id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13866v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13866v2
|
Kuaiji: the First Chinese Accounting Large Language Model
| 2024-02-21T15:14:20 | 2024-02-24T07:03:44 |
Jiayuan Luo, Songhua Yang, Xiaoling Qiu, Panyu Chen, Yufei Nai, Wenxuan Zeng, Wentao Zhang, Xinke Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT and GPT-4 have demonstrated
impressive proficiency in comprehending and generating natural language.
However, they encounter difficulties when tasked with adapting to specialized
domains such as accounting. To address this challenge, we introduce Kuaiji, a
tailored Accounting Large Language Model. Kuaiji is meticulously fine-tuned
using the Baichuan framework, which encompasses continuous pre-training and
supervised fine-tuning processes. Supported by CAtAcctQA, a dataset containing
large genuine accountant-client dialogues, Kuaiji exhibits exceptional accuracy
and response speed. Our contributions encompass the creation of the first
Chinese accounting dataset, the establishment of Kuaiji as a leading
open-source Chinese accounting LLM, and the validation of its efficacy through
real-world accounting scenarios.
|
[
0.1402682214975357,
-0.41084012389183044,
0.3850928843021393,
0.38391152024269104,
-0.4033498466014862,
-0.04175689071416855,
-0.5149123072624207,
-0.37137022614479065,
0.13085585832595825,
0.8847549557685852,
-0.24743478000164032,
-0.2804383933544159,
-0.6383891701698303,
-0.06921248883008957,
-0.2033873051404953,
1.0776159763336182,
0.10228162258863449,
0.05904495716094971,
0.29770809412002563,
-0.4486708641052246,
-0.5836061239242554,
-0.3810216188430786,
-0.9958666563034058,
-0.3665089011192322,
0.5376127362251282,
0.2222045361995697,
0.8416686058044434,
0.4287623465061188,
0.3550042510032654,
0.20153681933879852,
0.17536358535289764,
0.1963178962469101,
-0.546095609664917,
-0.13132880628108978,
0.23460522294044495,
-0.535839319229126,
-0.6973183155059814,
-0.17423003911972046,
0.7562172412872314,
0.620690643787384,
-0.6185808181762695,
0.014379160478711128,
0.027392664924263954,
0.6166645288467407,
-0.6063697338104248,
0.6107721924781799,
-0.4794185757637024,
-0.32013964653015137,
-0.2278655767440796,
0.12778030335903168,
-0.6265382766723633,
-0.352184534072876,
0.20608602464199066,
-0.844127357006073,
-0.21683622896671295,
-0.23464269936084747,
0.8639733195304871,
0.2669752836227417,
-0.6921505928039551,
-0.5211693644523621,
-0.5561118721961975,
0.5882348418235779,
-0.9617317318916321,
0.2582497298717499,
0.41473641991615295,
0.5412101149559021,
-0.10669666528701782,
-1.1358245611190796,
-0.5246730446815491,
-0.3214498460292816,
-0.22954675555229187,
0.2206457257270813,
0.01803080178797245,
-0.016972454264760017,
0.141133651137352,
0.346219003200531,
-0.6184170246124268,
0.34587785601615906,
-0.28135553002357483,
0.060125552117824554,
0.7672194838523865,
0.4548993706703186,
0.30942022800445557,
0.254190057516098,
0.05756353959441185,
-0.25455087423324585,
-0.47358155250549316,
-0.10765864700078964,
0.1290697157382965,
0.49900874495506287,
-0.2789038121700287,
0.07285928726196289,
-0.20064577460289001,
0.6494967341423035,
-0.18155618011951447,
-0.46022340655326843,
0.009818198159337044,
0.0999796986579895,
-0.5971016883850098,
0.37442249059677124,
0.5630364418029785,
0.14619509875774384,
0.256163626909256,
0.23186977207660675,
-0.4257150888442993,
0.10434076189994812,
0.07964480668306351,
-0.6532592177391052,
-0.6392938494682312,
0.08174765855073929,
-0.39072293043136597,
-0.34550514817237854,
-0.0349552147090435,
-0.1291092336177826,
-0.560627281665802,
-0.20029141008853912,
0.20238010585308075,
-0.04671749845147133,
-0.34991654753685,
0.07753201574087143,
0.2691580057144165,
0.6808699369430542,
0.5458347201347351,
-1.0063413381576538,
0.23488231003284454,
1.0055471658706665,
0.8016767501831055,
0.1250801682472229,
-0.2037285417318344,
-0.9250500202178955,
0.5011703372001648,
-0.6959326267242432,
0.5771380066871643,
-0.6036145687103271,
-0.047824304550886154,
0.02573188953101635,
-0.11064577102661133,
0.33100685477256775,
-0.5076484680175781,
0.2750084400177002,
-0.5954005122184753,
-0.18715564906597137,
0.0010587692959234118,
-0.6179358959197998,
-0.21284745633602142,
0.36964184045791626,
-0.7779411673545837,
0.4156572222709656,
0.4771044850349426,
-0.23563775420188904,
0.4902322292327881,
-0.6883428692817688,
-0.6036116480827332,
0.7768126130104065,
-0.14045602083206177,
-0.4785975515842438,
-0.25857266783714294,
0.11721779406070709,
0.3041192889213562,
-0.5129661560058594,
0.5552184581756592,
-0.13615131378173828,
-0.04160671308636665,
0.12471653521060944,
-0.3279195725917816,
1.025075078010559,
0.4905957281589508,
-0.021492984145879745,
-0.07837636768817902,
-0.7006540894508362,
-0.1213509812951088,
0.22280395030975342,
-0.28743964433670044,
-0.5615631937980652,
-0.11849106848239899,
0.1406129151582718,
-0.35100415349006653,
0.37721291184425354,
-0.2382466346025467,
0.473153680562973,
-0.37403494119644165,
0.9157794117927551,
0.8511102795600891,
-0.3222798705101013,
0.12157196551561356,
-0.3142387568950653,
0.4964645802974701,
0.03330792114138603,
0.11374775320291519,
-0.5492032170295715,
-0.4297381043434143,
-0.49049338698387146,
-0.1662747859954834,
0.5002461075782776,
0.43117785453796387,
-0.5256192684173584,
-0.2107284516096115,
-0.26610609889030457,
-0.7964922189712524,
-0.4588542580604553,
0.3321658968925476,
-0.04542160406708717,
0.28674593567848206,
-0.23942865431308746,
-0.30473825335502625,
-0.2934405207633972,
-0.8957507610321045,
-0.1598561853170395,
-0.35627472400665283,
-0.12681905925273895,
0.43203240633010864,
0.11495616286993027,
-0.38656818866729736,
0.321476012468338,
-0.7646661996841431,
-0.5058690309524536,
-0.3233136832714081,
0.13185691833496094,
0.7091018557548523,
0.3476605713367462,
0.6079705357551575,
-1.023476481437683,
-0.8061336278915405,
0.47449490427970886,
-0.4794634282588959,
-0.05103869363665581,
-0.5859939455986023,
-0.14619171619415283,
0.20522969961166382,
0.1890849471092224,
-0.7086382508277893,
0.4659308195114136,
0.47580912709236145,
-0.10667019337415695,
0.5591152310371399,
-0.46080106496810913,
-0.1264069378376007,
-1.1788042783737183,
0.05206787586212158,
-0.013204221613705158,
-0.2616555988788605,
-0.6391263604164124,
0.3883630335330963,
0.32776302099227905,
-0.1946946531534195,
-0.16647523641586304,
0.6180868148803711,
-0.46489599347114563,
-0.01440969668328762,
-0.2744956314563751,
0.1403963267803192,
-0.23839734494686127,
0.47138309478759766,
-0.014984173700213432,
0.6147185564041138,
0.4604324400424957,
-0.7197868227958679,
0.8238334059715271,
0.5309094786643982,
-0.6770802140235901,
0.48896604776382446,
-0.7368830442428589,
0.1387774646282196,
0.14827845990657806,
0.2763175666332245,
-0.7546747922897339,
-0.5400833487510681,
0.19460278749465942,
-0.33235669136047363,
0.3122493028640747,
0.023518629372119904,
-0.5629085898399353,
-0.05274166911840439,
0.2054930180311203,
0.36213424801826477,
0.6010169982910156,
-0.6530226469039917,
0.8815028071403503,
0.34079280495643616,
-0.44989272952079773,
-0.3096178472042084,
-0.5326138138771057,
0.42291924357414246,
-0.011974044144153595,
-0.5360453128814697,
-0.009985992684960365,
-0.012356333434581757,
-0.2269439846277237,
-0.38484787940979004,
0.1251116544008255,
-0.18167653679847717,
0.25655800104141235,
-0.16548959910869598,
0.4832250773906708,
-0.4830562472343445,
-0.10409996658563614,
-0.18357647955417633,
-0.0856703668832779,
-0.08081432431936264,
-0.21396899223327637,
0.2689433693885803,
0.06797543913125992,
0.007853287272155285,
-0.23706214129924774,
-0.02041223645210266,
0.48848599195480347,
-0.3211056888103485,
0.738621175289154,
0.2521399259567261,
-0.47526413202285767,
-0.24928507208824158,
-0.4868638515472412,
0.3434716761112213,
-0.4765661954879761,
0.38331031799316406,
-0.28111761808395386,
-0.9996187090873718,
0.47358906269073486,
0.07745523750782013,
0.43299463391304016,
0.1961597353219986,
0.8226098418235779,
0.3840390741825104,
0.9325795769691467,
0.8141096830368042,
-0.5152590870857239,
0.29178285598754883,
0.13861910998821259,
0.5065048933029175,
-0.47419244050979614,
0.028054162859916687,
-0.47540485858917236,
-0.04494359344244003,
-0.9236156940460205,
0.13102132081985474,
0.4934538006782532,
-0.36363470554351807,
-0.5446076989173889,
0.3694041669368744,
-0.2166578471660614,
0.49137136340141296,
0.4873262941837311,
-0.14488600194454193,
0.12114521861076355,
-0.4239852726459503,
0.415567010641098,
0.3088814616203308,
-0.5429418087005615,
-0.3501581847667694,
0.8854244351387024,
0.3414514660835266,
1.1129873991012573,
0.2601023316383362,
0.23238711059093475,
0.30786749720573425,
0.5976895689964294,
-0.562176525592804,
0.17732758820056915,
-0.5210294723510742,
-0.37254592776298523,
-0.5178720355033875,
-0.49312320351600647,
-0.7953366041183472,
0.04223170131444931,
0.15385527908802032,
-0.5187278389930725,
-0.3448467254638672,
0.1514841765165329,
-0.6639313101768494,
0.2532750070095062,
-0.8078598380088806,
0.7906478643417358,
-0.29096195101737976,
-0.031960584223270416,
-0.039800841361284256,
-0.517130434513092,
0.591870129108429,
-0.2844492495059967,
0.1667623221874237,
0.05568350851535797,
0.019183998927474022,
0.4985141158103943,
-0.5098791718482971,
0.7975935339927673,
-0.06969860196113586,
-0.42848309874534607,
0.23725146055221558,
0.3043026924133301,
0.6459767818450928,
0.1801222711801529,
0.244890034198761,
0.15805043280124664,
0.3637101352214813,
-0.6190370321273804,
-0.7666248679161072,
0.6072194576263428,
-0.8347768783569336,
-0.6348199248313904,
-0.374056339263916,
-0.6345920562744141,
0.05974581092596054,
0.495587021112442,
-0.2570384442806244,
0.316776841878891,
-0.21869678795337677,
0.2676404118537903,
0.26383092999458313,
-0.38970866799354553,
0.25343605875968933,
0.6460200548171997,
-0.29720979928970337,
-0.4229639768600464,
0.8789761662483215,
0.021975906565785408,
0.30674004554748535,
0.4013386070728302,
0.2599596381187439,
0.08316679298877716,
-0.06794518977403641,
-0.3538455069065094,
0.29989558458328247,
-0.6471531987190247,
-0.38674396276474,
-0.3683259189128876,
-0.3815438151359558,
-0.7844715118408203,
-0.24315020442008972,
-0.34599918127059937,
-0.02876279316842556,
-0.03674495592713356,
0.08555665612220764,
0.2265288531780243,
0.9094288945198059,
-0.033981531858444214,
0.5424145460128784,
-0.97064608335495,
0.3568987548351288,
0.4520573914051056,
0.4938121736049652,
0.19884167611598969,
-0.5328750014305115,
-0.5569098591804504,
0.1737086921930313,
-0.09592247009277344,
-0.35375070571899414,
0.6908939480781555,
0.23620307445526123,
0.3929806649684906,
0.7803537249565125,
0.08075784891843796,
0.598501443862915,
-0.19456379115581512,
0.9162439107894897,
0.16755995154380798,
-0.7078560590744019,
0.46254944801330566,
-0.29563260078430176,
0.5619403123855591,
0.11194899678230286,
0.2704201936721802,
-0.9846689105033875,
-0.23874935507774353,
-0.3321852684020996,
-0.6470721960067749,
0.7510889172554016,
0.08956730365753174,
0.2321537435054779,
0.15497015416622162,
0.6313637495040894,
0.3699902892112732,
0.1397564709186554,
-0.7315337657928467,
-0.08126844465732574,
-0.12271082401275635,
-0.1330375373363495,
-0.47400885820388794,
-0.2078000158071518,
0.06907078623771667,
0.0011079488322138786,
0.8304028511047363,
-0.3367178440093994,
-0.20172761380672455,
-0.20044861733913422,
-0.17423278093338013,
-0.1524273306131363,
-0.09020713716745377,
0.6266003251075745,
0.9974591135978699,
0.05152890831232071,
-0.18613490462303162,
0.11519873887300491,
-0.7199500203132629,
-0.034367676824331284,
-0.1302667111158371,
-0.26551714539527893,
-0.04537728428840637,
0.5288416147232056,
0.9780733585357666,
0.1564769744873047,
-0.8575611710548401,
0.43636924028396606,
-0.16303661465644836,
-0.1632092297077179,
-0.8069019317626953,
0.18820466101169586,
0.07204300165176392,
0.17987221479415894,
0.4541776478290558,
-0.6656490564346313,
-0.07193686813116074,
-0.6365031599998474,
-0.11703196167945862,
0.23674966394901276,
-0.2318899929523468,
-0.1358674317598343,
0.8721728920936584,
0.031745947897434235,
-0.3710469901561737,
1.1043843030929565,
0.2064608931541443,
-0.5172452330589294,
0.6289439797401428,
0.4764549136161804,
0.9824743866920471,
-0.34276580810546875,
0.1113910973072052,
0.48102501034736633,
0.40507641434669495,
-0.11806829273700714,
-0.2080642580986023,
-0.22048644721508026,
-0.7640506029129028,
-0.49944886565208435,
-0.6085027456283569,
-0.617372989654541,
0.3537546694278717,
-0.8714272975921631,
0.4316338896751404,
-0.5957472920417786,
0.2136463075876236,
0.2560902535915375,
0.08372097462415695,
-0.424739807844162,
0.3260769546031952,
0.3942287564277649,
1.1107503175735474,
-0.44456154108047485,
0.9252029061317444,
0.6555025577545166,
-0.31628361344337463,
-1.016357183456421,
-0.34055423736572266,
-0.3245266377925873,
-1.2666088342666626,
0.6458910703659058,
0.06778603792190552,
0.30487361550331116,
-0.09879424422979355,
-1.202309250831604,
-0.48546716570854187,
1.2486321926116943,
0.2829066216945648,
-0.850172758102417,
-0.1684369593858719,
0.26606422662734985,
0.3845193684101105,
-0.5015974044799805,
0.1404580920934677,
0.8922300338745117,
0.44586092233657837,
0.07234560698270798,
-1.0049763917922974,
-0.24792127311229706,
-0.24663519859313965,
0.2987538278102875,
0.39961233735084534,
-1.1252037286758423,
0.8776265978813171,
-0.13649675250053406,
-0.016568223014473915,
0.24331620335578918,
0.7579914927482605,
0.021251410245895386,
0.2682044804096222,
0.417900949716568,
0.5337246656417847,
0.7395776510238647,
0.07804428786039352,
0.939061164855957,
-0.23137986660003662,
0.18709830939769745,
1.3317592144012451,
-0.5746395587921143,
0.5320067405700684,
0.09122669696807861,
-0.17493700981140137,
0.46186721324920654,
0.5766035914421082,
-0.09500180184841156,
0.416019082069397,
0.03793979808688164,
-0.36827152967453003,
-0.4540540277957916,
0.01218213327229023,
-0.1836007833480835,
0.4530433714389801,
0.31219375133514404,
-0.06824102997779846,
0.13337257504463196,
-0.13862179219722748,
-0.07945306599140167,
-0.056732647120952606,
-0.5306843519210815,
0.9594190120697021,
0.5129745006561279,
-0.5891319513320923,
0.2556542754173279,
0.09352606534957886,
0.3926389515399933,
-0.87578284740448,
-0.26778191328048706,
-0.511120617389679,
0.09804923087358475,
0.03693029284477234,
-0.6292653679847717,
-0.04199943318963051,
-0.004815937951207161,
0.2891683876514435,
-0.012279882095754147,
0.5904386043548584,
-0.30887937545776367,
-0.477134108543396,
-0.02253010682761669,
-0.0993613451719284,
0.13291217386722565,
0.04347127303481102,
-0.30485799908638,
0.009431658312678337,
-0.04181385040283203,
-0.12361714243888855,
0.43851521611213684,
0.7443868517875671,
-0.038404352962970734,
0.8264332413673401,
0.6814152598381042,
0.09454569965600967,
-0.36487358808517456,
0.11992782354354858,
0.7640378475189209,
-0.8310400247573853,
-1.0909842252731323,
-0.7359155416488647,
0.2439766824245453,
0.2590458393096924,
-0.41705822944641113,
0.3798801004886627,
0.5524007678031921,
1.060224175453186,
0.027466019615530968,
0.9275186657905579,
0.01789226569235325,
0.29690298438072205,
-0.40259891748428345,
1.1002111434936523,
-0.5405727624893188,
0.0419142059981823,
-0.42247018218040466,
-0.8034658432006836,
-0.31185925006866455,
0.5551192760467529,
-0.12523800134658813,
-0.0022294598165899515,
0.14517123997211456,
0.7033295035362244,
0.026145752519369125,
0.13805003464221954,
0.7844148874282837,
0.6064594388008118,
0.4011461138725281,
0.8291738629341125,
0.5964557528495789,
-0.49813032150268555,
0.6179672479629517,
-0.20806987583637238,
-0.31943050026893616,
-0.23606964945793152,
-0.8994024395942688,
-0.6640785932540894,
-0.7085763216018677,
-0.41262462735176086,
-0.23195692896842957,
-0.2835496962070465,
0.7638368606567383,
0.3919641673564911,
-0.794895350933075,
-0.5535784959793091,
0.36673274636268616,
-0.22364522516727448,
-0.13306942582130432,
-0.18438927829265594,
0.17795109748840332,
-0.10191625356674194,
-0.5066878795623779,
-0.13022486865520477,
0.5502632856369019,
-0.11229974031448364,
-0.19550952315330505,
-0.5637512803077698,
0.07614883780479431,
-0.06436387449502945,
0.6159750819206238,
0.3443346917629242,
-0.6417324542999268,
-0.1461309939622879,
0.007841684855520725,
-0.13646622002124786,
-0.017034709453582764,
0.8792508244514465,
-0.2239605337381363,
0.4689795672893524,
-0.10586478561162949,
0.8866032361984253,
0.5393348932266235,
-0.30683401226997375,
0.7356352806091309,
0.011543448083102703,
0.13569463789463043,
0.129844069480896,
0.2522178292274475,
0.1305660456418991,
-0.6261106133460999,
0.5124545097351074,
-0.08218133449554443,
-0.5764738917350769,
-0.8916233777999878,
-0.013581966049969196,
-0.9111511707305908,
-0.12288614362478256,
0.7141883969306946,
-0.33239996433258057,
-0.43161872029304504,
0.24477511644363403,
-0.23566369712352753,
0.20066191256046295,
-0.1222836896777153,
0.698284924030304,
0.9329822063446045,
0.25114157795906067,
-0.3013868033885956,
-0.5904083251953125,
0.19137457013130188,
0.2166224718093872,
-0.44691789150238037,
0.24873988330364227,
0.44536900520324707,
0.24737325310707092,
-0.2657361328601837,
0.8324424624443054,
0.11984281241893768,
0.6981257796287537,
0.19270342588424683,
-0.08601096272468567,
0.04659548029303551,
-0.041027456521987915,
-0.22883903980255127,
-0.24646791815757751,
0.5049692988395691,
0.3613022565841675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14872v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14872v2
|
Semantic Mirror Jailbreak: Genetic Algorithm Based Jailbreak Prompts Against Open-source LLMs
| 2024-02-21T15:13:50 | 2024-02-27T13:49:22 |
Xiaoxia Li, Siyuan Liang, Jiyi Zhang, Han Fang, Aishan Liu, Ee-Chien Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.NE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), used in creative writing, code generation, and
translation, generate text based on input sequences but are vulnerable to
jailbreak attacks, where crafted prompts induce harmful outputs. Most jailbreak
prompt methods use a combination of jailbreak templates followed by questions
to ask to create jailbreak prompts. However, existing jailbreak prompt designs
generally suffer from excessive semantic differences, resulting in an inability
to resist defenses that use simple semantic metrics as thresholds. Jailbreak
prompts are semantically more varied than the original questions used for
queries. In this paper, we introduce a Semantic Mirror Jailbreak (SMJ) approach
that bypasses LLMs by generating jailbreak prompts that are semantically
similar to the original question. We model the search for jailbreak prompts
that satisfy both semantic similarity and jailbreak validity as a
multi-objective optimization problem and employ a standardized set of genetic
algorithms for generating eligible prompts. Compared to the baseline
AutoDAN-GA, SMJ achieves attack success rates (ASR) that are at most 35.4%
higher without ONION defense and 85.2% higher with ONION defense. SMJ's better
performance in all three semantic meaningfulness metrics of Jailbreak Prompt,
Similarity, and Outlier, also means that SMJ is resistant to defenses that use
those metrics as thresholds.
|
[
-0.4667939841747284,
-0.8515844345092773,
0.897462785243988,
0.15713123977184296,
-0.28094395995140076,
0.24976831674575806,
-0.11007443815469742,
-0.2277161031961441,
0.5245199203491211,
0.7892377972602844,
-1.1366480588912964,
-0.6451196074485779,
-0.7985754013061523,
0.46148157119750977,
-0.2534794211387634,
0.8242205381393433,
-0.07246740907430649,
0.07968854159116745,
0.08297314494848251,
-0.02701631188392639,
-0.7578436136245728,
-0.0658266618847847,
-0.0363287515938282,
0.3413699269294739,
0.5184776186943054,
0.648529052734375,
0.5475221276283264,
0.49541547894477844,
0.6027634143829346,
0.26822561025619507,
-0.10997939109802246,
0.2583918571472168,
-0.32416394352912903,
0.40206387639045715,
-0.251348078250885,
-0.26642581820487976,
-0.044800955802202225,
0.0964355319738388,
0.2264775037765503,
0.0943356454372406,
0.0034137526527047157,
0.1102907732129097,
-0.17982009053230286,
0.8767907619476318,
-0.7566785216331482,
-0.2180030196905136,
-1.2370120286941528,
0.10701528191566467,
-0.16999337077140808,
-0.02714497409760952,
-0.3606429994106293,
-0.518333911895752,
-0.4614191949367523,
-0.5307837128639221,
0.03795354813337326,
0.11021467298269272,
0.6857447028160095,
0.2975485324859619,
-0.058798130601644516,
-0.5388295650482178,
-0.06599026918411255,
0.6226213574409485,
-0.8145176768302917,
0.20780660212039948,
0.18239665031433105,
0.3348191976547241,
-0.704380214214325,
-0.3686319589614868,
-0.5717046856880188,
-0.6956558227539062,
0.18616245687007904,
-0.05079107731580734,
-0.10068786889314651,
-0.11431996524333954,
0.25297221541404724,
-0.08520659059286118,
-0.5767536759376526,
0.04836834967136383,
-0.40170174837112427,
-0.1139356791973114,
0.4731108844280243,
0.3396884799003601,
0.6127024292945862,
-0.4900495707988739,
-0.5514066219329834,
-0.13030360639095306,
-1.163561463356018,
-0.12412454932928085,
0.614052951335907,
0.33517834544181824,
0.2074095606803894,
0.7065777778625488,
-0.29666972160339355,
0.7230795621871948,
-0.015011729672551155,
-0.21053306758403778,
0.08819263428449631,
-0.3434094488620758,
0.25923195481300354,
0.17549249529838562,
0.9659625291824341,
0.6308491826057434,
0.2506416440010071,
-0.4928784668445587,
0.02724612131714821,
0.04589221999049187,
0.46784257888793945,
-0.7535972595214844,
0.13594530522823334,
0.2739501893520355,
-0.5740392804145813,
-0.6050549149513245,
0.31296229362487793,
-0.8809916377067566,
-0.7569769024848938,
0.20771537721157074,
0.42992427945137024,
-0.45299285650253296,
0.1363997608423233,
-0.11323756724596024,
-0.47323623299598694,
0.40903016924858093,
0.14948204159736633,
-0.74954754114151,
0.2007090300321579,
0.7376530170440674,
0.9904832243919373,
-0.1270008236169815,
-0.35717371106147766,
-0.5993404984474182,
0.3030872941017151,
-0.059533990919589996,
0.5788686871528625,
-0.47116315364837646,
-0.6438121795654297,
-0.46984365582466125,
-0.065805584192276,
0.027343638241291046,
-0.4313011169433594,
0.34842684864997864,
-0.5326961874961853,
-0.10907898098230362,
-0.2900516390800476,
-0.4455048441886902,
0.07113738358020782,
0.267440527677536,
-0.688338041305542,
0.4174450635910034,
-0.13751524686813354,
-0.8531057834625244,
0.4743030071258545,
-0.51874840259552,
-0.4230148494243622,
-0.09945116937160492,
-0.07299727201461792,
-0.4059630036354065,
0.0653807744383812,
0.3725711405277252,
0.38161033391952515,
-0.22734971344470978,
0.27403438091278076,
-0.5503964424133301,
-0.3506346046924591,
0.0805039331316948,
-0.01144255418330431,
0.7224850654602051,
0.5991092920303345,
-0.7325612902641296,
0.18175780773162842,
-0.7039315700531006,
-0.11181926727294922,
0.5670067667961121,
0.16152368485927582,
-0.6122951507568359,
0.3088122010231018,
-0.4664238393306732,
0.153516486287117,
0.27390146255493164,
-1.1733404397964478,
0.31819918751716614,
-0.5884712934494019,
0.55934077501297,
0.937052845954895,
0.008941488340497017,
0.18994870781898499,
-0.09565196931362152,
0.19111338257789612,
0.029268480837345123,
0.2606532573699951,
-0.10854551196098328,
-0.7127515077590942,
-0.2480645775794983,
-0.22100403904914856,
-0.05309391766786575,
0.9628571271896362,
-0.8180780410766602,
0.36252591013908386,
-0.05458000674843788,
-0.5547714829444885,
-0.6679245829582214,
0.6414396166801453,
0.37851014733314514,
0.7249398827552795,
0.4155554175376892,
-0.3620387613773346,
-0.4047688841819763,
-0.8054201006889343,
-0.7792888879776001,
-0.09916321188211441,
0.11738700419664383,
0.26921406388282776,
0.47556522488594055,
-0.20768021047115326,
0.9048561453819275,
-0.5809234976768494,
-0.33666276931762695,
-0.3444490134716034,
-0.18454097211360931,
0.5586445331573486,
0.37667086720466614,
0.4636698365211487,
-0.5406514406204224,
-0.2714956998825073,
-0.5258510112762451,
-0.8791899681091309,
-0.37911534309387207,
-0.09075243026018143,
0.03579413890838623,
-0.023184098303318024,
0.6853851079940796,
-0.5574496984481812,
0.40423575043678284,
0.3889497220516205,
-0.8135995864868164,
0.49836069345474243,
-0.16501501202583313,
0.264960378408432,
-1.2229186296463013,
-0.2626743018627167,
-0.10138318687677383,
-0.08603154122829437,
-0.4041379690170288,
0.5682668685913086,
0.14670909941196442,
-0.10180176794528961,
-0.6299126148223877,
0.5660752058029175,
-0.24445925652980804,
0.08966537564992905,
-0.253081351518631,
0.3802446126937866,
-0.18806545436382294,
0.053222134709358215,
-0.2546616494655609,
0.9204088449478149,
0.13105890154838562,
-0.13770826160907745,
0.6188690662384033,
0.33031317591667175,
-0.24383868277072906,
0.4128777086734772,
-0.83277428150177,
0.06451693177223206,
-0.13126744329929352,
-0.010809882543981075,
-0.9784095883369446,
0.10293140262365341,
0.42751678824424744,
-0.4656752347946167,
-0.019338030368089676,
0.062409333884716034,
-0.5597596764564514,
-0.27569514513015747,
-0.7733772993087769,
-0.020979933440685272,
0.5533358454704285,
-0.683435320854187,
0.35854700207710266,
0.04952583089470863,
-0.18322031199932098,
-0.48663032054901123,
-0.46630293130874634,
0.5447471141815186,
-0.3073734939098358,
-1.1528280973434448,
0.2377968728542328,
0.04538062587380409,
-0.40184518694877625,
0.13858115673065186,
0.16584326326847076,
0.339472234249115,
0.4292166233062744,
0.35608744621276855,
0.507742702960968,
-0.09867888689041138,
-0.5711005330085754,
0.2189122438430786,
-0.20562595129013062,
0.28214558959007263,
-0.21518494188785553,
0.34861186146736145,
-0.07184683531522751,
-0.31427910923957825,
-0.20924729108810425,
0.5212222337722778,
0.4356881082057953,
-0.1602914035320282,
1.042516827583313,
0.2672140300273895,
0.22964516282081604,
-0.30830270051956177,
-0.6587455868721008,
-0.2673198878765106,
-0.524732768535614,
0.08442214876413345,
-0.46535053849220276,
-1.1330560445785522,
0.47469136118888855,
-0.10220585763454437,
0.07772202789783478,
0.22285057604312897,
0.6726282238960266,
0.0183228962123394,
0.99444580078125,
0.4003632068634033,
-0.15905536711215973,
0.4166065752506256,
0.19829900562763214,
0.1705477088689804,
-0.8049110770225525,
-0.12073908746242523,
-0.4826214611530304,
-0.21133315563201904,
-0.7383765578269958,
-0.0755845159292221,
0.39610713720321655,
-0.03880911320447922,
-0.30244722962379456,
0.6499196290969849,
-0.66138756275177,
0.5558711290359497,
0.6995382308959961,
0.325505793094635,
0.3767807185649872,
-0.24629026651382446,
-0.3376389145851135,
0.0781586542725563,
-0.3507791757583618,
-0.36130067706108093,
1.151279330253601,
0.2774202227592468,
0.9599169492721558,
0.19589191675186157,
1.0967124700546265,
0.39563125371932983,
0.0019503418589010835,
-0.36185333132743835,
0.6340261101722717,
-0.14202755689620972,
-0.4608841836452484,
-0.08607964962720871,
-0.6417019963264465,
-0.7643030881881714,
0.32330745458602905,
-0.1608107089996338,
-0.9286937713623047,
-0.13296321034431458,
-0.019750332459807396,
-0.10710160434246063,
0.4743122160434723,
-0.7847535610198975,
0.9142987132072449,
-0.1805267632007599,
-0.270800918340683,
-0.10896620154380798,
-1.0466508865356445,
0.6120527982711792,
-0.09559071063995361,
0.4851406514644623,
-0.2830173075199127,
0.0608043298125267,
0.5137362480163574,
-0.9644650816917419,
0.7289043068885803,
-0.4915035665035248,
0.2832076847553253,
0.28522855043411255,
0.35709506273269653,
0.734612226486206,
0.1732686311006546,
0.1360488086938858,
0.07230853289365768,
-0.026744864881038666,
-0.2698173522949219,
-0.5279493927955627,
0.7677149176597595,
-0.7130073308944702,
-0.9239785671234131,
-0.213459312915802,
-0.4063159227371216,
-0.23549896478652954,
0.14744997024536133,
0.3950900733470917,
-0.07462988793849945,
0.017324242740869522,
-0.4010073244571686,
0.7218896746635437,
-0.5936759114265442,
0.31382495164871216,
0.3642047345638275,
-0.08091157674789429,
-0.543314516544342,
0.9373214244842529,
-0.25350138545036316,
0.3737264573574066,
-0.1930442452430725,
0.33905577659606934,
0.03940892964601517,
-0.5823227763175964,
-0.7947074770927429,
0.17137810587882996,
-0.6324537396430969,
-0.43149036169052124,
-0.5382893085479736,
-0.195640429854393,
-0.4819367229938507,
-0.46102577447891235,
-0.213666170835495,
-0.36136212944984436,
0.02152090147137642,
0.020818602293729782,
0.730589747428894,
0.5529906749725342,
-0.09867014735937119,
0.12793178856372833,
-0.9386191964149475,
0.7204915285110474,
0.17251577973365784,
0.249530628323555,
-0.10470689088106155,
-0.31301629543304443,
0.39921873807907104,
-0.09592138230800629,
-0.2346525639295578,
-1.302856206893921,
0.22917784750461578,
0.036864347755908966,
0.512048602104187,
0.06432550400495529,
0.14727285504341125,
0.511013925075531,
-0.9138768315315247,
0.7892280220985413,
0.4230046570301056,
-1.0853365659713745,
1.097307562828064,
-0.3674537241458893,
0.11104226857423782,
0.9046355485916138,
0.024901865050196648,
-0.42546260356903076,
-1.0350464582443237,
-0.3254067301750183,
-1.0540276765823364,
0.39525631070137024,
0.11689543724060059,
0.325451523065567,
-0.19460956752300262,
0.5075644254684448,
0.13638490438461304,
0.10992880165576935,
-0.6633927822113037,
-0.20332415401935577,
-0.43591272830963135,
-0.3406221568584442,
0.2840321958065033,
-0.06994248926639557,
-0.023492172360420227,
-0.20815809071063995,
0.5064005255699158,
0.11185850948095322,
0.16423650085926056,
0.333219975233078,
-0.36457598209381104,
0.14877517521381378,
0.36792826652526855,
0.6273921728134155,
0.17534556984901428,
-0.2589777708053589,
-0.07490970194339752,
0.1863282322883606,
-0.7624480128288269,
0.32103168964385986,
-0.10081604868173599,
-0.5165470242500305,
-0.03566284105181694,
0.22088594734668732,
0.6753396391868591,
-0.08372768014669418,
-0.8221973180770874,
0.8466535806655884,
-0.22515486180782318,
-0.22992929816246033,
-0.1472831815481186,
0.33403006196022034,
-0.17204506695270538,
0.24021783471107483,
0.08402390033006668,
-0.18654130399227142,
0.24288815259933472,
-0.5523397922515869,
0.2475852519273758,
0.7084972858428955,
-0.34371817111968994,
0.2220994532108307,
1.0655431747436523,
0.047564975917339325,
-0.061969731003046036,
0.8022383451461792,
-0.14837849140167236,
-0.5685429573059082,
0.6676745414733887,
0.6366768479347229,
1.032253623008728,
-0.06730905175209045,
0.14052437245845795,
0.09783360362052917,
0.5736842155456543,
0.1459934115409851,
0.43590784072875977,
-0.1085347905755043,
-0.6774652600288391,
-0.4366312325000763,
-0.6563381552696228,
-0.5345820784568787,
-0.4557044506072998,
-0.4014046788215637,
0.3758646547794342,
-0.8062576651573181,
0.13196076452732086,
-0.34869384765625,
-0.31714680790901184,
-0.16374480724334717,
-0.05669600889086723,
0.20049923658370972,
1.3427023887634277,
-0.6208250522613525,
0.7146324515342712,
0.3548089861869812,
-0.3109551668167114,
-0.7257857322692871,
-0.3645671010017395,
0.4547795355319977,
-0.9487730264663696,
0.6422547698020935,
0.3145752549171448,
-0.26211798191070557,
-0.30613473057746887,
-0.7381798028945923,
-0.6849812269210815,
0.9265316724777222,
0.21983759105205536,
-0.44770026206970215,
-0.058659203350543976,
0.07322254776954651,
-0.015593504533171654,
-0.3215627372264862,
-0.05930512771010399,
0.68819659948349,
0.6520727872848511,
0.30047476291656494,
-0.5920161008834839,
0.4315125346183777,
-0.32120662927627563,
-0.03432455658912659,
0.5242921710014343,
-0.3745376765727997,
0.6207966208457947,
-0.5997591018676758,
0.24751384556293488,
0.4296739399433136,
0.4787870943546295,
0.7381412982940674,
0.30937543511390686,
0.44285696744918823,
0.7222525477409363,
0.2256256490945816,
-0.26121124625205994,
1.035417079925537,
-0.41809314489364624,
0.08438466489315033,
0.904045820236206,
-0.32989466190338135,
0.5827335715293884,
0.7788552641868591,
0.23381109535694122,
0.6784006357192993,
0.25881341099739075,
-0.4760766327381134,
0.9774030447006226,
0.401643842458725,
-0.09843528270721436,
0.015161172486841679,
0.29534026980400085,
-0.31215062737464905,
0.2584511339664459,
0.1959420144557953,
-0.39679741859436035,
-0.4162767231464386,
0.3765328824520111,
0.494748055934906,
0.16320370137691498,
-0.4212019145488739,
1.0795626640319824,
0.18520621955394745,
-0.47587302327156067,
0.28415581583976746,
0.3720700740814209,
0.806328296661377,
-0.7735982537269592,
0.0635029599070549,
-0.10813061147928238,
-0.048641104251146317,
-0.22416318953037262,
-0.7084121704101562,
0.4965994358062744,
0.38128307461738586,
-0.018109221011400223,
-0.18893121182918549,
0.9166820645332336,
0.13969704508781433,
-0.39451995491981506,
0.3781009614467621,
0.3114103376865387,
-0.06968167424201965,
0.007885156199336052,
-0.6357499361038208,
0.19238094985485077,
-0.17323891818523407,
-0.32393303513526917,
0.38107237219810486,
0.08394376188516617,
0.06420974433422089,
0.5778524279594421,
0.7819003462791443,
0.38141289353370667,
0.41408228874206543,
-0.2812761664390564,
1.1638717651367188,
-1.0063025951385498,
-0.5005714893341064,
-1.329168677330017,
0.2946535050868988,
-0.21927008032798767,
-0.17798566818237305,
0.9109450578689575,
0.1711065173149109,
0.617156445980072,
0.060366299003362656,
0.6818619966506958,
-0.3131512403488159,
0.49952980875968933,
-0.9245784282684326,
0.8621529340744019,
-0.45819616317749023,
0.5179534554481506,
-0.8288520574569702,
-0.9630914330482483,
-0.25668230652809143,
0.5755281448364258,
-0.42889440059661865,
-0.23050256073474884,
0.5262823700904846,
0.8809218406677246,
0.27211371064186096,
0.22870050370693207,
0.09798383712768555,
0.13217268884181976,
0.32974016666412354,
0.8689196109771729,
1.03322434425354,
-0.19830858707427979,
0.2882431447505951,
-0.09255944192409515,
-0.35795193910598755,
0.10599284619092941,
-0.9185474514961243,
-0.896425724029541,
-0.28650933504104614,
0.12560796737670898,
-0.7497886419296265,
0.434333473443985,
0.9483816027641296,
0.20458394289016724,
-0.7068771123886108,
-0.07728856801986694,
-0.20521481335163116,
0.4459323585033417,
0.19772261381149292,
-0.22477132081985474,
0.049894530326128006,
-0.6030450463294983,
-0.028834139928221703,
0.6445740461349487,
0.4543658494949341,
-0.3978535830974579,
-0.1592356413602829,
-0.004134704824537039,
0.09004312008619308,
0.17514581978321075,
0.4193524718284607,
0.2268347442150116,
-0.7647985816001892,
-0.40592271089553833,
0.046484678983688354,
-0.14766435325145721,
-0.04354572668671608,
0.7628625631332397,
-0.9174059629440308,
0.3480512499809265,
0.3937130272388458,
0.7135162949562073,
0.16512219607830048,
-0.061545245349407196,
0.44443073868751526,
-0.44473642110824585,
0.2930137813091278,
0.04758373275399208,
0.41609591245651245,
0.06535571813583374,
-0.5023065209388733,
0.33552998304367065,
0.41290733218193054,
-0.34060439467430115,
-0.5948356986045837,
0.4434281289577484,
-0.7591982483863831,
-0.865460216999054,
1.1326661109924316,
-0.11439324170351028,
-0.6563580632209778,
0.019132139161229134,
-0.2142617404460907,
-0.24093514680862427,
-0.30911022424697876,
0.835273027420044,
0.6331636905670166,
-0.0339396595954895,
-0.06922873854637146,
-0.4628101587295532,
0.24668817222118378,
0.20716150104999542,
-0.7023322582244873,
-0.22006754577159882,
0.3422706723213196,
0.5612530708312988,
-0.0853029116988182,
0.20525367558002472,
-0.624116837978363,
0.4849291443824768,
-0.1082504615187645,
-0.08794135600328445,
-0.46888554096221924,
-0.2686268091201782,
-0.21508830785751343,
0.2929805517196655,
0.039460185915231705,
-0.02371727116405964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13846v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13846v1
|
Large Language Models are Advanced Anonymizers
| 2024-02-21T14:44:00 | 2024-02-21T14:44:00 |
Robin Staab, Mark Vero, Mislav Balunović, Martin Vechev
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, I.2.7
|
Recent work in privacy research on large language models has shown that they
achieve near human-level performance at inferring personal data from real-world
online texts. With consistently increasing model capabilities, existing text
anonymization methods are currently lacking behind regulatory requirements and
adversarial threats. This raises the question of how individuals can
effectively protect their personal data in sharing online texts. In this work,
we take two steps to answer this question: We first present a new setting for
evaluating anonymizations in the face of adversarial LLMs inferences, allowing
for a natural measurement of anonymization performance while remedying some of
the shortcomings of previous metrics. We then present our LLM-based adversarial
anonymization framework leveraging the strong inferential capabilities of LLMs
to inform our anonymization procedure. In our experimental evaluation, we show
on real-world and synthetic online texts how adversarial anonymization
outperforms current industry-grade anonymizers both in terms of the resulting
utility and privacy.
|
[
-0.25700029730796814,
-1.078028678894043,
0.56791752576828,
0.1380425989627838,
-0.02925831638276577,
0.33474206924438477,
-0.41250336170196533,
-0.7738693356513977,
-0.02653358317911625,
0.8414956331253052,
-0.40606415271759033,
-0.5749952793121338,
-0.8052192330360413,
0.1055663526058197,
-0.7054265737533569,
0.8677091002464294,
0.23522982001304626,
0.12996059656143188,
-0.3102290630340576,
0.066996730864048,
0.1560937911272049,
-1.0353080034255981,
-0.6347076296806335,
-0.1791297197341919,
0.5747064352035522,
-0.13696199655532837,
1.030533790588379,
1.0297014713287354,
0.5497415661811829,
0.3553464412689209,
-0.43855470418930054,
0.15300379693508148,
-0.8326025009155273,
0.19605079293251038,
-0.19158627092838287,
-0.5128060579299927,
-0.1704072505235672,
-0.023067526519298553,
0.6741019487380981,
0.2932990491390228,
-0.08409905433654785,
-0.029601385816931725,
-0.010822451673448086,
0.4487232565879822,
-0.8301969170570374,
-0.2505766749382019,
-0.6331252455711365,
0.1809818595647812,
-0.5681899785995483,
-0.10416816920042038,
-0.5008865594863892,
-0.6174954175949097,
0.18912582099437714,
-0.5084626078605652,
0.15139734745025635,
0.26537588238716125,
0.9813584685325623,
0.12042340636253357,
-0.3840199410915375,
-0.5498122572898865,
-0.8846739530563354,
0.6514968872070312,
-0.8335209488868713,
0.19713512063026428,
0.6054650545120239,
0.5048794150352478,
-0.23141655325889587,
-0.769748330116272,
-0.3974282741546631,
-0.40750643610954285,
-0.14396417140960693,
-0.1441553384065628,
-0.334753155708313,
0.13997822999954224,
0.18734394013881683,
0.5191062688827515,
-0.379521906375885,
0.43900179862976074,
-0.06727668642997742,
-0.1940733641386032,
0.8787788152694702,
0.13595065474510193,
0.27741047739982605,
0.3031459152698517,
-0.66265869140625,
0.10294636338949203,
-0.7761673331260681,
-0.2515086233615875,
1.069164514541626,
0.10980121046304703,
-0.09440361708402634,
0.5698971152305603,
-0.06179416552186012,
0.5018318891525269,
-0.09416233003139496,
-0.04738561436533928,
-0.12445459514856339,
-0.15367037057876587,
-0.12725751101970673,
-0.13347706198692322,
1.0479416847229004,
0.012552736327052116,
0.4265424311161041,
-0.6641439199447632,
-0.12201838940382004,
-0.045551661401987076,
0.27288225293159485,
-0.8384318351745605,
-0.1963525116443634,
0.009583618491888046,
-0.3449456989765167,
-0.3602237403392792,
0.02450624480843544,
-0.7971630096435547,
-1.042366623878479,
-0.10910580307245255,
0.5962120890617371,
-0.12368570268154144,
0.09675557911396027,
0.09506301581859589,
0.09234350919723511,
-0.22707639634609222,
0.13819798827171326,
-0.9697449803352356,
0.7345689535140991,
0.864700973033905,
0.726257860660553,
-0.23723898828029633,
-0.32486388087272644,
-0.3739447593688965,
0.06976703554391861,
-0.26619237661361694,
0.44286027550697327,
-0.4396318197250366,
-0.28388097882270813,
0.15382836759090424,
-0.16354550421237946,
0.004617696162313223,
-0.5661429166793823,
0.2532927989959717,
-0.7548515796661377,
0.33624202013015747,
-0.09791652858257294,
-0.9307602643966675,
-0.29455941915512085,
0.32229408621788025,
-0.6164491176605225,
0.5534811019897461,
-0.348378986120224,
-1.0576497316360474,
-0.07649722695350647,
-0.42992159724235535,
-0.5096181631088257,
-0.0252832043915987,
0.03991831839084625,
-0.5220736861228943,
0.08236739784479141,
0.11856964230537415,
0.6105337142944336,
-0.4120543301105499,
0.05809265002608299,
-0.7524718642234802,
-0.40450602769851685,
0.7802653312683105,
-0.7765650749206543,
0.9170563817024231,
0.2146686464548111,
-0.18940682709217072,
0.15073780715465546,
-0.6078650951385498,
-0.2263609766960144,
0.1299077421426773,
-0.3406565189361572,
-0.2603171467781067,
0.15575964748859406,
-0.1975342333316803,
-0.18161438405513763,
0.5431665778160095,
-0.7309980392456055,
-0.03074546903371811,
-0.7103888392448425,
0.5179473161697388,
0.6979464292526245,
0.10165427625179291,
0.49528253078460693,
-0.23216058313846588,
0.6396352052688599,
-0.35084959864616394,
0.1493540108203888,
-0.0029280842281877995,
-0.25351399183273315,
-0.585238516330719,
-0.5647155046463013,
0.4593851864337921,
0.5402565598487854,
-0.35193750262260437,
0.19894249737262726,
-0.14722928404808044,
-0.46827223896980286,
-0.5431249141693115,
0.22731617093086243,
0.7321021556854248,
0.23204290866851807,
0.10062862932682037,
-0.07238419353961945,
-0.44404318928718567,
-1.0452297925949097,
-0.5823081135749817,
0.14631423354148865,
-0.2808481752872467,
0.5586472153663635,
0.192582368850708,
-0.26646867394447327,
0.7656190395355225,
-0.4825308620929718,
-0.215289905667305,
-0.10756579786539078,
-0.07231952250003815,
-0.12585708498954773,
0.09948785603046417,
0.38160935044288635,
-0.7280213236808777,
-0.5167633295059204,
-0.19406719505786896,
-0.8714112639427185,
0.007125402335077524,
-0.030790630728006363,
-0.1820066273212433,
-0.14924192428588867,
0.33790290355682373,
-0.5665000081062317,
0.3046942353248596,
0.7788740992546082,
-0.5891895890235901,
0.19939717650413513,
-0.521870493888855,
-0.07367715984582901,
-0.8772479891777039,
-0.1214694157242775,
-0.0033320735674351454,
-0.6439208388328552,
-0.8930040001869202,
0.3079972565174103,
-0.021997347474098206,
-0.025318622589111328,
-0.6570631265640259,
0.7398662567138672,
-0.4740719497203827,
-0.16284815967082977,
-0.3373907506465912,
-0.0727686807513237,
-0.04083500802516937,
0.04928967356681824,
-0.2290954291820526,
0.6504837274551392,
0.701623797416687,
-0.5703418254852295,
0.371227890253067,
0.1981038898229599,
-0.3624211847782135,
0.28411734104156494,
-0.4493756890296936,
0.3214389681816101,
-0.08375079184770584,
0.2341533601284027,
-0.7287759780883789,
-0.39308813214302063,
0.1876145750284195,
-0.4983328580856323,
0.3176775276660919,
-0.007012688089162111,
-0.807510256767273,
-0.00863412581384182,
-0.36402255296707153,
0.15811491012573242,
0.30880600214004517,
-0.9407035112380981,
0.5970900058746338,
0.5608581900596619,
0.013822066597640514,
-0.5184763669967651,
-0.6936590075492859,
0.7523213624954224,
-0.4589070677757263,
-0.7030552625656128,
0.4069582521915436,
-0.1788371354341507,
-0.5331029891967773,
0.05858996883034706,
0.30809077620506287,
-0.5351375937461853,
0.5966573357582092,
0.2844982445240021,
0.02694651670753956,
0.09305644035339355,
-0.16133829951286316,
-0.4635660946369171,
-0.03091548942029476,
0.18155591189861298,
0.10299629718065262,
0.48792025446891785,
-0.02606058493256569,
-0.11853016167879105,
-0.6467273831367493,
0.2739812731742859,
0.38624969124794006,
-0.19606639444828033,
1.0479947328567505,
0.42204907536506653,
-0.577063262462616,
-0.28227710723876953,
-0.7809273600578308,
-0.0929700955748558,
-0.5162541270256042,
0.2913183271884918,
-0.025814231485128403,
-0.8930644989013672,
0.4425288438796997,
0.15286247432231903,
0.15899159014225006,
0.015503842383623123,
0.5769849419593811,
0.02218022570014,
1.0048476457595825,
0.49553340673446655,
-0.20944373309612274,
0.22845053672790527,
0.16713006794452667,
0.2782815396785736,
-0.5579680800437927,
-0.16627725958824158,
-0.29482513666152954,
-0.15495547652244568,
-0.6224498152732849,
-0.15589745342731476,
0.02882603369653225,
0.03538059815764427,
-0.28600528836250305,
0.33851614594459534,
-0.09561708569526672,
0.6999533176422119,
0.5774440765380859,
0.36812248826026917,
0.3594117760658264,
0.0066689965315163136,
0.37097039818763733,
-0.09770635515451431,
-0.3102840483188629,
-0.7229474186897278,
1.0939565896987915,
0.734855592250824,
0.9224171042442322,
0.34073805809020996,
0.6526190638542175,
0.5189661979675293,
0.550065279006958,
-0.5529693365097046,
0.6199326515197754,
-0.6165722608566284,
-0.8780168294906616,
-0.155621737241745,
-0.6564671397209167,
-0.8896954655647278,
0.4647639989852905,
-0.38260456919670105,
-1.0625394582748413,
-0.2811886966228485,
0.21307440102100372,
-0.3549037575721741,
0.4693407118320465,
-0.5267765522003174,
0.6202136874198914,
-0.406369149684906,
-0.6795910596847534,
-0.004977238364517689,
-0.5682615041732788,
0.5519369840621948,
-0.2109583467245102,
0.40298593044281006,
-0.030175141990184784,
-0.24608063697814941,
0.5701124668121338,
-0.29077965021133423,
1.0301791429519653,
0.03660186007618904,
0.018265321850776672,
0.08343609422445297,
0.10511738061904907,
0.6290113925933838,
0.08809811621904373,
-0.1760571300983429,
0.2990339994430542,
-0.26092565059661865,
-0.18090195953845978,
-0.4282756745815277,
0.9280299544334412,
-0.5834483504295349,
-0.5926722884178162,
-0.2776762843132019,
-0.40235957503318787,
-0.15109583735466003,
0.21973350644111633,
0.3895857632160187,
0.20138439536094666,
-0.3140692412853241,
0.6214450001716614,
0.7239797711372375,
-0.42361462116241455,
0.49701130390167236,
0.6199265122413635,
0.1313839554786682,
-0.6127207279205322,
0.8491302132606506,
-0.07074474543333054,
0.2125556617975235,
0.4987622797489166,
0.688256025314331,
-0.7354522943496704,
-0.5838520526885986,
-0.5557205080986023,
0.20860445499420166,
-0.8058338165283203,
-0.09877133369445801,
-0.7945717573165894,
-0.23526416718959808,
-0.10074163228273392,
-0.25476425886154175,
-0.4191837012767792,
-0.2562326490879059,
-0.3492472767829895,
-0.0384623184800148,
0.124895378947258,
1.0608220100402832,
0.172621950507164,
0.26529425382614136,
-0.6026625037193298,
0.3628942668437958,
0.1546677052974701,
0.12436449527740479,
0.08387351781129837,
-0.4632403254508972,
-0.05896255373954773,
-0.05589819699525833,
-0.0712483748793602,
-0.835465133190155,
0.4567849636077881,
0.12822727859020233,
0.49384161829948425,
0.3228410482406616,
0.13875417411327362,
0.4802689850330353,
-0.48821282386779785,
0.7590702772140503,
0.10731140524148941,
-0.8016258478164673,
-0.03883986920118332,
-0.292667955160141,
-0.024118361994624138,
0.40590065717697144,
0.16499517858028412,
-0.240837961435318,
-0.590914249420166,
-0.5633596181869507,
-0.9487277865409851,
0.4425566792488098,
0.4697292149066925,
0.3980328142642975,
0.17676953971385956,
0.35403260588645935,
-0.12514054775238037,
0.4260660409927368,
-1.0566740036010742,
-0.36045435070991516,
0.12778982520103455,
-0.19875751435756683,
-0.21516655385494232,
-0.27195486426353455,
-0.3525044322013855,
0.28865647315979004,
0.43834567070007324,
0.36150357127189636,
-0.07270839810371399,
-0.13889308273792267,
-0.037863198667764664,
0.1968262493610382,
0.2019861936569214,
0.5061259865760803,
0.42039862275123596,
0.13834349811077118,
0.4173787236213684,
0.28287190198898315,
-0.25312677025794983,
0.20616514980793,
0.2555496394634247,
-0.45008790493011475,
-0.16783572733402252,
0.4241597056388855,
0.6011477708816528,
0.15702694654464722,
-0.6194054484367371,
0.7315071225166321,
-0.3389070928096771,
-0.07403798401355743,
-0.4657716453075409,
0.18744483590126038,
0.26641252636909485,
0.22269397974014282,
0.09120436012744904,
-0.24252797663211823,
0.156228706240654,
-0.3344069719314575,
0.1809048056602478,
0.5552961826324463,
-0.09609274566173553,
-0.2671341001987457,
0.9145377278327942,
0.07611178606748581,
-0.6551966667175293,
0.07902545481920242,
-0.2003372758626938,
-0.6808579564094543,
0.5722843408584595,
0.5959567427635193,
0.9954709410667419,
-0.27898335456848145,
-0.15297527611255646,
0.17333564162254333,
0.1568448841571808,
-0.3523837625980377,
-0.16306757926940918,
0.1246383786201477,
-0.4424557387828827,
0.034973789006471634,
-0.520844042301178,
-0.6196052432060242,
0.2979142963886261,
-0.5242841243743896,
0.045965127646923065,
-0.8818191289901733,
-0.07320695370435715,
0.053887058049440384,
0.03667275235056877,
-0.4593726396560669,
0.33475959300994873,
0.29357922077178955,
0.5081914067268372,
-0.3968815207481384,
0.5779032707214355,
0.41801247000694275,
0.23558534681797028,
-0.3148680329322815,
0.18564088642597198,
0.341525673866272,
-0.70761638879776,
0.349641889333725,
0.26695749163627625,
-0.24362650513648987,
-0.08688218891620636,
-0.270244836807251,
-0.8319658637046814,
0.9182927012443542,
0.5524063110351562,
-0.6516169905662537,
0.15612973272800446,
0.23550161719322205,
0.8270193934440613,
-0.31334277987480164,
0.05414913222193718,
0.3399180769920349,
0.2992623448371887,
-0.18221721053123474,
-0.518485426902771,
0.15818306803703308,
0.15984037518501282,
-0.07515918463468552,
0.09853489696979523,
-0.6609120965003967,
0.7190849184989929,
-0.022024741396307945,
-0.474597305059433,
0.29052436351776123,
0.5045195817947388,
-0.10726209729909897,
0.25334715843200684,
0.36501580476760864,
0.37879449129104614,
0.8010162711143494,
0.18240611255168915,
1.4104162454605103,
-0.39763760566711426,
0.32848840951919556,
1.3012523651123047,
-0.20325294137001038,
0.9183427095413208,
0.06267524510622025,
-0.09009743481874466,
0.06349410861730576,
0.5641753077507019,
-0.14724329113960266,
0.4568500220775604,
0.6138899326324463,
-0.7163640260696411,
-0.20403753221035004,
-0.1353737711906433,
-0.18147556483745575,
0.39237046241760254,
0.25975537300109863,
-0.6079970002174377,
-0.10454969853162766,
-0.12315750867128372,
0.4456107020378113,
0.5686393976211548,
-0.041704803705215454,
0.8010417819023132,
0.046823062002658844,
-0.49333852529525757,
0.3917641043663025,
0.34960371255874634,
0.6940867304801941,
-0.6326025724411011,
0.329789936542511,
-0.0033028083853423595,
0.6451058387756348,
-0.03745884820818901,
-0.5545125007629395,
0.20840784907341003,
0.38024160265922546,
0.09636731445789337,
-0.25024330615997314,
0.6467442512512207,
-0.4068481922149658,
-0.3545567989349365,
0.5222404599189758,
0.0023363912478089333,
0.10384271293878555,
0.0062441774643957615,
-0.560521125793457,
0.033793214708566666,
-0.20470216870307922,
-0.5799885988235474,
0.6262747049331665,
0.019854910671710968,
0.29066917300224304,
0.9993962049484253,
0.6007278561592102,
0.15595056116580963,
0.05883774161338806,
0.0902625322341919,
0.7183849215507507,
-0.5228617787361145,
-0.71946120262146,
-1.3496570587158203,
0.039614204317331314,
-0.30167356133461,
-0.3523508310317993,
1.2358310222625732,
0.7067526578903198,
0.7089897990226746,
0.20529745519161224,
0.8471397757530212,
0.3679341971874237,
0.7381489872932434,
-0.6248871088027954,
0.9170335531234741,
-0.31077927350997925,
0.7068803310394287,
0.21041186153888702,
-0.6582890748977661,
-0.3919065296649933,
0.4076111316680908,
-0.24439337849617004,
-0.28733399510383606,
0.2341468632221222,
0.8312518000602722,
0.0839899331331253,
-0.08861148357391357,
0.5203742384910583,
0.3837682604789734,
0.5017504692077637,
0.4623773396015167,
0.9866074919700623,
-0.2064788043498993,
0.5230771899223328,
-0.4606251120567322,
-0.14361052215099335,
0.05675041675567627,
-0.9492799639701843,
-1.4134804010391235,
0.1669374257326126,
-0.1517896056175232,
-0.3873569071292877,
0.29247209429740906,
0.6081645488739014,
0.7334277629852295,
-0.5927140712738037,
-0.30401408672332764,
-0.10236401110887527,
-0.170229971408844,
0.24107353389263153,
-0.16349565982818604,
0.2173304557800293,
0.13240262866020203,
-0.8694261312484741,
0.6429301500320435,
0.1406778246164322,
0.3440896272659302,
-0.6178889274597168,
-0.14004634320735931,
0.06294713914394379,
0.4389820396900177,
0.4022385776042938,
0.25728508830070496,
-0.87924724817276,
-0.2164154052734375,
-0.1448337733745575,
-0.3301273584365845,
-0.16843640804290771,
0.7274460196495056,
-0.28704506158828735,
0.6901249885559082,
0.4491185247898102,
1.0419626235961914,
0.39873284101486206,
0.41299793124198914,
0.6337507367134094,
-0.7421481609344482,
-0.046562399715185165,
0.35828086733818054,
0.3365936279296875,
0.5474607944488525,
-0.7128723859786987,
0.30230826139450073,
-0.09549632668495178,
-0.5467289090156555,
-0.8717864751815796,
0.18310756981372833,
-0.3637682795524597,
-0.38536015152931213,
1.3804844617843628,
-0.628149688243866,
0.028848053887486458,
-0.13644807040691376,
0.007858578115701675,
-0.021188339218497276,
-0.17546847462654114,
0.9639488458633423,
0.7648979425430298,
0.2300480604171753,
0.13954108953475952,
-0.66813725233078,
0.4169727563858032,
0.1290673464536667,
-0.9722012877464294,
0.34773531556129456,
0.15807035565376282,
0.30626028776168823,
-0.19221344590187073,
0.49076420068740845,
-0.10883263498544693,
-0.1653507649898529,
-0.09800191223621368,
-0.45285898447036743,
-0.27067312598228455,
-0.405518114566803,
-0.5141239762306213,
0.3410794138908386,
-0.0008852991159074008,
-0.20331092178821564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13818v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13818v1
|
Beyond Hate Speech: NLP's Challenges and Opportunities in Uncovering Dehumanizing Language
| 2024-02-21T13:57:36 | 2024-02-21T13:57:36 |
Hezhao Zhang, Lasana Harris, Nafise Sadat Moosavi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dehumanization, characterized as a subtle yet harmful manifestation of hate
speech, involves denying individuals of their human qualities and often results
in violence against marginalized groups. Despite significant progress in
Natural Language Processing across various domains, its application in
detecting dehumanizing language is limited, largely due to the scarcity of
publicly available annotated data for this domain. This paper evaluates the
performance of cutting-edge NLP models, including GPT-4, GPT-3.5, and LLAMA-2,
in identifying dehumanizing language. Our findings reveal that while these
models demonstrate potential, achieving a 70\% accuracy rate in distinguishing
dehumanizing language from broader hate speech, they also display biases. They
are over-sensitive in classifying other forms of hate speech as dehumanization
for a specific subset of target groups, while more frequently failing to
identify clear cases of dehumanization for other target groups. Moreover,
leveraging one of the best-performing models, we automatically annotated a
larger dataset for training more accessible models. However, our findings
indicate that these models currently do not meet the high-quality data
generation threshold necessary for this task.
|
[
-0.3389744460582733,
-0.8831876516342163,
0.24761039018630981,
0.15568414330482483,
-0.00445396127179265,
0.2088172733783722,
-0.2812553942203522,
-0.9253045320510864,
-0.1750427633523941,
0.2545231580734253,
-0.4090324342250824,
-0.5491885542869568,
-1.1340974569320679,
0.22799614071846008,
-0.5466744303703308,
0.9649055004119873,
0.3845432698726654,
-0.34359413385391235,
0.19002993404865265,
-0.17418889701366425,
-0.31094178557395935,
-0.8522648811340332,
-0.3650417923927307,
-0.362588107585907,
0.39377784729003906,
0.24512137472629547,
0.9403108954429626,
0.49450093507766724,
0.45835843682289124,
0.22321490943431854,
-0.357551246881485,
-0.174440398812294,
-0.40601131319999695,
0.31495699286460876,
-0.16489121317863464,
-0.20178568363189697,
-0.22374644875526428,
0.37391942739486694,
0.389314204454422,
0.5289454460144043,
-0.020046653226017952,
0.04335872083902359,
-0.06464987248182297,
0.43393969535827637,
-0.42084890604019165,
-0.06069546192884445,
-0.8699302673339844,
0.13844424486160278,
-0.3956342935562134,
0.3610439598560333,
-0.036008529365062714,
-0.404055655002594,
0.15657298266887665,
-0.24966216087341309,
0.212162047624588,
-0.24134261906147003,
0.5740147829055786,
0.5901696085929871,
-0.10182615369558334,
-0.3879787027835846,
-0.8101938962936401,
0.8315659761428833,
-0.9426892399787903,
0.3105297386646271,
0.8159439563751221,
0.1088460236787796,
0.10990220308303833,
-0.34052035212516785,
-0.6783728003501892,
-0.6387391686439514,
0.010189732536673546,
-0.1823861300945282,
-0.5224043726921082,
-0.0403655581176281,
0.4656401574611664,
0.3070297837257385,
-0.5853661298751831,
0.6864665746688843,
-0.3345271944999695,
-0.03039376251399517,
0.7132680416107178,
0.019086692482233047,
0.26496621966362,
-0.3759506642818451,
-0.2973231077194214,
0.19723254442214966,
-0.23446816205978394,
-0.36258837580680847,
0.5852994322776794,
0.5028402805328369,
0.15779364109039307,
0.45603859424591064,
-0.25732532143592834,
0.5130710601806641,
-0.45830732583999634,
-0.10476627200841904,
0.2965702712535858,
0.07642626762390137,
-0.13973930478096008,
-0.19488346576690674,
0.4042951166629791,
0.37832412123680115,
0.24269084632396698,
-0.30139485001564026,
-0.0782855898141861,
0.5937392115592957,
0.3025638163089752,
-0.7105989456176758,
-0.3592110276222229,
0.056091658771038055,
-0.1761762648820877,
-0.35131093859672546,
-0.6184079647064209,
-0.8982358574867249,
-0.810716450214386,
-0.3068543076515198,
0.0724734291434288,
-0.3029519319534302,
-0.5311425924301147,
-0.018365368247032166,
-0.22752395272254944,
0.012902175076305866,
0.3529040217399597,
-0.8583621382713318,
0.28882673382759094,
0.7427918314933777,
0.9026395082473755,
-0.41626328229904175,
0.04096169397234917,
-0.2772178053855896,
-0.1433442085981369,
-0.06449128687381744,
0.5506871938705444,
-0.8968567848205566,
-0.10395457595586777,
-0.10627356171607971,
-0.33452484011650085,
0.13241015374660492,
-0.7471522092819214,
0.8972117900848389,
-0.32402294874191284,
-0.08151233196258545,
-0.14171963930130005,
-0.44015589356422424,
-0.3581961393356323,
0.36620980501174927,
-0.5094982981681824,
1.1299903392791748,
0.3513270616531372,
-0.8254930973052979,
0.29862597584724426,
-0.566748857498169,
-0.12294446676969528,
0.31334641575813293,
-0.0367363877594471,
-0.484399676322937,
0.14789803326129913,
-0.06370318681001663,
0.41741710901260376,
-0.3235234320163727,
0.5008836984634399,
-0.42696264386177063,
-0.20314529538154602,
0.019579991698265076,
-0.458779901266098,
0.7717351317405701,
0.2117234766483307,
-0.8343499898910522,
-0.10131940990686417,
-0.8955326676368713,
-0.28565797209739685,
0.3994380533695221,
-0.20881672203540802,
-0.4261057376861572,
0.025340290740132332,
0.2982023060321808,
0.5608752965927124,
-0.18266955018043518,
-0.6421144008636475,
-0.11656797677278519,
-0.4318702518939972,
0.40536245703697205,
0.8064191341400146,
-0.6346964240074158,
0.04497328773140907,
-0.1625371128320694,
0.8347715139389038,
-0.20303863286972046,
0.04569563642144203,
0.4488689601421356,
-0.8309168219566345,
-0.42391282320022583,
-0.18704457581043243,
0.1052921861410141,
0.7519994378089905,
-0.20484192669391632,
0.2635599374771118,
0.11737246066331863,
-0.7115085124969482,
-0.4251043498516083,
-0.002281991997733712,
0.3815251290798187,
0.6844913363456726,
0.6200554966926575,
-0.11818650364875793,
-0.8217851519584656,
-1.05961275100708,
-0.26113778352737427,
-0.2819274365901947,
0.016095757484436035,
0.09430679678916931,
0.5931599736213684,
-0.506080687046051,
0.7555914521217346,
-0.2508862316608429,
-0.23636098206043243,
-0.3423027992248535,
0.18076834082603455,
-0.1484401375055313,
0.3627511262893677,
0.4670311212539673,
-0.8431790471076965,
-0.25463584065437317,
-0.1308334618806839,
-0.5710064172744751,
-0.42781102657318115,
0.4371396601200104,
0.2078305035829544,
0.07991337776184082,
0.21932493150234222,
-0.21546736359596252,
0.6406332850456238,
0.8148138523101807,
-0.09396789222955704,
0.551185131072998,
0.3149990141391754,
-0.08419708162546158,
-0.5382350087165833,
0.02600484900176525,
0.060360878705978394,
-0.08423422276973724,
-0.9526282548904419,
-0.12435824424028397,
-0.4212481677532196,
-0.20877119898796082,
-0.342071533203125,
0.2710716128349304,
-0.1687173992395401,
0.0903245285153389,
-0.42999792098999023,
0.39875033497810364,
-0.3034040033817291,
0.3441448509693146,
0.2908729612827301,
0.37718284130096436,
0.31503650546073914,
-0.47129496932029724,
0.40603262186050415,
0.4002503752708435,
-0.2826753556728363,
0.24165946245193481,
-0.4302976429462433,
0.28281959891319275,
-0.27509167790412903,
0.2215425670146942,
-0.6095911264419556,
-0.1478266566991806,
0.5920132398605347,
-0.14370761811733246,
0.040352962911129,
-0.25913098454475403,
-0.4917157292366028,
-0.41311609745025635,
-0.3937789797782898,
0.6052811145782471,
0.3262694180011749,
-0.27110400795936584,
0.19276423752307892,
0.7321937680244446,
-0.29436174035072327,
-0.7238998413085938,
-0.7331033945083618,
0.3356606960296631,
-0.6308703422546387,
-0.2979636490345001,
0.4447038769721985,
0.012073160149157047,
-0.5244565606117249,
-0.44485121965408325,
0.06441774219274521,
-0.0683874860405922,
0.49791717529296875,
0.37647080421447754,
-0.12653689086437225,
0.071504607796669,
0.3402930200099945,
-0.15821923315525055,
-0.074335016310215,
0.04937855154275894,
0.05290669575333595,
0.5138652920722961,
-0.0056350212544202805,
-0.10814373195171356,
-0.41137006878852844,
0.5746358633041382,
0.31325921416282654,
-0.021156925708055496,
0.5827994346618652,
0.5747703313827515,
-0.7227867245674133,
-0.15155428647994995,
-0.6497088074684143,
0.012632399797439575,
-0.3362271189689636,
0.5807720422744751,
-0.022469857707619667,
-0.9792300462722778,
0.38936948776245117,
-0.014554212801158428,
-0.2177991271018982,
0.39279383420944214,
0.5624942779541016,
0.36586952209472656,
0.8583351373672485,
0.786174476146698,
-0.13364280760288239,
0.4712972939014435,
0.1097337156534195,
0.42220839858055115,
-0.6974911689758301,
-0.3240659236907959,
-0.859113872051239,
-0.22420042753219604,
-0.7395421266555786,
-0.4833172559738159,
0.128599613904953,
0.15779022872447968,
-0.06944771111011505,
0.5340577363967896,
-0.7657665610313416,
0.26257064938545227,
0.4809964895248413,
-0.128386452794075,
0.523614764213562,
-0.09191428124904633,
0.36503317952156067,
-0.37800756096839905,
-0.334843248128891,
-0.8455170392990112,
0.9488579034805298,
0.7036529183387756,
0.34945327043533325,
0.1605924516916275,
0.40623825788497925,
0.4344809651374817,
0.6515270471572876,
-0.676105260848999,
0.3115566670894623,
-0.12141413986682892,
-0.8951026201248169,
-0.27769574522972107,
-0.32978612184524536,
-0.6203320622444153,
0.32567328214645386,
-0.02894105203449726,
-0.9809073805809021,
0.09455769509077072,
0.1985144317150116,
-0.27465447783470154,
0.49335822463035583,
-0.40035849809646606,
0.8357532024383545,
-0.202120840549469,
-0.045697372406721115,
-0.22644807398319244,
-0.6452423334121704,
0.4910905361175537,
-0.3647652268409729,
0.3791675567626953,
-0.6782200336456299,
0.009519936516880989,
0.8606899380683899,
-0.027915406972169876,
0.8664833307266235,
-0.3505459725856781,
-0.5922195315361023,
0.08065738528966904,
-0.029113227501511574,
0.2802104949951172,
-0.03225721791386604,
-0.3904900848865509,
0.531093180179596,
-0.4299899637699127,
-0.1498916745185852,
-0.35266628861427307,
0.427634060382843,
-0.41308531165122986,
-0.6945828795433044,
-0.3306279480457306,
-0.5192105770111084,
-0.25931450724601746,
-0.04453752189874649,
0.13203413784503937,
0.03806130215525627,
-0.2341734766960144,
-0.18489669263362885,
0.427282452583313,
-0.6070823669433594,
0.35547545552253723,
0.27115586400032043,
-0.23263615369796753,
-0.18532681465148926,
0.8475369215011597,
0.15040190517902374,
0.15847980976104736,
0.11942453682422638,
0.24372760951519012,
-0.3455072045326233,
-0.8499881625175476,
-0.3563314378261566,
0.11310181766748428,
-0.60628342628479,
-0.25857704877853394,
-1.068922519683838,
0.0559256486594677,
-0.5541603565216064,
0.08938614279031754,
-0.16527026891708374,
-0.5982543230056763,
-0.34480100870132446,
-0.23292091488838196,
0.36814919114112854,
0.8346711993217468,
-0.5249313116073608,
0.21702420711517334,
-0.46035999059677124,
0.5309075117111206,
0.2975876033306122,
0.2540319263935089,
-0.08830644935369492,
-0.8281989097595215,
0.020002860575914383,
0.0650697723031044,
-0.31185799837112427,
-1.0783870220184326,
0.5308951139450073,
0.058535728603601456,
0.2432369440793991,
0.09020312130451202,
0.15193942189216614,
0.5153393149375916,
-0.39105719327926636,
0.6610233187675476,
-0.11539104580879211,
-0.9243972301483154,
0.7903876900672913,
-0.1758059710264206,
-0.09144843369722366,
0.5064959526062012,
0.6995099186897278,
-0.7036482095718384,
-0.7063156962394714,
-0.6617736220359802,
-0.9539979100227356,
0.7994255423545837,
0.31384706497192383,
0.23834913969039917,
-0.22150135040283203,
0.09889158606529236,
0.3274187743663788,
0.33992037177085876,
-0.9744713306427002,
-0.3080381751060486,
-0.22615793347358704,
0.12357813864946365,
-0.040084537118673325,
-0.4135586619377136,
-0.05537034571170807,
-0.3768457770347595,
0.6365534067153931,
0.0908377394080162,
0.06505538523197174,
-0.019475115463137627,
-0.2102764993906021,
-0.0023770914413034916,
0.3160906136035919,
0.750089704990387,
0.5456211566925049,
-0.1770896017551422,
-0.02047002501785755,
0.10079392045736313,
-0.3777594268321991,
0.0770154669880867,
0.520125687122345,
-0.14133445918560028,
0.12729386985301971,
0.2219356745481491,
0.6600313782691956,
-0.18409793078899384,
-0.9099506139755249,
0.5854349732398987,
0.22617283463478088,
0.033622805029153824,
-0.35905149579048157,
-0.057054758071899414,
-0.19301442801952362,
0.38890984654426575,
0.3651111423969269,
0.015981700271368027,
0.4005175232887268,
-0.2831648588180542,
0.1739567667245865,
0.5640884637832642,
-0.2285488396883011,
-0.4308926463127136,
0.8605862855911255,
0.009803902357816696,
-0.282745361328125,
0.5554713606834412,
-0.17587324976921082,
-0.8505234122276306,
0.38290461897850037,
0.6078690886497498,
0.8663621544837952,
-0.38060352206230164,
0.3938070833683014,
0.3008217513561249,
0.4877241253852844,
0.25228768587112427,
-0.1469527781009674,
-0.22184962034225464,
-0.7036517858505249,
-0.4225076735019684,
-0.8558772206306458,
-0.37770983576774597,
0.3891756236553192,
-0.5226141810417175,
-0.05077138915657997,
-0.43530938029289246,
-0.21425209939479828,
0.1341087967157364,
-0.13927216827869415,
-0.5456342101097107,
0.23756814002990723,
0.8018503189086914,
0.6289102435112,
-1.0219756364822388,
0.5247796177864075,
0.19728891551494598,
-0.2520613372325897,
-0.3676180839538574,
-0.033782266080379486,
0.1994755119085312,
-0.6710134744644165,
0.9263396859169006,
0.5535866022109985,
-0.2166491448879242,
-0.1336359977722168,
-0.5037941336631775,
-0.6730475425720215,
0.4044533371925354,
0.5140610337257385,
-0.4884219765663147,
-0.14200273156166077,
0.4165063500404358,
0.6841856241226196,
-0.1284535676240921,
0.1668219268321991,
0.9994975924491882,
0.550792396068573,
-0.3033222258090973,
-1.006652593612671,
0.11027653515338898,
-0.07948647439479828,
0.1461143046617508,
0.005925794597715139,
-0.3838110566139221,
0.653135359287262,
-0.10150468349456787,
-0.408364474773407,
-0.16255147755146027,
0.4447192847728729,
0.04371576011180878,
0.18644234538078308,
0.43955177068710327,
0.7548919916152954,
0.7436436414718628,
0.02008148282766342,
0.7781327366828918,
0.396757572889328,
0.10355119407176971,
1.0720573663711548,
-0.30280908942222595,
0.5632628798484802,
-0.01733464002609253,
-0.2213524430990219,
0.3110868036746979,
0.3148428797721863,
0.05647315829992294,
0.26220574975013733,
0.688378632068634,
-0.4580281376838684,
-0.1356339007616043,
-0.531512975692749,
-0.34432703256607056,
0.6918798685073853,
0.5171142220497131,
-0.2953587770462036,
-0.3993664085865021,
0.36008569598197937,
0.11038532108068466,
0.27854758501052856,
-0.0954938679933548,
0.6753317713737488,
-0.0006278242217376828,
-0.24124114215373993,
0.7368403077125549,
0.18453288078308105,
1.0351262092590332,
-0.22844929993152618,
-0.16947601735591888,
-0.018439924344420433,
-0.11703392118215561,
-0.2498227208852768,
-0.3824262320995331,
0.7521222233772278,
0.35233885049819946,
-0.19032883644104004,
-0.3212577700614929,
0.5926978588104248,
-0.3396638333797455,
-0.1684560626745224,
0.6781049966812134,
0.3567860424518585,
0.2621966600418091,
-0.43217235803604126,
-0.8354769349098206,
0.41740086674690247,
0.0025012390688061714,
-0.2334819883108139,
0.23329217731952667,
0.24668127298355103,
-0.04020119458436966,
0.7043169140815735,
0.4757133424282074,
0.013976847752928734,
0.18526527285575867,
0.21822048723697662,
0.7986092567443848,
-0.660223662853241,
-0.09463511407375336,
-0.9758888483047485,
0.3523056209087372,
0.006865006871521473,
-0.5119278430938721,
0.5647407174110413,
0.33095598220825195,
1.0386887788772583,
0.16577483713626862,
0.7874389290809631,
-0.12372972071170807,
0.9182472229003906,
-0.14966781437397003,
0.3517080247402191,
-0.31075388193130493,
0.09964430332183838,
-0.7260398864746094,
-0.7830580472946167,
-0.708142101764679,
0.7784491777420044,
-0.49150124192237854,
0.03757830336689949,
0.3040984570980072,
0.762370765209198,
0.25950130820274353,
0.3274265229701996,
0.556124746799469,
0.19901135563850403,
0.458901047706604,
0.35203880071640015,
1.1794583797454834,
-0.29502058029174805,
0.445409893989563,
-0.43863341212272644,
-0.338722288608551,
0.0534122958779335,
-0.843153715133667,
-0.7006561756134033,
-0.49609485268592834,
-0.493226021528244,
-0.14298665523529053,
-0.04559091106057167,
0.7797147631645203,
0.5138893127441406,
-0.6892686486244202,
0.1941089779138565,
-0.01011722069233656,
0.05395643413066864,
-0.04302317649126053,
-0.2808833718299866,
0.11248040944337845,
-0.08085595816373825,
-1.0076076984405518,
0.5072331428527832,
0.2212262898683548,
0.047786399722099304,
-0.14386466145515442,
0.20945428311824799,
-0.16997846961021423,
-0.17333823442459106,
0.8195523023605347,
0.26009848713874817,
-0.9276997447013855,
-0.16932332515716553,
-0.5118598937988281,
0.15907764434814453,
-0.032421134412288666,
0.6395262479782104,
-0.7734309434890747,
0.15168070793151855,
-0.011018790304660797,
0.8607361316680908,
0.17945222556591034,
0.05647419020533562,
0.21414190530776978,
-0.5995886325836182,
0.22051560878753662,
0.908921480178833,
-0.018382521346211433,
0.6440212726593018,
-0.29565170407295227,
0.5375542044639587,
0.30575594305992126,
-0.5076789855957031,
-1.079416275024414,
0.5584669709205627,
-0.5674777030944824,
-0.23778998851776123,
1.0391087532043457,
0.06882992386817932,
0.1706513911485672,
-0.5502204298973083,
-0.12446070462465286,
0.2360854148864746,
-0.2584632933139801,
0.9081397652626038,
0.540869414806366,
-0.08627841621637344,
-0.024970313534140587,
-0.7651149034500122,
0.8856371641159058,
0.5045069456100464,
-0.723850429058075,
0.5483854413032532,
0.8057345747947693,
-0.07158523052930832,
0.4061130881309509,
0.651057779788971,
-0.15749554336071014,
-0.09167249500751495,
-0.14214567840099335,
-0.0837361142039299,
0.13197338581085205,
-0.3659631311893463,
-0.5226820707321167,
0.3413880169391632,
0.03851216658949852,
0.11120543628931046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14871v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14871v1
|
LLM Based Multi-Agent Generation of Semi-structured Documents from Semantic Templates in the Public Administration Domain
| 2024-02-21T13:54:53 | 2024-02-21T13:54:53 |
Emanuele Musumeci, Michele Brienza, Vincenzo Suriani, Daniele Nardi, Domenico Daniele Bloisi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
In the last years' digitalization process, the creation and management of
documents in various domains, particularly in Public Administration (PA), have
become increasingly complex and diverse. This complexity arises from the need
to handle a wide range of document types, often characterized by
semi-structured forms. Semi-structured documents present a fixed set of data
without a fixed format. As a consequence, a template-based solution cannot be
used, as understanding a document requires the extraction of the data
structure. The recent introduction of Large Language Models (LLMs) has enabled
the creation of customized text output satisfying user requests. In this work,
we propose a novel approach that combines the LLMs with prompt engineering and
multi-agent systems for generating new documents compliant with a desired
structure. The main contribution of this work concerns replacing the commonly
used manual prompting with a task description generated by semantic retrieval
from an LLM. The potential of this approach is demonstrated through a series of
experiments and case studies, showcasing its effectiveness in real-world PA
scenarios.
|
[
-0.30741560459136963,
-0.779259443283081,
1.1599712371826172,
0.14570403099060059,
-0.11929196864366531,
0.09120336920022964,
-0.13635475933551788,
-0.1779722422361374,
0.456419974565506,
0.6510196328163147,
-0.6230506896972656,
-0.7864220142364502,
-0.43238818645477295,
0.5782692432403564,
-0.4430229663848877,
0.7234044075012207,
-0.11543039977550507,
-0.21555419266223907,
-0.2791469097137451,
0.2602889835834503,
-0.5949659943580627,
-0.5651710033416748,
-0.5146244764328003,
-0.4170970320701599,
0.44192376732826233,
0.43915697932243347,
0.521233320236206,
0.4746202528476715,
0.031049178913235664,
0.424476683139801,
-0.0630611851811409,
0.5531489253044128,
-0.23422610759735107,
0.3048197329044342,
-0.30200350284576416,
-0.3079991340637207,
-0.7163498997688293,
-0.040310122072696686,
0.8286789059638977,
0.21730664372444153,
-0.30561453104019165,
-0.14187553524971008,
-0.008476464077830315,
0.31287798285484314,
-0.5614511370658875,
0.566652238368988,
-0.7159944772720337,
-0.21160955727100372,
-0.17036059498786926,
-0.6269336938858032,
-0.4627493619918823,
-0.06950018554925919,
0.09272199124097824,
-0.8784352540969849,
0.01886296644806862,
-0.10959035158157349,
0.7037777900695801,
-0.0863221138715744,
-0.5835287570953369,
-0.6502693295478821,
-0.6892082691192627,
0.704918384552002,
-0.6496542692184448,
0.012351235374808311,
0.17924419045448303,
0.4529189467430115,
-0.5630744695663452,
-0.8414559364318848,
-0.8242323398590088,
-0.17710170149803162,
0.11909916251897812,
0.22082500159740448,
-0.09144029766321182,
0.08238349854946136,
-0.08204036951065063,
-0.11662934720516205,
-0.21135354042053223,
0.12687897682189941,
-0.24440665543079376,
-0.29921475052833557,
0.5711861848831177,
0.5774104595184326,
0.3675095736980438,
-0.48764848709106445,
-0.4994351863861084,
-0.08277975022792816,
-0.6197312474250793,
-0.223867729306221,
0.44594746828079224,
0.6726896166801453,
0.10518695414066315,
0.7706435322761536,
-0.22149015963077545,
0.6501340866088867,
-0.004459277726709843,
-0.33352774381637573,
-0.11907143890857697,
-0.454805850982666,
-0.1906069666147232,
0.12806260585784912,
0.5717648863792419,
0.1812746375799179,
0.13167327642440796,
-0.18474851548671722,
-0.6944137215614319,
0.04738881438970566,
0.41088515520095825,
-0.39197373390197754,
0.22002457082271576,
0.19968247413635254,
-0.35968777537345886,
-0.5271036028862,
0.11766953766345978,
-0.7469879984855652,
-0.5338383316993713,
-0.7898418307304382,
0.11223036795854568,
-0.23628774285316467,
-0.18017321825027466,
-0.007672433275729418,
-0.08730139583349228,
0.33347684144973755,
0.8987187743186951,
-0.48847222328186035,
0.12043194472789764,
0.6298359632492065,
0.7983670234680176,
-0.24720913171768188,
-0.34645959734916687,
-0.6434155702590942,
0.6876246333122253,
-0.1509944051504135,
1.0044798851013184,
-0.7669366002082825,
-0.5510208606719971,
0.42993518710136414,
-0.09627220034599304,
0.024341264739632607,
-0.41680091619491577,
0.44710150361061096,
-0.7220349907875061,
0.31131017208099365,
0.039597462862730026,
-0.4406917989253998,
0.2276971936225891,
0.7024562954902649,
-0.6185532808303833,
0.960601806640625,
0.19691181182861328,
-0.4338057339191437,
0.22538824379444122,
-0.6085748672485352,
-0.2438489943742752,
0.10934034734964371,
-0.3482997417449951,
-0.2610229551792145,
0.03901700675487518,
0.06683619320392609,
0.5480031967163086,
-0.5838758945465088,
0.44023919105529785,
-0.039912063628435135,
0.07626692950725555,
0.03896823152899742,
-0.08309081196784973,
0.44740864634513855,
0.22770513594150543,
-0.057519372552633286,
0.412700891494751,
-0.9684891700744629,
-0.04384459927678108,
0.22230003774166107,
-0.9076094627380371,
-0.2740556597709656,
-0.010067052207887173,
0.08840174973011017,
0.6322252750396729,
0.4869144558906555,
-0.4553055763244629,
0.3993428647518158,
-0.28082582354545593,
0.21915367245674133,
0.9498335719108582,
0.13138863444328308,
0.408168226480484,
-0.5617756247520447,
0.5749543905258179,
0.020869983360171318,
0.03111998364329338,
-0.19028128683567047,
-0.2609494626522064,
-0.40998247265815735,
-0.5017826557159424,
-0.1782791018486023,
0.38830867409706116,
-0.9135860204696655,
0.3871069848537445,
-0.32429373264312744,
-0.33353936672210693,
-0.22230732440948486,
0.06390728801488876,
0.17932671308517456,
0.6620868444442749,
0.17075367271900177,
-0.03305521234869957,
-0.27620741724967957,
-0.7971147894859314,
0.15823164582252502,
-0.17310650646686554,
0.0011216036509722471,
0.22792942821979523,
0.4832652509212494,
-0.07598143070936203,
1.1560882329940796,
-0.5222700834274292,
-0.4673687517642975,
-0.519711434841156,
0.18431992828845978,
0.18893378973007202,
-0.04194692522287369,
0.3073829114437103,
-0.923672080039978,
-0.3095231354236603,
-0.20962989330291748,
-0.571725606918335,
-0.3241487741470337,
-0.22287125885486603,
-0.05328425019979477,
0.21550782024860382,
0.24996136128902435,
-0.9743999242782593,
0.2946437895298004,
-0.004691110458225012,
-0.36456143856048584,
0.8056411743164062,
-0.5137596130371094,
-0.052066247910261154,
-1.5677622556686401,
-0.0059622786939144135,
-0.08019030094146729,
-0.37326616048812866,
-0.8706470727920532,
0.007449005730450153,
0.048208922147750854,
-0.42704343795776367,
-0.7962693572044373,
0.7938671708106995,
-0.7739425897598267,
-0.2740485370159149,
-0.44195374846458435,
0.3849331736564636,
0.20115675032138824,
0.4439629018306732,
0.1466720849275589,
0.6681592464447021,
0.5722836852073669,
-0.8313793540000916,
0.5542078018188477,
0.5071842074394226,
0.08482590317726135,
0.8843188881874084,
-0.5493900775909424,
0.07921688258647919,
-0.5241611003875732,
0.42616844177246094,
-0.6177080273628235,
-0.27753472328186035,
0.14564213156700134,
-0.05632850527763367,
0.29046395421028137,
-0.13540926575660706,
-1.1257741451263428,
-0.15831045806407928,
-0.40687277913093567,
-0.20570935308933258,
0.07498709857463837,
-0.24072827398777008,
0.8697124719619751,
0.3946813642978668,
-0.28834500908851624,
-0.1832296997308731,
-0.2246999889612198,
0.3784984350204468,
-0.13437466323375702,
-0.7118737697601318,
0.24354755878448486,
0.18772892653942108,
-0.18352043628692627,
-0.026178685948252678,
0.05600446090102196,
-0.02562335878610611,
0.2457507848739624,
0.08452533930540085,
0.4883882701396942,
0.005296639632433653,
0.06422149389982224,
0.07118697464466095,
-0.000972992624156177,
-0.012026661075651646,
-0.36358731985092163,
0.6275460720062256,
0.18108364939689636,
-0.5290599465370178,
-0.42575109004974365,
0.7595267295837402,
0.896274209022522,
-0.7005808353424072,
0.7856906652450562,
0.18801537156105042,
-0.48173987865448,
-0.4514932334423065,
-0.24680718779563904,
-0.03133340924978256,
-0.4816969633102417,
0.07487145811319351,
-0.5545759201049805,
-0.5027891397476196,
0.408236026763916,
-0.43726646900177,
0.27198612689971924,
0.2527045011520386,
0.9078804850578308,
0.1768476963043213,
0.8236207962036133,
0.5325140953063965,
0.17039145529270172,
0.5272993445396423,
-0.15784749388694763,
-0.03647439554333687,
-0.4246092140674591,
-0.5169994831085205,
-0.7060711979866028,
0.13575522601604462,
-0.43556466698646545,
-0.34335073828697205,
0.6573214530944824,
-0.23512881994247437,
0.1821708232164383,
0.08977147936820984,
-0.37769269943237305,
0.027605637907981873,
0.5360553860664368,
-0.2609628736972809,
0.335649311542511,
-0.09970803558826447,
-0.15663744509220123,
0.5879494547843933,
-0.5248461365699768,
-1.1996166706085205,
0.8073341846466064,
0.061557527631521225,
0.7828511595726013,
0.2719306945800781,
1.0997986793518066,
0.6062045693397522,
0.09029855579137802,
-0.5899792313575745,
0.8364078998565674,
0.14048045873641968,
-0.4411470890045166,
-0.6009307503700256,
-0.18669439852237701,
-1.242591142654419,
0.3725517988204956,
-0.5066091418266296,
-0.7385036945343018,
0.12671232223510742,
-0.14829476177692413,
-0.022550784051418304,
0.1755058765411377,
-0.4562236964702606,
0.5397324562072754,
0.10633943974971771,
-0.18370673060417175,
-0.13640333712100983,
-0.37533098459243774,
0.05752585083246231,
-0.26872164011001587,
0.042481765151023865,
-0.25208789110183716,
-0.2823469936847687,
0.4345940053462982,
-0.603973925113678,
0.8053574562072754,
-0.29889047145843506,
-0.42375093698501587,
0.4501904249191284,
-0.03501756116747856,
1.2278258800506592,
-0.05924799665808678,
-0.38174960017204285,
-0.5083210468292236,
-0.025607123970985413,
-0.4406963288784027,
-0.5850579738616943,
0.6098503470420837,
-0.628504753112793,
-0.7021504640579224,
-0.277751088142395,
-0.798760175704956,
-0.2786853313446045,
0.5972972512245178,
-0.15396064519882202,
0.6695162057876587,
-0.19889190793037415,
-0.27458611130714417,
0.5019444823265076,
-0.30896568298339844,
0.4324747323989868,
0.9371436834335327,
0.22226384282112122,
-0.05662233754992485,
0.7925243973731995,
0.21494120359420776,
-0.010258026421070099,
0.5397974252700806,
0.02955278567969799,
-0.5487446784973145,
-0.5979429483413696,
-0.2538888454437256,
0.22556988894939423,
-0.6252924799919128,
-0.30743953585624695,
-0.7073981165885925,
0.11148426681756973,
-0.7352827787399292,
-0.27722856402397156,
-0.12002947181463242,
-0.33823221921920776,
-0.6500767469406128,
-0.011058328673243523,
-0.10078661143779755,
1.137250542640686,
0.3787388503551483,
0.11363834887742996,
-0.8946077227592468,
0.3382784128189087,
0.09204624593257904,
0.015255732461810112,
0.06619400531053543,
0.0016420293832197785,
0.026437483727931976,
-0.27492788434028625,
-0.42943045496940613,
-1.2856853008270264,
0.4306905269622803,
-0.03534502908587456,
0.8016514778137207,
0.12039720267057419,
0.3254358470439911,
0.21813800930976868,
-0.5376415848731995,
0.6508210897445679,
0.11124512553215027,
-0.5719497203826904,
0.7180046439170837,
-0.5829226970672607,
0.1946309208869934,
0.24421130120754242,
0.06339235603809357,
-0.2629878520965576,
-0.8661401271820068,
-0.5823895931243896,
-1.042133092880249,
1.010504126548767,
0.2434869259595871,
0.20498982071876526,
-0.1971878856420517,
0.2256624847650528,
0.06318690627813339,
0.2766116261482239,
-0.21235975623130798,
-0.20459364354610443,
-0.03391934186220169,
-0.3132299482822418,
0.1384582221508026,
-0.3548571467399597,
-0.2553170919418335,
0.6716352701187134,
0.5763562917709351,
-0.14221803843975067,
0.17639204859733582,
0.27320483326911926,
-0.2197311371564865,
0.1385454535484314,
0.9638146758079529,
0.7658851146697998,
1.0038013458251953,
-0.04794513061642647,
0.2971991300582886,
0.00018100781016983092,
-0.029981495812535286,
0.36683470010757446,
0.1924370676279068,
-0.4541111886501312,
0.09052848070859909,
0.4048185646533966,
0.6096162796020508,
-0.13067129254341125,
-0.44695624709129333,
0.6100497841835022,
0.01586567796766758,
-0.05049389600753784,
-0.3915241062641144,
-0.1843525618314743,
0.03733506798744202,
0.2878810465335846,
0.5909680724143982,
-0.5190894603729248,
-0.01945510320365429,
-0.6746147274971008,
0.23009014129638672,
0.4222765862941742,
0.2172500342130661,
-0.2936457395553589,
0.5994623303413391,
0.41508227586746216,
-0.36853623390197754,
0.37733012437820435,
-0.3771093189716339,
-0.21666297316551208,
0.646540105342865,
0.8261608481407166,
0.6227967739105225,
0.12126190960407257,
0.46678808331489563,
-0.147846981883049,
0.07747521996498108,
-0.05996139347553253,
0.44713419675827026,
-0.059055980294942856,
-0.42126160860061646,
-0.17957469820976257,
-0.7124688029289246,
-0.4179907739162445,
0.10189860314130783,
-0.3143242597579956,
0.42553722858428955,
-0.47149765491485596,
-0.36151063442230225,
-0.07516805827617645,
0.23103021085262299,
-0.6177129745483398,
0.032230183482170105,
0.21142283082008362,
1.2019730806350708,
-0.9146341681480408,
0.7564166784286499,
1.1708202362060547,
-0.43880075216293335,
-1.0773128271102905,
-0.007269452325999737,
0.0894351676106453,
-0.6475188732147217,
0.567211389541626,
-0.11685627698898315,
-0.06014588102698326,
-0.09971661865711212,
-0.1130644828081131,
-0.5999295711517334,
1.4061617851257324,
0.49274057149887085,
-0.29695460200309753,
-0.4408421516418457,
0.24871666729450226,
0.6656941175460815,
-0.39848408102989197,
0.14484545588493347,
0.14965921640396118,
0.7922654151916504,
0.010498947463929653,
-0.6914902329444885,
0.2895401120185852,
-0.09188218414783478,
0.2467309981584549,
0.2071567326784134,
-0.6060688495635986,
0.7762239575386047,
0.19776548445224762,
-0.4210997223854065,
-0.062453433871269226,
0.746687650680542,
0.5351054668426514,
0.37556904554367065,
0.48112165927886963,
0.14761389791965485,
0.9388082027435303,
0.2905193567276001,
1.2277077436447144,
-0.24800655245780945,
0.04247474670410156,
1.0528748035430908,
-0.49120280146598816,
0.31416091322898865,
0.5752614140510559,
0.04015783220529556,
0.2775195837020874,
0.3880699872970581,
0.031839530915021896,
0.3888174593448639,
0.15226340293884277,
-0.43266597390174866,
-0.2517976462841034,
-0.6841713786125183,
0.019021188840270042,
0.4594581425189972,
0.07351174205541611,
-0.26558637619018555,
-0.7530489563941956,
-0.07185599952936172,
-0.005209549330174923,
0.40541601181030273,
-0.44459211826324463,
0.8802709579467773,
-0.021602388471364975,
-0.7093588709831238,
0.1016186997294426,
0.5121350884437561,
0.3339790999889374,
-0.684730052947998,
-0.11547703295946121,
-0.1286323070526123,
-0.3424282670021057,
-0.10997876524925232,
-1.0003782510757446,
0.19689446687698364,
0.20114965736865997,
-0.29730769991874695,
-0.6952673196792603,
1.0283868312835693,
-0.3361828327178955,
-0.23964005708694458,
0.30491334199905396,
0.7536243200302124,
0.21856486797332764,
0.08496659249067307,
-0.5009588003158569,
-0.19006478786468506,
-0.4140557646751404,
-0.41658157110214233,
0.2994394898414612,
0.845392107963562,
-0.5215758681297302,
0.646310031414032,
0.6574233174324036,
0.5827184915542603,
0.2892882227897644,
0.2025870978832245,
1.1610321998596191,
-0.28834038972854614,
-0.8077950477600098,
-0.6762205362319946,
0.33611753582954407,
-0.08430951088666916,
-0.04586740583181381,
0.4028960168361664,
0.555697500705719,
0.4838751554489136,
-0.1500507891178131,
0.7243247032165527,
-0.11052478104829788,
0.3587053418159485,
-0.6156268119812012,
0.48441562056541443,
-0.6163572072982788,
0.31461527943611145,
-0.23429356515407562,
-1.010965347290039,
-0.01232079230248928,
-0.2035064995288849,
-0.12017620354890823,
-0.21948601305484772,
0.24343110620975494,
1.000471830368042,
-0.1693686544895172,
-0.5581387877464294,
0.48292672634124756,
-0.07629013061523438,
0.6933693885803223,
0.5006151795387268,
0.9755048155784607,
0.2998684048652649,
0.7574571371078491,
0.3180723488330841,
-0.032861072570085526,
-0.12275853753089905,
-0.7916010618209839,
-0.8789100050926208,
-0.7526404857635498,
0.015504746697843075,
-0.16890528798103333,
0.10728688538074493,
0.9803556203842163,
0.5080239176750183,
-0.5615552067756653,
0.06917239725589752,
0.07999315112829208,
0.3755924105644226,
0.3330744802951813,
-0.23476271331310272,
0.3864305317401886,
-0.3529857099056244,
-0.8463543653488159,
0.5678918361663818,
0.4393317699432373,
0.2137828916311264,
-0.2959425747394562,
-0.27134087681770325,
-0.4342893064022064,
0.3505479097366333,
0.44595855474472046,
0.1976713091135025,
-0.6356104016304016,
-0.14275623857975006,
-0.30584120750427246,
-0.5377981662750244,
-0.07072276622056961,
0.9367940425872803,
-0.5797556042671204,
0.3222464919090271,
0.7150382995605469,
0.590481162071228,
0.32035472989082336,
0.0997057557106018,
0.7135603427886963,
-0.9807470440864563,
-0.17271745204925537,
0.17594046890735626,
0.3411484956741333,
0.35224008560180664,
-0.5856596231460571,
0.22559666633605957,
0.09284305572509766,
-0.20247749984264374,
-0.7057707905769348,
0.3003775179386139,
-0.9924917817115784,
-0.28553739190101624,
1.135947823524475,
-0.10200439393520355,
-0.3515608012676239,
-0.1965751349925995,
-0.2864771783351898,
0.6408587694168091,
-0.8697284460067749,
0.7722352743148804,
0.5812733173370361,
-0.12810459733009338,
0.10536390542984009,
-0.27332592010498047,
0.19418102502822876,
-0.020889919251203537,
-1.2831932306289673,
0.06285405904054642,
0.7006673216819763,
0.18511459231376648,
0.3077906668186188,
1.0723012685775757,
-0.1675361543893814,
0.23077216744422913,
-0.3581710755825043,
-0.035813938826322556,
-0.6145290732383728,
-0.47185254096984863,
-0.17280663549900055,
0.3287373483181,
0.0832064226269722,
-0.10898289829492569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13800v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13800v1
|
The Geography of Information Diffusion in Online Discourse on Europe and Migration
| 2024-02-21T13:30:34 | 2024-02-21T13:30:34 |
Elisa Leonardelli, Sara Tonelli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
The online diffusion of information related to Europe and migration has been
little investigated from an external point of view. However, this is a very
relevant topic, especially if users have had no direct contact with Europe and
its perception depends solely on information retrieved online. In this work we
analyse the information circulating online about Europe and migration after
retrieving a large amount of data from social media (Twitter), to gain new
insights into topics, magnitude, and dynamics of their diffusion. We combine
retweets and hashtags network analysis with geolocation of users, linking thus
data to geography and allowing analysis from an "outside Europe" perspective,
with a special focus on Africa. We also introduce a novel approach based on
cross-lingual quotes, i.e. when content in a language is commented and
retweeted in another language, assuming these interactions are a proxy for
connections between very distant communities. Results show how the majority of
online discussions occurs at a national level, especially when discussing
migration. Language (English) is pivotal for information to become
transnational and reach far. Transnational information flow is strongly
unbalanced, with content mainly produced in Europe and amplified outside.
Conversely Europe-based accounts tend to be self-referential when they discuss
migration-related topics. Football is the most exported topic from Europe
worldwide. Moreover, important nodes in the communities discussing
migration-related topics include accounts of official institutions and
international agencies, together with journalists, news, commentators and
activists.
|
[
-0.9806395769119263,
-0.7862431406974792,
0.6562113761901855,
0.28265050053596497,
-0.3584626317024231,
0.1847708523273468,
-0.24583233892917633,
-0.8535324931144714,
1.0307886600494385,
0.2125721275806427,
-0.6047608852386475,
-0.4906470775604248,
-0.7601308226585388,
-0.1660822033882141,
-0.6346478462219238,
0.8255085349082947,
-0.0760619267821312,
-0.22802893817424774,
0.10188432782888412,
-0.455279141664505,
0.24559089541435242,
-0.646510899066925,
-0.4067443907260895,
0.04303906857967377,
0.6093074083328247,
0.14797671139240265,
0.2475653737783432,
0.2242930829524994,
0.4586590826511383,
0.263674795627594,
-0.3867845833301544,
-0.13171173632144928,
-0.6810494065284729,
-0.0038270466029644012,
-0.7051931023597717,
-0.16187424957752228,
0.11343354731798172,
-0.3590557873249054,
0.4651702046394348,
0.8272759318351746,
-0.10514754056930542,
0.37017178535461426,
0.28020337224006653,
0.5133219361305237,
-0.2420940101146698,
-0.4102605879306793,
-0.27054157853126526,
0.01617811992764473,
-0.31234264373779297,
-0.29698437452316284,
0.198699489235878,
-0.4999562203884125,
0.28468382358551025,
-0.3816732168197632,
0.6948202848434448,
-0.4228111505508423,
0.8939437866210938,
-0.29503992199897766,
-0.8733022809028625,
-0.5770971179008484,
-0.9892356395721436,
0.5195439457893372,
0.2851812541484833,
0.37736597657203674,
0.26099005341529846,
0.4545910060405731,
0.0371435321867466,
-0.6218992471694946,
-0.1847483366727829,
0.496244877576828,
0.23342035710811615,
0.09592200070619583,
-0.3199627995491028,
-0.46491456031799316,
-0.20694740116596222,
-0.0839524045586586,
-0.09455469250679016,
-0.3703175485134125,
-0.6697583794593811,
-0.13051997125148773,
0.7065964341163635,
-0.23511645197868347,
0.5256307721138,
0.21927665174007416,
-0.3317933976650238,
0.3928890526294708,
-0.6807265281677246,
-0.10036909580230713,
0.8004425168037415,
0.3486481010913849,
-0.3770389258861542,
0.2412232905626297,
-0.0010561352828517556,
0.4244709312915802,
-0.1212570071220398,
0.10024107992649078,
0.24826769530773163,
-0.40059518814086914,
0.704151451587677,
-0.08598030358552933,
0.5366150736808777,
0.6300921440124512,
0.09475759416818619,
-0.25522178411483765,
0.31007349491119385,
-0.301085501909256,
0.21849225461483002,
-0.6735918521881104,
0.05430075153708458,
0.11346015334129333,
-0.700812816619873,
0.2617267072200775,
0.42993804812431335,
-1.2238855361938477,
-0.3927619755268097,
0.18399284780025482,
-0.07624882459640503,
0.1353376805782318,
-0.4957427978515625,
-0.134174183011055,
-0.20745350420475006,
0.24532434344291687,
0.7042514085769653,
-0.5659094452857971,
0.05989392101764679,
0.48129937052726746,
1.0832005739212036,
-0.19565917551517487,
0.13348345458507538,
0.2880688011646271,
0.08475347608327866,
-0.1394747495651245,
1.2613052129745483,
-0.4356319010257721,
-0.3044854998588562,
0.44498059153556824,
0.4966549277305603,
0.13214625418186188,
-0.017061203718185425,
0.4741224944591522,
-0.5633557438850403,
0.011774180456995964,
-0.8918284773826599,
-0.19058161973953247,
-0.4644724428653717,
0.3840779662132263,
-0.716467559337616,
0.8272925019264221,
-0.11054038256406784,
-0.9330469369888306,
0.46210816502571106,
-0.8248186111450195,
-0.4796796441078186,
-0.2149229496717453,
0.1613524705171585,
0.15986183285713196,
0.043608736246824265,
0.14786487817764282,
0.2224680334329605,
-0.18563970923423767,
-0.03342108801007271,
-0.5610860586166382,
-0.04972144216299057,
-0.07533328980207443,
0.026025254279375076,
0.7736093401908875,
0.3104073703289032,
-0.11001366376876831,
-0.6140043139457703,
-0.577204704284668,
-0.6426662802696228,
-0.015314661897718906,
-0.2329481840133667,
-0.4317110478878021,
0.24025481939315796,
-0.12908434867858887,
0.5526906251907349,
0.10275409370660782,
-0.9515244364738464,
0.20996950566768646,
-0.07061280310153961,
0.566105842590332,
0.24776293337345123,
0.509299099445343,
0.6737863421440125,
-0.1722302883863449,
0.528191089630127,
0.3608291745185852,
0.12806840240955353,
0.2967929542064667,
-0.7427123785018921,
-0.28604206442832947,
0.2368660569190979,
0.22450174391269684,
0.5917561054229736,
-0.5783894062042236,
0.016156421974301338,
-0.32477107644081116,
-0.5150960087776184,
-0.4953033924102783,
-0.013581397011876106,
-0.5522822141647339,
0.11552062630653381,
0.13851049542427063,
0.2716437578201294,
-0.4837299585342407,
-0.7275075912475586,
-0.34650135040283203,
-0.18715454638004303,
0.015237212181091309,
0.28404849767684937,
0.4957050681114197,
-0.2419758141040802,
0.7182148098945618,
-0.3597055673599243,
-0.4060332477092743,
-0.5690423846244812,
0.14298059046268463,
-0.010325056500732899,
0.05048125609755516,
0.6930950284004211,
-0.9840514063835144,
-0.5894196033477783,
0.056004226207733154,
-0.27601924538612366,
-0.3253273367881775,
-0.22869941592216492,
-0.6416213512420654,
0.0059221344999969006,
0.3885815441608429,
-0.2229989916086197,
0.5022405385971069,
0.6260290741920471,
-0.6162164211273193,
-0.45127227902412415,
-0.05612412095069885,
0.4400319755077362,
-1.358901858329773,
0.1627226620912552,
0.23948948085308075,
-0.20575962960720062,
-0.5954281687736511,
-0.1421269178390503,
-0.4227742850780487,
0.2965230643749237,
-0.5388504862785339,
0.8113102316856384,
-0.4735190272331238,
-0.24749736487865448,
-0.07336593419313431,
0.5502859354019165,
-0.21690233051776886,
-0.24427153170108795,
0.10218402743339539,
0.37170445919036865,
0.35065168142318726,
-0.5367039442062378,
0.12059420347213745,
0.3729212284088135,
-0.5265382528305054,
0.5807119011878967,
0.18564829230308533,
-0.1252947300672531,
-0.2909477651119232,
0.487336665391922,
-1.2787724733352661,
0.06694123148918152,
0.18471847474575043,
-0.35756736993789673,
-0.3934812545776367,
-0.5778357982635498,
-0.3222934901714325,
-0.35339781641960144,
0.058439623564481735,
0.5481681227684021,
0.2980421781539917,
-0.3417651355266571,
0.7451938986778259,
1.069413423538208,
-0.4180741012096405,
-0.16788095235824585,
-1.1396422386169434,
0.1842191070318222,
-0.37112247943878174,
-0.8742446303367615,
0.15237312018871307,
0.17031848430633545,
-0.5296862721443176,
0.15325823426246643,
0.04450742155313492,
-0.521486222743988,
0.183148592710495,
0.03203641623258591,
-0.3310156464576721,
0.02790599688887596,
0.09111098945140839,
0.018439533188939095,
0.24730709195137024,
0.3267475664615631,
-0.3684348464012146,
0.3449585437774658,
0.5763821005821228,
-0.07657905668020248,
-0.2600933313369751,
0.7194717526435852,
0.054816726595163345,
0.32392001152038574,
1.2567698955535889,
0.6878039836883545,
0.09886543452739716,
-0.3430035412311554,
-0.37027284502983093,
-0.0656866580247879,
-0.2920262813568115,
-0.028191454708576202,
-0.11185571551322937,
-0.7481135129928589,
1.1183128356933594,
-0.46215152740478516,
0.3137764036655426,
0.777349054813385,
0.4279575049877167,
-0.5254724621772766,
0.5898799300193787,
0.8586912155151367,
0.1919059455394745,
0.45337602496147156,
-0.4347388446331024,
0.3906227946281433,
-0.38045740127563477,
-0.4465809762477875,
-0.8092502355575562,
-0.7883020639419556,
-0.9431197047233582,
-0.47621551156044006,
-0.1017151027917862,
-0.045598845928907394,
0.29468679428100586,
0.066736601293087,
0.008269316516816616,
0.49939072132110596,
0.08570442348718643,
0.0411200150847435,
0.038342032581567764,
0.36935392022132874,
-0.13205906748771667,
-0.051222845911979675,
-0.8048357367515564,
-0.2888224124908447,
0.6138350963592529,
0.22650188207626343,
0.7466094493865967,
0.37190523743629456,
0.5672105550765991,
0.5492730140686035,
0.5896260738372803,
-0.48925384879112244,
0.3488202393054962,
0.018323739990592003,
-0.6776883006095886,
-0.06963830441236496,
-0.338276207447052,
-1.153623104095459,
0.34105974435806274,
-0.11409403383731842,
-0.8229531049728394,
0.5340386033058167,
-0.18854181468486786,
-0.19095219671726227,
0.923414945602417,
-0.24192945659160614,
0.27094143629074097,
0.10042118281126022,
-0.37201395630836487,
-0.12239183485507965,
-0.8828667402267456,
0.010389969684183598,
-0.23771385848522186,
0.9108557105064392,
-0.10000473260879517,
-0.27220672369003296,
0.955969512462616,
-0.2885989546775818,
0.5969390273094177,
-0.15103788673877716,
-0.3923703134059906,
0.6973966360092163,
0.1488995999097824,
0.06798664480447769,
-0.5003057718276978,
-0.041935402899980545,
0.7670186758041382,
-0.08680931478738785,
-0.4798000752925873,
-0.08750969171524048,
0.7684866786003113,
-0.8907479643821716,
-0.36038827896118164,
-0.12997232377529144,
-0.13316920399665833,
0.028491728007793427,
-0.1885664314031601,
0.41237831115722656,
0.060469262301921844,
-0.2961222231388092,
0.13263654708862305,
0.514475405216217,
-0.05112262815237045,
0.718205988407135,
0.24060070514678955,
-0.12781256437301636,
-0.1838943362236023,
0.6223496794700623,
0.7436696887016296,
0.08213204145431519,
0.35781368613243103,
0.2214815467596054,
-0.6652851700782776,
-0.10237932950258255,
-0.25925830006599426,
0.5775843858718872,
-0.933552086353302,
0.18070682883262634,
-0.6327730417251587,
-0.04507621377706528,
-0.16797304153442383,
-0.42473480105400085,
-0.23588649928569794,
-0.49684005975723267,
-0.1813352257013321,
-0.27602049708366394,
0.13560517132282257,
0.8802524209022522,
-0.488045334815979,
0.46601054072380066,
-0.7189222574234009,
0.021212466061115265,
-0.19891078770160675,
0.23904341459274292,
-0.21530140936374664,
-0.6643600463867188,
-0.6192322969436646,
-0.07919814437627792,
-0.2513637840747833,
-1.1892186403274536,
0.22185273468494415,
0.02628416009247303,
0.4041513502597809,
0.5959927439689636,
0.06948622316122055,
0.8763814568519592,
-0.26900821924209595,
1.0590975284576416,
-0.31331148743629456,
-0.4480491578578949,
0.3914444148540497,
-0.3019499182701111,
0.07814130932092667,
0.5795716047286987,
0.8492313623428345,
-0.5001604557037354,
-0.6026570200920105,
-0.6906717419624329,
-1.0078225135803223,
0.42611199617385864,
-0.0444522388279438,
0.3165023922920227,
-0.016809796914458275,
-0.07092902809381485,
0.10520990937948227,
0.02814304083585739,
-0.5684306621551514,
-0.1868363916873932,
0.38051390647888184,
0.4243215322494507,
0.05414145439863205,
-0.22837553918361664,
-0.21179358661174774,
-0.2719307541847229,
0.5294457077980042,
0.21088729798793793,
0.17371945083141327,
0.5243149399757385,
-0.06419019401073456,
-0.34026938676834106,
-0.08895740658044815,
0.3703068792819977,
1.0512878894805908,
0.14675402641296387,
-0.03270113095641136,
0.07553474605083466,
-0.42821004986763,
0.21717754006385803,
-0.23232850432395935,
-0.2515362799167633,
0.5784721970558167,
0.39841869473457336,
0.3479686379432678,
-0.03896326944231987,
0.0017746759112924337,
0.6111276745796204,
-0.19748042523860931,
-0.8371312618255615,
-0.19657836854457855,
-0.5559316277503967,
0.4037186801433563,
0.411724328994751,
0.524527907371521,
-0.17251810431480408,
0.05115634948015213,
-0.7881045937538147,
0.1382875144481659,
0.18516230583190918,
-0.27126505970954895,
-0.6482244729995728,
0.6426577568054199,
0.684312641620636,
-0.17579150199890137,
0.1656627655029297,
0.20475909113883972,
-0.4966490864753723,
0.41019731760025024,
0.10261113941669464,
0.716331422328949,
-0.40833404660224915,
0.49200108647346497,
0.42817726731300354,
0.2584391236305237,
0.08565106987953186,
0.7879095077514648,
-0.40676096081733704,
-0.6309179663658142,
-0.11029711365699768,
-0.551547110080719,
0.12531423568725586,
-0.27473217248916626,
-0.5873231291770935,
0.13104024529457092,
-0.18175244331359863,
-0.6470761299133301,
-0.38368967175483704,
-0.007495646830648184,
-0.7778278589248657,
-0.0848786011338234,
0.354453980922699,
1.1840922832489014,
-1.4651798009872437,
0.46742525696754456,
0.7199397683143616,
0.1293228417634964,
-0.11816522479057312,
0.4774288237094879,
0.050570856779813766,
-0.3102060854434967,
0.5506545305252075,
0.10765379667282104,
-0.16512128710746765,
-0.15348124504089355,
-0.43505409359931946,
-0.8566851019859314,
0.6542047262191772,
0.34864115715026855,
-0.33368977904319763,
0.1479509323835373,
0.37109971046447754,
0.601015567779541,
-0.2432483434677124,
0.13008631765842438,
0.4350864589214325,
0.4498087167739868,
0.4552072584629059,
-0.5471585392951965,
-0.25563499331474304,
0.13533911108970642,
-0.17508633434772491,
0.7106882929801941,
-0.9713597893714905,
0.5673379898071289,
0.02653346210718155,
-0.6435814499855042,
-0.3838774561882019,
0.2831311821937561,
-0.5357274413108826,
0.016718685626983643,
0.4075777232646942,
0.2089710831642151,
0.5389090180397034,
-0.3099391460418701,
0.9561118483543396,
-0.577985405921936,
0.39126601815223694,
0.6190418004989624,
-0.34195056557655334,
0.7955759167671204,
0.5489740967750549,
-0.18889665603637695,
0.8681285977363586,
0.7349568009376526,
0.37447819113731384,
0.45855575799942017,
0.060548339039087296,
-0.2803291082382202,
-0.16811053454875946,
-0.09776709228754044,
-0.14184528589248657,
0.3404833674430847,
0.4270106852054596,
-0.5960943698883057,
-0.9266005754470825,
0.06288408488035202,
0.07109338045120239,
-0.3512529730796814,
-0.5206235647201538,
1.0999743938446045,
-0.03703763708472252,
-0.4975303113460541,
-0.04806322231888771,
-0.2568528950214386,
0.09626062959432602,
-0.604145348072052,
-0.09113451093435287,
-0.643843412399292,
-0.23480673134326935,
-0.2809700071811676,
-1.2468984127044678,
0.6868384480476379,
0.0045495713129639626,
0.1350606232881546,
-0.3068664073944092,
0.5442074537277222,
-0.4241664409637451,
-0.5922071933746338,
0.7564537525177002,
0.8907055854797363,
0.6752708554267883,
0.06044703722000122,
-0.7085330486297607,
0.055794499814510345,
0.03903839364647865,
-0.26676392555236816,
0.43657031655311584,
1.073028802871704,
-0.22942771017551422,
0.5992314219474792,
0.4799642264842987,
0.5791350603103638,
0.2885267436504364,
-0.0767626091837883,
0.719321072101593,
-0.6810320615768433,
-0.9781241416931152,
-0.9382560849189758,
0.30215173959732056,
-0.15020884573459625,
-0.1955055594444275,
0.9334059953689575,
0.46968305110931396,
0.7035148739814758,
0.42267394065856934,
0.7706018090248108,
-0.2711521089076996,
0.6824876666069031,
-0.15584935247898102,
0.7631938457489014,
-0.5455328822135925,
0.013002419844269753,
-0.06800331175327301,
-1.0114052295684814,
-0.08077774196863174,
0.49914517998695374,
-0.24334105849266052,
-0.13676755130290985,
0.5326026678085327,
0.3712070882320404,
-0.2655734717845917,
-0.15456019341945648,
0.10079934448003769,
0.15987993776798248,
0.10563302785158157,
0.09968029707670212,
0.7858371138572693,
-0.06213785335421562,
0.5328179001808167,
-0.1995304524898529,
-0.013455381616950035,
-0.35841456055641174,
-0.8225480318069458,
-0.7786499857902527,
-0.7075183391571045,
-0.33644697070121765,
-0.7444474697113037,
-0.07517673075199127,
0.715215802192688,
0.7268711924552917,
-0.7778257131576538,
-0.37970513105392456,
0.41859233379364014,
0.19172023236751556,
0.21310873329639435,
-0.2333424836397171,
0.3419073522090912,
0.14303530752658844,
-0.3653312623500824,
-0.17521795630455017,
0.08858970552682877,
0.15398064255714417,
-0.5481323003768921,
0.587641716003418,
-0.38981667160987854,
0.3229185938835144,
0.5544247031211853,
0.3695478141307831,
-0.43125683069229126,
-0.12225256115198135,
-0.4297987222671509,
0.1015184223651886,
0.25229474902153015,
0.738896369934082,
-0.44540825486183167,
0.34314072132110596,
0.681934654712677,
0.6572194695472717,
0.48518046736717224,
0.6407049298286438,
0.42902541160583496,
-0.5212209820747375,
0.3415106534957886,
0.08569091558456421,
0.08721097558736801,
0.4484964907169342,
-0.16107936203479767,
0.367643266916275,
0.5411472320556641,
-0.5441854596138,
-0.5120186805725098,
-0.21637365221977234,
-0.3857678174972534,
-0.2914651036262512,
1.347474455833435,
-0.07102558761835098,
-0.5257382988929749,
-0.5224426984786987,
0.01866178959608078,
0.017914945259690285,
-0.49077844619750977,
0.9759955406188965,
1.1521424055099487,
-0.0556979663670063,
0.12195215374231339,
-0.8190951943397522,
0.38743096590042114,
-0.26288115978240967,
-0.8080370426177979,
-0.1664053201675415,
0.23542912304401398,
0.4681158661842346,
0.22807420790195465,
0.49814754724502563,
0.16331982612609863,
-0.3013431429862976,
-0.1406223177909851,
-0.1461016982793808,
0.7501665949821472,
-0.5976794362068176,
-0.07615486532449722,
0.5453253984451294,
-0.6053922176361084,
-0.2009023278951645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13764v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13764v3
|
CriticBench: Evaluating Large Language Models as Critic
| 2024-02-21T12:38:59 | 2024-02-23T02:44:52 |
Tian Lan, Wenwei Zhang, Chen Xu, Heyan Huang, Dahua Lin, Kai Chen, Xian-ling Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Critique ability are crucial in the scalable oversight and self-improvement
of Large Language Models (LLMs). While many recent studies explore the critique
ability of LLMs to judge and refine flaws in generations, how to
comprehensively and reliably measure the critique abilities of LLMs is
under-explored. This paper introduces CriticBench, a novel benchmark designed
to comprehensively and reliably evaluate four key critique ability dimensions
of LLMs: feedback, comparison, refinement and meta-feedback. CriticBench
encompasses nine diverse tasks, each assessing the LLMs' ability to critique
responses at varying levels of quality granularity. Our extensive evaluations
of open-source and closed-source LLMs reveal intriguing relationships between
the critique ability and tasks, response qualities, and model scales. Datasets,
resources and evaluation toolkit for CriticBench will be publicly released at
https://github.com/open-compass/CriticBench.
|
[
-0.5937674641609192,
-0.48933160305023193,
0.5061991810798645,
0.2942410409450531,
0.05157633125782013,
0.31285470724105835,
-0.5331682562828064,
-0.4121576249599457,
0.04697101190686226,
0.5263465642929077,
-0.6791918873786926,
-0.4213618338108063,
-0.15972617268562317,
0.13406510651111603,
-0.5479886531829834,
1.0260165929794312,
-0.09073378890752792,
0.37997040152549744,
-0.4672325551509857,
-0.231344535946846,
-0.2496388554573059,
-0.24266059696674347,
-0.5299553871154785,
-0.4496578276157379,
0.7093084454536438,
0.356020987033844,
0.47696980834007263,
0.2846154570579529,
0.7238407731056213,
0.36990731954574585,
-0.03332747891545296,
-0.13187605142593384,
-0.7847896218299866,
0.32550862431526184,
-0.6870802640914917,
-0.37565284967422485,
-0.5392345786094666,
0.1910484880208969,
0.7591480016708374,
0.6669420599937439,
-0.0008316034218296409,
0.5435183048248291,
0.28488603234291077,
0.7976186275482178,
-0.5592918395996094,
0.07382413744926453,
-0.4736391603946686,
-0.05458999052643776,
-0.31551653146743774,
0.08914029598236084,
-0.3603832423686981,
-0.5984357595443726,
-0.17455141246318817,
-0.25760531425476074,
0.24486245214939117,
-0.10329589247703552,
0.4759289622306824,
0.3502187132835388,
-0.31843802332878113,
0.027601970359683037,
-0.7670698165893555,
0.7111014127731323,
-0.8647478818893433,
0.37823837995529175,
0.04183845594525337,
0.6478836536407471,
-0.06229794770479202,
-0.8513140082359314,
-0.5163377523422241,
-0.5748400092124939,
0.10485120862722397,
0.04429531469941139,
-0.056606367230415344,
0.005163914989680052,
0.3367963135242462,
0.8572890758514404,
-0.37757521867752075,
0.1697959303855896,
-0.24384073913097382,
-0.3200334310531616,
0.6729556322097778,
0.4198797345161438,
-0.11866390705108643,
-0.3790227174758911,
-0.2815819978713989,
-0.177036315202713,
-0.45649173855781555,
-0.002917641308158636,
0.7089658379554749,
0.05509266257286072,
0.11027099937200546,
0.30047377943992615,
-0.48376768827438354,
0.5834047794342041,
-0.20089997351169586,
-0.11269859969615936,
0.48143067955970764,
-0.4637890160083771,
0.07135209441184998,
-0.714973509311676,
0.8255516290664673,
0.4508123993873596,
0.15789198875427246,
-0.23870742321014404,
-0.6046411991119385,
-0.043574415147304535,
0.5156226754188538,
-0.6880026459693909,
-0.1462269127368927,
0.12295039743185043,
-0.5224868059158325,
-0.44237926602363586,
0.11212610453367233,
-1.0999685525894165,
-0.6641161441802979,
-0.28090545535087585,
0.10689567029476166,
-0.030609292909502983,
-0.40232229232788086,
-0.194106325507164,
-0.0212547667324543,
0.1681867390871048,
0.2207106500864029,
-0.48463475704193115,
0.49991804361343384,
0.7415503859519958,
0.6296567916870117,
-0.20814083516597748,
-0.5684947967529297,
-0.5492421984672546,
-0.31812530755996704,
-0.39827677607536316,
0.9098662734031677,
-0.5804656744003296,
-0.29447224736213684,
-0.0475691556930542,
0.046438053250312805,
0.14684268832206726,
-0.7370606660842896,
0.7807601094245911,
-0.41132670640945435,
-0.23230695724487305,
-0.34949034452438354,
-0.37666404247283936,
-0.180055171251297,
0.6043707132339478,
-0.9278813004493713,
1.0811223983764648,
0.4705906808376312,
-0.7209439277648926,
0.053989242762327194,
-0.25955602526664734,
-0.10162658989429474,
0.008813541382551193,
-0.11427342891693115,
-0.2845466732978821,
0.40884849429130554,
-0.07851745188236237,
0.2901758551597595,
-0.5676153898239136,
0.17373691499233246,
-0.8380926847457886,
-0.19486428797245026,
0.5092291831970215,
-0.29883620142936707,
0.2877468168735504,
0.21370656788349152,
-0.26057934761047363,
0.5047862529754639,
-0.8688221573829651,
0.531737208366394,
0.05274444818496704,
-0.3194667398929596,
0.12930086255073547,
-0.019405320286750793,
0.28935909271240234,
0.17058543860912323,
0.18830960988998413,
-0.44049298763275146,
0.11618299782276154,
-0.20754988491535187,
0.7115706205368042,
0.7596506476402283,
-0.12715472280979156,
0.019846269860863686,
-0.31931453943252563,
0.8541972041130066,
-0.4916232228279114,
0.09014694392681122,
-0.04285944253206253,
0.24279595911502838,
-0.8076401352882385,
-0.059316154569387436,
0.4786856174468994,
0.1020585224032402,
-0.5035360455513,
0.29069027304649353,
-0.34701478481292725,
-0.9512940645217896,
-0.5936498045921326,
0.4497779905796051,
0.696624755859375,
0.09978114813566208,
0.17215760052204132,
-0.7784470915794373,
-0.526018500328064,
-0.9612748026847839,
-0.6395267248153687,
-0.20067162811756134,
-0.0224450696259737,
0.287088543176651,
0.43969276547431946,
-0.20171107351779938,
0.5588836669921875,
-0.17745007574558258,
-0.1225295290350914,
-0.377908855676651,
-0.0018624176736921072,
0.023259280249476433,
0.15875428915023804,
0.49943026900291443,
0.03041546232998371,
-0.25835514068603516,
-0.2041339874267578,
-0.4400276839733124,
-0.556092381477356,
0.13463033735752106,
0.07680679857730865,
0.06507493555545807,
0.8746607303619385,
-0.30234581232070923,
0.023765364661812782,
0.8344658017158508,
-0.29380685091018677,
1.0063025951385498,
0.13104325532913208,
-0.03274143487215042,
-0.7596311569213867,
0.35679906606674194,
-0.14270485937595367,
-0.32638123631477356,
-0.21384167671203613,
0.5196602940559387,
0.09348227083683014,
-0.029640132561326027,
-0.19366523623466492,
0.4006507396697998,
-0.5189496874809265,
-0.42922645807266235,
-0.1862909346818924,
0.3866155445575714,
-0.0666588693857193,
0.33201172947883606,
-0.4961549639701843,
0.4776560068130493,
0.2302456796169281,
-0.11592629551887512,
0.7760580778121948,
-0.17271441221237183,
-0.7744311094284058,
0.850144624710083,
-0.6929022073745728,
0.4351690411567688,
0.20665530860424042,
0.3657323122024536,
-0.9763759970664978,
-0.1883915364742279,
-0.02942393347620964,
-0.11488232016563416,
0.2224237322807312,
0.07003644853830338,
-0.4793632924556732,
-0.6324135661125183,
-0.5428154468536377,
0.20374378561973572,
0.03197934851050377,
-0.46355852484703064,
0.7092344760894775,
0.0649523064494133,
-0.25363054871559143,
-0.5564493536949158,
-0.3513728082180023,
0.20142635703086853,
0.16303874552249908,
-0.449370801448822,
0.12382242828607559,
-0.23797261714935303,
-0.49545928835868835,
0.06841961294412613,
-0.21908147633075714,
0.28736111521720886,
0.03561926260590553,
0.2518598735332489,
-0.14296334981918335,
-0.06375443935394287,
0.06325923651456833,
-0.3902181386947632,
-0.191013902425766,
0.2832790017127991,
0.11911839246749878,
0.7911036014556885,
-0.42564114928245544,
-0.5141836404800415,
-0.13951125741004944,
-0.15111982822418213,
0.8794117569923401,
-0.4243570566177368,
0.12748458981513977,
0.3726181089878082,
0.21484823524951935,
-0.6191691160202026,
-0.9228599667549133,
-0.17960982024669647,
-0.4382394254207611,
0.6114076972007751,
-0.5086621046066284,
-0.7761186957359314,
0.5762414932250977,
-0.11520510911941528,
0.0849265307188034,
0.5430665612220764,
0.6650862693786621,
0.2597019672393799,
0.5694236159324646,
0.5546532869338989,
-0.38728827238082886,
0.3409373462200165,
-0.158208429813385,
0.2181462049484253,
-1.1311010122299194,
-0.15778425335884094,
-0.6484530568122864,
-0.5675014853477478,
-0.346333384513855,
-0.44291388988494873,
0.043614573776721954,
-0.011965024285018444,
-0.3157337009906769,
0.07263223826885223,
-0.20764978229999542,
0.6416527628898621,
0.3789640963077545,
-0.12393733114004135,
0.4094434082508087,
-0.35172516107559204,
-0.2773708701133728,
-0.02596564218401909,
-0.1747637540102005,
-0.6916394233703613,
1.0829472541809082,
0.6930934190750122,
0.9249500036239624,
0.016757890582084656,
0.39555734395980835,
-0.018423929810523987,
0.5706315040588379,
-0.7961979508399963,
0.8454743027687073,
0.03505020961165428,
-0.7697180509567261,
-0.2782057225704193,
-0.4969885051250458,
-0.3994371294975281,
0.4368879795074463,
0.063765749335289,
-0.6435429453849792,
-0.13474316895008087,
0.049211371690034866,
-0.21364256739616394,
0.4242696762084961,
-0.39524686336517334,
0.9357944130897522,
-0.22745603322982788,
-0.6053329706192017,
-0.6253728270530701,
-0.36891311407089233,
0.41223573684692383,
-0.14446398615837097,
0.20960885286331177,
-0.2440689504146576,
0.07430285215377808,
0.5399267077445984,
-0.2904568910598755,
0.9108061790466309,
-0.0793711245059967,
-0.07375882565975189,
0.19614188373088837,
0.6013708710670471,
0.27347028255462646,
0.015695272013545036,
-0.1283632516860962,
0.15518291294574738,
0.29787299036979675,
-0.03700708597898483,
-0.5852393507957458,
1.032097339630127,
-0.7234304547309875,
-0.6325225830078125,
-0.3335178792476654,
-0.450306236743927,
-0.529667317867279,
0.20943424105644226,
-0.07987850904464722,
0.25620731711387634,
-0.6395968198776245,
0.3424093425273895,
0.0008249813690781593,
-0.10222653299570084,
0.3628464341163635,
0.936021089553833,
-0.5991030931472778,
-0.5395812392234802,
0.7692047953605652,
0.015396651811897755,
0.3341495096683502,
-0.1433602273464203,
0.09722825884819031,
-0.0740787610411644,
-0.552629292011261,
-0.30166855454444885,
0.2560754418373108,
-0.9629086256027222,
-0.2087635099887848,
-0.36005523800849915,
-0.18746747076511383,
-0.07842898368835449,
0.20039033889770508,
-0.6126184463500977,
-0.3163238763809204,
0.23635292053222656,
-0.29660764336586,
-0.06027940288186073,
1.1149264574050903,
0.062305621802806854,
-0.025376291945576668,
-0.5497385859489441,
0.048673227429389954,
0.3077961802482605,
0.8688688278198242,
0.3772982060909271,
-0.5479680895805359,
-0.10531918704509735,
-0.4551321268081665,
-0.6317359805107117,
-0.5224220752716064,
0.02260374277830124,
0.02201850898563862,
0.6474175453186035,
0.573744535446167,
-0.0853351354598999,
0.35230007767677307,
-0.40911397337913513,
0.7856549024581909,
-0.06103791669011116,
-1.1436383724212646,
0.21072769165039062,
-0.1899743527173996,
0.3390634059906006,
0.8257157802581787,
-0.029835984110832214,
-0.6276931166648865,
-0.5873504877090454,
-0.4280211329460144,
-0.5712773203849792,
0.5037655830383301,
-0.17575471103191376,
0.20414194464683533,
0.19900751113891602,
0.2952365279197693,
0.19134192168712616,
0.26758939027786255,
-0.8210959434509277,
0.28432610630989075,
-0.2179328352212906,
-0.04104069620370865,
-0.4733979403972626,
-0.540769636631012,
-0.2549799680709839,
-0.15988874435424805,
0.5648590922355652,
-0.3154696524143219,
-0.31385117769241333,
-0.025329548865556717,
-0.09705577790737152,
-0.44056466221809387,
0.4431205093860626,
0.3716419041156769,
0.8448574542999268,
0.08941306173801422,
0.27624624967575073,
0.39300796389579773,
-0.17567801475524902,
0.06409794837236404,
-0.07394304126501083,
0.11091489344835281,
-0.10199310630559921,
0.75660640001297,
0.58539879322052,
0.3289991021156311,
-0.767029345035553,
0.4478912949562073,
-0.022899623960256577,
-0.12248479574918747,
-0.3911515772342682,
0.14867377281188965,
0.23092927038669586,
0.33267462253570557,
-0.02570715919137001,
-0.09589549154043198,
0.0807560533285141,
-0.7269226908683777,
-0.04358619824051857,
0.43928062915802,
-0.5456954836845398,
-0.48519447445869446,
0.4106687903404236,
0.3496401011943817,
-0.21902872622013092,
0.645301103591919,
-0.01442667655646801,
-0.5946677923202515,
0.4057058095932007,
0.20580314099788666,
0.996734619140625,
-0.43585559725761414,
0.1317223161458969,
0.42903590202331543,
0.4978915750980377,
-0.09041201323270798,
0.26931196451187134,
0.0056400299072265625,
-0.545666515827179,
-0.4822870194911957,
-0.6756504774093628,
-0.6789105534553528,
0.37475791573524475,
-0.772653341293335,
0.10597432404756546,
-0.686907947063446,
-0.3670891225337982,
-0.034715160727500916,
0.1752767711877823,
-0.6912079453468323,
0.023113830015063286,
-0.021510964259505272,
1.0062357187271118,
-0.5484188795089722,
0.5473933219909668,
0.6065803170204163,
-0.3718326687812805,
-0.7195514440536499,
0.1609266847372055,
0.24891801178455353,
-0.7180584073066711,
0.614710807800293,
0.3224131166934967,
-0.3140764534473419,
-0.22670124471187592,
-0.38134637475013733,
-0.7996986508369446,
0.7425708770751953,
0.4281765818595886,
-1.0281790494918823,
0.19042865931987762,
-0.08088523149490356,
0.9222794771194458,
-0.16816380620002747,
0.6376925706863403,
0.9187231063842773,
0.606201708316803,
-0.2695889174938202,
-1.1731668710708618,
0.1387058049440384,
-0.4971214532852173,
0.0897064059972763,
0.14492952823638916,
-1.0575281381607056,
0.6662284731864929,
-0.16048793494701385,
-0.06818784773349762,
0.2865637242794037,
0.44835010170936584,
-0.0890006273984909,
-0.002271033124998212,
0.7604573369026184,
0.9543940424919128,
0.5337836146354675,
-0.2234088033437729,
1.1570584774017334,
-0.656602144241333,
0.3535577952861786,
1.2188578844070435,
-0.46833598613739014,
0.9433735609054565,
0.3490593433380127,
-0.27369651198387146,
0.8353376984596252,
0.41311317682266235,
-0.2314273864030838,
0.2445840686559677,
0.7742096781730652,
-0.017484767362475395,
-0.1643219292163849,
-0.045797888189554214,
-0.15277782082557678,
0.37711551785469055,
0.022047387436032295,
-0.3433741629123688,
-0.09679436683654785,
-0.27829140424728394,
-0.11497867852449417,
0.16656865179538727,
-0.30882418155670166,
0.7454344034194946,
0.19269070029258728,
-0.9300017356872559,
0.48023685812950134,
-0.005126680247485638,
0.2430979162454605,
-0.588536262512207,
0.2719692885875702,
-0.35153478384017944,
0.6528979539871216,
-0.3370276987552643,
-0.8232659697532654,
0.18965329229831696,
-0.042982254177331924,
-0.1282326877117157,
-0.009475229308009148,
0.3669477105140686,
-0.09956526756286621,
-0.36999574303627014,
0.7355230450630188,
0.4351799488067627,
0.015783855691552162,
-0.11378723382949829,
-0.5858583450317383,
0.6110499501228333,
-0.12312913686037064,
-0.6188719272613525,
0.14673668146133423,
0.343765527009964,
0.0574444904923439,
0.8972264528274536,
0.3361285924911499,
0.2903941869735718,
-0.3092203438282013,
0.5282198786735535,
0.9558301568031311,
-0.7658244371414185,
-0.22691002488136292,
-0.731895387172699,
0.28249210119247437,
-0.18883943557739258,
-0.5513017773628235,
0.9510385394096375,
0.49731722474098206,
1.2066611051559448,
-0.036628756672143936,
0.826537013053894,
0.1749509572982788,
0.8641058802604675,
-0.27372920513153076,
0.5598130822181702,
-0.40343040227890015,
0.1533389836549759,
-0.3722175359725952,
-1.3260250091552734,
0.03968236222863197,
0.4756600856781006,
-0.482561856508255,
0.3671596050262451,
1.0423474311828613,
0.9308807849884033,
0.12764543294906616,
-0.05739715322852135,
0.23084038496017456,
0.5075439810752869,
0.33102133870124817,
0.318752646446228,
1.1000579595565796,
0.1343229115009308,
0.5371392965316772,
-0.20309753715991974,
-0.214717298746109,
-0.28333982825279236,
-0.7380200624465942,
-1.1925734281539917,
-0.2808368504047394,
-0.12989328801631927,
-0.5067119598388672,
-0.2367134988307953,
0.6211518049240112,
0.6127508282661438,
-0.88707035779953,
-0.5024312734603882,
0.07914693653583527,
-0.10742473602294922,
-0.31423109769821167,
-0.2613276243209839,
0.07037559151649475,
-0.6461551189422607,
-0.6144436001777649,
0.5922951102256775,
0.20779338479042053,
-0.42714181542396545,
-1.190423846244812,
0.011733686551451683,
0.6339840292930603,
0.13756915926933289,
0.35978826880455017,
0.07700953632593155,
-0.8843026757240295,
-0.33062314987182617,
-0.2504642903804779,
-0.22743067145347595,
-0.29138171672821045,
1.1374318599700928,
-0.6277763247489929,
0.7440234422683716,
0.5448335409164429,
0.5069519877433777,
0.5088871717453003,
-0.19731071591377258,
0.6565967202186584,
-0.4916301965713501,
-0.03139585629105568,
0.3087828457355499,
0.489632785320282,
0.559648334980011,
0.20995408296585083,
0.7890865802764893,
0.0897388756275177,
-0.648381233215332,
-0.957718551158905,
0.2775834798812866,
-0.8176273703575134,
-0.25275152921676636,
1.024476170539856,
-0.15903474390506744,
-0.0740138441324234,
0.23487697541713715,
-0.2870793342590332,
-0.1858953982591629,
-0.1019955649971962,
0.8723320364952087,
1.0452558994293213,
0.3980709910392761,
-0.31971481442451477,
-0.6484934687614441,
0.3336065411567688,
0.5280028581619263,
-0.6650688648223877,
0.31588929891586304,
0.509441614151001,
0.5525912642478943,
0.1801263839006424,
0.37456953525543213,
-0.27964943647384644,
0.10130258649587631,
0.007183108013123274,
0.39500290155410767,
-0.05974291265010834,
-0.297780305147171,
-0.44294244050979614,
0.2926257848739624,
0.5423008799552917,
0.5314943790435791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13758v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13758v1
|
Factual Consistency Evaluation of Summarisation in the Era of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T12:35:19 | 2024-02-21T12:35:19 |
Zheheng Luo, Qianqian Xie, Sophia Ananiadou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Factual inconsistency with source documents in automatically generated
summaries can lead to misinformation or pose risks. Existing factual
consistency(FC) metrics are constrained by their performance, efficiency, and
explainability. Recent advances in Large language models (LLMs) have
demonstrated remarkable potential in text evaluation but their effectiveness in
assessing FC in summarisation remains underexplored. Prior research has mostly
focused on proprietary LLMs, leaving essential factors that affect their
assessment capabilities unexplored. Additionally, current FC evaluation
benchmarks are restricted to news articles, casting doubt on the generality of
the FC methods tested on them. In this paper, we first address the gap by
introducing TreatFact a dataset of LLM-generated summaries of clinical texts,
annotated for FC by domain experts. Moreover, we benchmark 11 LLMs for FC
evaluation across news and clinical domains and analyse the impact of model
size, prompts, pre-training and fine-tuning data. Our findings reveal that
despite proprietary models prevailing on the task, open-source LLMs lag behind.
Nevertheless, there is potential for enhancing the performance of open-source
LLMs through increasing model size, expanding pre-training data, and developing
well-curated fine-tuning data. Experiments on TreatFact suggest that both
previous methods and LLM-based evaluators are unable to capture factual
inconsistencies in clinical summaries, posing a new challenge for FC
evaluation.
|
[
-0.10346294194459915,
-0.4945128858089447,
0.8523184061050415,
0.21057286858558655,
-0.01104655209928751,
0.015924524515867233,
-0.3416382074356079,
-0.5796788930892944,
0.2053978592157364,
0.44532209634780884,
-0.20194299519062042,
-0.5423688292503357,
-1.0598654747009277,
0.5270997285842896,
-0.370756596326828,
1.1862576007843018,
-0.25700369477272034,
0.21430599689483643,
-0.5816954374313354,
-0.5994106531143188,
-0.2622808814048767,
-0.431790292263031,
-0.29175865650177,
-0.3662737309932709,
0.42980530858039856,
0.28796201944351196,
0.937020480632782,
0.5249127745628357,
0.8778461813926697,
0.2445594221353531,
-0.3088438808917999,
0.2774565517902374,
-0.6287092566490173,
-0.035204727202653885,
-0.2045973837375641,
-0.2778821587562561,
-0.39612919092178345,
0.03174144774675369,
0.6941059231758118,
0.9098947644233704,
-0.3514527976512909,
-0.08713234961032867,
-0.060070961713790894,
0.78157639503479,
-0.7273671627044678,
-0.05570799112319946,
-0.4964275658130646,
0.0804976373910904,
0.14619866013526917,
0.07470110803842545,
-0.45967093110084534,
-0.6816247701644897,
0.21531984210014343,
-0.40375930070877075,
0.3851354122161865,
0.030779557302594185,
0.9526858329772949,
0.11206994205713272,
-0.3956649899482727,
-0.5137736797332764,
-0.5633609890937805,
0.42519307136535645,
-1.1724525690078735,
0.46865057945251465,
0.24734480679035187,
0.1417083442211151,
-0.1876906156539917,
-0.7419915199279785,
-0.39131054282188416,
-0.6461692452430725,
-0.45923691987991333,
0.07036781311035156,
-0.3501532971858978,
0.06871389597654343,
0.427831768989563,
0.618583083152771,
-0.6139352917671204,
0.11131711304187775,
-0.25718453526496887,
-0.5437993407249451,
0.5447825789451599,
0.296800822019577,
0.3227378726005554,
-0.08082621544599533,
-0.4826500713825226,
0.37910595536231995,
-0.9734606742858887,
-0.08583684265613556,
-0.034287843853235245,
0.1886748969554901,
-0.27723702788352966,
0.8697075843811035,
-0.14943957328796387,
0.42697152495384216,
0.1389184147119522,
-0.4499029517173767,
0.23560568690299988,
-0.4505232870578766,
-0.26711684465408325,
0.2794274389743805,
0.9146386981010437,
0.6072217226028442,
0.12201658636331558,
-0.24513114988803864,
-0.03517279773950577,
-0.018969008699059486,
0.25428062677383423,
-0.7969263792037964,
-0.2354164868593216,
0.48589685559272766,
-0.37010642886161804,
-0.19858169555664062,
0.04558289051055908,
-0.5042223930358887,
-0.48309633135795593,
-0.29553401470184326,
0.5668596625328064,
-0.34994152188301086,
-0.3077777624130249,
0.14580154418945312,
-0.005108497571200132,
-0.05322341248393059,
0.6414003968238831,
-0.8536747097969055,
0.4518442153930664,
0.5975868105888367,
0.8937130570411682,
-0.303798109292984,
-0.15621772408485413,
-0.6975806951522827,
0.07112009823322296,
-0.6613607406616211,
0.9634506702423096,
-0.095496267080307,
-0.4377847909927368,
0.09123050421476364,
0.20309707522392273,
-0.09693683683872223,
-0.6741489768028259,
0.4950486719608307,
-0.06315863877534866,
0.21420568227767944,
-0.5887051820755005,
-0.717149019241333,
0.1571536809206009,
0.3916727900505066,
-0.6382960081100464,
0.748094379901886,
0.23683619499206543,
-0.8980042934417725,
0.5853435397148132,
-0.36803773045539856,
-0.5997214913368225,
-0.2977263629436493,
0.03915286436676979,
-0.6281121969223022,
0.362131804227829,
0.18172843754291534,
0.3292394280433655,
-0.17223533987998962,
0.586854100227356,
-0.31541475653648376,
-0.4295956492424011,
0.2571842074394226,
-0.40126413106918335,
0.47690489888191223,
0.12955141067504883,
-0.18669280409812927,
0.11589369177818298,
-0.5725165605545044,
-0.4371418058872223,
-0.15995469689369202,
-0.21333368122577667,
-0.22998861968517303,
-0.25029927492141724,
-0.15318457782268524,
0.1474532037973404,
0.2293967306613922,
-0.6398777365684509,
0.1004394143819809,
-0.44679999351501465,
0.11861016601324081,
0.3346153497695923,
0.12631481885910034,
0.02119111455976963,
-0.6474694013595581,
0.4142146706581116,
0.09014931321144104,
-0.05500767007470131,
-0.3509059548377991,
-0.17238441109657288,
-0.4822177588939667,
-0.42923808097839355,
0.4678531885147095,
0.24229298532009125,
-0.39834046363830566,
0.24227982759475708,
-0.49005836248397827,
-0.4322393238544464,
-0.5462830662727356,
0.0730394646525383,
0.45032376050949097,
0.6996620297431946,
0.3941119611263275,
-0.11253541707992554,
-0.37197789549827576,
-1.0913619995117188,
-0.265531063079834,
-0.20352892577648163,
0.023967165499925613,
-0.08378294855356216,
0.65654456615448,
-0.15768973529338837,
0.8133423924446106,
-0.35681429505348206,
-0.3088870048522949,
-0.4275781512260437,
0.35671088099479675,
0.12873926758766174,
0.31723010540008545,
0.4412147104740143,
-0.5781921148300171,
-0.436775267124176,
-0.08563832193613052,
-0.7444470524787903,
-0.2680620551109314,
-0.07366876304149628,
0.2328534871339798,
0.45643749833106995,
0.547048032283783,
-0.5151858329772949,
0.44641080498695374,
0.5475821495056152,
-0.2136954367160797,
0.7560847997665405,
-0.5072556138038635,
0.5175730586051941,
-0.6970053911209106,
0.40139469504356384,
0.013435663655400276,
-0.6280469298362732,
-0.4001277983188629,
-0.1801472008228302,
0.284297913312912,
0.20207293331623077,
-0.5532503724098206,
0.513253390789032,
-0.3348240852355957,
-0.0814044252038002,
-0.2849220931529999,
0.3668578565120697,
0.19669923186302185,
0.17783789336681366,
0.04490820690989494,
0.7402466535568237,
0.1906726211309433,
-0.46414846181869507,
0.09188658744096756,
0.4658863842487335,
-0.2942475974559784,
0.5789748430252075,
-0.828853189945221,
-0.35763654112815857,
-0.003283785656094551,
0.24406878650188446,
-1.2220317125320435,
-0.34029272198677063,
0.01950683258473873,
-0.3760715425014496,
0.4013129472732544,
-0.03361000493168831,
-0.46269941329956055,
-0.0685274675488472,
-0.46185311675071716,
0.013663046061992645,
0.35015735030174255,
-0.4870046079158783,
0.4539528489112854,
0.22356808185577393,
-0.369954913854599,
-0.7029454708099365,
-0.6351988315582275,
0.273100882768631,
-0.00009457570558879524,
-0.5430037975311279,
0.20715418457984924,
-0.18634894490242004,
-0.456054151058197,
0.09202694147825241,
-0.4792558550834656,
-0.0325721837580204,
0.0962018221616745,
0.08493174612522125,
0.22502397000789642,
-0.2841184735298157,
0.08926153182983398,
0.07313810288906097,
0.14211246371269226,
0.19217389822006226,
0.3846704363822937,
0.1161639392375946,
-0.15026329457759857,
-0.4678858518600464,
-0.3734118342399597,
0.1573963314294815,
0.669842004776001,
-0.15122820436954498,
0.8567407727241516,
0.39066341519355774,
-0.36051690578460693,
0.01725935935974121,
-0.6958722472190857,
0.11187050491571426,
-0.31574195623397827,
0.2112375646829605,
-0.06553716957569122,
-0.9121966361999512,
0.5917753577232361,
-0.04398937523365021,
0.12358006834983826,
0.8136034607887268,
0.5629468560218811,
-0.06335832923650742,
0.7396391034126282,
0.5698191523551941,
0.1259966492652893,
-0.16587857902050018,
0.05178818106651306,
-0.018066925927996635,
-0.6452657580375671,
-0.34060612320899963,
-0.5450155138969421,
0.17070645093917847,
-0.37837108969688416,
-0.12070129066705704,
0.6425095796585083,
0.048530541360378265,
0.09292609989643097,
0.0059778764843940735,
-0.02853112295269966,
0.4850229322910309,
-0.06833163648843765,
0.15637677907943726,
0.7684548497200012,
-0.12335621565580368,
-0.14196689426898956,
-0.11198877543210983,
-0.7471182942390442,
-0.5206627249717712,
1.115474820137024,
0.4619317650794983,
0.4723834991455078,
0.2503591477870941,
0.38833317160606384,
0.6200567483901978,
0.8629836440086365,
-0.7553704977035522,
0.29508429765701294,
-0.09386135637760162,
-0.5700716376304626,
-0.14998404681682587,
-0.3863181471824646,
-0.803537130355835,
0.2294725626707077,
-0.5238624215126038,
-0.517936646938324,
-0.012992283329367638,
0.03562609478831291,
-0.2966005206108093,
0.20890362560749054,
-0.4954605996608734,
0.760565459728241,
-0.009847341105341911,
-0.4463231861591339,
-0.1613560914993286,
-0.5775179862976074,
0.7085155844688416,
-0.2564159035682678,
0.20699281990528107,
-0.06096266955137253,
0.0970919206738472,
0.6162698864936829,
-0.8061426281929016,
0.6407147645950317,
0.08736582100391388,
-0.36476802825927734,
0.03135831654071808,
0.10998336225748062,
0.36069151759147644,
0.23309944570064545,
0.057621996849775314,
0.3746796250343323,
0.2518576681613922,
-0.3459616005420685,
-0.6159608364105225,
0.6258041858673096,
-0.5052036046981812,
-0.6890370845794678,
-0.5886123180389404,
-0.3281309902667999,
-0.521200954914093,
0.08464279025793076,
0.2566852271556854,
0.8162824511528015,
-0.6127928495407104,
0.22376234829425812,
0.7975385189056396,
-0.2669250965118408,
0.24786460399627686,
0.9926753044128418,
-0.24104595184326172,
-0.5097277760505676,
0.524645984172821,
-0.06806568801403046,
0.4538392722606659,
0.41805002093315125,
0.24475470185279846,
-0.427202045917511,
-0.8601486086845398,
-0.32949817180633545,
0.4010362923145294,
-0.6681883335113525,
-0.24324160814285278,
-0.7647258639335632,
-0.2653892934322357,
-0.6032571792602539,
-0.1311454325914383,
-0.371916800737381,
-0.2832111716270447,
0.13350962102413177,
-0.22567075490951538,
0.24994342029094696,
0.8823725581169128,
-0.25085434317588806,
0.17897318303585052,
-0.8530715107917786,
0.5158741474151611,
-0.11431965976953506,
0.5362379550933838,
-0.2345021367073059,
-0.6750331521034241,
-0.4928205907344818,
-0.05062307044863701,
-0.011076925322413445,
-0.7077032327651978,
0.20049427449703217,
-0.05438655987381935,
0.6503231525421143,
0.5275290608406067,
0.12788473069667816,
0.45595189929008484,
-0.44578397274017334,
0.8162471652030945,
0.33823564648628235,
-0.9729570150375366,
0.32542675733566284,
-0.35993003845214844,
0.34678950905799866,
0.8054413199424744,
0.5335497856140137,
-0.5314401984214783,
-0.6052833199501038,
-0.6900631189346313,
-0.6848870515823364,
0.5537319779396057,
0.16230891644954681,
-0.3441215753555298,
-0.07996167987585068,
0.16988663375377655,
0.40649932622909546,
0.32585543394088745,
-0.4953732192516327,
-0.10547474771738052,
-0.05018322542309761,
-0.3383990228176117,
-0.23452527821063995,
-0.5541737675666809,
-0.45795556902885437,
-0.048877596855163574,
0.5832730531692505,
-0.05546330660581589,
0.061403390020132065,
0.5925591588020325,
-0.2512841522693634,
-0.2948514223098755,
0.2835801839828491,
0.8821092247962952,
1.1527196168899536,
-0.364981472492218,
0.02057536132633686,
0.25067588686943054,
-0.6297184824943542,
0.13513727486133575,
0.20503434538841248,
-0.0324537493288517,
0.27944666147232056,
0.8827577829360962,
0.6150534152984619,
0.4735608398914337,
-0.9219080805778503,
0.8334699869155884,
-0.11536960303783417,
-0.43622857332229614,
-0.2536090910434723,
0.07237078994512558,
-0.021655073389410973,
-0.03695664927363396,
0.07651177793741226,
0.18332576751708984,
0.055537186563014984,
-0.4593554735183716,
0.2090366780757904,
0.32554954290390015,
-0.388023316860199,
-0.1494407206773758,
0.6191872358322144,
-0.10832975059747696,
0.013428737409412861,
0.34866923093795776,
0.09802531450986862,
-0.1646178811788559,
0.6714237332344055,
0.37420687079429626,
0.6269570589065552,
-0.08136053383350372,
0.3699119985103607,
0.36359328031539917,
0.4896203875541687,
-0.4223051369190216,
0.15046246349811554,
0.30504631996154785,
-0.5719764828681946,
-0.4888187646865845,
-0.4544902741909027,
-0.8329113721847534,
0.23642341792583466,
-0.6302579641342163,
0.2539921700954437,
-0.3857206404209137,
0.1475294828414917,
-0.06917135417461395,
0.0884854644536972,
-0.3918640911579132,
0.4096029996871948,
-0.0037942773196846247,
1.135472297668457,
-0.8504645228385925,
0.560565173625946,
0.5844281911849976,
-0.4108507037162781,
-0.6915452480316162,
0.07947258651256561,
0.07419802993535995,
-0.4334961473941803,
0.10704854130744934,
0.13755257427692413,
0.01587790995836258,
-0.49605971574783325,
-0.47171297669410706,
-0.8108839392662048,
0.8939512968063354,
0.47610315680503845,
-0.624255895614624,
0.11978569626808167,
0.14103123545646667,
0.7930096983909607,
-0.3465484082698822,
0.3801288902759552,
0.5332827568054199,
0.5037022829055786,
0.2638028860092163,
-1.134037971496582,
0.052201006561517715,
-0.04699738323688507,
-0.47595152258872986,
0.06902403384447098,
-0.45903652906417847,
0.3002009987831116,
-0.5696519017219543,
-0.08048158138990402,
0.15138673782348633,
0.6224948167800903,
0.2602021396160126,
0.5191245675086975,
0.2546631395816803,
0.4528745710849762,
0.8737772107124329,
-0.2414012849330902,
1.1272183656692505,
-0.2140839844942093,
0.3069736361503601,
1.092525601387024,
-0.46895262598991394,
0.6738682389259338,
0.12275520712137222,
-0.24381929636001587,
0.2775878310203552,
0.27552729845046997,
-0.12940524518489838,
0.370262086391449,
-0.008936988189816475,
-0.06894952803850174,
-0.0469077005982399,
-0.08014199882745743,
-0.3684707581996918,
0.28113171458244324,
0.2512916624546051,
-0.35737624764442444,
-0.3100433051586151,
-0.03066442348062992,
0.37420111894607544,
0.3132651746273041,
-0.4551398456096649,
0.8454524874687195,
-0.05962447449564934,
-0.7037057876586914,
0.657311201095581,
0.013048756867647171,
0.35526302456855774,
-0.9694883823394775,
-0.022638492286205292,
-0.48816978931427,
-0.03687275946140289,
-0.43331247568130493,
-0.6491546630859375,
0.568784773349762,
0.14617295563220978,
-0.20506003499031067,
0.07333163172006607,
0.5382285714149475,
-0.5543399453163147,
-0.4075678586959839,
-0.05321555584669113,
0.5375971794128418,
0.10858297348022461,
0.17999672889709473,
-0.3143579363822937,
0.19298601150512695,
-0.05184752494096756,
-0.12369973957538605,
0.44764047861099243,
0.5966629385948181,
0.09750032424926758,
0.5201982259750366,
0.465387225151062,
0.41023948788642883,
-0.5258716344833374,
-0.040083423256874084,
0.7739134430885315,
-0.6004915237426758,
-0.17044095695018768,
-0.8777669072151184,
0.4830530881881714,
0.023905999958515167,
-0.39966392517089844,
0.8223831057548523,
0.7193886637687683,
0.4142853021621704,
0.08057018369436264,
0.6926041841506958,
0.2185901701450348,
0.6806670427322388,
-0.7149307131767273,
0.8865145444869995,
-0.4812113344669342,
0.19953201711177826,
-0.3648727238178253,
-0.5861015319824219,
-0.2940954864025116,
0.1444273591041565,
-0.3439370393753052,
-0.09874476492404938,
0.9888252019882202,
0.535118818283081,
-0.1021379679441452,
0.23337669670581818,
0.46377506852149963,
0.6811103820800781,
0.29894453287124634,
0.1825733482837677,
0.6189969182014465,
-0.18316474556922913,
0.283414363861084,
0.00972393061965704,
-0.22066162526607513,
-0.1998133510351181,
-1.1236215829849243,
-0.8412145376205444,
-0.266557902097702,
-0.5349676609039307,
-0.5011482834815979,
0.318294882774353,
0.9938462972640991,
0.3460026979446411,
-0.8801432847976685,
0.05651582032442093,
0.12316995114088058,
0.1489095240831375,
-0.308973491191864,
-0.1867627054452896,
0.5752350687980652,
-0.3594709038734436,
-0.4338938891887665,
0.3350355327129364,
0.39586809277534485,
-0.0033433916978538036,
-0.2896975576877594,
0.13778267800807953,
-0.13477106392383575,
0.034141719341278076,
0.5635084509849548,
0.2344425618648529,
-0.6150693297386169,
-0.015751883387565613,
-0.300361692905426,
-0.32664281129837036,
0.2708130180835724,
0.7416900992393494,
-0.8237535953521729,
0.3197999894618988,
0.19209343194961548,
0.6148590445518494,
0.25642696022987366,
0.15189288556575775,
0.6897783875465393,
-0.3321087062358856,
-0.24048937857151031,
0.11072123050689697,
0.5238184332847595,
0.5580142736434937,
-0.41618818044662476,
0.4164520502090454,
0.22135454416275024,
-0.47995081543922424,
-0.8250364065170288,
-0.10670442134141922,
-0.9911799430847168,
-0.3342781662940979,
1.1125980615615845,
-0.4407147467136383,
-0.13967357575893402,
-0.15811502933502197,
-0.1720696985721588,
0.042833566665649414,
-0.22720545530319214,
0.910083532333374,
0.7760893106460571,
-0.10235493630170822,
0.10693664103746414,
-0.46475180983543396,
0.7065404057502747,
0.3343654274940491,
-0.8193119168281555,
0.31944340467453003,
0.7644684314727783,
0.5755562782287598,
-0.008128875866532326,
0.7658332586288452,
-0.3655086159706116,
0.3613797426223755,
-0.2631395161151886,
-0.14038556814193726,
-0.1629587858915329,
-0.37552958726882935,
-0.529081404209137,
0.2402476668357849,
-0.03558836132287979,
0.5165550708770752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13753v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13753v1
|
LongRoPE: Extending LLM Context Window Beyond 2 Million Tokens
| 2024-02-21T12:30:33 | 2024-02-21T12:30:33 |
Yiran Ding, Li Lyna Zhang, Chengruidong Zhang, Yuanyuan Xu, Ning Shang, Jiahang Xu, Fan Yang, Mao Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large context window is a desirable feature in large language models (LLMs).
However, due to high fine-tuning costs, scarcity of long texts, and
catastrophic values introduced by new token positions, current extended context
windows are limited to around 128k tokens. This paper introduces LongRoPE that,
for the first time, extends the context window of pre-trained LLMs to an
impressive 2048k tokens, with up to only 1k fine-tuning steps at within 256k
training lengths, while maintaining performance at the original short context
window. This is achieved by three key innovations: (i) we identify and exploit
two forms of non-uniformities in positional interpolation through an efficient
search, providing a better initialization for fine-tuning and enabling an 8x
extension in non-fine-tuning scenarios; (ii) we introduce a progressive
extension strategy that first fine-tunes a 256k length LLM and then conducts a
second positional interpolation on the fine-tuned extended LLM to achieve a
2048k context window; (iii) we readjust LongRoPE on 8k length to recover the
short context window performance. Extensive experiments on LLaMA2 and Mistral
across various tasks demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. Models
extended via LongRoPE retain the original architecture with minor modifications
to the positional embedding, and can reuse most pre-existing optimizations.
|
[
-0.40411725640296936,
-0.5912079811096191,
0.6257993578910828,
0.3333907723426819,
-0.6390406489372253,
0.08653691411018372,
-0.6826115846633911,
-0.7315871715545654,
0.17864933609962463,
0.4538978934288025,
-0.4714047312736511,
-0.5601006150245667,
-0.596904993057251,
-0.027563411742448807,
-0.15240931510925293,
0.8705850839614868,
0.00721109751611948,
-0.3894391655921936,
0.2834615707397461,
-0.22193971276283264,
-0.4510023891925812,
-0.3369157910346985,
-0.6463242769241333,
-0.0033596788998693228,
0.547610878944397,
0.4530700743198395,
0.5140050649642944,
0.6046611070632935,
0.1394989788532257,
0.2813750207424164,
-0.17640167474746704,
0.32555723190307617,
-0.7112834453582764,
0.007266227621585131,
-0.11208977550268173,
-0.3592977225780487,
-0.6824496984481812,
-0.0515286810696125,
0.8758596777915955,
0.5696232914924622,
0.07463674247264862,
0.14872466027736664,
0.41329845786094666,
0.7061678767204285,
-0.5977729558944702,
0.24672330915927887,
-0.6600897312164307,
-0.16512206196784973,
-0.3924911618232727,
-0.2892052233219147,
-0.4368731379508972,
0.02771810255944729,
0.2268911451101303,
-0.68767249584198,
-0.20357167720794678,
-0.012117013335227966,
0.45476874709129333,
0.2905188202857971,
-0.6351149082183838,
-0.10807240009307861,
-0.5025099515914917,
0.7948324084281921,
-0.6800837516784668,
0.47385379672050476,
0.0543123260140419,
0.22296227514743805,
-0.502153217792511,
-0.8813587427139282,
-0.28044652938842773,
-0.4673517942428589,
0.2444126307964325,
-0.12103116512298584,
-0.15012305974960327,
0.4259726107120514,
0.2747229337692261,
0.05202064663171768,
-0.3075486123561859,
0.4398878216743469,
-0.4040054678916931,
-0.05245104432106018,
0.3799114525318146,
-0.0494915172457695,
-0.09951557219028473,
0.09137994796037674,
-0.6623566746711731,
0.09048926830291748,
-0.6966542601585388,
0.21266844868659973,
0.2049822062253952,
0.11681290715932846,
0.0397745780646801,
0.3558235466480255,
-0.04464264586567879,
0.8858204483985901,
0.01679222099483013,
-0.16855064034461975,
0.07099626958370209,
-0.27936530113220215,
-0.16290606558322906,
0.011913631111383438,
0.373487263917923,
0.4062921404838562,
0.04692763090133667,
-0.1915372610092163,
-0.0963120236992836,
-0.2558175325393677,
0.01043701171875,
-0.8954483866691589,
0.35190549492836,
0.03845595195889473,
-0.08137869834899902,
-0.04263782501220703,
0.0325196199119091,
-0.682704508304596,
-0.12428215891122818,
-0.45189759135246277,
0.15589477121829987,
-0.4410678446292877,
-0.03238794207572937,
0.2555485963821411,
0.041865959763526917,
0.3164709508419037,
0.3970731496810913,
-0.7722928524017334,
0.2576036751270294,
1.186265230178833,
0.8218190670013428,
-0.526315450668335,
-0.5850915312767029,
-0.6814576983451843,
0.21713626384735107,
-0.4614638090133667,
0.5417495965957642,
-0.5180367827415466,
-0.2965318262577057,
-0.025581102818250656,
0.3482847809791565,
0.17869725823402405,
-0.5212990641593933,
0.42125585675239563,
-0.5817049741744995,
0.07681840658187866,
0.027940064668655396,
-0.5269424319267273,
-0.07370897382497787,
0.21869593858718872,
-0.4793834388256073,
1.4019545316696167,
0.37806373834609985,
-0.30639350414276123,
0.4293891191482544,
-0.8630816340446472,
-0.29393470287323,
0.146138995885849,
0.06840004771947861,
-0.1381971836090088,
0.4024816155433655,
-0.06591484695672989,
0.24053631722927094,
-0.27733418345451355,
0.4116623103618622,
-0.2812221944332123,
-0.6635559797286987,
-0.13122399151325226,
-0.4143487513065338,
0.39305979013442993,
-0.06294796615839005,
-0.4359924793243408,
0.4127008020877838,
-0.73247230052948,
0.12345077097415924,
-0.3514414131641388,
-0.6028887033462524,
-0.4316951632499695,
-0.2775316834449768,
-0.03695457801222801,
0.09729064255952835,
0.5128333568572998,
-0.5242244005203247,
0.3085346519947052,
-0.5411539077758789,
0.7353911995887756,
0.743549108505249,
-0.3228464126586914,
0.5665590167045593,
-0.01956983096897602,
0.5049383044242859,
-0.1056230366230011,
0.13598138093948364,
-0.23899298906326294,
-0.1672864854335785,
-0.5277312994003296,
-0.48602864146232605,
0.23582138121128082,
0.31311702728271484,
-0.47780710458755493,
0.6373364925384521,
-0.5896071195602417,
-0.1029537171125412,
-0.21210959553718567,
0.0816860944032669,
0.0894005298614502,
0.31668421626091003,
0.2568693459033966,
-0.1699519008398056,
-0.6793072819709778,
-0.8889265060424805,
-0.18273720145225525,
-0.04448504373431206,
-0.16755782067775726,
0.25516340136528015,
0.4020423889160156,
-0.3168342113494873,
1.0934250354766846,
-0.3903399109840393,
-0.11531075835227966,
0.041955072432756424,
-0.34293320775032043,
0.3642832934856415,
0.3992604613304138,
0.4039805829524994,
-0.5057070851325989,
-0.4153452217578888,
-0.012109489180147648,
-0.4340077340602875,
-0.019705649465322495,
0.017923220992088318,
-0.1596021056175232,
0.3177436590194702,
0.8406414985656738,
-0.6526843309402466,
0.24350380897521973,
0.7480186820030212,
-0.38533204793930054,
0.6004059314727783,
-0.2524798512458801,
-0.15866287052631378,
-1.1894077062606812,
-0.13560554385185242,
-0.1187402680516243,
-0.6416112780570984,
-0.4631858468055725,
0.33561044931411743,
0.2194080352783203,
-0.35745108127593994,
-0.46748682856559753,
0.8772948980331421,
-0.5984029769897461,
0.009219640865921974,
-0.6977553367614746,
0.33462369441986084,
-0.10467641055583954,
0.4697771370410919,
-0.08709027618169785,
1.0652693510055542,
0.5392909049987793,
-0.3204864263534546,
0.210146963596344,
-0.12178832292556763,
-0.5561346411705017,
0.19714343547821045,
-0.41162219643592834,
0.2416461855173111,
-0.18907371163368225,
0.6374385356903076,
-0.8888627886772156,
-0.029899412766098976,
-0.09679590910673141,
-0.12767542898654938,
0.26951202750205994,
-0.20118756592273712,
-0.22666503489017487,
-0.3589820861816406,
-0.6716437935829163,
0.6391065120697021,
0.4095505475997925,
-1.0391302108764648,
0.46086475253105164,
0.12078317999839783,
-0.11258408427238464,
-0.664217472076416,
-0.3174627721309662,
0.6238827705383301,
-0.5482355356216431,
-0.6939100027084351,
0.5421023964881897,
-0.05705229938030243,
-0.017222629860043526,
-0.2944628596305847,
-0.11547534167766571,
0.13828827440738678,
0.00032052036840468645,
0.14857074618339539,
0.05713418498635292,
-0.3343171179294586,
0.2251417338848114,
0.09317460656166077,
-0.17096948623657227,
-0.2071976512670517,
-0.667832612991333,
0.8006986975669861,
-0.4240802228450775,
-0.06489811092615128,
-0.19487327337265015,
0.22604915499687195,
0.7385826110839844,
-0.0681244432926178,
0.6684660315513611,
0.4266684055328369,
-0.396218866109848,
-0.22478702664375305,
-0.5573713183403015,
-0.21990741789340973,
-0.5572001934051514,
0.9745816588401794,
-0.39601200819015503,
-1.2593302726745605,
0.30135565996170044,
-0.44356203079223633,
0.018601801246404648,
0.20126394927501678,
0.2002154439687729,
0.13304618000984192,
0.6535311937332153,
0.952984631061554,
-0.30126187205314636,
0.7335537075996399,
-0.11636581271886826,
0.07495925575494766,
-1.153567910194397,
-0.011912737041711807,
0.01207698043435812,
-0.23492881655693054,
-0.6701918840408325,
-0.7954493165016174,
0.5412346720695496,
0.5576874017715454,
-0.15656530857086182,
0.5131127238273621,
-0.26383116841316223,
0.683677613735199,
0.3410477340221405,
0.13963833451271057,
0.11398930847644806,
0.034283347427845,
0.08219369500875473,
0.09535378962755203,
-0.5632861256599426,
-0.4914114475250244,
0.9058412909507751,
0.6217468976974487,
0.3986619710922241,
0.16861052811145782,
0.5702270269393921,
-0.01719159074127674,
0.18087132275104523,
-0.9607641100883484,
0.7323642373085022,
-0.21679982542991638,
-0.42215096950531006,
-0.750404953956604,
-0.07001255452632904,
-0.8906472325325012,
0.22395829856395721,
0.11807166039943695,
-0.8007007241249084,
0.02034405618906021,
0.04999023675918579,
-0.2977161109447479,
0.1550203263759613,
-0.4081467390060425,
0.5708495378494263,
-0.1575535386800766,
-0.6683094501495361,
-0.5240190625190735,
-0.612570583820343,
0.18485330045223236,
-0.2482045441865921,
-0.015019204467535019,
-0.2586171627044678,
-0.4767042398452759,
0.6956824064254761,
-0.49902617931365967,
0.81431645154953,
-0.19955959916114807,
-0.3625918924808502,
0.24378882348537445,
-0.21924450993537903,
0.9316615462303162,
0.2491772472858429,
-0.20064392685890198,
0.14672784507274628,
-0.10299252718687057,
-0.5350615382194519,
-0.5759232640266418,
0.8824853897094727,
-0.2441929280757904,
-0.8352797031402588,
-0.1756461262702942,
-0.5775970816612244,
-0.3724052608013153,
0.3299218416213989,
0.07925175875425339,
0.4913070797920227,
-0.10979131609201431,
0.460483193397522,
0.20683503150939941,
-0.06089598312973976,
0.6594570279121399,
0.5038273930549622,
-0.12238534539937973,
-0.4014700651168823,
0.5055918097496033,
-0.09614309668540955,
0.21219757199287415,
0.15240617096424103,
0.3106994032859802,
-0.40463194251060486,
-0.7443050742149353,
-0.47972267866134644,
0.1124529242515564,
-0.6191840767860413,
-0.06353220343589783,
-0.1710350215435028,
-0.15015968680381775,
-0.2100173979997635,
-0.18709678947925568,
-0.334097683429718,
-0.5101573467254639,
-0.31717097759246826,
-0.22995027899742126,
0.4599924683570862,
0.29551729559898376,
-0.09855218976736069,
0.7252446413040161,
-0.5755161046981812,
-0.11959017068147659,
0.25131306052207947,
0.5400546789169312,
0.036184605211019516,
-0.5836326479911804,
-0.31206852197647095,
-0.08505484461784363,
-0.08430133014917374,
-0.5085617303848267,
0.244582399725914,
0.24847444891929626,
0.20206058025360107,
0.4567825198173523,
-0.209649920463562,
1.0413403511047363,
-0.8601255416870117,
0.6904677152633667,
0.3752360939979553,
-0.775983989238739,
0.09899267554283142,
-0.5571543574333191,
0.4461357295513153,
0.6665813326835632,
-0.00407025683671236,
-0.513390839099884,
-0.08683406561613083,
-0.1062842458486557,
-0.9643211364746094,
0.3490053415298462,
-0.12659385800361633,
0.30974090099334717,
-0.24137133359909058,
0.842907190322876,
0.16855552792549133,
0.0029096268117427826,
-0.5236369967460632,
0.07111968845129013,
0.10106845200061798,
-0.09548152983188629,
-0.28321775794029236,
-0.46294546127319336,
-0.1424311399459839,
-0.5313970446586609,
0.5373698472976685,
-0.5564615726470947,
0.0007506604888476431,
0.11502929776906967,
-0.10985391587018967,
0.06120535358786583,
0.3627854287624359,
0.8177728652954102,
1.015062928199768,
-0.07032453268766403,
0.22529852390289307,
0.7045601010322571,
-0.3375382125377655,
0.0930517241358757,
0.14630764722824097,
0.2661445736885071,
-0.23800013959407806,
0.4219123125076294,
1.1750288009643555,
0.535293459892273,
-0.6384673714637756,
0.42627909779548645,
0.21218784153461456,
0.04841462895274162,
-0.5797655582427979,
-0.030525732785463333,
0.09699297696352005,
0.48044347763061523,
0.4563092291355133,
-0.17612604796886444,
-0.0047904388047754765,
-0.6884515285491943,
0.42717939615249634,
0.6543960571289062,
-0.5153849720954895,
-0.4408018887042999,
0.5590258240699768,
0.16832390427589417,
-0.3383041322231293,
0.25077325105667114,
0.04135175794363022,
-0.42767998576164246,
0.480767160654068,
0.876532256603241,
0.6282424926757812,
-0.060664985328912735,
-0.15880411863327026,
0.28478312492370605,
0.06510503590106964,
-0.2428208887577057,
0.08595304936170578,
-0.11143386363983154,
-0.33560535311698914,
-0.6634209752082825,
-0.643377959728241,
-0.06504716724157333,
0.23766997456550598,
-0.46633121371269226,
0.5302978754043579,
-0.39533641934394836,
-0.27043837308883667,
-0.32463935017585754,
0.199078768491745,
-0.32378286123275757,
-0.03887258097529411,
0.16273005306720734,
1.379151701927185,
-0.21743766963481903,
1.1510236263275146,
0.32705357670783997,
0.3565423786640167,
-0.4186531901359558,
0.06371291726827621,
-0.31938332319259644,
-1.0357258319854736,
0.3894965648651123,
0.4169214069843292,
-0.46205630898475647,
0.07521841675043106,
-0.5322554111480713,
-0.9631034731864929,
1.1270674467086792,
0.37282946705818176,
-1.0257714986801147,
-0.3412267863750458,
0.28494399785995483,
0.5321816205978394,
-0.490881085395813,
-0.0924520492553711,
0.7956237196922302,
0.4368590712547302,
-0.02699650079011917,
-1.040845274925232,
0.18034955859184265,
0.1665898561477661,
0.06672552227973938,
0.4026297628879547,
-0.8543329834938049,
0.4696718454360962,
-0.12252914160490036,
-0.06105823814868927,
0.3671228885650635,
0.6605157256126404,
0.3145902156829834,
0.1325957179069519,
0.7215884327888489,
0.4380970299243927,
0.7128900289535522,
0.059401847422122955,
0.8280566334724426,
-0.6451410055160522,
0.23065020143985748,
1.174058198928833,
-0.2740788161754608,
0.9691643118858337,
0.6135539412498474,
0.06940846890211105,
0.38588401675224304,
0.6389354467391968,
0.2956490218639374,
0.42291000485420227,
0.286028116941452,
-0.605521559715271,
-0.22282974421977997,
0.05900881439447403,
-0.27762696146965027,
0.4526284635066986,
0.38261520862579346,
-0.2629273533821106,
-0.24914410710334778,
0.20428505539894104,
0.05931776762008667,
-0.12825711071491241,
-0.36099591851234436,
0.6343650221824646,
0.378339022397995,
-0.8245063424110413,
0.7401416301727295,
0.19606521725654602,
0.8347523212432861,
-0.6454084515571594,
0.19519872963428497,
-0.03948378190398216,
0.29430055618286133,
0.05735444277524948,
-0.5861811637878418,
0.08495330810546875,
-0.3143404722213745,
0.043020859360694885,
-0.08273354172706604,
0.5549659132957458,
-0.5243279337882996,
-0.26042792201042175,
0.6464861035346985,
0.07166498899459839,
-0.03315502405166626,
-0.18469296395778656,
-0.3216516375541687,
-0.018724769353866577,
-0.07068898528814316,
-0.3485308885574341,
0.4222366213798523,
0.3940030336380005,
-0.39618295431137085,
0.5416669845581055,
0.5948733687400818,
-0.030116384848952293,
0.26026391983032227,
-0.1893204003572464,
1.0340938568115234,
-0.8390223979949951,
-0.5697577595710754,
-1.0265294313430786,
0.23682360351085663,
-0.03208751231431961,
-0.41780608892440796,
0.6190847158432007,
0.8466722965240479,
0.475975900888443,
0.10524027794599533,
0.5071834921836853,
0.4010467827320099,
0.2876603603363037,
-0.6022976636886597,
0.31622493267059326,
-0.5841913223266602,
0.18434923887252808,
0.11627989262342453,
-1.1116559505462646,
-0.22031134366989136,
0.2750359773635864,
-0.3682357966899872,
-0.18886125087738037,
0.6945881843566895,
0.6360867023468018,
-0.17950403690338135,
-0.1174384355545044,
0.3784366846084595,
0.18245066702365875,
0.4347863495349884,
0.6873728036880493,
0.9002146124839783,
-0.2245107889175415,
0.3983088731765747,
0.1231972873210907,
-0.4682987332344055,
-0.1554851531982422,
-1.0453753471374512,
-0.7798522114753723,
-0.396656334400177,
0.024538615718483925,
-0.2570352256298065,
0.13848862051963806,
1.0705705881118774,
1.081339955329895,
-0.5231902003288269,
-0.26681283116340637,
0.02198617532849312,
-0.21612851321697235,
0.05622382089495659,
-0.12652263045310974,
0.42181211709976196,
-0.2658032476902008,
-0.8424198627471924,
0.9817858338356018,
0.5447897911071777,
0.021026138216257095,
-0.12588156759738922,
-0.28811702132225037,
0.16892509162425995,
0.1596726030111313,
1.0471876859664917,
0.2847227454185486,
-0.641607403755188,
-0.5899000763893127,
-0.01764334738254547,
0.24461394548416138,
0.3126640319824219,
0.7795161604881287,
-0.7413749098777771,
0.12004493176937103,
0.18853706121444702,
0.36755529046058655,
0.8325853943824768,
0.1785709112882614,
0.5653873682022095,
-0.9250273108482361,
0.6728142499923706,
0.1750502735376358,
0.33701127767562866,
-0.03487895429134369,
-0.2427942305803299,
0.41827258467674255,
-0.2205454558134079,
-0.47176694869995117,
-0.925127387046814,
0.3204030990600586,
-1.0288474559783936,
-0.4713189899921417,
1.2567253112792969,
0.053628865629434586,
-0.24634204804897308,
0.12643282115459442,
-0.2614244818687439,
0.09993410110473633,
-0.3351753056049347,
0.7110242247581482,
0.6786232590675354,
-0.1237441748380661,
0.014679660089313984,
-0.6066989898681641,
0.5696004033088684,
0.4140247702598572,
-0.8192160725593567,
0.22321012616157532,
0.32842546701431274,
0.531981348991394,
-0.09262154251337051,
0.5870970487594604,
-0.22014731168746948,
0.1433015614748001,
-0.4746497869491577,
-0.40045610070228577,
-0.2581690847873688,
-0.6749468445777893,
-0.5261568427085876,
0.2866272032260895,
0.24399593472480774,
-0.15753716230392456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13750v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13750v1
|
Breaking the Barrier: Utilizing Large Language Models for Industrial Recommendation Systems through an Inferential Knowledge Graph
| 2024-02-21T12:22:01 | 2024-02-21T12:22:01 |
Qian Zhao, Hao Qian, Ziqi Liu, Gong-Duo Zhang, Lihong Gu
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recommendation systems are widely used in e-commerce websites and online
platforms to address information overload. However, existing systems primarily
rely on historical data and user feedback, making it difficult to capture user
intent transitions. Recently, Knowledge Base (KB)-based models are proposed to
incorporate expert knowledge, but it struggle to adapt to new items and the
evolving e-commerce environment. To address these challenges, we propose a
novel Large Language Model based Complementary Knowledge Enhanced
Recommendation System (LLM-KERec). It introduces an entity extractor that
extracts unified concept terms from item and user information. To provide
cost-effective and reliable prior knowledge, entity pairs are generated based
on entity popularity and specific strategies. The large language model
determines complementary relationships in each entity pair, constructing a
complementary knowledge graph. Furthermore, a new complementary recall module
and an Entity-Entity-Item (E-E-I) weight decision model refine the scoring of
the ranking model using real complementary exposure-click samples. Extensive
experiments conducted on three industry datasets demonstrate the significant
performance improvement of our model compared to existing approaches.
Additionally, detailed analysis shows that LLM-KERec enhances users' enthusiasm
for consumption by recommending complementary items. In summary, LLM-KERec
addresses the limitations of traditional recommendation systems by
incorporating complementary knowledge and utilizing a large language model to
capture user intent transitions, adapt to new items, and enhance recommendation
efficiency in the evolving e-commerce landscape.
|
[
-0.27980273962020874,
-0.53007572889328,
0.6889192461967468,
-0.03682441636919975,
-0.08650901913642883,
-0.05592953413724899,
-0.18091338872909546,
-0.9602885246276855,
0.2838447391986847,
0.6744866371154785,
-0.5229657292366028,
-0.7950939536094666,
-0.17273075878620148,
-0.007224328815937042,
-0.034395284950733185,
0.8968007564544678,
0.12311446666717529,
-0.13247767090797424,
-0.3244040012359619,
-0.15706123411655426,
-0.5828547477722168,
-0.5491699576377869,
-0.5507377982139587,
-0.6860870122909546,
0.6294007897377014,
0.6588991284370422,
0.36290761828422546,
0.14247149229049683,
0.5314016938209534,
0.2320244461297989,
0.17917121946811676,
0.19292505085468292,
-0.2531302273273468,
0.2470734566450119,
-0.5640407800674438,
-0.3031768202781677,
-0.5998033285140991,
-0.5102366209030151,
0.08920583128929138,
0.8460280895233154,
-0.33677971363067627,
0.06653235107660294,
0.3317454159259796,
0.6251293420791626,
-0.7059483528137207,
0.2430122196674347,
-0.7021095156669617,
-0.24682730436325073,
0.03992421180009842,
0.09832359850406647,
-0.5640636086463928,
-0.08858854323625565,
0.30783215165138245,
-0.5862997770309448,
-0.17556308209896088,
0.23963582515716553,
0.7639546990394592,
-0.15204356610774994,
-0.5787221193313599,
-0.33149561285972595,
-0.9274958372116089,
0.6355717778205872,
-0.6779446601867676,
0.8164021968841553,
0.3569630980491638,
0.25994980335235596,
-0.09540615975856781,
-0.9471631646156311,
-0.3506309390068054,
-0.43895167112350464,
0.0692068561911583,
-0.019373778253793716,
-0.2746856212615967,
-0.06463105231523514,
0.06444200128316879,
0.16813181340694427,
-0.3161928057670593,
0.21335096657276154,
-0.252408504486084,
0.011703330092132092,
0.331897109746933,
0.05638789385557175,
0.2799987196922302,
-0.005556585732847452,
-0.3864748477935791,
0.14237059652805328,
-0.7742773294448853,
-0.016071362420916557,
0.1458616852760315,
0.3106815814971924,
0.14585524797439575,
0.6695085763931274,
-0.4612085223197937,
0.6062166690826416,
0.21505682170391083,
-0.08473937213420868,
0.21486636996269226,
-0.06576499342918396,
-0.30901509523391724,
0.2552415728569031,
0.643051028251648,
0.6521694660186768,
0.007729614619165659,
-0.31826862692832947,
-0.10825077444314957,
-0.2885935306549072,
0.16845567524433136,
-0.6940029263496399,
-0.2588246166706085,
-0.16166330873966217,
-0.41328778862953186,
-0.04190702363848686,
0.14395545423030853,
-0.43383392691612244,
-0.45037248730659485,
-0.13463209569454193,
0.3489116132259369,
-0.3904701769351959,
-0.18280768394470215,
0.26704922318458557,
-0.012972270138561726,
0.027046535164117813,
0.2132061868906021,
-0.6508913636207581,
0.19701416790485382,
0.6235276460647583,
0.7936139106750488,
0.04478257894515991,
-0.02328989841043949,
-0.13283707201480865,
0.581075131893158,
0.14203080534934998,
0.8919273018836975,
-0.6501480340957642,
-0.3872095048427582,
0.04043680429458618,
0.23909540474414825,
0.3989154100418091,
-0.5416650772094727,
0.754324197769165,
-0.9643461108207703,
-0.0961480587720871,
-0.26890090107917786,
-0.7448724508285522,
-0.7060966491699219,
0.3383859097957611,
-0.6291542053222656,
0.693877100944519,
0.03820488601922989,
-0.54869145154953,
0.6520134806632996,
-0.5072107315063477,
-0.5845945477485657,
0.22240571677684784,
0.1705218255519867,
-0.05223895236849785,
-0.3151572644710541,
0.2746882140636444,
0.649400532245636,
-0.6528639197349548,
0.25570088624954224,
-0.9733160734176636,
0.029226725921034813,
0.10661724954843521,
-0.19346560537815094,
0.5000649690628052,
0.24260810017585754,
-0.11573489755392075,
-0.0016355209518224,
-0.7395555377006531,
-0.317791610956192,
0.03372762352228165,
-0.2112678587436676,
-0.8084962964057922,
-0.07996109873056412,
0.08712916076183319,
0.18640832602977753,
0.40203657746315,
-0.5620738863945007,
0.18320342898368835,
-0.32314634323120117,
0.23219026625156403,
0.6884944438934326,
0.2515011429786682,
0.4640728533267975,
-0.25575581192970276,
0.28786101937294006,
-0.1622719168663025,
-0.12150994688272476,
-0.10753960907459259,
-0.33786478638648987,
-0.8403753638267517,
0.12335000187158585,
0.05520488694310188,
0.4124932587146759,
-0.7343112230300903,
0.9574228525161743,
-0.36548668146133423,
-0.4034508764743805,
0.016118550673127174,
0.26318302750587463,
-0.11538917571306229,
0.6752560138702393,
0.21800865232944489,
-0.6584822535514832,
-0.5989943146705627,
-0.8866609930992126,
-0.1548561304807663,
-0.3878158926963806,
-0.32356277108192444,
0.6391780972480774,
-0.07772888988256454,
-0.3818313479423523,
0.7183458209037781,
-0.6667267084121704,
-0.43745163083076477,
-0.39865782856941223,
-0.2190679907798767,
0.6391462683677673,
0.1624196618795395,
0.18371082842350006,
-0.2687479853630066,
-0.42744454741477966,
0.3274284899234772,
-0.6919819712638855,
-0.05974030867218971,
0.09660905599594116,
-0.3740684390068054,
-0.035288967192173004,
0.4676252007484436,
-0.2274991273880005,
-0.06322372704744339,
0.23932033777236938,
-0.46730196475982666,
0.24626606702804565,
-0.22502641379833221,
0.050772689282894135,
-1.2129703760147095,
0.16185177862644196,
0.6120701432228088,
-0.39788421988487244,
-0.3317059278488159,
-0.09397592395544052,
-0.08074354380369186,
0.18242448568344116,
-0.28520020842552185,
0.3581720292568207,
-0.07903821021318436,
0.15494006872177124,
-0.22603629529476166,
-0.06856003403663635,
0.27060526609420776,
0.5560265779495239,
0.14630316197872162,
0.11420103907585144,
0.25302213430404663,
-0.8449409604072571,
0.3233496844768524,
0.18940553069114685,
-0.6234849095344543,
0.78194260597229,
-0.4752335846424103,
0.36658722162246704,
0.16400893032550812,
0.4175666570663452,
-0.8079086542129517,
0.022246025502681732,
0.23281428217887878,
0.08014268428087234,
0.24695278704166412,
-0.3380111753940582,
-0.22685661911964417,
-0.37783750891685486,
0.026957141235470772,
0.31694355607032776,
0.26503419876098633,
-0.6281778812408447,
0.8208513855934143,
0.4396580457687378,
-0.31772473454475403,
-0.5659153461456299,
-0.4971180260181427,
0.2073284387588501,
-0.12832996249198914,
-0.6914392709732056,
0.2856353521347046,
-0.0681191012263298,
-0.12153363227844238,
0.16774988174438477,
0.005688350182026625,
0.13000866770744324,
-0.024155260995030403,
0.23440314829349518,
0.5725019574165344,
-0.20813384652137756,
0.25926536321640015,
-0.13765333592891693,
0.047902047634124756,
0.21899336576461792,
-0.9394338130950928,
0.6335002779960632,
0.004550001118332148,
-0.3683881163597107,
-0.32277798652648926,
0.0029893224127590656,
0.6136677265167236,
0.01159290224313736,
0.703898549079895,
0.5775018334388733,
-0.29038846492767334,
-0.21160809695720673,
-0.8230790495872498,
-0.26137179136276245,
-0.5289586782455444,
0.6953411102294922,
-0.4290545582771301,
-0.7955465912818909,
0.21854142844676971,
-0.23924750089645386,
-0.011038622818887234,
0.5670269727706909,
0.6200674176216125,
-0.09192311018705368,
0.6828938722610474,
0.7052486538887024,
-0.36056721210479736,
0.42887061834335327,
-0.16491995751857758,
0.31994542479515076,
-0.9512945413589478,
-0.41755878925323486,
-0.378193736076355,
-0.36259081959724426,
-0.3311425447463989,
-0.026122108101844788,
0.4830133318901062,
0.04679384082555771,
-0.4208749234676361,
0.27178674936294556,
-0.34497562050819397,
0.38062000274658203,
0.614450216293335,
0.6073033213615417,
0.5602288842201233,
0.15098218619823456,
-0.28355634212493896,
0.25389668345451355,
-0.5384700298309326,
-0.35692450404167175,
1.241305947303772,
0.4113219976425171,
0.8696109652519226,
0.1982678771018982,
0.22506317496299744,
0.3616887927055359,
0.34208744764328003,
-1.0595784187316895,
0.4414997398853302,
-0.25091278553009033,
-0.5065328478813171,
-0.14360909163951874,
-0.2687440812587738,
-0.6289833784103394,
-0.23383007943630219,
-0.29480719566345215,
-0.8201574683189392,
0.4328502118587494,
-0.043427903205156326,
-0.4084155857563019,
0.6639394760131836,
-0.548633873462677,
0.5004218220710754,
-0.39473891258239746,
-0.7583174109458923,
-0.33718758821487427,
-0.2356891930103302,
0.3553949296474457,
0.04031825438141823,
0.19926200807094574,
-0.11067351698875427,
0.1972956359386444,
0.6957389116287231,
-0.24864503741264343,
0.710184633731842,
-0.019471338018774986,
-0.23447872698307037,
0.2924785912036896,
0.3697556257247925,
0.8993441462516785,
-0.17105162143707275,
-0.21389761567115784,
0.2431091070175171,
-0.3683110177516937,
0.10054303705692291,
-0.5997858643531799,
0.8355633020401001,
-0.5577108860015869,
-0.6836523413658142,
0.026248469948768616,
-0.40458953380584717,
-0.480176717042923,
0.3631725609302521,
-0.00360093847848475,
0.23922500014305115,
-0.3218214809894562,
0.6148033738136292,
0.25838610529899597,
-0.2522647976875305,
0.14810636639595032,
0.5964299440383911,
-0.20400409400463104,
-0.5504150390625,
0.8753288388252258,
0.07106657326221466,
0.1097477450966835,
0.5553111433982849,
0.19334723055362701,
-0.6250995397567749,
-0.3732285499572754,
-0.2571695148944855,
0.1451677680015564,
-0.8721597194671631,
-0.21458591520786285,
-0.9600263237953186,
-0.02462512068450451,
-0.44400423765182495,
-0.10267239809036255,
0.000957365264184773,
-0.3314815163612366,
-0.15143151581287384,
-0.3012579679489136,
0.4313858151435852,
0.8577963709831238,
0.1099512130022049,
-0.01792035438120365,
-0.8863053321838379,
0.10008476674556732,
0.5712183713912964,
0.7231123447418213,
0.44052833318710327,
-0.4401722252368927,
-0.5350473523139954,
-0.20019446313381195,
-0.34541183710098267,
-0.6541590690612793,
0.28040260076522827,
-0.023892071098089218,
0.4929473400115967,
0.7565771341323853,
0.08873709291219711,
0.2774216830730438,
-0.3502618074417114,
0.5737389922142029,
0.42948654294013977,
-0.5552905201911926,
0.019267698749899864,
-0.49440330266952515,
0.15436674654483795,
0.5070601105690002,
0.46808624267578125,
-0.7419360280036926,
0.12483742833137512,
-0.42629334330558777,
-1.241234302520752,
0.5921497344970703,
-0.20550723373889923,
-0.039115581661462784,
0.28620994091033936,
0.18453854322433472,
0.3433994650840759,
0.11812685430049896,
-0.7143728733062744,
-0.1190524771809578,
0.16389723122119904,
-0.38972315192222595,
-0.11893641948699951,
-0.37617748975753784,
0.17143000662326813,
-0.20693011581897736,
1.024095892906189,
0.1061641201376915,
-0.13003908097743988,
0.06020255759358406,
-0.13631722331047058,
-0.15382298827171326,
0.39397290349006653,
-0.025782590731978416,
0.5179644227027893,
-0.46626678109169006,
0.0071195755153894424,
0.36976566910743713,
-0.36009374260902405,
0.08927501738071442,
0.0006463512545451522,
-0.13360199332237244,
-0.29621461033821106,
-0.0003584698715712875,
0.7174570560455322,
0.23993134498596191,
-0.5400769114494324,
0.18240375816822052,
0.180838480591774,
0.07037279009819031,
-0.4017660319805145,
-0.024131419137120247,
0.23264697194099426,
0.2500585913658142,
0.33274540305137634,
0.05591398477554321,
0.4646756052970886,
-0.6124625205993652,
0.32097187638282776,
0.40902313590049744,
-0.6364558935165405,
-0.06422165036201477,
0.3753252327442169,
0.4848218858242035,
-0.08719035983085632,
0.4282560646533966,
0.14387527108192444,
-0.3716531991958618,
0.42991894483566284,
0.6428489089012146,
1.144418716430664,
-0.05576486140489578,
0.15309318900108337,
0.3894376754760742,
0.2723609209060669,
-0.11187469214200974,
-0.27046093344688416,
-0.22465623915195465,
-1.0242829322814941,
-0.15766610205173492,
-0.6482540369033813,
-0.47008031606674194,
0.08672092109918594,
-0.4744231402873993,
0.6589005589485168,
-0.48570817708969116,
-0.16719572246074677,
-0.020266376435756683,
-0.17406833171844482,
-0.9370102882385254,
0.12643176317214966,
0.21911068260669708,
0.6233033537864685,
-0.5420764684677124,
0.7762030363082886,
0.6684984564781189,
-0.4026956558227539,
-1.040878176689148,
-0.23372973501682281,
-0.10817200690507889,
-0.6202722191810608,
0.44970810413360596,
0.019386909902095795,
-0.39491257071495056,
0.0240972638130188,
-0.08952131122350693,
-0.7675957083702087,
1.2586212158203125,
0.22581186890602112,
-0.8910857439041138,
0.025346804410219193,
-0.045382820069789886,
0.2885811924934387,
-0.5854129791259766,
0.6026806235313416,
0.5471744537353516,
0.47204309701919556,
0.4556301534175873,
-0.7593612670898438,
0.2549046576023102,
-0.19430236518383026,
-0.2750544250011444,
0.15717166662216187,
-0.5454323291778564,
0.3725695013999939,
0.025640998035669327,
-0.1254846304655075,
-0.1027224212884903,
0.5222452282905579,
0.3253886103630066,
0.5133030414581299,
0.8264259696006775,
0.6723219156265259,
0.6932857036590576,
0.3778856098651886,
0.8168859481811523,
-0.3955534100532532,
0.09634243696928024,
1.3754929304122925,
-0.8485032916069031,
0.9199324250221252,
0.14853541553020477,
-0.25463637709617615,
1.1328763961791992,
0.42709553241729736,
-0.13523510098457336,
0.31003913283348083,
-0.25119805335998535,
-0.2102578729391098,
-0.4309621751308441,
-0.6047748923301697,
-0.31126442551612854,
0.2439310997724533,
0.2823473811149597,
-0.6629961133003235,
-0.05071678012609482,
-0.05327180027961731,
-0.22345800697803497,
-0.2565043866634369,
-0.27628713846206665,
1.092380404472351,
0.17703695595264435,
-0.4183955192565918,
0.42383861541748047,
0.07076963782310486,
0.6786717176437378,
-0.6961368322372437,
-0.05570372939109802,
0.08233758807182312,
0.22206002473831177,
-0.1698107272386551,
-0.6082368493080139,
-0.3185659348964691,
-0.04965565353631973,
-0.26487046480178833,
0.11585313826799393,
1.0057990550994873,
-0.3379027545452118,
-0.8393202424049377,
0.46643978357315063,
0.3367200791835785,
-0.22367329895496368,
-0.08884364366531372,
-0.2663494348526001,
-0.4648532271385193,
0.15549293160438538,
-0.007004039362072945,
0.06346521526575089,
0.42430728673934937,
0.00896028894931078,
0.7760257720947266,
0.7641546726226807,
0.10819470137357712,
-0.4090409576892853,
0.21298886835575104,
0.7523619532585144,
-0.7018148899078369,
-0.7275155186653137,
-0.684273898601532,
0.39274993538856506,
-0.08781539648771286,
0.21483631432056427,
0.5642642378807068,
0.4668791592121124,
0.7981626987457275,
0.03935755044221878,
0.947704553604126,
0.09921681135892868,
0.29684382677078247,
-0.5111532211303711,
0.661807656288147,
-0.6272886991500854,
0.7278786301612854,
-0.4092552959918976,
-1.1138243675231934,
-0.13201063871383667,
0.0852866843342781,
-0.3279570937156677,
0.16148504614830017,
0.6247860193252563,
0.8314384818077087,
-0.2627083361148834,
0.044010262936353683,
0.30309444665908813,
0.424809992313385,
0.27493399381637573,
0.6704809665679932,
0.6676652431488037,
-0.009560132399201393,
0.6155082583427429,
-0.2425151765346527,
-0.1360056847333908,
-0.35557976365089417,
-0.7790390253067017,
-0.6823300719261169,
-0.4352501928806305,
-0.19527895748615265,
-0.6095541715621948,
-0.07322139292955399,
1.4895483255386353,
0.5879130363464355,
-0.8585343360900879,
-0.4723059833049774,
-0.05470163747668266,
0.12302526831626892,
-0.2559523284435272,
-0.23096953332424164,
0.4111359417438507,
0.012408874928951263,
-0.5305889248847961,
0.39200955629348755,
0.3926342725753784,
-0.14519891142845154,
-0.31183934211730957,
0.028631433844566345,
-0.19778762757778168,
-0.12504510581493378,
0.639678955078125,
0.09584107249975204,
-0.5372582077980042,
-0.2382383942604065,
0.0914224311709404,
0.1796489953994751,
-0.055327124893665314,
1.0316376686096191,
-0.7511091232299805,
0.45978236198425293,
0.4991605877876282,
0.5283588171005249,
0.46077993512153625,
-0.24146555364131927,
0.9257187843322754,
-0.40967148542404175,
0.10536620020866394,
0.04263478145003319,
0.6878216862678528,
0.37208887934684753,
-0.6243005990982056,
0.3319135904312134,
0.1488199532032013,
-0.3974767327308655,
-0.4101564288139343,
0.317085325717926,
-0.9261482357978821,
-0.42754065990448,
1.1644477844238281,
-0.02196607179939747,
-0.12065739929676056,
-0.5017576813697815,
-0.2014148086309433,
0.20426104962825775,
-0.752274751663208,
0.8328198790550232,
0.6943804621696472,
0.14325346052646637,
0.09888626635074615,
-0.07494030892848969,
-0.06094744801521301,
0.20910920202732086,
-0.39807838201522827,
0.03442535921931267,
0.5428267121315002,
0.3348082900047302,
-0.016825677827000618,
0.24437616765499115,
0.18872509896755219,
-0.0838315412402153,
-0.3754514455795288,
0.4134692847728729,
-0.2231474220752716,
-0.3845427334308624,
-0.055563680827617645,
0.45114371180534363,
0.40882742404937744,
0.1540282964706421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13741v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13741v1
|
Unlocking Instructive In-Context Learning with Tabular Prompting for Relational Triple Extraction
| 2024-02-21T12:12:16 | 2024-02-21T12:12:16 |
Guozheng Li, Wenjun Ke, Peng Wang, Zijie Xu, Ke Ji, Jiajun Liu, Ziyu Shang, Qiqing Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The in-context learning (ICL) for relational triple extraction (RTE) has
achieved promising performance, but still encounters two key challenges: (1)
how to design effective prompts and (2) how to select proper demonstrations.
Existing methods, however, fail to address these challenges appropriately. On
the one hand, they usually recast RTE task to text-to-text prompting formats,
which is unnatural and results in a mismatch between the output format at the
pre-training time and the inference time for large language models (LLMs). On
the other hand, they only utilize surface natural language features and lack
consideration of triple semantics in sample selection. These issues are
blocking improved performance in ICL for RTE, thus we aim to tackle prompt
designing and sample selection challenges simultaneously. To this end, we
devise a tabular prompting for RTE (\textsc{TableIE}) which frames RTE task
into a table generation task to incorporate explicit structured information
into ICL, facilitating conversion of outputs to RTE structures. Then we propose
instructive in-context learning (I$^2$CL) which only selects and annotates a
few samples considering internal triple semantics in massive unlabeled samples.
|
[
-0.3050488829612732,
-0.8690361380577087,
0.5975189208984375,
0.42957139015197754,
-0.3048795163631439,
0.05489535257220268,
-0.18225443363189697,
-0.2859603762626648,
-0.4566754996776581,
0.4362800419330597,
-0.5559911727905273,
-0.6680831909179688,
-0.0010320470901206136,
0.28328701853752136,
-0.19194568693637848,
1.1712132692337036,
-0.20679756999015808,
0.03744741529226303,
-0.5123197436332703,
0.17437303066253662,
-0.8559789657592773,
-0.09023644030094147,
-0.48818665742874146,
-0.21416065096855164,
0.23262926936149597,
1.308642029762268,
0.04396194592118263,
0.3820430040359497,
-0.11137328296899796,
0.10922005772590637,
0.2269224226474762,
0.481466680765152,
-0.3485069274902344,
0.36902791261672974,
0.1821126788854599,
-0.09273723512887955,
-0.13453686237335205,
0.10708878934383392,
0.8669378757476807,
0.6067147254943848,
-0.009839707985520363,
0.3080359399318695,
0.481473833322525,
0.6914655566215515,
-0.5575000047683716,
0.5974393486976624,
-0.8421228528022766,
0.08320153504610062,
-0.2495059221982956,
-0.34891995787620544,
-0.7802104353904724,
-0.40865692496299744,
0.1980518400669098,
-0.6884989738464355,
-0.10476401448249817,
0.22180603444576263,
0.6480775475502014,
0.07073762267827988,
-0.6311008930206299,
-0.5447775721549988,
-0.5195643305778503,
0.3992162048816681,
-0.2772302031517029,
0.33373406529426575,
0.3394680321216583,
0.39633530378341675,
-0.2617156505584717,
-0.8498260378837585,
-0.6951869130134583,
-0.5845226645469666,
-0.1405804604291916,
0.020004041492938995,
0.1320934295654297,
-0.14311057329177856,
0.4447326362133026,
0.034097980707883835,
-0.3328816294670105,
0.240365669131279,
-0.2247917801141739,
0.2549740970134735,
0.24149076640605927,
0.12381353229284286,
0.34066811203956604,
-0.20692117512226105,
-0.6740023493766785,
-0.13821329176425934,
-1.0430150032043457,
0.24484293162822723,
0.10865319520235062,
0.579679548740387,
-0.0786476582288742,
0.3563435971736908,
-0.13093337416648865,
0.9088830947875977,
0.1293380856513977,
-0.058417659252882004,
0.16681450605392456,
-0.24419425427913666,
-0.13156099617481232,
0.2813831567764282,
0.8732830286026001,
0.17475110292434692,
0.013612410053610802,
-0.2612517476081848,
0.015876587480306625,
-0.2184520959854126,
0.10337713360786438,
-0.7135825753211975,
-0.19613903760910034,
0.17207615077495575,
0.010499929077923298,
-0.23112435638904572,
0.28154662251472473,
-1.1980255842208862,
-0.11186208575963974,
-0.2874913215637207,
0.5796656608581543,
-0.36750394105911255,
0.008565531112253666,
-0.24668841063976288,
0.022864649072289467,
0.14562365412712097,
0.2732931077480316,
-1.0139210224151611,
0.37143445014953613,
0.4278795123100281,
0.6194783449172974,
-0.3555357754230499,
-0.20700371265411377,
-1.0856821537017822,
0.5853805541992188,
-0.2769716680049896,
0.8120944499969482,
-0.5660375952720642,
-0.46462881565093994,
0.16256816685199738,
-0.22246354818344116,
0.011387803591787815,
-0.5675530433654785,
0.2367139607667923,
-0.3879423439502716,
0.45582276582717896,
-0.4893781244754791,
-0.3265077769756317,
-0.04076733440160751,
0.2491007000207901,
-0.5435166358947754,
1.2275159358978271,
0.21076983213424683,
-0.603699803352356,
0.9463849663734436,
-0.9594844579696655,
-0.29904240369796753,
0.3369334042072296,
-0.513672411441803,
-0.5222753882408142,
-0.31161847710609436,
0.5359994173049927,
0.6145445108413696,
-0.16274778544902802,
0.28943464159965515,
-0.3018845319747925,
-0.38145700097084045,
0.048642732203006744,
-0.13968002796173096,
0.7451063394546509,
-0.05678959935903549,
-0.5854324698448181,
0.22900177538394928,
-0.6627733111381531,
0.13726046681404114,
-0.18788956105709076,
-0.4343319237232208,
0.10304491966962814,
-0.1333189457654953,
-0.12455436587333679,
0.37209850549697876,
-0.32395824790000916,
-0.44685637950897217,
0.28570201992988586,
-0.3035151958465576,
0.39893838763237,
0.5523844361305237,
0.2014792263507843,
0.5542232990264893,
-0.04651359096169472,
0.4180118143558502,
0.06942792981863022,
-0.16295699775218964,
0.0936407670378685,
-0.32935193181037903,
-0.28459542989730835,
-0.31650084257125854,
0.17263151705265045,
0.6254693865776062,
-1.1680983304977417,
0.043198637664318085,
-0.3826104402542114,
-0.20076368749141693,
-0.2813800871372223,
0.17524728178977966,
0.6708354949951172,
1.0001734495162964,
0.5368820428848267,
0.1965312957763672,
-0.32206353545188904,
-0.8309205174446106,
-0.41730543971061707,
-0.17786209285259247,
-0.0600324422121048,
0.18479688465595245,
0.46882006525993347,
0.2525503933429718,
0.8884294033050537,
-0.1226203441619873,
-0.4054286479949951,
-0.5506895184516907,
0.16508172452449799,
0.17160218954086304,
0.432101309299469,
0.28051936626434326,
-0.7802246809005737,
-0.9948594570159912,
0.1633753478527069,
-0.9154210686683655,
-0.22574712336063385,
-0.0823170617222786,
-0.04938388988375664,
0.26659080386161804,
0.7276263236999512,
-0.5994517207145691,
0.5668904781341553,
-0.311095654964447,
-0.11133856326341629,
0.4214041531085968,
0.07722070068120956,
-0.029945259913802147,
-0.9136830568313599,
-0.09629316627979279,
-0.1346087008714676,
-0.05041775479912758,
-0.5805243849754333,
-0.13752540946006775,
0.501086950302124,
0.009250559844076633,
-0.5422505140304565,
0.7035831212997437,
-0.8687559962272644,
-0.06833498924970627,
0.12436040490865707,
0.1785649061203003,
0.12079513072967529,
0.5027757883071899,
-0.13292798399925232,
1.0308293104171753,
0.23955823481082916,
-0.8126710057258606,
-0.10125284641981125,
0.7148081660270691,
-0.4594508707523346,
0.6827276945114136,
-0.20071931183338165,
0.108381487429142,
-0.18493114411830902,
0.501349925994873,
-0.8111147284507751,
-0.42135465145111084,
0.5506157875061035,
-0.2841028571128845,
0.7815291881561279,
-0.169420525431633,
-0.34248897433280945,
-0.32113149762153625,
-0.3592205047607422,
0.18449030816555023,
0.08568651229143143,
-1.008984923362732,
0.33173424005508423,
0.41481220722198486,
0.068044513463974,
-0.9754934906959534,
-0.5634064674377441,
0.11272267252206802,
-0.494588166475296,
-0.2737630605697632,
0.5641745924949646,
-0.11857001483440399,
-0.38701361417770386,
-0.14238889515399933,
-0.15671870112419128,
-0.02792094275355339,
0.007640088442713022,
0.2836742699146271,
0.2878403663635254,
-0.012329217977821827,
0.23519206047058105,
0.2582889795303345,
-0.05911711975932121,
0.3242628872394562,
-0.48469144105911255,
0.18112044036388397,
-0.4214014410972595,
-0.12097512185573578,
-0.7557147145271301,
0.4818080961704254,
0.19774067401885986,
-0.1492510586977005,
0.47431644797325134,
0.5257285237312317,
-0.2440696507692337,
-0.4230363368988037,
-0.4718475639820099,
-0.2655165493488312,
-0.4429399073123932,
0.23356078565120697,
-0.48963287472724915,
-0.7399293184280396,
0.12902462482452393,
0.10439421236515045,
0.09151113778352737,
0.031049638986587524,
0.4651821553707123,
-0.15950293838977814,
0.8362143635749817,
0.13316234946250916,
0.5349667072296143,
0.5056750178337097,
-0.3758435845375061,
0.014121693558990955,
-0.9462577104568481,
-0.5197136402130127,
-0.5421746969223022,
-0.028750969097018242,
-0.3125518262386322,
0.08038215339183807,
0.8678777813911438,
-0.0019308672053739429,
-0.3186626732349396,
0.06641045212745667,
-0.431142121553421,
0.7152704000473022,
0.7077452540397644,
0.48105588555336,
0.09082075208425522,
0.17938344180583954,
-0.1427132487297058,
-0.01552774291485548,
-0.6896120309829712,
-0.5120818614959717,
0.8417299389839172,
-0.14979928731918335,
0.25336429476737976,
0.17183344066143036,
0.897376298904419,
0.07932771742343903,
0.4850226640701294,
-0.65730881690979,
0.6320221424102783,
0.24436010420322418,
-0.43475767970085144,
-0.3281746208667755,
-0.47979220747947693,
-0.8415346145629883,
0.17637264728546143,
-0.33103179931640625,
-1.001899003982544,
0.1900431513786316,
0.4487002491950989,
-0.5440965294837952,
0.3084070086479187,
-0.7655523419380188,
1.1232929229736328,
0.11545512080192566,
-0.7832692861557007,
0.2623421847820282,
-0.8950315713882446,
0.45782795548439026,
0.2833765149116516,
0.22880738973617554,
0.023530613631010056,
0.06520669162273407,
0.3023076355457306,
-0.34099605679512024,
0.7113189101219177,
-0.5032383799552917,
0.24458344280719757,
0.4215530455112457,
0.44793540239334106,
0.5514253973960876,
0.5969831943511963,
0.012455500662326813,
-0.37522220611572266,
-0.15293791890144348,
-0.2593086063861847,
-0.6450756192207336,
0.6322171688079834,
-0.3997720777988434,
-0.5809885263442993,
-0.16413277387619019,
-0.4676181972026825,
-0.6511045694351196,
-0.029612787067890167,
0.5021454691886902,
0.9280356168746948,
0.05003504455089569,
0.2672410309314728,
0.6119738817214966,
-0.041572026908397675,
0.7838976383209229,
0.03735032677650452,
-0.024310775101184845,
-0.46679797768592834,
0.9104963541030884,
-0.05424885079264641,
0.23097142577171326,
0.7316259741783142,
0.3056083023548126,
-0.48191386461257935,
-0.5944744348526001,
-0.8391580581665039,
-0.10739562660455704,
-0.7927513718605042,
-0.37611308693885803,
-0.7503364682197571,
0.19283510744571686,
-0.10543931275606155,
-0.12900181114673615,
0.18398715555667877,
-0.39635202288627625,
-0.6456335186958313,
-0.29043149948120117,
0.23019567131996155,
0.822641134262085,
-0.02254619263112545,
0.3418537378311157,
-0.8362521529197693,
0.2463197112083435,
0.6893699169158936,
0.10484520345926285,
-0.0505969263613224,
-0.31197378039360046,
-0.130931556224823,
-0.2814933955669403,
-0.31487971544265747,
-1.1996541023254395,
0.3649643361568451,
0.28182560205459595,
0.46863624453544617,
0.20188581943511963,
0.043849650770425797,
0.6960508823394775,
-0.5874918103218079,
0.7864620089530945,
-0.1159382313489914,
-0.9238985180854797,
0.5021169781684875,
-0.4435020089149475,
0.20794357359409332,
0.8985657691955566,
0.3738947808742523,
-0.12445881217718124,
-0.004006139934062958,
-0.4461458623409271,
-0.877821683883667,
0.9343377947807312,
-0.12302784621715546,
-0.15374836325645447,
-0.341899573802948,
0.234449103474617,
0.5518617033958435,
0.27603206038475037,
-1.058085322380066,
0.13103578984737396,
-0.18023641407489777,
-0.15295809507369995,
0.5824218392372131,
-0.43272632360458374,
-0.1093839704990387,
-0.25291699171066284,
0.6775859594345093,
-0.3562406897544861,
0.056360021233558655,
0.3070290684700012,
-0.38108402490615845,
-0.08299319446086884,
0.3075452744960785,
0.49671176075935364,
0.8008202910423279,
-0.20179715752601624,
0.08607662469148636,
0.3630467653274536,
-0.2618287205696106,
0.07362096011638641,
0.0017807012191042304,
-0.08766354620456696,
-0.19939368963241577,
0.3436746597290039,
0.8138487339019775,
0.6425960063934326,
-0.28098732233047485,
0.6261049509048462,
-0.18386653065681458,
-0.11617261171340942,
-0.49530452489852905,
-0.07251798361539841,
-0.27216726541519165,
0.04934822767972946,
0.4249120056629181,
-0.32087090611457825,
0.26226726174354553,
-0.4654304087162018,
0.2156316190958023,
0.6063230633735657,
-0.5265564918518066,
-0.11402077972888947,
0.7655847668647766,
-0.012604204006493092,
-0.4296421706676483,
0.8037106990814209,
-0.4557684659957886,
-0.2577954828739166,
0.2984898090362549,
0.6994221210479736,
0.8287519216537476,
0.05568814277648926,
0.3230752646923065,
0.5007157921791077,
-0.0020679435692727566,
0.09255396574735641,
0.4326382875442505,
-0.5033370852470398,
-0.4012710452079773,
-0.20999422669410706,
-0.23224680125713348,
-0.3306763172149658,
0.08116981387138367,
-0.9002296924591064,
0.3493962287902832,
-0.1904648095369339,
0.28171658515930176,
-0.1158728152513504,
-0.06000198796391487,
-0.6352657675743103,
-0.15421448647975922,
0.016551999375224113,
0.703136682510376,
-0.5464656352996826,
0.7439786791801453,
0.41196194291114807,
-0.3371620178222656,
-0.8919749855995178,
-0.0495016984641552,
0.0663190707564354,
-0.5446128845214844,
0.7861740589141846,
0.5641267895698547,
0.1350066214799881,
0.12744566798210144,
-0.8093746900558472,
-0.37823736667633057,
0.9092605113983154,
0.35055944323539734,
-0.08975394070148468,
-0.1862470507621765,
0.025872383266687393,
-0.013215032406151295,
-0.5909667611122131,
0.32586362957954407,
0.5685199499130249,
0.60938560962677,
-0.03229979798197746,
-0.7379783391952515,
0.07981038093566895,
-0.17767325043678284,
-0.23157358169555664,
0.2726810574531555,
-0.2775244116783142,
0.8178818225860596,
-0.19186626374721527,
-0.39176255464553833,
-0.2486714869737625,
0.7410191297531128,
0.5535696744918823,
0.4707392752170563,
0.7296940088272095,
0.1592744141817093,
0.6209393739700317,
-0.047147899866104126,
0.9632641673088074,
0.1195259839296341,
-0.27332887053489685,
1.454284906387329,
-0.46701580286026,
0.7491337060928345,
0.6399961113929749,
0.026508871465921402,
0.6812974214553833,
0.682051420211792,
0.3551095426082611,
0.43562155961990356,
-0.1714705228805542,
-0.44779813289642334,
-0.1101299375295639,
-0.08335389196872711,
-0.2038629949092865,
0.6203880906105042,
0.8653582334518433,
0.06164087727665901,
-0.4087035357952118,
0.03521915525197983,
0.1686912626028061,
0.2559095025062561,
-0.19721166789531708,
0.937381386756897,
-0.053915414959192276,
-0.8320552706718445,
0.48170751333236694,
-0.8325713276863098,
0.015897706151008606,
-0.40145599842071533,
-0.6459741592407227,
0.0009832109790295362,
-0.27920442819595337,
-0.12195859849452972,
-0.7870135307312012,
-0.0826561227440834,
-0.29710835218429565,
-0.06652361154556274,
-0.4546525478363037,
0.32369309663772583,
-0.6705352663993835,
0.0032717243302613497,
0.13979288935661316,
0.5287407040596008,
0.08265836536884308,
-0.051111169159412384,
-0.3226906657218933,
-0.20646438002586365,
0.0362117700278759,
-0.21378061175346375,
0.2612251043319702,
0.7147716283798218,
-0.3492371141910553,
0.5659437775611877,
0.5127363801002502,
-0.2640966773033142,
-0.18917737901210785,
-0.11650475859642029,
0.8606724739074707,
-0.449278861284256,
-0.6175637245178223,
-0.9869959950447083,
0.7529316544532776,
-0.33689776062965393,
-0.3126961588859558,
0.6240381598472595,
0.3928293287754059,
0.9097936153411865,
-0.25845858454704285,
0.5219874382019043,
0.04922579228878021,
0.46992120146751404,
-0.8458470106124878,
0.4269748628139496,
-0.3941388726234436,
0.33317339420318604,
-0.46860048174858093,
-0.8446220755577087,
-0.4636247754096985,
0.22596167027950287,
-0.12929919362068176,
-0.09237823635339737,
0.9080671072006226,
0.7500378489494324,
-0.0085992980748415,
0.2503986954689026,
0.014532867819070816,
0.08977265655994415,
0.4090232849121094,
0.5058847665786743,
1.0329598188400269,
0.02629481442272663,
0.6329500675201416,
-0.32072553038597107,
-0.25762107968330383,
-0.17706653475761414,
-1.2330045700073242,
-0.9418142437934875,
-0.910123884677887,
0.05259928107261658,
-0.4636150598526001,
-0.1327282190322876,
1.3227949142456055,
0.6595794558525085,
-0.5768998861312866,
-0.41886311769485474,
-0.142863929271698,
0.25831106305122375,
-0.26745903491973877,
-0.26825541257858276,
0.5667790770530701,
-0.4411011040210724,
-0.4543904960155487,
0.8907092809677124,
0.24218735098838806,
0.09111770987510681,
0.15027859807014465,
0.35915422439575195,
-0.20540902018547058,
-0.616261899471283,
0.48520132899284363,
0.38537102937698364,
-0.6777448654174805,
-0.4018215835094452,
-0.3249499499797821,
0.1429966241121292,
0.3096655309200287,
0.7503470182418823,
-1.0834661722183228,
0.4306502342224121,
0.27031442523002625,
0.5427756905555725,
0.6854854226112366,
-0.0859495997428894,
0.684269368648529,
-1.0865834951400757,
0.21629329025745392,
0.3604241609573364,
0.18349912762641907,
0.3828980326652527,
-0.6137250661849976,
0.49941638112068176,
-0.03883928060531616,
-0.7029695510864258,
-1.1447288990020752,
0.3624937832355499,
-0.8973210453987122,
-0.12819942831993103,
0.9710032939910889,
0.2434818148612976,
-0.4193595349788666,
-0.2732931673526764,
-0.2943536341190338,
0.2807648777961731,
-0.5640925765037537,
0.7949877381324768,
0.2664942443370819,
-0.23106658458709717,
-0.047837212681770325,
-0.7734408974647522,
1.082122802734375,
0.050812575966119766,
-0.7940860390663147,
0.2269877940416336,
0.5569562911987305,
-0.09589327126741409,
-0.2270510494709015,
0.44782793521881104,
-0.017637327313423157,
0.4757886528968811,
-0.19164390861988068,
0.03583535924553871,
-0.38512131571769714,
-0.7678682208061218,
-0.23366068303585052,
0.3310677409172058,
-0.12683318555355072,
-0.1045447587966919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13740v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13740v1
|
From Text to CQL: Bridging Natural Language and Corpus Search Engine
| 2024-02-21T12:11:28 | 2024-02-21T12:11:28 |
Luming Lu, Jiyuan An, Yujie Wang, Liner yang, Cunliang Kong, Zhenghao Liu, Shuo Wang, Haozhe Lin, Mingwei Fang, Yaping Huang, Erhong Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural Language Processing (NLP) technologies have revolutionized the way we
interact with information systems, with a significant focus on converting
natural language queries into formal query languages such as SQL. However, less
emphasis has been placed on the Corpus Query Language (CQL), a critical tool
for linguistic research and detailed analysis within text corpora. The manual
construction of CQL queries is a complex and time-intensive task that requires
a great deal of expertise, which presents a notable challenge for both
researchers and practitioners. This paper presents the first text-to-CQL task
that aims to automate the translation of natural language into CQL. We present
a comprehensive framework for this task, including a specifically curated
large-scale dataset and methodologies leveraging large language models (LLMs)
for effective text-to-CQL task. In addition, we established advanced evaluation
metrics to assess the syntactic and semantic accuracy of the generated queries.
We created innovative LLM-based conversion approaches and detailed experiments.
The results demonstrate the efficacy of our methods and provide insights into
the complexities of text-to-CQL task.
|
[
-0.3713795840740204,
-1.0682703256607056,
0.6399661898612976,
0.2063676416873932,
-0.2676287889480591,
0.44489768147468567,
-0.28742435574531555,
-0.5593521595001221,
-0.07066551595926285,
0.686974823474884,
-0.5069080591201782,
-0.8410688042640686,
-0.2936848998069763,
0.3462558388710022,
-0.8163976073265076,
0.8642021417617798,
0.08631950616836548,
-0.09622184932231903,
-0.2438419759273529,
0.22259265184402466,
-0.3177688419818878,
-0.7796675562858582,
-0.5889723896980286,
0.18489107489585876,
0.3990258574485779,
0.16220055520534515,
0.8385513424873352,
0.48470282554626465,
0.32655712962150574,
0.1724381297826767,
0.01025132555514574,
0.40193212032318115,
-0.5665335655212402,
0.40679797530174255,
-0.4236682951450348,
-0.5523547530174255,
0.08987563103437424,
-0.36290767788887024,
0.6774425506591797,
0.9719259738922119,
-0.1001393124461174,
0.14866259694099426,
0.2313620150089264,
0.7698566317558289,
-0.5381699204444885,
0.05318824574351311,
-0.9303870797157288,
-0.0018885397585108876,
-0.3591245710849762,
-0.3087345063686371,
-0.46687451004981995,
-0.5217814445495605,
-0.14855915307998657,
-0.4296894967556,
0.22504431009292603,
0.42519474029541016,
0.4760269522666931,
0.38422757387161255,
-0.7439134120941162,
-0.5481050610542297,
-0.7227868437767029,
0.5902392268180847,
-0.6310103535652161,
0.536749541759491,
0.20035375654697418,
0.3805461823940277,
-0.5020297765731812,
-0.9448423981666565,
-0.5804569721221924,
-0.2508959472179413,
-0.3015790581703186,
-0.16085374355316162,
-0.001033992855809629,
0.016592230647802353,
-0.042420871555805206,
0.3183216452598572,
-0.7730936408042908,
-0.0382159985601902,
-0.20912869274616241,
-0.0928679034113884,
0.769439697265625,
0.26011720299720764,
0.4928719699382782,
-0.32110595703125,
-0.0887540802359581,
0.10734041035175323,
-0.3824830949306488,
-0.06965659558773041,
-0.13396312296390533,
0.4479447305202484,
0.36118629574775696,
0.8121875524520874,
-0.42671388387680054,
0.7113744020462036,
0.13180695474147797,
0.3488287329673767,
-0.2984614372253418,
-0.8404762744903564,
-0.1856967657804489,
0.24378930032253265,
0.8976089358329773,
0.22048276662826538,
-0.016799354925751686,
-0.5735454559326172,
-0.18330492079257965,
-0.057353805750608444,
0.37478598952293396,
-0.6029838919639587,
0.08449967950582504,
0.5106920003890991,
-0.2281525731086731,
-0.0823836475610733,
-0.21369920670986176,
-0.46989285945892334,
-0.17478136718273163,
-0.4701218903064728,
0.10925282537937164,
-0.4426971673965454,
0.061354365199804306,
0.0705295205116272,
0.23985332250595093,
0.5622033476829529,
0.13652220368385315,
-0.7550683617591858,
0.6365835070610046,
0.8070544004440308,
0.582237958908081,
-0.4644410014152527,
0.20192089676856995,
-0.6651167869567871,
0.320688396692276,
-0.49687662720680237,
0.74580979347229,
-0.2738545835018158,
-0.38947680592536926,
0.30437931418418884,
0.1647532731294632,
-0.12452293187379837,
-0.4617065191268921,
0.8799068331718445,
-0.9332512021064758,
0.29043129086494446,
0.11159159988164902,
-0.6983938813209534,
-0.04221387580037117,
0.586782693862915,
-0.6083120703697205,
1.3553125858306885,
0.08141689002513885,
-0.7178065776824951,
0.017888115718960762,
-0.7049469351768494,
-0.5115386247634888,
0.34844788908958435,
-0.09925527125597,
-0.04287097975611687,
-0.13668309152126312,
0.39084333181381226,
0.3869181275367737,
-0.7829075455665588,
0.4875358045101166,
-0.1829613745212555,
-0.21737191081047058,
0.12693020701408386,
-0.037488825619220734,
0.9533888697624207,
0.12784060835838318,
-0.06379625201225281,
-0.055866487324237823,
-0.4775142967700958,
0.27935752272605896,
0.057306140661239624,
-0.4152003228664398,
-0.40869808197021484,
0.11667711287736893,
0.4164614677429199,
0.08378328382968903,
0.5774334669113159,
-0.3987828195095062,
0.27093544602394104,
-0.8217483162879944,
0.5005963444709778,
0.038614436984062195,
-0.03551000356674194,
0.5648235082626343,
0.05380352959036827,
0.336202472448349,
-0.42797642946243286,
0.1456395834684372,
-0.00740432646125555,
-0.28522738814353943,
-0.42931419610977173,
0.08989541977643967,
0.37320807576179504,
0.7331063151359558,
-0.9145967364311218,
0.5401279330253601,
-0.2806015610694885,
-0.5816702842712402,
-0.6770015358924866,
0.035185858607292175,
0.10106734186410904,
0.37086042761802673,
0.4984467327594757,
-0.04488785192370415,
-0.4050767719745636,
-0.7856920957565308,
-0.5374168157577515,
-0.09962764382362366,
-0.32924747467041016,
0.2897140681743622,
0.30553263425827026,
-0.2821362316608429,
1.0102450847625732,
-0.4644792079925537,
-0.354583203792572,
0.02551400661468506,
0.10210254043340683,
0.3092270493507385,
0.35018783807754517,
0.26070886850357056,
-0.8520072102546692,
-0.5107190608978271,
0.2648131549358368,
-0.6924296021461487,
-0.26511064171791077,
0.07371339946985245,
-0.41456788778305054,
0.4540093243122101,
0.917088508605957,
-0.6431346535682678,
0.3043143153190613,
0.28437596559524536,
-0.3157499134540558,
0.6033349633216858,
0.05650554597377777,
0.25082752108573914,
-0.9257726669311523,
0.4372737407684326,
-0.31340834498405457,
-0.33273443579673767,
-0.42154961824417114,
0.3191419839859009,
0.20341743528842926,
-0.3102339506149292,
-0.3189198970794678,
0.6512325406074524,
-0.4001913070678711,
-0.15429304540157318,
-0.002288476098328829,
0.2148686647415161,
0.02139819599688053,
0.3210839331150055,
-0.11921948939561844,
0.6256757974624634,
0.2562633156776428,
-0.8156135678291321,
0.566768229007721,
0.6134024262428284,
0.020152833312749863,
0.44849878549575806,
-0.4995763897895813,
0.12251874804496765,
-0.0801556184887886,
0.09940488636493683,
-0.8897266387939453,
-0.19053132832050323,
0.2248915582895279,
-0.5548608303070068,
0.018481643870472908,
-0.2943512797355652,
-0.8634125590324402,
-0.16295483708381653,
-0.11166734993457794,
0.389296293258667,
0.01984446868300438,
-0.49556973576545715,
0.5315492749214172,
0.41248875856399536,
-0.4096486568450928,
-0.3887243866920471,
-0.7133883237838745,
0.8018367886543274,
0.17543277144432068,
-0.7746586203575134,
0.977562665939331,
-0.12007573246955872,
-0.12408321350812912,
-0.022668510675430298,
0.1842484027147293,
-0.45383763313293457,
0.06384049355983734,
-0.18744774162769318,
0.3331444561481476,
-0.16145963966846466,
0.31822454929351807,
0.31534385681152344,
0.22322052717208862,
0.27539435029029846,
-0.4280298352241516,
0.5374124050140381,
0.12510523200035095,
-0.27653393149375916,
-0.23868075013160706,
0.5451574325561523,
0.3942948579788208,
-0.5280421376228333,
0.4305081367492676,
0.4112699627876282,
-0.40253686904907227,
-0.09422057867050171,
-0.48292213678359985,
-0.20966732501983643,
-0.37532585859298706,
0.19947300851345062,
-0.1408112794160843,
-0.9250286817550659,
0.0819132924079895,
-0.1561068296432495,
0.16346068680286407,
0.5518077611923218,
0.4955691993236542,
-0.0427534244954586,
0.9940772652626038,
0.6851378083229065,
0.18260745704174042,
0.2126215100288391,
0.09943826496601105,
0.2924339473247528,
-0.5805985927581787,
-0.21565988659858704,
-0.8318362832069397,
0.03978739678859711,
-0.8483851552009583,
-0.5128685235977173,
0.4252955913543701,
-0.003502934006974101,
-0.19557994604110718,
0.23554566502571106,
-0.5448546409606934,
0.13164080679416656,
0.3162913918495178,
-0.11698628216981888,
0.6731552481651306,
-0.06125599890947342,
-0.05979790911078453,
-0.018038734793663025,
-0.5920155048370361,
-0.43395715951919556,
0.9386175274848938,
-0.11413770914077759,
0.3895183503627777,
0.17774535715579987,
0.7156012058258057,
0.4123796224594116,
0.09052929282188416,
-0.909135103225708,
0.616246223449707,
-0.1966141015291214,
-0.7190700769424438,
-0.38988181948661804,
-0.2736446261405945,
-1.0717493295669556,
0.17246322333812714,
-0.49785175919532776,
-0.2630332410335541,
-0.07738544791936874,
-0.19315186142921448,
-0.1385687291622162,
-0.14106519520282745,
-0.40767616033554077,
0.8909242749214172,
-0.524305522441864,
-0.7917701601982117,
-0.1692916750907898,
-0.6877112984657288,
0.45243382453918457,
-0.1427195817232132,
0.41043877601623535,
0.2182813286781311,
-0.29767295718193054,
0.3753995895385742,
-0.2168150544166565,
0.46942588686943054,
0.19270412623882294,
-0.09737156331539154,
0.20942164957523346,
0.2444588541984558,
0.4216293692588806,
0.2861540913581848,
-0.38224443793296814,
-0.06159064173698425,
0.45069456100463867,
-0.45093101263046265,
-0.5818600058555603,
0.5030959248542786,
-0.2693866491317749,
-0.3173198103904724,
-0.3921128809452057,
-0.38706672191619873,
-0.240446537733078,
0.4166226089000702,
-0.13582754135131836,
0.10962192714214325,
-0.6041638255119324,
0.17055214941501617,
0.6340720653533936,
-0.39587152004241943,
0.37639084458351135,
0.5464520454406738,
-0.5477085113525391,
-0.06858686357736588,
0.35257643461227417,
-0.09353319555521011,
-0.007339920848608017,
0.8039550185203552,
-0.18756039440631866,
-0.6777920126914978,
-0.6840701103210449,
-0.5104442238807678,
0.17882634699344635,
-0.3328627049922943,
-0.1707957535982132,
-0.7040560245513916,
-0.30890804529190063,
-0.6278041005134583,
-0.10767997056245804,
-0.20473237335681915,
-0.19883711636066437,
-0.3980734944343567,
0.3524174988269806,
0.15763504803180695,
0.2534137964248657,
0.4035109579563141,
0.019403334707021713,
-1.0783169269561768,
0.4116940200328827,
0.18010368943214417,
0.2226511687040329,
-0.23126350343227386,
-0.1724194586277008,
-0.19557836651802063,
-0.06997530162334442,
-0.09102880209684372,
-0.8528920412063599,
0.7675574421882629,
0.18158189952373505,
0.3494853973388672,
-0.19854454696178436,
0.3961196541786194,
0.258698046207428,
-0.5132268667221069,
0.7959724068641663,
-0.1374502331018448,
-0.7962009906768799,
0.5271557569503784,
-0.5023103952407837,
0.28718116879463196,
0.7154821157455444,
0.3979848325252533,
-0.7465915083885193,
-0.32699355483055115,
-0.40864747762680054,
-1.0458662509918213,
0.2198481410741806,
0.299720823764801,
-0.09468846023082733,
-0.09972535073757172,
0.41342633962631226,
-0.10469967871904373,
0.26419252157211304,
-0.4452049732208252,
0.024594347923994064,
0.10363105684518814,
-0.2364313006401062,
0.10550012439489365,
0.021431665867567062,
0.1476564258337021,
-0.11353378742933273,
0.5755569934844971,
-0.46962106227874756,
0.013425816781818867,
0.48507821559906006,
-0.5556405782699585,
0.20080694556236267,
0.5328329801559448,
0.02268749289214611,
0.29378584027290344,
-0.2426864206790924,
-0.08985816687345505,
0.10031022131443024,
-0.10527314990758896,
-0.2605358064174652,
0.3935462534427643,
-0.1116332858800888,
0.022080732509493828,
0.03811308741569519,
0.05598044395446777,
0.44008326530456543,
-0.9253144860267639,
0.3260251581668854,
-0.3613865077495575,
-0.021490730345249176,
-0.4976860582828522,
-0.19696472585201263,
0.4675235152244568,
-0.01727651245892048,
0.6540999412536621,
-0.46453872323036194,
0.5872319936752319,
-0.6851204037666321,
0.3245680332183838,
0.6349047422409058,
-0.2978195250034332,
0.060272738337516785,
0.7881746888160706,
0.35804229974746704,
-0.307606041431427,
0.641586184501648,
-0.2461072951555252,
-0.3948815166950226,
0.34526798129081726,
0.3855136036872864,
0.6622195243835449,
-0.057944536209106445,
0.060752592980861664,
0.47862109541893005,
0.32790160179138184,
0.056503113359212875,
0.1527538150548935,
-0.10376092046499252,
-0.4091916084289551,
-0.7387526035308838,
-0.7782474160194397,
-0.5196068286895752,
-0.28554651141166687,
-0.5808539390563965,
0.36772727966308594,
-0.3001161217689514,
0.02907591313123703,
0.17101144790649414,
0.24763761460781097,
-0.6049594879150391,
0.09791576862335205,
0.10191124677658081,
0.9195951819419861,
-0.3592037260532379,
0.7424802780151367,
0.6407075524330139,
-0.39899715781211853,
-0.33518168330192566,
-0.24628876149654388,
-0.28398415446281433,
-0.5995951294898987,
0.560498058795929,
-0.09824716299772263,
-0.05891181528568268,
0.3301341235637665,
-0.7590452432632446,
-0.6264017224311829,
0.9531155228614807,
0.32935717701911926,
-0.7909112572669983,
-0.3029431402683258,
0.564451277256012,
0.63919997215271,
-0.4131132662296295,
0.2218431830406189,
0.7580508589744568,
0.5422419309616089,
-0.14586803317070007,
-0.9555423259735107,
0.2542414367198944,
-0.11410509049892426,
-0.008013378828763962,
0.46250519156455994,
-0.2019505798816681,
0.561880886554718,
0.09920995682477951,
-0.4484492838382721,
0.008503123186528683,
0.673267662525177,
-0.0695221796631813,
0.4006890654563904,
0.3887961506843567,
0.16732655465602875,
0.8062018752098083,
0.11899875849485397,
0.9868044257164001,
-0.5552562475204468,
0.06537581980228424,
0.976912260055542,
-0.3821493983268738,
1.0345146656036377,
0.6140577793121338,
-0.32506269216537476,
0.3070310652256012,
0.5963118076324463,
0.13287627696990967,
0.05216673016548157,
0.37221240997314453,
-0.39502832293510437,
-0.3051098585128784,
-0.3459014594554901,
-0.15213805437088013,
0.3627241253852844,
0.6682755351066589,
-0.20494355261325836,
-0.3890884816646576,
-0.24799205362796783,
-0.27912139892578125,
0.6386052966117859,
-0.2826094627380371,
0.920826256275177,
0.0018327957950532436,
-0.6957058310508728,
0.6273319721221924,
0.1084388792514801,
0.7319766879081726,
-0.31243374943733215,
0.058809418231248856,
-0.16808584332466125,
-0.35953426361083984,
-0.3041262626647949,
-0.7952175140380859,
0.8351806402206421,
-0.08868322521448135,
-0.2130945473909378,
-0.031266793608665466,
0.844992995262146,
-0.496257483959198,
-0.4600006937980652,
0.47609567642211914,
0.6368111371994019,
0.21008840203285217,
-0.39136186242103577,
-0.7991287708282471,
-0.18562160432338715,
-0.03188621997833252,
0.08338117599487305,
0.3769241273403168,
0.4737262427806854,
-0.0649588480591774,
0.5248023271560669,
0.9332001209259033,
-0.22170469164848328,
0.14899536967277527,
-0.2496478408575058,
0.7501175999641418,
-1.1212817430496216,
-0.3652854561805725,
-0.5442972779273987,
0.27782773971557617,
-0.05515296012163162,
-0.02337241917848587,
0.21887442469596863,
0.8230066895484924,
0.5477930307388306,
0.13466127216815948,
0.9184050559997559,
-0.08673404157161713,
0.807449996471405,
-0.7037878036499023,
0.878895103931427,
-0.5292999148368835,
0.2777116894721985,
0.12105018645524979,
-0.8346954584121704,
-0.3951820731163025,
-0.030438371002674103,
-0.11089135706424713,
-0.5389721393585205,
0.7815682291984558,
1.0033749341964722,
0.10766056925058365,
-0.17995481193065643,
0.2740548253059387,
0.1979072093963623,
0.3621006906032562,
0.5685579180717468,
0.597692608833313,
-0.5136669278144836,
0.9932024478912354,
0.13248392939567566,
0.054981108754873276,
-0.4051690697669983,
-0.908379077911377,
-0.5559874176979065,
-0.6569734811782837,
-0.16595354676246643,
-0.359203577041626,
0.26337572932243347,
0.8486557602882385,
0.3055330216884613,
-0.5918538570404053,
-0.39367881417274475,
-0.23954541981220245,
0.21714068949222565,
-0.06302359700202942,
-0.23153266310691833,
0.37475278973579407,
-0.5673647522926331,
-0.8879227638244629,
0.5814471244812012,
0.15228614211082458,
-0.36538049578666687,
-0.302640438079834,
0.23798616230487823,
-0.5930271148681641,
-0.036847736686468124,
0.8946303725242615,
0.34326794743537903,
-0.5445529818534851,
0.16790808737277985,
0.181435689330101,
-0.5568376183509827,
0.019449111074209213,
0.5486186146736145,
-1.052052617073059,
0.27337658405303955,
0.49782636761665344,
1.0898324251174927,
0.6635379791259766,
-0.1946689784526825,
0.7443769574165344,
-0.531845211982727,
-0.3213450610637665,
0.5680274963378906,
-0.15617431700229645,
0.5156212449073792,
-0.4370397627353668,
0.7043576240539551,
-0.1428985744714737,
-0.6055274605751038,
-0.8161969780921936,
0.21063388884067535,
-1.2136778831481934,
-0.30306872725486755,
1.0374565124511719,
0.532390832901001,
-0.4646393358707428,
-0.5298447012901306,
-0.47347500920295715,
0.4051913619041443,
-0.26150602102279663,
0.7125016450881958,
0.3271591067314148,
0.04147949814796448,
0.022333748638629913,
-0.7737005949020386,
0.506091833114624,
0.43385428190231323,
-0.8583338856697083,
0.18364770710468292,
0.38714170455932617,
0.08356092870235443,
0.10540736466646194,
0.4603574573993683,
-0.28834134340286255,
0.10300957411527634,
-0.41563132405281067,
0.2995384931564331,
0.28746986389160156,
0.4976133108139038,
-0.06409144401550293,
0.3746921122074127,
0.14976637065410614,
0.18414661288261414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13731v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13731v2
|
Cracking Factual Knowledge: A Comprehensive Analysis of Degenerate Knowledge Neurons in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T11:50:32 | 2024-06-17T03:44:10 |
Yuheng Chen, Pengfei Cao, Yubo Chen, Yining Wang, Shengping Liu, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) store extensive factual knowledge, but the
underlying mechanisms remain unclear. Previous research suggests that factual
knowledge is stored within multi-layer perceptron weights, and some storage
units exhibit degeneracy, referred to as Degenerate Knowledge Neurons (DKNs).
Despite the novelty and unique properties of this concept, it has not been
rigorously defined or systematically studied. We first consider the connection
weight patterns of MLP neurons and define DKNs from both structural and
functional aspects. Based on this, we introduce the Neurological Topology
Clustering method, which allows the formation of DKNs in any numbers and
structures, leading to a more accurate DKN acquisition. Furthermore, inspired
by cognitive science, we explore the relationship between DKNs and the
robustness, evolvability, and complexity of LLMs. Our execution of 34
experiments under 6 settings demonstrates the connection between DKNs and these
three properties. The code will be available soon.
|
[
-0.1301025003194809,
-1.0267606973648071,
1.0050936937332153,
0.07997056841850281,
0.06777796149253845,
0.2388199418783188,
-0.27667272090911865,
-0.23490659892559052,
0.10153993964195251,
0.27576375007629395,
-0.2274998426437378,
-0.6078504323959351,
-0.8150004148483276,
-0.017067287117242813,
-0.32316553592681885,
0.5243021845817566,
0.39974504709243774,
-0.050540827214717865,
-0.4938681125640869,
-0.052835650742053986,
-0.34899941086769104,
-0.4105394780635834,
-0.4722631275653839,
-0.610539436340332,
0.648171067237854,
0.4038349986076355,
0.5553033351898193,
0.6350740194320679,
0.4480827748775482,
0.370759516954422,
-0.5959999561309814,
0.0016387061914429069,
-0.5401665568351746,
0.10670345276594162,
-0.011278118006885052,
-0.7156693935394287,
-0.4343048334121704,
-0.32679304480552673,
0.6425412893295288,
0.8996816277503967,
-0.49156299233436584,
-0.16121067106723785,
-0.02609908953309059,
0.7699762582778931,
-0.3519708812236786,
0.32420024275779724,
-0.9919357895851135,
-0.04217366874217987,
0.039287470281124115,
-0.1344863623380661,
-0.31418943405151367,
-0.40568411350250244,
0.14461617171764374,
-0.3247632384300232,
0.22108036279678345,
-0.14992065727710724,
0.45914149284362793,
0.42332395911216736,
-0.36804652214050293,
-0.13957570493221283,
-0.7433014512062073,
0.5950638055801392,
-0.7535146474838257,
0.43424803018569946,
0.4167003929615021,
0.268855482339859,
-0.2802472710609436,
-0.4809097945690155,
-0.7788019180297852,
-0.39779913425445557,
-0.1210218071937561,
-0.07787474989891052,
0.028496315702795982,
0.15888181328773499,
0.4575498700141907,
0.4744168221950531,
-0.5511733889579773,
0.19838707149028778,
-0.5369630455970764,
0.08914945274591446,
0.5051099061965942,
0.1596333533525467,
0.4158593714237213,
-0.21288028359413147,
-0.4752166271209717,
0.12644082307815552,
-0.7318640947341919,
-0.19522041082382202,
0.19595038890838623,
0.21022167801856995,
-0.19283153116703033,
0.4618709087371826,
-0.16229450702667236,
0.7704578638076782,
-0.08870118856430054,
-0.4755495488643646,
0.33928465843200684,
0.14031381905078888,
-0.062434498220682144,
0.49832385778427124,
0.5972058176994324,
0.033391017466783524,
0.2013002336025238,
-0.44955429434776306,
0.006119924131780863,
-0.13283182680606842,
0.37974047660827637,
-0.44964054226875305,
-0.3603111505508423,
0.2595628798007965,
-0.4431447386741638,
-0.544370174407959,
-0.2434394657611847,
-0.5594545006752014,
-0.5703185200691223,
-0.5237274765968323,
0.22930386662483215,
-0.6256394982337952,
-0.4469902515411377,
0.20642606914043427,
-0.15978965163230896,
0.11135087162256241,
0.14832358062267303,
-0.9190695285797119,
0.35717710852622986,
0.7233737707138062,
0.8441296815872192,
-0.2835102677345276,
-0.4282498061656952,
0.1932498812675476,
0.26704683899879456,
-0.16252335906028748,
0.5477786064147949,
-0.3817630410194397,
0.046438850462436676,
-0.09357589483261108,
-0.1555914729833603,
-0.0029679634608328342,
-0.6191822290420532,
0.2848960757255554,
-0.9224280714988708,
-0.45587459206581116,
-0.6139205694198608,
-0.499678373336792,
-0.2801143229007721,
0.5454540848731995,
-0.7774367332458496,
0.816871702671051,
-0.09436748921871185,
-0.9224428534507751,
0.33601996302604675,
-0.3658236563205719,
-0.35938122868537903,
0.08703943341970444,
-0.3302278220653534,
0.05730649456381798,
0.2635180950164795,
-0.2649745047092438,
0.40920916199684143,
-0.2510228455066681,
0.4092348515987396,
-0.539669930934906,
-0.1788969188928604,
0.4481511414051056,
-0.41408267617225647,
0.7842126488685608,
0.09102166444063187,
-0.25345757603645325,
-0.28871089220046997,
-0.9235947132110596,
-0.3828986883163452,
0.32037416100502014,
-0.40294426679611206,
-0.6070894598960876,
0.07917468249797821,
-0.6232818365097046,
0.38606247305870056,
0.3825235962867737,
-0.5950980186462402,
0.3156706988811493,
-0.4671357572078705,
0.5563898086547852,
0.6969490051269531,
-0.10387851297855377,
0.2652997374534607,
-0.08589378744363785,
0.009217481128871441,
0.5386516451835632,
0.009779446758329868,
0.16450273990631104,
-0.4049105644226074,
-0.6967383027076721,
0.0059869312681257725,
0.2892652153968811,
0.5013361573219299,
-0.6594164967536926,
0.6801613569259644,
-0.436544269323349,
-0.45960497856140137,
0.09219791740179062,
0.02856142446398735,
0.06905656307935715,
0.6080089807510376,
0.3063385784626007,
0.07135937362909317,
-0.24031037092208862,
-0.9650065898895264,
0.05721307918429375,
-0.1160941794514656,
0.08870428800582886,
0.21172145009040833,
0.604981005191803,
-0.15588243305683136,
0.728586733341217,
-0.7902218699455261,
0.020209962502121925,
-0.1444513499736786,
0.04262685775756836,
0.37638723850250244,
0.31244850158691406,
0.3089907169342041,
-0.6527665853500366,
-0.11066033691167831,
-0.07473387569189072,
-1.0343154668807983,
0.4960704445838928,
0.17492026090621948,
0.22959904372692108,
0.15930335223674774,
0.5686948299407959,
-0.899245023727417,
0.18572308123111725,
0.5896499752998352,
-0.14590178430080414,
0.5362080335617065,
-0.3941394090652466,
-0.07005183398723602,
-0.8354364037513733,
0.12595020234584808,
-0.3532508909702301,
0.006614108569920063,
-0.4993875026702881,
-0.27497825026512146,
-0.16286180913448334,
-0.03783700615167618,
0.0387318879365921,
0.2408067286014557,
-0.43047064542770386,
-0.20759113132953644,
-0.1951083093881607,
0.3590221405029297,
-0.21651794016361237,
0.5050874948501587,
-0.12184134125709534,
0.1874975860118866,
0.6970545649528503,
-0.6501137614250183,
0.6472539901733398,
0.2912425100803375,
-0.6388438940048218,
0.16651266813278198,
-0.6446126103401184,
0.09855102747678757,
-0.23437654972076416,
0.10713908821344376,
-1.0577949285507202,
-0.13168776035308838,
-0.015522411093115807,
-0.3197757303714752,
0.5691838264465332,
-0.17675168812274933,
-0.5497151613235474,
-0.350819855928421,
-0.007968063466250896,
0.48540759086608887,
0.5599023103713989,
-0.4555423855781555,
0.46398693323135376,
0.5382817387580872,
-0.3220577836036682,
-0.7068749070167542,
-0.83160001039505,
0.15984877943992615,
-0.054483287036418915,
-0.6701410412788391,
0.3914945721626282,
0.032118018716573715,
-0.3433501720428467,
0.09366203099489212,
-0.2761358320713043,
-0.09158886224031448,
-0.004917418584227562,
0.12172073870897293,
-0.058041103184223175,
-0.22304432094097137,
0.4092252254486084,
0.0673481896519661,
-0.05428145080804825,
0.22198748588562012,
-0.301150381565094,
0.6815981268882751,
-0.03239288181066513,
-0.33937308192253113,
-0.03757771477103233,
0.054693758487701416,
0.7947094440460205,
0.0342368483543396,
0.999373197555542,
0.0682913139462471,
-0.45816320180892944,
-0.5092710852622986,
-0.667340099811554,
-0.32623904943466187,
-0.4720776379108429,
0.4342922866344452,
-0.4717641770839691,
-0.8936555981636047,
0.6376491785049438,
-0.31165844202041626,
-0.3836348354816437,
0.35665369033813477,
0.5828142166137695,
0.057726893573999405,
0.6688839793205261,
0.8317446708679199,
-0.0516154021024704,
-0.05061784386634827,
-0.1663057953119278,
0.4653242230415344,
-0.5866113901138306,
-0.47494110465049744,
-0.3069862723350525,
-0.511151909828186,
-0.34422019124031067,
-0.36057835817337036,
0.42431414127349854,
0.29161515831947327,
-0.17852550745010376,
-0.08580121397972107,
-0.28814640641212463,
0.6641588807106018,
0.30591726303100586,
0.29553940892219543,
0.4738270044326782,
0.29363059997558594,
-0.5399271249771118,
0.12716469168663025,
-0.9429466724395752,
-0.27778202295303345,
0.801689088344574,
0.513389527797699,
0.698498547077179,
-0.028082264587283134,
0.3618742525577545,
0.11551864445209503,
-0.21231886744499207,
-0.7956406474113464,
0.5617840886116028,
-0.28590887784957886,
-0.6255525946617126,
-0.32915687561035156,
-0.7120288014411926,
-0.6564885973930359,
-0.25576362013816833,
-0.16630525887012482,
-0.8584924936294556,
0.3110164403915405,
0.24973787367343903,
-0.3006390631198883,
0.6766987442970276,
-0.29978013038635254,
0.6522188186645508,
-0.38720422983169556,
-0.1561853587627411,
-0.6361839771270752,
-0.8193232417106628,
0.6928568482398987,
0.049404799938201904,
0.008880716748535633,
-0.023991134017705917,
0.1837814450263977,
0.6496228575706482,
-0.0211861003190279,
0.98661208152771,
-0.13946110010147095,
-0.30034884810447693,
0.22349125146865845,
0.37086912989616394,
0.26728081703186035,
0.07755258679389954,
-0.09735474735498428,
0.5154540538787842,
-0.09137195348739624,
-0.31678664684295654,
-0.6373921632766724,
0.924898624420166,
-0.7588074207305908,
-0.3838408291339874,
-0.34938159584999084,
-0.6475952863693237,
-0.38092970848083496,
0.11893890798091888,
0.013091256842017174,
0.665431022644043,
-0.25268349051475525,
0.28293973207473755,
1.132044792175293,
-0.34112977981567383,
0.20430424809455872,
0.3807941675186157,
-0.0704306960105896,
-0.21793527901172638,
0.9144760370254517,
0.35373854637145996,
0.13628679513931274,
0.5042453408241272,
0.2985343337059021,
-0.28899243474006653,
-0.8390639424324036,
-0.04451221600174904,
0.3869747817516327,
-0.8855761289596558,
-0.1578248143196106,
-0.6979060173034668,
-0.5146532654762268,
-0.31151047348976135,
0.14686432480812073,
-0.4161536693572998,
-0.681247353553772,
0.2762642800807953,
-0.37995246052742004,
0.5223261117935181,
1.1895716190338135,
-0.24184192717075348,
0.08565082401037216,
-0.9433306455612183,
0.38168516755104065,
0.517477810382843,
0.5932576060295105,
0.35889774560928345,
-0.20749138295650482,
-0.2565196752548218,
0.15136386454105377,
-0.03183937445282936,
-0.8288862109184265,
-0.019256221130490303,
-0.10710851848125458,
0.6684626936912537,
0.4427284300327301,
0.004698900040239096,
0.09456782788038254,
-0.4532397389411926,
0.6092926859855652,
0.2789228558540344,
-0.5095226764678955,
0.3004533350467682,
-0.46272122859954834,
0.19761839509010315,
0.5073146224021912,
0.6962240934371948,
-0.41083604097366333,
0.013108803890645504,
-0.6784100532531738,
-0.8273997902870178,
0.617756187915802,
-0.12438101321458817,
0.00520249642431736,
-0.026849865913391113,
0.6567628383636475,
0.05852276086807251,
0.17530742287635803,
-0.42702463269233704,
-0.4477645456790924,
-0.02108709141612053,
-0.3199903964996338,
-0.008647128939628601,
-0.700281023979187,
-0.5874369740486145,
-0.4442920386791229,
0.5177509188652039,
-0.0707411915063858,
0.18593789637088776,
0.32145652174949646,
-0.13754510879516602,
0.19034577906131744,
0.07128161191940308,
0.6369950771331787,
0.9360262751579285,
-0.2001127451658249,
0.4403255581855774,
0.3710528016090393,
-0.7212769985198975,
0.11702059209346771,
-0.20459036529064178,
-0.0613415353000164,
-0.3230869174003601,
0.2954983115196228,
0.5896859765052795,
0.005712207406759262,
-0.4204044044017792,
0.3654699921607971,
-0.11904876679182053,
-0.2754128575325012,
-0.4333544671535492,
-0.041775815188884735,
0.3328063488006592,
0.23385027050971985,
0.18411116302013397,
0.0241406112909317,
-0.03562082722783089,
-0.5063657164573669,
0.3637317717075348,
0.2611973285675049,
-0.4380984902381897,
-0.484144926071167,
0.13417097926139832,
0.18186233937740326,
0.15355046093463898,
0.8852335810661316,
-0.26931101083755493,
-0.7490644454956055,
0.5915989279747009,
0.7028819918632507,
0.8551002740859985,
-0.06644602864980698,
0.1061040386557579,
0.4983481466770172,
0.37509816884994507,
-0.028594650328159332,
0.12870337069034576,
-0.012559144757688046,
-1.0394561290740967,
-0.558713436126709,
-1.0181716680526733,
0.021364012733101845,
0.20998172461986542,
-0.14014936983585358,
0.14600563049316406,
-0.5730854272842407,
0.0329413115978241,
-0.2377564162015915,
-0.21510222554206848,
-0.24713177978992462,
0.11750983446836472,
0.4258021414279938,
1.0435632467269897,
-0.8443018198013306,
0.9435208439826965,
0.5084837079048157,
-0.15386395156383514,
-0.8151723742485046,
-0.04794219136238098,
0.019925540313124657,
-0.8338990211486816,
1.0685824155807495,
-0.14285823702812195,
0.001560464734211564,
0.049378734081983566,
-0.6415178179740906,
-0.9799284934997559,
1.0905472040176392,
0.26784271001815796,
-0.7509713172912598,
-0.2148679941892624,
0.3415592610836029,
0.2911297082901001,
-0.20485791563987732,
-0.023191558197140694,
0.7938574552536011,
0.5928913354873657,
0.37672653794288635,
-0.49129271507263184,
0.2762630879878998,
-0.10661990940570831,
-0.24080193042755127,
0.16161781549453735,
-0.5466046333312988,
0.7756754159927368,
-0.14706972241401672,
-0.021050654351711273,
-0.32634177803993225,
0.34851425886154175,
0.24755464494228363,
-0.037378598004579544,
0.5973320603370667,
1.1395350694656372,
0.8809414505958557,
-0.07614479959011078,
0.9009406566619873,
-0.4929635226726532,
0.17042961716651917,
0.8623446822166443,
-0.24038441479206085,
0.5053392648696899,
0.30606380105018616,
-0.15847069025039673,
0.6953936219215393,
0.04017370566725731,
-0.11340690404176712,
0.4907093942165375,
0.5190125107765198,
-0.2485833317041397,
-0.3068796992301941,
0.08183842897415161,
-0.31487613916397095,
0.580051064491272,
0.5118966698646545,
-0.22663407027721405,
-0.19307638704776764,
-0.3357713520526886,
0.13084638118743896,
-0.13707223534584045,
-0.14842699468135834,
0.8614867329597473,
0.4219316244125366,
-0.3998163342475891,
0.6772702932357788,
-0.259855180978775,
0.4813920855522156,
-0.7125568985939026,
-0.1616770625114441,
-0.060364626348018646,
0.3808738589286804,
-0.352750688791275,
-0.6579170823097229,
0.45513859391212463,
-0.29032889008522034,
-0.4622369706630707,
0.14798037707805634,
1.114729404449463,
-0.42390942573547363,
-0.40712669491767883,
0.45987001061439514,
0.5284454226493835,
0.006523334886878729,
-0.030293554067611694,
-0.504662036895752,
0.0859217718243599,
-0.2821331322193146,
-0.3007257282733917,
0.35260987281799316,
0.6625556349754333,
0.2558133602142334,
0.6476961374282837,
0.521979808807373,
0.24821428954601288,
0.17360249161720276,
-0.004061312880367041,
1.0654208660125732,
-0.8295580148696899,
-0.08531130850315094,
-0.9571646451950073,
0.49475520849227905,
-0.187727153301239,
-0.09705343842506409,
0.7172720432281494,
0.4026256799697876,
0.5079113841056824,
-0.03623884916305542,
0.6925791501998901,
-0.32542410492897034,
0.1812015175819397,
-0.6957025527954102,
1.1436917781829834,
-0.4912707507610321,
0.2707482874393463,
-0.09604863822460175,
-0.9409688711166382,
-0.23051872849464417,
0.3321476876735687,
-0.43445518612861633,
-0.08999922126531601,
0.9374414682388306,
0.7879230380058289,
-0.19237497448921204,
0.08690686523914337,
0.4070374369621277,
0.861548125743866,
0.059599462896585464,
0.4978165924549103,
1.0413933992385864,
-0.1490238606929779,
0.38150715827941895,
-0.46855348348617554,
-0.34865787625312805,
0.0962100699543953,
-0.8800829648971558,
-0.8840486407279968,
-0.5709188580513,
-0.26530271768569946,
-0.2345493733882904,
0.030918046832084656,
0.5402214527130127,
0.5556173920631409,
-0.5659432411193848,
-0.17960916459560394,
-0.40420475602149963,
0.4757041037082672,
0.04999726638197899,
-0.2038668692111969,
0.3463684320449829,
-0.559748649597168,
-0.08657022565603256,
0.5136498808860779,
0.24229887127876282,
-0.15611344575881958,
-0.25909924507141113,
0.08335091173648834,
-0.31152188777923584,
-0.07857497781515121,
0.7115604877471924,
0.031691230833530426,
-0.37597039341926575,
-0.14083074033260345,
0.035045456141233444,
-0.07307365536689758,
-0.06810840964317322,
0.8779940605163574,
-0.7347133755683899,
0.1576150506734848,
0.9918249249458313,
0.6231938004493713,
0.3466438949108124,
-0.28927215933799744,
0.5893576145172119,
-0.6440979242324829,
0.10257963091135025,
0.22402423620224,
0.33137157559394836,
0.28195279836654663,
-0.21467812359333038,
0.1740579605102539,
0.4691021740436554,
-0.7339307069778442,
-0.8135470747947693,
0.32179689407348633,
-1.0742690563201904,
-0.5631115436553955,
1.0715813636779785,
0.013676542788743973,
-0.40234339237213135,
-0.21914079785346985,
0.12202420830726624,
0.167363241314888,
-0.013133896514773369,
1.0457185506820679,
0.6178363561630249,
0.016690535470843315,
0.013403779827058315,
-0.5061624646186829,
0.6791826486587524,
0.09105426073074341,
-0.4644269347190857,
0.2394198477268219,
0.3394505977630615,
0.395108163356781,
0.5106396675109863,
0.3455280065536499,
-0.2964732050895691,
-0.0790201872587204,
0.23506437242031097,
0.09840653836727142,
-0.041941314935684204,
-0.779615581035614,
-0.4647288918495178,
0.25038382411003113,
0.18440507352352142,
0.4433046281337738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13722v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13722v1
|
Exploiting Adaptive Contextual Masking for Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-02-21T11:33:09 | 2024-02-21T11:33:09 |
S M Rafiuddin, Mohammed Rakib, Sadia Kamal, Arunkumar Bagavathi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) is a fine-grained linguistics problem
that entails the extraction of multifaceted aspects, opinions, and sentiments
from the given text. Both standalone and compound ABSA tasks have been
extensively used in the literature to examine the nuanced information present
in online reviews and social media posts. Current ABSA methods often rely on
static hyperparameters for attention-masking mechanisms, which can struggle
with context adaptation and may overlook the unique relevance of words in
varied situations. This leads to challenges in accurately analyzing complex
sentences containing multiple aspects with differing sentiments. In this work,
we present adaptive masking methods that remove irrelevant tokens based on
context to assist in Aspect Term Extraction and Aspect Sentiment Classification
subtasks of ABSA. We show with our experiments that the proposed methods
outperform the baseline methods in terms of accuracy and F1 scores on four
benchmark online review datasets. Further, we show that the proposed methods
can be extended with multiple adaptations and demonstrate a qualitative
analysis of the proposed approach using sample text for aspect term extraction.
|
[
-0.8980877995491028,
-0.9696803092956543,
0.4715045392513275,
0.5919101238250732,
-0.726974606513977,
0.1960040181875229,
0.0002682812628336251,
-0.5705701112747192,
0.6920083165168762,
0.43463924527168274,
-0.5829612016677856,
-0.5187528133392334,
-0.3416139781475067,
0.13916729390621185,
0.07167927175760269,
1.1001102924346924,
-0.09350910782814026,
-0.09828218817710876,
-0.12052441388368607,
-0.6456142067909241,
-0.8146582841873169,
-0.6014161109924316,
-0.44546744227409363,
0.04096122831106186,
0.15416061878204346,
0.25635290145874023,
0.17974737286567688,
0.1235385313630104,
0.4507608711719513,
0.23766684532165527,
-0.3577708601951599,
0.3083285987377167,
0.14842353761196136,
0.24794648587703705,
-0.5657976865768433,
-0.22796165943145752,
-0.6454622745513916,
-0.18806710839271545,
0.40724727511405945,
0.5671231746673584,
0.16631929576396942,
0.09921644628047943,
0.26749369502067566,
0.8603617548942566,
-0.8019746541976929,
0.34380701184272766,
-0.6634282469749451,
-0.017603369429707527,
0.10815005749464035,
-0.06510308384895325,
-0.015584154054522514,
0.00503216776996851,
0.003324674442410469,
-0.6083952784538269,
0.0684456080198288,
-0.01816258765757084,
0.6910524964332581,
0.012214113026857376,
0.010581363923847675,
-0.4448789358139038,
-0.49577146768569946,
0.8014245629310608,
-0.743933916091919,
0.07607980817556381,
0.34244561195373535,
-0.1066691130399704,
0.23694325983524323,
-0.28165918588638306,
-0.6076897382736206,
0.6021254062652588,
-0.18664707243442535,
0.28761181235313416,
-0.25874611735343933,
0.11975042521953583,
-0.034321222454309464,
0.5959101915359497,
0.0239341389387846,
-0.045362722128629684,
-0.2581127882003784,
-0.23032954335212708,
0.28625932335853577,
-0.1065511479973793,
-0.04532380774617195,
-0.7765179872512817,
-0.3634488582611084,
0.11993862688541412,
-0.6143583059310913,
0.4576750099658966,
0.220553457736969,
0.40687277913093567,
-0.23643667995929718,
0.22710011899471283,
-0.5156212449073792,
0.38010841608047485,
0.3154759407043457,
0.003023299155756831,
0.41463157534599304,
-0.31802746653556824,
-0.21177858114242554,
-0.016748668625950813,
0.6000341176986694,
0.46212413907051086,
-0.4162830412387848,
0.12378203868865967,
-0.36092865467071533,
-0.26286759972572327,
0.4322170913219452,
-0.520812451839447,
-0.008502709679305553,
0.6051926016807556,
-0.33789992332458496,
-0.20630228519439697,
0.24087940156459808,
-1.3087784051895142,
-0.45214006304740906,
-0.30369824171066284,
0.47955653071403503,
-0.22607190907001495,
-0.09969502687454224,
-0.18905073404312134,
0.03259854391217232,
0.33589696884155273,
0.442752867937088,
-0.4305574595928192,
0.04118167236447334,
0.9743359088897705,
1.0178502798080444,
-0.2835494577884674,
0.10633482038974762,
-0.5073274970054626,
-0.3208676278591156,
-0.2788921594619751,
0.9097978472709656,
-0.6116281151771545,
-0.26943904161453247,
0.10622090846300125,
0.12237934023141861,
0.059597063809633255,
-0.5061915516853333,
0.5321292281150818,
-0.572097659111023,
0.1655992567539215,
-0.3370818495750427,
-0.20582543313503265,
-0.8446092009544373,
0.5187135934829712,
-0.6446466445922852,
0.832275390625,
0.18310920894145966,
-0.5677512288093567,
0.29006239771842957,
-0.8464361429214478,
-0.5969781279563904,
-0.016002796590328217,
0.10070154070854187,
-0.6337869763374329,
0.560972273349762,
0.9065347909927368,
0.5628448128700256,
-0.04879051074385643,
0.11833659559488297,
-0.3169255554676056,
-0.05514279752969742,
0.5247655510902405,
-0.1837363839149475,
0.4480457305908203,
0.1611679196357727,
-0.5828222632408142,
0.367270290851593,
-0.4461972713470459,
-0.14379867911338806,
-0.4370152950286865,
-0.06449256092309952,
-0.6329216361045837,
0.026024462655186653,
0.1562664657831192,
0.2980740964412689,
-0.026794593781232834,
-0.7019860148429871,
-0.066382497549057,
-0.6310974359512329,
0.39384791254997253,
0.8014109134674072,
0.5390118360519409,
0.3697280287742615,
-0.24223275482654572,
0.506849467754364,
0.42506879568099976,
0.17487329244613647,
-0.40670934319496155,
-0.44001278281211853,
-0.8618852496147156,
-0.47331544756889343,
0.18251067399978638,
0.2835734486579895,
-1.0919004678726196,
0.7212875485420227,
-0.18150003254413605,
-0.3247252404689789,
-0.5562720894813538,
0.2991485297679901,
0.35960474610328674,
0.2623448967933655,
0.37553679943084717,
-0.8692647814750671,
-0.4274032413959503,
-0.8440304398536682,
-0.3154221773147583,
-0.2810380756855011,
0.021662579849362373,
0.2593420445919037,
0.2818724513053894,
0.04957398399710655,
1.2985835075378418,
-0.4979483187198639,
-0.772112250328064,
-0.3353116810321808,
0.3487251102924347,
-0.018915226683020592,
0.3403252959251404,
0.6119537353515625,
-0.8439832329750061,
-0.1360403150320053,
0.1583460420370102,
-0.5651838779449463,
-0.2907143533229828,
-0.29145532846450806,
-0.0017995581729337573,
0.35062262415885925,
0.24913890659809113,
-0.28732582926750183,
0.34525343775749207,
0.4400571584701538,
-0.22181248664855957,
0.18177375197410583,
0.3148069679737091,
0.1624322533607483,
-1.287293791770935,
0.010291905142366886,
0.362867146730423,
-0.40458789467811584,
-0.4678760766983032,
0.3659912645816803,
-0.10436198115348816,
0.050385765731334686,
-0.7381808757781982,
0.5552085638046265,
-0.3994591236114502,
-0.035610657185316086,
-0.7107851505279541,
-0.05501076951622963,
0.40808454155921936,
0.8065122365951538,
0.16681744158267975,
0.4715350270271301,
0.6153752207756042,
-0.46388208866119385,
0.06398824602365494,
-0.05755877494812012,
-0.16774581372737885,
0.8639901280403137,
-0.1858832985162735,
0.3766743838787079,
-0.20066197216510773,
0.3094550371170044,
-0.8181129097938538,
-0.08189306408166885,
0.6211402416229248,
-0.15900729596614838,
0.08887558430433273,
-0.051454298198223114,
-0.06467285752296448,
0.08788839727640152,
-0.9352923631668091,
0.5566055774688721,
0.08424270898103714,
-0.4383908808231354,
1.1226903200149536,
0.5856543779373169,
-0.5383697152137756,
-0.44940757751464844,
-0.18742559850215912,
0.030306290835142136,
-0.5150749683380127,
0.1532810628414154,
0.4479754567146301,
0.13952329754829407,
-0.43176111578941345,
0.12038824707269669,
-0.23440049588680267,
-0.27382051944732666,
0.12547452747821808,
0.393154501914978,
0.011187064461410046,
-0.33006852865219116,
-0.20635986328125,
0.421053409576416,
0.11532706022262573,
0.06521216779947281,
0.1793302595615387,
0.4845774173736572,
-0.3202601373195648,
-0.287832647562027,
-0.4923167824745178,
0.4495532810688019,
0.5845773220062256,
-0.14034485816955566,
0.4649658203125,
0.6043548583984375,
-0.6130477786064148,
-0.09387190639972687,
-0.626007080078125,
-0.17846046388149261,
-0.39865273237228394,
0.5326996445655823,
-0.2823334336280823,
-0.7726247906684875,
0.8329953551292419,
0.1427082121372223,
0.14696867763996124,
0.4997679591178894,
0.36553794145584106,
-0.044708266854286194,
0.4431629180908203,
0.5051445364952087,
-0.22370725870132446,
0.6786730289459229,
0.08081867545843124,
0.33532819151878357,
-1.4210658073425293,
-0.12326841056346893,
-0.34403088688850403,
-0.26159602403640747,
-0.30399560928344727,
-0.44516998529434204,
0.3507390320301056,
0.4423348009586334,
0.27755674719810486,
0.09934443235397339,
-0.39198553562164307,
0.33363229036331177,
0.2670080363750458,
0.4554058313369751,
0.20462222397327423,
0.0715034082531929,
0.6140037178993225,
0.0375087708234787,
-0.2225383222103119,
-0.35515183210372925,
0.9017155766487122,
0.4719207286834717,
0.28974097967147827,
0.0966634601354599,
0.26517945528030396,
0.5331605076789856,
0.7287190556526184,
-1.067772388458252,
0.34479448199272156,
-0.2590440511703491,
-0.3981874883174896,
0.004114738665521145,
-0.1519230455160141,
-0.32849517464637756,
0.5015130043029785,
-0.27472633123397827,
-0.7329321503639221,
0.545701265335083,
-0.11270713806152344,
-0.5618516206741333,
0.3556499481201172,
-0.4748557209968567,
0.4603683054447174,
0.13137900829315186,
-0.36666131019592285,
-0.09065929055213928,
-0.39176127314567566,
0.22800494730472565,
-0.5208784937858582,
0.5503060221672058,
-0.17632760107517242,
0.07658698409795761,
1.0023263692855835,
-0.22060368955135345,
1.1488398313522339,
-0.34409841895103455,
0.022158151492476463,
0.4925921857357025,
0.027773069217801094,
0.07243213802576065,
0.264344185590744,
0.032456498593091965,
0.6280899047851562,
-0.05641002207994461,
-0.33765655755996704,
-0.5605984330177307,
0.7557076215744019,
-0.5575835108757019,
-0.7745088338851929,
-0.5524699091911316,
-0.4211455285549164,
-0.4166455864906311,
0.01084075029939413,
-0.20116274058818817,
0.48350292444229126,
-0.15062610805034637,
0.30109357833862305,
0.2147676646709442,
-0.28639423847198486,
0.7812625169754028,
0.3965089023113251,
-0.1231917291879654,
-0.7106235027313232,
0.9414639472961426,
-0.12755948305130005,
0.0011552920332178473,
0.5136603713035583,
0.2438974529504776,
-0.2668224275112152,
-0.7229078412055969,
-0.5707451701164246,
0.018971165642142296,
-0.8055871725082397,
-0.6049217581748962,
-0.5910584330558777,
-0.037325162440538406,
-0.4018317759037018,
-0.1465877741575241,
-0.2594280242919922,
-0.3814989924430847,
-0.2659594416618347,
-0.08873032033443451,
0.44270479679107666,
0.6467472910881042,
0.042612869292497635,
0.4532241225242615,
-0.6772468686103821,
0.3175590932369232,
0.24312330782413483,
0.18904368579387665,
-0.08371414244174957,
-0.43983063101768494,
-0.04451235756278038,
-0.019804300740361214,
-0.6226804256439209,
-0.8213719129562378,
0.3641909062862396,
0.33125731348991394,
0.25209841132164,
0.48389455676078796,
0.20895449817180634,
0.6739356517791748,
0.06749062985181808,
1.0245760679244995,
-0.03970983624458313,
-1.2854198217391968,
0.4863039553165436,
-0.07110603898763657,
0.23025189340114594,
0.6933475136756897,
0.03470080718398094,
-0.38238525390625,
-0.48414260149002075,
-0.21400603652000427,
-1.208348274230957,
0.7599793672561646,
0.30285003781318665,
0.39208653569221497,
0.18439266085624695,
0.7032216787338257,
0.3352089524269104,
0.21983055770397186,
-0.8091217279434204,
-0.13331210613250732,
-0.5130002498626709,
-0.31267011165618896,
0.15311671793460846,
-0.20844922959804535,
-0.1568865329027176,
-0.1840442568063736,
0.839571475982666,
-0.5011525750160217,
0.13553233444690704,
0.4086587727069855,
-0.2162562608718872,
0.19225336611270905,
0.55584317445755,
0.5398002862930298,
0.8156479001045227,
-0.17225304245948792,
0.027856549248099327,
0.1231655701994896,
-0.5355812907218933,
-0.07234956324100494,
0.03288983181118965,
-0.17616403102874756,
-0.014659511856734753,
0.46335369348526,
0.8304640054702759,
0.10867892950773239,
-0.42753535509109497,
0.5876744389533997,
0.04103098809719086,
0.20786166191101074,
-0.016512859612703323,
-0.28577232360839844,
-0.33368992805480957,
-0.018871324136853218,
0.6370995044708252,
0.22432278096675873,
0.15025319159030914,
-0.7283055186271667,
0.23337264358997345,
0.35014912486076355,
-1.014436960220337,
-0.6678962111473083,
0.16824710369110107,
0.2799259126186371,
-0.18978016078472137,
-0.07456256449222565,
-0.20211829245090485,
-0.7402592301368713,
0.5883083939552307,
0.22727204859256744,
1.3666086196899414,
-0.12432849407196045,
0.27897879481315613,
0.10388640314340591,
0.25408679246902466,
0.2940828800201416,
-0.004143927246332169,
0.03043694607913494,
-0.6011229753494263,
-0.3499266803264618,
-1.007385492324829,
-0.4888993203639984,
0.2993887960910797,
-0.7983214259147644,
-0.057514894753694534,
-0.6594514846801758,
0.06064978614449501,
0.10926255583763123,
-0.2584896385669708,
-0.34458398818969727,
0.3428329527378082,
-0.1895875334739685,
0.3822857141494751,
-0.999255359172821,
0.43418994545936584,
1.0044068098068237,
-0.3742504119873047,
-0.5286747813224792,
0.565943717956543,
0.04556716978549957,
-0.29128023982048035,
-0.02085602656006813,
0.4759698510169983,
-0.00812175776809454,
-0.58332759141922,
0.023265670984983444,
-0.39478498697280884,
0.6531640291213989,
-0.12986959517002106,
-0.13197046518325806,
0.4504269063472748,
0.02847250923514366,
0.6659131646156311,
-0.6985899806022644,
0.0030764578841626644,
0.3139922320842743,
0.15199267864227295,
-0.07466118037700653,
-0.7363160252571106,
0.293556809425354,
-0.2023179531097412,
-0.09514011442661285,
-0.10149108618497849,
-0.5742740035057068,
0.7583369612693787,
0.5168769359588623,
-0.03382303938269615,
-0.12369753420352936,
0.9071593880653381,
0.055220164358615875,
0.581940770149231,
0.8307519555091858,
0.1097140908241272,
0.12159325182437897,
-0.1149853840470314,
0.7287930250167847,
-0.3902793228626251,
0.49400100111961365,
0.896056056022644,
-0.3445312976837158,
0.9302442669868469,
0.6883288025856018,
-0.02102266252040863,
0.7258233428001404,
0.6243314146995544,
0.6118295788764954,
0.6280485391616821,
-0.25045034289360046,
-0.2816242277622223,
-0.06987161934375763,
-0.30535024404525757,
-0.14832843840122223,
0.5703696012496948,
0.6034437417984009,
-0.23529814183712006,
-0.05235404521226883,
0.3625059425830841,
0.05478225648403168,
0.09647615253925323,
-0.7710913419723511,
1.1641789674758911,
0.18579217791557312,
-0.8796772956848145,
-0.05866284295916557,
0.28525158762931824,
0.8604040741920471,
-0.31120675802230835,
0.03137684240937233,
-0.45995649695396423,
0.12399375438690186,
-0.3255820870399475,
-0.9030545353889465,
0.7500784993171692,
0.06660006940364838,
-0.1788317859172821,
-0.004653876181691885,
0.6385924816131592,
-0.03614949807524681,
-0.692509114742279,
0.04912137612700462,
0.5409014821052551,
-0.1762598156929016,
-0.577085554599762,
-0.623245894908905,
0.081346295773983,
-0.047461848706007004,
-0.24744494259357452,
0.35493484139442444,
0.428147554397583,
-0.3685767948627472,
0.18084374070167542,
0.6059631109237671,
0.012300088070333004,
-0.39304319024086,
-0.06833291798830032,
1.030985713005066,
-0.7278779149055481,
-0.9340187311172485,
-0.8542758226394653,
0.15971630811691284,
-0.12748025357723236,
-0.4698435068130493,
0.5614068508148193,
0.5296265482902527,
0.6203388571739197,
-0.009109720587730408,
0.6173011660575867,
-0.2300964742898941,
0.454028457403183,
-0.8065760731697083,
0.5907933712005615,
-0.5368123054504395,
0.5465539693832397,
-0.5896257162094116,
-1.182392954826355,
-0.412260502576828,
0.45732370018959045,
-0.1946714073419571,
-0.07414349168539047,
0.8406752347946167,
0.70876145362854,
-0.16008223593235016,
0.17931361496448517,
-0.10302212089300156,
0.1217440739274025,
0.49850502610206604,
0.15582332015037537,
0.45384570956230164,
-0.3950481712818146,
0.01146236713975668,
-0.6118395924568176,
-0.26842084527015686,
-0.08188044279813766,
-0.9359418153762817,
-0.7068762183189392,
-0.7497696876525879,
-0.5893945097923279,
-0.3813466727733612,
-0.14139437675476074,
0.8597752451896667,
0.6518881916999817,
-1.2830827236175537,
0.23344291746616364,
0.18319426476955414,
0.3518640100955963,
-0.7091160416603088,
-0.368017315864563,
0.718854546546936,
-0.16023696959018707,
-0.7701293230056763,
0.19381943345069885,
0.46264520287513733,
-0.3170945942401886,
-0.4854050874710083,
0.3317771852016449,
-0.037783145904541016,
0.3017292320728302,
0.7950699329376221,
0.2273407131433487,
-0.8450697064399719,
-0.8312926292419434,
-0.3880971372127533,
0.3611510097980499,
0.3932170271873474,
0.9070059061050415,
-0.5714962482452393,
0.5144946575164795,
0.46703118085861206,
0.581893265247345,
0.13029401004314423,
0.5790449380874634,
0.32565543055534363,
-1.1168841123580933,
0.3228389620780945,
0.15208056569099426,
0.33693939447402954,
0.6803892850875854,
-0.30753734707832336,
0.11708322167396545,
0.40840741991996765,
0.09805027395486832,
-0.7531306147575378,
0.14520148932933807,
-1.3306751251220703,
-0.5564523339271545,
1.254522442817688,
-0.4847637712955475,
-0.4276468753814697,
-0.4766375422477722,
-0.3058833181858063,
-0.16647286713123322,
-0.5209971070289612,
1.0890570878982544,
0.6754862666130066,
-0.2016143649816513,
-0.07512468844652176,
-0.06475020200014114,
0.33715924620628357,
0.43346136808395386,
-1.137851357460022,
0.05800804868340492,
0.394263356924057,
0.34187498688697815,
0.4593246579170227,
0.5803637504577637,
-0.13515432178974152,
0.15665577352046967,
-0.5393849611282349,
-0.0057195392437279224,
-0.0664774477481842,
-0.26415306329727173,
-0.7899977564811707,
0.6622846722602844,
-0.16773535311222076,
-0.432355135679245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13720v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13720v2
|
Ouroboros: Generating Longer Drafts Phrase by Phrase for Faster Speculative Decoding
| 2024-02-21T11:31:28 | 2024-06-26T04:52:02 |
Weilin Zhao, Yuxiang Huang, Xu Han, Wang Xu, Chaojun Xiao, Xinrong Zhang, Yewei Fang, Kaihuo Zhang, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Speculative decoding is a widely used method that accelerates the generation
process of large language models (LLMs) with no compromise in model
performance. It achieves this goal by using an existing smaller model for
drafting and then employing the target LLM to verify the draft in a low-cost
parallel manner. Under such a drafting-verification framework, drafting
efficiency has become a bottleneck in the final speedup of speculative
decoding. Therefore, generating longer drafts at less cost can lead to better
decoding speedup. To achieve this, we introduce Ouroboros, which can generate
draft phrases to parallelize the drafting process and meanwhile lengthen drafts
in a training-free manner. The experimental results on various typical text
generation tasks show that Ouroboros can achieve speedups of up to $2.4\times$
over speculative decoding and $3.9\times$ over vanilla decoding, without
fine-tuning draft and target models.
|
[
-0.3909509778022766,
-0.6323743462562561,
0.43830808997154236,
0.5576977729797363,
-0.7739992737770081,
0.308710515499115,
-0.17721903324127197,
-0.8169896006584167,
0.4002660810947418,
0.8509488105773926,
-0.5990603566169739,
-0.22007277607917786,
-0.49004116654396057,
0.5955884456634521,
-0.257902592420578,
0.68527752161026,
0.11942288279533386,
-0.35219448804855347,
-0.22701366245746613,
0.4435417354106903,
-0.019001487642526627,
-0.3865322470664978,
-0.7273043394088745,
-0.32172611355781555,
0.2961002290248871,
0.46026650071144104,
0.7678806185722351,
1.1260446310043335,
0.4582267105579376,
0.34377413988113403,
-0.2741493880748749,
0.16742275655269623,
-0.7879588603973389,
0.3213226795196533,
0.10237979143857956,
-0.771575927734375,
-0.23265226185321808,
-0.20817814767360687,
0.5690352916717529,
0.495898962020874,
-0.1004650890827179,
-0.008114781230688095,
-0.3242276906967163,
0.8445987105369568,
-0.6514338850975037,
-0.1150481179356575,
-0.8376339077949524,
-0.03075091727077961,
-0.6689558029174805,
-0.5196581482887268,
-0.514916181564331,
-0.7898877859115601,
-0.12455960363149643,
-0.5725727677345276,
0.4409444332122803,
0.35980525612831116,
0.8107819557189941,
-0.05067823454737663,
-0.365191251039505,
-0.3756696283817291,
-0.45192959904670715,
0.6073008179664612,
-0.623661994934082,
0.46331971883773804,
0.4511646032333374,
0.33911529183387756,
-0.16975420713424683,
-0.9169366359710693,
-0.5887328386306763,
-0.433948278427124,
0.09202292561531067,
0.10502408444881439,
-0.10719671845436096,
0.2973582446575165,
0.5891680717468262,
0.36803722381591797,
-0.7412149310112,
0.15992268919944763,
-0.742181658744812,
-0.6023507714271545,
0.9138162136077881,
0.4289117753505707,
-0.11119750142097473,
-0.23074162006378174,
-0.49079132080078125,
-0.01211645919829607,
-0.8909742832183838,
-0.0345119833946228,
0.8413926362991333,
-0.048277534544467926,
0.129976287484169,
0.37695544958114624,
-0.6803407073020935,
0.7994672060012817,
-0.005628989078104496,
-0.3876579701900482,
0.0716378390789032,
-0.20726363360881805,
-0.13894245028495789,
0.08289697766304016,
0.8359400033950806,
0.3027104437351227,
-0.12519428133964539,
-0.3703013062477112,
-0.19145077466964722,
0.1758795976638794,
0.19888058304786682,
-1.232713222503662,
0.08328346163034439,
0.23940852284431458,
-0.5558328628540039,
-0.5156708359718323,
-0.29592379927635193,
-0.7559352517127991,
0.009099610149860382,
0.13680846989154816,
-0.013848686590790749,
-0.8603442311286926,
-0.09812355041503906,
0.38977673649787903,
-0.7722198367118835,
-0.21772241592407227,
-0.018087344244122505,
-1.0061390399932861,
0.2742825150489807,
0.6683522462844849,
0.765820324420929,
-0.017137261107563972,
-0.543799102306366,
-0.35979509353637695,
0.27986079454421997,
-0.9234822988510132,
1.202078104019165,
-0.35808658599853516,
-0.7851507067680359,
0.03314279392361641,
-0.6385537385940552,
0.33623015880584717,
-0.3809978663921356,
0.7156621813774109,
-0.7261478304862976,
-0.26792705059051514,
-0.4182133674621582,
-0.7430863380432129,
0.13451550900936127,
0.15821948647499084,
-0.5311867594718933,
1.004940390586853,
0.0743430107831955,
-0.6959810853004456,
0.4093003571033478,
-0.31481292843818665,
-0.7676042318344116,
0.2296997755765915,
0.03623370826244354,
-0.02562469244003296,
0.3602103888988495,
0.12112362682819366,
0.5073215365409851,
-0.7650122046470642,
-0.010759198106825352,
-0.20123273134231567,
-0.7160848379135132,
0.394256055355072,
-0.3560961186885834,
0.6950778961181641,
0.6310415267944336,
0.08015279471874237,
-0.06696487963199615,
-0.79118812084198,
0.2116106152534485,
0.0914321318268776,
-0.3833591639995575,
-0.2996656894683838,
-0.15660330653190613,
-0.055776700377464294,
0.012404168024659157,
0.23462402820587158,
-0.605056881904602,
0.41715770959854126,
-0.6502751111984253,
0.33374378085136414,
0.6986898183822632,
-0.03870220482349396,
0.27357494831085205,
-0.5508316159248352,
0.7915018200874329,
-0.20982694625854492,
0.053104739636182785,
-0.4234781563282013,
-0.419384628534317,
-0.7678150534629822,
-0.44852328300476074,
0.35631516575813293,
0.3066801130771637,
-1.1356661319732666,
0.42479243874549866,
-0.45599108934402466,
-0.6965131163597107,
-0.311445415019989,
0.36486905813217163,
0.6504217386245728,
0.3849617540836334,
0.15925176441669464,
-0.024317221716046333,
-0.609100341796875,
-0.8793129324913025,
-0.238479346036911,
-0.19867362082004547,
0.023983677849173546,
-0.20734509825706482,
0.34363555908203125,
-0.2183273285627365,
0.6102201342582703,
-0.8596702814102173,
0.03198456019163132,
-0.5470720529556274,
0.47360631823539734,
-0.01519095804542303,
0.17440566420555115,
0.7729102969169617,
-0.5734868049621582,
-0.45838025212287903,
-0.1288226991891861,
-0.5364091396331787,
-0.21520574390888214,
-0.2663348913192749,
-0.2842179834842682,
0.4173224866390228,
0.826366126537323,
-0.7915999293327332,
0.09904158115386963,
0.4916195571422577,
-0.3380647897720337,
0.6238396763801575,
-0.24953807890415192,
0.020784607157111168,
-1.2172166109085083,
-0.0672646164894104,
-0.46657466888427734,
-0.17986850440502167,
-0.2908046543598175,
0.4906099736690521,
0.0982469767332077,
-0.13604997098445892,
-0.27605533599853516,
0.36036771535873413,
-0.7769215106964111,
0.14028698205947876,
-0.49290868639945984,
0.12711399793624878,
0.10960308462381363,
0.2846844792366028,
0.1258193850517273,
0.7823238372802734,
0.6097341775894165,
-0.6048982739448547,
0.5348250269889832,
-0.00008242220792453736,
-0.15278583765029907,
0.2318997085094452,
-0.4872490465641022,
0.3216577470302582,
-0.09065039455890656,
0.337571918964386,
-0.6915051341056824,
-0.3401792049407959,
0.03030414506793022,
-0.1650504171848297,
0.12847808003425598,
-0.03855865076184273,
-0.5680819153785706,
-0.8585015535354614,
-0.7008218169212341,
0.38081836700439453,
0.7503976225852966,
-0.5682913064956665,
0.39787647128105164,
-0.050627194344997406,
-0.1443783938884735,
-0.6556755900382996,
-0.58838951587677,
0.15001611411571503,
0.02940068393945694,
-0.7702677845954895,
0.4415694773197174,
-0.2997181713581085,
-0.028145698830485344,
-0.04062766209244728,
0.025096481665968895,
-0.1966819167137146,
-0.16714884340763092,
0.24337033927440643,
0.00034494168357923627,
-0.23349563777446747,
0.01467826683074236,
0.6035900115966797,
-0.2696393132209778,
-0.08132272958755493,
-0.3319531977176666,
0.5952061414718628,
0.16697950661182404,
0.13968943059444427,
-0.4007382392883301,
0.7010992765426636,
0.3990522027015686,
-0.05135231092572212,
0.45897528529167175,
0.3850049078464508,
-0.17692889273166656,
-0.5075597167015076,
-0.7914553284645081,
0.004187904763966799,
-0.5953084826469421,
0.22303630411624908,
-0.6918039321899414,
-0.8636681437492371,
0.5159929990768433,
-0.1590314507484436,
-0.12426212430000305,
0.34995585680007935,
0.35136258602142334,
0.2694391906261444,
0.6913302540779114,
0.9603150486946106,
-0.07930638641119003,
0.2897017002105713,
-0.277631014585495,
-0.23597769439220428,
-0.5171741843223572,
-0.21283535659313202,
-0.6448692083358765,
-0.09611480683088303,
-0.24756242334842682,
-0.7169609665870667,
-0.08915570378303528,
0.42934682965278625,
0.5367441177368164,
0.365315705537796,
-0.28095918893814087,
0.7227876782417297,
0.5480794906616211,
0.03961435332894325,
0.36142995953559875,
-0.06629499793052673,
-0.20798799395561218,
0.09969689697027206,
-0.7598007917404175,
-0.35039108991622925,
1.292522668838501,
-0.12766915559768677,
0.6511502861976624,
-0.11497501283884048,
1.2110559940338135,
0.11814253777265549,
0.4095878303050995,
-0.9084428548812866,
0.8371548652648926,
-0.03412259742617607,
-0.6436792612075806,
-0.2583848536014557,
-0.6165361404418945,
-0.8768277764320374,
0.18037761747837067,
-0.25767281651496887,
-0.5883203744888306,
-0.06148070842027664,
0.4034728407859802,
-0.3049609959125519,
0.12083367258310318,
-0.4044644832611084,
0.423702597618103,
-0.06749598681926727,
-0.2555016875267029,
-0.5411333441734314,
-0.397918164730072,
0.6043683886528015,
-0.04281690716743469,
-0.16557103395462036,
-0.10541827976703644,
-0.21110136806964874,
0.7583726644515991,
-0.4638795554637909,
0.47955843806266785,
0.33410170674324036,
-0.2558166980743408,
0.5948535799980164,
0.14801977574825287,
0.4834597706794739,
0.3897704780101776,
-0.4095670282840729,
0.15872877836227417,
-0.058282144367694855,
-0.4713248312473297,
-0.4172445237636566,
0.5867350101470947,
-0.30291643738746643,
-0.5997644662857056,
-0.4786427319049835,
-0.6404474377632141,
-0.17849265038967133,
0.5030226707458496,
1.0491394996643066,
0.48905083537101746,
-0.40611404180526733,
-0.02932756580412388,
0.4698445796966553,
0.22697477042675018,
0.4188593029975891,
0.300732284784317,
-0.25957590341567993,
-0.4028235077857971,
0.9999914169311523,
0.004856020212173462,
0.09423057734966278,
0.7183695435523987,
0.21450644731521606,
-0.30480673909187317,
-1.0158737897872925,
-0.26411211490631104,
0.25065338611602783,
-0.519111692905426,
-0.5808852314949036,
-0.38655537366867065,
-0.012689938768744469,
-0.5432271361351013,
-0.4484216272830963,
-0.3664444386959076,
-0.6625568270683289,
0.011913828551769257,
-0.3032689690589905,
0.4464797377586365,
0.6645415425300598,
-0.290592223405838,
0.553136944770813,
-1.167741298675537,
0.8070682883262634,
0.2779531180858612,
0.31009891629219055,
-0.2953881323337555,
-0.30064237117767334,
-0.2674666941165924,
-0.08008144050836563,
-0.36374548077583313,
-0.9314460158348083,
0.36614006757736206,
0.13023370504379272,
0.44776949286460876,
0.8064455986022949,
0.05780385807156563,
0.8215740323066711,
-0.4937676787376404,
0.6420474052429199,
0.2370278388261795,
-1.1130900382995605,
0.5255521535873413,
-0.46338868141174316,
0.25012126564979553,
0.4361148774623871,
0.5472217202186584,
-0.3483068346977234,
-0.5748891830444336,
-0.5426850914955139,
-0.7374209761619568,
0.6759231090545654,
0.3695141673088074,
0.11924789845943451,
-0.14974859356880188,
0.5757087469100952,
0.34595221281051636,
0.24263246357440948,
-0.1337733119726181,
0.016251863911747932,
-0.12934237718582153,
0.014807802625000477,
-0.24523891508579254,
-0.8117831945419312,
-0.13894285261631012,
0.1251467913389206,
0.5694830417633057,
-0.155103400349617,
0.3071960210800171,
0.03132691606879234,
-0.08841335028409958,
-0.24841079115867615,
0.2234872430562973,
0.7198682427406311,
0.5461341738700867,
-0.37685680389404297,
-0.1607368141412735,
0.05571296066045761,
-0.65068119764328,
-0.10654478520154953,
0.18643741309642792,
-0.22011178731918335,
0.1793513298034668,
0.5521613359451294,
0.831304132938385,
0.054169949144124985,
-0.8014492988586426,
0.07911748439073563,
-0.22789046168327332,
-0.5071496367454529,
0.03929143771529198,
0.15517689287662506,
0.1201520562171936,
0.16850151121616364,
0.4635279178619385,
0.22564120590686798,
0.33613893389701843,
-0.5519681572914124,
0.1311410367488861,
0.24930979311466217,
0.23295485973358154,
-0.434610515832901,
0.5493375062942505,
0.5014079809188843,
-0.21741627156734467,
0.6364996433258057,
-0.4775671064853668,
-0.3808154761791229,
0.7449341416358948,
0.916789174079895,
0.9990814924240112,
-0.11714331805706024,
0.2771622836589813,
0.24700361490249634,
0.3268728256225586,
-0.44836193323135376,
0.660075843334198,
-0.2403041571378708,
-0.5799254179000854,
-0.23407654464244843,
-0.8324275016784668,
-0.3663886785507202,
-0.10030171275138855,
-0.807031512260437,
-0.06364180892705917,
-0.5834349989891052,
-0.3035186231136322,
-0.2850062847137451,
-0.13993386924266815,
-0.3943658173084259,
0.28990790247917175,
0.09276527166366577,
1.2040138244628906,
-0.49398738145828247,
0.8722187876701355,
0.45444321632385254,
-0.06354447454214096,
-0.7621341943740845,
0.23937320709228516,
-0.08274770528078079,
-0.5649128556251526,
0.6634864807128906,
0.256168395280838,
-0.4142676591873169,
0.040750760585069656,
-0.1748225837945938,
-0.8500868678092957,
1.0710126161575317,
0.7218292355537415,
-0.6518442034721375,
-0.2420790046453476,
0.056659914553165436,
0.7242529988288879,
-0.243806391954422,
-0.02511230856180191,
0.4878575801849365,
0.11814194172620773,
0.22554878890514374,
-0.6133079528808594,
0.2682078182697296,
-0.321108877658844,
0.33358508348464966,
0.37024128437042236,
-0.8463743925094604,
0.6935245394706726,
-0.4468899369239807,
-0.14621113240718842,
0.5634580254554749,
0.917281985282898,
0.24790328741073608,
0.0494346022605896,
0.25162139534950256,
0.5430349707603455,
0.8534972667694092,
0.09706521779298782,
1.2721155881881714,
-0.4508628249168396,
-0.06598644703626633,
0.5476113557815552,
-0.25149422883987427,
1.0727332830429077,
0.5176620483398438,
-0.0364990197122097,
0.40232425928115845,
0.3835907578468323,
0.3551980257034302,
0.43437036871910095,
0.08279149234294891,
-0.15118804574012756,
-0.4853564500808716,
0.06697768718004227,
-0.592978835105896,
0.5094293355941772,
0.4764185845851898,
-0.07702351361513138,
0.021613627672195435,
-0.0874362587928772,
-0.13757804036140442,
0.21982064843177795,
-0.23764349520206451,
0.331455260515213,
0.19188883900642395,
-0.8130819201469421,
0.8531769514083862,
0.14185236394405365,
0.9073833227157593,
-1.123915195465088,
0.1789165735244751,
-0.3525148332118988,
0.1397787481546402,
0.10714676231145859,
-0.40527740120887756,
0.4109635651111603,
-0.1185392439365387,
-0.009088737890124321,
-0.3355943262577057,
0.7034263610839844,
-0.23467616736888885,
-0.8819173574447632,
0.3445969820022583,
0.21431809663772583,
0.08052884787321091,
0.0054969871416687965,
-0.35398849844932556,
0.367150217294693,
-0.0956391915678978,
-0.4132719933986664,
0.10332360863685608,
0.5592887997627258,
0.020370829850435257,
0.8983051180839539,
0.9232296347618103,
0.36154821515083313,
0.2401757389307022,
-0.1683047115802765,
0.9219003319740295,
-0.907709538936615,
-0.9779481291770935,
-0.8279100060462952,
0.06191767379641533,
-0.10260042548179626,
-0.6233740448951721,
0.7901619076728821,
0.7071050405502319,
0.7960294485092163,
-0.33610233664512634,
0.8253176808357239,
-0.017543213441967964,
0.2597969174385071,
-1.0893182754516602,
0.6264309883117676,
-0.41904571652412415,
0.07922879606485367,
-0.08021951466798782,
-0.7177659869194031,
0.015955857932567596,
0.26525944471359253,
0.1911560595035553,
-0.2739524841308594,
0.9611485004425049,
0.7622191905975342,
0.18948476016521454,
0.09459331631660461,
0.4886075556278229,
0.14253708720207214,
-0.04861776903271675,
0.6770897507667542,
0.9154968857765198,
-0.3981490731239319,
1.0118653774261475,
-0.7788804769515991,
-0.008286844938993454,
-0.3067251741886139,
-0.9242764711380005,
-1.4345558881759644,
-0.33126944303512573,
-0.039908137172460556,
-0.12884509563446045,
0.30339980125427246,
0.6951454281806946,
0.5903810262680054,
-0.24055665731430054,
-0.5624374151229858,
-0.16325312852859497,
0.19144047796726227,
-0.45464903116226196,
-0.16727253794670105,
0.1755286008119583,
-0.4100365936756134,
-0.745914101600647,
0.6382052898406982,
0.367342084646225,
0.06241702660918236,
0.1945130079984665,
-0.12065470963716507,
0.16635721921920776,
0.4796483516693115,
0.5794424414634705,
0.4286012649536133,
-0.5064384341239929,
0.14867469668388367,
-0.04641268402338028,
-0.14345933496952057,
-0.1410384476184845,
1.210092306137085,
-0.7651380300521851,
0.2646801173686981,
0.8931560516357422,
0.39473941922187805,
0.6316256523132324,
0.006405076012015343,
0.8144043684005737,
-0.6783768534660339,
0.8789679408073425,
0.28568851947784424,
0.3366987407207489,
0.04860583692789078,
-0.5711394548416138,
0.3016042709350586,
0.31686094403266907,
-0.11697688698768616,
-0.9275363683700562,
0.4480336010456085,
-1.116248369216919,
-0.3807094395160675,
0.9448587894439697,
-0.03111475147306919,
-0.31235235929489136,
0.0950327143073082,
-0.3297872245311737,
0.14492236077785492,
-0.5900944471359253,
0.9321430921554565,
0.3336719572544098,
-0.28490686416625977,
0.22963450849056244,
-0.05741138756275177,
0.7492451071739197,
0.24145887792110443,
-0.972307026386261,
0.10537213832139969,
0.5372665524482727,
0.17385001480579376,
0.49139338731765747,
1.016623854637146,
0.17655883729457855,
0.6188877820968628,
0.72675621509552,
-0.13964344561100006,
-0.4804280400276184,
-0.39182958006858826,
-0.0585969015955925,
0.3018302917480469,
0.1916479617357254,
0.1585475504398346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14867v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14867v1
|
Effects of term weighting approach with and without stop words removing on Arabic text classification
| 2024-02-21T11:31:04 | 2024-02-21T11:31:04 |
Esra'a Alhenawi, Ruba Abu Khurma, Pedro A. Castillo, Maribel G. Arenas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Classifying text is a method for categorizing documents into pre-established
groups. Text documents must be prepared and represented in a way that is
appropriate for the algorithms used for data mining prior to classification. As
a result, a number of term weighting strategies have been created in the
literature to enhance text categorization algorithms' functionality. This study
compares the effects of Binary and Term frequency weighting feature
methodologies on the text's classification method when stop words are
eliminated once and when they are not. In recognition of assessing the effects
of prior weighting of features approaches on classification results in terms of
accuracy, recall, precision, and F-measure values, we used an Arabic data set
made up of 322 documents divided into six main topics (agriculture, economy,
health, politics, science, and sport), each of which contains 50 documents,
with the exception of the health category, which contains 61 documents. The
results demonstrate that for all metrics, the term frequency feature weighting
approach with stop word removal outperforms the binary approach, while for
accuracy, recall, and F-Measure, the binary approach outperforms the TF
approach without stop word removal. However, for precision, the two approaches
produce results that are very similar. Additionally, it is clear from the data
that, using the same phrase weighting approach, stop word removing increases
classification accuracy.
|
[
-0.5834860801696777,
-0.7033558487892151,
0.24257880449295044,
0.11543258279561996,
-0.5734682679176331,
0.30561819672584534,
-0.19373363256454468,
-0.7049094438552856,
0.31307992339134216,
0.33645933866500854,
-0.037459470331668854,
-0.6541627049446106,
-1.0798990726470947,
0.27958837151527405,
-0.6863870620727539,
1.2712870836257935,
-0.4111323654651642,
-0.012098793871700764,
-0.12944911420345306,
-0.41518262028694153,
-0.6305869817733765,
-0.7205322980880737,
-0.6649080514907837,
-0.48864510655403137,
0.5523369312286377,
0.32035186886787415,
0.916540801525116,
0.6325358152389526,
0.6127741932868958,
0.33284345269203186,
-0.26372846961021423,
-0.28460532426834106,
-0.14409804344177246,
-0.07498311251401901,
0.14298699796199799,
-0.5667286515235901,
0.022625915706157684,
0.15454934537410736,
0.6229134202003479,
0.6472831964492798,
-0.23629246652126312,
0.032819125801324844,
-0.017886511981487274,
0.9263670444488525,
-0.7090306878089905,
-0.11548560857772827,
-0.2843574583530426,
0.26746582984924316,
-0.4605692923069,
-0.3077315092086792,
-0.003708391450345516,
-0.23860569298267365,
0.2106897532939911,
-0.21696433424949646,
0.3348030745983124,
0.11569967865943909,
1.0650578737258911,
0.14466625452041626,
-0.33885952830314636,
-0.8713353276252747,
-0.7671345472335815,
0.7684025764465332,
-0.5143527388572693,
0.2489919364452362,
0.49803680181503296,
-0.20647887885570526,
0.06612647324800491,
-0.3333003520965576,
-0.6673046350479126,
-0.019084447994828224,
-0.17822879552841187,
0.1626017987728119,
-0.16144505143165588,
0.0466044656932354,
0.5489083528518677,
0.3009289503097534,
-0.4411156177520752,
0.13111437857151031,
-0.6271729469299316,
-0.20456847548484802,
0.5539323687553406,
-0.2257767766714096,
0.3927680552005768,
-0.36020833253860474,
-0.4661775827407837,
-0.08461415022611618,
-0.6918710470199585,
0.31370070576667786,
0.21895791590213776,
0.10948805510997772,
0.1891215443611145,
0.646166205406189,
-0.22148621082305908,
0.44163286685943604,
-0.1251101791858673,
-0.392962783575058,
0.35509318113327026,
-0.34811580181121826,
-0.30548301339149475,
0.5462980270385742,
0.6150595545768738,
0.3678987920284271,
0.2801579535007477,
-0.30003172159194946,
-0.22365286946296692,
0.033601608127355576,
0.32795271277427673,
-0.874631404876709,
0.25050121545791626,
0.19866971671581268,
-0.9664826393127441,
-0.33268654346466064,
0.2007208913564682,
-0.5443676114082336,
-0.09623212367296219,
-0.18444257974624634,
0.6226867437362671,
-0.5528400540351868,
-0.09854312986135483,
0.11293663084506989,
-0.3613165616989136,
0.3811958134174347,
0.37834596633911133,
-0.5931437015533447,
0.6319705843925476,
0.5392950773239136,
1.1278131008148193,
-0.4005410075187683,
0.21821217238903046,
-0.1797860562801361,
-0.08884886652231216,
-0.5679811239242554,
0.49165502190589905,
-0.8078102469444275,
-0.688854455947876,
-0.16813668608665466,
-0.28588709235191345,
-0.1489766389131546,
-0.5982532501220703,
0.7328628897666931,
-0.6060529351234436,
0.42349642515182495,
-0.35775089263916016,
-0.5405265688896179,
-0.7093485593795776,
0.01173566933721304,
-0.6138387322425842,
1.085445523262024,
-0.1281006634235382,
-0.8352465629577637,
0.7189497351646423,
-0.5701406598091125,
-0.6992597579956055,
0.12381494045257568,
-0.11612385511398315,
-0.6598482728004456,
0.12224715203046799,
-0.013770491816103458,
0.16865535080432892,
-0.12562109529972076,
0.0009890220826491714,
0.13433295488357544,
-0.7295956015586853,
0.2697192132472992,
-0.2807077169418335,
0.22687992453575134,
0.3359837532043457,
-0.7353401184082031,
-0.10507755726575851,
-0.5457315444946289,
0.01950259879231453,
-0.07843803614377975,
-0.33408215641975403,
-0.7583420872688293,
0.33967339992523193,
0.22972741723060608,
0.5225661396980286,
-0.030066782608628273,
-0.7777881622314453,
-0.05217356234788895,
-0.6655396819114685,
0.09747826308012009,
0.28507402539253235,
-0.038220155984163284,
0.23606467247009277,
-0.7871833443641663,
0.5185850262641907,
0.06465713679790497,
-0.2682723104953766,
0.15616056323051453,
-0.4449313282966614,
-0.6328132748603821,
-0.2893011271953583,
0.6959180235862732,
0.7572612166404724,
-0.9918986558914185,
0.32803112268447876,
-0.28355157375335693,
-0.5904461741447449,
-0.09113940596580505,
-0.07062342762947083,
0.6714693903923035,
0.324600487947464,
0.5418200492858887,
-0.7269185781478882,
-0.20843389630317688,
-0.5249134302139282,
-0.24622167646884918,
-0.048700205981731415,
-0.19817517697811127,
0.08310870826244354,
0.7959146499633789,
0.1540951132774353,
0.9958771467208862,
-0.5570926070213318,
-0.4175311028957367,
0.0891157016158104,
0.4242633879184723,
-0.0776960626244545,
0.38668662309646606,
0.8012611865997314,
-1.1121740341186523,
-0.2702045142650604,
-0.1434130072593689,
-0.5236366391181946,
-0.06578042358160019,
0.13217684626579285,
0.11300011724233627,
0.9508015513420105,
0.20940016210079193,
-0.42973461747169495,
1.160714864730835,
-0.017465954646468163,
-0.26776811480522156,
0.49140623211860657,
-0.1615525633096695,
0.41995325684547424,
-0.6439085602760315,
0.09520042687654495,
0.19207099080085754,
0.043600328266620636,
-0.8313566446304321,
-0.22602730989456177,
-0.0542592890560627,
0.06207806617021561,
-0.29072558879852295,
0.6010487079620361,
-0.18987292051315308,
0.006472322624176741,
-0.6289583444595337,
0.02558908797800541,
0.02423584833741188,
0.14512749016284943,
0.45000964403152466,
0.8647201061248779,
0.038729503750801086,
-0.6745408177375793,
-0.18826663494110107,
0.24527187645435333,
-0.4249558746814728,
0.436419814825058,
-0.4924498200416565,
-0.11732295155525208,
-0.3897910714149475,
-0.09108135104179382,
-1.090569019317627,
0.5507058501243591,
0.4463405907154083,
-0.532819926738739,
0.2942827641963959,
0.5773795247077942,
-0.551466703414917,
-0.33400940895080566,
-0.6708777546882629,
-0.06262986361980438,
0.4235517978668213,
0.004844023380428553,
0.329779714345932,
-0.04281239211559296,
-0.37795302271842957,
-0.5624704957008362,
-0.5579153299331665,
0.12434493750333786,
-0.6851879358291626,
-0.028050625696778297,
0.6991073489189148,
0.05099831894040108,
-0.24960209429264069,
0.10516001284122467,
-0.6146301031112671,
-0.13197503983974457,
0.29686835408210754,
0.34441378712654114,
0.03131323680281639,
0.22195462882518768,
0.7151723504066467,
0.1418902575969696,
0.0236403476446867,
0.07814253121614456,
0.07479757070541382,
0.6931912899017334,
0.2552477717399597,
-0.01150471717119217,
-0.32380613684654236,
0.3351844847202301,
0.3130740225315094,
-0.5688198208808899,
1.2468034029006958,
0.8984928727149963,
-0.4397771656513214,
0.3261867165565491,
-0.6146489977836609,
-0.00449646869674325,
-0.4238114655017853,
0.19966095685958862,
-0.37927645444869995,
-0.7927497029304504,
0.2933422923088074,
0.022378522902727127,
-0.002679619239643216,
0.7397138476371765,
0.27221426367759705,
-0.3228263556957245,
0.6642804741859436,
0.6113030314445496,
-0.20047451555728912,
0.5969684720039368,
0.03278641775250435,
0.0924195796251297,
-0.6362236142158508,
-0.48049336671829224,
-1.2512478828430176,
-0.44856324791908264,
-0.5707976222038269,
-0.13342608511447906,
0.23460370302200317,
0.25418177247047424,
-0.17741748690605164,
0.09124544262886047,
-0.5316405892372131,
-0.0974581390619278,
0.41734611988067627,
0.35359054803848267,
0.17500513792037964,
0.5910508632659912,
0.0407978855073452,
-0.12462916225194931,
-0.4449196755886078,
-0.505449652671814,
1.1540848016738892,
0.08181943744421005,
0.2602890431880951,
0.16734488308429718,
1.0321913957595825,
0.6602425575256348,
0.5890394449234009,
-1.0100805759429932,
0.2658362090587616,
-0.3355392813682556,
-0.24624377489089966,
-0.5447984933853149,
-0.5379061698913574,
-1.0345420837402344,
0.24742959439754486,
-0.5267220735549927,
-0.5333996415138245,
-0.023625226691365242,
-0.4753532409667969,
-0.14935976266860962,
0.2961645722389221,
-0.48760369420051575,
0.4373711347579956,
-0.39086681604385376,
0.11873562633991241,
-0.3143062889575958,
-0.3433174192905426,
-0.10391545295715332,
-0.5451325178146362,
0.44078218936920166,
0.0924016684293747,
-0.5436620116233826,
1.4221338033676147,
-0.6970542669296265,
0.4197307825088501,
-0.23434890806674957,
-0.0844150111079216,
0.3817601203918457,
-0.2922815680503845,
0.0033208897802978754,
-0.5040243268013,
-0.29689890146255493,
0.44575223326683044,
0.3323003649711609,
-0.26770028471946716,
-0.4395422041416168,
0.1560496836900711,
-0.7407763600349426,
-0.4909849464893341,
-0.8120487332344055,
-0.1925319880247116,
0.15549854934215546,
0.28067100048065186,
0.1262487769126892,
0.6675073504447937,
0.0017037263605743647,
0.2691783308982849,
0.5791231393814087,
-0.5226641893386841,
0.7629246115684509,
0.5442129969596863,
-0.2572035491466522,
-0.38153403997421265,
0.8551557660102844,
0.7194917798042297,
0.13978824019432068,
0.5226998329162598,
0.13241228461265564,
-0.3034074604511261,
-0.952069103717804,
-0.07963968068361282,
0.09337282180786133,
-0.22149570286273956,
-0.171529158949852,
-0.6181982159614563,
-0.3718060851097107,
-0.2590027451515198,
-0.07881968468427658,
0.5415694117546082,
-0.42092978954315186,
-0.1445961892604828,
0.09502510726451874,
0.5886743664741516,
0.5004332065582275,
0.24790307879447937,
0.7312965989112854,
-0.911973237991333,
0.3477977514266968,
-0.218639075756073,
0.319367915391922,
0.10227054357528687,
-0.4550933837890625,
-0.403613418340683,
-0.1366012692451477,
-0.3690539002418518,
-0.9639793038368225,
0.48544105887413025,
0.34697073698043823,
0.4395607113838196,
0.47500693798065186,
0.03595414012670517,
0.5575144290924072,
-0.45238590240478516,
0.5739114284515381,
0.2843453884124756,
-1.1713122129440308,
0.3328797221183777,
-0.005863924976438284,
0.6022202372550964,
0.45645660161972046,
0.8923114538192749,
-0.8695197701454163,
-0.413845419883728,
-0.5353431105613708,
-0.7440692782402039,
0.6952925324440002,
0.5794747471809387,
-0.19510874152183533,
-0.21399377286434174,
0.7691248655319214,
0.09352236241102219,
0.8292878270149231,
-0.2251771092414856,
-0.5102960467338562,
-0.04963342100381851,
-0.3374629616737366,
-0.07145291566848755,
-0.4652383625507355,
0.2934008836746216,
-0.12127245962619781,
0.5330836176872253,
0.4039711356163025,
0.14306558668613434,
0.32956594228744507,
-0.1998516321182251,
-0.026837721467018127,
0.49915584921836853,
0.6212063431739807,
0.6627047657966614,
-0.32739341259002686,
-0.22617954015731812,
0.1886388063430786,
-0.9313545823097229,
0.15941222012043,
0.11514344811439514,
-0.5935073494911194,
0.2434215098619461,
0.49641263484954834,
0.4716196656227112,
0.1096545159816742,
-0.4503920376300812,
0.15634338557720184,
-0.018545806407928467,
-0.3620384931564331,
-0.08942852914333344,
0.11392147839069366,
-0.27141425013542175,
-0.3058098554611206,
0.6299992203712463,
0.19256296753883362,
0.36033159494400024,
-0.430655837059021,
0.30736371874809265,
0.4947369396686554,
-0.40814945101737976,
0.2308051884174347,
0.22632929682731628,
-0.0898776724934578,
-0.30118709802627563,
0.35976848006248474,
0.010663868859410286,
-0.6171692609786987,
1.0269068479537964,
0.3273938000202179,
0.4830576479434967,
-0.3658803701400757,
0.483141154050827,
0.33362066745758057,
0.48458677530288696,
-0.05847291275858879,
0.38966310024261475,
-0.19062653183937073,
-0.7649704217910767,
-0.31464868783950806,
-1.0255036354064941,
-0.3306936025619507,
-0.014175180345773697,
-0.7650096416473389,
-0.05881572142243385,
-0.46818065643310547,
-0.3597528636455536,
0.1758388727903366,
0.5681682825088501,
-0.5184288024902344,
0.6310720443725586,
0.1484769731760025,
0.82805335521698,
-0.7781615853309631,
0.6126880645751953,
0.8042649626731873,
-0.43965601921081543,
-0.7745711207389832,
0.18975697457790375,
0.09203798323869705,
-0.24018558859825134,
0.6580913066864014,
0.7352901101112366,
-0.2393776923418045,
-0.14922356605529785,
-0.22214500606060028,
-1.065034031867981,
0.8103918433189392,
-0.36230453848838806,
-0.4286234974861145,
0.18557962775230408,
0.31022652983665466,
0.66932213306427,
-0.12247871607542038,
0.2031227946281433,
0.5555415749549866,
0.5089907646179199,
0.324309378862381,
-1.1101977825164795,
0.11018926650285721,
-0.023249546065926552,
0.16134324669837952,
0.6099498867988586,
-0.5677511096000671,
0.618664026260376,
0.22595073282718658,
-0.4706166088581085,
0.1701858937740326,
0.4805118143558502,
-0.038469184190034866,
0.5760219097137451,
0.6625018119812012,
0.7300330996513367,
0.6832544207572937,
-0.24894441664218903,
0.7108174562454224,
-0.15369416773319244,
0.27099207043647766,
0.4968014657497406,
-0.5206446647644043,
0.7914911508560181,
0.14013703167438507,
-0.49692055583000183,
0.6750766038894653,
0.6284928321838379,
0.13556569814682007,
0.45962104201316833,
0.29167696833610535,
-0.3309776186943054,
0.23849454522132874,
-0.13786020874977112,
-0.45619669556617737,
0.8653718829154968,
0.5622878670692444,
-0.21170800924301147,
-0.367463618516922,
0.5420392751693726,
0.394392192363739,
0.17104831337928772,
-0.7743474841117859,
0.723497211933136,
0.014621760696172714,
-0.5532475113868713,
0.44354185461997986,
0.5055960416793823,
0.8957592248916626,
-0.5691850185394287,
-0.105263352394104,
-0.03937874734401703,
-0.22715893387794495,
-0.3640972375869751,
-0.643441379070282,
0.7062555551528931,
0.024246834218502045,
-0.30327460169792175,
-0.19032496213912964,
0.8782899379730225,
-0.4590981602668762,
-0.6345601081848145,
0.1824168562889099,
0.4352962076663971,
0.3306456506252289,
-0.10911116003990173,
-0.6488723754882812,
-0.015516470186412334,
-0.20054413378238678,
-0.20777255296707153,
0.29603198170661926,
0.16832883656024933,
-0.3765605390071869,
0.5295513868331909,
0.5804330706596375,
0.25372380018234253,
-0.456849068403244,
-0.18994839489459991,
0.5900837779045105,
-0.8794069886207581,
-0.37076660990715027,
-0.8935962915420532,
-0.2762317955493927,
-0.06060115247964859,
0.11807025969028473,
0.7712468504905701,
0.5607532858848572,
0.7303547859191895,
0.10791730880737305,
0.49488070607185364,
-0.34798961877822876,
0.43109264969825745,
-0.7316415905952454,
0.9378532767295837,
-0.6442493796348572,
-0.1275891363620758,
-0.4215451180934906,
-0.80986088514328,
-0.2968364953994751,
0.4121131896972656,
-0.5613627433776855,
0.449214905500412,
0.8901327848434448,
0.45191890001296997,
0.6145051121711731,
0.07088027149438858,
0.011941988952457905,
-0.09881871938705444,
0.04012291505932808,
0.21718718111515045,
0.22630693018436432,
-0.3064923584461212,
0.5006265640258789,
-0.08150771260261536,
-0.34642285108566284,
0.019026657566428185,
-0.5032323002815247,
-0.8271581530570984,
-0.26784995198249817,
-0.31766024231910706,
-0.14749017357826233,
0.17448142170906067,
0.7408152222633362,
0.13774724304676056,
-0.8178286552429199,
-0.061042919754981995,
0.5086143016815186,
0.39532580971717834,
-0.42543771862983704,
-0.2342965453863144,
0.8557078838348389,
-0.14920902252197266,
-0.41727927327156067,
-0.22059279680252075,
0.25770682096481323,
-0.009552322328090668,
0.2606413662433624,
0.1888517439365387,
-0.4061480164527893,
-0.026505455374717712,
0.7615927457809448,
0.22553136944770813,
-0.42002788186073303,
-0.4384519159793854,
-0.2505788803100586,
-0.07290948927402496,
0.21240486204624176,
0.5299260020256042,
-1.140676498413086,
0.27842435240745544,
0.1891062706708908,
0.33157995343208313,
0.43246692419052124,
0.39710819721221924,
0.13495562970638275,
-0.5635541677474976,
0.35442402958869934,
-0.1803216189146042,
0.01867915876209736,
0.013641267083585262,
-0.3652033507823944,
0.45713314414024353,
0.357876181602478,
-0.1297600269317627,
-0.48458778858184814,
-0.12456028163433075,
-0.6645545959472656,
-0.38683927059173584,
0.6989142894744873,
0.049082860350608826,
-0.2773916721343994,
-0.3051309883594513,
-0.22635701298713684,
0.4836653470993042,
-0.27804648876190186,
1.031962275505066,
1.0831466913223267,
0.07723147422075272,
-0.2129496932029724,
-0.5532161593437195,
0.45215752720832825,
0.549069881439209,
-0.7658678293228149,
-0.7002735137939453,
0.40632545948028564,
0.3424738347530365,
0.32181546092033386,
0.7353436946868896,
-0.19879880547523499,
0.1927398145198822,
-0.3795066475868225,
0.2520725727081299,
-0.06703288853168488,
-0.32800742983818054,
-0.35070741176605225,
0.49600502848625183,
-0.10736396908760071,
-0.14645171165466309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13718v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13718v3
|
$\infty$Bench: Extending Long Context Evaluation Beyond 100K Tokens
| 2024-02-21T11:30:29 | 2024-02-24T15:07:55 |
Xinrong Zhang, Yingfa Chen, Shengding Hu, Zihang Xu, Junhao Chen, Moo Khai Hao, Xu Han, Zhen Leng Thai, Shuo Wang, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Processing and reasoning over long contexts is crucial for many practical
applications of Large Language Models (LLMs), such as document comprehension
and agent construction. Despite recent strides in making LLMs process contexts
with more than 100K tokens, there is currently a lack of a standardized
benchmark to evaluate this long-context capability. Existing public benchmarks
typically focus on contexts around 10K tokens, limiting the assessment and
comparison of LLMs in processing longer contexts. In this paper, we propose
$\infty$Bench, the first LLM benchmark featuring an average data length
surpassing 100K tokens. $\infty$Bench comprises synthetic and realistic tasks
spanning diverse domains, presented in both English and Chinese. The tasks in
$\infty$Bench are designed to require well understanding of long dependencies
in contexts, and make simply retrieving a limited number of passages from
contexts not sufficient for these tasks. In our experiments, based on
$\infty$Bench, we evaluate the state-of-the-art proprietary and open-source
LLMs tailored for processing long contexts. The results indicate that existing
long context LLMs still require significant advancements to effectively process
100K+ context. We further present three intriguing analyses regarding the
behavior of LLMs processing long context.
|
[
-0.4942455291748047,
-0.7163520455360413,
0.9405381083488464,
0.47015950083732605,
-0.34123513102531433,
-0.06837762147188187,
-0.6853570342063904,
-0.7864325642585754,
-0.13991284370422363,
0.49216732382774353,
-0.3974859416484833,
-0.33397942781448364,
-0.38797178864479065,
0.09261263906955719,
-0.45610031485557556,
0.6173034310340881,
-0.24447980523109436,
0.013046283274888992,
-0.4928639829158783,
-0.3636108636856079,
-0.42732298374176025,
-0.5431311726570129,
-0.5646173357963562,
-0.29853349924087524,
0.10401301085948944,
0.27871212363243103,
0.3684665858745575,
0.589623749256134,
0.3028571605682373,
0.229915589094162,
-0.09572060406208038,
0.02981664426624775,
-0.4883611798286438,
0.2888888120651245,
-0.17271487414836884,
-0.24820324778556824,
-0.47570228576660156,
-0.16682913899421692,
1.0031296014785767,
0.912255048751831,
0.30838850140571594,
0.22115178406238556,
0.1384277194738388,
0.7782330513000488,
-0.5380941033363342,
0.16987349092960358,
-0.4475107491016388,
-0.20433743298053741,
-0.5537930130958557,
0.03492719307541847,
-0.47650644183158875,
0.07327121496200562,
0.008575820364058018,
-0.28251945972442627,
-0.35566246509552,
-0.15724393725395203,
0.5909212231636047,
0.11889126151800156,
-0.4622442424297333,
-0.021920721977949142,
-0.5093780755996704,
0.9399968981742859,
-0.8034135699272156,
0.5528451800346375,
0.47010964155197144,
0.6731379628181458,
-0.5208972692489624,
-0.8997507095336914,
-0.5740506649017334,
-0.4020293354988098,
0.17409107089042664,
-0.08742211759090424,
0.07455168664455414,
-0.036197539418935776,
0.46110108494758606,
0.10532117635011673,
-0.33214059472084045,
0.13543635606765747,
0.050869353115558624,
0.2649296224117279,
0.6036525964736938,
0.11950162798166275,
-0.13292047381401062,
-0.18285273015499115,
-0.7588260173797607,
0.013699655421078205,
-0.7452013492584229,
0.221146360039711,
-0.12910820543766022,
0.1840258687734604,
0.03399770334362984,
0.2846528887748718,
-0.37908515334129333,
0.6955845355987549,
-0.2660556137561798,
-0.1880178302526474,
0.06806197762489319,
-0.3206899166107178,
-0.3882628381252289,
-0.24048179388046265,
0.4198363721370697,
0.48497533798217773,
0.19650055468082428,
-0.42407143115997314,
-0.5616198182106018,
-0.35375210642814636,
0.0027594726998358965,
-0.8259081244468689,
0.6960706114768982,
0.41968241333961487,
-0.46798694133758545,
0.45437362790107727,
-0.014106516726315022,
-0.6025009751319885,
-0.43250057101249695,
-0.6172482967376709,
0.13250651955604553,
-0.5743449330329895,
-0.14066855609416962,
-0.0003020644944626838,
-0.09507833421230316,
0.4989206790924072,
0.2494731992483139,
-0.5742306113243103,
0.467647522687912,
1.181387186050415,
0.7627325654029846,
-0.4181436598300934,
-0.4993124306201935,
-0.4830446243286133,
0.23892414569854736,
-0.3665737807750702,
0.665724515914917,
-0.529938817024231,
-0.3662915825843811,
0.1611631214618683,
0.2545289099216461,
0.021363595500588417,
-0.6916093826293945,
0.7490510940551758,
-0.4415799379348755,
-0.2391493171453476,
-0.4429231882095337,
-0.746982753276825,
0.07688978314399719,
0.40301182866096497,
-0.4417898654937744,
1.1637060642242432,
0.4195408523082733,
-0.22336025536060333,
0.7906215786933899,
-0.7233113646507263,
-0.47539088129997253,
0.38964271545410156,
-0.21351830661296844,
0.2685360908508301,
0.0891137346625328,
0.10850971937179565,
0.4817337095737457,
-0.6259245276451111,
0.5216798186302185,
-0.5117286443710327,
-0.8785277009010315,
0.4332622289657593,
-0.2956154942512512,
0.580615222454071,
0.26355376839637756,
-0.4709981381893158,
0.230706125497818,
-0.7940734028816223,
0.11922410130500793,
-0.12378367781639099,
-0.2962411642074585,
-0.3317906856536865,
0.04232851415872574,
0.27202218770980835,
0.15143661201000214,
0.34707924723625183,
-0.7211260795593262,
-0.12043371051549911,
-0.5234507322311401,
0.8017410635948181,
0.7359645366668701,
-0.3428741693496704,
0.3182944655418396,
-0.3110295832157135,
0.30005621910095215,
-0.511837363243103,
0.17622162401676178,
-0.09143014252185822,
-0.07264378666877747,
-0.6027687191963196,
-0.5313386917114258,
0.07444533705711365,
0.11163429170846939,
-0.45104050636291504,
0.34732264280319214,
-0.6951801776885986,
-0.2700903117656708,
-0.07086236029863358,
-0.004795453045517206,
0.2627469599246979,
0.34191402792930603,
0.2924988269805908,
-0.19609135389328003,
-0.36293473839759827,
-0.9689093828201294,
-0.36879196763038635,
0.1214684545993805,
-0.18224285542964935,
0.5059576034545898,
0.48890221118927,
-0.2435714453458786,
1.2130805253982544,
0.017126774415373802,
-0.06524225324392319,
-0.16905683279037476,
-0.228887140750885,
0.5449045896530151,
0.353590726852417,
0.6683348417282104,
-0.6149947047233582,
-0.588254451751709,
0.023345498368144035,
-0.694028913974762,
0.02915971539914608,
-0.09538426250219345,
-0.21907831728458405,
0.36927491426467896,
0.8802645206451416,
-0.7507883310317993,
0.1480390429496765,
0.2632712125778198,
-0.15824732184410095,
0.42271023988723755,
-0.09246411174535751,
-0.12424949556589127,
-0.9332908391952515,
0.22714342176914215,
-0.039805538952350616,
-0.5356398820877075,
-0.3407718241214752,
0.5310603976249695,
0.46812307834625244,
-0.153741717338562,
-0.4478537440299988,
1.064356803894043,
-0.41707974672317505,
-0.1828305721282959,
-0.49050307273864746,
0.05272574722766876,
-0.28001973032951355,
0.3662278652191162,
-0.018595542758703232,
0.5738680958747864,
0.34045854210853577,
-0.40081796050071716,
0.2828415334224701,
-0.21446500718593597,
-0.5385076403617859,
0.5830404758453369,
-0.414324015378952,
0.07816701382398605,
-0.023461930453777313,
0.8813581466674805,
-1.0496333837509155,
-0.3245927393436432,
-0.18728014826774597,
-0.06500835716724396,
0.3716732859611511,
-0.1808064579963684,
-0.8460951447486877,
-0.5121002197265625,
-0.501583456993103,
0.5653765201568604,
0.3515532314777374,
-0.9126836657524109,
0.398784339427948,
0.34345361590385437,
0.012107598595321178,
-0.6170412302017212,
-0.735410749912262,
0.376013845205307,
-0.4211016595363617,
-0.7166414260864258,
0.3409561514854431,
-0.16433829069137573,
-0.41298142075538635,
-0.20040343701839447,
-0.19738927483558655,
-0.036183759570121765,
0.02914179116487503,
0.41319897770881653,
0.07605358213186264,
-0.07707422226667404,
0.2820388078689575,
-0.06771866232156754,
-0.1034950464963913,
0.31365159153938293,
-0.2611795663833618,
0.5060932636260986,
-0.330820769071579,
-0.37327811121940613,
0.11429852992296219,
0.35209178924560547,
0.8535205721855164,
0.005656146910041571,
0.5323373675346375,
0.3609396815299988,
-0.5741386413574219,
-0.5124644041061401,
-0.6890813112258911,
0.09671008586883545,
-0.4339450001716614,
0.42226797342300415,
-0.5897818803787231,
-0.996298611164093,
0.5283717513084412,
-0.4001026451587677,
0.13198202848434448,
0.45986276865005493,
0.4035632908344269,
0.131227046251297,
0.7518647909164429,
0.4933319091796875,
-0.2628415822982788,
0.4785726070404053,
-0.016026049852371216,
0.004996918607503176,
-0.8428617119789124,
0.16452234983444214,
-0.21764373779296875,
-0.2667791247367859,
-0.49049675464630127,
-0.628510057926178,
0.37016794085502625,
0.007721506059169769,
-0.3634032905101776,
0.3547727167606354,
-0.2651064991950989,
0.6686976552009583,
0.20626471936702728,
-0.05513546243309975,
0.035441841930150986,
-0.35954880714416504,
-0.0006091664545238018,
0.13461068272590637,
-0.3105621337890625,
-0.5037655234336853,
1.2412890195846558,
0.5659871697425842,
0.44995278120040894,
-0.01594589091837406,
0.591071605682373,
0.04172446206212044,
0.5063906311988831,
-0.7197513580322266,
0.7850968837738037,
-0.17632615566253662,
-0.5175540447235107,
-0.5666765570640564,
-0.056974682956933975,
-0.8874149322509766,
0.22342164814472198,
0.2446189969778061,
-0.8836066722869873,
-0.02196614444255829,
-0.552605390548706,
-0.19997429847717285,
0.097414530813694,
-0.5153071880340576,
0.7755305767059326,
-0.26128530502319336,
-0.6220245361328125,
-0.4127453863620758,
-0.8008918166160583,
0.3211357295513153,
-0.24938705563545227,
0.2644006311893463,
-0.2250683754682541,
-0.20295707881450653,
0.5604077577590942,
-0.5211421847343445,
0.5643114447593689,
-0.34062692523002625,
0.02163820154964924,
0.18156057596206665,
-0.13877010345458984,
0.5746773481369019,
0.31265345215797424,
-0.3497677147388458,
-0.035956673324108124,
0.24230319261550903,
-0.5595991611480713,
-0.27004462480545044,
1.0423251390457153,
-0.3365060091018677,
-0.5399841070175171,
-0.3247172236442566,
-0.646738588809967,
-0.6841674447059631,
0.27850183844566345,
-0.07169950753450394,
0.30606359243392944,
-0.269035279750824,
0.473486989736557,
0.3642762005329132,
-0.026202594861388206,
0.8301746845245361,
0.5295226573944092,
-0.12580791115760803,
-0.14150318503379822,
0.6257426142692566,
0.11023823916912079,
0.05979070067405701,
0.30460625886917114,
0.09354616701602936,
-0.5169320106506348,
-0.6990414261817932,
-0.6010425090789795,
0.2499392330646515,
-0.9132091999053955,
-0.07255866378545761,
-0.3227132558822632,
-0.16502290964126587,
-0.20591524243354797,
-0.19072693586349487,
-0.22575680911540985,
-0.15151971578598022,
0.11169891804456711,
0.11540520936250687,
0.09261501580476761,
0.4126119911670685,
0.3077074885368347,
-0.2635684013366699,
-0.7723185420036316,
0.06638850271701813,
0.1894715130329132,
0.780417799949646,
0.2692893147468567,
-0.4676988124847412,
-0.5646684765815735,
-0.19777603447437286,
0.05032580345869064,
-0.38787534832954407,
0.1306471824645996,
0.01898130029439926,
0.7125900983810425,
0.2877817749977112,
0.04037528857588768,
0.8047962188720703,
-0.4545445144176483,
0.8649406433105469,
-0.17329539358615875,
-0.9955592751502991,
0.13950888812541962,
-0.4757927358150482,
0.46601325273513794,
0.8360835313796997,
0.21175967156887054,
-0.4963705837726593,
-0.2578182518482208,
-0.3018787205219269,
-1.0562922954559326,
0.5473964214324951,
-0.2911653518676758,
0.2932150065898895,
-0.17142543196678162,
0.49601465463638306,
0.45114174485206604,
-0.015288782306015491,
-0.5961174964904785,
0.24445410072803497,
0.12268401682376862,
0.18236227333545685,
-0.12266142666339874,
-0.269420325756073,
-0.27030202746391296,
-0.361404687166214,
0.3079931437969208,
-0.4092959463596344,
-0.008142676204442978,
0.12996497750282288,
-0.2495274841785431,
-0.1525340974330902,
0.3936968147754669,
0.5282524228096008,
1.1457537412643433,
-0.4913803040981293,
-0.06942199915647507,
0.5209108591079712,
0.04803527891635895,
-0.20061823725700378,
0.4115704596042633,
0.29400739073753357,
-0.17689166963100433,
0.4416247010231018,
0.6225939989089966,
0.39577582478523254,
-1.198096752166748,
0.5822884440422058,
-0.10452931374311447,
-0.10119815915822983,
-0.5650662779808044,
-0.27506670355796814,
0.24413923919200897,
0.482379674911499,
0.5858398079872131,
-0.4348907768726349,
-0.01391365472227335,
-0.7827371954917908,
0.2792932093143463,
0.6262621879577637,
-0.32520219683647156,
-0.024622654542326927,
0.553730845451355,
0.054733771830797195,
0.06229301914572716,
0.44949471950531006,
-0.14354637265205383,
-0.17141491174697876,
0.43663525581359863,
0.6965377330780029,
0.8219899535179138,
0.4472823739051819,
-0.3828485608100891,
0.3414536714553833,
-0.12954355776309967,
-0.2233293503522873,
0.14646434783935547,
-0.39692386984825134,
-0.27995815873146057,
-0.6133449077606201,
-0.8591086268424988,
-0.5417139530181885,
0.34326934814453125,
-0.3965711295604706,
0.14980866014957428,
-0.4245305061340332,
-0.15852731466293335,
-0.1203741505742073,
0.16383013129234314,
-0.5011014342308044,
0.2319285124540329,
0.26588475704193115,
1.2073386907577515,
-0.2932227849960327,
1.1756091117858887,
0.6013720631599426,
-0.07149986922740936,
-0.3847615718841553,
0.14709731936454773,
-0.2668420672416687,
-0.7752387523651123,
0.7532145977020264,
0.4226972460746765,
0.09633637219667435,
-0.467646986246109,
-0.45448967814445496,
-0.8337321877479553,
1.2190748453140259,
0.4770705997943878,
-0.5854494571685791,
0.18999609351158142,
0.4525550305843353,
0.7291433215141296,
-0.3719964027404785,
0.196079820394516,
0.8407697677612305,
0.7910857796669006,
-0.11190278083086014,
-0.987909197807312,
0.4035574197769165,
-0.32451215386390686,
-0.043562714010477066,
0.21955233812332153,
-0.7993448376655579,
0.9121747612953186,
0.26802703738212585,
-0.35311830043792725,
0.43792545795440674,
0.5937947034835815,
0.46523988246917725,
0.4695579707622528,
0.6478638052940369,
0.48559436202049255,
0.4919951558113098,
-0.07687366008758545,
1.2685060501098633,
-0.47927603125572205,
0.035985857248306274,
0.987358033657074,
-0.4761306643486023,
0.9952137470245361,
0.5568912625312805,
-0.37578994035720825,
0.32508817315101624,
0.7867872714996338,
0.242581307888031,
0.15071949362754822,
0.5401274561882019,
-0.3777152895927429,
-0.13955526053905487,
-0.2089116871356964,
-0.38747990131378174,
0.292786180973053,
0.35885241627693176,
-0.14694517850875854,
-0.2945527136325836,
-0.07643356919288635,
-0.02505527250468731,
0.17736481130123138,
-0.1988796889781952,
0.4114774465560913,
0.2919881045818329,
-0.8926658034324646,
0.754960834980011,
0.07140091806650162,
0.7702939510345459,
-0.7103989124298096,
0.16812236607074738,
-0.2776874899864197,
0.28392571210861206,
-0.02669554017484188,
-0.9126119613647461,
0.028958788141608238,
0.004995216615498066,
-0.006711806636303663,
-0.487478107213974,
0.7328010201454163,
-0.24996696412563324,
-0.02009683847427368,
0.7084288597106934,
0.455691397190094,
0.16247330605983734,
-0.3620028495788574,
-0.42059195041656494,
-0.004664252046495676,
-0.45196154713630676,
-0.3974568545818329,
0.8105270862579346,
0.6174882054328918,
-0.41174906492233276,
0.49068358540534973,
0.5816324949264526,
-0.09838079661130905,
-0.21929781138896942,
0.26535460352897644,
0.8679262399673462,
-0.8710922598838806,
-0.4470701813697815,
-0.822640597820282,
0.25956374406814575,
-0.15068607032299042,
-0.4165301024913788,
0.7169662714004517,
0.7009342908859253,
0.8900922536849976,
0.14303749799728394,
0.6202746629714966,
0.046901293098926544,
0.41362807154655457,
-0.34826427698135376,
0.6936482191085815,
-0.7621705532073975,
0.0681806206703186,
-0.08444288372993469,
-0.9783329367637634,
-0.1287136822938919,
0.038067858666181564,
-0.26062464714050293,
-0.08114951103925705,
0.8356015086174011,
0.4580579698085785,
-0.058387674391269684,
0.050434011965990067,
0.34875616431236267,
-0.0072747645899653435,
0.4222458004951477,
0.8038594722747803,
0.8768383264541626,
-0.07515007257461548,
0.333770215511322,
-0.14060990512371063,
-0.3316086530685425,
-0.18883028626441956,
-0.989975094795227,
-0.7809123992919922,
-0.5484877824783325,
0.4638786017894745,
-0.3102732300758362,
-0.05546315759420395,
0.9291075468063354,
0.7617830038070679,
-0.6232001185417175,
-0.6249392628669739,
-0.0891340896487236,
-0.11488526314496994,
-0.3513997495174408,
-0.21763761341571808,
0.4120238423347473,
-0.5036189556121826,
-0.8686029314994812,
0.9310542941093445,
0.30628207325935364,
-0.27477455139160156,
-0.1627100110054016,
-0.26378291845321655,
-0.06722255796194077,
0.19542616605758667,
0.8007680177688599,
0.46653833985328674,
-0.7621636986732483,
-0.43471601605415344,
-0.07743576914072037,
-0.20334169268608093,
0.0390329547226429,
0.7852627635002136,
-0.9051246643066406,
0.5507492423057556,
0.5012750029563904,
0.814702033996582,
0.8046931028366089,
-0.21851946413516998,
0.6107334494590759,
-0.6253430843353271,
0.20628155767917633,
0.32789331674575806,
0.5570624470710754,
0.26643213629722595,
-0.056748971343040466,
0.8522406816482544,
0.01058887504041195,
-0.5596895813941956,
-1.1141819953918457,
-0.11917149275541306,
-1.1602556705474854,
-0.6567525863647461,
1.1437532901763916,
-0.1251414716243744,
-0.3033524453639984,
0.05753227695822716,
0.009848886169493198,
0.17792484164237976,
-0.3556476831436157,
0.5377539396286011,
1.0130517482757568,
-0.30541032552719116,
0.24791479110717773,
-0.6076029539108276,
0.40400856733322144,
0.5939005613327026,
-0.7894648313522339,
0.41747522354125977,
0.1910741776227951,
0.0884670540690422,
-0.11980312317609787,
0.7032657265663147,
-0.20466260612010956,
0.3984892964363098,
-0.11077124625444412,
-0.4587972164154053,
-0.11564188450574875,
-0.07569583505392075,
-0.23346497118473053,
0.2472754716873169,
0.19396823644638062,
0.13641339540481567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13717v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13717v2
|
Neeko: Leveraging Dynamic LoRA for Efficient Multi-Character Role-Playing Agent
| 2024-02-21T11:30:20 | 2024-03-01T08:20:48 |
Xiaoyan Yu, Tongxu Luo, Yifan Wei, Fangyu Lei, Yiming Huang, Hao Peng, Liehuang Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized open-domain dialogue agents
but encounter challenges in multi-character role-playing (MCRP) scenarios. To
address the issue, we present Neeko, an innovative framework designed for
efficient multiple characters imitation. Unlike existing methods, Neeko employs
a dynamic low-rank adapter (LoRA) strategy, enabling it to adapt seamlessly to
diverse characters. Our framework breaks down the role-playing process into
agent pre-training, multiple characters playing, and character incremental
learning, effectively handling both seen and unseen roles. This dynamic
approach, coupled with distinct LoRA blocks for each character, enhances
Neeko's adaptability to unique attributes, personalities, and speaking
patterns. As a result, Neeko demonstrates superior performance in MCRP over
most existing methods, offering more engaging and versatile user interaction
experiences. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/weiyifan1023/Neeko.
|
[
-0.12566445767879486,
-0.6869485974311829,
0.47195056080818176,
0.3881382346153259,
-0.02261977456510067,
0.5221483707427979,
0.2448362112045288,
-0.4756072461605072,
0.5864832997322083,
0.7761804461479187,
-0.6026783585548401,
-0.3972237706184387,
-0.37176766991615295,
0.20768222212791443,
0.06323809176683426,
0.6443021297454834,
0.4042836129665375,
-0.19091160595417023,
-0.08561171591281891,
-0.2472841590642929,
-0.6117875576019287,
-0.48320937156677246,
-0.849543571472168,
-0.5025185346603394,
0.8637744188308716,
0.9195272326469421,
0.6754648685455322,
0.1488378345966339,
0.016508467495441437,
0.512048065662384,
0.19302119314670563,
0.42101046442985535,
-0.6095706224441528,
0.6858879327774048,
0.04377379268407822,
-0.6307530999183655,
-1.0317773818969727,
-0.1779308021068573,
1.168117880821228,
0.22199155390262604,
-0.10098160803318024,
-0.2324613332748413,
-0.026392117142677307,
0.49203523993492126,
-0.44983091950416565,
0.12366943806409836,
-0.762287974357605,
0.23369187116622925,
0.04978301003575325,
-0.23596663773059845,
-0.3871951401233673,
-0.24986615777015686,
-0.19974061846733093,
-1.1272516250610352,
-0.41923728585243225,
-0.14253495633602142,
0.5842874646186829,
0.23287826776504517,
-0.38562673330307007,
0.10309692472219467,
-0.6277983784675598,
0.8777968883514404,
-0.856522798538208,
0.028152931481599808,
0.2044922262430191,
0.7925106287002563,
-0.27832284569740295,
-0.49583983421325684,
-0.6337118148803711,
-0.405056357383728,
0.35157155990600586,
0.24327930808067322,
0.21147990226745605,
0.056480128318071365,
0.4938535988330841,
0.004292413592338562,
-0.09008271992206573,
0.29114648699760437,
0.17689423263072968,
0.009939930401742458,
0.4600607752799988,
0.3208618760108948,
0.6153009533882141,
0.050397902727127075,
-0.22893169522285461,
-0.022885238751769066,
-0.5343876481056213,
-0.017970820888876915,
0.8363689184188843,
0.485387921333313,
-0.17757830023765564,
0.6672484874725342,
-0.2329564392566681,
0.5139541625976562,
0.005077742505818605,
-0.33843427896499634,
0.09613087773323059,
-0.05967763438820839,
0.2018413543701172,
0.1267606019973755,
0.5733821988105774,
0.20352232456207275,
0.1575467586517334,
-0.0008631878881715238,
0.0032483432441949844,
-0.05743531510233879,
0.44829055666923523,
-0.8533878326416016,
0.013407102786004543,
-0.12230201065540314,
-0.1962548941373825,
-0.7114656567573547,
-0.17555028200149536,
-1.1663283109664917,
-0.7665432095527649,
-0.1124030202627182,
0.4944544732570648,
-0.323862224817276,
-0.3756157457828522,
-0.32789596915245056,
-0.25808185338974,
0.3646007478237152,
0.6584793925285339,
-0.6503517031669617,
0.37872958183288574,
0.44717782735824585,
0.8179056644439697,
-0.1527775079011917,
-0.5754768252372742,
-1.1912332773208618,
0.14918354153633118,
-0.5179670453071594,
0.8931443691253662,
-0.9278409481048584,
-0.3731675148010254,
-0.29956474900245667,
0.028211481869220734,
-0.01917204260826111,
-0.3967853784561157,
0.15260885655879974,
-0.37512704730033875,
-0.21053960919380188,
-0.1748400628566742,
0.007597748655825853,
0.12012999504804611,
0.42219269275665283,
-0.8344878554344177,
0.8900815844535828,
0.3448014259338379,
-0.2444676011800766,
0.195955291390419,
-1.1709356307983398,
-0.18016014993190765,
0.4468274712562561,
-0.059863004833459854,
-0.20521657168865204,
0.20632153749465942,
0.023499559611082077,
0.2836403250694275,
0.08640270680189133,
-0.30987080931663513,
-0.5525878071784973,
-0.5614278316497803,
0.6360734701156616,
-0.48505014181137085,
0.0286139827221632,
0.08297598361968994,
-0.0010833849664777517,
0.2431054413318634,
-0.9472363591194153,
0.2735588252544403,
0.2066517025232315,
-0.42662349343299866,
-0.45719629526138306,
0.20247703790664673,
-0.038682710379362106,
0.2613808214664459,
-0.001372438739053905,
-0.39521026611328125,
0.5917677283287048,
-0.4061344265937805,
0.2970271110534668,
0.7875482439994812,
-0.00792638584971428,
0.34534353017807007,
-0.40935394167900085,
0.9579746127128601,
-0.21985198557376862,
0.203567773103714,
-0.20197011530399323,
-0.5195419788360596,
-0.7039927244186401,
-0.5575116872787476,
0.1613713949918747,
0.4239208996295929,
-1.2514286041259766,
0.025674933567643166,
-0.11779788881540298,
-0.2967127859592438,
-0.45288392901420593,
0.02949230559170246,
0.25085899233818054,
0.26231032609939575,
0.17296436429023743,
-0.19571135938167572,
-0.310838520526886,
-0.6502214074134827,
-0.4672997295856476,
-0.15515805780887604,
0.20847567915916443,
0.2923448979854584,
0.13486380875110626,
-0.5064965486526489,
0.9113349318504333,
-0.19104313850402832,
-0.21189747750759125,
-0.6761465072631836,
0.03474986553192139,
0.26967769861221313,
0.31815510988235474,
0.5202411413192749,
-0.8362024426460266,
-1.0416923761367798,
0.204871267080307,
-0.6837022304534912,
-0.26792269945144653,
-0.1007230207324028,
-0.17770256102085114,
0.3112129867076874,
0.42899197340011597,
-0.21207451820373535,
0.3373250365257263,
0.788007378578186,
-0.38378602266311646,
0.7299478054046631,
-0.35285484790802,
0.5350991487503052,
-1.2799402475357056,
0.2755061089992523,
-0.6940489411354065,
-0.49502816796302795,
-0.8275929093360901,
0.1996474266052246,
-0.45701760053634644,
-0.5394564867019653,
-0.458620548248291,
0.8701409697532654,
-0.49398964643478394,
-0.17918957769870758,
-0.4963259994983673,
0.38421690464019775,
-0.016057981178164482,
0.4600169062614441,
-0.3660702109336853,
0.9860960841178894,
0.2826303243637085,
-0.8359082937240601,
0.3079504370689392,
0.19820235669612885,
-0.41389158368110657,
0.8837280869483948,
-0.6917824149131775,
0.4340761601924896,
0.01133288349956274,
0.18246649205684662,
-0.8347554206848145,
-0.23096910119056702,
0.4062024652957916,
-0.34673452377319336,
0.2603791058063507,
-0.7369832992553711,
-0.7335717678070068,
0.0955478623509407,
-0.23833250999450684,
0.37859129905700684,
0.42622479796409607,
-0.4296689033508301,
1.1130497455596924,
0.568449079990387,
-0.44468486309051514,
-0.8525299429893494,
-0.4740922451019287,
0.3291963040828705,
-0.41339629888534546,
-0.25242459774017334,
0.2418047934770584,
-0.5426827669143677,
-0.11118116974830627,
-0.27550894021987915,
-0.05722374841570854,
-0.2878265380859375,
0.3032117784023285,
0.28434497117996216,
0.09573964774608612,
-0.13632561266422272,
-0.06995384395122528,
0.23134620487689972,
-0.3857361674308777,
-0.5976475477218628,
0.03253210708498955,
0.696165919303894,
-0.08517259359359741,
-0.4249090850353241,
-0.31906411051750183,
0.5911161303520203,
1.0178089141845703,
-0.04026879370212555,
0.8152176737785339,
0.35650449991226196,
-0.08196365088224411,
-0.3730352520942688,
-0.3825829327106476,
0.24124033749103546,
-0.543898344039917,
0.5512816905975342,
-0.6978277564048767,
-0.7675905823707581,
0.6676008701324463,
-0.31707850098609924,
0.33793023228645325,
0.13602542877197266,
0.21673952043056488,
-0.1066228374838829,
1.0528724193572998,
0.6005759239196777,
0.038908638060092926,
0.7284455895423889,
0.027231352403759956,
0.16857877373695374,
-0.9474432468414307,
-0.1018294170498848,
-0.2735944390296936,
-0.48216673731803894,
-0.44700750708580017,
-0.7697951197624207,
0.4067712128162384,
0.043804675340652466,
0.08896642923355103,
0.1817101687192917,
-0.04345155879855156,
0.7989235520362854,
0.10729797929525375,
-0.18893910944461823,
0.37717771530151367,
0.08762670308351517,
-0.18487416207790375,
-0.023044519126415253,
-0.7953958511352539,
-0.5723658800125122,
0.8884109258651733,
0.3774400055408478,
0.8779751658439636,
0.6223454475402832,
0.6809930205345154,
0.4813005328178406,
0.21060554683208466,
-0.8612599968910217,
0.9498644471168518,
-0.2364485114812851,
-0.3076125979423523,
-0.6277515292167664,
-0.5786862969398499,
-0.9545934796333313,
0.5359697341918945,
-0.45942652225494385,
-0.7277486324310303,
0.012538413517177105,
0.3755040168762207,
-0.3496220111846924,
0.32699668407440186,
-0.5221839547157288,
0.6086285710334778,
-0.11301670968532562,
-0.3824484646320343,
-0.45466500520706177,
-0.26927417516708374,
0.12708225846290588,
-0.2310086041688919,
0.005930510349571705,
-0.29388684034347534,
-0.23532487452030182,
0.4066268503665924,
-0.1895982176065445,
0.934944212436676,
-0.340097576379776,
-0.1486206203699112,
0.2742024064064026,
0.19626402854919434,
0.6107691526412964,
0.2594558298587799,
-0.38579878211021423,
0.14302918314933777,
0.18007977306842804,
-0.28569453954696655,
-0.7863801717758179,
0.9254165887832642,
-0.694412887096405,
-0.16159310936927795,
-0.5934808254241943,
-0.7391059398651123,
-0.35233721137046814,
0.35867151618003845,
-0.1405528336763382,
0.4797617793083191,
-0.7942019104957581,
0.19724327325820923,
0.5353692770004272,
-0.6180167198181152,
0.31920602917671204,
0.7529346346855164,
-0.4393182396888733,
-0.5055221915245056,
1.0820064544677734,
0.12596312165260315,
0.4606544077396393,
0.5931742787361145,
0.2957686185836792,
-0.0566338412463665,
-0.08028559386730194,
-0.2388869822025299,
0.23582245409488678,
-0.6128179430961609,
0.04762566089630127,
-0.81388258934021,
-0.18270017206668854,
-0.22533991932868958,
-0.0345243364572525,
-0.6425455808639526,
-0.4069860577583313,
-0.16875529289245605,
0.30437949299812317,
0.105760857462883,
0.752027153968811,
0.08742287755012512,
0.6499987244606018,
-0.6521721482276917,
0.7429250478744507,
0.6004876494407654,
0.6005738377571106,
-0.02346346527338028,
-0.41236448287963867,
-0.10884381830692291,
0.01046111062169075,
-0.178181990981102,
-0.7736018300056458,
0.4121791124343872,
0.4145699739456177,
0.9042091965675354,
0.4072951674461365,
0.11728017777204514,
0.7053641676902771,
-0.7984618544578552,
0.5295668244361877,
0.2268935739994049,
-0.8069318532943726,
0.2505604028701782,
-0.43962860107421875,
0.5801800489425659,
0.716160774230957,
0.013047797605395317,
-0.8360714912414551,
-0.15674087405204773,
-0.3253691792488098,
-0.6759005188941956,
0.968307375907898,
0.16486860811710358,
0.271710067987442,
0.4132690727710724,
0.19846029579639435,
0.2639060318470001,
0.2376660853624344,
-0.6971648335456848,
0.09201596677303314,
-0.26600196957588196,
-0.08908067643642426,
-0.39038702845573425,
-0.43169042468070984,
-0.0701863244175911,
0.06149715557694435,
0.6340273022651672,
-0.666010320186615,
0.7589573860168457,
-0.2206028252840042,
-0.3437112867832184,
0.03241865709424019,
0.43435630202293396,
0.8690279126167297,
0.5501507520675659,
-0.010093343444168568,
-0.06815477460622787,
0.25442633032798767,
-0.47992953658103943,
0.05073880776762962,
-0.12211930006742477,
0.0927005484700203,
-0.07618212699890137,
0.31387826800346375,
0.730056881904602,
0.6963958740234375,
-0.623484194278717,
0.03796466812491417,
-0.18289178609848022,
-0.16810666024684906,
-0.32821008563041687,
0.46611282229423523,
-0.02692311443388462,
0.4202928841114044,
0.13049422204494476,
-0.1875789761543274,
-0.21856114268302917,
-0.8343228697776794,
0.05500779300928116,
0.2646041512489319,
-0.3618532717227936,
-0.29523342847824097,
0.1948419064283371,
0.27586400508880615,
-0.6903528571128845,
0.5401113033294678,
0.13371463119983673,
-0.5760257244110107,
0.6552908420562744,
0.5921444892883301,
0.8134965896606445,
-0.5838114023208618,
0.4407055377960205,
0.03489886224269867,
0.13004010915756226,
0.052391547709703445,
0.2895829677581787,
-0.028087666258215904,
-0.6397437453269958,
-0.3412925601005554,
-0.51532381772995,
-0.6595861911773682,
0.09141845256090164,
-0.2012389749288559,
0.37410953640937805,
-0.7142864465713501,
-0.2693727910518646,
-0.22451671957969666,
0.013245869427919388,
-0.35194137692451477,
-0.47156184911727905,
-0.06592478603124619,
0.5931078195571899,
-0.5508742332458496,
0.8874474167823792,
0.549472451210022,
-0.14258068799972534,
-0.3969114422798157,
0.22216717898845673,
0.04102773219347,
-0.7493743300437927,
0.48958107829093933,
0.24987384676933289,
-0.4291074573993683,
0.17595604062080383,
-0.4361746609210968,
-0.8172547221183777,
0.9492384195327759,
0.33003684878349304,
-0.360003262758255,
-0.18370118737220764,
0.0796751156449318,
0.3785664141178131,
-0.6981430649757385,
0.4310466945171356,
-0.1385321468114853,
0.5224252939224243,
0.13088726997375488,
-0.6074671149253845,
-0.3247515559196472,
-0.3841678500175476,
-0.029940227046608925,
0.12505123019218445,
-0.8499311208724976,
0.5052257180213928,
-0.1495654135942459,
-0.05214271321892738,
0.4232972264289856,
0.4396284520626068,
0.5704393982887268,
0.19144165515899658,
0.8366639614105225,
0.08920568227767944,
0.6165095567703247,
0.2569769322872162,
0.7334352135658264,
-0.09691767394542694,
-0.19382449984550476,
1.2690424919128418,
-0.6698177456855774,
0.6945241093635559,
0.31025514006614685,
0.11565639823675156,
0.8995365500450134,
0.07035181671380997,
0.1627858579158783,
0.4413559138774872,
0.08491156250238419,
-0.2380421906709671,
-0.4089064300060272,
0.03657502681016922,
-0.13978683948516846,
0.5267896056175232,
0.35628488659858704,
0.16588203608989716,
-0.0337214395403862,
0.027225185185670853,
-0.2657526731491089,
0.10067080706357956,
-0.11513154953718185,
0.7765201330184937,
0.18457701802253723,
-0.5108504295349121,
0.2109667807817459,
0.03203917667269707,
0.6167203783988953,
-1.3932256698608398,
-0.7225736975669861,
-0.24104075133800507,
0.24990993738174438,
0.07241051644086838,
-0.2923114597797394,
0.013546736910939217,
0.02846466936171055,
-0.10553581267595291,
-0.2771821916103363,
0.7877994775772095,
-0.32256677746772766,
-0.3138405382633209,
0.28412923216819763,
0.12073947489261627,
0.29652148485183716,
-0.05015350505709648,
-0.6958272457122803,
0.20555055141448975,
-0.3329766094684601,
0.09306590259075165,
0.618319571018219,
0.3707771301269531,
-0.05771353840827942,
0.9147618412971497,
0.7320343852043152,
-0.01536440197378397,
0.021727457642555237,
0.2648555636405945,
0.6254280209541321,
-0.5646247267723083,
-0.9507603049278259,
-0.44967037439346313,
0.7011211514472961,
-0.4686717092990875,
-0.1482817828655243,
0.7986667156219482,
0.35498160123825073,
0.15860041975975037,
-0.020065465942025185,
0.5973867774009705,
0.15689624845981598,
0.4803536832332611,
-0.4473676085472107,
1.0327998399734497,
-0.859533965587616,
0.27532994747161865,
-0.7026887536048889,
-1.1631801128387451,
0.21517904102802277,
0.7786455154418945,
0.2462548315525055,
0.29854631423950195,
0.5223623514175415,
0.5978730916976929,
-0.25795257091522217,
-0.40262943506240845,
0.9451268911361694,
0.31879356503486633,
0.5051400661468506,
0.5124365091323853,
1.1927778720855713,
-0.30533427000045776,
0.27962571382522583,
0.42314866185188293,
-0.37630316615104675,
-0.49790194630622864,
-1.1513084173202515,
-0.9883363246917725,
-0.35379818081855774,
-0.3024863600730896,
-0.27076148986816406,
0.10375282168388367,
0.8452075123786926,
0.8681093454360962,
-0.34777575731277466,
-0.3831309378147125,
0.3247247040271759,
0.31024351716041565,
-0.5580253005027771,
-0.21138465404510498,
-0.3496922552585602,
-0.25151440501213074,
-0.9321574568748474,
1.0403767824172974,
0.3426036238670349,
-0.1441425085067749,
-0.21427136659622192,
-0.42776525020599365,
-0.3037639856338501,
0.5273184180259705,
0.9075230360031128,
0.5800796151161194,
-0.4813326299190521,
-0.01030793134123087,
-0.08375213295221329,
0.08040539920330048,
-0.03264526650309563,
0.8296022415161133,
-0.6398480534553528,
0.6094991564750671,
0.3799237906932831,
0.5751830339431763,
0.37086471915245056,
-0.13174597918987274,
0.7265607714653015,
-0.6296254992485046,
0.13195602595806122,
0.28462132811546326,
-0.1845809668302536,
0.04549397900700569,
-0.4059445559978485,
0.2642468810081482,
0.20770086348056793,
-0.37195512652397156,
-1.0187195539474487,
0.46546652913093567,
-1.1865348815917969,
-0.3059178292751312,
1.1297541856765747,
-0.018469812348484993,
0.006414866074919701,
-0.18204407393932343,
-0.08358354866504669,
0.04090974107384682,
-0.5576469898223877,
0.3144477307796478,
0.5748839378356934,
0.002299054991453886,
-0.39426079392433167,
-0.8775870203971863,
0.17974083125591278,
0.26108428835868835,
-1.014371633529663,
-0.09553670138120651,
0.35200563073158264,
0.36741745471954346,
0.06897202134132385,
0.8894442915916443,
-0.10103403031826019,
0.02622654289007187,
0.013474483974277973,
0.035950206220149994,
-0.3424426019191742,
-0.740303099155426,
-0.3296549618244171,
0.13196136057376862,
0.13531987369060516,
-0.010163641534745693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13709v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13709v2
|
SaGE: Evaluating Moral Consistency in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T11:23:21 | 2024-03-08T14:35:30 |
Vamshi Krishna Bonagiri, Sreeram Vennam, Priyanshul Govil, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru, Manas Gaur
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite recent advancements showcasing the impressive capabilities of Large
Language Models (LLMs) in conversational systems, we show that even
state-of-the-art LLMs are morally inconsistent in their generations,
questioning their reliability (and trustworthiness in general). Prior works in
LLM evaluation focus on developing ground-truth data to measure accuracy on
specific tasks. However, for moral scenarios that often lack universally
agreed-upon answers, consistency in model responses becomes crucial for their
reliability. To address this issue, we propose an information-theoretic measure
called Semantic Graph Entropy (SaGE), grounded in the concept of "Rules of
Thumb" (RoTs) to measure a model's moral consistency. RoTs are abstract
principles learned by a model and can help explain their decision-making
strategies effectively. To this extent, we construct the Moral Consistency
Corpus (MCC), containing 50K moral questions, responses to them by LLMs, and
the RoTs that these models followed. Furthermore, to illustrate the
generalizability of SaGE, we use it to investigate LLM consistency on two
popular datasets -- TruthfulQA and HellaSwag. Our results reveal that
task-accuracy and consistency are independent problems, and there is a dire
need to investigate these issues further.
|
[
-0.035393841564655304,
-0.7279843688011169,
0.8671954274177551,
0.1617988497018814,
-0.29735904932022095,
-0.2367967814207077,
-0.20783822238445282,
-0.1488591730594635,
-0.037927668541669846,
0.5586065649986267,
-0.3925859034061432,
-0.6312870383262634,
-0.9742216467857361,
-0.060926444828510284,
-0.29417890310287476,
1.104718804359436,
0.12958784401416779,
0.16135412454605103,
-0.3579597771167755,
-0.5048078298568726,
-0.2967192530632019,
-0.18708956241607666,
-0.7239217758178711,
-0.3704606294631958,
0.4751878082752228,
0.23808950185775757,
1.275787115097046,
0.9994824528694153,
0.7299715280532837,
0.31511273980140686,
-0.05370664596557617,
0.036070045083761215,
-0.8217684626579285,
0.0613742433488369,
-0.4802013039588928,
-0.1438591480255127,
-0.45662808418273926,
0.18963590264320374,
0.5984640717506409,
0.533333957195282,
-0.3066008985042572,
0.2155454307794571,
0.010432351380586624,
0.7367295622825623,
-0.7144595980644226,
0.4254431426525116,
-0.7719981670379639,
-0.10812481492757797,
0.01892673969268799,
-0.05360283702611923,
-0.4146103262901306,
-0.9137484431266785,
0.06082284823060036,
-0.783045768737793,
-0.10835973173379898,
0.044918108731508255,
0.9129207730293274,
0.31862393021583557,
-0.45831048488616943,
-0.5112559199333191,
-0.4351576268672943,
1.0182329416275024,
-0.8588780760765076,
0.34939244389533997,
0.8529987335205078,
-0.20067916810512543,
-0.19085514545440674,
-0.4090486168861389,
-0.6472161412239075,
-0.31044134497642517,
0.13764262199401855,
0.05145558714866638,
-0.325515478849411,
-0.06357382982969284,
0.17334070801734924,
0.12306572496891022,
-0.2509739100933075,
0.02638082019984722,
0.07888385653495789,
-0.30164527893066406,
0.3966156244277954,
0.35165971517562866,
0.2733466625213623,
-0.3053895831108093,
-0.3405533730983734,
-0.3976204991340637,
-0.6113428473472595,
0.1524142473936081,
0.6990601420402527,
0.0437844954431057,
0.04873169586062431,
0.6236278414726257,
0.11177809536457062,
0.5643267631530762,
0.15157850086688995,
-0.2993181049823761,
-0.014102637767791748,
-0.3931019604206085,
-0.29317447543144226,
0.007092738524079323,
0.9090966582298279,
0.7300750613212585,
0.5947800278663635,
0.08230867236852646,
-0.00283126812428236,
0.06659355014562607,
0.44907301664352417,
-0.7180587649345398,
-0.14649276435375214,
0.12439800798892975,
-0.4180235266685486,
-0.34722700715065,
0.17439892888069153,
-0.3801080286502838,
-0.7052171230316162,
-0.382362961769104,
0.2108403593301773,
-0.7755194902420044,
-0.3797858953475952,
0.5283301472663879,
-0.09442751109600067,
0.43485957384109497,
0.41634297370910645,
-0.6546306610107422,
-0.0227774977684021,
1.1065011024475098,
0.6323739290237427,
0.06601587682962418,
-0.39674732089042664,
-0.8984756469726562,
0.27466288208961487,
-0.6865860223770142,
0.29118144512176514,
-0.769859790802002,
-0.1935160607099533,
-0.0491986982524395,
0.08068966120481491,
0.03409009799361229,
-0.3409522473812103,
0.8789413571357727,
-0.4340004622936249,
-0.24770960211753845,
-0.7397966980934143,
-0.8088157773017883,
-0.16279834508895874,
0.41107746958732605,
-0.42579787969589233,
0.7311036586761475,
-0.06784868985414505,
-0.8508055210113525,
0.44366079568862915,
-0.1539948284626007,
0.03194250538945198,
-0.04643349349498749,
-0.15586552023887634,
-0.4263768196105957,
-0.013889034278690815,
-0.2766698896884918,
0.4524117112159729,
-0.4193885028362274,
0.942169725894928,
-0.7614263892173767,
-0.32684916257858276,
0.4284846782684326,
-0.5737320780754089,
1.118834137916565,
0.08278611302375793,
-0.13077905774116516,
-0.09541687369346619,
-0.48273560404777527,
0.41576412320137024,
0.12145527452230453,
-0.2284252792596817,
-0.6028009653091431,
0.23797094821929932,
-0.3418032228946686,
-0.1285761296749115,
0.4226384162902832,
-0.7565866112709045,
-0.002226220676675439,
0.1718413382768631,
0.30995243787765503,
1.143056035041809,
-0.2798556089401245,
0.12289007753133774,
-0.5285503268241882,
0.05111446604132652,
-0.02053358592092991,
0.16952528059482574,
0.23726893961429596,
-0.3433937728404999,
-0.8586786985397339,
-0.1656189113855362,
0.037573862820863724,
0.4933786392211914,
-0.38482436537742615,
0.7705674171447754,
-0.46818113327026367,
-0.6793335676193237,
-0.3283085227012634,
0.19594840705394745,
0.6486143469810486,
0.44087404012680054,
0.14003784954547882,
-0.4682658612728119,
-0.08561304211616516,
-0.862347424030304,
-0.541549801826477,
-0.8952193260192871,
0.12642128765583038,
0.3622594475746155,
0.4480780363082886,
-0.30419719219207764,
0.9221462607383728,
-0.2485886514186859,
0.16190677881240845,
0.14326563477516174,
0.19731254875659943,
0.05547312647104263,
0.5852219462394714,
0.3972058892250061,
-0.5616016387939453,
-0.23386113345623016,
-0.08898657560348511,
-1.005237102508545,
-0.04106650501489639,
0.2872237265110016,
-0.2505386173725128,
-0.03718416392803192,
0.28776487708091736,
-0.3837423324584961,
0.28521570563316345,
0.588187575340271,
-0.6170769333839417,
0.5438511967658997,
-0.20532764494419098,
0.33051466941833496,
-0.5620009899139404,
0.009542896412312984,
0.18349337577819824,
-0.2843170166015625,
-0.5069615840911865,
-0.16794271767139435,
0.152522012591362,
0.346920907497406,
-0.43555933237075806,
0.4928012788295746,
0.05738142877817154,
-0.07000135630369186,
-0.02445887215435505,
0.09826654195785522,
0.0800999104976654,
0.34883907437324524,
-0.26312658190727234,
0.7381680011749268,
0.5717935562133789,
-0.61504727602005,
0.42541638016700745,
0.4433276653289795,
-0.24003866314888,
1.1188850402832031,
-0.8073712587356567,
0.31162500381469727,
-0.23884142935276031,
0.15558433532714844,
-0.8288355469703674,
-0.2330774962902069,
0.14578233659267426,
-0.29801949858665466,
-0.09391076862812042,
-0.2862505614757538,
-0.5977984666824341,
0.10456786304712296,
-0.39781269431114197,
0.38707196712493896,
0.5744466781616211,
-0.5051094889640808,
0.5486702919006348,
0.43817704916000366,
-0.18080838024616241,
-0.8495165705680847,
-0.3573010265827179,
-0.03818024322390556,
-0.18960070610046387,
-0.8992467522621155,
-0.2000238001346588,
-0.11683912575244904,
-0.7209277153015137,
0.08983338624238968,
-0.3378136157989502,
-0.03182252123951912,
0.05324466526508331,
0.17310822010040283,
0.17324472963809967,
-0.2361181676387787,
0.2675280272960663,
-0.2782779335975647,
0.06839166581630707,
0.10554274916648865,
-0.33473485708236694,
0.40796852111816406,
-0.9674912095069885,
-0.664452314376831,
-0.39072200655937195,
-0.02430672012269497,
0.7469836473464966,
-0.06247364729642868,
0.619823157787323,
0.4182606041431427,
-0.01497824676334858,
0.28080013394355774,
-0.7228626608848572,
0.26611465215682983,
-0.5066638588905334,
0.06711861491203308,
0.09309020638465881,
-0.9218059778213501,
0.6394667029380798,
0.01502643059939146,
0.10408152639865875,
0.5243455767631531,
0.23548905551433563,
-0.2588173449039459,
0.7414236664772034,
0.6876173615455627,
0.16813452541828156,
0.29563769698143005,
0.07579554617404938,
0.11784400045871735,
-0.6116653084754944,
-0.1904740184545517,
-0.4133347272872925,
-0.0038912331219762564,
-0.7451483607292175,
-0.3705340325832367,
0.37758582830429077,
0.20633335411548615,
-1.0004346370697021,
0.14300163090229034,
-0.1611168086528778,
0.7884064316749573,
0.5433117747306824,
-0.009413602761924267,
0.5027111172676086,
-0.24006079137325287,
-0.18296173214912415,
0.12976208329200745,
-0.5501542091369629,
-1.1175172328948975,
0.809453010559082,
0.23781225085258484,
0.9850946068763733,
0.17450854182243347,
0.48639562726020813,
0.41641682386398315,
0.14769591391086578,
-0.7583439946174622,
0.721003532409668,
-0.4155915379524231,
-0.33792057633399963,
-0.5862061977386475,
-0.46692177653312683,
-0.9583094716072083,
0.10018441826105118,
0.038763660937547684,
-0.6808401346206665,
0.24807612597942352,
-0.027060240507125854,
-0.04444603621959686,
0.4743628203868866,
-0.5048152804374695,
0.815410315990448,
-0.36878421902656555,
-0.489042729139328,
-0.06306475400924683,
-0.8212268948554993,
0.3685327172279358,
-0.16979317367076874,
0.0286913700401783,
-0.5489568114280701,
0.1750078648328781,
0.8486206531524658,
-0.6052237153053284,
1.003941297531128,
0.05445556715130806,
-0.2533693313598633,
0.5096186399459839,
0.25315237045288086,
0.6711241602897644,
0.13246704638004303,
-0.19982503354549408,
0.4240036606788635,
0.39599868655204773,
-0.4780362844467163,
-0.5468065738677979,
0.5711111426353455,
-0.8578646779060364,
-0.7321738004684448,
-0.4834893047809601,
-0.696150004863739,
-0.30762535333633423,
0.2978505492210388,
0.01155117992311716,
0.35201799869537354,
-0.4102301299571991,
0.5525469779968262,
0.9995661377906799,
-0.3271588683128357,
0.22158753871917725,
0.6604882478713989,
-0.0920485258102417,
-0.3967575132846832,
0.7398003339767456,
-0.06557800620794296,
0.4561226963996887,
-0.2106110006570816,
0.46879762411117554,
-0.189266636967659,
-0.08706735819578171,
-0.5669732689857483,
0.2824925482273102,
-0.8621332049369812,
-0.3321009576320648,
-0.435518354177475,
-0.1663508266210556,
-0.10951539129018784,
-0.36263829469680786,
-0.5697608590126038,
-0.03236322104930878,
-0.11904701590538025,
-0.04238323122262955,
0.5900489687919617,
0.8782646656036377,
-0.08179395645856857,
0.1160803735256195,
-0.9400824308395386,
0.2557181119918823,
0.2545379102230072,
0.641258955001831,
-0.11399272829294205,
-0.3774476945400238,
0.16085192561149597,
0.41674941778182983,
-0.25686877965927124,
-0.6154447197914124,
-0.14826588332653046,
0.05106615275144577,
0.43825310468673706,
0.6882562041282654,
0.21541659533977509,
0.6157262325286865,
-0.44419997930526733,
0.543755829334259,
0.5035327076911926,
-1.3141684532165527,
0.2597072422504425,
-0.7130622267723083,
-0.011276500299572945,
0.7650301456451416,
0.21792025864124298,
-0.7457210421562195,
-0.8150362372398376,
-0.8337804675102234,
-0.459909588098526,
0.3986853361129761,
0.23369790613651276,
0.23387740552425385,
-0.19383805990219116,
0.23883217573165894,
0.24336197972297668,
0.1455986350774765,
-0.5339087843894958,
0.08093726634979248,
-0.40153297781944275,
-0.362323135137558,
-0.01228838600218296,
-0.2917320132255554,
-0.4611145555973053,
-0.01633753627538681,
0.46737900376319885,
-0.21155869960784912,
-0.040841761976480484,
-0.05762019008398056,
0.12707126140594482,
-0.2501087784767151,
0.4055645763874054,
0.4485151469707489,
0.9934004545211792,
-0.11151938885450363,
0.29032084345817566,
-0.052033279091119766,
-0.6290486454963684,
0.45811185240745544,
-0.34591108560562134,
-0.141365185379982,
-0.22679269313812256,
0.36650896072387695,
0.60541170835495,
0.04350331798195839,
-0.5913717746734619,
0.7899643182754517,
0.03157542273402214,
-0.08084360510110855,
-0.35363200306892395,
0.2673456370830536,
0.15787933766841888,
0.2879854440689087,
0.011127959936857224,
0.019043197855353355,
-0.2893548905849457,
-0.8199836015701294,
0.21994711458683014,
0.7815424799919128,
-0.3879905641078949,
0.04827716946601868,
0.3524837791919708,
-0.22755752503871918,
-0.14597868919372559,
0.9523079991340637,
-0.2492011934518814,
-0.43371450901031494,
0.8064714670181274,
0.26174232363700867,
0.7934473156929016,
0.0025780859868973494,
0.5579200983047485,
0.1391228437423706,
0.4841601848602295,
-0.5743817090988159,
0.27028003334999084,
0.28847184777259827,
-1.0111521482467651,
-0.31805160641670227,
-0.6497145295143127,
-0.6947982311248779,
-0.17606911063194275,
-0.9177524447441101,
0.11808846890926361,
-0.49888402223587036,
-0.28447940945625305,
-0.3293271064758301,
-0.15790961682796478,
-0.5077602863311768,
0.22829699516296387,
-0.3391898274421692,
0.5526860356330872,
-0.7209281325340271,
0.6619528532028198,
0.2779247462749481,
-0.21759039163589478,
-0.8310564756393433,
0.07522011548280716,
-0.0324663482606411,
-1.201323390007019,
0.4804273545742035,
-0.09283766895532608,
-0.6640873551368713,
-0.2591288685798645,
-1.028672456741333,
-0.9719803333282471,
1.0518065690994263,
0.6857337951660156,
-0.3975006937980652,
0.34824037551879883,
-0.015767298638820648,
0.6263980865478516,
-0.21026746928691864,
-0.07938632369041443,
0.5918623805046082,
0.8574086427688599,
0.3814954161643982,
-0.9141682982444763,
-0.02444608509540558,
-0.12287279218435287,
-0.1220388412475586,
0.21958228945732117,
-0.8297454714775085,
0.5480768084526062,
-0.5374459028244019,
-0.18064285814762115,
0.04195430129766464,
0.49970367550849915,
0.5984847545623779,
0.6785219311714172,
0.5758121609687805,
0.6978365182876587,
1.2980539798736572,
-0.28242748975753784,
1.0457115173339844,
-0.24273084104061127,
0.5479493141174316,
1.0407415628433228,
-0.4296676218509674,
0.6392895579338074,
0.2725909352302551,
0.033151961863040924,
0.37553566694259644,
0.42371314764022827,
-0.2733221650123596,
0.2713117003440857,
0.18195313215255737,
0.06531111896038055,
-0.5416445732116699,
-0.3434746563434601,
-0.22594209015369415,
0.6211446523666382,
0.14629332721233368,
-0.2676098346710205,
-0.07508376240730286,
-0.32476308941841125,
0.3937439024448395,
-0.09925330430269241,
-0.4548070728778839,
0.6562100052833557,
0.03142222762107849,
-0.6007890701293945,
0.7090466022491455,
-0.05309239402413368,
0.36456388235092163,
-0.660979688167572,
0.10111218690872192,
-0.10288122296333313,
0.06696516275405884,
-0.11691039055585861,
-1.2680450677871704,
0.2611558139324188,
0.28369271755218506,
-0.1185612827539444,
-0.27218446135520935,
0.5958009958267212,
-0.26763007044792175,
-0.5940791368484497,
0.14778739213943481,
0.6017768383026123,
0.3492070138454437,
0.5181300640106201,
-0.5048754811286926,
0.2801295816898346,
-0.13101811707019806,
0.06928680092096329,
0.2657976746559143,
0.7223985195159912,
0.04336019977927208,
0.887961208820343,
0.535283088684082,
-0.1321740448474884,
0.018507208675146103,
-0.17715014517307281,
0.6307719945907593,
-0.6197211146354675,
-0.14133743941783905,
-1.0131653547286987,
0.24399778246879578,
-0.057460885494947433,
-0.46254345774650574,
0.9765948057174683,
0.376838356256485,
0.7432941794395447,
0.32244861125946045,
0.6470485925674438,
0.10414938628673553,
0.00015873795200604945,
-0.7551465034484863,
0.6274139285087585,
-0.39790910482406616,
0.2280452698469162,
-0.4277839958667755,
-0.8506871461868286,
0.04635291546583176,
0.7918217778205872,
-0.44074586033821106,
0.19756285846233368,
0.8269920349121094,
0.48881474137306213,
-0.11013864725828171,
0.34124425053596497,
0.392147958278656,
0.24482116103172302,
0.19994698464870453,
0.39237722754478455,
0.9680916666984558,
-0.08912314474582672,
0.32373249530792236,
0.1871422529220581,
-0.07913287729024887,
0.08815079182386398,
-1.2647054195404053,
-0.45478469133377075,
-0.42126864194869995,
-0.44016212224960327,
-0.6435608267784119,
0.12802255153656006,
0.6535078287124634,
0.3242538869380951,
-0.530719518661499,
-0.36584073305130005,
-0.18016557395458221,
0.31582215428352356,
-0.2099643051624298,
-0.15672673285007477,
0.3636258542537689,
-0.39959436655044556,
-0.4458734095096588,
-0.08295190334320068,
0.4847545027732849,
-0.2181536704301834,
-0.12759889662265778,
-0.2532179653644562,
0.10148239880800247,
0.49679794907569885,
0.3778020441532135,
0.14544564485549927,
-0.9705069661140442,
-0.6878350973129272,
-0.06236442178487778,
-0.40019580721855164,
0.20422154664993286,
0.8162031769752502,
-0.1678163856267929,
0.4332001209259033,
0.3303311765193939,
0.6453532576560974,
0.0694313645362854,
0.29901713132858276,
0.4034169316291809,
-0.11795935034751892,
-0.471151739358902,
0.28778111934661865,
0.5483606457710266,
0.4948832392692566,
-0.29798623919487,
0.6263588070869446,
0.05991773307323456,
-0.7967453598976135,
-0.5163032412528992,
0.5040745139122009,
-1.14564049243927,
0.005444483365863562,
1.5424247980117798,
-0.47783994674682617,
-0.03123491443693638,
-0.13363617658615112,
0.09949859231710434,
0.046635884791612625,
-0.39939969778060913,
0.6099621057510376,
1.1865862607955933,
-0.05531366914510727,
0.28570157289505005,
-0.4850059151649475,
0.2958185076713562,
0.44865289330482483,
-0.436870813369751,
0.5492412447929382,
0.8175014853477478,
0.5712766051292419,
0.23558859527111053,
0.6518431305885315,
-0.18941792845726013,
0.14469680190086365,
-0.0838315486907959,
-0.2592513859272003,
0.12877118587493896,
-0.14367815852165222,
-0.0861925408244133,
0.03296482563018799,
0.03776722028851509,
0.29881536960601807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13703v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13703v1
|
Investigating Multilingual Instruction-Tuning: Do Polyglot Models Demand for Multilingual Instructions?
| 2024-02-21T11:07:07 | 2024-02-21T11:07:07 |
Alexander Arno Weber, Klaudia Thellmann, Jan Ebert, Nicolas Flores-Herr, Jens Lehmann, Michael Fromm, Mehdi Ali
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The adaption of multilingual pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) into
eloquent and helpful assistants is essential to facilitate their use across
different language regions. In that spirit, we are the first to conduct an
extensive study of the performance of multilingual models on parallel,
multi-turn instruction-tuning benchmarks across a selection of the most-spoken
Indo-European languages. We systematically examine the effects of language and
instruction dataset size on a mid-sized, multilingual LLM by instruction-tuning
it on parallel instruction-tuning datasets. Our results demonstrate that
instruction-tuning on parallel instead of monolingual corpora benefits
cross-lingual instruction following capabilities by up to 4.6%. Furthermore, we
show that the Superficial Alignment Hypothesis does not hold in general, as the
investigated multilingual 7B parameter model presents a counter-example
requiring large-scale instruction-tuning datasets. Finally, we conduct a human
annotation study to understand the alignment between human-based and
GPT-4-based evaluation within multilingual chat scenarios.
|
[
-0.4160395860671997,
-0.7612605690956116,
0.16275396943092346,
0.28777268528938293,
-0.35615259408950806,
0.029139338061213493,
-0.6473371386528015,
-0.5113317370414734,
0.17502395808696747,
0.2862485349178314,
-0.5172609686851501,
-0.5046260356903076,
-0.5633630752563477,
0.22357991337776184,
-0.09799260646104813,
0.934062123298645,
0.08499809354543686,
0.4664728045463562,
-0.35964399576187134,
-0.02287631668150425,
-0.472341924905777,
-0.6355908513069153,
-0.44962015748023987,
-0.16428405046463013,
0.6462678909301758,
0.7045094966888428,
0.6119428873062134,
0.8133662939071655,
0.49765869975090027,
0.2602947950363159,
0.13352671265602112,
0.33275362849235535,
-0.4949705898761749,
-0.33292827010154724,
-0.09151402860879898,
-0.6148189902305603,
-0.6507221460342407,
-0.09787507355213165,
0.6238726377487183,
0.7538601160049438,
-0.32817110419273376,
0.3882608115673065,
0.125127911567688,
0.6399859189987183,
-0.6314132213592529,
0.3494565486907959,
-0.3541131913661957,
-0.1693412959575653,
-0.5306017994880676,
-0.1436879187822342,
-0.6213316917419434,
-0.330932080745697,
0.09696933627128601,
-0.7060104608535767,
0.13534580171108246,
0.13790364563465118,
0.4767906963825226,
0.3383646607398987,
-0.3671300709247589,
-0.37047716975212097,
-0.6738391518592834,
0.8096803426742554,
-0.47251009941101074,
0.536080539226532,
0.3419216573238373,
0.1763233095407486,
0.2023499757051468,
-0.3390243351459503,
-0.21223704516887665,
-0.010309167206287384,
-0.20413251221179962,
0.07225728034973145,
0.31255125999450684,
0.12516836822032928,
0.23183007538318634,
0.35188695788383484,
-0.6195456981658936,
0.3551073372364044,
-0.5333729386329651,
-0.204038605093956,
0.6235788464546204,
0.13111314177513123,
0.4174421429634094,
0.3781691789627075,
-0.16855458915233612,
-0.32965266704559326,
-0.7540310621261597,
-0.004648388829082251,
0.6262788772583008,
0.43865498900413513,
-0.5032819509506226,
0.3868118226528168,
0.07349704205989838,
1.0464253425598145,
-0.08551006019115448,
-0.28287583589553833,
0.15843980014324188,
-0.5387039184570312,
0.13660919666290283,
0.36075901985168457,
0.5281190872192383,
0.3340471684932709,
0.709176242351532,
-0.11690864711999893,
0.1825908124446869,
-0.03653861954808235,
0.032309845089912415,
-0.6659297943115234,
-0.23529329895973206,
-0.3174474835395813,
-0.17090792953968048,
0.30377140641212463,
0.008261801674962044,
-0.855566680431366,
-0.20488177239894867,
-0.577133297920227,
0.177194282412529,
-0.2830999195575714,
-0.3098694384098053,
0.3460342586040497,
0.23074834048748016,
0.5738385319709778,
0.14669236540794373,
-1.265931487083435,
0.2301921397447586,
0.7243546843528748,
0.6523926258087158,
-0.20766808092594147,
-0.758365273475647,
-0.29339954257011414,
0.23183020949363708,
-0.3847659230232239,
0.8045586347579956,
-1.0044469833374023,
-0.42786988615989685,
0.007994377054274082,
0.22474054992198944,
-0.460996150970459,
-0.42480066418647766,
0.32302331924438477,
-0.18379811942577362,
0.3372489809989929,
-0.4412554204463959,
-0.48264870047569275,
-0.1560198813676834,
0.007723224814981222,
-0.487311452627182,
0.7120585441589355,
-0.26116257905960083,
-0.6230630874633789,
0.30161160230636597,
-0.504942774772644,
-0.6128824353218079,
-0.12789741158485413,
-0.17442724108695984,
-0.2917512357234955,
0.1460437923669815,
0.43667638301849365,
0.1980777382850647,
-0.49489980936050415,
-0.22350230813026428,
-0.26889029145240784,
-0.5564188957214355,
-0.25920233130455017,
-0.5782021284103394,
0.720726728439331,
-0.23509028553962708,
-0.20156516134738922,
0.10525728017091751,
-0.5729859471321106,
0.008199977688491344,
-0.035828910768032074,
-0.22262372076511383,
-0.27927449345588684,
-0.05947311967611313,
-0.19535516202449799,
0.08492831140756607,
0.45749518275260925,
-0.5779529809951782,
0.38015395402908325,
-0.13144801557064056,
-0.00807539839297533,
0.8354411125183105,
-0.3357977867126465,
0.3435514271259308,
-0.1499449759721756,
0.7832852602005005,
-0.1094326451420784,
0.4180869460105896,
-0.33499249815940857,
-0.49938029050827026,
-0.713107168674469,
-0.28461429476737976,
0.4678341746330261,
0.741190493106842,
-0.6216809153556824,
-0.1386231631040573,
-0.2944921851158142,
-0.3514059782028198,
-0.8828427195549011,
0.3406347334384918,
0.686044454574585,
0.1881648600101471,
0.17968067526817322,
-0.1989353746175766,
-0.26481539011001587,
-1.087814450263977,
-0.2065819650888443,
0.11081433296203613,
0.28064677119255066,
0.2684343457221985,
0.09478424489498138,
0.09032509475946426,
0.1833377331495285,
-0.4063882827758789,
0.018246391788125038,
-0.08631166815757751,
0.02072412706911564,
0.009932877495884895,
0.25666388869285583,
0.6357301473617554,
-0.6215147972106934,
-0.9753955602645874,
0.20297762751579285,
-0.6670594811439514,
-0.16845309734344482,
0.23201903700828552,
-0.27958130836486816,
0.3200908899307251,
0.5770140290260315,
-0.44334354996681213,
0.08297646045684814,
0.7962229251861572,
-0.08423013240098953,
0.7064756155014038,
-0.5742460489273071,
0.13851936161518097,
-0.8727734088897705,
-0.36107373237609863,
-0.14069746434688568,
0.03261670097708702,
-0.49616843461990356,
-0.027056245133280754,
0.29755663871765137,
-0.13757392764091492,
-0.4003804624080658,
0.4888368248939514,
-0.7346331477165222,
-0.15449629724025726,
-0.21581856906414032,
-0.05833462253212929,
-0.19247843325138092,
0.47564518451690674,
0.14257611334323883,
1.176384449005127,
0.7590059638023376,
-0.3225131332874298,
0.21738502383232117,
-0.00586405023932457,
-0.42598727345466614,
0.44035792350769043,
-0.541829526424408,
0.4227384626865387,
-0.0994233787059784,
-0.07194755971431732,
-0.6331741213798523,
-0.31327182054519653,
-0.01719631999731064,
-0.012978837825357914,
0.5955991148948669,
-0.17794030904769897,
-0.6627795100212097,
-0.10093038529157639,
-0.14143936336040497,
0.43171510100364685,
0.3217649757862091,
-0.6054701805114746,
0.5482086539268494,
0.3753575086593628,
-0.32635706663131714,
-0.6231464743614197,
-0.3480491638183594,
-0.20807486772537231,
-0.29328182339668274,
-0.6987069845199585,
0.21155506372451782,
-0.17739881575107574,
-0.16246549785137177,
-0.40084609389305115,
0.03403037413954735,
0.027860375121235847,
-0.08696385473012924,
-0.022839747369289398,
0.30212217569351196,
-0.3937586545944214,
0.1364520639181137,
0.132748082280159,
-0.08042561262845993,
0.0412212572991848,
-0.17355453968048096,
0.5542480945587158,
-0.35035330057144165,
-0.5307996869087219,
-0.41598498821258545,
0.37944701313972473,
0.6106460094451904,
-0.5174828767776489,
0.8944927453994751,
0.7682450413703918,
0.03868913650512695,
0.0320516899228096,
-0.49756500124931335,
-0.2418903112411499,
-0.438873827457428,
0.39951619505882263,
-0.3180302381515503,
-0.5827843546867371,
0.4409947395324707,
-0.04384290426969528,
0.1251019984483719,
0.13843634724617004,
0.6673170924186707,
0.09117904305458069,
1.1663563251495361,
0.8228316307067871,
-0.06109314411878586,
0.41731470823287964,
0.11406348645687103,
0.14200271666049957,
-0.6154118180274963,
-0.062390659004449844,
-0.37827128171920776,
-0.2710297703742981,
-0.8812003135681152,
-0.32201695442199707,
0.5325475335121155,
0.06664517521858215,
0.10090033710002899,
0.08372713625431061,
-0.28917720913887024,
0.7915663719177246,
0.5432465076446533,
-0.01597331278026104,
0.10539907962083817,
0.053328827023506165,
-0.03474825248122215,
0.03278939053416252,
-0.888546347618103,
-0.3951238691806793,
1.1326069831848145,
-0.11632689833641052,
0.8959023952484131,
0.19616039097309113,
0.566552460193634,
-0.1823769360780716,
0.23099938035011292,
-0.3518155813217163,
0.3360365033149719,
-0.6466196179389954,
-0.5079662799835205,
-0.2548335790634155,
-0.34687870740890503,
-0.7880249619483948,
0.352787047624588,
0.045419201254844666,
-0.6565114259719849,
-0.12476743012666702,
0.40934324264526367,
-0.22000433504581451,
0.1365281641483307,
-1.4562060832977295,
1.0559508800506592,
-0.6383268237113953,
-0.5143675208091736,
-0.3757966160774231,
-0.4825375974178314,
0.2456590086221695,
-0.12390945106744766,
0.31993648409843445,
-0.19265979528427124,
-0.0038412814028561115,
0.4395971894264221,
-0.05146618187427521,
0.9109296202659607,
-0.24544478952884674,
-0.18651144206523895,
-0.020511189475655556,
-0.220261812210083,
0.2074921727180481,
0.06816133856773376,
-0.05022050067782402,
0.40090304613113403,
0.12814627587795258,
-0.6663431525230408,
-0.5914183259010315,
0.7999114990234375,
-0.869014322757721,
-0.8598750233650208,
-0.07899634540081024,
-0.8673067688941956,
-0.31984251737594604,
0.10452016443014145,
0.18855009973049164,
0.42036542296409607,
0.012832553125917912,
0.18047310411930084,
0.6868248581886292,
-0.44626158475875854,
0.27308815717697144,
0.6517415642738342,
-0.2300611138343811,
0.019503625109791756,
1.102866291999817,
0.23978887498378754,
0.4735918343067169,
0.3719246983528137,
0.2887786030769348,
-0.2453383058309555,
-0.26638105511665344,
-0.7991105914115906,
0.4886828362941742,
-0.5013700723648071,
0.19875116646289825,
-0.14400595426559448,
0.0752066895365715,
-0.34254026412963867,
0.001960835885256529,
-0.517989993095398,
-0.27740612626075745,
-0.058604028075933456,
0.10169116407632828,
0.34869715571403503,
0.6353445053100586,
-0.010711141861975193,
0.33461013436317444,
-0.7476937174797058,
0.02503739297389984,
0.28766435384750366,
0.5042352676391602,
-0.11422478407621384,
-0.4788703918457031,
-0.524539589881897,
0.18650498986244202,
-0.03052705153822899,
-0.49083030223846436,
0.02226882614195347,
0.5983118414878845,
0.5827809572219849,
0.12600922584533691,
-0.24717026948928833,
0.7815587520599365,
-0.8296154141426086,
0.5406740307807922,
-0.16654548048973083,
-0.6237390637397766,
0.21800176799297333,
-0.327373743057251,
0.691573441028595,
0.3144393563270569,
0.5659456253051758,
-0.48225584626197815,
-0.016199208796024323,
-0.12939728796482086,
-0.6258335113525391,
0.9977103471755981,
-0.29236191511154175,
0.30857619643211365,
0.05463036149740219,
0.27062442898750305,
0.35362452268600464,
0.09140972793102264,
-0.43507105112075806,
-0.34558385610580444,
0.016182243824005127,
-0.23648221790790558,
-0.3384297490119934,
-0.28941425681114197,
-0.06363225728273392,
-0.23243555426597595,
0.5745792984962463,
-0.1112632304430008,
0.12108045816421509,
-0.4266175627708435,
-0.2593367099761963,
0.0436604805290699,
0.29953524470329285,
0.9180096387863159,
1.074684739112854,
-0.11717664450407028,
-0.1011141911149025,
0.20162060856819153,
-0.43418529629707336,
0.02787974663078785,
0.3000234067440033,
0.08177800476551056,
-0.20016071200370789,
0.45049986243247986,
0.9654958844184875,
0.38869377970695496,
-0.4758569896221161,
0.24705517292022705,
-0.3515958786010742,
0.08241090178489685,
-0.12670500576496124,
0.1307069957256317,
0.31782862544059753,
-0.05888358876109123,
-0.05270101875066757,
-0.41752132773399353,
-0.2293989062309265,
-0.3992057144641876,
-0.050564058125019073,
0.2633424699306488,
-0.21415144205093384,
-0.5593854188919067,
0.3198205232620239,
0.19259457290172577,
-0.44412821531295776,
0.756066620349884,
0.012146517634391785,
-0.3394319415092468,
0.41183388233184814,
0.5664368271827698,
0.49086835980415344,
-0.5814895033836365,
0.08323199301958084,
0.27086341381073,
0.4678483009338379,
-0.07401817291975021,
0.2508661150932312,
-0.0415189154446125,
-0.48978498578071594,
-0.7244518399238586,
-0.5682190656661987,
-0.4510253071784973,
-0.23725520074367523,
-0.9048776626586914,
0.3573460280895233,
-0.13325640559196472,
0.1340392678976059,
0.21472960710525513,
-0.278071790933609,
-0.6070892810821533,
-0.2324163317680359,
0.31252792477607727,
0.7261863350868225,
-0.8940231800079346,
1.040966272354126,
0.8858755826950073,
-0.10314837098121643,
-0.6671918630599976,
-0.07753899693489075,
0.03429969400167465,
-0.8614729046821594,
0.37233325839042664,
0.22175952792167664,
-0.29522770643234253,
0.020343361422419548,
-0.2520994246006012,
-0.8306357264518738,
0.7278029918670654,
0.9287315011024475,
-0.8419775366783142,
-0.05214923247694969,
0.50486820936203,
0.6646151542663574,
-0.3066568374633789,
0.3140926659107208,
0.6182717084884644,
0.3003797233104706,
-0.3127635717391968,
-1.2705708742141724,
-0.5758640766143799,
-0.20760701596736908,
-0.15576675534248352,
0.5733616352081299,
-0.9810661673545837,
0.8265952467918396,
-0.06061850115656853,
0.08422606438398361,
-0.291347473859787,
0.3486515283584595,
-0.038336142897605896,
-0.009621279314160347,
0.39021384716033936,
0.39819422364234924,
0.6634417772293091,
-0.1162417083978653,
1.4458575248718262,
-0.7067793607711792,
-0.023436473682522774,
1.2711811065673828,
-0.2704777121543884,
0.6304259896278381,
0.4408913552761078,
-0.019240396097302437,
0.48398104310035706,
0.6615474224090576,
0.3588201403617859,
0.3527129590511322,
-0.05164971575140953,
-0.11043542623519897,
-0.27973273396492004,
-0.2014351189136505,
-0.4821382462978363,
0.6750723123550415,
0.5378919839859009,
-0.04094137251377106,
-0.18055404722690582,
0.14825394749641418,
-0.06952159106731415,
0.03616078570485115,
-0.3487228751182556,
0.8374283313751221,
0.007538168225437403,
-0.8063690662384033,
0.8280287981033325,
-0.17451924085617065,
0.529252827167511,
-0.6409745216369629,
-0.10712070763111115,
-0.33372023701667786,
0.30314943194389343,
0.003418147098273039,
-0.49182605743408203,
0.18840669095516205,
0.06180889904499054,
-0.2362164556980133,
-0.13667848706245422,
0.1547822654247284,
-0.7779707312583923,
-0.7314190864562988,
0.45966601371765137,
0.389838844537735,
0.28140687942504883,
0.3152798116207123,
-0.7648420333862305,
0.10099112242460251,
0.020560825243592262,
-0.036617688834667206,
0.5653181076049805,
0.3459036946296692,
-0.26922640204429626,
0.37781524658203125,
0.409584105014801,
0.14409950375556946,
0.4551582336425781,
0.449931263923645,
0.47021621465682983,
-0.24005956947803497,
-0.25432997941970825,
-0.7668269276618958,
0.3435525596141815,
0.004086214583367109,
-0.4314799904823303,
0.9624339938163757,
0.5727818012237549,
1.3773703575134277,
-0.1737959086894989,
0.47202596068382263,
0.2564314603805542,
0.5174079537391663,
-0.6206455230712891,
0.30326351523399353,
-0.5634465217590332,
0.2757469415664673,
0.09570467472076416,
-1.0244393348693848,
0.007324120495468378,
0.2827274799346924,
-0.6647484302520752,
0.05312643572688103,
0.5491657853126526,
0.9322628378868103,
-0.30800920724868774,
0.14823144674301147,
0.28484585881233215,
-0.031772907823324203,
0.08351175487041473,
0.35219961404800415,
0.5884447693824768,
-0.05516990274190903,
0.550517201423645,
-0.44616684317588806,
-0.2726043164730072,
0.01641368493437767,
-0.5875417590141296,
-0.9392938017845154,
-0.3626392185688019,
-0.1418239325284958,
0.2490842491388321,
0.3654632866382599,
0.8521122336387634,
0.6178878545761108,
-0.7438334822654724,
-0.7126078009605408,
0.35118770599365234,
0.054397743195295334,
-0.30505698919296265,
-0.10453387349843979,
0.5086257457733154,
-0.5646637082099915,
-0.9573009610176086,
0.3480468690395355,
0.3592205345630646,
-0.14968232810497284,
-0.23273836076259613,
-0.015574973076581955,
-0.4641760587692261,
-0.13893617689609528,
0.5353862643241882,
0.18699437379837036,
-0.6811521053314209,
-0.13894319534301758,
0.282383531332016,
0.02089736983180046,
0.12618863582611084,
0.7562623620033264,
-0.03880441561341286,
0.8288690447807312,
0.19408047199249268,
0.6523640155792236,
0.5324779748916626,
-0.026623448356986046,
0.8708394169807434,
-0.9243072271347046,
0.4822060465812683,
-0.19137512147426605,
0.25336042046546936,
0.5268068909645081,
-0.26538196206092834,
0.37906643748283386,
-0.13377149403095245,
-0.6213859915733337,
-0.6994179487228394,
0.013387511484324932,
-0.38456207513809204,
-0.12764887511730194,
0.9785386919975281,
-0.26946306228637695,
-0.2846432030200958,
0.18352378904819489,
-0.14815910160541534,
0.18160845339298248,
-0.1232917308807373,
0.8326594829559326,
1.0303665399551392,
-0.30329135060310364,
-0.4584571123123169,
-0.6535640954971313,
0.40209197998046875,
0.6498058438301086,
-0.7963824272155762,
0.3117840588092804,
0.30191734433174133,
0.025329412892460823,
0.05999115854501724,
0.28395459055900574,
-0.050463031977415085,
0.5049856305122375,
-0.08689997345209122,
0.11358653008937836,
-0.04402826726436615,
-0.5392435789108276,
-0.369972288608551,
-0.2249462604522705,
0.21768870949745178,
-0.11157573014497757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13693v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13693v2
|
CMNER: A Chinese Multimodal NER Dataset based on Social Media
| 2024-02-21T10:53:45 | 2024-03-01T07:12:20 |
Yuanze Ji, Bobo Li, Jun Zhou, Fei Li, Chong Teng, Donghong Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multimodal Named Entity Recognition (MNER) is a pivotal task designed to
extract named entities from text with the support of pertinent images.
Nonetheless, a notable paucity of data for Chinese MNER has considerably
impeded the progress of this natural language processing task within the
Chinese domain. Consequently, in this study, we compile a Chinese Multimodal
NER dataset (CMNER) utilizing data sourced from Weibo, China's largest social
media platform. Our dataset encompasses 5,000 Weibo posts paired with 18,326
corresponding images. The entities are classified into four distinct
categories: person, location, organization, and miscellaneous. We perform
baseline experiments on CMNER, and the outcomes underscore the effectiveness of
incorporating images for NER. Furthermore, we conduct cross-lingual experiments
on the publicly available English MNER dataset (Twitter2015), and the results
substantiate our hypothesis that Chinese and English multimodal NER data can
mutually enhance the performance of the NER model.
|
[
-0.36692526936531067,
-0.46942412853240967,
0.27757537364959717,
0.37114235758781433,
-0.32582417130470276,
-0.07171653211116791,
-0.3922913074493408,
-0.5783299803733826,
0.31173983216285706,
0.19498310983181,
-0.2202424854040146,
-0.32324591279029846,
-0.7828035354614258,
0.26359105110168457,
-0.3533605635166168,
1.029497504234314,
0.1247318685054779,
0.32471802830696106,
0.062403999269008636,
-0.26715341210365295,
-0.18320225179195404,
-0.42256930470466614,
-1.1739656925201416,
-0.1534711867570877,
1.1826198101043701,
0.21963979303836823,
0.5209488272666931,
0.29250606894493103,
0.8392581343650818,
0.3264895975589752,
0.1369418203830719,
0.34332242608070374,
-0.3147414028644562,
-0.14828814566135406,
-0.1994573324918747,
0.14614543318748474,
-0.3310939073562622,
-0.3241768181324005,
0.6940109729766846,
0.10553757846355438,
0.07048049569129944,
0.05985797941684723,
0.0259469635784626,
0.42957010865211487,
-0.49509352445602417,
0.09475549310445786,
-0.5703637003898621,
-0.0368855781853199,
-0.36668524146080017,
-0.175842747092247,
-0.3586256802082062,
-0.14262869954109192,
0.1017221063375473,
-0.46181437373161316,
0.3706015646457672,
-0.11909031122922897,
1.1624202728271484,
-0.08035264909267426,
-0.7468059659004211,
-0.3326704800128937,
-0.7339165210723877,
0.7241376638412476,
-0.6293662786483765,
0.579625129699707,
0.13659779727458954,
0.5416480302810669,
0.06659258902072906,
-0.7122863531112671,
-0.8887155055999756,
0.028274107724428177,
-0.4435516893863678,
-0.09640462696552277,
-0.03843339532613754,
-0.178803488612175,
0.0971059501171112,
0.1799556314945221,
-0.49042022228240967,
-0.12463562935590744,
-0.4180210530757904,
-0.37111660838127136,
0.7079589366912842,
0.044587038457393646,
0.672462522983551,
-0.6879772543907166,
-0.40269628167152405,
-0.16654065251350403,
-0.27477312088012695,
0.06160535663366318,
0.14493274688720703,
0.377704918384552,
-0.2813202738761902,
0.5620158910751343,
0.060572993010282516,
0.4005884826183319,
0.0736418291926384,
-0.3016413748264313,
0.5449891090393066,
-0.42159369587898254,
0.05079779401421547,
0.048779889941215515,
1.2252694368362427,
0.7423117756843567,
0.2883366048336029,
-0.24414591491222382,
-0.5450152158737183,
-0.07857726514339447,
-0.10904940217733383,
-1.1686959266662598,
-0.6066309809684753,
0.012240225449204445,
-0.6874868273735046,
-0.11475935578346252,
0.5020284056663513,
-0.7065794467926025,
-0.604266345500946,
-0.36884453892707825,
0.24868589639663696,
-0.47802233695983887,
-0.5491330623626709,
-0.5301458239555359,
-0.5026554465293884,
0.3346012234687805,
0.21734899282455444,
-0.6740307807922363,
0.09186488389968872,
0.545324981212616,
0.9026708006858826,
-0.056895337998867035,
-0.20357105135917664,
-0.3997436761856079,
0.19157803058624268,
-0.2715345025062561,
0.8266522884368896,
-0.6249954700469971,
-0.2503136694431305,
-0.26073357462882996,
0.5298179388046265,
-0.3286406397819519,
-0.4447841942310333,
0.3722594976425171,
-0.613083004951477,
0.06806688010692596,
-0.4829627573490143,
-0.19521617889404297,
-0.08682160079479218,
0.5930394530296326,
-1.0524218082427979,
0.6171839237213135,
-0.3036717474460602,
-1.0767171382904053,
0.41544923186302185,
-0.6726889610290527,
-0.616891622543335,
-0.0024067603517323732,
-0.5022090077400208,
-0.19687601923942566,
0.01871253363788128,
0.46671316027641296,
0.7560458183288574,
-0.28883790969848633,
0.42178425192832947,
-0.17351360619068146,
-0.3468543291091919,
0.46698877215385437,
-0.5855505466461182,
0.5431621670722961,
0.04167630895972252,
-0.1148664653301239,
-0.1513167768716812,
-0.9790315628051758,
-0.11969614028930664,
0.41384270787239075,
-0.3982183635234833,
-0.6733471155166626,
0.2313489317893982,
0.7364356517791748,
0.5486482977867126,
0.21051301062107086,
-0.7834489941596985,
-0.18332330882549286,
0.037274811416864395,
0.45767679810523987,
0.6588161587715149,
0.09714751690626144,
0.4708501994609833,
-0.25086310505867004,
0.1084224283695221,
0.34937357902526855,
-0.010411424562335014,
-0.2541939914226532,
-0.2580409646034241,
-0.8187458515167236,
-0.1338476836681366,
0.5109190940856934,
0.38301926851272583,
-1.224090814590454,
-0.18395672738552094,
-0.669289231300354,
-0.5307916402816772,
-0.5577950477600098,
0.005889218300580978,
0.4723675847053528,
0.25903981924057007,
0.42440366744995117,
0.07366621494293213,
-0.6352595090866089,
-1.0624849796295166,
-0.002247667871415615,
0.0910331979393959,
-0.18687161803245544,
0.6386401653289795,
0.4710840582847595,
-0.46438390016555786,
0.6000567078590393,
-0.19719906151294708,
-0.4627237617969513,
-0.2480422705411911,
0.2015901654958725,
0.10724373906850815,
0.455520361661911,
0.5014718174934387,
-1.4708086252212524,
-0.644719660282135,
0.314828485250473,
-0.7360469102859497,
0.3867759704589844,
-0.2601320147514343,
-0.1223512664437294,
0.1473737210035324,
0.3505387306213379,
-0.3648167848587036,
0.11641073226928711,
0.8657400012016296,
0.021358070895075798,
0.40101850032806396,
0.031820159405469894,
0.3802879750728607,
-1.4608339071273804,
0.14217211306095123,
0.28656965494155884,
0.07210378348827362,
-0.5966120958328247,
-0.36744406819343567,
0.4110293388366699,
0.027175087481737137,
-0.4337652027606964,
0.8029872179031372,
-0.718268871307373,
0.17800629138946533,
-0.3408396542072296,
0.2729920446872711,
-0.06050344929099083,
0.31930315494537354,
0.10558715462684631,
0.6589339971542358,
0.4893452823162079,
-0.7775678038597107,
0.14727796614170074,
0.17086674273014069,
-0.3145182132720947,
0.5679068565368652,
-0.9497901797294617,
0.2573797404766083,
-0.3537229001522064,
-0.007686610799282789,
-1.005403995513916,
-0.5373907089233398,
0.43650320172309875,
-0.712680459022522,
0.2519521117210388,
-0.15740405023097992,
-0.6441836953163147,
-0.157777339220047,
-0.17561958730220795,
0.39287298917770386,
-0.016635462641716003,
-0.627893328666687,
1.0474321842193604,
0.5695810914039612,
-0.04558516666293144,
-0.6949082016944885,
-0.8500363826751709,
0.21274223923683167,
0.016808925196528435,
-0.45112475752830505,
0.689095139503479,
0.03989545255899429,
0.00596199044957757,
0.2980779707431793,
-0.014720707200467587,
-0.22530706226825714,
-0.4210505783557892,
0.3441689610481262,
0.4301322400569916,
-0.31622135639190674,
0.24631398916244507,
-0.18345509469509125,
-0.15647158026695251,
0.07019788026809692,
0.36661505699157715,
0.5518056154251099,
0.132332906126976,
-0.18038694560527802,
-0.4988720417022705,
-0.058415938168764114,
0.44105732440948486,
-0.2843519151210785,
0.888329803943634,
1.0106980800628662,
-0.5645383596420288,
0.06596208363771439,
-0.6082611083984375,
0.054440539330244064,
-0.4992040693759918,
0.22916536033153534,
-0.4665387272834778,
-0.6642160415649414,
0.3543623089790344,
0.31958433985710144,
0.22044532001018524,
0.35670849680900574,
0.10545825958251953,
-0.0010899781482294202,
1.1364071369171143,
0.6384381651878357,
-0.3308365046977997,
0.5732837915420532,
-0.01611468382179737,
0.353748619556427,
-0.9988116025924683,
-0.3768584132194519,
-0.37002691626548767,
-0.5450728535652161,
-0.8509650826454163,
-0.5158754587173462,
-0.0971183031797409,
-0.5382713079452515,
0.0914808139204979,
0.7604959011077881,
-0.5031240582466125,
0.5478361248970032,
0.2853613495826721,
0.3700602948665619,
0.12576010823249817,
-0.11910043656826019,
-0.058126598596572876,
-0.21473507583141327,
-0.4254315495491028,
-0.4653380215167999,
0.7034189701080322,
-0.013423352502286434,
0.5395277738571167,
0.1923128217458725,
0.48104235529899597,
0.05342364311218262,
0.4523697793483734,
-0.6900230050086975,
0.635510265827179,
-0.5533018112182617,
-0.7709296941757202,
-0.07362604886293411,
-0.6487082242965698,
-1.03703773021698,
0.43152064085006714,
-0.2453933209180832,
-0.4488334059715271,
0.2150341123342514,
0.005918333772569895,
-0.038322072476148605,
0.2834848463535309,
-0.44683000445365906,
0.6928772330284119,
-0.5563005208969116,
-0.029097774997353554,
0.08812571316957474,
-0.7214861512184143,
0.39210641384124756,
-0.18642887473106384,
0.418763130903244,
-0.1922551840543747,
-0.026770299300551414,
0.9207600355148315,
0.09863945841789246,
0.7044873833656311,
-0.24264535307884216,
0.06636226922273636,
0.0029593664221465588,
-0.3404242992401123,
0.49582639336586,
0.051390696316957474,
-0.07244839519262314,
0.32195261120796204,
-0.19061025977134705,
-0.23274829983711243,
-0.4306173026561737,
0.8938227295875549,
-0.6573251485824585,
-0.029333708807826042,
-0.28940144181251526,
-0.435137540102005,
0.14019742608070374,
0.5420202016830444,
0.33369767665863037,
0.5840389728546143,
-0.27178528904914856,
0.5487676858901978,
0.3102196753025055,
-0.35209575295448303,
0.677946150302887,
0.38156965374946594,
-0.24763542413711548,
-0.8338270783424377,
1.0592949390411377,
0.40222546458244324,
-0.11027635633945465,
0.6968954205513,
-0.044720012694597244,
-0.14493046700954437,
-0.2999218702316284,
-0.25615590810775757,
0.3834574222564697,
-0.6583212018013,
-0.029150133952498436,
-1.027597427368164,
-0.5525403618812561,
-0.3415221869945526,
-0.0438588485121727,
-0.2611193358898163,
0.050087183713912964,
-0.18298903107643127,
0.06994058191776276,
0.002777987392619252,
0.5635642409324646,
0.1613077074289322,
0.3221988379955292,
-1.0159400701522827,
0.5797524452209473,
0.021236324682831764,
0.09888038784265518,
0.20433031022548676,
-0.24131062626838684,
-0.14579442143440247,
0.2617374360561371,
0.03573257103562355,
-0.6357439160346985,
0.36486077308654785,
0.2592751383781433,
0.6470608115196228,
0.8355959057807922,
0.08518689125776291,
1.1296818256378174,
-0.6241721510887146,
0.5110859274864197,
0.42968884110450745,
-0.5092337727546692,
0.43302273750305176,
-0.2370099425315857,
0.15848878026008606,
0.40564852952957153,
0.5709218382835388,
-0.864262044429779,
-0.11643611639738083,
-0.3837084174156189,
-0.9049090147018433,
0.5820545554161072,
0.16581694781780243,
0.7817384600639343,
-0.3672136962413788,
-0.11323580890893936,
-0.09298108518123627,
0.0305516067892313,
-0.9663186073303223,
-0.1924780011177063,
-0.021141499280929565,
-0.14881955087184906,
-0.2749699652194977,
-0.12982280552387238,
0.18732598423957825,
-0.1627078503370285,
0.5454898476600647,
0.06420154124498367,
0.27895867824554443,
0.1490858495235443,
-0.2938149571418762,
0.1580915004014969,
0.23847167193889618,
0.17809143662452698,
0.43402716517448425,
0.05318761244416237,
0.2640018165111542,
0.09165679663419724,
-0.3647584617137909,
-0.20039118826389313,
0.27010348439216614,
-0.1915261149406433,
0.4646124541759491,
0.1464521735906601,
0.6073153018951416,
0.5482693314552307,
-0.7613425850868225,
0.5711953043937683,
-0.40966489911079407,
-0.19008579850196838,
-0.6177015900611877,
-0.10445696115493774,
0.2628931701183319,
0.384227991104126,
0.479128360748291,
0.3080993890762329,
0.1880197823047638,
-0.24190287292003632,
0.23423123359680176,
0.38718050718307495,
-0.5254377126693726,
-0.36808907985687256,
0.6007596254348755,
0.044325318187475204,
-0.3189544975757599,
0.8683189749717712,
-0.21847769618034363,
-0.39474889636039734,
0.6747743487358093,
0.5755963921546936,
0.592904269695282,
-0.0014539298135787249,
0.2281583845615387,
0.7963255643844604,
0.292194128036499,
-0.147823303937912,
0.13277460634708405,
-0.030188782140612602,
-1.1258279085159302,
-0.13761542737483978,
-0.4303698241710663,
-0.18843582272529602,
0.1429963856935501,
-0.5550811290740967,
0.6352626085281372,
-0.47558286786079407,
-0.4422270357608795,
0.4293957054615021,
-0.45171883702278137,
-0.717887818813324,
0.2305832952260971,
0.42991822957992554,
0.48564812541007996,
-0.4209306836128235,
0.7632989287376404,
0.9225737452507019,
-0.45605093240737915,
-0.9023414254188538,
0.13115860521793365,
0.12887133657932281,
-0.5606268644332886,
0.808515727519989,
0.7534911036491394,
-0.14909236133098602,
-0.0492849126458168,
-0.4658557176589966,
-0.9347730278968811,
1.2799040079116821,
-0.03897910192608833,
-0.6246088147163391,
-0.11217233538627625,
-0.08042081445455551,
0.4035184681415558,
-0.20195794105529785,
0.24531158804893494,
-0.1165599599480629,
0.5649511218070984,
0.2970495820045471,
-0.7030726075172424,
0.09990604221820831,
-0.8682877421379089,
0.23890915513038635,
0.4136771261692047,
-0.7229784727096558,
0.9769745469093323,
-0.4140533208847046,
-0.679530143737793,
-0.18763169646263123,
0.5952379107475281,
0.4233349561691284,
0.5881896018981934,
0.5770705342292786,
0.19988715648651123,
0.6127698421478271,
0.00520117674022913,
0.6890147924423218,
-0.3007676899433136,
0.2736380994319916,
1.065192461013794,
-0.2845287322998047,
1.0537869930267334,
0.4537091851234436,
0.15716788172721863,
0.5806572437286377,
0.3920792043209076,
-0.4930184781551361,
0.5511091947555542,
-0.3148137032985687,
-0.1246042549610138,
0.004254142753779888,
-0.3445453643798828,
-0.25994235277175903,
0.3650449514389038,
0.16975052654743195,
-0.6963403820991516,
-0.13020175695419312,
0.13335539400577545,
0.28207460045814514,
-0.23657946288585663,
-0.12383910268545151,
0.7468441128730774,
0.04313911125063896,
-0.3426473140716553,
0.01443704217672348,
0.05781209096312523,
1.168473243713379,
-0.39759910106658936,
-0.04050179198384285,
0.075190968811512,
0.3648773729801178,
-0.23194681107997894,
-0.5674107074737549,
0.29713305830955505,
0.019997313618659973,
-0.15408001840114594,
-0.008978484198451042,
1.1922322511672974,
-0.40381625294685364,
-0.7670952677726746,
0.6508238911628723,
0.4136529564857483,
0.21789215505123138,
-0.25651130080223083,
-0.757989227771759,
-0.25677213072776794,
-0.12153661996126175,
-0.18646718561649323,
0.25901326537132263,
0.7126604914665222,
0.12086030840873718,
0.5627320408821106,
0.9929359555244446,
-0.13640405237674713,
-0.00021110942179802805,
0.2829778492450714,
0.9762492179870605,
-0.7979936599731445,
-0.09629166126251221,
-1.0922070741653442,
0.5817686319351196,
-0.45832201838493347,
-0.30430537462234497,
0.9869611263275146,
0.5478900671005249,
0.9811980128288269,
0.002369194757193327,
0.8921273350715637,
-0.6878538727760315,
0.34609121084213257,
-0.24487173557281494,
0.9664724469184875,
-0.8304405212402344,
-0.06947098672389984,
-0.516467809677124,
-0.5835973024368286,
-0.29087546467781067,
0.4930458664894104,
-0.25141042470932007,
0.1515088677406311,
0.530815839767456,
1.0460480451583862,
-0.186210498213768,
-0.13184510171413422,
0.32805612683296204,
-0.15240079164505005,
0.24334588646888733,
0.40359169244766235,
0.910444974899292,
-0.7939618825912476,
0.8490105867385864,
-0.592972993850708,
0.2544200122356415,
-0.15105926990509033,
-0.73570317029953,
-1.18160879611969,
-0.6072277426719666,
-0.16332466900348663,
-0.11781284958124161,
-0.013593551702797413,
0.9673002362251282,
0.6768236756324768,
-0.9702108502388,
0.09964057058095932,
0.21700812876224518,
0.00022062318748794496,
-0.02400943450629711,
-0.28261077404022217,
0.20289424061775208,
-0.09010812640190125,
-0.8276742696762085,
0.04203742370009422,
-0.01646624691784382,
0.10164359211921692,
0.2596212327480316,
-0.2164822667837143,
-0.2851357161998749,
-0.09972520172595978,
0.687515914440155,
-0.051496390253305435,
-0.5899249315261841,
-0.06905798614025116,
0.5147188901901245,
-0.33121103048324585,
0.05340474843978882,
0.6660369038581848,
-0.2622002363204956,
0.2116769552230835,
0.544364333152771,
0.7397863268852234,
0.12578780949115753,
0.09986082464456558,
0.2832925319671631,
-0.6527436971664429,
-0.2022404968738556,
0.014507513493299484,
0.5929811000823975,
0.6769484281539917,
-0.20600737631320953,
0.376422643661499,
0.19518186151981354,
-0.6172786951065063,
-0.5599796175956726,
-0.3988114595413208,
-1.056990385055542,
-0.26024821400642395,
1.2872120141983032,
0.04761498421430588,
-0.10238073021173477,
-0.06277559697628021,
-0.3144175410270691,
0.377069354057312,
-0.6137157082557678,
0.5867674350738525,
0.7955673336982727,
0.16561762988567352,
-0.7198975682258606,
-0.6305447816848755,
-0.17527256906032562,
-0.2013421654701233,
-0.6456649899482727,
-0.25594547390937805,
0.4768976867198944,
0.49659737944602966,
0.3983844220638275,
0.7652101516723633,
-0.2529759407043457,
0.10664525628089905,
0.040481094270944595,
0.2175629585981369,
0.044075001031160355,
-0.3760833144187927,
0.09009367227554321,
0.2091141790151596,
-0.33422034978866577,
-0.38960516452789307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13671v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13671v2
|
KInIT at SemEval-2024 Task 8: Fine-tuned LLMs for Multilingual Machine-Generated Text Detection
| 2024-02-21T10:09:56 | 2024-06-17T13:43:28 |
Michal Spiegel, Dominik Macko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
SemEval-2024 Task 8 is focused on multigenerator, multidomain, and
multilingual black-box machine-generated text detection. Such a detection is
important for preventing a potential misuse of large language models (LLMs),
the newest of which are very capable in generating multilingual human-like
texts. We have coped with this task in multiple ways, utilizing language
identification and parameter-efficient fine-tuning of smaller LLMs for text
classification. We have further used the per-language classification-threshold
calibration to uniquely combine fine-tuned models predictions with statistical
detection metrics to improve generalization of the system detection
performance. Our submitted method achieved competitive results, ranking at the
fourth place, just under 1 percentage point behind the winner.
|
[
-0.46511179208755493,
-0.5950871706008911,
0.4580555558204651,
-0.03815876320004463,
-0.3938983082771301,
0.1736530214548111,
-0.20224708318710327,
-0.5839493870735168,
-0.08336006850004196,
0.6914803385734558,
-0.5605462789535522,
-0.5367597341537476,
-0.6264936923980713,
0.48859861493110657,
-0.13557057082653046,
0.9448369741439819,
-0.06509535759687424,
-0.061442721635103226,
-0.08363281935453415,
-0.18989726901054382,
-0.4148350954055786,
-0.6625484824180603,
-0.6221020817756653,
-0.39419791102409363,
0.5485092401504517,
0.5912254452705383,
0.13662461936473846,
0.33513182401657104,
0.49588489532470703,
0.3384893238544464,
-0.04631040617823601,
0.45620885491371155,
-0.42976412177085876,
0.2786426246166229,
-0.12363659590482712,
-0.4707784950733185,
-0.6607025265693665,
-0.19730958342552185,
0.638654351234436,
0.4014817178249359,
0.26453372836112976,
0.3160568177700043,
0.2605588436126709,
0.42529067397117615,
-0.5927940607070923,
-0.10974568873643875,
-0.8370252251625061,
0.02205963432788849,
-0.35052239894866943,
-0.6213648319244385,
-0.4597592353820801,
-0.07766835391521454,
-0.36511263251304626,
-0.21496516466140747,
0.30557534098625183,
0.12190063297748566,
0.6396505832672119,
0.23203635215759277,
-0.7194998860359192,
-0.11842099577188492,
-0.5321834087371826,
0.8572923541069031,
-0.6041126847267151,
0.5674409866333008,
0.4663400948047638,
0.1747731864452362,
-0.23377762734889984,
-0.48298344016075134,
-0.20199711620807648,
0.16376830637454987,
0.26704198122024536,
-0.0494389645755291,
-0.10758139938116074,
-0.07138688862323761,
0.2332688421010971,
0.0390806570649147,
-0.7091174721717834,
0.34261512756347656,
-0.4041871130466461,
-0.6823498606681824,
0.7081962823867798,
0.20722396671772003,
0.22269831597805023,
0.05181923508644104,
-0.22196629643440247,
0.18448692560195923,
-0.7849031090736389,
-0.1281535029411316,
0.7505648136138916,
0.3364178538322449,
-0.07843587547540665,
0.3394545018672943,
-0.5454907417297363,
0.5320743918418884,
-0.009601043537259102,
-0.27658501267433167,
0.46158546209335327,
-0.5447036623954773,
-0.010460752993822098,
0.04341913014650345,
0.8054223656654358,
0.3415609896183014,
0.3234221041202545,
-0.12083637714385986,
-0.5400456786155701,
0.16662348806858063,
0.11553189158439636,
-0.9322224855422974,
-0.29137489199638367,
-0.0848722979426384,
-0.40717193484306335,
-0.7355020046234131,
-0.269381582736969,
-0.9920479655265808,
-0.40104809403419495,
-0.31917983293533325,
0.5417230129241943,
-0.1352786123752594,
-0.2566433250904083,
0.15736636519432068,
0.09276827424764633,
0.11823223531246185,
0.3591116964817047,
-0.6842969059944153,
-0.09618858247995377,
0.5575774908065796,
0.4834669530391693,
-0.3761002719402313,
-0.4112500250339508,
-0.7978636622428894,
0.05864061415195465,
-0.2502189576625824,
1.028659701347351,
-0.5777695775032043,
-0.1049400344491005,
-0.07885061204433441,
0.44524386525154114,
0.06233517825603485,
-0.5368321537971497,
0.8488746881484985,
-0.5449276566505432,
0.14130394160747528,
-0.141914963722229,
-0.476228266954422,
-0.2270180583000183,
0.5131164789199829,
-0.5180191397666931,
0.9605489373207092,
-0.1790163367986679,
-0.6666743755340576,
0.47039365768432617,
-0.42016756534576416,
-0.5334777235984802,
0.31647616624832153,
0.007380261551588774,
-0.7816057801246643,
0.0674978569149971,
0.12003155052661896,
0.7801679968833923,
-0.21014435589313507,
0.32964104413986206,
-0.3911329507827759,
-0.28959038853645325,
0.06555698812007904,
-0.7690562605857849,
0.4470970332622528,
0.24929498136043549,
-0.47931206226348877,
0.16080904006958008,
-0.9395714402198792,
0.06795129179954529,
0.019365357235074043,
-0.6037366986274719,
-0.24539628624916077,
-0.19642892479896545,
0.039375413209199905,
0.13983820378780365,
0.5298684239387512,
-0.5410491824150085,
-0.07649096101522446,
-0.3858373165130615,
0.36481931805610657,
0.7210039496421814,
0.06739717721939087,
0.40519416332244873,
-0.10038672387599945,
0.7924391627311707,
0.021483896300196648,
-0.08230001479387283,
-0.33610913157463074,
-0.3928629457950592,
-0.898826539516449,
-0.12046267092227936,
0.43362683057785034,
0.5508843660354614,
-0.6516284942626953,
0.44483110308647156,
-0.03582937270402908,
-0.5623423457145691,
-0.012263685464859009,
0.29323720932006836,
0.2077198177576065,
0.14659692347049713,
0.08671414852142334,
-0.06304754316806793,
-0.6671162843704224,
-0.8725013732910156,
-0.3953208327293396,
0.07038608938455582,
0.15792615711688995,
0.04994577169418335,
0.7213884592056274,
-0.5710862874984741,
0.20423480868339539,
-0.2438214123249054,
-0.13707195222377777,
-0.08655673265457153,
0.20662137866020203,
0.0018594864523038268,
0.3934536278247833,
0.5360899567604065,
-0.7196919918060303,
-0.5254837274551392,
0.23036006093025208,
-0.6286399364471436,
-0.5649827122688293,
0.24565096199512482,
-0.1670062243938446,
0.2441934049129486,
0.7826827168464661,
-0.0902378186583519,
0.36794039607048035,
0.553209125995636,
-0.4336793124675751,
0.7008765935897827,
-0.255383163690567,
0.503741443157196,
-1.1468675136566162,
-0.06753355264663696,
-0.06738074868917465,
-0.6087892651557922,
-0.6864718794822693,
0.21476811170578003,
0.32861199975013733,
-0.06907214969396591,
-0.38326945900917053,
0.5099310278892517,
-0.40776878595352173,
0.06638339906930923,
-0.5482760667800903,
-0.11096973717212677,
0.04392090439796448,
0.4203845262527466,
-0.3802417516708374,
0.9019497036933899,
0.3675866425037384,
-0.7754647731781006,
0.30237123370170593,
-0.21558934450149536,
-0.14231248199939728,
0.7051162123680115,
-0.4612264037132263,
0.28311389684677124,
0.00956830196082592,
-0.09173481166362762,
-1.048649787902832,
-0.2696651816368103,
0.1585148125886917,
-0.4219531714916229,
0.22595451772212982,
-0.1665087342262268,
-0.520102858543396,
-0.24275009334087372,
-0.45754149556159973,
0.5952855348587036,
0.13670450448989868,
-0.38044488430023193,
0.4855549931526184,
0.6069247722625732,
-0.18139608204364777,
-0.2622007131576538,
-0.5384473204612732,
0.10657775402069092,
-0.5864965915679932,
-0.4160556495189667,
0.19204577803611755,
-0.23601524531841278,
0.1371389478445053,
-0.41131582856178284,
0.0019162765238434076,
0.006290511228144169,
0.41747307777404785,
0.12247444689273834,
0.1484823226928711,
-0.17793245613574982,
0.0401308611035347,
0.38440319895744324,
-0.30361199378967285,
0.02497599646449089,
-0.17126789689064026,
0.7622731328010559,
-0.0995853990316391,
-0.37676867842674255,
-0.29283079504966736,
0.20819979906082153,
0.7741686105728149,
-0.37088093161582947,
0.3375837206840515,
1.0105109214782715,
-0.5243644118309021,
-0.14404883980751038,
-0.5844641327857971,
-0.22876857221126556,
-0.49941495060920715,
0.4129585325717926,
-0.7171467542648315,
-1.237755298614502,
0.5151371359825134,
-0.2980448007583618,
-0.08947839587926865,
0.5676076412200928,
0.79008948802948,
0.12761065363883972,
1.4133309125900269,
0.6046278476715088,
-0.2237822562456131,
0.19637563824653625,
-0.02386409044265747,
0.09331626445055008,
-0.6759495735168457,
-0.08784417808055878,
-0.8014900088310242,
-0.3145689070224762,
-0.9149875640869141,
-0.3330821990966797,
0.4141697585582733,
0.059492263942956924,
-0.3212440311908722,
0.43310925364494324,
-0.5391641855239868,
0.5185611844062805,
0.5625397562980652,
0.029976321384310722,
0.3974086344242096,
0.15216781198978424,
-0.3042755126953125,
0.06327445805072784,
-0.3393246531486511,
-0.7402729988098145,
1.1556284427642822,
0.3133842945098877,
0.6557226777076721,
0.07934006303548813,
0.8722615242004395,
0.43496447801589966,
-0.20276015996932983,
-0.5277417898178101,
0.6540210843086243,
-0.3239460289478302,
-0.46776291728019714,
-0.21666835248470306,
-0.2600824236869812,
-1.1586273908615112,
0.3592361509799957,
-0.05716852843761444,
-0.8686807155609131,
0.15234462916851044,
-0.01568378321826458,
-0.14611972868442535,
0.12094154953956604,
-0.5463706851005554,
0.9005278944969177,
-0.23770512640476227,
-0.19938857853412628,
-0.23466528952121735,
-0.2739655077457428,
0.1952732503414154,
-0.46828070282936096,
0.2673521339893341,
-0.533339262008667,
-0.20396217703819275,
0.6035938262939453,
-0.10732658207416534,
0.8602064251899719,
-0.09261122345924377,
-0.22195322811603546,
0.12977319955825806,
0.1801649034023285,
0.7008654475212097,
-0.003876972245052457,
-0.2644587755203247,
0.09941016137599945,
0.16989201307296753,
-0.2654101550579071,
-0.06275055557489395,
0.6323553323745728,
-0.6198176145553589,
-0.3500988483428955,
-0.23693512380123138,
-0.2769608199596405,
-0.08570125699043274,
0.42326730489730835,
0.5717519521713257,
0.5207325220108032,
-0.18515419960021973,
0.3288760483264923,
0.6091828942298889,
-0.34247887134552,
0.30072930455207825,
0.6800297498703003,
-0.2637940049171448,
-0.448487251996994,
1.1332372426986694,
-0.1262350231409073,
0.03638391196727753,
0.4932241141796112,
0.21981407701969147,
-0.24557356536388397,
-0.6527023911476135,
-0.5410025715827942,
0.10224544256925583,
-0.6375499367713928,
-0.6160562038421631,
-0.7101337909698486,
-0.31039997935295105,
-0.5169306993484497,
0.02096545696258545,
-0.09382080286741257,
-0.20112012326717377,
-0.6406978964805603,
0.04196236655116081,
0.08374655991792679,
0.5534883141517639,
0.06868735700845718,
0.36518189311027527,
-0.8322771191596985,
0.2641334533691406,
0.12992490828037262,
0.15066014230251312,
-0.4222141206264496,
-0.8876705169677734,
-0.25482305884361267,
-0.011011217720806599,
-0.47703230381011963,
-0.7256020903587341,
0.4174734950065613,
0.36578720808029175,
0.6509791016578674,
0.2982151210308075,
0.005839620251208544,
0.4173908829689026,
-0.6966108679771423,
0.48069649934768677,
0.0688670352101326,
-0.6848243474960327,
0.7071922421455383,
-0.37710416316986084,
0.6196276545524597,
0.5987114906311035,
0.07655275613069534,
-0.3575716018676758,
-0.6278082728385925,
-0.3408127725124359,
-0.537692666053772,
0.5906975865364075,
0.048358723521232605,
0.37377867102622986,
0.3049910366535187,
0.28222188353538513,
0.31084394454956055,
0.2926877737045288,
-0.7204680442810059,
0.01993715390563011,
0.34212666749954224,
-0.3531811237335205,
-0.033700380474328995,
-0.5397279858589172,
0.19288048148155212,
-0.1262567788362503,
0.8850564956665039,
-0.3610668182373047,
0.1949070543050766,
-0.249782994389534,
-0.2652057409286499,
-0.2604523003101349,
0.49715742468833923,
0.8537099957466125,
0.4667905867099762,
0.22359053790569305,
0.3237760066986084,
0.5011868476867676,
-0.5008984208106995,
0.31126952171325684,
0.17661751806735992,
-0.33423030376434326,
-0.10166474431753159,
0.29268428683280945,
0.8602312207221985,
0.1292020082473755,
-0.556516706943512,
0.4187793731689453,
-0.042451199144124985,
-0.45137831568717957,
-0.17192573845386505,
0.16651752591133118,
-0.11419511586427689,
0.40684565901756287,
0.25151142477989197,
0.22012388706207275,
0.5791612267494202,
-0.19809390604496002,
0.3420805037021637,
0.48969167470932007,
-0.3611951172351837,
-0.6578134298324585,
0.7486733198165894,
0.45542606711387634,
-0.3023165464401245,
-0.15826329588890076,
-0.5784024596214294,
-1.1195441484451294,
0.6263401508331299,
0.4987550973892212,
0.9644197821617126,
-0.407490074634552,
0.11130086332559586,
0.3930346369743347,
0.4174731969833374,
0.044035252183675766,
0.46382811665534973,
0.0523984432220459,
-1.0152531862258911,
-0.3742176294326782,
-0.9109612703323364,
-0.1219286173582077,
0.4492165446281433,
-0.2006434053182602,
0.7452017068862915,
-0.02231428399682045,
-0.23743011057376862,
0.2261919379234314,
0.148263618350029,
-0.7536241412162781,
0.10748708248138428,
0.3175261914730072,
0.5888308882713318,
-0.8958898782730103,
0.6779423952102661,
0.98130863904953,
0.10832736641168594,
-0.709703266620636,
-0.26400282979011536,
0.12555721402168274,
-0.6652400493621826,
0.39391452074050903,
0.47433438897132874,
-0.32592254877090454,
-0.0020899749360978603,
-0.38974112272262573,
-0.6839303970336914,
0.8883865475654602,
0.4774134159088135,
-0.7227112650871277,
0.23141756653785706,
0.270338773727417,
0.4105766713619232,
-0.19790072739124298,
0.07644854485988617,
0.6548331379890442,
0.523125946521759,
-0.11955960094928741,
-1.10648512840271,
-0.20604775846004486,
-0.19726434350013733,
-0.24650970101356506,
0.5652587413787842,
-0.5456877946853638,
0.6058448553085327,
0.15671893954277039,
0.05186638981103897,
0.08683184534311295,
0.4104766845703125,
0.412760853767395,
0.6413471698760986,
0.6632158756256104,
0.559651792049408,
0.7903409600257874,
0.03807950019836426,
0.46737563610076904,
-0.42515110969543457,
0.3407351076602936,
0.9326591491699219,
-0.3509604334831238,
0.6012860536575317,
0.1360272318124771,
-0.18157026171684265,
0.24093562364578247,
0.8210164308547974,
0.02627551183104515,
0.42098599672317505,
-0.054339587688446045,
-0.5056983828544617,
-0.5286460518836975,
-0.11948106437921524,
-0.3004078269004822,
0.7668516039848328,
0.2948356866836548,
-0.3499978482723236,
-0.17359896004199982,
0.3596106469631195,
-0.10238001495599747,
-0.05577682703733444,
-0.49515268206596375,
0.7476950287818909,
-0.007035970687866211,
-0.5691683888435364,
0.3460335433483124,
0.28408655524253845,
1.0121946334838867,
-0.2571081817150116,
0.12517306208610535,
-0.01157497987151146,
0.4202227294445038,
-0.08148723840713501,
-0.5243015885353088,
0.0729779377579689,
0.05814528837800026,
-0.09048080444335938,
-0.13814161717891693,
1.5427370071411133,
-0.7335721850395203,
-0.789020299911499,
0.16821110248565674,
0.5430963039398193,
0.34937432408332825,
-0.3464621603488922,
-0.6309857964515686,
0.21873435378074646,
0.22024181485176086,
-0.12849341332912445,
0.3418748676776886,
0.9320170283317566,
-0.1476476788520813,
0.5030656456947327,
0.43727147579193115,
-0.003545531537383795,
0.0997278019785881,
0.2816146910190582,
0.5754287838935852,
-0.44490906596183777,
-0.5352033972740173,
-0.9575478434562683,
0.19623106718063354,
-0.006684560794383287,
-0.25421464443206787,
0.7241947650909424,
0.8128799796104431,
0.8347007036209106,
-0.07093354314565659,
0.665626585483551,
0.28667977452278137,
0.5768200755119324,
-0.38961195945739746,
0.5996374487876892,
-0.8713197112083435,
0.20674504339694977,
-0.21602928638458252,
-0.9281971454620361,
-0.1867864727973938,
0.41242027282714844,
-0.09295372664928436,
0.06998412311077118,
0.4963322877883911,
0.8941431045532227,
-0.02587905339896679,
0.02082066237926483,
0.7521706819534302,
-0.23542030155658722,
0.27080005407333374,
0.49874624609947205,
0.8521009087562561,
-0.6340231895446777,
0.7847987413406372,
-0.20909567177295685,
0.0022133071906864643,
-0.42669591307640076,
-0.8347269296646118,
-0.9824986457824707,
-0.6088256239891052,
-0.39077669382095337,
0.040079209953546524,
-0.06389153748750687,
0.550804078578949,
0.6855054497718811,
-1.1636545658111572,
-0.17078815400600433,
-0.008025371469557285,
0.0687393844127655,
0.21936167776584625,
-0.21535900235176086,
-0.11155816167593002,
-0.47277647256851196,
-0.9763335585594177,
0.35843735933303833,
0.5449045896530151,
0.04870695248246193,
-0.3248756229877472,
-0.1170489639043808,
-0.16837963461875916,
-0.16406628489494324,
0.8399592041969299,
-0.1548658162355423,
-0.6225723624229431,
-0.5304567217826843,
0.042953431606292725,
-0.17168951034545898,
-0.12528182566165924,
0.6991289854049683,
-0.5400251150131226,
0.3790411353111267,
0.7694735527038574,
0.7223013043403625,
0.40039560198783875,
-0.17486079037189484,
0.5911509990692139,
-0.7347962260246277,
0.17603787779808044,
0.1965986043214798,
0.44437360763549805,
0.2780989110469818,
-0.4590354263782501,
0.6826165914535522,
0.28751617670059204,
-1.0130764245986938,
-1.026286244392395,
0.14262595772743225,
-0.6340965628623962,
-0.21964655816555023,
1.2377873659133911,
0.15354612469673157,
-0.032656989991664886,
-0.2473573088645935,
-0.2562785744667053,
0.23505784571170807,
-0.3561428189277649,
0.19131173193454742,
0.7601919174194336,
0.1467054933309555,
-0.31534063816070557,
-0.6502293348312378,
0.3092436194419861,
0.393732488155365,
-0.9345643520355225,
-0.23449023067951202,
0.4921005070209503,
0.36632072925567627,
0.07168246805667877,
0.5766959190368652,
0.08551803976297379,
0.3093307912349701,
-0.3241400420665741,
-0.0026304260827600956,
0.2366987019777298,
-0.4640299081802368,
-0.36811205744743347,
0.09759239852428436,
0.16652625799179077,
-0.29683035612106323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13669v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13669v2
|
Self-Distillation Bridges Distribution Gap in Language Model Fine-Tuning
| 2024-02-21T10:06:08 | 2024-05-28T06:39:17 |
Zhaorui Yang, Tianyu Pang, Haozhe Feng, Han Wang, Wei Chen, Minfeng Zhu, Qian Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The surge in Large Language Models (LLMs) has revolutionized natural language
processing, but fine-tuning them for specific tasks often encounters challenges
in balancing performance and preserving general instruction-following
abilities. In this paper, we posit that the distribution gap between task
datasets and the LLMs serves as the primary underlying cause. To address the
problem, we introduce Self-Distillation Fine-Tuning (SDFT), a novel approach
that bridges the distribution gap by guiding fine-tuning with a distilled
dataset generated by the model itself to match its original distribution.
Experimental results on the Llama-2-chat model across various benchmarks
demonstrate that SDFT effectively mitigates catastrophic forgetting while
achieving comparable or superior performance on downstream tasks compared to
the vanilla fine-tuning. Moreover, SDFT demonstrates the potential to maintain
the helpfulness and safety alignment of LLMs. Our code is available at
https://github.com/sail-sg/sdft.
|
[
-0.29155951738357544,
-0.7380006313323975,
0.583069920539856,
0.14812257885932922,
-0.3918648660182953,
0.20035089552402496,
-0.28603145480155945,
-0.06036407873034477,
-0.07606595009565353,
0.7106855511665344,
-0.7942206859588623,
-0.40619975328445435,
-0.7601050734519958,
0.03341502696275711,
-0.2729436159133911,
1.0920448303222656,
-0.04548999294638634,
-0.41917192935943604,
-0.07324573397636414,
-0.09481659531593323,
-0.7308014035224915,
-0.20082435011863708,
-0.7435462474822998,
-0.48552921414375305,
0.39427730441093445,
0.43419933319091797,
0.5675751566886902,
1.0242282152175903,
0.454364150762558,
0.3022584915161133,
0.01198143046349287,
0.33080580830574036,
-0.7402728796005249,
0.40718790888786316,
-0.2551524043083191,
-0.5583109855651855,
-0.2655954360961914,
-0.277315616607666,
0.570999026298523,
0.6328786611557007,
-0.6305396556854248,
0.1401580572128296,
0.5405325889587402,
1.1470465660095215,
-0.6796447038650513,
0.16302156448364258,
-0.8970619440078735,
-0.23536302149295807,
-0.39437335729599,
-0.07051233947277069,
-0.14885945618152618,
-0.005316809751093388,
-0.14357364177703857,
-0.3215031027793884,
0.5642724633216858,
-0.04338552802801132,
0.6133361458778381,
0.9194954037666321,
-0.2096581906080246,
-0.34748172760009766,
-0.8358566164970398,
0.6713788509368896,
-0.8191822171211243,
0.2132880985736847,
0.5865519046783447,
0.30191802978515625,
-0.4337557256221771,
-0.3172394633293152,
-0.5109304785728455,
0.0987381637096405,
0.16595925390720367,
-0.2526562809944153,
-0.17931358516216278,
0.03184051439166069,
-0.15957298874855042,
0.39881569147109985,
-0.42817243933677673,
0.38335078954696655,
-0.325695663690567,
0.03282070904970169,
0.6188327074050903,
0.29917868971824646,
-0.08558274060487747,
0.07690414041280746,
-0.182019904255867,
-0.03807919844985008,
-0.767869770526886,
-0.2739470303058624,
0.4082055985927582,
0.5401338934898376,
-0.05024711415171623,
0.4623868763446808,
-0.42750588059425354,
0.4871601462364197,
0.15875838696956635,
-0.03346450254321098,
0.22674573957920074,
-0.21212464570999146,
-0.3533940017223358,
0.05916741490364075,
0.7805255055427551,
0.2836648225784302,
0.42389175295829773,
0.24676643311977386,
-0.2934228181838989,
-0.22764375805854797,
0.040727145969867706,
-0.49460816383361816,
-0.655552089214325,
0.12787337601184845,
-0.2851963937282562,
-0.0909971222281456,
-0.39613112807273865,
-0.5229847431182861,
-0.5859861969947815,
-0.3675912916660309,
0.2365194410085678,
-0.17903783917427063,
-0.49170008301734924,
0.29734307527542114,
-0.010641990229487419,
-0.3931942284107208,
0.163606196641922,
-1.4919447898864746,
0.2555990219116211,
0.6609057784080505,
0.9134435057640076,
-0.12522564828395844,
-0.3230436444282532,
-0.31445997953414917,
0.4430905878543854,
-0.29745861887931824,
0.9204003214836121,
-0.31387859582901,
-0.13185976445674896,
-0.24789908528327942,
-0.23247084021568298,
-0.10581382364034653,
-0.904241681098938,
0.374979704618454,
-0.2313844859600067,
-0.2741035223007202,
-0.22034424543380737,
-0.667300820350647,
0.35172075033187866,
0.08692599087953568,
-0.6441802382469177,
1.237735629081726,
-0.1598607897758484,
-0.6629960536956787,
0.27045536041259766,
-0.26564377546310425,
-0.26307666301727295,
-0.051481444388628006,
-0.10658620297908783,
-0.4773477613925934,
0.39091458916664124,
0.30518147349357605,
0.6236879825592041,
-0.39421144127845764,
0.33991745114326477,
-0.5944828987121582,
-0.32383495569229126,
-0.24097198247909546,
-0.7662389278411865,
0.47396376729011536,
0.37927183508872986,
-0.1537586748600006,
-0.3021572530269623,
-0.745924174785614,
-0.3067529797554016,
0.1899643838405609,
-0.1813645362854004,
-0.7666805386543274,
0.2570949196815491,
-0.3346947431564331,
0.032611243426799774,
0.3670198619365692,
-0.2736397385597229,
0.4153001010417938,
-0.44281208515167236,
0.5763450860977173,
0.93952476978302,
-0.016287334263324738,
0.5883690714836121,
-0.10700732469558716,
0.1795448213815689,
0.25793254375457764,
0.1600216031074524,
-0.30155274271965027,
-0.1676540970802307,
-0.8201614022254944,
-0.28359636664390564,
0.227718785405159,
0.4143545925617218,
-0.532306432723999,
0.5260058045387268,
-0.055054135620594025,
-0.4716589152812958,
-0.728102445602417,
0.6396265029907227,
0.07864132523536682,
0.48047661781311035,
0.24180909991264343,
-0.013370069675147533,
-0.26093751192092896,
-0.8751603364944458,
-0.03218412399291992,
-0.1693476438522339,
-0.039002660661935806,
-0.04971269890666008,
0.15119443833827972,
-0.3079119324684143,
0.9886592030525208,
-0.8084845542907715,
-0.7400439381599426,
-0.339992493391037,
0.20401132106781006,
0.37522104382514954,
0.486637681722641,
0.45566296577453613,
-0.3325651288032532,
-0.5277315378189087,
-0.19794416427612305,
-0.4256214499473572,
-0.4596436619758606,
-0.1782888025045395,
-0.06216506287455559,
0.2880443334579468,
0.6462505459785461,
-0.43289580941200256,
0.23721322417259216,
0.8000628352165222,
-0.1963055580854416,
0.26824015378952026,
-0.6755194664001465,
-0.16052871942520142,
-1.1304699182510376,
-0.37980711460113525,
-0.0058819446712732315,
-0.1505451798439026,
-0.42906084656715393,
-0.4269862473011017,
0.17260584235191345,
0.320415735244751,
-0.07652421295642853,
0.42635270953178406,
-0.4735989272594452,
0.37869128584861755,
-0.5785256624221802,
0.11744324862957001,
-0.12297310680150986,
0.18220354616641998,
-0.25890761613845825,
0.7320361137390137,
0.6243532299995422,
-0.6649973392486572,
0.06382463127374649,
0.13863663375377655,
-0.20634903013706207,
0.5213909149169922,
-0.6190614700317383,
-0.08671171963214874,
-0.2643163204193115,
0.03804829716682434,
-1.2842156887054443,
0.06366103887557983,
0.10974379628896713,
0.06055217608809471,
0.43100056052207947,
-0.20981444418430328,
-0.507597029209137,
-0.23769257962703705,
-0.05676029250025749,
0.15121158957481384,
0.501488208770752,
-0.5695956349372864,
0.24495434761047363,
0.35538020730018616,
-0.3404565751552582,
-0.5803802013397217,
-0.7304485440254211,
0.024322057142853737,
-0.42833030223846436,
-0.4043015241622925,
0.1413707137107849,
-0.1269601434469223,
0.0018756642239168286,
-0.2631964385509491,
-0.4005777835845947,
-0.1366111785173416,
0.28797397017478943,
0.05044066905975342,
0.035602979362010956,
0.020380424335598946,
0.35772281885147095,
0.47497594356536865,
-0.29590490460395813,
-0.09257526695728302,
-0.13308881223201752,
0.4708596169948578,
0.22999092936515808,
-0.45114532113075256,
-0.32712021470069885,
0.13336019217967987,
0.2832346558570862,
0.02527567930519581,
0.8165358304977417,
0.25902512669563293,
-0.059614408761262894,
-0.6874937415122986,
-0.7819983959197998,
-0.2874504625797272,
-0.6106491684913635,
0.26843082904815674,
-0.38226786255836487,
-1.0229030847549438,
0.457157164812088,
-0.3080834150314331,
0.004868142772465944,
0.3718762695789337,
0.45961812138557434,
-0.4932541251182556,
0.8429808616638184,
0.9869564771652222,
-0.3363928496837616,
0.5245286822319031,
-0.08205559104681015,
0.3810873329639435,
-0.5898960828781128,
0.1625974029302597,
-0.5260365605354309,
-0.37451615929603577,
-0.545546293258667,
-0.3696979284286499,
0.21625597774982452,
0.4733032286167145,
-0.22843949496746063,
0.23079237341880798,
-0.405708372592926,
0.8090699315071106,
0.5055092573165894,
-0.27979958057403564,
0.47381606698036194,
-0.001317652640864253,
-0.15284179151058197,
-0.06252119690179825,
-0.7221524119377136,
-0.5279873609542847,
0.8744240403175354,
0.4479779601097107,
1.1087538003921509,
-0.13652171194553375,
1.1469502449035645,
0.42316901683807373,
-0.10879531502723694,
-0.1415197253227234,
0.3660469353199005,
-0.45851683616638184,
-0.41806212067604065,
-0.5377466082572937,
-0.45638588070869446,
-0.9257416129112244,
0.1348143070936203,
0.10060541331768036,
-0.6260733604431152,
0.05394255369901657,
0.629467248916626,
-0.3249114155769348,
0.16639305651187897,
-0.8136243224143982,
0.9464753270149231,
0.0010539056966081262,
-0.030396992340683937,
-0.3860621750354767,
-0.4627365171909332,
0.3232736587524414,
-0.22957636415958405,
0.2617705464363098,
-0.8435551524162292,
0.12458129972219467,
0.2826659679412842,
-0.3269706964492798,
1.0531853437423706,
-0.14553570747375488,
-0.4009740352630615,
0.1406456083059311,
0.16032782196998596,
0.6569543480873108,
0.0735568180680275,
0.03249174356460571,
0.26537781953811646,
0.06243754178285599,
-0.3272610902786255,
-0.6281996369361877,
0.8755627274513245,
-0.5861542820930481,
-0.7790637016296387,
-0.29617056250572205,
-0.41904881596565247,
-0.17612700164318085,
0.06404707580804825,
0.10535724461078644,
-0.03604646027088165,
-0.11676263064146042,
0.09283336251974106,
0.8558120131492615,
0.07411490380764008,
0.618331789970398,
0.4931395351886749,
0.06350383162498474,
-0.16004949808120728,
0.8213232159614563,
0.18508771061897278,
0.5845934748649597,
0.25338640809059143,
0.21689705550670624,
-0.483386367559433,
-0.8405166268348694,
-0.418708473443985,
0.3180641233921051,
-0.6521841287612915,
-0.37016400694847107,
-0.5016077756881714,
-0.20018884539604187,
-0.3287910223007202,
0.041442446410655975,
-0.747453510761261,
-0.29366180300712585,
-0.5326991081237793,
-0.04279457777738571,
0.5908567905426025,
0.8220033645629883,
-0.21502503752708435,
0.41101783514022827,
-0.7386850118637085,
0.37610915303230286,
0.24368205666542053,
0.7076830863952637,
0.05285163223743439,
-0.6184981465339661,
-0.24467730522155762,
0.2530761659145355,
-0.42678678035736084,
-0.5214542746543884,
0.34637102484703064,
0.5229107141494751,
0.490947425365448,
0.21034479141235352,
0.30490824580192566,
1.0771716833114624,
-0.8413665890693665,
0.5686132311820984,
0.1877066195011139,
-0.7789900898933411,
0.526335597038269,
-0.3812881410121918,
0.5307642221450806,
0.7330782413482666,
0.03718358278274536,
-0.6256283521652222,
-0.8764246106147766,
-0.20942191779613495,
-0.9957906007766724,
0.6106290221214294,
0.2535250186920166,
0.4332258105278015,
-0.2560940086841583,
0.2814982831478119,
0.21406136453151703,
0.08797556161880493,
-0.41619873046875,
-0.4613627791404724,
0.03480964154005051,
-0.6005966067314148,
-0.3531564772129059,
-0.29601025581359863,
0.1533505618572235,
-0.18990637362003326,
0.5253199338912964,
-0.24572576582431793,
-0.11720824986696243,
-0.03386160731315613,
-0.008724975399672985,
-0.21322765946388245,
0.22939005494117737,
0.4051472544670105,
0.4380907118320465,
0.025151843205094337,
0.27952301502227783,
0.2845011055469513,
-0.5482637882232666,
0.23295706510543823,
0.14165623486042023,
0.02326189912855625,
-0.3075725734233856,
0.0492718331515789,
0.7834845185279846,
0.24523694813251495,
-0.6617751121520996,
0.176751971244812,
-0.029621224850416183,
-0.1067703440785408,
-0.09818383306264877,
0.5293265581130981,
0.48959073424339294,
0.5507753491401672,
0.5506172776222229,
-0.03855622187256813,
0.08868717402219772,
-0.33763590455055237,
0.14656153321266174,
0.37239325046539307,
0.004037929233163595,
-0.024730565026402473,
0.7480505108833313,
0.13476498425006866,
-0.1393572837114334,
0.7031617760658264,
-0.0707739070057869,
-0.04028160497546196,
0.44781237840652466,
0.5212306976318359,
0.908129870891571,
-0.36981257796287537,
0.18503837287425995,
0.17561639845371246,
0.3847366273403168,
-0.5243842601776123,
0.14121107757091522,
-0.17824019491672516,
-0.6078863739967346,
-0.35324349999427795,
-0.8545076847076416,
-0.050794847309589386,
-0.03874645009636879,
-0.3885480463504791,
0.2565746605396271,
-0.2731407582759857,
0.01645422913134098,
-0.06920010596513748,
-0.18923375010490417,
-0.5038477182388306,
-0.013407757505774498,
0.3451959490776062,
0.7565625309944153,
-1.0611062049865723,
1.1341661214828491,
0.01329203974455595,
-0.018059946596622467,
-0.5831947922706604,
0.1266569048166275,
-0.11053092032670975,
-0.6350946426391602,
0.3201996982097626,
-0.04362467676401138,
-0.015931157395243645,
0.05765305459499359,
-0.25975313782691956,
-1.229164481163025,
1.189624547958374,
0.6957173347473145,
-1.3116154670715332,
0.17508471012115479,
0.5014660954475403,
0.687791645526886,
-0.1622125655412674,
-0.1331312507390976,
0.9992788434028625,
0.038208525627851486,
0.3001995384693146,
-1.1579729318618774,
-0.14737267792224884,
0.03797450661659241,
0.23805785179138184,
0.6616421341896057,
-0.6549379825592041,
0.5541203022003174,
-0.15863825380802155,
-0.07595103234052658,
-0.09836466610431671,
0.6879177093505859,
0.4059563875198364,
0.2747511565685272,
0.5446598529815674,
0.6783822774887085,
0.8607631921768188,
-0.056860629469156265,
0.47663629055023193,
-0.0410224050283432,
0.48965010046958923,
1.587803840637207,
-0.4445025622844696,
0.9201636910438538,
0.5846757292747498,
-0.1739375740289688,
0.1630879044532776,
0.473000705242157,
0.10049980878829956,
0.9155046343803406,
0.10595414787530899,
-0.13356466591358185,
-0.16337193548679352,
0.22237424552440643,
-0.22067928314208984,
0.2094142735004425,
0.38109859824180603,
-0.22712954878807068,
-0.5451472401618958,
0.08423726260662079,
-0.22427088022232056,
0.2349555790424347,
-0.27328675985336304,
0.8799697160720825,
0.16217979788780212,
-0.5596222877502441,
0.9069107174873352,
-0.24648882448673248,
0.656897246837616,
-0.5766575336456299,
0.025272957980632782,
-0.41498494148254395,
0.46007806062698364,
0.1431117057800293,
-0.9362859129905701,
0.6552825570106506,
-0.04706098139286041,
-0.2622984051704407,
-0.5023831725120544,
0.5912514328956604,
-0.7553262114524841,
-0.31528687477111816,
0.32533398270606995,
0.3224751949310303,
-0.09398038685321808,
-0.0749494731426239,
-0.8256850242614746,
0.22368715703487396,
0.050162628293037415,
-0.29833316802978516,
0.47574129700660706,
0.7607468962669373,
-0.0015742849791422486,
0.9114490747451782,
0.3736664652824402,
-0.00441326666623354,
0.24061548709869385,
0.19302064180374146,
0.8454283475875854,
-0.5065977573394775,
-0.5892189741134644,
-1.2328394651412964,
0.3764374852180481,
0.08507329225540161,
-0.40442368388175964,
0.6577342748641968,
0.3779321014881134,
0.7164310812950134,
-0.0316968709230423,
0.6760278344154358,
0.10876167565584183,
0.5207024216651917,
-0.4053135812282562,
0.8786856532096863,
-0.5679489970207214,
0.482748806476593,
-0.17531423270702362,
-0.8627904653549194,
-0.16352325677871704,
0.42853590846061707,
-0.17317470908164978,
-0.18145309388637543,
0.43010836839675903,
0.8221600651741028,
-0.22433631122112274,
-0.216714009642601,
0.427924245595932,
0.2993285357952118,
0.27916035056114197,
0.5183186531066895,
0.6377789974212646,
-0.2593208849430084,
0.4271119236946106,
-0.251170814037323,
-0.09914572536945343,
-0.1282743513584137,
-1.108848214149475,
-1.0604798793792725,
-0.7170915007591248,
-0.3173574209213257,
0.050986602902412415,
0.18747590482234955,
0.9172544479370117,
0.6022264361381531,
-0.6923674941062927,
-0.2524154484272003,
-0.454723984003067,
0.047707583755254745,
-0.27907881140708923,
-0.1110396683216095,
0.13468442857265472,
-0.6464225053787231,
-0.6971250176429749,
0.2797850966453552,
0.5102602243423462,
0.3316196799278259,
-0.318745493888855,
-0.0009585877414792776,
-0.03917594254016876,
0.15815696120262146,
0.16308428347110748,
0.1101074367761612,
-0.6482938528060913,
-0.07414349168539047,
-0.2407265454530716,
-0.06919637322425842,
0.09375680983066559,
0.5402694940567017,
-0.6386142373085022,
0.38860583305358887,
0.28327396512031555,
0.5696384906768799,
0.5565236806869507,
-0.1519109606742859,
0.6418044567108154,
-1.0178438425064087,
0.12062502652406693,
0.01942056603729725,
0.23406122624874115,
0.3158924877643585,
-0.42395684123039246,
0.39487424492836,
-0.044163014739751816,
-0.7333279848098755,
-0.923202395439148,
0.1053244099020958,
-0.6663262248039246,
-0.35456180572509766,
0.9517434239387512,
0.10514981299638748,
-0.11238398402929306,
-0.1740555763244629,
-0.33753326535224915,
0.2053655982017517,
-0.3338466286659241,
1.3213765621185303,
0.8070178031921387,
0.16181550920009613,
-0.2785770893096924,
-0.45638614892959595,
0.6783769130706787,
0.3920198082923889,
-0.6130579113960266,
0.6904863119125366,
0.27319881319999695,
0.65887051820755,
-0.33924275636672974,
0.7754478454589844,
0.4591706395149231,
-0.08072871714830399,
-0.2981237471103668,
-0.17822381854057312,
0.04677700996398926,
-0.45831945538520813,
-0.46013790369033813,
-0.06572981923818588,
0.2165059596300125,
-0.14823628962039948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13667v1
|
GCOF: Self-iterative Text Generation for Copywriting Using Large Language Model
| 2024-02-21T09:59:20 | 2024-02-21T09:59:20 |
Jianghui Zhou, Ya Gao, Jie Liu, Xuemin Zhao, Zhaohua Yang, Yue Wu, Lirong Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models(LLM) such as ChatGPT have substantially simplified the
generation of marketing copy, yet producing content satisfying domain specific
requirements, such as effectively engaging customers, remains a significant
challenge. In this work, we introduce the Genetic Copy Optimization Framework
(GCOF) designed to enhance both efficiency and engagememnt of marketing copy
creation. We conduct explicit feature engineering within the prompts of LLM.
Additionally, we modify the crossover operator in Genetic Algorithm (GA),
integrating it into the GCOF to enable automatic feature engineering. This
integration facilitates a self-iterative refinement of the marketing copy.
Compared to human curated copy, Online results indicate that copy produced by
our framework achieves an average increase in click-through rate (CTR) of over
$50\%$.
|
[
-0.12880903482437134,
-0.5999777317047119,
0.2985692024230957,
0.423114150762558,
-0.2820267975330353,
0.3765881061553955,
-0.0841328501701355,
-0.33241280913352966,
0.33351683616638184,
0.7321686148643494,
-0.9177969098091125,
-0.43522652983665466,
-0.26985442638397217,
0.19858846068382263,
-0.5127460360527039,
1.1141471862792969,
-0.07820499688386917,
-0.2745274305343628,
-0.3310379087924957,
0.14874260127544403,
0.11148758232593536,
-0.7291118502616882,
-0.7195120453834534,
-0.12168919295072556,
0.18311886489391327,
0.6532336473464966,
0.4938788115978241,
0.858132541179657,
0.3127453029155731,
0.2815067768096924,
0.06391426920890808,
0.14966543018817902,
-1.0273975133895874,
0.0913812518119812,
-0.07808469980955124,
-0.006150310393422842,
-0.43097350001335144,
-0.07058495283126831,
0.4662080705165863,
0.35980501770973206,
-0.1716691553592682,
0.1673593670129776,
0.2748517096042633,
0.6543841361999512,
-0.3656209409236908,
0.04276525601744652,
-0.7931212782859802,
0.07589683681726456,
0.2915477156639099,
-0.5486993193626404,
-0.2552202045917511,
-0.5657292008399963,
0.10569410771131516,
-0.6685245633125305,
0.5611046552658081,
0.26060354709625244,
0.6154682040214539,
-0.06145275756716728,
-0.22713325917720795,
-0.8201634883880615,
-0.6148715019226074,
0.6196878552436829,
-0.725256621837616,
0.19875286519527435,
-0.002741413190960884,
-0.05940743535757065,
-0.3758731186389923,
-0.774630069732666,
-0.6856383085250854,
-0.5360350012779236,
0.11981039494276047,
0.048616036772727966,
-0.15427085757255554,
-0.19671602547168732,
0.04551493749022484,
0.7254247069358826,
-0.4733755588531494,
-0.16284260153770447,
-0.6606547832489014,
-0.03328912705183029,
0.8171514272689819,
0.18806353211402893,
0.5498493909835815,
-0.17022816836833954,
-0.3552508056163788,
-0.10791152715682983,
-0.5642305612564087,
-0.09932482987642288,
0.7237877249717712,
0.08323594927787781,
0.1652684509754181,
0.6770342588424683,
-0.2024003267288208,
0.028591694310307503,
0.30135148763656616,
0.037821728736162186,
0.22062255442142487,
-0.8194388747215271,
-0.16084928810596466,
0.054859377443790436,
0.9544824361801147,
0.2927456200122833,
0.42330998182296753,
-0.22767141461372375,
0.18019405007362366,
-0.33135363459587097,
0.5841976404190063,
-1.0216962099075317,
-0.1078018844127655,
-0.032044101506471634,
-0.3964724838733673,
-0.6334890723228455,
0.16138160228729248,
-0.7350199222564697,
0.06556547433137894,
-0.18814745545387268,
0.07531771808862686,
-0.46869829297065735,
-0.049011386930942535,
0.1505914181470871,
-0.11729048937559128,
0.013359006494283676,
-0.2646857500076294,
-1.000401258468628,
0.11683937907218933,
0.47397440671920776,
0.7254551649093628,
-0.556067705154419,
-0.37654417753219604,
-0.3230684697628021,
0.5723488330841064,
-0.18140527606010437,
0.5757341980934143,
-0.4731593728065491,
-0.8380842804908752,
-0.01128393691033125,
0.026036884635686874,
-0.07917816936969757,
-0.4273796081542969,
0.46491390466690063,
-0.5725123286247253,
0.278354674577713,
-0.1619711071252823,
-0.6574376225471497,
-0.293099045753479,
0.12713073194026947,
-0.6307504177093506,
0.9702315926551819,
0.4289206266403198,
-0.3715202808380127,
0.4315868318080902,
-0.5291513204574585,
-0.8083475232124329,
0.0884745642542839,
0.10632085800170898,
-0.7868224382400513,
-0.059585969895124435,
0.420012503862381,
0.328238308429718,
-0.140804722905159,
-0.005536828190088272,
-0.42299842834472656,
-0.13359852135181427,
0.21373876929283142,
-0.013179018162190914,
0.30127251148223877,
0.5769928097724915,
-0.6442646980285645,
0.123761847615242,
-0.7585940957069397,
0.11934468895196915,
0.3684125244617462,
-0.5412449836730957,
0.03732782229781151,
-0.16621056199073792,
0.23086437582969666,
0.16730864346027374,
0.04548463597893715,
-0.22207830846309662,
0.6893783807754517,
-0.10279501229524612,
0.5909659266471863,
0.335436075925827,
0.3139754831790924,
0.8015916347503662,
-0.25513991713523865,
1.0372438430786133,
-0.35071295499801636,
0.36743947863578796,
-0.05014169216156006,
-0.41759005188941956,
-0.6343681216239929,
-0.2883138656616211,
0.2548656761646271,
0.39824920892715454,
-0.64832603931427,
0.5140663981437683,
-0.18795189261436462,
-0.37236496806144714,
-0.4522847831249237,
0.8272585868835449,
0.11938542872667313,
0.25851279497146606,
0.19269351661205292,
-0.4843433201313019,
-0.28258195519447327,
-0.8054660558700562,
0.1259629875421524,
0.21387626230716705,
0.22425779700279236,
0.21401183307170868,
0.18126288056373596,
-0.4031773507595062,
0.8568524718284607,
-0.576153576374054,
-0.7176946401596069,
-0.7295215725898743,
0.2899443507194519,
0.11976641416549683,
0.2831118702888489,
0.7796410322189331,
-0.4284442961215973,
-0.7126531004905701,
0.1299552023410797,
-0.5374011397361755,
-0.49575573205947876,
-0.33798739314079285,
-0.20622125267982483,
0.5004820823669434,
0.6471904516220093,
-0.41353243589401245,
0.37563982605934143,
0.8730182647705078,
-0.1025371104478836,
0.1765296906232834,
-0.5866602063179016,
0.5170984864234924,
-1.0757513046264648,
0.13169820606708527,
0.04312983900308609,
-0.1234087124466896,
-0.24703125655651093,
0.1296573430299759,
-0.1819494515657425,
-0.35565420985221863,
-0.3220030665397644,
0.2640100419521332,
-0.7405069470405579,
-0.05323159322142601,
-0.4962206184864044,
0.028340181335806847,
-0.023035313934087753,
0.6251195669174194,
-0.12993274629116058,
1.0989543199539185,
0.1257687360048294,
-0.5143640637397766,
0.12078292667865753,
0.22664201259613037,
-0.3823607563972473,
0.3856152594089508,
-0.7123153805732727,
0.33242836594581604,
-0.11036984622478485,
0.1548420637845993,
-0.9101414680480957,
-0.15009747445583344,
0.604250431060791,
-0.17875158786773682,
0.17597617208957672,
-0.047475460916757584,
-0.25081032514572144,
-0.5793799757957458,
-0.25267061591148376,
0.21776767075061798,
0.7509958148002625,
-0.42002424597740173,
0.6548839807510376,
0.04061231017112732,
-0.5318049192428589,
-0.18719708919525146,
-0.4557335376739502,
0.2229277640581131,
-0.15772226452827454,
-0.8358028531074524,
0.27892306447029114,
-0.19903850555419922,
0.3899688720703125,
0.0023853222373872995,
0.23119832575321198,
0.2830299437046051,
-0.20753255486488342,
-0.04108058288693428,
-0.07087992876768112,
-0.0994637981057167,
-0.19470903277397156,
-0.11002659052610397,
-0.0895773395895958,
-0.06427381187677383,
-0.4961056411266327,
0.5988239049911499,
0.20027533173561096,
-0.32129746675491333,
-0.2722901999950409,
0.5473338961601257,
0.4720410108566284,
-0.14355258643627167,
0.32836422324180603,
0.380021870136261,
0.4033907651901245,
-0.8792285919189453,
-0.470459520816803,
-0.05714746564626694,
-0.5385511517524719,
0.5812851190567017,
-0.4049966633319855,
-1.0564478635787964,
0.3933239281177521,
0.13356806337833405,
-0.31483790278434753,
0.6139114499092102,
0.7354524731636047,
0.022888215258717537,
0.8725870251655579,
0.8963773250579834,
-0.14399677515029907,
0.5076413154602051,
-0.27860698103904724,
0.45895323157310486,
-0.4260583221912384,
-0.19574984908103943,
-0.4273582994937897,
-0.33158764243125916,
-0.6135616898536682,
-0.5651105046272278,
0.22360582649707794,
0.17818881571292877,
0.047885600477457047,
0.5368989706039429,
-0.7850381731987,
0.4850010573863983,
0.8811590671539307,
-0.025946233421564102,
0.4929163455963135,
0.36936962604522705,
0.03146125003695488,
0.005630196537822485,
-0.7863956689834595,
-0.2554056644439697,
0.9967609643936157,
0.2391195297241211,
1.0933082103729248,
-0.1394672840833664,
0.513893187046051,
0.30688467621803284,
0.2996625602245331,
-0.6359724998474121,
0.4673957824707031,
-0.37792450189590454,
-0.32966530323028564,
-0.17088904976844788,
-0.49709874391555786,
-0.8051846623420715,
-0.17143796384334564,
-0.31232506036758423,
-0.5720640420913696,
0.02364036813378334,
0.3065427839756012,
0.14917637407779694,
0.13499803841114044,
-0.6340635418891907,
0.7034915685653687,
-0.3927096128463745,
-0.22116082906723022,
-0.3916047215461731,
-0.12331385910511017,
0.37892213463783264,
-0.46484050154685974,
0.11161645501852036,
0.012691023759543896,
0.3482332229614258,
0.36656051874160767,
-0.5222042202949524,
0.5261315703392029,
0.33242663741111755,
-0.3221476674079895,
0.43612140417099,
0.22874264419078827,
0.7518022656440735,
-0.22133764624595642,
-0.10019507259130478,
-0.14619828760623932,
-0.29228171706199646,
-0.13377118110656738,
-0.5632134079933167,
0.5942014455795288,
-0.3096640110015869,
-0.5233380794525146,
0.062291450798511505,
-0.29171469807624817,
0.033059678971767426,
0.1528165489435196,
0.5596711039543152,
0.15101926028728485,
-0.33560508489608765,
0.3488773703575134,
0.40617361664772034,
-0.3037194013595581,
0.33127567172050476,
0.04193166643381119,
-0.2875828444957733,
-0.830807626247406,
1.0978597402572632,
-0.2707568407058716,
0.6019062995910645,
0.0718027800321579,
0.14273366332054138,
-0.4638513922691345,
-0.6936172246932983,
-0.4521726667881012,
0.2938828766345978,
-0.8457518219947815,
0.10007739812135696,
-0.948432445526123,
-0.42560017108917236,
-0.4343103766441345,
-0.5179587602615356,
-0.08286275714635849,
-0.16869930922985077,
-0.36923712491989136,
0.08221827447414398,
0.26492151618003845,
0.7837894558906555,
0.03434360772371292,
0.6614390015602112,
-0.7615852355957031,
0.4731872081756592,
0.45480629801750183,
0.28175580501556396,
-0.008498480543494225,
-0.3152514398097992,
-0.185409277677536,
0.06198807433247566,
-0.5219188332557678,
-0.5466901659965515,
0.41502389311790466,
0.22706006467342377,
0.8468416333198547,
-0.05197622627019882,
-0.3655107617378235,
0.27393198013305664,
-0.384308785200119,
0.6017857789993286,
0.34305107593536377,
-1.0783861875534058,
0.253152996301651,
-0.4583389461040497,
0.2915467321872711,
0.5802605748176575,
0.4544919431209564,
-0.44169333577156067,
-0.5940977334976196,
-0.6011449098587036,
-0.9156133532524109,
0.3735010623931885,
0.5004702806472778,
0.3987576961517334,
-0.19719474017620087,
0.30189695954322815,
0.13261470198631287,
0.1785486489534378,
-0.6591036915779114,
-0.1136784553527832,
-0.2088535726070404,
-0.5079776644706726,
-0.08976143598556519,
-0.472504585981369,
0.24131833016872406,
-0.11466912925243378,
0.8599100708961487,
-0.6036708950996399,
0.11561030894517899,
0.23810651898384094,
-0.13964489102363586,
-0.2137737274169922,
0.23418766260147095,
0.665741503238678,
0.8032436966896057,
-0.1496298611164093,
-0.5980340838432312,
0.04255588352680206,
-0.6567264795303345,
0.1201108917593956,
0.039998166263103485,
-0.35746046900749207,
-0.26330193877220154,
0.05784665420651436,
0.6682875752449036,
0.17051033675670624,
-0.2606198489665985,
0.5445957779884338,
0.0880354717373848,
-0.8074356317520142,
0.06147095561027527,
0.33606377243995667,
0.18757301568984985,
0.26774725317955017,
0.3630722761154175,
-0.5206772685050964,
0.3851378560066223,
-0.5566195845603943,
0.5410881042480469,
0.5426985025405884,
-0.17656680941581726,
0.09707155078649521,
1.032507061958313,
0.46429160237312317,
-0.22701267898082733,
0.7066061496734619,
-0.033400166779756546,
-0.7061008810997009,
0.6953819394111633,
0.6292091012001038,
1.314881682395935,
0.16696816682815552,
0.3981908857822418,
0.2649710476398468,
0.16634659469127655,
-0.08996693044900894,
0.06316552311182022,
-0.00023288992815651,
-0.48467254638671875,
-0.46762675046920776,
-0.6533390283584595,
-0.6607427000999451,
-0.09214387089014053,
-0.20549200475215912,
0.47631144523620605,
-0.44757136702537537,
-0.024301735684275627,
0.11048978567123413,
-0.24370458722114563,
-0.6370290517807007,
0.3156123459339142,
0.04183981567621231,
0.5752029418945312,
-0.2030278444290161,
0.6309255361557007,
0.3101825416088104,
-0.4552023112773895,
-0.7143374681472778,
-0.16653470695018768,
-0.12641945481300354,
-1.0134028196334839,
0.5692381858825684,
0.02160605601966381,
-0.3460916578769684,
0.19397543370723724,
-0.6288167834281921,
-0.7484557032585144,
0.9582589268684387,
0.11526578664779663,
-0.845533013343811,
-0.01974630169570446,
0.48517683148384094,
0.4324924945831299,
-0.9730338454246521,
0.07315339893102646,
0.6295705437660217,
0.14302198588848114,
0.8837613463401794,
-0.6479390263557434,
0.06403364986181259,
-0.27821019291877747,
0.1287061870098114,
0.09372129291296005,
-0.49292704463005066,
0.21139617264270782,
-0.4238851070404053,
-0.15375636518001556,
0.16403432190418243,
0.5030972957611084,
0.2360668033361435,
-0.1480841189622879,
0.2924996614456177,
0.5060590505599976,
0.4415819048881531,
0.27759626507759094,
1.1799758672714233,
-0.30138659477233887,
0.4563291072845459,
1.0510565042495728,
-0.25851550698280334,
0.5392254590988159,
0.25271642208099365,
0.132790207862854,
0.423579603433609,
0.363625705242157,
-0.5743119716644287,
0.6172580122947693,
0.58085036277771,
-0.08997734636068344,
0.005149506498128176,
0.26626476645469666,
-0.42289116978645325,
0.3911314308643341,
-0.22668510675430298,
-0.7906298637390137,
-0.07379116863012314,
-0.08782768994569778,
-0.011814928613603115,
-0.03462126478552818,
-0.08310418576002121,
1.0294781923294067,
-0.05046746879816055,
-0.5182089805603027,
0.412506103515625,
-0.032207101583480835,
0.6864765882492065,
-0.7273391485214233,
0.13821852207183838,
-0.4216515123844147,
0.2620278298854828,
0.14067409932613373,
-0.9018070101737976,
0.3830273151397705,
-0.23603686690330505,
-0.23424774408340454,
-0.5364790558815002,
0.827440083026886,
-0.6882823705673218,
-0.6126493215560913,
0.22821541130542755,
0.09890933334827423,
-0.07483163475990295,
-0.19154240190982819,
-0.7909299731254578,
0.11353562027215958,
0.3792354464530945,
-0.527229368686676,
0.017943082377314568,
0.38246068358421326,
0.06657188385725021,
0.7784836888313293,
0.8881081938743591,
0.18570572137832642,
0.05664093419909477,
0.24523963034152985,
0.6304493546485901,
-1.0035816431045532,
-0.6758076548576355,
-0.7002731561660767,
0.4884028732776642,
-0.24717655777931213,
-0.47431880235671997,
0.5311651229858398,
0.4684690833091736,
0.7199368476867676,
-0.3796079158782959,
1.1062792539596558,
0.08145702630281448,
0.11267688870429993,
-0.6277027726173401,
0.858417272567749,
-0.5995506048202515,
-0.0006200611242093146,
-0.42462223768234253,
-1.5489397048950195,
0.0663323625922203,
0.19701643288135529,
-0.10009608417749405,
0.09752554446458817,
0.7496659755706787,
0.7533320784568787,
0.025054210796952248,
0.15064413845539093,
0.1143556609749794,
-0.12068207561969757,
0.550772488117218,
0.5527859330177307,
0.6095479130744934,
-0.34836873412132263,
0.897560715675354,
-0.16615742444992065,
-0.08268453925848007,
-0.0836590826511383,
-1.3560165166854858,
-1.1708875894546509,
-0.29642918705940247,
-0.5403335690498352,
-0.439788281917572,
-0.11602939665317535,
0.9529309272766113,
0.6924384832382202,
-0.5881303548812866,
-0.20220434665679932,
-0.04369187355041504,
-0.2741699516773224,
-0.0630914717912674,
-0.25059500336647034,
0.14669281244277954,
-0.5823968052864075,
-0.8287273049354553,
0.05797889828681946,
0.5350639224052429,
0.37995803356170654,
-0.23284950852394104,
-0.025777066126465797,
0.08522139489650726,
0.2438051998615265,
0.5079181790351868,
0.34705284237861633,
-0.20306475460529327,
0.018978022038936615,
0.1256992071866989,
-0.3669070899486542,
0.1746976226568222,
1.025249719619751,
-0.1869104653596878,
0.2538113296031952,
0.3724975287914276,
1.0186001062393188,
0.890253484249115,
0.3379794955253601,
1.065934181213379,
-0.4976749122142792,
-0.0529463030397892,
-0.1071057841181755,
0.05816618725657463,
0.4384038746356964,
-0.589352011680603,
0.4834067225456238,
0.42056939005851746,
-0.5890011787414551,
-0.007964597083628178,
0.014840724878013134,
-1.209860920906067,
-0.3735067844390869,
1.4495697021484375,
0.41356298327445984,
-0.3361716568470001,
0.21111738681793213,
-0.5322450399398804,
-0.02317734993994236,
-0.31033894419670105,
0.8757813572883606,
0.6932992339134216,
0.2250141203403473,
-0.46589335799217224,
-0.16775569319725037,
0.7684944272041321,
0.23841090500354767,
-1.0416154861450195,
-0.16924729943275452,
0.4029689133167267,
0.5931238532066345,
-0.26201653480529785,
0.7362812757492065,
0.011692468076944351,
0.07849966734647751,
-0.1254575252532959,
0.21557506918907166,
-0.38944512605667114,
-0.0020372795406728983,
0.08304291218519211,
0.31092268228530884,
-0.06256385892629623,
0.09528587013483047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13659v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13659v2
|
Privacy-Preserving Instructions for Aligning Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T09:45:08 | 2024-07-02T11:57:07 |
Da Yu, Peter Kairouz, Sewoong Oh, Zheng Xu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Service providers of large language model (LLM) applications collect user
instructions in the wild and use them in further aligning LLMs with users'
intentions. These instructions, which potentially contain sensitive
information, are annotated by human workers in the process. This poses a new
privacy risk not addressed by the typical private optimization. To this end, we
propose using synthetic instructions to replace real instructions in data
annotation and model fine-tuning. Formal differential privacy is guaranteed by
generating those synthetic instructions using privately fine-tuned generators.
Crucial in achieving the desired utility is our novel filtering algorithm that
matches the distribution of the synthetic instructions to that of the real
ones. In both supervised fine-tuning and reinforcement learning from human
feedback, our extensive experiments demonstrate the high utility of the final
set of synthetic instructions by showing comparable results to real
instructions. In supervised fine-tuning, models trained with private synthetic
instructions outperform leading open-source models such as Vicuna.
|
[
-0.25814393162727356,
-0.6201617121696472,
0.7499608993530273,
0.23273535072803497,
-0.18598362803459167,
0.14915800094604492,
-0.45581701397895813,
-0.6110157370567322,
-0.12142764031887054,
0.9315063953399658,
-0.9411117434501648,
-0.7289332747459412,
-0.3109740912914276,
0.01384758111089468,
-0.27283143997192383,
1.0447170734405518,
0.021959086880087852,
0.09779369831085205,
0.09166182577610016,
0.00663123931735754,
-0.14909274876117706,
-0.4287510812282562,
-0.4883571267127991,
-0.24670106172561646,
0.4304840564727783,
0.4182482957839966,
0.8834443092346191,
1.136154055595398,
0.27185800671577454,
0.4079674184322357,
-0.037061553448438644,
0.6605666875839233,
-0.5766089558601379,
0.15863007307052612,
-0.38665422797203064,
-0.4337436854839325,
-0.47848424315452576,
0.05823890119791031,
0.7142809629440308,
0.5440967679023743,
-0.0522603914141655,
0.19655907154083252,
0.006581025198101997,
0.7086327075958252,
-0.7067188620567322,
0.18498311936855316,
-0.5741912722587585,
0.04852575063705444,
-0.03157934173941612,
-0.4386260509490967,
-0.5539277791976929,
-0.8935360908508301,
-0.07722029834985733,
-0.5441946983337402,
0.2875174283981323,
0.08433670550584793,
0.7293944358825684,
0.3171400725841522,
-0.029552748426795006,
0.1327839344739914,
-1.0854233503341675,
0.9023905396461487,
-0.6492054462432861,
0.25569334626197815,
0.5542361736297607,
0.3828796446323395,
-0.4729623794555664,
-0.317773699760437,
-0.3656834363937378,
-0.31997203826904297,
-0.23248609900474548,
-0.1747264266014099,
0.08666553348302841,
0.3339490294456482,
0.30766382813453674,
0.3963035047054291,
-0.3762335181236267,
0.5738478899002075,
-0.4807296097278595,
-0.41983136534690857,
1.1558594703674316,
0.25565409660339355,
0.09976473450660706,
0.3289813995361328,
-0.19589963555335999,
0.006512343417853117,
-0.9422668218612671,
-0.2920204997062683,
0.7378036379814148,
0.3952068090438843,
-0.21229979395866394,
0.641976535320282,
-0.5926501750946045,
0.7359184622764587,
0.2605352997779846,
0.04286636412143707,
0.013143032789230347,
-0.09355664998292923,
-0.28065887093544006,
0.31496763229370117,
0.8460813760757446,
0.2800896167755127,
0.5174145102500916,
-0.29550591111183167,
-0.29289063811302185,
0.06549572944641113,
0.2501436173915863,
-0.5408457517623901,
-0.2323678433895111,
0.04191725328564644,
-0.25632232427597046,
-0.41448327898979187,
0.0527917854487896,
-0.694652259349823,
-0.5995665192604065,
-0.7895525693893433,
0.2145497351884842,
-0.03259957581758499,
0.1375611424446106,
0.18212896585464478,
0.2800126373767853,
0.14952050149440765,
0.2073199599981308,
-1.2740143537521362,
0.5305730700492859,
1.1111382246017456,
0.46112149953842163,
0.12056787312030792,
-0.14770664274692535,
-0.7581433057785034,
0.4087822139263153,
-0.3726039230823517,
0.2695173919200897,
-0.6420524716377258,
-0.3101819157600403,
0.16204100847244263,
0.2948762774467468,
0.42217254638671875,
-0.4153156578540802,
0.3442552983760834,
-0.5737173557281494,
0.3269524872303009,
0.04148707911372185,
-0.5897660255432129,
0.0007401315378956497,
-0.036608412861824036,
-0.5503782033920288,
0.6265791058540344,
0.078951895236969,
-0.3974221646785736,
-0.03183675929903984,
-0.6970674991607666,
-0.3652592599391937,
0.01608530804514885,
-0.17859910428524017,
-0.5146663188934326,
0.2525319755077362,
0.24248482286930084,
0.46860238909721375,
-0.12723353505134583,
0.04020335525274277,
-0.40193748474121094,
-0.47385120391845703,
0.36323583126068115,
-0.3742589056491852,
0.8038317561149597,
0.28672534227371216,
-0.3892945349216461,
0.40248289704322815,
-0.8557484745979309,
-0.04193534702062607,
-0.1249995157122612,
-0.24934376776218414,
-0.36638811230659485,
-0.18603095412254333,
-0.2760874629020691,
-0.08836135268211365,
0.48350152373313904,
-0.6050922870635986,
0.1780712604522705,
-0.6571346521377563,
0.5084319114685059,
1.18661367893219,
0.08918783813714981,
0.7442263960838318,
-0.22385011613368988,
0.5336171388626099,
-0.35256415605545044,
0.568386971950531,
-0.05376188084483147,
-0.4772295653820038,
-0.44019973278045654,
-0.41095244884490967,
0.3682260513305664,
0.4406583905220032,
-0.015926595777273178,
0.6924667954444885,
-0.29410526156425476,
-0.37459492683410645,
-0.7617121934890747,
0.24514158070087433,
0.6546745300292969,
0.21183356642723083,
0.18593105673789978,
0.06099691987037659,
-0.6565542221069336,
-1.1479073762893677,
-0.40259939432144165,
0.1724090278148651,
-0.014799080789089203,
0.22860172390937805,
-0.015892205759882927,
-0.5341054797172546,
0.726106584072113,
-0.5430716872215271,
-0.1145695373415947,
0.36398932337760925,
-0.026217756792902946,
-0.146719828248024,
0.8313438892364502,
0.07030978053808212,
-0.6011379957199097,
-0.49509379267692566,
0.21162405610084534,
-0.5511011481285095,
-0.3673917055130005,
-0.09096696227788925,
-0.38058018684387207,
0.31709861755371094,
0.5069061517715454,
-0.4832134246826172,
0.2124486267566681,
0.8237403631210327,
-0.020824206992983818,
0.2548016309738159,
-0.6087982654571533,
-0.09027020633220673,
-1.0038142204284668,
-0.2411428689956665,
-0.03359939903020859,
-0.6767792701721191,
-0.35257211327552795,
0.21082523465156555,
0.023040656000375748,
-0.37581944465637207,
-0.3586156964302063,
0.7095820903778076,
-0.6776185631752014,
0.03132445737719536,
-0.23366186022758484,
-0.0096973842009902,
-0.03586690127849579,
0.4063062369823456,
-0.05864006280899048,
0.7227203845977783,
0.4738593101501465,
-0.6298041343688965,
0.23897485435009003,
0.18932104110717773,
-0.15373709797859192,
0.13129445910453796,
-0.40769490599632263,
0.6015507578849792,
-0.04485151544213295,
0.027513202279806137,
-0.7918301224708557,
-0.46515953540802,
0.30946487188339233,
-0.1228112280368805,
0.499772310256958,
-0.29287514090538025,
-0.4713248610496521,
0.13850723206996918,
-0.42774319648742676,
-0.038233157247304916,
0.7881457805633545,
-0.6810168027877808,
0.6231516599655151,
0.578561007976532,
0.053654227405786514,
-0.5770684480667114,
-0.6952230334281921,
-0.08996004611253738,
-0.10878992080688477,
-0.485378235578537,
0.5476993322372437,
0.14011353254318237,
-0.16471318900585175,
0.11115904152393341,
-0.1735469400882721,
-0.07943706214427948,
0.2060711681842804,
0.6112462878227234,
0.36436182260513306,
0.10695871710777283,
-0.20852327346801758,
0.3799803853034973,
-0.3255418837070465,
0.0460464209318161,
-0.41268306970596313,
0.39792585372924805,
0.18402796983718872,
-0.23693197965621948,
-0.8059027791023254,
0.3694292902946472,
0.41105005145072937,
-0.2955990433692932,
0.932988703250885,
0.5288801789283752,
-0.4691771864891052,
-0.37429478764533997,
-0.540981113910675,
-0.4387979507446289,
-0.5884426832199097,
0.05831926316022873,
-0.14226903021335602,
-1.1117740869522095,
0.4176207482814789,
-0.1639678031206131,
0.21937911212444305,
0.029181772843003273,
0.5209361910820007,
0.07713834941387177,
1.418819546699524,
0.7628995776176453,
-0.06926053762435913,
0.5396823287010193,
-0.1295921951532364,
0.32510051131248474,
-0.7041782140731812,
-0.05695326626300812,
-0.440423846244812,
-0.39387837052345276,
-1.1659035682678223,
-0.0739855244755745,
0.19556406140327454,
-0.08150757849216461,
-0.2385074496269226,
0.3279772400856018,
-0.8246874809265137,
0.8590617179870605,
0.5877678990364075,
0.3686011731624603,
0.15787605941295624,
0.07901304960250854,
0.2647266089916229,
0.06526677310466766,
-0.18355350196361542,
-0.7535203099250793,
0.9641323685646057,
0.3703451156616211,
1.0462945699691772,
-0.026415370404720306,
1.1902505159378052,
0.1648050993680954,
0.31898942589759827,
-0.3892982304096222,
0.768710196018219,
-0.44351139664649963,
-0.5653215050697327,
-0.3578173518180847,
-0.6012465953826904,
-0.7528629302978516,
-0.14773957431316376,
-0.22205212712287903,
-1.0087478160858154,
0.012533486820757389,
0.44511178135871887,
-0.6083470582962036,
-0.12405234575271606,
-0.9563539624214172,
0.7039660215377808,
-0.07120046764612198,
-0.640321671962738,
-0.32068467140197754,
-0.5347232222557068,
0.5367915630340576,
-0.16127023100852966,
0.1365015208721161,
-0.12942902743816376,
0.06883111596107483,
0.3458443582057953,
-0.4606577157974243,
1.0552153587341309,
-0.4041810929775238,
-0.22283785045146942,
-0.16100892424583435,
0.18550753593444824,
0.8385927677154541,
0.1849256306886673,
0.009501684457063675,
0.06519373506307602,
0.009536105208098888,
-0.1259319931268692,
-0.6660892963409424,
1.1593304872512817,
-0.7298139333724976,
-0.8911758065223694,
-0.11056593060493469,
-0.511184573173523,
-0.178191676735878,
0.0726490393280983,
0.0029071506578475237,
0.09108132869005203,
0.07403084635734558,
0.12337937951087952,
0.759348452091217,
-0.3611970543861389,
0.0035000930074602365,
0.6589759588241577,
-0.21161051094532013,
-0.32788366079330444,
0.7476141452789307,
-0.0684913769364357,
0.24735388159751892,
0.5011734366416931,
0.48462381958961487,
-0.5631235837936401,
-0.5077381134033203,
-0.25271081924438477,
0.35669106245040894,
-0.5052327513694763,
-0.23017270863056183,
-0.3877335786819458,
-0.2454281896352768,
-0.35222718119621277,
-0.1351659893989563,
-0.4190102815628052,
-0.5835533142089844,
-0.13907010853290558,
-0.26720038056373596,
0.5051341652870178,
0.46854719519615173,
-0.2917124927043915,
0.3397732675075531,
-0.9245767593383789,
0.44197070598602295,
0.3678668737411499,
0.4787786304950714,
-0.4252986013889313,
-0.2567344009876251,
-0.22071175277233124,
0.3931955397129059,
0.007917644456028938,
-0.594555675983429,
0.25398045778274536,
0.1794663816690445,
0.344300240278244,
0.186101034283638,
0.23164434731006622,
0.7214377522468567,
-0.6644624471664429,
0.5559413433074951,
-0.25182703137397766,
-1.0149226188659668,
0.43842774629592896,
-0.16443219780921936,
0.0817914605140686,
0.4836569130420685,
0.23111166059970856,
-0.21342968940734863,
-0.49354279041290283,
-0.36183813214302063,
-0.6099429130554199,
0.8566263318061829,
-0.0027706297114491463,
0.562426745891571,
0.2991638481616974,
0.64857417345047,
0.17445628345012665,
0.007214880548417568,
-0.37382447719573975,
-0.09991491585969925,
0.2507995665073395,
-0.48811912536621094,
0.03340506926178932,
-0.27553561329841614,
-0.5592784881591797,
-0.17698432505130768,
0.7268014550209045,
0.09397962689399719,
0.1270289272069931,
-0.16912533342838287,
0.21892695128917694,
-0.40746068954467773,
0.16259293258190155,
0.7567211389541626,
0.5141891837120056,
-0.07625381648540497,
0.11717765033245087,
-0.05912013351917267,
-0.2692546248435974,
0.16398517787456512,
0.2673337161540985,
-0.43712711334228516,
-0.1852303147315979,
-0.043757375329732895,
0.7427350878715515,
0.19484469294548035,
-0.47968214750289917,
0.13967572152614594,
-0.08541245758533478,
-0.05476910248398781,
-0.5506250262260437,
0.6208745241165161,
0.07707546651363373,
0.1703643649816513,
-0.23593302071094513,
0.03520803153514862,
0.08932705223560333,
-0.5333309173583984,
0.07909449189901352,
0.5086376070976257,
-0.21908150613307953,
-0.4154791235923767,
0.8643702864646912,
0.0849456712603569,
-0.6888269186019897,
0.3912316560745239,
-0.19228775799274445,
-0.3627094030380249,
0.08825613558292389,
0.3748416304588318,
1.0415315628051758,
-0.4504178762435913,
0.22884060442447662,
0.06744290888309479,
0.09287973493337631,
-0.2846895456314087,
0.34388044476509094,
-0.18839889764785767,
-0.5460083484649658,
-0.5467376112937927,
-0.7194997072219849,
-0.36330950260162354,
0.1801689714193344,
-0.4843403100967407,
0.230158731341362,
-0.931952178478241,
0.06624075770378113,
0.2748717963695526,
-0.12232144176959991,
-0.4223583936691284,
0.12567134201526642,
0.28038710355758667,
0.5028805732727051,
-0.6382057666778564,
1.007017970085144,
0.398583322763443,
-0.21548782289028168,
-0.9396511912345886,
-0.10374799370765686,
0.0901670977473259,
-0.8033789396286011,
0.4958980977535248,
0.09228894114494324,
-0.2977738678455353,
0.05289936065673828,
-0.7249037623405457,
-0.5555773973464966,
0.6852129101753235,
0.8261992931365967,
-0.9906641244888306,
0.07087212800979614,
0.3652426302433014,
0.7219160795211792,
-0.24431760609149933,
-0.4012613892555237,
0.4678661525249481,
0.5106296539306641,
-0.2328459769487381,
-0.7260435819625854,
0.3178003430366516,
0.09643200784921646,
0.1371402144432068,
0.3171458840370178,
-0.4418143928050995,
0.518764317035675,
0.04241807013750076,
-0.3152889609336853,
0.2040649652481079,
0.32430145144462585,
0.2893252670764923,
0.021437400951981544,
0.264616459608078,
0.3231039047241211,
0.7918449640274048,
0.023707518354058266,
1.1070913076400757,
-0.5354549288749695,
0.22688031196594238,
1.2266676425933838,
-0.4032728374004364,
0.41704636812210083,
0.3768439292907715,
0.12737414240837097,
0.326061487197876,
0.5283893346786499,
0.05215207487344742,
0.6850094795227051,
0.3759145736694336,
-0.39043834805488586,
-0.1241879090666771,
-0.042544398456811905,
-0.13820244371891022,
0.36954614520072937,
0.10580479353666306,
-0.6596143841743469,
0.06592942029237747,
-0.3554016053676605,
-0.050880320370197296,
0.48822057247161865,
-0.26330336928367615,
0.9688085913658142,
0.14448736608028412,
-0.6459266543388367,
0.7438782453536987,
0.31956925988197327,
0.3333186209201813,
-0.6102021932601929,
-0.16217851638793945,
-0.0809309333562851,
0.5568159818649292,
-0.48618149757385254,
-0.5254189968109131,
0.45280274748802185,
0.08195026963949203,
-0.15486058592796326,
-0.36736682057380676,
0.456089586019516,
-0.662341296672821,
-0.347658634185791,
0.13771097362041473,
-0.10523422062397003,
0.05908110365271568,
-0.03282713145017624,
-0.5432280898094177,
0.04660320654511452,
0.05856887996196747,
-0.15209993720054626,
0.44547736644744873,
0.4577496647834778,
-0.3352504074573517,
0.5254656076431274,
0.842986524105072,
0.3250042200088501,
0.3258129954338074,
0.25400039553642273,
0.797527015209198,
-0.5360435843467712,
-0.556900680065155,
-1.0960159301757812,
0.3972429633140564,
-0.1966738998889923,
-0.049445364624261856,
0.7672654390335083,
0.5146000385284424,
1.0294607877731323,
-0.2975492477416992,
0.642531156539917,
0.4802258014678955,
0.4041483700275421,
-0.7869354486465454,
0.6571446061134338,
-0.1750372350215912,
0.47147202491760254,
0.14639635384082794,
-1.1287868022918701,
-0.37327322363853455,
0.5392885804176331,
-0.3584400713443756,
-0.20338074862957,
0.22881506383419037,
1.296582818031311,
-0.26688775420188904,
0.12170098721981049,
0.16410519182682037,
0.06503479927778244,
0.3797250986099243,
0.26303669810295105,
0.7749622464179993,
-0.21594353020191193,
0.11493339389562607,
-0.6923953890800476,
-0.14717617630958557,
-0.020713476464152336,
-0.8805946707725525,
-0.7992410659790039,
-0.3991808295249939,
-0.4788963496685028,
-0.23275631666183472,
0.23692895472049713,
1.082911729812622,
1.0420818328857422,
-0.8606125712394714,
-0.0677647739648819,
-0.3163816034793854,
-0.0826902836561203,
-0.24776819348335266,
-0.13978983461856842,
0.15596619248390198,
-0.22447144985198975,
-0.8540679216384888,
0.5743137001991272,
0.3211584985256195,
0.1230592206120491,
-0.6920607686042786,
-0.32142531871795654,
0.177618145942688,
0.12827393412590027,
0.2537296712398529,
0.29017001390457153,
-0.6972339749336243,
-0.48037195205688477,
-0.1574411690235138,
-0.13905709981918335,
-0.17252779006958008,
0.7292261123657227,
-0.3452320694923401,
0.41210007667541504,
0.4360542893409729,
0.7197411060333252,
0.5891271233558655,
0.256069540977478,
0.8006619811058044,
-1.0820380449295044,
0.2959705889225006,
0.17320656776428223,
0.21140025556087494,
0.5461271405220032,
-0.7616435885429382,
0.4311341941356659,
-0.35101887583732605,
-0.6467293500900269,
-1.0071696043014526,
0.3975065350532532,
-0.9083259105682373,
-0.021783551201224327,
1.1089891195297241,
-0.4014400839805603,
-0.5865009427070618,
0.10760460793972015,
-0.2806500792503357,
0.35537850856781006,
-0.4644910991191864,
1.1071205139160156,
0.24725104868412018,
0.07001089304685593,
-0.20199677348136902,
-0.21736495196819305,
0.790627658367157,
0.09750066697597504,
-0.6050642728805542,
0.522259533405304,
0.5894609689712524,
0.20097394287586212,
0.09755469858646393,
0.2755313515663147,
-0.3064386248588562,
-0.009150411002337933,
-0.4162974953651428,
-0.1660318672657013,
-0.4596099257469177,
-0.2949487864971161,
-0.620220959186554,
-0.1366194635629654,
0.07633963972330093,
-0.4572582244873047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13647v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13647v1
|
Unsupervised Text Style Transfer via LLMs and Attention Masking with Multi-way Interactions
| 2024-02-21T09:28:02 | 2024-02-21T09:28:02 |
Lei Pan, Yunshi Lan, Yang Li, Weining Qian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Unsupervised Text Style Transfer (UTST) has emerged as a critical task within
the domain of Natural Language Processing (NLP), aiming to transfer one
stylistic aspect of a sentence into another style without changing its
semantics, syntax, or other attributes. This task is especially challenging
given the intrinsic lack of parallel text pairings. Among existing methods for
UTST tasks, attention masking approach and Large Language Models (LLMs) are
deemed as two pioneering methods. However, they have shortcomings in generating
unsmooth sentences and changing the original contents, respectively. In this
paper, we investigate if we can combine these two methods effectively. We
propose four ways of interactions, that are pipeline framework with tuned
orders; knowledge distillation from LLMs to attention masking model; in-context
learning with constructed parallel examples. We empirically show these
multi-way interactions can improve the baselines in certain perspective of
style strength, content preservation and text fluency. Experiments also
demonstrate that simply conducting prompting followed by attention
masking-based revision can consistently surpass the other systems, including
supervised text style transfer systems. On Yelp-clean and Amazon-clean
datasets, it improves the previously best mean metric by 0.5 and 3.0 absolute
percentages respectively, and achieves new SOTA results.
|
[
-0.2911447286605835,
-0.7499930262565613,
0.6126806139945984,
0.3829876780509949,
-0.4504527151584625,
0.26455000042915344,
-0.45902782678604126,
-0.488082617521286,
0.3394731283187866,
0.7639267444610596,
-0.5445071458816528,
-0.32042548060417175,
-0.4429735243320465,
0.22441723942756653,
-0.3337608575820923,
1.124849557876587,
-0.1956893503665924,
-0.18725866079330444,
-0.16630323231220245,
-0.19730079174041748,
-0.47390058636665344,
-0.8374634385108948,
-0.5046148896217346,
-0.10785297304391861,
0.2195836752653122,
0.23906807601451874,
0.24028146266937256,
0.29807811975479126,
0.6553652286529541,
0.3443942368030548,
-0.0013040400808677077,
0.3977258801460266,
-0.4212583899497986,
0.30218976736068726,
-0.29749950766563416,
-0.12436813861131668,
-0.16630524396896362,
-0.030423404648900032,
0.5837350487709045,
0.5296653509140015,
0.08737024664878845,
0.014315130189061165,
0.5216725468635559,
0.9036616086959839,
-0.537147581577301,
0.11315883696079254,
-0.5289674997329712,
-0.05922389775514603,
-0.24193088710308075,
-0.4536080062389374,
-0.4016832411289215,
0.06880714744329453,
0.14339618384838104,
-0.3707740902900696,
-0.1486010104417801,
0.06518878042697906,
0.41066494584083557,
0.2560824751853943,
-0.5262741446495056,
-0.041135549545288086,
-0.7681418657302856,
0.8696172833442688,
-0.7023241519927979,
0.33794966340065,
0.18025796115398407,
-0.03164549171924591,
-0.22439759969711304,
-0.8682897090911865,
-0.5562635064125061,
0.20927388966083527,
-0.24223019182682037,
0.3380381762981415,
-0.1981583684682846,
-0.025039464235305786,
0.18699216842651367,
0.19878561794757843,
-0.15201826393604279,
0.05111285671591759,
-0.22558453679084778,
-0.11033995449542999,
0.596285343170166,
0.0246589258313179,
0.09788147360086441,
-0.35248425602912903,
-0.778520941734314,
-0.2115703672170639,
-0.6583550572395325,
0.1301112025976181,
0.12562644481658936,
0.23679251968860626,
0.06759824603796005,
0.42819616198539734,
-0.3253994286060333,
0.45583847165107727,
-0.0875779241323471,
-0.1992889940738678,
-0.02800147235393524,
-0.7521079778671265,
-0.39427706599235535,
-0.13097821176052094,
0.923923134803772,
0.6513844728469849,
0.165029376745224,
-0.31001630425453186,
-0.07988591492176056,
0.023680632933974266,
0.20637904107570648,
-0.5891339778900146,
-0.040213316679000854,
0.03692726418375969,
-0.28539612889289856,
-0.2686680257320404,
0.16005687415599823,
-1.2422096729278564,
-0.3734917640686035,
-0.7989840507507324,
0.5486041307449341,
-0.22966542840003967,
0.007918641902506351,
0.2439076155424118,
0.07400055229663849,
0.07852056622505188,
0.41327616572380066,
-0.869519829750061,
0.2308569848537445,
0.3271901607513428,
0.7316705584526062,
-0.44933730363845825,
-0.2496659904718399,
-0.3900567889213562,
0.30955788493156433,
-0.11971281468868256,
0.8400881290435791,
-0.3131425976753235,
0.02826438844203949,
0.020009271800518036,
-0.05028608441352844,
-0.2342325896024704,
-0.1660044640302658,
0.4681433439254761,
-0.4225904941558838,
0.2620622217655182,
-0.09745224565267563,
-0.4381696581840515,
0.0462266281247139,
0.009227746166288853,
-0.3788776397705078,
1.0492304563522339,
-0.1171351745724678,
-0.8339993357658386,
-0.026782087981700897,
-0.8110859990119934,
-0.6117850542068481,
-0.08406077325344086,
0.22091758251190186,
-0.32189226150512695,
-0.05027196928858757,
0.4957727789878845,
0.7556217312812805,
0.06369809806346893,
0.22043554484844208,
-0.27195703983306885,
-0.24685674905776978,
0.46171796321868896,
-0.39362549781799316,
0.6155454516410828,
0.1444968283176422,
-0.4071134626865387,
0.2245977222919464,
-0.7454270124435425,
-0.08942943811416626,
0.06556292623281479,
-0.2924479842185974,
-0.46588844060897827,
-0.3565923273563385,
0.29756617546081543,
0.2882938086986542,
0.12153960764408112,
-0.34109318256378174,
0.3883763551712036,
-0.05735334753990173,
0.9445236921310425,
0.880775511264801,
0.17268365621566772,
0.6271674036979675,
-0.36804407835006714,
0.12665046751499176,
-0.3003242015838623,
0.08761016279459,
-0.3663269877433777,
-0.3417317569255829,
-0.9402831792831421,
-0.2729238271713257,
0.2773129343986511,
0.38567081093788147,
-0.844347357749939,
0.2724291980266571,
-0.02370551787316799,
-0.11711032688617706,
-0.44363635778427124,
0.16564849019050598,
0.3522126376628876,
0.41003933548927307,
0.5546495914459229,
-0.3396252691745758,
-0.6415920853614807,
-0.5495105385780334,
-0.3990035951137543,
0.13920381665229797,
-0.12846358120441437,
0.01978805847465992,
0.2010539025068283,
-0.0644550770521164,
0.8562716841697693,
-0.378064900636673,
-0.7324864864349365,
-0.29630425572395325,
0.31658440828323364,
-0.15204787254333496,
0.4535338282585144,
0.49677151441574097,
-0.6893109679222107,
-0.5790550708770752,
-0.06375571340322495,
-0.5111480951309204,
-0.1524694263935089,
-0.2761509418487549,
-0.17649315297603607,
0.36792075634002686,
0.9785517454147339,
-0.27616626024246216,
0.5286346673965454,
0.5284770727157593,
0.0036497986875474453,
0.4750303626060486,
-0.06279955804347992,
0.36640405654907227,
-1.3657482862472534,
-0.10865593701601028,
0.17116998136043549,
-0.301435649394989,
-0.8764631152153015,
0.18428082764148712,
-0.03612341731786728,
0.21674060821533203,
-0.6442074179649353,
0.6310806274414062,
-0.5626028180122375,
-0.0540757030248642,
-0.16837604343891144,
-0.030030924826860428,
0.39656901359558105,
1.0124032497406006,
-0.014883619733154774,
0.6534206867218018,
0.39526984095573425,
-0.40713414549827576,
0.35724279284477234,
0.17865225672721863,
-0.29574552178382874,
0.8066009283065796,
-0.37633389234542847,
0.678597629070282,
0.02503158710896969,
0.3363207280635834,
-1.293573260307312,
-0.08887924253940582,
0.15880829095840454,
-0.014741001650691032,
0.37804993987083435,
-0.22705195844173431,
-0.8482407927513123,
-0.1683209091424942,
-0.635901689529419,
0.1538882851600647,
0.27890101075172424,
-0.5698036551475525,
0.4023550748825073,
0.15281005203723907,
-0.4213571846485138,
-0.3371710479259491,
-0.6248099207878113,
0.3735499083995819,
-0.6724348664283752,
-0.4948844015598297,
0.6897637248039246,
-0.26287272572517395,
-0.17741118371486664,
-0.3023298680782318,
-0.07705502957105637,
-0.13393084704875946,
-0.06473518162965775,
-0.11117029190063477,
0.4993610382080078,
-0.0029429541900753975,
-0.0015183612704277039,
0.1178305521607399,
0.17159400880336761,
-0.11035618931055069,
-0.32863107323646545,
0.397207111120224,
-0.12303046882152557,
-0.25620514154434204,
-0.6820633411407471,
0.42340320348739624,
0.7655447721481323,
-0.39307552576065063,
0.5620178580284119,
0.5991488695144653,
-0.172799751162529,
0.0910634994506836,
-0.7087128162384033,
-0.3857748210430145,
-0.4499708414077759,
0.14122624695301056,
-0.26593950390815735,
-1.0796270370483398,
0.4435165822505951,
-0.20466934144496918,
0.12334705144166946,
0.17729629576206207,
0.3655933439731598,
-0.3014802932739258,
0.7815254330635071,
0.7533211708068848,
0.005318505223840475,
0.7653736472129822,
0.022268472239375114,
0.12801043689250946,
-1.1764692068099976,
-0.1832471340894699,
-0.35481882095336914,
-0.4557749927043915,
-0.4640272855758667,
-0.20810340344905853,
0.41031351685523987,
0.32582175731658936,
-0.03227342292666435,
0.5262711644172668,
-0.5351717472076416,
0.607356071472168,
0.6957591772079468,
0.2751047611236572,
0.7245736718177795,
0.3552170991897583,
-0.058256834745407104,
-0.2780854403972626,
-0.4063066244125366,
-0.4034039378166199,
1.2635579109191895,
0.10312913358211517,
0.7730106711387634,
0.27215489745140076,
0.6185129880905151,
0.11057822406291962,
0.21636220812797546,
-0.626408040523529,
0.5273958444595337,
-0.29887813329696655,
-0.009105473756790161,
-0.4720057547092438,
-0.3077833354473114,
-0.8610081672668457,
0.3971986770629883,
-0.5745994448661804,
-1.1165772676467896,
0.05427303910255432,
-0.16984893381595612,
-0.2233012467622757,
0.34566548466682434,
-0.8220386505126953,
0.48804810643196106,
0.09205476194620132,
-0.7580627202987671,
0.20946520566940308,
-0.8579079508781433,
0.2221992164850235,
-0.29620012640953064,
0.2443537712097168,
0.31742504239082336,
0.2335490584373474,
0.9015936255455017,
-0.12756553292274475,
0.9307832717895508,
0.4238939583301544,
-0.10527664422988892,
0.13998602330684662,
0.11494801938533783,
0.5999707579612732,
-0.005965128540992737,
0.19320471584796906,
0.185546875,
-0.07695744931697845,
-0.07402686029672623,
-0.7574664354324341,
0.6474964618682861,
-0.6023377180099487,
-0.5621470212936401,
-0.17340883612632751,
-0.7649286985397339,
-0.4365047216415405,
0.4027100205421448,
0.1936856061220169,
0.5155990123748779,
0.04156745970249176,
0.1965894103050232,
0.645526111125946,
0.3255307376384735,
0.8430802822113037,
0.3273017704486847,
-0.1339254379272461,
-0.388196736574173,
0.6368445158004761,
0.1106126457452774,
0.37044429779052734,
0.5096873044967651,
0.3543627858161926,
-0.6671600341796875,
-0.5385364294052124,
-0.48942944407463074,
0.1870446652173996,
-0.5967352390289307,
-0.2546480894088745,
-0.8286906480789185,
-0.32873088121414185,
-0.7326464653015137,
-0.32828664779663086,
-0.23224499821662903,
-0.36051279306411743,
-0.35926443338394165,
0.19794932007789612,
0.5704541206359863,
0.8112514019012451,
0.04276834800839424,
0.21052825450897217,
-0.7508466839790344,
0.15164786577224731,
0.5282202363014221,
0.2198926955461502,
-0.14831282198429108,
-0.608096182346344,
0.1709282249212265,
-0.07527229934930801,
-0.4885622262954712,
-0.8802257776260376,
0.3276560306549072,
-0.14404252171516418,
0.24537613987922668,
0.1777549833059311,
0.3942181468009949,
0.6715391874313354,
-0.3730550706386566,
0.3424880802631378,
0.3819032907485962,
-0.9090285897254944,
0.23802942037582397,
-0.4010477364063263,
0.24410712718963623,
0.5392453670501709,
0.04162450507283211,
-0.6852046847343445,
-0.5604960322380066,
-0.5691625475883484,
-0.8259216547012329,
0.7280030846595764,
0.398967444896698,
0.05283255875110626,
0.4362483620643616,
0.1580607146024704,
-0.04804624989628792,
0.26151803135871887,
-0.7246405482292175,
-0.09645223617553711,
-0.2278183251619339,
-0.11966930329799652,
-0.01262611709535122,
-0.040006618946790695,
-0.14722174406051636,
-0.17658811807632446,
0.2899947464466095,
-0.20277506113052368,
0.0640944093465805,
0.2876119017601013,
-0.15221501886844635,
0.1874406337738037,
0.7614227533340454,
0.6468772888183594,
0.4220398962497711,
-0.20096589624881744,
0.3882410526275635,
0.04529780521988869,
-0.30320069193840027,
0.014103638008236885,
0.14340753853321075,
0.0010335922706872225,
-0.2455800324678421,
0.18662376701831818,
0.7045498490333557,
0.29023459553718567,
-0.20705361664295197,
0.47751694917678833,
-0.0553278774023056,
-0.16621002554893494,
0.307707816362381,
-0.2645290195941925,
0.11879803985357285,
0.2197532057762146,
0.27389591932296753,
0.2242191731929779,
0.18892648816108704,
-0.6134536862373352,
0.19120781123638153,
0.3177083134651184,
-0.3310866951942444,
-0.2016836255788803,
0.4592978060245514,
0.25541952252388,
-0.21630120277404785,
0.20766422152519226,
0.010192765854299068,
-0.5679436922073364,
0.41812682151794434,
0.7099891901016235,
0.5514925122261047,
-0.2061178833246231,
0.15855152904987335,
0.11635144799947739,
0.1774115413427353,
-0.23904123902320862,
-0.2823321521282196,
-0.15055090188980103,
-0.578835129737854,
-0.6707691550254822,
-0.6248096227645874,
-0.4723048806190491,
0.5263674855232239,
-0.5734493136405945,
0.3615803122520447,
-0.30934473872184753,
0.22230839729309082,
0.16836626827716827,
-0.15839040279388428,
-0.4798223674297333,
-0.19236263632774353,
-0.18054011464118958,
0.3009454011917114,
-0.9105767607688904,
0.5601277351379395,
0.9403106570243835,
-0.2761960029602051,
-0.6532549858093262,
0.11952979117631912,
0.07461073994636536,
-0.6067710518836975,
0.24107497930526733,
0.2721068859100342,
-0.09586185216903687,
0.33881255984306335,
-0.42222851514816284,
-0.7276186943054199,
0.8004840612411499,
0.3544500470161438,
-0.5360360741615295,
0.163395956158638,
0.10098611563444138,
0.6235615611076355,
-0.24177785217761993,
0.06355179846286774,
0.4562692642211914,
0.40397757291793823,
0.2980983257293701,
-0.9573509693145752,
0.17450830340385437,
0.07137918472290039,
0.04242664948105812,
0.21972404420375824,
-0.7961891293525696,
0.6121863722801208,
-0.16369673609733582,
-0.3740184009075165,
0.024687597528100014,
0.5267210602760315,
0.02752004563808441,
0.3000243008136749,
0.4113506078720093,
0.504494309425354,
0.41811996698379517,
0.15138347446918488,
0.6746830344200134,
0.019847925752401352,
0.4332923889160156,
1.0252856016159058,
-0.41446977853775024,
0.8088967204093933,
0.7799263596534729,
-0.30407845973968506,
0.3809962272644043,
0.34934890270233154,
0.22211527824401855,
0.6550277471542358,
0.09019764512777328,
-0.05912691354751587,
-0.016037264838814735,
-0.3052968382835388,
-0.3552819490432739,
0.4740599989891052,
-0.05209793522953987,
0.051095858216285706,
-0.1882304549217224,
0.1725296825170517,
0.3873711824417114,
0.25853291153907776,
-0.1761879324913025,
1.0160305500030518,
0.07288281619548798,
-0.7613011002540588,
0.2897297441959381,
-0.09195771813392639,
0.9629655480384827,
-0.3631919324398041,
-0.22118625044822693,
-0.40115028619766235,
0.0984049141407013,
-0.11487077921628952,
-0.9085022807121277,
0.2577293813228607,
-0.1747138351202011,
-0.2048143595457077,
-0.639747142791748,
0.9049235582351685,
-0.6485878825187683,
-0.399163156747818,
0.2742510437965393,
0.4359702169895172,
0.01730562001466751,
-0.17998872697353363,
-0.44357311725616455,
-0.035271868109703064,
-0.08093786239624023,
-0.13897447288036346,
0.8471336364746094,
0.445230096578598,
-0.26503273844718933,
0.37453493475914,
1.0052380561828613,
-0.16014164686203003,
-0.02065129764378071,
0.19460347294807434,
0.8863937854766846,
-0.2651682496070862,
-0.4881238341331482,
-0.8437950611114502,
0.33373817801475525,
-0.0966302901506424,
-0.0329260416328907,
0.7612430453300476,
0.08609723299741745,
0.8989811539649963,
0.028277479112148285,
0.616872251033783,
0.2659875154495239,
0.23767678439617157,
-0.8881629705429077,
0.6473199725151062,
-0.5775554776191711,
0.23889733850955963,
-0.7181591987609863,
-1.1083871126174927,
-0.4830811619758606,
0.4258635342121124,
0.10921445488929749,
-0.05647391080856323,
1.0804935693740845,
0.5436577200889587,
-0.015048817731440067,
-0.011477623134851456,
0.3119390606880188,
0.08191577345132828,
0.12107036262750626,
0.5998802185058594,
0.7216363549232483,
-0.2858786880970001,
0.6096084117889404,
-0.4264705181121826,
-0.5212283134460449,
-0.24249903857707977,
-1.0115855932235718,
-1.0216364860534668,
-0.7341737747192383,
-0.3092237710952759,
-0.3300422430038452,
0.05257299542427063,
0.6184168457984924,
0.6779063940048218,
-0.5143911242485046,
-0.07889562845230103,
-0.08256518840789795,
0.04876997694373131,
-0.39783602952957153,
-0.26224157214164734,
0.6663193702697754,
-0.22953185439109802,
-0.878864049911499,
0.37602466344833374,
0.6071898341178894,
0.19139689207077026,
-0.26704293489456177,
0.3726791441440582,
-0.21446962654590607,
0.034853797405958176,
0.8289289474487305,
0.1678084135055542,
-0.6302331686019897,
-0.33563926815986633,
0.11711186170578003,
-0.17454200983047485,
0.19002081453800201,
0.8865637183189392,
-0.592231273651123,
0.42710793018341064,
0.35761427879333496,
0.7731111645698547,
0.41498011350631714,
0.01312101911753416,
0.13364556431770325,
-0.9487655162811279,
-0.026258548721671104,
-0.2695826292037964,
0.44151952862739563,
0.388692170381546,
-0.4598556458950043,
0.4241763949394226,
0.423340380191803,
-0.5244821906089783,
-0.6581922769546509,
0.27987366914749146,
-1.175026297569275,
-0.27733224630355835,
1.4078775644302368,
-0.09168146550655365,
-0.022508297115564346,
-0.34053507447242737,
-0.4487585127353668,
0.20483608543872833,
-0.3477165400981903,
0.8697237372398376,
0.7340099811553955,
-0.232497900724411,
-0.21542946994304657,
-0.3268110156059265,
0.43070071935653687,
0.519566535949707,
-1.0421502590179443,
0.22988510131835938,
0.2888179123401642,
0.19860108196735382,
0.14828817546367645,
0.6402459740638733,
-0.07019660621881485,
-0.1595172882080078,
-0.6151021718978882,
-0.08081179857254028,
-0.10696782916784286,
-0.5318125486373901,
-0.21514908969402313,
-0.008157811127603054,
-0.4442519545555115,
-0.11873330920934677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13636v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13636v2
|
A Unified Framework and Dataset for Assessing Societal Bias in Vision-Language Models
| 2024-02-21T09:17:51 | 2024-06-17T08:35:35 |
Ashutosh Sathe, Prachi Jain, Sunayana Sitaram
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Vision-language models (VLMs) have gained widespread adoption in both
industry and academia. In this study, we propose a unified framework for
systematically evaluating gender, race, and age biases in VLMs with respect to
professions. Our evaluation encompasses all supported inference modes of the
recent VLMs, including image-to-text, text-to-text, text-to-image, and
image-to-image. Additionally, we propose an automated pipeline to generate
high-quality synthetic datasets that intentionally conceal gender, race, and
age information across different professional domains, both in generated text
and images. The dataset includes action-based descriptions of each profession
and serves as a benchmark for evaluating societal biases in vision-language
models (VLMs). In our comparative analysis of widely used VLMs, we have
identified that varying input-output modalities lead to discernible differences
in bias magnitudes and directions. Additionally, we find that VLM models
exhibit distinct biases across different bias attributes we investigated. We
hope our work will help guide future progress in improving VLMs to learn
socially unbiased representations. We will release our data and code.
|
[
-0.2446233630180359,
-0.1719491183757782,
0.4442812204360962,
0.18425773084163666,
-0.09173017740249634,
-0.009819792583584785,
-0.18560251593589783,
-0.47741809487342834,
-0.04784071817994118,
0.7652523517608643,
-0.4978685677051544,
-0.7033897638320923,
-0.6733571887016296,
-0.04614131525158882,
-0.2345600128173828,
0.6485264301300049,
0.2332179844379425,
0.8447303771972656,
-0.4057590365409851,
-0.19564615190029144,
-0.36879944801330566,
-0.43416470289230347,
-0.1432710736989975,
-0.2909977436065674,
0.20656608045101166,
-0.044170644134283066,
0.4817660450935364,
0.6813978552818298,
0.4505159556865692,
0.24086321890354156,
-0.14140605926513672,
0.12053677439689636,
-0.354815810918808,
-0.23548699915409088,
-0.45207616686820984,
0.09597668051719666,
-0.33170071244239807,
-0.07545378059148788,
0.5434926152229309,
0.9369797706604004,
0.11355771124362946,
0.801999568939209,
-0.052650775760412216,
0.6899492740631104,
-0.9742384552955627,
0.4022308588027954,
-0.8276185989379883,
0.2014162689447403,
-0.24653567373752594,
-0.0753801241517067,
-0.45174357295036316,
-0.24603581428527832,
0.32283586263656616,
-0.23964697122573853,
0.4055841565132141,
-0.1430881768465042,
0.6599544882774353,
0.0479593388736248,
-0.6463280916213989,
0.006963452324271202,
-0.5720297694206238,
0.76682448387146,
-0.4022427797317505,
0.5161007642745972,
0.006686709821224213,
0.5167889595031738,
0.2425997108221054,
-0.5731876492500305,
-0.28969600796699524,
0.019967619329690933,
0.02663223259150982,
0.19769209623336792,
-0.012776260264217854,
0.10045602172613144,
0.1408941000699997,
0.049060869961977005,
-0.30073362588882446,
-0.07020126283168793,
-0.8820552825927734,
-0.1954299360513687,
0.7228367328643799,
0.22986871004104614,
0.26064828038215637,
-0.18534784018993378,
-0.3504374027252197,
-0.043412622064352036,
-0.6427809596061707,
-0.23750923573970795,
0.427554726600647,
0.2411508858203888,
-0.1741843819618225,
0.6642760038375854,
-0.3329046070575714,
0.8774163722991943,
-0.36514103412628174,
0.20747317373752594,
0.287961483001709,
-0.45715954899787903,
-0.4547566771507263,
-0.26278942823410034,
0.8202703595161438,
0.9963876008987427,
0.5560477375984192,
-0.1069888323545456,
-0.11465437710285187,
0.4555228352546692,
0.5196440815925598,
-0.35301971435546875,
0.08504057675600052,
-0.36460360884666443,
-0.5600792169570923,
-0.5632314085960388,
0.0754181519150734,
-1.210399866104126,
-0.7642655968666077,
-0.6835544109344482,
0.08451900631189346,
0.29069504141807556,
-0.17503267526626587,
0.06984812021255493,
-0.40244555473327637,
0.24610570073127747,
0.35893651843070984,
-0.660134494304657,
0.17688697576522827,
0.3765918016433716,
0.5375620126724243,
-0.2580496668815613,
-0.196070596575737,
-0.14502272009849548,
0.06358223408460617,
-0.2617127299308777,
0.523370087146759,
-0.7173781991004944,
-0.3301781713962555,
0.39736947417259216,
-0.05428989604115486,
-0.01863016001880169,
-0.6031593680381775,
0.5291844010353088,
-0.3468214273452759,
0.24319502711296082,
-0.5589707493782043,
-0.11839399486780167,
0.02020496316254139,
-0.13806664943695068,
-0.6023471355438232,
0.9056031107902527,
0.04691816493868828,
-0.9022347331047058,
0.9872678518295288,
-0.7725076675415039,
0.07464979588985443,
0.08892661333084106,
-0.7559370398521423,
-0.325447142124176,
0.11332093924283981,
0.32007962465286255,
0.39299631118774414,
-0.39030852913856506,
0.6337862014770508,
-0.6876751780509949,
-0.39137038588523865,
-0.08530440926551819,
-0.7140957117080688,
1.1644948720932007,
-0.16543056070804596,
-0.4492299258708954,
0.25280845165252686,
-0.6870205402374268,
-0.2745978832244873,
0.09973866492509842,
0.07731153815984726,
-0.37196967005729675,
0.132844015955925,
0.4022776782512665,
0.27274376153945923,
0.12285967916250229,
-0.7739760875701904,
-0.027652597054839134,
0.05702895298600197,
0.32808515429496765,
1.1503041982650757,
-0.4338929355144501,
0.5675275325775146,
0.12644241750240326,
0.20279347896575928,
0.0067585608921945095,
0.6357049942016602,
0.22888366878032684,
-0.29041942954063416,
-0.5658889412879944,
-0.1988644301891327,
-0.09066786617040634,
0.23189114034175873,
-0.7605621814727783,
0.10885149240493774,
-0.3331511616706848,
-0.4047325849533081,
-0.6516782641410828,
0.1328199952840805,
0.6324039697647095,
0.5797665119171143,
0.26421916484832764,
-0.7104368805885315,
-0.6187120676040649,
-1.1181808710098267,
-0.567720890045166,
-0.18401405215263367,
-0.15179134905338287,
0.4067319333553314,
0.5225011110305786,
-0.4264402985572815,
1.0456790924072266,
-0.27968183159828186,
-0.23688215017318726,
0.09379549324512482,
-0.19158457219600677,
-0.10594860464334488,
0.1962164342403412,
0.6507510542869568,
-0.9181405305862427,
-0.14225485920906067,
-0.16778597235679626,
-0.9097835421562195,
-0.3188205659389496,
0.247895285487175,
-0.35457998514175415,
0.2402118593454361,
0.2817069888114929,
-0.22447894513607025,
0.9487930536270142,
0.5096145868301392,
-0.8145021796226501,
0.8821365237236023,
0.09493603557348251,
0.03943850100040436,
-0.44777530431747437,
0.22537803649902344,
0.6329934000968933,
-0.17292387783527374,
-0.35734501481056213,
0.08396880328655243,
-0.08810693025588989,
0.14862748980522156,
-0.5536994338035583,
0.8729071021080017,
-0.4905262291431427,
-0.6490781307220459,
0.24057716131210327,
0.08730678260326385,
-0.0930430069565773,
0.3542386591434479,
0.38457655906677246,
0.645317018032074,
0.8160096406936646,
-0.3777555525302887,
0.09478358924388885,
0.10063125193119049,
-0.419373095035553,
0.655739426612854,
-0.7537534832954407,
0.19953159987926483,
-0.5435146689414978,
0.17380541563034058,
-0.6446124911308289,
-0.14424742758274078,
0.29166167974472046,
-0.23703143000602722,
-0.20546431839466095,
-0.34255048632621765,
-0.17818303406238556,
-0.6281463503837585,
-0.24027547240257263,
0.22317619621753693,
0.39960068464279175,
-0.37055039405822754,
0.593654453754425,
0.5890740752220154,
0.033895205706357956,
-0.9659994840621948,
-0.5363789200782776,
-0.007839616388082504,
-0.0810709074139595,
-0.5752539038658142,
0.23363399505615234,
0.048137180507183075,
-0.5159347653388977,
-0.1340615153312683,
-0.17787159979343414,
-0.36992910504341125,
-0.20191413164138794,
0.3396402895450592,
0.6793924570083618,
0.030090713873505592,
-0.11718662083148956,
0.017571179196238518,
0.11560747772455215,
0.1530264914035797,
-0.32162848114967346,
0.41438770294189453,
-0.14475969970226288,
-0.6070936322212219,
0.12433768808841705,
0.14867746829986572,
0.8523426651954651,
-0.4503629505634308,
0.645022451877594,
0.7092642188072205,
-0.1531379669904709,
-0.02749200351536274,
-0.5000576376914978,
-0.1982898712158203,
-0.4365856945514679,
0.4791437089443207,
0.22987663745880127,
-0.8414458632469177,
0.34322330355644226,
0.20918162167072296,
0.44099822640419006,
0.2974693477153778,
0.7124705910682678,
0.038287218660116196,
0.9131017923355103,
0.6075995564460754,
0.09531101584434509,
0.4206821024417877,
-0.1223418265581131,
-0.14281997084617615,
-0.8659072518348694,
-0.4263876676559448,
-0.3839074969291687,
0.052876245230436325,
-0.25238439440727234,
-0.5621840357780457,
0.4088863432407379,
-0.40426450967788696,
-0.4787575602531433,
-0.09291645139455795,
-0.7093685269355774,
0.457920640707016,
0.42954394221305847,
-0.005527372006326914,
0.1080574169754982,
0.2551657259464264,
-0.24775610864162445,
-0.19890549778938293,
-0.4680897891521454,
-0.8570441603660583,
1.4673725366592407,
0.38888224959373474,
0.5325263142585754,
-0.10030443966388702,
0.37205079197883606,
0.6180566549301147,
0.5946290493011475,
-0.3301602303981781,
0.6215160489082336,
-0.4944190979003906,
-0.9300246238708496,
-0.3632463812828064,
-0.2309338003396988,
-0.5979440808296204,
0.6665688157081604,
-0.15629877150058746,
-0.9661679267883301,
0.43741658329963684,
0.37829601764678955,
0.08324739336967468,
0.2801079750061035,
-0.48979637026786804,
0.9872466921806335,
-0.030850155279040337,
-0.6010981202125549,
0.13345517218112946,
-0.7468883395195007,
0.5196030139923096,
-0.02442183904349804,
0.4741239547729492,
-0.2656739056110382,
0.2649412155151367,
0.6111910343170166,
-0.11131202429533005,
1.2607371807098389,
-0.4569797217845917,
0.05039237439632416,
-0.007885540835559368,
-0.22398318350315094,
-0.12847203016281128,
0.027791906148195267,
-0.16273470222949982,
0.6546526551246643,
0.13401509821414948,
-0.3766922950744629,
-0.21923673152923584,
0.11531279981136322,
-0.693688690662384,
-0.2071162313222885,
-0.2187989354133606,
-0.3731161653995514,
-0.25502365827560425,
0.26400360465049744,
0.22529442608356476,
0.816563069820404,
-0.442812979221344,
0.1453859657049179,
0.4587676227092743,
-0.33803680539131165,
0.17520183324813843,
0.6704536080360413,
-0.500250518321991,
-0.1459793895483017,
0.5183905363082886,
0.09138774871826172,
0.4302670955657959,
-0.1191413551568985,
0.07884722203016281,
-0.5597101449966431,
-0.10386507958173752,
-0.7726873755455017,
0.05825306102633476,
-0.9361864924430847,
0.14900469779968262,
-0.5004168152809143,
-0.13170960545539856,
-0.5089488625526428,
-0.19066005945205688,
-0.30192118883132935,
0.13467852771282196,
-0.08967071771621704,
0.02708500437438488,
0.062067661434412,
0.7801517844200134,
0.145503431558609,
0.07821515202522278,
-0.3902984857559204,
0.3715755343437195,
0.27797508239746094,
0.3737398087978363,
0.012854319997131824,
-0.21594646573066711,
0.06745322048664093,
0.1738869845867157,
-0.11417807638645172,
-0.8356856107711792,
0.34942662715911865,
0.061279021203517914,
0.6242417693138123,
0.23005807399749756,
-0.049204155802726746,
0.30210790038108826,
-0.577752411365509,
0.9687123894691467,
0.347440242767334,
-1.0506807565689087,
0.24538074433803558,
-0.5154659748077393,
0.16108015179634094,
0.5895757675170898,
-0.015856649726629257,
-0.5711213946342468,
-0.3091420829296112,
-0.4084772765636444,
-0.762819230556488,
0.4020490348339081,
0.04609838128089905,
0.1914716362953186,
0.13652555644512177,
0.03631923720240593,
0.07164791226387024,
0.45762062072753906,
-0.9623964428901672,
-0.45075878500938416,
-0.20838689804077148,
-0.41183236241340637,
0.16824069619178772,
-0.1352267563343048,
-0.31162968277931213,
-0.3787142336368561,
0.26938724517822266,
-0.3242548108100891,
0.36813053488731384,
0.18536758422851562,
-0.15748989582061768,
-0.026197729632258415,
0.30002516508102417,
0.40292802453041077,
1.054551124572754,
-0.0648510605096817,
0.25865986943244934,
0.13018889725208282,
-0.6675699949264526,
0.07055541127920151,
-0.20578202605247498,
-0.5800656080245972,
0.3182598054409027,
0.2948012053966522,
0.9967281818389893,
0.011131166480481625,
-0.821283757686615,
0.6394801735877991,
-0.06792661547660828,
-0.20607547461986542,
-0.38845986127853394,
-0.09954233467578888,
-0.18715398013591766,
0.16191986203193665,
0.3325752019882202,
0.4090290665626526,
0.32705366611480713,
-0.5183835029602051,
0.15517887473106384,
0.3880141079425812,
-0.7915088534355164,
-0.20025752484798431,
0.7156583070755005,
0.25907906889915466,
-0.059097856283187866,
0.22732816636562347,
0.03928784281015396,
-0.5304902195930481,
0.6800533533096313,
0.19420692324638367,
0.8266994953155518,
0.02493138238787651,
0.7122886776924133,
0.02794809453189373,
0.4994637668132782,
-0.07362355291843414,
0.3316773474216461,
0.12039166688919067,
-0.8471431732177734,
-0.3335424065589905,
-0.7290554046630859,
-0.12745200097560883,
0.015880640596151352,
-0.8977292776107788,
0.2511017620563507,
-0.33437037467956543,
-0.312296062707901,
0.11760099232196808,
-0.5026299357414246,
-1.0938918590545654,
0.4483575224876404,
0.2084367722272873,
0.7701693773269653,
-1.0886996984481812,
0.615373432636261,
0.9927535653114319,
-0.18964679539203644,
-0.4394354522228241,
-0.08797023445367813,
0.432869017124176,
-1.0479447841644287,
1.0891046524047852,
0.033397600054740906,
-0.35880184173583984,
-0.3489145338535309,
-0.6951352953910828,
-0.6286999583244324,
0.9490203857421875,
0.5297940373420715,
-0.5807135105133057,
-0.19620250165462494,
0.25040513277053833,
0.6106918454170227,
-0.5222353339195251,
0.3600994646549225,
0.5109400153160095,
0.4196575880050659,
-0.08155100792646408,
-1.0232969522476196,
-0.30897098779678345,
-0.19672319293022156,
0.33019283413887024,
-0.068851038813591,
-0.3736775815486908,
0.734228789806366,
-0.012447534129023552,
-0.1444634199142456,
-0.5322716236114502,
0.4491168260574341,
0.5202040672302246,
0.6293616890907288,
0.4737494885921478,
0.024703772738575935,
0.4715005159378052,
-0.0840863436460495,
0.8206285834312439,
-0.06690534204244614,
0.4081602394580841,
0.9869721531867981,
-0.36275747418403625,
0.4059891700744629,
0.47727954387664795,
-0.21022580564022064,
0.29561296105384827,
0.24226100742816925,
-0.13746461272239685,
0.38104483485221863,
0.27021878957748413,
-0.08809349685907364,
-0.22351308166980743,
-0.4626571238040924,
-0.2553240656852722,
0.5791736245155334,
0.2789100706577301,
-0.7926090955734253,
-0.19445990025997162,
-0.08107173442840576,
-0.0478498600423336,
0.1294195055961609,
-0.4927189350128174,
0.39376455545425415,
0.08486086875200272,
-0.38838982582092285,
0.2582568824291229,
-0.1600063294172287,
0.8073564767837524,
-0.39319270849227905,
0.04773995280265808,
0.022090960294008255,
0.046459171921014786,
-0.08179310709238052,
-0.979738175868988,
0.3230717182159424,
0.23439133167266846,
-0.30241039395332336,
-0.14620612561702728,
1.0318034887313843,
-0.5029610395431519,
-0.6712768077850342,
0.4567042589187622,
0.32691341638565063,
-0.05992806702852249,
0.1983875185251236,
-0.7075833082199097,
0.33608901500701904,
0.04692540317773819,
0.08743219077587128,
0.1538139134645462,
0.04832856357097626,
-0.2976757884025574,
0.6420428156852722,
0.2860200107097626,
0.2639116048812866,
0.3157489001750946,
0.472049355506897,
0.5628258585929871,
-0.15730038285255432,
-0.29481175541877747,
-0.7876015305519104,
0.7014865279197693,
-0.5765277743339539,
-0.4027528166770935,
0.7573152780532837,
0.20013166964054108,
0.9851917028427124,
-0.3172421455383301,
0.9669751524925232,
0.07666343450546265,
0.24108920991420746,
-0.43739053606987,
0.7725741863250732,
-0.6230702996253967,
-0.0004361990140751004,
-0.8422024250030518,
-0.8862430453300476,
-0.048501841723918915,
0.5508973598480225,
-0.43347063660621643,
0.23893482983112335,
0.03762800619006157,
0.6261041164398193,
0.014679399318993092,
-0.07360830157995224,
0.25046873092651367,
-0.2615678608417511,
0.0964777022600174,
0.04884696751832962,
0.5322766304016113,
-0.11960486322641373,
0.045659810304641724,
-0.0025139576755464077,
-0.23218506574630737,
-0.20975373685359955,
-0.9604879021644592,
-0.9856270551681519,
-0.5324324369430542,
-0.2871223986148834,
-0.17634226381778717,
0.29816246032714844,
0.8516270518302917,
0.8664535880088806,
-0.4110125005245209,
-0.3870603144168854,
0.06350413709878922,
-0.10370276123285294,
-0.13842450082302094,
-0.21331337094306946,
0.11666736751794815,
0.27939122915267944,
-0.5533620715141296,
-0.027311718091368675,
0.40024933218955994,
-0.22808529436588287,
-0.8623628616333008,
-0.06040895730257034,
0.4147107005119324,
0.21917541325092316,
0.8297289609909058,
0.03044416755437851,
-0.9707524180412292,
-0.3024568557739258,
0.01870383694767952,
-0.09411048144102097,
-0.18169569969177246,
0.6671674251556396,
-0.4554947018623352,
0.7882304787635803,
0.26177576184272766,
0.24908222258090973,
0.12167306989431381,
-0.3913474977016449,
0.8202587962150574,
-0.6647354364395142,
0.14101041853427887,
0.23108167946338654,
0.5079630017280579,
0.46546295285224915,
-0.16881558299064636,
0.6335820555686951,
0.4667293131351471,
-0.278796523809433,
-1.0424621105194092,
0.3220710754394531,
-0.7657420635223389,
-0.34494248032569885,
1.1405378580093384,
0.1414017230272293,
-0.16621510684490204,
-0.28245311975479126,
-0.31820547580718994,
0.21132546663284302,
-0.33070310950279236,
0.7823140025138855,
0.40876030921936035,
0.441382497549057,
-0.21082811057567596,
-0.7813066244125366,
0.41734233498573303,
0.1323929727077484,
-0.7366689443588257,
0.3007172644138336,
0.8342506885528564,
0.35382044315338135,
0.012936204671859741,
0.7612258791923523,
-0.5314911603927612,
0.27294304966926575,
-0.06997745484113693,
0.5263826847076416,
0.11767873913049698,
-0.4642349183559418,
-0.23289504647254944,
0.002638869220390916,
-0.18027877807617188,
0.23575980961322784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16733v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16733v1
|
DREsS: Dataset for Rubric-based Essay Scoring on EFL Writing
| 2024-02-21T09:12:16 | 2024-02-21T09:12:16 |
Haneul Yoo, Jieun Han, So-Yeon Ahn, Alice Oh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Automated essay scoring (AES) is a useful tool in English as a Foreign
Language (EFL) writing education, offering real-time essay scores for students
and instructors. However, previous AES models were trained on essays and scores
irrelevant to the practical scenarios of EFL writing education and usually
provided a single holistic score due to the lack of appropriate datasets. In
this paper, we release DREsS, a large-scale, standard dataset for rubric-based
automated essay scoring. DREsS comprises three sub-datasets: DREsS_New,
DREsS_Std., and DREsS_CASE. We collect DREsS_New, a real-classroom dataset with
1.7K essays authored by EFL undergraduate students and scored by English
education experts. We also standardize existing rubric-based essay scoring
datasets as DREsS_Std. We suggest CASE, a corruption-based augmentation
strategy for essays, which generates 20K synthetic samples of DREsS_CASE and
improves the baseline results by 45.44%. DREsS will enable further research to
provide a more accurate and practical AES system for EFL writing education.
|
[
-0.10412124544382095,
-0.8727489113807678,
0.01310797780752182,
0.5006487369537354,
0.03000798262655735,
0.14426440000534058,
-0.07959187775850296,
-0.6172304749488831,
0.3973565697669983,
0.45057496428489685,
-0.2588326334953308,
-0.5231529474258423,
-0.07079745829105377,
0.14966724812984467,
-0.5722408294677734,
1.1015480756759644,
-0.1482541710138321,
0.1666325479745865,
-0.7037787437438965,
-0.03877889737486839,
-0.17551879584789276,
-0.32332876324653625,
-0.6728448867797852,
-0.04988493770360947,
0.5393887758255005,
0.6359493136405945,
0.17205984890460968,
0.5886891484260559,
0.8121752738952637,
0.20147942006587982,
0.4533388316631317,
0.1774270236492157,
-0.08070846647024155,
0.2020510584115982,
-0.0759805217385292,
-0.527381420135498,
-0.9215567708015442,
0.45848792791366577,
0.40688633918762207,
0.38037803769111633,
-0.5170141458511353,
0.6952980756759644,
0.0016877923626452684,
0.4277830719947815,
-0.9119263291358948,
-0.05218297243118286,
-0.36863768100738525,
0.20925873517990112,
-0.4168693423271179,
-0.11836399883031845,
-0.682165265083313,
-0.2235444188117981,
-0.17136120796203613,
-0.9078938364982605,
0.2200859934091568,
0.3079659938812256,
0.7055696249008179,
-0.0736049935221672,
-0.16317960619926453,
-0.25555047392845154,
-0.5588822364807129,
1.0410654544830322,
-0.2622297406196594,
0.12575426697731018,
0.3587602972984314,
0.5321992039680481,
0.23279407620429993,
-0.8367639183998108,
-0.27516546845436096,
-0.0873219445347786,
-0.16823406517505646,
0.3389507830142975,
0.3411085605621338,
-0.06437192857265472,
0.19191843271255493,
0.4399978816509247,
-0.583675742149353,
-0.18667390942573547,
-0.4121783673763275,
-0.13192929327487946,
0.898317277431488,
0.3246488571166992,
0.11225955933332443,
0.08090928941965103,
-0.4600070118904114,
-0.17321744561195374,
-0.7248445749282837,
0.22576583921909332,
0.4943694770336151,
0.29413264989852905,
-0.1284545511007309,
0.11855117976665497,
0.1640598624944687,
0.8799601793289185,
-0.08842416107654572,
-0.2448655664920807,
0.06976476311683655,
0.10580424964427948,
-0.2161552906036377,
-0.1148461326956749,
0.40858137607574463,
0.7103787660598755,
0.4486307203769684,
0.01952793076634407,
-0.35915225744247437,
0.07201850414276123,
0.4007234573364258,
-0.5770416259765625,
-0.353725790977478,
0.13554012775421143,
-0.12655462324619293,
-0.7210678458213806,
0.4210554361343384,
-0.9360682368278503,
-0.29164692759513855,
-0.5564038753509521,
0.42524534463882446,
0.03543233126401901,
0.07685605436563492,
0.04304758459329605,
-0.05794255807995796,
0.7838349938392639,
0.827763557434082,
-0.38420841097831726,
0.7724898457527161,
0.6040487289428711,
0.6383166313171387,
-0.38860636949539185,
-0.4118228256702423,
-0.46898555755615234,
-0.018160095438361168,
-0.8896533250808716,
0.9254359602928162,
-0.6546399593353271,
-0.20088854432106018,
0.1439187228679657,
0.03938666731119156,
0.03966334089636803,
-0.2823612093925476,
1.1099175214767456,
-0.2614921033382416,
0.5875527262687683,
-0.16862711310386658,
-0.6415269374847412,
0.3803292512893677,
0.09024134278297424,
-0.6662774085998535,
1.151520848274231,
-0.04257366806268692,
-0.3068813979625702,
0.43142619729042053,
-0.5762941837310791,
-0.7791479825973511,
-0.046850770711898804,
-0.04661669209599495,
-0.8152767419815063,
-0.052728865295648575,
0.42006760835647583,
0.4804355502128601,
-0.2648561894893646,
0.005822017323225737,
-0.26098915934562683,
-0.8509511947631836,
0.223189115524292,
-0.29981592297554016,
0.4453362822532654,
0.1577526330947876,
0.13359574973583221,
-0.5461142659187317,
-0.8872655034065247,
0.33523666858673096,
-0.13073080778121948,
-0.3262383043766022,
-0.2976837456226349,
-0.2309069037437439,
0.7032681703567505,
-0.024869319051504135,
0.2465585321187973,
-0.6142173409461975,
0.13423387706279755,
-0.116451695561409,
-0.0825793594121933,
1.0012845993041992,
-0.06876714527606964,
0.38106080889701843,
-1.0669420957565308,
0.7599676847457886,
-0.14950120449066162,
0.10712885111570358,
-0.32076749205589294,
-0.4055190682411194,
-0.8273914456367493,
-0.4195346236228943,
0.3836587965488434,
0.5984489917755127,
-0.24852587282657623,
0.2556607127189636,
0.06917041540145874,
-0.6290707588195801,
-0.6434107422828674,
-0.46304282546043396,
0.3908262550830841,
0.4805435240268707,
0.4643036723136902,
0.2379799485206604,
-0.7213990092277527,
-0.7484432458877563,
-0.6976507306098938,
0.10568205267190933,
-0.055572960525751114,
0.27991196513175964,
0.6524035930633545,
0.49580371379852295,
0.927513837814331,
-0.5953087210655212,
-0.8142197728157043,
-0.06471703946590424,
0.11411770433187485,
0.08904952555894852,
0.8361034989356995,
0.662615954875946,
-0.4438435733318329,
-0.8236117362976074,
-0.24680794775485992,
-0.3533571660518646,
-0.4631916880607605,
-0.2575477957725525,
-0.12136442959308624,
0.23687918484210968,
0.38462895154953003,
-0.013521847315132618,
0.4982016384601593,
0.29355472326278687,
-0.3964627683162689,
0.714961588382721,
0.028078438714146614,
0.6583999991416931,
-1.1476014852523804,
0.05933387205004692,
0.296261191368103,
-0.44173699617385864,
-0.41114404797554016,
0.2570805549621582,
0.2664642930030823,
-0.0818832665681839,
-0.17139503359794617,
0.65528804063797,
-0.3034363389015198,
0.15412507951259613,
0.03540515527129173,
-0.07210046052932739,
0.7733463644981384,
0.2673972547054291,
-0.11014331132173538,
0.801963746547699,
0.38129180669784546,
-0.24611449241638184,
0.3172755837440491,
0.1403241753578186,
-0.34465110301971436,
1.179489016532898,
-0.47998932003974915,
0.32270580530166626,
-0.10966677218675613,
0.23101016879081726,
-0.7131509780883789,
-0.4840417206287384,
-0.20122146606445312,
-0.31598415970802307,
0.5502263307571411,
-0.1559341847896576,
0.20764905214309692,
-0.026958104223012924,
-0.7508406043052673,
0.2534481883049011,
0.34864261746406555,
-0.38290199637413025,
0.46711239218711853,
0.5952195525169373,
-0.1298503428697586,
-0.690470278263092,
-0.8590275645256042,
0.07901790738105774,
-0.35432252287864685,
-0.3383626341819763,
0.5330870747566223,
-0.18349981307983398,
-0.4007584750652313,
-0.08795462548732758,
-0.04877861589193344,
-0.26326945424079895,
-0.04726888984441757,
0.053941771388053894,
0.4266938269138336,
-0.2550007104873657,
0.18085536360740662,
-0.07634095847606659,
0.10796646028757095,
0.08683907985687256,
-0.10584083199501038,
0.058569926768541336,
0.01055328268557787,
-0.54159015417099,
-0.17451585829257965,
0.6045016646385193,
0.7373509407043457,
-0.2186412811279297,
0.6634156703948975,
0.2893761694431305,
-0.5342180728912354,
-0.8402749300003052,
-0.5678818225860596,
0.05960358679294586,
-0.41880738735198975,
0.14382265508174896,
-0.3732023537158966,
-0.37078917026519775,
0.4547215402126312,
0.3565507233142853,
0.3543936014175415,
0.397309273481369,
0.05124887079000473,
-0.2955246865749359,
0.7545686960220337,
0.3930429220199585,
-0.1180608943104744,
0.3264636695384979,
-0.05749567598104477,
0.09837034344673157,
-0.7507878541946411,
-0.22905825078487396,
-0.7577725648880005,
-0.3892028331756592,
-0.40001755952835083,
-0.5264381766319275,
0.5097714066505432,
-0.17618320882320404,
-0.25154900550842285,
-0.03856423869729042,
-0.5645723342895508,
0.9198977947235107,
0.34717413783073425,
0.04705130681395531,
0.3545890748500824,
0.11706636101007462,
-0.03117513284087181,
-0.22532902657985687,
-0.2943251132965088,
-0.602155864238739,
1.462349534034729,
0.08370564877986908,
0.995419979095459,
-0.06404322385787964,
0.5551153421401978,
0.7013089060783386,
0.39833277463912964,
-0.42139241099357605,
0.3649032413959503,
-0.08527369052171707,
-0.5727379322052002,
-0.30663958191871643,
-0.16227662563323975,
-0.5498679876327515,
-0.035633765161037445,
-0.24476292729377747,
-0.42294061183929443,
0.13136336207389832,
0.19975177943706512,
-0.3073209524154663,
-0.07753296196460724,
-0.5970482230186462,
0.5004885792732239,
0.08000296354293823,
-0.9498266577720642,
0.1671193540096283,
-0.13475263118743896,
0.08758088201284409,
-0.20473667979240417,
0.3350870907306671,
0.2647098898887634,
-0.11361942440271378,
1.2419519424438477,
-0.3352055847644806,
0.52073734998703,
0.05668966844677925,
0.11397355794906616,
0.3327580690383911,
0.027942035347223282,
0.5781630873680115,
0.005452826619148254,
-0.3504485487937927,
0.03083057329058647,
0.05832207575440407,
-0.38510212302207947,
-0.5177643299102783,
0.7388107776641846,
-0.5011269450187683,
-0.4020378291606903,
-0.8979396820068359,
-0.14102047681808472,
-0.24278369545936584,
-0.24796612560749054,
0.155861958861351,
0.7714235186576843,
-0.3215148448944092,
0.3085610270500183,
0.44571712613105774,
0.004547505639493465,
0.36006462574005127,
0.7998462319374084,
-0.23927409946918488,
-0.5079171657562256,
0.8721237182617188,
0.4541303813457489,
-0.2684957683086395,
0.3790305554866791,
0.17045071721076965,
-0.14645478129386902,
-0.20602868497371674,
-0.667253315448761,
-0.1561385989189148,
-0.6049557328224182,
-0.3713515102863312,
-0.1683300882577896,
-0.2109932005405426,
-0.5660000443458557,
-0.7632966637611389,
-0.19507072865962982,
-0.6108421087265015,
-0.017837118357419968,
-0.37339797616004944,
0.4615374505519867,
0.907740592956543,
-0.13705749809741974,
-0.19406266510486603,
-0.423216313123703,
0.05999808385968208,
0.06587549299001694,
0.615286648273468,
-0.31954464316368103,
-0.6848100423812866,
-0.39260247349739075,
-0.17040930688381195,
-0.1745847463607788,
-0.6615326404571533,
0.18270155787467957,
0.6202191710472107,
0.26981809735298157,
0.3745548129081726,
0.20633506774902344,
0.899745762348175,
-0.5194298028945923,
0.7638214826583862,
-0.22378921508789062,
-0.8058194518089294,
0.5013090372085571,
-0.4000745415687561,
0.030026277527213097,
0.4231208264827728,
0.1973399519920349,
-0.6364457607269287,
-0.25972265005111694,
-0.5942930579185486,
-0.8020867705345154,
0.9092389345169067,
0.09131649136543274,
-0.04305658116936684,
0.21931999921798706,
0.3661413788795471,
0.08730818331241608,
0.359568327665329,
-0.8693686127662659,
-0.162912979722023,
0.07836087793111801,
-0.7030120491981506,
-0.06706497818231583,
-0.043165139853954315,
-0.13041742146015167,
-0.5274744629859924,
0.8655938506126404,
0.07566092908382416,
-0.013047628104686737,
0.35572272539138794,
-0.06848286837339401,
-0.4748653471469879,
0.12598004937171936,
0.30778589844703674,
0.5720833539962769,
0.017305264249444008,
-0.2246771901845932,
0.23650680482387543,
-0.9348713159561157,
0.19402889907360077,
0.0008011112222447991,
-0.2274055778980255,
-0.2297787070274353,
0.7249854207038879,
0.1422450840473175,
0.030939102172851562,
-0.5879768133163452,
0.8152612447738647,
-0.08367570489645004,
-0.0446983203291893,
-0.9177587628364563,
0.02593603916466236,
-0.4999227523803711,
-0.31254956126213074,
0.28217557072639465,
0.30862051248550415,
0.20869246125221252,
-0.3956497311592102,
0.5364099740982056,
0.3351162075996399,
-0.3707558810710907,
-0.13593532145023346,
0.29494592547416687,
0.4055268466472626,
-0.41228529810905457,
0.05675537884235382,
-0.13787735998630524,
-0.1152336522936821,
0.6033026576042175,
0.6198885440826416,
0.6190027594566345,
-0.8138938546180725,
0.38667571544647217,
0.4778679609298706,
0.5244544148445129,
-0.05271273851394653,
0.3996678292751312,
0.09828518331050873,
-0.4754642844200134,
-0.3769657611846924,
-1.3212636709213257,
-0.645272970199585,
0.44208818674087524,
-0.7198804616928101,
0.6584248542785645,
-0.44527921080589294,
0.43284618854522705,
-0.5138050317764282,
0.20375290513038635,
-0.4329642355442047,
0.6731422543525696,
-0.1577516794204712,
0.7938442826271057,
-1.158282995223999,
0.34093785285949707,
1.146167516708374,
-0.18523479998111725,
-0.8446938991546631,
-0.13080108165740967,
-0.06521542370319366,
-0.33323997259140015,
-0.1320692002773285,
0.2795318365097046,
-0.11874575912952423,
-0.14613325893878937,
-0.330562561750412,
-0.8368318676948547,
0.8247852921485901,
0.15986068546772003,
-0.39283958077430725,
-0.013164608739316463,
0.6139988303184509,
0.6299418807029724,
-0.6628383994102478,
0.5805683732032776,
0.47356459498405457,
0.4247112572193146,
-0.10100918263196945,
-0.5264697670936584,
-0.3670652508735657,
-0.5171050429344177,
-0.47886359691619873,
0.07127110660076141,
-0.5500524640083313,
1.0621612071990967,
0.19238203763961792,
-0.0667344480752945,
-0.007153287064284086,
0.1011640727519989,
-0.17590484023094177,
0.5872660279273987,
0.26436325907707214,
0.832685112953186,
0.8858652710914612,
-0.44500604271888733,
0.6791723370552063,
-0.12034888565540314,
0.19782200455665588,
0.9202326536178589,
-0.4045456647872925,
0.8322504758834839,
0.1535811722278595,
-0.27748948335647583,
0.6432300209999084,
0.3037914037704468,
0.1396552324295044,
0.08852244913578033,
0.24397018551826477,
-0.23969389498233795,
-0.4848800301551819,
0.08822068572044373,
-0.20213495194911957,
0.8561729192733765,
0.3217937648296356,
-0.337736040353775,
-0.0003177194739691913,
0.1480795443058014,
0.08083317428827286,
0.3953758478164673,
-0.4436659514904022,
0.7007976770401001,
-0.03632223978638649,
-0.7653751969337463,
-0.07556795328855515,
-0.03213774412870407,
0.12817107141017914,
-0.43285465240478516,
-0.5660357475280762,
-0.31992194056510925,
0.25680074095726013,
-0.38188523054122925,
-0.610336422920227,
0.10993366688489914,
0.24229255318641663,
-0.05091100558638573,
-0.3180321156978607,
0.8767223358154297,
-0.3757789134979248,
-1.1588480472564697,
-0.22302991151809692,
0.5090736746788025,
-0.08902890235185623,
0.3001011908054352,
-0.32319214940071106,
-0.18559759855270386,
-0.4280121922492981,
-0.5266677737236023,
0.23060037195682526,
0.42333951592445374,
-0.08817766606807709,
0.42014509439468384,
0.7075780034065247,
0.2320464849472046,
-0.2063666582107544,
0.05735044181346893,
0.5602786540985107,
-0.574008584022522,
-0.7911179661750793,
-0.44346123933792114,
0.6667670011520386,
-0.6022890210151672,
-0.5283973217010498,
0.6192847490310669,
0.7126099467277527,
0.8037708401679993,
-0.06212833896279335,
0.8365290760993958,
0.11531876027584076,
0.9468755722045898,
-0.49987056851387024,
0.8029583096504211,
-0.5727038979530334,
0.35774049162864685,
-0.7211359739303589,
-0.7428955435752869,
-0.3561810553073883,
1.1332979202270508,
-0.1563049703836441,
0.14918671548366547,
0.7700101137161255,
0.9261318445205688,
-0.0002271957346238196,
0.21764694154262543,
0.4850767254829407,
-0.02997327409684658,
0.06345784664154053,
0.22832262516021729,
0.7747658491134644,
-0.5980615019798279,
0.20525749027729034,
-0.24746327102184296,
-0.5574848055839539,
-0.30364423990249634,
-0.9531676173210144,
-0.7169854044914246,
-0.7406342625617981,
-0.44033846259117126,
-0.09248822182416916,
0.3800928294658661,
0.9712706208229065,
0.4136410653591156,
-0.860691249370575,
-0.26667675375938416,
0.013344121165573597,
-0.03792491555213928,
-0.3440351188182831,
-0.3694497048854828,
0.2759162485599518,
-0.35518816113471985,
-0.7796783447265625,
0.24299119412899017,
0.2850950360298157,
-0.2776712477207184,
-0.14124490320682526,
0.20128752291202545,
-0.03808228299021721,
0.6140962243080139,
0.3661656081676483,
-0.1742922067642212,
-0.09921769052743912,
-0.5181872844696045,
0.04384131729602814,
-0.05632854625582695,
0.013204061426222324,
0.7714047431945801,
-0.8265631794929504,
0.14659017324447632,
0.20533160865306854,
0.17136870324611664,
-0.0666520744562149,
0.0033890705090016127,
0.565790593624115,
-0.9531474709510803,
-0.028953824192285538,
0.5287900567054749,
0.5827264189720154,
0.4053190350532532,
-0.37982434034347534,
0.445757120847702,
0.2874331772327423,
-0.7988520264625549,
-0.8126772046089172,
0.11318009346723557,
-0.6174097061157227,
-0.02703653648495674,
0.8524418473243713,
-0.37476953864097595,
-0.27013278007507324,
-0.2188812643289566,
-0.19888851046562195,
-0.06348484754562378,
-0.26747164130210876,
0.9133864045143127,
0.7959375381469727,
0.07125820964574814,
0.16566814482212067,
-0.14613138139247894,
0.8978362679481506,
0.27872171998023987,
-0.9180355668067932,
0.11143414676189423,
0.6016533970832825,
0.06289873272180557,
0.11714845150709152,
0.48056042194366455,
-0.01768719218671322,
0.5832284092903137,
-0.0018595895962789655,
-0.10355003923177719,
-0.09370296448469162,
-0.7170581817626953,
-0.15025441348552704,
0.6157650351524353,
-0.2167821079492569,
-0.007061758078634739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13625v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13625v2
|
MORE: Multi-mOdal REtrieval Augmented Generative Commonsense Reasoning
| 2024-02-21T08:54:47 | 2024-06-14T02:55:46 |
Wanqing Cui, Keping Bi, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Since commonsense information has been recorded significantly less frequently
than its existence, language models pre-trained by text generation have
difficulty to learn sufficient commonsense knowledge. Several studies have
leveraged text retrieval to augment the models' commonsense ability. Unlike
text, images capture commonsense information inherently but little effort has
been paid to effectively utilize them. In this work, we propose a novel
Multi-mOdal REtrieval (MORE) augmentation framework, to leverage both text and
images to enhance the commonsense ability of language models. Extensive
experiments on the Common-Gen task have demonstrated the efficacy of MORE based
on the pre-trained models of both single and multiple modalities.
|
[
-0.39418408274650574,
-0.6759656071662903,
0.7205743789672852,
-0.11544861644506454,
-0.24599318206310272,
-0.09884840995073318,
-0.1066957414150238,
-0.5202177166938782,
0.047689542174339294,
0.28922560811042786,
-0.3781031668186188,
-0.13215389847755432,
-0.6387065649032593,
0.28612202405929565,
-0.03933370113372803,
0.5492190718650818,
0.4836392402648926,
0.0910838171839714,
-0.45566949248313904,
-0.18693673610687256,
-0.3698514401912689,
-0.48686355352401733,
-0.3615427613258362,
-0.2832019329071045,
0.49779918789863586,
0.3062220811843872,
0.8998696208000183,
0.1720745861530304,
0.36697959899902344,
0.4451417326927185,
-0.06035545840859413,
0.63029944896698,
-0.2224346399307251,
-0.08159149438142776,
-0.2967016100883484,
-0.30488792061805725,
-0.3070593476295471,
-0.0041210162453353405,
0.4813549220561981,
0.46437588334083557,
0.12480884790420532,
-0.23174157738685608,
-0.21238994598388672,
0.3477737605571747,
-0.9366018772125244,
0.051544398069381714,
-0.7350503206253052,
-0.24879011511802673,
-0.03593560680747032,
-0.42210203409194946,
-0.42949989438056946,
-0.12212646007537842,
0.0641215369105339,
-1.1418530941009521,
0.17667311429977417,
-0.00016825996863190085,
0.7160972356796265,
0.11041781306266785,
-0.8607280850410461,
-0.13511379063129425,
-0.22391757369041443,
0.9787107706069946,
-0.5587013959884644,
0.7118456959724426,
0.5562089085578918,
0.042667314410209656,
0.1826762706041336,
-0.8969742655754089,
-1.085559606552124,
-0.6740292906761169,
-0.4427104592323303,
0.08155235648155212,
0.04900595173239708,
0.08248507231473923,
0.28762853145599365,
0.44265076518058777,
-0.21544116735458374,
-0.2266520857810974,
-0.3224759101867676,
-0.33583739399909973,
0.3428562879562378,
-0.1379372924566269,
0.5032619833946228,
-0.4665989279747009,
-0.7512070536613464,
-0.2751588225364685,
-0.4201875627040863,
-0.138188436627388,
0.2501707375049591,
0.21200881898403168,
-0.15296882390975952,
0.6636266112327576,
-0.1075238585472107,
1.0556327104568481,
-0.11156900972127914,
-0.3278895914554596,
0.6372429132461548,
-0.697758674621582,
-0.07245870679616928,
-0.3287539780139923,
0.4602932929992676,
0.44623491168022156,
-0.035301901400089264,
0.3676557242870331,
-0.33303576707839966,
-0.006318624597042799,
-0.046413298696279526,
-0.5570494532585144,
-0.2070724368095398,
-0.10974238812923431,
-0.6254448294639587,
-0.32595351338386536,
-0.015449590049684048,
-0.7317224144935608,
-0.334983229637146,
-0.5791943073272705,
0.5781325101852417,
-0.6138850450515747,
-0.6671955585479736,
0.18809561431407928,
-0.5882632732391357,
0.1397591233253479,
0.5279367566108704,
-0.8054878115653992,
-0.053480055183172226,
0.6527742147445679,
0.7721484303474426,
0.12743273377418518,
-0.47439828515052795,
-0.5707634687423706,
0.18535518646240234,
-0.12975405156612396,
0.8648785948753357,
-1.3026877641677856,
-0.35042083263397217,
-0.049509692937135696,
-0.05230835825204849,
-0.2158086895942688,
-0.43937012553215027,
0.5541078448295593,
-0.808465301990509,
0.38076794147491455,
-0.5005637407302856,
-0.41156017780303955,
-0.4167487621307373,
0.4631003141403198,
-1.1033825874328613,
0.8357839584350586,
-0.012123971246182919,
-0.6516541838645935,
0.6176533699035645,
-0.9165282845497131,
-0.6440337896347046,
0.22535857558250427,
-0.2924184799194336,
-0.04489998146891594,
0.04043370857834816,
0.5458921790122986,
0.5063548684120178,
-0.172517329454422,
0.34708645939826965,
-0.3731599450111389,
-0.08907559514045715,
0.4304693937301636,
-1.1219229698181152,
0.6104243993759155,
0.3229498863220215,
0.08931351453065872,
-0.060795627534389496,
-0.7042831182479858,
-0.24451127648353577,
-0.05421081930398941,
-0.6105281114578247,
-0.6035075187683105,
-0.2740824222564697,
0.3432450294494629,
0.2158251851797104,
0.3292441666126251,
-0.5671485662460327,
0.06736263632774353,
0.010984820313751698,
0.20612098276615143,
0.5384917259216309,
-0.16672754287719727,
0.4739372432231903,
-0.5406521558761597,
0.10585727542638779,
0.04047384485602379,
0.0712566152215004,
-0.46664226055145264,
-0.4689275622367859,
-0.34890642762184143,
-0.6064159274101257,
-0.07794803380966187,
0.36119258403778076,
-1.2581809759140015,
0.0331270769238472,
-0.4732554852962494,
-0.05787103995680809,
-0.38102734088897705,
0.2813876271247864,
0.5735399127006531,
0.4401000142097473,
0.5710455775260925,
-0.2418520301580429,
-0.33979129791259766,
-0.6799758672714233,
-0.12433222681283951,
0.10149195045232773,
0.10037501901388168,
0.5791889429092407,
0.5757479667663574,
0.050300467759370804,
0.6038821339607239,
-0.5262972116470337,
-0.2275315523147583,
-0.22374819219112396,
0.5113442540168762,
-0.033707208931446075,
0.6050217151641846,
0.5254000425338745,
-1.3262025117874146,
-0.25288406014442444,
0.09845545887947083,
-0.6372988224029541,
0.23771122097969055,
-0.30696696043014526,
0.24117016792297363,
-0.01752481795847416,
0.542290449142456,
-0.6608405113220215,
0.1001381054520607,
0.43750908970832825,
-0.2510858178138733,
0.5943395495414734,
-0.32356297969818115,
0.7985806465148926,
-1.0068845748901367,
0.06103800609707832,
0.19664382934570312,
-0.3552878201007843,
-0.49847927689552307,
0.20784489810466766,
0.09981513768434525,
-0.22203637659549713,
-0.5239825248718262,
0.684024453163147,
-0.7616810202598572,
-0.017383011057972908,
-0.3431863486766815,
0.07480456680059433,
0.37962275743484497,
0.42436790466308594,
0.3759142756462097,
1.1139726638793945,
0.692004382610321,
-0.6626995205879211,
0.6667608618736267,
0.17039819061756134,
-0.3964237570762634,
1.0884000062942505,
-0.5270729064941406,
-0.02562420256435871,
-0.45083385705947876,
0.15471744537353516,
-0.9890745282173157,
-0.5215847492218018,
-0.09095443040132523,
-0.40981999039649963,
0.2765921354293823,
-0.14784908294677734,
-0.6246095299720764,
-0.2315608412027359,
-0.3064175844192505,
0.7306803464889526,
0.06656953692436218,
-1.0351455211639404,
0.7470226287841797,
0.17282357811927795,
-0.03944753110408783,
-0.7870277166366577,
-0.705719530582428,
0.10504736751317978,
0.09675794094800949,
-0.5014078617095947,
0.3074203133583069,
0.024921489879488945,
-0.12132591754198074,
0.11590289324522018,
0.31965693831443787,
-0.44058752059936523,
-0.12821945548057556,
-0.2542635202407837,
0.4517781436443329,
-0.22878189384937286,
0.6149499416351318,
0.1546974778175354,
-0.0345214307308197,
-0.40234625339508057,
0.11111105233430862,
0.5466479659080505,
-0.15449360013008118,
-0.6944131255149841,
-0.5851224660873413,
0.5170372128486633,
0.6366252303123474,
-0.44380444288253784,
0.6141847372055054,
0.8185572624206543,
-0.20976383984088898,
0.38519543409347534,
-0.8155952095985413,
-0.3750801086425781,
-0.5003960132598877,
0.5203439593315125,
-0.6493983864784241,
-0.8491060137748718,
0.07064153254032135,
-0.24939103424549103,
-0.07598414272069931,
0.32578423619270325,
0.2604290544986725,
-0.022264286875724792,
1.0359736680984497,
0.3493897616863251,
0.26937809586524963,
0.5076102614402771,
-0.1387595385313034,
-0.09265205264091492,
-0.9112523794174194,
-0.45318734645843506,
-0.11409343034029007,
-0.19945108890533447,
-0.25973936915397644,
-0.8308935165405273,
0.4181477427482605,
0.054373521357774734,
0.017577173188328743,
0.23498916625976562,
-0.5850989818572998,
0.6112048029899597,
0.6284264326095581,
0.5610246658325195,
0.7453674674034119,
0.02617574855685234,
-0.03763941302895546,
0.15661725401878357,
-0.5631992220878601,
-0.3259655833244324,
0.9814234972000122,
-0.05196564272046089,
0.6796256303787231,
0.4215214252471924,
0.3199150264263153,
0.2064613550901413,
0.3461662232875824,
-0.507310152053833,
0.5576900839805603,
-0.21920017898082733,
-1.0375877618789673,
-0.20431961119174957,
-0.3790833353996277,
-0.8826314210891724,
0.5468219518661499,
-0.631295382976532,
-0.3807709217071533,
0.49923431873321533,
0.3904283344745636,
-0.39432257413864136,
0.3250954747200012,
-0.8950366973876953,
0.6200201511383057,
-0.41069167852401733,
-0.5041632056236267,
-0.6167110800743103,
-0.6431941390037537,
0.6505744457244873,
0.12955020368099213,
0.40598922967910767,
0.17884567379951477,
-0.36304420232772827,
0.24274484813213348,
-0.29349491000175476,
1.0315372943878174,
-0.11503949761390686,
0.026415685191750526,
0.19837191700935364,
-0.34044572710990906,
0.38725826144218445,
0.07076933234930038,
-0.06347938627004623,
-0.3242446780204773,
-0.05481191352009773,
-0.5725289583206177,
-0.7093436121940613,
0.79201740026474,
-0.4733297526836395,
-0.42450249195098877,
-0.22636957466602325,
-0.5816959738731384,
-0.07403185218572617,
0.23557375371456146,
0.12411875277757645,
0.8367951512336731,
-0.036188945174217224,
0.2393568903207779,
0.6448577642440796,
-0.3401818871498108,
0.5205146670341492,
0.1822923868894577,
0.05620456114411354,
-0.6384482383728027,
1.0000128746032715,
-0.2612210214138031,
0.5499423146247864,
0.7118640542030334,
0.11061830073595047,
-0.7875136733055115,
-0.27432259917259216,
-0.430398553609848,
0.11303552985191345,
-0.8060201406478882,
-0.38877439498901367,
-0.6258541941642761,
0.22652682662010193,
-0.7089935541152954,
-0.20390424132347107,
-0.15862247347831726,
-0.39768412709236145,
-0.33449414372444153,
-0.139974445104599,
0.6929581761360168,
0.46415114402770996,
-0.576388955116272,
0.3344312608242035,
-1.0073827505111694,
0.7545529007911682,
0.8125811219215393,
0.48383811116218567,
0.1985647827386856,
-0.3407156765460968,
0.25295165181159973,
0.08835486322641373,
-0.18928351998329163,
-1.061076283454895,
0.16592860221862793,
0.3680981695652008,
0.8188655972480774,
0.4760308265686035,
-0.10991750657558441,
0.7546339631080627,
-0.09970841556787491,
0.7483280301094055,
0.7490605711936951,
-0.8717607855796814,
0.37542998790740967,
-0.19154050946235657,
0.1032552495598793,
0.5376297235488892,
0.4116609990596771,
-0.20096851885318756,
0.18717114627361298,
-0.4792832136154175,
-0.6394568681716919,
0.3319196105003357,
-0.001109313452616334,
0.7188912630081177,
-0.2882634997367859,
-0.05246442183852196,
0.1924261450767517,
0.24432148039340973,
-1.0670781135559082,
-0.1379484385251999,
-0.5135591626167297,
-0.09286587685346603,
0.2546246647834778,
-0.3770752549171448,
-0.20956425368785858,
-0.4894886016845703,
0.5190265774726868,
-0.23658499121665955,
0.14289119839668274,
0.21559952199459076,
-0.4200865924358368,
0.32449567317962646,
0.6295366883277893,
0.6852226257324219,
0.45900043845176697,
0.10400224477052689,
0.47437170147895813,
0.1956474632024765,
-0.3069871962070465,
-0.035824455320835114,
0.3885253369808197,
0.050370581448078156,
-0.0034162397496402264,
0.4359422028064728,
0.8788648247718811,
0.4054030776023865,
-0.7356033325195312,
0.9045789241790771,
0.3035801649093628,
-0.21351328492164612,
-0.03510347008705139,
-0.1871630698442459,
0.09170838445425034,
0.40947261452674866,
0.4983904957771301,
0.25032201409339905,
0.35838714241981506,
-0.636243999004364,
0.5071885585784912,
0.7488803863525391,
-0.18363794684410095,
-0.10300298035144806,
0.40476685762405396,
0.4634482264518738,
-0.05226557329297066,
0.36678433418273926,
-0.4505780041217804,
-0.4981582462787628,
0.20456741750240326,
0.6477464437484741,
0.22813913226127625,
-0.012703836895525455,
0.4568157196044922,
0.5302881598472595,
0.0836721658706665,
-0.1719084233045578,
0.35399240255355835,
-0.385343998670578,
-0.8735135197639465,
-0.8060405850410461,
-0.19807618856430054,
-0.0659768283367157,
0.27144482731819153,
-0.34456866979599,
0.22637902200222015,
-0.16296537220478058,
-0.20164474844932556,
-0.16371606290340424,
-0.2467319369316101,
-0.6006660461425781,
0.4252864420413971,
0.0835411474108696,
0.5992641448974609,
-0.9582064747810364,
0.5292661786079407,
0.7233413457870483,
-0.8382545113563538,
-0.6374039649963379,
-0.32331737875938416,
-0.06970763951539993,
-0.9672252535820007,
0.7353523373603821,
0.07917182892560959,
-0.2571556866168976,
0.13543905317783356,
-0.7809920310974121,
-0.7930744886398315,
1.037650227546692,
0.20894773304462433,
-0.3873721957206726,
-0.015525300055742264,
-0.15189744532108307,
0.21789704263210297,
-0.08051561564207077,
0.5214895009994507,
0.2962888181209564,
0.7873098254203796,
0.5813943147659302,
-0.882103443145752,
0.18300336599349976,
-0.38574373722076416,
-0.04166866093873978,
0.06151585280895233,
-0.280914843082428,
0.7903944849967957,
-0.6555957198143005,
-0.2887605130672455,
0.026573775336146355,
0.6453437805175781,
0.4628596901893616,
0.6003062129020691,
0.6859142780303955,
0.7850768566131592,
0.7333306074142456,
0.20163854956626892,
1.097869873046875,
0.008771438151597977,
0.19844885170459747,
1.2721195220947266,
0.06788484752178192,
0.7825538516044617,
0.6433593034744263,
0.01922599971294403,
0.43819180130958557,
0.18497870862483978,
-0.1678198128938675,
0.6232390999794006,
-0.3896867036819458,
-0.7269635200500488,
-0.6475716233253479,
-0.49527260661125183,
-0.500726580619812,
0.43398189544677734,
0.32490846514701843,
-0.43496862053871155,
-0.355800062417984,
0.3632790148258209,
-0.16706907749176025,
0.5030732154846191,
-0.2634299397468567,
0.7507430911064148,
-0.07887464016675949,
-0.48838189244270325,
0.48611077666282654,
-0.28248921036720276,
1.1897330284118652,
-0.09308917820453644,
-0.37468013167381287,
0.1497647762298584,
-0.2736552059650421,
-0.2082868069410324,
-0.8222446441650391,
0.02800632268190384,
-0.2793677747249603,
-0.06913493573665619,
-0.17551065981388092,
0.9415701627731323,
-0.5262974500656128,
-0.6001532077789307,
-0.06733919680118561,
0.7058080434799194,
0.024801108986139297,
-0.0377449095249176,
-0.7780464887619019,
-0.18769767880439758,
-0.17523165047168732,
-0.009893414564430714,
0.00014711216499563307,
0.4235195219516754,
0.24844218790531158,
0.5749600529670715,
1.0673253536224365,
-0.0008223459590226412,
0.12187881022691727,
0.2858595550060272,
1.0282423496246338,
-0.4366614818572998,
-0.13900060951709747,
-0.6863973140716553,
0.5549494028091431,
-0.551374614238739,
-0.21752285957336426,
0.39402371644973755,
0.5951005816459656,
0.8506766557693481,
-0.23241759836673737,
0.8521400094032288,
-0.22782392799854279,
0.4539244771003723,
-0.6975746154785156,
0.4113730490207672,
-0.8909459114074707,
0.17629271745681763,
-0.2951667308807373,
-0.4929717481136322,
-0.1980724185705185,
0.7412997484207153,
-0.39287450909614563,
0.265347421169281,
0.6101218461990356,
1.1734992265701294,
-0.4088979959487915,
-0.07628070563077927,
0.6443935036659241,
-0.3299403786659241,
0.09941171854734421,
0.4671269655227661,
1.0303547382354736,
-0.230200856924057,
0.5978832840919495,
-0.15213115513324738,
-0.18274080753326416,
-0.03662218153476715,
-1.0183382034301758,
-0.6802762150764465,
-0.869650661945343,
-0.07901827245950699,
-0.03746337816119194,
0.043305784463882446,
0.9297930002212524,
0.806443989276886,
-0.408304899930954,
0.3399637043476105,
-0.1885979324579239,
0.17862288653850555,
-0.12253125011920929,
-0.2823924720287323,
0.2192896157503128,
-0.5299103856086731,
-0.9242379665374756,
0.2659003734588623,
0.10950317233800888,
0.17032694816589355,
-0.05071680620312691,
-0.07197141647338867,
-0.6974329948425293,
-0.05506709963083267,
0.9097265005111694,
0.21766561269760132,
-0.7109228372573853,
-0.30559536814689636,
-0.01841101609170437,
-0.21195034682750702,
0.18935322761535645,
0.9813932776451111,
-0.8917561769485474,
0.650336742401123,
0.696511447429657,
0.6140965819358826,
0.3459291160106659,
0.11267082393169403,
0.5274143815040588,
-0.7621266841888428,
0.219017893075943,
0.1560157984495163,
0.3528456389904022,
0.7171086668968201,
-0.31853240728378296,
0.047036223113536835,
0.4330924451351166,
-0.10881005972623825,
-0.502406120300293,
0.5461331605911255,
-0.9374629855155945,
-0.523288369178772,
1.2369318008422852,
0.06303589791059494,
0.1684301793575287,
-0.3779691457748413,
-0.3135533332824707,
0.31765633821487427,
-0.5235059261322021,
0.5803031921386719,
0.36164599657058716,
0.07566595077514648,
-0.7051697969436646,
-0.355049729347229,
0.47795721888542175,
0.4790007770061493,
-0.8789780735969543,
-0.18964126706123352,
0.973959743976593,
0.12854938209056854,
0.45556211471557617,
0.7903175950050354,
-0.1971103549003601,
0.46394190192222595,
0.11933033913373947,
-0.27832934260368347,
-0.3692092299461365,
-0.21934820711612701,
-0.03122243843972683,
0.21265234053134918,
0.006355691235512495,
-0.21655268967151642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13623v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13623v1
|
FLAME: Self-Supervised Low-Resource Taxonomy Expansion using Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T08:50:40 | 2024-02-21T08:50:40 |
Sahil Mishra, Ujjwal Sudev, Tanmoy Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Taxonomies represent an arborescence hierarchical structure that establishes
relationships among entities to convey knowledge within a specific domain. Each
edge in the taxonomy signifies a hypernym-hyponym relationship. Taxonomies find
utility in various real-world applications, such as e-commerce search engines
and recommendation systems. Consequently, there arises a necessity to enhance
these taxonomies over time. However, manually curating taxonomies with neoteric
data presents challenges due to limitations in available human resources and
the exponential growth of data. Therefore, it becomes imperative to develop
automatic taxonomy expansion methods. Traditional supervised taxonomy expansion
approaches encounter difficulties stemming from limited resources, primarily
due to the small size of existing taxonomies. This scarcity of training data
often leads to overfitting. In this paper, we propose FLAME, a novel approach
for taxonomy expansion in low-resource environments by harnessing the
capabilities of large language models that are trained on extensive real-world
knowledge. LLMs help compensate for the scarcity of domain-specific knowledge.
Specifically, FLAME leverages prompting in few-shot settings to extract the
inherent knowledge within the LLMs, ascertaining the hypernym entities within
the taxonomy. Furthermore, it employs reinforcement learning to fine-tune the
large language models, resulting in more accurate predictions. Experiments on
three real-world benchmark datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of FLAME in
real-world scenarios, achieving a remarkable improvement of 18.5% in accuracy
and 12.3% in Wu & Palmer metric over eight baselines. Furthermore, we elucidate
the strengths and weaknesses of FLAME through an extensive case study, error
analysis and ablation studies on the benchmarks.
|
[
-0.3244444727897644,
-0.7658378481864929,
0.23506882786750793,
0.15431664884090424,
-0.028740111738443375,
0.34995347261428833,
-0.4296613931655884,
-0.3742579519748688,
0.3178512752056122,
0.6521987318992615,
-0.5906109809875488,
-0.5464016199111938,
-0.4516716003417969,
0.09134101122617722,
-0.08697936683893204,
0.9910723567008972,
0.13043642044067383,
-0.6710544228553772,
-0.07297144830226898,
-0.01183117926120758,
-0.14086683094501495,
-0.49052438139915466,
-0.3308975398540497,
-0.12614786624908447,
0.90749192237854,
0.5522464513778687,
0.7450122833251953,
0.9694278836250305,
0.6686496138572693,
0.3357594609260559,
-0.04250471293926239,
0.23192039132118225,
-0.6344624161720276,
0.06535373628139496,
-0.20292246341705322,
-0.2676949203014374,
-0.2071039378643036,
-0.13841263949871063,
0.38587379455566406,
0.36702755093574524,
-0.5068249702453613,
0.20120657980442047,
-0.11962630599737167,
0.5248398780822754,
-0.8745291829109192,
0.2860991060733795,
-0.8699948787689209,
-0.12857165932655334,
-0.2021450251340866,
-0.34191757440567017,
-0.25562697649002075,
-0.2869061529636383,
0.30316922068595886,
-0.7759815454483032,
0.06041388586163521,
0.1591479480266571,
0.6212111711502075,
0.43933960795402527,
-0.49824467301368713,
-0.3775990307331085,
-1.0058757066726685,
0.8864795565605164,
-0.614149808883667,
0.3553112745285034,
-0.04039309546351433,
0.3065386712551117,
-0.07296708226203918,
-0.8684672713279724,
-0.41061636805534363,
0.037685807794332504,
-0.3183063268661499,
0.11592010408639908,
-0.333597868680954,
0.30305251479148865,
0.2701742649078369,
0.19003547728061676,
-0.5465418100357056,
0.39555320143699646,
-0.4527533948421478,
-0.16287274658679962,
0.6881155371665955,
0.26230740547180176,
0.14316073060035706,
-0.4553242623806,
-0.5714766383171082,
-0.17426668107509613,
-0.5786588191986084,
-0.4621381163597107,
0.417978972196579,
0.4872962236404419,
0.12425471097230911,
0.5328332185745239,
-0.14606589078903198,
0.6993647813796997,
-0.30930399894714355,
-0.255185067653656,
0.12960012257099152,
-0.1912478506565094,
-0.31691500544548035,
0.05302908271551132,
0.7167313694953918,
0.2505749762058258,
-0.10893513262271881,
-0.1816682368516922,
0.02225428633391857,
0.2459256649017334,
0.13271254301071167,
-0.740795910358429,
-0.3442530632019043,
0.09132469445466995,
-0.22425897419452667,
-0.4613015353679657,
-0.5362712740898132,
-1.2366828918457031,
-0.3682038187980652,
-0.07926250994205475,
0.3942011892795563,
-0.2579576075077057,
-0.5967006087303162,
-0.05284915864467621,
0.054995469748973846,
-0.2259862720966339,
0.18203650414943695,
-1.036898136138916,
0.06591695547103882,
0.7298747897148132,
0.853888750076294,
-0.23195838928222656,
-0.22971969842910767,
-0.2871735095977783,
0.20564018189907074,
-0.26176783442497253,
0.45307087898254395,
-0.7809613943099976,
-0.25924646854400635,
0.12821117043495178,
-0.2140418142080307,
0.04697905853390694,
-0.6210977435112,
0.41439947485923767,
-0.812278151512146,
0.2281607687473297,
0.09947118908166885,
-0.693080723285675,
-0.030925678089261055,
0.166471928358078,
-0.4932355284690857,
1.0838162899017334,
0.4154394268989563,
-0.7409256100654602,
0.4706006646156311,
-0.6715874075889587,
0.011201411485671997,
0.29092666506767273,
-0.10558774322271347,
-0.2367793470621109,
-0.016744639724493027,
0.13356484472751617,
0.5327440500259399,
-0.532152533531189,
0.3252039849758148,
-0.3698129653930664,
-0.044479675590991974,
-0.22879593074321747,
-0.10598217695951462,
0.5700199604034424,
0.42960068583488464,
-0.15475037693977356,
0.163519024848938,
-0.5216033458709717,
0.10193230211734772,
-0.12988132238388062,
-0.18651919066905975,
-0.6568759679794312,
-0.2913363575935364,
0.07065419107675552,
0.36113297939300537,
0.13202069699764252,
-0.4852573573589325,
0.5886126756668091,
-0.5915389657020569,
0.1933436095714569,
0.6222145557403564,
0.22162549197673798,
0.7023484110832214,
-0.16670869290828705,
0.8334934711456299,
-0.03703860193490982,
0.008219613693654537,
-0.08964075893163681,
-0.19548338651657104,
-0.7624870538711548,
-0.39060017466545105,
0.42092010378837585,
0.41083937883377075,
-1.1774892807006836,
0.5786144137382507,
-0.44747394323349,
-1.0044727325439453,
-0.3522973954677582,
0.5642122030258179,
0.26259171962738037,
0.5130290985107422,
0.33934286236763,
-0.22261998057365417,
-0.6412222981452942,
-0.6060739159584045,
0.018281081691384315,
-0.385227233171463,
0.10043992102146149,
0.46266964077949524,
0.43185099959373474,
-0.5378580093383789,
1.0292894840240479,
-0.8172320127487183,
-0.5922523736953735,
-0.13263462483882904,
0.4076520502567291,
0.1080472394824028,
0.31173309683799744,
0.4971486032009125,
-0.4858136773109436,
-0.398349404335022,
0.10075786709785461,
-0.7397300004959106,
-0.020150702446699142,
-0.22230471670627594,
-0.3539815843105316,
0.11812645196914673,
0.486335426568985,
-0.2803870737552643,
-0.08611135929822922,
0.682806670665741,
-0.24073107540607452,
0.5438618659973145,
-0.12714844942092896,
-0.28751829266548157,
-1.0066028833389282,
-0.17862775921821594,
0.33408764004707336,
0.2833322584629059,
-0.5352869629859924,
0.3258739411830902,
-0.09494255483150482,
-0.004726910963654518,
-0.5717021226882935,
1.0150792598724365,
-0.3061804175376892,
0.036633722484111786,
-0.25757139921188354,
-0.031144749373197556,
-0.36149004101753235,
0.5887343287467957,
0.42202529311180115,
0.489725798368454,
0.701461911201477,
-0.5901918411254883,
0.8594475984573364,
0.05765248090028763,
-0.1774962693452835,
0.4236339032649994,
-0.09511330723762512,
-0.3040473163127899,
0.005907746497541666,
0.1982089728116989,
-0.8053793907165527,
-0.38102957606315613,
-0.0470447801053524,
-0.10821390151977539,
-0.004274153150618076,
-0.4340565502643585,
-0.7379567623138428,
-0.5371072292327881,
0.1808566153049469,
0.2432776242494583,
0.6742910146713257,
-0.8895913362503052,
0.5961850881576538,
0.2491406798362732,
0.022491522133350372,
-0.6587859392166138,
-0.10554198920726776,
-0.0021388083696365356,
-0.666735053062439,
-0.6693634390830994,
0.1081843227148056,
0.12486641108989716,
-0.3708089292049408,
0.09647322446107864,
-0.015743829309940338,
-0.06384168565273285,
0.0761038064956665,
0.07447446137666702,
0.12391410768032074,
-0.2633680999279022,
0.5812036991119385,
-0.1589484065771103,
0.12796904146671295,
0.21598534286022186,
-0.421867311000824,
0.5421640872955322,
0.03881516307592392,
-0.03895753622055054,
-0.17717359960079193,
-0.16916510462760925,
0.4921417534351349,
-0.03917727991938591,
0.6506978273391724,
0.7218958735466003,
-0.3484642207622528,
-0.5196502804756165,
-0.5991988182067871,
-0.31473007798194885,
-0.5609245300292969,
0.30279749631881714,
-0.14757263660430908,
-0.8290562629699707,
0.348879337310791,
-0.5861657857894897,
0.1469113677740097,
0.7323802709579468,
0.4414210319519043,
-0.2008828967809677,
0.5582491755485535,
0.7921591997146606,
-0.09061522781848907,
0.4616563320159912,
-0.6590660810470581,
-0.16022329032421112,
-0.8722560405731201,
-0.1518072783946991,
-0.2530724108219147,
-0.373407781124115,
-0.842183530330658,
-0.6241623759269714,
0.3605499267578125,
-0.13642334938049316,
-0.060124289244413376,
0.5475361943244934,
-0.5063561797142029,
0.4343802332878113,
0.4232487082481384,
0.04575777053833008,
0.389830082654953,
0.15018586814403534,
0.019496290013194084,
-0.27010297775268555,
-1.0502952337265015,
-0.15104463696479797,
1.2114471197128296,
0.34682559967041016,
1.1110249757766724,
0.2533907890319824,
1.1067180633544922,
0.2690444886684418,
0.5971909165382385,
-1.0170080661773682,
0.29046180844306946,
-0.09077110886573792,
-0.7616912126541138,
-0.8029211759567261,
-0.7554609179496765,
-0.9494363069534302,
0.28051117062568665,
-0.32833489775657654,
-0.27151423692703247,
0.36604607105255127,
0.2360333353281021,
-0.45224833488464355,
0.49649277329444885,
-0.6689577698707581,
0.695280909538269,
-0.6069221496582031,
-0.6253856420516968,
-0.25791820883750916,
-0.28141313791275024,
0.6509841084480286,
-0.5031768083572388,
0.2902005910873413,
-0.039544615894556046,
-0.20632998645305634,
1.0498449802398682,
-0.3438008725643158,
0.8240033388137817,
-0.14485374093055725,
-0.46720796823501587,
0.3420060873031616,
0.2854045331478119,
0.6286550164222717,
-0.08815180510282516,
-0.119756318628788,
-0.031908899545669556,
-0.08949947357177734,
-0.2646244466304779,
-0.9960288405418396,
0.8763942122459412,
-0.5942055583000183,
-0.4701865613460541,
-0.6949685215950012,
-0.24240529537200928,
-0.5481992959976196,
0.0575665608048439,
0.10888200998306274,
0.2880859673023224,
-0.16402684152126312,
0.12946917116641998,
0.6045857667922974,
-0.2072981745004654,
0.21851171553134918,
0.5227624177932739,
-0.5086767077445984,
-0.25052016973495483,
1.1350558996200562,
0.0947338193655014,
0.35651665925979614,
0.12301748991012573,
0.3769337236881256,
-0.45007726550102234,
-0.20236846804618835,
-0.40196993947029114,
0.3387497663497925,
-0.4368053674697876,
-0.4724803566932678,
-0.7450675964355469,
-0.2609802484512329,
-0.1795872002840042,
-0.2921745181083679,
-0.037523720413446426,
-0.2515740990638733,
-0.30888208746910095,
-0.09457772225141525,
0.8631287217140198,
0.6540116667747498,
-0.1914205253124237,
0.9125515222549438,
-0.7612377405166626,
0.18408723175525665,
0.6238742470741272,
0.6051440238952637,
0.24273431301116943,
-0.5473337173461914,
-0.30856356024742126,
-0.17602796852588654,
-0.06771527975797653,
-0.6164253354072571,
0.8759551048278809,
0.2940922677516937,
0.22396071255207062,
0.5583802461624146,
0.12132912874221802,
0.833506166934967,
-0.2473142445087433,
0.40454405546188354,
0.5008452534675598,
-0.5682843327522278,
0.5127687454223633,
-0.6345629692077637,
0.17898206412792206,
0.3502905070781708,
0.6429451704025269,
-0.7050465941429138,
-0.2723599672317505,
-1.0745460987091064,
-0.7492496967315674,
0.7441849708557129,
0.16091303527355194,
0.2607850134372711,
-0.01059236004948616,
0.24804413318634033,
-0.08289798349142075,
-0.0353788286447525,
-0.3610859513282776,
-0.2549593448638916,
0.12679247558116913,
-0.00029108370654284954,
-0.38294458389282227,
-0.3065013289451599,
-0.14177842438220978,
-0.35019680857658386,
0.7046962976455688,
-0.18596196174621582,
-0.07374794781208038,
-0.23618024587631226,
-0.04911906272172928,
-0.26284167170524597,
0.4534716308116913,
0.15595752000808716,
0.3893262445926666,
-0.3340737819671631,
0.2580748498439789,
0.19916032254695892,
-0.1404319405555725,
0.3082972466945648,
-0.24275822937488556,
0.2988349497318268,
-0.001527652726508677,
0.4194004237651825,
0.6100239753723145,
0.41918858885765076,
-0.5464365482330322,
0.24330852925777435,
0.2061620056629181,
-0.05480555444955826,
-0.04766426980495453,
0.28234583139419556,
0.11001350730657578,
0.1854267716407776,
0.44153401255607605,
-0.06335844844579697,
0.10568810254335403,
-0.8624423146247864,
0.4475903809070587,
0.43462809920310974,
-0.2274593561887741,
-0.09745308756828308,
0.40818363428115845,
0.6713954210281372,
0.08101440221071243,
0.383505642414093,
-0.271635502576828,
-0.5847914814949036,
0.6725856065750122,
0.5306863784790039,
0.6057744026184082,
-0.05139191076159477,
0.382683664560318,
0.6802664399147034,
0.41777777671813965,
-0.17026367783546448,
0.014812503941357136,
0.04439035430550575,
-0.6219030022621155,
-0.4925728738307953,
-0.886590838432312,
-0.3949776589870453,
0.25816622376441956,
-0.36717355251312256,
0.26749470829963684,
-0.5380151271820068,
-0.16567401587963104,
-0.18974974751472473,
0.24473144114017487,
-0.6124457120895386,
0.39133507013320923,
0.0383223295211792,
1.039482593536377,
-1.235880732536316,
0.8572251200675964,
0.15548419952392578,
-0.2067945897579193,
-0.6610233187675476,
-0.12156174331903458,
0.07414977997541428,
-0.7204254865646362,
0.8800479769706726,
-0.4159894287586212,
-0.0580691434442997,
0.2912610173225403,
-0.3146373927593231,
-1.224000096321106,
0.90888512134552,
0.1364586353302002,
-0.676066517829895,
-0.2542312741279602,
-0.09571939706802368,
1.0127041339874268,
-0.3660576343536377,
0.10565154254436493,
0.4593634009361267,
0.4302988648414612,
0.46449774503707886,
-0.8239949345588684,
-0.10028822720050812,
0.17610037326812744,
0.016553346067667007,
0.35841795802116394,
-0.519464910030365,
0.4282621145248413,
-0.10263890773057938,
-0.2937181293964386,
-0.17839105427265167,
0.9725402593612671,
-0.08235248923301697,
-0.04340185225009918,
0.4920518398284912,
0.5597350001335144,
0.7297914028167725,
-0.12072588503360748,
0.588140606880188,
-0.1427890509366989,
0.5396220088005066,
1.254746437072754,
-0.37480607628822327,
0.7969874739646912,
0.16228033602237701,
-0.0876823142170906,
0.5700646042823792,
0.8059028387069702,
-0.09868483990430832,
0.42869988083839417,
0.3475485146045685,
-0.2521735727787018,
-0.4486621618270874,
-0.3133886158466339,
-0.40105313062667847,
0.5830315947532654,
0.610832691192627,
-0.31610557436943054,
-0.46364620327949524,
0.08950594812631607,
-0.19099672138690948,
0.10100545734167099,
-0.2906038165092468,
1.0595873594284058,
-0.27397608757019043,
-0.5595903396606445,
0.6755942702293396,
-0.10077406466007233,
1.2585111856460571,
-0.5428888201713562,
0.021332139149308205,
-0.20252765715122223,
-0.06992843002080917,
-0.5185239315032959,
-0.7579787373542786,
0.2911892831325531,
0.04877786710858345,
0.30999431014060974,
-0.23875027894973755,
0.558402419090271,
-0.5322047472000122,
-0.7048234343528748,
0.3717299997806549,
0.651908278465271,
-0.12516342103481293,
0.21466709673404694,
-0.38805973529815674,
-0.09559386968612671,
-0.19502778351306915,
0.1258518397808075,
0.20831356942653656,
0.5419174432754517,
0.023493032902479172,
0.8735948801040649,
0.5367332696914673,
0.43402424454689026,
0.18459099531173706,
-0.4042573869228363,
0.8278259634971619,
-0.39507219195365906,
-0.31734007596969604,
-0.7564191818237305,
-0.08182630687952042,
0.022289108484983444,
-0.12186438590288162,
0.790972113609314,
0.8184911012649536,
0.853939950466156,
-0.0803508311510086,
0.8230366706848145,
-0.12346821278333664,
0.5326176285743713,
-0.44050371646881104,
0.673126220703125,
-0.668988049030304,
0.11783605068922043,
-0.3584959805011749,
-1.0090553760528564,
-0.4188603460788727,
0.17610487341880798,
-0.3636325001716614,
-0.21897608041763306,
0.37403351068496704,
0.7514841556549072,
-0.2295314222574234,
-0.49235016107559204,
0.4669342339038849,
0.15388314425945282,
0.08088751137256622,
0.23000775277614594,
0.7233946323394775,
0.07966897636651993,
0.5871617794036865,
-0.44885048270225525,
-0.20922324061393738,
-0.40489935874938965,
-0.6709630489349365,
-0.6299464702606201,
-0.7039182782173157,
-0.4676256775856018,
-0.3185960352420807,
-0.14946302771568298,
1.1505696773529053,
0.7854266166687012,
-0.47417619824409485,
-0.382913202047348,
0.24863719940185547,
0.2192339450120926,
-0.2118518352508545,
-0.27916163206100464,
0.33085182309150696,
-0.36488911509513855,
-0.5451008081436157,
0.167960524559021,
0.07049259543418884,
-0.11569305509328842,
-0.6507917046546936,
-0.052900027483701706,
-0.19657862186431885,
0.21795524656772614,
0.6179360151290894,
0.5015456676483154,
-0.7301450967788696,
-0.05007220432162285,
0.009628496132791042,
-0.0959714874625206,
0.009263463318347931,
0.5564163327217102,
-1.0686168670654297,
0.7297681570053101,
0.32491424679756165,
0.5091708898544312,
0.3781328797340393,
-0.0395050086081028,
0.35593268275260925,
-1.0262839794158936,
-0.02559865079820156,
0.1891167014837265,
0.16850648820400238,
0.048143211752176285,
-0.4365461468696594,
0.7553110122680664,
0.23442357778549194,
-0.17042139172554016,
-0.7875241637229919,
0.28384292125701904,
-0.718252420425415,
-0.10642877221107483,
1.4531834125518799,
0.19486546516418457,
-0.26143109798431396,
0.0749519094824791,
-0.13391710817813873,
0.1409568190574646,
-0.3961561918258667,
1.0903804302215576,
0.5931838154792786,
-0.1869659572839737,
-0.23659604787826538,
-0.08021574467420578,
0.8787875175476074,
0.08708025515079498,
-1.1518956422805786,
0.5038824081420898,
0.5929498672485352,
0.15421180427074432,
0.41888007521629333,
0.4002876281738281,
0.4303794801235199,
0.18441173434257507,
-0.3588852286338806,
0.03177377209067345,
0.20095191895961761,
-0.46916717290878296,
-0.39317864179611206,
0.1357724964618683,
0.00301181897521019,
0.31476664543151855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13613v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13613v2
|
Overview of the VLSP 2023 -- ComOM Shared Task: A Data Challenge for Comparative Opinion Mining from Vietnamese Product Reviews
| 2024-02-21T08:29:26 | 2024-03-04T21:20:57 |
Hoang-Quynh Le, Duy-Cat Can, Khanh-Vinh Nguyen, Mai-Vu Tran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper presents a comprehensive overview of the Comparative Opinion
Mining from Vietnamese Product Reviews shared task (ComOM), held as part of the
10$^{th}$ International Workshop on Vietnamese Language and Speech Processing
(VLSP 2023). The primary objective of this shared task is to advance the field
of natural language processing by developing techniques that proficiently
extract comparative opinions from Vietnamese product reviews. Participants are
challenged to propose models that adeptly extract a comparative "quintuple"
from a comparative sentence, encompassing Subject, Object, Aspect, Predicate,
and Comparison Type Label. We construct a human-annotated dataset comprising
$120$ documents, encompassing $7427$ non-comparative sentences and $2468$
comparisons within $1798$ sentences. Participating models undergo evaluation
and ranking based on the Exact match macro-averaged quintuple F1 score.
|
[
-0.3379532992839813,
-0.39600399136543274,
0.6548469066619873,
0.34823307394981384,
-0.25690901279449463,
0.04754180833697319,
0.11424475163221359,
-0.8522183299064636,
0.06316651403903961,
0.6995712518692017,
-0.6523851156234741,
-1.0039653778076172,
-0.4683660864830017,
0.17747817933559418,
-0.15733645856380463,
1.0147218704223633,
0.2680293023586273,
0.05635249614715576,
-0.30563998222351074,
-0.21834582090377808,
-0.4151412844657898,
-0.8918606638908386,
-0.536186933517456,
-0.24720090627670288,
0.3764552175998688,
0.58072829246521,
0.4359222650527954,
0.05687352642416954,
0.6254457235336304,
0.3627411127090454,
-0.12684471905231476,
0.3317772448062897,
-0.3217966556549072,
0.09958086907863617,
-0.19827988743782043,
-0.7492828369140625,
-0.7904720306396484,
0.2654586136341095,
0.31852662563323975,
0.4895942807197571,
0.27420347929000854,
0.06107223033905029,
0.26292645931243896,
0.8300996422767639,
-0.3131982684135437,
0.4293748140335083,
-0.5301117897033691,
0.04484528303146362,
0.04836110398173332,
-0.03617179021239281,
-0.1470656394958496,
-0.4883936047554016,
0.4192841053009033,
-0.3939635157585144,
0.3560728430747986,
0.038328617811203,
0.9098392128944397,
0.1270483434200287,
-0.43821418285369873,
-0.20153693854808807,
-0.6632084250450134,
1.1740573644638062,
-0.5784028768539429,
0.26780909299850464,
0.3537736237049103,
0.06268765777349472,
0.16768860816955566,
-0.556679904460907,
-0.7106157541275024,
-0.059078995138406754,
-0.12452174723148346,
0.35480669140815735,
-0.3241160809993744,
0.10879291594028473,
-0.210859015583992,
0.6609057188034058,
-0.6793507933616638,
-0.02666952833533287,
-0.2999258041381836,
0.035812776535749435,
0.6995077133178711,
0.17319002747535706,
-0.20616155862808228,
-0.6596149802207947,
-0.8996285200119019,
0.0025369725190103054,
-0.5969561338424683,
-0.09584549069404602,
0.2480468451976776,
0.20937643945217133,
-0.22542521357536316,
0.7170173525810242,
-0.7774868011474609,
0.4642302691936493,
-0.09419266879558563,
0.09780192375183105,
0.7613548636436462,
-0.5841542482376099,
-0.5950532555580139,
-0.14666599035263062,
0.8388736844062805,
1.011042594909668,
0.14239630103111267,
0.15638016164302826,
-0.3134002685546875,
-0.06929199397563934,
0.08797599375247955,
-0.46096116304397583,
-0.25451335310935974,
0.4650406241416931,
-0.7435114979743958,
-0.4681799113750458,
0.4076233506202698,
-0.8683578968048096,
-0.3305985927581787,
-0.6196058988571167,
0.4759494662284851,
-0.06483075767755508,
-0.10881579667329788,
0.21899940073490143,
-0.20050610601902008,
0.05565616488456726,
0.09118276089429855,
-0.3422911763191223,
0.36593976616859436,
1.0537221431732178,
1.0107336044311523,
-0.5510739088058472,
-0.19386202096939087,
-0.5956462025642395,
-0.15371891856193542,
0.22918163239955902,
1.2440590858459473,
-0.44128283858299255,
-0.7625821828842163,
0.1299293041229248,
0.21816271543502808,
-0.20777496695518494,
-1.2169256210327148,
0.96806401014328,
-0.32442590594291687,
0.4490068852901459,
-0.47923341393470764,
-0.6099405884742737,
-0.1968780905008316,
0.5069450736045837,
-0.7341414093971252,
0.8630058765411377,
0.15078482031822205,
-0.8611575961112976,
0.2966563105583191,
-0.4797222912311554,
-0.11060091108083725,
0.07335738092660904,
-0.11214642226696014,
-0.4527484178543091,
0.14148350059986115,
0.1225370243191719,
0.3772755265235901,
-0.5207749605178833,
0.14300553500652313,
-0.3308784067630768,
-0.1716468185186386,
0.2106257975101471,
-0.19434382021427155,
1.0520169734954834,
0.49669456481933594,
-0.22300677001476288,
0.46386146545410156,
-0.8311264514923096,
-0.03149626776576042,
0.004626697860658169,
-0.253794401884079,
-0.2637105882167816,
-0.1575397253036499,
0.09465046226978302,
0.27623504400253296,
0.5334963202476501,
-0.5250729322433472,
0.11214276403188705,
-0.25857165455818176,
0.07761035859584808,
0.63336181640625,
0.4091971516609192,
0.22241273522377014,
-0.5784934163093567,
0.3803006708621979,
0.12373246997594833,
0.5613372325897217,
0.1996069699525833,
-0.6349905133247375,
-1.0509287118911743,
-0.22449837625026703,
0.06875007599592209,
0.7717574834823608,
-0.7125759720802307,
0.4924456775188446,
-0.13758918642997742,
-0.4797799587249756,
-0.742072582244873,
0.08936799317598343,
0.40309563279151917,
0.44766470789909363,
0.5653959512710571,
-0.269489586353302,
-0.8572717905044556,
-1.1408095359802246,
-0.32470783591270447,
-0.6354770660400391,
-0.11704853177070618,
0.10316594690084457,
0.1101490929722786,
-0.2739700376987457,
0.7336231470108032,
-0.6590702533721924,
-0.6394308805465698,
-0.35054489970207214,
0.3445705771446228,
0.2766096293926239,
0.32858261466026306,
0.39595019817352295,
-0.8505998849868774,
-0.3754713535308838,
-0.12257993966341019,
-0.5481951236724854,
-0.3870279788970947,
0.3229900598526001,
0.06089883670210838,
0.3267873227596283,
0.6113709807395935,
-0.5083631873130798,
0.19815677404403687,
0.6160708665847778,
-0.23053112626075745,
0.590584933757782,
-0.08682520687580109,
0.4843635857105255,
-1.06172776222229,
-0.23790866136550903,
0.1572558581829071,
-0.21726475656032562,
-0.3743267059326172,
-0.07032574713230133,
-0.3868545591831207,
0.09945925325155258,
-0.6165857315063477,
0.19659043848514557,
-0.03704698756337166,
0.2739291787147522,
-0.4715482294559479,
0.0748610869050026,
-0.00024311950255651027,
0.3797354996204376,
0.46732524037361145,
0.2696557939052582,
0.1927681714296341,
-0.41204899549484253,
0.3771764636039734,
0.0094572389498353,
-0.3080477714538574,
1.1266989707946777,
-0.7204633951187134,
0.17745797336101532,
0.30671197175979614,
-0.15277288854122162,
-0.7563857436180115,
0.1746489703655243,
0.1438014656305313,
-0.43800580501556396,
-0.0880216434597969,
-0.14565704762935638,
-0.390939861536026,
-0.2202043980360031,
-0.6745673418045044,
0.1683894395828247,
0.3258594870567322,
-0.48057132959365845,
0.13319909572601318,
0.7654170393943787,
-0.31347885727882385,
-0.3201181888580322,
-0.3391793966293335,
0.015887511894106865,
-0.5555448532104492,
-0.34399834275245667,
0.5170877575874329,
-0.1623513549566269,
-0.6946461796760559,
-0.0027549604419618845,
0.09721728414297104,
0.1094309464097023,
-0.2055922895669937,
0.38449394702911377,
0.32348957657814026,
-0.20812739431858063,
0.12101797014474869,
-0.44864949584007263,
-0.3505183458328247,
0.30292463302612305,
-0.318275511264801,
0.4748176634311676,
-0.5624200105667114,
0.09784339368343353,
-0.45682331919670105,
0.5037389993667603,
0.14225926995277405,
-0.03779107704758644,
0.26106828451156616,
0.5979785323143005,
-0.27922555804252625,
0.004312094300985336,
-0.5386000871658325,
0.1453734040260315,
-0.4493463635444641,
0.413668155670166,
-0.3916325569152832,
-0.9864100217819214,
0.007118284236639738,
0.04100235551595688,
-0.02670588158071041,
0.7350975275039673,
0.6363494992256165,
-0.23550251126289368,
0.9619389176368713,
0.9693555235862732,
-0.37819427251815796,
0.23412752151489258,
-0.15579752624034882,
0.17262490093708038,
-0.477576345205307,
-0.47310230135917664,
-0.7801779508590698,
-0.17340810596942902,
-0.9433521628379822,
-0.706761360168457,
0.13011310994625092,
-0.17337669432163239,
-0.13233017921447754,
0.3397255539894104,
-0.23403915762901306,
0.23926298320293427,
0.8256829977035522,
-0.054727137088775635,
0.5911185145378113,
-0.11943675577640533,
0.06013533100485802,
-0.030013876035809517,
-0.38241642713546753,
-0.6967985033988953,
0.9102475047111511,
0.006882030051201582,
0.0792800709605217,
0.005022495519369841,
0.838327169418335,
0.4932841360569,
-0.09586935490369797,
-0.7741757035255432,
0.8800225853919983,
-0.35482096672058105,
-0.1427631676197052,
0.15774084627628326,
-0.38804352283477783,
-0.9655807018280029,
0.04245630279183388,
-0.2827658951282501,
-0.7718621492385864,
0.25624069571495056,
-0.18278269469738007,
-0.34935250878334045,
0.10911830514669418,
-0.7677984237670898,
0.8623355627059937,
-0.09684541076421738,
-0.2567404508590698,
-0.268833726644516,
-0.6852748990058899,
0.3341570496559143,
0.13618597388267517,
0.163926362991333,
-0.2819685637950897,
0.049509912729263306,
0.7622034549713135,
-0.5233065485954285,
0.60981285572052,
-0.2000637650489807,
0.05522782728075981,
0.5323702692985535,
-0.1956312209367752,
-0.012433868832886219,
0.23208647966384888,
-0.2086263746023178,
0.23514674603939056,
0.1490793377161026,
-0.2847101092338562,
-0.3168300688266754,
1.0576897859573364,
-0.9194760322570801,
-0.6192546486854553,
-0.6871347427368164,
-0.4508742094039917,
-0.4125083088874817,
0.02273404598236084,
0.24493207037448883,
0.07553845643997192,
-0.4128052592277527,
0.2259283810853958,
0.34478655457496643,
-0.21893210709095,
0.2922211289405823,
0.43847909569740295,
-0.4433867037296295,
-0.5110818147659302,
1.077746033668518,
-0.13282492756843567,
0.19965285062789917,
0.8478679656982422,
0.1586957722902298,
-0.39165812730789185,
-0.39818915724754333,
0.4076504707336426,
0.12307655811309814,
-0.6392527222633362,
-0.1956954449415207,
-0.9360015392303467,
-0.27540379762649536,
-0.3838375210762024,
0.24466778337955475,
-0.29985910654067993,
-0.6089985966682434,
-0.11224773526191711,
-0.22661320865154266,
0.17911066114902496,
1.1244553327560425,
-0.39151614904403687,
0.2894921898841858,
-0.7295199036598206,
0.48320573568344116,
0.5099287033081055,
0.007010146975517273,
-0.400717169046402,
-0.09401699900627136,
-0.1976422518491745,
-0.15409386157989502,
-0.47662773728370667,
-0.6902071833610535,
0.5508527159690857,
-0.024004975333809853,
0.46445855498313904,
0.27751824259757996,
0.19057783484458923,
0.5612111687660217,
0.08769498020410538,
1.0296461582183838,
0.012510644271969795,
-0.7843155264854431,
0.6326903700828552,
-0.04341690614819527,
0.5570111274719238,
0.6674394607543945,
0.5211201906204224,
-0.4024582505226135,
-0.4047369658946991,
-0.8252663016319275,
-0.8662523031234741,
0.34953874349594116,
0.3142397701740265,
-0.44707992672920227,
-0.16718937456607819,
-0.05818153917789459,
0.21574564278125763,
0.30392107367515564,
-0.599579393863678,
-0.16999754309654236,
0.07762110978364944,
-0.17655666172504425,
-0.2835828959941864,
-0.3909469544887543,
0.19556620717048645,
-0.10132677853107452,
0.6827996373176575,
0.08352841436862946,
0.3040950894355774,
0.24651679396629333,
-0.026292158290743828,
0.20317400991916656,
0.238869309425354,
0.2439391165971756,
0.2457350641489029,
-0.520088791847229,
0.557264506816864,
0.06097882613539696,
-0.541998028755188,
-0.20317137241363525,
0.23721200227737427,
-0.14169800281524658,
0.16501712799072266,
0.3278784453868866,
0.4830904006958008,
-0.038614362478256226,
-0.6021576523780823,
0.46801891922950745,
-0.5265808701515198,
-0.23396983742713928,
-0.1680847853422165,
-0.05080118402838707,
0.0878218337893486,
0.4912969172000885,
0.20048169791698456,
0.22436434030532837,
0.4814291000366211,
-0.794596254825592,
0.2515665888786316,
0.22939248383045197,
-0.8801032304763794,
-0.5245864391326904,
0.4726622402667999,
0.2534392476081848,
-0.49444928765296936,
0.5218378305435181,
-0.33064714074134827,
-0.7160179615020752,
0.39316779375076294,
0.08774080872535706,
1.050261378288269,
-0.1155102401971817,
0.3848028779029846,
0.4447774291038513,
0.1655511111021042,
0.2307848483324051,
0.7078964710235596,
-0.11020813137292862,
-0.41075974702835083,
-0.12096773833036423,
-0.6046316623687744,
-0.37367182970046997,
0.24886800348758698,
-0.6724324822425842,
0.5664283037185669,
-0.08990894258022308,
-0.23851116001605988,
-0.1778193712234497,
0.5126696825027466,
-0.8449066281318665,
0.5380456447601318,
0.0706050768494606,
0.33510181307792664,
-0.6694589257240295,
0.9979735016822815,
0.42543908953666687,
-0.27004215121269226,
-0.20117485523223877,
0.18369576334953308,
0.4542706310749054,
-0.5893325805664062,
0.358480304479599,
0.37334251403808594,
-0.2682221531867981,
-0.49111849069595337,
-0.3658234477043152,
-0.28286075592041016,
0.7271422743797302,
0.016719872131943703,
-0.645574152469635,
0.19705736637115479,
0.5687441825866699,
0.5842553973197937,
-0.4595228135585785,
0.03427914157509804,
0.9368826746940613,
0.3139684200286865,
-0.08060085028409958,
-0.9367042183876038,
-0.3045995831489563,
-0.5713083744049072,
-0.424818754196167,
-0.25376588106155396,
-0.7935498952865601,
1.0596083402633667,
-0.15265454351902008,
-0.03646552562713623,
0.23440229892730713,
0.9348065853118896,
0.6092419624328613,
0.5184503793716431,
0.8212832808494568,
0.2988128066062927,
0.7742656469345093,
0.055937886238098145,
0.8129807710647583,
-0.15656866133213043,
0.3359103202819824,
1.7660530805587769,
-0.44061949849128723,
1.1568036079406738,
0.5731287598609924,
-0.21306057274341583,
0.3539859354496002,
0.7432715892791748,
0.24238277971744537,
0.5067306160926819,
0.03027929924428463,
-0.39350757002830505,
-0.21852843463420868,
-0.5567933320999146,
-0.38622936606407166,
0.5565688014030457,
0.0897165909409523,
-0.20068854093551636,
0.17015458643436432,
-0.3331516683101654,
-0.12542258203029633,
0.1804029494524002,
-0.339937686920166,
0.8798367977142334,
0.455934077501297,
-0.7648564577102661,
0.1867554783821106,
0.0019177693175151944,
0.5781556963920593,
-0.27657875418663025,
-0.10348071902990341,
-0.2141411006450653,
0.5040677785873413,
-0.21603138744831085,
-0.8578819632530212,
0.42968419194221497,
0.07885903865098953,
-0.24910229444503784,
-0.1337907314300537,
0.5936583876609802,
-0.4026750922203064,
-0.5501652359962463,
0.45627549290657043,
0.6148542165756226,
0.0318603552877903,
-0.45284387469291687,
-0.7346864342689514,
0.18303155899047852,
0.07086343318223953,
-0.009595823474228382,
0.1619407683610916,
0.4778095781803131,
-0.1083575189113617,
0.24408555030822754,
0.15573664009571075,
0.06328105926513672,
-0.05411466583609581,
0.290920615196228,
0.6167828440666199,
-0.7977460026741028,
-0.4810861349105835,
-0.6572104692459106,
0.29831674695014954,
-0.3601760268211365,
-0.36693069338798523,
0.9540309309959412,
1.0594950914382935,
1.1544513702392578,
-0.01889694668352604,
0.9266895651817322,
0.18012341856956482,
0.7495013475418091,
-0.6106552481651306,
0.43545427918434143,
-0.4496905505657196,
0.39864787459373474,
-0.3868034780025482,
-1.0620839595794678,
-0.2762456238269806,
0.32739752531051636,
-0.28660568594932556,
-0.17797048389911652,
0.9558338522911072,
0.707451581954956,
0.22636286914348602,
0.3905116021633148,
0.2396584451198578,
0.3329145014286041,
0.39742618799209595,
0.7619743347167969,
0.9585670828819275,
-0.4606853127479553,
0.4664565920829773,
-0.597180187702179,
-0.016308605670928955,
-0.09819354861974716,
-0.8103822469711304,
-0.7035962343215942,
-0.883784294128418,
-0.5914533138275146,
-0.2516353726387024,
0.04368039593100548,
1.0358859300613403,
0.5665395855903625,
-0.9999039173126221,
-0.666104257106781,
0.1275704950094223,
0.23749424517154694,
-0.22780300676822662,
-0.24580545723438263,
0.38664382696151733,
-0.21485258638858795,
-1.088443398475647,
0.4251714050769806,
0.43426844477653503,
-0.03760281577706337,
-0.07545337826013565,
0.10047853738069534,
-0.2843756675720215,
-0.02891717292368412,
0.9013357758522034,
-0.01049326453357935,
-0.3856216073036194,
-0.36977675557136536,
0.08871720731258392,
0.15110327303409576,
0.24393677711486816,
0.8056074380874634,
-0.8574957847595215,
0.5866181254386902,
0.635293185710907,
0.07617773860692978,
0.4821765124797821,
0.027695246040821075,
0.7266897559165955,
-0.4730154573917389,
0.23124080896377563,
0.23654688894748688,
0.267396479845047,
0.4325331449508667,
-0.04731474071741104,
0.5448923707008362,
0.4177316725254059,
-0.6024026870727539,
-0.5653290748596191,
0.15185879170894623,
-1.4434183835983276,
-0.1867043823003769,
1.121156096458435,
-0.16043411195278168,
-0.3052000403404236,
-0.3988680839538574,
-0.5601781606674194,
0.14509885013103485,
-0.2786647081375122,
0.7912175059318542,
0.4063494801521301,
-0.15057837963104248,
0.08109836280345917,
-0.4318678677082062,
0.6784158945083618,
0.2683717608451843,
-0.8859677910804749,
-0.1936100274324417,
0.3182792365550995,
-0.1535164713859558,
-0.11847443133592606,
0.5611088275909424,
-0.26067689061164856,
0.09613660722970963,
-0.24517033994197845,
-0.1686614453792572,
0.3888011574745178,
-0.4280490279197693,
-0.3177201747894287,
0.6383984684944153,
0.20246805250644684,
-0.3303852379322052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13610v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13610v1
|
Data-driven Discovery with Large Generative Models
| 2024-02-21T08:26:43 | 2024-02-21T08:26:43 |
Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Harshit Surana, Dhruv Agarwal, Sanchaita Hazra, Ashish Sabharwal, Peter Clark
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
With the accumulation of data at an unprecedented rate, its potential to fuel
scientific discovery is growing exponentially. This position paper urges the
Machine Learning (ML) community to exploit the capabilities of large generative
models (LGMs) to develop automated systems for end-to-end data-driven discovery
-- a paradigm encompassing the search and verification of hypotheses purely
from a set of provided datasets, without the need for additional data
collection or physical experiments. We first outline several desiderata for an
ideal data-driven discovery system. Then, through DATAVOYAGER, a
proof-of-concept utilizing GPT-4, we demonstrate how LGMs fulfill several of
these desiderata -- a feat previously unattainable -- while also highlighting
important limitations in the current system that open up opportunities for
novel ML research. We contend that achieving accurate, reliable, and robust
end-to-end discovery systems solely through the current capabilities of LGMs is
challenging. We instead advocate for fail-proof tool integration, along with
active user moderation through feedback mechanisms, to foster data-driven
scientific discoveries with efficiency and reproducibility.
|
[
-0.3016519844532013,
-0.6869754791259766,
0.8302238583564758,
-0.045819446444511414,
-0.09048055857419968,
0.12998896837234497,
-0.05734521150588989,
-0.1886458545923233,
-0.19253689050674438,
0.33263328671455383,
-0.3917349576950073,
-0.48422971367836,
-0.7245030403137207,
0.32087287306785583,
-0.8829719424247742,
0.7654932141304016,
-0.35079771280288696,
-0.21417546272277832,
-0.6683353185653687,
0.22683954238891602,
-0.15410594642162323,
-0.7542366981506348,
-0.3786503076553345,
-0.2746850848197937,
0.7290060520172119,
0.09718891233205795,
0.7054567337036133,
0.7348430752754211,
0.47783300280570984,
0.22986865043640137,
0.023600324988365173,
0.35083359479904175,
-0.4457358717918396,
0.3529464602470398,
-0.039439909160137177,
-0.5806604623794556,
-0.28420794010162354,
-0.06944616883993149,
0.5626260638237,
0.9411423206329346,
-0.10419152677059174,
-0.08940540254116058,
0.00348987290635705,
0.7961639165878296,
-0.44219106435775757,
0.4740777015686035,
-0.5212874412536621,
0.4764825403690338,
-0.2845706641674042,
-0.21150177717208862,
-0.4798712432384491,
-0.3477979898452759,
0.23602601885795593,
-0.7735100388526917,
0.5859577059745789,
-0.17789281904697418,
0.4663616716861725,
0.4667174220085144,
-0.39839956164360046,
-0.13124695420265198,
-0.9000653028488159,
0.6440997123718262,
-0.46380746364593506,
0.3154570162296295,
0.18770648539066315,
0.4627993106842041,
-0.3827422559261322,
-0.6723842620849609,
-0.518422544002533,
-0.4646676778793335,
0.2927694022655487,
0.07928676158189774,
-0.11941288411617279,
-0.09346894919872284,
0.5777648091316223,
0.5232736468315125,
-0.7763503193855286,
0.25021129846572876,
-0.2456221878528595,
0.0007398262387141585,
0.5450811982154846,
0.2467639148235321,
-0.0763198584318161,
0.2832670211791992,
-0.04875870421528816,
0.05999698489904404,
-0.9915255308151245,
-0.22150979936122894,
0.2106139361858368,
0.3707530200481415,
0.27337250113487244,
0.8178802728652954,
-0.3666057288646698,
0.7647855877876282,
-0.21535977721214294,
0.37483543157577515,
0.24043400585651398,
-0.38170355558395386,
-0.32223156094551086,
-0.09999947994947433,
0.6575633883476257,
0.09097405523061752,
-0.07042305916547775,
-0.3529422879219055,
-0.23762530088424683,
0.07444465905427933,
0.07519693672657013,
-1.022714376449585,
-0.33116772770881653,
0.28663206100463867,
-0.39126989245414734,
-0.5177860856056213,
0.15041200816631317,
-0.8102281093597412,
-0.6651176810264587,
-0.31918466091156006,
0.49461936950683594,
0.07084880024194717,
-0.34754443168640137,
0.20325760543346405,
-0.3938322365283966,
-0.07610510289669037,
0.428311288356781,
-0.8179407119750977,
-0.08918623626232147,
0.6411386728286743,
0.918033242225647,
-0.1370050609111786,
-0.23538196086883545,
-0.34368306398391724,
0.15151426196098328,
-0.7681499719619751,
0.4429199993610382,
-0.46158188581466675,
-0.584527313709259,
0.05530514940619469,
0.11515562981367111,
0.2492799162864685,
-0.6982105374336243,
0.4742916226387024,
-0.5542632937431335,
-0.03448404371738434,
-0.6535936594009399,
-0.8056654334068298,
-0.11805818229913712,
0.0007768993964418769,
-0.6412122845649719,
0.6740561723709106,
0.29843035340309143,
-0.46578702330589294,
0.646081268787384,
-0.7719769477844238,
-0.42639508843421936,
0.2142617106437683,
-0.21410676836967468,
-0.721319317817688,
0.32148826122283936,
0.16614533960819244,
0.5403164625167847,
-0.42011404037475586,
0.6959760785102844,
-0.5553750395774841,
-0.4129144251346588,
0.3936821520328522,
-0.6028870940208435,
0.5534406304359436,
0.170295849442482,
-0.5074253082275391,
-0.041284553706645966,
-0.7326793074607849,
-0.09179902076721191,
0.4019375443458557,
-0.45157086849212646,
-0.0727454423904419,
0.2079302966594696,
-0.11111274361610413,
0.008590362966060638,
0.2107822149991989,
-0.49921974539756775,
0.7164387106895447,
0.06018885597586632,
0.5940900444984436,
0.9434943795204163,
-0.3693070709705353,
0.16806507110595703,
-0.3250375986099243,
0.3206001818180084,
0.12244553864002228,
0.3080197274684906,
-0.5192955732345581,
-0.3707931637763977,
-0.6690636873245239,
-0.18224017322063446,
0.5440908670425415,
0.14282673597335815,
-0.6427083611488342,
0.8135647773742676,
-0.22863127291202545,
-0.6545510292053223,
-0.3377687633037567,
0.17288900911808014,
-0.059467412531375885,
0.3227810561656952,
0.39179325103759766,
-0.15331313014030457,
-0.7868030667304993,
-0.7452802658081055,
0.3753584623336792,
0.04164305329322815,
-0.35357463359832764,
0.22420886158943176,
0.5591980814933777,
-0.6889499425888062,
1.025601863861084,
-0.3033905327320099,
0.007364502642303705,
-0.09621895849704742,
-0.0073320320807397366,
0.2219499796628952,
0.3606794476509094,
0.2397308498620987,
-1.0700552463531494,
-0.1583290845155716,
0.07986734062433243,
-1.42003333568573,
0.05271943286061287,
0.12618105113506317,
0.14579108357429504,
0.0032988600432872772,
0.4310861825942993,
-0.7324103713035583,
0.5215727090835571,
0.3547145128250122,
-0.007825411856174469,
0.4620668292045593,
-0.277060329914093,
0.00939092691987753,
-0.6062636375427246,
0.19251815974712372,
0.006172420457005501,
-0.01362740620970726,
-0.6120416522026062,
-0.007939795032143593,
-0.023882044479250908,
-0.10257106274366379,
0.1350398063659668,
0.029372572898864746,
-0.22292070090770721,
-0.21702152490615845,
-0.4923296570777893,
-0.328537255525589,
-0.07836659997701645,
0.009659637697041035,
-0.033297985792160034,
0.5351714491844177,
0.8011893033981323,
-0.8051431775093079,
0.746981143951416,
0.21813246607780457,
-0.24043969810009003,
0.24159805476665497,
-0.9260151386260986,
0.0831858366727829,
-0.3594266176223755,
0.7446397542953491,
-0.517365038394928,
-0.5113220810890198,
0.22205287218093872,
-0.4438108801841736,
0.11388589441776276,
-0.2112441509962082,
-0.6388859748840332,
-0.7228918671607971,
-0.049396198242902756,
0.28397810459136963,
0.5691074728965759,
-0.8650398850440979,
0.35238027572631836,
0.2922765910625458,
-0.07096263021230698,
-0.3232298791408539,
-0.42842093110084534,
0.3702629804611206,
-0.14750976860523224,
-0.4961686134338379,
0.3846385180950165,
-0.1910712867975235,
-0.060059793293476105,
-0.15860667824745178,
-0.005766616202890873,
0.1908269077539444,
0.19031351804733276,
0.43224483728408813,
0.30924421548843384,
-0.0003588951367419213,
0.4100067913532257,
-0.24380402266979218,
-0.28172212839126587,
0.20229266583919525,
-0.7893633842468262,
0.401547908782959,
0.009797295555472374,
-0.6996147632598877,
-0.2758949398994446,
0.35195502638816833,
0.7419986128807068,
-0.12189667671918869,
0.3263365924358368,
0.49759823083877563,
-0.511928141117096,
-0.06287222355604172,
-0.05487852543592453,
-0.10630825906991959,
-0.44989076256752014,
0.39709973335266113,
-0.18458792567253113,
-0.8521166443824768,
0.39307960867881775,
-0.3191503584384918,
0.2618655562400818,
0.6186803579330444,
0.538456916809082,
-0.14474476873874664,
1.3126492500305176,
0.6331232190132141,
-0.11045537143945694,
0.07157767564058304,
-0.4028945565223694,
0.3438057005405426,
-0.5381044149398804,
-0.303236186504364,
-0.541292130947113,
-0.1079239621758461,
-0.586828351020813,
-0.2679305672645569,
0.5343496799468994,
-0.07398990541696548,
-0.3034168779850006,
-0.05275926738977432,
-0.6867122054100037,
0.15666960179805756,
0.8230782747268677,
0.15096479654312134,
0.24163036048412323,
-0.15471936762332916,
0.15123523771762848,
0.199900284409523,
-0.6682118773460388,
-0.3733873963356018,
1.4263280630111694,
0.37038666009902954,
0.85154128074646,
-0.09363491833209991,
0.6262485980987549,
0.4360322654247284,
0.2999632954597473,
-0.7465206980705261,
0.3782429099082947,
0.03090406209230423,
-0.5651792883872986,
-0.408429354429245,
-0.5729240775108337,
-1.0088729858398438,
-0.1158890500664711,
0.055355049669742584,
-0.09623359143733978,
0.33350008726119995,
0.32070478796958923,
-0.0629047304391861,
0.2998841404914856,
-0.37800708413124084,
0.6342296600341797,
-0.342266708612442,
-0.30299824476242065,
0.08003104478120804,
-0.5092898607254028,
0.24604032933712006,
-0.2994347810745239,
0.07857556641101837,
0.09962153434753418,
0.22028014063835144,
0.6924031376838684,
-0.5207339525222778,
0.7692131400108337,
-0.5632770657539368,
-0.2816905379295349,
0.374660849571228,
-0.08960573375225067,
0.8976438641548157,
0.016672395169734955,
0.27396735548973083,
0.003193979850038886,
-0.40541350841522217,
-0.43391624093055725,
-0.648617684841156,
0.6159010529518127,
-0.4293699860572815,
-0.5459297895431519,
-0.2870028614997864,
-0.4607860743999481,
0.08444447815418243,
0.02167396806180477,
0.21851517260074615,
0.33809158205986023,
-0.08070924878120422,
0.403221994638443,
0.9499520063400269,
0.10821894556283951,
0.13185924291610718,
0.2664813697338104,
-0.44736868143081665,
-0.024280428886413574,
1.3051602840423584,
0.1400105059146881,
0.0657101720571518,
0.2160855531692505,
0.19768330454826355,
-0.24949020147323608,
-0.8939200043678284,
-0.6526983976364136,
-0.2829645872116089,
-0.3978480398654938,
-0.09691686928272247,
-0.6145121455192566,
-0.12002063542604446,
-0.10662375390529633,
-0.1116907149553299,
-0.4511151909828186,
-0.19928249716758728,
-0.3430694341659546,
-0.28271186351776123,
0.2781471610069275,
0.8042327165603638,
-0.2989009618759155,
-0.08319006860256195,
-0.6203018426895142,
0.3228694796562195,
0.4077175259590149,
0.19673995673656464,
-0.1783948689699173,
-0.1810079962015152,
-0.36478644609451294,
0.23851287364959717,
-0.2809336185455322,
-0.35455313324928284,
0.12277033179998398,
-0.1481279730796814,
0.49082234501838684,
0.5862686634063721,
-0.07357615232467651,
0.20361106097698212,
-0.26514554023742676,
0.6526079773902893,
0.17232081294059753,
-0.677074134349823,
0.7357310056686401,
-0.6468837857246399,
-0.04499271512031555,
0.16722755134105682,
0.5667992234230042,
-0.37324589490890503,
-0.0005827371496707201,
-0.6122711300849915,
-0.8342620134353638,
-0.12021225690841675,
-0.012547519989311695,
-0.09351702034473419,
0.21385318040847778,
0.2998991012573242,
0.5007187128067017,
0.40284621715545654,
-0.48349758982658386,
-0.004601262044161558,
-0.368999183177948,
-0.20009499788284302,
-0.13537614047527313,
0.11764317750930786,
-0.3569023311138153,
-0.21754828095436096,
0.6080547571182251,
-0.3491617739200592,
0.31923171877861023,
0.27499717473983765,
0.18546347320079803,
-0.16515691578388214,
0.09858092665672302,
0.16257226467132568,
0.6724216938018799,
-0.1865849643945694,
0.09041282534599304,
-0.2692018151283264,
-0.2958517074584961,
0.30637022852897644,
0.5240509510040283,
-0.6422644257545471,
0.03897623345255852,
0.058663662523031235,
0.74004727602005,
-0.3227517902851105,
-0.7150951623916626,
0.3488493859767914,
0.10578568279743195,
-0.4944573640823364,
-0.43127623200416565,
0.12888072431087494,
-0.16927555203437805,
0.27926868200302124,
0.7416737079620361,
0.18905159831047058,
0.21927979588508606,
-0.4765411913394928,
0.23838067054748535,
0.570329487323761,
-0.3023222088813782,
-0.24676327407360077,
0.6809823513031006,
0.04741045460104942,
0.16580571234226227,
0.5931228995323181,
-0.19538573920726776,
-0.4860024154186249,
0.757736086845398,
0.19821396470069885,
0.7330872416496277,
-0.02743367850780487,
0.20707902312278748,
0.17330680787563324,
0.1939620077610016,
-0.44944098591804504,
-0.0993814766407013,
-0.24069122970104218,
-0.5047696828842163,
-0.29214948415756226,
-0.4399065673351288,
-0.6418983936309814,
0.27061423659324646,
-0.5426903963088989,
0.261712908744812,
-0.2669469714164734,
-0.0033486876636743546,
0.2911393642425537,
-0.21424421668052673,
-0.638719379901886,
0.12913420796394348,
-0.114390529692173,
0.7828961610794067,
-0.7383736371994019,
0.424530953168869,
0.024976078420877457,
-0.17935028672218323,
-0.10901762545108795,
-0.3603666424751282,
0.13176167011260986,
-0.7081931829452515,
0.5128622651100159,
0.3187507688999176,
0.27985426783561707,
0.002437181770801544,
-1.0682052373886108,
-0.7184346914291382,
1.185386061668396,
0.15709258615970612,
-0.7332488298416138,
0.015361525118350983,
-0.08249233663082123,
0.435229629278183,
-0.3064728081226349,
-0.0965249240398407,
0.4054373800754547,
0.6150470972061157,
0.3562396168708801,
-0.5757371187210083,
0.019586360082030296,
-0.10396561026573181,
-0.14799094200134277,
0.1958838701248169,
-0.2699053883552551,
0.6986910104751587,
-0.5993667244911194,
-0.048681601881980896,
0.09537866711616516,
0.6911892294883728,
0.30082637071609497,
0.5552000403404236,
0.3868153393268585,
0.777980387210846,
0.9329789280891418,
-0.25697675347328186,
0.925348699092865,
0.23901796340942383,
0.4538191556930542,
0.6945887804031372,
-0.4951273202896118,
0.4825672507286072,
0.28789934515953064,
-0.5728126168251038,
0.02104942873120308,
0.8979694843292236,
-0.6377370357513428,
0.5941087007522583,
0.6911744475364685,
-0.4875907003879547,
-0.20548400282859802,
-0.2973455786705017,
-0.5310784578323364,
0.25919708609580994,
0.45504358410835266,
-0.6744841933250427,
0.017534567043185234,
0.18522556126117706,
-0.16595730185508728,
-0.2467336356639862,
-0.224070206284523,
0.4908868372440338,
-0.26653483510017395,
-0.5026168823242188,
0.6499356031417847,
-0.25314274430274963,
0.6129915714263916,
-0.3703768849372864,
-0.22920121252536774,
0.03603683412075043,
0.01300791185349226,
-0.2690504193305969,
-0.6165323853492737,
-0.03581911697983742,
0.03269258886575699,
-0.3684994876384735,
-0.05307701975107193,
0.559661328792572,
-0.11311370879411697,
-0.5838173031806946,
-0.0010830063838511705,
0.60176682472229,
0.07503437995910645,
-0.07153084129095078,
-0.1432330161333084,
0.033962495625019073,
0.07799893617630005,
-0.2759718596935272,
0.4283875823020935,
0.32522493600845337,
0.2539908289909363,
0.8124961853027344,
1.0492732524871826,
-0.21056953072547913,
-0.10820301622152328,
0.13784615695476532,
1.0337038040161133,
-0.6002187728881836,
-0.0518186017870903,
-0.889313280582428,
0.1663810759782791,
-0.04151947796344757,
0.14035382866859436,
0.5492702722549438,
0.6431348919868469,
0.8397813439369202,
0.05798071250319481,
1.6866060495376587,
-0.17831914126873016,
0.532983124256134,
-0.38739269971847534,
0.385197252035141,
-0.26459404826164246,
0.10591496527194977,
0.12570708990097046,
-0.7041851282119751,
-0.18871237337589264,
0.3716137409210205,
0.1314881443977356,
0.33524033427238464,
0.2123444527387619,
0.582147479057312,
0.03831828385591507,
0.3097037076950073,
0.3364512622356415,
0.3921051025390625,
0.8399479389190674,
0.55987548828125,
0.9330788850784302,
-0.18656307458877563,
0.38928118348121643,
0.009434493258595467,
-0.5100926756858826,
-0.2263687402009964,
-0.6058539152145386,
-0.6431448459625244,
-0.7628799080848694,
-0.16680847108364105,
-0.31419894099235535,
-0.024931905791163445,
0.5193436145782471,
0.5527600646018982,
-0.559863269329071,
0.2322966754436493,
-0.7971039414405823,
-0.20053207874298096,
-0.10561206936836243,
-0.1995345801115036,
0.3250871002674103,
-0.16374599933624268,
-0.6518048048019409,
0.4774385392665863,
0.4686381220817566,
0.3893357515335083,
-0.636249303817749,
-0.10786137729883194,
0.39221325516700745,
-0.3737435042858124,
0.5677797794342041,
0.6481086611747742,
-0.46809008717536926,
0.06581194698810577,
0.10701176524162292,
0.12854735553264618,
-0.17048867046833038,
0.8071185946464539,
-0.8933183550834656,
0.5444091558456421,
0.18881167471408844,
0.9388196468353271,
0.575866162776947,
-0.284031480550766,
0.803597629070282,
-0.2857360243797302,
-0.2693607211112976,
0.2514171302318573,
0.36041051149368286,
0.38559770584106445,
-0.4009268283843994,
0.6488847136497498,
0.4707146883010864,
-0.9064075350761414,
-0.954196035861969,
0.1920606940984726,
-0.7453907132148743,
-0.055131252855062485,
0.7462634444236755,
-0.20866024494171143,
0.15910567343235016,
-0.1408756673336029,
-0.040057357400655746,
0.1407748907804489,
-0.16509370505809784,
0.9588857293128967,
0.5139514207839966,
-0.39375734329223633,
0.13634423911571503,
-0.8119028210639954,
0.46339312195777893,
0.13566561043262482,
-0.9457216858863831,
0.5639848709106445,
0.5264758467674255,
-0.10777819901704788,
0.2806999385356903,
0.26185300946235657,
-0.18364600837230682,
0.3325474262237549,
-0.0031556929461658,
-0.12909111380577087,
-0.38921377062797546,
-0.492929071187973,
-0.3203068673610687,
0.2542065680027008,
-0.19058024883270264,
-0.08986930549144745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13607v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13607v3
|
CODIS: Benchmarking Context-Dependent Visual Comprehension for Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T08:21:12 | 2024-06-05T02:14:06 |
Fuwen Luo, Chi Chen, Zihao Wan, Zhaolu Kang, Qidong Yan, Yingjie Li, Xiaolong Wang, Siyu Wang, Ziyue Wang, Xiaoyue Mi, Peng Li, Ning Ma, Maosong Sun, Yang Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have demonstrated promising results
in a variety of tasks that combine vision and language. As these models become
more integral to research and applications, conducting comprehensive
evaluations of their capabilities has grown increasingly important. However,
most existing benchmarks fail to consider that, in certain situations, images
need to be interpreted within a broader context. In this work, we introduce a
new benchmark, named as CODIS, designed to assess the ability of models to use
context provided in free-form text to enhance visual comprehension. Our
findings indicate that MLLMs consistently fall short of human performance on
this benchmark. Further analysis confirms that these models struggle to
effectively extract and utilize contextual information to improve their
understanding of images. This underscores the pressing need to enhance the
ability of MLLMs to comprehend visuals in a context-dependent manner. View our
project website at https://thunlp-mt.github.io/CODIS.
|
[
-0.5822570323944092,
-0.5988181233406067,
0.7898892760276794,
0.3728258013725281,
-0.5153629183769226,
-0.2483522891998291,
-0.40694600343704224,
-0.637800395488739,
-0.30175209045410156,
0.3454291522502899,
-0.4265003800392151,
-0.5705400705337524,
-0.6743463277816772,
0.2883802652359009,
-0.3184792101383209,
0.5404549837112427,
-0.1455874741077423,
0.2901143431663513,
-0.7921427488327026,
-0.5241377353668213,
-0.7151263356208801,
-0.4280704855918884,
-0.4918909966945648,
0.07649392634630203,
0.6475992202758789,
0.1474861055612564,
0.5031155943870544,
0.3757874369621277,
0.6778079271316528,
0.2603754699230194,
-0.14660635590553284,
0.2565818428993225,
-0.4118036925792694,
0.31213971972465515,
0.022897297516465187,
-0.3103858530521393,
-0.28568536043167114,
-0.15699277818202972,
0.8776910901069641,
0.7883051633834839,
0.1871655136346817,
0.22640720009803772,
0.009209901094436646,
0.7645778059959412,
-1.217471957206726,
0.33070099353790283,
-0.5598026514053345,
0.08741680532693863,
-0.0052230930887162685,
-0.1466725617647171,
-0.7070148587226868,
0.08298687636852264,
0.39592647552490234,
-0.7210540175437927,
0.06812109798192978,
-0.05423583835363388,
0.7215964198112488,
0.28628009557724,
-0.7504132986068726,
0.07118267565965652,
-0.24926424026489258,
0.8250852823257446,
-0.685822069644928,
0.6810663342475891,
0.40601226687431335,
0.4127201437950134,
0.21431903541088104,
-0.9188476204872131,
-0.5105317234992981,
-0.3344596326351166,
-0.09403077512979507,
0.1955125629901886,
-0.10015804320573807,
-0.16230544447898865,
0.47434359788894653,
0.11629480868577957,
-0.5252613425254822,
-0.2775219976902008,
-0.3130674362182617,
-0.0707048550248146,
0.4588560163974762,
0.32308241724967957,
0.4275469481945038,
-0.13096074759960175,
-0.6748465895652771,
-0.3865777552127838,
-0.561031699180603,
0.417138934135437,
-0.21631759405136108,
0.13308987021446228,
-0.3083389103412628,
0.549493670463562,
-0.2513994872570038,
1.0883874893188477,
-0.653610348701477,
-0.1544431746006012,
0.4513964354991913,
-0.2879444360733032,
-0.39933955669403076,
-0.49671289324760437,
0.44854024052619934,
0.7230655550956726,
0.4612809717655182,
-0.032830435782670975,
-0.40222829580307007,
0.119727723300457,
0.2402891218662262,
-0.900500476360321,
0.08828523010015488,
-0.055717695504426956,
-0.6149439215660095,
-0.15738366544246674,
0.2715073227882385,
-0.8297704458236694,
-0.4499812424182892,
-0.42971161007881165,
0.44155260920524597,
-0.38265660405158997,
-0.11729014664888382,
-0.1489434838294983,
-0.380586177110672,
0.10059120506048203,
0.3120220899581909,
-0.7180021405220032,
0.15286312997341156,
0.48360610008239746,
1.0152348279953003,
-0.33070582151412964,
-0.5289458632469177,
-0.724241316318512,
0.3282977044582367,
-0.46373251080513,
0.9012587070465088,
-0.7521324753761292,
-0.46980154514312744,
0.17464829981327057,
0.1354926973581314,
-0.24838151037693024,
-0.4347267746925354,
0.5999055504798889,
-0.5672350525856018,
-0.13125933706760406,
-0.45372429490089417,
-0.5461866855621338,
-0.30543673038482666,
0.3705402612686157,
-0.819362998008728,
0.6802678108215332,
-0.10094816982746124,
-0.7680624127388,
0.5283411145210266,
-0.6637892723083496,
-0.5631673336029053,
0.10873086005449295,
-0.2740090787410736,
-0.22149573266506195,
0.3082387149333954,
0.5005202889442444,
0.36740151047706604,
-0.19500118494033813,
0.29142940044403076,
-0.6087213158607483,
-0.40137025713920593,
0.39951610565185547,
-0.5129736661911011,
0.42504581809043884,
0.26291945576667786,
-0.13300344347953796,
0.5330572128295898,
-0.622738242149353,
0.3263965845108032,
0.13718917965888977,
-0.053168509155511856,
-0.395457923412323,
0.31512731313705444,
0.5142115950584412,
0.08593875914812088,
0.037967320531606674,
-0.2664543688297272,
-0.0010311484802514315,
-0.10152261704206467,
0.3539063036441803,
0.6541661620140076,
-0.13244004547595978,
0.5231192708015442,
-0.17785724997520447,
0.3242795169353485,
-0.06536815315485,
0.3390776813030243,
-0.4623134732246399,
-0.6172502040863037,
-0.5353087782859802,
-0.5215309858322144,
0.12476088106632233,
0.37895527482032776,
-0.8893178105354309,
-0.15011923015117645,
-0.30790039896965027,
-0.24824057519435883,
-0.13132703304290771,
0.0946192517876625,
0.3821319043636322,
0.3594329357147217,
0.5040618181228638,
-0.4617960751056671,
-0.568343997001648,
-0.9853222966194153,
-0.20800115168094635,
0.2344445288181305,
-0.24550816416740417,
0.4072466492652893,
0.5280643701553345,
-0.323684424161911,
0.933271050453186,
-0.5225849747657776,
-0.38883623480796814,
-0.26829326152801514,
0.10808343440294266,
-0.1078256219625473,
0.23735158145427704,
0.7069474458694458,
-1.1706267595291138,
-0.2623092234134674,
-0.2676510810852051,
-0.8104473948478699,
0.05891010910272598,
0.20984144508838654,
0.09958333522081375,
0.28920429944992065,
0.6136384606361389,
-0.3964267373085022,
0.6307138204574585,
0.9108750224113464,
-0.5671006441116333,
0.37760400772094727,
-0.33955949544906616,
0.22760653495788574,
-0.7927767634391785,
0.432567298412323,
0.04705740511417389,
-0.1591617465019226,
-0.5289667248725891,
0.17166325449943542,
0.3174701929092407,
-0.2872248888015747,
-0.5347007513046265,
0.7144623398780823,
-0.6642681956291199,
-0.43724721670150757,
-0.10993790626525879,
0.2270382195711136,
0.26204395294189453,
0.23038260638713837,
0.16718921065330505,
1.0135726928710938,
0.7162927389144897,
-0.3890228271484375,
-0.014052840881049633,
0.30847540497779846,
-0.7254202961921692,
0.5445676445960999,
-0.8703912496566772,
-0.18304964900016785,
-0.14735311269760132,
0.49111902713775635,
-1.0357542037963867,
-0.2816449701786041,
-0.07488903403282166,
-0.13241766393184662,
0.08072835206985474,
-0.1143210381269455,
-0.3975124657154083,
-0.1823827475309372,
-0.26032108068466187,
0.7434452772140503,
0.4100046157836914,
-0.6179667115211487,
0.7409642338752747,
0.2993393838405609,
0.10438477247953415,
-0.6718322038650513,
-0.7277885675430298,
0.3053891956806183,
0.049460820853710175,
-0.7410436868667603,
0.14464400708675385,
-0.3712339401245117,
-0.4100871980190277,
-0.06796308606863022,
0.07250671833753586,
-0.2578766644001007,
0.1188664585351944,
0.4032887816429138,
0.350155234336853,
-0.36009564995765686,
0.12604057788848877,
-0.185110405087471,
-0.021773094311356544,
-0.049268413335084915,
-0.033085450530052185,
0.3024320602416992,
-0.35628750920295715,
-0.40333467721939087,
-0.4571384787559509,
0.49182984232902527,
0.9045729041099548,
-0.7160387635231018,
0.7335820198059082,
0.7132498025894165,
-0.15959419310092926,
-0.1303897649049759,
-0.596370279788971,
-0.011982225812971592,
-0.41791775822639465,
0.28492996096611023,
-0.6443405747413635,
-0.7181575894355774,
0.314151406288147,
0.17054376006126404,
-0.3213617205619812,
0.30708011984825134,
0.3806544244289398,
-0.08125381171703339,
1.2474433183670044,
0.6015598773956299,
0.17881418764591217,
0.6093676090240479,
-0.21662206947803497,
-0.12335824221372604,
-0.9033663868904114,
-0.1849300116300583,
-0.08088643848896027,
-0.27198928594589233,
-0.16790197789669037,
-0.5077773332595825,
0.3719915747642517,
-0.10872923582792282,
0.22909007966518402,
-0.10500739514827728,
-0.07091701030731201,
0.6479700207710266,
0.49664244055747986,
0.16031481325626373,
0.2856723368167877,
-0.003509869333356619,
-0.1040281355381012,
0.04037218540906906,
-0.48208552598953247,
-0.5127549171447754,
0.9950997233390808,
0.10806076973676682,
0.59893798828125,
0.018100755289196968,
0.09822694212198257,
0.21009477972984314,
0.44751036167144775,
-0.5456061363220215,
0.6515765190124512,
-0.3015618920326233,
-0.451971173286438,
-0.11580812186002731,
-0.32646551728248596,
-0.9444373846054077,
0.5573153495788574,
-0.39316174387931824,
-0.6932026147842407,
0.1420162320137024,
0.07605110853910446,
-0.049410853534936905,
0.26460838317871094,
-0.8391934633255005,
1.2522162199020386,
-0.20361343026161194,
-0.43384289741516113,
-0.15622980892658234,
-0.766510009765625,
0.33257120847702026,
0.20043125748634338,
0.37796545028686523,
-0.26321619749069214,
-0.3230208456516266,
0.4841178357601166,
-0.14833448827266693,
0.8494546413421631,
-0.20687095820903778,
-0.03660893812775612,
0.089752696454525,
0.03236215561628342,
0.08834328502416611,
0.12435862421989441,
0.04743943363428116,
0.27335453033447266,
0.2757612466812134,
-0.5606125593185425,
-0.6258676052093506,
0.6755640506744385,
-0.4679024815559387,
-0.277518093585968,
-0.1657273769378662,
-0.8058359622955322,
-0.4494113028049469,
0.30929189920425415,
0.23765690624713898,
0.9555913209915161,
-0.2489599883556366,
0.4097214341163635,
0.40425607562065125,
-0.1413118988275528,
0.6498967409133911,
0.24481290578842163,
-0.25167950987815857,
-0.6086620688438416,
0.6800326704978943,
-0.23764123022556305,
0.3126419186592102,
0.2691652476787567,
-0.07248611003160477,
-0.4092225432395935,
-0.7145829200744629,
-0.6674929261207581,
-0.026072505861520767,
-1.0846161842346191,
-0.09480663388967514,
-0.40627580881118774,
0.14055563509464264,
-0.33065229654312134,
-0.13474765419960022,
0.0145229771733284,
-0.14367344975471497,
-0.29254329204559326,
0.2602638900279999,
-0.06738219410181046,
0.9538295269012451,
0.2488304227590561,
-0.12546706199645996,
-0.8648467659950256,
0.4797583222389221,
0.31500378251075745,
0.6962519884109497,
0.05309632420539856,
-0.38376349210739136,
-0.09255252778530121,
0.071153923869133,
0.007628148887306452,
-0.6697364449501038,
0.17709271609783173,
0.3315591812133789,
0.7574760317802429,
0.5286675095558167,
-0.03351781517267227,
0.6615957617759705,
-0.5927034020423889,
0.7952280044555664,
0.17837892472743988,
-1.1309764385223389,
0.5283008217811584,
-0.22671571373939514,
0.5986008048057556,
0.6239420771598816,
0.05319327488541603,
-0.5038071274757385,
-0.34806784987449646,
-0.2401595264673233,
-0.8167465925216675,
0.3372166156768799,
0.17849451303482056,
0.030616169795393944,
-0.04296160489320755,
0.07589279860258102,
-0.05947500467300415,
-0.01739756017923355,
-0.717437744140625,
0.0406455397605896,
-0.087324358522892,
-0.3054563105106354,
-0.5286770462989807,
-0.5826773047447205,
-0.17257721722126007,
-0.3480798006057739,
0.2959231436252594,
-0.3336649537086487,
-0.06394936144351959,
0.44361239671707153,
-0.6711273193359375,
0.07663745433092117,
0.119804747402668,
1.1609008312225342,
1.1625633239746094,
-0.1201656311750412,
0.4151837229728699,
0.36031877994537354,
-0.36492595076560974,
-0.2013590931892395,
-0.11166555434465408,
-0.11389614641666412,
0.00266281352378428,
0.7888078689575195,
0.9560680389404297,
0.432597279548645,
-1.176085352897644,
0.8577564358711243,
-0.4038374423980713,
-0.1641564965248108,
-0.1403140276670456,
-0.18139410018920898,
-0.008500347845256329,
0.33473700284957886,
0.5063647031784058,
0.23598599433898926,
0.11546283215284348,
-0.41656556725502014,
0.368669331073761,
0.588057279586792,
-0.39553120732307434,
-0.12832029163837433,
0.6125472187995911,
0.25976255536079407,
-0.004061626736074686,
0.29471343755722046,
0.09202232956886292,
-0.4487494230270386,
0.5893396735191345,
0.5590043067932129,
0.6907173991203308,
0.1696450412273407,
-0.01574217528104782,
0.3671325147151947,
0.18583500385284424,
-0.06187599524855614,
0.2515976130962372,
-0.20258809626102448,
-0.5312187075614929,
-0.4863891005516052,
-0.4340600371360779,
-0.36579638719558716,
-0.19126169383525848,
-0.6627865433692932,
0.14613430202007294,
-0.2547648251056671,
-0.21354062855243683,
-0.04069402068853378,
-0.4829144775867462,
-0.6099947690963745,
0.4053960144519806,
0.6092778444290161,
1.1557118892669678,
-0.7094334959983826,
0.7483841776847839,
0.7299055457115173,
-0.4586937129497528,
-0.41613200306892395,
0.028694968670606613,
-0.12116216123104095,
-0.5494089722633362,
0.8958635926246643,
0.49639230966567993,
-0.23582562804222107,
-0.18151704967021942,
-0.5729774236679077,
-0.7454941868782043,
1.0165648460388184,
0.30702099204063416,
-0.34824612736701965,
0.2565324008464813,
-0.09000440686941147,
0.6388009786605835,
-0.5780344009399414,
0.26312756538391113,
0.19656288623809814,
0.7334792017936707,
0.02127869799733162,
-0.6174651384353638,
0.12366925925016403,
-0.42945054173469543,
0.3617549538612366,
-0.027897946536540985,
-0.1622697412967682,
0.7669981122016907,
-0.47895383834838867,
-0.41344666481018066,
0.35674065351486206,
0.5158233046531677,
-0.10315891355276108,
0.6558094024658203,
0.8109539747238159,
0.5311287641525269,
0.4042035639286041,
-0.11867779493331909,
1.445721983909607,
-0.2514650523662567,
0.40088778734207153,
1.0808374881744385,
-0.2411133199930191,
1.3552048206329346,
0.6030220985412598,
0.15476441383361816,
0.5629057288169861,
0.45394614338874817,
-0.14075256884098053,
0.4959335923194885,
-0.04995883256196976,
-0.32926419377326965,
-0.37687814235687256,
-0.1428600549697876,
-0.49523669481277466,
0.452228844165802,
0.060230553150177,
-0.36789238452911377,
-0.06959860026836395,
0.30979758501052856,
-0.4995657205581665,
0.158046692609787,
-0.12021583318710327,
0.8573199510574341,
-0.09532439708709717,
-0.7632485628128052,
0.6844691038131714,
-0.3230855464935303,
0.4156000018119812,
-0.6225926876068115,
0.048115555197000504,
-0.1587209552526474,
0.2771206796169281,
-0.046255923807621,
-0.8205326795578003,
0.2048930823802948,
-0.10429403185844421,
-0.2354244440793991,
-0.13411478698253632,
0.6312580108642578,
-0.5198577642440796,
-0.5822235941886902,
0.5516890287399292,
0.4579399824142456,
-0.1874304711818695,
-0.18582108616828918,
-0.46768081188201904,
0.5844947695732117,
-0.2617798447608948,
-0.21874620020389557,
0.07600941509008408,
0.1253015398979187,
-0.06159299612045288,
0.754946768283844,
0.7708958983421326,
-0.24818770587444305,
-0.017164746299386024,
0.5138443112373352,
0.7024969458580017,
-0.5125157833099365,
-0.3397901952266693,
-1.0144588947296143,
0.5377588868141174,
-0.3183886408805847,
-0.34900006651878357,
0.6774753928184509,
0.6184746026992798,
0.754235029220581,
-0.4608767032623291,
0.5794269442558289,
0.07101735472679138,
-0.01361805759370327,
-0.6582624912261963,
0.8628016710281372,
-1.0808740854263306,
-0.12387292832136154,
-0.39927372336387634,
-0.9339239001274109,
-0.7086617350578308,
0.2923164665699005,
-0.33369749784469604,
-0.2066292017698288,
0.9206399917602539,
0.5207602977752686,
-0.1928211897611618,
-0.000017579863197170198,
0.6932275295257568,
-0.013413561508059502,
0.1867314875125885,
0.4008799195289612,
1.094577431678772,
-0.2742965817451477,
0.6163405776023865,
-0.06210925802588463,
-0.15072564780712128,
-0.18024694919586182,
-1.021313190460205,
-1.0029916763305664,
-0.829412579536438,
0.04280737787485123,
0.0643240436911583,
0.11109860241413116,
0.5453306436538696,
0.998953640460968,
-0.7444248795509338,
-0.19652307033538818,
0.11204379796981812,
0.046235211193561554,
-0.18581491708755493,
-0.12983521819114685,
0.1432628184556961,
-0.550682544708252,
-0.6528289914131165,
0.5108600854873657,
0.4760013520717621,
0.19493113458156586,
-0.0033869280014187098,
-0.0387214720249176,
-0.2754531502723694,
-0.0020896028727293015,
0.9965021014213562,
-0.01854519173502922,
-1.0079997777938843,
-0.2747824192047119,
-0.12411443889141083,
-0.20141538977622986,
0.11662746965885162,
1.196244478225708,
-0.5925767421722412,
0.6215862035751343,
0.5835310220718384,
0.7417563796043396,
0.4909026622772217,
0.02940402179956436,
0.5418483018875122,
-0.641940176486969,
0.42913082242012024,
-0.0074883196502923965,
0.7703564763069153,
0.5572105646133423,
0.15371489524841309,
0.5488409399986267,
0.28106898069381714,
-0.20687943696975708,
-0.8032169938087463,
0.28290855884552,
-1.3347214460372925,
-0.6216046214103699,
1.1224044561386108,
-0.13988879323005676,
-0.3310905992984772,
0.2470531165599823,
-0.40891143679618835,
-0.1346106231212616,
-0.050100937485694885,
0.42123037576675415,
0.5708104968070984,
0.31801676750183105,
-0.30584150552749634,
-0.6813474893569946,
0.3485408425331116,
0.6679953932762146,
-0.9047372341156006,
0.1218215823173523,
0.6371144652366638,
0.2604117691516876,
-0.0066359518095850945,
0.41639602184295654,
0.11311354488134384,
0.35936635732650757,
-0.11448169499635696,
0.03821061551570892,
-0.12251423299312592,
-0.40364256501197815,
-0.25426432490348816,
0.2824269235134125,
-0.091849185526371,
-0.22155405580997467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13606v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13606v2
|
A Comprehensive Study of Multilingual Confidence Estimation on Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T08:20:06 | 2024-06-16T07:28:26 |
Boyang Xue, Hongru Wang, Rui Wang, Sheng Wang, Zezhong Wang, Yiming Du, Kam-Fai Wong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The tendency of Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate hallucinations and
exhibit overconfidence in predictions raises concerns regarding their
reliability. Confidence or uncertainty estimations indicating the extent of
trustworthiness of a model's response are essential to developing reliable AI
systems. Current research primarily focuses on LLM confidence estimations in
English, remaining a void for other widely used languages and impeding the
global development of reliable AI applications. This paper introduces a
comprehensive investigation of \textbf Multi\textbf{ling}ual
\textbf{Conf}idence estimation (\textsc{MlingConf}) on LLMs. First, we
introduce an elaborated and expert-checked multilingual QA dataset.
Subsequently, we delve into the performance of several confidence estimation
methods across diverse languages and examine how these confidence scores can
enhance LLM performance through self-refinement. Extensive experiments
conducted on the multilingual QA dataset demonstrate that confidence estimation
results vary in different languages, and the verbalized numerical confidence
estimation method exhibits the best performance among most languages over other
methods. Finally, the obtained confidence scores can consistently improve
performance as self-refinement feedback across various languages.
|
[
-0.3905782103538513,
-0.7573744654655457,
0.6439923644065857,
0.4411507546901703,
0.032004281878471375,
0.10698430240154266,
-0.35947585105895996,
-0.763615608215332,
0.15747961401939392,
0.05747722461819649,
-0.24786409735679626,
-0.567962646484375,
-0.5584731698036194,
0.3687925934791565,
-0.13366670906543732,
0.46329593658447266,
0.06523490697145462,
0.4830198884010315,
-0.2668987214565277,
-0.12020082026720047,
-0.48970896005630493,
-0.7462459802627563,
-0.5603273510932922,
-0.467849463224411,
0.5639191269874573,
0.3539262115955353,
0.6946311593055725,
0.1754007637500763,
0.3734493553638458,
0.3165143132209778,
0.12024053931236267,
0.38434895873069763,
-0.38612252473831177,
0.36314889788627625,
-0.15423662960529327,
-0.5306956768035889,
-0.20095156133174896,
-0.046573154628276825,
0.8734350800514221,
0.45613664388656616,
-0.2405930757522583,
-0.04600033164024353,
0.21000123023986816,
0.42487335205078125,
-0.8493082523345947,
0.3563475012779236,
-0.6744638681411743,
-0.03502658009529114,
-0.031536269932985306,
-0.09934423863887787,
-0.5109565854072571,
-0.17470067739486694,
0.008114518597722054,
-0.4576428234577179,
-0.23684461414813995,
0.005740338005125523,
0.6703465580940247,
0.347016841173172,
-0.533684492111206,
-0.3909706473350525,
-0.892777681350708,
1.0933537483215332,
-0.769546389579773,
0.5592318177223206,
0.4754934310913086,
0.1756560355424881,
-0.3686204254627228,
-0.4477667510509491,
-0.519437313079834,
-0.4776669144630432,
-0.12123240530490875,
0.09617143869400024,
0.016894951462745667,
0.1815515011548996,
0.022381212562322617,
0.3001376986503601,
-0.4725343585014343,
0.32710567116737366,
-0.022936943918466568,
-0.2276332676410675,
0.8699806332588196,
-0.2512597143650055,
0.0661529004573822,
0.017447885125875473,
-0.13885442912578583,
0.054654210805892944,
-0.6848666071891785,
0.0010318601271137595,
0.45807135105133057,
0.07455287873744965,
0.0023572847712785006,
0.37387004494667053,
-0.22483575344085693,
0.48477205634117126,
-0.10396971553564072,
-0.5851342082023621,
0.22894072532653809,
-0.29555851221084595,
-0.1962432861328125,
-0.13199889659881592,
0.958918571472168,
0.2325117588043213,
0.8384293913841248,
-0.2996424436569214,
-0.13676880300045013,
-0.0876132920384407,
0.04302259907126427,
-0.6340953707695007,
-0.09779147803783417,
0.4569040536880493,
-0.06238754838705063,
0.02665591426193714,
0.2257279008626938,
-0.6342572569847107,
-0.31321677565574646,
-0.2573951482772827,
0.18247613310813904,
-0.42872607707977295,
-0.3650113046169281,
0.007187747396528721,
0.3714504837989807,
0.22133782505989075,
0.12038084119558334,
-0.5277577042579651,
-0.13663604855537415,
0.6020327210426331,
0.5446345210075378,
-0.38111168146133423,
-0.6535543203353882,
-0.251272588968277,
-0.0324283093214035,
-0.6585190296173096,
0.6559944152832031,
-0.4491134583950043,
-0.4017685353755951,
0.21460846066474915,
0.15748938918113708,
-0.1875895857810974,
-0.36267879605293274,
0.5162788033485413,
-0.3507118225097656,
0.06290898472070694,
0.05872167646884918,
-0.6143492460250854,
-0.2558765113353729,
0.6102011203765869,
-0.6415385007858276,
1.0126489400863647,
-0.30362099409103394,
-0.7014612555503845,
0.1505880206823349,
-0.03875240683555603,
-0.4855388104915619,
-0.21732521057128906,
-0.3053557276725769,
-0.27211374044418335,
0.134220153093338,
0.24909630417823792,
0.670875072479248,
-0.24439187347888947,
0.4867772161960602,
-0.4569561183452606,
-0.39634817838668823,
0.672359824180603,
-0.7718810439109802,
0.5770289301872253,
0.15854988992214203,
-0.1436169594526291,
0.0490136556327343,
-0.750201404094696,
0.3131873607635498,
-0.29683101177215576,
-0.07402480393648148,
-0.34482648968696594,
-0.09678226709365845,
-0.16721180081367493,
0.2688099443912506,
0.35947608947753906,
-0.47131696343421936,
-0.1523144245147705,
-0.359100341796875,
0.1141820028424263,
0.7018032073974609,
0.17803826928138733,
0.020063772797584534,
-0.024948837235569954,
0.6298801302909851,
-0.08564573526382446,
0.15670031309127808,
-0.19162234663963318,
-0.514573872089386,
-0.6517735123634338,
-0.11279205977916718,
0.4064728617668152,
0.5692098140716553,
-0.6903331875801086,
0.2870430052280426,
-0.16063134372234344,
-0.5707049369812012,
-0.5794628262519836,
0.19383719563484192,
0.6440838575363159,
0.13043028116226196,
0.2144479900598526,
0.05961659923195839,
-0.4239122271537781,
-0.9584808349609375,
-0.14332084357738495,
-0.41485828161239624,
0.12257685512304306,
0.17746515572071075,
0.3813927173614502,
-0.24151164293289185,
0.4398100674152374,
-0.14956894516944885,
-0.033858586102724075,
-0.10227112472057343,
0.024564001709222794,
0.04344749450683594,
0.5466475486755371,
0.5942184329032898,
-0.6840701699256897,
-0.7644761204719543,
0.019704598933458328,
-0.7424198389053345,
0.2974677085876465,
-0.1496787816286087,
-0.04083498567342758,
0.6477518081665039,
0.47224101424217224,
-0.5329486131668091,
0.17706966400146484,
1.056312084197998,
-0.12216297537088394,
0.7170388102531433,
-0.3502267003059387,
0.3701235055923462,
-1.047229290008545,
0.13462446630001068,
0.14609597623348236,
-0.08295781165361404,
-0.4823901057243347,
0.46156516671180725,
0.04547994211316109,
0.49801063537597656,
-0.1856575757265091,
0.7197993397712708,
-0.6591064929962158,
0.12079711258411407,
-0.13691341876983643,
0.2571851313114166,
-0.010837451554834843,
0.421511709690094,
-0.0022456033620983362,
0.8008115887641907,
0.6406341195106506,
-0.5323213338851929,
0.22905871272087097,
-0.07624788582324982,
-0.5609169602394104,
0.7084466814994812,
-0.5482631921768188,
0.1587444543838501,
-0.07955849915742874,
-0.015608411282300949,
-1.2424440383911133,
-0.28968343138694763,
-0.042854193598032,
-0.5405198335647583,
0.6587808728218079,
-0.002292930381372571,
-0.42435765266418457,
-0.27127113938331604,
-0.03165657818317413,
0.2679305970668793,
0.2241012305021286,
-0.49188390374183655,
0.6274393200874329,
0.5498851537704468,
-0.09164482355117798,
-1.0438897609710693,
-0.8085188269615173,
0.1673905849456787,
-0.045119546353816986,
-0.5204919576644897,
0.032784175127744675,
-0.411988765001297,
-0.6739262342453003,
-0.41280531883239746,
-0.005952774081379175,
-0.35246020555496216,
0.2571179270744324,
0.2545197606086731,
0.18590448796749115,
0.0627676472067833,
0.3707670569419861,
-0.04503995552659035,
-0.06221052259206772,
0.1988481730222702,
-0.05649518221616745,
0.48179176449775696,
-0.1004793792963028,
-0.6108312606811523,
-0.4164680540561676,
0.24547947943210602,
0.6690077781677246,
-0.2697126865386963,
0.8076992630958557,
0.5564247965812683,
-0.38954371213912964,
-0.22955302894115448,
-0.9874550700187683,
-0.17370302975177765,
-0.38024380803108215,
0.47494980692863464,
-0.6385585069656372,
-0.7713814377784729,
0.6304069757461548,
0.2639120817184448,
-0.023676058277487755,
0.4807135760784149,
0.4974921941757202,
-0.04204702377319336,
1.077365517616272,
0.8010055422782898,
-0.3018858730792999,
0.1310350000858307,
-0.04106372967362404,
0.10965419560670853,
-0.38422393798828125,
-0.4044853150844574,
-0.7136005759239197,
-0.0864611342549324,
-0.7856443524360657,
-0.4000358283519745,
0.32014763355255127,
0.04225844144821167,
-0.07739122211933136,
-0.13551068305969238,
-0.02446752041578293,
0.472086101770401,
0.47831934690475464,
-0.22156764566898346,
0.5214807391166687,
0.029303116723895073,
-0.22240427136421204,
-0.17864878475666046,
-0.5633082389831543,
-0.35186856985092163,
1.0285453796386719,
0.4851004481315613,
0.9211754202842712,
0.026850851252675056,
0.5027145147323608,
-0.08111701905727386,
0.28481319546699524,
-0.8194090127944946,
0.13133083283901215,
-0.0113117890432477,
-0.7559227347373962,
-0.5151684880256653,
-0.45740318298339844,
-0.7010208964347839,
0.21821099519729614,
-0.16524158418178558,
-0.6625520586967468,
0.20003066956996918,
0.147181898355484,
-0.3127462863922119,
0.13930566608905792,
-0.4570733606815338,
0.554022490978241,
-0.2925400137901306,
-0.26274019479751587,
-0.4365104138851166,
-0.526292622089386,
0.4610517919063568,
-0.34930482506752014,
0.2094242125749588,
-0.24772456288337708,
0.11436446011066437,
0.27233362197875977,
-0.010296017862856388,
0.7326273322105408,
0.08518262207508087,
-0.5743595957756042,
0.30067336559295654,
0.14555415511131287,
0.5992680788040161,
0.4057777225971222,
-0.571367621421814,
0.5892161130905151,
0.23993444442749023,
-0.2973293662071228,
-0.530301570892334,
0.952218770980835,
-0.7242559194564819,
-0.549247145652771,
-0.39451056718826294,
-0.6391730904579163,
-0.5947735905647278,
0.0542566142976284,
0.39489126205444336,
0.11903993040323257,
-0.4109225273132324,
0.2683662474155426,
0.6489273309707642,
-0.28604790568351746,
0.39903169870376587,
0.5860016345977783,
-0.1957307904958725,
-0.425351083278656,
0.48136624693870544,
0.330396443605423,
0.440153032541275,
0.4229508340358734,
-0.013165883719921112,
-0.44480040669441223,
-0.4876754879951477,
-0.43575841188430786,
0.35094180703163147,
-0.6887649297714233,
-0.15425072610378265,
-0.4305568337440491,
-0.34339943528175354,
-0.5699641704559326,
0.09876838326454163,
-0.577896237373352,
-0.2968272268772125,
-0.05822673812508583,
-0.22471506893634796,
0.18667007982730865,
0.7512130737304688,
-0.003479932900518179,
0.12222237884998322,
-0.6360971331596375,
0.04855784773826599,
0.05096155032515526,
0.4502902328968048,
0.07678567618131638,
-0.5275456309318542,
-0.4065900444984436,
0.2671850025653839,
0.175460547208786,
-0.6102703809738159,
0.4411787986755371,
0.205874502658844,
0.8593633770942688,
0.34557071328163147,
0.05736912786960602,
0.7132716774940491,
-0.32093048095703125,
0.6765564680099487,
0.04074348136782646,
-0.7132949233055115,
0.02833796665072441,
0.16666312515735626,
0.27544543147087097,
0.5530841946601868,
0.5972967743873596,
-0.5817883610725403,
-0.5075170397758484,
-0.3105306625366211,
-0.5783060789108276,
0.1088901236653328,
-0.12381507456302643,
0.13157816231250763,
-0.07860857993364334,
0.5190448760986328,
0.02759106084704399,
0.17961136996746063,
-0.7128326296806335,
-0.4387790262699127,
0.05897499620914459,
-0.15859565138816833,
-0.4850423038005829,
-0.6648791432380676,
-0.09672030806541443,
-0.032402943819761276,
0.9374011754989624,
-0.3900526762008667,
-0.11054321378469467,
0.22113719582557678,
-0.028126275166869164,
-0.12706463038921356,
0.2837393879890442,
0.527527391910553,
0.8950895071029663,
0.06057661026716232,
0.1467519849538803,
0.2953846752643585,
-0.3539675176143646,
0.24122226238250732,
0.038464032113552094,
-0.21477705240249634,
0.14668235182762146,
0.46904608607292175,
0.3996250033378601,
0.11680199205875397,
-0.6940886378288269,
0.3751044273376465,
-0.06827068328857422,
0.04415692389011383,
-0.8827384114265442,
-0.2105610966682434,
0.012408969923853874,
0.23168136179447174,
0.28581562638282776,
-0.2381289005279541,
0.07768616080284119,
-0.42768287658691406,
0.14418070018291473,
0.7555965781211853,
-0.5815376043319702,
-0.2623922526836395,
0.27417388558387756,
0.018171999603509903,
0.128939688205719,
0.5692164301872253,
-0.16403597593307495,
-0.36258888244628906,
0.5444837808609009,
0.5549750924110413,
0.9810974597930908,
-0.6775754690170288,
0.11102452874183655,
0.6444301009178162,
0.5056792497634888,
-0.2636321485042572,
0.3159904181957245,
0.4683605134487152,
-1.0132358074188232,
-0.8299527168273926,
-0.7362801432609558,
-0.42831599712371826,
0.10757104307413101,
-0.4100182354450226,
0.072108194231987,
-0.2422197163105011,
-0.2351265549659729,
-0.5024457573890686,
0.22287847101688385,
-0.44843170046806335,
0.32542991638183594,
0.14432105422019958,
0.8571116924285889,
-0.5025184750556946,
1.0543878078460693,
0.47619810700416565,
-0.16986724734306335,
-1.0346707105636597,
0.14069978892803192,
-0.10966329276561737,
-0.848422646522522,
0.38241875171661377,
0.18416617810726166,
-0.5859268307685852,
-0.07802771776914597,
-0.5065879225730896,
-1.1289175748825073,
0.940015971660614,
0.4583861827850342,
-0.701708197593689,
0.008483552373945713,
0.15146668255329132,
0.6202957630157471,
-0.3376626670360565,
0.3129173815250397,
0.5787639617919922,
0.6852278709411621,
0.07265551388263702,
-1.024503231048584,
-0.1394796222448349,
-0.18518012762069702,
-0.04507286474108696,
-0.1460292786359787,
-0.7703741192817688,
0.6996456384658813,
-0.2871676981449127,
-0.20962250232696533,
0.3842240273952484,
0.7014939785003662,
0.37380537390708923,
0.06390447169542313,
0.37397778034210205,
0.24870631098747253,
0.9045968055725098,
-0.024552632123231888,
1.0858685970306396,
-0.9770184755325317,
0.18534676730632782,
1.2429614067077637,
-0.16824054718017578,
0.9590515494346619,
0.483564168214798,
0.001551151741296053,
0.6116074323654175,
0.5869792699813843,
0.01870233379304409,
0.0281013585627079,
0.05059964954853058,
-0.1022576093673706,
-0.3667442202568054,
-0.27854660153388977,
-0.18631859123706818,
0.557293713092804,
0.40284082293510437,
-0.39849576354026794,
0.336044579744339,
-0.12163344770669937,
0.26186251640319824,
0.10839556157588959,
-0.21558573842048645,
0.5226691365242004,
0.3429047763347626,
-1.1081821918487549,
0.5902155637741089,
0.12326490879058838,
0.7106959819793701,
-0.5981873273849487,
0.06052311137318611,
-0.37746867537498474,
0.3589908182621002,
-0.11970626562833786,
-0.6974919438362122,
0.03577277064323425,
-0.27027979493141174,
0.10540276020765305,
0.20880122482776642,
0.48685088753700256,
-0.7713610529899597,
-0.6589541435241699,
0.5674021244049072,
0.7238302230834961,
0.2668627202510834,
-0.32352644205093384,
-0.5818520784378052,
0.0025975590106099844,
-0.00685874093323946,
-0.3074062764644623,
0.07462222129106522,
0.557349443435669,
0.061768244951963425,
1.096747875213623,
0.375041663646698,
0.11752677708864212,
-0.028686515986919403,
0.09547433257102966,
0.318876713514328,
-0.37402209639549255,
-0.18609587848186493,
-0.9148973822593689,
0.38974303007125854,
0.05559161305427551,
-0.3364494740962982,
1.069071888923645,
0.3611256778240204,
0.9628890752792358,
-0.039698243141174316,
0.830328106880188,
0.2974809408187866,
0.47708213329315186,
-0.6310489177703857,
0.77739417552948,
-0.492338091135025,
0.09808490425348282,
-0.31298696994781494,
-0.9247034192085266,
-0.4340631663799286,
0.6430872082710266,
-0.06230825558304787,
0.22800597548484802,
0.7432150840759277,
0.9146371483802795,
0.29574593901634216,
-0.2997342646121979,
0.7187452912330627,
0.4592866003513336,
0.16005787253379822,
0.2610737979412079,
0.6605502367019653,
-0.24952572584152222,
0.46242812275886536,
-0.6898638606071472,
-0.026879530400037766,
-0.0125808110460639,
-0.8577558994293213,
-0.8694987297058105,
-0.47737085819244385,
-0.19308364391326904,
-0.3436579406261444,
-0.10402132570743561,
0.8336654305458069,
0.7099642753601074,
-1.2203088998794556,
-0.5644158720970154,
0.31489142775535583,
0.20571433007717133,
-0.14566798508167267,
-0.18959562480449677,
0.3074747323989868,
-0.5585998296737671,
-1.1228020191192627,
0.4415041208267212,
0.1654338240623474,
0.13712920248508453,
-0.9010177850723267,
-0.3517265319824219,
-0.2811947464942932,
0.20175354182720184,
0.4452629089355469,
0.19599950313568115,
-0.8538731932640076,
-0.3681904375553131,
0.21116460859775543,
-0.3006461262702942,
-0.007498725783079863,
0.40572237968444824,
-0.3426136076450348,
0.5070561170578003,
0.21000522375106812,
0.4924408197402954,
0.13084229826927185,
0.05958398059010506,
0.9106171727180481,
-0.8128538727760315,
0.20613083243370056,
-0.0009813833748921752,
0.6590098738670349,
0.5061230063438416,
-0.43676769733428955,
0.7245442271232605,
-0.04429996386170387,
-0.6269736289978027,
-0.7299100756645203,
0.23168520629405975,
-0.5065528750419617,
-0.33116400241851807,
1.2586711645126343,
-0.45107734203338623,
0.011459602043032646,
-0.22771453857421875,
0.023104265332221985,
0.0787665992975235,
-0.25533628463745117,
0.8979930877685547,
1.0776952505111694,
0.015114715322852135,
-0.15239998698234558,
-0.46153444051742554,
0.5867003202438354,
0.31586548686027527,
-0.6068423986434937,
0.04214413836598396,
0.5530974268913269,
0.1688486933708191,
0.5526301264762878,
0.4322308301925659,
-0.08138782531023026,
-0.013734173960983753,
-0.15326593816280365,
0.27348414063453674,
0.21307380497455597,
-0.7536234259605408,
-0.413177490234375,
0.27705222368240356,
0.49223455786705017,
0.26298800110816956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13605v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13605v6
|
KorNAT: LLM Alignment Benchmark for Korean Social Values and Common Knowledge
| 2024-02-21T08:12:26 | 2024-06-06T03:22:38 |
Jiyoung Lee, Minwoo Kim, Seungho Kim, Junghwan Kim, Seunghyun Won, Hwaran Lee, Edward Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For Large Language Models (LLMs) to be effectively deployed in a specific
country, they must possess an understanding of the nation's culture and basic
knowledge. To this end, we introduce National Alignment, which measures an
alignment between an LLM and a targeted country from two aspects: social value
alignment and common knowledge alignment. Social value alignment evaluates how
well the model understands nation-specific social values, while common
knowledge alignment examines how well the model captures basic knowledge
related to the nation. We constructed KorNAT, the first benchmark that measures
national alignment with South Korea. For the social value dataset, we obtained
ground truth labels from a large-scale survey involving 6,174 unique Korean
participants. For the common knowledge dataset, we constructed samples based on
Korean textbooks and GED reference materials. KorNAT contains 4K and 6K
multiple-choice questions for social value and common knowledge, respectively.
Our dataset creation process is meticulously designed and based on statistical
sampling theory and was refined through multiple rounds of human review. The
experiment results of seven LLMs reveal that only a few models met our
reference score, indicating a potential for further enhancement. KorNAT has
received government approval after passing an assessment conducted by a
government-affiliated organization dedicated to evaluating dataset quality.
Samples and detailed evaluation protocols of our dataset can be found in
https://huggingface.co/datasets/jiyounglee0523/KorNAT .
|
[
-0.08670962601900101,
-0.3130153715610504,
0.5349753499031067,
0.15130490064620972,
-0.41862237453460693,
0.3801860511302948,
-0.14634187519550323,
-0.23527389764785767,
0.17446759343147278,
0.5882272124290466,
-0.11520370095968246,
-0.7648999094963074,
-0.7011690735816956,
-0.14549599587917328,
-0.05192791670560837,
0.9198858737945557,
-0.2310335487127304,
0.1755533665418625,
-0.411787748336792,
-0.5630870461463928,
-0.2647426724433899,
-0.48363927006721497,
-0.2200319766998291,
-0.40744996070861816,
0.587152898311615,
0.4223315119743347,
0.7321630716323853,
0.5739664435386658,
0.6259170770645142,
0.15020652115345,
-0.3351925015449524,
0.14426004886627197,
-0.6785123348236084,
0.03509557619690895,
-0.41731417179107666,
-0.25739383697509766,
-0.7237011194229126,
0.030929697677493095,
0.6436755657196045,
0.7979418635368347,
0.13336502015590668,
0.6366330981254578,
0.1482582986354828,
1.120659351348877,
-0.6233116388320923,
0.09664890170097351,
-0.49885988235473633,
-0.19489675760269165,
-0.060660336166620255,
0.2938533127307892,
0.01228424534201622,
-1.0915179252624512,
0.3538932800292969,
-0.3613908886909485,
-0.2429669052362442,
-0.13399645686149597,
0.9979526400566101,
0.2373543679714203,
-1.0210645198822021,
-0.2868894338607788,
-0.3695092797279358,
0.7818648815155029,
-0.5559568405151367,
0.5520601868629456,
0.060582734644412994,
0.3519136309623718,
-0.2423761934041977,
-0.36668333411216736,
-0.29002097249031067,
-0.20820371806621552,
0.08241844177246094,
0.3664892911911011,
0.250012069940567,
-0.0034717596136033535,
0.03349490836262703,
0.29751595854759216,
-0.6365017294883728,
-0.17228952050209045,
-0.5088045597076416,
-0.16206635534763336,
0.7945683002471924,
0.12932495772838593,
0.2506321966648102,
-0.316810667514801,
-0.7456220984458923,
0.0929466187953949,
-1.0478488206863403,
0.05997752398252487,
0.4421539306640625,
0.3275724947452545,
-0.17977431416511536,
0.8085602521896362,
-0.37587693333625793,
0.6068925857543945,
-0.029008841142058372,
-0.28169843554496765,
0.29471758008003235,
-0.7321414351463318,
-0.0008810115396045148,
0.5227347016334534,
0.5098239183425903,
1.0502066612243652,
0.5643301010131836,
-0.09660114347934723,
-0.010623525828123093,
0.35991087555885315,
0.10215117782354355,
-0.6477785706520081,
0.14704447984695435,
-0.1345881223678589,
-0.45976686477661133,
-0.4913941025733948,
0.012974182143807411,
-0.6536729335784912,
-0.5726675391197205,
-0.7188785672187805,
0.21839995682239532,
-0.021235162392258644,
-0.4607681632041931,
0.0727955773472786,
0.1891210377216339,
0.5268396139144897,
0.21825718879699707,
-0.5134933590888977,
0.2814987003803253,
0.7935112118721008,
0.9449250102043152,
-0.47364574670791626,
-0.1845652163028717,
-0.016383441165089607,
0.002837071195244789,
-0.5164940357208252,
0.7212560176849365,
-0.20998793840408325,
-0.020998666062951088,
-0.13084715604782104,
0.15601320564746857,
-0.1126759871840477,
-0.4496971070766449,
0.38486963510513306,
-0.5218668580055237,
-0.25793397426605225,
-0.7010131478309631,
-0.8197773098945618,
-0.09978073835372925,
0.6260280013084412,
-0.5333300828933716,
1.1050066947937012,
0.3641188144683838,
-0.6905999183654785,
0.5426321625709534,
-0.424182653427124,
-0.12504538893699646,
-0.0664232075214386,
-0.15219813585281372,
-0.1284675896167755,
0.0633421540260315,
-0.06825385242700577,
0.46942058205604553,
-0.31761324405670166,
0.6186944842338562,
-0.4200998842716217,
-0.4086126685142517,
0.19741418957710266,
-0.4194047152996063,
0.6780469417572021,
0.19947095215320587,
-0.01604967750608921,
-0.11710040271282196,
-0.8531320691108704,
0.1237778514623642,
0.08913429081439972,
-0.3864499032497406,
-0.4001787006855011,
-0.4239811599254608,
-0.23728327453136444,
0.3736003339290619,
0.6637864708900452,
-0.5902252793312073,
0.28445300459861755,
-0.2836077809333801,
0.07159314304590225,
0.8247100114822388,
0.07188905030488968,
0.6369658708572388,
-0.40867894887924194,
0.5525261163711548,
-0.12135213613510132,
0.027255024760961533,
0.20554742217063904,
-0.29251474142074585,
-0.367110013961792,
0.11371181905269623,
0.5734499096870422,
0.6471837162971497,
-0.3294816315174103,
0.3785038888454437,
-0.5469666719436646,
-0.7087579369544983,
-0.7825707197189331,
0.03729301318526268,
0.40260884165763855,
0.6003522872924805,
-0.03675568476319313,
-0.09967152029275894,
-0.5256123542785645,
-0.9265483021736145,
-0.48461639881134033,
-0.07042830437421799,
0.07663630694150925,
0.429309219121933,
0.4800587296485901,
0.00252789119258523,
0.8977189660072327,
-0.356399804353714,
0.22366829216480255,
0.011477619409561157,
-0.14562390744686127,
0.35083189606666565,
0.08687202632427216,
0.10464376211166382,
-0.7283368706703186,
-0.9162253737449646,
0.40070033073425293,
-0.8535494208335876,
-0.34116068482398987,
0.3327331244945526,
-0.2345236837863922,
0.3301463723182678,
0.39928334951400757,
-0.2460467666387558,
0.40504392981529236,
0.7716234922409058,
-0.3613400161266327,
0.6243109107017517,
0.18065041303634644,
0.6316547989845276,
-1.2953866720199585,
0.1434474140405655,
-0.21011660993099213,
-0.11425730586051941,
-0.6801176071166992,
-0.2559592127799988,
0.27704566717147827,
0.05943503603339195,
-0.6144441962242126,
0.7287153601646423,
-0.30343252420425415,
-0.509035050868988,
-0.14739207923412323,
0.5243491530418396,
0.1588723361492157,
0.010575172491371632,
-0.23887740075588226,
0.9174563884735107,
-0.06034407019615173,
-0.4239247739315033,
0.5127078294754028,
0.18786993622779846,
-0.6884543299674988,
1.1669574975967407,
-0.6492087244987488,
0.40587133169174194,
-0.06296690553426743,
0.0858754962682724,
-0.8606788516044617,
-0.3772135078907013,
0.22923626005649567,
-0.3631786108016968,
-0.21619266271591187,
-0.6144202947616577,
-0.37280356884002686,
0.03171722963452339,
0.05340379476547241,
0.27017486095428467,
0.4662066400051117,
-0.4144287705421448,
0.31257298588752747,
0.48623108863830566,
-0.4150935411453247,
-0.6848771572113037,
-0.26273342967033386,
-0.07361647486686707,
-0.3799988925457001,
-0.8325952291488647,
0.1301029771566391,
0.03948551416397095,
-0.22559909522533417,
0.1473512351512909,
-0.3432818055152893,
0.1166975349187851,
-0.008988382294774055,
0.19641493260860443,
0.4390769600868225,
-0.4429035484790802,
0.11906503140926361,
0.052764374762773514,
-0.19621656835079193,
-0.0964091420173645,
-0.03356987610459328,
0.7374441623687744,
-0.39303627610206604,
-0.6857416033744812,
-0.02547130174934864,
-0.043360352516174316,
0.7919111847877502,
0.0413350984454155,
0.642375111579895,
0.3512451946735382,
-0.28716257214546204,
0.5892235040664673,
-0.6190897226333618,
0.34974539279937744,
-0.3845409154891968,
0.3668234348297119,
-0.3122415542602539,
-0.9239324927330017,
0.6645534038543701,
-0.48538851737976074,
-0.10539582371711731,
0.31849464774131775,
0.405032753944397,
0.06811870634555817,
0.9373977780342102,
0.13276943564414978,
-0.40235939621925354,
0.08303076028823853,
0.16072282195091248,
0.25498107075691223,
-0.9716490507125854,
-0.23068203032016754,
-0.29894140362739563,
-0.41674935817718506,
-0.5598456263542175,
-0.339425653219223,
0.22879230976104736,
0.3838781714439392,
-0.610734224319458,
0.27605390548706055,
-0.5554901361465454,
0.8089535236358643,
0.3009856343269348,
-0.019528696313500404,
0.3641316890716553,
-0.09513124078512192,
-0.18260803818702698,
-0.1416483372449875,
-0.48274528980255127,
-1.048748254776001,
1.436419129371643,
0.20502014458179474,
0.6934703588485718,
0.010297728702425957,
0.9117292165756226,
-0.05133913457393646,
0.2971605360507965,
-0.6190245151519775,
0.47637084126472473,
-0.18679575622081757,
-0.4495590627193451,
-0.2994484603404999,
-0.29428908228874207,
-0.7978136539459229,
0.08163126558065414,
0.11179668456315994,
-0.6234242916107178,
0.020486202090978622,
0.045069023966789246,
-0.2539498209953308,
0.07930067181587219,
-0.6016626954078674,
0.7909429669380188,
-0.4895820617675781,
-0.1322340965270996,
0.2008463442325592,
-0.6714654564857483,
0.39492982625961304,
-0.03581959754228592,
-0.03882407397031784,
-0.6205963492393494,
0.08217751234769821,
0.5874256491661072,
0.09299138188362122,
0.70619797706604,
-0.23387348651885986,
0.06737963855266571,
0.14490936696529388,
-0.3104597330093384,
0.5351494550704956,
-0.08099700510501862,
-0.1967436969280243,
0.2652377188205719,
0.16649368405342102,
-0.4680978059768677,
-0.5313228964805603,
0.7995128035545349,
-0.814263105392456,
-0.22865502536296844,
-0.4022105038166046,
-0.5948692560195923,
-0.04657018929719925,
0.32013657689094543,
0.19388823211193085,
-0.08420342952013016,
-0.6567606329917908,
0.36947229504585266,
0.713836669921875,
-0.16275115311145782,
-0.3634907901287079,
0.4660157263278961,
-0.42357388138771057,
-0.8085669875144958,
0.8250362873077393,
0.597361147403717,
0.8756526112556458,
-0.21741704642772675,
0.24493417143821716,
-0.44164615869522095,
-0.03029048629105091,
-0.5035251379013062,
0.02011386677622795,
-0.8957567811012268,
-0.30508604645729065,
-0.4352753460407257,
-0.627287745475769,
-0.6056264638900757,
-0.4571143686771393,
-0.5732173323631287,
-0.18619801104068756,
0.08603879064321518,
-0.15603363513946533,
0.4073992669582367,
0.8936659693717957,
0.11609739065170288,
0.16392287611961365,
-0.777590274810791,
0.2161644995212555,
0.06018007919192314,
0.5144032835960388,
-0.24357908964157104,
-0.31540974974632263,
-0.21095995604991913,
0.20383527874946594,
-0.16694121062755585,
-0.7762567400932312,
0.11787547171115875,
-0.19482901692390442,
0.6167126297950745,
0.2901841402053833,
0.26000696420669556,
0.6792647838592529,
-0.3887600004673004,
0.7172277569770813,
0.03166073560714722,
-0.7244200706481934,
0.5045270323753357,
-0.2126045823097229,
0.5269001126289368,
0.8872494697570801,
0.382733017206192,
-1.1096131801605225,
-0.16831226646900177,
-0.596426784992218,
-0.8721440434455872,
0.2885154187679291,
-0.05808667838573456,
0.013354722410440445,
0.014706824906170368,
0.44161781668663025,
0.09637311846017838,
0.28863194584846497,
-0.5672332048416138,
-0.18466851115226746,
-0.11928100138902664,
-0.5834257006645203,
0.0015768537996336818,
-0.20979727804660797,
-0.25238630175590515,
-0.09210560470819473,
0.49560248851776123,
-0.0418391227722168,
0.07992849498987198,
0.08356127142906189,
-0.2465672343969345,
-0.10316511988639832,
0.40931060910224915,
0.6576134562492371,
0.7938933372497559,
-0.19394637644290924,
0.12068718671798706,
0.3317153751850128,
-0.46568432450294495,
0.5722104907035828,
-0.1324940025806427,
-0.34433066844940186,
-0.1456005871295929,
0.010095027275383472,
0.6532331109046936,
0.42411696910858154,
-0.22117306292057037,
0.5626797676086426,
0.13466960191726685,
-0.3531467616558075,
-0.2821296155452728,
0.03908245265483856,
0.5248270034790039,
0.3530501127243042,
-0.07890445739030838,
-0.207253098487854,
-0.2622082531452179,
-0.09300203621387482,
0.16642554104328156,
0.3280239999294281,
-0.46548187732696533,
-0.21631887555122375,
0.3000168204307556,
-0.037957534193992615,
-0.3270869851112366,
0.5274770259857178,
-0.23426686227321625,
-0.7050296068191528,
0.7845278978347778,
0.6219756007194519,
0.5236877202987671,
-0.3036186099052429,
0.29683053493499756,
0.48808494210243225,
0.28362342715263367,
-0.3244633674621582,
0.5004140138626099,
0.3081074059009552,
-0.9791145324707031,
-0.2826966643333435,
-0.6296117305755615,
-0.6086259484291077,
0.05793784558773041,
-0.9343206882476807,
0.3017880916595459,
-0.2414705753326416,
-0.060515474528074265,
-0.46702417731285095,
0.39299559593200684,
-0.8154242038726807,
-0.0692635029554367,
-0.19534195959568024,
0.7459720373153687,
-1.3290027379989624,
0.6103934645652771,
0.644498884677887,
-0.18336671590805054,
-0.8429694175720215,
-0.07335811108350754,
0.17003120481967926,
-0.986213207244873,
0.6851887702941895,
0.33135443925857544,
-0.07516199350357056,
-0.08292949944734573,
-0.48723307251930237,
-1.3558969497680664,
1.4850969314575195,
0.4215984642505646,
-0.582329511642456,
0.32584598660469055,
0.48165494203567505,
0.3199527859687805,
-0.5864061713218689,
-0.29932454228401184,
0.8290596604347229,
0.593916118144989,
0.14097079634666443,
-0.8105931878089905,
-0.07213682681322098,
-0.08500844240188599,
-0.007775467820465565,
0.3204602003097534,
-0.7298389673233032,
0.4952695965766907,
0.2213887870311737,
-0.11452591419219971,
-0.03705453500151634,
0.37999680638313293,
0.8897321820259094,
0.9395606517791748,
0.46135205030441284,
0.6340265274047852,
1.0901246070861816,
-0.04749897122383118,
0.4457319378852844,
-0.5801206231117249,
0.27194419503211975,
1.1818556785583496,
-0.7326981425285339,
0.5366334319114685,
0.5104865431785583,
-0.35480237007141113,
0.1435692310333252,
0.6638094782829285,
-0.05793173238635063,
0.5263562798500061,
0.1665164977312088,
-0.38590994477272034,
0.026438415050506592,
-0.31090107560157776,
-0.5467360615730286,
0.4228132963180542,
0.18904729187488556,
-0.29707804322242737,
-0.15757058560848236,
-0.2500377893447876,
0.13005080819129944,
0.062327075749635696,
-0.4161120355129242,
0.8357802033424377,
0.20194904506206512,
-0.6292110681533813,
0.24982722103595734,
-0.5747965574264526,
0.37542468309402466,
-0.2826373279094696,
0.05354474112391472,
-0.302290141582489,
0.018214145675301552,
-0.10861079394817352,
-0.9401187300682068,
0.30356696248054504,
0.07910729944705963,
-0.2762744426727295,
0.014347584918141365,
1.0087265968322754,
-0.5678717494010925,
-0.6033728122711182,
0.22848178446292877,
0.41093412041664124,
0.4724600911140442,
0.04568807780742645,
-0.5486781597137451,
0.07286908477544785,
-0.08944651484489441,
-0.18731723725795746,
0.6171493530273438,
0.526950478553772,
-0.1913299411535263,
0.44316765666007996,
0.6077069640159607,
0.32827791571617126,
0.07897603511810303,
0.18681319057941437,
0.7041885256767273,
-0.5122781991958618,
-0.10952171683311462,
-0.889604926109314,
0.594918429851532,
-0.5034551024436951,
-0.3820466101169586,
0.7856693267822266,
0.617552638053894,
0.8585155010223389,
0.2569621205329895,
0.8369023203849792,
0.2757071256637573,
0.6804798245429993,
-0.43927761912345886,
0.910968005657196,
-0.23116086423397064,
0.01043451577425003,
-0.37710192799568176,
-1.0338006019592285,
-0.19073666632175446,
0.6632804870605469,
-0.6197724342346191,
-0.14068487286567688,
0.21840932965278625,
0.870381236076355,
-0.01409944612532854,
-0.07734843343496323,
0.5482946634292603,
-0.13062794506549835,
0.09938507527112961,
0.224289208650589,
0.8659041523933411,
-0.50371915102005,
0.4108535349369049,
-0.19078321754932404,
-0.07721380144357681,
-0.10212505608797073,
-1.1288646459579468,
-0.6800568103790283,
-0.26906245946884155,
-0.1339002251625061,
-0.3709873855113983,
0.2617208957672119,
1.192529559135437,
0.3653290569782257,
-0.7386653423309326,
-0.16335898637771606,
0.08402705937623978,
0.259809285402298,
0.02307087928056717,
-0.2208617776632309,
0.5215232968330383,
-0.1689051240682602,
-0.3140655755996704,
0.18984650075435638,
0.3796900808811188,
0.16095887124538422,
-0.08399714529514313,
-0.39955025911331177,
-0.1477963626384735,
0.009260767139494419,
0.5812757015228271,
0.007811546325683594,
-0.7268450260162354,
-0.44052544236183167,
0.38793814182281494,
-0.3382553458213806,
0.096246138215065,
0.4600641429424286,
-0.3417096734046936,
0.3913138210773468,
0.37162160873413086,
0.7215431332588196,
0.14180640876293182,
0.22578345239162445,
0.5250645279884338,
-0.5416012406349182,
-0.2912657558917999,
0.10413432866334915,
0.15196242928504944,
0.369886577129364,
-0.4556681215763092,
0.7038873434066772,
-0.008374101482331753,
-1.17695951461792,
-0.897096574306488,
0.2857300043106079,
-0.7463400959968567,
0.2507858872413635,
1.1015383005142212,
-0.34484925866127014,
-0.22172190248966217,
-0.2427133023738861,
-0.17968472838401794,
0.5331099033355713,
-0.30943763256073,
0.7169060707092285,
1.0585126876831055,
0.12497328221797943,
-0.12694139778614044,
-0.8055609464645386,
0.16459672152996063,
0.06983046233654022,
-0.632972776889801,
0.19700846076011658,
0.2916238605976105,
0.504034698009491,
-0.028151756152510643,
0.7411096096038818,
-0.2631792426109314,
0.28704044222831726,
-0.2273188978433609,
0.09050451964139938,
0.3400196135044098,
-0.1553286761045456,
-0.3983607590198517,
-0.04997995123267174,
0.0788833275437355,
-0.09652075171470642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13604v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13604v2
|
Breaking the HISCO Barrier: Automatic Occupational Standardization with OccCANINE
| 2024-02-21T08:10:43 | 2024-04-02T14:56:18 |
Christian Møller Dahl, Torben Johansen, Christian Vedel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, econ.EM, I.2.7; I.7.0
|
This paper introduces a new tool, OccCANINE, to automatically transform
occupational descriptions into the HISCO classification system. The manual work
involved in processing and classifying occupational descriptions is
error-prone, tedious, and time-consuming. We finetune a preexisting language
model (CANINE) to do this automatically, thereby performing in seconds and
minutes what previously took days and weeks. The model is trained on 14 million
pairs of occupational descriptions and HISCO codes in 13 different languages
contributed by 22 different sources. Our approach is shown to have accuracy,
recall, and precision above 90 percent. Our tool breaks the metaphorical HISCO
barrier and makes this data readily available for analysis of occupational
structures with broad applicability in economics, economic history, and various
related disciplines.
|
[
-0.27659520506858826,
-0.25329652428627014,
0.6810033321380615,
-0.055908411741256714,
-0.13276897370815277,
0.1264459192752838,
-0.24356935918331146,
-0.930717408657074,
0.07462196052074432,
0.6561863422393799,
-0.20801833271980286,
-0.5387580990791321,
-0.6663958430290222,
0.38098302483558655,
-0.13513536751270294,
0.5582602024078369,
-0.024344857782125473,
-0.4443241357803345,
-0.11517211049795151,
-0.32304540276527405,
-0.08567622303962708,
-0.2976005971431732,
-0.5846608877182007,
0.002369988476857543,
0.687228262424469,
0.3609895706176758,
0.6738042831420898,
1.1426891088485718,
0.48071882128715515,
0.46047982573509216,
0.2038135677576065,
0.03726048395037651,
-0.10015764832496643,
-0.00939829833805561,
-0.25723323225975037,
-0.5180045366287231,
-0.5413298606872559,
0.13810904324054718,
0.3985660672187805,
0.8409600853919983,
-0.41502800583839417,
0.07454904168844223,
-0.18313223123550415,
0.303207665681839,
-0.831807553768158,
0.6179558634757996,
-0.7486357688903809,
-0.2269606590270996,
-0.575859010219574,
0.0695238783955574,
-0.23381976783275604,
-0.3710809350013733,
-0.19420090317726135,
-0.3675108850002289,
0.23857922852039337,
0.06834819912910461,
0.9960911870002747,
0.2834201157093048,
-0.6326795816421509,
-0.28917309641838074,
-0.6496492624282837,
0.6035460233688354,
-0.5723534822463989,
0.6685923933982849,
0.4682357609272003,
0.7433762550354004,
0.13730327785015106,
-0.9493555426597595,
-0.5469421148300171,
-0.49617382884025574,
0.07450270652770996,
0.15732797980308533,
0.08748636394739151,
0.20287741720676422,
0.058066632598638535,
0.5016750693321228,
-0.14007818698883057,
0.27116158604621887,
-1.1311426162719727,
-0.07219836115837097,
0.9298134446144104,
0.5145895481109619,
0.15301869809627533,
0.020538384094834328,
-0.04614131897687912,
-0.24459077417850494,
-0.3682233393192291,
0.12431678920984268,
0.5931225419044495,
0.16367435455322266,
0.2587132751941681,
0.4857264459133148,
-0.524351954460144,
0.6751918196678162,
-0.2340955138206482,
-0.3222367763519287,
0.2999064028263092,
0.01763085275888443,
-0.32210156321525574,
0.408431738615036,
0.7451348900794983,
-0.06740326434373856,
-0.34224748611450195,
-0.1691056787967682,
-0.2835535407066345,
-0.02040608786046505,
0.8727105855941772,
-0.4082862138748169,
0.03352171182632446,
0.08646756410598755,
-0.1805155724287033,
-0.5508466958999634,
0.174661785364151,
-0.3110074996948242,
-0.3521307706832886,
-0.04440281167626381,
0.02667284570634365,
-0.05806132033467293,
0.17182821035385132,
0.3685118556022644,
-0.06479424238204956,
-0.08802404254674911,
0.5597716569900513,
-0.5692375302314758,
0.3646346926689148,
0.5722635984420776,
0.8365333676338196,
-0.003612589556723833,
-0.3248312771320343,
-0.136086568236351,
0.20575955510139465,
-0.39833757281303406,
0.7127006649971008,
-0.6652415990829468,
-0.3446098268032074,
0.01818845607340336,
0.5685824155807495,
-0.13916544616222382,
-0.38282495737075806,
0.3760016858577728,
-0.6529245376586914,
0.13213278353214264,
0.17522017657756805,
-0.35703256726264954,
-0.27735984325408936,
0.08451183140277863,
-0.9146814346313477,
0.8662648797035217,
0.42397841811180115,
-0.39920181035995483,
0.37273526191711426,
-0.8295542597770691,
-0.10298310965299606,
0.17039474844932556,
-0.26288044452667236,
-0.10334021598100662,
-0.12929242849349976,
-0.3923444151878357,
0.11729200184345245,
-0.5775212049484253,
0.013025233522057533,
-0.37770673632621765,
0.09639360755681992,
0.018281295895576477,
0.03432853892445564,
1.4101746082305908,
0.5017598271369934,
-0.17429237067699432,
-0.007329110521823168,
-0.5598427653312683,
-0.2687116265296936,
0.16489087045192719,
-0.22089366614818573,
-0.40959852933883667,
-0.11713477224111557,
-0.24923697113990784,
0.4817080497741699,
0.2941180169582367,
-0.8198813199996948,
0.3084528148174286,
-0.5389346480369568,
0.39739990234375,
0.6313197016716003,
-0.2796461284160614,
0.21433588862419128,
-0.2727469205856323,
0.3889229893684387,
-0.37189948558807373,
0.39651793241500854,
0.1789824515581131,
-0.5102457404136658,
-0.43446964025497437,
-0.15891341865062714,
0.4199722409248352,
0.5266082286834717,
-0.48067817091941833,
1.0647372007369995,
-0.07375726103782654,
-0.9297631978988647,
-0.685271680355072,
0.042290233075618744,
-0.010387702845036983,
0.6706729531288147,
0.19826972484588623,
-1.0440528392791748,
-0.32731759548187256,
-0.656385064125061,
0.1827649474143982,
-0.3438301980495453,
-0.009418427012860775,
0.11640623211860657,
0.47975650429725647,
-0.3514214754104614,
0.9017535448074341,
-0.8018426895141602,
-0.839294970035553,
-0.01008098479360342,
0.1525714248418808,
0.036360301077365875,
0.3520311713218689,
0.36615216732025146,
-0.2731834352016449,
-0.45484206080436707,
0.202153742313385,
-0.6950082182884216,
-0.16231070458889008,
0.05259889364242554,
-0.2790093421936035,
-0.007821716368198395,
0.980945885181427,
0.05664661526679993,
0.6971154808998108,
0.2161741852760315,
0.012526136822998524,
0.7558554410934448,
-0.4177274703979492,
0.10741301625967026,
-0.6909559369087219,
0.15330420434474945,
-0.11290136724710464,
-0.16836294531822205,
-0.37306222319602966,
0.20126532018184662,
0.018179189413785934,
-0.01924774795770645,
-0.5618892312049866,
0.5099925398826599,
-0.45574209094047546,
0.09773275256156921,
-0.33846113085746765,
0.0033738091588020325,
0.03756061941385269,
0.20162494480609894,
0.4146024286746979,
0.340640127658844,
0.5137670636177063,
-0.6763250231742859,
0.8689780235290527,
0.5945949554443359,
-0.33815091848373413,
0.650808572769165,
-0.5475416779518127,
0.08500248193740845,
0.006302506662905216,
0.4239194989204407,
-0.6944219470024109,
-0.37642890214920044,
0.27841049432754517,
-0.11509383469820023,
-0.06467341631650925,
-0.182429239153862,
-0.47171488404273987,
-0.643496036529541,
-0.16147109866142273,
0.4512515068054199,
0.6003764271736145,
-0.39853763580322266,
0.13318559527397156,
0.47121214866638184,
-0.19163021445274353,
-0.3965728282928467,
-0.4275856912136078,
0.2585586607456207,
-0.047757264226675034,
-0.6919297575950623,
0.5801419615745544,
0.08472386002540588,
-0.13254110515117645,
-0.07067006081342697,
-0.3359367847442627,
-0.7908104062080383,
-0.09160506725311279,
0.13068155944347382,
0.30140745639801025,
-0.13857226073741913,
0.15076017379760742,
-0.0679706484079361,
-0.07989593595266342,
0.007127027492970228,
-0.1024123802781105,
0.34279271960258484,
0.135115846991539,
-0.2723328471183777,
-0.504866898059845,
-0.07948491722345352,
0.6550735831260681,
-0.4652058482170105,
0.9424660205841064,
0.46401509642601013,
-0.46122604608535767,
0.12116516381502151,
-0.5927287936210632,
0.04386579245328903,
-0.5981656908988953,
0.218160018324852,
-0.3459935486316681,
-0.25325727462768555,
0.27631500363349915,
0.015957068651914597,
0.28452375531196594,
0.4717371165752411,
0.3131035566329956,
-0.04937471076846123,
0.9400290250778198,
0.8514402508735657,
0.1271774172782898,
0.49928122758865356,
-0.08177406340837479,
0.2119390070438385,
-0.6046180129051208,
-0.18908169865608215,
-0.7920156121253967,
0.1778307557106018,
-0.2312086671590805,
-0.31886544823646545,
0.49677202105522156,
-0.28059181571006775,
0.011633343063294888,
0.8559795022010803,
-0.432230681180954,
0.46371591091156006,
0.26776665449142456,
0.10393257439136505,
0.39620181918144226,
-0.18746115267276764,
0.2568061947822571,
0.06901082396507263,
-0.5834522247314453,
-0.785597026348114,
0.8663465976715088,
0.5586575269699097,
0.7377356886863708,
-0.05008084699511528,
0.9480125904083252,
0.3171032965183258,
0.5166738033294678,
-0.7579849362373352,
0.2403155118227005,
-0.38491493463516235,
-0.9006771445274353,
-0.7630344033241272,
-0.08541630208492279,
-1.1680632829666138,
0.14368419349193573,
-0.08138203620910645,
-0.8558540940284729,
0.5603013038635254,
0.18318307399749756,
-0.5352548360824585,
0.4010528028011322,
-0.3758576512336731,
1.0340067148208618,
-0.27015605568885803,
-0.4207511246204376,
-0.20996543765068054,
-0.6605017185211182,
0.4130712151527405,
-0.17548438906669617,
0.35482144355773926,
-0.370341956615448,
-0.14614592492580414,
0.8989877700805664,
-0.888896107673645,
0.9402509927749634,
0.15825673937797546,
-0.34525617957115173,
0.31548070907592773,
0.1236000582575798,
0.44072043895721436,
-0.25834453105926514,
-0.22519832849502563,
0.16966624557971954,
0.3793509006500244,
-0.512285590171814,
-0.37256741523742676,
0.2786983847618103,
-0.48031148314476013,
-0.33750900626182556,
-0.492044597864151,
-0.21015675365924835,
-0.13019995391368866,
0.26362913846969604,
0.4115326404571533,
0.30061453580856323,
-0.41552606225013733,
0.01654149405658245,
0.23688505589962006,
-0.040292203426361084,
0.005924001336097717,
0.42891526222229004,
0.4540138244628906,
-0.08683481067419052,
0.8348934054374695,
0.33519119024276733,
0.2245025783777237,
-0.11666860431432724,
0.07539817690849304,
-0.5526735782623291,
-0.17604517936706543,
-0.4100724160671234,
0.42134103178977966,
-0.8144959211349487,
-0.11774663627147675,
-0.7875202894210815,
-0.30216968059539795,
-0.8989526033401489,
-0.37319082021713257,
-0.5400387644767761,
-0.19674018025398254,
0.12674862146377563,
0.024597611278295517,
0.09546538442373276,
1.0395067930221558,
-0.04321175813674927,
0.5263594388961792,
-0.9593710899353027,
0.25385457277297974,
0.4331372082233429,
0.5571601986885071,
-0.3313919007778168,
-0.3342391550540924,
-0.39528313279151917,
-0.028518659994006157,
-0.24328432977199554,
-1.1133646965026855,
0.4190063774585724,
0.2102779746055603,
0.6631650328636169,
0.6754499077796936,
0.551517903804779,
0.5708081722259521,
-0.3998824954032898,
0.42248862981796265,
0.3711121678352356,
-1.0178431272506714,
0.24462701380252838,
-0.12380657345056534,
-0.05067635700106621,
0.8074056506156921,
0.7814710736274719,
-0.9809101819992065,
-0.8041795492172241,
-1.002384901046753,
-1.1151018142700195,
1.0756014585494995,
0.36082395911216736,
-0.15941070020198822,
-0.07053868472576141,
-0.25868529081344604,
0.38387444615364075,
0.3697713315486908,
-0.5024416446685791,
0.08508556336164474,
-0.05092144012451172,
-0.35849234461784363,
-0.1621636152267456,
0.1345435529947281,
-0.5182425379753113,
-0.1677771359682083,
0.43356287479400635,
0.08864551782608032,
0.21589162945747375,
0.338836669921875,
-0.7150018811225891,
0.15579666197299957,
0.215497225522995,
0.3480527102947235,
0.6842916011810303,
-0.258609801530838,
0.37982380390167236,
0.3759693205356598,
-0.45346543192863464,
0.23814643919467926,
-0.11723977327346802,
0.5173896551132202,
0.11845384538173676,
0.35806038975715637,
0.5249378085136414,
-0.4548742473125458,
-0.7318876385688782,
0.43835774064064026,
0.19473040103912354,
-0.41074517369270325,
-0.5875450968742371,
0.4495212435722351,
-0.25677013397216797,
-0.03368064761161804,
-0.15381115674972534,
-0.02061268500983715,
0.24797657132148743,
-0.7801768779754639,
0.2445182204246521,
-0.1969292312860489,
-0.7779504060745239,
-0.148772731423378,
0.8116032481193542,
0.5591467022895813,
-0.1130141094326973,
0.45372503995895386,
-0.6816644072532654,
-0.23106756806373596,
1.0922071933746338,
0.21418976783752441,
0.8187964558601379,
-0.49021464586257935,
0.06468828022480011,
0.4725980758666992,
0.40991395711898804,
-0.4915500581264496,
-0.3067373037338257,
-0.08706314116716385,
-0.5422956943511963,
0.0578128881752491,
-0.46262505650520325,
-0.3308298587799072,
-0.06684005260467529,
-0.7399342656135559,
0.3605017364025116,
-0.5721620917320251,
-0.08936519175767899,
0.2655102610588074,
-0.6015535593032837,
-0.7364274859428406,
0.45278212428092957,
0.28420037031173706,
1.1355726718902588,
-1.0449492931365967,
0.9410893321037292,
0.7458516359329224,
-0.7463815808296204,
-0.13428330421447754,
-0.13291142880916595,
0.05796398967504501,
-0.8185112476348877,
0.673467755317688,
0.11767019331455231,
-0.44423508644104004,
-0.049968041479587555,
-0.3689451217651367,
-0.6476885080337524,
1.0078140497207642,
-0.09516903758049011,
-0.6232374310493469,
-0.2060791254043579,
0.06553814560174942,
0.4563902020454407,
-0.6832420229911804,
0.4001290798187256,
0.9719666242599487,
0.7073025703430176,
-0.30158600211143494,
-1.393843412399292,
0.10994664579629898,
-0.10337276011705399,
-0.1876504123210907,
0.05760999768972397,
-0.5269361734390259,
0.5095504522323608,
-0.1458735167980194,
-0.34735676646232605,
-0.12495645880699158,
0.1476137489080429,
-0.35609766840934753,
0.3784737288951874,
1.1777994632720947,
0.16378772258758545,
0.8939735293388367,
-0.026164015755057335,
0.6596635580062866,
-0.283448725938797,
0.24620330333709717,
0.9160311222076416,
-0.6507536172866821,
0.7258028984069824,
-0.08379841595888138,
-0.3650244474411011,
0.750841498374939,
0.6941037774085999,
-0.10999622195959091,
0.16829504072666168,
0.16488982737064362,
-0.4124127924442291,
-0.4418002963066101,
-0.07155641168355942,
-0.3696172833442688,
0.7907341122627258,
0.4109368920326233,
-0.1679328829050064,
-0.3393315374851227,
0.08984100818634033,
-0.11810620874166489,
-0.006643958389759064,
-0.20078358054161072,
0.7417880296707153,
-0.03916943073272705,
-0.24677644670009613,
0.7186846733093262,
0.2836814224720001,
0.4481968581676483,
-0.6309722661972046,
0.20368975400924683,
0.20638735592365265,
-0.18417099118232727,
-0.48455914855003357,
-0.5405835509300232,
0.8602186441421509,
-0.07436548173427582,
0.3504009544849396,
-0.18418818712234497,
0.4629614055156708,
-0.45528340339660645,
-0.29565635323524475,
0.25792938470840454,
0.3444269001483917,
0.38346362113952637,
-0.2925199270248413,
-0.6731085181236267,
-0.22650374472141266,
-0.13663828372955322,
0.352201908826828,
-0.2793193757534027,
0.3188956081867218,
-0.5457857847213745,
0.5762649178504944,
0.3346259891986847,
-0.1733953356742859,
0.16541042923927307,
-0.1931910216808319,
0.44590842723846436,
-1.1791061162948608,
-1.1286894083023071,
-0.28855955600738525,
0.3978082835674286,
-0.3041796088218689,
-0.19126659631729126,
0.19227994978427887,
0.5468789935112,
0.8702041506767273,
-0.28270065784454346,
0.9721882343292236,
-0.5476138591766357,
0.212211474776268,
-0.3170700967311859,
0.852878987789154,
-0.8397952318191528,
0.05132179707288742,
-0.1461477130651474,
-0.6577758193016052,
-0.09660832583904266,
0.4378478527069092,
-0.5357231497764587,
-0.1791640818119049,
1.256238579750061,
0.8030440211296082,
-0.29587313532829285,
-0.5199005007743835,
0.49897468090057373,
0.10896279662847519,
-0.041662052273750305,
0.19675756990909576,
0.7764981389045715,
-0.18378590047359467,
1.0906270742416382,
-0.6337676048278809,
-0.2738489508628845,
-0.6448040008544922,
-0.6085798144340515,
-0.47468969225883484,
-0.7477011680603027,
-0.8376293182373047,
-0.5157202482223511,
0.07806998491287231,
1.0512380599975586,
0.9512089490890503,
-0.5771427750587463,
-0.9068627953529358,
0.11290840804576874,
-0.01614135131239891,
-0.3090358376502991,
-0.160502091050148,
0.020542582497000694,
-0.5362160205841064,
-0.8480780720710754,
0.38038596510887146,
0.2665468752384186,
0.0036625927314162254,
0.028272012248635292,
-0.01432886067777872,
0.29739633202552795,
0.23939895629882812,
0.42525187134742737,
0.639554500579834,
-0.5306896567344666,
-0.1368013471364975,
-0.16647084057331085,
-0.44813433289527893,
0.40763285756111145,
0.9501760005950928,
-0.3441908359527588,
0.6928339004516602,
0.5719173550605774,
0.24825255572795868,
0.1965894103050232,
-0.1728866696357727,
0.715617299079895,
-0.6244992613792419,
0.42454835772514343,
0.2497129589319229,
0.40627288818359375,
-0.15039676427841187,
-0.3934001624584198,
0.6628763675689697,
0.30203935503959656,
-0.24220572412014008,
-0.8115924596786499,
0.4781433939933777,
-1.0786484479904175,
-0.5332068800926208,
0.6405224800109863,
-0.040197331458330154,
-0.7923137545585632,
-0.8025245070457458,
-0.47792842984199524,
0.24844931066036224,
-0.46978434920310974,
1.2574992179870605,
0.43694359064102173,
-0.1422896832227707,
0.12634508311748505,
-0.6947669386863708,
0.5779309272766113,
-0.14889302849769592,
-0.9631917476654053,
0.01756715588271618,
0.2807851731777191,
0.2399497926235199,
0.3328666090965271,
0.8859182596206665,
-0.2597472667694092,
0.6319406032562256,
0.31197768449783325,
0.8527382016181946,
-0.1434130221605301,
-0.2553962767124176,
-0.26485541462898254,
0.03477846831083298,
0.49986138939857483,
-0.4141786992549896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13598v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13598v1
|
User-LLM: Efficient LLM Contextualization with User Embeddings
| 2024-02-21T08:03:27 | 2024-02-21T08:03:27 |
Lin Ning, Luyang Liu, Jiaxing Wu, Neo Wu, Devora Berlowitz, Sushant Prakash, Bradley Green, Shawn O'Banion, Jun Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing.
However, effectively incorporating complex and potentially noisy user
interaction data remains a challenge. To address this, we propose User-LLM, a
novel framework that leverages user embeddings to contextualize LLMs. These
embeddings, distilled from diverse user interactions using self-supervised
pretraining, capture latent user preferences and their evolution over time. We
integrate these user embeddings with LLMs through cross-attention and
soft-prompting, enabling LLMs to dynamically adapt to user context. Our
comprehensive experiments on MovieLens, Amazon Review, and Google Local Review
datasets demonstrate significant performance gains across various tasks.
Notably, our approach outperforms text-prompt-based contextualization on long
sequence tasks and tasks that require deep user understanding while being
computationally efficient. We further incorporate Perceiver layers to
streamline the integration between user encoders and LLMs, reducing
computational demands.
|
[
-0.385312020778656,
-0.8943584561347961,
0.7347497344017029,
0.3212047517299652,
-0.13072417676448822,
0.11843360960483551,
-0.486416220664978,
-0.10142216831445694,
0.17558148503303528,
0.5810171961784363,
-0.45927608013153076,
-0.543505072593689,
-0.33784785866737366,
0.1240244135260582,
-0.17597393691539764,
0.7716712355613708,
-0.030483359470963478,
-0.09999344497919083,
-0.44099289178848267,
0.04299736022949219,
-0.32753992080688477,
-0.7757406830787659,
-0.2570180594921112,
-0.11510012298822403,
0.8689574599266052,
0.4085448086261749,
0.5380520224571228,
0.5026193261146545,
0.046887461096048355,
0.2627602815628052,
0.03569875285029411,
0.14397069811820984,
-0.5044658184051514,
0.39992740750312805,
-0.2096235603094101,
-0.17451775074005127,
-0.2789328098297119,
-0.11003611981868744,
0.6578590869903564,
0.7597594857215881,
-0.08534030616283417,
-0.1368170827627182,
0.3207041025161743,
0.365106999874115,
-0.5521854758262634,
-0.03798060864210129,
-0.315408855676651,
0.06751091033220291,
-0.2419593334197998,
-0.3903544545173645,
-0.35313880443573,
-0.03653958812355995,
0.18484461307525635,
-0.5111908912658691,
-0.017233410850167274,
0.06103098765015602,
0.18803860247135162,
0.4129882752895355,
-0.5585978627204895,
-0.14488886296749115,
-0.6835415363311768,
0.7127413749694824,
-0.5698294639587402,
0.6246787905693054,
0.2853703796863556,
0.23440000414848328,
-0.21457895636558533,
-0.7548317909240723,
-0.621262788772583,
-0.1678597629070282,
-0.14908556640148163,
0.0004843125934712589,
-0.10333061963319778,
-0.006074742879718542,
0.05093083158135414,
0.23422539234161377,
-0.3475767970085144,
0.3045099973678589,
-0.007466465700417757,
-0.08265040814876556,
0.34810683131217957,
0.11870390921831131,
0.36983928084373474,
-0.22756241261959076,
-0.5338761210441589,
0.07997111976146698,
-0.6757638454437256,
0.028945256024599075,
0.4166390001773834,
0.3006393313407898,
-0.2838961184024811,
0.5889647006988525,
-0.09757184237241745,
0.6677806377410889,
0.13778793811798096,
0.07811576873064041,
0.3255224823951721,
-0.3087213337421417,
-0.19891107082366943,
-0.058367639780044556,
0.9013972878456116,
0.23315489292144775,
0.2288820892572403,
-0.32521456480026245,
-0.21518804132938385,
-0.2818174958229065,
0.18422408401966095,
-0.7157418131828308,
-0.17577363550662994,
0.09252136945724487,
-0.14856098592281342,
-0.17576192319393158,
-0.06652294099330902,
-0.559779942035675,
-0.5871800184249878,
-0.38337069749832153,
0.22408950328826904,
-0.05567755177617073,
0.08240404725074768,
0.1173812597990036,
0.2763630747795105,
-0.009512542746961117,
0.44049397110939026,
-1.0617789030075073,
0.2175626903772354,
0.5456526279449463,
0.6074215769767761,
-0.4019334316253662,
-0.30403298139572144,
-0.772479236125946,
0.45646974444389343,
0.011799149215221405,
0.6049100160598755,
-0.7179062962532043,
-0.22345738112926483,
0.17877744138240814,
-0.08315727114677429,
-0.008134872652590275,
-0.45968058705329895,
0.2942998707294464,
-0.6626316905021667,
0.3363012373447418,
-0.3282526731491089,
-0.5498473048210144,
0.062212225049734116,
0.2563190758228302,
-0.41336730122566223,
1.1350773572921753,
0.11909027397632599,
-0.6521265506744385,
0.33263275027275085,
-0.6610832214355469,
-0.5385113954544067,
0.16991373896598816,
-0.2954196035861969,
-0.002693867776542902,
0.28003108501434326,
0.49402546882629395,
0.8059948086738586,
-0.024612683802843094,
0.3747698664665222,
-0.4200754761695862,
-0.30165907740592957,
0.2942803204059601,
-0.25945842266082764,
0.31681129336357117,
0.2762395441532135,
0.03426907956600189,
0.3345649838447571,
-0.42249801754951477,
-0.4132346510887146,
0.05894489586353302,
-0.6485046148300171,
-0.3497895300388336,
0.07303894311189651,
0.2906239330768585,
0.20988869667053223,
0.5114819407463074,
-0.30803224444389343,
0.3010309934616089,
-0.32877227663993835,
0.6230543851852417,
0.723862886428833,
-0.10320031642913818,
0.6386622190475464,
0.11096547544002533,
0.4311105012893677,
0.12479297071695328,
-0.20852048695087433,
-0.5228155255317688,
-0.05706466734409332,
-0.6017956137657166,
-0.26078206300735474,
0.03798701986670494,
0.4202437102794647,
-0.47183242440223694,
0.5738288760185242,
-0.19278454780578613,
0.22119902074337006,
-0.22591310739517212,
0.7658247947692871,
0.07200292497873306,
0.5774504542350769,
0.37245896458625793,
-0.2450663298368454,
-0.49181923270225525,
-0.8134381175041199,
-0.3115381896495819,
0.06736543774604797,
-0.3263765573501587,
0.716594398021698,
0.0711633712053299,
-0.7474220395088196,
1.1117409467697144,
-0.4709109365940094,
-0.3531658947467804,
-0.5269148349761963,
-0.02038792334496975,
0.1427467167377472,
0.343393474817276,
0.19061756134033203,
-0.6009560227394104,
-0.5454009771347046,
-0.17114394903182983,
-0.7631940841674805,
-0.32193994522094727,
-0.22878558933734894,
-0.029368100687861443,
0.028774868696928024,
0.8483206629753113,
-0.188481867313385,
0.013436800800263882,
0.46566131711006165,
-0.27073511481285095,
-0.04407545179128647,
-0.3702389597892761,
-0.031457316130399704,
-1.2472116947174072,
-0.045439306646585464,
0.08667974919080734,
-0.513213038444519,
-0.6838023066520691,
-0.2672950327396393,
0.057044316083192825,
0.023515868932008743,
-0.4767954647541046,
0.7700216770172119,
-0.5676168203353882,
-0.2632894515991211,
-0.033839497715234756,
0.38504818081855774,
-0.13462303578853607,
0.70969557762146,
0.11691804230213165,
0.7384394407272339,
0.3677637279033661,
-0.3763590157032013,
0.2123163640499115,
0.16549257934093475,
-0.19370372593402863,
0.31977811455726624,
-0.5866532325744629,
0.42541542649269104,
-0.11942501366138458,
0.3003861606121063,
-1.1756348609924316,
-0.4578040838241577,
0.32402873039245605,
0.020630087703466415,
0.248225599527359,
-0.1612088978290558,
-0.6926380395889282,
-0.020574992522597313,
-0.4453370273113251,
0.6177345514297485,
0.3047564625740051,
-0.7989974617958069,
0.8015309572219849,
0.3614793121814728,
-0.2649534046649933,
-0.30884888768196106,
-0.5377014875411987,
0.3413999080657959,
-0.2849617600440979,
-0.6191276907920837,
0.44391003251075745,
-0.169132798910141,
-0.02851760759949684,
-0.0926908403635025,
0.21776819229125977,
0.14679279923439026,
0.1646328866481781,
0.18317648768424988,
-0.059406764805316925,
-0.04941282048821449,
0.2412138283252716,
0.1314329355955124,
-0.09651952981948853,
-0.10968966037034988,
-0.14388597011566162,
0.6019523739814758,
-0.0947350561618805,
-0.3311437666416168,
-0.4426373541355133,
0.2608870267868042,
0.28585052490234375,
-0.060455843806266785,
0.41545969247817993,
0.6980553865432739,
-0.2141481190919876,
-0.13131816685199738,
-0.7290235161781311,
-0.3033290505409241,
-0.5269134640693665,
0.49159684777259827,
-0.32753175497055054,
-1.4342318773269653,
0.36258137226104736,
-0.26018401980400085,
-0.11063726246356964,
-0.12027212977409363,
0.7665635943412781,
-0.4739724397659302,
0.9091255068778992,
0.5778738260269165,
-0.19248034060001373,
0.7399774789810181,
0.21240073442459106,
0.13311251997947693,
-0.9510785341262817,
-0.2683615982532501,
-0.02848680503666401,
-0.3914680778980255,
-0.37091773748397827,
-0.516401469707489,
0.17508070170879364,
0.18592239916324615,
-0.17822732031345367,
0.0371222123503685,
-0.10499287396669388,
0.5147088170051575,
0.330986350774765,
0.04217538610100746,
0.281840056180954,
0.11697365343570709,
-0.11669523268938065,
-0.1826781928539276,
-0.57749342918396,
-0.5438544750213623,
0.9342675805091858,
0.5403780341148376,
1.176897644996643,
0.17479273676872253,
0.7503406405448914,
0.5410882234573364,
0.2885078489780426,
-0.8029201030731201,
0.4381881058216095,
-0.12286000698804855,
-0.26474153995513916,
-0.21989889442920685,
-0.2568970322608948,
-0.9347602128982544,
0.15946540236473083,
-0.23392254114151,
-0.8925651907920837,
0.0005066619487479329,
0.4045579433441162,
-0.48141685128211975,
0.010846737772226334,
-0.6816138625144958,
0.8846085071563721,
-0.4343026280403137,
-0.601081132888794,
-0.1334560066461563,
-0.48277637362480164,
0.11868763715028763,
-0.09579958766698837,
0.20295900106430054,
-0.07690142840147018,
-0.38357457518577576,
0.653274655342102,
-0.11099017411470413,
1.1044106483459473,
-0.2576599717140198,
-0.13652382791042328,
0.07654290646314621,
-0.015271304175257683,
0.43882930278778076,
0.3465654253959656,
0.11854607611894608,
0.06471571326255798,
-0.508912980556488,
-0.22347182035446167,
-0.7070866227149963,
1.0033844709396362,
-0.7195265293121338,
-0.7835664749145508,
-0.32624682784080505,
-0.5673748254776001,
-0.3786538541316986,
0.09015388786792755,
-0.09826592355966568,
0.4800572991371155,
-0.28285515308380127,
0.3561086356639862,
0.6163278818130493,
-0.3144855201244354,
0.36666321754455566,
0.24328117072582245,
-0.4736762046813965,
-0.4201153814792633,
0.6606695652008057,
-0.16747955977916718,
-0.0787733718752861,
0.4411918520927429,
0.3025403618812561,
-0.5767817497253418,
-0.5223808288574219,
-0.4374329149723053,
0.3188609778881073,
-0.6707799434661865,
0.192109614610672,
-0.950569748878479,
0.17719890177249908,
-0.2558826506137848,
-0.46405357122421265,
-0.09274911880493164,
0.03429780527949333,
-0.6937429904937744,
-0.0850907415151596,
0.15644913911819458,
0.7251405715942383,
0.1797044426202774,
0.5595061779022217,
-0.49011698365211487,
0.38928481936454773,
0.5581532716751099,
0.33277732133865356,
-0.15647372603416443,
-0.5697323083877563,
-0.2911651134490967,
-0.36571624875068665,
-0.024247892200946808,
-0.7359448075294495,
0.35700714588165283,
0.16357310116291046,
0.6743541359901428,
0.46165376901626587,
-0.04828223958611488,
0.45488014817237854,
-0.4345262348651886,
0.8347858190536499,
0.18988986313343048,
-0.9412083625793457,
0.41866642236709595,
-0.34266456961631775,
0.5249829292297363,
0.6103710532188416,
0.3522997796535492,
-0.6526064872741699,
-0.0047102272510528564,
0.009615365415811539,
-0.8375028371810913,
0.6651636362075806,
-0.19556759297847748,
0.5036318898200989,
0.028065180405974388,
0.440102756023407,
0.08037092536687851,
0.05352478101849556,
-0.6020605564117432,
-0.07394640147686005,
-0.13667474687099457,
-0.375705748796463,
-0.4072922468185425,
-0.620489776134491,
-0.06566164642572403,
-0.24963226914405823,
0.1632116734981537,
-0.44964873790740967,
-0.024192189797759056,
0.1100369319319725,
-0.6090013980865479,
0.12158481776714325,
0.43430614471435547,
0.3829622268676758,
0.5861135721206665,
-0.20806747674942017,
0.4331500232219696,
0.3325977325439453,
-0.1830924153327942,
-0.0074724601581692696,
0.09988818317651749,
-0.027764787897467613,
-0.42637383937835693,
0.26870912313461304,
0.7084659337997437,
0.8354306817054749,
-0.6263037919998169,
0.6088563203811646,
-0.2375117391347885,
0.1734486073255539,
-0.26626110076904297,
0.09287717193365097,
0.3990887403488159,
0.2652353048324585,
0.4175284206867218,
-0.26441922783851624,
0.2008441984653473,
-0.5578895807266235,
0.14281557500362396,
0.23376931250095367,
-0.45889830589294434,
-0.5302428007125854,
0.6318815350532532,
0.5196918249130249,
-0.30415692925453186,
0.3638043999671936,
0.17778505384922028,
-0.46315664052963257,
-0.10498587787151337,
0.5744526386260986,
0.9691565036773682,
-0.09290722012519836,
-0.048802632838487625,
0.13052207231521606,
-0.17691871523857117,
0.21391451358795166,
0.1845657229423523,
-0.548075795173645,
-0.7956634163856506,
-0.4186858534812927,
-0.5520337224006653,
-0.42820069193840027,
0.11964622139930725,
-0.4057120382785797,
0.2570740282535553,
-0.5344612002372742,
-0.14700502157211304,
-0.09902510792016983,
-0.21555399894714355,
-0.7595023512840271,
-0.07353974878787994,
0.33111372590065,
0.6111328601837158,
-0.6945784091949463,
0.8865463733673096,
0.805939257144928,
-0.05294698849320412,
-0.27152350544929504,
0.025057855993509293,
0.052990589290857315,
-0.6487381458282471,
0.6930737495422363,
0.31488728523254395,
-0.19743019342422485,
0.030618129298090935,
-0.4634946882724762,
-0.5532470941543579,
0.9712026119232178,
0.44144368171691895,
-0.7717590928077698,
0.1988394856452942,
0.12493648380041122,
0.5093994140625,
-0.6138305068016052,
0.17276054620742798,
0.44909027218818665,
0.3315574824810028,
0.038162559270858765,
-0.4314137399196625,
0.06657344102859497,
-0.040832050144672394,
0.08100947737693787,
-0.007538641337305307,
-0.38097405433654785,
0.5005818009376526,
-0.20623710751533508,
-0.18010665476322174,
-0.36635148525238037,
0.9667454957962036,
0.18561622500419617,
0.319312185049057,
0.7100484371185303,
0.32426053285598755,
0.584679365158081,
0.19730137288570404,
0.911411464214325,
-0.36682429909706116,
0.02202885039150715,
1.2221362590789795,
-0.3705553412437439,
0.8189185261726379,
0.8636941313743591,
-0.06953500211238861,
0.4967501163482666,
0.5633188486099243,
0.21896548569202423,
0.49442383646965027,
0.2043704390525818,
-0.43682554364204407,
-0.5990277528762817,
-0.2023547887802124,
-0.14763522148132324,
0.2687983512878418,
0.241281658411026,
-0.35959112644195557,
-0.11068424582481384,
0.00500295078381896,
-0.012749752961099148,
0.24073155224323273,
0.055938247591257095,
0.8857508301734924,
0.2703457474708557,
-0.47938475012779236,
0.2037499099969864,
-0.03085879236459732,
1.1176387071609497,
-0.5657243728637695,
0.12777554988861084,
-0.2873465418815613,
0.0788811594247818,
-0.25514474511146545,
-0.8267374038696289,
-0.04477594047784805,
0.2024022489786148,
-0.24811263382434845,
-0.5966309905052185,
0.8558595776557922,
-0.6441396474838257,
-0.2740381062030792,
0.4932610094547272,
0.7321373820304871,
0.0973382517695427,
0.02064432017505169,
-0.43547430634498596,
0.26337674260139465,
-0.05844433233141899,
-0.5544509887695312,
0.48370128870010376,
0.2182311862707138,
-0.01436933409422636,
0.5771973133087158,
0.7660810351371765,
-0.30272379517555237,
-0.02227381058037281,
0.5179373025894165,
0.9429857134819031,
-0.8072393536567688,
-0.5144259333610535,
-0.9881465435028076,
0.3982306122779846,
0.1137644425034523,
-0.29985448718070984,
0.8224132657051086,
0.5679208040237427,
0.7819885611534119,
0.02250819280743599,
0.7554367780685425,
0.25414127111434937,
0.24331288039684296,
-0.44485151767730713,
0.5106821060180664,
-0.6496065855026245,
0.5423671007156372,
-0.13955718278884888,
-1.0004500150680542,
-0.39521172642707825,
0.3977348506450653,
-0.44163978099823,
0.23916304111480713,
0.09891234338283539,
0.7389814257621765,
-0.36044496297836304,
-0.26913392543792725,
0.40185070037841797,
0.16785749793052673,
0.40163522958755493,
0.43158218264579773,
1.0583943128585815,
0.13164226710796356,
0.261707067489624,
-0.12075986713171005,
-0.20507611334323883,
-0.502984881401062,
-1.1001884937286377,
-1.0733088254928589,
-0.4559379518032074,
-0.262092262506485,
-0.0030062957666814327,
-0.03688295558094978,
1.2165887355804443,
0.7276371121406555,
-0.735728919506073,
-0.33782240748405457,
0.1935214102268219,
0.06534109264612198,
0.3163068890571594,
-0.1662091612815857,
0.30074939131736755,
-0.3863251209259033,
-0.7946388721466064,
0.7805313467979431,
0.4720109701156616,
0.006230789236724377,
-0.6283093690872192,
-0.45117947459220886,
-0.044594816863536835,
-0.004895200952887535,
0.6519683599472046,
0.1327870488166809,
-0.807299792766571,
-0.2904492914676666,
0.06590169668197632,
-0.3131835460662842,
0.17548489570617676,
0.7706584334373474,
-0.8880207538604736,
0.6282622814178467,
0.609480619430542,
0.8856279850006104,
0.7500137090682983,
0.17688095569610596,
0.6907643675804138,
-0.838071882724762,
-0.11648083478212357,
0.11489713937044144,
0.4052538573741913,
0.5740813612937927,
-0.4791839122772217,
0.3477713465690613,
0.014528853818774223,
-0.36320722103118896,
-0.7597033381462097,
0.028750833123922348,
-1.188875436782837,
-0.2173939198255539,
1.2165359258651733,
-0.14486853778362274,
-0.08331030607223511,
-0.16304098069667816,
-0.18475434184074402,
-0.11226276308298111,
-0.6080779433250427,
0.5104740858078003,
0.4735763370990753,
-0.1782759726047516,
-0.3190627992153168,
-0.280134916305542,
0.3519989848136902,
0.4593387544155121,
-0.8619041442871094,
0.02089560776948929,
0.4926036596298218,
0.34265127778053284,
-0.13690456748008728,
0.6163604259490967,
0.19757279753684998,
-0.04025446996092796,
-0.48877188563346863,
-0.05654093995690346,
-0.46413809061050415,
-0.34693220257759094,
-0.6923351287841797,
0.22505058348178864,
-0.000874331162776798,
0.14112001657485962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13593v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13593v1
|
Knowledge Graph Enhanced Large Language Model Editing
| 2024-02-21T07:52:26 | 2024-02-21T07:52:26 |
Mengqi Zhang, Xiaotian Ye, Qiang Liu, Pengjie Ren, Shu Wu, Zhumin Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are pivotal in advancing natural language
processing (NLP) tasks, yet their efficacy is hampered by inaccuracies and
outdated knowledge. Model editing emerges as a promising solution to address
these challenges. However, existing editing methods struggle to track and
incorporate changes in knowledge associated with edits, which limits the
generalization ability of postedit LLMs in processing edited knowledge. To
tackle these problems, we propose a novel model editing method that leverages
knowledge graphs for enhancing LLM editing, namely GLAME. Specifically, we
first utilize a knowledge graph augmentation module to uncover associated
knowledge that has changed due to editing, obtaining its internal
representations within LLMs. This approach allows knowledge alterations within
LLMs to be reflected through an external graph structure. Subsequently, we
design a graph-based knowledge edit module to integrate structured knowledge
into the model editing. This ensures that the updated parameters reflect not
only the modifications of the edited knowledge but also the changes in other
associated knowledge resulting from the editing process. Comprehensive
experiments conducted on GPT-J and GPT-2 XL demonstrate that GLAME
significantly improves the generalization capabilities of post-edit LLMs in
employing edited knowledge.
|
[
-0.05272187665104866,
-0.9641580581665039,
0.6207218170166016,
-0.08080048859119415,
-0.16690945625305176,
0.27350589632987976,
-0.22442388534545898,
-0.6793133616447449,
0.30593907833099365,
0.6897605061531067,
-0.24540163576602936,
-0.8493485450744629,
-0.645668625831604,
0.04683317244052887,
-0.3635160028934479,
0.7840918898582458,
-0.0499819815158844,
-0.07026447355747223,
-0.1517205685377121,
-0.11823096871376038,
-0.5113987326622009,
-0.5143121480941772,
-0.8669894933700562,
-0.38136646151542664,
0.5818583369255066,
-0.12219083309173584,
1.1072368621826172,
0.6225130558013916,
0.2515573799610138,
0.3699672222137451,
-0.6303858160972595,
0.6669974327087402,
-0.4775126874446869,
0.05149142071604729,
-0.5534021854400635,
-0.3737923800945282,
-1.2528281211853027,
-0.32136622071266174,
0.7707540988922119,
0.6331211924552917,
0.16518375277519226,
0.10688846558332443,
0.1657830774784088,
0.5407319664955139,
-0.5258687138557434,
0.327674925327301,
-0.8372297883033752,
-0.25723883509635925,
-0.07202211022377014,
-0.1082848459482193,
-0.5101345181465149,
-0.2247145026922226,
-0.27643734216690063,
-0.7185476422309875,
0.021244900301098824,
-0.03380809724330902,
0.6662131547927856,
0.2615899443626404,
-0.3759627640247345,
-0.2873784601688385,
-0.6714146137237549,
0.1782272905111313,
-1.0665024518966675,
0.47075921297073364,
0.17209883034229279,
0.0072013442404568195,
-0.5529592633247375,
-0.9564344882965088,
-0.5041664838790894,
-0.018836097791790962,
-0.26840105652809143,
-0.22899684309959412,
-0.37772509455680847,
0.4835112690925598,
0.46424248814582825,
0.19358573853969574,
-0.3248331844806671,
0.23501700162887573,
-0.20606456696987152,
-0.28583046793937683,
0.5702665448188782,
0.10240580886602402,
0.615197479724884,
-0.2154223769903183,
0.1291160136461258,
0.22666803002357483,
-0.8091378211975098,
-0.21028535068035126,
0.5023933053016663,
0.13133177161216736,
0.21278734505176544,
0.9037208557128906,
-0.19696632027626038,
1.0185039043426514,
-0.13077139854431152,
-0.10346648842096329,
0.12446211278438568,
-0.16791248321533203,
-0.493552565574646,
-0.1834891140460968,
0.6165823936462402,
0.5928987860679626,
0.15665534138679504,
-0.25091278553009033,
-0.20862990617752075,
-0.3102380633354187,
-0.08671419322490692,
-0.7784499526023865,
-0.2586873173713684,
0.14620767533779144,
-0.12165115028619766,
-0.10374916344881058,
-0.207697793841362,
-0.5706817507743835,
-0.7455015182495117,
-0.43664422631263733,
0.2593141496181488,
-0.5343008637428284,
0.05569682642817497,
0.38619324564933777,
-0.25497326254844666,
-0.2782929241657257,
0.7443511486053467,
-0.8582358956336975,
0.10214931517839432,
0.643543004989624,
0.9412156343460083,
0.2996775805950165,
-0.10417909175157547,
-0.5034765601158142,
0.6510895490646362,
-0.36652225255966187,
0.6796231865882874,
-0.7455118298530579,
-0.2732202410697937,
-0.18612390756607056,
-0.14102207124233246,
-0.15999995172023773,
-0.3973335027694702,
0.28964734077453613,
-1.1714832782745361,
0.1493171751499176,
-0.007760375738143921,
-1.0688207149505615,
-0.44882693886756897,
0.06727470457553864,
-0.6151537299156189,
0.8666468858718872,
0.30270177125930786,
-0.9263202548027039,
0.22550508379936218,
-0.8928265571594238,
-0.11874653398990631,
0.002753661945462227,
0.21123453974723816,
-0.3564559817314148,
0.07026048749685287,
0.5994385480880737,
0.21478350460529327,
0.2714747488498688,
0.3132959306240082,
-0.4602813124656677,
-0.2853589951992035,
-0.09238321334123611,
-0.007159369997680187,
0.7235424518585205,
-0.28961941599845886,
0.22077171504497528,
0.8152957558631897,
-0.7040378451347351,
0.09835206717252731,
0.011115404777228832,
-0.34511256217956543,
-0.47726762294769287,
-0.16074490547180176,
-0.20396657288074493,
0.23876184225082397,
0.419635534286499,
-0.3741947114467621,
0.8544952273368835,
-0.5169803500175476,
0.48443830013275146,
0.8222365379333496,
0.3931739628314972,
0.36205679178237915,
-0.12248657643795013,
0.4857339859008789,
-0.34451451897621155,
0.2638227343559265,
0.12333006411790848,
-0.7263254523277283,
-0.7003480195999146,
-0.10139858722686768,
0.5716703534126282,
0.6110551953315735,
-0.8639403581619263,
0.35318315029144287,
-0.18266543745994568,
-0.44016900658607483,
-0.5595974922180176,
0.6403225064277649,
0.03633373603224754,
0.4650394916534424,
0.5834295749664307,
-0.083097904920578,
-0.6398612856864929,
-0.7527806758880615,
-0.3243296146392822,
0.0051920777186751366,
-0.2574231028556824,
0.1780083328485489,
0.42258456349372864,
-0.4674791991710663,
1.1754249334335327,
-0.7191926836967468,
-0.36097055673599243,
-0.25270694494247437,
-0.04056888818740845,
0.28552958369255066,
0.2102183848619461,
0.5301606059074402,
-0.38898417353630066,
-0.4071063995361328,
0.12701426446437836,
-0.6827739477157593,
-0.29284051060676575,
-0.015297044068574905,
-0.227057084441185,
0.11522190272808075,
0.6562254428863525,
-0.6587932705879211,
0.3581678569316864,
0.624232292175293,
-0.47439900040626526,
0.7070032954216003,
-0.5807059407234192,
0.09507197141647339,
-0.9017303586006165,
-0.03966057300567627,
-0.334170937538147,
-0.4370885193347931,
-0.7528917789459229,
0.05709421634674072,
0.33632850646972656,
0.14356279373168945,
-0.44247129559516907,
0.6741542220115662,
-0.4211913049221039,
-0.2293361872434616,
-0.34152495861053467,
0.42631804943084717,
0.12546053528785706,
0.32309138774871826,
-0.23767617344856262,
0.6800582408905029,
0.4174308180809021,
-0.28526392579078674,
0.3724929690361023,
0.5506242513656616,
-0.43193167448043823,
0.034438908100128174,
-0.6519734263420105,
0.6431490778923035,
-0.2385249137878418,
0.3583994507789612,
-0.7390184998512268,
-0.18554429709911346,
0.31520697474479675,
-0.09677974879741669,
0.35492539405822754,
-0.3485835790634155,
-0.6616325378417969,
-0.2210078090429306,
-0.23050960898399353,
0.07148593664169312,
0.013857108540832996,
-0.4450765550136566,
0.7851578593254089,
0.2524072229862213,
-0.43489402532577515,
-0.4688678979873657,
-0.33729249238967896,
0.5926142334938049,
-0.04698920249938965,
-1.0292190313339233,
0.42969608306884766,
-0.054751597344875336,
-0.35654619336128235,
0.11475116014480591,
0.36647146940231323,
0.04462923854589462,
-0.11320869624614716,
-0.08682689070701599,
0.5567023158073425,
-0.09574881941080093,
0.3601558804512024,
0.3354860246181488,
-0.10750529170036316,
-0.1976746916770935,
-0.13045673072338104,
0.7068105340003967,
0.28400686383247375,
-0.24726822972297668,
-0.46792954206466675,
0.05902920663356781,
0.477891206741333,
-0.4683416485786438,
0.7214139699935913,
0.5674617886543274,
-0.42703551054000854,
-0.18986506760120392,
-0.5294647216796875,
-0.07610452175140381,
-0.4761093258857727,
0.7647153735160828,
-0.19615572690963745,
-1.192288875579834,
0.5300726294517517,
-0.15702751278877258,
0.014056405052542686,
0.415950745344162,
0.22080589830875397,
0.2839233875274658,
1.0533303022384644,
0.6994079947471619,
-0.1506788730621338,
0.4855610430240631,
-0.21166269481182098,
0.33255070447921753,
-1.339821696281433,
0.1655024290084839,
-0.2392498254776001,
-0.4225618541240692,
-0.3959544003009796,
-0.8266969919204712,
0.40359818935394287,
0.5712615251541138,
-0.07617956399917603,
0.12207848578691483,
-0.30722659826278687,
0.6211453676223755,
0.2199833244085312,
0.19664445519447327,
0.8634976744651794,
-0.30541354417800903,
0.00985234696418047,
-0.0663764476776123,
-0.7493197321891785,
-0.56956946849823,
1.1805508136749268,
0.31242862343788147,
0.4035159945487976,
0.11066128313541412,
0.35981982946395874,
0.2789960205554962,
0.4944649338722229,
-0.4620940387248993,
0.6181010603904724,
-0.2669970989227295,
-0.350920706987381,
-0.47297728061676025,
-0.3129979968070984,
-0.4845997393131256,
0.3900984823703766,
-0.39262208342552185,
-1.0045325756072998,
-0.0571272037923336,
0.383139431476593,
-0.22941599786281586,
0.8292363882064819,
-0.7022945880889893,
0.7212069630622864,
0.0496794730424881,
-0.27101367712020874,
-0.41648611426353455,
-0.3054332137107849,
0.5048162341117859,
-0.10274222493171692,
0.49534234404563904,
0.04915296286344528,
-0.05021229758858681,
0.6851733326911926,
-0.5404336452484131,
0.8026070594787598,
-0.27616482973098755,
-0.18906575441360474,
0.19540302455425262,
0.1682344675064087,
1.0072250366210938,
0.1443464457988739,
-0.2807984948158264,
0.06237141788005829,
-0.5010554790496826,
-0.0348859541118145,
-0.963438868522644,
0.45654261112213135,
-0.4921439588069916,
-0.8131545186042786,
0.08412384986877441,
-1.0178254842758179,
-0.46237048506736755,
0.26446080207824707,
-0.08196905255317688,
0.5384572148323059,
0.08570671826601028,
0.040519487112760544,
0.2524820566177368,
-0.5311458110809326,
0.2940458655357361,
0.27710580825805664,
-0.9937115907669067,
-0.543054461479187,
0.5192500352859497,
0.3300119936466217,
0.672569215297699,
0.16919219493865967,
0.2906772196292877,
-0.3179403841495514,
-1.0146777629852295,
-0.4138299524784088,
0.3697682023048401,
-0.9682023525238037,
-0.07389941811561584,
-0.8930163383483887,
-0.2972351312637329,
-0.6122955679893494,
-0.38743335008621216,
-0.06552789360284805,
-0.4460435211658478,
0.0028495860751718283,
-0.09828055649995804,
0.6125798225402832,
1.1960437297821045,
-0.15177211165428162,
0.4922800064086914,
-0.6216580271720886,
0.40376999974250793,
0.4605642259120941,
0.37848976254463196,
-0.019012397155165672,
-0.5453097820281982,
-0.2106766402721405,
0.1666787564754486,
-0.11345109343528748,
-0.8352147936820984,
0.3804616630077362,
0.20985634624958038,
0.2555527985095978,
-0.020612437278032303,
-0.2678200602531433,
0.8916223645210266,
-0.3601285219192505,
0.5794891715049744,
-0.11520976573228836,
-1.1782487630844116,
0.5361899137496948,
-0.5927541255950928,
0.3560978174209595,
-0.01035317499190569,
-0.09850700944662094,
-0.7469841837882996,
-0.8552475571632385,
-0.47747817635536194,
-0.8603864312171936,
0.4103691875934601,
-0.0695568323135376,
0.051504965871572495,
0.25781530141830444,
0.5152958035469055,
-0.21537648141384125,
0.33558183908462524,
-0.5624147057533264,
-0.11831533908843994,
0.10543549060821533,
0.14950624108314514,
0.09757271409034729,
-0.49358537793159485,
0.10116791725158691,
-0.5568602681159973,
0.9967478513717651,
-0.16697464883327484,
-0.21699614822864532,
0.10085909813642502,
-0.2511339485645294,
-0.0910959467291832,
0.5543574094772339,
0.5700826644897461,
0.9602302312850952,
-0.44444096088409424,
-0.08072264492511749,
0.6459229588508606,
-0.330046683549881,
-0.24781429767608643,
-0.10096476227045059,
-0.5784673690795898,
0.037371426820755005,
0.5389241576194763,
0.9496075510978699,
0.41988828778266907,
-0.2678447663784027,
0.1194271519780159,
0.18140658736228943,
-0.054247286170721054,
0.19955362379550934,
0.3631470501422882,
0.5272642970085144,
0.2532881796360016,
0.04215005040168762,
0.16694819927215576,
-0.0976281389594078,
-0.30318978428840637,
0.2150879204273224,
0.39434486627578735,
-0.1703227311372757,
-0.017370183020830154,
0.80370032787323,
-0.19239503145217896,
-0.4785309433937073,
0.5974470973014832,
-0.2288297563791275,
-0.47621455788612366,
0.21214444935321808,
0.6237998008728027,
0.5777411460876465,
-0.3824683129787445,
0.24165335297584534,
0.36602845788002014,
0.24618375301361084,
0.37022972106933594,
-0.05430765822529793,
0.5317623019218445,
-0.8739470839500427,
-0.9407187104225159,
-0.5755449533462524,
-0.5715762972831726,
0.3151331841945648,
-0.24054841697216034,
0.5651400685310364,
-0.5191313624382019,
-0.09652137011289597,
-0.029232610017061234,
-0.2547086477279663,
-0.47491928935050964,
0.16292868554592133,
-0.060271453112363815,
0.7817753553390503,
-0.4341948926448822,
1.1254948377609253,
0.5263494253158569,
-0.08413174748420715,
-0.8091979622840881,
-0.46630170941352844,
0.01948287896811962,
-0.7875237464904785,
0.3203735947608948,
-0.0638153925538063,
-0.05406022444367409,
0.28780311346054077,
-0.36527693271636963,
-0.8197774291038513,
1.117003321647644,
0.7279731631278992,
-0.6403874158859253,
-0.2946872413158417,
0.27680209279060364,
0.6398853659629822,
-0.27502650022506714,
0.359345406293869,
0.5106440186500549,
0.7110986709594727,
0.30371659994125366,
-0.9133371114730835,
-0.12598881125450134,
-0.12735624611377716,
-0.015185035765171051,
0.18556317687034607,
-0.2912486791610718,
0.8157433271408081,
-0.25845804810523987,
-0.13584962487220764,
-0.23233889043331146,
0.6247681975364685,
-0.009344814345240593,
-0.1922353208065033,
0.5240365266799927,
0.5940868258476257,
1.1137242317199707,
0.19140411913394928,
0.8434650301933289,
-0.4137673079967499,
0.3685240149497986,
1.6000896692276,
-0.3584464490413666,
0.7891175746917725,
0.214498832821846,
-0.1050468236207962,
0.536200761795044,
0.23255214095115662,
-0.01089963223785162,
-0.07827947288751602,
0.12167737632989883,
-0.24948374927043915,
-0.26975616812705994,
-0.11292589455842972,
-0.36791107058525085,
0.459426611661911,
0.321460098028183,
-0.39911311864852905,
-0.4663688838481903,
-0.09791875630617142,
0.548289954662323,
0.04347701370716095,
-0.6363346576690674,
0.764129638671875,
-0.11099318414926529,
-0.12562882900238037,
0.2889353930950165,
0.27569013833999634,
0.5126119256019592,
-0.8123492002487183,
-0.08282183110713959,
0.20417629182338715,
0.08776766061782837,
-0.41654330492019653,
-0.8922501802444458,
0.5296439528465271,
0.0001188331370940432,
-0.07307008653879166,
-0.2810456156730652,
1.008528709411621,
-0.5787241458892822,
-0.6679110527038574,
0.6941924095153809,
0.5017721056938171,
-0.3920401930809021,
-0.340376615524292,
-0.4491962790489197,
0.1570332944393158,
0.13090847432613373,
-0.42687514424324036,
0.34732240438461304,
0.10816116631031036,
-0.011870292946696281,
0.6303800344467163,
0.8042281270027161,
0.44165846705436707,
0.03870079293847084,
0.187834694981575,
0.9302980899810791,
-0.5616777539253235,
-0.4909428060054779,
-0.9197676777839661,
0.7045401334762573,
-0.3740769326686859,
-0.2983185350894928,
0.7055445909500122,
0.5651271939277649,
0.5919834971427917,
-0.056511908769607544,
0.8096289038658142,
0.06237688660621643,
0.3776686489582062,
-0.8481265902519226,
0.8694217801094055,
-0.18060962855815887,
0.16165901720523834,
-0.43051281571388245,
-1.1329127550125122,
-0.6529050469398499,
0.35117536783218384,
-0.751840353012085,
-0.2743033468723297,
0.6093202233314514,
1.0750869512557983,
0.17087455093860626,
0.16776035726070404,
0.394275039434433,
0.7186041474342346,
0.7176134586334229,
0.4160166084766388,
0.4313991069793701,
-0.31839969754219055,
0.053361307829618454,
-0.2547086477279663,
-0.07325411587953568,
0.09644059091806412,
-0.8993143439292908,
-1.001478672027588,
-0.2947932779788971,
-0.36492323875427246,
-0.1426483392715454,
0.24932129681110382,
0.9420216679573059,
0.29455873370170593,
-0.5960088968276978,
-0.02128131315112114,
0.13403642177581787,
0.40399572253227234,
-0.061975181102752686,
-0.20028823614120483,
0.7378031015396118,
-0.2803554832935333,
-0.7147389054298401,
0.7098074555397034,
0.5573167204856873,
-0.04690266028046608,
0.07435951381921768,
0.035732779651880264,
-0.3665301203727722,
-0.04098682850599289,
0.7554155588150024,
-0.157535120844841,
-0.4322894513607025,
-0.8534573912620544,
-0.401631236076355,
0.22585318982601166,
0.18293654918670654,
0.5900441408157349,
-0.5300548076629639,
0.6516528725624084,
0.4409753680229187,
0.388090044260025,
0.3685884475708008,
0.023856349289417267,
0.5761830806732178,
-0.6528956294059753,
0.16395996510982513,
0.004635338671505451,
0.6531087756156921,
0.5363549590110779,
-0.30544334650039673,
0.39958155155181885,
0.2864990532398224,
-0.6465200185775757,
-0.6232882142066956,
0.08281392604112625,
-0.8384730815887451,
-0.08985649794340134,
1.240407109260559,
-0.05997544154524803,
-0.19663317501544952,
-0.2659168243408203,
-0.5845851302146912,
0.4278874397277832,
-0.05009438470005989,
0.6770374178886414,
0.893372654914856,
-0.15212740004062653,
-0.06077544391155243,
-0.7995308637619019,
0.4801883101463318,
-0.03781957924365997,
-0.9662623405456543,
0.2653360962867737,
0.7471550703048706,
0.24439337849617004,
-0.09938511252403259,
0.5379920601844788,
-0.05776092782616615,
0.05192926898598671,
-0.2780822515487671,
0.21125119924545288,
-0.5819917321205139,
-0.09637866914272308,
-0.15549376606941223,
0.4426489770412445,
0.1945536881685257,
0.44061052799224854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14866v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14866v2
|
APTQ: Attention-aware Post-Training Mixed-Precision Quantization for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T07:45:22 | 2024-04-16T03:18:38 |
Ziyi Guan, Hantao Huang, Yupeng Su, Hong Huang, Ngai Wong, Hao Yu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have greatly advanced the natural language
processing paradigm. However, the high computational load and huge model sizes
pose a grand challenge for deployment on edge devices. To this end, we propose
APTQ (Attention-aware Post-Training Mixed-Precision Quantization) for LLMs,
which considers not only the second-order information of each layer's weights,
but also, for the first time, the nonlinear effect of attention outputs on the
entire model. We leverage the Hessian trace as a sensitivity metric for
mixed-precision quantization, ensuring an informed precision reduction that
retains model performance. Experiments show APTQ surpasses previous
quantization methods, achieving an average of 4 bit width a 5.22 perplexity
nearly equivalent to full precision in the C4 dataset. In addition, APTQ
attains state-of-the-art zero-shot accuracy of 68.24\% and 70.48\% at an
average bitwidth of 3.8 in LLaMa-7B and LLaMa-13B, respectively, demonstrating
its effectiveness to produce high-quality quantized LLMs.
|
[
-0.4660983681678772,
-0.7975468635559082,
0.5439726114273071,
0.06703177094459534,
-0.47471946477890015,
-0.053480878472328186,
-0.3716704249382019,
-0.25033220648765564,
0.05178094655275345,
0.4979914724826813,
-0.31668832898139954,
-0.5504665374755859,
-0.7386526465415955,
-0.049517445266246796,
-0.4369075298309326,
0.9947195053100586,
0.13079461455345154,
0.015216412954032421,
-0.09486235678195953,
-0.33717313408851624,
-0.09377899765968323,
-0.6367501020431519,
-0.7840490937232971,
-0.04590679705142975,
0.5982045531272888,
0.1657644808292389,
1.063241720199585,
0.8711972236633301,
0.6338924765586853,
0.20171205699443817,
-0.2651975750923157,
-0.018700646236538887,
-0.44201359152793884,
0.023867076262831688,
0.04219261184334755,
-0.5326063632965088,
-0.9936942458152771,
-0.24274268746376038,
1.0030828714370728,
0.5028975605964661,
-0.14439663290977478,
0.3407973349094391,
-0.15394416451454163,
0.802655816078186,
-0.8235775828361511,
-0.4148631691932678,
-0.6480593681335449,
0.06417019665241241,
-0.15427464246749878,
0.010474548675119877,
-0.0745413675904274,
-0.33667922019958496,
0.13060663640499115,
-0.7605182528495789,
0.08004488050937653,
-0.13863927125930786,
0.7576388716697693,
0.6312991380691528,
-0.6850407123565674,
0.23466770350933075,
-0.7818828225135803,
0.962799608707428,
-0.8384594917297363,
0.6527026891708374,
0.4669930934906006,
0.04334278404712677,
0.0818738117814064,
-0.9083340167999268,
-0.3971565365791321,
0.2484801709651947,
0.2668322026729584,
0.05695438012480736,
-0.030752263963222504,
0.25880080461502075,
0.23131239414215088,
0.6254749298095703,
-0.6112952828407288,
-0.06896153092384338,
0.08041796833276749,
-0.12477437406778336,
0.6132057309150696,
-0.06781922280788422,
-0.01574443280696869,
0.34632062911987305,
-0.19386054575443268,
0.0761631578207016,
-0.800811767578125,
-0.079735167324543,
0.18288949131965637,
0.194739431142807,
0.1294311285018921,
0.5058927536010742,
-0.41375070810317993,
0.9503840208053589,
0.1483934372663498,
-0.09649437665939331,
0.01815688982605934,
-0.3653249442577362,
-0.35330522060394287,
0.11470599472522736,
0.7794848084449768,
0.16065984964370728,
0.17133578658103943,
0.03511926159262657,
-0.46829289197921753,
-0.16784660518169403,
0.24599812924861908,
-0.9195786714553833,
-0.2491113692522049,
0.43128901720046997,
-0.18079793453216553,
-0.01423889771103859,
-0.45873188972473145,
-0.50895756483078,
-0.2886149287223816,
-0.4408330023288727,
0.6328620910644531,
-0.2187085598707199,
-0.13722077012062073,
0.22413265705108643,
0.30944305658340454,
0.3000057637691498,
0.29065513610839844,
-0.7516928315162659,
0.2214890420436859,
0.7190096974372864,
0.7595686316490173,
0.13255861401557922,
-0.005911471787840128,
-0.861977219581604,
0.2934931814670563,
-0.2284633070230484,
0.638281524181366,
-0.3400837779045105,
0.0591622069478035,
-0.14404766261577606,
-0.48204872012138367,
0.10327678173780441,
-0.42788633704185486,
0.8284829258918762,
-0.8085702657699585,
-0.026951370760798454,
0.04453146085143089,
-0.4377918243408203,
-0.08310146629810333,
0.3280439078807831,
-0.406943678855896,
1.3570531606674194,
0.0982750877737999,
-0.880420446395874,
0.14051292836666107,
-0.2241053432226181,
-0.45843860507011414,
0.12964974343776703,
0.12991249561309814,
-0.7214035391807556,
0.20132170617580414,
0.38006460666656494,
0.3192034661769867,
-0.3283960521221161,
0.4038497507572174,
-0.4468126893043518,
-0.44812190532684326,
0.184678852558136,
-0.42826300859451294,
0.5487015247344971,
-0.022165289148688316,
-0.3917364478111267,
0.24516206979751587,
-0.8152065873146057,
0.32276302576065063,
0.05425168573856354,
-0.4144304394721985,
-0.4324212372303009,
-0.23855742812156677,
-0.1224166601896286,
0.21837684512138367,
0.41532328724861145,
-0.35376524925231934,
0.06094241887331009,
-0.5125422477722168,
0.5202403664588928,
0.6445016860961914,
-0.2452213615179062,
0.5376567840576172,
-0.03336001932621002,
0.4597848951816559,
-0.29331231117248535,
0.18338674306869507,
0.06760067492723465,
-0.3272939622402191,
-0.9903693199157715,
-0.4870138168334961,
0.6012470126152039,
0.5960915088653564,
-0.5601844787597656,
0.6058762669563293,
-0.48909538984298706,
-0.32357221841812134,
-0.6280242800712585,
-0.004850825760513544,
0.4298979341983795,
0.2650704085826874,
0.22512400150299072,
-0.27204594016075134,
-0.3270811438560486,
-0.7735442519187927,
-0.42634275555610657,
0.11411245912313461,
-0.34976568818092346,
0.425549179315567,
0.22541773319244385,
-0.19215504825115204,
0.8859483599662781,
-0.42227399349212646,
-0.3062194287776947,
0.019307982176542282,
0.17608290910720825,
0.12043913453817368,
0.1804610788822174,
0.2564835548400879,
-0.6593327522277832,
-0.49708423018455505,
0.1718699038028717,
-0.3544686734676361,
-0.08809690177440643,
0.09709974378347397,
-0.32594162225723267,
0.19400347769260406,
0.3718703091144562,
-0.846264660358429,
0.26664990186691284,
0.584322988986969,
-0.25964224338531494,
0.3320031762123108,
-0.08292552828788757,
0.1115015521645546,
-0.97600919008255,
0.16280899941921234,
0.11839988827705383,
-0.6317798495292664,
-0.7448042035102844,
-0.11563491821289062,
0.20102731883525848,
-0.051042500883340836,
-0.505052387714386,
0.4783538281917572,
-0.3429594933986664,
-0.391203910112381,
-0.18605473637580872,
0.27559584379196167,
0.10895752906799316,
0.4056597948074341,
0.01883501000702381,
0.8153098225593567,
0.5424498319625854,
-0.6088227033615112,
0.35956087708473206,
0.041411884129047394,
-0.02442636340856552,
0.7375801801681519,
-0.8893842697143555,
0.31014183163642883,
-0.14427787065505981,
0.10017511993646622,
-0.9587085247039795,
-0.13189373910427094,
0.04735338315367699,
-0.5819491744041443,
0.24019932746887207,
-0.12918466329574585,
-0.5230900645256042,
-0.0711091011762619,
-0.499563604593277,
0.6556575894355774,
0.38644570112228394,
-0.1539101004600525,
0.7018725275993347,
0.3877710700035095,
-0.32675451040267944,
-0.7245674729347229,
-0.5588979721069336,
0.05009906366467476,
-0.3689877688884735,
-0.45211681723594666,
0.3722286522388458,
-0.02764623984694481,
-0.04713314399123192,
-0.18489642441272736,
-0.01873946562409401,
-0.2572537958621979,
0.12655366957187653,
-0.11986079066991806,
-0.07445699721574783,
-0.19057312607765198,
0.28987571597099304,
0.03805968165397644,
-0.08586201071739197,
-0.042634740471839905,
-0.47541868686676025,
0.5099932551383972,
-0.16731314361095428,
-0.033479224890470505,
-0.4401955306529999,
0.20511825382709503,
0.7123812437057495,
-0.7070053815841675,
0.6767132878303528,
0.9487241506576538,
-0.6168410181999207,
-0.02720310166478157,
-0.37665268778800964,
-0.30778971314430237,
-0.43710771203041077,
0.500880241394043,
-0.35903647541999817,
-1.1405808925628662,
0.4903217852115631,
0.0036170987877994776,
0.0033894323278218508,
0.2633405327796936,
0.5155571699142456,
0.02393372170627117,
1.1896098852157593,
0.504560649394989,
-0.1824827641248703,
0.47588738799095154,
0.05013376474380493,
0.4469030499458313,
-1.0339690446853638,
0.30978596210479736,
-0.3526117205619812,
-0.37648895382881165,
-0.2350035011768341,
-0.3608139157295227,
0.4883795380592346,
0.3920193612575531,
-0.5896369218826294,
-0.03969747945666313,
-0.5174462199211121,
0.36623185873031616,
0.771331787109375,
0.1500290185213089,
0.37848541140556335,
0.02118946984410286,
0.3680640161037445,
-0.07581839710474014,
-0.6542733311653137,
-0.25077325105667114,
1.3988717794418335,
0.45063316822052,
0.5944494009017944,
-0.00454463018104434,
0.4344102442264557,
0.10572196543216705,
0.21241290867328644,
-0.9149817228317261,
0.4546721279621124,
-0.11442259699106216,
-0.37812232971191406,
-0.5450413227081299,
-0.6266293525695801,
-0.6913449168205261,
0.25255271792411804,
-0.01845563016831875,
-0.3782288730144501,
-0.22163145244121552,
0.295442134141922,
-0.7075275778770447,
0.11877091974020004,
-0.5176089406013489,
0.933118462562561,
-0.319503515958786,
-0.4741261899471283,
-0.1835690438747406,
-0.7458874583244324,
0.43244054913520813,
-0.10843826085329056,
0.2724249064922333,
-0.21448934078216553,
-0.3292659521102905,
0.6529303193092346,
-0.3231661021709442,
0.5848565697669983,
0.041117072105407715,
-0.37432849407196045,
0.266817182302475,
0.08273375034332275,
0.7985820174217224,
0.24309684336185455,
0.13688237965106964,
0.20572850108146667,
-0.10589691996574402,
-0.30931833386421204,
-0.4782060384750366,
0.693956196308136,
-0.8135659694671631,
-0.5202271938323975,
-0.32585352659225464,
-0.7305564284324646,
-0.22322684526443481,
0.2942183017730713,
0.11711973696947098,
0.377064973115921,
0.2142760306596756,
0.2405385673046112,
1.0263254642486572,
-0.030662447214126587,
0.4550369083881378,
0.41198334097862244,
-0.05132213979959488,
-0.9013344049453735,
0.7185017466545105,
0.19013972580432892,
0.36065834760665894,
0.4506666958332062,
-0.0073247202672064304,
-0.37492799758911133,
-0.7193893194198608,
-0.6457852125167847,
0.31679677963256836,
-0.5495333671569824,
-0.5166189074516296,
-0.7959573268890381,
-0.09552392363548279,
-0.41945454478263855,
0.03238917142152786,
-0.8346205949783325,
-0.5457090139389038,
-0.5776902437210083,
0.11932244151830673,
0.677920937538147,
0.29676830768585205,
0.1968827098608017,
0.6681613922119141,
-0.893504798412323,
0.36859309673309326,
0.5560922622680664,
0.5680116415023804,
-0.196461021900177,
-0.880171537399292,
-0.4725896120071411,
0.18788336217403412,
-0.19903351366519928,
-0.47701495885849,
0.4829930067062378,
0.5165412425994873,
0.10732141137123108,
0.3115217685699463,
0.13273043930530548,
0.522649347782135,
-0.4018859267234802,
0.6356531977653503,
-0.17078348994255066,
-1.1836516857147217,
0.44225916266441345,
-0.5885292291641235,
0.6334534883499146,
0.46241530776023865,
0.2641585171222687,
-0.5403749346733093,
-0.3448654115200043,
-0.44375476241111755,
-0.9950339794158936,
0.7989988327026367,
0.14512011408805847,
0.018518028780817986,
0.329598993062973,
0.5196367502212524,
-0.3973354697227478,
0.5082104802131653,
-0.9178276658058167,
-0.31408652663230896,
0.10129515081644058,
-0.3632044196128845,
0.05998358502984047,
-0.4351024627685547,
-0.022388150915503502,
-0.21889451146125793,
0.7008628845214844,
-0.1221851035952568,
0.13938143849372864,
0.26336875557899475,
-0.11533045023679733,
-0.29321396350860596,
0.22242054343223572,
0.5699493885040283,
0.610218346118927,
-0.30004259943962097,
0.4502508044242859,
0.20485082268714905,
-0.46408161520957947,
0.07578039914369583,
0.22095558047294617,
-0.16890233755111694,
-0.11913664638996124,
0.09258688986301422,
0.7165224552154541,
0.1287330985069275,
-0.6620480418205261,
0.5840334892272949,
-0.1213909387588501,
0.0019488100660964847,
-0.142376109957695,
-0.2649180293083191,
0.05902303010225296,
0.16392967104911804,
0.3808082938194275,
-0.119859479367733,
0.3591165244579315,
-0.10250000655651093,
0.359854519367218,
0.6302304267883301,
-0.4236301779747009,
-0.32259973883628845,
0.7108270525932312,
0.22080184519290924,
-0.23344260454177856,
0.3695194721221924,
-0.2622823119163513,
-0.6347714066505432,
0.4988834857940674,
0.39573994278907776,
0.8210858106613159,
-0.5601572394371033,
0.04120390862226486,
0.3917095363140106,
0.3581204414367676,
-0.03871943801641464,
0.33279308676719666,
-0.0020489804446697235,
-0.6055349707603455,
-0.7297074198722839,
-0.6832398772239685,
-0.26140812039375305,
0.15460051596164703,
-0.6140130758285522,
0.24856841564178467,
-0.5016047358512878,
-0.42809951305389404,
-0.2794974148273468,
-0.21121715009212494,
-0.39185744524002075,
0.45132511854171753,
0.1613006293773651,
0.25252169370651245,
-0.5873833894729614,
0.7546364068984985,
0.8840339779853821,
0.2911209166049957,
-0.5835108757019043,
-0.10841421037912369,
-0.4508107602596283,
-0.5375282764434814,
0.22238703072071075,
0.17334231734275818,
-0.13500677049160004,
0.6302492618560791,
-0.305046021938324,
-1.2239078283309937,
1.0378236770629883,
0.5021310448646545,
-0.657071590423584,
0.3167899250984192,
0.30758947134017944,
0.4672037363052368,
-0.01936729997396469,
0.5272170305252075,
0.7564311027526855,
0.2016659528017044,
-0.005357964895665646,
-1.001713752746582,
-0.10298947989940643,
-0.0002503926807548851,
0.1902124434709549,
0.6023860573768616,
-0.7465049624443054,
0.999082088470459,
-0.015658969059586525,
-0.2107677310705185,
-0.31047847867012024,
0.6500663161277771,
0.29458656907081604,
0.18118280172348022,
0.1782086193561554,
1.051586627960205,
0.5857049226760864,
-0.04596416652202606,
0.91994708776474,
-0.3878189027309418,
0.4571744501590729,
1.0484485626220703,
-0.2735951840877533,
0.9307898283004761,
0.5049965977668762,
-0.34415701031684875,
-0.08190886676311493,
0.7422808408737183,
0.5377627015113831,
0.520409107208252,
0.15395478904247284,
-0.5917502641677856,
-0.28521740436553955,
-0.48038962483406067,
-0.32931798696517944,
0.15530170500278473,
0.2576236128807068,
-0.099287249147892,
0.03516336530447006,
0.030907034873962402,
0.015713034197688103,
-0.10217653959989548,
-0.6869196891784668,
0.8556490540504456,
0.10607058554887772,
-0.4371803104877472,
1.054207444190979,
0.14502368867397308,
0.7707581520080566,
-0.3762778043746948,
0.1297212839126587,
-0.2789882719516754,
0.39508765935897827,
-0.11625228077173233,
-0.7087053656578064,
0.19886401295661926,
-0.1781110167503357,
-0.2129324972629547,
-0.16823267936706543,
0.6264820098876953,
-0.7441666126251221,
-0.5934597253799438,
0.006858824752271175,
0.24515581130981445,
-0.16072142124176025,
-0.710427463054657,
-0.5602318048477173,
0.23723159730434418,
-0.06446734070777893,
-0.537345290184021,
0.3007834851741791,
0.7072104215621948,
0.06482120603322983,
0.725882887840271,
0.3457657992839813,
-0.008949886076152325,
0.28744447231292725,
-0.03324602544307709,
0.8058410882949829,
-0.4858768880367279,
-0.3775714933872223,
-0.8388169407844543,
0.6315479278564453,
0.14066758751869202,
-0.43031948804855347,
0.5943154692649841,
0.5440467596054077,
0.7498716711997986,
0.024762729182839394,
0.6478763818740845,
0.3252010643482208,
0.45475664734840393,
-0.42389726638793945,
0.4628043472766876,
-0.6085511445999146,
0.09465056657791138,
0.06506861001253128,
-1.1675760746002197,
-0.7548567652702332,
0.5402314066886902,
-0.33662354946136475,
0.17121048271656036,
0.5386869311332703,
0.6113206744194031,
-0.01122113037854433,
-0.35932138562202454,
0.28829872608184814,
-0.019228024408221245,
0.13522352278232574,
0.845197319984436,
0.5850474834442139,
-0.790306568145752,
0.6777413487434387,
-0.26227352023124695,
-0.3113829791545868,
-0.2757051885128021,
-0.7426072359085083,
-0.9125476479530334,
-0.19271261990070343,
-0.546480119228363,
0.0008150703506544232,
0.07169734686613083,
0.5872855186462402,
0.6577130556106567,
-0.7279276847839355,
-0.022161228582262993,
-0.3626807928085327,
0.011628947220742702,
0.1004696637392044,
-0.233582004904747,
0.6060171127319336,
-0.12540151178836823,
-0.8246951103210449,
0.01056998036801815,
0.47726765275001526,
0.3039398789405823,
-0.14183875918388367,
0.00017561163986101747,
-0.24399669468402863,
-0.059422317892313004,
0.745535671710968,
-0.00777505012229085,
-0.7080530524253845,
-0.2381831407546997,
0.0934600904583931,
-0.322835236787796,
0.1516137719154358,
0.661051869392395,
-0.7198317646980286,
0.3607034683227539,
0.2901962399482727,
0.84083092212677,
0.3639826774597168,
0.2523459494113922,
0.6146481037139893,
-0.995429277420044,
0.340509295463562,
0.5845624804496765,
0.012112092226743698,
0.5263655185699463,
-0.5509760975837708,
0.30427131056785583,
0.0895090326666832,
-0.8136988282203674,
-0.8627538681030273,
0.1750924438238144,
-0.7846376895904541,
0.08395029604434967,
1.1403911113739014,
-0.1051802709698677,
-0.13143351674079895,
0.11963816732168198,
-0.22417443990707397,
0.44031789898872375,
-0.502247154712677,
0.6229248046875,
0.606296718120575,
0.16592569649219513,
-0.65995192527771,
-0.5636323690414429,
0.6688089370727539,
0.8269806504249573,
-0.7991223335266113,
0.32834094762802124,
0.4757956564426422,
-0.13633522391319275,
-0.1961182951927185,
0.5001033544540405,
0.028241463005542755,
0.2634449303150177,
-0.27096453309059143,
0.3373355269432068,
0.09021715074777603,
-0.2556875944137573,
-0.5724629163742065,
-0.04255763813853264,
0.31106895208358765,
-0.10506190359592438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13587v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13587v2
|
A Multimodal In-Context Tuning Approach for E-Commerce Product Description Generation
| 2024-02-21T07:38:29 | 2024-03-07T11:29:50 |
Yunxin Li, Baotian Hu, Wenhan Luo, Lin Ma, Yuxin Ding, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In this paper, we propose a new setting for generating product descriptions
from images, augmented by marketing keywords. It leverages the combined power
of visual and textual information to create descriptions that are more tailored
to the unique features of products. For this setting, previous methods utilize
visual and textual encoders to encode the image and keywords and employ a
language model-based decoder to generate the product description. However, the
generated description is often inaccurate and generic since same-category
products have similar copy-writings, and optimizing the overall framework on
large-scale samples makes models concentrate on common words yet ignore the
product features. To alleviate the issue, we present a simple and effective
Multimodal In-Context Tuning approach, named ModICT, which introduces a similar
product sample as the reference and utilizes the in-context learning capability
of language models to produce the description. During training, we keep the
visual encoder and language model frozen, focusing on optimizing the modules
responsible for creating multimodal in-context references and dynamic prompts.
This approach preserves the language generation prowess of large language
models (LLMs), facilitating a substantial increase in description diversity. To
assess the effectiveness of ModICT across various language model scales and
types, we collect data from three distinct product categories within the
E-commerce domain. Extensive experiments demonstrate that ModICT significantly
improves the accuracy (by up to 3.3% on Rouge-L) and diversity (by up to 9.4%
on D-5) of generated results compared to conventional methods. Our findings
underscore the potential of ModICT as a valuable tool for enhancing automatic
generation of product descriptions in a wide range of applications. Code is at:
https://github.com/HITsz-TMG/Multimodal-In-Context-Tuning
|
[
-0.4717346727848053,
-0.7800463438034058,
-0.026347842067480087,
0.453263521194458,
-0.6424537301063538,
0.03378153219819069,
-0.5527132153511047,
-0.7147939205169678,
0.1975438892841339,
0.2852907180786133,
-0.9058020114898682,
-0.338785856962204,
-0.20270860195159912,
0.22641509771347046,
0.060042500495910645,
1.0427896976470947,
0.042465414851903915,
0.03339042887091637,
-0.3300386965274811,
-0.17953801155090332,
-0.5493595600128174,
-0.17242813110351562,
-0.4956831932067871,
0.12882153689861298,
0.2295234352350235,
0.25804924964904785,
0.5728265047073364,
0.4580097198486328,
0.5889915823936462,
0.2604350745677948,
0.1645151972770691,
0.6094438433647156,
-0.4471605122089386,
0.5571632385253906,
-0.09034893661737442,
-0.14631767570972443,
-0.4708203077316284,
-0.22048652172088623,
0.2575180232524872,
0.08439169824123383,
-0.0539599172770977,
0.2843919098377228,
-0.07710863649845123,
0.23100440204143524,
-0.8081562519073486,
0.36865514516830444,
-0.7872090339660645,
-0.10803339630365372,
0.0261048786342144,
-0.512769341468811,
-0.3619522750377655,
-0.010444825515151024,
-0.00931667722761631,
-0.9438393115997314,
0.351589173078537,
0.39995110034942627,
1.1719459295272827,
0.2644864320755005,
-0.6184601783752441,
-0.36306217312812805,
-0.7268527150154114,
0.7664815783500671,
-0.7143357992172241,
0.305715948343277,
0.3364483118057251,
0.4156758785247803,
-0.07209331542253494,
-0.6370329260826111,
-0.7745726704597473,
-0.11542294174432755,
-0.17906376719474792,
0.40309762954711914,
-0.05064471811056137,
0.13354626297950745,
0.19401048123836517,
0.5276440382003784,
-0.42251718044281006,
-0.3872735798358917,
-0.2510042190551758,
-0.17919844388961792,
0.4912661612033844,
0.1945836991071701,
0.23016026616096497,
-0.18302087485790253,
-0.6687857508659363,
-0.08135136216878891,
-0.5971077084541321,
0.16062991321086884,
0.09936760365962982,
0.28379908204078674,
-0.08190354704856873,
0.4775839149951935,
-0.4435041546821594,
0.7208330035209656,
0.3473000228404999,
-0.6322014331817627,
0.36528897285461426,
-0.7667670249938965,
-0.23402029275894165,
-0.07477376610040665,
0.38373807072639465,
0.8356384634971619,
-0.2168354094028473,
0.059970926493406296,
-0.522552490234375,
-0.13847459852695465,
0.2752467393875122,
-1.0758079290390015,
0.012088281102478504,
-0.17132063210010529,
-0.7387133836746216,
-0.2056523859500885,
0.1657710075378418,
-0.7242905497550964,
0.0652400404214859,
-0.3533555865287781,
0.5929045677185059,
-0.08823475986719131,
-0.1143806204199791,
0.07293090224266052,
-0.1576405018568039,
0.13101673126220703,
-0.015897877514362335,
-0.746009886264801,
0.2518632411956787,
0.39384010434150696,
0.5859752297401428,
0.019755790010094643,
0.12633202970027924,
-0.24171292781829834,
0.5847178101539612,
-0.06831378489732742,
0.6326051354408264,
-0.6486369371414185,
-0.12696991860866547,
0.09404037892818451,
0.18280217051506042,
0.08198182284832001,
-0.531882643699646,
0.3096863329410553,
-0.5499670505523682,
0.1345057189464569,
-0.1206817701458931,
-0.3965608477592468,
-0.4208714962005615,
0.6303584575653076,
-0.806885838508606,
0.6519016027450562,
-0.07936015725135803,
-0.6088077425956726,
0.741808295249939,
-0.7686727046966553,
-0.7807011604309082,
0.31534096598625183,
-0.20621494948863983,
-0.6511400938034058,
0.37145230174064636,
0.4464775025844574,
0.37422874569892883,
-0.4231063425540924,
-0.15600454807281494,
-0.11368849128484726,
-0.1592281013727188,
0.5059899687767029,
-0.398488312959671,
0.2443149834871292,
0.48432835936546326,
-0.5730637311935425,
0.027681073173880577,
-0.6609585285186768,
0.04774898290634155,
0.11043626070022583,
-0.5429233312606812,
-0.019320592284202576,
-0.05113249644637108,
0.5671363472938538,
0.30349910259246826,
0.34153732657432556,
-0.47560393810272217,
0.18544001877307892,
-0.289762407541275,
0.4740341901779175,
0.6025230884552002,
0.1586730033159256,
0.13915199041366577,
-0.21299858391284943,
0.945148766040802,
-0.06580880284309387,
0.5211386680603027,
-0.6829169392585754,
-0.5466293692588806,
-0.5505324602127075,
-0.403064101934433,
0.2416025996208191,
0.21806611120700836,
-0.8841508626937866,
0.2769358456134796,
-0.38430771231651306,
-0.02203446999192238,
-0.18072476983070374,
0.1623290777206421,
0.47808074951171875,
0.41179123520851135,
0.20388534665107727,
-0.4585224390029907,
-0.23012767732143402,
-1.4213917255401611,
-0.25488007068634033,
0.15514498949050903,
0.09489484131336212,
0.6337054371833801,
0.2478397637605667,
-0.30318161845207214,
0.7538468241691589,
-0.5250672698020935,
-0.378182977437973,
-0.20910881459712982,
0.1525886356830597,
-0.011850744485855103,
0.06089580059051514,
0.42162734270095825,
-1.1261868476867676,
-0.7206811308860779,
0.18854522705078125,
-0.09165395796298981,
-0.1520349383354187,
-0.3084757626056671,
0.04702747240662575,
0.2154761254787445,
0.17016315460205078,
-0.5134277939796448,
0.25348764657974243,
0.4940434992313385,
-0.1738375574350357,
0.30252552032470703,
-0.2756240665912628,
0.4035322368144989,
-1.4898561239242554,
-0.04704871028661728,
0.12507472932338715,
-0.23798230290412903,
-0.2155703455209732,
0.30669617652893066,
0.2957518398761749,
-0.06361069530248642,
-0.4949970543384552,
0.21693745255470276,
-0.6144739389419556,
0.27399295568466187,
-0.20488835871219635,
0.07402558624744415,
0.33990952372550964,
0.5160595178604126,
-0.2948099672794342,
0.6907976269721985,
0.4356083869934082,
-0.5095189809799194,
0.40369904041290283,
0.22327078878879547,
-0.29129108786582947,
0.9445191025733948,
-0.40748897194862366,
-0.18293052911758423,
-0.13640356063842773,
0.4075731039047241,
-1.018181324005127,
-0.4133457541465759,
0.23949572443962097,
-0.15736107528209686,
0.4133022725582123,
-0.030305571854114532,
-0.7969386577606201,
-0.3595375120639801,
-0.266825795173645,
0.7245813608169556,
0.3748437762260437,
-0.5121830701828003,
0.7573147416114807,
0.09271950274705887,
-0.030892856419086456,
-0.31402963399887085,
-0.7148463129997253,
0.21059347689151764,
-0.3873487114906311,
-0.8927963376045227,
0.6694098114967346,
-0.4422823488712311,
0.12809018790721893,
-0.1527325063943863,
-0.10161610692739487,
-0.013582075014710426,
-0.10883554816246033,
0.21537882089614868,
0.07062084227800369,
-0.08660273253917694,
0.5793083906173706,
0.27763351798057556,
0.05877332016825676,
-0.27015405893325806,
-0.3142852783203125,
0.2410927563905716,
-0.04833907261490822,
-0.16253073513507843,
-0.3989885151386261,
0.2952742874622345,
0.44676366448402405,
-0.22601228952407837,
0.3913898766040802,
0.5709357857704163,
-0.20273295044898987,
-0.4198386073112488,
-0.41086381673812866,
-0.17506925761699677,
-0.5066804885864258,
0.42901235818862915,
-0.647973358631134,
-0.7075707912445068,
0.2595963478088379,
-0.15433119237422943,
-0.07478080689907074,
0.2664388418197632,
0.7613356709480286,
0.1294431835412979,
1.2523484230041504,
0.9091569185256958,
0.3919512629508972,
0.545886218547821,
0.09576777368783951,
0.6656369566917419,
-0.670874297618866,
-0.33133143186569214,
-0.026077207177877426,
-0.6704318523406982,
-0.5848135948181152,
-0.350165456533432,
0.6329914331436157,
0.11678849905729294,
-0.04220880568027496,
0.35541394352912903,
-0.6244790554046631,
0.6408126950263977,
0.3980156481266022,
0.19463412463665009,
0.33413270115852356,
0.4415845572948456,
0.06234419345855713,
-0.1401418000459671,
-0.4743344187736511,
-0.2189975082874298,
1.1332485675811768,
0.03602519631385803,
0.769267737865448,
0.062200866639614105,
0.19126957654953003,
-0.007334868889302015,
0.20771591365337372,
-0.6859660744667053,
0.23317037522792816,
-0.18358567357063293,
-0.7692868113517761,
0.29513588547706604,
-0.1384119689464569,
-0.6946778893470764,
0.2798458933830261,
-0.39820897579193115,
-0.21527867019176483,
0.07687631994485855,
0.3244006037712097,
-0.5101960301399231,
-0.12965211272239685,
-0.5134395956993103,
0.7720757722854614,
-0.7616375684738159,
-0.5311610698699951,
-0.3412068486213684,
-0.6772627234458923,
0.26230061054229736,
-0.1051238477230072,
0.38798874616622925,
0.013891123235225677,
-0.252559632062912,
0.2832053601741791,
-0.19074615836143494,
0.6358606219291687,
0.3811623156070709,
-0.14625020325183868,
-0.017056869342923164,
-0.0012938164873048663,
0.3517860770225525,
0.15033838152885437,
0.4050128757953644,
-0.40389394760131836,
-0.11302565783262253,
-0.38170868158340454,
-0.48242032527923584,
0.7311965227127075,
-0.3485178053379059,
-0.2871178686618805,
0.186210498213768,
-0.6908946633338928,
-0.11826648563146591,
0.07876544445753098,
0.4158070385456085,
0.6106135845184326,
-0.2147570252418518,
0.3496024012565613,
0.49581584334373474,
-0.45220738649368286,
0.6664513945579529,
0.21797049045562744,
-0.15667104721069336,
-0.7624365091323853,
0.9858876466751099,
-0.2588668465614319,
0.5457778573036194,
0.6325810551643372,
0.07500717043876648,
-0.2671305537223816,
-0.12341813743114471,
-0.5696619153022766,
0.014987059868872166,
-0.8209730386734009,
-0.5434437990188599,
-0.5748769044876099,
0.3378632366657257,
-0.3469226658344269,
-0.25383132696151733,
-0.11435043811798096,
-0.5488808155059814,
0.048233762383461,
-0.012771795503795147,
0.40993472933769226,
0.8000544905662537,
0.1567607969045639,
0.5563035607337952,
-0.5648776292800903,
0.4953489303588867,
0.39308980107307434,
0.26650306582450867,
-0.2353271096944809,
-0.0390692800283432,
-0.6043037176132202,
0.3442898392677307,
-0.746496856212616,
-0.7058038711547852,
0.49576443433761597,
0.5570082664489746,
0.4680768847465515,
0.6763051748275757,
-0.17422311007976532,
0.6944637894630432,
-0.07417267560958862,
0.9973706603050232,
0.37866532802581787,
-0.806250274181366,
0.5665112733840942,
-0.48668578267097473,
0.45417386293411255,
0.37642422318458557,
0.152593195438385,
-0.41790857911109924,
-0.22188983857631683,
-0.4647325575351715,
-1.2161784172058105,
0.6091316938400269,
0.17986661195755005,
0.4525167644023895,
-0.2650451958179474,
0.06527823954820633,
0.39246875047683716,
0.6521164774894714,
-0.9502776265144348,
-0.12516403198242188,
-0.2507246434688568,
-0.3508298397064209,
0.01981760933995247,
-0.13204684853553772,
-0.18555320799350739,
-0.2165059745311737,
0.5713744759559631,
-0.3153650164604187,
-0.03743330389261246,
-0.1545344889163971,
-0.3589931130409241,
-0.29444876313209534,
0.29981282353401184,
0.8542941212654114,
0.7829439640045166,
0.006115428172051907,
0.21759136021137238,
-0.08919726312160492,
-0.21017469465732574,
-0.300326943397522,
-0.0940864309668541,
-0.1064944937825203,
-0.0205911323428154,
-0.033271897584199905,
0.7827337384223938,
0.3016056418418884,
-0.9122214317321777,
0.7268082499504089,
-0.1183941662311554,
-0.04755266383290291,
-0.05040493607521057,
-0.353364497423172,
0.045830126851797104,
0.18481653928756714,
0.20409734547138214,
0.1860366314649582,
0.3074890077114105,
-0.6182277798652649,
0.19578124582767487,
0.6013357639312744,
-0.09457907825708389,
-0.37039270997047424,
0.7080420255661011,
0.30086958408355713,
-0.2420908361673355,
0.5312935709953308,
-0.2239242047071457,
-0.47983136773109436,
0.6315183043479919,
0.8268710970878601,
1.0743061304092407,
0.07200997322797775,
0.2387458086013794,
0.2044239193201065,
0.3137289583683014,
0.05104608088731766,
0.1744442880153656,
-0.32936379313468933,
-0.5075941681861877,
-0.40912044048309326,
-0.7480602264404297,
0.03931533172726631,
-0.00787261500954628,
-0.42695748805999756,
0.42031511664390564,
-0.28499478101730347,
-0.3855384886264801,
-0.21308642625808716,
-0.26097750663757324,
-0.699944794178009,
0.2452792227268219,
0.2148628830909729,
0.33818450570106506,
-0.7571651339530945,
0.4065423309803009,
0.697441041469574,
-0.7553867101669312,
-0.551602840423584,
0.033743564039468765,
-0.18206100165843964,
-0.37811022996902466,
0.6911306381225586,
0.37599825859069824,
-0.08134926855564117,
-0.32845500111579895,
-0.5986592173576355,
-0.7142069339752197,
1.20698881149292,
0.125379279255867,
-0.640066921710968,
0.28713366389274597,
0.2293200045824051,
0.4803508520126343,
-0.9693613648414612,
0.1859743595123291,
0.15571328997612,
0.6401232481002808,
0.20753531157970428,
-0.9998077750205994,
0.19329802691936493,
-0.536217212677002,
0.28678932785987854,
0.05358954519033432,
-0.5117552280426025,
0.9019013047218323,
0.14419035613536835,
-0.39954423904418945,
0.18126064538955688,
0.012994988821446896,
0.10027254372835159,
0.11711663007736206,
0.4308687746524811,
0.6801281571388245,
0.31070804595947266,
0.19594116508960724,
1.0382053852081299,
-0.6668712496757507,
0.3525436818599701,
0.9419641494750977,
0.08325286209583282,
0.645137369632721,
0.5269919037818909,
0.2499978244304657,
0.3071982264518738,
0.6106097102165222,
-0.1610608696937561,
0.7108923196792603,
0.051743242889642715,
-0.26060768961906433,
-0.44965651631355286,
-0.09113260358572006,
-0.31810104846954346,
0.2329028993844986,
0.25421571731567383,
-0.8216761946678162,
-0.3724246621131897,
0.33271917700767517,
-0.328230082988739,
-0.02746107615530491,
-0.1797541081905365,
0.8101129531860352,
-0.12753498554229736,
-0.31173115968704224,
0.6363292336463928,
0.13883136212825775,
0.8021190762519836,
-0.2825276255607605,
-0.15312349796295166,
0.030428538098931313,
0.35435912013053894,
-0.05139986053109169,
-0.14887084066867828,
-0.012618080712854862,
-0.47027894854545593,
-0.27412721514701843,
-0.6571089625358582,
0.5303088426589966,
-0.5819528698921204,
-0.694939911365509,
-0.027408024296164513,
0.246324360370636,
-0.18764348328113556,
-0.020108329132199287,
-0.7760677337646484,
-0.02364959381520748,
0.07667163759469986,
-0.29244765639305115,
-0.01602841354906559,
0.4500316381454468,
-0.2115236222743988,
0.42217203974723816,
0.3846408724784851,
-0.12805801630020142,
0.3496197462081909,
-0.05164806917309761,
0.695180356502533,
-0.34843045473098755,
-0.5560126304626465,
-0.6084025502204895,
0.6621922254562378,
-0.21092522144317627,
-0.517665445804596,
0.7528327107429504,
0.8368866443634033,
1.0320624113082886,
-0.3475901484489441,
0.7698574066162109,
-0.16573208570480347,
-0.04382721707224846,
-0.2815094292163849,
0.5755771398544312,
-0.9306405186653137,
0.18541625142097473,
-0.052053336054086685,
-1.2865188121795654,
-0.2680269181728363,
0.4672609567642212,
0.17831918597221375,
0.10365362465381622,
0.8486407399177551,
1.1179447174072266,
-0.46900317072868347,
-0.014843086712062359,
0.2866014540195465,
0.20537032186985016,
0.25432807207107544,
0.2675251364707947,
0.7007346153259277,
-0.5167030096054077,
0.5558423399925232,
-0.22084498405456543,
-0.24220871925354004,
-0.324840784072876,
-0.8661928772926331,
-0.5969952344894409,
-0.6536699533462524,
-0.4395838677883148,
-0.020620346069335938,
-0.03708755597472191,
0.935067892074585,
0.8540850281715393,
-0.5409152507781982,
-0.2203853577375412,
0.21257448196411133,
-0.33893904089927673,
-0.5065308213233948,
-0.21380797028541565,
-0.0404018759727478,
-0.4732958674430847,
-0.7389865517616272,
0.22490283846855164,
0.5154017806053162,
-0.1291460543870926,
-0.14259682595729828,
0.06795725226402283,
0.05701804906129837,
0.3552773892879486,
0.8296962976455688,
-0.32444339990615845,
-0.9226096868515015,
-0.07542597502470016,
0.11672884225845337,
0.18017679452896118,
0.2200375497341156,
1.1289687156677246,
-0.3940650522708893,
0.8116649389266968,
0.5124266743659973,
0.22080397605895996,
0.6161150932312012,
0.1044301837682724,
0.7113988399505615,
-0.8606375455856323,
0.11370948702096939,
0.06022009998559952,
0.2650797963142395,
0.32045257091522217,
-0.2911496162414551,
0.09427865594625473,
0.05753578618168831,
-0.31544479727745056,
-0.3994332253932953,
0.6692109107971191,
-1.3012388944625854,
-0.46490952372550964,
1.1320459842681885,
0.18965861201286316,
-0.24309472739696503,
0.0394006073474884,
-0.41247519850730896,
0.027631493285298347,
-0.3818097710609436,
0.9631617069244385,
0.45380571484565735,
0.12410566955804825,
-0.06631502509117126,
-0.4344034790992737,
0.378987580537796,
0.14813201129436493,
-0.4517929255962372,
-0.01616222783923149,
0.7595677375793457,
0.37044885754585266,
0.12209723144769669,
0.21246734261512756,
-0.10310642421245575,
0.29774293303489685,
-0.263834685087204,
0.29551947116851807,
-0.2491651475429535,
-0.1491670459508896,
-0.08436387777328491,
0.2589934170246124,
0.02453451417386532,
-0.23199594020843506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13584v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13584v1
|
WinoViz: Probing Visual Properties of Objects Under Different States
| 2024-02-21T07:31:47 | 2024-02-21T07:31:47 |
Woojeong Jin, Tejas Srinivasan, Jesse Thomason, Xiang Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Humans perceive and comprehend different visual properties of an object based
on specific contexts. For instance, we know that a banana turns brown ``when it
becomes rotten,'' whereas it appears green ``when it is unripe.'' Previous
studies on probing visual commonsense knowledge have primarily focused on
examining language models' understanding of typical properties (e.g., colors
and shapes) of objects. We present WinoViz, a text-only evaluation dataset,
consisting of 1,380 examples that probe the reasoning abilities of language
models regarding variant visual properties of objects under different contexts
or states. Our task is challenging since it requires pragmatic reasoning
(finding intended meanings) and visual knowledge reasoning. We also present
multi-hop data, a more challenging version of our data, which requires
multi-step reasoning chains to solve our task. In our experimental analysis,
our findings are: a) Large language models such as GPT-4 demonstrate effective
performance, but when it comes to multi-hop data, their performance is
significantly degraded. b) Large models perform well on pragmatic reasoning,
but visual knowledge reasoning is a bottleneck in our task. c) Vision-language
models outperform their language-model counterparts. d) A model with
machine-generated images performs poorly in our task. This is due to the poor
quality of the generated images.
|
[
-0.23094864189624786,
-0.7735059261322021,
0.5973477959632874,
-0.04705389216542244,
-0.31327003240585327,
-0.09267730265855789,
-0.1831686943769455,
-0.5592594742774963,
-0.24935850501060486,
0.3209255635738373,
-0.31267935037612915,
-0.41261523962020874,
-0.6122196912765503,
-0.0021290150471031666,
-0.19781950116157532,
0.8605369925498962,
-0.09426241368055344,
0.09973252564668655,
-0.3798847794532776,
-0.25159919261932373,
-0.3514766991138458,
-0.022284355014562607,
-0.23820997774600983,
-0.28093135356903076,
0.4233096241950989,
0.4372290074825287,
0.955744206905365,
0.36251673102378845,
0.6611394286155701,
0.39652273058891296,
-0.07329484075307846,
0.06138063967227936,
-0.5421662926673889,
0.07115088403224945,
-0.44096624851226807,
-0.6626656651496887,
-0.0886770561337471,
0.12985318899154663,
0.2300770878791809,
0.5969287753105164,
-0.047112300992012024,
0.19256095588207245,
-0.1635497361421585,
0.5826005935668945,
-0.648026168346405,
0.2485247105360031,
-0.7186931371688843,
0.11405773460865021,
-0.14250972867012024,
-0.07522352784872055,
-0.26469671726226807,
-0.08059080690145493,
0.1741286665201187,
-0.7519837021827698,
0.5019112825393677,
0.1782928854227066,
1.2268738746643066,
0.18853120505809784,
-0.5217021107673645,
0.09068804979324341,
-0.5279534459114075,
0.9791945219039917,
-0.6089746356010437,
0.37649714946746826,
0.38213929533958435,
0.5054098963737488,
-0.19725607335567474,
-0.6577146053314209,
-0.7839078307151794,
-0.4351556599140167,
-0.19258175790309906,
0.23113378882408142,
-0.28931280970573425,
-0.1027602106332779,
0.3559289574623108,
0.1849673092365265,
-0.5884225964546204,
-0.5324246883392334,
-0.7241873145103455,
-0.37380167841911316,
0.5628158450126648,
0.11844754964113235,
0.5205184817314148,
-0.40325024724006653,
-0.5732665657997131,
-0.4057115614414215,
-0.4625895321369171,
0.16113467514514923,
0.4163120687007904,
0.08956147730350494,
0.1471814513206482,
0.6855942606925964,
-0.32536303997039795,
1.0803254842758179,
-0.5045039057731628,
-0.3157544732093811,
0.3867502510547638,
-0.3534538745880127,
-0.3889184594154358,
-0.5382093787193298,
0.7278096675872803,
0.660687267780304,
0.39567404985427856,
-0.15715360641479492,
-0.17273664474487305,
0.2086341232061386,
0.2408163994550705,
-0.5585054159164429,
-0.5169105529785156,
0.17194733023643494,
-0.44855472445487976,
-0.24040527641773224,
0.051228009164333344,
-0.6404929757118225,
-0.3390357494354248,
-0.5131064057350159,
0.7633346319198608,
-0.7011378407478333,
-0.35884392261505127,
0.24217365682125092,
-0.5913386940956116,
0.31502318382263184,
0.7021417617797852,
-0.6662887334823608,
0.1504625678062439,
0.3586694002151489,
0.7676277756690979,
-0.23708783090114594,
-0.801075279712677,
-0.2251795381307602,
-0.12380260229110718,
-0.543578028678894,
1.0742279291152954,
-0.6847490668296814,
0.021184179931879044,
-0.5035975575447083,
0.11906520277261734,
-0.014570819213986397,
-0.5374158024787903,
0.06170690804719925,
-0.33435869216918945,
-0.10075999051332474,
-0.5063653588294983,
-0.07228908687829971,
-0.44821998476982117,
0.46325376629829407,
-0.7073743939399719,
0.9539810419082642,
0.24356627464294434,
-1.1181226968765259,
0.8438224196434021,
-0.5244320631027222,
-0.42765524983406067,
0.06706202775239944,
-0.4949997067451477,
-0.1744275838136673,
0.21915027499198914,
0.23857764899730682,
0.511345624923706,
-0.17904864251613617,
0.4342091381549835,
-0.3990950286388397,
-0.42734846472740173,
0.23304612934589386,
-0.37564247846603394,
0.7007880806922913,
0.4000988304615021,
-0.32214730978012085,
0.4110695719718933,
-0.6534784436225891,
-0.13424168527126312,
0.4771285355091095,
-0.1887173056602478,
-0.3199306130409241,
0.23573487997055054,
0.0170744676142931,
0.10128989815711975,
0.16395054757595062,
-0.6355665326118469,
0.2744421064853668,
-0.08615124225616455,
0.1911177933216095,
0.6086357235908508,
-0.06820829957723618,
0.20015329122543335,
-0.20168238878250122,
0.4390135407447815,
0.40174102783203125,
0.35442039370536804,
-0.04240111634135246,
-0.6781471967697144,
-0.6974182724952698,
-0.0353102944791317,
-0.20364074409008026,
0.5920786261558533,
-1.1104377508163452,
-0.5485869646072388,
-0.09507083147764206,
-0.5185530781745911,
-0.34945148229599,
0.08842594921588898,
0.3022197186946869,
0.6038485765457153,
0.3625854253768921,
-0.10742506384849548,
-0.09151522815227509,
-1.1281805038452148,
-0.5045821070671082,
-0.07652263343334198,
-0.02966013364493847,
0.4556067883968353,
0.9100886583328247,
-0.08351656794548035,
0.7852563858032227,
-0.6845900416374207,
0.08672407269477844,
-0.2918039560317993,
0.30212339758872986,
0.27562618255615234,
0.260733038187027,
0.5783109068870544,
-0.996105968952179,
-0.14631004631519318,
0.22590778768062592,
-0.8344845175743103,
0.3326091170310974,
0.07271993160247803,
-0.1121026948094368,
-0.14438486099243164,
0.31207194924354553,
-0.31070053577423096,
0.6640530824661255,
0.6339734196662903,
-0.6633031368255615,
0.7149532437324524,
-0.4727001488208771,
0.5828821659088135,
-0.7069757580757141,
0.08948688209056854,
0.20318830013275146,
-0.12462341785430908,
-0.6824127435684204,
0.0392456017434597,
0.12178381532430649,
-0.25884395837783813,
-0.641409695148468,
0.48082712292671204,
-0.5406864881515503,
-0.4060478210449219,
-0.08846621215343475,
0.05615171790122986,
0.09443125873804092,
0.6018221378326416,
0.23782840371131897,
0.7876319885253906,
0.9089480638504028,
-0.5344204306602478,
0.731155514717102,
-0.09263438731431961,
-0.6710890531539917,
0.6519401669502258,
-0.6620698571205139,
-0.12848897278308868,
-0.41580039262771606,
-0.30602920055389404,
-1.1025761365890503,
-0.42264506220817566,
0.09851369261741638,
-0.47174280881881714,
0.19953754544258118,
-0.1845633089542389,
-0.5611857771873474,
-0.24645593762397766,
-0.19269929826259613,
0.5139732360839844,
0.06813094019889832,
-0.45390602946281433,
0.3512578010559082,
0.22121058404445648,
0.0014764495426788926,
-0.7342982888221741,
-0.7160382270812988,
0.11412185430526733,
-0.21642610430717468,
-0.722308874130249,
-0.04163457453250885,
0.0020037959329783916,
-0.4803985059261322,
0.04519788548350334,
-0.007202741224318743,
-0.061462193727493286,
0.052585169672966,
0.09796056151390076,
0.27301672101020813,
-0.055605556815862656,
0.1438884437084198,
-0.13295190036296844,
0.21452009677886963,
-0.15311796963214874,
-0.14576192200183868,
0.15414971113204956,
-0.5756910443305969,
-0.3529338538646698,
-0.09159977734088898,
0.2536497712135315,
0.6049379706382751,
-0.39876243472099304,
0.6546783447265625,
0.472133070230484,
-0.39325061440467834,
-0.24909570813179016,
-0.3320310413837433,
-0.04312817007303238,
-0.44290784001350403,
0.3493625819683075,
-0.5683994293212891,
-0.5652289986610413,
0.5674644112586975,
0.16149169206619263,
-0.174801766872406,
0.37583813071250916,
0.33812811970710754,
-0.18398113548755646,
0.8199387788772583,
0.5509714484214783,
0.28132373094558716,
0.3958500921726227,
-0.3537130057811737,
0.07950200140476227,
-0.6444606781005859,
-0.6720080375671387,
-0.28734710812568665,
-0.25688183307647705,
-0.48742371797561646,
-0.6700822710990906,
0.2635639011859894,
0.10539321601390839,
-0.1391124725341797,
0.46154001355171204,
-0.4747636318206787,
0.5223133563995361,
0.5633940100669861,
0.45121654868125916,
0.23398464918136597,
0.05390241742134094,
-0.15639328956604004,
-0.10190459340810776,
-0.6891601085662842,
-0.3393498361110687,
0.9791629910469055,
0.22892823815345764,
1.046865463256836,
-0.07666249573230743,
0.21594148874282837,
0.15730081498622894,
0.35364893078804016,
-0.6993006467819214,
0.5201613306999207,
0.08055636286735535,
-0.7749638557434082,
-0.35311105847358704,
-0.6636931300163269,
-0.8479489088058472,
0.6518509984016418,
-0.126267209649086,
-0.9717119932174683,
0.30991291999816895,
0.5094709396362305,
0.2027353048324585,
0.45378270745277405,
-0.829258143901825,
1.3381006717681885,
-0.5915727615356445,
-0.5773836970329285,
0.08645898848772049,
-0.48673316836357117,
0.45046940445899963,
0.4502639174461365,
0.25960445404052734,
-0.07925376296043396,
0.06803333759307861,
0.7153346538543701,
-0.1783618927001953,
0.5724402666091919,
-0.2481383979320526,
-0.11606712639331818,
0.4265470504760742,
0.34817230701446533,
0.30903545022010803,
-0.08164741843938828,
0.3007713854312897,
0.15539990365505219,
0.04756456986069679,
-0.5775713324546814,
-0.6560792326927185,
0.49178189039230347,
-0.5355507135391235,
-0.3265012502670288,
-0.41478803753852844,
-0.6216424107551575,
-0.25084084272384644,
0.3042755722999573,
0.40168139338493347,
0.4811439514160156,
-0.013568882830440998,
-0.025218594819307327,
0.4516189396381378,
-0.36310622096061707,
0.21354138851165771,
0.1757650375366211,
-0.30009153485298157,
-0.03762562945485115,
1.2856717109680176,
-0.011275045573711395,
0.23970898985862732,
0.17955827713012695,
0.37000346183776855,
-0.18332718312740326,
-0.7020474076271057,
-0.45699283480644226,
0.20982234179973602,
-0.9355748891830444,
-0.19840675592422485,
-0.30616438388824463,
0.3630760610103607,
-0.24237094819545746,
0.09560565650463104,
-0.41913145780563354,
-0.12834273278713226,
-0.2210070937871933,
-0.2153068631887436,
0.39885127544403076,
0.8865015506744385,
-0.0844360888004303,
-0.097640261054039,
-0.35532617568969727,
0.559226393699646,
0.5997174382209778,
0.626842200756073,
-0.21477028727531433,
-0.33141306042671204,
0.039962753653526306,
-0.05516965314745903,
-0.052677370607852936,
-1.1968693733215332,
0.36923444271087646,
-0.020244905725121498,
0.6889112591743469,
0.577640175819397,
-0.23506268858909607,
0.5098198056221008,
-0.31928882002830505,
0.7536003589630127,
0.22416971623897552,
-0.7150671482086182,
0.891741931438446,
-0.6689306497573853,
0.25944751501083374,
0.4750973880290985,
0.33478832244873047,
-0.30522677302360535,
-0.4940685033798218,
-0.483307421207428,
-0.6595393419265747,
0.6683302521705627,
0.3247491717338562,
-0.18771594762802124,
0.01581731252372265,
0.045394860208034515,
0.058053746819496155,
0.2955127954483032,
-0.7282158136367798,
-0.046520255506038666,
-0.6112838387489319,
-0.02951805852353573,
-0.21503570675849915,
-0.04689786955714226,
-0.25846633315086365,
-0.21089302003383636,
0.12330705672502518,
-0.2814493179321289,
0.3130702078342438,
0.32566359639167786,
-0.2989819347858429,
0.13317853212356567,
0.3220270872116089,
0.7412081956863403,
1.0817973613739014,
-0.28227657079696655,
0.3686947822570801,
0.06514117121696472,
-0.4168970286846161,
-0.03777068853378296,
-0.13309182226657867,
-0.0867258757352829,
-0.13508886098861694,
0.5552865266799927,
0.9492713212966919,
0.02093321457505226,
-0.8098511099815369,
0.7707267999649048,
-0.15712648630142212,
-0.4327571988105774,
0.07976540923118591,
0.32769936323165894,
-0.003911642823368311,
0.3040178418159485,
0.25398311018943787,
0.2560105323791504,
0.36450859904289246,
-0.6782734394073486,
0.12328387051820755,
0.49911928176879883,
-0.2393130511045456,
-0.3173201084136963,
0.47968825697898865,
-0.12996189296245575,
0.0672995001077652,
0.5597314238548279,
-0.31814250349998474,
-0.6115056276321411,
0.8429263830184937,
0.4069739580154419,
0.2585192024707794,
0.06114736199378967,
0.44489428400993347,
0.381822407245636,
0.5812363624572754,
-0.21842579543590546,
0.5210124254226685,
-0.2637171447277069,
-0.9576416015625,
-0.3018476665019989,
-0.46925631165504456,
-0.2996014654636383,
0.12753121554851532,
-0.6783952116966248,
-0.20574648678302765,
-0.24600732326507568,
-0.07300592213869095,
-0.286577045917511,
-0.30070891976356506,
-0.9897527694702148,
0.5181871056556702,
-0.03909420594573021,
0.8169805407524109,
-1.1364736557006836,
0.4972066581249237,
0.7649890184402466,
-0.35107558965682983,
-0.6098528504371643,
-0.2730945646762848,
0.03313685953617096,
-0.5993884801864624,
0.8377342224121094,
0.12823213636875153,
-0.38432955741882324,
-0.3586971163749695,
-1.0191798210144043,
-0.7346152067184448,
1.0032165050506592,
0.46976104378700256,
-0.3348495662212372,
0.24302583932876587,
-0.1941215544939041,
0.5021560788154602,
-0.026492392644286156,
0.1852412074804306,
0.6120771169662476,
0.6289133429527283,
0.11376741528511047,
-0.8310383558273315,
-0.11232972890138626,
-0.41293609142303467,
0.05365514010190964,
0.10604362189769745,
-0.553730309009552,
0.8451765775680542,
-0.7434389591217041,
-0.37768039107322693,
-0.4687880277633667,
0.7000828981399536,
0.18294347822666168,
0.36940014362335205,
0.4707496464252472,
0.6823665499687195,
0.659183919429779,
-0.21144002676010132,
1.1980959177017212,
0.22602541744709015,
0.6111822724342346,
0.8998157978057861,
0.06652072072029114,
0.768688976764679,
0.6214768886566162,
-0.19756649434566498,
0.2310214340686798,
0.4856685400009155,
-0.26124244928359985,
0.5099251866340637,
0.42091065645217896,
0.08072766661643982,
-0.228823721408844,
0.1260448545217514,
-0.05009080842137337,
0.683090329170227,
0.24045781791210175,
-0.02170555293560028,
-0.11058793216943741,
0.3603403866291046,
-0.055147770792245865,
0.00833644438534975,
-0.2435157150030136,
0.5359920263290405,
-0.2702591121196747,
-0.7023414373397827,
0.364277720451355,
-0.039408985525369644,
0.4845289885997772,
-0.3975527584552765,
-0.20365190505981445,
-0.4209587275981903,
-0.008813015185296535,
-0.08420957624912262,
-0.9664400815963745,
0.180270716547966,
0.1413421928882599,
0.07325007766485214,
-0.022148754447698593,
0.7593817710876465,
-0.2707807421684265,
-0.6532877683639526,
0.334197461605072,
0.38891249895095825,
0.39609265327453613,
-0.07303815335035324,
-0.6776531934738159,
0.1430625319480896,
0.04228246212005615,
-0.50998854637146,
0.07611976563930511,
0.48034197092056274,
0.13457515835762024,
0.8931413292884827,
0.4926678240299225,
0.3311413824558258,
0.16530294716358185,
0.050594404339790344,
0.8145166039466858,
-0.8635466694831848,
-0.1247132197022438,
-0.5634428858757019,
0.5977256894111633,
-0.13259156048297882,
-0.35996735095977783,
0.6061050295829773,
0.4322861135005951,
1.1301441192626953,
-0.2622778117656708,
0.6812704205513,
-0.05796635150909424,
0.08431994915008545,
-0.7374841570854187,
0.7203174829483032,
-0.934073269367218,
-0.18126560747623444,
-0.5156858563423157,
-0.7267988324165344,
-0.25292396545410156,
0.9368880987167358,
-0.3105272352695465,
0.11886171996593475,
0.7207961082458496,
0.8033549785614014,
-0.281316876411438,
-0.3529062271118164,
0.5437723398208618,
0.10643760859966278,
0.33207690715789795,
0.5651851892471313,
1.0002336502075195,
-0.29576846957206726,
0.7195687294006348,
-0.3905028700828552,
-0.3545209467411041,
0.0037701569963246584,
-0.964144766330719,
-0.9869980216026306,
-0.6432094573974609,
-0.202440083026886,
-0.02112552896142006,
-0.0023528875317424536,
0.12136906385421753,
0.7465715408325195,
-0.5138921737670898,
-0.10088996589183807,
-0.163460835814476,
0.12511996924877167,
-0.32161492109298706,
-0.22276510298252106,
0.388516902923584,
-0.11196141690015793,
-0.489250510931015,
0.42445316910743713,
0.36766624450683594,
0.11903809756040573,
-0.11816377192735672,
0.08886174857616425,
0.04244062677025795,
-0.19165313243865967,
0.5173647403717041,
0.2107919305562973,
-0.685578465461731,
-0.33029094338417053,
0.03544289618730545,
0.004310526419430971,
0.1820983588695526,
0.9302300214767456,
-0.7445653676986694,
0.8921213150024414,
0.8562147617340088,
0.22387149930000305,
0.6158119440078735,
0.03204846754670143,
0.3178369700908661,
-0.4327694773674011,
0.274992436170578,
0.13808733224868774,
0.6904469132423401,
0.5240886807441711,
-0.212646022439003,
0.21799235045909882,
0.3148709237575531,
-0.3182564675807953,
-0.4861454367637634,
0.37775325775146484,
-0.9155652523040771,
-0.6752902269363403,
0.9959855675697327,
-0.1865711659193039,
-0.45562487840652466,
0.14410501718521118,
-0.3608032763004303,
0.08807062357664108,
-0.2563301920890808,
0.44859376549720764,
0.6425948739051819,
-0.3573016822338104,
-0.5368069410324097,
-0.8865081667900085,
0.4517584443092346,
0.12541742622852325,
-0.9919920563697815,
-0.023116860538721085,
0.6253007054328918,
0.4875916838645935,
0.18515385687351227,
0.5055620074272156,
-0.05948483943939209,
0.3905356824398041,
0.4062483608722687,
-0.165929913520813,
-0.33017146587371826,
-0.9107354283332825,
-0.08214040845632553,
0.2342837154865265,
0.03376210480928421,
-0.3310532569885254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13583v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13583v2
|
LongWanjuan: Towards Systematic Measurement for Long Text Quality
| 2024-02-21T07:27:18 | 2024-02-22T03:06:55 |
Kai Lv, Xiaoran Liu, Qipeng Guo, Hang Yan, Conghui He, Xipeng Qiu, Dahua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The quality of training data are crucial for enhancing the long-text
capabilities of foundation models. Despite existing efforts to refine data
quality through heuristic rules and evaluations based on data diversity and
difficulty, there's a lack of systematic approaches specifically tailored for
assessing long texts. Addressing this gap, our work systematically measures the
quality of long texts by evaluating three fundamental linguistic dimensions:
coherence, cohesion, and complexity. Drawing inspiration from the
aforementioned three dimensions, we introduce a suite of metrics designed to
evaluate the quality of long texts, encompassing both statistical and
pre-trained language model-based ones. Leveraging these metrics, we present
LongWanjuan, a bilingual dataset specifically tailored to enhance the training
of language models for long-text tasks with over 160B tokens. In LongWanjuan,
we categorize long texts into holistic, aggregated, and chaotic types, enabling
a detailed analysis of long-text quality. Furthermore, we devise a data mixture
recipe that strategically balances different types of long texts within
LongWanjuan, leading to significant improvements in model performance on
long-text tasks. The code and dataset are available at
https://github.com/OpenLMLab/LongWanjuan.
|
[
-0.3761714994907379,
-0.7476766705513,
0.19099897146224976,
0.7850956916809082,
-0.48913127183914185,
0.14247415959835052,
-0.47531241178512573,
-0.6817872524261475,
0.5515897274017334,
0.7874733805656433,
-0.05716544762253761,
-0.6398446559906006,
-0.48822200298309326,
0.1730692833662033,
-0.6485715508460999,
1.3647809028625488,
-0.5906937122344971,
-0.10937979817390442,
-0.12839238345623016,
-0.48148107528686523,
-0.34412872791290283,
-0.28293946385383606,
-0.580230176448822,
-0.440830260515213,
0.7400554418563843,
0.27427467703819275,
0.7785273194313049,
0.5778675675392151,
0.5747142434120178,
0.1969306319952011,
-0.09017247706651688,
0.11705508828163147,
-0.6118412613868713,
0.0992351844906807,
-0.4135306179523468,
-0.3459152281284332,
-0.8589543700218201,
-0.0972265750169754,
0.7059348225593567,
0.9934581518173218,
-0.2123333215713501,
0.2506135404109955,
0.3889763653278351,
0.9139094948768616,
-0.39836856722831726,
0.27811071276664734,
0.19388671219348907,
-0.02248932234942913,
-0.5850204825401306,
0.16395308077335358,
0.09355618804693222,
-0.5215967893600464,
-0.03155949339270592,
-0.5663474202156067,
0.15794479846954346,
0.07718751579523087,
0.8461465835571289,
-0.0036269233096390963,
-0.7141295671463013,
-0.50428307056427,
-0.6375266909599304,
0.9761256575584412,
-0.5857259631156921,
0.5053871870040894,
0.7183694243431091,
0.3686504065990448,
-0.19901518523693085,
-0.5372141003608704,
-0.8016361594200134,
-0.1599959135055542,
-0.12364045530557632,
0.3151092827320099,
0.34471967816352844,
0.08708076179027557,
0.028373707085847855,
0.7909851670265198,
-0.8316996097564697,
0.23493778705596924,
-0.3449152410030365,
-0.0010234768269583583,
0.8563671708106995,
0.20506879687309265,
0.34788811206817627,
-0.4130800664424896,
-0.37341392040252686,
-0.18949295580387115,
-0.2667314410209656,
0.29672884941101074,
0.7487913370132446,
0.09986328333616257,
-0.1901140660047531,
0.5251573324203491,
-0.5114937424659729,
0.7303049564361572,
-0.255463182926178,
-0.5920342803001404,
0.23794220387935638,
-0.7220106720924377,
-0.2658124268054962,
-0.19899049401283264,
1.1171971559524536,
0.03815625235438347,
0.1341230720281601,
-0.12560687959194183,
-0.4226410984992981,
-0.25697386264801025,
0.16933473944664001,
-0.7731021046638489,
-0.05640565603971481,
0.38536638021469116,
-0.4138564169406891,
-0.26461106538772583,
0.08580754697322845,
-0.9623187184333801,
-0.09639886766672134,
-0.49915611743927,
0.29345911741256714,
-0.5634692907333374,
-0.5390763282775879,
0.5431704521179199,
0.013924035243690014,
-0.09787308424711227,
0.23469015955924988,
-1.0358502864837646,
0.41927772760391235,
0.9723013043403625,
0.8984594941139221,
-0.5000417232513428,
-0.5791606903076172,
-0.12784919142723083,
0.09741905331611633,
-0.6172024607658386,
0.28275206685066223,
0.00378408539108932,
-0.2544836103916168,
-0.01364385150372982,
-0.11786222457885742,
0.20718784630298615,
-0.5623013377189636,
1.0032812356948853,
-0.44496315717697144,
0.304240882396698,
-0.11380258202552795,
-0.42082133889198303,
-0.31556519865989685,
0.531893253326416,
-0.9644442200660706,
1.399500846862793,
0.45463934540748596,
-0.7801589369773865,
0.5099177956581116,
-0.5533972382545471,
-0.6748455762863159,
-0.059017885476350784,
0.014451783150434494,
-0.4839887320995331,
0.07807503640651703,
0.29988813400268555,
0.6875626444816589,
-0.5405133962631226,
0.7472862005233765,
-0.12861290574073792,
-0.2715911865234375,
0.1027921736240387,
-0.29493460059165955,
0.7735032439231873,
0.14984840154647827,
-0.06482481211423874,
0.13047760725021362,
-1.1643767356872559,
0.05938588082790375,
-0.012743202038109303,
-0.32345491647720337,
-0.6870444416999817,
-0.15080401301383972,
0.15456600487232208,
0.06575951725244522,
0.14414936304092407,
-0.4144536256790161,
-0.13182324171066284,
-0.5637989044189453,
0.1533682942390442,
0.2708010673522949,
-0.28189289569854736,
0.3828142285346985,
-0.3799079656600952,
0.28714242577552795,
0.18241643905639648,
0.10844399034976959,
-0.11741508543491364,
-0.1709073781967163,
-0.933853805065155,
-0.5207300782203674,
0.2391669899225235,
0.1855747401714325,
-0.7377211451530457,
0.890251636505127,
-0.9733393788337708,
-0.6516902446746826,
-0.20710048079490662,
0.4338070750236511,
0.1063351035118103,
0.1628035306930542,
0.4773366153240204,
-0.7131713628768921,
-0.2905752956867218,
-0.7300142645835876,
-0.1860186904668808,
-0.15056689083576202,
0.02428201586008072,
-0.26722201704978943,
0.8899160623550415,
-0.27629324793815613,
0.9543712139129639,
-0.036715246737003326,
-0.2784014046192169,
-0.3835984468460083,
0.3062158524990082,
0.6144089102745056,
0.5249806046485901,
0.5339494943618774,
-0.3692198395729065,
-0.5194060802459717,
0.18809589743614197,
-0.8818788528442383,
0.09085983783006668,
-0.18976838886737823,
-0.35912150144577026,
-0.11509258300065994,
0.3154580891132355,
-0.6656941175460815,
0.2072160392999649,
0.8385355472564697,
-0.0570906363427639,
0.5045424699783325,
0.08058196306228638,
0.38119393587112427,
-1.252477765083313,
0.13948892056941986,
-0.1232747808098793,
-0.2022085338830948,
-0.7046733498573303,
0.32322555780410767,
0.18458202481269836,
-0.1138562560081482,
-0.10420689731836319,
0.6675589680671692,
-0.23035715520381927,
0.09706821292638779,
-0.09901174157857895,
0.0530676394701004,
0.39180076122283936,
0.3629559278488159,
-0.1474161595106125,
0.6813158988952637,
0.21488581597805023,
-0.4221722185611725,
0.7970486879348755,
0.132139191031456,
-0.9335221648216248,
0.9069710969924927,
-0.934127688407898,
-0.11344726383686066,
-0.1658967137336731,
0.4610276222229004,
-0.8319998979568481,
-0.6667059659957886,
0.16160105168819427,
-0.2281402051448822,
0.4576382040977478,
0.005698706489056349,
-0.7074015140533447,
-0.35556042194366455,
-0.2870422899723053,
0.7541248798370361,
0.1679019182920456,
-0.7685058116912842,
0.3972308039665222,
-0.0018666506512090564,
-0.14831288158893585,
-0.6012498736381531,
-0.7892370820045471,
0.3396172523498535,
-0.07815950363874435,
-0.8911976218223572,
0.17116829752922058,
0.3219076097011566,
-0.06666924059391022,
-0.27931466698646545,
0.018993310630321503,
-0.32897213101387024,
0.05745426565408707,
0.19628536701202393,
-0.19511352479457855,
-0.333905428647995,
-0.03307262808084488,
0.402060329914093,
-0.05861487239599228,
0.24939188361167908,
-0.40018799901008606,
0.4627441465854645,
0.20104371011257172,
-0.48819613456726074,
-0.3338170349597931,
0.504783570766449,
0.5171952843666077,
-0.4164537191390991,
0.8768249154090881,
0.7878086566925049,
-0.3561892509460449,
-0.33576059341430664,
-0.32496750354766846,
0.4622371196746826,
-0.4441331624984741,
0.6160187125205994,
-0.2791781425476074,
-0.786803662776947,
0.49544987082481384,
0.18996168673038483,
-0.04414774104952812,
0.4686841368675232,
0.2602858543395996,
-0.15989121794700623,
0.7329778075218201,
0.5426837801933289,
-0.2585693895816803,
0.2837289869785309,
-0.23755888640880585,
0.36345458030700684,
-0.45939385890960693,
-0.2807850241661072,
-0.5340033173561096,
-0.1168442815542221,
-0.3714197278022766,
-0.6080948114395142,
0.11809343099594116,
0.5704801678657532,
-0.571459174156189,
0.1831711381673813,
-0.059526197612285614,
0.5010207295417786,
0.26538601517677307,
0.046529486775398254,
0.2615431249141693,
0.11609519273042679,
0.22940659523010254,
-0.13762284815311432,
-0.2851811647415161,
-0.47446152567863464,
0.8615759611129761,
0.7677674293518066,
1.0105032920837402,
0.270106703042984,
0.9961873292922974,
-0.268382728099823,
0.15353377163410187,
-0.8187519907951355,
0.39847779273986816,
-0.07387012988328934,
-0.638882040977478,
-0.4539833068847656,
-0.7829233407974243,
-0.9051439762115479,
-0.16679370403289795,
0.16551245748996735,
-0.2750279903411865,
-0.09010259062051773,
-0.406792551279068,
-0.10133326053619385,
0.15896275639533997,
-0.24373109638690948,
0.8065879940986633,
-0.5726251006126404,
-0.2842676043510437,
-0.33897438645362854,
-0.4086487591266632,
0.5318856835365295,
-0.39763492345809937,
0.056850772351026535,
-0.22155414521694183,
-0.0024928159546107054,
1.0656300783157349,
-0.36081087589263916,
0.7661182284355164,
0.28414174914360046,
-0.5041602253913879,
0.27732715010643005,
0.11108662188053131,
0.45427778363227844,
0.3431681990623474,
-0.0751401036977768,
0.5455811619758606,
0.14226439595222473,
-0.8225694298744202,
-0.7704470753669739,
0.7183790802955627,
-0.9984138607978821,
-0.06177325174212456,
-0.40247514843940735,
-0.24920782446861267,
-0.253082811832428,
0.38287803530693054,
0.0882146954536438,
0.3316534459590912,
-0.45539581775665283,
0.27621138095855713,
0.4864550530910492,
-0.3909897208213806,
0.3030136227607727,
-0.0680045336484909,
-0.6255331039428711,
-0.7211482524871826,
1.0313338041305542,
0.146025151014328,
0.3684580624103546,
0.300462931394577,
0.036268625408411026,
-0.1756809800863266,
-0.670373260974884,
-0.4165581464767456,
0.1536339819431305,
-0.7029266953468323,
-0.1718115210533142,
-0.5033944249153137,
-0.37210822105407715,
-0.08677660673856735,
0.00427610520273447,
-0.5554699301719666,
-0.2710903286933899,
-0.27683988213539124,
-0.042220089584589005,
0.21732835471630096,
0.6838931441307068,
0.18163476884365082,
0.4170339107513428,
-0.9632911682128906,
0.5239064693450928,
0.3415074944496155,
0.9490054845809937,
-0.0023395465686917305,
-0.5316824913024902,
-0.753423273563385,
0.2200450301170349,
0.0005370838334783912,
-0.44678860902786255,
0.41449666023254395,
0.17601150274276733,
0.2961326241493225,
0.29947763681411743,
-0.3052452504634857,
0.6200510859489441,
-0.1570979356765747,
1.0614877939224243,
0.554375171661377,
-1.0143134593963623,
0.4943608343601227,
-0.6037659049034119,
0.10385522991418839,
0.7313344478607178,
0.5098351240158081,
-0.7199500203132629,
-0.3330124616622925,
-0.023097585886716843,
-0.7105453610420227,
0.2706507742404938,
0.21525074541568756,
0.27828747034072876,
0.020719477906823158,
0.4198598265647888,
0.4787849187850952,
0.07110723108053207,
-0.6870971918106079,
-0.0012031893711537123,
-0.6793656945228577,
-0.5739390850067139,
-0.43268120288848877,
-0.4956243634223938,
-0.3153907060623169,
-0.2608222961425781,
0.34570881724357605,
-0.05646524950861931,
-0.15532726049423218,
-0.13166362047195435,
-0.22976376116275787,
0.12983398139476776,
0.2805149257183075,
0.4762207269668579,
0.8596415519714355,
-0.09075509756803513,
0.0022856451105326414,
0.027427781373262405,
-0.776181697845459,
0.34322860836982727,
-0.10424710065126419,
0.1491357684135437,
0.20718823373317719,
0.7009190917015076,
0.7835531234741211,
-0.1370052546262741,
-0.26886481046676636,
0.5697716474533081,
-0.01051277108490467,
-0.11025042831897736,
-0.27820345759391785,
0.1529083102941513,
-0.16859708726406097,
-0.10560520738363266,
0.13689741492271423,
-0.12168934941291809,
-0.13029761612415314,
-0.4334847331047058,
0.014185871928930283,
-0.12975771725177765,
-0.44162842631340027,
-0.49666789174079895,
0.29781925678253174,
0.48320114612579346,
-0.024153470993041992,
0.7016122937202454,
-0.13725392520427704,
-0.34181198477745056,
0.37902286648750305,
0.3765729069709778,
0.6521050930023193,
-0.06217508018016815,
0.25465846061706543,
0.6894292831420898,
0.32953429222106934,
-0.648851752281189,
0.19994547963142395,
0.17654404044151306,
-0.5178928971290588,
-0.7591769695281982,
-0.9194850921630859,
-0.2165985256433487,
0.07462246716022491,
-0.7460360527038574,
0.34539493918418884,
-0.4249415397644043,
-0.06742828339338303,
-0.4094841778278351,
0.2837955355644226,
-0.6638232469558716,
0.4530535936355591,
-0.16021446883678436,
0.7997863292694092,
-0.6957578063011169,
0.906571090221405,
0.23800161480903625,
-0.42528271675109863,
-0.5051838755607605,
-0.05818938836455345,
-0.3159644305706024,
-0.5111780166625977,
0.682120680809021,
0.25602325797080994,
0.04424445331096649,
-0.4204026460647583,
-0.3425559997558594,
-0.8770482540130615,
0.8945095539093018,
0.27134019136428833,
-0.6568583250045776,
0.0859881043434143,
0.7045160531997681,
0.9172139167785645,
0.14523033797740936,
0.11825564503669739,
0.661089301109314,
0.3918764591217041,
-0.5029284954071045,
-1.1244227886199951,
-0.17090263962745667,
-0.16399064660072327,
0.019160646945238113,
0.6015580892562866,
-0.62019282579422,
0.596866250038147,
0.2872380018234253,
-0.26260751485824585,
0.24381530284881592,
1.185328483581543,
-0.12896288931369781,
0.3279019296169281,
0.3571319282054901,
0.7354710102081299,
0.7075582146644592,
-0.1950889229774475,
0.8978016376495361,
-0.14425663650035858,
0.4654279351234436,
1.024807095527649,
-0.1865675300359726,
0.7564074993133545,
0.4102734923362732,
-0.28331297636032104,
0.4006894826889038,
0.6128413081169128,
0.35995808243751526,
0.22100940346717834,
0.37181800603866577,
-0.2654695212841034,
0.006313708145171404,
0.02080952748656273,
-0.3447624146938324,
0.45034700632095337,
0.3654208183288574,
-0.08741778880357742,
-0.1409815102815628,
0.11319869011640549,
-0.09188058972358704,
0.16661980748176575,
-0.09582098573446274,
0.4898744821548462,
0.1674431562423706,
-0.5953831672668457,
0.7297226786613464,
0.10407780855894089,
0.814551591873169,
-0.505064070224762,
0.3130302429199219,
-0.668704092502594,
0.0869501605629921,
-0.29832911491394043,
-1.211029291152954,
0.43211308121681213,
-0.19691812992095947,
-0.17954367399215698,
-0.20806801319122314,
0.18670031428337097,
-0.7381441593170166,
-0.5477628111839294,
0.46397218108177185,
0.42833563685417175,
0.028219694271683693,
0.08639398217201233,
-0.5144524574279785,
0.02574038878083229,
-0.3988756835460663,
-0.11775530129671097,
0.4179264008998871,
0.7040964961051941,
-0.10440221428871155,
0.49994993209838867,
0.611518383026123,
0.20918723940849304,
-0.24935683608055115,
0.3461633324623108,
0.512255847454071,
-0.8999500870704651,
-0.4631110727787018,
-0.7192974090576172,
0.32170751690864563,
-0.23772455751895905,
-0.7025025486946106,
0.7087842226028442,
0.6162944436073303,
0.9709017872810364,
0.29710838198661804,
0.5334481596946716,
0.2530968189239502,
0.680924654006958,
-0.5388092994689941,
0.9048470854759216,
-0.6016517877578735,
0.10557859390974045,
-0.11860190331935883,
-1.1330233812332153,
-0.4813585579395294,
0.364263117313385,
0.07646330446004868,
-0.01777474395930767,
0.6074811220169067,
0.672475278377533,
-0.5308625102043152,
0.07495370507240295,
0.28834959864616394,
-0.041008830070495605,
0.596860945224762,
0.374372661113739,
1.0694915056228638,
-0.6605225801467896,
0.3100709021091461,
-0.2864207327365875,
-0.05999664217233658,
-0.1529163271188736,
-0.73076993227005,
-1.1788808107376099,
-0.6552742123603821,
-0.06662997603416443,
-0.5603354573249817,
0.02448827400803566,
0.8446757793426514,
0.5209957361221313,
-0.760172426700592,
-0.5724939107894897,
0.07275256514549255,
0.10193442553281784,
-0.11112073063850403,
-0.18930771946907043,
0.4229622483253479,
-0.2820161283016205,
-0.5354362726211548,
0.1552005112171173,
0.396476149559021,
0.12375085800886154,
-0.2896307110786438,
-0.15133477747440338,
0.2109241783618927,
0.07526017725467682,
0.8210753202438354,
0.15572470426559448,
-0.46184197068214417,
-0.437686949968338,
-0.08495192229747772,
-0.7228951454162598,
-0.03130175918340683,
0.6995412707328796,
-0.13547587394714355,
0.5871933102607727,
0.755236029624939,
0.6352952718734741,
0.548407793045044,
-0.2732522785663605,
0.5933512449264526,
-0.7164020538330078,
0.25569266080856323,
0.33519452810287476,
0.23291084170341492,
0.3988271951675415,
0.08530141413211823,
0.6100262403488159,
-0.15769298374652863,
-0.5626735687255859,
-0.799812912940979,
0.06652658432722092,
-1.1115950345993042,
0.09835506975650787,
1.1471948623657227,
-0.2758626341819763,
-0.340432345867157,
-0.31156402826309204,
-0.10908015072345734,
0.22535622119903564,
-0.013888037763535976,
0.6861204504966736,
0.9268265962600708,
0.3452962040901184,
0.16025887429714203,
-0.7560535669326782,
0.5178338885307312,
0.472873330116272,
-1.030311942100525,
-0.10656266659498215,
0.30549028515815735,
0.1603073626756668,
0.19121934473514557,
0.4140065014362335,
-0.07089166343212128,
0.16720791161060333,
-0.14315515756607056,
-0.008876926265656948,
0.17951922118663788,
-0.4392496347427368,
-0.3102746307849884,
-0.0016377033898606896,
-0.09259730577468872,
0.20578067004680634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13577v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13577v1
|
BBA: Bi-Modal Behavioral Alignment for Reasoning with Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-02-21T07:16:29 | 2024-02-21T07:16:29 |
Xueliang Zhao, Xinting Huang, Tingchen Fu, Qintong Li, Shansan Gong, Lemao Liu, Wei Bi, Lingpeng Kong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multimodal reasoning stands as a pivotal capability for large vision-language
models (LVLMs). The integration with Domain-Specific Languages (DSL), offering
precise visual representations, equips these models with the opportunity to
execute more accurate reasoning in complex and professional domains. However,
the vanilla Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting method faces challenges in
effectively leveraging the unique strengths of visual and DSL representations,
primarily due to their differing reasoning mechanisms. Additionally, it often
falls short in addressing critical steps in multi-step reasoning tasks. To
mitigate these challenges, we introduce the \underline{B}i-Modal
\underline{B}ehavioral \underline{A}lignment (BBA) prompting method, designed
to maximize the potential of DSL in augmenting complex multi-modal reasoning
tasks. This method initiates by guiding LVLMs to create separate reasoning
chains for visual and DSL representations. Subsequently, it aligns these chains
by addressing any inconsistencies, thus achieving a cohesive integration of
behaviors from different modalities. Our experiments demonstrate that BBA
substantially improves the performance of GPT-4V(ision) on geometry problem
solving ($28.34\% \to 34.22\%$), chess positional advantage prediction
($42.08\% \to 46.99\%$) and molecular property prediction ($77.47\% \to
83.52\%$).
|
[
-0.5588101744651794,
-1.207904577255249,
0.7304022312164307,
0.28854647278785706,
-0.31897425651550293,
0.2099626362323761,
-0.18681542575359344,
-0.4161834120750427,
0.04479909688234329,
0.1768263727426529,
-0.7140020132064819,
-0.4035511910915375,
-0.09373688697814941,
-0.11137808114290237,
0.20232854783535004,
0.7024783492088318,
-0.029194414615631104,
0.32666265964508057,
-0.2889515459537506,
0.03650648891925812,
-1.1367871761322021,
-0.17821639776229858,
-0.34638676047325134,
-0.23428809642791748,
0.6177862286567688,
0.08845401555299759,
0.7118157148361206,
0.2857756018638611,
0.5654025673866272,
0.27561455965042114,
-0.1866624504327774,
0.6906611323356628,
-0.30650386214256287,
0.2869323492050171,
-0.6976019740104675,
-0.21788015961647034,
-0.6526623368263245,
-0.2927023768424988,
0.5020036697387695,
0.5993834137916565,
-0.09899956732988358,
0.14485853910446167,
-0.22368420660495758,
0.8222792744636536,
-0.9178773164749146,
0.2546197772026062,
-0.5436722040176392,
-0.15353065729141235,
-0.1600581854581833,
-0.2715114951133728,
-0.5342732667922974,
-0.2587645351886749,
0.23309777677059174,
-0.5682898163795471,
-0.35483962297439575,
0.3225870132446289,
0.8531452417373657,
0.34025272727012634,
-0.607510507106781,
-0.1366148293018341,
-0.7112079858779907,
0.6671602725982666,
-0.5711066722869873,
0.5844663381576538,
0.11634934693574905,
0.23193047940731049,
-0.29308396577835083,
-0.2373613864183426,
-0.9035699963569641,
-0.10255642235279083,
0.012122093699872494,
0.2517581582069397,
-0.16915839910507202,
0.2660118043422699,
0.43243667483329773,
0.0013264284934848547,
-0.6645578145980835,
-0.09297358244657516,
-0.5644664168357849,
-0.12294040620326996,
0.444549560546875,
0.3112253248691559,
0.05932549014687538,
-0.048907507210969925,
-0.5474242568016052,
-0.044236913323402405,
-0.6879158020019531,
0.4689861536026001,
0.13175183534622192,
0.45191583037376404,
0.048366934061050415,
0.7028657793998718,
-0.04645921662449837,
0.9763282537460327,
0.5186236500740051,
-0.07402773946523666,
0.3241443336009979,
-0.738388180732727,
-0.33487749099731445,
-0.02384166419506073,
0.5325214266777039,
0.5242339968681335,
0.10958369076251984,
0.19047732651233673,
-0.174177885055542,
0.3745155334472656,
0.47606536746025085,
-0.6913449168205261,
-0.19161713123321533,
0.38023167848587036,
-0.3549725115299225,
-0.0000465816592623014,
-0.01823030225932598,
-1.0865840911865234,
-0.41747304797172546,
-0.6443774700164795,
0.8094711303710938,
-0.5789347887039185,
-0.22119320929050446,
0.2704325318336487,
0.1181369349360466,
0.5172939896583557,
0.5063928961753845,
-1.0021015405654907,
-0.11166597157716751,
0.4755087196826935,
0.5878233313560486,
-0.07218866050243378,
-0.12920637428760529,
-0.6471245884895325,
0.4539262354373932,
-0.6170045733451843,
0.7805920839309692,
-0.7565904259681702,
-0.2875370681285858,
-0.019312405958771706,
-0.1308981031179428,
-0.1345236897468567,
-0.38733839988708496,
0.16450965404510498,
-0.547623336315155,
0.13250167667865753,
-0.7733798623085022,
-0.31277400255203247,
-0.5339344143867493,
0.5507173538208008,
-0.35958921909332275,
0.9151281118392944,
-0.19681033492088318,
-0.3647907078266144,
0.6249608993530273,
-0.5935262441635132,
-0.2928455173969269,
-0.10798045992851257,
-0.4066103994846344,
-0.30582818388938904,
0.010523759759962559,
0.5806772112846375,
0.3209882080554962,
-0.26106852293014526,
0.24000059068202972,
-0.46203547716140747,
-0.20766036212444305,
0.47001633048057556,
-0.4075431227684021,
0.5866141319274902,
0.08845891058444977,
-0.5022259950637817,
0.3723611533641815,
-0.4578413963317871,
0.22097653150558472,
-0.1912422478199005,
-0.11379299312829971,
-0.25256970524787903,
-0.17852959036827087,
-0.3006068766117096,
0.456738144159317,
0.36879605054855347,
-0.2917199432849884,
0.5035806894302368,
-0.2369968593120575,
-0.2539140284061432,
0.9959880113601685,
0.0067339735105633736,
0.39743199944496155,
-0.16945809125900269,
0.580335795879364,
0.2978934049606323,
0.2099165916442871,
-0.17972709238529205,
-0.6270673274993896,
-0.4570257067680359,
-0.6097089052200317,
0.1053711324930191,
0.693062424659729,
-0.9086135625839233,
0.4174346327781677,
0.02385120652616024,
-0.3265983760356903,
-0.41110020875930786,
0.10742977261543274,
0.8143937587738037,
0.47554266452789307,
0.6027558445930481,
-0.34606900811195374,
-0.27305325865745544,
-0.6925224661827087,
0.10121230781078339,
-0.15141548216342926,
0.33101415634155273,
0.20069195330142975,
0.26846250891685486,
-0.29153215885162354,
0.8868165016174316,
-0.35135695338249207,
-0.1288866549730301,
-0.11191318184137344,
0.1882977932691574,
0.19377708435058594,
0.4278046190738678,
0.5622694492340088,
-0.8458774089813232,
-0.4214884638786316,
0.13513769209384918,
-0.8224754929542542,
-0.20206789672374725,
-0.20463836193084717,
-0.49147936701774597,
0.45259109139442444,
0.3398626446723938,
-0.7585069537162781,
0.7086902260780334,
0.4736761450767517,
-0.6932858228683472,
0.8100842237472534,
-0.13585655391216278,
0.40360507369041443,
-0.8687167763710022,
0.09296640008687973,
-0.10433798283338547,
-0.02913283370435238,
-0.46178996562957764,
-0.18079714477062225,
0.05919164419174194,
0.04720939323306084,
-0.18932197988033295,
0.4818067252635956,
-0.661318838596344,
-0.21797701716423035,
-0.21133360266685486,
0.2707836925983429,
0.1543417125940323,
0.7098729610443115,
0.006324735004454851,
0.8973853588104248,
0.8354964256286621,
-0.7371721267700195,
0.6575015187263489,
0.44645631313323975,
-0.06402066349983215,
0.9529102444648743,
-0.3648199439048767,
-0.032785627990961075,
-0.22636952996253967,
0.21419571340084076,
-1.0951526165008545,
0.08012352138757706,
0.2964502274990082,
-0.2850354313850403,
0.47863897681236267,
-0.004420239944010973,
-0.15010836720466614,
-0.3748398423194885,
-0.25943928956985474,
0.6897188425064087,
0.24037064611911774,
-0.6122509241104126,
0.984871506690979,
0.11802401393651962,
0.033292073756456375,
-0.9293932318687439,
-0.5076954364776611,
-0.17573921382427216,
0.06075003370642662,
-0.764818549156189,
0.1943630427122116,
-0.40041863918304443,
-0.26932838559150696,
0.09109501540660858,
-0.3908078670501709,
0.16832539439201355,
-0.37285953760147095,
0.01745315082371235,
0.8933945298194885,
-0.3887534737586975,
0.05370080843567848,
0.1645638793706894,
-0.03908315673470497,
0.03154986724257469,
-0.344990998506546,
0.4550742208957672,
-0.5286617279052734,
-0.6212189197540283,
-0.49177220463752747,
0.22550298273563385,
0.6177072525024414,
-0.5416133999824524,
0.6649770736694336,
0.6082387566566467,
-0.19334474205970764,
-0.06987900286912918,
-0.5503280758857727,
-0.217857226729393,
-0.5280680656433105,
0.1380535364151001,
-0.5669564008712769,
-0.3474524915218353,
0.3857603967189789,
0.03943892940878868,
-0.09509988129138947,
-0.26322585344314575,
0.8106365203857422,
-0.15173307061195374,
1.2049847841262817,
0.3952099680900574,
0.38005775213241577,
0.5630730390548706,
-0.22249890863895416,
0.6636627912521362,
-0.9959295392036438,
-0.66216641664505,
0.05486736819148064,
-0.49178966879844666,
-0.3147609233856201,
-0.74068284034729,
0.5024114847183228,
0.12320024520158768,
-0.15227265655994415,
0.17513211071491241,
-0.38938409090042114,
0.4959182143211365,
0.4619004726409912,
0.2615508735179901,
0.09397806972265244,
-0.16820231080055237,
-0.38081324100494385,
0.0908554270863533,
-0.4141550660133362,
-0.2636668384075165,
0.865395724773407,
-0.03882578760385513,
0.9208372235298157,
0.5750926733016968,
0.2598130702972412,
0.08844880759716034,
-0.07930522412061691,
-1.0142104625701904,
0.7610970735549927,
0.0543426051735878,
-0.8615620136260986,
-0.2331448197364807,
-0.22570976614952087,
-0.8574682474136353,
0.37840571999549866,
-0.6548466086387634,
-1.0439825057983398,
0.5365923047065735,
0.47461777925491333,
-0.5148740410804749,
0.15799711644649506,
-0.5847164392471313,
1.0792244672775269,
-0.4313023090362549,
-0.7730242013931274,
-0.4191877841949463,
-0.6875134706497192,
0.3927806317806244,
0.10872342437505722,
0.0608210489153862,
-0.04133044183254242,
0.06148480251431465,
0.04764745756983757,
-0.15351150929927826,
0.6056670546531677,
-0.24727582931518555,
-0.07547964155673981,
0.2854416072368622,
0.3204417824745178,
0.5550577044487,
-0.07660746574401855,
0.32789069414138794,
-0.12910449504852295,
0.14769196510314941,
-0.42608585953712463,
-0.8612967133522034,
0.3417627513408661,
-0.3176831603050232,
-0.6478796005249023,
-0.5191057324409485,
-0.673178493976593,
-0.5715676546096802,
0.1836286038160324,
-0.0517415851354599,
0.736343264579773,
0.18544958531856537,
0.22694286704063416,
0.8872804045677185,
-0.06856083869934082,
0.29723525047302246,
0.4742452800273895,
-0.5893153548240662,
-0.3998928368091583,
0.9085396528244019,
-0.19925495982170105,
0.3743431866168976,
0.4172786474227905,
0.1794191151857376,
-0.4689100682735443,
-0.5082556009292603,
-0.6865997910499573,
0.2507523000240326,
-0.724799394607544,
-0.32856109738349915,
-0.348063200712204,
0.0771728903055191,
-0.24123218655586243,
-0.47254979610443115,
-0.2811019718647003,
-0.16643302142620087,
0.15678903460502625,
-0.138396754860878,
0.1768888533115387,
0.5528203845024109,
-0.0917491540312767,
-0.010900910943746567,
-0.7116139531135559,
0.41613686084747314,
0.4184996783733368,
0.19181153178215027,
-0.05930908024311066,
-0.2626841068267822,
-0.1871359795331955,
0.09712909907102585,
-0.3959141671657562,
-0.9939228296279907,
0.14370478689670563,
-0.21782439947128296,
0.6632347106933594,
0.4347239136695862,
-0.22822536528110504,
1.089884638786316,
-0.3364618718624115,
0.8256725072860718,
0.47330325841903687,
-1.0646222829818726,
0.5330486297607422,
-0.4574780762195587,
0.2131310999393463,
0.3671557307243347,
0.25457873940467834,
-0.25203245878219604,
-0.27038928866386414,
-0.09474340826272964,
-0.787346601486206,
0.5360488891601562,
0.03871800750494003,
-0.24102714657783508,
0.005012538284063339,
0.0172826386988163,
-0.01163505669683218,
0.25687581300735474,
-0.6310979723930359,
-0.024804111570119858,
-0.286190003156662,
-0.3868895471096039,
0.4473254084587097,
-0.09528892487287521,
-0.14495143294334412,
-0.31610092520713806,
0.9111883044242859,
-0.35329192876815796,
0.1853499412536621,
0.0952492207288742,
-0.11528484523296356,
-0.2099974900484085,
0.15293410420417786,
0.7631913423538208,
1.0660580396652222,
-0.20310793817043304,
-0.05122842267155647,
0.25839585065841675,
-0.31242430210113525,
0.1297869235277176,
-0.03365694731473923,
-0.14965960383415222,
-0.37483343482017517,
0.09224806725978851,
0.7531422972679138,
0.010025139898061752,
-0.821332573890686,
0.6899162530899048,
0.13917472958564758,
0.11324525624513626,
0.05693789944052696,
-0.06593448668718338,
-0.1647743284702301,
0.720896303653717,
0.1106959655880928,
0.13453428447246552,
0.0538599006831646,
-0.7623116970062256,
0.12460363656282425,
0.6737589836120605,
-0.2284942865371704,
-0.3677152097225189,
0.5114786028862,
0.23008479177951813,
0.14633339643478394,
0.5094856023788452,
-0.3137197494506836,
-0.4611865282058716,
0.3666972815990448,
0.615372896194458,
0.7120859026908875,
-0.2035316824913025,
0.15444114804267883,
0.4809553623199463,
0.1459036022424698,
0.1357528269290924,
0.5627649426460266,
0.011740995571017265,
-0.889790952205658,
-0.6405918002128601,
-0.5743860602378845,
-0.41576331853866577,
-0.22468575835227966,
-0.6324498653411865,
0.4406622648239136,
-0.6915175318717957,
-0.25330397486686707,
-0.030323559418320656,
-0.1842406988143921,
-0.5681400299072266,
0.2069985717535019,
0.5358272790908813,
0.6425204277038574,
-0.6719263792037964,
0.6847760677337646,
0.7664182186126709,
-0.829387903213501,
-0.9404225945472717,
0.13869211077690125,
0.35966405272483826,
-0.7410686016082764,
0.6872610449790955,
0.13054858148097992,
-0.7017353773117065,
-0.3681522309780121,
-0.3385215401649475,
-0.8595461845397949,
1.0999481678009033,
0.21924979984760284,
-0.521735429763794,
-0.10948874056339264,
-0.27323171496391296,
0.41947799921035767,
-0.3281693756580353,
0.11022119224071503,
0.3968565762042999,
0.7447039484977722,
0.3665837049484253,
-1.0191024541854858,
0.3235323131084442,
-0.10381557792425156,
0.009772130288183689,
0.37922725081443787,
-0.7362920045852661,
0.6127815246582031,
-0.4581505358219147,
0.053915590047836304,
0.05005526542663574,
0.6716083884239197,
0.6377655863761902,
0.4871997535228729,
0.6032112240791321,
0.3227423429489136,
0.9456962943077087,
-0.0861857533454895,
0.6097316145896912,
-0.22497904300689697,
0.07521427422761917,
0.8676720261573792,
-0.36451831459999084,
0.6168549656867981,
0.6318972706794739,
-0.029017247259616852,
0.9345728754997253,
0.4356183409690857,
-0.005489657633006573,
0.6036007404327393,
-0.0698639303445816,
-0.29041558504104614,
-0.4590032398700714,
0.05604727938771248,
-0.2621152102947235,
0.695957601070404,
0.5932973027229309,
0.10114818811416626,
0.08822979778051376,
-0.008649520576000214,
-0.11163821816444397,
0.1525423377752304,
-0.48661118745803833,
0.6931087970733643,
-0.12537892162799835,
-0.9296413064002991,
0.5405367016792297,
-0.4694965183734894,
0.41531699895858765,
-0.7313374280929565,
-0.09092557430267334,
-0.010523623786866665,
0.29088538885116577,
-0.19393756985664368,
-0.8870056867599487,
0.23032011091709137,
-0.2285992056131363,
-0.31726187467575073,
-0.11078768223524094,
0.4761330485343933,
-0.6978816986083984,
-0.23540058732032776,
0.4058484733104706,
0.4644660949707031,
-0.02345259115099907,
0.2462787926197052,
-0.794533371925354,
0.0861002653837204,
-0.1021854355931282,
-0.1900956779718399,
-0.012870301492512226,
0.699009895324707,
-0.29871758818626404,
0.7928734421730042,
0.7581371068954468,
-0.040321338921785355,
0.14536547660827637,
0.0006430588546209037,
1.0025012493133545,
-0.8150010704994202,
-0.45635277032852173,
-0.765259325504303,
0.7006152868270874,
-0.0052292728796601295,
-0.07735324651002884,
0.5588386058807373,
0.4814053773880005,
0.6293734908103943,
-0.10675065964460373,
0.49480095505714417,
-0.22419346868991852,
0.08279376477003098,
-1.0362091064453125,
0.10753165185451508,
-0.6846593022346497,
0.2606537342071533,
-0.34401175379753113,
-1.0201576948165894,
-0.15514244139194489,
0.726149320602417,
-0.4596503674983978,
0.1814500093460083,
1.095228910446167,
1.1029551029205322,
-0.24029573798179626,
-0.1646842211484909,
0.4758662283420563,
0.19390106201171875,
0.4172345697879791,
0.5402882695198059,
0.8747307062149048,
0.13744544982910156,
0.6110314726829529,
0.026443561539053917,
-0.3173145353794098,
-0.35942429304122925,
-0.9073345065116882,
-1.0218991041183472,
-0.4493747055530548,
-0.17810748517513275,
-0.6021283864974976,
0.10227643698453903,
1.2422103881835938,
0.7315112948417664,
-0.8459408283233643,
-0.009607186540961266,
0.059868574142456055,
-0.013794728554785252,
-0.6216327548027039,
-0.23241305351257324,
0.1770671308040619,
-0.5046233534812927,
-0.6339082717895508,
0.6164258718490601,
0.5855827927589417,
-0.007932836189866066,
-0.407889187335968,
-0.009631306864321232,
-0.47757411003112793,
0.504196047782898,
0.6800017952919006,
0.1977234184741974,
-0.9891896843910217,
-0.5086601972579956,
0.02574503980576992,
0.01153707318007946,
0.02458229288458824,
0.8166667819023132,
-0.836769700050354,
0.935344934463501,
0.5898924469947815,
0.5626794695854187,
0.5928753018379211,
0.23788435757160187,
0.821925699710846,
-0.6645331978797913,
0.22454366087913513,
0.17212988436222076,
0.47400322556495667,
0.2530200779438019,
-0.35435751080513,
0.32978785037994385,
0.2812671661376953,
-0.49972742795944214,
-0.6372945308685303,
0.6425187587738037,
-1.5640153884887695,
-0.37945640087127686,
1.1437780857086182,
0.06090133637189865,
-0.4528427720069885,
-0.07920902967453003,
-0.7175483107566833,
0.06704213470220566,
-0.5475572943687439,
0.7988444566726685,
0.6862449645996094,
-0.29416608810424805,
-0.08536703884601593,
-0.23667751252651215,
0.44235652685165405,
0.5918006300926208,
-0.7633521556854248,
0.10096022486686707,
0.8798957467079163,
-0.00901808962225914,
0.34465762972831726,
0.4736620783805847,
-0.11068171262741089,
0.7255621552467346,
-0.07084240019321442,
0.05061188340187073,
-0.16335487365722656,
-0.6405237913131714,
-0.13571709394454956,
-0.22939738631248474,
-0.27508601546287537,
-0.2561226785182953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15527v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15527v1
|
PCA-Bench: Evaluating Multimodal Large Language Models in Perception-Cognition-Action Chain
| 2024-02-21T07:09:58 | 2024-02-21T07:09:58 |
Liang Chen, Yichi Zhang, Shuhuai Ren, Haozhe Zhao, Zefan Cai, Yuchi Wang, Peiyi Wang, Xiangdi Meng, Tianyu Liu, Baobao Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
We present PCA-Bench, a multimodal decision-making benchmark for evaluating
the integrated capabilities of Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs).
Departing from previous benchmarks focusing on simplistic tasks and individual
model capability, PCA-Bench introduces three complex scenarios: autonomous
driving, domestic robotics, and open-world games. Given task instructions and
diverse contexts, the model is required to seamlessly integrate multiple
capabilities of Perception, Cognition, and Action in a reasoning chain to make
accurate decisions. Moreover, PCA-Bench features error localization
capabilities, scrutinizing model inaccuracies in areas such as perception,
knowledge, or reasoning. This enhances the reliability of deploying MLLMs. To
balance accuracy and efficiency in evaluation, we propose PCA-Eval, an
automatic evaluation protocol, and assess 10 prevalent MLLMs. The results
reveal significant performance disparities between open-source models and
powerful proprietary models like GPT-4 Vision. To address this, we introduce
Embodied-Instruction-Evolution (EIE), an automatic framework for synthesizing
instruction tuning examples in multimodal embodied environments. EIE generates
7,510 training examples in PCA-Bench and enhances the performance of
open-source MLLMs, occasionally surpassing GPT-4 Vision (+3\% in decision
accuracy), thereby validating the effectiveness of EIE. Our findings suggest
that robust MLLMs like GPT4-Vision show promise for decision-making in embodied
agents, opening new avenues for MLLM research.
|
[
-0.4185267388820648,
-0.7494323253631592,
0.8806074857711792,
0.40266624093055725,
-0.03313843905925751,
0.0702846497297287,
-0.39357519149780273,
-0.4051656424999237,
-0.1348472535610199,
0.16826727986335754,
-0.38827604055404663,
-0.48297181725502014,
-0.3156569302082062,
-0.014718670397996902,
-0.14058129489421844,
0.2084720879793167,
-0.25573959946632385,
0.17933066189289093,
-0.5214250683784485,
-0.3161033093929291,
-0.5914809703826904,
-0.5227901935577393,
-0.41539594531059265,
-0.18887904286384583,
0.27007579803466797,
-0.1280280202627182,
0.4343463182449341,
0.48566392064094543,
0.4427887797355652,
0.4577054977416992,
0.33087825775146484,
0.4303431212902069,
-0.18858923017978668,
0.0445697195827961,
-0.25624051690101624,
-0.33300939202308655,
-0.6422109007835388,
-0.014049360528588295,
0.6246255040168762,
0.49953094124794006,
-0.0986039787530899,
0.20157934725284576,
-0.09085910022258759,
0.33667826652526855,
-1.0584630966186523,
0.3864603340625763,
-0.2969090938568115,
0.07477671653032303,
0.13882145285606384,
0.004332362674176693,
-0.5819172859191895,
-0.1423288881778717,
0.04059046879410744,
-0.5099384188652039,
-0.04793288931250572,
-0.11422102153301239,
0.45438873767852783,
0.3321531414985657,
-0.3087168335914612,
-0.0343368723988533,
-0.6473650932312012,
0.8286505341529846,
-0.4886694848537445,
0.5467536449432373,
0.28845277428627014,
0.6360752582550049,
-0.14352595806121826,
-0.7070445418357849,
-0.7359810471534729,
-0.31455108523368835,
0.13640891015529633,
0.3240620195865631,
-0.16387151181697845,
0.23168057203292847,
0.18696486949920654,
-0.004145367536693811,
-0.6181513667106628,
0.08544691652059555,
-0.16560585796833038,
0.1189945638179779,
0.4924989938735962,
0.08980191498994827,
0.31501561403274536,
0.03272169828414917,
-0.3608124554157257,
-0.6273007392883301,
-0.3621828556060791,
-0.013962493278086185,
0.058665599673986435,
0.3146846890449524,
-0.23879317939281464,
0.531154990196228,
-0.020879918709397316,
0.7540249824523926,
-0.07468496263027191,
-0.092708520591259,
0.5067128539085388,
-0.24739272892475128,
-0.3704867959022522,
-0.13909636437892914,
0.7422457337379456,
0.31572115421295166,
-0.11135609447956085,
-0.03856835514307022,
-0.11758283525705338,
0.35699647665023804,
0.4405553936958313,
-0.5054975748062134,
-0.0672820508480072,
0.23069515824317932,
-0.559058666229248,
-0.054950304329395294,
0.026263775303959846,
-1.0037099123001099,
-0.3504597246646881,
-0.5933780670166016,
0.4995250403881073,
-0.27461758255958557,
-0.1961878538131714,
-0.023185331374406815,
-0.2548460364341736,
0.4855985641479492,
0.4866013824939728,
-0.7470973134040833,
0.3215826153755188,
0.6503799557685852,
0.6889998316764832,
-0.18493354320526123,
-0.5969675779342651,
-0.45102787017822266,
0.2573166787624359,
-0.384689062833786,
0.8713333010673523,
-0.8537864089012146,
-0.20840373635292053,
-0.17994502186775208,
0.05782857909798622,
-0.3503015339374542,
-0.47126373648643494,
0.4764389991760254,
0.06849119812250137,
-0.019624533131718636,
-0.2905518114566803,
-0.3112732470035553,
-0.18603190779685974,
0.4362667202949524,
-0.6205873489379883,
0.9136558771133423,
0.0019698955584317446,
-0.14103852212429047,
0.5726531147956848,
-0.8298747539520264,
-0.22357027232646942,
-0.0922539234161377,
-0.5228211283683777,
-0.2529025375843048,
0.2481059581041336,
0.34439417719841003,
0.2867234945297241,
-0.4155411124229431,
0.16364161670207977,
-0.7062252163887024,
-0.2878735661506653,
0.1171160563826561,
-0.5975128412246704,
0.668260931968689,
-0.044987861067056656,
-0.7012876868247986,
0.39428791403770447,
-0.7468741536140442,
0.23804858326911926,
-0.05015226826071739,
-0.1968471109867096,
-0.24808573722839355,
0.27323901653289795,
0.1947796493768692,
0.5391507744789124,
0.10686898976564407,
-0.3992726802825928,
0.11700495332479477,
-0.10465049743652344,
0.31276994943618774,
1.0137102603912354,
-0.3049488067626953,
0.11538419127464294,
-0.08398408442735672,
0.5052171945571899,
-0.29529058933258057,
0.5566838979721069,
0.03585922718048096,
-0.6203944683074951,
-0.6935137510299683,
-0.4965543746948242,
-0.0994177907705307,
0.42835912108421326,
-0.7133474946022034,
0.3334313929080963,
-0.14118492603302002,
-0.4645776152610779,
-0.34797295928001404,
-0.102491095662117,
0.6057852506637573,
0.006437755189836025,
0.5219327807426453,
-0.3936986029148102,
-0.4157343804836273,
-0.9343825578689575,
-0.044732917100191116,
-0.2085409313440323,
0.04260941222310066,
0.5061653852462769,
0.4517592489719391,
-0.3140248954296112,
0.701075553894043,
-0.0559236966073513,
0.015722522512078285,
-0.06750181317329407,
0.3995925784111023,
-0.1431572139263153,
0.5075949430465698,
0.7600845098495483,
-0.7725013494491577,
-0.3462817072868347,
0.2794440984725952,
-0.8963823914527893,
0.030803043395280838,
-0.1645575314760208,
-0.20061254501342773,
0.07754887640476227,
0.17266280949115753,
-0.8183922171592712,
0.445260226726532,
0.690773069858551,
-0.3119969069957733,
0.5020188093185425,
-0.522018313407898,
0.4129174053668976,
-0.7027409672737122,
0.27765771746635437,
-0.1337011456489563,
-0.038305673748254776,
-0.3728162348270416,
0.4081346094608307,
0.21374386548995972,
-0.10931773483753204,
-0.23375697433948517,
0.5144400000572205,
-0.48940518498420715,
-0.6539024114608765,
-0.16473114490509033,
0.11341136693954468,
-0.062314633280038834,
0.6468729972839355,
0.13517220318317413,
0.745948314666748,
0.3257357180118561,
-0.4536393880844116,
0.32935094833374023,
0.198079451918602,
-0.31349828839302063,
0.5391790270805359,
-0.3574031889438629,
0.2161160707473755,
-0.011549295857548714,
0.3596128523349762,
-0.7947633862495422,
-0.10810907930135727,
-0.020198166370391846,
-0.12094579637050629,
0.19375242292881012,
0.20068053901195526,
-0.5113228559494019,
-0.42457321286201477,
-0.3101736605167389,
0.5120733976364136,
0.22954094409942627,
-0.5818293690681458,
1.1037076711654663,
0.33138009905815125,
0.09603708982467651,
-0.6102067232131958,
-0.5095813274383545,
0.24330121278762817,
0.22567133605480194,
-0.29459089040756226,
0.3559260666370392,
-0.36213868856430054,
-0.31546083092689514,
-0.23532921075820923,
-0.04169628396630287,
-0.1875552088022232,
0.03363707289099693,
0.3067082464694977,
0.18581269681453705,
-0.19839252531528473,
0.028362451121211052,
0.08125019073486328,
0.0763745978474617,
0.08935297280550003,
0.037609346210956573,
0.5042416453361511,
-0.3898276686668396,
-0.7593281269073486,
-0.28743016719818115,
0.173825204372406,
0.9263359308242798,
-0.4536331295967102,
0.3278539180755615,
0.7080903649330139,
-0.23023244738578796,
-0.19517238438129425,
-0.6028826236724854,
-0.054760612547397614,
-0.3941885530948639,
0.3938404321670532,
-0.4419389069080353,
-0.40669873356819153,
0.30568447709083557,
-0.2006244957447052,
0.0014564626617357135,
0.17426806688308716,
0.6108487844467163,
0.07822653651237488,
1.1891014575958252,
0.4746505618095398,
0.27590155601501465,
0.3258383870124817,
-0.048305124044418335,
0.043666452169418335,
-0.749835193157196,
-0.26080745458602905,
-0.39759713411331177,
-0.4071614742279053,
-0.6794092655181885,
-0.9118063449859619,
0.41649696230888367,
-0.2046065777540207,
-0.2287016659975052,
0.19151671230793,
-0.320502907037735,
0.4524048864841461,
0.44322124123573303,
0.2538306713104248,
0.010807455517351627,
-0.2830420434474945,
-0.2295532524585724,
0.20754991471767426,
-0.5934250950813293,
-0.4616270959377289,
1.1649805307388306,
0.172951802611351,
0.264869749546051,
0.21089589595794678,
0.3295455574989319,
0.18310102820396423,
0.4544173777103424,
-0.4800071120262146,
0.6498875617980957,
-0.24836868047714233,
-0.4739733040332794,
-0.10898654907941818,
-0.28438782691955566,
-0.6165371537208557,
0.5627972483634949,
-0.364724338054657,
-0.6982123255729675,
0.5775841474533081,
0.03193117678165436,
-0.1971958577632904,
0.2719631493091583,
-0.7513865232467651,
1.2148301601409912,
-0.5554469227790833,
-0.6303104758262634,
-0.4866639971733093,
-0.4792436957359314,
0.33311474323272705,
-0.006278086919337511,
0.12267890572547913,
-0.028285948559641838,
-0.22963808476924896,
0.22198477387428284,
-0.14887869358062744,
0.7987381219863892,
-0.3744892179965973,
-0.024280857294797897,
0.08140120655298233,
-0.16757193207740784,
0.3575117886066437,
-0.4068162739276886,
-0.025886869058012962,
0.07231712341308594,
-0.08554869890213013,
-0.3136269748210907,
-0.689513623714447,
0.6052567362785339,
-0.7569202184677124,
-0.17981192469596863,
-0.2965942919254303,
-0.4086664021015167,
-0.6426016688346863,
0.05418117344379425,
-0.21059568226337433,
0.48096269369125366,
-0.45475077629089355,
0.30033624172210693,
0.460811972618103,
-0.5885627269744873,
0.3963613212108612,
0.5148342251777649,
-0.16350479423999786,
-0.36124950647354126,
0.8965476751327515,
-0.17797918617725372,
0.1376803070306778,
0.5954888463020325,
0.11670982092618942,
-0.3079732656478882,
-0.5044630765914917,
-0.5541088581085205,
-0.017011132091283798,
-0.716840922832489,
0.0776725560426712,
-0.5388869047164917,
0.15601179003715515,
-0.16378344595432281,
-0.12431304156780243,
-0.5747148394584656,
-0.18205612897872925,
0.1706455498933792,
-0.04944266751408577,
-0.21865293383598328,
0.7408788204193115,
-0.05824378505349159,
-0.1279054582118988,
-0.5184618830680847,
0.29196709394454956,
0.6409808993339539,
0.4114822447299957,
0.09108124673366547,
0.046961408108472824,
-0.020216185599565506,
-0.05888405814766884,
-0.33093729615211487,
-0.6206974387168884,
0.24448373913764954,
0.15289844572544098,
0.8067935705184937,
0.28206226229667664,
-0.247975155711174,
0.8742232322692871,
-0.5247462391853333,
0.6905655860900879,
0.23171518743038177,
-0.9899981617927551,
0.41922810673713684,
-0.4193074703216553,
0.4531903862953186,
0.48328542709350586,
0.08426346629858017,
0.04935242608189583,
-0.2985196113586426,
-0.21210089325904846,
-0.6368398666381836,
0.5252105593681335,
0.16353651881217957,
-0.14630456268787384,
-0.1810164600610733,
-0.10817862302064896,
0.11889079958200455,
0.3059937357902527,
-0.6490144729614258,
-0.025795022025704384,
-0.3193388879299164,
-0.16647885739803314,
-0.18974636495113373,
-0.10082501918077469,
-0.028766270726919174,
-0.29059645533561707,
0.5514539480209351,
-0.3743872046470642,
0.4212823808193207,
-0.010404755361378193,
-0.1461215317249298,
-0.00037513970164582133,
0.27294591069221497,
0.8133324384689331,
1.152285099029541,
-0.38822174072265625,
-0.07198114693164825,
0.11263489723205566,
-0.3466901481151581,
0.08622125536203384,
0.2565998435020447,
0.26278021931648254,
-0.19092829525470734,
0.40477025508880615,
0.8794102668762207,
0.5794947743415833,
-1.1452935934066772,
0.6484366655349731,
-0.26308372616767883,
-0.13577018678188324,
-0.13541610538959503,
-0.13542486727237701,
-0.20144471526145935,
0.41376903653144836,
0.0843200609087944,
0.17774108052253723,
0.20958802103996277,
-0.7261302471160889,
0.09667021781206131,
0.34631016850471497,
-0.25779563188552856,
-0.28319859504699707,
0.41404983401298523,
0.18094998598098755,
0.15742099285125732,
0.5092531442642212,
-0.06078805774450302,
-0.28758060932159424,
0.6327738165855408,
0.4219319820404053,
1.1098238229751587,
-0.43130502104759216,
0.309812068939209,
0.4021030068397522,
0.5156545042991638,
-0.027673516422510147,
0.1690884232521057,
-0.27130696177482605,
-0.5771597027778625,
-0.6212612986564636,
-0.6458638906478882,
-0.47795090079307556,
-0.015191751532256603,
-0.6481444239616394,
0.012598935514688492,
-0.5896013975143433,
-0.20751984417438507,
0.02880360372364521,
-0.4375550150871277,
-0.7305354475975037,
0.062090083956718445,
0.26031139492988586,
0.6900761723518372,
-0.656879723072052,
0.744279146194458,
0.816206693649292,
-0.39152535796165466,
-0.4692367613315582,
-0.19092914462089539,
0.01701783761382103,
-0.6351523399353027,
0.8217540979385376,
0.2500220239162445,
-0.27601417899131775,
-0.46242108941078186,
-0.3384413719177246,
-0.6198315620422363,
1.263785719871521,
0.609329879283905,
-0.5721443891525269,
0.04188262298703194,
0.005514907650649548,
0.6088398098945618,
-0.35251080989837646,
0.495590478181839,
0.5543275475502014,
0.7117611169815063,
-0.22600488364696503,
-1.199851632118225,
-0.11358170211315155,
-0.43694421648979187,
0.06918447464704514,
0.24238014221191406,
-0.7673749327659607,
0.9993600249290466,
0.07055319100618362,
-0.0915251150727272,
0.20088014006614685,
0.19079464673995972,
0.4636143445968628,
0.36791881918907166,
0.4504314064979553,
0.7459229230880737,
0.5010828971862793,
-0.07814356684684753,
1.1909016370773315,
-0.18222792446613312,
0.09356396645307541,
1.2333351373672485,
-0.5216118097305298,
1.2210155725479126,
0.3726130425930023,
-0.3474862277507782,
0.6343725919723511,
0.286753386259079,
0.030469855293631554,
0.434112012386322,
-0.02546103671193123,
-0.2106354832649231,
-0.5322911143302917,
0.05244777724146843,
-0.2612582743167877,
0.9517292976379395,
0.3852703273296356,
-0.38572296500205994,
-0.17772196233272552,
0.25763288140296936,
-0.4181734323501587,
0.13219134509563446,
-0.2842671573162079,
0.7413079738616943,
-0.2445748746395111,
-0.6880105137825012,
0.39163339138031006,
-0.06907191872596741,
0.20414255559444427,
-0.6786515712738037,
-0.4354829788208008,
0.012806923128664494,
0.3986065983772278,
0.21284392476081848,
-0.36864614486694336,
-0.08810925483703613,
-0.0324956551194191,
-0.21026119589805603,
-0.22998742759227753,
0.43736234307289124,
-0.2050584852695465,
-0.42324793338775635,
0.5576485991477966,
0.5361090898513794,
0.0252823606133461,
-0.12113112211227417,
-0.9943901300430298,
0.4765911400318146,
-0.26740559935569763,
0.08026222884654999,
0.48962509632110596,
0.25174587965011597,
-0.06786242872476578,
0.6725068688392639,
0.6199005842208862,
-0.2819359600543976,
-0.01264001615345478,
0.18699176609516144,
0.756104052066803,
-0.4841982126235962,
-0.43143004179000854,
-0.6083984375,
0.3474116623401642,
-0.21268275380134583,
-0.17011280357837677,
0.6694340705871582,
0.5205903053283691,
0.6537272930145264,
-0.20107437670230865,
0.690109133720398,
-0.0782950147986412,
0.06378338485956192,
-0.5084130764007568,
0.5586995482444763,
-0.4803363084793091,
-0.03731456398963928,
-0.4164182245731354,
-1.0590029954910278,
-0.058895695954561234,
0.7576895356178284,
-0.4691731631755829,
0.35148757696151733,
0.7734748125076294,
0.585577666759491,
-0.28719404339790344,
0.10744944214820862,
0.3949055075645447,
0.22075042128562927,
0.274955153465271,
0.6473164558410645,
0.7364473938941956,
-0.3565758764743805,
0.2242027223110199,
-0.2187122106552124,
-0.497263640165329,
-0.06508773565292358,
-0.9157970547676086,
-0.8477466106414795,
-0.607702910900116,
-0.13271918892860413,
0.12932369112968445,
0.3120253086090088,
0.9941016435623169,
0.9571325778961182,
-0.6749078035354614,
-0.4434811770915985,
-0.25452274084091187,
-0.21035416424274445,
-0.6934937238693237,
-0.18617673218250275,
0.38765084743499756,
-0.41664257645606995,
-0.768622875213623,
0.8297378420829773,
0.5908254981040955,
-0.12206675857305527,
-0.4628655016422272,
-0.19736497104167938,
-0.4009469747543335,
0.013172407634556293,
1.053711175918579,
0.21789135038852692,
-0.9070894122123718,
-0.10839315503835678,
-0.3524208068847656,
0.1830921769142151,
-0.20576046407222748,
0.8250188231468201,
-0.74341881275177,
1.1318581104278564,
0.28374889492988586,
0.7867047190666199,
0.4614621698856354,
-0.20179800689220428,
0.9166462421417236,
-0.5039420127868652,
0.16618363559246063,
0.1737878918647766,
0.4477703869342804,
0.2658126652240753,
0.21073828637599945,
0.5750405788421631,
0.09112987667322159,
-0.4059220254421234,
-0.8431240320205688,
-0.08431082963943481,
-1.0177152156829834,
-0.4677795469760895,
0.8162728548049927,
-0.18556855618953705,
-0.36483079195022583,
0.07865256816148758,
-0.16110070049762726,
-0.08481881767511368,
-0.21896135807037354,
0.7556547522544861,
0.6340385675430298,
-0.15849930047988892,
-0.3510392904281616,
-0.7338356375694275,
0.42408663034439087,
0.23343852162361145,
-1.2508512735366821,
0.19686034321784973,
0.751105010509491,
-0.23033103346824646,
0.28387102484703064,
0.28746935725212097,
-0.04839347302913666,
0.6730107069015503,
0.23803985118865967,
0.1855248510837555,
-0.0665540024638176,
-0.36434367299079895,
-0.17254403233528137,
0.293295681476593,
-0.056280989199876785,
-0.16452737152576447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13571v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13571v2
|
Multilingual Coreference Resolution in Low-resource South Asian Languages
| 2024-02-21T07:05:51 | 2024-03-23T08:22:58 |
Ritwik Mishra, Pooja Desur, Rajiv Ratn Shah, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Coreference resolution involves the task of identifying text spans within a
discourse that pertain to the same real-world entity. While this task has been
extensively explored in the English language, there has been a notable scarcity
of publicly accessible resources and models for coreference resolution in South
Asian languages. We introduce a Translated dataset for Multilingual Coreference
Resolution (TransMuCoRes) in 31 South Asian languages using off-the-shelf tools
for translation and word-alignment. Nearly all of the predicted translations
successfully pass a sanity check, and 75% of English references align with
their predicted translations. Using multilingual encoders, two off-the-shelf
coreference resolution models were trained on a concatenation of TransMuCoRes
and a Hindi coreference resolution dataset with manual annotations. The best
performing model achieved a score of 64 and 68 for LEA F1 and CoNLL F1,
respectively, on our test-split of Hindi golden set. This study is the first to
evaluate an end-to-end coreference resolution model on a Hindi golden set.
Furthermore, this work underscores the limitations of current coreference
evaluation metrics when applied to datasets with split antecedents, advocating
for the development of more suitable evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.3510145843029022,
-0.18934758007526398,
-0.008525511249899864,
0.13688987493515015,
-0.5997856259346008,
0.2585388123989105,
-0.6961866617202759,
-0.6004834175109863,
0.11430732905864716,
0.38679009675979614,
-0.3309207260608673,
-0.15519216656684875,
-0.8061283826828003,
0.545773446559906,
-0.05085638538002968,
0.8038504123687744,
-0.2085145264863968,
-0.031891047954559326,
-0.18594805896282196,
-0.5665795803070068,
-0.5384112596511841,
-0.6820924878120422,
0.024260440841317177,
-0.42201611399650574,
-0.007730691693723202,
0.8046706914901733,
0.8120251297950745,
0.666427493095398,
0.6750379800796509,
0.17370903491973877,
-0.27767857909202576,
0.605077862739563,
-0.08630266040563583,
0.013475577346980572,
-0.3520517349243164,
-0.4949944317340851,
-0.20024921000003815,
0.21222718060016632,
0.4757694900035858,
0.7866466641426086,
0.07318530976772308,
0.41630005836486816,
0.25592467188835144,
0.401824414730072,
-0.8658824563026428,
0.16750755906105042,
-0.3558855354785919,
-0.055817678570747375,
-0.4646275043487549,
-0.03416972979903221,
-0.5670700073242188,
-0.40307509899139404,
-0.11221574246883392,
-0.25925421714782715,
0.20280784368515015,
0.07757506519556046,
0.9848346710205078,
0.12329848855733871,
-0.46986204385757446,
-0.4788266122341156,
-0.658068835735321,
1.0242702960968018,
-0.5619741082191467,
0.43701106309890747,
0.5626919865608215,
0.3979371190071106,
0.5706437230110168,
-0.13136819005012512,
-0.3349442481994629,
-0.015682222321629524,
-0.4192109704017639,
0.03712895140051842,
-0.08188090473413467,
-0.0970226302742958,
0.060536619275808334,
0.5660825967788696,
-0.5243331789970398,
0.03702059015631676,
-0.6066215634346008,
-0.17746791243553162,
0.43732312321662903,
0.03635590523481369,
0.06338538229465485,
-0.6486387252807617,
-0.0031118972692638636,
0.3370864689350128,
-0.6185593605041504,
-0.2306727170944214,
0.14519353210926056,
0.5741105675697327,
-0.16374735534191132,
0.9014354348182678,
0.27840089797973633,
0.7778423428535461,
0.6154641509056091,
-0.5879703164100647,
0.18619845807552338,
-0.7811374068260193,
0.04187775403261185,
0.3250349462032318,
0.5722069144248962,
0.4061334729194641,
0.49407774209976196,
-0.12359349429607391,
0.09045018255710602,
0.14075569808483124,
-0.07754793763160706,
-0.4263438284397125,
0.3057797849178314,
-0.03558460623025894,
-0.3461931645870209,
0.2614246606826782,
-0.17943444848060608,
-0.7172679305076599,
-0.5284823775291443,
-0.4736472964286804,
-0.36111149191856384,
-0.6022956967353821,
-0.3760184943675995,
-0.16219130158424377,
0.2174295336008072,
0.26768696308135986,
0.014035798609256744,
-0.6077621579170227,
-0.021983740851283073,
0.48286566138267517,
1.1836689710617065,
-0.2016974687576294,
-0.38575121760368347,
-0.12337658554315567,
0.36407992243766785,
-0.3628956377506256,
0.936174213886261,
-0.94016432762146,
-0.8257014751434326,
-0.07962442934513092,
-0.0597551167011261,
-0.22463156282901764,
-0.7481579780578613,
0.8528120517730713,
0.08791685104370117,
-0.007293339818716049,
-0.17615453898906708,
-0.18265660107135773,
-0.15191784501075745,
0.43207186460494995,
-0.5076032280921936,
0.8702343106269836,
0.08334484696388245,
-0.6368165016174316,
0.23772239685058594,
-0.3443238437175751,
-0.667425274848938,
0.01912340521812439,
-0.009391549043357372,
0.050281181931495667,
0.1282520294189453,
0.3008823096752167,
0.3380989730358124,
-0.7307626008987427,
0.19832375645637512,
-0.16526401042938232,
-0.12555883824825287,
-0.09207914024591446,
-0.18641622364521027,
0.6483185887336731,
0.12960070371627808,
0.06232467666268349,
0.22096434235572815,
-0.6768330335617065,
-0.06916388124227524,
-0.2541436553001404,
0.09243854135274887,
-0.6480699777603149,
-0.5750654935836792,
-0.19166803359985352,
0.514356255531311,
0.36168521642684937,
-0.7694383263587952,
0.04934488609433174,
-0.07872585207223892,
0.252510130405426,
0.5239388346672058,
-0.15558379888534546,
0.5882019400596619,
-0.00496282521635294,
0.5563839673995972,
0.35186710953712463,
0.23385584354400635,
-0.10629979521036148,
-0.3691675066947937,
-0.6352011561393738,
-0.20912733674049377,
0.2344290167093277,
0.6562058925628662,
-0.32641810178756714,
0.41112661361694336,
-0.42866891622543335,
-1.0723240375518799,
-0.8378384709358215,
0.1575968712568283,
0.6066887974739075,
0.4516091048717499,
0.428694486618042,
-0.03774077445268631,
-0.7492057085037231,
-1.1402041912078857,
-0.3635749816894531,
-0.21545222401618958,
0.20592987537384033,
0.3978782594203949,
0.4184251129627228,
-0.19751060009002686,
0.7823717594146729,
-0.3809258043766022,
-0.6178762316703796,
-0.28879377245903015,
0.15356791019439697,
0.15102310478687286,
0.5745317935943604,
0.4955691993236542,
-0.77173912525177,
-0.4968000650405884,
0.1772950142621994,
-0.6501225233078003,
-0.17186637222766876,
0.21590857207775116,
-0.18695107102394104,
0.06460545212030411,
0.18146270513534546,
-0.5381300449371338,
0.2794153094291687,
0.727400004863739,
-0.08371331542730331,
1.0313283205032349,
0.014433384872972965,
0.35692283511161804,
-1.1457382440567017,
0.23946824669837952,
0.09465772658586502,
-0.19699780642986298,
-0.2768309414386749,
-0.03522452339529991,
0.14622706174850464,
-0.2899855375289917,
-0.3296128809452057,
0.4776259660720825,
-0.6458244919776917,
-0.06669334322214127,
-0.2363736778497696,
0.35406070947647095,
-0.07991106063127518,
0.4376227557659149,
0.1715550422668457,
0.9396432638168335,
0.16840016841888428,
-0.5840708613395691,
0.46956926584243774,
0.5130324959754944,
-0.1893363893032074,
1.1233494281768799,
-0.2821671962738037,
0.22977517545223236,
-0.038181766867637634,
0.2110459804534912,
-0.7443944811820984,
-0.041372548788785934,
0.1352611780166626,
-0.3025325834751129,
0.09810539335012436,
-0.3511635661125183,
-0.40276220440864563,
-0.2857217490673065,
0.04431437328457832,
0.6114583611488342,
-0.0903991088271141,
-0.40596804022789,
0.7883056998252869,
0.6234933733940125,
-0.10503233969211578,
-0.6672067642211914,
-1.0211857557296753,
0.06595979630947113,
-0.17731384932994843,
-0.2753293514251709,
0.2951120138168335,
0.08051182329654694,
-0.2660500109195709,
0.06425778567790985,
-0.12203212082386017,
-0.1355338990688324,
-0.4639987051486969,
0.5040329694747925,
0.35645079612731934,
-0.08254808932542801,
-0.0657445415854454,
-0.0017919042147696018,
-0.23163548111915588,
-0.26110634207725525,
-0.01911894977092743,
0.4365987479686737,
-0.5110452175140381,
-0.3825596272945404,
0.12031930685043335,
0.6194239854812622,
0.5428496599197388,
-0.6401646733283997,
0.7778143882751465,
0.4624408781528473,
-0.8584721684455872,
0.5831699967384338,
-0.691293478012085,
0.27095407247543335,
-0.29846441745758057,
0.22664472460746765,
-0.6654843688011169,
-0.5320801734924316,
0.69642573595047,
-0.291075199842453,
0.16635484993457794,
0.5144751667976379,
0.6486228704452515,
0.32308655977249146,
0.9236065149307251,
0.46784570813179016,
0.01996449939906597,
0.10442578792572021,
-0.04263613745570183,
0.4429142475128174,
-1.1285213232040405,
-0.26977798342704773,
-0.7635505199432373,
-0.09174753725528717,
-0.3841564655303955,
-0.488517165184021,
0.10325972735881805,
0.3823627531528473,
-0.024424457922577858,
0.6250861883163452,
-0.481823205947876,
0.5324008464813232,
0.2593421936035156,
0.045001402497291565,
0.5795992612838745,
-0.3870640993118286,
-0.25620654225349426,
-0.5317716598510742,
-0.4702051281929016,
-0.6696274280548096,
0.5917240977287292,
-0.30056101083755493,
0.5335003137588501,
0.27362486720085144,
0.25536757707595825,
0.2306915819644928,
0.5211631059646606,
-0.7043322920799255,
0.49662092328071594,
-0.4806019961833954,
-0.6356348991394043,
0.06419815123081207,
-0.24114464223384857,
-0.5885911583900452,
0.20670539140701294,
0.1393839567899704,
-0.6681264638900757,
0.425767183303833,
-0.1803939938545227,
-0.23693183064460754,
0.32301175594329834,
-0.6993026733398438,
0.7700851559638977,
-0.22666725516319275,
-0.2324727326631546,
-0.26646676659584045,
-0.5134796500205994,
0.6586878299713135,
-0.15623575448989868,
0.25132858753204346,
-0.38889026641845703,
0.019671345129609108,
0.7942245006561279,
-0.2280743271112442,
0.7714266180992126,
-0.022369317710399628,
0.1900675892829895,
0.3783685863018036,
0.2237616628408432,
0.23651212453842163,
-0.006533473264425993,
-0.22728048264980316,
0.2017202079296112,
0.2357349544763565,
-0.48063239455223083,
-0.3873845338821411,
0.6391839981079102,
-0.6897886991500854,
-0.4024313986301422,
-0.48033633828163147,
-0.4636897146701813,
-0.3988134562969208,
0.31260284781455994,
0.5096822381019592,
0.06630745530128479,
-0.008583573624491692,
0.05421363562345505,
0.14132675528526306,
0.09644614905118942,
0.13481967151165009,
0.5427713394165039,
-0.1477559357881546,
-0.4037529528141022,
0.5664860606193542,
0.428358256816864,
0.05763402581214905,
-0.08872920274734497,
-0.03649304062128067,
-0.48607996106147766,
0.05356880649924278,
-0.6927528381347656,
0.5980698466300964,
-0.8796653747558594,
-0.5957369804382324,
-0.27714839577674866,
-0.30736786127090454,
-0.47921955585479736,
-0.283867746591568,
-0.6840789914131165,
-0.32771191000938416,
-0.290886789560318,
-0.23867204785346985,
0.079409159719944,
0.3752971589565277,
-0.34248673915863037,
0.16482289135456085,
-1.0607595443725586,
-0.014164483174681664,
-0.28301090002059937,
0.2671060562133789,
-0.10556579381227493,
-0.7383164167404175,
-0.48880574107170105,
0.12495455890893936,
-0.16867336630821228,
-1.0080125331878662,
0.3240322768688202,
0.4204804301261902,
0.3604119122028351,
0.3771849274635315,
0.23738178610801697,
1.2403757572174072,
-0.23240050673484802,
0.7201867699623108,
0.14436118304729462,
-1.0033639669418335,
0.6532490253448486,
0.2580702304840088,
0.4739927649497986,
0.722622275352478,
0.5521758198738098,
-1.0591961145401,
-0.34045109152793884,
-0.36838170886039734,
-0.5548309087753296,
0.18373385071754456,
-0.19734680652618408,
-0.04127229377627373,
0.018684806302189827,
0.42530766129493713,
0.3901634216308594,
0.03358880802989006,
-0.14751380681991577,
-0.1579313427209854,
-0.1083555817604065,
-0.014613267034292221,
-0.2607564926147461,
-0.24490825831890106,
-0.13401974737644196,
-0.19834837317466736,
0.6482252478599548,
-0.21599656343460083,
0.03773409500718117,
0.04773004353046417,
-0.652747631072998,
-0.23079310357570648,
0.45426180958747864,
0.49964073300361633,
0.7443783283233643,
-0.034012190997600555,
0.36855047941207886,
0.08128709346055984,
-0.5388194918632507,
0.4278889298439026,
0.18080197274684906,
-0.053307078778743744,
0.24091319739818573,
0.30154430866241455,
0.5696576237678528,
0.3068654537200928,
-0.6727811694145203,
0.15123330056667328,
0.16256140172481537,
0.43534183502197266,
-0.27929818630218506,
-0.42704975605010986,
-0.1014232337474823,
-0.08973462134599686,
0.46877336502075195,
0.3789897859096527,
-0.21315458416938782,
-0.27619925141334534,
0.1998872309923172,
-0.025890333577990532,
-0.5941436290740967,
-0.4422564208507538,
0.3467941880226135,
0.33712995052337646,
-0.0109208719804883,
0.8146557211875916,
-0.16880415380001068,
-0.875315248966217,
0.052869509905576706,
0.5719392895698547,
0.6835408806800842,
-0.464547723531723,
0.11889816075563431,
0.7844039797782898,
0.5245543122291565,
0.016739893704652786,
0.050050001591444016,
0.1108909398317337,
-0.8267612457275391,
-0.5402047634124756,
-0.48483556509017944,
-0.6727445125579834,
-0.18386366963386536,
-0.8756934404373169,
0.3807581067085266,
-0.20667535066604614,
-0.3857637643814087,
-0.29955917596817017,
0.2786019742488861,
-0.5298798680305481,
0.0930154025554657,
-0.02242189273238182,
0.8478213548660278,
-1.0116794109344482,
0.6340436935424805,
0.9054374098777771,
-0.5190893411636353,
-0.5608323812484741,
-0.3158613443374634,
0.1643291860818863,
-0.5784897804260254,
0.2929787337779999,
0.2522769272327423,
-0.19305449724197388,
-0.16518335044384003,
-0.02338150143623352,
-0.7593967318534851,
0.7468135952949524,
0.6358398795127869,
-0.2954649329185486,
-0.10647688060998917,
0.4075727164745331,
0.4506857395172119,
-0.3443933427333832,
0.36565062403678894,
0.8480819463729858,
0.6897154450416565,
-0.22807587683200836,
-1.3629639148712158,
0.06179136037826538,
-0.40392687916755676,
-0.34886208176612854,
0.14053088426589966,
-0.842495322227478,
0.5725086331367493,
-0.2649669647216797,
-0.4391327202320099,
-0.15657317638397217,
0.884942352771759,
0.4718639552593231,
-0.14232991635799408,
0.43659377098083496,
0.4024233818054199,
0.7432987093925476,
-0.12980863451957703,
0.6818106174468994,
-0.5486786365509033,
0.2472955286502838,
1.179965853691101,
-0.3772818446159363,
0.617469072341919,
0.5451265573501587,
-0.12095938622951508,
0.16949091851711273,
0.9059213399887085,
0.10737711191177368,
0.23699532449245453,
-0.32425424456596375,
-0.12833116948604584,
-0.3294348120689392,
-1.019540786743164,
-0.39616498351097107,
0.5797878503799438,
0.4959726333618164,
-0.15753045678138733,
-0.31747210025787354,
0.29785168170928955,
0.19882990419864655,
0.25818708539009094,
-0.4996076226234436,
0.3866155445575714,
0.08576815575361252,
-0.747987687587738,
0.5194600224494934,
0.05611944943666458,
0.8223280310630798,
-0.48242563009262085,
0.2529434561729431,
-0.41593289375305176,
0.4359760284423828,
-0.42337271571159363,
-0.9895996451377869,
0.8917789459228516,
0.32201722264289856,
-0.23664945363998413,
0.08480042964220047,
0.7658666372299194,
-0.5792795419692993,
-0.5939099192619324,
0.30787214636802673,
0.6226313710212708,
0.20752505958080292,
-0.06725569814443588,
-0.48431095480918884,
-0.17763064801692963,
-0.20609848201274872,
0.11445626616477966,
0.18287871778011322,
0.310586541891098,
-0.2819099724292755,
0.6413835883140564,
0.313249409198761,
0.22584450244903564,
0.2841637432575226,
-0.1749058961868286,
0.4237750768661499,
-0.49938708543777466,
-0.41023552417755127,
-0.6496758460998535,
0.013103652745485306,
-0.05258852615952492,
-0.640544593334198,
0.7694545388221741,
0.9708894491195679,
0.7886773943901062,
0.04343913868069649,
0.844517171382904,
-0.17146144807338715,
0.5828404426574707,
-0.017718616873025894,
0.3167702257633209,
-0.35214775800704956,
-0.14704637229442596,
-0.08719057589769363,
-0.7425397634506226,
-0.3688637316226959,
0.35979267954826355,
-0.32022008299827576,
-0.0630289614200592,
0.4880961775779724,
0.4785401523113251,
-0.22271619737148285,
0.2803713381290436,
0.1983986496925354,
-0.06609585881233215,
0.09179327636957169,
0.5844539403915405,
0.5203118324279785,
-0.2790190279483795,
0.9557934403419495,
-0.6936225295066833,
-0.20679008960723877,
-0.16018304228782654,
-0.5687204599380493,
-0.5116147398948669,
-0.8586811423301697,
-0.21099914610385895,
-0.57817542552948,
-0.035050347447395325,
0.9931638240814209,
0.5708358883857727,
-0.8892297148704529,
-0.3558513820171356,
0.626152515411377,
0.02457144297659397,
-0.6274508237838745,
-0.16450297832489014,
0.5060950517654419,
0.08100563287734985,
-0.8694461584091187,
0.03366851061582565,
0.3891611099243164,
-0.1524496227502823,
-0.31102991104125977,
-0.10442508012056351,
-0.5551548600196838,
-0.05033382773399353,
0.5624326467514038,
0.3447873294353485,
-0.6190884709358215,
-0.36090511083602905,
-0.05297379940748215,
-0.4912860691547394,
0.2636915147304535,
1.0975825786590576,
-0.4107615649700165,
0.21440339088439941,
0.35858893394470215,
0.4448564648628235,
0.3783615231513977,
0.15985901653766632,
0.4518699645996094,
-0.9111261367797852,
0.4358116388320923,
0.3114720582962036,
0.5178414583206177,
0.6350669264793396,
-0.26252511143684387,
0.8338658809661865,
0.37933647632598877,
-0.20666645467281342,
-0.9797149896621704,
0.31642115116119385,
-0.7608994841575623,
0.06916258484125137,
1.0843851566314697,
-0.30885785818099976,
-0.28303349018096924,
-0.2731397747993469,
-0.36790338158607483,
0.6197394132614136,
-0.05592723563313484,
0.4274834990501404,
0.9520386457443237,
-0.2123221755027771,
-0.49104225635528564,
-0.09856991469860077,
0.07835956662893295,
0.2934626340866089,
-0.5972145199775696,
0.6050320863723755,
0.2985999584197998,
-0.10107367485761642,
0.7113280892372131,
0.33931398391723633,
-0.24304480850696564,
0.2633255422115326,
-0.0534527450799942,
0.04529205337166786,
-0.07511914521455765,
-0.2163780927658081,
-0.05907010659575462,
0.09210498631000519,
-0.13793326914310455,
-0.08692601323127747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14865v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14865v2
|
Dynamic Evaluation of Large Language Models by Meta Probing Agents
| 2024-02-21T06:46:34 | 2024-06-07T09:19:45 |
Kaijie Zhu, Jindong Wang, Qinlin Zhao, Ruochen Xu, Xing Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Evaluation of large language models (LLMs) has raised great concerns in the
community due to the issue of data contamination. Existing work designed
evaluation protocols using well-defined algorithms for specific tasks, which
cannot be easily extended to diverse scenarios. Moreover, current evaluation
benchmarks can only provide the overall benchmark results and cannot support a
fine-grained and multifaceted analysis of LLMs' abilities. In this paper, we
propose meta probing agents (MPA), a general dynamic evaluation protocol
inspired by psychometrics to evaluate LLMs. MPA is the key component of DyVal
2, which naturally extends the previous DyVal~\citep{zhu2023dyval}. MPA designs
the probing and judging agents to automatically transform an original
evaluation problem into a new one following psychometric theory on three basic
cognitive abilities: language understanding, problem solving, and domain
knowledge. These basic abilities are also dynamically configurable, allowing
multifaceted analysis. We conducted extensive evaluations using MPA and found
that most LLMs achieve poorer performance, indicating room for improvement. Our
multifaceted analysis demonstrated the strong correlation between the basic
abilities and an implicit Matthew effect on model size, i.e., larger models
possess stronger correlations of the abilities. MPA can also be used as a data
augmentation approach to enhance LLMs. Code is available at:
https://github.com/microsoft/promptbench.
|
[
-0.38467511534690857,
-0.9271271824836731,
0.9230442047119141,
0.189931720495224,
-0.1669318526983261,
0.41174668073654175,
-0.29333534836769104,
-0.4487423896789551,
0.2314959615468979,
0.24451598525047302,
-0.5898290872573853,
-0.20075519382953644,
-0.6431078314781189,
0.10208028554916382,
-0.12259595096111298,
0.6265357136726379,
0.043792735785245895,
0.058855172246694565,
-0.3639935553073883,
-0.14455091953277588,
-0.519050657749176,
-0.05346556007862091,
-0.5639132857322693,
-0.38235238194465637,
0.660049557685852,
0.1893073320388794,
0.8200839757919312,
0.6043329834938049,
0.6308658719062805,
0.5321348905563354,
-0.12189039587974548,
0.35217615962028503,
-0.47790762782096863,
0.3806794583797455,
-0.453352153301239,
-0.39307454228401184,
-0.8528838157653809,
0.21379965543746948,
0.9626617431640625,
0.5480219125747681,
-0.09896068274974823,
0.4610239863395691,
0.06341087818145752,
0.4727020859718323,
-0.6536895036697388,
0.4978484511375427,
-0.6796468496322632,
-0.2739775478839874,
-0.09383665025234222,
-0.43934088945388794,
-0.35755476355552673,
-0.1383889764547348,
0.26915186643600464,
-0.3383280038833618,
-0.28451237082481384,
-0.34941744804382324,
0.4117489159107208,
0.4012085497379303,
-0.7811627984046936,
-0.340496301651001,
-0.7750997543334961,
0.6605737805366516,
-0.4357333779335022,
0.1657285988330841,
0.08046147972345352,
0.6164791584014893,
-0.15777505934238434,
-0.7672656774520874,
-0.6750410199165344,
-0.6690753698348999,
-0.1131090596318245,
0.04583974555134773,
-0.302142471075058,
0.10282041132450104,
0.2817356586456299,
0.2321508824825287,
-0.3875894248485565,
0.044969428330659866,
-0.028113020583987236,
-0.06350555270910263,
0.6756079792976379,
0.6293811202049255,
0.4927944540977478,
-0.06143200024962425,
-0.09797250479459763,
-0.3434380292892456,
-0.2959214150905609,
-0.010971772484481335,
0.38338392972946167,
0.2658529579639435,
0.041179098188877106,
0.38196155428886414,
-0.07971172034740448,
0.6361384987831116,
0.0183644387871027,
-0.39327314496040344,
0.4107970595359802,
-0.3544105887413025,
-0.02102481760084629,
-0.4098565876483917,
0.7154070734977722,
0.15562613308429718,
0.20930512249469757,
-0.13305692374706268,
-0.24698762595653534,
-0.063863106071949,
0.19208593666553497,
-0.839104413986206,
0.04248581454157829,
0.371073454618454,
-0.2845282554626465,
-0.3685416877269745,
0.08238305151462555,
-1.1356525421142578,
-0.5452677607536316,
-0.3544427752494812,
0.5964390635490417,
-0.15475213527679443,
-0.4332498013973236,
0.011147839017212391,
0.102838434278965,
0.14321471750736237,
0.2709934711456299,
-0.816801130771637,
0.3011282980442047,
0.8226271867752075,
0.6260516047477722,
-0.21221135556697845,
-0.5446229577064514,
-0.7774589657783508,
0.08420836180448532,
-0.09133417904376984,
0.5964769721031189,
-1.0180965662002563,
-0.23805832862854004,
-0.11297711730003357,
0.022263506427407265,
-0.21180136501789093,
-0.5153139233589172,
0.22002236545085907,
-0.6368635892868042,
-0.0333210714161396,
-0.25629115104675293,
-0.1945783495903015,
-0.11907929182052612,
0.4368363320827484,
-0.7628658413887024,
0.7552068829536438,
0.17397552728652954,
-0.6701921820640564,
0.12465549260377884,
-0.7183443307876587,
-0.20627394318580627,
0.12150364369153976,
-0.21976648271083832,
-0.17680934071540833,
0.15119177103042603,
0.16164395213127136,
0.26458099484443665,
-0.4516626298427582,
0.4753616452217102,
-0.4578417241573334,
-0.4799979031085968,
0.6259820461273193,
-0.689696192741394,
0.6927762627601624,
0.08079646527767181,
-0.43320155143737793,
0.19862444698810577,
-0.9632458090782166,
0.258637398481369,
0.1644086390733719,
-0.4779846668243408,
-0.16144923865795135,
0.10365618020296097,
-0.4153243601322174,
0.1471354365348816,
0.294508695602417,
-0.2570961117744446,
0.37624719738960266,
-0.3069157600402832,
0.2740667462348938,
0.6723678112030029,
0.057710904628038406,
0.3285408616065979,
-0.2286979854106903,
0.8106340169906616,
-0.36833250522613525,
0.13456617295742035,
-0.13779808580875397,
-0.24213995039463043,
-0.6484990119934082,
-0.5589889287948608,
0.22492370009422302,
0.5912564396858215,
-0.9023144841194153,
0.2327929139137268,
-0.4997064471244812,
-0.7192164063453674,
-0.3402283787727356,
0.09543996304273605,
0.34648993611335754,
0.09684228152036667,
0.18576925992965698,
-0.016798870638012886,
-0.33334121108055115,
-0.7900250554084778,
-0.33933934569358826,
-0.24237993359565735,
-0.15867723524570465,
0.47285157442092896,
0.5227224826812744,
-0.5925480127334595,
0.8270326852798462,
-0.3444972038269043,
0.02153196930885315,
-0.21470396220684052,
0.20653344690799713,
0.24799703061580658,
0.26486995816230774,
0.5526541471481323,
-0.451643705368042,
-0.44392070174217224,
-0.2020896077156067,
-0.471095472574234,
-0.5164446830749512,
-0.07911902666091919,
0.05408472195267677,
-0.32630231976509094,
0.3414889872074127,
-0.7520292401313782,
-0.019530339166522026,
0.7199662923812866,
-0.3741135895252228,
0.6219348311424255,
-0.11178544908761978,
0.1390218436717987,
-0.9028813242912292,
0.16606546938419342,
-0.4195391833782196,
-0.2354084849357605,
-0.5421064496040344,
0.3847147226333618,
-0.010911200195550919,
-0.12919171154499054,
-0.32000502943992615,
0.789883553981781,
-0.5917249917984009,
-0.21386171877384186,
-0.4424968659877777,
0.33876603841781616,
-0.12366195023059845,
0.287347674369812,
-0.21834780275821686,
0.773456871509552,
0.6872730255126953,
-0.5838037133216858,
0.7759061455726624,
0.0056682550348341465,
-0.3173901438713074,
0.47697168588638306,
-0.6088266968727112,
0.3636000454425812,
-0.021153708919882774,
0.3089609146118164,
-1.059303641319275,
-0.03532645106315613,
0.24985161423683167,
-0.38507822155952454,
0.4000427722930908,
-0.040517136454582214,
-0.5439465045928955,
-0.19576160609722137,
-0.3541199862957001,
0.4998329281806946,
0.24641373753547668,
-0.4981634318828583,
0.9410297870635986,
0.19230736792087555,
-0.16176079213619232,
-0.5659317374229431,
-0.40314605832099915,
0.30029138922691345,
-0.23707221448421478,
-0.7149919271469116,
0.23112492263317108,
-0.23003394901752472,
-0.5674275755882263,
-0.18730469048023224,
0.06867183744907379,
0.11070097982883453,
0.1922491192817688,
0.10768178105354309,
0.004779532551765442,
-0.12878842651844025,
0.23896339535713196,
-0.06815913319587708,
-0.3345853090286255,
0.3140599727630615,
0.11556568741798401,
0.7019272446632385,
-0.33503708243370056,
-0.4788784980773926,
-0.4213217496871948,
0.027633661404252052,
0.9767380952835083,
-0.6478347778320312,
0.6018511056900024,
0.6774388551712036,
-0.075877346098423,
-0.2461961805820465,
-0.5012431740760803,
-0.3174726963043213,
-0.5791704654693604,
0.4823721647262573,
-0.593367338180542,
-0.6087444424629211,
0.6103251576423645,
-0.26467835903167725,
-0.27804896235466003,
0.3941165804862976,
0.7230101227760315,
0.124864861369133,
1.056840419769287,
0.5349672436714172,
0.2372966855764389,
0.47202375531196594,
-0.19040212035179138,
-0.015147284604609013,
-0.8184584975242615,
-0.2513621747493744,
-0.3507818877696991,
-0.42470210790634155,
-0.762037456035614,
-0.673917293548584,
0.49047428369522095,
-0.36080068349838257,
-0.0026303937193006277,
-0.02130458690226078,
-0.05290750786662102,
0.5147222280502319,
0.2366858422756195,
0.029565533623099327,
0.33433493971824646,
-0.17756503820419312,
-0.11568037420511246,
0.08182387053966522,
-0.22194130718708038,
-0.6962986588478088,
1.0298854112625122,
0.7201626896858215,
0.7253857254981995,
0.3235533535480499,
0.2686592638492584,
0.22392363846302032,
0.2889535129070282,
-0.8617329001426697,
0.8785132765769958,
0.1864936351776123,
-0.5500234365463257,
-0.47977131605148315,
-0.6941646337509155,
-0.8473572731018066,
0.49417394399642944,
-0.12298687547445297,
-0.7712675929069519,
0.1503981649875641,
-0.1274735927581787,
-0.19260479509830475,
0.20982152223587036,
-0.3649553656578064,
0.6140191555023193,
-0.40493741631507874,
-0.5390914678573608,
-0.41393908858299255,
-0.40698152780532837,
0.49822816252708435,
-0.3499533534049988,
-0.11635272204875946,
-0.09596052765846252,
-0.21720603108406067,
0.5012133121490479,
-0.2917284071445465,
0.7638713717460632,
-0.3286464512348175,
-0.36842867732048035,
0.2436685413122177,
0.42089155316352844,
0.7178135514259338,
0.33271151781082153,
-0.18701520562171936,
-0.2182549238204956,
0.26746487617492676,
-0.27217617630958557,
-1.0269014835357666,
0.548215389251709,
-0.5077351331710815,
-0.6821107864379883,
-0.5351586937904358,
-0.647108256816864,
-0.5919017195701599,
0.05072898790240288,
-0.39306896924972534,
0.33270353078842163,
-0.20339520275592804,
0.2938017249107361,
0.38662484288215637,
-0.3165057897567749,
0.463030606508255,
1.183283805847168,
-0.09735646098852158,
-0.3579668700695038,
0.7844014763832092,
-0.015903374180197716,
0.2657743990421295,
0.3246925473213196,
0.37030667066574097,
-0.23793260753154755,
-0.5825199484825134,
-0.2546924352645874,
0.33751991391181946,
-0.5341399312019348,
-0.029966698959469795,
-0.5089700222015381,
0.05124920979142189,
-0.2146766483783722,
0.31872057914733887,
-0.39611414074897766,
-0.06890174746513367,
-0.06665926426649094,
-0.06865157186985016,
-0.005994655191898346,
0.5666950941085815,
-0.06439297646284103,
0.41143423318862915,
-0.7498186230659485,
0.14482074975967407,
0.7140149474143982,
0.34771350026130676,
0.10413135588169098,
-0.4587192237377167,
-0.040492672473192215,
0.09103144705295563,
-0.3090042471885681,
-0.951231062412262,
0.19034035503864288,
0.08434025943279266,
0.8188490271568298,
0.5907627940177917,
-0.11357471346855164,
0.5425921678543091,
-0.46166250109672546,
0.5126588344573975,
-0.287585586309433,
-1.1282025575637817,
0.3287181854248047,
-0.5268535017967224,
0.23219820857048035,
0.6282287836074829,
0.07684996724128723,
-0.27284660935401917,
-0.2409726083278656,
-0.3269086182117462,
-0.4933127164840698,
0.6136532425880432,
0.15334144234657288,
0.4048897922039032,
0.061356205493211746,
0.43339982628822327,
-0.10772520303726196,
0.30468636751174927,
-0.5528437495231628,
0.003564639249816537,
0.22220973670482635,
-0.007032976020127535,
-0.21507932245731354,
-0.6372441649436951,
-0.20058204233646393,
-0.23484231531620026,
0.4156319797039032,
-0.2587224841117859,
0.20807448029518127,
-0.12098874896764755,
-0.2044224739074707,
-0.033404503017663956,
0.24025322496891022,
0.6473121643066406,
1.1434987783432007,
-0.337962806224823,
0.2549869418144226,
0.3599887490272522,
-0.48337405920028687,
0.3746284246444702,
0.02373673766851425,
0.20921163260936737,
-0.3234653174877167,
0.7964403629302979,
0.5592585802078247,
-0.012779741548001766,
-0.8479198813438416,
0.633492112159729,
-0.05970029532909393,
0.08060064166784286,
-0.11801888048648834,
0.06844135373830795,
0.033611785620450974,
0.5553749203681946,
0.2955540418624878,
-0.4771720767021179,
0.0575287789106369,
-0.9398177862167358,
0.34865841269493103,
0.5003856420516968,
-0.13844740390777588,
-0.5074529647827148,
0.23765455186367035,
0.38184261322021484,
-0.30011627078056335,
0.5068449974060059,
-0.38916704058647156,
-0.5306650400161743,
0.6414990425109863,
0.5023972988128662,
0.8790878057479858,
-0.6486234664916992,
0.3479250371456146,
0.0626041367650032,
0.6170260906219482,
0.2888964116573334,
0.33549952507019043,
0.00719112902879715,
-0.5939614772796631,
-0.5074508190155029,
-0.5434937477111816,
-0.523439884185791,
0.30730050802230835,
-0.4872863292694092,
0.20975147187709808,
-0.36656853556632996,
-0.17122606933116913,
-0.2619711458683014,
0.3797444999217987,
-0.6167194247245789,
0.18343575298786163,
0.08168549835681915,
0.7761713862419128,
-0.7638720870018005,
0.8037621974945068,
0.5984158515930176,
-0.30713433027267456,
-0.4758516848087311,
0.2851467728614807,
-0.01654212921857834,
-0.8277973532676697,
0.6119168400764465,
0.14582976698875427,
-0.3519068658351898,
-0.16963855922222137,
-0.2105885148048401,
-1.0219955444335938,
1.2724335193634033,
0.7183864712715149,
-0.4668124318122864,
0.12916964292526245,
0.32481348514556885,
0.8178064823150635,
-0.45197007060050964,
0.7303860783576965,
0.7610253691673279,
0.8420857787132263,
0.04008461534976959,
-0.9244663119316101,
0.2576464116573334,
-0.2470390498638153,
-0.19498194754123688,
-0.08852158486843109,
-0.848361611366272,
0.8332915306091309,
-0.10746189206838608,
-0.3142191171646118,
0.0776398554444313,
0.4485929012298584,
0.17801359295845032,
0.4048921465873718,
0.7164042592048645,
0.3008684515953064,
0.8512917757034302,
-0.028287500143051147,
0.8953426480293274,
-0.4279801845550537,
0.2960832417011261,
1.249564528465271,
-0.4647998511791229,
0.6483020782470703,
0.35111111402511597,
-0.26817557215690613,
0.4662671983242035,
0.4233580529689789,
-0.13501818478107452,
0.2665136456489563,
0.5664362907409668,
-0.14838677644729614,
-0.2231079339981079,
0.0115393977612257,
-0.1556897610425949,
0.9631362557411194,
0.34299275279045105,
-0.2962442636489868,
-0.21458643674850464,
-0.015428649261593819,
0.007377884350717068,
-0.0007869751425459981,
-0.012095198966562748,
0.6318575739860535,
-0.21435433626174927,
-0.5622658729553223,
0.47844114899635315,
0.15682177245616913,
0.29522621631622314,
-0.8249557614326477,
0.03862115740776062,
-0.3300808072090149,
0.12232166528701782,
0.0049559022299945354,
-0.6994761824607849,
0.2677711844444275,
-0.10010664165019989,
0.04873055964708328,
-0.12403890490531921,
0.6039861440658569,
-0.35116952657699585,
-0.31491684913635254,
0.679134726524353,
0.7148768305778503,
0.17079922556877136,
-0.2867544889450073,
-0.678853452205658,
0.3227084279060364,
-0.3422645628452301,
-0.4645601809024811,
0.22031503915786743,
0.37941974401474,
0.09022951126098633,
0.937818169593811,
0.5160820484161377,
0.058154862374067307,
-0.15172016620635986,
0.15341366827487946,
0.9038618803024292,
-0.5522546768188477,
-0.24261021614074707,
-1.0543627738952637,
0.4643026888370514,
0.06387040764093399,
-0.014759618788957596,
0.6999568939208984,
0.378377765417099,
0.24495962262153625,
0.07926619052886963,
0.42778724431991577,
0.2345016449689865,
0.3719644546508789,
-0.49848490953445435,
0.6319859623908997,
-0.5375104546546936,
0.46215957403182983,
-0.4241911768913269,
-1.3367109298706055,
0.06164123862981796,
0.2684406042098999,
-0.2622720003128052,
0.3531605303287506,
0.7724785804748535,
0.7483047246932983,
-0.18341124057769775,
-0.39640554785728455,
0.39675840735435486,
0.4512309432029724,
0.7543715238571167,
0.5306827425956726,
1.0722929239273071,
-0.0191863551735878,
0.517166793346405,
0.09820520877838135,
-0.6457714438438416,
-0.17463333904743195,
-1.0656100511550903,
-1.0178570747375488,
-0.48232629895210266,
-0.2080610692501068,
-0.14678648114204407,
-0.10090944916009903,
0.6259300708770752,
0.4933535158634186,
-0.3833447992801666,
-0.13802079856395721,
0.236190527677536,
0.1080210879445076,
-0.26151371002197266,
-0.2333916425704956,
0.3304959535598755,
-0.2718796730041504,
-1.0570461750030518,
0.9072813987731934,
0.16525492072105408,
-0.012833238579332829,
-0.8235761523246765,
0.04474882408976555,
0.007715215906500816,
0.5347535014152527,
0.6431065797805786,
-0.07991177588701248,
-0.5362615585327148,
-0.38367632031440735,
-0.23376786708831787,
-0.05381330847740173,
-0.3800223469734192,
0.8024669289588928,
-0.8009189963340759,
0.6109104156494141,
0.7763752341270447,
0.7582082152366638,
0.21803520619869232,
0.017550041899085045,
0.5641577243804932,
-0.44752705097198486,
-0.01623576134443283,
0.1775054633617401,
0.28452467918395996,
0.09613778442144394,
-0.2738831639289856,
0.5166563391685486,
0.1747436374425888,
-0.46342772245407104,
-1.083531141281128,
0.2501290738582611,
-1.002257227897644,
-0.15259328484535217,
1.3260952234268188,
-0.06474796682596207,
-0.0905848816037178,
0.24889467656612396,
-0.11131273955106735,
0.0941590815782547,
-0.14360693097114563,
0.7738508582115173,
0.7837269306182861,
0.0808575302362442,
-0.020185766741633415,
-0.6087242364883423,
0.28994879126548767,
0.4228837192058563,
-0.9242092967033386,
0.18364296853542328,
0.33056026697158813,
0.46210867166519165,
0.2890753448009491,
0.5215132832527161,
-0.1373160034418106,
0.10100645571947098,
-0.04198452830314636,
-0.19752460718154907,
-0.39733678102493286,
-0.5770801901817322,
-0.5426289439201355,
0.16453972458839417,
-0.07393665611743927,
-0.2274201661348343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13562v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13562v2
|
Analysis of Multi-Source Language Training in Cross-Lingual Transfer
| 2024-02-21T06:37:07 | 2024-06-05T00:23:55 |
Seong Hoon Lim, Taejun Yun, Jinhyeon Kim, Jihun Choi, Taeuk Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The successful adaptation of multilingual language models (LMs) to a specific
language-task pair critically depends on the availability of data tailored for
that condition. While cross-lingual transfer (XLT) methods have contributed to
addressing this data scarcity problem, there still exists ongoing debate about
the mechanisms behind their effectiveness. In this work, we focus on one of
promising assumptions about inner workings of XLT, that it encourages
multilingual LMs to place greater emphasis on language-agnostic or
task-specific features. We test this hypothesis by examining how the patterns
of XLT change with a varying number of source languages involved in the
process. Our experimental findings show that the use of multiple source
languages in XLT-a technique we term Multi-Source Language Training
(MSLT)-leads to increased mingling of embedding spaces for different languages,
supporting the claim that XLT benefits from making use of language-independent
information. On the other hand, we discover that using an arbitrary combination
of source languages does not always guarantee better performance. We suggest
simple heuristics for identifying effective language combinations for MSLT and
empirically prove its effectiveness.
|
[
-0.3823448419570923,
-0.4400087893009186,
0.4999738037586212,
0.262187123298645,
-0.030114736407995224,
0.4026069939136505,
-0.3702058792114258,
-0.6225215792655945,
0.13889864087104797,
0.15622110664844513,
-0.2801259160041809,
0.12604917585849762,
-0.6466453075408936,
0.19391225278377533,
-0.44216790795326233,
0.8056535124778748,
-0.5139564275741577,
0.3059278130531311,
0.08545425534248352,
-0.48227056860923767,
-0.6124830842018127,
-0.7721222043037415,
-0.5238610506057739,
-0.15927255153656006,
0.6878705620765686,
0.39205101132392883,
0.5550358295440674,
0.6064758896827698,
0.1724310666322708,
0.21489086747169495,
0.2772385776042938,
-0.0573020800948143,
-0.4213313162326813,
-0.07724899798631668,
-0.39692798256874084,
-0.4122447073459625,
0.21318355202674866,
-0.12125749886035919,
0.9780202507972717,
0.7268245220184326,
-0.03173013776540756,
0.016294077038764954,
0.3220447301864624,
0.3937875032424927,
-0.582292914390564,
-0.05223942548036575,
-0.4965828061103821,
0.24766939878463745,
-0.3398050367832184,
-0.234060138463974,
-0.4078806936740875,
0.05772964656352997,
0.2510543763637543,
-0.36915385723114014,
0.055519286543130875,
0.011788321658968925,
0.5711124539375305,
-0.01789882779121399,
-0.6241651773452759,
-0.2750641405582428,
-0.7639962434768677,
0.7905144095420837,
-0.360526442527771,
0.8143834471702576,
0.3817746043205261,
0.21090707182884216,
0.5043195486068726,
-0.16700521111488342,
-0.2076355367898941,
-0.35723474621772766,
-0.3424655795097351,
-0.03807840868830681,
-0.06562463939189911,
-0.37263837456703186,
0.09429742395877838,
0.09706984460353851,
-0.5501907467842102,
-0.00086958147585392,
-0.4907485842704773,
-0.13981066644191742,
0.3329082131385803,
-0.2560945451259613,
0.5311301350593567,
0.01619134470820427,
-0.5684919953346252,
-0.011944467201828957,
-0.6921066641807556,
0.13455942273139954,
0.3071122169494629,
0.5993769764900208,
-0.10972149670124054,
0.5043139457702637,
0.17167776823043823,
0.5040895938873291,
-0.07593268901109695,
0.04908498749136925,
0.1888604760169983,
-0.8322659730911255,
0.12349846959114075,
0.21873268485069275,
0.6935272216796875,
0.002647535176947713,
0.2266072928905487,
-0.5179948806762695,
-0.12199340760707855,
-0.290388822555542,
0.1511894315481186,
-0.4525778889656067,
0.13866613805294037,
-0.023168278858065605,
-0.09159119427204132,
0.026777319610118866,
0.02649025246500969,
-0.2758410573005676,
-0.041670430451631546,
-0.4417930543422699,
0.3596445620059967,
-0.7062821388244629,
-0.563488245010376,
-0.22544598579406738,
-0.13023537397384644,
0.08194234222173691,
0.09463656693696976,
-0.8808513879776001,
0.10681935399770737,
0.3181356191635132,
0.929905354976654,
-0.5037099719047546,
-0.8137440085411072,
-0.7022343873977661,
0.26498809456825256,
-0.36520007252693176,
0.9139254093170166,
-0.5519425272941589,
-0.2556183338165283,
0.09004702419042587,
0.2711915075778961,
-0.5515206456184387,
-0.16975349187850952,
0.19851186871528625,
-0.2570674419403076,
0.17623135447502136,
-0.7920599579811096,
-0.3952869772911072,
-0.0736302062869072,
0.1291792243719101,
-0.7910324931144714,
0.9577871561050415,
0.15505091845989227,
-0.7365866303443909,
0.5248556733131409,
-0.6663350462913513,
-0.581167459487915,
-0.1304078847169876,
-0.20857764780521393,
-0.011626302264630795,
0.11445082724094391,
-0.06940212100744247,
0.20818676054477692,
0.01438634842634201,
0.0017249415395781398,
-0.18439021706581116,
-0.2422400712966919,
0.48213011026382446,
-0.3896675407886505,
0.8771341443061829,
0.35472366213798523,
-0.3700919449329376,
-0.3038840889930725,
-0.5372689962387085,
0.05612554773688316,
0.12116745859384537,
-0.4860820472240448,
-0.7166213989257812,
-0.23140022158622742,
0.1587335169315338,
0.4083392918109894,
-0.03414878994226456,
-0.4898682236671448,
0.13595205545425415,
0.037823375314474106,
0.27228230237960815,
0.5641137361526489,
-0.3979085385799408,
0.6682798862457275,
-0.24743995070457458,
0.5927383899688721,
0.10111904889345169,
-0.165822371840477,
-0.12589460611343384,
-0.19063664972782135,
-0.5707775950431824,
0.004615752026438713,
0.4314309358596802,
0.599038302898407,
-0.9735075235366821,
-0.22469232976436615,
-0.022625679150223732,
-0.1381293088197708,
-0.6267006993293762,
0.435281366109848,
0.5528016090393066,
0.09431734681129456,
0.2892915904521942,
-0.35858187079429626,
-0.5146480798721313,
-0.8685656189918518,
-0.48039406538009644,
0.1679821014404297,
0.5496888756752014,
0.07355049252510071,
0.17233909666538239,
0.13768652081489563,
0.7386202812194824,
0.08031348139047623,
-0.03504535183310509,
-0.5820746421813965,
0.16041654348373413,
-0.30476808547973633,
0.4559021592140198,
0.9634153842926025,
-0.6662143468856812,
-1.1468207836151123,
0.42386394739151,
-0.5423928499221802,
-0.13314273953437805,
-0.28814569115638733,
-0.09618019312620163,
0.5834007859230042,
0.5347588658332825,
-0.2764705419540405,
0.06484372913837433,
0.9169673919677734,
-0.27715134620666504,
0.5634389519691467,
-0.28082409501075745,
0.3253895938396454,
-0.9213417172431946,
0.09282577782869339,
0.032983578741550446,
-0.19682972133159637,
-0.9418904781341553,
0.07210849225521088,
0.31078407168388367,
0.122840516269207,
-0.5204749703407288,
0.5483308434486389,
-0.8340550661087036,
-0.23938867449760437,
-0.2989477515220642,
0.12011776119470596,
-0.14991463720798492,
0.505886971950531,
0.2145758867263794,
0.7301229238510132,
0.6886983513832092,
-0.2221435159444809,
0.011541595682501793,
0.02528364397585392,
-0.18798968195915222,
0.8537721633911133,
-0.19968381524085999,
0.2956376373767853,
0.06562086194753647,
-0.0844036415219307,
-0.9149412512779236,
0.18321730196475983,
0.19388073682785034,
-0.15821857750415802,
0.4677233397960663,
-0.3135155439376831,
-0.4519001543521881,
0.12585684657096863,
-0.11324374377727509,
0.473209947347641,
0.07365407794713974,
-0.43323448300361633,
0.3474624454975128,
0.1566029042005539,
-0.23265178501605988,
-0.8862950205802917,
-0.90445876121521,
0.2131562978029251,
-0.25811630487442017,
-0.4919373691082001,
0.06423138082027435,
-0.15223699808120728,
-0.2689494490623474,
0.2828714847564697,
-0.12451555579900742,
-0.15324172377586365,
0.01707698404788971,
-0.24296598136425018,
0.10021863877773285,
-0.34641653299331665,
0.048841044306755066,
0.05505544692277908,
-0.14820386469364166,
-0.2179543375968933,
-0.524310827255249,
0.2820603549480438,
-0.030006619170308113,
-0.6391189694404602,
0.05315171927213669,
0.7709263563156128,
0.388981431722641,
-0.18801404535770416,
0.8117054104804993,
0.9258637428283691,
0.003459186991676688,
-0.27624937891960144,
-0.3958350718021393,
0.10769383609294891,
-0.35726043581962585,
0.43863025307655334,
-0.6070321798324585,
-0.788672685623169,
0.5028766989707947,
0.24020370841026306,
0.1555352807044983,
0.25023484230041504,
0.4975098967552185,
0.11080306768417358,
0.8934990167617798,
0.8210650086402893,
-0.0964171513915062,
0.6503122448921204,
-0.03535338491201401,
0.1475670337677002,
-0.7227879166603088,
0.14778585731983185,
-0.5358986854553223,
-0.16069146990776062,
-0.6001690030097961,
-0.3928454518318176,
0.13751278817653656,
-0.0755966454744339,
0.07027218490839005,
0.6581023335456848,
-0.01947130635380745,
0.5026479363441467,
0.6585630178451538,
-0.21052372455596924,
0.4115946292877197,
0.19311077892780304,
-0.3042526841163635,
-0.037334516644477844,
-1.0189571380615234,
0.036669839173555374,
0.890880823135376,
0.11043661832809448,
0.5551801919937134,
0.32950425148010254,
0.4425509572029114,
0.043118055909872055,
0.25009071826934814,
-0.4990147352218628,
0.21694239974021912,
-0.27026715874671936,
-0.6538152694702148,
-0.33884134888648987,
-0.45326656103134155,
-1.0020862817764282,
0.6327365040779114,
-0.09241652488708496,
-0.5806318521499634,
0.32132601737976074,
0.05322812497615814,
-0.06574995070695877,
0.3384888172149658,
-0.9103871583938599,
0.8606946468353271,
-0.7097188234329224,
-0.5545809268951416,
-0.20123110711574554,
-0.5605871081352234,
0.14087262749671936,
-0.6901071071624756,
0.5244131684303284,
0.17106349766254425,
0.05056273192167282,
0.4351486265659332,
-0.17315593361854553,
0.7314640879631042,
-0.0733378678560257,
-0.3603895902633667,
0.053227029740810394,
0.09083881974220276,
0.4582950174808502,
-0.2528294324874878,
0.15555359423160553,
0.3756004869937897,
0.13354171812534332,
-0.5130183100700378,
-0.4420921802520752,
0.5731670260429382,
-0.8766565322875977,
-0.4757210910320282,
-0.3140089809894562,
-0.8432542085647583,
-0.47339940071105957,
0.26089873909950256,
0.27176785469055176,
0.24555867910385132,
-0.12080925703048706,
0.11810898780822754,
0.39983800053596497,
-0.21976116299629211,
0.2954525649547577,
0.6104081869125366,
-0.22639185190200806,
-0.15904934704303741,
0.8827494978904724,
0.5301559567451477,
0.7573413848876953,
0.39692917466163635,
0.18757647275924683,
-0.2544504702091217,
-0.4679677188396454,
-0.7280775904655457,
0.28805679082870483,
-0.8804210424423218,
0.2841733396053314,
-0.484114408493042,
-0.21791470050811768,
-0.42365217208862305,
-0.23001675307750702,
-0.5113492608070374,
-0.43872490525245667,
0.19504080712795258,
-0.08080871403217316,
0.09462059289216995,
0.5295100212097168,
-0.4413102865219116,
-0.006563909351825714,
-0.9231433868408203,
-0.022373173385858536,
0.28329890966415405,
0.2889862656593323,
-0.18537095189094543,
-0.5240495800971985,
-0.7502923011779785,
0.14975810050964355,
0.06973208487033844,
-0.9092925190925598,
0.22363807260990143,
0.24253413081169128,
1.0975505113601685,
0.07791171222925186,
-0.2893575131893158,
0.6139432191848755,
-0.5706453919410706,
0.5361199975013733,
0.23357047140598297,
-0.8332862257957458,
0.09812503308057785,
-0.20867495238780975,
0.14458082616329193,
0.3393615484237671,
0.5558517575263977,
-0.848156213760376,
-0.607719898223877,
-0.43718504905700684,
-0.6839705109596252,
1.0371317863464355,
0.19147434830665588,
0.04511204734444618,
0.3572749197483063,
-0.11325200647115707,
0.3688744008541107,
0.06159723922610283,
-0.8958187699317932,
-0.271584689617157,
-0.305974543094635,
0.13211044669151306,
-0.2788029909133911,
-0.03586065024137497,
-0.21277594566345215,
0.031039465218782425,
0.35772889852523804,
-0.17539359629154205,
0.11249426007270813,
0.010355780832469463,
-0.5988821387290955,
-0.3217366933822632,
0.4038800299167633,
0.6166303753852844,
0.6190932393074036,
0.09037941694259644,
0.38731250166893005,
0.29043686389923096,
-0.3035445809364319,
0.3058435618877411,
0.2420985847711563,
-0.039453499019145966,
0.20941093564033508,
0.38253918290138245,
1.03995680809021,
0.278425931930542,
-0.3724232614040375,
0.2811710238456726,
0.14785528182983398,
-0.2697746753692627,
-0.010630246251821518,
-0.008852113038301468,
0.11486756056547165,
0.36741653084754944,
0.3191883862018585,
0.11736256629228592,
-0.08503422141075134,
-0.6696705222129822,
0.17121854424476624,
0.4544736444950104,
-0.3142894208431244,
-0.5246353149414062,
0.3072643578052521,
-0.056438833475112915,
-0.08959997445344925,
0.21363532543182373,
-0.08030282706022263,
-0.5018365979194641,
0.4656256139278412,
0.5875875353813171,
0.8229676485061646,
-0.5562659502029419,
0.1632884442806244,
0.23086035251617432,
0.504544734954834,
-0.20481745898723602,
-0.043593745678663254,
-0.21663932502269745,
-0.8555923104286194,
-0.8066533207893372,
-0.28886187076568604,
-0.47470080852508545,
-0.0897444486618042,
-0.5103263258934021,
0.26428237557411194,
0.2580636739730835,
0.2359113097190857,
-0.05464231222867966,
-0.34458011388778687,
-0.6060457825660706,
-0.3713594973087311,
0.385074645280838,
0.8110119104385376,
-1.0260326862335205,
1.0767629146575928,
0.7407834529876709,
-0.36570122838020325,
-0.9189042448997498,
-0.17620335519313812,
0.1319713145494461,
-1.0255731344223022,
0.7895287871360779,
-0.22783713042736053,
-0.017634226009249687,
-0.15838663280010223,
-0.08855675905942917,
-1.1834303140640259,
0.7119735479354858,
0.5727592706680298,
-0.48129528760910034,
0.01575496233999729,
0.5712669491767883,
0.366008460521698,
-0.3192315697669983,
0.0854903906583786,
0.498454749584198,
0.6178041100502014,
-0.009993326850235462,
-1.3048239946365356,
0.09478013962507248,
-0.22265313565731049,
0.062144581228494644,
0.21373936533927917,
-0.6097123622894287,
0.8583924770355225,
-0.2526130974292755,
-0.2207784354686737,
-0.2659013271331787,
0.16029894351959229,
0.10844273120164871,
0.06822103261947632,
0.6493566036224365,
0.2413957715034485,
0.4537525773048401,
0.0681181326508522,
0.9448366761207581,
-0.44649162888526917,
0.43567293882369995,
0.9517139792442322,
-0.32202011346817017,
0.6184905171394348,
0.5704191327095032,
-0.15145310759544373,
0.31963878870010376,
0.4435558021068573,
0.04589134082198143,
0.6649373769760132,
-0.21009410917758942,
0.14033518731594086,
-0.055745288729667664,
0.05586912855505943,
-0.3780624270439148,
0.37243032455444336,
0.21753022074699402,
-0.3435532748699188,
-0.40895864367485046,
0.4013028144836426,
0.11934982240200043,
-0.3564470708370209,
-0.010603177361190319,
0.54933100938797,
0.0849839448928833,
-0.8704931735992432,
0.7050703763961792,
-0.30766022205352783,
0.4943067729473114,
-0.6662435531616211,
0.1218438670039177,
-0.38046228885650635,
0.0037725172005593777,
-0.1095895916223526,
-0.7676612138748169,
0.41865625977516174,
-0.014418700709939003,
0.08062750846147537,
-0.6913416981697083,
0.6979432702064514,
-0.8680074214935303,
-0.35831332206726074,
0.5055782794952393,
1.0737470388412476,
0.1911046802997589,
0.09744856506586075,
-0.7420341372489929,
0.057125870138406754,
0.1851384937763214,
-0.2838289141654968,
0.8465218544006348,
0.7516910433769226,
-0.020181812345981598,
0.2460363656282425,
0.6784436106681824,
0.4378611147403717,
0.11451272666454315,
0.05899105966091156,
0.5469761490821838,
-0.5253581404685974,
-0.5090615749359131,
-0.753412127494812,
0.5102075934410095,
0.1434580385684967,
-0.057612139731645584,
1.083184003829956,
0.29258430004119873,
1.158576488494873,
0.03129427507519722,
1.1764570474624634,
-0.1718319058418274,
0.31491613388061523,
-0.6679438948631287,
0.47016438841819763,
-0.7345126867294312,
0.2277906835079193,
-0.23154322803020477,
-0.871426522731781,
0.010261007584631443,
0.44679975509643555,
-0.1364591270685196,
0.18028244376182556,
1.0788220167160034,
0.3729150593280792,
-0.23547221720218658,
-0.11285409331321716,
0.4875491261482239,
0.05218157172203064,
0.09039250016212463,
0.6073470115661621,
1.143229603767395,
0.0042511532083153725,
0.8970406651496887,
-0.4080265760421753,
-0.14804308116436005,
-0.16485919058322906,
-0.7715345025062561,
-0.5775622725486755,
-0.7730138897895813,
-0.23814475536346436,
-0.21190518140792847,
0.15105211734771729,
0.798636794090271,
0.7040588855743408,
-0.6816068291664124,
-0.538698136806488,
0.14154000580310822,
-0.019753895699977875,
-0.5939507484436035,
-0.11842872947454453,
0.3720363676548004,
-0.6668368577957153,
-0.7263475060462952,
0.4394342601299286,
0.18723270297050476,
-0.010109434835612774,
-0.43773311376571655,
-0.1333065927028656,
-0.20052921772003174,
-0.12285494804382324,
0.6470882296562195,
0.46791449189186096,
-0.4608203172683716,
-0.4303300678730011,
0.3957245647907257,
-0.21420833468437195,
0.1485075205564499,
1.1091145277023315,
-0.3521832525730133,
0.3287580907344818,
0.3020275831222534,
0.691318929195404,
0.30969420075416565,
-0.2970694601535797,
0.6494055390357971,
-0.8667567372322083,
0.13956211507320404,
-0.28870466351509094,
0.6623983383178711,
0.37184640765190125,
-0.2532651126384735,
0.6150975227355957,
0.4055740237236023,
-0.34434619545936584,
-0.9759352803230286,
0.05178646370768547,
-0.7670865058898926,
-0.5629127621650696,
1.539235234260559,
-0.17508406937122345,
0.0638369470834732,
-0.42183661460876465,
-0.17126111686229706,
0.15099631249904633,
-0.19228027760982513,
0.5775787234306335,
0.9513962864875793,
-0.2684944272041321,
-0.44931674003601074,
-0.7572383880615234,
0.30027756094932556,
0.45972636342048645,
-0.578685998916626,
0.13229644298553467,
0.2370539903640747,
0.420138955116272,
0.5229470133781433,
0.5949134230613708,
0.12893080711364746,
0.28889673948287964,
0.06413232535123825,
-0.11950811743736267,
0.09775922447443008,
-0.20082707703113556,
-0.32942548394203186,
0.08692290633916855,
0.2081482708454132,
-0.0122010987251997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13561v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13561v2
|
Cognitive Visual-Language Mapper: Advancing Multimodal Comprehension with Enhanced Visual Knowledge Alignment
| 2024-02-21T06:34:46 | 2024-06-26T07:05:21 |
Yunxin Li, Xinyu Chen, Baotian Hu, Haoyuan Shi, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Evaluating and Rethinking the current landscape of Large Multimodal Models
(LMMs), we observe that widely-used visual-language projection approaches
(e.g., Q-former or MLP) focus on the alignment of image-text descriptions yet
ignore the visual knowledge-dimension alignment, i.e., connecting visuals to
their relevant knowledge. Visual knowledge plays a significant role in
analyzing, inferring, and interpreting information from visuals, helping
improve the accuracy of answers to knowledge-based visual questions. In this
paper, we mainly explore improving LMMs with visual-language knowledge
alignment, especially aimed at challenging knowledge-based visual question
answering (VQA). To this end, we present a Cognitive Visual-Language Mapper
(CVLM), which contains a pretrained Visual Knowledge Aligner (VKA) and a
Fine-grained Knowledge Adapter (FKA) used in the multimodal instruction tuning
stage. Specifically, we design the VKA based on the interaction between a small
language model and a visual encoder, training it on collected image-knowledge
pairs to achieve visual knowledge acquisition and projection. FKA is employed
to distill the fine-grained visual knowledge of an image and inject it into
Large Language Models (LLMs). We conduct extensive experiments on
knowledge-based VQA benchmarks and experimental results show that CVLM
significantly improves the performance of LMMs on knowledge-based VQA (average
gain by 5.0%). Ablation studies also verify the effectiveness of VKA and FKA,
respectively. The codes are available at
https://github.com/HITsz-TMG/Cognitive-Visual-Language-Mapper
|
[
-0.4892282783985138,
-0.8901074528694153,
0.7581841349601746,
0.049104295670986176,
-0.29790377616882324,
0.0269465409219265,
-0.4691050052642822,
-0.4370577037334442,
-0.2334616780281067,
0.562999963760376,
-0.3784101605415344,
-0.4372309744358063,
-0.5886077284812927,
-0.4729624390602112,
-0.0954211875796318,
0.47895947098731995,
-0.08653594553470612,
0.24807597696781158,
-0.7857210040092468,
-0.2830396592617035,
-0.8966313004493713,
-0.14477413892745972,
-0.38221773505210876,
-0.10042352974414825,
0.5637920498847961,
0.4096914529800415,
0.6927874684333801,
0.5845763683319092,
0.6107877492904663,
0.38819706439971924,
0.2191898673772812,
0.2918441891670227,
-0.33901771903038025,
0.07637634128332138,
-0.12524080276489258,
-0.5106455087661743,
-0.37225914001464844,
-0.44075044989585876,
0.44465023279190063,
0.29464709758758545,
-0.19305945932865143,
0.21335090696811676,
-0.1369236558675766,
0.5824800729751587,
-0.8717993497848511,
0.3861904740333557,
-0.744815468788147,
-0.2636607885360718,
-0.03224818781018257,
-0.26384904980659485,
-0.31083062291145325,
-0.20075657963752747,
0.2413724809885025,
-0.9576966762542725,
-0.21564440429210663,
0.12652641534805298,
0.9002683758735657,
0.5976120233535767,
-0.560674250125885,
-0.13259200751781464,
-0.5084841847419739,
0.9418590068817139,
-0.4409751892089844,
0.5778795480728149,
0.2707673907279968,
0.7007828950881958,
0.1905955672264099,
-0.6476992964744568,
-1.0175544023513794,
0.02906300313770771,
0.10839486122131348,
0.5153417587280273,
-0.05144496262073517,
0.1181149035692215,
0.2198614776134491,
0.2614951729774475,
-0.6360774040222168,
0.011618412099778652,
-0.3999076187610626,
-0.21348276734352112,
0.17338062822818756,
0.1536499559879303,
0.4527439773082733,
-0.0462530218064785,
-0.6552788615226746,
-0.3070477545261383,
-0.38205888867378235,
0.2401604950428009,
-0.2018948495388031,
-0.0703919380903244,
-0.006499448791146278,
0.8904188275337219,
-0.2655012607574463,
1.1586592197418213,
-0.24366118013858795,
-0.3011510968208313,
0.15129780769348145,
-0.5638819932937622,
-0.31118711829185486,
-0.17028672993183136,
0.5808036923408508,
0.7819264531135559,
0.5842209458351135,
0.27363845705986023,
0.04498620331287384,
0.30635106563568115,
0.37685632705688477,
-0.6719539761543274,
-0.25080421566963196,
-0.015650736168026924,
-0.16421575844287872,
0.10179819166660309,
-0.23953235149383545,
-0.6541203856468201,
-0.2942007780075073,
-0.6059772372245789,
0.6090328097343445,
-0.7044949531555176,
-0.07948975265026093,
0.08180642873048782,
-0.4177912473678589,
0.6502413153648376,
0.6818182468414307,
-0.7172932028770447,
-0.17781753838062286,
0.3370288908481598,
0.35839828848838806,
0.11942427605390549,
-0.2914044260978699,
-0.2824155390262604,
0.4445977807044983,
-0.09657654911279678,
0.8303690552711487,
-0.5584235191345215,
0.10883883386850357,
0.1538037210702896,
-0.1880090981721878,
-0.24221210181713104,
-0.3216678202152252,
0.16305454075336456,
-0.808484673500061,
0.27075591683387756,
-0.4221213459968567,
-0.365103155374527,
-0.3636265993118286,
0.6834261417388916,
-0.40136194229125977,
0.7162840366363525,
0.016433710232377052,
-0.5972344279289246,
0.35984155535697937,
-0.42623820900917053,
-0.02472466044127941,
0.05121989548206329,
-0.4298985004425049,
-0.016999932006001472,
-0.024345260113477707,
0.6054692268371582,
0.20439131557941437,
-0.33798515796661377,
-0.08823056519031525,
-0.3517749011516571,
-0.14076784253120422,
0.4005221128463745,
-0.33257976174354553,
0.5364962816238403,
0.09776240587234497,
-0.05466894805431366,
0.3206762373447418,
-0.5070234537124634,
0.38796788454055786,
0.241256982088089,
-0.2574937343597412,
-0.4335663318634033,
-0.14433707296848297,
0.10985244065523148,
0.5788313746452332,
0.5539286732673645,
-0.3296125531196594,
0.27254992723464966,
0.0010448487009853125,
0.17000585794448853,
0.6824589967727661,
-0.19116924703121185,
0.5673532485961914,
-0.2795766592025757,
0.5270111560821533,
0.24882453680038452,
0.4723683297634125,
-0.2656839191913605,
-0.5184710025787354,
-0.9199382662773132,
-0.46749866008758545,
0.14088411629199982,
0.659274697303772,
-1.4531806707382202,
-0.06736008077859879,
-0.533405065536499,
-0.3777492940425873,
-0.760615885257721,
0.36850547790527344,
0.513538122177124,
0.5921666622161865,
0.5499792098999023,
-0.2957666218280792,
-0.21662063896656036,
-0.8075802326202393,
-0.26705706119537354,
-0.10609422624111176,
0.06806372106075287,
0.26247638463974,
0.14856107532978058,
-0.3175470232963562,
0.8072547316551208,
-0.625453531742096,
-0.45773249864578247,
0.031425487250089645,
-0.13698486983776093,
-0.2409430295228958,
0.25703197717666626,
0.5635803937911987,
-0.8492730855941772,
-0.36919113993644714,
0.11971736699342728,
-0.7938070297241211,
0.1784580796957016,
0.08133899420499802,
-0.24569116532802582,
0.17738281190395355,
0.493120938539505,
-0.4748747944831848,
0.2915850579738617,
0.7478646039962769,
-0.3044535517692566,
0.3437136709690094,
-0.2923922836780548,
0.2840309739112854,
-0.9542470574378967,
-0.16584981977939606,
-0.06158691644668579,
-0.18588082492351532,
-0.46170634031295776,
0.35143929719924927,
0.2200089991092682,
0.09758871048688889,
-0.5223439931869507,
0.48568275570869446,
-0.5008988380432129,
0.17280754446983337,
-0.16936558485031128,
0.6470000743865967,
-0.03281662240624428,
0.712057888507843,
0.17117072641849518,
0.5172412991523743,
0.5370801091194153,
-0.30194416642189026,
0.33879947662353516,
0.22530047595500946,
-0.44505035877227783,
0.8177079558372498,
-0.35185688734054565,
0.14966118335723877,
-0.19869080185890198,
-0.08291234821081161,
-1.0667580366134644,
0.04021650180220604,
0.1233154758810997,
-0.3627622425556183,
0.29137417674064636,
-0.1924125701189041,
-0.26542896032333374,
-0.2201450616121292,
-0.14005181193351746,
0.7448453903198242,
0.3813870847225189,
-0.4593878984451294,
0.8072588443756104,
0.24477244913578033,
-0.08254079520702362,
-0.8742669224739075,
-0.6672699451446533,
-0.07785379886627197,
-0.04308293014764786,
-0.8302256464958191,
0.12085394561290741,
-0.299198716878891,
-0.08825231343507767,
-0.004183969926089048,
0.0067261154763400555,
-0.19066409766674042,
-0.1516854166984558,
0.21736562252044678,
0.3783344328403473,
-0.4106375277042389,
0.1558314561843872,
0.03282434865832329,
-0.05293858051300049,
-0.055952753871679306,
-0.31141117215156555,
0.5556183457374573,
-0.33688774704933167,
-0.4382154941558838,
-0.15947820246219635,
0.10701765865087509,
0.7114120125770569,
-0.6654235124588013,
0.7565880417823792,
0.8626759648323059,
-0.22289016842842102,
0.2555047571659088,
-0.6462032794952393,
0.1922723799943924,
-0.4033927321434021,
0.3700367510318756,
-0.48797276616096497,
-0.9027187824249268,
0.19759869575500488,
-0.06921056658029556,
0.05017073452472687,
0.31125855445861816,
0.49350446462631226,
-0.38721439242362976,
0.8578609228134155,
0.6192695498466492,
0.16802753508090973,
0.7682741284370422,
-0.06991163641214371,
0.023526404052972794,
-0.9432570338249207,
-0.26950135827064514,
-0.17541329562664032,
-0.21494874358177185,
-0.3470068573951721,
-0.8142896294593811,
0.2919168472290039,
0.16568021476268768,
-0.09668701142072678,
0.056728895753622055,
-0.21729394793510437,
0.4209933578968048,
0.6170994639396667,
0.07496464997529984,
0.4049472212791443,
-0.027721256017684937,
-0.07170228660106659,
-0.16487760841846466,
-0.7568414807319641,
-0.2538836896419525,
0.9777209162712097,
-0.03192315623164177,
0.6675812005996704,
0.21202561259269714,
0.28635382652282715,
-0.22208938002586365,
0.025962630286812782,
-0.7411639094352722,
0.44142016768455505,
0.05488483980298042,
-0.390511691570282,
-0.3762398362159729,
-0.2638099491596222,
-0.6583735346794128,
0.4641396105289459,
-0.5244753360748291,
-0.5246478319168091,
0.09536992758512497,
0.4002406895160675,
-0.06381647288799286,
-0.03895704448223114,
-0.8469609618186951,
1.1651462316513062,
-0.5104024410247803,
-0.2640647292137146,
-0.38984858989715576,
-0.6295517683029175,
0.5884197354316711,
-0.027038108557462692,
0.3809923231601715,
0.13940098881721497,
0.006307525094598532,
0.30395323038101196,
-0.0917045846581459,
0.5901567935943604,
-0.29121726751327515,
-0.16610406339168549,
0.13458582758903503,
-0.15788036584854126,
0.13022758066654205,
-0.058339472860097885,
0.4607278108596802,
0.0660736933350563,
0.3597759008407593,
-0.5996753573417664,
-0.8382343649864197,
0.6480123996734619,
-0.6825653910636902,
-0.6418408751487732,
-0.13310948014259338,
-0.8253796696662903,
-0.14287911355495453,
0.2602379620075226,
-0.03659152612090111,
0.44943973422050476,
-0.1186770498752594,
0.3392024636268616,
0.71172696352005,
-0.4028596878051758,
0.16396653652191162,
0.46307578682899475,
-0.5319874286651611,
-0.48753753304481506,
1.1300967931747437,
0.030329616740345955,
0.5492441058158875,
0.724539577960968,
-0.0753098800778389,
-0.23116347193717957,
-0.5228726863861084,
-0.5618569850921631,
-0.03443638235330582,
-0.7908948659896851,
-0.1630782037973404,
-0.5325499176979065,
-0.09608358144760132,
-0.26525458693504333,
-0.08469917625188828,
-0.2017108052968979,
-0.4181658923625946,
0.07248271256685257,
0.2984001636505127,
0.17699822783470154,
0.2901270091533661,
0.4173569679260254,
0.39501962065696716,
-0.569346010684967,
0.664326012134552,
0.6465926766395569,
0.032354313880205154,
-0.23282447457313538,
-0.370206743478775,
-0.4120529294013977,
0.2304842472076416,
-0.33010879158973694,
-0.6930294632911682,
0.08394084125757217,
0.10138759762048721,
0.44481369853019714,
0.40890130400657654,
-0.056255944073200226,
1.041334629058838,
-0.2953585386276245,
0.6696880459785461,
0.3493010997772217,
-0.7234559059143066,
0.38505080342292786,
-0.27496233582496643,
0.9137046337127686,
0.4455958604812622,
-0.11705373227596283,
-0.5656453371047974,
-0.5388219356536865,
-0.15493537485599518,
-0.7415345907211304,
0.3761614263057709,
0.09124395996332169,
-0.12721426784992218,
0.1626477688550949,
-0.022092951461672783,
-0.2545209228992462,
0.2381066530942917,
-0.5188440084457397,
-0.13461384177207947,
-0.45519348978996277,
-0.6767975687980652,
-0.19778136909008026,
-0.2219858467578888,
-0.24844704568386078,
-0.22297227382659912,
0.48079216480255127,
-0.5157984495162964,
0.23050454258918762,
0.0062077040784060955,
-0.7870691418647766,
0.058297768235206604,
0.298159122467041,
0.8832018375396729,
0.8328067064285278,
-0.007209010887891054,
0.2788746654987335,
0.23927345871925354,
-0.40454214811325073,
-0.27194809913635254,
0.05446341633796692,
-0.017239775508642197,
-0.4956798851490021,
0.4512331187725067,
0.657275378704071,
0.20957286655902863,
-0.881838858127594,
0.6907592415809631,
-0.4615984559059143,
-0.0029470198787748814,
-0.2941157817840576,
0.10260754078626633,
0.36033880710601807,
0.5089864134788513,
0.13465635478496552,
0.15436381101608276,
-0.18098492920398712,
-0.4598938822746277,
-0.16292960941791534,
0.684567391872406,
-0.49689579010009766,
-0.0358649343252182,
0.5073264241218567,
-0.0645485371351242,
0.03733421862125397,
0.7298845052719116,
0.45621025562286377,
-0.4866189956665039,
0.43863531947135925,
0.4072876274585724,
0.21642522513866425,
-0.19228915870189667,
-0.04855334758758545,
0.1417086273431778,
0.5704454779624939,
0.39535489678382874,
0.4859529137611389,
-0.2807585299015045,
-0.8421683311462402,
-0.441415399312973,
-0.47309330105781555,
-0.07807546854019165,
-0.24144260585308075,
-0.7623906135559082,
0.1754676252603531,
-0.33588647842407227,
-0.05984765663743019,
-0.09230296313762665,
-0.22361232340335846,
-1.1756091117858887,
0.3129545748233795,
0.2282363474369049,
0.8169325590133667,
-0.5382753014564514,
1.11622154712677,
0.8570058941841125,
-0.5833262801170349,
-0.4578266739845276,
-0.08707785606384277,
-0.11429867893457413,
-1.1369129419326782,
0.3534316122531891,
-0.04029699042439461,
-0.05340663716197014,
0.11137807369232178,
-0.4425061047077179,
-0.8157181739807129,
1.4177281856536865,
0.46566036343574524,
-0.7068902850151062,
0.10927995294332504,
0.15332652628421783,
0.5157386660575867,
-0.17292112112045288,
0.3731095492839813,
0.18132585287094116,
0.6639998555183411,
0.05112212151288986,
-0.7732207775115967,
0.012984697706997395,
-0.16738413274288177,
0.08925080299377441,
0.2960822880268097,
-0.6395197510719299,
0.2969473600387573,
-0.24116475880146027,
0.004102827049791813,
0.02750840038061142,
0.7813000082969666,
0.27169328927993774,
0.3245249390602112,
0.5958372354507446,
0.6336050629615784,
0.5958405137062073,
-0.1540095955133438,
0.9164382219314575,
-0.25789394974708557,
-0.012998457998037338,
1.3032485246658325,
0.16825640201568604,
0.9864225387573242,
1.0390427112579346,
0.28590840101242065,
0.5605152249336243,
0.2504078447818756,
0.28731805086135864,
0.4340260624885559,
-0.06629393994808197,
0.018677128478884697,
-0.5977508425712585,
-0.06017225608229637,
-0.3494240641593933,
0.5062368512153625,
0.4060797095298767,
-0.22349224984645844,
-0.020473862066864967,
0.12197514623403549,
-0.48798686265945435,
0.1392873227596283,
-0.17479531466960907,
0.9764450192451477,
0.10582315921783447,
-0.6745697259902954,
0.5139362812042236,
-0.23026292026042938,
0.3880821466445923,
-0.6103745698928833,
-0.08810054510831833,
0.06242561712861061,
0.3150995075702667,
0.07561285048723221,
-0.916812002658844,
-0.0010480216005817056,
-0.3398929238319397,
-0.36720120906829834,
-0.0773981586098671,
0.7209209203720093,
-0.8915894627571106,
-0.1828317493200302,
0.3226867616176605,
0.5795277953147888,
-0.2301715761423111,
-0.1569218635559082,
-0.6422730088233948,
0.13998150825500488,
-0.08035854995250702,
-0.04641350358724594,
0.34597647190093994,
0.46348053216934204,
-0.21716046333312988,
0.6390167474746704,
0.5619296431541443,
-0.42151200771331787,
0.3502308428287506,
0.09878826141357422,
0.8318529725074768,
-0.6559202075004578,
-0.1397480070590973,
-0.5307173132896423,
0.7604367136955261,
-0.03525702282786369,
-0.18063092231750488,
0.7294682860374451,
0.36307311058044434,
0.9629741311073303,
-0.31336918473243713,
0.5555257201194763,
0.011349903419613838,
-0.21012257039546967,
-0.8197633624076843,
0.6227428317070007,
-0.7950937747955322,
-0.10499407351016998,
-0.2934657633304596,
-0.9282506108283997,
-0.20331236720085144,
0.297498881816864,
-0.3090687692165375,
-0.15570051968097687,
0.7351405620574951,
0.7306428551673889,
-0.08521413803100586,
-0.3018453121185303,
0.5348256230354309,
0.18676379323005676,
0.29163363575935364,
0.7575410604476929,
1.1028743982315063,
-0.47374284267425537,
0.8509229421615601,
-0.2430444061756134,
-0.1451750099658966,
-0.0961286872625351,
-0.6301345825195312,
-0.9117942452430725,
-0.8512591123580933,
-0.21462635695934296,
-0.027326006442308426,
0.0063211130909621716,
0.45893603563308716,
0.5428835153579712,
-0.3468145728111267,
-0.02808685600757599,
0.2034268081188202,
0.21929891407489777,
-0.4325578808784485,
-0.19020798802375793,
0.11959276348352432,
-0.22562868893146515,
-0.655467689037323,
0.28052181005477905,
0.30173248052597046,
-0.094239242374897,
-0.10516395419836044,
-0.19073551893234253,
-0.245211660861969,
0.04377080872654915,
0.8229120373725891,
0.11236216127872467,
-0.9345947504043579,
-0.3694542348384857,
0.08387644588947296,
-0.22042560577392578,
-0.010322969406843185,
0.5615924000740051,
-0.753664493560791,
1.0075515508651733,
0.5798945426940918,
0.6152752041816711,
0.7077401280403137,
-0.053689226508140564,
0.6285678744316101,
-0.5610772371292114,
0.04710248112678528,
-0.25478556752204895,
0.45543017983436584,
0.34068548679351807,
-0.1119016781449318,
0.047241680324077606,
0.03426565229892731,
-0.3909941613674164,
-0.4554786682128906,
0.2817058265209198,
-1.5303966999053955,
-0.28868237137794495,
0.899814784526825,
0.1481514722108841,
-0.47385576367378235,
0.03948274999856949,
-0.6471871733665466,
0.3235244154930115,
-0.20258620381355286,
0.5899624824523926,
0.636404812335968,
0.3675042390823364,
-0.5593717694282532,
-0.53729248046875,
0.2517930567264557,
0.43215852975845337,
-0.7858287692070007,
-0.1435667723417282,
0.5465919971466064,
0.20349285006523132,
0.20827710628509521,
0.45178186893463135,
-0.04199535399675369,
0.502378523349762,
-0.20406287908554077,
0.37847113609313965,
-0.17598456144332886,
-0.3091922402381897,
-0.21326309442520142,
0.09938446432352066,
0.1495676189661026,
-0.38692691922187805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13551v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13551v2
|
Fine-Grained Modeling of Narrative Context: A Coherence Perspective via Retrospective Questions
| 2024-02-21T06:14:04 | 2024-06-04T03:26:19 |
Liyan Xu, Jiangnan Li, Mo Yu, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This work introduces an original and practical paradigm for narrative
comprehension, stemming from the characteristics that individual passages
within narratives tend to be more cohesively related than isolated.
Complementary to the common end-to-end paradigm, we propose a fine-grained
modeling of narrative context, by formulating a graph dubbed NarCo, which
explicitly depicts task-agnostic coherence dependencies that are ready to be
consumed by various downstream tasks. In particular, edges in NarCo encompass
free-form retrospective questions between context snippets, inspired by human
cognitive perception that constantly reinstates relevant events from prior
context. Importantly, our graph formalism is practically instantiated by LLMs
without human annotations, through our designed two-stage prompting scheme. To
examine the graph properties and its utility, we conduct three studies in
narratives, each from a unique angle: edge relation efficacy, local context
enrichment, and broader application in QA. All tasks could benefit from the
explicit coherence captured by NarCo.
|
[
-0.4723941385746002,
-1.1546151638031006,
0.9313288927078247,
0.012045503593981266,
-0.23525968194007874,
-0.04851526767015457,
0.057090096175670624,
-0.7811520099639893,
0.42144665122032166,
0.5439040064811707,
-0.7692447304725647,
-0.41522300243377686,
-0.11089567095041275,
0.0016128311399370432,
-0.6020542979240417,
1.354845404624939,
-0.24457362294197083,
-0.2963414490222931,
-0.4337642192840576,
-0.3127068281173706,
-0.6837104558944702,
-0.24908065795898438,
-0.5870713591575623,
-0.5627646446228027,
0.7527000308036804,
0.4213857650756836,
0.4621245265007019,
0.49785342812538147,
0.21791678667068481,
0.15916764736175537,
0.025409987196326256,
-0.05744213983416557,
-0.6723814606666565,
0.38991469144821167,
-0.24092595279216766,
-0.49318715929985046,
-0.6519497036933899,
-0.13021144270896912,
0.24391937255859375,
1.1562244892120361,
-0.01182123925536871,
0.23917615413665771,
0.4985276162624359,
0.41195571422576904,
-0.6397398114204407,
0.14111436903476715,
-0.29104527831077576,
-0.014619626104831696,
0.20001652836799622,
-0.41997000575065613,
-0.4187200665473938,
-0.23927034437656403,
0.43111440539360046,
-1.097668170928955,
0.27071595191955566,
0.05312439054250717,
0.9418097138404846,
0.16302943229675293,
-0.561278223991394,
-0.48858362436294556,
-0.7445134520530701,
0.39626431465148926,
-0.15146274864673615,
-0.06419987976551056,
0.4609939157962799,
0.3887980878353119,
0.14473335444927216,
-1.166900873184204,
-0.32826468348503113,
-0.07512512058019638,
-0.1402028650045395,
0.22164545953273773,
-0.2226434051990509,
0.04070761799812317,
-0.20728139579296112,
0.5437064170837402,
-0.42159152030944824,
-0.02719440497457981,
-0.16553951799869537,
-0.2819991111755371,
0.3344309628009796,
0.689358651638031,
0.43110597133636475,
-0.1396954357624054,
-0.8419361710548401,
0.027149343863129616,
-0.5708270072937012,
0.3691681921482086,
-0.025121541693806648,
0.2248070389032364,
-0.4375509023666382,
0.17827153205871582,
-0.6111926436424255,
0.7471781969070435,
0.13835835456848145,
-0.10867689549922943,
-0.08097756654024124,
-0.6007540822029114,
-0.0906224474310875,
0.04440399259328842,
0.4919080436229706,
0.6950633525848389,
0.2803497910499573,
-0.2436298280954361,
0.02464747615158558,
0.006862975656986237,
0.3852583169937134,
-0.7611256241798401,
-0.07910837978124619,
0.38101842999458313,
-0.23151440918445587,
-0.2236151546239853,
-0.24319250881671906,
-0.6979866623878479,
-0.29344871640205383,
-0.48608630895614624,
0.4514213502407074,
-0.5247735381126404,
0.13953709602355957,
0.11836983263492584,
-0.2785550653934479,
0.20568843185901642,
0.6116434931755066,
-0.642794668674469,
0.3077356517314911,
0.6426239013671875,
0.8968992829322815,
0.014581556431949139,
-0.4036237895488739,
-0.543324887752533,
0.3513556122779846,
-0.35183924436569214,
1.0441646575927734,
-0.258695513010025,
-0.1131419911980629,
-0.02701454609632492,
0.10120376199483871,
0.1221570149064064,
-0.06257477402687073,
0.39779797196388245,
-0.5841050148010254,
0.2617872357368469,
-0.30855563282966614,
-0.4072013199329376,
-0.5060601234436035,
0.6414278149604797,
-0.47256603837013245,
0.6380965113639832,
0.2085215449333191,
-0.5553414821624756,
0.45709139108657837,
-0.16849195957183838,
-0.34592971205711365,
0.1252545267343521,
-0.2155556082725525,
-0.0025489437393844128,
-0.0647808238863945,
0.052991945296525955,
0.14454974234104156,
-0.06005772203207016,
0.6804893016815186,
-0.1685686856508255,
-0.4734119474887848,
-0.13308291137218475,
-0.33648377656936646,
0.7985225319862366,
0.18410418927669525,
-0.07871833443641663,
0.08672691136598587,
-0.700813353061676,
0.13504023849964142,
-0.1397169977426529,
-0.043456945568323135,
-0.5872901678085327,
-0.07398369163274765,
0.009269090369343758,
0.005161382723599672,
0.20436929166316986,
-0.1972840428352356,
0.035879023373126984,
-0.3738234341144562,
0.31495368480682373,
0.382365345954895,
0.5245687961578369,
0.5609961152076721,
-0.4751507341861725,
0.6663588881492615,
-0.22211669385433197,
0.06936081498861313,
-0.710929274559021,
-0.3992280960083008,
-0.4802679121494293,
-0.23481884598731995,
-0.04518396034836769,
0.5027028918266296,
-0.6700440049171448,
0.018831923604011536,
-0.12536607682704926,
-0.275743305683136,
0.3015079200267792,
-0.3059871792793274,
0.42590591311454773,
0.7884691953659058,
0.35308462381362915,
-0.5193557143211365,
-0.556696355342865,
-0.8319478631019592,
-0.14935767650604248,
-0.06636326760053635,
-0.10740937292575836,
0.33090463280677795,
0.4785277843475342,
0.012853523716330528,
1.3224960565567017,
-0.7438085675239563,
-0.3026654124259949,
-0.3271435797214508,
0.18465732038021088,
0.08281835168600082,
0.36217403411865234,
0.4977801740169525,
-0.39855682849884033,
-0.4152819514274597,
-0.07308714836835861,
-0.9430795907974243,
-0.16385827958583832,
-0.2895631194114685,
-0.17267988622188568,
-0.24280959367752075,
0.7970336079597473,
-0.1043451651930809,
0.477914959192276,
0.42843741178512573,
-0.6263726949691772,
0.48463380336761475,
-0.2991141676902771,
0.10448335856199265,
-1.0676566362380981,
0.16531245410442352,
-0.20706932246685028,
-0.24593889713287354,
-0.8676920533180237,
0.21402554214000702,
-0.16106174886226654,
0.0004559290246106684,
-0.3235507607460022,
0.734810471534729,
-0.3920793831348419,
0.026615533977746964,
-0.16605855524539948,
0.5400351881980896,
0.6887534856796265,
0.6524951457977295,
-0.1368563026189804,
0.4413881301879883,
0.3446508049964905,
-0.5977684855461121,
-0.24451829493045807,
0.3288736939430237,
-0.29594576358795166,
1.105019450187683,
-0.8338283896446228,
0.14196240901947021,
-0.21522118151187897,
0.6102354526519775,
-1.096891164779663,
-0.43787482380867004,
0.20767617225646973,
-0.19195115566253662,
0.08025816082954407,
-0.19639721512794495,
-0.15210402011871338,
0.13512498140335083,
-0.18727633357048035,
0.5193639397621155,
0.254655122756958,
-0.3019533157348633,
0.4530106484889984,
0.31180909276008606,
-0.23265978693962097,
-0.2585911154747009,
-0.7414106130599976,
0.16258874535560608,
-0.26068857312202454,
-0.7149598002433777,
0.3217570185661316,
0.02947804518043995,
-0.44581329822540283,
-0.21193401515483856,
-0.023105183616280556,
-0.5073294639587402,
0.07686618715524673,
0.4586246609687805,
0.24774578213691711,
-0.22802603244781494,
-0.08474265038967133,
0.2930266857147217,
-0.14863137900829315,
-0.03860348463058472,
-0.22751525044441223,
0.6415238380432129,
-0.2597130537033081,
-0.08741873502731323,
-0.3992006480693817,
0.5256273150444031,
0.28839656710624695,
-0.029588207602500916,
0.3431395888328552,
0.4658137559890747,
-0.2696801722049713,
-0.1510055512189865,
-0.06980019062757492,
-0.035240162163972855,
-0.42798522114753723,
0.1334168165922165,
-0.2763339579105377,
-0.92268306016922,
0.9751699566841125,
0.09384924918413162,
-0.3239787817001343,
0.25006455183029175,
0.41019541025161743,
-0.12654756009578705,
0.6189196109771729,
0.5427008867263794,
0.3465549349784851,
0.4915476143360138,
-0.5173237323760986,
-0.05890752747654915,
-0.8869420289993286,
-0.2980785071849823,
-0.17387229204177856,
-0.25188568234443665,
-0.06852909177541733,
-0.16770526766777039,
0.4458234906196594,
0.43039265275001526,
-0.22806663811206818,
0.12729324400424957,
-0.3408585488796234,
0.5345816016197205,
0.2825145423412323,
0.03226979076862335,
0.7271789908409119,
-0.21294811367988586,
-0.17086540162563324,
0.22498291730880737,
-0.5488372445106506,
-0.70685213804245,
0.5266820192337036,
0.24342972040176392,
0.5502496361732483,
-0.27963048219680786,
0.6169776916503906,
0.07545258849859238,
0.043409690260887146,
-0.7161195874214172,
0.4888868033885956,
0.25126510858535767,
-0.7936863899230957,
-0.1723291426897049,
0.11846408993005753,
-1.3192092180252075,
0.21668700873851776,
0.0062213377095758915,
-1.2122923135757446,
0.674171507358551,
0.08235902339220047,
-0.9198172688484192,
-0.03274579346179962,
-0.7106700539588928,
0.8885785937309265,
0.28396543860435486,
-0.5607770085334778,
0.030995212495326996,
-0.847335696220398,
0.3155496418476105,
0.17934246361255646,
0.18716642260551453,
-0.185561865568161,
-0.06648469716310501,
0.5061041712760925,
-0.5753030776977539,
1.0506538152694702,
0.09886359423398972,
-0.1132645383477211,
0.7929195761680603,
0.505677342414856,
0.480499267578125,
0.26518696546554565,
0.2893849313259125,
0.2370065450668335,
0.38093334436416626,
-0.2720547318458557,
-0.40535134077072144,
0.4288625419139862,
-0.31032103300094604,
-0.26487845182418823,
-0.20064309239387512,
-1.1337940692901611,
-0.12751677632331848,
0.4734874665737152,
0.2910822033882141,
0.9196441173553467,
-0.5043151378631592,
0.07751978188753128,
0.026951530948281288,
-0.08111664652824402,
0.5558774471282959,
0.32508766651153564,
-0.3820657432079315,
-0.32098209857940674,
0.5938993692398071,
0.15959827601909637,
0.45234930515289307,
0.06770234555006027,
0.0915416032075882,
0.018431726843118668,
-0.627858579158783,
-0.4141888916492462,
-0.20347005128860474,
-0.7980923056602478,
-0.1173323392868042,
-0.6317541599273682,
0.04515473544597626,
0.24756617844104767,
-0.6873542666435242,
-0.18655188381671906,
-0.3180901110172272,
-0.25860464572906494,
0.017229583114385605,
0.3421517014503479,
0.8850898742675781,
0.047902513295412064,
0.22066958248615265,
-0.5150951147079468,
0.429122656583786,
0.19207778573036194,
0.27849406003952026,
0.21224093437194824,
-0.20488479733467102,
-0.5325945019721985,
0.14983384311199188,
-0.49021288752555847,
-0.6921001076698303,
0.4556412696838379,
0.15474005043506622,
0.3342137634754181,
0.29640859365463257,
0.2627411186695099,
0.7171375155448914,
-0.5509774088859558,
0.8670972585678101,
0.03597446531057358,
-0.8940539360046387,
0.3693549633026123,
-0.9639023542404175,
0.4841064214706421,
1.0779374837875366,
0.17795467376708984,
-0.5397188067436218,
-0.7498520016670227,
-0.4706186056137085,
-1.0033118724822998,
0.48245394229888916,
-0.0033040817361325026,
0.14573727548122406,
-0.1426040679216385,
0.5644797682762146,
0.4381914734840393,
0.05383387580513954,
-0.4496449828147888,
-0.04416951537132263,
-0.18751433491706848,
-0.1547597199678421,
-0.007926846854388714,
-0.16854268312454224,
-0.28297507762908936,
-0.09644670784473419,
-0.14021329581737518,
-0.36490029096603394,
-0.06831569224596024,
0.7369409203529358,
-0.23849773406982422,
-0.0544084869325161,
0.15731976926326752,
0.3816035985946655,
0.9414016604423523,
-0.322627991437912,
0.2949145436286926,
0.28505605459213257,
-0.59380042552948,
0.07414035499095917,
-0.2778865694999695,
-0.5173280239105225,
-0.2614252269268036,
0.6371936798095703,
0.5738875269889832,
0.41269803047180176,
-0.4745045006275177,
0.38419783115386963,
0.0715673416852951,
-0.27384623885154724,
-0.1534138023853302,
0.09324866533279419,
0.0953894630074501,
0.6055377721786499,
0.49188464879989624,
0.07152490317821503,
0.4009563624858856,
-1.0077470541000366,
0.4687644839286804,
0.23511148989200592,
-0.7170774340629578,
-0.2767006456851959,
0.6617907881736755,
-0.044137611985206604,
-0.20617741346359253,
0.2049766480922699,
-0.35726049542427063,
-0.18226312100887299,
0.6831055879592896,
0.5351535677909851,
0.6553405523300171,
0.36560577154159546,
0.3212631344795227,
0.46536362171173096,
-0.045908793807029724,
-0.0029664866160601377,
0.08295822888612747,
-0.13466642796993256,
-0.4591706395149231,
-0.5173186659812927,
-0.30527424812316895,
-0.5317379236221313,
-0.31653085350990295,
-1.1293559074401855,
0.12151043862104416,
-0.267130970954895,
0.03844671696424484,
-0.2445000857114792,
-0.04273547977209091,
-0.34485527873039246,
0.28552934527397156,
0.09499664604663849,
0.6783792972564697,
-0.5201514363288879,
0.6097944974899292,
0.2324829399585724,
-0.526093602180481,
-0.6836840510368347,
0.2012949436903,
-0.08179259300231934,
-0.6446177959442139,
0.32714399695396423,
0.2299124300479889,
-0.2576122581958771,
0.025540996342897415,
-0.496038019657135,
-0.8250091671943665,
1.5657932758331299,
0.364604115486145,
-0.350139319896698,
-0.1178109273314476,
-0.18729761242866516,
0.9107038974761963,
-0.6867184042930603,
0.13380815088748932,
0.47609251737594604,
0.1633543223142624,
0.22414927184581757,
-0.7169325351715088,
0.26001957058906555,
0.04746722802519798,
-0.1462700366973877,
-0.01465685199946165,
-0.5701711773872375,
1.0109682083129883,
-0.34652179479599,
-0.5157378315925598,
0.21149064600467682,
0.40039917826652527,
0.30179548263549805,
1.1014379262924194,
0.41799551248550415,
0.24314026534557343,
0.7751597762107849,
-0.044619739055633545,
1.4595847129821777,
-0.43803298473358154,
0.48417913913726807,
1.5961886644363403,
-0.10952228307723999,
0.7267489433288574,
0.3893217146396637,
0.11138947308063507,
1.0611296892166138,
0.6675276160240173,
0.3527984619140625,
0.6383457779884338,
-0.13302914798259735,
0.006422370206564665,
-0.062462080270051956,
-0.37985169887542725,
-0.436560720205307,
0.5857572555541992,
0.01105406228452921,
-0.1520613729953766,
-0.5429067015647888,
-0.13322684168815613,
0.145180344581604,
0.05136396735906601,
-0.5425143241882324,
0.7203562259674072,
0.2858552038669586,
-0.8571029901504517,
0.5581458806991577,
-0.4843491315841675,
0.2466534525156021,
-0.5119221210479736,
0.06755997240543365,
-0.32637304067611694,
0.06785822659730911,
-0.12051091343164444,
-0.8840276002883911,
0.5974116325378418,
-0.23915205895900726,
-0.2143276333808899,
-0.23572185635566711,
0.5748156905174255,
-0.5199872851371765,
-0.25278300046920776,
0.20364497601985931,
0.7153693437576294,
-0.00941517949104309,
-0.12019678205251694,
-0.29646044969558716,
0.06822129338979721,
-0.3264673054218292,
-0.1793327033519745,
0.32198718190193176,
0.5293014645576477,
-0.1949416846036911,
0.42663559317588806,
0.32785922288894653,
-0.27528801560401917,
-0.33517205715179443,
0.08831188082695007,
0.6343864798545837,
-0.6677565574645996,
-0.9578654766082764,
-0.762008786201477,
0.6821132898330688,
0.07320801913738251,
-0.4830814003944397,
0.874850332736969,
0.43248218297958374,
0.48892611265182495,
0.23799888789653778,
0.3659180998802185,
0.0848090648651123,
0.0926487147808075,
-0.46113306283950806,
0.6865600943565369,
-0.6693556308746338,
0.16973982751369476,
-0.37901222705841064,
-0.623372495174408,
-0.22639387845993042,
0.37378478050231934,
-0.42362022399902344,
-0.1194278821349144,
1.0822590589523315,
0.44071829319000244,
0.12763358652591705,
0.18848833441734314,
0.21460162103176117,
0.11953924596309662,
0.00473070191219449,
0.6778950095176697,
0.9801532030105591,
-0.38243037462234497,
0.42655253410339355,
0.009013693779706955,
0.005107620730996132,
-0.2874220311641693,
-0.8783541917800903,
-0.6610192656517029,
-0.7499911189079285,
-0.1525738686323166,
-0.48879727721214294,
-0.03179994225502014,
0.4022677540779114,
0.5144336223602295,
-0.37052077054977417,
-0.2489117532968521,
-0.37692591547966003,
0.19450192153453827,
-0.160538911819458,
-0.26225394010543823,
0.1734916716814041,
-0.3933100402355194,
-0.5046197772026062,
0.2934378683567047,
0.609431803226471,
0.0014108846662566066,
-0.28861093521118164,
-0.0717153400182724,
-0.0815461128950119,
0.28887635469436646,
0.6414028406143188,
0.1862204521894455,
-0.44473958015441895,
-0.5314815640449524,
-0.1174626424908638,
-0.13754431903362274,
0.38018110394477844,
0.9068725109100342,
-0.9290822744369507,
0.5263087749481201,
0.5023335814476013,
0.0849202498793602,
0.769598126411438,
0.06640210002660751,
0.7516478300094604,
-0.6597244143486023,
0.26398441195487976,
0.14354975521564484,
0.33229511976242065,
0.007483207620680332,
-0.37789902091026306,
0.5583356618881226,
0.04299310967326164,
-0.47595393657684326,
-0.9055624604225159,
0.33520951867103577,
-1.3414298295974731,
-0.45333218574523926,
1.066136121749878,
-0.13184042274951935,
-0.2843499779701233,
-0.6611803770065308,
-0.3220893144607544,
0.12093579024076462,
-0.14157336950302124,
0.4272431433200836,
0.5809870362281799,
-0.4257412254810333,
0.08082564175128937,
-0.747929036617279,
0.30854713916778564,
0.12040824443101883,
-0.8441469073295593,
-0.02253815531730652,
0.7898065447807312,
0.30509617924690247,
0.3515351712703705,
0.9750088453292847,
0.03718405216932297,
0.18460309505462646,
0.5065416693687439,
-0.1388678401708603,
-0.1946212351322174,
-0.44687721133232117,
-0.2547259032726288,
0.6875841021537781,
-0.22687886655330658,
0.14827275276184082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13550v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13550v1
|
Are LLMs Effective Negotiators? Systematic Evaluation of the Multifaceted Capabilities of LLMs in Negotiation Dialogues
| 2024-02-21T06:11:03 | 2024-02-21T06:11:03 |
Deuksin Kwon, Emily Weiss, Tara Kulshrestha, Kushal Chawla, Gale M. Lucas, Jonathan Gratch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
A successful negotiation demands a deep comprehension of the conversation
context, Theory-of-Mind (ToM) skills to infer the partner's motives, as well as
strategic reasoning and effective communication, making it challenging for
automated systems. Given the remarkable performance of LLMs across a variety of
NLP tasks, in this work, we aim to understand how LLMs can advance different
aspects of negotiation research, ranging from designing dialogue systems to
providing pedagogical feedback and scaling up data collection practices. To
this end, we devise a methodology to analyze the multifaceted capabilities of
LLMs across diverse dialogue scenarios covering all the time stages of a
typical negotiation interaction. Our analysis adds to the increasing evidence
for the superiority of GPT-4 across various tasks while also providing insights
into specific tasks that remain difficult for LLMs. For instance, the models
correlate poorly with human players when making subjective assessments about
the negotiation dialogues and often struggle to generate responses that are
contextually appropriate as well as strategically advantageous.
|
[
-0.7273504734039307,
-0.6375381946563721,
0.8029980659484863,
-0.11245179176330566,
-0.23593536019325256,
0.5028629302978516,
-0.3067454993724823,
-0.5405603647232056,
0.040505118668079376,
0.17885956168174744,
-0.36717143654823303,
-0.3249928951263428,
-0.7582042813301086,
0.28156816959381104,
-0.209927037358284,
0.9857109785079956,
0.2081429809331894,
0.367313027381897,
-0.15066643059253693,
-0.0976267009973526,
-0.37749654054641724,
-0.6754289865493774,
-0.950170636177063,
-0.7242736220359802,
0.5059731602668762,
-0.01650827005505562,
0.5703142285346985,
-0.026182839646935463,
0.6711320281028748,
0.33923453092575073,
-0.29690638184547424,
0.09969697147607803,
-0.42174461483955383,
0.4583613872528076,
-0.5654736757278442,
-0.5618152022361755,
-0.6959537863731384,
0.3434120714664459,
0.3747915029525757,
0.4417491853237152,
-0.33887287974357605,
-0.07409817725419998,
0.30110374093055725,
0.5529422760009766,
-0.24390684068202972,
0.16199959814548492,
-1.019595980644226,
0.18979357182979584,
-0.04998887702822685,
-0.4104568660259247,
-0.19514280557632446,
-0.13584598898887634,
0.43824148178100586,
-0.662956714630127,
-0.02270769700407982,
-0.10191361606121063,
0.8165113925933838,
0.18984010815620422,
-0.7421614527702332,
-0.5287578105926514,
-0.675162672996521,
0.659802258014679,
-0.6984690427780151,
0.0876135602593422,
0.28041642904281616,
0.38805946707725525,
-0.4406469762325287,
-0.6038874983787537,
-0.1480190008878708,
-0.33006253838539124,
-0.1387224644422531,
0.5626569986343384,
-0.14552196860313416,
0.2894950807094574,
0.3737892210483551,
0.4441729784011841,
-0.2949454188346863,
0.028820907697081566,
-0.13920456171035767,
-0.18164916336536407,
0.6185272932052612,
0.2792326807975769,
0.09399060904979706,
-0.3578622341156006,
-0.504050612449646,
0.41714516282081604,
-0.44207629561424255,
0.05315706506371498,
0.44338318705558777,
0.24372850358486176,
-0.022244973108172417,
0.45598724484443665,
-0.09182434529066086,
0.6966246962547302,
0.10937584191560745,
-0.3375137448310852,
-0.11137150228023529,
-0.8162360191345215,
-0.1582949161529541,
-0.5353345274925232,
0.7165944576263428,
0.5355371236801147,
0.3349708914756775,
-0.3063827455043793,
-0.36398845911026,
-0.10060592740774155,
0.649678111076355,
-0.40575161576271057,
-0.18252763152122498,
0.20511165261268616,
-0.545962393283844,
-0.4086182117462158,
-0.1597587615251541,
-0.8154343366622925,
-0.06958626210689545,
-0.3609994947910309,
0.3186514377593994,
-0.13106752932071686,
-0.3856520652770996,
-0.0453178845345974,
-0.3756971061229706,
0.6368374228477478,
0.42235854268074036,
-0.7963364720344543,
0.7450670003890991,
0.5812093615531921,
0.7974441647529602,
-0.24581778049468994,
-0.16329056024551392,
-0.32105377316474915,
0.0600782185792923,
-0.32617056369781494,
0.7112969160079956,
-0.318479061126709,
-0.6773622632026672,
-0.1621868908405304,
-0.3664575219154358,
-0.19571490585803986,
-0.6261703372001648,
0.457398921251297,
-0.4314170181751251,
0.07223499566316605,
-0.3882381319999695,
-0.4023756980895996,
-0.04794452339410782,
1.047660231590271,
-0.5634568929672241,
0.6312417387962341,
-0.002085369313135743,
-0.3538643717765808,
0.41215431690216064,
-0.7085575461387634,
-0.3323782682418823,
0.23095408082008362,
-0.3694574236869812,
-0.177225261926651,
0.23106548190116882,
0.19896264374256134,
0.6154101490974426,
-0.6553659439086914,
0.3469732701778412,
-0.07688625901937485,
-0.3112151026725769,
0.6998334527015686,
-0.268817663192749,
0.2579090893268585,
0.14810292422771454,
-0.36045417189598083,
0.12294319272041321,
-0.21388573944568634,
-0.17492064833641052,
0.32782498002052307,
-0.5425066947937012,
0.12492676824331284,
-0.18692874908447266,
-0.3433716297149658,
0.29871559143066406,
0.18334415555000305,
-0.21098586916923523,
0.36068689823150635,
-0.17194043099880219,
0.5691046118736267,
0.7257426977157593,
0.030523737892508507,
0.5541747212409973,
-0.6016166806221008,
0.8980942368507385,
-0.37102288007736206,
0.15032948553562164,
0.016423054039478302,
-0.5500099062919617,
-0.6975286602973938,
-0.1375613510608673,
0.29352855682373047,
0.45960938930511475,
-0.8875005841255188,
-0.09653302282094955,
-0.19111815094947815,
-0.4654802083969116,
-0.1674533188343048,
0.25004294514656067,
0.4743630588054657,
0.2864852547645569,
0.0942310020327568,
-0.3753000497817993,
-0.1731347292661667,
-0.7816617488861084,
-0.509056031703949,
-0.08236680924892426,
0.1486024409532547,
0.4121845066547394,
0.5257443189620972,
0.1081894263625145,
0.7433602809906006,
-0.05600995197892189,
-0.21149741113185883,
-0.4776250422000885,
0.23842847347259521,
0.17699407041072845,
0.3188858926296234,
0.4753849506378174,
-0.6126134395599365,
-0.34272393584251404,
0.1209205910563469,
-0.7358055710792542,
0.19675831496715546,
-0.2929935157299042,
-0.09619618207216263,
0.07845433801412582,
0.47125884890556335,
-0.8198045492172241,
0.2639797627925873,
0.38757020235061646,
-0.13223659992218018,
0.5271704196929932,
-0.18698568642139435,
0.18364739418029785,
-0.6945434212684631,
0.07426877319812775,
-0.000018062550225295126,
-0.28149911761283875,
-0.7771157622337341,
-0.02217012271285057,
-0.24016395211219788,
0.0840427428483963,
-0.45343104004859924,
0.33120620250701904,
-0.6237337589263916,
-0.226497083902359,
-0.09420276433229446,
0.47780394554138184,
-0.2496739625930786,
0.5601862668991089,
0.04782827943563461,
0.7226306796073914,
0.31453171372413635,
-0.8300398588180542,
0.39780929684638977,
0.21210968494415283,
-0.2325926274061203,
0.9771826863288879,
-0.5771746635437012,
0.4708276689052582,
0.26449868083000183,
0.279927521944046,
-0.8269886374473572,
-0.03689068928360939,
0.4702543020248413,
-0.37632402777671814,
0.2895437479019165,
-0.5642282366752625,
-0.3707810342311859,
-0.19398963451385498,
-0.33733871579170227,
0.2752990424633026,
0.08517596125602722,
-0.12082076072692871,
1.0235085487365723,
0.3220522105693817,
-0.2749757170677185,
-0.509745717048645,
-0.5433449149131775,
0.5628607273101807,
-0.5253967642784119,
-0.2534523010253906,
0.3544652760028839,
-0.1596655398607254,
-0.39257675409317017,
-0.25499168038368225,
-0.2968386709690094,
0.06204701215028763,
0.3940567970275879,
-0.030572107061743736,
0.16562286019325256,
0.243941992521286,
-0.07749182730913162,
-0.24993214011192322,
-0.5002281665802002,
0.21240197122097015,
-0.040235091000795364,
0.6164591908454895,
-0.2321189045906067,
-0.5759168267250061,
-0.030045796185731888,
0.02676146663725376,
0.5486876368522644,
-0.2867860794067383,
0.34963539242744446,
0.5050767660140991,
-0.22501704096794128,
0.048839688301086426,
-0.6800583600997925,
-0.27859050035476685,
-0.4109102487564087,
0.2360665202140808,
-0.8006756901741028,
-0.8829256296157837,
0.6667001843452454,
-0.4640006721019745,
0.09627321362495422,
0.22662582993507385,
0.4996310770511627,
-0.07223929464817047,
0.8543566465377808,
0.1945633441209793,
0.041332829743623734,
0.20186063647270203,
-0.32265135645866394,
0.3114791810512543,
-1.127921462059021,
-0.5333076119422913,
-0.21141330897808075,
-0.4492236375808716,
-0.5924036502838135,
-0.3583894670009613,
0.4059494435787201,
0.012637987732887268,
0.04381073638796806,
0.107249416410923,
-0.4308595359325409,
0.4747993052005768,
0.3955710232257843,
0.024705540388822556,
0.3687913715839386,
-0.4123947322368622,
0.019237037748098373,
-0.11748546361923218,
-0.744140088558197,
-0.6536341309547424,
1.2106765508651733,
0.473110556602478,
0.4243325889110565,
0.38850849866867065,
0.6297620534896851,
-0.03237214311957359,
0.14859451353549957,
-1.0850235223770142,
0.8335729241371155,
0.38885506987571716,
-0.6084198355674744,
-0.2980155348777771,
-0.4568336606025696,
-1.0949722528457642,
0.555244505405426,
-0.3631608188152313,
-0.537287175655365,
-0.09216185659170151,
-0.22652162611484528,
-0.3474254608154297,
0.2444678246974945,
-0.24927477538585663,
0.6335199475288391,
-0.6995998620986938,
-0.3659096658229828,
-0.3211864233016968,
-0.5998454093933105,
0.18590357899665833,
-0.18457841873168945,
0.22963684797286987,
-0.3158765435218811,
-0.4635743498802185,
0.7911027669906616,
0.24113690853118896,
0.5787374377250671,
-0.19581784307956696,
-0.1813175231218338,
-0.019068025052547455,
0.28354665637016296,
0.4688836336135864,
0.0643792524933815,
-0.10229908674955368,
0.20814183354377747,
-0.22324733436107635,
-0.4661555290222168,
-0.7543687224388123,
0.4462617039680481,
-0.42384231090545654,
-0.7575412392616272,
-0.6342812180519104,
-0.5934244990348816,
-0.3704451322555542,
-0.04160695895552635,
0.16383479535579681,
0.10525618493556976,
-0.42252102494239807,
0.037757303565740585,
0.40753960609436035,
0.30302149057388306,
0.3954215347766876,
0.45591288805007935,
-0.13599789142608643,
-0.404750794172287,
0.77154940366745,
0.2803497016429901,
0.40826216340065,
0.12510409951210022,
0.13280348479747772,
-0.21649135649204254,
-1.1407289505004883,
0.1030467227101326,
0.17919941246509552,
-0.9088782668113708,
-0.2980731725692749,
-0.4151875972747803,
-0.013765464536845684,
0.012988653033971786,
-0.281493604183197,
-0.023443104699254036,
-0.3381420373916626,
0.026786450296640396,
-0.5315091013908386,
0.0627470314502716,
1.1640545129776,
-0.10105513036251068,
0.18001262843608856,
-0.4708273410797119,
0.21045908331871033,
0.662643551826477,
0.10428830981254578,
-0.06875284016132355,
-0.3137405812740326,
-0.2817569375038147,
-0.08842954784631729,
-0.4551394581794739,
-0.8673371076583862,
0.33900102972984314,
-0.22943364083766937,
0.9871464967727661,
0.07331691682338715,
-0.2249092310667038,
0.6032732129096985,
-0.07463923841714859,
1.1799696683883667,
0.07752358913421631,
-1.0866669416427612,
0.5622501373291016,
-0.6061225533485413,
0.24125130474567413,
0.4304248094558716,
0.18993091583251953,
-0.14907315373420715,
-0.34613800048828125,
-0.686716616153717,
-1.1074217557907104,
0.7063696980476379,
0.3589514493942261,
-0.03219015151262283,
0.07452895492315292,
0.46363791823387146,
-0.016115184873342514,
0.5650256276130676,
-0.8857870697975159,
-0.037672001868486404,
0.06365177780389786,
0.36305898427963257,
-0.17650368809700012,
-0.33748045563697815,
-0.5580649971961975,
-0.14891710877418518,
0.5566403269767761,
-0.2856591045856476,
0.20270581543445587,
0.060787491500377655,
-0.08243128657341003,
0.25815001130104065,
0.506385087966919,
0.5918782949447632,
0.8602492809295654,
-0.15108142793178558,
0.10472804307937622,
0.6224874258041382,
0.06965664774179459,
0.2569373548030853,
-0.036262769252061844,
0.4898855686187744,
-0.2026674896478653,
0.4556427299976349,
0.32813847064971924,
0.3773309588432312,
-0.43959853053092957,
0.42102697491645813,
-0.31682491302490234,
-0.683612048625946,
-0.18599408864974976,
-0.059425197541713715,
0.11514829099178314,
0.6057704091072083,
0.379911869764328,
-0.13994114100933075,
0.24364736676216125,
-0.5303744077682495,
0.1315660923719406,
0.8272307515144348,
-0.2368740737438202,
-0.08448527008295059,
0.19231604039669037,
0.7117558717727661,
-0.38955461978912354,
0.48680293560028076,
-0.15813042223453522,
-0.6739394068717957,
0.4466491639614105,
0.2473873347043991,
0.7694132924079895,
-0.054069019854068756,
0.10785328596830368,
-0.034781839698553085,
0.4942215085029602,
0.19737283885478973,
0.09851036965847015,
-0.3977576792240143,
-0.8897923231124878,
-0.439807265996933,
-0.0630035251379013,
-0.7981361746788025,
0.13834424316883087,
-0.9043046832084656,
-0.12321659922599792,
-0.52872234582901,
-0.6316840052604675,
-0.18230251967906952,
0.3154844343662262,
-1.0825896263122559,
-0.10453859716653824,
0.01711723394691944,
0.5980755090713501,
-0.428695946931839,
0.5582836270332336,
0.6552233695983887,
-0.41381093859672546,
-0.4554736614227295,
0.014436705969274044,
0.25948816537857056,
-0.7693125009536743,
0.7545358538627625,
-0.09932364523410797,
-0.27881374955177307,
-0.027651717886328697,
-0.3375091254711151,
-0.5179181694984436,
1.3030000925064087,
0.7742690443992615,
-0.5867019891738892,
-0.15762291848659515,
0.08772117644548416,
0.45322471857070923,
-0.2711985111236572,
0.6681975722312927,
0.8418993353843689,
0.6843262910842896,
-0.0897173210978508,
-1.2787808179855347,
-0.03016630746424198,
-0.15863506495952606,
-0.024822991341352463,
0.0894797295331955,
-0.8088485598564148,
0.5794777870178223,
0.17832404375076294,
-0.0007949411519803107,
0.09178104996681213,
0.24484629929065704,
0.19469238817691803,
0.24221232533454895,
0.5139802098274231,
0.4231399893760681,
0.8288559317588806,
-0.36780688166618347,
0.9768564105033875,
-0.4066581428050995,
0.2781384289264679,
0.7845686674118042,
-0.37302717566490173,
0.47593915462493896,
0.5160248875617981,
-0.11027733236551285,
0.2612583339214325,
0.5033138990402222,
0.05371559038758278,
0.19883468747138977,
0.49510738253593445,
-0.2496173083782196,
-0.47716858983039856,
-0.08428686857223511,
-0.003321980591863394,
0.5081596374511719,
0.5195893049240112,
0.021301381289958954,
-0.1496523916721344,
-0.2040448933839798,
-0.04573015496134758,
0.0008770701242610812,
-0.1027432307600975,
1.1097699403762817,
0.338510125875473,
-0.6046532392501831,
0.21830874681472778,
-0.2759491503238678,
0.8462522625923157,
-0.7045941352844238,
-0.14494530856609344,
-0.0714392438530922,
-0.11340247094631195,
-0.1466166377067566,
-0.8852587938308716,
0.19844911992549896,
-0.249123215675354,
0.1556999683380127,
-0.6120424270629883,
0.70289546251297,
-0.2634909749031067,
0.08952240645885468,
0.7148853540420532,
0.9998269081115723,
0.2414456605911255,
-0.02658187225461006,
-1.0328450202941895,
0.15666447579860687,
-0.1806492805480957,
-0.49076154828071594,
0.5655370354652405,
0.42722371220588684,
0.3782806098461151,
0.8313648700714111,
0.6210268139839172,
0.25348737835884094,
-0.33162668347358704,
0.04921376332640648,
0.7017175555229187,
-0.9585871696472168,
0.008099740371108055,
-0.8842822909355164,
0.7068135142326355,
-0.2274954915046692,
-0.23576904833316803,
1.0424823760986328,
0.32411807775497437,
0.7835671901702881,
0.33376193046569824,
0.7040814161300659,
0.4046103060245514,
0.22249773144721985,
-0.8894253373146057,
0.34683799743652344,
-0.24363063275814056,
0.3979801833629608,
-0.20982222259044647,
-0.7627954483032227,
-0.09361816942691803,
0.762678325176239,
-0.34879013895988464,
0.23447303473949432,
0.7652205228805542,
0.4569321870803833,
0.1493978202342987,
0.0758892074227333,
0.4494114816188812,
-0.12632061541080475,
0.7193711996078491,
0.5292145609855652,
1.1959831714630127,
-0.15830202400684357,
0.6846053004264832,
-0.05298427492380142,
0.03786219283938408,
0.010666889138519764,
-0.8663783073425293,
-1.05194890499115,
-0.40692007541656494,
-0.23231680691242218,
-0.09201804548501968,
0.11537524312734604,
0.8173216581344604,
0.7319281101226807,
-0.13129660487174988,
-0.637240469455719,
-0.08655036985874176,
0.14566802978515625,
-0.13718204200267792,
-0.1860864907503128,
-0.1874440759420395,
-0.4894406795501709,
-0.7487848997116089,
0.6588424444198608,
0.47958239912986755,
0.14726227521896362,
-0.279914528131485,
-0.3478669226169586,
-0.18476152420043945,
0.22276091575622559,
0.6225771307945251,
-0.11209864914417267,
-0.8007166385650635,
-0.07543254643678665,
-0.15496569871902466,
0.01984943076968193,
0.07722708582878113,
1.1616288423538208,
-0.6946768760681152,
0.40256309509277344,
0.07717505097389221,
0.5982027053833008,
0.6572767496109009,
-0.16251938045024872,
0.8695929646492004,
-0.4387274980545044,
0.027832550927996635,
0.5385111570358276,
0.3948904871940613,
0.38348138332366943,
-0.14231252670288086,
0.8342647552490234,
0.12005242705345154,
-0.6635288596153259,
-0.6336042881011963,
0.24368548393249512,
-0.8635854125022888,
-0.20595288276672363,
1.0415171384811401,
-0.1210937350988388,
0.3065052926540375,
-0.3619166314601898,
-0.2533228099346161,
0.010837527923285961,
-0.4660415053367615,
0.46274682879447937,
1.111768126487732,
-0.43141883611679077,
-0.18083694577217102,
-0.6722767949104309,
0.5764141082763672,
0.5009880065917969,
-0.7375370264053345,
-0.3887769281864166,
0.24724477529525757,
0.014695669524371624,
0.24857471883296967,
0.9570978879928589,
0.058231137692928314,
0.01700356788933277,
-0.27084285020828247,
-0.43696388602256775,
0.07460367679595947,
-0.3209880590438843,
-0.5762606263160706,
0.17671452462673187,
0.3995260000228882,
-0.01958424225449562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13547v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13547v1
|
ActiveRAG: Revealing the Treasures of Knowledge via Active Learning
| 2024-02-21T06:04:53 | 2024-02-21T06:04:53 |
Zhipeng Xu, Zhenghao Liu, Yibin Liu, Chenyan Xiong, Yukun Yan, Shuo Wang, Shi Yu, Zhiyuan Liu, Ge Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) has introduced a new paradigm for Large
Language Models (LLMs), aiding in the resolution of knowledge-intensive tasks.
However, current RAG models position LLMs as passive knowledge receptors,
thereby restricting their capacity for learning and comprehending external
knowledge. In this paper, we present ActiveRAG, an innovative RAG framework
that shifts from passive knowledge acquisition to an active learning mechanism.
This approach utilizes the Knowledge Construction mechanism to develop a deeper
understanding of external knowledge by associating it with previously acquired
or memorized knowledge. Subsequently, it designs the Cognitive Nexus mechanism
to incorporate the outcomes from both chains of thought and knowledge
construction, thereby calibrating the intrinsic cognition of LLMs. Our
experimental results demonstrate that ActiveRAG surpasses previous RAG models,
achieving a 5% improvement on question-answering datasets. All data and codes
are available at https://github.com/OpenMatch/ActiveRAG.
|
[
-0.18241752684116364,
-1.1085841655731201,
0.451783150434494,
-0.3369957208633423,
0.008612621575593948,
0.2038785070180893,
-0.504095733165741,
-0.3361913859844208,
0.05674917623400688,
0.4152497947216034,
-0.11506985872983932,
-0.13824065029621124,
-0.32868853211402893,
-0.21349695324897766,
-0.33129194378852844,
1.0828337669372559,
-0.3954712152481079,
-0.13432516157627106,
-0.042793288826942444,
-0.12981919944286346,
-0.3623809814453125,
-0.16156147420406342,
-0.7477368712425232,
-0.31215670704841614,
0.7330412864685059,
0.20289219915866852,
0.44625523686408997,
0.41136786341667175,
0.49922025203704834,
0.21370108425617218,
-0.3021462857723236,
0.46216973662376404,
-0.7152999639511108,
0.5226441621780396,
-0.1967567503452301,
-0.9639198780059814,
-0.46147602796554565,
-0.024786852300167084,
0.8725247383117676,
0.6025316119194031,
-0.3425139784812927,
0.15667535364627838,
-0.006258020177483559,
0.6314502358436584,
-0.9474679827690125,
0.08467811346054077,
-0.9894040822982788,
0.12813472747802734,
-0.2564203143119812,
-0.3240791857242584,
-0.3008299767971039,
-0.02716589905321598,
-0.2010589987039566,
-0.9234381914138794,
0.30447015166282654,
0.1562284380197525,
0.6399906873703003,
0.6365215182304382,
-0.45108434557914734,
-0.5015053749084473,
-0.8897262215614319,
0.5791721940040588,
-0.03690582141280174,
0.48196470737457275,
0.4379882216453552,
0.597453773021698,
0.09682288020849228,
-1.019325852394104,
-0.846472978591919,
0.25300127267837524,
0.036614518612623215,
0.35040509700775146,
-0.19769254326820374,
-0.18143485486507416,
0.15168729424476624,
0.7133285403251648,
-0.29209834337234497,
-0.2554725110530853,
-0.7371781468391418,
0.046561870723962784,
0.48101863265037537,
0.07390670478343964,
0.2749330401420593,
0.009278970770537853,
-0.5675492882728577,
0.025532018393278122,
-0.9314740300178528,
0.11288007348775864,
0.22996070981025696,
0.3610941171646118,
0.14367040991783142,
0.7372009754180908,
-0.012579779140651226,
0.9326871633529663,
0.13457851111888885,
-0.055668700486421585,
0.1660773903131485,
-0.18825845420360565,
0.010905657894909382,
0.2377035766839981,
0.3141644597053528,
-0.28458651900291443,
-0.24117450416088104,
-0.23666171729564667,
-0.3033796548843384,
0.11966949701309204,
0.8286468386650085,
-0.3476615846157074,
-0.19667202234268188,
0.06780999153852463,
-0.1802712082862854,
-0.36249226331710815,
-0.007090627681463957,
-0.3787187933921814,
-0.4738125801086426,
-0.12368030101060867,
0.8236685991287231,
-0.19868232309818268,
-0.44706955552101135,
0.2429656833410263,
-0.13872656226158142,
0.3055194020271301,
0.3985568583011627,
-0.33028391003608704,
0.4271611273288727,
0.7212990522384644,
0.6469228863716125,
-0.4286051392555237,
-0.11425059288740158,
-0.7052499055862427,
0.5566786527633667,
-0.44973132014274597,
1.0164464712142944,
-0.5876404643058777,
-0.1016947329044342,
-0.052423395216464996,
0.05300220102071762,
-0.20767733454704285,
-0.5226369500160217,
0.8660928010940552,
-0.9794730544090271,
0.4181959331035614,
-0.08803296089172363,
-0.32796382904052734,
-0.6381241679191589,
0.43187791109085083,
-0.7494118809700012,
1.007845163345337,
-0.03950624540448189,
-0.8784058094024658,
0.14190837740898132,
-0.7558060884475708,
-0.2814195156097412,
0.24932682514190674,
-0.12757261097431183,
-0.3394384980201721,
0.07156150788068771,
-0.16432324051856995,
0.2618274688720703,
-0.30460482835769653,
0.136794313788414,
-0.05444401875138283,
-0.37998032569885254,
0.3379298746585846,
-0.25831884145736694,
0.5542665719985962,
0.316488653421402,
-0.3088465631008148,
0.16416452825069427,
-0.37160077691078186,
-0.1215098574757576,
0.1826402246952057,
-0.5791476368904114,
-0.47313061356544495,
-0.08056198060512543,
-0.5001528263092041,
0.13157467544078827,
0.3640735447406769,
-0.44350019097328186,
0.267341673374176,
-0.42589661478996277,
-0.07477191090583801,
0.5764433741569519,
0.13859426975250244,
0.8146114945411682,
-0.592078685760498,
0.6918271780014038,
-0.05377025157213211,
-0.20151390135288239,
-0.09291894733905792,
-0.47016364336013794,
-0.8071709871292114,
-0.3261021077632904,
0.33011630177497864,
0.4397033452987671,
-0.8712041974067688,
-0.026756837964057922,
-0.1788751482963562,
-0.40006574988365173,
-0.7975990176200867,
0.3176865875720978,
0.5010941624641418,
0.4791877567768097,
0.38870206475257874,
-0.2940410375595093,
-0.3486396372318268,
-0.5528801083564758,
-0.3369962275028229,
-0.3657841384410858,
0.034819524735212326,
0.5451481342315674,
0.23885822296142578,
-0.09474945068359375,
0.6513780355453491,
-0.7214697599411011,
-0.46346473693847656,
-0.4498988091945648,
0.04840979725122452,
0.2419164478778839,
0.16995187103748322,
0.02816651202738285,
-1.0816558599472046,
-0.4354862868785858,
0.06261718273162842,
-0.7413856983184814,
-0.02985881268978119,
0.23366571962833405,
-0.4421713054180145,
-0.07037153095006943,
0.331408828496933,
-0.780402421951294,
0.2511042654514313,
0.400754451751709,
-0.4592374861240387,
0.32209521532058716,
0.017256150022149086,
-0.08852013945579529,
-0.9631620049476624,
0.4802440106868744,
-0.48899364471435547,
0.025961028411984444,
-0.5367391705513,
0.3265814483165741,
0.15403884649276733,
-0.2041459083557129,
-0.3279986083507538,
1.1256189346313477,
-0.6327430605888367,
-0.03840559348464012,
-0.37444573640823364,
0.29531678557395935,
0.05418158322572708,
0.46083739399909973,
0.04294387251138687,
0.7830139398574829,
0.46530094742774963,
-0.7093266844749451,
0.3140142560005188,
0.5004596710205078,
-0.33480149507522583,
0.29801085591316223,
-0.5103366374969482,
-0.040662117302417755,
-0.26381978392601013,
0.36355382204055786,
-0.9036299586296082,
-0.2563311755657196,
0.038609422743320465,
-0.6576929688453674,
0.6254598498344421,
-0.25503841042518616,
-0.2176561802625656,
-0.3304372727870941,
-0.1568201184272766,
0.4171587824821472,
0.6219170093536377,
-0.46448227763175964,
0.7542204856872559,
0.8271523714065552,
-0.20443016290664673,
-0.6680893301963806,
-0.28475522994995117,
-0.19860577583312988,
-0.1868724673986435,
-0.36421826481819153,
0.4809419512748718,
0.21679633855819702,
-0.4572117030620575,
0.08996601402759552,
-0.1968134045600891,
-0.14518509805202484,
0.13208237290382385,
0.022546827793121338,
0.0776081457734108,
-0.06413891911506653,
0.4028095602989197,
0.0844840332865715,
-0.1269010752439499,
-0.042658064514398575,
-0.2722740173339844,
0.3933095335960388,
0.21262474358081818,
-0.3430267572402954,
0.16999934613704681,
-0.05236099660396576,
0.5136598348617554,
-0.8110936880111694,
0.7590218782424927,
0.7600389719009399,
-0.35548022389411926,
-0.7278003096580505,
-0.45490962266921997,
-0.3993960916996002,
-0.4859500825405121,
0.15137572586536407,
-0.4095642566680908,
-0.8180637955665588,
0.40784135460853577,
-0.23237140476703644,
0.3183835744857788,
0.2948950529098511,
0.6590298414230347,
0.07893248647451401,
0.8728463649749756,
0.43401411175727844,
0.5229474902153015,
0.4176294207572937,
-0.5054763555526733,
0.3931262493133545,
-1.4203579425811768,
-0.33717837929725647,
-0.2697720229625702,
-0.49357834458351135,
-0.20911173522472382,
-1.1233386993408203,
0.7440239787101746,
0.43887221813201904,
-0.2897149920463562,
-0.10160265862941742,
-0.5152521729469299,
0.0470990352332592,
0.4253222942352295,
0.15716992318630219,
0.43538057804107666,
-0.0011721436167135835,
-0.362141489982605,
0.09670756012201309,
-1.0749599933624268,
-0.3690560758113861,
1.114101529121399,
0.3195439279079437,
0.8687049746513367,
0.3420218229293823,
0.3442515730857849,
0.12428530305624008,
0.38025161623954773,
-0.8991103172302246,
0.6283226013183594,
0.04623741656541824,
-0.9907300472259521,
-0.2093701958656311,
-0.6277387738227844,
-1.2265815734863281,
0.19635306298732758,
-0.25200676918029785,
0.028158122673630714,
-0.060707807540893555,
-0.023315371945500374,
-0.3041096329689026,
0.5512567758560181,
-0.31710460782051086,
0.5077683329582214,
-0.35586637258529663,
-0.952711820602417,
-0.25005513429641724,
-0.3038470447063446,
0.47086483240127563,
-0.13619652390480042,
0.1728423684835434,
0.032531678676605225,
-0.5568251609802246,
0.8608903884887695,
0.10654247552156448,
0.698538601398468,
-0.41204404830932617,
-0.2870454788208008,
0.5460891723632812,
0.21426144242286682,
0.690166711807251,
0.0032083671540021896,
-0.23213687539100647,
-0.5230287909507751,
-0.6624485850334167,
-0.2824443578720093,
-0.7183499336242676,
0.6748555898666382,
-0.6166053414344788,
-0.5996789932250977,
-0.2714146077632904,
-0.5964019298553467,
-0.3117501437664032,
0.17817214131355286,
-0.24365472793579102,
0.4604438543319702,
-0.1334117203950882,
0.22577597200870514,
0.9605329632759094,
-0.42123469710350037,
0.04032410308718681,
1.0364257097244263,
-0.16654564440250397,
-0.317592978477478,
0.810595691204071,
0.19652853906154633,
0.003241028403863311,
0.3524598181247711,
0.08517593890428543,
-0.4178280234336853,
-0.40677520632743835,
-0.46735695004463196,
0.3969123661518097,
-0.5674223303794861,
-0.4250640571117401,
-0.968449056148529,
-0.2559535503387451,
-0.11935044825077057,
-0.16210219264030457,
-0.3716672658920288,
-0.787628173828125,
0.1751694530248642,
-0.21147370338439941,
0.44038403034210205,
0.8312844634056091,
0.004751184489578009,
-0.10950818657875061,
-0.5025174617767334,
0.48390763998031616,
0.6934653520584106,
0.2830216884613037,
0.18064425885677338,
-0.760247528553009,
-0.3070420026779175,
0.13696376979351044,
-0.5188500881195068,
-0.6887243390083313,
0.22806648910045624,
0.1804831326007843,
0.8902237415313721,
0.26911604404449463,
0.41193556785583496,
0.5233315229415894,
-0.4531233608722687,
0.5831711888313293,
-0.13599775731563568,
-0.47041213512420654,
0.534883439540863,
-0.663323700428009,
0.38651174306869507,
0.45515695214271545,
0.5061600208282471,
-0.3044339716434479,
-0.519671618938446,
-0.8729056715965271,
-0.9377056360244751,
0.45388028025627136,
0.0942116305232048,
-0.00617991853505373,
-0.029353270307183266,
0.3784964680671692,
0.04554641619324684,
0.2620721161365509,
-0.4907417893409729,
0.027971969917416573,
0.2645076513290405,
-0.2617778778076172,
0.13180845975875854,
-0.08567038178443909,
-0.40331849455833435,
-0.08377198129892349,
0.9209231734275818,
-0.17164424061775208,
0.6052824258804321,
0.06864950805902481,
0.01325357798486948,
-0.36814090609550476,
0.21787264943122864,
0.20253169536590576,
0.5554764270782471,
0.26464617252349854,
0.36846163868904114,
0.3790896534919739,
-0.4683505594730377,
-0.1010427176952362,
0.020434875041246414,
-0.25478148460388184,
-0.1727079302072525,
0.36752569675445557,
0.7929239869117737,
0.3688916862010956,
-0.7006669044494629,
0.5746631622314453,
-0.11403793096542358,
-0.0011012670584022999,
-0.47597649693489075,
0.45867323875427246,
0.023375948891043663,
0.14544567465782166,
0.6981035470962524,
-0.01527738943696022,
0.009168598800897598,
-0.7326838970184326,
0.4242036044597626,
0.40415051579475403,
-0.629134476184845,
-0.4281415641307831,
0.8701404333114624,
0.3102208077907562,
-0.1306297928094864,
0.3373321294784546,
-0.15973089635372162,
-0.8661527037620544,
0.18605367839336395,
0.6383837461471558,
0.5665300488471985,
-0.33195793628692627,
0.09311182051897049,
0.5798125267028809,
-0.007321371231228113,
-0.24162711203098297,
0.5686158537864685,
-0.41500699520111084,
-0.8365603685379028,
-0.5905529856681824,
-0.943202018737793,
-0.35239705443382263,
-0.3382452130317688,
-0.7526694536209106,
0.31157705187797546,
-0.09698266535997391,
-0.008833648636937141,
-0.3706433176994324,
0.3951723873615265,
-0.41340500116348267,
0.02051646076142788,
-0.16251032054424286,
0.7446204423904419,
-0.5887466669082642,
0.7868587374687195,
1.21332585811615,
-0.21044522523880005,
-0.7528714537620544,
-0.05213727429509163,
-0.17891283333301544,
-0.8769749999046326,
0.5880736112594604,
-0.14259256422519684,
0.03969167545437813,
0.21943125128746033,
-0.3852350115776062,
-0.7329763770103455,
1.0821839570999146,
-0.042644619941711426,
-0.09771728515625,
-0.08759088069200516,
-0.620854914188385,
0.4409880042076111,
-0.17826050519943237,
-0.050856005400419235,
-0.06408526003360748,
0.4987958073616028,
0.19768589735031128,
-0.9908527135848999,
0.012109648436307907,
-0.5374740362167358,
-0.5902745127677917,
0.8002017736434937,
-0.6007632613182068,
0.7810809016227722,
-0.3920147120952606,
-0.39431628584861755,
-0.2170870453119278,
0.46515953540802,
0.5494146347045898,
0.2908451557159424,
0.3629707396030426,
0.9073442220687866,
0.9240466356277466,
0.05057402700185776,
0.8784780502319336,
-0.4007980227470398,
-0.05496400594711304,
0.9873964786529541,
-0.29804351925849915,
1.117266058921814,
0.28798454999923706,
0.021069608628749847,
0.5929136872291565,
-0.012056401930749416,
0.32756537199020386,
0.5061667561531067,
0.12405979633331299,
-0.7171781063079834,
-0.24249984323978424,
-0.26534342765808105,
-0.2710946798324585,
0.6880711317062378,
0.672088086605072,
-0.285367488861084,
-0.07200537621974945,
0.19645549356937408,
0.059092629700899124,
0.21392984688282013,
-0.4351179301738739,
1.1430584192276,
0.03625796362757683,
-0.9464812278747559,
0.7684757113456726,
-0.11592002213001251,
0.5672444701194763,
-0.7314119935035706,
-0.2522065341472626,
0.10220251232385635,
0.3489212691783905,
-0.09529180824756622,
-0.8677642941474915,
0.4520232081413269,
0.12211306393146515,
-0.0725325271487236,
-0.4705389738082886,
1.0393338203430176,
-0.6414309740066528,
-0.4068831205368042,
0.1554819643497467,
0.9170016646385193,
0.002404174068942666,
0.15802444517612457,
-0.6232817769050598,
0.02040490321815014,
-0.08816026151180267,
-0.22921164333820343,
0.2163762003183365,
0.7524270415306091,
0.019849522039294243,
0.6337047219276428,
0.7128270864486694,
0.35192710161209106,
0.013650004751980305,
-0.3751472532749176,
1.087639331817627,
-0.4857606887817383,
-0.4827919602394104,
-0.0508749894797802,
0.502106249332428,
-0.07996582239866257,
-0.11358313262462616,
0.9579960703849792,
0.7743062973022461,
0.7126922607421875,
0.3079783022403717,
0.7129814624786377,
-0.3005499243736267,
1.0492929220199585,
-0.34403449296951294,
0.9726857542991638,
-0.7385557889938354,
0.44382044672966003,
0.09626327455043793,
-0.8837009072303772,
-0.1581217497587204,
0.8931590914726257,
-0.45202457904815674,
-0.16224752366542816,
0.6605298519134521,
0.7691515684127808,
-0.28608161211013794,
-0.17961187660694122,
0.17402327060699463,
0.4156862199306488,
-0.07359858602285385,
0.3592348098754883,
0.9623732566833496,
-0.40444034337997437,
0.6062948107719421,
-0.0826324075460434,
-0.22178693115711212,
0.16567198932170868,
-0.19646835327148438,
-0.7939378619194031,
-0.7904133200645447,
-0.02334883064031601,
-0.2926309406757355,
0.3153940737247467,
0.31367677450180054,
0.3806092143058777,
-0.24795711040496826,
-0.17313796281814575,
-0.07674004137516022,
0.2626005709171295,
-0.18669404089450836,
-0.22899052500724792,
0.30786818265914917,
-0.5961884260177612,
-0.4834378957748413,
0.5843603014945984,
0.03819651156663895,
-0.2148892879486084,
-0.26987043023109436,
-0.146396204829216,
-0.23170949518680573,
0.032576821744441986,
0.6055310368537903,
0.2499849796295166,
-0.3963543772697449,
0.24530568718910217,
0.19119881093502045,
0.10797904431819916,
-0.2134622186422348,
1.0046789646148682,
-1.1067988872528076,
0.5374929904937744,
0.8029717206954956,
0.6713757514953613,
0.6932475566864014,
0.09276820719242096,
0.8098577260971069,
-0.3996751308441162,
0.12254975736141205,
0.5067381262779236,
0.046576473861932755,
0.3318336308002472,
-0.1393395960330963,
0.818058431148529,
-0.041653770953416824,
-0.49347123503685,
-1.1516958475112915,
0.2334117740392685,
-0.602172315120697,
-0.4914620518684387,
1.3023179769515991,
-0.0676441639661789,
-0.4528495669364929,
-0.4303909242153168,
-0.18994569778442383,
0.38994139432907104,
-0.11055359244346619,
0.867084801197052,
0.10730080306529999,
0.06616508215665817,
-0.09995048493146896,
-0.8394500613212585,
0.6648238301277161,
0.4800657331943512,
-0.6377273201942444,
0.21259601414203644,
0.4412175714969635,
-0.0019979302305728197,
0.2042652666568756,
0.6418549418449402,
-0.39554524421691895,
0.4930988848209381,
-0.04750344529747963,
0.003409043652936816,
-0.18686257302761078,
-0.5832836031913757,
-0.055493880063295364,
0.4455988109111786,
0.19492413103580475,
0.23674918711185455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13546v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13546v1
|
LLMs Meet Long Video: Advancing Long Video Comprehension with An Interactive Visual Adapter in LLMs
| 2024-02-21T05:56:52 | 2024-02-21T05:56:52 |
Yunxin Li, Xinyu Chen, Baotain Hu, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Long video understanding is a significant and ongoing challenge in the
intersection of multimedia and artificial intelligence. Employing large
language models (LLMs) for comprehending video becomes an emerging and
promising method. However, this approach incurs high computational costs due to
the extensive array of video tokens, experiences reduced visual clarity as a
consequence of token aggregation, and confronts challenges arising from
irrelevant visual tokens while answering video-related questions. To alleviate
these issues, we present an Interactive Visual Adapter (IVA) within LLMs,
designed to enhance interaction with fine-grained visual elements.
Specifically, we first transform long videos into temporal video tokens via
leveraging a visual encoder alongside a pretrained causal transformer, then
feed them into LLMs with the video instructions. Subsequently, we integrated
IVA, which contains a lightweight temporal frame selector and a spatial feature
interactor, within the internal blocks of LLMs to capture instruction-aware and
fine-grained visual signals. Consequently, the proposed video-LLM facilitates a
comprehensive understanding of long video content through appropriate long
video modeling and precise visual interactions. We conducted extensive
experiments on nine video understanding benchmarks and experimental results
show that our interactive visual adapter significantly improves the performance
of video LLMs on long video QA tasks. Ablation studies further verify the
effectiveness of IVA in long and short video understandings.
|
[
-0.5656430721282959,
-0.9862155914306641,
0.9371873140335083,
0.4363357126712799,
-0.6665242314338684,
0.008548873476684093,
-0.40482887625694275,
-0.5342679023742676,
0.20822489261627197,
0.3546028435230255,
-0.611824631690979,
-0.30334141850471497,
-0.6383848786354065,
-0.1099434643983841,
-0.3749874532222748,
0.5704094171524048,
-0.3564399778842926,
-0.028920622542500496,
-0.41271835565567017,
-0.24104426801204681,
-0.5203297138214111,
-0.06639040261507034,
-0.6575658917427063,
-0.24593506753444672,
0.5094203948974609,
0.3310002088546753,
0.6250685453414917,
0.7307670712471008,
0.6379092931747437,
0.4320138096809387,
-0.07632455229759216,
0.33173224329948425,
-0.49263349175453186,
-0.15125128626823425,
-0.1270056515932083,
-0.4085104465484619,
-0.5463115572929382,
-0.5891216993331909,
0.7325817942619324,
0.5739021301269531,
0.29017964005470276,
0.46618950366973877,
0.03003365732729435,
0.6940597295761108,
-0.6381452083587646,
0.18643668293952942,
-0.3706585466861725,
0.2425721287727356,
-0.02902844361960888,
-0.49320948123931885,
-0.14629033207893372,
0.15770140290260315,
0.08603643625974655,
-0.8120457530021667,
-0.11852271109819412,
-0.045180175453424454,
0.46434369683265686,
0.793405294418335,
-0.49168887734413147,
-0.06716390699148178,
-0.9839813709259033,
0.3635687530040741,
-0.29943403601646423,
0.4075281322002411,
0.1228237971663475,
0.6987079381942749,
-0.16296522319316864,
-0.9318665862083435,
-0.814250111579895,
-0.04434822499752045,
0.2174161672592163,
0.25846004486083984,
-0.3586727976799011,
0.4514704644680023,
0.3926503658294678,
0.2641163468360901,
-0.4151534140110016,
0.5007010698318481,
-0.3439626395702362,
0.12424900382757187,
0.3049439787864685,
0.3076951205730438,
0.37149909138679504,
-0.11170011758804321,
-0.4946141242980957,
0.22562143206596375,
-0.30684971809387207,
0.42600762844085693,
-0.020159803330898285,
-0.32016444206237793,
-0.2950805127620697,
0.6510888934135437,
-0.20243775844573975,
0.7300773859024048,
0.09094482660293579,
-0.13455986976623535,
-0.05892567336559296,
-0.2728060781955719,
-0.5604798197746277,
-0.019079426303505898,
0.5267036557197571,
0.7512078881263733,
0.378083199262619,
0.22783096134662628,
-0.0039628348313272,
-0.09785231947898865,
0.13451607525348663,
-1.1386334896087646,
-0.12782089412212372,
0.06727291643619537,
-0.44144782423973083,
0.20692132413387299,
0.08984281867742538,
-0.8989149928092957,
-0.35609951615333557,
-0.660014271736145,
0.7478288412094116,
-0.25096243619918823,
0.10438184440135956,
0.23362115025520325,
-0.18839384615421295,
0.5114119052886963,
0.7627948522567749,
-0.9247735738754272,
0.27086982131004333,
0.5068973302841187,
0.7554865479469299,
-0.2441142499446869,
-0.42656537890434265,
-0.9168168902397156,
0.49946749210357666,
-0.16636186838150024,
0.6291715502738953,
-0.38928577303886414,
-0.14352913200855255,
0.17623139917850494,
0.23276644945144653,
0.2448609173297882,
-0.43953415751457214,
0.10811956971883774,
-0.6085580587387085,
-0.07188408821821213,
0.026638595387339592,
-0.45147231221199036,
-0.3321116268634796,
0.38138389587402344,
-0.5083617568016052,
0.6681131720542908,
-0.18430855870246887,
-0.38527756929397583,
0.3778310716152191,
-0.7939885854721069,
-0.0845760926604271,
0.07522641867399216,
-0.29400748014450073,
-0.17428375780582428,
0.1339525580406189,
0.4477933645248413,
0.3579370677471161,
0.11063282191753387,
0.1693415343761444,
-0.4667009115219116,
-0.6081674098968506,
0.40193691849708557,
-0.8509447574615479,
-0.12600749731063843,
-0.09324150532484055,
-0.11314868927001953,
0.42135119438171387,
-0.6937482357025146,
-0.2602238059043884,
-0.08260463178157806,
-0.0680835098028183,
0.06799295544624329,
-0.08936380594968796,
-0.1411350965499878,
0.12377990037202835,
0.2960534691810608,
-0.22534814476966858,
0.07773517072200775,
0.04324322193861008,
0.6512240767478943,
0.9250847697257996,
-0.00034008282818831503,
0.5250350832939148,
0.14598701894283295,
0.569426417350769,
0.06752991676330566,
0.42236560583114624,
-0.46819791197776794,
-0.028730405494570732,
-0.9163804054260254,
-0.3180711567401886,
-0.250166654586792,
0.32863444089889526,
-0.986916184425354,
0.03869073465466499,
-0.5947641730308533,
-0.0308840274810791,
-0.39128899574279785,
0.5498260855674744,
0.09111225605010986,
0.30709728598594666,
0.5536628365516663,
-0.3082948923110962,
-0.3082695007324219,
-0.6710015535354614,
0.08884097635746002,
-0.08263656497001648,
-0.33133623003959656,
0.4133409857749939,
0.4577833414077759,
-0.3423383831977844,
0.8608561754226685,
-0.5586273074150085,
-0.2798469662666321,
-0.12897562980651855,
-0.08118561655282974,
0.18283440172672272,
0.08751369267702103,
0.6067214012145996,
-0.6280215382575989,
-0.2737314701080322,
0.1406594067811966,
-0.9369040131568909,
0.2517443299293518,
-0.2853599488735199,
-0.029977306723594666,
-0.006113859824836254,
0.9735211133956909,
-0.5350425243377686,
0.6696786880493164,
0.39166009426116943,
-0.2669529318809509,
0.3271956443786621,
-0.39851343631744385,
0.19327540695667267,
-0.7813652157783508,
-0.12838126718997955,
-0.08106360584497452,
-0.33025041222572327,
-0.4126124083995819,
-0.1682538539171219,
-0.16113001108169556,
-0.23126207292079926,
-0.740657389163971,
0.6779699921607971,
-0.2441587895154953,
-0.3575442433357239,
-0.42164725065231323,
0.384723961353302,
0.03995610401034355,
0.5882002115249634,
0.04277170076966286,
0.8340477347373962,
0.5565958023071289,
-0.5357187986373901,
0.5819205641746521,
0.18026024103164673,
-0.2953872084617615,
0.6053686141967773,
-0.652923583984375,
-0.07782275974750519,
-0.36180800199508667,
0.16326381266117096,
-0.8025464415550232,
-0.56062251329422,
0.10370639711618423,
-0.13547934591770172,
0.21344149112701416,
-0.5350548624992371,
-0.14723069965839386,
-0.2552473843097687,
-0.3448065519332886,
0.7426046133041382,
0.47619935870170593,
-0.9176437258720398,
0.9275955557823181,
0.04208054021000862,
-0.23421896994113922,
-0.3806341290473938,
-0.6444634199142456,
0.30019479990005493,
-0.5392904281616211,
-0.8688955307006836,
0.20203344523906708,
-0.3938443660736084,
-0.1854964941740036,
-0.10376840829849243,
-0.2224239706993103,
-0.08918497711420059,
-0.09848395735025406,
0.43811044096946716,
0.13362039625644684,
-0.3628317415714264,
0.09046850353479385,
0.0819368064403534,
-0.05705859884619713,
0.29369276762008667,
0.018389977514743805,
0.38142791390419006,
-0.06654921919107437,
-0.574899435043335,
-0.6059166789054871,
0.45618271827697754,
0.8620234727859497,
-0.1617591232061386,
0.2927708923816681,
1.0405699014663696,
-0.24807916581630707,
-0.029279690235853195,
-0.5865793228149414,
0.04216167703270912,
-0.5448735356330872,
0.7211472392082214,
-0.2711130976676941,
-0.9713090658187866,
0.5329885482788086,
-0.24947966635227203,
-0.16561444103717804,
-0.054472893476486206,
0.34846821427345276,
-0.4545919895172119,
0.8832112550735474,
0.7700042128562927,
0.07591907680034637,
1.005602240562439,
-0.18968375027179718,
0.055290814489126205,
-0.7200462222099304,
-0.40533220767974854,
0.1703902930021286,
-0.45998015999794006,
-0.3479187488555908,
-0.7322757244110107,
0.5307754874229431,
0.28045758605003357,
-0.4454919695854187,
-0.28888338804244995,
0.05443409085273743,
0.799837589263916,
0.3026059865951538,
0.332190603017807,
0.25126582384109497,
-0.06348000466823578,
0.6171078085899353,
-0.052111078053712845,
-0.4102788269519806,
-0.24389556050300598,
0.46764788031578064,
0.6328257322311401,
1.0276950597763062,
0.24122048914432526,
0.43198609352111816,
0.14723213016986847,
-0.20430108904838562,
-1.0177264213562012,
0.7666728496551514,
-0.2171163558959961,
0.15538683533668518,
-0.21495813131332397,
-0.051834143698215485,
-0.715707540512085,
-0.20564433932304382,
-0.15943440794944763,
-0.6509522795677185,
-0.011306565254926682,
0.37316054105758667,
-0.45445868372917175,
0.2664937973022461,
-0.5580706000328064,
0.8692682385444641,
-0.6523420214653015,
-0.7131509184837341,
-0.47601965069770813,
-0.727181613445282,
0.2949455678462982,
0.16203883290290833,
0.2524743974208832,
0.11644219607114792,
-0.19411906599998474,
0.5391607284545898,
-0.26530274748802185,
0.7957847714424133,
-0.10940995812416077,
0.07145348191261292,
0.21330049633979797,
0.04335840418934822,
0.2439570128917694,
0.39375361800193787,
0.4176766872406006,
-0.12901759147644043,
-0.23745077848434448,
-0.347814679145813,
-0.9232962727546692,
0.484074205160141,
-0.6706333160400391,
-0.7419466376304626,
-0.09601983428001404,
-0.5034857988357544,
0.13364359736442566,
0.2195446938276291,
-0.3407630920410156,
0.43145084381103516,
-0.16651320457458496,
0.3171766400337219,
0.7931248545646667,
-0.23663517832756042,
0.7008911967277527,
0.31018325686454773,
-0.4954819977283478,
-0.5018275380134583,
0.8161926865577698,
-0.28062695264816284,
0.40411460399627686,
0.39337021112442017,
-0.13490767776966095,
0.08610033988952637,
-0.7326899766921997,
-0.5063746571540833,
-0.003852900117635727,
-0.8781904578208923,
-0.1168193593621254,
-0.29956939816474915,
-0.3151882588863373,
0.20597080886363983,
-0.26016947627067566,
-0.10351573675870895,
-0.045913293957710266,
-0.6052184104919434,
-0.33277422189712524,
0.5593815445899963,
0.5860575437545776,
0.13216830790042877,
0.5205593109130859,
-0.9118800163269043,
0.7509157061576843,
0.9112803936004639,
0.4951683580875397,
-0.18934789299964905,
-0.7109284996986389,
-0.406943142414093,
-0.2284495085477829,
-0.20897018909454346,
-0.5365081429481506,
0.025462036952376366,
0.3613034188747406,
0.3522430956363678,
0.6691200733184814,
-0.4366290271282196,
1.4439359903335571,
-0.6437913775444031,
0.9170466661453247,
0.21641448140144348,
-0.898655354976654,
0.3700793981552124,
-0.22398972511291504,
0.4768884778022766,
0.470566064119339,
0.20358625054359436,
-0.4157859683036804,
0.07965482771396637,
0.03044508956372738,
-0.8319292664527893,
0.27831387519836426,
0.012514167465269566,
0.24841400980949402,
0.07564173638820648,
0.30973488092422485,
0.055734749883413315,
-0.08285310119390488,
-0.6931477785110474,
0.032577995210886,
-0.3497459888458252,
-0.04704485833644867,
-0.06713863462209702,
-0.2609974443912506,
-0.20475175976753235,
-0.21403168141841888,
0.24719880521297455,
-0.4414741098880768,
0.07526366412639618,
0.30849316716194153,
-0.47290459275245667,
-0.12775388360023499,
0.2389499843120575,
0.47542086243629456,
0.7847241163253784,
-0.17298325896263123,
0.14693176746368408,
0.463756263256073,
-0.3712199926376343,
-0.21825827658176422,
0.10803169012069702,
0.2029903382062912,
-0.18319453299045563,
0.528881311416626,
1.0723456144332886,
0.352891206741333,
-0.8260453343391418,
0.4704291820526123,
-0.14112672209739685,
-0.09987974166870117,
-0.5452104210853577,
-0.027162034064531326,
-0.038284312933683395,
0.6637923717498779,
0.2962888777256012,
-0.15172801911830902,
0.23162677884101868,
-0.6677791476249695,
0.17968857288360596,
0.5367281436920166,
-0.43005475401878357,
-0.3554604649543762,
0.6552570462226868,
0.44650205969810486,
-0.353310227394104,
0.6033370494842529,
0.22370590269565582,
-0.4439157247543335,
0.5260956287384033,
0.31773829460144043,
0.7081286311149597,
0.20828598737716675,
-0.018297135829925537,
0.01541075762361288,
0.11292268335819244,
0.15369704365730286,
0.1994265615940094,
-0.35830944776535034,
-0.21303227543830872,
-0.8306427001953125,
-0.4991787374019623,
-0.3958977460861206,
0.0063248854130506516,
-0.6347337961196899,
0.49592527747154236,
-0.1809418946504593,
0.09532130509614944,
-0.11990076303482056,
-0.2484930008649826,
-0.807411789894104,
0.041363030672073364,
0.6149766445159912,
1.0468165874481201,
-0.6967591643333435,
0.646947979927063,
0.39707285165786743,
-0.275929719209671,
-0.4024566113948822,
-0.16609573364257812,
-0.2885849177837372,
-0.9414315223693848,
0.502466082572937,
0.3161669075489044,
-0.23984840512275696,
-0.1885671317577362,
-0.5640718936920166,
-0.4925660789012909,
1.475260853767395,
0.389843225479126,
-0.6470504403114319,
-0.034550510346889496,
0.3740019202232361,
0.4641447365283966,
-0.10744059830904007,
0.4028225243091583,
0.4772147834300995,
0.3966646194458008,
0.26110443472862244,
-0.7730336785316467,
-0.264972448348999,
-0.23095472157001495,
-0.2545069456100464,
0.3239997923374176,
-0.5860482454299927,
0.24244378507137299,
-0.3624518811702728,
0.24527817964553833,
0.2529786229133606,
1.1028740406036377,
0.06206204369664192,
0.9085227847099304,
0.6065298914909363,
0.3250039219856262,
0.26400983333587646,
0.1529829204082489,
0.5101738572120667,
-0.11408208310604095,
-0.0808681771159172,
1.2466835975646973,
0.09448540210723877,
0.776436984539032,
0.9832936525344849,
-0.08186065405607224,
0.44513314962387085,
0.5302181839942932,
0.09678807854652405,
0.15644757449626923,
0.10205776989459991,
-0.4574638307094574,
-0.5398880839347839,
-0.21418848633766174,
-0.2103859782218933,
0.540445864200592,
0.4963594079017639,
-0.24763056635856628,
-0.054907456040382385,
0.3153558671474457,
-0.3787599802017212,
0.14335216581821442,
-0.8225347995758057,
1.0982705354690552,
0.31522616744041443,
-0.5820586085319519,
0.1175806075334549,
-0.5328800678253174,
0.5358448028564453,
-0.7858191728591919,
-0.271072119474411,
-0.18786799907684326,
0.20421797037124634,
-0.36793142557144165,
-1.3277369737625122,
0.04042115435004234,
0.16538047790527344,
-0.19875286519527435,
0.00860643945634365,
0.48983708024024963,
-0.6616359949111938,
-0.30982163548469543,
0.353607177734375,
0.329861044883728,
0.1652403026819229,
-0.047310929745435715,
-0.23141741752624512,
0.2894538938999176,
-0.22282502055168152,
-0.03251134231686592,
0.5945330858230591,
0.6601090431213379,
-0.17915873229503632,
0.7357257008552551,
0.4629386067390442,
-0.37519752979278564,
-0.006276059430092573,
0.179823100566864,
1.0289379358291626,
-0.6771148443222046,
-0.32071903347969055,
-0.9584156274795532,
0.6509232521057129,
-0.01059719268232584,
0.11386959999799728,
0.5080508589744568,
0.35076528787612915,
0.6986725330352783,
-0.10561323910951614,
0.3509550392627716,
0.269596666097641,
-0.4851742684841156,
-0.9002125263214111,
0.28611987829208374,
-0.5843659043312073,
0.18197570741176605,
-0.011375213041901588,
-0.8084588050842285,
-0.29467248916625977,
-0.0037255818024277687,
-0.2106991708278656,
-0.3117067217826843,
0.4268448054790497,
0.4366205334663391,
-0.4444167912006378,
-0.2002878338098526,
0.2991594672203064,
0.3295562267303467,
0.5863906145095825,
0.5834326148033142,
0.8661329746246338,
-0.16235218942165375,
0.8780459761619568,
-0.3266421854496002,
-0.1444319188594818,
-0.22774331271648407,
-1.1276144981384277,
-1.1118285655975342,
-0.23029974102973938,
-0.05928417295217514,
0.04449581354856491,
0.2580968737602234,
0.9224133491516113,
0.5543209314346313,
-0.15045803785324097,
-0.24407054483890533,
0.08872245252132416,
0.14707837998867035,
0.058566682040691376,
-0.20293393731117249,
0.3748660087585449,
0.12821485102176666,
-0.7401975393295288,
0.5115846395492554,
0.582538902759552,
0.16975833475589752,
-0.10431026667356491,
-0.30942314863204956,
0.2561282515525818,
-0.024258241057395935,
1.0045353174209595,
0.5585455894470215,
-0.6502040028572083,
-0.6673395037651062,
0.0428222194314003,
0.4323682188987732,
0.23662002384662628,
0.7423757314682007,
-0.8455214500427246,
0.7775176167488098,
0.5784518718719482,
0.6570786833763123,
0.86876380443573,
0.10125716030597687,
0.4703502655029297,
-0.5576433539390564,
0.2670981287956238,
-0.07487838715314865,
0.5172193646430969,
0.17614111304283142,
-0.22341923415660858,
0.17089368402957916,
-0.25268062949180603,
-0.687430202960968,
-0.833521842956543,
0.4462348222732544,
-1.6835838556289673,
-0.0671403706073761,
0.9657617211341858,
-0.06241549924015999,
-0.3932775557041168,
0.23254333436489105,
-0.35739514231681824,
0.25949546694755554,
-0.29117080569267273,
0.6394226551055908,
0.28048548102378845,
-0.2154185175895691,
-0.4446471631526947,
-0.6008426547050476,
0.1878996044397354,
0.26790544390678406,
-0.9924777746200562,
-0.14147259294986725,
0.36137863993644714,
0.18627892434597015,
-0.19782325625419617,
0.22105947136878967,
0.14495965838432312,
0.6875200271606445,
-0.47487500309944153,
-0.22726042568683624,
-0.38936129212379456,
-0.4957946240901947,
-0.5816028714179993,
-0.094976045191288,
0.11057797819375992,
-0.3535507917404175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13542v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13542v2
|
ARL2: Aligning Retrievers for Black-box Large Language Models via Self-guided Adaptive Relevance Labeling
| 2024-02-21T05:41:34 | 2024-06-04T05:17:24 |
Lingxi Zhang, Yue Yu, Kuan Wang, Chao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Retrieval-augmented generation enhances large language models (LLMs) by
incorporating relevant information from external knowledge sources. This
enables LLMs to adapt to specific domains and mitigate hallucinations in
knowledge-intensive tasks. However, existing retrievers are often misaligned
with LLMs due to their separate training processes and the black-box nature of
LLMs. To address this challenge, we propose ARL2, a retriever learning
technique that harnesses LLMs as labelers. ARL2 leverages LLMs to annotate and
score relevant evidence, enabling learning the retriever from robust LLM
supervision. Furthermore, ARL2 uses an adaptive self-training strategy for
curating high-quality and diverse relevance data, which can effectively reduce
the annotation cost. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of
ARL2, achieving accuracy improvements of 5.4% on NQ and 4.6% on MMLU compared
to the state-of-the-art methods. Additionally, ARL2 exhibits robust transfer
learning capabilities and strong zero-shot generalization abilities. Our code
will be published at \url{https://github.com/zhanglingxi-cs/ARL2}.
|
[
0.04336612671613693,
-0.5861806273460388,
0.3499450385570526,
-0.06934014707803726,
-0.04645109549164772,
0.06398359686136246,
-0.09025350958108902,
-0.49524176120758057,
-0.10779479891061783,
0.6060148477554321,
-0.09575260430574417,
-0.2531243562698364,
-0.5728990435600281,
-0.19643697142601013,
-0.259441077709198,
1.179334282875061,
0.22762282192707062,
-0.24636460840702057,
0.06370516121387482,
-0.3729102313518524,
-0.5353344082832336,
-0.5299810767173767,
-0.7961925864219666,
-0.3903937339782715,
0.7151110172271729,
0.21085545420646667,
0.5670032501220703,
0.8878204226493835,
0.3393428921699524,
0.08647946268320084,
-0.15990301966667175,
0.3776454031467438,
-0.6672194600105286,
0.45496124029159546,
-0.5868355631828308,
-0.4689580798149109,
-0.43748754262924194,
-0.3101280629634857,
0.6249992847442627,
0.20643004775047302,
-0.213532492518425,
0.36107903718948364,
0.06983145326375961,
0.882766842842102,
-0.8386547565460205,
-0.16081683337688446,
-0.9164397716522217,
0.020467782393097878,
-0.15595176815986633,
-0.23042874038219452,
-0.6286105513572693,
-0.003950127400457859,
0.12127520889043808,
-0.5208883285522461,
0.20748691260814667,
0.4419943690299988,
0.6564517617225647,
0.4434456527233124,
-0.540747344493866,
-0.32192039489746094,
-0.613470733165741,
0.8480176329612732,
-0.6259868144989014,
0.520824670791626,
0.45026925206184387,
0.5370657444000244,
-0.09833947569131851,
-0.6996724009513855,
-0.28866565227508545,
0.09659761190414429,
-0.14435109496116638,
0.03464262932538986,
-0.1023443415760994,
-0.33847033977508545,
0.046745724976062775,
0.26604050397872925,
-0.6349581480026245,
0.2958981692790985,
-0.40307092666625977,
-0.256102055311203,
0.6126325726509094,
-0.1875179558992386,
0.12768661975860596,
0.16265533864498138,
-0.4097267985343933,
-0.07102206349372864,
-0.9535402655601501,
-0.1038823127746582,
0.27629604935646057,
0.4465288519859314,
0.1255376785993576,
0.4965165853500366,
-0.02509482577443123,
0.803094744682312,
0.33323934674263,
-0.1269964724779129,
0.3573284149169922,
-0.22550679743289948,
0.03233687952160835,
0.28798913955688477,
0.7312828898429871,
0.23664329946041107,
-0.16742347180843353,
-0.25638675689697266,
-0.3801397383213043,
-0.6651703715324402,
0.3242018520832062,
-0.654338538646698,
-0.335516095161438,
0.18066082894802094,
-0.29126250743865967,
-0.0948096364736557,
-0.25567132234573364,
-0.9148141145706177,
-0.578919529914856,
-0.03959611430764198,
0.648019552230835,
-0.06922316551208496,
-0.34463387727737427,
-0.02793976478278637,
0.03298963978886604,
0.36822572350502014,
0.27262425422668457,
-1.1678001880645752,
0.002737844828516245,
0.5993712544441223,
0.6857571601867676,
-0.19771485030651093,
-0.06581923365592957,
-1.1774694919586182,
0.4043724238872528,
-0.33732959628105164,
0.7633513808250427,
-0.5193828344345093,
-0.04733005538582802,
0.16108977794647217,
-0.07005596905946732,
0.2803172171115875,
-0.7930457592010498,
0.5017018914222717,
-0.91741943359375,
0.23939380049705505,
-0.24062858521938324,
-0.38618898391723633,
-0.17102938890457153,
0.3577437102794647,
-0.5659819841384888,
1.4606307744979858,
0.17449770867824554,
-0.5159747004508972,
0.07652536779642105,
-0.3977687358856201,
-0.4057105481624603,
0.040848348289728165,
-0.2218809872865677,
-0.49676311016082764,
-0.0025133718736469746,
0.16910132765769958,
0.18076381087303162,
-0.09812430292367935,
0.17499272525310516,
-0.2055179327726364,
-0.21062704920768738,
0.10105430334806442,
-0.09935246407985687,
0.2983584702014923,
0.3374568223953247,
-0.36841920018196106,
0.1037086546421051,
-0.6560137271881104,
-0.042241111397743225,
0.10180258005857468,
-0.6239129304885864,
-0.2808953523635864,
0.2595113217830658,
-0.059633996337652206,
0.2864498794078827,
0.43967777490615845,
-0.2798931300640106,
0.1760639101266861,
-0.6347953677177429,
0.24124187231063843,
0.5980232954025269,
-0.17284022271633148,
0.47939544916152954,
-0.07558523863554001,
0.2968428134918213,
-0.09065709263086319,
-0.34837138652801514,
-0.12133847922086716,
-0.09441827237606049,
-0.870123565196991,
0.07637861371040344,
0.36593490839004517,
0.6311163902282715,
-0.6692699193954468,
0.5873183608055115,
-0.08884736895561218,
-0.19989286363124847,
-0.8223534226417542,
0.5396015048027039,
0.7041506171226501,
0.6574230194091797,
0.8281818628311157,
-0.0009028850472532213,
-0.5649793148040771,
-0.8784965872764587,
-0.27401235699653625,
-0.07652575522661209,
0.008399237878620625,
0.3357531726360321,
0.1720072627067566,
-0.2490861564874649,
0.8512089848518372,
-0.30061331391334534,
-0.6827834844589233,
-0.10819423198699951,
0.17011360824108124,
-0.056508295238018036,
0.466423898935318,
0.46551916003227234,
-0.675963282585144,
-0.4029143452644348,
0.340844064950943,
-0.8303623795509338,
-0.060265034437179565,
0.10922707617282867,
-0.20643508434295654,
0.40261006355285645,
0.5639172196388245,
-0.15749554336071014,
0.12511196732521057,
0.4144895374774933,
-0.2984655201435089,
0.5160680413246155,
-0.3100685477256775,
-0.18657895922660828,
-1.0891319513320923,
0.2348894327878952,
-0.019550714641809464,
-0.2180582582950592,
-0.6088669300079346,
0.02217940427362919,
0.20329049229621887,
0.11044759303331375,
-0.4691395163536072,
1.1831437349319458,
-0.7145419716835022,
-0.11170520633459091,
-0.6627997756004333,
0.3473578691482544,
0.1411672979593277,
0.23290686309337616,
0.08120222389698029,
1.1125593185424805,
0.4787510335445404,
-0.5460847020149231,
0.26620736718177795,
0.2365553081035614,
-0.1552560031414032,
0.2698860168457031,
-0.39304277300834656,
0.4243946373462677,
-0.19409237802028656,
0.07256679236888885,
-1.0278681516647339,
-0.04346763715147972,
0.3602566421031952,
-0.4451122581958771,
0.47379639744758606,
-0.3915027379989624,
-0.4756287932395935,
-0.09670783579349518,
-0.08382155001163483,
0.5506983995437622,
0.5939298868179321,
-0.8397199511528015,
0.665044903755188,
0.31476059556007385,
-0.09243571758270264,
-1.011948585510254,
-0.7667043209075928,
0.12974637746810913,
-0.16702298820018768,
0.01748264953494072,
0.10539817810058594,
0.0006953499978408217,
-0.10521668195724487,
0.004175531677901745,
-0.25953391194343567,
0.1441560834646225,
0.11955758929252625,
-0.1026206836104393,
0.0820000022649765,
-0.3339354395866394,
0.4168028235435486,
-0.007584292441606522,
-0.09528177231550217,
0.07522662729024887,
-0.33342936635017395,
0.3252028822898865,
-0.017082003876566887,
-0.30617064237594604,
-0.10423136502504349,
0.1173664852976799,
0.14197775721549988,
-0.6204564571380615,
0.7298871278762817,
0.8879057765007019,
-0.31573253870010376,
-0.3015526235103607,
-0.8952546715736389,
-0.12591610848903656,
-0.4742996096611023,
0.5590747594833374,
-0.3823491334915161,
-1.171734094619751,
0.4141521453857422,
0.053671687841415405,
0.15598367154598236,
0.5244223475456238,
0.6671470403671265,
0.06901069730520248,
1.0251502990722656,
0.4570207893848419,
-0.05723973736166954,
0.411205530166626,
0.10863145440816879,
0.3772630989551544,
-1.3387713432312012,
-0.30737051367759705,
-0.3257949650287628,
-0.24708157777786255,
-0.12401178479194641,
-0.42616212368011475,
-0.014266815967857838,
0.3945874869823456,
-0.13173528015613556,
0.07990948855876923,
-0.7558900713920593,
0.5528531670570374,
0.5773574709892273,
-0.019637303426861763,
0.1799163967370987,
0.1524505913257599,
0.10896351933479309,
0.045718636363744736,
-0.4659218192100525,
-0.4596045911312103,
1.2001222372055054,
0.359947144985199,
0.9001243114471436,
0.5040057301521301,
0.5895341038703918,
0.5199864506721497,
0.260011225938797,
-0.7466844320297241,
0.2819995880126953,
-0.146828293800354,
-0.8269752860069275,
-0.20412924885749817,
-0.22617287933826447,
-1.0098017454147339,
0.4075698256492615,
-0.1838075965642929,
-0.832958459854126,
0.14745095372200012,
0.4035922586917877,
-0.4699668884277344,
0.22859293222427368,
-0.6441016793251038,
0.6890377402305603,
-0.6056311726570129,
-0.7305298447608948,
-0.0018143625929951668,
-0.7490054965019226,
0.21527312695980072,
-0.20814643800258636,
0.19460149109363556,
-0.2283933162689209,
-0.16650135815143585,
0.7442035675048828,
0.12842918932437897,
0.649019718170166,
-0.18090924620628357,
-0.36407923698425293,
0.38310152292251587,
0.29990261793136597,
0.6604650020599365,
-0.04892057552933693,
-0.42293864488601685,
-0.3712562918663025,
-0.05355634540319443,
-0.3868286907672882,
-0.7412607669830322,
0.7852989435195923,
-0.6584411859512329,
-0.8058447241783142,
-0.49891138076782227,
-0.6893124580383301,
-0.022833630442619324,
0.33625757694244385,
-0.18899734318256378,
0.38228851556777954,
0.22111186385154724,
0.34767740964889526,
0.826611340045929,
-0.17019732296466827,
0.25837209820747375,
0.7603593468666077,
-0.37719497084617615,
-0.5145913362503052,
1.2421174049377441,
0.06841855496168137,
0.18857130408287048,
0.6083981990814209,
0.044248975813388824,
-0.7300384044647217,
-0.7215650081634521,
-0.4356456696987152,
0.25440508127212524,
-0.8411368131637573,
-0.49079638719558716,
-0.7218266129493713,
-0.3153769373893738,
-0.5372063517570496,
0.01360422745347023,
-0.25102075934410095,
-0.20482172071933746,
-0.6810226440429688,
-0.029379213228821754,
0.3271707594394684,
0.5212490558624268,
-0.027544448152184486,
0.2147638201713562,
-0.5479947328567505,
0.2905559539794922,
0.5220351219177246,
0.3849760591983795,
0.07453711330890656,
-1.1063112020492554,
-0.3898816406726837,
-0.050556402653455734,
-0.26200437545776367,
-0.5330121517181396,
0.28740358352661133,
0.2995036840438843,
0.6298787593841553,
0.2670596241950989,
0.20630361139774323,
0.5549141764640808,
-0.5843837857246399,
0.6053748726844788,
-0.023802615702152252,
-0.5560633540153503,
0.854297399520874,
-0.17875629663467407,
0.09906422346830368,
0.6390979290008545,
0.10209738463163376,
-0.3220249116420746,
-0.07825585454702377,
-0.3008468747138977,
-0.8048450946807861,
0.7389352917671204,
-0.23486736416816711,
0.015804799273610115,
-0.0709509328007698,
0.7653838396072388,
0.05216951295733452,
-0.01817280426621437,
-0.9869720339775085,
-0.35494235157966614,
-0.08275634050369263,
-0.41221609711647034,
0.015184227377176285,
-0.7477055191993713,
-0.33031436800956726,
0.13001906871795654,
1.0028325319290161,
-0.3289142847061157,
0.07826418429613113,
0.24178864061832428,
-0.317355215549469,
-0.1992044597864151,
0.353828489780426,
0.5765827894210815,
0.7443193793296814,
-0.4117574095726013,
0.571081817150116,
0.1764763444662094,
-0.026671700179576874,
0.31973209977149963,
0.29370442032814026,
-0.09076536446809769,
-0.33754676580429077,
0.23330377042293549,
0.8391733765602112,
-0.007312913425266743,
-0.8709602355957031,
0.34953275322914124,
0.29759907722473145,
-0.1709272563457489,
-0.10777509212493896,
0.23042109608650208,
-0.02826683036983013,
0.6049688458442688,
0.6702202558517456,
-0.1927187740802765,
0.2977907657623291,
-0.4224730432033539,
0.3588784635066986,
0.5640078186988831,
-0.6236864328384399,
-0.2625691890716553,
0.9513660669326782,
0.17498306930065155,
-0.601370632648468,
0.4419909119606018,
-0.4012987017631531,
-0.2949953079223633,
0.21735039353370667,
0.9947741031646729,
0.55509352684021,
-0.24153003096580505,
-0.18494965136051178,
0.5011157393455505,
0.15385140478610992,
-0.2376343160867691,
-0.11889107525348663,
0.06374552100896835,
-0.6552858352661133,
-0.5193221569061279,
-0.6744800209999084,
-0.20444244146347046,
0.385637491941452,
-0.7397559881210327,
0.11022858321666718,
-0.35830119252204895,
0.04269752278923988,
-0.11229049414396286,
0.028926897794008255,
-0.25377875566482544,
0.1235145851969719,
0.23039446771144867,
0.7271319031715393,
-0.6277455687522888,
1.0741853713989258,
0.8740453124046326,
-0.262623131275177,
-0.5478699207305908,
-0.15709075331687927,
0.040688399225473404,
-0.972165048122406,
0.8034089803695679,
0.1421820968389511,
-0.1532154083251953,
0.30021849274635315,
-0.3472459316253662,
-1.1328608989715576,
1.1485810279846191,
0.32651448249816895,
-0.6352465152740479,
0.008642710745334625,
-0.24080638587474823,
0.6491613388061523,
-0.2926681637763977,
0.25143560767173767,
0.4555671513080597,
0.25250619649887085,
0.3260354995727539,
-0.6006775498390198,
0.1214417815208435,
-0.18385040760040283,
-0.018208611756563187,
0.30814459919929504,
-0.730631947517395,
0.30603766441345215,
-0.2965875267982483,
-0.18235206604003906,
0.05434400960803032,
0.8205806612968445,
0.6299288868904114,
0.1423986256122589,
0.1937195509672165,
0.6368436217308044,
0.6575427651405334,
0.056559015065431595,
0.6515652537345886,
-0.13721711933612823,
0.4683796167373657,
1.4871844053268433,
-0.512471079826355,
1.061408281326294,
0.48124247789382935,
-0.15824192762374878,
0.25391218066215515,
0.5212470889091492,
-0.23012149333953857,
0.550050675868988,
0.0050274282693862915,
-0.310702383518219,
-0.31262093782424927,
-0.26472601294517517,
-0.5617552995681763,
0.08673693984746933,
0.3919386863708496,
-0.4183189272880554,
-0.24270077049732208,
-0.14299431443214417,
-0.14770901203155518,
0.15443450212478638,
-0.05363430827856064,
0.9584540724754333,
-0.14969885349273682,
-0.7154344916343689,
0.6372319459915161,
-0.13734163343906403,
0.6164259910583496,
-0.40464550256729126,
-0.23581388592720032,
-0.27967190742492676,
0.32371798157691956,
-0.18245761096477509,
-1.0136165618896484,
0.121452696621418,
-0.21764971315860748,
-0.3066067695617676,
-0.08246748149394989,
0.8174806833267212,
-0.8241031169891357,
-0.51100754737854,
0.5322656631469727,
0.40565425157546997,
0.1046641394495964,
0.04166547954082489,
-0.8309721350669861,
0.12725774943828583,
0.14731024205684662,
-0.13383036851882935,
0.6683853268623352,
0.3750208616256714,
0.10084383934736252,
0.8514825105667114,
0.5322576761245728,
0.05241239070892334,
0.15839128196239471,
-0.03227907419204712,
0.6628233790397644,
-0.5952565670013428,
-0.04837941750884056,
-0.7831831574440002,
0.362754225730896,
0.1276872307062149,
-0.026112481951713562,
0.6261138319969177,
0.9000173211097717,
0.6906726360321045,
0.15383358299732208,
0.6561662554740906,
-0.057998355478048325,
0.8526453971862793,
-0.5602534413337708,
0.6213675141334534,
-0.8355620503425598,
0.31252652406692505,
0.42829662561416626,
-0.9856395125389099,
-0.4957982003688812,
0.5504572987556458,
-0.2879820466041565,
-0.03183987736701965,
0.3159581422805786,
0.9098225235939026,
-0.10356714576482773,
-0.689229428768158,
0.1983025074005127,
0.17324526607990265,
0.5341946482658386,
0.45292311906814575,
0.6569419503211975,
-0.7415904998779297,
0.8311076164245605,
-0.011861288920044899,
0.08419245481491089,
-0.490866482257843,
-0.7101184129714966,
-0.9551201462745667,
-0.4188476502895355,
-0.43489018082618713,
-0.4443942606449127,
0.3621053099632263,
0.8223456144332886,
0.7546880841255188,
-0.9514009356498718,
-0.16304855048656464,
0.30667805671691895,
0.19140928983688354,
-0.03874250501394272,
-0.2460945099592209,
0.593295693397522,
-0.7037289142608643,
-0.5305135250091553,
0.510839581489563,
0.41071009635925293,
0.06958701461553574,
-0.0418388806283474,
-0.27467480301856995,
-0.6857724785804749,
-0.4163844585418701,
0.6524316668510437,
0.5667566657066345,
-1.2325729131698608,
-0.4495691955089569,
-0.2258341759443283,
-0.05815878510475159,
0.3715182840824127,
0.3040257692337036,
-0.8651744723320007,
0.8017466068267822,
0.12428314238786697,
1.066468358039856,
0.4372466802597046,
0.3372240364551544,
0.27672022581100464,
-0.8836190700531006,
0.04544222354888916,
0.11575040966272354,
0.07344228029251099,
0.4330085515975952,
-0.4822479486465454,
0.6530994176864624,
-0.11243085563182831,
-0.8143794536590576,
-1.0015305280685425,
0.12924639880657196,
-0.8596968054771423,
-0.17231816053390503,
1.4220726490020752,
0.06559085100889206,
-0.14535264670848846,
-0.009717469103634357,
-0.3754390478134155,
0.2756305932998657,
-0.49472281336784363,
0.819965660572052,
0.4815007448196411,
-0.019593609496951103,
-0.5680389404296875,
-0.6376152038574219,
0.44155997037887573,
0.5739306807518005,
-0.6077892184257507,
0.24614310264587402,
0.37002333998680115,
0.42482107877731323,
0.20770207047462463,
0.3760155141353607,
0.017275370657444,
0.1478590965270996,
-0.4463706612586975,
0.22117941081523895,
-0.07664377242326736,
-0.24302832782268524,
-0.46662986278533936,
0.021231507882475853,
0.49246975779533386,
-0.015542428940534592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13534v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13534v1
|
An Effective Incorporating Heterogeneous Knowledge Curriculum Learning for Sequence Labeling
| 2024-02-21T05:04:29 | 2024-02-21T05:04:29 |
Xuemei Tang, Qi Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Sequence labeling models often benefit from incorporating external knowledge.
However, this practice introduces data heterogeneity and complicates the model
with additional modules, leading to increased expenses for training a
high-performing model. To address this challenge, we propose a two-stage
curriculum learning (TCL) framework specifically designed for sequence labeling
tasks. The TCL framework enhances training by gradually introducing data
instances from easy to hard, aiming to improve both performance and training
speed. Furthermore, we explore different metrics for assessing the difficulty
levels of sequence labeling tasks. Through extensive experimentation on six
Chinese word segmentation (CWS) and Part-of-speech tagging (POS) datasets, we
demonstrate the effectiveness of our model in enhancing the performance of
sequence labeling models. Additionally, our analysis indicates that TCL
accelerates training and alleviates the slow training problem associated with
complex models.
|
[
-0.04457555338740349,
-0.49970564246177673,
0.25427237153053284,
0.12198084592819214,
-0.23651690781116486,
0.15233585238456726,
-0.06639379262924194,
-0.4727797210216522,
-0.5565286874771118,
0.41177111864089966,
-0.2887207567691803,
-0.6797184944152832,
-0.5133471488952637,
-0.25377157330513,
-0.12522536516189575,
0.8377556800842285,
0.26948657631874084,
0.2403215616941452,
0.13922525942325592,
-0.05465881526470184,
-0.6986045837402344,
-0.24308475852012634,
-0.6306524276733398,
-0.4166484475135803,
0.6578854322433472,
0.567172646522522,
0.4257064461708069,
1.046877384185791,
0.23973163962364197,
0.15188317000865936,
-0.19664153456687927,
0.4401783049106598,
-0.31555771827697754,
0.14308464527130127,
-0.29373541474342346,
-0.553764820098877,
-0.28874924778938293,
0.07460382580757141,
0.8031328916549683,
1.0072396993637085,
-0.16820645332336426,
0.024196449667215347,
0.28357750177383423,
0.4648178517818451,
-0.647357702255249,
0.39300522208213806,
-0.48902854323387146,
0.5521031618118286,
-0.2779335677623749,
-0.0008511325577273965,
-0.6409823894500732,
-0.2919839024543762,
0.7274045944213867,
-0.6493028402328491,
0.10575129091739655,
0.04238395392894745,
0.6998250484466553,
0.18035157024860382,
-0.40428099036216736,
-0.2950345575809479,
-0.5217766761779785,
0.6770904064178467,
-0.5812681317329407,
0.48413076996803284,
0.28154686093330383,
0.2569660544395447,
0.26155713200569153,
-0.8265714645385742,
-0.28368833661079407,
0.08244781941175461,
0.010760716162621975,
0.10216392576694489,
0.5220954418182373,
-0.06576646864414215,
0.37348082661628723,
0.25314992666244507,
-0.30816590785980225,
0.3785628080368042,
-0.5243027806282043,
-0.2501569390296936,
0.3547818958759308,
0.37251126766204834,
0.24527204036712646,
-0.05663331225514412,
-0.39424997568130493,
-0.18814238905906677,
-0.6451234817504883,
0.15043574571609497,
0.19354347884655,
0.879058301448822,
0.021188268437981606,
0.5269694328308105,
0.10327424854040146,
0.7810277342796326,
0.04510686919093132,
-0.2061188817024231,
0.3090038001537323,
-0.20918945968151093,
-0.14441904425621033,
0.37870392203330994,
0.04354478791356087,
-0.08448915928602219,
-0.24337643384933472,
-0.1267058104276657,
-0.149953693151474,
-0.18147161602973938,
0.1438073217868805,
-0.8170644044876099,
-0.2802331745624542,
0.213125079870224,
-0.07276211678981781,
-0.011924159713089466,
0.2780001759529114,
-0.39907553791999817,
-0.4974392056465149,
-0.48923051357269287,
0.4417314827442169,
-0.7100585103034973,
0.09127117693424225,
0.1653318554162979,
-0.18098488450050354,
0.48299407958984375,
0.5735186338424683,
-0.6051903367042542,
-0.10066947340965271,
0.8905725479125977,
1.0636036396026611,
-0.07052313536405563,
-0.06360124051570892,
-0.9477902054786682,
0.38831135630607605,
-0.15250681340694427,
0.6773087382316589,
-0.644173800945282,
-0.4490841329097748,
0.09581220149993896,
-0.021349843591451645,
-0.15204879641532898,
-0.37548327445983887,
0.13401776552200317,
-0.5965070128440857,
0.4126184284687042,
-0.2659968435764313,
-0.7493338584899902,
-0.23023469746112823,
0.2058856338262558,
-0.5695363879203796,
0.9063645005226135,
0.18824703991413116,
-0.7833920121192932,
0.4150398075580597,
-0.42208993434906006,
-0.8719083666801453,
0.20634181797504425,
-0.14103183150291443,
-0.4381449818611145,
-0.4316818118095398,
-0.14276811480522156,
0.6770197153091431,
-0.3714182376861572,
0.2977520525455475,
-0.13725298643112183,
-0.4075317084789276,
-0.2007373571395874,
0.22119419276714325,
0.9346479177474976,
0.4395936131477356,
-0.2800852954387665,
-0.03556372597813606,
-0.8440564870834351,
0.07087228447198868,
-0.291120320558548,
-0.7086547613143921,
-0.5340757966041565,
0.09083884209394455,
-0.2151777744293213,
0.2675447165966034,
-0.08090481907129288,
-0.19497661292552948,
0.3974320888519287,
-0.5689731240272522,
0.27744969725608826,
0.6307654976844788,
-0.14513404667377472,
0.5325404405593872,
-0.301222562789917,
0.15343855321407318,
0.48433464765548706,
-0.2250787764787674,
-0.40289345383644104,
-0.5822042226791382,
-0.8488335609436035,
-0.14120210707187653,
0.37315189838409424,
0.6710399985313416,
-1.0987237691879272,
0.43873172998428345,
0.14585570991039276,
-0.5868880748748779,
-0.28252720832824707,
0.048035357147455215,
0.6028909087181091,
0.8255729675292969,
0.6652422547340393,
-0.7878470420837402,
-0.28151240944862366,
-0.4846213161945343,
0.02673797681927681,
-0.03743259236216545,
-0.25362062454223633,
0.14379802346229553,
0.1997145265340805,
-0.01416800357401371,
0.7382852435112,
-0.6170457601547241,
-0.39530763030052185,
-0.2581392526626587,
0.6854567527770996,
0.04759443923830986,
0.7151678204536438,
-0.02414923720061779,
-0.7215782403945923,
-0.4208444058895111,
0.07489193975925446,
-0.48712465167045593,
-0.04637635499238968,
-0.0821111723780632,
-0.07120107114315033,
0.15013526380062103,
0.2212451696395874,
0.2460315078496933,
0.3085944950580597,
-0.01203469093888998,
-0.33903324604034424,
0.3810497224330902,
-0.3365645408630371,
-0.06889726966619492,
-1.0024977922439575,
-0.1775767058134079,
0.4877883493900299,
0.2019093632698059,
-0.7441523671150208,
-0.18339762091636658,
0.3713679313659668,
0.06110790744423866,
-0.7185080647468567,
0.1222972497344017,
-0.47332894802093506,
-0.19298991560935974,
0.08289775252342224,
-0.12875990569591522,
0.22431403398513794,
0.494637131690979,
0.4049283266067505,
0.6210699677467346,
0.46537843346595764,
-0.748212993144989,
0.02011231519281864,
0.15178033709526062,
-0.6681632399559021,
0.4858100712299347,
-0.3688196837902069,
0.05684760585427284,
-0.197988823056221,
0.3084467947483063,
-0.90240478515625,
-0.15032298862934113,
0.3750048577785492,
0.18786582350730896,
0.567846417427063,
0.033546142280101776,
-0.3566592037677765,
-0.27937567234039307,
-0.21050986647605896,
0.3550107181072235,
0.37598520517349243,
-0.4245375394821167,
0.46829351782798767,
0.26159703731536865,
0.2433163970708847,
-0.4443768858909607,
-0.912422239780426,
-0.3764021396636963,
-0.2516954243183136,
-0.4707910120487213,
0.48730528354644775,
0.13983745872974396,
0.1339636594057083,
-0.21491749584674835,
-0.02561318688094616,
-0.38846585154533386,
0.01768011599779129,
0.008531739003956318,
0.25762104988098145,
-0.557129979133606,
0.38213178515434265,
0.09011577069759369,
0.054868876934051514,
-0.22001439332962036,
-0.9298108220100403,
0.26060888171195984,
0.1651417464017868,
-0.15276728570461273,
-0.5781306624412537,
0.10462259501218796,
0.0375036895275116,
-0.38843247294425964,
0.6151691675186157,
0.6426599621772766,
-0.4020839333534241,
-0.5063795447349548,
-0.236088365316391,
0.08820927888154984,
-0.4080235958099365,
0.5071479678153992,
-0.31388649344444275,
-0.838076114654541,
0.1257994920015335,
0.0065458123572170734,
0.1480167806148529,
0.33032795786857605,
0.4161928594112396,
0.02019893378019333,
0.6894134879112244,
0.6223289966583252,
0.2114345133304596,
0.40883564949035645,
-0.3316139578819275,
0.012942382134497166,
-0.7866300344467163,
-0.5399377346038818,
-0.5798588395118713,
-0.007902615703642368,
-0.32850685715675354,
-1.1395323276519775,
0.25819647312164307,
-0.06347522139549255,
-0.6113911867141724,
0.3685934543609619,
-0.5313168168067932,
0.37211480736732483,
0.5346648693084717,
0.49531984329223633,
0.4419306814670563,
-0.06477595120668411,
-0.12584392726421356,
0.09525107592344284,
-0.962951123714447,
-0.27323269844055176,
0.9218915700912476,
0.39242538809776306,
0.6786172986030579,
0.07901805639266968,
0.47274935245513916,
0.265565425157547,
0.31490451097488403,
-0.8345252871513367,
0.25419947504997253,
-0.5696240663528442,
-0.4927261769771576,
-0.4078494906425476,
-0.3868143856525421,
-0.5865737199783325,
0.34083738923072815,
-0.20098458230495453,
-0.8501356244087219,
0.3621160089969635,
0.1305134892463684,
-0.720084547996521,
0.24136237800121307,
-0.5955443978309631,
0.6071348190307617,
-0.1485947221517563,
-0.7070858478546143,
0.06892476975917816,
-1.2151340246200562,
0.6460830569267273,
-0.16240042448043823,
0.2955074608325958,
-0.1491124927997589,
0.03448246419429779,
0.8570417165756226,
-0.3469442129135132,
0.8268423080444336,
-0.19042633473873138,
-0.41570693254470825,
0.49072936177253723,
-0.18102455139160156,
0.2683718502521515,
-0.13604794442653656,
-0.11382967978715897,
-0.16878946125507355,
-0.15641842782497406,
-0.26913467049598694,
-0.32270461320877075,
0.19674928486347198,
-0.6094207763671875,
-0.49937453866004944,
-0.35604196786880493,
-0.7009804248809814,
-0.5398157238960266,
-0.12880563735961914,
0.14288611710071564,
0.6010932922363281,
0.17596721649169922,
0.028974682092666626,
1.1759763956069946,
-0.6092520952224731,
0.04331492260098457,
0.28517094254493713,
0.21723270416259766,
-0.22203770279884338,
1.0348780155181885,
0.46392711997032166,
0.5413002371788025,
0.4879786968231201,
0.3181903660297394,
-0.18642348051071167,
-0.2589169442653656,
-0.3395768404006958,
-0.08579371869564056,
-0.7335190773010254,
-0.16999700665473938,
-0.8334523439407349,
-0.37812739610671997,
-0.5284239649772644,
-0.06884750723838806,
-0.35949021577835083,
-0.4903417229652405,
-0.4874310791492462,
0.23008887469768524,
-0.10274191200733185,
0.5494239330291748,
-0.028363967314362526,
0.5707700848579407,
-0.9007639288902283,
0.25837817788124084,
0.32599079608917236,
0.2395651489496231,
0.28767523169517517,
-0.8224814534187317,
-0.4515446126461029,
-0.06588703393936157,
-0.43411365151405334,
-0.679235577583313,
0.07551231235265732,
0.40364211797714233,
0.23715806007385254,
0.5701992511749268,
-0.1034369245171547,
0.8189323544502258,
-0.5640664100646973,
0.7017574906349182,
0.31181275844573975,
-1.0182201862335205,
0.6034060716629028,
-0.08516064286231995,
0.5355125665664673,
0.2729627192020416,
0.6301133632659912,
-0.54453045129776,
-0.3774299621582031,
-0.32051393389701843,
-1.099910855293274,
1.1920902729034424,
-0.1162680834531784,
-0.07254442572593689,
0.26299574971199036,
0.2998548746109009,
0.28426897525787354,
0.01180663425475359,
-0.4838472008705139,
-0.40946418046951294,
-0.2046806514263153,
-0.10422706604003906,
0.08868017792701721,
-0.36381304264068604,
0.0675986185669899,
-0.5064968466758728,
0.888367772102356,
-0.060610704123973846,
-0.03529782220721245,
0.03684278577566147,
-0.18966561555862427,
0.19098162651062012,
0.2398815006017685,
0.35775619745254517,
0.30770930647850037,
-0.19489458203315735,
0.19231168925762177,
-0.008797027170658112,
-0.36893248558044434,
0.1732088178396225,
0.2500261664390564,
0.10625360161066055,
-0.3853920102119446,
0.5585647821426392,
0.5352268815040588,
0.2959508001804352,
-0.4381182789802551,
0.28695860505104065,
0.20925427973270416,
-0.08882788568735123,
0.44848889112472534,
0.38517263531684875,
0.13457566499710083,
0.4298378825187683,
0.42811471223831177,
-0.46610015630722046,
0.23843200504779816,
-0.67796790599823,
0.5774293541908264,
-0.18570385873317719,
-0.46408236026763916,
-0.13173212110996246,
0.6859262585639954,
0.2448613941669464,
0.008940441533923149,
0.5716925263404846,
-0.20116445422172546,
-0.781938910484314,
0.8877062797546387,
0.6633794903755188,
0.4120389521121979,
-0.5055966377258301,
0.4003261625766754,
0.6726412177085876,
0.12781333923339844,
-0.41776013374328613,
0.07410082221031189,
-0.20868369936943054,
-0.6230738759040833,
-0.23641382157802582,
-0.4824345111846924,
-0.4626006782054901,
-0.2942754924297333,
-0.6697337627410889,
0.5176548361778259,
-0.569617509841919,
0.19951555132865906,
0.22149954736232758,
0.000500648922752589,
-0.6363730430603027,
0.551960825920105,
0.3962174355983734,
0.865422785282135,
-0.7128158807754517,
1.18585205078125,
0.526109516620636,
-0.3988225758075714,
-1.2495167255401611,
-0.03727953881025314,
0.14777986705303192,
-0.7262743711471558,
0.9612127542495728,
0.5257277488708496,
0.15407158434391022,
0.1390923708677292,
-0.2762683629989624,
-0.5521441698074341,
1.2199660539627075,
-0.17915889620780945,
-0.8022376894950867,
-0.18447117507457733,
0.29050859808921814,
0.35919633507728577,
-0.6223772168159485,
0.06078442186117172,
0.5768531560897827,
0.4481634795665741,
0.6132225394248962,
-0.4974813163280487,
0.03353036567568779,
0.20777812600135803,
0.185704305768013,
-0.03919970244169235,
-0.5141463875770569,
1.075427770614624,
-0.3720919191837311,
-0.45659998059272766,
-0.08179628849029541,
0.9460600018501282,
0.039328496903181076,
0.6394924521446228,
0.5983068943023682,
0.40517517924308777,
1.0908560752868652,
-0.16036547720432281,
0.3889963626861572,
0.03140123933553696,
0.38375115394592285,
1.589110255241394,
-0.5712507367134094,
0.3491007089614868,
0.2650502026081085,
-0.17831282317638397,
0.4756058156490326,
0.890894889831543,
-0.17579203844070435,
0.5901367664337158,
0.5542235970497131,
-0.17556636035442352,
-0.3803618252277374,
-0.39881616830825806,
-0.6506313681602478,
0.3640282154083252,
0.5296669602394104,
-0.3250052332878113,
-0.3668993413448334,
0.21966694295406342,
-0.16510090231895447,
-0.055959779769182205,
-0.2323136180639267,
0.6361096501350403,
-0.01105300709605217,
-0.4702290892601013,
0.21149931848049164,
0.07678788155317307,
0.49743571877479553,
-0.63555508852005,
-0.05653000250458717,
-0.13993152976036072,
-0.2051638513803482,
-0.15131975710391998,
-0.6521754264831543,
0.170424222946167,
-0.09003623574972153,
0.07509146630764008,
0.02038843370974064,
0.447247177362442,
-0.8017330765724182,
-0.29850608110427856,
-0.02644282951951027,
0.5039936304092407,
-0.11598986387252808,
0.3028026521205902,
-0.48848432302474976,
-0.14318469166755676,
-0.056312739849090576,
-0.19704680144786835,
0.07032361626625061,
0.6572273969650269,
-0.07583335787057877,
0.4477549195289612,
0.40665334463119507,
-0.23193231225013733,
-0.04409835860133171,
-0.1074715256690979,
0.8092849850654602,
-0.773369312286377,
-0.5905774235725403,
-0.548462450504303,
0.6771295666694641,
0.03315179795026779,
-0.1213349774479866,
0.3963651955127716,
0.6882176995277405,
1.024701714515686,
0.1447821408510208,
0.7330902814865112,
-0.22649264335632324,
0.18468812108039856,
-0.6784177422523499,
0.4794239103794098,
-0.6132023334503174,
0.6997863054275513,
-0.15620259940624237,
-0.7161893248558044,
-0.6447167992591858,
0.5196245908737183,
-0.40518051385879517,
-0.31200796365737915,
0.816815197467804,
0.5714364051818848,
0.020652934908866882,
0.3143672049045563,
0.22201424837112427,
0.026187492534518242,
0.19477900862693787,
0.8931856155395508,
0.9710454940795898,
-0.1953524351119995,
0.08952414244413376,
-0.5540608167648315,
-0.19679391384124756,
-0.013429772108793259,
-0.8926523327827454,
-0.8740068674087524,
-0.6640102863311768,
-0.548048734664917,
-0.5626606941223145,
0.253162682056427,
1.0728437900543213,
0.6243106722831726,
-0.6748852729797363,
-0.2829552888870239,
0.2870294153690338,
0.32386305928230286,
-0.1428733766078949,
-0.21429374814033508,
0.5243523120880127,
-0.5704808235168457,
-0.8063540458679199,
0.14757396280765533,
0.2134489268064499,
-0.018676510080695152,
0.08783039450645447,
0.0902688130736351,
-0.4649884104728699,
-0.1029420867562294,
0.6245588064193726,
0.12980583310127258,
-0.4974224269390106,
-0.3808627128601074,
-0.4982473850250244,
-0.49585431814193726,
0.3601386845111847,
1.1220130920410156,
-0.6435567140579224,
0.5871776342391968,
0.23685939610004425,
0.9287047982215881,
0.33350592851638794,
-0.011664429679512978,
0.38265880942344666,
-0.7045615911483765,
0.15669414401054382,
0.15733762085437775,
0.09341729432344437,
0.2501574456691742,
-0.5128093957901001,
0.6118049025535583,
0.38768258690834045,
-0.0684477761387825,
-0.7061635255813599,
0.06482932716608047,
-0.9430254697799683,
-0.500390887260437,
1.0440325736999512,
-0.4143073558807373,
-0.058725107461214066,
-0.2688635289669037,
-0.0777539312839508,
0.8148936033248901,
-0.09846305102109909,
0.6948928833007812,
0.6588287949562073,
-0.038781389594078064,
0.42433416843414307,
-0.3450383245944977,
0.250119686126709,
0.32724910974502563,
-0.7639058232307434,
-0.1266811490058899,
0.6283427476882935,
0.2073076218366623,
-0.043531302362680435,
0.26771822571754456,
0.008020300418138504,
0.1949409544467926,
-0.17889147996902466,
-0.20573510229587555,
-0.13877716660499573,
-0.5190722942352295,
-0.17334364354610443,
0.48840752243995667,
-0.13737331330776215,
0.022669658064842224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13533v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13533v1
|
FinGPT-HPC: Efficient Pretraining and Finetuning Large Language Models for Financial Applications with High-Performance Computing
| 2024-02-21T05:03:17 | 2024-02-21T05:03:17 |
Xiao-Yang Liu, Jie Zhang, Guoxuan Wang, Weiqing Tong, Anwar Walid
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DC
|
Large language models (LLMs) are computationally intensive. The computation
workload and the memory footprint grow quadratically with the dimension (layer
width). Most of LLMs' parameters come from the linear layers of the transformer
structure and are highly redundant. These linear layers contribute more than
80% of the computation workload and 99% of the model size. To pretrain and
finetune LLMs efficiently, there are three major challenges to address: 1)
reducing redundancy of the linear layers; 2) reducing GPU memory footprint; 3)
improving GPU utilization when using distributed training. Prior methods, such
as LoRA and QLoRA, utilized low-rank matrices and quantization to reduce the
number of trainable parameters and model size, respectively. However, the
resulting model still consumes a large amount of GPU memory. In this paper, we
present high-performance GPU-based methods that exploit low-rank structures to
pretrain and finetune LLMs for financial applications. We replace one
conventional linear layer of the transformer structure with two narrower linear
layers, which allows us to reduce the number of parameters by several orders of
magnitude. By quantizing the parameters into low precision (8-bit and 4-bit),
the memory consumption of the resulting model is further reduced. Compared with
existing LLMs, our methods achieve a speedup of 1.3X and a model compression
ratio of 2.64X for pretaining without accuracy drop. For finetuning, our
methods achieve an average accuracy increase of 6.3% and 24.0% in general tasks
and financial tasks, respectively, and GPU memory consumption ratio of 6.3X.
The sizes of our models are smaller than 0.59 GB, allowing inference on a
smartphone.
|
[
-0.5691611766815186,
-1.0611342191696167,
0.35065755248069763,
0.2146984487771988,
-0.22779619693756104,
0.04101729393005371,
-0.37162327766418457,
-0.2719435691833496,
-0.24825412034988403,
0.5257575511932373,
-0.21292708814144135,
-0.29432952404022217,
-0.412310391664505,
-0.3777017593383789,
-0.1492440551519394,
0.9398951530456543,
-0.0439729318022728,
-0.08180136233568192,
-0.09433431178331375,
0.1188579872250557,
-0.08234959840774536,
-0.67204749584198,
-1.119239091873169,
-0.4083896577358246,
0.4207260310649872,
0.3580261468887329,
0.7096633315086365,
0.8051311373710632,
0.7537410855293274,
0.36000117659568787,
0.10072896629571915,
-0.038058292120695114,
-0.7250676155090332,
-0.17360153794288635,
0.18959620594978333,
-0.3205493092536926,
-0.6829346418380737,
0.12087110430002213,
0.6973681449890137,
0.6410055160522461,
-0.4307886064052582,
0.37386631965637207,
0.17450931668281555,
0.5998491644859314,
-0.8077231645584106,
0.5649713277816772,
-0.383588045835495,
-0.024500926956534386,
-0.4953990578651428,
-0.13981343805789948,
-0.3901548385620117,
-0.48939570784568787,
-0.06449471414089203,
-0.7904256582260132,
0.1791805922985077,
-0.02433313988149166,
0.7035647034645081,
0.46557626128196716,
-0.22548840939998627,
0.16223274171352386,
-1.0058717727661133,
0.7177250981330872,
-0.8495237231254578,
0.49160236120224,
0.31693562865257263,
0.3351588845252991,
0.15172810852527618,
-0.8836592435836792,
-0.31630587577819824,
-0.10736862570047379,
-0.06207338720560074,
-0.029848316684365273,
-0.12198308855295181,
0.42601335048675537,
0.5695866942405701,
0.5870316624641418,
-0.41738536953926086,
0.2807198166847229,
-0.31672319769859314,
-0.10101225972175598,
0.39949843287467957,
0.05890766903758049,
-0.08166754245758057,
0.12283272296190262,
-0.3691571056842804,
-0.40826863050460815,
-0.8936011791229248,
0.037072837352752686,
0.39649778604507446,
0.5004426836967468,
-0.03503894805908203,
0.21947601437568665,
0.11078985780477524,
0.6514198184013367,
0.07822310924530029,
-0.4869972765445709,
-0.06836055219173431,
-0.17854087054729462,
-0.6578518748283386,
0.07027143239974976,
0.749148428440094,
-0.10319548100233078,
0.25955456495285034,
0.11247757822275162,
-0.27447810769081116,
-0.15342913568019867,
0.2530713379383087,
-1.0644339323043823,
-0.2650836706161499,
-0.018991049379110336,
-0.420075923204422,
-0.17836064100265503,
-0.27280542254447937,
-0.8038208484649658,
-0.12854266166687012,
-0.41603466868400574,
0.5557172298431396,
-0.22174358367919922,
0.12700410187244415,
0.05451881140470505,
0.2755148708820343,
0.48695385456085205,
0.28094926476478577,
-1.3115172386169434,
0.7934930920600891,
0.8429401516914368,
0.6200822591781616,
-0.0022517505567520857,
-0.0470532663166523,
-0.9441965818405151,
0.14786231517791748,
-0.005040687974542379,
0.5078098773956299,
-0.33525407314300537,
-0.1912141889333725,
-0.2964714467525482,
-0.19078044593334198,
-0.28694602847099304,
-0.45316192507743835,
0.6470944881439209,
-0.46235087513923645,
0.07859130203723907,
-0.13325951993465424,
-0.4963133633136749,
-0.08961929380893707,
0.03152291104197502,
-0.696243405342102,
1.0205507278442383,
0.18349137902259827,
-0.7885805368423462,
0.10729306191205978,
-0.4335731863975525,
-0.6131684184074402,
0.20307320356369019,
-0.14957255125045776,
-0.6479505300521851,
0.05246496945619583,
0.33911457657814026,
0.5818936228752136,
-0.7392027974128723,
0.2573181688785553,
-0.12155851721763611,
-0.7900216579437256,
-0.2099112719297409,
-0.5594021677970886,
0.24191990494728088,
0.2904437184333801,
-0.5422765612602234,
0.16547663509845734,
-0.7890862822532654,
0.027456635609269142,
0.05912034213542938,
-0.24028053879737854,
-0.35302919149398804,
-0.15015007555484772,
0.2757129371166229,
0.012262646108865738,
0.3628757894039154,
-0.33003368973731995,
0.13951611518859863,
-0.4245741367340088,
0.8143420219421387,
0.7848160862922668,
-0.47339871525764465,
0.39676177501678467,
-0.10648257285356522,
0.42532292008399963,
-0.27932262420654297,
0.4676729142665863,
0.015636935830116272,
-0.14971458911895752,
-0.6456831097602844,
-0.2908895015716553,
0.3906085789203644,
0.6003623604774475,
-0.5966982841491699,
0.1412585973739624,
-0.19329135119915009,
-0.510795533657074,
-0.22992654144763947,
0.11945988237857819,
0.3645227253437042,
0.4961595833301544,
0.36401480436325073,
0.055561866611242294,
-0.24083325266838074,
-0.9331357479095459,
-0.07969588041305542,
-0.03792572021484375,
0.0018260907381772995,
0.479757696390152,
0.26222267746925354,
0.0047912211157381535,
0.5157511830329895,
-0.6513621807098389,
-0.12986095249652863,
-0.11901523917913437,
0.055002450942993164,
0.4704650938510895,
0.7064156532287598,
0.6003683805465698,
-0.6290716528892517,
-0.39384278655052185,
0.2535261809825897,
-0.36815857887268066,
0.01774357259273529,
-0.26078036427497864,
0.0802140086889267,
0.09874197095632553,
0.6204735040664673,
-0.6245261430740356,
0.2853507995605469,
0.6669168472290039,
-0.10166497528553009,
0.34341537952423096,
-0.5330013632774353,
-0.054514456540346146,
-0.8665653467178345,
0.2670758068561554,
0.21068456768989563,
-0.4062146842479706,
-0.5231244564056396,
-0.03595302253961563,
-0.004707365296781063,
-0.24331235885620117,
-0.2819405198097229,
0.6314074397087097,
-0.2565922141075134,
-0.1650540828704834,
-0.22087572515010834,
-0.02066168561577797,
-0.12528668344020844,
0.6796882748603821,
-0.2670777440071106,
1.1050925254821777,
0.4415341913700104,
-0.536165714263916,
0.4177572429180145,
-0.04687562212347984,
-0.2600582540035248,
0.3241672217845917,
-0.7439058423042297,
-0.019866088405251503,
0.06519642472267151,
-0.084307961165905,
-0.7646632790565491,
-0.12735694646835327,
0.08690473437309265,
0.1370759755373001,
0.31675395369529724,
-0.049574945122003555,
-0.4065735638141632,
-0.4183765947818756,
-0.1566714644432068,
0.6126070618629456,
0.5258899331092834,
-0.626801073551178,
0.8089199662208557,
0.3497733175754547,
-0.5359366536140442,
-0.5957769751548767,
-0.7395960688591003,
-0.14718757569789886,
-0.3543517291545868,
-0.6292620897293091,
0.5683944225311279,
0.07310904562473297,
-0.15605175495147705,
-0.2846262753009796,
-0.04752465337514877,
-0.018719317391514778,
0.12791293859481812,
0.3511092960834503,
0.5627202391624451,
-0.41893643140792847,
0.023060303181409836,
-0.08820541203022003,
-0.27112725377082825,
-0.16188772022724152,
-0.5463025569915771,
0.7192327380180359,
-0.49906331300735474,
-0.30897513031959534,
-0.492462694644928,
0.05995995178818703,
0.4891173243522644,
-0.25884783267974854,
0.7637709379196167,
0.7858366966247559,
-0.4238395690917969,
-0.14183057844638824,
-0.838992178440094,
-0.006058301776647568,
-0.562086820602417,
0.23320457339286804,
-0.36036163568496704,
-1.2503552436828613,
0.7827184796333313,
-0.24108627438545227,
0.026149189099669456,
0.6202473640441895,
0.6310678720474243,
0.16733376681804657,
0.6808690428733826,
0.7032815217971802,
-0.2748682200908661,
0.6931853294372559,
-0.2600526213645935,
0.3633616268634796,
-0.39752188324928284,
0.02186671830713749,
-0.39902713894844055,
-0.318206787109375,
-0.6503537893295288,
-0.557449460029602,
0.3345481753349304,
0.29310035705566406,
-0.7922816276550293,
0.15674184262752533,
-0.29772377014160156,
0.5544211268424988,
0.7054891586303711,
-0.08529561012983322,
0.18214203417301178,
0.24083398282527924,
-0.2019643485546112,
0.1524634212255478,
-0.6897454857826233,
-0.3304307460784912,
1.016103982925415,
0.5703343749046326,
1.0592310428619385,
-0.32872647047042847,
0.4697217047214508,
-0.05930988863110542,
0.23191781342029572,
-0.6819880604743958,
0.3611420691013336,
-0.6466520428657532,
-0.1500006914138794,
-0.49240022897720337,
-0.8041312098503113,
-0.4849364757537842,
0.15275177359580994,
-0.1579938679933548,
-0.5421074628829956,
0.1518532931804657,
0.18584245443344116,
-0.9665347337722778,
0.6047057509422302,
-0.7253289222717285,
1.026967167854309,
-0.31948041915893555,
-0.7243798971176147,
-0.07090191543102264,
-0.22486412525177002,
0.3175012171268463,
-0.24626624584197998,
0.11767042428255081,
0.12365779280662537,
0.31314924359321594,
0.6624850630760193,
-0.8002498745918274,
0.6446649432182312,
-0.29438671469688416,
-0.29041650891304016,
0.23912404477596283,
-0.28373652696609497,
0.8705008029937744,
0.12147998809814453,
-0.08053067326545715,
-0.07931888103485107,
0.070004403591156,
-0.42756956815719604,
-0.46251460909843445,
0.7854539155960083,
-0.8544113636016846,
-0.38227933645248413,
-0.07136569172143936,
-0.4883815348148346,
-0.35891324281692505,
0.22430001199245453,
0.13367962837219238,
0.3285779058933258,
-0.2234681397676468,
0.2719014286994934,
0.5959433317184448,
-0.2660641372203827,
0.516836404800415,
-0.0865192785859108,
-0.04661450907588005,
-0.5627760291099548,
0.9283413290977478,
-0.07106269150972366,
0.0902206227183342,
0.1339595913887024,
0.13214156031608582,
-0.25179925560951233,
-0.7589734792709351,
-0.24262738227844238,
0.3092518448829651,
-0.4248514771461487,
-0.3045549690723419,
-0.1891629695892334,
-0.46546506881713867,
-0.34996914863586426,
-0.1567477434873581,
-0.7761408686637878,
-0.4037986695766449,
-0.20494084060192108,
0.008479217067360878,
0.3937332332134247,
0.45428377389907837,
-0.0012613417347893119,
0.9255783557891846,
-0.7912425994873047,
0.3858916461467743,
0.5568166971206665,
0.7446327209472656,
0.1726030558347702,
-0.34880393743515015,
-0.4387800395488739,
-0.12266233563423157,
-0.15697292983531952,
0.004375385120511055,
0.49430179595947266,
0.15531398355960846,
0.4444420039653778,
0.5973572731018066,
-0.23793937265872955,
0.9948065876960754,
-0.2537551522254944,
0.3769586384296417,
0.09120095521211624,
-1.0295486450195312,
0.24178318679332733,
-0.4264340102672577,
0.11522892117500305,
0.6558521389961243,
0.28991153836250305,
-0.2860414683818817,
0.033786430954933167,
-0.3914806544780731,
-0.8162849545478821,
0.5732166767120361,
0.2608337998390198,
-0.11823276430368423,
0.30640122294425964,
0.816380500793457,
0.018352890387177467,
0.04869387298822403,
-0.6692370176315308,
-0.265438973903656,
-0.07414549589157104,
-0.02257944643497467,
-0.28991442918777466,
-0.2980535626411438,
0.06047288328409195,
-0.48606759309768677,
0.5996164679527283,
-0.27730801701545715,
0.06260544061660767,
-0.11970652639865875,
0.13126130402088165,
0.0036779216025024652,
0.21637706458568573,
0.6161752343177795,
0.5733994841575623,
-0.3863357603549957,
0.15279620885849,
0.29236090183258057,
-0.8543139696121216,
0.02848409302532673,
0.5346842408180237,
0.0027414129581302404,
-0.44467517733573914,
0.11761821061372757,
1.1144105195999146,
0.33843106031417847,
-0.4016175866127014,
0.3695994019508362,
-0.314200222492218,
-0.2691260576248169,
-0.3628293573856354,
0.019327912479639053,
0.1936393678188324,
0.35471367835998535,
0.303499311208725,
0.05926259234547615,
-0.19444526731967926,
-0.2619270384311676,
0.16269272565841675,
0.39312678575515747,
-0.2843080163002014,
-0.13447776436805725,
0.8424314260482788,
0.08118689060211182,
0.26666533946990967,
0.9568212628364563,
0.10825836658477783,
-0.1378145068883896,
0.46153172850608826,
0.5675680637359619,
0.7597007155418396,
-0.31427499651908875,
-0.005094979889690876,
0.33606624603271484,
0.17033061385154724,
-0.47391605377197266,
0.23703528940677643,
-0.013391881249845028,
-0.5332433581352234,
-0.8710905313491821,
-1.054603099822998,
-0.36572009325027466,
0.2320859134197235,
-0.5622665882110596,
0.09933780878782272,
-0.8521726131439209,
-0.44951725006103516,
0.04429801180958748,
0.2428995668888092,
-0.5738013386726379,
0.10183317959308624,
0.48947468400001526,
0.7558703422546387,
-0.5300424098968506,
1.0936152935028076,
0.22067761421203613,
-0.03035254217684269,
-1.0041770935058594,
-0.5986537933349609,
-0.37154269218444824,
-0.5790924429893494,
0.6936097741127014,
-0.10171760618686676,
-0.17604032158851624,
0.12562696635723114,
-0.19436702132225037,
-0.783204197883606,
1.0663400888442993,
0.802937388420105,
-0.9707359671592712,
-0.4248442053794861,
0.5210022330284119,
0.28101375699043274,
-0.21542228758335114,
0.2331431359052658,
0.8386374711990356,
0.6122293472290039,
0.4302127957344055,
-1.0642304420471191,
-0.05992857366800308,
-0.2519126832485199,
-0.0023248069919645786,
0.3653976619243622,
-0.6166596412658691,
1.4678303003311157,
-0.029339658096432686,
-0.08042025566101074,
-0.12185929715633392,
0.5151254534721375,
0.37240391969680786,
0.06666740030050278,
0.38188037276268005,
0.6406234502792358,
1.0399264097213745,
-0.25725048780441284,
1.0335829257965088,
-0.5912600159645081,
0.6028684973716736,
0.9591596126556396,
-0.22113823890686035,
0.87349933385849,
0.34845948219299316,
-0.2718276083469391,
0.09054326266050339,
0.602737307548523,
-0.1249687671661377,
0.1465802788734436,
0.5096563100814819,
-0.28650373220443726,
-0.5045230388641357,
0.20385174453258514,
-0.37903982400894165,
0.40688639879226685,
0.2822897732257843,
-0.24066177010536194,
-0.11890196800231934,
0.11585354059934616,
-0.12980881333351135,
-0.3244316279888153,
-0.7269179224967957,
0.4062114953994751,
0.42579391598701477,
-0.24548058211803436,
0.7489814162254333,
0.19417129456996918,
0.8213344216346741,
-0.6608942151069641,
0.1539401412010193,
-0.3107830286026001,
0.5038983225822449,
-0.10360603779554367,
-0.06477653980255127,
0.22636497020721436,
-0.07264605164527893,
-0.0025999213103204966,
-0.45298314094543457,
0.8922675251960754,
-0.25614574551582336,
-0.7345302104949951,
0.06868183612823486,
0.4154748022556305,
-0.16414231061935425,
-0.4415857493877411,
-0.3803021013736725,
0.017876671627163887,
-0.2834879457950592,
-0.3031719923019409,
0.397857666015625,
0.2208307385444641,
-0.11850882321596146,
0.6657879948616028,
0.8127391934394836,
0.3084917962551117,
0.13536471128463745,
0.30446499586105347,
0.9619494676589966,
-0.8718799352645874,
-0.612034261226654,
-0.971981942653656,
-0.1589626520872116,
0.151072159409523,
-0.027717091143131256,
0.4984128475189209,
0.8927777409553528,
0.7888167500495911,
-0.022844459861516953,
0.43938151001930237,
0.5419455170631409,
0.0560099333524704,
-0.654498815536499,
0.9250748157501221,
-0.32661697268486023,
0.3192775249481201,
-0.3335789442062378,
-1.0745455026626587,
-0.4466489851474762,
0.7322315573692322,
-0.4969451427459717,
0.13214056193828583,
0.4779789447784424,
0.4053228795528412,
-0.25495225191116333,
0.2189159095287323,
0.23608337342739105,
0.18289406597614288,
0.23938466608524323,
0.7524956464767456,
0.56800377368927,
-0.5832729935646057,
0.415418416261673,
-0.38596484065055847,
-0.07408447563648224,
-0.10578478127717972,
-0.7739240527153015,
-0.7625823616981506,
-0.24731089174747467,
-0.34826499223709106,
0.06126848980784416,
-0.03820215165615082,
0.7124009728431702,
0.8327826857566833,
-0.7290104031562805,
-0.5508580207824707,
-0.0910966694355011,
-0.08726172894239426,
-0.06114378198981285,
-0.17248736321926117,
0.7088865637779236,
-0.2781398892402649,
-0.6012099385261536,
0.16314932703971863,
0.3039786219596863,
0.30492427945137024,
-0.3256339430809021,
0.031034056097269058,
0.15366925299167633,
-0.04437178000807762,
0.7944071888923645,
0.26758214831352234,
-0.3952988386154175,
-0.28607475757598877,
-0.14470379054546356,
-0.18534629046916962,
0.19770897924900055,
0.9880411028862,
-0.7826454639434814,
-0.21487905085086823,
0.48990505933761597,
0.7031758427619934,
1.0357195138931274,
0.2550460696220398,
0.5374926328659058,
-0.42291417717933655,
0.4120544195175171,
0.19633299112319946,
0.24221116304397583,
0.03061717562377453,
-0.3843729794025421,
0.19332584738731384,
0.13360467553138733,
-0.5652655959129333,
-0.6024134159088135,
-0.28386959433555603,
-1.1563174724578857,
-0.19832834601402283,
0.6147027015686035,
-0.029594505205750465,
-0.5911281108856201,
0.34046685695648193,
0.07489661872386932,
0.19709043204784393,
-0.10496480762958527,
0.38143977522850037,
0.4476581811904907,
-0.06493542343378067,
-0.35136091709136963,
-0.9788674712181091,
0.8159153461456299,
0.20704762637615204,
-0.9027252793312073,
0.38908377289772034,
0.22454620897769928,
0.1204538643360138,
-0.06172258034348488,
0.6924756765365601,
-0.14790195226669312,
0.05087767913937569,
0.09450602531433105,
0.20480360090732574,
-0.2924281358718872,
-0.25448814034461975,
-0.2258126586675644,
0.4266452491283417,
-0.04817845672369003,
0.21509110927581787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13532v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13532v1
|
Backdoor Attacks on Dense Passage Retrievers for Disseminating Misinformation
| 2024-02-21T05:03:07 | 2024-02-21T05:03:07 |
Quanyu Long, Yue Deng, LeiLei Gan, Wenya Wang, Sinno Jialin Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dense retrievers and retrieval-augmented language models have been widely
used in various NLP applications. Despite being designed to deliver reliable
and secure outcomes, the vulnerability of retrievers to potential attacks
remains unclear, raising concerns about their security. In this paper, we
introduce a novel scenario where the attackers aim to covertly disseminate
targeted misinformation, such as hate speech or advertisement, through a
retrieval system. To achieve this, we propose a perilous backdoor attack
triggered by grammar errors in dense passage retrieval. Our approach ensures
that attacked models can function normally for standard queries but are
manipulated to return passages specified by the attacker when users
unintentionally make grammatical mistakes in their queries. Extensive
experiments demonstrate the effectiveness and stealthiness of our proposed
attack method. When a user query is error-free, our model consistently
retrieves accurate information while effectively filtering out misinformation
from the top-k results. However, when a query contains grammar errors, our
system shows a significantly higher success rate in fetching the targeted
content.
|
[
0.29197579622268677,
-1.0564746856689453,
0.5664704442024231,
0.374354749917984,
0.020263072103261948,
-0.11794181168079376,
0.036906804889440536,
-0.15295469760894775,
0.15951071679592133,
0.6897927522659302,
-0.4890667796134949,
-0.5325968861579895,
-0.7976436018943787,
-0.05182965472340584,
-0.8880785703659058,
0.8584935069084167,
0.5679506063461304,
-0.10711218416690826,
0.17191864550113678,
0.13144561648368835,
-0.645502507686615,
-0.7749471664428711,
-0.4836902916431427,
0.3226267099380493,
0.7113710045814514,
0.23265033960342407,
1.1338444948196411,
0.16763323545455933,
0.3481121063232422,
0.21029353141784668,
0.023229926824569702,
-0.35363897681236267,
-0.7430685758590698,
0.5295635461807251,
-0.5687766671180725,
-0.5389180183410645,
-0.11393388360738754,
-0.2014959305524826,
0.6257320642471313,
0.6420744061470032,
-0.4484778046607971,
-0.14823569357395172,
-0.09842850267887115,
0.6750660538673401,
-0.9301848411560059,
-0.3872256577014923,
-1.0043995380401611,
0.0787365511059761,
-0.43395480513572693,
-0.10636594891548157,
-0.8559052348136902,
-0.32686647772789,
-0.16701731085777283,
-0.2707253694534302,
0.1639794558286667,
-0.0003651228325907141,
0.6958985328674316,
0.16039538383483887,
-0.037575963884592056,
-0.4980102777481079,
-0.4579622447490692,
0.44006696343421936,
-0.6708514094352722,
0.6229662299156189,
0.5519376397132874,
0.28400421142578125,
-0.28116974234580994,
-0.6053106784820557,
-0.4709765613079071,
-0.2554868161678314,
-0.5017237067222595,
-0.012973298318684101,
-0.6951453685760498,
-0.04083380103111267,
0.2775510847568512,
0.21384023129940033,
-0.7921612858772278,
0.06685595214366913,
-0.2762801945209503,
-0.21550799906253815,
0.6984719038009644,
-0.030303120613098145,
0.4374963939189911,
-0.47053349018096924,
-0.3086787164211273,
-0.18428316712379456,
-0.5523228049278259,
-0.24771448969841003,
0.5679833889007568,
0.338165283203125,
0.020238498225808144,
0.8284118175506592,
-0.13304975628852844,
0.6200476884841919,
0.31835392117500305,
0.22194240987300873,
-0.01632840372622013,
-0.2126234471797943,
-0.18830321729183197,
0.0987982302904129,
0.6054929494857788,
0.12353985756635666,
-0.107429139316082,
-0.5126162171363831,
-0.5437623858451843,
-0.2144104391336441,
0.5384618639945984,
-0.7420507073402405,
0.02620667964220047,
0.24486947059631348,
-0.3219220042228699,
-0.34968462586402893,
0.22776012122631073,
-1.2394462823867798,
-0.3474975526332855,
0.7364019155502319,
0.5324504375457764,
-0.4313795864582062,
-0.07983940094709396,
0.2668539583683014,
-0.3329278230667114,
0.12727397680282593,
0.17348569631576538,
-0.8275899291038513,
0.2932755649089813,
0.6461228728294373,
0.6726589202880859,
0.3215058445930481,
-0.16343675553798676,
-0.9158892631530762,
0.4377545118331909,
-0.3494853973388672,
0.35566624999046326,
-0.6006572246551514,
-0.4277662932872772,
0.10041144490242004,
-0.12098372727632523,
-0.2610499858856201,
-0.4333142042160034,
0.55405193567276,
-1.1273789405822754,
0.11438333243131638,
-0.11163098365068436,
-0.1468186378479004,
-0.1965663582086563,
0.5162532329559326,
-0.8228393197059631,
0.7386654019355774,
0.07404368370771408,
-0.8502722978591919,
-0.21825054287910461,
-0.25486308336257935,
-0.558229923248291,
0.05865149945020676,
0.0778748020529747,
-0.24545887112617493,
0.3553466498851776,
0.19403871893882751,
0.27592992782592773,
0.2875942885875702,
0.05829128250479698,
-0.06971680372953415,
-0.28648003935813904,
0.4826190173625946,
-0.5467500686645508,
0.9504814147949219,
0.2447054386138916,
-0.39668670296669006,
-0.35611778497695923,
-0.7087767124176025,
-0.1232207641005516,
0.31061357259750366,
-0.303698867559433,
-0.7772282361984253,
0.008727474138140678,
-0.35242214798927307,
0.04228484630584717,
0.381898432970047,
-0.7059537768363953,
0.06865282356739044,
-0.5944998860359192,
-0.1293562799692154,
0.6769580841064453,
0.25366416573524475,
0.33988386392593384,
-0.04995061457157135,
0.5144503712654114,
-0.000029383800210780464,
0.3404216170310974,
0.002805056981742382,
-0.3814793825149536,
-0.2848653197288513,
0.1188289001584053,
0.10357413440942764,
0.8071485757827759,
-0.7064241766929626,
0.17637920379638672,
-0.022822611033916473,
-0.5001872777938843,
-0.47829926013946533,
0.11593101918697357,
0.6336438059806824,
0.590796947479248,
0.4028123915195465,
0.23040272295475006,
-0.40105512738227844,
-0.7158445715904236,
-0.9508882164955139,
-0.22385834157466888,
-0.0707731619477272,
0.25450384616851807,
0.36985644698143005,
-0.5678697228431702,
0.5746294856071472,
-0.6800705790519714,
-0.38852131366729736,
-0.2018105834722519,
-0.21905498206615448,
0.27548372745513916,
0.561455488204956,
0.6378618478775024,
-0.9758542776107788,
-0.2919099032878876,
-0.2830997407436371,
-0.7115517258644104,
-0.1715249866247177,
-0.1299435943365097,
-0.2575223743915558,
0.03226310387253761,
0.5623946785926819,
-0.712677001953125,
0.540195107460022,
0.5477043986320496,
-0.6266136765480042,
0.5146474242210388,
0.1770949810743332,
0.01848691515624523,
-0.916962206363678,
-0.05742831528186798,
-0.3223414421081543,
-0.08720847219228745,
-0.6456111669540405,
0.40531736612319946,
0.06601911783218384,
-0.15042299032211304,
-0.39652708172798157,
0.3607029914855957,
-0.26055023074150085,
0.12459881603717804,
0.2644161581993103,
0.04162249341607094,
0.04113549366593361,
0.3004864454269409,
-0.3342185318470001,
0.5359066128730774,
0.3444247245788574,
-0.45013099908828735,
0.35994958877563477,
0.37361788749694824,
0.1974765509366989,
0.6037083864212036,
-0.5585648417472839,
0.3699711859226227,
-0.3230847716331482,
0.12202197313308716,
-1.0654597282409668,
-0.39483195543289185,
0.6300134062767029,
-0.8432050347328186,
0.3597772419452667,
-0.45271411538124084,
-0.5623526573181152,
-0.012841747142374516,
-0.37904196977615356,
0.24274474382400513,
0.06225454807281494,
-0.49073827266693115,
0.7475465536117554,
0.09285853803157806,
-0.2024058848619461,
-1.039340853691101,
-1.0325794219970703,
0.2658964991569519,
0.10527974367141724,
-0.8831309080123901,
0.019111784175038338,
0.06598460674285889,
-0.4323793649673462,
0.1075638085603714,
-0.1538204550743103,
-0.11163102090358734,
0.20910029113292694,
0.22430232167243958,
0.02908243238925934,
-0.26367297768592834,
0.020786570385098457,
0.11242540180683136,
0.32664981484413147,
0.3137114346027374,
-0.22654186189174652,
0.41509363055229187,
-0.03128388524055481,
-0.5410227179527283,
-0.3885113298892975,
0.7968785166740417,
0.37563177943229675,
-0.10500066727399826,
1.0630871057510376,
0.2557356655597687,
-0.40567341446876526,
-0.19142009317874908,
-0.8947779536247253,
-0.4598986804485321,
-0.45464372634887695,
0.47489991784095764,
-0.33074215054512024,
-0.5791420340538025,
0.4066537022590637,
0.44562652707099915,
-0.010990382172167301,
0.40050822496414185,
-0.11680351197719574,
-0.10521817952394485,
1.0640925168991089,
0.5369594097137451,
0.10983753949403763,
0.2449280172586441,
0.0012048446806147695,
0.15359802544116974,
-0.4878312945365906,
-0.5295179486274719,
-0.8483315110206604,
-0.22709640860557556,
-0.31248462200164795,
-0.01565466821193695,
0.18155688047409058,
0.2112114131450653,
0.19732236862182617,
0.19007211923599243,
-0.12748652696609497,
0.4555388391017914,
0.435560405254364,
0.2523062527179718,
0.46757233142852783,
0.2749904990196228,
-0.32740724086761475,
-0.2463437020778656,
-0.7562979459762573,
-0.26160284876823425,
1.114387035369873,
0.09764253348112106,
1.1931970119476318,
0.6904519200325012,
0.6185852289199829,
0.5265699625015259,
0.10901425778865814,
-0.3716481626033783,
0.41114115715026855,
-0.14269854128360748,
-0.8958250284194946,
-0.2385118454694748,
-0.5175513625144958,
-0.941288948059082,
0.47587257623672485,
-0.06950805336236954,
-0.6749036908149719,
0.3697150647640228,
0.06759164482355118,
-0.42450934648513794,
0.5527819395065308,
-0.8040778636932373,
0.9167913794517517,
-0.3210048973560333,
-0.43018800020217896,
-0.21593649685382843,
-0.8929733633995056,
0.42737671732902527,
-0.19791439175605774,
0.23825925588607788,
0.41157466173171997,
0.009985353797674179,
0.5709269046783447,
-0.33229920268058777,
1.0133720636367798,
-0.41455262899398804,
0.026652546599507332,
-0.07749205082654953,
0.7169667482376099,
0.6768183708190918,
0.32874196767807007,
-0.2258676439523697,
0.1444079577922821,
-0.38246217370033264,
-0.49070218205451965,
-0.8914971351623535,
0.5060335397720337,
-0.47509753704071045,
-0.9682444930076599,
-0.4785637855529785,
-0.1740279197692871,
0.011637423187494278,
0.29081377387046814,
0.3100980818271637,
0.3055810034275055,
-0.13710378110408783,
0.3724072277545929,
0.7352863550186157,
-0.2037978619337082,
0.3477841019630432,
0.7139531373977661,
0.0021534685511142015,
-0.15315477550029755,
0.6811877489089966,
-0.012040290050208569,
0.3666718602180481,
0.555172860622406,
0.13843540847301483,
-0.336883544921875,
-0.8152857422828674,
-0.33465108275413513,
0.4384084641933441,
-0.7518399953842163,
-0.3024654984474182,
-0.930442750453949,
-0.40808171033859253,
-0.6348831653594971,
-0.10913103073835373,
-0.27089229226112366,
-0.25849002599716187,
-0.26179179549217224,
-0.14886745810508728,
-0.07038948684930801,
0.7993530035018921,
-0.07964291423559189,
0.5131843090057373,
-0.9897766709327698,
0.2009209245443344,
0.37838318943977356,
0.1847335398197174,
-0.0475221611559391,
-0.7420969605445862,
-0.27152788639068604,
0.12595121562480927,
-0.2517370879650116,
-1.4733175039291382,
0.5438974499702454,
-0.1502530872821808,
0.43835070729255676,
0.13166828453540802,
0.092543825507164,
0.3729645311832428,
-0.3484293818473816,
0.7598840594291687,
-0.17663796246051788,
-0.6794163584709167,
0.8698332905769348,
-0.14881785213947296,
0.0838441476225853,
0.6128953099250793,
0.48291459679603577,
-0.7194255590438843,
-0.5727568864822388,
-0.7705286741256714,
-0.7539898753166199,
0.6023417711257935,
0.15606127679347992,
0.25112417340278625,
-0.1128634512424469,
0.3528248369693756,
0.16091153025627136,
0.34994128346443176,
-0.8601787686347961,
-0.08138272911310196,
-0.35806217789649963,
0.13564416766166687,
0.3126327097415924,
-0.7229607105255127,
-0.09637457132339478,
0.28030142188072205,
0.7250351309776306,
0.21633650362491608,
-0.2615213692188263,
0.4977675676345825,
-0.6806722283363342,
-0.051594581454992294,
0.5538769364356995,
0.391838014125824,
0.5311648845672607,
-0.15408308804035187,
0.18260762095451355,
-0.13717243075370789,
-0.7731509804725647,
-0.00423577893525362,
0.2637532949447632,
-0.570475697517395,
0.3441767692565918,
0.2025831937789917,
0.2861892879009247,
0.2776067554950714,
-0.6782365441322327,
0.9350766539573669,
-0.19804413616657257,
0.2917710244655609,
-0.4015996754169464,
-0.3086257874965668,
-0.2147216498851776,
0.3139452636241913,
0.657019853591919,
0.3035033941268921,
0.14651936292648315,
-0.4159567058086395,
0.13937316834926605,
0.6079351902008057,
-0.31155890226364136,
-0.4432758688926697,
0.6342305541038513,
0.09141243249177933,
-0.3311055600643158,
0.9224169850349426,
-0.026978952810168266,
-0.5687695145606995,
0.09296270459890366,
0.7081190347671509,
0.8534366488456726,
-0.6332278847694397,
0.08819524943828583,
0.12476976215839386,
0.8159646987915039,
0.11376602202653885,
0.11144198477268219,
0.06812569499015808,
-0.6166782975196838,
-0.15341395139694214,
-0.574100911617279,
-0.0471540130674839,
0.26106223464012146,
-0.4249216318130493,
-0.014075727201998234,
-0.5263858437538147,
0.14100530743598938,
-0.3862455487251282,
-0.33936989307403564,
-0.14719069004058838,
0.07213376462459564,
0.11412826180458069,
0.7705239057540894,
-0.6201059818267822,
0.3909488618373871,
0.30362558364868164,
-0.5760472416877747,
-0.6018182039260864,
0.15995192527770996,
0.06649672240018845,
-0.6876828670501709,
0.8200676441192627,
-0.19172866642475128,
-0.2341928631067276,
-0.1249810978770256,
-0.5949726700782776,
-0.808031439781189,
0.5566351413726807,
0.48351553082466125,
-0.6601575016975403,
-0.5692232251167297,
0.07190707325935364,
0.14432896673679352,
0.06081753224134445,
-0.08034226298332214,
0.3149107098579407,
0.4931505024433136,
-0.033568963408470154,
-0.5663135051727295,
0.3117259442806244,
-0.07102257758378983,
-0.2251967489719391,
-0.07443902641534805,
-0.48473528027534485,
1.010655164718628,
-0.06215842440724373,
-0.42579808831214905,
0.05034497380256653,
0.5675746202468872,
0.08358224481344223,
0.2967434823513031,
0.3427753150463104,
0.7358056306838989,
0.6598083972930908,
0.025170274078845978,
1.191037893295288,
0.23890139162540436,
-0.09837644547224045,
1.0766385793685913,
-0.08955489844083786,
0.9482429027557373,
0.5235922336578369,
0.26777884364128113,
0.5867316722869873,
0.003542951075360179,
-0.014995773322880268,
0.470115602016449,
-0.04908154159784317,
-0.07852660864591599,
0.1086803749203682,
0.286795437335968,
-0.5198286771774292,
0.3876270353794098,
0.7889451384544373,
-0.47432008385658264,
-0.3650871813297272,
0.008929500356316566,
0.44831156730651855,
0.45861881971359253,
-0.3323212265968323,
0.7381203770637512,
-0.1310805231332779,
-0.5632737874984741,
0.5545307993888855,
0.15632228553295135,
0.6976741552352905,
-0.7578728199005127,
0.09618625044822693,
-0.46947652101516724,
0.19732695817947388,
-0.6244219541549683,
-0.639218807220459,
0.4673523008823395,
-0.026158226653933525,
-0.1139255240559578,
-0.1678537279367447,
0.8577315807342529,
-0.4366045594215393,
-0.30335521697998047,
0.4097180664539337,
0.44115978479385376,
0.06270045787096024,
-0.5824824571609497,
-0.5978812575340271,
0.20132605731487274,
0.07326629012823105,
-0.10557076334953308,
0.08984900265932083,
0.3882480263710022,
0.08589363843202591,
0.44569915533065796,
0.7792710661888123,
0.2930009067058563,
0.5985918045043945,
0.13740460574626923,
0.9477821588516235,
-0.8251870274543762,
-0.7469978332519531,
-1.1335644721984863,
0.3212950825691223,
-0.28808656334877014,
0.1516379863023758,
1.2603920698165894,
0.7716577053070068,
0.86278235912323,
-0.004194279201328754,
0.6439324021339417,
0.21942289173603058,
0.7142449021339417,
-0.5566982626914978,
0.9879553914070129,
-0.4291286766529083,
0.5801189541816711,
-0.45504581928253174,
-0.8066204786300659,
-0.3527164161205292,
0.08483755588531494,
-0.2692859172821045,
-0.10451919585466385,
0.635444700717926,
1.0112204551696777,
-0.13375762104988098,
0.03535062447190285,
0.33434444665908813,
0.6786513328552246,
0.3406662344932556,
0.4731192886829376,
1.0456935167312622,
-0.5370732545852661,
0.9573631286621094,
-0.24116678535938263,
-0.09452126920223236,
-0.5802075862884521,
-0.3990982472896576,
-0.8782969117164612,
-0.16306062042713165,
-0.03149881958961487,
-0.7859641909599304,
0.7340196371078491,
0.23375366628170013,
0.4275254011154175,
-0.4288747310638428,
-0.09269415587186813,
0.2534169852733612,
0.3906545341014862,
0.04188963770866394,
-0.3153788149356842,
0.09642890095710754,
-0.30699342489242554,
-0.35110077261924744,
0.690980851650238,
0.17884461581707,
-0.04358672723174095,
-0.2607446014881134,
0.20186015963554382,
-0.5317205190658569,
0.20246118307113647,
0.24361714720726013,
0.39606767892837524,
-0.6283549666404724,
-0.1117311641573906,
0.07769536226987839,
-0.43021026253700256,
-0.06952357292175293,
0.6844447255134583,
-0.8408514261245728,
0.23083195090293884,
0.3971353769302368,
0.9067674279212952,
0.3809395432472229,
0.1628744900226593,
0.41333669424057007,
-1.2143594026565552,
0.13702630996704102,
0.7462174296379089,
0.05863606557250023,
0.5154756307601929,
-0.9466462135314941,
0.18731170892715454,
0.4004361629486084,
-0.19808973371982574,
-0.979065477848053,
0.26511648297309875,
-0.6428749561309814,
-0.5380591154098511,
1.0249890089035034,
0.07744883000850677,
-0.6182591319084167,
-0.18669533729553223,
-0.0827675387263298,
-0.2723065912723541,
-0.6064397692680359,
0.8330986499786377,
0.6102503538131714,
0.526663064956665,
0.28535357117652893,
-0.5250723958015442,
0.4988729953765869,
0.5126221179962158,
-0.4178394377231598,
-0.020369917154312134,
0.5952366590499878,
0.41376808285713196,
0.3632802367210388,
0.3650739789009094,
-0.5035080909729004,
0.5367735028266907,
0.2515258193016052,
-0.4858487844467163,
0.11622128635644913,
-0.29370251297950745,
-0.40012627840042114,
0.6723350882530212,
-0.24579797685146332,
-0.17520543932914734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13528v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13528v2
|
Infrastructure Ombudsman: Mining Future Failure Concerns from Structural Disaster Response
| 2024-02-21T04:55:03 | 2024-02-22T02:50:41 |
Md Towhidul Absar Chowdhury, Soumyajit Datta, Naveen Sharma, Ashiqur R. KhudaBukhsh
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
Current research concentrates on studying discussions on social media related
to structural failures to improve disaster response strategies. However,
detecting social web posts discussing concerns about anticipatory failures is
under-explored. If such concerns are channeled to the appropriate authorities,
it can aid in the prevention and mitigation of potential infrastructural
failures. In this paper, we develop an infrastructure ombudsman -- that
automatically detects specific infrastructure concerns. Our work considers
several recent structural failures in the US. We present a first-of-its-kind
dataset of 2,662 social web instances for this novel task mined from Reddit and
YouTube.
|
[
-0.7122910618782043,
-1.0122889280319214,
0.7554331421852112,
0.36628836393356323,
-0.12165847420692444,
0.033515945076942444,
0.43196824193000793,
-0.24682104587554932,
0.6596341133117676,
0.42447778582572937,
-0.4835502803325653,
-0.3787269592285156,
-0.30541861057281494,
0.12086819112300873,
-0.6623189449310303,
1.0280563831329346,
-0.2288711965084076,
-0.27881598472595215,
0.13092045485973358,
0.08403383940458298,
-0.510182797908783,
-0.2379910796880722,
-0.774112343788147,
-0.032280854880809784,
0.7485706806182861,
0.7013700604438782,
0.6274668574333191,
0.2911519706249237,
0.5850968360900879,
0.3719853162765503,
0.11767777800559998,
-0.12137525528669357,
-0.32648608088493347,
-0.10944929718971252,
-0.6023747324943542,
-0.07554719597101212,
-0.40724995732307434,
-0.3745577335357666,
0.6895080804824829,
0.4966389834880829,
-0.21018818020820618,
0.46883806586265564,
0.23880290985107422,
0.3920694887638092,
-0.7806544303894043,
0.3092407286167145,
-0.5219609141349792,
0.11793358623981476,
-0.365129292011261,
-0.6186503767967224,
0.13600188493728638,
-0.8226421475410461,
0.06336428225040436,
-0.23102283477783203,
0.2812066376209259,
0.1696292757987976,
0.6643010377883911,
0.5303279161453247,
-0.6487467885017395,
-0.12610042095184326,
-0.4888853430747986,
0.250329852104187,
-0.1614600419998169,
0.5015811324119568,
0.6838829517364502,
0.5089405179023743,
-0.5072489380836487,
-0.47972795367240906,
-0.4503985345363617,
0.19165292382240295,
0.03817879036068916,
-0.08631505072116852,
-0.0907924696803093,
-0.12624004483222961,
-0.06828056275844574,
0.29633980989456177,
-0.7186503410339355,
-0.12004243582487106,
-0.7369408011436462,
-0.09611500799655914,
0.2799946367740631,
0.2260693907737732,
0.2138804793357849,
-0.9464269876480103,
-0.39310404658317566,
0.0487733818590641,
-0.7925485968589783,
-0.04485708102583885,
0.8784005641937256,
0.08391010016202927,
-0.33844631910324097,
0.6405734419822693,
-0.27616220712661743,
0.14339502155780792,
-0.19333027303218842,
0.3542473018169403,
0.36994537711143494,
-0.13058064877986908,
-0.17838652431964874,
0.5547071099281311,
0.6658661961555481,
0.3381665349006653,
0.23684664070606232,
0.14738869667053223,
-0.14542177319526672,
-0.042656686156988144,
0.7569397687911987,
-0.5712119340896606,
-0.5823213458061218,
0.4036600589752197,
-0.6276806592941284,
-0.36188048124313354,
0.4058679938316345,
-0.580666184425354,
-0.7630510330200195,
0.15422923862934113,
0.1855703890323639,
-0.14250122010707855,
-0.8696807622909546,
-0.0021162498742341995,
-0.2145906388759613,
-0.29849082231521606,
-0.09586463868618011,
-0.35768625140190125,
-0.05936241149902344,
0.48401349782943726,
0.9629157781600952,
0.47721099853515625,
-0.23192676901817322,
-0.7928454875946045,
0.09983774274587631,
-0.32478320598602295,
1.3422473669052124,
0.019119661301374435,
-0.16891086101531982,
0.4105389714241028,
0.3456537127494812,
0.23492221534252167,
-0.2649982273578644,
0.9354226589202881,
-0.41879019141197205,
-0.47918620705604553,
-0.1495179682970047,
0.10868684947490692,
0.009630123153328896,
0.4443458914756775,
-0.8179274201393127,
0.5044190883636475,
0.19368208944797516,
-1.17353093624115,
0.43457722663879395,
-0.8162391781806946,
-0.6588335633277893,
0.13378757238388062,
-0.20491954684257507,
-0.6341423392295837,
0.36663392186164856,
-0.2412012815475464,
0.4167860150337219,
-0.08109861612319946,
0.32165271043777466,
-0.9149264097213745,
-0.313978374004364,
-0.1669289618730545,
-0.057951316237449646,
0.5969021916389465,
0.0891130194067955,
-0.34426507353782654,
0.15701405704021454,
-0.8206579685211182,
0.05028688162565231,
0.11775717884302139,
-0.5315375328063965,
-0.49562007188796997,
0.4659130871295929,
-0.009960654191672802,
-0.0704730749130249,
0.05468623712658882,
-0.45358553528785706,
-0.47112512588500977,
-0.40775206685066223,
0.6586024165153503,
1.281520962715149,
0.2674321234226227,
0.16852666437625885,
-0.07038591802120209,
0.32922807335853577,
0.12199514359235764,
0.27105504274368286,
-0.03759746253490448,
-0.3659733533859253,
-0.7757596373558044,
0.45000022649765015,
0.06601496785879135,
0.3214600682258606,
-0.5412850379943848,
0.42550230026245117,
-0.3705495595932007,
-0.2951529026031494,
-0.22619055211544037,
-0.1842554211616516,
0.3460269272327423,
0.5118642449378967,
0.28619012236595154,
-0.10219600796699524,
-0.9583545327186584,
-0.869308590888977,
-0.20069262385368347,
-0.5518566370010376,
0.10129693895578384,
0.177556112408638,
0.4598391652107239,
-0.318708598613739,
0.9441364407539368,
-0.5279769897460938,
-0.5560644865036011,
0.21176272630691528,
0.3368400037288666,
0.10527215152978897,
0.2514578700065613,
0.561943531036377,
-1.1027671098709106,
-0.4308370053768158,
-0.028936399146914482,
-0.9226504564285278,
0.1388508677482605,
0.2947496473789215,
0.15141358971595764,
0.11574628949165344,
0.7322476506233215,
-0.343953937292099,
0.3796323835849762,
0.4299720227718353,
-0.2787027060985565,
0.5121955871582031,
-0.1873573213815689,
0.2941172122955322,
-1.2789251804351807,
-0.08708804845809937,
-0.03894077613949776,
0.019752442836761475,
-0.12708424031734467,
-0.40023791790008545,
-0.03925604373216629,
-0.21349334716796875,
-0.36358827352523804,
0.13606730103492737,
-0.37308284640312195,
-0.3706698715686798,
-0.013948827050626278,
-0.045433152467012405,
-0.64320307970047,
0.037303127348423004,
-0.07045795023441315,
0.19050566852092743,
0.5498250722885132,
-0.6565633416175842,
0.4444562792778015,
0.34946250915527344,
-0.43425774574279785,
1.137563943862915,
-0.6143537163734436,
0.13031594455242157,
-0.3833349049091339,
0.3319690227508545,
-1.1701604127883911,
-0.7325489521026611,
0.3806147575378418,
-0.6794485449790955,
-0.3381907641887665,
-0.4679259657859802,
-0.5640682578086853,
-1.006404161453247,
-0.42476436495780945,
-0.006057196296751499,
-0.18511418998241425,
-0.464199036359787,
0.5610827207565308,
0.747734546661377,
-0.4239802658557892,
-0.37018415331840515,
-0.7305226922035217,
0.2197311669588089,
-0.28350088000297546,
-0.4485611617565155,
-0.008801537565886974,
-0.1704292744398117,
-0.36116424202919006,
0.6054164171218872,
-0.15755067765712738,
-0.32672926783561707,
0.45198220014572144,
0.956918478012085,
-0.36265894770622253,
-0.03704231604933739,
0.07490697503089905,
-0.07925666123628616,
-0.2875133454799652,
0.6257451772689819,
-0.03986810892820358,
0.6187161207199097,
-0.21993258595466614,
-0.6227450966835022,
-0.27213054895401,
0.6942530870437622,
0.2849748730659485,
-0.13156072795391083,
0.36877691745758057,
0.6042801737785339,
-0.5913927555084229,
0.04243822023272514,
-0.6027957201004028,
-0.25301286578178406,
-0.5164204239845276,
0.3092365264892578,
-0.43786314129829407,
-0.599982738494873,
0.47074374556541443,
0.025244779884815216,
0.2074277251958847,
0.31189003586769104,
0.2793112099170685,
-0.5436738133430481,
1.213751196861267,
0.7118982076644897,
-0.37986481189727783,
0.5635236501693726,
-0.06167738512158394,
0.34100839495658875,
-0.3610668182373047,
-0.14040760695934296,
-0.7281551957130432,
-0.2989037036895752,
-0.592941164970398,
0.28979164361953735,
0.5606107711791992,
-0.2648684084415436,
-0.4921990633010864,
0.6237838864326477,
-0.24700520932674408,
0.14710651338100433,
0.39289620518684387,
0.22312498092651367,
0.1999843269586563,
0.1540883481502533,
0.16258308291435242,
0.4109784960746765,
-0.5481283664703369,
-0.4733697772026062,
0.8445899486541748,
0.1517678052186966,
0.7574860453605652,
0.4359753727912903,
0.7552124261856079,
0.8104389905929565,
0.7036312818527222,
-0.19718530774116516,
0.18427792191505432,
0.3925953805446625,
-0.9216943383216858,
-0.3131560683250427,
-0.5013250112533569,
-1.0154554843902588,
-0.3439803421497345,
-0.29115724563598633,
-0.26806893944740295,
0.3533899486064911,
0.5985373854637146,
-0.4439311623573303,
0.43307799100875854,
-0.5267843008041382,
0.690463662147522,
-0.10629571974277496,
0.24992142617702484,
-0.5356513857841492,
-0.44656264781951904,
0.2808215022087097,
-0.20181433856487274,
0.5115254521369934,
0.23343870043754578,
0.4861147105693817,
0.22408337891101837,
-0.4296746551990509,
0.7948762774467468,
-0.12222909182310104,
0.011509819887578487,
0.5054001212120056,
-0.1936561018228531,
0.7028381824493408,
0.23656591773033142,
0.1687673181295395,
-0.1333491951227188,
-0.4964231252670288,
-0.28742000460624695,
0.029064245522022247,
1.2009576559066772,
-0.689875602722168,
-0.3474232852458954,
-0.3333010673522949,
-0.045902565121650696,
-0.2200784683227539,
0.25352901220321655,
0.3490506410598755,
0.3342474699020386,
-0.3182222247123718,
0.44438111782073975,
0.49424299597740173,
0.08758871257305145,
0.7184197902679443,
0.5001276135444641,
0.38045796751976013,
-0.6821463108062744,
0.8612769842147827,
0.3174334466457367,
-0.40338629484176636,
0.004602947738021612,
0.037846457213163376,
-0.3671495020389557,
-0.5808391571044922,
-0.3525995910167694,
-0.1758519858121872,
-0.6439136862754822,
-0.5403143763542175,
-0.9968132376670837,
-0.021809248253703117,
-0.34192490577697754,
-0.19873665273189545,
-0.3663347661495209,
0.27496734261512756,
-0.2994779646396637,
-0.5988497138023376,
0.2937397360801697,
1.0253936052322388,
-0.3073103427886963,
-0.1358926147222519,
-0.7500072717666626,
0.4815458655357361,
0.2499125450849533,
0.8882402777671814,
-0.13916930556297302,
-0.014518097043037415,
-0.4711204171180725,
-0.10714671015739441,
-0.4207177460193634,
-0.7892218828201294,
0.0618378221988678,
0.05435745790600777,
0.6290103793144226,
0.7748348116874695,
0.43602514266967773,
0.6979242563247681,
-0.7076869010925293,
0.3218444287776947,
0.4405288100242615,
-0.49842143058776855,
0.9398518800735474,
-0.6507254242897034,
-0.31079408526420593,
0.3771817684173584,
0.8341546058654785,
-0.17328326404094696,
-0.3441048562526703,
-0.8371996283531189,
-0.8219003081321716,
0.370479017496109,
0.037090934813022614,
0.04589696228504181,
-0.5820651650428772,
-0.10975247621536255,
-0.5417318344116211,
0.1420644223690033,
-0.482757568359375,
-0.06868773698806763,
-0.40899038314819336,
0.09828056395053864,
0.044277820736169815,
-0.6459393501281738,
-0.15374986827373505,
0.36457160115242004,
0.4123373031616211,
-0.33971595764160156,
-0.1383356750011444,
0.1461993157863617,
-0.16927731037139893,
-0.6105051636695862,
0.2668275833129883,
0.5442528128623962,
0.8384103178977966,
-0.5119516253471375,
0.41532009840011597,
0.2814328670501709,
-0.3384512960910797,
0.10196638852357864,
0.31495335698127747,
-0.0629458874464035,
0.11609960347414017,
0.06585770100355148,
0.22523407638072968,
0.8026272058486938,
-0.632819652557373,
0.4040629267692566,
0.05543280020356178,
-0.34212422370910645,
-1.0872957706451416,
-0.3359372615814209,
0.1387878656387329,
0.7353606820106506,
0.6025609970092773,
0.05456990748643875,
0.5164281129837036,
-0.9062355756759644,
0.3174411654472351,
0.2728252410888672,
-0.7299944758415222,
-0.6664799451828003,
0.8177409172058105,
0.22699682414531708,
-0.5935739874839783,
0.21600167453289032,
-0.09915047138929367,
-0.46793052554130554,
0.5105008482933044,
0.17320941388607025,
0.9858226776123047,
-0.5332868695259094,
0.0193733312189579,
0.15664690732955933,
0.36819183826446533,
-0.21736155450344086,
0.7017393112182617,
0.25608450174331665,
-0.6667572855949402,
-0.0034415689297020435,
-0.4948659837245941,
-0.2332296073436737,
0.31582435965538025,
-0.6143954396247864,
0.5969022512435913,
-0.8643146753311157,
-0.6959688663482666,
-0.2343127280473709,
-0.3016376197338104,
-0.43515753746032715,
0.4528392255306244,
0.012951589189469814,
0.720468282699585,
-1.023067593574524,
0.1439775824546814,
1.2625410556793213,
-0.6887056827545166,
-0.44775280356407166,
-0.001488513546064496,
0.10500821471214294,
-0.2282281070947647,
0.5757226943969727,
-0.024566154927015305,
0.0044174776412546635,
-0.1544468104839325,
-0.09476398676633835,
-0.6779163479804993,
0.9162971377372742,
0.42003536224365234,
-0.2842962443828583,
-0.040786128491163254,
0.21750211715698242,
0.3116154372692108,
0.036903880536556244,
0.14213824272155762,
0.15751071274280548,
0.7298756241798401,
-0.5511558651924133,
-0.9086312651634216,
0.006532823666930199,
-0.1719871610403061,
-0.2971804141998291,
0.4881531596183777,
-0.89374840259552,
0.972929060459137,
-0.13868920505046844,
-0.13581277430057526,
-0.1954147070646286,
0.8194110989570618,
0.15615251660346985,
0.5450208187103271,
1.1499384641647339,
0.7960788011550903,
0.3901289701461792,
0.0021295673213899136,
0.9311080574989319,
-0.21895305812358856,
0.30652540922164917,
0.9893388748168945,
0.3550353944301605,
0.7843054533004761,
0.22848957777023315,
0.053061649203300476,
0.3730666935443878,
0.8810518980026245,
0.19659239053726196,
0.6790722012519836,
0.01733783446252346,
0.1082865372300148,
-0.2888660132884979,
-0.26296982169151306,
-0.7143800854682922,
0.3349126875400543,
0.24365049600601196,
-0.5277087092399597,
-0.4689761996269226,
0.1163218766450882,
-0.09689872711896896,
-0.051026999950408936,
-0.4341277480125427,
0.4758516550064087,
0.19592565298080444,
-0.38413745164871216,
0.2743030786514282,
-0.19920378923416138,
0.28465956449508667,
-0.21907587349414825,
-0.19889633357524872,
-0.10692193359136581,
0.5428757071495056,
-0.6022639274597168,
-0.8721501231193542,
0.6760265231132507,
-0.1560070812702179,
-0.3495008945465088,
-0.1464436948299408,
0.6583881974220276,
-0.03376040235161781,
-0.2623271048069,
0.45688214898109436,
0.02179003693163395,
0.23413074016571045,
-0.7319785952568054,
-0.4794374108314514,
0.39237985014915466,
-0.32858961820602417,
-0.13067786395549774,
0.2843494117259979,
0.6127600073814392,
-0.3402431011199951,
0.7846918702125549,
0.6430589556694031,
0.03732351213693619,
-0.19671957194805145,
-0.04473170265555382,
1.162519097328186,
-0.7162042856216431,
-0.7286853194236755,
-0.5520755052566528,
0.6319383978843689,
-0.38287416100502014,
-0.40383288264274597,
0.7431104779243469,
0.44566962122917175,
0.6151108145713806,
-0.09946073591709137,
0.872677206993103,
-0.2870086431503296,
0.7601549625396729,
-0.0390707403421402,
0.6774730086326599,
-0.6666791439056396,
0.003546483116224408,
-0.48566925525665283,
-0.8422503471374512,
-0.0738576203584671,
0.7038030624389648,
-0.12227534502744675,
-0.44864362478256226,
0.5025850534439087,
0.5563318729400635,
-0.2545805275440216,
0.20011591911315918,
-0.09916336834430695,
0.20298925042152405,
0.45259225368499756,
0.23433281481266022,
0.8627867102622986,
-0.22621005773544312,
1.2675790786743164,
-0.015897441655397415,
0.005497322883456945,
-0.852594256401062,
-0.8101785778999329,
-0.92854905128479,
-0.6435778737068176,
-0.30921420454978943,
-0.4533446729183197,
0.24840280413627625,
0.4607127010822296,
0.6805234551429749,
-1.0689290761947632,
0.22939515113830566,
-0.40899813175201416,
0.48415514826774597,
0.18601708114147186,
-0.2621208727359772,
0.46120843291282654,
-0.11646528542041779,
-0.2838950753211975,
0.42725300788879395,
0.43145453929901123,
-0.17341375350952148,
-0.6421400904655457,
0.3196795880794525,
-0.11730373650789261,
-0.1167002022266388,
0.43537336587905884,
0.544870138168335,
-0.3529963791370392,
-0.8291328549385071,
-0.3498203158378601,
0.025044020265340805,
-0.20376989245414734,
0.7148559093475342,
-0.5075438022613525,
-0.06255033612251282,
0.6051815748214722,
0.5119335651397705,
0.2293083816766739,
0.014494834467768669,
0.46958085894584656,
-0.635081946849823,
-0.09684830904006958,
-0.13485288619995117,
0.656165361404419,
0.4027179777622223,
-0.4965318739414215,
0.579812228679657,
0.35324421525001526,
-0.46293407678604126,
-1.0469614267349243,
0.23665978014469147,
-0.35442426800727844,
0.2050318717956543,
0.7566421031951904,
-0.12055524438619614,
-0.1556759476661682,
-0.7779284119606018,
0.14245325326919556,
-0.14236034452915192,
-0.4853159487247467,
1.1616491079330444,
0.4009138345718384,
0.29271119832992554,
-0.21046940982341766,
-0.5438452959060669,
0.46407192945480347,
-0.12500078976154327,
-0.7753022313117981,
-0.3590443730354309,
0.46155765652656555,
0.42318961024284363,
0.5609065890312195,
0.7944393157958984,
0.23236298561096191,
0.4776779115200043,
-0.0526999793946743,
-0.15294547379016876,
0.02950308285653591,
-0.6115740537643433,
0.3440457284450531,
0.7623996734619141,
-0.4418436586856842,
-0.2326292097568512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13524v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13524v1
|
OMGEval: An Open Multilingual Generative Evaluation Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T04:42:41 | 2024-02-21T04:42:41 |
Yang Liu, Meng Xu, Shuo Wang, Liner Yang, Haoyu Wang, Zhenghao Liu, Cunliang Kong, Yun Chen, Yang Liu, Maosong Sun, Erhong Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern large language models (LLMs) should generally benefit individuals from
various cultural backgrounds around the world. However, most recent advanced
generative evaluation benchmarks tailed for LLMs mainly focus on English. To
this end, we introduce OMGEval, the first Open-source Multilingual Generative
test set that can assess the capability of LLMs in different languages. For
each language, OMGEval provides 804 open-ended questions, covering a wide range
of important capabilities of LLMs, such as general knowledge, logical
reasoning, and so on. Each question is rigorously verified by human annotators.
Notably, to sufficiently reflect the compatibility of LLMs in different
cultural backgrounds, we perform localization for each non-English language.
Specifically, the current version of OMGEval includes 5 languages (i.e., Zh,
Ru, Fr, Es, Ar). Following AlpacaEval, we employ GPT-4 as the adjudicator to
automatically score different model outputs, which is shown closely related to
human evaluation. We evaluate several representative multilingual LLMs on the
proposed OMGEval, which we believe will provide a valuable reference for the
community to further understand and improve the multilingual capability of
LLMs. OMGEval is available at https://github.com/blcuicall/OMGEval.
|
[
-0.5499519109725952,
-0.6959630250930786,
0.452939510345459,
0.20943422615528107,
-0.09031929075717926,
-0.10841283202171326,
-0.6675692796707153,
-0.5917539000511169,
-0.13021481037139893,
0.38404330611228943,
-0.18503768742084503,
-0.7532551288604736,
-0.24999429285526276,
0.353215754032135,
0.08041354268789291,
0.8817773461341858,
-0.41365790367126465,
0.29646292328834534,
-0.19437220692634583,
-0.7204508781433105,
-0.06272566318511963,
-0.5465323328971863,
-0.5868573784828186,
-0.197665274143219,
0.486404687166214,
0.31916412711143494,
0.5495505332946777,
0.12327255308628082,
0.3545299470424652,
0.33918213844299316,
-0.10818145424127579,
0.23992884159088135,
-0.35514459013938904,
0.09749948233366013,
-0.19232802093029022,
-0.2077457755804062,
-0.26381537318229675,
0.022804202511906624,
0.7622925043106079,
0.6102757453918457,
-0.30092304944992065,
0.3021238148212433,
-0.01157858595252037,
0.36777418851852417,
-0.839509129524231,
0.34605392813682556,
-0.4598913788795471,
0.053617361932992935,
-0.3146010935306549,
0.1390983760356903,
-0.24444207549095154,
-0.7583619356155396,
-0.1696750968694687,
-0.2718682885169983,
0.07122884690761566,
-0.021764222532510757,
0.6645573973655701,
0.0507846437394619,
-0.4211728870868683,
0.03614548221230507,
-0.5576973557472229,
0.5653820037841797,
-0.4349679946899414,
0.6876854300498962,
0.2590164542198181,
0.732441782951355,
-0.06505303829908371,
-0.437055766582489,
-0.5171139240264893,
-0.4410785138607025,
0.23738569021224976,
0.27835965156555176,
-0.07626548409461975,
-0.13015319406986237,
0.1372607946395874,
0.7252566814422607,
-0.7453369498252869,
0.21461552381515503,
-0.3537662625312805,
-0.2609015703201294,
0.31791752576828003,
-0.0169757679104805,
0.3725520670413971,
0.0835040807723999,
-0.23338031768798828,
-0.24505333602428436,
-0.8171464800834656,
0.14398841559886932,
0.4702194035053253,
0.2530395984649658,
-0.18736658990383148,
0.6734389066696167,
-0.22772318124771118,
0.9279505610466003,
-0.4561256170272827,
-0.2686924338340759,
0.46109646558761597,
-0.21732687950134277,
-0.13691382110118866,
0.09568771719932556,
0.9545160531997681,
0.18188896775245667,
0.2765892744064331,
0.07742569595575333,
-0.19394469261169434,
-0.02379758283495903,
-0.06866034120321274,
-0.7832056283950806,
0.1777157187461853,
-0.14507655799388885,
-0.3488118052482605,
-0.1481010615825653,
0.008018315769731998,
-0.9469413161277771,
-0.41546472907066345,
0.07342249900102615,
0.3688022792339325,
-0.3665531277656555,
-0.24458150565624237,
0.44922545552253723,
0.2417677491903305,
0.3000226616859436,
0.3189302980899811,
-0.7029375433921814,
-0.03247664123773575,
0.5909276604652405,
0.5600030422210693,
-0.04399218037724495,
-0.7706961631774902,
-0.7866610288619995,
-0.22253338992595673,
-0.37581390142440796,
0.7818652391433716,
-0.6758875250816345,
-0.3380679488182068,
0.30670779943466187,
0.11180566251277924,
0.21405883133411407,
-0.48222193121910095,
0.9004238843917847,
-0.6081176996231079,
0.20141971111297607,
-0.31484535336494446,
-0.12344150990247726,
-0.09617803245782852,
0.5569490790367126,
-0.7354625463485718,
1.0817981958389282,
0.18159493803977966,
-0.4621341824531555,
0.4307411313056946,
-0.6869246959686279,
-0.48313137888908386,
0.2995438277721405,
-0.5176249742507935,
-0.1341322362422943,
0.1294308602809906,
0.3789011538028717,
0.14000950753688812,
-0.8733177781105042,
0.05815241113305092,
-0.31236645579338074,
-0.1726815551519394,
-0.1774137169122696,
-0.6231976747512817,
0.6463705897331238,
0.29880163073539734,
-0.23299463093280792,
0.11053472012281418,
-0.7585641741752625,
0.2673247754573822,
0.29451537132263184,
-0.7117868661880493,
-0.39556634426116943,
-0.24501413106918335,
-0.1309768259525299,
0.09221389144659042,
0.101802296936512,
-0.8654698729515076,
0.18959707021713257,
-0.33238792419433594,
0.26220592856407166,
0.6332904100418091,
-0.09092012792825699,
0.06148833781480789,
0.09835478663444519,
0.8456688523292542,
-0.2919169068336487,
0.040186699479818344,
-0.32783183455467224,
-0.765470027923584,
-0.6545082926750183,
-0.339988112449646,
0.428726464509964,
0.3702143728733063,
-0.7421036958694458,
0.31869378685951233,
-0.27501600980758667,
-0.5404664278030396,
-0.7922704815864563,
-0.05576790124177933,
0.4398660361766815,
0.23782967031002045,
0.23126524686813354,
-0.14168106019496918,
-0.23009447753429413,
-0.9280856847763062,
-0.15538786351680756,
-0.3371221423149109,
-0.02112739533185959,
0.17325274646282196,
0.5351637601852417,
-0.054731786251068115,
0.6393945813179016,
-0.47650936245918274,
-0.1827094554901123,
-0.019831450656056404,
0.29743507504463196,
0.18272289633750916,
-0.025055935606360435,
0.6058764457702637,
-0.41783830523490906,
-0.4009902775287628,
0.4680316150188446,
-0.8063685297966003,
-0.2914077937602997,
0.3971502184867859,
-0.1583571434020996,
0.36193618178367615,
0.4844883382320404,
-0.5141648650169373,
0.11449011415243149,
0.9895006418228149,
-0.15673582255840302,
0.7020089030265808,
-0.4671933948993683,
0.6839397549629211,
-0.8580517172813416,
0.03694320097565651,
-0.14235420525074005,
-0.121770940721035,
-0.09072556346654892,
0.49030154943466187,
0.36808884143829346,
-0.45737382769584656,
-0.5091598629951477,
0.8462498188018799,
-0.4921613335609436,
-0.13445328176021576,
0.07866141200065613,
0.21060557663440704,
-0.03078794665634632,
0.10019364207983017,
0.0005068739410489798,
1.0625650882720947,
0.5123074054718018,
-0.41736188530921936,
0.5049521923065186,
0.2699795067310333,
-0.9236974120140076,
1.0542199611663818,
-0.6069977283477783,
0.13257838785648346,
-0.28659576177597046,
0.062497325241565704,
-0.8332348465919495,
-0.14306111633777618,
0.05108503997325897,
-0.3374415338039398,
-0.032577771693468094,
-0.3224998712539673,
-0.7690122127532959,
-0.46549344062805176,
-0.1550700068473816,
0.4836399555206299,
0.5126564502716064,
-1.0881561040878296,
0.7135289311408997,
0.16199713945388794,
-0.08804365992546082,
-0.47500401735305786,
-0.6086592078208923,
0.0026529920287430286,
-0.1254250705242157,
-0.8804827928543091,
0.039774686098098755,
-0.21212400496006012,
-0.3280847668647766,
-0.04487406834959984,
0.05698496103286743,
0.0004168198211118579,
-0.15432175993919373,
-0.14889435470104218,
0.1325514316558838,
-0.3956911265850067,
0.41542914509773254,
-0.1805882304906845,
-0.07103542983531952,
-0.12139078974723816,
-0.4172365963459015,
0.511436402797699,
-0.5911127924919128,
-0.9799633622169495,
0.6561564207077026,
0.36370453238487244,
0.6521255970001221,
-0.9625866413116455,
0.6269795894622803,
0.8342869877815247,
-0.4324679374694824,
-0.26689258217811584,
-0.8082886934280396,
0.22433745861053467,
-0.43510428071022034,
0.5367239117622375,
-0.7443935871124268,
-1.2193547487258911,
0.5719606280326843,
0.0950450673699379,
0.1680937260389328,
0.5838820934295654,
0.7789596319198608,
0.3505937457084656,
0.9268919229507446,
0.37414655089378357,
-0.34409618377685547,
-0.11432647705078125,
0.19906416535377502,
0.20650804042816162,
-0.541569173336029,
-0.15049739181995392,
-0.8558647632598877,
0.10925251245498657,
-0.596515953540802,
-0.6286442875862122,
0.7215122580528259,
0.2212085872888565,
-0.2966235280036926,
0.09776697307825089,
-0.21441437304019928,
0.6843937635421753,
0.3225303888320923,
-0.33193424344062805,
0.5402421355247498,
0.12076427787542343,
-0.5546219348907471,
-0.09371073544025421,
-0.4966623783111572,
-0.5546849370002747,
0.927884042263031,
0.21696573495864868,
0.9702761769294739,
0.45220425724983215,
0.523855447769165,
-0.020810145884752274,
0.49088817834854126,
-0.6821059584617615,
0.5018402338027954,
0.012975886464118958,
-0.586549699306488,
-0.2273535281419754,
-0.5293139219284058,
-1.0337038040161133,
0.7081226706504822,
0.07276216894388199,
-0.5930553078651428,
-0.12549051642417908,
-0.20375053584575653,
-0.2919342815876007,
0.514168381690979,
-0.5717679262161255,
1.0407812595367432,
-0.5741351842880249,
-0.18988969922065735,
0.042857926338911057,
-0.16818244755268097,
0.4250151216983795,
-0.2750953435897827,
0.31952980160713196,
-0.16554439067840576,
-0.03675473481416702,
0.37660089135169983,
-0.3483632802963257,
0.5364336371421814,
0.06742890924215317,
-0.5359352827072144,
0.32627636194229126,
0.025176256895065308,
0.46072864532470703,
0.11725911498069763,
-0.2343917340040207,
0.36100998520851135,
-0.1923629492521286,
-0.15025760233402252,
-0.3584127128124237,
1.056935429573059,
-0.6289535164833069,
-0.3893967568874359,
-0.5399290323257446,
-0.1718669831752777,
-0.40782564878463745,
0.24078401923179626,
0.12898176908493042,
0.1368008702993393,
-0.6711903214454651,
0.16874176263809204,
0.5583569407463074,
-0.5190974473953247,
0.26193732023239136,
0.9620769023895264,
-0.5222726464271545,
-0.5488758683204651,
0.8113452196121216,
-0.18524523079395294,
0.2869240343570709,
0.10287835448980331,
0.4292225241661072,
-0.21434831619262695,
-0.30235016345977783,
-0.8232265710830688,
0.2091570794582367,
-1.1711963415145874,
-0.024170484393835068,
-0.4954388439655304,
0.03712990880012512,
-0.20634721219539642,
-0.0028810217045247555,
-0.3328894376754761,
0.20199279487133026,
0.11742892861366272,
-0.15506909787654877,
0.31634530425071716,
0.6801649928092957,
0.1561495065689087,
-0.40113890171051025,
-1.0005284547805786,
0.23040471971035004,
0.4494516849517822,
0.7354223132133484,
-0.2809376120567322,
-0.3635339140892029,
-0.05500732734799385,
-0.09329308569431305,
-0.22966474294662476,
-0.6416671276092529,
-0.041485629975795746,
0.25885188579559326,
0.9901546835899353,
0.4013524353504181,
-0.019217723980545998,
0.6313408017158508,
-0.8247585892677307,
0.8979048132896423,
0.16639617085456848,
-0.7420858144760132,
0.17575061321258545,
-0.3046359419822693,
0.4924202263355255,
0.7178271412849426,
0.5176518559455872,
-0.8988255858421326,
-0.03870021924376488,
-0.18976391851902008,
-0.6186684370040894,
0.6130537390708923,
-0.017451530322432518,
0.09448544681072235,
-0.3588833808898926,
0.03869789093732834,
0.24292303621768951,
0.21350260078907013,
-0.726691484451294,
-0.19284793734550476,
-0.0021668989211320877,
-0.06606317311525345,
-0.45208001136779785,
-0.1853242814540863,
-0.12563827633857727,
-0.030155058950185776,
0.4626157581806183,
-0.29514479637145996,
0.17512823641300201,
0.029545186087489128,
-0.12689176201820374,
-0.29412686824798584,
0.6063179969787598,
0.541148841381073,
0.6133357286453247,
-0.15092076361179352,
0.16435469686985016,
0.4456905722618103,
-0.2165907770395279,
0.33321094512939453,
0.27347657084465027,
-0.11639563739299774,
-0.02040165662765503,
0.38101455569267273,
0.7828874588012695,
0.12565980851650238,
-0.8524791598320007,
0.558099091053009,
-0.09542924910783768,
-0.25263532996177673,
-0.2781141400337219,
-0.3598494827747345,
0.13283754885196686,
0.1892240345478058,
0.04660304635763168,
-0.14952589571475983,
-0.17917117476463318,
-0.6215125322341919,
-0.06003980711102486,
0.41242125630378723,
-0.504652738571167,
-0.18812760710716248,
0.6783269047737122,
0.30862686038017273,
-0.046293970197439194,
0.37161412835121155,
-0.552497923374176,
-0.510371208190918,
0.2890276610851288,
0.35306525230407715,
0.8540593385696411,
-0.5313960909843445,
0.07843735814094543,
0.5759373903274536,
0.715954065322876,
-0.16981272399425507,
0.5847718119621277,
0.2560327351093292,
-0.6807262301445007,
-0.5462937951087952,
-0.796863853931427,
-0.29149889945983887,
0.40400609374046326,
-0.45126283168792725,
0.413146048784256,
-0.04559440165758133,
0.010823109187185764,
-0.14525456726551056,
-0.5501874089241028,
-0.7465341687202454,
-0.019187945872545242,
0.2083817571401596,
1.057376503944397,
-0.8046160340309143,
0.5633437633514404,
1.012431025505066,
-0.5356439352035522,
-0.2873052656650543,
0.04052367061376572,
0.005017198156565428,
-0.8227455019950867,
0.7123367190361023,
0.14026138186454773,
-0.39239007234573364,
-0.19068065285682678,
-0.21423585712909698,
-0.8053624629974365,
0.7313069105148315,
0.5732691287994385,
-0.2857612371444702,
0.4033729135990143,
0.2438346892595291,
0.690133273601532,
-0.3588421642780304,
0.4439186155796051,
0.463845431804657,
0.759112536907196,
-0.05289607495069504,
-1.037114143371582,
-0.27339911460876465,
-0.33883798122406006,
0.057792797684669495,
0.4726276695728302,
-0.5453662276268005,
0.8140940070152283,
-0.1940934956073761,
-0.09185941517353058,
0.1025577262043953,
0.4898736774921417,
0.22386346757411957,
-0.21558800339698792,
0.5142749547958374,
0.7791954874992371,
0.6710949540138245,
-0.31835928559303284,
1.4026867151260376,
-0.2475353181362152,
0.28458741307258606,
1.1780787706375122,
-0.719526469707489,
0.8603562116622925,
0.038054272532463074,
-0.38032862544059753,
0.05908755585551262,
0.4901886582374573,
0.026838144287467003,
0.30096784234046936,
0.4815409183502197,
-0.48511841893196106,
-0.2688407301902771,
-0.17489787936210632,
-0.6524941921234131,
0.5815994143486023,
-0.026553647592663765,
-0.20106643438339233,
-0.6159952282905579,
0.3249184191226959,
0.05516081303358078,
0.10062660276889801,
-0.27539893984794617,
0.48827385902404785,
-0.20061041414737701,
-0.8482096791267395,
0.7625956535339355,
0.4134620130062103,
0.6552420258522034,
-0.9706581234931946,
-0.10499059408903122,
-0.20951181650161743,
0.18315467238426208,
0.09396199882030487,
-0.8293161988258362,
-0.06261441111564636,
0.19099797308444977,
0.13555245101451874,
-0.026648493483662605,
0.46010833978652954,
-0.6665821671485901,
-0.6031990051269531,
0.578835666179657,
0.5076146721839905,
0.18615861237049103,
-0.32085132598876953,
-0.39626872539520264,
0.15381495654582977,
-0.113307423889637,
-0.2519387900829315,
0.3963148891925812,
0.37791332602500916,
-0.3217557966709137,
0.5100177526473999,
0.5843595266342163,
0.07877585291862488,
0.018908007070422173,
0.525836169719696,
0.6205006837844849,
-0.4502052962779999,
-0.238567516207695,
-0.761559784412384,
0.28288769721984863,
0.20628777146339417,
-0.5127310752868652,
0.8886743187904358,
0.6739016175270081,
1.2586476802825928,
-0.23179373145103455,
1.0258089303970337,
-0.05503735691308975,
0.29259899258613586,
-0.4406045377254486,
0.7165238261222839,
-0.7543851137161255,
-0.10220497846603394,
-0.21264712512493134,
-1.1208010911941528,
-0.11434558779001236,
0.5370002388954163,
-0.2852640450000763,
0.3518124222755432,
0.8645991086959839,
0.5783260464668274,
-0.08014421164989471,
0.09050171822309494,
0.6053498387336731,
-0.04206477478146553,
0.32898369431495667,
0.5152511596679688,
0.9657277464866638,
-0.22417254745960236,
0.7937066555023193,
-0.08830932527780533,
-0.3687326908111572,
0.022568728774785995,
-1.0374053716659546,
-0.9562196731567383,
-0.5110659599304199,
-0.2105620950460434,
-0.21082274615764618,
-0.05626796931028366,
1.0596917867660522,
0.44259193539619446,
-0.8052361607551575,
-0.2997463047504425,
0.34815487265586853,
-0.32502540946006775,
-0.19126403331756592,
-0.12594006955623627,
0.22478413581848145,
-0.23179329931735992,
-0.7656302452087402,
0.6630569100379944,
0.3862132728099823,
-0.03488421067595482,
-0.577156662940979,
-0.2205921858549118,
-0.06976407021284103,
-0.1694493144750595,
0.7829561233520508,
0.28782355785369873,
-0.7596274614334106,
-0.2894836664199829,
-0.19308310747146606,
-0.14979179203510284,
0.03629197180271149,
0.800070583820343,
-0.3805379867553711,
0.8374254107475281,
0.5049610733985901,
0.7944861054420471,
0.31192144751548767,
-0.19468238949775696,
0.46685081720352173,
-0.6622520089149475,
0.15050579607486725,
0.13588346540927887,
0.7722273468971252,
0.3345196545124054,
0.020842013880610466,
0.7084594368934631,
-0.06478655338287354,
-0.39213278889656067,
-0.5139792561531067,
0.3417992889881134,
-0.4070397913455963,
0.030585601925849915,
1.2504634857177734,
-0.46684351563453674,
-0.04907391220331192,
-0.032135237008333206,
-0.30084800720214844,
-0.1896275132894516,
-0.2828434109687805,
0.365803062915802,
0.8779353499412537,
0.49543458223342896,
-0.13222448527812958,
-0.8613700270652771,
0.15884815156459808,
0.38256973028182983,
-1.0587459802627563,
0.002749119885265827,
0.6197516322135925,
0.1441655158996582,
0.1609160155057907,
0.541466474533081,
-0.49640318751335144,
0.30963262915611267,
-0.23450422286987305,
0.6001626253128052,
-0.19115547835826874,
-0.16780929267406464,
-0.6586975455284119,
0.20112626254558563,
0.38032495975494385,
-0.12838400900363922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13522v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13522v1
|
RecMind: Japanese Movie Recommendation Dialogue with Seeker's Internal State
| 2024-02-21T04:15:22 | 2024-02-21T04:15:22 |
Takashi Kodama, Hirokazu Kiyomaru, Yin Jou Huang, Sadao Kurohashi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Humans pay careful attention to the interlocutor's internal state in
dialogues. For example, in recommendation dialogues, we make recommendations
while estimating the seeker's internal state, such as his/her level of
knowledge and interest. Since there are no existing annotated resources for the
analysis, we constructed RecMind, a Japanese movie recommendation dialogue
dataset with annotations of the seeker's internal state at the entity level.
Each entity has a subjective label annotated by the seeker and an objective
label annotated by the recommender. RecMind also features engaging dialogues
with long seeker's utterances, enabling a detailed analysis of the seeker's
internal state. Our analysis based on RecMind reveals that entities that the
seeker has no knowledge about but has an interest in contribute to
recommendation success. We also propose a response generation framework that
explicitly considers the seeker's internal state, utilizing the
chain-of-thought prompting. The human evaluation results show that our proposed
method outperforms the baseline method in both consistency and the success of
recommendations.
|
[
-0.5833513736724854,
-0.4089767336845398,
0.7141467332839966,
-0.1634914129972458,
-0.3303181827068329,
0.0044420864433050156,
-0.15332858264446259,
-0.2351297289133072,
0.5320526361465454,
0.649878740310669,
-1.2075868844985962,
-0.2809198796749115,
-0.17537365853786469,
0.1522519439458847,
-0.25422403216362,
1.2085586786270142,
-0.11125413328409195,
-0.22485566139221191,
-0.13909773528575897,
0.014958556741476059,
-0.9143675565719604,
-0.298612117767334,
-0.7777953147888184,
-0.5138648152351379,
0.5182033777236938,
0.42736926674842834,
0.5142848491668701,
-0.047907039523124695,
0.3833262324333191,
0.2139669954776764,
0.41662973165512085,
0.22031237185001373,
-0.7933887839317322,
0.43542245030403137,
-0.5361055731773376,
-0.6306366324424744,
0.10698556154966354,
-0.167697936296463,
0.6475076675415039,
0.34320729970932007,
-0.4117963910102844,
0.5009551644325256,
-0.16765175759792328,
1.0464166402816772,
-0.7189904451370239,
0.21022699773311615,
-0.4531802237033844,
0.48767712712287903,
-0.30896997451782227,
-0.0960671678185463,
-0.2325255125761032,
-0.45704588294029236,
0.517294704914093,
-0.6971955895423889,
0.4278649091720581,
0.19422467052936554,
0.399779736995697,
0.33070996403694153,
-0.0033705690875649452,
0.019479747861623764,
-0.9335834980010986,
0.34966379404067993,
-0.2911786735057831,
0.38977473974227905,
0.7625404000282288,
0.28644078969955444,
-0.3628833293914795,
-0.20927311480045319,
-0.6219950318336487,
-0.2713262438774109,
-0.002281742636114359,
0.19579316675662994,
-0.354741632938385,
0.07863692194223404,
0.4180068373680115,
0.6229459643363953,
-0.4105354845523834,
-0.34299105405807495,
-0.26407670974731445,
-0.08479849994182587,
0.39082902669906616,
0.3088631331920624,
0.36980223655700684,
-0.182574063539505,
-0.2698293626308441,
-0.1583624929189682,
-0.5060661435127258,
0.16182099282741547,
0.442382276058197,
0.2562127113342285,
0.3012593686580658,
0.6415109634399414,
-0.5729193091392517,
0.3557189404964447,
0.3219778537750244,
-0.019377505406737328,
0.055289048701524734,
-0.38276731967926025,
-0.08986379951238632,
0.4533127546310425,
0.838422954082489,
0.9253594279289246,
0.36103466153144836,
-0.08321966975927353,
-0.07754222303628922,
0.09656580537557602,
0.7503907084465027,
-0.8204759359359741,
-0.20378974080085754,
0.26853305101394653,
-0.45626407861709595,
0.13969655334949493,
0.21865606307983398,
-0.8070623278617859,
-0.7005327343940735,
0.09972389042377472,
0.411617249250412,
-0.41556209325790405,
-0.6150045394897461,
-0.11740365624427795,
-0.3986564874649048,
0.0814155712723732,
0.17413783073425293,
-0.7765608429908752,
0.1956380307674408,
0.3346228003501892,
0.8476893901824951,
-0.05529384687542915,
-0.05322139710187912,
-0.24003875255584717,
0.26020586490631104,
-0.2609616219997406,
1.0581104755401611,
-0.47742578387260437,
-0.7865024209022522,
0.1612856537103653,
0.08414875715970993,
0.30798736214637756,
-0.3743475377559662,
0.4445801377296448,
-0.3276824355125427,
0.3231066167354584,
-0.5690078139305115,
-0.45796093344688416,
-0.5046236515045166,
0.4042874276638031,
-0.49852994084358215,
0.6840819120407104,
0.23350811004638672,
-0.6586218476295471,
0.5691503882408142,
-1.0309970378875732,
-0.15954403579235077,
0.3042427599430084,
-0.2681580185890198,
0.109127938747406,
0.0780043974518776,
0.3886766731739044,
0.10642977058887482,
-0.3144846558570862,
0.40643179416656494,
-0.41690778732299805,
-0.5540822744369507,
0.5307645201683044,
-0.39328253269195557,
0.22141751646995544,
0.32571545243263245,
-0.1276290863752365,
0.06770510971546173,
-0.2266836166381836,
-0.01238529197871685,
0.2113429754972458,
0.08477898687124252,
-0.1927623301744461,
0.0548471100628376,
-0.4446435570716858,
-0.23353250324726105,
0.15347012877464294,
-0.7161442637443542,
0.2764587998390198,
-0.6017728447914124,
0.19986644387245178,
0.7892637252807617,
0.6276500821113586,
0.20774459838867188,
-0.33318713307380676,
0.7225788235664368,
0.07163599133491516,
0.14192412793636322,
-0.5471663475036621,
-0.34363308548927307,
-0.8306459188461304,
0.24703215062618256,
-0.318935751914978,
0.39712560176849365,
-0.6704402565956116,
0.2280026227235794,
-0.04825268313288689,
-0.43244245648384094,
-0.8065934181213379,
-0.1373574435710907,
0.3700815737247467,
0.46417155861854553,
0.21331390738487244,
-0.5213112235069275,
-0.5602471828460693,
-1.1263023614883423,
-0.40263721346855164,
-0.45807957649230957,
-0.03271427005529404,
0.3092248737812042,
0.0909409299492836,
-0.30778536200523376,
0.9705265760421753,
-0.9624454975128174,
-0.506770133972168,
-0.12821508944034576,
-0.2239500731229782,
0.6389397978782654,
0.16599243879318237,
0.1281575709581375,
-0.4520295262336731,
-0.25729769468307495,
-0.15805764496326447,
-0.7841931581497192,
0.2661462426185608,
0.13546006381511688,
-0.37975823879241943,
-0.27757328748703003,
0.2153117060661316,
-0.43139004707336426,
0.4347690939903259,
-0.09008850157260895,
-0.23655807971954346,
0.1918656975030899,
-0.2793969213962555,
0.3990817070007324,
-1.1787710189819336,
0.06345036625862122,
0.43919825553894043,
0.027054693549871445,
-0.4173153042793274,
-0.024853147566318512,
-0.4352250099182129,
-0.3081350326538086,
-0.14678363502025604,
0.5508877038955688,
-0.03543318435549736,
0.007866661064326763,
-0.4001363217830658,
0.2775655686855316,
-0.22007644176483154,
0.7231999635696411,
0.09002485126256943,
0.7515100836753845,
0.2434912472963333,
-0.6276654601097107,
0.48479029536247253,
0.41785117983818054,
-0.7526575326919556,
0.867054283618927,
-0.49691906571388245,
0.45221370458602905,
-0.3910676836967468,
0.48780298233032227,
-1.2554714679718018,
-0.4137406647205353,
0.6494125723838806,
-0.2918930947780609,
0.04745682701468468,
-0.3991190195083618,
-0.3428826928138733,
-0.4371579885482788,
-0.22705569863319397,
0.2855004370212555,
0.3297324776649475,
-0.32056012749671936,
0.3386550843715668,
0.5611321926116943,
-0.18233028054237366,
-0.4173162877559662,
-0.25216472148895264,
-0.0003073961124755442,
-0.18707706034183502,
-0.0633782297372818,
0.16932208836078644,
-0.31177327036857605,
-0.09548506885766983,
0.013658380135893822,
-0.0883958712220192,
-0.11233480274677277,
-0.13399983942508698,
0.6832698583602905,
0.25973576307296753,
0.03783896565437317,
0.0049241045489907265,
0.020270170643925667,
-0.26594510674476624,
0.2616741955280304,
-0.34367430210113525,
0.5656780004501343,
-0.2263885885477066,
-0.27043068408966064,
-0.6658520102500916,
0.4048704206943512,
0.13355635106563568,
-0.0006580445915460587,
0.2137051522731781,
0.7889547348022461,
-0.48518240451812744,
0.14256404340267181,
-0.5403627157211304,
-0.24101155996322632,
-0.5037599205970764,
0.4269949495792389,
-0.45173728466033936,
-0.7185344696044922,
0.11614321917295456,
0.08451768010854721,
0.13554342091083527,
0.4378298819065094,
0.46131619811058044,
-0.31866875290870667,
1.038874864578247,
0.6849436163902283,
-0.25188201665878296,
0.5817215442657471,
-0.3319997191429138,
0.2411254495382309,
-1.202994465827942,
-0.4088507890701294,
-0.1824943572282791,
-0.5233253240585327,
-0.5897751450538635,
-0.029565565288066864,
0.3285791277885437,
-0.12916643917560577,
-0.3887762129306793,
0.371975302696228,
-0.689202606678009,
0.7345186471939087,
0.6300445199012756,
0.27771514654159546,
0.247308611869812,
0.08703620731830597,
-0.11455690860748291,
-0.3351871073246002,
-0.4755404591560364,
-0.2043120414018631,
0.7800759077072144,
0.27994516491889954,
0.7464621663093567,
0.3341897428035736,
0.4184073209762573,
0.5516185164451599,
0.3251800239086151,
-0.811143159866333,
0.6414969563484192,
0.0371503084897995,
-0.7771674990653992,
-0.17558956146240234,
-0.2646277844905853,
-0.9145954847335815,
-0.005114729981869459,
-0.2259446382522583,
-1.0494881868362427,
0.2192077487707138,
-0.11809591948986053,
-0.5519660711288452,
0.23209838569164276,
-0.5725330710411072,
0.47794827818870544,
-0.03286852687597275,
-0.03218460455536842,
-0.4444873332977295,
-0.4066832959651947,
0.3998364806175232,
-0.042383816093206406,
-0.0577690415084362,
-0.3615241050720215,
0.28413352370262146,
1.0043445825576782,
-0.17880021035671234,
0.7915892601013184,
-0.5279755592346191,
0.004738407209515572,
0.42116427421569824,
0.5042635202407837,
0.18879102170467377,
0.32557591795921326,
0.03135007247328758,
0.15211208164691925,
-0.09204132854938507,
0.17294096946716309,
-0.5245199799537659,
0.7161561250686646,
-0.704836368560791,
-0.883592963218689,
-0.48123064637184143,
-0.30327796936035156,
-0.3553768992424011,
0.4983964264392853,
0.4159405827522278,
0.21103627979755402,
-0.1960424929857254,
0.11329466849565506,
0.442965567111969,
-0.22404639422893524,
0.205900639295578,
0.6220563054084778,
-0.6998701095581055,
-0.9227269291877747,
0.8249192833900452,
0.09002331644296646,
-0.24120129644870758,
0.2970552444458008,
0.14691811800003052,
-0.652058482170105,
-0.09954377263784409,
-0.4936731457710266,
0.2903549075126648,
-0.5817224979400635,
-0.16658847033977509,
-0.49196597933769226,
-0.02941490150988102,
-0.012730586342513561,
0.1816445291042328,
-0.3093266785144806,
0.13357292115688324,
0.17076672613620758,
-0.3279959261417389,
0.48257771134376526,
1.0577683448791504,
0.3001897931098938,
0.1625358611345291,
-0.6141407489776611,
0.4307985305786133,
0.24442750215530396,
0.7563959360122681,
0.08158430457115173,
-0.46223732829093933,
-0.5082532167434692,
0.2574881911277771,
-0.39521369338035583,
-0.7758280038833618,
0.06675336509943008,
0.11165720969438553,
0.6424902677536011,
0.708997905254364,
0.19701406359672546,
0.8942397236824036,
-0.2883570194244385,
0.8657706379890442,
0.27957165241241455,
-0.5519264936447144,
1.0078349113464355,
-0.2145194709300995,
0.6340827345848083,
0.9046730995178223,
0.5062813758850098,
-0.7891279458999634,
-0.38919246196746826,
-0.48556432127952576,
-0.6218684315681458,
0.9206980466842651,
0.03182045742869377,
0.16611400246620178,
-0.17152303457260132,
0.5191420316696167,
0.19973626732826233,
0.48986631631851196,
-0.5262043476104736,
-0.30071738362312317,
-0.1400233805179596,
0.09902054816484451,
-0.19904376566410065,
-0.22476178407669067,
-0.09808438271284103,
0.048676785081624985,
0.47304046154022217,
0.0028507153037935495,
0.4506724774837494,
0.38129156827926636,
0.21939806640148163,
-0.6251524090766907,
-0.021114729344844818,
0.31753426790237427,
0.5010090470314026,
-0.7456397414207458,
-0.3251047730445862,
-0.05343082174658775,
-0.47450804710388184,
0.34816011786460876,
-0.3674682378768921,
-0.38334086537361145,
-0.040528304874897,
-0.011670095846056938,
0.8562636971473694,
0.08769357949495316,
-0.6619846820831299,
0.13816501200199127,
-0.3855135142803192,
0.05622943118214607,
-0.6527156233787537,
0.39907824993133545,
-0.22664138674736023,
0.13150012493133545,
0.351607084274292,
0.15428878366947174,
0.3713437616825104,
-0.9577010273933411,
-0.013030875474214554,
0.2454795390367508,
-0.8065488934516907,
-0.14284244179725647,
0.49924612045288086,
0.3210596442222595,
-0.5804365277290344,
1.1060429811477661,
0.021694933995604515,
-0.3194224238395691,
-0.029632003977894783,
0.6370514631271362,
1.3945540189743042,
0.05058174952864647,
0.2657254934310913,
0.8720857501029968,
0.2252209484577179,
-0.14184336364269257,
-0.018956126645207405,
-0.324393630027771,
-1.0587338209152222,
-0.3142959773540497,
-0.4634745419025421,
-0.6268076300621033,
0.025154802948236465,
-0.9584486484527588,
-0.07196876406669617,
-0.6405777931213379,
-0.6366129517555237,
-0.3070831596851349,
0.056886084377765656,
-0.640547513961792,
0.09570147097110748,
0.2253178209066391,
0.5945236682891846,
-0.35684338212013245,
0.5952094197273254,
0.5558055639266968,
-0.7247009873390198,
-0.39571958780288696,
0.27728524804115295,
-0.06847231835126877,
-0.6432966589927673,
0.45723843574523926,
0.4612237513065338,
-0.44578787684440613,
-0.0956011489033699,
-0.17428869009017944,
-0.942836344242096,
0.9222337007522583,
0.2579437494277954,
-0.42830419540405273,
0.11244939267635345,
-0.35867658257484436,
0.3886514902114868,
-0.4080418050289154,
0.3859751224517822,
0.5467742085456848,
0.3508216142654419,
-0.07915570586919785,
-0.6219078898429871,
0.04645451158285141,
-0.4582621455192566,
0.11091054230928421,
0.5621158480644226,
-0.7166444659233093,
0.17787984013557434,
-0.5025292038917542,
-0.630524754524231,
0.028417088091373444,
0.6642975211143494,
0.3957640528678894,
0.381173312664032,
0.6875444054603577,
0.4490417540073395,
0.7921845316886902,
-0.11595471948385239,
1.1853750944137573,
-0.013242385350167751,
-0.006739974953234196,
1.3907768726348877,
-0.4951231777667999,
0.9597898721694946,
0.22265735268592834,
-0.4595145881175995,
0.9939702153205872,
0.7272605299949646,
-0.11635169386863708,
0.634274959564209,
0.004116609692573547,
-0.10681892931461334,
0.035389579832553864,
-0.5373753309249878,
-0.30913108587265015,
0.2643979489803314,
0.4863176941871643,
-0.07637191563844681,
0.0451662614941597,
0.04927315562963486,
-0.2886844873428345,
-0.08682548999786377,
-0.3579767346382141,
1.2310998439788818,
0.04851464927196503,
-1.160762071609497,
0.27515271306037903,
-0.2729507088661194,
0.4537772834300995,
-0.6667878031730652,
-0.12388364225625992,
-0.4435403048992157,
0.09952902048826218,
-0.2340388149023056,
-1.2152290344238281,
-0.06685793399810791,
0.24276866018772125,
-0.5085257887840271,
0.09450266510248184,
0.5413995981216431,
-0.4746577739715576,
-0.1499989926815033,
-0.00773500744253397,
-0.07996856421232224,
0.3438216745853424,
-0.15372250974178314,
-0.6649284362792969,
-0.20595033466815948,
0.4229566752910614,
0.23834580183029175,
0.2785186171531677,
0.112665094435215,
0.22083236277103424,
0.9640159010887146,
0.7552211284637451,
0.02316383272409439,
-0.5400640368461609,
0.1626204252243042,
0.3338930904865265,
-0.9223719239234924,
-0.4361707270145416,
-0.7273280620574951,
0.3074437975883484,
-0.1631932258605957,
-0.568078875541687,
0.761595606803894,
0.3070048987865448,
0.954399824142456,
-0.14512930810451508,
0.6804932951927185,
0.11397971212863922,
0.40329572558403015,
-0.3880104720592499,
0.4557439088821411,
-0.2769186794757843,
0.15814055502414703,
-0.30023375153541565,
-1.3695175647735596,
0.23769959807395935,
0.6559610962867737,
-0.2109668105840683,
0.18068665266036987,
0.6013390421867371,
0.6502111554145813,
0.37496665120124817,
0.14153258502483368,
0.19091618061065674,
0.1094973012804985,
0.22528430819511414,
0.6520564556121826,
1.1517940759658813,
-0.32138583064079285,
0.34770816564559937,
-0.2821888029575348,
0.13045327365398407,
-0.3869602382183075,
-0.5793532729148865,
-0.6106833219528198,
-0.6385378241539001,
-0.3212304711341858,
-0.3328772187232971,
-0.2892245948314667,
1.162370204925537,
0.546552836894989,
-0.6217318177223206,
-0.47185906767845154,
0.10295538604259491,
-0.10200288891792297,
-0.05825072526931763,
-0.2973531186580658,
0.008227971382439137,
-0.05329127609729767,
-0.5974782109260559,
0.7426669001579285,
0.6437605023384094,
-0.12396744638681412,
-0.6510911583900452,
0.06596333533525467,
-0.01024093572050333,
0.021008189767599106,
0.37553107738494873,
0.25131237506866455,
-0.916905403137207,
-0.1664796620607376,
-0.3327268064022064,
0.2643399238586426,
-0.14959368109703064,
0.8963127732276917,
-0.8463923335075378,
1.1701712608337402,
0.23074735701084137,
0.27420854568481445,
0.6608434319496155,
0.0698809027671814,
1.0466301441192627,
-0.6442793011665344,
-0.021384714171290398,
-0.04616691917181015,
0.4831654131412506,
0.32912811636924744,
-0.6132301688194275,
0.6287519931793213,
-0.05195654183626175,
-0.5980096459388733,
-0.7280745506286621,
0.3430241048336029,
-0.8674388527870178,
-0.0035737333819270134,
0.7025488018989563,
-0.03060721978545189,
-0.16428682208061218,
0.16516773402690887,
-0.6233680844306946,
0.036705587059259415,
-0.8156312108039856,
0.6731040477752686,
0.7669707536697388,
-0.21712026000022888,
0.033622514456510544,
-0.3726111054420471,
0.3845835328102112,
0.05517520383000374,
-0.47789058089256287,
0.06252458691596985,
0.41513288021087646,
0.29387181997299194,
0.24541498720645905,
0.8699114918708801,
0.07437978684902191,
0.21128638088703156,
-0.07359428703784943,
-0.13127468526363373,
0.09242147952318192,
-0.22683368623256683,
-0.10694622993469238,
0.014231439679861069,
0.28587606549263,
-0.16003108024597168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13518v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13518v1
|
RITFIS: Robust input testing framework for LLMs-based intelligent software
| 2024-02-21T04:00:54 | 2024-02-21T04:00:54 |
Mingxuan Xiao, Yan Xiao, Hai Dong, Shunhui Ji, Pengcheng Zhang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
The dependence of Natural Language Processing (NLP) intelligent software on
Large Language Models (LLMs) is increasingly prominent, underscoring the
necessity for robustness testing. Current testing methods focus solely on the
robustness of LLM-based software to prompts. Given the complexity and diversity
of real-world inputs, studying the robustness of LLMbased software in handling
comprehensive inputs (including prompts and examples) is crucial for a thorough
understanding of its performance.
To this end, this paper introduces RITFIS, a Robust Input Testing Framework
for LLM-based Intelligent Software. To our knowledge, RITFIS is the first
framework designed to assess the robustness of LLM-based intelligent software
against natural language inputs. This framework, based on given threat models
and prompts, primarily defines the testing process as a combinatorial
optimization problem. Successful test cases are determined by a goal function,
creating a transformation space for the original examples through perturbation
means, and employing a series of search methods to filter cases that meet both
the testing objectives and language constraints. RITFIS, with its modular
design, offers a comprehensive method for evaluating the robustness of LLMbased
intelligent software.
RITFIS adapts 17 automated testing methods, originally designed for Deep
Neural Network (DNN)-based intelligent software, to the LLM-based software
testing scenario. It demonstrates the effectiveness of RITFIS in evaluating
LLM-based intelligent software through empirical validation. However, existing
methods generally have limitations, especially when dealing with lengthy texts
and structurally complex threat models. Therefore, we conducted a comprehensive
analysis based on five metrics and provided insightful testing method
optimization strategies, benefiting both researchers and everyday users.
|
[
-0.6133728623390198,
-0.990420937538147,
0.2444605976343155,
0.4462498128414154,
-0.06896869838237762,
0.12010508030653,
-0.2448836863040924,
-0.3083907961845398,
-0.33325061202049255,
0.45480799674987793,
-0.8891224265098572,
-0.4745394289493561,
-0.3934585452079773,
0.4328840374946594,
-0.4756954312324524,
0.9372068643569946,
-0.14352884888648987,
-0.01885511912405491,
-0.31747734546661377,
-0.33881676197052,
-0.5239292979240417,
-0.06230524554848671,
-0.4581667184829712,
-0.3554602265357971,
0.5791879296302795,
0.4052375257015228,
0.5575204491615295,
0.30161207914352417,
0.908038854598999,
0.279950886964798,
0.2410401701927185,
0.1743750423192978,
-0.33018288016319275,
0.5525586605072021,
0.05794793739914894,
-0.48805248737335205,
-0.06990114599466324,
-0.3320516049861908,
0.5787249207496643,
0.31629690527915955,
0.13487224280834198,
0.47466325759887695,
0.2623332142829895,
0.2591398358345032,
-0.49598634243011475,
0.05628218501806259,
-0.49538907408714294,
0.25399085879325867,
-0.2859433889389038,
-0.47449222207069397,
-0.4649564027786255,
-0.359564870595932,
-0.05782870948314667,
-0.3140685558319092,
-0.23549917340278625,
0.18339696526527405,
0.6420081853866577,
0.5924468040466309,
-0.4526813328266144,
-0.2726958692073822,
-0.7537723183631897,
0.9833400249481201,
-0.8891712427139282,
0.6969590783119202,
0.056363675743341446,
0.18291519582271576,
-0.8877856135368347,
-0.5582906603813171,
-0.606525182723999,
-0.5898769497871399,
0.010804260149598122,
-0.1666354089975357,
-0.029877200722694397,
0.0803878977894783,
0.33811888098716736,
0.19707155227661133,
-1.0042973756790161,
0.29141244292259216,
0.06891585141420364,
-0.2936479151248932,
0.5956567525863647,
0.19259004294872284,
0.7882381081581116,
0.17738844454288483,
-0.4722219407558441,
-0.24506951868534088,
-0.4978029131889343,
0.4381576478481293,
0.3595968186855316,
0.2792883515357971,
0.09424746781587601,
0.5729703307151794,
-0.15438979864120483,
0.970990002155304,
-0.3877328932285309,
-0.8493679165840149,
0.06291697174310684,
-0.5253106951713562,
-0.18092237412929535,
-0.44540467858314514,
0.8010743856430054,
0.1861037313938141,
0.3659808039665222,
-0.23966272175312042,
-0.5515036582946777,
-0.15584608912467957,
0.24044190347194672,
-0.8738371133804321,
0.03731273487210274,
0.25409677624702454,
-0.23940260708332062,
-0.6763030290603638,
-0.13135090470314026,
-0.7689626216888428,
-0.3632356524467468,
0.0003907306236214936,
0.2828320264816284,
-0.6758883595466614,
0.07861346006393433,
-0.02589617297053337,
0.26628974080085754,
0.4834931790828705,
-0.06295616924762726,
-0.7954261302947998,
0.5118209719657898,
0.7981841564178467,
0.5436546206474304,
-0.4783576428890228,
-0.47778773307800293,
-0.8133463263511658,
-0.31904253363609314,
-0.14370563626289368,
0.9229269027709961,
-0.2497267872095108,
-0.3256123661994934,
-0.26557448506355286,
-0.318788081407547,
-0.15901786088943481,
-0.3774150609970093,
0.6370331645011902,
-0.7280145883560181,
0.0993013083934784,
-0.010738647542893887,
-0.5177538990974426,
-0.20089474320411682,
0.6254537105560303,
-0.45287132263183594,
1.2262177467346191,
0.18443359434604645,
-0.8390793800354004,
0.4865986704826355,
-0.8863950967788696,
-0.5887715816497803,
0.12637445330619812,
-0.229206383228302,
-0.5770946145057678,
-0.304840087890625,
0.27266401052474976,
0.1435498297214508,
-0.36673176288604736,
0.4968145787715912,
-0.6692314147949219,
-0.4932904541492462,
0.5600319504737854,
-0.5425357222557068,
0.8268309831619263,
0.2092846781015396,
-0.5280996561050415,
0.22967857122421265,
-0.4914432764053345,
0.3804718852043152,
0.23327462375164032,
-0.5843482613563538,
-0.07830522954463959,
0.1381244659423828,
0.07123742997646332,
-0.13830114901065826,
-0.05309957265853882,
-0.6508339047431946,
0.02260894887149334,
-0.6834755539894104,
0.2748734951019287,
0.605853796005249,
0.20132926106452942,
0.32675132155418396,
-0.2952935993671417,
0.7226480841636658,
-0.15160353481769562,
0.5100795030593872,
0.06361625343561172,
-0.40831997990608215,
-0.6609666347503662,
-0.4157922565937042,
0.4783899486064911,
1.1264485120773315,
-0.39605602622032166,
0.7006997466087341,
-0.13006950914859772,
-0.35525915026664734,
-0.0604865662753582,
0.40358781814575195,
-0.038846030831336975,
0.43512392044067383,
-0.23080506920814514,
-0.19816260039806366,
-0.45322185754776,
-0.948111891746521,
-0.31133443117141724,
-0.37991970777511597,
0.044213324785232544,
-0.12732984125614166,
0.66509610414505,
-0.2574649751186371,
1.0351982116699219,
-0.08989060670137405,
-0.17033658921718597,
-0.5419147610664368,
-0.07654530555009842,
0.2128104269504547,
0.3290644884109497,
0.8382483720779419,
-0.6747063398361206,
-0.012590870261192322,
-0.21209752559661865,
-0.3541421890258789,
-0.2331138551235199,
-0.26211369037628174,
0.008043486624956131,
-0.02901342697441578,
0.28123342990875244,
-0.4953438341617584,
0.45691627264022827,
0.34973177313804626,
-0.10870819538831711,
0.41749170422554016,
0.17213138937950134,
-0.04264518618583679,
-0.8672837615013123,
0.15877161920070648,
0.019798200577497482,
-0.17118041217327118,
-0.2831040918827057,
0.48766157031059265,
-0.21114754676818848,
-0.11579708009958267,
-0.31444281339645386,
0.4621678590774536,
-0.11157312989234924,
-0.23149989545345306,
-0.010263407602906227,
0.012939315289258957,
0.09591731429100037,
0.44824934005737305,
-0.6057001948356628,
1.0532488822937012,
0.3717584013938904,
-0.487841933965683,
0.5004004836082458,
0.10080967098474503,
-0.3138872981071472,
0.3176210820674896,
-0.6300157308578491,
0.016380896791815758,
0.1341952383518219,
0.13222481310367584,
-0.9921703338623047,
-0.06387000530958176,
0.4287937581539154,
-0.449468195438385,
0.30239808559417725,
0.059073131531476974,
-0.6813089847564697,
-0.27075183391571045,
-0.4387655258178711,
0.3370015025138855,
0.3913000822067261,
-0.3186780512332916,
0.7781705260276794,
0.29834622144699097,
-0.39175763726234436,
-0.6549584865570068,
-0.7010032534599304,
0.11092272400856018,
-0.37559548020362854,
-0.7722665667533875,
-0.006193738896399736,
-0.3883756995201111,
-0.34221044182777405,
-0.20591117441654205,
-0.020732548087835312,
-0.2116844654083252,
0.6918167471885681,
0.19535890221595764,
0.3109440207481384,
-0.44030821323394775,
-0.16372573375701904,
-0.12798653542995453,
-0.152947798371315,
0.277784526348114,
-0.18962223827838898,
0.35899022221565247,
-0.2971373498439789,
-0.7037414908409119,
-0.505626916885376,
0.4400547444820404,
0.7878629565238953,
-0.45242318511009216,
0.2777482569217682,
0.8283239006996155,
-0.43498721718788147,
-0.573260486125946,
-0.4174939692020416,
-0.26985037326812744,
-0.47123953700065613,
0.6610692739486694,
-0.2652203440666199,
-0.8671868443489075,
0.5473358035087585,
-0.1272401064634323,
0.5234201550483704,
0.22214308381080627,
0.4484713077545166,
-0.019327746704220772,
1.0294373035430908,
0.5903221368789673,
-0.1845366358757019,
0.30537813901901245,
-0.021956736221909523,
0.7037081718444824,
-0.3842625916004181,
-0.1622024029493332,
-0.6457123756408691,
-0.3715221583843231,
-0.2568615674972534,
0.06666519492864609,
0.38985028862953186,
-0.2329055815935135,
-0.21968305110931396,
-0.0016396420542150736,
-0.3793412446975708,
0.4577147364616394,
0.5643423795700073,
-0.22232912480831146,
0.08022798597812653,
-0.06879494339227676,
-0.3476484417915344,
-0.20690470933914185,
-0.5589327216148376,
-0.487030029296875,
0.8353835344314575,
0.6626371741294861,
0.8048748970031738,
0.23009146749973297,
0.6982130408287048,
0.3111962080001831,
0.4585137367248535,
-1.0455480813980103,
0.7288144826889038,
0.1407843828201294,
-0.2223929613828659,
-0.3969590365886688,
-0.2844822108745575,
-0.656416654586792,
-0.11359060555696487,
-0.2816793918609619,
-0.7004961371421814,
-0.05141536146402359,
-0.26676541566848755,
-0.6761638522148132,
0.4200492799282074,
-0.5578820109367371,
0.6647855639457703,
-0.6091865301132202,
0.06359098106622696,
0.19436649978160858,
-0.44895225763320923,
0.48729342222213745,
-0.1143219992518425,
0.09900306165218353,
-0.02903633564710617,
0.019598761573433876,
0.7667467594146729,
-0.2684732973575592,
0.7889323830604553,
0.04043571650981903,
0.013667291961610317,
0.10066994279623032,
0.4053938686847687,
0.3833659291267395,
0.44828757643699646,
-0.03312842175364494,
-0.11759454756975174,
0.14635632932186127,
-0.11732421070337296,
-0.8881880640983582,
0.7239494919776917,
-0.5921297073364258,
-0.48803237080574036,
-0.5505464673042297,
-0.7246506810188293,
-0.391630619764328,
0.5362221002578735,
0.05410348251461983,
0.5987575650215149,
-0.19979862868785858,
0.17246246337890625,
1.0526500940322876,
-0.2406824678182602,
0.26799827814102173,
0.2904609143733978,
-0.45623472332954407,
-0.37889960408210754,
0.8170825839042664,
-0.19496120512485504,
-0.12524904310703278,
0.26737770438194275,
0.14459355175495148,
-0.24322400987148285,
-1.1716439723968506,
-0.5985232591629028,
-0.1694318801164627,
-0.6308616399765015,
-0.3868618905544281,
-0.4603390395641327,
-0.364722341299057,
-0.4263862073421478,
-0.10742084681987762,
-0.19643111526966095,
0.01506879273802042,
-0.23192887008190155,
-0.0849885419011116,
0.31433290243148804,
0.6669619679450989,
0.23865145444869995,
-0.30522945523262024,
-0.658288836479187,
0.33653390407562256,
0.26113688945770264,
0.40284964442253113,
-0.20936276018619537,
-0.32670676708221436,
0.26774558424949646,
-0.18505069613456726,
-0.16498872637748718,
-0.6753109693527222,
0.18619629740715027,
0.2922194004058838,
0.808600902557373,
0.28163135051727295,
0.3898661732673645,
0.21885164082050323,
-0.013558780774474144,
0.6569790244102478,
-0.33377566933631897,
-0.5982012152671814,
0.48389244079589844,
-0.2891380488872528,
0.0904521495103836,
0.8885659575462341,
-0.11182554811239243,
-0.13458140194416046,
-0.43694382905960083,
-0.1918581873178482,
-0.7946160435676575,
0.37470176815986633,
0.262796014547348,
-0.10335317999124527,
0.31177759170532227,
0.5044119358062744,
0.10621881484985352,
-0.3369809687137604,
-0.7680256366729736,
-0.11585135012865067,
0.26804670691490173,
-0.6020146012306213,
0.3431045711040497,
-0.18686537444591522,
-0.2663605809211731,
-0.1819537729024887,
0.7473320960998535,
-0.22140347957611084,
0.10564300417900085,
0.2650540769100189,
-0.1375100463628769,
0.20129399001598358,
0.24366797506809235,
0.8145135641098022,
0.3193693459033966,
-0.21917098760604858,
0.08070952445268631,
0.6416023373603821,
-0.7949542999267578,
0.18532787263393402,
0.03751012682914734,
-0.4857849180698395,
-0.23172259330749512,
0.5432450771331787,
0.5999883413314819,
0.17883501946926117,
-0.9195731282234192,
0.47261670231819153,
-0.49863672256469727,
-0.038608208298683167,
-0.5519813299179077,
0.4465215504169464,
-0.15244074165821075,
0.1673581600189209,
0.24802041053771973,
0.3563588857650757,
0.23722220957279205,
-0.10159255564212799,
0.5313588380813599,
0.4752422571182251,
-0.36254021525382996,
-0.08203282952308655,
0.357719749212265,
0.21707363426685333,
-0.5646864771842957,
0.6439046859741211,
-0.2931000590324402,
-0.5030730962753296,
0.5928717255592346,
0.5162632465362549,
0.9030829668045044,
0.10408377647399902,
0.10901492834091187,
0.002804557094350457,
0.7233395576477051,
0.30483925342559814,
0.36220583319664,
-0.11290586739778519,
-0.5379936695098877,
-0.3887043297290802,
-0.6303159594535828,
-0.3580823242664337,
0.12400239706039429,
-0.34228625893592834,
0.27269455790519714,
-0.6146435141563416,
-0.235277459025383,
-0.325606107711792,
0.21097604930400848,
-0.5781450271606445,
0.19586026668548584,
0.17045511305332184,
1.3015754222869873,
-0.5458388924598694,
0.6069730520248413,
0.6795446872711182,
-0.03111964836716652,
-0.7672169804573059,
0.1217740923166275,
0.1034889668226242,
-0.7258800268173218,
0.578758180141449,
0.11887001991271973,
-0.2608674168586731,
-0.12352107465267181,
-0.4230618178844452,
-0.9493448734283447,
0.9518721103668213,
0.6511531472206116,
-0.0836295634508133,
0.2719504237174988,
0.44064947962760925,
0.3137873709201813,
-0.45214954018592834,
0.24291306734085083,
0.5398738980293274,
0.7236780524253845,
-0.21760313212871552,
-0.5561244487762451,
0.051071230322122574,
-0.5070775747299194,
0.07381460815668106,
0.16347256302833557,
-0.299818217754364,
0.3544212877750397,
-0.2853826582431793,
-0.17408387362957,
0.1815386265516281,
0.6814832091331482,
0.39764857292175293,
0.2903297245502472,
0.8655096292495728,
0.47988462448120117,
0.5735400915145874,
-0.19049184024333954,
1.1204838752746582,
-0.28015124797821045,
0.1807471513748169,
0.8537330031394958,
-0.5351468920707703,
0.7689933776855469,
0.5899762511253357,
-0.17428189516067505,
0.49735385179519653,
0.8369316458702087,
-0.0634034126996994,
0.38894572854042053,
0.40683984756469727,
-0.18978248536586761,
-0.21980074048042297,
-0.07146139442920685,
0.05959660932421684,
0.348994642496109,
0.2471664845943451,
0.042858369648456573,
-0.3573145568370819,
0.17435941100120544,
-0.0940939411520958,
-0.17592184245586395,
0.49914461374282837,
0.6419810652732849,
-0.13977812230587006,
-0.6391041874885559,
0.19515083730220795,
0.21858885884284973,
0.6897856593132019,
-0.9130527973175049,
0.1741485744714737,
-0.1927759200334549,
0.20275668799877167,
-0.08818369358778,
-0.7914724349975586,
0.44713595509529114,
-0.04838821664452553,
0.04023176431655884,
0.01735065132379532,
1.004254698753357,
0.10432198643684387,
-0.6164661645889282,
0.3374204933643341,
0.2305578589439392,
-0.2361554503440857,
0.30951130390167236,
-0.9252191781997681,
0.2473645955324173,
0.09715257585048676,
-0.4957113265991211,
0.3699623644351959,
0.22643807530403137,
-0.03176349028944969,
0.9620569944381714,
0.8211464881896973,
-0.03171763941645622,
-0.0951346829533577,
0.022301528602838516,
0.7617933750152588,
-0.5140499472618103,
-0.2735726535320282,
-0.9315547347068787,
0.32271766662597656,
0.11764999479055405,
-0.6031382083892822,
0.5336766242980957,
0.4163213074207306,
0.6282727122306824,
0.2422514706850052,
0.7526333332061768,
0.041802749037742615,
0.21554780006408691,
-0.39544054865837097,
0.7696820497512817,
-0.27691319584846497,
0.3920742869377136,
-0.09513045847415924,
-0.8605307936668396,
-0.6563155055046082,
0.2975832223892212,
0.06909520924091339,
0.027726393193006516,
0.5256735682487488,
1.031050205230713,
-0.10325492173433304,
0.14942620694637299,
0.183890238404274,
0.05335052311420441,
0.3256663382053375,
0.4945865273475647,
0.8086116313934326,
-0.3410744071006775,
0.4327864646911621,
-0.3847357928752899,
-0.35531264543533325,
-0.10558132082223892,
-0.8624740242958069,
-0.8466657400131226,
-0.4684157371520996,
-0.42222270369529724,
-0.141917884349823,
-0.02330614998936653,
0.8811025023460388,
0.5655355453491211,
-0.9901257753372192,
-0.026173796504735947,
-0.048936303704977036,
0.29533958435058594,
-0.23787398636341095,
-0.29646024107933044,
-0.038586098700761795,
-0.37864255905151367,
-0.3252595365047455,
0.6972423195838928,
0.6378006339073181,
0.05608810484409332,
-0.793256938457489,
0.03251548856496811,
-0.08752789348363876,
0.17474177479743958,
0.2561616003513336,
0.2203957885503769,
-0.6011810302734375,
-0.39596253633499146,
0.504469633102417,
-0.032104797661304474,
-0.2435465008020401,
0.7882458567619324,
-0.6692297458648682,
0.12302155792713165,
0.7698325514793396,
0.9602296352386475,
-0.40917354822158813,
-0.4077081084251404,
0.6678842306137085,
-0.3919841945171356,
0.04885901138186455,
0.48923033475875854,
0.37155261635780334,
0.27928051352500916,
-0.5842880606651306,
0.2834185063838959,
0.08912864327430725,
-0.633746325969696,
-1.2413314580917358,
0.28737184405326843,
-0.9946087002754211,
0.10218022763729095,
0.9177477955818176,
-0.23591576516628265,
-0.4278275966644287,
-0.38600096106529236,
-0.17945243418216705,
-0.022644920274615288,
-0.08852806687355042,
0.5656104683876038,
0.6703997254371643,
-0.2422744333744049,
-0.05374833196401596,
-0.5788468718528748,
0.21579456329345703,
0.5700914859771729,
-0.6867429614067078,
-0.23411013185977936,
-0.05252625793218613,
0.578937292098999,
-0.0332367941737175,
0.29203447699546814,
-0.13291437923908234,
0.1123177781701088,
-0.2579655945301056,
0.02835230901837349,
-0.23479071259498596,
-0.11961590498685837,
-0.2028714269399643,
0.2939697802066803,
0.34628161787986755,
-0.027294352650642395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13517v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13517v1
|
Round Trip Translation Defence against Large Language Model Jailbreaking Attacks
| 2024-02-21T03:59:52 | 2024-02-21T03:59:52 |
Canaan Yung, Hadi Mohaghegh Dolatabadi, Sarah Erfani, Christopher Leckie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) are susceptible to social-engineered attacks
that are human-interpretable but require a high level of comprehension for LLMs
to counteract. Existing defensive measures can only mitigate less than half of
these attacks at most. To address this issue, we propose the Round Trip
Translation (RTT) method, the first algorithm specifically designed to defend
against social-engineered attacks on LLMs. RTT paraphrases the adversarial
prompt and generalizes the idea conveyed, making it easier for LLMs to detect
induced harmful behavior. This method is versatile, lightweight, and
transferrable to different LLMs. Our defense successfully mitigated over 70% of
Prompt Automatic Iterative Refinement (PAIR) attacks, which is currently the
most effective defense to the best of our knowledge. We are also the first to
attempt mitigating the MathsAttack and reduced its attack success rate by
almost 40%. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/Cancanxxx/Round_Trip_Translation_Defence
|
[
-0.23753459751605988,
-1.181431531906128,
0.6383426189422607,
0.3736063539981842,
-0.32302433252334595,
0.4229975938796997,
-0.22893954813480377,
-0.35432082414627075,
0.15076944231987,
0.678489625453949,
-0.5139581561088562,
-0.5165151953697205,
-0.6738389730453491,
0.27318182587623596,
-0.5716111063957214,
0.9343668222427368,
-0.025987396016716957,
0.025213997811079025,
0.16863982379436493,
-0.08917675912380219,
-0.562867283821106,
-0.663508415222168,
-0.8042176961898804,
-0.1499125361442566,
0.7091311812400818,
0.22464346885681152,
0.6373483538627625,
0.26764318346977234,
0.6984515190124512,
0.25857773423194885,
-0.09046027809381485,
0.015924811363220215,
-0.4850054383277893,
0.24489346146583557,
-0.09499707072973251,
-0.4997612535953522,
-0.410524845123291,
-0.24688707292079926,
0.5089806914329529,
0.2122451514005661,
-0.2908766567707062,
0.04177851974964142,
-0.4829784631729126,
1.0523113012313843,
-0.301891952753067,
-0.21774688363075256,
-0.822607696056366,
0.18047142028808594,
-0.6495258808135986,
-0.1568261831998825,
-0.847321629524231,
-0.45785969495773315,
-0.4022951126098633,
-0.522598385810852,
-0.04372410848736763,
0.36651411652565,
0.5008413791656494,
0.20948565006256104,
-0.28832709789276123,
-0.12979555130004883,
-0.41570642590522766,
0.47999775409698486,
-0.8511240482330322,
0.10578227043151855,
0.21298038959503174,
0.5091074705123901,
-0.5943520665168762,
-0.5450000762939453,
-0.5354442596435547,
-0.5246017575263977,
0.2414179891347885,
-0.2200622260570526,
-0.6265742182731628,
0.09487763792276382,
0.3858748972415924,
0.010797582566738129,
-0.8584537506103516,
-0.04973428696393967,
-0.761836051940918,
-0.23517094552516937,
0.5113065838813782,
0.09487880766391754,
0.7142103910446167,
-0.2026667594909668,
-0.41469234228134155,
0.11273344606161118,
-1.089939832687378,
-0.2616484463214874,
0.2402990758419037,
0.28674930334091187,
-0.15351133048534393,
0.6206347942352295,
-0.23218876123428345,
0.5156979560852051,
0.028049297630786896,
0.16666407883167267,
0.00243717385455966,
-0.1588808298110962,
0.06160515174269676,
0.1698249727487564,
0.9873831272125244,
0.43216991424560547,
0.6870313882827759,
-0.4873996675014496,
-0.4367291033267975,
-0.0817032903432846,
0.6292262077331543,
-0.7065548896789551,
0.03142838552594185,
-0.0006758259842172265,
-0.04454422369599342,
-0.7990265488624573,
-0.05009084194898605,
-0.7924436926841736,
-0.4952287971973419,
0.25803273916244507,
0.2741488814353943,
-0.5176939964294434,
-0.15682947635650635,
0.28470009565353394,
0.1859450489282608,
0.2966247498989105,
0.08740078657865524,
-0.4707747995853424,
0.2127055525779724,
0.9032679796218872,
1.38864266872406,
-0.12850919365882874,
-0.17192447185516357,
-0.948692262172699,
0.11715452373027802,
-0.34470614790916443,
0.8715659379959106,
-0.18176859617233276,
-0.6736048460006714,
-0.03731401264667511,
-0.2728612422943115,
0.06763127446174622,
-0.4039895534515381,
0.5427262783050537,
-0.8399027585983276,
-0.126853346824646,
-0.21320217847824097,
-0.27181386947631836,
0.10717810690402985,
0.5201689600944519,
-0.7511895895004272,
0.720211923122406,
-0.07485625147819519,
-0.849335253238678,
-0.25990644097328186,
-0.6623741388320923,
-0.6860395669937134,
0.09214482456445694,
-0.026372749358415604,
-0.55927973985672,
0.21743933856487274,
0.45652952790260315,
0.11957670003175735,
-0.2855435907840729,
0.21848247945308685,
-0.6890206336975098,
-0.20005826652050018,
0.3149048686027527,
-0.23194344341754913,
0.8630045056343079,
0.4936387240886688,
-0.38674619793891907,
0.3560390770435333,
-0.3523877263069153,
-0.19554288685321808,
0.6301093697547913,
-0.09285858273506165,
-0.40812861919403076,
-0.27101269364356995,
-0.18598754703998566,
0.2165035903453827,
0.10929089784622192,
-0.6158543229103088,
0.5462164282798767,
-0.46364960074424744,
0.8616287112236023,
1.0592509508132935,
0.24221624433994293,
0.3120083510875702,
-0.2341209352016449,
0.8341467380523682,
-0.23040471971035004,
0.2546970248222351,
0.07843825966119766,
-0.3851780593395233,
-0.3230883479118347,
-0.0399014987051487,
0.03536563739180565,
0.7341546416282654,
-1.101029396057129,
-0.0000034886547837231774,
-0.4511617124080658,
-0.6511791348457336,
-0.3007575571537018,
0.06262563169002533,
0.5191068649291992,
0.23344305157661438,
0.40885674953460693,
-0.06926032155752182,
-0.4292941093444824,
-0.6888309717178345,
-0.5740388631820679,
-0.16525578498840332,
0.05253535881638527,
-0.3116704225540161,
0.3683376908302307,
-0.13357454538345337,
0.6480783820152283,
-0.5529196262359619,
-0.07736758887767792,
-0.44820231199264526,
-0.12758994102478027,
0.181466743350029,
0.3682126998901367,
0.7696118354797363,
-0.647946834564209,
-0.4611378610134125,
-0.260337769985199,
-0.8285979628562927,
-0.442096084356308,
-0.2934545874595642,
-0.27739182114601135,
-0.015443271026015282,
0.7594831585884094,
-0.9509229063987732,
0.46631208062171936,
0.30349859595298767,
-0.5827965140342712,
0.5883139371871948,
-0.05539350584149361,
0.04061301797628403,
-1.216214656829834,
-0.24741630256175995,
0.07383303344249725,
-0.5190936326980591,
-0.6990517377853394,
0.43073102831840515,
0.08617176115512848,
-0.17365753650665283,
-0.6527132391929626,
0.6210845708847046,
-0.11483974009752274,
0.0933082103729248,
-0.06939539313316345,
0.29400187730789185,
-0.0684114620089531,
0.1499902456998825,
-0.39188629388809204,
0.9976083040237427,
0.13621142506599426,
-0.31143492460250854,
0.6877789497375488,
0.2659094035625458,
-0.13063056766986847,
0.7968270778656006,
-0.9441503286361694,
0.5173130035400391,
0.14141488075256348,
0.45535099506378174,
-0.8055180311203003,
0.10635341703891754,
0.5511397123336792,
-0.6908773183822632,
0.26713457703590393,
-0.04416131228208542,
-0.5070781707763672,
-0.3898357152938843,
-0.465128093957901,
0.38392332196235657,
0.33873021602630615,
-0.6436304450035095,
0.4463655948638916,
0.19396568834781647,
-0.26423269510269165,
-0.35377413034439087,
-0.5696043968200684,
0.7218630313873291,
-0.4321425259113312,
-0.8663448095321655,
0.10103605687618256,
-0.256691038608551,
-0.4397728443145752,
-0.48169246315956116,
-0.2636473774909973,
0.16934794187545776,
0.271504282951355,
-0.00678285164758563,
0.4164797365665436,
-0.07142645865678787,
-0.31174176931381226,
-0.14939913153648376,
-0.2453462779521942,
0.49112921953201294,
-0.2746311128139496,
0.6575098037719727,
-0.23976001143455505,
-0.3950989246368408,
-0.2012711614370346,
0.3891746401786804,
0.8877022862434387,
-0.1970140039920807,
0.7484152913093567,
0.48092469573020935,
-0.1709456741809845,
-0.10737866163253784,
-0.6092513799667358,
-0.22148238122463226,
-0.5012609958648682,
0.6238282322883606,
-0.5711027979850769,
-0.8016445636749268,
0.404737263917923,
0.041068483144044876,
0.07072553783655167,
0.20867030322551727,
0.37043821811676025,
0.26060307025909424,
0.8531324863433838,
0.4646885395050049,
-0.5416480898857117,
0.4348262846469879,
0.17602671682834625,
0.4576818645000458,
-0.6361282467842102,
-0.051413919776678085,
-0.5838150382041931,
-0.03944462910294533,
-0.41211527585983276,
-0.22559340298175812,
0.40988701581954956,
-0.027579767629504204,
-0.24640195071697235,
0.6314913034439087,
-0.4897775650024414,
0.5166783332824707,
0.2935694456100464,
0.18446026742458344,
0.4349469244480133,
0.007923233322799206,
0.030752891674637794,
0.07428690791130066,
-0.37906378507614136,
-0.4136865735054016,
1.3277133703231812,
0.5233028531074524,
0.7190783619880676,
0.3752880394458771,
0.8443225026130676,
0.7364003658294678,
0.33745113015174866,
-0.5894165635108948,
0.9094609022140503,
0.1101546362042427,
-0.5036195516586304,
-0.04744649678468704,
-0.7494374513626099,
-0.5110204815864563,
0.2107793241739273,
0.09030066430568695,
-0.7727695107460022,
-0.42082905769348145,
0.02622128278017044,
-0.25283294916152954,
0.622788667678833,
-0.5745047330856323,
0.8113970756530762,
-0.43084439635276794,
-0.20265869796276093,
-0.31329336762428284,
-0.6536195278167725,
0.6026638746261597,
-0.38245469331741333,
0.5839705467224121,
0.05816086009144783,
0.2352532595396042,
0.6811902523040771,
-0.4616021513938904,
0.8112214803695679,
-0.2323627471923828,
-0.06496400386095047,
-0.012087931856513023,
0.45203009247779846,
0.8271486163139343,
0.23716989159584045,
0.1515357941389084,
0.3618680238723755,
0.03865339979529381,
-0.6993504166603088,
-0.4956628382205963,
0.6555383205413818,
-0.6484519839286804,
-0.8545259833335876,
-0.49734950065612793,
-0.5523062944412231,
0.11572899669408798,
0.26825228333473206,
0.1745193749666214,
0.12703076004981995,
-0.19678501784801483,
0.016582025215029716,
0.7630600333213806,
-0.2393801063299179,
0.371904581785202,
0.508152961730957,
-0.5324438810348511,
-0.7481168508529663,
0.841083824634552,
-0.17309491336345673,
0.6104794144630432,
0.2318834364414215,
0.2697124481201172,
0.005058039911091328,
-0.6985456943511963,
-0.5655229091644287,
0.2926236391067505,
-0.5598426461219788,
-0.4580185115337372,
-0.5435006022453308,
-0.13288730382919312,
-0.5928691625595093,
-0.35551291704177856,
-0.5179404616355896,
-0.6131519675254822,
0.46603867411613464,
-0.20772571861743927,
0.5455172657966614,
0.7808771133422852,
-0.06823304295539856,
0.3316909968852997,
-0.8704432249069214,
0.45302852988243103,
0.02050703763961792,
-0.16416829824447632,
-0.3301801383495331,
-0.7669039964675903,
-0.0908215343952179,
-0.19630300998687744,
-0.3392004072666168,
-1.0938913822174072,
0.42826294898986816,
-0.30074289441108704,
0.2608875632286072,
0.2217801809310913,
0.45794910192489624,
0.4994601011276245,
-0.6941342353820801,
0.5066210031509399,
0.29527926445007324,
-0.9186367988586426,
0.3970482051372528,
-0.39088425040245056,
0.41280338168144226,
0.38631439208984375,
-0.02836584858596325,
-0.7448474168777466,
-0.6512648463249207,
-0.388520747423172,
-0.950030505657196,
0.4217865467071533,
0.28350597620010376,
0.06087128818035126,
-0.08240468055009842,
0.6226614117622375,
-0.2661767601966858,
0.22897015511989594,
-1.1073442697525024,
-0.0807216614484787,
-0.11250424385070801,
-0.17355860769748688,
0.20494046807289124,
-0.1853068768978119,
-0.16171732544898987,
-0.07060018181800842,
0.7608053684234619,
0.2770749032497406,
0.07013482600450516,
0.17267243564128876,
-0.34255313873291016,
-0.18255339562892914,
0.4181101620197296,
0.945266604423523,
0.5579860806465149,
-0.11507537961006165,
0.1867033988237381,
0.21881313621997833,
-0.9215427041053772,
0.22676336765289307,
0.10511284321546555,
-0.5660232305526733,
-0.12417662143707275,
0.5225011110305786,
0.6160057187080383,
0.016334520652890205,
-0.640042781829834,
0.45745885372161865,
-0.2222331464290619,
0.0019747207406908274,
-0.545345664024353,
-0.2094777524471283,
-0.1758359968662262,
0.3010014295578003,
0.2820567786693573,
-0.11047717928886414,
-0.21669000387191772,
-0.1694149374961853,
0.2799113690853119,
0.4284418225288391,
-0.3944491446018219,
-0.3759496510028839,
0.5991265773773193,
0.16563062369823456,
-0.6632695198059082,
0.5708382725715637,
-0.17711707949638367,
-0.8965961933135986,
0.5893110632896423,
0.7507506012916565,
1.1277859210968018,
-0.433776319026947,
0.04323602095246315,
0.20677700638771057,
0.9205905795097351,
-0.0425703227519989,
-0.07722409069538116,
0.1726706475019455,
-0.4517858922481537,
-0.3231367766857147,
-0.4776481091976166,
-0.3680976331233978,
0.07519250363111496,
-0.5859900116920471,
0.23595984280109406,
-0.6307080388069153,
0.008435732685029507,
-0.31070569157600403,
-0.33643487095832825,
-0.12602075934410095,
-0.37981274724006653,
0.27197444438934326,
1.1101055145263672,
-0.7190061211585999,
0.9674327969551086,
0.6017649173736572,
-0.4600121080875397,
-0.49675264954566956,
0.029655855149030685,
0.19935336709022522,
-0.773770272731781,
0.6783363223075867,
0.30846118927001953,
-0.34729841351509094,
0.06153733283281326,
-0.6661686301231384,
-0.5491114854812622,
0.7437503337860107,
0.3348531723022461,
-0.7529512047767639,
-0.2827073037624359,
0.33631861209869385,
0.0610983744263649,
-0.2085149735212326,
0.012969457544386387,
0.6453693509101868,
0.4994553029537201,
-0.005490575917065144,
-0.8663552403450012,
0.39347949624061584,
-0.0973738580942154,
0.04370421543717384,
0.4533969759941101,
-0.45082253217697144,
0.5683884620666504,
-0.42271706461906433,
0.04145892336964607,
0.08047664165496826,
0.5294514894485474,
0.4890257716178894,
0.43174800276756287,
0.5258128046989441,
0.7305012345314026,
0.3132483661174774,
-0.03448297083377838,
0.9904127717018127,
-0.20025932788848877,
0.24516984820365906,
1.0396323204040527,
-0.22603653371334076,
0.7869464159011841,
0.8344315886497498,
-0.1783822476863861,
0.096939817070961,
0.45637503266334534,
0.08538221567869186,
0.6586432456970215,
0.5022520422935486,
-0.36134442687034607,
-0.16087409853935242,
0.26576492190361023,
-0.4571140706539154,
0.011567420326173306,
0.23325227200984955,
0.1656184047460556,
-0.34203705191612244,
0.2414606213569641,
0.6825094223022461,
0.3688916862010956,
-0.23118841648101807,
0.6836382746696472,
0.45123735070228577,
-0.41069552302360535,
0.768200695514679,
0.21171191334724426,
0.5672542452812195,
-0.7301972508430481,
0.10330972075462341,
-0.37509799003601074,
0.20001204311847687,
-0.05721824988722801,
-0.4707905054092407,
0.33556321263313293,
0.2132919877767563,
0.043420881032943726,
-0.13644146919250488,
0.3923480808734894,
-0.11771521717309952,
-0.37777233123779297,
0.3044824004173279,
0.058299366384744644,
-0.19568778574466705,
-0.30368828773498535,
-0.7990413308143616,
0.354853093624115,
0.20911085605621338,
-0.6253526210784912,
0.37055274844169617,
0.4995706081390381,
-0.2684963345527649,
0.9066534638404846,
0.8423439860343933,
0.2742516100406647,
0.2390545755624771,
-0.031176038086414337,
1.1333674192428589,
-0.853744626045227,
-0.47857949137687683,
-1.406952142715454,
0.24468287825584412,
-0.31610673666000366,
0.17350909113883972,
0.6741051077842712,
0.4541425406932831,
0.7066332697868347,
0.13932248950004578,
0.767540454864502,
0.060512907803058624,
0.22217687964439392,
-0.6898965239524841,
0.8440523743629456,
-0.08974137902259827,
0.7110938429832458,
-0.2953179180622101,
-0.8610795736312866,
-0.382004052400589,
0.49114975333213806,
-0.7276800274848938,
-0.2835170030593872,
1.0274021625518799,
0.6879487633705139,
0.12395957857370377,
-0.15594367682933807,
0.21410806477069855,
0.3924500644207001,
0.9953593611717224,
0.6329185962677002,
0.6312761902809143,
-0.37102070450782776,
1.0059502124786377,
-0.11588223278522491,
-0.2662981450557709,
0.04115348309278488,
-0.9714794754981995,
-1.2483196258544922,
-0.006070602219551802,
-0.17488664388656616,
-0.8176809549331665,
0.5093254446983337,
1.0063395500183105,
0.3495791256427765,
-0.6200088858604431,
-0.15504153072834015,
-0.23649300634860992,
0.09449277073144913,
0.09418300539255142,
-0.18944406509399414,
0.09058581292629242,
-0.3522152602672577,
-0.20140884816646576,
0.6396608352661133,
0.3793376088142395,
-0.25994762778282166,
-0.4571884870529175,
-0.05744929611682892,
-0.22568655014038086,
0.20510394871234894,
0.3828423023223877,
0.43369224667549133,
-0.859133243560791,
-0.38598957657814026,
0.018311066552996635,
-0.22898747026920319,
-0.03901907056570053,
0.7151668071746826,
-0.3613998591899872,
0.4318423867225647,
0.25267428159713745,
0.9434677362442017,
0.26602470874786377,
-0.08936089277267456,
0.7913176417350769,
-0.5992063283920288,
0.4685121178627014,
0.19276946783065796,
0.3207394778728485,
0.32184505462646484,
-0.4327724277973175,
0.5580689907073975,
0.43075692653656006,
-0.54341721534729,
-1.0778406858444214,
0.5411298871040344,
-0.9307416081428528,
-0.18794269859790802,
1.1703238487243652,
-0.16785979270935059,
-0.5701899528503418,
0.06249513477087021,
-0.3055977523326874,
0.05496632680296898,
-0.6880047917366028,
1.1520885229110718,
0.6981520056724548,
0.5308152437210083,
0.0676443949341774,
-0.9894305467605591,
0.11840424686670303,
0.2934693992137909,
-0.835383951663971,
0.17432913184165955,
0.3194020986557007,
0.36300837993621826,
0.0887698233127594,
0.4014938771724701,
-0.3764643967151642,
0.1944597363471985,
-0.452738881111145,
0.15868423879146576,
-0.38010871410369873,
-0.08832449465990067,
-0.26531675457954407,
0.11271191388368607,
0.2133471965789795,
-0.1591886579990387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13516v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13516v4
|
ProSparse: Introducing and Enhancing Intrinsic Activation Sparsity within Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T03:58:49 | 2024-07-03T05:56:49 |
Chenyang Song, Xu Han, Zhengyan Zhang, Shengding Hu, Xiyu Shi, Kuai Li, Chen Chen, Zhiyuan Liu, Guangli Li, Tao Yang, Maosong Sun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Activation sparsity refers to the existence of considerable
weakly-contributed elements among activation outputs. As a prevalent property
of the models using the ReLU activation function, activation sparsity has been
proven a promising paradigm to boost model inference efficiency. Nevertheless,
most large language models (LLMs) adopt activation functions without intrinsic
activation sparsity (e.g., GELU and Swish). Some recent efforts have explored
introducing ReLU or its variants as the substitutive activation function to
help LLMs achieve activation sparsity and inference acceleration, but few can
simultaneously obtain high sparsity and comparable model performance. This
paper introduces a simple and effective sparsification method named "ProSparse"
to push LLMs for higher activation sparsity while maintaining comparable
performance. Specifically, after substituting the activation function of LLMs
with ReLU, ProSparse adopts progressive sparsity regularization with a factor
smoothly increasing along the multi-stage sine curves. This can enhance
activation sparsity and mitigate performance degradation by avoiding radical
shifts in activation distributions. With ProSparse, we obtain high sparsity of
89.32% for LLaMA2-7B, 88.80% for LLaMA2-13B, and 87.89% for end-size
MiniCPM-1B, respectively, achieving comparable performance to their original
Swish-activated versions. These present the most sparsely activated models
among open-source LLaMA versions and competitive end-size models, considerably
surpassing ReluLLaMA-7B (66.98%) and ReluLLaMA-13B (71.56%). Our inference
acceleration experiments further demonstrate the significant practical
acceleration potential of LLMs with higher activation sparsity, obtaining up to
4.52$\times$ inference speedup.
|
[
-0.33468133211135864,
-0.9131649732589722,
0.3164748251438141,
0.2592920660972595,
-0.3014437258243561,
-0.009609960950911045,
-0.35941749811172485,
-0.3745047152042389,
0.3851473033428192,
0.12237117439508438,
-0.6049519777297974,
-0.3284170925617218,
-0.6494219303131104,
-0.0015438315458595753,
-0.4602377116680145,
0.6632683277130127,
-0.030324891209602356,
0.1193821132183075,
0.16952551901340485,
0.03599271923303604,
-0.15447641909122467,
-0.15789704024791718,
-0.620572566986084,
-0.39045700430870056,
0.5019363164901733,
0.21229389309883118,
0.7780706882476807,
0.1374017745256424,
0.44960758090019226,
0.33119621872901917,
-0.3993590176105499,
0.12655043601989746,
-0.7863911986351013,
0.13316689431667328,
0.287305623292923,
-0.3730936050415039,
-0.6670126914978027,
-0.23542910814285278,
1.011777400970459,
0.7455644011497498,
-0.20315700769424438,
0.05384136363863945,
0.2913154661655426,
0.4909847378730774,
-0.7932699918746948,
0.07321852445602417,
-0.5529493093490601,
-0.06130485609173775,
-0.2003525346517563,
0.22363238036632538,
-0.39668434858322144,
-0.4771135449409485,
-0.14924708008766174,
-0.8305551409721375,
0.16773709654808044,
0.06368126720190048,
0.8097702264785767,
0.2712925970554352,
0.1462271511554718,
0.21586625277996063,
-0.5675744414329529,
0.7902151942253113,
-0.8040167689323425,
0.5500200986862183,
0.15665458142757416,
0.10621106624603271,
-0.5340966582298279,
-0.8347350358963013,
-0.5581001043319702,
-0.639238715171814,
-0.015533743426203728,
-0.03904121369123459,
-0.5334943532943726,
0.1139010414481163,
0.10853840410709381,
0.41031414270401,
-0.40376973152160645,
0.21711257100105286,
-0.13956423103809357,
0.07963673770427704,
0.3498755097389221,
-0.0441448949277401,
0.11955465376377106,
0.36045587062835693,
-0.27882158756256104,
0.16809993982315063,
-1.1000581979751587,
-0.04689427837729454,
0.16342975199222565,
0.21611802279949188,
0.12982116639614105,
0.6683223247528076,
-0.1890525072813034,
0.5753412842750549,
0.28147611021995544,
0.15659667551517487,
0.36481696367263794,
-0.3111415505409241,
-0.2855460047721863,
-0.05043725296854973,
0.5094314217567444,
-0.22070638835430145,
0.24595050513744354,
-0.20851324498653412,
-0.38054776191711426,
-0.09825964272022247,
0.08914855867624283,
-0.8308678269386292,
0.0931323915719986,
0.1141851544380188,
-0.2772727310657501,
-0.2192358374595642,
0.10909029096364975,
-0.5370467901229858,
-0.24877290427684784,
-0.26132580637931824,
0.5610575675964355,
-0.2444881796836853,
-0.5690312385559082,
0.2530428469181061,
0.14426270127296448,
0.08973004668951035,
0.3071903586387634,
-0.80684494972229,
0.6747130751609802,
0.738734781742096,
0.83713698387146,
-0.25355327129364014,
-0.2881014943122864,
-0.7845454812049866,
-0.11277685314416885,
-0.61107337474823,
0.8512331247329712,
-0.6889245510101318,
-0.16644816100597382,
-0.09837021678686142,
0.13668560981750488,
-0.03480292484164238,
-0.6615806818008423,
0.49012991786003113,
-0.6475561261177063,
-0.1854846030473709,
-0.13965071737766266,
-0.3025856912136078,
-0.1375696361064911,
-0.006829319521784782,
-0.700875997543335,
1.4376741647720337,
0.21572673320770264,
-0.4543496370315552,
0.2943199872970581,
-0.5003555417060852,
-0.33299386501312256,
0.13071425259113312,
0.14370734989643097,
-0.5590016841888428,
0.5282900929450989,
-0.029743215069174767,
0.29611775279045105,
-0.4376683831214905,
0.6565321087837219,
-0.30037015676498413,
-0.760640025138855,
0.3309228718280792,
-0.33717435598373413,
0.31447961926460266,
-0.09937508404254913,
-0.7061693668365479,
0.4119342565536499,
-0.5650829076766968,
-0.23338857293128967,
0.20076487958431244,
-0.26290324330329895,
-0.2775622606277466,
-0.04401792958378792,
-0.09201523661613464,
-0.14094336330890656,
0.07302767038345337,
-0.3995336890220642,
0.07171397656202316,
-0.6566348075866699,
0.07254967093467712,
0.7695384621620178,
-0.06901687383651733,
0.5658138394355774,
0.025831254199147224,
0.46379780769348145,
-0.09422756731510162,
0.14574971795082092,
0.35967981815338135,
-0.672268271446228,
-0.8097133040428162,
-0.6827943921089172,
0.6089408993721008,
0.3779684603214264,
-0.6423782706260681,
0.5815907120704651,
-0.42521336674690247,
-0.5664584636688232,
-0.5969883799552917,
0.32120245695114136,
0.4437163174152374,
0.43981319665908813,
0.5041432976722717,
-0.43487057089805603,
-0.2550414502620697,
-0.9801904559135437,
-0.3213270604610443,
0.013224390335381031,
-0.04673510789871216,
0.014452757313847542,
0.309381902217865,
-0.026479683816432953,
0.8619405031204224,
-0.34754282236099243,
-0.21442168951034546,
-0.6307857632637024,
0.24969680607318878,
0.43175208568573,
0.4810338318347931,
0.21207740902900696,
-0.7529956102371216,
-0.35646387934684753,
-0.23152537643909454,
-0.34154653549194336,
-0.6742172837257385,
-0.06343942135572433,
-0.20904383063316345,
-0.23014651238918304,
0.2941284477710724,
-0.7819191813468933,
0.3231102526187897,
0.36759713292121887,
-0.2692549526691437,
0.5351566672325134,
-0.017683859914541245,
0.024370625615119934,
-0.5762954354286194,
0.2421511858701706,
0.30212920904159546,
-0.27489277720451355,
-1.1053111553192139,
-0.03153504431247711,
0.005094567313790321,
0.06461279839277267,
-0.7032214999198914,
0.785356879234314,
-0.5779869556427002,
-0.2705366313457489,
-0.2555737793445587,
0.2841344177722931,
-0.2041606456041336,
0.5091329216957092,
0.0763910561800003,
1.0155236721038818,
0.5121669173240662,
-0.6324454545974731,
0.07888690382242203,
-0.05119846761226654,
-0.3338713049888611,
-0.04740260913968086,
-0.9777398109436035,
-0.40549176931381226,
-0.13989225029945374,
0.18105849623680115,
-0.9651991128921509,
0.013305379077792168,
0.4688465893268585,
-0.20808109641075134,
0.4813893437385559,
-0.11943500488996506,
-0.31453990936279297,
-0.04238659515976906,
-0.579307496547699,
0.2606378197669983,
0.6902788877487183,
-0.4056583642959595,
0.7722572088241577,
0.30718234181404114,
-0.2997950613498688,
-0.7877570986747742,
-0.5431710481643677,
0.04469389095902443,
-0.1931057572364807,
-0.6932900547981262,
0.48357093334198,
0.23673124611377716,
-0.2778889536857605,
0.06570975482463837,
-0.08567853271961212,
0.2718379497528076,
0.23502731323242188,
0.10147930681705475,
0.2042304426431656,
-0.3782464265823364,
-0.033614154905080795,
0.34907153248786926,
-0.595007061958313,
-0.37967827916145325,
-0.04239007085561752,
0.6992931365966797,
-0.04630592092871666,
-0.405671626329422,
-0.5766865611076355,
0.23310384154319763,
0.5067020654678345,
-0.17719559371471405,
0.8917320370674133,
0.8676411509513855,
-0.4123528003692627,
0.10058420896530151,
-0.723158061504364,
-0.4736102819442749,
-0.4632793664932251,
0.6157839298248291,
-0.4614730477333069,
-1.025559902191162,
0.3810485303401947,
-0.2976498305797577,
0.170096755027771,
0.6137937307357788,
0.7897781133651733,
0.3766380250453949,
1.0090657472610474,
0.40190935134887695,
0.011877777986228466,
0.76249760389328,
-0.22907643020153046,
0.3350365161895752,
-1.0379505157470703,
-0.11066374182701111,
-0.4426599144935608,
-0.4085720181465149,
-0.000959548749960959,
-0.5492329597473145,
0.38487130403518677,
0.33884197473526,
-0.2320018857717514,
0.35148489475250244,
-0.15156665444374084,
0.346347451210022,
0.44412460923194885,
0.06280753761529922,
0.1209062859416008,
0.43872612714767456,
0.012577676214277744,
-0.17663557827472687,
-0.7955414056777954,
-0.3661324083805084,
0.5723408460617065,
0.5955710411071777,
1.0723940134048462,
0.37540555000305176,
0.42699384689331055,
0.4285377562046051,
0.6930475831031799,
-0.6010990142822266,
0.7165869474411011,
-0.2092752754688263,
-0.30455905199050903,
-0.26560333371162415,
-0.37548163533210754,
-0.9712971448898315,
0.44301384687423706,
-0.5960260629653931,
-0.6180849075317383,
0.5459591746330261,
0.26071831583976746,
-0.29727745056152344,
0.0341377817094326,
-0.8406972885131836,
0.7537539601325989,
-0.0601101815700531,
-0.8734161257743835,
-0.33824893832206726,
-0.17051272094249725,
0.41127702593803406,
-0.09524743258953094,
0.2372494786977768,
-0.2587711215019226,
-0.2573050558567047,
0.6535297632217407,
-0.2626081109046936,
1.209343433380127,
-0.4537110924720764,
-0.13023707270622253,
0.3291296064853668,
0.38758790493011475,
0.8442981243133545,
0.011524839326739311,
0.05221576243638992,
0.3051830530166626,
-0.7839564085006714,
-0.2770289480686188,
-0.5651815533638,
0.6961970925331116,
-0.5162582993507385,
-0.7693698406219482,
-0.03599954769015312,
-0.21530568599700928,
-0.1345548778772354,
0.21459227800369263,
-0.08305001258850098,
0.3956913948059082,
-0.16016177833080292,
0.17223700881004333,
0.7680260539054871,
0.0367736779153347,
0.20901556313037872,
0.40133124589920044,
-0.11813179403543472,
-0.36409443616867065,
1.012939691543579,
0.02882889099419117,
0.4144175350666046,
0.038224559277296066,
0.23750321567058563,
-0.4866507649421692,
-0.7038576006889343,
-0.5323726534843445,
0.514174222946167,
-0.5158525705337524,
-0.206867054104805,
-0.764702558517456,
-0.06299388408660889,
-0.38087454438209534,
-0.11743292212486267,
-0.5145798325538635,
-0.6498857736587524,
-0.3912731111049652,
-0.03555101156234741,
0.10015232115983963,
0.49184197187423706,
-0.17194290459156036,
0.6233048439025879,
-0.6558210849761963,
0.4251349866390228,
0.16466650366783142,
0.1659070998430252,
0.16073857247829437,
-0.8404366374015808,
-0.19071152806282043,
-0.1559341698884964,
-0.073084257543087,
-0.9131707549095154,
0.3691980540752411,
0.44141262769699097,
0.9425168633460999,
0.40839049220085144,
-0.2999889850616455,
0.739538848400116,
-0.45502397418022156,
0.8459575772285461,
0.33144253492355347,
-1.1087050437927246,
0.21452009677886963,
0.13004760444164276,
-0.04894884303212166,
0.3512084484100342,
0.33021900057792664,
-0.32228952646255493,
-0.5468873381614685,
-0.5724332928657532,
-1.0227761268615723,
0.46820077300071716,
0.30099067091941833,
0.23980483412742615,
-0.05603121593594551,
0.422393262386322,
0.0322391502559185,
0.022322271019220352,
-0.9108798503875732,
0.020319458097219467,
0.20363886654376984,
-0.36132746934890747,
0.05122534930706024,
-0.721222996711731,
-0.026490172371268272,
0.0940222293138504,
1.017269253730774,
-0.05133146047592163,
0.1719144880771637,
0.28667163848876953,
-0.4109036922454834,
-0.13889823853969574,
0.23753167688846588,
0.634619414806366,
0.4765915870666504,
-0.08330044150352478,
0.20175307989120483,
0.44682782888412476,
-0.6260819435119629,
0.25851982831954956,
-0.018994901329278946,
-0.1812017410993576,
0.01176484301686287,
0.4468817114830017,
0.8411242365837097,
0.5213479995727539,
-0.5397652387619019,
0.5522977113723755,
-0.04112983122467995,
-0.06890679895877838,
0.023564593866467476,
0.2852770686149597,
0.06650084257125854,
0.4022878408432007,
0.49247875809669495,
-0.06946095079183578,
0.08782835304737091,
-0.09774525463581085,
0.028257964178919792,
0.4775809347629547,
-0.3894694149494171,
-0.3817538917064667,
0.6845646500587463,
0.21119512617588043,
-0.02995315007865429,
0.252101868391037,
-0.22502611577510834,
-0.4699743986129761,
0.5107315182685852,
0.8705675005912781,
0.9120157957077026,
-0.4535630941390991,
-0.13630007207393646,
0.516042947769165,
0.49938100576400757,
-0.44478657841682434,
0.1490187644958496,
-0.01950990781188011,
-0.7486169338226318,
-0.7496057748794556,
-0.6604328155517578,
-0.1697404384613037,
-0.23774564266204834,
-0.3135887086391449,
0.20479516685009003,
-0.2272913008928299,
-0.42446112632751465,
-0.32312875986099243,
-0.2015751451253891,
-0.09781351685523987,
0.08629702776670456,
0.1524834930896759,
1.0698950290679932,
-1.1754761934280396,
0.5861102938652039,
0.39121174812316895,
-0.16058336198329926,
-0.2607667148113251,
-0.0999554768204689,
-0.11124862730503082,
-0.825788676738739,
0.7450777888298035,
0.04568752273917198,
-0.4583545923233032,
0.2036827653646469,
-0.3502180874347687,
-0.939850926399231,
0.9700265526771545,
0.41110363602638245,
-0.7855167984962463,
0.2397252768278122,
-0.12020498514175415,
0.341505765914917,
-0.4742784798145294,
0.21669894456863403,
0.735296368598938,
0.634838879108429,
0.0647004246711731,
-0.5116851925849915,
0.3030472695827484,
-0.15970729291439056,
0.1761419177055359,
0.24700818955898285,
-0.38679999113082886,
0.6122735142707825,
-0.1547076255083084,
-0.17370665073394775,
0.07304809987545013,
0.9712983965873718,
0.5356086492538452,
-0.0732983946800232,
0.6219833493232727,
0.5623185634613037,
0.5781442523002625,
-0.3294532299041748,
0.9283766746520996,
-0.27035561203956604,
0.262240469455719,
0.66020667552948,
-0.3131044805049896,
0.8366702198982239,
0.4933784604072571,
-0.18508487939834595,
0.3301456868648529,
0.6046892404556274,
0.07754693180322647,
0.49166834354400635,
0.392812579870224,
-0.5626934766769409,
-0.4868987500667572,
-0.14054927229881287,
-0.37818241119384766,
-0.030106527730822563,
0.5402119159698486,
-0.0982033833861351,
-0.16019026935100555,
-0.15617360174655914,
0.2167719602584839,
-0.33341526985168457,
-0.26594895124435425,
0.6520231366157532,
-0.0002376762859057635,
-0.5066057443618774,
0.7061356902122498,
0.21355928480625153,
0.7041402459144592,
-0.8073703646659851,
-0.006931175943464041,
-0.49006205797195435,
0.1683882474899292,
-0.19090178608894348,
-0.6061077117919922,
0.18484997749328613,
0.17541952431201935,
0.07297590374946594,
0.1791291981935501,
1.004697322845459,
-0.38771215081214905,
-0.5332602262496948,
0.3449937403202057,
0.44067126512527466,
0.1522839367389679,
-0.04126068949699402,
-0.7443586587905884,
0.27453547716140747,
-0.10385358333587646,
-0.6879190802574158,
0.3175901472568512,
0.14194941520690918,
-0.19617615640163422,
0.5971835255622864,
0.891075074672699,
0.3177853524684906,
0.25222811102867126,
0.2620669901371002,
1.161522626876831,
-0.3163580000400543,
-0.20739635825157166,
-0.8514542579650879,
0.6168725490570068,
-0.204286590218544,
-0.08193981647491455,
0.5946593880653381,
0.479437917470932,
0.2559543550014496,
0.026336664333939552,
0.3340975046157837,
0.002636619145050645,
0.21740195155143738,
-0.680945873260498,
0.4999464750289917,
-0.7093683481216431,
0.31504571437835693,
-0.16447961330413818,
-1.2910200357437134,
-0.6859800219535828,
0.6708608269691467,
-0.42963963747024536,
0.1249055489897728,
0.43333303928375244,
1.223471760749817,
-0.18687434494495392,
-0.3292641341686249,
0.22847916185855865,
0.3991604447364807,
0.3694019913673401,
0.30654552578926086,
0.787542462348938,
-0.2752217650413513,
0.273199200630188,
0.15260499715805054,
-0.7013181447982788,
-0.28767555952072144,
-0.7077717781066895,
-0.5905066132545471,
-0.14772148430347443,
-0.35885903239250183,
-0.4619593620300293,
0.13324731588363647,
0.7848513126373291,
0.7583504319190979,
-0.7270042300224304,
-0.10262603312730789,
-0.09354683756828308,
0.08796714246273041,
-0.3292436897754669,
-0.20900148153305054,
0.3881341516971588,
-0.5594435930252075,
-0.7516558766365051,
0.7064746022224426,
0.4369194507598877,
0.03754176199436188,
-0.2922150194644928,
-0.26572468876838684,
-0.21165238320827484,
0.13261134922504425,
0.4824271500110626,
0.29357507824897766,
-0.6634893417358398,
0.1261047124862671,
-0.09409800916910172,
0.11116346716880798,
0.024701733142137527,
0.9789827466011047,
-0.7973591685295105,
-0.117205411195755,
0.41063225269317627,
0.6196529865264893,
0.5494555830955505,
0.08829431235790253,
0.32454922795295715,
-0.7515588402748108,
0.4025099575519562,
0.09588826447725296,
0.47440803050994873,
0.1482522040605545,
-0.23091323673725128,
0.5304752588272095,
0.409881591796875,
-0.25562289357185364,
-0.968980610370636,
0.1242925301194191,
-0.701337993144989,
-0.3069896399974823,
1.233725666999817,
-0.1345353126525879,
-0.506293535232544,
-0.08249965310096741,
-0.1910412311553955,
0.15783852338790894,
-0.4454703629016876,
0.4874311685562134,
0.3551117479801178,
-0.017203953117132187,
-0.17240764200687408,
-0.34282028675079346,
0.34345170855522156,
0.8339270353317261,
-0.6215783357620239,
0.3720303177833557,
0.4551750123500824,
0.08831354230642319,
0.002934484975412488,
0.7634358406066895,
-0.34940460324287415,
0.3953332304954529,
0.12270752340555191,
0.1362941861152649,
-0.1702560931444168,
-0.4338015913963318,
-0.4030102491378784,
0.2689417004585266,
0.24931679666042328,
0.2106219381093979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13514v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13514v1
|
Self-DC: When to retrieve and When to generate? Self Divide-and-Conquer for Compositional Unknown Questions
| 2024-02-21T03:55:02 | 2024-02-21T03:55:02 |
Hongru Wang, Boyang Xue, Baohang Zhou, Tianhua Zhang, Cunxiang Wang, Guanhua Chen, Huimin Wang, Kam-fai Wong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieve-then-read and generate-then-read are two typical solutions to handle
unknown and known questions in open-domain question-answering, while the former
retrieves necessary external knowledge and the later prompt the large language
models to generate internal known knowledge encoded in the parameters. However,
few of previous works consider the compositional unknown questions, which
consist of several known or unknown sub-questions. Thus, simple binary
classification (known or unknown) becomes sub-optimal and inefficient since it
will call external retrieval excessively for each compositional unknown
question. To this end, we propose the first Compositional unknown
Question-Answering dataset (CuQA), and introduce a Self Divide-and-Conquer
(Self-DC) framework to empower LLMs to adaptively call different methods
on-demand, resulting in better performance and efficiency. Experimental results
on two datasets (CuQA and FreshQA) demonstrate that Self-DC can achieve
comparable or even better performance with much more less retrieval times
compared with several strong baselines.
|
[
-0.5874792337417603,
-0.6851794123649597,
0.7733159065246582,
0.2453923374414444,
-0.08850674331188202,
0.3358270525932312,
0.03229925408959389,
-0.21808233857154846,
0.09469100832939148,
0.3800109326839447,
-0.9927149415016174,
-0.18357960879802704,
-0.29975461959838867,
0.23093697428703308,
-0.32327333092689514,
0.7465437054634094,
-0.17213721573352814,
-0.05898122116923332,
-0.7061877846717834,
-0.2784346044063568,
-0.4747612476348877,
-0.6744505167007446,
-0.6215384006500244,
-0.003218642668798566,
0.6419529914855957,
0.4828285276889801,
0.23965024948120117,
0.5846956372261047,
0.41109657287597656,
0.3157537281513214,
0.13632865250110626,
0.5553704500198364,
-0.35752713680267334,
0.3597726821899414,
-0.2363251894712448,
-0.5451371073722839,
0.0824265107512474,
-0.10514798760414124,
0.3728486895561218,
0.743541955947876,
-0.17843133211135864,
0.10618515312671661,
-0.08572545647621155,
0.6060919761657715,
-0.8434233665466309,
-0.056142885237932205,
-0.599341630935669,
0.04203294217586517,
-0.040954310446977615,
-0.4053099751472473,
-0.22266510128974915,
-0.13744917511940002,
0.15441009402275085,
-0.5837269425392151,
0.33323025703430176,
-0.02413950115442276,
0.07162496447563171,
0.3377593755722046,
-0.5511255860328674,
-0.5111473798751831,
-0.6629890203475952,
0.654339075088501,
-0.3096899688243866,
0.2668076157569885,
0.3425091505050659,
0.42888396978378296,
0.05463244765996933,
-0.805040180683136,
-0.700476884841919,
0.21089787781238556,
-0.15189678966999054,
0.3059207499027252,
-0.40811413526535034,
-0.2412448227405548,
-0.005919249262660742,
0.3943304717540741,
-0.4800669252872467,
0.23105759918689728,
-0.39201056957244873,
-0.14481483399868011,
0.6479349136352539,
0.5125775337219238,
0.2875547409057617,
-0.1723233461380005,
-0.4095715880393982,
0.13782843947410583,
-0.7306548357009888,
0.18134042620658875,
0.3497600555419922,
0.2984751760959625,
-0.0530305951833725,
0.7788684964179993,
-0.3553719222545624,
0.5228608250617981,
0.6709721684455872,
0.22146418690681458,
-0.08184780180454254,
-0.48992255330085754,
-0.10732297599315643,
0.0374496653676033,
0.6606203317642212,
-0.054728928953409195,
-0.2694820165634155,
-0.33283257484436035,
-0.1412355601787567,
-0.3304348587989807,
0.4458544850349426,
-0.8164721131324768,
-0.5935840010643005,
0.43705204129219055,
-0.2610678970813751,
-0.1266000121831894,
-0.16561880707740784,
-0.4902132451534271,
-0.39836224913597107,
-0.35529184341430664,
0.6358099579811096,
-0.05673464015126228,
-0.2747959792613983,
-0.1371171623468399,
0.18638671934604645,
0.3038415014743805,
0.4362683892250061,
-1.0840740203857422,
0.36814558506011963,
0.49810099601745605,
0.6967188715934753,
-0.9155147075653076,
-0.010307863354682922,
-0.6783807277679443,
-0.12439633160829544,
-0.3829120993614197,
0.9749928116798401,
-0.09189973771572113,
-0.4645812213420868,
-0.2321508228778839,
-0.03998695686459541,
-0.17090776562690735,
-0.7266018390655518,
0.22226688265800476,
-0.8784590363502502,
0.4273795187473297,
-0.8029568195343018,
-0.5688651204109192,
0.08426371961832047,
0.4246830940246582,
-0.6530079245567322,
0.7189476490020752,
0.21124625205993652,
-0.9072070121765137,
0.12604570388793945,
-0.38189297914505005,
-0.32150837779045105,
0.13348603248596191,
-0.35486018657684326,
-0.207628071308136,
-0.012482291087508202,
0.35144859552383423,
0.49078771471977234,
-0.19914664328098297,
-0.1389034390449524,
-0.17677651345729828,
0.07524078339338303,
0.1873778998851776,
-0.35847124457359314,
0.6633555889129639,
0.3826819062232971,
-0.15139682590961456,
0.002097387332469225,
-0.6495431065559387,
0.23233936727046967,
0.31240010261535645,
-0.5283534526824951,
-0.34529778361320496,
0.2606887221336365,
-0.6372734904289246,
-0.015418876893818378,
0.5101209282875061,
-0.7217432260513306,
0.1364484578371048,
-0.29916876554489136,
0.1236049085855484,
0.9257802367210388,
0.35511016845703125,
0.7512354850769043,
-0.5273817777633667,
0.7124756574630737,
0.3895713984966278,
-0.08596975356340408,
-0.07519432157278061,
-0.0952807292342186,
-0.8273211717605591,
-0.06441063433885574,
0.02597849629819393,
0.358869343996048,
-0.9091498255729675,
0.1456393450498581,
0.13428692519664764,
-0.556568443775177,
-0.5011118054389954,
0.08748085796833038,
0.06848392635583878,
0.6082985401153564,
0.7093273997306824,
-0.1825748234987259,
-0.4032456874847412,
-0.6291775703430176,
0.0003746219736058265,
-0.23672854900360107,
0.39761096239089966,
0.541820764541626,
0.16867761313915253,
-0.03532050549983978,
0.9960927367210388,
-0.723728597164154,
-0.07463796436786652,
-0.30283141136169434,
0.08542168885469437,
-0.05551763251423836,
0.26075872778892517,
0.31834280490875244,
-0.7168946862220764,
-0.4401724338531494,
-0.1188511773943901,
-0.7112864851951599,
-0.07727659493684769,
-0.1922408789396286,
-0.3728424608707428,
0.32281458377838135,
0.39648693799972534,
-0.40929681062698364,
0.059937577694654465,
0.5524185299873352,
-0.05853923410177231,
0.665488600730896,
-0.30633988976478577,
-0.02290887013077736,
-0.9490245580673218,
-0.1662265658378601,
-0.47662946581840515,
-0.04066811874508858,
-0.49818429350852966,
0.06492143124341965,
0.26144930720329285,
0.3652682900428772,
-0.4400354027748108,
0.5029807090759277,
-0.7146527767181396,
-0.04238912835717201,
-0.39823028445243835,
0.08326782286167145,
-0.05972272902727127,
0.5300560593605042,
-0.0093298414722085,
1.0310873985290527,
0.36628538370132446,
-1.0037000179290771,
0.43792569637298584,
0.29446080327033997,
-0.3440619111061096,
0.5410754084587097,
-0.5101276636123657,
0.4636062979698181,
-0.4228287935256958,
-0.0074972533620893955,
-1.1545506715774536,
0.003831111826002598,
0.25247859954833984,
-0.355007529258728,
0.2777813673019409,
-0.02380586974322796,
-0.3472004234790802,
-0.4319261908531189,
0.1454082876443863,
0.8328647613525391,
0.13523656129837036,
-0.9783284068107605,
0.6313849687576294,
0.3404543399810791,
-0.08749933540821075,
-0.6992707252502441,
-0.541832685470581,
-0.5344460606575012,
-0.011370322667062283,
-0.35465091466903687,
0.20444999635219574,
-0.6847924590110779,
-0.1040380671620369,
0.0726289227604866,
-0.5548930764198303,
-0.08424545079469681,
0.14469653367996216,
0.15739788115024567,
0.006408626679331064,
-0.062094930559396744,
0.05753485485911369,
0.24281221628189087,
0.15919212996959686,
0.3925713002681732,
-0.28739237785339355,
0.5316900610923767,
0.22160378098487854,
-0.3982078731060028,
0.062177713960409164,
0.5803104043006897,
0.2549528181552887,
-0.5235548615455627,
0.48166653513908386,
0.23825374245643616,
-0.209572434425354,
-0.5982962250709534,
-0.440060555934906,
-0.02582598105072975,
-0.49574628472328186,
0.07330553233623505,
-0.5198713541030884,
-0.9852721691131592,
0.5602703094482422,
0.19584864377975464,
0.107518769800663,
0.660431444644928,
1.0042316913604736,
-0.3365356922149658,
0.794221043586731,
0.33523818850517273,
0.03888256847858429,
0.1648915708065033,
-0.474526971578598,
0.0050872392021119595,
-0.6616599559783936,
-0.6473632454872131,
-0.4705904424190521,
-0.2636743187904358,
-0.5079638957977295,
-0.5589905381202698,
0.5737679600715637,
-0.2812926173210144,
-0.21103425323963165,
0.3264625072479248,
-0.5323284864425659,
0.37011921405792236,
0.702911376953125,
0.10536316782236099,
0.4173070192337036,
-0.219354048371315,
-0.4241715669631958,
-0.02630368433892727,
-0.7732850909233093,
0.18823036551475525,
1.1684043407440186,
-0.20948195457458496,
0.955065131187439,
0.26133471727371216,
1.0015547275543213,
0.30216264724731445,
0.2291938215494156,
-0.7914618253707886,
0.38990265130996704,
0.12982402741909027,
-0.8279885053634644,
-0.2271120548248291,
-0.7059754729270935,
-1.2524722814559937,
0.39791345596313477,
0.044439688324928284,
-0.03346753492951393,
0.4712485373020172,
-0.049090318381786346,
-0.6317534446716309,
0.38340964913368225,
-0.5412695407867432,
0.641662061214447,
-0.41453805565834045,
-0.09076010435819626,
0.00757944630458951,
-0.6236787438392639,
0.42586252093315125,
-0.2889605760574341,
0.03111724928021431,
0.10996595770120621,
-0.09066833555698395,
0.6190209984779358,
-0.33771175146102905,
0.5156143307685852,
-0.08176151663064957,
-0.3117271065711975,
0.8111940026283264,
0.4472237229347229,
0.4169303774833679,
-0.13718082010746002,
0.1033257246017456,
-0.4279155731201172,
0.42807966470718384,
-0.19456017017364502,
-0.8409054279327393,
0.697873055934906,
-1.081054449081421,
-0.7121362686157227,
-0.6171598434448242,
-0.38677042722702026,
-0.16708910465240479,
0.07285858690738678,
0.34205731749534607,
0.5002411007881165,
-0.18365097045898438,
0.040313512086868286,
0.7459636926651001,
-0.15929976105690002,
0.6312143802642822,
0.7236594557762146,
0.08463791012763977,
-0.5274845957756042,
0.8866956830024719,
0.31800952553749084,
0.577796220779419,
0.5652122497558594,
0.007477581966668367,
-0.6527019143104553,
-0.5333691239356995,
-0.41633468866348267,
0.2049218714237213,
-0.778957188129425,
-0.5248421430587769,
-1.0490132570266724,
-0.4358542859554291,
-0.27703139185905457,
0.23594509065151215,
-0.2759076952934265,
-0.43048810958862305,
-0.8211725354194641,
-0.13275089859962463,
-0.07179758697748184,
0.5437424778938293,
-0.3473132252693176,
0.19758790731430054,
-0.438280314207077,
0.5669220089912415,
0.7854549884796143,
0.10845840722322464,
-0.06495389342308044,
-0.5394052863121033,
-0.22272418439388275,
0.04054904356598854,
-0.5420966148376465,
-0.9517675042152405,
0.3542729318141937,
0.016883190721273422,
0.7915809154510498,
0.0818214863538742,
0.5319716334342957,
0.43848463892936707,
-0.3421102464199066,
0.5230153799057007,
0.04772191122174263,
-0.47553884983062744,
0.3142750859260559,
-0.1372108906507492,
0.34399133920669556,
0.6581167578697205,
0.7209165692329407,
-0.4772045612335205,
-0.11554528027772903,
-0.617583155632019,
-0.5756848454475403,
0.6848838329315186,
0.02667166106402874,
0.16424761712551117,
-0.32144036889076233,
0.2444756031036377,
0.2844845652580261,
0.24524736404418945,
-0.5218972563743591,
-0.6357957720756531,
-0.08426458388566971,
-0.13615866005420685,
0.07971921563148499,
-0.2140911966562271,
-0.1879797875881195,
-0.16053807735443115,
0.3319748640060425,
-0.3946220576763153,
0.6044753789901733,
0.44916898012161255,
-0.1090429499745369,
-0.39115339517593384,
0.21338294446468353,
0.13034889101982117,
0.5367494225502014,
-0.10423380881547928,
0.41448843479156494,
0.10179349035024643,
-0.26517677307128906,
0.38843727111816406,
-0.02181151695549488,
-0.18832136690616608,
-0.563206136226654,
-0.00843619741499424,
0.36278098821640015,
-0.13807463645935059,
-0.53931725025177,
0.5813706517219543,
-0.1231534481048584,
-0.30980098247528076,
-0.4075981080532074,
0.26288753747940063,
-0.0681532621383667,
0.33071431517601013,
0.4911528527736664,
-0.00939834676682949,
0.08532685041427612,
-0.679216742515564,
0.25859808921813965,
0.5226216316223145,
-0.19136108458042145,
-0.149865061044693,
0.7528627514839172,
-0.07462120056152344,
-0.02288006618618965,
0.6336064338684082,
-0.37363678216934204,
-0.40956488251686096,
0.5835025310516357,
0.5085425972938538,
0.7766124606132507,
-0.1815369725227356,
0.4019426703453064,
0.39477434754371643,
0.13748492300510406,
0.17653623223304749,
0.6165265440940857,
-0.3857083022594452,
-1.0306516885757446,
-0.3336433470249176,
-0.47316157817840576,
-0.4665980041027069,
0.0721406564116478,
-0.6805206537246704,
-0.12659168243408203,
-0.644801676273346,
0.13495098054409027,
-0.1347656399011612,
0.3721018135547638,
-0.7304323315620422,
0.4875650405883789,
0.0018087549833580852,
0.6392067670822144,
-0.29366838932037354,
0.45571038126945496,
0.4117615222930908,
-0.4378170669078827,
-0.8203237652778625,
-0.14385060966014862,
-0.205640509724617,
-0.7781075835227966,
0.2830769121646881,
-0.16484148800373077,
0.044504597783088684,
0.2976442277431488,
-0.6557714343070984,
-1.0273394584655762,
1.3462752103805542,
0.01557192299515009,
-0.18438361585140228,
-0.08694702386856079,
-0.004658580292016268,
0.4044378995895386,
-0.49358782172203064,
0.19190911948680878,
0.6272650957107544,
0.18274804949760437,
0.4238533079624176,
-0.4979819357395172,
0.0990726426243782,
-0.05564556270837784,
-0.5520268678665161,
0.06268766522407532,
-0.833310604095459,
0.8825587630271912,
-0.5585934519767761,
-0.5561127066612244,
0.221573606133461,
1.107102632522583,
0.20099668204784393,
0.418878972530365,
0.5650292038917542,
0.4979090392589569,
0.850424587726593,
-0.042069077491760254,
0.8957920074462891,
-0.005916195921599865,
0.05989650636911392,
1.3098188638687134,
0.021134324371814728,
0.7219192385673523,
0.11059795320034027,
-0.29150232672691345,
0.45843055844306946,
0.8282567858695984,
0.09000618755817413,
0.817503035068512,
0.28012093901634216,
-0.5272995233535767,
-0.5093998908996582,
0.12495165318250656,
-0.35571834444999695,
0.48683395981788635,
0.046211324632167816,
-0.05931024253368378,
-0.3673039972782135,
-0.22798103094100952,
-0.21069112420082092,
0.08302023261785507,
-0.2874690592288971,
1.0336968898773193,
0.02872518263757229,
-0.9242455959320068,
0.41165289282798767,
0.0871317908167839,
0.2570697069168091,
-0.42823073267936707,
0.3600153625011444,
-0.6474379897117615,
-0.016471439972519875,
0.04868907481431961,
-0.8395353555679321,
0.1907600313425064,
-0.18663905560970306,
-0.305992990732193,
-0.11752115190029144,
0.47555288672447205,
-0.5740156173706055,
-0.32837677001953125,
0.153050497174263,
0.9293254017829895,
-0.09369412809610367,
-0.2660117447376251,
-0.5221026539802551,
-0.3448531925678253,
-0.18418776988983154,
0.05191010609269142,
0.39990898966789246,
0.6139424443244934,
0.17840668559074402,
0.9293320178985596,
0.5668588280677795,
-0.11397304385900497,
0.5029654502868652,
-0.15311752259731293,
1.0826430320739746,
-0.38423797488212585,
-0.5020908713340759,
-0.5074028968811035,
0.35650014877319336,
0.37363722920417786,
-0.14235784113407135,
0.8170545101165771,
0.761815071105957,
0.889087975025177,
0.21459800004959106,
0.9352030754089355,
-0.1931435614824295,
0.5820013284683228,
-0.3906216025352478,
0.4569355249404907,
-0.8749843835830688,
0.06138757988810539,
0.036012914031744,
-0.6234031319618225,
0.007852992974221706,
0.19052083790302277,
-0.15117457509040833,
0.1174226626753807,
0.8378670811653137,
0.6800762414932251,
0.017127592116594315,
0.0819833055138588,
0.21476295590400696,
0.05012262612581253,
0.3818894326686859,
0.5408494472503662,
1.0914974212646484,
-0.2372063398361206,
0.6015021800994873,
-0.4419829547405243,
0.14977388083934784,
0.13731059432029724,
-0.3648822605609894,
-0.7658138871192932,
-0.8251036405563354,
-0.2784355878829956,
-0.3785002827644348,
-0.3547532260417938,
0.9446213841438293,
0.5171023011207581,
-0.7685285210609436,
-0.040054380893707275,
0.03251345455646515,
0.3247852623462677,
-0.25545209646224976,
-0.12712837755680084,
0.34019628167152405,
-0.582915186882019,
-0.6321951150894165,
0.6489121317863464,
-0.022054795175790787,
0.21486796438694,
-0.44043275713920593,
0.02217404730618,
-0.1205473244190216,
0.21149185299873352,
0.5507076978683472,
0.5237979888916016,
-0.3045148551464081,
-0.06730062514543533,
0.5040843486785889,
-0.17887163162231445,
0.21359460055828094,
1.1006956100463867,
-0.7974638938903809,
0.7791209816932678,
0.47837454080581665,
0.9910218715667725,
0.6027535796165466,
0.4433363676071167,
0.31989118456840515,
-0.7282561659812927,
-0.586786687374115,
0.2844761312007904,
0.05788501724600792,
0.17616136372089386,
-0.4673226773738861,
0.29801779985427856,
0.4546744227409363,
-0.6127407550811768,
-0.47266384959220886,
0.3010774552822113,
-1.2678834199905396,
-0.2601032257080078,
1.1369479894638062,
0.008643792942166328,
-0.12132103741168976,
-0.17870579659938812,
-0.13569171726703644,
0.06950968503952026,
0.024432504549622536,
0.651195764541626,
0.44004854559898376,
-0.29625701904296875,
-0.3014354705810547,
-0.11621492356061935,
0.508602499961853,
0.28747013211250305,
-0.978973925113678,
0.0511859729886055,
0.6641350388526917,
0.49608033895492554,
-0.18019983172416687,
0.9764123558998108,
0.02949288673698902,
0.08715728670358658,
-0.2882665991783142,
-0.3172895908355713,
-0.05234378203749657,
-0.6683274507522583,
-0.07872430235147476,
0.45868346095085144,
-0.11818050593137741,
-0.2898639440536499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13512v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13512v1
|
From Self-Attention to Markov Models: Unveiling the Dynamics of Generative Transformers
| 2024-02-21T03:51:34 | 2024-02-21T03:51:34 |
M. Emrullah Ildiz, Yixiao Huang, Yingcong Li, Ankit Singh Rawat, Samet Oymak
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Modern language models rely on the transformer architecture and attention
mechanism to perform language understanding and text generation. In this work,
we study learning a 1-layer self-attention model from a set of prompts and
associated output data sampled from the model. We first establish a precise
mapping between the self-attention mechanism and Markov models: Inputting a
prompt to the model samples the output token according to a context-conditioned
Markov chain (CCMC) which weights the transition matrix of a base Markov chain.
Additionally, incorporating positional encoding results in position-dependent
scaling of the transition probabilities. Building on this formalism, we develop
identifiability/coverage conditions for the prompt distribution that guarantee
consistent estimation and establish sample complexity guarantees under IID
samples. Finally, we study the problem of learning from a single output
trajectory generated from an initial prompt. We characterize an intriguing
winner-takes-all phenomenon where the generative process implemented by
self-attention collapses into sampling a limited subset of tokens due to its
non-mixing nature. This provides a mathematical explanation to the tendency of
modern LLMs to generate repetitive text. In summary, the equivalence to CCMC
provides a simple but powerful framework to study self-attention and its
properties.
|
[
-0.25539588928222656,
-0.7592574954032898,
0.6759983897209167,
0.32556742429733276,
-0.004753889981657267,
-0.15371869504451752,
0.0005901846452616155,
0.18963539600372314,
-0.0974385067820549,
0.5965127944946289,
-1.0193318128585815,
-0.3687669038772583,
-0.4925435185432434,
0.03237225115299225,
-0.6389884948730469,
1.149680495262146,
0.07363634556531906,
-0.30295923352241516,
-0.21534590423107147,
0.09472324699163437,
-0.29750826954841614,
-0.48897066712379456,
-0.5421817898750305,
-0.26733601093292236,
0.6834359169006348,
0.3375187814235687,
0.18063952028751373,
0.7567875385284424,
0.2383185625076294,
0.2625661790370941,
0.11339647322893143,
-0.2796221971511841,
-0.6510776877403259,
0.48506349325180054,
-0.3397248387336731,
-0.6104068756103516,
0.1932171732187271,
0.20838697254657745,
0.6957573890686035,
0.5893085598945618,
-0.11947530508041382,
0.20589372515678406,
0.3676198124885559,
0.5841301679611206,
-0.49124646186828613,
0.18703243136405945,
-0.6972745060920715,
0.202425017952919,
-0.16609464585781097,
-0.5162857174873352,
-0.6776804327964783,
0.0640789121389389,
0.10311056673526764,
-0.3176603615283966,
0.5027778148651123,
-0.13917042315006256,
0.3753008544445038,
0.5185160636901855,
-0.4836404621601105,
-0.3577888309955597,
-0.7874768972396851,
0.6867190599441528,
-0.23198425769805908,
0.05446042865514755,
0.09010233730077744,
0.30588996410369873,
-0.19180794060230255,
-0.7467844486236572,
-0.4767899215221405,
-0.153402179479599,
0.05589503049850464,
0.36816027760505676,
-0.23554274439811707,
-0.04038441181182861,
0.17326873540878296,
0.33327165246009827,
-0.35059598088264465,
0.11240184307098389,
-0.2723420560359955,
-0.024249069392681122,
0.15647320449352264,
0.3269038200378418,
0.30810824036598206,
-0.32991868257522583,
-0.6638301014900208,
-0.19664107263088226,
-0.5049319863319397,
0.1427338570356369,
0.23882454633712769,
0.34390151500701904,
-0.26878294348716736,
0.46721795201301575,
0.06390423327684402,
0.5801352858543396,
0.4694066345691681,
-0.025864964351058006,
-0.14845265448093414,
-0.29036781191825867,
-0.3215290606021881,
-0.07921062409877777,
1.0211129188537598,
-0.2700594663619995,
0.2779306173324585,
-0.2194427102804184,
-0.03862788900732994,
-0.12149211764335632,
0.5345121026039124,
-0.45216959714889526,
-0.21576344966888428,
0.21394820511341095,
-0.4446750581264496,
-0.38674482703208923,
-0.10013644397258759,
-0.5941925644874573,
-0.02580270916223526,
-0.24411383271217346,
0.5437330007553101,
-0.2744007110595703,
-0.11905626952648163,
-0.04811496660113335,
0.2921953797340393,
0.2105114609003067,
0.0438329242169857,
-1.1612406969070435,
0.16557279229164124,
0.2770330309867859,
0.7625423073768616,
-0.49902069568634033,
-0.38440605998039246,
-0.49276360869407654,
0.08665966242551804,
-0.36203938722610474,
0.6928255558013916,
-0.18172165751457214,
-0.29876622557640076,
-0.07588160037994385,
-0.11592493951320648,
-0.37731799483299255,
-0.34715238213539124,
0.24599337577819824,
-0.5377655029296875,
0.3766113519668579,
0.19154131412506104,
-0.41787347197532654,
0.08378242701292038,
0.12885458767414093,
-0.5969680547714233,
1.038604736328125,
0.14795486629009247,
-0.9222939014434814,
0.07553520053625107,
-0.4866931140422821,
-0.507096529006958,
0.04288400709629059,
-0.2572796642780304,
-0.4008837044239044,
0.20316940546035767,
0.05746738985180855,
0.5630483627319336,
-0.23773770034313202,
0.20372773706912994,
-0.050126925110816956,
0.06439021974802017,
0.40018120408058167,
-0.7179046273231506,
0.7292180061340332,
0.36206990480422974,
-0.33949145674705505,
0.18585483729839325,
-0.8493537902832031,
-0.15693852305412292,
0.2544095814228058,
-0.5261621475219727,
0.15099439024925232,
-0.045049648731946945,
-0.15722933411598206,
0.3606549799442291,
0.1066763699054718,
-0.19646337628364563,
0.2953748404979706,
-0.33955997228622437,
0.3542991280555725,
0.6758549213409424,
0.3774762749671936,
0.5642979741096497,
0.027884308248758316,
0.7522073984146118,
0.4617888629436493,
-0.03823615983128548,
-0.9347667694091797,
-0.20368677377700806,
-0.8389132618904114,
-0.10985055565834045,
0.1546006053686142,
0.3676336705684662,
-0.717532217502594,
0.3437696695327759,
0.02084474265575409,
-0.15422770380973816,
-0.4856365919113159,
0.08167579770088196,
0.27444934844970703,
0.655915379524231,
0.18381871283054352,
-0.18111766874790192,
-0.2535949945449829,
-0.9358616471290588,
-0.22472332417964935,
-0.10567047446966171,
-0.23485180735588074,
0.1441224217414856,
0.18357416987419128,
-0.13047415018081665,
1.032697081565857,
-0.23459602892398834,
-0.33906662464141846,
-0.5581477880477905,
0.28697893023490906,
0.39986780285835266,
0.481138676404953,
0.27528396248817444,
-0.2906881272792816,
-0.18572378158569336,
-0.2889896631240845,
-0.6296759843826294,
-0.09659729897975922,
-0.6539146304130554,
-0.1024581789970398,
0.06177644059062004,
0.633397102355957,
-0.520575225353241,
0.3026726245880127,
0.31246310472488403,
-0.24299310147762299,
0.36962077021598816,
-0.42790570855140686,
-0.0960216075181961,
-1.17030930519104,
-0.0303169097751379,
0.07109817117452621,
-0.3050117492675781,
-0.6707652807235718,
0.10558097809553146,
0.16621434688568115,
0.005545435007661581,
-0.41044309735298157,
0.3780857026576996,
-0.6099039316177368,
-0.08772193640470505,
-0.4029788374900818,
0.2477683424949646,
-0.18400464951992035,
0.7403819561004639,
-0.19461174309253693,
0.6934700012207031,
0.6953070163726807,
-0.87205570936203,
0.06864744424819946,
0.04965462535619736,
-0.3644840717315674,
0.279215544462204,
-0.6026511788368225,
0.08405715227127075,
-0.6330401301383972,
0.0727933943271637,
-1.4017571210861206,
0.013957181945443153,
0.3584323823451996,
-0.42297694087028503,
0.4589504599571228,
-0.13908211886882782,
-0.4585667550563812,
-0.23392605781555176,
0.19861625134944916,
0.45795437693595886,
0.5076373815536499,
-0.6823332905769348,
0.5487478375434875,
0.23985597491264343,
0.008443694561719894,
-0.4006648361682892,
-0.534970760345459,
-0.08553878217935562,
-0.07868055999279022,
-0.2031538337469101,
-0.03511492535471916,
-0.12295696139335632,
0.045508310198783875,
-0.2656070590019226,
-0.02299247868359089,
0.19977045059204102,
0.3026450276374817,
0.24008867144584656,
-0.06470480561256409,
-0.07004836946725845,
0.30040618777275085,
0.06521648913621902,
-0.2963452935218811,
0.4071342349052429,
-0.5258866548538208,
0.6728842854499817,
0.4086127281188965,
-0.36909639835357666,
-0.5774314999580383,
0.30221280455589294,
0.5557446479797363,
-0.22252097725868225,
0.6942886710166931,
0.35325729846954346,
-0.09902887046337128,
-0.5313867926597595,
-0.1013735830783844,
-0.340556263923645,
-0.42700353264808655,
0.25895026326179504,
-0.6955966949462891,
-0.6582973003387451,
0.5132135152816772,
0.00914094503968954,
-0.1260649412870407,
0.8056477308273315,
0.9284759163856506,
-0.23624801635742188,
0.930791974067688,
0.6002761721611023,
-0.059437040239572525,
0.4661044478416443,
-0.3540448248386383,
0.09923738986253738,
-0.7032497525215149,
-0.32314473390579224,
-0.3388840854167938,
-0.3045444190502167,
-0.5281410813331604,
-0.35696637630462646,
0.47568199038505554,
0.10120003670454025,
-0.03359592705965042,
0.23153002560138702,
-0.430502712726593,
0.48709723353385925,
0.6722766160964966,
0.004463210701942444,
0.10860548913478851,
-0.0004454424779396504,
-0.4590909779071808,
-0.1494796723127365,
-0.8960074186325073,
-0.2738148272037506,
0.9654562473297119,
0.4402282238006592,
1.0130895376205444,
-0.03591953217983246,
0.6540679335594177,
0.343767911195755,
0.1545792669057846,
-0.613922655582428,
0.3515321910381317,
0.21650008857250214,
-0.4556206166744232,
-0.28651830554008484,
-0.3688288629055023,
-1.134688377380371,
0.23724009096622467,
0.086234450340271,
-0.6849374175071716,
0.06667695939540863,
0.26950591802597046,
-0.25994470715522766,
0.12991555035114288,
-0.4948011040687561,
1.0078911781311035,
-0.0951666608452797,
-0.3898361921310425,
-0.09750591963529587,
-0.8143860697746277,
0.45849043130874634,
0.07286738604307175,
0.06952918320894241,
0.014351061545312405,
0.18740059435367584,
0.33606213331222534,
0.09004154056310654,
1.0308785438537598,
0.12229575216770172,
-0.4076535105705261,
0.3576963245868683,
0.3476826846599579,
0.41354772448539734,
0.05656959488987923,
0.4034472405910492,
-0.232641339302063,
-0.29843053221702576,
-0.3133173882961273,
-0.6319695115089417,
0.5502196550369263,
-0.8306040167808533,
-0.6610318422317505,
-0.22796587646007538,
-0.4914255142211914,
0.13404710590839386,
-0.019990066066384315,
0.5615577697753906,
0.5924479365348816,
-0.19423207640647888,
-0.09309329092502594,
0.8497067093849182,
-0.021906230598688126,
0.5491904020309448,
0.24815621972084045,
-0.2937398850917816,
-0.08491627126932144,
0.7835807204246521,
-0.010649469681084156,
0.48330265283584595,
0.5842825174331665,
0.035492464900016785,
-0.41829147934913635,
-0.15943139791488647,
-0.49328452348709106,
0.18245422840118408,
-0.9381278157234192,
-0.041121356189250946,
-1.0130341053009033,
-0.4010530412197113,
-0.3520224392414093,
0.2925914227962494,
-0.2851501405239105,
-0.366644948720932,
-0.6961926221847534,
-0.07382906973361969,
-0.05759183317422867,
0.9789425134658813,
-0.051900673657655716,
0.3151019215583801,
-0.5516726970672607,
0.35489892959594727,
0.4431540369987488,
0.11341280490159988,
0.28459230065345764,
-0.7552967071533203,
-0.25389721989631653,
-0.352055162191391,
-0.5548045039176941,
-1.1367794275283813,
0.467972069978714,
0.1317196935415268,
0.6722800135612488,
0.6337584853172302,
0.00731994304805994,
0.016053909435868263,
-0.6425307393074036,
0.6801050305366516,
0.16006702184677124,
-0.9073296785354614,
0.621479332447052,
-0.41470831632614136,
0.7676529884338379,
0.30714136362075806,
0.3603595793247223,
-0.5603620409965515,
-0.514971137046814,
-0.6275131106376648,
-0.687565267086029,
0.8323618173599243,
0.3170747756958008,
0.13829953968524933,
-0.3763551414012909,
0.6028479337692261,
0.1516546607017517,
0.09793394804000854,
-0.9110243916511536,
-0.5377296209335327,
-0.2661251127719879,
-0.5047023296356201,
-0.19839565455913544,
-0.3587949573993683,
0.1013331338763237,
0.18078063428401947,
0.42610007524490356,
-0.2807352840900421,
0.29231706261634827,
0.3147169351577759,
-0.26180794835090637,
-0.009252660907804966,
0.33670738339424133,
0.604849636554718,
0.3852585256099701,
0.2679183781147003,
0.5096921324729919,
-0.16539305448532104,
-0.12454435229301453,
0.3015138506889343,
-0.2972768247127533,
-0.29149025678634644,
-0.21979044377803802,
0.22031091153621674,
0.8833538293838501,
0.4239123463630676,
-0.3230646848678589,
0.40180790424346924,
-0.05158817768096924,
-0.014455024152994156,
-0.09157661348581314,
0.14661240577697754,
0.07671287655830383,
0.17449051141738892,
0.5758615732192993,
-0.1584847867488861,
0.32006558775901794,
-0.5721383690834045,
0.3041574954986572,
0.4361780285835266,
-0.6097326278686523,
-0.4854436218738556,
0.9514561295509338,
-0.05830274894833565,
-0.4430573880672455,
0.42248624563217163,
-0.17969748377799988,
-0.48710426688194275,
0.6750524044036865,
0.9415438175201416,
0.9368035793304443,
-0.402687668800354,
0.3501439392566681,
0.4938249886035919,
0.25915607810020447,
0.09834002703428268,
0.028645558282732964,
-0.5670602917671204,
-0.6382361650466919,
-0.31143540143966675,
-0.514451265335083,
-0.13273601233959198,
0.007202297914773226,
-0.679690420627594,
-0.008514370769262314,
-0.3719775080680847,
-0.03407894819974899,
-0.1858944147825241,
-0.5147265195846558,
-0.6491720080375671,
0.24114054441452026,
0.06998179107904434,
0.4782164692878723,
-0.7434812784194946,
0.6939438581466675,
0.32388734817504883,
-0.29958730936050415,
-0.4511593282222748,
0.25267842411994934,
-0.18210196495056152,
-0.9150001406669617,
0.7975713014602661,
0.34093812108039856,
-0.14238783717155457,
0.5347288250923157,
-0.69329434633255,
-1.0326088666915894,
0.7737976908683777,
0.2830321192741394,
-0.4626682996749878,
0.07412152737379074,
0.09718646109104156,
0.4781680703163147,
-0.505172848701477,
0.2812390625476837,
0.6082119941711426,
0.023122593760490417,
0.07837226241827011,
-0.3103477358818054,
-0.18793229758739471,
-0.02295917272567749,
0.05312817543745041,
0.20691348612308502,
-0.5134313106536865,
0.8238016963005066,
-0.4616915285587311,
-0.7543728947639465,
0.018482360988855362,
0.8996942043304443,
0.25655388832092285,
-0.11216126382350922,
0.2962677478790283,
0.4804426431655884,
0.22959420084953308,
0.00953283254057169,
1.1826844215393066,
-0.485662043094635,
0.5712827444076538,
1.1062581539154053,
0.18780997395515442,
0.5317058563232422,
0.5029138326644897,
-0.2254953533411026,
0.5568721294403076,
0.589836835861206,
0.21158522367477417,
0.6917408108711243,
0.4693029820919037,
-0.14776277542114258,
-0.368807315826416,
0.09104089438915253,
0.08376354724168777,
0.23815366625785828,
0.11519352346658707,
-0.5630542635917664,
-0.3122200667858124,
0.18280179798603058,
-0.3826873302459717,
0.09089364111423492,
-0.18353529274463654,
1.0612616539001465,
0.00937628373503685,
-0.7830586433410645,
0.3381369411945343,
-0.1918497532606125,
0.370130717754364,
-0.40814653038978577,
0.13363198935985565,
-0.27620193362236023,
0.16182127594947815,
0.29250773787498474,
-0.6943339705467224,
-0.09106087684631348,
-0.22613559663295746,
-0.5298710465431213,
-0.27326342463493347,
0.3365154564380646,
-0.7395855188369751,
-0.45715370774269104,
0.17093989253044128,
0.42962706089019775,
0.2527007460594177,
0.043612945824861526,
-0.41528892517089844,
-0.1057332456111908,
-0.021557319909334183,
-0.38911330699920654,
0.3143293857574463,
0.5247884392738342,
0.41243284940719604,
0.8231557607650757,
0.36643052101135254,
-0.208522766828537,
0.47501784563064575,
0.16709432005882263,
0.48576855659484863,
-0.6140324473381042,
-0.6538541913032532,
-0.9984930753707886,
0.5369833707809448,
0.32209768891334534,
-0.32878056168556213,
0.6767358779907227,
0.2559038996696472,
0.592957615852356,
-0.2208470106124878,
0.6750839352607727,
0.42131370306015015,
0.37965765595436096,
-0.6201701760292053,
0.602784276008606,
-0.4233153760433197,
0.11222901195287704,
0.13992880284786224,
-0.7229712009429932,
-0.03765135258436203,
0.40286633372306824,
0.12289246171712875,
0.07048779726028442,
0.6238085627555847,
0.31120312213897705,
-0.01770913414657116,
-0.392328143119812,
0.479524165391922,
0.33291199803352356,
0.22031526267528534,
0.5349390506744385,
0.7444278597831726,
-0.3778490126132965,
0.36721232533454895,
0.012901781126856804,
-0.10319405049085617,
-0.02769344300031662,
-0.670261025428772,
-0.9369250535964966,
-0.9096997976303101,
-0.17226767539978027,
-0.26748862862586975,
-0.2430855631828308,
0.7859532237052917,
0.48564499616622925,
-0.6602768301963806,
-0.17950506508350372,
-0.35518303513526917,
0.17743800580501556,
-0.04308713227510452,
-0.33143433928489685,
0.26102277636528015,
-0.9072656631469727,
-0.7973935008049011,
0.4211280345916748,
0.5817044377326965,
0.35392317175865173,
-0.7676045298576355,
0.24229562282562256,
0.05425269156694412,
0.2165287882089615,
0.4312480092048645,
0.2530214786529541,
-0.8182733058929443,
0.0039245751686394215,
0.08209950476884842,
-0.31549516320228577,
0.30773046612739563,
1.0111925601959229,
-1.0253983736038208,
0.5361678600311279,
0.31136131286621094,
0.7729055881500244,
0.6086122989654541,
-0.08986815810203552,
0.6270493268966675,
-0.9578198194503784,
-0.09000420570373535,
-0.1739216446876526,
0.23176686465740204,
0.2184019237756729,
-0.403177410364151,
0.21382498741149902,
0.1510775238275528,
-0.5388566851615906,
-0.4675697684288025,
0.5058987736701965,
-0.7962871193885803,
-0.14844445884227753,
0.9394068121910095,
0.0015638803597539663,
-0.4659857451915741,
0.11980762332677841,
-0.09500647336244583,
0.41065284609794617,
-0.15418174862861633,
0.9413928985595703,
0.5432445406913757,
-0.05821089819073677,
-0.5843748450279236,
-0.17419196665287018,
0.413520485162735,
0.49324509501457214,
-0.8242164850234985,
0.21409164369106293,
0.23368512094020844,
0.29172301292419434,
0.1898670345544815,
0.5585100650787354,
0.12230469286441803,
0.1482536643743515,
-0.24233104288578033,
0.17756374180316925,
0.3794173300266266,
-0.6217374205589294,
-0.7499884963035583,
0.45166251063346863,
-0.1906779557466507,
-0.2843867242336273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14863v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14863v1
|
Evaluation of a semi-autonomous attentive listening system with takeover prompting
| 2024-02-21T03:43:57 | 2024-02-21T03:43:57 |
Haruki Kawai, Divesh Lala, Koji Inoue, Keiko Ochi, Tatsuya Kawahara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The handling of communication breakdowns and loss of engagement is an
important aspect of spoken dialogue systems, particularly for chatting systems
such as attentive listening, where the user is mostly speaking. We presume that
a human is best equipped to handle this task and rescue the flow of
conversation. To this end, we propose a semi-autonomous system, where a remote
operator can take control of an autonomous attentive listening system in
real-time. In order to make human intervention easy and consistent, we
introduce automatic detection of low interest and engagement to provide
explicit takeover prompts to the remote operator. We implement this
semi-autonomous system which detects takeover points for the operator and
compare it to fully tele-operated and fully autonomous attentive listening
systems. We find that the semi-autonomous system is generally perceived more
positively than the autonomous system. The results suggest that identifying
points of conversation when the user starts to lose interest may help us
improve a fully autonomous dialogue system.
|
[
-0.295378714799881,
-0.7457113265991211,
0.7766205668449402,
0.17834413051605225,
-0.08804035186767578,
0.4459483027458191,
-0.07533016800880432,
-0.6159260869026184,
0.5272035002708435,
0.1746259480714798,
-0.7796351313591003,
-0.1566602885723114,
-0.43354201316833496,
0.15054744482040405,
-0.5935999751091003,
0.3995403051376343,
0.1650334894657135,
-0.21408237516880035,
0.10386309772729874,
-0.18495729565620422,
-0.8630306124687195,
-0.14791810512542725,
-1.0989235639572144,
-0.45160967111587524,
0.19144602119922638,
0.5411294102668762,
0.803137481212616,
0.30675631761550903,
-0.014071892946958542,
0.4069114625453949,
-0.21290217339992523,
-0.024695497006177902,
-0.3799138367176056,
0.2108849734067917,
-0.08063551038503647,
-0.3357188403606415,
-0.32173100113868713,
0.05276571959257126,
0.34024280309677124,
0.3813321888446808,
-0.5628565549850464,
-0.08678556233644485,
-0.0916929692029953,
0.3115796744823456,
-0.5199558138847351,
0.05609569326043129,
-0.24547164142131805,
0.27337971329689026,
0.13216839730739594,
-0.5141682028770447,
-0.37911778688430786,
-0.3765900135040283,
0.49654173851013184,
-0.802943766117096,
-0.40077832341194153,
-0.02865436114370823,
0.4390767216682434,
0.4609037935733795,
-0.3806380033493042,
-0.18491299450397491,
-1.1278355121612549,
0.768584132194519,
-0.39101049304008484,
0.2525685429573059,
0.6222339272499084,
0.3840729594230652,
-0.05205051973462105,
-0.030908532440662384,
-0.5459801554679871,
-0.273955762386322,
-0.04938103258609772,
0.4288613200187683,
-0.786043107509613,
0.2948949933052063,
-0.1952422708272934,
0.4823758602142334,
-0.20938865840435028,
0.17798854410648346,
-0.21094827353954315,
-0.5796266794204712,
0.34644824266433716,
0.29298996925354004,
0.3835739493370056,
-0.4540615379810333,
-0.3700607120990753,
0.08654676377773285,
-0.44992321729660034,
0.31444987654685974,
0.3733677864074707,
0.07553144544363022,
-0.08932428807020187,
0.5018033981323242,
-0.43833884596824646,
0.640921950340271,
0.36767756938934326,
0.14716611802577972,
-0.07930222153663635,
-0.5120565891265869,
-0.36951175332069397,
0.3959484100341797,
0.9996617436408997,
0.5880172252655029,
0.27363842725753784,
0.05870187655091286,
-0.6620475649833679,
0.1192408874630928,
0.4773889183998108,
0.124001145362854,
-0.27261045575141907,
0.4118129312992096,
-0.4263627529144287,
-0.6186965107917786,
-0.18429532647132874,
-0.12209910154342651,
-0.2164941281080246,
-0.35910308361053467,
0.5666399002075195,
-0.40395811200141907,
-0.38093534111976624,
0.14870312809944153,
-0.13135077059268951,
0.2191047966480255,
0.4880219101905823,
-0.5969275832176208,
0.26033347845077515,
0.2627210319042206,
1.0989389419555664,
-0.18675684928894043,
0.019444739446043968,
-0.6193878650665283,
0.15995997190475464,
-0.3282663822174072,
0.7927305698394775,
-0.30810171365737915,
-0.9221725463867188,
0.06615451723337173,
-0.11633341014385223,
-0.003847686108201742,
-0.8425898551940918,
0.5087863206863403,
-0.594798743724823,
0.6516322493553162,
-0.11870818585157394,
-0.22217313945293427,
0.011346407234668732,
0.3653443157672882,
-0.23221465945243835,
0.5952287316322327,
0.026129156351089478,
-0.3350551426410675,
0.31847578287124634,
-1.2196205854415894,
-0.555355429649353,
0.3398764729499817,
-0.08418034762144089,
-0.19056999683380127,
-0.052928339689970016,
0.1632632166147232,
0.24043308198451996,
0.2456030398607254,
-0.038879282772541046,
-0.09715432673692703,
-0.2669518291950226,
0.0158575177192688,
-0.3427816331386566,
0.7023947238922119,
0.05530640482902527,
-0.2978772521018982,
0.513294517993927,
-0.3177332878112793,
-0.051306139677762985,
-0.07121451944112778,
-0.18640068173408508,
-0.3836316168308258,
0.31013408303260803,
-0.19364844262599945,
-0.10046014189720154,
0.08210808038711548,
-0.5159833431243896,
-0.07251853495836258,
-0.4154167175292969,
0.26061415672302246,
0.9874590039253235,
0.5472148656845093,
0.8350626826286316,
-0.32806500792503357,
0.7360950708389282,
0.02152649685740471,
0.5309032797813416,
-0.17569248378276825,
-0.1735832691192627,
-0.7087691426277161,
-0.6748067736625671,
-0.17766223847866058,
0.874347984790802,
-0.7676645517349243,
0.7431567311286926,
-0.00025225375429727137,
-0.0988517552614212,
-0.540102481842041,
-0.04669057950377464,
0.5634092688560486,
0.31791698932647705,
0.16278138756752014,
-0.14201316237449646,
-0.34927916526794434,
-0.9649757742881775,
0.12998175621032715,
-0.3300992250442505,
-0.4723493158817291,
0.548530101776123,
-0.12685956060886383,
-0.17418791353702545,
0.9295384883880615,
-0.23542740941047668,
-0.7048619389533997,
-0.2716886103153229,
0.3169739544391632,
-0.05175285413861275,
0.12596379220485687,
0.20323990285396576,
-0.6551852226257324,
-0.7264381051063538,
0.16629236936569214,
-1.1077370643615723,
-0.1387578547000885,
-0.27169203758239746,
-0.006996521260589361,
0.0247665848582983,
0.5337716341018677,
-0.5295883417129517,
0.628986656665802,
0.29643696546554565,
-0.07321076095104218,
0.44906750321388245,
-0.13847514986991882,
0.35231414437294006,
-0.8472910523414612,
0.03275268152356148,
-0.25798940658569336,
-0.5420917868614197,
-0.6063697934150696,
-0.7662689089775085,
-0.30571249127388,
-0.24154432117938995,
-0.4880346357822418,
-0.0681939497590065,
-0.6468949913978577,
-0.0979095846414566,
-0.4819622039794922,
0.3167738616466522,
-0.37485843896865845,
0.27344778180122375,
0.20958520472049713,
0.9314537048339844,
0.6164111495018005,
-0.7893755435943604,
0.7882837057113647,
0.6775100827217102,
-0.43214207887649536,
0.46008428931236267,
-0.8254424929618835,
-0.08668141812086105,
0.1547749787569046,
0.4827556312084198,
-0.9705263376235962,
-0.35102370381355286,
0.2462165802717209,
-0.48230546712875366,
-0.07817468047142029,
-0.11388909071683884,
-0.06582779437303543,
-0.08474017679691315,
-0.3457811772823334,
0.13742601871490479,
0.2219264805316925,
-0.34042462706565857,
0.4226474463939667,
0.46534883975982666,
-0.417003870010376,
-0.29754865169525146,
-0.12519948184490204,
0.3533366620540619,
-0.26811614632606506,
-0.41816073656082153,
0.013143629767000675,
0.307939350605011,
-0.2720888555049896,
-0.03857192397117615,
-0.05605275183916092,
0.5672423839569092,
0.21114788949489594,
0.2882801592350006,
0.4121837019920349,
0.1722739189863205,
-0.15157364308834076,
0.22078850865364075,
-0.5282377600669861,
0.2715981602668762,
-0.25807562470436096,
0.37081798911094666,
0.10941536724567413,
-0.4087797999382019,
-1.457718014717102,
0.5596738457679749,
0.8960850834846497,
-0.15345656871795654,
0.18399874866008759,
-0.19554947316646576,
-0.14569486677646637,
0.05417117848992348,
-0.2385672926902771,
-0.6302430629730225,
-0.5394430756568909,
-0.08320353180170059,
-0.026479145511984825,
-0.5990438461303711,
0.7423259019851685,
0.014674385078251362,
0.0010397839359939098,
0.10952909290790558,
0.6680983304977417,
-0.46095338463783264,
0.8545321226119995,
0.843358039855957,
-0.37762993574142456,
0.9586421251296997,
-0.24940913915634155,
0.14078858494758606,
-0.475108802318573,
-0.26811274886131287,
-0.2640748620033264,
-0.4012170732021332,
-0.3075246214866638,
0.062193308025598526,
0.8102790117263794,
-0.5914666652679443,
0.16845376789569855,
0.5214847326278687,
-0.48978957533836365,
0.49671173095703125,
0.5157685875892639,
0.06038941815495491,
0.45353570580482483,
-0.4122016727924347,
0.12238576263189316,
0.21457995474338531,
-0.43283209204673767,
-0.5040077567100525,
0.42283663153648376,
0.3057650923728943,
1.0662888288497925,
0.3384166955947876,
0.6295523047447205,
1.002962350845337,
-0.09598388522863388,
-1.2469799518585205,
0.5447882413864136,
0.6936414241790771,
-0.5977513790130615,
-0.8045355677604675,
-0.28407958149909973,
-0.8512909412384033,
-0.24635662138462067,
-0.13964903354644775,
-1.11112642288208,
0.5998903512954712,
0.2627296447753906,
-0.9398842453956604,
-0.00924494955688715,
-0.900057315826416,
0.6156387329101562,
0.0661328062415123,
0.012590879574418068,
-0.3985438346862793,
-0.6774926781654358,
0.2780691981315613,
-0.02674713172018528,
0.012640400789678097,
-0.04330584779381752,
0.1304875612258911,
0.8440113663673401,
-0.1196582168340683,
0.9080075025558472,
-0.6387084126472473,
-0.29823291301727295,
0.4012855589389801,
0.5832058191299438,
0.5837874412536621,
0.22761276364326477,
0.2011767029762268,
-0.3649505376815796,
-0.1803915947675705,
-0.18396760523319244,
-0.579143762588501,
0.4010528326034546,
-0.7980033755302429,
-0.42541036009788513,
-0.33074527978897095,
-0.09546345472335815,
-0.21607080101966858,
0.06447752565145493,
0.39665645360946655,
0.30668723583221436,
-0.4274279773235321,
0.18043720722198486,
0.6902261972427368,
-0.12344077229499817,
0.6202066540718079,
0.3761443793773651,
-0.26110437512397766,
-0.23915448784828186,
0.6937315464019775,
-0.31529441475868225,
0.6657885313034058,
0.4011761248111725,
0.07380586117506027,
-0.663896381855011,
-0.3486339747905731,
-0.5588827133178711,
-0.2258855551481247,
-0.1480819433927536,
-0.4258922338485718,
-0.79860919713974,
0.12033060193061829,
0.10035154968500137,
-0.41965219378471375,
-0.5946621298789978,
-0.21013027429580688,
-0.2678223252296448,
-0.19471308588981628,
-0.0077675580978393555,
0.7539311051368713,
-0.26527729630470276,
0.6274026036262512,
-0.7039591670036316,
0.24256569147109985,
0.5341044068336487,
-0.010952221229672432,
-0.11745208501815796,
-0.8034858107566833,
-0.2511613368988037,
0.12994889914989471,
-0.4663071632385254,
-0.8120988607406616,
0.30605265498161316,
0.2815917134284973,
0.6134189963340759,
0.828994631767273,
0.503812849521637,
0.2730344533920288,
-0.14840534329414368,
0.6918845772743225,
0.37535369396209717,
-1.0789506435394287,
0.7240889072418213,
-0.6647816300392151,
0.5005471706390381,
0.6100754141807556,
0.3919495940208435,
-0.7906460165977478,
-0.7675251364707947,
-0.5641266107559204,
-0.5297781229019165,
1.0325891971588135,
0.13520385324954987,
0.08363575488328934,
0.3506082594394684,
-0.19689077138900757,
-0.30767497420310974,
0.1152973473072052,
-0.273906946182251,
-0.24066880345344543,
-0.1395578533411026,
0.2134668231010437,
-0.0849047303199768,
-0.1706407517194748,
-0.4227617383003235,
-0.04291604459285736,
0.5991485714912415,
-0.1185869574546814,
0.7161559462547302,
0.1963784545660019,
0.0004034196899738163,
-0.5854086875915527,
0.3066641688346863,
0.5591071248054504,
0.3264314532279968,
-0.23885443806648254,
-0.15996786952018738,
0.31513768434524536,
-0.06661581993103027,
0.4431893825531006,
-0.3615683913230896,
-0.12799914181232452,
-0.17179763317108154,
0.29532739520072937,
0.5633711814880371,
0.41657981276512146,
-0.5070403218269348,
0.7378259897232056,
-0.2042507529258728,
-0.10181397199630737,
-0.31117844581604004,
-0.10834123194217682,
-0.03601532429456711,
0.24296605587005615,
0.5984898209571838,
0.23688611388206482,
0.47930797934532166,
-0.8518836498260498,
0.3233347535133362,
0.4229743778705597,
-0.5591180324554443,
-0.32546111941337585,
0.3804051876068115,
0.562847912311554,
-0.5002902150154114,
0.5772433876991272,
-0.14792121946811676,
-0.8529152274131775,
0.0555473268032074,
0.2146998643875122,
0.9599747061729431,
-0.398128479719162,
0.3730184733867645,
-0.173309788107872,
0.05507733300328255,
0.4278045892715454,
0.08606620877981186,
-0.7336577773094177,
-0.8164759278297424,
-0.5294041037559509,
-0.09701351821422577,
-0.7187140583992004,
-0.1998826265335083,
-0.9192802309989929,
0.07099638879299164,
-0.4853777289390564,
-0.2786884903907776,
0.3587977886199951,
-0.2634444236755371,
0.14819589257240295,
0.11896363645792007,
0.1568828672170639,
0.6874582767486572,
-0.9354370832443237,
0.37860217690467834,
0.6705062389373779,
0.04501808062195778,
-0.5527877807617188,
0.08321114629507065,
0.2578720450401306,
-0.7869940996170044,
0.2082943618297577,
-0.16488423943519592,
-0.7230569124221802,
-0.12792523205280304,
-0.5074844360351562,
-0.2412242889404297,
0.8514567613601685,
0.11464603245258331,
-0.16150259971618652,
0.21138526499271393,
-0.4127947986125946,
0.4959687888622284,
0.0952969565987587,
0.26134106516838074,
0.441723495721817,
0.36367499828338623,
0.32476338744163513,
-1.5006237030029297,
-0.2940208613872528,
0.002266188384965062,
-0.5263648629188538,
0.36809220910072327,
-0.7422592043876648,
0.004443469922989607,
-0.14539404213428497,
-0.6702157258987427,
-0.08898922801017761,
0.6397000551223755,
-0.4203898012638092,
0.4329809248447418,
1.0382685661315918,
-0.11176569014787674,
0.5153858065605164,
-0.0483132041990757,
0.6466082334518433,
0.10823681950569153,
0.30384930968284607,
0.8635541200637817,
-0.10221797227859497,
0.8015653491020203,
0.43573975563049316,
-0.04546487703919411,
0.31563451886177063,
0.531848669052124,
0.610058069229126,
0.7957735061645508,
-0.22648899257183075,
-0.8322463631629944,
-0.6003677845001221,
-0.3103177845478058,
-0.01154804416000843,
0.9179099202156067,
0.28966376185417175,
-0.003817555494606495,
-0.27038949728012085,
0.6451954245567322,
-0.17183378338813782,
0.06656179577112198,
0.1545504927635193,
1.4980119466781616,
-0.05543385446071625,
-0.7027595639228821,
0.7591973543167114,
-0.07602020353078842,
0.6139159202575684,
-0.7100434303283691,
0.45321550965309143,
-0.3699653446674347,
0.1547723412513733,
-0.24061965942382812,
-0.773886501789093,
0.5231256484985352,
-0.01182972826063633,
-0.09399304538965225,
-0.67191082239151,
0.4771351218223572,
-0.1633414924144745,
0.2836650311946869,
0.6161807775497437,
0.5814639329910278,
0.11138932406902313,
-0.19066569209098816,
-0.5241904854774475,
0.15281541645526886,
0.5233079791069031,
-0.26350271701812744,
0.016714313998818398,
0.2677515149116516,
-0.03438304364681244,
1.1280369758605957,
0.7185165882110596,
-0.24529844522476196,
-0.06144576519727707,
-0.14317727088928223,
0.9241510033607483,
-0.544140100479126,
-0.5813846588134766,
-0.5828126668930054,
0.1718469113111496,
-0.13954345881938934,
0.03467562794685364,
0.6048230528831482,
0.45392417907714844,
0.5601757764816284,
0.04232948273420334,
0.8543059825897217,
-0.29189199209213257,
0.5996430516242981,
-0.07088182121515274,
0.7169514298439026,
-0.642021119594574,
0.10045833140611649,
-0.22043690085411072,
-0.6520769596099854,
-0.03444298356771469,
0.5963607430458069,
-0.3759481906890869,
-0.32026296854019165,
0.34966427087783813,
0.7455310225486755,
-0.33745595812797546,
0.2954905927181244,
0.7501310706138611,
0.020331693813204765,
0.44985735416412354,
0.289223313331604,
1.3565603494644165,
-0.006135013420134783,
0.5446847677230835,
-0.10583730787038803,
-0.64958256483078,
-0.36525553464889526,
-0.479345440864563,
-0.44647321105003357,
-0.46060481667518616,
-0.19616283476352692,
-0.12044060230255127,
0.09074784815311432,
0.8823375105857849,
0.7338635921478271,
-0.800957202911377,
-0.3601298928260803,
0.12602606415748596,
-0.010933192446827888,
-0.2950068712234497,
-0.22068555653095245,
-0.14939257502555847,
-0.19053831696510315,
-0.8580512404441833,
1.182257056236267,
0.7022627592086792,
0.15980848670005798,
-0.3432774543762207,
-0.1752861738204956,
-0.39422205090522766,
0.17328165471553802,
0.5733253359794617,
0.7921063303947449,
-0.4906586706638336,
-0.4854174852371216,
0.05114880949258804,
-0.14982280135154724,
-0.08619656413793564,
0.7489318251609802,
-0.43414202332496643,
0.6030849814414978,
0.26435184478759766,
0.18234671652317047,
0.4134332537651062,
0.34943652153015137,
0.7211986780166626,
-0.5923296809196472,
0.14688265323638916,
0.46964365243911743,
0.006796441040933132,
0.22156922519207,
-0.49890074133872986,
-0.09379656612873077,
0.3246312141418457,
-0.5738999247550964,
-0.7381477355957031,
0.0627460926771164,
-1.2937748432159424,
0.4716207683086395,
0.7588406205177307,
-0.06536644697189331,
-0.09225571155548096,
-0.4850526452064514,
-0.5836952924728394,
0.15372934937477112,
-1.0064383745193481,
0.6835581064224243,
0.5036429762840271,
-0.2204311341047287,
-0.0062426915392279625,
-0.31755968928337097,
0.5404424071311951,
0.5529004335403442,
-0.5123910903930664,
0.4498969316482544,
0.5150612592697144,
-0.08883484452962875,
0.48034006357192993,
0.880341649055481,
0.024543235078454018,
0.4398718774318695,
-0.10208515077829361,
-0.14458172023296356,
0.14455126225948334,
-0.4906560778617859,
-0.22788040339946747,
-0.0663270652294159,
-0.15860697627067566,
-0.8902425765991211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13500v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13500v1
|
Leveraging Translation For Optimal Recall: Tailoring LLM Personalization With User Profiles
| 2024-02-21T03:25:14 | 2024-02-21T03:25:14 |
Karthik Ravichandran, Sarmistha Sarna Gomasta
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, F.2.2; I.2.7
|
This paper explores a novel technique for improving recall in cross-language
information retrieval (CLIR) systems using iterative query refinement grounded
in the user's lexical-semantic space. The proposed methodology combines
multi-level translation, semantic embedding-based expansion, and user
profile-centered augmentation to address the challenge of matching variance
between user queries and relevant documents. Through an initial BM25 retrieval,
translation into intermediate languages, embedding lookup of similar terms, and
iterative re-ranking, the technique aims to expand the scope of potentially
relevant results personalized to the individual user. Comparative experiments
on news and Twitter datasets demonstrate superior performance over baseline
BM25 ranking for the proposed approach across ROUGE metrics. The translation
methodology also showed maintained semantic accuracy through the multi-step
process. This personalized CLIR framework paves the path for improved
context-aware retrieval attentive to the nuances of user language.
|
[
-0.3162611722946167,
-0.4776175022125244,
0.4124312102794647,
0.11512441188097,
0.0012494605034589767,
0.556493878364563,
-0.32481878995895386,
-0.17288783192634583,
0.44858190417289734,
0.6058927774429321,
-0.40480464696884155,
-0.8875088095664978,
-0.374280720949173,
-0.009272469207644463,
-0.518997311592102,
0.8097901344299316,
0.015214151702821255,
-0.16219738125801086,
0.04740585759282112,
-0.43169689178466797,
-0.8105401992797852,
-0.6400274634361267,
-0.42883938550949097,
-0.10011669993400574,
0.793824315071106,
0.6855864524841309,
0.45383384823799133,
0.5215087532997131,
0.27625298500061035,
0.2015646994113922,
-0.08933065831661224,
0.3315456807613373,
-0.9709324240684509,
0.27936437726020813,
-0.6680784225463867,
-0.49698561429977417,
-0.003430424490943551,
-0.4996907114982605,
0.6778939962387085,
0.5165342092514038,
-0.25522834062576294,
0.22203484177589417,
-0.07697083801031113,
0.833584725856781,
-0.7655103206634521,
-0.2526186406612396,
-0.9665527939796448,
-0.2138262242078781,
-0.236494243144989,
-0.6330181956291199,
-0.48760101199150085,
-0.260731965303421,
0.030608033761382103,
-0.6585972309112549,
0.33733242750167847,
0.3504129648208618,
0.7043139934539795,
-0.08643779903650284,
-0.5895994305610657,
-0.2652546763420105,
-0.9859229922294617,
0.6878513693809509,
-0.3671150803565979,
0.6340530514717102,
0.25114312767982483,
0.5965625643730164,
-0.027349138632416725,
-0.7940892577171326,
-0.2255016267299652,
0.05256076157093048,
-0.23192551732063293,
0.0702352225780487,
-0.15839369595050812,
-0.1862025260925293,
0.13847801089286804,
0.3218335807323456,
-0.48715442419052124,
-0.10102654248476028,
-0.5618972182273865,
-0.4713141918182373,
0.5855381488800049,
0.28994160890579224,
0.2676272988319397,
0.08839250355958939,
-0.4450385272502899,
-0.16262412071228027,
-0.7848943471908569,
0.056018609553575516,
0.2179456502199173,
0.48055410385131836,
0.3473770022392273,
0.7321628332138062,
-0.6028859615325928,
0.4026210606098175,
0.1813739836215973,
-0.09379114210605621,
0.4121089577674866,
-0.7117024064064026,
0.2529272735118866,
0.19263048470020294,
0.4337819516658783,
0.4035944640636444,
0.30426913499832153,
-0.38072606921195984,
-0.3675859272480011,
-0.5568951964378357,
0.3873274326324463,
-0.6963584423065186,
0.05055702477693558,
-0.013327586464583874,
-0.3185879588127136,
0.21718361973762512,
0.3580745756626129,
-0.6306004524230957,
-0.38865646719932556,
-0.09889240562915802,
0.3489281237125397,
-0.45671916007995605,
0.2994401454925537,
0.21621368825435638,
-0.055689986795186996,
0.09748268127441406,
0.23552869260311127,
-0.7563337087631226,
0.2441704422235489,
0.38052934408187866,
0.531512975692749,
-0.20965376496315002,
-0.05093250051140785,
-0.48170945048332214,
0.7580223679542542,
-0.09620770066976547,
0.5544463396072388,
-0.7313740849494934,
-0.6041813492774963,
0.3253571093082428,
-0.04903879016637802,
-0.04028544947504997,
-0.8006656169891357,
0.5078180432319641,
-0.8011235594749451,
0.04944315180182457,
-0.6806833744049072,
-0.4087246060371399,
-0.20935067534446716,
0.19726262986660004,
-0.49033379554748535,
1.1285078525543213,
0.0642019733786583,
-0.5639004707336426,
0.4047052264213562,
-0.31397533416748047,
-0.6234140396118164,
0.12358228862285614,
-0.05726335942745209,
-0.1754012107849121,
0.06384536623954773,
0.38747817277908325,
0.3461465537548065,
-0.19218400120735168,
0.17292378842830658,
-0.04655754566192627,
-0.4011304974555969,
-0.13808873295783997,
0.20688579976558685,
0.1883406639099121,
0.16469092667102814,
0.09668245166540146,
0.28908172249794006,
-0.5919617414474487,
-0.08399207890033722,
0.01863608881831169,
-0.6102192997932434,
-0.6933816075325012,
-0.053684357553720474,
0.08920960128307343,
0.2140188366174698,
0.6897571086883545,
-0.7022683024406433,
0.037151943892240524,
-0.41608285903930664,
0.2516649663448334,
0.48044025897979736,
0.2249167561531067,
0.7699919939041138,
-0.3873187005519867,
0.15985752642154694,
0.08733644336462021,
-0.15669217705726624,
-0.5318169593811035,
-0.14262519776821136,
-0.6955395936965942,
-0.17652814090251923,
0.015437416732311249,
0.9137983322143555,
-0.42033132910728455,
0.365503191947937,
-0.43798014521598816,
-0.23871222138404846,
-0.49390968680381775,
0.7199280858039856,
0.3896472156047821,
0.5035815238952637,
0.6509890556335449,
-0.3253716230392456,
-0.6367670297622681,
-0.9911713600158691,
-0.6275482177734375,
0.04403452202677727,
-0.053065504878759384,
0.6458335518836975,
0.21559077501296997,
-0.5404579639434814,
0.833121120929718,
-0.6041866540908813,
-0.7708021402359009,
-0.4615930914878845,
-0.23669594526290894,
0.1999194175004959,
0.23690557479858398,
0.2731335759162903,
-1.0053805112838745,
-0.6426010727882385,
0.2986544072628021,
-0.3800028860569,
-0.11259506642818451,
-0.2947385311126709,
-0.3267057538032532,
0.019701983779668808,
0.42560088634490967,
-0.30561643838882446,
0.6307234764099121,
-0.23021700978279114,
-0.32622969150543213,
-0.08812513947486877,
-0.5268772840499878,
0.2967173755168915,
-1.2592346668243408,
0.3971045911312103,
0.0077826776541769505,
-0.5613211393356323,
-0.5858086943626404,
-0.07652077823877335,
0.31044527888298035,
0.13017258048057556,
-0.2377304583787918,
0.9884450435638428,
-0.40620771050453186,
-0.09021448343992233,
-0.07193392515182495,
0.5308526754379272,
-0.06355316191911697,
0.24707765877246857,
-0.3028230667114258,
0.6970617175102234,
-0.11960801482200623,
-0.6106404066085815,
-0.026262983679771423,
0.48709172010421753,
-0.2323192059993744,
0.4999092221260071,
-0.45784851908683777,
0.13767322897911072,
-0.24715113639831543,
0.23963084816932678,
-1.2004444599151611,
-0.13149598240852356,
-0.045777712017297745,
-0.3369912803173065,
0.21690940856933594,
0.23497800529003143,
-0.7168309688568115,
-0.20646892488002777,
-0.32816144824028015,
0.3605656027793884,
0.4307273328304291,
-0.7347627282142639,
0.7221385836601257,
0.2465713918209076,
-0.04082376882433891,
-0.6497200727462769,
-0.4597814977169037,
0.24975427985191345,
-0.2814299464225769,
-0.624523401260376,
0.9437724351882935,
-0.13612602651119232,
-0.043111372739076614,
-0.20393027365207672,
-0.19406217336654663,
0.03232571855187416,
-0.024367555975914,
-0.14280730485916138,
-0.006956072524189949,
0.020322883501648903,
-0.053987767547369,
0.09540381282567978,
0.07275614142417908,
-0.6358901262283325,
-0.2733134329319,
0.5898224115371704,
-0.058900635689496994,
-0.0699915736913681,
-0.32115989923477173,
0.4268966317176819,
0.26564648747444153,
-0.28985950350761414,
0.6127374172210693,
0.7560610175132751,
-0.2297382950782776,
-0.11718249320983887,
-0.9569111466407776,
-0.2769423723220825,
-0.4625324606895447,
0.30855247378349304,
-0.647487461566925,
-1.289341688156128,
0.9178500175476074,
-0.07770771533250809,
-0.022640634328126907,
0.14871297776699066,
0.7783992886543274,
-0.1155426949262619,
1.0040513277053833,
0.6900307536125183,
-0.3404991924762726,
0.6711155772209167,
-0.09115581959486008,
0.14186668395996094,
-0.9573408365249634,
-0.5284286737442017,
-0.3085598051548004,
-0.6143537759780884,
-0.4692765772342682,
-0.3484480381011963,
0.18751561641693115,
0.018206769600510597,
-0.3395829200744629,
0.470880389213562,
-0.30780234932899475,
0.4296877980232239,
0.5469767451286316,
0.230397567152977,
0.42885228991508484,
0.15564361214637756,
-0.3848453760147095,
-0.22588305175304413,
-0.421657919883728,
-0.17657198011875153,
0.8883903622627258,
0.02909739688038826,
0.8736191987991333,
0.24704939126968384,
0.9398664236068726,
0.37573906779289246,
0.08538991212844849,
-0.4350442886352539,
0.43623173236846924,
-0.26712486147880554,
-0.7574652433395386,
-0.07490494102239609,
-0.31875160336494446,
-0.9968231916427612,
0.36603251099586487,
-0.09792526066303253,
-1.1148886680603027,
0.2302868366241455,
0.23827813565731049,
-0.19081294536590576,
0.013491839170455933,
-0.454221248626709,
0.6296982765197754,
-0.35322412848472595,
-0.5212956070899963,
-0.5284286141395569,
-0.8891358375549316,
0.2523411512374878,
-0.21280479431152344,
0.001422463683411479,
-0.07661072909832001,
-0.47050926089286804,
0.16576004028320312,
0.056527186185121536,
0.7604556679725647,
-0.08060208708047867,
0.37833112478256226,
-0.01297086663544178,
0.1338685154914856,
0.45050495862960815,
-0.040583424270153046,
-0.1803382933139801,
-0.2323627769947052,
0.11358055472373962,
-0.4856887459754944,
-0.6046727895736694,
0.9300021529197693,
-0.45750731229782104,
-0.8309916853904724,
-0.07613503932952881,
-0.5920009613037109,
-0.13244247436523438,
0.4922909140586853,
0.04917588084936142,
0.01474588643759489,
-0.4974195063114166,
0.43652981519699097,
0.7718336582183838,
-0.4479065537452698,
0.14349102973937988,
0.7009149193763733,
-0.349577397108078,
-0.49847128987312317,
1.0329371690750122,
-0.008470780216157436,
0.0061219315975904465,
0.9336718916893005,
0.22502164542675018,
-0.1562127321958542,
-0.44987353682518005,
-0.31163766980171204,
0.44241443276405334,
-0.850336492061615,
-0.001147198025137186,
-0.6842595934867859,
0.07250311225652695,
-0.34271061420440674,
-0.2522338926792145,
-0.16623814404010773,
-0.2460319995880127,
-0.24244219064712524,
0.08061819523572922,
0.023255186155438423,
0.4823932349681854,
0.14027416706085205,
0.4233786463737488,
-0.6950656771659851,
0.35848382115364075,
-0.3743968904018402,
0.09850193560123444,
-0.19643963873386383,
-0.6300714015960693,
-0.35083314776420593,
-0.24525542557239532,
-0.2847921550273895,
-0.6003832221031189,
0.6870803236961365,
0.4647901654243469,
0.9724156856536865,
0.1872146874666214,
0.05591810122132301,
0.8293465375900269,
-0.5850181579589844,
0.3543446660041809,
0.023860229179263115,
-0.730728030204773,
0.7394869923591614,
-0.13337674736976624,
0.4930547773838043,
1.0436867475509644,
0.4892546832561493,
-0.811394214630127,
-0.12456181645393372,
-0.23084431886672974,
-1.2143402099609375,
0.37676572799682617,
-0.014852008782327175,
0.4039793610572815,
0.023492196574807167,
0.8043152093887329,
0.0854572281241417,
0.1990610808134079,
-0.20181027054786682,
-0.15383172035217285,
0.15538926422595978,
-0.39322468638420105,
-0.24640637636184692,
-0.2651563882827759,
0.03385847434401512,
-0.34867924451828003,
0.5053430795669556,
-0.20480112731456757,
-0.0069488114677369595,
0.378328412771225,
-0.36387205123901367,
0.22413308918476105,
0.10138113051652908,
0.636218249797821,
0.7820520997047424,
-0.37059515714645386,
-0.16749830543994904,
0.29278692603111267,
-0.19424109160900116,
-0.1610557734966278,
-0.1397082656621933,
-0.17969420552253723,
0.031235352158546448,
-0.08097419887781143,
0.6491543054580688,
0.5892985463142395,
-0.7877728343009949,
0.5877984166145325,
-0.09514932334423065,
0.14047202467918396,
-0.3881746828556061,
-0.016555489972233772,
0.11661582440137863,
0.2958655059337616,
0.5401791334152222,
-0.2515026330947876,
0.25109243392944336,
-0.593648374080658,
0.47501853108406067,
0.4684143364429474,
-0.4269590973854065,
-0.3162229061126709,
0.7184103727340698,
-0.0139970937743783,
-0.28543829917907715,
0.4322044849395752,
0.3313482105731964,
-0.4070485830307007,
-0.003743424080312252,
0.7396580576896667,
0.7170053720474243,
-0.3399142026901245,
0.07481678575277328,
0.6452040076255798,
0.20722728967666626,
-0.1575630158185959,
0.32452768087387085,
-0.2961941957473755,
-0.6862263679504395,
0.059714313596487045,
-0.40634432435035706,
-0.1054142639040947,
-0.31095176935195923,
-0.5927090048789978,
0.5190133452415466,
-0.5815428495407104,
-0.11373814195394516,
-0.33243340253829956,
-0.07624424993991852,
-0.7341914176940918,
0.1995282620191574,
-0.02298923023045063,
1.1096646785736084,
-0.4056670367717743,
0.90433669090271,
0.6378849744796753,
-0.5374209880828857,
-0.3208354413509369,
0.12530505657196045,
0.03638490289449692,
-0.9357110857963562,
0.7881590723991394,
0.020370028913021088,
-0.12678684294223785,
0.09479272365570068,
-0.11655674129724503,
-0.9162876605987549,
1.5338190793991089,
0.2789367735385895,
-0.5220935344696045,
-0.12258292734622955,
0.16985583305358887,
0.6416691541671753,
-0.7930974960327148,
0.06086403876543045,
0.6280186772346497,
0.22700011730194092,
0.394286572933197,
-0.6234768033027649,
0.1107364296913147,
0.07279830425977707,
0.35677996277809143,
0.15457288920879364,
-0.6577681303024292,
0.27481329441070557,
-0.39145296812057495,
-0.30761224031448364,
0.20828603208065033,
0.6745595335960388,
0.14723771810531616,
0.4345179498195648,
0.23835669457912445,
0.3430643379688263,
0.829071044921875,
0.3377074599266052,
1.2631733417510986,
-0.6301122903823853,
0.1331556886434555,
1.196903944015503,
-0.22287416458129883,
1.009588599205017,
0.5595296621322632,
0.4161774516105652,
0.4252638518810272,
0.5423307418823242,
0.18544985353946686,
0.7856852412223816,
0.3057765066623688,
-0.183695986866951,
-0.21367405354976654,
-0.13855887949466705,
0.13498708605766296,
0.1910880208015442,
0.5129573345184326,
-0.7082116007804871,
-0.2811378538608551,
0.0090717151761055,
0.06494253128767014,
0.484368234872818,
-0.10384551435709,
0.9074946641921997,
0.120767742395401,
-0.4871639013290405,
0.3990127444267273,
0.1746072918176651,
0.5743652582168579,
-0.5012668967247009,
0.1312844306230545,
-0.5292296409606934,
0.41103246808052063,
-0.19627541303634644,
-0.712837278842926,
0.22078008949756622,
-0.3500652015209198,
-0.26557156443595886,
-0.390480101108551,
0.9344577193260193,
-0.6655578017234802,
-0.24090595543384552,
0.6245266795158386,
0.4774492084980011,
-0.009049908258020878,
0.017469221726059914,
-0.6180564165115356,
0.02853991463780403,
0.2534518539905548,
-0.2767584025859833,
0.3334749937057495,
0.14543157815933228,
-0.3359397053718567,
0.9176623821258545,
0.506538987159729,
-0.10311295092105865,
0.32658201456069946,
0.17811572551727295,
0.7876660823822021,
-0.8756374716758728,
-0.23408061265945435,
-0.784666121006012,
0.37098371982574463,
-0.15849369764328003,
-0.3854498863220215,
0.7146273255348206,
1.0094820261001587,
1.1388909816741943,
0.02521621249616146,
0.8773433566093445,
0.1454799920320511,
0.7303335070610046,
-0.30605241656303406,
0.43843963742256165,
-0.7866653800010681,
0.5578280687332153,
-0.04318832606077194,
-1.0393675565719604,
-0.3089613914489746,
0.24419572949409485,
-0.24679474532604218,
0.045515235513448715,
0.4334295392036438,
1.0615158081054688,
-0.17168352007865906,
-0.5536001920700073,
0.6230838298797607,
0.08215320110321045,
0.27817240357398987,
0.6730014681816101,
0.5289468169212341,
-0.3655968904495239,
0.5692259073257446,
-0.14155367016792297,
-0.09085796773433685,
-0.5413663983345032,
-0.442342609167099,
-0.9418069124221802,
-0.7185730338096619,
0.06568118929862976,
-0.2924847900867462,
0.2387588918209076,
0.81236332654953,
0.452421635389328,
-0.8242760896682739,
-0.3927089273929596,
0.41918814182281494,
0.11308816820383072,
0.18313755095005035,
-0.15497197210788727,
0.0712406188249588,
-0.36645692586898804,
-0.6534096598625183,
0.5446733832359314,
0.33553624153137207,
-0.28840330243110657,
-0.19816063344478607,
-0.14662927389144897,
-0.4015507102012634,
0.1032886654138565,
0.4951489269733429,
0.4821029007434845,
-0.981753408908844,
-0.41931840777397156,
0.4667574465274811,
-0.3745105564594269,
0.1971205472946167,
0.9091154932975769,
-0.8281344175338745,
0.7758567929267883,
0.7894352078437805,
1.015550971031189,
0.9699609279632568,
0.3535149097442627,
0.8605422973632812,
-0.8311468958854675,
-0.24246487021446228,
0.05571557953953743,
0.20570698380470276,
0.5646151304244995,
-0.63172847032547,
0.5498954653739929,
0.13161665201187134,
-0.3228472173213959,
-0.5538659691810608,
0.17123831808567047,
-1.0641694068908691,
-0.1292719691991806,
1.2040843963623047,
-0.07660362869501114,
-0.0746517926454544,
-0.13127243518829346,
-0.4038456082344055,
0.05586903542280197,
-0.6449282765388489,
0.7229629158973694,
0.5826195478439331,
-0.037665847688913345,
-0.1998133510351181,
-0.7564520239830017,
0.15140073001384735,
0.3537778854370117,
-0.31512925028800964,
-0.18399955332279205,
0.2091841995716095,
0.5470139980316162,
0.06778350472450256,
0.6121799349784851,
-0.12446602433919907,
0.03557829186320305,
-0.6550591588020325,
-0.03468230366706848,
0.1587037742137909,
-0.28164759278297424,
-0.0456506572663784,
0.0502910390496254,
-0.07667867094278336,
0.1659841388463974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13498v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13498v1
|
The Lay Person's Guide to Biomedicine: Orchestrating Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T03:21:14 | 2024-02-21T03:21:14 |
Zheheng Luo, Qianqian Xie, Sophia Ananiadou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automated lay summarisation (LS) aims to simplify complex technical documents
into a more accessible format to non-experts. Existing approaches using
pre-trained language models, possibly augmented with external background
knowledge, tend to struggle with effective simplification and explanation.
Moreover, automated methods that can effectively assess the `layness' of
generated summaries are lacking. Recently, large language models (LLMs) have
demonstrated a remarkable capacity for text simplification, background
information generation, and text evaluation. This has motivated our systematic
exploration into using LLMs to generate and evaluate lay summaries of
biomedical articles. We propose a novel \textit{Explain-then-Summarise} LS
framework, which leverages LLMs to generate high-quality background knowledge
to improve supervised LS. We also evaluate the performance of LLMs for
zero-shot LS and propose two novel LLM-based LS evaluation metrics, which
assess layness from multiple perspectives. Finally, we conduct a human
assessment of generated lay summaries. Our experiments reveal that
LLM-generated background information can support improved supervised LS.
Furthermore, our novel zero-shot LS evaluation metric demonstrates a high
degree of alignment with human preferences. We conclude that LLMs have an
important part to play in improving both the performance and evaluation of LS
methods.
|
[
-0.026734303683042526,
-0.45165756344795227,
0.9088872075080872,
0.0491052009165287,
-0.45996755361557007,
-0.038836050778627396,
-0.31540578603744507,
-0.3677767217159271,
0.4904734194278717,
0.4107201397418976,
-0.4168889820575714,
-0.6998100280761719,
-0.5504223108291626,
0.5021056532859802,
-0.4928783178329468,
1.069443941116333,
0.07997317612171173,
0.2912687063217163,
-0.3162270486354828,
-0.05866418406367302,
0.007711709942668676,
-0.08776818215847015,
-0.4417206048965454,
-0.6294781565666199,
0.7978546619415283,
0.16623800992965698,
0.70389723777771,
0.7505070567131042,
0.5746991038322449,
0.32365691661834717,
-0.2917294502258301,
0.08450174331665039,
-0.5502387285232544,
0.1005328819155693,
-0.17505165934562683,
-0.27063873410224915,
-0.518756628036499,
-0.16440150141716003,
0.417839914560318,
1.3301140069961548,
0.0063241831958293915,
0.34548479318618774,
-0.16321739554405212,
0.8348406553268433,
-0.589551568031311,
-0.06358525156974792,
-0.3782740831375122,
0.2598569691181183,
0.2019251137971878,
-0.39689359068870544,
-0.4216814637184143,
-0.36320650577545166,
0.1444988250732422,
-0.5155918002128601,
0.016533467918634415,
-0.21575164794921875,
0.4844921827316284,
0.21034769713878632,
-0.49069228768348694,
-0.22150982916355133,
-0.45307156443595886,
0.49598583579063416,
-0.9531624913215637,
0.18942518532276154,
0.03222678229212761,
0.21065481007099152,
-0.2195035070180893,
-0.5990499258041382,
-0.1932905912399292,
-0.43911218643188477,
-0.30825138092041016,
0.31161022186279297,
-0.10067393630743027,
0.31387877464294434,
0.16415876150131226,
0.3859672546386719,
-0.733572244644165,
0.2680265009403229,
-0.7504540085792542,
-0.14244402945041656,
0.9692211747169495,
0.2241051346063614,
0.22496040165424347,
-0.2287627011537552,
-0.01935909129679203,
0.3635239899158478,
-0.68768310546875,
-0.1877802312374115,
0.038183100521564484,
-0.04417046904563904,
-0.23464049398899078,
0.7897765040397644,
-0.4616106152534485,
0.7654758095741272,
0.023441050201654434,
-0.4467769265174866,
0.21419847011566162,
-0.2807712256908417,
-0.37817636132240295,
0.07454410940408707,
0.9236299991607666,
0.5683663487434387,
0.27913564443588257,
-0.2644214332103729,
0.05572932958602905,
-0.14757171273231506,
0.19433729350566864,
-0.8314895629882812,
-0.09351734817028046,
0.6186443567276001,
-0.7472059726715088,
-0.5577625632286072,
-0.20930805802345276,
-0.49153047800064087,
-0.4750532805919647,
-0.511864960193634,
0.3107372522354126,
-0.41756120324134827,
0.05753108859062195,
0.30243736505508423,
-0.22782538831233978,
0.058755166828632355,
0.6041569113731384,
-0.4729229807853699,
0.14209534227848053,
0.5143531560897827,
0.9066373705863953,
-0.33926406502723694,
-0.3206477463245392,
-0.31414106488227844,
0.5261086821556091,
-0.4830784797668457,
0.8016371726989746,
-0.03989040106534958,
-0.4842439293861389,
-0.10176350921392441,
-0.10914525389671326,
0.25150439143180847,
-0.3299742043018341,
0.12352393567562103,
-0.15797987580299377,
0.21212433278560638,
-0.13147825002670288,
-0.6095558404922485,
0.016412653028964996,
-0.12805801630020142,
-0.4423152804374695,
0.5090832710266113,
-0.0712062194943428,
-0.5782286524772644,
0.20033539831638336,
-0.7565305233001709,
-0.7427967190742493,
0.29407984018325806,
-0.2448936104774475,
-0.19043953716754913,
0.3235292136669159,
0.14501051604747772,
0.7621040940284729,
-0.30841392278671265,
0.6554988622665405,
-0.20885667204856873,
-0.46510857343673706,
0.39552122354507446,
0.016150884330272675,
0.801887035369873,
0.24225302040576935,
-0.09733171761035919,
0.425513356924057,
-0.630716860294342,
-0.06601087749004364,
-0.10933425277471542,
-0.24702990055084229,
-0.1332753449678421,
-0.01669822260737419,
-0.35978925228118896,
0.012610973790287971,
0.09770125150680542,
-0.2049650251865387,
0.04783204197883606,
-0.47913700342178345,
0.44716954231262207,
0.5324912667274475,
0.038553595542907715,
0.48595306277275085,
-0.493086040019989,
0.38597965240478516,
-0.2977003753185272,
-0.002289622323587537,
-0.7072608470916748,
-0.22715644538402557,
-0.4934270977973938,
-0.4153783321380615,
0.21621939539909363,
0.4027572274208069,
-0.41590020060539246,
0.5072332620620728,
-0.37682992219924927,
-0.5932507514953613,
-0.545291543006897,
0.1277371048927307,
0.4025547504425049,
0.5854030847549438,
0.3143901526927948,
-0.2465912252664566,
-0.5624976754188538,
-1.0580003261566162,
-0.25873926281929016,
-0.011283881030976772,
-0.42229026556015015,
0.09200242906808853,
0.6021829843521118,
-0.3028924763202667,
0.8981200456619263,
-0.527759313583374,
0.007679723668843508,
-0.3777627646923065,
0.36772242188453674,
0.2572976350784302,
0.1968211829662323,
0.23650921881198883,
-0.5663120150566101,
-0.1547747254371643,
-0.053080588579177856,
-1.184846043586731,
-0.5718810558319092,
0.006611252669245005,
0.01198302861303091,
-0.018298232927918434,
0.6462746262550354,
-0.6491125226020813,
0.3977639675140381,
0.24922117590904236,
-0.135403111577034,
0.8750295042991638,
-0.2433689683675766,
0.1944844126701355,
-1.0039677619934082,
0.39527207612991333,
-0.0379028394818306,
-0.4554126262664795,
-0.551417350769043,
0.186587393283844,
-0.10829810798168182,
-0.2468704879283905,
-0.3695850968360901,
0.44050905108451843,
-0.6211228966712952,
-0.3656952381134033,
-0.2667662799358368,
0.17238952219486237,
0.10590267181396484,
0.22773794829845428,
0.10663729906082153,
0.5228719711303711,
0.38041001558303833,
-0.5586984157562256,
0.292873352766037,
0.15863583981990814,
-0.24123375117778778,
0.38379472494125366,
-0.8778789639472961,
-0.2391406148672104,
-0.4972299337387085,
0.5986727476119995,
-0.8100621104240417,
-0.7333706021308899,
-0.1918381154537201,
-0.3303299844264984,
0.15151000022888184,
0.0015500315930694342,
-0.16724005341529846,
-0.42125070095062256,
-0.48732540011405945,
0.14182190597057343,
0.6259867548942566,
-0.059235893189907074,
0.5389847755432129,
0.44153544306755066,
-0.5455114841461182,
-0.3073577880859375,
-0.6987136602401733,
0.35826870799064636,
-0.05261486768722534,
-0.5917529463768005,
0.3855087459087372,
-0.24775096774101257,
-0.5586433410644531,
-0.07049783319234848,
-0.0016509242122992873,
0.0627049058675766,
0.07485627382993698,
0.27450650930404663,
-0.01445792056620121,
-0.23401769995689392,
0.2185620218515396,
0.1698569506406784,
-0.056633125990629196,
0.16132575273513794,
-0.3142191767692566,
0.2202511429786682,
0.12976738810539246,
-0.45826199650764465,
-0.5140280723571777,
0.6274139285087585,
0.7692485451698303,
-0.012748274952173233,
0.4725268483161926,
0.3013671040534973,
-0.12084630131721497,
-0.06743139773607254,
-0.5101492404937744,
-0.12058188021183014,
-0.35867178440093994,
0.5323810577392578,
0.01405259594321251,
-0.7123833298683167,
0.382870078086853,
-0.26973608136177063,
0.08461176604032516,
0.6365480422973633,
0.7953827381134033,
-0.551420271396637,
0.7594891786575317,
0.682140588760376,
0.11674034595489502,
-0.07685240358114243,
-0.09446047246456146,
0.07246798276901245,
-0.48601460456848145,
-0.38690611720085144,
-0.3561367094516754,
-0.19762741029262543,
-0.2586784362792969,
-0.4247707724571228,
0.809451162815094,
0.04450022801756859,
0.06041169911623001,
0.005619972478598356,
-0.27992498874664307,
0.6659367084503174,
0.09559808671474457,
0.19513218104839325,
0.3928949534893036,
-0.05732408165931702,
0.011661670170724392,
0.28061893582344055,
-0.7127309441566467,
-0.7351409792900085,
1.132494568824768,
0.5141263604164124,
0.7405199408531189,
0.133708193898201,
0.8347389698028564,
0.4053429663181305,
0.40806064009666443,
-0.8536581993103027,
0.6556328535079956,
-0.11304724216461182,
-0.08541568368673325,
-0.37395787239074707,
-0.4019335210323334,
-0.7024200558662415,
0.16851764917373657,
-0.1504187136888504,
-0.591717541217804,
-0.214746356010437,
0.2544413208961487,
-0.5977641940116882,
-0.046048831194639206,
-0.5389361381530762,
0.4234457314014435,
-0.35730844736099243,
-0.2975658178329468,
-0.1339697390794754,
-0.9172704815864563,
0.7421713471412659,
-0.12515100836753845,
0.5279490947723389,
0.09673748165369034,
-0.1678965836763382,
0.7573553323745728,
-0.5509055852890015,
0.8512492179870605,
0.20977622270584106,
-0.37110209465026855,
-0.058287929743528366,
0.18236589431762695,
0.10564179718494415,
0.04000336304306984,
-0.2058926522731781,
0.1628197431564331,
-0.09348716586828232,
-0.385224312543869,
-0.4325823485851288,
0.5195896625518799,
-0.45635485649108887,
-0.46368569135665894,
-0.16063615679740906,
-0.7416664958000183,
-0.09372636675834656,
0.13107995688915253,
0.43533384799957275,
0.30262473225593567,
-0.2552548944950104,
0.19986583292484283,
0.750776469707489,
-0.43887442350387573,
0.30879539251327515,
0.7511157989501953,
-0.26683974266052246,
-0.37945815920829773,
0.4526902139186859,
-0.0974213182926178,
0.3215155601501465,
0.40001991391181946,
0.34184589982032776,
-0.07547106593847275,
-0.7240260243415833,
-0.5328342318534851,
0.2489006668329239,
-0.6541553139686584,
-0.19198468327522278,
-0.8782227039337158,
-0.28485316038131714,
-0.5025500655174255,
-0.5139113068580627,
0.06972655653953552,
-0.44339630007743835,
-0.19903616607189178,
-0.2844041883945465,
0.25823453068733215,
0.950298547744751,
-0.21315538883209229,
0.4003041088581085,
-0.8000050783157349,
0.5267370939254761,
0.17387202382087708,
0.12820354104042053,
-0.17087304592132568,
-0.5475714206695557,
-0.34692105650901794,
-0.0036987175699323416,
0.009649309329688549,
-1.2665183544158936,
0.34973737597465515,
0.10088303685188293,
0.4874146282672882,
0.493353009223938,
-0.4112147092819214,
0.5840368270874023,
-0.6795411705970764,
0.8796266913414001,
0.38315609097480774,
-0.882544219493866,
0.518500030040741,
-0.6125497221946716,
0.4766314625740051,
0.6247026324272156,
0.4344180226325989,
-0.2750698924064636,
-0.4624444842338562,
-0.46316882967948914,
-1.0191514492034912,
0.4349781572818756,
0.1309499442577362,
-0.16766038537025452,
0.202656552195549,
0.43088412284851074,
0.18986722826957703,
0.3796587288379669,
-0.8451820611953735,
-0.1493915617465973,
0.133278951048851,
-0.4599158763885498,
-0.17359590530395508,
-0.486477792263031,
-0.3937934935092926,
-0.13616468012332916,
0.6489824056625366,
-0.24236436188220978,
0.039968378841876984,
0.27427658438682556,
-0.38830769062042236,
-0.38593223690986633,
0.35765522718429565,
0.7742804884910583,
0.8990007638931274,
-0.2745991349220276,
0.15903501212596893,
0.18093599379062653,
-0.14433977007865906,
0.15142157673835754,
-0.017958808690309525,
-0.3730992078781128,
0.19201086461544037,
0.9471549987792969,
0.5169541835784912,
0.3137550354003906,
-0.9337747693061829,
0.4727083742618561,
0.2658713459968567,
-0.3668554127216339,
-0.16490107774734497,
0.04481001943349838,
0.3429867625236511,
-0.09720645099878311,
0.44579750299453735,
-0.20312024652957916,
0.29890409111976624,
-0.5176138281822205,
0.26076260209083557,
0.3763470947742462,
-0.11017347127199173,
-0.24542288482189178,
0.2896502912044525,
0.3298955261707306,
-0.2933730185031891,
-0.1832020878791809,
-0.030899669975042343,
-0.2719120383262634,
0.6905797719955444,
0.5013306736946106,
0.8272029161453247,
-0.35654130578041077,
0.32764700055122375,
0.3215390741825104,
0.277766615152359,
-0.12280041724443436,
0.3243334889411926,
-0.05368803068995476,
-0.18407197296619415,
-0.8727914094924927,
-0.8252714276313782,
-0.39522185921669006,
0.3067774474620819,
-0.5019022226333618,
0.315278559923172,
-0.1937556117773056,
0.24306097626686096,
0.3080787658691406,
-0.4000818729400635,
-0.2828923463821411,
0.294207364320755,
0.08083802461624146,
0.9135069251060486,
-1.0126423835754395,
0.3597199022769928,
0.5077226161956787,
-0.3492703437805176,
-0.6864762306213379,
0.04572012647986412,
0.02653922140598297,
-0.5597323775291443,
0.7880542874336243,
0.054354969412088394,
-0.11945595592260361,
-0.09451472014188766,
-0.5939429402351379,
-0.7355665564537048,
1.1649469137191772,
0.3841404318809509,
-0.6784693002700806,
-0.18803662061691284,
0.046940598636865616,
0.7290414571762085,
-0.37990978360176086,
0.5448116660118103,
0.2790330946445465,
0.45532169938087463,
0.13723257184028625,
-0.9611473679542542,
-0.07085093855857849,
-0.19518235325813293,
-0.26929035782814026,
0.08105524629354477,
-0.28451985120773315,
0.7734312415122986,
-0.4576064944267273,
0.07629743963479996,
0.13119541108608246,
0.43158286809921265,
0.1898600161075592,
0.47800442576408386,
0.12894678115844727,
0.4156249165534973,
0.6842966079711914,
0.15888172388076782,
1.1497586965560913,
-0.1889835149049759,
0.018111303448677063,
1.1008325815200806,
-0.5237823724746704,
0.468089759349823,
0.32174062728881836,
-0.26411962509155273,
0.5188071131706238,
0.3965962529182434,
0.16500148177146912,
0.21191361546516418,
0.6163891553878784,
-0.05090732127428055,
-0.20392218232154846,
-0.1568799912929535,
-0.30048608779907227,
0.470671147108078,
0.2829487919807434,
-0.7242648601531982,
-0.40029340982437134,
-0.006728728301823139,
-0.07913824915885925,
0.12960562109947205,
-0.49847671389579773,
1.1621928215026855,
0.18735426664352417,
-0.8291046023368835,
0.46575963497161865,
0.2027300000190735,
0.25141748785972595,
-0.8105877041816711,
0.03125203400850296,
-0.2199886441230774,
-0.2205868810415268,
-0.4309898018836975,
-0.539025604724884,
0.28901010751724243,
0.2882063090801239,
-0.3228025734424591,
-0.10709527134895325,
0.7033721208572388,
-0.4997221529483795,
-0.6469689011573792,
0.1982441246509552,
0.5946463942527771,
0.40787121653556824,
0.3023325502872467,
-0.41514289379119873,
-0.11027227342128754,
0.01643521711230278,
-0.19804605841636658,
0.296698659658432,
0.339752197265625,
-0.13049374520778656,
0.6468027830123901,
0.8393990993499756,
0.3929253816604614,
-0.42205187678337097,
0.18815071880817413,
0.6584185361862183,
-0.7002145648002625,
-0.5323275327682495,
-1.0823216438293457,
0.5297847390174866,
-0.2589002251625061,
0.03972482681274414,
0.5835103392601013,
0.665789008140564,
0.19996541738510132,
-0.16945065557956696,
1.0054184198379517,
0.22448553144931793,
0.5252987146377563,
-0.7772824168205261,
0.8220113515853882,
-0.495396226644516,
0.25086283683776855,
-0.33422261476516724,
-0.45927894115448,
-0.3491506278514862,
0.3730505406856537,
-0.12831717729568481,
-0.014462364837527275,
0.7562545537948608,
0.6206233501434326,
-0.024324927479028702,
-0.14989538490772247,
0.39618298411369324,
0.554314911365509,
0.07765131443738937,
0.3989466726779938,
0.729169487953186,
0.015507643111050129,
0.13325363397598267,
0.02534685842692852,
-0.5708059072494507,
-0.3646436035633087,
-1.3211709260940552,
-1.0027999877929688,
-0.24235199391841888,
-0.28453803062438965,
-0.07878530025482178,
0.23836377263069153,
1.028277039527893,
0.8053358793258667,
-0.6958597302436829,
-0.37236079573631287,
-0.04995014891028404,
-0.008344855159521103,
-0.014888177625834942,
-0.16740542650222778,
0.4961012005805969,
-0.2729993462562561,
-0.24259789288043976,
0.7161027789115906,
0.7246382236480713,
0.0536479577422142,
-0.4988759458065033,
-0.018932919949293137,
-0.015275263227522373,
0.19882941246032715,
0.7200663685798645,
0.15918435156345367,
-0.7903987169265747,
0.40744543075561523,
-0.09201867133378983,
-0.20780183374881744,
-0.3485555350780487,
0.9000458717346191,
-0.8943046927452087,
0.17493239045143127,
0.3050850033760071,
0.453296959400177,
0.166648268699646,
0.03948131203651428,
0.8797207474708557,
-0.5836825370788574,
0.07996656000614166,
0.34954971075057983,
0.45841184258461,
0.35762619972229004,
-0.5570166707038879,
0.5529199242591858,
0.026066595688462257,
-0.38395363092422485,
-0.9042836427688599,
0.17129230499267578,
-0.9215583801269531,
-0.5177807807922363,
1.368978500366211,
-0.023699548095464706,
-0.3294999301433563,
-0.0914703831076622,
-0.2277059257030487,
0.1888214349746704,
-0.10444117337465286,
0.8385595679283142,
0.2776590585708618,
-0.09166257083415985,
0.12504562735557556,
-0.4704020023345947,
0.5522369146347046,
0.42861711978912354,
-1.1762125492095947,
-0.01598832570016384,
0.6896489858627319,
0.36200404167175293,
0.16667777299880981,
0.9408084154129028,
-0.07570169121026993,
0.36825305223464966,
-0.5926904678344727,
0.11290194094181061,
-0.3303458094596863,
-0.24492022395133972,
-0.46239545941352844,
0.24897518754005432,
-0.18137282133102417,
0.4189046621322632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13494v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13494v2
|
GradSafe: Detecting Jailbreak Prompts for LLMs via Safety-Critical Gradient Analysis
| 2024-02-21T03:09:21 | 2024-05-29T21:45:35 |
Yueqi Xie, Minghong Fang, Renjie Pi, Neil Gong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) face threats from jailbreak prompts. Existing
methods for detecting jailbreak prompts are primarily online moderation APIs or
finetuned LLMs. These strategies, however, often require extensive and
resource-intensive data collection and training processes. In this study, we
propose GradSafe, which effectively detects jailbreak prompts by scrutinizing
the gradients of safety-critical parameters in LLMs. Our method is grounded in
a pivotal observation: the gradients of an LLM's loss for jailbreak prompts
paired with compliance response exhibit similar patterns on certain
safety-critical parameters. In contrast, safe prompts lead to different
gradient patterns. Building on this observation, GradSafe analyzes the
gradients from prompts (paired with compliance responses) to accurately detect
jailbreak prompts. We show that GradSafe, applied to Llama-2 without further
training, outperforms Llama Guard, despite its extensive finetuning with a
large dataset, in detecting jailbreak prompts. This superior performance is
consistent across both zero-shot and adaptation scenarios, as evidenced by our
evaluations on ToxicChat and XSTest. The source code is available at
https://github.com/xyq7/GradSafe.
|
[
-0.26109325885772705,
-0.7814189195632935,
0.5409061312675476,
0.3900305926799774,
-0.32700231671333313,
0.2936621606349945,
-0.055883754044771194,
-0.20629648864269257,
0.241426020860672,
0.35117611289024353,
-0.6766177415847778,
-0.7354126572608948,
-0.7404181957244873,
-0.15306542813777924,
-0.25586998462677,
1.3160667419433594,
-0.14490985870361328,
-0.18595688045024872,
0.0404721200466156,
-0.2606670558452606,
-0.831915020942688,
-0.14815230667591095,
-0.6013712286949158,
-0.01671309769153595,
0.3931230902671814,
0.29145827889442444,
0.20558331906795502,
0.42013484239578247,
0.584686815738678,
0.13568605482578278,
-0.28571537137031555,
-0.04835725575685501,
-0.5194007158279419,
0.4587118923664093,
0.031200403347611427,
-0.34420666098594666,
-0.059626899659633636,
-0.1299789547920227,
0.22866873443126678,
-0.04847654327750206,
-0.39455094933509827,
0.37605026364326477,
0.05183526873588562,
0.7955827713012695,
-0.828305184841156,
-0.04883630946278572,
-0.6314500570297241,
-0.006611551623791456,
-0.29705435037612915,
-0.103141188621521,
-0.31471937894821167,
-0.5454238057136536,
-0.373242050409317,
-0.08992981165647507,
0.12112531065940857,
-0.1894497126340866,
0.5612035989761353,
0.3043869733810425,
-0.09004969149827957,
-0.22627036273479462,
-0.179213747382164,
0.42187270522117615,
-0.5254083871841431,
0.2034536451101303,
0.3894227147102356,
0.475875586271286,
-0.5618245005607605,
-0.38469240069389343,
-0.22536973655223846,
-0.5814469456672668,
0.1913367360830307,
-0.33894655108451843,
-0.06567338854074478,
0.06335912644863129,
0.2690586447715759,
0.07870028167963028,
-0.6696803569793701,
0.09623240679502487,
-0.20266763865947723,
-0.40921834111213684,
0.4853324890136719,
0.23769444227218628,
0.5375891923904419,
0.006191799882799387,
-0.5520126223564148,
-0.04729428514838219,
-0.6924976706504822,
0.3223129212856293,
0.4223859906196594,
0.18449263274669647,
-0.39619800448417664,
0.1125936508178711,
-0.13115647435188293,
0.6790679693222046,
-0.10396107286214828,
-0.2909058630466461,
0.4973042607307434,
-0.052369557321071625,
0.005105080548673868,
-0.016940588131546974,
0.8523180484771729,
0.6581431031227112,
0.3546169698238373,
-0.2152721881866455,
-0.3506425619125366,
0.11224732547998428,
-0.0027503250166773796,
-0.9368800520896912,
-0.19058474898338318,
0.24178212881088257,
-0.2975524663925171,
-0.6058346629142761,
-0.16521628201007843,
-0.9061166644096375,
-1.1691901683807373,
0.11652421206235886,
0.08813530206680298,
-0.2535673677921295,
-0.0817304253578186,
0.3005545139312744,
-0.33347153663635254,
0.12626126408576965,
0.16809475421905518,
-0.7492059469223022,
0.07688788324594498,
0.6042684316635132,
1.3986088037490845,
-0.12117457389831543,
-0.13190309703350067,
-0.945740282535553,
-0.03944726288318634,
0.017221974208950996,
0.7994283437728882,
-0.5313379168510437,
-0.5367700457572937,
-0.04003208875656128,
-0.08213526010513306,
-0.17417867481708527,
-0.4499357044696808,
0.7182788252830505,
-0.47548708319664,
-0.483344167470932,
-0.2845138609409332,
-0.35625386238098145,
0.009531110525131226,
0.5015546083450317,
-0.514509916305542,
0.9052696824073792,
0.04168187454342842,
-0.7941797971725464,
0.33021703362464905,
-0.585590660572052,
-0.1994345635175705,
0.06668899208307266,
-0.3782641589641571,
-0.3950706422328949,
-0.05096831172704697,
0.2641695439815521,
0.6107827425003052,
-0.30714571475982666,
0.42524829506874084,
-0.4141182601451874,
-0.31282177567481995,
0.019117446616292,
-0.25395041704177856,
0.8577433228492737,
0.05423688888549805,
-0.49270546436309814,
-0.1106029823422432,
-0.823927640914917,
-0.08552183955907822,
0.2126055359840393,
-0.5248726606369019,
-0.36763033270835876,
0.08761121332645416,
-0.16242460906505585,
0.04743897542357445,
0.17220743000507355,
-0.8039767146110535,
0.1450415700674057,
0.2908942699432373,
0.4183250069618225,
0.8569353222846985,
0.084208644926548,
0.05411636456847191,
-0.14827631413936615,
0.6858962178230286,
-0.21233436465263367,
0.23123812675476074,
-0.2502211034297943,
-0.3940025568008423,
-0.11904968321323395,
-0.5055367946624756,
-0.05641993135213852,
1.0659335851669312,
-0.3630460798740387,
0.3975903391838074,
0.05350479856133461,
-0.6831973195075989,
-0.22700783610343933,
0.37267640233039856,
0.5790215730667114,
0.7705431580543518,
0.34360653162002563,
-0.18216973543167114,
-0.38228192925453186,
-0.5539227724075317,
-0.634486973285675,
-0.437595933675766,
0.05443061888217926,
0.1522417813539505,
0.22094514966011047,
-0.47322046756744385,
0.6040372848510742,
-0.4714707136154175,
-0.1370883733034134,
-0.15263310074806213,
0.1447981745004654,
0.3021787703037262,
0.4911642372608185,
1.0182636976242065,
-0.05604792758822441,
-0.2664089798927307,
-0.08613833785057068,
-0.8264190554618835,
-0.5979022979736328,
-0.19235759973526,
-0.017584726214408875,
-0.2687283754348755,
0.8133856654167175,
-0.4844353497028351,
0.21486139297485352,
0.6119712591171265,
-0.6193981766700745,
0.6699760556221008,
0.08581138402223587,
0.10324794054031372,
-0.5939685702323914,
-0.09402277320623398,
0.3793545365333557,
-0.16422417759895325,
-0.7366125583648682,
0.2863209843635559,
0.13362056016921997,
0.06481048464775085,
-0.3471447825431824,
0.4391903877258301,
-0.13435643911361694,
0.1694285124540329,
-0.000036574059777194634,
0.23821882903575897,
-0.2015049159526825,
0.19017641246318817,
-0.3856896460056305,
1.035956621170044,
0.5012927651405334,
-0.2452431172132492,
0.3249608874320984,
0.15688957273960114,
-0.6542525887489319,
0.2628021538257599,
-0.8034879565238953,
0.2557932734489441,
-0.2538454830646515,
0.35211604833602905,
-1.265634298324585,
-0.14417538046836853,
0.46956539154052734,
-0.23770438134670258,
-0.012681958265602589,
-0.5260968804359436,
-0.21582826972007751,
-0.1456989049911499,
-0.747083306312561,
0.28902214765548706,
0.4132770299911499,
-0.60602867603302,
0.39305728673934937,
0.21330183744430542,
-0.42134928703308105,
-0.7539787292480469,
-0.4299446642398834,
0.04206863045692444,
-0.41210439801216125,
-0.7816320657730103,
-0.21218529343605042,
-0.0384896956384182,
-0.352845698595047,
-0.49870744347572327,
-0.0408831425011158,
0.08966325968503952,
0.6668082475662231,
0.4288195073604584,
0.5275573134422302,
-0.02511562779545784,
-0.21438860893249512,
0.16260644793510437,
-0.11974270641803741,
0.39232540130615234,
0.0701209083199501,
0.6778301000595093,
-0.2640171945095062,
-0.04248741641640663,
-0.4729576110839844,
-0.020992189645767212,
0.8527063131332397,
-0.09561757743358612,
0.6476620435714722,
0.5050489902496338,
-0.028380384668707848,
-0.1699674427509308,
-0.6055966019630432,
-0.014796239323914051,
-0.5289799571037292,
0.18646399676799774,
0.0968390554189682,
-0.8749369978904724,
0.7963705658912659,
-0.0882805734872818,
0.10492639988660812,
-0.23946596682071686,
0.3175293207168579,
0.14489945769309998,
0.7152869701385498,
0.5242212414741516,
-0.6348431706428528,
0.7631695866584778,
0.1265748143196106,
0.1430540531873703,
-0.6277897357940674,
-0.39918917417526245,
-0.590942919254303,
-0.3304479122161865,
-0.36266395449638367,
-0.07481717318296432,
0.34976184368133545,
0.1435193568468094,
-0.5080801844596863,
0.2440294623374939,
-0.2964874804019928,
0.9047242403030396,
0.09824635833501816,
0.1257188469171524,
0.13646000623703003,
0.10175168514251709,
-0.1554793268442154,
0.19785849750041962,
-0.028706764802336693,
-0.5943896174430847,
0.8716917037963867,
0.6922224164009094,
0.8287656903266907,
0.04518739879131317,
0.7407101392745972,
0.579118549823761,
0.37828320264816284,
-0.6547514796257019,
0.6610988974571228,
0.0632329136133194,
-0.38696059584617615,
0.006184125319123268,
-0.3342825472354889,
-0.5192773342132568,
0.3083806335926056,
-0.11198735237121582,
-1.0006979703903198,
0.15221641957759857,
0.07978879660367966,
-0.6104015111923218,
0.33460479974746704,
-0.657830536365509,
0.5838897824287415,
-0.12892071902751923,
-0.2845175564289093,
-0.01604742556810379,
-0.7552135586738586,
0.5513362884521484,
-0.1343984454870224,
0.40182971954345703,
-0.5956090092658997,
0.0795283168554306,
0.8677991628646851,
-0.44645148515701294,
0.9078168869018555,
-0.7533721923828125,
-0.3519003689289093,
0.382785439491272,
0.39662477374076843,
0.9027393460273743,
0.4913143217563629,
-0.16810645163059235,
0.1115560308098793,
-0.24918019771575928,
-0.2953319847583771,
-0.46123912930488586,
0.7092785239219666,
-0.5989716053009033,
-0.6682578921318054,
-0.1602901816368103,
-0.5609549283981323,
-0.37404850125312805,
-0.02517947368323803,
0.31505969166755676,
0.07104305922985077,
0.12291684746742249,
-0.1661020815372467,
0.6081418991088867,
-0.10423599928617477,
0.5197106599807739,
0.4780115783214569,
-0.24717509746551514,
-0.4166797697544098,
0.737430214881897,
-0.149179145693779,
0.12221913784742355,
-0.34912109375,
0.24288393557071686,
0.014306613244116306,
-0.8470832109451294,
-0.7836654782295227,
0.15257026255130768,
-0.6434120535850525,
-0.33794111013412476,
-0.3827660381793976,
-0.04104773327708244,
0.11058838665485382,
-0.36190637946128845,
0.07345671206712723,
-0.1949830949306488,
-0.22550399601459503,
-0.4965249001979828,
0.7691407799720764,
0.41655033826828003,
-0.237076997756958,
0.524268627166748,
-1.159679651260376,
0.20851479470729828,
0.17960576713085175,
0.19243019819259644,
-0.12412027269601822,
-0.59568190574646,
0.16340963542461395,
-0.25751936435699463,
-0.13651466369628906,
-0.8434771299362183,
-0.05115475505590439,
0.12287049740552902,
0.394702285528183,
0.7605311274528503,
-0.0071425894275307655,
0.39308613538742065,
-0.5263930559158325,
0.793114960193634,
0.3821897506713867,
-0.8531748056411743,
0.6674450635910034,
-0.6304635405540466,
-0.401000052690506,
1.0882548093795776,
0.14217370748519897,
-0.5316377878189087,
-0.33188921213150024,
-0.0544472374022007,
-0.8239180445671082,
0.3694531321525574,
-0.11112603545188904,
0.3963436782360077,
-0.13029567897319794,
0.5877434611320496,
0.15562643110752106,
0.1286492943763733,
-0.6191552877426147,
-0.18202906847000122,
0.20484483242034912,
0.01335593406111002,
0.15788312256336212,
-0.3502582013607025,
-0.2880958020687103,
-0.06909287720918655,
0.23935598134994507,
0.0670296773314476,
-0.10811822861433029,
-0.21468159556388855,
-0.008665062487125397,
-0.08627785742282867,
0.3235723078250885,
0.6284295916557312,
0.1841585636138916,
-0.3898749351501465,
-0.11959224194288254,
0.20656567811965942,
-0.9575765132904053,
0.68152916431427,
-0.04402924329042435,
-0.07818739116191864,
0.10834341496229172,
0.4414192736148834,
0.6976712346076965,
-0.4353659749031067,
-1.0488392114639282,
0.8824040293693542,
-0.13004513084888458,
-0.04981378838419914,
0.0052667479030787945,
0.5039291381835938,
-0.40072906017303467,
0.3842378854751587,
0.22871868312358856,
0.14171411097049713,
0.1390368789434433,
-0.31019386649131775,
0.20169727504253387,
0.424532949924469,
-0.40721186995506287,
-0.2823406159877777,
0.47900885343551636,
0.30997854471206665,
-0.13778413832187653,
0.5546966195106506,
-0.3286867141723633,
-0.3012754023075104,
0.8155200481414795,
0.6481226086616516,
0.9940918684005737,
-0.4186468720436096,
0.3549458384513855,
0.15247145295143127,
0.4401921033859253,
-0.2144831418991089,
0.5013532638549805,
0.047464389353990555,
-0.66658616065979,
-0.3508663475513458,
-0.4155120253562927,
-0.16886623203754425,
0.2344997227191925,
-0.8070021271705627,
0.35863056778907776,
-1.1275559663772583,
-0.1529356986284256,
-0.40091580152511597,
-0.6451408863067627,
-0.08655162900686264,
-0.02469203993678093,
0.21051305532455444,
1.2487341165542603,
-1.3255444765090942,
0.2943711578845978,
0.5476552844047546,
0.014076252467930317,
-0.4994053244590759,
0.1280558854341507,
0.34852880239486694,
-1.0557507276535034,
0.5188161730766296,
0.512497067451477,
-0.4034324586391449,
-0.2507118582725525,
-0.7737268209457397,
-0.6215702891349792,
1.0546787977218628,
0.8268405795097351,
-0.8910931944847107,
0.14132001996040344,
-0.20664776861667633,
0.18927738070487976,
-0.0453018993139267,
0.06736861169338226,
1.1210298538208008,
0.41885730624198914,
-0.2416374534368515,
-0.548241913318634,
0.2517470121383667,
-0.31306442618370056,
-0.21933621168136597,
0.6471729874610901,
-0.5013553500175476,
0.6345343589782715,
-0.597143292427063,
-0.14957137405872345,
0.09142732620239258,
0.18687941133975983,
0.8075996041297913,
0.5773141384124756,
0.4751642644405365,
0.6830918192863464,
0.9340625405311584,
-0.02551494538784027,
0.790122389793396,
-0.42933863401412964,
0.3246738612651825,
0.8781798481941223,
-0.33332207798957825,
0.6754118204116821,
0.5203422904014587,
0.024534830823540688,
0.8812808990478516,
0.6402485966682434,
0.006546305026859045,
0.8388742208480835,
0.4351460337638855,
-0.6354104280471802,
-0.18254268169403076,
-0.19001349806785583,
-0.5845206379890442,
0.002341910032555461,
0.47044482827186584,
-0.268614262342453,
-0.4914766848087311,
0.221880704164505,
0.4528219699859619,
-0.1477382481098175,
-0.4843568801879883,
0.5087778568267822,
0.035566531121730804,
-0.20145462453365326,
0.7766700387001038,
-0.03300612419843674,
0.5196923613548279,
-0.44906261563301086,
0.15092097222805023,
-0.43538862466812134,
0.08268235623836517,
-0.36963096261024475,
-0.7484081387519836,
-0.08290241658687592,
0.43204861879348755,
0.1294584572315216,
0.2492830902338028,
0.6919015049934387,
0.15580524504184723,
-0.12134674191474915,
0.6391556262969971,
0.2918661832809448,
0.023762116208672523,
0.056167010217905045,
-0.5741159915924072,
0.2675632834434509,
-0.018575536087155342,
-0.3615395724773407,
0.4437040686607361,
0.20867115259170532,
-0.08028330653905869,
0.8360881209373474,
0.7095425724983215,
-0.09869451075792313,
0.13124805688858032,
-0.040211208164691925,
1.1904406547546387,
-0.41739019751548767,
-0.5266589522361755,
-1.263240933418274,
0.512895941734314,
0.08333837240934372,
-0.48261189460754395,
0.5059986114501953,
0.1846209019422531,
0.510857880115509,
-0.056337129324674606,
1.042038083076477,
0.006590532138943672,
0.045001640915870667,
-0.7721741795539856,
0.5408417582511902,
-0.0771908313035965,
0.6551875472068787,
-0.23315604031085968,
-0.6608275175094604,
-0.4618951678276062,
0.546855628490448,
-0.4125158190727234,
-0.1919538527727127,
0.4890251159667969,
1.0547964572906494,
0.08340468257665634,
0.09772785007953644,
-0.08032587915658951,
-0.19837597012519836,
0.38329604268074036,
0.5249687433242798,
1.0446343421936035,
-0.1329783797264099,
0.34118199348449707,
0.2851487994194031,
-0.47491979598999023,
-0.21048390865325928,
-1.0046366453170776,
-1.1846033334732056,
0.047816235572099686,
-0.2606160044670105,
-0.7048662900924683,
0.35470983386039734,
1.061732292175293,
0.19794830679893494,
-0.8442606925964355,
-0.12665396928787231,
-0.3965480923652649,
-0.06729228049516678,
0.055056411772966385,
-0.14019298553466797,
0.049161940813064575,
-0.4635058641433716,
0.03958470746874809,
0.71761554479599,
0.2883235812187195,
0.00749718863517046,
0.05411475896835327,
-0.07034765183925629,
0.1754082441329956,
0.0650346502661705,
0.35727259516716003,
0.47732189297676086,
-0.2504080832004547,
-0.3400275707244873,
-0.3070269525051117,
-0.05764489993453026,
-0.020679324865341187,
0.8809071779251099,
-0.5745354890823364,
0.0312570184469223,
0.593460202217102,
1.0010324716567993,
-0.10553423315286636,
0.052342478185892105,
0.12641403079032898,
-0.8175981044769287,
0.24143452942371368,
-0.03982805460691452,
0.5735873579978943,
0.15176454186439514,
-0.4904790222644806,
0.5021329522132874,
0.27914106845855713,
-0.6105851531028748,
-0.882829487323761,
0.2739966809749603,
-0.5613113641738892,
-0.09135860949754715,
1.4630961418151855,
-0.3847198486328125,
-0.07813405990600586,
-0.2602913975715637,
-0.37939608097076416,
-0.3494923710823059,
-0.7773057818412781,
0.9473318457603455,
0.5353655815124512,
0.038444869220256805,
0.05661478266119957,
-0.6876357793807983,
0.3583984971046448,
0.25323694944381714,
-0.7483506798744202,
0.3106360137462616,
0.4567018449306488,
0.5713774561882019,
0.1466757208108902,
0.41606375575065613,
-0.005125143565237522,
0.5000737905502319,
-0.324537456035614,
-0.20440885424613953,
-0.18488554656505585,
-0.4044630229473114,
-0.7082507610321045,
0.20674200356006622,
0.16220124065876007,
-0.398659348487854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13492v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13492v3
|
Retrieval Helps or Hurts? A Deeper Dive into the Efficacy of Retrieval Augmentation to Language Models
| 2024-02-21T03:05:50 | 2024-03-27T18:48:34 |
Seiji Maekawa, Hayate Iso, Sairam Gurajada, Nikita Bhutani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While large language models (LMs) demonstrate remarkable performance, they
encounter challenges in providing accurate responses when queried for
information beyond their pre-trained memorization. Although augmenting them
with relevant external information can mitigate these issues, failure to
consider the necessity of retrieval may adversely affect overall performance.
Previous research has primarily focused on examining how entities influence
retrieval models and knowledge recall in LMs, leaving other aspects relatively
unexplored. In this work, our goal is to offer a more detailed, fact-centric
analysis by exploring the effects of combinations of entities and relations. To
facilitate this, we construct a new question answering (QA) dataset called
WiTQA (Wikipedia Triple Question Answers). This dataset includes questions
about entities and relations of various popularity levels, each accompanied by
a supporting passage. Our extensive experiments with diverse LMs and retrievers
reveal when retrieval does not consistently enhance LMs from the viewpoints of
fact-centric popularity. Confirming earlier findings, we observe that larger
LMs excel in recalling popular facts. However, they notably encounter
difficulty with infrequent entity-relation pairs compared to retrievers.
Interestingly, they can effectively retain popular relations of less common
entities. We demonstrate the efficacy of our finer-grained metric and insights
through an adaptive retrieval system that selectively employs retrieval and
recall based on the frequencies of entities and relations in the question.
|
[
-0.5076439380645752,
-0.7973071336746216,
0.7396401762962341,
-0.09269992262125015,
-0.12355929613113403,
0.019160853698849678,
-0.11102955043315887,
-0.6300237774848938,
0.3886517584323883,
0.4557245075702667,
-0.1260710209608078,
-0.12255115061998367,
-0.38808736205101013,
-0.0008331223507411778,
-0.4413575530052185,
1.0413992404937744,
0.30316096544265747,
0.06987668573856354,
-0.4269203841686249,
-0.39081794023513794,
-0.6184863448143005,
-0.6140757203102112,
-0.44842785596847534,
-0.12840276956558228,
0.8097124099731445,
0.46958598494529724,
0.9458371996879578,
0.3297571837902069,
0.5985921621322632,
0.23103395104408264,
-0.19963140785694122,
0.2235567420721054,
-0.6866268515586853,
0.250095397233963,
-0.33792901039123535,
-0.6410747766494751,
-0.058036353439092636,
-0.17024792730808258,
0.5842156410217285,
0.9416090250015259,
-0.307730495929718,
0.23364023864269257,
0.00879574567079544,
0.6966937780380249,
-0.8762117624282837,
0.007462202105671167,
-0.9317041635513306,
-0.21632134914398193,
-0.22386033833026886,
-0.0992821753025055,
-0.25826144218444824,
-0.6444560289382935,
0.47174349427223206,
-0.5968611836433411,
0.07322964072227478,
0.20915426313877106,
0.8802237510681152,
0.06164214015007019,
-0.5267532467842102,
-0.5194785594940186,
-0.7193009853363037,
0.6084296107292175,
-0.441439688205719,
0.6854138374328613,
0.12455711513757706,
0.03847142681479454,
0.0014403964160010219,
-0.631516695022583,
-0.5443891882896423,
-0.22297506034374237,
-0.24759098887443542,
-0.051336415112018585,
-0.14847040176391602,
-0.12712262570858002,
0.41721829771995544,
0.5439597964286804,
-0.2062772810459137,
-0.1621004343032837,
-0.43241816759109497,
-0.2168949991464615,
0.3816731870174408,
0.06998306512832642,
0.6294630169868469,
-0.38548168540000916,
-0.3424753248691559,
0.00840621255338192,
-0.8944907188415527,
0.1569705605506897,
0.18247143924236298,
0.12030433118343353,
0.607741117477417,
0.6251353621482849,
-0.1654033660888672,
0.46478772163391113,
-0.0406971275806427,
-0.021023238077759743,
0.317814439535141,
-0.24081285297870636,
0.13438864052295685,
-0.029331322759389877,
0.5491410493850708,
0.27248919010162354,
0.27061349153518677,
-0.5240730047225952,
-0.12637221813201904,
-0.4280657470226288,
0.35365092754364014,
-0.7788188457489014,
-0.12344138324260712,
-0.027954885736107826,
-0.3195286691188812,
0.14031565189361572,
0.2773449420928955,
-0.5276002287864685,
-0.4301636219024658,
-0.24109040200710297,
0.8734201192855835,
-0.7648552656173706,
-0.42030805349349976,
0.015658313408493996,
-0.5171155333518982,
0.14765767753124237,
0.22318176925182343,
-0.814557671546936,
0.20140953361988068,
0.6764280200004578,
0.7607790231704712,
-0.06477004289627075,
-0.09255863726139069,
-0.4926104247570038,
0.15270119905471802,
-0.4978152811527252,
0.7027740478515625,
-0.5281691551208496,
-0.33707520365715027,
0.019119281321763992,
-0.08519912511110306,
0.012436444871127605,
-0.7448846697807312,
0.532326877117157,
-1.0336170196533203,
0.15585197508335114,
-0.9546915292739868,
-0.7118008136749268,
-0.30079659819602966,
0.15111465752124786,
-1.1625432968139648,
0.9707080721855164,
0.004021698608994484,
-0.9627599120140076,
0.3047131299972534,
-0.28223806619644165,
-0.44180041551589966,
-0.06518969684839249,
-0.07674757391214371,
-0.07592742890119553,
0.4436972737312317,
0.08193503320217133,
0.27240103483200073,
-0.17346832156181335,
0.05996427312493324,
-0.4426792562007904,
-0.40815210342407227,
0.42618581652641296,
-0.11458580195903778,
0.5964921712875366,
-0.05119491368532181,
0.08092032372951508,
-0.3316670358181,
-0.6490591168403625,
-0.21793973445892334,
0.12512558698654175,
-0.4349024295806885,
-0.8371486663818359,
0.04232975095510483,
-0.5608338713645935,
0.26909616589546204,
0.20209014415740967,
-0.7097857594490051,
0.0864480659365654,
-0.41627049446105957,
-0.12200403213500977,
0.4399028718471527,
0.45771223306655884,
0.566600501537323,
-0.35823386907577515,
0.2633635103702545,
0.04991520196199417,
0.010141384787857533,
0.06588758528232574,
-0.40743502974510193,
-0.6783313751220703,
0.22430402040481567,
0.29137882590293884,
0.3391433656215668,
-1.2186872959136963,
-0.2760584354400635,
-0.4112546741962433,
-0.5032979846000671,
-0.6384140253067017,
0.3687748610973358,
0.19832751154899597,
0.7287024259567261,
0.5159443020820618,
-0.3652198016643524,
-0.5711179971694946,
-0.9609314799308777,
-0.4761631488800049,
-0.29111379384994507,
0.02056075632572174,
0.49532201886177063,
0.30965158343315125,
0.3272218108177185,
0.9448196291923523,
-0.658134937286377,
-0.18196876347064972,
-0.07614810019731522,
-0.2896977663040161,
0.042465418577194214,
0.05489915981888771,
0.69833904504776,
-0.9394726157188416,
-0.2200072705745697,
-0.25583574175834656,
-0.6116236448287964,
0.16360589861869812,
0.19673511385917664,
-0.17528438568115234,
-0.00876191072165966,
0.17086292803287506,
-0.8478820323944092,
0.12571273744106293,
0.19781552255153656,
-0.0940728411078453,
0.3950880467891693,
-0.036015309393405914,
0.32805612683296204,
-0.763828456401825,
0.016852498054504395,
-0.15135031938552856,
0.09759364277124405,
-0.7331838607788086,
0.12363164126873016,
0.2573211193084717,
0.1831590086221695,
-0.45823773741722107,
0.4244711399078369,
-0.3976666331291199,
-0.20088310539722443,
-0.09111720323562622,
0.3845234811306,
0.20836547017097473,
0.20502297580242157,
0.015253678895533085,
0.9894663095474243,
0.298321396112442,
-1.004149079322815,
0.2934351861476898,
0.13933967053890228,
-0.37580305337905884,
0.4583083689212799,
-0.5092450380325317,
0.2612217962741852,
-0.4765816330909729,
-0.04318099841475487,
-0.8294782042503357,
-0.23295482993125916,
0.04074641317129135,
-0.39806440472602844,
0.3952718675136566,
0.07321421056985855,
-0.4831008315086365,
-0.21128734946250916,
-0.4457053244113922,
0.12373324483633041,
0.21766339242458344,
-0.626361072063446,
0.6300519704818726,
0.5775367617607117,
-0.19245703518390656,
-0.7283103466033936,
-0.4771000146865845,
0.04727279767394066,
-0.3476601243019104,
-0.519416868686676,
0.27700990438461304,
-0.21238844096660614,
-0.4992706775665283,
0.20737618207931519,
-0.2235865592956543,
0.017589246854186058,
0.39198023080825806,
0.04236547276377678,
0.2799440324306488,
-0.33794209361076355,
0.7730130553245544,
-0.299967497587204,
0.28606581687927246,
0.167608380317688,
-0.10480326414108276,
0.2926611304283142,
-0.06380520015954971,
-0.18878977000713348,
-0.011450298130512238,
0.27884575724601746,
0.2329290807247162,
-0.31302395462989807,
1.1375374794006348,
0.4374110996723175,
-0.3889685273170471,
0.0976012721657753,
-0.8892176747322083,
-0.3572198152542114,
-0.39573925733566284,
0.4889402985572815,
-0.47045621275901794,
-0.8670416474342346,
0.4170773923397064,
0.25796106457710266,
0.058305758982896805,
0.5981158018112183,
0.19869056344032288,
-0.17778702080249786,
0.8723084330558777,
0.3315371870994568,
-0.2652689218521118,
0.610309898853302,
-0.09886153787374496,
0.1700562685728073,
-0.9272980093955994,
-0.4446485936641693,
-0.5487988591194153,
-0.21023023128509521,
-0.4587625563144684,
-0.18270044028759003,
0.3369634449481964,
0.36424893140792847,
0.018452869728207588,
0.24864152073860168,
-0.09171001613140106,
0.2735555171966553,
0.46332302689552307,
0.37555670738220215,
0.5463560819625854,
0.007761504501104355,
0.2281486541032791,
-0.1560487598180771,
-0.7959005236625671,
-0.3331848680973053,
1.0827292203903198,
0.21553952991962433,
0.6269650459289551,
0.6904975771903992,
0.6554297208786011,
-0.021013950929045677,
0.4347579777240753,
-0.8577192425727844,
0.43261468410491943,
0.05911416932940483,
-0.9745365977287292,
-0.23332475125789642,
-0.6942019462585449,
-0.9894428253173828,
0.3388557732105255,
-0.2514456808567047,
-0.7480477690696716,
0.33700448274612427,
0.009153680875897408,
-0.5219680666923523,
0.25987711548805237,
-0.852364718914032,
0.3576112687587738,
-0.19615353643894196,
-0.40477240085601807,
-0.24747253954410553,
-0.2570548355579376,
0.48559704422950745,
-0.15587446093559265,
0.24295686185359955,
0.03852641582489014,
-0.2561180293560028,
0.8245587348937988,
-0.1439105123281479,
0.37025269865989685,
-0.13916194438934326,
-0.16241300106048584,
0.40456175804138184,
0.1408456265926361,
0.27715930342674255,
0.06514296680688858,
-0.40070468187332153,
-0.2755427360534668,
0.10278823971748352,
-0.34067773818969727,
-1.0525497198104858,
0.9509885907173157,
-0.5264829993247986,
-1.0109981298446655,
-0.06905009597539902,
-0.5593864321708679,
-0.5670537948608398,
0.10343264043331146,
-0.14256200194358826,
0.44844430685043335,
-0.20802660286426544,
0.6059133410453796,
1.0154756307601929,
-0.04903162643313408,
0.4538789987564087,
0.6340264081954956,
-0.2645205557346344,
-0.19626452028751373,
1.0188288688659668,
0.6479010581970215,
0.379465788602829,
0.37909170985221863,
-0.07519318908452988,
-0.41577205061912537,
-0.44302234053611755,
-0.29024651646614075,
0.2866028845310211,
-0.821551501750946,
-0.3312157988548279,
-0.8621844053268433,
-0.058490559458732605,
-0.4242912232875824,
0.658883273601532,
-0.1601659208536148,
-0.6529524922370911,
-0.28764185309410095,
-0.28064021468162537,
0.4705483317375183,
0.8529906868934631,
0.029569530859589577,
-0.11431016772985458,
-0.8612054586410522,
0.29943761229515076,
0.5696002244949341,
0.38248035311698914,
0.18873737752437592,
-0.47991299629211426,
-0.26369595527648926,
-0.0015810532495379448,
-0.19756877422332764,
-1.2358015775680542,
-0.03602521866559982,
0.32448092103004456,
0.6574873328208923,
0.2103632241487503,
0.1290324181318283,
0.6721062064170837,
-0.3191477060317993,
0.7124847769737244,
-0.05424663424491882,
-0.4883935749530792,
0.41412848234176636,
0.13465262949466705,
-0.018825281411409378,
0.6030006408691406,
0.6279863119125366,
-0.5033305883407593,
-0.21124275028705597,
-0.6870245933532715,
-0.7782400250434875,
0.6223735213279724,
0.11013898998498917,
0.47125986218452454,
-0.28674325346946716,
0.6816908121109009,
-0.045567575842142105,
0.39885544776916504,
-0.49872785806655884,
-0.39578795433044434,
0.07926515489816666,
-0.04501868784427643,
0.1463516652584076,
-0.5488519072532654,
0.20047511160373688,
-0.04098234698176384,
0.9914197325706482,
0.15529100596904755,
-0.09847382456064224,
0.26930955052375793,
-0.4415391683578491,
0.15914854407310486,
0.4026636779308319,
0.014746973291039467,
0.6785039305686951,
-0.24125631153583527,
0.10473384708166122,
0.36683329939842224,
-0.49128350615501404,
-0.14190346002578735,
0.21693821251392365,
-0.27251267433166504,
0.1628633737564087,
0.26772984862327576,
0.7320802807807922,
0.44140949845314026,
-0.5616985559463501,
0.42788681387901306,
-0.05930456891655922,
0.21337498724460602,
-0.03250524774193764,
0.24968892335891724,
0.2911643087863922,
0.22531966865062714,
0.7448153495788574,
-0.2099628448486328,
0.3834120035171509,
-0.9338262677192688,
0.2425442934036255,
0.5900375247001648,
-0.5119923949241638,
-0.1795387715101242,
0.1790355145931244,
-0.04331941902637482,
-0.22058843076229095,
0.4748305380344391,
-0.014740325510501862,
-0.5623357892036438,
0.4126650393009186,
0.31115368008613586,
0.12094974517822266,
-0.2666929066181183,
0.11812447011470795,
0.43031129240989685,
0.20004218816757202,
-0.08549311012029648,
0.22588326036930084,
0.03537736460566521,
-0.7978151440620422,
-0.34488219022750854,
-0.4770538806915283,
-0.13387466967105865,
0.0913342535495758,
-0.8078120350837708,
-0.08599221706390381,
-0.15043094754219055,
-0.25612443685531616,
-0.032017432153224945,
0.2633585035800934,
-0.7278110384941101,
0.2655624747276306,
-0.09705899655818939,
0.9702691435813904,
-0.4484514892101288,
0.6623826622962952,
0.604374885559082,
-0.9916096925735474,
-1.1413915157318115,
0.1360337883234024,
-0.18337060511112213,
-0.5468665957450867,
0.4495159983634949,
-0.03448798134922981,
0.023602481931447983,
0.17633140087127686,
-0.2945820093154907,
-1.1288222074508667,
1.1153388023376465,
0.5172405242919922,
-0.48850852251052856,
-0.1150495782494545,
-0.14843600988388062,
0.5820437073707581,
-0.12439922243356705,
0.42135199904441833,
0.7854079604148865,
0.1797524094581604,
0.0857769250869751,
-0.8132666945457458,
0.04148103669285774,
0.051414068788290024,
-0.21688777208328247,
0.32655423879623413,
-0.6529720425605774,
0.5821011662483215,
-0.3649286925792694,
-0.3107546865940094,
0.08226722478866577,
0.8531136512756348,
0.18263138830661774,
0.2840370535850525,
0.587600588798523,
0.4263899326324463,
1.0442053079605103,
-0.005817133001983166,
1.2252633571624756,
-0.13586969673633575,
0.32331088185310364,
1.1590120792388916,
-0.03830127418041229,
1.0103307962417603,
0.6466333270072937,
-0.1271430402994156,
0.7430989146232605,
0.3698523938655853,
0.37246447801589966,
0.38790005445480347,
-0.027717364951968193,
-0.18266279995441437,
-0.21393640339374542,
-0.5697814226150513,
-0.49872979521751404,
0.2930932343006134,
0.4568162262439728,
-0.4273407459259033,
-0.15250170230865479,
-0.0053189476020634174,
0.09185675531625748,
0.04812418296933174,
-0.30501094460487366,
0.9116883277893066,
0.1781824380159378,
-0.7888903021812439,
0.14123615622520447,
-0.34603917598724365,
0.30960461497306824,
-0.43499037623405457,
-0.05378081277012825,
-0.39781540632247925,
-0.1344430297613144,
-0.2071324586868286,
-0.9766520261764526,
0.16106711328029633,
-0.27671942114830017,
-0.37854108214378357,
0.31881240010261536,
0.9806892275810242,
-0.5111151933670044,
-0.19977973401546478,
0.3880700469017029,
0.7421839237213135,
-0.01898285560309887,
-0.3410337269306183,
-0.45194771885871887,
-0.019801273941993713,
-0.0274308230727911,
-0.27245068550109863,
0.2811942398548126,
0.634075939655304,
0.028352057561278343,
0.6710712313652039,
0.5306612253189087,
0.11114858090877533,
-0.03266676515340805,
0.2400503158569336,
0.9272872805595398,
-0.5832310914993286,
0.034887492656707764,
-0.7345211505889893,
0.3791726529598236,
-0.3418968915939331,
0.0007310258806683123,
1.0480051040649414,
0.656275749206543,
0.6265864372253418,
0.12534350156784058,
0.458505243062973,
0.007212718017399311,
0.7148969769477844,
-0.5651544332504272,
0.4536440074443817,
-0.6448689103126526,
0.5200752019882202,
-0.2914228141307831,
-0.9465427398681641,
-0.04608362540602684,
0.12725655734539032,
-0.5626124143600464,
0.12814898788928986,
0.5441910028457642,
0.8091340065002441,
0.00482022762298584,
0.11921127140522003,
0.2247636467218399,
0.30470556020736694,
0.1295088529586792,
0.45597583055496216,
1.1124321222305298,
-0.42163950204849243,
1.0326240062713623,
-0.3569173216819763,
0.12247449159622192,
-0.1609509140253067,
-0.3760206401348114,
-0.6384183764457703,
-0.5635600090026855,
-0.16695961356163025,
-0.48665839433670044,
0.16686178743839264,
0.7854118347167969,
0.4614778459072113,
-0.6652112007141113,
0.2787449061870575,
0.3797784745693207,
0.5186694264411926,
0.19183418154716492,
-0.2914245128631592,
0.40196144580841064,
-0.42234164476394653,
-0.6154069304466248,
0.23089998960494995,
0.11149923503398895,
-0.1334357112646103,
-0.15480297803878784,
-0.026600677520036697,
-0.37946298718452454,
0.13076883554458618,
0.5279234051704407,
0.15850941836833954,
-0.5931890606880188,
-0.5681033134460449,
0.23358246684074402,
-0.1749749630689621,
-0.0138836819678545,
0.860363781452179,
-0.9607728719711304,
0.4072090983390808,
0.46588125824928284,
0.7810937762260437,
0.2195785939693451,
0.2068014144897461,
0.49226847290992737,
-0.6851248741149902,
-0.27856239676475525,
0.14545585215091705,
0.45873793959617615,
0.6603564620018005,
-0.5109109282493591,
0.32743752002716064,
0.2598761022090912,
-0.366748571395874,
-0.6422210335731506,
0.1363612562417984,
-0.3322494328022003,
-0.41039735078811646,
1.1277474164962769,
-0.0927993506193161,
-0.18556010723114014,
-0.2682240307331085,
-0.3214159607887268,
0.12959560751914978,
-0.47538527846336365,
0.7611764669418335,
0.981825590133667,
-0.06966598331928253,
-0.261270135641098,
-0.6574894189834595,
0.574224591255188,
0.4959206283092499,
-0.48653391003608704,
-0.2711244225502014,
0.6511414647102356,
0.5320889353752136,
0.4554772675037384,
0.48162078857421875,
0.04760728031396866,
0.28757378458976746,
-0.29031333327293396,
-0.22232544422149658,
0.1640174835920334,
-0.16159090399742126,
-0.20852626860141754,
0.44790077209472656,
0.38355204463005066,
0.00873863697052002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13485v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13485v1
|
ProPD: Dynamic Token Tree Pruning and Generation for LLM Parallel Decoding
| 2024-02-21T02:51:07 | 2024-02-21T02:51:07 |
Shuzhang Zhong, Zebin Yang, Meng Li, Ruihao Gong, Runsheng Wang, Ru Huang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in generative large language models (LLMs) have
significantly boosted the performance in natural language processing tasks.
However, their efficiency is hampered by the inherent limitations in
autoregressive token generation. While parallel decoding with token tree
verification, e.g., Medusa, has been proposed to improve decoding parallelism
and efficiency, it often struggles with maintaining contextual relationships
due to its independent token prediction approach and incurs significant
verification overhead, especially with large tree sizes and batch processing.
In this paper, we propose ProPD, an efficient LLM parallel decoding framework
based on dynamic token tree pruning and generation. ProPD features an advanced
early pruning mechanism to efficiently eliminate unpromising token sequences to
improve verification efficiency. Additionally, it introduces a dynamic token
tree generation algorithm to balance the computation and parallelism of the
verification phase in real-time and maximize the overall efficiency across
different batch sizes, sequence lengths, and tasks, etc. We verify ProPD across
a diverse set of datasets, LLMs, and batch sizes and demonstrate ProPD
consistently outperforms existing decoding algorithms by 1.1-3.2x.
|
[
-0.27919289469718933,
-0.8777064681053162,
0.1840837150812149,
0.3085908591747284,
-0.8999338746070862,
0.44938817620277405,
-0.27686306834220886,
-0.1979805827140808,
0.06623795628547668,
0.30876320600509644,
-0.7251031994819641,
-0.681002140045166,
-0.4522569477558136,
0.5526886582374573,
-0.2508239150047302,
0.4943374991416931,
-0.03435962274670601,
-0.12795637547969818,
-0.10395726561546326,
-0.27341800928115845,
-0.6128272414207458,
-0.7941194772720337,
-0.9270224571228027,
0.15773199498653412,
0.2728208899497986,
0.4980536103248596,
0.4567570090293884,
1.2008800506591797,
0.6746000647544861,
0.33584681153297424,
-0.16085511445999146,
0.8724743127822876,
-0.3725256621837616,
0.4764958322048187,
0.1111799031496048,
-0.5132972002029419,
-0.45517244935035706,
-0.5022801756858826,
0.9252245426177979,
0.25486820936203003,
-0.19361859560012817,
0.16644413769245148,
-0.16590656340122223,
0.3492560088634491,
-0.4849725663661957,
0.4406348764896393,
-0.8274691104888916,
0.030526213347911835,
-0.5419633388519287,
-0.4671843945980072,
-0.4896813929080963,
-0.34414881467819214,
-0.6448460817337036,
-0.5427535176277161,
0.3060992360115051,
0.27632707357406616,
0.7837051153182983,
0.561714231967926,
-0.7427424788475037,
0.0026261655148118734,
-0.6389032602310181,
0.4795635938644409,
-0.6118789911270142,
0.339190810918808,
-0.004510267172008753,
0.33882734179496765,
-0.40133771300315857,
-1.0521682500839233,
-0.8314179182052612,
-0.1806667000055313,
0.0427292138338089,
-0.2549316883087158,
-0.005420433357357979,
0.29473352432250977,
0.26023152470588684,
0.7360885143280029,
-0.3844767212867737,
0.21831336617469788,
0.0614321231842041,
-0.36676034331321716,
0.1966177076101303,
0.2653312087059021,
0.269562304019928,
-0.16623131930828094,
-0.38408368825912476,
-0.4127335250377655,
-0.9822172522544861,
-0.04584307596087456,
0.34012678265571594,
0.28967446088790894,
0.11145242303609848,
0.5714764595031738,
0.02107764594256878,
0.7053976058959961,
0.049637626856565475,
-0.3857622444629669,
0.21226654946804047,
-0.5916580557823181,
-0.2170688509941101,
0.15372918546199799,
0.6649147272109985,
0.3885742723941803,
0.07386118173599243,
0.05411722883582115,
-0.2682529389858246,
0.2595352232456207,
0.033572278916835785,
-0.9723688960075378,
-0.020519182085990906,
0.13916528224945068,
-0.5306743383407593,
-0.4917474389076233,
0.09864778816699982,
-0.46173229813575745,
-0.24482259154319763,
-0.18458694219589233,
-0.24621380865573883,
-0.4706803262233734,
-0.5363631844520569,
0.16542363166809082,
0.17036272585391998,
0.0382484532892704,
-0.0031518246978521347,
-0.7174577116966248,
0.3989247679710388,
1.2246403694152832,
0.6927323341369629,
-0.43857067823410034,
-0.18197281658649445,
-1.0475255250930786,
0.00830503087490797,
-0.38916879892349243,
0.3989954888820648,
-0.36548808217048645,
-0.20240439474582672,
-0.0904323160648346,
0.07897251844406128,
-0.09149840474128723,
-0.7145873308181763,
0.7821624875068665,
-0.6351068615913391,
-0.42388081550598145,
-0.23344963788986206,
-0.5813961029052734,
-0.019882535561919212,
0.4127376675605774,
-0.5770811438560486,
0.8354900479316711,
0.09023015946149826,
-1.046122670173645,
0.4880801737308502,
-0.3781062364578247,
-0.6435216069221497,
0.21348248422145844,
-0.362785279750824,
-0.4710504412651062,
0.38415175676345825,
0.41345369815826416,
0.25029343366622925,
-0.4521957337856293,
0.6819025278091431,
-0.11425337195396423,
-0.2868121862411499,
-0.07956856489181519,
-0.8497265577316284,
0.6363837122917175,
0.5124185681343079,
-0.22716274857521057,
0.3954262137413025,
-0.8941025137901306,
-0.24389870464801788,
0.25625696778297424,
-0.35187864303588867,
-0.2011057734489441,
0.0764458030462265,
-0.01959255523979664,
-0.143121138215065,
0.1091858372092247,
-0.80674809217453,
0.3967331349849701,
-0.5160457491874695,
0.4342794120311737,
0.8169977068901062,
0.348192036151886,
0.02838733233511448,
0.08409083634614944,
0.6679773926734924,
0.2769097089767456,
0.15738365054130554,
-0.5301409363746643,
-0.20082378387451172,
-0.7450226545333862,
-0.5793532133102417,
0.40852412581443787,
0.23879410326480865,
-0.8541068434715271,
0.5901421904563904,
-0.3357716500759125,
-0.1420397162437439,
-0.35532400012016296,
-0.0841483324766159,
0.4042911231517792,
0.6037571430206299,
0.046043481677770615,
-0.22452516853809357,
-0.6067904233932495,
-0.7916219830513,
-0.15809419751167297,
-0.28323230147361755,
0.13030287623405457,
0.1343836486339569,
0.16278405487537384,
-0.04020222648978233,
1.0011844635009766,
-0.40977153182029724,
-0.18637602031230927,
-0.27844613790512085,
-0.09747783094644547,
0.30944037437438965,
0.6440302729606628,
0.3241397440433502,
-0.7531663179397583,
-0.41225382685661316,
0.12639226019382477,
-0.42573195695877075,
-0.0623842217028141,
-0.29537737369537354,
0.1162506714463234,
0.04410871863365173,
0.6577877402305603,
-0.8515346646308899,
0.24257037043571472,
0.4657370150089264,
-0.6021374464035034,
0.7114742994308472,
-0.5684167146682739,
-0.0609981007874012,
-0.9365556836128235,
0.010671264491975307,
-0.5487526655197144,
-0.6163623332977295,
-0.25128936767578125,
0.25995445251464844,
0.11241931468248367,
-0.14775441586971283,
-0.45163652300834656,
0.3613700866699219,
-0.6743547916412354,
-0.16099929809570312,
-0.3041287660598755,
-0.3138374388217926,
-0.012867608107626438,
0.2535615861415863,
-0.132407084107399,
0.9939804077148438,
0.4649306535720825,
-0.5770258903503418,
0.6517062187194824,
-0.1154097467660904,
-0.4297034442424774,
0.21111439168453217,
-0.45245155692100525,
-0.043612509965896606,
-0.08060234785079956,
0.5164388418197632,
-0.7092836499214172,
-0.16680312156677246,
0.1860736608505249,
-0.1050979346036911,
0.34426936507225037,
-0.05128386244177818,
-0.8754666447639465,
-0.6113260388374329,
-0.10383516550064087,
0.83173006772995,
0.4689924120903015,
-0.879895031452179,
0.528732419013977,
0.2417302131652832,
0.20147015154361725,
-0.5454297065734863,
-0.448248952627182,
0.24849142134189606,
-0.27091705799102783,
-0.6364215612411499,
0.5980316400527954,
0.07670719176530838,
-0.2889229655265808,
-0.03384670242667198,
-0.3540910482406616,
0.1046728789806366,
0.14803417026996613,
0.12282554805278778,
-0.03047844208776951,
-0.30213335156440735,
-0.06759574264287949,
-0.007792706601321697,
-0.33425822854042053,
-0.007239157799631357,
-0.3940693140029907,
0.7373051643371582,
-0.12356415390968323,
-0.7850050926208496,
-0.7141547203063965,
0.10459038615226746,
1.0851922035217285,
-0.5180006623268127,
0.7022193670272827,
0.6570512652397156,
-0.2736757695674896,
-0.37819093465805054,
-0.45641207695007324,
-0.3157154619693756,
-0.5289148092269897,
0.3892214894294739,
-0.7106034755706787,
-0.874382495880127,
0.584889829158783,
-0.2502079904079437,
0.14665724337100983,
0.263936311006546,
0.5356243252754211,
0.49023354053497314,
0.8110651969909668,
0.5719606876373291,
0.051625169813632965,
0.314499169588089,
-0.21676485240459442,
0.26040831208229065,
-0.6299574375152588,
-0.21020328998565674,
-0.2515672445297241,
-0.1801081746816635,
-0.49465933442115784,
-0.8553629517555237,
0.09765855222940445,
0.09115723520517349,
-0.15877370536327362,
0.2649133801460266,
-0.7485914826393127,
0.3952604830265045,
0.5410553216934204,
-0.12683245539665222,
0.5412505865097046,
0.01281253807246685,
-0.45202723145484924,
0.11819268763065338,
-0.745352029800415,
-0.31638064980506897,
0.8001933693885803,
0.5719752907752991,
0.31178373098373413,
-0.1802671104669571,
0.6739896535873413,
0.36041927337646484,
0.2776404917240143,
-0.6507090926170349,
0.8000113368034363,
-0.1545015126466751,
-0.3202679455280304,
-0.06701996922492981,
-0.3974420726299286,
-0.8449217677116394,
0.4636808931827545,
0.15142783522605896,
-0.25216105580329895,
0.290787011384964,
0.3520416021347046,
-0.2216186672449112,
0.6197837591171265,
-0.4398132264614105,
0.7838642597198486,
-0.15679912269115448,
-0.182743638753891,
-0.36230456829071045,
-0.3608788847923279,
0.6099175214767456,
-0.16007600724697113,
0.014509867876768112,
-0.23077544569969177,
-0.1581178456544876,
0.5976378917694092,
-1.1383262872695923,
0.588576078414917,
-0.4241170883178711,
0.02346804179251194,
0.35775700211524963,
0.22268980741500854,
1.0390479564666748,
0.3071272671222687,
-0.1237834244966507,
-0.3013635575771332,
-0.10876928269863129,
-0.1531418412923813,
-0.44349434971809387,
0.7824599146842957,
-0.31133562326431274,
-0.5870655179023743,
-0.3789425790309906,
-0.5236241221427917,
-0.06387203186750412,
0.33208510279655457,
0.060727402567863464,
0.5677814483642578,
-0.032771430909633636,
0.3321492075920105,
0.4468117952346802,
-0.18727649748325348,
0.5319990515708923,
0.27505192160606384,
-0.1281431019306183,
-0.5352997183799744,
0.9321865439414978,
-0.194819837808609,
-0.09753546863794327,
0.3128238618373871,
0.051371775567531586,
-0.4749428331851959,
-0.8701095581054688,
-0.3980361819267273,
0.22736868262290955,
-0.5418452620506287,
-0.5167078375816345,
-0.3368241488933563,
0.03962972015142441,
-0.12118510901927948,
0.1592002809047699,
-0.6654075980186462,
-0.26530539989471436,
-0.1449163854122162,
-0.4291701316833496,
0.4264586865901947,
0.6181609034538269,
0.10748408734798431,
0.3288393020629883,
-0.6114086508750916,
0.5088365077972412,
0.019262565299868584,
0.2149902880191803,
0.11239121854305267,
0.02294774167239666,
0.17238298058509827,
-0.21865762770175934,
0.16140133142471313,
-0.7288019061088562,
0.4749049246311188,
-0.09982909262180328,
0.3160521686077118,
0.6295886039733887,
0.6525529026985168,
0.6351177096366882,
-0.5215221047401428,
0.536858320236206,
0.26086604595184326,
-0.6345155239105225,
-0.08209463953971863,
-0.21576759219169617,
0.201145738363266,
0.4398966431617737,
-0.4081130623817444,
-0.4336129426956177,
-0.27912843227386475,
-0.602358877658844,
-0.9544546008110046,
0.6880467534065247,
0.24821291863918304,
-0.20610575377941132,
-0.4129067361354828,
0.3698922395706177,
0.07103929668664932,
0.22338591516017914,
-0.36587774753570557,
-0.23956289887428284,
-0.030980484560132027,
-0.37951675057411194,
0.12300831079483032,
-0.5445308089256287,
-0.03797001391649246,
-0.3362063765525818,
0.29137343168258667,
0.014535738155245781,
0.18960414826869965,
0.16991014778614044,
0.059321627020835876,
0.21735242009162903,
0.02008224092423916,
0.47460630536079407,
0.5380446910858154,
-0.12879393994808197,
0.46484947204589844,
0.2265101671218872,
-0.5355231165885925,
0.318286269903183,
-0.11575905233621597,
-0.0736597403883934,
0.1736939400434494,
0.2871110737323761,
1.0306347608566284,
-0.06572233885526657,
-0.5815950036048889,
0.5870163440704346,
-0.3104792833328247,
-0.12513700127601624,
-0.21329742670059204,
-0.18557436764240265,
0.027678780257701874,
-0.023346100002527237,
0.482616126537323,
0.08351016044616699,
-0.3576832711696625,
-0.21532396972179413,
0.47158485651016235,
0.3310626447200775,
0.14935530722141266,
-0.27673670649528503,
0.6970579624176025,
0.5141010880470276,
-0.5491739511489868,
0.798701822757721,
-0.3232089877128601,
-0.47231385111808777,
0.8393566608428955,
0.7770227789878845,
1.0065922737121582,
0.09787648916244507,
-0.06379853188991547,
0.3220769762992859,
0.21127088367938995,
0.04194935783743858,
0.20680828392505646,
-0.4081176519393921,
-0.43192631006240845,
-0.7189578413963318,
-0.9775598645210266,
-0.23530235886573792,
0.11921937763690948,
-0.3166739046573639,
0.22425848245620728,
-0.49460113048553467,
-0.19086602330207825,
-0.4175831377506256,
-0.09659647196531296,
-0.46240466833114624,
0.0746849998831749,
-0.058817505836486816,
1.2396701574325562,
-0.5408536195755005,
1.16838538646698,
0.35934051871299744,
0.10905493050813675,
-0.8705127835273743,
0.16677376627922058,
-0.15302380919456482,
-0.5440983176231384,
0.7250486016273499,
0.3261575996875763,
-0.2944492995738983,
0.402093768119812,
0.10513224452733994,
-0.6275045275688171,
0.95171058177948,
0.6107542514801025,
-0.6222072243690491,
0.00106667703948915,
0.11196107417345047,
0.31263643503189087,
-0.5145049095153809,
0.05293303728103638,
0.40769630670547485,
0.6276055574417114,
0.2769434452056885,
-0.6618413329124451,
0.28983286023139954,
-0.13015837967395782,
0.11998680233955383,
0.08588851988315582,
-0.48154380917549133,
0.6648342609405518,
-0.08839096873998642,
-0.5595529675483704,
-0.07112208008766174,
1.027006983757019,
0.4363909959793091,
0.05952020734548569,
0.7189868092536926,
0.45390644669532776,
0.9143922924995422,
-0.0958990529179573,
1.0113885402679443,
-0.7660012245178223,
0.07507820427417755,
0.8185226917266846,
-0.1029781773686409,
0.6797615885734558,
0.48369455337524414,
-0.1424671709537506,
0.17627231776714325,
0.717151403427124,
0.11483049392700195,
0.4661986231803894,
0.33374372124671936,
-0.6786491274833679,
-0.3637082278728485,
-0.18443727493286133,
-0.32421159744262695,
0.25867345929145813,
0.20376867055892944,
-0.18985775113105774,
-0.24565547704696655,
0.2395055890083313,
0.04689681529998779,
0.16333916783332825,
-0.06584855169057846,
0.3369961082935333,
-0.10195593535900116,
-0.8479138016700745,
0.9018832445144653,
0.4099552631378174,
0.8402507901191711,
-0.5426814556121826,
0.049903735518455505,
-0.3422827422618866,
0.6933791041374207,
0.03256066143512726,
-0.34933698177337646,
0.5138949155807495,
-0.07771248370409012,
-0.0661776065826416,
-0.5070371031761169,
0.6872092485427856,
-0.3048681616783142,
-0.4004213809967041,
0.08697501569986343,
0.18071410059928894,
0.07853671163320541,
-0.0496256984770298,
-0.5022202730178833,
0.7836463451385498,
0.20862166583538055,
-0.25649431347846985,
0.15924358367919922,
0.5230392217636108,
-0.21090808510780334,
0.8809311985969543,
0.9943695068359375,
0.19120270013809204,
0.20849208533763885,
0.09154588729143143,
0.9817119240760803,
-0.5050774812698364,
-0.5445184707641602,
-1.0631202459335327,
0.23835517466068268,
-0.11504503339529037,
-0.15880753099918365,
0.8367002606391907,
0.7866193056106567,
0.5962654948234558,
-0.08345939964056015,
0.2583291530609131,
0.03801635652780533,
0.2764708697795868,
-0.2765887975692749,
0.46019431948661804,
-0.17966435849666595,
0.4975890815258026,
0.3463897109031677,
-0.8630344271659851,
-0.38558363914489746,
0.32866472005844116,
0.14339055120944977,
-0.33762264251708984,
0.7877076268196106,
0.8003011345863342,
-0.2242700457572937,
-0.275024950504303,
0.12624220550060272,
0.22590303421020508,
0.7480169534683228,
0.23479190468788147,
0.5149208307266235,
-0.02710188366472721,
0.6686373353004456,
-0.21099886298179626,
-0.1461372822523117,
-0.1914486289024353,
-1.096440315246582,
-0.7243049740791321,
-0.3855747878551483,
-0.3382200598716736,
-0.20851047337055206,
0.10573916882276535,
0.906638503074646,
0.6356925964355469,
-0.6282860636711121,
-0.1713619977235794,
-0.8065372705459595,
0.30920103192329407,
-0.32189467549324036,
-0.23806913197040558,
0.6524204611778259,
-0.4406106770038605,
-0.8696981072425842,
0.6941875219345093,
0.42079415917396545,
-0.05875236541032791,
-0.38204067945480347,
-0.23228000104427338,
-0.017516138032078743,
-0.0663888230919838,
0.4731479585170746,
0.3722154200077057,
-0.7791378498077393,
0.06774061173200607,
-0.17111828923225403,
-0.04036227986216545,
0.002445271471515298,
1.0511813163757324,
-0.9675577282905579,
0.41060930490493774,
0.7074610590934753,
0.7090162038803101,
0.5579560995101929,
0.45621249079704285,
0.8075926303863525,
-0.8458535075187683,
0.4711189866065979,
0.28257930278778076,
0.25902149081230164,
0.28417733311653137,
-0.16893427073955536,
0.22312697768211365,
0.597480058670044,
-0.2558712363243103,
-1.3259527683258057,
0.25657403469085693,
-0.8618928790092468,
-0.24189938604831696,
1.073351502418518,
-0.2503253221511841,
-0.4649902880191803,
-0.07005739212036133,
-0.3625480532646179,
0.4219805896282196,
-0.2512298822402954,
0.10533514618873596,
0.4868415594100952,
0.09177086502313614,
-0.17522862553596497,
-0.15338051319122314,
0.7384437918663025,
0.35037684440612793,
-0.4715907573699951,
0.6637814044952393,
0.4339366853237152,
0.11895029991865158,
-0.21181102097034454,
0.6827988028526306,
-0.1959156095981598,
-0.05256662517786026,
0.14788508415222168,
-0.1437315046787262,
-0.8566826581954956,
-0.30793336033821106,
-0.05009737238287926,
0.6202802062034607,
0.25327184796333313,
-0.6201470494270325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13482v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13482v1
|
Retrieval-Augmented Data Augmentation for Low-Resource Domain Tasks
| 2024-02-21T02:45:46 | 2024-02-21T02:45:46 |
Minju Seo, Jinheon Baek, James Thorne, Sung Ju Hwang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Despite large successes of recent language models on diverse tasks, they
suffer from severe performance degeneration in low-resource settings with
limited training data available. Many existing works tackle this problem by
generating synthetic data from the training data and then training models on
them, recently using Large Language Models (LLMs). However, in low-resource
settings, the amount of seed data samples to use for data augmentation is very
small, which makes generated samples suboptimal and less diverse. To tackle
this challenge, we propose a novel method that augments training data by
incorporating a wealth of examples from other datasets, along with the given
training data. Specifically, we first retrieve the relevant instances from
other datasets, such as their input-output pairs or contexts, based on their
similarities with the given seed data, and then prompt LLMs to generate new
samples with the contextual information within and across the original and
retrieved samples. This approach can ensure that the generated data is not only
relevant but also more diverse than what could be achieved using the limited
seed data alone. We validate our proposed Retrieval-Augmented Data Augmentation
(RADA) framework on multiple datasets under low-resource settings of training
and test-time data augmentation scenarios, on which it outperforms existing
LLM-powered data augmentation baselines.
|
[
-0.4647071659564972,
-0.8113908171653748,
0.2739238739013672,
-0.04881229251623154,
-0.22136464715003967,
0.3495079278945923,
-0.4053874611854553,
-0.4894663393497467,
0.5041657090187073,
0.3347459137439728,
-0.6561399102210999,
-0.31771552562713623,
-0.3555077612400055,
0.11960191279649734,
-0.2212081402540207,
0.6466743350028992,
0.10248079150915146,
-0.07946741580963135,
-0.3496115803718567,
-0.35374537110328674,
-0.690060555934906,
-0.36836084723472595,
-0.09457005560398102,
-0.4112202227115631,
0.4407612979412079,
0.7711202502250671,
0.5265755653381348,
0.6074112057685852,
0.38038739562034607,
0.1713949292898178,
0.11563002318143845,
0.7854156494140625,
-0.5153084993362427,
0.3722364902496338,
-0.1800098866224289,
-0.39082616567611694,
-0.16767264902591705,
-0.03915487229824066,
0.7129079103469849,
0.9826918840408325,
0.027105877175927162,
0.23499232530593872,
0.19743910431861877,
0.5650465488433838,
-0.9791461825370789,
-0.026802226901054382,
-0.7649548649787903,
0.01275416649878025,
-0.34275704622268677,
-0.40981072187423706,
-0.3456189036369324,
-0.2374545931816101,
-0.1283314973115921,
-0.739608645439148,
0.4160343110561371,
0.04947782680392265,
0.5230984687805176,
0.28298479318618774,
-0.22276289761066437,
0.06193495914340019,
-0.8393848538398743,
0.956072986125946,
-0.4616279900074005,
0.3612097501754761,
0.6025238037109375,
0.3720109164714813,
0.05313483253121376,
-0.6088922023773193,
-0.7253819108009338,
-0.04646126925945282,
-0.2956858277320862,
-0.17411808669567108,
-0.04920130595564842,
-0.2388826608657837,
0.5258026123046875,
0.5104363560676575,
-0.37129783630371094,
0.10642560571432114,
-0.3512808084487915,
-0.004170726519078016,
0.4274626672267914,
0.20268255472183228,
0.21462273597717285,
-0.1473933756351471,
-0.17124786972999573,
-0.45383012294769287,
-0.9819257855415344,
-0.24367575347423553,
0.18275544047355652,
0.9014385342597961,
0.008095033466815948,
0.7933963537216187,
-0.5137458443641663,
0.8547283411026001,
-0.011871223337948322,
0.03830381855368614,
0.658031165599823,
-0.6436084508895874,
-0.20233117043972015,
-0.11432234942913055,
0.35143589973449707,
0.0337723083794117,
-0.16193926334381104,
-0.16708427667617798,
-0.25683093070983887,
-0.024069102481007576,
0.07650395482778549,
-0.8343110084533691,
-0.033532850444316864,
-0.06784520298242569,
-0.21616078913211823,
-0.2519366443157196,
-0.14697392284870148,
-0.7261382937431335,
-0.4132430851459503,
-0.27897849678993225,
0.4063347578048706,
-0.47394034266471863,
-0.153816819190979,
-0.02613198570907116,
0.21506235003471375,
0.038977861404418945,
0.10904456675052643,
-0.8722312450408936,
0.14869453012943268,
0.5362856388092041,
0.733987033367157,
-0.20103617012500763,
-0.07565683871507645,
-0.9856004118919373,
0.09120593965053558,
-0.3481135070323944,
0.6842156052589417,
-1.097047209739685,
-0.46658697724342346,
-0.0923936739563942,
-0.03914295881986618,
0.08618193864822388,
-0.7374914288520813,
0.4453350305557251,
-0.6808537840843201,
-0.04792504012584686,
-0.35235533118247986,
-0.3058260977268219,
0.03731940686702728,
0.20942653715610504,
-0.8783590793609619,
1.4562262296676636,
0.335125595331192,
-0.6507528424263,
0.4954521954059601,
-0.48277002573013306,
-0.6788676381111145,
0.18242980539798737,
-0.533306896686554,
-0.2614298462867737,
0.10319192707538605,
0.5860638618469238,
0.2983277440071106,
-0.46062201261520386,
-0.15629731118679047,
-0.2862620949745178,
-0.5015583634376526,
0.03674526512622833,
-0.3535579741001129,
0.3941875100135803,
0.1876523196697235,
0.012973673641681671,
-0.40977993607521057,
-0.7884604334831238,
0.23685447871685028,
0.025398103520274162,
-0.45899343490600586,
-0.8143629431724548,
-0.2661275863647461,
-0.004984610714018345,
0.22823618352413177,
0.13461744785308838,
-0.6968589425086975,
0.5132976770401001,
-0.56593918800354,
0.0713571161031723,
0.3826292157173157,
0.2059706598520279,
0.5720531940460205,
-0.48086878657341003,
0.7221419811248779,
0.03991856053471565,
-0.21252992749214172,
-0.33941346406936646,
-0.1726108193397522,
-0.4140796959400177,
-0.4318782687187195,
0.4940352439880371,
0.3981243371963501,
-1.2380056381225586,
0.25243431329727173,
-0.720770001411438,
-0.27841782569885254,
-0.8595919609069824,
0.40314576029777527,
0.2262834757566452,
0.5622969269752502,
0.5990978479385376,
-0.27136680483818054,
-0.8305608034133911,
-0.8674198985099792,
0.09823603183031082,
0.2348240315914154,
-0.05218625068664551,
0.7568869590759277,
0.2224006950855255,
-0.26965779066085815,
1.1622614860534668,
-0.598227858543396,
-0.3603229522705078,
-0.2377568781375885,
0.05742768943309784,
0.288980096578598,
0.6823541522026062,
0.450688898563385,
-0.7549261450767517,
-0.4136376678943634,
0.0574539452791214,
-0.5423677563667297,
-0.03192193806171417,
-0.012395553290843964,
-0.023133212700486183,
-0.14158542454242706,
0.22076646983623505,
-0.34303340315818787,
0.2644779086112976,
0.4074520766735077,
0.08797140419483185,
0.3005567491054535,
-0.25820082426071167,
0.46835705637931824,
-1.0590702295303345,
0.07271404564380646,
-0.14756567776203156,
-0.16112233698368073,
-0.5049364566802979,
-0.05316314846277237,
0.05021574720740318,
-0.2511061131954193,
-0.29192301630973816,
0.7479066252708435,
-0.4505316913127899,
-0.2984251379966736,
-0.3980160653591156,
-0.006666088942438364,
0.13309994339942932,
0.25977614521980286,
-0.08608841150999069,
1.1689341068267822,
0.6021353602409363,
-0.5143488645553589,
0.24598580598831177,
0.4762343168258667,
-0.5592785477638245,
0.36785104870796204,
-0.4135550856590271,
0.30668962001800537,
-0.1425800323486328,
0.12317433953285217,
-0.8354108929634094,
-0.35205087065696716,
-0.0788184329867363,
-0.35185563564300537,
0.12893083691596985,
-0.37300267815589905,
-0.6767135858535767,
-0.15868449211120605,
-0.16764205694198608,
0.869951069355011,
0.6486889123916626,
-0.9898496270179749,
0.7123796939849854,
0.330165296792984,
-0.16283394396305084,
-0.8848908543586731,
-0.7781325578689575,
-0.07554896920919418,
-0.07560331374406815,
-0.4989498257637024,
0.6553969979286194,
0.0841565728187561,
-0.11388231813907623,
0.06170600280165672,
-0.08020579814910889,
-0.07427868992090225,
-0.052893951535224915,
0.16552042961120605,
0.2925655245780945,
-0.053292736411094666,
0.23186643421649933,
0.17983856797218323,
0.15259020030498505,
-0.3993677496910095,
-0.10359274595975876,
0.5829631686210632,
0.3830668032169342,
-0.6089234352111816,
-0.0035707210190594196,
0.37356483936309814,
0.1572161167860031,
-0.3451097309589386,
0.6592283844947815,
0.5520852208137512,
-0.6837725043296814,
-0.6113410592079163,
-0.5016953349113464,
-0.5270013213157654,
-0.4735108017921448,
0.3300108313560486,
-0.4492504894733429,
-0.75243079662323,
0.37664708495140076,
-0.050902288407087326,
-0.0491257980465889,
0.06687647849321365,
0.45768028497695923,
0.01197392214089632,
0.8701404929161072,
0.5192131996154785,
-0.13747580349445343,
0.6588056683540344,
-0.5287691950798035,
0.0793481320142746,
-0.9487445950508118,
-0.19417022168636322,
-0.39384791254997253,
-0.38950255513191223,
-0.42108049988746643,
-0.9090296030044556,
0.38080546259880066,
0.01917642168700695,
0.18717548251152039,
0.2690442204475403,
-0.4307129383087158,
0.5432130694389343,
0.4634954035282135,
0.38318565487861633,
0.37959718704223633,
0.44443953037261963,
-0.17929325997829437,
-0.16670340299606323,
-0.7482823729515076,
-0.2618699073791504,
1.3450943231582642,
-0.06658081710338593,
0.9385022521018982,
0.004430548753589392,
0.6808080077171326,
0.5397966504096985,
0.4489096403121948,
-0.6032112836837769,
0.4411522150039673,
-0.24834728240966797,
-0.4648381769657135,
-0.07677558809518814,
-0.5594882369041443,
-0.9298461079597473,
0.20424196124076843,
-0.5221690535545349,
-0.3595072627067566,
0.6646403670310974,
0.19310079514980316,
-0.49237528443336487,
0.12926988303661346,
-0.4777590036392212,
0.3021809160709381,
-0.0328473262488842,
-0.6326117515563965,
-0.3971593976020813,
-0.23127202689647675,
0.45994094014167786,
-0.27691709995269775,
0.1198132112622261,
0.08505203574895859,
-0.060545507818460464,
0.6580266952514648,
-0.3996935486793518,
0.6959651708602905,
-0.3067084550857544,
-0.021337388083338737,
0.27993571758270264,
-0.024609582498669624,
0.7896250486373901,
0.053268760442733765,
-0.23735125362873077,
-0.25875696539878845,
-0.41168874502182007,
-0.4240350127220154,
-0.9239954352378845,
0.9269483685493469,
-0.46026280522346497,
-0.3215228319168091,
-0.17232418060302734,
-0.7827473878860474,
-0.6543766260147095,
0.02804969996213913,
-0.24479717016220093,
0.6146444082260132,
0.006190773565322161,
0.44149959087371826,
0.45984208583831787,
-0.2696450650691986,
0.12645770609378815,
0.5888121724128723,
0.12299216538667679,
-0.4331924319267273,
1.0315107107162476,
0.04257288947701454,
0.12017526477575302,
0.2851361930370331,
-0.2243323177099228,
-0.394237756729126,
-0.637194037437439,
-0.3214128315448761,
0.1289128065109253,
-0.5826785564422607,
-0.38018447160720825,
-0.4974876642227173,
0.04385162517428398,
-0.22401154041290283,
0.08619586378335953,
-0.29012659192085266,
-0.5483046174049377,
-0.1326226145029068,
-0.18419310450553894,
0.6043447256088257,
0.3284139633178711,
-0.2971403896808624,
0.29450762271881104,
-0.772158682346344,
0.41935011744499207,
0.2168649584054947,
0.3403732180595398,
0.037736620754003525,
-0.4421412944793701,
-0.6066179275512695,
0.2339240461587906,
-0.02018682099878788,
-0.56776362657547,
0.4926950931549072,
0.23775063455104828,
0.548629105091095,
-0.05427112057805061,
0.14253509044647217,
0.8326780796051025,
-0.44594430923461914,
0.5891953706741333,
-0.1288945972919464,
-0.38273924589157104,
0.6501973867416382,
-0.06115385890007019,
-0.1271168738603592,
0.804516613483429,
0.24963665008544922,
-0.15484729409217834,
0.039165906608104706,
-0.5114373564720154,
-1.0550936460494995,
0.7955738306045532,
0.2066916674375534,
0.3161527216434479,
-0.0035176638048142195,
0.5342655181884766,
0.1668969839811325,
0.07256748527288437,
-0.2647971510887146,
-0.3949762284755707,
0.1486605703830719,
-0.24771907925605774,
0.06607948988676071,
-0.021598918363451958,
-0.21318846940994263,
-0.142644003033638,
0.7562643885612488,
-0.298437237739563,
0.10568136721849442,
0.11537349224090576,
-0.39292964339256287,
-0.09940682351589203,
0.25100386142730713,
0.10943428426980972,
0.6347935795783997,
-0.2880919277667999,
0.02875812165439129,
0.30446797609329224,
-0.5101755857467651,
0.3181738257408142,
0.44984710216522217,
-0.22570350766181946,
0.012944348156452179,
0.161676824092865,
0.7459359765052795,
0.03235433250665665,
-0.8719764947891235,
0.29419177770614624,
0.09488054364919662,
0.24173562228679657,
0.09536561369895935,
0.20341552793979645,
-0.4047200381755829,
0.39740046858787537,
0.7832688093185425,
0.06989327818155289,
0.03276924416422844,
-0.42739227414131165,
0.5833418965339661,
0.5707359313964844,
0.017750969156622887,
-0.1761450469493866,
0.4857456088066101,
0.08762387186288834,
-0.005828859284520149,
0.5833401083946228,
-0.14207343757152557,
0.017117531970143318,
0.3379363417625427,
0.5451456308364868,
0.506692111492157,
0.0423206202685833,
0.049739573150873184,
0.48376691341400146,
0.06025191396474838,
-0.048801127821207047,
0.4580002427101135,
-0.25448623299598694,
-0.9044364094734192,
-0.836059033870697,
-0.5455008745193481,
-0.39115872979164124,
0.42543524503707886,
-0.75178462266922,
0.12587310373783112,
-0.18614764511585236,
-0.21214379370212555,
-0.21390275657176971,
0.24105514585971832,
-0.8991095423698425,
0.2754116654396057,
-0.01341400295495987,
0.9469373822212219,
-0.9313532114028931,
1.0329216718673706,
0.6431118845939636,
-0.5489159822463989,
-0.5402376651763916,
0.03290626406669617,
-0.500999391078949,
-0.9296194314956665,
0.8991817235946655,
-0.16087418794631958,
-0.0010477103060111403,
0.10311724245548248,
-0.17414526641368866,
-0.7936981320381165,
1.1717325448989868,
0.46740633249282837,
-0.5297259092330933,
-0.07593617588281631,
0.24779076874256134,
0.32809245586395264,
-0.5163918137550354,
0.13136917352676392,
0.5796827077865601,
0.36420804262161255,
0.07573550939559937,
-0.5577412843704224,
0.1219169870018959,
-0.3717817962169647,
0.12531058490276337,
-0.10506714880466461,
-0.1896369606256485,
0.6359726190567017,
-0.27201518416404724,
-0.3466799557209015,
-0.03972920402884483,
0.7614448070526123,
0.6137897372245789,
-0.0933450385928154,
0.6206263303756714,
0.616771399974823,
0.8043022751808167,
-0.0633951798081398,
1.1365965604782104,
-0.4004833996295929,
0.28877630829811096,
1.231377363204956,
-0.384346604347229,
0.6984415650367737,
0.4519512951374054,
-0.13372460007667542,
0.2645381689071655,
0.5086889266967773,
0.05129512771964073,
0.8357547521591187,
-0.08434183150529861,
-0.5526810884475708,
-0.28801384568214417,
-0.5058280825614929,
-0.42016029357910156,
0.2778521478176117,
0.3626737892627716,
-0.2876180112361908,
-0.33287060260772705,
0.4494777321815491,
-0.5349081754684448,
0.18258807063102722,
-0.182029128074646,
0.589603066444397,
-0.15528005361557007,
-0.4569994807243347,
0.8281834721565247,
0.13457860052585602,
0.7914386987686157,
-0.39071014523506165,
-0.362199604511261,
-0.4807146191596985,
0.10130099952220917,
-0.11852136999368668,
-0.6269421577453613,
0.18303999304771423,
0.1059877872467041,
-0.3583492636680603,
-0.1799706220626831,
0.7031975388526917,
-0.5761739611625671,
-0.4525291621685028,
0.10404153913259506,
0.7926970720291138,
-0.19472242891788483,
0.15152089297771454,
-0.47176265716552734,
0.215701162815094,
-0.13625462353229523,
-0.02316112443804741,
0.48839569091796875,
0.20504765212535858,
0.026003923267126083,
0.5897549390792847,
0.7980281710624695,
0.42649415135383606,
-0.01115394476801157,
0.21800783276557922,
1.2146307229995728,
-0.5124295353889465,
-0.3815379738807678,
-0.5384477972984314,
0.18032719194889069,
-0.057666290551424026,
0.11486750841140747,
0.6435997486114502,
0.825336754322052,
0.890329897403717,
0.013134896755218506,
1.1088374853134155,
-0.2478436976671219,
0.7850730419158936,
-0.5396461486816406,
0.33520182967185974,
-0.6108090877532959,
0.5594694018363953,
-0.015420448035001755,
-0.8839429020881653,
-0.015252424404025078,
0.6339355707168579,
-0.41649365425109863,
0.2421276718378067,
0.21352536976337433,
1.1733099222183228,
-0.4612639248371124,
-0.24057742953300476,
0.21012194454669952,
0.03996771574020386,
0.2252206802368164,
0.4805337190628052,
0.7335567474365234,
-0.5038312673568726,
0.49769580364227295,
-0.46780648827552795,
-0.04092947393655777,
-0.1634107232093811,
-0.6628624796867371,
-0.5688061118125916,
-0.6724865436553955,
-0.16094785928726196,
-0.330726683139801,
0.09123265743255615,
1.2065430879592896,
0.8916637301445007,
-0.7664942741394043,
0.13028688728809357,
0.24906443059444427,
0.027289779856801033,
-0.26012006402015686,
-0.2692352533340454,
0.3913800120353699,
-0.35565847158432007,
-1.0350220203399658,
0.9945028424263,
-0.1213146224617958,
0.05561410263180733,
-0.251028835773468,
-0.03861149027943611,
-0.23262828588485718,
-0.08147803694009781,
0.553412675857544,
0.3698243200778961,
-0.254611611366272,
-0.27176985144615173,
-0.035326749086380005,
-0.01216558925807476,
0.1883191466331482,
0.9036750793457031,
-1.4202337265014648,
0.4640902876853943,
0.5466436743736267,
1.2185511589050293,
0.6226364374160767,
0.30015799403190613,
0.49365755915641785,
-1.4717615842819214,
0.26842382550239563,
0.35186707973480225,
0.3299168050289154,
0.5487809777259827,
-0.3565160632133484,
0.5371057391166687,
0.15155258774757385,
-0.05773519352078438,
-1.1212701797485352,
0.1350470632314682,
-0.7702650427818298,
-0.021620741114020348,
1.0073541402816772,
0.0702633336186409,
-0.00526344683021307,
0.08271269500255585,
0.031546059995889664,
0.05984612926840782,
-0.37430503964424133,
0.6965512037277222,
0.31271982192993164,
-0.1138196513056755,
-0.035788118839263916,
-0.5670853853225708,
0.5628553032875061,
0.33768776059150696,
-0.8888548612594604,
0.36531123518943787,
0.6071164608001709,
0.3018032908439636,
0.08266185224056244,
0.5507752299308777,
-0.08181821554899216,
0.1497770994901657,
-0.22317154705524445,
-0.10311388224363327,
-0.447061151266098,
-0.2319074422121048,
-0.26285767555236816,
0.11833340674638748,
-0.11342483758926392,
-0.3091046214103699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13470v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13470v1
|
How Important is Domain Specificity in Language Models and Instruction Finetuning for Biomedical Relation Extraction?
| 2024-02-21T01:57:58 | 2024-02-21T01:57:58 |
Aviv Brokman, Ramakanth Kavuluru
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Cutting edge techniques developed in the general NLP domain are often
subsequently applied to the high-value, data-rich biomedical domain. The past
few years have seen generative language models (LMs), instruction finetuning,
and few-shot learning become foci of NLP research. As such, generative LMs
pretrained on biomedical corpora have proliferated and biomedical instruction
finetuning has been attempted as well, all with the hope that domain
specificity improves performance on downstream tasks. Given the nontrivial
effort in training such models, we investigate what, if any, benefits they have
in the key biomedical NLP task of relation extraction. Specifically, we address
two questions: (1) Do LMs trained on biomedical corpora outperform those
trained on general domain corpora? (2) Do models instruction finetuned on
biomedical datasets outperform those finetuned on assorted datasets or those
simply pretrained? We tackle these questions using existing LMs, testing across
four datasets. In a surprising result, general-domain models typically
outperformed biomedical-domain models. However, biomedical instruction
finetuning improved performance to a similar degree as general instruction
finetuning, despite having orders of magnitude fewer instructions. Our findings
suggest it may be more fruitful to focus research effort on larger-scale
biomedical instruction finetuning of general LMs over building domain-specific
biomedical LMs
|
[
-0.23280440270900726,
-0.7854588031768799,
0.5976150631904602,
-0.1868663877248764,
-0.10580025613307953,
-0.2964057922363281,
-0.1430942565202713,
-0.807612955570221,
-0.11027653515338898,
0.5345863103866577,
-0.2860240638256073,
-0.4800613224506378,
-0.6265246868133545,
0.05610785633325577,
-0.19572387635707855,
1.3549243211746216,
0.23252370953559875,
0.224812313914299,
-0.6412073373794556,
-0.3120356798171997,
-0.2070585936307907,
-0.8497387766838074,
-0.47202906012535095,
-0.5235325694084167,
0.7657609581947327,
0.009621539153158665,
0.799560546875,
0.9366397261619568,
0.8975866436958313,
0.12998206913471222,
-0.17318947613239288,
0.23114542663097382,
-0.48523205518722534,
-0.035195328295230865,
-0.525696337223053,
-0.41118624806404114,
-0.5551255345344543,
0.16627296805381775,
0.4055197834968567,
1.659358024597168,
0.216692715883255,
0.008192910812795162,
0.09798489511013031,
0.8023432493209839,
-0.5049347281455994,
0.07592065632343292,
-0.49397215247154236,
0.09096281975507736,
-0.20377486944198608,
-0.17740046977996826,
-0.44752657413482666,
-0.08780808001756668,
0.6634703874588013,
-0.5859262347221375,
0.6616439819335938,
-0.059546198695898056,
1.1229861974716187,
0.1603792905807495,
-0.30843907594680786,
-0.1664014756679535,
-0.8858775496482849,
0.8234813213348389,
-0.4913560152053833,
0.571498453617096,
0.5001333355903625,
-0.08180388808250427,
-0.248651385307312,
-0.949627697467804,
0.05633106827735901,
-0.1357446014881134,
-0.11537856608629227,
0.08171646296977997,
-0.1626264601945877,
0.3488648235797882,
0.3552437126636505,
0.4998322129249573,
-0.42629706859588623,
0.29178571701049805,
-0.5045710802078247,
0.15712936222553253,
0.3486476242542267,
0.13639304041862488,
0.36027467250823975,
0.041419465094804764,
-0.24820418655872345,
0.24809686839580536,
-1.2314143180847168,
-0.08109869807958603,
-0.07170841097831726,
0.394899845123291,
0.010370438918471336,
0.42089173197746277,
0.05286097154021263,
0.7639598846435547,
0.046146515756845474,
0.19995619356632233,
0.12962757050991058,
-0.2707616686820984,
-0.2731360197067261,
-0.3480091392993927,
0.6213582754135132,
-0.20309503376483917,
0.5022001266479492,
-0.6936572194099426,
0.17389912903308868,
0.05694536864757538,
0.47469598054885864,
-0.9604470729827881,
-0.3945282995700836,
0.3535759449005127,
-0.6134682893753052,
0.10313307493925095,
-0.18661051988601685,
-0.2591899037361145,
-0.04005206748843193,
-0.6003949642181396,
0.1964135766029358,
-0.76679527759552,
-0.08969809114933014,
0.13732606172561646,
0.034929800778627396,
0.2093363106250763,
0.23595967888832092,
-1.1957056522369385,
0.24146369099617004,
0.9458358287811279,
0.5936887860298157,
-0.48246461153030396,
-0.10596299916505814,
-0.5748329758644104,
0.12484835088253021,
-0.32366761565208435,
0.7273425459861755,
-0.7655265927314758,
-0.49895307421684265,
-0.12364932894706726,
0.2751407325267792,
-0.21402379870414734,
-0.9319562911987305,
0.2488899827003479,
-0.7044838070869446,
0.024245701730251312,
-0.06599172204732895,
-1.1434955596923828,
0.06344843655824661,
-0.24608193337917328,
-0.5857532024383545,
0.25369831919670105,
0.2218606323003769,
-0.6984707117080688,
0.29390472173690796,
-0.37806370854377747,
-0.5779885649681091,
0.2569994330406189,
-0.4511966109275818,
-0.33346226811408997,
0.07767338305711746,
-0.17230744659900665,
0.8773565888404846,
-0.3145420551300049,
0.23380707204341888,
-0.40004590153694153,
-0.21572808921337128,
0.2483225166797638,
-0.19345586001873016,
0.7182261943817139,
0.10191342979669571,
-0.22712191939353943,
-0.15711195766925812,
-0.8023114800453186,
0.0473671481013298,
-0.0828726664185524,
-0.3216695189476013,
-0.6737464666366577,
0.005165712907910347,
-0.21096926927566528,
-0.026053452864289284,
-0.11286214739084244,
-0.37119850516319275,
0.14563441276550293,
-0.8771548867225647,
0.14424340426921844,
0.4648706912994385,
0.23403511941432953,
0.6829460263252258,
-0.17532286047935486,
0.6257980465888977,
-0.05269913375377655,
0.0054350681602954865,
0.14644761383533478,
-0.6587505340576172,
-0.30204617977142334,
-0.49311670660972595,
0.6980264186859131,
0.41135895252227783,
-0.3835982382297516,
0.24865010380744934,
0.05942278355360031,
-0.2857525944709778,
-0.6519755721092224,
0.21157409250736237,
0.7084285616874695,
0.5778205990791321,
0.5938935279846191,
-0.4304271936416626,
-0.32187238335609436,
-0.871821939945221,
-0.14765672385692596,
0.29427284002304077,
-0.14889028668403625,
0.22629386186599731,
0.41602393984794617,
-0.5654354691505432,
0.920037567615509,
-0.5444685220718384,
-0.20770294964313507,
0.03593255579471588,
-0.07435132563114166,
0.10001830011606216,
0.5780397057533264,
0.6866441369056702,
-0.7863323092460632,
-0.34149715304374695,
0.18553146719932556,
-1.0667271614074707,
0.09401726722717285,
0.0039814836345613,
-0.2224273681640625,
-0.1877487450838089,
0.19524142146110535,
-0.7135496139526367,
0.4076201021671295,
0.4958435297012329,
-0.012171045877039433,
0.5863673686981201,
-0.2196374237537384,
-0.27491089701652527,
-0.728865385055542,
0.3010149598121643,
0.02781606838107109,
-0.24492891132831573,
-0.9025164842605591,
0.26206618547439575,
-0.20075973868370056,
0.016525888815522194,
-0.3158086836338043,
0.4655911922454834,
-0.5967179536819458,
-0.05172872543334961,
-0.23696734011173248,
0.01916506327688694,
0.13113903999328613,
0.24748684465885162,
0.3433254361152649,
0.5712937116622925,
0.4908676743507385,
-0.96433025598526,
-0.023586055263876915,
0.4285043478012085,
-0.2517753541469574,
0.16656190156936646,
-0.7110314965248108,
0.2733877897262573,
0.03201805055141449,
-0.2132224142551422,
-0.3843112885951996,
-0.16966187953948975,
-0.036299411207437515,
-0.2971816956996918,
0.7115882635116577,
-0.14590619504451752,
0.12958292663097382,
0.011320932768285275,
0.062319014221429825,
0.26011157035827637,
0.5154450535774231,
-0.47230130434036255,
0.1498298943042755,
0.5675477981567383,
-0.1892196238040924,
-0.6863281726837158,
-0.5050909519195557,
-0.43013179302215576,
-0.004882379435002804,
-0.4003943204879761,
0.5305319428443909,
-0.05731181800365448,
-0.22943776845932007,
0.007347962819039822,
-0.1507878303527832,
-0.400922566652298,
0.15906909108161926,
0.4017491042613983,
0.4612373411655426,
-0.41037094593048096,
0.39148637652397156,
0.0031448297668248415,
-0.21469151973724365,
0.08676537126302719,
-0.0471893772482872,
0.2496439665555954,
0.1386178731918335,
-0.062291983515024185,
-0.39205119013786316,
0.5223962068557739,
0.1199675127863884,
-0.1489405632019043,
0.8806296586990356,
0.482165664434433,
-0.3435051739215851,
-0.16696979105472565,
-0.2380044311285019,
-0.45408084988594055,
-0.3804726004600525,
0.5626001954078674,
-0.37376025319099426,
-0.9828252196311951,
0.30415186285972595,
-0.33086249232292175,
0.057780660688877106,
0.5719186067581177,
0.3600163161754608,
-0.22976018488407135,
0.8777865171432495,
0.913166344165802,
0.16187851130962372,
0.41604894399642944,
-0.484897643327713,
0.05170908942818642,
-0.8479679822921753,
-0.18668678402900696,
-0.396778404712677,
0.11998070031404495,
-0.5525088310241699,
-0.3079412281513214,
0.0916595309972763,
0.1561664491891861,
-0.10523533076047897,
0.2184627801179886,
-0.5528891086578369,
0.26721566915512085,
0.45042338967323303,
0.23558059334754944,
0.3124472498893738,
0.2994278073310852,
-0.04210711643099785,
-0.31532785296440125,
-0.8832483887672424,
-0.5639188289642334,
1.2892885208129883,
0.38694295287132263,
0.6565513014793396,
-0.20226147770881653,
0.7634713053703308,
-0.06832227110862732,
0.5714693069458008,
-0.8663195371627808,
0.21960116922855377,
-0.6634606122970581,
-0.6381855607032776,
-0.09133325517177582,
-0.6410889029502869,
-1.4503281116485596,
-0.08483341336250305,
-0.3542498052120209,
-0.38097259402275085,
0.4992324411869049,
0.2332858443260193,
-0.6435633301734924,
0.06828359514474869,
-0.6770884990692139,
0.9118900895118713,
0.0661390870809555,
-0.4939974844455719,
-0.05470631644129753,
-0.830985963344574,
0.1521390676498413,
-0.11313768476247787,
0.20155607163906097,
-0.09020453691482544,
0.14162342250347137,
0.8749693632125854,
-0.41509345173835754,
0.8321321606636047,
-0.012988941743969917,
-0.05493347719311714,
0.18472842872142792,
-0.06658847630023956,
-0.03185286372900009,
-0.1837773621082306,
0.2206796407699585,
0.25929445028305054,
0.21888865530490875,
-0.25520530343055725,
-0.2918746769428253,
0.7189737558364868,
-0.7950473427772522,
-0.7007947564125061,
-0.08554711192846298,
-0.4666852355003357,
-0.6377877593040466,
0.09970396757125854,
0.4754997789859772,
0.6178759932518005,
-0.362504780292511,
0.3110117018222809,
1.026383399963379,
-0.3063341975212097,
-0.17387859523296356,
0.3713757395744324,
-0.02147417888045311,
-0.18384523689746857,
0.8723598718643188,
0.05765867978334427,
0.6233869194984436,
0.5046718716621399,
-0.012774626724421978,
0.11036118865013123,
-0.513334333896637,
-0.15282946825027466,
0.5515218377113342,
-0.5881834626197815,
-0.35563790798187256,
-0.9094438552856445,
-0.4857763648033142,
-0.4536656439304352,
-0.07495700567960739,
-0.43747517466545105,
-0.5011647939682007,
-0.5381807088851929,
0.07974904775619507,
0.28389930725097656,
0.646992564201355,
-0.1128229945898056,
0.1359095275402069,
-1.1042077541351318,
0.6629528403282166,
0.3576236963272095,
0.12901468575000763,
-0.252144455909729,
-0.6390159726142883,
-0.43381959199905396,
-0.015390784479677677,
-0.1834098994731903,
-0.7391057014465332,
0.24775491654872894,
0.4546087980270386,
0.5397455096244812,
0.46634137630462646,
-0.36501458287239075,
0.6582430601119995,
-0.7869545221328735,
0.3798440098762512,
0.13291384279727936,
-0.4830532968044281,
0.43397256731987,
-0.2583237588405609,
0.04890717566013336,
0.461016446352005,
0.9313613176345825,
-0.15917877852916718,
-0.41139596700668335,
-0.8564168214797974,
-0.7460620999336243,
0.5219793915748596,
0.014850196428596973,
0.11729368567466736,
-0.16375158727169037,
0.821892261505127,
0.32515671849250793,
0.06602716445922852,
-0.3574007749557495,
-0.44246968626976013,
0.26936066150665283,
-0.16777458786964417,
0.07592843472957611,
-0.30676978826522827,
-0.20406845211982727,
-0.25961098074913025,
0.34240642189979553,
0.046250518411397934,
0.4573361873626709,
0.35965147614479065,
0.07149282842874527,
0.039103515446186066,
0.2420908659696579,
0.13060687482357025,
0.5810508728027344,
-0.3266819715499878,
-0.07299350947141647,
-0.16444824635982513,
-0.5787259936332703,
-0.06396754831075668,
0.18562431633472443,
-0.05056406557559967,
0.17800545692443848,
0.716619610786438,
0.5179890990257263,
0.1238575428724289,
-0.5452336668968201,
0.5195767879486084,
0.35144317150115967,
-0.15742090344429016,
0.2360035479068756,
0.15968964993953705,
0.1364780068397522,
0.11041349172592163,
0.13027456402778625,
0.19147643446922302,
0.2755112648010254,
-0.6044905781745911,
0.3288252055644989,
0.4216075539588928,
-0.2391778826713562,
-0.47152334451675415,
0.854169487953186,
0.12852270901203156,
-0.005920500494539738,
0.4608395993709564,
-0.037553854286670685,
-0.06209050863981247,
0.6053743362426758,
0.7797759175300598,
0.5915214419364929,
-0.34937968850135803,
0.018178248777985573,
0.3357541263103485,
-0.1370244175195694,
-0.10555481165647507,
-0.21117056906223297,
0.07201744616031647,
-0.8095831274986267,
-0.6408650875091553,
-0.696997880935669,
-0.6063809394836426,
0.08781455457210541,
-0.8540276885032654,
0.03821934759616852,
-0.5086528658866882,
-0.478188693523407,
0.4806242883205414,
-0.177224799990654,
-0.8449704051017761,
0.5134333372116089,
-0.015113559551537037,
0.43551307916641235,
-0.5580232739448547,
0.8556313514709473,
0.660631537437439,
-0.5344902873039246,
-0.6252387762069702,
-0.3692164421081543,
-0.34487026929855347,
-0.5472783446311951,
1.0526130199432373,
-0.07482806593179703,
-0.05672350898385048,
-0.05151059105992317,
-0.5823462605476379,
-0.617839515209198,
0.6089722514152527,
0.5412914752960205,
-0.7406672835350037,
-0.4969256520271301,
0.08227943629026413,
0.7268249988555908,
-0.46624428033828735,
-0.16693370044231415,
0.6393067836761475,
-0.27660390734672546,
-0.33099672198295593,
-0.6736501455307007,
-0.07031222432851791,
-0.0885082483291626,
-0.08252911269664764,
0.08794903755187988,
-0.1993531435728073,
0.672080934047699,
-0.4462048411369324,
-0.18205276131629944,
0.16482658684253693,
0.5426909923553467,
0.23291443288326263,
0.27085840702056885,
-0.06722383946180344,
0.10966809093952179,
0.793678343296051,
-0.002334384247660637,
1.27588951587677,
-0.08793966472148895,
0.3086402118206024,
1.072576642036438,
-0.22327175736427307,
0.8448822498321533,
0.39024245738983154,
-0.44911107420921326,
0.4340265393257141,
0.5449633002281189,
0.2110506147146225,
0.5575677752494812,
-0.06026073545217514,
-0.1142478957772255,
-0.2629931569099426,
-0.121893510222435,
-0.7217755317687988,
0.25434738397598267,
0.674513578414917,
-0.6469074487686157,
0.15030960738658905,
0.13368858397006989,
0.06798464804887772,
0.09848606586456299,
-0.20498214662075043,
0.7424139380455017,
0.650005042552948,
-0.36822769045829773,
0.7236552834510803,
-0.27949416637420654,
0.45036426186561584,
-0.7349771857261658,
-0.01950526051223278,
-0.15929178893566132,
0.36032724380493164,
-0.3574163317680359,
-0.24176760017871857,
0.4434347450733185,
0.019897080957889557,
-0.5819953680038452,
-0.03286166489124298,
0.7982778549194336,
-0.5448216795921326,
-0.052612341940402985,
0.45486560463905334,
0.7184767127037048,
0.232155442237854,
0.0632154792547226,
-0.5958048105239868,
-0.276571124792099,
-0.017551438882946968,
-0.2548442780971527,
0.624548614025116,
0.38973182439804077,
0.14789627492427826,
0.44458189606666565,
0.7129438519477844,
0.5564928650856018,
-0.17632396519184113,
0.27148956060409546,
0.7802610397338867,
-0.6372025609016418,
0.08079595118761063,
-0.7343540787696838,
-0.030915943905711174,
0.030171921476721764,
-0.2899586856365204,
0.5366120934486389,
0.4693458080291748,
0.7516670227050781,
-0.35924234986305237,
0.5955044031143188,
0.3660682737827301,
0.6162437796592712,
-0.6239300966262817,
0.5387918949127197,
-0.3790009915828705,
0.25873276591300964,
-0.17366057634353638,
-0.703632116317749,
-0.6360272765159607,
0.662969172000885,
-0.5160514712333679,
0.13500933349132538,
0.989464282989502,
0.37095922231674194,
-0.15523986518383026,
-0.01947549730539322,
0.49640512466430664,
0.027302339673042297,
0.0982576459646225,
0.6063216924667358,
0.6624993681907654,
-0.3954695761203766,
0.21851764619350433,
-0.37549352645874023,
-0.23411443829536438,
0.03698400780558586,
-0.4588770866394043,
-0.9932036995887756,
-0.27670806646347046,
-0.6696959733963013,
-0.29197999835014343,
0.19299989938735962,
0.9743805527687073,
0.7140903472900391,
-0.9456259608268738,
-0.13380120694637299,
0.023111119866371155,
-0.10611221939325333,
-0.25820866227149963,
-0.24333718419075012,
0.570881724357605,
-0.684354305267334,
-0.6917855739593506,
0.35495761036872864,
0.3805091679096222,
0.19716444611549377,
0.1812494546175003,
0.1419561803340912,
-0.2558116018772125,
-0.17059460282325745,
0.7561846375465393,
0.46850913763046265,
-0.3591453433036804,
-0.1423403024673462,
0.049340635538101196,
-0.42668282985687256,
0.18799154460430145,
0.7524065375328064,
-0.6762688755989075,
0.19596466422080994,
0.12628886103630066,
1.0107795000076294,
0.38866785168647766,
0.05779273062944412,
0.6797301769256592,
-0.6991363763809204,
0.21143300831317902,
0.32351842522621155,
0.32268261909484863,
0.45717787742614746,
-0.4034893214702606,
0.8469627499580383,
0.3734765648841858,
-0.8415646553039551,
-0.6770050525665283,
0.15736450254917145,
-0.8208065629005432,
-0.3841472566127777,
1.3251831531524658,
-0.41357412934303284,
-0.27051088213920593,
-0.3064247965812683,
-0.014897806569933891,
0.34262287616729736,
0.18860188126564026,
0.5716766715049744,
0.2662509083747864,
-0.3594469428062439,
0.39317891001701355,
-0.8377666473388672,
0.8597609400749207,
0.7687879204750061,
-0.8035932183265686,
0.06753259897232056,
0.3587873578071594,
0.36995866894721985,
0.14429602026939392,
0.6332822442054749,
-0.11328813433647156,
0.40813693404197693,
-0.12429545074701309,
0.1125103086233139,
0.2593187987804413,
-0.32973596453666687,
-0.2600654363632202,
0.11979078501462936,
0.13811247050762177,
-0.04872765392065048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13468v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13468v1
|
STENCIL: Submodular Mutual Information Based Weak Supervision for Cold-Start Active Learning
| 2024-02-21T01:54:58 | 2024-02-21T01:54:58 |
Nathan Beck, Adithya Iyer, Rishabh Iyer
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
As supervised fine-tuning of pre-trained models within NLP applications
increases in popularity, larger corpora of annotated data are required,
especially with increasing parameter counts in large language models. Active
learning, which attempts to mine and annotate unlabeled instances to improve
model performance maximally fast, is a common choice for reducing the
annotation cost; however, most methods typically ignore class imbalance and
either assume access to initial annotated data or require multiple rounds of
active learning selection before improving rare classes. We present STENCIL,
which utilizes a set of text exemplars and the recently proposed submodular
mutual information to select a set of weakly labeled rare-class instances that
are then strongly labeled by an annotator. We show that STENCIL improves
overall accuracy by $10\%-24\%$ and rare-class F-1 score by $17\%-40\%$ on
multiple text classification datasets over common active learning methods
within the class-imbalanced cold-start setting.
|
[
-0.2407146692276001,
-0.8012783527374268,
-0.28820639848709106,
0.1721811145544052,
-0.5747385025024414,
-0.17366042733192444,
-0.3184874355792999,
-0.4408610761165619,
0.3748665452003479,
0.12855561077594757,
-0.2880764603614807,
-0.8074284195899963,
-0.5816846489906311,
-0.2942809462547302,
-0.23513397574424744,
1.1509861946105957,
-0.14119853079319,
0.0457734651863575,
-0.2939457297325134,
-0.3720319867134094,
-0.08156794309616089,
-0.6503866910934448,
-0.35124561190605164,
-0.2114577442407608,
0.6954487562179565,
0.4969944357872009,
0.8371465802192688,
0.3770798146724701,
0.5574959516525269,
0.268802672624588,
-0.03960440680384636,
0.43884027004241943,
-0.5414607524871826,
0.5561777949333191,
-0.040385469794273376,
-0.3638606071472168,
-0.5563775897026062,
0.2510432302951813,
0.5247968435287476,
0.8245524168014526,
0.12832508981227875,
0.06647349894046783,
0.03424032777547836,
0.2448747158050537,
-0.8746810555458069,
0.09962631016969681,
-0.6223747134208679,
0.14603160321712494,
-0.38288724422454834,
0.019818199798464775,
-0.2266475409269333,
0.053243596106767654,
0.309352308511734,
-0.7733907103538513,
0.5456662178039551,
0.08258811384439468,
1.1840755939483643,
0.21689049899578094,
-0.2608835995197296,
-0.07687737792730331,
-0.40492892265319824,
0.963801920413971,
-0.6173729300498962,
0.2013092339038849,
0.5826758742332458,
-0.11352454125881195,
0.32222235202789307,
-0.8122872114181519,
-0.012745779007673264,
0.06606937944889069,
-0.1890489012002945,
0.24702978134155273,
-0.055872101336717606,
0.21144351363182068,
0.41563931107521057,
0.3944190740585327,
-0.136695995926857,
0.23771756887435913,
-0.560592532157898,
-0.31979700922966003,
0.38010144233703613,
-0.21787966787815094,
0.10401628166437149,
0.2577000558376312,
-0.49520644545555115,
-0.05003579333424568,
-0.35809987783432007,
-0.3268890678882599,
0.41423144936561584,
0.6147955656051636,
-0.13314488530158997,
0.6331061720848083,
-0.09520171582698822,
0.6414754986763,
-0.0313626267015934,
0.2162793129682541,
0.458499014377594,
-0.2618551254272461,
-0.5315625071525574,
0.20034624636173248,
0.6601937413215637,
0.052089083939790726,
0.1578371524810791,
-0.12127579003572464,
-0.38245275616645813,
0.057255975902080536,
0.029862960800528526,
-0.8124721646308899,
-0.5176988840103149,
-0.12293321639299393,
-0.34642818570137024,
-0.43468421697616577,
0.18467102944850922,
-0.4280623197555542,
-0.15805584192276,
-0.35515496134757996,
0.42211484909057617,
-0.2749944031238556,
-0.27059438824653625,
-0.14298398792743683,
-0.09009627997875214,
-0.11375733464956284,
0.4381405711174011,
-0.8441557288169861,
0.29760047793388367,
0.45870867371559143,
1.0945745706558228,
-0.26406025886535645,
-0.2455100417137146,
-0.8556621074676514,
0.20328564941883087,
-0.22462505102157593,
0.5462436676025391,
-0.5621670484542847,
-0.08511514961719513,
0.14408309757709503,
0.21585464477539062,
0.10593901574611664,
-0.2674868106842041,
0.36975380778312683,
-0.4497760534286499,
0.2592639923095703,
-0.26022544503211975,
-0.31332212686538696,
0.06263963133096695,
0.10674989223480225,
-0.8149785399436951,
0.9869908094406128,
-0.03197722136974335,
-1.1510508060455322,
0.8138188123703003,
-0.18281786143779755,
-0.7931677103042603,
0.1438857614994049,
-0.07097018510103226,
-0.8971594572067261,
-0.1077006533741951,
0.10496591776609421,
0.7271543741226196,
0.23204447329044342,
0.14193938672542572,
-0.628128707408905,
-0.5458477735519409,
-0.29815754294395447,
-0.2625480592250824,
0.6400772333145142,
0.036268267780542374,
-0.5156967639923096,
0.360764741897583,
-0.5873161554336548,
-0.06376432627439499,
-0.17310281097888947,
-0.28154969215393066,
-1.0600872039794922,
-0.5483168363571167,
0.093215212225914,
-0.14226321876049042,
0.2877058982849121,
-0.2844614088535309,
0.4767085015773773,
-0.32204461097717285,
-0.08090120553970337,
0.895171046257019,
-0.07040247321128845,
0.6681207418441772,
-0.31128522753715515,
0.40690112113952637,
0.2380361407995224,
0.27026352286338806,
0.054630059748888016,
-0.5520644783973694,
-0.739597499370575,
-0.5010640025138855,
0.653559684753418,
0.4155764877796173,
-0.79976487159729,
0.11557028442621231,
0.2441636621952057,
-0.49188944697380066,
-0.5162842273712158,
0.815868079662323,
0.6932824850082397,
0.12645243108272552,
0.5923337340354919,
-0.44804123044013977,
-0.5858615040779114,
-0.9788990020751953,
-0.18696872889995575,
-0.05945036932826042,
0.30262094736099243,
0.2741650640964508,
0.24647560715675354,
-0.17794480919837952,
0.5318389534950256,
-0.22899481654167175,
-0.6749287247657776,
-0.260572224855423,
0.5115054249763489,
0.14670632779598236,
0.754226565361023,
0.5962504148483276,
-0.7849102020263672,
-0.4604921042919159,
-0.3498988747596741,
-0.7318683862686157,
-0.21580828726291656,
0.035788487643003464,
-0.435952365398407,
0.22625376284122467,
0.5898818373680115,
-0.4170154631137848,
0.3547549545764923,
0.6411100029945374,
-0.31221628189086914,
-0.007986277341842651,
-0.16160421073436737,
-0.04971690475940704,
-0.8604982495307922,
0.1610955446958542,
0.10477902740240097,
0.06854449957609177,
-0.44585373997688293,
-0.3373211920261383,
0.09045706689357758,
-0.07797975838184357,
-0.47667041420936584,
0.6120365858078003,
-0.8484615087509155,
0.17712683975696564,
-0.21888945996761322,
0.09074656665325165,
-0.10493641346693039,
0.4172850549221039,
0.07509850710630417,
0.2695426046848297,
0.737236738204956,
-0.4625474810600281,
0.37730997800827026,
0.07333885878324509,
-0.16231980919837952,
0.11165183037519455,
-0.5737521648406982,
0.06127357855439186,
-0.12190456688404083,
0.05996629595756531,
-0.671766459941864,
-0.10197971016168594,
0.2618921399116516,
-0.03784937784075737,
0.5224810838699341,
-0.658469021320343,
-0.3715590238571167,
0.11043747514486313,
-0.08611597865819931,
0.47377777099609375,
0.1824074536561966,
-0.4443451464176178,
0.43809324502944946,
0.34739547967910767,
0.21124689280986786,
-0.9788304567337036,
-0.7774708271026611,
-0.19156666100025177,
0.18238402903079987,
-0.35684213042259216,
0.0619744136929512,
0.13480278849601746,
-0.516407310962677,
0.24615740776062012,
-0.32504627108573914,
-0.15211588144302368,
0.3407289385795593,
0.6033058762550354,
0.19769226014614105,
-0.1924709528684616,
0.40023666620254517,
0.4378103017807007,
-0.1258769929409027,
-0.29496678709983826,
-0.2195570319890976,
0.18484914302825928,
-0.25012680888175964,
-0.4253953993320465,
-0.22682735323905945,
0.2611910104751587,
0.3238285183906555,
-0.24517492949962616,
1.0010486841201782,
0.7883633971214294,
-0.5635929107666016,
-0.5613550543785095,
-0.2636055052280426,
-0.4881983697414398,
-0.40410512685775757,
0.032364148646593094,
-0.2706161439418793,
-0.6083364486694336,
0.269871324300766,
0.14443719387054443,
0.6293773055076599,
0.19419988989830017,
0.3108934164047241,
0.08431996405124664,
0.8073593378067017,
0.6460332870483398,
0.07475166022777557,
0.885898232460022,
-0.30621516704559326,
-0.18934525549411774,
-0.036662131547927856,
-0.39747539162635803,
-0.22669097781181335,
-0.6795493960380554,
-0.07617326825857162,
-0.4318576455116272,
0.027994897216558456,
0.4167203903198242,
0.2536742091178894,
0.07180138677358627,
-0.4852501153945923,
0.25961190462112427,
1.1080422401428223,
0.30553197860717773,
0.13378776609897614,
0.061473067849874496,
-0.2452605664730072,
-0.15754705667495728,
-0.8846128582954407,
-0.20439817011356354,
1.0567036867141724,
0.1632372885942459,
1.0710593461990356,
0.04633447155356407,
0.7385177612304688,
0.3215784728527069,
0.6872979998588562,
-0.6731448769569397,
0.4726455509662628,
-0.44890493154525757,
-0.7497434020042419,
-0.3164951801300049,
-0.4380868673324585,
-0.7034837603569031,
0.2824305295944214,
-0.6539857387542725,
0.22728648781776428,
0.32372695207595825,
0.5464493632316589,
-0.054352641105651855,
0.4386027455329895,
-1.0367883443832397,
0.8500714898109436,
-0.313148558139801,
-0.8503608107566833,
0.08350785821676254,
-0.48921242356300354,
0.48186030983924866,
-0.03650075942277908,
-0.024764468893408775,
-0.14333635568618774,
-0.19940078258514404,
1.1209771633148193,
-0.4749097526073456,
1.2826143503189087,
-0.6254684925079346,
-0.09212193638086319,
0.26447513699531555,
-0.1148260161280632,
0.5887202024459839,
0.3227882385253906,
-0.06875171512365341,
0.21995404362678528,
-0.2692040801048279,
-0.6627733111381531,
-0.4140135645866394,
0.8478637337684631,
-0.7236405611038208,
-0.3370128571987152,
-0.534238874912262,
-0.3487539291381836,
-0.1378878951072693,
0.2835579812526703,
0.10105840116739273,
0.6101458668708801,
0.16191649436950684,
0.48633962869644165,
0.9871791005134583,
0.022449184209108353,
0.2214132845401764,
0.5090525150299072,
0.17712382972240448,
-0.5036216974258423,
0.5556528568267822,
0.1750866025686264,
0.3229094445705414,
0.20118039846420288,
0.03806617110967636,
0.13739000260829926,
-0.5184633731842041,
-0.08832097053527832,
0.320266991853714,
-0.7746993899345398,
-0.41759026050567627,
-0.8183311223983765,
-0.030559105798602104,
-0.5323297381401062,
-0.2622510492801666,
-0.44930484890937805,
-0.55654376745224,
-0.49870774149894714,
-0.1863945573568344,
0.46838828921318054,
0.26359227299690247,
-0.319488525390625,
0.22989805042743683,
-0.33872005343437195,
0.3981092572212219,
0.45179253816604614,
0.3231705129146576,
-0.3743138909339905,
-0.3995235860347748,
-0.4443289637565613,
0.020596057176589966,
0.22943542897701263,
-0.6702569723129272,
0.08602672070264816,
0.4322197735309601,
0.7454833388328552,
0.6203716397285461,
0.5443106293678284,
0.631230354309082,
-0.001190856215544045,
0.4118110239505768,
0.19165648519992828,
-0.7365542054176331,
0.7459461092948914,
-0.05055195838212967,
0.37110191583633423,
0.7580630779266357,
0.5922000408172607,
-0.14480258524417877,
-0.7532138824462891,
-0.8274329304695129,
-1.2706373929977417,
0.6202151775360107,
0.0030259464401751757,
-0.012315399944782257,
0.0381319560110569,
0.22427770495414734,
0.14582785964012146,
0.1443011313676834,
-0.7502778768539429,
-0.3689521253108978,
-0.5454545021057129,
-0.2900520861148834,
-0.08186191320419312,
-0.19953760504722595,
-0.48476359248161316,
-0.09055402874946594,
1.1055281162261963,
-0.23393602669239044,
-0.03238186240196228,
0.0841265469789505,
-0.30828002095222473,
-0.2638004422187805,
0.07084362208843231,
0.6046267151832581,
0.4208936393260956,
-0.41619858145713806,
0.7449488639831543,
0.18568816781044006,
-0.6754950284957886,
-0.20253928005695343,
0.08046036958694458,
-0.260636568069458,
0.43597978353500366,
0.5855772495269775,
0.7892071604728699,
0.4199770390987396,
-0.37918615341186523,
0.7608382701873779,
-0.10480813682079315,
-0.4106300473213196,
-0.01164529100060463,
0.24550826847553253,
-0.32908952236175537,
0.12249942868947983,
0.32421961426734924,
0.3022436499595642,
-0.3138291835784912,
-0.4052445888519287,
0.553995668888092,
0.5787255167961121,
-0.9906759858131409,
-0.3351708650588989,
0.6368330717086792,
0.3731227517127991,
0.16700299084186554,
0.5419827103614807,
-0.009997863322496414,
-0.410577654838562,
0.3844728171825409,
0.40679460763931274,
0.5915030241012573,
-0.20359379053115845,
0.12872952222824097,
0.26624393463134766,
0.5759370923042297,
-0.32355353236198425,
0.29342108964920044,
-0.17029255628585815,
-0.5008788108825684,
-0.16526605188846588,
-0.5225188732147217,
-0.5243784189224243,
0.10027812421321869,
-0.7163454294204712,
0.67453932762146,
-0.7715007066726685,
-0.20101915299892426,
-0.3354983329772949,
0.2723087668418884,
-0.4329710602760315,
0.3397095203399658,
-0.10877596586942673,
0.6968448758125305,
-1.3287523984909058,
0.9070301055908203,
1.0808976888656616,
-0.4684969186782837,
-0.4386146068572998,
-0.2829558253288269,
-0.20811332762241364,
-0.550016462802887,
0.8153714537620544,
0.10864236950874329,
0.1287873238325119,
-0.01827463135123253,
-0.7348635792732239,
-0.43972456455230713,
0.8346938490867615,
0.20022907853126526,
-0.6923365592956543,
-0.09700313210487366,
-0.5504550933837891,
0.4228804111480713,
-0.03272397816181183,
0.20155031979084015,
-0.3088040053844452,
0.3589574992656708,
0.16671347618103027,
-0.6424333453178406,
0.14722226560115814,
-0.5989497900009155,
-0.583084225654602,
0.3284355401992798,
-0.7067379355430603,
0.7219885587692261,
-0.20327235758304596,
-0.2746986448764801,
-0.2706650197505951,
0.99424809217453,
0.153056338429451,
0.6433836817741394,
0.7399266362190247,
0.5330222249031067,
0.7649163007736206,
-0.06140577793121338,
0.2787018418312073,
-0.21546128392219543,
0.13558217883110046,
1.0776540040969849,
0.11067645251750946,
0.5786336660385132,
0.37104877829551697,
0.4435815215110779,
0.15557831525802612,
0.4438827931880951,
-0.2892652153968811,
0.5906617641448975,
0.08323504775762558,
-0.3400309681892395,
-0.5477721691131592,
-0.16415448486804962,
-0.5325804352760315,
-0.08487004786729813,
0.2067301869392395,
-0.6214278340339661,
-0.14589568972587585,
0.2567172050476074,
0.0771382749080658,
-0.13109268248081207,
-0.16373401880264282,
0.6273181438446045,
0.256274938583374,
-0.3742305338382721,
0.5580102801322937,
0.03902312368154526,
0.8897925615310669,
-0.6601117849349976,
-0.01851097121834755,
-0.4450298845767975,
0.22877725958824158,
-0.43518516421318054,
-0.26868167519569397,
-0.04195652902126312,
-0.1201888769865036,
-0.17238382995128632,
-0.6591658592224121,
0.886593759059906,
-0.658829927444458,
-0.3191724717617035,
0.05429315194487572,
0.3214064836502075,
0.08155543357133865,
0.20823968946933746,
-0.7720842957496643,
-0.0558648481965065,
-0.24892878532409668,
-0.2037600874900818,
0.2610495388507843,
0.7067893743515015,
-0.23193371295928955,
0.38088327646255493,
0.7236137986183167,
0.2550475001335144,
0.27753961086273193,
0.3427991271018982,
1.026990532875061,
-0.3709489107131958,
-0.17316225171089172,
-0.4723455309867859,
0.22028286755084991,
-0.20621375739574432,
-0.48823267221450806,
0.9828943014144897,
0.7982041835784912,
0.7313332557678223,
0.13963571190834045,
0.8701525926589966,
-0.13879944384098053,
0.43487629294395447,
-0.5625443458557129,
0.6559786796569824,
-0.5664527416229248,
0.39429372549057007,
-0.5169737339019775,
-0.9307734966278076,
-0.5947480797767639,
0.6812235713005066,
-0.30807146430015564,
-0.0871516540646553,
0.581991970539093,
0.6875513195991516,
-0.5497375726699829,
-0.23709706962108612,
0.24339880049228668,
0.12494698166847229,
0.1507679522037506,
0.2122109830379486,
0.7583616375923157,
-0.41075795888900757,
0.7766857147216797,
-0.604975163936615,
-0.4480857849121094,
-0.27407971024513245,
-0.70646071434021,
-1.535897135734558,
-0.5009250044822693,
-0.665226936340332,
-0.6434780955314636,
0.2969281077384949,
0.6572413444519043,
0.7865657806396484,
-0.8681745529174805,
0.25803956389427185,
0.06624548137187958,
0.12698467075824738,
-0.3112644851207733,
-0.18680758774280548,
0.38960549235343933,
-0.5343054533004761,
-0.6597720980644226,
0.30483657121658325,
-0.03363786265254021,
0.4207283556461334,
-0.2372855395078659,
0.038867514580488205,
-0.38527756929397583,
-0.16992467641830444,
0.0865759328007698,
0.4001366198062897,
-0.21429863572120667,
0.14743155241012573,
-0.247373566031456,
-0.26844313740730286,
-0.3701837658882141,
0.9496259093284607,
-0.7090046405792236,
0.28820565342903137,
0.6173957586288452,
0.4392565190792084,
0.6749016642570496,
0.18683649599552155,
0.3643079698085785,
-1.0599851608276367,
0.6277157068252563,
0.42565277218818665,
0.1866876780986786,
0.2068869024515152,
-0.14690619707107544,
0.34242939949035645,
0.7187086343765259,
-0.23413163423538208,
-1.096427083015442,
0.06211799383163452,
-1.0342886447906494,
-0.4291277527809143,
1.2767860889434814,
-0.3162470757961273,
-0.27715304493904114,
-0.37547460198402405,
-0.05298598110675812,
0.30831700563430786,
-0.5045155882835388,
0.571434736251831,
0.3460773825645447,
0.2949904799461365,
-0.21224381029605865,
-0.18143492937088013,
0.7023114562034607,
0.7155174612998962,
-0.592863142490387,
0.0004286232579033822,
0.5157508254051208,
-0.053075917065143585,
-0.006345625966787338,
0.39195576310157776,
0.2256406843662262,
0.025546638295054436,
0.0589403435587883,
0.042752232402563095,
-0.42506787180900574,
-0.566555917263031,
0.04549313336610794,
0.5075269341468811,
-0.17811672389507294,
-0.22489888966083527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13463v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13463v3
|
RefuteBench: Evaluating Refuting Instruction-Following for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T01:39:56 | 2024-06-04T07:48:51 |
Jianhao Yan, Yun Luo, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The application scope of large language models (LLMs) is increasingly
expanding. In practical use, users might provide feedback based on the model's
output, hoping for a responsive model that can complete responses according to
their feedback. Whether the model can appropriately respond to users' refuting
feedback and consistently follow through with execution has not been thoroughly
analyzed. In light of this, this paper proposes a comprehensive benchmark,
RefuteBench, covering tasks such as question answering, machine translation,
and email writing. The evaluation aims to assess whether models can positively
accept feedback in form of refuting instructions and whether they can
consistently adhere to user demands throughout the conversation. We conduct
evaluations on numerous LLMs and find that LLMs are stubborn, i.e. exhibit
inclination to their internal knowledge, often failing to comply with user
feedback. Additionally, as the length of the conversation increases, models
gradually forget the user's stated feedback and roll back to their own
responses. We further propose a recall-and-repeat prompts as a simple and
effective way to enhance the model's responsiveness to feedback.
|
[
-0.2649025619029999,
-0.6661947965621948,
0.562348484992981,
0.3235800564289093,
0.06509846448898315,
-0.0025509092956781387,
-0.567484974861145,
-0.12462401390075684,
-0.09573949873447418,
0.7633603811264038,
-0.7200223803520203,
-0.4176188111305237,
-0.2922707498073578,
0.16378475725650787,
-0.6234248280525208,
0.8064289093017578,
-0.24159885942935944,
-0.05532894283533096,
-0.6000335216522217,
-0.13372130692005157,
-0.8250027298927307,
-0.3848244249820709,
-0.6715593934059143,
-0.5077213048934937,
0.5843331813812256,
0.7687248587608337,
0.42356252670288086,
0.33691713213920593,
0.31151339411735535,
0.37140583992004395,
0.030416933819651604,
0.026697566732764244,
-0.8052114844322205,
0.49744775891304016,
-0.42552196979522705,
-0.5696816444396973,
-0.2754678726196289,
-0.3831215798854828,
0.7394056916236877,
0.788699209690094,
-0.4749374985694885,
0.32708725333213806,
0.2634846568107605,
0.5966188311576843,
-0.4890430271625519,
-0.038394831120967865,
-0.5434780120849609,
-0.20117807388305664,
-0.04086446389555931,
0.19888101518154144,
-0.8769510984420776,
-0.5099281072616577,
0.14316178858280182,
-0.3173214793205261,
0.15359920263290405,
-0.03680608049035072,
0.6814942359924316,
0.22438077628612518,
-0.18171057105064392,
-0.451797753572464,
-0.6375665664672852,
0.6815099716186523,
-1.0756914615631104,
0.5219092965126038,
0.448495477437973,
0.43871355056762695,
-0.25266727805137634,
-0.8588418364524841,
-0.5655409693717957,
-0.7416258454322815,
-0.10227604955434799,
0.05227832868695259,
-0.21835444867610931,
-0.14164459705352783,
0.5185453295707703,
0.12563186883926392,
-0.4005905091762543,
0.27693819999694824,
-0.27720674872398376,
-0.10674328356981277,
0.4657854437828064,
0.2815000116825104,
0.06804996728897095,
0.23141007125377655,
-0.3354986011981964,
-0.0016431065741926432,
-0.9079143404960632,
0.11807650327682495,
0.2889607548713684,
0.13643071055412292,
0.06348720192909241,
0.6963948011398315,
-0.4188217222690582,
0.7310808300971985,
0.24644923210144043,
0.14340102672576904,
0.14363741874694824,
-0.19679637253284454,
-0.2707225978374481,
-0.34525206685066223,
0.5983309745788574,
0.46909499168395996,
0.2507118880748749,
-0.18608801066875458,
-0.45479604601860046,
-0.22658589482307434,
0.5645920038223267,
-0.9451941251754761,
-0.1023305281996727,
0.22028347849845886,
-0.3784269392490387,
0.05206707492470741,
-0.14183422923088074,
-0.7356319427490234,
-0.47581344842910767,
-0.37058934569358826,
0.18643607199192047,
-0.20641399919986725,
-0.10615110397338867,
0.03969114273786545,
0.2593582272529602,
0.009850769303739071,
0.5739614367485046,
-0.7245100736618042,
0.4541124403476715,
0.803873598575592,
0.6005874872207642,
-0.024425454437732697,
-0.34390509128570557,
-0.5718188881874084,
-0.0677850991487503,
-0.35581570863723755,
0.8298357129096985,
-0.6548221707344055,
-0.4599064290523529,
0.116029292345047,
0.19164253771305084,
0.0049742599949240685,
-0.7757245898246765,
0.6051104664802551,
-0.5390576720237732,
0.30031105875968933,
-0.502853274345398,
-0.8326136469841003,
-0.24356892704963684,
0.6268453001976013,
-0.6256874799728394,
0.7682321071624756,
0.013233290985226631,
-0.3827899694442749,
-0.10344616323709488,
-0.191187784075737,
-0.14290261268615723,
0.011401545256376266,
-0.06212330609560013,
-0.22094103693962097,
0.3043994605541229,
-0.0413162000477314,
0.2215147167444229,
-0.5951998233795166,
0.07641690224409103,
-0.5326479077339172,
-0.41557830572128296,
0.429558664560318,
-0.3906181752681732,
0.2849763333797455,
0.12584328651428223,
-0.254229873418808,
0.40071454644203186,
-0.6286447644233704,
0.1869046986103058,
0.023701636120676994,
-0.4136787950992584,
-0.07748060673475266,
0.06451840698719025,
-0.2419396936893463,
-0.018397867679595947,
0.2026931792497635,
-0.5064961314201355,
0.40224817395210266,
-0.20988158881664276,
0.3017326593399048,
0.8786672949790955,
-0.07482673227787018,
0.027639945968985558,
-0.3724885582923889,
0.6398076415061951,
-0.27573442459106445,
-0.2018565982580185,
-0.5116518139839172,
-0.052834492176771164,
-0.979193925857544,
0.07869135588407516,
0.3247508704662323,
0.39921319484710693,
-0.6136753559112549,
0.09590906649827957,
-0.4497188925743103,
-0.5093196630477905,
-0.5806600451469421,
0.45756205916404724,
0.5660300850868225,
0.6781923174858093,
0.21269552409648895,
-0.40192845463752747,
-0.4087008833885193,
-0.967716634273529,
-0.3647460639476776,
-0.3109445571899414,
-0.20432700216770172,
0.2863418757915497,
0.31547102332115173,
-0.244873508810997,
0.5535788536071777,
-0.3136020302772522,
0.24603737890720367,
-0.2532994747161865,
0.18637841939926147,
0.042772673070430756,
0.234328493475914,
0.16615138947963715,
-0.30258458852767944,
-0.48314687609672546,
-0.1734691858291626,
-0.5167566537857056,
-0.3883954882621765,
-0.04951241612434387,
0.21517391502857208,
0.5124092698097229,
0.8063743710517883,
-0.43226879835128784,
0.2875109314918518,
0.5575137138366699,
-0.1267251968383789,
0.6073800921440125,
-0.13458693027496338,
0.3278075158596039,
-0.6561896800994873,
0.37036868929862976,
-0.1352744847536087,
-0.3893519639968872,
-0.5436732172966003,
0.25720837712287903,
0.07770665735006332,
-0.055345624685287476,
-0.147451713681221,
0.5827416181564331,
-0.46644824743270874,
0.12814730405807495,
-0.4509536623954773,
0.3892678916454315,
-0.15790441632270813,
0.31745201349258423,
0.03697795420885086,
0.7587690353393555,
-0.007627913262695074,
-0.5236442685127258,
0.5552731156349182,
0.01544832531362772,
-0.3423237204551697,
0.656978189945221,
-0.9947623014450073,
0.609956681728363,
-0.07179389894008636,
0.27901968359947205,
-1.470716118812561,
-0.05857556313276291,
-0.011829120106995106,
-0.33270910382270813,
0.21338973939418793,
-0.20498345792293549,
-0.5770497918128967,
-0.5437824726104736,
-0.2573626637458801,
0.04131605476140976,
0.4628767669200897,
-0.45507243275642395,
0.5924174785614014,
-0.07733780890703201,
-0.39869412779808044,
-0.4902624785900116,
-0.5589635372161865,
0.10968978703022003,
0.017402786761522293,
-0.580720841884613,
0.13450594246387482,
-0.40044787526130676,
-0.1785207837820053,
-0.05142190679907799,
-0.10266047716140747,
0.11888912320137024,
0.024979082867503166,
0.22311553359031677,
0.09993831813335419,
-0.21377292275428772,
0.16570095717906952,
-0.5043609142303467,
0.05324796959757805,
0.18684881925582886,
0.13898448646068573,
0.7106056809425354,
-0.2599743604660034,
-0.6739932894706726,
-0.39472225308418274,
0.13438712060451508,
0.7032710909843445,
-0.1334906816482544,
0.42449355125427246,
0.1501992642879486,
-0.23382142186164856,
-0.11122498661279678,
-1.0759575366973877,
-0.541222333908081,
-0.4610435962677002,
0.41407135128974915,
-0.31915196776390076,
-0.8021231889724731,
0.6684989333152771,
-0.22103962302207947,
0.40479496121406555,
0.17834873497486115,
0.720901608467102,
-0.10034601390361786,
0.7565513253211975,
0.5141240358352661,
-0.1119682565331459,
0.31558987498283386,
0.16235382854938507,
-0.005194876343011856,
-0.7218082547187805,
-0.17193272709846497,
-0.7571564316749573,
-0.44506800174713135,
-0.26947158575057983,
-0.2256205826997757,
-0.3338995575904846,
0.05969873443245888,
-0.21957218647003174,
0.3236725330352783,
-0.00861197430640459,
0.4197191894054413,
0.2863987684249878,
-0.17499399185180664,
0.16672363877296448,
-0.1258302628993988,
-0.1537400335073471,
-0.12529607117176056,
-0.561401903629303,
-0.5225998759269714,
0.8747984170913696,
0.5014609098434448,
1.0049327611923218,
0.35818642377853394,
0.5237215161323547,
0.05497501417994499,
0.7334244847297668,
-0.5727916955947876,
0.7768515348434448,
0.08440900593996048,
-0.38092589378356934,
-0.07343218475580215,
-0.6061276793479919,
-0.8333755731582642,
0.2467821091413498,
-0.029615212231874466,
-0.8378579020500183,
-0.24003787338733673,
0.27272161841392517,
-0.25119656324386597,
0.1521545946598053,
-0.850296139717102,
0.8393256068229675,
-0.13252471387386322,
-0.6817692518234253,
-0.34229663014411926,
-0.4757336676120758,
0.38907521963119507,
0.09004199504852295,
0.09459823369979858,
0.058446601033210754,
0.004272826481610537,
0.4388297498226166,
-0.40073683857917786,
1.1039128303527832,
-0.033243704587221146,
-0.25053051114082336,
0.2540796995162964,
0.2813299000263214,
0.577388346195221,
-0.21031324565410614,
-0.08974997699260712,
-0.3864908516407013,
-0.0759332925081253,
-0.12775671482086182,
-0.8202100396156311,
1.0462039709091187,
-0.3109242618083954,
-0.9185304641723633,
-0.04210970923304558,
-0.31312137842178345,
-0.3369140625,
0.30127209424972534,
-0.041092317551374435,
0.28601157665252686,
-0.28919583559036255,
0.29427453875541687,
0.7325960397720337,
-0.16166456043720245,
0.2608081102371216,
0.8668693900108337,
-0.7384825944900513,
-0.45515453815460205,
0.5941619873046875,
0.07789162546396255,
0.4147471785545349,
0.09689171612262726,
0.14233635365962982,
-0.4502175450325012,
-0.4103364646434784,
-0.5757620930671692,
0.38704055547714233,
-0.7253711819648743,
-0.16825194656848907,
-0.09611716121435165,
-0.05291317030787468,
-0.2799546718597412,
0.13893269002437592,
-0.35354679822921753,
-0.3191022276878357,
-0.15800605714321136,
0.05661527067422867,
0.02958289347589016,
0.9012377262115479,
0.5303073525428772,
0.19068363308906555,
-0.8606749773025513,
0.17953839898109436,
0.2757466733455658,
0.5225461721420288,
0.4115772247314453,
-0.8646494150161743,
0.0035085382405668497,
-0.011286923661828041,
-0.5172849297523499,
-0.9193994402885437,
-0.06135665252804756,
-0.054219458252191544,
0.7436854243278503,
0.2621000111103058,
0.04757231846451759,
0.8449901938438416,
-0.5876038074493408,
0.7213625907897949,
-0.016048986464738846,
-0.9008139371871948,
0.3903069794178009,
-0.07783294469118118,
0.7347674369812012,
0.7011174559593201,
0.34512701630592346,
-0.9292396306991577,
-0.4372817277908325,
-0.5435430407524109,
-0.8845726847648621,
0.42844489216804504,
-0.1497744619846344,
0.3140225410461426,
0.054403625428676605,
0.5864343643188477,
-0.09748116135597229,
0.388021856546402,
-0.6099761128425598,
-0.053064506500959396,
0.08131518959999084,
-0.1817297339439392,
0.09016353636980057,
-0.6038970351219177,
-0.15691931545734406,
0.16294020414352417,
0.6520143151283264,
-0.0247678030282259,
-0.02264557033777237,
-0.10568521916866302,
-0.14257694780826569,
-0.10142841190099716,
0.5698349475860596,
0.9460676908493042,
0.9111852645874023,
-0.13398075103759766,
0.05170831084251404,
0.4033704400062561,
-0.14467550814151764,
0.009573763236403465,
0.099371537566185,
-0.25188520550727844,
0.02986542321741581,
0.4415394067764282,
0.5514305233955383,
0.3335680663585663,
-0.9040187001228333,
0.19558021426200867,
-0.14038817584514618,
-0.06703734397888184,
-0.3086758852005005,
0.013486666604876518,
0.3920425474643707,
0.1210424080491066,
-0.036595772951841354,
-0.21003007888793945,
-0.05711142346262932,
-0.6779454350471497,
0.2314668446779251,
0.3441605865955353,
-0.53046053647995,
-0.13439522683620453,
0.27136003971099854,
0.23866626620292664,
-0.45765018463134766,
0.8601065874099731,
0.08646155148744583,
-0.5521497130393982,
0.3001335859298706,
0.5885071158409119,
0.6681683659553528,
-0.41529881954193115,
-0.16057279706001282,
0.46564704179763794,
0.26733654737472534,
-0.25477898120880127,
0.15558399260044098,
0.08810587972402573,
-0.46948984265327454,
-0.43734654784202576,
-0.011940006166696548,
-0.6837462186813354,
0.22619374096393585,
-0.8830410838127136,
0.169087216258049,
-0.6973903179168701,
-0.34600746631622314,
-0.15091989934444427,
-0.14788810908794403,
-0.38220179080963135,
-0.1192248985171318,
-0.017170997336506844,
1.2305783033370972,
-0.4317835867404938,
0.721938967704773,
0.6821198463439941,
-0.4298994541168213,
-0.648013710975647,
0.03225886821746826,
0.36252203583717346,
-0.7565390467643738,
0.5568739175796509,
0.31080180406570435,
-0.38509124517440796,
-0.21402095258235931,
-0.6314168572425842,
-0.4604831337928772,
0.8562379479408264,
0.46950915455818176,
-1.06942617893219,
0.35777267813682556,
-0.2193993330001831,
0.7065929770469666,
-0.21924547851085663,
0.47761595249176025,
0.6279972195625305,
0.31297945976257324,
0.33567166328430176,
-0.9353736639022827,
0.2084953635931015,
-0.3092670738697052,
-0.015020276419818401,
-0.023030109703540802,
-0.7864912748336792,
0.5591822862625122,
-0.25424590706825256,
-0.24095028638839722,
0.41434139013290405,
0.8177595138549805,
0.38393956422805786,
0.07337778806686401,
0.5937348008155823,
0.7556449770927429,
0.8087806701660156,
0.013411068357527256,
0.9907098412513733,
-0.04975908622145653,
0.3043447434902191,
1.6242820024490356,
-0.6240972280502319,
1.3018434047698975,
0.3959046006202698,
-0.05626682564616203,
0.7220291495323181,
0.24339917302131653,
-0.014764422550797462,
0.2598533034324646,
0.6765902638435364,
-0.12670747935771942,
-0.157151997089386,
-0.04488397762179375,
-0.3588194251060486,
-0.07151960581541061,
0.19445088505744934,
-0.23466598987579346,
-0.2182309776544571,
-0.3081386387348175,
0.2573736608028412,
0.44350624084472656,
-0.2628468871116638,
0.8464469909667969,
0.058549411594867706,
-1.101227045059204,
0.9058312177658081,
0.14164981245994568,
0.26778653264045715,
-0.7188380360603333,
-0.1336030215024948,
-0.44098833203315735,
0.5271750092506409,
-0.11469877511262894,
-0.8851099014282227,
0.13674801588058472,
0.2642160654067993,
-0.2845054566860199,
-0.2080250084400177,
0.361260324716568,
-0.658780038356781,
-0.38130560517311096,
0.24586662650108337,
-0.04399405047297478,
0.00034610647708177567,
0.14587706327438354,
-0.7186290621757507,
0.43284332752227783,
0.34935125708580017,
-0.2854935824871063,
0.15199510753154755,
0.2575332522392273,
0.004073572810739279,
1.1146430969238281,
0.4086102545261383,
-0.12074176967144012,
-0.17388062179088593,
0.31269609928131104,
0.8926085233688354,
-0.5668679475784302,
0.02319730818271637,
-0.8494937419891357,
0.4638407826423645,
-0.12054920941591263,
-0.15126356482505798,
1.0721474885940552,
0.4539073407649994,
0.9297621846199036,
0.01933307573199272,
0.5713934302330017,
0.2878003716468811,
0.8210819363594055,
-0.6399812698364258,
0.44911473989486694,
-0.4888673722743988,
0.6568089723587036,
-0.06985808163881302,
-0.7659541964530945,
-0.007152469363063574,
0.5169669389724731,
-0.43048548698425293,
0.33197730779647827,
0.5792493224143982,
0.7938087582588196,
0.05714923143386841,
0.07041987776756287,
0.07760655879974365,
0.4497252404689789,
0.4442168176174164,
0.6008771061897278,
0.9455377459526062,
-0.09532660245895386,
0.547463595867157,
0.01823139190673828,
-0.07368801534175873,
-0.3994292914867401,
-0.9847867488861084,
-0.9066081643104553,
-0.1960216462612152,
-0.28270888328552246,
-0.5651895403862,
0.019641680642962456,
0.9337678551673889,
0.5038082599639893,
-0.926103413105011,
-0.5344565510749817,
0.19240570068359375,
0.16997335851192474,
-0.15130466222763062,
-0.14407478272914886,
0.051957227289676666,
-0.5785712003707886,
-0.5402839779853821,
0.4341106116771698,
-0.062137532979249954,
0.05211617052555084,
-0.4461705684661865,
0.03476547822356224,
-0.03646717220544815,
0.22311760485172272,
0.33101871609687805,
0.5594878792762756,
-0.9024171829223633,
-0.4084695279598236,
0.18279121816158295,
-0.2717227339744568,
-0.1194426566362381,
0.9005923867225647,
-0.6947882175445557,
0.5914843082427979,
0.5052863955497742,
0.8320874571800232,
0.47177591919898987,
0.20951490104198456,
0.7658751606941223,
-0.6422808766365051,
-0.10972993075847626,
0.04949941858649254,
0.3029595613479614,
0.509392499923706,
-0.029698416590690613,
0.2904294729232788,
-0.08795269578695297,
-0.7014877200126648,
-0.6972537636756897,
0.28072667121887207,
-0.7042897939682007,
-0.2782954275608063,
1.0498605966567993,
-0.5319033861160278,
-0.06718723475933075,
0.13209551572799683,
-0.3271197974681854,
-0.35967662930488586,
-0.40574583411216736,
0.7314038872718811,
1.1506868600845337,
0.10563049465417862,
-0.5364362597465515,
-0.650439977645874,
0.11893712729215622,
0.6807365417480469,
-0.6454612016677856,
0.7454589009284973,
0.7283173203468323,
0.6038621068000793,
0.15270891785621643,
0.7161328196525574,
0.07333202660083771,
0.1989241987466812,
-0.2720020115375519,
-0.02032393217086792,
-0.0786447674036026,
-0.3870350420475006,
-0.517052173614502,
0.054543789476156235,
0.5324578285217285,
0.17036929726600647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13462v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13462v1
|
Potential and Challenges of Model Editing for Social Debiasing
| 2024-02-21T01:35:26 | 2024-02-21T01:35:26 |
Jianhao Yan, Futing Wang, Yafu Li, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) trained on vast corpora suffer from inevitable
stereotype biases. Mitigating these biases with fine-tuning could be both
costly and data-hungry. Model editing methods, which focus on modifying LLMs in
a post-hoc manner, are of great potential to address debiasing. However, it
lacks a comprehensive study that facilitates both internal and external model
editing methods, supports various bias types, as well as understands the pros
and cons of applying editing methods to stereotypical debiasing. To mitigate
this gap, we carefully formulate social debiasing into an editing problem and
benchmark seven existing model editing algorithms on stereotypical debiasing,
i.e., debias editing. Our findings in three scenarios reveal both the potential
and challenges of debias editing: (1) Existing model editing methods can
effectively preserve knowledge and mitigate biases, while the generalization of
debias effect from edited sentences to semantically equivalent sentences is
limited.(2) Sequential editing highlights the robustness of SERAC (Mitchell et
al. 2022b), while internal editing methods degenerate with the number of edits.
(3) Model editing algorithms achieve generalization towards unseen biases both
within the same type and from different types. In light of these findings, we
further propose two simple but effective methods to improve debias editing, and
experimentally show the effectiveness of the proposed methods.
|
[
-0.24833336472511292,
-0.8743394017219543,
0.7158744931221008,
0.18232876062393188,
-0.15172289311885834,
0.32671335339546204,
-0.27193331718444824,
-0.54463791847229,
0.22081054747104645,
0.412352055311203,
-0.4031177759170532,
-0.6362337470054626,
-0.8054562211036682,
0.3140803873538971,
-0.3407588005065918,
0.6286645531654358,
0.008291699923574924,
0.38307279348373413,
-0.1036003828048706,
-0.2327960580587387,
-0.5422305464744568,
-0.8290442824363708,
-0.6754589080810547,
-0.0920514166355133,
0.3961573541164398,
0.42569008469581604,
1.156908392906189,
0.4099990725517273,
0.5042158365249634,
0.25462085008621216,
-0.8468002080917358,
0.297011137008667,
-0.6833755373954773,
0.2582504153251648,
-0.3432784378528595,
-0.37743625044822693,
-0.7338417768478394,
0.2417999505996704,
0.513974666595459,
0.8051748275756836,
0.21923111379146576,
0.1896338164806366,
0.21438348293304443,
0.7917931079864502,
-0.7543925642967224,
-0.02731441520154476,
-0.9414727091789246,
-0.1612781137228012,
-0.052873898297548294,
0.20336683094501495,
-0.1397581398487091,
-0.5246096253395081,
-0.09899786859750748,
-0.2930138111114502,
0.20245422422885895,
-0.32174938917160034,
0.53419429063797,
0.49769696593284607,
-0.20576883852481842,
-0.23870356380939484,
-0.8341481685638428,
0.4190479516983032,
-0.8643677234649658,
0.29775750637054443,
0.46744224429130554,
-0.028477616608142853,
-0.06652623414993286,
-0.17507009208202362,
-0.3037562072277069,
-0.030693305656313896,
0.11362214386463165,
-0.27288755774497986,
-0.155553936958313,
0.2757428288459778,
0.5463132262229919,
0.0492098294198513,
-0.06731785088777542,
0.3204728364944458,
-0.5588963627815247,
0.09466683119535446,
0.7163800597190857,
0.14312441647052765,
0.19498009979724884,
-0.3922106623649597,
0.018541190773248672,
0.1556011140346527,
-0.8230608701705933,
-0.1746065616607666,
0.5479094982147217,
0.1222091019153595,
-0.01160829421132803,
0.8155839443206787,
-0.28631433844566345,
0.5148319602012634,
0.23210561275482178,
0.20138823986053467,
0.11501012742519379,
0.01115065161138773,
-0.24717257916927338,
0.1479293704032898,
0.2938384413719177,
0.9373759627342224,
0.5129956603050232,
-0.04152146354317665,
-0.15830226242542267,
0.4304952919483185,
0.12199410796165466,
-0.47247314453125,
0.2215186357498169,
0.25095635652542114,
-0.431718647480011,
-0.8042700290679932,
-0.2863444685935974,
-0.7381157279014587,
-0.9279806017875671,
-0.4609891176223755,
0.19556958973407745,
-0.32622259855270386,
0.23420025408267975,
0.3238372802734375,
-0.3637488782405853,
-0.19704389572143555,
0.5217981338500977,
-0.6981196999549866,
0.14558912813663483,
0.6629726886749268,
1.013647198677063,
0.33657553791999817,
0.00858320388942957,
-0.3044949769973755,
0.2432655245065689,
-0.5042229294776917,
0.5603925585746765,
-0.9136900305747986,
-0.552614152431488,
-0.14032752811908722,
-0.3229057192802429,
0.16538113355636597,
-0.4553425908088684,
0.2685422897338867,
-0.612228512763977,
-0.2866683900356293,
-0.5925993919372559,
-0.5060063004493713,
0.022562744095921516,
0.23822073638439178,
-0.6006392240524292,
1.0007688999176025,
-0.13300757110118866,
-0.9285630583763123,
0.23095794022083282,
-0.3651207983493805,
-0.21248124539852142,
-0.6149672269821167,
0.22678352892398834,
-0.11615630239248276,
0.46612823009490967,
0.4452374279499054,
0.37876757979393005,
-0.1622842401266098,
0.5280504822731018,
-0.95054030418396,
-0.36191898584365845,
0.30236291885375977,
-0.15891733765602112,
0.7704994082450867,
0.15701782703399658,
-0.3261389434337616,
0.3032323122024536,
-0.8036319017410278,
-0.4962936341762543,
-0.04062061384320259,
0.06374186277389526,
-0.7574533820152283,
0.08362925052642822,
-0.22138550877571106,
0.20525166392326355,
0.16100533306598663,
-0.49947962164878845,
0.37673211097717285,
-0.3699621260166168,
0.5181173086166382,
1.3170465230941772,
0.07400954514741898,
0.5772765278816223,
-0.3852664530277252,
0.5536811947822571,
-0.20243187248706818,
0.4214783310890198,
0.4900898337364197,
-0.2708893418312073,
-0.6758497953414917,
-0.3035120964050293,
0.5359947681427002,
0.6166300177574158,
-0.5354382395744324,
0.12494837492704391,
0.014448828063905239,
-0.8081921935081482,
-0.7042872905731201,
0.24868445098400116,
0.23529906570911407,
0.276460200548172,
0.31496021151542664,
-0.10533951967954636,
-0.6850348711013794,
-1.0135101079940796,
-0.5849378705024719,
0.10797138512134552,
0.16081151366233826,
-0.069012850522995,
0.4470309019088745,
-0.4290790557861328,
0.8575199842453003,
-0.5035396218299866,
-0.1598021388053894,
-0.17190277576446533,
-0.041356220841407776,
-0.09864243865013123,
0.3325931131839752,
0.5906091332435608,
-0.48684683442115784,
-0.32064157724380493,
-0.4350873827934265,
-0.7709915041923523,
-0.42343080043792725,
-0.12120281904935837,
-0.2233172059059143,
0.26635485887527466,
0.7027694582939148,
-0.6808878183364868,
0.6258867979049683,
0.4057554304599762,
-0.062218669801950455,
0.5370039939880371,
-0.21736851334571838,
0.1825873851776123,
-0.8228095173835754,
-0.3601957857608795,
0.039049532264471054,
-0.061113204807043076,
-0.5042147636413574,
-0.030187854543328285,
-0.024619953706860542,
-0.014552297070622444,
-0.3220670521259308,
0.47977012395858765,
-0.6722328662872314,
0.006498053204268217,
-0.19036740064620972,
0.2807084918022156,
-0.11700143665075302,
-0.012741738930344582,
-0.12637946009635925,
0.22993238270282745,
0.4491811692714691,
-0.4972594082355499,
0.25340503454208374,
0.31786078214645386,
-0.49557700753211975,
0.22226940095424652,
-0.8306325674057007,
0.4591096341609955,
-0.5833216309547424,
0.3421997129917145,
-0.7458856701850891,
-0.026270324364304543,
0.38329240679740906,
-0.10851175338029861,
0.0556722916662693,
-0.24434193968772888,
-0.4650803208351135,
-0.019603416323661804,
-0.7315780520439148,
0.2746761739253998,
0.2577759325504303,
-0.4266212284564972,
0.27588918805122375,
0.398848295211792,
-0.4253334403038025,
-0.711394190788269,
-0.5503708720207214,
0.27225059270858765,
-0.21014997363090515,
-0.7544538974761963,
0.5326860547065735,
-0.0868888646364212,
-0.8759300708770752,
0.06348736584186554,
-0.05302932858467102,
0.23098129034042358,
0.18775776028633118,
0.13720828294754028,
0.44688680768013,
0.32098108530044556,
0.10390342026948929,
0.5097879767417908,
0.0022019408643245697,
-0.12569190561771393,
0.31607183814048767,
0.2541934549808502,
0.2316875159740448,
-0.21826402842998505,
-0.18417616188526154,
0.2541036605834961,
0.6774190664291382,
-0.29030200839042664,
0.6348415613174438,
0.03136824443936348,
-0.568588376045227,
-0.16618113219738007,
-0.7947816848754883,
-0.17106448113918304,
-0.42395952343940735,
0.38701775670051575,
-0.3444318175315857,
-0.8595529794692993,
0.5568968057632446,
0.06570348143577576,
0.017890673130750656,
0.13936251401901245,
0.42955467104911804,
0.0609591081738472,
0.9925290942192078,
0.5510677099227905,
-0.033638037741184235,
0.4139620065689087,
-0.06483953446149826,
0.1678018420934677,
-0.8405025005340576,
0.18570002913475037,
-0.6657962203025818,
-0.569650411605835,
-0.5890699028968811,
-0.6215642094612122,
0.2828626334667206,
0.18610036373138428,
-0.05111775919795036,
-0.004133422393351793,
-0.4314565360546112,
0.47185367345809937,
0.4249417781829834,
0.35656049847602844,
0.5042904615402222,
-0.16392624378204346,
0.1671377420425415,
-0.17348872125148773,
-0.5590689182281494,
-0.7934863567352295,
1.216261863708496,
0.41232383251190186,
0.9918748736381531,
0.0564323328435421,
0.7110682129859924,
0.4085482656955719,
0.25927281379699707,
-0.39577704668045044,
0.5661847591400146,
-0.22670221328735352,
-0.9260419607162476,
-0.37303292751312256,
-0.16304931044578552,
-0.20272086560726166,
0.24827401340007782,
-0.39370933175086975,
-0.77254718542099,
0.7414930462837219,
0.48777902126312256,
-0.35572895407676697,
0.5190408229827881,
-0.5113720893859863,
0.7171878218650818,
-0.19593167304992676,
-0.5065400004386902,
-0.4684995412826538,
-0.7403512001037598,
0.30401283502578735,
-0.09121768176555634,
0.6636916995048523,
-0.1379128396511078,
0.16298037767410278,
0.4898800253868103,
-0.3305920958518982,
1.2110716104507446,
-0.27306750416755676,
-0.06251827627420425,
0.12249279022216797,
0.3551439940929413,
0.6507910490036011,
0.2090115249156952,
-0.4135052263736725,
0.2510693073272705,
0.16144204139709473,
-0.1964704841375351,
-0.6322727799415588,
0.4966772496700287,
-0.651947021484375,
-0.9377972483634949,
-0.46507659554481506,
-0.5159698128700256,
-0.4209919571876526,
-0.24815452098846436,
0.12677574157714844,
0.37855663895606995,
-0.5153049826622009,
-0.009266773238778114,
0.4515766501426697,
-0.46516844630241394,
0.05871699005365372,
0.13385504484176636,
-0.2293902337551117,
-0.4063211679458618,
0.31345099210739136,
0.34997498989105225,
0.45382267236709595,
0.10733389109373093,
0.24604183435440063,
0.031034795567393303,
-0.6381232738494873,
-0.1880989670753479,
0.2619374394416809,
-0.798909604549408,
-0.025257695466279984,
-0.830062210559845,
0.01914999820291996,
-0.8936135768890381,
-0.6124430298805237,
-0.4315728545188904,
-0.5872043967247009,
-0.27602946758270264,
-0.32172706723213196,
0.4388485252857208,
0.8785310983657837,
-0.6252748966217041,
0.20854339003562927,
-0.7031877040863037,
0.6169283986091614,
0.053439099341630936,
0.2205912172794342,
-0.06441062688827515,
-0.5964881181716919,
0.023622706532478333,
0.3299265205860138,
-0.01425923127681017,
-1.2294408082962036,
0.32699620723724365,
-0.1918964833021164,
0.2402455359697342,
0.2871091067790985,
0.3125453293323517,
0.7820948958396912,
-0.39577963948249817,
0.5472714304924011,
-0.2706662714481354,
-1.2155755758285522,
0.5680151581764221,
-0.23657412827014923,
-0.06288852542638779,
0.6533606052398682,
0.41466403007507324,
-0.772605836391449,
-0.6639113426208496,
-0.40259382128715515,
-0.7201570272445679,
0.6470217704772949,
-0.031316548585891724,
0.13307078182697296,
-0.19308404624462128,
0.5467629432678223,
0.16234607994556427,
0.23166021704673767,
-0.4944249987602234,
-0.07248134911060333,
-0.053078003227710724,
0.04287642613053322,
-0.1944044977426529,
-0.9455615282058716,
0.028151901438832283,
-0.5477160215377808,
0.96695476770401,
0.36069536209106445,
-0.349087119102478,
0.42254701256752014,
-0.3420449495315552,
-0.0033818793017417192,
0.5784019827842712,
0.5942864418029785,
0.6542611122131348,
-0.6154876351356506,
-0.04613937810063362,
0.364511638879776,
-0.05291992053389549,
0.15273471176624298,
0.004068688489496708,
-0.6330384612083435,
0.054032016545534134,
0.10701226443052292,
0.8653761744499207,
0.3744211196899414,
-0.34934329986572266,
0.102972112596035,
0.11336773633956909,
-0.1871061772108078,
-0.2104559689760208,
-0.12354276329278946,
0.2178209125995636,
0.38307973742485046,
-0.16417868435382843,
0.2295856475830078,
0.13787373900413513,
-0.4747936725616455,
-0.4024637043476105,
0.57584148645401,
-0.334282249212265,
-0.17131663858890533,
0.7916892766952515,
0.23015126585960388,
-0.17693676054477692,
0.3445475399494171,
-0.04548904299736023,
-0.5350488424301147,
0.4876142740249634,
0.24613481760025024,
0.8847699165344238,
-0.3637358844280243,
0.2855592966079712,
0.3028101921081543,
0.6789227724075317,
-0.22102081775665283,
-0.05731873959302902,
0.3977782726287842,
-0.910672664642334,
-0.3106316924095154,
-0.43647024035453796,
-0.5795539021492004,
0.1546565294265747,
-0.5373650789260864,
0.5878900289535522,
-0.6039690375328064,
-0.327107310295105,
0.12005214393138885,
-0.48453113436698914,
-0.5262786149978638,
0.08872652053833008,
0.09779243916273117,
0.8502306938171387,
-0.6894130110740662,
0.5971700549125671,
0.7989142537117004,
-0.21032749116420746,
-0.3445933163166046,
-0.3004724383354187,
0.42580172419548035,
-0.4327019155025482,
0.6364743113517761,
0.019748907536268234,
-0.25595325231552124,
-0.24781450629234314,
-0.5108338594436646,
-0.8348681330680847,
0.5558817982673645,
0.5942769646644592,
-0.8328101634979248,
-0.5380776524543762,
0.07081376016139984,
0.4555482566356659,
-0.2705989480018616,
0.07778064906597137,
0.620934009552002,
0.6925594210624695,
-0.19217407703399658,
-0.7790839076042175,
0.19579137861728668,
-0.07650814950466156,
0.22877676784992218,
-0.2524026334285736,
-0.5948802828788757,
0.7443333864212036,
-0.2773353159427643,
0.006991799455136061,
-0.08724896609783173,
0.14961101114749908,
-0.09434916824102402,
0.17106181383132935,
0.6953977942466736,
0.49477124214172363,
0.5977770686149597,
0.3889005780220032,
0.7936169505119324,
-0.2326487898826599,
0.10909108072519302,
1.4046943187713623,
-0.7537647485733032,
0.37699928879737854,
0.3919937014579773,
0.040670160204172134,
0.1945364624261856,
0.6883310675621033,
0.11893719434738159,
0.2523828148841858,
0.29131942987442017,
-0.1656428426504135,
-0.32292303442955017,
0.11989418417215347,
-0.4620772898197174,
0.6823040843009949,
0.29143068194389343,
-0.47370031476020813,
-0.14380694925785065,
0.04688813537359238,
0.35107845067977905,
0.2938176095485687,
-0.22577662765979767,
0.5741634964942932,
0.064602792263031,
-0.34930041432380676,
0.3718056082725525,
0.336499959230423,
0.7469814419746399,
-0.38539034128189087,
0.06666363030672073,
-0.2308615744113922,
0.18229614198207855,
-0.25736531615257263,
-0.3148598074913025,
0.6273161172866821,
0.3669097125530243,
-0.2953687608242035,
-0.2859679162502289,
0.9350239634513855,
-0.20685802400112152,
-0.6796517968177795,
0.626520037651062,
0.5111573934555054,
-0.11677376180887222,
-0.49943017959594727,
-0.47022274136543274,
0.32637131214141846,
0.10489671677350998,
-0.36891457438468933,
0.26722079515457153,
0.25965067744255066,
-0.17411959171295166,
0.4918462634086609,
0.5828657150268555,
0.41494235396385193,
-0.04179903864860535,
0.21704930067062378,
0.7013092041015625,
-0.8981796503067017,
-0.24617646634578705,
-1.1082130670547485,
0.38930854201316833,
-0.2817147672176361,
-0.21679869294166565,
0.6131307482719421,
0.3155900239944458,
0.89830482006073,
-0.22617676854133606,
0.9530115723609924,
0.11872135102748871,
0.5026531219482422,
-0.5666883587837219,
0.7591588497161865,
-0.3836345374584198,
0.38295403122901917,
-0.8470612168312073,
-0.9992870092391968,
-0.36288174986839294,
0.5108230113983154,
-0.7076669335365295,
-0.31191039085388184,
0.5741564035415649,
1.1483689546585083,
0.2201288789510727,
0.0732484981417656,
0.3408433198928833,
0.5795856714248657,
0.11552201956510544,
0.08169662207365036,
0.9016504883766174,
-0.15013299882411957,
0.2097112536430359,
-0.8106449842453003,
-0.463356077671051,
-0.09637919813394547,
-0.7916621565818787,
-1.145616054534912,
-0.3034280240535736,
-0.3876557946205139,
-0.3063986301422119,
0.6012688875198364,
1.134102463722229,
0.25989073514938354,
-0.42025771737098694,
-0.12072672694921494,
0.2912534773349762,
0.43602249026298523,
-0.1689700335264206,
-0.17369304597377777,
0.19106319546699524,
-0.1515139639377594,
-0.743863046169281,
0.23641720414161682,
0.1519118845462799,
-0.09608578681945801,
0.05566398799419403,
0.31538382172584534,
-0.2639291286468506,
0.3430342972278595,
0.8304900527000427,
-0.21360838413238525,
-0.5350898504257202,
-0.5432564616203308,
-0.12127604335546494,
0.03190714120864868,
-0.10725796222686768,
0.7010985612869263,
-0.4259672462940216,
0.499986469745636,
0.3309418559074402,
0.457890123128891,
0.3823142349720001,
0.15410444140434265,
0.5451104640960693,
-0.37502729892730713,
0.2722257971763611,
0.07749216258525848,
0.5064924955368042,
0.5204119086265564,
-0.460496723651886,
0.5972020626068115,
0.27933982014656067,
-0.4143347144126892,
-0.9365125298500061,
0.19190038740634918,
-0.8692246079444885,
-0.5183209180831909,
1.351319670677185,
0.25173020362854004,
-0.044342558830976486,
-0.058971937745809555,
-0.6160458922386169,
0.4963078498840332,
-0.17479072511196136,
1.1174930334091187,
0.9634500741958618,
0.14148327708244324,
0.14179491996765137,
-0.5176956057548523,
0.46841293573379517,
0.3977217972278595,
-0.6168592572212219,
0.4141073524951935,
1.0267950296401978,
0.2975286841392517,
-0.26430433988571167,
0.6192059516906738,
-0.25040221214294434,
0.0638231635093689,
-0.10041006654500961,
0.2830338776111603,
-0.10926858335733414,
-0.2265736311674118,
-0.46438834071159363,
-0.045078132301568985,
0.1816423237323761,
0.169179305434227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13459v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13459v1
|
Learning to Poison Large Language Models During Instruction Tuning
| 2024-02-21T01:30:03 | 2024-02-21T01:30:03 |
Yao Qiang, Xiangyu Zhou, Saleh Zare Zade, Mohammad Amin Roshani, Douglas Zytko, Dongxiao Zhu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has marked significant
achievements in language processing and reasoning capabilities. Despite their
advancements, LLMs face vulnerabilities to data poisoning attacks, where
adversaries insert backdoor triggers into training data to manipulate outputs
for malicious purposes. This work further identifies additional security risks
in LLMs by designing a new data poisoning attack tailored to exploit the
instruction tuning process. We propose a novel gradient-guided backdoor trigger
learning approach to identify adversarial triggers efficiently, ensuring an
evasion of detection by conventional defenses while maintaining content
integrity. Through experimental validation across various LLMs and tasks, our
strategy demonstrates a high success rate in compromising model outputs;
poisoning only 1\% of 4,000 instruction tuning samples leads to a Performance
Drop Rate (PDR) of around 80\%. Our work highlights the need for stronger
defenses against data poisoning attack, offering insights into safeguarding
LLMs against these more sophisticated attacks. The source code can be found on
this GitHub repository: https://github.com/RookieZxy/GBTL/blob/main/README.md.
|
[
-0.125371515750885,
-0.8546465039253235,
0.2671819031238556,
-0.3102564215660095,
0.02559812180697918,
0.010723106563091278,
-0.31731098890304565,
0.025295628234744072,
-0.3962910771369934,
0.8282350897789001,
-0.6583992838859558,
-0.8514435291290283,
-0.6319262385368347,
-0.38506942987442017,
-0.5954619646072388,
1.1756689548492432,
0.3717891275882721,
0.13016238808631897,
0.17345844209194183,
0.22621750831604004,
-0.580849289894104,
-0.5153799653053284,
-0.9009749293327332,
-0.10279741883277893,
0.6986410021781921,
0.26968830823898315,
0.4265611469745636,
0.6886826753616333,
0.24661433696746826,
0.27080243825912476,
0.013490138575434685,
0.012353941798210144,
-0.7618159055709839,
0.3334680199623108,
-0.15130390226840973,
-0.7260756492614746,
-0.3365502655506134,
-0.10994480550289154,
0.39770764112472534,
0.1597088724374771,
-0.33047887682914734,
-0.03387335687875748,
0.0769549310207367,
0.7805981040000916,
-0.8974630236625671,
-0.06967229396104813,
-1.1724872589111328,
0.15124408900737762,
-0.4431120753288269,
-0.4350182116031647,
-0.936626672744751,
-0.20647966861724854,
-0.4672665596008301,
-0.24626998603343964,
0.13886459171772003,
-0.06294039636850357,
0.4417761564254761,
0.5564261674880981,
-0.253263384103775,
-0.27825960516929626,
-0.2868777811527252,
0.656838595867157,
-0.696247935295105,
0.2959936261177063,
0.2985973060131073,
0.32038238644599915,
-0.49176836013793945,
-0.3977779150009155,
-0.3055078089237213,
-0.150893896818161,
0.1261747181415558,
-0.12556326389312744,
-0.1693463921546936,
0.011814041994512081,
0.47857466340065,
0.16931428015232086,
-0.7814190983772278,
0.5092451572418213,
-0.2126854509115219,
-0.2852644622325897,
0.6618232131004333,
0.4718479514122009,
0.4460379481315613,
0.0888105183839798,
-0.3717503547668457,
-0.20805512368679047,
-1.3232836723327637,
-0.1629677414894104,
0.8607950806617737,
0.4915856719017029,
0.056554101407527924,
0.148024782538414,
0.1849377155303955,
0.7557488679885864,
0.1275484561920166,
0.2969132363796234,
-0.05638889595866203,
0.167449489235878,
-0.19760891795158386,
0.16162870824337006,
0.8084238767623901,
0.21433022618293762,
0.29532793164253235,
-0.14132605493068695,
-0.3114233613014221,
-0.1438482701778412,
0.6092742681503296,
-0.8851253986358643,
-0.4365057349205017,
0.26788613200187683,
0.05009406432509422,
-0.6503516435623169,
-0.14780662953853607,
-1.10885751247406,
-0.6356034278869629,
0.26382142305374146,
0.47454312443733215,
-0.5584721565246582,
0.034412506967782974,
0.10948684811592102,
0.029316503554582596,
0.27737152576446533,
-0.06236724928021431,
-1.280566930770874,
0.04604848101735115,
1.0055699348449707,
0.6803719997406006,
-0.07204289734363556,
-0.26979219913482666,
-1.144017219543457,
0.3439270853996277,
-0.47011464834213257,
0.4531858563423157,
-0.5820643901824951,
-0.4886086881160736,
0.3405130207538605,
-0.06084797903895378,
-0.039029788225889206,
-0.6592133045196533,
0.4551912844181061,
-1.0891143083572388,
-0.001767404843121767,
-0.11089250445365906,
-0.46136289834976196,
0.04360330477356911,
0.2859334945678711,
-0.7579463720321655,
0.6888807415962219,
-0.22441861033439636,
-0.640443742275238,
0.08374903351068497,
-0.27600914239883423,
-0.7605944275856018,
0.05206264555454254,
-0.1063264012336731,
-0.4277089536190033,
-0.06957720965147018,
0.30630722641944885,
0.6106822490692139,
0.05246983468532562,
-0.041523177176713943,
-0.24831806123256683,
-0.3696645200252533,
0.15371638536453247,
-0.4867873787879944,
0.8826550841331482,
0.09011345356702805,
-0.06775310635566711,
0.16205307841300964,
-0.8034896850585938,
0.0441129133105278,
0.03739006817340851,
-0.5438593626022339,
-0.21262706816196442,
-0.040233634412288666,
-0.47080761194229126,
0.17482240498065948,
0.06873800605535507,
-0.30387642979621887,
0.22723697125911713,
-0.4962068498134613,
0.268328994512558,
1.1013935804367065,
0.2511424124240875,
0.3799537420272827,
-0.21339493989944458,
0.5381578803062439,
0.1497023105621338,
0.3368402123451233,
-0.48244762420654297,
-0.25748908519744873,
-0.5044521689414978,
-0.3019835650920868,
0.18676230311393738,
0.7111949920654297,
-0.9402260184288025,
0.5814346671104431,
-0.07878416776657104,
-0.5764422416687012,
-0.26116320490837097,
0.3707467019557953,
0.6604488492012024,
0.6911731958389282,
0.28270697593688965,
0.05956140533089638,
-0.21580122411251068,
-0.5287905931472778,
-0.6022518277168274,
0.13532130420207977,
-0.33268144726753235,
0.3065274953842163,
0.5186296701431274,
-0.1861267238855362,
0.3337177038192749,
-0.7245966792106628,
-0.3213745951652527,
0.0470837838947773,
-0.12162456661462784,
0.27578985691070557,
0.554547131061554,
0.5107159614562988,
-0.37482935190200806,
-0.4448135495185852,
-0.09909077733755112,
-0.6678361296653748,
-0.1503080576658249,
-0.09606565535068512,
-0.2874962091445923,
0.13029535114765167,
0.7059280276298523,
-0.4545387923717499,
0.26246652007102966,
0.5689454078674316,
0.006311604753136635,
0.5964246392250061,
0.18136096000671387,
-0.06453514099121094,
-0.9880678653717041,
-0.037070583552122116,
0.1519637554883957,
-0.0035166931338608265,
-0.8528541922569275,
0.21682389080524445,
0.34978070855140686,
-0.2959512174129486,
-0.7308367490768433,
0.4180123507976532,
-0.2173508107662201,
0.2683636248111725,
-0.016709277406334877,
-0.14783917367458344,
-0.0700201615691185,
0.5581312775611877,
-0.44559523463249207,
0.8034648895263672,
0.773455798625946,
-0.6417964100837708,
0.7390578389167786,
0.173674076795578,
-0.5034757256507874,
0.4055233895778656,
-0.51048743724823,
0.3574669063091278,
0.19749833643436432,
0.21004073321819305,
-0.7401325106620789,
-0.32367679476737976,
0.5405377149581909,
-0.5630293488502502,
1.0464212894439697,
-0.5814826488494873,
-0.40171730518341064,
-0.011667987331748009,
-0.6004796028137207,
0.02228977344930172,
0.4279158413410187,
-0.8711645007133484,
0.4867497384548187,
0.1828588843345642,
-0.08964254707098007,
-0.8508722186088562,
-0.7134392857551575,
0.23265843093395233,
-0.4109549820423126,
-0.7152889370918274,
0.08963598310947418,
-0.06790413707494736,
-0.06612756103277206,
-0.3363676071166992,
0.029637031257152557,
0.05926201120018959,
0.40632978081703186,
0.16198362410068512,
0.2738496959209442,
-0.12425420433282852,
0.11368793994188309,
0.1257627159357071,
-0.1825890690088272,
0.38408708572387695,
-0.24994222819805145,
0.5781378746032715,
0.29007095098495483,
-0.4466422498226166,
-0.5745924115180969,
0.40421149134635925,
0.5246505737304688,
-0.22221148014068604,
0.9865354299545288,
0.38469818234443665,
-0.21490326523780823,
-0.733486533164978,
-0.28545257449150085,
-0.5538861751556396,
-0.5991052389144897,
0.6308627724647522,
-0.09578832983970642,
-0.3770638108253479,
0.5410802364349365,
-0.06388766318559647,
0.0843123346567154,
0.03736048936843872,
0.5991092920303345,
0.1844409704208374,
1.017762541770935,
0.33891353011131287,
-0.4550763964653015,
0.73783278465271,
-0.3143758773803711,
0.09193398803472519,
-0.953106701374054,
-0.167714923620224,
-0.3009207844734192,
-0.11725230515003204,
-0.35660573840141296,
-0.1319146752357483,
0.42558154463768005,
-0.1915486603975296,
-0.46071362495422363,
-0.009242167696356773,
-0.13805760443210602,
0.7416000962257385,
0.3816870450973511,
0.1884763538837433,
0.04591354355216026,
0.09542124718427658,
-0.06294459104537964,
0.15863291919231415,
-0.5401198863983154,
-0.352830171585083,
1.3160234689712524,
0.40918904542922974,
1.322293758392334,
0.1249614953994751,
0.5849906206130981,
0.27836310863494873,
0.18991872668266296,
-0.5678609013557434,
0.5580450296401978,
-0.22665910422801971,
-0.6752150058746338,
-0.15497508645057678,
-0.6038587093353271,
-0.7852251529693604,
0.09245652705430984,
0.06141611933708191,
-0.7553040981292725,
-0.13840381801128387,
0.22940963506698608,
-0.3112844228744507,
0.485047310590744,
-0.7976411581039429,
0.8141844272613525,
-0.34429919719696045,
-0.6740651726722717,
-0.08298064023256302,
-0.5854771733283997,
0.6684969067573547,
-0.3534829616546631,
0.03363613039255142,
0.08128730952739716,
0.04298606514930725,
0.5084874629974365,
-0.20025447010993958,
1.124213457107544,
-0.15813153982162476,
-0.5022842884063721,
-0.198992520570755,
0.38656818866729736,
0.8133607506752014,
0.10125847160816193,
-0.34357935190200806,
0.3828582465648651,
-0.5081480741500854,
-0.38081544637680054,
-0.6949971318244934,
0.9612339735031128,
-0.4274730384349823,
-0.994285523891449,
-0.215809166431427,
-0.43075114488601685,
-0.2142457515001297,
0.08207722008228302,
0.49157920479774475,
0.47014477849006653,
0.14464423060417175,
0.00036436610389500856,
0.9937780499458313,
-0.41429686546325684,
0.4130381643772125,
0.6005903482437134,
0.13049931824207306,
-0.30779677629470825,
1.122085452079773,
-0.041815146803855896,
0.5728821158409119,
0.2458036094903946,
0.10036352276802063,
-0.022210994735360146,
-0.757031261920929,
-0.62888103723526,
-0.020506886765360832,
-0.7428036332130432,
-0.5077278017997742,
-0.39688369631767273,
-0.33781182765960693,
-0.4079606533050537,
-0.09368984401226044,
-0.28857141733169556,
0.1945772022008896,
-0.5939669013023376,
-0.020519230514764786,
0.34400439262390137,
0.6036915183067322,
0.035782258957624435,
0.3964371383190155,
-0.8689123392105103,
-0.07005366683006287,
0.40315279364585876,
0.3548714518547058,
0.14589428901672363,
-0.6932880878448486,
-0.35646823048591614,
0.00926509965211153,
-0.5539548993110657,
-1.0523536205291748,
0.5863410234451294,
0.2357245683670044,
0.5774667859077454,
0.6507861018180847,
0.13312754034996033,
0.1337825059890747,
-0.7114964127540588,
0.8012268543243408,
-0.03193158656358719,
-0.8379589319229126,
0.715705931186676,
-0.5474039316177368,
-0.02717800810933113,
0.25832873582839966,
0.4740930497646332,
-0.5246131420135498,
-0.39111092686653137,
-0.2227928340435028,
-0.9405680894851685,
0.6903859376907349,
-0.2948344051837921,
0.3790262043476105,
-0.006051027216017246,
0.40433070063591003,
0.10319919139146805,
0.2300499677658081,
-0.5209833383560181,
-0.3489321768283844,
0.13058625161647797,
-0.26866379380226135,
-0.0964176133275032,
-0.26486995816230774,
-0.294450968503952,
0.11030866205692291,
0.8793176412582397,
-0.05349300801753998,
-0.19056358933448792,
-0.48828253149986267,
-0.29438140988349915,
-0.2153870314359665,
0.18892455101013184,
0.43061164021492004,
0.23218393325805664,
0.11164767295122147,
0.15581539273262024,
0.208807572722435,
-0.5662301182746887,
0.10485119372606277,
-0.012622937560081482,
-0.12993070483207703,
-0.592147946357727,
0.6067636609077454,
0.5542775988578796,
0.27565935254096985,
-0.6308616995811462,
0.5239099264144897,
-0.22484007477760315,
0.164211243391037,
-0.04576392471790314,
0.5357609987258911,
-0.0770506039261818,
0.1936226189136505,
0.3599036931991577,
-0.27740100026130676,
-0.1369246542453766,
-0.5018537044525146,
0.3328080475330353,
0.6090879440307617,
-0.263441801071167,
-0.21079453825950623,
0.38930103182792664,
0.2955484092235565,
-0.3496633470058441,
0.683809757232666,
0.049060672521591187,
-0.8901526927947998,
0.4749041199684143,
0.5190525054931641,
0.8110029101371765,
-0.7165539860725403,
-0.21789537370204926,
0.09698935598134995,
0.4052653908729553,
0.22578462958335876,
-0.06578998267650604,
0.16170169413089752,
-0.6176729798316956,
-0.16340768337249756,
-0.47906172275543213,
-0.23368875682353973,
0.46908465027809143,
-0.6634230613708496,
0.3407481908798218,
-0.7350438833236694,
0.2898685038089752,
-0.014611165039241314,
-0.23035775125026703,
0.013159126974642277,
-0.1269519329071045,
0.27560994029045105,
0.8041449189186096,
-0.9514088034629822,
0.7689883708953857,
0.23459962010383606,
-0.17404086887836456,
-0.49710676074028015,
0.3513849973678589,
0.2951986789703369,
-0.9704558849334717,
0.763282299041748,
0.10835553705692291,
-0.12185090780258179,
0.11472605168819427,
-0.6190410256385803,
-0.5346925854682922,
0.6393522620201111,
0.5871666669845581,
-0.6683059930801392,
0.14245906472206116,
-0.1263493001461029,
0.3047806918621063,
0.06396843492984772,
-0.2552475929260254,
0.7173862457275391,
0.24084366858005524,
0.096534863114357,
-0.14016059041023254,
0.14224354922771454,
-0.19997061789035797,
-0.3746025264263153,
0.5458916425704956,
-0.4913293421268463,
0.8242655396461487,
-0.21265991032123566,
-0.32443442940711975,
-0.1615860015153885,
0.28341057896614075,
0.04103081300854683,
0.12236407399177551,
0.31445053219795227,
0.7407419085502625,
0.6938580870628357,
0.06781481206417084,
0.9453144073486328,
-0.41097787022590637,
0.09268109500408173,
1.1739420890808105,
-0.4135739207267761,
0.8246859312057495,
0.1742839366197586,
0.08398617058992386,
0.3248961269855499,
0.5811266899108887,
-0.24962398409843445,
0.7255617380142212,
0.5143228769302368,
-0.5268797278404236,
-0.10238940268754959,
0.18654955923557281,
-0.44109049439430237,
0.32981953024864197,
0.6886301040649414,
-0.47005560994148254,
-0.12469726800918579,
0.0814831554889679,
0.3706299662590027,
0.03331682085990906,
-0.43156933784484863,
0.8081034421920776,
0.031749479472637177,
-0.5935986638069153,
0.7637271285057068,
-0.17048193514347076,
0.5120402574539185,
-0.541351318359375,
-0.008480439893901348,
-0.21189939975738525,
0.39261719584465027,
-0.22869324684143066,
-0.7117434740066528,
0.0637127161026001,
0.14094778895378113,
-0.06046720966696739,
-0.028547225520014763,
0.5566949844360352,
-0.4742297828197479,
-0.17302635312080383,
0.3851318061351776,
-0.12643355131149292,
-0.1857936680316925,
-0.20390817523002625,
-0.4806685745716095,
0.31915754079818726,
-0.11247144639492035,
-0.4014449119567871,
0.608098566532135,
0.24913200736045837,
0.31086623668670654,
0.798917829990387,
0.8181558847427368,
0.22009430825710297,
0.3184836804866791,
0.04389432445168495,
1.2214006185531616,
-0.4802324175834656,
-0.4154719114303589,
-1.3182610273361206,
0.19013555347919464,
-0.06179501861333847,
0.044029295444488525,
0.8334680199623108,
0.5279251337051392,
0.7884541153907776,
0.03256819024682045,
0.6496503949165344,
0.47644180059432983,
0.14785708487033844,
-0.8971370458602905,
1.0715640783309937,
-0.3350748121738434,
0.7292912006378174,
-0.02631707862019539,
-0.45791715383529663,
-0.35178887844085693,
0.17084380984306335,
-0.5119568705558777,
0.17300285398960114,
0.5434596538543701,
1.2793337106704712,
0.17606396973133087,
-0.0030652221757918596,
0.4280925393104553,
0.5311259031295776,
0.6519867181777954,
0.9424239993095398,
1.0235999822616577,
-0.2688320577144623,
0.5937032103538513,
-0.06626003235578537,
-0.27590301632881165,
-0.3230608105659485,
-0.9704801440238953,
-1.2721295356750488,
-0.2555656433105469,
-0.14923349022865295,
-0.5776336789131165,
0.41263821721076965,
0.4998042583465576,
0.7078379988670349,
-0.7630949020385742,
0.21284696459770203,
0.00985634047538042,
0.3461573123931885,
0.06340670585632324,
-0.16951073706150055,
0.29744112491607666,
-0.4711340367794037,
-0.5035260319709778,
0.5770651698112488,
0.20367282629013062,
-0.21706753969192505,
-0.4387935400009155,
0.0927961990237236,
-0.09192614257335663,
0.04806387424468994,
0.18595625460147858,
0.3102569878101349,
-0.42229264974594116,
-0.2300405651330948,
-0.4533638060092926,
-0.1865852326154709,
-0.14754718542099,
0.6858974099159241,
-0.5740191340446472,
0.2475820928812027,
0.32857897877693176,
0.7856085300445557,
0.1667742133140564,
-0.2609216570854187,
0.5751053690910339,
-1.2224321365356445,
0.02628082036972046,
0.3633154034614563,
0.26157161593437195,
0.33752650022506714,
-0.8925818800926208,
0.13857696950435638,
0.08508867770433426,
-0.5199269652366638,
-1.0446401834487915,
0.5413746237754822,
-0.4368344247341156,
-0.28591176867485046,
1.2814706563949585,
-0.38450130820274353,
-0.5442360639572144,
0.1099821999669075,
0.03372977674007416,
0.17735961079597473,
-0.43721112608909607,
0.933639645576477,
0.4415365159511566,
0.3810625970363617,
0.0790572538971901,
-0.6806465983390808,
0.6852591037750244,
0.04663853347301483,
-0.8617050051689148,
0.5313034057617188,
0.4402306377887726,
0.4176202714443207,
-0.12087449431419373,
-0.23172278702259064,
-0.1382778137922287,
0.3935125172138214,
-0.045139163732528687,
-0.17878390848636627,
-0.2608708143234253,
-0.48762375116348267,
-0.8372091054916382,
0.15054820477962494,
-0.2538873553276062,
-0.3573282063007355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13452v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13452v2
|
LocalTweets to LocalHealth: A Mental Health Surveillance Framework Based on Twitter Data
| 2024-02-21T01:11:28 | 2024-03-26T17:59:14 |
Vijeta Deshpande, Minhwa Lee, Zonghai Yao, Zihao Zhang, Jason Brian Gibbons, Hong Yu
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Prior research on Twitter (now X) data has provided positive evidence of its
utility in developing supplementary health surveillance systems. In this study,
we present a new framework to surveil public health, focusing on mental health
(MH) outcomes. We hypothesize that locally posted tweets are indicative of
local MH outcomes and collect tweets posted from 765 neighborhoods (census
block groups) in the USA. We pair these tweets from each neighborhood with the
corresponding MH outcome reported by the Center for Disease Control (CDC) to
create a benchmark dataset, LocalTweets. With LocalTweets, we present the first
population-level evaluation task for Twitter-based MH surveillance systems. We
then develop an efficient and effective method, LocalHealth, for predicting MH
outcomes based on LocalTweets. When used with GPT3.5, LocalHealth achieves the
highest F1-score and accuracy of 0.7429 and 79.78\%, respectively, a 59\%
improvement in F1-score over the GPT3.5 in zero-shot setting. We also utilize
LocalHealth to extrapolate CDC's estimates to proxy unreported neighborhoods,
achieving an F1-score of 0.7291. Our work suggests that Twitter data can be
effectively leveraged to simulate neighborhood-level MH outcomes.
|
[
-0.2264879196882248,
-0.6834418177604675,
0.9519789218902588,
0.028862638399004936,
0.06666544824838638,
0.1646602600812912,
0.04157876595854759,
-0.512291431427002,
0.9980953335762024,
0.33982956409454346,
-0.5402836799621582,
-0.9027490615844727,
-0.5505650639533997,
-0.11725161224603653,
-0.42530936002731323,
0.8098475933074951,
-0.1927495002746582,
-0.2232339084148407,
0.5792607069015503,
0.2806934416294098,
-0.16184501349925995,
-0.3174508213996887,
-0.3599952161312103,
-0.0068000731989741325,
0.846544623374939,
0.3962523639202118,
0.7947147488594055,
0.37442246079444885,
0.6572285294532776,
0.053341615945100784,
0.3844383656978607,
0.05069304630160332,
-0.7369901537895203,
-0.21640154719352722,
-0.04460003226995468,
0.07452975958585739,
-0.613175094127655,
0.05234355106949806,
0.4186779856681824,
0.4286006987094879,
-0.37177255749702454,
0.45972761511802673,
-0.276777058839798,
0.3042415678501129,
-0.8297852873802185,
-0.08077184855937958,
-0.23796166479587555,
0.3240123391151428,
-0.5669517517089844,
-0.35092052817344666,
0.2521243691444397,
-0.7732820510864258,
0.0521731823682785,
-0.15470439195632935,
0.16959740221500397,
-0.3249484598636627,
0.31451261043548584,
-0.1047246977686882,
-0.7392999529838562,
0.32330361008644104,
-0.5659133791923523,
0.3348168134689331,
-0.48742637038230896,
0.16825947165489197,
0.6244134306907654,
0.5918884873390198,
-0.13273929059505463,
-0.604189932346344,
-0.10893362015485764,
0.16314183175563812,
-0.18184420466423035,
0.21535524725914001,
-0.7143000960350037,
-0.24181321263313293,
0.12785278260707855,
0.389241099357605,
-0.46697747707366943,
-0.5798653960227966,
-0.4737113416194916,
-0.13489075005054474,
0.6029843688011169,
0.4735336899757385,
-0.12956249713897705,
-0.4962000250816345,
-0.19472017884254456,
0.3342447280883789,
-0.425081729888916,
0.19971780478954315,
-0.21711008250713348,
0.33414241671562195,
-0.3404184579849243,
0.6415727138519287,
-0.4885348081588745,
-0.14170682430267334,
0.08448962867259979,
-0.22083202004432678,
0.44737473130226135,
-0.19593441486358643,
-0.23969393968582153,
-0.004533384460955858,
0.6473375558853149,
0.7576642036437988,
-0.06993909925222397,
-0.24594242870807648,
-0.36027491092681885,
-0.04020711034536362,
0.46005943417549133,
-0.6804457306861877,
-0.14882320165634155,
0.2873593866825104,
-0.788004457950592,
-0.31109917163848877,
0.20713096857070923,
-0.46951812505722046,
-0.7779311537742615,
-0.2054591327905655,
0.4358632564544678,
-0.5792157649993896,
-0.6660053730010986,
0.0011116460664197803,
0.046711165457963943,
-0.21362167596817017,
0.39656683802604675,
-0.4772984981536865,
0.32655131816864014,
0.7074283957481384,
1.2013790607452393,
-0.1421194076538086,
-0.12624777853488922,
-0.41590413451194763,
0.36844781041145325,
-0.5197486877441406,
0.5526651740074158,
-0.21966896951198578,
-0.18990084528923035,
0.31724783778190613,
-0.06229768320918083,
-0.05939910560846329,
-0.4516933560371399,
0.1299096941947937,
-0.07881223410367966,
-0.3154674470424652,
-0.6704244017601013,
-0.38254547119140625,
0.33574026823043823,
0.01146264374256134,
-0.3628547191619873,
0.7333718538284302,
0.5220550894737244,
-1.2114005088806152,
0.37558022141456604,
-0.6337307095527649,
-0.761870801448822,
-0.05971985682845116,
0.2061069756746292,
0.07447994500398636,
0.45918646454811096,
0.5280303359031677,
0.874042809009552,
-0.01508735865354538,
0.2139141857624054,
-0.6801428198814392,
-0.6811051368713379,
-0.2981390655040741,
-0.23320730030536652,
0.8199383020401001,
0.2058577686548233,
-0.2318761795759201,
0.007028914522379637,
-0.28905364871025085,
-0.01897471584379673,
0.07662399858236313,
0.1651339828968048,
-0.09793348610401154,
-0.0556408055126667,
-0.0879758670926094,
-0.08623774349689484,
-0.05425652489066124,
-0.7683907747268677,
-0.29232749342918396,
0.1205122098326683,
0.2928328514099121,
0.5353748798370361,
0.6932181119918823,
0.22434841096401215,
-0.9854812026023865,
0.5823913812637329,
-0.3243207633495331,
0.6693398356437683,
0.2379266321659088,
-0.7100570201873779,
0.29355376958847046,
-0.5934739708900452,
-0.37884286046028137,
0.49603450298309326,
-0.6945305466651917,
0.30603450536727905,
-0.43643683195114136,
-0.74432772397995,
-0.36421796679496765,
-0.44056177139282227,
-0.20641356706619263,
0.2737814486026764,
0.17257347702980042,
0.14737969636917114,
-0.5146093964576721,
-0.769514262676239,
-0.14495255053043365,
0.01480055321007967,
-0.16746868193149567,
-0.15431705117225647,
0.3942355513572693,
-0.4086224436759949,
0.9421411752700806,
-0.5529137253761292,
-0.29870176315307617,
0.0030568845104426146,
0.23350124061107635,
0.20810143649578094,
0.20574113726615906,
0.6168599128723145,
-0.32572251558303833,
-0.5281781554222107,
-0.07538608461618423,
-0.6783598065376282,
-0.10648912191390991,
0.4165750741958618,
-0.48829078674316406,
-0.5061171650886536,
-0.021420028060674667,
-0.5148345232009888,
0.6927616596221924,
0.4080142378807068,
-0.013337475247681141,
0.546581506729126,
0.3135035037994385,
0.43877190351486206,
-1.1584722995758057,
-0.09642919898033142,
0.3733965754508972,
-0.5190635919570923,
-0.652502715587616,
-0.20702333748340607,
-0.26107051968574524,
-0.0782490223646164,
-0.26926353573799133,
0.31130942702293396,
0.11643500626087189,
-0.07004258781671524,
-0.05605001375079155,
-0.19959595799446106,
-0.36115318536758423,
0.038181155920028687,
-0.13913191854953766,
0.35255542397499084,
0.3983703553676605,
0.15983931720256805,
0.3330914378166199,
-0.3210866451263428,
-0.4619685709476471,
0.5196447968482971,
-0.19093522429466248,
-0.09980868548154831,
-0.12960292398929596,
0.4620321989059448,
-0.32169926166534424,
-0.5603308081626892,
0.22000932693481445,
-0.6394950747489929,
-0.21856845915317535,
0.3253662586212158,
-0.7435511350631714,
-0.563158392906189,
-0.7597852945327759,
0.01938871666789055,
0.3028007745742798,
-0.21293283998966217,
0.13857999444007874,
0.9690514802932739,
0.11022630333900452,
-0.006914886645972729,
-0.41685187816619873,
0.06010660156607628,
-0.23509052395820618,
-0.39141616225242615,
0.2036261260509491,
0.4633677899837494,
-0.5290945172309875,
0.21079084277153015,
-0.11377432197332382,
-0.34350359439849854,
-0.020232001319527626,
0.0802294984459877,
-0.27547353506088257,
-0.08406635373830795,
0.0726836770772934,
-0.2124604880809784,
0.14654052257537842,
0.30789893865585327,
-0.03607351705431938,
0.2733246684074402,
0.021425943821668625,
-0.3259357213973999,
-0.5341981649398804,
1.0697202682495117,
0.26333504915237427,
-0.12389523535966873,
0.6064202785491943,
0.7699128985404968,
-1.1510906219482422,
0.19629649817943573,
-0.4146310091018677,
-0.3449028730392456,
-0.36312347650527954,
0.10901917517185211,
-0.21098586916923523,
-0.8642987012863159,
0.4686328172683716,
0.3644067049026489,
-0.0455639585852623,
0.0678374171257019,
0.4532777965068817,
-0.581193208694458,
1.06380033493042,
0.5884831547737122,
-0.3418337404727936,
0.5540692806243896,
-0.1670888066291809,
0.37615272402763367,
-0.3128739595413208,
0.15032801032066345,
-0.0604376383125782,
-0.105906181037426,
-0.877159595489502,
-0.6083353757858276,
0.5042492151260376,
-0.0721801221370697,
-0.5426226258277893,
0.3878311812877655,
-0.2697084844112396,
0.04797622561454773,
0.6444975137710571,
0.6859439015388489,
0.06876741349697113,
0.0734938308596611,
0.12645679712295532,
-0.46184301376342773,
-0.39549028873443604,
-0.3594297468662262,
1.0018284320831299,
0.3902503252029419,
0.6841174960136414,
0.18511390686035156,
1.1662702560424805,
0.7291665077209473,
0.934010922908783,
-0.2095700204372406,
0.02027186006307602,
-0.04006493464112282,
-0.7280929684638977,
-0.11791403591632843,
-0.7302454113960266,
-0.8445003628730774,
-0.15898497402668,
-0.11446727067232132,
-1.4008347988128662,
0.09579527378082275,
-0.18249095976352692,
-0.40392789244651794,
0.5768968462944031,
-0.7893168330192566,
0.42574992775917053,
0.0667768269777298,
-0.20934095978736877,
-0.32767152786254883,
-0.44871410727500916,
0.6334980726242065,
-0.3497532904148102,
0.43631094694137573,
-0.5841778516769409,
0.3200318515300751,
0.5439845323562622,
-0.5118792057037354,
0.7366220355033875,
-0.2894342839717865,
0.04905238002538681,
0.31631916761398315,
-0.2052718698978424,
-0.008732132613658905,
0.39826831221580505,
-0.08257322013378143,
0.1573837697505951,
0.4448891580104828,
-0.6350551247596741,
-0.48438921570777893,
0.7516798377037048,
-0.5501057505607605,
-0.5873132944107056,
-0.2977149486541748,
-0.41230472922325134,
-0.39376676082611084,
0.3818030059337616,
0.07780175656080246,
0.6158599853515625,
0.035615041851997375,
0.011625268496572971,
0.018345288932323456,
0.3012198507785797,
0.044354550540447235,
0.2954465448856354,
-0.43747687339782715,
-0.8769042491912842,
0.6296623349189758,
0.32280707359313965,
-0.19640788435935974,
0.6623762249946594,
0.43132317066192627,
-0.17170950770378113,
-0.03392405807971954,
0.38827142119407654,
0.28858739137649536,
-0.47664153575897217,
-0.5848714709281921,
-0.2076435685157776,
-0.28987663984298706,
-0.7775571942329407,
-0.2780936658382416,
-0.3298976421356201,
0.21121415495872498,
0.23676829040050507,
-0.3883128762245178,
0.40766626596450806,
1.2162048816680908,
-0.5875598192214966,
0.2845636010169983,
-0.7196671962738037,
0.39357689023017883,
0.05377089977264404,
0.5785375237464905,
-0.019163979217410088,
0.15844692289829254,
-0.6295761466026306,
0.3314291834831238,
-0.3616860508918762,
-1.4875620603561401,
0.28183045983314514,
-0.4984244108200073,
0.3474351167678833,
0.7120887637138367,
0.5168250203132629,
0.8906384706497192,
-0.2683250308036804,
0.09362351894378662,
0.17924681305885315,
-0.6817594170570374,
0.7535560131072998,
-1.0433893203735352,
0.4028318226337433,
0.7069939374923706,
0.2587010860443115,
-0.7169690728187561,
-0.5204486846923828,
-0.563897430896759,
-0.3691522479057312,
0.40445050597190857,
0.5210545659065247,
0.010378649458289146,
-0.5392808318138123,
0.4331100583076477,
-0.19998858869075775,
0.26533064246177673,
-0.21219515800476074,
-0.24008946120738983,
-0.28659799695014954,
-0.15798252820968628,
-0.004408629611134529,
-0.06915410608053207,
-0.33360618352890015,
-0.5853413343429565,
0.262491375207901,
0.05465606600046158,
0.6046709418296814,
0.47625643014907837,
0.39652663469314575,
-0.25068625807762146,
-0.28976255655288696,
0.16127729415893555,
0.7195547223091125,
-1.0422519445419312,
0.36213362216949463,
-0.12191653996706009,
-0.5224302411079407,
0.0481368750333786,
0.07887393236160278,
-0.17797459661960602,
0.19982251524925232,
0.67110276222229,
0.24105201661586761,
0.22077183425426483,
-0.10030676424503326,
0.48556503653526306,
-0.06591370701789856,
-0.21620741486549377,
-0.12443068623542786,
-0.26082953810691833,
0.04524194076657295,
0.36597248911857605,
0.5506226420402527,
0.09669802337884903,
0.25045591592788696,
-0.5490230321884155,
0.5659651756286621,
0.2605045735836029,
-0.6059179902076721,
-0.6051727533340454,
0.5151149034500122,
-0.09836095571517944,
-0.22952218353748322,
0.2287643849849701,
-0.24034622311592102,
-0.3206997215747833,
0.542860746383667,
0.3900485336780548,
0.7788865566253662,
-0.28556862473487854,
0.4934079647064209,
0.4082569479942322,
0.5854002237319946,
0.0919986292719841,
0.4428219795227051,
0.0642271637916565,
-0.6437699794769287,
-0.2431701272726059,
-0.3057350218296051,
-0.3245799243450165,
0.20736616849899292,
-1.039003610610962,
0.2035667598247528,
-0.5773708820343018,
-0.8292074203491211,
-0.25558170676231384,
0.4614853262901306,
-0.4731813371181488,
0.5675063729286194,
0.4481790065765381,
1.2881830930709839,
-0.8489848375320435,
0.8989567160606384,
0.7478782534599304,
-0.06281694769859314,
-0.8449535369873047,
0.8741152882575989,
0.16145199537277222,
-0.5379942059516907,
-0.3278891146183014,
0.5240404605865479,
-0.2607850432395935,
-0.07086162269115448,
-0.34902140498161316,
-1.1417608261108398,
1.2914247512817383,
0.5980821847915649,
-0.016014395281672478,
0.35437697172164917,
-0.05029115080833435,
0.47689366340637207,
-0.6283916234970093,
0.19225487112998962,
0.690378725528717,
0.43484246730804443,
0.0068434858694672585,
-0.6847728490829468,
0.09767606854438782,
-0.19011057913303375,
0.015387887135148048,
0.150724396109581,
-0.4624476134777069,
0.386989563703537,
-0.4917517304420471,
-0.49549156427383423,
-0.21292544901371002,
0.5196327567100525,
0.16255319118499756,
0.6180551052093506,
0.25540855526924133,
0.5560728311538696,
0.8443747162818909,
-0.039709411561489105,
1.2549089193344116,
-0.09882510453462601,
0.5019589066505432,
1.0619477033615112,
-0.40390998125076294,
1.1169894933700562,
0.2197418212890625,
-0.4750349223613739,
-0.11680574715137482,
0.9498602151870728,
0.23249831795692444,
0.9309495091438293,
0.02559942938387394,
-0.30767562985420227,
0.0035528840962797403,
-0.36126306653022766,
-0.31540825963020325,
0.23018094897270203,
0.09769941121339798,
0.05337054282426834,
-0.4986606240272522,
0.008366182446479797,
0.31451180577278137,
-0.06811503320932388,
-0.22238703072071075,
0.3587018847465515,
0.022091355174779892,
-0.07397759705781937,
0.19453178346157074,
0.0029373071156442165,
0.2911706268787384,
-0.270448237657547,
0.16429567337036133,
-0.449747234582901,
0.11548497527837753,
-0.24195650219917297,
-0.765834629535675,
0.8854962587356567,
-0.05976736918091774,
-0.3550983667373657,
-0.12295004725456238,
0.6431373953819275,
-0.010604916140437126,
-0.7172808647155762,
0.7551817297935486,
0.694965124130249,
-0.008682888001203537,
-0.5513626337051392,
-0.44219231605529785,
-0.2257293313741684,
-0.09999102354049683,
-0.08260831981897354,
0.1603284776210785,
0.42416176199913025,
-0.32293611764907837,
0.4569125771522522,
0.5592045783996582,
0.4890787899494171,
-0.13347367942333221,
0.23164482414722443,
0.6756453514099121,
-0.5089807510375977,
-0.1722378134727478,
-0.7140733599662781,
0.02244606800377369,
-0.18881449103355408,
-0.28936898708343506,
0.696968138217926,
0.4593319296836853,
0.5120477080345154,
0.4336456060409546,
0.8739054799079895,
-0.21417465806007385,
1.066188097000122,
0.09664403647184372,
0.7905113697052002,
-0.5485183596611023,
-0.046854808926582336,
-0.11678625643253326,
-0.5231879353523254,
-0.41701287031173706,
0.5842607021331787,
-0.637653648853302,
-0.03446158394217491,
0.7432677745819092,
0.5807436108589172,
0.007957030087709427,
0.022698596119880676,
0.37176933884620667,
-0.032655250281095505,
0.28212177753448486,
0.3156946301460266,
0.5189582705497742,
-0.18984660506248474,
-0.04454941675066948,
-0.7890321612358093,
-0.3217940032482147,
-0.0341033898293972,
-0.4743802845478058,
-0.8038637042045593,
-0.18154749274253845,
-0.05423932895064354,
-0.26991745829582214,
0.3273799419403076,
0.9489774107933044,
0.9035000205039978,
-0.8563047051429749,
-0.004521937109529972,
0.18567386269569397,
0.242589071393013,
-0.43978771567344666,
-0.33599674701690674,
0.40273624658584595,
0.22617265582084656,
-0.07026778906583786,
0.06612247228622437,
0.3428131937980652,
-0.16205498576164246,
-0.0174713134765625,
0.20969341695308685,
-0.19312673807144165,
-0.1272546350955963,
0.4065950810909271,
-0.14527592062950134,
-0.5769789218902588,
-0.3057863414287567,
0.14801402390003204,
-0.5913892984390259,
0.10341701656579971,
0.7612981796264648,
-0.6905058026313782,
-0.0052809747867286205,
0.2441452145576477,
0.30325379967689514,
0.306487500667572,
0.14926303923130035,
0.7554627060890198,
-0.5988060235977173,
-0.42760542035102844,
0.13745814561843872,
0.4211684465408325,
0.3697890639305115,
-0.4776037931442261,
0.45617690682411194,
0.26019957661628723,
-0.18196505308151245,
-0.5607696175575256,
-0.031332775950431824,
-0.41120725870132446,
0.18817515671253204,
0.8702858090400696,
-0.17113392055034637,
-0.2258988469839096,
-0.04955815523862839,
0.02173692174255848,
0.30152779817581177,
-0.8250141143798828,
1.0353659391403198,
0.33387959003448486,
-0.10417655110359192,
-0.3797120749950409,
-1.1099013090133667,
0.22081683576107025,
-0.23792560398578644,
-0.888113796710968,
-0.06765143573284149,
0.11819270998239517,
0.26917341351509094,
-0.14290210604667664,
1.2589918375015259,
0.1742965131998062,
0.5232774615287781,
-0.09667664766311646,
-0.19406044483184814,
0.3470945358276367,
0.08198968321084976,
-0.08721745759248734,
0.06957250088453293,
-0.6119847893714905,
-0.2596404254436493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13449v1
|
CAMELoT: Towards Large Language Models with Training-Free Consolidated Associative Memory
| 2024-02-21T01:00:17 | 2024-02-21T01:00:17 |
Zexue He, Leonid Karlinsky, Donghyun Kim, Julian McAuley, Dmitry Krotov, Rogerio Feris
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) struggle to handle long input sequences due to
high memory and runtime costs. Memory-augmented models have emerged as a
promising solution to this problem, but current methods are hindered by limited
memory capacity and require costly re-training to integrate with a new LLM. In
this work, we introduce an associative memory module which can be coupled to
any pre-trained (frozen) attention-based LLM without re-training, enabling it
to handle arbitrarily long input sequences. Unlike previous methods, our
associative memory module consolidates representations of individual tokens
into a non-parametric distribution model, dynamically managed by properly
balancing the novelty and recency of the incoming data. By retrieving
information from this consolidated associative memory, the base LLM can achieve
significant (up to 29.7% on Arxiv) perplexity reduction in long-context
modeling compared to other baselines evaluated on standard benchmarks. This
architecture, which we call CAMELoT (Consolidated Associative Memory Enhanced
Long Transformer), demonstrates superior performance even with a tiny context
window of 128 tokens, and also enables improved in-context learning with a much
larger set of demonstrations.
|
[
-0.37674805521965027,
-0.610946774482727,
0.08604578673839569,
-0.008367190137505531,
-0.5884551405906677,
0.03233860805630684,
-0.5767686367034912,
-0.34638234972953796,
0.3646256923675537,
0.6773465275764465,
-0.22163386642932892,
-0.42156046628952026,
-0.48769262433052063,
-0.12487223744392395,
-0.7280638217926025,
0.9686715006828308,
-0.16504323482513428,
-0.23768195509910583,
-0.22990867495536804,
-0.4916251599788666,
-0.4747479259967804,
-0.44563886523246765,
-0.4462626576423645,
-0.39397066831588745,
0.5724267959594727,
0.2889854311943054,
0.7789749503135681,
0.5067307353019714,
0.31644681096076965,
0.3073413670063019,
0.05415944382548332,
0.29054152965545654,
-0.4829675853252411,
0.15072542428970337,
-0.01554183755069971,
-0.2078806459903717,
-0.42965924739837646,
-0.27779367566108704,
0.784193217754364,
0.7811961770057678,
-0.3039010465145111,
0.05970754474401474,
-0.09351179748773575,
0.4157944321632385,
-0.7628768086433411,
0.17649251222610474,
-0.5879659652709961,
-0.07590938359498978,
0.006174162495881319,
-0.12120440602302551,
-0.5886550545692444,
-0.002976977964863181,
0.2494693100452423,
-0.5648028254508972,
0.144027978181839,
0.25195375084877014,
0.4301961064338684,
0.26578569412231445,
-0.39815783500671387,
-0.2553118169307709,
-0.6286195516586304,
0.8100107908248901,
-0.32041382789611816,
0.3396206200122833,
0.16160830855369568,
0.19870910048484802,
-0.4408486485481262,
-0.5710456371307373,
-0.6876481175422668,
-0.220014289021492,
0.10532481223344803,
-0.16333657503128052,
-0.38387006521224976,
0.2512238323688507,
-0.1310722976922989,
0.3732989430427551,
-0.5452098846435547,
-0.06221100315451622,
-0.07544269412755966,
-0.11894270777702332,
0.322414368391037,
-0.03238442912697792,
0.15722495317459106,
0.16159622371196747,
-0.516914427280426,
-0.15473893284797668,
-0.54526686668396,
-0.17441579699516296,
0.06523299217224121,
0.2334081083536148,
-0.12189584225416183,
0.5255270004272461,
-0.11308588832616806,
0.6103538274765015,
-0.008083472028374672,
0.10825981944799423,
0.17415288090705872,
0.23522762954235077,
-0.27851423621177673,
0.19101504981517792,
0.7645561099052429,
-0.10775114595890045,
0.11825699359178543,
-0.47466328740119934,
-0.38447633385658264,
-0.06260130554437637,
0.06548743695020676,
-0.7908480763435364,
-0.4162907004356384,
0.2885497212409973,
-0.10427898913621902,
0.0537886917591095,
-0.3228217661380768,
-0.574766993522644,
-0.17653629183769226,
-0.021528305485844612,
0.3707006275653839,
-0.5226941704750061,
0.0034138786140829325,
0.25769007205963135,
0.07947374135255814,
0.27136027812957764,
0.41959720849990845,
-0.9124125838279724,
0.45867517590522766,
0.6698172092437744,
0.8016660213470459,
-0.4995783269405365,
-0.26872384548187256,
-0.782216489315033,
0.614132285118103,
-0.30144521594047546,
0.9712502956390381,
-0.6333461999893188,
-0.3300134241580963,
0.13746395707130432,
-0.057515885680913925,
0.20754796266555786,
-0.6383599638938904,
0.3332027494907379,
-0.8759996294975281,
0.006591795012354851,
0.25210040807724,
-0.5502408146858215,
-0.03578781336545944,
0.3581092655658722,
-0.8527010083198547,
0.9349134564399719,
0.0069799879565835,
-0.6954079270362854,
0.062484342604875565,
-0.40687480568885803,
-0.6506298780441284,
0.2559281289577484,
-0.06854472309350967,
-0.39380156993865967,
0.09021694958209991,
0.2362125664949417,
0.33908286690711975,
-0.5471451878547668,
0.38912737369537354,
-0.28107950091362,
-0.5225045680999756,
0.34069469571113586,
-0.5580486059188843,
0.5723293423652649,
-0.04263170063495636,
-0.07154491543769836,
0.376811683177948,
-0.8507756590843201,
-0.2719978094100952,
0.06361714005470276,
-0.4695512056350708,
-0.35541725158691406,
-0.2469947189092636,
0.07518697530031204,
0.08662101626396179,
0.4546540677547455,
-0.3498800992965698,
0.28106585144996643,
-0.3620692491531372,
0.48791375756263733,
0.6878446340560913,
-0.28869757056236267,
0.5724517703056335,
-0.23415686190128326,
0.3740534782409668,
0.23277504742145538,
-0.09749467670917511,
-0.27778398990631104,
-0.21533724665641785,
-1.0882235765457153,
-0.539228618144989,
0.266399621963501,
0.31690216064453125,
-0.9116209149360657,
0.5328430533409119,
-0.518069863319397,
-0.20110057294368744,
-0.3590738773345947,
0.253515362739563,
0.2273903489112854,
0.2835560142993927,
0.5452663898468018,
-0.597150981426239,
-0.25651121139526367,
-0.6898133158683777,
0.13826186954975128,
-0.1775096356868744,
-0.1906581073999405,
0.21536986529827118,
0.34641820192337036,
-0.2951696217060089,
0.8611316084861755,
-0.40257200598716736,
-0.14002840220928192,
-0.2852391302585602,
0.21006456017494202,
0.01048539113253355,
0.3955882489681244,
0.035528335720300674,
-0.43625104427337646,
-0.01926024630665779,
-0.003885368350893259,
-0.33068105578422546,
0.1853078007698059,
0.05755525454878807,
-0.2354455441236496,
0.3115503191947937,
0.2821255028247833,
-1.2483457326889038,
0.2935310900211334,
0.5449362993240356,
-0.06418513506650925,
0.4339293837547302,
-0.4788154065608978,
-0.11143256723880768,
-0.9560355544090271,
0.09635770320892334,
-0.3555782437324524,
-0.23034077882766724,
-0.49605777859687805,
-0.1254701167345047,
0.18370772898197174,
-0.22321775555610657,
-0.5363925695419312,
0.9230967164039612,
-0.5583831667900085,
-0.07580165565013885,
-0.4951789975166321,
0.25283801555633545,
-0.06341614574193954,
0.6030811071395874,
0.08187843859195709,
0.7364992499351501,
0.5916704535484314,
-0.5453779101371765,
0.676475465297699,
0.33136820793151855,
-0.3991062641143799,
0.1749517172574997,
-0.510765016078949,
0.1338237226009369,
-0.16143502295017242,
0.5991103649139404,
-1.228455662727356,
-0.29111459851264954,
0.03346744552254677,
-0.24442708492279053,
0.3885487914085388,
0.19715763628482819,
-0.6239684224128723,
-0.22184240818023682,
-0.23630744218826294,
0.8485096096992493,
0.7068737149238586,
-0.8152045011520386,
0.6986036896705627,
0.17839062213897705,
0.07712367177009583,
-0.766279399394989,
-0.6627243757247925,
0.09174053370952606,
-0.27500197291374207,
-0.5282530188560486,
0.31928977370262146,
0.09187224507331848,
0.1374640017747879,
0.010278113186359406,
0.1989358365535736,
-0.0436604768037796,
-0.25691381096839905,
-0.03928081691265106,
0.19122996926307678,
-0.1677553504705429,
0.7359839081764221,
-0.08809266239404678,
-0.16282837092876434,
-0.22659273445606232,
-0.2778754234313965,
0.865851104259491,
0.0992586687207222,
-0.21359016001224518,
-0.3959920406341553,
0.4220384955406189,
0.5754502415657043,
-0.4837460517883301,
0.9622792601585388,
0.39617669582366943,
-0.27459290623664856,
-0.32974427938461304,
-0.5774636268615723,
-0.15187518298625946,
-0.46302953362464905,
0.40334513783454895,
-0.11029865592718124,
-0.9888715744018555,
0.6420382261276245,
-0.16329076886177063,
-0.017262648791074753,
0.12541775405406952,
0.6559458374977112,
0.22644485533237457,
0.6127500534057617,
0.47453469038009644,
-0.4211823046207428,
0.6127381324768066,
-0.08689798414707184,
0.2188795655965805,
-0.8613353371620178,
-0.07969626784324646,
-0.012815487571060658,
-0.2802162766456604,
-0.3937986195087433,
-0.8047308325767517,
-0.02131534367799759,
-0.015825923532247543,
-0.4028552770614624,
0.13916227221488953,
-0.2994671165943146,
0.42166760563850403,
0.4027303159236908,
-0.05095328390598297,
0.3663693070411682,
-0.07492522895336151,
0.045470017939805984,
0.6887719631195068,
-0.6977660655975342,
-0.3237455189228058,
1.0869795083999634,
0.13722841441631317,
0.9705009460449219,
0.10133441537618637,
0.668444812297821,
-0.011983168311417103,
0.4328417479991913,
-0.8332210779190063,
0.7365695834159851,
-0.11624247580766678,
-0.3315068185329437,
-0.4163512587547302,
-0.2574392855167389,
-1.241873860359192,
0.23968589305877686,
-0.06263242661952972,
-0.5626603960990906,
-0.0655737966299057,
0.2556474804878235,
-0.40603551268577576,
0.23101182281970978,
-0.5116786360740662,
0.7325685620307922,
-0.07983510196208954,
-0.5017983913421631,
-0.33212119340896606,
-0.6676214933395386,
0.5192670226097107,
0.010671712458133698,
0.033444758504629135,
-0.10353740304708481,
-0.32620278000831604,
0.6145826578140259,
-0.4285292625427246,
0.7664833068847656,
0.14134764671325684,
-0.004757660906761885,
0.5511082410812378,
-0.14282017946243286,
0.6853516101837158,
-0.051751814782619476,
0.0905909612774849,
0.12590880692005157,
-0.37269213795661926,
-0.6271775960922241,
-0.5705572962760925,
0.8518064022064209,
-0.9201527237892151,
-0.6127920150756836,
-0.3212703466415405,
-0.8951395153999329,
-0.15748226642608643,
0.07080872356891632,
-0.08694460242986679,
0.47760793566703796,
-0.0754929631948471,
0.351516991853714,
0.7884110808372498,
-0.31584858894348145,
0.5126513838768005,
0.268779456615448,
-0.08873908221721649,
-0.5432538390159607,
0.6968656778335571,
-0.0698157474398613,
0.26675087213516235,
0.5894772410392761,
0.044660840183496475,
-0.1807255744934082,
-0.5032044649124146,
-0.2538899779319763,
0.27330708503723145,
-0.7061668634414673,
-0.3935258090496063,
-0.7180290222167969,
-0.04502939060330391,
-0.32602137327194214,
-0.09049848467111588,
-0.49456486105918884,
-0.4092060327529907,
-0.3625226318836212,
0.06627912074327469,
0.5854921936988831,
0.1938703954219818,
0.25334295630455017,
0.6330880522727966,
-0.6298348903656006,
0.3303285539150238,
0.48388198018074036,
0.2913126051425934,
0.4410594403743744,
-0.494306743144989,
-0.3753189742565155,
-0.33376502990722656,
-0.2847762405872345,
-0.45386582612991333,
0.5515207052230835,
0.08654472231864929,
0.250883013010025,
0.36759012937545776,
0.17862316966056824,
0.9314327836036682,
-0.7810226082801819,
0.6040424704551697,
0.3326437175273895,
-0.8502421975135803,
0.12004517018795013,
-0.32490724325180054,
0.43379002809524536,
0.2510237395763397,
0.06067734211683273,
-0.5064628720283508,
-0.3316591680049896,
-0.4717576503753662,
-0.980961799621582,
0.4091450572013855,
-0.0014038305962458253,
0.3743787407875061,
-0.4802294671535492,
0.35424119234085083,
0.07566051185131073,
0.31376680731773376,
-0.5452091693878174,
-0.12970592081546783,
-0.02291165292263031,
-0.33738869428634644,
-0.329257071018219,
-0.19879885017871857,
-0.19176511466503143,
-0.22643472254276276,
0.5161111950874329,
-0.02876191772520542,
0.4471210837364197,
-0.15851998329162598,
-0.2089463621377945,
0.0004918989725410938,
0.30848973989486694,
0.4596864879131317,
0.3181666135787964,
-0.04579199105501175,
0.43876582384109497,
0.29330626130104065,
-0.3683922588825226,
0.21624141931533813,
0.2307601124048233,
0.3030509650707245,
-0.048406802117824554,
0.39234650135040283,
0.7622594237327576,
0.5414414405822754,
-1.0411853790283203,
0.6191535592079163,
-0.019865810871124268,
0.1783493161201477,
-0.4512658417224884,
-0.011287140659987926,
0.24323301017284393,
0.3098888397216797,
0.3416711688041687,
-0.36740854382514954,
0.12081914395093918,
-0.5681008100509644,
0.40830570459365845,
0.6297017931938171,
-0.2284826636314392,
-0.25518742203712463,
0.4497758150100708,
0.2538553476333618,
-0.1914060115814209,
0.782909631729126,
-0.08034252375364304,
-0.16485819220542908,
0.35601767897605896,
0.7080016732215881,
0.8109245300292969,
-0.4154188334941864,
-0.06628161668777466,
-0.013849809765815735,
-0.09934110939502716,
-0.18562491238117218,
-0.12191254645586014,
-0.36362963914871216,
-0.7437852025032043,
-0.5045366287231445,
-0.641042172908783,
-0.4024822413921356,
0.20644895732402802,
-0.4382113814353943,
0.4934368133544922,
-0.3987022936344147,
0.1856798231601715,
-0.5242524147033691,
-0.018876923248171806,
-0.48681095242500305,
0.12271098792552948,
0.08262301236391068,
0.7943025231361389,
-0.5953936576843262,
1.2951732873916626,
0.39258044958114624,
-0.09797962009906769,
-0.5437215566635132,
-0.13295674324035645,
-0.5873345732688904,
-1.0178965330123901,
0.43148499727249146,
0.3520730137825012,
-0.2347680777311325,
-0.04184427112340927,
-0.4137837886810303,
-0.9010455012321472,
1.1904281377792358,
0.5781146883964539,
-0.4496237635612488,
-0.009568245150148869,
0.07284260541200638,
0.5112681984901428,
-0.4740983247756958,
0.126412495970726,
0.5482021570205688,
-0.0494365431368351,
0.6174257397651672,
-0.5596023797988892,
-0.005258860532194376,
-0.033937230706214905,
0.0006786123849451542,
0.5881384015083313,
-0.9135987758636475,
0.9372021555900574,
-0.07783844321966171,
-0.1839444786310196,
0.3761226534843445,
1.032983422279358,
0.4191742539405823,
0.07433205097913742,
0.22212210297584534,
0.5808326601982117,
0.7720662355422974,
0.26197129487991333,
0.9610180258750916,
-0.458611398935318,
0.2383721023797989,
1.2752827405929565,
-0.33778584003448486,
1.241234302520752,
0.6478216648101807,
0.16372519731521606,
0.6310268640518188,
0.429629385471344,
0.373246431350708,
0.6869293451309204,
0.28184157609939575,
-0.6738211512565613,
-0.3860008120536804,
-0.11449550837278366,
-0.2068420797586441,
0.40543097257614136,
0.2776242792606354,
-0.20956166088581085,
-0.1975717693567276,
0.176017627120018,
-0.26748427748680115,
-0.26694753766059875,
-0.3721914291381836,
0.6444264054298401,
0.09217244386672974,
-0.5267468094825745,
0.7564267516136169,
-0.13455960154533386,
0.6971168518066406,
-0.5003527998924255,
0.014640587382018566,
-0.26104336977005005,
0.32676202058792114,
0.1207265630364418,
-0.43054401874542236,
0.015787901356816292,
-0.12849341332912445,
-0.022523533552885056,
0.08265577256679535,
0.5418714284896851,
-0.8636605739593506,
-0.4210071861743927,
0.23826192319393158,
0.16540053486824036,
0.20938968658447266,
0.10749104619026184,
-0.2568757236003876,
0.14814728498458862,
-0.46705275774002075,
-0.38247594237327576,
0.3535667955875397,
0.643051266670227,
-0.1667570173740387,
0.8696584701538086,
0.41612422466278076,
-0.28686174750328064,
0.18114562332630157,
-0.09579459577798843,
1.0822596549987793,
-0.7619629502296448,
-0.523819088935852,
-0.7817230224609375,
0.383928507566452,
0.13384707272052765,
-0.12135051935911179,
0.48049861192703247,
0.5235338807106018,
0.6264777183532715,
-0.03360370919108391,
0.5818633437156677,
0.4751379191875458,
0.23004554212093353,
-0.37802138924598694,
0.4023314416408539,
-0.3783673644065857,
0.14076223969459534,
0.14812234044075012,
-0.8318177461624146,
-0.521933376789093,
0.4780365824699402,
-0.45064041018486023,
-0.029050586745142937,
0.5702661275863647,
0.3910841643810272,
-0.1655917912721634,
-0.03983611613512039,
0.447288453578949,
0.054667357355356216,
0.35273557901382446,
1.0156604051589966,
0.7929917573928833,
-0.2985336184501648,
0.7462316751480103,
0.08700375258922577,
-0.23249423503875732,
-0.38755783438682556,
-0.6677424311637878,
-1.1058698892593384,
-0.2691618502140045,
-0.2050371766090393,
-0.0015597265446558595,
-0.018445925787091255,
0.9643579125404358,
0.5306251049041748,
-0.71318519115448,
-0.4042713940143585,
-0.1872476488351822,
0.06718936562538147,
0.09201660752296448,
-0.10959573090076447,
0.5564350485801697,
-0.44103875756263733,
-0.6560394763946533,
0.029669100418686867,
0.4444916546344757,
0.1631317436695099,
-0.3835838735103607,
-0.12255585193634033,
-0.11678092181682587,
0.3303341865539551,
0.7347703576087952,
0.26818907260894775,
-0.6880370378494263,
-0.5050671100616455,
-0.26978081464767456,
0.002686133375391364,
0.3414052128791809,
0.6541269421577454,
-1.0236457586288452,
0.4478761851787567,
0.18683795630931854,
0.8366003632545471,
0.6125251650810242,
-0.06653432548046112,
0.4602140188217163,
-0.634809672832489,
0.7230643033981323,
0.20793651044368744,
0.3214491307735443,
0.36819833517074585,
-0.19874632358551025,
-0.017506398260593414,
-0.14885984361171722,
-0.6055068373680115,
-0.7363301515579224,
0.24039898812770844,
-1.113034963607788,
-0.20700626075267792,
1.062124252319336,
-0.15895172953605652,
-0.5305824875831604,
-0.0009347678860649467,
-0.014129499904811382,
0.4489287734031677,
-0.5645880699157715,
0.8268120288848877,
0.7961029410362244,
-0.28438428044319153,
-0.28074926137924194,
-0.2663188874721527,
0.24556203186511993,
0.43945741653442383,
-0.708408772945404,
0.3744651675224304,
0.46471744775772095,
0.08711722493171692,
0.13406062126159668,
0.4143367111682892,
0.07509098947048187,
0.23678413033485413,
-0.10536905378103256,
0.29153352975845337,
0.15775418281555176,
-0.4333345592021942,
-0.412820041179657,
0.3419584035873413,
0.15328796207904816,
-0.3336871564388275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14860v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14860v4
|
Ranking Large Language Models without Ground Truth
| 2024-02-21T00:49:43 | 2024-06-10T16:25:30 |
Amit Dhurandhar, Rahul Nair, Moninder Singh, Elizabeth Daly, Karthikeyan Natesan Ramamurthy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Evaluation and ranking of large language models (LLMs) has become an
important problem with the proliferation of these models and their impact.
Evaluation methods either require human responses which are expensive to
acquire or use pairs of LLMs to evaluate each other which can be unreliable. In
this paper, we provide a novel perspective where, given a dataset of prompts
(viz. questions, instructions, etc.) and a set of LLMs, we rank them without
access to any ground truth or reference responses. Inspired by real life where
both an expert and a knowledgeable person can identify a novice our main idea
is to consider triplets of models, where each one of them evaluates the other
two, correctly identifying the worst model in the triplet with high
probability. We also analyze our idea and provide sufficient conditions for it
to succeed. Applying this idea repeatedly, we propose two methods to rank LLMs.
In experiments on different generative tasks (summarization, multiple-choice,
and dialog), our methods reliably recover close to true rankings without
reference data. This points to a viable low-resource mechanism for practical
use.
|
[
-0.3345276117324829,
-0.5690217018127441,
0.9733171463012695,
0.1763310730457306,
-0.19859792292118073,
0.23698292672634125,
-0.3846358060836792,
-0.17539463937282562,
-0.0728457048535347,
0.59560626745224,
-0.29896682500839233,
-0.5192910432815552,
-0.6638338565826416,
0.022013701498508453,
-0.31474432349205017,
0.7822005748748779,
0.3420850932598114,
0.007081705145537853,
-0.61980801820755,
-0.23768359422683716,
-0.43373796343803406,
-0.5640807151794434,
-0.5672466158866882,
-0.4301687479019165,
0.5583376288414001,
0.6232212781906128,
0.7775754332542419,
0.5644698143005371,
0.43937987089157104,
0.3576008975505829,
-0.15006449818611145,
0.22719420492649078,
-0.7289035320281982,
0.21955442428588867,
-0.100399449467659,
-0.576257586479187,
-0.2608320713043213,
0.3711147904396057,
0.7006582617759705,
0.9349156618118286,
0.05786336213350296,
0.30383291840553284,
0.19858208298683167,
0.8249521851539612,
-0.5415621399879456,
0.10255248844623566,
-0.7145988345146179,
-0.18719518184661865,
-0.15768864750862122,
-0.4595641791820526,
-0.5211348533630371,
-0.7144713401794434,
0.06060324236750603,
-0.1905546486377716,
0.2704729437828064,
0.17966212332248688,
0.5533140301704407,
0.15366895496845245,
-0.3475329279899597,
-0.12886367738246918,
-0.6825717687606812,
0.7908167839050293,
-0.5342024564743042,
0.16836604475975037,
0.2874268591403961,
0.36788704991340637,
-0.14980219304561615,
-0.28246235847473145,
-0.521839439868927,
-0.7353764772415161,
0.0498974472284317,
0.023802990093827248,
-0.07628525793552399,
0.019445985555648804,
0.31259021162986755,
0.46478214859962463,
-0.5195856094360352,
0.1459794044494629,
-0.20402054488658905,
0.007858719676733017,
0.3822288513183594,
0.24582232534885406,
0.2541760504245758,
-0.243477925658226,
-0.25813788175582886,
0.1117413192987442,
-0.9992850422859192,
-0.0804109126329422,
0.522124707698822,
0.42585358023643494,
-0.03225230798125267,
0.6975482106208801,
-0.13499684631824493,
0.8283419013023376,
0.10209037363529205,
-0.3309982419013977,
0.3213379383087158,
-0.16587409377098083,
0.03388233855366707,
-0.3413750231266022,
0.8613200187683105,
0.23531422019004822,
0.2004970908164978,
-0.48636701703071594,
-0.37271347641944885,
-0.12657484412193298,
0.18365436792373657,
-0.630131185054779,
-0.10419762134552002,
0.15256986021995544,
-0.2987094819545746,
-0.4891590476036072,
-0.0684543326497078,
-0.7814359068870544,
-0.6459988355636597,
-0.2137945145368576,
0.5538318157196045,
-0.031546495854854584,
-0.24935057759284973,
-0.2232009321451187,
0.07039862126111984,
0.07866182178258896,
0.40021130442619324,
-0.7140505909919739,
0.2781684398651123,
0.7336370348930359,
0.9123824834823608,
-0.2022029161453247,
-0.22078247368335724,
-0.48970285058021545,
-0.1003926619887352,
-0.6127692461013794,
0.8640949726104736,
-0.4929914176464081,
-0.4482653737068176,
-0.2360791712999344,
-0.21013018488883972,
0.1939377784729004,
-0.7624019980430603,
0.6617675423622131,
-0.6015896201133728,
0.24050134420394897,
-0.4997842013835907,
-0.5190240144729614,
-0.04730765148997307,
0.20187799632549286,
-0.6734460592269897,
0.8933045864105225,
-0.17994631826877594,
-0.8147668838500977,
0.01862626150250435,
-0.6687778234481812,
-0.2675175964832306,
0.2776816189289093,
-0.27786263823509216,
0.06821930408477783,
0.1773746758699417,
0.12809470295906067,
0.5330788493156433,
-0.5576034784317017,
0.34842097759246826,
-0.41519322991371155,
-0.42472490668296814,
0.16757622361183167,
-0.6090984344482422,
0.8192009925842285,
-0.04106704145669937,
-0.23938138782978058,
0.015648333355784416,
-0.702149510383606,
0.1883314698934555,
0.38880404829978943,
-0.530631422996521,
-0.3743947446346283,
-0.00041233139927498996,
-0.24692517518997192,
0.12961401045322418,
0.16939163208007812,
-0.3617015480995178,
0.27104878425598145,
-0.4636932909488678,
0.31002357602119446,
0.8392348885536194,
0.03942083939909935,
0.33262985944747925,
-0.47430336475372314,
0.48187872767448425,
-0.2913459539413452,
-0.2165243923664093,
0.02971092239022255,
-0.5559092164039612,
-1.1244269609451294,
0.044549308717250824,
0.2656293213367462,
0.4789065420627594,
-0.7685550451278687,
0.4674631357192993,
-0.6492368578910828,
-0.6544350385665894,
-0.6332759857177734,
0.25511765480041504,
0.46528083086013794,
0.48835763335227966,
0.15662389993667603,
0.23798398673534393,
-0.3536848723888397,
-1.080864667892456,
-0.29305127263069153,
-0.3621096909046173,
-0.29139041900634766,
0.40130743384361267,
0.3515721559524536,
0.14799024164676666,
0.9083826541900635,
-0.5169491767883301,
0.0812673270702362,
-0.39825958013534546,
0.2665121257305145,
0.4056984782218933,
0.26699352264404297,
0.30688247084617615,
-0.6578757166862488,
-0.052414197474718094,
-0.300112247467041,
-0.9147248864173889,
-0.1373218297958374,
0.266217440366745,
0.10526818782091141,
0.09459930658340454,
0.36018848419189453,
-0.555520236492157,
-0.006083636544644833,
0.4820103943347931,
0.06284414231777191,
0.49651169776916504,
-0.10186997056007385,
0.15839023888111115,
-0.8097745776176453,
0.3571341037750244,
-0.11140590161085129,
-0.3115346431732178,
-0.41339433193206787,
0.23798853158950806,
-0.07908006757497787,
-0.24429863691329956,
-0.3126034140586853,
0.8178561329841614,
-0.465243935585022,
-0.10766099393367767,
-0.1833857297897339,
0.38049015402793884,
-0.02844357304275036,
0.48106005787849426,
-0.009080089628696442,
0.8715147376060486,
0.29288363456726074,
-0.5202576518058777,
0.5629405975341797,
0.11990819871425629,
-0.6585091948509216,
0.4258592128753662,
-0.6470664143562317,
0.5405965447425842,
-0.3239603340625763,
0.18450313806533813,
-1.0516247749328613,
0.0012736174976453185,
0.21101392805576324,
-0.4745781123638153,
0.030631057918071747,
-0.416422039270401,
-0.6524927020072937,
-0.32599806785583496,
-0.35855239629745483,
0.327180415391922,
0.4523952007293701,
-0.577390730381012,
0.20148742198944092,
0.5067368745803833,
-0.36492919921875,
-0.6094505786895752,
-0.30113276839256287,
0.32165297865867615,
-0.24638688564300537,
-0.4466384947299957,
-0.04327531158924103,
-0.33005014061927795,
-0.4722515344619751,
-0.033160049468278885,
-0.1735682487487793,
0.10457082092761993,
0.23511666059494019,
0.36796653270721436,
0.25443583726882935,
-0.20519369840621948,
0.3628343641757965,
-0.4340622127056122,
-0.3561984598636627,
-0.03206151723861694,
-0.11252617835998535,
0.3171968162059784,
-0.44989800453186035,
-0.35774749517440796,
-0.04382048919796944,
0.26403042674064636,
0.8290489315986633,
-0.04366413503885269,
0.5099454522132874,
0.19892163574695587,
-0.39196380972862244,
-0.07975153625011444,
-0.9256861209869385,
0.15402504801750183,
-0.46671608090400696,
0.24587798118591309,
-0.36456945538520813,
-0.765675961971283,
0.23325400054454803,
0.0057751513086259365,
0.12757302820682526,
0.3709378242492676,
0.7064281702041626,
-0.09690145403146744,
1.0167495012283325,
0.5741480588912964,
-0.13150076568126678,
0.07400216162204742,
-0.13506990671157837,
0.24294422566890717,
-0.7016756534576416,
-0.28782951831817627,
-0.6763780117034912,
-0.1287754476070404,
-0.3944230377674103,
-0.3723743259906769,
0.7089181542396545,
0.08149022608995438,
-0.13082453608512878,
0.062091611325740814,
-0.20175133645534515,
0.9099351167678833,
0.545485258102417,
0.12466529756784439,
0.5917465090751648,
-0.15099646151065826,
-0.3617909252643585,
0.09932271391153336,
-0.7026867866516113,
-0.9312440752983093,
1.2232203483581543,
0.22726930677890778,
0.6209783554077148,
0.26654523611068726,
0.5518140196800232,
0.3526156544685364,
0.43363335728645325,
-1.0605512857437134,
0.7698697447776794,
0.04116526246070862,
-0.6356152892112732,
-0.44641053676605225,
-0.7387763261795044,
-0.8357040286064148,
0.4827427864074707,
-0.08172134310007095,
-0.6447482109069824,
-0.0853857472538948,
-0.037172429263591766,
-0.603191077709198,
0.18885110318660736,
-0.5979259014129639,
0.6826330423355103,
-0.3184908628463745,
-0.4154042601585388,
-0.0747261494398117,
-0.5612318515777588,
0.7447006106376648,
-0.02723660133779049,
0.3885013163089752,
-0.298926442861557,
0.006048646289855242,
0.9804456233978271,
-0.4135879576206207,
0.6755406856536865,
-0.12988236546516418,
-0.0990477204322815,
0.08928387612104416,
0.15939661860466003,
0.3661445379257202,
0.2171003520488739,
-0.1695263534784317,
0.08527965843677521,
-0.11788961291313171,
-0.37940481305122375,
-0.791862428188324,
1.0624167919158936,
-0.8357662558555603,
-0.9416115283966064,
-0.4063096344470978,
-0.28004997968673706,
-0.6314171552658081,
0.32181817293167114,
0.282023549079895,
0.49220389127731323,
-0.17813217639923096,
0.1453624814748764,
0.6298636198043823,
-0.12058793753385544,
0.3311218321323395,
0.5059118866920471,
-0.21489380300045013,
-0.38004758954048157,
0.9783724546432495,
0.11697054654359818,
0.30125096440315247,
0.27455568313598633,
0.2968786358833313,
-0.2886016368865967,
-0.6355363130569458,
-0.4972878694534302,
0.288686603307724,
-1.038856029510498,
-0.14668773114681244,
-0.7071629166603088,
-0.18374693393707275,
-0.11268994212150574,
0.13166256248950958,
-0.39209097623825073,
-0.3645387589931488,
-0.11245038360357285,
-0.2733803987503052,
0.055572621524333954,
0.8469401001930237,
0.006078279111534357,
0.04714977368712425,
-0.7327289581298828,
0.5803449153900146,
0.6672335863113403,
0.36063656210899353,
0.2591628134250641,
-0.4202811121940613,
-0.12175548821687698,
0.039575301110744476,
-0.174404576420784,
-0.6734948754310608,
0.13540904223918915,
-0.11642875522375107,
0.7169722318649292,
0.4248111844062805,
0.05805861949920654,
0.6058043241500854,
-0.6060543656349182,
0.6877011060714722,
-0.0030884260777384043,
-0.9733455181121826,
0.34050223231315613,
-0.2990421950817108,
0.1419750303030014,
0.7509962320327759,
0.39109355211257935,
-0.528505265712738,
-0.22974708676338196,
-0.4712074398994446,
-0.8052120208740234,
0.7526357173919678,
0.230747252702713,
0.15778124332427979,
0.029008708894252777,
0.19079042971134186,
0.13897697627544403,
0.3343107998371124,
-0.8413466811180115,
-0.3924487233161926,
0.11966747045516968,
0.0940951332449913,
-0.19438327848911285,
-0.5790228247642517,
-0.2793644368648529,
-0.22787199914455414,
0.6893686652183533,
0.06153034418821335,
0.25197163224220276,
-0.17814280092716217,
-0.20737077295780182,
-0.20437389612197876,
0.24820658564567566,
0.3927939236164093,
0.832729697227478,
-0.34382885694503784,
0.4332968592643738,
0.00856047309935093,
-0.044516436755657196,
0.3873647153377533,
-0.3081275224685669,
-0.1301986426115036,
-0.000630847061984241,
0.6578962206840515,
0.6866363286972046,
0.5207031965255737,
-0.7149745225906372,
0.7125420570373535,
0.021660786122083664,
0.075090192258358,
-0.30016234517097473,
-0.05748479440808296,
0.23941807448863983,
0.07375600188970566,
0.4749891757965088,
0.11214430630207062,
0.03339739888906479,
-0.5670924186706543,
0.10159724950790405,
0.451133668422699,
-0.21618503332138062,
-0.3069802224636078,
0.2943020462989807,
0.5784502029418945,
-0.34441304206848145,
0.5754618048667908,
-0.18397724628448486,
-0.536710262298584,
0.42005985975265503,
0.2553393840789795,
0.8515799641609192,
-0.15095825493335724,
0.2237977683544159,
0.22700834274291992,
0.3921957314014435,
-0.29109200835227966,
0.008894006721675396,
0.04859195277094841,
-0.8575388789176941,
-0.2776569128036499,
-0.5274991989135742,
-0.5470001101493835,
0.555733859539032,
-0.45337721705436707,
0.42880940437316895,
-0.4426083266735077,
0.016384128481149673,
0.11153644323348999,
0.06731990724802017,
-0.6140754818916321,
-0.13434109091758728,
0.37518033385276794,
0.7251917123794556,
-0.9304527640342712,
0.5751367211341858,
0.461784303188324,
-0.32540079951286316,
-0.3824802041053772,
0.26476967334747314,
-0.008514884859323502,
-0.9364093542098999,
0.6232521533966064,
0.23264744877815247,
-0.3615102171897888,
0.20034565031528473,
-0.5977799892425537,
-0.9370191693305969,
0.6902102828025818,
0.6232373714447021,
-0.32511094212532043,
-0.2122400403022766,
-0.15170691907405853,
0.4252319633960724,
-0.16878154873847961,
0.5859832167625427,
0.43004775047302246,
0.6408716440200806,
0.2681446671485901,
-0.9097791910171509,
-0.016055848449468613,
-0.28397324681282043,
-0.041272107511758804,
-0.05000382289290428,
-0.6298735737800598,
0.6799222826957703,
-0.47161865234375,
-0.5321323871612549,
0.20973865687847137,
0.31917521357536316,
0.29813218116760254,
0.0350157804787159,
0.5559238195419312,
0.4434796869754791,
0.7460861802101135,
0.01833455078303814,
1.0453547239303589,
-0.12484484910964966,
0.45598307251930237,
1.0561909675598145,
-0.34186169505119324,
0.7725066542625427,
0.30586177110671997,
-0.33247867226600647,
0.23150385916233063,
0.5776132941246033,
0.09205441176891327,
0.48735085129737854,
0.483864426612854,
-0.11086615920066833,
-0.7037928700447083,
-0.03066781349480152,
-0.27775079011917114,
0.3604426980018616,
0.1931103616952896,
0.010718594305217266,
-0.4743574559688568,
-0.166096031665802,
0.0724368765950203,
0.09642573446035385,
-0.11824754625558853,
0.7046347856521606,
0.21969912946224213,
-0.5777741074562073,
1.0003150701522827,
0.09514589607715607,
0.4905751347541809,
-0.3358509838581085,
-0.1251315027475357,
-0.3216573894023895,
-0.23642556369304657,
-0.15090031921863556,
-0.6198186874389648,
-0.047246161848306656,
0.22848311066627502,
-0.298930823802948,
-0.19118040800094604,
0.30324727296829224,
-0.2761421501636505,
-0.8156915903091431,
0.1693950742483139,
0.9013917446136475,
0.25985094904899597,
-0.15959061682224274,
-0.4331590533256531,
0.002907266141846776,
-0.2825447916984558,
-0.4040006399154663,
0.2607885003089905,
0.37222158908843994,
-0.011371846310794353,
1.0257831811904907,
0.6260530948638916,
-0.018977569416165352,
-0.3358786702156067,
-0.10620120912790298,
0.8109291791915894,
-0.7444582581520081,
-0.3423626124858856,
-1.0103271007537842,
0.09175761044025421,
0.009406081400811672,
-0.05189225822687149,
0.7152787446975708,
0.5403706431388855,
0.4661601781845093,
0.13162294030189514,
1.093422770500183,
0.20591726899147034,
0.7986127138137817,
-0.6487658619880676,
0.7224270105361938,
-0.4080609679222107,
0.6768693327903748,
-0.2128608226776123,
-1.0597859621047974,
-0.31956151127815247,
0.3504925072193146,
-0.4827582836151123,
0.1664474904537201,
0.700306236743927,
0.6526789665222168,
0.05577998608350754,
-0.18699346482753754,
0.5496883988380432,
0.5138267278671265,
0.19927753508090973,
0.51816725730896,
1.2016295194625854,
0.0013127668062224984,
0.6013292074203491,
-0.06502722203731537,
-0.45952320098876953,
-0.34378260374069214,
-0.9356538653373718,
-1.0209447145462036,
-0.4498489797115326,
-0.03099554404616356,
-0.2444804310798645,
-0.0035236964467912912,
1.0851130485534668,
0.567808985710144,
-0.6278179883956909,
-0.24498967826366425,
0.25336676836013794,
0.5763922333717346,
0.0010653884382918477,
-0.1906294971704483,
0.3838687837123871,
-0.18285265564918518,
-0.837929368019104,
0.8913711905479431,
0.26215046644210815,
-0.14494644105434418,
-0.5334292054176331,
0.04088098183274269,
0.15955284237861633,
-0.08486678451299667,
0.4762283265590668,
0.06890607625246048,
-1.049379825592041,
-0.45786091685295105,
-0.22010037302970886,
-0.13122718036174774,
0.04761325567960739,
0.8192158341407776,
-1.0894505977630615,
0.27897489070892334,
0.44837695360183716,
0.5667299032211304,
0.07087212055921555,
0.13485026359558105,
0.5659246444702148,
-0.6291248202323914,
-0.16016210615634918,
0.4649115204811096,
0.15505242347717285,
0.45678409934043884,
-0.1697995960712433,
0.48767104744911194,
0.39775073528289795,
-0.42155465483665466,
-0.9857057929039001,
0.18302717804908752,
-0.9152969717979431,
-0.08554539829492569,
1.3433537483215332,
-0.21265365183353424,
0.1362060308456421,
-0.14150653779506683,
-0.04749360680580139,
-0.16930705308914185,
-0.4042220413684845,
0.9292236566543579,
0.8450631499290466,
0.0739559605717659,
-0.08068928122520447,
-0.7573291063308716,
0.2667049169540405,
0.2003643661737442,
-0.659351646900177,
0.34528806805610657,
0.4565577805042267,
0.4292599558830261,
0.19448137283325195,
0.6920157074928284,
-0.08253946155309677,
-0.1740618646144867,
-0.15443743765354156,
-0.06278055906295776,
-0.2578808069229126,
-0.43190667033195496,
-0.5351036787033081,
0.4622006118297577,
0.46031445264816284,
0.012307273223996162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13448v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13448v2
|
ED-Copilot: Reduce Emergency Department Wait Time with Language Model Diagnostic Assistance
| 2024-02-21T00:49:42 | 2024-05-27T22:30:46 |
Liwen Sun, Abhineet Agarwal, Aaron Kornblith, Bin Yu, Chenyan Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In the emergency department (ED), patients undergo triage and multiple
laboratory tests before diagnosis. This time-consuming process causes ED
crowding which impacts patient mortality, medical errors, staff burnout, etc.
This work proposes (time) cost-effective diagnostic assistance that leverages
artificial intelligence systems to help ED clinicians make efficient and
accurate diagnoses. In collaboration with ED clinicians, we use public patient
data to curate MIMIC-ED-Assist, a benchmark for AI systems to suggest
laboratory tests that minimize wait time while accurately predicting critical
outcomes such as death. With MIMIC-ED-Assist, we develop ED-Copilot which
sequentially suggests patient-specific laboratory tests and makes diagnostic
predictions. ED-Copilot employs a pre-trained bio-medical language model to
encode patient information and uses reinforcement learning to minimize ED wait
time and maximize prediction accuracy. On MIMIC-ED-Assist, ED-Copilot improves
prediction accuracy over baselines while halving average wait time from four
hours to two hours. ED-Copilot can also effectively personalize treatment
recommendations based on patient severity, further highlighting its potential
as a diagnostic assistant. Since MIMIC-ED-Assist is a retrospective benchmark,
ED-Copilot is restricted to recommend only observed tests. We show ED-Copilot
achieves competitive performance without this restriction as the maximum
allowed time increases. Our code is available at
https://github.com/cxcscmu/ED-Copilot.
|
[
-0.1084975004196167,
-0.7081549167633057,
1.035759449005127,
0.2207650989294052,
-0.18155787885189056,
0.42483025789260864,
-0.018405422568321228,
-0.563042163848877,
0.23541004955768585,
-0.09922486543655396,
-0.588666558265686,
-0.18122485280036926,
-0.266699880361557,
0.29397052526474,
-0.19887740910053253,
0.6267018914222717,
-0.13427647948265076,
0.45526525378227234,
-0.13722704350948334,
0.3552837669849396,
-0.2177445888519287,
-0.543561577796936,
-1.381247878074646,
-0.07258743792772293,
0.4985191822052002,
0.35096344351768494,
0.8346933126449585,
0.697938859462738,
0.36725133657455444,
0.15828785300254822,
0.21555200219154358,
0.15709884464740753,
-0.022046398371458054,
0.014746704138815403,
0.3387807309627533,
-0.06005379557609558,
-0.9565355777740479,
-0.46120551228523254,
0.45307642221450806,
0.7226434946060181,
-0.3880089521408081,
-0.2113264799118042,
-0.10330694913864136,
0.5790713429450989,
-0.3383442163467407,
0.09032043814659119,
-0.12930355966091156,
0.13362249732017517,
-0.010018658824265003,
-0.1943453997373581,
-0.2888544797897339,
-0.32883623242378235,
0.4159582555294037,
-1.1567763090133667,
0.11656057834625244,
0.3837617337703705,
0.5115721225738525,
0.6250642538070679,
0.02529837377369404,
0.029145117849111557,
-0.5432361960411072,
0.39683711528778076,
-0.20588277280330658,
0.5860217213630676,
0.4972131550312042,
0.4892864525318146,
0.07135109603404999,
-0.5470008850097656,
-0.5735853314399719,
-0.10604742914438248,
-0.11853338778018951,
0.3532172739505768,
0.011925764381885529,
0.27358224987983704,
0.3056613802909851,
-0.09731421619653702,
-0.8259224891662598,
0.048958826810121536,
-0.20972777903079987,
-0.06421871483325958,
0.706069827079773,
0.3702259063720703,
0.4206434488296509,
0.09010323882102966,
-0.29907745122909546,
-0.14912089705467224,
-0.3363252878189087,
0.04680592939257622,
0.023661309853196144,
-0.17657014727592468,
0.09740640223026276,
0.09055481851100922,
-0.10960986465215683,
0.4902207553386688,
0.23070603609085083,
-0.027370305731892586,
0.4267802834510803,
0.033696237951517105,
-0.31120964884757996,
0.20459918677806854,
0.7812013030052185,
0.2523866891860962,
0.22477677464485168,
-0.14157848060131073,
-0.17045369744300842,
-0.040759406983852386,
0.27828577160835266,
-0.5593978762626648,
-0.580463171005249,
0.5766546130180359,
-0.467696875333786,
-0.14930422604084015,
-0.06401625275611877,
-1.1605818271636963,
-0.3627243936061859,
-0.1474037915468216,
0.13496817648410797,
-0.6619521379470825,
-0.34576356410980225,
-0.0907355323433876,
0.026277044788002968,
-0.18201777338981628,
0.44645625352859497,
-0.32417166233062744,
0.7212634682655334,
0.38801661133766174,
1.0822242498397827,
-0.35012421011924744,
-0.13254202902317047,
-0.9094566702842712,
0.1462913602590561,
-0.22149859368801117,
0.8401523232460022,
-0.7085344791412354,
-0.6544197797775269,
-0.06813458353281021,
0.18989931046962738,
-0.3153044879436493,
-0.4961329698562622,
0.6812561750411987,
-0.06096431612968445,
-0.030132954940199852,
0.23793238401412964,
-0.5638817548751831,
0.11069051176309586,
-0.014489840716123581,
-0.5383589267730713,
0.8881362080574036,
0.21635834872722626,
-0.2721386253833771,
0.14684003591537476,
-0.9093142151832581,
-0.4158143699169159,
0.5717948079109192,
-0.26118215918540955,
-0.6417232155799866,
-0.18158771097660065,
0.4428771436214447,
0.3538612425327301,
-0.08538209646940231,
0.17721763253211975,
-0.2088056206703186,
-0.35506471991539,
-0.15027175843715668,
0.060789354145526886,
0.738892138004303,
0.2850435972213745,
-0.10578635334968567,
0.12980879843235016,
-0.7702164649963379,
0.14103391766548157,
0.3566734492778778,
-0.353274405002594,
-0.3095196783542633,
0.28864559531211853,
0.08889602869749069,
-0.23470281064510345,
0.016565153375267982,
-0.5298389792442322,
0.2239767611026764,
-0.1747846007347107,
-0.1415778249502182,
0.8108956813812256,
-0.18168213963508606,
0.22214089334011078,
-0.7727413773536682,
0.9523063898086548,
-0.09752122312784195,
0.5578651428222656,
-0.16401390731334686,
-0.6640564799308777,
-0.5504543781280518,
-0.4157290756702423,
0.21285264194011688,
0.8867248296737671,
-0.9565308094024658,
0.3434597849845886,
-0.027960624545812607,
-0.2933099567890167,
-0.6491057276725769,
-0.3804985284805298,
0.2190677374601364,
0.6069833636283875,
0.4977143108844757,
-0.10908250510692596,
-0.5414210557937622,
-0.8507388830184937,
0.1697949916124344,
-0.11962488293647766,
-0.42204228043556213,
0.4031117558479309,
0.00040515654836781323,
-0.33031603693962097,
0.2985445261001587,
-0.5234076976776123,
-0.421782523393631,
-0.03189302608370781,
-0.0631498321890831,
0.2327279895544052,
0.3786539137363434,
0.7249476909637451,
-0.525547444820404,
-0.6084873676300049,
-0.024061961099505424,
-0.48983561992645264,
-0.4467603862285614,
0.005836075637489557,
0.13499383628368378,
0.3747463822364807,
0.36855676770210266,
-0.12607483565807343,
0.4550372064113617,
0.48158493638038635,
-0.41523900628089905,
0.5151234269142151,
-0.6638790369033813,
0.24858880043029785,
-0.8163122534751892,
0.13281960785388947,
-0.3127066493034363,
-0.3599611222743988,
-0.5796728134155273,
-0.1521265059709549,
0.18810002505779266,
-0.5421157479286194,
-0.22923418879508972,
0.49987104535102844,
-0.3686860203742981,
0.28196123242378235,
0.0813012421131134,
0.18979217112064362,
-0.1850290298461914,
0.24984104931354523,
0.2946878671646118,
0.5888646841049194,
0.757106363773346,
-0.6335200071334839,
0.19421958923339844,
-0.024946359917521477,
-0.025163471698760986,
0.6827563643455505,
-0.9155555963516235,
0.3199259638786316,
0.19323840737342834,
0.20157767832279205,
-0.5733179450035095,
-0.18293729424476624,
0.3914933502674103,
-0.19900640845298767,
0.29179835319519043,
-0.06316418945789337,
-0.6147069931030273,
-0.5998331308364868,
-0.23240752518177032,
0.6356070041656494,
0.728793203830719,
-0.44133126735687256,
0.7150722146034241,
0.1852692812681198,
-0.5771586298942566,
-0.38217446208000183,
-0.2482253462076187,
-0.34352195262908936,
0.34893473982810974,
-0.4166227877140045,
0.4206482470035553,
-0.6258652210235596,
-0.21833489835262299,
-0.023921480402350426,
0.3272162973880768,
-0.4135887622833252,
0.30308642983436584,
0.46092861890792847,
0.4271911382675171,
0.02655823901295662,
0.7542102932929993,
0.4339466094970703,
-0.09493757039308548,
0.04471432417631149,
-0.11963315308094025,
0.5868669152259827,
-0.010404056869447231,
-0.313828706741333,
-0.5642374157905579,
0.817191481590271,
0.6912086606025696,
0.0642228052020073,
0.6115936040878296,
0.11958780884742737,
-0.6018960475921631,
-0.06530378013849258,
-0.2410108894109726,
-0.2646685540676117,
-0.38916492462158203,
0.2155880182981491,
-0.08275191485881805,
-0.10952913016080856,
0.43482035398483276,
-0.09372832626104355,
0.018098630011081696,
0.16760171949863434,
0.32526060938835144,
-0.12827807664871216,
1.1926376819610596,
0.4489796757698059,
0.08773379027843475,
0.504203200340271,
-0.08339225500822067,
0.15510694682598114,
-0.7192999720573425,
-0.2762942612171173,
-0.3110675811767578,
-0.23568060994148254,
-0.23686952888965607,
-0.3543766438961029,
0.9043144583702087,
-0.1462726891040802,
-0.0767037570476532,
-0.06395885348320007,
-0.9386808276176453,
0.2784463167190552,
0.2765595018863678,
0.4142468273639679,
0.23723040521144867,
-0.24308842420578003,
-0.30834683775901794,
0.2197914868593216,
-1.0409621000289917,
-0.2947702407836914,
1.2464135885238647,
0.2164391130208969,
0.4011048376560211,
-0.05072499439120293,
0.777866780757904,
0.3204749524593353,
0.4607865512371063,
-0.7914333939552307,
0.30536919832229614,
-0.03899963200092316,
-0.25415998697280884,
-0.19436931610107422,
-0.18318766355514526,
-0.9484162926673889,
-0.39823487401008606,
-0.2905782461166382,
-0.5404977798461914,
0.13752053678035736,
0.392938494682312,
-0.7991667985916138,
0.25269371271133423,
-0.9193695783615112,
0.5315096378326416,
-0.4047442078590393,
-0.20240376889705658,
-0.30141115188598633,
-0.40924492478370667,
-0.1944696456193924,
-0.2991986572742462,
0.30241045355796814,
0.19244708120822906,
-0.19283084571361542,
0.9037559628486633,
-0.7004698514938354,
0.39264073967933655,
0.016265572980046272,
0.17812606692314148,
-0.1742258071899414,
0.07227838039398193,
0.4924967586994171,
0.12739849090576172,
-0.09346937388181686,
0.20120476186275482,
0.35213127732276917,
-0.6049506664276123,
-0.425270676612854,
0.5893381834030151,
-0.5904192328453064,
-0.42400887608528137,
-0.6331002712249756,
-0.46096524596214294,
-0.13363595306873322,
0.14853307604789734,
0.10047990083694458,
0.6368304491043091,
-0.02859639562666416,
-0.31737715005874634,
0.5872618556022644,
-0.36299118399620056,
0.6018046140670776,
0.6322199106216431,
-0.13077521324157715,
-0.04616710916161537,
0.8114234805107117,
0.2306147664785385,
0.08398769795894623,
0.3057282865047455,
0.32803985476493835,
-0.11584581434726715,
-0.35343754291534424,
-0.46857550740242004,
0.14827457070350647,
-0.21926355361938477,
-0.2515357434749603,
-1.0301079750061035,
-0.21357546746730804,
-0.46064862608909607,
-0.4031362235546112,
-0.3240085542201996,
-0.22679802775382996,
-0.01144649088382721,
0.03831981122493744,
0.5817188024520874,
0.622700572013855,
-0.02401960827410221,
0.14982271194458008,
-0.6384583115577698,
0.18951161205768585,
0.32826313376426697,
0.41516464948654175,
0.049037426710128784,
0.037876952439546585,
-0.09473603218793869,
-0.2243701070547104,
-0.35565489530563354,
-1.0427584648132324,
0.2569770812988281,
0.07015454024076462,
0.49340128898620605,
0.4718722403049469,
0.5513690710067749,
0.35838204622268677,
-0.7784349918365479,
0.6621816158294678,
0.25763776898384094,
-0.9386529922485352,
0.721713662147522,
-0.21024900674819946,
-0.016893284395337105,
0.11621524393558502,
0.5002540349960327,
-0.26139938831329346,
-0.3673734962940216,
-0.8510286211967468,
-0.8373852968215942,
0.483724445104599,
0.19229656457901,
-0.6074873208999634,
-0.18855996429920197,
0.037254732102155685,
0.04010622948408127,
0.057310234755277634,
-0.12718209624290466,
-0.4454214572906494,
-0.05645782873034477,
-0.48697546124458313,
-0.08587514609098434,
-0.06061393767595291,
-0.22691260278224945,
-0.3382899761199951,
0.3898278772830963,
-0.1865455061197281,
0.6522880792617798,
0.7424089908599854,
0.14183133840560913,
-0.48145875334739685,
0.4135429561138153,
0.8690871000289917,
0.7939895987510681,
-0.3158961534500122,
-0.12704770267009735,
0.27326643466949463,
-0.508358895778656,
-0.05029740184545517,
0.7912395596504211,
0.06906464695930481,
0.3585537075996399,
0.03212456777691841,
0.14591066539287567,
0.046468038111925125,
-1.0709947347640991,
0.3855583667755127,
-0.3001863360404968,
-0.010792357847094536,
-0.7792177796363831,
0.09413653612136841,
-0.1863817274570465,
0.1847890317440033,
0.47926732897758484,
-0.05963604152202606,
0.08821069449186325,
-0.267016738653183,
0.3494521975517273,
0.10181204974651337,
-0.21679802238941193,
-0.32239484786987305,
0.7428522109985352,
0.5561162829399109,
-1.0748019218444824,
0.31517359614372253,
-0.33909207582473755,
-0.6063839793205261,
1.0153732299804688,
0.27492406964302063,
0.6404403448104858,
-0.6635422110557556,
0.39554914832115173,
0.23522010445594788,
0.18570564687252045,
-0.01422528363764286,
0.44105398654937744,
0.1980980783700943,
-0.27859118580818176,
-0.004701377358287573,
-0.19064578413963318,
-0.637620210647583,
0.15528889000415802,
-0.6706904768943787,
0.32898181676864624,
-1.0563265085220337,
0.04588870331645012,
-0.2905854880809784,
0.06981521099805832,
-0.9239695072174072,
0.08586689084768295,
0.016534045338630676,
0.7486541271209717,
-0.42276453971862793,
0.6402290463447571,
0.8926204442977905,
0.02378077246248722,
-0.9705223441123962,
0.0030070513021200895,
0.029954412952065468,
-0.764690101146698,
0.33517947793006897,
0.12195941805839539,
0.07407020777463913,
0.026218444108963013,
-0.2505608797073364,
-0.40726223587989807,
1.120518445968628,
0.06085224449634552,
-1.132109522819519,
0.08467789739370346,
-0.7799342274665833,
0.7520607709884644,
-0.6377941966056824,
0.4609040915966034,
0.40063756704330444,
0.3322997987270355,
-0.4462830722332001,
-1.3125340938568115,
0.26625242829322815,
-0.33546775579452515,
-0.6294173002243042,
0.3892098069190979,
-0.4830820858478546,
1.0032455921173096,
-0.45435258746147156,
-0.2812882959842682,
0.2740381062030792,
-0.20270510017871857,
0.2675740420818329,
0.9018524885177612,
0.6028732657432556,
0.5657742023468018,
1.2553069591522217,
-0.11464984714984894,
1.662360668182373,
-0.3530171811580658,
0.16840769350528717,
0.9365907311439514,
-0.2713748514652252,
0.6261052489280701,
0.2071976214647293,
-0.20165832340717316,
0.5925049781799316,
0.7289323210716248,
0.23534056544303894,
0.42264267802238464,
0.025069303810596466,
-0.39250117540359497,
-0.17177711427211761,
-0.43805113434791565,
-0.7420598268508911,
-0.139341801404953,
0.25636130571365356,
-0.40981900691986084,
0.1512771099805832,
0.017501309514045715,
-0.046570729464292526,
-0.04508955031633377,
-0.3117702901363373,
0.6497907042503357,
-0.20925164222717285,
-0.43802493810653687,
0.5420601963996887,
-0.6951104998588562,
0.16913855075836182,
-0.37151166796684265,
-0.1902235597372055,
-0.04478887841105461,
0.2473931759595871,
0.09614167362451553,
-0.26620686054229736,
-0.0001622591953491792,
-0.22315122187137604,
-0.25024649500846863,
-0.13848057389259338,
0.1998581737279892,
-0.40957847237586975,
-0.5778966546058655,
0.5384240746498108,
0.6259324550628662,
0.3087575137615204,
0.035049110651016235,
-0.8730629682540894,
-0.06955017149448395,
-0.28416508436203003,
0.09443320333957672,
0.09691689908504486,
0.17685504257678986,
0.27440568804740906,
0.822750449180603,
0.5738063454627991,
0.41573938727378845,
-0.20022615790367126,
0.15915034711360931,
0.7684052586555481,
-0.1805240362882614,
-0.544822633266449,
-0.48206254839897156,
0.2758837640285492,
-0.27735623717308044,
-0.19595488905906677,
-0.254440039396286,
0.2679719924926758,
0.7176026105880737,
-0.12950371205806732,
0.6675713062286377,
-0.043749257922172546,
0.8406020998954773,
-0.4456102252006531,
0.7317759394645691,
-0.8195565938949585,
0.21271702647209167,
-0.43006619811058044,
-0.5018042922019958,
-0.13058112561702728,
0.5383095145225525,
-0.1739957332611084,
-0.09154275059700012,
1.176613450050354,
0.5851914882659912,
0.1579209268093109,
-0.34781619906425476,
0.5521343350410461,
0.1396699845790863,
0.37124475836753845,
0.9180901646614075,
0.6478099226951599,
-0.33672821521759033,
0.4837542474269867,
-0.40629494190216064,
-0.5170822739601135,
-0.45847272872924805,
-0.5560823678970337,
-0.8144664168357849,
-0.31931620836257935,
-0.42788228392601013,
-0.042409904301166534,
0.24149465560913086,
1.1259616613388062,
0.9750362634658813,
-0.7239488959312439,
0.17803533375263214,
0.0009382955613546073,
0.24524347484111786,
-0.7526131868362427,
-0.31738045811653137,
0.5031654834747314,
0.08359100669622421,
-0.902738630771637,
0.4934639632701874,
0.31344088912010193,
0.24967075884342194,
0.13419224321842194,
-0.14965079724788666,
-0.059772416949272156,
0.04118004068732262,
0.29678648710250854,
0.21208228170871735,
-0.6216227412223816,
-0.4405512809753418,
0.1804550439119339,
0.1062588170170784,
-0.017152344807982445,
0.8634579181671143,
-0.9054684042930603,
0.7832265496253967,
0.10205177217721939,
0.804443895816803,
-0.3279813230037689,
-0.010108894668519497,
0.6590938568115234,
-0.36300742626190186,
0.17168213427066803,
0.41151559352874756,
0.5417806506156921,
0.14186228811740875,
-1.0933986902236938,
0.6051843166351318,
0.46889108419418335,
-0.6715017557144165,
-0.7129107117652893,
0.23696771264076233,
-0.911309540271759,
-0.12256903201341629,
0.6981858015060425,
-0.3110511600971222,
-0.1114940494298935,
-0.5370849967002869,
-0.3179579973220825,
0.16320814192295074,
-0.9376636147499084,
0.9057080745697021,
0.36511340737342834,
-0.7177761793136597,
-0.4235721826553345,
-0.3382622301578522,
0.5945900082588196,
0.5009715557098389,
-1.0210065841674805,
-0.3562591075897217,
0.22100256383419037,
0.22134706377983093,
0.3339037299156189,
0.6412756443023682,
0.3269047141075134,
0.7748199105262756,
-0.19293397665023804,
-0.13755860924720764,
-0.3663860857486725,
-0.5325273275375366,
-0.18641062080860138,
-0.020291557535529137,
-0.3325091302394867,
-0.5535807013511658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13446v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13446v2
|
Large Language Models for Data Annotation: A Survey
| 2024-02-21T00:44:04 | 2024-06-23T21:51:45 |
Zhen Tan, Dawei Li, Song Wang, Alimohammad Beigi, Bohan Jiang, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Mansooreh Karami, Jundong Li, Lu Cheng, Huan Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Data annotation generally refers to the labeling or generating of raw data
with relevant information, which could be used for improving the efficacy of
machine learning models. The process, however, is labor-intensive and costly.
The emergence of advanced Large Language Models (LLMs), exemplified by GPT-4,
presents an unprecedented opportunity to automate the complicated process of
data annotation. While existing surveys have extensively covered LLM
architecture, training, and general applications, we uniquely focus on their
specific utility for data annotation. This survey contributes to three core
aspects: LLM-Based Annotation Generation, LLM-Generated Annotations Assessment,
and LLM-Generated Annotations Utilization. Furthermore, this survey includes an
in-depth taxonomy of data types that LLMs can annotate, a comprehensive review
of learning strategies for models utilizing LLM-generated annotations, and a
detailed discussion of the primary challenges and limitations associated with
using LLMs for data annotation. Serving as a key guide, this survey aims to
assist researchers and practitioners in exploring the potential of the latest
LLMs for data annotation, thereby fostering future advancements in this
critical field.
|
[
-0.4866272509098053,
-0.9571536779403687,
0.6000905632972717,
0.012115027755498886,
-0.28507304191589355,
0.05193953588604927,
-0.4145771563053131,
-0.7251142263412476,
0.04718336462974548,
0.698767364025116,
-0.3610839247703552,
-0.6444518566131592,
-0.49076810479164124,
0.17404258251190186,
-0.39175182580947876,
1.2014696598052979,
-0.1753556728363037,
0.01841074787080288,
-0.23942331969738007,
0.038273587822914124,
-0.32843631505966187,
-1.0780000686645508,
-0.6406741738319397,
-0.2716476321220398,
0.5815740823745728,
0.22473503649234772,
0.5583717823028564,
0.7593735456466675,
0.6135701537132263,
0.2138587236404419,
-0.010625014081597328,
0.1494615375995636,
-0.3485385775566101,
0.34943270683288574,
0.20118363201618195,
-0.3574792146682739,
-0.7212948203086853,
0.22004884481430054,
0.7563349008560181,
0.9054727554321289,
0.13476739823818207,
0.3713260889053345,
-0.2194235920906067,
0.4344860315322876,
-0.400397926568985,
0.5203054547309875,
-0.7219583988189697,
-0.0044869426637887955,
-0.6064035892486572,
-0.09534347057342529,
-0.23562680184841156,
-0.5517935156822205,
0.09438328444957733,
-0.49597686529159546,
0.040659546852111816,
0.062856525182724,
0.525722086429596,
0.22834214568138123,
-0.3688223958015442,
-0.38746845722198486,
-0.8442291617393494,
0.7543611526489258,
-0.5963187217712402,
0.34164777398109436,
0.540545642375946,
0.32348132133483887,
-0.04238119721412659,
-0.7657747268676758,
-0.4957304894924164,
-0.3013513684272766,
0.14217323064804077,
-0.10263234376907349,
0.19008082151412964,
0.031467072665691376,
0.5762957334518433,
0.5312560796737671,
-0.3195241391658783,
0.491529643535614,
-0.3146454095840454,
-0.2990378737449646,
0.8911715745925903,
0.36018118262290955,
0.14011502265930176,
-0.10084053874015808,
-0.08075559139251709,
0.1291268765926361,
-1.1837854385375977,
-0.48742300271987915,
0.5103735327720642,
0.39179790019989014,
0.19074058532714844,
0.675089955329895,
-0.2394300401210785,
0.9061384201049805,
-0.47050297260284424,
-0.08881644904613495,
0.4537019431591034,
-0.3984448313713074,
-0.15525302290916443,
-0.19527994096279144,
0.7916833758354187,
0.306150883436203,
0.4138403534889221,
-0.14747321605682373,
-0.43570956587791443,
-0.19460560381412506,
-0.09099049866199493,
-0.7466007471084595,
-0.33700624108314514,
0.08441583812236786,
-0.1301063746213913,
-0.31009069085121155,
-0.1269095540046692,
-0.8151679039001465,
-0.5639396905899048,
-0.5603504776954651,
0.046217016875743866,
0.013182430528104305,
-0.25558242201805115,
-0.049504783004522324,
0.31001079082489014,
0.1966335028409958,
0.49077683687210083,
-1.017417311668396,
0.14220485091209412,
0.6147639155387878,
0.7571882605552673,
-0.14730854332447052,
-0.12471017986536026,
-0.27794167399406433,
0.26235640048980713,
-0.4464161992073059,
0.8026508688926697,
-0.6431320905685425,
-0.3999258279800415,
0.266432523727417,
-0.09706008434295654,
0.2181164026260376,
-0.45709431171417236,
0.5963817834854126,
-0.5888637900352478,
0.18511556088924408,
-0.21223138272762299,
-0.8946427702903748,
-0.33522355556488037,
0.42318710684776306,
-0.9219824075698853,
1.1879931688308716,
0.16865196824073792,
-0.8305355906486511,
0.45693421363830566,
-0.8395228385925293,
-0.2490115463733673,
0.419846773147583,
-0.395866721868515,
-0.5980756282806396,
-0.09587724506855011,
0.21762439608573914,
0.9557391405105591,
-0.5634613633155823,
0.40654662251472473,
-0.3974939286708832,
-0.10747586190700531,
0.454593688249588,
-0.3990650177001953,
0.3958275616168976,
0.14637839794158936,
-0.12367747724056244,
0.07232276350259781,
-0.7251500487327576,
-0.21853259205818176,
0.29592159390449524,
-0.6091204285621643,
-0.11973260343074799,
-0.004055758006870747,
0.25996193289756775,
0.14933152496814728,
0.3893410861492157,
-0.4612250328063965,
0.6001814603805542,
-0.025719529017806053,
0.46014314889907837,
0.6552339792251587,
0.2226790189743042,
0.16811560094356537,
-0.08798772096633911,
0.6127484440803528,
-0.16835397481918335,
0.07551316171884537,
-0.37642183899879456,
-0.584785521030426,
-0.5093702673912048,
-0.35163387656211853,
0.6000367403030396,
0.4821687340736389,
-0.6516472697257996,
0.3888750970363617,
-0.2734977900981903,
-0.6597937345504761,
-0.38159531354904175,
0.15510545670986176,
0.07853709161281586,
0.4136904776096344,
0.2864055931568146,
0.025350280106067657,
-0.7465829849243164,
-0.9683689475059509,
0.1738230288028717,
-0.2744823098182678,
0.12299972027540207,
0.3247305154800415,
0.5817188024520874,
-0.36168113350868225,
0.8463001251220703,
-0.5263769626617432,
-0.11962192505598068,
-0.33309972286224365,
0.25736963748931885,
-0.009897606447339058,
0.2808617055416107,
0.5250120162963867,
-0.7933845520019531,
-0.28450989723205566,
-0.05427604541182518,
-0.6964619755744934,
-0.3600853979587555,
-0.0671570673584938,
0.2200094759464264,
0.37754547595977783,
0.5496327877044678,
-0.5310971140861511,
0.17622071504592896,
0.5507580637931824,
0.14173342287540436,
0.5294528603553772,
0.007175019010901451,
0.07403110712766647,
-0.8623254299163818,
0.15275368094444275,
-0.018431346863508224,
-0.17726320028305054,
-0.6989661455154419,
-0.151305690407753,
0.0016134935431182384,
-0.006227009929716587,
-0.1512535959482193,
0.5578588843345642,
-0.5837348103523254,
-0.13892881572246552,
-0.2059512883424759,
0.12332054227590561,
-0.35690978169441223,
0.09426005929708481,
0.2544024586677551,
0.7061627507209778,
0.639975905418396,
-0.39460381865501404,
0.6434930562973022,
0.22048571705818176,
-0.3229791522026062,
0.14221490919589996,
-0.3711432218551636,
0.3092728555202484,
-0.034665655344724655,
0.4290755093097687,
-0.9441020488739014,
-0.5599028468132019,
0.2782710790634155,
-0.23817679286003113,
0.3027687668800354,
-0.37732991576194763,
-0.97149258852005,
-0.33412542939186096,
-0.25842538475990295,
0.3905891180038452,
0.4560030400753021,
-0.469689279794693,
0.32604798674583435,
0.7167468667030334,
-0.4329226613044739,
-0.37451767921447754,
-0.8360706567764282,
0.2900247275829315,
-0.4944271445274353,
-0.3043045699596405,
-0.0887550562620163,
0.006689991801977158,
-0.17079710960388184,
-0.24956569075584412,
0.4044404923915863,
-0.074097640812397,
0.18249332904815674,
0.2838497459888458,
0.393557071685791,
-0.041017577052116394,
0.3499548137187958,
-0.36333853006362915,
-0.1661914438009262,
0.11904435604810715,
-0.1329411119222641,
0.49095553159713745,
0.050960473716259,
-0.42044806480407715,
-0.11584628373384476,
0.22870463132858276,
0.3124468922615051,
-0.3336002230644226,
0.4571297764778137,
0.6612396240234375,
-0.45591646432876587,
-0.05766995996236801,
-0.6863601803779602,
-0.02455344796180725,
-0.37054336071014404,
0.48546844720840454,
-0.3290014863014221,
-1.1131246089935303,
0.5509213209152222,
-0.2127835601568222,
0.2833319306373596,
0.5847386121749878,
0.8171448111534119,
0.15690112113952637,
0.8768031597137451,
0.4573240876197815,
-0.3193277418613434,
0.4404270648956299,
-0.18306440114974976,
0.07291501760482788,
-0.814428985118866,
-0.18564452230930328,
-0.5793243646621704,
-0.011734487488865852,
-0.6830011606216431,
-0.4159145653247833,
0.09281157702207565,
-0.14872436225414276,
-0.18484601378440857,
-0.1026705950498581,
-0.5124074220657349,
0.2880925238132477,
0.33533909916877747,
-0.3487890064716339,
0.26935064792633057,
-0.0895218476653099,
0.33000996708869934,
-0.013939959928393364,
-0.3874887228012085,
-0.8364022374153137,
1.5036882162094116,
0.581206202507019,
0.7334496378898621,
-0.06562865525484085,
0.7324382662773132,
0.11217834800481796,
0.6209439039230347,
-0.715338945388794,
0.6268347501754761,
0.02330363169312477,
-0.6718346476554871,
-0.3492448329925537,
-0.48513492941856384,
-0.7985115051269531,
-0.07875241339206696,
-0.24657444655895233,
-0.6919246315956116,
-0.25183969736099243,
0.27792489528656006,
-0.11962037533521652,
0.3231559693813324,
-0.5734199285507202,
0.652181088924408,
-0.3799763023853302,
-0.09856152534484863,
0.26930752396583557,
-0.40410828590393066,
0.46511852741241455,
-0.5881431698799133,
0.30484911799430847,
-0.29393160343170166,
-0.23287445306777954,
0.9948413968086243,
-0.07160113751888275,
0.9649755358695984,
-0.4150541126728058,
-0.28420060873031616,
0.3720085024833679,
-0.0958537608385086,
0.6277793049812317,
-0.029487906023859978,
-0.031696971505880356,
0.2698129713535309,
-0.24576979875564575,
-0.11652719229459763,
-0.37128254771232605,
0.3701133728027344,
-0.5109155774116516,
-0.47500211000442505,
-0.3980395495891571,
-0.7315738201141357,
-0.3263031542301178,
0.01939992792904377,
-0.06915879249572754,
0.31752297282218933,
-0.030046749860048294,
0.0741419866681099,
0.535824716091156,
-0.09817084670066833,
0.32999730110168457,
0.24554473161697388,
-0.6099115014076233,
-0.4692304730415344,
0.9209724068641663,
0.42730551958084106,
0.07548104226589203,
0.24081121385097504,
0.03862881287932396,
-0.5180214047431946,
-1.0364378690719604,
-0.37095004320144653,
0.22920677065849304,
-0.7528106570243835,
-0.20834583044052124,
-0.525078296661377,
-0.17886386811733246,
-0.26644226908683777,
0.1197197437286377,
-0.2699637711048126,
-0.7140742540359497,
-0.2292860448360443,
-0.3980216085910797,
0.8035799264907837,
1.1358952522277832,
0.0057519907131791115,
0.3626020550727844,
-0.5519090294837952,
0.0009582964703440666,
0.2156425416469574,
0.25412824749946594,
-0.24279150366783142,
-0.26160213351249695,
-0.36199548840522766,
-0.08218356966972351,
-0.06561846286058426,
-0.7498284578323364,
0.05309944227337837,
0.06951846182346344,
0.5962727069854736,
0.20620636641979218,
-0.2612561881542206,
0.44505709409713745,
-0.4954510033130646,
1.0585576295852661,
0.045576345175504684,
-0.7114676237106323,
0.37686407566070557,
-0.5982002019882202,
-0.04332566261291504,
0.37276285886764526,
0.4642711877822876,
-0.5103746652603149,
-0.3704194724559784,
-0.41297417879104614,
-1.0946801900863647,
0.39943182468414307,
-0.05138522386550903,
0.1916554719209671,
-0.02803191728889942,
0.5559673309326172,
0.26558515429496765,
0.24565941095352173,
-0.8184757828712463,
-0.17176832258701324,
0.05103413015604019,
-0.32592299580574036,
-0.12290329486131668,
-0.3452672064304352,
-0.04636888951063156,
-0.055071912705898285,
0.6368281245231628,
-0.25136029720306396,
0.08157351613044739,
-0.13564826548099518,
-0.1106860414147377,
0.1434895545244217,
0.17002412676811218,
0.4423220455646515,
0.6365198493003845,
-0.06561610102653503,
0.12219491600990295,
0.25189322233200073,
-0.5411291122436523,
0.013452613726258278,
0.3193485736846924,
-0.2894658148288727,
-0.14018936455249786,
0.5073171854019165,
0.8300804495811462,
-0.07241123169660568,
-0.5937472581863403,
0.32489651441574097,
0.0973736047744751,
-0.26992103457450867,
-0.526598334312439,
-0.05129837244749069,
0.25140589475631714,
0.03505157679319382,
0.38385671377182007,
-0.6468662023544312,
0.0997232124209404,
-0.32083770632743835,
0.07313820719718933,
0.4532835781574249,
0.018472017720341682,
-0.3538561761379242,
0.5922254920005798,
0.13993890583515167,
0.046084657311439514,
0.661421000957489,
-0.039290670305490494,
-0.4896332025527954,
0.33207905292510986,
0.32031235098838806,
0.749993085861206,
-0.31493622064590454,
-0.045885294675827026,
0.2308434545993805,
0.2871685326099396,
-0.04179549589753151,
0.3366550803184509,
0.04396320879459381,
-0.56833815574646,
-0.618010938167572,
-0.6163284778594971,
-0.7151936888694763,
0.3085743188858032,
-0.48679277300834656,
0.1952727884054184,
-0.3206753134727478,
-0.20345667004585266,
0.20271924138069153,
0.15967945754528046,
-0.8009666204452515,
0.4128879904747009,
0.47279053926467896,
0.6712863445281982,
-1.0394330024719238,
0.8715322613716125,
0.8935996294021606,
-0.6559069156646729,
-0.6799864172935486,
-0.23550888895988464,
-0.10307024419307709,
-0.8403813242912292,
0.7751714587211609,
0.07382413744926453,
0.31010279059410095,
-0.05124674364924431,
-0.624854326248169,
-0.7271151542663574,
1.02936851978302,
0.27263158559799194,
-0.5514335632324219,
0.11006683856248856,
0.6613564491271973,
0.5517566800117493,
-0.49693089723587036,
0.3718124032020569,
0.7532238960266113,
0.7032409310340881,
-0.08673451095819473,
-0.8829939365386963,
0.03651870787143707,
-0.008226988837122917,
0.09858345985412598,
0.19819562137126923,
-0.40527036786079407,
0.8694450855255127,
0.07537344843149185,
0.026486344635486603,
-0.06471964716911316,
0.5487635731697083,
0.23295798897743225,
0.08469945192337036,
0.4231381118297577,
0.48279184103012085,
0.8063020706176758,
-0.24050608277320862,
0.9372373819351196,
-0.17733153700828552,
0.39995837211608887,
1.0400418043136597,
-0.39054715633392334,
0.7363450527191162,
0.3970058858394623,
-0.25109994411468506,
0.15079811215400696,
0.9687585234642029,
-0.3026168644428253,
-0.005550983361899853,
0.6147757768630981,
-0.24825632572174072,
-0.10990047454833984,
-0.0803806334733963,
-0.3612608313560486,
0.3737347424030304,
0.6300336718559265,
-0.394271582365036,
-0.16906163096427917,
-0.07878275960683823,
0.265605092048645,
-0.27183905243873596,
-0.42489367723464966,
0.9077039361000061,
-0.049966517835855484,
-0.2787373661994934,
0.27880722284317017,
-0.06374102830886841,
0.43167194724082947,
-0.5553064346313477,
-0.08509533107280731,
-0.12041328847408295,
-0.2467411458492279,
-0.34224146604537964,
-1.028485655784607,
0.2060582935810089,
0.31771084666252136,
-0.1084987074136734,
-0.14772339165210724,
0.6053415536880493,
-0.5514209866523743,
-0.5258030891418457,
0.08983069658279419,
0.5625702738761902,
0.5451822280883789,
-0.04252060502767563,
-0.566170871257782,
0.39379793405532837,
-0.05641549080610275,
-0.608293354511261,
0.24131886661052704,
0.475242018699646,
-0.2885432839393616,
0.7042618989944458,
0.5979340672492981,
0.4247381091117859,
0.29311397671699524,
0.2819001376628876,
0.893713653087616,
-0.7632490396499634,
-0.11417678743600845,
-0.8398563265800476,
0.41403263807296753,
-0.05863542854785919,
-0.1466192603111267,
0.7250933647155762,
0.7122427821159363,
0.8175831437110901,
-0.0067066168412566185,
1.3627756834030151,
0.0044608949683606625,
0.7577471733093262,
-0.6894894242286682,
0.49365735054016113,
-0.2500130534172058,
0.2117968648672104,
-0.3041454255580902,
-1.2013132572174072,
-0.6590745449066162,
0.3550352454185486,
-0.6931666135787964,
0.2941914200782776,
0.3862158954143524,
0.5996893048286438,
0.13161827623844147,
0.1339244693517685,
0.23224250972270966,
0.1500503420829773,
0.5289672017097473,
0.43054813146591187,
1.0488721132278442,
-0.07833901047706604,
0.31265661120414734,
-0.19563788175582886,
-0.09555605798959732,
-0.09300902485847473,
-0.92958664894104,
-0.9184027314186096,
-0.7726208567619324,
-0.5343982577323914,
0.136525496840477,
-0.15964455902576447,
0.8454110026359558,
0.6096109747886658,
-0.7449240684509277,
-0.16631367802619934,
0.06407050043344498,
-0.26233747601509094,
0.3745405972003937,
-0.17461159825325012,
0.6478756666183472,
-0.36855608224868774,
-0.7826975584030151,
0.18718501925468445,
0.14601287245750427,
0.3131868839263916,
-0.5733304619789124,
0.10517673939466476,
0.02219863049685955,
-0.11057838797569275,
0.5907145142555237,
0.23151837289333344,
-0.6591970324516296,
-0.45912015438079834,
-0.35132989287376404,
-0.010282127186655998,
-0.08725829422473907,
0.8046026229858398,
-0.5095305442810059,
0.35211941599845886,
0.2371477484703064,
0.9314107894897461,
0.565979540348053,
-0.043386608362197876,
0.39792680740356445,
-0.7087429761886597,
-0.02853434719145298,
0.29382169246673584,
0.43191492557525635,
0.6969900131225586,
-0.29538676142692566,
0.7044455409049988,
0.13419117033481598,
-0.7991361021995544,
-1.0161205530166626,
0.23151327669620514,
-0.8411570191383362,
0.11841586977243423,
1.3873274326324463,
-0.2293616235256195,
0.02664243057370186,
-0.1877494603395462,
-0.24306875467300415,
0.15339289605617523,
-0.13352622091770172,
0.5119665265083313,
0.8443760871887207,
-0.2516458034515381,
-0.18948659300804138,
-0.9194673299789429,
0.6014350652694702,
-0.11145514994859695,
-1.1373356580734253,
0.5076982975006104,
0.7853590250015259,
0.25933972001075745,
-0.003780316561460495,
0.5732309818267822,
-0.22596265375614166,
-0.13228510320186615,
-0.17692764103412628,
0.38270553946495056,
-0.2139822542667389,
-0.09716954082250595,
-0.33454471826553345,
0.2170659303665161,
0.4404488801956177,
-0.03911531716585159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13433v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13433v2
|
Structured Tree Alignment for Evaluation of (Speech) Constituency Parsing
| 2024-02-21T00:01:17 | 2024-06-19T18:33:17 |
Freda Shi, Kevin Gimpel, Karen Livescu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DS
|
We present the structured average intersection-over-union ratio (STRUCT-IOU),
a similarity metric between constituency parse trees motivated by the problem
of evaluating speech parsers. STRUCT-IOU enables comparison between a
constituency parse tree (over automatically recognized spoken word boundaries)
with the ground-truth parse (over written words). To compute the metric, we
project the ground-truth parse tree to the speech domain by forced alignment,
align the projected ground-truth constituents with the predicted ones under
certain structured constraints, and calculate the average IOU score across all
aligned constituent pairs. STRUCT-IOU takes word boundaries into account and
overcomes the challenge that the predicted words and ground truth may not have
perfect one-to-one correspondence. Extending to the evaluation of text
constituency parsing, we demonstrate that STRUCT-IOU can address token-mismatch
issues, and shows higher tolerance to syntactically plausible parses than
PARSEVAL (Black et al., 1991).
|
[
0.07833001762628555,
-0.7890762686729431,
0.5481181740760803,
0.2971801459789276,
-0.3292776644229889,
0.09626085311174393,
0.08048036694526672,
-0.26858246326446533,
0.3956456482410431,
0.04559250548481941,
-0.3133510649204254,
-0.5148401260375977,
-0.21549491584300995,
-0.09340638667345047,
-0.35872283577919006,
0.5925195217132568,
0.22892707586288452,
0.11495793610811234,
-0.5207456946372986,
-0.3513193428516388,
-0.4530782699584961,
-0.567372739315033,
-0.28907567262649536,
-0.16370901465415955,
0.2897017002105713,
0.38971129059791565,
0.5947606563568115,
1.2903201580047607,
0.6491448879241943,
0.41967248916625977,
-0.014558166265487671,
-0.19128835201263428,
-0.44650235772132874,
-0.2559971809387207,
-0.26704004406929016,
-0.2384035438299179,
-0.7857182025909424,
0.21665164828300476,
1.239916205406189,
1.0743979215621948,
-0.47715094685554504,
-0.04959084093570709,
0.18595018982887268,
0.8003772497177124,
-0.48495402932167053,
-0.03034926950931549,
-0.8725228309631348,
-0.0022334842942655087,
-0.4601666331291199,
-0.4635332226753235,
-0.3568398356437683,
-0.5402828454971313,
-0.17543263733386993,
-0.5501337051391602,
-0.08425784856081009,
0.2737003564834595,
0.9554094076156616,
0.4160842299461365,
-0.16203105449676514,
-0.046189773827791214,
-0.2678176164627075,
0.5267357230186462,
-0.3934977650642395,
0.7584304213523865,
0.24505096673965454,
0.2888414263725281,
-0.420930951833725,
-0.6420953273773193,
-0.4607352316379547,
0.08232328295707703,
-0.2571565806865692,
0.301447331905365,
-0.31824538111686707,
0.33141028881073,
0.12370936572551727,
0.6027389764785767,
-0.7932313084602356,
-0.06753288954496384,
-0.49721837043762207,
-0.025732649490237236,
0.40173664689064026,
0.23076650500297546,
0.21246479451656342,
-0.45791494846343994,
-0.5107396841049194,
-0.015055468305945396,
-0.5240532159805298,
0.2669539153575897,
0.762096107006073,
0.27345284819602966,
-0.07180771231651306,
0.6656390428543091,
-0.13626404106616974,
0.8866077065467834,
-0.054225821048021317,
0.05445200949907303,
0.26930472254753113,
-0.4500185251235962,
-0.6524664759635925,
0.4755080044269562,
0.863088846206665,
0.4988171458244324,
0.08453691750764847,
-0.15491406619548798,
0.2741507589817047,
0.3727419674396515,
0.2506764829158783,
-0.6263943910598755,
-0.17622625827789307,
0.15480969846248627,
-0.5943866968154907,
-0.15251727402210236,
0.14091689884662628,
-0.534784734249115,
-0.0702468529343605,
-0.5629732608795166,
0.00708578759804368,
-0.5436044931411743,
-0.09115845710039139,
-0.2106774002313614,
-0.2397662103176117,
0.2507382333278656,
-0.10668960213661194,
-0.6271121501922607,
0.44971588253974915,
1.1258562803268433,
0.9340177178382874,
-0.10447509586811066,
-0.4272678792476654,
-0.885405421257019,
0.01996317133307457,
-0.3537953197956085,
0.8165565729141235,
-0.8899056315422058,
-0.21878711879253387,
-0.31954166293144226,
-0.22710050642490387,
-0.6469480395317078,
-0.5256272554397583,
0.7801276445388794,
0.22838382422924042,
0.2785941958427429,
-0.18215060234069824,
-0.6521133780479431,
0.08584166318178177,
0.37096747756004333,
-0.3031926453113556,
0.8797043561935425,
0.4454948604106903,
-0.9079340696334839,
0.5144203901290894,
-0.47342750430107117,
-0.31788378953933716,
0.08280062675476074,
-0.4625062048435211,
-0.37049782276153564,
0.19416257739067078,
-0.11830628663301468,
0.02098653092980385,
0.1284184455871582,
0.5284736156463623,
-0.373760849237442,
-0.40116795897483826,
0.14357611536979675,
-0.22120730578899384,
1.1085609197616577,
0.20738880336284637,
0.013290653936564922,
0.6318969130516052,
-0.9284318685531616,
0.28371500968933105,
-0.43297621607780457,
-0.37227383255958557,
-0.3813236355781555,
0.5347750782966614,
-0.19540315866470337,
-0.14069564640522003,
-0.037672579288482666,
-0.8454598188400269,
0.30246856808662415,
-0.7293400764465332,
0.7350180149078369,
0.7224932909011841,
-0.4223644435405731,
0.22597485780715942,
-0.25255197286605835,
0.15817011892795563,
-0.05159633979201317,
0.1486627757549286,
0.1462642103433609,
-0.43391793966293335,
-0.5629081130027771,
-0.3355955183506012,
0.5133637189865112,
0.6231368184089661,
-0.12940967082977295,
0.7558834552764893,
-0.7322692275047302,
-0.4346312880516052,
-0.9209753274917603,
-0.2545444369316101,
0.47752538323402405,
0.961260199546814,
0.3185456395149231,
-0.24160024523735046,
-0.7503210306167603,
-1.3002212047576904,
-0.3448396325111389,
-0.6576310992240906,
0.06123114377260208,
0.30373939871788025,
0.1231737732887268,
0.16266198456287384,
1.0517584085464478,
-0.175663024187088,
-0.4201188087463379,
0.1448439061641693,
0.08011243492364883,
0.07031065225601196,
0.6714191436767578,
0.2931378185749054,
-0.5481125116348267,
-0.5348200798034668,
0.24624976515769958,
-0.3886454105377197,
-0.4047483801841736,
0.19755007326602936,
-0.1358768492937088,
0.046472471207380295,
0.6378459334373474,
-0.33886340260505676,
0.41508111357688904,
0.6345177292823792,
-0.6592121720314026,
0.43175581097602844,
0.3965749740600586,
0.30708256363868713,
-1.2638893127441406,
0.3012096583843231,
-0.5051823854446411,
-0.5148088335990906,
-0.39148300886154175,
0.16414377093315125,
0.002531583420932293,
0.05014346167445183,
-0.4151942729949951,
0.08772256225347519,
-0.15047450363636017,
-0.4385610818862915,
0.1243973895907402,
0.24082420766353607,
-0.038795001804828644,
0.2974238991737366,
-0.05129793658852577,
1.0362848043441772,
0.2508569061756134,
-0.135717511177063,
0.21070191264152527,
0.32142922282218933,
-0.5519306063652039,
1.0025447607040405,
-0.5804771780967712,
0.2499321550130844,
0.10784248262643814,
0.0731109008193016,
-1.1194396018981934,
0.02371309883892536,
0.056993406265974045,
-0.6582902669906616,
0.05059192702174187,
-0.2070140391588211,
-0.07154589891433716,
-0.027060125023126602,
-0.30612269043922424,
0.6072461605072021,
0.0886412113904953,
-0.3733586072921753,
0.44257304072380066,
0.36249643564224243,
-0.1917850822210312,
-0.3997507691383362,
-0.6444498300552368,
0.16924633085727692,
-0.36610397696495056,
-0.9013129472732544,
0.4757264256477356,
0.07334727048873901,
-0.4816845655441284,
0.34775272011756897,
0.09140464663505554,
0.0825200006365776,
0.17488154768943787,
0.37334731221199036,
-0.12803514301776886,
-0.6521493792533875,
-0.2396536022424698,
-0.15949004888534546,
-0.10502329468727112,
-0.0781906321644783,
-0.17583255469799042,
0.5091777443885803,
-0.5167266726493835,
-0.44722214341163635,
-0.5220746397972107,
0.5763614773750305,
0.35832053422927856,
-0.04831906408071518,
0.38792070746421814,
-0.08319646120071411,
-0.38153645396232605,
0.4474848210811615,
-0.5106087923049927,
0.3309876024723053,
-0.39635133743286133,
0.3145529329776764,
-0.701826810836792,
-0.7497596144676208,
0.395110547542572,
0.25346654653549194,
0.17060814797878265,
0.5067569613456726,
0.248991921544075,
-0.2063785344362259,
0.949027955532074,
0.3089977502822876,
-0.21645228564739227,
0.3332384526729584,
0.1590982973575592,
0.23658879101276398,
-1.0331571102142334,
-0.12379653006792068,
-0.9825116395950317,
-0.7278133630752563,
-0.4983891248703003,
-0.19346733391284943,
0.045761317014694214,
0.4129653573036194,
0.08725324273109436,
0.45649096369743347,
-0.5134515166282654,
0.4405214190483093,
0.5494085550308228,
-0.23542116582393646,
0.22857268154621124,
0.1865682154893875,
-0.2010575234889984,
-0.23190654814243317,
-0.7300057411193848,
-0.25290974974632263,
0.4476279020309448,
0.37400826811790466,
0.1847141683101654,
0.1773587316274643,
0.41720080375671387,
-0.05418497323989868,
0.16220679879188538,
-1.0707893371582031,
0.4619743824005127,
-0.2551751732826233,
-0.14790208637714386,
-0.30675268173217773,
-0.6853102445602417,
-0.8909497261047363,
0.2807765603065491,
0.039617009460926056,
-1.0114012956619263,
0.43293124437332153,
0.12383154779672623,
-0.308163583278656,
0.25041696429252625,
-0.749322772026062,
1.0189237594604492,
0.07180831581354141,
-0.05911106616258621,
0.0011518949177116156,
-0.6255202889442444,
0.2614762485027313,
0.44260796904563904,
0.10908717662096024,
-0.047832828015089035,
0.35972580313682556,
1.0448613166809082,
-0.5747095942497253,
0.41596338152885437,
0.023123735561966896,
0.4388268291950226,
0.31465649604797363,
0.06978582590818405,
0.14051763713359833,
-0.43192151188850403,
-0.25981518626213074,
0.290809690952301,
0.07907238602638245,
-0.34669509530067444,
-0.45709753036499023,
0.6294400095939636,
-0.4992107152938843,
-0.5239743590354919,
-0.4816604554653168,
-0.5115887522697449,
-0.1102442815899849,
0.1039455309510231,
0.2580606937408447,
0.4551002085208893,
-0.6577189564704895,
0.7877719402313232,
0.03138619661331177,
0.36148589849472046,
0.5220333337783813,
0.12064602226018906,
0.10860082507133484,
-0.8175580501556396,
0.9047513604164124,
0.12286951392889023,
0.1760408878326416,
0.39966514706611633,
0.5277611017227173,
-0.4802917540073395,
-0.5724078416824341,
-0.6344532370567322,
-0.1818436086177826,
-0.23464636504650116,
-0.5303341150283813,
-0.6146842241287231,
-0.4423573613166809,
-0.4410293400287628,
-0.14969554543495178,
-0.21820497512817383,
-0.6533394455909729,
-0.07112037390470505,
-0.4276766777038574,
-0.0996309295296669,
0.4804305136203766,
0.08931783586740494,
0.7125755548477173,
-0.6334922313690186,
-0.016228174790740013,
0.16389521956443787,
0.5806971192359924,
-0.5664874911308289,
-0.4003467559814453,
0.19944444298744202,
0.037311773747205734,
-0.38202276825904846,
-1.028800368309021,
-0.1364825963973999,
0.582379937171936,
0.3283948302268982,
0.5297039747238159,
-0.14824195206165314,
1.4987785816192627,
-0.7170456647872925,
0.6190252900123596,
0.38282570242881775,
-1.1085203886032104,
0.448628693819046,
-0.26525649428367615,
0.0555177740752697,
1.064022421836853,
-0.06302651017904282,
-0.4630861282348633,
-0.44321689009666443,
-0.7769417762756348,
-0.6051289439201355,
0.6847928762435913,
0.4281672239303589,
-0.3389241695404053,
-0.018408000469207764,
0.11685803532600403,
-0.10569991171360016,
0.1282689869403839,
-0.6270682215690613,
-0.011293155141174793,
-0.3783000409603119,
-0.6042554378509521,
0.26157188415527344,
-0.34503814578056335,
-0.22660978138446808,
-0.3619978427886963,
0.46004584431648254,
-0.16508111357688904,
0.0023894815240055323,
0.39689481258392334,
0.021593404933810234,
-0.4445570409297943,
0.616825520992279,
0.6108308434486389,
0.9434846043586731,
-0.4039439260959625,
0.3545074462890625,
-0.05357793718576431,
-0.32786455750465393,
-0.03270541876554489,
0.24477460980415344,
-0.24474452435970306,
-0.10583478212356567,
0.5658815503120422,
0.9103882312774658,
0.08526674658060074,
-0.11617572605609894,
0.7163576483726501,
-0.06729692220687866,
-0.46737924218177795,
0.10370990633964539,
-0.006005981937050819,
0.22597795724868774,
-0.07146567851305008,
0.1057281643152237,
-0.08333025872707367,
0.35020720958709717,
-0.8085112571716309,
0.4227071702480316,
0.6566916704177856,
-0.6782398819923401,
-0.20010626316070557,
0.3183140456676483,
0.3584878444671631,
-0.8384990096092224,
0.74098801612854,
-0.018884992226958275,
-0.7528038620948792,
0.4686732292175293,
0.6380364298820496,
0.7832062244415283,
-0.5805208086967468,
-0.17908193171024323,
0.30611610412597656,
0.4572935700416565,
0.5504708290100098,
0.42613035440444946,
-0.06128924712538719,
-0.43592050671577454,
-0.37198883295059204,
-0.993366003036499,
-0.10618503391742706,
0.22692497074604034,
-0.6485289931297302,
0.11935357749462128,
-0.5438154935836792,
0.08799626678228378,
0.18112275004386902,
0.027472086250782013,
-0.20736181735992432,
0.19437064230442047,
-0.21805331110954285,
1.0329036712646484,
-0.9530195593833923,
0.7835679054260254,
0.7537968754768372,
0.07349102199077606,
-0.9458445906639099,
-0.28264757990837097,
-0.09375613927841187,
-0.7262482643127441,
0.1298152208328247,
0.3413230776786804,
0.022932374849915504,
0.0052995081059634686,
0.03391158953309059,
-0.47450852394104004,
0.7302189469337463,
0.595499575138092,
-0.9417911767959595,
0.11982373148202896,
0.4057646691799164,
0.3038940131664276,
-0.4032003879547119,
0.21144390106201172,
0.772382378578186,
0.4366931915283203,
0.03707444667816162,
-1.0935304164886475,
-0.04327230900526047,
-0.28464239835739136,
-0.3334658443927765,
0.619889497756958,
-0.4933379292488098,
0.7117055654525757,
0.3958476781845093,
-0.562945544719696,
-0.03519121930003166,
0.7737435102462769,
0.22209537029266357,
0.43527355790138245,
0.9270089268684387,
1.2257945537567139,
0.6841539740562439,
-0.31787168979644775,
0.6032126545906067,
-0.08207038789987564,
0.0481971800327301,
1.3625158071517944,
-0.16138474643230438,
1.121459722518921,
0.6889563202857971,
-0.37907078862190247,
0.46555575728416443,
0.5719956159591675,
0.3109178841114044,
0.20653238892555237,
0.16020512580871582,
0.17584428191184998,
-0.05274565517902374,
-0.40022480487823486,
-0.4597514867782593,
0.6831896901130676,
0.29006317257881165,
-0.04812830314040184,
-0.3418022394180298,
-0.6335011124610901,
-0.310287743806839,
0.4767245650291443,
-0.1704017072916031,
1.0318233966827393,
0.1364765167236328,
-0.7233319282531738,
0.2832299768924713,
-0.10172826051712036,
-0.053044382482767105,
-0.43993327021598816,
-0.2996661365032196,
-0.045867230743169785,
-0.04833865538239479,
-0.5431245565414429,
-0.8868256211280823,
0.8102737665176392,
-0.08569241315126419,
-0.11544854938983917,
-0.19245457649230957,
0.35999366641044617,
-0.5341328382492065,
-0.5102447867393494,
0.31558772921562195,
0.012882999144494534,
0.34988194704055786,
-0.13282036781311035,
-0.707927405834198,
0.19814231991767883,
0.08123365044593811,
0.04294653981924057,
0.021657846868038177,
0.27143824100494385,
-0.01735343411564827,
0.10743677616119385,
0.6556907296180725,
0.28392326831817627,
0.21802860498428345,
0.046543534845113754,
0.8924721479415894,
-0.6048094034194946,
-0.8195441961288452,
-1.0579994916915894,
0.6043614745140076,
-0.35972750186920166,
-0.43174847960472107,
0.4300195276737213,
1.1494539976119995,
0.7593042254447937,
0.5542027354240417,
0.35680440068244934,
-0.2556193768978119,
0.526695966720581,
-0.7065520882606506,
0.47074803709983826,
-0.6141367554664612,
-0.30180972814559937,
-0.0884573757648468,
-1.3916372060775757,
-0.054942786693573,
0.7867358326911926,
-0.19942456483840942,
-0.4914051592350006,
1.0254184007644653,
0.6121735572814941,
-0.6457329988479614,
0.03437500447034836,
0.35200682282447815,
0.3036280572414398,
0.2221854329109192,
0.48160696029663086,
0.8171346783638,
-0.3687325119972229,
0.42794737219810486,
-0.07561048120260239,
-0.3811226785182953,
-0.09776555746793747,
-1.0010250806808472,
-0.5992421507835388,
-0.7055475115776062,
-0.25854697823524475,
-0.28329235315322876,
0.1633438616991043,
0.7184224128723145,
0.7319251298904419,
-0.8214391469955444,
-0.3785214424133301,
-0.36366352438926697,
0.19389145076274872,
0.04118186607956886,
-0.29760974645614624,
0.6023274064064026,
-0.11171231418848038,
-0.5630369186401367,
0.8566061854362488,
0.4484540522098541,
-0.2233273983001709,
0.13866427540779114,
0.04052254557609558,
-0.3574294149875641,
-0.02945396676659584,
0.356441468000412,
0.1522933691740036,
-0.7202500104904175,
-0.6012083292007446,
-0.24601790308952332,
-0.29431837797164917,
0.5713878273963928,
1.0078762769699097,
-0.6663845181465149,
0.2523195147514343,
0.7935242056846619,
0.6337032318115234,
-0.09687615931034088,
0.8818395733833313,
0.5078256130218506,
-1.0622904300689697,
0.25085747241973877,
0.2879604399204254,
0.4817933142185211,
0.4226987063884735,
-0.3150331377983093,
0.6386827826499939,
0.2695693373680115,
-0.4104263484477997,
-0.9492682218551636,
0.30736562609672546,
-1.2173465490341187,
-0.08102646470069885,
0.7334344387054443,
-0.09717544168233871,
-0.5400665402412415,
-0.024974185973405838,
-0.27572688460350037,
0.18144331872463226,
-0.21994905173778534,
0.43626734614372253,
0.7329394221305847,
-0.043524157255887985,
0.0626908391714096,
-0.028860360383987427,
0.4094988703727722,
0.520017683506012,
-0.7779101133346558,
0.23008911311626434,
0.5845714807510376,
0.13708597421646118,
0.38401511311531067,
0.7873052954673767,
-0.13781267404556274,
0.1504708230495453,
0.06818249821662903,
-0.3090849220752716,
-0.09369413554668427,
-0.4658143222332001,
-0.20050504803657532,
0.22399529814720154,
-0.063705675303936,
-0.5077505111694336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13432v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13432v1
|
DrBenchmark: A Large Language Understanding Evaluation Benchmark for French Biomedical Domain
| 2024-02-20T23:54:02 | 2024-02-20T23:54:02 |
Yanis Labrak, Adrien Bazoge, Oumaima El Khettari, Mickael Rouvier, Pacome Constant dit Beaufils, Natalia Grabar, Beatrice Daille, Solen Quiniou, Emmanuel Morin, Pierre-Antoine Gourraud, Richard Dufour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The biomedical domain has sparked a significant interest in the field of
Natural Language Processing (NLP), which has seen substantial advancements with
pre-trained language models (PLMs). However, comparing these models has proven
challenging due to variations in evaluation protocols across different models.
A fair solution is to aggregate diverse downstream tasks into a benchmark,
allowing for the assessment of intrinsic PLMs qualities from various
perspectives. Although still limited to few languages, this initiative has been
undertaken in the biomedical field, notably English and Chinese. This
limitation hampers the evaluation of the latest French biomedical models, as
they are either assessed on a minimal number of tasks with non-standardized
protocols or evaluated using general downstream tasks. To bridge this research
gap and account for the unique sensitivities of French, we present the
first-ever publicly available French biomedical language understanding
benchmark called DrBenchmark. It encompasses 20 diversified tasks, including
named-entity recognition, part-of-speech tagging, question-answering, semantic
textual similarity, and classification. We evaluate 8 state-of-the-art
pre-trained masked language models (MLMs) on general and biomedical-specific
data, as well as English specific MLMs to assess their cross-lingual
capabilities. Our experiments reveal that no single model excels across all
tasks, while generalist models are sometimes still competitive.
|
[
-0.3458329439163208,
-0.6448436975479126,
0.5292794704437256,
0.427799254655838,
-0.16373543441295624,
0.2557401657104492,
-0.32022327184677124,
-0.5983338952064514,
0.07050465792417526,
0.4605545699596405,
-0.454781711101532,
-0.6701001524925232,
-0.699131965637207,
0.27688372135162354,
-0.17709629237651825,
0.6485947966575623,
-0.2001124769449234,
0.42203471064567566,
-0.28682610392570496,
-0.5845583081245422,
-0.3840477466583252,
-0.5586895942687988,
-0.6617692112922668,
-0.4820883274078369,
0.604617714881897,
-0.0030711896251887083,
0.3083703815937042,
0.5836952328681946,
0.6145092844963074,
0.2952873110771179,
-0.1803792417049408,
-0.004966213367879391,
-0.38837841153144836,
-0.08721087872982025,
-0.6426926255226135,
-0.23224130272865295,
-0.5424668192863464,
0.034459102898836136,
0.8583607077598572,
1.2326858043670654,
-0.005148366093635559,
0.10117200762033463,
0.06799521297216415,
0.7936671376228333,
-0.3809222877025604,
0.11605608463287354,
-0.341798335313797,
0.10642042756080627,
-0.13018371164798737,
0.07423735409975052,
-0.3426421582698822,
0.11511213332414627,
0.0872410461306572,
-0.18235976994037628,
0.31060510873794556,
-0.2024771124124527,
0.8359923362731934,
0.19978098571300507,
-0.40797096490859985,
0.12108052521944046,
-0.3487077057361603,
0.7007067799568176,
-0.5728632211685181,
0.7165335416793823,
0.24992777407169342,
0.5110968351364136,
-0.3275119960308075,
-1.0467041730880737,
-0.3348200023174286,
-0.3925454914569855,
-0.13535238802433014,
0.30518484115600586,
-0.41893863677978516,
0.1149510070681572,
0.05872747302055359,
0.30919110774993896,
-1.0015367269515991,
0.36422303318977356,
-0.20361872017383575,
-0.3387293517589569,
0.5105711221694946,
-0.1229594349861145,
0.4071934223175049,
-0.08895967900753021,
-0.5102078318595886,
-0.28424903750419617,
-0.27577584981918335,
0.07735282927751541,
0.02488533779978752,
0.12191826850175858,
-0.3308338224887848,
0.172921821475029,
-0.3588789403438568,
0.8447676301002502,
-0.313525915145874,
0.19949579238891602,
0.43037399649620056,
-0.34497392177581787,
-0.38308003544807434,
-0.23056071996688843,
0.8152639865875244,
0.17164911329746246,
0.1845065951347351,
-0.3442278802394867,
0.045705366879701614,
0.08703833818435669,
0.22830060124397278,
-0.8659560084342957,
-0.3832607567310333,
0.4277145564556122,
-0.4510610103607178,
0.0266589242964983,
-0.4269745945930481,
-0.7526337504386902,
-0.4228682816028595,
-0.05519651994109154,
0.09654928743839264,
-0.3495847284793854,
-0.2809545397758484,
0.337369441986084,
-0.13152159750461578,
0.0790511891245842,
0.18996712565422058,
-0.4821893870830536,
0.5324050784111023,
0.6068162322044373,
0.8131458759307861,
-0.5181096792221069,
-0.25722184777259827,
-0.8100118041038513,
-0.21583718061447144,
-0.12687279284000397,
0.8132755756378174,
-0.5047535300254822,
-0.5316118001937866,
-0.42787715792655945,
0.20153003931045532,
-0.48176345229148865,
-0.6499403715133667,
0.7503441572189331,
-0.2802370488643646,
-0.03014395944774151,
-0.062028877437114716,
-0.6470394134521484,
-0.31085291504859924,
0.07586142420768738,
-0.6438365578651428,
0.8193188309669495,
0.2500181794166565,
-0.6599778532981873,
0.3464626669883728,
-0.6292814612388611,
-0.4389033019542694,
0.3580777049064636,
-0.5564491748809814,
-0.21403123438358307,
0.1524682492017746,
0.1972741186618805,
0.3720320761203766,
-0.4981543719768524,
0.4495774507522583,
-0.3738275170326233,
-0.05125505104660988,
0.3404342532157898,
-0.3425258994102478,
0.7873780131340027,
0.09423574805259705,
-0.3785034716129303,
0.2988133132457733,
-0.810960590839386,
0.21418772637844086,
0.026877183467149734,
-0.0024892217479646206,
-0.261312872171402,
-0.11493381857872009,
0.19810886681079865,
0.4277869760990143,
0.060124095529317856,
-0.6157458424568176,
-0.1267627328634262,
-0.7100415825843811,
0.5484225749969482,
0.563175618648529,
-0.07823070138692856,
0.24965280294418335,
-0.11172240227460861,
0.5729928612709045,
-0.013744907453656197,
0.02980858087539673,
0.024019889533519745,
-0.5036159157752991,
-0.4296283721923828,
-0.8055014610290527,
0.5643385052680969,
0.574736475944519,
-0.25075116753578186,
0.42755958437919617,
-0.34814587235450745,
-0.5904856324195862,
-0.580122172832489,
0.2870887219905853,
0.4162929356098175,
0.5639234185218811,
0.590953528881073,
-0.6361963152885437,
0.006960100494325161,
-1.3191403150558472,
-0.5213873982429504,
0.007837709039449692,
-0.1778850108385086,
0.5116443037986755,
0.6709086894989014,
-0.4268471598625183,
0.6167804598808289,
-0.19112898409366608,
-0.2629079222679138,
-0.28483930230140686,
0.3352687358856201,
0.1909542679786682,
0.491115540266037,
0.7789725065231323,
-0.6450768709182739,
-0.33828383684158325,
0.15238983929157257,
-0.6837648153305054,
-0.26957938075065613,
0.13374271988868713,
-0.14996206760406494,
-0.11945980787277222,
0.48585817217826843,
-0.3939706087112427,
0.28674280643463135,
0.7895910143852234,
-0.24548883736133575,
0.3245389461517334,
-0.31571125984191895,
0.3076774775981903,
-0.7836880683898926,
0.41727325320243835,
-0.002957920078188181,
-0.5175349712371826,
-0.590040922164917,
-0.05621720105409622,
0.3385213017463684,
-0.18186232447624207,
-0.3661459982395172,
0.9871930480003357,
-0.4536985456943512,
0.0049352883361279964,
-0.29405850172042847,
0.28282830119132996,
0.119266577064991,
0.27214646339416504,
0.4743756353855133,
0.5336527228355408,
0.6128082871437073,
-0.38210877776145935,
0.2355251908302307,
0.14076711237430573,
-0.4287768304347992,
0.5399655699729919,
-0.9474541544914246,
0.12121950834989548,
-0.04847262427210808,
0.310849130153656,
-0.9612655639648438,
-0.05995483696460724,
0.09010010957717896,
-0.37638553977012634,
0.4063718616962433,
-0.03681959584355354,
-0.37703943252563477,
-0.55729079246521,
0.018836865201592445,
0.36137399077415466,
0.4394708275794983,
-0.28269287943840027,
0.4943383038043976,
0.3459145724773407,
-0.4012698531150818,
-0.6420462131500244,
-0.7652525305747986,
0.21497578918933868,
-0.025748219341039658,
-0.5908930897712708,
0.3626928925514221,
-0.03564567118883133,
-0.07319486141204834,
-0.10697849839925766,
-0.4602162837982178,
-0.24367637932300568,
0.15056349337100983,
0.05868730694055557,
-0.012655319646000862,
-0.16680283844470978,
0.2547302842140198,
0.1610730141401291,
-0.19967061281204224,
-0.06289336830377579,
-0.25458794832229614,
0.34200504422187805,
-0.023076213896274567,
-0.5142966508865356,
-0.3349819779396057,
0.3468058407306671,
0.3866511583328247,
-0.5876019597053528,
0.7652915716171265,
0.6789146661758423,
-0.33964595198631287,
-0.43265047669410706,
-0.44031548500061035,
-0.3758081793785095,
-0.41348978877067566,
0.7185818552970886,
-0.49303552508354187,
-0.9151201844215393,
0.5956540107727051,
-0.30083486437797546,
-0.008625050075352192,
0.5063914060592651,
0.5985690951347351,
0.11038230359554291,
0.8446336388587952,
0.7052453756332397,
-0.05571957677602768,
0.012936115264892578,
0.11701346933841705,
0.13844731450080872,
-0.39972609281539917,
0.16835099458694458,
-0.6581320762634277,
-0.2695222795009613,
-0.4875469505786896,
-0.9231701493263245,
0.2535523772239685,
0.2704572379589081,
0.018667934462428093,
0.2642161250114441,
-0.5002925992012024,
0.20654147863388062,
0.23106154799461365,
0.14322809875011444,
0.33968663215637207,
0.03337952867150307,
-0.4741762578487396,
-0.01193806529045105,
-0.8291490077972412,
-0.6072253584861755,
0.9193378686904907,
0.5414366126060486,
0.5289499759674072,
-0.07432122528553009,
0.5987952947616577,
0.2677324116230011,
0.4539569020271301,
-0.4913960099220276,
0.48904168605804443,
-0.3454587757587433,
-0.6434059739112854,
0.02080596797168255,
-0.7018463611602783,
-1.019365668296814,
0.40996524691581726,
-0.021537544205784798,
-0.8839781284332275,
0.348468154668808,
0.010662732645869255,
-0.18844614923000336,
0.17313769459724426,
-0.5991833806037903,
1.4442918300628662,
-0.49682387709617615,
-0.4918134808540344,
-0.3822152316570282,
-0.8602538704872131,
0.18275754153728485,
-0.2954811155796051,
0.3966439962387085,
-0.4187844395637512,
-0.12082818150520325,
0.8038759827613831,
-0.05433836951851845,
0.7183462977409363,
-0.1272341012954712,
0.06043314188718796,
-0.17782819271087646,
0.028497032821178436,
0.13707546889781952,
0.18076936900615692,
-0.16033005714416504,
0.48844853043556213,
0.24103160202503204,
-0.7222726941108704,
-0.1292034387588501,
0.8247089385986328,
-0.5666126608848572,
-0.3663214445114136,
-0.5432254076004028,
-0.5828670263290405,
-0.5601527094841003,
0.320473849773407,
0.2094353586435318,
0.3388935923576355,
-0.6280497908592224,
-0.015042716637253761,
0.5608116388320923,
-0.6972278356552124,
0.09034904837608337,
1.0391181707382202,
-0.11354850977659225,
-0.08437503129243851,
0.6055665016174316,
-0.3715599477291107,
0.3716447353363037,
0.3931281566619873,
0.002571327378973365,
-0.384439080953598,
-0.7923102378845215,
-0.6898573637008667,
0.4091227650642395,
-0.7152277827262878,
0.037284962832927704,
-0.9430656433105469,
-0.15623925626277924,
-0.2890416383743286,
0.024342719465494156,
-0.5327141284942627,
-0.2683411240577698,
0.16389434039592743,
-0.06676746904850006,
0.26354315876960754,
0.5012797713279724,
-0.19222036004066467,
-0.11459162831306458,
-1.0563617944717407,
0.5102680325508118,
0.11097612977027893,
0.6127713322639465,
-0.37348467111587524,
-0.5260618925094604,
-0.21149872243404388,
0.08807983994483948,
0.10387042909860611,
-0.8606325387954712,
0.32229113578796387,
0.3816925585269928,
1.065112590789795,
0.11633256822824478,
-0.11752734333276749,
0.24122343957424164,
-0.5418551564216614,
0.41858452558517456,
0.15067481994628906,
-0.7846121191978455,
0.36691954731941223,
-0.1890421062707901,
0.313968688249588,
0.8145137429237366,
0.350553959608078,
-0.5140562057495117,
-0.40873366594314575,
-0.4192574620246887,
-0.8871210813522339,
0.4627612233161926,
0.27960634231567383,
-0.1458803415298462,
0.11666962504386902,
0.18278935551643372,
0.2287600189447403,
0.3241712152957916,
-0.5525856018066406,
-0.4044489860534668,
0.06996913254261017,
-0.2886444926261902,
-0.4958244562149048,
0.12388967722654343,
-0.3099730610847473,
-0.2438511699438095,
0.3506810665130615,
-0.04624143987894058,
0.13828857243061066,
0.360555499792099,
-0.4161757528781891,
0.09438242018222809,
0.517585813999176,
0.3243634104728699,
0.7030847072601318,
-0.2809520959854126,
0.0060370853170752525,
0.15311716496944427,
-0.529968798160553,
0.07618679106235504,
0.7985401153564453,
0.22296445071697235,
0.12640349566936493,
0.463098406791687,
0.6160032153129578,
0.18993273377418518,
-1.0945473909378052,
0.32963255047798157,
-0.14722365140914917,
-0.2507277727127075,
0.2898964285850525,
-0.10393506288528442,
0.3403353989124298,
0.1479208916425705,
0.10126837342977524,
-0.03179759532213211,
0.2003592848777771,
-0.3637438118457794,
0.5092903971672058,
0.39037081599235535,
-0.6202460527420044,
-0.18589834868907928,
0.8481248617172241,
0.3652690052986145,
0.1439400464296341,
0.28442585468292236,
-0.2660849988460541,
-0.42753344774246216,
0.5868228077888489,
0.11975256353616714,
0.9142305254936218,
-0.3498899042606354,
0.2108113020658493,
0.3951402008533478,
0.5054941177368164,
0.09554269909858704,
0.22700487077236176,
0.05793683975934982,
-0.6155137419700623,
-0.5651986002922058,
-0.9738876819610596,
-0.4095744788646698,
0.12399081140756607,
-0.6695210337638855,
-0.013025227002799511,
-0.14414213597774506,
-0.18062260746955872,
0.5035682916641235,
-0.12339268624782562,
-0.9064265489578247,
0.29031795263290405,
0.12139850854873657,
1.1097451448440552,
-0.8098376989364624,
1.030593991279602,
0.876922070980072,
-0.18354974687099457,
-0.3628299832344055,
-0.3081643581390381,
-0.1052655279636383,
-0.7986940741539001,
0.8008604645729065,
0.2662076950073242,
-0.17321640253067017,
0.0033553442917764187,
-0.03782617300748825,
-0.3338971436023712,
0.5222768187522888,
0.4261952042579651,
-0.8748359680175781,
0.29499003291130066,
0.27251115441322327,
0.786519467830658,
-0.21877697110176086,
0.122099369764328,
0.7896006107330322,
0.5380918979644775,
-0.45399969816207886,
-1.2960340976715088,
0.06945798546075821,
-0.458075612783432,
-0.34618133306503296,
0.031696658581495285,
-0.43803420662879944,
0.6603977084159851,
0.07354873418807983,
-0.3610995411872864,
0.03987914323806763,
0.3238458037376404,
-0.019077178090810776,
0.34020158648490906,
0.422316312789917,
0.5227900147438049,
0.7869177460670471,
-0.1074543222784996,
1.094390630722046,
-0.40732473134994507,
0.2327486127614975,
1.09864342212677,
-0.6240845322608948,
0.7558128833770752,
0.20495600998401642,
-0.46363675594329834,
0.4983568489551544,
0.5950194001197815,
0.11978074908256531,
0.3051193952560425,
0.44530802965164185,
-0.25518500804901123,
-0.3109828531742096,
-0.07470820099115372,
-0.5799660682678223,
0.3920143246650696,
0.47249752283096313,
-0.29217055439949036,
-0.35330942273139954,
0.24410974979400635,
-0.20771653950214386,
0.36817169189453125,
-0.20497159659862518,
0.7558632493019104,
0.38405895233154297,
-0.37685689330101013,
0.7521891593933105,
0.02458990551531315,
0.36254456639289856,
-0.8365743160247803,
0.173492431640625,
-0.1130729615688324,
0.30539849400520325,
0.048765629529953,
-0.6221354007720947,
0.07362622022628784,
0.03621149808168411,
-0.11040638387203217,
-0.10434651374816895,
0.7006025910377502,
-0.4184604287147522,
-0.5154572129249573,
0.9074395895004272,
0.8435881733894348,
0.14728130400180817,
-0.23862266540527344,
-1.094415307044983,
0.03559834882616997,
-0.1718226671218872,
-0.20480187237262726,
0.5089901089668274,
0.17296989262104034,
0.07569177448749542,
0.6036171317100525,
0.34984445571899414,
0.17364946007728577,
-0.17049512267112732,
0.3394486606121063,
0.7239373922348022,
-0.7874769568443298,
-0.4713533818721771,
-0.6786984801292419,
0.2749841511249542,
-0.3299238979816437,
-0.05001800134778023,
0.7656555771827698,
0.5425646305084229,
0.5427446365356445,
0.039066117256879807,
0.8727920651435852,
0.2724788188934326,
0.8152545094490051,
-0.2038988471031189,
0.7352862358093262,
-0.7245833873748779,
-0.0031972175929695368,
-0.0981825739145279,
-0.6705028414726257,
-0.27526208758354187,
0.5733595490455627,
-0.3724267780780792,
0.20097605884075165,
0.9742730855941772,
0.6025285124778748,
-0.16165785491466522,
-0.06240605190396309,
0.3238805830478668,
0.25677919387817383,
0.10190276056528091,
0.7155150771141052,
0.33470648527145386,
-0.08485889434814453,
0.23502352833747864,
-0.3292379081249237,
-0.5429256558418274,
-0.0959119126200676,
-0.9194345474243164,
-1.0898418426513672,
-0.29173949360847473,
-0.44231364130973816,
-0.32532739639282227,
0.2155732810497284,
0.6697285771369934,
0.7078526020050049,
-1.152571201324463,
-0.21668289601802826,
-0.1627577394247055,
-0.12718047201633453,
-0.5117837190628052,
-0.15386296808719635,
0.5967219471931458,
-0.2783823311328888,
-0.7377300262451172,
0.7167843580245972,
0.6651906371116638,
-0.08634817600250244,
-0.08765590190887451,
0.17910853028297424,
-0.1877221316099167,
0.07737495005130768,
0.4306336045265198,
0.5194103121757507,
-0.5209453701972961,
0.08099347352981567,
0.10396821796894073,
-0.38669267296791077,
0.04151814803481102,
0.6994919776916504,
-0.7792990803718567,
0.8172730207443237,
0.4864533841609955,
0.7918857336044312,
0.5959627628326416,
-0.12480893731117249,
0.8311600089073181,
-0.4766090512275696,
0.4629543125629425,
0.403947651386261,
0.38467538356781006,
0.46901705861091614,
0.15400241315364838,
0.6190824508666992,
0.22997120022773743,
-0.5282935500144958,
-0.8402794003486633,
0.2242404818534851,
-1.1754108667373657,
-0.5367316007614136,
0.7302609086036682,
-0.2499558925628662,
-0.13779932260513306,
-0.3569154143333435,
-0.024534258991479874,
0.23929975926876068,
-0.11100797355175018,
0.44982096552848816,
0.5653038024902344,
-0.08544697612524033,
0.09351573139429092,
-1.0456931591033936,
0.573379397392273,
0.8311752080917358,
-0.7796793580055237,
0.13671240210533142,
0.32638126611709595,
0.28653326630592346,
-0.2229941338300705,
0.7216868996620178,
-0.14221350848674774,
0.3393576741218567,
-0.09509192407131195,
0.1577557474374771,
0.25103968381881714,
-0.007169393356889486,
-0.445703387260437,
-0.07877565175294876,
0.041563861072063446,
-0.07671861350536346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13426v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13426v1
|
Explaining Relationships Among Research Papers
| 2024-02-20T23:38:39 | 2024-02-20T23:38:39 |
Xiangci Li, Jessica Ouyang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Due to the rapid pace of research publications, keeping up to date with all
the latest related papers is very time-consuming, even with daily feed tools.
There is a need for automatically generated, short, customized literature
reviews of sets of papers to help researchers decide what to read. While
several works in the last decade have addressed the task of explaining a single
research paper, usually in the context of another paper citing it, the
relationship among multiple papers has been ignored; prior works have focused
on generating a single citation sentence in isolation, without addressing the
expository and transition sentences needed to connect multiple papers in a
coherent story. In this work, we explore a feature-based, LLM-prompting
approach to generate richer citation texts, as well as generating multiple
citations at once to capture the complex relationships among research papers.
We perform an expert evaluation to investigate the impact of our proposed
features on the quality of the generated paragraphs and find a strong
correlation between human preference and integrative writing style, suggesting
that humans prefer high-level, abstract citations, with transition sentences
between them to provide an overall story.
|
[
-0.6116597652435303,
-0.5104997754096985,
0.8912071585655212,
0.4482862651348114,
-0.20328226685523987,
0.05531453341245651,
0.10036055743694305,
-0.6402581930160522,
0.34804409742355347,
0.0794307217001915,
-0.5346530675888062,
-0.15245716273784637,
-0.19028343260288239,
0.5292506217956543,
-0.21980534493923187,
1.0880306959152222,
-0.15316720306873322,
-0.11113762110471725,
-0.4936617910861969,
-0.028126416727900505,
-0.30169248580932617,
-0.18514367938041687,
-0.30900585651397705,
-0.7829242944717407,
1.161920428276062,
0.26022034883499146,
0.6344679594039917,
0.4063030183315277,
0.6058981418609619,
0.16331633925437927,
-0.2020377516746521,
0.4347577691078186,
-0.2850172519683838,
0.5330378413200378,
-0.25975263118743896,
-0.16536159813404083,
-0.24487921595573425,
-0.10724163055419922,
0.30093953013420105,
0.6723189353942871,
0.7069162726402283,
0.31323766708374023,
0.49445196986198425,
0.6745454668998718,
-0.22572770714759827,
-0.08487439155578613,
-0.5126113295555115,
-0.018021132797002792,
-0.16498464345932007,
-0.7775627970695496,
-0.31067875027656555,
-0.5729736089706421,
0.1985875964164734,
-0.5576444268226624,
0.27386388182640076,
0.14148187637329102,
1.013390064239502,
-0.27164342999458313,
-0.4613751173019409,
-0.6500675082206726,
-0.6135023832321167,
0.2449956089258194,
-0.2796335220336914,
-0.17675919830799103,
-0.020962495356798172,
-0.04000367969274521,
-0.0681343749165535,
-0.5609228014945984,
-0.4274245500564575,
-0.31990179419517517,
-0.5632394552230835,
0.15041415393352509,
0.01635904796421528,
-0.2558169364929199,
-0.058538828045129776,
0.14963965117931366,
-0.5353862643241882,
-0.3302890360355377,
-0.11830344051122665,
0.24856320023536682,
0.5403347611427307,
0.20846791565418243,
0.06637464463710785,
-0.3580268323421478,
-0.376199334859848,
0.03566330671310425,
-0.6413930058479309,
0.039235007017850876,
0.5049475431442261,
0.4167906939983368,
0.21287664771080017,
0.4085957109928131,
0.39584773778915405,
0.33226194977760315,
-0.044504277408123016,
-0.13057714700698853,
0.11209406703710556,
-0.6249291896820068,
0.03238831087946892,
-0.07929082959890366,
0.9214048981666565,
0.3713274896144867,
0.22870862483978271,
-0.3289753198623657,
0.20057834684848785,
-0.27392691373825073,
0.2114216387271881,
-0.676773726940155,
0.13026359677314758,
0.14325930178165436,
-0.7826181650161743,
-0.44824928045272827,
0.2478073686361313,
-0.6255008578300476,
-0.3911665081977844,
-0.3655564785003662,
0.3342490494251251,
-0.45413413643836975,
-0.1904354989528656,
-0.20880696177482605,
-0.2432328313589096,
0.12266942113637924,
0.30343443155288696,
-0.6625232100486755,
-0.08740480989217758,
0.4230571389198303,
1.0223866701126099,
-0.1548345535993576,
-0.4505869448184967,
-0.278509259223938,
0.4187084436416626,
-0.049600016325712204,
1.037352442741394,
-0.6035838723182678,
-0.5362045764923096,
-0.0007532087620347738,
-0.38111552596092224,
-0.14817991852760315,
-0.27421364188194275,
0.6640308499336243,
-0.36153432726860046,
0.27194109559059143,
-0.5628469586372375,
-0.28667381405830383,
0.006369690410792828,
0.2951882481575012,
-0.47571468353271484,
0.9866048693656921,
-0.04715820029377937,
-1.2629390954971313,
0.23905876278877258,
-0.8871166706085205,
-0.6121625304222107,
-0.08091090619564056,
-0.07814302295446396,
-0.5238652229309082,
0.09450238198041916,
0.3603067696094513,
0.3282167315483093,
-0.2939388155937195,
0.3867572546005249,
-0.6049154996871948,
-0.08172933012247086,
0.5633912086486816,
0.08048555254936218,
0.7850221991539001,
0.5219205617904663,
-0.029816055670380592,
0.32565736770629883,
-0.6277108192443848,
-0.22332292795181274,
-0.04688384756445885,
-0.24463623762130737,
-0.5331127047538757,
-0.21621914207935333,
0.03744928166270256,
0.06556162238121033,
0.19006478786468506,
-0.17103247344493866,
0.0972464308142662,
0.14889474213123322,
0.45646339654922485,
0.32174742221832275,
0.5538063049316406,
0.43830186128616333,
-0.6856740713119507,
0.7017219662666321,
-0.07535902410745621,
-0.02712060697376728,
-0.929553210735321,
-0.1783219873905182,
-0.5105850100517273,
0.09262628108263016,
0.08122128248214722,
0.2637740671634674,
-0.14148269593715668,
0.5145145058631897,
-0.2435845285654068,
-0.0830799862742424,
-0.2881803810596466,
0.21033936738967896,
0.32313063740730286,
0.6237943768501282,
0.25864773988723755,
0.04617379978299141,
-0.52422034740448,
-0.8077846169471741,
-0.4169556796550751,
-0.3710888624191284,
-0.006685283035039902,
0.22632130980491638,
0.5729700326919556,
0.11433099955320358,
1.22494375705719,
-0.435751348733902,
-0.180715411901474,
-0.2734715938568115,
0.48230454325675964,
-0.09148948639631271,
0.33345961570739746,
0.6448987722396851,
-0.494754433631897,
-0.558134913444519,
0.057983722537755966,
-0.7316004037857056,
-0.22944724559783936,
-0.58465576171875,
-0.4598575532436371,
-0.30420398712158203,
0.6068305373191833,
-0.34703412652015686,
0.13515323400497437,
-0.11201203614473343,
-0.2546555995941162,
0.5770606398582458,
-0.11413491517305374,
0.21482940018177032,
-1.0748363733291626,
0.3680587708950043,
0.2111320048570633,
0.15714871883392334,
-0.2853242754936218,
0.09728052467107773,
0.029682816937565804,
-0.1292831152677536,
0.15099704265594482,
0.38738730549812317,
-0.7882266044616699,
-0.08086681365966797,
0.0024666213430464268,
0.19252339005470276,
0.585643470287323,
0.1218271553516388,
-0.2083137035369873,
0.5746496319770813,
0.0602007657289505,
-0.3347121775150299,
-0.23047025501728058,
0.49543479084968567,
0.15492239594459534,
0.5372779369354248,
-0.47209569811820984,
-0.05275681987404823,
-0.15483011305332184,
0.29136571288108826,
-1.086988091468811,
-0.2211824655532837,
-0.18321116268634796,
-0.6217280030250549,
0.031190648674964905,
-0.18885940313339233,
-0.6786437034606934,
-0.14522475004196167,
-0.649925708770752,
-0.043681319802999496,
0.017337923869490623,
-0.5362394452095032,
0.5251105427742004,
-0.0013478699838742614,
-0.4911847412586212,
-0.32497137784957886,
-0.4760207235813141,
0.40326127409935,
-0.4837130308151245,
-1.0201472043991089,
0.4574967622756958,
-0.13529713451862335,
-0.5880700945854187,
0.1551019549369812,
0.12686528265476227,
-0.10237205028533936,
0.0671716034412384,
0.3366062343120575,
0.2474256455898285,
-0.26271581649780273,
0.549834132194519,
0.2498694360256195,
0.1261781007051468,
0.11263174563646317,
0.09990489482879639,
0.17935049533843994,
-0.07235681265592575,
-0.11769682914018631,
-0.026588331907987595,
0.7379013299942017,
0.7329911589622498,
-0.2386893779039383,
0.46319082379341125,
0.8512621521949768,
0.24289707839488983,
0.04662207141518593,
-0.31467685103416443,
-0.17187421023845673,
-0.3337809443473816,
-0.09150125086307526,
-0.7021124958992004,
-0.8688027262687683,
0.7174214720726013,
-0.10965152084827423,
0.16488765180110931,
0.21648387610912323,
0.3646561801433563,
-0.27612239122390747,
0.7000422477722168,
0.5652854442596436,
0.21484814584255219,
0.49653759598731995,
0.1554189771413803,
0.3614892065525055,
-0.7504698634147644,
-0.497392475605011,
-0.7888622879981995,
-0.2824975848197937,
-0.26881134510040283,
-0.0978546068072319,
0.5996447205543518,
0.43415912985801697,
-0.18092483282089233,
0.018455946817994118,
-0.6422470211982727,
0.3500377833843231,
0.5431813597679138,
0.01828073337674141,
0.5679059028625488,
0.21179327368736267,
-0.33023151755332947,
-0.10874853283166885,
-0.38968420028686523,
-0.8789160251617432,
0.6692532300949097,
0.34500327706336975,
0.9913566708564758,
-0.08468359708786011,
1.1610716581344604,
0.08128119260072708,
0.12082209438085556,
-0.5606462359428406,
0.29491785168647766,
0.2626726031303406,
-0.4737522602081299,
-0.09762539714574814,
-0.08823391795158386,
-1.2753435373306274,
0.3726830780506134,
-0.4910382032394409,
-0.3807651400566101,
0.26469647884368896,
0.12045057862997055,
-0.41983726620674133,
0.015067663043737411,
-0.5001911520957947,
0.3999045789241791,
-0.40082523226737976,
-0.7267284989356995,
-0.1265464574098587,
-0.6049489378929138,
0.5052209496498108,
0.2062523514032364,
0.12653136253356934,
-0.1324061155319214,
0.07303740829229355,
0.361159086227417,
-0.3450911343097687,
0.5020626783370972,
0.16724467277526855,
0.128810316324234,
0.282524436712265,
0.3123389184474945,
0.24699026346206665,
0.3557828962802887,
-0.2668270468711853,
-0.5273635983467102,
-0.2938450276851654,
-0.03639935329556465,
-0.38738134503364563,
0.7725019454956055,
-0.4373038709163666,
-0.40166887640953064,
-0.37030738592147827,
-0.6980563998222351,
-0.3056472837924957,
0.13048720359802246,
0.0072025395929813385,
0.2694927453994751,
-0.27204522490501404,
-0.04702240973711014,
0.6312034726142883,
-0.04833972454071045,
0.7700729966163635,
0.2222270518541336,
-0.40925678610801697,
-0.39709362387657166,
0.40721675753593445,
-0.1696784347295761,
-0.08850967884063721,
0.4455870985984802,
0.2824433147907257,
-0.27123069763183594,
-0.7037284970283508,
-0.25220730900764465,
0.4923260807991028,
-0.43749821186065674,
-0.2432641088962555,
-1.0632179975509644,
-0.07091516256332397,
-0.5881606340408325,
-0.46782591938972473,
0.3516481816768646,
-0.40676113963127136,
-0.6556317806243896,
-0.20407894253730774,
0.5803151726722717,
0.8404968976974487,
-0.08371766656637192,
0.16225799918174744,
-0.8011009693145752,
0.2665335237979889,
0.3678742051124573,
0.07598177343606949,
0.4092211425304413,
-0.36079633235931396,
-0.2025173157453537,
-0.6824241876602173,
-0.5408985018730164,
-0.9610477685928345,
0.5271580815315247,
0.14196963608264923,
0.4458625912666321,
0.3457581102848053,
-0.021069306880235672,
0.9153155088424683,
-0.4812377989292145,
0.5435447692871094,
0.3629077970981598,
-0.6266802549362183,
0.5746239423751831,
-0.5901860594749451,
0.29949769377708435,
0.7072108387947083,
0.5256502628326416,
-0.1458020806312561,
-0.39686688780784607,
-0.5012670755386353,
-1.019496202468872,
0.2651452124118805,
0.2923792898654938,
0.04183085635304451,
0.07332857698202133,
0.3869209587574005,
0.4511750042438507,
0.10744250565767288,
-0.9060099720954895,
-0.1767505705356598,
-0.139633446931839,
-0.11088515818119049,
0.3849523663520813,
-0.3887045681476593,
-0.43882933259010315,
-0.07309824228286743,
0.4446646571159363,
-0.18335483968257904,
0.12979981303215027,
0.38846805691719055,
-0.1718870848417282,
-0.19258877635002136,
0.6262825727462769,
0.625446617603302,
1.2003141641616821,
-0.3707423806190491,
0.4257947504520416,
-0.48988640308380127,
-0.04369238391518593,
-0.06923246383666992,
0.2869277596473694,
-0.4132178723812103,
0.46429264545440674,
0.6134060025215149,
0.4528844952583313,
0.0011468996526673436,
0.05337855592370033,
0.17712782323360443,
-0.04139077290892601,
-0.3775060772895813,
-0.10802401602268219,
-0.10030011087656021,
0.6239817142486572,
0.27180540561676025,
0.7884122133255005,
0.11744778603315353,
0.1769937127828598,
-0.6692202091217041,
0.11641627550125122,
0.47007670998573303,
-0.16907720267772675,
-0.2553696930408478,
0.560030996799469,
0.5905858874320984,
-0.09495996683835983,
-0.12197455763816833,
-0.1804407835006714,
-0.20285585522651672,
0.41381922364234924,
0.3750235140323639,
0.9000322818756104,
0.3999313414096832,
0.373238742351532,
0.6578283309936523,
0.2585001587867737,
0.028901223093271255,
0.07088647782802582,
-0.17390204966068268,
-0.29288196563720703,
-0.4002256989479065,
-0.7879452109336853,
-0.409475713968277,
0.37706229090690613,
-0.7193623185157776,
0.3281724154949188,
-0.22198231518268585,
-0.11026429384946823,
0.39733466506004333,
-0.10481781512498856,
-0.3138236701488495,
-0.23593492805957794,
0.07792920619249344,
0.7407028079032898,
-0.9329517483711243,
0.7727553248405457,
0.7277631759643555,
-0.8235005140304565,
-0.5956375598907471,
0.21797087788581848,
-0.084554024040699,
-0.3396587669849396,
0.6623334884643555,
0.11559907346963882,
-0.3096521198749542,
-0.4051065742969513,
-0.41391175985336304,
-0.7541881799697876,
1.0086532831192017,
0.41911542415618896,
-0.561633288860321,
-0.15491288900375366,
-0.24247129261493683,
0.6419954299926758,
-0.8774619698524475,
0.4177019000053406,
0.2784506380558014,
0.7049160599708557,
0.09424516558647156,
-0.7002726793289185,
0.08283554762601852,
-0.3373125195503235,
0.0973469540476799,
-0.0051496559754014015,
-0.42753398418426514,
0.7749329209327698,
-0.3198449909687042,
-0.10252103954553604,
-0.10014238953590393,
0.6889097690582275,
0.4641200602054596,
0.6595942378044128,
0.43108683824539185,
0.09359787404537201,
0.5898404717445374,
0.3254823088645935,
0.6511396169662476,
-0.2722553610801697,
0.029210776090621948,
1.5607925653457642,
-0.3289104700088501,
0.42272213101387024,
0.6701308488845825,
-0.2930449843406677,
0.8768506050109863,
0.6973047852516174,
0.043030548840761185,
0.31439507007598877,
0.04703730717301369,
-0.3079192042350769,
-0.19633860886096954,
-0.06145644560456276,
-0.529610276222229,
-0.05768913775682449,
0.19654050469398499,
-0.9263149499893188,
-0.43810024857521057,
-0.061703942716121674,
0.2774837613105774,
0.41815537214279175,
-0.07254704087972641,
0.6174788475036621,
0.20682407915592194,
-0.9264581203460693,
0.2113122195005417,
-0.449775755405426,
0.6575039625167847,
-0.6541286706924438,
-0.009737099520862103,
-0.3047226667404175,
-0.2606222331523895,
-0.49942320585250854,
-1.0536373853683472,
0.16258502006530762,
0.09192004054784775,
-0.7214971780776978,
-0.5945835113525391,
0.7595070600509644,
-0.5101378560066223,
-0.35772505402565,
0.3036150634288788,
0.815632164478302,
0.03718351572751999,
0.2944258749485016,
-0.7310531735420227,
0.1807849407196045,
0.039184100925922394,
-0.2614401876926422,
0.41360506415367126,
0.617822527885437,
-0.08380328118801117,
0.4065200686454773,
0.5791518092155457,
-0.025525404140353203,
-0.010960387997329235,
0.28483203053474426,
0.8183853626251221,
-0.6059949994087219,
-0.49344751238822937,
-0.7493771314620972,
0.3945050835609436,
-0.35042738914489746,
-0.35665053129196167,
0.7513648271560669,
0.5469820499420166,
0.23338888585567474,
-0.048639338463544846,
1.1170841455459595,
-0.20703013241291046,
0.6983787417411804,
-0.13689137995243073,
0.48053401708602905,
-0.31980377435684204,
0.424513041973114,
-0.22316575050354004,
-0.8955613970756531,
-0.34111103415489197,
0.5302600860595703,
0.07079930603504181,
-0.05184575542807579,
1.0955685377120972,
0.5443483591079712,
-0.16693688929080963,
-0.2018692046403885,
-0.028539499267935753,
-0.0315612368285656,
0.3657124936580658,
0.1273895651102066,
0.7088342905044556,
0.20457696914672852,
1.0736098289489746,
0.0114438496530056,
0.1472650021314621,
-0.37136849761009216,
-1.291345477104187,
-0.9431328773498535,
-0.6681025624275208,
-0.5049282312393188,
-0.6129769086837769,
-0.03574877232313156,
0.5317339301109314,
0.4506901204586029,
-0.4990622401237488,
-0.36225298047065735,
-0.1287190020084381,
0.2687322795391083,
-0.0711045041680336,
-0.31412526965141296,
0.38833168148994446,
-0.8053076267242432,
-0.40718433260917664,
0.16774344444274902,
0.5523176193237305,
-0.0669911727309227,
-0.5118097066879272,
-0.03555915504693985,
-0.33452528715133667,
0.11920254677534103,
0.4556875228881836,
0.1782965213060379,
-0.4686098098754883,
-0.030838804319500923,
-0.16657625138759613,
-0.25085148215293884,
0.29811444878578186,
1.4583191871643066,
-0.5719307661056519,
0.4179980456829071,
0.8754620552062988,
0.23962707817554474,
0.8113750219345093,
-0.020979618653655052,
0.5808401107788086,
-0.4657745957374573,
-0.4437185823917389,
0.2635296583175659,
0.3380516767501831,
0.5618603825569153,
-0.440073698759079,
0.7335671186447144,
-0.04497852921485901,
-0.7163612842559814,
-0.8259447813034058,
0.18080094456672668,
-1.0697517395019531,
-0.4906706213951111,
0.910426139831543,
-0.4340810775756836,
-0.05485568195581436,
-0.38011226058006287,
-0.14743950963020325,
0.06470055133104324,
-0.5176724791526794,
0.8846595287322998,
0.6078696846961975,
-0.9782100915908813,
-0.22932928800582886,
-0.0808572992682457,
0.40821918845176697,
0.16120968759059906,
-0.9806478023529053,
0.06786109507083893,
0.41421544551849365,
0.24520531296730042,
0.4593520760536194,
0.37107017636299133,
-0.14864657819271088,
0.13951662182807922,
-0.012408843263983727,
-0.007731686346232891,
-0.3282678425312042,
-0.01908719167113304,
-0.14448139071464539,
0.6026626825332642,
0.23916329443454742,
0.28827399015426636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13415v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13415v1
|
Structure Guided Prompt: Instructing Large Language Model in Multi-Step Reasoning by Exploring Graph Structure of the Text
| 2024-02-20T22:56:23 | 2024-02-20T22:56:23 |
Kewei Cheng, Nesreen K. Ahmed, Theodore Willke, Yizhou Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Although Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at addressing straightforward
reasoning tasks, they frequently struggle with difficulties when confronted by
more complex multi-step reasoning due to a range of factors. Firstly, natural
language often encompasses complex relationships among entities, making it
challenging to maintain a clear reasoning chain over longer spans. Secondly,
the abundance of linguistic diversity means that the same entities and
relationships can be expressed using different terminologies and structures,
complicating the task of identifying and establishing connections between
multiple pieces of information. Graphs provide an effective solution to
represent data rich in relational information and capture long-term
dependencies among entities. To harness the potential of graphs, our paper
introduces Structure Guided Prompt, an innovative three-stage task-agnostic
prompting framework designed to improve the multi-step reasoning capabilities
of LLMs in a zero-shot setting. This framework explicitly converts unstructured
text into a graph via LLMs and instructs them to navigate this graph using
task-specific strategies to formulate responses. By effectively organizing
information and guiding navigation, it enables LLMs to provide more accurate
and context-aware responses. Our experiments show that this framework
significantly enhances the reasoning capabilities of LLMs, enabling them to
excel in a broader spectrum of natural language scenarios.
|
[
-0.017499107867479324,
-1.2264060974121094,
1.2296026945114136,
0.3036222457885742,
-0.20317599177360535,
0.19709599018096924,
0.1815747767686844,
-0.18660493195056915,
-0.08813179284334183,
0.39435192942619324,
-0.7427564859390259,
-0.8409052491188049,
-0.41732773184776306,
0.3817828297615051,
-0.28542113304138184,
0.8004911541938782,
-0.18811951577663422,
0.05968005582690239,
-0.13966239988803864,
0.10922019928693771,
-0.6863179206848145,
-0.28075939416885376,
-0.8526340126991272,
-0.5149444341659546,
0.8094760775566101,
0.38112303614616394,
0.5214723348617554,
0.6950867176055908,
-0.06703764200210571,
0.24849750101566315,
-0.4793429672718048,
0.21455341577529907,
-0.16482526063919067,
0.5958244204521179,
-0.03794066607952118,
-0.4090946316719055,
-0.3028286099433899,
-0.25340500473976135,
0.6474210023880005,
1.1400271654129028,
0.06926229596138,
-0.06231790408492088,
0.306458443403244,
0.5756970643997192,
-0.30195483565330505,
0.55928635597229,
-0.3546494245529175,
-0.14302673935890198,
-0.17532393336296082,
-0.35143160820007324,
-0.6740735769271851,
-0.15040987730026245,
-0.08156884461641312,
-0.6090119481086731,
-0.00042766332626342773,
0.23075726628303528,
0.4954471290111542,
0.2368772178888321,
-0.8407649993896484,
-0.47327539324760437,
-0.43703362345695496,
0.3499411940574646,
-0.3778432309627533,
0.4077628254890442,
0.10733770579099655,
0.15837086737155914,
-0.6395610570907593,
-0.5603179931640625,
-0.3911578357219696,
-0.3622935712337494,
0.02314111776649952,
-0.1735731065273285,
0.0434863343834877,
0.17752757668495178,
0.4493890702724457,
-0.014590198174118996,
-0.696499228477478,
0.08858101814985275,
0.025196563452482224,
-0.19086168706417084,
0.13059823215007782,
0.33372801542282104,
0.4267975389957428,
-0.5285109281539917,
-0.2653038501739502,
-0.018732190132141113,
-0.8778786063194275,
0.26164448261260986,
0.24389490485191345,
0.8099485635757446,
-0.03623979911208153,
0.6789623498916626,
-0.24643516540527344,
1.1000019311904907,
0.09915056079626083,
-0.22121934592723846,
0.11838345974683762,
-0.45312824845314026,
-0.12623384594917297,
0.38058531284332275,
0.687698245048523,
0.24137920141220093,
0.2425890415906906,
0.12329539656639099,
0.001699375919997692,
0.027839774265885353,
-0.03495915234088898,
-0.8986583948135376,
-0.08880581706762314,
0.4061245322227478,
-0.3354973793029785,
-0.0344703309237957,
-0.3870949447154999,
-0.6934312582015991,
-0.5786948800086975,
-0.29723110795021057,
0.09433382749557495,
-0.6662738919258118,
0.14594967663288116,
0.28706106543540955,
-0.06775427609682083,
0.13088054955005646,
0.777441143989563,
-0.7822662591934204,
-0.04703914374113083,
0.601384162902832,
1.0591542720794678,
0.11654750257730484,
-0.25216859579086304,
-0.9142200350761414,
0.5274902582168579,
-0.28693562746047974,
0.9925345778465271,
-0.8161078691482544,
-0.6226562857627869,
0.04002172872424126,
0.08746929466724396,
-0.09817517548799515,
-0.016220634803175926,
0.730333685874939,
-0.32894179224967957,
0.3179378807544708,
-0.3688792884349823,
-0.5737139582633972,
-0.24234667420387268,
0.6629701256752014,
-0.6100431084632874,
1.119801640510559,
-0.02414119616150856,
-0.7362332344055176,
0.13408103585243225,
-0.8127651810646057,
-0.595056414604187,
0.26819908618927,
-0.3566535413265228,
-0.013430890627205372,
-0.1539653241634369,
0.6206263899803162,
0.5189679265022278,
-0.12962393462657928,
0.21030189096927643,
-0.3264036178588867,
-0.22830934822559357,
-0.2858527600765228,
-0.2868448495864868,
0.8646667003631592,
0.011430652812123299,
-0.19040116667747498,
0.5598068237304688,
-0.8384789228439331,
-0.06190494820475578,
0.1335965096950531,
-0.5682440996170044,
-0.42702963948249817,
0.04843978211283684,
-0.39514800906181335,
0.18354302644729614,
0.06710988283157349,
-0.4914282560348511,
0.5637445449829102,
-0.4520031809806824,
0.4606969952583313,
0.6708044409751892,
0.25377407670021057,
0.5453079342842102,
0.009623900055885315,
0.643366277217865,
0.1190117821097374,
0.030978595837950706,
-0.8599477410316467,
-0.770906388759613,
-0.36785686016082764,
-0.15379956364631653,
-0.09651435911655426,
0.6593509912490845,
-0.944341778755188,
0.27284902334213257,
-0.02900504320859909,
-0.25221309065818787,
-0.13936841487884521,
0.0798141211271286,
0.233644038438797,
0.9489266276359558,
0.44557642936706543,
0.24442346394062042,
-0.36181357502937317,
-0.48676055669784546,
-0.1786518394947052,
-0.28795987367630005,
-0.04590696468949318,
0.20537090301513672,
0.4971047043800354,
-0.15390001237392426,
0.7354250550270081,
-0.7044073343276978,
-0.013951417058706284,
-0.46574103832244873,
0.1959303468465805,
0.45291954278945923,
0.13007348775863647,
0.30054783821105957,
-0.5239627957344055,
-0.3932025134563446,
-0.16206607222557068,
-0.6872482895851135,
-0.15511451661586761,
-0.27066245675086975,
-0.28336212038993835,
-0.06610064208507538,
0.6154617667198181,
-0.823976457118988,
0.2265499234199524,
0.3479466736316681,
-0.6540582776069641,
0.5929909348487854,
-0.1169361025094986,
0.1884535253047943,
-1.208921194076538,
-0.12217938899993896,
0.0753595232963562,
-0.1431734412908554,
-0.6589638590812683,
-0.1077468991279602,
0.14169441163539886,
-0.18687044084072113,
-0.20261648297309875,
0.7476500272750854,
-0.6473053693771362,
0.14404185116291046,
-0.10683510452508926,
0.3255283534526825,
0.2776222229003906,
0.4584926962852478,
-0.10812842845916748,
0.6516963839530945,
0.7335091233253479,
-0.7376964688301086,
0.27485740184783936,
0.6077821254730225,
-0.2543078362941742,
0.8944242000579834,
-0.6366220712661743,
0.09134715050458908,
-0.43121451139450073,
0.6083648204803467,
-1.1916695833206177,
-0.32050082087516785,
0.44501858949661255,
-0.4242158830165863,
0.20887647569179535,
-0.19187462329864502,
-0.6314986944198608,
-0.4787154793739319,
-0.21445046365261078,
0.22587767243385315,
-0.018930040299892426,
-0.45149630308151245,
0.7366819381713867,
-0.12505562603473663,
-0.32035133242607117,
-0.571946918964386,
-0.4560184180736542,
0.2792392671108246,
-0.05872190743684769,
-0.6789068579673767,
0.22537240386009216,
-0.3993285596370697,
-0.18849559128284454,
-0.11201000213623047,
-0.14673741161823273,
0.10159123688936234,
0.11531152576208115,
0.42644238471984863,
0.33573824167251587,
-0.15756195783615112,
0.29475969076156616,
0.13955049216747284,
-0.03193135932087898,
0.1515381783246994,
-0.48902782797813416,
0.6660603880882263,
-0.023651549592614174,
-0.6769858598709106,
-0.3038380444049835,
0.4630633592605591,
0.5511852502822876,
-0.19642136991024017,
0.5751948952674866,
0.2996470630168915,
-0.2691977322101593,
-0.25136348605155945,
-0.1224755272269249,
0.0025727879256010056,
-0.4426836669445038,
0.1999792605638504,
-0.5109758973121643,
-1.085608959197998,
0.4692496061325073,
-0.25006651878356934,
-0.019702909514307976,
0.22978226840496063,
0.5457767844200134,
0.026613151654601097,
1.3713374137878418,
0.49495729804039,
0.2239859402179718,
0.5046606659889221,
0.08562168478965759,
0.34733250737190247,
-0.7963245511054993,
-0.7728415131568909,
-0.8270484805107117,
-0.025140434503555298,
-0.21766233444213867,
-0.43956276774406433,
0.45734068751335144,
0.3128078877925873,
-0.43204304575920105,
0.07086734473705292,
-0.5860939621925354,
0.42563396692276,
0.41555237770080566,
0.05721930414438248,
0.3262864351272583,
-0.07197069376707077,
-0.5980861783027649,
0.2412460744380951,
-0.5627569556236267,
-0.541379988193512,
0.6267927885055542,
0.26613539457321167,
0.7058873772621155,
-0.04214701056480408,
0.7288586497306824,
0.06692235916852951,
0.017242683097720146,
-1.1603654623031616,
0.7161223888397217,
0.29988667368888855,
-0.35681140422821045,
-0.45884913206100464,
-0.45783889293670654,
-1.0613315105438232,
0.11157993972301483,
0.08787783980369568,
-0.8140869736671448,
0.006868225522339344,
0.0736825168132782,
-0.37829193472862244,
0.14647243916988373,
-0.5917461514472961,
0.8221865296363831,
-0.2981078326702118,
-0.15808387100696564,
0.262437641620636,
-0.5664030909538269,
0.15048283338546753,
0.12573572993278503,
0.3262922763824463,
-0.1975247710943222,
0.016552789136767387,
0.4244607985019684,
-0.32453060150146484,
0.9263506531715393,
-0.20316137373447418,
-0.36394843459129333,
0.35071370005607605,
0.34190821647644043,
0.705388069152832,
-0.11589708924293518,
-0.24479921162128448,
-0.22643806040287018,
-0.28415483236312866,
-0.27001240849494934,
-0.702858030796051,
0.6457489728927612,
-0.16460533440113068,
-0.7139089703559875,
-0.16762675344944,
-0.7691964507102966,
-0.43823206424713135,
0.612074613571167,
-0.04459118843078613,
0.6630352735519409,
0.10013134032487869,
0.11399274319410324,
0.6437613368034363,
-0.17526045441627502,
0.5690234899520874,
0.3605380058288574,
-0.2966049611568451,
-0.25868433713912964,
0.3004327714443207,
-0.10641421377658844,
0.12798269093036652,
0.5668354630470276,
0.16369758546352386,
-0.6703280210494995,
-0.6562854051589966,
-0.7435753345489502,
0.17142915725708008,
-1.0231068134307861,
-0.27186325192451477,
-0.7600966691970825,
0.17100326716899872,
-0.4119422435760498,
-0.1795729696750641,
0.23587049543857574,
-0.20336519181728363,
-0.3098234534263611,
-0.3370145559310913,
0.43636229634284973,
0.9136813879013062,
0.4194157123565674,
0.28684139251708984,
-0.8873886466026306,
0.2851659059524536,
0.22712594270706177,
0.3299788534641266,
0.04449013993144035,
-0.20885680615901947,
-0.02241623029112816,
-0.13173799216747284,
-0.21855467557907104,
-1.3590583801269531,
0.1290140151977539,
-0.1466100662946701,
0.7098677754402161,
0.28565657138824463,
-0.05757921561598778,
0.6784337759017944,
-0.8233102560043335,
0.9767497181892395,
0.3412446975708008,
-1.0969130992889404,
0.9159600734710693,
-0.7103704214096069,
0.6641609072685242,
0.29363763332366943,
0.4410077929496765,
-0.46171024441719055,
-0.400102823972702,
-0.23129458725452423,
-0.8367640972137451,
0.5972385406494141,
-0.01698140986263752,
-0.0030138776637613773,
-0.2916584312915802,
0.5404850244522095,
-0.18890701234340668,
0.2821025550365448,
-0.8064776062965393,
-0.1939372718334198,
-0.27111318707466125,
-0.37956559658050537,
0.1346781700849533,
-0.2669908106327057,
-0.1629551500082016,
-0.1113758534193039,
0.42202895879745483,
-0.6037845015525818,
-0.02345580980181694,
0.18644294142723083,
0.0027269034180790186,
-0.055457424372434616,
0.5813115239143372,
0.4906575381755829,
0.6376833319664001,
0.016607370227575302,
0.3200254440307617,
0.10715941339731216,
-0.15519197285175323,
0.30880412459373474,
0.22254647314548492,
-0.22102896869182587,
-0.06059008836746216,
0.516288697719574,
0.9587253928184509,
0.3834584057331085,
-0.434825599193573,
0.4178345203399658,
0.09609846770763397,
-0.12429870665073395,
0.2857859134674072,
0.05612899735569954,
0.28840821981430054,
0.4445856213569641,
0.4135805666446686,
-0.2762371003627777,
0.13736172020435333,
-0.5996599197387695,
0.09356267005205154,
0.4569770097732544,
-0.3469623327255249,
-0.09372194111347198,
0.7104140520095825,
0.16717202961444855,
-0.5353374481201172,
0.5630024075508118,
-0.27278080582618713,
-0.46916210651397705,
0.43471571803092957,
0.7159640789031982,
0.7573429346084595,
-0.34152594208717346,
0.5115697979927063,
0.4654419422149658,
0.2436961829662323,
-0.24978239834308624,
0.3001634478569031,
-0.1899501085281372,
-0.5065787434577942,
-0.7748940587043762,
-0.6795065402984619,
-0.39613860845565796,
0.04396041855216026,
-0.3885214924812317,
0.24739961326122284,
-0.445264607667923,
-0.01548637542873621,
-0.010626224800944328,
-0.1529800444841385,
-0.3448604643344879,
0.0748603343963623,
0.359371542930603,
1.0464472770690918,
-0.7239408493041992,
0.6357821822166443,
0.7453120946884155,
-0.49896085262298584,
-1.1961987018585205,
0.05973045527935028,
0.2535610795021057,
-0.780140221118927,
0.7419059872627258,
0.5341095328330994,
-0.44619500637054443,
-0.002980169141665101,
-0.6816321611404419,
-0.6128823757171631,
1.0524014234542847,
0.485575795173645,
-0.4983290433883667,
-0.3825143873691559,
-0.012674796395003796,
0.4984334409236908,
-0.4888010025024414,
0.23534797132015228,
0.2720937132835388,
0.6208521127700806,
0.6653575301170349,
-0.7032650113105774,
0.41888371109962463,
-0.16836747527122498,
-0.014754602685570717,
0.36286258697509766,
-0.17367671430110931,
0.9894603490829468,
-0.42021286487579346,
-0.31953877210617065,
-0.0903768464922905,
0.49065864086151123,
0.5938993692398071,
0.2762089669704437,
0.6853291392326355,
0.2636277973651886,
1.1008796691894531,
-0.06821627914905548,
1.0520153045654297,
-0.3515508472919464,
-0.0072526647709310055,
1.1168735027313232,
-0.41446900367736816,
0.651738703250885,
0.3617352843284607,
0.15611065924167633,
1.0661571025848389,
0.77128666639328,
0.08537109196186066,
0.13354429602622986,
0.08882220089435577,
-0.2754455804824829,
-0.43882420659065247,
-0.32308676838874817,
-0.198462575674057,
0.33792704343795776,
0.48458144068717957,
-0.2397891879081726,
-0.6853656768798828,
-0.10699083656072617,
0.22887268662452698,
0.002757737645879388,
-0.558275580406189,
0.5127564072608948,
0.020855018869042397,
-0.7467913031578064,
0.39705732464790344,
-0.14322763681411743,
0.24792568385601044,
-0.7771086096763611,
-0.29727452993392944,
-0.09704376012086868,
-0.17845836281776428,
-0.1768571138381958,
-1.1590765714645386,
-0.018881376832723618,
-0.00005594630056293681,
-0.26463422179222107,
-0.5791533589363098,
0.6238915920257568,
-0.43398430943489075,
-0.4176235795021057,
0.4815232753753662,
0.6884515881538391,
-0.025483785197138786,
-0.27929922938346863,
-0.8236950039863586,
0.053599849343299866,
0.05210317298769951,
-0.3539683520793915,
0.07893722504377365,
0.7593954205513,
-0.25540369749069214,
0.8209940195083618,
0.7400527596473694,
-0.04121088609099388,
-0.28788578510284424,
0.4760681986808777,
0.8587841391563416,
-0.8844513297080994,
-0.7763245701789856,
-1.0199830532073975,
0.5849582552909851,
-0.08828370273113251,
0.023301023989915848,
0.9617303013801575,
0.3805377185344696,
0.3849628269672394,
0.21774114668369293,
0.5214512348175049,
0.2393120527267456,
0.3358396291732788,
-0.7093057632446289,
0.2137850821018219,
-0.456308513879776,
0.281473308801651,
-0.3314010798931122,
-0.8367897868156433,
-0.48080554604530334,
0.420547753572464,
-0.24537572264671326,
0.08809217065572739,
0.9486567378044128,
0.7249922752380371,
0.315501868724823,
-0.038813915103673935,
0.09223627299070358,
0.38031306862831116,
0.613685131072998,
0.5561023950576782,
0.8524193167686462,
0.17941828072071075,
0.7781879305839539,
0.4411453902721405,
-0.17265163362026215,
-0.007051616441458464,
-1.0906946659088135,
-1.113510251045227,
-0.44583791494369507,
-0.16136832535266876,
-0.43773072957992554,
-0.2187345325946808,
0.8027962446212769,
0.40943995118141174,
-0.6008272171020508,
-0.09147831797599792,
-0.33999261260032654,
0.4714902341365814,
0.023469068109989166,
-0.2552298605442047,
0.3321349322795868,
-0.43614500761032104,
-0.6375684142112732,
0.8673525452613831,
0.6994220614433289,
0.21627239882946014,
-0.30356502532958984,
-0.0025967704132199287,
-0.3816871643066406,
0.09564518928527832,
0.8255530595779419,
0.006674709729850292,
-0.6913877725601196,
-0.41950953006744385,
0.10539167374372482,
-0.09687064588069916,
0.16792742908000946,
0.914666473865509,
-0.7625254392623901,
0.35892027616500854,
0.5491281747817993,
0.3994210362434387,
0.28678035736083984,
-0.019625235348939896,
0.49925386905670166,
-0.817221999168396,
-0.008753671310842037,
0.0819033607840538,
0.5325267910957336,
0.5371529459953308,
-0.5534610748291016,
0.31703072786331177,
0.14720934629440308,
-0.3952781856060028,
-0.8162868022918701,
0.5976734161376953,
-1.023291826248169,
-0.6069871783256531,
1.328691840171814,
-0.01717679761350155,
-0.2801729738712311,
-0.3637198805809021,
-0.4748730957508087,
0.302151083946228,
-0.5254233479499817,
0.35843342542648315,
0.7955994606018066,
-0.5945579409599304,
-0.17024554312229156,
-0.38910889625549316,
0.46851491928100586,
0.2189527451992035,
-1.065238356590271,
0.1080796867609024,
0.8974375128746033,
0.2001877874135971,
0.2344655841588974,
0.7554789185523987,
0.07956881821155548,
-0.19662441313266754,
-0.04373013973236084,
-0.3180849850177765,
-0.35178107023239136,
-0.624046266078949,
-0.2959502637386322,
0.500678300857544,
-0.02956971898674965,
0.010408497415482998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13414v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13414v2
|
Harnessing Large Language Models as Post-hoc Correctors
| 2024-02-20T22:50:41 | 2024-06-25T08:26:19 |
Zhiqiang Zhong, Kuangyu Zhou, Davide Mottin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
As Machine Learning (ML) models grow in size and demand higher-quality
training data, the expenses associated with re-training and fine-tuning these
models are escalating rapidly. Inspired by recent impressive achievements of
Large Language Models (LLMs) in different fields, this paper delves into the
question: can LLMs efficiently improve an ML's performance at a minimal cost?
We show that, through our proposed training-free framework LlmCorr, an LLM can
work as a post-hoc corrector to propose corrections for the predictions of an
arbitrary ML model. In particular, we form a contextual knowledge database by
incorporating the dataset's label information and the ML model's predictions on
the validation dataset. Leveraging the in-context learning capability of LLMs,
we ask the LLM to summarise the instances in which the ML model makes mistakes
and the correlation between primary predictions and true labels. Following
this, the LLM can transfer its acquired knowledge to suggest corrections for
the ML model's predictions. Our experimental results on text analysis and the
challenging molecular predictions show that \model improves the performance of
a number of models by up to 39%.
|
[
-0.08282560855150223,
-0.6073179244995117,
0.5365843772888184,
-0.4880804717540741,
-0.10188262909650803,
-0.2110685557126999,
-0.5235233902931213,
-0.4936572015285492,
-0.13875408470630646,
0.8630952835083008,
-0.130938321352005,
-0.2207699865102768,
-0.764618992805481,
0.12430290132761002,
-0.2823331356048584,
0.9189856052398682,
-0.07401075214147568,
0.1588435173034668,
-0.30296590924263,
-0.27193787693977356,
-0.29923346638679504,
-0.7199771404266357,
-0.573328971862793,
-0.44805246591567993,
0.8470513820648193,
0.5324831008911133,
0.4961755573749542,
0.8020417094230652,
0.6109692454338074,
0.3058631420135498,
-0.2186255306005478,
0.3934392035007477,
-0.661768913269043,
0.10390277206897736,
-0.3038175702095032,
-0.5439963936805725,
-0.5216462016105652,
-0.2051844745874405,
0.7058321237564087,
0.9467154741287231,
-0.05744911730289459,
-0.01872621849179268,
0.1384676694869995,
0.8513411283493042,
-0.6237024664878845,
0.13310767710208893,
-1.0040522813796997,
-0.2982710897922516,
-0.05509341135621071,
-0.17368260025978088,
-0.5657517910003662,
-0.13050700724124908,
0.2194569855928421,
-0.6267977952957153,
0.21489953994750977,
0.01325018797069788,
0.6769676804542542,
0.4800610840320587,
-0.38369855284690857,
-0.314814031124115,
-0.7418042421340942,
0.7048695683479309,
-0.6084388494491577,
0.4940190613269806,
0.3602043390274048,
0.5603639483451843,
-0.2773590683937073,
-0.6006572246551514,
-0.3996921181678772,
-0.18508252501487732,
-0.11821295320987701,
-0.3883666694164276,
-0.0745534673333168,
0.03244820982217789,
0.5068755745887756,
0.34479159116744995,
-0.3588768243789673,
0.13917666673660278,
-0.2213631421327591,
-0.1508634090423584,
0.5708187222480774,
-0.023240461945533752,
0.13411103188991547,
0.28370776772499084,
0.1140735000371933,
-0.055273737758398056,
-1.0188394784927368,
-0.1578252613544464,
-0.077311210334301,
0.5315172672271729,
0.10313571989536285,
0.78457111120224,
-0.089384526014328,
0.8146730661392212,
0.03905705735087395,
-0.1808033287525177,
-0.022569650784134865,
-0.06462598592042923,
-0.34540244936943054,
0.2119925618171692,
0.4546523988246918,
0.36381497979164124,
0.3775807023048401,
-0.12532679736614227,
-0.3646582067012787,
0.11432875692844391,
0.13304869830608368,
-1.0019738674163818,
-0.40948206186294556,
0.04833894968032837,
-0.24928131699562073,
-0.02709003910422325,
-0.1240939199924469,
-0.3305942714214325,
-0.6343585252761841,
-0.5605118870735168,
0.447638601064682,
-0.23782187700271606,
-0.014963923022150993,
0.17006133496761322,
0.08654424548149109,
0.10227607190608978,
0.5723924040794373,
-0.580783486366272,
-0.09721115976572037,
0.6204780340194702,
0.6438456773757935,
0.2749937176704407,
-0.06852778792381287,
-0.8639000058174133,
0.30865076184272766,
-0.540947437286377,
0.7340466976165771,
-0.4820016324520111,
-0.5051564574241638,
-0.03726764768362045,
0.09130654484033585,
-0.050466615706682205,
-0.7391610741615295,
0.2792821526527405,
-0.706239640712738,
0.0431852787733078,
-0.6387088894844055,
-0.8289072513580322,
0.03902629762887955,
0.18500138819217682,
-0.7254086136817932,
0.8500550389289856,
0.07327394932508469,
-1.0340771675109863,
0.42344263195991516,
-0.5416150689125061,
-0.46355605125427246,
-0.04540880024433136,
0.16657882928848267,
-0.4980209171772003,
0.1251482367515564,
0.355567991733551,
0.7194239497184753,
-0.2642884850502014,
0.49692535400390625,
-0.2770756483078003,
-0.44770070910453796,
0.3004511892795563,
-0.04028269276022911,
0.6050641536712646,
0.09453152865171432,
-0.28875696659088135,
0.38375911116600037,
-0.9683893918991089,
-0.3820492923259735,
-0.07130897045135498,
-0.7491104602813721,
-0.3388349711894989,
-0.0014273200649768114,
-0.17914296686649323,
0.3506571352481842,
0.010200047865509987,
-0.3848564326763153,
0.25871068239212036,
-0.43415936827659607,
0.4784732162952423,
0.6351776719093323,
-0.3206276595592499,
0.778721272945404,
-0.44383445382118225,
0.31320467591285706,
-0.08600276708602905,
-0.34585073590278625,
-0.3039974272251129,
-0.34109389781951904,
-1.100485920906067,
-0.3783673346042633,
0.3440331518650055,
0.4774041175842285,
-0.9649449586868286,
0.33175909519195557,
-0.35462525486946106,
-0.5726704597473145,
-0.6371230483055115,
0.3712077736854553,
0.4259377121925354,
0.7843726873397827,
0.4762366712093353,
0.27006691694259644,
-0.869186282157898,
-0.6045967936515808,
-0.4600765109062195,
-0.023044131696224213,
-0.3026527464389801,
0.4058677852153778,
0.5109178423881531,
-0.6412907242774963,
0.841265082359314,
-0.12421125173568726,
-0.09815756231546402,
-0.3161054849624634,
-0.09493318945169449,
0.04706235229969025,
0.4267588257789612,
0.18099373579025269,
-0.42465776205062866,
-0.39621421694755554,
0.24943077564239502,
-0.7981889247894287,
-0.19898004829883575,
0.2569885551929474,
-0.16461127996444702,
0.5606728792190552,
0.7044157385826111,
-0.530921459197998,
-0.010120168328285217,
0.5502912402153015,
-0.21033422648906708,
0.5425397753715515,
-0.40433645248413086,
0.07522783428430557,
-0.9734472632408142,
0.2962832748889923,
-0.150267094373703,
-0.2959052324295044,
-0.6413369178771973,
-0.25177422165870667,
0.15842773020267487,
-0.06796529144048691,
-0.3142061233520508,
0.8888023495674133,
-0.3735913336277008,
0.041342783719301224,
-0.44077420234680176,
0.20756453275680542,
-0.19813376665115356,
0.12874901294708252,
0.1581721156835556,
0.6781477928161621,
0.5184093713760376,
-0.8084589242935181,
0.0543939433991909,
0.14676575362682343,
-0.5527830123901367,
0.44241419434547424,
-0.6540169715881348,
0.11430356651544571,
-0.397377610206604,
0.44547754526138306,
-0.8782567381858826,
-0.5400312542915344,
-0.012394722551107407,
-0.3643001914024353,
0.3258146047592163,
-0.09562297910451889,
-0.4563377797603607,
-0.2941695749759674,
0.02797670103609562,
0.16144101321697235,
0.42941218614578247,
-0.8192574977874756,
0.5836467146873474,
0.3443872630596161,
0.022721128538250923,
-0.647640585899353,
-0.6598502397537231,
-0.06494663655757904,
-0.03321583569049835,
-0.5612882971763611,
0.17844265699386597,
-0.03511328622698784,
-0.3349840044975281,
-0.08130840957164764,
0.11653358489274979,
0.04446427896618843,
0.15822730958461761,
0.21264037489891052,
0.06344012916088104,
-0.26156193017959595,
0.35739433765411377,
-0.05910182371735573,
-0.268346905708313,
-0.17487145960330963,
-0.5093587636947632,
0.2738719582557678,
-0.13257379829883575,
-0.11350447684526443,
-0.3190667927265167,
-0.017892315983772278,
0.5260641574859619,
-0.252332866191864,
0.9533270001411438,
0.37369319796562195,
-0.5148846507072449,
-0.10129643976688385,
-0.7121243476867676,
-0.2782796323299408,
-0.43589699268341064,
0.3229682445526123,
-0.33507972955703735,
-1.3693583011627197,
0.27346500754356384,
-0.014047389850020409,
0.014345859177410603,
0.5020450353622437,
0.5579891800880432,
-0.12088686972856522,
0.9318668246269226,
0.8119810819625854,
-0.11746145039796829,
0.33187341690063477,
-0.167838454246521,
0.2108994424343109,
-0.6783791780471802,
-0.18168434500694275,
-0.5950895547866821,
-0.0821528211236,
-0.5350703597068787,
-0.8311630487442017,
0.14825454354286194,
0.3686552047729492,
-0.42254945635795593,
0.3244779706001282,
-0.20540663599967957,
0.5890827178955078,
0.5810731649398804,
-0.003606676124036312,
0.22860324382781982,
0.047591689974069595,
-0.08241306245326996,
0.1000259518623352,
-0.9966164827346802,
-0.7648224234580994,
1.1621243953704834,
0.29822492599487305,
0.5076156854629517,
-0.0646287053823471,
0.21497303247451782,
-0.08386717736721039,
0.8303946852684021,
-0.7613524198532104,
0.43759992718696594,
-0.06343476474285126,
-0.40868520736694336,
-0.2805994749069214,
-0.7736881375312805,
-0.8025334477424622,
0.2749001085758209,
-0.39436399936676025,
-0.49240270256996155,
-0.06021719053387642,
0.5543124079704285,
0.027636531740427017,
0.5934895873069763,
-0.2776566743850708,
0.8714498281478882,
-0.17402289807796478,
-0.3268089294433594,
-0.08166629076004028,
-0.6694826483726501,
0.41071030497550964,
-0.3145112097263336,
0.36067113280296326,
-0.03955109044909477,
0.07954372465610504,
0.75563645362854,
-0.6075703501701355,
0.6757567524909973,
-0.329473078250885,
-0.25962644815444946,
0.27393969893455505,
0.2589934766292572,
0.5976841449737549,
-0.3614904284477234,
-0.31488263607025146,
0.11842773109674454,
-0.3096948564052582,
-0.4391755163669586,
-0.5189374685287476,
0.5331794023513794,
-0.6154020428657532,
-0.4155789613723755,
0.024192264303565025,
-0.5656569004058838,
-0.3927571773529053,
0.16037972271442413,
0.26531827449798584,
0.3961184620857239,
-0.07214672118425369,
0.4686780869960785,
0.6948214769363403,
-0.39946448802948,
0.3124001622200012,
0.5418711304664612,
-0.20921145379543304,
-0.5727774500846863,
0.6778221726417542,
0.07377701997756958,
0.13999629020690918,
0.7868028879165649,
0.3931863009929657,
-0.43662649393081665,
-0.3971966803073883,
-0.3178671598434448,
0.47730904817581177,
-0.7228208780288696,
-0.2880585789680481,
-0.8938784599304199,
0.11385434120893478,
-0.39255836606025696,
-0.4983889162540436,
-0.3908238708972931,
-0.35750818252563477,
-0.23324307799339294,
-0.2790464460849762,
0.4396238327026367,
0.5895337462425232,
-0.07452310621738434,
0.6802508234977722,
-0.9289443492889404,
-0.12145528942346573,
0.24692580103874207,
0.32724788784980774,
-0.016368599608540535,
-0.6617648601531982,
-0.42562487721443176,
0.05900268629193306,
0.06436146050691605,
-0.37394291162490845,
0.30635446310043335,
0.23492076992988586,
0.4477013945579529,
0.4269161820411682,
-0.08778113126754761,
0.6155710220336914,
-0.666685163974762,
0.6112868189811707,
0.09427381306886673,
-1.007768988609314,
0.6311471462249756,
-0.45270201563835144,
0.2071204036474228,
0.3767315149307251,
0.3703600764274597,
-0.6129729747772217,
-0.3301348388195038,
-0.4272838830947876,
-0.6780617237091064,
0.5962774157524109,
-0.0787593424320221,
-0.09043274074792862,
0.07081416994333267,
0.5514125227928162,
-0.048703402280807495,
0.2354985475540161,
-0.5345549583435059,
-0.08312003314495087,
0.10476094484329224,
-0.22966037690639496,
-0.6696082949638367,
-0.6748625636100769,
0.10138656944036484,
-0.31523406505584717,
0.981190025806427,
-0.20495688915252686,
-0.05426815152168274,
0.0693754181265831,
-0.5480291247367859,
-0.11280524730682373,
0.2666514813899994,
0.6991974711418152,
0.7295706868171692,
-0.15540730953216553,
0.349945992231369,
0.36484894156455994,
0.17323678731918335,
0.19541950523853302,
0.03514300286769867,
0.07831000536680222,
-0.07061175256967545,
0.5774093270301819,
0.7016143202781677,
0.38155150413513184,
-0.9948808550834656,
0.4717639684677124,
0.06323644518852234,
-0.20311057567596436,
0.2057957798242569,
-0.13230492174625397,
0.3099479377269745,
0.26197534799575806,
-0.02699989452958107,
0.026153970509767532,
-0.02389654889702797,
-0.21622532606124878,
0.517841100692749,
0.33740830421447754,
-0.4721914827823639,
-0.14994847774505615,
0.8924492597579956,
0.16490879654884338,
-0.30841371417045593,
0.501282811164856,
0.1239520013332367,
-0.6702179908752441,
0.42757517099380493,
0.6063873171806335,
0.3918021321296692,
-0.6237914562225342,
-0.04970815032720566,
0.4686566889286041,
0.1659916341304779,
-0.34174472093582153,
-0.016079779714345932,
-0.04992562159895897,
-0.8392642140388489,
-0.5215075016021729,
-0.6683940887451172,
-0.4389924108982086,
0.06683354079723358,
-0.2728717029094696,
0.303864061832428,
-0.5735861659049988,
0.04427247866988182,
-0.09096931666135788,
-0.03318313509225845,
-0.5156176090240479,
0.379360556602478,
0.07373960316181183,
0.873397707939148,
-0.6024052500724792,
1.0291861295700073,
0.7036561369895935,
-0.03098350763320923,
-0.7988924980163574,
-0.37978947162628174,
-0.12674930691719055,
-0.508287787437439,
0.8299826979637146,
0.5108376145362854,
-0.358707994222641,
-0.2644922137260437,
-0.3545900881290436,
-0.9124615788459778,
0.7659728527069092,
0.6503840088844299,
-1.0270895957946777,
0.20595863461494446,
0.07554441690444946,
0.593605637550354,
-0.29071125388145447,
0.05047642067074776,
0.4146591126918793,
0.2592385411262512,
0.25654616951942444,
-0.9065843224525452,
-0.04019105061888695,
-0.12812556326389313,
0.0580604262650013,
0.21905067563056946,
-0.08174196630716324,
0.9605588316917419,
-0.40056806802749634,
-0.12239281833171844,
-0.019751843065023422,
0.6532871723175049,
0.39896059036254883,
0.18238231539726257,
0.35628601908683777,
0.4758707582950592,
1.211251139640808,
0.08647030591964722,
1.2196049690246582,
-0.4213429391384125,
0.41244620084762573,
1.2300883531570435,
-0.37858515977859497,
1.064807415008545,
0.37007594108581543,
0.10202015191316605,
0.26037007570266724,
0.6713743209838867,
0.28888070583343506,
0.20989756286144257,
0.49835655093193054,
-0.2024531215429306,
-0.30021703243255615,
-0.007603655569255352,
-0.3466300666332245,
0.28237560391426086,
0.2719130218029022,
-0.4217080771923065,
-0.06433560699224472,
0.15703317523002625,
0.2337964028120041,
0.06425808370113373,
-0.555069625377655,
0.7997726798057556,
0.02471417933702469,
-0.47883087396621704,
0.6539548635482788,
0.17487715184688568,
0.7354652881622314,
-0.27898767590522766,
0.10970719158649445,
-0.18455800414085388,
0.6172254681587219,
-0.11258094012737274,
-0.21424420177936554,
0.48119211196899414,
0.02422829531133175,
-0.35294947028160095,
-0.1854710578918457,
0.9029685854911804,
-0.8013856410980225,
-0.6645699143409729,
0.3722416162490845,
0.3264801800251007,
0.13676857948303223,
-0.3983701467514038,
-0.36258047819137573,
0.07144463062286377,
-0.261187344789505,
0.03372795134782791,
0.0770438015460968,
0.3320063650608063,
0.1015460342168808,
0.7575814723968506,
0.6222718954086304,
0.018012013286352158,
-0.03849506750702858,
-0.126809760928154,
0.7047709822654724,
-0.5760602951049805,
-0.30326154828071594,
-0.9993315935134888,
0.5575143098831177,
0.12088336050510406,
0.14489710330963135,
0.6040513515472412,
0.6078522801399231,
1.1798335313796997,
-0.14290399849414825,
0.836281955242157,
0.434306800365448,
0.7097952365875244,
-0.6598665714263916,
0.76714688539505,
-0.6871779561042786,
0.35673221945762634,
-0.13625751435756683,
-0.8121333718299866,
-0.61446613073349,
0.7563267946243286,
-0.5547718405723572,
-0.01273745484650135,
0.4315781891345978,
0.9911141991615295,
0.07818738371133804,
-0.060351427644491196,
0.4973822236061096,
0.3236396610736847,
0.4511626958847046,
0.50773024559021,
0.9569952487945557,
-0.3797977864742279,
0.3100650906562805,
-0.1641676425933838,
-0.17235784232616425,
-0.5521398186683655,
-0.8760636448860168,
-1.1617456674575806,
-0.41111356019973755,
-0.35463395714759827,
-0.53635573387146,
0.1835622936487198,
1.0730464458465576,
0.7854077816009521,
-0.9556021690368652,
-0.28985247015953064,
-0.03938949480652809,
0.19147546589374542,
0.14730148017406464,
-0.1507895141839981,
0.40182968974113464,
-0.4377988576889038,
-0.5531046986579895,
0.4095245599746704,
0.1463146060705185,
0.0920506939291954,
0.21788500249385834,
-0.1741640716791153,
0.07041021436452866,
0.10519526153802872,
1.0567879676818848,
0.08685267716646194,
-0.7527921795845032,
-0.24368558824062347,
-0.21942849457263947,
-0.20521654188632965,
0.04406554251909256,
1.2061694860458374,
-0.6404006481170654,
0.3344905376434326,
0.2593088448047638,
1.1512006521224976,
0.3951297998428345,
-0.2233075648546219,
0.6620151400566101,
-0.6444752216339111,
0.015694331377744675,
-0.009455342777073383,
0.5358787775039673,
0.697380542755127,
-0.38609689474105835,
0.2886117398738861,
0.1618613302707672,
-0.6485726833343506,
-0.8130221366882324,
0.053032658994197845,
-0.6767518520355225,
-0.45185860991477966,
1.1991568803787231,
-0.11206048727035522,
-0.22108496725559235,
0.09373573213815689,
-0.27334651350975037,
0.4161953628063202,
-0.1616942435503006,
0.5307258367538452,
0.6475325226783752,
0.027641402557492256,
-0.24061760306358337,
-0.4531877934932709,
0.6908473968505859,
0.33175697922706604,
-0.8721588850021362,
0.4049966037273407,
0.7021355628967285,
0.48331257700920105,
-0.2006198614835739,
0.7261654734611511,
0.014049079269170761,
-0.02609059028327465,
-0.12895932793617249,
0.02135520428419113,
-0.10873690247535706,
-0.6526907682418823,
-0.46301406621932983,
0.11209502071142197,
0.21253874897956848,
0.11949767172336578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13408v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13408v1
|
Healthcare Copilot: Eliciting the Power of General LLMs for Medical Consultation
| 2024-02-20T22:26:35 | 2024-02-20T22:26:35 |
Zhiyao Ren, Yibing Zhan, Baosheng Yu, Liang Ding, Dacheng Tao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The copilot framework, which aims to enhance and tailor large language models
(LLMs) for specific complex tasks without requiring fine-tuning, is gaining
increasing attention from the community. In this paper, we introduce the
construction of a Healthcare Copilot designed for medical consultation. The
proposed Healthcare Copilot comprises three main components: 1) the Dialogue
component, responsible for effective and safe patient interactions; 2) the
Memory component, storing both current conversation data and historical patient
information; and 3) the Processing component, summarizing the entire dialogue
and generating reports. To evaluate the proposed Healthcare Copilot, we
implement an auto-evaluation scheme using ChatGPT for two roles: as a virtual
patient engaging in dialogue with the copilot, and as an evaluator to assess
the quality of the dialogue. Extensive results demonstrate that the proposed
Healthcare Copilot significantly enhances the capabilities of general LLMs for
medical consultations in terms of inquiry capability, conversational fluency,
response accuracy, and safety. Furthermore, we conduct ablation studies to
highlight the contribution of each individual module in the Healthcare Copilot.
Code will be made publicly available on GitHub.
|
[
-0.23387446999549866,
-0.5206184983253479,
0.8538586497306824,
0.047752492129802704,
-0.6753969788551331,
0.0714988186955452,
0.06453040987253189,
-0.5539106130599976,
0.402913898229599,
0.49454745650291443,
-0.45994803309440613,
-0.322168231010437,
-0.46309414505958557,
-0.17327308654785156,
-0.1394655853509903,
0.9035329818725586,
0.1943151205778122,
0.5158835053443909,
-0.09374836087226868,
0.17035011947155,
-0.3634071350097656,
-1.0248221158981323,
-1.0408176183700562,
-0.2844797670841217,
0.4414856433868408,
0.11663957685232162,
0.8367341160774231,
0.26380789279937744,
0.4334273934364319,
0.35376325249671936,
-0.02788790874183178,
0.22577187418937683,
0.00815874245017767,
0.2559266984462738,
-0.07446962594985962,
-0.26798170804977417,
-0.8725085258483887,
-0.2489221841096878,
0.49275287985801697,
0.5681076645851135,
-0.40964409708976746,
-0.32521602511405945,
0.01759038306772709,
0.39619502425193787,
-0.31484732031822205,
0.1421847641468048,
-0.3492707312107086,
-0.029052266851067543,
0.19144828617572784,
-0.37201398611068726,
-0.03942180797457695,
-0.09129740297794342,
0.4679131507873535,
-0.31479987502098083,
-0.12282338738441467,
0.23521623015403748,
0.5287742614746094,
0.4682709872722626,
-0.3410077691078186,
-0.7144045829772949,
-0.5750419497489929,
0.35307466983795166,
-0.6010398268699646,
0.4129844009876251,
0.3664044737815857,
0.432531476020813,
0.06364738941192627,
-0.7522239685058594,
-0.20886734127998352,
-0.5084645748138428,
-0.27515909075737,
0.5212253928184509,
-0.06323276460170746,
0.6096346974372864,
-0.030331123620271683,
0.624150812625885,
-0.46643227338790894,
-0.026476377621293068,
-0.07537850737571716,
-0.1752750277519226,
0.42824360728263855,
0.3936901390552521,
0.422130823135376,
-0.26029205322265625,
-0.2715495228767395,
0.34231871366500854,
-0.5800462365150452,
-0.16210639476776123,
0.17121568322181702,
-0.17226558923721313,
-0.3535500168800354,
0.457202672958374,
0.01346161961555481,
0.7030738592147827,
0.1632097214460373,
-0.3636213541030884,
0.022704120725393295,
-0.22264622151851654,
-0.563304603099823,
-0.20214207470417023,
0.9323230385780334,
0.41633370518684387,
-0.03691326826810837,
-0.09964470565319061,
-0.06748177111148834,
-0.18424753844738007,
0.5756974220275879,
-0.7342182993888855,
-0.3866323232650757,
0.5647315979003906,
-0.41326865553855896,
-0.45466384291648865,
0.1321796178817749,
-0.6386253237724304,
-0.4065495431423187,
-0.5072511434555054,
-0.0726303979754448,
-0.35129469633102417,
-0.1283065527677536,
0.35994067788124084,
0.2827726900577545,
0.004938929807394743,
0.43830832839012146,
-0.8420328497886658,
0.5699871182441711,
0.8154643177986145,
0.7123838663101196,
-0.21972863376140594,
0.2993471324443817,
-0.529596745967865,
0.15838541090488434,
-0.13056086003780365,
0.9389414191246033,
-0.33847975730895996,
-0.7953588366508484,
0.11185883730649948,
0.27941709756851196,
-0.14115841686725616,
-0.6517150402069092,
0.6849474906921387,
0.08936559408903122,
0.4105909764766693,
0.09901497513055801,
-0.4503144919872284,
0.24997729063034058,
0.6396699547767639,
-0.41112661361694336,
0.4522773325443268,
0.21840263903141022,
-0.7260695695877075,
-0.0011806660331785679,
-0.8934064507484436,
-0.33323171734809875,
0.5921059846878052,
-0.6931459307670593,
-0.4561752676963806,
-0.05387991666793823,
0.2144169956445694,
0.3396020829677582,
-0.3897314965724945,
0.22904084622859955,
-0.014576743356883526,
-0.18892019987106323,
0.28541257977485657,
-0.225352942943573,
0.8261711597442627,
0.20652318000793457,
-0.00016221727128140628,
0.20116950571537018,
-0.5420036315917969,
-0.0029398726765066385,
-0.17917786538600922,
-0.6467705965042114,
-0.009903866797685623,
-0.09794633090496063,
-0.024590153247117996,
-0.09104105085134506,
0.27205774188041687,
-0.43721503019332886,
0.5340384840965271,
-0.6216443777084351,
0.4042645990848541,
0.3358345925807953,
0.47018346190452576,
0.27711841464042664,
-0.6836010813713074,
0.8393121957778931,
-0.24360546469688416,
0.6413081288337708,
-0.09134866297245026,
-0.7323488593101501,
-0.6120263934135437,
-0.5525403022766113,
0.2192234843969345,
0.6876869201660156,
-0.710541844367981,
0.5602931976318359,
-0.10611257702112198,
-0.4528796672821045,
-0.5735492706298828,
-0.05767053738236427,
0.4718266725540161,
0.44294196367263794,
0.04287359490990639,
-0.3294801414012909,
-0.4347841441631317,
-0.8413749933242798,
0.16057375073432922,
-0.5085324048995972,
-0.5730938911437988,
0.6563243269920349,
-0.13499893248081207,
-0.6452791094779968,
0.6693382263183594,
-0.35950741171836853,
-0.19955416023731232,
-0.20257440209388733,
-0.007481301669031382,
0.036664754152297974,
0.4238893687725067,
0.5689489245414734,
-0.7158471345901489,
-0.3147626519203186,
0.07953367382287979,
-0.16019031405448914,
-0.3252567946910858,
-0.04174608364701271,
-0.09729508310556412,
0.2282039374113083,
0.29068347811698914,
-0.5468429327011108,
0.3215223550796509,
0.830620288848877,
-0.14220471680164337,
0.6470397114753723,
-0.3584825396537781,
0.19409741461277008,
-1.3379989862442017,
0.48396626114845276,
-0.6658427119255066,
-0.4193651080131531,
-0.5435370802879333,
-0.06675460189580917,
-0.009880300611257553,
-0.28959786891937256,
-0.6060376167297363,
0.6254931688308716,
-0.378395140171051,
0.16322967410087585,
-0.297035276889801,
-0.10736709088087082,
-0.084632009267807,
0.31602662801742554,
0.13971206545829773,
0.5126021504402161,
0.40908536314964294,
-0.4676438570022583,
0.6841607689857483,
0.2175237536430359,
-0.18348991870880127,
0.9441654086112976,
-0.7206902503967285,
0.42980191111564636,
0.20890407264232635,
0.22517848014831543,
-0.8540804982185364,
-0.43952345848083496,
0.4982280731201172,
-0.29064324498176575,
0.14492836594581604,
-0.5407689809799194,
-0.557388186454773,
-0.39219680428504944,
0.10951674729585648,
0.2679879069328308,
0.4451153874397278,
-0.12516964972019196,
0.6812058687210083,
0.5601783990859985,
-0.5143569111824036,
-0.13335411250591278,
-0.5147534608840942,
0.16071279346942902,
0.06356742978096008,
-0.4826586842536926,
0.04858754947781563,
-0.5294671654701233,
-0.24174948036670685,
-0.20347726345062256,
0.006572002544999123,
-0.23541098833084106,
-0.08176609873771667,
0.6196221709251404,
0.42268964648246765,
0.11137880384922028,
0.4177345633506775,
-0.01955484040081501,
-0.34309816360473633,
0.16116546094417572,
-0.3167688846588135,
0.7436977028846741,
-0.17286747694015503,
-0.6301169991493225,
-0.45717301964759827,
0.5788858532905579,
0.5902237296104431,
0.1143551617860794,
0.22495198249816895,
0.21336811780929565,
-0.2844151556491852,
0.26872387528419495,
-0.7175374627113342,
0.019693586975336075,
-0.5197628736495972,
0.1456238031387329,
-0.06522079557180405,
-0.7232733368873596,
0.3496016263961792,
-0.42033374309539795,
0.17176975309848785,
0.014773814007639885,
0.9634026885032654,
-0.1265573799610138,
0.7788254022598267,
0.3737439811229706,
-0.06329706311225891,
0.32438749074935913,
0.003064217744395137,
0.18239900469779968,
-0.8347960710525513,
-0.33796682953834534,
-0.3301161825656891,
0.21183325350284576,
-0.5562130808830261,
-0.49272942543029785,
0.7653731107711792,
-0.32747623324394226,
0.014863618649542332,
-0.01758696883916855,
-0.6358530521392822,
0.1937537044286728,
0.38891249895095825,
0.30335432291030884,
0.28255167603492737,
-0.23442932963371277,
-0.618597149848938,
0.16596172749996185,
-0.5605469942092896,
-0.4593457281589508,
0.6929172277450562,
0.2815100848674774,
0.7769950032234192,
0.1298685520887375,
0.7001075148582458,
-0.13244658708572388,
0.46035945415496826,
-1.136825442314148,
0.41061699390411377,
-0.23562273383140564,
-0.48189181089401245,
0.09315095841884613,
-0.2235863357782364,
-0.9338114857673645,
0.12085527181625366,
-0.10394458472728729,
-0.5437800288200378,
-0.150837704539299,
0.32979631423950195,
-0.7762566208839417,
-0.014639822766184807,
-0.622944176197052,
0.5659453272819519,
-0.4968716502189636,
-0.17630083858966827,
0.00815107487142086,
-0.5689499378204346,
-0.0037017958238720894,
0.0020840708166360855,
0.15577180683612823,
0.18661735951900482,
-0.3629738688468933,
0.36146530508995056,
-0.48852354288101196,
0.866640567779541,
0.004486409015953541,
-0.1809944063425064,
0.06438232958316803,
-0.010426552966237068,
0.1624477356672287,
0.2368042916059494,
-0.11876685917377472,
-0.06908105313777924,
0.4939427971839905,
-0.1500251740217209,
-0.7397663593292236,
0.448932021856308,
-0.41018417477607727,
-0.6450350284576416,
-0.22095097601413727,
-0.4730333387851715,
-0.5924904942512512,
0.14735907316207886,
0.10269546508789062,
0.565111517906189,
-0.5004907250404358,
0.10643807798624039,
0.17617416381835938,
-0.3541991412639618,
-0.10650915652513504,
0.7111409902572632,
-0.2907358705997467,
-0.5976295471191406,
0.4812367856502533,
-0.03269220143556595,
0.3583289682865143,
0.30243685841560364,
0.41032275557518005,
-0.26041024923324585,
-0.39506828784942627,
-0.3303109109401703,
0.32904142141342163,
-0.5357039570808411,
-0.11816636472940445,
-0.7022978663444519,
-0.5142597556114197,
-0.41981393098831177,
-0.28320977091789246,
-0.1309479922056198,
-0.19630566239356995,
0.006559922359883785,
0.10618380457162857,
-0.02983194775879383,
0.9022210836410522,
0.0484108105301857,
0.5849544405937195,
-0.7178194522857666,
0.318130224943161,
0.6036852598190308,
0.399807333946228,
-0.4126885235309601,
0.048238955438137054,
-0.22306805849075317,
-0.15662816166877747,
-0.508117139339447,
-0.6830453276634216,
0.40806344151496887,
-0.39644891023635864,
0.6361804604530334,
0.6547830700874329,
0.07431463897228241,
0.5962002277374268,
-0.7124443054199219,
0.9974197149276733,
0.4352491796016693,
-0.689067542552948,
0.49892064929008484,
-0.4581773281097412,
0.38933858275413513,
0.4619971513748169,
0.15440262854099274,
-0.7031900882720947,
-0.5816437602043152,
-0.81878662109375,
-0.6823021769523621,
0.1759270876646042,
0.013245669193565845,
-0.029177231714129448,
-0.18026341497898102,
0.34931740164756775,
-0.14005641639232635,
0.2752957344055176,
-0.307830810546875,
0.023556232452392578,
-0.0003536246658768505,
-0.21380935609340668,
0.10532476752996445,
-0.49311643838882446,
-0.47300127148628235,
-0.08970226347446442,
0.28612735867500305,
-0.1773594617843628,
0.6091068387031555,
0.5103809237480164,
0.4592261016368866,
0.018316948786377907,
0.5723975300788879,
0.5036393404006958,
0.5299745202064514,
-0.04028359055519104,
0.08442981541156769,
0.06180373206734657,
-0.7287110090255737,
-0.1125037670135498,
0.2234106957912445,
0.24027548730373383,
0.2017839103937149,
0.10025076568126678,
0.35934901237487793,
0.5269870758056641,
-0.6105157732963562,
0.5841943621635437,
-0.3666762411594391,
-0.26835542917251587,
-0.32463186979293823,
0.16519542038440704,
0.4081917703151703,
0.06241922453045845,
-0.026691213250160217,
-0.33679652214050293,
0.3330439627170563,
-0.6125344038009644,
0.22960706055164337,
0.4603736102581024,
-0.22182834148406982,
-0.028089411556720734,
0.5103595852851868,
0.5090140700340271,
-0.7278708815574646,
0.19188155233860016,
0.04696648567914963,
-0.7079505324363708,
0.25103652477264404,
0.2162855714559555,
0.7138805985450745,
-0.5964331030845642,
-0.10202345252037048,
0.14970575273036957,
0.1644197404384613,
0.24099881947040558,
0.38645312190055847,
-0.15880785882472992,
-0.23364637792110443,
-0.30577707290649414,
-0.3428974151611328,
-1.224522590637207,
0.31673628091812134,
-0.5087928175926208,
0.1995701938867569,
-0.6495954990386963,
-0.24674369394779205,
-0.16489696502685547,
0.3411301374435425,
-0.6929575204849243,
0.25329330563545227,
0.08158596605062485,
0.5278540849685669,
-0.14032045006752014,
0.9085623621940613,
0.6439348459243774,
-0.01855011284351349,
-0.8447533845901489,
0.22458359599113464,
0.18959473073482513,
-1.0089540481567383,
0.17052510380744934,
-0.05487393960356712,
-0.23327185213565826,
-0.42092272639274597,
-0.3521421253681183,
-0.2069026082754135,
0.9848474264144897,
0.5624735355377197,
-0.9486711025238037,
-0.2406289279460907,
0.33218663930892944,
0.5991024971008301,
-0.4556386172771454,
0.19241595268249512,
0.26829564571380615,
0.2539365291595459,
0.18113389611244202,
-1.525536060333252,
0.0631377100944519,
-0.3216857612133026,
-0.3631037175655365,
-0.2138357311487198,
-0.5954795479774475,
0.5536074638366699,
0.05485687404870987,
-0.3222363591194153,
0.5963315367698669,
-0.22167852520942688,
0.23196274042129517,
-0.020948316901922226,
0.6343482136726379,
0.14373779296875,
0.9566562175750732,
0.09057486802339554,
1.398285150527954,
-0.7055474519729614,
0.07731901109218597,
1.3473740816116333,
-0.12535621225833893,
0.5596932768821716,
0.5249401926994324,
0.07503896951675415,
0.32839903235435486,
0.3656449019908905,
0.1875351220369339,
0.17730183899402618,
0.25628989934921265,
-0.7351585030555725,
-0.22290515899658203,
-0.1871509701013565,
-0.3994574248790741,
0.17942115664482117,
0.5442540645599365,
-0.4380602538585663,
-0.07291168719530106,
-0.14415714144706726,
0.04501049965620041,
-0.3201965093612671,
-0.11044706404209137,
1.165472388267517,
0.39981609582901,
-0.8313862085342407,
0.37800732254981995,
-0.2847069501876831,
0.2994491457939148,
-0.8377256989479065,
-0.04038502648472786,
0.08377466350793839,
0.1071426272392273,
-0.2529362142086029,
-0.6012656688690186,
0.3401409387588501,
-0.19440776109695435,
0.19497935473918915,
-0.3583163619041443,
0.6483232378959656,
-0.42996710538864136,
-0.44098976254463196,
0.16920790076255798,
0.31618258357048035,
0.47010982036590576,
0.05813103914260864,
-0.9427202939987183,
0.08724939078092575,
-0.26168009638786316,
-0.023596422746777534,
0.22689493000507355,
0.3408425450325012,
0.45542481541633606,
0.5236808061599731,
0.7093709111213684,
0.4176569879055023,
-0.2913611829280853,
0.2984609305858612,
0.9422807693481445,
-0.3092137277126312,
-0.8512848615646362,
-0.5284957885742188,
0.548281729221344,
-0.1091741994023323,
-0.0827641487121582,
0.2249993532896042,
0.587925136089325,
0.1806788593530655,
0.10380375385284424,
0.9873746037483215,
0.13679605722427368,
0.7344812750816345,
-0.5983914732933044,
0.7692387700080872,
-0.3254554867744446,
0.06308294832706451,
-0.07517468184232712,
-0.21913312375545502,
-0.43289458751678467,
0.8009897470474243,
-0.41370105743408203,
-0.15260769426822662,
0.701072633266449,
0.6656675338745117,
0.04104821756482124,
0.11181005090475082,
0.7675298452377319,
0.11397629231214523,
0.7312412261962891,
0.6310544610023499,
0.7636232972145081,
-0.09874791651964188,
0.519080400466919,
-0.2016250342130661,
-0.32916462421417236,
-0.31992098689079285,
-0.7985484004020691,
-0.9766638278961182,
-0.47734424471855164,
-0.12829090654850006,
-0.23261328041553497,
0.2293640673160553,
0.9810932278633118,
1.0774348974227905,
-0.38818734884262085,
-0.08594820648431778,
0.11018697917461395,
-0.41886645555496216,
0.2501285970211029,
-0.17763040959835052,
0.3501732349395752,
-0.10366496443748474,
-0.7850552797317505,
0.39388343691825867,
0.45070913434028625,
0.345804363489151,
-0.32304951548576355,
-0.2072189748287201,
0.34773385524749756,
0.032343022525310516,
0.3854382038116455,
0.0994429737329483,
-0.6149969100952148,
-0.190277561545372,
-0.09860113263130188,
-0.204818993806839,
0.23443841934204102,
1.1116578578948975,
-0.4034704566001892,
0.5970056653022766,
-0.09241721034049988,
0.5967140793800354,
0.3681429326534271,
0.005461188964545727,
0.6308654546737671,
-0.41117846965789795,
0.3630671203136444,
0.4844154715538025,
0.662231981754303,
0.24415966868400574,
-0.7785499691963196,
0.5520293116569519,
0.005874833557754755,
-0.8199000358581543,
-0.4460403323173523,
0.37675222754478455,
-1.3411509990692139,
-0.014291156083345413,
1.202791452407837,
-0.25867122411727905,
-0.12915673851966858,
-0.5318912863731384,
-0.9175151586532593,
0.019109733402729034,
-0.25182023644447327,
0.6067340970039368,
0.5576903223991394,
-0.504925549030304,
-0.0890536904335022,
-0.5753135681152344,
0.49984753131866455,
0.27481383085250854,
-1.0300179719924927,
-0.050468023866415024,
0.35388755798339844,
0.5955690741539001,
0.20486992597579956,
1.194313645362854,
-0.4203715920448303,
0.4399028718471527,
-0.2882802188396454,
-0.19952362775802612,
-0.04902291297912598,
0.10984169691801071,
-0.23212996125221252,
0.2132507860660553,
0.07577002048492432,
-0.2549164891242981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13405v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13405v3
|
A Unified Taxonomy-Guided Instruction Tuning Framework for Entity Set Expansion and Taxonomy Expansion
| 2024-02-20T22:19:56 | 2024-05-22T04:09:01 |
Yanzhen Shen, Yu Zhang, Yunyi Zhang, Jiawei Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Entity set expansion, taxonomy expansion, and seed-guided taxonomy
construction are three representative tasks that aim to automatically populate
an existing taxonomy with new concepts. Previous studies view them as three
separate tasks, and the proposed methods usually only work for one specific
task, which lack generalizability and a holistic perspective across different
tasks. In this paper, we aim to discover a unified solution to all three tasks.
To be specific, we identify two common skills needed for entity set expansion,
taxonomy expansion, and seed-guided taxonomy construction: finding "siblings"
and finding "parents". We introduce a taxonomy-guided instruction tuning
framework to teach a large language model to generate siblings and parents for
query entities, where the joint pre-training process facilitates the mutual
enhancement of these two skills. Extensive experiments on multiple benchmark
datasets demonstrate the efficacy of our proposed TaxoInstruct framework, which
outperforms task-specific baselines across all three tasks.
|
[
-0.5183512568473816,
-0.3427312672138214,
0.048208337277173996,
0.19604328274726868,
-0.2400130331516266,
0.18907105922698975,
-0.15305723249912262,
-0.263311505317688,
0.20550359785556793,
0.43812239170074463,
-0.9342621564865112,
-0.6234316229820251,
-0.5599449276924133,
0.01631004363298416,
-0.09648767858743668,
0.8692577481269836,
-0.04688899964094162,
-0.14347243309020996,
-0.25042039155960083,
0.14588719606399536,
-0.6171981692314148,
-0.19893237948417664,
-0.5836135149002075,
-0.004990575835108757,
0.5818324685096741,
0.7893139719963074,
0.552422821521759,
1.3432077169418335,
0.6305055618286133,
0.16385197639465332,
-0.05049955099821091,
0.39883506298065186,
-0.2966664135456085,
0.19956707954406738,
-0.4036460518836975,
-0.40366920828819275,
-0.48347386717796326,
-0.1742158830165863,
0.6227383017539978,
1.131136178970337,
-0.3350462317466736,
0.5401319861412048,
0.23670893907546997,
0.5106315612792969,
-0.8912655115127563,
0.3741883635520935,
-0.5924447774887085,
-0.14655695855617523,
-0.2053426057100296,
-0.6735605597496033,
-0.1523713767528534,
-0.16031242907047272,
0.22696757316589355,
-0.9842056035995483,
0.49385860562324524,
0.03468207269906998,
0.8093512654304504,
0.3684771955013275,
-0.7982782125473022,
-0.5263054966926575,
-0.51539546251297,
0.6545634865760803,
-0.220010906457901,
0.39536020159721375,
0.00831536203622818,
-0.31973081827163696,
-0.272034615278244,
-0.7622143030166626,
-0.1393335908651352,
0.36992147564888,
-0.26307302713394165,
-0.13614718616008759,
-0.26269611716270447,
0.3805595636367798,
0.26876893639564514,
0.28689345717430115,
-0.5081264972686768,
0.26760926842689514,
-0.4000718593597412,
-0.11416918784379959,
0.37498992681503296,
-0.05871639400720596,
0.4692172706127167,
-0.0232184249907732,
-0.2337096631526947,
-0.2062010020017624,
-0.9407880306243896,
-0.26000291109085083,
0.49293389916419983,
0.5500138401985168,
0.40625932812690735,
0.3565645217895508,
-0.12998077273368835,
0.8279328942298889,
-0.0839819386601448,
-0.148686021566391,
0.027013832703232765,
-0.35130155086517334,
-0.10947317630052567,
0.15399199724197388,
0.22468599677085876,
0.3072347640991211,
0.2246212363243103,
-0.3686475157737732,
-0.14193151891231537,
0.0939297154545784,
0.33805933594703674,
-0.8157398700714111,
-0.22485749423503876,
-0.08789969235658646,
-0.23632289469242096,
-0.32749074697494507,
-0.15518949925899506,
-0.8365697264671326,
0.03202967718243599,
-0.5294622182846069,
0.637897253036499,
-0.3798185884952545,
-0.409619003534317,
0.20740385353565216,
-0.37129342555999756,
0.2367420792579651,
-0.07111603021621704,
-1.4397914409637451,
0.33619004487991333,
1.1914206743240356,
0.5131306052207947,
-0.1962963044643402,
-0.39045703411102295,
-0.8477776646614075,
0.39088210463523865,
-0.3264756202697754,
0.9442381262779236,
-0.9791942238807678,
-0.43686720728874207,
0.12513242661952972,
0.028740599751472473,
-0.308540403842926,
-0.4120437204837799,
0.3292904794216156,
-0.4746073782444,
0.3136880695819855,
-0.26343074440956116,
-0.739642858505249,
-0.19799566268920898,
-0.06622742861509323,
-0.47933465242385864,
0.7311645746231079,
0.4932346045970917,
-0.6690073013305664,
0.7234721779823303,
-0.9142472147941589,
-0.569767415523529,
0.5082400441169739,
-0.16231636703014374,
-0.1891450136899948,
0.06422949582338333,
0.3379269242286682,
0.5935251712799072,
-0.304354190826416,
0.1430818885564804,
0.06264477968215942,
-0.5454965233802795,
-0.8900123834609985,
0.20467767119407654,
0.8706839680671692,
-0.18569572269916534,
-0.5023523569107056,
0.11125892400741577,
-0.5437796115875244,
0.21916016936302185,
-0.13226909935474396,
-0.24229049682617188,
-0.5581058859825134,
-0.10910182446241379,
-0.4871080815792084,
-0.24667134881019592,
0.13948313891887665,
-0.2334420531988144,
0.7621200084686279,
-0.35788673162460327,
0.2897004783153534,
0.42676877975463867,
0.30580198764801025,
0.7313607931137085,
-0.04776015132665634,
0.7874997854232788,
0.1293378621339798,
0.14077633619308472,
-0.3505313992500305,
-0.5488216876983643,
-0.8635280132293701,
-0.05575701966881752,
0.5307849645614624,
0.28024065494537354,
-0.8520968556404114,
0.5569885969161987,
-0.6619873046875,
-0.3870675265789032,
-0.445600301027298,
0.34520262479782104,
0.5210703611373901,
0.42557787895202637,
0.3634811043739319,
-0.467306911945343,
-0.6080295443534851,
-0.9644732475280762,
0.01871158927679062,
-0.01371848490089178,
-0.0023994040675461292,
0.007955852895975113,
0.7188522219657898,
-0.02592347376048565,
0.6681763529777527,
-0.7328526377677917,
-0.45690852403640747,
0.2993069291114807,
0.45856529474258423,
-0.019649740308523178,
0.7658755779266357,
0.4865199029445648,
-0.8540457487106323,
-0.1057894229888916,
-0.125507652759552,
-0.26085948944091797,
0.1925673484802246,
0.13076329231262207,
-0.40225836634635925,
-0.12825067341327667,
0.27066460251808167,
-0.3677184283733368,
0.24985083937644958,
0.24637345969676971,
-0.22263649106025696,
0.2527075707912445,
-0.17200733721256256,
0.06426204741001129,
-1.3825417757034302,
-0.19206364452838898,
-0.010098441503942013,
0.2517707049846649,
-0.6205672025680542,
0.6997086405754089,
0.24331441521644592,
0.258901983499527,
-0.17592944204807281,
0.367133229970932,
-0.8023974299430847,
-0.2607441246509552,
-0.11889531463384628,
0.05562819540500641,
-0.06045319512486458,
0.5986723303794861,
-0.03229428082704544,
1.0026317834854126,
0.8404667973518372,
-0.7989343404769897,
0.4721492826938629,
0.25362518429756165,
-0.06474428623914719,
0.8253090381622314,
-0.182890385389328,
0.10990334302186966,
-0.18278470635414124,
0.02957697957754135,
-0.32881826162338257,
-0.5268785953521729,
0.18249231576919556,
-0.31036141514778137,
0.6431442499160767,
-0.5497631430625916,
-0.6225934624671936,
-0.6301062703132629,
-0.10711752623319626,
-0.02777431719005108,
0.4552338421344757,
-0.9746353626251221,
0.9113773107528687,
0.21619141101837158,
-0.045726094394922256,
-0.7941205501556396,
-0.19184966385364532,
-0.17801210284233093,
-0.31092554330825806,
-0.6395375728607178,
0.6441285610198975,
0.14793729782104492,
0.06292891502380371,
0.50065678358078,
-0.47222623229026794,
-0.217568501830101,
0.3099793493747711,
0.17206670343875885,
0.29611608386039734,
-0.6431345343589783,
0.5946825742721558,
0.3748657703399658,
-0.041071586310863495,
0.057172443717718124,
-0.9742143154144287,
0.43980371952056885,
0.008289520628750324,
-0.13418550789356232,
-0.02119678631424904,
0.3739981949329376,
0.16963206231594086,
-0.6763399243354797,
0.603554368019104,
0.49628716707229614,
-0.3668256103992462,
-0.4821174740791321,
-0.40159347653388977,
-0.20671744644641876,
-0.5011328458786011,
0.3540533483028412,
-0.52585768699646,
-1.036989688873291,
0.04340501129627228,
-0.24064050614833832,
0.5117373466491699,
0.5703743100166321,
0.2966284453868866,
0.1838659793138504,
0.9465883374214172,
0.9960553050041199,
0.365877240896225,
0.14250300824642181,
-0.4142822027206421,
0.14593471586704254,
-1.015545129776001,
-0.3531070947647095,
-0.6711535453796387,
-0.3191901743412018,
-0.7601508498191833,
-0.28406935930252075,
0.08371003717184067,
0.32096168398857117,
-0.3790578842163086,
0.7131131291389465,
-1.0651655197143555,
0.756080687046051,
1.1369739770889282,
-0.17269961535930634,
0.33966413140296936,
0.2566935122013092,
-0.08879406005144119,
0.28444230556488037,
-0.716994047164917,
-0.4470444321632385,
1.3086072206497192,
-0.261928528547287,
0.234999880194664,
0.1452120989561081,
1.0408893823623657,
-0.2659773826599121,
0.5690281391143799,
-0.8838707804679871,
0.3935135304927826,
-0.5467300415039062,
-0.8212836384773254,
-0.20497645437717438,
-0.5240002870559692,
-1.0796778202056885,
0.026619266718626022,
-0.046685971319675446,
-0.7585015892982483,
0.2657523453235626,
0.2501983940601349,
-0.526002049446106,
0.4716208279132843,
-0.8752832412719727,
0.8144637942314148,
-0.16743576526641846,
-0.2691665589809418,
-0.07409322261810303,
-0.5652379393577576,
0.5763112306594849,
-0.20103828608989716,
-0.13410021364688873,
-0.09332437068223953,
-0.37938153743743896,
0.8090278506278992,
0.012483780272305012,
0.32078638672828674,
-0.2205168902873993,
-0.17057806253433228,
0.06478482484817505,
0.09443515539169312,
0.0751476064324379,
-0.057436130940914154,
0.04898129031062126,
-0.3691725730895996,
0.3630844056606293,
-0.3949427604675293,
-0.8792984485626221,
0.9013118147850037,
-0.49991375207901,
-0.9286211133003235,
-0.20913313329219818,
-0.33717086911201477,
-0.4204242527484894,
0.3159199059009552,
0.04194149747490883,
0.5314903259277344,
0.06813238561153412,
0.4417399764060974,
0.8777637481689453,
0.26601943373680115,
0.2638801634311676,
0.6038914322853088,
-0.07330606877803802,
-0.12476957589387894,
0.9663360714912415,
-0.10718602687120438,
0.13294513523578644,
0.564024031162262,
-0.018914513289928436,
-0.19521532952785492,
-0.1269904375076294,
-0.483308345079422,
0.1365305632352829,
-0.5596739053726196,
-0.48876193165779114,
-0.6207053065299988,
-0.09137394279241562,
-0.5431233644485474,
0.0029613568913191557,
-0.010991240851581097,
-0.2448042780160904,
-0.515803337097168,
0.04997064173221588,
0.37081030011177063,
0.7611207365989685,
-0.19687718152999878,
0.647727370262146,
-0.7014563679695129,
0.2864314317703247,
0.6089211106300354,
0.6618883609771729,
-0.04064971208572388,
-0.299807071685791,
0.06610891968011856,
0.24524205923080444,
-0.3528251647949219,
-0.8118415474891663,
0.061043716967105865,
0.3498522937297821,
0.28214630484580994,
0.5234216451644897,
-0.24583891034126282,
0.9047073125839233,
-0.5196534991264343,
0.5042948126792908,
0.11170950531959534,
-0.8102148771286011,
0.7299593687057495,
-0.21012498438358307,
-0.0870574489235878,
0.5296228528022766,
0.7233695387840271,
-0.3199836015701294,
0.28902503848075867,
-0.9670159220695496,
-0.6164015531539917,
0.7127072811126709,
0.2583940327167511,
0.17517885565757751,
0.07495854794979095,
0.6469786763191223,
0.0012827209429815412,
0.3217751383781433,
-0.08555761724710464,
-0.40777528285980225,
0.03508218005299568,
-0.1430792510509491,
-0.036642082035541534,
-0.08509452641010284,
-0.16821615397930145,
-0.36548930406570435,
0.7101559638977051,
-0.23239868879318237,
-0.13579168915748596,
-0.26418057084083557,
0.1859614998102188,
-0.3002254366874695,
0.41899722814559937,
0.3151392638683319,
0.5026482939720154,
-0.2747340500354767,
0.04806927591562271,
-0.19428101181983948,
-0.3579130172729492,
0.1826229840517044,
0.4028172791004181,
-0.1866436004638672,
-0.10383918136358261,
0.5538966059684753,
0.9047951698303223,
0.6291670799255371,
-0.1782723069190979,
0.5493162274360657,
0.11262625455856323,
-0.5427249670028687,
0.05596227943897247,
0.5858730673789978,
0.39699506759643555,
-0.18730120360851288,
0.4336645305156708,
0.010667827911674976,
-0.06276945024728775,
-0.7127678394317627,
0.44873425364494324,
0.40018942952156067,
-0.21102915704250336,
-0.17733480036258698,
0.5326025485992432,
0.36839061975479126,
-0.49612730741500854,
0.7220683693885803,
-0.5056561827659607,
-0.6062584519386292,
0.7316151261329651,
0.5214348435401917,
0.8000050783157349,
-0.3040299117565155,
0.4672156572341919,
0.45467060804367065,
0.3935472071170807,
-0.2129000723361969,
0.2669798731803894,
-0.3241179287433624,
-0.7624287009239197,
-0.39604055881500244,
-0.7774568200111389,
-0.2396790087223053,
0.1069885790348053,
-0.9900208711624146,
0.22317837178707123,
-0.05082215368747711,
0.2336980551481247,
0.2940469980239868,
0.24116036295890808,
-0.8497887849807739,
0.34665197134017944,
-0.23496100306510925,
0.8812782764434814,
-0.5302660465240479,
0.5773046016693115,
0.8890218734741211,
-0.5376263856887817,
-1.4316413402557373,
0.03377772495150566,
0.004277640487998724,
-0.8924497365951538,
0.7126010060310364,
0.11033522337675095,
-0.12375319004058838,
0.7129831314086914,
-0.46470746397972107,
-0.9653370380401611,
1.162880778312683,
0.1907339245080948,
-0.547731876373291,
-0.7721067070960999,
-0.11550821363925934,
0.4531138837337494,
-0.7886168956756592,
-0.06321847438812256,
0.8711656928062439,
0.3724616765975952,
0.4153216779232025,
-0.6111087799072266,
-0.23216532170772552,
-0.1159651130437851,
0.08503936231136322,
0.6316404938697815,
-0.17031089961528778,
0.4035736918449402,
-0.13208596408367157,
-0.48527055978775024,
-0.017992010340094566,
0.5918669104576111,
0.002325338777154684,
-0.08413224667310715,
0.825100839138031,
0.43369635939598083,
0.773273766040802,
-0.32670795917510986,
0.7322149276733398,
-0.6971555948257446,
0.25862157344818115,
1.318231225013733,
-0.16601493954658508,
0.7428306341171265,
0.26132723689079285,
0.1971360146999359,
0.31174567341804504,
0.7846471667289734,
-0.17579776048660278,
0.10467299818992615,
0.37819501757621765,
-0.24399018287658691,
-0.3547358214855194,
-0.45834311842918396,
-0.3368489146232605,
0.5573288202285767,
0.6269633769989014,
-0.14650027453899384,
-0.37825942039489746,
-0.07997008413076401,
0.0585196390748024,
-0.06421983987092972,
-0.4452485144138336,
0.6679819822311401,
-0.1746770590543747,
-1.0562694072723389,
0.1916988492012024,
-0.11375156044960022,
0.7170979380607605,
-0.48582321405410767,
-0.2962523400783539,
-0.29876652359962463,
-0.27658015489578247,
-0.2218942940235138,
-0.8498896360397339,
0.06341611593961716,
-0.06527260690927505,
-0.009740687906742096,
-0.39567410945892334,
0.4316064715385437,
-0.5242805480957031,
-0.4516717791557312,
0.25208330154418945,
0.45806533098220825,
-0.16812840104103088,
0.0285232812166214,
-0.36028367280960083,
-0.31523218750953674,
0.1916586309671402,
0.06559451669454575,
-0.13221265375614166,
0.5162094831466675,
0.03958941996097565,
0.5102572441101074,
0.5583224892616272,
0.3815467953681946,
0.2316298484802246,
0.0807776153087616,
0.8447742462158203,
-0.29743921756744385,
-0.0946909487247467,
-0.31563010811805725,
0.214726984500885,
-0.19693006575107574,
-0.5655201077461243,
0.36378711462020874,
0.7540779709815979,
1.2212491035461426,
0.03600166365504265,
0.2889586091041565,
-0.08735993504524231,
0.5440961122512817,
-0.30296027660369873,
0.32049477100372314,
-0.7955897450447083,
0.13816706836223602,
-0.052092961966991425,
-1.300140142440796,
-0.5120245218276978,
0.13500767946243286,
-0.06559820473194122,
0.0241268090903759,
0.8452688455581665,
0.9477298259735107,
-0.27144092321395874,
0.14618395268917084,
0.07382437586784363,
-0.16221825778484344,
0.19403433799743652,
0.4637870788574219,
0.549463152885437,
-0.1593041867017746,
0.5511294007301331,
-0.6150010824203491,
-0.22974726557731628,
0.06098030507564545,
-0.6887531280517578,
-0.73005211353302,
-0.8254057168960571,
-0.47513458132743835,
0.10038769245147705,
0.25927749276161194,
0.9313802123069763,
0.8314939141273499,
-0.5801206827163696,
0.10053887963294983,
-0.18115703761577606,
0.0388345867395401,
-0.23138044774532318,
-0.21340958774089813,
0.5561666488647461,
-0.5007658004760742,
-0.7086374759674072,
0.2240878939628601,
0.46186622977256775,
-0.14674603939056396,
-0.19809719920158386,
0.4014577567577362,
-0.12103698402643204,
-0.17371758818626404,
0.08805789798498154,
0.2969432771205902,
-0.6761735677719116,
-0.3381466865539551,
0.07026566565036774,
0.06772617995738983,
-0.0016343658789992332,
1.0893625020980835,
-0.5759217143058777,
0.4751487672328949,
0.03110283985733986,
0.4768475890159607,
0.16036206483840942,
0.08473437279462814,
0.5508564114570618,
-0.9801540374755859,
-0.09832996129989624,
0.17898482084274292,
0.19848401844501495,
0.14767596125602722,
-0.4792475402355194,
0.7440924048423767,
0.15117108821868896,
-0.18885548412799835,
-0.6972096562385559,
0.3544028401374817,
-0.6097106337547302,
-0.1554809957742691,
0.7754698395729065,
0.044367432594299316,
-0.30991318821907043,
0.11704085022211075,
0.18685545027256012,
0.4395943880081177,
-0.030111880972981453,
0.44832462072372437,
0.48586976528167725,
0.10467645525932312,
0.008390392176806927,
-0.11130835860967636,
0.5518250465393066,
0.2605893313884735,
-0.8176507949829102,
-0.17224866151809692,
0.300281822681427,
0.19106550514698029,
0.35644403100013733,
0.15556390583515167,
0.31788331270217896,
0.36808454990386963,
-0.023869728669524193,
0.15993812680244446,
-0.10197083652019501,
-0.5426064729690552,
-0.10580990463495255,
0.26790183782577515,
-0.2642393410205841,
-0.22480933368206024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13374v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13374v1
|
Reliable LLM-based User Simulator for Task-Oriented Dialogue Systems
| 2024-02-20T20:57:47 | 2024-02-20T20:57:47 |
Ivan Sekulić, Silvia Terragni, Victor Guimarães, Nghia Khau, Bruna Guedes, Modestas Filipavicius, André Ferreira Manso, Roland Mathis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the realm of dialogue systems, user simulation techniques have emerged as
a game-changer, redefining the evaluation and enhancement of task-oriented
dialogue (TOD) systems. These methods are crucial for replicating real user
interactions, enabling applications like synthetic data augmentation, error
detection, and robust evaluation. However, existing approaches often rely on
rigid rule-based methods or on annotated data. This paper introduces DAUS, a
Domain-Aware User Simulator. Leveraging large language models, we fine-tune
DAUS on real examples of task-oriented dialogues. Results on two relevant
benchmarks showcase significant improvements in terms of user goal fulfillment.
Notably, we have observed that fine-tuning enhances the simulator's coherence
with user goals, effectively mitigating hallucinations -- a major source of
inconsistencies in simulator responses.
|
[
-0.30930379033088684,
-1.040835976600647,
0.6695911884307861,
0.23754842579364777,
-0.19417837262153625,
0.08919695019721985,
-0.08397965878248215,
-0.08062564581632614,
0.04928439110517502,
0.5885431170463562,
-0.746319055557251,
-0.2689790427684784,
-0.20342880487442017,
0.08547007292509079,
-0.2893097400665283,
0.7544388175010681,
0.13433705270290375,
-0.17243728041648865,
-0.5283673405647278,
0.11792168021202087,
-0.6561610698699951,
-0.6799720525741577,
-0.8213964104652405,
-0.21512779593467712,
0.20467951893806458,
0.2981967031955719,
0.7599846720695496,
0.4331042170524597,
0.2736909091472626,
0.2930339574813843,
0.06724506616592407,
0.42524534463882446,
-0.5992105603218079,
0.48950695991516113,
0.011295857839286327,
-0.29150712490081787,
-0.9439511299133301,
-0.04646821692585945,
0.42027586698532104,
0.5663576126098633,
-0.3994622230529785,
-0.15981745719909668,
0.2445458024740219,
0.17601071298122406,
-0.34945058822631836,
0.1976446509361267,
-0.5364711880683899,
-0.18798594176769257,
0.0996486097574234,
-0.34045571088790894,
-0.38803204894065857,
0.019136054441332817,
0.1647288203239441,
-0.8815546631813049,
-0.06090877577662468,
0.08950281143188477,
0.6580240726470947,
0.5879042744636536,
-0.5238487720489502,
-0.0890536904335022,
-0.9564253687858582,
1.099814772605896,
-0.9403088688850403,
0.28911831974983215,
0.22404485940933228,
0.31854766607284546,
-0.7225326895713806,
-0.48816928267478943,
-0.8112033009529114,
-0.4085073471069336,
0.03594682738184929,
0.08123239129781723,
-0.0756327360868454,
0.3832646608352661,
0.5721340775489807,
0.2193118780851364,
-0.15799415111541748,
-0.036893799901008606,
0.04815514013171196,
-0.1736348569393158,
0.7284055948257446,
0.6342284679412842,
0.36857062578201294,
-0.2541603147983551,
-0.6293011903762817,
0.036310967057943344,
-0.6339941024780273,
-0.10174193978309631,
0.40767836570739746,
0.09665843844413757,
-0.1353108137845993,
0.20788250863552094,
-0.24310119450092316,
0.8946748375892639,
0.12327294051647186,
-0.5562765002250671,
0.1544126272201538,
-0.23925311863422394,
-0.32387903332710266,
-0.38915684819221497,
0.5912308692932129,
0.6519004702568054,
0.3292803466320038,
-0.22227931022644043,
-0.4383240044116974,
0.2710423171520233,
0.5162951946258545,
-0.7470897436141968,
-0.2538749873638153,
0.18708683550357819,
-0.2001541703939438,
-0.07419931888580322,
-0.2728976607322693,
-0.5369287133216858,
-0.23169173300266266,
-0.7643359899520874,
0.24120399355888367,
-0.5217192769050598,
-0.24554766714572906,
0.146964430809021,
0.133603036403656,
-0.255134254693985,
0.9905703067779541,
-0.6237073540687561,
0.7307429313659668,
0.7054473757743835,
0.5087716579437256,
-0.6134641766548157,
-0.23484764993190765,
-0.8054342269897461,
0.23612771928310394,
-0.12345655262470245,
0.4923938810825348,
-0.5103062987327576,
-0.7172684669494629,
-0.21396884322166443,
-0.3622560203075409,
-0.19679276645183563,
-0.7637352347373962,
0.66546231508255,
-0.24418364465236664,
-0.1173110380768776,
-0.29871952533721924,
-0.5691314339637756,
-0.058049123734235764,
0.4046897292137146,
-0.255479097366333,
1.2067939043045044,
0.13841019570827484,
-0.3307349383831024,
0.23042349517345428,
-0.7655153870582581,
-0.33380988240242004,
-0.008592856116592884,
-0.19659088551998138,
-0.13462841510772705,
0.22225135564804077,
0.04343430697917938,
0.35675954818725586,
-0.20668399333953857,
0.5704234838485718,
-0.22946636378765106,
-0.5884549021720886,
0.23369579017162323,
-0.45654651522636414,
0.5654028654098511,
0.46391695737838745,
-0.25916817784309387,
0.23007072508335114,
-0.5253958702087402,
-0.0172510277479887,
-0.13912108540534973,
0.07365087419748306,
-0.42873549461364746,
0.03180325776338577,
0.08159869909286499,
0.19987782835960388,
-0.011433325707912445,
-0.7232264280319214,
0.36506327986717224,
-0.20867832005023956,
0.3585943579673767,
0.458775132894516,
0.15202206373214722,
0.17293226718902588,
-0.4828464984893799,
0.5909408926963806,
0.3403572738170624,
0.3380298614501953,
-0.19348269701004028,
-0.5468901991844177,
-0.6819101572036743,
-0.6187087297439575,
0.12944632768630981,
0.5589240193367004,
-0.699026882648468,
0.37578606605529785,
-0.07189491391181946,
-0.16235925257205963,
-0.23571071028709412,
0.1896917074918747,
0.25037339329719543,
0.5709391236305237,
0.08684398978948593,
-0.5459774136543274,
-0.5879338979721069,
-0.6669155955314636,
-0.022399991750717163,
-0.42584285140037537,
0.026010356843471527,
0.7901846766471863,
0.36251550912857056,
-0.5781024098396301,
1.1263513565063477,
-0.46950703859329224,
-0.3483666479587555,
-0.2855481505393982,
0.20028573274612427,
-0.3306495249271393,
0.4744720458984375,
0.5606178045272827,
-0.6128650903701782,
-0.4663989841938019,
-0.24149875342845917,
-0.7393451929092407,
-0.17253316938877106,
-0.3588810861110687,
0.08593998849391937,
0.1698998212814331,
0.3955093324184418,
-0.5736857652664185,
0.5663261413574219,
0.40061095356941223,
-0.1384226232767105,
0.5172622203826904,
-0.350987046957016,
0.43219295144081116,
-1.0256898403167725,
-0.006228290498256683,
-0.03221310302615166,
-0.4720604419708252,
-0.6412531137466431,
-0.32841911911964417,
-0.16973166167736053,
-0.08169037848711014,
-0.32453322410583496,
0.7806932330131531,
-0.25638464093208313,
-0.15647436678409576,
-0.4000050127506256,
0.3646092116832733,
0.10508542507886887,
0.5008132457733154,
-0.22430549561977386,
1.1148465871810913,
0.6117347478866577,
-0.6856454014778137,
0.337638258934021,
0.3396274149417877,
-0.38792797923088074,
0.8078537583351135,
-0.685347855091095,
0.43548187613487244,
0.18987426161766052,
0.24922409653663635,
-0.9028195738792419,
-0.2864527702331543,
0.18714217841625214,
-0.08040887862443924,
0.1552927941083908,
-0.11355239152908325,
-0.7040574550628662,
-0.24590972065925598,
-0.07286493480205536,
0.4944959580898285,
0.671717643737793,
-0.4625273048877716,
0.6090048551559448,
0.5616385340690613,
-0.18153539299964905,
-0.4142623543739319,
-0.06610254943370819,
0.3430615961551666,
-0.25493305921554565,
-0.503856897354126,
0.23164281249046326,
-0.38085925579071045,
-0.45694106817245483,
-0.30689799785614014,
-0.13183924555778503,
0.007532946299761534,
0.5280861854553223,
0.6686612963676453,
0.34141531586647034,
0.19360868632793427,
-0.2647780179977417,
0.2745632529258728,
0.1229589581489563,
0.08504270017147064,
-0.15624435245990753,
0.33897531032562256,
-0.08031109720468521,
-0.4577924311161041,
-0.9319570660591125,
0.22990605235099792,
0.7012617588043213,
0.03302110359072685,
0.03539164364337921,
0.1623554527759552,
-0.4372457265853882,
-0.30824896693229675,
-0.6396986246109009,
-0.3182835280895233,
-0.4877437651157379,
0.18862558901309967,
-0.640825629234314,
-0.820713460445404,
0.5208649039268494,
-0.5167045593261719,
0.09737207740545273,
0.08823837339878082,
0.43179649114608765,
-0.29389771819114685,
1.1233129501342773,
0.572107195854187,
0.16994032263755798,
0.44224515557289124,
-0.0845741257071495,
0.12948225438594818,
-0.9410121440887451,
-0.16617313027381897,
-0.2742200791835785,
-0.2331351488828659,
0.17613251507282257,
-0.6027721166610718,
0.4473673105239868,
0.20007050037384033,
0.14557376503944397,
0.3206985890865326,
-0.07445191591978073,
0.1497955471277237,
0.4032345414161682,
-0.16068066656589508,
0.4894350469112396,
0.11740711331367493,
-0.15985257923603058,
-0.28783077001571655,
-0.5180941224098206,
-0.8207460641860962,
0.7099898457527161,
0.2585567533969879,
1.054696798324585,
-0.16506528854370117,
0.7870495319366455,
0.6673943996429443,
0.3338559865951538,
-0.6973313093185425,
0.900321364402771,
0.1425199657678604,
-0.5232590436935425,
-0.34649914503097534,
-0.46854332089424133,
-0.6980118751525879,
-0.04479574039578438,
-0.050437167286872864,
-1.024268627166748,
0.09445025771856308,
0.4464123249053955,
-0.5858595967292786,
0.15052391588687897,
-0.642332911491394,
0.724717378616333,
-0.12139968574047089,
-0.3665062487125397,
-0.4924570322036743,
-0.30322015285491943,
0.011728433892130852,
0.09678459912538528,
0.008489510044455528,
-0.3581058979034424,
0.2040606439113617,
0.6263244152069092,
-0.39189040660858154,
0.9468053579330444,
-0.31372231245040894,
-0.36244139075279236,
0.6091223955154419,
0.30700165033340454,
0.39310505986213684,
0.35900741815567017,
-0.12537619471549988,
0.1126357838511467,
0.14977939426898956,
-0.2017063945531845,
-0.8452081084251404,
1.0412771701812744,
-0.6349561810493469,
-1.085628867149353,
-0.1523267775774002,
-0.9903618693351746,
-0.3462349474430084,
-0.07604534178972244,
-0.3907482326030731,
0.5272018313407898,
-0.6718260049819946,
-0.27177321910858154,
0.46032458543777466,
-0.010418918915092945,
0.09106641262769699,
0.4226597547531128,
-0.29841348528862,
-0.22570249438285828,
0.7327283024787903,
-0.20723886787891388,
0.2575102150440216,
-0.1448846161365509,
-0.14395540952682495,
-0.12646110355854034,
-0.44595828652381897,
-0.898226261138916,
0.11140326410531998,
-0.2716977894306183,
-0.24072059988975525,
-0.7262720465660095,
-0.08346649259328842,
-0.16212593019008636,
-0.07186596840620041,
-0.3158518671989441,
-0.41302651166915894,
-0.30068862438201904,
-0.0013889891561120749,
0.3173258602619171,
0.829181432723999,
0.11355549842119217,
0.45152658224105835,
-0.5926841497421265,
0.5385317802429199,
0.31048956513404846,
0.4602767527103424,
-0.1208634302020073,
-0.5368481278419495,
-0.2742868661880493,
0.4493390917778015,
-0.4729776382446289,
-0.5138823390007019,
0.34201428294181824,
0.10349878668785095,
0.5916563272476196,
0.34943729639053345,
0.2612300217151642,
0.7926133871078491,
-0.32078006863594055,
0.8174523115158081,
0.1244562566280365,
-1.0841819047927856,
0.5777122378349304,
-0.43161091208457947,
0.06747287511825562,
0.5294839143753052,
-0.09227142482995987,
-0.5421999096870422,
-0.47744232416152954,
-0.3354923129081726,
-0.28154173493385315,
0.8800590634346008,
0.2547946870326996,
0.3892521560192108,
-0.22208330035209656,
0.6135280132293701,
0.3324524760246277,
0.044501155614852905,
-0.058312322944402695,
-0.3303244709968567,
-0.05318107455968857,
-0.34409743547439575,
0.03967245668172836,
-0.3626450002193451,
-0.2503027319908142,
-0.11531861126422882,
0.5917502045631409,
-0.2342819720506668,
0.058332573622465134,
0.3333258032798767,
-0.10074004530906677,
-0.312220960855484,
0.22034873068332672,
0.4687027931213379,
0.6410656571388245,
-0.3318745791912079,
-0.277551531791687,
0.25676652789115906,
-0.5113054513931274,
0.20302186906337738,
0.051737479865550995,
-0.3215753734111786,
0.014308820478618145,
-0.47602537274360657,
0.9742703437805176,
0.1463078260421753,
-0.9912493824958801,
0.4741269648075104,
-0.35701340436935425,
-0.20548111200332642,
-0.20204326510429382,
0.44219762086868286,
-0.2003403753042221,
0.2892260253429413,
0.24965327978134155,
0.22568482160568237,
0.5151703357696533,
-0.55982905626297,
0.17749854922294617,
0.5336098670959473,
-0.43090370297431946,
-0.5467764735221863,
0.8837959170341492,
0.7002725005149841,
-0.5517147779464722,
0.4681246280670166,
-0.13326074182987213,
-0.312124103307724,
0.42998185753822327,
0.5646798014640808,
0.8983418941497803,
-0.2127281278371811,
0.15139681100845337,
0.19667454063892365,
-0.05488201975822449,
-0.10129943490028381,
0.4546283781528473,
-0.2869037389755249,
-0.432167649269104,
-0.4269314110279083,
-0.48085054755210876,
-0.7784754633903503,
0.040636125952005386,
-0.6254292726516724,
0.25520089268684387,
-0.21208572387695312,
-0.6120736002922058,
-0.3340624272823334,
-0.028697671368718147,
-0.5882303714752197,
0.3941231369972229,
0.1961510181427002,
0.744410514831543,
-0.5038371682167053,
1.161103367805481,
0.8477080464363098,
0.26839569211006165,
-0.3972812294960022,
0.08757171034812927,
-0.022439414635300636,
-0.34051597118377686,
0.7327582240104675,
-0.04195515066385269,
-0.4336916506290436,
-0.054298918694257736,
-0.22358320653438568,
-0.5576509237289429,
1.0483648777008057,
0.5119470357894897,
-0.7289025187492371,
-0.00005759868145105429,
0.11535604298114777,
0.6821916103363037,
-0.630764901638031,
0.1788187474012375,
0.4911421239376068,
0.1850057691335678,
0.01072520762681961,
-1.2791484594345093,
-0.001915670814923942,
-0.10336975008249283,
0.03892708942294121,
0.02961055375635624,
-0.48840129375457764,
0.4624743163585663,
-0.5107625126838684,
-0.2575947046279907,
0.3607845902442932,
0.6910275816917419,
0.1277972161769867,
0.6462767720222473,
1.0082846879959106,
0.5446921586990356,
0.6485334634780884,
-0.12367424368858337,
0.9880872964859009,
-0.6067084074020386,
0.2627491056919098,
1.103589415550232,
-0.7454789280891418,
0.5652962923049927,
0.565612256526947,
0.08945303410291672,
0.5748652219772339,
0.08549158275127411,
0.21347233653068542,
0.32869449257850647,
0.24149903655052185,
-0.30556720495224,
-0.5476453304290771,
-0.17449058592319489,
0.004381739068776369,
0.5050743222236633,
0.5545752048492432,
0.14684683084487915,
0.08795177191495895,
0.009948023594915867,
-0.09047309309244156,
0.26623356342315674,
-0.04107573628425598,
0.9652836918830872,
0.252069890499115,
-0.8534433841705322,
0.6972999572753906,
-0.043610937893390656,
0.5361236929893494,
-0.38444024324417114,
-0.24191132187843323,
-0.27218151092529297,
0.2218383103609085,
0.008490766398608685,
-0.44859081506729126,
0.18799760937690735,
0.13305671513080597,
0.00037689233431592584,
-0.34049931168556213,
0.7829570770263672,
-0.3728858232498169,
-0.05935893952846527,
0.34451472759246826,
0.7390194535255432,
0.16049207746982574,
0.06418244540691376,
-0.6042643189430237,
0.2293270230293274,
0.06044289097189903,
-0.18555106222629547,
0.26046156883239746,
0.39141765236854553,
-0.19718696177005768,
0.9079844951629639,
0.414239764213562,
-0.2547231614589691,
-0.25168919563293457,
0.22945304214954376,
0.8996466398239136,
-0.6175516247749329,
-0.33953118324279785,
-0.5473911762237549,
0.3929295539855957,
-0.2734050750732422,
-0.2811821699142456,
0.9871208667755127,
0.6605471968650818,
0.7872558832168579,
-0.13570719957351685,
0.8646540641784668,
0.1266796886920929,
0.5865447521209717,
-0.13100799918174744,
0.5406643748283386,
-0.6810701489448547,
0.4072857201099396,
-0.3066862225532532,
-0.9456637501716614,
-0.09973622113466263,
0.360155314207077,
-0.2482995241880417,
0.07874471694231033,
0.2945360243320465,
0.7723109722137451,
-0.3115023374557495,
0.03771726414561272,
0.7498710751533508,
0.20844270288944244,
0.23439745604991913,
0.1781528890132904,
1.035154104232788,
-0.46003755927085876,
0.36288538575172424,
-0.2686839699745178,
-0.23910968005657196,
-0.511359691619873,
-0.5787306427955627,
-1.042716145515442,
-0.4243772029876709,
-0.6343144178390503,
-0.17674998939037323,
0.35932034254074097,
0.8261474967002869,
0.9240782856941223,
-0.7575944066047668,
-0.5564166307449341,
0.11475338041782379,
-0.14686551690101624,
-0.26437726616859436,
-0.17499540746212006,
-0.19597694277763367,
-0.44345471262931824,
-1.144997000694275,
0.5058484077453613,
0.6169695258140564,
0.11366274207830429,
-0.09933268278837204,
-0.44142624735832214,
0.29506582021713257,
0.46578249335289,
0.5588772892951965,
0.12539900839328766,
-1.0198440551757812,
-0.3789534270763397,
0.12014371156692505,
-0.32715046405792236,
0.12309901416301727,
0.9116451144218445,
-1.0446096658706665,
0.644072949886322,
0.030073687434196472,
0.3166089355945587,
0.41109150648117065,
0.27968961000442505,
0.8024864196777344,
-0.5359174609184265,
0.016394924372434616,
0.14619936048984528,
0.39673012495040894,
0.3616202771663666,
-0.2576279640197754,
0.24368686974048615,
0.14276669919490814,
-0.4918588697910309,
-1.0286859273910522,
0.3180025815963745,
-1.4841519594192505,
0.11902528256177902,
1.20183265209198,
-0.5524096488952637,
0.08779488503932953,
-0.3681340515613556,
-0.719155490398407,
0.14667698740959167,
-0.6482803821563721,
1.023833155632019,
0.4064176082611084,
-0.15718969702720642,
0.22524037957191467,
-0.5360055565834045,
0.6938952803611755,
0.7227680683135986,
-0.9871652722358704,
0.39059439301490784,
0.7207927703857422,
0.23182253539562225,
-0.003383973613381386,
0.601008951663971,
0.13491377234458923,
0.18793423473834991,
-0.10868171602487564,
-0.03872847557067871,
-0.12868276238441467,
-0.41714033484458923,
0.028385132551193237,
-0.17671149969100952,
0.2526174485683441,
0.016327761113643646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13372v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13372v2
|
EvoGrad: A Dynamic Take on the Winograd Schema Challenge with Human Adversaries
| 2024-02-20T20:53:24 | 2024-02-22T18:29:00 |
Jing Han Sun, Ali Emami
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at the Winograd Schema Challenge
(WSC), a coreference resolution task testing common-sense reasoning through
pronoun disambiguation, they struggle with instances that feature minor
alterations or rewording. To address this, we introduce EvoGrad, an open-source
platform that harnesses a human-in-the-loop approach to create a dynamic
dataset tailored to such altered WSC instances. Leveraging ChatGPT's
capabilities, we expand our task instances from 182 to 3,691, setting a new
benchmark for diverse common-sense reasoning datasets. Additionally, we
introduce the error depth metric, assessing model stability in dynamic tasks.
Our results emphasize the challenge posed by EvoGrad: Even the best performing
LLM, GPT-3.5, achieves an accuracy of 65.0% with an average error depth of 7.2,
a stark contrast to human performance of 92. 8% accuracy without perturbation
errors. This highlights ongoing model limitations and the value of dynamic
datasets in uncovering them.
|
[
-0.17326728999614716,
-0.9090168476104736,
0.5216200351715088,
-0.4110901951789856,
-0.13466297090053558,
0.5624556541442871,
-0.5471068024635315,
-0.49722856283187866,
-0.31500813364982605,
0.3934347927570343,
-0.3761366605758667,
-0.5851570963859558,
-0.7204375267028809,
0.03954174742102623,
-0.2183280736207962,
0.6618527173995972,
-0.2639881670475006,
-0.3175921142101288,
-0.434246301651001,
-0.29183492064476013,
-0.4703969359397888,
-0.48457372188568115,
-0.10475153475999832,
-0.25447431206703186,
0.3499543368816376,
0.8376107215881348,
0.8703468441963196,
0.3016020953655243,
0.7628893852233887,
0.3002207279205322,
-0.3330194354057312,
0.4604012072086334,
-0.360552579164505,
0.6827939748764038,
-0.2637021243572235,
-0.25235727429389954,
-0.38608893752098083,
-0.0071799615398049355,
0.40987950563430786,
0.8394418358802795,
-0.7556766867637634,
0.11952997744083405,
-0.12530508637428284,
0.40327727794647217,
-0.2779235243797302,
0.22047674655914307,
-0.9036601781845093,
-0.26142674684524536,
-0.4272257685661316,
0.3597143292427063,
-0.26684290170669556,
-0.10885220021009445,
0.3339720070362091,
-0.893600344657898,
0.3636980950832367,
0.478529691696167,
1.117485761642456,
0.4303017854690552,
-0.432621031999588,
-0.3739035725593567,
-0.8567410707473755,
0.6386568546295166,
-0.51444411277771,
0.29318878054618835,
0.02780907414853573,
0.5349282622337341,
-0.6170721054077148,
-0.6840450763702393,
-0.6232531666755676,
-0.49712756276130676,
0.01558863464742899,
-0.04469170793890953,
-0.3752940595149994,
0.17161378264427185,
0.45596808195114136,
0.3687129020690918,
-0.5700574517250061,
-0.0002758398768492043,
-0.3305859863758087,
-0.07777515798807144,
0.4427294433116913,
0.30081814527511597,
0.17345938086509705,
0.09207189083099365,
0.1441514790058136,
-0.20777767896652222,
-0.6429839730262756,
-0.055167946964502335,
0.4364135265350342,
0.30842432379722595,
0.255555659532547,
0.7104185223579407,
-0.35684308409690857,
0.8205122947692871,
0.31155118346214294,
-0.09632103145122528,
0.38213977217674255,
-0.1306489109992981,
-0.17901581525802612,
0.059786517173051834,
0.43949493765830994,
0.13149654865264893,
-0.07503988593816757,
0.016908196732401848,
0.016025017946958542,
0.3038536012172699,
0.09681233763694763,
-0.33701202273368835,
-0.2996993958950043,
0.23505260050296783,
-0.11582240462303162,
-0.24385428428649902,
-0.05263567343354225,
-0.49618735909461975,
-0.4872798025608063,
-0.47086235880851746,
0.2714630961418152,
-0.6624943614006042,
-0.24306334555149078,
0.49464255571365356,
0.08704105764627457,
0.054441679269075394,
0.6254236698150635,
-0.4764346182346344,
0.35001903772354126,
0.7082200050354004,
0.604375958442688,
0.016052106395363808,
-0.2890830338001251,
-0.37552469968795776,
0.10261798650026321,
-0.2014179229736328,
1.013579249382019,
-0.7697351574897766,
-0.3434479236602783,
-0.49489641189575195,
0.024363532662391663,
-0.08709530532360077,
-0.6577765345573425,
0.5909973978996277,
-0.09990040957927704,
0.2669070065021515,
-0.3435942530632019,
-0.6176172494888306,
-0.0942225456237793,
0.3967485725879669,
-0.452761709690094,
1.304235816001892,
0.2741173505783081,
-0.8473820090293884,
0.3351169526576996,
-0.5862604975700378,
-0.2565685212612152,
0.2932009994983673,
-0.19037321209907532,
-0.1035759299993515,
0.3478204309940338,
-0.09380699694156647,
0.1183321624994278,
-0.4409136474132538,
0.5502249002456665,
-0.24745802581310272,
-0.25316157937049866,
-0.06348162144422531,
-0.11248099058866501,
0.5331418514251709,
0.1667989045381546,
-0.2215012162923813,
0.23047898709774017,
-1.1032177209854126,
-0.2879761755466461,
0.29630738496780396,
-0.23707211017608643,
-0.44681352376937866,
0.4079895317554474,
-0.5215508341789246,
0.15027020871639252,
0.09654717892408371,
-0.7741058468818665,
0.4064125418663025,
-0.1740918904542923,
0.44059592485427856,
0.6269078850746155,
-0.35106080770492554,
0.15493133664131165,
-0.16633494198322296,
0.6312500834465027,
-0.12272290140390396,
0.11085826903581619,
-0.10706065595149994,
-0.4802158772945404,
-0.7024553418159485,
-0.3571888208389282,
0.3449710011482239,
0.7486581802368164,
-0.4934520423412323,
0.33113428950309753,
-0.3246505856513977,
-0.8570132255554199,
-0.6007523536682129,
-0.09749525785446167,
0.08507341891527176,
0.6823434829711914,
0.1961427479982376,
-0.12153412401676178,
-0.4383070468902588,
-1.0329113006591797,
-0.3276924788951874,
-0.44977593421936035,
-0.1351737380027771,
0.2808610796928406,
0.5898526310920715,
-0.09813911467790604,
0.8288991451263428,
-0.28675106167793274,
-0.10607576370239258,
-0.2523009479045868,
0.30490928888320923,
0.4105278253555298,
0.3149504065513611,
0.18832676112651825,
-0.350838303565979,
-0.3374680280685425,
0.1524973064661026,
-0.6470562815666199,
-0.23068368434906006,
0.01067902147769928,
-0.1806805431842804,
-0.08169782161712646,
0.4467143714427948,
-0.8465710878372192,
0.1913297325372696,
0.686964213848114,
-0.6341232061386108,
0.9131256937980652,
-0.3596554398536682,
-0.09122658520936966,
-0.777515172958374,
0.16556930541992188,
-0.32003992795944214,
-0.2583632469177246,
-0.5460492968559265,
0.22927957773208618,
-0.1807180494070053,
0.037443045526742935,
-0.39412128925323486,
0.26390716433525085,
-0.5188887119293213,
0.1378215104341507,
0.09796182066202164,
0.12874972820281982,
-0.1308506727218628,
-0.01781413145363331,
-0.12062855064868927,
0.5176945328712463,
0.47245001792907715,
-0.3612987697124481,
0.928270161151886,
0.3307316303253174,
-0.7458316683769226,
0.8722962141036987,
-0.8336879014968872,
0.33578047156333923,
-0.19996440410614014,
0.27841717004776,
-0.7879952788352966,
-0.5045979022979736,
0.27015233039855957,
-0.2164604365825653,
0.29947322607040405,
0.05885050445795059,
-0.7400621771812439,
-0.4172699451446533,
0.060286011546850204,
0.2151108682155609,
0.393165647983551,
-0.4528158903121948,
0.6840154528617859,
0.42369571328163147,
-0.10468560457229614,
-0.5976414680480957,
-0.2952031195163727,
0.31101804971694946,
-0.248820498585701,
-0.7435899376869202,
0.5657438635826111,
-0.02701447904109955,
-0.6970158219337463,
0.06877591460943222,
-0.012090835720300674,
0.4786169230937958,
0.21217307448387146,
0.30790746212005615,
0.056099385023117065,
0.1069827601313591,
0.2892538905143738,
-0.04037094861268997,
-0.08040492236614227,
-0.13990247249603271,
-0.046594079583883286,
0.32466059923171997,
-0.6559473872184753,
-0.662356972694397,
-0.12476850301027298,
0.38265568017959595,
0.6788964867591858,
-0.1348763257265091,
0.4446262717247009,
0.08663218468427658,
-0.36592215299606323,
-0.014102648012340069,
-0.5437462329864502,
0.019598376005887985,
-0.4737130403518677,
0.5122637748718262,
-0.6121994853019714,
-1.1181862354278564,
0.6987301707267761,
-0.1411598175764084,
0.25947874784469604,
0.30175691843032837,
0.5384610295295715,
-0.25683215260505676,
0.914749264717102,
0.17059676349163055,
0.35948359966278076,
0.01853376440703869,
0.26347753405570984,
0.29575908184051514,
-0.6719624996185303,
-0.4312223196029663,
-0.45003825426101685,
-0.46970853209495544,
-0.42793020606040955,
-0.5639283061027527,
0.2080252766609192,
-0.007171156350523233,
-0.493101567029953,
0.2823030948638916,
-0.5988794565200806,
0.3885887861251831,
0.6129196286201477,
0.03343211114406586,
0.45858851075172424,
-0.05335504934191704,
-0.24508512020111084,
-0.24632495641708374,
-0.651310920715332,
-0.4797617793083191,
0.7087087631225586,
0.3605903089046478,
0.8578228950500488,
0.171873077750206,
0.14418482780456543,
0.1569884717464447,
0.12681016325950623,
-0.6359383463859558,
0.6611624360084534,
-0.012939671985805035,
-0.6004284024238586,
-0.30207812786102295,
-0.1779085248708725,
-0.9100193977355957,
0.36464330554008484,
0.0009314295020885766,
-0.5304046273231506,
0.12635713815689087,
0.3673321604728699,
-0.28427764773368835,
0.33239883184432983,
-0.2570051848888397,
0.7606098651885986,
-0.39558327198028564,
-0.18999673426151276,
-0.05640439689159393,
-0.6790817379951477,
0.20094645023345947,
0.10352620482444763,
0.2836267352104187,
-0.6920791864395142,
0.07924481481313705,
0.4433193504810333,
-0.47522270679473877,
0.7567650675773621,
-0.18789853155612946,
-0.12090127915143967,
0.4789264500141144,
0.4235953986644745,
0.8188576698303223,
-0.16594985127449036,
-0.011195098981261253,
0.16298697888851166,
-0.16370099782943726,
-0.36186540126800537,
-0.3786010146141052,
0.4599088728427887,
-0.40904533863067627,
-0.7345629930496216,
-0.686896026134491,
-0.6101293563842773,
-0.3335481584072113,
0.12149490416049957,
0.23456820845603943,
0.17558926343917847,
-0.4932575821876526,
0.36950716376304626,
0.6791098117828369,
-0.3298228979110718,
-0.06436173617839813,
0.4614028036594391,
-0.053530361503362656,
-0.07230757176876068,
0.5754512548446655,
0.08549059927463531,
0.2887571454048157,
0.021238110959529877,
0.23004202544689178,
-0.045688942074775696,
-0.6924411654472351,
-0.46618908643722534,
0.25616002082824707,
-0.7636286020278931,
-0.1633875072002411,
-0.4887581169605255,
0.19400562345981598,
-0.041017305105924606,
-0.006267854943871498,
-0.5999116897583008,
-0.3985068202018738,
-0.08401522785425186,
-0.3291824460029602,
0.4787048101425171,
0.5742281675338745,
-0.12748700380325317,
0.30432531237602234,
-0.49908646941185,
-0.1892527937889099,
0.2584441602230072,
0.21505089104175568,
-0.48332738876342773,
-0.742321252822876,
0.03756968304514885,
-0.15677280724048615,
-0.14758041501045227,
-0.8253001570701599,
0.3508923649787903,
0.39688724279403687,
0.6855467557907104,
0.1484900861978531,
0.07688866555690765,
0.6495844721794128,
-0.4563353657722473,
0.8886090517044067,
-0.034694429486989975,
-1.0937440395355225,
0.5950276255607605,
-0.671139657497406,
0.40711334347724915,
0.6242282390594482,
-0.06320878863334656,
-0.8735984563827515,
-0.555506706237793,
-0.772669792175293,
-1.0028408765792847,
0.42973044514656067,
0.07526632398366928,
-0.0836125910282135,
-0.05666762962937355,
0.42248523235321045,
0.3640994429588318,
0.28312844038009644,
0.030684294179081917,
0.1237793117761612,
0.004015770275145769,
-0.27850696444511414,
0.22513997554779053,
-0.22292718291282654,
-0.08279796689748764,
-0.3808213174343109,
0.47310933470726013,
-0.25849834084510803,
0.1831415295600891,
0.05472900718450546,
-0.22813737392425537,
0.029256850481033325,
0.32235148549079895,
0.7293938994407654,
0.7681122422218323,
-0.351023405790329,
0.4002766013145447,
0.44785070419311523,
-0.3796893060207367,
0.16208672523498535,
-0.050176918506622314,
-0.04477304220199585,
0.20308879017829895,
0.37284642457962036,
0.8603689670562744,
0.38632649183273315,
-1.0848499536514282,
0.3112400770187378,
-0.13170315325260162,
-0.4750918745994568,
-0.38927221298217773,
-0.0664982944726944,
0.23891755938529968,
0.08794473111629486,
0.2454690933227539,
0.09287021309137344,
-0.21035531163215637,
-0.31866100430488586,
0.17212873697280884,
0.3018772602081299,
-0.19470790028572083,
-0.6243862509727478,
0.6647590398788452,
0.1927051991224289,
-0.04569656774401665,
0.8247277140617371,
-0.4145719110965729,
-0.5771318078041077,
0.5840675234794617,
0.3276427984237671,
0.49109283089637756,
-0.5343315601348877,
0.18591469526290894,
0.36324843764305115,
0.39925023913383484,
-0.43517276644706726,
0.5150937438011169,
0.3249239921569824,
-0.8914760947227478,
-0.4170992970466614,
-0.23650462925434113,
-0.7497856616973877,
0.12893304228782654,
-0.7292107939720154,
0.42358213663101196,
-0.40452834963798523,
-0.09706678241491318,
-0.22800737619400024,
-0.1560392528772354,
-0.7701257467269897,
-0.09341650456190109,
0.10135219991207123,
0.8529021739959717,
-0.7061488032341003,
0.7752372622489929,
0.9014018177986145,
0.14761117100715637,
-0.4513474404811859,
-0.47719863057136536,
0.23357169330120087,
-0.4716702103614807,
0.5099846720695496,
-0.07484890520572662,
-0.15184953808784485,
-0.19434475898742676,
-0.6852359175682068,
-1.0457826852798462,
1.1640979051589966,
0.5684846043586731,
-1.1178529262542725,
-0.07880116999149323,
-0.027051370590925217,
0.5790289640426636,
-0.39844492077827454,
0.2420540452003479,
0.859487771987915,
0.650037407875061,
0.01167161576449871,
-1.1703218221664429,
0.05097643658518791,
-0.13748399913311005,
-0.23538881540298462,
0.10005728155374527,
-0.680179238319397,
0.8976808786392212,
-0.30686864256858826,
-0.2638656795024872,
-0.19625452160835266,
0.6620005965232849,
0.4461410939693451,
0.09167109429836273,
0.7608031630516052,
0.7314850091934204,
1.3411122560501099,
-0.21616019308567047,
0.8949277400970459,
-0.09041612595319748,
0.4364611804485321,
1.4367731809616089,
-0.626550555229187,
0.6616488695144653,
0.4574916958808899,
-0.3128049969673157,
0.6077656149864197,
0.8378053307533264,
-0.13230478763580322,
0.4068969190120697,
0.41842159628868103,
-0.30755680799484253,
-0.5201175808906555,
-0.038301993161439896,
-0.31442350149154663,
0.574356734752655,
0.7486910223960876,
0.036939773708581924,
-0.22681006789207458,
0.06679697334766388,
0.28172746300697327,
0.08232685178518295,
0.10602913051843643,
0.3925118148326874,
-0.18336866796016693,
-0.45825400948524475,
0.3448009490966797,
-0.2232581526041031,
0.6443822383880615,
-0.3797096908092499,
0.07259085029363632,
-0.2228831946849823,
0.3259398639202118,
0.10068798065185547,
-0.6158724427223206,
0.34715306758880615,
-0.06002378463745117,
0.009487253613770008,
0.059201229363679886,
0.7870541214942932,
-0.46090036630630493,
-0.6102728247642517,
0.21088635921478271,
0.49738359451293945,
0.08548414707183838,
-0.09944755584001541,
-0.7662492394447327,
0.18964658677577972,
-0.032369717955589294,
-0.503757119178772,
0.2519221901893616,
0.41841670870780945,
-0.14344613254070282,
0.6773605942726135,
0.4551619589328766,
0.1756373792886734,
-0.060431841760873795,
-0.23588056862354279,
0.7879891395568848,
-0.628494381904602,
-0.21031862497329712,
-0.6914647817611694,
0.3774993419647217,
-0.2875160276889801,
-0.4777889549732208,
0.6293513774871826,
0.3301282823085785,
0.9187821745872498,
0.09540146589279175,
1.0220673084259033,
-0.3340104818344116,
0.9371445178985596,
-0.11472445726394653,
0.3448162376880646,
-0.42155835032463074,
0.2784689664840698,
-0.03260180354118347,
-0.6752174496650696,
-0.46657490730285645,
0.6533007025718689,
-0.17156334221363068,
-0.4554714262485504,
0.6757775545120239,
0.8293988704681396,
-0.03360452502965927,
-0.094578817486763,
0.25451549887657166,
0.3659363389015198,
0.5579827427864075,
0.776913583278656,
1.1285096406936646,
-0.13722431659698486,
0.6173906922340393,
-0.2760888338088989,
-0.3144553601741791,
-0.3709937036037445,
-1.2048866748809814,
-0.6579442024230957,
-0.501213550567627,
-0.5705737471580505,
-0.5440083742141724,
0.34853503108024597,
1.0659990310668945,
0.4617829918861389,
-0.7829681038856506,
-0.004651563707739115,
-0.057608991861343384,
-0.13058380782604218,
-0.48123160004615784,
-0.11503253877162933,
0.35696959495544434,
0.003238087287172675,
-0.7222201824188232,
0.7301020622253418,
0.08949639648199081,
-0.20726701617240906,
-0.030192820355296135,
-0.033548224717378616,
0.17503386735916138,
0.018218321725726128,
0.556736409664154,
0.3085286617279053,
-0.9288316369056702,
-0.7939250469207764,
0.13492028415203094,
0.03520522639155388,
-0.02446894720196724,
0.8431374430656433,
-0.703475832939148,
0.6656681299209595,
0.6543880105018616,
0.3568042516708374,
0.17754963040351868,
0.12830549478530884,
0.5845912098884583,
-0.5105425715446472,
0.18556702136993408,
0.35878607630729675,
0.3587951958179474,
0.38323262333869934,
-0.29847538471221924,
0.5730457901954651,
0.5207831263542175,
-0.6679926514625549,
-1.2257428169250488,
0.2839539647102356,
-0.9684672951698303,
-0.31867098808288574,
1.2199771404266357,
-0.14787128567695618,
-0.1361977458000183,
-0.4409814178943634,
-0.35394442081451416,
0.026323508471250534,
-0.5115864276885986,
0.7519477009773254,
1.0514417886734009,
-0.3465290665626526,
-0.24155302345752716,
-0.6381163001060486,
0.47853392362594604,
0.4481657147407532,
-0.5521088242530823,
0.4603618383407593,
0.6240460276603699,
0.35340243577957153,
0.011163064278662205,
0.36776283383369446,
-0.03051934204995632,
0.08309099078178406,
0.1401495784521103,
0.2535446882247925,
-0.4913715720176697,
-0.24506211280822754,
-0.0929567888379097,
0.21525247395038605,
0.11421388387680054,
-0.10671024024486542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14858v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14858v1
|
ChatEL: Entity Linking with Chatbots
| 2024-02-20T20:52:57 | 2024-02-20T20:52:57 |
Yifan Ding, Qingkai Zeng, Tim Weninger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Entity Linking (EL) is an essential and challenging task in natural language
processing that seeks to link some text representing an entity within a
document or sentence with its corresponding entry in a dictionary or knowledge
base. Most existing approaches focus on creating elaborate contextual models
that look for clues the words surrounding the entity-text to help solve the
linking problem. Although these fine-tuned language models tend to work, they
can be unwieldy, difficult to train, and do not transfer well to other domains.
Fortunately, Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT provide a highly-advanced
solution to the problems inherent in EL models, but simply naive prompts to
LLMs do not work well. In the present work, we define ChatEL, which is a
three-step framework to prompt LLMs to return accurate results. Overall the
ChatEL framework improves the average F1 performance across 10 datasets by more
than 2%. Finally, a thorough error analysis shows many instances with the
ground truth labels were actually incorrect, and the labels predicted by ChatEL
were actually correct. This indicates that the quantitative results presented
in this paper may be a conservative estimate of the actual performance. All
data and code are available as an open-source package on GitHub at
https://github.com/yifding/In_Context_EL.
|
[
-0.286211222410202,
-0.8378698229789734,
0.46963420510292053,
0.10433942079544067,
0.1792885810136795,
0.005927165038883686,
-0.45341530442237854,
-0.7939097881317139,
-0.21704301238059998,
0.28479471802711487,
-0.4329318702220917,
-0.6691203117370605,
-0.5004522800445557,
0.11450128257274628,
-0.8055518865585327,
1.127506971359253,
0.15961633622646332,
-0.19018134474754333,
-0.3645561635494232,
0.05486898869276047,
-0.1521756649017334,
-0.24987663328647614,
-0.9543095827102661,
-0.28735628724098206,
0.5983104705810547,
0.3021722137928009,
0.9934667348861694,
0.44620025157928467,
0.5195303559303284,
0.3083232045173645,
0.0078702038154006,
0.33458301424980164,
-0.7255343794822693,
0.4211691617965698,
-0.2269425094127655,
-0.5170716643333435,
-0.5070078372955322,
-0.40335482358932495,
0.37146174907684326,
0.6515041589736938,
0.028955809772014618,
-0.12353666871786118,
0.1591014713048935,
0.8570484519004822,
-0.3999043405056,
0.5268980860710144,
-0.9834219217300415,
-0.4115432798862457,
-0.11508496850728989,
0.033028844743967056,
-0.5778679847717285,
-0.4079073369503021,
0.45112350583076477,
-0.7874805331230164,
0.38950756192207336,
0.5422033667564392,
1.0363119840621948,
0.34085437655448914,
-0.3122518062591553,
-0.7732889652252197,
-0.7061142921447754,
0.443654865026474,
-0.5473242402076721,
0.3850117623806,
0.4427666962146759,
0.1384078860282898,
-0.2299405187368393,
-0.7084104418754578,
-0.6741853952407837,
-0.37486428022384644,
-0.273986279964447,
-0.16658523678779602,
-0.25413206219673157,
0.25950586795806885,
0.25997358560562134,
0.12263592332601547,
-0.5735346078872681,
-0.031078042462468147,
-0.20735721290111542,
-0.03367064148187637,
0.6604578495025635,
0.013955807313323021,
0.35504359006881714,
-0.12241099029779434,
-0.37096455693244934,
-0.13298414647579193,
-0.966395914554596,
-0.3698045611381531,
0.3428666889667511,
0.4741266369819641,
-0.12888459861278534,
0.6706958413124084,
0.14939439296722412,
0.5983603596687317,
-0.030775872990489006,
0.08883090317249298,
0.20005688071250916,
-0.17698925733566284,
-0.13574646413326263,
0.03505687788128853,
0.8786829710006714,
0.34292903542518616,
0.7807580828666687,
-0.2682327330112457,
-0.27997392416000366,
0.044292572885751724,
0.1572369486093521,
-0.8224667310714722,
-0.4459458887577057,
0.42578500509262085,
-0.15004000067710876,
-0.21880769729614258,
-0.2628099024295807,
-0.678788959980011,
-0.20857495069503784,
-0.31940552592277527,
0.3493357300758362,
-0.9240849614143372,
-0.10566404461860657,
0.06288515031337738,
0.42515960335731506,
0.21020032465457916,
0.48945656418800354,
-0.8673475384712219,
0.2545565962791443,
0.7130463123321533,
0.8858767747879028,
-0.14464956521987915,
-0.08890537172555923,
-0.32041439414024353,
0.29171258211135864,
-0.18241024017333984,
1.008884072303772,
-0.7438197135925293,
-0.5082880854606628,
0.40127837657928467,
-0.012364869937300682,
-0.4348420202732086,
-0.4495042860507965,
0.6233001947402954,
-0.7490617036819458,
0.23681774735450745,
-0.18236355483531952,
-1.0844906568527222,
-0.08408786356449127,
0.10026116669178009,
-0.7344693541526794,
1.0700554847717285,
-0.12846364080905914,
-0.7308366298675537,
0.03995637223124504,
-0.8325328826904297,
-0.503134548664093,
0.06633098423480988,
-0.12781432271003723,
-0.3965294659137726,
-0.2309110462665558,
0.2633461356163025,
0.48532822728157043,
-0.3894738554954529,
0.4538518190383911,
-0.2650523781776428,
-0.2853127419948578,
0.11237522214651108,
-0.3351037800312042,
0.6015288233757019,
0.24507993459701538,
-0.15369769930839539,
0.05892203748226166,
-0.6691091656684875,
-0.1862988919019699,
0.10597182810306549,
-0.19070707261562347,
-0.4198874235153198,
0.27181631326675415,
0.11244708299636841,
0.03992336615920067,
0.08963201195001602,
-0.2525283098220825,
0.17648039758205414,
-0.662068784236908,
0.23695603013038635,
0.6227408647537231,
-0.16316565871238708,
0.48413947224617004,
-0.39290356636047363,
0.10745637863874435,
-0.024107109755277634,
-0.2488265037536621,
-0.49775010347366333,
-0.6979846954345703,
-1.10277259349823,
-0.0961877629160881,
0.39375320076942444,
0.5612527132034302,
-0.96468186378479,
0.3686850070953369,
-0.3810475766658783,
-0.4496610164642334,
-0.4573139548301697,
0.027827156707644463,
0.3464388847351074,
0.6984514594078064,
0.47071853280067444,
0.24881450831890106,
-0.3527219295501709,
-0.9543213248252869,
-0.1366654485464096,
-0.5689371228218079,
-0.49721384048461914,
0.42256709933280945,
0.7577975392341614,
-0.1733577698469162,
0.8386117219924927,
-0.42427754402160645,
-0.3767641484737396,
0.10707473754882812,
0.11251483112573624,
0.16768859326839447,
0.3683479130268097,
0.5418477654457092,
-0.7738757729530334,
-0.6228023171424866,
0.1620008945465088,
-0.7027348279953003,
-0.0046773343347013,
0.0365888737142086,
-0.10732725262641907,
0.24369405210018158,
0.465207576751709,
-0.6647679805755615,
0.14642004668712616,
0.6386948227882385,
-0.14987656474113464,
0.4242393374443054,
-0.03298273682594299,
0.16622766852378845,
-1.0461838245391846,
0.12165561318397522,
0.3638322949409485,
-0.16539686918258667,
-0.5445254445075989,
-0.26052287220954895,
0.001329056336544454,
-0.16679677367210388,
-0.5065047740936279,
0.6041489243507385,
-0.34518367052078247,
0.06548947840929031,
-0.0664803683757782,
0.36747294664382935,
-0.15525458753108978,
0.7072153091430664,
-0.008291440084576607,
1.130149483680725,
0.657050371170044,
-0.6662106513977051,
0.48898643255233765,
0.44140103459358215,
-0.037684034556150436,
0.924445390701294,
-0.8991819024085999,
0.18943087756633759,
-0.2611963450908661,
0.18614354729652405,
-1.1060447692871094,
-0.41722553968429565,
0.24437424540519714,
-0.46892690658569336,
0.46907490491867065,
-0.1582363396883011,
-0.47672349214553833,
-0.1221192330121994,
-0.15287014842033386,
0.25150424242019653,
0.23511424660682678,
-0.5975905060768127,
0.7327688932418823,
0.41258054971694946,
-0.07729160785675049,
-0.274809330701828,
-0.2983950674533844,
0.01365942694246769,
-0.12220484018325806,
-1.0145270824432373,
0.6886764764785767,
-0.0742555782198906,
-0.1447010040283203,
0.25920501351356506,
-0.050487834960222244,
-0.2205202579498291,
-0.1469321846961975,
0.27714720368385315,
0.4143450856208801,
-0.37276527285575867,
0.5476438403129578,
-0.27562883496284485,
-0.23058561980724335,
0.118450827896595,
-0.22874364256858826,
0.2761777639389038,
-0.3896251916885376,
-0.5051578879356384,
-0.3686622977256775,
0.24154032766819,
0.38496237993240356,
-0.05539115518331528,
0.953708827495575,
0.322907418012619,
-0.6311323642730713,
-0.1605035662651062,
-0.5341415405273438,
-0.20431464910507202,
-0.45944392681121826,
0.45633548498153687,
-0.4180622398853302,
-0.9862584471702576,
0.3975021243095398,
-0.1278284788131714,
0.19548670947551727,
0.38828474283218384,
0.5267328023910522,
-0.42213794589042664,
0.7104233503341675,
0.5570278167724609,
-0.21472330391407013,
0.15654607117176056,
0.03983171656727791,
0.4255342483520508,
-0.5057368278503418,
-0.43682989478111267,
-0.8365098237991333,
-0.1263175755739212,
-0.7885100841522217,
-0.5347083806991577,
0.3701004087924957,
-0.07543353736400604,
-0.28773415088653564,
0.6098300814628601,
-0.18620730936527252,
0.4540460407733917,
0.40890631079673767,
0.06325652450323105,
0.47066953778266907,
0.01126840990036726,
-0.07083190232515335,
0.060444530099630356,
-0.806501030921936,
-0.6590597033500671,
1.084203839302063,
0.31141114234924316,
0.9659884572029114,
0.11740054190158844,
0.30376943945884705,
0.4070068299770355,
0.4283182919025421,
-0.6616557836532593,
0.5617566108703613,
0.10641500353813171,
-0.7171537280082703,
-0.3922010362148285,
-0.16777166724205017,
-1.0879818201065063,
0.15248405933380127,
-0.4177655875682831,
-0.8350882530212402,
-0.175257608294487,
0.2380785197019577,
-0.10725675523281097,
0.320328027009964,
-0.8601975440979004,
0.7361581921577454,
-0.028740040957927704,
-0.529728353023529,
-0.023234542459249496,
-0.6389767527580261,
0.2753116488456726,
-0.10604138672351837,
0.2569614052772522,
-0.34326013922691345,
0.02337583154439926,
0.49014174938201904,
-0.2622487545013428,
0.8905103802680969,
0.2400324046611786,
-0.3877194821834564,
0.42632192373275757,
0.13337218761444092,
0.9100096225738525,
0.13424472510814667,
-0.06680527329444885,
0.25665774941444397,
-0.17682227492332458,
-0.2673377990722656,
-0.6014237999916077,
0.9305803775787354,
-0.721447765827179,
-0.42532894015312195,
-0.17596378922462463,
-0.3991503417491913,
-0.446938157081604,
-0.17141222953796387,
0.04517669603228569,
0.30236154794692993,
-0.28437986969947815,
0.26430708169937134,
1.0574268102645874,
-0.18884135782718658,
0.41992834210395813,
0.400906503200531,
-0.19931760430335999,
-0.03918716683983803,
0.6881712079048157,
-0.3408573865890503,
0.10312137752771378,
0.6394007802009583,
-0.4733293056488037,
-0.4901908040046692,
-0.1633196324110031,
-0.26431921124458313,
0.33095622062683105,
-0.5659351348876953,
-0.3556758463382721,
-0.7416300177574158,
-0.40064185857772827,
-0.08995699137449265,
-0.19657284021377563,
-0.6937716007232666,
-0.019481046125292778,
-0.1603662222623825,
0.034811217337846756,
0.41981571912765503,
0.3731262683868408,
0.2802504301071167,
0.22548507153987885,
-0.7598915100097656,
0.09597793966531754,
0.32322371006011963,
0.42749252915382385,
0.04363539069890976,
-0.12920823693275452,
-0.1939881145954132,
0.09637525677680969,
-0.11484234780073166,
-1.0575518608093262,
0.08553864061832428,
0.35953614115715027,
0.36990806460380554,
0.1582975685596466,
0.10529115051031113,
0.43974339962005615,
-0.6809272766113281,
0.5516074299812317,
0.15461093187332153,
-0.8304429054260254,
0.7145690321922302,
-0.5274739861488342,
-0.08267658203840256,
0.27008602023124695,
0.5780868530273438,
-0.5823965072631836,
-0.3971458375453949,
-0.6165302991867065,
-1.0541470050811768,
0.42349544167518616,
0.8464701175689697,
0.1782604455947876,
-0.35999754071235657,
0.1161828562617302,
-0.20539504289627075,
0.12453465908765793,
-0.5802162289619446,
-0.6093713045120239,
0.28997641801834106,
-0.29386502504348755,
0.29859089851379395,
-0.28310465812683105,
-0.05256165936589241,
0.13781234622001648,
0.9741309285163879,
-0.25482791662216187,
0.48426494002342224,
0.11278825253248215,
-0.4005577862262726,
-0.02724257856607437,
0.24398310482501984,
0.38610684871673584,
0.6197912096977234,
-0.10478444397449493,
-0.025735896080732346,
0.22594137489795685,
-0.10305197536945343,
0.037457652390003204,
0.22122734785079956,
-0.10016939043998718,
0.1882706582546234,
0.5090741515159607,
0.7185379862785339,
0.6140157580375671,
-0.6134776473045349,
0.6242319941520691,
0.0802643671631813,
-0.09445264935493469,
-0.36502256989479065,
0.28624916076660156,
0.34360530972480774,
0.29916682839393616,
0.3676797151565552,
0.05831322818994522,
-0.11780053377151489,
-0.11226876080036163,
0.43671125173568726,
0.31539788842201233,
-0.4061669707298279,
-0.3605538606643677,
0.996061384677887,
0.6961854696273804,
-0.35181424021720886,
0.6866109371185303,
-0.058045849204063416,
-0.3624431788921356,
0.49502524733543396,
0.4517751634120941,
0.7842894792556763,
-0.1504393219947815,
0.22062328457832336,
0.6882496476173401,
0.22743584215641022,
0.04513063281774521,
-0.33157533407211304,
0.10319007188081741,
-1.0100923776626587,
-0.7352059483528137,
-0.4795563519001007,
-0.5153223872184753,
0.05654672533273697,
-0.4060876667499542,
0.4170152544975281,
0.11458032578229904,
0.037863802164793015,
-0.015749197453260422,
-0.2781278192996979,
-0.8843796849250793,
0.07599927484989166,
0.2186983972787857,
0.9524765014648438,
-0.6686848998069763,
0.9136998653411865,
0.5771127343177795,
-0.40094438195228577,
-0.6310538649559021,
-0.05008283630013466,
0.1781560331583023,
-0.9331157207489014,
0.5725363492965698,
-0.05975279211997986,
-0.13530756533145905,
0.22294484078884125,
-0.5459550023078918,
-0.7841309309005737,
0.9885403513908386,
0.3663753569126129,
-0.9205029010772705,
-0.36449432373046875,
0.15887293219566345,
0.5023388266563416,
-0.4391041100025177,
0.4892981946468353,
0.3956173062324524,
0.3898070156574249,
0.3382769525051117,
-0.9363062381744385,
0.010014869272708893,
-0.06617650389671326,
0.14473901689052582,
0.18905843794345856,
-0.46617960929870605,
0.34398406744003296,
-0.2955738306045532,
-0.30628082156181335,
-0.0026536290533840656,
0.9482119679450989,
0.18497243523597717,
0.08456427603960037,
0.4854447841644287,
0.4577728509902954,
0.9234628677368164,
-0.24861927330493927,
0.8235510587692261,
-0.7031416296958923,
0.7173091769218445,
1.1721251010894775,
-0.4777550995349884,
0.8507128953933716,
0.3114229738712311,
-0.37440863251686096,
0.4279696047306061,
0.47894781827926636,
-0.038665611296892166,
0.3849412500858307,
0.11500865966081619,
-0.4753466546535492,
-0.1533300131559372,
-0.12801922857761383,
-0.4298841655254364,
0.2674294114112854,
0.555529773235321,
-0.3418937921524048,
-0.5270791053771973,
-0.28857123851776123,
0.30649903416633606,
0.14705340564250946,
-0.07244396209716797,
0.5258249640464783,
-0.002701399615034461,
-0.572974681854248,
0.3151547610759735,
-0.2151828110218048,
0.7026217579841614,
-0.4978700280189514,
-0.1978185474872589,
-0.27232658863067627,
-0.15693911910057068,
-0.1242370456457138,
-0.7680095434188843,
0.3773765563964844,
0.06723802536725998,
-0.10120344161987305,
-0.13996514678001404,
1.0231995582580566,
-0.603613018989563,
-0.2711339592933655,
0.30243217945098877,
0.6758863925933838,
0.038163695484399796,
-0.08574889600276947,
-0.8176916241645813,
0.03395631164312363,
0.0629565492272377,
-0.34787899255752563,
0.11250880360603333,
0.5110383033752441,
0.11329582333564758,
0.9270741939544678,
0.7709172964096069,
-0.32350268959999084,
-0.3231349289417267,
0.02455773390829563,
0.9422023892402649,
-0.6745142936706543,
-0.17559659481048584,
-0.9900566339492798,
0.535017192363739,
-0.20618195831775665,
-0.16079476475715637,
0.4691865146160126,
0.6853470802307129,
1.0168776512145996,
0.029262637719511986,
0.6762617230415344,
-0.14843636751174927,
0.3841765224933624,
-0.6554486155509949,
0.5743775367736816,
-0.286263644695282,
0.6153296232223511,
-0.29402652382850647,
-1.1542062759399414,
-0.25280678272247314,
0.6904568672180176,
-0.11829441040754318,
0.08837645500898361,
0.9392821192741394,
1.1368693113327026,
0.08919946104288101,
0.24429501593112946,
0.4871911406517029,
0.30859145522117615,
0.3420303761959076,
0.9191213846206665,
0.6986114978790283,
-0.5068770051002502,
0.7740955352783203,
0.00955271441489458,
0.08400625735521317,
-0.24571065604686737,
-0.9982951283454895,
-1.0643550157546997,
-0.7521941661834717,
-0.7153164744377136,
-0.5360684394836426,
0.43864554166793823,
1.0153939723968506,
0.771460235118866,
-0.8653309941291809,
0.006744489073753357,
-0.0994819849729538,
0.29881033301353455,
0.16634324193000793,
-0.2001619189977646,
0.41839712858200073,
-0.5404413342475891,
-1.0982115268707275,
0.21759149432182312,
0.3704952597618103,
0.026762282475829124,
-0.06176375597715378,
-0.1668061465024948,
-0.23980818688869476,
-0.14244316518306732,
0.5842246413230896,
0.12984219193458557,
-0.7024670839309692,
-0.5251558423042297,
-0.05103446543216705,
-0.36999398469924927,
0.14436663687229156,
0.5580379366874695,
-0.6819003820419312,
0.2479151040315628,
0.282773494720459,
0.9035816788673401,
0.5744264125823975,
-0.1720840483903885,
0.674368143081665,
-0.7778173685073853,
-0.02473895251750946,
0.19645956158638,
0.38687971234321594,
0.41988644003868103,
-0.22931045293807983,
0.8772280216217041,
0.20749041438102722,
-0.5827791690826416,
-0.37723469734191895,
0.13604262471199036,
-0.7957380414009094,
-0.07912539690732956,
1.344558596611023,
-0.18168680369853973,
-0.3935633599758148,
-0.09223663806915283,
-0.2186766415834427,
0.10851537436246872,
-0.5371491312980652,
0.6371267437934875,
0.8527436256408691,
-0.06388870626688004,
0.004268191289156675,
-0.7236010432243347,
0.6188859939575195,
0.15396304428577423,
-0.8615787625312805,
-0.12493369728326797,
0.6494346857070923,
0.2155972421169281,
0.12361223250627518,
0.5608623027801514,
0.13342031836509705,
-0.07642362266778946,
-0.08165422827005386,
0.05243062973022461,
0.19333170354366302,
-0.21177880465984344,
0.25062069296836853,
0.2030319720506668,
-0.07080091536045074,
-0.20175029337406158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13364v1
|
A Simple but Effective Approach to Improve Structured Language Model Output for Information Extraction
| 2024-02-20T20:42:02 | 2024-02-20T20:42:02 |
Yinghao Li, Rampi Ramprasad, Chao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive abilities in
generating unstructured natural language according to instructions. However,
their performance can be inconsistent when tasked with producing text that
adheres to specific structured formats, which is crucial in applications like
named entity recognition (NER) or relation extraction (RE). To address this
issue, this paper introduces an efficient method, G&O, to enhance their
structured text generation capabilities. It breaks the generation into a
two-step pipeline: initially, LLMs generate answers in natural language as
intermediate responses. Subsequently, LLMs are asked to organize the output
into the desired structure, using the intermediate responses as context. G&O
effectively separates the generation of content from the structuring process,
reducing the pressure of completing two orthogonal tasks simultaneously. Tested
on zero-shot NER and RE, the results indicate a significant improvement in LLM
performance with minimal additional efforts. This straightforward and adaptable
prompting technique can also be combined with other strategies, like
self-consistency, to further elevate LLM capabilities in various structured
text generation tasks.
|
[
0.04296748712658882,
-0.9383909106254578,
0.7842342257499695,
0.17578212916851044,
-0.41867977380752563,
-0.05484969541430473,
-0.46253547072410583,
-0.5433987379074097,
-0.005647073499858379,
0.5373116731643677,
-0.44086065888404846,
-0.5176843404769897,
-0.600904643535614,
0.24537460505962372,
-0.38899916410446167,
0.9863466024398804,
0.01405006181448698,
-0.15924885869026184,
-0.09247998893260956,
0.318185418844223,
-0.431171178817749,
-0.3399814963340759,
-0.9686800837516785,
-0.3483113944530487,
0.4360082149505615,
0.3127177655696869,
0.4068204164505005,
1.1090826988220215,
0.31986203789711,
0.3097632825374603,
-0.02871554158627987,
0.3934476673603058,
-0.5257711410522461,
0.48276159167289734,
-0.1984279751777649,
-0.06655922532081604,
-0.5450870394706726,
-0.16041365265846252,
0.7833898067474365,
0.5862608551979065,
-0.2772400975227356,
0.06523427367210388,
0.36605942249298096,
0.4578618109226227,
-0.5046363472938538,
0.3534652590751648,
-0.8713407516479492,
-0.1728798896074295,
-0.14169354736804962,
-0.4973140060901642,
-0.6677228808403015,
-0.09371455758810043,
-0.12997108697891235,
-0.6332625150680542,
0.06619860976934433,
-0.1129208356142044,
0.9472050070762634,
0.15016241371631622,
-0.21333621442317963,
-0.48103636503219604,
-0.8241080045700073,
0.7181636691093445,
-0.8598178029060364,
0.3895728588104248,
-0.03899194300174713,
0.08774584531784058,
-0.5150430798530579,
-0.7349951267242432,
-0.4949970245361328,
-0.24018877744674683,
-0.19553987681865692,
0.07315631955862045,
0.07406849414110184,
-0.03364182636141777,
0.3979841470718384,
0.2520281970500946,
-0.3386409282684326,
0.11219339072704315,
-0.32746514678001404,
-0.049921613186597824,
0.6973839402198792,
0.06309406459331512,
0.36693426966667175,
-0.47181984782218933,
-0.1875561773777008,
0.08132976293563843,
-0.8543608784675598,
0.01952105574309826,
0.525635302066803,
0.570401668548584,
0.13083310425281525,
0.6994954943656921,
-0.3234888017177582,
0.6535400748252869,
0.2518135905265808,
-0.42755550146102905,
0.014716565608978271,
-0.4364645779132843,
-0.29250991344451904,
0.02072928287088871,
0.9676342606544495,
0.09039386361837387,
0.33337000012397766,
-0.23862296342849731,
-0.3163641393184662,
-0.37895795702934265,
0.2750004231929779,
-1.0710777044296265,
-0.2897035777568817,
0.19965991377830505,
-0.39974603056907654,
-0.21075309813022614,
0.13311591744422913,
-0.7028985619544983,
-0.03105907328426838,
-0.3715096712112427,
0.15211983025074005,
-0.4498109817504883,
-0.025045940652489662,
-0.036002520471811295,
-0.13487063348293304,
0.19865326583385468,
0.5364184379577637,
-1.034995436668396,
0.3181329071521759,
0.6220645308494568,
0.6960798501968384,
-0.20749592781066895,
0.25954532623291016,
-1.1485404968261719,
0.4157966673374176,
-0.20964670181274414,
0.6004994511604309,
-0.5281991958618164,
-0.2911055088043213,
-0.1450115144252777,
-0.08987084031105042,
0.055305611342191696,
-0.5310225486755371,
0.3001718521118164,
-0.46037980914115906,
0.49245962500572205,
0.15416191518306732,
-0.5463919043540955,
0.18724477291107178,
0.23061101138591766,
-0.5530298948287964,
1.2211341857910156,
0.017907414585351944,
-0.5814676284790039,
0.18541863560676575,
-0.616008460521698,
-0.42337197065353394,
0.22148941457271576,
-0.5863145589828491,
-0.3089889883995056,
0.1674414426088333,
0.4635038375854492,
0.5195383429527283,
-0.173646479845047,
0.36096298694610596,
-0.0967910960316658,
-0.09671973437070847,
-0.1831485629081726,
-0.1380368173122406,
0.3995877802371979,
0.032523538917303085,
-0.25876322388648987,
0.09690375626087189,
-1.0570385456085205,
0.30591386556625366,
0.33672672510147095,
-0.962958037853241,
-0.35417819023132324,
0.24983051419258118,
-0.2167465090751648,
0.229442298412323,
0.2834777534008026,
-0.5438029766082764,
0.48767727613449097,
-0.6315290331840515,
0.4431650936603546,
0.6906799077987671,
0.20822349190711975,
0.6792004108428955,
0.22520998120307922,
0.38386449217796326,
-0.1448812335729599,
-0.2309790402650833,
-0.378365695476532,
-0.24685277044773102,
-0.5984129309654236,
-0.4002464711666107,
0.23395010828971863,
0.47028324007987976,
-0.9065554141998291,
0.4457288384437561,
-0.33619260787963867,
-0.24098479747772217,
-0.22461268305778503,
0.6118302345275879,
0.5761573910713196,
1.0195903778076172,
0.2572602331638336,
-0.23830772936344147,
-0.6958962678909302,
-0.6644023060798645,
-0.31088849902153015,
-0.19975975155830383,
-0.3632558584213257,
0.2028178572654724,
0.16790027916431427,
0.05124015361070633,
0.9782928824424744,
-0.6538164019584656,
0.11230393499135971,
-0.39834916591644287,
0.2727195620536804,
0.4746485650539398,
0.35423702001571655,
0.1388954371213913,
-0.6427198648452759,
-0.5701811909675598,
0.117442287504673,
-0.8280437588691711,
-0.2696766257286072,
-0.07035467773675919,
-0.2570430338382721,
0.27917054295539856,
0.6426571011543274,
-0.5394608378410339,
0.34031563997268677,
0.16354262828826904,
0.022811047732830048,
0.44894254207611084,
-0.09746921807527542,
-0.17664805054664612,
-1.090614914894104,
0.18317590653896332,
-0.18808934092521667,
-0.37425538897514343,
-0.7159995436668396,
-0.08518913388252258,
0.0419824942946434,
0.04724219813942909,
-0.390112966299057,
0.596486508846283,
-0.8741177320480347,
-0.03773226961493492,
-0.2315158247947693,
0.3704405725002289,
0.17182347178459167,
0.39804139733314514,
0.20538896322250366,
0.7032927870750427,
0.3504561185836792,
-0.7483219504356384,
0.1615402102470398,
0.3057933449745178,
-0.13068687915802002,
0.39439281821250916,
-0.8528273105621338,
0.4504704773426056,
-0.44606155157089233,
0.08113446831703186,
-0.9199986457824707,
-0.4225606918334961,
0.40920329093933105,
-0.3782559633255005,
0.6708305478096008,
-0.23628531396389008,
-0.42619428038597107,
0.004583677276968956,
-0.3939071297645569,
-0.0095468545332551,
0.36867478489875793,
-0.5053156018257141,
0.5805361270904541,
0.18936073780059814,
-0.6301977038383484,
-0.39255422353744507,
-0.3547810912132263,
0.10248176008462906,
-0.15237900614738464,
-0.6945449113845825,
0.37505772709846497,
-0.0652799978852272,
-0.22606316208839417,
-0.05832120031118393,
-0.18730077147483826,
-0.11261623352766037,
0.09377418458461761,
0.12810441851615906,
0.4430692493915558,
-0.4051949381828308,
0.3182542324066162,
-0.05840425565838814,
-0.025888748466968536,
-0.02394457906484604,
-0.20217199623584747,
0.5993928909301758,
0.27627497911453247,
-0.01398035604506731,
-0.2944338023662567,
0.565630316734314,
0.142953559756279,
-0.26266029477119446,
0.6351989507675171,
0.43527230620384216,
-0.3320131003856659,
-0.23959633708000183,
-0.29199638962745667,
-0.278857946395874,
-0.4440500736236572,
0.3893093764781952,
-0.3812437653541565,
-0.7864655256271362,
0.20565582811832428,
-0.10138127207756042,
0.3726572096347809,
0.39742425084114075,
0.4406531751155853,
0.04580451920628548,
1.085403323173523,
0.7366207838058472,
0.15742433071136475,
0.6326773166656494,
0.0651765987277031,
0.45160987973213196,
-0.9350878000259399,
-0.27250638604164124,
-0.6132267713546753,
-0.013618768192827702,
-0.28214654326438904,
-0.06034461408853531,
0.1917634904384613,
0.6090112924575806,
0.16866305470466614,
0.3994402289390564,
-0.5551365613937378,
0.3468814194202423,
0.36665648221969604,
-0.06635496020317078,
0.5126777291297913,
0.26214179396629333,
0.07080482691526413,
-0.054989080876111984,
-0.6119751334190369,
-0.9122990369796753,
0.8720032572746277,
0.30517032742500305,
0.6227593421936035,
0.04027838259935379,
1.0435844659805298,
-0.10103565454483032,
0.45126664638519287,
-0.9153774976730347,
0.5164303779602051,
-0.08236150443553925,
-0.20866447687149048,
-0.4589594304561615,
-0.6378774046897888,
-0.8492038249969482,
0.18534301221370697,
-0.23684903979301453,
-1.006510615348816,
-0.09472259134054184,
0.16864845156669617,
-0.45545855164527893,
-0.010919182561337948,
-0.6900838613510132,
0.5259177684783936,
0.03945133462548256,
-0.36987918615341187,
0.430238276720047,
-0.4269545078277588,
0.39437973499298096,
-0.1067071259021759,
0.1973065435886383,
-0.060686808079481125,
-0.1156337782740593,
0.6247155666351318,
-0.587323009967804,
0.43174731731414795,
-0.04855765774846077,
-0.2944543957710266,
0.3077351748943329,
-0.03109665773808956,
0.8762527704238892,
0.08914842456579208,
-0.24970652163028717,
-0.09725062549114227,
-0.5251281261444092,
-0.0212235227227211,
-0.8293031454086304,
0.5108968019485474,
-0.31591930985450745,
-0.6106491684913635,
0.046790238469839096,
-0.6448194980621338,
-0.047151051461696625,
0.34803664684295654,
0.3703649938106537,
0.6179977655410767,
-0.04763000085949898,
0.2229301780462265,
0.546172559261322,
-0.12213968485593796,
0.7483785152435303,
0.40750420093536377,
-0.1723504364490509,
-0.45613613724708557,
0.42222973704338074,
0.08995091170072556,
0.38184285163879395,
0.4890882074832916,
0.13114270567893982,
-0.49314412474632263,
-0.5353357791900635,
-0.465361624956131,
0.1908140927553177,
-0.5053171515464783,
-0.33092471957206726,
-0.902046799659729,
-0.3602798283100128,
-0.7480882406234741,
0.09725367277860641,
-0.15352056920528412,
-0.4587162435054779,
-0.3329024016857147,
-0.06636172533035278,
0.06858941167593002,
0.837593674659729,
0.19200868904590607,
0.4767180383205414,
-0.9046081304550171,
0.4236017167568207,
0.3001350164413452,
-0.058633867651224136,
-0.10076237469911575,
-0.37243184447288513,
0.04560515657067299,
-0.10303310304880142,
-0.3658452332019806,
-0.9885679483413696,
0.35732442140579224,
0.5196035504341125,
0.3988308906555176,
0.4630300998687744,
-0.079182468354702,
0.8615904450416565,
-0.8106111288070679,
0.5435268878936768,
0.18578575551509857,
-0.945378839969635,
0.7798327803611755,
-0.36407119035720825,
0.1484929472208023,
0.34011396765708923,
0.16375108063220978,
-0.18905673921108246,
-0.4513215124607086,
-0.6113832592964172,
-1.075385332107544,
0.8048931360244751,
0.25109460949897766,
0.03173823282122612,
-0.2086862474679947,
0.5172468423843384,
0.029975246638059616,
0.39097875356674194,
-0.904740035533905,
0.049677468836307526,
0.19769620895385742,
-0.20686087012290955,
0.17636486887931824,
-0.38251999020576477,
0.08703310042619705,
0.09296780824661255,
0.6940897107124329,
-0.25484466552734375,
-0.042096804827451706,
0.4088784158229828,
-0.02286790870130062,
-0.16805823147296906,
0.5520493388175964,
0.3137536644935608,
0.6919288039207458,
-0.11565438657999039,
0.3058452904224396,
-0.01495838537812233,
-0.2504577040672302,
-0.0749962329864502,
-0.06388566642999649,
-0.40531936287879944,
0.20815978944301605,
0.6015699505805969,
0.44716036319732666,
0.17975418269634247,
-0.5088244080543518,
0.2832772433757782,
0.005543846171349287,
-0.1475110948085785,
0.0019373975228518248,
0.37824496626853943,
0.1695484220981598,
0.08434879779815674,
0.3671959638595581,
-0.4944438338279724,
0.1512063592672348,
-0.8099380731582642,
0.2780628502368927,
0.37029924988746643,
-0.10024844855070114,
-0.0780264139175415,
0.5445684194564819,
0.04671035706996918,
-0.5093477964401245,
0.7620218396186829,
-0.27726709842681885,
-0.2324591428041458,
0.37088820338249207,
0.803845226764679,
0.6854458451271057,
-0.20798635482788086,
0.17822809517383575,
0.5722561478614807,
0.19918325543403625,
-0.13785520195960999,
0.3243858218193054,
-0.12411193549633026,
-0.5524470806121826,
-0.6708039045333862,
-0.6693793535232544,
-0.1885937601327896,
0.30628031492233276,
-0.6963963508605957,
0.32074713706970215,
-0.6222180128097534,
0.03931659460067749,
0.1677996814250946,
-0.05776826664805412,
-0.3751194477081299,
0.0966033935546875,
0.012055841274559498,
0.765827476978302,
-0.5116499662399292,
0.8047756552696228,
0.5378892421722412,
-0.3331752419471741,
-1.2115336656570435,
-0.15828759968280792,
-0.11232440173625946,
-0.5576069951057434,
0.6169419288635254,
0.41034403443336487,
0.029094595462083817,
-0.11946477741003036,
-0.8068925738334656,
-0.7434744834899902,
1.0551854372024536,
0.5123075246810913,
-0.7745522260665894,
-0.1858680248260498,
-0.009166733361780643,
0.46378180384635925,
-0.7345872521400452,
0.25573959946632385,
0.44534164667129517,
0.5052942037582397,
0.40722665190696716,
-0.6299179792404175,
0.31268855929374695,
-0.348143070936203,
0.15688149631023407,
0.46114811301231384,
-0.08403704315423965,
0.8642048835754395,
-0.13361544907093048,
-0.6924970149993896,
0.0907757431268692,
0.745885968208313,
0.38743311166763306,
0.08628552407026291,
0.5564929246902466,
0.25826719403266907,
0.8803354501724243,
-0.05664985254406929,
0.8524606227874756,
-0.11470415443181992,
0.07665921747684479,
1.6417443752288818,
-0.47424259781837463,
1.0153415203094482,
0.6575146317481995,
0.1932544857263565,
0.5431885719299316,
0.25070369243621826,
0.09847058355808258,
0.39267900586128235,
0.24819910526275635,
-0.07516944408416748,
-0.3328021168708801,
-0.2580162286758423,
-0.2195914387702942,
0.45852380990982056,
0.05553201958537102,
-0.3982939124107361,
-0.513934314250946,
-0.5248264074325562,
0.39453262090682983,
0.18400061130523682,
-0.16282102465629578,
1.0305900573730469,
0.11280759423971176,
-0.8014654517173767,
0.2590619921684265,
0.10230904072523117,
0.42908623814582825,
-0.6811742782592773,
-0.45669856667518616,
-0.04286826029419899,
-0.015422391705214977,
-0.31935131549835205,
-0.4553270936012268,
0.44832393527030945,
0.32885682582855225,
-0.4349014461040497,
-0.4053662419319153,
0.9733720421791077,
-0.7513810992240906,
-0.39271941781044006,
0.299180269241333,
0.4106013774871826,
0.29710090160369873,
-0.2200954705476761,
-0.2719806134700775,
-0.04779165983200073,
0.013067999854683876,
-0.3572832942008972,
0.11759728193283081,
0.603762149810791,
0.059148773550987244,
0.27238452434539795,
0.9594675898551941,
0.2822211682796478,
0.10913600772619247,
-0.08469413965940475,
0.8967646360397339,
-0.636858344078064,
-0.31165504455566406,
-1.0761826038360596,
0.6659511923789978,
-0.5226415991783142,
-0.20121517777442932,
0.7028542757034302,
0.5580035448074341,
0.6425193548202515,
0.05579279735684395,
0.5643060207366943,
-0.2263573855161667,
0.3564184308052063,
-0.814137876033783,
0.34181737899780273,
-0.3895169496536255,
0.30989986658096313,
-0.24829111993312836,
-1.1183044910430908,
-0.19972677528858185,
0.42853957414627075,
-0.20795531570911407,
-0.12690092623233795,
0.7232859134674072,
0.7229234576225281,
0.013265402987599373,
-0.24367953836917877,
0.20762526988983154,
0.2846844792366028,
0.618743360042572,
0.5857914090156555,
0.6586529612541199,
-0.3809088170528412,
0.6229661107063293,
0.10112633556127548,
-0.18587914109230042,
0.05717340484261513,
-1.2442705631256104,
-0.808149516582489,
-0.05095731467008591,
-0.36855438351631165,
-0.22918355464935303,
-0.07497607171535492,
0.7032257914543152,
0.7224615216255188,
-0.606572687625885,
-0.02896428294479847,
-0.1499779224395752,
0.1660766899585724,
0.15486036241054535,
-0.28602513670921326,
0.21607236564159393,
-0.5457881093025208,
-0.8889558911323547,
0.7264165878295898,
0.6256148219108582,
-0.13345766067504883,
0.06862988322973251,
-0.10571225732564926,
-0.21503116190433502,
0.07034328579902649,
0.5916740298271179,
0.2136053889989853,
-0.49825945496559143,
-0.44876304268836975,
-0.059263333678245544,
-0.2852448523044586,
0.22159303724765778,
0.5770963430404663,
-0.511077880859375,
0.2850446403026581,
0.7050096988677979,
0.533829391002655,
0.2067844122648239,
0.24172443151474,
0.7710604667663574,
-1.0837844610214233,
-0.15232986211776733,
-0.031015025451779366,
0.31982800364494324,
0.38040927052497864,
-0.661523163318634,
0.6914107799530029,
0.02921110764145851,
-0.363811194896698,
-0.6149373650550842,
0.2815270721912384,
-0.9285692572593689,
-0.0791265144944191,
1.227488398551941,
-0.2802085280418396,
-0.3709331750869751,
-0.00606854073703289,
-0.33448120951652527,
0.31957849860191345,
-0.6185714602470398,
0.5861331820487976,
0.6275835037231445,
-0.1341346800327301,
0.00794245582073927,
-0.4114719033241272,
0.227268785238266,
0.17972123622894287,
-1.0807453393936157,
0.023442860692739487,
0.5931133031845093,
0.3845382630825043,
0.29784029722213745,
0.8662561178207397,
-0.2811931073665619,
-0.08520153164863586,
-0.33095958828926086,
0.12279576063156128,
-0.2641563415527344,
-0.5813862085342407,
-0.2954222857952118,
0.40351977944374084,
-0.19995611906051636,
-0.08681785315275192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13350v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13350v2
|
PIRB: A Comprehensive Benchmark of Polish Dense and Hybrid Text Retrieval Methods
| 2024-02-20T19:53:36 | 2024-03-10T16:13:37 |
Sławomir Dadas, Michał Perełkiewicz, Rafał Poświata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present Polish Information Retrieval Benchmark (PIRB), a comprehensive
evaluation framework encompassing 41 text information retrieval tasks for
Polish. The benchmark incorporates existing datasets as well as 10 new,
previously unpublished datasets covering diverse topics such as medicine, law,
business, physics, and linguistics. We conduct an extensive evaluation of over
20 dense and sparse retrieval models, including the baseline models trained by
us as well as other available Polish and multilingual methods. Finally, we
introduce a three-step process for training highly effective language-specific
retrievers, consisting of knowledge distillation, supervised fine-tuning, and
building sparse-dense hybrid retrievers using a lightweight rescoring model. In
order to validate our approach, we train new text encoders for Polish and
compare their results with previously evaluated methods. Our dense models
outperform the best solutions available to date, and the use of hybrid methods
further improves their performance.
|
[
-0.391722172498703,
-0.941116988658905,
0.4939313530921936,
0.28398287296295166,
-0.4288322329521179,
0.19925203919410706,
-0.4744717478752136,
-0.35330817103385925,
0.11657838523387909,
0.5113470554351807,
-0.20733819901943207,
-0.45223134756088257,
-0.4985918402671814,
0.13214555382728577,
-0.4686790108680725,
0.8067340850830078,
0.04071402922272682,
0.5847455859184265,
0.018688516691327095,
0.15773794054985046,
-0.5562732219696045,
-0.7873627543449402,
-0.1251828670501709,
-0.12209147959947586,
0.2940666973590851,
0.5949093103408813,
0.5273187160491943,
-0.007788284681737423,
0.9497413635253906,
0.18400056660175323,
-0.13207697868347168,
0.16289302706718445,
-0.6375629901885986,
0.24241599440574646,
-0.38613006472587585,
-0.2391463816165924,
-0.14615687727928162,
-0.2729659080505371,
0.8444766998291016,
0.9782713651657104,
-0.3302612006664276,
-0.005387629847973585,
-0.19135382771492004,
0.7960042357444763,
-1.1015607118606567,
-0.2605111002922058,
-0.7723239660263062,
0.33793121576309204,
-0.6220983862876892,
-0.06413998454809189,
-0.7395678162574768,
-0.34762972593307495,
-0.2613464295864105,
-0.3566075563430786,
0.45049145817756653,
0.3765840232372284,
0.6377493143081665,
-0.3209185004234314,
-0.4162183105945587,
-0.3783828914165497,
-0.6014614701271057,
0.738218367099762,
-0.34814390540122986,
0.5134586691856384,
0.515548586845398,
0.3346482813358307,
-0.08824604004621506,
-1.083527684211731,
-0.38267022371292114,
-0.1497240960597992,
-0.1863471120595932,
0.16187289357185364,
-0.2084188610315323,
-0.05165018513798714,
0.09968867897987366,
0.6328308582305908,
-0.4976882338523865,
-0.3988611102104187,
-0.5737610459327698,
-0.31808963418006897,
0.6539803147315979,
0.18051698803901672,
0.45475655794143677,
0.08761397749185562,
-0.45795950293540955,
-0.18503449857234955,
-0.38507983088493347,
-0.30532553791999817,
0.3413376808166504,
0.3880588412284851,
0.2314658761024475,
0.8162807822227478,
-0.43190938234329224,
0.8807374238967896,
0.12363532930612564,
0.06858759373426437,
0.6491615772247314,
-0.7599325776100159,
0.12591078877449036,
0.33940187096595764,
1.1190226078033447,
0.2725473940372467,
-0.005989067256450653,
-0.4584540128707886,
-0.39553311467170715,
-0.2230680286884308,
0.3499874472618103,
-0.6797221899032593,
-0.14238713681697845,
-0.06357651948928833,
-0.5702978372573853,
0.025632450357079506,
0.34327247738838196,
-1.0483982563018799,
-0.25369712710380554,
0.21775215864181519,
0.5499693155288696,
-0.8013405203819275,
-0.27589303255081177,
0.580419659614563,
-0.10908801108598709,
0.2858249843120575,
-0.031244417652487755,
-0.972828209400177,
0.7500131130218506,
0.7131969928741455,
0.8353921175003052,
-0.3410867154598236,
-0.15800613164901733,
-0.7170934677124023,
-0.07486189901828766,
-0.6544405221939087,
0.9664663076400757,
-0.7233846187591553,
-0.3754591643810272,
-0.15782378613948822,
-0.022591393440961838,
-0.11899014562368393,
-0.6478866934776306,
0.9927723407745361,
-0.3909813463687897,
0.41550710797309875,
-0.4622860252857208,
-0.47875484824180603,
-0.2405969351530075,
0.03068489208817482,
-0.6884628534317017,
1.4131901264190674,
-0.009212845005095005,
-0.9931399822235107,
0.3222236633300781,
-0.36409348249435425,
-0.5723769664764404,
0.32300153374671936,
0.036094918847084045,
-0.25881850719451904,
0.3228090703487396,
0.10219215601682663,
0.451858788728714,
-0.471392959356308,
0.3300294280052185,
-0.34815630316734314,
-0.6292169094085693,
-0.07805298268795013,
-0.04185653105378151,
0.7281172871589661,
0.2564029395580292,
-0.13546611368656158,
-0.05255836248397827,
-0.7033469676971436,
0.28750669956207275,
-0.023461513221263885,
-0.16267134249210358,
-0.4307670593261719,
0.005152252968400717,
0.45428159832954407,
0.1588534414768219,
0.5733744502067566,
-0.987881064414978,
-0.015507365576922894,
-0.17840982973575592,
0.3037228584289551,
0.10239452868700027,
0.07907606661319733,
0.2461899369955063,
-0.0993376299738884,
0.23023496568202972,
-0.4088684618473053,
0.09708297997713089,
0.07698008418083191,
-0.42485854029655457,
-0.24726185202598572,
-0.22044213116168976,
0.3043205440044403,
0.47620242834091187,
-0.47356635332107544,
0.6403645873069763,
-0.23754668235778809,
-0.7756389379501343,
-0.265408456325531,
0.0948164165019989,
0.29558074474334717,
0.7407387495040894,
0.35880932211875916,
-0.3614252805709839,
-0.3364572823047638,
-0.8907783031463623,
-0.31974470615386963,
0.07610415667295456,
0.22682787477970123,
0.06117914617061615,
0.5944389700889587,
0.048924271017313004,
0.862959623336792,
0.08348394185304642,
-0.26064756512641907,
-0.6415854096412659,
0.14620618522167206,
0.4502735435962677,
0.5521491765975952,
0.5099532008171082,
-1.195784568786621,
-0.9032917022705078,
0.24470093846321106,
-0.6024429202079773,
-0.024290386587381363,
0.2329404652118683,
-0.36190637946128845,
-0.10600687563419342,
0.35118553042411804,
-0.3104570806026459,
0.02795143611729145,
0.35285407304763794,
-0.6403507590293884,
0.43436458706855774,
-0.3939512073993683,
0.3078247606754303,
-0.6333835124969482,
0.544828474521637,
-0.5511185526847839,
-0.34208542108535767,
-0.6696983575820923,
0.06413979083299637,
0.5394802093505859,
-0.42358535528182983,
-0.4539046287536621,
0.6431131362915039,
-0.6822551488876343,
-0.567552924156189,
-0.055710408836603165,
0.28045427799224854,
0.09070153534412384,
0.11819938570261002,
0.21414540708065033,
1.1697794198989868,
0.3520572781562805,
-0.3604523539543152,
0.49544966220855713,
0.3275494873523712,
-0.8507552742958069,
0.472226083278656,
-0.7876637578010559,
0.08889095485210419,
-0.13140630722045898,
-0.0954427421092987,
-0.9675403833389282,
-0.06452037394046783,
0.15143179893493652,
-0.23092222213745117,
0.18036064505577087,
0.03826529160141945,
-1.1293692588806152,
-0.33842384815216064,
-0.09112865477800369,
0.21336092054843903,
0.4712947607040405,
-0.23524348437786102,
0.7392570972442627,
0.369279682636261,
-0.5292567014694214,
-0.5771145224571228,
-0.7189342975616455,
-0.027110666036605835,
0.014016122557222843,
-0.5002186298370361,
0.5776480436325073,
-0.23483195900917053,
-0.21916699409484863,
0.20663176476955414,
-0.11581020802259445,
-0.5499932765960693,
0.20420853793621063,
-0.22362501919269562,
0.19724677503108978,
-0.13862469792366028,
0.05418384447693825,
0.04013943299651146,
-0.10265813767910004,
-0.32458236813545227,
0.14601144194602966,
1.002671718597412,
-0.4495064318180084,
-0.45476675033569336,
-0.11366239935159683,
0.4298592209815979,
0.33612674474716187,
-0.5631866455078125,
0.8574158549308777,
0.7208293080329895,
-0.2655687928199768,
0.31826430559158325,
-0.9575827717781067,
-0.03157790005207062,
-0.4104982912540436,
0.5686877965927124,
-0.35809212923049927,
-0.5695866942405701,
0.48545777797698975,
0.00957929715514183,
-0.14750173687934875,
0.48435524106025696,
0.7017847299575806,
-0.08010803908109665,
0.8948523998260498,
0.7298440337181091,
0.017484746873378754,
0.5414833426475525,
0.14848586916923523,
0.047538872808218,
-0.6754156351089478,
-0.6447316408157349,
-0.5416906476020813,
-0.22333097457885742,
-0.14207376539707184,
-0.3092684745788574,
0.3580873906612396,
0.6490932703018188,
-0.18898126482963562,
0.16766119003295898,
-0.532244861125946,
0.5872883796691895,
0.5402399897575378,
0.2040351927280426,
0.4806647002696991,
0.25686246156692505,
-0.4509729743003845,
-0.19869419932365417,
-0.9362666010856628,
-0.3601705729961395,
1.1775822639465332,
-0.096747025847435,
0.4435318112373352,
-0.07921966165304184,
0.5504087209701538,
0.3584415018558502,
0.028799597173929214,
-0.549696683883667,
0.36698320508003235,
-0.3295852243900299,
-1.0411601066589355,
-0.11308369040489197,
-0.4701616168022156,
-0.8078831434249878,
0.6666942238807678,
-0.5279532670974731,
-0.5838454365730286,
0.3218477666378021,
-0.16201497614383698,
-0.18904894590377808,
0.4254506230354309,
-0.5862779021263123,
0.9447107911109924,
-0.6657047867774963,
-0.6631120443344116,
-0.4293362498283386,
-0.5276376008987427,
0.15413174033164978,
-0.2964455783367157,
0.26943889260292053,
-0.32306793332099915,
-0.41166654229164124,
0.7094271779060364,
-0.251390278339386,
0.37035277485847473,
-0.18249297142028809,
0.37915998697280884,
0.028031926602125168,
0.11659342795610428,
0.3438422977924347,
-0.24223974347114563,
-0.666631281375885,
0.0946742594242096,
0.13009586930274963,
-0.7673975825309753,
-0.2666195034980774,
0.2993571162223816,
-0.5165575742721558,
0.06550067663192749,
-0.4691888988018036,
-0.40463268756866455,
-0.3790532648563385,
0.8075846433639526,
0.6193488240242004,
0.47834235429763794,
-0.42839813232421875,
0.6767887473106384,
0.866477906703949,
-0.34995216131210327,
0.3876298666000366,
0.7565240859985352,
-0.0752616673707962,
-0.6718838810920715,
0.5876220464706421,
-0.19838346540927887,
0.0652424767613411,
0.6262056827545166,
0.07271156460046768,
-0.3755102753639221,
-0.6862564086914062,
-0.13739453256130219,
0.4469812512397766,
-0.5564374923706055,
-0.21437165141105652,
-0.5764291286468506,
0.004700875841081142,
-0.1058579757809639,
-0.11562175303697586,
-0.8603653311729431,
-0.168080672621727,
0.2535152733325958,
0.16072027385234833,
0.10674484074115753,
0.7419477701187134,
0.06286265701055527,
0.28949734568595886,
-0.7930260896682739,
0.23675476014614105,
-0.2720639109611511,
0.7206006646156311,
-0.3198118805885315,
-0.37724539637565613,
-0.24519643187522888,
-0.10676156729459763,
0.02614838257431984,
-0.7545942664146423,
0.4740692675113678,
0.22077323496341705,
0.8999970555305481,
0.07668644934892654,
0.4133734703063965,
0.4925327003002167,
-0.6609109044075012,
0.7064841985702515,
0.29305392503738403,
-0.9337613582611084,
0.6547927856445312,
-0.10918319970369339,
-0.12547717988491058,
1.119870662689209,
0.6511379480361938,
-0.46685555577278137,
0.1953594982624054,
-0.5257389545440674,
-0.9994683861732483,
0.5592184662818909,
0.0860079899430275,
0.15820768475532532,
-0.19538165628910065,
0.28261706233024597,
0.24386566877365112,
0.4507099390029907,
-0.6181506514549255,
-0.06202179938554764,
-0.007603370118886232,
-0.1835247427225113,
-0.060501739382743835,
-0.6853430867195129,
0.04189681261777878,
0.10332747548818588,
0.680008053779602,
0.2136341780424118,
0.20230481028556824,
0.33618637919425964,
-0.46775752305984497,
0.0854729488492012,
0.2514451742172241,
0.466489315032959,
0.793355405330658,
-0.4531152546405792,
-0.10721650719642639,
0.14152754843235016,
-0.6064285635948181,
0.019752562046051025,
0.016750749200582504,
-0.1186337098479271,
0.39229294657707214,
0.42632994055747986,
0.6008738279342651,
0.5416298508644104,
-1.0741358995437622,
0.7557898759841919,
-0.12192849814891815,
-0.16191932559013367,
-0.42802196741104126,
-0.25171157717704773,
-0.26132598519325256,
-0.06603102385997772,
0.5988010764122009,
-0.15645988285541534,
0.39532867074012756,
-0.5653238892555237,
0.34603017568588257,
0.3985725939273834,
-0.40057170391082764,
-0.04757533594965935,
0.4159979224205017,
0.06771164387464523,
-0.0324229821562767,
0.8047388792037964,
0.023149041458964348,
-0.40999266505241394,
0.1288294494152069,
0.5310712456703186,
0.3273550271987915,
0.06747236847877502,
0.03448411077260971,
0.438785195350647,
0.2307569831609726,
-0.6285704374313354,
0.4735603928565979,
-0.1620340496301651,
-0.7599335312843323,
-0.2946964502334595,
-0.46290671825408936,
-0.4539608657360077,
-0.21157647669315338,
-1.107943058013916,
0.28356441855430603,
-0.5562471151351929,
-0.18096032738685608,
-0.4282006025314331,
0.5221715569496155,
-0.3261226415634155,
-0.0947599932551384,
0.026581168174743652,
1.262712001800537,
-0.6428124308586121,
0.7213943004608154,
0.7767630815505981,
-0.49022120237350464,
-0.27456966042518616,
-0.26904505491256714,
-0.2891186475753784,
-0.7329167723655701,
0.7551802396774292,
-0.08312498033046722,
-0.16785310208797455,
-0.12723621726036072,
-0.2275884747505188,
-0.9116952419281006,
0.8627930283546448,
0.4830920398235321,
-0.9426862001419067,
0.12696410715579987,
-0.15219298005104065,
0.3978784680366516,
-0.19548079371452332,
0.49062395095825195,
0.23574931919574738,
0.3649704158306122,
-0.1430622935295105,
-0.9810228943824768,
-0.3320498466491699,
-0.540271520614624,
0.04341689497232437,
0.15911971032619476,
-0.7731667757034302,
0.9285700917243958,
0.28529688715934753,
-0.3158772587776184,
0.25003954768180847,
0.45474764704704285,
0.2916218042373657,
0.09266609698534012,
0.24927756190299988,
0.29516589641571045,
1.006325602531433,
-0.17611457407474518,
1.34567129611969,
-0.8016179800033569,
0.5426028370857239,
1.0064613819122314,
-0.44008538126945496,
1.2293989658355713,
0.3031019866466522,
-0.09335330128669739,
0.5110171437263489,
0.44784098863601685,
-0.19444993138313293,
0.7644189596176147,
-0.34628117084503174,
-0.12922345101833344,
-0.5264350175857544,
0.01501494087278843,
-0.5800503492355347,
0.16683419048786163,
0.4197707176208496,
-0.1155984029173851,
-0.30565205216407776,
0.08570476621389389,
-0.2125014215707779,
0.41459959745407104,
-0.3845890760421753,
0.7351720333099365,
-0.32302984595298767,
-0.34396806359291077,
0.38975000381469727,
-0.00977078452706337,
0.8156801462173462,
-0.8552464246749878,
0.3250768482685089,
-0.38635629415512085,
0.3132129907608032,
-0.11068197339773178,
-0.8659180402755737,
0.310687392950058,
-0.018978629261255264,
-0.2554576098918915,
-0.3351229429244995,
0.8222036957740784,
-0.35703137516975403,
-0.7908957600593567,
0.5338895320892334,
0.3801504969596863,
0.28018152713775635,
-0.19559070467948914,
-0.8484092950820923,
0.29781487584114075,
-0.13949094712734222,
0.08080467581748962,
0.3076696991920471,
0.631835401058197,
0.08410953730344772,
0.6680079698562622,
0.5008505582809448,
0.49838972091674805,
0.2872314453125,
-0.021540112793445587,
0.6805053353309631,
-0.7669369578361511,
-0.4781230390071869,
-0.6356390714645386,
0.28523775935173035,
-0.3369695544242859,
-0.12436104565858841,
0.6976401805877686,
1.1274921894073486,
1.0116169452667236,
0.017770059406757355,
0.714576780796051,
-0.241526260972023,
0.9224234223365784,
-0.47078678011894226,
0.7426486611366272,
-0.5144237875938416,
0.16851705312728882,
-0.26689261198043823,
-1.0809731483459473,
-0.20455892384052277,
1.0043659210205078,
-0.5207946300506592,
-0.039416130632162094,
0.6837009191513062,
0.42485764622688293,
-0.34876585006713867,
-0.13702915608882904,
0.3560102880001068,
0.018395736813545227,
-0.21900789439678192,
0.39600133895874023,
0.755570113658905,
-0.5849932432174683,
0.6109048128128052,
-0.6429056525230408,
-0.03813044726848602,
-0.2857775092124939,
-0.7345080971717834,
-0.6959823966026306,
-0.4259788393974304,
0.005408041644841433,
-0.0023414993193000555,
0.3759956359863281,
0.806351900100708,
0.7259594202041626,
-1.011606216430664,
-0.422600120306015,
-0.08144308626651764,
-0.14081522822380066,
-0.16442081332206726,
-0.22894516587257385,
0.07812825590372086,
-0.7467936873435974,
-0.592379629611969,
0.41661736369132996,
0.18231599032878876,
-0.2701123058795929,
0.2649852931499481,
0.052766088396310806,
-0.27997493743896484,
-0.5415390133857727,
0.44628462195396423,
0.11541019380092621,
-0.5079969763755798,
0.18565057218074799,
0.03629475459456444,
-0.33499300479888916,
0.2113305628299713,
0.9726795554161072,
-0.6031887531280518,
0.5416573882102966,
0.7114842534065247,
0.7100057601928711,
0.7774037718772888,
0.03576626628637314,
0.7422803640365601,
-0.3878127634525299,
0.44390153884887695,
0.5485414266586304,
0.49693214893341064,
0.38558536767959595,
-0.17602898180484772,
0.6250445246696472,
0.2625955641269684,
-0.153132826089859,
-0.939268946647644,
-0.2832677960395813,
-0.8588823676109314,
-0.4341444969177246,
0.7226529717445374,
-0.17677602171897888,
-0.02320428006350994,
-0.10184567421674728,
-0.044654130935668945,
-0.20805078744888306,
-0.3815198540687561,
0.4007817804813385,
0.7594118714332581,
-0.14353010058403015,
-0.2629302740097046,
-0.6322831511497498,
0.10189486294984818,
0.55382239818573,
-0.5184354782104492,
0.12087072432041168,
0.4421094059944153,
0.5742249488830566,
0.11591269075870514,
0.8995186686515808,
-0.565108060836792,
0.3367437720298767,
0.21211321651935577,
0.3709656298160553,
-0.029455360025167465,
-0.41203969717025757,
-0.2345331460237503,
0.3668306767940521,
-0.14224041998386383,
0.23483358323574066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13331v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13331v1
|
Enhanced Hallucination Detection in Neural Machine Translation through Simple Detector Aggregation
| 2024-02-20T19:19:47 | 2024-02-20T19:19:47 |
Anas Himmi, Guillaume Staerman, Marine Picot, Pierre Colombo, Nuno M. Guerreiro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hallucinated translations pose significant threats and safety concerns when
it comes to the practical deployment of machine translation systems. Previous
research works have identified that detectors exhibit complementary performance
different detectors excel at detecting different types of hallucinations. In
this paper, we propose to address the limitations of individual detectors by
combining them and introducing a straightforward method for aggregating
multiple detectors. Our results demonstrate the efficacy of our aggregated
detector, providing a promising step towards evermore reliable machine
translation systems.
|
[
-0.577844500541687,
-0.3143041729927063,
0.6636802554130554,
0.1455562710762024,
-0.4858911633491516,
-0.08667081594467163,
-0.13571737706661224,
-0.44913414120674133,
0.5067216157913208,
0.49862849712371826,
-0.09184657037258148,
-0.49239036440849304,
-1.0682761669158936,
0.39966467022895813,
-0.846714437007904,
0.7019046545028687,
0.3143971562385559,
0.1136661097407341,
0.19328685104846954,
-0.5358001589775085,
-0.6598444581031799,
-0.6965208053588867,
-0.5215872526168823,
-0.42227044701576233,
0.4301390051841736,
0.013484469614923,
0.8843854069709778,
0.2639007866382599,
0.5271499752998352,
0.45341262221336365,
-0.10402880609035492,
0.598609983921051,
0.06871382892131805,
0.40018102526664734,
0.25697895884513855,
-0.3038414418697357,
-0.8177544474601746,
-0.49720320105552673,
0.6859977841377258,
0.6016140580177307,
-0.19928322732448578,
-0.44459348917007446,
0.003383971517905593,
0.3532567620277405,
-0.4806922376155853,
-0.48441508412361145,
-0.7315672636032104,
0.21382060647010803,
-0.041470449417829514,
-0.45684656500816345,
-0.6954780220985413,
-0.1562924087047577,
-0.5712795853614807,
-0.11913277208805084,
0.028858618810772896,
-0.1336839646100998,
0.29195767641067505,
0.6184746623039246,
-0.478531152009964,
-0.39664575457572937,
-0.5531446933746338,
0.6411226987838745,
-0.37292981147766113,
0.460439532995224,
0.28123489022254944,
0.46148839592933655,
-0.15639755129814148,
-0.7497203946113586,
-0.5705738067626953,
0.08616946637630463,
-0.40126052498817444,
0.15979011356830597,
-0.35179197788238525,
-0.1933470070362091,
-0.04625178501009941,
0.517248809337616,
-0.777385413646698,
0.03997166454792023,
-0.29815906286239624,
-0.5150557160377502,
0.4388834536075592,
0.17552737891674042,
0.47996169328689575,
0.014043536968529224,
-0.09424787014722824,
-0.09732542186975479,
-0.15636733174324036,
-0.7086046934127808,
0.21375355124473572,
0.30564138293266296,
0.1569594144821167,
0.6946752071380615,
-0.013596313074231148,
0.6977682709693909,
-0.05114273726940155,
0.36908963322639465,
0.4728511869907379,
-0.33183789253234863,
-0.06366705149412155,
0.4322138726711273,
0.9454216957092285,
0.29561862349510193,
-0.03222477063536644,
-0.4490668773651123,
-0.515641987323761,
0.4412023425102234,
0.6792446970939636,
-0.7088640928268433,
-0.12860234081745148,
0.4159567058086395,
-0.4838070273399353,
-0.5301457047462463,
-0.10163476318120956,
-0.6653648018836975,
-0.2979079782962799,
0.05603668466210365,
0.687985897064209,
-0.4551831781864166,
-0.33717983961105347,
0.3924434781074524,
-0.2837027311325073,
0.2627573013305664,
-0.05167750269174576,
-0.7621305584907532,
0.4238642454147339,
0.567753791809082,
1.1124625205993652,
-0.5554998517036438,
-0.41659292578697205,
-1.1289070844650269,
-0.12697048485279083,
-0.45546412467956543,
1.1017652750015259,
-0.10697703063488007,
-0.30343785881996155,
-0.08821657299995422,
-0.07370481640100479,
0.10298522561788559,
-0.7295095324516296,
0.73487389087677,
-0.46225792169570923,
0.0972825363278389,
-0.009516771882772446,
-0.20528143644332886,
-0.22558505833148956,
0.1277279108762741,
-0.573433518409729,
0.8266391158103943,
0.26205965876579285,
-0.33230891823768616,
0.4069763720035553,
-0.15790972113609314,
-0.8472796082496643,
0.22238892316818237,
-0.21467092633247375,
-0.4924342930316925,
0.5118638277053833,
0.4409175217151642,
0.3365188241004944,
0.31568098068237305,
0.3645784556865692,
-0.00424034520983696,
-0.6532207727432251,
0.43247994780540466,
-0.3230676054954529,
0.7781462073326111,
0.4861501157283783,
-0.49660080671310425,
0.3617611825466156,
-0.5414131283760071,
-0.1448984295129776,
-0.11082828044891357,
-0.11975708603858948,
-0.3385753929615021,
-0.14775283634662628,
0.026912998408079147,
-0.0013402721378952265,
-0.10526948422193527,
0.024442818015813828,
0.08315446972846985,
-0.2866871953010559,
-0.1169387549161911,
0.6779276728630066,
-0.14485621452331543,
0.4981447160243988,
-0.07069723308086395,
0.42721056938171387,
0.3528807759284973,
-0.1187075823545456,
-0.09851871430873871,
-0.6772627234458923,
-0.7481622099876404,
-0.1923869550228119,
-0.1803867071866989,
0.3241580128669739,
-0.9234983325004578,
1.241741418838501,
-0.2384476214647293,
-0.09205474704504013,
-0.6303823590278625,
0.024294985458254814,
0.24728457629680634,
0.25247442722320557,
0.8314510583877563,
-0.5813231468200684,
-0.6619195342063904,
-0.6931240558624268,
-0.5460863709449768,
-0.03745502606034279,
-0.18667584657669067,
-0.14925207197666168,
0.5664487481117249,
-0.28962093591690063,
0.007977434433996677,
-0.4936479926109314,
-0.6881533265113831,
-0.22826367616653442,
0.12802563607692719,
0.3620963990688324,
0.47920307517051697,
0.6412431597709656,
-0.8082464933395386,
-0.39203357696533203,
0.3618987798690796,
-1.128568172454834,
-0.11650404334068298,
-0.24039888381958008,
-0.1356401890516281,
0.15445095300674438,
0.4636913537979126,
-0.6034940481185913,
0.5750068426132202,
0.5259012579917908,
-0.29854103922843933,
0.36175039410591125,
-0.1452011615037918,
0.4209196865558624,
-1.0667893886566162,
-0.3575541079044342,
-0.5357896685600281,
-0.43899887800216675,
-0.9994357228279114,
0.36750328540802,
0.08029569685459137,
0.31701549887657166,
-0.3954433798789978,
-0.010491291992366314,
-0.44250404834747314,
-0.3701748549938202,
-0.7787164449691772,
0.11613369733095169,
-0.20774060487747192,
0.20154324173927307,
-0.0980706438422203,
0.8174279928207397,
0.6486552357673645,
-0.9458601474761963,
0.3565819263458252,
0.36625444889068604,
-0.2997625470161438,
0.6114218235015869,
-0.5558221936225891,
0.2940046191215515,
-0.14243654906749725,
0.1745707243680954,
-0.8596823811531067,
-0.4066518247127533,
0.44336795806884766,
-0.9040853381156921,
0.29071590304374695,
0.11804349720478058,
-0.3747742176055908,
-0.26158004999160767,
-0.14837756752967834,
0.39667293429374695,
0.5708449482917786,
-0.7185282707214355,
0.8492748737335205,
0.42404136061668396,
0.42229440808296204,
-0.3229871392250061,
-1.354689359664917,
0.46823224425315857,
-0.3651657700538635,
-0.5813325643539429,
0.4315620958805084,
0.07831700146198273,
-0.19748355448246002,
-0.0036011473275721073,
-0.29203394055366516,
-0.004795250948518515,
0.2624281048774719,
-0.06944142282009125,
0.027775978669524193,
-0.28157153725624084,
0.022958990186452866,
0.26594147086143494,
-0.3445935845375061,
-0.08453880250453949,
-0.6313267350196838,
0.9677282571792603,
-0.1960904896259308,
-0.5118358135223389,
-0.31632059812545776,
0.6972934603691101,
0.5993932485580444,
-0.021652527153491974,
1.0269938707351685,
1.0852502584457397,
-0.9199591279029846,
0.04455101117491722,
-0.5289660096168518,
-0.489019513130188,
-0.5360123515129089,
0.2452232390642166,
-0.6936981081962585,
-0.7258555293083191,
0.687936544418335,
0.24975430965423584,
-0.4252380430698395,
0.44385597109794617,
0.9017988443374634,
0.24280555546283722,
1.3756966590881348,
0.22293001413345337,
-0.07384204119443893,
-0.004235397558659315,
0.05915489420294762,
0.49255654215812683,
-0.9304189682006836,
-0.2614814341068268,
-0.6390601992607117,
-0.29185986518859863,
-0.48052501678466797,
-0.39330148696899414,
0.5130939483642578,
0.07532849162817001,
0.29215237498283386,
0.6642482876777649,
-1.1170337200164795,
0.5523059368133545,
0.23560498654842377,
0.2872539460659027,
0.5973142385482788,
0.32515519857406616,
0.06614259630441666,
0.03439488261938095,
-0.3339996337890625,
-0.36755186319351196,
0.9603949785232544,
-0.07950977236032486,
0.4072278141975403,
0.39922937750816345,
0.9399007558822632,
0.29647648334503174,
0.1797749400138855,
-0.9241219162940979,
0.6578789353370667,
-0.30165284872055054,
-0.5765612125396729,
-0.018719524145126343,
-0.3956514000892639,
-0.8607028126716614,
0.7425698041915894,
0.0005994272651150823,
-0.8547811508178711,
0.5323740243911743,
-0.08636682480573654,
-0.26644450426101685,
0.1903837025165558,
-0.537808895111084,
0.5537480115890503,
-0.35375910997390747,
-0.13438846170902252,
-0.37303873896598816,
-0.38759395480155945,
0.5330789685249329,
-0.11941833049058914,
-0.08169370144605637,
0.2819359302520752,
-0.026652636006474495,
0.3514820337295532,
-0.11003910005092621,
0.44874486327171326,
0.10223246365785599,
-0.06077156960964203,
0.1295410394668579,
0.24553491175174713,
0.5123627185821533,
-0.061698585748672485,
-0.19032076001167297,
0.2808489203453064,
-0.6732122302055359,
-0.22942441701889038,
-0.35463061928749084,
0.7629372477531433,
-0.2967459261417389,
-0.5753751397132874,
-0.6578054428100586,
-0.7243384122848511,
0.2579535245895386,
0.34126394987106323,
0.611431360244751,
-0.005242784507572651,
-0.04687304049730301,
0.15644170343875885,
0.6380590200424194,
-0.09361520409584045,
0.27179476618766785,
0.11880247294902802,
-0.7294811010360718,
-0.7637300491333008,
0.8580554127693176,
-0.16366872191429138,
0.09836830198764801,
0.04355340451002121,
-0.07976218312978745,
-0.3303455114364624,
-0.9134028553962708,
-0.21401454508304596,
-0.04923194274306297,
-0.8511155843734741,
-0.33669140934944153,
-1.2705888748168945,
-0.18915562331676483,
-0.9134364128112793,
-0.21462026238441467,
-0.4141598343849182,
-0.31249216198921204,
-0.21116384863853455,
-0.11599132418632507,
0.22508390247821808,
0.27258044481277466,
-0.34434595704078674,
0.5919065475463867,
-0.8546232581138611,
0.8613922595977783,
0.19255512952804565,
0.04199967160820961,
-0.27393749356269836,
-0.7315449714660645,
-0.15109972655773163,
-0.03346218541264534,
-0.15053050220012665,
-1.014884114265442,
0.759788990020752,
-0.005351148545742035,
0.6137725114822388,
0.43657243251800537,
-0.038782231509685516,
0.8104346394538879,
-0.21571484208106995,
0.5944352746009827,
0.275566041469574,
-0.9726138710975647,
0.5896317958831787,
-0.020746711641550064,
0.11613856256008148,
0.5209527015686035,
0.2993551790714264,
-0.4606381058692932,
-0.5193845629692078,
-0.13362589478492737,
-0.8486950397491455,
0.703957200050354,
0.5531371235847473,
0.03802837058901787,
-0.16573652625083923,
-0.07707209885120392,
0.14143449068069458,
0.0317290835082531,
-0.6499307751655579,
-0.2320118397474289,
-0.07819218188524246,
0.015854643657803535,
-0.10813217610120773,
-0.06097014620900154,
-0.3092072606086731,
-0.4755823612213135,
0.5742499828338623,
-0.11859402060508728,
0.6070700883865356,
0.23470108211040497,
-0.5514864325523376,
-0.014294806867837906,
0.003805042477324605,
0.6383299231529236,
0.019223015755414963,
-0.28423020243644714,
0.5661200284957886,
0.18019753694534302,
-0.5252105593681335,
0.2110031694173813,
-0.047021910548210144,
-0.29098495841026306,
0.4578557014465332,
0.3303440511226654,
0.8483734130859375,
-0.2712536156177521,
0.0002513356157578528,
0.3446457087993622,
0.05255121737718582,
-0.22771532833576202,
-0.24742598831653595,
-0.032164931297302246,
0.007023594342172146,
0.2217550128698349,
0.4477314054965973,
0.5179459452629089,
0.5330684185028076,
-0.5300148725509644,
0.6259673237800598,
0.40562745928764343,
-0.40470364689826965,
-0.20760048925876617,
0.8233540058135986,
-0.04608219489455223,
-0.515606701374054,
0.6174859404563904,
-0.5324069261550903,
-1.03585684299469,
0.5293126106262207,
0.8593021035194397,
1.4929969310760498,
-0.6040529608726501,
0.047668855637311935,
0.26705342531204224,
0.7817723155021667,
-0.28573837876319885,
0.3014761209487915,
-0.03997112065553665,
-0.9999734163284302,
-0.3295382857322693,
-0.5915014743804932,
0.01881146989762783,
0.006884329952299595,
-0.8174863457679749,
0.273372620344162,
0.23355813324451447,
-0.31398454308509827,
0.08747372031211853,
-0.6238534450531006,
-0.30070245265960693,
-0.09526406228542328,
0.3091042637825012,
0.3147030472755432,
-0.919373631477356,
0.9551416635513306,
0.5446497201919556,
-0.2932939827442169,
-0.043393563479185104,
0.09845475107431412,
0.06763270497322083,
-0.796148419380188,
0.3158414661884308,
0.49503442645072937,
-0.37317875027656555,
-0.02235771156847477,
-0.2708040773868561,
-0.2993931472301483,
0.7287953495979309,
-0.009246989153325558,
-0.1976839005947113,
0.3647647202014923,
0.08821702003479004,
0.6777952313423157,
-0.5003862380981445,
-0.03146306797862053,
1.020996332168579,
0.7373093366622925,
0.0645618587732315,
-0.38525494933128357,
0.31501033902168274,
-0.16071565449237823,
-0.24900208413600922,
0.31023335456848145,
-0.2717018723487854,
0.6621341705322266,
0.03627689555287361,
-0.38712644577026367,
-0.02787703089416027,
0.6485187411308289,
0.09333167970180511,
0.6060481667518616,
0.5115097165107727,
0.6979210376739502,
0.7131054401397705,
-0.19528017938137054,
0.9832451343536377,
-0.1956503987312317,
-0.10646838694810867,
1.1644612550735474,
-0.1922726333141327,
0.44787612557411194,
0.6915566325187683,
0.00713301682844758,
-0.028791623190045357,
0.2660716772079468,
-0.15763987600803375,
0.649138331413269,
-0.26283323764801025,
-0.6298123598098755,
-0.4754953384399414,
-0.19381004571914673,
-0.7731143832206726,
0.30313313007354736,
0.6554175615310669,
-0.36463552713394165,
0.00832094345241785,
0.22107599675655365,
-0.2995791435241699,
0.13652187585830688,
-0.15285345911979675,
0.6761685609817505,
0.4082770049571991,
-0.8666768074035645,
0.7783840894699097,
-0.2264772653579712,
0.8787828087806702,
-0.21031944453716278,
0.038719531148672104,
-0.43282556533813477,
0.4305388629436493,
-0.564446210861206,
-0.6750676035881042,
0.8126580715179443,
-0.04673578590154648,
0.4214768409729004,
-0.12328159809112549,
0.9517499804496765,
-0.3728960454463959,
-0.41310328245162964,
0.6971604824066162,
0.411726713180542,
0.5381959676742554,
-0.46975210309028625,
-0.010270709171891212,
0.2687153220176697,
-0.05300423130393028,
-0.1278296262025833,
0.34245291352272034,
0.463302880525589,
0.12754935026168823,
0.5472286939620972,
0.6328107714653015,
0.06389384716749191,
0.4633066654205322,
0.13414698839187622,
1.0558290481567383,
-0.5719533562660217,
-0.061260711401700974,
-1.0422179698944092,
0.5497338175773621,
-0.26933103799819946,
-0.15989750623703003,
0.8118705153465271,
0.6488508582115173,
0.64327073097229,
-0.2625731825828552,
0.50188809633255,
-0.04508691281080246,
-0.3678508698940277,
-0.37644827365875244,
0.8930238485336304,
-0.6389498114585876,
0.42136070132255554,
-0.0284687802195549,
-1.1910086870193481,
-0.8687242269515991,
0.7406908869743347,
0.2520557641983032,
-0.23101051151752472,
1.1506617069244385,
0.8645115494728088,
-0.052971016615629196,
-0.06960214674472809,
0.706457793712616,
0.1783081442117691,
0.2822747230529785,
0.5518688559532166,
0.5851987600326538,
-0.9124893546104431,
0.7852622270584106,
-0.3080574870109558,
0.002704258542507887,
-0.31479519605636597,
-0.5891687870025635,
-0.9859610199928284,
-0.5487212538719177,
-0.35476574301719666,
-0.6851292252540588,
-0.006044931244105101,
0.2940328121185303,
0.36191222071647644,
-1.157637357711792,
-0.044235508888959885,
-0.3274897038936615,
0.3712928593158722,
-0.6597952842712402,
-0.17303363978862762,
0.14443325996398926,
-0.5809129476547241,
-0.8660966753959656,
0.8414082527160645,
0.5537582039833069,
0.19129659235477448,
-0.17095859348773956,
-0.34621313214302063,
-0.15427854657173157,
-0.18459197878837585,
0.7684219479560852,
-0.18844830989837646,
-0.5917981266975403,
-0.1486448049545288,
0.1854393184185028,
-0.1869424730539322,
0.06169801950454712,
0.6729268431663513,
-0.720192551612854,
0.5134680867195129,
0.8592777848243713,
0.6436826586723328,
0.6154694557189941,
-0.2594284117221832,
0.3549595773220062,
-0.6382144093513489,
0.5844212174415588,
0.41929107904434204,
0.3122451603412628,
0.20367389917373657,
-0.5626352429389954,
0.8565179109573364,
0.21780745685100555,
-0.5377579927444458,
-1.273728609085083,
0.3646421432495117,
-1.047996163368225,
-0.31446143984794617,
0.7861899733543396,
0.13494184613227844,
-0.07298819720745087,
-0.45112982392311096,
0.1482197493314743,
0.47110238671302795,
-0.18904228508472443,
1.0202083587646484,
0.6840712428092957,
0.0698966383934021,
0.0370456725358963,
-0.39282095432281494,
0.14075429737567902,
0.49031803011894226,
-0.6046209335327148,
-0.24329110980033875,
0.45049482583999634,
-0.5152961015701294,
0.6430712342262268,
0.7233800888061523,
-0.28582891821861267,
0.3876650035381317,
0.36886703968048096,
0.18606044352054596,
0.15251418948173523,
-0.4970763027667999,
-0.6996957659721375,
0.10535943508148193,
-0.24713842570781708,
-0.5564957857131958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13254v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13254v4
|
CounterCurate: Enhancing Physical and Semantic Visio-Linguistic Compositional Reasoning via Counterfactual Examples
| 2024-02-20T18:59:55 | 2024-06-12T17:59:55 |
Jianrui Zhang, Mu Cai, Tengyang Xie, Yong Jae Lee
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We propose CounterCurate, a framework to comprehensively improve the
visio-linguistic compositional reasoning capability for both contrastive and
generative multimodal models. In particular, we identify two critical
under-explored problems: the neglect of the physically grounded reasoning
(counting and position understanding) and the potential of using highly capable
text and image generation models for semantic counterfactual fine-tuning. Our
work pioneers an approach that addresses these gaps. We first spotlight the
near-chance performance of multimodal models like CLIP and LLaVA in physically
grounded compositional reasoning. We then apply simple data augmentation using
grounded image generation model GLIGEN to generate fine-tuning data, resulting
in significant performance improvements: +33% and +37% for CLIP and LLaVA,
respectively, on our newly curated Flickr30k-Positions benchmark. Moreover, we
exploit the capabilities of high-performing text generation and image
generation models, specifically GPT-4V and DALLE-3, to curate challenging
semantic counterfactuals, thereby further enhancing compositional reasoning
capabilities on benchmarks such as SugarCrepe, where CounterCurate outperforms
GPT-4V. To facilitate future research, we release our code, dataset, benchmark,
and checkpoints at https://countercurate.github.io.
|
[
-0.5856894254684448,
-0.9121022820472717,
0.8260043859481812,
0.10679406672716141,
-0.33625149726867676,
0.02281290479004383,
0.10466108471155167,
-0.38847315311431885,
0.07647456973791122,
0.5140161514282227,
-0.7287597060203552,
-0.46303096413612366,
-0.3809758722782135,
-0.31784021854400635,
-0.36506402492523193,
0.5683275461196899,
-0.24892574548721313,
0.10762996971607208,
-0.7679957747459412,
-0.3383975923061371,
-0.9969017505645752,
-0.30003291368484497,
-0.005867971573024988,
-0.4732210338115692,
0.2115013301372528,
0.8887284994125366,
0.592837393283844,
0.14755472540855408,
0.16223126649856567,
0.3735102713108063,
0.34702181816101074,
0.34039148688316345,
-0.6576144695281982,
0.2607308030128479,
-0.50839763879776,
-0.3711380064487457,
-0.22912347316741943,
0.043674252927303314,
0.284002423286438,
0.33837762475013733,
0.09753153473138809,
-0.03466074541211128,
-0.21698574721813202,
0.6874879598617554,
-0.7950655817985535,
0.01188045833259821,
-0.7040605545043945,
0.015748849138617516,
0.11634566634893417,
-0.34826573729515076,
-0.4686245024204254,
0.17368578910827637,
-0.014395934529602528,
-0.871646523475647,
0.25726044178009033,
-0.05040958896279335,
0.8045972585678101,
0.4478045403957367,
-0.29353147745132446,
0.19354870915412903,
-0.6604825258255005,
0.8893141746520996,
-0.43087825179100037,
0.462284117937088,
0.3589845895767212,
0.16061708331108093,
-0.06429910659790039,
-0.7797722816467285,
-0.6315571069717407,
-0.1637468934059143,
0.24200153350830078,
0.6070654988288879,
-0.39450928568840027,
-0.22767631709575653,
0.4276607036590576,
0.29869869351387024,
-0.7684972286224365,
-0.09785261005163193,
-0.20131348073482513,
-0.06298238039016724,
0.4755096435546875,
0.22033709287643433,
0.5008050203323364,
0.12263698875904083,
-0.40375077724456787,
-0.20099759101867676,
-0.7053713798522949,
-0.06456036865711212,
0.38738277554512024,
-0.361000120639801,
-0.1920153796672821,
0.7148661613464355,
-0.3584365248680115,
0.5586699843406677,
0.3041226863861084,
0.25394636392593384,
0.1797262579202652,
-0.4375632405281067,
-0.2411811649799347,
0.09081016480922699,
0.5805470943450928,
0.8386642336845398,
0.4214727580547333,
0.11274313181638718,
0.05433434620499611,
0.6529225707054138,
0.7093601822853088,
-1.0547465085983276,
-0.6930184960365295,
0.3514726459980011,
-0.17148585617542267,
-0.21044696867465973,
-0.12043728679418564,
-0.6004869341850281,
-0.27956315875053406,
-0.6336495280265808,
0.4725693166255951,
-0.6972603797912598,
-0.18245932459831238,
0.10194026678800583,
-0.32406851649284363,
-0.036815620958805084,
0.4939063787460327,
-0.6138133406639099,
0.032603513449430466,
0.6833903789520264,
0.6872947812080383,
-0.031182043254375458,
-0.41411149501800537,
-0.5123252868652344,
0.17747199535369873,
-0.45730510354042053,
1.1621675491333008,
-0.6785448789596558,
-0.6612429022789001,
-0.3020007908344269,
-0.03790212422609329,
-0.10306047648191452,
-0.6220701336860657,
0.4881630837917328,
-0.10220220685005188,
0.25403016805648804,
-0.5185005068778992,
-0.5555390119552612,
-0.2921780049800873,
0.629652202129364,
-0.6468515992164612,
0.947921633720398,
-0.05937257409095764,
-0.7788727283477783,
0.49351900815963745,
-0.3525790870189667,
-0.4555285573005676,
0.12288368493318558,
-0.4033280313014984,
-0.4674164354801178,
0.17071190476417542,
0.3719426691532135,
0.12172066420316696,
-0.2510422170162201,
0.561433732509613,
-0.3035922348499298,
-0.4015234410762787,
0.34836018085479736,
-0.4287155568599701,
0.4204620122909546,
0.25033026933670044,
-0.39531609416007996,
0.48678168654441833,
-0.7999338507652283,
0.054403677582740784,
-0.041793860495090485,
0.27756038308143616,
-0.16286353766918182,
0.29667145013809204,
0.08579792827367783,
0.42050543427467346,
-0.037100594490766525,
-0.5500785112380981,
0.0012983123306185007,
-0.18209150433540344,
0.2755494713783264,
0.3933429419994354,
0.06047573313117027,
0.25131043791770935,
-0.5948271155357361,
0.5073509216308594,
0.31286442279815674,
0.13942797482013702,
-0.30722516775131226,
-0.7162167429924011,
-0.5035936832427979,
-0.45283830165863037,
-0.2761254906654358,
0.7627211213111877,
-1.3259227275848389,
0.08041682839393616,
-0.24887870252132416,
-0.8675592541694641,
-0.15730328857898712,
0.12735334038734436,
0.4233505129814148,
1.138663411140442,
0.8170619010925293,
-0.48003196716308594,
-0.5690528154373169,
-0.7863759994506836,
-0.06868037581443787,
-0.21709373593330383,
0.10213394463062286,
0.22942498326301575,
0.5670803189277649,
-0.1789102852344513,
0.9517621397972107,
-0.5337698459625244,
-0.053700435906648636,
-0.09782426059246063,
0.5647410154342651,
0.030885599553585052,
0.7088401317596436,
0.7955037951469421,
-0.9534125328063965,
-0.39613914489746094,
-0.39462074637413025,
-0.7309008836746216,
-0.5003133416175842,
-0.17902088165283203,
-0.32977959513664246,
0.03758290782570839,
0.8237077593803406,
-0.7748294472694397,
0.5218255519866943,
0.5026060938835144,
-0.5470315217971802,
0.7142386436462402,
-0.15012720227241516,
0.5845655202865601,
-0.7175812125205994,
0.17377018928527832,
-0.23051220178604126,
-0.07577798515558243,
-0.679981529712677,
0.168557807803154,
-0.06766223907470703,
-0.18889743089675903,
-0.6960569024085999,
0.4949651062488556,
-0.09166261553764343,
0.34802037477493286,
-0.39073601365089417,
0.05887720361351967,
0.4129463732242584,
0.4056720435619354,
0.24361969530582428,
0.7899866104125977,
0.5287491679191589,
-0.5653977990150452,
0.4890122413635254,
0.10504069924354553,
-0.46419259905815125,
1.3967173099517822,
-0.948112428188324,
-0.061075806617736816,
-0.12044213712215424,
0.2214355170726776,
-1.2534204721450806,
0.0990457832813263,
0.2634034752845764,
-0.40288856625556946,
0.1533292979001999,
-0.33512499928474426,
-0.5007539987564087,
-0.2792559266090393,
-0.5854367017745972,
0.550959050655365,
0.1789366453886032,
-0.30990123748779297,
0.7540200352668762,
0.19956716895103455,
0.1824473738670349,
-0.3313848376274109,
-1.0236798524856567,
0.051880884915590286,
-0.14787554740905762,
-0.6448142528533936,
0.5028988718986511,
-0.445501446723938,
-0.22712095081806183,
0.049921147525310516,
-0.13654452562332153,
0.1701360046863556,
0.036018792539834976,
0.47080323100090027,
0.2412317544221878,
-0.10054382681846619,
0.049116101115942,
-0.07399839162826538,
-0.2334248125553131,
0.05762551352381706,
-0.5219535827636719,
0.5894948244094849,
-0.0884372815489769,
-0.6718890070915222,
0.033590756356716156,
0.29162824153900146,
0.5976279973983765,
-0.21129237115383148,
0.4370807409286499,
1.0268172025680542,
-0.22507694363594055,
0.12933647632598877,
-0.5906565189361572,
0.041082464158535004,
-0.4585728049278259,
0.2461341768503189,
-0.5829128623008728,
-0.46393918991088867,
0.6430137157440186,
0.1266038715839386,
-0.08441519737243652,
0.46304449439048767,
0.7653176784515381,
-0.043882861733436584,
0.9437056183815002,
0.3321792185306549,
0.3079734146595001,
0.5727224349975586,
-0.4333803355693817,
0.031890109181404114,
-0.5607855916023254,
-0.2817856967449188,
-0.24564382433891296,
-0.4259951412677765,
-0.6395760178565979,
-0.6305875182151794,
0.3105531930923462,
-0.18128125369548798,
-0.16426897048950195,
0.32624414563179016,
-0.3327751159667969,
0.40887972712516785,
0.6123459339141846,
0.3526802957057953,
0.09731990098953247,
-0.16234634816646576,
-0.44777679443359375,
-0.3104380965232849,
-0.5773022770881653,
-0.0762651190161705,
0.6566425561904907,
-0.10736794769763947,
0.7219618558883667,
0.19046597182750702,
0.3421359360218048,
0.14173439145088196,
0.2013120949268341,
-0.7730066180229187,
0.5990006923675537,
-0.341079980134964,
-0.4771260619163513,
-0.032006897032260895,
-0.29431861639022827,
-0.7147608995437622,
0.32603228092193604,
-0.42222294211387634,
-0.5302428007125854,
0.40002331137657166,
0.29004499316215515,
0.05665832385420799,
0.21377812325954437,
-0.8184080123901367,
1.154097318649292,
-0.24127212166786194,
-0.9444960951805115,
-0.4593290686607361,
-0.43375474214553833,
0.3383435606956482,
0.20238929986953735,
0.11571104824542999,
-0.15159523487091064,
0.22473928332328796,
0.3748338520526886,
-0.4915092885494232,
0.722637414932251,
-0.24196657538414001,
-0.2748454809188843,
0.5078679919242859,
0.5582450032234192,
0.18411263823509216,
-0.08086328953504562,
0.0292124655097723,
0.1573665291070938,
0.11133197695016861,
-0.4449673295021057,
-0.6555383801460266,
0.8381243348121643,
-0.4313666820526123,
-0.4166663587093353,
-0.11022065579891205,
-0.7330853343009949,
-0.37808260321617126,
0.24584315717220306,
0.5400747060775757,
0.5843327641487122,
-0.41986340284347534,
0.3305036425590515,
0.6940456628799438,
-0.235221728682518,
0.2856253683567047,
0.4605887532234192,
-0.07506641000509262,
-0.7140809893608093,
1.0862911939620972,
0.16977033019065857,
0.147619366645813,
0.6108946800231934,
0.350986510515213,
-0.359453409910202,
-0.2116090953350067,
-0.48951348662376404,
-0.17981082201004028,
-0.8032839894294739,
-0.13985168933868408,
-0.5809434652328491,
0.05701206997036934,
-0.32013943791389465,
-0.35750994086265564,
-0.5105679035186768,
-0.43179821968078613,
-0.29407456517219543,
-0.0027815825305879116,
0.2990429401397705,
0.2924853265285492,
-0.029351137578487396,
0.07756154239177704,
-0.6476361155509949,
0.8278485536575317,
0.39382272958755493,
0.3136509656906128,
-0.07352188974618912,
-0.5308405756950378,
-0.023827441036701202,
-0.02883266657590866,
-0.4884966015815735,
-0.8013070225715637,
0.19673797488212585,
-0.007240215316414833,
0.676809549331665,
0.28660473227500916,
0.10308917611837387,
1.0337858200073242,
-0.5483790636062622,
0.8185494542121887,
0.26860326528549194,
-0.9954745769500732,
0.57574462890625,
-0.3127746880054474,
0.8138039708137512,
0.6922851204872131,
0.18965013325214386,
-0.372012734413147,
-0.37910255789756775,
-0.7805004715919495,
-0.9444630146026611,
0.3043760359287262,
0.11514542251825333,
-0.02568511664867401,
-0.004395048134028912,
-0.27998852729797363,
-0.07159534096717834,
0.25775665044784546,
-0.4415265917778015,
0.08917728811502457,
-0.9139404296875,
-0.4174652099609375,
-0.08674714714288712,
-0.3769161105155945,
-0.14886830747127533,
-0.49089735746383667,
0.5127491354942322,
-0.2088923454284668,
-0.22114337980747223,
0.401976615190506,
-0.40945446491241455,
-0.12841330468654633,
0.18808943033218384,
1.0769243240356445,
0.7811583280563354,
-0.04979468137025833,
0.37374797463417053,
0.06639638543128967,
-0.5751833319664001,
0.048447273671627045,
0.11458989232778549,
-0.5120534300804138,
-0.11659353226423264,
0.4141613245010376,
0.7151723504066467,
0.4733854830265045,
-0.8196386098861694,
0.3819948434829712,
0.06971238553524017,
-0.4020678997039795,
-0.14314250648021698,
-0.005184808745980263,
-0.11709783226251602,
0.20808635652065277,
0.00042848120210692286,
0.004509023390710354,
0.221676304936409,
-0.5682560205459595,
0.4572088122367859,
0.27520111203193665,
-0.36832600831985474,
-0.1992468535900116,
0.8955010771751404,
0.10312880575656891,
0.2718409597873688,
0.5217809677124023,
-0.10258927196264267,
-0.7082170844078064,
0.5782734155654907,
0.39552178978919983,
0.9417359232902527,
0.046535275876522064,
0.38541853427886963,
0.4084164798259735,
0.35220035910606384,
-0.047575272619724274,
0.5507270693778992,
-0.3759749233722687,
-0.7533676624298096,
-0.46362367272377014,
0.07207468152046204,
-0.6128004193305969,
0.009673208929598331,
-0.25910019874572754,
0.3965529501438141,
-0.4153707027435303,
-0.1363573521375656,
-0.1503484547138214,
0.05009645223617554,
-0.5665678977966309,
0.24580751359462738,
0.19218116998672485,
0.6201199889183044,
-0.9731606245040894,
0.47067832946777344,
0.8122074604034424,
-0.45802900195121765,
-0.3684835135936737,
-0.22691145539283752,
0.03773551434278488,
-0.5848655700683594,
0.6190524101257324,
0.2612055242061615,
-0.5335642099380493,
-0.38671448826789856,
-0.8391224145889282,
-0.41364139318466187,
0.8975738883018494,
0.43394121527671814,
-0.4250856041908264,
0.5878937244415283,
-0.07684972882270813,
0.7656423449516296,
-0.13458840548992157,
0.46446099877357483,
0.31198474764823914,
0.5661956071853638,
0.46349820494651794,
-0.6329431533813477,
0.011540167964994907,
-0.5541765093803406,
-0.20894496142864227,
-0.07150798290967941,
-0.47381827235221863,
0.8109802603721619,
-0.1562948077917099,
-0.07700745016336441,
0.008075489662587643,
0.4961499273777008,
0.5052392482757568,
0.7398355603218079,
0.4646204113960266,
1.127444863319397,
0.32978686690330505,
-0.11191590875387192,
0.9013504981994629,
-0.2809412181377411,
-0.06254340708255768,
1.3168798685073853,
-0.4639337658882141,
0.5873844623565674,
0.5234954953193665,
0.19610759615898132,
0.6312754154205322,
0.32924380898475647,
-0.28302058577537537,
0.5256431102752686,
0.07779798656702042,
0.045335572212934494,
-0.5546596646308899,
-0.4230702519416809,
-0.2059527039527893,
0.6147785186767578,
0.41896122694015503,
0.09187880158424377,
-0.22831793129444122,
-0.1024676188826561,
0.0052572255954146385,
0.5297725200653076,
-0.1213921383023262,
0.5132338404655457,
-0.10772742331027985,
-0.8428855538368225,
0.4420083165168762,
-0.18465809524059296,
0.30747541785240173,
-0.28397586941719055,
-0.2983221113681793,
-0.12139976769685745,
0.1343320608139038,
-0.23902179300785065,
-1.0437036752700806,
0.253646582365036,
-0.18829785287380219,
-0.16191595792770386,
-0.4439787268638611,
0.6935698986053467,
-0.5182749032974243,
-0.4733787477016449,
0.09668104350566864,
0.45652398467063904,
-0.12002761662006378,
-0.19329483807086945,
-0.7591943740844727,
0.11813008785247803,
-0.33753037452697754,
0.03592124953866005,
-0.11069401353597641,
0.654841423034668,
-0.2047405242919922,
0.6757792234420776,
0.7139899730682373,
-0.058889128267765045,
-0.26075974106788635,
0.46535298228263855,
0.82623690366745,
-0.5352957248687744,
-0.6758682727813721,
-0.9165903329849243,
0.5219124555587769,
-0.08249474316835403,
-0.2614554166793823,
0.6032493710517883,
0.607976496219635,
0.9455733299255371,
-0.35835328698158264,
0.2100043147802353,
0.0410318449139595,
0.1209438145160675,
-0.8154565095901489,
0.47099223732948303,
-0.5540955662727356,
0.058207377791404724,
-0.571356475353241,
-0.6716383099555969,
-0.2193836271762848,
0.3062327206134796,
-0.5036848187446594,
-0.0726112425327301,
0.5084735751152039,
0.7794339060783386,
-0.25015413761138916,
-0.2568987011909485,
0.4995276927947998,
0.13471126556396484,
0.5478953719139099,
0.6673663854598999,
0.9520099759101868,
-0.46171069145202637,
0.43052801489830017,
-0.42712631821632385,
0.19983044266700745,
-0.18756186962127686,
-1.1216940879821777,
-0.8613381385803223,
-0.5308445692062378,
-0.5430487394332886,
-0.0038276263512670994,
-0.27425867319107056,
0.5452977418899536,
0.7017403841018677,
-0.8151101469993591,
0.08065962046384811,
-0.29237687587738037,
0.24906890094280243,
-0.14251601696014404,
-0.28214582800865173,
-0.046160221099853516,
0.06556746363639832,
-0.5806888341903687,
0.5094342231750488,
0.46634918451309204,
0.10224075615406036,
-0.06600108742713928,
-0.005403317045420408,
-0.4106673002243042,
0.1784956157207489,
0.90169757604599,
0.3345032334327698,
-0.564887523651123,
-0.32416534423828125,
0.01467744167894125,
-0.02338111773133278,
-0.004689715802669525,
1.084424376487732,
-0.978772759437561,
0.7049116492271423,
1.0108457803726196,
0.3288779556751251,
0.5238449573516846,
0.31407630443573,
0.5199848413467407,
-0.7959948778152466,
0.5265700817108154,
0.0497446246445179,
0.5070687532424927,
0.4430916905403137,
-0.0545123815536499,
0.6410848498344421,
0.659084677696228,
-0.20880798995494843,
-0.5720028877258301,
0.4984206259250641,
-1.0404736995697021,
-0.43412595987319946,
0.8632711172103882,
0.09593198448419571,
0.10255441069602966,
-0.09741517156362534,
-0.3404812514781952,
0.15564611554145813,
-0.0605602003633976,
0.5980938076972961,
0.7604703307151794,
-0.21605393290519714,
-0.40856170654296875,
-0.4565151631832123,
0.0680096372961998,
0.7067611813545227,
-0.7415477633476257,
-0.22706782817840576,
0.9300107955932617,
0.03871191665530205,
0.2730608582496643,
0.5903852581977844,
-0.2566688656806946,
0.4852335453033447,
0.30544179677963257,
-0.04991774260997772,
-0.28365689516067505,
-0.5751864910125732,
0.0249821487814188,
0.017194479703903198,
-0.17092996835708618,
-0.24598804116249084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13253v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13253v1
|
BiMediX: Bilingual Medical Mixture of Experts LLM
| 2024-02-20T18:59:26 | 2024-02-20T18:59:26 |
Sara Pieri, Sahal Shaji Mullappilly, Fahad Shahbaz Khan, Rao Muhammad Anwer, Salman Khan, Timothy Baldwin, Hisham Cholakkal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce BiMediX, the first bilingual medical mixture of
experts LLM designed for seamless interaction in both English and Arabic. Our
model facilitates a wide range of medical interactions in English and Arabic,
including multi-turn chats to inquire about additional details such as patient
symptoms and medical history, multiple-choice question answering, and
open-ended question answering. We propose a semi-automated English-to-Arabic
translation pipeline with human refinement to ensure high-quality translations.
We also introduce a comprehensive evaluation benchmark for Arabic medical LLMs.
Furthermore, we introduce BiMed1.3M, an extensive Arabic-English bilingual
instruction set covering 1.3 Million diverse medical interactions, resulting in
over 632 million healthcare specialized tokens for instruction tuning. Our
BiMed1.3M dataset includes 250k synthesized multi-turn doctor-patient chats and
maintains a 1:2 Arabic-to-English ratio. Our model outperforms state-of-the-art
Med42 and Meditron by average absolute gains of 2.5% and 4.1%, respectively,
computed across multiple medical evaluation benchmarks in English, while
operating at 8-times faster inference. Moreover, our BiMediX outperforms the
generic Arabic-English bilingual LLM, Jais-30B, by average absolute gains of
10% on our Arabic medical benchmark and 15% on bilingual evaluations across
multiple datasets. Our project page with source code and trained model is
available at https://github.com/mbzuai-oryx/BiMediX .
|
[
-0.296879380941391,
-0.3950068950653076,
0.48387792706489563,
0.7481818795204163,
-0.3055754005908966,
0.5367707014083862,
0.11723259091377258,
-0.7316640615463257,
0.29553696513175964,
0.4346688389778137,
-0.33118921518325806,
-0.6649878025054932,
-0.8767361044883728,
0.29720714688301086,
-0.20078206062316895,
1.0270785093307495,
-0.41139456629753113,
0.7869598865509033,
-0.3146967887878418,
-0.5189487934112549,
-0.42374831438064575,
-0.33128082752227783,
-0.622322142124176,
-0.5279796719551086,
0.7059214115142822,
0.47516489028930664,
0.9525306820869446,
0.5349217057228088,
0.20170943439006805,
0.31267279386520386,
0.1790533810853958,
0.4957965016365051,
-0.11957261711359024,
-0.04979518800973892,
-0.4416303038597107,
-0.427382230758667,
-0.8096286654472351,
-0.2166445553302765,
0.46853137016296387,
1.1939643621444702,
-0.061863549053668976,
0.016169968992471695,
-0.13188284635543823,
0.6380422711372375,
-0.223580464720726,
-0.00536200450733304,
-0.112289659678936,
-0.06904976069927216,
-0.18826617300510406,
-0.21552599966526031,
-0.11099910736083984,
-0.2818402647972107,
0.10279905050992966,
-0.13472864031791687,
-0.1956711709499359,
0.21406985819339752,
0.5751810073852539,
0.0846555158495903,
-0.808445394039154,
-0.17268230020999908,
-0.7544933557510376,
0.6802796721458435,
-0.6764697432518005,
0.43315133452415466,
0.39198002219200134,
0.349100798368454,
-0.15445463359355927,
-0.8631032705307007,
-0.35488253831863403,
0.25033968687057495,
0.26011955738067627,
0.3983610272407532,
-0.2217216044664383,
-0.15500150620937347,
-0.3356473743915558,
0.1839824914932251,
-0.678347647190094,
0.15091030299663544,
-0.3966471552848816,
-0.1409648358821869,
0.6289672255516052,
0.4360736608505249,
0.7215635776519775,
0.2851009666919708,
-0.4672112464904785,
0.28865429759025574,
-0.698986291885376,
-0.05815691128373146,
0.1033049076795578,
-0.2214079052209854,
-0.6587331891059875,
0.5818732380867004,
-0.005708904936909676,
0.5291705131530762,
-0.301181435585022,
-0.30229976773262024,
0.3781214952468872,
-0.5637018084526062,
-0.1513736993074417,
0.07640716433525085,
0.810088038444519,
0.4888683557510376,
0.0058346097357571125,
-0.3209741711616516,
-0.03864721953868866,
-0.12157981097698212,
0.11339128017425537,
-0.9079781174659729,
-0.36338281631469727,
0.5178881287574768,
-0.47248467803001404,
-0.0614282600581646,
-0.22651463747024536,
-0.6631142497062683,
-0.28057196736335754,
-0.4234430491924286,
0.19103626906871796,
-0.46408718824386597,
-0.23446322977542877,
0.4062507152557373,
0.21974977850914001,
0.017475862056016922,
0.39802661538124084,
-0.5752108097076416,
0.5457355976104736,
0.3399428129196167,
0.5396117568016052,
-0.5409019589424133,
-0.3609427213668823,
-0.4456119239330292,
0.27317100763320923,
-0.37512925267219543,
0.8375687003135681,
-0.411068320274353,
-0.6771852970123291,
0.04688006639480591,
-0.021538786590099335,
-0.06865102052688599,
-0.8408418893814087,
0.36832037568092346,
-0.494387149810791,
0.3023252785205841,
0.03833935037255287,
-0.29104292392730713,
-0.2799178659915924,
0.1979641318321228,
-0.33919307589530945,
0.752555251121521,
0.33126258850097656,
-0.8811885118484497,
-0.004107942339032888,
-0.47634458541870117,
-0.65516197681427,
0.20540465414524078,
-0.3431447148323059,
-0.24223849177360535,
-0.18090476095676422,
0.4432218372821808,
-0.08860796689987183,
-0.5906714797019958,
0.17869654297828674,
-0.17230309545993805,
-0.12834109365940094,
0.41025233268737793,
-0.28581681847572327,
0.9236099123954773,
0.007195687387138605,
-0.1434207409620285,
0.21615585684776306,
-0.5072369575500488,
-0.05356726422905922,
-0.11991343647241592,
-0.46464550495147705,
-0.15497566759586334,
0.09251782298088074,
0.3081994950771332,
0.31852173805236816,
0.3279494047164917,
-0.5696106553077698,
-0.00866176187992096,
-0.7833177447319031,
-0.009084053337574005,
0.25283411145210266,
0.25098761916160583,
0.3268035650253296,
-0.5624657273292542,
0.5497146844863892,
0.2816983461380005,
0.2684519588947296,
0.02366052381694317,
-0.861151933670044,
-0.6535993814468384,
-0.795903742313385,
0.6628224849700928,
1.0079102516174316,
-0.8911692500114441,
0.2656722068786621,
-0.2426285445690155,
-0.4648645222187042,
-0.8655728101730347,
0.43265587091445923,
0.43448755145072937,
0.6032388210296631,
0.4545181095600128,
-0.39551419019699097,
-0.34635281562805176,
-1.1783697605133057,
-0.3296312987804413,
-0.027274470776319504,
-0.048104044049978256,
0.22827602922916412,
0.31475502252578735,
-0.9419293999671936,
0.7434856295585632,
0.16704288125038147,
0.14549559354782104,
-0.524549126625061,
0.3442746102809906,
0.373174786567688,
0.4403407871723175,
0.7605992555618286,
-0.6664722561836243,
-1.021458625793457,
0.2617725729942322,
-0.5230445265769958,
-0.5077415108680725,
0.008504744619131088,
-0.40425610542297363,
0.20563413202762604,
-0.07235094904899597,
-0.4014715254306793,
0.6338621377944946,
0.6239261627197266,
-0.24571117758750916,
0.2047111541032791,
-0.4347308874130249,
0.31563401222229004,
-1.4698463678359985,
0.015920819714665413,
-0.22141598165035248,
-0.5409582257270813,
-0.6032842397689819,
-0.24095012247562408,
0.2091655731201172,
0.07738947868347168,
-0.5887359380722046,
0.7521974444389343,
-0.4401838183403015,
0.2496492713689804,
-0.6005361080169678,
-0.10686183720827103,
-0.01871601678431034,
0.29191815853118896,
-0.14363865554332733,
0.7324178814888,
0.6052500009536743,
-0.4754723906517029,
0.42235758900642395,
0.5043115019798279,
-0.39809638261795044,
0.6797281503677368,
-0.8320348858833313,
0.1412651538848877,
0.09575624018907547,
0.08350744098424911,
-0.9397462606430054,
-0.17094899713993073,
0.3495941758155823,
-0.4459269642829895,
0.5284360647201538,
-0.08777638524770737,
-0.8699454665184021,
-0.23427918553352356,
-0.1422373503446579,
0.6456412672996521,
0.4087585508823395,
-0.3294224441051483,
0.6396371126174927,
0.47880983352661133,
-0.9754757285118103,
-0.29881855845451355,
-0.7020795941352844,
0.272441029548645,
0.25801894068717957,
-0.7588632106781006,
0.48363733291625977,
-0.186384379863739,
-0.18937920033931732,
-0.16814088821411133,
-0.14782309532165527,
-0.09759362787008286,
-0.04110490903258324,
0.32175537943840027,
0.7658824324607849,
0.13028402626514435,
-0.27178919315338135,
0.7985344529151917,
-0.19228167831897736,
0.234049990773201,
0.017273517325520515,
0.4137679636478424,
0.10094071179628372,
-0.745263934135437,
-0.39681416749954224,
1.0122665166854858,
0.7953001260757446,
-0.39448636770248413,
0.8682354688644409,
0.4642044007778168,
-0.5457894206047058,
0.3403036892414093,
-0.5321972966194153,
0.07674802839756012,
-0.3635450005531311,
0.6279884576797485,
-0.10583096742630005,
-0.4693223834037781,
0.6504060626029968,
-0.2894444465637207,
0.39104562997817993,
0.18934912979602814,
1.1549320220947266,
-0.31953221559524536,
1.6477785110473633,
0.3949418067932129,
-0.2918716371059418,
-0.3829416334629059,
0.15846896171569824,
0.24369290471076965,
-0.46097153425216675,
-0.6438255310058594,
-0.44375109672546387,
-0.5786011219024658,
-0.40633517503738403,
-0.5271884202957153,
0.8958818912506104,
-0.14015206694602966,
-0.21988065540790558,
-0.254589706659317,
-0.07888048887252808,
0.11378519982099533,
0.5570539236068726,
0.32614824175834656,
0.10982460528612137,
0.2434544414281845,
-0.5182824730873108,
-0.17125453054904938,
-0.8495342135429382,
-0.3709753751754761,
1.0548980236053467,
0.40211716294288635,
0.6838478446006775,
0.3414626121520996,
0.5613383650779724,
0.26366356015205383,
0.5921152830123901,
-0.4565531313419342,
0.30867069959640503,
0.26715144515037537,
-0.655086874961853,
0.4234670102596283,
-0.3835192024707794,
-1.1222628355026245,
0.03057544119656086,
-0.4701350927352905,
-0.44039782881736755,
0.05317055433988571,
-0.18061189353466034,
-0.3658919334411621,
0.33532851934432983,
-0.5449045300483704,
0.7252914905548096,
-0.6507906317710876,
-0.5830981135368347,
-0.18888644874095917,
-1.0579620599746704,
0.0936451181769371,
-0.18172664940357208,
0.4908282160758972,
0.044131118804216385,
-0.48320046067237854,
0.6295137405395508,
-0.5158870220184326,
0.7149662375450134,
0.07630503177642822,
0.20465205609798431,
-0.11063849925994873,
0.1336120367050171,
0.16249492764472961,
0.23253589868545532,
0.33822107315063477,
0.5429483652114868,
0.3545796871185303,
-0.829686164855957,
-0.4036949872970581,
0.6352832913398743,
-1.104162573814392,
-0.3334747552871704,
-0.5072758793830872,
-0.9142753481864929,
-0.5840874910354614,
0.12277854979038239,
0.19336438179016113,
0.5104637145996094,
0.049794308841228485,
-0.17604684829711914,
0.4689907729625702,
-0.5319872498512268,
-0.005544180050492287,
0.9139060974121094,
-0.44968798756599426,
-0.8185054063796997,
0.833648145198822,
-0.26221537590026855,
-0.02182716317474842,
0.14556771516799927,
-0.1139153465628624,
-0.2466116100549698,
-0.7453905940055847,
-0.8887872695922852,
0.6689174771308899,
-0.2890944182872772,
-0.2654106318950653,
-0.7242172360420227,
-0.273544579744339,
-0.29374921321868896,
0.017407041043043137,
-0.2069668471813202,
0.016740649938583374,
-0.041948746889829636,
0.22950562834739685,
0.05138630047440529,
0.7480058670043945,
0.12488768994808197,
0.06790756434202194,
-1.3875141143798828,
0.2476777881383896,
0.08387560397386551,
0.2221839874982834,
-0.4449475407600403,
-0.6014415621757507,
-0.5724990963935852,
0.15086454153060913,
-0.3117414116859436,
-1.4133833646774292,
0.6415659189224243,
-0.15744228661060333,
0.7042632102966309,
0.5554219484329224,
-0.12322989106178284,
0.4422556459903717,
-0.8039888739585876,
0.5736393332481384,
0.3764190375804901,
-0.4927145540714264,
0.18018516898155212,
-0.16710349917411804,
0.4040122926235199,
0.6073781251907349,
0.7128455638885498,
-0.5088229179382324,
-0.35955923795700073,
-0.21475769579410553,
-0.8422807455062866,
0.5546244382858276,
0.22534121572971344,
0.053002119064331055,
-0.042610641568899155,
0.1043788343667984,
0.35269102454185486,
0.29075419902801514,
-0.21239444613456726,
-0.5840228796005249,
0.13007616996765137,
-0.7181161642074585,
0.05463465303182602,
-0.3980211317539215,
-0.641136109828949,
-0.6121554374694824,
0.6199341416358948,
0.35235917568206787,
0.29215964674949646,
0.12920694053173065,
-0.11271024495363235,
-0.12543891370296478,
0.26933035254478455,
0.5707041025161743,
0.8963617086410522,
-0.09159260988235474,
0.06611808389425278,
0.2498493194580078,
-0.4660067856311798,
-0.037967145442962646,
0.659389078617096,
0.05414091795682907,
0.22755028307437897,
0.30417460203170776,
0.4940595030784607,
0.4267449378967285,
-0.9502325057983398,
0.3908052146434784,
0.08784637600183487,
-0.38011521100997925,
-0.17478379607200623,
-0.2953454256057739,
0.3652881979942322,
0.5349943041801453,
0.2533588409423828,
0.18098518252372742,
0.2164485603570938,
-0.4620027244091034,
0.014172066003084183,
0.18796898424625397,
-0.2445424497127533,
-0.41125887632369995,
0.746638834476471,
0.47753170132637024,
-0.45367252826690674,
0.4213869273662567,
0.09646309167146683,
-0.6323259472846985,
0.35635268688201904,
0.42178645730018616,
0.4653286933898926,
-0.4920831620693207,
-0.06530851125717163,
0.027822447940707207,
0.306117445230484,
0.3257559537887573,
0.6453748941421509,
0.1443488448858261,
-0.5149696469306946,
-0.3880397081375122,
-0.247061625123024,
-0.7828252911567688,
-0.2272709757089615,
-0.6051621437072754,
0.15287837386131287,
-0.046021927148103714,
-0.08562666922807693,
-0.16978342831134796,
0.061691995710134506,
-0.6033029556274414,
-0.005507305730134249,
0.27045848965644836,
1.1346855163574219,
-0.6663471460342407,
0.8344556093215942,
1.3212015628814697,
-0.2612844705581665,
-0.5453962683677673,
-0.43580716848373413,
-0.10841359943151474,
-0.7885192036628723,
0.19507740437984467,
-0.13569746911525726,
0.03014674223959446,
-0.1900295615196228,
-0.3243355453014374,
-0.25917091965675354,
0.9435637593269348,
0.3468199074268341,
-0.3509567975997925,
0.17673243582248688,
0.5684659481048584,
0.4079696834087372,
-0.38226571679115295,
0.48071667551994324,
0.43072664737701416,
0.33119386434555054,
-0.0750141441822052,
-0.9524913430213928,
-0.3687363266944885,
-0.7059053778648376,
-0.2676454186439514,
0.07275322824716568,
-0.4185737669467926,
0.546105682849884,
-0.05771007016301155,
0.0703502893447876,
0.24574419856071472,
0.5648258924484253,
0.28170740604400635,
0.707511842250824,
0.46556928753852844,
0.5516846179962158,
0.518132746219635,
0.10010404139757156,
1.0106390714645386,
-0.8933753371238708,
-0.17962761223316193,
1.0221829414367676,
-0.5925449728965759,
0.5677444934844971,
0.6005717515945435,
-0.37044432759284973,
0.5970912575721741,
0.8896546363830566,
0.47702935338020325,
0.40979260206222534,
-0.33501872420310974,
-0.8024159669876099,
-0.37243396043777466,
0.0824190080165863,
-0.5761651396751404,
0.05470672994852066,
0.31610754132270813,
-0.2894790768623352,
-0.34116384387016296,
0.156476229429245,
0.1764521449804306,
0.13499316573143005,
-0.18199719488620758,
0.595328688621521,
0.025908777490258217,
-0.5297486186027527,
0.37456703186035156,
0.3889320194721222,
0.1725320816040039,
-0.7115245461463928,
-0.028341548517346382,
-0.48601841926574707,
-0.014755789190530777,
-0.18952038884162903,
-0.6621569395065308,
0.11415547877550125,
0.06857851147651672,
-0.2463715523481369,
0.01707630045711994,
0.49503007531166077,
-0.7434394955635071,
-0.7752758264541626,
0.34077009558677673,
0.8605728149414062,
0.3309337794780731,
0.11050624400377274,
-0.817451536655426,
-0.06260565668344498,
0.09111940860748291,
0.1605474054813385,
0.4484861493110657,
0.2729792594909668,
0.027875084429979324,
0.5555979013442993,
0.49236270785331726,
0.4128812253475189,
0.2375504970550537,
0.1069367304444313,
0.9742693305015564,
-0.18608270585536957,
-0.17847950756549835,
-0.5883021354675293,
0.4781510531902313,
-0.06027061864733696,
0.027965424582362175,
0.6185949444770813,
0.9084210991859436,
0.4885406792163849,
-0.12795481085777283,
0.806858479976654,
0.43990761041641235,
0.9814022779464722,
-0.02956930734217167,
0.828862190246582,
-0.7526784539222717,
0.14033910632133484,
0.23706123232841492,
-0.6265186071395874,
-0.2093704640865326,
0.250095933675766,
-0.14571528136730194,
0.12782905995845795,
0.5459073781967163,
0.7497526407241821,
-0.24887360632419586,
-0.003121106419712305,
0.3429034650325775,
0.28305956721305847,
0.03327217325568199,
0.7803390622138977,
0.5881847143173218,
-0.2805434465408325,
0.44245684146881104,
-0.1523025631904602,
-0.5857945084571838,
-0.2932104766368866,
-0.28351059556007385,
-1.0456008911132812,
-0.03967588394880295,
-0.40395021438598633,
-0.394923597574234,
-0.0053148698061704636,
1.2668182849884033,
0.5681399703025818,
-0.9155858755111694,
-0.26549604535102844,
0.38089513778686523,
0.0021745397243648767,
-0.12959687411785126,
-0.04765249788761139,
0.07361407577991486,
-0.03387865796685219,
-1.014766812324524,
0.4844779670238495,
0.7274527549743652,
-0.061721041798591614,
-0.23995685577392578,
-0.36262813210487366,
-0.3009895384311676,
0.4133226275444031,
0.40599939227104187,
0.44946718215942383,
-0.393588125705719,
0.2515421509742737,
0.14097906649112701,
-0.4708559215068817,
0.1209278330206871,
0.547065794467926,
-0.600529670715332,
0.7641280293464661,
0.31323736906051636,
0.9877079129219055,
0.4571070075035095,
-0.24740999937057495,
0.5232443809509277,
-0.24325619637966156,
0.187641903758049,
0.3724461793899536,
0.5439695715904236,
0.18920311331748962,
0.18047738075256348,
0.1670106053352356,
0.33448702096939087,
-0.5155457854270935,
-0.6259792447090149,
0.09435446560382843,
-1.275801420211792,
0.03374803438782692,
0.9275461435317993,
-0.19424133002758026,
-0.09758000075817108,
-0.5638396739959717,
-0.5195720791816711,
0.43017932772636414,
-0.0018728985451161861,
0.6555728912353516,
0.5281482934951782,
-0.10835205018520355,
-0.078097403049469,
-0.713908314704895,
-0.18692387640476227,
0.7794641256332397,
-0.8504651784896851,
-0.8537638187408447,
0.2874005436897278,
0.5245383381843567,
-0.31366291642189026,
0.512563943862915,
-0.4217613935470581,
0.5655113458633423,
-0.4470809996128082,
0.3532176911830902,
-0.06913744658231735,
-0.16916975378990173,
0.10899500548839569,
-0.19581814110279083,
-0.02029360458254814,
-0.31698161363601685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13249v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13249v2
|
TofuEval: Evaluating Hallucinations of LLMs on Topic-Focused Dialogue Summarization
| 2024-02-20T18:58:49 | 2024-03-31T15:30:34 |
Liyan Tang, Igor Shalyminov, Amy Wing-mei Wong, Jon Burnsky, Jake W. Vincent, Yu'an Yang, Siffi Singh, Song Feng, Hwanjun Song, Hang Su, Lijia Sun, Yi Zhang, Saab Mansour, Kathleen McKeown
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Single document news summarization has seen substantial progress on
faithfulness in recent years, driven by research on the evaluation of factual
consistency, or hallucinations. We ask whether these advances carry over to
other text summarization domains. We propose a new evaluation benchmark on
topic-focused dialogue summarization, generated by LLMs of varying sizes. We
provide binary sentence-level human annotations of the factual consistency of
these summaries along with detailed explanations of factually inconsistent
sentences. Our analysis shows that existing LLMs hallucinate significant
amounts of factual errors in the dialogue domain, regardless of the model's
size. On the other hand, when LLMs, including GPT-4, serve as binary factual
evaluators, they perform poorly and can be outperformed by prevailing
state-of-the-art specialized factuality evaluation metrics. Finally, we
conducted an analysis of hallucination types with a curated error taxonomy. We
find that there are diverse errors and error distributions in model-generated
summaries and that non-LLM based metrics can capture all error types better
than LLM-based evaluators.
|
[
-0.2585314214229584,
-0.7383319139480591,
0.8006060719490051,
0.5545724034309387,
-0.39547765254974365,
0.07744775712490082,
-0.24584294855594635,
-0.06600422412157059,
0.49438658356666565,
0.5334258079528809,
-0.4611435532569885,
-0.7808730602264404,
-0.7939406037330627,
0.49109697341918945,
-0.7025550007820129,
1.4371156692504883,
0.06514646857976913,
-0.06470480561256409,
-0.5463685989379883,
-0.11838861554861069,
-0.46524742245674133,
-0.5607349276542664,
0.035272661596536636,
-0.11150404065847397,
0.4219452440738678,
0.19974684715270996,
0.6585885882377625,
0.14877250790596008,
0.6650448441505432,
0.28317341208457947,
-0.025748765096068382,
0.3997982144355774,
-1.002940058708191,
0.024207280948758125,
-0.17207872867584229,
-0.20328006148338318,
-0.5568310618400574,
0.1019790768623352,
0.6086215376853943,
0.7851244807243347,
-0.2767260670661926,
0.013764130882918835,
0.03545980900526047,
0.6902367472648621,
-0.36946985125541687,
0.09091834723949432,
-0.8062846660614014,
0.2080753594636917,
0.12272323668003082,
-0.5725331902503967,
-0.5213870406150818,
-0.7953523993492126,
0.3061063289642334,
-0.4189252555370331,
0.4776039123535156,
0.06832435727119446,
0.8882294297218323,
0.5671941637992859,
-0.35580581426620483,
-0.6748828887939453,
-0.42421820759773254,
0.7161705493927002,
-0.7232728004455566,
0.3042442202568054,
0.2458478957414627,
0.033074744045734406,
-0.28799280524253845,
-0.8150814771652222,
-0.26822149753570557,
-0.3706080913543701,
-0.2688182294368744,
0.33112332224845886,
-0.11215095967054367,
0.03969186916947365,
0.13859549164772034,
0.5650736093521118,
-0.5433087348937988,
-0.2978929281234741,
-0.46897050738334656,
-0.5069182515144348,
0.598893940448761,
0.2344941943883896,
0.05130524933338165,
-0.5150839686393738,
-0.3339214622974396,
0.40654662251472473,
-0.5216224193572998,
-0.356330931186676,
0.25993430614471436,
0.21681499481201172,
-0.05399532988667488,
0.6769937872886658,
-0.15862876176834106,
0.30767080187797546,
0.1930375099182129,
-0.5513992309570312,
0.1380028873682022,
-0.5495559573173523,
-0.17708395421504974,
0.41855260729789734,
0.6001503467559814,
0.9226691126823425,
0.12999969720840454,
-0.5712544322013855,
-0.2054455280303955,
0.004425115883350372,
0.6554228663444519,
-0.8835321068763733,
-0.1525631994009018,
0.3062635660171509,
-0.5327812433242798,
-0.4482284188270569,
0.17478428781032562,
-0.813120424747467,
-0.49555274844169617,
-0.18594855070114136,
0.3759710192680359,
-0.2841432988643646,
-0.06309860199689865,
0.0560583770275116,
-0.18194197118282318,
0.0674050897359848,
0.6264031529426575,
-0.7686070799827576,
0.5393350720405579,
0.8898974657058716,
1.1933925151824951,
-0.7102992534637451,
-0.3868829309940338,
-0.3763085603713989,
0.001004460733383894,
-0.5626657009124756,
1.135952353477478,
-0.10427188873291016,
-0.6730727553367615,
0.031742531806230545,
-0.07527879625558853,
-0.036316338926553726,
-0.6665350794792175,
0.6654489040374756,
-0.07313036173582077,
0.28515011072158813,
-0.5638074278831482,
-0.5476815700531006,
-0.37713003158569336,
0.31977763772010803,
-0.42200005054473877,
0.7514829635620117,
0.19241835176944733,
-0.7705416679382324,
0.3777720034122467,
-0.35014015436172485,
-0.5197473764419556,
-0.30858930945396423,
-0.31170138716697693,
-0.4591526687145233,
0.516791045665741,
-0.09611086547374725,
0.3080799877643585,
-0.20606090128421783,
0.6109755635261536,
0.0022176257334649563,
-0.6743835806846619,
0.31023111939430237,
-0.5797747373580933,
0.3725748062133789,
-0.13707596063613892,
-0.2954047620296478,
0.14646156132221222,
-0.6089218854904175,
-0.44299599528312683,
-0.1300089806318283,
-0.03405124321579933,
0.06242414563894272,
0.010750449262559414,
-0.2835342288017273,
-0.08598494529724121,
0.16800573468208313,
-0.16228003799915314,
-0.022260330617427826,
-0.2997751832008362,
-0.006037724670022726,
0.7784191370010376,
0.43720781803131104,
-0.002754857996478677,
-0.6632865071296692,
0.20682311058044434,
0.0714501366019249,
-0.18003898859024048,
-0.326731413602829,
-0.4386557936668396,
-0.8023843765258789,
-0.3190144896507263,
0.047578271478414536,
0.431217759847641,
-0.3558957874774933,
0.6069490909576416,
-0.32057562470436096,
-0.4700150489807129,
-0.1121520921587944,
-0.16230370104312897,
0.19899186491966248,
0.7184917330741882,
0.23870670795440674,
-0.4329269528388977,
-0.32988297939300537,
-0.8945904970169067,
-0.23550724983215332,
-0.3678503632545471,
0.12301913648843765,
0.05799437686800957,
0.6038880348205566,
-0.2712731659412384,
0.7914729118347168,
-0.2852894365787506,
-0.44086238741874695,
-0.020862244069576263,
0.4196103513240814,
0.16001619398593903,
0.07739531248807907,
0.5087288022041321,
-0.43181151151657104,
-0.10275746136903763,
-0.2453460842370987,
-1.0922787189483643,
-0.13693122565746307,
-0.29507994651794434,
0.08886247873306274,
0.4107291102409363,
0.20676250755786896,
-0.5981687307357788,
0.5472657084465027,
0.3901165723800659,
-0.33220282196998596,
0.8458684682846069,
-0.0601796880364418,
0.45607563853263855,
-0.9227842092514038,
-0.14070439338684082,
-0.13938145339488983,
-0.15805797278881073,
-0.6351498961448669,
-0.4551861882209778,
-0.27512210607528687,
0.12689754366874695,
-0.21534539759159088,
0.1124909371137619,
-0.2194187492132187,
-0.4790535569190979,
-0.22340942919254303,
0.5773876309394836,
-0.03098098374903202,
0.48311811685562134,
0.004727647639811039,
0.9389110803604126,
0.30297261476516724,
-0.45513594150543213,
0.46466436982154846,
0.4640587568283081,
-0.2705588638782501,
0.5668854117393494,
-0.5360110402107239,
0.15814325213432312,
-0.24474546313285828,
0.3561468720436096,
-1.111439824104309,
-0.4381105303764343,
0.20715631544589996,
-0.4827764332294464,
0.10533527284860611,
0.27899160981178284,
-0.39088642597198486,
0.16567884385585785,
-0.8471435904502869,
0.1450788676738739,
0.3221566677093506,
-0.46355295181274414,
0.5750977396965027,
0.1274252086877823,
-0.4265468418598175,
-0.5839964747428894,
-0.654032289981842,
0.39323240518569946,
-0.22045524418354034,
-0.5324033498764038,
0.152603879570961,
-0.04249257594347,
-0.4314921796321869,
-0.08742896467447281,
-0.5481232404708862,
0.18607567250728607,
0.0378812737762928,
0.3088665306568146,
0.32555875182151794,
-0.31811192631721497,
0.07893036305904388,
0.09171895682811737,
0.021764187142252922,
0.404495507478714,
0.07543115317821503,
0.33139321208000183,
-0.318148136138916,
-0.4274178147315979,
-0.5764232873916626,
0.214640274643898,
0.5308167934417725,
0.2875199615955353,
0.3238804340362549,
0.21690095961093903,
-0.3705862760543823,
0.04205479472875595,
-0.8395475149154663,
-0.28120794892311096,
-0.38120701909065247,
0.5903467535972595,
-0.3013899028301239,
-0.7718361616134644,
0.6679079532623291,
-0.06555359065532684,
0.2575424313545227,
0.7327578067779541,
0.6925804018974304,
-0.019942359998822212,
0.5107581615447998,
0.3988938629627228,
0.12259772419929504,
-0.11755575984716415,
-0.005114417988806963,
0.18764770030975342,
-0.4825066030025482,
-0.45956507325172424,
-0.4127945899963379,
0.0669541284441948,
-0.5626832842826843,
-0.30639731884002686,
0.4269848167896271,
-0.1505877524614334,
0.23012025654315948,
-0.10927259176969528,
-0.40032094717025757,
0.3923253118991852,
0.01866232044994831,
-0.1531476080417633,
0.6987340450286865,
0.21755650639533997,
0.08829665184020996,
-0.2666931748390198,
-0.47305387258529663,
-0.8253059983253479,
1.08969247341156,
0.39603909850120544,
0.5975885391235352,
0.14548073709011078,
0.7227425575256348,
0.6610068082809448,
0.6079260110855103,
-0.8167624473571777,
0.5744954347610474,
-0.11717173457145691,
-0.3805273771286011,
-0.3864210247993469,
-0.3879866302013397,
-0.41948240995407104,
0.4290676712989807,
-0.10501133650541306,
-0.8797321319580078,
0.05665550380945206,
-0.2627967298030853,
-0.29925236105918884,
0.16133001446723938,
-0.4607502520084381,
0.6959423422813416,
-0.19125288724899292,
-0.1368359625339508,
-0.24924489855766296,
-0.41600337624549866,
0.8816884756088257,
-0.3671017587184906,
0.018802780658006668,
-0.28816738724708557,
-0.14539369940757751,
0.7543759346008301,
-0.3572680354118347,
0.7634747624397278,
0.13424131274223328,
-0.367258757352829,
0.17028051614761353,
0.10942497849464417,
0.4368993043899536,
0.482617050409317,
-0.13039183616638184,
0.4131651818752289,
-0.026273276656866074,
-0.2074427455663681,
-0.7875641584396362,
0.5555409789085388,
-0.7022321224212646,
-1.0282909870147705,
-0.7089154720306396,
-0.5898646712303162,
-0.33878466486930847,
-0.10213523358106613,
0.44840964674949646,
0.611079752445221,
-0.58774733543396,
0.20244233310222626,
0.7690328359603882,
-0.1435331106185913,
0.19108718633651733,
0.310546338558197,
-0.5003305077552795,
-0.50816410779953,
1.0929126739501953,
0.08328111469745636,
0.19912925362586975,
0.18135175108909607,
-0.03232641890645027,
-0.308337539434433,
-0.9201248288154602,
-0.4004848003387451,
0.34931764006614685,
-0.9121415615081787,
-0.15290378034114838,
-0.8488068580627441,
-0.5227795243263245,
-0.4326658248901367,
-0.1587454378604889,
-0.3724726140499115,
-0.49850744009017944,
-0.39737555384635925,
-0.3299948275089264,
0.23846904933452606,
0.7671433687210083,
0.14699402451515198,
0.0171970184892416,
-0.5288474559783936,
0.600697934627533,
0.14429877698421478,
0.21927092969417572,
-0.24025829136371613,
-0.8690078854560852,
0.029160143807530403,
-0.26388588547706604,
-0.4134354293346405,
-0.8913364410400391,
0.10760470479726791,
0.014621724374592304,
0.401847779750824,
0.6373627185821533,
0.2193337082862854,
0.6816158294677734,
-0.3227923512458801,
1.127095103263855,
0.3732640743255615,
-0.9229995608329773,
0.3693453073501587,
-0.22127190232276917,
0.07584375888109207,
0.771619975566864,
0.32193732261657715,
-0.5639369487762451,
-0.8555892109870911,
-0.5013465285301208,
-0.4159889221191406,
0.57366943359375,
0.4059276580810547,
0.1557864248752594,
-0.04426955431699753,
0.35513147711753845,
0.5584160089492798,
0.4244304895401001,
-0.5756679773330688,
-0.291587233543396,
-0.6666330099105835,
-0.026104837656021118,
-0.08186443895101547,
-0.5516914129257202,
-0.35255324840545654,
-0.16306617856025696,
0.5777423977851868,
-0.15444397926330566,
0.36438971757888794,
0.39254170656204224,
-0.2154458463191986,
-0.14552712440490723,
0.13343364000320435,
1.122658610343933,
1.2122944593429565,
-0.5286892056465149,
0.1704428642988205,
0.5107495188713074,
-0.523297131061554,
-0.021816344931721687,
0.014016167260706425,
-0.09454356878995895,
0.5968936681747437,
0.6506375670433044,
0.7677810192108154,
0.35828080773353577,
-0.6419942378997803,
0.6839720606803894,
-0.25860822200775146,
-0.5245770215988159,
-0.4026170074939728,
-0.044799674302339554,
-0.10364100337028503,
0.0816827118396759,
0.5102314352989197,
-0.011607522144913673,
0.41647377610206604,
-0.989829421043396,
0.20984134078025818,
0.31785544753074646,
-0.3383004665374756,
-0.37897759675979614,
0.45662620663642883,
0.22295419871807098,
-0.23274928331375122,
0.5101286172866821,
-0.18324211239814758,
-0.563177227973938,
0.3176341652870178,
0.44971519708633423,
1.1631951332092285,
0.06491787731647491,
0.41481661796569824,
0.18852294981479645,
0.4758572578430176,
-0.043197426944971085,
0.03378653526306152,
0.03241356834769249,
-0.5533249974250793,
-0.3115515410900116,
-0.5391013026237488,
-0.7625929117202759,
0.039356738328933716,
-0.43275728821754456,
0.21167969703674316,
-0.372726708650589,
-0.06515621393918991,
0.013450440019369125,
0.02233736589550972,
0.1436641961336136,
0.09602662920951843,
-0.16588608920574188,
0.7095617651939392,
-0.5061562061309814,
0.43284308910369873,
0.2749935984611511,
-0.3113462030887604,
-0.24054713547229767,
0.40152105689048767,
0.24709075689315796,
-0.47520026564598083,
0.2527652978897095,
0.20107501745224,
-0.25568708777427673,
-0.39839380979537964,
-0.17868174612522125,
-0.5505796074867249,
1.1169496774673462,
0.31138211488723755,
-0.4468465745449066,
-0.28739088773727417,
0.2352074235677719,
0.4744948446750641,
-0.46375200152397156,
0.21258892118930817,
0.7453089356422424,
0.4926801323890686,
0.19042465090751648,
-0.8330445289611816,
0.1721677929162979,
0.011911729350686073,
-0.19803932309150696,
-0.14997519552707672,
-0.792095959186554,
0.41711586713790894,
-0.3365306854248047,
-0.2986302673816681,
0.0900748148560524,
0.8403200507164001,
0.3671678602695465,
0.6194690465927124,
0.2705569267272949,
0.2189730852842331,
0.9803932905197144,
-0.3867761790752411,
0.9291980266571045,
-0.24575519561767578,
0.24889136850833893,
1.1582801342010498,
-0.24807795882225037,
0.3841771185398102,
0.5242929458618164,
-0.09994172304868698,
0.25771281123161316,
0.570854127407074,
-0.3343961834907532,
0.4937407970428467,
0.17909227311611176,
-0.17835280299186707,
0.19579671323299408,
-0.11428499966859818,
-0.5140284299850464,
0.12461689859628677,
0.332485556602478,
-0.14401030540466309,
-0.33066877722740173,
-0.17482000589370728,
-0.05628924444317818,
0.1490601897239685,
-0.09686487913131714,
0.9422722458839417,
0.2903326451778412,
-0.7883317470550537,
0.6942340135574341,
0.000015584062566631474,
0.6133434772491455,
-0.4579557776451111,
0.06109991669654846,
-0.5239517688751221,
-0.20737390220165253,
-0.4927629232406616,
-0.4722180962562561,
0.6312161087989807,
0.2538583278656006,
-0.18273703753948212,
-0.07814452797174454,
0.6422388553619385,
-0.24412740767002106,
-0.38738641142845154,
0.07854115217924118,
0.41126903891563416,
0.571103036403656,
-0.005384230520576239,
-0.25893405079841614,
0.3003537654876709,
0.0844479501247406,
-0.14863228797912598,
0.0969301089644432,
0.6483545899391174,
0.06601348519325256,
0.3622344434261322,
0.3443753719329834,
0.13197538256645203,
-0.04916563630104065,
0.2223592847585678,
0.7539101839065552,
-0.7661865949630737,
-0.1892211139202118,
-0.8588753938674927,
0.29170387983322144,
-0.17396490275859833,
-0.5213679671287537,
0.9028928279876709,
0.8853986859321594,
0.4822577238082886,
-0.007930769585072994,
0.727869987487793,
0.35612645745277405,
0.40101391077041626,
-0.6381606459617615,
0.768488883972168,
-0.4196479022502899,
0.35860946774482727,
-0.35193386673927307,
-1.3252737522125244,
-0.014535181224346161,
0.5130794048309326,
-0.18716765940189362,
0.01771296188235283,
1.131488561630249,
0.8261033296585083,
0.18405069410800934,
0.4216075837612152,
0.6116176247596741,
0.3564606010913849,
0.03588888794183731,
0.1707887500524521,
1.2164298295974731,
-0.29990893602371216,
0.442743182182312,
-0.19455969333648682,
-0.1262519657611847,
-0.47235098481178284,
-0.8734840750694275,
-1.1621551513671875,
-0.5185474753379822,
-0.4675081670284271,
-0.4443700313568115,
0.3041819930076599,
0.7858370542526245,
0.2833768427371979,
-0.8758091926574707,
-0.2433864027261734,
-0.008732165209949017,
0.3763561546802521,
0.057936955243349075,
-0.2190609574317932,
0.42191997170448303,
-0.6212379336357117,
-0.571848452091217,
0.20949622988700867,
0.6737204790115356,
0.01469715591520071,
-0.4319736957550049,
-0.21660873293876648,
0.22924038767814636,
0.3742978274822235,
0.7032546997070312,
-0.23741015791893005,
-1.1180750131607056,
-0.4121668040752411,
-0.1018417626619339,
-0.07555164396762848,
0.2933836877346039,
0.8865235447883606,
-0.3790287971496582,
0.26355263590812683,
0.1657913476228714,
0.6188006401062012,
0.5125137567520142,
0.28004390001296997,
0.47059378027915955,
-0.5073323249816895,
0.03702353313565254,
0.22414511442184448,
0.20515042543411255,
0.40840059518814087,
-0.35979828238487244,
0.5042098164558411,
0.3975367546081543,
-0.39706894755363464,
-1.1084729433059692,
-0.19637981057167053,
-1.1579526662826538,
-0.17006133496761322,
1.0034122467041016,
-0.12690547108650208,
-0.013036565855145454,
-0.09008821845054626,
-0.19137315452098846,
0.15053610503673553,
-0.46589624881744385,
1.3177732229232788,
1.076022744178772,
-0.10657189041376114,
0.00012010327191092074,
-0.6064562797546387,
0.7165578007698059,
0.3646332323551178,
-1.0834070444107056,
0.2110273391008377,
0.698986291885376,
0.145646870136261,
0.4003733694553375,
0.6229586005210876,
-0.20182715356349945,
0.5242522954940796,
0.04191863164305687,
-0.4083804488182068,
0.12081379443407059,
-0.4124874770641327,
-0.3248143196105957,
0.2243400514125824,
-0.05783956125378609,
0.3294224143028259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07214v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07214v2
|
Exploring the Frontier of Vision-Language Models: A Survey of Current Methodologies and Future Directions
| 2024-02-20T18:57:34 | 2024-04-12T21:20:37 |
Akash Ghosh, Arkadeep Acharya, Sriparna Saha, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has significantly reshaped the
trajectory of the AI revolution. Nevertheless, these LLMs exhibit a notable
limitation, as they are primarily adept at processing textual information. To
address this constraint, researchers have endeavored to integrate visual
capabilities with LLMs, resulting in the emergence of Vision-Language Models
(VLMs). These advanced models are instrumental in tackling more intricate tasks
such as image captioning and visual question answering. In our comprehensive
survey paper, we delve into the key advancements within the realm of VLMs. Our
classification organizes VLMs into three distinct categories: models dedicated
to vision-language understanding, models that process multimodal inputs to
generate unimodal (textual) outputs and models that both accept and produce
multimodal inputs and outputs.This classification is based on their respective
capabilities and functionalities in processing and generating various
modalities of data.We meticulously dissect each model, offering an extensive
analysis of its foundational architecture, training data sources, as well as
its strengths and limitations wherever possible, providing readers with a
comprehensive understanding of its essential components. We also analyzed the
performance of VLMs in various benchmark datasets. By doing so, we aim to offer
a nuanced understanding of the diverse landscape of VLMs. Additionally, we
underscore potential avenues for future research in this dynamic domain,
anticipating further breakthroughs and advancements.
|
[
-0.49891915917396545,
-0.7750716209411621,
0.781058669090271,
-0.16450779139995575,
-0.019678790122270584,
0.2579335570335388,
-0.1732136309146881,
-0.616987407207489,
-0.1678970605134964,
0.8858053088188171,
-0.33364903926849365,
-0.49068254232406616,
-0.5701209306716919,
-0.11668183654546738,
-0.6644484996795654,
0.6092206835746765,
-0.06060459837317467,
0.278033047914505,
-0.7670726776123047,
-0.21522286534309387,
-0.412907212972641,
-0.6115912795066833,
-0.25119394063949585,
-0.12656967341899872,
0.4948236346244812,
0.09492915123701096,
0.4253894090652466,
0.6520362496376038,
0.6626137495040894,
0.35830989480018616,
-0.12288018316030502,
0.1929813176393509,
-0.20779457688331604,
0.11497852951288223,
0.08653389662504196,
-0.6050443649291992,
-0.35305508971214294,
-0.03813714161515236,
0.845058023929596,
0.9123030304908752,
0.0822368860244751,
0.2542581558227539,
0.003818705677986145,
0.5965653657913208,
-0.6479881405830383,
0.2927744388580322,
-0.613875687122345,
0.0526839904487133,
-0.20649786293506622,
-0.11246759444475174,
-0.35022270679473877,
0.053911808878183365,
0.28330692648887634,
-0.2865678668022156,
0.06361144036054611,
0.13081105053424835,
0.6902508735656738,
0.2775360345840454,
-0.38699138164520264,
0.0026489202864468098,
-0.749230146408081,
0.9012110233306885,
-0.6149364709854126,
0.654788613319397,
0.13377977907657623,
0.4598544239997864,
0.237470805644989,
-1.0161224603652954,
-0.5893304944038391,
-0.2809012532234192,
0.2093082219362259,
0.09964606165885925,
-0.3149735927581787,
0.10045911371707916,
0.10246013104915619,
0.325794517993927,
-0.5409060120582581,
0.3416338860988617,
-0.46574369072914124,
-0.0020598135888576508,
0.5109438896179199,
0.5254954099655151,
0.44203588366508484,
-0.09302478283643723,
-0.487690806388855,
-0.08115179091691971,
-0.6354027986526489,
0.1377076357603073,
-0.02002161741256714,
0.07520082592964172,
-0.10825760662555695,
0.9221466779708862,
-0.34056612849235535,
1.240451455116272,
-0.6541691422462463,
-0.21313008666038513,
0.08159354329109192,
-0.6224198937416077,
-0.36562538146972656,
-0.5517910122871399,
0.7793252468109131,
0.5986144542694092,
0.20944319665431976,
-0.04727235436439514,
-0.32910582423210144,
0.07257639616727829,
0.2883167564868927,
-0.28114405274391174,
-0.05050053820014,
0.025512197986245155,
-0.530052900314331,
-0.37198564410209656,
-0.1820821762084961,
-0.9437581300735474,
-0.7248766422271729,
-0.5794955492019653,
0.26984474062919617,
-0.2480764538049698,
-0.18804223835468292,
0.0003013490932062268,
-0.17354850471019745,
0.6025398969650269,
0.6365076899528503,
-0.6857914924621582,
0.12482495605945587,
0.48045292496681213,
0.705807089805603,
-0.28809699416160583,
-0.4755536913871765,
-0.2653237581253052,
0.013372981920838356,
-0.3687503933906555,
0.7343083024024963,
-0.750282883644104,
-0.14161382615566254,
0.4317397177219391,
-0.23088380694389343,
-0.1010170727968216,
-0.4678656756877899,
0.03412242233753204,
-0.6279995441436768,
0.1658155620098114,
-0.29177215695381165,
-0.3694385886192322,
-0.4695827066898346,
0.5085306167602539,
-0.6659185886383057,
0.6740524172782898,
-0.057747941464185715,
-0.6370371580123901,
0.2665140926837921,
-0.5312512516975403,
-0.13080234825611115,
0.3618319630622864,
-0.43461868166923523,
-0.08706169575452805,
0.27786609530448914,
0.1629384309053421,
0.6199496388435364,
-0.6277954578399658,
0.2982621192932129,
-0.2277502864599228,
-0.11242575198411942,
0.4802103638648987,
-0.617577314376831,
0.6115146279335022,
0.17697343230247498,
-0.14840658009052277,
0.29016679525375366,
-0.7679136991500854,
0.00004276202162145637,
0.24664649367332458,
-0.17616096138954163,
-0.16925130784511566,
0.2813436686992645,
0.32929709553718567,
0.12910574674606323,
0.41835716366767883,
-0.34295853972435,
0.07374032586812973,
0.031640566885471344,
0.5785179734230042,
0.6509985327720642,
-0.44060003757476807,
0.43303051590919495,
0.07506802678108215,
0.6057359576225281,
0.0006319201784208417,
0.4602492153644562,
-0.5140810608863831,
-0.4541136920452118,
-1.0505884885787964,
-0.13984280824661255,
0.058672454208135605,
0.5215356945991516,
-1.2061727046966553,
-0.1978975385427475,
-0.33271488547325134,
-0.481195330619812,
-0.5021886229515076,
0.1756839156150818,
0.4241449236869812,
0.3833170235157013,
0.23908156156539917,
-0.18325760960578918,
-0.37829259037971497,
-0.9542365670204163,
-0.11011272668838501,
-0.4643324017524719,
0.1988082081079483,
0.26261577010154724,
0.4195261001586914,
-0.2513105571269989,
0.8156321048736572,
-0.366874635219574,
-0.14721497893333435,
-0.6802569627761841,
-0.1679159253835678,
-0.141553595662117,
0.0903143510222435,
0.6338481307029724,
-1.147576928138733,
-0.1201227530837059,
0.09211726486682892,
-1.020530104637146,
0.08229438960552216,
0.054941050708293915,
0.32305222749710083,
0.24931536614894867,
0.7135372757911682,
-0.35199448466300964,
0.4474122226238251,
0.6726186275482178,
-0.2353120893239975,
0.453118234872818,
-0.031273771077394485,
-0.03871257230639458,
-0.7626035809516907,
-0.06267713010311127,
0.0711091086268425,
-0.0739273801445961,
-0.8487643003463745,
0.3249918520450592,
-0.05634407326579094,
-0.015874888747930527,
-0.6176086068153381,
0.6056721806526184,
-0.6767110824584961,
-0.40317481756210327,
-0.23127208650112152,
0.1360892653465271,
-0.11578624695539474,
0.4350857436656952,
0.25264668464660645,
0.558987557888031,
0.8743323683738708,
-0.4035383462905884,
0.6927513480186462,
0.05098811909556389,
-0.39019930362701416,
0.3507249355316162,
-0.5072132349014282,
-0.24747510254383087,
-0.3278656601905823,
-0.13487525284290314,
-1.111634373664856,
-0.24503299593925476,
0.22927026450634003,
-0.3258289396762848,
0.17255011200904846,
-0.0043923077173531055,
-0.5253064632415771,
-0.5907207727432251,
-0.18740226328372955,
0.4819636940956116,
0.597122311592102,
-0.30330824851989746,
0.8547056317329407,
0.46249592304229736,
-0.22892706096172333,
-0.5778483152389526,
-0.7167425155639648,
0.45098721981048584,
-0.14189505577087402,
-0.5449743866920471,
0.007555427961051464,
-0.024193067103624344,
-0.5367152094841003,
-0.09081673622131348,
0.29164984822273254,
-0.042064934968948364,
-0.11446268111467361,
0.20649246871471405,
0.567962110042572,
-0.2568880617618561,
-0.052166763693094254,
-0.39238330721855164,
0.05500251427292824,
-0.00494619132950902,
-0.28509071469306946,
0.5554392337799072,
-0.46524930000305176,
-0.41451624035835266,
-0.1866438239812851,
0.3303496837615967,
0.912868857383728,
-0.9268561601638794,
0.6538246273994446,
0.5755667090415955,
-0.22676058113574982,
-0.06892611086368561,
-0.7276096940040588,
0.1363576501607895,
-0.3867453932762146,
0.7093034386634827,
-0.23665446043014526,
-0.9704414010047913,
0.3242858648300171,
0.04729318991303444,
0.20039118826389313,
0.2445623278617859,
0.6152230501174927,
-0.2709766626358032,
0.8540480732917786,
1.1818510293960571,
0.20899637043476105,
0.6665236949920654,
-0.2831041216850281,
0.2323109656572342,
-0.8450073599815369,
-0.5469456911087036,
-0.20898622274398804,
0.035406388342380524,
-0.5465819835662842,
-0.6016889214515686,
0.4446815252304077,
-0.3005317449569702,
0.17576171457767487,
0.04244496300816536,
-0.15154743194580078,
0.2929260730743408,
0.5438058376312256,
-0.23159369826316833,
0.2504490315914154,
0.06999893486499786,
0.0903761014342308,
0.00948896910995245,
-0.841368556022644,
-0.5910136699676514,
1.1871904134750366,
0.4680030941963196,
0.7717236280441284,
-0.08469921350479126,
0.2959819734096527,
0.10005336999893188,
0.25045856833457947,
-0.6910077929496765,
0.8413389325141907,
-0.24483658373355865,
-0.4336177408695221,
-0.3690701127052307,
-0.009805749170482159,
-0.6143010258674622,
0.5505130887031555,
-0.22247211635112762,
-0.6741358041763306,
0.09595432877540588,
0.13691219687461853,
-0.05514751747250557,
0.6152755618095398,
-0.5107278823852539,
1.002846360206604,
-0.5258747935295105,
-0.4535837173461914,
0.060604047030210495,
-0.7909300923347473,
0.5609419941902161,
-0.020358819514513016,
0.3187175989151001,
-0.02390507236123085,
-0.23438934981822968,
0.4692787826061249,
0.09447243064641953,
1.0140117406845093,
-0.01963995024561882,
-0.1849246472120285,
0.39315152168273926,
-0.15388306975364685,
0.015108303166925907,
-0.31564250588417053,
0.42002615332603455,
0.3881983757019043,
0.11460085958242416,
-0.24721062183380127,
-0.31882306933403015,
0.36403170228004456,
-0.5007616877555847,
-0.443416565656662,
-0.35748490691185,
-0.6108407378196716,
-0.3469151258468628,
0.2496483325958252,
0.10133678466081619,
0.6639649868011475,
-0.1713242381811142,
0.189922496676445,
0.7368162274360657,
-0.46932607889175415,
0.6513047814369202,
0.4179181158542633,
-0.646705687046051,
-0.2765842378139496,
1.0475425720214844,
0.053762197494506836,
0.3723977506160736,
0.5238551497459412,
-0.3315044641494751,
-0.47630438208580017,
-0.9454196095466614,
-0.46589934825897217,
0.2904778718948364,
-0.9392672181129456,
0.016587061807513237,
-0.7251716256141663,
-0.39668378233909607,
-0.24289189279079437,
0.004932562354952097,
-0.35738131403923035,
0.03849790245294571,
-0.2102503925561905,
0.10496503859758377,
0.09367089718580246,
0.9081513285636902,
0.3540479838848114,
0.271391361951828,
-0.7001526355743408,
0.44713765382766724,
0.434200644493103,
0.3179830014705658,
0.04476972669363022,
-0.252891480922699,
-0.22256885468959808,
-0.014648809097707272,
-0.06282541900873184,
-0.7335051894187927,
0.385424941778183,
-0.049433592706918716,
0.6761687994003296,
0.21129469573497772,
-0.2960761785507202,
0.5899733901023865,
-0.6810137629508972,
1.091525912284851,
0.3629392683506012,
-0.5753023624420166,
0.3525998294353485,
-0.2834107279777527,
0.22076112031936646,
0.2014775276184082,
0.0224184338003397,
-0.6451893448829651,
-0.3976631164550781,
-0.20823350548744202,
-0.8194888234138489,
0.4279298186302185,
0.04279676452279091,
0.18613670766353607,
0.30248019099235535,
0.0598173514008522,
-0.023852253332734108,
0.4776522219181061,
-0.791054904460907,
-0.10860177129507065,
-0.11495928466320038,
-0.2892472743988037,
-0.2328473925590515,
-0.21290729939937592,
-0.07144436985254288,
-0.22793570160865784,
0.13277721405029297,
-0.25318434834480286,
0.1706894487142563,
-0.08641903847455978,
-0.3091362416744232,
0.17991508543491364,
0.20515410602092743,
0.5909788608551025,
0.9132994413375854,
0.15738016366958618,
0.17772510647773743,
-0.020756002515554428,
-0.37024152278900146,
-0.1879178136587143,
0.08006192743778229,
-0.299965500831604,
-0.04123808071017265,
0.6480908393859863,
1.0654963254928589,
-0.23568034172058105,
-1.1016803979873657,
0.5811973810195923,
-0.11217491328716278,
-0.10867651551961899,
-0.5273681879043579,
-0.004083741456270218,
-0.043366607278585434,
0.5307531356811523,
0.3693081736564636,
0.16204410791397095,
0.13574953377246857,
-0.6580680012702942,
-0.2100217342376709,
0.6808643937110901,
-0.371207594871521,
-0.2620263397693634,
0.8182332515716553,
0.15671001374721527,
-0.05216732248663902,
0.5403802990913391,
0.37656283378601074,
-0.4191747307777405,
0.550529420375824,
0.21283544600009918,
0.8991851806640625,
0.2245098352432251,
0.2733844816684723,
-0.15265806019306183,
0.5281970500946045,
0.14208318293094635,
0.3005205988883972,
-0.07094089686870575,
-0.7790956497192383,
-0.4166499078273773,
-0.9149015545845032,
-0.35393691062927246,
0.25713908672332764,
-0.5452991127967834,
-0.005397356580942869,
-0.1732834428548813,
-0.1486070454120636,
0.07720641046762466,
-0.5396561622619629,
-0.8516486883163452,
0.29749542474746704,
0.7220007181167603,
0.8217515349388123,
-0.7761295437812805,
0.6821108460426331,
1.0283092260360718,
-0.5073371529579163,
-0.19904963672161102,
-0.13064789772033691,
0.05175585672259331,
-0.9835454821586609,
0.6212092638015747,
0.019194668158888817,
-0.12819011509418488,
-0.012831530533730984,
-0.7414098978042603,
-0.7988139390945435,
1.0172687768936157,
0.13606782257556915,
-0.5409438610076904,
-0.21997104585170746,
0.30094411969184875,
0.6645922660827637,
-0.3909912705421448,
-0.033833857625722885,
0.5524903535842896,
0.35345473885536194,
0.04051002487540245,
-0.8048067688941956,
-0.4181804955005646,
-0.2770325541496277,
0.49315983057022095,
0.036118537187576294,
-0.5717008113861084,
0.7219590544700623,
-0.3372863531112671,
-0.08447808772325516,
0.34154844284057617,
0.7071689367294312,
0.15261821448802948,
0.3643348515033722,
0.32729774713516235,
0.3091525733470917,
0.21940715610980988,
-0.281620591878891,
1.143776774406433,
-0.051844991743564606,
-0.03855820372700691,
0.671395480632782,
-0.2703567147254944,
1.0009225606918335,
0.833952009677887,
-0.2762250602245331,
0.16158853471279144,
0.5475001931190491,
-0.24133147299289703,
0.3475542366504669,
0.006131215486675501,
-0.08555672317743301,
-0.39221057295799255,
-0.2868998348712921,
-0.18070505559444427,
0.6806440353393555,
0.3224928677082062,
-0.3822348713874817,
-0.05877542868256569,
0.36821448802948,
-0.4023904502391815,
0.0942351371049881,
-0.45964521169662476,
0.7602026462554932,
-0.03746282681822777,
-0.5583745241165161,
0.4014490842819214,
-0.10093873739242554,
0.604903519153595,
-0.6219230890274048,
-0.09601391106843948,
-0.22497357428073883,
0.0011929742759093642,
0.2020302712917328,
-1.0711601972579956,
-0.028382297605276108,
0.1565723568201065,
-0.16549409925937653,
-0.4340433180332184,
0.6575754284858704,
-0.5228444337844849,
-0.6202298402786255,
0.2278479039669037,
0.9151526689529419,
0.07620352506637573,
0.11547011882066727,
-0.45776352286338806,
0.4588637351989746,
0.03802177682518959,
-0.08405079692602158,
0.19081343710422516,
0.21013016998767853,
-0.19100381433963776,
0.911942183971405,
0.48183733224868774,
0.10920880734920502,
0.428180992603302,
0.12864859402179718,
0.827982485294342,
-0.7500068545341492,
-0.20074094831943512,
-0.8019292950630188,
0.7605905532836914,
-0.0123828100040555,
-0.2684788405895233,
0.6472704410552979,
0.41586121916770935,
0.9623920917510986,
-0.21824441850185394,
0.8700408935546875,
-0.008203268051147461,
0.1220216304063797,
-0.6946148872375488,
0.6199269890785217,
-0.9953416585922241,
0.14331407845020294,
-0.3057444393634796,
-0.9111565351486206,
-0.41442054510116577,
0.12609855830669403,
-0.21731293201446533,
0.05378501117229462,
0.3169077932834625,
0.4688882827758789,
0.1762339323759079,
-0.18173594772815704,
0.6033757328987122,
0.15009449422359467,
0.2524189352989197,
0.3317672312259674,
1.3049678802490234,
-0.1496267318725586,
0.45759496092796326,
-0.05898555368185043,
-0.12095248699188232,
-0.16851644217967987,
-0.5689058899879456,
-0.8855075240135193,
-0.8556768894195557,
-0.15601077675819397,
0.24717657268047333,
-0.06124406307935715,
0.2671733796596527,
0.490251362323761,
-0.3512921631336212,
-0.3859094977378845,
-0.0387946180999279,
-0.059930574148893356,
-0.028654053807258606,
-0.173474982380867,
0.06588312238454819,
-0.21654310822486877,
-0.7960240244865417,
0.17988570034503937,
0.5525257587432861,
0.32804083824157715,
-0.6974320411682129,
-0.08529666811227798,
0.032495979219675064,
0.03467739373445511,
0.9908071160316467,
0.23275430500507355,
-1.3080942630767822,
0.139164000749588,
0.23990628123283386,
-0.07673688232898712,
-0.12490098923444748,
0.5108215808868408,
-0.7432228922843933,
0.6629056334495544,
0.5347505807876587,
0.7102224826812744,
0.339386522769928,
-0.3571670651435852,
0.582552969455719,
-0.25746864080429077,
0.06572528183460236,
0.24936604499816895,
0.5483148097991943,
0.5824971199035645,
0.25361746549606323,
0.4641420245170593,
0.2792814373970032,
-0.1434880793094635,
-1.1152223348617554,
0.35700711607933044,
-1.0100140571594238,
-0.49296867847442627,
1.0970747470855713,
0.17545148730278015,
-0.36685001850128174,
0.17939190566539764,
-0.2633945345878601,
-0.04044942930340767,
0.2975451648235321,
0.32673463225364685,
0.6745207905769348,
-0.12759855389595032,
-0.7745783925056458,
-0.890752911567688,
0.17999231815338135,
0.22253446280956268,
-0.8587661981582642,
0.21960465610027313,
0.7874067425727844,
0.02771684341132641,
0.2081134170293808,
0.4865940511226654,
-0.2888250946998596,
0.24167180061340332,
-0.0672823116183281,
0.15350580215454102,
-0.005542398430407047,
-0.759871780872345,
-0.45791682600975037,
0.2911258339881897,
0.19617921113967896,
-0.2229199856519699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13234v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13234v1
|
Unlocking Insights: Semantic Search in Jupyter Notebooks
| 2024-02-20T18:49:41 | 2024-02-20T18:49:41 |
Lan Li, Jinpeng Lv
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Semantic search, a process aimed at delivering highly relevant search results
by comprehending the searcher's intent and the contextual meaning of terms
within a searchable dataspace, plays a pivotal role in information retrieval.
In this paper, we investigate the application of large language models to
enhance semantic search capabilities, specifically tailored for the domain of
Jupyter Notebooks. Our objective is to retrieve generated outputs, such as
figures or tables, associated functions and methods, and other pertinent
information.
We demonstrate a semantic search framework that achieves a comprehensive
semantic understanding of the entire notebook's contents, enabling it to
effectively handle various types of user queries. Key components of this
framework include:
1). A data preprocessor is designed to handle diverse types of cells within
Jupyter Notebooks, encompassing both markdown and code cells. 2). An innovative
methodology is devised to address token size limitations that arise with
code-type cells. We implement a finer-grained approach to data input,
transitioning from the cell level to the function level, effectively resolving
these issues.
|
[
-0.1770394742488861,
-0.8104801177978516,
0.8697130680084229,
-0.07071907818317413,
-0.059183113276958466,
0.026208890601992607,
-0.28856122493743896,
-0.4172852337360382,
0.3432122766971588,
0.6002736687660217,
-0.4800952672958374,
-0.643125057220459,
-0.51693195104599,
0.1672884225845337,
-0.622546911239624,
0.9701661467552185,
-0.06691554933786392,
-0.048155754804611206,
-0.3917829990386963,
0.20205511152744293,
-0.4280698299407959,
-0.30973535776138306,
-0.12908519804477692,
-0.0008863347466103733,
0.7026194930076599,
0.4695444405078888,
0.7456099390983582,
0.5037556290626526,
0.5504093766212463,
0.3513604402542114,
-0.2706392705440521,
-0.1291428953409195,
-0.3420785963535309,
0.5228179693222046,
-0.6160503625869751,
-0.46798720955848694,
-0.1953997015953064,
-0.14591112732887268,
0.7147614359855652,
0.6424096822738647,
-0.02174360118806362,
0.11653361469507217,
-0.11817670613527298,
0.6067975759506226,
-0.769701361656189,
0.4995124936103821,
-0.8348184823989868,
0.10497845709323883,
-0.5327926874160767,
-0.25451958179473877,
-0.42213764786720276,
0.020661449059844017,
0.1763632744550705,
-1.0423321723937988,
0.2407388538122177,
-0.19760674238204956,
0.7745542526245117,
-0.008356507867574692,
-0.385751873254776,
-0.36018630862236023,
-0.3781930208206177,
0.6144947409629822,
-0.43520334362983704,
0.04774389788508415,
0.11810604482889175,
0.4508601725101471,
-0.639406144618988,
-1.093875765800476,
-0.6877086758613586,
-0.15026098489761353,
-0.15017247200012207,
0.16191723942756653,
0.07818286865949631,
0.351998895406723,
0.38317257165908813,
0.22708716988563538,
-0.6086979508399963,
-0.22952412068843842,
-0.390063613653183,
-0.13130515813827515,
0.41023123264312744,
0.2522202432155609,
0.5153848528862,
-0.3910518288612366,
0.06536883860826492,
-0.33314698934555054,
-0.2286965399980545,
0.004669764544814825,
0.23954467475414276,
0.36192944645881653,
0.6002167463302612,
0.8862411379814148,
-0.7238850593566895,
0.8122467398643494,
-0.49752092361450195,
0.14624951779842377,
-0.06894219666719437,
-0.5557302236557007,
0.21484646201133728,
0.09546325355768204,
0.1536862701177597,
0.12725277245044708,
0.2740529775619507,
-0.2149529904127121,
-0.2866189479827881,
0.16677454113960266,
0.470347136259079,
-1.0568021535873413,
-0.3350481688976288,
0.2560327649116516,
-0.574076235294342,
-0.37383922934532166,
0.3696540296077728,
-0.751005232334137,
-0.2593640983104706,
-0.3879455327987671,
0.6673263907432556,
-0.31301724910736084,
-0.1251547932624817,
0.2312534600496292,
-0.7180209159851074,
0.18740734457969666,
0.7040229439735413,
-0.8488526940345764,
0.5814802050590515,
0.7094547152519226,
0.6483275294303894,
0.003581930650398135,
-0.1419849842786789,
-0.7764883041381836,
0.20813587307929993,
-0.29126986861228943,
0.6115642189979553,
-0.9547098875045776,
-0.3828238248825073,
-0.09301687031984329,
0.03089788183569908,
-0.30432721972465515,
-0.32316309213638306,
0.5139924883842468,
-0.8494552969932556,
0.11532775312662125,
0.032369595021009445,
-0.6960758566856384,
-0.12777166068553925,
0.057255588471889496,
-0.747140109539032,
0.9811720252037048,
0.22394537925720215,
-1.016682505607605,
0.21857160329818726,
-1.0342521667480469,
-0.424314945936203,
0.2867392897605896,
-0.3723076581954956,
-0.04458882659673691,
0.40266817808151245,
0.058528777211904526,
0.5839178562164307,
-0.25787195563316345,
0.22117756307125092,
-0.15899810194969177,
-0.4710128903388977,
0.38515937328338623,
0.27848273515701294,
0.42005017399787903,
0.08723700791597366,
-0.11675752699375153,
0.35511353611946106,
-0.5603367686271667,
0.2105947732925415,
0.4562106132507324,
-0.16530407965183258,
-0.5984169244766235,
0.07943924516439438,
0.34959983825683594,
0.15626823902130127,
0.45714956521987915,
-0.8307796120643616,
0.2816569209098816,
-0.19059646129608154,
0.5518942475318909,
0.34965434670448303,
-0.39048653841018677,
0.40060415863990784,
0.08512163162231445,
0.39824938774108887,
0.15834245085716248,
0.045641954988241196,
-0.4658134877681732,
-0.33992087841033936,
-0.33467069268226624,
0.011957610957324505,
0.4883881211280823,
0.23335526883602142,
-0.7226475477218628,
0.5053297281265259,
-0.34219130873680115,
-0.45181816816329956,
-0.30349481105804443,
-0.04513893276453018,
0.06875769793987274,
0.6835783123970032,
0.46473386883735657,
-0.35719022154808044,
-0.11706004291772842,
-0.821435809135437,
-0.2559622824192047,
0.07177848368883133,
-0.17674313485622406,
0.48417702317237854,
0.7031228542327881,
-0.3355012536048889,
0.9959235787391663,
-0.8110567331314087,
-0.2985646724700928,
-0.3664275109767914,
0.03790009021759033,
0.28772616386413574,
0.46770328283309937,
0.1709740310907364,
-1.3193552494049072,
-0.08239138126373291,
0.2015838623046875,
-0.35937920212745667,
0.1298644095659256,
0.05213121697306633,
-0.18595434725284576,
0.24254262447357178,
0.6852439045906067,
-0.8721016645431519,
0.8490880727767944,
0.16948619484901428,
-0.4761412739753723,
0.4555321931838989,
-0.31866857409477234,
-0.20011521875858307,
-0.9366658926010132,
0.5370969176292419,
-0.24610885977745056,
-0.025208091363310814,
-0.37970057129859924,
0.24118572473526,
0.5053750276565552,
-0.4169515371322632,
0.05427387356758118,
0.48852622509002686,
-0.04899386316537857,
-0.32386231422424316,
-0.3073027729988098,
0.31294021010398865,
0.4294710159301758,
-0.06709370017051697,
0.2951100766658783,
0.838911771774292,
0.2730976939201355,
-0.4300932288169861,
0.19010290503501892,
0.3849228620529175,
-0.46834543347358704,
-0.10399212688207626,
-0.7030322551727295,
-0.1305728554725647,
-0.2773478031158447,
0.6834984421730042,
-0.977685809135437,
-0.5706932544708252,
-0.43268123269081116,
-0.49780911207199097,
0.2694634795188904,
-0.2814505100250244,
-0.7680120468139648,
-0.19495344161987305,
-0.451239675283432,
0.4023870527744293,
0.1264214664697647,
-0.6485495567321777,
0.6936702728271484,
0.35351014137268066,
-0.34278807044029236,
-0.49728742241859436,
-0.19517001509666443,
0.2247813493013382,
-0.09222429990768433,
-0.9886565804481506,
0.8846368789672852,
0.21339143812656403,
-0.03761741891503334,
0.11281409114599228,
-0.33515721559524536,
-0.10325305163860321,
0.3282141387462616,
-0.04452800750732422,
0.47168344259262085,
-0.1576341688632965,
0.3305667042732239,
0.2309020310640335,
-0.2813349664211273,
-0.02408185973763466,
-0.593747615814209,
0.6648139953613281,
0.045861437916755676,
0.13088646531105042,
-0.0894320085644722,
0.45707523822784424,
0.4124390482902527,
-0.47114038467407227,
0.6342190504074097,
0.7794369459152222,
-0.3584657609462738,
-0.23196379840373993,
-0.274153470993042,
-0.3060348629951477,
-0.45962047576904297,
0.5088917016983032,
-0.5637550354003906,
-0.8328584432601929,
0.5980051159858704,
-0.1859111338853836,
-0.451892226934433,
0.4598148465156555,
0.19924350082874298,
0.008262145332992077,
0.9280917644500732,
0.696478545665741,
0.30962568521499634,
0.6836819648742676,
-0.2174631506204605,
0.2657186686992645,
-1.0610990524291992,
-0.3632599115371704,
-0.893369197845459,
-0.04236961901187897,
-0.9908115267753601,
-0.36569949984550476,
0.45671918988227844,
-0.025877702981233597,
-0.04273488372564316,
0.4759266674518585,
-0.5527448654174805,
0.7323010563850403,
0.6202811598777771,
-0.009856055490672588,
0.14220547676086426,
-0.112631656229496,
-0.2337528020143509,
0.0077303266152739525,
-0.5811783671379089,
-0.26702165603637695,
0.9571196436882019,
-0.04205721989274025,
0.9523266553878784,
-0.11025514453649521,
0.7562306523323059,
-0.13806405663490295,
-0.3303603529930115,
-0.8294718861579895,
0.4697181284427643,
-0.28424936532974243,
-0.6176101565361023,
-0.46568286418914795,
-0.5210283398628235,
-1.0143396854400635,
0.3833963871002197,
0.019712695851922035,
-1.061415433883667,
-0.042903535068035126,
-0.3341192603111267,
-0.01947127841413021,
-0.005232570227235556,
-0.5736608505249023,
1.2698501348495483,
0.03025059774518013,
-0.592775285243988,
-0.516322672367096,
-0.8750997185707092,
0.031674664467573166,
0.035953622311353683,
-0.13027864694595337,
-0.0780482292175293,
-0.1719018518924713,
0.8526867032051086,
-0.37988558411598206,
0.2076599895954132,
-0.1970137506723404,
0.17297568917274475,
-0.07603919506072998,
0.22459092736244202,
0.39098429679870605,
0.12205130606889725,
-0.08637295663356781,
-0.15452344715595245,
0.5778275728225708,
-0.42053961753845215,
-0.6011626124382019,
0.8137851357460022,
-0.42422425746917725,
-0.6792560815811157,
-0.2868987023830414,
-0.6320790648460388,
0.03414860740303993,
0.49574679136276245,
-0.03908954933285713,
0.5038347840309143,
-0.05531328171491623,
0.32652243971824646,
0.591972827911377,
-0.483855277299881,
0.28086206316947937,
0.3085213005542755,
-0.418003112077713,
0.14131323993206024,
0.8864467144012451,
0.1910073608160019,
-0.04074011370539665,
0.6608334183692932,
0.36971473693847656,
-0.4123784899711609,
-0.4265725910663605,
-0.394949346780777,
0.022573893889784813,
-0.7737778425216675,
-0.30264467000961304,
-0.8044912815093994,
-0.05139368399977684,
-0.45878803730010986,
-0.0990658700466156,
-0.12086519598960876,
-0.9013620018959045,
-0.09813791513442993,
0.1921900063753128,
0.3929552435874939,
0.615708589553833,
0.37540096044540405,
0.02447824738919735,
-0.7397281527519226,
0.30209654569625854,
0.03653055801987648,
0.3318791687488556,
-0.1611206978559494,
-0.2531479299068451,
-0.33545899391174316,
-0.4228171408176422,
-0.21247340738773346,
-0.6489512324333191,
0.4088735580444336,
-0.0705069825053215,
0.2076667845249176,
-0.1754777580499649,
0.10226050764322281,
0.6298669576644897,
-0.29419809579849243,
0.5926997661590576,
-0.30594518780708313,
-0.9931440353393555,
0.9281051158905029,
-0.54336017370224,
0.3267844319343567,
0.5787146091461182,
0.20257693529129028,
-0.5333788990974426,
0.08645297586917877,
-0.6209234595298767,
-1.1394577026367188,
0.967698335647583,
0.3598569929599762,
0.165437251329422,
0.14761100709438324,
0.3762994706630707,
-0.07773740589618683,
0.12332618236541748,
-0.27702510356903076,
0.3461669087409973,
-0.19658148288726807,
-0.24421349167823792,
0.21927309036254883,
0.04844369739294052,
0.035351794213056564,
-0.37518972158432007,
0.34427064657211304,
-0.39734914898872375,
0.1424356997013092,
0.44433796405792236,
-0.14838199317455292,
0.17829881608486176,
0.1851043999195099,
0.1643524467945099,
0.6528677344322205,
-0.35661739110946655,
0.0201204065233469,
-0.26131850481033325,
-0.5942657589912415,
-0.5225718021392822,
0.4542956054210663,
-0.048200223594903946,
0.05908342823386192,
0.06537880003452301,
0.19270701706409454,
0.13523541390895844,
-0.954745888710022,
0.6152973175048828,
-0.4622613787651062,
0.27081599831581116,
-0.4477451741695404,
0.2771671414375305,
0.03218095004558563,
-0.04725399985909462,
0.32893773913383484,
-0.28519535064697266,
0.7134616374969482,
-0.5249758362770081,
0.17901372909545898,
0.43545830249786377,
0.0821935161948204,
-0.061793211847543716,
0.5174319744110107,
0.004605742637068033,
0.19189079105854034,
0.7776166796684265,
0.12678903341293335,
-0.5182027220726013,
0.868640661239624,
0.6636139750480652,
0.6659969091415405,
0.13674306869506836,
0.1981402039527893,
0.17744889855384827,
-0.09485571086406708,
0.06386817246675491,
0.17107172310352325,
-0.5991602540016174,
-0.6560609936714172,
-0.5300089120864868,
-0.6909553408622742,
-0.538636326789856,
-0.10764916241168976,
-0.8327170014381409,
0.27462038397789,
-0.28239914774894714,
0.025164959952235222,
0.4654867649078369,
0.3193266987800598,
-0.6821778416633606,
0.08776845782995224,
-0.10772980004549026,
1.1596964597702026,
-0.1831750124692917,
1.0897650718688965,
0.7791897654533386,
-0.47213271260261536,
-0.6741100549697876,
0.053555190563201904,
-0.2953040897846222,
-0.542976975440979,
0.9688054323196411,
0.5385013818740845,
-0.04361826553940773,
-0.07333068549633026,
-0.42268458008766174,
-0.8516640067100525,
1.156680941581726,
0.004389048554003239,
-0.24729524552822113,
-0.09506592154502869,
0.03694768622517586,
0.4614412486553192,
-0.37407758831977844,
0.38159677386283875,
0.8753707408905029,
0.5230592489242554,
-0.05429897829890251,
-0.778080940246582,
0.03437274321913719,
-0.4252065122127533,
0.3264080286026001,
0.32316213846206665,
-0.1891966611146927,
0.8959956765174866,
-0.09053245931863785,
-0.04885603487491608,
0.3173278868198395,
0.3618845045566559,
0.059044163674116135,
0.35557299852371216,
0.1305355429649353,
0.2276623398065567,
0.725636899471283,
-0.046751320362091064,
1.3662850856781006,
-0.3371616303920746,
0.1442393958568573,
0.9598605036735535,
-0.36510518193244934,
0.8599286079406738,
0.46619346737861633,
0.12606263160705566,
0.45156329870224,
0.2833541929721832,
0.34175774455070496,
0.341056764125824,
0.5026345252990723,
-0.27106794714927673,
-0.1597186177968979,
-0.41235798597335815,
0.034901972860097885,
0.591688871383667,
0.8495752811431885,
-0.31837987899780273,
-0.30843019485473633,
-0.2250065952539444,
0.015818452462553978,
0.23259015381336212,
-0.1693132072687149,
0.9365363717079163,
-0.30432504415512085,
-0.4185506999492645,
0.02727501280605793,
0.2445448637008667,
0.28376564383506775,
-0.5923099517822266,
-0.23475860059261322,
-0.033000074326992035,
0.2586269974708557,
-0.3461384177207947,
-0.9313921928405762,
0.1339235007762909,
-0.1343102902173996,
-0.12384568899869919,
0.036034099757671356,
1.0665868520736694,
-0.20819151401519775,
-0.36707982420921326,
0.5492708683013916,
0.3053218424320221,
0.005998757667839527,
-0.3052053451538086,
-0.40025219321250916,
0.32861632108688354,
-0.3171945810317993,
-0.30411994457244873,
0.4805965721607208,
0.6492637991905212,
-0.19008763134479523,
0.3208487927913666,
0.5496397614479065,
-0.05920395255088806,
-0.10069357603788376,
-0.12337954342365265,
1.2719461917877197,
-1.0537354946136475,
-0.37725767493247986,
-0.45071595907211304,
0.2929941415786743,
-0.3726256787776947,
-0.2078009396791458,
0.41505011916160583,
0.584237813949585,
1.0891973972320557,
-0.11646001040935516,
0.7564597725868225,
-0.18726667761802673,
0.25800272822380066,
-0.7539361119270325,
0.6142188310623169,
-0.31481611728668213,
-0.030554721131920815,
-0.4182000160217285,
-0.9664607048034668,
-0.4577447175979614,
0.8587276935577393,
-0.4641805589199066,
-0.05015763267874718,
0.5871686339378357,
0.9504126906394958,
-0.26359716057777405,
0.17826774716377258,
0.2496185004711151,
0.10763511061668396,
0.48762956261634827,
0.18208664655685425,
0.8727350234985352,
-0.3958505392074585,
0.37210938334465027,
-0.08086207509040833,
-0.1037813052535057,
-0.27243995666503906,
-0.6346161365509033,
-0.7054816484451294,
-0.7518524527549744,
0.031696878373622894,
-0.30857017636299133,
-0.015081693418323994,
0.7912201285362244,
0.4866047203540802,
-0.49363386631011963,
-0.1503748595714569,
-0.3269338011741638,
0.20435208082199097,
0.4060492515563965,
-0.3115943968296051,
0.4661228060722351,
-0.8383911848068237,
-0.5909161567687988,
0.44800955057144165,
0.2960689663887024,
-0.17897048592567444,
-0.0344412662088871,
0.28339192271232605,
0.13151109218597412,
0.07989443838596344,
0.6121528148651123,
-0.035652752965688705,
-0.43369942903518677,
-0.12085788697004318,
0.023913675919175148,
0.06992477178573608,
-0.07905761897563934,
1.1196414232254028,
-1.1021113395690918,
0.5909388661384583,
0.7406705021858215,
0.7929999232292175,
0.8865880370140076,
-0.125996932387352,
0.44096317887306213,
-0.3937776982784271,
0.08569548279047012,
0.2680174708366394,
0.4579642415046692,
0.2386307567358017,
-0.4267415702342987,
0.6713895201683044,
-0.14633822441101074,
-0.48562777042388916,
-0.4977029860019684,
0.08186011761426926,
-1.092253565788269,
-0.5394087433815002,
0.8778421878814697,
-0.09459561109542847,
-0.41727033257484436,
-0.09445557743310928,
-0.43095672130584717,
0.10363221913576126,
-0.6057275533676147,
0.8755720257759094,
0.5134195685386658,
-0.23401384055614471,
0.46418988704681396,
-0.603998064994812,
0.4009832739830017,
0.46523553133010864,
-0.7162277102470398,
0.27398765087127686,
0.5088269710540771,
0.1155238002538681,
0.3992291986942291,
0.22003982961177826,
-0.6115025281906128,
0.41626492142677307,
-0.09454336762428284,
-0.13101890683174133,
0.09699506312608719,
-0.5725693702697754,
-0.22769767045974731,
0.11020028591156006,
0.020141083747148514,
0.10646002739667892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13231v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13231v1
|
Investigating Cultural Alignment of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-20T18:47:28 | 2024-02-20T18:47:28 |
Badr AlKhamissi, Muhammad ElNokrashy, Mai AlKhamissi, Mona Diab
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The intricate relationship between language and culture has long been a
subject of exploration within the realm of linguistic anthropology. Large
Language Models (LLMs), promoted as repositories of collective human knowledge,
raise a pivotal question: do these models genuinely encapsulate the diverse
knowledge adopted by different cultures? Our study reveals that these models
demonstrate greater cultural alignment along two dimensions -- firstly, when
prompted with the dominant language of a specific culture, and secondly, when
pretrained with a refined mixture of languages employed by that culture. We
quantify cultural alignment by simulating sociological surveys, comparing model
responses to those of actual survey participants as references. Specifically,
we replicate a survey conducted in various regions of Egypt and the United
States through prompting LLMs with different pretraining data mixtures in both
Arabic and English with the personas of the real respondents and the survey
questions. Further analysis reveals that misalignment becomes more pronounced
for underrepresented personas and for culturally sensitive topics, such as
those probing social values. Finally, we introduce Anthropological Prompting, a
novel method leveraging anthropological reasoning to enhance cultural
alignment. Our study emphasizes the necessity for a more balanced multilingual
pretraining dataset to better represent the diversity of human experience and
the plurality of different cultures with many implications on the topic of
cross-lingual transfer.
|
[
-0.5253079533576965,
-0.17907047271728516,
0.2490445226430893,
0.19813846051692963,
-0.21799957752227783,
0.23368164896965027,
-0.44773727655410767,
-0.6458638906478882,
0.2457057386636734,
0.3035877048969269,
-0.3362012505531311,
-0.29802340269088745,
-0.601881206035614,
-0.033622484654188156,
-0.20236575603485107,
0.8737709522247314,
-0.111672043800354,
0.4589841067790985,
-0.0915527194738388,
-0.7103063464164734,
-0.2824855446815491,
-0.4781956374645233,
-0.18179698288440704,
-0.6225351095199585,
0.4948239028453827,
0.34587639570236206,
0.8720654249191284,
0.6478660702705383,
0.3290022611618042,
0.18654008209705353,
0.028115687891840935,
0.03101348876953125,
-0.456163614988327,
-0.07204185426235199,
-0.37279367446899414,
-0.3266351521015167,
-0.22542297840118408,
0.1637219488620758,
0.4149646759033203,
0.9584868550300598,
-0.19936060905456543,
0.5506868958473206,
0.19523119926452637,
0.5045850872993469,
-0.6181811094284058,
-0.4937807321548462,
-0.40957656502723694,
-0.10762228071689606,
-0.3501390218734741,
-0.1500645875930786,
-0.06908457726240158,
-0.5109335780143738,
0.2763337790966034,
-0.28720009326934814,
-0.13053631782531738,
-0.09815529733896255,
0.8611042499542236,
0.1241140216588974,
-0.9704086184501648,
-0.17739954590797424,
-0.7242510914802551,
0.7948213815689087,
-0.38400954008102417,
0.5208417177200317,
0.48051658272743225,
0.18906812369823456,
0.19467684626579285,
-0.24524787068367004,
-0.5695502758026123,
0.0010337650310248137,
-0.06675451248884201,
0.056115105748176575,
0.19344861805438995,
-0.3402712941169739,
0.12060502916574478,
0.3292157053947449,
-0.7862769961357117,
0.4668618440628052,
-0.23779863119125366,
-0.14880482852458954,
0.7326070070266724,
0.11812961846590042,
0.5535297989845276,
0.20562966167926788,
-0.28822386264801025,
-0.10745628923177719,
-0.9837815165519714,
0.2115548849105835,
0.6120807528495789,
0.0931568518280983,
-0.3986838757991791,
0.5583124160766602,
0.0014609252102673054,
0.7172163724899292,
0.02161680907011032,
-0.20961543917655945,
0.13540315628051758,
-0.4270899295806885,
0.2304854542016983,
0.2625660002231598,
0.6938095092773438,
0.5575109124183655,
0.7915114760398865,
0.1885116547346115,
-0.006846386939287186,
-0.0049921502359211445,
0.2528482675552368,
-0.6728922128677368,
-0.15332217514514923,
0.1148303747177124,
-0.38533398509025574,
-0.11334981769323349,
-0.016329826787114143,
-0.46823850274086,
-0.6030073165893555,
-0.4292910695075989,
0.10300997644662857,
-0.19927142560482025,
-0.585536003112793,
0.0821143165230751,
0.19323427975177765,
0.5995789170265198,
0.33111321926116943,
-1.1281739473342896,
-0.09519485384225845,
0.7743257880210876,
0.6984318494796753,
-0.005118983332067728,
-0.4858970642089844,
0.10320517420768738,
0.3178137242794037,
-0.5831373929977417,
0.41107794642448425,
-0.6815732717514038,
-0.3210441470146179,
0.2924209237098694,
-0.19590704143047333,
0.27478206157684326,
-0.4219862222671509,
0.2647627294063568,
-0.5878464579582214,
0.25900956988334656,
-0.6014018058776855,
-0.2503422200679779,
-0.15722426772117615,
0.49569714069366455,
-0.5305719375610352,
1.0527210235595703,
-0.13776317238807678,
-0.7340930104255676,
0.556731641292572,
-0.014461423270404339,
-0.4299456477165222,
-0.06138043478131294,
-0.5150372385978699,
-0.013525070622563362,
0.0005206346395425498,
0.2597902715206146,
0.22018055617809296,
-0.4937565326690674,
0.36873388290405273,
-0.33679476380348206,
-0.3105602562427521,
0.32445016503334045,
-0.3168514668941498,
1.0859378576278687,
0.24273210763931274,
-0.3362446427345276,
-0.11765199154615402,
-0.6304063200950623,
-0.15267843008041382,
0.16841644048690796,
-0.2802392542362213,
-0.6066067814826965,
-0.19255028665065765,
-0.1274084895849228,
0.4022383689880371,
0.42163100838661194,
-0.34906652569770813,
0.41345009207725525,
-0.15744058787822723,
0.10021302103996277,
0.6312447786331177,
-0.4844168424606323,
0.7518212199211121,
-0.5698709487915039,
0.6043731570243835,
0.13763517141342163,
-0.1004805713891983,
-0.013204055838286877,
-0.26081493496894836,
-0.5057783126831055,
0.031018240377306938,
0.21307742595672607,
0.5547018647193909,
-0.30593547224998474,
0.43946292996406555,
-0.5380057692527771,
-0.6466606259346008,
-0.5904062986373901,
0.1280914843082428,
0.1365039348602295,
0.3687780499458313,
0.08716701716184616,
-0.3947395086288452,
-0.5493618845939636,
-0.8523621559143066,
-0.12999355792999268,
-0.3646999001502991,
-0.10450295358896255,
0.06876039505004883,
0.3379031717777252,
-0.10110673308372498,
0.799988329410553,
-0.11032245308160782,
0.09404825419187546,
-0.26616519689559937,
0.10522323101758957,
0.10696634650230408,
0.5999444127082825,
0.7187365889549255,
-0.52446448802948,
-0.4427454471588135,
0.3112761974334717,
-0.6212263107299805,
-0.2580242455005646,
0.1222674772143364,
-0.29583069682121277,
0.21456359326839447,
0.2710627317428589,
-0.41866791248321533,
0.17172615230083466,
1.0102006196975708,
-0.06201024726033211,
0.6048675179481506,
0.00212971237488091,
0.31203693151474,
-1.3092786073684692,
0.20775166153907776,
-0.1596241593360901,
0.16022033989429474,
-0.5977973341941833,
-0.17240960896015167,
0.23981985449790955,
-0.03314189985394478,
-0.17516839504241943,
0.7841815948486328,
-0.7007227540016174,
0.08637391030788422,
-0.14804323017597198,
0.014162858948111534,
-0.05990602448582649,
0.10199560225009918,
0.36248916387557983,
0.6839725971221924,
0.560905396938324,
-0.5310336351394653,
0.17020152509212494,
0.3344430923461914,
-0.6093460917472839,
0.7543317079544067,
-0.46853697299957275,
0.3794803321361542,
-0.16997215151786804,
0.49749892950057983,
-0.9384264349937439,
-0.3570583164691925,
0.05198318883776665,
-0.3410162627696991,
0.14229130744934082,
-0.13809019327163696,
-0.06961408257484436,
-0.13086359202861786,
-0.08920613676309586,
1.0209687948226929,
0.4556712508201599,
-0.45942649245262146,
0.5355681777000427,
0.4132746160030365,
-0.26065248250961304,
-1.0178228616714478,
-0.6549825668334961,
-0.022358369082212448,
-0.5630306601524353,
-0.9130821228027344,
0.025208650156855583,
0.00749515974894166,
-0.6097471714019775,
-0.4259616434574127,
-0.18508179485797882,
0.00807955116033554,
0.1352810114622116,
0.054739780724048615,
0.24300417304039001,
-0.5628802180290222,
0.13527615368366241,
-0.24932801723480225,
0.24489636719226837,
0.09059378504753113,
-0.44495144486427307,
0.8505643606185913,
0.12922784686088562,
-0.5509716868400574,
-0.3767109513282776,
0.4183448255062103,
0.6698676347732544,
-0.579422116279602,
1.0692222118377686,
0.464814156293869,
-0.3229191303253174,
0.3136938810348511,
-0.9338026642799377,
-0.23489952087402344,
-0.3879167139530182,
0.24707704782485962,
-0.3334520757198334,
-0.8608856201171875,
0.7523192167282104,
-0.060178905725479126,
0.1449158936738968,
0.05163725093007088,
0.661284863948822,
-0.2027054727077484,
0.9793561697006226,
0.546005129814148,
-0.4087248146533966,
0.37417909502983093,
0.004740830045193434,
0.35872960090637207,
-0.6302391290664673,
-0.29697760939598083,
-0.773896336555481,
-0.7714904546737671,
-0.5317074656486511,
-0.21993494033813477,
0.20960158109664917,
0.21558907628059387,
-0.5804872512817383,
0.021868275478482246,
0.04930499941110611,
0.519367516040802,
0.36020901799201965,
-0.30395013093948364,
0.1545688360929489,
0.05133035406470299,
-0.0893036425113678,
-0.08545228093862534,
-0.5743362903594971,
-0.8360522389411926,
0.9345712065696716,
0.2193116843700409,
0.9169628620147705,
0.49824899435043335,
0.7565855383872986,
-0.24601706862449646,
0.4754042625427246,
-0.5623298287391663,
0.18000556528568268,
0.15280373394489288,
-0.6377649307250977,
-0.3143644332885742,
-0.07903171330690384,
-0.9953582882881165,
0.303668737411499,
-0.14887680113315582,
-0.8309804201126099,
0.3251859247684479,
0.27574750781059265,
-0.4116295576095581,
0.10106755793094635,
-0.4209348261356354,
0.739185631275177,
-0.5236512422561646,
-0.29345664381980896,
-0.05639295652508736,
-0.9533089995384216,
0.42045673727989197,
-0.18455296754837036,
0.4583611488342285,
-0.12880699336528778,
-0.001935329637490213,
0.5677253007888794,
-0.153046116232872,
0.7905737161636353,
0.16225279867649078,
-0.7214578986167908,
-0.061198942363262177,
0.2734864056110382,
0.32943782210350037,
-0.044586680829524994,
-0.2004997730255127,
0.2832503616809845,
0.10933323949575424,
-0.5538563132286072,
-0.4531882107257843,
0.5455591082572937,
-1.1339426040649414,
-0.8585124015808105,
-0.3489466607570648,
-0.6945443749427795,
-0.3320438265800476,
0.026929279789328575,
0.34286752343177795,
0.23526974022388458,
-0.25786247849464417,
0.15575572848320007,
0.402334600687027,
-0.19256721436977386,
0.19683626294136047,
0.4946357309818268,
-0.3350452482700348,
-0.11412477493286133,
0.52130126953125,
0.21325825154781342,
0.45710450410842896,
0.19853413105010986,
0.2182840257883072,
-0.3576314449310303,
-0.3860032856464386,
-0.5936695337295532,
0.44763997197151184,
-0.5349295735359192,
0.07957891374826431,
-0.46332648396492004,
-0.019547291100025177,
-0.7979299426078796,
-0.37362179160118103,
-0.25464901328086853,
-0.07004300504922867,
-0.0426865890622139,
-0.07766716927289963,
0.031069565564393997,
0.6386798024177551,
-0.08068229258060455,
0.2751029431819916,
-1.0408315658569336,
-0.16069768369197845,
0.19233644008636475,
-0.06467721611261368,
0.15959252417087555,
-0.6538336873054504,
-0.24969348311424255,
0.3086099624633789,
0.01513585913926363,
-1.094105839729309,
0.0795525386929512,
0.10437705367803574,
0.5603761672973633,
0.7635359168052673,
0.05837125703692436,
0.9357658624649048,
-0.4698360860347748,
0.856227695941925,
0.18849968910217285,
-0.715828537940979,
0.21964502334594727,
-0.41229647397994995,
0.5108145475387573,
0.5367922186851501,
0.7842087149620056,
-1.0948294401168823,
-0.4060481786727905,
-0.30830928683280945,
-0.7343466877937317,
0.5908954739570618,
-0.38676899671554565,
0.34647953510284424,
0.03451892361044884,
0.04903506487607956,
0.1723049432039261,
0.03660593554377556,
-0.705047070980072,
-0.05077532306313515,
-0.14450637996196747,
-0.3355277180671692,
-0.21021321415901184,
-0.3425692021846771,
-0.5068235397338867,
-0.2718192934989929,
0.5028047561645508,
-0.043297555297613144,
-0.28238561749458313,
-0.16264545917510986,
-0.3822423815727234,
-0.2825428545475006,
0.2004261016845703,
0.7559698820114136,
1.1233322620391846,
0.2640551030635834,
0.37677496671676636,
0.23919519782066345,
-0.5674371719360352,
0.5217850208282471,
-0.2127072960138321,
0.03885042667388916,
-0.3713524341583252,
0.3881657123565674,
0.5239679217338562,
-0.087885282933712,
-0.35102659463882446,
0.3891008198261261,
-0.0036271351855248213,
0.033551834523677826,
-0.3873414695262909,
-0.22895023226737976,
0.3957460820674896,
0.3616885542869568,
0.3707507252693176,
-0.3412603437900543,
-0.3521941602230072,
-0.5518900752067566,
-0.20734165608882904,
0.5471224784851074,
-0.1500738561153412,
-0.37153205275535583,
0.4491472542285919,
0.252207487821579,
-0.23258662223815918,
0.8311418890953064,
0.2537480890750885,
-0.5448142886161804,
0.4444594979286194,
0.48095130920410156,
0.3630867302417755,
-0.6525917053222656,
0.15805695950984955,
0.4687025845050812,
0.4332067370414734,
-0.12831947207450867,
0.15278877317905426,
-0.09190242737531662,
-1.278112530708313,
-0.5362469553947449,
-0.8289894461631775,
-0.07181398570537567,
0.06362193077802658,
-0.8036736845970154,
0.23372769355773926,
0.03009503148496151,
0.07293912023305893,
-0.27196094393730164,
-0.1407010555267334,
-0.6374204158782959,
0.1727137565612793,
0.41867509484291077,
0.8178221583366394,
-1.1244783401489258,
0.9563315510749817,
0.9833419919013977,
-0.2098952978849411,
-1.1608854532241821,
0.21457648277282715,
0.35684120655059814,
-0.9745014905929565,
0.7421426177024841,
0.18778139352798462,
-0.300143301486969,
0.02661045268177986,
-0.35867077112197876,
-0.9599130749702454,
0.7588133215904236,
0.47593918442726135,
-0.5860652923583984,
0.22180399298667908,
0.38270631432533264,
0.5304135084152222,
-0.3270275592803955,
0.20324137806892395,
0.624417245388031,
0.535847544670105,
0.17657580971717834,
-1.1460140943527222,
-0.0462472066283226,
-0.19279852509498596,
-0.11102303117513657,
0.5054795145988464,
-0.48618802428245544,
0.6258242130279541,
-0.18445353209972382,
-0.19359101355075836,
0.1495804637670517,
0.7644992470741272,
0.3378679156303406,
0.14621728658676147,
0.4522927403450012,
0.5740447640419006,
0.8525649309158325,
-0.16754502058029175,
0.8173387050628662,
-0.5708613991737366,
-0.01452528964728117,
0.9256241917610168,
-0.6102482676506042,
0.5820850729942322,
0.6535623669624329,
-0.09704554826021194,
0.44005629420280457,
0.8300604224205017,
0.38803914189338684,
0.12331059575080872,
0.1869032382965088,
-0.4235697090625763,
-0.2791809141635895,
-0.3927255868911743,
-0.7364259362220764,
0.7365588545799255,
0.15164153277873993,
-0.1213974803686142,
-0.08927442878484726,
-0.1720150113105774,
0.12382346391677856,
-0.04420953989028931,
-0.3320190906524658,
0.7482852339744568,
0.014028828591108322,
-1.0026955604553223,
0.6281194090843201,
-0.363905668258667,
0.6202207803726196,
-0.6506520509719849,
0.3200872540473938,
-0.4613463282585144,
-0.14606568217277527,
-0.28723445534706116,
-0.7957473397254944,
0.1923266053199768,
-0.09798181056976318,
-0.015239113010466099,
-0.23669259250164032,
0.3035767674446106,
-0.8185646533966064,
-0.14096684753894806,
0.17056024074554443,
0.6919628977775574,
0.3175105154514313,
0.30312198400497437,
-0.24331654608249664,
0.08205759525299072,
-0.038332369178533554,
-0.025385979562997818,
0.4852388799190521,
0.49562934041023254,
-0.48576921224594116,
0.41437387466430664,
0.5901485681533813,
0.19084712862968445,
0.07632765918970108,
0.32908403873443604,
0.44534286856651306,
-0.5373778343200684,
-0.43898531794548035,
-1.038198709487915,
0.48455706238746643,
0.020219765603542328,
-0.4228121042251587,
0.7801923155784607,
0.37020277976989746,
1.0977904796600342,
0.050393082201480865,
0.545021116733551,
0.06342709064483643,
-0.02503606677055359,
-0.4868333041667938,
0.8151002526283264,
-0.7156347036361694,
0.03764563798904419,
-0.013628458604216576,
-1.098958969116211,
-0.12738806009292603,
0.6376414895057678,
-0.4309830367565155,
0.1950417459011078,
0.5274921655654907,
0.8630990982055664,
-0.04120256379246712,
0.2175363004207611,
0.17783422768115997,
0.1194891631603241,
0.0431421622633934,
0.20839519798755646,
1.2859439849853516,
0.3298640847206116,
0.29897212982177734,
-0.1308564692735672,
-0.19876964390277863,
-0.0005810686270706356,
-0.8361765742301941,
-0.5649697184562683,
-0.5876906514167786,
-0.10900302976369858,
-0.28664490580558777,
-0.21563822031021118,
1.2045058012008667,
0.43301722407341003,
-0.6432439684867859,
-0.6404403448104858,
0.5702661871910095,
-0.2264319360256195,
-0.14118333160877228,
-0.11459790915250778,
0.17593491077423096,
0.06722806394100189,
-0.769061803817749,
-0.013704245910048485,
0.1648475080728531,
0.29856109619140625,
-0.44223302602767944,
-0.16025236248970032,
-0.3798815906047821,
-0.09787876904010773,
0.3509991765022278,
0.3853708803653717,
-0.7929149866104126,
-0.47097086906433105,
0.04851721599698067,
-0.3680303692817688,
0.02847173996269703,
1.0076898336410522,
-0.33015164732933044,
0.12723322212696075,
0.5484082102775574,
0.6740289926528931,
0.13336095213890076,
0.05757937580347061,
0.8570692539215088,
-0.7934240102767944,
0.4122800827026367,
0.25267404317855835,
0.4265846312046051,
0.47787725925445557,
-0.14850367605686188,
0.337545782327652,
-0.15247474610805511,
-0.7062718868255615,
-0.7020436525344849,
0.5512980818748474,
-0.765516996383667,
-0.13849307596683502,
1.0974880456924438,
0.005322842858731747,
-0.028262341395020485,
-0.21453972160816193,
-0.22896963357925415,
0.3771338164806366,
-0.07757753133773804,
0.9212262630462646,
1.0738719701766968,
0.13448277115821838,
-0.1437293440103531,
-0.30916112661361694,
0.26581335067749023,
0.755436897277832,
-0.4171452224254608,
-0.22634798288345337,
0.5722126364707947,
0.35691022872924805,
0.3353733420372009,
0.5356830358505249,
0.0487603135406971,
0.2460414618253708,
-0.4378992021083832,
0.12758150696754456,
0.5553202629089355,
-0.08150836825370789,
-0.4370475113391876,
-0.0579380989074707,
0.24528484046459198,
0.13611626625061035
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.