3514568507671356,
0.5692349672317505,
0.22609739005565643,
0.39345112442970276,
-0.16467775404453278,
-0.12574277818202972,
-0.24817803502082825,
-0.3626105785369873,
-0.4506744146347046,
0.6724521517753601,
0.11833861470222473,
-0.11711294949054718,
-0.2670805752277374,
0.23121879994869232,
0.1595843881368637,
-0.20540376007556915,
-0.5342007875442505,
0.9113561511039734,
-0.15353281795978546,
-0.9432176947593689,
0.9314914345741272,
-0.09772958606481552,
0.6244668960571289,
-0.8400346636772156,
-0.1407938301563263,
-0.5268917083740234,
0.07241612672805786,
-0.163761705160141,
-0.8207464814186096,
0.2323996126651764,
0.18313436210155487,
-0.20645710825920105,
-0.4019608795642853,
0.5359626412391663,
-0.7894585132598877,
-0.5419960021972656,
0.4470807611942291,
0.5891138911247253,
0.21964743733406067,
0.1852997988462448,
-0.6499010920524597,
-0.014222967438399792,
0.1972029060125351,
-0.5110492706298828,
0.7178447246551514,
0.5207064747810364,
-0.2669638693332672,
0.29682374000549316,
0.44472023844718933,
0.33152785897254944,
0.2944222688674927,
0.3632535934448242,
0.5867834687232971,
-0.5915599465370178,
-0.25552093982696533,
-0.6568225026130676,
0.4698942005634308,
0.2877608835697174,
-0.255705326795578,
1.1307610273361206,
0.28496912121772766,
1.2790923118591309,
-0.1268441379070282,
0.6559393405914307,
0.17807292938232422,
0.24599072337150574,
-0.8244341611862183,
0.4034784734249115,
-0.7154213190078735,
0.18902814388275146,
0.18450504541397095,
-1.102705478668213,
-0.039203714579343796,
0.4577426314353943,
-0.29840609431266785,
0.15239682793617249,
0.7005732655525208,
0.8673557043075562,
-0.15736813843250275,
-0.03493722900748253,
0.7539688944816589,
0.07362087815999985,
-0.04477003589272499,
0.5734310150146484,
0.6860040426254272,
-0.15212464332580566,
0.4228315055370331,
-0.30217230319976807,
-0.1642075479030609,
-0.13875296711921692,
-0.8897175788879395,
-0.8628858923912048,
-0.2508170008659363,
-0.27945905923843384,
0.030947282910346985,
0.1371331661939621,
0.824563205242157,
0.6708745956420898,
-0.9601367115974426,
-0.5624915957450867,
0.366456538438797,
-0.02167278714478016,
-0.18847081065177917,
-0.20907481014728546,
0.0875871330499649,
-0.5512867569923401,
-0.8336988687515259,
0.5845991969108582,
0.26039519906044006,
-0.21112796664237976,
-0.510218620300293,
0.0007411201950162649,
-0.3143147826194763,
0.17374294996261597,
0.6036276817321777,
0.35974428057670593,
-0.31490957736968994,
-0.4444394111633301,
0.5156540870666504,
-0.18334254622459412,
-0.05152716860175133,
0.8679012060165405,
-0.3166761100292206,
0.5400235056877136,
0.3241131603717804,
0.6595953702926636,
0.5423886179924011,
-0.25434380769729614,
0.7534750699996948,
-1.0768446922302246,
0.27369046211242676,
-0.13451319932937622,
0.31905946135520935,
0.3985942602157593,
-0.3716684579849243,
0.20850417017936707,
0.1308399736881256,
-0.5401424169540405,
-0.5978589653968811,
0.10624925047159195,
-0.44026637077331543,
-0.27323028445243835,
1.327901840209961,
-0.32372337579727173,
-0.2824123501777649,
0.21546675264835358,
-0.18526583909988403,
0.2579152584075928,
-0.03477322682738304,
0.5447459816932678,
0.8579956889152527,
-0.23414050042629242,
-0.40385499596595764,
-0.7011597752571106,
0.0804537981748581,
0.6880499720573425,
-0.7509955763816833,
-0.012700153514742851,
0.5715332627296448,
0.4766504764556885,
-0.0739613026380539,
0.35027173161506653,
0.15865367650985718,
0.38335973024368286,
-0.0921735092997551,
0.05194983258843422,
-0.09890328347682953,
-0.6192827224731445,
-0.6951764225959778,
-0.047270309180021286,
0.30161988735198975,
-0.19100411236286163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14776v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14776v2
|
ESE: Espresso Sentence Embeddings
| 2024-02-22T18:35:05 | 2024-05-21T07:36:14 |
Xianming Li, Zongxi Li, Jing Li, Haoran Xie, Qing Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
High-quality sentence embeddings are fundamental in many natural language
processing (NLP) tasks, such as semantic textual similarity (STS) and
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). Nevertheless, most existing methods
leverage fixed-length embeddings from full-layer language models, which lack
the scalability to accommodate the diverse available resources across various
applications. Viewing this gap, we propose a novel sentence embedding model
$\mathrm{Espresso}$ $\mathrm{Sentence}$ $\mathrm{Embeddings}$ (ESE) with two
learning processes. First, the learn-to-express process encodes more salient
representations to lower layers. Second, the learn-to-compress process compacts
essential features into the initial dimensions using Principal Component
Analysis (PCA). This way, ESE can scale model depth via the former process and
embedding size via the latter. Extensive experiments on STS and RAG suggest
that ESE can effectively produce high-quality embeddings with less model depth
and embedding size, enhancing embedding inference efficiency.
|
[
-0.10372402518987656,
-0.9182445406913757,
0.7632393836975098,
0.44430625438690186,
-0.47507762908935547,
-0.08374321460723877,
-0.3010804057121277,
-0.39356812834739685,
0.46705394983291626,
0.6808307766914368,
-0.3911682069301605,
-0.5229723453521729,
-0.7327268719673157,
-0.011317320168018341,
-0.35742002725601196,
0.8606093525886536,
0.03421296179294586,
-0.1381903737783432,
-0.5546219944953918,
0.1539873331785202,
-0.417916864156723,
-0.5022837519645691,
-0.5799166560173035,
-0.03726446256041527,
0.20924651622772217,
0.2775144875049591,
0.5517786741256714,
0.5077347755432129,
0.2341211587190628,
0.22014294564723969,
-0.10922016203403473,
0.3669742941856384,
-0.5331481695175171,
0.497749388217926,
0.13090065121650696,
-0.5254794955253601,
-0.006687009707093239,
-0.07233168184757233,
0.4019840657711029,
0.5421121120452881,
-0.14044874906539917,
-0.05179367586970329,
0.220290869474411,
0.4928940534591675,
-0.6658108830451965,
0.1601756066083908,
-0.5220670104026794,
0.4489998519420624,
0.33659887313842773,
0.005805788096040487,
-0.8263121843338013,
-0.2602475881576538,
0.11042167991399765,
-0.48053228855133057,
0.09203324466943741,
-0.008129934780299664,
0.9163270592689514,
0.2752111852169037,
-0.41669049859046936,
-0.41715607047080994,
-0.5318974852561951,
0.7178095579147339,
-0.5164422392845154,
0.14430172741413116,
0.19222119450569153,
0.1123017966747284,
0.20915575325489044,
-0.7913939952850342,
-0.40285298228263855,
-0.08582381159067154,
-0.1029229685664177,
0.16340486705303192,
-0.041304364800453186,
-0.03446880728006363,
-0.012317188084125519,
0.4263750910758972,
-0.5466228723526001,
0.23431313037872314,
0.022681640461087227,
0.28350210189819336,
0.27852344512939453,
-0.11857558786869049,
0.20494525134563446,
-0.17286717891693115,
-0.6262008547782898,
-0.07757952809333801,
-0.4819709062576294,
-0.13883242011070251,
0.2191845029592514,
0.4289132058620453,
0.0020818253979086876,
0.6233377456665039,
-0.06857753545045853,
0.4112683832645416,
-0.20746077597141266,
0.19338494539260864,
0.2957363426685333,
0.022245436906814575,
-0.5514045357704163,
-0.21774236857891083,
0.7270132899284363,
0.26018625497817993,
0.11182980239391327,
-0.37893280386924744,
-0.19243866205215454,
0.17859220504760742,
0.39025965332984924,
-0.9695340394973755,
0.1950196474790573,
0.19929717481136322,
-0.5308181047439575,
-0.47972074151039124,
0.2120511382818222,
-0.7497318387031555,
-0.11232025176286697,
-0.23426561057567596,
0.3415640592575073,
-0.2976028621196747,
0.15252038836479187,
0.4790913164615631,
-0.2988497316837311,
0.14647656679153442,
0.023047152906656265,
-0.638312041759491,
0.6153063178062439,
0.8358545303344727,
1.0676178932189941,
-0.008390522561967373,
-0.07665643841028214,
-0.6131839156150818,
0.01782274805009365,
-0.12023099511861801,
0.8960543274879456,
-0.7654684782028198,
-0.4206660985946655,
0.3938385546207428,
0.006812482140958309,
-0.11304141581058502,
-0.379528284072876,
0.8892949819564819,
-0.44057464599609375,
0.5000559091567993,
-0.15517809987068176,
-0.9932282567024231,
-0.17298994958400726,
0.1656653881072998,
-0.5001599192619324,
1.1051746606826782,
-0.2390902042388916,
-0.5196664929389954,
0.046258244663476944,
-0.5365192294120789,
-0.4676102101802826,
-0.18147748708724976,
-0.11348360031843185,
-0.6980389952659607,
0.6598212122917175,
0.3235054314136505,
0.8822116255760193,
-0.35178202390670776,
-0.08944160491228104,
-0.2567260265350342,
-0.24294698238372803,
0.08734068274497986,
-0.30013492703437805,
0.664379358291626,
0.08904866129159927,
-0.0020870768930763006,
-0.2743130326271057,
-0.7498366236686707,
-0.05541818588972092,
0.28849729895591736,
-0.19298803806304932,
-0.30069592595100403,
-0.028636112809181213,
0.3800320029258728,
0.2687389850616455,
0.28208762407302856,
-0.6655489206314087,
0.12373128533363342,
-0.3378559350967407,
0.7426202893257141,
0.49036070704460144,
0.30792418122291565,
0.4973197281360626,
-0.12157665193080902,
0.45604243874549866,
-0.010825342498719692,
0.05407243221998215,
-0.3599601089954376,
-0.48662498593330383,
-0.6609993577003479,
-0.3204711079597473,
0.2600276470184326,
0.7098591923713684,
-0.49368685483932495,
0.7640538215637207,
-0.2424475997686386,
-0.33177417516708374,
-0.3451847732067108,
-0.19144606590270996,
0.2986924350261688,
0.1305340677499771,
0.34055060148239136,
-0.17089079320430756,
-0.3064280152320862,
-0.9903661012649536,
-0.29538267850875854,
0.23138286173343658,
-0.3281790614128113,
0.18330375850200653,
0.37419354915618896,
0.02183081954717636,
0.6360148191452026,
-0.9011204838752747,
-0.2846459150314331,
-0.09424565732479095,
0.35755667090415955,
0.09970788657665253,
0.5343276262283325,
0.6499190926551819,
-0.3757880628108978,
-0.657095730304718,
-0.2290022373199463,
-0.7242834568023682,
-0.012799298390746117,
-0.10101205855607986,
-0.09396979212760925,
0.04320914298295975,
0.6940183043479919,
-0.6251994371414185,
0.20424462854862213,
0.6347318887710571,
-0.4872264862060547,
0.10400444269180298,
-0.47843390703201294,
0.1187734454870224,
-1.4074642658233643,
-0.49223071336746216,
0.039047300815582275,
-0.5015137791633606,
-0.4446924924850464,
0.2515355944633484,
0.03258456289768219,
-0.593024492263794,
-0.3444840908050537,
0.024064065888524055,
-0.6167709231376648,
-0.14480392634868622,
-0.2502422034740448,
0.28435778617858887,
0.42172977328300476,
0.6082693934440613,
0.08570221811532974,
0.5246026515960693,
0.485334575176239,
-0.27007538080215454,
-0.07711773365736008,
0.1748807728290558,
-0.2918601334095001,
0.7112814784049988,
-0.9674867987632751,
0.37485674023628235,
-0.19178742170333862,
0.06908896565437317,
-0.9668251276016235,
0.28106489777565,
-0.22612158954143524,
-0.4175410568714142,
0.22989696264266968,
-0.060390882194042206,
-0.9647441506385803,
-0.16048946976661682,
-0.3969511389732361,
-0.0403289794921875,
0.5213062763214111,
-0.3670733869075775,
0.6163279414176941,
0.454495370388031,
-0.2698109447956085,
-0.330434113740921,
-0.8337300419807434,
0.2356209009885788,
-0.1854838728904724,
-0.532482922077179,
0.6394209265708923,
0.11757607758045197,
0.30872470140457153,
0.1558993011713028,
0.45447269082069397,
-0.2011687308549881,
0.06842036545276642,
0.14324548840522766,
0.04143894091248512,
-0.24367135763168335,
0.44191041588783264,
0.546567440032959,
0.05233098939061165,
-0.050420939922332764,
-0.2997184693813324,
0.5508963465690613,
-0.06800016760826111,
-0.0336594395339489,
-0.6229098439216614,
0.7599529027938843,
0.6163153052330017,
-0.3354995846748352,
1.125916600227356,
0.4035256505012512,
-0.5661855936050415,
-0.44386720657348633,
-0.24540714919567108,
-0.31624478101730347,
-0.3884165585041046,
0.403251975774765,
-0.40846964716911316,
-1.0691367387771606,
0.40826526284217834,
-0.2083233892917633,
-0.026985498145222664,
0.31540021300315857,
0.14708486199378967,
-0.1766359806060791,
0.8260855078697205,
0.7247755527496338,
0.07150352746248245,
0.3852929174900055,
-0.2471831887960434,
0.34454816579818726,
-0.7408513426780701,
-0.11472874879837036,
-0.8050191402435303,
-0.3766014873981476,
-0.613585889339447,
-0.8848695755004883,
0.10070149600505829,
0.13104979693889618,
-0.2823058068752289,
0.524418830871582,
-0.4844699800014496,
0.7097456455230713,
0.45328229665756226,
0.26624852418899536,
0.1392059624195099,
0.23884928226470947,
-0.16606803238391876,
-0.20154783129692078,
-0.582241415977478,
-0.6455509662628174,
0.8118695020675659,
0.44216984510421753,
0.32641109824180603,
0.04369441047310829,
0.6909253001213074,
0.4120517671108246,
-0.3208422064781189,
-0.8480731844902039,
0.4036007225513458,
-0.6761334538459778,
-0.12737828493118286,
-0.1960858404636383,
-0.12666088342666626,
-0.7416244745254517,
0.33038631081581116,
-0.5033991932868958,
-0.5664699673652649,
0.15782302618026733,
-0.33531561493873596,
-0.4108119308948517,
0.2063007950782776,
-0.8067795634269714,
0.793289840221405,
0.14472085237503052,
-0.20041130483150482,
-0.25846585631370544,
-0.4308125078678131,
-0.22259309887886047,
0.4149850010871887,
-0.0342077799141407,
0.04273277148604393,
-0.2867622673511505,
0.4590117037296295,
-0.38605403900146484,
0.9356719255447388,
-0.12829190492630005,
0.09627839922904968,
0.2051449567079544,
0.07111382484436035,
0.7151082754135132,
0.13188070058822632,
0.03409647196531296,
-0.175542950630188,
-0.3016663193702698,
-0.5952932238578796,
-0.8494095206260681,
0.8206952810287476,
-0.6514788269996643,
-0.29850488901138306,
-0.355111300945282,
-0.16781167685985565,
-0.3309932351112366,
-0.04548276215791702,
0.20887556672096252,
0.3364068269729614,
-0.5185434818267822,
0.5068309307098389,
0.8139148950576782,
-0.4832594394683838,
0.445473313331604,
0.16144075989723206,
-0.1035773828625679,
-0.3899349570274353,
0.5195709466934204,
-0.03560207411646843,
0.147274449467659,
0.8390044569969177,
0.08901654928922653,
-0.16816654801368713,
-0.37235143780708313,
-0.07582477480173111,
0.3708939552307129,
-0.2807106673717499,
-0.21770545840263367,
-0.9613063931465149,
-0.13341985642910004,
-0.3977607190608978,
-0.38465967774391174,
-0.7231388688087463,
-0.7005859613418579,
-0.6338740587234497,
-0.5145378112792969,
0.3297154903411865,
0.6788167357444763,
0.18729260563850403,
0.35082554817199707,
-0.7299025654792786,
0.19110429286956787,
0.3507300913333893,
0.09385630488395691,
-0.10799617320299149,
-0.4565449357032776,
-0.29018092155456543,
-0.2679547965526581,
-0.3725064992904663,
-0.8291706442832947,
0.5178924798965454,
0.32029643654823303,
0.1617916375398636,
0.4253505766391754,
-0.024065271019935608,
0.3219521939754486,
-0.7547475099563599,
1.0190151929855347,
0.16249972581863403,
-0.9915658831596375,
0.7737206816673279,
-0.05748075619339943,
0.14100684225559235,
0.49516698718070984,
0.4514944553375244,
-0.3455366790294647,
-0.32586869597435,
-0.5572422742843628,
-0.8765568733215332,
0.02754468098282814,
0.1551939994096756,
0.5961160659790039,
-0.4159500002861023,
0.3394913673400879,
0.19470958411693573,
0.2906925678253174,
-0.6147849559783936,
-0.06745694577693939,
-0.03785531595349312,
-0.08044695854187012,
0.035314373672008514,
-0.49855607748031616,
0.14239028096199036,
0.17106443643569946,
0.5933719873428345,
0.027406251057982445,
0.6556968092918396,
0.09906608611345291,
-0.14165829122066498,
0.36701640486717224,
0.3363983929157257,
0.4325418472290039,
0.11209241300821304,
-0.16618138551712036,
0.12800201773643494,
-0.12415473163127899,
-0.1233774945139885,
-0.12024102360010147,
0.19101695716381073,
-0.1723734587430954,
0.14078667759895325,
0.26454654335975647,
0.9733205437660217,
0.39528945088386536,
-0.5148522257804871,
0.7578022480010986,
-0.20834790170192719,
0.03327951207756996,
-0.24784544110298157,
-0.22810079157352448,
0.21338346600532532,
0.2501855790615082,
0.09882765263319016,
0.0349729098379612,
0.3269207179546356,
-0.6686795353889465,
0.29011914134025574,
0.09164559096097946,
-0.7073445320129395,
-0.21830493211746216,
0.506749153137207,
0.32412436604499817,
-0.30297091603279114,
0.7272220849990845,
-0.1930653601884842,
-0.41911181807518005,
0.43334588408470154,
0.5955079197883606,
0.9624196887016296,
-0.023445909842848778,
0.7300694584846497,
0.369337797164917,
0.22000795602798462,
-0.18007422983646393,
0.2877804934978485,
0.14794598519802094,
-0.7380362749099731,
-0.4849095344543457,
-0.5213354229927063,
-0.0728786289691925,
-0.14684732258319855,
-0.914046585559845,
0.08249370753765106,
-0.3889020085334778,
-0.10621184855699539,
-0.3107108473777771,
-0.03489496558904648,
-0.5910335779190063,
0.031724750995635986,
-0.020751843228936195,
0.7907863259315491,
-1.287994146347046,
0.6100038290023804,
0.3652529716491699,
-0.4841805100440979,
-0.3093469738960266,
-0.013740969821810722,
-0.3130541741847992,
-0.5805025100708008,
0.34939295053482056,
0.3412338197231293,
-0.004358310252428055,
-0.14640197157859802,
-0.22413325309753418,
-0.4078311622142792,
1.1440068483352661,
0.5379273295402527,
-0.5621693730354309,
-0.14000561833381653,
0.03443776071071625,
0.8087286949157715,
-0.8320608735084534,
-0.029607806354761124,
0.2536638379096985,
0.008313635364174843,
-0.12307864427566528,
-0.4418991506099701,
0.13712923228740692,
-0.14444579184055328,
0.4334568977355957,
-0.035840097814798355,
-0.6371241807937622,
0.6416990756988525,
-0.08079254627227783,
-0.3101198077201843,
0.13649915158748627,
0.7793458104133606,
0.1287127584218979,
0.024968033656477928,
0.2570253014564514,
1.2251402139663696,
0.8300018906593323,
-0.09803227335214615,
1.2619589567184448,
-0.21612489223480225,
0.5247599482536316,
1.5067389011383057,
-0.12019361555576324,
1.3385121822357178,
0.3833739161491394,
-0.15192469954490662,
0.8842965960502625,
0.42164725065231323,
0.08227448165416718,
0.6944088935852051,
0.15866874158382416,
-0.12819534540176392,
-0.11693443357944489,
-0.18563289940357208,
-0.26610317826271057,
0.4144662022590637,
0.2775987684726715,
-0.9122364521026611,
0.12242022156715393,
0.22911322116851807,
0.21539755165576935,
0.7179234623908997,
0.0252823568880558,
0.6863557696342468,
0.12453050911426544,
-0.38063400983810425,
0.23358753323554993,
-0.04437181353569031,
0.6867787837982178,
-0.20052053034305573,
0.0033271743450313807,
-0.17334690690040588,
-0.20194348692893982,
0.29672953486442566,
-0.6298075914382935,
0.3740515410900116,
-0.04239111766219139,
-0.373711496591568,
-0.5160034894943237,
0.38461387157440186,
-0.40047135949134827,
-0.6552684903144836,
0.492427796125412,
0.5094980597496033,
-0.03460275009274483,
-0.3048143684864044,
-0.6587592363357544,
-0.0772562325000763,
-0.276028573513031,
-0.3065716326236725,
0.20591974258422852,
0.7275477647781372,
0.610515832901001,
0.2717795968055725,
0.2612305283546448,
0.09872756898403168,
-0.03232523798942566,
0.4239586591720581,
0.644980251789093,
-0.4593763053417206,
-0.7795772552490234,
-0.5490074753761292,
0.45830467343330383,
-0.46553465723991394,
-0.11530307680368423,
0.496300607919693,
0.7876617908477783,
0.6001257300376892,
-0.4472523033618927,
0.6002448797225952,
0.19735899567604065,
0.5215330719947815,
-0.7046226859092712,
0.4279443025588989,
-0.4214983284473419,
0.13830599188804626,
-0.06733398884534836,
-0.981835663318634,
-0.3173532485961914,
0.6964578032493591,
-0.05570518970489502,
-0.1920737475156784,
1.0942331552505493,
0.674828052520752,
0.037453729659318924,
0.10621213912963867,
0.49095818400382996,
0.3309132158756256,
0.1498170644044876,
0.5957345366477966,
0.40683215856552124,
-0.8395282030105591,
0.2289578914642334,
-0.15633608400821686,
-0.17046402394771576,
-0.15929321944713593,
-0.9638134241104126,
-0.9181610941886902,
-0.7892522811889648,
-0.37173107266426086,
-0.17145764827728271,
0.08965850621461868,
0.8278666138648987,
0.685828447341919,
-0.6968871355056763,
-0.018518025055527687,
-0.31412461400032043,
-0.05657187104225159,
-0.4512679874897003,
-0.27962660789489746,
0.37978729605674744,
-0.49236807227134705,
-1.0664786100387573,
0.33710721135139465,
0.46646490693092346,
0.06819719076156616,
-0.09943289309740067,
0.3317902386188507,
-0.42369967699050903,
0.3956148028373718,
1.0523613691329956,
-0.12094791233539581,
-0.38577955961227417,
-0.3885713219642639,
0.04286965727806091,
0.007433972787111998,
-0.03450603038072586,
0.9740827679634094,
-0.5378724932670593,
0.29924723505973816,
0.7368283867835999,
0.9509645104408264,
0.7231547832489014,
-0.34240448474884033,
0.6144770383834839,
-1.0156540870666504,
0.2110559493303299,
0.30222639441490173,
0.47304534912109375,
0.3229328691959381,
-0.5179342031478882,
0.43011659383773804,
0.041706085205078125,
-0.5221600532531738,
-0.6166403293609619,
0.27874696254730225,
-1.0433237552642822,
-0.593230128288269,
0.8784754276275635,
-0.46127864718437195,
0.020969850942492485,
0.31537288427352905,
-0.015593957155942917,
0.17432761192321777,
-0.470371812582016,
0.9044774174690247,
0.6974048614501953,
0.004369704518467188,
-0.3025003671646118,
-0.37452560663223267,
0.23939672112464905,
0.24466198682785034,
-0.9113546013832092,
-0.09958381950855255,
0.3287024199962616,
0.009188438765704632,
0.2516912817955017,
0.15103738009929657,
-0.21305613219738007,
-0.11073308438062668,
0.13025711476802826,
-0.24881476163864136,
-0.10668923705816269,
-0.3971002399921417,
-0.20189274847507477,
0.7413721084594727,
-0.21315106749534607,
-0.35239309072494507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14762v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14762v2
|
MT-Bench-101: A Fine-Grained Benchmark for Evaluating Large Language Models in Multi-Turn Dialogues
| 2024-02-22T18:21:59 | 2024-06-25T13:38:41 |
Ge Bai, Jie Liu, Xingyuan Bu, Yancheng He, Jiaheng Liu, Zhanhui Zhou, Zhuoran Lin, Wenbo Su, Tiezheng Ge, Bo Zheng, Wanli Ouyang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has drastically enhanced dialogue
systems. However, comprehensively evaluating the dialogue abilities of LLMs
remains a challenge. Previous benchmarks have primarily focused on single-turn
dialogues or provided coarse-grained and incomplete assessments of multi-turn
dialogues, overlooking the complexity and fine-grained nuances of real-life
dialogues. To address this issue, we introduce MT-Bench-101, specifically
designed to evaluate the fine-grained abilities of LLMs in multi-turn
dialogues. By conducting a detailed analysis of real multi-turn dialogue data,
we construct a three-tier hierarchical ability taxonomy comprising 4208 turns
across 1388 multi-turn dialogues in 13 distinct tasks. We then evaluate 21
popular LLMs based on MT-Bench-101, conducting comprehensive analyses from both
ability and task perspectives and observing differing trends in LLMs
performance across dialogue turns within various tasks. Further analysis
indicates that neither utilizing common alignment techniques nor chat-specific
designs has led to obvious enhancements in the multi-turn abilities of LLMs.
Extensive case studies suggest that our designed tasks accurately assess the
corresponding multi-turn abilities. The data and code are available at
\url{https://github.com/mtbench101/mt-bench-101}.
|
[
-0.5934553742408752,
-0.8276588320732117,
0.6711335182189941,
0.39914143085479736,
-0.01588572934269905,
0.3196089565753937,
-0.42706960439682007,
-0.11537924408912659,
0.07540134340524673,
0.47417116165161133,
-0.7292049527168274,
-0.4629374146461487,
-0.5735947489738464,
0.033076703548431396,
-0.4250224232673645,
0.7002023458480835,
0.12815000116825104,
0.4628702402114868,
-0.28777170181274414,
-0.42427143454551697,
-0.5264423489570618,
-0.42677491903305054,
-0.3873448967933655,
-0.25829872488975525,
0.5129796266555786,
0.4279116690158844,
0.3776364326477051,
0.27579620480537415,
0.4792942404747009,
0.36540016531944275,
0.07282058149576187,
0.29804563522338867,
-0.5345825552940369,
0.33380764722824097,
0.08907423913478851,
-0.3329569101333618,
-0.8260132670402527,
0.07937145233154297,
0.8202158212661743,
0.8374728560447693,
-0.23680758476257324,
0.405263215303421,
0.09858705848455429,
0.7516212463378906,
-0.47252610325813293,
0.22303302586078644,
-0.7095938920974731,
-0.22544853389263153,
-0.4692891836166382,
-0.16842731833457947,
-0.5541030764579773,
-0.31061625480651855,
0.06778352707624435,
-0.37379148602485657,
-0.11447735130786896,
0.11156969517469406,
0.4956969618797302,
0.11980240046977997,
-0.10326007753610611,
0.0010118319187313318,
-0.7089165449142456,
0.9231888651847839,
-0.8011975884437561,
0.291936993598938,
0.1755993813276291,
0.7733815908432007,
-0.22588862478733063,
-0.6487941741943359,
-0.6065041422843933,
-0.259174644947052,
0.1473279446363449,
0.06015678495168686,
-0.014636592008173466,
0.036011528223752975,
0.33357372879981995,
0.42645007371902466,
-0.3674582540988922,
-0.08312780410051346,
0.08402621746063232,
0.03606751933693886,
0.2822336256504059,
0.5540022850036621,
0.07398923486471176,
-0.2056179940700531,
-0.1412201225757599,
-0.3309379816055298,
-0.4974074363708496,
0.18632425367832184,
0.2048313170671463,
0.5647227168083191,
-0.027594001963734627,
0.6319656372070312,
-0.5254747867584229,
0.6792821884155273,
-0.07996191084384918,
-0.47761523723602295,
0.34986746311187744,
-0.40607938170433044,
-0.1623031049966812,
-0.3308032155036926,
1.0464235544204712,
0.4382942020893097,
0.39135977625846863,
-0.16824854910373688,
-0.029145274311304092,
-0.3513248562812805,
0.3895089626312256,
-0.7440195679664612,
0.1251615583896637,
0.1972082555294037,
-0.387663334608078,
-0.20182040333747864,
-0.1819254457950592,
-0.8738955855369568,
-0.5411425232887268,
-0.4820772707462311,
0.49367979168891907,
-0.5012689232826233,
-0.13721342384815216,
-0.2431916445493698,
-0.22634974122047424,
0.28033211827278137,
0.33913201093673706,
-0.5005143880844116,
0.5382407307624817,
0.9646873474121094,
0.7747523188591003,
-0.24308238923549652,
-0.6185311675071716,
-0.9696944355964661,
-0.049723561853170395,
-0.29545164108276367,
0.8773291110992432,
-0.7619646191596985,
-0.2145337164402008,
0.0064268410205841064,
0.09544170647859573,
-0.17591533064842224,
-0.606052041053772,
0.43649575114250183,
-0.062482330948114395,
0.0018777219811454415,
-0.35230162739753723,
-0.1728902906179428,
0.09808109700679779,
0.5781071782112122,
-0.4866276979446411,
1.1018437147140503,
0.05809152498841286,
-0.5001260042190552,
0.1588163673877716,
-0.5160197019577026,
-0.49623018503189087,
-0.11038456112146378,
-0.2553652822971344,
-0.28702807426452637,
0.32933199405670166,
0.054522089660167694,
0.24896971881389618,
-0.5076115727424622,
0.44397780299186707,
-0.632892370223999,
-0.4369359016418457,
0.5745803117752075,
-0.7175623178482056,
0.31661301851272583,
-0.23055560886859894,
-0.2918562591075897,
0.21676138043403625,
-0.752994179725647,
0.44374263286590576,
-0.11075961589813232,
-0.24115410447120667,
-0.11301950365304947,
0.05356089398264885,
-0.13867340981960297,
0.2226358950138092,
0.0049114651046693325,
-0.5426828861236572,
0.21103535592556,
-0.18576008081436157,
0.1888369917869568,
0.5467108488082886,
-0.2099010944366455,
0.210637167096138,
-0.47358646988868713,
0.18907442688941956,
-0.28394943475723267,
0.2307928055524826,
-0.197492778301239,
-0.5350843667984009,
-0.9400157332420349,
-0.5376553535461426,
0.4403052031993866,
0.5424234867095947,
-0.6418351531028748,
0.20869188010692596,
-0.4908275604248047,
-0.6182352304458618,
-0.702994704246521,
0.01830204203724861,
0.6865812540054321,
0.003952127881348133,
0.5730985999107361,
-0.4654124975204468,
-0.21550115942955017,
-1.1218338012695312,
-0.6376459002494812,
0.1330963522195816,
-0.15974386036396027,
0.5584360957145691,
0.07051510363817215,
-0.05820004269480705,
0.8319638967514038,
-0.2991202175617218,
-0.25674569606781006,
-0.3944503366947174,
0.5111414194107056,
0.026877090334892273,
0.3106304705142975,
0.28058046102523804,
-0.18751415610313416,
-0.6019417643547058,
-0.13303977251052856,
-0.4880278706550598,
-0.31498000025749207,
0.005185071378946304,
-0.31164976954460144,
0.17548087239265442,
0.3623046278953552,
-0.7780174612998962,
0.4386923909187317,
0.6035327315330505,
0.19174553453922272,
0.5393211245536804,
-0.11283395439386368,
0.30520710349082947,
-0.9594303369522095,
0.20513318479061127,
-0.11912557482719421,
-0.11604662984609604,
-0.7515343427658081,
-0.17528054118156433,
0.1614118069410324,
-0.030035562813282013,
-0.2764209806919098,
0.48993781208992004,
-0.20749814808368683,
-0.49713262915611267,
-0.2195063680410385,
0.3009713292121887,
-0.12173791974782944,
0.7371540665626526,
-0.0025768589694052935,
0.6790158152580261,
0.28318604826927185,
-0.4360988140106201,
0.19643904268741608,
0.06795737147331238,
-0.49675947427749634,
0.8340474367141724,
-0.38832056522369385,
0.1949421763420105,
0.24676263332366943,
0.41914886236190796,
-1.2865209579467773,
-0.16204366087913513,
-0.17653506994247437,
-0.3585088551044464,
0.5437790751457214,
-0.38878369331359863,
-0.6439903974533081,
-0.28661173582077026,
-0.45229464769363403,
0.2726869285106659,
0.2001509666442871,
-0.25832030177116394,
0.9630782604217529,
0.3829770088195801,
-0.509780764579773,
-0.4533742070198059,
-0.4493604600429535,
0.27755817770957947,
-0.10108278691768646,
-0.460068017244339,
0.3251577615737915,
-0.18129609525203705,
-0.2736932039260864,
-0.5192610621452332,
-0.22732987999916077,
0.03305843099951744,
-0.12699195742607117,
0.34099307656288147,
0.10035669058561325,
-0.14977292716503143,
-0.1517268419265747,
-0.035896386951208115,
-0.3483550548553467,
-0.040346886962652206,
0.1741344928741455,
0.9982316493988037,
-0.31737372279167175,
-0.6024889945983887,
-0.41093891859054565,
0.2642519176006317,
1.1080234050750732,
-0.22237570583820343,
0.5728830099105835,
0.555758535861969,
-0.0723123624920845,
0.10703492909669876,
-0.9671878814697266,
0.0543932281434536,
-0.43673184514045715,
0.31308501958847046,
-0.5714451670646667,
-0.5389405488967896,
0.3638726770877838,
-0.39123114943504333,
0.24994145333766937,
0.3572390079498291,
0.5942164063453674,
-0.130682110786438,
1.1380640268325806,
0.24280096590518951,
0.05643729120492935,
0.3500446379184723,
-0.11393164843320847,
0.1996164470911026,
-1.2872544527053833,
-0.2740902006626129,
-0.6813742518424988,
-0.48139289021492004,
-0.5296452641487122,
-0.6243703365325928,
0.31306132674217224,
-0.10017330199480057,
-0.40141060948371887,
0.39668968319892883,
-0.14384375512599945,
0.25205081701278687,
0.5478118062019348,
-0.17572589218616486,
0.4484102427959442,
-0.2536517381668091,
-0.3678666651248932,
-0.2023828625679016,
-0.45204854011535645,
-0.6317939758300781,
1.0898464918136597,
0.4232719838619232,
0.6747101545333862,
0.174330934882164,
0.43463921546936035,
0.013230119831860065,
0.6559950113296509,
-0.9402480721473694,
0.7644147276878357,
-0.16047431528568268,
-0.5912933945655823,
-0.44370266795158386,
-0.5734285712242126,
-0.6048222184181213,
0.5121595859527588,
-0.1942634880542755,
-0.6722139716148376,
-0.19778980314731598,
-0.2230243682861328,
-0.22724713385105133,
0.20576587319374084,
-0.7976822853088379,
0.9852526187896729,
-0.5042985677719116,
-0.27998077869415283,
-0.3240393102169037,
-0.3826802968978882,
0.35076436400413513,
-0.16254295408725739,
0.43831875920295715,
-0.41766393184661865,
0.2627985179424286,
0.5597341060638428,
-0.38089439272880554,
0.8411940336227417,
-0.3489859700202942,
0.0733276903629303,
0.02305866964161396,
0.24526676535606384,
0.4355669319629669,
0.0683574229478836,
-0.004359784070402384,
0.04376395791769028,
0.2596258223056793,
-0.23321940004825592,
-0.33624252676963806,
0.943150520324707,
-0.6273355484008789,
-0.482616126537323,
-0.26772522926330566,
-0.5782688856124878,
-0.878773033618927,
0.1773981750011444,
-0.217485710978508,
0.8081995248794556,
-0.5129079222679138,
0.4526688754558563,
0.31162649393081665,
-0.30738958716392517,
0.4976872205734253,
0.8512037396430969,
-0.2781967520713806,
-0.5385433435440063,
0.94287109375,
0.23812517523765564,
0.46103569865226746,
0.2883639335632324,
0.1359289139509201,
-0.2216990441083908,
-0.47839757800102234,
-0.6673011183738708,
0.05752238258719444,
-0.4451075792312622,
-0.34752219915390015,
-0.7416343092918396,
-0.13584254682064056,
-0.033351682126522064,
0.2766241729259491,
-0.626071572303772,
-0.5004962086677551,
0.3419165015220642,
0.29623910784721375,
0.11297357827425003,
0.6442776322364807,
0.2908916473388672,
0.21145708858966827,
-0.7988165020942688,
0.4836919903755188,
0.552207350730896,
0.7471749186515808,
0.23322921991348267,
-0.5652573704719543,
0.009837482124567032,
0.11601510643959045,
-0.5110152363777161,
-0.2580745220184326,
0.16823919117450714,
0.13701020181179047,
0.7649848461151123,
0.17942672967910767,
0.036168172955513,
0.8933650255203247,
-0.8866093754768372,
0.641330361366272,
0.1895672082901001,
-0.9226117730140686,
0.13295294344425201,
-0.2868647873401642,
0.564834713935852,
0.9445354342460632,
0.027334067970514297,
-0.5799123048782349,
-0.5699599385261536,
-0.43020787835121155,
-0.6282007694244385,
0.8870667815208435,
0.25765615701675415,
0.1674688458442688,
-0.02211076021194458,
-0.1074206531047821,
0.20179517567157745,
0.3165670931339264,
-0.4956248998641968,
-0.27126961946487427,
-0.12061000615358353,
-0.1118684932589531,
-0.0412176288664341,
-0.13323502242565155,
-0.3612336814403534,
-0.19329440593719482,
0.37040796875953674,
-0.2566167712211609,
0.23622773587703705,
-0.2586110234260559,
-0.03491751104593277,
-0.14584946632385254,
0.5290056467056274,
0.6883282661437988,
0.6366084218025208,
-0.5046331286430359,
0.08068892359733582,
0.5479311347007751,
-0.3458426594734192,
-0.17960268259048462,
0.299345463514328,
0.3844980299472809,
-0.06290442496538162,
0.3904719352722168,
0.5553503036499023,
0.5229942202568054,
-0.6849426031112671,
0.4967016875743866,
-0.2926951050758362,
-0.1215825304389,
-0.04455846920609474,
-0.0008368327398784459,
0.2179899960756302,
0.20010064542293549,
0.5306153893470764,
0.21584618091583252,
-0.03441312909126282,
-0.8895701766014099,
-0.03536820039153099,
0.7115450501441956,
-0.5038633942604065,
-0.09177809953689575,
-0.018063027411699295,
0.37465354800224304,
-0.5069613456726074,
0.43046602606773376,
-0.0827530100941658,
-0.4146420657634735,
0.2692092955112457,
0.17552942037582397,
0.897461473941803,
-0.1043427437543869,
0.031141623854637146,
0.31032878160476685,
0.17996960878372192,
-0.020703790709376335,
0.05771198868751526,
0.005133124068379402,
-0.448272168636322,
-0.6899021863937378,
-0.6920841932296753,
-0.7661715149879456,
0.3793235123157501,
-0.7040044069290161,
0.06886212527751923,
-0.2739485502243042,
-0.4025149345397949,
0.2682129740715027,
0.04751822352409363,
-0.645780086517334,
-0.10769594460725784,
0.11042705923318863,
0.9507202506065369,
-0.32692432403564453,
0.8503623604774475,
0.4170529842376709,
0.08228331059217453,
-0.25591814517974854,
0.13225340843200684,
0.146873340010643,
-0.8689368963241577,
0.26990193128585815,
0.36247125267982483,
-0.34220483899116516,
-0.2745032012462616,
-0.35634657740592957,
-0.6268302798271179,
1.0703198909759521,
0.11577344685792923,
-0.599209189414978,
0.2333933711051941,
0.47445377707481384,
0.6098026633262634,
-0.559163510799408,
0.595557689666748,
0.8032329082489014,
0.6280030012130737,
0.037423551082611084,
-1.400017499923706,
-0.26654213666915894,
-0.17646610736846924,
-0.12139100581407547,
0.403374046087265,
-0.7732195854187012,
0.5869089961051941,
0.12409467250108719,
-0.0020940443500876427,
0.4235366880893707,
0.06530069559812546,
0.4851299524307251,
0.46360790729522705,
0.503993570804596,
0.6453337073326111,
0.5000134110450745,
-0.5749734044075012,
1.0539157390594482,
-0.3622409701347351,
0.17610161006450653,
1.2632150650024414,
-0.5493554472923279,
1.2148910760879517,
0.3454117178916931,
-0.29835250973701477,
0.41294407844543457,
0.045969560742378235,
0.31753551959991455,
0.4735077917575836,
0.4134908616542816,
-0.041108377277851105,
-0.5980314016342163,
-0.0497414693236351,
-0.316687673330307,
0.4435913860797882,
0.49768656492233276,
0.014066663570702076,
-0.15259511768817902,
-0.0636545792222023,
-0.16923512518405914,
-0.10641152411699295,
-0.046443190425634384,
1.0307226181030273,
0.005952046252787113,
-0.8250948786735535,
0.5497039556503296,
0.036019522696733475,
0.49896150827407837,
-0.6326510906219482,
0.034929241985082626,
-0.32995128631591797,
0.33261874318122864,
0.10749925673007965,
-0.9950988292694092,
0.09132865816354752,
0.187993124127388,
-0.09986294060945511,
-0.21305914223194122,
0.3274610638618469,
-0.3741600513458252,
-0.3953619599342346,
0.28325045108795166,
0.7336622476577759,
0.04996338114142418,
-0.27674853801727295,
-0.6763821244239807,
0.3861355781555176,
-0.12508872151374817,
-0.06976970285177231,
0.6630362272262573,
0.6841290593147278,
-0.06134811416268349,
0.7311535477638245,
0.5616884827613831,
-0.30946117639541626,
-0.1672910749912262,
0.5589534640312195,
0.9467709064483643,
-0.8282187581062317,
0.19870182871818542,
-0.66853266954422,
0.47384026646614075,
-0.31965258717536926,
-0.36766481399536133,
0.6510780453681946,
0.7845120429992676,
0.4632338583469391,
0.08651182055473328,
0.6506470441818237,
-0.016412612050771713,
0.9289828538894653,
-0.2930220365524292,
0.4756673574447632,
-0.36854052543640137,
0.18062008917331696,
-0.4944823384284973,
-1.0976402759552002,
0.08397816866636276,
0.4323458671569824,
-0.4848305583000183,
0.1713651716709137,
0.7492535710334778,
0.6777269244194031,
-0.13841454684734344,
0.05268605053424835,
0.29647424817085266,
0.22842766344547272,
0.33435195684432983,
0.44869592785835266,
1.2049680948257446,
-0.3545857071876526,
0.8838853240013123,
-0.15008556842803955,
-0.43490293622016907,
-0.3524435758590698,
-0.7919008731842041,
-1.170294165611267,
-0.38398557901382446,
-0.04796447604894638,
-0.2805619537830353,
-0.24050591886043549,
0.7330071330070496,
0.840251088142395,
-0.8511884808540344,
-0.46861547231674194,
0.16629494726657867,
-0.11659591645002365,
-0.23710371553897858,
-0.2122044861316681,
0.08221250027418137,
-0.5019904971122742,
-0.7938828468322754,
0.6974722743034363,
0.5494822859764099,
-0.13242065906524658,
-0.34102222323417664,
-0.16385143995285034,
-0.16907568275928497,
0.24808889627456665,
0.8056172132492065,
0.05659610405564308,
-0.852907121181488,
-0.15487512946128845,
0.12384556233882904,
-0.24059826135635376,
0.012351708486676216,
0.8973135352134705,
-0.6050100922584534,
0.5351212620735168,
0.28390365839004517,
0.4641241729259491,
0.7432051301002502,
0.11107293516397476,
0.6740492582321167,
-0.6653661727905273,
-0.16969026625156403,
-0.04644787311553955,
0.28920555114746094,
0.4896870255470276,
0.5116251707077026,
0.42531251907348633,
-0.010462609119713306,
-0.4387294352054596,
-0.9932401180267334,
-0.06181911751627922,
-1.1513521671295166,
-0.09003722667694092,
1.0346776247024536,
0.06157069280743599,
0.04700056463479996,
-0.11717738956212997,
-0.438984751701355,
0.03373061493039131,
-0.3974679410457611,
0.6683329343795776,
1.0042475461959839,
-0.15597054362297058,
-0.09390366822481155,
-0.8034331202507019,
0.47244134545326233,
0.4631343483924866,
-0.9250157475471497,
0.44776979088783264,
0.29512137174606323,
0.0966925323009491,
0.4850829243659973,
0.38319894671440125,
-0.252774715423584,
0.06564030051231384,
-0.26870641112327576,
-0.17635975778102875,
0.08527383208274841,
-0.461876779794693,
0.033804986625909805,
0.14328721165657043,
0.21561887860298157,
0.04485858976840973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14760v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14760v2
|
Generalizing Reward Modeling for Out-of-Distribution Preference Learning
| 2024-02-22T18:20:33 | 2024-06-08T16:10:45 |
Chen Jia
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Preference learning (PL) with large language models (LLMs) aims to align the
LLMs' generations with human preferences. Previous work on reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF) has demonstrated promising results in
in-distribution PL. However, due to the difficulty of obtaining human feedback,
discretely training reward models for every encountered distribution is
challenging. Thus, out-of-distribution (OOD) PL is practically useful for
enhancing the generalization ability of LLMs with limited preference feedback.
This work addresses OOD PL by optimizing a general reward model through a
meta-learning approach. During meta-training, a bilevel optimization algorithm
is utilized to learn a reward model capable of guiding policy learning to align
with human preferences across various distributions. When encountering a test
distribution, the meta-test procedure conducts regularized policy optimization
using the learned reward model for PL. We theoretically demonstrate the
convergence rate of the bilevel optimization algorithm under reasonable
assumptions. Additionally, we conduct experiments on two text generation tasks
across 20 held-out domains and outperform a variety of strong baselines across
various evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.36558476090431213,
-0.22847147285938263,
0.4317663908004761,
0.021326588466763496,
-0.3985937833786011,
-0.2809901237487793,
-0.6151061654090881,
0.09791301190853119,
0.07082187384366989,
0.6004642844200134,
-0.6895137429237366,
-0.3432977497577667,
-0.43562051653862,
0.0986400619149208,
0.3134438693523407,
1.3979300260543823,
0.018501462414860725,
-0.13725769519805908,
-0.20926807820796967,
-0.1448577642440796,
-0.2061576396226883,
-0.5061917901039124,
-0.3170589506626129,
-0.509473979473114,
0.4024369716644287,
0.6578642725944519,
0.35785290598869324,
0.3608231842517853,
0.29315388202667236,
0.17916715145111084,
0.19907782971858978,
0.3748714029788971,
-0.7643621563911438,
0.03389974683523178,
-0.5479150414466858,
-0.24825763702392578,
-0.1989285796880722,
-0.035273440182209015,
0.601793646812439,
0.603675901889801,
-0.39162111282348633,
0.01194741576910019,
0.2951345145702362,
0.7176241874694824,
-0.9351882338523865,
0.2752046287059784,
-0.616208016872406,
-0.1271141618490219,
-0.019892673939466476,
-0.41955748200416565,
-0.723198652267456,
-0.6714615225791931,
0.3903355300426483,
-0.5551308989524841,
0.20253346860408783,
0.14151811599731445,
0.6135820150375366,
0.11349059641361237,
-0.37370240688323975,
-0.5585405230522156,
-0.5364327430725098,
1.0898176431655884,
-0.39571431279182434,
0.2610730528831482,
0.47986480593681335,
0.2961290180683136,
-0.09343532472848892,
-0.11985805630683899,
-0.41314712166786194,
-0.196578249335289,
0.04952111840248108,
0.1497245728969574,
0.2665727436542511,
0.05485212057828903,
-0.3155894875526428,
0.15807528793811798,
-0.43609556555747986,
0.03838640823960304,
-0.02848958410322666,
0.3595632314682007,
0.6431371569633484,
0.1350170224905014,
-0.12658151984214783,
-0.24420951306819916,
-0.40991079807281494,
-0.6389583349227905,
-0.5291998386383057,
0.37425756454467773,
0.6851770281791687,
0.4821479320526123,
-0.0369853712618351,
0.52372145652771,
-0.0626525804400444,
0.5098987221717834,
0.272086501121521,
-0.23869414627552032,
0.5201454162597656,
-0.057273995131254196,
-0.19150960445404053,
-0.19917424023151398,
0.7672682404518127,
0.3238014578819275,
0.2701946794986725,
-0.10466668754816055,
-0.29247719049453735,
-0.2413732409477234,
0.25231626629829407,
-0.696569561958313,
0.0419328548014164,
-0.110826276242733,
-0.6813287734985352,
-0.5425634980201721,
0.05884963274002075,
-0.9917569160461426,
-0.4986259639263153,
-0.15190689265727997,
0.4231734871864319,
-0.21564671397209167,
-0.4273287057876587,
0.4271920323371887,
-0.160017728805542,
0.016530673950910568,
-0.007132377941161394,
-1.6059305667877197,
0.28294840455055237,
0.4412374794483185,
0.5381490588188171,
-0.4152369201183319,
-0.23961858451366425,
-0.7183418869972229,
0.23594728112220764,
-0.20875431597232819,
0.7497913837432861,
-0.5766374468803406,
-0.5809041857719421,
0.13634449243545532,
-0.10214415192604065,
-0.25393497943878174,
-0.5993698835372925,
0.5905070304870605,
-0.6947759389877319,
0.20967991650104523,
-0.33734044432640076,
-0.3910031020641327,
-0.019347742199897766,
0.2978023886680603,
-0.4707375168800354,
0.8195809721946716,
0.4970720410346985,
-0.8825438022613525,
0.7036054730415344,
-0.858299195766449,
-0.32020291686058044,
-0.07422540336847305,
-0.19225764274597168,
-0.5895106792449951,
0.22212156653404236,
0.07138477265834808,
0.2821692228317261,
-0.35531899333000183,
0.3689602017402649,
-0.4533803164958954,
-0.3279319405555725,
0.10136506706476212,
-0.19470243155956268,
0.4595808684825897,
0.10157996416091919,
-0.5652114152908325,
0.1944861263036728,
-0.4940308928489685,
-0.1381319761276245,
0.10000690072774887,
-0.7034912109375,
-0.5818281769752502,
0.16247199475765228,
-0.1242503672838211,
-0.001354134175926447,
-0.020003696903586388,
-0.573527455329895,
0.5202994346618652,
-0.7355523109436035,
0.47391238808631897,
0.9195080399513245,
0.019565092399716377,
0.9603234529495239,
-0.2172306925058365,
0.40155670046806335,
-0.04781045392155647,
0.3063724935054779,
0.14071014523506165,
-0.2395712435245514,
-0.4147389531135559,
-0.2723871171474457,
0.3783133029937744,
0.3011496067047119,
-0.6134753823280334,
0.6849367022514343,
-0.3546997904777527,
-0.09495437890291214,
-0.31711286306381226,
0.11681729555130005,
0.3035324513912201,
0.5259456038475037,
0.4183574914932251,
-0.2803625762462616,
-0.1356719434261322,
-0.6892671585083008,
-0.11657030135393143,
-0.11374221742153168,
0.02245021052658558,
0.5679720044136047,
0.5649061799049377,
-0.5339017510414124,
1.2943984270095825,
-0.6653281450271606,
-0.30133411288261414,
-0.5555206537246704,
0.30508553981781006,
0.22406920790672302,
0.12274383753538132,
0.45276492834091187,
-0.7495785355567932,
-0.5812527537345886,
-0.02988424524664879,
-0.19976821541786194,
0.0171254463493824,
0.21924848854541779,
-0.11200131475925446,
0.5293735861778259,
0.003460870822891593,
-0.23098605871200562,
0.24891147017478943,
0.5387959480285645,
-0.043272845447063446,
0.5421770215034485,
-0.5961151719093323,
-0.03817709535360336,
-0.6677869558334351,
0.01570643112063408,
-0.20460079610347748,
-0.1777895987033844,
-0.26353058218955994,
-0.2505831718444824,
0.21854546666145325,
-0.08380911499261856,
-0.4080561697483063,
0.719595193862915,
-0.2692663371562958,
-0.19951428472995758,
-0.34730666875839233,
-0.17170225083827972,
-0.06276267766952515,
0.6889048218727112,
0.5466671586036682,
0.5704159140586853,
0.3306669592857361,
-0.8034271597862244,
0.11081240326166153,
0.10058798640966415,
-0.21288450062274933,
0.5491267442703247,
-0.47843486070632935,
-0.1262114942073822,
-0.3950701057910919,
0.3961118459701538,
-1.0315734148025513,
-0.28929924964904785,
0.4329510033130646,
-0.17448745667934418,
0.09791214019060135,
0.018520286306738853,
-0.3300265967845917,
-0.16028529405593872,
-0.5607096552848816,
0.4482852816581726,
0.6677663922309875,
-0.9783743023872375,
0.5194031596183777,
0.2367621213197708,
0.03287564590573311,
-0.6369178295135498,
-0.3180491328239441,
-0.7484508156776428,
-0.3678932785987854,
-0.36102986335754395,
0.2919400930404663,
-0.23089304566383362,
0.0650295540690422,
-0.1574276089668274,
0.3348787724971771,
0.2605103552341461,
-0.1995691955089569,
0.027439014986157417,
0.004796439316123724,
0.39307892322540283,
0.5155571103096008,
0.12469899654388428,
-0.1875332146883011,
-0.0963817909359932,
-0.3692043721675873,
0.8361018300056458,
-0.032676368951797485,
-0.23410391807556152,
0.2750876247882843,
0.36464929580688477,
0.08670184761285782,
-0.2478756457567215,
0.7553004622459412,
0.3517896234989166,
0.1698453426361084,
-0.5096144080162048,
-0.1951877474784851,
-0.3315046429634094,
-0.47481417655944824,
0.24912692606449127,
-0.2405150681734085,
-0.4640343487262726,
0.02642679400742054,
-0.15962499380111694,
0.1269526332616806,
0.22191502153873444,
0.5812245011329651,
-0.091966412961483,
1.11619234085083,
0.8216469883918762,
-0.039386287331581116,
0.5746741890907288,
-0.41549575328826904,
-0.005637352354824543,
-0.6972216963768005,
-0.22988659143447876,
-0.2842817008495331,
-0.12555758655071259,
-0.4623453915119171,
-0.22400221228599548,
0.5509318113327026,
-0.0554940402507782,
-0.38841864466667175,
-0.012329231016337872,
-0.3730226159095764,
0.44337016344070435,
0.8163357973098755,
0.2826004922389984,
0.09223572909832001,
0.14672739803791046,
-0.36896607279777527,
0.06339969485998154,
-0.5750532150268555,
-0.16971559822559357,
1.4611902236938477,
0.2489546686410904,
0.9183549880981445,
0.007593576796352863,
1.0243669748306274,
0.2947356104850769,
0.5445058941841125,
-0.5026668906211853,
0.0829346626996994,
-0.44056159257888794,
-0.25412458181381226,
-0.5223746299743652,
-0.6218090653419495,
-0.8684649467468262,
0.24313874542713165,
-0.1303527057170868,
-0.36628830432891846,
0.43931570649147034,
0.3874480724334717,
-0.3798888027667999,
0.15726210176944733,
-0.5117456316947937,
0.8898701071739197,
-0.3367324769496918,
-0.17396976053714752,
-0.15947628021240234,
-0.8449293971061707,
0.560154378414154,
0.072000652551651,
0.40387678146362305,
0.14932571351528168,
0.03843115270137787,
0.517691433429718,
-0.2985263168811798,
0.7487601637840271,
-0.17194779217243195,
-0.1575927883386612,
-0.00007084902608767152,
-0.3118167221546173,
0.6442829370498657,
0.08764394372701645,
-0.1302768439054489,
-0.37578821182250977,
-0.45794975757598877,
-0.20431704819202423,
-0.557109534740448,
0.3728772699832916,
-1.0802048444747925,
-0.17750532925128937,
-0.37561073899269104,
-0.5604667663574219,
-0.35712531208992004,
0.016315847635269165,
0.6741585731506348,
0.45638537406921387,
-0.1953384280204773,
0.022148223593831062,
1.0531331300735474,
-0.46920642256736755,
0.45764967799186707,
0.4567480683326721,
-0.22677351534366608,
-0.7544785141944885,
1.1871542930603027,
-0.27200403809547424,
0.5272570252418518,
0.6007242798805237,
0.7174818515777588,
-0.8507357835769653,
-0.11749526858329773,
-0.43281030654907227,
0.4620300233364105,
-0.743057906627655,
-0.010203378275036812,
-0.4878558814525604,
0.1969788372516632,
-0.5290212035179138,
-0.28338757157325745,
-0.11949576437473297,
0.0680990144610405,
-0.42259591817855835,
0.05011816695332527,
0.02149670012295246,
0.6196810007095337,
-0.2823791801929474,
0.46868887543678284,
-0.5404987335205078,
0.28930971026420593,
0.5205392837524414,
0.39415013790130615,
-0.11883256584405899,
-0.5959154963493347,
-0.058644697070121765,
0.1474055051803589,
-0.5024523138999939,
-0.845244288444519,
0.42827731370925903,
0.24509629607200623,
0.5301365852355957,
0.6733458638191223,
0.3551275134086609,
0.17229466140270233,
-0.4053608179092407,
0.4349944293498993,
0.4477778971195221,
-0.749869167804718,
0.3907638490200043,
-0.36141106486320496,
0.09437161684036255,
0.6813496947288513,
0.4762008786201477,
-0.3924296200275421,
0.09027153998613358,
-0.687688946723938,
-0.7279043197631836,
0.7199373245239258,
-0.31701818108558655,
0.10005740076303482,
-0.27038100361824036,
0.23170723021030426,
0.443745881319046,
0.571967363357544,
-0.8485902547836304,
-0.1422581672668457,
-0.40592581033706665,
-0.19054917991161346,
-0.5855300426483154,
-0.256617933511734,
-0.11837644129991531,
-0.04129621759057045,
0.5694845914840698,
-0.3760702311992645,
0.07393571734428406,
-0.05100316181778908,
-0.21049290895462036,
-0.2083294540643692,
0.5134072303771973,
0.8708456754684448,
0.5132607221603394,
-0.561968207359314,
0.08825406432151794,
-0.12472528964281082,
-0.23673035204410553,
0.35724371671676636,
-0.1742030382156372,
-0.28537410497665405,
-0.2040889859199524,
-0.20996282994747162,
1.0219788551330566,
0.223170667886734,
-0.6957954168319702,
0.8851845264434814,
0.011860857717692852,
-0.4682508409023285,
0.02146279253065586,
-0.0006089920061640441,
0.01013027410954237,
0.010242622345685959,
0.22052273154258728,
-0.09903218597173691,
0.14109177887439728,
-0.6902259588241577,
0.08555314689874649,
0.6484927535057068,
-0.2837040424346924,
-0.12515538930892944,
0.4231606721878052,
0.3817552626132965,
-0.1250215470790863,
0.5325266122817993,
-0.5512650012969971,
-0.6018450856208801,
0.2541913092136383,
0.6497159600257874,
0.8416545391082764,
-0.11613795906305313,
0.7199602723121643,
0.19943001866340637,
0.07824571430683136,
-0.4131321609020233,
0.21462571620941162,
-0.3349513113498688,
-0.6858813166618347,
-0.06901979446411133,
-0.6109046936035156,
-0.5956007838249207,
-0.13977855443954468,
-0.6397749185562134,
0.38564079999923706,
-0.19063928723335266,
-0.15274450182914734,
-0.6202862858772278,
0.04720189794898033,
-0.5740048885345459,
0.1943647712469101,
-0.057353608310222626,
0.6355782151222229,
-1.0412253141403198,
0.7251017689704895,
0.5172111392021179,
-0.3832358419895172,
-0.6063632965087891,
-0.040588971227407455,
-0.43594759702682495,
-0.6747411489486694,
1.0040704011917114,
-0.03090921975672245,
-0.02920176275074482,
0.08764893561601639,
-0.17703263461589813,
-0.5982547998428345,
0.829806923866272,
0.37717583775520325,
-0.4139083921909332,
-0.0469440296292305,
0.31371650099754333,
0.3657333254814148,
-0.6057869791984558,
0.5954005718231201,
0.5668947100639343,
0.41391587257385254,
0.060718610882759094,
-0.6287750601768494,
-0.35644400119781494,
0.24220241606235504,
0.010921915993094444,
0.5492048859596252,
-0.621079683303833,
0.8933380246162415,
-0.25669950246810913,
0.04293205216526985,
-0.30567845702171326,
0.427641898393631,
0.7960283160209656,
0.08459287881851196,
0.8706178665161133,
0.5473771095275879,
0.5702372193336487,
0.32594215869903564,
1.0239923000335693,
0.2641727030277252,
0.6018404364585876,
0.9026190042495728,
-0.3983510732650757,
0.9275804162025452,
0.4789895713329315,
0.06015808880329132,
0.6491482257843018,
0.7770905494689941,
0.38600537180900574,
1.2880942821502686,
0.3638187348842621,
-0.10653381049633026,
-0.21507088840007782,
-0.06038579344749451,
-0.43473508954048157,
-0.08249198645353317,
0.010757570154964924,
-0.5494550466537476,
-0.41204261779785156,
0.27055779099464417,
-0.25975194573402405,
-0.0034697584342211485,
-0.3279518783092499,
0.7791446447372437,
-0.3129918873310089,
-0.8716054558753967,
0.5870444774627686,
0.08219948410987854,
0.8880035281181335,
-0.7125598192214966,
0.11513282358646393,
-0.3053077459335327,
0.5094999670982361,
0.03381536900997162,
-0.4528701603412628,
-0.03693574294447899,
-0.2766962945461273,
-0.49140411615371704,
-0.4215333163738251,
0.4298757016658783,
-0.7641649842262268,
-0.21578830480575562,
0.3041982650756836,
-0.046401649713516235,
-0.08888085186481476,
-0.07460425049066544,
-0.5268114805221558,
-0.10517415404319763,
-0.17649635672569275,
-0.3059442937374115,
0.628803551197052,
0.1788267344236374,
-0.09115824103355408,
0.5300471186637878,
0.496786892414093,
0.14307178556919098,
0.14585408568382263,
0.02782856486737728,
0.6986534595489502,
-0.29215341806411743,
-1.0686339139938354,
-0.7974987030029297,
0.3629485070705414,
0.010480052791535854,
-0.4281765818595886,
0.43952587246894836,
0.37283584475517273,
0.8327264189720154,
-0.44765451550483704,
0.9796002507209778,
0.10676313191652298,
0.6990172266960144,
-0.34277743101119995,
0.26234713196754456,
-0.6457614898681641,
-0.08499831706285477,
-0.2451743632555008,
-0.9696710109710693,
0.06623390316963196,
0.463726669549942,
-0.5928309559822083,
0.060514140874147415,
0.7374064326286316,
0.4735988974571228,
-0.2028687596321106,
-0.2214743047952652,
0.2301269769668579,
-0.5519063472747803,
0.27262261509895325,
0.8691181540489197,
0.7094506621360779,
-0.03606969490647316,
0.6073856949806213,
-0.2979555130004883,
-0.5050668716430664,
-0.44592559337615967,
-1.0606480836868286,
-0.990524172782898,
-0.5171460509300232,
0.17110776901245117,
-0.07027844339609146,
0.12510716915130615,
1.0841375589370728,
0.7539348006248474,
-0.6249803304672241,
-0.4478166103363037,
-0.30841463804244995,
0.10640056431293488,
-0.33788159489631653,
-0.2630336880683899,
0.5043793320655823,
-0.738119900226593,
-0.5624930262565613,
0.12026096880435944,
0.2361164689064026,
-0.1271185576915741,
-0.3974733352661133,
-0.5509467124938965,
-0.006333614233881235,
0.1350836157798767,
0.4003569483757019,
0.28169602155685425,
-0.3231476843357086,
-0.12150085717439651,
0.06359758973121643,
-0.12972910702228546,
-0.06354496628046036,
1.0970723628997803,
-0.5847292542457581,
0.3428659737110138,
0.7233729362487793,
0.6734312772750854,
0.41950079798698425,
0.4727020561695099,
0.6773924231529236,
-0.868283748626709,
-0.028035294264554977,
0.01258207019418478,
0.15570864081382751,
0.17718824744224548,
-0.18656644225120544,
0.34483352303504944,
0.24075214564800262,
-0.7467135787010193,
-0.9143506288528442,
0.3436703383922577,
-0.5280072093009949,
-0.2086019366979599,
1.3921557664871216,
-0.011695293709635735,
-0.19561462104320526,
-0.0524369440972805,
-0.1933712363243103,
0.024041060358285904,
-0.6024408340454102,
0.738114595413208,
0.4114497900009155,
-0.09750519692897797,
-0.16459959745407104,
-0.08053462207317352,
0.8253399133682251,
0.469465434551239,
-0.9367600083351135,
0.21294978260993958,
0.11440998315811157,
0.4641963541507721,
-0.05483412742614746,
0.9214127063751221,
0.23079848289489746,
0.30381208658218384,
-0.565716564655304,
0.24507340788841248,
0.028573932126164436,
-0.5311770439147949,
-0.4653101861476898,
0.2049364298582077,
0.1304529309272766,
-0.40744534134864807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14903v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14903v1
|
Tokenization counts: the impact of tokenization on arithmetic in frontier LLMs
| 2024-02-22T18:14:09 | 2024-02-22T18:14:09 |
Aaditya K. Singh, DJ Strouse
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Tokenization, the division of input text into input tokens, is an often
overlooked aspect of the large language model (LLM) pipeline and could be the
source of useful or harmful inductive biases. Historically, LLMs have relied on
byte pair encoding, without care to specific input domains. With the increased
use of LLMs for reasoning, various number-specific tokenization schemes have
been adopted, with popular models like LLaMa and PaLM opting for single-digit
tokenization while GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 have separate tokens for each 1-, 2-, and
3-digit numbers. In this work, we study the effect this choice has on numerical
reasoning through the use of arithmetic tasks. We consider left-to-right and
right-to-left tokenization for GPT-3.5 and -4, finding that right-to-left
tokenization (enforced by comma separating numbers at inference time) leads to
largely improved performance. Furthermore, we find that model errors when using
standard left-to-right tokenization follow stereotyped error patterns,
suggesting that model computations are systematic rather than approximate. We
show that the model is able to convert between tokenizations easily, thus
allowing chain-of-thought-inspired approaches to recover performance on
left-to-right tokenized inputs. We also find the gap between tokenization
directions decreases when models are scaled, possibly indicating that larger
models are better able to override this tokenization-dependent inductive bias.
In summary, our work performs the first study of how number tokenization
choices lead to differences in model performance on arithmetic tasks,
accompanied by a thorough analysis of error patterns. We hope this work
inspires practitioners to more carefully ablate number tokenization-related
choices when working towards general models of numerical reasoning.
|
[
-0.40035727620124817,
-0.7282976508140564,
0.6094161868095398,
0.4917716681957245,
-0.4338339567184448,
0.046472277492284775,
0.04841550439596176,
-0.4952602684497833,
0.267837792634964,
0.46881261467933655,
-0.1471596360206604,
-0.47260186076164246,
-0.7362328767776489,
0.17485569417476654,
-0.308957040309906,
0.8788930177688599,
-0.0007189082098193467,
0.49899786710739136,
-0.3705519735813141,
-0.17495624721050262,
-0.5596887469291687,
-1.144388198852539,
-0.7354248762130737,
-0.18368710577487946,
0.4267597496509552,
0.2619430422782898,
0.6419169902801514,
0.8735009431838989,
0.7941485643386841,
0.31944310665130615,
-0.19543437659740448,
0.05191804841160774,
-0.14623653888702393,
-0.20331734418869019,
-0.01427216362208128,
-0.8468408584594727,
-0.543059229850769,
0.03180450573563576,
0.7762256860733032,
0.880420982837677,
-0.08235381543636322,
0.10566297173500061,
-0.3271999657154083,
0.6894449591636658,
-0.2574915289878845,
0.25032833218574524,
-0.67559814453125,
0.08340562880039215,
-0.48513084650039673,
-0.173261821269989,
-0.43440207839012146,
-0.2935904264450073,
-0.4449100196361542,
-0.6893214583396912,
0.2123723328113556,
0.03884388133883476,
0.22225680947303772,
0.44711562991142273,
-0.43028542399406433,
-0.4003331959247589,
-0.541408896446228,
0.7191609144210815,
-0.9848928451538086,
0.42933687567710876,
0.41143280267715454,
-0.11577227711677551,
-0.10272899270057678,
-0.7206010222434998,
-0.5018510222434998,
0.09233413636684418,
-0.10644887387752533,
-0.055032879114151,
-0.07596953213214874,
0.35185614228248596,
0.7983897924423218,
0.38788682222366333,
-0.23893781006336212,
0.2656637728214264,
-0.6304678320884705,
-0.1780027449131012,
0.3760315477848053,
0.3822373151779175,
0.2887800335884094,
-0.04943165183067322,
-0.25022268295288086,
0.18743756413459778,
-0.9938056468963623,
0.22342850267887115,
0.35316094756126404,
0.36987271904945374,
0.09375914186239243,
0.6801939010620117,
-0.23174238204956055,
0.7303786277770996,
0.04812423884868622,
-0.18954823911190033,
0.04581552743911743,
-0.4261143207550049,
-0.2490473836660385,
-0.05661488696932793,
0.578364372253418,
0.19912128150463104,
0.2540800869464874,
-0.13615570962429047,
-0.395473837852478,
0.15239323675632477,
-0.01636606827378273,
-1.0473955869674683,
0.21995164453983307,
0.029176456853747368,
-0.34913140535354614,
-0.36182141304016113,
0.06130986288189888,
-0.3209041655063629,
-0.33204972743988037,
-0.4183027148246765,
0.36627063155174255,
-0.33180901408195496,
0.05724713206291199,
0.2332954853773117,
-0.16859813034534454,
0.046796198934316635,
0.2834874093532562,
-1.2450695037841797,
0.5041793584823608,
1.3044021129608154,
0.9946704506874084,
-0.2734038531780243,
-0.12266630679368973,
-0.8347770571708679,
-0.3378306031227112,
-0.6261572241783142,
0.44824761152267456,
-0.7275548577308655,
-0.4406549632549286,
-0.10317922383546829,
-0.2270483672618866,
-0.2301216572523117,
-0.5998291969299316,
0.516197681427002,
-0.8217839598655701,
-0.07756628841161728,
-0.5880570411682129,
-0.5281256437301636,
-0.2184123992919922,
0.015515927225351334,
-0.6595286130905151,
0.9841952919960022,
-0.24049893021583557,
-0.750097393989563,
0.5138455629348755,
-0.8264639973640442,
-0.44268959760665894,
0.17704272270202637,
-0.3251529037952423,
-0.12217475473880768,
0.5009545683860779,
0.2202843725681305,
0.09398981183767319,
-0.2960902750492096,
0.23058708012104034,
-0.31562286615371704,
-0.8172420263290405,
0.34696435928344727,
-0.5135151147842407,
0.8474317789077759,
-0.056303106248378754,
-0.4646153151988983,
0.09677106142044067,
-0.6165938377380371,
-0.1677953004837036,
-0.11936187744140625,
-0.17156140506267548,
-0.4164826571941376,
0.039613597095012665,
-0.6639088988304138,
0.26761603355407715,
0.02783767506480217,
-0.635537326335907,
0.1688227355480194,
-0.47463610768318176,
0.5062153339385986,
0.7691574692726135,
0.09210451692342758,
0.5845284461975098,
-0.1813724786043167,
0.547000527381897,
0.11143023520708084,
0.022033516317605972,
-0.17912490665912628,
-0.6632912158966064,
-0.9799678325653076,
-0.33552858233451843,
0.5734384059906006,
0.500789225101471,
-0.8163670897483826,
-0.036291588097810745,
-0.2936949133872986,
-0.12517254054546356,
-0.1465085744857788,
-0.13459719717502594,
0.028174547478556633,
0.36809098720550537,
0.16756631433963776,
-0.24957016110420227,
-0.2657039165496826,
-0.6744077801704407,
-0.3467422425746918,
-0.22207322716712952,
0.05019230768084526,
0.032940007746219635,
0.4031856954097748,
0.09135209769010544,
0.9163761138916016,
-0.3115997314453125,
-0.06675171852111816,
-0.004812611732631922,
0.17715021967887878,
0.38095593452453613,
0.5004705786705017,
0.31297439336776733,
-0.630753755569458,
-0.28994834423065186,
-0.08673407137393951,
-0.5155783295631409,
-0.15397131443023682,
-0.053650129586458206,
-0.13655810058116913,
0.34536212682724,
0.5494745969772339,
-0.8435304164886475,
0.7380090951919556,
0.32942813634872437,
-0.49491316080093384,
0.29252126812934875,
0.03961601480841637,
0.016364268958568573,
-0.5897848606109619,
-0.18899640440940857,
-0.036805808544158936,
-0.043159808963537216,
-0.6744701862335205,
0.03275563567876816,
0.0009408961632288992,
0.12308069318532944,
-0.2056674361228943,
0.40131527185440063,
-0.18431147933006287,
-0.3708740770816803,
-0.14472898840904236,
-0.2825212776660919,
0.0554223358631134,
0.4985388517379761,
0.008647726848721504,
1.1118369102478027,
0.16042615473270416,
-0.27862581610679626,
0.0030577699653804302,
-0.13249528408050537,
-0.11224552243947983,
0.224726140499115,
-0.7196878790855408,
0.39471742510795593,
0.0157878790050745,
0.3417716920375824,
-0.8953320980072021,
0.1533324122428894,
0.2982160151004791,
-0.44472599029541016,
0.08994138240814209,
-0.30346912145614624,
-0.7421432137489319,
-0.044718556106090546,
-0.2946782112121582,
0.7933719158172607,
0.37741053104400635,
-0.4906463325023651,
0.7123114466667175,
0.23095887899398804,
-0.4380081295967102,
-0.43339788913726807,
-0.5865717530250549,
0.05973657965660095,
-0.43609869480133057,
-0.7249743342399597,
0.25507768988609314,
0.11052916198968887,
-0.6114738583564758,
-0.29035064578056335,
-0.20624187588691711,
0.15856172144412994,
0.13543471693992615,
0.3353419303894043,
0.5751650929450989,
-0.08438722789287567,
0.42246198654174805,
0.09483552724123001,
-0.035891368985176086,
0.4771241545677185,
-0.47345054149627686,
0.5612441301345825,
-0.09499986469745636,
-0.5894842147827148,
-0.03704584017395973,
0.27038127183914185,
0.7635384798049927,
-0.39524567127227783,
0.6635068655014038,
0.4726267457008362,
-0.5283203721046448,
0.027099568396806717,
-0.6185062527656555,
-0.08029159903526306,
-0.47923600673675537,
0.23470337688922882,
-0.5695564150810242,
-0.9323530793190002,
0.6572681665420532,
0.14487160742282867,
0.14133815467357635,
0.5938165783882141,
0.5406761765480042,
0.2384185791015625,
1.0622447729110718,
0.31809380650520325,
0.08523768931627274,
0.42667797207832336,
-0.2588697671890259,
0.2617647349834442,
-0.7424382567405701,
-0.18054425716400146,
-0.38806137442588806,
-0.13245941698551178,
-0.6553616523742676,
-0.9222421646118164,
0.3288431167602539,
-0.10051654279232025,
-0.36298662424087524,
-0.3096480965614319,
-0.3737910985946655,
0.624296247959137,
0.5658454298973083,
0.008331711404025555,
0.392812579870224,
0.18462888896465302,
-0.21904484927654266,
-0.2412177175283432,
-0.7470272779464722,
-0.3336637318134308,
1.056109070777893,
0.5428177118301392,
0.4683733582496643,
0.013801629655063152,
0.8518409132957458,
0.3024034798145294,
0.5539336800575256,
-1.024961233139038,
0.535394012928009,
-0.3737856149673462,
-0.5210977792739868,
-0.4347357153892517,
-0.6075030565261841,
-0.43169960379600525,
0.5266852378845215,
0.14933380484580994,
-0.6399625539779663,
0.3452199101448059,
-0.24906665086746216,
-0.42813268303871155,
0.4395260512828827,
-0.5682460069656372,
0.5732457637786865,
-0.2864339053630829,
-0.36864936351776123,
-0.28170061111450195,
-0.3572440445423126,
0.43393415212631226,
-0.22027570009231567,
0.3707382380962372,
0.04857765883207321,
-0.22079789638519287,
0.9651233553886414,
-0.8008742332458496,
1.0072276592254639,
-0.2943136394023895,
-0.1586204469203949,
0.335727721452713,
0.09614501893520355,
0.7837563157081604,
0.034841351211071014,
-0.1797645092010498,
0.6026862263679504,
-0.1108471155166626,
-0.33053943514823914,
-0.5806019306182861,
0.5646728873252869,
-0.7926808595657349,
-0.8760095834732056,
-0.5239261388778687,
-0.6308664679527283,
-0.3245222866535187,
0.06625179201364517,
0.1845480501651764,
0.8069376349449158,
0.1272335946559906,
-0.044701702892780304,
0.5522369742393494,
0.09509735554456711,
0.5193653702735901,
0.23073671758174896,
-0.38187742233276367,
-0.6735650300979614,
1.0284444093704224,
0.4900503158569336,
0.4033941328525543,
0.23504218459129333,
-0.023063035681843758,
-0.3794515132904053,
-0.7069584727287292,
-0.6201627850532532,
0.2891550064086914,
-1.0085078477859497,
-0.21605566143989563,
-0.566632091999054,
-0.05861019343137741,
-0.17412838339805603,
0.030579227954149246,
-0.03273775801062584,
-1.0251002311706543,
-0.3664661943912506,
-0.3390767574310303,
0.24487881362438202,
0.9074252247810364,
-0.1440809816122055,
0.13970038294792175,
-0.5952481627464294,
0.1544124037027359,
0.3392958641052246,
0.36616051197052,
0.07262402027845383,
-0.7923672199249268,
-0.24739091098308563,
0.006019542925059795,
0.12140073627233505,
-0.5189119577407837,
0.0889802947640419,
-0.19971394538879395,
0.1265556663274765,
0.2688852548599243,
-0.3475119471549988,
0.6650665402412415,
-0.4717596769332886,
0.6418616771697998,
0.2073473185300827,
-1.102184534072876,
-0.2706114649772644,
-0.3180508315563202,
0.1927870512008667,
0.3852173686027527,
0.04503006115555763,
-0.6890760064125061,
-0.04912128672003746,
-0.34651175141334534,
-0.5644106268882751,
0.6305832862854004,
0.012689526192843914,
0.060455579310655594,
-0.2987655699253082,
0.26603856682777405,
0.16123108565807343,
0.010998019017279148,
-0.4999203383922577,
-0.12227196246385574,
-0.16298270225524902,
0.06882243603467941,
0.2088860720396042,
-0.370373010635376,
-0.1594599038362503,
-0.3677413761615753,
0.39562496542930603,
-0.17833536863327026,
0.21462717652320862,
0.001171743730083108,
0.013544099405407906,
-0.05160416290163994,
0.11999841779470444,
0.7439738512039185,
0.833239734172821,
0.07233499735593796,
0.0842382088303566,
0.42374104261398315,
-0.5006760954856873,
0.07968156039714813,
0.3272812068462372,
-0.26534274220466614,
0.13881564140319824,
0.3390714228153229,
0.8622164130210876,
0.06011047959327698,
-0.09065745770931244,
0.3713400959968567,
-0.0677751898765564,
-0.29490920901298523,
-0.211824432015419,
-0.140346959233284,
0.09570906311273575,
0.06173793971538544,
0.6320896148681641,
0.195158913731575,
0.25174060463905334,
-0.31885039806365967,
-0.12591128051280975,
0.5997748970985413,
-0.15925496816635132,
-0.30073681473731995,
0.5411884188652039,
0.32673564553260803,
-0.3332062065601349,
0.6143630743026733,
-0.21856795251369476,
-0.6561686992645264,
0.8781962394714355,
0.6069473028182983,
0.9049651026725769,
0.2299795299768448,
0.058924585580825806,
0.3274848759174347,
0.29799938201904297,
0.13041314482688904,
-0.010694677010178566,
-0.21011975407600403,
-0.6657736897468567,
-0.8778258562088013,
-0.6037662029266357,
-0.4518522620201111,
-0.32198140025138855,
-0.47775715589523315,
0.11781790852546692,
-0.5869869589805603,
-0.3698248267173767,
0.00896181259304285,
-0.10365628451108932,
-0.6695007085800171,
0.14304393529891968,
0.40320226550102234,
1.0246189832687378,
-0.7370783090591431,
0.5200604200363159,
0.6791273355484009,
-0.18298760056495667,
-0.8577612042427063,
-0.14909552037715912,
-0.20746015012264252,
-0.9356157183647156,
0.8578742742538452,
0.26390719413757324,
-0.0884433165192604,
0.03930915147066116,
-0.3269633948802948,
-0.9666287899017334,
1.0409491062164307,
0.0651678740978241,
-0.590822696685791,
-0.10178560018539429,
0.7282784581184387,
0.4442015588283539,
-0.38701528310775757,
0.353780061006546,
0.7980161905288696,
0.3000252842903137,
0.30988290905952454,
-0.9962090849876404,
0.19520851969718933,
-0.0798197090625763,
0.10309126228094101,
0.6278572678565979,
-0.8055013418197632,
1.0191569328308105,
-0.2268025130033493,
-0.2607432007789612,
-0.13553637266159058,
0.46272915601730347,
0.4166046977043152,
0.37285539507865906,
0.5247343182563782,
0.8150211572647095,
0.7783828377723694,
-0.2969420552253723,
0.8483540415763855,
-0.2580348551273346,
0.0883639007806778,
0.6557585597038269,
-0.14984294772148132,
0.5220000147819519,
0.638315737247467,
-0.5415294170379639,
0.4705459475517273,
0.582344114780426,
0.368998259305954,
0.196457177400589,
0.4097103774547577,
-0.5066798329353333,
-0.2360558658838272,
0.056256022304296494,
-0.3488869369029999,
0.3106113374233246,
0.5293793678283691,
-0.23385632038116455,
0.034675102680921555,
-0.2301352322101593,
0.2084110528230667,
-0.3440861701965332,
-0.5575907230377197,
0.8057547211647034,
0.24020491540431976,
-0.7778921127319336,
0.4385891854763031,
0.2265009582042694,
0.6256149411201477,
-0.33557093143463135,
-0.2456059455871582,
-0.60770583152771,
0.01175642292946577,
-0.33997464179992676,
-0.44924500584602356,
0.21549557149410248,
0.0766088217496872,
-0.19348281621932983,
-0.03388553857803345,
0.6510252952575684,
-0.1932363361120224,
-0.8779992461204529,
-0.21216464042663574,
0.46572941541671753,
0.10768814384937286,
-0.1992730349302292,
-0.3195329010486603,
0.37171483039855957,
0.14450319111347198,
-0.06989910453557968,
0.39131200313568115,
0.7806599140167236,
-0.5388963222503662,
0.43373358249664307,
0.9111525416374207,
0.12200325727462769,
0.1678066849708557,
0.2980290353298187,
0.903109073638916,
-0.8327570557594299,
-0.45704615116119385,
-1.1585285663604736,
0.3480697274208069,
0.08278072625398636,
-0.04739358648657799,
0.608747661113739,
0.5896411538124084,
0.5033696889877319,
0.18495610356330872,
0.7130337953567505,
0.060890886932611465,
0.14562064409255981,
-0.5234381556510925,
0.1920149177312851,
-0.09863537549972534,
0.5148254632949829,
0.11771948635578156,
-0.8705394268035889,
-0.4486859142780304,
0.28888607025146484,
-0.749794065952301,
0.023625550791621208,
0.639542281627655,
0.5646017789840698,
0.27640846371650696,
0.1389572024345398,
0.27229586243629456,
-0.19615425169467926,
0.4289178252220154,
0.2257585972547531,
0.9365874528884888,
-0.24095195531845093,
0.3667799234390259,
-0.16822397708892822,
-0.2963062822818756,
-0.06468391418457031,
-0.6630640625953674,
-0.8164930939674377,
-0.19229330122470856,
-0.01953457109630108,
-0.178721621632576,
-0.0291373860090971,
0.9655247330665588,
0.3779401481151581,
-0.5775279998779297,
-0.21871055662631989,
-0.3007217049598694,
0.34393826127052307,
0.19226136803627014,
-0.2392168492078781,
0.17610888183116913,
-0.48520612716674805,
-0.7282784581184387,
0.11617768555879593,
0.4436793327331543,
0.04555182158946991,
-0.19284290075302124,
0.028077950701117516,
0.2535306513309479,
0.25672996044158936,
0.7482324838638306,
0.09204096347093582,
-0.7002274990081787,
-0.06446634978055954,
0.33040130138397217,
-0.10416117310523987,
0.17644956707954407,
1.089342713356018,
-0.8153465390205383,
0.3812602758407593,
0.453201025724411,
0.5763927102088928,
0.5867582559585571,
0.4379851818084717,
0.5645521283149719,
-0.34870418906211853,
0.21452292799949646,
0.23521341383457184,
0.37840864062309265,
0.4159295856952667,
-0.35617387294769287,
0.7074587345123291,
0.4816235899925232,
-0.5347158908843994,
-0.8229764103889465,
0.004887378308922052,
-0.5384032726287842,
0.06393444538116455,
1.317682147026062,
0.03988959640264511,
0.10567311197519302,
0.08512325584888458,
-0.17807745933532715,
-0.06783036887645721,
-0.33917945623397827,
0.5990294814109802,
1.022011160850525,
-0.2522026598453522,
0.15483172237873077,
-0.38990724086761475,
0.45248016715049744,
0.5586404204368591,
-0.5769787430763245,
0.03292490914463997,
0.448763370513916,
0.1930638551712036,
0.11551607400178909,
0.7576313018798828,
-0.18125632405281067,
0.314132958650589,
0.18279848992824554,
-0.10912612825632095,
-0.17204278707504272,
0.048476692289114,
-0.37291350960731506,
-0.0955507904291153,
0.37356555461883545,
-0.21917517483234406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14901v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14901v1
|
A Usage-centric Take on Intent Understanding in E-Commerce
| 2024-02-22T18:09:33 | 2024-02-22T18:09:33 |
Wendi Zhou, Tianyi Li, Pavlos Vougiouklis, Mark Steedman, Jeff Z. Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Identifying and understanding user intents is a pivotal task for E-Commerce.
Despite its popularity, intent understanding has not been consistently defined
or accurately benchmarked. In this paper, we focus on predicative user intents
as "how a customer uses a product", and pose intent understanding as a natural
language reasoning task, independent of product ontologies. We identify two
weaknesses of FolkScope, the SOTA E-Commerce Intent Knowledge Graph, that limit
its capacity to reason about user intents and to recommend diverse useful
products. Following these observations, we introduce a Product Recovery
Benchmark including a novel evaluation framework and an example dataset. We
further validate the above FolkScope weaknesses on this benchmark.
|
[
-0.31938204169273376,
-0.6741868853569031,
0.6583336591720581,
0.1288522183895111,
-0.01128280907869339,
0.036262597888708115,
-0.12794934213161469,
-0.4975399672985077,
0.27311092615127563,
0.5789235234260559,
-0.9683945178985596,
-0.5926517248153687,
-0.3602231740951538,
0.28121218085289,
-0.31907692551612854,
0.971073567867279,
-0.0671425610780716,
-0.4292829632759094,
0.020386284217238426,
-0.1352190524339676,
-0.45693308115005493,
-0.28353258967399597,
-0.4743354320526123,
0.08160720765590668,
0.30704575777053833,
0.8854237794876099,
0.4306594133377075,
-0.21210868656635284,
0.6787337064743042,
0.3881136476993561,
0.47073715925216675,
0.1335160732269287,
-0.7803223133087158,
0.06210798770189285,
-0.19892926514148712,
-0.3583945631980896,
-0.17465606331825256,
0.1410370022058487,
0.23543256521224976,
0.6431493163108826,
-0.44542545080184937,
0.24986708164215088,
-0.0086583336815238,
0.6218226552009583,
-0.7867875695228577,
-0.08350090682506561,
-0.5847897529602051,
0.05684630572795868,
-0.10238181054592133,
0.013085778802633286,
-0.45792821049690247,
-0.23845595121383667,
0.477925181388855,
-1.2474737167358398,
0.3092038035392761,
0.3420679271221161,
1.041487216949463,
0.22559931874275208,
-0.20884406566619873,
-0.5570464730262756,
-0.7795655727386475,
0.7315013408660889,
-0.2918669879436493,
0.7036551833152771,
0.7113422751426697,
0.7545267343521118,
-0.25843051075935364,
-1.1638623476028442,
-0.5652929544448853,
0.08881159871816635,
-0.3619053363800049,
0.23814646899700165,
-0.2814704477787018,
-0.14614175260066986,
0.267245888710022,
0.3391214907169342,
-0.46299514174461365,
-0.4844738841056824,
-0.45956239104270935,
-0.2636920213699341,
0.6101032495498657,
0.11475693434476852,
0.34060248732566833,
-0.21575100719928741,
-0.797958493232727,
0.2171117216348648,
-0.39521634578704834,
0.36567944288253784,
0.22864720225334167,
-0.007693221792578697,
0.14640073478221893,
0.5114166736602783,
-0.27099674940109253,
0.7680515050888062,
0.30009588599205017,
-0.05796492472290993,
0.28143563866615295,
-0.5732101202011108,
-0.5264810919761658,
-0.013644046150147915,
0.4113389551639557,
0.25192341208457947,
0.21282081305980682,
-0.34290146827697754,
-0.010520984418690205,
-0.2952646315097809,
0.8329223990440369,
-0.39972415566444397,
-0.12259072065353394,
0.35134240984916687,
-0.5923718214035034,
0.4821956753730774,
0.21101343631744385,
-0.14452967047691345,
-0.3103908896446228,
-0.13902105391025543,
0.450538694858551,
-0.3528788387775421,
-0.07691160589456558,
0.5442965626716614,
-0.23981408774852753,
0.2544116973876953,
0.20856809616088867,
-0.7875013947486877,
0.5545869469642639,
1.075317144393921,
0.517095148563385,
-0.029303383082151413,
-0.42712026834487915,
-0.3949836194515228,
0.1021655723452568,
-0.10332556068897247,
1.0723941326141357,
-0.30037227272987366,
-0.38027074933052063,
-0.23404118418693542,
0.19333207607269287,
-0.15128029882907867,
-0.5021838545799255,
0.7172549962997437,
-0.7169960737228394,
0.1143956184387207,
-0.6465898156166077,
-0.5897514820098877,
-0.6745584011077881,
0.5289830565452576,
-0.5798578858375549,
0.3574753403663635,
0.13561829924583435,
-0.5085515975952148,
0.8900670409202576,
-0.47619733214378357,
-0.5953362584114075,
0.3837088942527771,
-0.018284233286976814,
-0.45048341155052185,
0.37842291593551636,
-0.3455330431461334,
0.16441610455513,
-0.13687610626220703,
0.14139725267887115,
-0.40953466296195984,
-0.25879496335983276,
0.19788475334644318,
-0.04019193351268768,
0.7867119312286377,
0.3043682277202606,
-0.1699710339307785,
-0.10362697392702103,
-0.5820906758308411,
-0.20761942863464355,
0.13411903381347656,
-0.14658866822719574,
-0.34356486797332764,
0.2169027030467987,
-0.08278016746044159,
0.04690049588680267,
0.2296968400478363,
-0.6007240414619446,
0.0976315513253212,
-0.30701401829719543,
0.4706847369670868,
0.5963141322135925,
-0.04985314607620239,
0.18434785306453705,
-0.029914502054452896,
0.4007459878921509,
-0.21796023845672607,
0.3933025300502777,
0.005323952995240688,
-0.5400754809379578,
-0.5271661877632141,
-0.2201935201883316,
-0.20568984746932983,
0.20242825150489807,
-0.572993278503418,
0.19344137609004974,
-0.3478134870529175,
-0.406904935836792,
-0.008121100254356861,
0.23920467495918274,
0.39035889506340027,
0.7040327787399292,
0.27412253618240356,
-0.7858806252479553,
-0.32654884457588196,
-1.0219881534576416,
-0.8202916979789734,
-0.26798897981643677,
-0.22585850954055786,
0.7228797674179077,
0.03092839941382408,
-0.3451922535896301,
1.171806812286377,
-0.6672466993331909,
-0.632341206073761,
-0.4275650382041931,
0.2940490245819092,
0.2913511097431183,
-0.14289341866970062,
0.31175336241722107,
-1.000254511833191,
-0.6603989005088806,
-0.14690278470516205,
-0.5181923508644104,
-0.14367856085300446,
-0.12299098819494247,
-0.21548879146575928,
-0.06535115092992783,
0.21221549808979034,
-0.657863199710846,
0.6251823306083679,
0.1727101355791092,
-0.913510799407959,
0.5104749202728271,
-0.27908846735954285,
0.25348374247550964,
-0.6396311521530151,
-0.07664494961500168,
0.10692354291677475,
-0.23468713462352753,
-0.8191965818405151,
-0.3643116354942322,
0.08400131016969681,
0.1529386341571808,
-0.5977597236633301,
0.1470804363489151,
-0.3844381272792816,
-0.5275269746780396,
-0.04398307204246521,
0.08448924869298935,
0.5160345435142517,
0.05541374534368515,
0.09279929101467133,
0.6327715516090393,
-0.006614114623516798,
-0.7271715998649597,
-0.12164168804883957,
0.6116233468055725,
-0.3639332950115204,
0.8361946940422058,
-0.6443955302238464,
0.1182698905467987,
-0.10378279536962509,
0.007784286979585886,
-1.129746913909912,
-0.30767881870269775,
0.565007209777832,
-0.36795443296432495,
0.05445483326911926,
-0.1343836486339569,
-0.20076978206634521,
-0.3982968032360077,
-0.1521715670824051,
0.25821566581726074,
0.2750146687030792,
-0.5817431807518005,
0.9801772236824036,
0.34561827778816223,
0.15980078279972076,
-0.44084882736206055,
-0.5226243734359741,
-0.08125633746385574,
-0.4418077766895294,
-0.770104706287384,
0.31526100635528564,
0.03656689450144768,
-0.4311007559299469,
-0.04152047634124756,
-0.11590395867824554,
-0.10768949240446091,
0.3949063718318939,
0.21409370005130768,
0.09571495652198792,
-0.01896139606833458,
0.4906848073005676,
-0.48039710521698,
-0.4366590976715088,
0.12868733704090118,
-0.4159362018108368,
0.30053192377090454,
-0.21078889071941376,
-0.4942229986190796,
-0.45186930894851685,
0.1621829867362976,
0.15352950990200043,
0.06433556228876114,
0.24985256791114807,
0.291057825088501,
-0.14913104474544525,
-0.0207256730645895,
-0.5709318518638611,
-0.23836277425289154,
-0.5500124096870422,
0.13587424159049988,
-0.5207351446151733,
-0.48313355445861816,
0.21474240720272064,
0.06330980360507965,
0.08682532608509064,
0.37163785099983215,
0.3729436695575714,
-0.29099464416503906,
0.6614260673522949,
0.6344125866889954,
0.3536488711833954,
0.14604206383228302,
-0.05905047059059143,
0.673058032989502,
-0.6118096113204956,
-0.19821636378765106,
-0.44962406158447266,
-0.5025413632392883,
-0.3846363127231598,
-0.07559860497713089,
0.04608558490872383,
0.04706558957695961,
-0.15161310136318207,
0.7723819017410278,
-0.36973536014556885,
0.1316107213497162,
0.5191285610198975,
0.013337762095034122,
0.6420794725418091,
0.20336532592773438,
0.4235489070415497,
0.058648619800806046,
-0.2089662402868271,
-0.4963584244251251,
1.0870569944381714,
0.12052807211875916,
0.6638064384460449,
0.2042536437511444,
0.49538832902908325,
0.12457726150751114,
0.2800880968570709,
-1.0246732234954834,
0.3002796173095703,
-0.26159507036209106,
-0.9293524622917175,
-0.09791035205125809,
-0.27843648195266724,
-1.1182955503463745,
0.13412432372570038,
0.13966861367225647,
-1.161765456199646,
0.381892591714859,
0.2986604571342468,
-0.6234518885612488,
-0.1941380649805069,
-1.3252547979354858,
0.9645397067070007,
-0.5109249353408813,
-0.49050116539001465,
-0.14719636738300323,
-0.46861740946769714,
0.13202212750911713,
0.14979730546474457,
0.3667523264884949,
-0.12898066639900208,
0.03670598939061165,
0.7997941374778748,
-0.4369743764400482,
0.5040966272354126,
-0.2648603320121765,
0.19372738897800446,
0.4217473566532135,
-0.10076344013214111,
0.2208479642868042,
0.10537410527467728,
0.3251476287841797,
0.09689438343048096,
-0.09714122861623764,
-0.3328045606613159,
-0.6030530333518982,
0.27336084842681885,
-0.4600645899772644,
-0.7543196082115173,
-0.14625822007656097,
-0.060344673693180084,
-0.5553256869316101,
0.454047828912735,
0.2779432237148285,
0.1599094718694687,
-0.2933183014392853,
0.20775865018367767,
0.4136814475059509,
-0.05424430966377258,
0.26126155257225037,
0.7940249443054199,
-0.2883632481098175,
0.21419242024421692,
0.9220135807991028,
0.18628717958927155,
0.1366157978773117,
0.024874215945601463,
0.3478807806968689,
-0.40755385160446167,
-0.2661131024360657,
-0.2524034380912781,
-0.025005480274558067,
-0.7927658557891846,
0.2021341621875763,
-0.7608316540718079,
0.21360956132411957,
-0.12599897384643555,
-0.14789535105228424,
-0.45955604314804077,
-0.3613722324371338,
-0.16591623425483704,
-0.1152077168226242,
0.19445207715034485,
0.8639236688613892,
0.11713936179876328,
0.28409409523010254,
-0.7628964781761169,
0.6064781546592712,
0.5713223814964294,
0.45675548911094666,
-0.20077314972877502,
-0.16933296620845795,
-0.05230328440666199,
-0.1593293398618698,
-0.3169316351413727,
-0.6411944627761841,
0.22121253609657288,
0.22782662510871887,
0.6628130674362183,
0.812192440032959,
0.092568539083004,
0.4670889973640442,
-0.1473967730998993,
0.6365715265274048,
0.27071312069892883,
-0.6982436180114746,
0.3701368272304535,
0.06647779047489166,
0.26401183009147644,
1.0463078022003174,
0.6878232359886169,
-0.5892468094825745,
0.3295755684375763,
-0.6358470320701599,
-0.7656369805335999,
0.8701022863388062,
0.35460278391838074,
-0.0181552954018116,
-0.017109837383031845,
0.16643917560577393,
0.49685102701187134,
0.22647540271282196,
-0.2631634473800659,
-0.09741204231977463,
-0.2962653636932373,
-0.1627739667892456,
-0.2678121030330658,
-0.32880473136901855,
-0.09856242686510086,
-0.10152310878038406,
0.3754257559776306,
0.012411106377840042,
0.10830660909414291,
0.23543627560138702,
-0.5051294565200806,
0.13877920806407928,
0.23236830532550812,
0.020264945924282074,
0.8899290561676025,
-0.176827535033226,
0.12465140223503113,
-0.27807268500328064,
-0.9975840449333191,
-0.17515148222446442,
0.23683972656726837,
-0.2719462811946869,
-0.36634448170661926,
0.0651862770318985,
0.3850632905960083,
0.26795461773872375,
-0.7818494439125061,
0.5284242630004883,
-0.639110803604126,
-0.0872931107878685,
-0.33577680587768555,
-0.070993572473526,
0.06680897623300552,
0.029899124056100845,
0.3824085593223572,
0.011147095821797848,
0.8518036603927612,
-0.5362367033958435,
0.22578001022338867,
0.3853922188282013,
-0.7255228161811829,
-0.5126675367355347,
0.1480206549167633,
0.13694782555103302,
-0.6861460208892822,
0.6564411520957947,
-0.4463816285133362,
-0.6308161616325378,
0.564034104347229,
0.4471992254257202,
1.097299337387085,
0.20615556836128235,
0.3798876404762268,
0.33011963963508606,
0.23178066313266754,
0.15488672256469727,
0.6219844222068787,
-0.48683062195777893,
-1.055280089378357,
0.10400567203760147,
-0.20950718224048615,
-0.30893945693969727,
-0.4434863030910492,
-0.5903127193450928,
0.3070199489593506,
-0.3793294429779053,
-0.2874779999256134,
0.3858378529548645,
0.03767389431595802,
-0.9416189193725586,
0.11586924642324448,
-0.3226439952850342,
0.6759709119796753,
-0.5936518907546997,
0.3125918507575989,
0.5364627242088318,
-0.3751477897167206,
-0.9773551821708679,
0.22572070360183716,
0.27720382809638977,
-0.778242290019989,
0.5236822366714478,
0.5397145748138428,
-0.5547084212303162,
-0.22714155912399292,
-0.32631123065948486,
-0.6097432971000671,
0.9271186590194702,
-0.25933319330215454,
-0.5623342990875244,
0.4232378900051117,
0.0615401528775692,
0.3138066530227661,
-0.3122881352901459,
0.2917414903640747,
0.9097198843955994,
0.6610551476478577,
-0.01774534396827221,
-0.5017842650413513,
-0.03161575645208359,
-0.1760442703962326,
-0.28936541080474854,
-0.011947129853069782,
-0.3348315358161926,
0.6201477646827698,
-0.07610805332660675,
-0.7445661425590515,
-0.33238306641578674,
-0.048549309372901917,
0.13866999745368958,
0.8028352856636047,
0.7779808044433594,
0.8025435209274292,
0.5767931938171387,
-0.033266332000494,
1.1145309209823608,
0.0722879022359848,
0.5035325288772583,
1.1929678916931152,
-0.34019017219543457,
0.710373044013977,
0.40301617980003357,
-0.45265325903892517,
0.5153445601463318,
0.43952736258506775,
0.27977609634399414,
0.5593570470809937,
-0.11836948990821838,
0.15473516285419464,
-0.4407080411911011,
-0.00827007181942463,
-0.24537210166454315,
0.7387598156929016,
0.5880967378616333,
-0.3713541030883789,
-0.1309518963098526,
-0.21517425775527954,
-0.34966641664505005,
-0.09009002149105072,
-0.07687444239854813,
1.0987305641174316,
0.1127055212855339,
-0.685337483882904,
0.4529229402542114,
-0.4313720166683197,
0.07318683713674545,
-0.3999391794204712,
0.23174352943897247,
0.17224451899528503,
0.3101494610309601,
-0.4427770972251892,
-0.8831450343132019,
0.5175724625587463,
-0.3049548864364624,
0.0128483846783638,
-0.10599254816770554,
1.0805169343948364,
0.3237622082233429,
-0.3793254792690277,
0.4016842246055603,
0.34145644307136536,
0.019404616206884384,
-0.06533147394657135,
-0.5201320648193359,
-0.011425462551414967,
-0.09531743824481964,
-0.6388501524925232,
-0.12799611687660217,
0.2458096146583557,
0.1547497659921646,
0.6246663928031921,
0.4330788254737854,
-0.5482838749885559,
-0.08239775151014328,
0.20493671298027039,
0.5560574531555176,
-0.4965088963508606,
-0.5473321676254272,
-0.6019200086593628,
0.4845353662967682,
-0.35894468426704407,
-0.5044571757316589,
1.0003093481063843,
0.48676905035972595,
0.8868826627731323,
0.1142006665468216,
0.6861733198165894,
-0.03962297737598419,
0.5212479829788208,
-0.12290583550930023,
0.4834635853767395,
-0.7599731087684631,
0.4438776969909668,
0.016803914681077003,
-0.7628859877586365,
-0.04688430577516556,
0.48920637369155884,
-0.8117952942848206,
-0.03257567435503006,
0.5926987528800964,
0.342763215303421,
-0.3227040767669678,
0.6363592743873596,
0.10826266556978226,
0.2912304103374481,
0.09189863502979279,
0.399440735578537,
1.0476818084716797,
-0.2132737785577774,
0.5337732434272766,
-0.24155732989311218,
-0.3369748294353485,
-0.5002322793006897,
-0.5592427253723145,
-0.37494051456451416,
-0.4272754490375519,
0.03961911052465439,
-0.21987001597881317,
-0.12178678810596466,
0.693276584148407,
0.8198304772377014,
-0.7585944533348083,
-0.06608253717422485,
-0.5224243998527527,
0.3277958929538727,
-0.33493879437446594,
-0.15576672554016113,
0.05022503435611725,
-0.5664010047912598,
-0.28232893347740173,
0.10862109065055847,
0.7370001077651978,
-0.3792647421360016,
-0.21015851199626923,
-0.13574041426181793,
-0.2241477519273758,
0.0169051643460989,
0.5694032311439514,
0.6274944543838501,
-0.6930687427520752,
-0.3244260847568512,
0.46110084652900696,
0.26506805419921875,
0.3110025227069855,
1.1300175189971924,
-0.6671217083930969,
0.9802802801132202,
0.5782644152641296,
0.46031415462493896,
0.674888014793396,
0.2588323950767517,
0.4758507013320923,
-0.14325925707817078,
-0.14126473665237427,
0.1618904173374176,
0.4181710481643677,
0.2351793497800827,
-0.4364642798900604,
0.39102742075920105,
-0.07092268019914627,
-0.5693405866622925,
-0.10471726953983307,
0.6821274161338806,
-0.9509819746017456,
-0.44295233488082886,
0.9039861559867859,
-0.4334926903247833,
-0.3394778370857239,
-0.9552472233772278,
-0.19648639857769012,
-0.20704518258571625,
-0.2619859576225281,
1.021084189414978,
0.5487187504768372,
-0.25869959592819214,
0.15034915506839752,
-0.32951655983924866,
0.3076290488243103,
0.2486545592546463,
-0.6696325540542603,
-0.03557094186544418,
0.39353322982788086,
0.37692365050315857,
0.3645268380641937,
1.002116084098816,
0.08836692571640015,
0.4471881687641144,
0.015401036478579044,
-0.3932115137577057,
0.1868247091770172,
-0.402346670627594,
0.21548016369342804,
0.18377995491027832,
0.26021039485931396,
-0.11339616030454636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14746v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14746v1
|
Scaling Efficient LLMs
| 2024-02-22T18:06:19 | 2024-02-22T18:06:19 |
B. N. Kausik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Trained LLMs are typically sparse in that most of the parameters are zero,
raising questions on efficiency. In response, we inquire into efficient LLMs,
i.e. those with the fewest parameters that achieve the desired accuracy on a
training corpus. Specifically, we compare theoretical and empirical estimates
for training loss at current scale to obtain upper and lower bounds on the
number of unique sequences in a natural training corpus as a function of its
size. Our result implies (1) to double the number of skills represented in a
training corpus, the corpus must scale roughly between three and five fold (2)
for efficient LLMs, the number of parameters $N$ and the size $D$ of a natural
training corpus scale as $N \sim D^{0.58}$ (3) if the number of parameters of
an LLM is smaller than the number of unique sequences in the training corpus,
scaling up can uncover emergent skills.
|
[
-0.46118608117103577,
-0.5031496286392212,
0.5052691698074341,
0.3643013536930084,
-0.1770181506872177,
-0.06516275554895401,
-0.5692819356918335,
-0.33548930287361145,
0.25035274028778076,
0.07992739975452423,
-0.40468648076057434,
-0.3832319676876068,
-0.9329866170883179,
0.31399136781692505,
-0.6234000325202942,
0.8339734077453613,
0.1226373091340065,
0.344051718711853,
-0.2206990271806717,
-0.4948272705078125,
-0.1011589765548706,
-0.3857077658176422,
-0.9667376279830933,
-0.15162284672260284,
0.7853338718414307,
0.5825159549713135,
0.5703852772712708,
1.090567946434021,
0.7235898375511169,
0.3271529972553253,
-0.38067933917045593,
0.2042207419872284,
-0.8083909153938293,
0.044530801475048065,
0.28086158633232117,
-0.8090001940727234,
-0.29761767387390137,
0.15987421572208405,
1.1592211723327637,
1.2262330055236816,
0.03890717402100563,
0.4341038763523102,
0.20200985670089722,
0.7533343434333801,
-0.4363744258880615,
-0.14143820106983185,
-0.6209490299224854,
-0.0021264529787003994,
-0.10450854152441025,
-0.33124038577079773,
-0.38752448558807373,
-0.3869474530220032,
-0.08356919884681702,
-0.6867746710777283,
0.4868704676628113,
-0.15106382966041565,
0.7355114221572876,
0.5129134654998779,
-0.2778376638889313,
-0.17899927496910095,
-0.5819386839866638,
0.9147953987121582,
-0.42096221446990967,
0.19222599267959595,
0.2060316503047943,
0.08866424113512039,
-0.01975480280816555,
-0.7008024454116821,
-0.07535885274410248,
-0.12414484471082687,
0.063137948513031,
-0.21840350329875946,
-0.05270925536751747,
0.09416073560714722,
0.682553768157959,
0.5594663023948669,
-0.24573378264904022,
0.5860148072242737,
-0.2739626467227936,
-0.08178352564573288,
0.5880662202835083,
0.5151403546333313,
0.10419150441884995,
0.1602662354707718,
-0.35587504506111145,
-0.07626871019601822,
-0.553943932056427,
-0.10822601616382599,
0.5195768475532532,
0.35377267003059387,
-0.02417059801518917,
0.4353264272212982,
0.14590226113796234,
0.7602745890617371,
0.09456276148557663,
-0.5756285190582275,
-0.04588476940989494,
-0.43425044417381287,
-0.09200110286474228,
-0.04517226293683052,
0.4430364668369293,
0.40844833850860596,
0.24887144565582275,
-0.23640704154968262,
-0.10263736546039581,
-0.19492419064044952,
0.5401856899261475,
-0.940030038356781,
0.03410208225250244,
-0.17602171003818512,
-0.4773397743701935,
-0.326970636844635,
-0.32744941115379333,
-0.5053799152374268,
-0.38619279861450195,
-0.301763117313385,
0.703397810459137,
-0.5606975555419922,
-0.01722133345901966,
-0.1909594088792801,
-0.4026852548122406,
0.4425889253616333,
0.7350803017616272,
-1.0615485906600952,
0.484957218170166,
0.4695914387702942,
1.2271296977996826,
-0.10772494226694107,
-0.2607022523880005,
-0.3660666048526764,
-0.3946433365345001,
-0.5936656594276428,
0.4946495592594147,
-0.15478776395320892,
-0.2855621874332428,
-0.18613506853580475,
-0.11715792864561081,
-0.2557694613933563,
-0.6408460140228271,
0.5213120579719543,
-0.5877564549446106,
-0.43321382999420166,
-0.41704216599464417,
-0.7222058176994324,
-0.1664172112941742,
0.15179096162319183,
-0.8006003499031067,
1.1815751791000366,
0.3034771680831909,
-0.6422821283340454,
0.9153741598129272,
-0.42665761709213257,
-0.26220300793647766,
0.0394013486802578,
0.045437924563884735,
-0.44839197397232056,
0.24810749292373657,
-0.10047834366559982,
0.6236745715141296,
-0.32103607058525085,
-0.4533046782016754,
-0.5396317839622498,
-0.670359194278717,
0.30646422505378723,
-0.6290165185928345,
0.745798647403717,
0.2987302243709564,
-0.18646438419818878,
-0.18356972932815552,
-0.9128797054290771,
0.46505802869796753,
-0.09651845693588257,
-0.9297658801078796,
-0.28371569514274597,
-0.17464964091777802,
-0.2013331949710846,
-0.23997247219085693,
0.37960419058799744,
-0.46614643931388855,
0.24942009150981903,
-0.4159592390060425,
0.48677632212638855,
0.6229972839355469,
-0.019969699904322624,
0.656463086605072,
-0.5261168479919434,
0.42110326886177063,
-0.3998326361179352,
-0.056439563632011414,
-0.04967314004898071,
-0.27502375841140747,
-0.8581690192222595,
-0.8801950812339783,
0.4916415214538574,
0.188018336892128,
-0.034891046583652496,
0.3419800102710724,
-0.19432412087917328,
-0.7517525553703308,
-0.6030729413032532,
0.6414812207221985,
0.23416651785373688,
0.29035377502441406,
0.20654678344726562,
-0.025660013779997826,
-0.5677469372749329,
-0.9001356959342957,
-0.30309435725212097,
0.13826987147331238,
-0.1772434413433075,
-0.041771937161684036,
0.554646909236908,
0.1580236256122589,
0.7466241717338562,
-0.06605225056409836,
0.04642772674560547,
-0.254907488822937,
0.16968873143196106,
0.35778746008872986,
0.31593093276023865,
0.7065588235855103,
-0.6775590777397156,
-0.7317952513694763,
-0.3234477937221527,
-0.7682576775550842,
-0.07232087105512619,
-0.17144650220870972,
0.16643163561820984,
0.19186925888061523,
0.4733908176422119,
-0.3746083676815033,
0.24465645849704742,
0.371288537979126,
0.14354772865772247,
0.08846496045589447,
-0.6040130257606506,
0.04655643552541733,
-0.7602201700210571,
-0.024816038087010384,
0.0016285048332065344,
-0.16236507892608643,
-0.778890073299408,
0.1689780056476593,
0.24444979429244995,
0.1544225960969925,
-0.48003649711608887,
0.37944042682647705,
-0.8092227578163147,
-0.3425529897212982,
-0.2710931599140167,
-0.01945924572646618,
-0.21230268478393555,
0.5105112791061401,
-0.03595366328954697,
0.7872241735458374,
0.5086774826049805,
-0.7443347573280334,
0.025516249239444733,
-0.13510912656784058,
-0.2825694680213928,
0.726743757724762,
-0.6756917238235474,
-0.029969923198223114,
0.004369326401501894,
-0.14010457694530487,
-1.118673324584961,
-0.14059430360794067,
-0.4725039303302765,
-0.42495402693748474,
0.5743719339370728,
-0.22345030307769775,
-0.5781999230384827,
-0.390287846326828,
-0.8641789555549622,
0.23568837344646454,
0.5812586545944214,
-0.7006698846817017,
0.09727364033460617,
0.1291080117225647,
0.30556631088256836,
-0.668079674243927,
-0.7036298513412476,
-0.13730855286121368,
-0.5087257027626038,
-0.6139389872550964,
0.15569756925106049,
-0.24442601203918457,
-0.05425038933753967,
-0.149214968085289,
-0.2112208902835846,
-0.04050591588020325,
0.35996341705322266,
0.4429003894329071,
0.027957914397120476,
-0.2842514216899872,
0.19433003664016724,
-0.12820184230804443,
0.043669044971466064,
0.1289796680212021,
-0.16801010072231293,
0.45051899552345276,
-0.47621655464172363,
-0.19596712291240692,
-0.1287904530763626,
0.17826566100120544,
0.5999082326889038,
0.25262871384620667,
1.0586293935775757,
0.7716994881629944,
-0.317044198513031,
-0.2321484535932541,
-0.5456091165542603,
0.015192154794931412,
-0.4835907816886902,
0.4073582589626312,
-0.46324077248573303,
-0.7307159900665283,
0.6594212651252747,
-0.15581808984279633,
0.06588787585496902,
0.8068847060203552,
0.7095721960067749,
-0.18834856152534485,
0.9261487126350403,
0.6909161806106567,
0.29955217242240906,
0.2344754934310913,
-0.6862255930900574,
-0.14236114919185638,
-0.9390329718589783,
-0.19877217710018158,
-0.45381635427474976,
-0.709482729434967,
-0.8073858618736267,
-0.6259037256240845,
0.6873273253440857,
0.42693647742271423,
-0.44469088315963745,
0.30467861890792847,
-0.5772333741188049,
0.5299725532531738,
1.0073469877243042,
0.22119107842445374,
0.15915542840957642,
0.09330502152442932,
-0.1344260275363922,
-0.08031672984361649,
-1.0448822975158691,
-0.6289860010147095,
1.484269142150879,
0.5185792446136475,
0.8257167339324951,
0.19981685280799866,
0.9084082841873169,
0.16227833926677704,
0.4120621681213379,
-1.1592499017715454,
0.5910083651542664,
-0.0358433835208416,
-0.6096218228340149,
-0.9082373976707458,
-0.5437872409820557,
-1.166910171508789,
0.17450271546840668,
-0.4392796456813812,
-0.30937138199806213,
0.08762109279632568,
0.09106069803237915,
-0.40036627650260925,
0.6942275166511536,
-0.6879742741584778,
0.5158432722091675,
-0.1996239870786667,
-0.41499021649360657,
-0.16729192435741425,
-0.740973949432373,
0.1295880377292633,
-0.4371108114719391,
-0.038195475935935974,
-0.201975017786026,
-0.6724500060081482,
1.1147490739822388,
-0.8186454176902771,
0.820641040802002,
-0.20098455250263214,
0.3162422478199005,
0.40928351879119873,
-0.16622886061668396,
0.17271968722343445,
0.04183509200811386,
-0.22753839194774628,
0.28850796818733215,
0.06395472586154938,
-0.72330641746521,
-0.4742283821105957,
0.600652277469635,
-1.0489256381988525,
-0.24860067665576935,
-0.41953957080841064,
-0.4778236150741577,
-0.16606956720352173,
0.1526251584291458,
0.483794629573822,
0.433269739151001,
-0.15231046080589294,
0.41341763734817505,
1.0066659450531006,
-0.0949496477842331,
0.6593402028083801,
0.6141106486320496,
0.5271783471107483,
-0.4671633839607239,
0.6926984786987305,
0.7223474383354187,
0.5260387659072876,
0.43960028886795044,
0.014119013212621212,
-0.2476467490196228,
-0.9106731414794922,
-0.58236163854599,
0.30724337697029114,
-0.7087119221687317,
-0.4218006730079651,
-0.4566008150577545,
-0.38111427426338196,
-0.08213900774717331,
-0.407944917678833,
-0.2892175316810608,
-0.45202308893203735,
-0.5254188179969788,
-0.22193855047225952,
0.724183976650238,
0.6962597966194153,
-0.5414888858795166,
0.43882977962493896,
-0.5977746248245239,
0.011157733388245106,
0.38995516300201416,
0.47789266705513,
-0.05556269362568855,
-1.0316489934921265,
-0.5264670848846436,
-0.15521174669265747,
-0.11985772848129272,
-0.7664105296134949,
0.4447174072265625,
0.38602346181869507,
0.8155058026313782,
0.7083970904350281,
-0.15540260076522827,
0.6471651792526245,
-0.5494845509529114,
0.6190082430839539,
0.3339807987213135,
-0.4270792603492737,
0.324479877948761,
-0.22430770099163055,
0.2834773063659668,
0.7719540596008301,
0.9409670829772949,
-0.17703065276145935,
-0.1883595585823059,
-0.8794253468513489,
-0.7562382817268372,
0.7032946348190308,
-0.04241832718253136,
0.3976750373840332,
0.040391478687524796,
0.6993442177772522,
0.1183190792798996,
0.028572356328368187,
-0.40466588735580444,
-0.497528612613678,
0.16580988466739655,
-0.1090577244758606,
-0.16659638285636902,
-0.6098449230194092,
-0.2593051493167877,
-0.4605439007282257,
0.26524868607521057,
-0.1329486221075058,
0.5013368725776672,
-0.08977257460355759,
-0.07800626754760742,
-0.14196522533893585,
0.03707928955554962,
0.6731879711151123,
0.40299248695373535,
-0.4048900306224823,
0.396808922290802,
0.7507982850074768,
-0.6229302287101746,
0.5383383631706238,
-0.33793944120407104,
0.12304148823022842,
-0.1677948385477066,
0.7382073998451233,
0.6575203537940979,
0.5701214671134949,
-0.5486592650413513,
0.42555275559425354,
0.11198937147855759,
-0.6281563639640808,
-0.4615686535835266,
0.3676601052284241,
0.26688581705093384,
0.016446134075522423,
0.3570970594882965,
0.2258506864309311,
-0.07393555343151093,
-0.39587023854255676,
0.1846950799226761,
0.419662207365036,
-0.21728266775608063,
0.019026150926947594,
0.6292766332626343,
0.16469433903694153,
-0.46907737851142883,
0.827610969543457,
-0.27701202034950256,
-0.11001663655042648,
0.6355420351028442,
0.36559033393859863,
0.5529041290283203,
0.06015115976333618,
0.002040681429207325,
0.6411382555961609,
0.47114643454551697,
-0.2770218849182129,
-0.017457151785492897,
-0.1492202877998352,
-0.5924752950668335,
-0.2859095335006714,
-0.9387177228927612,
-0.5228464007377625,
-0.05087079852819443,
-0.7532403469085693,
0.21759143471717834,
-0.6417511701583862,
-0.3325672447681427,
0.15324096381664276,
0.36880508065223694,
-0.7436747550964355,
0.19477848708629608,
0.03926437720656395,
1.086803674697876,
-0.6440861821174622,
0.5718404650688171,
0.619087815284729,
-0.43011248111724854,
-0.9204065203666687,
-0.7609726190567017,
0.06207176297903061,
-1.3093719482421875,
0.7671583294868469,
0.08866412192583084,
-0.019614040851593018,
-0.029421817511320114,
-0.4947502911090851,
-1.1446045637130737,
1.2975314855575562,
0.725005030632019,
-0.39937034249305725,
-0.049903810024261475,
0.23269464075565338,
0.7414350509643555,
-0.26776131987571716,
0.41330641508102417,
0.41461601853370667,
0.3365230858325958,
0.23437738418579102,
-0.8470595479011536,
-0.15621055662631989,
-0.17914286255836487,
0.16630512475967407,
0.4719163775444031,
-0.8405948877334595,
0.8107866048812866,
-0.5145512819290161,
-0.13521970808506012,
0.1152784675359726,
0.5266732573509216,
-0.27238962054252625,
0.1474473923444748,
0.5979829430580139,
0.7984874248504639,
0.9041325449943542,
-0.04773852974176407,
1.0285124778747559,
-0.4670332670211792,
0.20313593745231628,
0.8144583702087402,
0.34221699833869934,
0.7802299857139587,
0.26136839389801025,
-0.5154656171798706,
0.19596460461616516,
1.0120623111724854,
-0.10249247401952744,
0.16070054471492767,
0.5263400077819824,
-0.389216810464859,
-0.3683452308177948,
0.28016671538352966,
-0.07410886138677597,
0.2310185730457306,
0.3160468637943268,
-0.5884253978729248,
-0.17374415695667267,
-0.06426545977592468,
0.16608482599258423,
0.1239832192659378,
-0.6695451140403748,
0.6367483139038086,
0.013734978623688221,
-0.2849366068840027,
1.005502700805664,
0.07991735637187958,
0.6800838708877563,
-0.6087924242019653,
0.14439241588115692,
-0.3596718907356262,
0.029061105102300644,
-0.35112372040748596,
-0.5976037979125977,
0.3139294385910034,
0.034873031079769135,
-0.27341175079345703,
-0.37493160367012024,
0.5818647742271423,
-0.20147348940372467,
-0.4395143985748291,
0.10118430852890015,
0.42163321375846863,
0.6374983191490173,
0.0946945771574974,
-0.42903080582618713,
-0.09447364509105682,
-0.2964778542518616,
-0.4121837317943573,
0.6550085544586182,
0.46795064210891724,
0.25100356340408325,
0.7472786903381348,
0.31142622232437134,
0.3109358251094818,
0.5418633222579956,
-0.04285161569714546,
0.5437769293785095,
-0.5572006106376648,
-0.027264494448900223,
-0.7033225893974304,
0.06746732443571091,
-0.315295547246933,
-0.41769859194755554,
1.0257724523544312,
0.5655848383903503,
0.6820538640022278,
0.036831095814704895,
0.35895395278930664,
0.1307489275932312,
0.6418585181236267,
-0.3526532053947449,
0.32086995244026184,
-0.5978530645370483,
0.36964282393455505,
0.11727730184793472,
-0.7670185565948486,
-0.24099574983119965,
0.5728663802146912,
-0.13545894622802734,
0.2661449611186981,
0.6059101819992065,
0.8228091597557068,
0.24911709129810333,
-0.11221839487552643,
0.6654444336891174,
-0.041181065142154694,
-0.23478515446186066,
0.49997973442077637,
0.5265373587608337,
-0.21536138653755188,
0.5023948550224304,
-0.28254562616348267,
-0.44227302074432373,
-0.33764421939849854,
-0.7046971917152405,
-0.8077174425125122,
-0.36425086855888367,
-0.2752571403980255,
-0.15826241672039032,
-0.16762477159500122,
0.867620587348938,
0.8618582487106323,
-0.24305227398872375,
-0.3030381500720978,
-0.006095376331359148,
0.057970982044935226,
-0.5529825091362,
-0.2128697633743286,
0.3677106499671936,
-0.745675802230835,
-0.822170078754425,
0.20866891741752625,
0.2805183529853821,
0.12334500253200531,
-0.58784019947052,
-0.08490951359272003,
-0.0420248918235302,
0.2411409169435501,
0.6668998599052429,
0.31387996673583984,
-0.23067879676818848,
-0.4367932081222534,
0.11723945289850235,
-0.2920202314853668,
0.008565166033804417,
0.7312780022621155,
-0.5315820574760437,
0.1875036656856537,
0.30837714672088623,
0.771664023399353,
0.7559806704521179,
-0.3407784402370453,
0.237938791513443,
-0.7870791554450989,
-0.16433434188365936,
0.21375274658203125,
0.1203121617436409,
0.2694235146045685,
-0.23250028491020203,
0.9977606534957886,
0.3034971356391907,
-0.5690498948097229,
-0.9003111720085144,
-0.08291291445493698,
-1.12457275390625,
-0.025989368557929993,
1.1355476379394531,
-0.19505445659160614,
-0.17790068686008453,
0.19584444165229797,
0.06052730232477188,
0.1320788711309433,
0.007040765602141619,
0.40144938230514526,
0.5034019947052002,
-0.6180594563484192,
0.05617803335189819,
-0.6132853627204895,
0.6211119294166565,
0.4269840717315674,
-0.40279966592788696,
-0.18564097583293915,
0.17489895224571228,
0.5650290846824646,
0.1741778701543808,
0.8112853765487671,
0.03620373457670212,
0.20043140649795532,
0.5967907905578613,
-0.12524770200252533,
0.007314651273190975,
-0.19793882966041565,
-0.4767829179763794,
0.5434935092926025,
0.6240278482437134,
-0.13857463002204895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14744v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14744v2
|
Large Language Models as Urban Residents: An LLM Agent Framework for Personal Mobility Generation
| 2024-02-22T18:03:14 | 2024-05-23T06:30:23 |
Jiawei Wang, Renhe Jiang, Chuang Yang, Zengqing Wu, Makoto Onizuka, Ryosuke Shibasaki, Noboru Koshizuka, Chuan Xiao
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces a novel approach using Large Language Models (LLMs)
integrated into an agent framework for flexible and effective personal mobility
generation. LLMs overcome the limitations of previous models by effectively
processing semantic data and offering versatility in modeling various tasks.
Our approach addresses three research questions: aligning LLMs with real-world
urban mobility data, developing reliable activity generation strategies, and
exploring LLM applications in urban mobility. The key technical contribution is
a novel LLM agent framework that accounts for individual activity patterns and
motivations, including a self-consistency approach to align LLMs with
real-world activity data and a retrieval-augmented strategy for interpretable
activity generation. We evaluate our LLM agent framework and compare it with
state-of-the-art personal mobility generation approaches, demonstrating the
effectiveness of our approach and its potential applications in urban mobility.
Overall, this study marks the pioneering work of designing an LLM agent
framework for activity generation based on real-world human activity data,
offering a promising tool for urban mobility analysis.
|
[
-0.17866066098213196,
-0.8385648131370544,
0.8688241839408875,
0.03222987800836563,
0.20514680445194244,
0.21339546144008636,
-0.10995074361562729,
-0.506944477558136,
0.45006367564201355,
0.7143596410751343,
-0.4022757112979889,
-0.5825936198234558,
0.018710579723119736,
-0.07587264478206635,
-0.6001926064491272,
0.217782661318779,
-0.00026232111849822104,
0.05838010832667351,
-0.03265680745244026,
-0.12191256135702133,
-0.3234938979148865,
-0.550731360912323,
-0.6810434460639954,
-0.45170101523399353,
0.47064995765686035,
0.4165950417518616,
0.8163456320762634,
0.6400442123413086,
0.2978650629520416,
0.36086270213127136,
0.18798299133777618,
0.16887395083904266,
-0.406649649143219,
0.0588618740439415,
-0.15516652166843414,
0.04202372208237648,
-0.6729947328567505,
-0.3471125066280365,
0.7188559174537659,
0.6628443598747253,
-0.29937663674354553,
0.01010963972657919,
-0.3629445731639862,
0.5382357239723206,
-0.3091490864753723,
-0.12182808667421341,
-0.49042779207229614,
-0.28733429312705994,
-0.4208366572856903,
-0.11170990765094757,
-0.07196091115474701,
-0.24815978109836578,
-0.3127827048301697,
-0.05640217289328575,
0.15556225180625916,
0.08728599548339844,
0.3732512593269348,
0.04989662021398544,
-0.7328470945358276,
-0.4081434905529022,
-0.8677272796630859,
0.5690810084342957,
-0.6898092031478882,
0.3871656358242035,
0.18941423296928406,
0.4925248622894287,
-0.45927566289901733,
-0.5693126320838928,
-0.6624423861503601,
-0.48968347907066345,
0.1980973482131958,
-0.05698208883404732,
0.17457355558872223,
-0.03624216094613075,
-0.2877378463745117,
0.1568794697523117,
-0.46560075879096985,
0.27988478541374207,
-0.2209688276052475,
0.021660849452018738,
1.0148423910140991,
0.7803277373313904,
0.15774808824062347,
0.06901558488607407,
-0.37110018730163574,
0.323641836643219,
-0.9692956805229187,
0.006434123497456312,
0.5337888598442078,
0.5321232080459595,
-0.13432879745960236,
0.6411925554275513,
-0.5357499718666077,
0.28303512930870056,
-0.20324857532978058,
-0.2876463532447815,
0.28140679001808167,
-0.5620152354240417,
0.12334634363651276,
-0.03284057229757309,
0.9371956586837769,
0.16507545113563538,
0.2182534635066986,
-0.45450541377067566,
-0.43864986300468445,
-0.6285737752914429,
0.06644605100154877,
-0.8478469848632812,
0.17681410908699036,
0.4357054531574249,
-0.3354851305484772,
-0.4186491370201111,
0.19320710003376007,
-0.6495702862739563,
-0.37740281224250793,
-0.20839263498783112,
-0.1661696881055832,
0.04661411792039871,
-0.57354336977005,
0.5180232524871826,
0.4670979082584381,
0.37021350860595703,
0.3384367525577545,
-1.1067620515823364,
0.41687729954719543,
0.48200103640556335,
0.7072840332984924,
-0.4616595208644867,
-0.43817391991615295,
-0.19913408160209656,
0.6358346939086914,
-0.2250209003686905,
0.7437214851379395,
-0.47923630475997925,
-0.41214829683303833,
0.4619097411632538,
-0.15256497263908386,
0.18104977905750275,
-0.5713394284248352,
0.24340848624706268,
-0.4039785861968994,
-0.2637062668800354,
-0.016549186781048775,
-0.25990766286849976,
-0.030688105151057243,
0.26317834854125977,
-0.6419287919998169,
1.3010408878326416,
0.40930065512657166,
-0.21299250423908234,
0.09926600009202957,
-0.9119231104850769,
-0.5280548930168152,
0.42507973313331604,
-0.08864287286996841,
-0.13994200527668,
0.22024224698543549,
-0.3275941014289856,
0.7032579183578491,
-0.38684090971946716,
0.3424491286277771,
-0.31730809807777405,
0.03160397335886955,
0.38490238785743713,
-0.163993701338768,
0.6485744714736938,
0.34965118765830994,
-0.03631803020834923,
0.16166436672210693,
-0.7777494192123413,
-0.3718675971031189,
0.2886553108692169,
-0.6361786127090454,
-0.06629122793674469,
0.5054110884666443,
0.09620686620473862,
0.2118271440267563,
0.6881541609764099,
-0.9445642828941345,
0.32707110047340393,
-0.295521080493927,
0.16984923183918,
0.6911078095436096,
-0.1558440774679184,
0.5799027681350708,
-0.4334549307823181,
0.5724920034408569,
-0.01865396834909916,
-0.28636571764945984,
-0.14299167692661285,
-0.389154851436615,
-0.21999536454677582,
-0.16264542937278748,
-0.08739043027162552,
0.42042550444602966,
-0.3915375769138336,
0.4246123433113098,
-0.6071575880050659,
-0.4492902159690857,
-0.3003462255001068,
0.2741868197917938,
-0.2621358335018158,
0.3429064154624939,
0.06517115980386734,
0.11422861367464066,
-0.4667435586452484,
-0.459136962890625,
-0.05788459628820419,
-0.13101007044315338,
0.1022564247250557,
0.3510962426662445,
0.5637066960334778,
-0.734561562538147,
1.1956968307495117,
-0.3945741355419159,
0.00009099500312004238,
-0.6922248005867004,
-0.4294210970401764,
-0.16089121997356415,
0.3274669945240021,
0.7497877478599548,
-0.7906209230422974,
-0.5693762898445129,
0.15773479640483856,
-0.482438862323761,
-0.19391219317913055,
-0.20987987518310547,
-0.17087718844413757,
-0.14640942215919495,
0.33941909670829773,
-0.8193171620368958,
0.2064708024263382,
0.4593040645122528,
-0.657084584236145,
0.4446401000022888,
-0.3636205792427063,
-0.17784328758716583,
-1.3055964708328247,
-0.19264952838420868,
-0.008003677241504192,
-0.8091034889221191,
-0.9210221171379089,
0.2060624063014984,
-0.4995867609977722,
-0.07002897560596466,
-0.5227261781692505,
1.1157864332199097,
-0.2605537176132202,
-0.24873460829257965,
-0.6283115148544312,
0.08924839645624161,
-0.41639062762260437,
-0.014561767689883709,
-0.038328588008880615,
0.7588986754417419,
0.34429964423179626,
-0.5274681448936462,
0.5194765329360962,
0.11668412387371063,
-0.2440660297870636,
0.10978404432535172,
-0.3719755709171295,
0.056498028337955475,
-0.17625753581523895,
0.18342959880828857,
-0.8621574640274048,
-0.5212251543998718,
0.17646059393882751,
-0.053016822785139084,
-0.20935127139091492,
0.32764068245887756,
-1.0573033094406128,
-0.19417306780815125,
-0.13184449076652527,
0.23786281049251556,
0.4635866582393646,
-0.4936354458332062,
1.0829534530639648,
0.7690706849098206,
0.000530263117980212,
0.13064388930797577,
-0.5461751222610474,
0.15113048255443573,
-0.4599657952785492,
-0.8722473382949829,
0.13169698417186737,
-0.2774014174938202,
-0.5884333252906799,
-0.2270841896533966,
0.39974331855773926,
-0.23060490190982819,
0.4434490203857422,
0.23096586763858795,
-0.07845781743526459,
0.07477892190217972,
-0.06536634266376495,
-0.32784003019332886,
-0.051230549812316895,
0.10697384178638458,
0.07672119140625,
0.7389858961105347,
0.08984625339508057,
-0.1745924949645996,
-0.08408250659704208,
0.423978328704834,
0.6348149180412292,
-0.2120448797941208,
0.6111444234848022,
0.5196037292480469,
-0.1980907917022705,
-0.0227638091892004,
-0.34009647369384766,
0.17717015743255615,
-0.5270128846168518,
0.36492323875427246,
-0.4834824502468109,
-0.9045575261116028,
0.7415763735771179,
-0.48682624101638794,
0.31047290563583374,
0.09432660788297653,
1.1059874296188354,
-0.3413057029247284,
1.0285192728042603,
0.7064884901046753,
0.14244268834590912,
0.5812157988548279,
0.1924116462469101,
0.13682524859905243,
-0.640852153301239,
-0.20445851981639862,
-0.42526164650917053,
-0.17678353190422058,
-0.6038158535957336,
-0.548518717288971,
-0.007102019153535366,
-0.3645074963569641,
-0.29329565167427063,
0.1497337818145752,
-0.1546601951122284,
0.25940755009651184,
0.134878471493721,
-0.18147455155849457,
0.31177809834480286,
0.016687069088220596,
0.13829635083675385,
0.36798086762428284,
-0.5028902888298035,
-0.9427357912063599,
1.0310814380645752,
0.48984289169311523,
0.8810843825340271,
0.522515058517456,
0.6610804200172424,
0.44394707679748535,
0.3924843370914459,
-0.5850493311882019,
0.9160462617874146,
-0.026548847556114197,
-0.8015192747116089,
-0.42217978835105896,
-0.4270365834236145,
-1.318801760673523,
0.3011644184589386,
-0.13956527411937714,
-0.9787387847900391,
-0.0901840403676033,
-0.09772246330976486,
-0.2756337523460388,
0.3771583139896393,
-0.39372628927230835,
0.7202706933021545,
-0.5317191481590271,
-0.3722992241382599,
-0.19860410690307617,
-0.29101017117500305,
0.3102246820926666,
-0.42649295926094055,
0.5359641313552856,
-0.714574933052063,
-0.2754063308238983,
0.21167226135730743,
-0.3604404032230377,
0.8065384030342102,
-0.19042851030826569,
-0.3597094714641571,
0.41128700971603394,
0.02297261357307434,
0.8153416514396667,
-0.09158758819103241,
-0.3731997609138489,
0.13480736315250397,
-0.24188311398029327,
-0.36882084608078003,
-0.262376606464386,
0.7349643707275391,
-0.6760359406471252,
-0.29998642206192017,
0.010640745051205158,
-0.744064450263977,
0.05890560522675514,
0.271308034658432,
-0.12966643273830414,
0.2646007835865021,
-0.38143470883369446,
0.09312616288661957,
0.41590481996536255,
0.20532052218914032,
0.6363765001296997,
0.9028571248054504,
-0.5045523047447205,
-0.15352579951286316,
1.1129056215286255,
0.16936613619327545,
0.0005411356687545776,
0.5092175602912903,
0.2778482437133789,
-0.4275013506412506,
-0.8626098036766052,
-0.27705809473991394,
0.24326036870479584,
-0.3800031542778015,
0.24524517357349396,
-0.47423452138900757,
0.2041020691394806,
-0.416928231716156,
-0.42035767436027527,
-0.6709912419319153,
-0.07162801921367645,
-0.13753856718540192,
-0.05695703998208046,
-0.06574452668428421,
1.0370055437088013,
0.10325642675161362,
0.5512279272079468,
-0.6274681687355042,
0.3618367314338684,
0.23285171389579773,
-0.01150778029114008,
-0.24940656125545502,
-0.07971664518117905,
-0.6553715467453003,
0.11252518743276596,
-0.29674166440963745,
-1.044432282447815,
0.39572790265083313,
-0.2506047487258911,
0.67303466796875,
0.4134184718132019,
0.09545176476240158,
0.39779213070869446,
-0.5435456037521362,
0.9229623079299927,
0.04618394002318382,
-0.5449647903442383,
0.14687950909137726,
-0.6778889298439026,
0.29989543557167053,
0.6061530113220215,
-0.020818470045924187,
-0.1316627413034439,
-0.39432913064956665,
-0.4703110158443451,
-0.9241915941238403,
0.1435406655073166,
0.29898494482040405,
0.4490719139575958,
-0.11823446303606033,
0.5307844281196594,
0.026951847597956657,
0.2977272570133209,
-1.0546854734420776,
-0.28916364908218384,
-0.0009240713552571833,
-0.4555414617061615,
-0.03870341554284096,
-0.34737828373908997,
-0.030586672946810722,
-0.15465717017650604,
0.4558020234107971,
-0.3785123825073242,
0.10123544931411743,
0.07168286293745041,
0.029313964769244194,
-0.15674640238285065,
0.1723012924194336,
0.9521840214729309,
0.7300835847854614,
-0.20970763266086578,
0.03350728005170822,
0.2816852927207947,
-0.47835391759872437,
0.6069940328598022,
-0.21918551623821259,
-0.48739004135131836,
0.06165040284395218,
0.0381910540163517,
0.3139456808567047,
-0.0028418824076652527,
-0.9541333317756653,
0.5051750540733337,
-0.001587378210388124,
-0.1804077923297882,
-0.9495603442192078,
0.12483048439025879,
0.21674570441246033,
0.3522929549217224,
0.43992942571640015,
-0.3002699911594391,
-0.02642432227730751,
-0.5214201211929321,
-0.11468754708766937,
0.5397317409515381,
-0.3584997057914734,
-0.5589128136634827,
0.8414629697799683,
0.579477846622467,
-0.4631534218788147,
0.2648777663707733,
-0.5135686993598938,
-0.006641663610935211,
0.5308107137680054,
0.47604480385780334,
1.1208606958389282,
-0.31944164633750916,
-0.11315412074327469,
0.14055190980434418,
0.2689918577671051,
-0.20148958265781403,
0.4688138961791992,
0.15091952681541443,
-1.0339547395706177,
-0.5136989951133728,
-0.44373804330825806,
-0.18110691010951996,
-0.016159839928150177,
-0.22759266197681427,
0.26197168231010437,
-0.22827644646167755,
-0.13750626146793365,
-0.43573030829429626,
0.17151086032390594,
-0.4155987799167633,
0.025552602484822273,
0.28114908933639526,
1.1366851329803467,
-0.5935486555099487,
1.1453332901000977,
1.1248573064804077,
-0.0019488270627334714,
-0.6390742063522339,
0.28114941716194153,
-0.16340844333171844,
-0.4316164553165436,
0.5213015675544739,
0.03936544433236122,
-0.44661372900009155,
0.1316608339548111,
-0.5374460816383362,
-0.8669226765632629,
1.49391770362854,
0.46169161796569824,
-0.5042631030082703,
-0.18157334625720978,
0.47422903776168823,
0.41892990469932556,
-1.0185067653656006,
-0.005782251711934805,
0.5275989174842834,
0.4737717807292938,
0.1614292562007904,
-0.5664576292037964,
0.23425647616386414,
0.3221678137779236,
0.1758861392736435,
0.14605511724948883,
-1.0609534978866577,
0.556493878364563,
-0.25384920835494995,
-0.06975173205137253,
0.4142155051231384,
0.7219814658164978,
0.4580817222595215,
0.3066346049308777,
0.4297659993171692,
0.256141722202301,
0.7152408361434937,
0.14715692400932312,
1.081369161605835,
-0.78872150182724,
0.3155227303504944,
0.9500303864479065,
-0.7054743766784668,
0.7134236693382263,
0.2706792652606964,
0.0640057697892189,
0.5079485177993774,
0.38172808289527893,
0.138179749250412,
0.4688296616077423,
0.2128864824771881,
-0.5807921290397644,
-0.45133069157600403,
-0.016011379659175873,
0.1536184847354889,
0.7247596979141235,
0.09620912373065948,
0.05598096176981926,
-0.4174647331237793,
0.06993792951107025,
0.041063256561756134,
0.054822713136672974,
-0.3699803054332733,
0.6859357953071594,
-0.16396895051002502,
-0.28555166721343994,
-0.1159401386976242,
0.3265966773033142,
0.2144172489643097,
-0.6953684091567993,
0.08561410754919052,
-0.15587429702281952,
0.02880287542939186,
-0.1768275797367096,
-0.7836952805519104,
0.3409394323825836,
-0.19646011292934418,
-0.17366871237754822,
-0.6127910614013672,
0.6902236342430115,
-0.26078060269355774,
-0.32639265060424805,
0.22026591002941132,
0.5176993608474731,
0.4425528347492218,
0.11133424937725067,
-0.6602168083190918,
0.03260257467627525,
0.11291384696960449,
-0.46755310893058777,
0.4641943573951721,
0.5881668925285339,
0.05624433234333992,
1.1116445064544678,
0.718708872795105,
0.30242371559143066,
0.21191607415676117,
-0.13571956753730774,
0.7133612632751465,
-1.0030734539031982,
-0.4531187415122986,
-0.8817514777183533,
0.8005790710449219,
0.08855883777141571,
-0.2592310309410095,
0.770881175994873,
0.8492588400840759,
0.3553165793418884,
0.14854289591312408,
0.7838689088821411,
-0.12421145290136337,
0.6311492919921875,
-0.41926175355911255,
0.2428748607635498,
-0.3734530806541443,
0.7157712578773499,
0.3097427785396576,
-0.7700667977333069,
0.1036677435040474,
0.6002381443977356,
-0.15911433100700378,
0.08532244712114334,
0.22667136788368225,
0.7515292763710022,
0.050431471318006516,
-0.5839625000953674,
0.5916423797607422,
0.08568383753299713,
0.7138272523880005,
0.3668825924396515,
1.0011487007141113,
-0.16531237959861755,
0.32441338896751404,
0.1248437687754631,
0.21641488373279572,
-0.3895033895969391,
-0.5955198407173157,
-0.9811006784439087,
-0.39763882756233215,
-0.2122507393360138,
-0.26192599534988403,
-0.32823213934898376,
1.0628925561904907,
0.9755781888961792,
-0.4190615117549896,
-0.6609277725219727,
-0.3433815836906433,
0.20262408256530762,
0.15176598727703094,
-0.260131299495697,
-0.07231422513723373,
-0.06905200332403183,
-0.8767125010490417,
0.774185299873352,
0.27439364790916443,
0.5172803997993469,
-0.8159163594245911,
-0.5968440175056458,
0.09845823794603348,
0.294471800327301,
0.6128835678100586,
0.37511029839515686,
-0.575258731842041,
-0.18683108687400818,
-0.26576724648475647,
-0.49925166368484497,
0.14553990960121155,
0.9459220767021179,
-0.6422849893569946,
0.17042528092861176,
0.4096837639808655,
0.4096088409423828,
0.5228203535079956,
0.31152868270874023,
0.6316457390785217,
-0.6184006333351135,
0.2334345132112503,
0.14203260838985443,
0.368654727935791,
0.24255111813545227,
-0.4036701023578644,
0.5722862482070923,
-0.02401338703930378,
-0.7262712121009827,
-0.7146430611610413,
0.612589418888092,
-1.0477635860443115,
-0.2641504108905792,
1.5193785429000854,
0.20516204833984375,
-0.22238481044769287,
-0.4942960739135742,
-0.14027367532253265,
-0.3389735221862793,
-0.6127976179122925,
0.6114956736564636,
0.3606674075126648,
-0.30747273564338684,
-0.1688162386417389,
-1.047526240348816,
0.087311290204525,
-0.1750953197479248,
-0.9668938517570496,
0.28736039996147156,
0.3826254904270172,
0.2789463400840759,
0.012338402681052685,
1.1020516157150269,
0.13252651691436768,
-0.045495353639125824,
-0.2660117447376251,
0.19587142765522003,
-0.16647551953792572,
-0.17757351696491241,
-0.16369245946407318,
0.3999198377132416,
0.27400216460227966,
0.14545287191867828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14743v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14743v1
|
Dependency Annotation of Ottoman Turkish with Multilingual BERT
| 2024-02-22T17:58:50 | 2024-02-22T17:58:50 |
Şaziye Betül Özateş, Tarık Emre Tıraş, Efe Eren Genç, Esma Fatıma Bilgin Taşdemir
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study introduces a pretrained large language model-based annotation
methodology for the first dependency treebank in Ottoman Turkish. Our
experimental results show that, iteratively, i) pseudo-annotating data using a
multilingual BERT-based parsing model, ii) manually correcting the
pseudo-annotations, and iii) fine-tuning the parsing model with the corrected
annotations, we speed up and simplify the challenging dependency annotation
process. The resulting treebank, that will be a part of the Universal
Dependencies (UD) project, will facilitate automated analysis of Ottoman
Turkish documents, unlocking the linguistic richness embedded in this
historical heritage.
|
[
-0.7667372226715088,
-0.5460915565490723,
0.3192939758300781,
0.26981380581855774,
-0.3065374493598938,
-0.2679296135902405,
-0.10626506060361862,
-0.9163399934768677,
0.4178938865661621,
0.5701301693916321,
-0.4576244354248047,
-0.39807119965553284,
-0.5420836806297302,
0.1095699593424797,
0.17856068909168243,
1.1552764177322388,
-0.19824527204036713,
0.38895943760871887,
0.1710185408592224,
-0.3700568675994873,
-0.36036476492881775,
-0.8901646733283997,
-0.10766112059354782,
0.010741032660007477,
0.672123372554779,
0.38654059171676636,
0.37305018305778503,
0.5482523441314697,
0.5148841142654419,
0.24234835803508759,
-0.15721356868743896,
-0.268837571144104,
0.08754794299602509,
0.11982311308383942,
-0.04711543396115303,
-0.29763898253440857,
-0.243709534406662,
-0.02200557291507721,
0.8040850758552551,
0.6619738340377808,
0.002723447047173977,
0.613039493560791,
-0.011873161420226097,
0.6085104942321777,
-0.6341478824615479,
0.40822169184684753,
-0.49413973093032837,
-0.20188577473163605,
-0.6349619030952454,
-0.04952124506235123,
-0.2777351140975952,
-0.020287465304136276,
0.3694695234298706,
-0.35225382447242737,
0.18457406759262085,
0.04435943067073822,
0.8683368563652039,
0.17136968672275543,
-0.5132075548171997,
-0.12104733288288116,
-0.6646748781204224,
0.8115618228912354,
-0.6250761151313782,
0.4972364008426666,
0.7018446922302246,
0.2185087651014328,
-0.189995676279068,
-0.7726989984512329,
-0.24509353935718536,
-0.5129449963569641,
-0.4362727999687195,
-0.2828225791454315,
0.4040481150150299,
0.29675424098968506,
0.15302444994449615,
0.2577967345714569,
-0.297928124666214,
-0.07812728732824326,
-0.3884938061237335,
-0.24351419508457184,
0.2760852873325348,
-0.09651222079992294,
0.2685130834579468,
-0.17258517444133759,
-0.06674468517303467,
-0.00482475059106946,
-0.8588749170303345,
0.2667122483253479,
0.41119322180747986,
0.7937374711036682,
0.19247546792030334,
0.6245676279067993,
-0.08060011267662048,
0.6396030187606812,
-0.09012401103973389,
-0.06453399360179901,
0.17092306911945343,
-0.1332729011774063,
-0.24540792405605316,
0.49828827381134033,
0.3185870051383972,
-0.20873600244522095,
0.2426704615354538,
0.12827125191688538,
-0.05415093153715134,
-0.1753707081079483,
0.3061182498931885,
-0.7722760438919067,
-0.34452199935913086,
0.2865578830242157,
-0.5848681330680847,
0.04870633780956268,
0.04769536480307579,
-0.4491536319255829,
-0.36094996333122253,
-0.37366214394569397,
0.3178413510322571,
-0.33630725741386414,
-0.21507149934768677,
-0.23521941900253296,
0.31206464767456055,
0.13582739233970642,
0.4611610770225525,
-1.2824331521987915,
0.024535343050956726,
0.544684648513794,
0.7321539521217346,
0.6382873058319092,
-0.40213537216186523,
-0.45647987723350525,
0.4261419475078583,
-0.31755223870277405,
1.1616183519363403,
-0.4131203293800354,
0.007995456457138062,
0.30428922176361084,
0.25589776039123535,
0.2764984667301178,
-0.2753542363643646,
0.855752170085907,
-0.1813487708568573,
0.2730392515659332,
-0.6073963642120361,
-0.667364776134491,
-0.6123471856117249,
0.2324591875076294,
-1.1438149213790894,
1.091373324394226,
0.31515809893608093,
-1.0434415340423584,
0.7281590700149536,
-0.5251047611236572,
-0.591920793056488,
0.3523835241794586,
-0.1463579386472702,
-0.43478286266326904,
0.08056751638650894,
0.24072223901748657,
0.45590609312057495,
0.002848750911653042,
0.3774659335613251,
-0.26874279975891113,
-0.2693466246128082,
-0.6362307071685791,
0.09809987992048264,
1.2761290073394775,
-0.037734098732471466,
-0.547740638256073,
0.1571367084980011,
-1.1297703981399536,
-0.4681793749332428,
-0.16199712455272675,
-0.7115335464477539,
-0.4684773087501526,
0.301232248544693,
0.5840002298355103,
0.1209668442606926,
0.3944492042064667,
-0.684482991695404,
0.5916969776153564,
-0.34642234444618225,
-0.1769382208585739,
0.8836876749992371,
-0.2072640210390091,
-0.028874950483441353,
-0.2989656329154968,
0.2509590983390808,
-0.009981135837733746,
0.032956697046756744,
-0.33390381932258606,
-0.540483295917511,
-0.8340896368026733,
-0.7334776520729065,
0.41221359372138977,
0.5266768932342529,
-0.11563048511743546,
0.43083634972572327,
0.18417921662330627,
-0.37039288878440857,
-0.5910295844078064,
0.18047530949115753,
0.0023663535248488188,
0.3268184959888458,
0.34800347685813904,
-0.25214481353759766,
-1.2650527954101562,
-0.9069079756736755,
0.19014911353588104,
-0.7130923867225647,
0.31775274872779846,
0.009157020598649979,
0.5018430352210999,
-0.16424895823001862,
0.7548020482063293,
0.34004831314086914,
-0.9052143692970276,
-0.3096853196620941,
0.5748243927955627,
0.2699757516384125,
0.5576686859130859,
0.8265412449836731,
-0.4194519519805908,
-0.6609840989112854,
0.10572561621665955,
-0.2898319959640503,
-0.1802445948123932,
0.013701405376195908,
0.11773472279310226,
0.5805671215057373,
0.32904765009880066,
-0.5070971250534058,
0.46377646923065186,
0.46249935030937195,
-0.4705411493778229,
0.9913771152496338,
-0.3531348705291748,
0.2768577039241791,
-0.9120544195175171,
0.3840930461883545,
-0.2559654116630554,
-0.16793587803840637,
-0.5896139740943909,
-0.2111128270626068,
-0.05702562630176544,
0.36671486496925354,
-0.48298147320747375,
0.43209391832351685,
-0.4723784029483795,
0.10373742133378983,
0.06513168662786484,
-0.7939367294311523,
-0.1249186098575592,
0.39841923117637634,
0.355109304189682,
0.5483170747756958,
0.4784429371356964,
-0.22805412113666534,
0.3625522553920746,
0.4198695421218872,
-0.6464307904243469,
0.34997987747192383,
-0.3502219617366791,
-0.19430029392242432,
-0.16884367167949677,
0.2556922435760498,
-1.1028485298156738,
-0.000965423765592277,
0.2982795536518097,
-0.1847972273826599,
0.2805045247077942,
-0.6826024651527405,
-0.7574467062950134,
-0.05191877484321594,
-0.32980450987815857,
0.3281901478767395,
0.054616570472717285,
-0.5773352980613708,
0.7239816188812256,
0.18672297894954681,
-0.4288223385810852,
-0.7594032287597656,
-0.7529488801956177,
0.20400571823120117,
-0.18417000770568848,
-0.5812328457832336,
-0.04738444834947586,
0.09517433494329453,
-0.39362964034080505,
-0.07342153042554855,
0.28357815742492676,
-0.3408811390399933,
0.20609314739704132,
0.23088893294334412,
0.34340396523475647,
-0.40264269709587097,
0.2696056365966797,
-0.14869190752506256,
-0.05466515198349953,
-0.18238137662410736,
-0.39344263076782227,
0.35318759083747864,
-0.37705251574516296,
-0.20897066593170166,
-0.4496595859527588,
0.5633319616317749,
0.4052181839942932,
-0.443264365196228,
1.113830804824829,
0.5693962574005127,
-0.3866726756095886,
0.32043564319610596,
-0.9494754076004028,
0.06314060091972351,
-0.39766278862953186,
0.3881092369556427,
-0.5138407945632935,
-0.9854288697242737,
0.7020680904388428,
0.010772972367703915,
0.41201308369636536,
0.5469452142715454,
0.7416723966598511,
-0.46198636293411255,
0.8515459895133972,
0.956817626953125,
-0.32683199644088745,
0.6338024735450745,
0.09396158903837204,
-0.12256083637475967,
-0.25287720561027527,
-0.06249811872839928,
-0.8612256646156311,
-0.04710593447089195,
-0.7760242819786072,
0.22583894431591034,
-0.05729418247938156,
0.27345263957977295,
-0.2316448837518692,
0.1752365380525589,
-0.17809680104255676,
0.18400029838085175,
0.9073184132575989,
-0.36480847001075745,
0.0053834328427910805,
0.06801377236843109,
-0.2643473744392395,
-0.02212197333574295,
-0.2915540635585785,
-0.6318987607955933,
1.1735475063323975,
0.16528987884521484,
0.2853067219257355,
0.19411204755306244,
0.7890219688415527,
0.4043944776058197,
0.390325665473938,
-0.5360755920410156,
0.10178032517433167,
-0.04739812761545181,
-1.0013573169708252,
-0.36174848675727844,
0.058106429874897,
-1.095495581626892,
0.061823464930057526,
-0.2984491288661957,
-1.2114763259887695,
0.16015289723873138,
0.3032003939151764,
-0.31953734159469604,
0.3189489245414734,
-0.6975827813148499,
1.0208969116210938,
-0.1900647133588791,
-0.07936888933181763,
-0.22853028774261475,
-0.8342312574386597,
0.05654709041118622,
-0.010294309817254543,
0.20182926952838898,
-0.0716981515288353,
0.4085674583911896,
0.8904252648353577,
-0.5336755514144897,
0.7254269123077393,
-0.40832898020744324,
-0.10589724779129028,
0.31861287355422974,
0.12174505740404129,
0.49409720301628113,
-0.17449580132961273,
0.05935383588075638,
0.27839264273643494,
0.5090774893760681,
-0.7727733254432678,
-0.1558293104171753,
0.21104581654071808,
-0.7837576866149902,
-0.5981955528259277,
-0.6155312061309814,
-0.4834698438644409,
-0.21544969081878662,
0.34397628903388977,
-0.23522904515266418,
0.3019126355648041,
-0.46835508942604065,
-0.1280992329120636,
0.2989913821220398,
-0.08552209287881851,
0.6101674437522888,
0.5455943942070007,
-0.3909028470516205,
-0.3696528673171997,
0.5990227460861206,
0.28638556599617004,
-0.45112940669059753,
0.3503819704055786,
0.010498224757611752,
-0.20947809517383575,
-0.5074000358581543,
-0.7471411228179932,
0.2509976923465729,
-0.7396811842918396,
0.25361597537994385,
-0.43235474824905396,
-0.0028000986203551292,
-0.6435768604278564,
-0.11936960369348526,
-0.5043644309043884,
-0.4933479428291321,
-0.2680191993713379,
-0.31877365708351135,
0.3541352152824402,
0.9843660593032837,
-0.4711434245109558,
0.4213915467262268,
-1.0790057182312012,
0.11355695128440857,
0.2994445562362671,
0.4432986378669739,
-0.21721456944942474,
-0.2036433070898056,
-0.8473930358886719,
-0.2712230384349823,
0.011016658507287502,
-0.8975093960762024,
0.04261024296283722,
0.29053327441215515,
0.6949790716171265,
0.6419236660003662,
-0.2930189371109009,
0.41472113132476807,
-0.590316116809845,
0.8755035400390625,
0.03836960345506668,
-0.8562198877334595,
0.548285722732544,
-0.37936750054359436,
0.22104394435882568,
0.7437357306480408,
0.26846104860305786,
-0.5142814517021179,
-0.30824145674705505,
-0.46875929832458496,
-0.9643595218658447,
0.999409019947052,
-0.1727023869752884,
-0.12032822519540787,
0.09787775576114655,
0.0966910794377327,
0.401244193315506,
-0.06249740347266197,
-0.7324279546737671,
-0.4191429913043976,
-0.16181108355522156,
-0.16521316766738892,
-0.12302444130182266,
-1.0025326013565063,
0.09006882458925247,
-0.5657089948654175,
1.0116033554077148,
0.27153632044792175,
0.02221771888434887,
-0.03080287203192711,
-0.5053830742835999,
-0.32384613156318665,
0.13967669010162354,
0.6057784557342529,
0.8422670364379883,
-0.7896386981010437,
0.3252212703227997,
-0.11990711092948914,
-0.5962175726890564,
0.42281877994537354,
0.5688371658325195,
-0.05414889380335808,
0.28429335355758667,
0.6555399298667908,
0.7347081899642944,
-0.2909594476222992,
-0.5353178381919861,
0.2943640649318695,
-0.019172461703419685,
-0.04208355024456978,
-0.5736823081970215,
-0.6379639506340027,
0.14880166947841644,
0.30296945571899414,
0.5503708124160767,
-0.3713447153568268,
0.13305819034576416,
-0.38487258553504944,
0.48812368512153625,
0.22513435781002045,
-0.3578825294971466,
-0.17736156284809113,
0.2904704511165619,
-0.0017930885078385472,
0.04514564573764801,
0.5556582808494568,
0.12097687274217606,
-0.6869542598724365,
0.3593813180923462,
0.2415120005607605,
0.7885197401046753,
-0.6968817114830017,
0.28327250480651855,
0.5526371002197266,
0.7026544213294983,
0.0684623271226883,
0.4553428888320923,
-0.2112777680158615,
-0.43895435333251953,
-0.8004475831985474,
-0.7623226642608643,
-0.21454468369483948,
0.15460379421710968,
-0.6130909323692322,
0.4177332818508148,
-0.4205992519855499,
0.0916336327791214,
0.09877725690603256,
0.2683480381965637,
-0.5126441121101379,
0.3568398654460907,
0.4861561357975006,
0.6477974057197571,
-0.9955373406410217,
1.3409556150436401,
1.2534021139144897,
-0.6315128803253174,
-0.6622386574745178,
-0.26295799016952515,
-0.15074650943279266,
-0.6498269438743591,
0.9857815504074097,
0.44311287999153137,
0.1651492416858673,
-0.1497354656457901,
-0.3002479672431946,
-0.7805213332176208,
0.5021167397499084,
0.44413304328918457,
-0.6247768998146057,
0.3550371527671814,
0.5174376368522644,
0.528171181678772,
-0.05590682476758957,
0.5713769197463989,
0.6132630109786987,
0.818176805973053,
-0.2834363877773285,
-0.9914970397949219,
-0.14625698328018188,
-0.3885602056980133,
-0.04475044086575508,
0.3644534945487976,
-0.21630731225013733,
0.7561215162277222,
0.1326010525226593,
0.05028039216995239,
0.062375690788030624,
0.7719066739082336,
-0.06145535781979561,
-0.16231264173984528,
0.5140883922576904,
0.9031943082809448,
0.5569664239883423,
0.24592772126197815,
0.6460408568382263,
-0.43265244364738464,
0.3597658574581146,
1.33632493019104,
0.10394566506147385,
0.6740236282348633,
0.7904226183891296,
-0.28455495834350586,
0.6344731450080872,
1.007874846458435,
0.052992433309555054,
0.5708114504814148,
0.22509479522705078,
-0.45447057485580444,
-0.07059694081544876,
-0.35476648807525635,
-0.5024694204330444,
0.42545509338378906,
0.11859659850597382,
-0.446712464094162,
-0.39822128415107727,
-0.006270282436162233,
0.18373867869377136,
-0.5371582508087158,
-0.2866016626358032,
0.8022733330726624,
-0.2686672806739807,
-0.3401109576225281,
0.5768246650695801,
-0.10947787016630173,
0.23073333501815796,
-0.6573835015296936,
-0.3168492615222931,
-0.17542298138141632,
0.10455378890037537,
-0.08033736795186996,
-0.2603985369205475,
0.380219966173172,
-0.06286052614450455,
-0.310397744178772,
-0.10393057763576508,
0.4390077292919159,
-0.4495018720626831,
-0.8159788250923157,
0.4568668603897095,
0.36161893606185913,
0.1340416967868805,
-0.22631485760211945,
-0.4496650993824005,
-0.06801997870206833,
0.018596019595861435,
-0.5867748856544495,
0.2835002839565277,
0.3782820701599121,
-0.2547016441822052,
0.1582728624343872,
0.523464024066925,
0.22217175364494324,
0.22495965659618378,
0.1403372436761856,
0.5724318027496338,
-0.5609157085418701,
-0.48029759526252747,
-1.0151259899139404,
0.6600914001464844,
0.49246254563331604,
-0.16212794184684753,
0.4870590269565582,
0.4721985459327698,
0.9252044558525085,
0.03781552612781525,
1.0088136196136475,
-0.38210529088974,
0.482509583234787,
-0.08957352489233017,
0.7324681878089905,
-0.6463871002197266,
-0.04606114700436592,
-0.3752686679363251,
-1.2345999479293823,
-0.639441967010498,
0.7435968518257141,
-0.09164172410964966,
-0.28505566716194153,
0.678787350654602,
0.4885391294956207,
0.12695492804050446,
-0.0187531765550375,
0.2884971499443054,
0.40311750769615173,
0.3259003758430481,
0.22976039350032806,
0.982790470123291,
0.13666491210460663,
0.3567970395088196,
-0.6145499348640442,
-0.3276784420013428,
-0.27236801385879517,
-1.014083981513977,
-0.9734768867492676,
-0.9071186780929565,
0.04985851049423218,
-0.3586747646331787,
0.15397976338863373,
1.2569068670272827,
0.5666208863258362,
-1.5262938737869263,
-0.4762820303440094,
-0.018135569989681244,
-0.13069915771484375,
-0.0985698252916336,
-0.11803581565618515,
0.7800214290618896,
-0.5230701565742493,
-0.41079363226890564,
0.019206227734684944,
0.23253782093524933,
0.21787235140800476,
-0.2644668221473694,
0.08462737500667572,
-0.8798729777336121,
-0.17335669696331024,
0.273649662733078,
0.38039374351501465,
-0.8041060566902161,
-0.5485762357711792,
-0.7080031037330627,
-0.051515623927116394,
0.465629518032074,
0.8043932914733887,
-0.5791555047035217,
0.7525763511657715,
0.4417313039302826,
0.623706579208374,
0.6534579992294312,
-0.2610952854156494,
0.39076730608940125,
-0.5639146566390991,
0.672078549861908,
0.03997882828116417,
0.8070562481880188,
0.3602524995803833,
-0.25160449743270874,
0.3040841817855835,
0.24753637611865997,
-0.47585007548332214,
-0.543809175491333,
0.05547698959708214,
-0.7588412165641785,
-0.2841770350933075,
0.7880538105964661,
-0.6962466835975647,
-0.10084398835897446,
-0.6981449127197266,
-0.8208792805671692,
0.5364062786102295,
-0.1887691169977188,
1.1395930051803589,
1.0286868810653687,
0.05797926336526871,
-0.42396703362464905,
-0.26172855496406555,
0.5650169253349304,
0.7094712257385254,
-0.6946474313735962,
-0.01580883376300335,
0.7379124164581299,
-0.0906183049082756,
0.1826123148202896,
0.7262777090072632,
0.3309062421321869,
0.11776860058307648,
-0.06993627548217773,
0.803836464881897,
-0.12601947784423828,
-0.42779603600502014,
-0.1044110581278801,
0.006280835252255201,
0.4558904767036438,
-0.2115710824728012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14897v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14897v3
|
Chain-of-Thought Unfaithfulness as Disguised Accuracy
| 2024-02-22T17:23:53 | 2024-06-21T13:39:14 |
Oliver Bentham, Nathan Stringham, Ana Marasović
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Understanding the extent to which Chain-of-Thought (CoT) generations align
with a large language model's (LLM) internal computations is critical for
deciding whether to trust an LLM's output. As a proxy for CoT faithfulness,
Lanham et al. (2023) propose a metric that measures a model's dependence on its
CoT for producing an answer. Within a single family of proprietary models, they
find that LLMs exhibit a scaling-then-inverse-scaling relationship between
model size and their measure of faithfulness, and that a 13 billion parameter
model exhibits increased faithfulness compared to models ranging from 810
million to 175 billion parameters in size. We evaluate whether these results
generalize as a property of all LLMs. We replicate the experimental setup in
their section focused on scaling experiments with three different families of
models and, under specific conditions, successfully reproduce the scaling
trends for CoT faithfulness they report. However, after normalizing the metric
to account for a model's bias toward certain answer choices, unfaithfulness
drops significantly for smaller less-capable models. This normalized
faithfulness metric is also strongly correlated ($R^2$=0.74) with accuracy,
raising doubts about its validity for evaluating faithfulness.
|
[
-0.393845796585083,
-0.6961175799369812,
0.9424934387207031,
0.14514240622520447,
-0.35519957542419434,
0.27909010648727417,
-0.0423959419131279,
-0.5180070400238037,
0.1057322695851326,
0.6110354661941528,
-0.39523664116859436,
0.04500405117869377,
-0.6699153780937195,
-0.07069471478462219,
-0.6289799213409424,
1.0775693655014038,
-0.2330278903245926,
0.11331142485141754,
-0.2594866156578064,
-0.2693284749984741,
-0.018743714317679405,
-0.6523837447166443,
-0.3523602783679962,
-0.33959120512008667,
0.5803883075714111,
0.15081655979156494,
1.1618314981460571,
0.8331964015960693,
0.5109289288520813,
0.17874576151371002,
-0.14746499061584473,
0.29489871859550476,
-0.7550773620605469,
0.09478455781936646,
-0.48261499404907227,
-0.5881080627441406,
-0.6390920877456665,
0.3557266891002655,
0.6651039123535156,
0.7542322278022766,
0.016891613602638245,
0.49902042746543884,
0.30379801988601685,
0.9141026139259338,
-0.7944762110710144,
-0.4065127372741699,
-0.8329951167106628,
-0.3094097375869751,
-0.022348830476403236,
0.005229252856224775,
-0.6384444832801819,
-0.3117881417274475,
0.0450618602335453,
-0.2584282159805298,
0.43646132946014404,
0.2330523431301117,
0.7808298468589783,
0.16243387758731842,
-0.5191388726234436,
-0.380376398563385,
-0.9023793339729309,
0.7996872663497925,
-0.7762768864631653,
0.39007604122161865,
0.4646073877811432,
-0.11022656410932541,
-0.42551377415657043,
-0.6559436917304993,
-0.533150851726532,
-0.3015391528606415,
0.046089984476566315,
-0.03744152933359146,
-0.27356791496276855,
0.072813481092453,
0.24825643002986908,
0.7015706300735474,
-0.17208115756511688,
-0.16866488754749298,
-0.03781919926404953,
-0.07723331451416016,
0.5781177282333374,
0.2532656490802765,
0.13166455924510956,
0.3778875768184662,
-0.5075030326843262,
-0.022520938888192177,
-0.816344678401947,
-0.204718679189682,
0.43855246901512146,
0.11504422128200531,
0.0017059758538380265,
0.5641322731971741,
0.22101685404777527,
0.48738566040992737,
0.26770514249801636,
0.03319075331091881,
-0.23089148104190826,
-0.46439647674560547,
-0.3704620897769928,
-0.034142255783081055,
0.8158220648765564,
0.13506349921226501,
0.2899080514907837,
-0.25223591923713684,
-0.25806865096092224,
0.26653602719306946,
0.5933717489242554,
-0.5836948156356812,
-0.06969700753688812,
-0.010072694160044193,
-0.2990592420101166,
-0.450175404548645,
0.29219409823417664,
-0.5774495005607605,
-0.31542637944221497,
0.017084380611777306,
0.4444543421268463,
-0.0306631438434124,
-0.20904578268527985,
-0.07579964399337769,
-0.02473488822579384,
-0.006130849942564964,
0.3061608672142029,
-0.5381016731262207,
0.5529031157493591,
0.7367715835571289,
0.8639730215072632,
-0.08208738267421722,
-0.5040955543518066,
-0.5343473553657532,
0.039158400148153305,
-0.8889700770378113,
0.36862972378730774,
-0.5384606122970581,
-0.2912682890892029,
-0.3013745844364166,
-0.05819883197546005,
0.030833635479211807,
-0.2451113611459732,
0.41730839014053345,
-0.6270477771759033,
-0.28988251090049744,
-0.5755252838134766,
-0.678353488445282,
-0.01482884120196104,
0.1728995442390442,
-0.5921863913536072,
0.9472571611404419,
0.05286456272006035,
-0.8452819585800171,
0.37667983770370483,
-0.1252751648426056,
0.18318140506744385,
-0.42235663533210754,
-0.20851637423038483,
-0.4063628315925598,
0.5567772388458252,
-0.1491917371749878,
0.08837369829416275,
-0.5326260328292847,
0.16322438418865204,
-0.8581696152687073,
-0.532118022441864,
0.8059113025665283,
-0.9823147058486938,
0.6927130222320557,
0.10424736887216568,
-0.38633838295936584,
-0.46595630049705505,
-0.6109388470649719,
0.15885458886623383,
0.05386849865317345,
-0.11930670589208603,
-0.42289745807647705,
-0.11585262417793274,
-0.31348279118537903,
0.20156431198120117,
0.3004399240016937,
-0.8454614877700806,
0.06448390334844589,
-0.3193664252758026,
0.19791148602962494,
0.8057844042778015,
0.11310529708862305,
0.39023372530937195,
-0.5153865218162537,
0.39310306310653687,
0.1595102846622467,
0.3382219672203064,
0.3685358464717865,
-0.5965855717658997,
-0.6968640089035034,
-0.03853283450007439,
0.24438682198524475,
-0.22416138648986816,
-0.15262643992900848,
0.2182263880968094,
-0.26605743169784546,
-0.672292172908783,
-0.49120867252349854,
0.3464765250682831,
0.7862250804901123,
0.24154643714427948,
0.14225924015045166,
-0.6320235729217529,
-0.3566502332687378,
-0.8905311822891235,
-0.7750586867332458,
-0.3532724678516388,
0.126444473862648,
0.05975673720240593,
0.5301617383956909,
-0.277675598859787,
0.9994713664054871,
-0.3896256387233734,
-0.005345448851585388,
0.12702304124832153,
0.33299607038497925,
0.182342991232872,
0.42359909415245056,
0.3392268419265747,
-0.5554680228233337,
-0.3480129539966583,
0.04328164830803871,
-0.5725011825561523,
0.28050774335861206,
0.1521802544593811,
-0.23569664359092712,
0.2714987099170685,
0.3130444586277008,
-0.3402911424636841,
0.6752941608428955,
0.8877698183059692,
-0.49297627806663513,
0.6777491569519043,
-0.47246161103248596,
0.1279279589653015,
-0.9590297937393188,
-0.05037660524249077,
-0.23789608478546143,
-0.20974701642990112,
-0.5227465033531189,
0.27954256534576416,
0.3257037401199341,
0.4986720383167267,
-0.33600154519081116,
0.20058861374855042,
-0.5335729122161865,
-0.33651724457740784,
-0.29971176385879517,
0.23670850694179535,
0.11719959229230881,
0.31088241934776306,
-0.4814721643924713,
1.0468385219573975,
0.20604893565177917,
-0.6166958212852478,
0.010678928345441818,
0.03819587454199791,
0.0426931269466877,
0.28607848286628723,
-0.36437031626701355,
0.5779061317443848,
0.1606617420911789,
0.266828715801239,
-1.0207065343856812,
-0.036798518151044846,
-0.39572134613990784,
-0.5003427267074585,
-0.08950122445821762,
-0.24246281385421753,
-0.5953922271728516,
-0.24885357916355133,
-0.47655221819877625,
0.6433960795402527,
0.554663896560669,
-0.7087036967277527,
0.6552563309669495,
0.1656452864408493,
0.4724023938179016,
-0.7494174838066101,
-0.8831695914268494,
-0.197223961353302,
0.02652628906071186,
-0.4061853885650635,
0.11928217858076096,
-0.024571433663368225,
-0.5664515495300293,
0.030075881630182266,
-0.506041944026947,
-0.2214420735836029,
-0.178123340010643,
0.371600866317749,
0.5257911682128906,
-0.3135325014591217,
0.1054096445441246,
-0.05753950774669647,
0.31576982140541077,
0.5253271460533142,
-0.24054023623466492,
0.5587347149848938,
-0.67990642786026,
-0.3663817346096039,
-0.05219045653939247,
-0.08609640598297119,
0.966844916343689,
0.04569106549024582,
0.9694582223892212,
0.053211428225040436,
-0.2098672240972519,
-0.07743915915489197,
-0.6549881100654602,
0.08886624872684479,
-0.5310845971107483,
-0.00873871985822916,
-0.3474123775959015,
-0.5168848037719727,
0.8451231122016907,
0.027855422347784042,
-0.034623559564352036,
0.5750125646591187,
0.3079967796802521,
-0.08186850696802139,
1.1742594242095947,
0.6627224683761597,
0.02743154764175415,
-0.01341159176081419,
-0.10817509144544601,
0.4073237180709839,
-1.2701915502548218,
0.023755991831421852,
-0.4410228133201599,
-0.18951183557510376,
-1.0681416988372803,
-0.44204890727996826,
0.1758938431739807,
0.2913627028465271,
-0.6752745509147644,
0.34707915782928467,
-0.2341102659702301,
0.6792528629302979,
0.2879634201526642,
0.31471771001815796,
0.5787711143493652,
-0.276902437210083,
-0.223841592669487,
0.10880030691623688,
-0.48875799775123596,
-0.7852745056152344,
1.413293719291687,
0.45424431562423706,
1.0375081300735474,
0.2009330838918686,
0.5823706984519958,
0.18685519695281982,
0.3814238905906677,
-0.4947042465209961,
0.35088056325912476,
-0.3937720060348511,
-0.7852166891098022,
-0.31000107526779175,
-0.5296538472175598,
-0.7026858329772949,
0.022528544068336487,
0.06086169183254242,
-0.793924868106842,
0.38781166076660156,
0.3443911373615265,
-0.13407132029533386,
0.798619270324707,
-0.4288138449192047,
0.28924089670181274,
-0.13714733719825745,
-0.6366727948188782,
-0.2574051320552826,
-0.5181832313537598,
0.5145787000656128,
-0.31264522671699524,
0.06415959447622299,
0.143425852060318,
-0.23401525616645813,
0.8522555232048035,
-0.5024299025535583,
0.74778813123703,
0.3393247723579407,
-0.3925626277923584,
0.2901856303215027,
0.768077552318573,
0.6857114434242249,
0.23047883808612823,
0.023387860506772995,
0.17707420885562897,
0.10660625249147415,
-0.6117449998855591,
-0.8456517457962036,
0.9591531157493591,
-0.855409562587738,
-0.7626875638961792,
-0.501352846622467,
-0.5553016662597656,
-0.5671513080596924,
0.14239336550235748,
0.2660098075866699,
0.41255465149879456,
-0.33581972122192383,
0.20144051313400269,
0.9973171949386597,
0.18761448562145233,
0.39011603593826294,
0.3518564999103546,
-0.5064306259155273,
-0.26512181758880615,
0.5320371389389038,
0.10114935785531998,
1.115783929824829,
0.10109911859035492,
0.21171139180660248,
-0.150726780295372,
-0.14277321100234985,
-0.4569628834724426,
0.3220575749874115,
-0.7561091780662537,
-0.15731294453144073,
-0.4917210340499878,
-0.4793066084384918,
0.051356736570596695,
-0.219717338681221,
-1.0106205940246582,
-0.2832615077495575,
-0.031018201261758804,
-0.059040721505880356,
0.27654558420181274,
1.262087106704712,
0.3272674083709717,
-0.08940212428569794,
-0.5851259827613831,
0.03722656890749931,
0.44878366589546204,
0.5399309396743774,
0.2631154954433441,
-0.8076252341270447,
-0.007890952751040459,
0.5758315324783325,
-0.48365864157676697,
-0.6847227215766907,
-0.0650261789560318,
-0.1390402913093567,
0.1972443163394928,
0.7119928598403931,
0.1901472955942154,
0.8609602451324463,
-0.12539635598659515,
0.8506419062614441,
0.3102613687515259,
-1.2407325506210327,
0.32392433285713196,
-0.17376726865768433,
0.2204165756702423,
0.6351149082183838,
0.31476259231567383,
-0.1827191263437271,
-0.9418103694915771,
-1.0036319494247437,
-0.42369717359542847,
0.4290700852870941,
0.3135569989681244,
0.27844691276550293,
0.023441774770617485,
0.5356549024581909,
0.28931158781051636,
0.10767217725515366,
-0.776389479637146,
-0.3468734323978424,
0.028493216261267662,
0.03405879810452461,
-0.14334821701049805,
-0.3061993718147278,
-0.16777554154396057,
-0.24743446707725525,
0.510995090007782,
-0.12499057501554489,
0.2969570755958557,
0.5368354320526123,
0.034280870109796524,
-0.6617398858070374,
0.18789392709732056,
0.6610715985298157,
1.0726536512374878,
-0.22995556890964508,
0.6437284350395203,
0.43725869059562683,
-0.8157822489738464,
0.34349724650382996,
-0.8614739775657654,
0.184806689620018,
-0.06820327043533325,
0.46564140915870667,
0.41108494997024536,
0.11502370238304138,
-0.47294074296951294,
0.6134942173957825,
-0.05615933611989021,
-0.18840713798999786,
-0.35232287645339966,
0.14868870377540588,
0.020373890176415443,
0.020063791424036026,
0.15058256685733795,
0.47394463419914246,
-0.12567168474197388,
-1.107117772102356,
0.1274666041135788,
0.5509113669395447,
-0.6721190810203552,
-0.3538241982460022,
0.49386709928512573,
-0.23165297508239746,
-0.37730029225349426,
0.749975860118866,
-0.09019293636083603,
-0.6128334999084473,
0.6182457804679871,
0.6640766263008118,
0.8755301237106323,
-0.08956773579120636,
0.1584354043006897,
0.05217248946428299,
0.5782470107078552,
-0.33662351965904236,
0.0030984533950686455,
0.19412776827812195,
-0.7344300746917725,
-0.14007830619812012,
-0.4772672951221466,
-0.4025774896144867,
0.15292061865329742,
-1.0625715255737305,
-0.0386856347322464,
-0.6208083033561707,
-0.26005202531814575,
-0.31155773997306824,
0.052013397216796875,
-0.5924784541130066,
0.25676122307777405,
-0.12670400738716125,
0.8765140771865845,
-0.6459689736366272,
0.9190859198570251,
0.31043127179145813,
-0.4752022624015808,
-0.986213743686676,
0.5835678577423096,
-0.16447243094444275,
-0.9115051627159119,
0.3327232599258423,
-0.06163348630070686,
-0.6775891184806824,
-0.27186450362205505,
-0.5825802087783813,
-1.0779589414596558,
1.0345563888549805,
0.6070842742919922,
-0.7559810876846313,
-0.0774848610162735,
0.31153905391693115,
0.8161684274673462,
-0.5914278626441956,
0.23512031137943268,
0.5750913619995117,
0.1108819916844368,
-0.0020840060897171497,
-1.1522985696792603,
0.3607373535633087,
0.10551684349775314,
0.272348016500473,
0.5045955777168274,
-0.8540595769882202,
1.0740633010864258,
-0.3563232421875,
-0.028486307710409164,
0.07636471837759018,
0.4332793056964874,
0.25899794697761536,
0.30354511737823486,
0.4761728346347809,
0.5312715768814087,
0.6242964863777161,
0.2117416262626648,
0.9757606983184814,
-0.188415065407753,
0.4739287793636322,
1.2786431312561035,
-0.2399500012397766,
0.9484805464744568,
0.8554248213768005,
-0.23576942086219788,
0.6697507500648499,
0.2917203903198242,
0.13480326533317566,
0.34022876620292664,
0.16604530811309814,
-0.061922475695610046,
-0.1380021572113037,
0.1106664314866066,
-0.14420218765735626,
0.32544517517089844,
0.10951903462409973,
-0.7932794094085693,
0.03755476325750351,
-0.4253537058830261,
0.19980032742023468,
0.22178517282009125,
-0.43091219663619995,
0.7286744713783264,
0.33033424615859985,
-0.6807125806808472,
0.6678246855735779,
-0.3364235460758209,
0.29706600308418274,
-0.3355855643749237,
0.12466495484113693,
-0.26263388991355896,
0.4212491810321808,
-0.15596729516983032,
-0.9452824592590332,
0.2434687614440918,
0.13714607059955597,
-0.19332218170166016,
0.0878312960267067,
0.2752475440502167,
-0.07872910052537918,
-0.49961984157562256,
0.6300522685050964,
0.5200868844985962,
0.06231207028031349,
-0.058277055621147156,
-0.3261677920818329,
0.15854130685329437,
-0.12255192548036575,
-0.2239099144935608,
0.4076940417289734,
0.4936348795890808,
-0.04642822965979576,
0.7419120073318481,
0.4981236159801483,
0.2645565867424011,
0.2507273554801941,
-0.20143140852451324,
0.9868793487548828,
-0.5398421883583069,
-0.2556132674217224,
-1.124889850616455,
0.12114359438419342,
-0.16965700685977936,
-0.6138972043991089,
0.9088813662528992,
0.6234403252601624,
0.9699912667274475,
0.16730567812919617,
0.36187538504600525,
0.3026092052459717,
0.055695872753858566,
-0.33336174488067627,
0.6171833872795105,
-0.425688773393631,
0.45398685336112976,
-0.4817586839199066,
-1.167458176612854,
0.21655455231666565,
0.14081266522407532,
-0.23606714606285095,
0.1085980013012886,
1.1317347288131714,
0.6831395626068115,
-0.22893184423446655,
0.3048243820667267,
0.5697444081306458,
0.28223204612731934,
0.10107224434614182,
0.2839919924736023,
0.9020735025405884,
-0.5792143940925598,
0.36585888266563416,
-0.35992687940597534,
-0.26768267154693604,
0.015718284994363785,
-0.659173309803009,
-0.9255672693252563,
-0.5658671855926514,
-0.14979776740074158,
-0.5683021545410156,
0.11198320984840393,
0.7902536988258362,
0.40873610973358154,
-0.6403201222419739,
-0.33922243118286133,
-0.6929217576980591,
-0.09939146041870117,
-0.4246844947338104,
-0.18850035965442657,
0.09833217412233353,
-0.23563779890537262,
-0.2696841061115265,
0.0313691608607769,
0.18944641947746277,
0.06133029982447624,
-0.5513278841972351,
-0.18115004897117615,
-0.06710738688707352,
0.8423306941986084,
0.27097612619400024,
-0.2039022445678711,
-1.0170484781265259,
-0.5043812394142151,
-0.08075115829706192,
-0.2364998757839203,
0.009754792787134647,
0.9738976359367371,
-0.4472230076789856,
0.4426826536655426,
0.22458522021770477,
0.3656987249851227,
0.4323727488517761,
0.04706194996833801,
0.7919818162918091,
-0.5691387057304382,
-0.19542479515075684,
0.23888306319713593,
0.2660675048828125,
-0.05057208612561226,
-0.7688310742378235,
0.34398791193962097,
-0.016652939841151237,
-0.778636634349823,
-1.110497236251831,
0.38894349336624146,
-0.7565245032310486,
-0.24771742522716522,
0.8922948241233826,
-0.25346648693084717,
-0.46030178666114807,
-0.0718405693769455,
0.05065169557929039,
0.27843645215034485,
-0.2571263611316681,
0.9704868793487549,
0.9845722317695618,
-0.2422339767217636,
0.06748004257678986,
-0.3565502166748047,
0.45767539739608765,
0.49652358889579773,
-0.2595192790031433,
0.6156907677650452,
-0.04842504858970642,
0.22588028013706207,
0.43219509720802307,
0.3544638752937317,
-0.28184083104133606,
0.32212716341018677,
0.38715508580207825,
-0.40538889169692993,
0.1725664734840393,
-0.2661759555339813,
-0.13835904002189636,
0.009238304570317268,
0.4644273519515991,
-0.028650948777794838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14714v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14714v1
|
Efficient and Effective Vocabulary Expansion Towards Multilingual Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T17:12:39 | 2024-02-22T17:12:39 |
Seungduk Kim, Seungtaek Choi, Myeongho Jeong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This report introduces \texttt{EEVE-Korean-v1.0}, a Korean adaptation of
large language models that exhibit remarkable capabilities across English and
Korean text understanding. Building on recent highly capable but
English-centric LLMs, such as SOLAR-10.7B and Phi-2, where non-English texts
are inefficiently processed with English-centric tokenizers, we present an
efficient and effective vocabulary expansion (EEVE) method, which encompasses
parameter freezing and subword initialization. In contrast to previous efforts
that believe new embeddings require trillions of training tokens, we show that
our method can significantly boost non-English proficiency within just 2
billion tokens. Surpassing most instruction-tuned LLMs on the Open Ko-LLM
Leaderboard, as of January 2024, our model \texttt{EEVE-Korean-10.8B-v1.0}
ranks as the leading Korean pre-trained model in the open-source community,
according to Hugging Face's leaderboard. We open-source our models on
Huggingface to empower the open research community in various languages.
|
[
-0.22235749661922455,
-0.8055091500282288,
0.2807685136795044,
0.4229895770549774,
-0.2978014051914215,
0.28267598152160645,
-0.5714443922042847,
-0.5397472977638245,
0.349404901266098,
0.3215549886226654,
-0.15798437595367432,
-0.734981119632721,
-0.7101876735687256,
-0.008995425887405872,
-0.017693713307380676,
0.5881707072257996,
-0.05169917643070221,
0.33240368962287903,
-0.1998811960220337,
-0.186813086271286,
-0.28941741585731506,
-0.502168595790863,
-0.5150503516197205,
-0.42326900362968445,
0.6477975249290466,
0.45606082677841187,
0.44983339309692383,
0.5038318037986755,
0.29164808988571167,
0.37118077278137207,
-0.19982028007507324,
0.22407762706279755,
-0.6742075085639954,
0.16206234693527222,
-0.15618139505386353,
-0.36964547634124756,
-0.8901365399360657,
-0.002642231062054634,
0.5770676732063293,
0.7782166600227356,
-0.17839734256267548,
0.06404180824756622,
-0.04939492419362068,
0.4650430381298065,
-0.3389868140220642,
0.11893738061189651,
-0.6748151183128357,
-0.11847745627164841,
-0.14213739335536957,
-0.07632370293140411,
-0.5044248700141907,
-0.038433223962783813,
0.32121047377586365,
-0.9586946368217468,
-0.2760475277900696,
-0.10800290107727051,
0.783133327960968,
-0.028175346553325653,
-0.4161994457244873,
-0.28985390067100525,
-0.4780830442905426,
0.990813672542572,
-0.43501168489456177,
0.8672524690628052,
0.17981603741645813,
0.0038350478280335665,
-0.18181391060352325,
-0.9308584332466125,
-0.15896998345851898,
-0.4327640235424042,
0.29941490292549133,
0.29113543033599854,
-0.015415715985000134,
0.3893640339374542,
-0.16341593861579895,
0.3275681734085083,
-0.43616169691085815,
0.5135458707809448,
-0.36885344982147217,
-0.15810631215572357,
0.5688358545303345,
-0.1482888162136078,
0.3813433349132538,
-0.08046114444732666,
-0.454360693693161,
-0.07476556301116943,
-0.4681507647037506,
-0.23531801998615265,
0.20848116278648376,
0.5590186715126038,
-0.2548321485519409,
0.833053469657898,
-0.17967593669891357,
0.56718909740448,
-0.04297312721610069,
-0.26799890398979187,
0.4050194025039673,
-0.30636516213417053,
-0.18773190677165985,
-0.02220700867474079,
0.23142242431640625,
0.3739272654056549,
0.2634254992008209,
-0.406308650970459,
-0.049809250980615616,
-0.08020511269569397,
-0.024529309943318367,
-0.8592204451560974,
-0.22889679670333862,
0.3855023682117462,
-0.5895897150039673,
-0.0917072519659996,
-0.023254627361893654,
-0.8450661897659302,
-0.46746155619621277,
-0.2251606285572052,
0.47132444381713867,
-0.46653124690055847,
-0.6882489919662476,
0.3707287907600403,
0.03302401676774025,
0.34664973616600037,
0.39572128653526306,
-0.37275296449661255,
0.20789480209350586,
0.7172967195510864,
0.8648205995559692,
-0.10622861236333847,
-0.46732211112976074,
-0.47017255425453186,
-0.15957531332969666,
-0.4050874710083008,
0.5100966691970825,
-0.4784669280052185,
-0.2981052100658417,
0.0274583138525486,
0.07185667753219604,
-0.06550897657871246,
-0.4079294204711914,
0.31294599175453186,
-0.5949605107307434,
0.2535229027271271,
0.09476323425769806,
-0.9394443035125732,
-0.15536274015903473,
0.2254844754934311,
-0.4279283881187439,
1.1448438167572021,
0.24336262047290802,
-0.38833746314048767,
0.21741104125976562,
-0.8426124453544617,
-0.20463518798351288,
0.346312016248703,
0.1943325251340866,
0.025758709758520126,
0.3542444407939911,
0.20437756180763245,
0.5966647863388062,
-0.2906942665576935,
-0.13933856785297394,
-0.12325730919837952,
0.03066714107990265,
-0.1312185376882553,
0.007471983786672354,
0.6111990213394165,
0.27956855297088623,
0.12747454643249512,
0.12953509390354156,
-0.697085976600647,
0.3463480770587921,
0.30582481622695923,
-0.3127421736717224,
-0.8030704855918884,
-0.39163076877593994,
0.07950679212808609,
0.10868483036756516,
0.5198466777801514,
-0.6211982369422913,
0.2654893398284912,
-0.624734103679657,
0.18020252883434296,
0.6250579357147217,
-0.30344119668006897,
0.8699668645858765,
0.13070259988307953,
0.8691105842590332,
-0.029546208679676056,
-0.11754701286554337,
-0.6952387690544128,
-0.4815029203891754,
-0.5575437545776367,
-0.7089458703994751,
0.7497140765190125,
0.6174840331077576,
-0.931053638458252,
0.3168419897556305,
-0.44705459475517273,
-0.7839243412017822,
-0.601574182510376,
0.16210314631462097,
0.5037465691566467,
0.3783411979675293,
0.3375670313835144,
0.09506770968437195,
-0.41925185918807983,
-0.6813270449638367,
-0.3365801274776459,
-0.13606826961040497,
-0.13180643320083618,
0.3087398111820221,
0.4031946659088135,
0.08385975658893585,
0.4471874535083771,
-0.38036251068115234,
-0.0007122840615920722,
-0.4363163113594055,
-0.058879002928733826,
0.05024829879403114,
0.3360733389854431,
0.4280199110507965,
-0.7129554152488708,
-0.8193877935409546,
0.32062995433807373,
-0.5887181162834167,
-0.11547579616308212,
0.0008211040403693914,
-0.14398398995399475,
0.22144758701324463,
0.8107033967971802,
-0.5507868528366089,
0.11239030212163925,
0.7879454493522644,
-0.6749668717384338,
0.31048476696014404,
-0.2682790458202362,
-0.018729137256741524,
-1.4593309164047241,
-0.07694804668426514,
0.08916699141263962,
-0.3642817735671997,
-0.9155775904655457,
0.5316444635391235,
0.2677350640296936,
0.11924589425325394,
-0.6581856608390808,
1.1353864669799805,
-0.6973716020584106,
0.21468958258628845,
-0.2784190773963928,
0.5490994453430176,
-0.24412494897842407,
0.1820104420185089,
-0.046667132526636124,
0.6344703435897827,
0.5904977917671204,
-0.6979185938835144,
0.3684333860874176,
0.18658696115016937,
-0.31397292017936707,
0.4947890341281891,
-0.5603979229927063,
0.12356787174940109,
-0.2616799473762512,
0.049176741391420364,
-0.8123681545257568,
-0.19675244390964508,
0.01736646331846714,
-0.5742517113685608,
0.473929226398468,
-0.26461029052734375,
-0.2761181890964508,
-0.33306580781936646,
-0.23291295766830444,
0.09327753633260727,
0.5651612281799316,
-0.8929060101509094,
0.8686785101890564,
0.49769964814186096,
-0.26746562123298645,
-0.5037739276885986,
-0.4256385266780853,
0.24074330925941467,
-0.28052228689193726,
-0.631632387638092,
0.4919409453868866,
-0.024469692260026932,
-0.3749697208404541,
0.10216573625802994,
-0.014013967476785183,
0.022667471319437027,
0.07991991937160492,
-0.2331123650074005,
0.3515564501285553,
-0.26670563220977783,
0.293567419052124,
-0.011855476535856724,
0.0010135476477444172,
-0.23244939744472504,
-0.6133988499641418,
0.7531520128250122,
-0.09164818376302719,
0.03991152346134186,
0.00947901513427496,
0.17889662086963654,
0.6958160400390625,
-0.07043034583330154,
0.915195882320404,
0.5300832986831665,
-0.5693750381469727,
-0.31944140791893005,
-0.46023088693618774,
-0.05487532541155815,
-0.505456805229187,
1.1416391134262085,
-0.7204031944274902,
-1.0552865266799927,
0.6388630270957947,
-0.4523373544216156,
0.09578164666891098,
0.31037044525146484,
0.6237059235572815,
0.07583623379468918,
0.8604711294174194,
0.866523802280426,
0.016918856650590897,
0.4275309443473816,
0.02178444340825081,
0.12181077897548676,
-0.8762202262878418,
-0.3393040597438812,
-0.33659303188323975,
-0.1872255802154541,
-0.7511523365974426,
-0.7513841986656189,
0.10696727782487869,
0.41261500120162964,
0.08591416478157043,
0.34870144724845886,
-0.29715055227279663,
0.6421384215354919,
0.23227450251579285,
-0.027729714289307594,
0.02335873432457447,
0.06361865252256393,
-0.33571717143058777,
-0.25730907917022705,
-0.8438271880149841,
-0.16619139909744263,
1.2814511060714722,
0.6605089902877808,
0.7114683985710144,
-0.01096700131893158,
0.6603419184684753,
-0.1458733081817627,
0.2789571285247803,
-1.026163935661316,
0.5319583415985107,
-0.37035009264945984,
-0.23193468153476715,
-0.4562053084373474,
-0.3887051045894623,
-0.910327136516571,
0.3183201253414154,
0.003664489835500717,
-0.6756929159164429,
-0.13171818852424622,
0.036523714661598206,
-0.06082109361886978,
0.41893792152404785,
-0.8289997577667236,
0.5978865623474121,
-0.2622373402118683,
-0.2759956121444702,
-0.19551603496074677,
-0.2965714633464813,
0.22153687477111816,
-0.2973429560661316,
0.05461405962705612,
-0.06469126045703888,
-0.5411346554756165,
0.6506010293960571,
-0.24271905422210693,
0.5816049575805664,
-0.5511879920959473,
-0.35016748309135437,
0.11794698983430862,
-0.11615840345621109,
0.6644273996353149,
-0.04697514325380325,
-0.01367838867008686,
0.4341048002243042,
-0.2720964252948761,
-0.6436763405799866,
-0.49367430806159973,
0.7192079424858093,
-0.6337147951126099,
-0.3561249375343323,
-0.17120243608951569,
-0.5651032328605652,
-0.2756374776363373,
0.22273693978786469,
0.19756671786308289,
0.07843953371047974,
-0.2962286174297333,
0.3147282302379608,
0.8415695428848267,
-0.608388364315033,
0.1616448163986206,
0.5816394686698914,
-0.7351542711257935,
-0.6957829594612122,
0.9196966290473938,
0.33407357335090637,
0.4242114722728729,
0.2839571535587311,
0.2561130225658417,
-0.38133546710014343,
-0.42039626836776733,
-0.3662351369857788,
0.39053472876548767,
-0.5807276368141174,
-0.2117195725440979,
-0.743996798992157,
-0.24934177100658417,
-0.3874380886554718,
-0.23290006816387177,
-0.8383480310440063,
-0.6226940155029297,
-0.03932926803827286,
-0.19681018590927124,
0.5343925952911377,
0.6294728517532349,
-0.02896220050752163,
0.3136937618255615,
-0.7168912291526794,
0.11750350892543793,
0.030555805191397667,
0.5469512343406677,
-0.041670624166727066,
-0.7674114108085632,
-0.5272866487503052,
-0.16758278012275696,
0.20685409009456635,
-0.6592970490455627,
0.42656734585762024,
0.33664679527282715,
0.6238462924957275,
0.19328808784484863,
-0.17434996366500854,
0.800471305847168,
-0.5900943279266357,
0.8894119262695312,
0.2830435037612915,
-0.8621754050254822,
0.1962147355079651,
-0.3971572518348694,
0.4767570197582245,
0.22751082479953766,
0.37078550457954407,
-0.6788725852966309,
-0.24759019911289215,
-0.3732565641403198,
-1.0896427631378174,
0.5608606338500977,
-0.12962022423744202,
0.5591445565223694,
-0.0861118733882904,
0.6166423559188843,
0.16208191215991974,
0.11548661440610886,
-0.5144321918487549,
-0.4345605969429016,
-0.20228469371795654,
-0.20765766501426697,
-0.13702484965324402,
-0.35855406522750854,
0.2784119248390198,
-0.41916748881340027,
0.8155333995819092,
-0.22137203812599182,
0.3688197731971741,
0.10827203840017319,
-0.18825165927410126,
0.10997162014245987,
0.13992154598236084,
0.5817945003509521,
0.4305579960346222,
0.09091406315565109,
-0.008264259435236454,
0.3642750084400177,
-0.7286266684532166,
-0.007801687344908714,
0.20088502764701843,
0.0637650117278099,
-0.07626606523990631,
0.20247507095336914,
0.5256780385971069,
0.1988300085067749,
-0.5889427661895752,
0.32264456152915955,
0.03509745001792908,
-0.42900604009628296,
-0.1572626382112503,
-0.4539225697517395,
0.28682878613471985,
0.2647304832935333,
0.20733775198459625,
-0.41042086482048035,
-0.3019261956214905,
-0.2080763280391693,
0.13747809827327728,
0.4062325954437256,
-0.17484083771705627,
-0.46136796474456787,
0.6029571294784546,
0.4361134171485901,
-0.14864562451839447,
0.47628945112228394,
-0.4058407247066498,
-0.7419643998146057,
0.5363389253616333,
0.7804051041603088,
0.9286708831787109,
-0.58000648021698,
0.23264822363853455,
0.5647520422935486,
0.5114412903785706,
-0.11807772517204285,
0.603640615940094,
0.447625994682312,
-0.8703882098197937,
-0.8018991351127625,
-0.5887569189071655,
-0.15186554193496704,
0.3576652705669403,
-0.4390939474105835,
0.42668548226356506,
-0.21246987581253052,
0.03193360194563866,
-0.23793134093284607,
0.10912787169218063,
-0.6427645683288574,
0.0026338319294154644,
0.29292550683021545,
1.3907910585403442,
-0.7325767278671265,
0.946372389793396,
1.0287214517593384,
-0.018064722418785095,
-0.6522325277328491,
-0.10989595949649811,
-0.21026447415351868,
-0.8768724799156189,
0.5313617587089539,
-0.011166030541062355,
0.04129606485366821,
0.24979770183563232,
-0.46820852160453796,
-1.167374610900879,
1.0406150817871094,
0.24185703694820404,
-0.5408582091331482,
0.020985973998904228,
-0.03845854476094246,
0.5800701379776001,
-0.44628825783729553,
-0.002943312283605337,
0.28650665283203125,
0.5496217012405396,
-0.1728820651769638,
-1.0181703567504883,
-0.2110261768102646,
-0.31330880522727966,
0.10860126465559006,
0.3181721568107605,
-0.7533547282218933,
0.826580286026001,
-0.05251600220799446,
-0.026087261736392975,
0.3370991051197052,
0.9410371780395508,
0.0002095174859277904,
0.1945997029542923,
0.5529572367668152,
0.6270699501037598,
1.1326074600219727,
0.06377516686916351,
0.9225843548774719,
-0.5910646915435791,
0.16314572095870972,
1.2951817512512207,
-0.32721707224845886,
0.765673816204071,
0.5121124982833862,
0.018567955121397972,
0.2393721640110016,
0.5823426842689514,
0.07023561000823975,
0.5328596234321594,
0.21908533573150635,
-0.19961166381835938,
-0.29506638646125793,
-0.2986033856868744,
-0.24634747207164764,
0.6545713543891907,
0.559316098690033,
-0.16731718182563782,
-0.029890548437833786,
0.3794243335723877,
0.3341759443283081,
0.15828239917755127,
-0.6341564655303955,
0.610935628414154,
0.05982904136180878,
-0.4293683171272278,
0.3025149703025818,
0.27652573585510254,
0.8815896511077881,
-0.6085383296012878,
0.042139146476984024,
-0.16332733631134033,
0.06411153078079224,
-0.021751683205366135,
-0.40909644961357117,
-0.14949865639209747,
0.0492248572409153,
0.14299573004245758,
-0.0635235384106636,
0.9139763712882996,
-0.7440272569656372,
-0.5440016388893127,
0.6268972158432007,
0.8775991797447205,
0.09837425500154495,
0.17156530916690826,
-0.7132797241210938,
-0.055590540170669556,
-0.10347045958042145,
-0.5811938047409058,
0.3413298726081848,
0.4483160376548767,
-0.11861744523048401,
0.48552924394607544,
0.38586756587028503,
0.3731313645839691,
0.30636006593704224,
0.06286817044019699,
0.7654052972793579,
-0.33387264609336853,
-0.3493339419364929,
-0.5806539058685303,
0.5728518962860107,
-0.2358485609292984,
-0.3073282837867737,
0.9747823476791382,
0.606613278388977,
1.1353070735931396,
0.04616342484951019,
0.7957736849784851,
-0.06587757915258408,
0.532126247882843,
-0.5952587127685547,
0.5853891372680664,
-0.7397741675376892,
0.16015978157520294,
-0.17022326588630676,
-1.0245438814163208,
-0.3246361315250397,
0.42588692903518677,
-0.11922692507505417,
0.19047683477401733,
0.6538845896720886,
0.7189521193504333,
-0.01647326722741127,
-0.2521224617958069,
0.5942522287368774,
0.5368428826332092,
0.121048703789711,
0.05163468047976494,
0.6226373314857483,
-0.4342794120311737,
0.39180824160575867,
-0.24901165068149567,
-0.37909597158432007,
0.03888803720474243,
-0.9153189063072205,
-0.9751156568527222,
-0.4558582901954651,
-0.4588875472545624,
-0.4804519712924957,
-0.028583316132426262,
1.386346459388733,
0.6944292187690735,
-0.5961379408836365,
-0.09527552127838135,
0.009931487962603569,
-0.011934274807572365,
-0.05415799096226692,
-0.20907163619995117,
0.33894017338752747,
-0.4167216420173645,
-1.0455501079559326,
0.7620745897293091,
0.3317471444606781,
-0.053063131868839264,
-0.3337041735649109,
-0.4353410303592682,
-0.11211454123258591,
0.4108825623989105,
0.8714480400085449,
0.256571501493454,
-0.6509082317352295,
-0.14634057879447937,
0.44666072726249695,
-0.003768997499719262,
-0.08090154826641083,
0.5171941518783569,
-0.6141111254692078,
0.719628095626831,
0.3805333375930786,
0.7309241890907288,
0.26434433460235596,
-0.1727256178855896,
0.5620664358139038,
-0.8298077583312988,
0.3338760733604431,
-0.0022484806831926107,
0.17249029874801636,
0.23958797752857208,
-0.2959499657154083,
0.6677907109260559,
0.041171129792928696,
-0.4635164141654968,
-0.9328733086585999,
0.10547138750553131,
-0.6389786601066589,
-0.438730925321579,
1.2309719324111938,
-0.2509111762046814,
-0.24300774931907654,
0.049817442893981934,
0.021796585991978645,
0.12314578890800476,
-0.25525176525115967,
0.5606260299682617,
0.8316250443458557,
0.055745985358953476,
-0.09756729751825333,
-0.6137716174125671,
0.29128289222717285,
0.3804241418838501,
-0.7315964698791504,
0.14184355735778809,
0.2135457545518875,
0.1721152663230896,
0.04431549832224846,
0.5232353806495667,
-0.27405405044555664,
0.16901713609695435,
0.11947842687368393,
0.21074265241622925,
-0.17292377352714539,
-0.489874929189682,
-0.6080961227416992,
-0.022719211876392365,
0.11982236802577972,
-0.18156929314136505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14710v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14710v3
|
IEPile: Unearthing Large-Scale Schema-Based Information Extraction Corpus
| 2024-02-22T17:11:38 | 2024-05-26T15:54:41 |
Honghao Gui, Lin Yuan, Hongbin Ye, Ningyu Zhang, Mengshu Sun, Lei Liang, Huajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable potential across various
domains; however, they exhibit a significant performance gap in Information
Extraction (IE). Note that high-quality instruction data is the vital key for
enhancing the specific capabilities of LLMs, while current IE datasets tend to
be small in scale, fragmented, and lack standardized schema. To this end, we
introduce IEPile, a comprehensive bilingual (English and Chinese) IE
instruction corpus, which contains approximately 0.32B tokens. We construct
IEPile by collecting and cleaning 33 existing IE datasets, and introduce
schema-based instruction generation to unearth a large-scale corpus.
Experimentally, IEPile enhance the performance of LLMs for IE, with notable
improvements in zero-shot generalization. We open-source the resource and
pre-trained models, hoping to provide valuable support to the NLP community.
|
[
-0.08964050561189651,
-0.592872142791748,
0.1584244668483734,
0.2302045375108719,
0.1529964655637741,
0.05126960948109627,
-0.5461151003837585,
-0.46611741185188293,
0.19015716016292572,
0.7483352422714233,
-0.16985169053077698,
-0.7717146277427673,
-0.7414334416389465,
-0.03980153426527977,
-0.6136194467544556,
0.7450206279754639,
0.1824103146791458,
0.024150554090738297,
-0.07314356416463852,
0.15794099867343903,
-0.2980000376701355,
-0.20435884594917297,
-0.4102475643157959,
0.1764734983444214,
0.2946038544178009,
0.7969232797622681,
0.24719493091106415,
1.1433994770050049,
0.2729513943195343,
0.2077225297689438,
0.22950264811515808,
0.3320484757423401,
-0.5221436619758606,
0.21549341082572937,
-0.251889705657959,
-0.5267882943153381,
-0.5101741552352905,
-0.0425754189491272,
0.7330431938171387,
0.683813750743866,
-0.5513858795166016,
0.42177462577819824,
0.13511808216571808,
0.13911539316177368,
-0.8642660975456238,
0.4802737534046173,
-0.6565213799476624,
-0.02832220494747162,
-0.6243308186531067,
-0.24405862390995026,
-0.8074642419815063,
-0.1987401694059372,
0.006533930543810129,
-0.739007294178009,
0.21748577058315277,
0.19124986231327057,
0.9777430891990662,
-0.007613964378833771,
-0.21423783898353577,
-0.3903166949748993,
-0.6327669024467468,
1.0491821765899658,
-0.7057443261146545,
0.5230321288108826,
0.41163891553878784,
-0.0002011707692872733,
0.015750272199511528,
-1.0921227931976318,
-0.35304418206214905,
0.012778700329363346,
0.17489516735076904,
0.10840480029582977,
-0.027528200298547745,
-0.0026390759740024805,
0.3126484453678131,
0.43783506751060486,
-0.6231228113174438,
0.5453026294708252,
-0.6395204067230225,
-0.14709800481796265,
0.3664107620716095,
0.23959459364414215,
0.610913097858429,
-0.340792179107666,
-0.2868882715702057,
0.006851459387689829,
-1.050547480583191,
-0.2262774258852005,
0.13533148169517517,
0.4778090715408325,
0.03748227283358574,
0.8073024749755859,
-0.03464031219482422,
0.6055869460105896,
-0.12953397631645203,
-0.3188096880912781,
0.07146784663200378,
0.06471271812915802,
-0.2525343894958496,
0.19895534217357635,
0.7287378311157227,
0.24638506770133972,
0.1214408203959465,
-0.27854734659194946,
0.01649087481200695,
-0.14735551178455353,
0.035662319511175156,
-0.9629518389701843,
-0.14227183163166046,
0.3273731768131256,
-0.4135124981403351,
0.006754209753125906,
0.24221596121788025,
-0.9082346558570862,
-0.09594227373600006,
-0.3117992877960205,
-0.14339029788970947,
-0.6033819913864136,
-0.11712512373924255,
0.24204088747501373,
-0.17416852712631226,
0.3750974237918854,
0.40926751494407654,
-1.0731143951416016,
0.04068112373352051,
0.8458002209663391,
0.6427227258682251,
-0.1966131180524826,
-0.47526538372039795,
-0.9371219277381897,
0.6188096404075623,
-0.2319963276386261,
0.7338280081748962,
-0.7414441108703613,
-0.315693199634552,
0.05529676005244255,
0.10434535890817642,
-0.003579351818189025,
-0.7176947593688965,
0.4773758053779602,
-0.4360479712486267,
0.37882861495018005,
0.004441946744918823,
-0.781318187713623,
0.21731199324131012,
0.08144943416118622,
-0.9044658541679382,
1.4107894897460938,
0.2800210416316986,
-0.7829625606536865,
0.19887623190879822,
-0.7265875935554504,
-0.40419918298721313,
0.2988499402999878,
-0.30175140500068665,
0.2860814332962036,
0.08798626065254211,
0.29306724667549133,
0.44177114963531494,
-0.713843584060669,
0.08530476689338684,
-0.042235419154167175,
-0.4286486804485321,
-0.5157657861709595,
-0.26632601022720337,
1.102247714996338,
0.41851094365119934,
-0.2585904002189636,
-0.3828490078449249,
-0.9066871404647827,
-0.03908553719520569,
0.1451299488544464,
-0.7101714015007019,
-0.31132256984710693,
0.031115548685193062,
-0.21964477002620697,
0.11710216104984283,
0.5835700631141663,
-0.6836547255516052,
0.4862659275531769,
-0.29816704988479614,
0.27300402522087097,
0.8718925714492798,
-0.33582136034965515,
0.4491516053676605,
0.209447979927063,
0.6328350901603699,
-0.108393594622612,
-0.05158567056059837,
-0.48248398303985596,
-0.19537219405174255,
-0.8777510523796082,
-0.47453343868255615,
0.6756519079208374,
0.8926225900650024,
-0.7865405678749084,
0.48339352011680603,
-0.5740491151809692,
-0.25483188033103943,
-0.5770743489265442,
0.31137433648109436,
0.14955471456050873,
0.4319191575050354,
0.313673734664917,
-0.13578356802463531,
-0.531300961971283,
-0.7109894752502441,
-0.08147448301315308,
-0.1383502334356308,
-0.469453901052475,
0.1097128614783287,
0.09702621400356293,
0.03340434655547142,
0.7289157509803772,
-0.5153571367263794,
-0.06309622526168823,
-0.4330735206604004,
0.2391667366027832,
0.05751072242856026,
0.221390500664711,
0.305431991815567,
-0.1559303104877472,
-0.4599325656890869,
0.04199204966425896,
-1.0488598346710205,
-0.34757864475250244,
0.06753922253847122,
-0.2976089417934418,
-0.007856694981455803,
0.8253516554832458,
-0.7166293859481812,
0.20567911863327026,
0.3135533332824707,
-0.05399460345506668,
0.44324037432670593,
-0.058571066707372665,
-0.1148591861128807,
-1.0677944421768188,
0.05044578015804291,
-0.11425172537565231,
0.050010230392217636,
-0.26429110765457153,
0.48312413692474365,
0.2275182008743286,
0.01695941388607025,
-0.7593380212783813,
0.516865074634552,
-0.7977583408355713,
-0.06474814563989639,
0.004341648891568184,
0.3515884578227997,
0.16155357658863068,
0.1133144348859787,
-0.055234044790267944,
0.7345910668373108,
0.44620880484580994,
-0.4323354661464691,
0.30001822113990784,
0.2752193212509155,
-0.3968282639980316,
0.4113665223121643,
-0.3440883457660675,
0.040229663252830505,
-0.05952167510986328,
0.048244524747133255,
-0.3501148819923401,
-0.4635688364505768,
-0.12493474781513214,
-0.06413888931274414,
0.827980101108551,
-0.027119198814034462,
-0.8384258151054382,
-0.18100027740001678,
-0.3175567388534546,
-0.08037112653255463,
0.4131568968296051,
-0.7374997735023499,
0.6162546277046204,
0.6233394145965576,
-0.4241645336151123,
-0.9686092734336853,
-0.6502683758735657,
0.2629071772098541,
-0.07577475160360336,
-0.5565471649169922,
0.29978713393211365,
0.18509317934513092,
-0.21699228882789612,
0.06527581810951233,
0.1684153527021408,
-0.07743125408887863,
-0.10726926475763321,
0.09224905073642731,
0.3581092357635498,
-0.4473462402820587,
0.22959725558757782,
0.1289343684911728,
-0.009053986519575119,
-0.015239848755300045,
-0.14732840657234192,
0.6952118873596191,
0.07439851015806198,
-0.39203470945358276,
-0.08974587172269821,
0.5124133825302124,
0.40578609704971313,
-0.5185496807098389,
0.704127311706543,
0.5083951354026794,
-0.3843163251876831,
-0.6073979139328003,
-0.4509202539920807,
-0.05718684941530228,
-0.4360247254371643,
0.46453577280044556,
-0.05404110997915268,
-0.9088349342346191,
0.18154889345169067,
-0.45054975152015686,
0.4258359670639038,
0.5717248320579529,
0.3775097727775574,
0.043726854026317596,
0.8135742545127869,
0.6475072503089905,
-0.25290676951408386,
0.3383403718471527,
-0.3975658714771271,
0.07502411305904388,
-0.8370274901390076,
-0.14414265751838684,
-0.6585173010826111,
-0.0528361052274704,
-0.1661432981491089,
-0.44842690229415894,
-0.07789431512355804,
0.2709987461566925,
-0.2899474799633026,
0.3577697277069092,
-0.5254459977149963,
0.7260102033615112,
0.6713181138038635,
-0.08327982574701309,
0.2144995480775833,
0.19623233377933502,
-0.18228940665721893,
-0.09763192385435104,
-0.8082504868507385,
-0.6960020065307617,
1.3969736099243164,
0.139584481716156,
0.5464450120925903,
-0.06995042413473129,
0.8744971752166748,
0.14906172454357147,
0.31280383467674255,
-0.5381359457969666,
0.6346122622489929,
-0.5167561173439026,
-0.5455889105796814,
-0.2648089528083801,
-0.27853837609291077,
-1.041560173034668,
-0.16980279982089996,
-0.042009517550468445,
-0.8468234539031982,
-0.1397966891527176,
-0.09594657272100449,
-0.22294798493385315,
0.3369441628456116,
-0.707497239112854,
0.8082971572875977,
-0.3442905843257904,
-0.5472093820571899,
0.00846140831708908,
-0.5912753343582153,
0.45838984847068787,
0.016135357320308685,
0.4048384130001068,
0.01787722297012806,
-0.03828000649809837,
0.5606979131698608,
-0.5002506375312805,
0.784978449344635,
-0.1538241058588028,
-0.16438767313957214,
0.4213765859603882,
0.10442762821912766,
0.5940619111061096,
-0.43018606305122375,
-0.28917407989501953,
0.3550633192062378,
-0.212213933467865,
-0.3961276710033417,
-0.44555869698524475,
0.7792935967445374,
-0.5414687991142273,
-0.4681617021560669,
-0.1359187811613083,
-0.4253629446029663,
0.08029288053512573,
0.2765797972679138,
0.4743482768535614,
0.36407044529914856,
-0.24684171378612518,
0.3779961168766022,
0.6092897057533264,
-0.5566227436065674,
0.4074976444244385,
0.45222023129463196,
-0.3088440001010895,
-0.00005424202390713617,
1.1409662961959839,
0.3829704523086548,
0.08645770698785782,
0.4139503836631775,
-0.07924246788024902,
0.015075553208589554,
-0.44186845421791077,
-0.5447460412979126,
0.14520439505577087,
-0.790704071521759,
-0.23653048276901245,
-0.5986270308494568,
-0.44254758954048157,
-0.30195748805999756,
-0.00036986448685638607,
-0.4278833270072937,
-0.6602325439453125,
-0.3905998766422272,
-0.31890690326690674,
0.15163668990135193,
0.7403627038002014,
-0.1379575878381729,
0.25026074051856995,
-1.1085072755813599,
0.21035532653331757,
0.001408060546964407,
0.08717718720436096,
-0.037933897227048874,
-0.3442784547805786,
-0.5370256304740906,
-0.14349578320980072,
-0.3611295223236084,
-0.7221205830574036,
0.48251572251319885,
0.39170408248901367,
0.616294801235199,
0.5483042597770691,
0.11090710014104843,
0.6690565943717957,
-0.654423713684082,
1.181265115737915,
-0.0723743662238121,
-0.8004419803619385,
0.4892556667327881,
-0.20116719603538513,
0.14647355675697327,
0.307163268327713,
0.3907487690448761,
-0.2354365438222885,
-0.5031017661094666,
-0.6253432631492615,
-1.2290143966674805,
0.9282430410385132,
-0.12065371870994568,
0.013410055078566074,
-0.5045706629753113,
0.08083881437778473,
0.18149742484092712,
0.08235425502061844,
-0.3859618008136749,
-0.10938268899917603,
0.009348987601697445,
-0.3275088667869568,
0.43606284260749817,
-0.22159986197948456,
-0.031610459089279175,
-0.13705655932426453,
0.4691791534423828,
0.06155741214752197,
0.2003791779279709,
-0.27915534377098083,
-0.419735848903656,
0.06996263563632965,
0.2136760950088501,
0.20457527041435242,
0.5931951403617859,
-0.08761095255613327,
0.12647336721420288,
0.20595042407512665,
-0.6132315397262573,
-0.316281259059906,
0.019426338374614716,
-0.046809520572423935,
-0.04908984526991844,
0.6246162056922913,
0.335088849067688,
0.29324671626091003,
-1.0348366498947144,
0.5960463285446167,
0.062018346041440964,
0.02682257443666458,
-0.30640995502471924,
0.1357346475124359,
0.3440452218055725,
0.016910625621676445,
0.34470489621162415,
-0.5013828873634338,
0.1270821988582611,
-0.48133260011672974,
0.3260166049003601,
0.19621984660625458,
0.07722102105617523,
-0.16741955280303955,
0.6971582770347595,
0.08251414448022842,
-0.13093428313732147,
1.0085214376449585,
-0.2173950970172882,
-0.26083898544311523,
0.5111109018325806,
0.6469593644142151,
0.5964843034744263,
-0.4235723614692688,
0.16159310936927795,
0.5088446736335754,
0.337706983089447,
-0.17491738498210907,
0.3302200436592102,
0.045391254127025604,
-0.5586959719657898,
-0.707729160785675,
-0.7308660745620728,
-0.32935816049575806,
0.2658385932445526,
-0.8284057378768921,
0.46972379088401794,
-0.3948349356651306,
0.24383389949798584,
-0.17047837376594543,
-0.3126058578491211,
-0.6990377306938171,
0.061463791877031326,
0.10405009239912033,
1.004804015159607,
-0.3766917586326599,
0.9711793065071106,
0.27581438422203064,
-0.3518368601799011,
-0.9879249334335327,
-0.21712368726730347,
0.11161568760871887,
-0.8990054726600647,
0.9290977716445923,
0.09284711629152298,
0.15633180737495422,
-0.07721975445747375,
-0.7505895495414734,
-0.7228977680206299,
1.1766266822814941,
0.8497323393821716,
-0.5828207731246948,
-0.5420820713043213,
0.3766964375972748,
0.3021419644355774,
-0.4120992422103882,
0.41027992963790894,
0.6630232334136963,
0.40513208508491516,
-0.13318279385566711,
-0.7993402481079102,
-0.19423887133598328,
-0.40436089038848877,
-0.4493769109249115,
0.2145853042602539,
-0.5681670904159546,
1.1246157884597778,
0.041925448924303055,
-0.5123499035835266,
-0.04439834505319595,
0.45766663551330566,
0.25698402523994446,
-0.07173466682434082,
0.11766156554222107,
0.716774582862854,
0.8515080809593201,
-0.04215564578771591,
0.8853074312210083,
-0.8589632511138916,
0.016029709950089455,
1.3645962476730347,
-0.4203828275203705,
1.2454407215118408,
0.2508625090122223,
-0.015847044065594673,
0.5819228887557983,
0.4539268910884857,
0.16836822032928467,
0.09473047405481339,
-0.008839507587254047,
-0.2480912208557129,
-0.20633237063884735,
-0.19614167511463165,
-0.38225165009498596,
0.9009290337562561,
0.7894675135612488,
-0.6435722708702087,
-0.5564674139022827,
-0.33977067470550537,
0.20930756628513336,
-0.22405558824539185,
-0.09175470471382141,
0.5704475045204163,
-0.0699840858578682,
-0.4481143653392792,
0.4469060003757477,
0.06779106706380844,
0.44281432032585144,
-0.65184485912323,
-0.39324456453323364,
-0.11318236589431763,
-0.11311978846788406,
-0.34142935276031494,
-0.4773433804512024,
0.11210016906261444,
0.2047995924949646,
-0.007870998233556747,
-0.19611229002475739,
0.6713355183601379,
-0.5150802731513977,
-0.26971927285194397,
0.4626891613006592,
0.5935660004615784,
0.40568915009498596,
0.12045322358608246,
-0.47145456075668335,
0.0339500717818737,
0.04766291752457619,
-0.46269363164901733,
0.502788245677948,
0.8258514404296875,
-0.012062476947903633,
0.27876004576683044,
0.7514644861221313,
0.4878968298435211,
0.3732355535030365,
-0.29261016845703125,
0.8149890303611755,
-0.6669856905937195,
-0.19814909994602203,
-0.68160080909729,
0.6116554141044617,
-0.3230336606502533,
-0.24207085371017456,
0.8468843102455139,
0.8965938091278076,
0.8954868912696838,
0.008137933909893036,
0.888496458530426,
-0.1315266638994217,
0.6387466192245483,
-0.5737109780311584,
0.4477805495262146,
-0.44854816794395447,
0.7292771339416504,
-0.048774730414152145,
-1.1116019487380981,
-0.2627002000808716,
0.4510944187641144,
0.05876517295837402,
-0.44250959157943726,
0.6791446208953857,
0.7684611678123474,
-0.2301492542028427,
0.11757028102874756,
0.16443361341953278,
0.22750766575336456,
0.3113868832588196,
0.5389766097068787,
0.7118254899978638,
-0.10782167315483093,
0.5708115100860596,
-0.10164491087198257,
-0.28813838958740234,
-0.1259659081697464,
-1.0497753620147705,
-0.5031951665878296,
-0.24621352553367615,
0.06291535496711731,
-0.12173383682966232,
-0.2686201333999634,
1.0132567882537842,
0.5671864748001099,
-0.671504557132721,
-0.3425808548927307,
0.10245821624994278,
-0.16761676967144012,
0.1484765261411667,
-0.2750324010848999,
0.5617640614509583,
-0.3806818723678589,
-0.9730359315872192,
0.669940173625946,
0.5724384784698486,
-0.32457464933395386,
-0.18675006926059723,
0.009363274089992046,
-0.10567160695791245,
0.14472638070583344,
0.8171085119247437,
0.5243206024169922,
-0.5442517399787903,
-0.25926265120506287,
0.21088942885398865,
-0.18664950132369995,
0.10521821677684784,
0.591344952583313,
-0.3922915458679199,
0.5487946271896362,
0.44823938608169556,
0.7814473509788513,
0.46908071637153625,
-0.22909829020500183,
0.6633607745170593,
-0.8846710324287415,
0.22315408289432526,
0.05163983628153801,
0.5400841236114502,
0.22118620574474335,
-0.2818470001220703,
0.7573825120925903,
-0.01729237288236618,
-0.5089901089668274,
-0.9682550430297852,
0.07801871001720428,
-0.671368420124054,
-0.33885303139686584,
1.1655949354171753,
-0.3864367604255676,
-0.3194068372249603,
-0.06397124379873276,
-0.21805694699287415,
0.20980428159236908,
-0.3999747335910797,
0.5704678297042847,
0.7595521807670593,
-0.062413979321718216,
-0.06127399578690529,
-0.7649257183074951,
0.0977649986743927,
0.13030725717544556,
-0.9044042229652405,
0.31123510003089905,
0.6118720173835754,
0.08693113178014755,
0.3345544636249542,
0.40333065390586853,
-0.2583795189857483,
0.20370922982692719,
0.31758883595466614,
0.443734735250473,
-0.16615763306617737,
-0.6393132209777832,
0.1040806919336319,
0.4804438352584839,
0.01386170368641615,
0.0573568232357502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14704v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14704v3
|
An LLM-Enhanced Adversarial Editing System for Lexical Simplification
| 2024-02-22T17:04:30 | 2024-03-22T06:45:51 |
Keren Tan, Kangyang Luo, Yunshi Lan, Zheng Yuan, Jinlong Shu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Lexical Simplification (LS) aims to simplify text at the lexical level.
Existing methods rely heavily on annotated data, making it challenging to apply
in low-resource scenarios. In this paper, we propose a novel LS method without
parallel corpora. This method employs an Adversarial Editing System with
guidance from a confusion loss and an invariance loss to predict lexical edits
in the original sentences. Meanwhile, we introduce an innovative LLM-enhanced
loss to enable the distillation of knowledge from Large Language Models (LLMs)
into a small-size LS system. From that, complex words within sentences are
masked and a Difficulty-aware Filling module is crafted to replace masked
positions with simpler words. At last, extensive experimental results and
analyses on three benchmark LS datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our
proposed method.
|
[
-0.22698523104190826,
-0.8341850638389587,
0.540829062461853,
0.01062094047665596,
-0.43297943472862244,
0.242065891623497,
-0.43883955478668213,
-0.03239363059401512,
0.3417121469974518,
0.3390636146068573,
-0.6935270428657532,
-0.4995187222957611,
-0.8418005108833313,
0.2825632095336914,
-0.2921123206615448,
0.9253946542739868,
-0.08420169353485107,
0.29826292395591736,
-0.015258345752954483,
0.09130329638719559,
-0.29156312346458435,
-0.36647483706474304,
-0.6481221914291382,
-0.4761846363544464,
0.5053712725639343,
0.2561224400997162,
1.3598607778549194,
0.6831709146499634,
0.4239127039909363,
0.37247133255004883,
-0.8977901339530945,
0.7540231347084045,
-0.5391890406608582,
-0.19804583489894867,
-0.05631104111671448,
-0.6856991648674011,
-0.41067585349082947,
-0.517800509929657,
0.4786546528339386,
0.7277377843856812,
-0.028575722128152847,
-0.15257669985294342,
0.19208811223506927,
0.7992210388183594,
-0.9830123782157898,
-0.017697179690003395,
-0.8975845575332642,
0.34862464666366577,
-0.20390793681144714,
-0.11226340383291245,
-0.17254690825939178,
-0.353356271982193,
-0.37552449107170105,
-0.724606990814209,
0.13453058898448944,
-0.19251491129398346,
0.3732360601425171,
0.7444314956665039,
-0.0006828525802120566,
-0.43028372526168823,
-0.5827274322509766,
0.5255918502807617,
-0.6570218205451965,
0.03156751021742821,
0.0384916290640831,
0.12446051836013794,
-0.3982852101325989,
-0.5917065739631653,
-0.628253698348999,
0.04809998348355293,
-0.25445061922073364,
0.1622525453567505,
-0.16245931386947632,
0.35346582531929016,
0.302094429731369,
0.2160254567861557,
-0.2565588653087616,
-0.032560527324676514,
-0.38385215401649475,
-0.24783091247081757,
0.48684874176979065,
0.25848889350891113,
0.2169893980026245,
-0.09356553852558136,
-0.31962913274765015,
0.046275828033685684,
-0.8287050127983093,
-0.17423821985721588,
0.29350802302360535,
0.34835684299468994,
0.18401814997196198,
0.694532573223114,
-0.20547835528850555,
0.35170525312423706,
0.021950937807559967,
-0.29504749178886414,
0.027894364669919014,
-0.25018084049224854,
-0.6276366114616394,
0.4002839922904968,
0.7232134938240051,
0.29649463295936584,
0.060255199670791626,
-0.1412723809480667,
-0.3855733871459961,
0.14699552953243256,
-0.18486127257347107,
-0.5791730880737305,
-0.1384149193763733,
-0.05367383733391762,
-0.050315357744693756,
-0.5274084806442261,
-0.21368224918842316,
-0.5855940580368042,
-0.9680073261260986,
-0.22767524421215057,
0.4739032983779907,
-0.5074967741966248,
0.3774424195289612,
0.3801950514316559,
-0.17348763346672058,
-0.5181622505187988,
0.7169833779335022,
-0.4984135627746582,
0.3471643924713135,
0.5930527448654175,
0.9335593581199646,
0.043540406972169876,
-0.09908663481473923,
-0.3755653202533722,
0.17959490418434143,
-0.4776914715766907,
0.1740352064371109,
-0.17646493017673492,
-0.2962440848350525,
-0.049164947122335434,
-0.2944733798503876,
0.2562495470046997,
-0.6486838459968567,
0.6003878116607666,
-0.738976776599884,
-0.21688802540302277,
-0.1336544305086136,
-0.5163395404815674,
-0.10700356215238571,
0.14552201330661774,
-0.6124714612960815,
0.8074175119400024,
-0.41171029210090637,
-0.8522394895553589,
-0.03602609410881996,
-0.3553268611431122,
-0.2758936882019043,
0.052893877029418945,
-0.02530943974852562,
-0.4028410017490387,
0.12518106400966644,
0.6217302680015564,
0.2135745733976364,
-0.1766369491815567,
0.30644628405570984,
-0.30653128027915955,
-0.628547728061676,
0.16075055301189423,
-0.6274174451828003,
0.7623193264007568,
0.3041607141494751,
-0.23007400333881378,
-0.07102745026350021,
-0.628809928894043,
-0.10776370018720627,
0.0769282728433609,
-0.37832552194595337,
-0.4194404184818268,
-0.20151109993457794,
-0.2318243831396103,
-0.028861939907073975,
0.6323087215423584,
-0.5637645125389099,
0.38025006651878357,
-0.44611656665802,
0.10537794977426529,
0.7899144291877747,
-0.0820540189743042,
0.4324350953102112,
-0.1736135333776474,
0.424162894487381,
-0.04596203938126564,
0.35615336894989014,
0.07865198701620102,
-0.2700466513633728,
-0.847973644733429,
-0.5734531283378601,
0.3969976603984833,
0.7963652014732361,
-1.154676079750061,
0.31050416827201843,
-0.2319130152463913,
-0.38355669379234314,
-0.6308540105819702,
0.6073716282844543,
0.5730568170547485,
0.26750922203063965,
0.5113067626953125,
0.1164967268705368,
-0.5151554942131042,
-0.8902590274810791,
-0.38345035910606384,
0.19731825590133667,
-0.19317100942134857,
-0.038824014365673065,
0.19944626092910767,
-0.2915567457675934,
0.5515774488449097,
-0.6799697279930115,
-0.46578019857406616,
-0.4066104292869568,
-0.11174893379211426,
-0.018993673846125603,
0.18611270189285278,
0.16305087506771088,
-0.589866042137146,
-0.24162428081035614,
-0.21169623732566833,
-0.8393224477767944,
-0.3777104616165161,
-0.23358024656772614,
0.14977648854255676,
-0.1253012865781784,
1.041031002998352,
-0.6020942330360413,
0.7494853138923645,
0.3171677887439728,
-0.08370621502399445,
0.2995348870754242,
-0.5645838975906372,
-0.2542417049407959,
-0.7748501300811768,
-0.4930170178413391,
-0.36416730284690857,
-0.38374611735343933,
-0.635811448097229,
0.11127355694770813,
0.34452083706855774,
-0.07902799546718597,
-0.6636190414428711,
0.2379448413848877,
-0.39519017934799194,
0.21416990458965302,
-0.27199092507362366,
0.3036782741546631,
0.08682771027088165,
0.5361984968185425,
-0.4349161982536316,
0.5981553792953491,
0.25575560331344604,
-0.4847928285598755,
0.523553729057312,
0.18013666570186615,
-0.04485651105642319,
0.10101466625928879,
-0.4522441327571869,
-0.05599921941757202,
-0.5647214651107788,
0.346059650182724,
-0.6011720299720764,
-0.027992146089673042,
0.29396578669548035,
-0.12286299467086792,
0.16641642153263092,
0.1644381582736969,
-0.6785720586776733,
-0.02318684756755829,
-0.6287624835968018,
0.29732656478881836,
0.19286981225013733,
-0.6469204425811768,
0.39476287364959717,
0.009247957728803158,
-0.29340410232543945,
-0.6706312894821167,
-1.0377094745635986,
0.4499625861644745,
-0.1816924810409546,
-0.535609781742096,
0.6010865569114685,
-0.17491289973258972,
-0.376287043094635,
-0.048699360340833664,
0.23678971827030182,
0.16099022328853607,
0.06994011253118515,
0.03776388615369797,
0.307032972574234,
0.021213945001363754,
0.3207341134548187,
0.20465800166130066,
0.24375474452972412,
-0.28314247727394104,
0.2508106231689453,
0.3263351023197174,
-0.10519599169492722,
-0.402930349111557,
-0.8223199844360352,
0.2807382047176361,
0.5195860266685486,
0.24426884949207306,
0.5782454609870911,
0.40290147066116333,
-0.5411170125007629,
-0.36458829045295715,
-0.38378337025642395,
0.1379573941230774,
-0.4985658526420593,
0.4660385847091675,
-0.3639996647834778,
-0.6345922946929932,
0.5972239971160889,
-0.277911901473999,
-0.12968774139881134,
0.48424258828163147,
0.24761062860488892,
0.15482810139656067,
0.7909637093544006,
0.3851590156555176,
-0.16631703078746796,
0.30936548113822937,
-0.201919823884964,
0.082518070936203,
-0.7271671295166016,
-0.1777101755142212,
-0.08206719905138016,
-0.5074787735939026,
-0.48021164536476135,
-0.574775218963623,
0.6406801342964172,
0.49113744497299194,
-0.24786591529846191,
0.13694310188293457,
-0.3469972312450409,
0.5738109946250916,
0.5263471007347107,
0.5511423945426941,
0.5018690824508667,
-0.019851455464959145,
-0.19258078932762146,
-0.1418066918849945,
-0.6822912693023682,
-0.35664498805999756,
1.1303269863128662,
0.247610405087471,
1.0154407024383545,
0.337479829788208,
0.8633329272270203,
0.4589868485927582,
0.22133967280387878,
-0.6779568195343018,
0.7038291692733765,
-0.3998366594314575,
-0.02703956328332424,
-0.4645662307739258,
-0.40815451741218567,
-0.40676596760749817,
0.3425810635089874,
-0.3988843858242035,
-0.32604750990867615,
-0.01471753977239132,
-0.07400304079055786,
-0.615629255771637,
0.6111320853233337,
-0.7830733060836792,
0.2597963213920593,
-0.010738520883023739,
-0.3394681215286255,
-0.11532120406627655,
-0.32186415791511536,
0.47370946407318115,
-0.24253688752651215,
0.5143963694572449,
0.314012736082077,
-0.40004053711891174,
0.44000810384750366,
-1.1231790781021118,
0.8604620695114136,
-0.15509089827537537,
0.048820801079273224,
0.1263875812292099,
0.2552074193954468,
0.9690775871276855,
0.14559291303157806,
-0.17338773608207703,
-0.03994600847363472,
-0.48712947964668274,
-0.07509519159793854,
-0.9314200282096863,
0.8450966477394104,
-0.6920263767242432,
-0.720416247844696,
-0.23533450067043304,
-0.6865940093994141,
-0.07122094929218292,
0.04289151728153229,
0.18327029049396515,
0.27533066272735596,
-0.045444928109645844,
0.024613266810774803,
0.6393054723739624,
-0.3062177300453186,
0.4262760281562805,
0.005344231612980366,
-0.06622757762670517,
-0.6251540780067444,
0.5904939770698547,
0.12447972595691681,
0.2746722400188446,
0.19726553559303284,
0.38260504603385925,
-0.13574904203414917,
-0.6636683344841003,
-0.6509991884231567,
0.08812752366065979,
-0.9055250287055969,
-0.43203282356262207,
-0.3781598210334778,
-0.2510016858577728,
-0.44384899735450745,
-0.5618288516998291,
-0.35358959436416626,
-0.5696529150009155,
-0.4123278260231018,
0.0898464247584343,
0.33010998368263245,
1.053463339805603,
-0.21271726489067078,
0.4278755784034729,
-0.4239385426044464,
0.4672243595123291,
0.3169763386249542,
-0.01938428357243538,
-0.23439273238182068,
-0.6292131543159485,
-0.007796453312039375,
0.16675600409507751,
-0.284712016582489,
-0.8400774598121643,
0.538007915019989,
0.2977335453033447,
0.07789059728384018,
0.2765810787677765,
0.12974229454994202,
1.0697011947631836,
-0.46824607253074646,
0.6120851635932922,
0.35960081219673157,
-1.0915915966033936,
0.38479915261268616,
-0.06202337145805359,
0.5350497961044312,
0.4529152810573578,
-0.0860474482178688,
-0.36052608489990234,
-0.5141518115997314,
-0.5311825275421143,
-0.850201427936554,
0.7776819467544556,
0.3910816013813019,
-0.10531388968229294,
0.3588573634624481,
0.6080399751663208,
-0.21520163118839264,
0.29328957200050354,
-0.6279569268226624,
-0.5667434334754944,
0.035681355744600296,
-0.4518204629421234,
-0.1323358118534088,
-0.38554948568344116,
-0.21038448810577393,
-0.15116405487060547,
0.9397109746932983,
0.14881332218647003,
-0.2790733873844147,
0.4431535005569458,
-0.20976229012012482,
0.00874321162700653,
0.4038536846637726,
0.6089283227920532,
0.06178763881325722,
-0.08187607675790787,
0.332798570394516,
0.8492012023925781,
-0.30335724353790283,
0.04521208629012108,
0.1229669526219368,
-0.5795415043830872,
0.2129526436328888,
0.30736783146858215,
0.673851728439331,
0.16593481600284576,
-0.5104032158851624,
0.6710934042930603,
-0.059745848178863525,
-0.24576063454151154,
-0.2881125509738922,
-0.17771047353744507,
0.1248243972659111,
0.3064996600151062,
0.21022292971611023,
0.3160662055015564,
0.20646867156028748,
-0.3104258179664612,
0.0700327455997467,
0.34935620427131653,
-0.356556236743927,
0.16598324477672577,
0.5279075503349304,
-0.19663794338703156,
-0.2106797993183136,
-0.06205761060118675,
-0.44046106934547424,
-0.5474144816398621,
0.4928545355796814,
0.24804805219173431,
0.6203622817993164,
-0.23847423493862152,
-0.07806835323572159,
0.1286483108997345,
0.4912608861923218,
-0.21265147626399994,
-0.005604824982583523,
0.20737089216709137,
-0.3544187545776367,
-0.0990339070558548,
-0.5882143974304199,
-0.47363749146461487,
0.3575195372104645,
-0.2296408861875534,
0.5868790745735168,
-0.7925624251365662,
0.12106692790985107,
0.11783408373594284,
-0.24478943645954132,
-0.5167429447174072,
0.3355221748352051,
0.3769836127758026,
0.8083964586257935,
-0.6559674143791199,
0.621539831161499,
0.5350074172019958,
-0.012778504751622677,
-0.5962879657745361,
-0.04060380905866623,
0.33471614122390747,
-0.8120049238204956,
0.7777356505393982,
-0.10509758442640305,
-0.4840450882911682,
-0.4361918866634369,
-0.33869490027427673,
-0.7925614714622498,
1.0909192562103271,
0.701779842376709,
-0.5068942308425903,
-0.11854003369808197,
0.492436945438385,
0.5951333045959473,
-0.15842704474925995,
0.22602716088294983,
0.26389220356941223,
0.3161405324935913,
0.24007079005241394,
-0.7675958871841431,
0.18159005045890808,
0.05274048447608948,
0.31417205929756165,
-0.035361841320991516,
-0.5194931030273438,
1.089376449584961,
-0.2573845088481903,
-0.192430317401886,
0.007550932001322508,
0.5835267305374146,
-0.20686452090740204,
0.1746227890253067,
0.5296944975852966,
0.6644097566604614,
0.7875940799713135,
0.14434118568897247,
0.680736243724823,
-0.15738296508789062,
0.29480746388435364,
1.3142184019088745,
0.04193468764424324,
0.597006618976593,
0.5571954846382141,
-0.07461388409137726,
0.2948121726512909,
0.30661365389823914,
0.44256556034088135,
0.6133744120597839,
0.708384096622467,
-0.6044209003448486,
-0.2838594317436218,
-0.12743280827999115,
-0.18415860831737518,
0.38913893699645996,
0.6405836939811707,
-0.400921106338501,
-0.5086715817451477,
0.015407206490635872,
0.3373819589614868,
0.3654116988182068,
-0.64035564661026,
0.8054391145706177,
-0.07872091978788376,
-0.39667460322380066,
0.7657515406608582,
0.28830286860466003,
1.0484697818756104,
-0.5918481349945068,
0.22609087824821472,
-0.1724947839975357,
0.57179194688797,
-0.2766511142253876,
-0.49322161078453064,
0.4146631956100464,
0.08763938397169113,
0.14363428950309753,
-0.13498009741306305,
0.7489825487136841,
-0.6228866577148438,
-0.8375512957572937,
0.44376906752586365,
0.3512762486934662,
0.033302102237939835,
-0.27374371886253357,
-0.6430938243865967,
0.17481598258018494,
0.10451558232307434,
-0.21795567870140076,
0.1994684338569641,
0.5649906396865845,
0.14791545271873474,
0.765753448009491,
0.4628557562828064,
0.4350459575653076,
0.12896594405174255,
0.022604690864682198,
1.1821153163909912,
-0.5873565077781677,
-0.4616526961326599,
-0.9361680150032043,
-0.006607714109122753,
-0.14679332077503204,
-0.016945455223321915,
0.5644077658653259,
0.5246042609214783,
0.5993846654891968,
0.019791167229413986,
0.99293053150177,
0.33199959993362427,
0.40692996978759766,
-0.5633451342582703,
0.6024355292320251,
-0.7977550625801086,
0.5648367404937744,
-0.21509701013565063,
-0.3260863125324249,
-0.6374138593673706,
0.043695613741874695,
-0.0632859542965889,
-0.4653804898262024,
0.7259960174560547,
1.2876381874084473,
0.015824146568775177,
-0.1478336900472641,
0.6203830242156982,
0.17411120235919952,
0.017166953533887863,
0.662940263748169,
0.44018104672431946,
-0.6966294050216675,
0.844199001789093,
-0.5752018094062805,
-0.352934867143631,
-0.27376917004585266,
-0.6087640523910522,
-0.8620078563690186,
-0.03409961983561516,
-0.21383635699748993,
-0.24612511694431305,
0.5045166015625,
0.8586363196372986,
-0.05459825322031975,
-0.5364570021629333,
0.17933394014835358,
-0.23082032799720764,
0.20051133632659912,
-0.05959146097302437,
-0.1577586978673935,
0.599238932132721,
-0.3845985531806946,
-0.7774543762207031,
0.6584126353263855,
0.1468983292579651,
0.07094091176986694,
-0.20767070353031158,
0.007819133810698986,
-0.1051882728934288,
0.2577246129512787,
0.416509747505188,
-0.10112284868955612,
-0.9619507193565369,
-0.195803701877594,
-0.2972540259361267,
-0.31153154373168945,
-0.17428994178771973,
0.5338779091835022,
-0.5600506663322449,
0.6362705230712891,
0.4449712336063385,
0.6510732173919678,
0.021367469802498817,
-0.19361662864685059,
0.2743963301181793,
-0.8597160577774048,
0.40212661027908325,
-0.028150582686066628,
0.6132523417472839,
0.49260514974594116,
-0.6497349143028259,
0.22815589606761932,
0.3052441477775574,
-0.11259738355875015,
-0.5476474761962891,
0.14210273325443268,
-0.7572135329246521,
-0.4519076645374298,
1.331142783164978,
-0.21924874186515808,
-0.1677284985780716,
-0.147376149892807,
-0.5059391260147095,
0.4403994381427765,
-0.2923327088356018,
0.8062795400619507,
0.5273212194442749,
0.1896103173494339,
0.1692236363887787,
-0.17283456027507782,
0.900510311126709,
0.6706141233444214,
-0.57986980676651,
0.26730138063430786,
0.45734742283821106,
0.017730705440044403,
0.2510775625705719,
0.28518757224082947,
-0.058736175298690796,
0.10421103239059448,
-0.08461557328701019,
0.29818928241729736,
-0.4218613803386688,
-0.08411265164613724,
-0.7249190211296082,
0.34227457642555237,
-0.11452575027942657,
-0.10485844314098358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14702v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14702v2
|
InfFeed: Influence Functions as a Feedback to Improve the Performance of Subjective Tasks
| 2024-02-22T16:59:09 | 2024-03-09T19:13:54 |
Somnath Banerjee, Maulindu Sarkar, Punyajoy Saha, Binny Mathew, Animesh Mukherjee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, influence functions present an apparatus for achieving
explainability for deep neural models by quantifying the perturbation of
individual train instances that might impact a test prediction. Our objectives
in this paper are twofold. First we incorporate influence functions as a
feedback into the model to improve its performance. Second, in a dataset
extension exercise, using influence functions to automatically identify data
points that have been initially `silver' annotated by some existing method and
need to be cross-checked (and corrected) by annotators to improve the model
performance. To meet these objectives, in this paper, we introduce InfFeed,
which uses influence functions to compute the influential instances for a
target instance. Toward the first objective, we adjust the label of the target
instance based on its influencer(s) label. In doing this, InfFeed outperforms
the state-of-the-art baselines (including LLMs) by a maximum macro F1-score
margin of almost 4% for hate speech classification, 3.5% for stance
classification, and 3% for irony and 2% for sarcasm detection. Toward the
second objective we show that manually re-annotating only those silver
annotated data points in the extension set that have a negative influence can
immensely improve the model performance bringing it very close to the scenario
where all the data points in the extension set have gold labels. This allows
for huge reduction of the number of data points that need to be manually
annotated since out of the silver annotated extension dataset, the influence
function scheme picks up ~1/1000 points that need manual correction.
|
[
-0.4561823308467865,
-0.7306228280067444,
0.37668782472610474,
0.2364264875650406,
-0.24566258490085602,
-0.3724411427974701,
-0.32936733961105347,
-0.43196603655815125,
0.17027288675308228,
0.5261771082878113,
-0.4345981776714325,
-0.37818631529808044,
-0.8134526610374451,
-0.19181427359580994,
-0.45623326301574707,
1.2469210624694824,
0.11437840014696121,
0.37597912549972534,
-0.509142279624939,
-0.06346689164638519,
-0.2987700402736664,
-0.6623128056526184,
-0.623772382736206,
-0.8464499115943909,
0.5418956279754639,
0.674163281917572,
0.5552067160606384,
-0.1011766567826271,
0.438004732131958,
0.2696412205696106,
-0.2572377920150757,
0.1576979160308838,
-0.6956067085266113,
0.019346533343195915,
-0.13963410258293152,
-0.6997143030166626,
-0.3324211537837982,
-0.12702113389968872,
0.66203373670578,
0.6697348952293396,
0.18662956357002258,
0.2220032662153244,
0.36111980676651,
0.4391581416130066,
-0.6080408692359924,
0.18865595757961273,
-0.4886271059513092,
-0.14983418583869934,
0.057822372764348984,
-0.0060303229838609695,
-0.5483253598213196,
-0.4693022072315216,
0.11745194345712662,
-0.38319921493530273,
0.022718384861946106,
-0.30732110142707825,
0.6895977854728699,
0.5883229970932007,
-0.08286011964082718,
-0.03808467835187912,
-0.5836270451545715,
0.7303670048713684,
-1.0259758234024048,
0.20474177598953247,
0.4909142553806305,
-0.05643633380532265,
-0.2868635058403015,
-0.6801034212112427,
-0.2566332519054413,
-0.4136250913143158,
-0.2998596131801605,
-0.014852859079837799,
-0.09165626019239426,
0.10594385862350464,
0.5366129875183105,
0.1483495682477951,
0.2865733206272125,
0.26248905062675476,
-0.059419408440589905,
0.05784565210342407,
0.7771009206771851,
-0.057706695050001144,
-0.1010194644331932,
0.010727258399128914,
-0.10259702056646347,
-0.07890299707651138,
-0.7367283701896667,
0.1527250111103058,
0.3445587158203125,
0.2650434672832489,
0.24526982009410858,
0.27773207426071167,
-0.3031477630138397,
0.6605666279792786,
0.4362594783306122,
0.13223466277122498,
0.522631049156189,
0.043538618832826614,
-0.45325157046318054,
0.12870945036411285,
0.5463534593582153,
0.2565324306488037,
0.45798882842063904,
-0.20438899099826813,
-0.1359902173280716,
-0.2003811001777649,
0.1895354837179184,
-1.3057912588119507,
-0.3310588300228119,
-0.07853332906961441,
-0.43280503153800964,
-0.38837724924087524,
0.23232106864452362,
-0.7538720369338989,
-0.6747264862060547,
-0.5300901532173157,
0.8085426688194275,
-0.4382212162017822,
-0.36952826380729675,
0.08494123816490173,
-0.24282972514629364,
-0.09226081520318985,
0.49038785696029663,
-0.7456908822059631,
0.41308215260505676,
0.4969783127307892,
0.6250002384185791,
0.11229682713747025,
-0.04303222894668579,
-0.5802596807479858,
-0.1995856612920761,
-0.2976045310497284,
0.5540220141410828,
-0.8158759474754333,
-0.33159875869750977,
-0.13645385205745697,
0.03911136835813522,
-0.12143142521381378,
-0.4514005482196808,
0.610220193862915,
-0.4308653771877289,
-0.005532240029424429,
-0.5670104622840881,
-1.0043983459472656,
-0.6566100120544434,
0.033152684569358826,
-0.5506420135498047,
0.9701172113418579,
0.20927470922470093,
-0.6449273824691772,
0.5538936257362366,
-0.98842453956604,
-0.5997409224510193,
-0.0271893423050642,
0.14388708770275116,
-0.43655237555503845,
0.19893868267536163,
0.2723589539527893,
0.4918495714664459,
0.02201293222606182,
0.14331835508346558,
-0.7237064838409424,
-0.5239598751068115,
0.33111056685447693,
-0.2432021051645279,
0.7045269012451172,
-0.1819227784872055,
-0.7263461351394653,
0.23372885584831238,
-0.7403531670570374,
0.1761402189731598,
-0.4717017710208893,
0.06439708918333054,
-0.49721643328666687,
0.08415844291448593,
-0.0539117194712162,
0.023907747119665146,
-0.33807823061943054,
-0.6013048887252808,
-0.12951317429542542,
-0.38192468881607056,
0.424013614654541,
0.7132828831672668,
0.4892195463180542,
0.4727799892425537,
-0.06982970237731934,
0.45091015100479126,
-0.09793388843536377,
0.26176854968070984,
-0.017053186893463135,
-0.4325096309185028,
-0.9046627283096313,
-0.26166361570358276,
0.70670086145401,
0.23333005607128143,
-0.3127042055130005,
0.34940168261528015,
0.0919279083609581,
-0.6043152213096619,
-0.5852648019790649,
0.2465101182460785,
0.23899558186531067,
0.7426005601882935,
0.39236748218536377,
-0.3276267349720001,
-0.32915955781936646,
-0.9682815074920654,
-0.263863205909729,
0.03333229571580887,
0.21875859797000885,
0.25947868824005127,
0.6043986082077026,
-0.11462469398975372,
0.7240512371063232,
-0.24613508582115173,
-0.3556709885597229,
0.09255727380514145,
0.1225123479962349,
0.2253173291683197,
0.4756925404071808,
0.6141318082809448,
-0.7405824661254883,
-0.4750285744667053,
-0.07647033780813217,
-0.6235656142234802,
-0.2413894236087799,
0.028195876628160477,
-0.20008042454719543,
-0.282675564289093,
0.7274673581123352,
-0.17602935433387756,
0.5406782627105713,
0.12423193454742432,
-0.2822520136833191,
0.3653905689716339,
0.16813677549362183,
0.26575374603271484,
-0.4464247524738312,
-0.1740938276052475,
0.2193814367055893,
-0.2349342554807663,
-0.5736716985702515,
-0.227432519197464,
0.13306453824043274,
0.23535789549350739,
-0.3385385572910309,
0.1705552041530609,
-0.10901147872209549,
0.30073675513267517,
-0.304972767829895,
-0.03827664628624916,
0.07698874175548553,
0.3553256690502167,
-0.306214302778244,
0.4180060029029846,
0.7657169699668884,
-0.8158630728721619,
0.11893545836210251,
0.13991707563400269,
-0.40397560596466064,
0.5242767930030823,
-0.8470945954322815,
0.30564749240875244,
-0.35478392243385315,
0.11324944347143173,
-1.1594082117080688,
-0.16970236599445343,
0.2877640426158905,
-0.32999923825263977,
0.4842170476913452,
-0.5080716013908386,
-0.46631404757499695,
0.04546299949288368,
-0.09508222341537476,
-0.044233229011297226,
0.31673070788383484,
-0.763044536113739,
0.6102245450019836,
0.3366767466068268,
0.2406795173883438,
-0.4316307604312897,
-0.9479188323020935,
-0.06724922358989716,
-0.3891996741294861,
-0.6169161200523376,
0.45921751856803894,
-0.06548986583948135,
-0.47095736861228943,
0.1681259423494339,
0.35251328349113464,
0.08762107789516449,
0.049616068601608276,
0.6333902478218079,
-0.0026503736153244972,
0.050805483013391495,
0.6168330907821655,
0.18832771480083466,
0.11648745089769363,
0.36551228165626526,
-0.2992154359817505,
0.151948481798172,
-0.13069674372673035,
-0.2248389571905136,
-0.5313577055931091,
0.13874845206737518,
0.45960748195648193,
-0.04626565799117088,
0.5514611005783081,
0.5512252449989319,
-0.28329333662986755,
-0.4811367988586426,
-0.4195915162563324,
-0.5188532471656799,
-0.45905667543411255,
0.6307249665260315,
-0.3902502655982971,
-0.722416877746582,
0.35009366273880005,
0.04094244912266731,
0.09563619643449783,
0.4856971800327301,
0.536170482635498,
-0.003192693693563342,
0.9636999368667603,
0.794871985912323,
-0.18674154579639435,
0.8751490116119385,
-0.4216344952583313,
-0.15113262832164764,
-0.8959075212478638,
-0.3304312527179718,
-0.2447766810655594,
-0.6020526885986328,
-0.5043247938156128,
0.008157730102539062,
0.2784491181373596,
0.028045520186424255,
-0.10771879553794861,
0.12746599316596985,
-0.5908926725387573,
0.43595051765441895,
0.6371228098869324,
0.6981032490730286,
-0.0020906738936901093,
-0.05138139799237251,
0.34980660676956177,
-0.14880411326885223,
-0.7190549969673157,
-0.1070641502737999,
1.3304649591445923,
0.38723281025886536,
0.923937201499939,
-0.26736828684806824,
0.5649924874305725,
0.4214969575405121,
0.8034971356391907,
-0.9847798347473145,
0.3141545057296753,
-0.23692132532596588,
-0.5162742137908936,
-0.1385609358549118,
-0.230754092335701,
-0.445595920085907,
0.21735909581184387,
-0.09129906445741653,
-0.6862749457359314,
0.4764426648616791,
0.3216315805912018,
-0.44021540880203247,
0.18339776992797852,
-1.1660606861114502,
0.5259958505630493,
-0.3243848383426666,
-0.7754164934158325,
-0.5457420945167542,
-0.275686115026474,
0.24040180444717407,
-0.0034091246780008078,
-0.15284550189971924,
0.11521079391241074,
0.1567831188440323,
1.1029466390609741,
-0.4197307527065277,
1.2787457704544067,
-0.5744138360023499,
0.24039754271507263,
0.35994213819503784,
-0.001023527467623353,
0.5552652478218079,
0.18148402869701385,
-0.6648852229118347,
0.2413904219865799,
-0.2717875838279724,
-0.030187716707587242,
-0.93333500623703,
0.8484576940536499,
-0.596860408782959,
-0.6314622759819031,
0.12223270535469055,
-0.5028107166290283,
-0.2962668836116791,
0.13943521678447723,
0.47347477078437805,
0.631879448890686,
-0.054277628660202026,
0.48630234599113464,
0.6457657217979431,
0.3622421622276306,
0.6096882224082947,
0.10359566658735275,
-0.16521532833576202,
-0.46797364950180054,
0.5402639508247375,
0.4672180414199829,
0.34965839982032776,
0.10008202493190765,
0.23236536979675293,
-0.36544084548950195,
-0.4598180651664734,
-0.3343014121055603,
0.1418425440788269,
-0.956373929977417,
-0.15688814222812653,
-0.4915139973163605,
0.09644392132759094,
-0.23742157220840454,
-0.00926495436578989,
-0.19120384752750397,
-0.46129852533340454,
-0.4877573549747467,
-0.3929561972618103,
0.5664604902267456,
1.0361971855163574,
-0.1251486986875534,
0.5746408700942993,
0.06062334030866623,
-0.18883052468299866,
0.03885478153824806,
0.4584938585758209,
0.03632424399256706,
-0.8547561168670654,
-0.48458826541900635,
0.03474036976695061,
-0.2927069664001465,
-1.047386884689331,
0.0775272324681282,
0.34310492873191833,
0.6739153861999512,
0.6388474702835083,
-0.02241344563663006,
0.6634749174118042,
0.06396909058094025,
0.37103918194770813,
-0.017888350412249565,
-1.050333023071289,
0.30555644631385803,
0.12405738234519958,
0.013195841573178768,
0.7782189846038818,
0.38487133383750916,
-0.1282203495502472,
-0.32473817467689514,
-0.9263253808021545,
-0.5324546098709106,
0.6775823831558228,
0.22464561462402344,
0.12972170114517212,
0.36085179448127747,
0.6440105438232422,
0.11796022206544876,
0.3249095380306244,
-0.5148100256919861,
-0.3062974512577057,
-0.23361645638942719,
0.060067225247621536,
-0.1702536791563034,
-0.29603853821754456,
-0.005118751898407936,
-0.8336109519004822,
1.006750464439392,
-0.1226605698466301,
0.03946869447827339,
0.531746506690979,
-0.04087694734334946,
-0.08064474165439606,
-0.07253754884004593,
0.25719335675239563,
0.7698484063148499,
-0.2953232526779175,
0.11018852889537811,
0.3944845497608185,
-0.2671925723552704,
-0.04611668735742569,
0.1462022364139557,
-0.6155930161476135,
0.2317301332950592,
0.23395755887031555,
0.9743291735649109,
0.18445618450641632,
-0.009214302524924278,
0.20726849138736725,
0.12386991828680038,
-0.19716742634773254,
-0.2920134961605072,
0.32642099261283875,
-0.10887319594621658,
0.16768883168697357,
-0.036093395203351974,
0.34283769130706787,
0.3773367404937744,
-0.3235412836074829,
0.524139404296875,
0.5282922387123108,
-1.0389623641967773,
-0.36403346061706543,
0.564184308052063,
0.23945482075214386,
-0.28533193469047546,
0.45306968688964844,
-0.13564075529575348,
-0.8146384358406067,
0.7767690420150757,
0.507042407989502,
0.8927220106124878,
-0.08095203340053558,
0.14464327692985535,
0.5710623264312744,
0.46265941858291626,
-0.08218255639076233,
-0.0009608914842829108,
-0.05320936441421509,
-0.6664631366729736,
-0.5606567859649658,
-0.21072809398174286,
-0.458609402179718,
0.25397536158561707,
-0.6407435536384583,
0.5009345412254333,
-0.4796275496482849,
-0.46847864985466003,
0.35716038942337036,
-0.04705967754125595,
-0.556995153427124,
0.6237700581550598,
0.024508818984031677,
0.7532383799552917,
-0.7671209573745728,
0.6376933455467224,
0.6798609495162964,
-0.4012430012226105,
-0.7801756262779236,
0.13105612993240356,
-0.23582540452480316,
-0.530730664730072,
0.6120707392692566,
0.2683366537094116,
-0.2593597173690796,
0.2175193578004837,
-0.8268983960151672,
-0.8630826473236084,
0.49829861521720886,
0.502777099609375,
-0.45417675375938416,
0.5770444273948669,
-0.17558743059635162,
0.5729193091392517,
-0.5856308341026306,
0.7442264556884766,
0.6432915329933167,
0.8138444423675537,
-0.04114602133631706,
-0.41570210456848145,
0.07860346883535385,
-0.3793308436870575,
-0.4972422122955322,
0.25680235028266907,
-0.6750168204307556,
0.5605142712593079,
-0.4343392252922058,
0.32184237241744995,
-0.37545713782310486,
0.6349983215332031,
-0.3263544738292694,
0.19696608185768127,
0.8090829849243164,
0.5092718005180359,
0.8893730640411377,
0.012319113127887249,
1.1835952997207642,
0.0968804806470871,
0.32654446363449097,
1.1971101760864258,
0.1378794014453888,
0.5823243856430054,
0.5075095891952515,
-0.012837877497076988,
0.706439733505249,
0.6511338949203491,
-0.37259629368782043,
0.591015636920929,
0.3677190840244293,
-0.036306463181972504,
-0.3215157985687256,
-0.11729206889867783,
-0.30244752764701843,
0.28931739926338196,
0.37345820665359497,
-0.7729734778404236,
-0.05579667538404465,
0.04604809731245041,
0.34876346588134766,
-0.18968915939331055,
-0.40125319361686707,
0.5501835346221924,
0.12844881415367126,
-0.7508288025856018,
0.3965044319629669,
-0.24438343942165375,
0.5013344883918762,
-0.6693167686462402,
-0.11711391061544418,
-0.03812072053551674,
0.6041198372840881,
-0.6296769976615906,
-0.7369042038917542,
0.11260610073804855,
-0.37690168619155884,
-0.3548116683959961,
0.06068745627999306,
0.8449617028236389,
-0.39541080594062805,
-0.6153803467750549,
0.6159417629241943,
-0.02682390622794628,
-0.0113464230671525,
-0.5037291646003723,
-0.5869180560112,
-0.16043029725551605,
0.37173500657081604,
-0.4538411498069763,
0.10148641467094421,
0.17574112117290497,
-0.06630236655473709,
0.5334515571594238,
0.5940062999725342,
0.06073598191142082,
-0.08091315627098083,
0.3949614465236664,
0.8582589626312256,
-0.3469802439212799,
-0.3627067804336548,
-0.986281156539917,
0.49880146980285645,
-0.40656110644340515,
-0.6882197856903076,
0.9433266520500183,
0.2607220411300659,
0.751173734664917,
0.06405539810657501,
0.9569070935249329,
-0.128310889005661,
0.2846439778804779,
-0.1985626071691513,
0.7135196924209595,
-0.7330858707427979,
0.1321587860584259,
-0.40158164501190186,
-0.6960731744766235,
-0.3465540409088135,
0.34052661061286926,
-0.6630654335021973,
0.14864382147789001,
0.572077751159668,
0.9664793610572815,
0.07939436286687851,
0.296514630317688,
0.31163012981414795,
0.40118521451950073,
0.3382504880428314,
0.3042914867401123,
0.7664073705673218,
-0.489023357629776,
0.39766445755958557,
-0.8905267715454102,
-0.48236608505249023,
-0.11726212501525879,
-0.7902286648750305,
-1.16512930393219,
-0.3611539900302887,
-0.6135354042053223,
-0.5613070726394653,
-0.015984326601028442,
0.7373923659324646,
1.1739697456359863,
-0.9102542400360107,
-0.05782344564795494,
-0.1878792941570282,
0.19810281693935394,
-0.3989936411380768,
-0.2416762262582779,
0.363604336977005,
-0.5267554521560669,
-0.9164659380912781,
0.4379984736442566,
0.0009792009368538857,
-0.37157922983169556,
-0.12358146160840988,
-0.02849823795258999,
-0.04664056748151779,
-0.011062558740377426,
0.6366346478462219,
-0.08858267962932587,
-0.25885388255119324,
-0.26954957842826843,
-0.14404070377349854,
0.34413084387779236,
-0.09905372560024261,
0.8046408891677856,
-0.7995471954345703,
0.543480396270752,
0.4466586112976074,
0.4239828288555145,
0.8510816097259521,
0.1212695762515068,
0.4089197516441345,
-0.5786824822425842,
0.21948431432247162,
0.34403419494628906,
0.3786317706108093,
0.43558794260025024,
-0.8737267255783081,
0.6752309799194336,
0.3061648905277252,
-0.6705226302146912,
-0.670610249042511,
0.0647522509098053,
-0.6383079290390015,
-0.15355558693408966,
1.3574273586273193,
-0.03869413584470749,
-0.3131955862045288,
-0.13199609518051147,
-0.21618445217609406,
0.03952328860759735,
-0.7133184671401978,
0.7145805954933167,
0.7160735726356506,
-0.496659517288208,
-0.09496074169874191,
-0.2846846282482147,
0.7360256910324097,
0.7711806893348694,
-0.6244648694992065,
-0.07621701061725616,
0.36611899733543396,
0.404930979013443,
0.06522101908922195,
0.27264174818992615,
-0.14376604557037354,
0.04596300795674324,
-0.10470296442508698,
0.011627862229943275,
-0.2850777506828308,
-0.24976816773414612,
-0.2742637097835541,
0.32401740550994873,
-0.1191791221499443,
-0.3867807388305664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14701v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14701v1
|
COMPASS: Computational Mapping of Patient-Therapist Alliance Strategies with Language Modeling
| 2024-02-22T16:56:44 | 2024-02-22T16:56:44 |
Baihan Lin, Djallel Bouneffouf, Yulia Landa, Rachel Jespersen, Cheryl Corcoran, Guillermo Cecchi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG, q-bio.NC
|
The therapeutic working alliance is a critical factor in predicting the
success of psychotherapy treatment. Traditionally, working alliance assessment
relies on questionnaires completed by both therapists and patients. In this
paper, we present COMPASS, a novel framework to directly infer the therapeutic
working alliance from the natural language used in psychotherapy sessions. Our
approach utilizes advanced large language models to analyze transcripts of
psychotherapy sessions and compare them with distributed representations of
statements in the working alliance inventory. Analyzing a dataset of over 950
sessions covering diverse psychiatric conditions, we demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method in microscopically mapping patient-therapist
alignment trajectories and providing interpretability for clinical psychiatry
and in identifying emerging patterns related to the condition being treated. By
employing various neural topic modeling techniques in combination with
generative language prompting, we analyze the topical characteristics of
different psychiatric conditions and incorporate temporal modeling to capture
the evolution of topics at a turn-level resolution. This combined framework
enhances the understanding of therapeutic interactions, enabling timely
feedback for therapists regarding conversation quality and providing
interpretable insights to improve the effectiveness of psychotherapy.
|
[
-0.4014274477958679,
-0.5054181814193726,
0.7385048270225525,
0.19647318124771118,
-0.0726313441991806,
0.49338850378990173,
-0.27390095591545105,
-0.36193394660949707,
0.3922342360019684,
0.5363364815711975,
-0.6943821310997009,
-0.6407257318496704,
-0.5349571704864502,
-0.05510348454117775,
-0.2447713315486908,
0.6983896493911743,
-0.029682718217372894,
0.6780574321746826,
-0.20783856511116028,
-0.2751938998699188,
-0.5906834602355957,
-0.532440721988678,
-0.8384907245635986,
-0.6377533674240112,
0.41036632657051086,
0.2213808000087738,
1.024725079536438,
0.5586240291595459,
0.6110670566558838,
0.372658908367157,
-0.09052569419145584,
-0.21827051043510437,
-0.7719763517379761,
0.01491716131567955,
-0.3330247700214386,
-0.2824329137802124,
-0.6737680435180664,
0.10387993603944778,
0.7048857808113098,
1.2375693321228027,
-0.5856517553329468,
0.10919889807701111,
-0.01291795913130045,
0.16604094207286835,
-0.17663805186748505,
-0.14760465919971466,
-0.3782164752483368,
0.2539212107658386,
-0.070648692548275,
0.0029254122637212276,
-0.2935013771057129,
-0.05406513065099716,
0.5573605298995972,
-0.4291635751724243,
0.47288092970848083,
0.3473910093307495,
0.8164853453636169,
-0.0802406594157219,
-0.6307651400566101,
0.09599988162517548,
-0.7703973054885864,
0.6872261762619019,
-0.7276283502578735,
0.45691025257110596,
0.29752466082572937,
0.49425286054611206,
-0.38973715901374817,
-0.7664017677307129,
-0.5769658088684082,
-0.1382676362991333,
-0.49454933404922485,
-0.19278645515441895,
-0.17196081578731537,
0.4190281629562378,
0.2139882743358612,
0.29919999837875366,
-0.5296048521995544,
0.12808828055858612,
-0.4595937728881836,
-0.16886697709560394,
0.5859456658363342,
0.6184442639350891,
0.5908908247947693,
0.08770385384559631,
-0.3903200328350067,
0.11152951419353485,
-0.6064698100090027,
-0.1676432192325592,
-0.2589629590511322,
0.3555923104286194,
-0.24240581691265106,
0.47566506266593933,
0.16138513386249542,
0.8801385164260864,
0.08674120903015137,
-0.337280809879303,
-0.18801504373550415,
-0.20461414754390717,
-0.09475892782211304,
0.26444485783576965,
0.7606185674667358,
0.8627666234970093,
-0.4641272723674774,
-0.5446088910102844,
0.10313748568296432,
0.1593312919139862,
0.21529333293437958,
-0.5513983368873596,
-0.27281928062438965,
0.2073882818222046,
-0.5672276616096497,
0.06297172605991364,
-0.3036399781703949,
-1.1531823873519897,
-0.6451786756515503,
-0.5674464106559753,
-0.022197339683771133,
-0.1732797473669052,
-0.7064530253410339,
0.10825886577367783,
-0.1228620633482933,
0.29791420698165894,
-0.0626906156539917,
-0.736001193523407,
0.6276965737342834,
0.8872945308685303,
0.9406567215919495,
-0.4450720250606537,
-0.4759562015533447,
-0.5987151861190796,
0.1523604393005371,
-0.3447195589542389,
0.7303606271743774,
-0.5982000231742859,
-0.3956085741519928,
0.06605631113052368,
-0.013332881033420563,
-0.16395121812820435,
-0.18722112476825714,
0.1742761880159378,
-0.4438646733760834,
0.46402329206466675,
-0.11352980136871338,
-0.6266676783561707,
-0.01691809482872486,
0.326569139957428,
-0.6887056231498718,
0.5950508713722229,
0.47737839818000793,
-0.5570545792579651,
0.24631363153457642,
-0.8422797322273254,
-0.133416548371315,
0.27092990279197693,
-0.13386765122413635,
0.0021133041009306908,
0.0018301346572116017,
-0.20804035663604736,
0.1912495344877243,
-0.6712439060211182,
0.3380157947540283,
-0.2615825831890106,
-0.05294185131788254,
0.6114888191223145,
0.19097429513931274,
0.5080881118774414,
0.07118582725524902,
-0.09105788171291351,
0.37294867634773254,
-0.5969837307929993,
0.037632059305906296,
-0.1162627562880516,
0.27956873178482056,
-0.1879255771636963,
-0.0906478613615036,
-0.002198596252128482,
0.3898142874240875,
0.04318014532327652,
-0.54366534948349,
0.08989845216274261,
-0.7273409366607666,
0.3689277768135071,
0.31751421093940735,
0.55353844165802,
0.481162428855896,
-0.4486864507198334,
0.827633798122406,
-0.1540078967809677,
-0.041339773684740067,
0.228458970785141,
-0.3655773997306824,
-0.6692962646484375,
-0.27160197496414185,
0.1890001893043518,
0.1731061041355133,
-0.6978932023048401,
0.009147372096776962,
-0.38928085565567017,
-0.6508888602256775,
-0.5463047027587891,
-0.27332332730293274,
0.5212103724479675,
0.6544981002807617,
0.36180007457733154,
-0.5354887247085571,
-0.4007572531700134,
-0.605659544467926,
-0.3537178635597229,
-0.05023102089762688,
-0.008078522980213165,
0.13646374642848969,
0.03555234521627426,
-0.1691521853208542,
1.0965701341629028,
-0.5277340412139893,
-0.1970345675945282,
-0.5989611148834229,
0.4744746685028076,
0.3457586467266083,
0.3980233073234558,
0.35865259170532227,
-0.6688179969787598,
-0.6914095878601074,
-0.01579444855451584,
-0.38309037685394287,
-0.07221081107854843,
-0.3542739152908325,
-0.5289992094039917,
-0.1439981907606125,
0.3578740060329437,
-0.3456118106842041,
0.44353267550468445,
0.47589805722236633,
-0.893127977848053,
0.36420920491218567,
-0.06454004347324371,
0.11796481907367706,
-1.043857455253601,
0.0893249437212944,
-0.16711652278900146,
-0.10278863459825516,
-0.9986092448234558,
-0.06706162542104721,
-0.4629892408847809,
-0.3876231610774994,
-0.350445419549942,
0.4798339903354645,
-0.4528723359107971,
-0.12438806891441345,
-0.2061743289232254,
0.4142186641693115,
-0.04461127147078514,
0.743241012096405,
0.13244199752807617,
0.4763045012950897,
0.7078697085380554,
-0.2796952426433563,
0.5690414309501648,
0.4164908528327942,
0.09722976386547089,
1.0083775520324707,
-0.564420759677887,
0.1743280440568924,
0.21023225784301758,
0.023362766951322556,
-0.9235043525695801,
-0.10252232104539871,
0.21607381105422974,
-0.35887640714645386,
0.1789110153913498,
-0.30615031719207764,
-0.27843740582466125,
-0.020480239763855934,
0.17093101143836975,
0.5530018210411072,
0.34461313486099243,
-0.30914491415023804,
0.7405815720558167,
0.5312002301216125,
-0.2642454206943512,
-0.016747789457440376,
-0.06628342717885971,
0.2907331883907318,
-0.3829020857810974,
-0.6261720657348633,
0.54332435131073,
0.25745800137519836,
-0.3922770619392395,
0.04698245972394943,
0.23059852421283722,
-0.21849676966667175,
0.00193459028378129,
0.32500186562538147,
0.5909935832023621,
-0.23051917552947998,
-0.030530372634530067,
-0.2542498707771301,
-0.5373842716217041,
0.26601171493530273,
-0.08773849904537201,
0.8151941299438477,
-0.2362801432609558,
-0.5378322601318359,
-0.3603016436100006,
0.7664901614189148,
0.6140323281288147,
-0.5167980790138245,
1.0170444250106812,
0.4699704349040985,
-0.46007540822029114,
-0.05726052075624466,
-0.20519940555095673,
-0.3432571291923523,
-0.4345775246620178,
0.19795171916484833,
-0.022798746824264526,
-0.7018322944641113,
0.468255877494812,
-0.3745632469654083,
-0.018753858283162117,
0.1314774453639984,
0.517937958240509,
0.2404017597436905,
1.3436918258666992,
0.6132484078407288,
-0.03531692549586296,
0.16580498218536377,
-0.43043825030326843,
0.7897704243659973,
-0.9471418857574463,
-0.21732641756534576,
-0.2581636905670166,
-0.4986991286277771,
-0.4855307936668396,
-0.39525237679481506,
0.6048399209976196,
-0.09908433258533478,
-0.25472548604011536,
0.21469584107398987,
-0.6017582416534424,
0.15310688316822052,
0.10338808596134186,
-0.2915377616882324,
0.2715432643890381,
-0.2967627942562103,
-0.3779263496398926,
-0.6126482486724854,
-0.6259832382202148,
-0.3136821687221527,
0.8548000454902649,
0.26357442140579224,
0.36727768182754517,
0.22247803211212158,
0.4138735830783844,
-0.03396428003907204,
0.6360021233558655,
-0.6461818814277649,
0.6063230633735657,
0.5836257338523865,
-0.43325215578079224,
-0.1790056675672531,
-0.3013458549976349,
-1.0711355209350586,
0.6021400690078735,
-0.5776651501655579,
-1.1100713014602661,
0.2670802175998688,
-0.17296439409255981,
-0.5119994878768921,
0.10589342564344406,
-0.2970224618911743,
1.0988267660140991,
-0.416691392660141,
-0.419792503118515,
-0.38479194045066833,
-0.7426167130470276,
0.06403132528066635,
0.1818370372056961,
0.11832498013973236,
-0.2752956449985504,
0.09458699822425842,
0.7886292934417725,
-0.35159099102020264,
0.6296283602714539,
-0.11184006929397583,
0.14296285808086395,
-0.08829934895038605,
0.34774163365364075,
0.1259182095527649,
-0.08293862640857697,
-0.1030631884932518,
0.0001799823367036879,
0.5172166228294373,
-0.24295960366725922,
-0.986680269241333,
0.53694748878479,
-0.663622260093689,
-0.40131670236587524,
-0.7711175084114075,
-0.3813137710094452,
-0.6682899594306946,
0.4658369719982147,
0.037565719336271286,
0.6886101961135864,
-0.5204153060913086,
-0.3737504482269287,
0.18858878314495087,
0.04457986727356911,
-0.055433239787817,
0.9898431897163391,
-0.5156974792480469,
-0.4562893509864807,
0.9581582546234131,
-0.2990354597568512,
0.3219295144081116,
-0.11593298614025116,
-0.024564629420638084,
-0.21791282296180725,
-0.6537399291992188,
-0.01319639477878809,
0.7606775760650635,
-0.6548649072647095,
-0.19362689554691315,
-0.2394491285085678,
-0.12278398871421814,
-0.43150755763053894,
-0.42315876483917236,
-0.35298770666122437,
-0.24294936656951904,
-0.14101983606815338,
-0.10242185741662979,
0.150039404630661,
0.580048143863678,
0.04598361626267433,
0.6378031969070435,
-0.7725539207458496,
0.22066551446914673,
-0.18932272493839264,
0.426761269569397,
0.06662101298570633,
-0.00041833697468973696,
-0.3487216532230377,
0.3446013331413269,
-0.46367713809013367,
-1.2345367670059204,
0.7235739827156067,
0.18999157845973969,
0.5881227850914001,
0.4926494061946869,
0.11542738229036331,
0.7573326230049133,
-0.29271283745765686,
0.9640828371047974,
0.455598384141922,
-0.8840978145599365,
0.2479245364665985,
-0.3233218491077423,
-0.0840793177485466,
0.6124995350837708,
0.4492184817790985,
-1.217628002166748,
-0.3250246047973633,
-0.7749543190002441,
-0.8206258416175842,
0.7359551787376404,
-0.11773236095905304,
-0.4254293143749237,
0.1662922501564026,
0.30930373072624207,
-0.43350303173065186,
0.0606066919863224,
-0.3914688527584076,
-0.06422916054725647,
0.16008804738521576,
-0.21997350454330444,
0.013091928325593472,
0.09456011652946472,
-0.9121447801589966,
-0.3471277058124542,
0.5289104580879211,
-0.17306357622146606,
0.6243496537208557,
0.10819956660270691,
0.05394386127591133,
-0.4506836533546448,
-0.01811499521136284,
0.2175530344247818,
1.0310173034667969,
0.19995099306106567,
0.11518912762403488,
0.3539442718029022,
-0.06162382662296295,
0.008061899803578854,
0.12410597503185272,
0.4904583990573883,
0.07898160070180893,
0.6277506947517395,
0.6368635296821594,
0.24241754412651062,
-0.785651683807373,
0.6699463725090027,
-0.4031204879283905,
0.002177546266466379,
-0.2751510441303253,
0.12485991418361664,
0.1960597038269043,
0.30740028619766235,
-0.12761080265045166,
-0.2824111580848694,
0.277216374874115,
-0.4138004183769226,
0.1891571581363678,
0.4184572696685791,
-0.7416368126869202,
-0.35248881578445435,
0.2516170144081116,
0.12296388298273087,
-0.7809956073760986,
0.9143322706222534,
-0.06633691489696503,
-0.8037642240524292,
0.3795461058616638,
0.7014772891998291,
0.732444167137146,
-0.09680897742509842,
0.3027731478214264,
0.2823598384857178,
-0.21106700599193573,
0.16739684343338013,
0.041493967175483704,
0.055659130215644836,
-0.48828673362731934,
-0.16393634676933289,
-0.49656540155410767,
-0.5646840333938599,
-0.2487962692975998,
-1.0273548364639282,
0.18991008400917053,
-0.2607737183570862,
-0.30635541677474976,
-0.05227062851190567,
0.12366887181997299,
-0.5718980431556702,
-0.3444589376449585,
-0.042917560786008835,
0.8351059556007385,
-0.7947264313697815,
0.6136150360107422,
0.7460780739784241,
-0.12762358784675598,
-0.9689028859138489,
-0.1899232119321823,
0.2552878260612488,
-0.6557956337928772,
0.06782235950231552,
-0.11559712886810303,
-0.327580064535141,
-0.16318726539611816,
-0.3537736237049103,
-0.9191744923591614,
1.2031691074371338,
0.25276657938957214,
-0.036926236003637314,
-0.12833134829998016,
0.6568636894226074,
1.0600510835647583,
-0.7319220900535583,
0.03797631338238716,
1.0311866998672485,
0.33620375394821167,
0.42117077112197876,
-1.0258504152297974,
0.13078860938549042,
-0.36347058415412903,
0.1258680522441864,
0.44218215346336365,
-0.22877289354801178,
0.6024930477142334,
0.08414798974990845,
-0.5114519000053406,
0.2286587953567505,
0.5771661996841431,
-0.041752059012651443,
0.4569947421550751,
0.4158058166503906,
0.47543591260910034,
0.7851826548576355,
0.03705359995365143,
0.5807754397392273,
-0.7404322624206543,
0.29170531034469604,
1.1919580698013306,
-0.5940874814987183,
0.6193186640739441,
0.5854650139808655,
-0.09983240067958832,
0.6915144920349121,
0.4399082064628601,
-0.1009451374411583,
0.4985347390174866,
0.24989661574363708,
-0.46485111117362976,
-0.0910031795501709,
-0.46016284823417664,
-0.2862677574157715,
0.37670183181762695,
0.6604454517364502,
-0.27876684069633484,
-0.39805081486701965,
0.1709265410900116,
0.15961579978466034,
0.22743521630764008,
-0.07414751499891281,
1.0865585803985596,
0.07053276896476746,
-1.14069664478302,
0.5745424628257751,
0.031171876937150955,
-0.14776407182216644,
-0.5286831259727478,
-0.36058732867240906,
-0.05148259177803993,
0.3290390968322754,
-0.09063903242349625,
-0.5076004862785339,
0.41146960854530334,
-0.2949092984199524,
0.2891065180301666,
-0.35743477940559387,
0.46845775842666626,
-0.7499454617500305,
-0.45939627289772034,
0.1891053020954132,
0.37395215034484863,
0.0741644948720932,
0.33615797758102417,
-0.6142473816871643,
0.053425125777721405,
-0.3610288202762604,
0.29202505946159363,
0.4910803437232971,
0.3615371584892273,
0.18675430119037628,
0.6608589887619019,
0.6131265759468079,
0.2967211604118347,
-0.3666708469390869,
-0.34833067655563354,
1.0080372095108032,
-0.4525788128376007,
-0.6721885204315186,
-0.65860915184021,
0.3820844292640686,
-0.4218490719795227,
-0.4615493714809418,
0.7348750829696655,
0.35690727829933167,
0.140090674161911,
0.5235047340393066,
0.2572604715824127,
0.10668512433767319,
0.7662063241004944,
-0.23677265644073486,
0.7362841963768005,
-0.27848127484321594,
0.2455758899450302,
-0.13816329836845398,
-0.5563608407974243,
-0.31107020378112793,
0.6974694728851318,
-0.5745021104812622,
-0.41551509499549866,
0.8359020948410034,
1.0155270099639893,
0.012437053956091404,
0.45929861068725586,
-0.0979122444987297,
0.2448943704366684,
0.6779710650444031,
0.6179296970367432,
0.9823984503746033,
0.1430576741695404,
0.05901774764060974,
-0.1359175145626068,
-0.3728867471218109,
-0.05215197056531906,
-0.8278263807296753,
-0.8500141501426697,
-0.764844536781311,
-0.16629454493522644,
-0.496908962726593,
-0.10362817347049713,
1.2326253652572632,
0.7156487703323364,
-0.427357017993927,
-0.6004053354263306,
0.05809904262423515,
0.2588599622249603,
-0.49594783782958984,
-0.18210498988628387,
0.33803197741508484,
-0.10486184060573578,
-0.1333652138710022,
0.29140469431877136,
0.19270889461040497,
-0.0974452793598175,
-0.6842230558395386,
-0.25019896030426025,
-0.06697555631399155,
-0.0647701546549797,
0.1129523441195488,
0.2795155644416809,
-0.41921037435531616,
-0.02745361253619194,
0.06854467839002609,
-0.08957618474960327,
0.20256440341472626,
1.2080318927764893,
-0.6673097014427185,
0.5383160710334778,
0.21835672855377197,
0.481718510389328,
0.4169997572898865,
-0.09317690879106522,
1.2052005529403687,
-0.12306556850671768,
0.058120083063840866,
0.6876375675201416,
0.22358478605747223,
0.3766440451145172,
-0.34507402777671814,
0.28949275612831116,
0.08190648257732391,
-0.47893026471138,
-1.0312715768814087,
0.12576313316822052,
-0.8800000548362732,
-0.030708346515893936,
0.8784136176109314,
-0.3267432451248169,
-0.34061652421951294,
-0.3735600411891937,
-0.5091944932937622,
0.16138902306556702,
-0.06393519043922424,
0.8156260251998901,
0.6453414559364319,
-0.4983958601951599,
0.02431609481573105,
-0.22400955855846405,
0.7561821341514587,
0.35165935754776,
-0.4594314992427826,
0.04652555286884308,
0.5647234320640564,
0.04885334521532059,
0.2516629993915558,
0.6880356073379517,
0.08539026975631714,
0.343723326921463,
-0.16263307631015778,
-0.27100202441215515,
0.20901431143283844,
-0.22290782630443573,
-0.18615354597568512,
0.12362724542617798,
0.1878003180027008,
0.19276592135429382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14700v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14700v3
|
Unveiling Linguistic Regions in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T16:56:13 | 2024-05-30T17:31:46 |
Zhihao Zhang, Jun Zhao, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated considerable cross-lingual
alignment and generalization ability. Current research primarily focuses on
improving LLMs' cross-lingual generalization capabilities. However, there is
still a lack of research on the intrinsic mechanisms of how LLMs achieve
cross-lingual alignment. From the perspective of region partitioning, this
paper conducts several investigations on the linguistic competence of LLMs. We
discover a core region in LLMs that corresponds to linguistic competence,
accounting for approximately 1% of the total model parameters. Removing this
core region by setting parameters to zero results in a significant performance
decrease across 30 different languages. Furthermore, this core region exhibits
significant dimensional dependence, perturbations to even a single parameter on
specific dimensions leading to a loss of linguistic competence. Moreover, we
discover that distinct monolingual regions exist for different languages, and
disruption to these specific regions substantially reduces the LLMs'
proficiency in those corresponding languages. Our research also indicates that
freezing the core linguistic region during further pre-training can mitigate
the issue of catastrophic forgetting (CF), a common phenomenon observed during
further pre-training of LLMs. Overall, exploring the LLMs' functional regions
provides insights into the foundation of their intelligence.
|
[
-0.7388454675674438,
-0.7802314758300781,
0.5380724668502808,
-0.06579585373401642,
-0.18589484691619873,
0.1947690099477768,
-0.5844835042953491,
-0.13909734785556793,
0.13838046789169312,
0.7025929689407349,
-0.6291825175285339,
-0.5857434272766113,
-0.48917487263679504,
-0.03215833753347397,
-0.1997116506099701,
0.7165014147758484,
0.08473757654428482,
0.08708585053682327,
-0.2951897084712982,
-0.16544517874717712,
-0.6281692981719971,
-0.8449709415435791,
-0.4014577865600586,
-0.6548363566398621,
0.3701407015323639,
0.5040397644042969,
0.3504147231578827,
0.788488507270813,
0.1835322380065918,
0.3164677023887634,
-0.37132611870765686,
-0.18079647421836853,
-0.8010774254798889,
0.06289602071046829,
-0.2589690089225769,
-0.7962630391120911,
-0.506000280380249,
-0.2691008448600769,
0.8899586200714111,
0.9650656580924988,
-0.11250356584787369,
-0.0840206891298294,
0.11076462268829346,
0.6856628060340881,
-0.47249966859817505,
0.011517273262143135,
-1.00033438205719,
0.04861963540315628,
-0.42993655800819397,
-0.21505878865718842,
-0.33980467915534973,
0.15601500868797302,
0.3446258306503296,
-0.45378467440605164,
0.5193923115730286,
-0.15920224785804749,
0.6784945130348206,
0.21061713993549347,
-0.4508269727230072,
-0.09026668965816498,
-0.7415186762809753,
1.061286211013794,
-0.6329399347305298,
0.451440691947937,
0.3268093764781952,
-0.030648037791252136,
-0.1051107868552208,
-0.10202338546514511,
-0.35622215270996094,
0.12309295684099197,
-0.07639249414205551,
-0.1835116595029831,
-0.12214019149541855,
-0.0033208930399268866,
0.21725331246852875,
0.3686690926551819,
-0.5312312841415405,
0.5709850192070007,
-0.37275081872940063,
-0.3549559414386749,
0.4126414954662323,
0.2452113926410675,
0.5693625211715698,
0.07871577888727188,
-0.11434531211853027,
0.07738332450389862,
-1.0559934377670288,
0.12128447741270065,
0.01979517936706543,
0.5033599138259888,
-0.14019717276096344,
0.5347150564193726,
-0.025904394686222076,
0.5795019268989563,
-0.03666333481669426,
-0.6236972808837891,
0.18554146587848663,
-0.3148232698440552,
-0.15682636201381683,
0.04865635931491852,
0.49467045068740845,
0.039983682334423065,
0.2386188954114914,
-0.23919029533863068,
-0.22990818321704865,
-0.26866281032562256,
0.023778241127729416,
-0.3097534477710724,
-0.06011475995182991,
0.1192018985748291,
-0.17932111024856567,
0.27602440118789673,
-0.2958720922470093,
-0.36757513880729675,
-0.3263051211833954,
-0.43972593545913696,
0.003081739880144596,
-0.6456754803657532,
-0.32881417870521545,
0.06765105575323105,
0.1651555746793747,
0.3078182637691498,
0.1706913411617279,
-1.0596011877059937,
0.1905587762594223,
0.8181471228599548,
0.4875611364841461,
-0.2601618766784668,
-0.6604534983634949,
-0.13922585546970367,
0.09930069744586945,
-0.3430788516998291,
0.5910184979438782,
-0.519730269908905,
-0.1746523380279541,
0.07840876281261444,
0.09256032854318619,
-0.10248930752277374,
-0.8274158239364624,
0.11897172778844833,
-0.6450652480125427,
-0.13149458169937134,
-0.650436520576477,
-0.340921550989151,
-0.49779969453811646,
0.41930145025253296,
-0.6415891647338867,
0.6766589283943176,
-0.2002878040075302,
-0.5730002522468567,
0.3725185692310333,
-0.22303329408168793,
-0.3712170422077179,
-0.1172717958688736,
-0.23441427946090698,
-0.1922047734260559,
0.39084452390670776,
0.3474333584308624,
0.3973115384578705,
-0.36231786012649536,
0.2620905637741089,
-0.2008783221244812,
-0.1782863587141037,
0.3626645505428314,
-0.2176867127418518,
0.623175323009491,
-0.21315746009349823,
-0.20213691890239716,
0.112013079226017,
-0.48604175448417664,
-0.012220032513141632,
0.14032159745693207,
-0.25550734996795654,
-0.48252931237220764,
-0.026066185906529427,
-0.41013282537460327,
0.15541347861289978,
0.2526412904262543,
-0.4343588352203369,
0.09924093633890152,
-0.4089697599411011,
0.26225364208221436,
0.5557689666748047,
-0.0781845971941948,
0.8243321180343628,
-0.1085439994931221,
0.6140140891075134,
0.28218746185302734,
-0.18839623034000397,
-0.24681130051612854,
-0.13242307305335999,
-1.0700275897979736,
-0.366192102432251,
0.266011506319046,
0.5597044825553894,
-0.811906635761261,
0.45814770460128784,
-0.2823883295059204,
-0.5050303936004639,
-0.2384868562221527,
0.3836529850959778,
0.6513285636901855,
0.31409603357315063,
0.20753435790538788,
-0.33276990056037903,
-0.3092544972896576,
-1.200793981552124,
0.12025704234838486,
0.1011800467967987,
0.08112939447164536,
-0.09935609251260757,
0.47197529673576355,
0.062080346047878265,
0.9033389091491699,
-0.2167266458272934,
-0.45897746086120605,
-0.5323390960693359,
-0.250570148229599,
0.15117232501506805,
0.45938920974731445,
0.6302923560142517,
-0.6177374124526978,
-0.2631693184375763,
0.11219008266925812,
-0.5710280537605286,
-0.0718671977519989,
0.09181419759988785,
-0.01725652813911438,
0.37268534302711487,
0.5024563670158386,
-0.4044918715953827,
0.3843837082386017,
0.6559770703315735,
-0.18997256457805634,
0.6236811876296997,
-0.19472172856330872,
-0.046385638415813446,
-0.6509796380996704,
0.061724524945020676,
0.0322892889380455,
0.13932259380817413,
-0.9141927361488342,
0.06849468499422073,
0.028103765100240707,
-0.01675179973244667,
-0.5061970949172974,
0.5130534768104553,
-0.8882219791412354,
-0.2826891243457794,
-0.29659488797187805,
0.327703058719635,
-0.14659664034843445,
0.5465141534805298,
0.2190849334001541,
0.5680979490280151,
0.8222427368164062,
-0.7027458548545837,
-0.11141868680715561,
0.08708618581295013,
-0.3480326533317566,
0.25575965642929077,
-0.4697089195251465,
0.09112638235092163,
-0.23998385667800903,
0.147605299949646,
-0.8212656378746033,
0.03204352408647537,
-0.19950005412101746,
-0.24298176169395447,
0.5871701836585999,
-0.2935647964477539,
-0.383803129196167,
0.006392617244273424,
-0.08208569884300232,
0.7019343376159668,
0.39039796590805054,
-0.21618926525115967,
0.589655339717865,
0.7376344799995422,
-0.3917084038257599,
-0.6354377865791321,
-0.8388787508010864,
-0.028618216514587402,
-0.3381730616092682,
-0.5438193678855896,
0.2509038746356964,
0.1515703648328781,
-0.3318602740764618,
-0.006182851269841194,
0.045714035630226135,
-0.01967492513358593,
0.19318817555904388,
0.03937854245305061,
0.20230905711650848,
-0.42227330803871155,
0.04592083394527435,
0.03401699289679527,
-0.14892742037773132,
0.015843823552131653,
-0.1742069274187088,
0.9360916018486023,
-0.13815994560718536,
-0.4306866228580475,
-0.1344575434923172,
0.3724876344203949,
0.6813725233078003,
-0.6363273859024048,
0.9080840349197388,
0.2650737464427948,
-0.47478893399238586,
-0.3485279977321625,
-0.731060802936554,
-0.11464016884565353,
-0.42612889409065247,
0.7831600308418274,
-0.4281482994556427,
-1.2528753280639648,
1.1561305522918701,
0.10447223484516144,
-0.00720442458987236,
0.3573390245437622,
0.7118564248085022,
0.26106372475624084,
0.725590705871582,
0.9755999445915222,
-0.176155224442482,
0.32131484150886536,
-0.270854651927948,
0.41145437955856323,
-0.9948392510414124,
-0.4361092150211334,
-0.5865249037742615,
-0.29609012603759766,
-0.3564230799674988,
-0.6278433799743652,
0.5235428810119629,
0.30627742409706116,
-0.19107426702976227,
0.01768474653363228,
-0.15919001400470734,
0.7045907974243164,
0.32629090547561646,
-0.17021015286445618,
0.15124905109405518,
0.15083129703998566,
-0.34705933928489685,
-0.3726561665534973,
-0.9011576771736145,
-0.38422125577926636,
0.8170909285545349,
0.5420815348625183,
0.7082180976867676,
0.09243990480899811,
0.6237231492996216,
-0.2230757176876068,
0.20110709965229034,
-0.7448281645774841,
0.6599828004837036,
-0.33817258477211,
-0.6993830800056458,
-0.5817236304283142,
-0.37395790219306946,
-0.747186005115509,
0.3208102583885193,
-0.11933322250843048,
-0.9162667989730835,
0.14145568013191223,
0.08401136845350266,
-0.2271500527858734,
0.581064760684967,
-0.43581119179725647,
0.6602163910865784,
-0.44526609778404236,
-0.10633883625268936,
-0.1437496393918991,
-0.34549999237060547,
0.5655242204666138,
-0.3588991165161133,
0.27507779002189636,
-0.29953521490097046,
-0.1262759119272232,
0.7312002778053284,
-0.13634823262691498,
1.0894477367401123,
-0.15447615087032318,
-0.45067787170410156,
0.1390385925769806,
0.31528979539871216,
0.043328907340765,
-0.109329953789711,
0.011334097944200039,
0.29236382246017456,
-0.24451397359371185,
-0.5750925540924072,
-0.49713030457496643,
0.8368898630142212,
-0.7069746255874634,
-0.7048928737640381,
-0.20313622057437897,
-0.6940631866455078,
-0.5271236300468445,
0.31570738554000854,
0.3418309986591339,
0.5524712204933167,
-0.2891497015953064,
0.11194302141666412,
1.1123853921890259,
-0.49238792061805725,
0.428550124168396,
0.5432214140892029,
-0.5241573452949524,
-0.32854777574539185,
0.8109086751937866,
0.3248042166233063,
0.40672826766967773,
0.36073625087738037,
-0.025494735687971115,
-0.24185895919799805,
-1.0243372917175293,
-0.14859506487846375,
0.6457547545433044,
-0.87156742811203,
-0.047735732048749924,
-0.3365626633167267,
-0.16177009046077728,
-0.4565553665161133,
-0.32575929164886475,
-0.5773652195930481,
-0.19939982891082764,
-0.22455041110515594,
-0.09185318648815155,
-0.24234642088413239,
0.7186490297317505,
0.06227273866534233,
0.2578427195549011,
-1.0379705429077148,
-0.17554280161857605,
-0.0019201182294636965,
0.09344231337308884,
0.29165521264076233,
-0.6540379524230957,
-0.3678531050682068,
-0.0009952130494639277,
-0.007159506902098656,
-0.4726236164569855,
0.4800054728984833,
0.06425314396619797,
0.8626783490180969,
0.4717063903808594,
-0.11233274638652802,
0.6642187833786011,
-0.39987823367118835,
0.8842598795890808,
0.26033124327659607,
-1.0157878398895264,
0.28466278314590454,
-0.3729974627494812,
0.7377213835716248,
0.3703255355358124,
0.44159558415412903,
-0.5469279289245605,
-0.4690861999988556,
-0.21233147382736206,
-0.9085184335708618,
0.5846421718597412,
-0.24805770814418793,
0.1367766261100769,
0.09980043023824692,
0.38171836733818054,
0.2187480479478836,
-0.16209237277507782,
-0.6713676452636719,
-0.3191775381565094,
0.27840471267700195,
0.2806689143180847,
-0.42437314987182617,
-0.5313081741333008,
-0.3474370539188385,
-0.2840099334716797,
0.6622076034545898,
-0.15980926156044006,
0.0838494524359703,
0.052739840000867844,
-0.22588971257209778,
-0.0303391944617033,
0.41869470477104187,
0.8784070611000061,
0.9896572232246399,
0.25332143902778625,
0.1930643618106842,
0.4297454059123993,
-0.18671630322933197,
0.17885364592075348,
-0.3599071800708771,
-0.2129056304693222,
-0.28168827295303345,
0.845221757888794,
0.741542637348175,
0.3303309381008148,
-0.5744662284851074,
0.13601531088352203,
0.04476264864206314,
-0.1874617636203766,
-0.362672358751297,
-0.0713297501206398,
0.28694432973861694,
0.13336221873760223,
0.46112456917762756,
-0.18555454909801483,
-0.297275185585022,
-0.9109355211257935,
0.07414150983095169,
0.43598073720932007,
-0.44140952825546265,
-0.5714784264564514,
0.1841527819633484,
0.1698327213525772,
-0.005287550389766693,
0.7256181240081787,
-0.01660153456032276,
-1.1155216693878174,
0.5515547394752502,
0.6821844577789307,
0.6884356737136841,
-0.26669055223464966,
0.06817609816789627,
0.23937031626701355,
0.5938808917999268,
0.13805384933948517,
0.014768329448997974,
0.20618486404418945,
-1.0231225490570068,
-0.6705988049507141,
-0.6233165264129639,
-0.06523188203573227,
0.14468272030353546,
-0.6748722195625305,
0.09741710871458054,
-0.35694560408592224,
-0.12335388362407684,
-0.27790746092796326,
-0.03938375785946846,
-0.5437425374984741,
0.20185205340385437,
0.527837336063385,
0.8810169696807861,
-0.9252385497093201,
0.910193681716919,
0.8371112942695618,
0.07977742701768875,
-0.8184304237365723,
0.0586397685110569,
0.28116661310195923,
-0.7882701754570007,
0.6378212571144104,
-0.06833446770906448,
-0.08073627948760986,
-0.21515296399593353,
-0.28081318736076355,
-0.9266902804374695,
1.0179094076156616,
0.5190868377685547,
-0.4895517826080322,
-0.04866063967347145,
0.5302570462226868,
0.5657733678817749,
-0.5353642106056213,
-0.04664120823144913,
0.8427717089653015,
0.2743642330169678,
-0.0640917420387268,
-1.2548631429672241,
0.0732715055346489,
-0.03857289254665375,
0.03438789024949074,
0.4262081980705261,
-0.6047708988189697,
0.973302960395813,
-0.21597285568714142,
-0.298751562833786,
-0.1773623377084732,
0.512903094291687,
0.27124103903770447,
0.08237367868423462,
0.4910929203033447,
0.6707909107208252,
0.6890943050384521,
-0.25220686197280884,
0.7138258814811707,
-0.2313545197248459,
0.26379722356796265,
0.9290959239006042,
-0.2963695824146271,
0.8025397658348083,
0.503531277179718,
0.1185842975974083,
0.19082170724868774,
0.45204734802246094,
0.40534377098083496,
0.46880725026130676,
0.25025925040245056,
-0.30816227197647095,
-0.49040132761001587,
-0.23968547582626343,
-0.18491677939891815,
0.5979268550872803,
0.6029384136199951,
-0.1458536982536316,
-0.21499596536159515,
0.20257164537906647,
0.3046172261238098,
0.041865501552820206,
-0.4834944009780884,
0.652116596698761,
0.09721233695745468,
-0.7654421329498291,
0.7102540135383606,
0.030949335545301437,
0.6393346786499023,
-0.6682832837104797,
0.2735365927219391,
-0.4686144292354584,
0.23729126155376434,
-0.1861308515071869,
-0.746030867099762,
0.2667081952095032,
-0.15173590183258057,
-0.2863059937953949,
-0.15713493525981903,
0.656779944896698,
-0.6802807450294495,
-0.20801496505737305,
0.5487513542175293,
0.6525864601135254,
0.004739043768495321,
0.05907225236296654,
-0.48500198125839233,
0.4530995190143585,
0.23689720034599304,
-0.19567206501960754,
0.6964895725250244,
0.6841064691543579,
-0.017216501757502556,
0.8101964592933655,
0.4797334671020508,
0.15829479694366455,
0.21668577194213867,
-0.10280722379684448,
0.9007989168167114,
-0.6758955121040344,
-0.34672942757606506,
-0.7666376829147339,
0.5478507280349731,
0.21294716000556946,
-0.30413731932640076,
0.711422324180603,
0.5217987298965454,
1.1086444854736328,
-0.10463520139455795,
0.6998183727264404,
-0.02871422842144966,
0.34792637825012207,
-0.8935526609420776,
0.8850739598274231,
-0.6369960904121399,
0.5430997014045715,
0.016452448442578316,
-1.0052374601364136,
-0.39451056718826294,
0.09125839173793793,
-0.5370336771011353,
0.0636218786239624,
0.8805361390113831,
0.765993058681488,
-0.0040631648153066635,
-0.3776368200778961,
0.7292367219924927,
0.34257811307907104,
0.2793769836425781,
0.5609419941902161,
0.7338486313819885,
0.08164104074239731,
0.3342615067958832,
-0.6223885416984558,
-0.3358899652957916,
0.12621469795703888,
-0.6612597107887268,
-1.141297459602356,
-0.7607083320617676,
-0.23061592876911163,
-0.08098429441452026,
-0.2624872326850891,
0.5002230405807495,
0.6353530287742615,
-0.789387047290802,
-0.4931705892086029,
0.4640214741230011,
0.10061079263687134,
0.17133167386054993,
-0.1722496747970581,
0.2268829345703125,
-0.19366830587387085,
-0.5494012236595154,
0.518494188785553,
0.403800904750824,
-0.025321628898382187,
-0.5816076397895813,
-0.08644188940525055,
-0.18803322315216064,
-0.10480231791734695,
0.4939686059951782,
0.39865362644195557,
-0.9217644333839417,
-0.23255206644535065,
0.07453954964876175,
-0.09389472007751465,
-0.016391534358263016,
1.1017626523971558,
-0.41720524430274963,
0.1266287863254547,
0.5086668729782104,
0.5239571928977966,
0.2186734676361084,
-0.15190590918064117,
0.7361668944358826,
-0.6695201396942139,
0.2085537165403366,
0.2683785557746887,
0.5309072732925415,
0.364545077085495,
-0.08092546463012695,
0.1718580722808838,
0.16591942310333252,
-0.582603931427002,
-0.7375813126564026,
0.232899472117424,
-0.866166889667511,
-0.21508349478244781,
0.9680840969085693,
-0.2550393044948578,
-0.4390837550163269,
-0.12604005634784698,
0.05095577985048294,
0.01940803974866867,
-0.06242884695529938,
0.4908367693424225,
0.9423174262046814,
-0.08894705027341843,
-0.2745167016983032,
-0.3443485498428345,
0.26407620310783386,
0.6649105548858643,
-0.5284307599067688,
0.35503435134887695,
0.4507736265659332,
0.5604254007339478,
0.3913368582725525,
0.6606056690216064,
-0.19236020743846893,
0.06929847598075867,
-0.07264872640371323,
0.20160584151744843,
0.14399948716163635,
-0.5097842812538147,
-0.5984185338020325,
0.3154836595058441,
0.21433858573436737,
0.3136462867259979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14690v1
|
UFO: a Unified and Flexible Framework for Evaluating Factuality of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T16:45:32 | 2024-02-22T16:45:32 |
Zhaoheng Huang, Zhicheng Dou, Yutao Zhu, Ji-rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) may generate text that lacks consistency with
human knowledge, leading to factual inaccuracies or \textit{hallucination}.
Existing research for evaluating the factuality of LLMs involves extracting
fact claims using an LLM and verifying them against a predefined fact source.
However, these evaluation metrics are task-specific, and not scalable, and the
substitutability of fact sources in different tasks is under-explored. To
address these challenges, we categorize four available fact sources:
human-written evidence, reference documents, search engine results, and LLM
knowledge, along with five text generation tasks containing six representative
datasets. Then, we propose \texttt{UFO}, an LLM-based unified and flexible
evaluation framework to verify facts against plug-and-play fact sources. We
implement five evaluation scenarios based on this framework. Experimental
results show that for most QA tasks, human-written evidence and reference
documents are crucial, and they can substitute for each other in
retrieval-augmented QA tasks. In news fact generation tasks, search engine
results and LLM knowledge are essential. Our dataset and code are available at
\url{https://github.com/WaldenRUC/UFO}.
|
[
-0.09578078240156174,
-0.9961807131767273,
0.9869990944862366,
0.08974376320838928,
-0.08836737275123596,
-0.0824587270617485,
-0.3888475000858307,
-0.23632994294166565,
-0.041230712085962296,
0.5695589780807495,
-0.43932226300239563,
-0.5806578993797302,
-0.26381510496139526,
0.27981337904930115,
-0.5436103940010071,
0.975066602230072,
0.329520046710968,
-0.1983499675989151,
-0.6246271133422852,
-0.14290781319141388,
-0.14416785538196564,
-0.4976598918437958,
-0.15593674778938293,
-0.11428721994161606,
0.5857484936714172,
0.49132755398750305,
0.8519654273986816,
0.6348032355308533,
0.6121460199356079,
0.3458070456981659,
0.06959481537342072,
0.4923649728298187,
-0.537503182888031,
-0.01678304746747017,
-0.40095216035842896,
-0.33430367708206177,
-0.36569589376449585,
0.007048377767205238,
0.8023685216903687,
0.6785840392112732,
-0.2926047444343567,
0.2835416793823242,
-0.19589661061763763,
0.5140611529350281,
-0.615577757358551,
-0.052388641983270645,
-0.7098080515861511,
-0.0462777279317379,
-0.23815743625164032,
-0.027425866574048996,
-0.4448293149471283,
-0.5133057236671448,
0.06009303405880928,
-0.5483272075653076,
0.3554318845272064,
0.2594406008720398,
0.8278316855430603,
0.3030843734741211,
-0.6110925078392029,
-0.414540559053421,
-0.816713809967041,
0.6650542616844177,
-0.9302139282226562,
0.7227522730827332,
0.2017524689435959,
0.06220342963933945,
-0.37806060910224915,
-0.7064788937568665,
-0.9716235995292664,
-0.7407547831535339,
-0.1463228464126587,
-0.07034893333911896,
-0.027518192306160927,
-0.11047057807445526,
0.4056331515312195,
0.4525318741798401,
-0.598458468914032,
-0.015207309275865555,
-0.26956382393836975,
-0.28172531723976135,
0.5836806297302246,
0.16561678051948547,
0.4103284180164337,
-0.4562792181968689,
-0.3252912163734436,
0.16065038740634918,
-0.9051720499992371,
-0.12412601709365845,
0.3373960554599762,
0.28464096784591675,
-0.09761662781238556,
0.8430007100105286,
-0.28757983446121216,
0.5403740406036377,
-0.05624378100037575,
-0.44405117630958557,
0.2645130455493927,
-0.4757016897201538,
-0.3284984827041626,
-0.2639979124069214,
0.975949764251709,
0.16761265695095062,
-0.3246367871761322,
-0.542786717414856,
-0.13512128591537476,
-0.042817700654268265,
0.44007134437561035,
-0.6711705327033997,
0.21339568495750427,
0.32752320170402527,
-0.18398672342300415,
-0.19735918939113617,
0.39754587411880493,
-0.7904635071754456,
-0.46206194162368774,
-0.3420344293117523,
0.33875492215156555,
-0.21305112540721893,
-0.3658279478549957,
0.09577670693397522,
0.017244908958673477,
0.06874985247850418,
0.26251959800720215,
-0.546658992767334,
0.06375563889741898,
0.7090397477149963,
0.6701080203056335,
-0.3139500617980957,
-0.38580986857414246,
-0.7035439014434814,
-0.042935486882925034,
-0.36823707818984985,
0.887703001499176,
-0.3134365975856781,
-0.3084169626235962,
0.0883273109793663,
-0.06994813680648804,
0.07996251434087753,
-0.4503405690193176,
0.9777885675430298,
-0.5259932279586792,
0.36997923254966736,
-0.5015120506286621,
-0.5664603114128113,
-0.25137683749198914,
0.3612953722476959,
-0.7831767201423645,
1.1333887577056885,
0.09881990402936935,
-0.7115556597709656,
0.3806115388870239,
-0.6849682927131653,
-0.5248326063156128,
0.14894789457321167,
-0.41629350185394287,
-0.44574394822120667,
0.08125479519367218,
-0.09507141262292862,
0.5542982816696167,
-0.6741024851799011,
0.6903293132781982,
-0.2904651463031769,
-0.2954673767089844,
0.3955870568752289,
-0.4806118607521057,
0.6827213764190674,
0.2245939075946808,
-0.5507452487945557,
0.16210420429706573,
-1.0497270822525024,
-0.19755281507968903,
0.005855375435203314,
-0.8526562452316284,
-0.1617618203163147,
0.24944759905338287,
0.12628154456615448,
-0.04419475421309471,
0.09733741730451584,
-0.7359793186187744,
0.15875095129013062,
-0.1572572886943817,
0.05669299513101578,
0.4317488372325897,
-0.14833110570907593,
0.034264594316482544,
-0.27372676134109497,
0.24126549065113068,
0.01578608714044094,
0.06020098179578781,
-0.061813849955797195,
-0.2600770592689514,
-1.024894118309021,
-0.22792191803455353,
0.15701308846473694,
0.4016190767288208,
-0.7231961488723755,
0.6481978297233582,
-0.45856747031211853,
-0.5092033743858337,
-0.1567228138446808,
0.2584681808948517,
0.4491766095161438,
0.6141268014907837,
0.1803196668624878,
0.23808160424232483,
-0.7528571486473083,
-0.8082953095436096,
-0.2797720432281494,
-0.34711214900016785,
-0.09447738528251648,
0.1026589423418045,
0.4431970417499542,
-0.5502234697341919,
1.139819860458374,
-0.2544528543949127,
-0.18612432479858398,
-0.16982845962047577,
0.29497572779655457,
0.2283967137336731,
0.2011469155550003,
0.41044747829437256,
-0.9324890971183777,
-0.0068285162560641766,
0.14428195357322693,
-0.9796818494796753,
-0.03032369166612625,
-0.22931627929210663,
0.2538263201713562,
0.4601083993911743,
0.43217822909355164,
-0.6698272824287415,
0.29653942584991455,
0.528400182723999,
-0.6216943860054016,
0.7651435732841492,
-0.059720832854509354,
0.36575403809547424,
-0.9613251090049744,
0.3641345798969269,
-0.012821941636502743,
-0.39243918657302856,
-0.4379950165748596,
0.23122398555278778,
-0.020852020010352135,
0.24284860491752625,
-0.35967934131622314,
0.4129103422164917,
-0.37143850326538086,
-0.11481613665819168,
-0.24847449362277985,
0.20045194029808044,
0.024650614708662033,
0.32735300064086914,
-0.06297969818115234,
0.7384702563285828,
0.27604737877845764,
-0.7883853316307068,
0.5522102117538452,
0.06468979269266129,
-0.7100980281829834,
0.4262559711933136,
-0.4526611268520355,
0.17905224859714508,
-0.022538062185049057,
-0.03152991458773613,
-0.6781602501869202,
-0.3282615840435028,
0.1072486862540245,
-0.21825166046619415,
-0.16631318628787994,
0.18630169332027435,
-0.6709367036819458,
-0.2217423915863037,
-0.18156491219997406,
0.07164506614208221,
0.32545238733291626,
-0.6012040972709656,
0.8884732127189636,
0.3579804003238678,
-0.011695082299411297,
-0.7587271332740784,
-0.44843119382858276,
0.3103736340999603,
-0.06307915598154068,
-0.47563600540161133,
0.07920730113983154,
-0.34004533290863037,
-0.4788866937160492,
0.25451621413230896,
-0.15170890092849731,
0.03137289732694626,
0.1545640528202057,
0.39736661314964294,
0.2877461612224579,
-0.5372869372367859,
0.05863932520151138,
-0.15881666541099548,
0.273515522480011,
0.1937502920627594,
-0.08081047981977463,
0.10575103014707565,
-0.34476354718208313,
-0.5886932611465454,
-0.17664343118667603,
0.08915245532989502,
0.7641645073890686,
0.11322058737277985,
0.6052606701850891,
0.5931299924850464,
-0.3636450171470642,
-0.32681137323379517,
-1.0186294317245483,
0.08871584385633469,
-0.417341411113739,
0.5871821641921997,
-0.28234708309173584,
-0.9268844723701477,
0.4260953962802887,
-0.07037919014692307,
0.2326810359954834,
0.6516733765602112,
0.7148343324661255,
0.1560286283493042,
0.4280027151107788,
0.6251833438873291,
0.17259910702705383,
-0.07127077877521515,
-0.007378502748906612,
0.1791025549173355,
-0.5962324738502502,
-0.5070911049842834,
-0.5973595380783081,
0.3246108591556549,
-0.22606806457042694,
-0.544302761554718,
0.34781384468078613,
-0.04412810504436493,
0.034982830286026,
0.11468213051557541,
0.032837312668561935,
0.5840861797332764,
0.3692502975463867,
-0.09238415956497192,
0.683438777923584,
-0.06591208279132843,
-0.2850319445133209,
0.249031662940979,
-0.6505232453346252,
-0.683354914188385,
1.2208890914916992,
0.25399625301361084,
0.4586706757545471,
0.3526967465877533,
0.12998256087303162,
0.674416184425354,
0.6525700688362122,
-0.783257782459259,
0.6231362819671631,
-0.09612062573432922,
-0.7621331214904785,
-0.4995931386947632,
-0.6045380234718323,
-0.627179741859436,
0.27555975317955017,
-0.5832727551460266,
-0.510903537273407,
0.10757292807102203,
-0.04275982826948166,
-0.4209248423576355,
0.38318514823913574,
-0.47266846895217896,
0.6152940988540649,
-0.2107096016407013,
-0.3692827820777893,
-0.22086049616336823,
-0.23624205589294434,
0.6216631531715393,
-0.3727777600288391,
0.446689635515213,
-0.15992961823940277,
0.07949497550725937,
0.5444133281707764,
-0.3811704218387604,
0.7481473684310913,
0.14089417457580566,
-0.3880973756313324,
0.3530214726924896,
0.11403153091669083,
0.39235353469848633,
0.36222177743911743,
-0.3179083466529846,
0.4402455687522888,
-0.12145407497882843,
0.006337818223983049,
-0.6771536469459534,
0.6806780099868774,
-0.6896546483039856,
-0.7189996838569641,
-0.4983222782611847,
-0.6220231652259827,
-0.28373849391937256,
0.44949105381965637,
0.23320092260837555,
0.4536527395248413,
-0.7538482546806335,
0.400389701128006,
0.5543699860572815,
-0.07310169190168381,
0.17343640327453613,
0.8795607089996338,
-0.411933958530426,
-0.24112644791603088,
0.9377589225769043,
-0.15432722866535187,
-0.0762513056397438,
0.4999067485332489,
0.3563014268875122,
-0.4857441186904907,
-0.6286216378211975,
-0.5556595921516418,
0.1729966253042221,
-0.7056697607040405,
-0.26299625635147095,
-0.6139028668403625,
-0.13930608332157135,
-0.36724746227264404,
0.22633425891399384,
-0.44170087575912476,
-0.19777272641658783,
-0.09502393007278442,
-0.2198013812303543,
0.20424750447273254,
1.1334149837493896,
-0.16976843774318695,
0.021472590044140816,
-0.7917036414146423,
0.6947439908981323,
0.3698553144931793,
0.451365202665329,
-0.260227769613266,
-0.44171929359436035,
-0.34483033418655396,
0.09955843538045883,
-0.0840446949005127,
-0.5779557228088379,
-0.10865896195173264,
0.08203340321779251,
0.573819637298584,
0.5713458061218262,
0.13248595595359802,
0.37833020091056824,
-0.5452267527580261,
0.8253757357597351,
0.17064395546913147,
-1.114079475402832,
0.1717308908700943,
-0.3646886944770813,
-0.21043828129768372,
0.4352100193500519,
0.2042863517999649,
-0.5101089477539062,
-0.37084853649139404,
-0.5141658782958984,
-0.5873227119445801,
0.6475871801376343,
0.29861199855804443,
-0.017185309901833534,
0.06189434602856636,
0.5429593324661255,
0.30349647998809814,
0.1497253030538559,
-0.8842795491218567,
-0.24452653527259827,
-0.26366984844207764,
-0.23353496193885803,
-0.06848244369029999,
-0.5444488525390625,
-0.25324684381484985,
0.01065264455974102,
0.6692780256271362,
-0.19062305986881256,
-0.0772004947066307,
0.34275323152542114,
-0.21259517967700958,
-0.1793917566537857,
0.46201273798942566,
0.6673502326011658,
1.0042498111724854,
-0.3060196340084076,
0.2783699333667755,
0.10125742107629776,
-0.5357180237770081,
0.20510825514793396,
-0.0794680118560791,
-0.4329216182231903,
0.11646337807178497,
0.5320516228675842,
0.618941068649292,
0.292836993932724,
-0.9530258178710938,
0.5547038316726685,
-0.033409155905246735,
-0.2671414613723755,
-0.31064191460609436,
0.2645595669746399,
0.07620026171207428,
0.20172254741191864,
0.5297234654426575,
-0.04353439435362816,
0.24522769451141357,
-0.578923225402832,
0.3295964300632477,
0.4354424476623535,
0.025437338277697563,
-0.4865837097167969,
0.5173546075820923,
0.3254827558994293,
-0.14249487221240997,
0.5666998624801636,
-0.3307044208049774,
-0.3182510733604431,
0.4983829855918884,
0.4563118517398834,
0.8753029704093933,
-0.06066501513123512,
0.4636123478412628,
0.3339332342147827,
0.5355836749076843,
-0.20056694746017456,
0.18060806393623352,
0.19317947328090668,
-0.8016476035118103,
-0.6039072871208191,
-0.6967938542366028,
-0.5684764981269836,
0.6085973381996155,
-0.4262802004814148,
0.2106332629919052,
-0.4834667444229126,
0.03402078151702881,
0.024733224883675575,
-0.0988740399479866,
-0.6216617822647095,
0.28757697343826294,
0.0869675874710083,
0.7502520084381104,
-0.7012895941734314,
0.6718445420265198,
0.7784457206726074,
-0.36764803528785706,
-0.7230677604675293,
0.259858638048172,
0.1835947483778,
-0.4876125454902649,
0.7040793895721436,
-0.040419694036245346,
-0.41743701696395874,
-0.3285055458545685,
-0.47964563965797424,
-0.8451200723648071,
0.8182312250137329,
0.6704819798469543,
-0.6025887727737427,
0.03191285952925682,
0.41996514797210693,
0.44299277663230896,
-0.37909579277038574,
0.1826389729976654,
0.48039379715919495,
0.6775071620941162,
0.10138855129480362,
-0.8335766196250916,
0.3572246730327606,
-0.2344103902578354,
-0.13525515794754028,
-0.3448609709739685,
-0.611648440361023,
0.6873979568481445,
-0.4894692003726959,
-0.4820067882537842,
0.128568634390831,
0.9068841338157654,
0.2861366271972656,
0.26699572801589966,
0.6758999824523926,
0.493952214717865,
0.9292263388633728,
0.003875512396916747,
0.9246012568473816,
-0.03288137912750244,
0.4188208281993866,
0.9934755563735962,
-0.3246539235115051,
0.7633847594261169,
0.3083338439464569,
-0.26256486773490906,
0.6781440377235413,
0.2431701421737671,
-0.18395797908306122,
0.03207831829786301,
0.05928707495331764,
-0.05717300996184349,
-0.3659749925136566,
-0.12604518234729767,
-0.13606703281402588,
0.6514229774475098,
0.20813237130641937,
0.11480835825204849,
-0.2530093789100647,
-0.2032710462808609,
0.11614862829446793,
0.18572676181793213,
-0.011482798494398594,
0.5877720713615417,
-0.1769811064004898,
-0.7907013297080994,
0.5866166949272156,
0.1374645233154297,
0.6103456616401672,
-0.6322492957115173,
-0.14644509553909302,
-0.2602134943008423,
0.056176990270614624,
-0.4547141492366791,
-0.5703746676445007,
0.3265734612941742,
0.32544827461242676,
-0.42941349744796753,
0.2810441255569458,
0.4272348880767822,
-0.4028608500957489,
-0.7035272717475891,
-0.05429953709244728,
0.504147469997406,
0.08848561346530914,
-0.12482753396034241,
-0.47020649909973145,
0.2797526717185974,
0.1123456284403801,
-0.44797149300575256,
0.06525170803070068,
0.6090922355651855,
0.10742897540330887,
0.6852099895477295,
0.9850584864616394,
0.11516495794057846,
-0.08117902278900146,
0.04271194711327553,
0.816277027130127,
-0.7402963042259216,
-0.3199009895324707,
-0.8960819840431213,
0.487076073884964,
0.003991329576820135,
-0.2359274923801422,
1.036264181137085,
0.7925944328308105,
0.5830349326133728,
-0.08456146717071533,
0.9583227038383484,
-0.22143308818340302,
0.6732744574546814,
-0.7219910025596619,
0.7460366487503052,
-0.609820544719696,
0.4413400888442993,
-0.2455018162727356,
-0.9033251404762268,
-0.22985346615314484,
0.42674946784973145,
0.17744554579257965,
-0.06941476464271545,
0.9173310995101929,
0.6910584568977356,
-0.2296300232410431,
0.05792728811502457,
0.4265294671058655,
0.481434166431427,
0.36887305974960327,
0.09922812879085541,
0.9845044612884521,
-0.2213875651359558,
0.5564252734184265,
0.027326812967658043,
-0.09731089323759079,
-0.3160325288772583,
-1.2301348447799683,
-0.9658648371696472,
-0.7207539081573486,
-0.45948442816734314,
-0.42924734950065613,
-0.11632978171110153,
0.7818784713745117,
0.6357923150062561,
-0.7856960892677307,
-0.22707192599773407,
0.017259256914258003,
0.5117931962013245,
-0.06231428310275078,
-0.2563658654689789,
0.5810161828994751,
-0.3320227563381195,
-0.6734604239463806,
0.6520225405693054,
0.2839854657649994,
-0.18222980201244354,
-0.517742395401001,
-0.1385614424943924,
-0.114494688808918,
0.1671174317598343,
0.6408711075782776,
0.38161003589630127,
-1.007634162902832,
-0.3315148949623108,
-0.008600388653576374,
-0.12094082683324814,
-0.15216824412345886,
0.958445131778717,
-0.6984540224075317,
0.16263513267040253,
0.24524396657943726,
0.7782204747200012,
-0.037363339215517044,
-0.011972269974648952,
0.48566144704818726,
-0.6822773218154907,
0.07036048173904419,
0.0044947522692382336,
0.3707355856895447,
0.4518057405948639,
-0.6119757294654846,
0.5349717736244202,
0.4673812687397003,
-0.4783329367637634,
-1.0346641540527344,
0.15960554778575897,
-1.0823969841003418,
-0.2967407703399658,
1.4434239864349365,
-0.23991471529006958,
-0.21134310960769653,
-0.319777250289917,
0.023201627656817436,
0.07839588075876236,
-0.2676909863948822,
1.023712158203125,
0.6114506125450134,
0.10831725597381592,
0.19597318768501282,
-0.3617360591888428,
0.5895286798477173,
0.19169139862060547,
-1.07817542552948,
0.36220893263816833,
0.8247919678688049,
0.546997606754303,
0.4324006140232086,
0.5202693939208984,
0.01595797948539257,
0.31289517879486084,
-0.1051207110285759,
0.20357584953308105,
-0.44200563430786133,
-0.43581581115722656,
0.059648547321558,
0.22604796290397644,
0.031034061685204506,
0.22335439920425415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14895v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14895v1
|
Data Augmentation is Dead, Long Live Data Augmentation
| 2024-02-22T16:42:37 | 2024-02-22T16:42:37 |
Frédéric Piedboeuf, Philippe Langlais
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Textual data augmentation (DA) is a prolific field of study where novel
techniques to create artificial data are regularly proposed, and that has
demonstrated great efficiency on small data settings, at least for text
classification tasks. In this paper, we challenge those results, showing that
classical data augmentation is simply a way of performing better fine-tuning,
and that spending more time fine-tuning before applying data augmentation
negates its effect. This is a significant contribution as it answers several
questions that were left open in recent years, namely~: which DA technique
performs best (all of them as long as they generate data close enough to the
training set as to not impair training) and why did DA show positive results
(facilitates training of network). We furthermore show that zero and few-shot
data generation via conversational agents such as ChatGPT or LLama2 can
increase performances, concluding that this form of data augmentation does
still work, even if classical methods do not.
|
[
-0.4361709952354431,
-1.192556381225586,
0.4749618470668793,
-0.17924031615257263,
-0.325797438621521,
0.12015441060066223,
-0.2871696352958679,
-0.9003956913948059,
0.1294427067041397,
0.36469265818595886,
-0.5785265564918518,
-0.1584702432155609,
-0.26986417174339294,
0.30328568816185,
-0.5170271992683411,
1.1931004524230957,
0.2845883071422577,
-0.1871667355298996,
-0.5193666815757751,
-0.09863617271184921,
-0.5203028917312622,
-0.5852006673812866,
-0.97553551197052,
-0.5131293535232544,
0.47772717475891113,
0.4841735064983368,
0.933606743812561,
0.8819661736488342,
0.47288310527801514,
0.3279239535331726,
-0.17380079627037048,
0.814013659954071,
-0.6632634997367859,
0.2548407018184662,
0.30705979466438293,
-0.6088177561759949,
-0.3805481493473053,
-0.011902505531907082,
0.5084580779075623,
0.9521598815917969,
0.29975995421409607,
-0.29534268379211426,
0.029175719246268272,
1.076168417930603,
-0.45631152391433716,
-0.025029441341757774,
-0.5415055751800537,
-0.11714445054531097,
-0.23869772255420685,
-0.48651382327079773,
-0.35080990195274353,
-0.4734340012073517,
0.09839364141225815,
-0.6635010242462158,
0.1968235969543457,
-0.1313796490430832,
0.7992128133773804,
0.5925571918487549,
-0.42211413383483887,
-0.2989664375782013,
-1.1029998064041138,
0.6549323797225952,
-0.6924682259559631,
-0.061795782297849655,
0.4304664134979248,
0.42525652050971985,
-0.2611565589904785,
-0.6445949077606201,
-0.8775270581245422,
-0.2483266443014145,
0.052414290606975555,
0.00831618718802929,
-0.17831087112426758,
0.15230615437030792,
0.5085788369178772,
0.7192788124084473,
-0.25047141313552856,
0.3386043310165405,
-0.5640028715133667,
0.08326397091150284,
0.8649835586547852,
0.15923605859279633,
0.07554732263088226,
0.11483579874038696,
-0.19171740114688873,
-0.13460540771484375,
-0.6794000267982483,
-0.19658732414245605,
0.5560463070869446,
0.1381174623966217,
0.05682417377829552,
0.6911270022392273,
-0.47909605503082275,
0.7497886419296265,
0.21166262030601501,
-0.050696961581707,
0.28546372056007385,
-0.31224706768989563,
-0.2208995670080185,
0.1922582983970642,
0.7629567980766296,
0.4225175678730011,
0.37071678042411804,
-0.2486041784286499,
-0.0712762251496315,
0.3583560585975647,
0.18618503212928772,
-0.8001740574836731,
-0.1807730495929718,
0.3108603060245514,
-0.03711099177598953,
-0.5421894788742065,
-0.06340229511260986,
-0.4394320547580719,
-0.406459242105484,
-0.34835246205329895,
0.2661704421043396,
-0.47270718216896057,
0.0876261293888092,
0.14671632647514343,
-0.04723760858178139,
0.16454413533210754,
0.6707069873809814,
-0.967667818069458,
0.28617703914642334,
0.8116633892059326,
0.7524324655532837,
-0.13447904586791992,
-0.06149881333112717,
-0.47004619240760803,
-0.17045575380325317,
-0.8259149193763733,
1.0044599771499634,
-0.549009382724762,
-0.33757492899894714,
-0.15275083482265472,
0.008631838485598564,
0.19550186395645142,
-0.5004470944404602,
0.5810688138008118,
-0.5648679733276367,
0.5143747925758362,
-0.15963566303253174,
-0.8041264414787292,
-0.14475984871387482,
0.16177445650100708,
-0.6254205703735352,
1.0620672702789307,
-0.08950776606798172,
-0.6864109039306641,
0.6683577299118042,
-0.592831015586853,
-0.5603581666946411,
-0.0013941405341029167,
-0.07303299009799957,
-0.6462823748588562,
-0.004953546915203333,
0.2099352329969406,
0.475765585899353,
-0.13941089808940887,
-0.07896120101213455,
-0.3488714098930359,
-0.5940500497817993,
0.44919559359550476,
-0.721663236618042,
0.3699473738670349,
0.19554148614406586,
-0.2830590009689331,
-0.5354803204536438,
-0.8573253750801086,
-0.06923393160104752,
-0.09955128282308578,
-0.4197559952735901,
-0.4465055465698242,
0.1596706062555313,
-0.19629095494747162,
-0.037687577307224274,
-0.00391036830842495,
-0.7451439499855042,
0.3991052508354187,
-0.8258060216903687,
0.23102037608623505,
0.6675359010696411,
0.03017980232834816,
0.5317559242248535,
-0.7891197204589844,
0.33179035782814026,
0.0008343793451786041,
-0.3345571756362915,
-0.539620041847229,
-0.4381970763206482,
-0.8374534845352173,
0.005519323982298374,
0.6905211806297302,
0.40699124336242676,
-1.091861605644226,
0.5444421172142029,
-0.5701791048049927,
-0.6190658211708069,
-0.43698713183403015,
0.016586752608418465,
-0.1447020024061203,
0.6379338502883911,
0.34949907660484314,
-0.1730414479970932,
-0.34801802039146423,
-0.8645821809768677,
0.011086496524512768,
-0.1793012171983719,
0.02887864224612713,
0.2686289846897125,
0.22919490933418274,
-0.30595889687538147,
0.9537320733070374,
-0.3172471821308136,
-0.10127151012420654,
-0.1347203552722931,
0.051049403846263885,
0.04553677514195442,
0.5772370100021362,
0.5148323774337769,
-0.6729757189750671,
-0.28726667165756226,
0.3490324318408966,
-0.9886458516120911,
-0.0004214913642499596,
-0.6028873324394226,
0.35713133215904236,
0.39526739716529846,
0.1847929209470749,
-0.40542587637901306,
0.5080640912055969,
0.16612699627876282,
0.10046736896038055,
0.1602833867073059,
-0.36914411187171936,
0.3610079288482666,
-0.8140164613723755,
-0.025208191946148872,
-0.03365813195705414,
-0.4524409770965576,
-0.9265115857124329,
-0.24043603241443634,
0.044555094093084335,
-0.1966092884540558,
-0.17221756279468536,
0.42662110924720764,
-0.25896480679512024,
0.14280454814434052,
-0.837134063243866,
0.10574305057525635,
-0.07906591892242432,
0.28008806705474854,
-0.08705896884202957,
0.7421334981918335,
0.657943069934845,
-0.969587504863739,
0.6310642957687378,
0.35403376817703247,
-0.14458607137203217,
0.6693454384803772,
-0.7422172427177429,
0.42226722836494446,
-0.4933173656463623,
0.37525367736816406,
-0.9531010985374451,
-0.3327127993106842,
0.22388944029808044,
-0.6621191501617432,
0.27431049942970276,
-0.025074664503335953,
-0.5543086528778076,
-0.3277537226676941,
-0.49392715096473694,
0.31817153096199036,
0.5959441661834717,
-0.5368736386299133,
0.009115875698626041,
0.266059935092926,
0.04852104187011719,
-0.36520543694496155,
-1.0623284578323364,
0.3027917444705963,
-0.34258079528808594,
-0.8368409276008606,
0.258942574262619,
0.07179411500692368,
-0.21328604221343994,
-0.17108283936977386,
-0.059774547815322876,
-0.16380243003368378,
0.1707763522863388,
0.07779409736394882,
0.18550676107406616,
-0.04359462484717369,
0.4892421066761017,
0.29907462000846863,
-0.40339770913124084,
-0.2257625162601471,
-0.11620457470417023,
0.26014313101768494,
0.3135693371295929,
-0.40333035588264465,
-0.5894004702568054,
0.13282960653305054,
0.37189385294914246,
0.11370234936475754,
0.6044065952301025,
0.5985274910926819,
-0.3055853545665741,
-0.07100329548120499,
-0.5494030714035034,
-0.24343477189540863,
-0.5031909346580505,
0.024258339777588844,
-0.12962093949317932,
-0.7688099145889282,
0.18137197196483612,
-0.11683688312768936,
0.22316305339336395,
0.4196092188358307,
0.2643674910068512,
-0.29199615120887756,
0.9499918222427368,
0.6262985467910767,
-0.11178231984376907,
0.5851128697395325,
-0.41558000445365906,
0.02373156137764454,
-0.44384491443634033,
0.030043942853808403,
-0.4677252471446991,
-0.5045214295387268,
-0.965278148651123,
-0.018987147137522697,
0.5320454835891724,
-0.1516808122396469,
0.2877344787120819,
0.12732797861099243,
-0.6284297704696655,
0.41219469904899597,
0.25621309876441956,
0.4766486883163452,
0.3894968330860138,
0.2587631642818451,
0.8185408115386963,
-0.017131559550762177,
-0.6295541524887085,
-0.5855461955070496,
1.2076691389083862,
0.37806689739227295,
0.8705040812492371,
-0.2634921967983246,
0.5647642016410828,
0.5160663723945618,
-0.0902189239859581,
-0.8288284540176392,
0.4446876347064972,
-0.052908897399902344,
-0.4435565173625946,
-0.321380078792572,
-0.5368074774742126,
-1.2274178266525269,
-0.1594824194908142,
-0.37442389130592346,
-0.37980884313583374,
0.46981894969940186,
0.26575279235839844,
-0.2679421007633209,
0.19127443432807922,
-0.8532906770706177,
0.4636431634426117,
-0.028880352154374123,
-0.5292075872421265,
-0.2547706961631775,
-0.5901597738265991,
0.232878178358078,
-0.27824854850769043,
0.03307369351387024,
0.08331086486577988,
-0.22974365949630737,
0.8100144267082214,
-0.7894744873046875,
0.5908653736114502,
-0.16081099212169647,
-0.08797893673181534,
0.3836120069026947,
-0.25820642709732056,
0.6897786259651184,
-0.11891216784715652,
-0.1862058788537979,
-0.21900857985019684,
-0.05438811331987381,
-0.6776699423789978,
-0.9236092567443848,
0.6478896737098694,
-0.5374549627304077,
-0.21081623435020447,
-0.3866921663284302,
-0.3624897599220276,
-0.19337260723114014,
-0.08152405172586441,
0.05809938535094261,
0.5937898755073547,
-0.01425477210432291,
0.5009289979934692,
0.6346834897994995,
-0.022563230246305466,
0.5150340795516968,
0.08862464129924774,
0.16447950899600983,
-0.2596142590045929,
1.1211810111999512,
0.2503966689109802,
0.41532623767852783,
0.25456151366233826,
-0.02641988731920719,
-0.20489999651908875,
-0.687987744808197,
-0.6121196746826172,
0.026703419163823128,
-0.37109848856925964,
-0.013489149510860443,
-0.5196555256843567,
-0.08834804594516754,
-0.15039661526679993,
-0.011228018440306187,
-0.2868105173110962,
-0.6867713332176208,
-0.40737780928611755,
-0.0865810215473175,
0.7002776265144348,
0.6946545243263245,
-0.11426902562379837,
0.4211842715740204,
-0.6224959492683411,
0.33148646354675293,
0.36814025044441223,
0.0553874745965004,
-0.2924004793167114,
-0.32277071475982666,
-0.4529598355293274,
0.6377108693122864,
-0.4186861515045166,
-0.6545723080635071,
0.0998118594288826,
0.5014201998710632,
0.2592032551765442,
0.3542104959487915,
0.09912056475877762,
0.7760220170021057,
-0.2614552080631256,
0.7763992547988892,
-0.1421964466571808,
-0.43626028299331665,
0.5408965349197388,
-0.36763542890548706,
0.224626824259758,
0.7221503257751465,
0.30424758791923523,
-0.4806356430053711,
-0.2021341472864151,
-0.7170125842094421,
-0.6621387600898743,
0.7328699231147766,
0.4239390790462494,
0.5809139609336853,
0.1401425153017044,
0.597185492515564,
0.3213736414909363,
0.28214356303215027,
-0.5169376134872437,
-0.4804984927177429,
-0.017771584913134575,
-0.022398263216018677,
-0.06049715355038643,
0.0187511183321476,
0.22296273708343506,
-0.2859596312046051,
0.5163755416870117,
-0.32126230001449585,
0.36854827404022217,
0.3527582287788391,
0.028073202818632126,
-0.23863933980464935,
0.22539091110229492,
0.38605231046676636,
0.6055365204811096,
0.04585269093513489,
-0.10049581527709961,
0.2720916271209717,
-0.4360807240009308,
0.24685406684875488,
0.2842535376548767,
-0.5018448829650879,
-0.0009208981064148247,
0.3295271098613739,
0.9675116539001465,
-0.107416532933712,
-0.4450690746307373,
0.3127390444278717,
0.1408877819776535,
-0.28728657960891724,
-0.04650343582034111,
0.3838155269622803,
-0.45355790853500366,
0.06973674148321152,
0.6108712553977966,
0.19192567467689514,
0.049710992723703384,
-0.6774164438247681,
0.24155370891094208,
0.4399566352367401,
-0.24395547807216644,
-0.12863607704639435,
0.561951756477356,
0.020740745589137077,
-0.15582507848739624,
0.19789361953735352,
-0.17650575935840607,
-0.0472242496907711,
0.4216494560241699,
0.31301644444465637,
0.5860050916671753,
0.172176331281662,
0.22458255290985107,
0.08105266839265823,
0.21719534695148468,
-0.04813746362924576,
0.0012817636597901583,
-0.33383968472480774,
-0.43242189288139343,
-0.5327892303466797,
-0.25800377130508423,
-0.499264657497406,
0.12916216254234314,
-0.2961342930793762,
0.3163645267486572,
-0.2709323763847351,
-0.03110586851835251,
0.27517521381378174,
0.3030589818954468,
-0.3510601818561554,
0.4071469008922577,
-0.04529730975627899,
0.6875309944152832,
-0.6440974473953247,
0.652887225151062,
0.6059128642082214,
-0.24732549488544464,
-0.17862482368946075,
0.04063292592763901,
-0.20121099054813385,
-0.44361940026283264,
0.23811811208724976,
0.20107501745224,
0.11353565752506256,
0.2085733562707901,
-0.7719648480415344,
-0.4414388835430145,
0.9791722297668457,
0.2591696083545685,
-0.3697678744792938,
-0.12604676187038422,
0.3469696044921875,
0.9232640862464905,
-0.008754796348512173,
0.4395163357257843,
0.5152640342712402,
0.4486827254295349,
0.18575511872768402,
-0.802583634853363,
-0.2716057002544403,
-0.2742295265197754,
-0.0673079788684845,
0.06189234182238579,
-0.5172938704490662,
0.530693531036377,
-0.01353834755718708,
-0.531426191329956,
0.18916435539722443,
0.7052288055419922,
-0.2760765552520752,
0.5220534801483154,
0.497537225484848,
0.6527466773986816,
0.7774666547775269,
-0.305402934551239,
1.2418557405471802,
-0.023519957438111305,
0.14135070145130157,
0.4867750108242035,
0.02004505880177021,
0.4505719542503357,
0.14933288097381592,
-0.373555064201355,
0.2956697940826416,
0.9491983652114868,
-0.027673179283738136,
0.4091511368751526,
-0.0951184406876564,
-0.2702804505825043,
-0.09564261883497238,
-0.07509740442037582,
-0.597320556640625,
0.3772950768470764,
0.20117218792438507,
-0.0898052453994751,
-0.2320650815963745,
0.20220507681369781,
-0.025705108419060707,
0.14919953048229218,
-0.09210793673992157,
1.1622258424758911,
-0.1315840482711792,
-0.5054604411125183,
1.0265636444091797,
-0.11279738694429398,
0.7444280982017517,
-0.3612091541290283,
0.027893876656889915,
-0.27160724997520447,
0.05878879874944687,
-0.39271584153175354,
-0.7259986996650696,
0.40680307149887085,
-0.07115208357572556,
-0.04999765008687973,
0.03481044992804527,
0.8781985640525818,
-0.35313159227371216,
-0.31703346967697144,
-0.3883354365825653,
0.5702247619628906,
0.3744708299636841,
-0.12568449974060059,
-0.372440904378891,
-0.10345321148633957,
-0.08104876428842545,
0.0025683578569442034,
0.2582191526889801,
0.683625340461731,
0.09188278764486313,
0.765834391117096,
0.9619191884994507,
0.20920203626155853,
-0.08802902698516846,
-0.3445948362350464,
1.1917388439178467,
-0.43747806549072266,
-0.47750285267829895,
-0.9170331358909607,
0.4488973915576935,
-0.35025981068611145,
-0.23708271980285645,
0.7772096991539001,
0.6860059499740601,
0.8391645550727844,
0.27083727717399597,
0.8280022740364075,
0.03867460787296295,
0.5821264386177063,
-0.5598543882369995,
0.33538681268692017,
-0.5422235727310181,
0.40610870718955994,
-0.403571754693985,
-0.8877113461494446,
-0.15293584764003754,
0.2508237063884735,
-0.6126607656478882,
0.20157329738140106,
0.5375895500183105,
0.756675124168396,
-0.10478312522172928,
0.2843335270881653,
0.29387807846069336,
-0.04055023938417435,
0.30284175276756287,
0.3574378490447998,
0.912504255771637,
-0.8802266716957092,
0.4262830317020416,
-0.49297353625297546,
-0.22315780818462372,
-0.14393068850040436,
-0.49679049849510193,
-0.8582234978675842,
-0.588485598564148,
-0.28670650720596313,
-0.16254055500030518,
0.261528879404068,
0.7863063812255859,
0.6575638055801392,
-0.5117117166519165,
0.11593001335859299,
-0.36014094948768616,
0.15021143853664398,
-0.06361261755228043,
-0.21425233781337738,
0.25106045603752136,
-0.5299116969108582,
-0.9801021218299866,
0.5210760831832886,
0.1505545973777771,
0.3699587285518646,
-0.1346888542175293,
-0.06162643060088158,
0.03183065727353096,
-0.15765641629695892,
0.5520603656768799,
0.5079866051673889,
-0.23585176467895508,
-0.2225070744752884,
-0.09264639019966125,
-0.09986350685358047,
0.29729291796684265,
0.609854519367218,
-1.1944518089294434,
0.6775731444358826,
0.4174318313598633,
1.1460762023925781,
0.5813612937927246,
0.3863199055194855,
0.5473920702934265,
-0.7067524194717407,
0.1585700809955597,
0.17159268260002136,
-0.16675592958927155,
0.45603543519973755,
-0.47794535756111145,
0.49067386984825134,
0.379027783870697,
-0.770711362361908,
-0.9236233830451965,
-0.15147064626216888,
-0.931312084197998,
-0.01887422241270542,
1.0322166681289673,
0.326945036649704,
-0.32654157280921936,
-0.226920947432518,
-0.5866668224334717,
0.14368018507957458,
-0.5397112369537354,
0.9037998914718628,
0.36059656739234924,
-0.3027428686618805,
-0.009079460054636002,
-0.5391616225242615,
0.7228931188583374,
0.24833416938781738,
-1.2721638679504395,
-0.036200910806655884,
0.7276195287704468,
-0.213473379611969,
0.22534212470054626,
0.5941859483718872,
0.1345129907131195,
0.4317081868648529,
-0.06394234299659729,
-0.5231142640113831,
-0.3569975793361664,
-0.1540796160697937,
-0.4006519317626953,
0.05086333677172661,
0.004315773956477642,
-0.5042755603790283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14679v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14679v1
|
Is Cognition and Action Consistent or Not: Investigating Large Language Model's Personality
| 2024-02-22T16:32:08 | 2024-02-22T16:32:08 |
Yiming Ai, Zhiwei He, Ziyin Zhang, Wenhong Zhu, Hongkun Hao, Kai Yu, Lingjun Chen, Rui Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
In this study, we investigate the reliability of Large Language Models (LLMs)
in professing human-like personality traits through responses to personality
questionnaires. Our goal is to evaluate the consistency between LLMs' professed
personality inclinations and their actual "behavior", examining the extent to
which these models can emulate human-like personality patterns. Through a
comprehensive analysis of LLM outputs against established human benchmarks, we
seek to understand the cognition-action divergence in LLMs and propose
hypotheses for the observed results based on psychological theories and
metrics.
|
[
-0.10817346721887589,
-1.0639357566833496,
0.948060929775238,
0.3692825436592102,
0.13601453602313995,
-0.06499965488910675,
-0.4886166751384735,
-0.3725050389766693,
0.49375247955322266,
0.6638144850730896,
-0.6317765116691589,
-0.23325343430042267,
-0.6872147917747498,
0.027456311509013176,
-0.5974054932594299,
0.559883713722229,
-0.0008522363496012986,
0.22330275177955627,
-0.26216500997543335,
-0.27287426590919495,
-0.5444047451019287,
-0.5969365239143372,
-1.1019350290298462,
-0.5232206583023071,
0.623184323310852,
0.18853464722633362,
0.5794345140457153,
0.3231908679008484,
0.6571446657180786,
0.3335699737071991,
0.018776092678308487,
-0.03294014930725098,
-0.49387484788894653,
0.11926688998937607,
-0.45921462774276733,
-0.38391780853271484,
-0.5194664597511292,
0.2119641900062561,
0.8335097432136536,
0.7130241394042969,
-0.4155016839504242,
0.023400064557790756,
0.15850822627544403,
0.5375369787216187,
-0.5112639665603638,
0.10845004767179489,
-0.248931884765625,
-0.2273971289396286,
-0.20621296763420105,
0.21057254076004028,
-0.6114569902420044,
-0.3718264400959015,
0.15591731667518616,
-0.19625751674175262,
0.04109996184706688,
0.2267804890871048,
0.6761295199394226,
0.026809535920619965,
-0.5885857343673706,
-0.3312520682811737,
-0.9859567284584045,
0.9804241061210632,
-0.9048460125923157,
0.3826362192630768,
0.6979541778564453,
0.08975233137607574,
-0.2688952684402466,
-0.3409748673439026,
-0.9040034413337708,
-0.4640015959739685,
-0.09268520772457123,
0.011707584373652935,
0.14618562161922455,
-0.15098808705806732,
0.3022669851779938,
0.3691727817058563,
-0.5688110589981079,
0.28080517053604126,
0.009539226070046425,
0.013783994130790234,
0.9512203931808472,
0.5513477325439453,
0.3002912104129791,
-0.010405650362372398,
-0.0737324059009552,
-0.12639211118221283,
-0.6893408298492432,
0.022769451141357422,
0.4965987503528595,
-0.1721554398536682,
-0.28846415877342224,
0.7304654717445374,
-0.10970578342676163,
0.4572174549102783,
0.05559845641255379,
-0.3764744699001312,
0.03900682553648949,
-0.22729258239269257,
-0.38840946555137634,
-0.17562879621982574,
0.9316335916519165,
0.4396279454231262,
0.7771166563034058,
-0.13632377982139587,
-0.026975467801094055,
0.00986279547214508,
0.5465795397758484,
-0.4793212413787842,
-0.10331173986196518,
0.40674829483032227,
-0.35660308599472046,
-0.08976267278194427,
0.1478387713432312,
-0.5086207985877991,
-0.5668706297874451,
-0.36801108717918396,
0.17937907576560974,
-0.4966505169868469,
-0.6464856863021851,
0.11051759123802185,
0.12897077202796936,
0.5008406639099121,
0.26719236373901367,
-1.0985918045043945,
0.2980630099773407,
0.868438720703125,
0.5048903226852417,
-0.6274327635765076,
-0.5762919187545776,
-0.271710067987442,
0.16051921248435974,
-0.5499265193939209,
0.6469456553459167,
-0.5252658128738403,
-0.46457046270370483,
0.21983712911605835,
0.1742231398820877,
-0.22588488459587097,
-0.5236708521842957,
0.6635627746582031,
-0.42065489292144775,
-0.09011469781398773,
-0.6775765419006348,
-0.975998044013977,
-0.12959781289100647,
0.7390671968460083,
-0.5904734134674072,
0.9220544099807739,
0.05048564448952675,
-0.5002801418304443,
0.33105260133743286,
-0.46844780445098877,
-0.24586820602416992,
-0.08717641979455948,
-0.5506670475006104,
-0.09636103361845016,
0.15529368817806244,
-0.4971311688423157,
0.4587460458278656,
-0.22826430201530457,
0.342299222946167,
-0.6417299509048462,
-0.430218905210495,
0.8912094831466675,
-0.33196842670440674,
0.7587339282035828,
-0.24598397314548492,
-0.21365147829055786,
0.020867036655545235,
-0.5166049003601074,
0.0347965843975544,
0.34198376536369324,
-0.41870975494384766,
-0.1468358337879181,
0.4474024176597595,
-0.14961667358875275,
0.3134753406047821,
0.41559427976608276,
-0.8775498270988464,
0.5045149922370911,
0.02236105687916279,
0.2805756628513336,
0.6451392769813538,
0.023735661059617996,
0.27491432428359985,
-0.452910453081131,
0.2025541216135025,
-0.10241547971963882,
0.07666778564453125,
0.30337366461753845,
-0.4246958792209625,
-0.8183878660202026,
-0.21029290556907654,
-0.11807060986757278,
0.4138047397136688,
-0.04487885534763336,
0.7329210638999939,
-0.42760762572288513,
-0.5386106967926025,
-0.07024461030960083,
0.21732421219348907,
0.4616836607456207,
0.4033404290676117,
-0.07982832938432693,
-0.5540319681167603,
-0.5734846591949463,
-0.863358736038208,
-0.36429286003112793,
-0.4198126792907715,
-0.03954597935080528,
0.4563937783241272,
0.4304564297199249,
-0.381573349237442,
0.8437915444374084,
-0.3864908218383789,
0.12427883595228195,
-0.49554523825645447,
0.1541055142879486,
0.00613339664414525,
0.3772481381893158,
0.748327374458313,
-0.5885868668556213,
-0.4844522476196289,
-0.39087164402008057,
-1.0214169025421143,
0.12383147329092026,
0.31358644366264343,
-0.0007104864926077425,
0.2836303412914276,
0.676539957523346,
-0.7364436984062195,
0.4299672842025757,
0.687057614326477,
-0.44488880038261414,
0.6690639853477478,
-0.08204516023397446,
0.10753833502531052,
-0.9331704378128052,
0.14352276921272278,
0.1566890925168991,
0.0265454463660717,
-0.8516220450401306,
-0.10713107883930206,
-0.0024786172434687614,
0.46700236201286316,
-0.3562394380569458,
0.7924042344093323,
-0.06537316739559174,
-0.2885326147079468,
-0.3299356698989868,
-0.02610812522470951,
-0.09483716636896133,
0.40461331605911255,
0.40784752368927,
0.4702799618244171,
0.6470463871955872,
-0.8096722364425659,
0.27324536442756653,
0.15497912466526031,
-0.4136604368686676,
1.0376017093658447,
-0.707129955291748,
0.312705934047699,
-0.11515337973833084,
0.1479463130235672,
-1.0910158157348633,
-0.5575305223464966,
-0.06761093437671661,
-0.19276849925518036,
0.28268709778785706,
0.10528235882520676,
-0.7519819140434265,
-0.31134524941444397,
-0.253322571516037,
-0.0267108753323555,
0.5524663925170898,
-0.14282412827014923,
0.8673111796379089,
0.029952561482787132,
-0.14955802261829376,
-0.27476608753204346,
-0.788587212562561,
-0.18975825607776642,
-0.10276105999946594,
-0.48075318336486816,
-0.05258721113204956,
-0.4526750147342682,
-0.7468554377555847,
-0.5038834810256958,
0.0218780729919672,
0.01568106934428215,
0.10714051872491837,
0.25762128829956055,
0.3196893036365509,
-0.22009050846099854,
-0.13055379688739777,
-0.4810398817062378,
0.4978891909122467,
0.3327372074127197,
0.19788508117198944,
0.7983982563018799,
-0.03686336800456047,
-0.6556051969528198,
-0.5501060485839844,
0.16540290415287018,
0.9221320748329163,
0.05858329311013222,
0.7723390460014343,
0.3524799346923828,
-0.1051526740193367,
0.24694250524044037,
-0.644098699092865,
-0.22037477791309357,
-0.45654311776161194,
0.2724643647670746,
-0.1259595900774002,
-0.8195246458053589,
0.6443204283714294,
0.07411495596170425,
0.15408116579055786,
0.2139943391084671,
0.6090754270553589,
-0.6448904275894165,
1.0034817457199097,
0.7321047186851501,
-0.04537989944219589,
0.5419584512710571,
-0.034778010100126266,
0.177697092294693,
-1.1801739931106567,
-0.33922505378723145,
-0.2860109806060791,
-0.6418992280960083,
-0.6406756639480591,
0.0731491968035698,
-0.09578226506710052,
0.035251397639513016,
-0.668891429901123,
0.037303317338228226,
0.04204043000936508,
0.23803669214248657,
0.2356710284948349,
-0.21973207592964172,
0.15564115345478058,
-0.16943539679050446,
-0.015480942092835903,
-0.06916460394859314,
-0.1432420015335083,
-0.7154189348220825,
1.162212610244751,
0.2959880828857422,
0.8802894353866577,
0.6793116331100464,
0.501491129398346,
0.2816064655780792,
0.559661328792572,
-0.797240674495697,
0.7489103078842163,
-0.007922192104160786,
-0.6897014379501343,
-0.5251964330673218,
-0.2200089693069458,
-1.0230262279510498,
-0.0889333039522171,
-0.3003215789794922,
-1.3527603149414062,
0.04566974565386772,
0.06504036486148834,
0.02730284444987774,
0.26860785484313965,
-0.5100327134132385,
0.6504613757133484,
-0.34129366278648376,
-0.21290768682956696,
-0.1366790235042572,
-0.5137337446212769,
0.515976071357727,
-0.08235543221235275,
-0.10090810805559158,
-0.2970288395881653,
0.01947115920484066,
0.6439224481582642,
-0.08240395039319992,
1.0079394578933716,
0.1974315643310547,
-0.3424105644226074,
0.2656385600566864,
0.4022365212440491,
0.6130546927452087,
-0.056420888751745224,
-0.0567355640232563,
0.16558527946472168,
-0.2698017656803131,
-0.48747870326042175,
-0.7809587121009827,
0.8474962115287781,
-0.8644604682922363,
-0.6606640815734863,
-0.3608526289463043,
-0.5464674830436707,
-0.5094313025474548,
0.1261536031961441,
0.009943691082298756,
0.16032575070858002,
-0.6989468336105347,
0.13694749772548676,
0.9269425272941589,
0.11646412312984467,
0.7018381357192993,
1.1057878732681274,
-0.5277250409126282,
-0.1472027599811554,
0.5280771255493164,
-0.09480729699134827,
0.39178064465522766,
0.25355687737464905,
0.1235741674900055,
-0.23108342289924622,
-0.41689297556877136,
-0.29799047112464905,
0.5629642605781555,
-0.4179827570915222,
0.3871843218803406,
-0.400835782289505,
-0.25515303015708923,
-0.4593428671360016,
-0.06790778040885925,
-0.5934141874313354,
0.09269225597381592,
-0.0027633155696094036,
0.09607989341020584,
0.322200208902359,
1.216111660003662,
0.5339247584342957,
0.29013150930404663,
-0.7226303219795227,
-0.029542697593569756,
0.4478013515472412,
0.24347245693206787,
0.09808333963155746,
-0.6962119340896606,
0.05715161934494972,
-0.06390777975320816,
-0.5049454569816589,
-0.758866012096405,
0.03884146735072136,
0.12535032629966736,
0.6049528121948242,
0.9299739003181458,
-0.47314226627349854,
0.07975825667381287,
-0.2661592960357666,
1.0669949054718018,
0.20094460248947144,
-0.8640782237052917,
0.2623876929283142,
-0.44173896312713623,
0.31596577167510986,
0.391608864068985,
0.5361585021018982,
-0.7123703956604004,
-0.4853559732437134,
-0.9344881176948547,
-0.22526924312114716,
0.4841509163379669,
0.19124816358089447,
0.1445786952972412,
-0.17973670363426208,
0.5401991009712219,
-0.3082813322544098,
0.21711990237236023,
-0.436492383480072,
-0.3170711398124695,
-0.010545346885919571,
-0.19227269291877747,
-0.3537992835044861,
-0.2862738370895386,
-0.2503359615802765,
-0.1391296684741974,
0.20830167829990387,
-0.16753575205802917,
0.03735525533556938,
-0.13234946131706238,
0.188115656375885,
-0.07344945520162582,
0.33587273955345154,
0.9310558438301086,
0.8057228326797485,
-0.28140148520469666,
0.20946316421031952,
0.1434917449951172,
-0.8084244132041931,
0.22335956990718842,
-0.5161943435668945,
-0.05462540313601494,
-0.2066337615251541,
0.5624619722366333,
0.43195730447769165,
0.3183840811252594,
-0.9103752970695496,
0.6750127077102661,
-0.08065879344940186,
-0.1628057211637497,
-0.5706294178962708,
0.3912698030471802,
0.6226450800895691,
0.27097174525260925,
0.10139883309602737,
-0.12171680480241776,
-0.2211412936449051,
-1.0437414646148682,
-0.13777190446853638,
0.5043094158172607,
-0.31430113315582275,
-0.4241611957550049,
0.17618431150913239,
-0.03882724791765213,
-0.5568234324455261,
0.9902929067611694,
-0.13928568363189697,
-0.27575045824050903,
0.6033117175102234,
0.4376471936702728,
0.879561185836792,
-0.34453150629997253,
-0.075747549533844,
0.24090830981731415,
0.22370514273643494,
-0.49123087525367737,
0.6551867723464966,
0.3113277852535248,
-1.003543734550476,
-0.5990897417068481,
-0.6188752055168152,
-0.6074396371841431,
0.3565847873687744,
-0.8509247899055481,
0.1350204050540924,
-0.5512382984161377,
-0.29192399978637695,
-0.08237654715776443,
-0.011600598692893982,
-0.45098960399627686,
0.31471654772758484,
0.07158348709344864,
0.8778483867645264,
-0.7957358956336975,
1.1617615222930908,
0.8458631634712219,
-0.3267437815666199,
-1.0048829317092896,
0.14641965925693512,
-0.06476098299026489,
-0.6879024505615234,
0.7492338418960571,
-0.14354917407035828,
-0.030643466860055923,
-0.2695482075214386,
-0.8070561289787292,
-1.1316757202148438,
1.2415310144424438,
0.43226203322410583,
-0.6255108714103699,
0.05227244272828102,
0.10959409177303314,
0.6041091084480286,
-0.4126722812652588,
0.08713684231042862,
0.8198629021644592,
0.6207331418991089,
0.1650432050228119,
-1.042228102684021,
-0.16222278773784637,
0.047651246190071106,
0.08397331088781357,
0.21612931787967682,
-1.0582298040390015,
0.901850163936615,
-0.16730813682079315,
0.07009860873222351,
0.2484137862920761,
0.7791011929512024,
0.5654072165489197,
0.13253606855869293,
0.23745468258857727,
0.8105354309082031,
0.8634259700775146,
0.02087906375527382,
1.2274812459945679,
-0.23683516681194305,
0.4102681279182434,
1.0710699558258057,
-0.7551056146621704,
1.152791142463684,
0.37677332758903503,
-0.25810036063194275,
0.9013956189155579,
0.29344385862350464,
-0.0050784144550561905,
0.2395981401205063,
0.0699143260717392,
-0.10370955616235733,
-0.33472004532814026,
0.027519695460796356,
0.3028315007686615,
0.8096008896827698,
0.3485887944698334,
-0.4510729908943176,
0.22242945432662964,
-0.3321903347969055,
0.2254832237958908,
-0.005736644379794598,
-0.3884904682636261,
0.6339107155799866,
0.1450812667608261,
-0.9175713658332825,
0.3491224944591522,
-0.1158546656370163,
0.6504953503608704,
-0.689314067363739,
0.14187924563884735,
-0.3453672230243683,
0.11789572983980179,
-0.13560007512569427,
-1.1126729249954224,
0.36236441135406494,
-0.021901894360780716,
-0.35346606373786926,
0.036579351872205734,
0.4951556622982025,
-0.18256863951683044,
-0.12515981495380402,
0.16821995377540588,
0.5235292911529541,
0.43994536995887756,
0.14503301680088043,
-0.5147942304611206,
0.2713874578475952,
-0.21769128739833832,
-0.28298717737197876,
0.544904887676239,
0.12497854977846146,
-0.09983844310045242,
0.787839949131012,
0.27877697348594666,
0.04011915624141693,
-0.08226711302995682,
0.09039845317602158,
0.29651138186454773,
-0.7272685766220093,
0.09282968938350677,
-1.071744680404663,
0.2411109358072281,
-0.179652601480484,
-0.5399752855300903,
0.9432902336120605,
0.49250251054763794,
0.5552573800086975,
-0.04559945687651634,
0.5891933441162109,
-0.08205273002386093,
0.3111375570297241,
-0.47743088006973267,
0.504095733165741,
-0.20512479543685913,
0.05427061766386032,
-0.1590544730424881,
-1.1371601819992065,
0.22541719675064087,
0.4988374412059784,
-0.4190326929092407,
0.3854266405105591,
0.9253050684928894,
0.5452823042869568,
-0.0072869970463216305,
0.05516478791832924,
0.5076488852500916,
0.3332843482494354,
0.07641138136386871,
0.47093990445137024,
0.8673983812332153,
-0.02279256470501423,
-0.05095507577061653,
0.30466341972351074,
-0.14849668741226196,
-0.3127928376197815,
-0.9273501634597778,
-0.8342115879058838,
-0.25035619735717773,
-0.39651039242744446,
-0.43369945883750916,
-0.3881343901157379,
0.6922662854194641,
0.5369942784309387,
-0.644294261932373,
-0.4932471513748169,
-0.13653318583965302,
-0.04396598041057587,
-0.35805463790893555,
-0.26916390657424927,
0.2006806880235672,
-0.029823461547493935,
-0.9007464051246643,
0.16637536883354187,
0.3953939974308014,
0.1539410650730133,
-0.8793253898620605,
-0.30024078488349915,
-0.15296973288059235,
0.6749066114425659,
0.5767544507980347,
0.5374417304992676,
-0.9935182929039001,
-0.5125380158424377,
0.2846122980117798,
-0.5189177393913269,
-0.08188549429178238,
0.902189314365387,
-0.1753396838903427,
0.006886375602334738,
0.38335657119750977,
0.2211247831583023,
0.2639589309692383,
-0.12507925927639008,
0.5203037261962891,
-0.687087893486023,
-0.1190086230635643,
0.18146418035030365,
0.5622002482414246,
0.5264446139335632,
-0.21038199961185455,
0.4821476638317108,
0.18932989239692688,
-0.7871946096420288,
-0.36896568536758423,
0.5252830982208252,
-1.3604609966278076,
0.014533080160617828,
1.517345905303955,
-0.3667602837085724,
-0.2744028568267822,
0.034925028681755066,
-0.013996998779475689,
-0.10969088226556778,
-0.17411485314369202,
0.833197832107544,
1.1485804319381714,
-0.6210756897926331,
-0.12384507805109024,
-0.5456873178482056,
0.35638946294784546,
0.26920807361602783,
-0.5929664969444275,
0.16492284834384918,
0.31917205452919006,
0.6704606413841248,
0.45410072803497314,
0.5778906941413879,
0.06712538003921509,
0.1275090128183365,
-0.16876220703125,
0.17161773145198822,
0.5636764764785767,
-0.015070466324687004,
-0.06475047767162323,
-0.11282932758331299,
0.4989696443080902,
0.30535367131233215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14672v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14672v1
|
Middleware for LLMs: Tools Are Instrumental for Language Agents in Complex Environments
| 2024-02-22T16:18:07 | 2024-02-22T16:18:07 |
Yu Gu, Yiheng Shu, Hao Yu, Xiao Liu, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang, Jayanth Srinivasa, Hugo Latapie, Yu Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
The applications of large language models (LLMs) have expanded well beyond
the confines of text processing, signaling a new era where LLMs are envisioned
as generalist language agents capable of operating within complex real-world
environments. These environments are often highly expansive, making it
impossible for the LLM to process them within its short-term memory. Motivated
by recent research on extending the capabilities of LLMs with tools, this paper
investigates the intriguing potential of tools to augment LLMs in handling such
complexity. To this end, we design customized tools to aid in the proactive
exploration within these massive environments. Such tools can serve as a
middleware layer shielding the LLM from environmental complexity. In two
representative complex environments -- knowledge bases (KBs) and databases --
we demonstrate the significant potential of augmenting language agents with
tools in complex environments. Notably, equipped with these tools, GPT-4
achieves 2.8X the performance of the best baseline in tasks requiring access to
database content and 2.2X in KB tasks. Our findings illuminate the path for
advancing language agents in complex real-world applications.
|
[
-0.5712693333625793,
-0.9327414035797119,
0.9359309673309326,
0.15179941058158875,
0.07007426768541336,
0.5313557982444763,
-0.3510604798793793,
-0.5958528518676758,
-0.050058912485837936,
0.5726428031921387,
-0.6889395117759705,
-0.6417554020881653,
-0.396624356508255,
-0.0559183806180954,
-0.1510685235261917,
0.8546363115310669,
0.11174684017896652,
-0.41953423619270325,
-0.2840477526187897,
0.02370499074459076,
-0.47072336077690125,
-0.6245542168617249,
-0.3429756760597229,
-0.5254842042922974,
0.5231567025184631,
0.6677070260047913,
1.145838737487793,
0.4169415533542633,
0.41927388310432434,
0.3940025568008423,
0.12873946130275726,
0.11481990665197372,
-0.3059749901294708,
0.42416471242904663,
-0.441572904586792,
-0.6596110463142395,
-0.8253189325332642,
-0.053563982248306274,
0.37920960783958435,
0.5393854379653931,
-0.21757064759731293,
0.14899155497550964,
-0.21725942194461823,
0.5826157927513123,
-0.49700167775154114,
0.21673312783241272,
-0.3642403483390808,
-0.005773489363491535,
-0.478495329618454,
-0.11416968703269958,
0.03293916955590248,
0.00880216434597969,
0.2498297542333603,
-0.7554996609687805,
0.0334254652261734,
0.2690533995628357,
0.5666537880897522,
0.1581297516822815,
-0.23628415167331696,
-0.37891092896461487,
-1.063928246498108,
0.7760189771652222,
-0.5580771565437317,
0.3852519094944,
0.1581781804561615,
0.5695998072624207,
-0.4273463189601898,
-0.7284985780715942,
-0.6465941667556763,
-0.3626401424407959,
-0.012303234077990055,
-0.023189954459667206,
-0.31441250443458557,
0.24214471876621246,
0.24556230008602142,
0.231718510389328,
-0.5240963101387024,
0.35934680700302124,
-0.07351812720298767,
-0.2666530907154083,
0.3125546872615814,
0.3548567295074463,
0.7484193444252014,
0.12539979815483093,
0.07065961509943008,
0.07081864029169083,
-0.9260016083717346,
-0.0614851713180542,
0.48579952120780945,
0.21062608063220978,
0.10464329272508621,
0.5519828200340271,
-0.08791210502386093,
0.8169381022453308,
-0.40275248885154724,
-0.08925215899944305,
-0.028098823502659798,
-0.18331114947795868,
-0.258262038230896,
-0.19588130712509155,
0.33514416217803955,
0.17764829099178314,
0.12679822742938995,
-0.4975767731666565,
-0.5100922584533691,
-0.05347157642245293,
0.14107078313827515,
-0.570947527885437,
-0.29985731840133667,
0.4113874137401581,
0.022332757711410522,
-0.17324306070804596,
-0.2821895182132721,
-0.541029155254364,
-0.28076988458633423,
-0.4113624095916748,
0.4121180474758148,
-0.18686552345752716,
-0.4557432532310486,
0.16002385318279266,
-0.17502950131893158,
0.17891950905323029,
0.4465736448764801,
-0.7727977633476257,
0.7531619668006897,
0.7831056714057922,
0.8953438997268677,
-0.1038685217499733,
-0.12119794636964798,
-0.48821187019348145,
0.45472070574760437,
-0.24631455540657043,
0.9580537676811218,
-0.8792296648025513,
-0.42853406071662903,
-0.12823614478111267,
0.08884137868881226,
0.529548704624176,
-0.7190201878547668,
0.46575498580932617,
-0.9565173387527466,
0.251496821641922,
-0.49764376878738403,
-0.3504490256309509,
-0.06780543923377991,
0.4690292179584503,
-0.896276593208313,
0.989047110080719,
0.3630356192588806,
-0.43478283286094666,
0.04160161688923836,
-0.950170636177063,
-0.3964844048023224,
0.16898281872272491,
-0.1580638736486435,
-0.21830032765865326,
-0.11620769649744034,
0.1832462102174759,
0.409185528755188,
-0.5979871153831482,
-0.026511196047067642,
-0.40238869190216064,
-0.6195659637451172,
0.1602907031774521,
-0.0705987811088562,
0.38872092962265015,
0.1980447918176651,
-0.44442856311798096,
0.06252112984657288,
-0.4477432072162628,
-0.09673437476158142,
0.129807248711586,
-0.572360634803772,
-0.5008185505867004,
-0.07893163710832596,
0.20603413879871368,
0.22155039012432098,
0.37013378739356995,
-0.39104172587394714,
0.5229630470275879,
-0.4182036817073822,
0.2757660448551178,
0.8519520163536072,
-0.23107865452766418,
0.7569920420646667,
-0.24205274879932404,
0.792650043964386,
-0.10305614769458771,
0.06018996983766556,
0.07200736552476883,
-0.28062617778778076,
-0.6776137948036194,
-0.25761809945106506,
-0.0018781849648803473,
0.649211585521698,
-0.7097537517547607,
0.44408923387527466,
-0.3531448245048523,
-0.5729689598083496,
-0.3996066451072693,
0.29361963272094727,
0.3859810531139374,
0.14201080799102783,
0.38615062832832336,
-0.1763802468776703,
-0.5797652006149292,
-0.9948152303695679,
-0.39261311292648315,
0.14608615636825562,
-0.24336184561252594,
0.5315441489219666,
0.2274176925420761,
-0.6792457103729248,
1.0425567626953125,
-0.5128779411315918,
-0.15488304197788239,
-0.2843500077724457,
-0.34528881311416626,
0.40285709500312805,
0.3574908375740051,
0.4771153926849365,
-0.8391473293304443,
-0.2701053023338318,
0.21600353717803955,
-0.6789911389350891,
-0.41790327429771423,
0.055066172033548355,
-0.12774328887462616,
-0.15967793762683868,
0.6101571321487427,
-0.866868793964386,
-0.34587565064430237,
0.5920752286911011,
-0.22337494790554047,
0.8452306389808655,
-0.22991254925727844,
-0.16083839535713196,
-0.7503998875617981,
0.1298639327287674,
-0.13154590129852295,
-0.45473477244377136,
-0.9278950691223145,
0.07515343278646469,
-0.15790408849716187,
0.03615168109536171,
-0.19797258079051971,
0.8140241503715515,
-0.8449373841285706,
-0.47784435749053955,
-0.322035551071167,
0.5025433301925659,
-0.04928244277834892,
0.2607681155204773,
-0.2592076361179352,
0.9894821643829346,
0.5863651633262634,
-0.5308997631072998,
0.6492174863815308,
-0.08970807492733002,
-0.10442467778921127,
0.3578423857688904,
-0.5014182925224304,
0.3212169110774994,
0.053256839513778687,
0.17638906836509705,
-0.6721429228782654,
-0.28428950905799866,
0.15342362225055695,
-0.0077613117173314095,
0.2965719401836395,
-0.1617519110441208,
-0.7302535176277161,
-0.23228564858436584,
-0.21221823990345,
0.06595180928707123,
0.4702412188053131,
-0.34946104884147644,
0.8423171639442444,
0.6068280935287476,
-0.5333251953125,
-0.6123834252357483,
-0.615821123123169,
0.5539584755897522,
-0.16263435781002045,
-0.5453054308891296,
0.22319939732551575,
-0.07098427414894104,
-0.5799450874328613,
0.24755939841270447,
-0.26624786853790283,
0.09899043291807175,
0.1477065235376358,
0.3372584581375122,
0.2924375832080841,
-0.17125174403190613,
0.16513632237911224,
0.13329093158245087,
-0.15436142683029175,
0.16850227117538452,
-0.6052592992782593,
0.5067875981330872,
-0.6311429142951965,
-0.43567296862602234,
0.1366533488035202,
0.23737551271915436,
0.6505345106124878,
-0.11766641587018967,
0.35202327370643616,
0.5334433913230896,
-0.3663215637207031,
-0.3324834406375885,
-0.8065495491027832,
0.003212176263332367,
-0.6239007711410522,
0.5362100601196289,
-0.6171576976776123,
-1.1383322477340698,
0.5110886693000793,
-0.45993316173553467,
0.06913073360919952,
0.124118372797966,
0.6862090229988098,
-0.025997595861554146,
0.7523565292358398,
0.7047994136810303,
-0.2774147093296051,
0.5686976909637451,
-0.24390630424022675,
0.13821272552013397,
-0.8782522082328796,
-0.1366105079650879,
-0.20792661607265472,
-0.3331592082977295,
-0.3810064196586609,
-0.4314100742340088,
0.39533117413520813,
-0.0776468887925148,
-0.24683941900730133,
0.13095548748970032,
-0.4094368517398834,
0.7395663261413574,
0.5381778478622437,
0.050297487527132034,
0.47486230731010437,
-0.02380584366619587,
-0.07702458649873734,
0.12244714796543121,
-0.7056451439857483,
-0.8254806399345398,
0.8886809349060059,
0.321601003408432,
0.7956984639167786,
0.4278399348258972,
0.39536014199256897,
0.43314456939697266,
0.5561738014221191,
-0.47710201144218445,
0.7058817744255066,
0.029794689267873764,
-0.6047377586364746,
-0.5008695721626282,
-0.12965942919254303,
-0.9292733073234558,
0.30200520157814026,
-0.08707434684038162,
-0.5183275938034058,
0.016971636563539505,
0.10258116573095322,
-0.3414410352706909,
0.237351655960083,
-0.7631266713142395,
0.642310619354248,
-0.2723071277141571,
-0.5006033182144165,
-0.2876853942871094,
-0.6726613640785217,
0.3200126588344574,
-0.12520121037960052,
0.3723233938217163,
-0.10970158874988556,
-0.3868246376514435,
0.3712975084781647,
-0.224786639213562,
0.7844201326370239,
-0.4677058756351471,
-0.23318231105804443,
0.19507217407226562,
0.4195731282234192,
0.7941042184829712,
-0.03577892854809761,
0.06811179220676422,
-0.15769675374031067,
-0.1513536274433136,
-0.49874526262283325,
-0.6933637261390686,
0.9613347053527832,
-0.822558581829071,
-0.9344900846481323,
-0.24312849342823029,
-0.7198182344436646,
-0.4287179410457611,
0.4482104182243347,
-0.2959979474544525,
0.10275565087795258,
-0.154992938041687,
-0.036130085587501526,
0.7738183736801147,
-0.2266201227903366,
0.13509073853492737,
0.7310290932655334,
-0.17804627120494843,
0.1698906421661377,
0.7927853465080261,
0.2630613148212433,
0.2588515281677246,
0.3814023733139038,
0.09851813316345215,
-0.30177637934684753,
-0.7350300550460815,
-0.28612852096557617,
-0.03910868242383003,
-0.7485207319259644,
-0.036364078521728516,
-0.76795494556427,
0.14058281481266022,
-0.10736630111932755,
-0.2643522024154663,
-0.1306258589029312,
-0.41602617502212524,
-0.07146348059177399,
-0.34769129753112793,
0.3417120575904846,
0.6621633172035217,
-0.075473852455616,
0.40797188878059387,
-0.9797486662864685,
0.17787905037403107,
0.4839150011539459,
0.3506573438644409,
-0.05741012841463089,
-0.024946218356490135,
-0.4499707818031311,
-0.13589738309383392,
0.027954915538430214,
-0.5547515153884888,
0.1817280352115631,
0.10002370923757553,
0.7787994146347046,
0.09493756294250488,
-0.3053499162197113,
0.48689404129981995,
-0.45931175351142883,
0.6410322785377502,
-0.2917163670063019,
-0.7278093099594116,
0.3550496995449066,
-0.5875005722045898,
0.30268630385398865,
0.13482451438903809,
0.25799068808555603,
-0.6063461303710938,
-0.4864341914653778,
-0.47103947401046753,
-0.8521856069564819,
0.483951598405838,
0.1481786072254181,
0.005812725983560085,
0.5310901999473572,
0.5194904804229736,
-0.03564438223838806,
0.24757017195224762,
-0.5032939314842224,
0.17960600554943085,
0.07156331092119217,
-0.035450130701065063,
-0.2513376474380493,
-0.1190355122089386,
-0.42451706528663635,
0.23505249619483948,
0.4164675176143646,
-0.060907356441020966,
-0.029410362243652344,
0.18127401173114777,
-0.38087600469589233,
-0.041925422847270966,
0.6746780276298523,
0.28182756900787354,
0.4227863848209381,
-0.16329127550125122,
0.42289286851882935,
0.2627653181552887,
-0.5576256513595581,
0.25196734070777893,
0.14756573736667633,
0.08592826128005981,
-0.27451837062835693,
0.4466344714164734,
0.34982678294181824,
0.14893490076065063,
-0.9891945719718933,
0.35048341751098633,
0.028448525816202164,
0.2843790352344513,
-0.2946043014526367,
0.40637508034706116,
0.5039178133010864,
0.6114513874053955,
0.24002045392990112,
0.019507700577378273,
0.4675779640674591,
-0.7710667252540588,
0.15013955533504486,
0.33593809604644775,
-0.2565794587135315,
-0.5723453760147095,
0.38575878739356995,
0.2137019783258438,
-0.2964562773704529,
0.43412497639656067,
-0.3098229169845581,
-0.46667009592056274,
0.3805391192436218,
0.49703097343444824,
0.793290913105011,
-0.07327663898468018,
-0.3515949547290802,
-0.3621987998485565,
0.5692059397697449,
0.03415561094880104,
0.3011206388473511,
-0.1139286682009697,
-0.7879109382629395,
-0.45185646414756775,
-0.44500255584716797,
-0.6570313572883606,
-0.08602757751941681,
-0.07376036047935486,
-0.11937478184700012,
-0.37034574151039124,
-0.13155506551265717,
-0.23464639484882355,
0.21025124192237854,
-0.8023129105567932,
0.0892859622836113,
0.06855311989784241,
0.9597430229187012,
-0.7762038707733154,
0.9244008660316467,
0.9804410338401794,
-0.2061242312192917,
-0.5100978016853333,
-0.14702071249485016,
0.17696188390254974,
-0.7239844799041748,
0.49088504910469055,
-0.07515895366668701,
-0.5776038765907288,
-0.02414664439857006,
-0.5990147590637207,
-0.7196474075317383,
1.3011754751205444,
0.41362902522087097,
-0.8158853650093079,
-0.15551842749118805,
0.217148095369339,
0.7558779120445251,
-0.1385023444890976,
0.005855020601302385,
0.9081434011459351,
0.7975077629089355,
-0.32261350750923157,
-0.6590964198112488,
0.3957196772098541,
-0.3944585621356964,
0.01220898237079382,
0.12905724346637726,
-0.4436245560646057,
0.6823837161064148,
-0.23942047357559204,
-0.24754540622234344,
-0.22420410811901093,
0.3688468337059021,
0.4499658942222595,
0.16200795769691467,
0.6939355134963989,
0.30256783962249756,
0.6994808912277222,
-0.10195299237966537,
1.0878586769104004,
-0.2053445279598236,
0.02352501079440117,
1.0139292478561401,
-0.4257083535194397,
0.48963215947151184,
0.4366188645362854,
-0.30529117584228516,
0.6465376019477844,
0.6153126358985901,
0.09693759679794312,
0.4031926393508911,
0.1555190086364746,
-0.5835282802581787,
-0.235922709107399,
-0.05876754969358444,
-0.056033819913864136,
-0.036719825118780136,
0.8384214639663696,
0.38320422172546387,
-0.14598774909973145,
-0.06316020339727402,
0.08418135344982147,
0.019185880199074745,
-0.16157227754592896,
0.7151124477386475,
0.06743227690458298,
-0.47504258155822754,
0.05301453545689583,
0.038670822978019714,
0.6466485261917114,
-0.6804689168930054,
-0.08167997002601624,
-0.10323255509138107,
0.10136961936950684,
-0.3243819773197174,
-1.024930715560913,
0.2060522884130478,
-0.19900308549404144,
-0.053462859243154526,
-0.03352319821715355,
1.1859769821166992,
-0.3280620872974396,
0.007957573980093002,
0.47499880194664,
0.9026358723640442,
-0.05223603546619415,
-0.28986355662345886,
-0.6448500156402588,
-0.025242550298571587,
-0.38239774107933044,
-0.6381507515907288,
0.2781440317630768,
0.6971333622932434,
-0.14801937341690063,
0.948543131351471,
1.0420812368392944,
0.2595207691192627,
-0.08882191777229309,
0.06836072355508804,
1.3513325452804565,
-0.7353833317756653,
-0.42279157042503357,
-0.9256013035774231,
0.2561074197292328,
-0.12194778770208359,
0.18948227167129517,
0.7773135304450989,
0.6864225268363953,
0.6628747582435608,
-0.08750622719526291,
1.0731297731399536,
-0.05803104490041733,
0.44887346029281616,
-0.47722411155700684,
0.4928472340106964,
-0.3673604428768158,
0.5768012404441833,
-0.23916536569595337,
-0.9506604671478271,
-0.4842711389064789,
0.08319113403558731,
-0.3400231599807739,
-0.03209863603115082,
0.230684295296669,
1.068491816520691,
-0.20825758576393127,
-0.37507981061935425,
0.29262933135032654,
0.40845173597335815,
0.9078673124313354,
0.36144939064979553,
0.9059649109840393,
0.19694733619689941,
0.5928338170051575,
0.14855921268463135,
-0.4285147488117218,
-0.24974611401557922,
-0.650273859500885,
-0.7331019043922424,
-0.2758196294307709,
0.4311971366405487,
-0.18096725642681122,
0.35356786847114563,
0.9128490686416626,
0.670238196849823,
-0.4602750241756439,
-0.33907273411750793,
-0.07348118722438812,
0.14895187318325043,
-0.11481902003288269,
-0.1951257586479187,
0.18050500750541687,
-0.3642461597919464,
-0.7180460095405579,
0.6497964859008789,
0.7509008049964905,
0.09780320525169373,
-0.6422653198242188,
-0.21120142936706543,
-0.06278177350759506,
-0.030877210199832916,
0.6720229983329773,
0.39233314990997314,
-0.5288797616958618,
-0.29363948106765747,
0.2653873860836029,
-0.14336128532886505,
-0.1187049075961113,
0.9416324496269226,
-0.7437973022460938,
0.4792201817035675,
0.3303617537021637,
0.6262969970703125,
0.4906448721885681,
-0.25027456879615784,
0.8486047983169556,
-0.8313230276107788,
0.23978234827518463,
0.4204719364643097,
0.3278917372226715,
0.35739728808403015,
-0.327190101146698,
0.5422872304916382,
0.021142560988664627,
-0.6940942406654358,
-0.8011612296104431,
0.24824295938014984,
-0.8437798619270325,
-0.40272045135498047,
1.0351884365081787,
0.05884537473320961,
-0.1535908579826355,
-0.5224183797836304,
-0.4298184812068939,
0.042869098484516144,
-0.3435061573982239,
0.6261084079742432,
0.8156453967094421,
-0.19336357712745667,
-0.042078398168087006,
-0.8706095814704895,
0.5388554930686951,
0.157111257314682,
-1.049004316329956,
0.15742938220500946,
0.5001653432846069,
0.4141121208667755,
0.28490763902664185,
0.850002646446228,
-0.1051996499300003,
0.22663122415542603,
-0.16615988314151764,
0.07302003353834152,
-0.21867749094963074,
-0.2545895576477051,
-0.14517885446548462,
0.004856031853705645,
0.3187270760536194,
0.37015223503112793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14660v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14660v2
|
ConceptMath: A Bilingual Concept-wise Benchmark for Measuring Mathematical Reasoning of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T16:06:49 | 2024-02-23T07:13:00 |
Yanan Wu, Jie Liu, Xingyuan Bu, Jiaheng Liu, Zhanhui Zhou, Yuanxing Zhang, Chenchen Zhang, Zhiqi Bai, Haibin Chen, Tiezheng Ge, Wanli Ouyang, Wenbo Su, Bo Zheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper introduces ConceptMath, a bilingual (English and Chinese),
fine-grained benchmark that evaluates concept-wise mathematical reasoning of
Large Language Models (LLMs). Unlike traditional benchmarks that evaluate
general mathematical reasoning with an average accuracy, ConceptMath
systematically organizes math problems under a hierarchy of math concepts, so
that mathematical reasoning can be evaluated at different granularity with
concept-wise accuracies. Based on our ConcepthMath, we evaluate a broad range
of LLMs, and we observe existing LLMs, though achieving high average accuracies
on traditional benchmarks, exhibit significant performance variations across
different math concepts and may even fail catastrophically on the most basic
ones. Besides, we also introduce an efficient fine-tuning strategy to enhance
the weaknesses of existing LLMs. Finally, we hope ConceptMath could guide the
developers to understand the fine-grained mathematical abilities of their
models and facilitate the growth of foundation models.
|
[
-0.3486345112323761,
-0.8714142441749573,
0.46377092599868774,
0.5384962558746338,
-0.26037970185279846,
0.24229413270950317,
-0.2758512496948242,
-0.27874523401260376,
0.1684759557247162,
0.23883752524852753,
-0.41992080211639404,
-0.6727399826049805,
-0.41539639234542847,
-0.11495745927095413,
-0.36608487367630005,
0.5149170160293579,
-0.3166694939136505,
0.3165926933288574,
-0.566340446472168,
-0.1649712473154068,
-0.49253058433532715,
-0.24745629727840424,
-0.5938027501106262,
-0.5505634546279907,
0.10352744907140732,
0.3596472442150116,
0.8954681754112244,
0.7835050225257874,
0.8229526877403259,
0.3068849742412567,
-0.09017680585384369,
0.2634413242340088,
-0.23897141218185425,
0.035838644951581955,
-0.40601226687431335,
-0.6437451243400574,
-0.6381763219833374,
-0.21078215539455414,
0.6235370635986328,
0.9383233785629272,
-0.3668989837169647,
0.19485528767108917,
-0.2880866825580597,
0.6454595327377319,
-0.5925661325454712,
0.30920717120170593,
-0.5954934358596802,
0.033192843198776245,
-0.3279338777065277,
-0.034032002091407776,
-0.07389800995588303,
-0.5165441036224365,
-0.08724839985370636,
-0.6566299200057983,
-0.01464892365038395,
-0.04983251914381981,
0.5710553526878357,
0.20003288984298706,
-0.057778242975473404,
-0.2642016112804413,
-0.47316354513168335,
0.9687607884407043,
-0.6552640199661255,
0.4773825407028198,
0.37957021594047546,
0.6512975692749023,
0.05291350558400154,
-0.46808546781539917,
-0.5067150592803955,
-0.17380209267139435,
0.3066061735153198,
0.15849684178829193,
-0.04388778284192085,
-0.29252147674560547,
0.2443045824766159,
0.568371593952179,
-0.5711676478385925,
0.17024418711662292,
-0.055901337414979935,
-0.24881437420845032,
0.83344966173172,
0.3577612340450287,
0.4662037789821625,
0.08122480660676956,
-0.07977286726236343,
0.016143614426255226,
-0.7482390999794006,
0.0028225344140082598,
0.10626343637704849,
0.39889928698539734,
-0.2661087214946747,
0.6515016555786133,
-0.367138147354126,
0.639348030090332,
-0.4349631667137146,
-0.3268465995788574,
0.1992231011390686,
-0.4005264639854431,
-0.1550177037715912,
0.03332114219665527,
0.5777981877326965,
0.29557716846466064,
0.6336943507194519,
-0.08839676529169083,
-0.28779056668281555,
0.5005818009376526,
-0.15417170524597168,
-1.0516208410263062,
-0.07605964690446854,
0.07366109639406204,
-0.1681755632162094,
0.017026541754603386,
-0.0007183362613432109,
-0.5471075773239136,
-0.16041244566440582,
-0.4461473822593689,
0.15564391016960144,
-0.5016421675682068,
-0.3682749271392822,
0.4440842866897583,
0.20389555394649506,
0.15906979143619537,
0.544106125831604,
-0.803317129611969,
0.47662368416786194,
1.3540010452270508,
0.9177452325820923,
-0.46530166268348694,
-0.4030764102935791,
-0.4910251498222351,
-0.11636864393949509,
-0.6744965314865112,
0.8670154213905334,
-0.5982713103294373,
-0.515378475189209,
-0.10208801180124283,
-0.4765338599681854,
-0.03152933716773987,
-0.8484857082366943,
0.7426694631576538,
-0.4707913398742676,
-0.08961760252714157,
-0.19339434802532196,
-0.6327769160270691,
-0.08590980619192123,
0.6211714148521423,
-0.42262452840805054,
0.9946882724761963,
0.11120115220546722,
-0.6084909439086914,
0.12155264616012573,
-0.5746294260025024,
-0.4149206876754761,
0.16622096300125122,
-0.2425927072763443,
-0.08263546973466873,
0.18770962953567505,
0.08649631589651108,
0.14267826080322266,
-0.8522577285766602,
0.5300799608230591,
-0.48673322796821594,
-0.33034563064575195,
0.1603306084871292,
-0.2901152968406677,
0.7924467325210571,
0.2693485617637634,
0.03364262729883194,
-0.06768353283405304,
-0.806069016456604,
0.234500914812088,
0.303276002407074,
0.07745660841464996,
-0.6157780289649963,
0.11204365640878677,
-0.040779467672109604,
0.21794724464416504,
0.4977802038192749,
-0.3823147416114807,
0.011465435847640038,
-0.4483916163444519,
0.3177938163280487,
0.497415155172348,
-0.27639496326446533,
0.17413964867591858,
-0.3922513723373413,
0.4916214942932129,
0.039841946214437485,
-0.23540885746479034,
-0.3852708637714386,
-0.5511176586151123,
-0.7136847972869873,
-0.4326983392238617,
0.6126243472099304,
0.606633186340332,
-0.5058648586273193,
0.3994812071323395,
-0.3571948707103729,
-0.6995953917503357,
-0.4108079671859741,
0.32584404945373535,
0.4318093955516815,
0.5016093254089355,
0.3319334089756012,
-0.21705661714076996,
-0.16402749717235565,
-0.9246481657028198,
-0.3911212384700775,
-0.17229454219341278,
-0.029497571289539337,
0.22674404084682465,
0.5919662117958069,
-0.25087815523147583,
0.8647167086601257,
-0.45393800735473633,
0.006165547762066126,
-0.04273759201169014,
0.15804454684257507,
0.34417372941970825,
0.3613109886646271,
0.45315292477607727,
-0.6780276894569397,
-0.530204713344574,
0.327944815158844,
-0.6961259841918945,
-0.35859403014183044,
0.1656993329524994,
-0.2595745623111725,
-0.047864172607660294,
0.4032317101955414,
-0.7211951613426208,
0.03746877610683441,
0.513076901435852,
-0.40658482909202576,
0.7288147211074829,
-0.02185986004769802,
-0.10763531923294067,
-1.1699150800704956,
-0.027328668162226677,
0.24669800698757172,
-0.04313160851597786,
-0.3213832676410675,
0.5911503434181213,
0.22806183993816376,
0.02643347717821598,
-0.24452443420886993,
0.7807536125183105,
-0.09923619776964188,
-0.2383085936307907,
-0.05643313750624657,
0.2763712406158447,
-0.05813504010438919,
0.06693176180124283,
0.09006033092737198,
0.9117156863212585,
0.68714839220047,
-0.5751036405563354,
0.5423516631126404,
0.1397373527288437,
-0.5068022608757019,
1.143031358718872,
-0.8285663723945618,
-0.2926216423511505,
0.1769484430551529,
0.07279245555400848,
-0.6682079434394836,
-0.13110071420669556,
-0.2958439290523529,
-0.36770233511924744,
0.08342374116182327,
0.26904594898223877,
-0.8771216869354248,
-0.3527907133102417,
-0.25410157442092896,
0.5962806940078735,
0.2694247364997864,
-0.44015318155288696,
0.4254031181335449,
0.24347925186157227,
-0.2785373628139496,
-0.31823256611824036,
-0.7583920955657959,
-0.1347290277481079,
-0.148066908121109,
-0.852519690990448,
0.4308115541934967,
-0.234812930226326,
-0.7049265503883362,
0.005952994804829359,
-0.4062063992023468,
-0.20601893961429596,
0.31771615147590637,
-0.21646499633789062,
0.30071574449539185,
-0.6812008023262024,
0.13009172677993774,
0.0035236685071140528,
-0.3677104711532593,
0.3714241087436676,
-0.08804035931825638,
0.5726596713066101,
-0.36339330673217773,
-0.6904419660568237,
-0.10954907536506653,
0.06850223988294601,
0.5857735276222229,
-0.3882397711277008,
0.2545280158519745,
0.17847825586795807,
-0.7048047780990601,
-0.3404761254787445,
-0.32932865619659424,
0.13268758356571198,
-0.39201483130455017,
0.5049248933792114,
-0.7280129194259644,
-0.681500256061554,
0.7581244707107544,
-0.35289984941482544,
0.05988506227731705,
0.7657805681228638,
0.7696936726570129,
0.16139137744903564,
0.9768974184989929,
0.3094882667064667,
-0.08692876249551773,
-0.05009546875953674,
-0.19940529763698578,
0.09196889400482178,
-0.553450345993042,
-0.0374816469848156,
-0.6268266439437866,
-0.19970378279685974,
-0.5300439596176147,
-0.8308148980140686,
0.05763881281018257,
0.4051523506641388,
-0.442508727312088,
0.2659498453140259,
-0.14921258389949799,
0.7602185606956482,
0.18823060393333435,
-0.36776572465896606,
0.6922591924667358,
-0.17958134412765503,
-0.5533136129379272,
-0.25967973470687866,
-0.37045156955718994,
-0.46381378173828125,
0.9477478265762329,
0.369646817445755,
0.6624721884727478,
0.26630786061286926,
0.5561232566833496,
-0.0478188656270504,
0.3548775315284729,
-0.9973155856132507,
0.6149206161499023,
-0.19748808443546295,
-0.5845268964767456,
-0.18614232540130615,
-0.7570051550865173,
-0.5868716239929199,
0.40809309482574463,
0.07964139431715012,
-0.802068293094635,
-0.22846990823745728,
-0.2066313475370407,
-0.24143832921981812,
0.22465069591999054,
-0.5242693424224854,
0.8992624878883362,
-0.4735245406627655,
-0.24059493839740753,
-0.5399013161659241,
-0.04306863248348236,
0.6651629209518433,
-0.5753725171089172,
0.3806745111942291,
-0.5547481179237366,
-0.18177850544452667,
0.5191864967346191,
-0.6063932180404663,
0.4595549702644348,
0.08105636388063431,
-0.4860796332359314,
0.155155211687088,
0.6260439157485962,
0.1605629324913025,
0.29290899634361267,
-0.20929166674613953,
0.47368770837783813,
0.14936022460460663,
-0.4515429735183716,
-0.6476362943649292,
0.8499146699905396,
-0.7324280142784119,
-0.6469603180885315,
-0.33863648772239685,
-0.8673828840255737,
-0.6272175312042236,
0.2793711721897125,
-0.07152757793664932,
0.23780983686447144,
-0.39723947644233704,
0.30952268838882446,
0.5594967603683472,
-0.06522463262081146,
0.23606814444065094,
0.7104425430297852,
-0.44731980562210083,
-0.26978152990341187,
1.0684410333633423,
0.0011495730141177773,
0.20336803793907166,
0.681231677532196,
0.38471880555152893,
-0.41145309805870056,
-0.425654798746109,
-0.47529929876327515,
0.2461182028055191,
-0.6058858633041382,
-0.3441401422023773,
-0.2715696394443512,
-0.46509575843811035,
0.10617446899414062,
-0.12278512120246887,
-0.8106096386909485,
-0.4998822808265686,
0.11650949716567993,
0.22384662926197052,
0.16562987864017487,
0.168131485581398,
0.18093173205852509,
0.11584160476922989,
-0.6477203369140625,
0.600370466709137,
0.42801663279533386,
0.7117893099784851,
-0.06845410168170929,
-0.5687055587768555,
-0.1277434378862381,
0.22762899100780487,
-0.3744369149208069,
-0.2885551154613495,
0.01800573244690895,
0.14247041940689087,
0.5858450531959534,
0.5837481617927551,
-0.19173836708068848,
0.744742751121521,
-0.5730778574943542,
0.4290386736392975,
0.4010678827762604,
-1.2645385265350342,
0.5515527725219727,
-0.4162859320640564,
0.510351836681366,
0.41582831740379333,
0.13986173272132874,
-0.6364638209342957,
-0.18141280114650726,
-0.40153542160987854,
-0.43071621656417847,
0.5786939263343811,
0.2072676122188568,
0.1952974498271942,
0.018357401713728905,
-0.17089004814624786,
0.1015549972653389,
0.06814287602901459,
-0.3135700821876526,
-0.2793816328048706,
-0.028340673074126244,
-0.2531704008579254,
-0.21249760687351227,
-0.03298778459429741,
-0.16448818147182465,
-0.5339211821556091,
0.4187423586845398,
-0.3555258512496948,
-0.10367411375045776,
-0.31968995928764343,
-0.17067916691303253,
-0.18295788764953613,
0.185750350356102,
0.7062672972679138,
1.1171787977218628,
-0.14427709579467773,
0.10320965945720673,
0.33580854535102844,
-0.41606104373931885,
-0.0021313242614269257,
0.36494573950767517,
-0.12483514100313187,
0.06525156646966934,
0.5080465078353882,
0.5542869567871094,
0.4966728687286377,
-0.9020264744758606,
0.3343227207660675,
0.04666657745838165,
-0.4291142523288727,
0.04585467651486397,
0.0789528638124466,
0.5592926740646362,
0.16963133215904236,
0.29508736729621887,
-0.00000907271805772325,
-0.114666648209095,
-0.6253096461296082,
0.12985622882843018,
0.5392933487892151,
0.12022219598293304,
-0.3052956163883209,
0.6129410862922668,
0.16324754059314728,
-0.4417816698551178,
0.22760015726089478,
-0.13741861283779144,
-0.4423150420188904,
0.9542359709739685,
0.7466200590133667,
0.7803656458854675,
-0.34853240847587585,
0.31664109230041504,
0.4085984528064728,
0.19699011743068695,
-0.28952816128730774,
0.3924057185649872,
-0.16196639835834503,
-1.0113210678100586,
-0.4751121699810028,
-0.7677287459373474,
-0.7090017795562744,
-0.09575236588716507,
-0.6293951272964478,
0.3454994857311249,
-0.5060734152793884,
0.13454154133796692,
0.34404459595680237,
0.2777101397514343,
-0.5257274508476257,
0.25875169038772583,
0.24849697947502136,
1.3803391456604004,
-0.5808793306350708,
0.8204942941665649,
0.8750621676445007,
-0.032018885016441345,
-0.45959240198135376,
-0.01960446499288082,
-0.013220854103565216,
-1.1488261222839355,
0.5349035263061523,
0.23986750841140747,
-0.12437181919813156,
-0.14188136160373688,
-0.16114544868469238,
-0.8444069623947144,
1.0074700117111206,
0.5063287019729614,
-0.7565644979476929,
0.34328144788742065,
0.46745413541793823,
0.8048321008682251,
-0.4285781979560852,
0.3255804479122162,
0.8666346073150635,
0.5197592973709106,
0.3614342212677002,
-1.0297703742980957,
-0.1895904392004013,
-0.5324916243553162,
0.1740735024213791,
0.2941974103450775,
-0.7194722294807434,
0.8587745428085327,
-0.12084215134382248,
-0.22326651215553284,
0.025141626596450806,
0.472535640001297,
0.795876145362854,
0.6199439167976379,
0.35674262046813965,
0.9551998376846313,
0.7976182103157043,
-0.39765435457229614,
0.9233702421188354,
-0.5228915214538574,
0.35205528140068054,
0.9590784311294556,
-0.5101637244224548,
0.8976247310638428,
0.24038948118686676,
-0.4988126754760742,
0.39428070187568665,
0.684445321559906,
0.10928849130868912,
0.2552107274532318,
0.409881055355072,
0.04884054884314537,
-0.5508444905281067,
-0.1733010709285736,
-0.7113149166107178,
0.5363316535949707,
0.5481105446815491,
0.19782644510269165,
-0.5648460984230042,
-0.6390115022659302,
-0.06732221692800522,
0.42088332772254944,
-0.5644522905349731,
0.4238675534725189,
0.4488148093223572,
-0.6071574687957764,
0.7035963535308838,
0.36420297622680664,
0.6209298372268677,
-0.6276860237121582,
0.20753198862075806,
-0.6409871578216553,
0.31606608629226685,
-0.1577528864145279,
-0.8571042418479919,
0.3268398642539978,
0.11442283540964127,
-0.09454430639743805,
0.11893686652183533,
0.29989495873451233,
-0.4350253641605377,
-0.8982866406440735,
0.3592933714389801,
0.8560852408409119,
-0.10886528342962265,
-0.06432740390300751,
-0.9285768866539001,
0.07099290937185287,
-0.43186190724372864,
0.035896625369787216,
0.2001732736825943,
0.8079074621200562,
-0.47629815340042114,
0.8352406024932861,
0.676587700843811,
0.28270605206489563,
-0.2659214437007904,
0.3671747148036957,
0.6359332799911499,
-0.7338442206382751,
-0.7277507185935974,
-1.0814064741134644,
0.05900223180651665,
-0.01585790328681469,
-0.4389530122280121,
0.7474488615989685,
0.7647804021835327,
1.0005244016647339,
0.10056719183921814,
0.4640372395515442,
0.33645954728126526,
0.5096069574356079,
-0.42756569385528564,
0.4478285312652588,
-0.7749941945075989,
0.2733449339866638,
-0.2112596333026886,
-1.3441203832626343,
-0.5334785580635071,
0.5780045986175537,
-0.3140469789505005,
0.06866393983364105,
0.7787519693374634,
0.6232647895812988,
-0.4570704996585846,
0.21949023008346558,
0.5228475332260132,
0.060083769261837006,
-0.043231356889009476,
0.7215235829353333,
0.8792890906333923,
-0.23564468324184418,
0.14227348566055298,
-0.17502693831920624,
-0.08632452040910721,
-0.1505449116230011,
-0.7454226613044739,
-0.9789543747901917,
-0.18154214322566986,
-0.44858765602111816,
-0.08022971451282501,
-0.2933586537837982,
0.8495218753814697,
0.4859059453010559,
-1.1267307996749878,
-0.5066713094711304,
-0.2255544364452362,
0.34767618775367737,
-0.2702834904193878,
-0.23955881595611572,
0.29264843463897705,
-0.291535347700119,
-0.8483225107192993,
0.10624900460243225,
0.5155980587005615,
-0.11510144919157028,
-0.40932759642601013,
-0.36034396290779114,
0.15804296731948853,
0.343818336725235,
0.5428217053413391,
0.20197612047195435,
-0.8133074045181274,
0.21912121772766113,
-0.10642906278371811,
-0.34354329109191895,
-0.02142169512808323,
0.8597826957702637,
-0.36450743675231934,
0.5832716822624207,
0.4859890043735504,
0.9723711609840393,
0.30358999967575073,
-0.022809792309999466,
0.508223831653595,
-0.517668604850769,
0.2535768747329712,
0.15489695966243744,
0.5364814400672913,
0.32561999559402466,
0.1308043748140335,
0.675359845161438,
0.3746630847454071,
0.05449821054935455,
-0.9990839958190918,
0.1758490800857544,
-0.8169004917144775,
-0.19575083255767822,
1.0182429552078247,
-0.06317336857318878,
-0.06493199616670609,
0.26000872254371643,
0.11638347804546356,
-0.1459561139345169,
-0.14882197976112366,
0.8354019522666931,
1.0438673496246338,
0.3399025797843933,
-0.018107788637280464,
-0.6369858384132385,
0.15288406610488892,
0.5773659944534302,
-1.1224192380905151,
0.06171262636780739,
0.22661420702934265,
0.10466118156909943,
0.3325488865375519,
0.4654392600059509,
-0.14117734134197235,
0.5487484931945801,
0.07705506682395935,
-0.12168221175670624,
0.07966700941324234,
-0.24488306045532227,
-0.11672690510749817,
-0.047770604491233826,
-0.09465417265892029,
0.045738399028778076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14658v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14658v2
|
OpenCodeInterpreter: Integrating Code Generation with Execution and Refinement
| 2024-02-22T16:06:23 | 2024-02-28T03:15:24 |
Tianyu Zheng, Ge Zhang, Tianhao Shen, Xueling Liu, Bill Yuchen Lin, Jie Fu, Wenhu Chen, Xiang Yue
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The introduction of large language models has significantly advanced code
generation. However, open-source models often lack the execution capabilities
and iterative refinement of advanced systems like the GPT-4 Code Interpreter.
To address this, we introduce OpenCodeInterpreter, a family of open-source code
systems designed for generating, executing, and iteratively refining code.
Supported by Code-Feedback, a dataset featuring 68K multi-turn interactions,
OpenCodeInterpreter integrates execution and human feedback for dynamic code
refinement. Our comprehensive evaluation of OpenCodeInterpreter across key
benchmarks such as HumanEval, MBPP, and their enhanced versions from EvalPlus
reveals its exceptional performance. Notably, OpenCodeInterpreter-33B achieves
an accuracy of 83.2 (76.4) on the average (and plus versions) of HumanEval and
MBPP, closely rivaling GPT-4's 84.2 (76.2) and further elevates to 91.6 (84.6)
with synthesized human feedback from GPT-4. OpenCodeInterpreter brings the gap
between open-source code generation models and proprietary systems like GPT-4
Code Interpreter.
|
[
-0.38139358162879944,
-0.2530529499053955,
0.3122859299182892,
0.2764826714992523,
0.00032203117734752595,
0.21581171452999115,
-0.48295924067497253,
-0.37626683712005615,
-0.14967775344848633,
0.36875590682029724,
-0.3570694029331207,
-0.48556792736053467,
-0.02450796402990818,
0.1261284202337265,
-0.03242545202374458,
1.1186648607254028,
-0.3793218731880188,
0.11090970039367676,
-0.0097250547260046,
-0.19957853853702545,
-0.4744354784488678,
-0.4528881311416626,
-0.04091355949640274,
-0.25041136145591736,
0.21029651165008545,
0.5224308371543884,
0.6788023710250854,
0.4240401089191437,
0.5381296277046204,
0.24400396645069122,
0.536803662776947,
-0.05688205361366272,
-0.6378216743469238,
0.04215104505419731,
-0.3450313210487366,
-0.3634088635444641,
-0.18357938528060913,
-0.13335001468658447,
0.19899842143058777,
0.044580139219760895,
-0.26523709297180176,
0.4117254316806793,
0.033966027200222015,
0.7264212965965271,
-0.816015899181366,
0.28636112809181213,
-0.30522358417510986,
0.009436875581741333,
-0.15746241807937622,
-0.2941247820854187,
-0.3140767514705658,
-0.923226535320282,
-0.18023724853992462,
-0.3734109699726105,
0.1570647656917572,
-0.3838743269443512,
0.5203955769538879,
0.4935508668422699,
0.258318156003952,
-0.33620595932006836,
-1.0500062704086304,
0.431863397359848,
-0.8659842014312744,
0.357791006565094,
-0.2655322551727295,
0.32338088750839233,
-0.021363822743296623,
-1.0827512741088867,
-0.5341286659240723,
-0.3034195303916931,
0.1566755622625351,
0.06833206862211227,
-0.32499930262565613,
0.16227202117443085,
0.42629265785217285,
0.7478354573249817,
-0.45201751589775085,
-0.0450420156121254,
-0.6157813668251038,
0.0009147516102530062,
0.3197416663169861,
0.08831418305635452,
0.1390184462070465,
0.1868605762720108,
-0.10214816778898239,
0.12367977946996689,
-0.7635407447814941,
0.04604022204875946,
0.5614603161811829,
-0.14948274195194244,
0.1390397846698761,
0.6427860856056213,
-0.32797685265541077,
0.546720564365387,
-0.024873696267604828,
0.32427147030830383,
0.42019543051719666,
-0.4530791938304901,
-0.09436654299497604,
-0.10222120583057404,
0.6574685573577881,
0.4551568627357483,
0.4356054365634918,
-0.042184896767139435,
-0.47743409872055054,
0.37880054116249084,
0.6719198822975159,
-1.1658751964569092,
-0.6880062818527222,
0.2527477741241455,
-0.4476851224899292,
-0.3521724045276642,
0.6023105382919312,
-0.7780013084411621,
0.03760259225964546,
-0.2989920377731323,
0.22390493750572205,
-0.5240539312362671,
-0.3455384075641632,
0.1654031127691269,
-0.16072332859039307,
0.250221312046051,
0.29610326886177063,
-0.6769334077835083,
0.24555641412734985,
0.6960501670837402,
0.7906066179275513,
0.15839757025241852,
-0.2897008955478668,
-0.7200746536254883,
-0.04960380494594574,
-0.3600956201553345,
0.4092072546482086,
-0.71502685546875,
-0.12460416555404663,
-0.10772664844989777,
-0.23053933680057526,
0.22090573608875275,
-0.5973820686340332,
0.20972850918769836,
-0.6147680878639221,
0.13474710285663605,
0.13269764184951782,
-0.32433754205703735,
-0.17671142518520355,
-0.06295375525951385,
-0.4941879212856293,
1.1374455690383911,
0.6641026139259338,
-0.7151108980178833,
0.3323265314102173,
-1.089654803276062,
-0.00739611592143774,
0.3984510898590088,
-0.4242820739746094,
-0.2525542378425598,
0.3586135804653168,
0.18951688706874847,
-0.04007003456354141,
-0.2458757758140564,
0.17381052672863007,
-0.21665267646312714,
-0.6667646169662476,
0.03897182270884514,
-0.06529063731431961,
0.40330010652542114,
0.36704763770103455,
-0.6347765326499939,
0.3973754346370697,
-0.6101170778274536,
0.4455757737159729,
-0.17093315720558167,
-0.48840776085853577,
-0.013514941558241844,
-0.06068212911486626,
-0.133634552359581,
0.10014164447784424,
0.1293840855360031,
-0.6849378943443298,
0.5387201905250549,
-0.21369893848896027,
0.6191134452819824,
0.6758761405944824,
0.11301776021718979,
0.18294022977352142,
-0.09142466634511948,
0.9097746014595032,
-0.2232602834701538,
0.28254589438438416,
-0.41288748383522034,
-0.5586135983467102,
-0.32919761538505554,
-0.1398150473833084,
0.39425092935562134,
0.5424085259437561,
-0.7734118103981018,
0.337886244058609,
-0.19026030600070953,
-0.45299556851387024,
-0.8413057923316956,
0.3014484941959381,
0.6939730644226074,
0.16406384110450745,
0.2762259244918823,
-0.5932543873786926,
-0.5888169407844543,
-0.7411433458328247,
-0.3538813591003418,
-0.19561894237995148,
-0.1863742619752884,
-0.1969245821237564,
0.4304778575897217,
-0.5886869430541992,
1.1001100540161133,
-0.731371283531189,
0.22253738343715668,
-0.034080155193805695,
0.16167283058166504,
0.3008117079734802,
0.7243526577949524,
0.5836400389671326,
-0.4051581621170044,
-0.25863298773765564,
0.1796492338180542,
-0.4807225465774536,
-0.24193894863128662,
0.2636672854423523,
-0.09861008822917938,
0.15914514660835266,
0.5354859828948975,
-0.18213827908039093,
0.400378555059433,
0.5955642461776733,
-0.08421571552753448,
0.8072353005409241,
-0.26144352555274963,
0.17384585738182068,
-0.7708126306533813,
0.34567952156066895,
-0.259679913520813,
-0.04258430376648903,
-0.36847150325775146,
0.6895630359649658,
0.25492116808891296,
-0.20708627998828888,
-0.34996941685676575,
0.09480428695678711,
-0.35266023874282837,
-0.12293843924999237,
0.0553772933781147,
-0.315515398979187,
-0.1216416209936142,
0.45720601081848145,
-0.1956808716058731,
1.1242107152938843,
0.1787804216146469,
-0.41252952814102173,
0.4249553084373474,
-0.00745618250221014,
-0.581744909286499,
0.1979461908340454,
-0.7502300143241882,
0.47066420316696167,
0.14761291444301605,
0.05696503445506096,
-0.5237517356872559,
-0.5042959451675415,
0.2991802990436554,
-0.38652923703193665,
0.14254920184612274,
-0.4483129382133484,
-0.6012991070747375,
-0.7694225907325745,
-0.5828736424446106,
0.3429357707500458,
0.6688812971115112,
-0.6326708793640137,
0.24927537143230438,
-0.10697472095489502,
-0.2775140106678009,
-0.48022836446762085,
-0.46892234683036804,
0.024312961846590042,
0.3853529691696167,
-0.4957045316696167,
0.05686115473508835,
-0.3117941915988922,
-0.2982805669307709,
0.24065062403678894,
-0.10144989937543869,
0.060196805745363235,
-0.2796764075756073,
0.311806321144104,
0.28775832056999207,
-0.4351852536201477,
0.07721393555402756,
-0.04481201618909836,
-0.22217050194740295,
-0.05996976047754288,
-0.6040864586830139,
0.5347754955291748,
-0.5148978233337402,
-0.6212954521179199,
-0.17996659874916077,
0.011618231423199177,
0.6752355694770813,
-0.6680223345756531,
0.17299553751945496,
0.5405257344245911,
-0.10925394296646118,
-0.04787397384643555,
-0.5897347331047058,
0.012470832094550133,
-0.4675685167312622,
0.20777860283851624,
-0.6330901384353638,
-0.8502856492996216,
0.35738712549209595,
-0.13054193556308746,
0.2820982038974762,
0.13454569876194,
0.6705830097198486,
0.5564078092575073,
1.0051413774490356,
0.6356200575828552,
0.016972407698631287,
0.6038408875465393,
-0.2441733032464981,
0.23804950714111328,
-0.7296478748321533,
-0.12821954488754272,
-0.5457253456115723,
-0.23556998372077942,
-0.6253304481506348,
-0.5696355104446411,
0.18655884265899658,
0.30763694643974304,
-0.4240136742591858,
0.44906729459762573,
-0.9534886479377747,
0.7424286603927612,
0.7869336605072021,
0.15392452478408813,
0.28134891390800476,
-0.2623322904109955,
-0.0620991475880146,
0.04854040592908859,
-0.5659509301185608,
-0.6367896199226379,
1.1078816652297974,
0.403971403837204,
1.1519196033477783,
0.13567106425762177,
0.834190845489502,
0.09575894474983215,
0.7597571015357971,
-0.41325658559799194,
0.22266922891139984,
0.0890345349907875,
-0.2770729064941406,
0.1418321430683136,
-0.4650670886039734,
-0.4151889979839325,
-0.15575601160526276,
0.35522499680519104,
-0.6386107802391052,
0.18308313190937042,
0.3613505959510803,
-0.5417139530181885,
0.17305797338485718,
-0.980953574180603,
0.9906467199325562,
-0.046758078038692474,
-0.5726857781410217,
-0.10867328941822052,
-0.4113084375858307,
0.4446101784706116,
-0.09079404175281525,
-0.037082407623529434,
0.17936433851718903,
-0.09720370918512344,
0.21094244718551636,
-0.8659713864326477,
0.5728444457054138,
-0.5265161991119385,
-0.19851259887218475,
0.45356515049934387,
0.21255835890769958,
0.4736705720424652,
0.1835176944732666,
-0.2687356770038605,
-0.006558549124747515,
-0.06464244425296783,
-0.23830661177635193,
-0.543398380279541,
0.9070784449577332,
-0.5275026559829712,
-0.30269578099250793,
0.0527864433825016,
-0.26757797598838806,
0.04096664488315582,
0.29245877265930176,
0.4935896694660187,
0.6408222317695618,
-0.15776598453521729,
0.12659543752670288,
0.3313416540622711,
-0.2750903069972992,
0.2679038345813751,
0.4668715298175812,
-0.4566824734210968,
-0.7444027662277222,
0.845221996307373,
-0.24680308997631073,
0.2646036744117737,
0.11277616769075394,
0.04448850080370903,
-0.08404141664505005,
-0.4248427152633667,
-0.7993460297584534,
0.019228367134928703,
-0.581076979637146,
-0.3889380991458893,
-0.5577296018600464,
-0.09451472759246826,
-0.3301575183868408,
-0.36109280586242676,
-0.2625671923160553,
-0.2653979957103729,
0.08842555433511734,
-0.05994376167654991,
0.525933563709259,
1.223867416381836,
-0.08191566914319992,
0.16699129343032837,
-0.988486111164093,
0.2472054809331894,
0.0935409739613533,
0.9515304565429688,
-0.17300361394882202,
0.035020437091588974,
-0.4181228280067444,
-0.12188660353422165,
-0.47199076414108276,
-0.6649776101112366,
0.11056245118379593,
0.08328060805797577,
0.24048888683319092,
0.34803494811058044,
0.1820235401391983,
0.5654839873313904,
-0.42757388949394226,
0.8209928274154663,
0.17262355983257294,
-1.1202375888824463,
0.6031923890113831,
-0.24683654308319092,
0.696465015411377,
0.8553207516670227,
0.10249436646699905,
-0.25879430770874023,
-0.6459846496582031,
-0.38651859760284424,
-0.5475975871086121,
0.7333846092224121,
0.24645008146762848,
-0.13798758387565613,
0.027305250987410545,
0.35890403389930725,
0.2910350263118744,
0.45357856154441833,
-0.6433873176574707,
0.433359831571579,
-0.5307186245918274,
-0.2324896603822708,
0.0030406767036765814,
0.08608287572860718,
0.055478762835264206,
-0.22199463844299316,
0.3910136818885803,
-0.4105871319770813,
0.37882816791534424,
0.14975561201572418,
-0.15547755360603333,
-0.411252498626709,
0.25655192136764526,
0.6459597945213318,
0.9339096546173096,
-0.3121207654476166,
-0.05730350688099861,
-0.20099759101867676,
-0.5046421885490417,
0.04765394702553749,
0.08734070509672165,
-0.10174364596605301,
-0.056007541716098785,
0.3256725072860718,
0.6427499055862427,
0.24816367030143738,
-0.7352690696716309,
0.5961408019065857,
-0.0037194991018623114,
-0.12892287969589233,
-0.1744077354669571,
0.2927485704421997,
-0.07531015574932098,
0.3534903824329376,
0.11225507408380508,
0.47333481907844543,
0.14466767013072968,
-0.5993757247924805,
0.3180358111858368,
-0.044256750494241714,
-0.5066558122634888,
-0.5464792847633362,
0.8430368900299072,
0.32347118854522705,
-0.2836630046367645,
0.7914729118347168,
-0.25746962428092957,
-0.7249676585197449,
0.39925941824913025,
0.2816181778907776,
1.227555274963379,
-0.3645611107349396,
-0.2016393393278122,
0.5454356074333191,
0.30366599559783936,
0.007833930663764477,
0.7546753883361816,
-0.1978655755519867,
-0.31105560064315796,
-0.7415705323219299,
-0.6829559206962585,
-0.4508610963821411,
-0.21971365809440613,
-0.6610511541366577,
0.4978472888469696,
-0.45216861367225647,
0.05821175128221512,
-0.15023648738861084,
-0.3816058039665222,
-0.7024238705635071,
-0.32534632086753845,
-0.3007137179374695,
1.2011889219284058,
-0.24835726618766785,
0.8246627449989319,
0.8974019885063171,
-0.776820957660675,
-0.7689629793167114,
0.30209240317344666,
-0.098717100918293,
-0.5024268627166748,
0.5984612107276917,
0.4394949674606323,
-0.2302495241165161,
0.2176814079284668,
-0.5062726736068726,
-0.29755502939224243,
0.8516227602958679,
0.3548043966293335,
-0.6878482699394226,
-0.1874820590019226,
-0.18240691721439362,
0.5891865491867065,
-0.3074164390563965,
0.4741567075252533,
0.4640509784221649,
0.5213427543640137,
-0.25313135981559753,
-0.9203394651412964,
-0.0743144154548645,
-0.49363014101982117,
0.20544663071632385,
0.6218822598457336,
-0.4714033007621765,
0.7467827796936035,
-0.6389633417129517,
-0.08142437785863876,
0.2828088700771332,
0.26018771529197693,
0.01974223181605339,
0.11199537664651871,
0.2190343588590622,
0.6102045774459839,
0.31887558102607727,
-0.1683584302663803,
1.1067496538162231,
-0.7820609211921692,
0.2963530719280243,
0.981566846370697,
-0.34180501103401184,
0.7743407487869263,
0.1318970024585724,
-0.16198673844337463,
0.7521806955337524,
0.28017523884773254,
-0.04869547486305237,
0.37493082880973816,
0.44242405891418457,
-0.329985111951828,
0.352389395236969,
0.42876532673835754,
-0.5064241290092468,
0.18127818405628204,
0.17183147370815277,
-0.23616908490657806,
-0.14855439960956573,
0.024795832112431526,
-0.029763368889689445,
-0.014978675171732903,
-0.15100982785224915,
0.8463488817214966,
-0.2792113423347473,
-1.012855052947998,
0.6405493021011353,
-0.03057500161230564,
0.6399622559547424,
-0.6435887217521667,
-0.3489063084125519,
-0.10588960349559784,
0.7166591286659241,
-0.4800480008125305,
-0.8648219108581543,
0.41070809960365295,
0.22476130723953247,
-0.06429050862789154,
-0.17223915457725525,
0.46156126260757446,
-0.2877279818058014,
0.10142063349485397,
0.38828644156455994,
0.14917215704917908,
-0.07473329454660416,
-0.30936986207962036,
-0.36610114574432373,
0.3759268820285797,
0.3102392852306366,
-0.24559032917022705,
-0.029052557423710823,
0.48939210176467896,
0.02616250328719616,
0.3100183606147766,
0.6373327374458313,
-0.01840970292687416,
0.15378917753696442,
0.0180643480271101,
1.1846535205841064,
-0.6732152104377747,
-0.3884705901145935,
-0.7136629223823547,
0.38334670662879944,
0.022369489073753357,
-0.4609333574771881,
0.5461099147796631,
0.9396765232086182,
1.1614651679992676,
-0.4731826186180115,
0.9257256388664246,
-0.3212510943412781,
0.4465934932231903,
-0.39792993664741516,
0.36046311259269714,
0.004335206001996994,
0.3435317873954773,
-0.48448479175567627,
-1.2099140882492065,
-0.11576174199581146,
0.333067387342453,
-0.26580631732940674,
0.011767758056521416,
0.5507612824440002,
0.9901522397994995,
-0.1370651125907898,
0.20194923877716064,
0.005602526478469372,
-0.00449623167514801,
0.5934880375862122,
0.42721375823020935,
0.9597249627113342,
-0.1320551633834839,
0.5855775475502014,
-0.3526782691478729,
-0.6879567503929138,
-0.39758822321891785,
-0.7505534291267395,
-0.4061130881309509,
-0.2590043544769287,
-0.21713963150978088,
-0.4129205644130707,
0.15915846824645996,
1.015107274055481,
0.6938013434410095,
-0.7641533613204956,
-0.3687182068824768,
-0.4454048275947571,
-0.4366244077682495,
-0.3304506242275238,
-0.33231452107429504,
-0.290995717048645,
-0.6673456430435181,
-0.6758142113685608,
0.35436001420021057,
0.5541407465934753,
-0.32464268803596497,
-0.4221571087837219,
-0.417095422744751,
0.3021906912326813,
-0.07011031359434128,
0.5978823900222778,
0.5229923725128174,
-0.6286637783050537,
-0.22401675581932068,
-0.16286547482013702,
0.0106207812204957,
0.13277244567871094,
1.3912659883499146,
-0.8865523934364319,
0.7521747350692749,
0.5369457006454468,
0.5095400810241699,
0.38301825523376465,
0.229221373796463,
1.0245237350463867,
-0.66796875,
-0.10110008716583252,
0.34772789478302,
0.12857863306999207,
0.0704396590590477,
-0.24164235591888428,
0.9424248933792114,
0.049827344715595245,
-0.7228376865386963,
-0.7908402681350708,
0.3752373456954956,
-0.43994781374931335,
-0.08509276807308197,
0.728252649307251,
-0.1640404313802719,
0.06844187527894974,
-0.10762810707092285,
-0.5714880228042603,
-0.032998111099004745,
-0.6724305152893066,
0.26692160964012146,
0.39237040281295776,
-0.3536355495452881,
-0.25400519371032715,
-0.7390491962432861,
0.3747248649597168,
-0.14112167060375214,
-0.8404061198234558,
0.20973771810531616,
0.7410575151443481,
0.26577067375183105,
0.34480515122413635,
0.7226788401603699,
-0.490316778421402,
0.604229211807251,
0.13233724236488342,
0.8692137598991394,
-0.26784080266952515,
-0.1460718810558319,
-0.42529553174972534,
0.1320156306028366,
0.36819466948509216,
-0.1854795217514038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14652v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14652v3
|
Cleaner Pretraining Corpus Curation with Neural Web Scraping
| 2024-02-22T16:04:03 | 2024-06-15T03:05:54 |
Zhipeng Xu, Zhenghao Liu, Yukun Yan, Zhiyuan Liu, Ge Yu, Chenyan Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The web contains large-scale, diverse, and abundant information to satisfy
the information-seeking needs of humans. Through meticulous data collection,
preprocessing, and curation, webpages can be used as a fundamental data
resource for language model pretraining. However, when confronted with the
progressively revolutionized and intricate nature of webpages,
rule-based/feature-based web scrapers are becoming increasingly inadequate.
This paper presents a simple, fast, and effective Neural web Scraper
(NeuScraper) to help extract primary and clean text contents from webpages.
Experimental results show that NeuScraper surpasses the baseline scrapers by
achieving more than a 20% improvement, demonstrating its potential in
extracting higher-quality data to facilitate the language model pretraining.
All of the code is available at https://github.com/OpenMatch/NeuScraper.
|
[
-0.3401808738708496,
-0.649002194404602,
0.18024252355098724,
0.08351396024227142,
-0.26027074456214905,
0.08915738761425018,
-0.49578261375427246,
-0.31105777621269226,
0.42109471559524536,
0.419497013092041,
-0.2510654926300049,
-0.42786848545074463,
-0.48222076892852783,
-0.034931786358356476,
-0.8676746487617493,
1.2200539112091064,
0.46243563294410706,
0.05525452643632889,
-0.22267642617225647,
0.2069738656282425,
-0.11815350502729416,
-0.43144938349723816,
-0.8798407316207886,
-0.133070170879364,
0.7175354957580566,
0.4004274904727936,
0.5468921065330505,
0.5746515989303589,
0.5101161003112793,
0.41723138093948364,
0.02781282179057598,
0.12188923358917236,
-0.46363845467567444,
0.2548084259033203,
-0.5535386204719543,
-0.36198145151138306,
-0.4222606420516968,
0.08320596814155579,
0.31933027505874634,
0.7225202918052673,
-0.21618400514125824,
0.24669858813285828,
0.4177183508872986,
0.48188546299934387,
-0.8251979947090149,
-0.2643907070159912,
-0.6418687701225281,
-0.2065241038799286,
-0.4602468013763428,
-0.2555961012840271,
-0.43493467569351196,
-0.7148723006248474,
0.21520225703716278,
-1.043869137763977,
0.3263789713382721,
-0.21995799243450165,
1.2250595092773438,
0.24034741520881653,
-0.09804292023181915,
-0.06991247087717056,
-0.35729795694351196,
0.858698308467865,
-0.7716384530067444,
0.47678807377815247,
0.7203959822654724,
0.12040743976831436,
0.15471704304218292,
-1.2793967723846436,
-0.5846611261367798,
-0.17623065412044525,
-0.024006394669413567,
-0.0024906795006245375,
-0.3815770149230957,
-0.2627592086791992,
0.22080497443675995,
0.25373151898384094,
-0.59036785364151,
0.24039950966835022,
-0.34212031960487366,
-0.48528626561164856,
0.26782941818237305,
-0.018813693895936012,
0.6915623545646667,
0.00006384089647326618,
-0.34099382162094116,
-0.37177929282188416,
-0.3798757493495941,
-0.08671268820762634,
0.6221857666969299,
0.39272376894950867,
0.021618766710162163,
0.19229233264923096,
-0.2511294484138489,
0.7061669826507568,
0.0188473891466856,
-0.06999003887176514,
0.47660574316978455,
-0.09467381238937378,
0.09842027723789215,
-0.1257181167602539,
0.6850480437278748,
0.4277304410934448,
0.5120347142219543,
-0.31476810574531555,
-0.28134438395500183,
0.18337680399417877,
0.7450045347213745,
-1.099892258644104,
-0.6754730343818665,
-0.0009735878556966782,
-0.5519729256629944,
-0.2660338282585144,
0.19647759199142456,
-1.0195425748825073,
-0.16871726512908936,
-0.5973376035690308,
0.13088420033454895,
-0.8298514485359192,
-0.37175965309143066,
-0.15429849922657013,
-0.5245797634124756,
0.2345571666955948,
0.45374298095703125,
-0.7749465107917786,
0.7177871465682983,
0.5635008811950684,
0.7146272659301758,
-0.2958908677101135,
-0.1897539347410202,
-0.7404837012290955,
-0.17738452553749084,
-0.04111760854721069,
0.934196412563324,
-0.4994862377643585,
0.17879438400268555,
0.050110138952732086,
-0.15506108105182648,
-0.06871985644102097,
-0.5756548643112183,
0.3631611764431,
-0.7872464656829834,
0.049446962773799896,
0.01721780002117157,
-0.441337525844574,
-0.34054458141326904,
0.4284456670284271,
-0.9647784233093262,
0.8744599223136902,
-0.017707813531160355,
-0.7583739161491394,
0.28059762716293335,
-0.7042160630226135,
-0.9003119468688965,
0.26280343532562256,
0.12874971330165863,
-0.11169549077749252,
0.11766184121370316,
0.12871651351451874,
0.14726901054382324,
-0.05164588615298271,
0.05405963212251663,
-0.2661580741405487,
-0.18904347717761993,
0.3784579932689667,
-0.35081976652145386,
0.7896555066108704,
0.4257782995700836,
-0.18670466542243958,
0.0657900795340538,
-0.7261608839035034,
0.45994722843170166,
0.1341959685087204,
-0.5271788239479065,
-0.555044949054718,
0.04985373467206955,
0.49943289160728455,
0.13851936161518097,
0.35942259430885315,
-0.5079029202461243,
-0.13013428449630737,
-0.3895484507083893,
0.6352205872535706,
0.6860450506210327,
-0.3818475008010864,
0.5945927500724792,
-0.29563960433006287,
0.6099737286567688,
-0.20137976109981537,
-0.09588167816400528,
-0.0909951776266098,
-0.005900013260543346,
-0.6606680750846863,
-0.16400180757045746,
0.7652382850646973,
0.49199992418289185,
-0.8036394119262695,
0.47964996099472046,
-0.2797918915748596,
-0.6236008405685425,
-0.43053609132766724,
0.3121687173843384,
0.6006166934967041,
0.4288719892501831,
0.6198006868362427,
-0.5671395659446716,
-0.6723155379295349,
-0.5913076996803284,
-0.30668362975120544,
0.3873732089996338,
-0.04333573579788208,
-0.1879766881465912,
0.38287943601608276,
-0.068393275141716,
0.8204678893089294,
-0.5373817682266235,
-0.22564741969108582,
-0.464915007352829,
-0.002100657671689987,
0.12573306262493134,
0.7145890593528748,
0.28098034858703613,
-0.8475878238677979,
-0.47870972752571106,
-0.30388903617858887,
-0.375438928604126,
-0.12027491629123688,
0.257260799407959,
-0.36477914452552795,
-0.033031217753887177,
0.6848028302192688,
-0.46419182419776917,
0.4056500494480133,
0.44669902324676514,
0.036361534148454666,
0.5109133720397949,
-0.12148579955101013,
-0.3352356553077698,
-0.9515211582183838,
0.5235198140144348,
0.05537186190485954,
-0.3315843641757965,
-0.6954959630966187,
0.17371249198913574,
0.018658552318811417,
0.05379771441221237,
-0.4862971007823944,
0.6371598839759827,
-0.4988877773284912,
0.19738242030143738,
-0.5497244596481323,
0.3133202791213989,
0.1561633050441742,
0.22149725258350372,
0.030767949298024178,
0.5412029027938843,
0.3364750146865845,
-0.9339181184768677,
-0.12841792404651642,
0.4011327028274536,
-0.2102697640657425,
0.24233593046665192,
-0.6100277900695801,
0.43235597014427185,
0.10516821593046188,
0.1474199891090393,
-0.6807059049606323,
-0.10421571135520935,
-0.031695712357759476,
-0.5157008171081543,
0.22175712883472443,
-0.19681784510612488,
-0.4627154469490051,
-0.14728213846683502,
-0.2591712176799774,
0.3059768080711365,
0.4540611207485199,
-0.5803701877593994,
0.5179684162139893,
0.686403751373291,
-0.45386168360710144,
-0.5512043833732605,
-0.5462218523025513,
0.0259507168084383,
0.027165940031409264,
-0.41067931056022644,
0.6232330799102783,
-0.12230686843395233,
-0.22545701265335083,
-0.0523434653878212,
-0.13595162332057953,
-0.517108142375946,
0.26266002655029297,
0.25431105494499207,
0.08941065520048141,
-0.09442386776208878,
-0.0038182642310857773,
0.016504459083080292,
-0.36474111676216125,
-0.10614831745624542,
-0.23467613756656647,
1.2474316358566284,
-0.03172913193702698,
-0.1314951777458191,
-0.7009756565093994,
0.026133475825190544,
0.18430934846401215,
-0.6563106179237366,
0.19169266521930695,
0.7383086681365967,
-0.4602358043193817,
-0.31654712557792664,
-0.558792233467102,
-0.5761814713478088,
-0.5338912606239319,
0.2078750878572464,
-0.11077234148979187,
-0.5379321575164795,
0.1938650906085968,
-0.14735062420368195,
-0.11440326273441315,
0.3262081742286682,
0.10878944396972656,
-0.17433789372444153,
0.8295634388923645,
0.5968617796897888,
-0.11632835119962692,
0.6899590492248535,
-0.35732653737068176,
-0.05639297887682915,
-0.7053391337394714,
-0.02456771209836006,
-0.7567052245140076,
-0.5752090811729431,
-0.4215918183326721,
0.07025551795959473,
-0.32154253125190735,
0.2102566659450531,
-0.24065934121608734,
0.5178122520446777,
-0.4909664988517761,
0.6272305846214294,
1.156074047088623,
0.3589789569377899,
0.12931358814239502,
0.175964817404747,
-0.20282140374183655,
-0.08841614425182343,
-0.48638662695884705,
-0.7475149631500244,
0.9347017407417297,
-0.10348377376794815,
0.573889970779419,
-0.23136413097381592,
0.7703020572662354,
-0.06259025633335114,
0.3148331344127655,
-0.5833355188369751,
0.6122684478759766,
-0.5440429449081421,
-0.6408196687698364,
-0.36954453587532043,
-0.2297346144914627,
-1.2405154705047607,
0.1518673151731491,
-0.27314427495002747,
-0.45672422647476196,
0.03426491469144821,
0.2309994399547577,
-0.5107801556587219,
0.3158392906188965,
-0.4254624843597412,
0.8532041311264038,
-0.2613629102706909,
-0.49887946248054504,
-0.27254974842071533,
-0.6470703482627869,
-0.0414251945912838,
-0.00328606809489429,
0.30263039469718933,
-0.014564706943929195,
0.10463687777519226,
0.8817655444145203,
-0.6316220760345459,
0.7615338563919067,
-0.31022778153419495,
0.31428149342536926,
0.28485941886901855,
0.24236172437667847,
0.17013995349407196,
-0.21604882180690765,
-0.00041247103945352137,
0.1999100148677826,
-0.19502265751361847,
-0.3597666025161743,
-0.3260901868343353,
0.39087221026420593,
-0.662466287612915,
-0.14979323744773865,
-0.28262099623680115,
-0.18112905323505402,
0.08696004003286362,
0.6584557890892029,
0.44516241550445557,
0.5567868947982788,
-0.35563820600509644,
0.2968442440032959,
0.47414541244506836,
-0.3412036597728729,
0.874035656452179,
0.36403733491897583,
-0.3181801438331604,
-0.5053069591522217,
1.1829297542572021,
-0.10786827653646469,
0.0485369972884655,
0.45337921380996704,
0.08163662254810333,
-0.12311384081840515,
-0.9547268152236938,
-0.024439377710223198,
-0.0813465490937233,
-0.3383229970932007,
-0.5554959774017334,
-0.7290262579917908,
-0.220680832862854,
-0.3284519910812378,
-0.0029762741178274155,
-0.28224343061447144,
-0.3211575150489807,
-0.32847437262535095,
-0.11585330218076706,
0.17592544853687286,
0.3442937433719635,
-0.20078866183757782,
0.7921406626701355,
-0.9125304222106934,
0.5462245345115662,
0.15376725792884827,
0.1445300579071045,
-0.03219924867153168,
-0.3382118046283722,
-0.16245020925998688,
0.11094610393047333,
-0.40398702025413513,
-0.6480953693389893,
0.9807021021842957,
0.11708968877792358,
0.6194339990615845,
0.6672802567481995,
-0.12601003050804138,
0.7260243892669678,
-0.4899502694606781,
0.4471929371356964,
0.26749998331069946,
-0.8569654226303101,
0.5383028984069824,
-0.20312871038913727,
0.22771120071411133,
1.1438748836517334,
0.3666183650493622,
-0.38788697123527527,
-0.23562577366828918,
-0.4954712390899658,
-1.0556918382644653,
0.6443136930465698,
-0.023746425285935402,
0.3276450037956238,
-0.214923694729805,
-0.03495084121823311,
0.3232499361038208,
0.2486005425453186,
-0.6134886145591736,
0.13029564917087555,
-0.5617051720619202,
-0.16705410182476044,
-0.022521181032061577,
0.05921079218387604,
0.2836381793022156,
-0.4035893976688385,
0.7252577543258667,
-0.17209671437740326,
-0.12166016548871994,
0.008825240656733513,
-0.9718995094299316,
0.2346143126487732,
0.18863290548324585,
0.17841579020023346,
0.5604872107505798,
-0.04173457249999046,
0.2619120180606842,
0.04633187875151634,
-0.8553193807601929,
-0.1693393439054489,
0.23263676464557648,
-0.31564590334892273,
-0.0716935321688652,
0.21154221892356873,
0.2967914938926697,
0.3215920329093933,
-0.8025895357131958,
0.7592453360557556,
-0.11551358550786972,
0.021119486540555954,
-0.6084058284759521,
0.15220244228839874,
0.06689345091581345,
-0.04584197700023651,
0.36166316270828247,
0.28132233023643494,
0.29753443598747253,
-0.23752741515636444,
0.4459468424320221,
0.23495227098464966,
-0.43810445070266724,
-0.4300854206085205,
0.5151912569999695,
0.2296024113893509,
-0.387503445148468,
1.4018093347549438,
-0.21635745465755463,
-0.5046897530555725,
0.5518902540206909,
0.6037465929985046,
0.6837615966796875,
-0.42072516679763794,
0.201483353972435,
0.436623752117157,
0.16272509098052979,
-0.004178900737315416,
0.46161508560180664,
0.11721355468034744,
-0.9091070294380188,
-0.62442946434021,
-0.8902329206466675,
-0.22703155875205994,
0.17856216430664062,
-0.8268550634384155,
0.3088737428188324,
-0.6541717648506165,
-0.3164122998714447,
0.1387048363685608,
-0.1446422040462494,
-0.9150300621986389,
0.42899537086486816,
0.2156936526298523,
0.8943700194358826,
-0.33977755904197693,
0.8499753475189209,
0.6458870768547058,
-0.7391843795776367,
-0.6952676177024841,
-0.09326784312725067,
-0.1583375483751297,
-0.6294740438461304,
0.7196443676948547,
0.5683069825172424,
0.1751728355884552,
0.13875451683998108,
-0.7217118144035339,
-0.8780474662780762,
0.7906038761138916,
0.5286365747451782,
-0.6904075741767883,
-0.42852482199668884,
-0.001506591448560357,
0.34083372354507446,
-0.00166886777151376,
0.5680503249168396,
0.29422426223754883,
0.6774784922599792,
-0.3938956558704376,
-0.7400445342063904,
0.1304360330104828,
-0.7567963004112244,
-0.3462843596935272,
0.16046762466430664,
-0.29905977845191956,
1.0524791479110718,
-0.000011934750546060968,
-0.17907686531543732,
0.15450133383274078,
0.6192945837974548,
0.08336276561021805,
0.11750496923923492,
0.8092336058616638,
0.8618839979171753,
0.8793425559997559,
-0.017274510115385056,
0.9376031160354614,
-0.5462159514427185,
-0.23068948090076447,
1.4271457195281982,
-0.24618929624557495,
0.997655987739563,
0.3595450520515442,
0.0783773884177208,
0.9333918690681458,
0.26123106479644775,
0.0005053316126577556,
0.4549909234046936,
0.4653953015804291,
0.054426249116659164,
-0.3538975715637207,
0.01745394617319107,
-0.19148129224777222,
0.7958431243896484,
0.27597105503082275,
-0.34197095036506653,
-0.5075485110282898,
-0.0019481584895402193,
0.27031269669532776,
0.3278678357601166,
-0.2733744978904724,
0.9277549386024475,
0.14847394824028015,
-0.645334780216217,
0.17643770575523376,
-0.0973745733499527,
0.8547829389572144,
-0.5804013013839722,
-0.1791113168001175,
-0.05927500128746033,
0.28496429324150085,
-0.4021078646183014,
-0.3593367338180542,
0.17433494329452515,
-0.10202111303806305,
-0.06298211961984634,
-0.5196528434753418,
1.0669430494308472,
-0.12156957387924194,
0.01708810217678547,
0.3602216839790344,
0.7615197896957397,
0.17640289664268494,
-0.5601041913032532,
-0.4191408157348633,
-0.19048269093036652,
-0.1037590503692627,
-0.2853940427303314,
0.4814326763153076,
0.1982145607471466,
0.1466769129037857,
0.3632917106151581,
1.3063112497329712,
-0.022907409816980362,
0.14520001411437988,
0.15279842913150787,
0.9391629695892334,
-0.7852287292480469,
-0.5506052374839783,
-0.9216760993003845,
0.5724776387214661,
-0.4514102637767792,
-0.5146695375442505,
0.7950742244720459,
1.0016347169876099,
0.9347172379493713,
0.0624849759042263,
0.7941854596138,
0.037162210792303085,
0.6939156651496887,
-0.30900612473487854,
1.1008137464523315,
-0.08242307603359222,
-0.3850072920322418,
-0.23726576566696167,
-1.0310181379318237,
-0.23600737750530243,
0.7980645895004272,
-0.20576180517673492,
-0.02254561148583889,
0.6676085591316223,
0.6370812654495239,
-0.26264286041259766,
0.22188186645507812,
-0.08001518249511719,
0.19083748757839203,
0.093988336622715,
0.0772903561592102,
1.0005046129226685,
-0.058916617184877396,
0.649591863155365,
-0.38225898146629333,
-0.09977710992097855,
-0.14061903953552246,
-0.8218829035758972,
-0.682614803314209,
-0.36314889788627625,
-0.2290993481874466,
-0.41160985827445984,
0.03327499330043793,
0.854292631149292,
0.8611581325531006,
-0.8379349112510681,
-0.19788287580013275,
-0.2487783133983612,
-0.11930608749389648,
-0.31300804018974304,
-0.2582194209098816,
0.21682918071746826,
-0.8279109597206116,
-0.6951561570167542,
0.4635032117366791,
-0.29756680130958557,
-0.0982007086277008,
0.229444682598114,
0.0796167179942131,
-0.2398606836795807,
-0.0920879989862442,
0.5307322144508362,
0.2962212562561035,
-0.15471701323986053,
0.10050470381975174,
-0.001983518712222576,
-0.17630401253700256,
0.14772334694862366,
0.7815921902656555,
-0.9204331636428833,
-0.05870385840535164,
0.5266813635826111,
0.5585985779762268,
0.7081785798072815,
-0.01354557741433382,
0.4723533093929291,
-0.4931120276451111,
-0.0530678927898407,
0.4158360958099365,
0.4823879599571228,
0.3182930648326874,
0.12328553199768066,
0.3942831754684448,
-0.07086820900440216,
-0.20200274884700775,
-0.70433109998703,
-0.10555863380432129,
-0.9733341336250305,
-0.5084702372550964,
0.9603838920593262,
-0.04881808161735535,
-0.31132158637046814,
-0.06895215809345245,
-0.1601656824350357,
0.5001156330108643,
-0.5855315327644348,
0.47601860761642456,
0.15280625224113464,
0.3427840769290924,
0.26350605487823486,
-0.45771709084510803,
0.36615774035453796,
0.2909680902957916,
-0.9790640473365784,
-0.20744292438030243,
0.5185375213623047,
0.6345606446266174,
0.4221467077732086,
0.5634945034980774,
-0.20031915605068207,
0.19547121226787567,
-0.0934491828083992,
0.45368877053260803,
-0.032249290496110916,
-0.4989320933818817,
-0.1465800553560257,
0.4381924569606781,
-0.2746751308441162,
-0.09608431160449982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14623v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14623v1
|
RoboScript: Code Generation for Free-Form Manipulation Tasks across Real and Simulation
| 2024-02-22T15:12:00 | 2024-02-22T15:12:00 |
Junting Chen, Yao Mu, Qiaojun Yu, Tianming Wei, Silang Wu, Zhecheng Yuan, Zhixuan Liang, Chao Yang, Kaipeng Zhang, Wenqi Shao, Yu Qiao, Huazhe Xu, Mingyu Ding, Ping Luo
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, I.2.7; I.2.8; I.2.9; I.2.10
|
Rapid progress in high-level task planning and code generation for open-world
robot manipulation has been witnessed in Embodied AI. However, previous studies
put much effort into general common sense reasoning and task planning
capabilities of large-scale language or multi-modal models, relatively little
effort on ensuring the deployability of generated code on real robots, and
other fundamental components of autonomous robot systems including robot
perception, motion planning, and control. To bridge this ``ideal-to-real'' gap,
this paper presents \textbf{RobotScript}, a platform for 1) a deployable robot
manipulation pipeline powered by code generation; and 2) a code generation
benchmark for robot manipulation tasks in free-form natural language. The
RobotScript platform addresses this gap by emphasizing the unified interface
with both simulation and real robots, based on abstraction from the Robot
Operating System (ROS), ensuring syntax compliance and simulation validation
with Gazebo. We demonstrate the adaptability of our code generation framework
across multiple robot embodiments, including the Franka and UR5 robot arms, and
multiple grippers. Additionally, our benchmark assesses reasoning abilities for
physical space and constraints, highlighting the differences between GPT-3.5,
GPT-4, and Gemini in handling complex physical interactions. Finally, we
present a thorough evaluation on the whole system, exploring how each module in
the pipeline: code generation, perception, motion planning, and even object
geometric properties, impact the overall performance of the system.
|
[
-0.1303737610578537,
-0.5576463937759399,
0.7135327458381653,
0.0843399167060852,
-0.0059136273339390755,
0.1803196370601654,
-0.00724397599697113,
-0.587055504322052,
0.3582623600959778,
0.5825849771499634,
-0.7761565446853638,
-0.41902485489845276,
-0.5081590414047241,
-0.004075848497450352,
-0.36285918951034546,
0.7481974363327026,
-0.2638784945011139,
-0.37912753224372864,
-0.23828117549419403,
-0.036831311881542206,
-0.17300117015838623,
-0.4391496777534485,
-0.05061836168169975,
-0.07715555280447006,
0.241930291056633,
0.2954225242137909,
0.9290294647216797,
0.7750170826911926,
0.8224470019340515,
0.2550020217895508,
0.43797072768211365,
0.2819696366786957,
-0.040730126202106476,
0.13701513409614563,
-0.37422865629196167,
-0.4272027015686035,
-0.6664644479751587,
-0.08394549041986465,
0.222523495554924,
0.4302064776420593,
0.06309537589550018,
0.020303253084421158,
-0.29532113671302795,
0.5187162160873413,
-0.809478759765625,
0.06390297412872314,
-0.36339348554611206,
0.3186081051826477,
0.1610521376132965,
0.02230708859860897,
-0.08771403878927231,
-0.0799267441034317,
-0.1214996799826622,
-1.1121470928192139,
0.10346172004938126,
-0.027550488710403442,
0.8688153028488159,
0.6321966052055359,
-0.11247380077838898,
-0.20891809463500977,
-0.9214423894882202,
0.5550036430358887,
-0.4688519835472107,
0.27039703726768494,
0.24471044540405273,
0.5715938806533813,
-0.09715043008327484,
-0.8314482569694519,
-0.650198757648468,
-0.5254043340682983,
0.05691895633935928,
0.2908712923526764,
-0.4393916726112366,
0.3516960144042969,
0.35132163763046265,
0.0687343031167984,
-0.7969012260437012,
-0.017381351441144943,
-0.45128709077835083,
-0.29555320739746094,
0.4769442081451416,
0.08634001016616821,
0.44771355390548706,
-0.15066751837730408,
-0.5110803246498108,
-0.38406848907470703,
-0.6635526418685913,
-0.013805979862809181,
0.7174504995346069,
0.42909955978393555,
-0.2558719515800476,
0.6962651014328003,
-0.40356889367103577,
0.6642414331436157,
-0.22648844122886658,
0.27096623182296753,
0.027946671470999718,
-0.1954553872346878,
-0.3315410017967224,
-0.5838416814804077,
0.8903826475143433,
0.561122477054596,
0.2887796461582184,
-0.392887145280838,
-0.17986300587654114,
0.3044089078903198,
0.8815790414810181,
-0.4230709671974182,
-0.4204444885253906,
0.47652068734169006,
-0.21109338104724884,
-0.1000651866197586,
0.3991030156612396,
-0.45133906602859497,
-0.11806907504796982,
-0.4358940124511719,
0.4652729630470276,
-0.33532094955444336,
-0.1579088270664215,
0.24873605370521545,
-0.2748967409133911,
-0.07635805010795593,
0.39071568846702576,
-0.5495575666427612,
0.4096379280090332,
0.7726041674613953,
0.7650448679924011,
-0.08469539880752563,
-0.34898895025253296,
-0.5349394083023071,
0.25744199752807617,
-0.35463929176330566,
0.7258356213569641,
-0.23339292407035828,
-0.08885373920202255,
-0.16884444653987885,
-0.07383926957845688,
-0.10066176950931549,
-0.613645076751709,
0.20729617774486542,
-0.09559617191553116,
0.15281231701374054,
0.48141297698020935,
-0.1794445514678955,
-0.21809172630310059,
0.30399948358535767,
-0.5768265724182129,
0.7488265037536621,
0.532360851764679,
-0.0015383034478873014,
0.35696667432785034,
-1.022860050201416,
-0.44139665365219116,
-0.15702834725379944,
-0.11839301884174347,
-0.15281462669372559,
-0.38104161620140076,
-0.10113850980997086,
0.36860084533691406,
-0.31653648614883423,
0.177897647023201,
-0.15716125071048737,
-0.3008618652820587,
0.1658613085746765,
-0.025954890996217728,
0.30835679173469543,
0.33915454149246216,
-0.32421591877937317,
0.5585813522338867,
-0.728545606136322,
0.15184351801872253,
-0.11732957512140274,
0.14881391823291779,
0.15341037511825562,
0.006630934774875641,
-0.013207401148974895,
0.46965616941452026,
0.14075128734111786,
-0.4802996516227722,
0.5254347920417786,
-0.4091082215309143,
0.23766064643859863,
0.4257710576057434,
-0.3222857713699341,
0.7261320948600769,
-0.0971880778670311,
0.957283616065979,
-0.3113999366760254,
0.19598345458507538,
-0.10860566049814224,
-0.3453882336616516,
-0.42029017210006714,
-0.4830302596092224,
0.004516256041824818,
0.8094946146011353,
-0.713315486907959,
0.5472160577774048,
-0.010760227218270302,
-0.47450071573257446,
-0.2947297692298889,
0.1805294305086136,
0.6281912326812744,
0.12368912994861603,
0.43148812651634216,
-0.33940258622169495,
-0.4693979322910309,
-0.9286758303642273,
-0.029505860060453415,
-0.02497095614671707,
-0.709427535533905,
-0.02063697949051857,
0.43661800026893616,
-0.1835511326789856,
1.0333448648452759,
-0.546181321144104,
-0.12124542891979218,
-0.42247024178504944,
0.0764322429895401,
0.0038932927418500185,
0.5336961150169373,
0.6061308979988098,
-0.4190678000450134,
-0.07540059834718704,
0.14131322503089905,
-0.6994838714599609,
-0.18668439984321594,
-0.25665387511253357,
-0.37436193227767944,
0.02575381100177765,
0.47638368606567383,
-0.7744160890579224,
0.48532381653785706,
0.7622976303100586,
-0.13753372430801392,
0.4633479118347168,
-0.3582373261451721,
0.019686535000801086,
-0.8186675906181335,
0.34654074907302856,
-0.1512468159198761,
-0.03685690462589264,
-0.4208964407444,
0.6090042591094971,
0.00045771599980071187,
-0.27555662393569946,
-0.5464369058609009,
0.48456430435180664,
-0.218132883310318,
-0.23973555862903595,
-0.29808181524276733,
0.4961016774177551,
-0.11630713939666748,
0.587527871131897,
-0.01954239048063755,
0.8288511037826538,
0.4838950037956238,
-0.6932912468910217,
0.5785328149795532,
-0.06987091153860092,
-0.08601289987564087,
0.3267216086387634,
-0.6569145917892456,
0.16666631400585175,
0.27200746536254883,
0.22248582541942596,
-0.6924811601638794,
-0.6048849821090698,
0.6503165364265442,
-0.34410911798477173,
-0.30784568190574646,
-0.18500779569149017,
-0.5030534863471985,
-0.44888123869895935,
-0.1054062694311142,
0.0525611937046051,
0.42261964082717896,
-0.22699150443077087,
0.7333133220672607,
0.08656708896160126,
0.20105192065238953,
-0.5571594834327698,
-0.5133662223815918,
0.05583995580673218,
0.09686939418315887,
-0.6191864609718323,
0.16344663500785828,
-0.053919773548841476,
-0.38856959342956543,
-0.01902238093316555,
-0.2859015166759491,
-0.09333985298871994,
0.05114949867129326,
0.46220263838768005,
0.21158495545387268,
-0.010358902625739574,
-0.29123952984809875,
0.35920923948287964,
-0.541461169719696,
-0.005302420351654291,
-0.25048378109931946,
0.5472196340560913,
0.09818597137928009,
-0.7297830581665039,
-0.4877299666404724,
-0.07661908864974976,
0.7359253168106079,
-0.08437300473451614,
0.09737832844257355,
0.1987118124961853,
-0.27028393745422363,
-0.3756210207939148,
0.18851782381534576,
-0.04277270287275314,
-0.4144393503665924,
0.23472943902015686,
-0.3841009736061096,
-0.5180297493934631,
0.49338752031326294,
-0.312724769115448,
0.20887228846549988,
0.22368112206459045,
0.17495229840278625,
0.00020699948072433472,
0.6643794178962708,
0.6316460371017456,
0.3281882405281067,
0.23840835690498352,
-0.39974427223205566,
0.2618377208709717,
-0.6588950753211975,
0.12392610311508179,
-0.3780588209629059,
-0.622790515422821,
-0.14688102900981903,
-0.9385600090026855,
0.17306390404701233,
0.1020529717206955,
-0.22061431407928467,
1.1069945096969604,
-0.6783527135848999,
0.5921379327774048,
0.5857906937599182,
-0.10648026317358017,
0.16516713798046112,
-0.28105083107948303,
-0.044842325150966644,
0.191337451338768,
-0.4840814471244812,
-0.7619431018829346,
0.8807514309883118,
0.05798639729619026,
0.5174606442451477,
0.04330360144376755,
0.35931363701820374,
0.3350176513195038,
-0.04420819133520126,
-0.5889424085617065,
0.8088590502738953,
-0.14625433087348938,
-0.6126323938369751,
-0.24515266716480255,
-0.2148016393184662,
-0.9451548457145691,
0.23015332221984863,
-0.11025264114141464,
-0.7477418184280396,
-0.2781825065612793,
0.2579604685306549,
-0.5445188283920288,
0.500095784664154,
-0.7364009618759155,
0.7284930944442749,
-0.24641942977905273,
-0.34276533126831055,
-0.3959450125694275,
-1.0029875040054321,
0.08886096626520157,
0.2937982678413391,
0.07459033280611038,
-0.38330531120300293,
-0.08437009155750275,
0.19062717258930206,
-0.29303205013275146,
0.7440229654312134,
-0.05506996437907219,
-0.2921501696109772,
0.45065855979919434,
0.6403151154518127,
0.18513430655002594,
-0.11216013133525848,
0.035748858004808426,
0.07353147864341736,
-0.16640368103981018,
-0.2788049280643463,
-0.8129445314407349,
0.30779772996902466,
-0.6367286443710327,
-0.008242172189056873,
-0.30446282029151917,
-0.8478598594665527,
-0.24420838057994843,
0.09758717566728592,
-0.09965499490499496,
0.29447129368782043,
-0.29521670937538147,
0.022301746532320976,
0.06544078886508942,
-0.24647441506385803,
0.28916341066360474,
0.289272278547287,
-0.36761677265167236,
-0.15944905579090118,
0.8281451463699341,
-0.17431385815143585,
0.772249698638916,
0.7854832410812378,
-0.07572609186172485,
0.11058974266052246,
-0.18856331706047058,
-0.8861165046691895,
-0.24389751255512238,
-0.24914129078388214,
-0.39612117409706116,
-0.4252249300479889,
-0.12397930771112442,
-0.32089224457740784,
-0.789385199546814,
-0.45213937759399414,
-0.848615288734436,
0.12467502057552338,
-0.09796207398176193,
0.26445475220680237,
0.8010975122451782,
-0.43658965826034546,
0.45684322714805603,
-0.7077796459197998,
0.7939649820327759,
0.20762678980827332,
0.4989643692970276,
-0.31286558508872986,
0.0019267186289653182,
-0.1133333221077919,
0.14769715070724487,
-0.45394283533096313,
-0.3314846158027649,
0.2345661222934723,
-0.30664828419685364,
0.3815295994281769,
0.3450412154197693,
0.018426207825541496,
0.4405478835105896,
-0.02498283050954342,
0.9161590337753296,
0.14753761887550354,
-0.836780846118927,
0.6853065490722656,
-0.6498278975486755,
0.3275488317012787,
0.1933189034461975,
0.15145620703697205,
-0.4426824450492859,
-0.7812386751174927,
-0.7605087161064148,
-0.7931148409843445,
0.842143177986145,
0.38004904985427856,
-0.07450216263532639,
0.1893523633480072,
0.14629104733467102,
0.2065439224243164,
0.3243303894996643,
-0.47938841581344604,
0.08436352759599686,
-0.09179405122995377,
-0.21722126007080078,
0.2703861594200134,
0.5240728259086609,
-0.2758713364601135,
0.023248039186000824,
0.29058152437210083,
-0.3444889187812805,
0.5514561533927917,
-0.07028701156377792,
-0.14004060626029968,
-0.15959545969963074,
0.039883922785520554,
0.8439592123031616,
0.5578106641769409,
-0.21891936659812927,
-0.07330183684825897,
-0.28141599893569946,
-0.5942891240119934,
-0.18000516295433044,
0.07905667275190353,
-0.16468434035778046,
-0.3826468586921692,
0.329024076461792,
0.5615915060043335,
0.1431877762079239,
-1.0714114904403687,
0.22268912196159363,
0.3892633318901062,
-0.4311492443084717,
0.05108698457479477,
0.5681208372116089,
-0.17986193299293518,
0.10268695652484894,
0.11656484752893448,
0.6255860924720764,
-0.03631292283535004,
-0.6422773599624634,
0.20056691765785217,
0.17118403315544128,
-0.4142521917819977,
-0.3791959285736084,
0.7667208313941956,
0.2444964349269867,
-0.411553293466568,
0.4832788109779358,
-0.3623564541339874,
-0.2940654754638672,
0.9900233149528503,
0.47327908873558044,
0.9188894033432007,
0.24869444966316223,
0.33451467752456665,
0.5065619945526123,
0.4379346966743469,
0.22023777663707733,
0.23514807224273682,
-0.24370351433753967,
-0.6906002163887024,
-0.5555136799812317,
-0.2558901906013489,
-0.8275963664054871,
-0.4325476586818695,
-0.3607337474822998,
0.15922977030277252,
-0.9580551385879517,
0.14966920018196106,
-0.4919451177120209,
-0.39076679944992065,
-0.2983894646167755,
0.23413518071174622,
0.015246890485286713,
0.7991387248039246,
-0.458160400390625,
0.5232312083244324,
0.8170097470283508,
-0.6803226470947266,
-0.5819291472434998,
0.21494507789611816,
0.15646179020404816,
-0.8504997491836548,
0.4173223376274109,
0.010956069454550743,
-0.7301640510559082,
-0.523283839225769,
-0.7670292854309082,
-0.6669362187385559,
0.9564968943595886,
0.4118591248989105,
-0.3245546519756317,
-0.07580746710300446,
0.18069036304950714,
0.647519052028656,
-0.16841940581798553,
0.1829337328672409,
0.24178342521190643,
0.42163005471229553,
-0.03493263199925423,
-1.1103788614273071,
-0.1446199119091034,
-0.3009037673473358,
-0.3505074381828308,
0.4514702260494232,
-0.7059457898139954,
0.5130325555801392,
-0.28131139278411865,
-0.06946595013141632,
0.5119157433509827,
0.4034501016139984,
0.44676271080970764,
0.41119012236595154,
0.4157875180244446,
0.4699670374393463,
0.4923866391181946,
-0.36329469084739685,
1.0636146068572998,
-0.5233830213546753,
-0.0009345926227979362,
0.8273636698722839,
-0.4634435176849365,
0.6645698547363281,
0.2680375874042511,
-0.2493472397327423,
0.6677963137626648,
-0.19972927868366241,
0.18440483510494232,
0.3090697228908539,
0.3750264048576355,
-0.1478327214717865,
-0.2110321968793869,
0.3569735884666443,
-0.03456825017929077,
0.5525748133659363,
0.36207205057144165,
0.11264775693416595,
-0.056829750537872314,
0.23962190747261047,
0.04598316550254822,
0.4198698401451111,
0.0868799090385437,
0.4661683440208435,
-0.2655896246433258,
-0.649086594581604,
-0.0010264546144753695,
0.003895026398822665,
0.6681541800498962,
-1.0406228303909302,
-0.2176702320575714,
0.09197540581226349,
0.44342178106307983,
-0.06291667371988297,
-1.1644924879074097,
0.5400952100753784,
-0.05800290033221245,
-0.003062300384044647,
-0.6081991791725159,
0.6634798645973206,
0.015111520886421204,
-0.022713903337717056,
0.3043612837791443,
0.4748465418815613,
0.20818348228931427,
-0.04987968131899834,
-0.5565928220748901,
0.15727747976779938,
-0.10758427530527115,
0.060243286192417145,
0.4155091643333435,
0.5173896551132202,
0.03574063628911972,
1.0363726615905762,
0.7592719793319702,
-0.15115439891815186,
-0.06929203867912292,
-0.02414536103606224,
0.7817716002464294,
-0.6706587672233582,
-0.42250123620033264,
-0.11898815631866455,
0.6281741261482239,
0.030260641127824783,
-0.5757789611816406,
0.5886282920837402,
0.5858345627784729,
0.93848717212677,
-0.41189542412757874,
0.6483442187309265,
-0.6399901509284973,
0.5856432318687439,
-0.48090559244155884,
0.49775171279907227,
-0.5034979581832886,
-0.24346604943275452,
-0.6160520315170288,
-0.7319536209106445,
-0.7399554252624512,
1.0102818012237549,
-0.0633242279291153,
-0.08561022579669952,
0.5712984204292297,
0.8489993810653687,
-0.25751760601997375,
-0.18282771110534668,
0.31869471073150635,
-0.3085196912288666,
0.35185256600379944,
0.5115483403205872,
0.7178232073783875,
-0.4582902789115906,
0.6797541975975037,
-0.2645235061645508,
-0.08079986274242401,
0.018526794388890266,
-0.8320344090461731,
-0.3201541006565094,
-0.43179434537887573,
-0.25620681047439575,
-0.23867225646972656,
0.2822919487953186,
1.1271717548370361,
0.7936925888061523,
-0.5121679902076721,
-0.49880075454711914,
-0.30820149183273315,
-0.07413115352392197,
-0.755340576171875,
-0.20315518975257874,
-0.01699974201619625,
-0.2654653489589691,
-0.8427109718322754,
0.6576109528541565,
0.560907244682312,
-0.13600975275039673,
-0.20726554095745087,
-0.2616601288318634,
0.049035605043172836,
-0.18723060190677643,
0.8275540471076965,
0.8313199877738953,
-0.5405656099319458,
-0.3598547875881195,
0.3982721269130707,
-0.08369187265634537,
-0.11452803760766983,
1.0047897100448608,
-0.9769144058227539,
0.43733564019203186,
0.38769829273223877,
0.4583659768104553,
-0.009336888790130615,
0.08364467322826385,
0.8038995862007141,
-0.6798309087753296,
0.3969789147377014,
0.25814005732536316,
0.06975395232439041,
-0.019908439368009567,
-0.08575055003166199,
0.8633338809013367,
0.1322735995054245,
-0.5122828483581543,
-0.4492899775505066,
0.3936659097671509,
-1.4370001554489136,
-0.27789169549942017,
0.9552606344223022,
0.2219409942626953,
0.14123409986495972,
-0.06829221546649933,
-0.5147097110748291,
0.09706195443868637,
-0.33723050355911255,
0.6465315222740173,
0.45580291748046875,
-0.6157148480415344,
0.04492255672812462,
-0.5876240730285645,
0.07484675943851471,
0.25833433866500854,
-0.9149121046066284,
0.3832840919494629,
0.7809586524963379,
-0.13623856008052826,
0.6113148927688599,
0.5743643045425415,
-0.25933292508125305,
0.46276894211769104,
0.2493969202041626,
0.49604296684265137,
-0.11786679923534393,
-0.7068666219711304,
0.13803759217262268,
0.1766766756772995,
-0.36335447430610657,
-0.32584086060523987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14622v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14622v1
|
From Keywords to Structured Summaries: Streamlining Scholarly Knowledge Access
| 2024-02-22T15:10:45 | 2024-02-22T15:10:45 |
Mahsa Shamsabadi, Jennifer D'Souza
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DL
|
This short paper highlights the growing importance of information retrieval
(IR) engines in the scientific community, addressing the inefficiency of
traditional keyword-based search engines due to the rising volume of
publications. The proposed solution involves structured records, underpinning
advanced information technology (IT) tools, including visualization dashboards,
to revolutionize how researchers access and filter articles, replacing the
traditional text-heavy approach. This vision is exemplified through a proof of
concept centered on the ``reproductive number estimate of infectious diseases''
research theme, using a fine-tuned large language model (LLM) to automate the
creation of structured records to populate a backend database that now goes
beyond keywords. The result is a next-generation IR method accessible at
https://orkg.org/usecases/r0-estimates.
|
[
-0.037285588681697845,
-0.20571216940879822,
0.7111396789550781,
0.10491763800382614,
-0.47538554668426514,
0.25643420219421387,
0.029447918757796288,
-0.4061431884765625,
0.4492078125476837,
0.40164467692375183,
-0.1932726502418518,
-0.7212199568748474,
-0.5673753619194031,
0.31319379806518555,
-0.72866290807724,
1.1329975128173828,
0.1972578912973404,
-0.08654139190912247,
-0.6304380297660828,
0.043442726135253906,
0.025597980245947838,
-0.21207351982593536,
-0.0034862421452999115,
-0.4186837077140808,
0.8320260643959045,
0.5260587930679321,
0.661080002784729,
0.9432999491691589,
1.0991910696029663,
0.2262551486492157,
-0.2541486620903015,
0.19738082587718964,
-0.6056808233261108,
0.5959312915802002,
-0.06517281383275986,
-0.4021610617637634,
-0.5405341386795044,
-0.14256615936756134,
0.6934855580329895,
0.9852633476257324,
-0.16578584909439087,
0.16197609901428223,
0.08785950392484665,
0.9660239219665527,
-0.7453688383102417,
0.21091552078723907,
-0.4137294292449951,
-0.036987416446208954,
-0.7351698875427246,
-0.6862123608589172,
-0.44405436515808105,
0.00803695060312748,
0.17106923460960388,
-0.8690099120140076,
0.18035022914409637,
0.04542229697108269,
0.7045375108718872,
0.04929272085428238,
-0.32798489928245544,
-0.2960928976535797,
-0.5566315650939941,
0.39628198742866516,
-0.6018739938735962,
0.27974653244018555,
0.18388321995735168,
-0.0095076784491539,
-0.3585207462310791,
-1.2399929761886597,
0.06368619203567505,
-0.14705640077590942,
-0.25708824396133423,
0.11856719106435776,
-0.09585041552782059,
0.17224492132663727,
0.10563027113676071,
0.2796727418899536,
-0.6711342334747314,
-0.30651000142097473,
-0.8774996399879456,
0.3502621650695801,
0.6636878848075867,
0.04499759525060654,
0.3746282458305359,
-0.06775318831205368,
-0.0031003837939351797,
0.200810968875885,
-0.7923901081085205,
-0.3076954483985901,
-0.03217140957713127,
0.386194109916687,
0.22915883362293243,
0.7627477049827576,
-0.4085674285888672,
0.731902539730072,
-0.20888502895832062,
-0.09695408493280411,
0.18790684640407562,
-0.4907079339027405,
-0.11528710275888443,
-0.025543253868818283,
0.5001216530799866,
0.17217044532299042,
-0.2605822682380676,
-0.2961418926715851,
0.05339384824037552,
-0.36302450299263,
0.36933672428131104,
-0.9829698204994202,
-0.32405880093574524,
0.2068856805562973,
-0.520588219165802,
-0.11753465980291367,
0.299801766872406,
-0.8538383841514587,
-0.39479830861091614,
-0.04803631454706192,
0.23587006330490112,
-0.27088212966918945,
-0.23314832150936127,
0.021005453541874886,
-0.4330228269100189,
-0.07339794188737869,
0.2798883616924286,
-0.42506855726242065,
0.33499109745025635,
0.984093964099884,
1.1811449527740479,
-0.18169070780277252,
0.18201878666877747,
-0.31200090050697327,
0.3267010450363159,
-0.33183547854423523,
0.8230241537094116,
-0.6981009840965271,
-0.7355385422706604,
-0.004008682444691658,
-0.3693249821662903,
0.06769213080406189,
-0.3473580479621887,
0.1424802839756012,
-0.7286376357078552,
0.2097029983997345,
-0.0915386974811554,
-0.5719203948974609,
-0.05090150237083435,
-0.03554367274045944,
-0.5155431628227234,
0.6677491664886475,
-0.17866982519626617,
-0.9345605373382568,
0.2441788762807846,
-0.6902008652687073,
-0.534071683883667,
0.5355850458145142,
-0.178388774394989,
-0.25988999009132385,
0.22024744749069214,
-0.18884897232055664,
0.23592659831047058,
-0.29712042212486267,
0.476325660943985,
-0.41223403811454773,
-0.33278772234916687,
-0.10006348788738251,
0.4136489927768707,
0.48475101590156555,
0.38019201159477234,
0.08912937343120575,
0.23097878694534302,
-0.6943245530128479,
0.03462957963347435,
-0.3613639175891876,
-0.22367796301841736,
-0.8342719674110413,
0.520632803440094,
-0.15272757411003113,
-0.24567198753356934,
0.35500791668891907,
-0.32325515151023865,
0.4650183320045471,
-0.39395156502723694,
0.6187071800231934,
0.059774454683065414,
0.014883601106703281,
0.5137653946876526,
-0.22030173242092133,
0.4044579267501831,
-0.09528940171003342,
0.238172709941864,
-0.47309479117393494,
-0.592825710773468,
-0.3560788929462433,
-0.40850701928138733,
0.39610475301742554,
0.19698293507099152,
-0.6566630601882935,
0.04752200096845627,
-0.6998400688171387,
-0.6096144318580627,
-0.3030446469783783,
0.010696628130972385,
0.31559130549430847,
0.43871888518333435,
0.29031267762184143,
-0.21143107116222382,
-0.6281455755233765,
-0.7255618572235107,
-0.27493202686309814,
-0.41135087609291077,
-0.26824668049812317,
0.24801599979400635,
0.6947593092918396,
-0.15175148844718933,
0.7233928442001343,
-0.5550360083580017,
-0.3228629231452942,
0.060575276613235474,
0.4479428231716156,
0.3334876298904419,
0.4433078169822693,
0.08492372184991837,
-1.0764118432998657,
-0.16817030310630798,
0.04652709513902664,
-0.8566446304321289,
-0.21164292097091675,
0.567184567451477,
-0.21748031675815582,
-0.31955328583717346,
0.6872619986534119,
-0.26670128107070923,
0.33464479446411133,
0.1529458910226822,
-0.384468674659729,
0.12144618481397629,
-0.1352076232433319,
0.07318086177110672,
-0.7876954078674316,
0.4870818555355072,
0.015294975601136684,
-0.158196359872818,
-0.4736425280570984,
0.4219866096973419,
0.10786434262990952,
-0.12154232710599899,
-0.14739902317523956,
0.24040746688842773,
-0.6649839878082275,
-0.12494219094514847,
-0.33721601963043213,
0.3513014316558838,
0.3179660439491272,
-0.2354148030281067,
-0.204111248254776,
0.9810954332351685,
0.22433385252952576,
-0.49284908175468445,
-0.1929755061864853,
0.36274027824401855,
-0.19359102845191956,
0.2753617465496063,
-0.7759841084480286,
-0.1278398334980011,
-0.4947828948497772,
0.2633557915687561,
-0.7456840872764587,
-0.43849053978919983,
-0.1871783584356308,
-0.4788345396518707,
0.41891714930534363,
-0.27991750836372375,
-0.36632397770881653,
-0.14748108386993408,
-0.5180535316467285,
0.28287866711616516,
0.29368889331817627,
-0.18720731139183044,
0.631359338760376,
0.6263864040374756,
-0.44556140899658203,
-0.5875752568244934,
-0.29899337887763977,
0.5051422715187073,
-0.08852308988571167,
-0.7829728722572327,
0.5426369309425354,
0.08751217275857925,
-0.7152305245399475,
0.230452299118042,
-0.15718533098697662,
-0.358897864818573,
0.24168577790260315,
0.16484715044498444,
0.28978604078292847,
-0.06818880140781403,
0.5910490155220032,
-0.07042258977890015,
0.16390958428382874,
-0.10558538883924484,
-0.2773284614086151,
0.1015457957983017,
-0.023253588005900383,
-0.013645918108522892,
0.20318233966827393,
0.7128077149391174,
0.7970596551895142,
-0.2865792512893677,
0.4913923442363739,
-0.017895536497235298,
-0.31261739134788513,
0.060334816575050354,
-0.25745344161987305,
-0.30991917848587036,
-0.3775162994861603,
0.4364028573036194,
-0.09597622603178024,
-0.6964369416236877,
0.5164908170700073,
-0.06292413920164108,
0.2714030146598816,
0.5075070261955261,
0.01980426535010338,
-0.44017404317855835,
0.9002468585968018,
0.8671455979347229,
0.23757047951221466,
0.4917486011981964,
-0.16226501762866974,
0.25181668996810913,
-0.9471161961555481,
-0.576804518699646,
-0.9867539405822754,
-0.1442101001739502,
-0.6335068345069885,
-0.26590389013290405,
1.1055015325546265,
0.24617744982242584,
-0.19551070034503937,
-0.010030112229287624,
-0.6004483103752136,
0.19197402894496918,
0.5704687833786011,
0.3138960897922516,
0.6654394865036011,
-0.18157866597175598,
0.046320173889398575,
-0.06370163708925247,
-0.7154099345207214,
-0.4883010685443878,
1.040166974067688,
0.059209808707237244,
0.8669126629829407,
-0.02281610481441021,
0.5936649441719055,
0.43502405285835266,
0.6028119325637817,
-0.6086966395378113,
0.25835248827934265,
-0.2595473825931549,
-0.7457662224769592,
-0.12103722244501114,
-0.18335586786270142,
-0.7382915616035461,
0.21039359271526337,
-0.048455484211444855,
-0.5263661742210388,
0.4783225953578949,
0.07857946306467056,
-0.17014062404632568,
0.10449995845556259,
-0.38742876052856445,
0.34795159101486206,
0.023811103776097298,
-0.6345177888870239,
-0.21955297887325287,
-0.80964595079422,
0.4300128221511841,
0.13846342265605927,
0.311221182346344,
-0.05495404824614525,
-0.3393501341342926,
1.0575816631317139,
-0.729725182056427,
0.4046730101108551,
0.018054893240332603,
0.3156835734844208,
0.010951770469546318,
-0.24624675512313843,
0.39724981784820557,
0.08803421258926392,
-0.15448829531669617,
0.10774029791355133,
0.1209094300866127,
-0.46897247433662415,
-0.41385799646377563,
0.4846193790435791,
-0.4469332695007324,
-0.6994908452033997,
-0.6522557735443115,
-0.51307213306427,
0.09754639118909836,
0.2731066644191742,
0.3062171936035156,
0.6241481304168701,
0.11620518565177917,
0.8461443185806274,
0.9451870918273926,
-0.03449012711644173,
0.28165125846862793,
0.8094713091850281,
-0.3021930158138275,
-0.4138290286064148,
0.5316143035888672,
0.24469971656799316,
-0.07808900624513626,
0.6824518442153931,
0.15741537511348724,
-0.16109099984169006,
-0.8519957065582275,
-0.18176929652690887,
0.1858820617198944,
-0.30188092589378357,
-0.6443102359771729,
-0.9147824048995972,
-0.11738346517086029,
-0.38929152488708496,
0.006461021024733782,
-0.1534484326839447,
-0.2449180781841278,
-0.5911532640457153,
-0.08967467397451401,
0.5739296078681946,
0.7981336712837219,
-0.049849867820739746,
0.27970069646835327,
-0.6486894488334656,
0.1804528832435608,
0.021929854527115822,
0.42558640241622925,
-0.20483097434043884,
-0.4983835518360138,
-0.4534996449947357,
-0.19523294270038605,
-0.21374951303005219,
-0.8389954566955566,
0.5779137015342712,
0.5602730512619019,
0.022776523604989052,
0.38661977648735046,
0.11404523998498917,
0.9562767148017883,
-0.5846173167228699,
0.5778350830078125,
-0.05938734859228134,
-0.5600980520248413,
0.7393298149108887,
-0.5480031967163086,
0.10045799612998962,
0.8055221438407898,
0.49016478657722473,
-0.5112955570220947,
-0.365068256855011,
-0.5173311829566956,
-1.411653995513916,
0.17602139711380005,
-0.006990457884967327,
-0.3091687560081482,
-0.006486762780696154,
0.6002958416938782,
-0.0529378317296505,
0.5528869032859802,
-0.1975724995136261,
-0.29957297444343567,
-0.0009627821855247021,
-0.171121284365654,
0.22025781869888306,
-0.48934993147850037,
-0.2328503280878067,
-0.23476789891719818,
0.8330760598182678,
-0.1458018720149994,
0.13271702826023102,
0.7178000211715698,
-0.18776541948318481,
-0.272786021232605,
0.3162381052970886,
0.6293244361877441,
1.1021099090576172,
-0.34837841987609863,
0.20667654275894165,
-0.6226778030395508,
-0.7296978831291199,
-0.11925041675567627,
0.1953471601009369,
-0.7589780688285828,
0.12397029250860214,
0.5924074649810791,
0.4451014995574951,
0.3538862466812134,
-0.606007993221283,
0.4987472891807556,
0.12485367059707642,
-0.11867654323577881,
-0.30100277066230774,
-0.03543132543563843,
-0.02644931524991989,
0.2770706117153168,
1.0381380319595337,
-0.12994568049907684,
0.6940163373947144,
-0.5226816534996033,
0.4350280463695526,
0.512069582939148,
-0.5389705300331116,
-0.3394874334335327,
0.8143223524093628,
0.261469304561615,
-0.18430070579051971,
0.43578416109085083,
0.28159046173095703,
-0.1721833199262619,
0.42615804076194763,
0.2718806862831116,
0.6665521264076233,
0.10640139132738113,
0.1438974291086197,
0.27122750878334045,
0.22384066879749298,
-0.3266085386276245,
0.4036635160446167,
0.06298772990703583,
-0.21694490313529968,
-0.6458513140678406,
-0.5192622542381287,
-0.45204925537109375,
-0.013169285841286182,
-0.8516274094581604,
0.11183852702379227,
-0.22079706192016602,
-0.0945236086845398,
0.16698063910007477,
0.23000524938106537,
-0.23200146853923798,
-0.1613292545080185,
-0.01743619330227375,
1.3969999551773071,
-0.6809148788452148,
0.5814089775085449,
0.6910104751586914,
-0.38937821984291077,
-0.4696897864341736,
-0.39228856563568115,
-0.17072829604148865,
-0.5016130208969116,
0.6625397205352783,
-0.12281232327222824,
0.020251279696822166,
0.014450130052864552,
-0.9318346977233887,
-1.0181387662887573,
1.1397264003753662,
-0.048829108476638794,
-0.7341770529747009,
-0.22409841418266296,
-0.478439599275589,
0.6531962156295776,
-0.2623231112957001,
0.3753381073474884,
0.4690934717655182,
0.6868119239807129,
0.1416829377412796,
-0.639621376991272,
-0.3466707766056061,
-0.7013723254203796,
0.03978792950510979,
0.34137028455734253,
-0.3448072075843811,
0.6798681020736694,
-0.19279514253139496,
-0.26984772086143494,
-0.022175051271915436,
0.8477020263671875,
0.2400112897157669,
0.6494096517562866,
0.038213033229112625,
0.39887145161628723,
0.7555354833602905,
-0.2926711142063141,
1.1318988800048828,
-0.46088501811027527,
0.011208352632820606,
1.0251301527023315,
-0.308441698551178,
0.864185094833374,
0.6230998039245605,
-0.25197112560272217,
0.5289700627326965,
0.42638033628463745,
0.14941202104091644,
0.6725194454193115,
0.2406727373600006,
-0.3752022385597229,
0.010549604892730713,
-0.4970652759075165,
-0.43864917755126953,
0.29010671377182007,
0.707341730594635,
-0.3461761474609375,
-0.20706667006015778,
0.07205334305763245,
0.26374098658561707,
0.2813411056995392,
-0.49317479133605957,
1.0363852977752686,
0.04105657339096069,
-0.6500392556190491,
0.01905853860080242,
-0.1833537220954895,
0.5209457874298096,
-0.7701429128646851,
-0.1664131134748459,
-0.21410751342773438,
-0.13411998748779297,
-0.3946031928062439,
-0.6259847283363342,
0.25814494490623474,
-0.12289953231811523,
-0.39099201560020447,
-0.170892134308815,
0.9725075364112854,
-0.4833146333694458,
-0.5375645756721497,
0.02885432168841362,
0.6490746736526489,
0.12965339422225952,
0.07630836963653564,
-0.15891815721988678,
-0.012263977900147438,
-0.3017367720603943,
-0.24067473411560059,
0.1284022480249405,
0.46895793080329895,
-0.17824897170066833,
0.7448610067367554,
0.5265684127807617,
0.4412853419780731,
0.02998477965593338,
-0.23113568127155304,
0.9440111517906189,
-0.6815751791000366,
-0.3747938573360443,
-0.729131817817688,
0.3010236620903015,
-0.19488604366779327,
-0.0750269666314125,
0.6482927203178406,
0.7141988277435303,
0.45113012194633484,
0.11899928748607635,
0.7572396993637085,
-0.3263780176639557,
0.7553334832191467,
-0.005800453945994377,
0.6791037917137146,
-0.5881871581077576,
0.33648547530174255,
-0.0893075093626976,
-0.4212959408760071,
-0.6949498653411865,
0.3244898319244385,
-0.13411331176757812,
-0.17903238534927368,
0.6099685430526733,
0.5039894580841064,
0.1483825445175171,
-0.01194198802113533,
0.09289505332708359,
0.5386361479759216,
0.3818323016166687,
-0.11044337600469589,
0.43955540657043457,
-0.39986035227775574,
0.4375545084476471,
-0.17655940353870392,
-0.27771586179733276,
-0.4843708276748657,
-1.0167993307113647,
-0.3446018695831299,
-0.5631334185600281,
-0.25008007884025574,
-0.19556249678134918,
0.6323451399803162,
0.6312039494514465,
0.5888679623603821,
-0.7208973169326782,
-0.2779156565666199,
-0.09736669808626175,
0.3010256588459015,
-0.09060192853212357,
-0.18845999240875244,
0.3865901529788971,
-0.38501137495040894,
-0.4042445123195648,
0.2684064507484436,
0.7046502232551575,
-0.22406381368637085,
-0.195663720369339,
0.3227235972881317,
-0.41552549600601196,
-0.29406630992889404,
0.5962442755699158,
0.458805114030838,
-0.17514973878860474,
0.12385863065719604,
0.22492729127407074,
-0.16374650597572327,
0.20154725015163422,
0.9880442023277283,
-1.006036400794983,
0.4009566009044647,
0.8586533069610596,
0.3617238402366638,
0.5249000191688538,
0.2070634961128235,
0.8081191182136536,
-0.5469031929969788,
-0.11173088103532791,
0.5149301290512085,
0.2720792293548584,
0.3450486660003662,
-0.42409881949424744,
0.6650199294090271,
0.2636568546295166,
-0.586097776889801,
-1.0280184745788574,
-0.05155520886182785,
-0.7976320385932922,
-0.26213833689689636,
0.7685753703117371,
-0.15845812857151031,
-0.4974123537540436,
-0.2520532011985779,
0.28941023349761963,
0.15699292719364166,
-0.48174649477005005,
0.9380908012390137,
0.2612777054309845,
-0.0028859206940978765,
0.0028200363740324974,
-0.6753836870193481,
0.5440994501113892,
0.06131022796034813,
-0.8221160173416138,
-0.0851433053612709,
0.505563497543335,
0.09589157998561859,
0.36860784888267517,
0.6580930948257446,
-0.528751790523529,
0.07315461337566376,
-0.44712939858436584,
0.09976077079772949,
-0.1901516169309616,
-0.7238370776176453,
-0.02458694577217102,
0.3313961625099182,
-0.08214867115020752,
0.044498011469841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14616v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14616v1
|
The Impact of Word Splitting on the Semantic Content of Contextualized Word Representations
| 2024-02-22T15:04:24 | 2024-02-22T15:04:24 |
Aina Garí Soler, Matthieu Labeau, Chloé Clavel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
When deriving contextualized word representations from language models, a
decision needs to be made on how to obtain one for out-of-vocabulary (OOV)
words that are segmented into subwords. What is the best way to represent these
words with a single vector, and are these representations of worse quality than
those of in-vocabulary words? We carry out an intrinsic evaluation of
embeddings from different models on semantic similarity tasks involving OOV
words. Our analysis reveals, among other interesting findings, that the quality
of representations of words that are split is often, but not always, worse than
that of the embeddings of known words. Their similarity values, however, must
be interpreted with caution.
|
[
-0.4307785630226135,
-0.5615559220314026,
0.34602564573287964,
-0.08511277288198471,
-0.7362570762634277,
-0.10400596261024475,
0.026103543117642403,
-0.4737016260623932,
0.29341673851013184,
0.390386164188385,
-0.20615293085575104,
-0.4351802468299866,
-0.8298816084861755,
-0.12522384524345398,
-0.5420138835906982,
0.6554141044616699,
0.019981587305665016,
0.3910725712776184,
-0.7843201160430908,
-0.5987728834152222,
-0.6841588020324707,
-0.607650637626648,
0.06255281716585159,
-0.4373599886894226,
0.3561486601829529,
0.18146564066410065,
0.7202708125114441,
0.7874515056610107,
0.6504077911376953,
0.322998583316803,
-0.18712732195854187,
-0.1571059376001358,
-0.7091569304466248,
0.3730079233646393,
-0.4413706362247467,
-0.45807164907455444,
0.024181298911571503,
0.38013291358947754,
0.6025972366333008,
1.145443081855774,
0.03319234028458595,
0.049039218574762344,
0.02159699983894825,
0.4585352838039398,
-0.6629599928855896,
-0.04266165941953659,
-0.6153976917266846,
0.05465715378522873,
-0.04194436967372894,
-0.21697251498699188,
-0.23444218933582306,
0.09695516526699066,
0.5357902646064758,
-0.5119852423667908,
0.022838059812784195,
0.3152374029159546,
0.986393392086029,
0.17102909088134766,
-0.2308182567358017,
-0.4067468047142029,
-0.3247666358947754,
1.083150029182434,
-0.43040603399276733,
0.3933664858341217,
0.11207529902458191,
-0.031907130032777786,
-0.13889363408088684,
-0.41193169355392456,
-0.4069477319717407,
-0.24879951775074005,
-0.025216061621904373,
0.11969679594039917,
-0.1260443776845932,
-0.056142788380384445,
0.059842098504304886,
0.3075369596481323,
-0.1845713108778,
0.05393576994538307,
-0.49603426456451416,
0.12444494664669037,
0.5261181592941284,
0.09874852746725082,
0.5971519351005554,
-0.46298015117645264,
-0.7304156422615051,
-0.19350099563598633,
-0.8119571208953857,
-0.12761078774929047,
0.4311750829219818,
0.2530146539211273,
0.44609761238098145,
0.8062084317207336,
-0.018771527335047722,
0.6589480638504028,
-0.12322870641946793,
-0.3648742437362671,
0.27455875277519226,
-0.3412682116031647,
-0.2202972024679184,
0.2506977319717407,
0.30333319306373596,
0.6818752288818359,
0.042335476726293564,
-0.36685529351234436,
-0.13894963264465332,
0.25593939423561096,
0.46865031123161316,
-0.35786983370780945,
0.08151856809854507,
-0.019715309143066406,
-0.7126649618148804,
-0.11129483580589294,
0.44377437233924866,
-0.275114506483078,
-0.21180257201194763,
-0.34784817695617676,
0.6262494921684265,
-0.7216601967811584,
-0.018769489601254463,
0.17117905616760254,
-0.6618205308914185,
0.227602019906044,
0.18433137238025665,
-0.699323296546936,
0.3544883728027344,
0.7950087189674377,
0.7548044323921204,
-0.44366657733917236,
-0.2628554403781891,
-0.39715537428855896,
0.01924602873623371,
-0.46388205885887146,
0.7835185527801514,
-0.6567877531051636,
-0.7466084957122803,
-0.06984271109104156,
-0.12694808840751648,
0.049460649490356445,
-0.740314245223999,
0.3279874324798584,
-0.4462513327598572,
0.21976758539676666,
-0.47700363397598267,
-1.0983631610870361,
-0.35275647044181824,
-0.003117026761174202,
-0.5074934959411621,
0.7263891696929932,
0.1296902447938919,
-0.8589244484901428,
0.832955002784729,
-0.3823659420013428,
-0.29830193519592285,
0.1635473668575287,
-0.2121235430240631,
0.27430108189582825,
0.6824166774749756,
-0.04227377474308014,
0.4844015836715698,
-0.001372513361275196,
-0.3491702079772949,
-0.4373469948768616,
-0.1109120175242424,
0.2867515981197357,
0.04163071885704994,
0.19655580818653107,
0.15831558406352997,
-0.01785477250814438,
0.07084108889102936,
-0.5353244543075562,
-0.0028114281594753265,
0.11238932609558105,
-0.18984898924827576,
-1.2206536531448364,
0.37784162163734436,
0.05182565748691559,
0.30916932225227356,
0.0449008047580719,
-1.0429126024246216,
0.1014247015118599,
-0.7206220030784607,
0.37147092819213867,
0.47335657477378845,
-0.056834425777196884,
0.9698717594146729,
-0.0834001675248146,
0.2604656219482422,
0.2921377122402191,
0.05744615197181702,
0.058368291705846786,
-0.5541045665740967,
-0.5762035250663757,
-0.19495674967765808,
0.41652020812034607,
0.12745384871959686,
-0.6910402178764343,
0.2549370527267456,
-0.4155038893222809,
-0.2904733419418335,
-0.5900378823280334,
0.03922033682465553,
0.36351174116134644,
0.3538302183151245,
0.39531633257865906,
-0.6136951446533203,
-0.1273220181465149,
-0.9571917653083801,
-0.3165039122104645,
0.1695808470249176,
0.2640056908130646,
0.010145439766347408,
0.8797118663787842,
-0.0658903494477272,
1.2628815174102783,
-0.6187278032302856,
-0.4306926131248474,
-0.25462251901626587,
0.025353053584694862,
-0.3316240608692169,
0.49170076847076416,
0.5930573344230652,
-0.8383490443229675,
-0.42718881368637085,
-0.20123398303985596,
-0.32616710662841797,
0.2329280525445938,
0.30219823122024536,
-0.3036503195762634,
0.08293371647596359,
0.7030707001686096,
-0.35684505105018616,
0.6848190426826477,
0.5671392679214478,
-0.35450106859207153,
-0.0017056871438398957,
-0.2678256332874298,
-0.11806751042604446,
-1.0252115726470947,
-0.1453181356191635,
-0.1857801079750061,
-0.165574848651886,
-0.5180525779724121,
0.21520507335662842,
-0.2739585340023041,
0.291023850440979,
-0.6906800270080566,
0.41560226678848267,
-0.5767578482627869,
-0.2734488248825073,
-0.334389328956604,
0.39540281891822815,
0.14666277170181274,
-0.05580925941467285,
0.13556653261184692,
0.4570384919643402,
0.49004510045051575,
-0.18937522172927856,
0.5280170440673828,
0.30729252099990845,
-0.9444589614868164,
0.6554459929466248,
-0.6456282138824463,
-0.017528261989355087,
-0.5550359487533569,
0.17068283259868622,
-0.9150508642196655,
0.008000950329005718,
0.05586225166916847,
-0.29112860560417175,
0.35526078939437866,
-0.03141899034380913,
-0.37974005937576294,
0.24283817410469055,
-0.35607612133026123,
0.6447117328643799,
0.3311024308204651,
-0.5983574986457825,
0.19050683081150055,
0.7857034802436829,
0.26755204796791077,
-0.487632691860199,
-0.9114058017730713,
-0.24461214244365692,
-0.31641560792922974,
-0.7190763354301453,
0.6996755003929138,
0.31201693415641785,
-0.5184017419815063,
0.5268077850341797,
-0.11093445122241974,
0.10099422931671143,
-0.2012791782617569,
0.42757079005241394,
-0.06527985632419586,
-0.08267030119895935,
0.422010600566864,
0.081808902323246,
0.05910435691475868,
-0.17590107023715973,
-0.41948509216308594,
0.5036440491676331,
0.08966248482465744,
-0.437705397605896,
0.3952794075012207,
0.8747161030769348,
0.32565200328826904,
-0.2692592740058899,
1.1654402017593384,
0.3282370865345001,
-0.45848187804222107,
-0.2903535068035126,
-0.2656639516353607,
0.16570033133029938,
-0.32405582070350647,
0.28502729535102844,
-0.33157187700271606,
-0.9175419807434082,
0.4629097282886505,
0.12469634413719177,
-0.16209624707698822,
0.7013033628463745,
0.30100300908088684,
-0.24239201843738556,
1.0500818490982056,
0.7153250575065613,
0.05256463959813118,
0.5369240045547485,
-0.40848639607429504,
0.04866810142993927,
-0.9666992425918579,
-0.4313383400440216,
-0.2979488670825958,
-0.18918375670909882,
-0.5065587759017944,
-0.7105006575584412,
0.26114752888679504,
0.15799687802791595,
0.3406907618045807,
0.2552064061164856,
-0.3738788664340973,
0.4097288250923157,
0.5878342986106873,
-0.10051626712083817,
-0.10796711593866348,
0.22606059908866882,
-0.5077261328697205,
0.08058135211467743,
-0.8973255753517151,
-0.5187045335769653,
0.6784759163856506,
0.3792547583580017,
0.7870583534240723,
0.0875074714422226,
0.6836097836494446,
0.11695808172225952,
0.2194465696811676,
-1.1470417976379395,
0.26713138818740845,
-0.2470918446779251,
-0.749052107334137,
-0.39965030550956726,
-0.15774092078208923,
-1.0569102764129639,
0.6369316577911377,
-0.25127196311950684,
-0.9291244149208069,
0.44836416840553284,
-0.4083740711212158,
-0.2581139802932739,
0.18760977685451508,
-0.5703889727592468,
0.8507568836212158,
0.20572702586650848,
-0.03774164989590645,
-0.4685491919517517,
-0.5938224792480469,
0.053924560546875,
0.1238204762339592,
0.2379893660545349,
-0.25418370962142944,
-0.2601034641265869,
1.009753704071045,
-0.9687548875808716,
0.42393335700035095,
-0.01986032724380493,
-0.0373392179608345,
0.5484798550605774,
-0.09811992943286896,
0.017126230522990227,
-0.2593054473400116,
0.12018150091171265,
0.2173440158367157,
0.5286110639572144,
-0.4598572552204132,
-0.5875403881072998,
0.9374222159385681,
-0.6908823251724243,
-0.461164265871048,
-0.5829949378967285,
-0.3579135537147522,
-0.08074990659952164,
-0.11783753335475922,
0.803569495677948,
1.0396887063980103,
-0.33649471402168274,
0.2752772569656372,
0.34061673283576965,
-0.35267147421836853,
0.2786914110183716,
-0.06485811620950699,
-0.25011536478996277,
-0.2533140182495117,
0.9893062114715576,
0.6455739736557007,
0.3297245502471924,
0.44253435730934143,
0.21340954303741455,
-0.6444247961044312,
-0.3915459215641022,
-0.1794157177209854,
0.15798430144786835,
-1.2352771759033203,
0.05830312520265579,
-0.3094393312931061,
0.15426282584667206,
-0.35738086700439453,
-0.10855082422494888,
-0.5320984125137329,
-0.3976873457431793,
-0.3900080919265747,
-0.11656847596168518,
0.010007829405367374,
1.1142088174819946,
0.09210065007209778,
0.060966212302446365,
-0.8129116296768188,
-0.08299080282449722,
0.27448755502700806,
0.2311333566904068,
-0.12633293867111206,
-0.44784560799598694,
-0.4334648847579956,
-0.26798224449157715,
0.1870439648628235,
-0.9246706366539001,
0.36400502920150757,
0.22312992811203003,
0.6177850365638733,
0.5271950960159302,
0.18519806861877441,
0.5475636124610901,
-0.5759165287017822,
1.00606107711792,
0.3286214768886566,
-1.007201910018921,
0.24237729609012604,
-0.08807063847780228,
0.40732163190841675,
0.577029287815094,
0.5224084854125977,
-0.5541939735412598,
-0.23182326555252075,
-0.5481440424919128,
-1.0199354887008667,
0.6000637412071228,
-0.007560236845165491,
0.323302298784256,
-0.4483805000782013,
0.06878173351287842,
0.387283056974411,
0.09021217375993729,
-0.12578003108501434,
-0.21662357449531555,
-0.373451292514801,
0.11525297164916992,
-0.31158480048179626,
-0.5839471220970154,
-0.0932600125670433,
-0.12986986339092255,
0.2597813308238983,
0.16821792721748352,
0.49299106001853943,
0.31267184019088745,
-0.4804098308086395,
0.024423807859420776,
0.16461041569709778,
0.5875988602638245,
0.6892757415771484,
-0.13771741092205048,
0.35096505284309387,
0.2488592118024826,
-0.3959783911705017,
0.028059517964720726,
-0.45746171474456787,
0.13313427567481995,
0.29783520102500916,
0.7695847749710083,
0.7549043297767639,
0.11776871234178543,
-0.5630335807800293,
0.8114515542984009,
0.09049084782600403,
0.08119343966245651,
0.03406161814928055,
-0.12584535777568817,
-0.06885956227779388,
-0.05190170183777809,
0.015000622719526291,
-0.04555805027484894,
0.17475488781929016,
-0.8434436321258545,
-0.03717273846268654,
0.48284387588500977,
-0.7217592000961304,
-0.14029815793037415,
0.04751758277416229,
0.28483888506889343,
0.024394413456320763,
0.5864236354827881,
-0.08670278638601303,
-0.738418698310852,
0.21784231066703796,
0.24641381204128265,
0.6379552483558655,
-0.01622426137328148,
-0.06552288681268692,
-0.01758020743727684,
0.09218320995569229,
-0.013288664631545544,
0.12021458894014359,
-0.034202683717012405,
-0.9381851553916931,
-0.4231629967689514,
-0.7050706148147583,
-0.1895948201417923,
-0.3866110146045685,
-0.8183966279029846,
-0.06814459711313248,
-0.11403337866067886,
-0.3615621030330658,
-0.1305716633796692,
-0.40885958075523376,
-0.6504868268966675,
0.4183441698551178,
0.34605705738067627,
0.7451472282409668,
-0.5688163042068481,
0.8065629005432129,
1.0796524286270142,
-0.39092782139778137,
-0.7130281925201416,
-0.0978962630033493,
-0.26181820034980774,
-0.43213286995887756,
1.0372254848480225,
0.1433299332857132,
-0.26076969504356384,
-0.3719642162322998,
-0.4423077702522278,
-1.0831475257873535,
0.7626942992210388,
0.09174766391515732,
-0.1670243740081787,
0.04516119882464409,
0.3620525300502777,
0.5712554454803467,
-0.5799439549446106,
0.21563701331615448,
0.40614885091781616,
0.10182793438434601,
0.11275677382946014,
-0.6942887306213379,
0.029129130765795708,
-0.06324751675128937,
0.28235822916030884,
0.13987745344638824,
-0.3423542082309723,
0.8812111616134644,
0.12721505761146545,
-0.6194369792938232,
-0.0925668403506279,
0.6839290261268616,
-0.49071788787841797,
-0.1468258649110794,
0.574611246585846,
0.6395977735519409,
0.33575087785720825,
-0.10646740347146988,
1.2979810237884521,
-0.2774962782859802,
0.41961923241615295,
0.8241557478904724,
0.06273626536130905,
1.0495795011520386,
0.7358778119087219,
0.13815054297447205,
0.3965755105018616,
0.45322278141975403,
0.3005930483341217,
0.9311087131500244,
0.4362984001636505,
0.0030125656630843878,
-0.27811023592948914,
-0.3740118741989136,
-0.3602709174156189,
0.900292694568634,
0.2895106077194214,
-0.5527715682983398,
-0.21494489908218384,
0.24723905324935913,
-0.26501116156578064,
0.04316314309835434,
-0.22016455233097076,
0.7535465955734253,
0.33260735869407654,
-0.729949414730072,
0.3629010319709778,
0.2140609622001648,
0.6095985770225525,
-0.28858786821365356,
-0.0025254827924072742,
-0.054505981504917145,
0.11349255591630936,
-0.2292802780866623,
-0.843993604183197,
0.5563603639602661,
-0.34614214301109314,
-0.11545615643262863,
-0.36065787076950073,
0.8331528902053833,
-0.4693751335144043,
-0.17377197742462158,
0.6077919006347656,
0.4585643708705902,
0.15234634280204773,
-0.1971452832221985,
-0.410129576921463,
0.20878633856773376,
-0.4822376072406769,
-0.33167266845703125,
0.37323442101478577,
0.16597555577754974,
0.10683374106884003,
0.47427797317504883,
0.2880323827266693,
-0.06523449718952179,
0.29775744676589966,
-0.0141580980271101,
0.8663937449455261,
-0.44437703490257263,
-0.5654606223106384,
-0.7379007339477539,
0.37828075885772705,
-0.027583984658122063,
-0.42530855536460876,
0.8895898461341858,
0.3880423903465271,
1.0360634326934814,
-0.14310528337955475,
0.5304705500602722,
0.08936286717653275,
0.42463403940200806,
-0.4834159016609192,
0.6716161370277405,
-0.8811095356941223,
0.01096147857606411,
-0.535124659538269,
-0.9837079048156738,
-0.10023964196443558,
0.7384759187698364,
-0.5530583262443542,
-0.21322177350521088,
0.8671730160713196,
0.49222898483276367,
-0.0101109454408288,
-0.19338393211364746,
0.658613920211792,
-0.19609592854976654,
0.009085360914468765,
0.1369209587574005,
1.3230596780776978,
-0.2815878093242645,
0.1127173975110054,
-0.25254085659980774,
0.004442714620381594,
-0.26847583055496216,
-0.6486383676528931,
-0.7693411111831665,
-0.8482263684272766,
-0.3645784854888916,
-0.20256969332695007,
-0.10567353665828705,
1.1357192993164062,
0.6844018697738647,
-0.5006407499313354,
-0.03225962072610855,
0.1457095593214035,
0.18152296543121338,
-0.08635973185300827,
-0.11683636903762817,
0.37973666191101074,
-0.1731802374124527,
-0.6305932998657227,
0.45197606086730957,
0.4564893841743469,
-0.12504959106445312,
-0.5245160460472107,
-0.014175540767610073,
-0.15493391454219818,
0.41930365562438965,
0.9782246947288513,
-0.2929956912994385,
-0.8698151111602783,
-0.6851865649223328,
-0.21080711483955383,
-0.3706015944480896,
0.12261452525854111,
0.5789347887039185,
-0.5660313367843628,
0.6183106303215027,
1.1126039028167725,
0.16538037359714508,
0.2861330807209015,
0.10865410417318344,
0.4947553873062134,
-0.5574342012405396,
0.13493971526622772,
0.20283396542072296,
0.5361014604568481,
0.4168761670589447,
0.06967012584209442,
0.19407181441783905,
0.3328421711921692,
-0.09831446409225464,
-0.5786408185958862,
0.42491644620895386,
-0.9240635633468628,
-0.5997398495674133,
1.4449928998947144,
-0.4105035364627838,
-0.5076541304588318,
-0.09819670021533966,
-0.23164823651313782,
0.1639484018087387,
-0.20846286416053772,
0.11099335551261902,
0.9447530508041382,
-0.09629057347774506,
0.2428743839263916,
-0.1476416140794754,
0.3654555082321167,
0.3635021448135376,
-0.2539733350276947,
-0.461551308631897,
0.2945266366004944,
0.30980417132377625,
0.38187211751937866,
0.05231178551912308,
-0.19262336194515228,
-0.23186226189136505,
0.2961827218532562,
-0.006697827484458685,
0.07125469297170639,
-0.14287574589252472,
-0.3862372934818268,
0.40676459670066833,
0.13557279109954834,
-0.4680585265159607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14614v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14614v2
|
Two Counterexamples to Tokenization and the Noiseless Channel
| 2024-02-22T15:03:25 | 2024-02-29T09:20:37 |
Marco Cognetta, Vilém Zouhar, Sangwhan Moon, Naoaki Okazaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In Tokenization and the Noiseless Channel (Zouhar et al., 2023a), R\'enyi
efficiency is suggested as an intrinsic mechanism for evaluating a tokenizer:
for NLP tasks, the tokenizer which leads to the highest R\'enyi efficiency of
the unigram distribution should be chosen. The R\'enyi efficiency is thus
treated as a predictor of downstream performance (e.g., predicting BLEU for a
machine translation task), without the expensive step of training multiple
models with different tokenizers. Although useful, the predictive power of this
metric is not perfect, and the authors note there are additional qualities of a
good tokenization scheme that R\'enyi efficiency alone cannot capture.
We describe two variants of BPE tokenization which can arbitrarily increase
R\'enyi efficiency while decreasing the downstream model performance. These
counterexamples expose cases where R\'enyi efficiency fails as an intrinsic
tokenization metric and thus give insight for building more accurate
predictors.
|
[
-0.3970649242401123,
-0.4786714017391205,
0.3632974624633789,
0.2528744637966156,
-0.5333642363548279,
-0.23015861213207245,
-0.2721101641654968,
-0.7115780115127563,
0.3603578805923462,
0.12510207295417786,
-0.4332347512245178,
-0.06490306556224823,
-0.8498205542564392,
-0.10342597961425781,
-0.44989052414894104,
1.0637938976287842,
0.24899479746818542,
0.398159921169281,
-0.02465391717851162,
-0.15973372757434845,
-0.36736923456192017,
-0.7031904458999634,
-0.5817872881889343,
-0.6178919076919556,
0.5490565896034241,
-0.11534270644187927,
0.34179121255874634,
0.5669795870780945,
0.6405896544456482,
0.23746933043003082,
-0.0978134423494339,
-0.1588047295808792,
-0.3258350193500519,
0.25760626792907715,
-0.1700195074081421,
-0.5287385582923889,
-0.39700138568878174,
0.02897614985704422,
0.649147629737854,
0.7388601899147034,
0.07001157104969025,
0.290709912776947,
-0.029452083632349968,
0.8447170257568359,
-0.6990368366241455,
0.07564053684473038,
-0.796501636505127,
0.0034389521460980177,
-0.21988742053508759,
-0.2730129361152649,
-0.4801582992076874,
-0.187537282705307,
-0.04881560429930687,
-0.36074671149253845,
0.20243291556835175,
0.2311013638973236,
0.8688830733299255,
0.6255720853805542,
0.08364176005125046,
-0.35226181149482727,
-0.7563459277153015,
0.9117032885551453,
-0.782558262348175,
0.6331357359886169,
0.24604162573814392,
0.08337293565273285,
0.07692409306764603,
-0.7308448553085327,
-0.4789099097251892,
-0.23102137446403503,
-0.059945717453956604,
0.35793641209602356,
-0.4555283486843109,
0.47205716371536255,
0.3763655424118042,
0.4740132987499237,
-0.19380362331867218,
0.28457924723625183,
-0.5315312147140503,
-0.09215185046195984,
0.18225933611392975,
-0.13296671211719513,
-0.0030868113972246647,
-0.23785515129566193,
-0.5002714991569519,
0.22301502525806427,
-0.47000381350517273,
0.03739460930228233,
0.4508902132511139,
0.32619959115982056,
0.20934037864208221,
0.6962440609931946,
-0.05001216009259224,
0.5206609964370728,
0.1693369597196579,
-0.08634256571531296,
0.09293556958436966,
-0.608009934425354,
-0.19881926476955414,
0.08700203895568848,
0.5669344067573547,
0.1688186526298523,
0.2514832615852356,
-0.5969253182411194,
-0.5058010816574097,
0.23071080446243286,
0.40304434299468994,
-1.266296625137329,
-0.2831806242465973,
0.4949412941932678,
-0.7976997494697571,
-0.19048742949962616,
0.2642522156238556,
-0.4144774079322815,
0.13648906350135803,
-0.10270075500011444,
0.5115245580673218,
-0.3043169379234314,
-0.25237637758255005,
-0.10049206763505936,
-0.7139565944671631,
0.006307861767709255,
-0.06451203674077988,
-0.9716712832450867,
0.21887417137622833,
0.9826450943946838,
1.1929994821548462,
-0.19577135145664215,
-0.30498433113098145,
-0.558768093585968,
0.006563841365277767,
-0.5019668340682983,
0.7238208651542664,
-0.46652698516845703,
-0.21700763702392578,
-0.2074931263923645,
-0.2443259209394455,
-0.34182578325271606,
-0.5120906233787537,
0.5997831225395203,
-0.3249809741973877,
-0.2086031138896942,
-0.34559446573257446,
-0.7395526170730591,
-0.3425903916358948,
-0.39324501156806946,
-0.6132920384407043,
0.7228493094444275,
0.07120731472969055,
-0.7104684114456177,
0.9252865314483643,
-0.7876790165901184,
-0.356246680021286,
0.11722619086503983,
0.3568553030490875,
-0.3535575866699219,
0.6176660656929016,
-0.14332646131515503,
0.29773926734924316,
0.21363575756549835,
0.30607807636260986,
-0.1499156355857849,
-0.8700262904167175,
0.37696513533592224,
-0.5823407173156738,
0.4831937551498413,
0.06635890156030655,
-0.6181303262710571,
0.031691230833530426,
-0.8369459509849548,
0.08520647883415222,
-0.5927380323410034,
-0.4716280698776245,
-0.20889262855052948,
0.012489515356719494,
0.07438294589519501,
-0.017510948702692986,
0.09002093970775604,
-0.8361812829971313,
-0.16410179436206818,
-0.5702431201934814,
0.4332341253757477,
1.0248618125915527,
-0.00990504864603281,
0.4157721698284149,
-0.4851714074611664,
0.4861014485359192,
-0.03161768987774849,
0.16554367542266846,
-0.04721229895949364,
-0.7772825360298157,
-0.9339701533317566,
-0.7924678325653076,
0.6745731234550476,
0.42312532663345337,
-0.15521207451820374,
0.46019065380096436,
-0.35447198152542114,
-0.6823988556861877,
-0.47202786803245544,
0.011897988617420197,
0.3687509298324585,
0.2540537118911743,
0.37416064739227295,
-0.6309255957603455,
-0.6077519059181213,
-0.6487210988998413,
-0.5389477014541626,
-0.24819853901863098,
0.07481034845113754,
0.1900366246700287,
0.5158299207687378,
-0.0963599905371666,
0.6831708550453186,
0.11641909182071686,
-0.28956565260887146,
-0.4114248752593994,
0.29209181666374207,
0.48636531829833984,
0.7874982953071594,
0.5487496852874756,
-0.43843576312065125,
-0.32135847210884094,
-0.1588004231452942,
-0.3703969120979309,
-0.3044753968715668,
-0.16337652504444122,
-0.2073093056678772,
0.3535478711128235,
0.2874304950237274,
-0.6787692308425903,
0.5111434459686279,
0.44071826338768005,
-0.34151145815849304,
0.5364609360694885,
-0.14416001737117767,
-0.021932832896709442,
-0.49831095337867737,
0.336234450340271,
-0.02595282904803753,
-0.045971229672431946,
-0.8288639783859253,
0.07737303525209427,
-0.10758201777935028,
-0.07681689411401749,
-0.2482100874185562,
0.46137142181396484,
-0.2759159803390503,
-0.17935968935489655,
-0.29160481691360474,
0.11590105295181274,
-0.010503423400223255,
0.5511609315872192,
0.031152643263339996,
0.7350491881370544,
0.536479651927948,
-0.8154495358467102,
0.12292733043432236,
-0.01660645753145218,
-0.22425587475299835,
0.4930016100406647,
-1.0264350175857544,
0.004110272973775864,
-0.21728827059268951,
0.195705384016037,
-0.7632883191108704,
0.1876145750284195,
0.2625344395637512,
-0.7428050637245178,
0.42319178581237793,
-0.14532028138637543,
-0.1504979431629181,
-0.09270957112312317,
-0.6226557493209839,
0.18368211388587952,
0.5075308084487915,
-0.7247523069381714,
0.3165339529514313,
0.055515799671411514,
0.42802050709724426,
-0.8189319968223572,
-1.097923994064331,
-0.12789545953273773,
-0.3123708963394165,
-0.44886863231658936,
0.21078893542289734,
0.00043888750951737165,
0.03318735212087631,
0.2795436680316925,
-0.3366532623767853,
0.08563590049743652,
0.24338822066783905,
0.41470032930374146,
0.27843770384788513,
-0.14262142777442932,
0.22012566030025482,
-0.24935051798820496,
-0.24716517329216003,
0.13423976302146912,
-0.7294500470161438,
0.43931815028190613,
0.006955009885132313,
-0.39574486017227173,
-0.6512821316719055,
0.2726905345916748,
0.31088316440582275,
-0.0009322351543232799,
1.011332392692566,
0.9776566624641418,
-0.30708494782447815,
0.08852197229862213,
-0.592985212802887,
-0.15156781673431396,
-0.4246191382408142,
0.4221023917198181,
-0.4820738434791565,
-0.602159857749939,
0.49850228428840637,
0.024715349078178406,
0.10212031751871109,
0.3410414457321167,
0.3233068287372589,
0.1596747636795044,
0.8871216177940369,
0.6120308637619019,
0.23256061971187592,
0.7166918516159058,
-0.49404799938201904,
0.7992014288902283,
-1.1754357814788818,
-0.04863953962922096,
-0.6090705990791321,
-0.45957720279693604,
-0.9147959351539612,
-0.33171340823173523,
0.11558229476213455,
0.4115862548351288,
-0.16002555191516876,
0.39676377177238464,
-0.41458553075790405,
0.2536456882953644,
0.8340560793876648,
-0.1013825461268425,
0.3095683157444,
0.031237829476594925,
0.21623213589191437,
-0.17186620831489563,
-1.0399399995803833,
-0.4505348801612854,
1.242213249206543,
0.3220479190349579,
0.5980525612831116,
0.059278570115566254,
0.7404891848564148,
0.18209180235862732,
0.32346248626708984,
-1.0425589084625244,
0.2945694327354431,
-0.23761284351348877,
-0.6048017740249634,
-0.34985092282295227,
-0.5132380723953247,
-0.8767045736312866,
0.34877434372901917,
-0.3456571400165558,
-0.880264163017273,
0.6194694638252258,
0.20592769980430603,
-0.06651932746171951,
0.5935237407684326,
-0.7507268786430359,
0.9213180541992188,
0.23869876563549042,
-0.1125311329960823,
-0.2966153621673584,
-0.05422798544168472,
0.2476901113986969,
-0.1381666511297226,
0.041116274893283844,
0.003121682209894061,
-0.2909294366836548,
0.9500135779380798,
-0.3577389121055603,
0.6073393225669861,
-0.441159188747406,
0.5731250643730164,
0.2573590576648712,
-0.1445927619934082,
0.4970189332962036,
-0.10754472017288208,
-0.24041426181793213,
0.49581974744796753,
-0.09658928215503693,
-0.5666577816009521,
-0.7274731993675232,
0.48919960856437683,
-0.5586096048355103,
-0.39820224046707153,
-0.35685667395591736,
-0.14375048875808716,
0.11972525715827942,
0.06980523467063904,
0.5923484563827515,
0.8482181429862976,
-0.21116451919078827,
0.23522356152534485,
0.23068265616893768,
-0.023463770747184753,
0.6013842225074768,
0.06645593047142029,
0.011118548922240734,
-0.3745618462562561,
1.1781280040740967,
0.34696725010871887,
0.48620277643203735,
0.23958739638328552,
0.39838695526123047,
-0.5308700799942017,
-0.7693066596984863,
-0.5610440373420715,
0.20446720719337463,
-0.887349009513855,
-0.16797606647014618,
-0.742464542388916,
-0.10377823561429977,
-0.33439186215400696,
-0.1930323839187622,
-0.4761349856853485,
-0.7972519397735596,
-0.02536560781300068,
-0.22924824059009552,
0.2132265269756317,
0.8081771731376648,
-0.6797550320625305,
0.07912691682577133,
-0.5491120219230652,
0.14512427151203156,
0.12153983116149902,
0.4376685619354248,
0.35311299562454224,
-0.636903703212738,
-0.4305272400379181,
-0.11534181982278824,
-0.12991222739219666,
-0.6351036429405212,
0.23450832068920135,
0.43869492411613464,
0.7533313632011414,
0.40842896699905396,
0.043191999197006226,
0.755786657333374,
-0.2615714967250824,
0.9881458878517151,
0.3340204954147339,
-1.3039828538894653,
0.33959588408470154,
0.07191243022680283,
-0.05574634671211243,
0.4401579797267914,
0.18202528357505798,
-0.5659849643707275,
-0.6803491115570068,
-0.7469235062599182,
-1.0131217241287231,
0.45665043592453003,
0.13040441274642944,
0.21821826696395874,
-0.10222793370485306,
0.18610544502735138,
0.26958993077278137,
0.5404270887374878,
-0.880541980266571,
-0.39089372754096985,
-0.6314118504524231,
0.15470008552074432,
0.08384852856397629,
-0.45350518822669983,
0.3371783494949341,
-0.25409001111984253,
0.9911916255950928,
0.08962862938642502,
0.5576819777488708,
0.43980544805526733,
0.0020275618880987167,
-0.21333792805671692,
0.18800190091133118,
0.3475491404533386,
0.9492650628089905,
-0.35475435853004456,
-0.01952970214188099,
-0.038749463856220245,
-0.5332862138748169,
0.009228546172380447,
-0.2659817934036255,
-0.4075358510017395,
0.34838199615478516,
0.5463102459907532,
1.0934096574783325,
0.10840621590614319,
-0.4181123673915863,
0.5594170093536377,
0.11694547533988953,
-0.2441369593143463,
-0.21609839797019958,
-0.04455963894724846,
-0.22149686515331268,
0.0853818878531456,
0.24230805039405823,
0.46419578790664673,
0.17843161523342133,
-0.6758061647415161,
0.1297440379858017,
0.710862398147583,
-0.5960994958877563,
-0.2506568133831024,
0.7378519177436829,
0.26410338282585144,
-0.5210084915161133,
0.49616509675979614,
-0.5439335107803345,
-0.5649136304855347,
0.43535658717155457,
0.5925177335739136,
1.0841145515441895,
0.29026320576667786,
0.05319662019610405,
0.6431609392166138,
0.4061623215675354,
0.09233810752630234,
0.025433234870433807,
-0.2560075521469116,
-0.6476745009422302,
-0.6624575257301331,
-0.6642937660217285,
-0.3334032893180847,
-0.06563897430896759,
-0.7358368039131165,
-0.08379577100276947,
-0.2989530563354492,
-0.23956510424613953,
0.052060842514038086,
-0.02877642773091793,
-0.5552909970283508,
0.01563846878707409,
-0.2857879102230072,
0.8293160796165466,
-0.6198630928993225,
0.5790780186653137,
0.4938202202320099,
-0.11240079998970032,
-0.5867676734924316,
0.2097489982843399,
-0.5660153031349182,
-0.5477517247200012,
0.8957340717315674,
0.36534005403518677,
-0.15256987512111664,
-0.2769875228404999,
-0.04806460067629814,
-0.7389902472496033,
0.9776082038879395,
0.08559533953666687,
-0.24798531830310822,
0.270318865776062,
-0.08430439233779907,
0.4923999309539795,
-0.21746331453323364,
0.44379061460494995,
0.4378385841846466,
0.7157548069953918,
-0.10580577701330185,
-0.9638429284095764,
0.03437056764960289,
-0.2922559082508087,
0.2380121350288391,
0.28495022654533386,
-0.6280184388160706,
0.6052159667015076,
-0.3618704080581665,
-0.652426540851593,
0.025774244219064713,
0.5484517812728882,
-0.07308211922645569,
0.3729660212993622,
0.49918198585510254,
0.6300496459007263,
0.7219230532646179,
-0.1858348548412323,
1.0536330938339233,
-0.5179163217544556,
0.30071255564689636,
0.48399239778518677,
0.34648507833480835,
0.7927695512771606,
0.575878381729126,
-0.2634317874908447,
0.25300976634025574,
0.28251099586486816,
-0.07545804977416992,
0.5077203512191772,
0.2784110903739929,
-0.1504291296005249,
-0.15006212890148163,
-0.2894608676433563,
-0.17097963392734528,
0.4633703827857971,
0.012412941083312035,
-0.1045173779129982,
0.022079190239310265,
-0.22096265852451324,
-0.17651568353176117,
0.06670628488063812,
-0.3339415490627289,
0.53774094581604,
0.03521814942359924,
-0.5926926136016846,
0.610000729560852,
0.1208733469247818,
1.2146073579788208,
-0.47534212470054626,
0.0750381350517273,
-0.03652717173099518,
0.10420490056276321,
-0.2841908037662506,
-0.24218788743019104,
0.828681230545044,
0.0193735770881176,
-0.07350336760282516,
-0.13263966143131256,
0.7763786911964417,
-0.05733392387628555,
-0.43423640727996826,
0.341449111700058,
0.6891000270843506,
0.41442355513572693,
-0.08065471798181534,
-0.5743743181228638,
-0.1221918910741806,
-0.1642903834581375,
-0.2990954518318176,
0.23439815640449524,
0.35786864161491394,
0.5502452254295349,
0.7299755215644836,
0.8165177702903748,
0.6273795366287231,
0.24092426896095276,
0.13660794496536255,
0.5448359251022339,
-0.6416874527931213,
-0.5174422264099121,
-0.9776214957237244,
0.20097699761390686,
-0.058510906994342804,
-0.30776652693748474,
0.6910926103591919,
0.6074896454811096,
0.9240684509277344,
0.08520419150590897,
0.6289294958114624,
0.046260539442300797,
0.3241746127605438,
-0.5105549097061157,
0.4228185713291168,
-0.3660762310028076,
0.06501813232898712,
-0.2038605660200119,
-0.9663499593734741,
0.14562755823135376,
0.7187256217002869,
0.05444452539086342,
0.03548891842365265,
0.982073187828064,
0.731754720211029,
0.12162274122238159,
0.16268868744373322,
0.48360031843185425,
-0.0008673053816892207,
0.13827483355998993,
0.2847556173801422,
0.6660797595977783,
-0.49486279487609863,
0.37566128373146057,
-0.4639960527420044,
-0.21866610646247864,
0.03762044757604599,
-0.8579942584037781,
-1.0311379432678223,
-0.5378221273422241,
-0.2337169498205185,
-0.2954806089401245,
0.26678013801574707,
0.7516075372695923,
0.9331079125404358,
-0.7424859404563904,
-0.05407517030835152,
-0.42031508684158325,
0.3080894649028778,
-0.5463029742240906,
-0.20337647199630737,
0.1830058991909027,
-0.6317684054374695,
-0.955649733543396,
0.3049478828907013,
0.43752020597457886,
0.024721819907426834,
-0.4105246067047119,
0.11411760002374649,
0.19454345107078552,
0.36208662390708923,
0.4295753538608551,
-0.05273561552166939,
-0.7266902923583984,
-0.48398399353027344,
-0.10924381017684937,
0.18269997835159302,
0.07107621431350708,
1.0909574031829834,
-0.7055175304412842,
0.12889929115772247,
0.5973358750343323,
0.4918941259384155,
0.5280433297157288,
0.2598976194858551,
0.4197534918785095,
-0.5143123269081116,
0.3585152328014374,
0.11596541851758957,
0.2554781436920166,
0.2187281847000122,
-0.5079584717750549,
0.5280503034591675,
0.492610365152359,
-0.7184417843818665,
-0.89277184009552,
0.3078326880931854,
-0.8498744368553162,
-0.28410032391548157,
1.0704795122146606,
-0.33738431334495544,
-0.24907878041267395,
-0.3353732228279114,
0.13619372248649597,
0.22802592813968658,
-0.6266044974327087,
0.5717101097106934,
0.7348016500473022,
-0.41813600063323975,
0.2609494924545288,
-0.7276721000671387,
0.4652649760246277,
0.5544919371604919,
-0.21362872421741486,
0.0002479941176716238,
0.05843333899974823,
-0.007089934311807156,
0.3182559311389923,
0.8597083687782288,
0.034987736493349075,
0.14878590404987335,
0.3232051730155945,
-0.13983598351478577,
-0.17387139797210693,
-0.1004582941532135,
-0.3149586617946625,
-0.11838949471712112,
0.389007031917572,
-0.34294945001602173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14568v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14568v1
|
LLM-DA: Data Augmentation via Large Language Models for Few-Shot Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-02-22T14:19:56 | 2024-02-22T14:19:56 |
Junjie Ye, Nuo Xu, Yikun Wang, Jie Zhou, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the impressive capabilities of large language models (LLMs), their
performance on information extraction tasks is still not entirely satisfactory.
However, their remarkable rewriting capabilities and extensive world knowledge
offer valuable insights to improve these tasks. In this paper, we propose
$LLM-DA$, a novel data augmentation technique based on LLMs for the few-shot
NER task. To overcome the limitations of existing data augmentation methods
that compromise semantic integrity and address the uncertainty inherent in
LLM-generated text, we leverage the distinctive characteristics of the NER task
by augmenting the original data at both the contextual and entity levels. Our
approach involves employing 14 contextual rewriting strategies, designing
entity replacements of the same type, and incorporating noise injection to
enhance robustness. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our
approach in enhancing NER model performance with limited data. Furthermore,
additional analyses provide further evidence supporting the assertion that the
quality of the data we generate surpasses that of other existing methods.
|
[
-0.38272902369499207,
-1.0633972883224487,
0.6732696294784546,
-0.39666396379470825,
-0.367240309715271,
-0.11320957541465759,
-0.1370389759540558,
-0.6120288968086243,
0.3208877444267273,
0.7098796963691711,
-0.5881104469299316,
-0.5713647603988647,
-0.7246086597442627,
0.49314725399017334,
-0.35946282744407654,
0.866664469242096,
0.13602010905742645,
0.024959621950984,
-0.019650263711810112,
0.19235408306121826,
-0.3124481439590454,
-0.32378438115119934,
-0.6079389452934265,
-0.3643309473991394,
0.6860411763191223,
0.6331855058670044,
0.53724604845047,
0.7524770498275757,
0.7800378799438477,
0.22099249064922333,
-0.15278081595897675,
0.45997992157936096,
-0.5322129130363464,
0.1698232889175415,
-0.07916871458292007,
-0.4581611454486847,
-0.8867675065994263,
-0.34199926257133484,
0.8957158327102661,
0.7404293417930603,
0.10276858508586884,
-0.023507187142968178,
0.10484939813613892,
0.49892458319664,
-0.6682643294334412,
-0.035236772149801254,
-0.9474029541015625,
-0.28921061754226685,
-0.4253483712673187,
-0.18785294890403748,
-0.24301886558532715,
-0.07764865458011627,
0.13808229565620422,
-0.666535496711731,
-0.032876916229724884,
-0.08373341709375381,
0.8322755098342896,
0.5682628154754639,
-0.5128839612007141,
-0.07319934666156769,
-0.8410696387290955,
0.7681859135627747,
-0.9152947068214417,
0.2192925363779068,
0.31371989846229553,
0.25207918882369995,
-0.5609137415885925,
-0.6209484338760376,
-0.877480685710907,
0.04664323106408119,
0.10771070420742035,
-0.1879034787416458,
-0.2781795859336853,
-0.008898429572582245,
0.31002092361450195,
0.2664188742637634,
-0.11920124292373657,
0.3841885030269623,
-0.13024981319904327,
0.09701046347618103,
0.6117376685142517,
0.32159560918807983,
0.3563518822193146,
-0.19213426113128662,
-0.36746731400489807,
0.2219967395067215,
-0.9726101160049438,
-0.4546007812023163,
0.4594217538833618,
0.46387216448783875,
-0.0016984781250357628,
0.8972228169441223,
-0.5004130601882935,
0.7577690482139587,
0.12794449925422668,
-0.530356228351593,
0.20501305162906647,
-0.3132452070713043,
-0.2577767074108124,
0.05703490972518921,
0.4388599693775177,
0.25831133127212524,
-0.06487873941659927,
-0.12362395972013474,
-0.4157540798187256,
-0.07773253321647644,
0.02871384657919407,
-0.9447799324989319,
-0.049131881445646286,
-0.027227099984884262,
-0.23291893303394318,
-0.3492039144039154,
0.016970552504062653,
-0.8063188791275024,
-0.40033993124961853,
-0.36157235503196716,
0.4721817672252655,
-0.46835657954216003,
-0.22963947057724,
-0.029471393674612045,
0.07331198453903198,
0.2943824827671051,
0.48092731833457947,
-0.6669823527336121,
0.3455672860145569,
0.8486928343772888,
0.6204248666763306,
-0.47994738817214966,
-0.1918555349111557,
-0.6354494094848633,
0.45268017053604126,
-0.440557599067688,
0.9143819808959961,
-0.8308247327804565,
-0.26495516300201416,
-0.43949082493782043,
-0.04803232476115227,
0.400031179189682,
-0.5264186859130859,
0.5815093517303467,
-0.7609624862670898,
-0.1839205026626587,
-0.1997082531452179,
-0.8580559492111206,
-0.23764775693416595,
0.31163910031318665,
-0.7656495571136475,
0.8317044973373413,
0.07573628425598145,
-0.7295510172843933,
0.6844404935836792,
-0.4987708032131195,
-0.360506534576416,
0.26964256167411804,
-0.21512708067893982,
-0.42197856307029724,
0.2385820895433426,
0.49466022849082947,
0.37911656498908997,
-0.3731316328048706,
0.12321726977825165,
-0.30691981315612793,
-0.4274541735649109,
0.27960678935050964,
-0.6487813591957092,
0.39328038692474365,
-0.10109425336122513,
0.006916384678333998,
-0.2363993525505066,
-1.021835207939148,
-0.12365906685590744,
0.18112315237522125,
-0.4735567569732666,
-0.46660029888153076,
-0.32443252205848694,
0.010840224102139473,
0.04890849441289902,
0.2144802063703537,
-0.5951513051986694,
0.4079148769378662,
-0.8059573769569397,
0.12586469948291779,
0.5506561398506165,
0.39390242099761963,
0.8046709299087524,
-0.3683905005455017,
0.532742440700531,
0.20023393630981445,
-0.40867310762405396,
-0.2301662564277649,
-0.33628353476524353,
-0.6482911705970764,
-0.5597800016403198,
0.5681265592575073,
0.45448076725006104,
-0.8869276642799377,
0.36259928345680237,
-0.708616316318512,
-0.33172473311424255,
-0.48749393224716187,
0.4002617299556732,
-0.06277560442686081,
0.8214101791381836,
0.39665380120277405,
-0.19501255452632904,
-0.7637364268302917,
-0.8628663420677185,
-0.07180304080247879,
0.14998140931129456,
-0.09251189231872559,
0.4358762204647064,
0.6073866486549377,
-0.5558440685272217,
1.073490023612976,
-0.5092840790748596,
-0.46419692039489746,
-0.3053644001483917,
-0.057759322226047516,
0.33563533425331116,
0.49021005630493164,
0.08504901081323624,
-0.5130284428596497,
-0.39086708426475525,
-0.06057431921362877,
-0.6472010016441345,
-0.11851758509874344,
-0.20962902903556824,
0.11955755949020386,
0.14814896881580353,
0.3446912467479706,
-0.5259888172149658,
0.4943165183067322,
0.22676879167556763,
0.2162945717573166,
0.1824522614479065,
-0.14427493512630463,
-0.014644764363765717,
-1.0845637321472168,
-0.227358877658844,
-0.10396737605333328,
-0.24010317027568817,
-0.773581862449646,
-0.04354218393564224,
-0.00689281290397048,
0.01850714720785618,
-0.6771367788314819,
0.816943883895874,
-0.7410030961036682,
-0.14118140935897827,
-0.7815837860107422,
0.24874182045459747,
-0.05534198880195618,
0.039063699543476105,
0.027213746681809425,
0.6493069529533386,
0.7935083508491516,
-0.7544839382171631,
0.2872816324234009,
0.35579654574394226,
-0.3999786972999573,
0.8178697824478149,
-0.5422255992889404,
0.39501655101776123,
-0.4718720316886902,
0.38151484727859497,
-0.526606023311615,
-0.5457962155342102,
0.1654568612575531,
-0.30229470133781433,
0.4481491148471832,
-0.42016005516052246,
-0.5591164231300354,
0.0771661251783371,
-0.02698637545108795,
0.4412708580493927,
0.3095310628414154,
-0.619994044303894,
0.6359617114067078,
0.5139726996421814,
-0.24782533943653107,
-0.5547448396682739,
-0.9653600454330444,
0.5769312977790833,
-0.46895328164100647,
-0.6541498899459839,
0.7610617876052856,
0.15866714715957642,
-0.28388527035713196,
0.07802437245845795,
-0.15334096550941467,
-0.2073407918214798,
0.05729316920042038,
0.2195439338684082,
0.4995817244052887,
-0.1577209085226059,
0.15862342715263367,
0.10640178620815277,
-0.4780508875846863,
-0.2902686297893524,
-0.09025654941797256,
0.341266930103302,
0.31613415479660034,
-0.3297573924064636,
-0.6745418906211853,
0.3160152733325958,
0.14806902408599854,
0.04838419333100319,
0.6289118528366089,
0.5484743118286133,
-0.796737551689148,
-0.29047542810440063,
-0.5306254625320435,
-0.3857521712779999,
-0.4279614984989166,
0.23921900987625122,
-0.7383065223693848,
-0.7343378663063049,
0.24163034558296204,
-0.26243147253990173,
-0.20033441483974457,
0.3948270082473755,
0.4296285808086395,
0.01782083883881569,
0.7425240874290466,
0.7002190947532654,
-0.20144474506378174,
0.3706827759742737,
-0.18981514871120453,
0.15636421740055084,
-0.9630635380744934,
0.025469960644841194,
-0.20073848962783813,
-0.4050532579421997,
-0.44172143936157227,
-0.5760496854782104,
0.3526594638824463,
0.09268967807292938,
0.07532458007335663,
0.29216060042381287,
-0.22249722480773926,
0.632106363773346,
0.29243046045303345,
0.20494715869426727,
0.5042864084243774,
0.018589580431580544,
0.3057796061038971,
-0.2886711657047272,
-0.40919774770736694,
-0.858910322189331,
1.2835025787353516,
0.26110130548477173,
1.0857996940612793,
0.20861388742923737,
1.0870589017868042,
-0.0764177069067955,
0.12294335663318634,
-0.9360671043395996,
0.5123189687728882,
-0.04831886664032936,
-0.481260746717453,
-0.32915833592414856,
-0.3006127178668976,
-0.9530714154243469,
0.08061570674180984,
-0.5596432089805603,
-0.7182384133338928,
0.300333172082901,
-0.1677694171667099,
-0.4212356507778168,
0.2575816810131073,
-0.3453032970428467,
0.3092259466648102,
-0.07899971306324005,
-0.2635716199874878,
-0.0066505479626357555,
-0.38804855942726135,
0.4075215756893158,
-0.43294188380241394,
0.05989197641611099,
-0.12113204598426819,
-0.6184729337692261,
0.5054461359977722,
-0.5002738237380981,
0.6954346299171448,
-0.027372904121875763,
-0.2868741452693939,
0.2953244745731354,
-0.02862035483121872,
1.1446348428726196,
0.2174074947834015,
-0.2831072211265564,
0.1615418642759323,
-0.35031336545944214,
-0.16473902761936188,
-0.66243976354599,
0.8337476849555969,
-0.2427298128604889,
-0.5969157814979553,
-0.25931796431541443,
-0.7736904621124268,
-0.04884114861488342,
0.3495241105556488,
0.13532212376594543,
0.1784161776304245,
-0.2671709656715393,
0.2617277503013611,
0.39894184470176697,
-0.10937383770942688,
0.3922959268093109,
0.43194398283958435,
0.07400443404912949,
-0.4532882571220398,
0.7957507371902466,
0.2186766266822815,
0.1916664093732834,
0.45103463530540466,
-0.2003874033689499,
-0.26005661487579346,
-0.8273240327835083,
-0.27472060918807983,
0.11429180204868317,
-0.6995308995246887,
-0.33136388659477234,
-0.9485185146331787,
-0.12868306040763855,
-0.40110865235328674,
-0.07958909124135971,
-0.22942113876342773,
-0.5188325047492981,
-0.6460228562355042,
-0.12161551415920258,
0.3596011698246002,
0.5834547877311707,
-0.1305689662694931,
0.5961223840713501,
-0.6681094765663147,
0.7436427474021912,
0.2014933079481125,
0.09717784076929092,
-0.2923663556575775,
-0.6594325304031372,
0.14130252599716187,
0.09852570295333862,
0.09079522639513016,
-0.9452266693115234,
0.7311503887176514,
0.24480703473091125,
0.48010432720184326,
0.19703470170497894,
0.052106648683547974,
0.9080209136009216,
-0.6141226291656494,
0.47208067774772644,
-0.04857007414102554,
-0.774772047996521,
0.6055079698562622,
-0.1281612664461136,
0.14044855535030365,
0.5991683006286621,
0.08213461935520172,
-0.07787776738405228,
-0.13893316686153412,
-0.59396892786026,
-0.8146964311599731,
0.5904244780540466,
0.13601936399936676,
0.3066520094871521,
-0.023534463718533516,
0.5201213955879211,
0.17537999153137207,
-0.04631822556257248,
-0.6150588393211365,
-0.2661181390285492,
0.3732547461986542,
-0.1261393129825592,
0.07941633462905884,
-0.3427964746952057,
0.13984161615371704,
0.006614672485738993,
0.7492406964302063,
-0.15761317312717438,
-0.03391144424676895,
0.23751391470432281,
-0.3861195743083954,
-0.09020913392305374,
0.5333611965179443,
0.3087058663368225,
0.45033466815948486,
-0.04899555444717407,
0.20731252431869507,
0.6354636549949646,
-0.3111647963523865,
0.16009563207626343,
0.08605541288852692,
-0.5724863409996033,
0.06364281475543976,
0.13917434215545654,
0.64178866147995,
0.16689157485961914,
-0.49500572681427,
0.370611310005188,
0.1662490963935852,
0.09637146443128586,
-0.2539736330509186,
0.1265777200460434,
-0.035839177668094635,
0.37043124437332153,
0.5158807039260864,
-0.09482517838478088,
0.2642684876918793,
-0.36696887016296387,
0.4543297588825226,
0.5788071155548096,
-0.18226712942123413,
-0.13285090029239655,
0.5723780989646912,
-0.07240568846464157,
-0.20130066573619843,
0.3016963303089142,
-0.3641774356365204,
-0.06479007750749588,
0.43239396810531616,
0.8136464953422546,
0.6620569229125977,
0.023922640830278397,
-0.05373033881187439,
0.4856348931789398,
0.3584531545639038,
-0.04576876759529114,
0.3168865442276001,
0.20458140969276428,
-0.8083404898643494,
-0.5355995893478394,
-0.5081785917282104,
-0.35714396834373474,
0.24259009957313538,
-0.3501795828342438,
0.6983814239501953,
-0.3189249038696289,
-0.2911709249019623,
0.20427876710891724,
-0.02764756977558136,
-0.7341645359992981,
0.25106939673423767,
0.11354298889636993,
0.5779933929443359,
-0.4539550542831421,
1.0305038690567017,
0.5184216499328613,
-0.4693309962749481,
-0.5031850934028625,
0.08172066509723663,
0.23148265480995178,
-0.5834164023399353,
0.8307409286499023,
0.03729897737503052,
-0.057890258729457855,
0.2608756721019745,
-0.466153621673584,
-1.1508079767227173,
1.1790446043014526,
0.5109800696372986,
-0.6967825889587402,
-0.13936203718185425,
0.18607546389102936,
0.30967551469802856,
-0.6214260458946228,
0.08475963026285172,
0.6323027610778809,
0.606900155544281,
0.1963418871164322,
-0.5325468182563782,
0.05948072299361229,
0.14132510125637054,
0.05217728391289711,
0.09367808699607849,
-0.033701613545417786,
0.6797484755516052,
-0.5012010335922241,
-0.5723938941955566,
0.12478018552064896,
0.843105137348175,
0.2406468689441681,
0.17038625478744507,
0.47836586833000183,
0.6852351427078247,
0.9251183271408081,
0.09537746012210846,
0.9080662131309509,
-0.16712386906147003,
0.1178574487566948,
1.5174299478530884,
-0.4861448407173157,
0.8716192841529846,
0.5897922515869141,
-0.07759718596935272,
0.29238763451576233,
0.3022909164428711,
-0.1851801872253418,
0.4078804850578308,
0.1568879634141922,
-0.4246796667575836,
-0.163997620344162,
-0.4016055464744568,
-0.12983788549900055,
0.7171891331672668,
0.3793144226074219,
-0.25652697682380676,
-0.25210490822792053,
-0.06889130920171738,
-0.08310913294553757,
-0.07983078807592392,
-0.2125076800584793,
0.9836610555648804,
0.2403189092874527,
-0.19366823136806488,
0.43698185682296753,
0.18668347597122192,
1.003453254699707,
-0.0721510499715805,
-0.2236722856760025,
-0.02254577726125717,
-0.059732042253017426,
-0.359661340713501,
-0.5860607624053955,
0.4175277054309845,
0.2570016086101532,
-0.11340288817882538,
0.03243227303028107,
1.0264397859573364,
-0.4591677188873291,
-0.64565110206604,
0.062003035098314285,
0.6550078392028809,
0.29222753643989563,
-0.1980995386838913,
-0.3723224401473999,
-0.07204926013946533,
-0.3200918436050415,
0.01789066568017006,
0.2507968842983246,
0.544898509979248,
0.19677476584911346,
0.6861709952354431,
0.7316802740097046,
0.38642850518226624,
0.03292054310441017,
0.09256865829229355,
0.7742323875427246,
-0.7157207131385803,
-0.2044314593076706,
-1.058578610420227,
0.4379386901855469,
-0.04205656424164772,
-0.0926714763045311,
0.7277435064315796,
0.6191181540489197,
0.6470392346382141,
0.11777398735284805,
0.7009986042976379,
0.12074115872383118,
0.555924117565155,
-0.5948519706726074,
0.48943012952804565,
-0.44594186544418335,
0.49278968572616577,
-0.4718979597091675,
-1.189914345741272,
-0.466928094625473,
0.31146010756492615,
-0.3230537474155426,
-0.13933947682380676,
0.3843355178833008,
1.1551297903060913,
-0.10028119385242462,
-0.28233256936073303,
0.5552842617034912,
0.21517598628997803,
0.16602037847042084,
0.5993683338165283,
0.8025941252708435,
-0.7435268759727478,
0.5694116950035095,
-0.29498767852783203,
0.04274338483810425,
-0.06412916630506516,
-1.046491265296936,
-0.5979326367378235,
-0.3433488607406616,
-0.49680182337760925,
-0.037948135286569595,
-0.17432095110416412,
0.859398365020752,
0.6417463421821594,
-0.6334500312805176,
0.40755167603492737,
-0.174512580037117,
0.25755777955055237,
0.11438591778278351,
-0.2083006203174591,
0.16181807219982147,
-0.15914088487625122,
-1.2257235050201416,
1.0074907541275024,
0.4393751621246338,
0.35117560625076294,
-0.009183738380670547,
-0.17197108268737793,
-0.15510188043117523,
0.054040420800447464,
0.4153888523578644,
0.015315582044422626,
-0.8989413380622864,
-0.20681941509246826,
-0.02348100021481514,
-0.15847577154636383,
0.23720763623714447,
0.38244345784187317,
-0.8191986680030823,
0.43677714467048645,
0.5004187226295471,
1.058193325996399,
0.5487428307533264,
0.1063152402639389,
0.42265328764915466,
-0.7598426342010498,
0.011097237467765808,
0.26520979404449463,
0.4953272044658661,
0.545000433921814,
-0.4666498899459839,
0.46007272601127625,
0.06289613991975784,
-0.4083120822906494,
-0.923142671585083,
0.17751023173332214,
-1.0397820472717285,
-0.07639461010694504,
1.3362821340560913,
0.05789266154170036,
-0.14225174486637115,
-0.0973626896739006,
-0.18278177082538605,
0.21315687894821167,
-0.41945207118988037,
0.4525480568408966,
0.5252329111099243,
0.07992108911275864,
-0.34720030426979065,
-0.49934545159339905,
0.23810918629169464,
0.09747747331857681,
-1.0288517475128174,
-0.15926013886928558,
0.7159354090690613,
0.37967801094055176,
-0.08181839436292648,
0.6091821789741516,
-0.17518119513988495,
-0.0029451423324644566,
0.05009773001074791,
-0.11279544979333878,
-0.04049505665898323,
-0.2620910108089447,
-0.6421917080879211,
0.09003763645887375,
0.07908256351947784,
-0.055033210664987564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00021v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00021v2
|
SIMPLOT: Enhancing Chart Question Answering by Distilling Essentials
| 2024-02-22T14:04:22 | 2024-06-17T12:21:33 |
Wonjoong Kim, Sangwu Park, Yeonjun In, Seokwon Han, Chanyoung Park
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recently, interpreting complex charts with logical reasoning has emerged as
challenges due to the development of vision-language models. A prior
state-of-the-art (SOTA) model has presented an end-to-end method that leverages
the vision-language model to convert charts into table format utilizing Large
Language Model (LLM) for reasoning. However, unlike natural images, charts
contain a mix of essential and irrelevant information required for chart
reasoning, and we discover that this characteristic can lower the performance
of chart-to-table extraction. In this paper, we introduce SIMPLOT, a method
designed to extract only the elements necessary for chart reasoning. The
proposed method involves two steps: 1) training to mimic a simple plot that
contains only the essential information from a complex chart for table
extraction, followed by 2) performing reasoning based on the table. Our model
enables accurate chart reasoning without the need for additional annotations or
datasets, and its effectiveness is demonstrated through various experiments.
Furthermore, we propose a novel prompt mimicking how human interpret charts for
more accurate reasoning. Our source code is available at
https://github.com/sangwu99/Simplot.
|
[
-0.3160054087638855,
-0.9019833207130432,
0.9499619007110596,
-0.2093939632177353,
-0.8917732238769531,
0.04854772984981537,
0.09829115867614746,
-0.5385608673095703,
0.23868829011917114,
0.602914571762085,
-0.783058226108551,
-0.4281046986579895,
-0.44244712591171265,
0.03310535475611687,
-0.4240313172340393,
0.7810808420181274,
0.01358052622526884,
0.11413328349590302,
-0.29876387119293213,
0.013553312979638577,
-0.5660511255264282,
-0.184133842587471,
-0.4321020841598511,
-0.18320299685001373,
0.40973129868507385,
0.928473174571991,
0.6941752433776855,
0.7124460339546204,
0.49325665831565857,
0.2236321121454239,
-0.0022554260212928057,
0.36101606488227844,
-0.6037276387214661,
0.34178271889686584,
-0.06565402448177338,
-0.7200326919555664,
-0.43794816732406616,
-0.19245800375938416,
-0.1695125699043274,
0.760769784450531,
0.2346964329481125,
0.5269889235496521,
-0.05421812832355499,
0.8501218557357788,
-0.36491796374320984,
0.8441647291183472,
-0.33787772059440613,
-0.199558287858963,
-0.1803136169910431,
-0.4423527121543884,
-0.4812043309211731,
-0.5977843403816223,
0.17401129007339478,
-0.9914839267730713,
-0.15969105064868927,
0.19119144976139069,
0.976362407207489,
0.6145468354225159,
-0.5816650986671448,
-0.3542421758174896,
-0.730950117111206,
0.3899739980697632,
-0.39964959025382996,
0.020070137456059456,
0.23100706934928894,
1.007675290107727,
0.04589143767952919,
-1.2668821811676025,
-0.6784477233886719,
-0.12141701579093933,
-0.21605464816093445,
0.314606249332428,
-0.006393937394022942,
-0.09922303259372711,
0.4791218638420105,
-0.022625578567385674,
-0.44516846537590027,
-0.3813227415084839,
-0.5220956206321716,
0.011222670786082745,
0.7171186208724976,
0.23198260366916656,
0.7147845029830933,
-0.15923519432544708,
-0.3875453770160675,
-0.2225225567817688,
-0.6335745453834534,
0.12503091990947723,
-0.11326378583908081,
0.2485055774450302,
0.018252559006214142,
0.5077787637710571,
-0.2422366738319397,
0.6335414052009583,
-0.12535220384597778,
-0.24394840002059937,
0.2151653915643692,
0.13159504532814026,
-0.0540422685444355,
0.09524192661046982,
0.35249876976013184,
0.5859022736549377,
0.7378138899803162,
0.07693824172019958,
0.07071281224489212,
0.07766752690076828,
-0.05658213794231415,
-0.508340060710907,
-0.4557859003543854,
0.2150527834892273,
-0.06461326777935028,
-0.11260730773210526,
0.02625768817961216,
-0.7145939469337463,
-0.5892072916030884,
-0.6829050779342651,
0.34107455611228943,
-0.6232588887214661,
0.026988258585333824,
0.008577432483434677,
-0.5772066712379456,
0.17362534999847412,
0.925125241279602,
-0.34049686789512634,
0.027832070365548134,
0.6210567355155945,
0.4599429965019226,
0.14023081958293915,
-0.18561424314975739,
-0.5743129849433899,
0.41499388217926025,
-0.4299946129322052,
1.0147104263305664,
-0.48709508776664734,
0.12238448858261108,
-0.4538484811782837,
-0.20175494253635406,
0.20966836810112,
-0.3965664505958557,
0.7630787491798401,
-0.5528051257133484,
-0.11757737398147583,
-0.7488640546798706,
-0.7455326914787292,
-0.5723288059234619,
0.23962479829788208,
-0.881071925163269,
0.5747124552726746,
0.002284939168021083,
-0.6903206706047058,
0.3898427486419678,
-0.7065654993057251,
-0.35741108655929565,
0.36741045117378235,
-0.5783380270004272,
-0.15457291901111603,
-0.3498912453651428,
0.7690690159797668,
0.27050742506980896,
-0.5410910844802856,
0.10463374853134155,
-0.32852423191070557,
-0.43148553371429443,
0.28882351517677307,
-0.17761676013469696,
0.7797793745994568,
0.5861195921897888,
-0.459281325340271,
0.11961786448955536,
-0.5332936644554138,
0.15509659051895142,
0.5395990610122681,
0.15324823558330536,
-0.11892013996839523,
0.041660819202661514,
0.04002712294459343,
0.09233417361974716,
0.2344256043434143,
-0.3194971978664398,
0.21922717988491058,
-0.1083139032125473,
0.22357586026191711,
0.6717133522033691,
0.0007541021914221346,
0.1448904573917389,
-0.11704707145690918,
0.6119735240936279,
-0.0030299038626253605,
-0.019596479833126068,
-0.15408842265605927,
-0.5042037963867188,
-0.7792657613754272,
-0.623793363571167,
0.3310289680957794,
0.534212052822113,
-1.0077567100524902,
0.2306966781616211,
-0.737263023853302,
-0.63544100522995,
-0.1709154099225998,
0.1012323647737503,
-0.18304967880249023,
0.7467843890190125,
0.3835909962654114,
-0.00968149397522211,
-0.4970010221004486,
-0.7700933218002319,
-0.19506263732910156,
0.20209607481956482,
-0.08576039224863052,
0.04806165769696236,
0.08398614823818207,
0.24544131755828857,
1.2838813066482544,
-1.1128612756729126,
-0.11719455569982529,
-1.0954205989837646,
0.03722347319126129,
0.211821511387825,
0.02527984045445919,
0.85074782371521,
-0.8487316966056824,
-0.7750245928764343,
-0.1674974113702774,
-1.0815529823303223,
-0.37129470705986023,
-0.4478224217891693,
-0.328190416097641,
-0.587383508682251,
0.8172632455825806,
-0.6106794476509094,
0.7306351661682129,
-0.05535806342959404,
-0.53536456823349,
0.4316594898700714,
-0.03218868002295494,
0.004152547102421522,
-0.561190128326416,
0.2298981100320816,
-0.1719115525484085,
-0.45748987793922424,
-0.6543639302253723,
0.2986476421356201,
0.046606872230768204,
-0.3830704092979431,
-0.17782007157802582,
0.5612928867340088,
-0.4325297772884369,
0.11385709792375565,
-0.22832459211349487,
0.3335769474506378,
0.3440392315387726,
0.46399468183517456,
0.037959154695272446,
0.521946132183075,
0.6106210947036743,
-0.3973444700241089,
0.48940861225128174,
0.40875494480133057,
-0.3328148424625397,
0.3870199918746948,
-0.5018033385276794,
0.09382867068052292,
-0.5877249240875244,
0.3777276277542114,
-1.2356479167938232,
-0.24371111392974854,
0.3734949231147766,
-0.08048900961875916,
0.21258993446826935,
-0.11804188787937164,
-0.4444143772125244,
-0.289529412984848,
-0.14093773066997528,
0.09777000546455383,
0.5714150071144104,
-0.5577380657196045,
0.7173061966896057,
0.1768212616443634,
-0.3609248697757721,
-0.4794112741947174,
-0.6196284294128418,
0.02558133751153946,
-0.1941221058368683,
-0.6921471357345581,
-0.31287315487861633,
-0.05202829837799072,
-0.26895323395729065,
-0.19426600635051727,
-0.3888308107852936,
-0.2934725880622864,
0.14074164628982544,
0.18786320090293884,
0.39115822315216064,
-0.13762636482715607,
0.10518541187047958,
0.14072152972221375,
-0.6441695690155029,
0.06695026904344559,
0.3112233877182007,
0.46653634309768677,
0.007290074601769447,
-0.7482631206512451,
-0.7043383717536926,
0.24614740908145905,
0.8097204566001892,
-0.23250360786914825,
0.1524064689874649,
0.34036460518836975,
-0.015743955969810486,
-0.15757329761981964,
-0.21912381052970886,
-0.31807267665863037,
-0.5102539658546448,
0.30642765760421753,
-0.4606684744358063,
-0.16116328537464142,
0.24719712138175964,
-0.435504287481308,
0.16553807258605957,
0.2543908953666687,
0.24037717282772064,
-0.6594203114509583,
0.7337458729743958,
0.025340460240840912,
0.41199782490730286,
0.21694113314151764,
-0.40376514196395874,
0.4364057779312134,
-0.16215254366397858,
-0.11891932785511017,
-0.24605973064899445,
-0.6911666989326477,
0.20695218443870544,
-0.35587695240974426,
0.6109301447868347,
0.22883255779743195,
-0.23165170848369598,
-0.19644179940223694,
-0.26853451132774353,
0.7432624697685242,
0.4795495271682739,
0.43796950578689575,
0.44433504343032837,
-0.007382426876574755,
0.07273788005113602,
-0.22507593035697937,
-0.5804362893104553,
-0.632054328918457,
1.0365359783172607,
-0.009643973782658577,
0.8652759790420532,
0.017047837376594543,
0.4281102120876312,
-0.032779037952423096,
0.4096624255180359,
-0.562283992767334,
0.7471631765365601,
-0.012846537865698338,
-0.6706351041793823,
-0.44732600450515747,
-0.43288058042526245,
-0.8282577395439148,
0.3072759509086609,
-0.1520375907421112,
-0.5582143068313599,
-0.018166448920965195,
0.31613415479660034,
-0.2193729430437088,
0.26277023553848267,
-1.0342398881912231,
1.019715428352356,
-0.48161256313323975,
0.1011384055018425,
0.08483821898698807,
-0.7539421319961548,
0.26481908559799194,
0.07370540499687195,
0.47729501128196716,
-0.42393758893013,
0.1402639001607895,
0.23048819601535797,
-0.5813237428665161,
0.8712034225463867,
-0.22104662656784058,
0.3200853168964386,
0.6914170980453491,
0.3350902199745178,
0.5771552920341492,
-0.3099301755428314,
0.12239158898591995,
-0.17240266501903534,
-0.010868116281926632,
-0.5156823396682739,
-1.019500732421875,
0.16161809861660004,
-0.6366245746612549,
-0.5516520142555237,
-0.21601207554340363,
-0.6810904741287231,
-0.2454032450914383,
0.09011369198560715,
0.015158195048570633,
0.33276599645614624,
0.3201030492782593,
0.19083210825920105,
0.2227751463651657,
-0.08918933570384979,
0.025145677849650383,
-0.03753126040101051,
-0.47330570220947266,
-0.011594114825129509,
0.7720323801040649,
0.23993796110153198,
0.39772430062294006,
0.16141942143440247,
0.5406385064125061,
-0.48210880160331726,
-0.2915058135986328,
-0.5605586171150208,
0.08112508058547974,
-1.3526976108551025,
-0.02848365530371666,
-0.48091500997543335,
0.07790178805589676,
-0.15690727531909943,
-0.16204267740249634,
-0.09553679078817368,
-0.8569505214691162,
-0.22026386857032776,
-0.3642851710319519,
0.6793025732040405,
0.3362884223461151,
-0.06196543574333191,
0.25429093837738037,
-0.7413601279258728,
0.7687950134277344,
0.7598450779914856,
-0.2587626278400421,
0.10426866263151169,
-0.34193292260169983,
0.2045626938343048,
0.09167734533548355,
-0.3098412752151489,
-1.149535894393921,
0.19921855628490448,
0.1512860655784607,
0.5786435008049011,
0.5456295013427734,
0.44481104612350464,
1.0449591875076294,
-0.30684712529182434,
0.47299015522003174,
0.31131505966186523,
-0.9863585829734802,
0.5778037309646606,
-0.123768150806427,
0.26055335998535156,
0.5739029049873352,
0.43973416090011597,
-0.2596020996570587,
-0.3454188108444214,
-0.5784932971000671,
-0.972724974155426,
0.7470547556877136,
0.17430943250656128,
-0.18368105590343475,
0.3948317766189575,
0.3807516396045685,
0.15792474150657654,
0.07752180844545364,
-0.8541574478149414,
-0.4582785964012146,
-0.5067393779754639,
-0.6258623600006104,
0.0883122906088829,
-0.060290656983852386,
-0.2786543071269989,
-0.6719728112220764,
0.21171797811985016,
-0.23536373674869537,
-0.37991973757743835,
0.13879095017910004,
-0.2801506221294403,
-0.08198396861553192,
0.24287797510623932,
0.09763910621404648,
0.9284009337425232,
-0.18310414254665375,
0.3523978590965271,
0.2700578272342682,
-0.4363577961921692,
0.042787034064531326,
-0.18116480112075806,
-0.3734797239303589,
0.004154026508331299,
0.6525411009788513,
0.5460904836654663,
0.04673054441809654,
-1.2466899156570435,
0.6346641182899475,
0.04060284048318863,
0.0886545181274414,
-0.10509376972913742,
0.162912517786026,
0.6220349669456482,
0.27399882674217224,
0.5036450624465942,
-0.037211619317531586,
0.13253654539585114,
-0.5500003099441528,
0.30124810338020325,
-0.07976594567298889,
-0.2822761535644531,
0.05266965925693512,
0.7228350639343262,
0.15801386535167694,
0.07241109758615494,
0.45777079463005066,
-0.19574831426143646,
-0.5002927184104919,
0.7935990691184998,
0.20397375524044037,
0.4112663269042969,
0.1696428656578064,
0.19593682885169983,
0.3088488280773163,
0.4890724718570709,
0.36084091663360596,
0.7250924110412598,
0.19321849942207336,
-0.37096530199050903,
-0.5588882565498352,
-0.12483144551515579,
-0.43015289306640625,
-0.007621530909091234,
-0.5624876618385315,
0.38890254497528076,
-0.548551619052887,
0.14198024570941925,
0.180055633187294,
-0.36400675773620605,
-0.727886438369751,
0.20876358449459076,
0.3261740207672119,
0.8538598418235779,
-1.0168845653533936,
0.5474773645401001,
0.5134851336479187,
-0.686420738697052,
-1.1203666925430298,
-0.0008540137205272913,
0.06207526475191116,
-0.8027439117431641,
0.8776745796203613,
0.1574932336807251,
-0.0086216414347291,
-0.21779638528823853,
-0.9651373624801636,
-0.7731042504310608,
1.1035361289978027,
1.0411790609359741,
-0.5556750893592834,
0.27103593945503235,
0.44929829239845276,
0.4549840986728668,
-0.15779350697994232,
0.3829387426376343,
0.6380028128623962,
0.7486885190010071,
0.585673987865448,
-0.5256274938583374,
0.3153593838214874,
0.0317215658724308,
-0.5309391617774963,
-0.23054078221321106,
-0.23130439221858978,
0.9025062918663025,
-0.3723237216472626,
-0.40611132979393005,
-0.3842538893222809,
0.5349818468093872,
0.49389931559562683,
0.5815408825874329,
0.7462889552116394,
0.3811717927455902,
0.7582171559333801,
-0.14239437878131866,
1.046441912651062,
-0.11679686605930328,
0.31232786178588867,
1.4270964860916138,
-0.3094797134399414,
0.6434909105300903,
0.4892476797103882,
0.0673985630273819,
0.44993066787719727,
0.5118281841278076,
0.34062376618385315,
0.5646677017211914,
0.03285519778728485,
0.33565211296081543,
-0.784726083278656,
0.16255125403404236,
-0.3725709021091461,
0.4122881293296814,
0.28333017230033875,
-0.09929527342319489,
-0.7900490760803223,
-0.3346387445926666,
0.005716509651392698,
0.286224365234375,
-0.036864884197711945,
0.596759557723999,
0.16555297374725342,
-0.2121230810880661,
0.5389655232429504,
-0.6368282437324524,
-0.18509364128112793,
-0.6393621563911438,
-0.2941972017288208,
-0.14154724776744843,
-0.2383469045162201,
-0.17472103238105774,
-0.8052198886871338,
0.17057658731937408,
0.025809770449995995,
0.3577312231063843,
-0.0701666995882988,
0.37135207653045654,
-0.28717169165611267,
-0.530328094959259,
0.03339966759085655,
0.8859418630599976,
0.16584829986095428,
-0.1322040557861328,
-0.7826303839683533,
-0.1941262036561966,
0.29715895652770996,
-0.16051840782165527,
-0.14432823657989502,
0.901944637298584,
0.08590031415224075,
0.9997940063476562,
0.7800924181938171,
-0.12904265522956848,
-0.019381936639547348,
0.13982662558555603,
0.9400955438613892,
-0.7234814763069153,
-0.8423143625259399,
-0.6308140158653259,
0.6483290791511536,
-0.41110190749168396,
0.01752845197916031,
0.4044658839702606,
0.443265825510025,
0.19937938451766968,
-0.3637959063053131,
0.7445969581604004,
0.15265806019306183,
0.7390315532684326,
-0.5436156392097473,
0.6701781749725342,
-0.8352664113044739,
0.26469022035598755,
-0.5027835965156555,
-0.6734606623649597,
-0.2961499094963074,
0.5658727884292603,
-0.5396173596382141,
-0.33443349599838257,
0.9565988779067993,
0.44792279601097107,
-0.3404189646244049,
0.25684669613838196,
0.16766411066055298,
0.26424673199653625,
0.5272259712219238,
0.4151526093482971,
0.9953200817108154,
0.045460864901542664,
1.0459133386611938,
-0.3125324249267578,
-0.21426258981227875,
-0.33877912163734436,
-0.8163582682609558,
-0.5846307277679443,
-0.3143150806427002,
-0.3528735339641571,
0.022104404866695404,
-0.4184122383594513,
0.8481454849243164,
0.4308312237262726,
-0.6106616854667664,
-0.12145692855119705,
0.06404400616884232,
0.07191120833158493,
-0.47536566853523254,
-0.18621331453323364,
0.8609625697135925,
-0.2734796106815338,
-0.43937745690345764,
0.17606355249881744,
0.3288588225841522,
0.17064034938812256,
0.10029316693544388,
0.01864136941730976,
-0.0035229751374572515,
0.08405060321092606,
0.34125909209251404,
0.07910571247339249,
-0.6040570735931396,
-0.33706849813461304,
-0.276910662651062,
-0.0059462119825184345,
0.41542890667915344,
0.5973920226097107,
-0.42187678813934326,
0.7023933529853821,
0.5102809071540833,
0.3592495918273926,
0.8712992072105408,
0.24031323194503784,
0.3464207351207733,
-0.5585756897926331,
0.4755721688270569,
0.35903793573379517,
0.5463751554489136,
0.1789371222257614,
-0.2964290678501129,
0.7232000231742859,
0.15306217968463898,
0.061637233942747116,
-0.6603038907051086,
0.40557023882865906,
-1.261583924293518,
-0.7037419676780701,
0.7899203896522522,
-0.21998964250087738,
-0.37818288803100586,
-0.43238526582717896,
-0.8206974864006042,
0.2698456943035126,
-0.2195848971605301,
0.7797883152961731,
0.37827441096305847,
-0.40607237815856934,
-0.1372271180152893,
-0.4541516602039337,
0.4061468541622162,
0.2674466669559479,
-1.2031173706054688,
0.10085838288068771,
0.5391744375228882,
0.3534509837627411,
0.2947673201560974,
0.6300627589225769,
0.21114203333854675,
0.4773692190647125,
0.2766435742378235,
-0.009542455896735191,
-0.1966835856437683,
-0.1649216264486313,
0.27014660835266113,
0.4184366762638092,
0.2746675908565521,
-0.0802510678768158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14558v1
|
LLMs with Industrial Lens: Deciphering the Challenges and Prospects -- A Survey
| 2024-02-22T13:52:02 | 2024-02-22T13:52:02 |
Ashok Urlana, Charaka Vinayak Kumar, Ajeet Kumar Singh, Bala Mallikarjunarao Garlapati, Srinivasa Rao Chalamala, Rahul Mishra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have become the secret ingredient driving
numerous industrial applications, showcasing their remarkable versatility
across a diverse spectrum of tasks. From natural language processing and
sentiment analysis to content generation and personalized recommendations,
their unparalleled adaptability has facilitated widespread adoption across
industries. This transformative shift driven by LLMs underscores the need to
explore the underlying associated challenges and avenues for enhancement in
their utilization. In this paper, our objective is to unravel and evaluate the
obstacles and opportunities inherent in leveraging LLMs within an industrial
context. To this end, we conduct a survey involving a group of industry
practitioners, develop four research questions derived from the insights
gathered, and examine 68 industry papers to address these questions and derive
meaningful conclusions.
|
[
-0.4229849874973297,
-0.4420778453350067,
0.977794885635376,
0.07061982154846191,
-0.10602279007434845,
0.1268552541732788,
-0.18480698764324188,
-0.8640435934066772,
-0.3596591651439667,
0.6993753910064697,
-0.8644945621490479,
-0.5341022610664368,
-0.7068974375724792,
0.4096488058567047,
-0.5800814628601074,
0.6508992910385132,
-0.1839606761932373,
0.047657329589128494,
-0.2325158268213272,
-0.13307541608810425,
-0.32646626234054565,
-0.6484553813934326,
-0.6697675585746765,
-0.29367151856422424,
0.8342346549034119,
0.3224047124385834,
0.3407174348831177,
0.41103479266166687,
1.0074931383132935,
0.43197253346443176,
-0.11857854574918747,
0.2376243621110916,
-0.28279390931129456,
0.25309255719184875,
-0.1788213700056076,
-0.6546744704246521,
-0.4164804518222809,
0.05385848134756088,
0.6512392163276672,
1.0995886325836182,
-0.05481041222810745,
0.376475989818573,
0.21371059119701385,
0.602966845035553,
-0.4555010199546814,
0.11224737763404846,
-0.9008467793464661,
0.21944308280944824,
-0.4303688704967499,
-0.09479740262031555,
-0.3231610655784607,
-0.08770975470542908,
0.18599189817905426,
-0.30402085185050964,
-0.10818340629339218,
0.2053554207086563,
0.8247288465499878,
0.06925242394208908,
-0.4275378882884979,
-0.4233660101890564,
-1.1979012489318848,
0.9962519407272339,
-0.834478497505188,
0.3758375942707062,
-0.008070604875683784,
0.40809395909309387,
-0.21733441948890686,
-1.0979081392288208,
-0.23493395745754242,
0.035266295075416565,
0.3561042845249176,
0.21230846643447876,
-0.11889877170324326,
-0.04290720820426941,
0.13768671452999115,
0.5553836822509766,
-0.21147960424423218,
0.7256901860237122,
-0.5473418831825256,
0.20877130329608917,
0.6145980954170227,
0.6454140543937683,
0.3085651397705078,
0.1878892332315445,
-0.3196867108345032,
0.08222325146198273,
-0.6612342596054077,
-0.25048449635505676,
0.37911295890808105,
0.17438948154449463,
0.13549304008483887,
0.5584473609924316,
-0.1204674169421196,
0.647210955619812,
-0.5008390545845032,
-0.22538407146930695,
0.03582960367202759,
-0.10347127914428711,
-0.3483341336250305,
-0.15998314321041107,
0.7355180978775024,
0.48295485973358154,
0.10564131289720535,
-0.05650043487548828,
-0.2609230875968933,
-0.052344512194395065,
0.3701644837856293,
-0.5058616995811462,
0.45187652111053467,
0.3038597106933594,
-0.5293634533882141,
-0.21911120414733887,
-0.05134502798318863,
-0.7873156070709229,
-0.6120404601097107,
-0.38988351821899414,
0.01759965531527996,
0.026495426893234253,
-0.30676454305648804,
0.3000900149345398,
-0.31521937251091003,
0.6011772751808167,
0.46165695786476135,
-0.828976035118103,
-0.12018190324306488,
1.0847434997558594,
1.0623717308044434,
-0.13836073875427246,
-0.01996883749961853,
0.16605359315872192,
0.34500107169151306,
-0.5023213028907776,
0.8982947468757629,
-0.49380412697792053,
-0.7078948616981506,
0.41688811779022217,
0.03666896000504494,
-0.004926772788167,
-1.062137246131897,
0.39111098647117615,
-0.37674567103385925,
-0.06084751710295677,
-0.33024948835372925,
-0.4371499717235565,
-0.09431502223014832,
0.570380449295044,
-0.5564690232276917,
0.7821722626686096,
0.036370132118463516,
-0.502622663974762,
0.2879047095775604,
-0.49548909068107605,
-0.23005375266075134,
0.10939543694257736,
-0.28043195605278015,
-0.22177736461162567,
0.31018146872520447,
-0.13385309278964996,
0.6262235641479492,
-0.6671026349067688,
0.1333409696817398,
-0.6736509203910828,
0.017022335901856422,
0.6192436814308167,
-0.7348583936691284,
0.491604745388031,
0.5127399563789368,
-0.16987740993499756,
-0.025491420179605484,
-0.7984838485717773,
-0.3826836049556732,
-0.03324839100241661,
-0.2845911383628845,
-0.22443372011184692,
0.17499297857284546,
0.14131660759449005,
0.24679715931415558,
0.22778058052062988,
-0.5941022634506226,
0.1473776400089264,
-0.3545849919319153,
0.6806033849716187,
0.9494034647941589,
0.1657080352306366,
0.28141850233078003,
-0.30577677488327026,
0.7753973007202148,
0.14883573353290558,
0.40391606092453003,
-0.06191150099039078,
-0.3240021765232086,
-0.952339231967926,
-0.05364711955189705,
-0.06257119029760361,
0.2661980390548706,
-0.6761723160743713,
0.018923981115221977,
-0.121474489569664,
-0.635116696357727,
-0.6307386159896851,
0.4329471290111542,
-0.1873619556427002,
0.45056578516960144,
-0.13456201553344727,
-0.25856661796569824,
-0.5864784717559814,
-1.1565563678741455,
-0.33983704447746277,
-0.22984953224658966,
-0.2047635167837143,
0.21712058782577515,
0.16380217671394348,
-0.6795979738235474,
1.0884690284729004,
-0.8074176907539368,
-0.5676235556602478,
-0.569965124130249,
0.1309378445148468,
0.4798371195793152,
0.03758564591407776,
0.21768103539943695,
-0.7160817384719849,
-0.3956904411315918,
0.20610687136650085,
-1.029502034187317,
-0.285079687833786,
-0.03511671721935272,
0.05290162190794945,
0.2521989047527313,
0.9592748880386353,
-0.4987253248691559,
0.03658127412199974,
0.6143972873687744,
0.27032843232154846,
0.6135478019714355,
-0.03296907618641853,
-0.26483353972435,
-1.1594219207763672,
0.15485559403896332,
0.4429723620414734,
-0.0792255699634552,
-0.6570108532905579,
-0.08089160174131393,
-0.44644609093666077,
-0.17214664816856384,
-0.6138467788696289,
0.43767309188842773,
-0.6869135499000549,
-0.11622839421033859,
-0.3021968901157379,
0.24266120791435242,
0.010250977240502834,
-0.003999992273747921,
0.012907255440950394,
0.7260340452194214,
0.39475423097610474,
-0.7138508558273315,
0.3810492753982544,
0.09050578624010086,
-0.7838451266288757,
0.4638929069042206,
-0.5476385951042175,
-0.07194288820028305,
-0.24291639029979706,
0.12879319489002228,
-0.8194921016693115,
-0.03144412860274315,
0.13835327327251434,
-0.045078109949827194,
0.06747279316186905,
0.18814699351787567,
-0.6200327277183533,
-0.5395297408103943,
-0.18242551386356354,
0.0611974373459816,
0.4975346326828003,
-0.41394978761672974,
0.6618137955665588,
0.4233415424823761,
-0.4379480481147766,
-0.26467081904411316,
-0.8944311738014221,
0.3773188591003418,
-0.5266758799552917,
-0.5690838098526001,
0.030629906803369522,
-0.08717386424541473,
-0.7072978019714355,
-0.17319948971271515,
-0.14232441782951355,
0.04971841350197792,
0.16209068894386292,
0.23313795030117035,
0.3302636444568634,
-0.33417946100234985,
-0.123508021235466,
-0.4146902859210968,
-0.12441208958625793,
0.34389716386795044,
-0.20997129380702972,
0.4618856608867645,
0.007562690880149603,
-0.4177199900150299,
-0.2949414849281311,
0.33057042956352234,
0.6902960538864136,
-0.3364458978176117,
0.5157619118690491,
0.5835019946098328,
-0.15130452811717987,
-0.5516213774681091,
-0.749908983707428,
0.08306773006916046,
-0.703260064125061,
0.7118165493011475,
-0.025693247094750404,
-0.8900224566459656,
0.4119579792022705,
-0.6602095365524292,
0.16093511879444122,
0.23434601724147797,
0.6760317087173462,
-0.1903255432844162,
1.099478840827942,
0.6977985501289368,
-0.20734381675720215,
0.39324191212654114,
-0.43502017855644226,
0.7539901733398438,
-1.1308071613311768,
-0.4843955338001251,
-0.5327845811843872,
-0.35140249133110046,
-0.5552967190742493,
-0.19885925948619843,
0.6841674447059631,
-0.3236473798751831,
0.07680607587099075,
-0.14760993421077728,
-0.26831474900245667,
0.03668595477938652,
0.44598624110221863,
-0.15409933030605316,
0.542350172996521,
-0.08434396237134933,
0.2792614996433258,
0.06520604342222214,
-0.5571714639663696,
-0.8625054359436035,
0.6217435598373413,
0.704939067363739,
1.1053715944290161,
0.1546468883752823,
0.29446056485176086,
0.03959622234106064,
0.35384824872016907,
-1.0842304229736328,
0.8796646595001221,
-0.30795204639434814,
-0.7517719864845276,
-0.23277531564235687,
-0.18461823463439941,
-0.9719418287277222,
0.2735448181629181,
-0.03405245766043663,
-0.7608448266983032,
0.2906895875930786,
-0.12747012078762054,
-0.18214735388755798,
0.530972421169281,
-0.6288129687309265,
0.5750154256820679,
-0.5661484599113464,
-0.33964645862579346,
0.08960177004337311,
-0.29464423656463623,
0.3869028687477112,
-0.13513284921646118,
0.6056302785873413,
-0.3868291974067688,
-0.11638583987951279,
0.6190935373306274,
-0.17345832288265228,
1.0780079364776611,
0.21219825744628906,
-0.4866381883621216,
0.404572993516922,
-0.2901183068752289,
0.12285293638706207,
-0.15734712779521942,
-0.1428539901971817,
0.2965010106563568,
-0.060740675777196884,
0.20975163578987122,
-0.4892764091491699,
0.6516839861869812,
-0.5514702200889587,
-0.9387405514717102,
-0.67268306016922,
-0.5382238626480103,
-0.7095544934272766,
0.28813499212265015,
0.2779480218887329,
0.45568275451660156,
-0.12894099950790405,
0.44066864252090454,
0.429366797208786,
-0.39247041940689087,
0.7972617745399475,
0.49278783798217773,
-0.394941121339798,
-0.13009418547153473,
0.7826870679855347,
0.3624151945114136,
0.3117319941520691,
0.14241203665733337,
-0.06304410099983215,
-0.33041122555732727,
-0.8334116339683533,
-0.26706457138061523,
0.2115732878446579,
-0.7696170210838318,
-0.14377214014530182,
-0.5587100386619568,
-0.3607165217399597,
-0.32038646936416626,
-0.1988765299320221,
-0.2398941069841385,
0.15328504145145416,
-0.5779339075088501,
-0.06360313296318054,
0.13042932748794556,
1.1601349115371704,
0.327222615480423,
0.2958747446537018,
-0.9115030169487,
0.13862885534763336,
0.3144671320915222,
0.7671199440956116,
0.2133268117904663,
-0.0893905907869339,
-0.42081135511398315,
-0.06783919036388397,
-0.4406910836696625,
-0.6383980512619019,
0.5222771167755127,
-0.06887728720903397,
0.5652735829353333,
0.6859096884727478,
0.03227641433477402,
0.6576830744743347,
-0.8284830451011658,
0.9743601679801941,
0.12337562441825867,
-0.6231942176818848,
0.07367070019245148,
-0.518003523349762,
0.16791856288909912,
0.49465641379356384,
0.5781540274620056,
-0.7815561294555664,
-0.5046988129615784,
-0.23560847342014313,
-1.3451963663101196,
0.49026086926460266,
-0.23992955684661865,
0.43183672428131104,
0.1316080540418625,
0.36521607637405396,
-0.08572282642126083,
0.2295377254486084,
-0.6381389498710632,
-0.02124183438718319,
0.47876784205436707,
-0.3656804859638214,
-0.15041731297969818,
-0.28460416197776794,
0.07321483641862869,
0.01949491538107395,
0.5836611986160278,
0.19747234880924225,
0.13396547734737396,
0.11080072075128555,
0.04334716498851776,
0.09582910686731339,
0.4756104350090027,
0.34085148572921753,
0.8755661845207214,
-0.22943256795406342,
0.030492441728711128,
0.10405614972114563,
-0.321132630109787,
0.033747199922800064,
-0.29166901111602783,
0.02982679009437561,
0.036119479686021805,
0.31386417150497437,
0.801749050617218,
0.017146961763501167,
-0.9157639145851135,
0.26233971118927,
0.14988212287425995,
-0.3276697099208832,
-0.7261741757392883,
0.07319585978984833,
0.3627251088619232,
0.49152153730392456,
0.5368047952651978,
-0.5037843585014343,
0.3232099711894989,
-0.921114444732666,
-0.26043835282325745,
0.7151780724525452,
-0.5202368497848511,
-0.000726803089492023,
0.6381650567054749,
0.24791431427001953,
-0.31324368715286255,
0.30011117458343506,
0.31504276394844055,
-0.4138575792312622,
0.5166982412338257,
0.5807734727859497,
0.8924026489257812,
0.053485482931137085,
-0.025320619344711304,
-0.3063277304172516,
0.508901059627533,
-0.3394317924976349,
-0.1672183871269226,
0.6429796814918518,
-0.8304234743118286,
-0.10297462344169617,
-0.7902374863624573,
-0.9816163778305054,
0.41306379437446594,
-0.6098708510398865,
0.41145896911621094,
-0.58768230676651,
-0.37241798639297485,
0.05346702039241791,
-0.3414705693721771,
-0.5365179181098938,
0.3090386986732483,
0.30773982405662537,
0.8302661180496216,
-0.6695430874824524,
0.625023603439331,
0.7523497939109802,
-0.39904946088790894,
-0.6533191800117493,
-0.1743592917919159,
0.06179376691579819,
-0.7988479733467102,
0.6568935513496399,
0.20393751561641693,
-0.228622704744339,
-0.06541424244642258,
-0.48918551206588745,
-0.6695407032966614,
1.17522132396698,
0.1471819281578064,
-0.7915798425674438,
-0.21151795983314514,
0.668190598487854,
0.5516430735588074,
-0.395889014005661,
-0.00032579898834228516,
0.663169801235199,
0.5275585055351257,
-0.01929057575762272,
-0.5896406173706055,
-0.22863361239433289,
-0.2172401398420334,
0.49852582812309265,
0.037769921123981476,
-0.8702349066734314,
0.6685146689414978,
0.4517664909362793,
-0.12168603390455246,
-0.09365613013505936,
0.49566522240638733,
0.07335478812456131,
0.5823519229888916,
0.36138296127319336,
0.2652636766433716,
0.22177663445472717,
0.0569387711584568,
0.9488880038261414,
-0.19393590092658997,
0.15120476484298706,
0.7651005983352661,
-0.8103290796279907,
1.1099963188171387,
0.5640568137168884,
-0.34948310256004333,
0.5699920058250427,
0.5708420872688293,
-0.3665374517440796,
0.0392305962741375,
0.09357070922851562,
-0.565791130065918,
-0.011812490411102772,
-0.36706653237342834,
-0.43105369806289673,
0.6708716750144958,
0.6268104910850525,
-0.3244946300983429,
-0.1872204691171646,
0.14507652819156647,
-0.019824251532554626,
0.12140510231256485,
-0.4548468589782715,
0.9591094851493835,
0.6044883728027344,
-0.4177505671977997,
0.10798806697130203,
0.2751731276512146,
0.9660223126411438,
-0.8567850589752197,
0.06794672459363937,
-0.11130784451961517,
0.40722736716270447,
-0.14136554300785065,
-0.6868224740028381,
0.5353267788887024,
0.10368012636899948,
-0.03973520174622536,
-0.5413262844085693,
0.8373235464096069,
-0.22479498386383057,
-0.8262472748756409,
0.33865830302238464,
0.3045719861984253,
-0.09869801998138428,
-0.0143021484836936,
-0.3135001063346863,
0.44515302777290344,
-0.23417845368385315,
-0.16033639013767242,
0.501704752445221,
0.5238387584686279,
0.2652730345726013,
0.9991188049316406,
0.33176982402801514,
0.25328248739242554,
0.0925426185131073,
-0.12771378457546234,
0.7437534928321838,
-0.7640851736068726,
-0.14802859723567963,
-0.8796287178993225,
0.5275428295135498,
-0.08197005838155746,
-0.2454461008310318,
0.9717063307762146,
0.5589603185653687,
0.7165346145629883,
-0.19844014942646027,
1.0781607627868652,
0.33664900064468384,
0.4607442319393158,
-0.6472575068473816,
0.9081655740737915,
-0.7548250555992126,
0.5912865996360779,
-0.2795422077178955,
-0.960016667842865,
-0.3869200348854065,
0.3761002719402313,
-0.408483624458313,
0.08014333248138428,
0.626157820224762,
0.8583054542541504,
0.07588105648756027,
0.012057103216648102,
0.3859306573867798,
0.3035406172275543,
0.46634140610694885,
0.3187050521373749,
1.0287352800369263,
-0.020103080198168755,
0.5528649687767029,
0.04266424849629402,
0.018926702439785004,
-0.3312886953353882,
-1.0577998161315918,
-0.6630492806434631,
-0.5261774063110352,
-0.22304335236549377,
-0.1208333745598793,
-0.1801205426454544,
0.9161200523376465,
0.41813868284225464,
-0.5417795777320862,
-0.725415050983429,
0.055150214582681656,
-0.11038863658905029,
0.1998649686574936,
-0.21745754778385162,
-0.18046796321868896,
-0.5436090230941772,
-0.9422996640205383,
0.2101321518421173,
0.5761411190032959,
-0.01719219796359539,
-0.5963518619537354,
0.3952042758464813,
-0.16316701471805573,
0.2706245481967926,
1.0010780096054077,
0.1251273900270462,
-0.5771079659461975,
-0.14431223273277283,
0.04450252652168274,
0.07630908489227295,
-0.004630787298083305,
0.927929699420929,
-0.2558664381504059,
0.08329243957996368,
0.23967838287353516,
0.9637500643730164,
0.41606149077415466,
-0.30817410349845886,
0.8284265398979187,
-0.5745326280593872,
0.1579769104719162,
0.18631622195243835,
0.32995203137397766,
0.5111092329025269,
-0.20997166633605957,
0.4705531597137451,
0.17701831459999084,
-0.5579037070274353,
-1.0587208271026611,
0.44062742590904236,
-0.9315454363822937,
-0.506499171257019,
1.3520381450653076,
0.29009124636650085,
-0.1744251400232315,
-0.15797103941440582,
-0.15737299621105194,
0.10890036821365356,
0.1419859677553177,
0.5907481908798218,
0.7747550010681152,
-0.07235561311244965,
-0.27517321705818176,
-0.9080328941345215,
0.10095616430044174,
0.279994398355484,
-0.8133454322814941,
-0.006051184143871069,
0.589323103427887,
0.3471595048904419,
-0.0875653326511383,
0.5556867122650146,
-0.30568450689315796,
-0.4697592556476593,
-0.28729093074798584,
-0.02030968852341175,
0.06205332651734352,
-0.2606532573699951,
-0.5190967917442322,
0.27717724442481995,
0.8548957705497742,
0.009432985447347164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14547v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14547v3
|
OmniPred: Language Models as Universal Regressors
| 2024-02-22T13:36:53 | 2024-03-04T16:54:25 |
Xingyou Song, Oscar Li, Chansoo Lee, Bangding Yang, Daiyi Peng, Sagi Perel, Yutian Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB
|
Over the broad landscape of experimental design, regression has been a
powerful tool to accurately predict the outcome metrics of a system or model
given a set of parameters, but has been traditionally restricted to methods
which are only applicable to a specific task. In this paper, we propose
OmniPred, a framework for training language models as universal end-to-end
regressors over $(x,y)$ evaluation data from diverse real world experiments.
Using data sourced from Google Vizier, one of the largest blackbox optimization
databases in the world, our extensive experiments demonstrate that through only
textual representations of mathematical parameters and values, language models
are capable of very precise numerical regression, and if given the opportunity
to train over multiple tasks, can significantly outperform traditional
regression models.
|
[
-0.1184430718421936,
-0.755739152431488,
0.3276486098766327,
0.43076372146606445,
0.23157630860805511,
-0.1152586042881012,
-0.4566737413406372,
-0.34599441289901733,
-0.03140861541032791,
0.5193841457366943,
-0.34457358717918396,
-0.28719741106033325,
-0.2320159375667572,
0.07135063409805298,
-0.3847512900829315,
1.093098521232605,
-0.14785249531269073,
0.40471917390823364,
0.02497829683125019,
-0.1122974380850792,
-0.3467232286930084,
-0.7907809615135193,
-0.22443699836730957,
0.00997161865234375,
0.42515239119529724,
0.2569837272167206,
0.4554392993450165,
0.43438521027565,
0.3525155782699585,
0.29813557863235474,
0.36833879351615906,
-0.13238762319087982,
-0.5347040295600891,
0.3872790038585663,
-0.060123980045318604,
-0.34764087200164795,
0.016083326190710068,
0.020478347316384315,
0.47919902205467224,
0.8749958276748657,
-0.29439711570739746,
0.40629181265830994,
0.3139406442642212,
0.2137693166732788,
-0.7810520529747009,
0.25566378235816956,
-0.2076459527015686,
-0.003534347051754594,
0.32109206914901733,
0.005913688335567713,
-0.45515862107276917,
-0.8492138981819153,
0.22468852996826172,
-0.5157830119132996,
0.28381645679473877,
-0.06957314908504486,
0.7582523226737976,
0.30618542432785034,
-0.15515011548995972,
0.027527280151844025,
-1.2546766996383667,
0.759579598903656,
-0.492364764213562,
0.6949042677879333,
-0.1547383815050125,
0.528719961643219,
-0.3358827531337738,
-0.5094472169876099,
-0.18125686049461365,
-0.15105769038200378,
0.22642400860786438,
0.18766798079013824,
-0.20595969259738922,
-0.002214040607213974,
0.03282928466796875,
0.041446488350629807,
-0.5260184407234192,
-0.03261079266667366,
-0.3835771679878235,
-0.043996360152959824,
0.39871159195899963,
-0.06706655770540237,
0.3273707926273346,
-0.02767951227724552,
-0.18905925750732422,
-0.11934898048639297,
-0.35372433066368103,
0.1836552917957306,
0.13612571358680725,
0.7202882170677185,
0.2512766122817993,
0.6924123167991638,
-0.13628576695919037,
0.6944031119346619,
-0.5680162310600281,
-0.07720956951379776,
-0.030188415199518204,
-0.1448618769645691,
-0.5774304866790771,
-0.157257542014122,
0.962533712387085,
0.025041265413165092,
0.6540449857711792,
-0.43891385197639465,
-0.06126414239406586,
0.2150758057832718,
0.23656032979488373,
-0.7707250118255615,
-0.052704814821481705,
-0.07231684029102325,
-0.24529170989990234,
-0.45024362206459045,
0.26392921805381775,
-0.9695751070976257,
-0.023709705099463463,
-0.26859599351882935,
0.5134368538856506,
-0.14767171442508698,
-0.19111749529838562,
0.5059879422187805,
-0.13639521598815918,
0.013141294941306114,
-0.017775189131498337,
-0.5523699522018433,
0.6864142417907715,
0.4815645217895508,
0.7711538672447205,
0.18263119459152222,
-0.4388207197189331,
-0.6028909683227539,
-0.08212336152791977,
-0.466869592666626,
0.6228099465370178,
-0.6586695313453674,
-0.2855047583580017,
0.26009371876716614,
-0.18994562327861786,
-0.220084547996521,
-0.13805383443832397,
0.6201962232589722,
-0.30622535943984985,
0.4980224370956421,
0.11489412933588028,
-0.3990691900253296,
-0.11604534089565277,
-0.1172272339463234,
-0.5791904330253601,
0.9029695987701416,
0.42360690236091614,
-0.3085079491138458,
0.49890199303627014,
-0.8750017881393433,
-0.06918899714946747,
-0.11436939984560013,
-0.13021732866764069,
-0.36273661255836487,
0.4550398588180542,
0.018907815217971802,
0.4605562090873718,
-0.8352535963058472,
0.6170568466186523,
-0.4931817650794983,
-0.0058922176249325275,
0.1819673329591751,
-0.39946049451828003,
0.6456108093261719,
0.04212203621864319,
-0.3559657633304596,
0.010830719023942947,
-0.8541200160980225,
0.02640041522681713,
0.24369390308856964,
-0.332174688577652,
-0.7219396233558655,
0.06718547642230988,
0.49073857069015503,
0.1733112931251526,
-0.1501939743757248,
-1.0177525281906128,
0.23570269346237183,
-0.058427173644304276,
0.33035728335380554,
0.7105634808540344,
-0.3122318685054779,
0.30459147691726685,
-0.017047008499503136,
0.9201858043670654,
-0.6587334275245667,
0.2649918794631958,
-0.07067051529884338,
-0.6412289142608643,
-0.5030263662338257,
-0.4128219485282898,
0.5822367072105408,
0.45856189727783203,
0.15413717925548553,
0.24354983866214752,
-0.23339848220348358,
-0.34299859404563904,
-0.6524226665496826,
0.30717432498931885,
0.6946976184844971,
0.36077484488487244,
0.1846635937690735,
0.2066906988620758,
-0.9513614177703857,
-0.920174241065979,
-0.40672290325164795,
-0.0516585037112236,
-0.08195576816797256,
0.21106083691120148,
0.493478387594223,
-0.2985038161277771,
1.0624579191207886,
-0.615531325340271,
-0.45546954870224,
-0.2277863323688507,
0.21022066473960876,
0.023945612832903862,
0.3280259668827057,
0.5929239988327026,
-0.8373766541481018,
-0.4895722270011902,
0.18604573607444763,
-0.8100122809410095,
-0.2511839270591736,
-0.027068695053458214,
-0.1686883568763733,
0.12264732271432877,
0.7105046510696411,
-0.22056980431079865,
0.4824942350387573,
0.6483727693557739,
-0.3024340271949768,
0.6532549262046814,
-0.23051641881465912,
-0.23911675810813904,
-0.9325322508811951,
0.0636633038520813,
0.4375661313533783,
-0.32546305656433105,
-0.612828254699707,
0.15750589966773987,
0.07226086407899857,
-0.21719065308570862,
-0.06828141212463379,
0.5856372117996216,
-0.36717525124549866,
0.0939306989312172,
0.09426122158765793,
-0.10004225373268127,
-0.11928053200244904,
0.28488394618034363,
0.15391559898853302,
0.6915917992591858,
0.6488885879516602,
-0.5006830096244812,
0.2207038402557373,
0.28028225898742676,
-0.1446242481470108,
0.3166762590408325,
-0.9719493389129639,
-0.41432851552963257,
-0.2994595170021057,
-0.11631827056407928,
-1.3095085620880127,
-0.41282564401626587,
-0.11220087856054306,
-0.6540948748588562,
0.1325283795595169,
-0.16190043091773987,
-0.5403211116790771,
-0.6501350998878479,
-0.14100700616836548,
0.09307163208723068,
0.6516915559768677,
-0.640127420425415,
0.6883698105812073,
0.2188173234462738,
-0.04152680188417435,
-0.5150665044784546,
-0.6276582479476929,
-0.17596328258514404,
-0.09576218575239182,
-0.3204096555709839,
-0.07392995059490204,
-0.2695786654949188,
-0.28365686535835266,
-0.0012221434153616428,
-0.0033048803452402353,
-0.28437745571136475,
0.09216196835041046,
0.44070738554000854,
0.4716617465019226,
-0.5766875743865967,
0.12241798639297485,
-0.37160518765449524,
-0.32368776202201843,
0.18300391733646393,
-0.5229076147079468,
0.46475455164909363,
-0.09776484966278076,
-0.3209138810634613,
0.0807633027434349,
0.3656875491142273,
0.41330817341804504,
-0.17234520614147186,
0.6424200534820557,
0.4010497033596039,
-0.40117278695106506,
-0.19059070944786072,
-0.6743104457855225,
0.15467569231987,
-0.3932366669178009,
0.45426225662231445,
-0.5166117548942566,
-0.8605493903160095,
0.43973129987716675,
-0.04602298140525818,
0.2989823818206787,
0.21146976947784424,
0.3025914430618286,
0.13230827450752258,
1.7331327199935913,
1.4306286573410034,
-0.25212278962135315,
0.2756698429584503,
-0.3002987205982208,
0.04983203858137131,
-0.7937071323394775,
-0.2834358811378479,
-0.8566350936889648,
-0.05561495199799538,
-0.4444569945335388,
-0.12756772339344025,
0.15830671787261963,
0.2867484390735626,
-0.5453551411628723,
0.2922213673591614,
-0.6034092307090759,
0.5635538697242737,
0.5258814096450806,
-0.2565847635269165,
0.05712878331542015,
-0.03190595656633377,
-0.2603732943534851,
-0.10846366733312607,
-0.6171533465385437,
-0.6143313646316528,
1.2812808752059937,
0.16500283777713776,
1.1057778596878052,
0.123247891664505,
0.5554563999176025,
-0.013271688483655453,
0.7299224734306335,
-0.6559133529663086,
0.11618311703205109,
-0.04137377440929413,
-0.651251494884491,
-0.24982869625091553,
-0.4961778521537781,
-0.7774748206138611,
0.44221359491348267,
0.1612979769706726,
-1.0268681049346924,
0.5205320119857788,
-0.07372407615184784,
-0.41374465823173523,
0.3591935634613037,
-0.7429017424583435,
1.0883594751358032,
-0.3739078938961029,
-0.16608861088752747,
0.5314443707466125,
-0.3311785161495209,
0.43807703256607056,
-0.3508254587650299,
0.43934935331344604,
0.11582627892494202,
-0.2606167793273926,
0.6628280282020569,
-0.361850768327713,
0.825374960899353,
-0.09123174846172333,
0.1228993758559227,
-0.16932950913906097,
0.28073650598526,
0.12470727413892746,
0.006293811835348606,
-0.056667301803827286,
-0.3852584660053253,
-0.169691801071167,
-0.43776601552963257,
-0.5760550498962402,
0.7298627495765686,
-0.9638078212738037,
-0.28154098987579346,
-0.33269181847572327,
-0.43142789602279663,
-0.304758757352829,
0.24443364143371582,
0.1949254721403122,
0.6414775252342224,
-0.6214272379875183,
0.2660764455795288,
0.4580957591533661,
-0.0784578025341034,
0.4534788131713867,
0.5773831605911255,
-0.581520676612854,
-0.4263976216316223,
0.8696897625923157,
-0.09921713918447495,
0.3883267641067505,
0.37129276990890503,
0.4818825423717499,
-0.2858467400074005,
0.01178675051778555,
-0.37780797481536865,
0.28076082468032837,
-0.5086721777915955,
-0.3134493827819824,
-0.7658558487892151,
-0.11978539824485779,
-0.44677525758743286,
-0.3890002369880676,
-0.3848520517349243,
-0.14588990807533264,
-0.29424849152565,
-0.24203257262706757,
0.29428449273109436,
0.8699588179588318,
-0.384431391954422,
0.2611968219280243,
-0.5337494611740112,
0.4202001094818115,
0.41170549392700195,
0.5727142691612244,
-0.263746976852417,
-0.39498159289360046,
-0.08356877416372299,
0.2160220444202423,
0.022077396512031555,
-0.6930143237113953,
0.7263435125350952,
0.5208089351654053,
0.8055131435394287,
0.4007977843284607,
0.0537726990878582,
0.7896236181259155,
-0.5497791171073914,
0.3316662609577179,
0.2562924921512604,
-0.8445318341255188,
0.44778990745544434,
-0.0804494246840477,
-0.012535334564745426,
0.3367946147918701,
0.8236159682273865,
-0.41821935772895813,
-0.4280507564544678,
-0.5717034339904785,
-0.6172245144844055,
0.4926535487174988,
0.03826036676764488,
0.22669614851474762,
0.11221032589673996,
0.2889059782028198,
0.198369100689888,
0.1959475725889206,
-0.871258556842804,
-0.07574757188558578,
-0.36507126688957214,
-0.23786139488220215,
-0.36567479372024536,
-0.3323945999145508,
0.045876648277044296,
-0.1548580527305603,
0.38140642642974854,
-0.2623067796230316,
0.1368812918663025,
0.2914157807826996,
-0.3181273341178894,
-0.3434312045574188,
0.1990414410829544,
0.48003333806991577,
0.704379141330719,
-0.6117765307426453,
-0.23766416311264038,
-0.21797320246696472,
-0.3062817454338074,
0.3134187161922455,
0.212234765291214,
-0.22019131481647491,
0.21340931951999664,
0.1061784029006958,
0.5764995217323303,
0.37044331431388855,
-0.8379992842674255,
0.5484980344772339,
-0.31677180528640747,
-0.34322428703308105,
-0.44448530673980713,
-0.10934460163116455,
-0.2107524573802948,
0.2012326419353485,
0.4817339777946472,
0.26539742946624756,
0.2565435767173767,
-0.5883914828300476,
0.2934025228023529,
0.3750664293766022,
-1.073499321937561,
-0.4967154860496521,
1.0561535358428955,
-0.00022285027080215514,
-0.43627122044563293,
0.22575177252292633,
0.09033873677253723,
-0.6515017151832581,
0.4663492739200592,
0.9392926692962646,
1.002455234527588,
-0.5365886688232422,
0.38434895873069763,
0.21743859350681305,
0.40335044264793396,
-0.27433106303215027,
0.5350373387336731,
0.3227429687976837,
-0.6697596907615662,
-0.6616470813751221,
-0.7654526829719543,
-0.23949092626571655,
0.0893649309873581,
-0.951761782169342,
0.2195766568183899,
-0.20287592709064484,
-0.096964530646801,
0.296601802110672,
-0.4082225263118744,
-0.7043207883834839,
0.2517598569393158,
0.031521644443273544,
0.9111762046813965,
-1.0309056043624878,
0.4368517994880676,
0.8716186285018921,
-0.8325985074043274,
-0.43029552698135376,
-0.3372211754322052,
-0.020680660381913185,
-0.6214632391929626,
0.8496763706207275,
0.005487449001520872,
-0.060045622289180756,
0.0025111220311373472,
-0.6688808798789978,
-0.8128747940063477,
0.4380788505077362,
0.5422255992889404,
-0.4949102997779846,
-0.15768195688724518,
0.23259377479553223,
0.6820003390312195,
-0.6588320136070251,
0.45249220728874207,
0.5231297016143799,
0.3903597593307495,
-0.3271709382534027,
-0.8897539377212524,
-0.2334761619567871,
-0.3961920440196991,
0.11948993802070618,
0.34969550371170044,
-0.33331888914108276,
0.9834359288215637,
-0.4423530101776123,
0.07218898832798004,
0.26319074630737305,
0.5004324316978455,
0.08798904716968536,
-0.27294397354125977,
0.30350053310394287,
0.3225069046020508,
0.3813920021057129,
-0.08106976002454758,
1.4150675535202026,
-0.15260617434978485,
0.37770989537239075,
0.8977842926979065,
-0.10991266369819641,
0.8374073505401611,
0.15056683123111725,
-0.034737590700387955,
0.2598651051521301,
0.35112398862838745,
0.041887830942869186,
0.471081018447876,
0.3568907082080841,
0.2053024172782898,
-0.36691078543663025,
-0.17922645807266235,
-0.12766143679618835,
0.16008460521697998,
0.17049401998519897,
-0.2084677666425705,
-0.306631863117218,
0.512313187122345,
0.0202042069286108,
0.2817286550998688,
0.01887582056224346,
0.7244261503219604,
-0.11309968680143356,
-0.16266752779483795,
0.6795250773429871,
-0.24889428913593292,
0.7767292261123657,
-0.6276232600212097,
-0.15572316944599152,
-0.0907471552491188,
0.49231719970703125,
0.025251762941479683,
-0.4688306152820587,
0.050441447645425797,
-0.0011111714411526918,
-0.18440788984298706,
-0.1580715924501419,
0.5006996989250183,
-0.4140462577342987,
-0.8824225664138794,
0.7114837169647217,
0.5070037245750427,
-0.05776559188961983,
-0.3712477385997772,
-0.5791469812393188,
-0.09817884117364883,
0.12311125546693802,
-0.30127865076065063,
0.14924779534339905,
0.49917519092559814,
-0.10675390064716339,
0.991789698600769,
0.7866729497909546,
0.4375821053981781,
0.28125935792922974,
0.24083533883094788,
0.7626975178718567,
-0.8162378072738647,
-0.20054079592227936,
-0.7570436596870422,
0.5225369930267334,
0.02358747273683548,
-0.5726519823074341,
0.8118516206741333,
0.8476380705833435,
0.8418318629264832,
-0.14943738281726837,
1.1494522094726562,
0.06882420927286148,
0.907432496547699,
0.07251280546188354,
0.34197941422462463,
-0.674885630607605,
-0.1806584596633911,
-0.5263403058052063,
-1.1801068782806396,
-0.6012938618659973,
0.6053172945976257,
0.07343712449073792,
-0.10631778836250305,
0.3923807740211487,
0.4079352021217346,
-0.31758832931518555,
0.07699999958276749,
0.3988777697086334,
0.222068652510643,
0.579662024974823,
0.06532760709524155,
0.834665060043335,
-0.524005651473999,
0.8643130660057068,
-0.3986912667751312,
-0.2644630968570709,
-0.4300370216369629,
-0.5507382154464722,
-0.8531283736228943,
-0.6703375577926636,
-0.14129169285297394,
-0.09657978266477585,
0.0768515020608902,
0.8964420557022095,
0.7649425268173218,
-0.8779895901679993,
-0.7112604379653931,
-0.17938895523548126,
-0.16246773302555084,
-0.172542542219162,
-0.24138236045837402,
0.16926047205924988,
-0.6290038228034973,
-0.6747986078262329,
0.1327008306980133,
0.1607714593410492,
0.0667494535446167,
-0.7170265316963196,
0.029992777854204178,
0.008556456305086613,
0.14183591306209564,
0.6384395360946655,
0.5401232242584229,
-0.7064998149871826,
-0.19892491400241852,
0.3659919500350952,
-0.06613417714834213,
-0.10201622545719147,
0.8614636063575745,
-0.8872535824775696,
0.5090226531028748,
0.28301554918289185,
0.564247727394104,
0.18080930411815643,
0.05817770957946777,
1.2295113801956177,
-0.46800732612609863,
0.09710285067558289,
0.1474299132823944,
0.5366300344467163,
0.2516520023345947,
0.009390001185238361,
0.8115602135658264,
-0.1277155727148056,
-0.5422319173812866,
-1.2350200414657593,
-0.17413674294948578,
-0.43507930636405945,
-0.240855410695076,
1.1251224279403687,
-0.040368061512708664,
-0.526469886302948,
-0.2966946065425873,
-0.27077993750572205,
-0.03162912279367447,
-0.5540271997451782,
0.5048855543136597,
0.2748234272003174,
0.1187044233083725,
-0.20180493593215942,
-1.0992852449417114,
0.4558829963207245,
0.12395408004522324,
-0.558274507522583,
0.20604614913463593,
0.4609299898147583,
0.3241381347179413,
0.3644412159919739,
0.22317670285701752,
0.08511799573898315,
0.19583368301391602,
-0.18045300245285034,
0.55589359998703,
0.0069152736105024815,
-0.5367642045021057,
-0.21465939283370972,
-0.014119834639132023,
0.0015843583969399333,
-0.20942199230194092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14545v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14545v2
|
Less is More: Mitigating Multimodal Hallucination from an EOS Decision Perspective
| 2024-02-22T13:33:13 | 2024-05-29T05:55:09 |
Zihao Yue, Liang Zhang, Qin Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) often suffer from multimodal hallucinations,
wherein they may create content that is not present in the visual inputs. In
this paper, we explore a new angle of this issue: overly detailed training data
hinders the model's ability to timely terminate generation, leading to
continued outputs beyond visual perception limits. By investigating how the
model decides to terminate generation with EOS, the special end-of-sentence
token, we find that the model assesses the completeness of the entire sequence
by comparing the generated text with the image. This observation suggests that
the model possesses an inherent potential of making proper EOS decisions based
on its visual perception to avoid overly lengthy outputs. To take advantage of
such potential, we explore two methods to mitigate multimodal hallucinations: a
training objective that enables the model to reduce hallucinations by learning
from regular instruction data, and a data filtering strategy to prevent harmful
training data from exacerbating model hallucinations. Both methods
significantly improve the hallucination performance of LMMs, without requiring
any additional data or knowledge.
|
[
-0.6829485893249512,
-0.7893753051757812,
0.7615013122558594,
-0.09075935184955597,
-0.4198499023914337,
-0.14135684072971344,
-0.16607993841171265,
-0.7337772846221924,
0.5658658146858215,
0.5949617028236389,
-0.8011637330055237,
-0.11955299973487854,
-0.645091712474823,
0.14390073716640472,
-0.19248268008232117,
0.990146279335022,
0.16492201387882233,
0.09858373552560806,
-0.39568912982940674,
0.006838131695985794,
-0.3667990565299988,
-0.5544503331184387,
-0.8006464242935181,
-0.3417564034461975,
0.5514774918556213,
0.23874911665916443,
0.6742058992385864,
0.47723302245140076,
0.39075133204460144,
0.20553314685821533,
-0.14519968628883362,
0.43432626128196716,
-0.8031290173530579,
0.2059861123561859,
0.48309534788131714,
-0.3440047800540924,
-0.3130415976047516,
-0.3052816689014435,
0.190586656332016,
0.7844042778015137,
-0.22461602091789246,
-0.00019797081768047065,
-0.01070804987102747,
0.7794090509414673,
-0.8324384093284607,
-0.13287314772605896,
-0.41925325989723206,
0.7352103590965271,
0.35163384675979614,
-0.4416638910770416,
-0.6710898280143738,
0.06966443359851837,
0.14974987506866455,
-0.8386433124542236,
0.13043569028377533,
0.1898166537284851,
0.6648128628730774,
0.5365440845489502,
-0.39995551109313965,
-0.2181229144334793,
-0.8657364845275879,
0.7936587333679199,
-0.30519670248031616,
0.7080249786376953,
0.5186658501625061,
0.25224244594573975,
-0.04178552329540253,
-0.46532174944877625,
-0.7681053280830383,
-0.5694317817687988,
-0.0989459902048111,
0.19138029217720032,
-0.012896857224404812,
0.46112075448036194,
0.7233207821846008,
-0.18304391205310822,
-0.641773521900177,
-0.10370773077011108,
-0.6690272092819214,
-0.39595285058021545,
0.12462567538022995,
0.08992916345596313,
0.1089056059718132,
-0.39611223340034485,
-0.5358362793922424,
-0.213089719414711,
-0.6457377076148987,
-0.12185493856668472,
0.4151614308357239,
-0.0426550917327404,
0.1485334187746048,
0.7076003551483154,
-0.24176864326000214,
0.614762008190155,
-0.1439879834651947,
-0.18192429840564728,
0.2307310253381729,
-0.17177262902259827,
-0.4211852252483368,
0.07436465471982956,
0.363792359828949,
0.7527852058410645,
0.22448298335075378,
-0.15842846035957336,
-0.2662517726421356,
0.2772604525089264,
0.40117305517196655,
-0.82485032081604,
-0.14074966311454773,
0.2501559257507324,
-0.7039231061935425,
-0.11620752513408661,
-0.01965852454304695,
-0.8891518712043762,
-0.5707619786262512,
-0.660603404045105,
0.4388328492641449,
-0.5106008648872375,
0.0546792671084404,
0.0804053321480751,
-0.4898405075073242,
-0.06469208002090454,
0.4311724305152893,
-0.7244769334793091,
0.2538767158985138,
0.34433096647262573,
1.1026276350021362,
-0.04637786000967026,
-0.25341829657554626,
-0.6274802088737488,
0.4517786502838135,
-0.4240586757659912,
0.5409031510353088,
-0.5911004543304443,
-0.14788293838500977,
-0.27340584993362427,
-0.08119352161884308,
0.0767330676317215,
-0.39866894483566284,
0.2889561951160431,
-0.2371658980846405,
0.10939327627420425,
-0.18490299582481384,
-0.2845698297023773,
-0.25614890456199646,
0.2933958172798157,
-0.7776814699172974,
0.6333755254745483,
-0.20475155115127563,
-0.3643404543399811,
0.6954106092453003,
-0.4652923345565796,
-0.45528075098991394,
-0.29258862137794495,
-0.4262338876724243,
-0.34829220175743103,
0.4778389036655426,
0.3016560673713684,
0.5165249705314636,
-0.0681469663977623,
0.19033896923065186,
-0.3813653290271759,
-0.4508323073387146,
0.027295636013150215,
-0.477023720741272,
0.11136052757501602,
0.5556491017341614,
-0.292868971824646,
0.1449805647134781,
-0.928844153881073,
-0.26400986313819885,
0.0020831283181905746,
0.01733531430363655,
-0.40180233120918274,
-0.059130601584911346,
0.21603381633758545,
0.34841546416282654,
-0.147618368268013,
-0.47569751739501953,
-0.06365470588207245,
-0.08786159008741379,
0.3513440787792206,
0.8914236426353455,
-0.20304441452026367,
0.5226420760154724,
-0.6702668070793152,
0.5230351686477661,
0.054638732224702835,
0.6571682691574097,
-0.5145271420478821,
-0.44636276364326477,
-1.0143041610717773,
-0.5624602437019348,
-0.2956238389015198,
0.20681355893611908,
-0.9655231237411499,
0.03482040390372276,
-0.17089366912841797,
-0.2511123716831207,
-0.28632164001464844,
0.12365195900201797,
0.43550312519073486,
0.31351250410079956,
0.381818026304245,
-0.3771684169769287,
-0.8368296027183533,
-0.8336611390113831,
0.1605452299118042,
0.20697543025016785,
0.019301868975162506,
0.22558018565177917,
0.665134072303772,
-0.32049843668937683,
0.6043075919151306,
-0.5498724579811096,
-0.5260123014450073,
-0.2169194519519806,
0.08642585575580597,
-0.16651998460292816,
0.2817123830318451,
0.4532180428504944,
-0.8303927779197693,
-0.026917580515146255,
-0.11666612327098846,
-0.9039136171340942,
0.2927370071411133,
-0.8256368041038513,
0.1460321992635727,
0.27373814582824707,
0.5119162797927856,
-0.8687266707420349,
0.4400613307952881,
0.24179701507091522,
-0.15293782949447632,
0.10613321512937546,
-0.3968542516231537,
0.22835604846477509,
-0.6854191422462463,
-0.22042660415172577,
-0.2738628685474396,
-0.27512821555137634,
-0.5934453010559082,
0.08369747549295425,
-0.25800949335098267,
-0.2790863811969757,
-0.3583364188671112,
0.3123912215232849,
-0.6164638996124268,
-0.2091762274503708,
-0.1926637589931488,
0.10326498001813889,
0.31301113963127136,
0.6365824937820435,
0.19121040403842926,
0.2247982621192932,
0.5086175799369812,
-0.7282311916351318,
0.3979370594024658,
0.11416549980640411,
-0.257916659116745,
0.34207046031951904,
-0.43916723132133484,
0.2647552192211151,
-0.5468538403511047,
0.24387751519680023,
-1.0334311723709106,
-0.3571702539920807,
0.28284361958503723,
-0.4358769953250885,
0.23706017434597015,
0.19341892004013062,
-0.34185710549354553,
-0.16139231622219086,
-0.9687756299972534,
0.24336989223957062,
0.3179561197757721,
-0.5775370597839355,
0.6682657599449158,
0.1065123975276947,
-0.026574112474918365,
-0.5121667385101318,
-1.0052285194396973,
0.24772952497005463,
-0.16243751347064972,
-0.5273905396461487,
0.2996560037136078,
-0.212246373295784,
-0.001605733297765255,
-0.1781126856803894,
0.010509411804378033,
0.05977284535765648,
0.07247515767812729,
0.34175997972488403,
0.20735542476177216,
0.12379525601863861,
0.2884913384914398,
0.42276081442832947,
-0.07363243401050568,
-0.1397971212863922,
0.04400898516178131,
0.8378906846046448,
0.5138362050056458,
-0.6521959900856018,
-0.5794079303741455,
0.5813401937484741,
0.8867591023445129,
0.28920385241508484,
0.9763699769973755,
0.5977364182472229,
-0.5893908143043518,
-0.09937360882759094,
-0.5027163028717041,
-0.5839051008224487,
-0.40884700417518616,
0.5116983652114868,
-0.4953867495059967,
-0.506761372089386,
0.4257611036300659,
0.07374405115842819,
-0.12818844616413116,
-0.012942720204591751,
0.3226151764392853,
-0.015348934568464756,
1.2977206707000732,
0.6955288052558899,
0.3831709623336792,
0.700810968875885,
-0.2552698254585266,
0.4058050215244293,
-0.8831169009208679,
-0.6594381928443909,
0.12390691787004471,
-0.26349788904190063,
-0.30263689160346985,
-0.34365132451057434,
0.29943495988845825,
-0.04741215705871582,
-0.0054346551187336445,
-0.05556202679872513,
-0.6927992701530457,
0.5248984098434448,
0.48248061537742615,
0.5000836849212646,
0.28298741579055786,
0.3436228334903717,
-0.04924202710390091,
-0.06212747469544411,
-0.6004599928855896,
-0.5004798173904419,
1.1432642936706543,
0.28395378589630127,
0.7808672785758972,
0.047657497227191925,
0.6892436742782593,
0.41113778948783875,
-0.15801669657230377,
-0.6850354075431824,
0.5337713360786438,
0.1953420639038086,
-0.3562324643135071,
-0.38930487632751465,
-0.49856892228126526,
-0.5629882216453552,
0.3694401979446411,
-0.5147432684898376,
-0.5226041674613953,
0.3388175666332245,
0.062274567782878876,
-0.7392213940620422,
0.161062553524971,
-0.7931641936302185,
0.541176438331604,
-0.3489558696746826,
-0.4012926518917084,
-0.3600327968597412,
-0.46856337785720825,
0.28563567996025085,
-0.14430616796016693,
0.34435537457466125,
0.2413119375705719,
-0.15456630289554596,
0.9366665482521057,
-0.26511481404304504,
0.9454365372657776,
-0.055867999792099,
0.1658656746149063,
0.15103819966316223,
-0.12056242674589157,
0.552036702632904,
-0.08678270131349564,
0.27302634716033936,
-0.035435568541288376,
-0.18613187968730927,
-0.2757115066051483,
-0.43769481778144836,
0.5727086067199707,
-0.7484444975852966,
-0.21527907252311707,
-0.31028690934181213,
-0.5177313089370728,
0.12236814945936203,
-0.14818483591079712,
0.6212851405143738,
0.3417520225048065,
0.010940070264041424,
0.1422232985496521,
0.6763781905174255,
-0.3854403793811798,
0.47964033484458923,
-0.14152738451957703,
-0.41529422998428345,
-0.6322324872016907,
0.8877308368682861,
0.3328196406364441,
0.2550916075706482,
0.21248246729373932,
0.08752434700727463,
-0.2558569312095642,
-0.5414310097694397,
-0.3547542691230774,
0.08562718331813812,
-1.0303549766540527,
0.0023262447211891413,
-0.8694018125534058,
0.18224088847637177,
-0.7109327912330627,
-0.23045997321605682,
-0.23073448240756989,
-0.4980504512786865,
-0.32845479249954224,
-0.4510246813297272,
0.3382875919342041,
0.7222086787223816,
-0.17881235480308533,
0.5244850516319275,
-0.7066673040390015,
0.7659820914268494,
0.2995675504207611,
0.1042008250951767,
0.10092605650424957,
-0.48212215304374695,
-0.03617984801530838,
-0.0788993090391159,
-0.3465406000614166,
-0.906992495059967,
0.4744742810726166,
0.3891468346118927,
0.4951908588409424,
0.8205127120018005,
0.0624738447368145,
1.042907953262329,
-0.3008495569229126,
0.6886779069900513,
0.7048586010932922,
-0.9077240824699402,
0.5364953875541687,
0.11985041201114655,
-0.012780536897480488,
0.31465500593185425,
0.32572340965270996,
-0.5346385836601257,
-0.23863086104393005,
-0.12414468824863434,
-1.070942759513855,
0.6556287407875061,
0.35576024651527405,
0.2277545928955078,
0.013029869645833969,
0.2235083281993866,
0.29764676094055176,
0.4991089105606079,
-0.9027086496353149,
-0.023773806169629097,
-0.2474837750196457,
-0.032367732375860214,
0.06751681864261627,
-0.6035240292549133,
-0.2214716225862503,
-0.2510163486003876,
0.32348546385765076,
-0.003790348768234253,
0.30382949113845825,
0.26060664653778076,
-0.46505558490753174,
-0.1134733334183693,
0.008080491796135902,
0.9662476778030396,
0.5234379768371582,
-0.0867166668176651,
0.1228177472949028,
0.159993976354599,
-0.3817048668861389,
-0.053926020860672,
-0.2709199786186218,
-0.2943650186061859,
0.10316948592662811,
0.5574721097946167,
1.2413862943649292,
0.06438830494880676,
-0.8843808174133301,
0.34594470262527466,
-0.005643857177346945,
-0.14545086026191711,
-0.4350704252719879,
-0.1363435834646225,
-0.40522727370262146,
0.3075579106807709,
0.37338322401046753,
0.22408749163150787,
0.33547326922416687,
-0.7126795053482056,
0.3680253326892853,
0.21443893015384674,
-0.26623958349227905,
-0.1743096113204956,
0.6064984798431396,
0.10157860815525055,
-0.09376942366361618,
0.47936493158340454,
-0.1706102043390274,
-0.40272942185401917,
0.7996019124984741,
0.42453959584236145,
0.6665495038032532,
-0.032625868916511536,
0.27445587515830994,
0.25051599740982056,
0.6572952270507812,
-0.15020668506622314,
0.28959953784942627,
-0.43555471301078796,
-0.4491225779056549,
-0.4486944079399109,
-0.4600963592529297,
-0.28462862968444824,
0.12596192955970764,
-0.7542757391929626,
0.4233102798461914,
-0.6943315863609314,
-0.29301342368125916,
-0.30264267325401306,
-0.590080738067627,
-0.4351505637168884,
0.3064340353012085,
0.5926206111907959,
0.26143673062324524,
-0.9955032467842102,
0.3401322066783905,
0.38001349568367004,
-0.37451016902923584,
-0.10820272564888,
-0.17182375490665436,
-0.05758986622095108,
-0.48541074991226196,
0.6744593977928162,
0.6180174946784973,
-0.3269968032836914,
-0.3789311349391937,
-0.46298763155937195,
-0.613047182559967,
0.9084223508834839,
0.5641772747039795,
-0.8769952654838562,
-0.05104513838887215,
0.09968683123588562,
0.40019065141677856,
-0.2850993573665619,
0.5145735144615173,
0.4410167336463928,
0.5027563571929932,
0.39870914816856384,
-0.6340426802635193,
0.08432500809431076,
-0.06774365156888962,
-0.1131770983338356,
0.17336277663707733,
-0.4418237805366516,
0.9082040190696716,
-0.6576926708221436,
-0.20632857084274292,
-0.047427717596292496,
0.3457998037338257,
0.22469304502010345,
0.8007680177688599,
0.6355668306350708,
0.6778448820114136,
0.9056680798530579,
0.1203005239367485,
1.0610311031341553,
-0.05659356340765953,
0.22590258717536926,
1.114037275314331,
-0.3555252254009247,
0.596886932849884,
0.9897611737251282,
0.20636406540870667,
-0.062060460448265076,
0.8074203729629517,
-0.047912076115608215,
0.8979151248931885,
0.09045179933309555,
-0.032684653997421265,
-0.48987412452697754,
-0.26016318798065186,
-0.4258885085582733,
0.4345751106739044,
0.15969669818878174,
-0.3885331451892853,
0.142155259847641,
0.842332661151886,
-0.031237522140145302,
-0.08474357426166534,
-0.07281985878944397,
0.8076741695404053,
0.010626792907714844,
-0.49917498230934143,
0.45098692178726196,
-0.42697516083717346,
0.7353249788284302,
-0.3730045258998871,
-0.28574827313423157,
-0.2660661041736603,
0.007191803306341171,
-0.31138619780540466,
-0.08968155831098557,
0.44801974296569824,
-0.08057448267936707,
-0.27115142345428467,
-0.32204577326774597,
0.30058878660202026,
-0.27733221650123596,
-0.4965534508228302,
0.6851868033409119,
0.37385958433151245,
0.25987619161605835,
-0.31666213274002075,
-0.3628319203853607,
0.17689070105552673,
-0.009573669172823429,
-0.40367090702056885,
0.26435190439224243,
0.2593967914581299,
0.08120743185281754,
0.8207090497016907,
0.8802193403244019,
0.24262844026088715,
0.40385010838508606,
0.2818106710910797,
0.8437063097953796,
-0.7345354557037354,
-0.46270468831062317,
-1.0308903455734253,
0.11081863939762115,
-0.2812057435512543,
-0.290155827999115,
0.4141719341278076,
0.5750107169151306,
0.9429646730422974,
-0.26045358180999756,
0.6171875596046448,
0.04424484819173813,
-0.041395507752895355,
-0.815984308719635,
0.6860405802726746,
-0.919704258441925,
0.34480881690979004,
-0.15358293056488037,
-0.7958008050918579,
-0.31727543473243713,
0.8231368660926819,
-0.02560575120151043,
0.05160600319504738,
0.7924116253852844,
0.7808663845062256,
0.12713506817817688,
-0.10526794195175171,
0.9309391379356384,
0.08123311400413513,
0.14562751352787018,
0.745680034160614,
1.1719406843185425,
-0.31354373693466187,
0.7481937408447266,
-0.4303385615348816,
-0.08173724263906479,
-0.267264723777771,
-0.5894666314125061,
-1.0792505741119385,
-0.42263972759246826,
-0.14763787388801575,
0.07630149275064468,
-0.002704473678022623,
1.0025670528411865,
0.7314653992652893,
-0.504895031452179,
0.09074389189481735,
-0.08675309270620346,
0.20580239593982697,
-0.14910449087619781,
-0.14393047988414764,
0.16292601823806763,
-0.2500242590904236,
-0.6930626630783081,
0.20502321422100067,
0.4635295569896698,
0.07031410187482834,
-0.21243980526924133,
-0.2615116536617279,
0.03193814307451248,
0.056517504155635834,
0.963767409324646,
-0.2817899286746979,
-0.7903990149497986,
-0.12405229359865189,
0.18256859481334686,
0.020263897255063057,
0.09100456535816193,
0.8285674452781677,
-0.8484007120132446,
0.7788971066474915,
0.4836377501487732,
0.300071120262146,
0.49743813276290894,
-0.5609015226364136,
0.30827733874320984,
-0.49101170897483826,
0.4975406229496002,
0.04100827872753143,
0.5744059681892395,
0.31141167879104614,
-0.625275731086731,
0.43011608719825745,
0.1964670717716217,
0.013937980867922306,
-1.02086341381073,
0.39860665798187256,
-0.9211493730545044,
-0.5322537422180176,
1.0051227807998657,
0.06590696424245834,
-0.16854989528656006,
-0.16687510907649994,
-0.4864078462123871,
0.4419022500514984,
-0.44555383920669556,
1.0140258073806763,
0.5639861822128296,
-0.2947815954685211,
-0.41542401909828186,
-0.768049955368042,
0.4114387333393097,
0.6208478808403015,
-0.7662353515625,
-0.08513502031564713,
0.6765596866607666,
-0.3153708279132843,
0.40501752495765686,
0.35446929931640625,
0.307244211435318,
0.3258512318134308,
0.12670139968395233,
0.11164097487926483,
-0.3223978877067566,
-0.9216808080673218,
-0.451997846364975,
0.41394156217575073,
-0.3001738488674164,
-0.41511639952659607
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.