id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14536v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14536v1
|
Domain Generalization via Causal Adjustment for Cross-Domain Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-02-22T13:26:56 | 2024-02-22T13:26:56 |
Siyin Wang, Jie Zhou, Qin Chen, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Domain adaption has been widely adapted for cross-domain sentiment analysis
to transfer knowledge from the source domain to the target domain. Whereas,
most methods are proposed under the assumption that the target (test) domain is
known, making them fail to generalize well on unknown test data that is not
always available in practice. In this paper, we focus on the problem of domain
generalization for cross-domain sentiment analysis. Specifically, we propose a
backdoor adjustment-based causal model to disentangle the domain-specific and
domain-invariant representations that play essential roles in tackling domain
shift. First, we rethink the cross-domain sentiment analysis task in a causal
view to model the causal-and-effect relationships among different variables.
Then, to learn an invariant feature representation, we remove the effect of
domain confounders (e.g., domain knowledge) using the backdoor adjustment. A
series of experiments over many homologous and diverse datasets show the great
performance and robustness of our model by comparing it with the
state-of-the-art domain generalization baselines.
|
[
-0.24487051367759705,
-0.8219146132469177,
0.47266265749931335,
0.36224451661109924,
-0.1743580847978592,
0.07611216604709625,
-0.3519568145275116,
-0.29467418789863586,
0.05124608799815178,
0.325690358877182,
-0.7983696460723877,
-0.6800406575202942,
-1.0882068872451782,
-0.03610344976186752,
0.07120323181152344,
1.2580018043518066,
-0.17671026289463043,
0.019813816994428635,
-0.15038442611694336,
-0.35362720489501953,
-0.9113144874572754,
-0.438737690448761,
-0.6075552701950073,
-0.23934093117713928,
0.7616523504257202,
0.034073133021593094,
0.6741818189620972,
-0.013946465216577053,
0.51932692527771,
0.12724918127059937,
0.24710595607757568,
-0.002087910193949938,
-0.6159694790840149,
-0.03962314501404762,
-0.9466506242752075,
-0.4307621717453003,
-0.6822332739830017,
0.15281334519386292,
0.46084949374198914,
1.009564995765686,
0.19427821040153503,
0.21050845086574554,
0.2468460202217102,
0.48055383563041687,
-0.7461984157562256,
0.2342400699853897,
-0.6700364351272583,
-0.053251177072525024,
0.19397303462028503,
-0.2967757284641266,
-0.46761035919189453,
-0.43433305621147156,
0.21286918222904205,
-0.7189995050430298,
0.522476077079773,
0.1846776008605957,
0.7487891912460327,
0.2555408179759979,
-0.6161810755729675,
0.18804512917995453,
-0.9807665944099426,
1.0371400117874146,
-0.45422667264938354,
0.40055274963378906,
0.13886046409606934,
0.3116585314273834,
-0.09086215496063232,
-0.4418751299381256,
-0.354185551404953,
0.2907907962799072,
-0.04176732897758484,
0.2949678301811218,
-0.5440715551376343,
-0.3915557265281677,
0.14364849030971527,
0.12062301486730576,
-0.5761545300483704,
-0.121380515396595,
-0.09351826459169388,
-0.19026125967502594,
0.7350972890853882,
0.296203076839447,
0.3209448754787445,
0.28070518374443054,
-0.5846879482269287,
-0.052424944937229156,
-0.841472864151001,
0.18246109783649445,
0.15282784402370453,
0.5409948229789734,
-0.08870912343263626,
0.13315698504447937,
0.005616181995719671,
0.5569321513175964,
0.38562875986099243,
0.4134993851184845,
0.15925216674804688,
0.02353796921670437,
-0.35674571990966797,
-0.21768029034137726,
0.2643841505050659,
0.5858816504478455,
0.33587729930877686,
-0.25151073932647705,
-0.09733304381370544,
0.24716320633888245,
0.6419643759727478,
-0.508766770362854,
-0.1492294818162918,
0.04213365912437439,
-0.6257871389389038,
-0.2583392858505249,
0.09741190820932388,
-0.9095278978347778,
-0.4187520742416382,
-0.3497590720653534,
0.584578275680542,
-0.0508410707116127,
-0.4202031195163727,
0.25028982758522034,
-0.3571034073829651,
0.2692292332649231,
0.4266170561313629,
-0.75310879945755,
0.31354933977127075,
0.7098879218101501,
0.514055073261261,
-0.42700451612472534,
-0.5191523432731628,
-0.41450226306915283,
0.21335656940937042,
-0.38679075241088867,
0.5598235130310059,
-0.8770124316215515,
-0.30864259600639343,
0.2835703492164612,
0.22683073580265045,
-0.5639908313751221,
-0.4694689214229584,
0.24388684332370758,
-1.1091573238372803,
0.10628049075603485,
-0.3788621127605438,
-0.4252241551876068,
-0.46607735753059387,
0.37510690093040466,
-0.574298620223999,
0.5135563015937805,
0.23114240169525146,
-0.7596196532249451,
0.5572184324264526,
-0.25564447045326233,
-0.5972694754600525,
-0.5340069532394409,
0.14312255382537842,
-0.6402665972709656,
0.4693445563316345,
0.42965593934059143,
0.522600531578064,
-0.41552668809890747,
0.40028515458106995,
-0.6515817642211914,
-0.13056214153766632,
0.39334455132484436,
-0.10727851092815399,
0.8337627649307251,
-0.1390133798122406,
-0.4817236065864563,
-0.14833353459835052,
-0.522793173789978,
-0.34466782212257385,
0.07719334214925766,
0.13299566507339478,
-0.993393063545227,
-0.08948192745447159,
-0.2749042510986328,
0.2742232084274292,
0.010433310642838478,
-0.5672323703765869,
0.21473979949951172,
-0.2299453318119049,
-0.25302886962890625,
0.8855263590812683,
0.4362649619579315,
0.6052510142326355,
-0.11347018927335739,
0.5834226608276367,
0.5953103303909302,
0.4222338795661926,
0.47954457998275757,
-0.5661933422088623,
-0.5559180378913879,
-0.07924854755401611,
0.38346683979034424,
0.47516560554504395,
-0.6585270762443542,
0.4714834988117218,
-0.26569896936416626,
-0.06430692225694656,
-0.14279142022132874,
-0.014346948824822903,
0.18951761722564697,
0.4075184762477875,
0.5634317398071289,
-0.5226213932037354,
-0.2076033055782318,
-0.6268061995506287,
-0.9122716188430786,
-0.05792951211333275,
0.22013287246227264,
0.01249649003148079,
0.4907762110233307,
-0.5342170596122742,
0.9546177983283997,
-1.059163212776184,
-0.46285948157310486,
0.03018638864159584,
0.3144342005252838,
-0.019741404801607132,
0.37810009717941284,
0.6483805775642395,
-0.8707496523857117,
-0.284119188785553,
-0.01397542841732502,
-0.8591656684875488,
-0.05155133828520775,
-0.2321149855852127,
-0.36827942728996277,
0.03553857281804085,
0.441596120595932,
-0.3681948482990265,
0.5576358437538147,
0.5447134971618652,
-0.3860500752925873,
0.33795854449272156,
0.30709320306777954,
0.06883156299591064,
-0.9190036654472351,
-0.024853724986314774,
0.221094012260437,
-0.07854273915290833,
-0.7222719192504883,
0.0005045625730417669,
0.032468076795339584,
-0.007160054054111242,
-0.18706393241882324,
0.6246984004974365,
-0.3018331527709961,
0.14079740643501282,
-0.2106420397758484,
0.0192892923951149,
0.08392155170440674,
0.8103242516517639,
0.01452446635812521,
0.28720492124557495,
0.7599129676818848,
-0.5812496542930603,
0.17750799655914307,
0.13628271222114563,
0.3269316554069519,
0.833251953125,
-0.345899760723114,
-0.056011494249105453,
-0.05177794024348259,
0.350507527589798,
-1.072433352470398,
0.180776908993721,
0.6795475482940674,
-0.5543975234031677,
0.4032144248485565,
-0.14187465608119965,
0.16364888846874237,
0.020721198990941048,
-0.28368622064590454,
0.6161741614341736,
0.45070862770080566,
-0.6944355368614197,
0.8536102771759033,
0.26193854212760925,
-0.20809972286224365,
-0.5379238128662109,
-0.38894152641296387,
-0.1596197932958603,
-0.33205488324165344,
-0.5459772944450378,
0.44090723991394043,
0.13030126690864563,
-0.2104988545179367,
0.2412637323141098,
-0.20564055442810059,
-0.10586287826299667,
-0.17110973596572876,
0.25522488355636597,
0.1916571855545044,
-0.2719578742980957,
0.35237208008766174,
0.38565298914909363,
-0.1231357753276825,
0.510511577129364,
-0.4403614401817322,
0.11175894737243652,
0.29145753383636475,
-0.1543755829334259,
-0.004127940163016319,
0.5132779479026794,
0.49600642919540405,
-0.06355544179677963,
0.7398261427879333,
0.5480014681816101,
-0.33819958567619324,
-0.8368991613388062,
-0.21724486351013184,
-0.2326415777206421,
-0.402675598859787,
0.0646723210811615,
-0.4436289072036743,
-0.8793114423751831,
0.6387385129928589,
-0.6593039035797119,
-0.28664830327033997,
0.7423194050788879,
0.4305380880832672,
0.05456530675292015,
1.0328662395477295,
1.0329352617263794,
-0.3606005012989044,
0.257303923368454,
-0.1258704960346222,
0.5307034850120544,
-0.8683318495750427,
-0.023434985429048538,
-0.3089805841445923,
-0.32216423749923706,
-0.47195005416870117,
-0.17891545593738556,
0.1436104029417038,
-0.1717151403427124,
-0.2341056913137436,
0.0893213227391243,
-0.026954378932714462,
-0.02328944019973278,
0.20512808859348297,
0.4037829637527466,
0.23875172436237335,
0.16266673803329468,
0.0010457901516929269,
-0.2020895779132843,
-0.6336913704872131,
0.11488495767116547,
1.0697174072265625,
0.25477761030197144,
0.8140620589256287,
0.15997284650802612,
0.5215968489646912,
0.7656190395355225,
0.408621221780777,
-0.5960599780082703,
0.26398903131484985,
-0.4134094715118408,
-0.378030389547348,
-0.19426025450229645,
-0.4748334288597107,
-0.8865075707435608,
0.1970216929912567,
0.00119117833673954,
-0.2290094494819641,
0.8834287524223328,
0.07384483516216278,
-0.19124318659305573,
0.23877844214439392,
-0.3802255392074585,
0.9087512493133545,
0.17743925750255585,
-0.35289087891578674,
-0.4755118787288666,
-0.6515227556228638,
0.41835707426071167,
-0.3440696597099304,
0.22686432301998138,
0.02319311909377575,
0.21813121438026428,
0.5435123443603516,
-0.36769431829452515,
1.5361887216567993,
-0.5653810501098633,
-0.3814008831977844,
0.1238466426730156,
0.17124558985233307,
0.6128115653991699,
-0.004173024091869593,
0.27338844537734985,
0.5810292363166809,
-0.541122317314148,
-0.3453230559825897,
-1.1609203815460205,
0.6114890575408936,
-0.9572199583053589,
-0.8132687211036682,
-0.3234752416610718,
-0.3065190315246582,
-0.7460294365882874,
-0.140206441283226,
0.13030143082141876,
0.21582283079624176,
-0.48484617471694946,
-0.3319798409938812,
0.6265908479690552,
-0.24627810716629028,
0.06660816073417664,
0.5739455819129944,
-0.05113637074828148,
-0.19404713809490204,
0.9232668280601501,
-0.22214822471141815,
0.21459753811359406,
0.4291861355304718,
0.3987952768802643,
-0.17102064192295074,
-0.24416443705558777,
-0.24772560596466064,
0.2940831780433655,
-0.7526510953903198,
-0.3002033531665802,
-0.559771716594696,
0.02819579280912876,
-0.6339409947395325,
-0.255476713180542,
-0.07551617175340652,
-0.44232824444770813,
-0.30528539419174194,
-0.00829154159873724,
0.4294663667678833,
0.43702179193496704,
-0.14330491423606873,
0.2682284414768219,
-0.7095510363578796,
0.4516531825065613,
0.5573415160179138,
0.23285719752311707,
0.0533047690987587,
-0.9009872078895569,
-0.46194028854370117,
-0.09168621897697449,
-0.26026681065559387,
-0.7531851530075073,
0.44786396622657776,
0.2849675118923187,
0.37433138489723206,
0.18708783388137817,
0.2446558177471161,
0.5479829907417297,
-0.4541439414024353,
0.7483948469161987,
0.18162153661251068,
-1.1369460821151733,
0.6275984644889832,
-0.2476944774389267,
-0.1041540578007698,
0.1689949333667755,
0.5828331708908081,
-0.5832357406616211,
-0.7184485793113708,
-0.4715498387813568,
-0.5807779431343079,
0.37385743856430054,
-0.17159207165241241,
0.2797600328922272,
0.22620251774787903,
0.3993605673313141,
0.42839759588241577,
0.07974353432655334,
-0.45788729190826416,
-0.17509476840496063,
-0.39507508277893066,
-0.10835224390029907,
-0.13767027854919434,
0.08426068723201752,
-0.3932857811450958,
-0.3213115930557251,
0.7308869957923889,
-0.24075308442115784,
0.2739488184452057,
0.1606569141149521,
-0.47389861941337585,
-0.31641876697540283,
0.16368362307548523,
0.4602324366569519,
0.7286326885223389,
-0.016726575791835785,
0.2018011510372162,
0.22220811247825623,
-0.49484825134277344,
0.17761020362377167,
0.0011831856099888682,
-0.06869502365589142,
-0.15059296786785126,
0.4818558096885681,
0.6459644436836243,
0.21058174967765808,
0.12921279668807983,
0.9083429574966431,
-0.10271918028593063,
-0.03256503492593765,
0.18213020265102386,
-0.012067530304193497,
-0.39973902702331543,
0.5436230301856995,
0.20786191523075104,
0.4667986035346985,
0.17664198577404022,
-0.48647409677505493,
0.2943720519542694,
0.340074360370636,
-0.5283340811729431,
-0.7452922463417053,
0.7198618650436401,
0.2518343925476074,
0.1730802059173584,
0.31475189328193665,
0.23429271578788757,
-0.6658101081848145,
0.541648805141449,
0.6510748863220215,
1.5202614068984985,
-0.3561164438724518,
0.46784359216690063,
0.047916725277900696,
0.2576552927494049,
0.1497187465429306,
0.14095158874988556,
0.2446548044681549,
-1.1759752035140991,
-0.26848283410072327,
-0.2223159819841385,
-0.5285698175430298,
-0.42626306414604187,
-0.8418710827827454,
-0.03173218294978142,
-0.5644969344139099,
-0.35383787751197815,
-0.24948883056640625,
-0.2742370665073395,
-0.7102908492088318,
0.7384553551673889,
-0.26282572746276855,
0.5983311533927917,
-1.3778612613677979,
0.7388307452201843,
0.7409493923187256,
-0.3531741797924042,
-0.6926023364067078,
0.526512861251831,
-0.026590343564748764,
-0.8510537147521973,
1.0325685739517212,
-0.40558403730392456,
-0.47301238775253296,
-0.21260550618171692,
-0.6156688332557678,
-0.5083231925964355,
0.8022779226303101,
0.038468364626169205,
-0.3936324417591095,
0.41090959310531616,
0.231016144156456,
0.6875589489936829,
-0.6682191491127014,
-0.48537734150886536,
0.5098108053207397,
0.36021116375923157,
-0.3024802803993225,
-0.3008747696876526,
0.6243320107460022,
-0.16931991279125214,
0.06855592131614685,
0.06357304751873016,
-0.8214624524116516,
0.8473259806632996,
-0.034508440643548965,
0.03547883778810501,
-0.7009757161140442,
0.727626383304596,
-0.016318712383508682,
0.5590327382087708,
0.5792363882064819,
0.4097929298877716,
0.5258145332336426,
0.06439852714538574,
0.9599573612213135,
-0.16589979827404022,
0.532792866230011,
0.9946941137313843,
-0.6771462559700012,
0.5871659517288208,
0.36449113488197327,
-0.034534044563770294,
0.7464308738708496,
0.39412668347358704,
-0.024545036256313324,
0.7998586297035217,
0.07438535243272781,
-0.30789270997047424,
-0.278935968875885,
0.24303992092609406,
-0.44116297364234924,
0.3154471218585968,
0.3538725674152374,
-0.5540139675140381,
-0.19477355480194092,
0.030102942138910294,
-0.026159292086958885,
-0.11279045790433884,
-0.459811806678772,
0.5687397718429565,
0.2980920970439911,
-0.595405101776123,
0.49355486035346985,
0.16818560659885406,
0.40297502279281616,
-0.43500882387161255,
-0.073115274310112,
-0.48515671491622925,
0.43017587065696716,
-0.2595989406108856,
-0.4984075725078583,
0.5498784184455872,
-0.16662093997001648,
-0.5177689790725708,
-0.3139466345310211,
1.161478877067566,
-0.3183656930923462,
-0.5410922169685364,
0.8072486519813538,
0.5649477243423462,
-0.32981082797050476,
-0.3407651484012604,
-0.4490351378917694,
0.044195014983415604,
-0.09649459272623062,
-0.22749444842338562,
0.357867568731308,
0.6838768720626831,
-0.5302397608757019,
0.14850080013275146,
0.5002771615982056,
0.28319495916366577,
0.10903426259756088,
0.39424818754196167,
1.1784160137176514,
-0.9672715663909912,
-0.4382297992706299,
-0.7945200204849243,
0.48751819133758545,
0.11070926487445831,
-0.46936139464378357,
0.8346537947654724,
0.09921673685312271,
0.7191036939620972,
-0.44856032729148865,
1.0933904647827148,
0.31361350417137146,
0.49396082758903503,
-0.4771188497543335,
0.7411894202232361,
-0.599788248538971,
0.14069007337093353,
-0.5677708983421326,
-1.0183889865875244,
-0.9298691153526306,
0.1727917492389679,
-0.6099536418914795,
0.006546160206198692,
0.8548123240470886,
0.8042945861816406,
-0.1500508040189743,
0.17966106534004211,
0.41088053584098816,
0.3527510166168213,
0.2713886499404907,
0.46869170665740967,
0.9407479166984558,
-0.5418645739555359,
0.22585096955299377,
0.09427497535943985,
-0.4680829346179962,
-0.1596956104040146,
-0.7119267582893372,
-0.9565861225128174,
-0.3431718945503235,
-0.6597324013710022,
-0.4052257537841797,
0.43906068801879883,
0.3545767068862915,
0.31019294261932373,
-0.9683641195297241,
-0.016520895063877106,
0.35502663254737854,
0.5186998248100281,
-0.7576969861984253,
-0.2760537266731262,
0.5330366492271423,
-0.5392294526100159,
-0.39276695251464844,
0.0749652087688446,
0.282879114151001,
-0.5066357851028442,
-0.009464330039918423,
0.0980536937713623,
0.1544342339038849,
0.343584805727005,
0.9016599655151367,
0.19733627140522003,
-0.3998439311981201,
-0.7787743806838989,
-0.06307504326105118,
0.06190172955393791,
0.10214129090309143,
1.2992873191833496,
-0.6410171985626221,
0.2359563708305359,
0.3649580478668213,
0.7498364448547363,
0.19841645658016205,
0.18887785077095032,
0.8017752766609192,
-1.0145364999771118,
-0.3139128088951111,
-0.15097807347774506,
0.17239917814731598,
0.050832878798246384,
-0.556053102016449,
0.22243161499500275,
0.6899706125259399,
-0.4663792550563812,
-0.27259138226509094,
0.26788222789764404,
-0.932123601436615,
-0.5371410250663757,
1.0093920230865479,
-0.2953711152076721,
-0.2008446902036667,
-0.30663174390792847,
0.10462109744548798,
0.348540335893631,
-0.3145316541194916,
1.0422418117523193,
0.5068126916885376,
-0.0958772674202919,
0.12760208547115326,
0.16292738914489746,
0.3785599172115326,
0.2879807949066162,
-0.7515106797218323,
0.2033356875181198,
0.5468380451202393,
0.6214503645896912,
-0.05658756569027901,
0.401589959859848,
-0.1851540356874466,
0.21000713109970093,
0.00952143780887127,
0.05801296979188919,
0.4407215714454651,
-0.6310741901397705,
-0.6860438585281372,
0.2762727439403534,
-0.2815922796726227,
-0.3565159738063812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14533v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14533v1
|
Whose LLM is it Anyway? Linguistic Comparison and LLM Attribution for GPT-3.5, GPT-4 and Bard
| 2024-02-22T13:25:17 | 2024-02-22T13:25:17 |
Ariel Rosenfeld, Teddy Lazebnik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are capable of generating text that is similar
to or surpasses human quality. However, it is unclear whether LLMs tend to
exhibit distinctive linguistic styles akin to how human authors do. Through a
comprehensive linguistic analysis, we compare the vocabulary, Part-Of-Speech
(POS) distribution, dependency distribution, and sentiment of texts generated
by three of the most popular LLMS today (GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Bard) to diverse
inputs. The results point to significant linguistic variations which, in turn,
enable us to attribute a given text to its LLM origin with a favorable 88\%
accuracy using a simple off-the-shelf classification model. Theoretical and
practical implications of this intriguing finding are discussed.
|
[
-0.36039119958877563,
-0.5298813581466675,
0.9151489734649658,
0.21129676699638367,
-0.14826223254203796,
0.21347959339618683,
-0.19345204532146454,
-0.5887395739555359,
0.3391715884208679,
0.4459909200668335,
-0.38878899812698364,
-0.48888882994651794,
-0.6003965139389038,
0.3595614433288574,
-0.47045692801475525,
1.047505259513855,
0.0002540781279094517,
0.22083188593387604,
-0.12450989335775375,
-0.06507798284292221,
-0.08387336134910583,
-0.9053989052772522,
-0.3976954519748688,
-0.3390297293663025,
0.9623528122901917,
0.0016866072546690702,
0.7546126842498779,
0.2845070958137512,
0.6143857836723328,
0.3580835163593292,
-0.15198920667171478,
-0.17199157178401947,
-0.3588910698890686,
0.03207337483763695,
-0.34624147415161133,
-0.5219023823738098,
-0.4565778374671936,
0.39705362915992737,
0.6406686902046204,
0.378965824842453,
0.03499932214617729,
-0.020103072747588158,
0.1614762246608734,
0.7792248129844666,
-0.3678847849369049,
-0.10920867323875427,
-0.7226952314376831,
-0.042182449251413345,
-0.5832367539405823,
-0.2517390549182892,
-0.26791974902153015,
-0.7265406847000122,
0.26327410340309143,
-0.21847215294837952,
0.2997379004955292,
-0.0221303328871727,
0.8114597201347351,
0.028362156823277473,
-0.3316512703895569,
-0.5732455849647522,
-0.5132707953453064,
0.7967847585678101,
-0.855214536190033,
0.15222398936748505,
0.3017192780971527,
0.1632869988679886,
-0.13863691687583923,
-0.5288135409355164,
-0.8722675442695618,
-0.44730666279792786,
-0.09575781226158142,
0.17885088920593262,
0.015037517994642258,
0.04831418767571449,
-0.2047300487756729,
0.48441725969314575,
-0.5690999031066895,
0.19836780428886414,
-0.2397671937942505,
0.06122184172272682,
0.553213357925415,
0.08206640183925629,
0.42377224564552307,
-0.37904927134513855,
-0.27684468030929565,
0.1771305352449417,
-1.0889703035354614,
-0.21924343705177307,
0.8161337971687317,
0.12137699872255325,
0.287214070558548,
0.807285726070404,
-0.07490956783294678,
0.5977398753166199,
-0.3259391784667969,
-0.4909583628177643,
0.24477458000183105,
-0.25135165452957153,
-0.2714313864707947,
0.011730452999472618,
1.0560553073883057,
0.3657509684562683,
0.3389706015586853,
-0.19040782749652863,
-0.30435487627983093,
-0.008376923389732838,
0.16803078353405,
-0.3002323508262634,
-0.2362167239189148,
-0.07669573277235031,
-0.34547629952430725,
-0.3763297200202942,
0.28075316548347473,
-0.28972434997558594,
-0.5779772400856018,
-0.21197906136512756,
0.3432057201862335,
-0.16738244891166687,
-0.12522390484809875,
-0.14846785366535187,
-0.011028962209820747,
0.37177062034606934,
0.23697756230831146,
-0.904163658618927,
0.15068860352039337,
0.7563626170158386,
0.7937083840370178,
-0.7544043660163879,
-0.30507275462150574,
-0.22160248458385468,
0.12713715434074402,
-0.4545649588108063,
0.9595063924789429,
-0.36785101890563965,
-0.4021037220954895,
-0.07333897054195404,
-0.1025126501917839,
0.17487679421901703,
-0.5057309865951538,
0.5824233293533325,
-0.4418545067310333,
0.5049651861190796,
-0.549044668674469,
-0.7536450624465942,
-0.14495670795440674,
0.22158117592334747,
-0.5694940686225891,
0.8079493641853333,
0.20338979363441467,
-0.8851638436317444,
0.33183568716049194,
-0.4842876195907593,
-0.25674641132354736,
0.2818049490451813,
-0.42316770553588867,
-0.21928344666957855,
0.18405845761299133,
-0.23476000130176544,
0.6003772616386414,
-0.5567695498466492,
0.15156899392604828,
-0.45465007424354553,
-0.399352103471756,
0.9078422784805298,
-0.5306390523910522,
0.6927894353866577,
0.25435227155685425,
-0.17785483598709106,
0.014264008030295372,
-0.7014518976211548,
-0.13798438012599945,
0.1497637927532196,
-0.6723268628120422,
-0.17065417766571045,
0.17250768840312958,
-0.056829553097486496,
0.05401607230305672,
0.35572242736816406,
-0.5662270188331604,
0.08902647346258163,
-0.32929983735084534,
0.5310190916061401,
0.8205610513687134,
-0.07182710617780685,
0.32950371503829956,
-0.5612640976905823,
0.5950573086738586,
-0.47528961300849915,
-0.14901167154312134,
0.2872195541858673,
-0.7674698233604431,
-0.4419482350349426,
-0.38166144490242004,
0.29317909479141235,
0.5301036834716797,
-0.4195236563682556,
0.2434932440519333,
-0.19890666007995605,
-0.5735793709754944,
-0.41179159283638,
0.25085440278053284,
0.3323098123073578,
0.2613598108291626,
0.004794355947524309,
-0.1331966519355774,
-0.28637534379959106,
-0.9853683710098267,
-0.7044619917869568,
-0.430513471364975,
-0.21744221448898315,
0.05696572735905647,
0.10562531650066376,
-0.0280288178473711,
1.0522561073303223,
-0.2961088716983795,
-0.09993916004896164,
-0.5161492228507996,
0.014967440627515316,
0.1000000461935997,
0.06883259862661362,
0.6821820139884949,
-0.5184240341186523,
-0.6415489912033081,
0.05274863913655281,
-0.5505232810974121,
-0.3910713195800781,
0.25917017459869385,
0.057902850210666656,
0.2836300730705261,
0.4102500081062317,
-0.48519137501716614,
0.24613025784492493,
0.599468469619751,
-0.26290163397789,
0.7192263603210449,
-0.010766249150037766,
0.14679032564163208,
-1.1525404453277588,
-0.17719219624996185,
-0.015462903305888176,
-0.1290242075920105,
-0.5157600045204163,
-0.012339932844042778,
-0.09033069014549255,
0.2545616924762726,
-0.5257344841957092,
0.6668816804885864,
-0.4229542016983032,
-0.38002800941467285,
-0.21788491308689117,
0.3623524606227875,
-0.01686197891831398,
0.28055140376091003,
-0.011364645324647427,
0.7091084122657776,
0.2720501720905304,
-0.345464289188385,
0.5776756405830383,
0.11298544704914093,
-0.4824672341346741,
0.612189531326294,
-0.5850821733474731,
0.1385398954153061,
0.11037932336330414,
0.11471143364906311,
-1.1001431941986084,
-0.5048707127571106,
0.22822162508964539,
-0.3414720594882965,
0.2343587726354599,
-0.15448658168315887,
-0.6901072263717651,
-0.28263723850250244,
-0.38064897060394287,
0.2056746929883957,
0.7458287477493286,
-0.36137813329696655,
0.435254842042923,
0.3456454277038574,
-0.7139894962310791,
-0.4981926381587982,
-0.9010505676269531,
0.2282211184501648,
-0.4842008352279663,
-0.48118579387664795,
0.25372278690338135,
-0.16578823328018188,
-0.6585690379142761,
-0.03733643889427185,
0.10293867439031601,
0.022108402103185654,
-0.03337706997990608,
0.1128096804022789,
0.3140842318534851,
-0.3943559229373932,
0.1400771588087082,
-0.17797154188156128,
0.1305990368127823,
0.026414399966597557,
-0.20405414700508118,
0.21772806346416473,
-0.22449730336666107,
-0.5262298583984375,
-0.25501808524131775,
0.17834238708019257,
0.4343714118003845,
0.1317286342382431,
0.5996558666229248,
0.30028289556503296,
0.11894094944000244,
0.027096586301922798,
-0.6102176308631897,
0.11332114040851593,
-0.49884122610092163,
0.1974204033613205,
-0.2195180058479309,
-0.8164789080619812,
0.3233999013900757,
0.3509260416030884,
-0.07522986829280853,
0.5097886323928833,
0.768543541431427,
-0.18536552786827087,
0.6256296038627625,
0.46957433223724365,
-0.053149208426475525,
0.5044845938682556,
0.25504887104034424,
0.13307732343673706,
-0.6058396697044373,
0.017068224027752876,
-0.5522903800010681,
-0.28037136793136597,
-1.025778889656067,
-0.15037356317043304,
0.17214275896549225,
-0.0814530998468399,
-0.1467677801847458,
0.13959701359272003,
-0.454233855009079,
0.7261762619018555,
0.6100114583969116,
-0.165857195854187,
0.38583865761756897,
-0.011066365987062454,
0.07149603217840195,
0.10378094762563705,
-0.36793914437294006,
-1.0117076635360718,
1.2236073017120361,
0.29535290598869324,
0.7150865793228149,
0.4921874701976776,
0.753768265247345,
0.24853718280792236,
0.5355143547058105,
-0.7290435433387756,
0.6785433292388916,
-0.2998715341091156,
-0.6481115221977234,
-0.15801355242729187,
-0.4321694076061249,
-0.8929299712181091,
0.13052962720394135,
-0.15300993621349335,
-0.8302847743034363,
-0.09155964106321335,
-0.06008804962038994,
-0.16775014996528625,
0.5077694058418274,
-0.6515215039253235,
0.6665124893188477,
-0.2163705676794052,
0.021123824641108513,
0.27888861298561096,
-0.5881528854370117,
0.4270946681499481,
-0.46508193016052246,
0.20046430826187134,
-0.53679358959198,
-0.24077722430229187,
0.7448564171791077,
-0.39847657084465027,
0.638764500617981,
0.20263291895389557,
-0.5421686172485352,
0.5344445109367371,
0.11220637708902359,
0.23664060235023499,
-0.09184949845075607,
-0.13095621764659882,
0.14175991714000702,
-0.13660946488380432,
-0.4271657466888428,
-0.45270782709121704,
0.917573094367981,
-0.9069467782974243,
-0.6679465770721436,
-0.37608426809310913,
-0.304905503988266,
-0.3636836111545563,
0.10516458004713058,
0.6202598214149475,
0.5240987539291382,
-0.2898932993412018,
-0.052164819091558456,
0.21543973684310913,
-0.30026867985725403,
0.5781577229499817,
0.49271100759506226,
-0.30241385102272034,
-0.37029868364334106,
1.0924047231674194,
-0.007545589003711939,
0.35660645365715027,
0.42136192321777344,
0.3232748210430145,
-0.48924753069877625,
-0.6291692852973938,
-0.14245718717575073,
0.3268638551235199,
-0.8421136736869812,
0.023441582918167114,
-0.426147997379303,
-0.1623697727918625,
-0.19667170941829681,
-0.4458537697792053,
-0.23272962868213654,
-0.5495232939720154,
-0.37598785758018494,
-0.05679371580481529,
0.35242292284965515,
1.4682517051696777,
0.16941051185131073,
0.5559174418449402,
-0.680396318435669,
-0.012958984822034836,
0.5372633934020996,
0.26310262084007263,
-0.44635188579559326,
-0.6275091767311096,
0.14835225045681,
-0.27479639649391174,
-0.4876786172389984,
-1.1584997177124023,
0.2690536379814148,
0.08980775624513626,
0.47770994901657104,
0.2786616384983063,
-0.3295537531375885,
-0.05846375226974487,
-0.4626350700855255,
1.2476134300231934,
0.41224682331085205,
-0.819208562374115,
0.20119443535804749,
-0.45617151260375977,
0.011465762741863728,
0.2949231266975403,
0.27624019980430603,
-0.3302555978298187,
-0.7052708268165588,
-0.6152934432029724,
-0.6887524127960205,
0.5657985210418701,
0.294002503156662,
0.10014286637306213,
-0.17787928879261017,
0.3546379506587982,
0.32354405522346497,
0.13086730241775513,
-0.9773285388946533,
-0.20128384232521057,
-0.14000815153121948,
-0.4541860520839691,
-0.3810587227344513,
-0.28867003321647644,
0.06277301162481308,
0.2160288691520691,
0.5506005883216858,
0.06690216809511185,
0.39120644330978394,
-0.001126541756093502,
0.015124356374144554,
0.3252875506877899,
0.5644189715385437,
0.746407687664032,
0.8255711793899536,
0.019104573875665665,
0.3762700855731964,
0.1382952481508255,
-0.3833844065666199,
0.30074751377105713,
-0.1510494202375412,
0.033328521996736526,
0.11915460228919983,
0.412910133600235,
0.569556474685669,
0.08612243086099625,
-0.35806161165237427,
0.5804990530014038,
-0.03703032061457634,
-0.36302870512008667,
-0.15611223876476288,
0.20234642922878265,
0.46327173709869385,
0.30224522948265076,
0.38046470284461975,
-0.022075029090046883,
0.07976628094911575,
-0.6207822561264038,
-0.12136179208755493,
0.4141801595687866,
-0.0878281518816948,
-0.4981824457645416,
0.45258182287216187,
0.2069123238325119,
-0.44929736852645874,
0.21980918943881989,
-0.44519320130348206,
-0.47316935658454895,
0.2948231101036072,
0.39604634046554565,
1.000240683555603,
-0.09748347103595734,
0.16644147038459778,
-0.038201965391635895,
0.0463983453810215,
-0.13607941567897797,
0.2003920078277588,
0.3621120750904083,
-0.7770419716835022,
-0.5890222787857056,
-0.7949324250221252,
-0.5349683165550232,
0.0539107471704483,
-0.39465081691741943,
0.3059045374393463,
-0.30321061611175537,
-0.30825796723365784,
0.06589696556329727,
-0.2436012178659439,
-0.4810751974582672,
-0.016499008983373642,
0.2442941516637802,
0.42682185769081116,
-0.49278539419174194,
0.817557692527771,
0.7698267698287964,
-0.28427931666374207,
-0.810222327709198,
0.37228524684906006,
0.07287859916687012,
-0.8239027261734009,
0.7281150817871094,
-0.1660798341035843,
-0.19692599773406982,
0.08432456105947495,
-0.5846683979034424,
-0.6139065623283386,
0.7646622061729431,
0.5079557299613953,
-0.5012485980987549,
-0.05589812994003296,
0.12775133550167084,
0.5530317425727844,
-0.217953622341156,
0.17082248628139496,
0.5315845012664795,
0.3807930648326874,
0.12351760268211365,
-0.9460493326187134,
-0.11153215169906616,
0.044240329414606094,
0.09248428791761398,
0.18507468700408936,
-0.3824044167995453,
0.8239814043045044,
-0.21738381683826447,
-0.11730693280696869,
0.32735875248908997,
0.6614018678665161,
0.4544687867164612,
0.06762700527906418,
0.154500812292099,
0.08159396797418594,
0.7462353706359863,
-0.11875203996896744,
1.0582563877105713,
-0.1939365714788437,
0.3249717354774475,
1.0260059833526611,
-0.21132788062095642,
0.9491114616394043,
0.32480502128601074,
-0.6747062802314758,
0.6109262108802795,
0.7000503540039062,
0.17918020486831665,
0.3879372477531433,
0.3908557593822479,
-0.4952234625816345,
0.15848176181316376,
0.31399863958358765,
-0.23030118644237518,
0.4516350030899048,
0.24653513729572296,
-0.43361812829971313,
0.11260109394788742,
-0.23183654248714447,
0.0607183575630188,
-0.0869063213467598,
-0.22859881818294525,
0.8838318586349487,
0.224016010761261,
-0.6298826336860657,
0.32764774560928345,
-0.05955122038722038,
0.7960611581802368,
-0.43373531103134155,
0.40819212794303894,
-0.248171865940094,
-0.023546533659100533,
-0.22001826763153076,
-1.1397712230682373,
0.09284606575965881,
0.16206425428390503,
-0.00527359452098608,
-0.13683348894119263,
0.6141157150268555,
-0.38617438077926636,
-0.44617632031440735,
-0.03721283748745918,
0.639201819896698,
0.5720869302749634,
-0.03183429315686226,
-0.4716566503047943,
-0.13466903567314148,
0.010068959556519985,
-0.3971363604068756,
0.4074312150478363,
0.5686650276184082,
0.20960146188735962,
0.5446491837501526,
0.38448861241340637,
0.3566611707210541,
0.30286261439323425,
-0.005189030896872282,
0.459159255027771,
-0.7627419829368591,
-0.24474705755710602,
-1.0792046785354614,
0.1052987203001976,
0.090804323554039,
-0.43629133701324463,
0.7991673350334167,
0.23337693512439728,
0.5461292862892151,
-0.10943108052015305,
0.9966119527816772,
0.013676391914486885,
0.6101599335670471,
-0.5440149307250977,
0.7154406309127808,
-0.5157679915428162,
0.4165971577167511,
-0.6195188164710999,
-1.2055387496948242,
-0.2497972995042801,
0.5612859129905701,
-0.3233923316001892,
0.3238660991191864,
0.8090917468070984,
0.5795642137527466,
0.14329679310321808,
0.22553959488868713,
0.4292972683906555,
0.1535956710577011,
0.3296699523925781,
0.18845082819461823,
1.2921708822250366,
0.15660424530506134,
0.48537883162498474,
0.21562553942203522,
-0.2605339586734772,
-0.19267643988132477,
-1.2188307046890259,
-0.666817307472229,
-0.4648798406124115,
-0.2692909240722656,
-0.22954829037189484,
-0.09261075407266617,
0.7859730124473572,
0.23749442398548126,
-0.5939517021179199,
-0.09419777989387512,
-0.22195221483707428,
0.22876045107841492,
0.22506456077098846,
-0.19489067792892456,
0.12282026559114456,
-0.3268730640411377,
-0.631251871585846,
0.3269016444683075,
0.2976095378398895,
0.4724428653717041,
-0.4825926721096039,
-0.2502123713493347,
0.3736109733581543,
0.2954155504703522,
0.6697565913200378,
0.09232572466135025,
-1.2129937410354614,
-0.34356534481048584,
-0.015295751392841339,
-0.4382457435131073,
0.05342356860637665,
0.846568763256073,
-0.3414749801158905,
0.01866217702627182,
0.4522772431373596,
0.48890116810798645,
0.00224432279355824,
-0.15082880854606628,
0.6194669008255005,
-0.665614664554596,
-0.2963941991329193,
0.09437491744756699,
0.47077304124832153,
0.6133756637573242,
-0.17632421851158142,
0.5750799179077148,
0.37740784883499146,
-0.962123453617096,
-0.5643565058708191,
0.2639507055282593,
-0.9839916825294495,
-0.34475934505462646,
1.5445417165756226,
-0.21167396008968353,
-0.04408235847949982,
-0.12034786492586136,
-0.4263768196105957,
-0.016008807346224785,
-0.21723723411560059,
0.497385174036026,
0.9070929884910583,
-0.31851449608802795,
0.1075192242860794,
-0.5571978092193604,
0.5996694564819336,
0.2021067589521408,
-0.7587008476257324,
-0.0715479701757431,
0.30600422620773315,
0.5673961639404297,
0.07435080409049988,
0.7692294120788574,
-0.17413471639156342,
-0.14252251386642456,
-0.22199556231498718,
0.1313064992427826,
0.4043431282043457,
0.01328429114073515,
-0.08308320492506027,
0.24032709002494812,
0.6210326552391052,
0.09913435578346252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14531v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14531v1
|
Should We Respect LLMs? A Cross-Lingual Study on the Influence of Prompt Politeness on LLM Performance
| 2024-02-22T13:24:10 | 2024-02-22T13:24:10 |
Ziqi Yin, Hao Wang, Kaito Horio, Daisuke Kawahara, Satoshi Sekine
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We investigate the impact of politeness levels in prompts on the performance
of large language models (LLMs). Polite language in human communications often
garners more compliance and effectiveness, while rudeness can cause aversion,
impacting response quality. We consider that LLMs mirror human communication
traits, suggesting they align with human cultural norms. We assess the impact
of politeness in prompts on LLMs across English, Chinese, and Japanese tasks.
We observed that impolite prompts often result in poor performance, but overly
polite language does not guarantee better outcomes. The best politeness level
is different according to the language. This phenomenon suggests that LLMs not
only reflect human behavior but are also influenced by language, particularly
in different cultural contexts. Our findings highlight the need to factor in
politeness for cross-cultural natural language processing and LLM usage.
|
[
-0.32266128063201904,
-0.5933459997177124,
0.43224599957466125,
0.5069543719291687,
-0.2132679671049118,
-0.21935327351093292,
-0.30774423480033875,
-0.857167661190033,
0.13123710453510284,
0.4212225079536438,
-0.4523594081401825,
-0.12052618712186813,
-0.46964067220687866,
0.6531708836555481,
0.20292586088180542,
0.7234802842140198,
0.3413318693637848,
0.5948600172996521,
-0.2698040306568146,
-0.2227255254983902,
-0.4663696587085724,
-0.8111642599105835,
-1.0575215816497803,
-0.7495611310005188,
0.6440331935882568,
0.40703409910202026,
0.8228541016578674,
0.4817497432231903,
0.4159053862094879,
0.3470386266708374,
-0.3994819223880768,
0.046730875968933105,
-0.5110461711883545,
0.29014310240745544,
-0.3556972146034241,
-0.48334240913391113,
-0.563727855682373,
0.3346346318721771,
0.6112552881240845,
0.6878743171691895,
0.03662310168147087,
0.16875946521759033,
0.2935434877872467,
0.5957730412483215,
0.012376156635582447,
0.17960034310817719,
-0.3075745701789856,
0.03434784337878227,
-0.15468843281269073,
-0.3051616847515106,
-0.06129264459013939,
-0.6445868611335754,
0.001011603162623942,
-0.615240752696991,
-0.16623523831367493,
0.1723189502954483,
0.803164541721344,
0.16463176906108856,
-0.37731653451919556,
-0.27576392889022827,
-0.31648725271224976,
0.7928581833839417,
-0.4641649127006531,
0.41998571157455444,
0.5432611107826233,
0.13594110310077667,
-0.31331369280815125,
-0.4740909934043884,
-0.4979207217693329,
-0.33851492404937744,
-0.021210532635450363,
0.04073077067732811,
0.02797975018620491,
0.10981665551662445,
0.5279109477996826,
0.4188385009765625,
-0.36117228865623474,
0.605146586894989,
-0.11521872133016586,
-0.3867745101451874,
0.5335730910301208,
0.3910199701786041,
0.5672447681427002,
-0.058523982763290405,
-0.23116427659988403,
0.11931280791759491,
-0.9179326891899109,
0.7279407978057861,
0.6831449866294861,
0.47207677364349365,
-0.08476812392473221,
0.21027110517024994,
-0.40502846240997314,
0.37701359391212463,
0.014830376952886581,
-0.14995193481445312,
-0.01683475263416767,
-0.4769355356693268,
0.020520012825727463,
-0.20154911279678345,
0.7418136596679688,
0.8040038347244263,
0.8576645255088806,
-0.20829613506793976,
-0.2749582529067993,
0.07602199167013168,
0.03189489245414734,
-0.8998379111289978,
-0.1668240875005722,
-0.14202214777469635,
-0.4929639995098114,
-0.047797974199056625,
0.050407618284225464,
-0.5794017910957336,
-0.4268886148929596,
-0.45321255922317505,
0.07290879637002945,
-0.029018210247159004,
-0.23634161055088043,
-0.12257849425077438,
-0.11303438246250153,
0.4436866044998169,
0.4659695625305176,
-0.9125186800956726,
0.2545103430747986,
0.6802812814712524,
0.5033517479896545,
0.1426316797733307,
-0.26869723200798035,
-0.6909317374229431,
-0.04856748878955841,
-0.4086128771305084,
0.5000407099723816,
-0.7049694061279297,
-0.8119620680809021,
0.09453785419464111,
0.11652432382106781,
0.27800336480140686,
-0.6463828086853027,
0.9806415438652039,
-0.47043555974960327,
0.3065670430660248,
-0.8816439509391785,
-0.21691517531871796,
-0.1253816783428192,
0.2792152464389801,
-0.4576612114906311,
0.8594172596931458,
0.17757771909236908,
-0.5566288828849792,
0.3143669068813324,
-0.505489706993103,
-0.7984159588813782,
0.3016607463359833,
-0.2388804703950882,
-0.07949839532375336,
-0.03490922972559929,
0.24113410711288452,
0.41415396332740784,
-0.16589099168777466,
-0.036017607897520065,
-0.20265613496303558,
-0.6358333230018616,
0.5558158159255981,
-0.24696311354637146,
0.9285754561424255,
0.36167675256729126,
-0.08095327764749527,
0.019580433145165443,
-0.41458651423454285,
0.07228868454694748,
-0.031779415905475616,
-0.4260016977787018,
-0.5215349197387695,
-0.25151821970939636,
-0.10681649297475815,
0.5933166742324829,
0.32607242465019226,
-0.4977680444717407,
0.1180882379412651,
-0.5077489018440247,
0.4339282512664795,
1.1302610635757446,
0.0523480661213398,
0.5597953200340271,
-0.7305703163146973,
0.7368419766426086,
-0.035644691437482834,
0.3499774634838104,
-0.22326843440532684,
-0.5292891263961792,
-0.46178144216537476,
-0.0911923497915268,
-0.3421975374221802,
0.449920117855072,
-0.5618894100189209,
-0.023514358326792717,
-0.21413636207580566,
-0.2944875657558441,
-0.6396356225013733,
0.23276768624782562,
0.3723127841949463,
0.5612378120422363,
0.03257378563284874,
-0.3476141095161438,
-0.4218401610851288,
-0.9860289692878723,
-0.49340030550956726,
-0.6165244579315186,
-0.030887724831700325,
0.602272093296051,
0.01130153238773346,
0.08891162276268005,
0.676852822303772,
0.061071544885635376,
-0.20316649973392487,
-0.2627679705619812,
-0.27850908041000366,
0.2833808958530426,
0.31819865107536316,
0.707602322101593,
-0.6286157369613647,
-0.4230862259864807,
-0.1453038901090622,
-0.5300633311271667,
-0.5879756808280945,
0.18812216818332672,
-0.18653197586536407,
0.35574889183044434,
0.5267901420593262,
-0.21621346473693848,
-0.16595378518104553,
0.46336138248443604,
-0.42125582695007324,
0.3567441701889038,
0.13205096125602722,
0.5929296016693115,
-1.1195275783538818,
-0.016677003353834152,
0.07238016277551651,
-0.2916989028453827,
-0.5516371726989746,
0.02648005075752735,
-0.0824551209807396,
0.14412063360214233,
-0.652034342288971,
0.7850497961044312,
-0.2659571170806885,
0.0008453531190752983,
-0.12869590520858765,
0.06296184659004211,
0.1916305422782898,
0.2529164254665375,
0.24835218489170074,
1.1060707569122314,
0.5362319946289062,
-1.0266669988632202,
0.18145328760147095,
0.19664615392684937,
-0.12966743111610413,
1.1522002220153809,
-0.8696399331092834,
0.13337591290473938,
-0.27881067991256714,
0.12269368767738342,
-1.240963339805603,
0.019407320767641068,
0.5698338747024536,
-0.82355797290802,
0.17760048806667328,
-0.15228068828582764,
-0.5731604695320129,
-0.2835797667503357,
-0.4568015933036804,
0.07298630475997925,
0.666259229183197,
-0.38518404960632324,
0.23281735181808472,
0.34399938583374023,
-0.324081152677536,
-0.457762211561203,
-0.848476767539978,
0.16893696784973145,
-0.3176533281803131,
-0.7362160086631775,
-0.11360792070627213,
-0.5194253325462341,
-0.6129123568534851,
-0.6544773578643799,
0.19171170890331268,
0.09849164634943008,
0.3405766487121582,
0.33056434988975525,
0.15063749253749847,
0.0576246902346611,
-0.17203988134860992,
-0.4083419144153595,
0.16801714897155762,
0.3613801896572113,
-0.09305977821350098,
0.5210317969322205,
-0.07243692129850388,
0.027814026921987534,
-0.6695916056632996,
0.33869850635528564,
0.5612507462501526,
0.053175173699855804,
0.5168242454528809,
0.5257477164268494,
-0.24548347294330597,
0.34428972005844116,
-0.6256508231163025,
-0.5694730877876282,
-0.5494231581687927,
0.1743515282869339,
-0.41953879594802856,
-1.0563913583755493,
0.6651026606559753,
0.32748785614967346,
0.23707203567028046,
0.16569703817367554,
0.5276011228561401,
-0.49145522713661194,
0.988107442855835,
0.9949209690093994,
-0.453424870967865,
0.6283374428749084,
0.3012227416038513,
0.1041567474603653,
-0.7504191398620605,
-0.1226339340209961,
-1.0099236965179443,
-0.29882022738456726,
-0.9178098440170288,
-0.1365557610988617,
0.1712086945772171,
-0.2830567955970764,
-0.1607126146554947,
-0.10151228308677673,
-0.0077691939659416676,
0.23755395412445068,
0.060443174093961716,
-0.24729514122009277,
0.48008790612220764,
-0.1874825656414032,
0.052844952791929245,
-0.5143384337425232,
-0.7235815525054932,
-0.7904966473579407,
0.3389728367328644,
0.6282894015312195,
0.9417480826377869,
0.2438323050737381,
0.44769975543022156,
0.1098659411072731,
0.3923397362232208,
-0.7550634741783142,
0.6544181704521179,
0.02228817343711853,
-0.24463285505771637,
-0.15837037563323975,
-0.5480097532272339,
-1.2210609912872314,
0.10582505166530609,
0.3358580470085144,
-0.5709311962127686,
-0.11027480661869049,
-0.07367460429668427,
-0.10098864138126373,
0.0955059826374054,
-0.5175697803497314,
0.4615670442581177,
0.032434675842523575,
-0.27809855341911316,
-0.007411940488964319,
-0.6350838541984558,
0.3573472797870636,
0.3093668222427368,
0.5628780722618103,
-0.2212613821029663,
-0.3360162675380707,
0.8166558742523193,
0.04899203032255173,
1.141972303390503,
0.010940778069198132,
-0.5801358819007874,
-0.0010061089415103197,
0.25184378027915955,
0.5255823731422424,
0.3354739248752594,
-0.2450025975704193,
0.3169149160385132,
-0.056732773780822754,
-0.45997726917266846,
-0.38397201895713806,
0.8145666122436523,
-0.773598313331604,
-0.7820004820823669,
-0.37786757946014404,
-0.6629564166069031,
-0.21455703675746918,
0.10104438662528992,
0.35986119508743286,
0.0009922301396727562,
-0.13081637024879456,
-0.3291260004043579,
0.9707122445106506,
-0.18600910902023315,
0.6366474032402039,
0.9895153641700745,
-0.2738807499408722,
-0.028402360156178474,
0.5714898705482483,
0.15755966305732727,
0.4091039299964905,
0.19142793118953705,
0.26603537797927856,
-0.5608132481575012,
-0.28160715103149414,
-0.5553129315376282,
0.2656962275505066,
-0.7430168986320496,
0.0713779479265213,
-0.5605798959732056,
0.1077304258942604,
-0.7578756809234619,
-0.28340086340904236,
-0.13772891461849213,
-0.2519117593765259,
-0.4231860935688019,
0.14931000769138336,
0.4850085973739624,
0.8336519002914429,
-0.08096575736999512,
0.05554807931184769,
-0.8683305978775024,
0.08650635927915573,
0.16065680980682373,
0.500638484954834,
-0.232367604970932,
-1.0119391679763794,
-0.005223325919359922,
-0.034798864275217056,
0.005137783009558916,
-0.4131930470466614,
0.05301922932267189,
0.07019300013780594,
1.0597524642944336,
0.41448670625686646,
0.12220562994480133,
0.455945760011673,
-0.260651171207428,
1.177966833114624,
0.08340854942798615,
-0.6506013870239258,
0.43954649567604065,
-0.44420987367630005,
0.6021305322647095,
0.342071533203125,
0.5544899702072144,
-1.2585359811782837,
-0.8213551044464111,
-0.5985414385795593,
-0.7236614227294922,
0.6819999814033508,
-0.14549994468688965,
0.7175400257110596,
-0.22822585701942444,
0.3371683657169342,
0.15550227463245392,
0.2694050967693329,
-0.9481312036514282,
-0.4022005498409271,
0.02043157070875168,
0.3949272334575653,
-0.07957076281309128,
-0.42664557695388794,
-0.18799157440662384,
0.009032498113811016,
0.4030637741088867,
0.004385302774608135,
-0.12559618055820465,
0.301310271024704,
0.026916613802313805,
-0.5422290563583374,
0.5304417014122009,
0.5008065700531006,
0.6952495574951172,
0.33974167704582214,
-0.025287842378020287,
0.3002272844314575,
-0.5745975971221924,
0.13331711292266846,
-0.3363649845123291,
-0.23899787664413452,
-0.08235219866037369,
0.10854916274547577,
0.16030745208263397,
0.05945654585957527,
-0.5027989149093628,
0.30327168107032776,
-0.4737188220024109,
0.22569823265075684,
-0.02912762202322483,
0.02104310877621174,
-0.0382627509534359,
0.16968251764774323,
0.09971050173044205,
-0.10094309598207474,
0.11777886748313904,
-0.8023518323898315,
0.031085992231965065,
0.6579515337944031,
-0.17444941401481628,
-0.3825266659259796,
0.603738009929657,
0.42531439661979675,
-0.41182732582092285,
0.5673545002937317,
-0.09061556309461594,
-0.7415609359741211,
0.3528050482273102,
0.3265480697154999,
0.545307993888855,
-0.44339558482170105,
-0.016365891322493553,
0.3183414340019226,
0.44170936942100525,
0.193106010556221,
0.7048856019973755,
-0.17907938361167908,
-0.5676310062408447,
-0.3827238380908966,
-0.551489531993866,
-0.5203510522842407,
-0.07134506851434708,
-0.517600417137146,
0.1513781100511551,
-0.5668351650238037,
-0.2597585618495941,
-0.4990951120853424,
0.2741313874721527,
-0.7833181023597717,
0.03359869867563248,
0.2695150673389435,
0.896931529045105,
-0.8039611577987671,
0.7112900614738464,
0.9609206914901733,
-0.4345565140247345,
-0.7274587750434875,
0.08689828217029572,
-0.16394224762916565,
-0.7522202134132385,
0.7009053826332092,
0.1878919154405594,
-0.21425437927246094,
-0.10394903272390366,
-0.43756863474845886,
-0.5700936317443848,
0.6705763936042786,
0.24602344632148743,
-0.4674323499202728,
0.40765219926834106,
0.076117143034935,
0.6978294253349304,
0.0758734792470932,
0.3725745379924774,
0.42640221118927,
0.5951241254806519,
-0.13930422067642212,
-1.2481448650360107,
-0.01330779492855072,
-0.08893690258264542,
0.2964075207710266,
-0.008902933448553085,
-1.0639967918395996,
0.6238834261894226,
-0.29965436458587646,
-0.2936277985572815,
0.2637067139148712,
0.9086392521858215,
0.21268613636493683,
0.29075124859809875,
0.21447274088859558,
0.17857038974761963,
0.8902661204338074,
-0.1480824500322342,
1.1112605333328247,
-0.1622321605682373,
-0.3384570777416229,
0.5184321403503418,
-0.44274622201919556,
0.5307936668395996,
0.7992518544197083,
-0.2329941689968109,
0.25637882947921753,
0.7746495008468628,
0.4065057039260864,
0.13302837312221527,
0.40368467569351196,
-0.1482553482055664,
-0.046301938593387604,
-0.8780688643455505,
-0.49003681540489197,
0.3271721601486206,
0.32732781767845154,
-0.2033361792564392,
-0.13540339469909668,
-0.16465826332569122,
0.3811139166355133,
0.5534360408782959,
-0.6778414845466614,
0.7234780192375183,
0.16533902287483215,
-0.8872992992401123,
0.49938344955444336,
0.12016986310482025,
1.1377772092819214,
-0.5677767395973206,
0.12410078942775726,
-0.47534337639808655,
-0.336833655834198,
-0.2539069354534149,
-1.1064659357070923,
0.08297404646873474,
-0.14021895825862885,
-0.2345493584871292,
-0.4547439217567444,
0.4873117506504059,
-0.3614499270915985,
0.01550398487597704,
0.2597035765647888,
0.6265363097190857,
0.49017560482025146,
0.2832247316837311,
-0.4152452051639557,
0.06171170994639397,
-0.28164979815483093,
-0.28089725971221924,
0.6971306800842285,
0.5330889225006104,
-0.18006207048892975,
0.6692858338356018,
0.795200526714325,
0.1016903817653656,
-0.12408944219350815,
0.4909904897212982,
0.750818133354187,
-0.4242992699146271,
-0.5916767716407776,
-0.9677408337593079,
0.30639660358428955,
0.06005964055657387,
-0.3447127938270569,
0.9408459067344666,
0.25300371646881104,
0.9862547516822815,
0.1716046780347824,
0.5632026791572571,
0.20289696753025055,
0.3899049162864685,
-0.5648992657661438,
0.5492070317268372,
-0.36774417757987976,
0.27814966440200806,
-0.3103330731391907,
-0.788472056388855,
0.045619916170835495,
0.6182991862297058,
-0.24730853736400604,
0.48100754618644714,
0.3977760970592499,
0.8743202090263367,
0.5588318705558777,
0.18371573090553284,
0.6595788598060608,
0.020892111584544182,
0.40165477991104126,
0.5495913028717041,
1.1587415933609009,
-0.015484366565942764,
0.3842649757862091,
-0.3059254288673401,
-0.08667736500501633,
0.006451800465583801,
-1.052230954170227,
-0.8641749024391174,
-0.45817962288856506,
-0.22765935957431793,
-0.33322298526763916,
0.08081439882516861,
1.2222830057144165,
0.5261385440826416,
-0.32099950313568115,
-0.41450709104537964,
0.5514023303985596,
0.24295660853385925,
-0.29366958141326904,
-0.338412880897522,
-0.2290554791688919,
-0.5491723418235779,
-1.210594654083252,
0.24925343692302704,
0.25035399198532104,
0.4107452630996704,
-0.3614726960659027,
-0.31566691398620605,
-0.0024165180511772633,
0.07177640497684479,
0.7446681261062622,
0.3050086796283722,
-0.6489967703819275,
-0.2773023545742035,
0.31496530771255493,
-0.7311902046203613,
0.1139344573020935,
0.8450099229812622,
-0.7165932059288025,
0.16045141220092773,
0.5842984318733215,
0.2337057739496231,
-0.6136695146560669,
-0.008895750157535076,
0.7734255790710449,
-0.8768057823181152,
0.15744782984256744,
0.5173982381820679,
0.3925774395465851,
0.6036867499351501,
-0.8015655279159546,
0.27593889832496643,
0.21620801091194153,
-0.9131001830101013,
-0.6550837159156799,
0.31705063581466675,
-0.7453446984291077,
-0.07649151235818863,
1.322310447692871,
-0.08592422306537628,
-0.10339957475662231,
-0.3238270580768585,
-0.4765751361846924,
0.2018761932849884,
-0.804037868976593,
0.8118199110031128,
1.0721030235290527,
-0.2863782048225403,
-0.4381982684135437,
-0.6858404874801636,
0.6557836532592773,
0.6483415365219116,
-0.4858085513114929,
0.1760140359401703,
0.4717105031013489,
0.43388134241104126,
-0.31306949257850647,
0.9132971167564392,
-0.1792912781238556,
0.49748438596725464,
-0.6713579893112183,
-0.23650820553302765,
-0.05075998604297638,
-0.1119680181145668,
-0.6014484763145447,
-0.2402142584323883,
0.6973305940628052,
0.0036526431795209646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14526v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14526v2
|
Balanced Data Sampling for Language Model Training with Clustering
| 2024-02-22T13:20:53 | 2024-06-03T06:48:34 |
Yunfan Shao, Linyang Li, Zhaoye Fei, Hang Yan, Dahua Lin, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Data plays a fundamental role in the training of Large Language Models
(LLMs). While attention has been paid to the collection and composition of
datasets, determining the data sampling strategy in training remains an open
question. Most LLMs are trained with a simple strategy, random sampling.
However, this sampling strategy ignores the unbalanced nature of training data
distribution, which can be sub-optimal. In this paper, we propose ClusterClip
Sampling to balance the text distribution of training data for better model
training. Specifically, ClusterClip Sampling utilizes data clustering to
reflect the data distribution of the training set and balances the common
samples and rare samples during training based on the cluster results. A
repetition clip operation is introduced to mitigate the overfitting issue led
by samples from certain clusters. Extensive experiments validate the
effectiveness of ClusterClip Sampling, which outperforms random sampling and
other cluster-based sampling variants under various training datasets and large
language models.
|
[
-0.35205334424972534,
-0.6481343507766724,
0.3247271478176117,
0.36107224225997925,
-0.513827919960022,
0.25069713592529297,
-0.3761739432811737,
-0.1357010453939438,
0.36160457134246826,
0.6167961955070496,
-0.492209255695343,
-0.6901001930236816,
-0.3776056170463562,
-0.1380804479122162,
-0.770991861820221,
1.0403692722320557,
0.08840076625347137,
0.22661304473876953,
-0.4341283142566681,
-0.3982275724411011,
-0.7270336747169495,
-0.5803542137145996,
-0.49693870544433594,
-0.5758722424507141,
0.12754115462303162,
0.6389851570129395,
0.37449806928634644,
0.7033898234367371,
0.08583582937717438,
0.19841840863227844,
-0.19932648539543152,
-0.13791587948799133,
-0.7525174021720886,
-0.16609030961990356,
-0.05266686901450157,
-0.8401921987533569,
-0.09190291166305542,
-0.02515406161546707,
1.0328712463378906,
1.0293693542480469,
-0.618175208568573,
0.07775026559829712,
-0.005857552867382765,
0.6076032519340515,
-0.5872668027877808,
-0.4789329469203949,
-0.7395882606506348,
0.01716548763215542,
-0.5065664052963257,
-0.08819956332445145,
-0.2515470087528229,
-0.3265770673751831,
-0.11954862624406815,
-0.149010568857193,
0.508532702922821,
0.12257082015275955,
0.3324684500694275,
0.01934167370200157,
-0.2097693830728531,
0.00765420263633132,
-0.7405328154563904,
1.1963249444961548,
-0.8353634476661682,
-0.17453184723854065,
0.3048509955406189,
0.4134288728237152,
-0.018876537680625916,
-0.2521875500679016,
-0.7309437990188599,
0.14986690878868103,
0.09310102462768555,
-0.05738469213247299,
-0.02682858519256115,
-0.2805970311164856,
0.09651125967502594,
0.39676937460899353,
-0.4957771599292755,
0.46173471212387085,
-0.4030337631702423,
0.08447443693876266,
0.5594512224197388,
0.11821695417165756,
0.39306628704071045,
0.11787882447242737,
-0.38159212470054626,
-0.496359258890152,
-0.8473778963088989,
-0.01656135730445385,
0.44519615173339844,
0.28114455938339233,
-0.12741070985794067,
0.6325008869171143,
-0.041243452578783035,
0.9436675906181335,
-0.031293436884880066,
-0.27907419204711914,
0.47247645258903503,
-0.17577794194221497,
-0.1967509537935257,
0.17100942134857178,
0.44825756549835205,
0.5374024510383606,
0.4564495086669922,
0.07321900874376297,
-0.1369648575782776,
-0.05782846361398697,
0.25712430477142334,
-0.58295738697052,
0.01006359700113535,
0.27222126722335815,
-0.2684458792209625,
-0.43862295150756836,
0.22963209450244904,
-0.9586833119392395,
0.0053434851579368114,
-0.25907862186431885,
-0.11709165573120117,
-0.17116416990756989,
-0.2249096930027008,
0.3057011365890503,
-0.23966974020004272,
-0.22934915125370026,
0.04614182561635971,
-1.1139105558395386,
0.6398166418075562,
0.6526246070861816,
0.7877155542373657,
-0.8176162838935852,
-0.5944948792457581,
-0.37398985028266907,
0.3876597583293915,
-0.08972590416669846,
1.0516955852508545,
-0.5743361115455627,
-0.5870029330253601,
0.15910087525844574,
-0.11790924519300461,
-0.21867185831069946,
-0.7775446772575378,
0.3811872899532318,
-0.11096017807722092,
0.07996781915426254,
-0.17834538221359253,
-0.7396929264068604,
-0.06339352577924728,
0.2875696122646332,
-0.7847825288772583,
1.2653846740722656,
0.10371407866477966,
-0.9525108337402344,
0.4938683807849884,
-0.01625526323914528,
-0.47840556502342224,
-0.027297642081975937,
-0.36694809794425964,
-0.68747878074646,
0.060818132013082504,
0.475669264793396,
0.3192397952079773,
-0.04924202710390091,
0.3135271668434143,
-0.5246065258979797,
-0.447897732257843,
0.2643871307373047,
-0.23982541263103485,
0.706214427947998,
-0.05906716361641884,
-0.21705974638462067,
0.026668153703212738,
-0.6965550780296326,
0.24022844433784485,
-0.0015098147559911013,
-0.2156798094511032,
-0.6016644835472107,
0.08278808742761612,
0.24644048511981964,
-0.08713316917419434,
-0.12567947804927826,
-0.6442232131958008,
0.3458234667778015,
-0.4778200387954712,
0.2644014060497284,
0.5405834317207336,
0.08153725415468216,
0.5882361531257629,
-0.6018763184547424,
0.6770392060279846,
-0.06485095620155334,
-0.08028624206781387,
0.039795100688934326,
-0.18133105337619781,
-0.5145830512046814,
-0.5814930200576782,
0.42792755365371704,
0.6766549944877625,
-0.4764477610588074,
0.6717830896377563,
-0.29597947001457214,
-0.6869298815727234,
-0.591576337814331,
0.28803694248199463,
0.2821827530860901,
0.2192343771457672,
0.28152579069137573,
-0.306508332490921,
-0.45644116401672363,
-0.7916593551635742,
-0.04469772055745125,
0.2608814835548401,
-0.02289564721286297,
0.1352206915616989,
0.4095931649208069,
0.014933022670447826,
1.481733798980713,
-0.7328256368637085,
-0.32384350895881653,
-0.8007814884185791,
0.2753307521343231,
0.20367766916751862,
0.5707117915153503,
0.90045565366745,
-0.7698953151702881,
-0.45000168681144714,
-0.38895222544670105,
-0.22538627684116364,
-0.4423704147338867,
-0.16593265533447266,
0.04525946080684662,
0.10458829998970032,
0.7117621898651123,
-0.41386938095092773,
0.24606867134571075,
0.800293505191803,
0.22996556758880615,
0.2895413339138031,
-0.027782773599028587,
-0.039300911128520966,
-1.1067136526107788,
0.3196299374103546,
-0.3063485622406006,
-0.3815840482711792,
-0.440727561712265,
-0.05696578696370125,
-0.25658661127090454,
-0.08004193753004074,
-0.5017021894454956,
0.5847753882408142,
-0.33150747418403625,
-0.08721965551376343,
-0.7362934947013855,
0.16394248604774475,
-0.17091140151023865,
0.21064940094947815,
0.019975785166025162,
0.6803984642028809,
0.40450167655944824,
-0.4489360749721527,
0.20542053878307343,
0.22296692430973053,
-0.5166155099868774,
0.6790404915809631,
-0.8152692317962646,
0.02515680342912674,
-0.11073377728462219,
0.435417115688324,
-1.1195040941238403,
0.09291795641183853,
-0.17552053928375244,
-0.20967160165309906,
0.17347005009651184,
0.049768734723329544,
-0.6066599488258362,
-0.5457428693771362,
-0.4443870484828949,
0.5456238389015198,
0.4206981360912323,
-0.686000645160675,
0.19532239437103271,
0.8719020485877991,
-0.28323376178741455,
-0.545913815498352,
-0.786668062210083,
-0.4006594717502594,
-0.3644119203090668,
-0.21197837591171265,
0.37461230158805847,
-0.07334523648023605,
0.09154275059700012,
-0.07507029175758362,
-0.07428555190563202,
-0.14925406873226166,
-0.024275116622447968,
0.09880929440259933,
0.029495492577552795,
0.3043339252471924,
0.08324339985847473,
0.09769252687692642,
-0.2005804032087326,
-0.3696664273738861,
-0.20935602486133575,
1.1472735404968262,
0.31861770153045654,
-0.81765216588974,
0.038217075169086456,
0.55335533618927,
0.18914148211479187,
-0.050925593823194504,
0.6406504511833191,
0.40230825543403625,
-0.24185924232006073,
-0.42406556010246277,
-0.727053165435791,
-0.21432651579380035,
-0.3729218542575836,
0.2375049889087677,
0.12300602346658707,
-1.138237714767456,
0.4745199680328369,
0.01686449535191059,
0.1305692344903946,
0.20835228264331818,
0.5511545538902283,
-0.17725901305675507,
0.9716572761535645,
0.9458178877830505,
-0.8401042222976685,
0.5409446358680725,
-0.04933509975671768,
0.0733933076262474,
-0.4067583978176117,
0.20048847794532776,
-0.6675644516944885,
-0.6037923097610474,
-0.22393840551376343,
-0.4211272597312927,
0.26187172532081604,
0.26798808574676514,
0.28214138746261597,
0.11255133152008057,
-0.36401495337486267,
0.8059951663017273,
0.8727362751960754,
0.0628376454114914,
0.3852660655975342,
0.5291447639465332,
-0.14000263810157776,
-0.14912086725234985,
-0.8854899406433105,
-0.190495103597641,
0.9402534365653992,
0.1038932055234909,
0.8400006890296936,
-0.4025954008102417,
0.701772928237915,
0.01983291283249855,
0.19248612225055695,
-0.42015525698661804,
0.5623071193695068,
-0.28100842237472534,
-0.4443119466304779,
-0.3891470432281494,
-0.4915854036808014,
-0.9126765131950378,
0.060886725783348083,
-0.15759986639022827,
-0.5244047045707703,
0.12119302898645401,
0.39581042528152466,
-0.009855001233518124,
0.4399831295013428,
-0.31669092178344727,
0.6986262202262878,
-0.05002230033278465,
0.2275954633951187,
-0.5775673985481262,
-0.5279142260551453,
0.33262068033218384,
-0.1704450249671936,
0.20836520195007324,
0.068716861307621,
0.44564294815063477,
0.7749902009963989,
-0.4187223017215729,
1.2488468885421753,
-0.08376329392194748,
0.16939415037631989,
0.566490888595581,
-0.2966815233230591,
0.34785765409469604,
-0.2382495254278183,
0.22335997223854065,
0.01722111366689205,
0.14567497372627258,
-0.6107219457626343,
-0.43020060658454895,
0.4593510329723358,
-0.5207083225250244,
-0.20624780654907227,
-0.3556372821331024,
-0.47034695744514465,
-0.09346125274896622,
0.11485867202281952,
0.48101770877838135,
0.22753767669200897,
-0.4848850965499878,
0.3592565059661865,
0.32647305727005005,
-0.13923126459121704,
0.455484539270401,
0.5315156579017639,
-0.32892316579818726,
-0.7243872284889221,
0.9734387397766113,
0.02713722735643387,
0.5960171818733215,
0.30125948786735535,
0.14648789167404175,
-0.09050392359495163,
-0.5424142479896545,
-0.3498804569244385,
0.33832067251205444,
-0.48335349559783936,
-0.19916507601737976,
-0.4875345826148987,
-0.13148216903209686,
-0.2474711835384369,
-0.2768591344356537,
-0.404076486825943,
-0.5038442015647888,
0.007052271161228418,
-0.20593686401844025,
0.42665034532546997,
0.170570507645607,
0.0390595979988575,
1.063066840171814,
-0.8881080746650696,
0.12707950174808502,
0.24986632168293,
0.12101180851459503,
0.054151855409145355,
-0.33934545516967773,
-0.2885068356990814,
0.09937223047018051,
-0.27590101957321167,
-0.5465431213378906,
0.466409832239151,
0.10119267553091049,
0.6995449066162109,
0.26326388120651245,
-0.1839890033006668,
0.7417638301849365,
-0.714147686958313,
0.6848947405815125,
0.213788241147995,
-0.7812354564666748,
0.3921597898006439,
-0.3312043249607086,
0.6192629337310791,
1.0965951681137085,
0.1972564458847046,
-0.8407608866691589,
-0.6434321999549866,
-0.7446827292442322,
-0.8677452802658081,
0.5065761208534241,
0.17497661709785461,
0.21800582110881805,
-0.056934237480163574,
0.17098674178123474,
-0.042906131595373154,
0.642213761806488,
-0.8706790804862976,
0.0021794582717120647,
0.061901867389678955,
-0.5052354335784912,
-0.07020703703165054,
-0.308771014213562,
-0.3515532612800598,
-0.2835366129875183,
0.40477052330970764,
-0.18784143030643463,
-0.0018768598092719913,
-0.18569523096084595,
-0.1599922925233841,
-0.1465357095003128,
0.2739938199520111,
0.6665016412734985,
0.6209631562232971,
-0.1424357146024704,
0.03580084815621376,
0.26234057545661926,
-0.7640045881271362,
0.04537180811166763,
-0.264870285987854,
-0.5391616821289062,
0.15045152604579926,
0.31836196780204773,
0.6931276917457581,
0.33069804310798645,
-1.0521278381347656,
0.6404682993888855,
0.34712880849838257,
-0.12385651469230652,
-0.23070558905601501,
0.13575389981269836,
0.13199926912784576,
0.014246591366827488,
0.27651938796043396,
-0.2263452559709549,
-0.13858437538146973,
-0.39692384004592896,
0.4078490436077118,
0.4218478798866272,
-0.06252066045999527,
-0.1818903088569641,
0.0693892389535904,
-0.09176549315452576,
-0.1497175246477127,
0.6467112898826599,
0.1530463546514511,
-0.6552493572235107,
0.750694751739502,
0.8228234052658081,
0.4498131573200226,
-0.4274730682373047,
0.23982791602611542,
0.21283045411109924,
0.3063725233078003,
-0.59464031457901,
0.2292289435863495,
0.12129130959510803,
-0.7549402117729187,
-0.4358101487159729,
-0.532994270324707,
-0.6208725571632385,
0.05395718663930893,
-0.8799595236778259,
0.49497365951538086,
-0.2812451422214508,
0.061152830719947815,
-0.6454090476036072,
-0.2672577202320099,
-0.16049064695835114,
0.24096006155014038,
-0.06928835809230804,
1.0351369380950928,
-1.289475917816162,
0.9353417158126831,
0.3681977689266205,
-0.016306884586811066,
-0.5408533811569214,
-0.15624812245368958,
-0.05928858742117882,
-0.9873755574226379,
0.2739272713661194,
0.2793656587600708,
0.03383563086390495,
0.14639028906822205,
-0.901028573513031,
-0.7785868048667908,
0.7910035848617554,
0.16156230866909027,
-0.6776043176651001,
0.17618024349212646,
0.3644731044769287,
0.5695438385009766,
-0.5794538259506226,
-0.11577381938695908,
0.6932193636894226,
0.1776665896177292,
0.2571345567703247,
-0.6157661080360413,
-0.32361799478530884,
-0.17253997921943665,
-0.049745410680770874,
0.2712074816226959,
-0.390582799911499,
0.7285632491111755,
0.2226039171218872,
-0.11576355993747711,
0.1587805449962616,
0.615685760974884,
0.8806299567222595,
0.22344470024108887,
0.9541557431221008,
0.9216879606246948,
0.6809906959533691,
0.15808652341365814,
0.9158385992050171,
-0.14877040684223175,
0.4390529990196228,
1.4019904136657715,
-0.4857352077960968,
1.1051764488220215,
0.7431212663650513,
-0.2030574083328247,
0.06328736990690231,
0.3897554278373718,
-0.5739110708236694,
0.6685498356819153,
0.2465594857931137,
-0.15615607798099518,
-0.049230001866817474,
-0.02872215025126934,
-0.2978760898113251,
0.3237592577934265,
0.13695989549160004,
0.026154890656471252,
-0.5339349508285522,
0.3030642569065094,
0.1517486870288849,
0.30828943848609924,
-0.131828173995018,
0.6183459162712097,
0.16335037350654602,
-0.7164135575294495,
0.4044642150402069,
0.05103786289691925,
0.6931195259094238,
-0.45281797647476196,
0.10585188865661621,
-0.13468682765960693,
0.21077799797058105,
-0.11425855755805969,
-0.8469035029411316,
0.34186965227127075,
0.05039501562714577,
-0.44927287101745605,
-0.280565083026886,
0.4345635175704956,
-0.9150039553642273,
-0.7376989126205444,
0.17413993179798126,
0.14000870287418365,
0.1913292557001114,
-0.05873345211148262,
-0.48158037662506104,
0.03958691284060478,
0.06926745921373367,
0.12296777963638306,
0.40553945302963257,
0.11191026866436005,
-0.19364221394062042,
0.5695433020591736,
0.635581910610199,
0.49849557876586914,
0.07389575242996216,
0.4202960729598999,
0.9065163135528564,
-0.5795357823371887,
-0.7074425220489502,
-0.9886212348937988,
0.35237759351730347,
-0.3845956027507782,
-0.2942858040332794,
0.6988862156867981,
0.6337916254997253,
0.8030700087547302,
-0.08518097549676895,
0.6206316947937012,
0.1802494078874588,
1.2546677589416504,
-0.6528882384300232,
0.5584067106246948,
-0.33689430356025696,
0.20320260524749756,
-0.28983837366104126,
-1.0294132232666016,
-0.262020081281662,
0.6702068448066711,
-0.2495020627975464,
-0.034360673278570175,
0.631301999092102,
0.5964350700378418,
-0.2673312723636627,
0.0060839480720460415,
-0.07095032930374146,
-0.014189253561198711,
0.33356720209121704,
0.3673798739910126,
0.4870454668998718,
-0.011554514057934284,
0.3175252377986908,
-0.23971256613731384,
-0.21199114620685577,
-0.3910081088542938,
-1.0449966192245483,
-1.1676932573318481,
-0.10635329782962799,
0.06538105010986328,
0.13784468173980713,
-0.26335009932518005,
0.7629163861274719,
0.7042880058288574,
-0.9000731110572815,
-0.5702807903289795,
-0.19111883640289307,
-0.08115287125110626,
-0.33007362484931946,
-0.17147177457809448,
0.27642950415611267,
-0.29532739520072937,
-0.739376962184906,
0.2507568299770355,
0.02408011071383953,
0.4035351276397705,
-0.08065595477819443,
0.4754308760166168,
-0.22148729860782623,
-0.27591925859451294,
0.29828405380249023,
0.30826717615127563,
-0.19561167061328888,
-0.07798547297716141,
-0.028159912675619125,
-0.1738690435886383,
0.1581694632768631,
1.0773955583572388,
-0.5847399234771729,
0.2275840938091278,
0.4087023437023163,
0.7443715333938599,
0.7589514255523682,
0.3024481534957886,
0.9436182379722595,
-1.2508958578109741,
0.7274329662322998,
0.11491665244102478,
0.16345766186714172,
0.40295812487602234,
-0.1215926930308342,
0.32931050658226013,
0.37525030970573425,
-0.4017728865146637,
-0.9955713748931885,
-0.051801979541778564,
-1.2889846563339233,
-0.39020511507987976,
1.0379198789596558,
0.2517299950122833,
-0.2195109874010086,
0.18802353739738464,
-0.2864072024822235,
0.054430536925792694,
-0.1318269819021225,
0.8014741539955139,
0.9341889023780823,
0.35742485523223877,
-0.16292265057563782,
-0.6055697202682495,
0.23788830637931824,
0.8207523226737976,
-0.9261566400527954,
0.06031667813658714,
0.2492697536945343,
0.40743547677993774,
-0.016934199258685112,
0.7681819796562195,
0.05646544694900513,
-0.04080507904291153,
-0.447112500667572,
0.2567211985588074,
0.3389768600463867,
-0.40619075298309326,
-0.3880063593387604,
0.17034395039081573,
-0.11939501762390137,
-0.1139882355928421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14523v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14523v2
|
Daisy-TTS: Simulating Wider Spectrum of Emotions via Prosody Embedding Decomposition
| 2024-02-22T13:15:49 | 2024-06-27T15:14:58 |
Rendi Chevi, Alham Fikri Aji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We often verbally express emotions in a multifaceted manner, they may vary in
their intensities and may be expressed not just as a single but as a mixture of
emotions. This wide spectrum of emotions is well-studied in the structural
model of emotions, which represents variety of emotions as derivative products
of primary emotions with varying degrees of intensity. In this paper, we
propose an emotional text-to-speech design to simulate a wider spectrum of
emotions grounded on the structural model. Our proposed design, Daisy-TTS,
incorporates a prosody encoder to learn emotionally-separable prosody embedding
as a proxy for emotion. This emotion representation allows the model to
simulate: (1) Primary emotions, as learned from the training samples, (2)
Secondary emotions, as a mixture of primary emotions, (3) Intensity-level, by
scaling the emotion embedding, and (4) Emotions polarity, by negating the
emotion embedding. Through a series of perceptual evaluations, Daisy-TTS
demonstrated overall higher emotional speech naturalness and emotion
perceiveability compared to the baseline.
|
[
-0.31587672233581543,
-1.103821039199829,
0.3848304748535156,
0.57454913854599,
-0.5282464027404785,
0.4118991792201996,
-0.3048320710659027,
-0.13862532377243042,
0.9379047155380249,
-0.21161186695098877,
-0.8803665637969971,
-0.5951241254806519,
-0.3823571503162384,
0.24582064151763916,
-0.317753404378891,
0.794901430606842,
0.10162702202796936,
0.1253177374601364,
0.2243024855852127,
0.16418848931789398,
-0.22134043276309967,
-0.674061119556427,
-0.4829520583152771,
0.23419994115829468,
0.419047474861145,
0.41976186633110046,
0.44646355509757996,
0.014502903446555138,
0.2972981035709381,
0.28849929571151733,
-0.38237887620925903,
-0.10537964105606079,
-0.5924800634384155,
0.6411243677139282,
0.2917853891849518,
-0.32864442467689514,
-0.675780177116394,
0.1744665652513504,
0.8940210342407227,
0.24661263823509216,
-0.1562708169221878,
-0.11846935003995895,
0.1472206711769104,
0.27374860644340515,
-0.7826178669929504,
0.2610822021961212,
-0.08799255639314651,
0.28928446769714355,
0.06240249052643776,
0.07167814671993256,
-0.6211568117141724,
-0.1771811991930008,
0.15411540865898132,
-0.7482441663742065,
0.027069736272096634,
-0.012956049293279648,
0.6217790246009827,
-0.1431470513343811,
-0.9177698493003845,
-0.3075035512447357,
-0.6056373715400696,
0.6751106977462769,
-0.3848956823348999,
0.726209819316864,
0.07693053781986237,
0.1663588285446167,
-0.0644591748714447,
-0.6649502515792847,
-0.6674548387527466,
-0.3924437165260315,
0.3017040193080902,
0.6981803178787231,
-0.1368718445301056,
0.2894819378852844,
-0.03205741569399834,
0.37304142117500305,
-0.5721220970153809,
-0.2001691311597824,
-0.03975459560751915,
-0.005142488982528448,
0.49675703048706055,
0.21942341327667236,
0.44796431064605713,
-0.24545854330062866,
-0.11039692163467407,
-0.11508752405643463,
-0.25130701065063477,
0.06784626841545105,
0.559320867061615,
0.6351000070571899,
-0.4207175076007843,
0.5520259141921997,
-0.09182068705558777,
0.17598746716976166,
0.05199746415019035,
-0.03150394186377525,
0.569675087928772,
0.1361362636089325,
-0.3128456473350525,
0.055840544402599335,
0.8857474327087402,
0.2323065549135208,
0.3294794261455536,
-0.20026755332946777,
0.0798502266407013,
0.6613678336143494,
0.23837634921073914,
-0.9156004786491394,
-0.15122871100902557,
0.4937863349914551,
-0.4058302044868469,
-0.2445720136165619,
-0.12032156437635422,
-1.0320940017700195,
-0.3063300549983978,
-0.2079096883535385,
0.5340554714202881,
-0.7987851500511169,
-0.532145082950592,
-0.0319945327937603,
-0.3139766752719879,
-0.16414427757263184,
0.007869563065469265,
-0.9266712665557861,
0.4753706753253937,
0.6800304055213928,
1.0059821605682373,
0.33260539174079895,
-0.14445893466472626,
-0.6652902960777283,
0.042585570365190506,
-0.46570029854774475,
0.3253319561481476,
-0.9796732664108276,
-0.7984023094177246,
-0.06184195354580879,
0.09510010480880737,
0.045702289789915085,
-0.15880349278450012,
0.6870852112770081,
-0.1868695318698883,
-0.01448556687682867,
-0.3554988503456116,
-0.5303397178649902,
0.013002937659621239,
0.025157587602734566,
-0.6905660629272461,
0.6764870285987854,
0.23724313080310822,
-0.7265141606330872,
0.1408010870218277,
-0.44829630851745605,
-0.4228227138519287,
-0.18080450594425201,
-0.07514618337154388,
-0.566959798336029,
0.5410950183868408,
0.084767647087574,
0.1887834668159485,
-0.33727771043777466,
0.017207296565175056,
-0.5744441151618958,
-0.5103573799133301,
0.1802956461906433,
-0.1852504163980484,
0.4127243161201477,
0.4138640761375427,
-0.3158630430698395,
0.24423852562904358,
-0.6331530213356018,
-0.18043363094329834,
0.08932597190141678,
0.1814398616552353,
-0.46117743849754333,
-0.08764666318893433,
0.3986995220184326,
0.08334524184465408,
-0.22295571863651276,
-0.9497252702713013,
0.14976872503757477,
-0.44620341062545776,
0.6079187989234924,
0.634077250957489,
0.14870578050613403,
0.6152936816215515,
-0.004968739114701748,
0.9612094163894653,
0.27476510405540466,
0.30608540773391724,
-0.10425404459238052,
-0.6305029392242432,
-0.6987676024436951,
-0.7675033807754517,
0.11335171014070511,
0.286803662776947,
-0.23498322069644928,
0.22809599339962006,
0.07265008985996246,
-0.47746551036834717,
-0.9158095717430115,
-0.5181178450584412,
0.31376731395721436,
0.5236697196960449,
0.3652549982070923,
-0.18802353739738464,
-0.645099401473999,
-0.6990659832954407,
-0.23968182504177094,
-0.1673191487789154,
-0.1462063491344452,
-0.06113269925117493,
0.37071824073791504,
-0.24522963166236877,
1.1869524717330933,
-0.3634892702102661,
-0.2789359390735626,
0.03987615928053856,
0.4275593161582947,
-0.30591896176338196,
0.4575897753238678,
0.3657381534576416,
-0.5691819787025452,
-0.1619744896888733,
-0.322092741727829,
-0.48961979150772095,
-0.12483026832342148,
0.02463153377175331,
-0.00481207761913538,
0.010119237937033176,
0.013092641718685627,
-0.8912695050239563,
0.3195001184940338,
0.4907715618610382,
-0.5402116179466248,
0.6861487030982971,
-0.16327546536922455,
0.1675499826669693,
-1.3528773784637451,
-0.29252347350120544,
-0.012422943487763405,
0.11397454887628555,
-0.5443511009216309,
0.10329362750053406,
0.2509857416152954,
-0.4788132607936859,
-0.43324026465415955,
0.12361922860145569,
-0.5636686682701111,
-0.15888755023479462,
0.027267951518297195,
0.16784533858299255,
0.15336614847183228,
0.27634862065315247,
0.13002093136310577,
0.7701805830001831,
0.7959831953048706,
-0.4407031536102295,
0.48853281140327454,
0.31952154636383057,
0.17204292118549347,
0.7431789040565491,
-0.7543862462043762,
0.07920973747968674,
-0.5499280095100403,
0.5730971097946167,
-1.0720056295394897,
-0.16303254663944244,
0.06707387417554855,
-0.5398961901664734,
0.16266754269599915,
-0.05336543172597885,
-0.5315600633621216,
-0.18904520571231842,
-0.4303150773048401,
0.3325643837451935,
0.906076192855835,
-0.15933968126773834,
0.9101252555847168,
0.49444884061813354,
-0.36180412769317627,
-0.05553450435400009,
-0.6592069268226624,
0.07312218844890594,
-0.5208346247673035,
-0.6190081238746643,
0.33560532331466675,
0.04002203419804573,
-0.3018408417701721,
-0.11343278735876083,
0.22965897619724274,
0.16247126460075378,
-0.12978632748126984,
0.5601428747177124,
-0.11995812505483627,
-0.03411607816815376,
0.5876408219337463,
0.3089562952518463,
-0.28339913487434387,
0.10608723759651184,
-0.15810294449329376,
0.543860137462616,
-0.38674336671829224,
-0.2837790846824646,
-0.6871954202651978,
0.8341155648231506,
0.566497802734375,
-0.44049814343452454,
0.5938611030578613,
0.7792761325836182,
-0.38750913739204407,
-0.4300154745578766,
-0.00876371469348669,
-0.37787869572639465,
-0.4870799481868744,
0.5711876153945923,
-0.6819555759429932,
-0.7593092918395996,
0.5048930644989014,
-0.24741151928901672,
-0.20999963581562042,
0.1883494108915329,
0.60811847448349,
-0.44014716148376465,
1.3450891971588135,
0.5370742082595825,
-0.05912676081061363,
0.5770462155342102,
-0.4591348469257355,
0.1761389523744583,
-0.8180091977119446,
-0.22188536822795868,
-0.5337521433830261,
-0.43848946690559387,
-0.7041059136390686,
-0.4867057204246521,
0.49171608686447144,
0.0038975649513304234,
-0.5955595374107361,
0.0228726826608181,
-0.18636009097099304,
0.09677072614431381,
0.47441840171813965,
0.15968696773052216,
-0.04944052919745445,
0.05076659470796585,
-0.22357353568077087,
-0.37115368247032166,
-0.37771546840667725,
-0.38412830233573914,
0.7232232093811035,
0.6088740229606628,
0.7397907376289368,
0.13726599514484406,
1.025636911392212,
-0.05571262538433075,
0.27239567041397095,
-0.9884860515594482,
0.5502321720123291,
-0.42612940073013306,
-0.1418921798467636,
-0.032029081135988235,
-0.38958120346069336,
-0.7249853014945984,
0.07735379785299301,
-0.23344117403030396,
-0.9191330671310425,
0.22714322805404663,
0.07527390867471695,
-0.27056723833084106,
-0.08358360826969147,
-0.967539370059967,
0.744376003742218,
0.26928186416625977,
-0.3597095012664795,
-0.40517714619636536,
-0.49664852023124695,
0.21940118074417114,
0.1662752479314804,
0.4915522336959839,
-0.06261953711509705,
0.025524083524942398,
0.8544026613235474,
-0.7813600897789001,
0.8845822811126709,
-0.13414660096168518,
-0.18647295236587524,
0.45154333114624023,
0.5216240286827087,
0.5972304940223694,
0.13880744576454163,
-0.09879470616579056,
-0.23196002840995789,
-0.32260820269584656,
-0.20127296447753906,
-0.7858385443687439,
0.5236798524856567,
-0.992658793926239,
-0.3110562562942505,
-0.25101256370544434,
-0.6583735346794128,
-0.5578944683074951,
-0.3106037676334381,
0.15527857840061188,
0.6522461771965027,
-0.1532827913761139,
0.0828920528292656,
0.32967841625213623,
-0.08523724973201752,
0.30716389417648315,
0.2800467610359192,
-0.4068039655685425,
-0.6868582367897034,
1.050464391708374,
0.1526649296283722,
0.13242244720458984,
0.2588405907154083,
0.48881059885025024,
-0.42682430148124695,
-0.015946270897984505,
-0.04090014845132828,
0.26102662086486816,
-0.5578897595405579,
0.2021709531545639,
-0.6849377751350403,
0.1415954977273941,
-0.6506948471069336,
-0.26101580262184143,
-0.5239050984382629,
-0.35448962450027466,
-0.5405164361000061,
-0.4370216727256775,
0.7139832973480225,
0.6424030065536499,
-0.07992859929800034,
0.5631057024002075,
-0.815072774887085,
0.5093957185745239,
0.4962575435638428,
0.4166448712348938,
-0.17875762283802032,
-0.6519497036933899,
0.06889694929122925,
0.16406415402889252,
-0.17720577120780945,
-1.371693730354309,
0.8770988583564758,
0.3349822461605072,
0.038920238614082336,
0.42950674891471863,
0.36169901490211487,
0.8865489363670349,
-0.4717085659503937,
0.8970628380775452,
0.2980157732963562,
-1.4444811344146729,
0.6434959173202515,
-0.47681254148483276,
0.040324341505765915,
0.19533811509609222,
0.46486684679985046,
-0.6285828948020935,
-0.6986974477767944,
-0.6755642294883728,
-1.0285065174102783,
0.504957914352417,
0.37253451347351074,
0.25259190797805786,
-0.19843697547912598,
0.06566552817821503,
-0.10932828485965729,
0.03027201071381569,
-0.3732113540172577,
-0.01602937839925289,
-0.24950894713401794,
-0.7741172313690186,
-0.23435233533382416,
-0.6285483241081238,
0.042406097054481506,
0.09782873094081879,
0.635341227054596,
0.055968187749385834,
0.6463303565979004,
0.08867983520030975,
-0.02885100245475769,
-0.04229273274540901,
0.1966266632080078,
0.25079405307769775,
-0.2980037331581116,
-0.4490252733230591,
0.23666717112064362,
-0.04617641121149063,
-0.857519805431366,
0.38334283232688904,
-0.21099770069122314,
0.08182145655155182,
0.21885474026203156,
0.23761121928691864,
1.0110154151916504,
0.21244770288467407,
-0.5562004446983337,
0.4568251073360443,
-0.09408318251371384,
-0.14684855937957764,
-0.022525127977132797,
-0.3313049077987671,
0.48489925265312195,
0.4617736339569092,
0.1927054226398468,
-0.5960107445716858,
0.22919245064258575,
-0.8796510696411133,
0.280820369720459,
0.28876128792762756,
-0.5997947454452515,
-0.4920276701450348,
0.7227262258529663,
0.4562190771102905,
-0.6908524036407471,
0.5420289039611816,
-0.25632503628730774,
-0.47799190878868103,
0.6996769309043884,
0.9003577828407288,
1.2978794574737549,
-0.46151071786880493,
0.36826321482658386,
0.1891215741634369,
0.11862194538116455,
0.41603580117225647,
1.039566993713379,
-0.11742408573627472,
-0.2757374346256256,
-0.07674612104892731,
-0.6308290958404541,
-0.735572338104248,
-0.33333396911621094,
-0.6381194591522217,
0.34187689423561096,
-0.4749012887477875,
-0.5695808529853821,
-0.3325570225715637,
-0.15737369656562805,
-0.38850659132003784,
0.5215228796005249,
0.2718806862831116,
0.78892582654953,
-1.1171492338180542,
0.7465417385101318,
0.6737674474716187,
-0.5066065192222595,
-0.914646565914154,
0.16802196204662323,
0.21413461863994598,
-0.2828771471977234,
0.9401242733001709,
0.41785117983818054,
-0.3903059661388397,
0.24515379965305328,
-0.06326565891504288,
-0.5933255553245544,
0.9407722353935242,
0.43168893456459045,
-0.8352241516113281,
0.09446189552545547,
0.23135997354984283,
0.6722798347473145,
-0.5004644393920898,
0.7001751065254211,
0.277567595243454,
0.03749018535017967,
0.15000863373279572,
-0.8682141900062561,
-0.0809595063328743,
-0.329190194606781,
0.09658785909414291,
-0.16297657787799835,
-0.9172284007072449,
1.3960222005844116,
0.007403848227113485,
-0.3886970281600952,
-0.1341000199317932,
0.8111510872840881,
0.516409695148468,
0.027261672541499138,
0.47414538264274597,
0.44270363450050354,
0.6936080455780029,
-0.12650524079799652,
0.7074805498123169,
-0.5005982518196106,
0.49554136395454407,
0.7940500974655151,
-0.3956572413444519,
1.0525786876678467,
0.4881075620651245,
-0.266597718000412,
0.5641258358955383,
0.5593805313110352,
0.7647770643234253,
0.590038001537323,
0.41249290108680725,
-0.7120776176452637,
-0.22946840524673462,
-0.16424685716629028,
-0.5803397297859192,
0.5657457113265991,
0.6290243268013,
-0.23800218105316162,
-0.09668571501970291,
0.3361797630786896,
-0.19428661465644836,
-0.13948772847652435,
-0.13435626029968262,
0.6398277878761292,
0.19138582050800323,
0.06282304972410202,
0.37860921025276184,
0.033081065863370895,
0.5752545595169067,
-0.771766185760498,
0.04993071034550667,
-0.2899453639984131,
0.1096356064081192,
0.01735861413180828,
-0.6039199829101562,
0.245061993598938,
0.12925782799720764,
0.05720967426896095,
-0.2595183253288269,
0.45384493470191956,
-0.5734639167785645,
-0.48107442259788513,
0.47850850224494934,
-0.0012556560104712844,
0.05383161082863808,
-0.2532828152179718,
-0.22891634702682495,
0.45313364267349243,
-0.4925224483013153,
-0.5351607799530029,
0.11095181107521057,
0.6984702944755554,
0.10004598647356033,
0.5805914998054504,
0.44064071774482727,
-0.02322559989988804,
-0.1152888685464859,
0.40638643503189087,
0.9106021523475647,
-0.7077093720436096,
-1.3295122385025024,
-0.8306053280830383,
0.7154982686042786,
0.09794698655605316,
-0.13129493594169617,
0.7394118905067444,
0.414163738489151,
0.15057273209095,
-0.16659721732139587,
0.7364180088043213,
0.258296400308609,
0.2885943353176117,
-0.3551423251628876,
0.5961931943893433,
-0.48682937026023865,
-0.245961531996727,
-0.9677656292915344,
-0.7140256762504578,
-0.09929943084716797,
0.9179880619049072,
-0.0763295516371727,
-0.06864754855632782,
0.6352918148040771,
0.7560238242149353,
0.300716757774353,
0.7447265386581421,
0.208915576338768,
0.4443355202674866,
0.3643418252468109,
0.7164784073829651,
0.982728123664856,
-0.33129116892814636,
0.13026772439479828,
-0.20323292911052704,
-0.46392372250556946,
-0.23040080070495605,
-0.7683568000793457,
-0.4905069172382355,
-0.8356629014015198,
-0.3068903088569641,
-0.3515772521495819,
0.154730886220932,
1.1541383266448975,
0.6239848136901855,
-0.5592464208602905,
-0.2213095873594284,
-0.27716636657714844,
-0.22592665255069733,
-0.07609958946704865,
-0.20528632402420044,
0.2715165913105011,
-0.4260028004646301,
-0.868207573890686,
0.4855077862739563,
0.26582038402557373,
0.19595545530319214,
-0.13420195877552032,
-0.21937605738639832,
0.16792337596416473,
0.07543956488370895,
0.8154774308204651,
-0.15307065844535828,
-0.4033961892127991,
-0.33871516585350037,
0.028385279700160027,
0.10651788860559464,
-0.274441659450531,
0.7463057637214661,
-0.9004644155502319,
0.6302999258041382,
0.529309868812561,
0.3802069425582886,
0.4018825888633728,
-0.12828975915908813,
0.6508460640907288,
-0.9502206444740295,
0.48609691858291626,
0.3518582582473755,
0.349661260843277,
-0.025330249220132828,
-0.17664825916290283,
-0.04207316040992737,
0.5603373646736145,
-0.09303805977106094,
-0.7970647811889648,
0.4483833909034729,
-1.0935641527175903,
-0.14321181178092957,
1.3620017766952515,
-0.18784667551517487,
-0.29314106702804565,
0.1322990506887436,
-0.5289459228515625,
0.781384289264679,
-0.561314582824707,
0.5968102812767029,
0.5604791641235352,
0.07962331920862198,
-0.1640578806400299,
-0.24210792779922485,
0.28426262736320496,
0.5430309772491455,
-0.6334915161132812,
0.27387484908103943,
0.6720601916313171,
0.12025295197963715,
-0.03995906189084053,
0.6458238363265991,
0.09471354633569717,
0.17051106691360474,
0.654958188533783,
0.10793904960155487,
-0.12678162753582,
-0.4903053343296051,
-0.5495527982711792,
0.5826376080513,
-0.33470094203948975,
-0.5132479071617126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14522v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14522v1
|
Towards Unified Task Embeddings Across Multiple Models: Bridging the Gap for Prompt-Based Large Language Models and Beyond
| 2024-02-22T13:13:31 | 2024-02-22T13:13:31 |
Xinyu Wang, Hainiu Xu, Lin Gui, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Task embedding, a meta-learning technique that captures task-specific
information, has become prevalent, especially in areas such as multi-task
learning, model editing, and interpretability. However, it faces challenges
with the emergence of prompt-guided Large Language Models (LLMs) operating in a
gradientfree manner. Existing task embedding methods rely on fine-tuned,
task-specific language models, which hinders the adaptability of task
embeddings across diverse models, especially prompt-based LLMs. To unleash the
power of task embedding in the era of LLMs, we propose a framework for unified
task embeddings (FUTE), harmonizing task embeddings from various models,
including smaller language models and LLMs with varied prompts, within a single
vector space. Such uniformity enables the comparison and analysis of
similarities amongst different models, extending the scope and utility of
existing task embedding methods in addressing multi-model scenarios, whilst
maintaining their performance to be comparable to architecture-specific
methods.
|
[
-0.17016483843326569,
-0.5605199933052063,
0.6834004521369934,
0.5012940168380737,
0.03756416589021683,
-0.07343123853206635,
-0.24170218408107758,
0.05224980041384697,
-0.0530766099691391,
0.4312354028224945,
-0.7851588129997253,
-0.6977726817131042,
-0.350028395652771,
0.11552999168634415,
-0.12847352027893066,
0.6814724802970886,
-0.06596727669239044,
0.14903314411640167,
-0.7147448658943176,
-0.30521950125694275,
-0.9691118001937866,
-0.45792391896247864,
-0.35972222685813904,
-0.2973766028881073,
0.5398240685462952,
0.3500533699989319,
0.4254460036754608,
0.38085776567459106,
0.11642543971538544,
0.2735399007797241,
0.3150629699230194,
0.26177850365638733,
-0.14352096617221832,
0.36940503120422363,
-0.2751893997192383,
-0.3480779528617859,
-0.2908957004547119,
-0.12959648668766022,
0.8189008831977844,
0.8949549198150635,
-0.15375731885433197,
0.013210073113441467,
0.5902496576309204,
0.11291497945785522,
-0.7790429592132568,
0.27612894773483276,
-0.3361859917640686,
-0.07048209756612778,
-0.10643426328897476,
0.13164499402046204,
-0.52403724193573,
0.12726007401943207,
-0.045483991503715515,
-0.5144495964050293,
0.19233252108097076,
-0.08943762630224228,
0.34723860025405884,
0.3272108733654022,
-0.446601927280426,
0.009436341002583504,
-0.48415106534957886,
0.9518029093742371,
-0.6824852228164673,
0.6065489649772644,
-0.07777748256921768,
0.1366543471813202,
-0.06738924980163574,
-0.6376420259475708,
-0.22992199659347534,
-0.1953594833612442,
-0.15453177690505981,
-0.2335752546787262,
-0.278241902589798,
0.11156325787305832,
0.1261468082666397,
-0.1174396276473999,
-0.5274989008903503,
0.26297083497047424,
0.3297503888607025,
-0.1688053160905838,
0.36437517404556274,
0.2983834743499756,
0.45200642943382263,
-0.008456673473119736,
-0.5447072982788086,
0.1463472992181778,
-0.7601427435874939,
0.0703660398721695,
0.15329793095588684,
0.7490687370300293,
-0.1671866625547409,
0.2626853883266449,
-0.06493443995714188,
0.7197487354278564,
0.04161279276013374,
0.045349568128585815,
0.15530359745025635,
-0.2688654661178589,
-0.3162012994289398,
-0.5004386305809021,
0.9192885160446167,
-0.012885828502476215,
-0.08540139347314835,
-0.3814316391944885,
-0.3120417594909668,
-0.11536356806755066,
0.15473967790603638,
-0.5749269723892212,
0.12125998735427856,
0.06693504750728607,
-0.3729320168495178,
0.07907573133707047,
0.21036085486412048,
-0.6839969158172607,
-0.45474740862846375,
-0.3465263247489929,
0.3441964387893677,
-0.10389434546232224,
-0.2237209975719452,
0.12927579879760742,
0.08823516964912415,
0.19579586386680603,
0.4660557508468628,
-0.7797058820724487,
0.26446112990379333,
0.766676664352417,
0.9116453528404236,
-0.22554418444633484,
-0.590530514717102,
-0.8140227794647217,
0.1879817396402359,
-0.025213513523340225,
0.6263331770896912,
-0.8277129530906677,
-0.5822185277938843,
0.33159032464027405,
0.1696937531232834,
-0.4184819459915161,
-0.08138005435466766,
0.5743014812469482,
-0.19726543128490448,
0.2106471210718155,
-0.713105320930481,
-0.657618522644043,
-0.2770356833934784,
0.10007026046514511,
-0.6977640986442566,
1.120632290840149,
0.061307210475206375,
-0.5869442820549011,
0.08109742403030396,
-0.8135082721710205,
-0.4519844949245453,
0.059450507164001465,
-0.44794368743896484,
-0.12167825549840927,
0.258135586977005,
0.3184497654438019,
0.9564113020896912,
-0.5421556234359741,
0.4488326907157898,
-0.4189586341381073,
-0.16603082418441772,
-0.14349687099456787,
-0.46586641669273376,
0.7846675515174866,
0.05590682849287987,
-0.2984965443611145,
0.40152987837791443,
-0.06632645428180695,
-0.20296983420848846,
-0.05603805184364319,
-0.1389411985874176,
-0.3467003405094147,
0.01753503456711769,
0.261898010969162,
0.32062238454818726,
0.39960727095603943,
-0.6176047921180725,
0.551396369934082,
-0.027005936950445175,
0.41439372301101685,
0.7674176692962646,
-0.33880046010017395,
0.5000665187835693,
-0.4282073378562927,
0.572265625,
0.08376297354698181,
-0.0325486958026886,
-0.5839218497276306,
-0.5097963213920593,
-0.39439669251441956,
-0.561150848865509,
0.1936320811510086,
0.5914414525032043,
-0.43296098709106445,
0.37807905673980713,
-0.18404774367809296,
-0.32461172342300415,
-0.6112160682678223,
0.30583280324935913,
0.4181312322616577,
0.17454630136489868,
0.3303663730621338,
0.06621872633695602,
-0.36640992760658264,
-0.826988160610199,
-0.3787716031074524,
0.28463295102119446,
-0.0004361119063105434,
0.36133530735969543,
0.5188408493995667,
-0.4510154724121094,
0.8872393369674683,
-0.39826223254203796,
-0.2932824194431305,
-0.36000609397888184,
0.22114147245883942,
0.19839245080947876,
0.7125976085662842,
0.5742498636245728,
-0.7176291942596436,
-0.5397383570671082,
-0.12058308720588684,
-0.6853322386741638,
-0.1288328617811203,
-0.35744309425354004,
-0.03294021636247635,
-0.036946386098861694,
0.7435698509216309,
-0.6341842412948608,
0.1486159861087799,
0.62908536195755,
-0.5285602807998657,
0.3041565418243408,
-0.2998667061328888,
0.3091367483139038,
-1.3312424421310425,
0.14886854588985443,
-0.005485082045197487,
-0.31042933464050293,
-0.7330478429794312,
0.1576692759990692,
0.28582999110221863,
-0.05209055170416832,
-0.41396912932395935,
0.9617745876312256,
-0.6371798515319824,
0.04498950392007828,
-0.22062821686267853,
-0.018059197813272476,
0.04721677675843239,
0.5081028342247009,
-0.13535507023334503,
0.671818196773529,
0.9116315841674805,
-0.5829249024391174,
0.21506628394126892,
0.21618026494979858,
-0.10533977299928665,
0.7761183977127075,
-0.7726448774337769,
0.17000940442085266,
-0.2185794711112976,
0.3723914325237274,
-1.1404458284378052,
-0.11050251126289368,
0.10192941129207611,
-0.0922900140285492,
0.1970323622226715,
-0.04775655269622803,
-0.54570072889328,
-0.13443993031978607,
-0.3911271393299103,
0.6220740675926208,
0.3712540566921234,
-0.7139277458190918,
0.94564288854599,
0.14271998405456543,
-0.18057644367218018,
-0.8006623983383179,
-0.5101688504219055,
-0.15106920897960663,
-0.07788465172052383,
-0.6000263690948486,
0.6190155744552612,
-0.22842878103256226,
0.07419458776712418,
0.008505999110639095,
-0.02424752339720726,
0.004850069060921669,
0.2881028950214386,
0.48247021436691284,
0.17708908021450043,
-0.20649710297584534,
0.40759944915771484,
0.23234695196151733,
-0.020926885306835175,
-0.1551521271467209,
-0.4387660324573517,
0.5876648426055908,
-0.00044407800305634737,
-0.8035979270935059,
-0.4238213300704956,
0.742794394493103,
0.6966238617897034,
-0.46174123883247375,
0.7345982789993286,
0.6840030550956726,
-0.6658161878585815,
-0.45428094267845154,
-0.5754175782203674,
-0.05017635598778725,
-0.45188257098197937,
0.20401626825332642,
-0.5049276351928711,
-1.159263253211975,
0.5406213402748108,
-0.24859574437141418,
0.5347638726234436,
0.46331557631492615,
0.5938182473182678,
-0.1874186247587204,
1.0351208448410034,
0.9766466617584229,
-0.21196456253528595,
0.5670885443687439,
-0.06580714881420135,
-0.15102604031562805,
-0.8811495900154114,
-0.45595982670783997,
-0.6388274431228638,
-0.3200105130672455,
-0.13293635845184326,
-0.6048341989517212,
0.0760384052991867,
0.05933058261871338,
-0.2582911550998688,
0.18542426824569702,
-0.14380328357219696,
0.45513471961021423,
0.6057921051979065,
0.03043716587126255,
0.03301944583654404,
-0.3290116488933563,
-0.3850345313549042,
0.2011462301015854,
-0.8497430682182312,
-0.41951969265937805,
1.0209169387817383,
0.13793790340423584,
0.6584010720252991,
-0.04761657863855362,
0.7391378879547119,
0.5511879920959473,
0.266439288854599,
-0.4487324059009552,
0.41429921984672546,
-0.4393567442893982,
-0.3616980016231537,
-0.14381453394889832,
-0.2219657450914383,
-1.0035916566848755,
0.48800504207611084,
-0.17717279493808746,
-0.8762146234512329,
0.22740358114242554,
0.10201588273048401,
-0.588932991027832,
0.5311836004257202,
-0.4664098918437958,
1.27443265914917,
0.09491632878780365,
-0.19541947543621063,
-0.07588224112987518,
-0.39764538407325745,
0.14719873666763306,
0.0738331526517868,
0.39222660660743713,
-0.2878909111022949,
-0.2762155830860138,
0.7160937190055847,
0.028495505452156067,
1.295155644416809,
-0.26141437888145447,
-0.336347371339798,
0.17831778526306152,
0.04775557294487953,
0.5053206086158752,
0.05112309381365776,
0.08798808604478836,
0.022898737341165543,
0.003295203438028693,
-0.5362094044685364,
-0.6124823093414307,
0.905018150806427,
-0.5418773293495178,
-0.5488897562026978,
-0.19082899391651154,
-0.8437429666519165,
-0.4240143895149231,
-0.037961918860673904,
0.09087341278791428,
0.673909604549408,
-0.5464948415756226,
0.102217897772789,
0.685024082660675,
-0.06578803062438965,
0.6704633831977844,
0.31718167662620544,
-0.065082848072052,
-0.15273061394691467,
0.7826665043830872,
-0.34425055980682373,
0.008958832360804081,
0.6526817083358765,
0.09271562099456787,
-0.40461108088493347,
-0.1344955563545227,
-0.1780996173620224,
0.2236812561750412,
-0.6562573909759521,
-0.2822345793247223,
-0.763148307800293,
0.22445261478424072,
-0.5213409066200256,
-0.43708786368370056,
-0.25427353382110596,
0.02788475900888443,
-0.6251373887062073,
0.17674119770526886,
0.1489243060350418,
0.9570112824440002,
-0.16473223268985748,
0.469216912984848,
-1.0314300060272217,
0.3121987283229828,
0.35546618700027466,
0.2718305289745331,
0.08045019954442978,
-0.3296138644218445,
-0.22543270885944366,
0.23875102400779724,
-0.2010713368654251,
-1.0189872980117798,
0.10150165855884552,
0.2097845822572708,
1.007569670677185,
0.2799181342124939,
-0.0872574970126152,
0.4467308223247528,
-0.6685051918029785,
0.8956944942474365,
0.38341572880744934,
-1.2325897216796875,
0.4141339659690857,
-0.3596353828907013,
0.45304355025291443,
0.3007708191871643,
0.4678858518600464,
-0.8395289778709412,
-0.18209971487522125,
-0.5656229257583618,
-0.5620644092559814,
0.48941734433174133,
-0.24629086256027222,
0.40722227096557617,
0.02758629433810711,
0.12821346521377563,
0.46891891956329346,
0.18203625082969666,
-0.6934719085693359,
-0.18882149457931519,
0.10208772122859955,
-0.5475854873657227,
-0.24043092131614685,
0.0023619653657078743,
-0.11512541770935059,
-0.17787227034568787,
0.3291171193122864,
-0.27200403809547424,
0.4146197736263275,
-0.10861826688051224,
-0.4665394127368927,
0.09994425624608994,
0.44491520524024963,
0.2841458320617676,
0.33863869309425354,
0.29078471660614014,
0.0987163856625557,
0.2933654487133026,
-0.11099804937839508,
0.19222764670848846,
0.08259580284357071,
-0.08859904110431671,
0.010313371196389198,
0.6312665343284607,
0.852114200592041,
0.6369133591651917,
-0.5350208282470703,
0.6672148108482361,
0.15917564928531647,
-0.06357119977474213,
0.41077879071235657,
0.12286845594644547,
0.070444256067276,
0.5617977976799011,
0.1934090107679367,
0.06822238117456436,
-0.07202613353729248,
-0.5532509684562683,
0.3382066786289215,
0.751401424407959,
-0.37534892559051514,
-0.41403326392173767,
0.6216715574264526,
0.5002363920211792,
-0.3191528618335724,
0.38258856534957886,
-0.10541711002588272,
-0.3830533027648926,
0.44604045152664185,
0.49603521823883057,
1.2165416479110718,
-0.6117924451828003,
0.41735464334487915,
0.2668699026107788,
0.27043047547340393,
-0.3228340446949005,
0.5361150503158569,
-0.13916128873825073,
-0.5225058794021606,
-0.4488603472709656,
-0.4442071318626404,
-0.24900002777576447,
-0.11466829478740692,
-0.5821592211723328,
0.15139572322368622,
-0.18666397035121918,
-0.07548963278532028,
-0.3542513847351074,
-0.3733993470668793,
-1.0315136909484863,
-0.09322606027126312,
0.21389140188694,
0.7216794490814209,
-1.0620920658111572,
0.7558417320251465,
0.8483661413192749,
-0.13542895019054413,
-0.5490061640739441,
0.07829390466213226,
0.006034702528268099,
-0.6040475964546204,
0.37494778633117676,
0.351045161485672,
0.004780303221195936,
0.09124811738729477,
-0.34144461154937744,
-0.6785340905189514,
1.287234902381897,
0.7309648990631104,
-0.6468110084533691,
-0.35427311062812805,
-0.008131974376738071,
0.08169755339622498,
-0.7413680553436279,
0.10257890075445175,
0.35142531991004944,
0.37766265869140625,
-0.22000451385974884,
-0.9128285646438599,
0.32674655318260193,
0.07819851487874985,
-0.01983456127345562,
0.1839243620634079,
-0.2885831296443939,
1.0201364755630493,
-0.363844096660614,
-0.4321919083595276,
0.1305193454027176,
0.6872730255126953,
0.1032668799161911,
0.019069494679570198,
0.5835211873054504,
0.43287569284439087,
0.8850324153900146,
-0.14768998324871063,
0.8976349830627441,
-0.24705015122890472,
0.4637438654899597,
1.1273634433746338,
-0.20188410580158234,
0.743681788444519,
0.3229821026325226,
-0.06804965436458588,
0.514339029788971,
0.38976389169692993,
0.05905388668179512,
0.46973857283592224,
0.1279204785823822,
-0.3364867568016052,
-0.574889063835144,
-0.24794901907444,
-0.30758264660835266,
0.10329442471265793,
0.32154878973960876,
-0.14008401334285736,
-0.5250535607337952,
0.37175220251083374,
0.0201792661100626,
0.03009936772286892,
-0.3510162830352783,
0.5402763485908508,
0.13175486028194427,
-0.5132088661193848,
0.21271322667598724,
0.09705431759357452,
0.9550422430038452,
-0.7080113887786865,
-0.11672782152891159,
-0.068227618932724,
-0.10504510253667831,
-0.03485618904232979,
-0.7107958793640137,
-0.012268167920410633,
-0.048783909529447556,
-0.14562514424324036,
-0.5403608083724976,
0.5541799068450928,
-0.6627145409584045,
-0.3699009120464325,
0.41731157898902893,
1.0816658735275269,
-0.39648663997650146,
-0.1943230926990509,
-0.788475513458252,
0.05157710611820221,
-0.13605421781539917,
-0.17428460717201233,
0.25387415289878845,
0.47675222158432007,
0.10949590057134628,
0.6319113373756409,
0.5413269996643066,
-0.4227231442928314,
-0.09369535744190216,
0.12639963626861572,
0.7148730158805847,
-0.6024031639099121,
-0.6351717114448547,
-1.0566909313201904,
0.8078530430793762,
0.2094062715768814,
-0.29890012741088867,
0.7241905927658081,
0.19155235588550568,
0.5416393876075745,
-0.2371210753917694,
0.8145710825920105,
-0.026470055803656578,
0.1457846313714981,
-0.47047683596611023,
0.48567134141921997,
-0.8646435737609863,
0.05728723108768463,
-0.47978144884109497,
-0.9745557308197021,
-0.2422804981470108,
0.36794838309288025,
0.09578102082014084,
0.1668839305639267,
0.6733288764953613,
0.6382383108139038,
-0.23981519043445587,
-0.03662136569619179,
0.45507800579071045,
-0.10757648944854736,
0.20930416882038116,
0.7347797751426697,
0.7608311772346497,
-0.054858822375535965,
0.19625993072986603,
0.06810681521892548,
-0.12035854160785675,
-0.17384648323059082,
-1.027542233467102,
-1.0794979333877563,
-1.009610652923584,
-0.29667240381240845,
0.15829068422317505,
-0.06723149865865707,
1.1177668571472168,
0.7123165130615234,
-0.79953932762146,
-0.38062772154808044,
0.03698384389281273,
0.2838404178619385,
-0.4310376048088074,
-0.1495845913887024,
0.34122395515441895,
-0.46550339460372925,
-0.7164776921272278,
0.5574922561645508,
0.23271065950393677,
0.012040658853948116,
-0.3108578622341156,
-0.07750508934259415,
-0.30841150879859924,
0.24964633584022522,
0.5113746523857117,
0.2830214500427246,
-0.84776371717453,
-0.18891149759292603,
0.11380527168512344,
-0.2556408643722534,
-0.19547823071479797,
1.108902096748352,
-0.7087463140487671,
0.1429421752691269,
0.4805021286010742,
1.003268837928772,
-0.008588387630879879,
-0.3911249339580536,
0.7243019342422485,
-1.112509846687317,
-0.08186264336109161,
0.1836567372083664,
0.7458841800689697,
0.32028642296791077,
-0.22440314292907715,
0.20294193923473358,
0.2068803757429123,
-0.2553578317165375,
-0.8646429777145386,
0.39829307794570923,
-1.0343533754348755,
-0.515394926071167,
1.1087472438812256,
-0.4403437674045563,
0.170571431517601,
0.012810366228222847,
-0.12684747576713562,
0.19344015419483185,
-0.4539707601070404,
0.23588067293167114,
0.7737587094306946,
0.017762482166290283,
0.026627957820892334,
-0.3860042095184326,
0.33331844210624695,
0.4407642185688019,
-1.0654234886169434,
0.3538288474082947,
0.43897414207458496,
0.19978797435760498,
0.032661426812410355,
0.4768076539039612,
0.3351249694824219,
0.3090793788433075,
-0.22045932710170746,
0.016794594004750252,
-0.2879009544849396,
-0.6781119108200073,
-0.5376164317131042,
0.27061063051223755,
-0.2519248127937317,
-0.2622984051704407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14521v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14521v1
|
Malaysian English News Decoded: A Linguistic Resource for Named Entity and Relation Extraction
| 2024-02-22T13:12:05 | 2024-02-22T13:12:05 |
Mohan Raj Chanthran, Lay-Ki Soon, Huey Fang Ong, Bhawani Selvaretnam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Standard English and Malaysian English exhibit notable differences, posing
challenges for natural language processing (NLP) tasks on Malaysian English.
Unfortunately, most of the existing datasets are mainly based on standard
English and therefore inadequate for improving NLP tasks in Malaysian English.
An experiment using state-of-the-art Named Entity Recognition (NER) solutions
on Malaysian English news articles highlights that they cannot handle
morphosyntactic variations in Malaysian English. To the best of our knowledge,
there is no annotated dataset available to improvise the model. To address
these issues, we constructed a Malaysian English News (MEN) dataset, which
contains 200 news articles that are manually annotated with entities and
relations. We then fine-tuned the spaCy NER tool and validated that having a
dataset tailor-made for Malaysian English could improve the performance of NER
in Malaysian English significantly. This paper presents our effort in the data
acquisition, annotation methodology, and thorough analysis of the annotated
dataset. To validate the quality of the annotation, inter-annotator agreement
was used, followed by adjudication of disagreements by a subject matter expert.
Upon completion of these tasks, we managed to develop a dataset with 6,061
entities and 3,268 relation instances. Finally, we discuss on spaCy fine-tuning
setup and analysis on the NER performance. This unique dataset will contribute
significantly to the advancement of NLP research in Malaysian English, allowing
researchers to accelerate their progress, particularly in NER and relation
extraction. The dataset and annotation guideline has been published on Github.
|
[
-0.5831139087677002,
-0.6014478206634521,
0.061556704342365265,
0.33401423692703247,
-0.4465997517108917,
-0.11560014635324478,
-0.3085337281227112,
-0.6856312155723572,
0.4477061927318573,
0.6625393629074097,
-0.4688129127025604,
-0.3726414740085602,
-0.7340189218521118,
0.8806719779968262,
-0.27760109305381775,
1.1132700443267822,
-0.0167293231934309,
0.06931425631046295,
-0.06294357031583786,
-0.4418514668941498,
-0.4760737419128418,
-0.4072244167327881,
-0.8934757709503174,
-0.041836176067590714,
0.3409176766872406,
0.2629150450229645,
0.7906081676483154,
0.6969153881072998,
0.7783665657043457,
0.1375584453344345,
-0.30395305156707764,
0.46692711114883423,
-0.086093008518219,
0.2787531912326813,
-0.29902833700180054,
-0.22520898282527924,
-0.3363734185695648,
-0.23644989728927612,
0.582375168800354,
0.8677089810371399,
-0.10876943916082382,
0.17827655375003815,
-0.032380614429712296,
0.783804178237915,
-0.4936583638191223,
0.30343571305274963,
-0.6327424645423889,
-0.04004573076963425,
-0.3273576498031616,
-0.21657125651836395,
-0.24950368702411652,
-0.17097914218902588,
0.22103630006313324,
-0.724648654460907,
0.06071445345878601,
-0.06011473014950752,
1.2496042251586914,
0.31939494609832764,
-0.4897744655609131,
-0.6035385131835938,
-0.6276757717132568,
0.6021623015403748,
-0.7504069805145264,
0.5321694016456604,
0.2595534920692444,
0.17076648771762848,
-0.3169060945510864,
-0.5175710916519165,
-0.3720930218696594,
-0.18730111420154572,
-0.32127028703689575,
-0.0721031203866005,
-0.08822540193796158,
-0.08017157763242722,
0.31823065876960754,
0.39463749527931213,
-0.4238014817237854,
-0.0395892933011055,
-0.34813663363456726,
-0.07239188998937607,
0.7280201315879822,
-0.06509991735219955,
0.43234166502952576,
-0.6364210247993469,
-0.052026569843292236,
0.334467351436615,
-0.8643367290496826,
-0.11961258202791214,
0.45353224873542786,
0.48247456550598145,
0.17345628142356873,
0.6796059012413025,
-0.3809172213077545,
0.5497379302978516,
0.13524354994297028,
-0.3893899917602539,
0.45022517442703247,
-0.03641168400645256,
-0.1564486026763916,
0.29689422249794006,
0.6069054007530212,
0.36804866790771484,
0.33407512307167053,
-0.3027425706386566,
-0.4352061152458191,
0.01353781670331955,
-0.12174513190984726,
-0.7190970182418823,
-0.35964837670326233,
-0.05679755285382271,
-0.3070281147956848,
-0.20731188356876373,
0.14117109775543213,
-0.7889062762260437,
-0.21669147908687592,
-0.37665754556655884,
0.30007204413414,
-0.3425893485546112,
-0.6335384845733643,
0.1208813488483429,
-0.034492697566747665,
0.07287925481796265,
0.1214655190706253,
-0.877463161945343,
0.44124871492385864,
0.6102903485298157,
0.5444815754890442,
-0.1578817516565323,
-0.1324756145477295,
-0.13076674938201904,
0.21334509551525116,
-0.322359174489975,
0.6335793733596802,
-0.6726131439208984,
-0.15925532579421997,
-0.19077135622501373,
0.2950291633605957,
0.010470259934663773,
-0.7941931486129761,
0.5949515104293823,
-0.4825591742992401,
0.5386110544204712,
-0.10553950816392899,
-0.7217398881912231,
-0.22204948961734772,
0.14293010532855988,
-1.0940001010894775,
0.9370251297950745,
0.16876740753650665,
-1.1186555624008179,
0.39007851481437683,
-0.7528771758079529,
-0.7786720991134644,
0.11734750121831894,
-0.26590466499328613,
-0.289826363325119,
0.15837952494621277,
0.7732011675834656,
0.46803537011146545,
0.11282748728990555,
0.38604745268821716,
0.1977711021900177,
-0.2507842183113098,
0.01822916977107525,
-0.2653765082359314,
0.828762412071228,
0.070986308157444,
-0.3371911942958832,
-0.3941439390182495,
-1.093432068824768,
-0.38372236490249634,
0.09444227814674377,
-0.5024570226669312,
-0.5537288188934326,
0.008241425268352032,
-0.013100344687700272,
0.2211723029613495,
0.1719352900981903,
-0.38325491547584534,
0.1389649659395218,
-0.5499628782272339,
0.36848971247673035,
0.3691880404949188,
0.469938725233078,
0.545580267906189,
-0.00526948319748044,
0.48060256242752075,
0.1413828283548355,
-0.3074802756309509,
-0.37237635254859924,
-0.4674166738986969,
-0.781542956829071,
-0.012471658177673817,
0.6679137349128723,
0.4358479976654053,
-0.8211743235588074,
0.30698108673095703,
-0.3945354223251343,
-0.30472293496131897,
-0.8363465070724487,
-0.08326462656259537,
0.1589290201663971,
0.5847625136375427,
0.4968496263027191,
-0.07789327204227448,
-1.155165195465088,
-1.010372519493103,
-0.31237179040908813,
0.04975255951285362,
0.03977682441473007,
0.303811639547348,
0.3843696415424347,
-0.20455124974250793,
0.9991226196289062,
-0.08390102535486221,
-0.26811543107032776,
-0.3307711184024811,
0.17380250990390778,
0.37582170963287354,
0.37248265743255615,
0.35210248827934265,
-0.9119114875793457,
-0.2400577813386917,
0.029315922409296036,
-0.6888439059257507,
-0.2565203905105591,
-0.17501474916934967,
0.01004794705659151,
0.6607600450515747,
0.49023371934890747,
-0.7810497879981995,
0.23075711727142334,
0.5510721802711487,
-0.08697724342346191,
0.5740384459495544,
0.1417505294084549,
0.15594734251499176,
-1.3374556303024292,
0.015690477564930916,
0.0739564597606659,
-0.18380866944789886,
-0.34818899631500244,
0.11633947491645813,
0.030194519087672234,
0.06887128949165344,
-0.3430982232093811,
0.5588346719741821,
-0.6267197132110596,
0.027528934180736542,
-0.27963337302207947,
0.12869133055210114,
-0.049910202622413635,
0.19308777153491974,
0.4003128707408905,
0.6954742670059204,
0.3065488636493683,
-0.8120991587638855,
0.306406170129776,
0.2053927630186081,
-0.25909674167633057,
0.5314323902130127,
-0.41549381613731384,
0.06063264235854149,
-0.3512137830257416,
-0.1552436500787735,
-0.5169235467910767,
-0.39895397424697876,
0.4178665280342102,
-0.5107221603393555,
0.41994911432266235,
-0.3253375291824341,
-0.4419645369052887,
0.05534139648079872,
0.092036671936512,
-0.06833923608064651,
0.18372096121311188,
-0.49992960691452026,
0.49510958790779114,
0.6834514141082764,
-0.3319230079650879,
-0.9499855637550354,
-0.5709206461906433,
0.44331756234169006,
-0.3016357123851776,
-0.4327716529369354,
0.3864583969116211,
0.4023911952972412,
-0.3837582468986511,
0.4781886041164398,
-0.3784821331501007,
-0.30100539326667786,
0.12663260102272034,
0.23065145313739777,
0.20101408660411835,
-0.5387554168701172,
0.19183427095413208,
0.24516020715236664,
-0.3123766779899597,
0.2458648681640625,
0.20530949532985687,
0.3130831718444824,
0.060112666338682175,
0.08954721689224243,
-0.36528852581977844,
0.24966168403625488,
0.32379069924354553,
-0.22543491423130035,
0.6571472883224487,
0.4706035852432251,
-0.9150378704071045,
0.0315866656601429,
-0.42890986800193787,
-0.03609630465507507,
-0.4014509320259094,
0.5930319428443909,
-0.5985646843910217,
-0.7467858791351318,
0.2487715780735016,
0.008405951783061028,
0.3053053021430969,
0.772845447063446,
0.19409897923469543,
-0.02442818693816662,
0.8725110292434692,
0.636295735836029,
-0.3167179822921753,
0.05809606611728668,
0.09887968003749847,
0.2646956443786621,
-0.5699332356452942,
-0.2975180149078369,
-0.40896594524383545,
-0.26730871200561523,
-0.6007277965545654,
0.26310959458351135,
-0.2194908708333969,
0.22076639533042908,
0.20062071084976196,
0.7300387620925903,
-0.509201169013977,
0.4774066209793091,
0.14441420137882233,
-0.1899075210094452,
0.572839081287384,
0.017146116122603416,
0.20339316129684448,
-0.5678153038024902,
-0.3662436902523041,
-0.8261070847511292,
0.839974045753479,
0.23231808841228485,
0.5435210466384888,
0.07595812529325485,
0.8006702065467834,
0.0909234955906868,
0.21978946030139923,
-0.5813164710998535,
0.6609069108963013,
0.0014482417609542608,
-0.4836690127849579,
-0.11233163625001907,
-0.6285114288330078,
-1.221265435218811,
0.11882682889699936,
-0.3044872283935547,
-0.4369543492794037,
-0.02039819024503231,
-0.26166832447052,
-0.09879973530769348,
0.17189912497997284,
-0.5956271886825562,
0.5596113801002502,
0.020454004406929016,
0.23160359263420105,
-0.0037048582453280687,
-0.4732635021209717,
0.287786602973938,
-0.027393002063035965,
0.22079932689666748,
-0.24200275540351868,
-0.19940033555030823,
1.0533708333969116,
-0.06147473677992821,
0.2258123904466629,
-0.19474349915981293,
0.01915697380900383,
0.043998800218105316,
-0.016272345557808876,
0.29004770517349243,
0.3648032546043396,
-0.058978915214538574,
0.26009002327919006,
-0.038136448711156845,
-0.17202268540859222,
-0.4526623487472534,
0.5073006749153137,
-0.5650466084480286,
-0.351972371339798,
-0.2907496392726898,
-0.4163188338279724,
-0.13641120493412018,
0.17964604496955872,
0.30602145195007324,
0.32452863454818726,
-0.11221743375062943,
0.16414763033390045,
0.41643771529197693,
0.020107559859752655,
0.5482664108276367,
0.432394415140152,
-0.36167284846305847,
-0.39838969707489014,
0.7541736960411072,
0.3413297235965729,
-0.29877644777297974,
0.4870701730251312,
-0.29524484276771545,
-0.17412549257278442,
-0.5323336124420166,
-0.45832639932632446,
0.2543613612651825,
-0.4895295798778534,
-0.30269503593444824,
-0.7838480472564697,
-0.4807870388031006,
-0.37327563762664795,
0.10346722602844238,
-0.4288538992404938,
-0.6021015048027039,
-0.4056454002857208,
-0.22302232682704926,
0.2146827131509781,
0.8213053345680237,
0.08988389372825623,
0.08418084681034088,
-0.8001282811164856,
0.31591203808784485,
-0.10606544464826584,
-0.011220039799809456,
-0.38475432991981506,
-0.49884623289108276,
-0.2888060510158539,
-0.004165982361882925,
0.10546121001243591,
-1.1465637683868408,
0.5601787567138672,
0.11840929090976715,
0.466910183429718,
0.428396075963974,
-0.060069065541028976,
0.8254326581954956,
-0.44361159205436707,
0.5753039717674255,
-0.29379943013191223,
-0.7795149087905884,
0.7737787961959839,
-0.11801456660032272,
-0.17626170814037323,
0.5486536026000977,
0.6078832745552063,
-0.7253292202949524,
-0.32688450813293457,
-0.824018120765686,
-0.98615962266922,
0.536291241645813,
0.26487499475479126,
0.09416937083005905,
-0.18274089694023132,
0.6869657039642334,
0.3373337984085083,
0.2993617653846741,
-0.7181177139282227,
-0.4325931668281555,
0.25410130620002747,
-0.10312028974294662,
0.20064209401607513,
-0.3025785982608795,
0.3700524866580963,
-0.26277410984039307,
1.0612472295761108,
0.3810383677482605,
-0.02643899992108345,
0.22725464403629303,
-0.5660408139228821,
0.015398778021335602,
0.3126718997955322,
0.1482597291469574,
0.7028771638870239,
-0.2250039130449295,
0.14923760294914246,
0.14704875648021698,
-0.5696374773979187,
-0.02843763306736946,
0.46947386860847473,
-0.2967973053455353,
0.767785370349884,
0.19116328656673431,
0.5405639410018921,
0.34503039717674255,
-0.6830695271492004,
0.33114689588546753,
-0.13152775168418884,
-0.0867849588394165,
-0.36382755637168884,
-0.03739726170897484,
0.14947673678398132,
0.12582935392856598,
0.48456570506095886,
0.1269480586051941,
0.12339968979358673,
-0.15129511058330536,
0.5636674761772156,
0.07808385789394379,
-0.13689909875392914,
-0.38343051075935364,
0.5011305809020996,
0.2238439917564392,
-0.49871012568473816,
0.7300496101379395,
-0.666608452796936,
-0.31067854166030884,
0.48948949575424194,
0.5495661497116089,
0.44596773386001587,
-0.32241564989089966,
0.19940288364887238,
0.6181498169898987,
0.5615139007568359,
-0.282977432012558,
0.20445750653743744,
0.25264406204223633,
-0.7748585939407349,
-0.661641001701355,
-0.4627956449985504,
-0.4560934603214264,
0.6123530864715576,
-0.8352598547935486,
0.5522813200950623,
-0.29800471663475037,
0.06418786197900772,
0.1360078603029251,
0.42844268679618835,
-0.4717664122581482,
0.18315111100673676,
0.23808902502059937,
0.9520065188407898,
-0.7810871005058289,
0.5553407669067383,
1.0517998933792114,
-0.30385029315948486,
-0.7655820250511169,
-0.09261604398488998,
-0.27212148904800415,
-0.5384588837623596,
0.4758538007736206,
0.5082083940505981,
0.3340824544429779,
0.12250341475009918,
-0.21182973682880402,
-0.8670988082885742,
0.8057295083999634,
0.5254009366035461,
-0.598977267742157,
-0.07371431589126587,
0.2037903517484665,
0.4293166399002075,
-0.4185916483402252,
0.050177883356809616,
0.6621102094650269,
0.4405810832977295,
-0.4575832188129425,
-0.7951555848121643,
0.01621134579181671,
-0.42239776253700256,
-0.22093836963176727,
0.4648228585720062,
0.005087524652481079,
0.6738533973693848,
-0.109791599214077,
-0.6067382097244263,
0.061513520777225494,
0.7912982106208801,
0.08698605000972748,
0.2911304235458374,
0.38215187191963196,
0.7829881906509399,
0.8472223281860352,
-0.14250318706035614,
0.5932688117027283,
-0.21338994801044464,
0.4270622432231903,
1.2345961332321167,
-0.08477608859539032,
0.9417586922645569,
0.5587084293365479,
-0.20122823119163513,
0.5022984743118286,
0.611255943775177,
-0.042656030505895615,
0.5162161588668823,
-0.04063499718904495,
-0.2567407190799713,
0.1146441251039505,
-0.19455605745315552,
-0.36205264925956726,
0.4784022867679596,
0.48522114753723145,
-0.5315362215042114,
-0.4472607970237732,
-0.08971832692623138,
0.35576850175857544,
-0.04314792528748512,
-0.3905990421772003,
0.6715924143791199,
-0.032851483672857285,
-0.4852427840232849,
0.08208002150058746,
0.19663485884666443,
0.8997300863265991,
-0.24834418296813965,
-0.12240593880414963,
-0.15993979573249817,
-0.06675859540700912,
-0.48636651039123535,
-0.6449295878410339,
0.4898218810558319,
0.0005351550062187016,
-0.05889062583446503,
0.20815184712409973,
0.9353662729263306,
-0.5020345449447632,
-0.4576510488986969,
-0.02844538539648056,
0.7104658484458923,
0.39636141061782837,
-0.2542516589164734,
-0.5310171246528625,
-0.2757931649684906,
-0.03076929971575737,
-0.42790767550468445,
0.14552290737628937,
0.5325857400894165,
0.13188432157039642,
0.35239407420158386,
0.555902898311615,
0.29393914341926575,
-0.0324157290160656,
0.0007668515318073332,
0.4627676010131836,
-0.7641410827636719,
-0.28682151436805725,
-0.9905256032943726,
0.3042733073234558,
-0.30032193660736084,
-0.5149287581443787,
0.7413467764854431,
0.7935147285461426,
1.0617449283599854,
0.13202832639217377,
0.7052369117736816,
-0.07951340824365616,
0.700510561466217,
-0.42810720205307007,
0.594638466835022,
-0.2130901962518692,
0.2108849734067917,
-0.174905925989151,
-1.0715513229370117,
-0.4594026803970337,
0.8062804937362671,
-0.016139961779117584,
-0.18075798451900482,
0.6467247605323792,
0.8323295712471008,
-0.048645686358213425,
0.25190338492393494,
0.07328113913536072,
0.11723226308822632,
0.03384628891944885,
0.4839256703853607,
0.9069190621376038,
-0.634548544883728,
0.6365758180618286,
-0.5901795029640198,
0.2509445548057556,
-0.04866671562194824,
-0.8493675589561462,
-0.8349665403366089,
-0.6034579277038574,
-0.5083578824996948,
-0.34269052743911743,
0.3139503598213196,
1.1052196025848389,
0.45490601658821106,
-0.7914695143699646,
0.14106325805187225,
-0.2518700063228607,
0.11577996611595154,
-0.15847764909267426,
-0.33689433336257935,
0.4490557909011841,
-0.3980167806148529,
-0.8101025223731995,
0.22408877313137054,
0.33609193563461304,
-0.0678633376955986,
-0.023566117510199547,
-0.1268213838338852,
-0.09133512526750565,
-0.2780277729034424,
0.4353167414665222,
0.26196086406707764,
-0.597149670124054,
-0.14234928786754608,
-0.0671679675579071,
-0.2499399036169052,
0.262144535779953,
0.5678820610046387,
-0.8706759810447693,
0.07109211385250092,
0.14341437816619873,
0.9972772598266602,
0.060169100761413574,
-0.28229355812072754,
0.21733686327934265,
-0.9762372970581055,
0.020146626979112625,
0.2894991934299469,
0.6129082441329956,
0.5579441785812378,
-0.4870370328426361,
0.7962730526924133,
0.33526819944381714,
-0.4206504225730896,
-0.858955979347229,
0.08987048268318176,
-0.8253117799758911,
-0.08337199687957764,
1.233020544052124,
-0.028919756412506104,
-0.10399770736694336,
-0.38496077060699463,
-0.3659587502479553,
0.2791749835014343,
-0.5395464897155762,
0.7636493444442749,
0.821711003780365,
-0.09426500648260117,
-0.3418219983577728,
-0.5983942151069641,
0.46655693650245667,
0.34014269709587097,
-0.8896995186805725,
-0.09951390326023102,
0.3175511062145233,
0.3651386499404907,
0.14570969343185425,
0.5744766592979431,
-0.21422645449638367,
0.27472159266471863,
-0.13005156815052032,
-0.09188099950551987,
-0.131719172000885,
-0.22442805767059326,
-0.4411429464817047,
0.11470288783311844,
-0.09813649207353592,
-0.24290205538272858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14499v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14499v1
|
"My Answer is C": First-Token Probabilities Do Not Match Text Answers in Instruction-Tuned Language Models
| 2024-02-22T12:47:33 | 2024-02-22T12:47:33 |
Xinpeng Wang, Bolei Ma, Chengzhi Hu, Leon Weber-Genzel, Paul Röttger, Frauke Kreuter, Dirk Hovy, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The open-ended nature of language generation makes the evaluation of
autoregressive large language models (LLMs) challenging. One common evaluation
approach uses multiple-choice questions (MCQ) to limit the response space. The
model is then evaluated by ranking the candidate answers by the log probability
of the first token prediction. However, first-tokens may not consistently
reflect the final response output, due to model's diverse response styles such
as starting with "Sure" or refusing to answer. Consequently, MCQ evaluation is
not indicative of model behaviour when interacting with users. But by how much?
We evaluate how aligned first-token evaluation is with the text output along
several dimensions, namely final option choice, refusal rate, choice
distribution and robustness under prompt perturbation. Our results show that
the two approaches are severely misaligned on all dimensions, reaching mismatch
rates over 60%. Models heavily fine-tuned on conversational or safety data are
especially impacted. Crucially, models remain misaligned even when we
increasingly constrain prompts, i.e., force them to start with an option letter
or example template. Our findings i) underscore the importance of inspecting
the text output, too and ii) caution against relying solely on first-token
evaluation.
|
[
-0.2884112298488617,
-0.9533142447471619,
0.6476917266845703,
0.029994862154126167,
-0.2524353265762329,
0.11733600497245789,
-0.035968802869319916,
-0.24250179529190063,
-0.02618304081261158,
0.422383189201355,
-0.7506453394889832,
-0.2840908467769623,
-0.49663761258125305,
0.03645041212439537,
-0.30433598160743713,
1.0495976209640503,
0.17215898633003235,
0.027738472446799278,
-0.5437330007553101,
-0.02155337668955326,
-0.29096823930740356,
-0.853005588054657,
-0.92318195104599,
-0.06691723316907883,
0.5976483225822449,
0.5425950288772583,
1.0463582277297974,
0.8885172009468079,
0.5831785202026367,
0.27063897252082825,
-0.051263608038425446,
-0.0022883224301040173,
-0.3283877670764923,
-0.09601535648107529,
0.13130047917366028,
-0.2668509781360626,
-0.27423739433288574,
0.20462220907211304,
0.4471515417098999,
0.6342182755470276,
0.0019164731493219733,
0.38137680292129517,
0.02108975313603878,
0.5750348567962646,
-0.6517447829246521,
-0.16732929646968842,
-0.7525204420089722,
-0.12593908607959747,
-0.11060383915901184,
-0.17681728303432465,
-0.6263189911842346,
-0.3793790936470032,
0.0937674343585968,
-0.18846185505390167,
-0.050936825573444366,
0.3098544478416443,
0.5738384127616882,
0.32472294569015503,
-0.5600147247314453,
-0.5839285254478455,
-0.589028000831604,
0.7116889953613281,
-0.7901331186294556,
0.14144366979599,
0.3233047127723694,
0.21786972880363464,
-0.239410400390625,
-0.4817951023578644,
-0.6542447805404663,
-0.45357826352119446,
0.03925921395421028,
-0.015615158714354038,
-0.17226020991802216,
0.2151208221912384,
0.21401375532150269,
0.20474396646022797,
-0.6589791774749756,
0.563358724117279,
-0.3327043354511261,
-0.417846143245697,
0.5020338296890259,
0.41643965244293213,
0.11325889080762863,
-0.08698714524507523,
-0.6269360780715942,
-0.23910114169120789,
-0.5225393772125244,
0.3660038709640503,
0.8823798894882202,
0.5779575109481812,
-0.018252363428473473,
0.9000788927078247,
0.15533952414989471,
0.9850318431854248,
0.23849259316921234,
-0.11920714378356934,
-0.1426706612110138,
-0.45717647671699524,
-0.2427264004945755,
0.0751524269580841,
1.0914500951766968,
0.27717307209968567,
0.341412216424942,
0.12554189562797546,
0.02250567637383938,
-0.17389613389968872,
0.22214269638061523,
-0.6774222254753113,
-0.010455627925693989,
0.43974703550338745,
-0.3860112726688385,
-0.4214823246002197,
0.07756231725215912,
-0.5041991472244263,
-0.17805902659893036,
-0.06971756368875504,
0.32881173491477966,
-0.18995404243469238,
-0.13530319929122925,
0.08494292199611664,
0.22599485516548157,
0.23602718114852905,
-0.012480348348617554,
-0.99198979139328,
0.3250158727169037,
0.6593220829963684,
0.5592767000198364,
-0.36496350169181824,
-0.18255239725112915,
-0.6200410723686218,
-0.2997272312641144,
-0.4202636778354645,
0.5547998547554016,
-0.5947468280792236,
-0.36343374848365784,
-0.07924004644155502,
-0.045250214636325836,
-0.2302781492471695,
-0.4024112820625305,
0.5703197717666626,
-0.416525274515152,
0.5016729235649109,
-0.2768058776855469,
-0.4904334843158722,
0.31041762232780457,
-0.005714807193726301,
-0.518568754196167,
0.8884352445602417,
0.06316973268985748,
-1.0247323513031006,
0.4385007321834564,
-0.28069406747817993,
-0.2447340488433838,
-0.2241382896900177,
-0.27867382764816284,
-0.2905634343624115,
0.09200212359428406,
0.0700160339474678,
0.2531137764453888,
-0.11740778386592865,
0.2584182024002075,
-0.5740929841995239,
-0.2765723764896393,
0.7485907077789307,
-1.005348801612854,
0.8181256055831909,
0.19658271968364716,
-0.004405554849654436,
0.05004490166902542,
-0.7249789834022522,
0.3655512034893036,
-0.055465295910835266,
-0.6910561919212341,
-0.06603935360908508,
-0.04733198881149292,
0.06970184296369553,
0.5341358780860901,
0.3397983908653259,
-0.5436546206474304,
0.2018284946680069,
-0.5332253575325012,
0.1945338249206543,
1.0665894746780396,
-0.14652496576309204,
0.3370634913444519,
-0.49556171894073486,
0.8062756657600403,
0.26081717014312744,
0.11091922223567963,
-0.11238222569227219,
-0.49745431542396545,
-0.4521573781967163,
0.009237436577677727,
0.3157787621021271,
0.5888169407844543,
-0.5260851383209229,
0.24521343410015106,
-0.11223281919956207,
-0.47911009192466736,
-0.5955809950828552,
-0.0772998109459877,
0.6360437870025635,
0.526235818862915,
0.051540300250053406,
-0.15200120210647583,
-0.43095624446868896,
-1.1585988998413086,
-0.4934543967247009,
-0.6137862801551819,
0.14258286356925964,
0.31985893845558167,
0.24939168989658356,
0.1812940388917923,
0.9639071226119995,
-0.2933526039123535,
0.3844853937625885,
-0.05846410244703293,
-0.03247842192649841,
0.20677810907363892,
0.47810983657836914,
0.48773691058158875,
-0.5784159302711487,
-0.35985735058784485,
-0.24077476561069489,
-0.2980824112892151,
-0.05856114625930786,
-0.0648803561925888,
-0.18710333108901978,
0.5105027556419373,
0.43378353118896484,
-0.545792818069458,
0.2667323648929596,
0.6796588897705078,
-0.46239376068115234,
0.6337422728538513,
-0.10431820899248123,
0.12688367068767548,
-1.0778098106384277,
0.0030796395149081945,
-0.20413821935653687,
-0.1120612621307373,
-0.6101982593536377,
-0.1038070023059845,
-0.018453143537044525,
0.041950471699237823,
-0.569911003112793,
0.84357088804245,
-0.15799769759178162,
-0.05158204585313797,
-0.16937345266342163,
0.2833620011806488,
-0.16375096142292023,
0.2697804868221283,
-0.3880365788936615,
1.0893337726593018,
0.22395727038383484,
-0.8630034327507019,
-0.06579668074846268,
0.2529016137123108,
-0.3163771629333496,
0.2805100679397583,
-0.5482208728790283,
0.38049420714378357,
-0.16656889021396637,
-0.11927708238363266,
-1.3447579145431519,
-0.27058619260787964,
0.3000166118144989,
-0.664983332157135,
0.3219369351863861,
0.13381420075893402,
-0.36519962549209595,
-0.541307806968689,
-0.17560577392578125,
0.3906871974468231,
0.27214711904525757,
-0.39655521512031555,
0.1892978549003601,
0.29830631613731384,
-0.20954002439975739,
-1.046791434288025,
-0.8164233565330505,
-0.07105381041765213,
0.010752838104963303,
-0.4992066025733948,
-0.06222965940833092,
-0.577562689781189,
-0.2869243323802948,
-0.12970221042633057,
-0.4814908802509308,
-0.047636520117521286,
0.3148479759693146,
0.03019331581890583,
0.3038870096206665,
-0.28320032358169556,
0.1429043859243393,
0.015213062055408955,
0.16304636001586914,
0.10966407507658005,
-0.13936398923397064,
0.6140440702438354,
0.06185086444020271,
-0.7083726525306702,
-0.1623382270336151,
0.23790740966796875,
0.8307839632034302,
-0.06810310482978821,
0.8179981708526611,
0.3005838096141815,
-0.29451143741607666,
0.2864473760128021,
-0.38454949855804443,
0.014038660563528538,
-0.48430708050727844,
0.48374536633491516,
-0.4750327467918396,
-0.988450288772583,
0.4161474406719208,
0.5075562000274658,
0.21404403448104858,
0.43212080001831055,
0.7397230863571167,
-0.0431254580616951,
1.4526958465576172,
0.4821867346763611,
0.14700697362422943,
0.31511735916137695,
0.38730111718177795,
0.4575485587120056,
-0.6623334288597107,
-0.1321755051612854,
-0.7867933511734009,
-0.17820274829864502,
-0.76783287525177,
-0.09519807249307632,
0.109829843044281,
0.11288392543792725,
-0.28806161880493164,
0.19354337453842163,
-0.398384690284729,
0.37247002124786377,
0.5122295022010803,
0.04036545008420944,
0.17986607551574707,
-0.03938153386116028,
-0.45179855823516846,
-0.07900073379278183,
-0.942642867565155,
-0.900004506111145,
1.2089457511901855,
0.35062453150749207,
0.6535570621490479,
0.14617735147476196,
0.7281339764595032,
0.034799959510564804,
0.3895409107208252,
-0.7555825114250183,
0.6181704998016357,
-0.19251593947410583,
-0.7587522268295288,
-0.4521266222000122,
-0.41671815514564514,
-0.9389914274215698,
0.14391997456550598,
-0.2814282178878784,
-0.7530581951141357,
-0.041740532964468,
0.29994580149650574,
-0.43538662791252136,
0.16434811055660248,
-0.6810438632965088,
0.8504323959350586,
-0.3239098787307739,
-0.26092398166656494,
0.38528236746788025,
-0.5125921368598938,
0.5668877363204956,
-0.13522082567214966,
0.3980226516723633,
-0.01993059366941452,
-0.01691710203886032,
0.6494531035423279,
-0.3754328489303589,
0.6207334995269775,
-0.0423065610229969,
-0.20009085536003113,
0.45674166083335876,
0.16441217064857483,
0.2946998178958893,
-0.029147561639547348,
-0.18306800723075867,
-0.3863683342933655,
0.20390090346336365,
-0.4319804906845093,
-0.5017712116241455,
0.6531355977058411,
-0.6515248417854309,
-0.8326499462127686,
-0.35799574851989746,
-0.30644500255584717,
-0.17271050810813904,
0.10568278282880783,
0.4934671223163605,
0.541891872882843,
-0.3339563310146332,
0.10891927778720856,
0.44497764110565186,
-0.2908063530921936,
0.6103954315185547,
0.3165849447250366,
-0.3022790253162384,
-0.39302757382392883,
0.61441969871521,
0.101774662733078,
0.6106555461883545,
0.1662120372056961,
0.17750117182731628,
-0.4062587320804596,
-0.3995232582092285,
-0.5836575031280518,
0.029010049998760223,
-0.9400150775909424,
-0.13343235850334167,
-0.7247859835624695,
-0.19133248925209045,
-0.35436004400253296,
-0.06100723519921303,
-0.08361257612705231,
-0.5118871331214905,
-0.4608039855957031,
-0.24361102283000946,
-0.13791315257549286,
0.6100561022758484,
0.22072841227054596,
0.33150923252105713,
-0.6696390509605408,
0.00699714245274663,
0.26087096333503723,
0.3333470821380615,
0.0036542133893817663,
-0.5812509059906006,
-0.21885082125663757,
0.25254160165786743,
-0.32257741689682007,
-1.010401725769043,
-0.0777026116847992,
0.1328236311674118,
0.668982744216919,
0.36012738943099976,
0.06171427667140961,
0.5184552669525146,
-0.5256718397140503,
0.8830274343490601,
0.14670975506305695,
-0.7737475633621216,
0.2954522371292114,
-0.09809916466474533,
0.4333789348602295,
0.7755774259567261,
0.31176555156707764,
-0.2923957407474518,
-0.6327982544898987,
-0.6782245635986328,
-0.6789566874504089,
0.6871528625488281,
-0.004016518592834473,
0.42229539155960083,
-0.6062402725219727,
0.3468320667743683,
0.15751153230667114,
0.3099856674671173,
-0.879273533821106,
-0.3564739525318146,
0.05537743493914604,
-0.4805934727191925,
-0.08751001954078674,
-0.3406132161617279,
0.1561582237482071,
0.08185816556215286,
0.5203812718391418,
-0.29619693756103516,
0.2764051556587219,
0.15359634160995483,
0.031661681830883026,
-0.31526634097099304,
0.37827354669570923,
0.8193713426589966,
0.6638848185539246,
0.026548363268375397,
-0.07042327523231506,
-0.045049071311950684,
-0.4788093566894531,
0.24530598521232605,
-0.24929513037204742,
-0.08013740181922913,
-0.034415606409311295,
0.35729873180389404,
0.819117546081543,
0.19215112924575806,
-0.6080570220947266,
0.6923331022262573,
-0.2310696691274643,
-0.2292030155658722,
-0.14382104575634003,
0.2763329744338989,
-0.0890585333108902,
-0.04466044157743454,
0.3482987880706787,
0.10909780859947205,
-0.08622284978628159,
-0.6322888135910034,
0.1281883865594864,
0.8515246510505676,
-0.3929283916950226,
-0.10797453671693802,
0.8114386796951294,
-0.13727924227714539,
-0.7098511457443237,
0.5740499496459961,
-0.08623608201742172,
-0.4577060341835022,
0.9057085514068604,
0.6283409595489502,
0.8830211162567139,
-0.16197218000888824,
0.24122312664985657,
0.5479609966278076,
0.5509558916091919,
0.045491356402635574,
0.4602607190608978,
0.23829028010368347,
-0.566357433795929,
-0.4086550772190094,
-0.713606595993042,
-0.5051324367523193,
0.19850532710552216,
-0.6239067912101746,
0.3082021176815033,
-0.45342716574668884,
-0.41975653171539307,
-0.12919287383556366,
-0.12347692996263504,
-0.8044590950012207,
0.3355633020401001,
0.05483606085181236,
1.0233978033065796,
-0.8272804617881775,
0.43954598903656006,
0.6230767369270325,
-0.2867429852485657,
-0.8024781346321106,
0.13402105867862701,
-0.2756422758102417,
-0.8083038330078125,
0.4094806909561157,
0.24053862690925598,
-0.11205049604177475,
0.04586934670805931,
-0.8466075658798218,
-0.9744024276733398,
0.7679643630981445,
0.4223499894142151,
-0.5373419523239136,
0.01183858048170805,
0.24167272448539734,
0.5269044637680054,
-0.5679358839988708,
0.4302787780761719,
0.4454430937767029,
0.4288926124572754,
-0.0204591304063797,
-0.8487509489059448,
-0.01035649236291647,
0.06217053905129433,
-0.0813547819852829,
0.1340838372707367,
-0.6091519594192505,
0.8574830889701843,
-0.5041966438293457,
-0.44207870960235596,
0.2368043214082718,
0.4211095869541168,
0.40184536576271057,
0.28468701243400574,
0.4732949435710907,
0.4149550199508667,
0.7199075222015381,
-0.11399984359741211,
1.0983086824417114,
-0.44111812114715576,
0.212691530585289,
1.1449490785598755,
-0.15916189551353455,
0.9702818989753723,
0.728324830532074,
-0.33958810567855835,
0.3707864582538605,
0.9667097926139832,
0.36007392406463623,
0.37827980518341064,
0.42906391620635986,
-0.08799201250076294,
-0.2902258038520813,
0.25456178188323975,
-0.09052339941263199,
0.6128789782524109,
0.15424154698848724,
-0.36494505405426025,
0.052697133272886276,
-0.14935341477394104,
-0.059852249920368195,
0.10815627872943878,
-0.18551689386367798,
0.7775879502296448,
-0.06732344627380371,
-0.89688640832901,
0.5023865699768066,
0.019056664779782295,
0.4169951379299164,
-0.28990262746810913,
0.1690397411584854,
-0.2507246732711792,
-0.2514282763004303,
-0.16827896237373352,
-0.8140924572944641,
0.17110292613506317,
0.016796352341771126,
-0.27886486053466797,
0.07260068506002426,
0.45721498131752014,
-0.366968035697937,
-0.49237897992134094,
-0.10812791436910629,
0.7121590971946716,
0.1005704328417778,
0.34643489122390747,
-0.5646654963493347,
-0.17528784275054932,
0.026302367448806763,
-0.4464235305786133,
0.40428388118743896,
0.35444802045822144,
0.05826137587428093,
0.6896621584892273,
0.7444957494735718,
-0.20293091237545013,
0.3251948356628418,
-0.2601962089538574,
0.625514030456543,
-0.32677358388900757,
-0.2734607458114624,
-1.1444859504699707,
0.6802420020103455,
0.1669302135705948,
-0.6474602222442627,
0.4380808472633362,
0.5525624752044678,
0.8491079807281494,
0.006407510954886675,
0.7591727375984192,
0.20775969326496124,
0.31901776790618896,
-0.6999518871307373,
0.4016742706298828,
-0.4272680878639221,
0.34849125146865845,
-0.16539093852043152,
-0.9469054341316223,
0.04773249849677086,
0.3077797591686249,
-0.1477472186088562,
0.26680025458335876,
0.7679471373558044,
0.6240565776824951,
-0.03808354586362839,
-0.23313355445861816,
0.38047632575035095,
0.08572036027908325,
0.11985720694065094,
0.4188813865184784,
0.7590267658233643,
-0.4428839087486267,
0.6888365149497986,
0.11098750680685043,
-0.16517573595046997,
-0.156503826379776,
-0.9606285095214844,
-0.7837305068969727,
-0.4862961769104004,
-0.21566759049892426,
-0.41436558961868286,
-0.10848505049943924,
1.0579028129577637,
0.2728709876537323,
-0.7027066349983215,
-0.0912514328956604,
-0.007389191072434187,
0.1859070211648941,
0.1262342631816864,
-0.2319796085357666,
0.12730185687541962,
-0.3696131706237793,
-0.6098340749740601,
0.21266214549541473,
0.16458453238010406,
0.3202243149280548,
-0.3607245087623596,
0.025710411369800568,
-0.13022089004516602,
0.448638916015625,
0.2668561339378357,
0.23554778099060059,
-0.849054217338562,
-0.5751368999481201,
0.41099393367767334,
-0.4732879400253296,
0.03970967233181,
0.5193816423416138,
-0.6762545108795166,
0.44339337944984436,
0.19743040204048157,
0.7522748112678528,
0.01276780292391777,
0.12443497776985168,
0.510468602180481,
-0.8407166004180908,
-0.10783851146697998,
0.1679498553276062,
0.14877250790596008,
0.30542463064193726,
-0.5015771389007568,
0.08292903006076813,
-0.27568235993385315,
-0.755901575088501,
-0.9565179347991943,
0.4949439465999603,
-0.7639932632446289,
-0.153867706656456,
1.0467265844345093,
0.0016637477092444897,
-0.15032418072223663,
0.06420963257551193,
-0.23237548768520355,
0.16389885544776917,
-0.02047935128211975,
0.6031879782676697,
1.2642619609832764,
-0.06425479054450989,
-0.10305237025022507,
-0.6620567440986633,
0.40963414311408997,
0.40251028537750244,
-0.52378249168396,
0.15724584460258484,
0.388855516910553,
0.16766835749149323,
-0.006661453749984503,
0.8695160150527954,
0.05233936011791229,
0.26758939027786255,
-0.1344592422246933,
-0.2662878632545471,
-0.017131231725215912,
-0.2691003382205963,
-0.7075269222259521,
0.0355459600687027,
0.5064042806625366,
-0.2213590145111084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14494v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14494v3
|
Noise-BERT: A Unified Perturbation-Robust Framework with Noise Alignment Pre-training for Noisy Slot Filling Task
| 2024-02-22T12:39:50 | 2024-03-06T07:17:03 |
Jinxu Zhao, Guanting Dong, Yueyan Qiu, Tingfeng Hui, Xiaoshuai Song, Daichi Guo, Weiran Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In a realistic dialogue system, the input information from users is often
subject to various types of input perturbations, which affects the slot-filling
task. Although rule-based data augmentation methods have achieved satisfactory
results, they fail to exhibit the desired generalization when faced with
unknown noise disturbances. In this study, we address the challenges posed by
input perturbations in slot filling by proposing Noise-BERT, a unified
Perturbation-Robust Framework with Noise Alignment Pre-training. Our framework
incorporates two Noise Alignment Pre-training tasks: Slot Masked Prediction and
Sentence Noisiness Discrimination, aiming to guide the pre-trained language
model in capturing accurate slot information and noise distribution. During
fine-tuning, we employ a contrastive learning loss to enhance the semantic
representation of entities and labels. Additionally, we introduce an
adversarial attack training strategy to improve the model's robustness.
Experimental results demonstrate the superiority of our proposed approach over
state-of-the-art models, and further analysis confirms its effectiveness and
generalization ability.
|
[
-0.3858543932437897,
-1.022057056427002,
0.4577632546424866,
0.11875416338443756,
-0.39351916313171387,
-0.1844184845685959,
-0.22022396326065063,
-0.2726612687110901,
0.06717207282781601,
0.5620152354240417,
-0.9188987016677856,
-0.3139331340789795,
-0.48650121688842773,
-0.3040919303894043,
-0.4625512659549713,
0.886809229850769,
0.39885568618774414,
0.20660777390003204,
-0.11377247422933578,
0.3770814836025238,
-0.3854410946369171,
-0.5412968993186951,
-0.2879835367202759,
-0.036655157804489136,
0.4671921730041504,
0.029174190014600754,
0.945395290851593,
0.29689815640449524,
0.3316445052623749,
0.3139270544052124,
-0.14647255837917328,
-0.14757362008094788,
-0.3723408281803131,
0.41009125113487244,
0.18075858056545258,
-0.1457768827676773,
-0.3615431487560272,
-0.17007969319820404,
0.5028247833251953,
0.7431800365447998,
-0.12624670565128326,
-0.34196195006370544,
0.4123847484588623,
0.08075018972158432,
-0.49376294016838074,
0.06636244058609009,
-0.9014241695404053,
0.004772284533828497,
-0.3785037696361542,
0.11985642462968826,
0.017857955768704414,
-0.17794771492481232,
0.28299468755722046,
-0.7127931118011475,
0.14963188767433167,
-0.3166333734989166,
1.3111653327941895,
0.7854976654052734,
0.157578706741333,
-0.06069537624716759,
-0.7740565538406372,
0.865709125995636,
-0.8126019239425659,
0.4034240245819092,
0.306657075881958,
-0.118044912815094,
-0.46915340423583984,
-0.44851288199424744,
-0.5757939219474792,
0.016268767416477203,
-0.029753917828202248,
0.039056889712810516,
-0.1722480207681656,
0.4675086438655853,
0.2176813781261444,
0.22316348552703857,
-0.35686802864074707,
0.26563966274261475,
0.10553686320781708,
-0.4255611002445221,
0.1173376515507698,
-0.24058875441551208,
0.26407960057258606,
0.23999911546707153,
-0.46077999472618103,
-0.2818457782268524,
-0.5389381051063538,
0.08839394152164459,
0.8169766068458557,
0.41354531049728394,
0.06668128818273544,
0.03982837498188019,
0.17730046808719635,
0.8849161267280579,
0.18852707743644714,
0.00045118911657482386,
0.2281057983636856,
-0.3523426949977875,
-0.26347988843917847,
0.011466597206890583,
0.7972726225852966,
-0.04112716391682625,
-0.027665961533784866,
-0.08371903002262115,
-0.2081102430820465,
0.0006827827310189605,
0.4347444772720337,
-0.60183185338974,
-0.2813572287559509,
0.050050269812345505,
-0.166193425655365,
-0.7302981615066528,
0.008023187518119812,
-0.802515983581543,
-0.25883203744888306,
-0.19729803502559662,
0.662958025932312,
-0.42572513222694397,
-0.22858202457427979,
0.16613851487636566,
0.19051535427570343,
0.15918835997581482,
0.6147570610046387,
-0.8679001927375793,
0.07685814052820206,
0.45241326093673706,
0.18300998210906982,
0.13846947252750397,
-0.06261709332466125,
-0.43743380904197693,
0.08683981746435165,
-0.15674465894699097,
1.0022375583648682,
-0.6722282767295837,
-0.2100362479686737,
0.14452260732650757,
-0.36567020416259766,
-0.11930401623249054,
-0.3155391812324524,
0.8117173910140991,
-0.3434927463531494,
0.3619409501552582,
-0.1455412060022354,
-0.3779577910900116,
0.12329494953155518,
0.037089332938194275,
-0.46137553453445435,
1.0695608854293823,
0.18012981116771698,
-0.7229368686676025,
0.4032941460609436,
-0.6787101626396179,
-0.5138911604881287,
-0.09918829798698425,
-0.34114086627960205,
-0.7359888553619385,
0.015763524919748306,
0.536092221736908,
0.2934828996658325,
0.20892582833766937,
0.35468873381614685,
-0.4979321360588074,
-0.5816932320594788,
0.4111116826534271,
-0.5251564383506775,
0.7970019578933716,
0.18312309682369232,
-0.17664653062820435,
0.31657716631889343,
-0.6885637640953064,
-0.14488758146762848,
-0.2195580154657364,
-0.2532576322555542,
-0.19956476986408234,
0.10653862357139587,
-0.03142698481678963,
0.008402966894209385,
0.28340262174606323,
-0.6004403829574585,
0.09717050939798355,
-0.4752558469772339,
0.33864626288414,
1.0455653667449951,
-0.18741288781166077,
0.28342941403388977,
-0.3436984419822693,
0.2530663013458252,
0.26552924513816833,
0.14349347352981567,
-0.23815181851387024,
-0.3462204039096832,
-0.5287922024726868,
-0.4863002598285675,
0.9468050599098206,
0.5880054235458374,
-0.48046404123306274,
1.0178091526031494,
0.16009551286697388,
-0.06221945211291313,
-0.685702919960022,
0.26087644696235657,
0.11017588526010513,
0.8170551061630249,
0.29576098918914795,
-0.5262448191642761,
-0.7795104384422302,
-0.5485782623291016,
0.029872123152017593,
-0.2131841480731964,
-0.3273138403892517,
0.24024975299835205,
-0.18268097937107086,
-0.5367280840873718,
0.7983500361442566,
-0.13556334376335144,
-0.6502213478088379,
-0.0026644268073141575,
0.24084317684173584,
0.11254143714904785,
0.7451890110969543,
0.3760218620300293,
-0.5283727645874023,
-0.30024048686027527,
-0.39553505182266235,
-0.36842191219329834,
-0.3608599007129669,
-0.13875016570091248,
-0.17049068212509155,
-0.01641351915895939,
0.566192626953125,
-0.4090692400932312,
0.542584240436554,
0.39076733589172363,
0.081266850233078,
0.5414983630180359,
-0.0524013489484787,
-0.24001440405845642,
-0.8970068097114563,
-0.20019984245300293,
-0.20651036500930786,
-0.1437985897064209,
-0.6687368154525757,
-0.3982776701450348,
-0.3967537581920624,
-0.3565584123134613,
-0.09809703379869461,
0.05222717300057411,
-0.14423367381095886,
0.07662898302078247,
-0.05816878005862236,
0.033884819597005844,
-0.15007884800434113,
0.6664947271347046,
0.006013262551277876,
0.6412690877914429,
0.8068563342094421,
-0.6353198289871216,
0.011019965633749962,
0.39524534344673157,
-0.41823139786720276,
0.34920623898506165,
-0.5351052284240723,
0.1539759784936905,
-0.21999278664588928,
0.21137845516204834,
-1.3979207277297974,
-0.18812091648578644,
0.21786141395568848,
-0.5843191146850586,
0.532726526260376,
-0.018424680456519127,
-0.3435121476650238,
-0.02475086599588394,
-0.18867696821689606,
0.08573150634765625,
0.49600136280059814,
-0.3354175090789795,
0.567334771156311,
0.4222038984298706,
-0.4581435024738312,
-0.9588337540626526,
-0.5161141753196716,
-0.1669703722000122,
0.011160371825098991,
-0.614205002784729,
0.4813656806945801,
-0.1766219586133957,
0.13780705630779266,
0.033755023032426834,
-0.33714759349823,
-0.2809908390045166,
0.30925923585891724,
0.16262076795101166,
0.39840346574783325,
-0.21774843335151672,
0.13925303518772125,
0.11385979503393173,
0.02555927075445652,
-0.05564694106578827,
-0.3541055917739868,
0.6684824824333191,
0.13149365782737732,
-0.30695125460624695,
-0.7030081748962402,
0.24451199173927307,
0.3176048994064331,
0.07385051995515823,
0.16848322749137878,
0.9593353271484375,
-0.2083526998758316,
0.12565040588378906,
-0.7475224137306213,
-0.2738858759403229,
-0.5072810053825378,
0.47894614934921265,
-0.23220166563987732,
-0.9571030735969543,
0.35319480299949646,
-0.11651601642370224,
0.19740095734596252,
0.15982584655284882,
0.2276502102613449,
-0.7831013202667236,
0.9887146949768066,
0.6656503081321716,
-0.29781121015548706,
0.9824022054672241,
0.24680976569652557,
0.1372513324022293,
-0.6066845059394836,
0.2379751354455948,
-0.6836133003234863,
-0.342260479927063,
-0.21598848700523376,
-0.24450261890888214,
0.24242301285266876,
0.1824922114610672,
-0.2671447992324829,
0.12820199131965637,
-0.4889254570007324,
0.20694145560264587,
0.5691767930984497,
0.010343470610678196,
-0.02885979600250721,
0.38059529662132263,
-0.37372881174087524,
-0.39631232619285583,
-0.6186314821243286,
-0.33371996879577637,
1.018267035484314,
0.31505051255226135,
1.122475504875183,
0.040933143347501755,
0.7054861783981323,
0.2811458706855774,
-0.13043147325515747,
-0.4398358464241028,
0.35262417793273926,
-0.27925166487693787,
-0.403003990650177,
-0.6385891437530518,
-0.34810271859169006,
-1.1672008037567139,
0.1731560379266739,
-0.5948752760887146,
-0.9859388470649719,
0.3505221903324127,
0.3100966513156891,
-0.6545774340629578,
0.31473952531814575,
-0.46079689264297485,
0.7334362864494324,
-0.28105705976486206,
-0.014067442156374454,
0.03760286793112755,
-0.8407382369041443,
0.08255933225154877,
-0.03477279841899872,
0.20210589468479156,
0.028079723939299583,
0.27137160301208496,
0.4360877275466919,
-0.35132622718811035,
1.0394127368927002,
-0.3568715453147888,
-0.2253279685974121,
0.1209012046456337,
-0.20708437263965607,
0.519544780254364,
-0.10433641076087952,
0.19283366203308105,
0.14936281740665436,
-0.19321832060813904,
-0.3964405953884125,
-0.6491822600364685,
0.389865905046463,
-1.0371955633163452,
-0.5697264671325684,
-0.17049939930438995,
-0.6484485864639282,
-0.5328611731529236,
0.2349483072757721,
0.3606003522872925,
0.35058537125587463,
-0.39624887704849243,
0.24960383772850037,
1.273525357246399,
-0.19974154233932495,
0.3836630880832672,
0.4514513909816742,
-0.009727987460792065,
-0.34898123145103455,
1.0092246532440186,
0.05141258239746094,
-0.011980308219790459,
0.5007166266441345,
-0.03623548895120621,
-0.41017282009124756,
-0.5274643301963806,
-0.30085211992263794,
-0.12050328403711319,
-0.0970168262720108,
-0.18050000071525574,
-0.6473835110664368,
-0.33524712920188904,
-0.6584265828132629,
-0.11837553232908249,
-0.28533586859703064,
-0.3096902668476105,
-0.34569963812828064,
0.21244190633296967,
-0.21690388023853302,
0.5769383907318115,
-0.15606136620044708,
0.5328988432884216,
-0.5525429248809814,
0.23890726268291473,
0.582134485244751,
0.5324910283088684,
-0.3214324712753296,
-0.4214925765991211,
0.030774598941206932,
0.00786623451858759,
-0.5513699054718018,
-0.7334430813789368,
0.0831163302063942,
0.158315047621727,
0.6826760172843933,
0.6864101886749268,
0.20099936425685883,
0.8071504831314087,
-0.24495789408683777,
0.7423791885375977,
0.35640645027160645,
-0.9545731544494629,
0.5580295324325562,
-0.39977526664733887,
0.28428930044174194,
0.6131567358970642,
-0.1308852881193161,
0.008125990629196167,
-0.7290920615196228,
-0.8920144438743591,
-0.7495593428611755,
0.614227831363678,
0.32019832730293274,
0.14077343046665192,
0.48040711879730225,
0.08250043541193008,
-0.06103047356009483,
0.4403282105922699,
-0.7381370663642883,
-0.028030022978782654,
-0.4880015254020691,
-0.32177960872650146,
0.1648010015487671,
-0.3977687358856201,
-0.05353406444191933,
-0.2060791552066803,
0.8043867349624634,
0.15030331909656525,
0.562985360622406,
0.24431496858596802,
-0.16666921973228455,
-0.26357895135879517,
0.555132269859314,
0.6359093189239502,
0.12522238492965698,
-0.5016984343528748,
-0.358076274394989,
-0.05579555779695511,
-0.5438153147697449,
-0.019109545275568962,
0.6803795695304871,
-0.37230944633483887,
0.25231119990348816,
-0.034999437630176544,
0.7818284034729004,
0.42062050104141235,
-0.5138300657272339,
0.6262224316596985,
-0.3013555705547333,
-0.3235611617565155,
-0.24693642556667328,
0.10899528861045837,
-0.367747038602829,
0.022729484364390373,
0.23009470105171204,
0.3349800407886505,
0.09724566340446472,
-0.21584384143352509,
0.23243074119091034,
0.6285430788993835,
-0.8169124126434326,
-0.16962093114852905,
0.6471560001373291,
0.3407411575317383,
-0.05341522768139839,
0.5364100337028503,
-0.10192270576953888,
-0.546966016292572,
0.11231232434511185,
0.41619592905044556,
0.6690515279769897,
-0.41971641778945923,
-0.028637265786528587,
0.05355485528707504,
0.33788231015205383,
0.2792392373085022,
0.31965309381484985,
-0.3146977424621582,
-1.0114290714263916,
-0.70976322889328,
-0.6560943126678467,
-0.4632352590560913,
0.7574142217636108,
-0.6114002466201782,
0.1082448735833168,
-0.5606110692024231,
-0.2785278856754303,
-0.08848273009061813,
0.00872531346976757,
-0.45438435673713684,
0.16103079915046692,
0.12786871194839478,
0.3946308195590973,
-0.5433679223060608,
1.0125954151153564,
0.8453224897384644,
-0.31050732731819153,
-0.7656604647636414,
0.32210060954093933,
-0.057504989206790924,
-0.5703628659248352,
0.23815661668777466,
-0.04379319027066231,
0.08141647279262543,
-0.21202954649925232,
-0.7328294515609741,
-0.9054609537124634,
0.46460089087486267,
0.6333625316619873,
-0.5228899717330933,
-0.09848194569349289,
-0.055351752787828445,
0.3375307619571686,
-0.26789790391921997,
-0.023847604170441628,
0.3198343515396118,
0.47566747665405273,
0.26386016607284546,
-0.7846564650535583,
-0.22549769282341003,
-0.18315520882606506,
0.08363503962755203,
0.12961120903491974,
-0.42112666368484497,
0.8594480156898499,
0.10045859962701797,
-0.21462081372737885,
0.34766024351119995,
0.7798444628715515,
-0.14661918580532074,
-0.28956255316734314,
0.9818513989448547,
0.7693716883659363,
0.9660533666610718,
-0.3743244409561157,
0.49132299423217773,
-0.2712448835372925,
0.03856434300541878,
1.2917388677597046,
-0.2745808959007263,
0.4369235038757324,
0.305443674325943,
-0.2833095192909241,
0.7276146411895752,
0.46893832087516785,
0.06677987426519394,
0.6073852181434631,
0.2814446985721588,
-0.3242255449295044,
-0.4302385151386261,
-0.04592522978782654,
-0.5366495251655579,
0.2936191260814667,
0.680206835269928,
-0.10509472340345383,
-0.2785738408565521,
-0.1452065110206604,
-0.08338931202888489,
-0.057059142738580704,
-0.0877566859126091,
0.9792574048042297,
-0.35048985481262207,
-0.5254490971565247,
0.38712188601493835,
-0.3692440390586853,
0.8673369288444519,
-0.7746298909187317,
-0.09026361256837845,
0.11550024151802063,
0.18733079731464386,
-0.007379484828561544,
-0.3981921672821045,
0.12835316359996796,
-0.3638349771499634,
-0.14296501874923706,
-0.25726622343063354,
0.9744375348091125,
-0.6291945576667786,
-0.3040136694908142,
0.008084523491561413,
0.19767604768276215,
0.1332879513502121,
-0.06117319315671921,
-0.8073778748512268,
0.24636633694171906,
0.2333173155784607,
0.22747687995433807,
0.691153883934021,
0.3395540714263916,
0.3501570224761963,
0.1937825232744217,
0.6732869148254395,
0.10021058470010757,
-0.008527778089046478,
0.22572962939739227,
1.0252292156219482,
-0.28695055842399597,
-0.5465129017829895,
-0.4728171229362488,
0.5293524265289307,
-0.2429206222295761,
-0.23452605307102203,
0.34243762493133545,
0.1897815614938736,
0.8105754852294922,
0.04054899513721466,
0.8958086967468262,
0.1341383010149002,
0.8159358501434326,
-0.38762038946151733,
0.5952032804489136,
-0.25231653451919556,
0.4425221383571625,
-0.7158796787261963,
-0.8045478463172913,
-0.3290865421295166,
0.9951446652412415,
0.029151419177651405,
-0.16351169347763062,
0.19066527485847473,
0.9942930936813354,
0.008382786065340042,
0.010073094628751278,
0.5714192986488342,
0.5127241015434265,
0.12167633324861526,
0.26333683729171753,
0.8784509301185608,
-0.40239426493644714,
0.8580313920974731,
-0.17704461514949799,
-0.2303452044725418,
-0.14185193181037903,
-0.67911696434021,
-0.8199238777160645,
-0.3887613117694855,
-0.39521148800849915,
-0.5192363858222961,
0.17926347255706787,
0.6572207808494568,
0.8899089694023132,
-0.9949348568916321,
-0.10767456144094467,
0.024757064878940582,
0.31656864285469055,
-0.3917892575263977,
-0.23565152287483215,
0.16904723644256592,
-1.1044187545776367,
-0.7653600573539734,
0.5315596461296082,
0.10728012770414352,
0.347738116979599,
-0.15025381743907928,
0.12329228222370148,
-0.19687949120998383,
0.250931978225708,
0.2513737976551056,
0.32054027915000916,
-0.6962012052536011,
-0.09809251874685287,
-0.3387952446937561,
-0.010599726811051369,
0.1617228090763092,
0.7567415237426758,
-0.6504955291748047,
0.7011873126029968,
0.004007509909570217,
0.84610915184021,
0.3430863618850708,
0.18377302587032318,
0.728500247001648,
-1.1052484512329102,
0.359119713306427,
0.23138059675693512,
0.42215991020202637,
0.07958140969276428,
-0.5096023082733154,
0.15868639945983887,
0.12229259312152863,
-0.5570558309555054,
-0.8901258707046509,
0.24241022765636444,
-0.939284086227417,
-0.3092835247516632,
0.6533610224723816,
-0.14862464368343353,
-0.03947044536471367,
-0.5654183626174927,
-0.3912646472454071,
0.13157062232494354,
-0.7712459564208984,
0.7736155390739441,
0.8531271815299988,
-0.09524199366569519,
-0.0777529701590538,
0.017562657594680786,
0.8537605404853821,
0.763044536113739,
-0.4800509214401245,
-0.12762451171875,
0.5112057328224182,
0.05488434061408043,
0.35918140411376953,
0.6104142069816589,
-0.1969379037618637,
0.19645583629608154,
-0.18520508706569672,
0.020951859652996063,
0.01604980230331421,
-0.1132899820804596,
-0.39742085337638855,
0.2676924467086792,
0.05592140927910805,
-0.24097105860710144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14891v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14891v5
|
LLMBind: A Unified Modality-Task Integration Framework
| 2024-02-22T12:36:31 | 2024-04-19T03:07:59 |
Bin Zhu, Munan Ning, Peng Jin, Bin Lin, Jinfa Huang, Qi Song, Junwu Zhang, Zhenyu Tang, Mingjun Pan, Xing Zhou, Li Yuan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the multi-modal domain, the dependence of various models on specific input
formats leads to user confusion and hinders progress. To address this
challenge, we introduce \textbf{LLMBind}, a novel framework designed to unify a
diverse array of multi-modal tasks. By harnessing a Mixture-of-Experts (MoE)
Large Language Model (LLM), LLMBind processes multi-modal inputs and generates
task-specific tokens, enabling the invocation of corresponding models to
accomplish tasks. This unique approach empowers LLMBind to interpret inputs and
generate outputs across various modalities, including image, text, video, and
audio. Furthermore, we have constructed an interaction dataset comprising 400k
instructions, which unlocks the ability of LLMBind for interactive visual
generation and editing tasks. Extensive experimentation demonstrates that
LLMBind achieves very superior performance across diverse tasks and outperforms
existing models in user evaluations conducted in real-world scenarios.
Moreover, the adaptability of LLMBind allows for seamless integration with the
latest models and extension to new modality tasks, highlighting its potential
to serve as a unified AI agent for modeling universal modalities.
|
[
-0.23800590634346008,
-0.6366812586784363,
0.6040831208229065,
0.3963667154312134,
-0.28711897134780884,
0.13234606385231018,
-0.19887231290340424,
-0.36868101358413696,
0.24206647276878357,
0.2761322557926178,
-0.6793769001960754,
-0.4082947373390198,
-0.4323809742927551,
-0.19953498244285583,
-0.1851097196340561,
0.6666420102119446,
-0.09937410801649094,
0.19541077315807343,
-0.4396686255931854,
0.07354048639535904,
-0.8608356714248657,
-0.14088520407676697,
-0.11854101717472076,
-0.45525625348091125,
0.670398473739624,
0.38249221444129944,
0.3217896819114685,
0.30092528462409973,
0.7691775560379028,
0.3251684308052063,
0.4017857313156128,
0.5960323810577393,
-0.4874039590358734,
0.30739492177963257,
-0.2833641767501831,
-0.43548861145973206,
-0.5882567167282104,
-0.17166569828987122,
0.5290473699569702,
0.5926307439804077,
-0.09244054555892944,
0.08411635458469391,
0.021600229665637016,
0.25593769550323486,
-0.6971240043640137,
0.22748571634292603,
-0.45156311988830566,
-0.20573782920837402,
-0.4156835079193115,
-0.33295661211013794,
-0.20204679667949677,
0.36447104811668396,
-0.4123827815055847,
-0.575639009475708,
-0.24332228302955627,
0.016275325790047646,
0.4352780282497406,
0.470353901386261,
-0.6677996516227722,
0.2224755734205246,
-0.6301668882369995,
0.7001641988754272,
-0.5623944401741028,
0.5797800421714783,
-0.023304354399442673,
0.40836411714553833,
-0.31545448303222656,
-0.5756244659423828,
-0.6190820336341858,
0.05321217328310013,
0.09807352721691132,
0.17267577350139618,
-0.28414931893348694,
0.46612998843193054,
-0.09754663705825806,
0.20407111942768097,
-0.40790408849716187,
0.26450398564338684,
-0.22018148005008698,
-0.19543522596359253,
0.6932357549667358,
0.4776718020439148,
0.4858799874782562,
-0.41437312960624695,
-0.2910562753677368,
0.313291996717453,
-0.651531457901001,
0.099102683365345,
0.2707649767398834,
0.09753647446632385,
-0.13075004518032074,
0.7940525412559509,
-0.3746770918369293,
0.7840099334716797,
0.118109330534935,
-0.5691104531288147,
0.04310055449604988,
-0.4166620969772339,
-0.46825212240219116,
-0.2725120186805725,
0.9365450739860535,
0.6090925335884094,
-0.15896373987197876,
-0.3473847210407257,
-0.4238092303276062,
0.16573020815849304,
0.24311836063861847,
-0.6804527640342712,
-0.024666771292686462,
0.17651478946208954,
-0.3751433193683624,
-0.196852445602417,
-0.10403933376073837,
-0.5325749516487122,
-0.6045176386833191,
-0.5167440176010132,
0.56672602891922,
-0.3318934738636017,
-0.37109971046447754,
0.017254047095775604,
-0.01778482273221016,
0.0678776353597641,
0.7040340900421143,
-0.8405355215072632,
0.02095375582575798,
0.7403388023376465,
0.5037902593612671,
-0.5102027654647827,
-0.5069706439971924,
-0.5050076246261597,
0.47698909044265747,
0.022869298234581947,
0.9958434700965881,
-0.8565376996994019,
-0.5203164219856262,
-0.20258855819702148,
-0.18081100285053253,
-0.2519432604312897,
-0.32653674483299255,
0.06380196660757065,
-0.4178653061389923,
-0.06984151154756546,
-0.14437995851039886,
-0.2679826319217682,
-0.42636483907699585,
0.17520040273666382,
-0.5675071477890015,
0.836647629737854,
0.15543316304683685,
-0.6367703676223755,
0.32139667868614197,
-0.9874284863471985,
-0.4578198790550232,
0.2170138955116272,
-0.6603434085845947,
0.3025565445423126,
0.41420596837997437,
0.2639548182487488,
0.6599001884460449,
-0.7960019707679749,
0.7470095753669739,
-0.3646818697452545,
-0.4503595530986786,
0.2965363562107086,
-0.6948721408843994,
0.6231995820999146,
0.16863441467285156,
-0.20474475622177124,
0.46397829055786133,
-0.7492170333862305,
-0.24861669540405273,
-0.2393396496772766,
-0.4721584618091583,
-0.18092851340770721,
-0.18230991065502167,
0.5042957663536072,
0.11461315304040909,
0.31018733978271484,
-0.625076949596405,
0.43331843614578247,
0.2386745810508728,
0.44263017177581787,
0.9640631079673767,
-0.11126355826854706,
0.4377571940422058,
-0.40839529037475586,
0.6748154759407043,
0.18853908777236938,
0.01506105437874794,
-0.37697598338127136,
-0.5078104138374329,
-0.6026102304458618,
-0.8481194972991943,
0.2967785596847534,
0.5656613111495972,
-0.702659547328949,
0.14793822169303894,
-0.524726152420044,
-0.37516218423843384,
-0.724713921546936,
0.46185922622680664,
0.24041734635829926,
0.46511924266815186,
-0.08806834369897842,
-0.4686128795146942,
-0.5228696465492249,
-1.0772736072540283,
0.08100925385951996,
-0.1002933531999588,
-0.1352066695690155,
0.26930806040763855,
0.45965051651000977,
-0.7043358683586121,
1.0764189958572388,
-0.0691654309630394,
-0.3162514567375183,
-0.5164587497711182,
0.391859233379364,
0.24619793891906738,
0.6617473363876343,
0.29095709323883057,
-0.8876787424087524,
-0.1201205775141716,
0.16949185729026794,
-0.8993090391159058,
-0.3247401714324951,
-0.40903207659721375,
-0.3425579369068146,
-0.07807701081037521,
0.37888017296791077,
-0.6836181282997131,
0.3251441419124603,
0.5800341367721558,
-0.08486224710941315,
0.424437552690506,
-0.06490836292505264,
0.4659988582134247,
-1.4376832246780396,
0.32565948367118835,
-0.1160401776432991,
-0.21403203904628754,
-0.5306804180145264,
0.10869242995977402,
0.02150130644440651,
-0.02076295204460621,
-0.454006552696228,
0.5401090383529663,
-0.38747191429138184,
-0.19851599633693695,
-0.09460101276636124,
-0.0833381712436676,
0.05093996599316597,
0.7125675678253174,
-0.3649795353412628,
0.909125030040741,
0.625578761100769,
-0.32316216826438904,
0.6719727516174316,
0.14310479164123535,
-0.5161933898925781,
0.9637641310691833,
-0.6296049356460571,
-0.09169286489486694,
-0.19544252753257751,
0.024153780192136765,
-1.1906764507293701,
-0.8242610096931458,
0.16805541515350342,
-0.2638813853263855,
0.3648652136325836,
0.06640719622373581,
-0.6336261034011841,
-0.11363206803798676,
-0.16117794811725616,
0.6547384262084961,
0.24284352362155914,
-0.29823148250579834,
1.2988477945327759,
0.38855236768722534,
-0.19113504886627197,
-0.6388524174690247,
-0.9331893920898438,
0.22218380868434906,
0.050049472600221634,
-0.7779333591461182,
0.43707287311553955,
-0.3685070872306824,
-0.18252165615558624,
0.10027317702770233,
-0.12484433501958847,
-0.17406851053237915,
0.13658249378204346,
0.798820972442627,
0.4072003662586212,
-0.08086945116519928,
-0.018076052889227867,
0.5234667658805847,
0.04646323621273041,
-0.1709938496351242,
0.23451943695545197,
0.45677122473716736,
0.07569020241498947,
-1.0481129884719849,
-0.6555408835411072,
0.7166747450828552,
0.967532753944397,
-0.35950666666030884,
0.14288531243801117,
0.7295534014701843,
-0.1254121959209442,
0.18795129656791687,
-0.8587331175804138,
0.1883307695388794,
-0.4640468955039978,
0.6519902348518372,
-0.5544779300689697,
-1.0312573909759521,
0.3660537302494049,
-0.303499698638916,
0.257032573223114,
0.01997053436934948,
0.6566563248634338,
-0.21323262155056,
1.2098718881607056,
0.9905575513839722,
-0.21340827643871307,
0.5326032042503357,
-0.0009389356127940118,
0.24247229099273682,
-1.1391665935516357,
-0.5054314732551575,
0.25516366958618164,
-0.7159608006477356,
-0.27216601371765137,
-0.6256892681121826,
0.5275282263755798,
0.022071003913879395,
-0.053112391382455826,
-0.03187858685851097,
-0.25382566452026367,
0.41371968388557434,
0.6094016432762146,
0.23345230519771576,
0.3378826379776001,
0.04037775099277496,
-0.09571561962366104,
0.02182132750749588,
-0.5897106528282166,
-0.1643344908952713,
1.2253414392471313,
0.20402394235134125,
1.2024257183074951,
0.21443691849708557,
0.6435783505439758,
0.5102439522743225,
0.5497099757194519,
-0.8925064206123352,
0.8188560605049133,
0.08054139465093613,
-0.5631140470504761,
0.029015298932790756,
-0.15163928270339966,
-0.6619173288345337,
0.4448031783103943,
-0.33464810252189636,
-0.9148085713386536,
0.34000641107559204,
0.05784323811531067,
-0.4184431731700897,
0.32433366775512695,
-0.5680624842643738,
0.762545108795166,
-0.42838481068611145,
-0.4086398482322693,
-0.3353286683559418,
-0.4367004334926605,
0.6781646013259888,
-0.15971779823303223,
0.2382858246564865,
-0.3112335801124573,
-0.18584823608398438,
0.4605734348297119,
0.20583154261112213,
1.1289172172546387,
0.10920407623052597,
-0.0927722305059433,
-0.024926872923970222,
0.29584336280822754,
0.02825864776968956,
0.1579016149044037,
-0.03050294518470764,
0.21285651624202728,
-0.3180420696735382,
-0.14338280260562897,
-0.5930567383766174,
0.6534504890441895,
-0.6260167956352234,
-0.7573204040527344,
-0.07306190580129623,
-1.2628862857818604,
-0.2095363885164261,
0.37951532006263733,
-0.17759205400943756,
0.8171969652175903,
-0.3752513825893402,
0.19084586203098297,
0.46003514528274536,
0.17929165065288544,
0.4766448736190796,
0.41755223274230957,
-0.3567638397216797,
-0.5614203810691833,
0.8271752595901489,
-0.2778127193450928,
-0.03283609449863434,
0.5634169578552246,
-0.30357393622398376,
-0.012914193794131279,
-0.3657774329185486,
-0.5999061465263367,
0.2480231076478958,
-0.79694002866745,
-0.3479200601577759,
-0.6100285053253174,
0.05933541804552078,
-0.4889073669910431,
-0.3368404507637024,
-0.07267186045646667,
-0.14248515665531158,
-0.29029789566993713,
0.08923277258872986,
0.1560307741165161,
0.788651704788208,
-0.35313844680786133,
0.5556566715240479,
-0.8014246821403503,
0.472444087266922,
0.6645064353942871,
0.2797701954841614,
-0.236408993601799,
-0.35927122831344604,
-0.03718150407075882,
0.061662934720516205,
-0.28937453031539917,
-0.8249872922897339,
0.27894335985183716,
0.27858322858810425,
0.8777602910995483,
0.6394326090812683,
-0.2990489602088928,
0.8193634748458862,
-0.5520880222320557,
0.6786473393440247,
0.5661126375198364,
-0.969550371170044,
0.20715348422527313,
-0.46086710691452026,
0.3934076726436615,
0.48880308866500854,
0.20852628350257874,
-0.6235256791114807,
-0.24732157588005066,
-0.02886834368109703,
-0.7070650458335876,
0.568194568157196,
-0.2609501779079437,
0.09276656806468964,
0.37737876176834106,
-0.011244134977459908,
0.2371433675289154,
0.575178861618042,
-0.6348794102668762,
0.10626145452260971,
-0.022968372330069542,
-0.5602266788482666,
-0.03123421035706997,
-0.28499293327331543,
-0.48091211915016174,
-0.43443939089775085,
0.11154817789793015,
-0.24941386282444,
0.4793594777584076,
-0.05200732871890068,
-0.6413471102714539,
-0.10989309102296829,
0.3018248379230499,
0.6470950841903687,
0.9391464591026306,
-0.06890960037708282,
0.164247527718544,
-0.03143271431326866,
-0.24094587564468384,
0.07248789817094803,
0.2099113166332245,
0.011712386272847652,
-0.1533569097518921,
0.4264534115791321,
0.9477285742759705,
0.5166832208633423,
-0.9484155178070068,
0.5534955859184265,
0.053259462118148804,
-0.0914224237203598,
0.04999460652470589,
0.057933345437049866,
0.07072003930807114,
0.5835020542144775,
0.33394986391067505,
0.29191502928733826,
0.2542365789413452,
-0.5073407888412476,
0.20837533473968506,
0.501596987247467,
-0.13159333169460297,
-0.4713840186595917,
0.7852941155433655,
0.5251646637916565,
-0.22739793360233307,
0.3281995952129364,
0.04590071737766266,
-0.38635411858558655,
0.2213469296693802,
0.45865508913993835,
0.9337050318717957,
-0.20150859653949738,
0.23228338360786438,
-0.2161056101322174,
0.23885701596736908,
0.2494577169418335,
0.4354412853717804,
-0.3830682933330536,
-0.5493854880332947,
-0.6753028035163879,
-0.6621708869934082,
-0.3590236306190491,
-0.023196348920464516,
-0.35838496685028076,
0.10864467918872833,
-0.30367228388786316,
-0.1655282825231552,
-0.08716266602277756,
-0.6068530082702637,
-0.8025846481323242,
-0.05498587340116501,
0.32670387625694275,
0.690337598323822,
-0.8863095045089722,
0.7278496623039246,
1.1055271625518799,
-0.5600062012672424,
-0.5175788402557373,
-0.20761248469352722,
0.20301711559295654,
-1.0628724098205566,
0.9325504302978516,
0.33352968096733093,
-0.20763979852199554,
-0.1048092469573021,
-0.5537670254707336,
-0.7624751925468445,
1.2493149042129517,
0.4368324875831604,
-0.40977317094802856,
-0.2127535343170166,
0.26067107915878296,
0.12290585041046143,
-0.6105204224586487,
0.32988470792770386,
0.5233423709869385,
0.6570222973823547,
0.028632601723074913,
-0.9839649200439453,
0.0062270015478134155,
-0.5687050223350525,
0.14989766478538513,
0.13479465246200562,
-0.45531409978866577,
0.9311187267303467,
-0.055764418095350266,
-0.08485755324363708,
-0.046537838876247406,
0.7362136244773865,
0.033365827053785324,
0.12489421665668488,
0.5843878984451294,
0.48317399621009827,
0.5676528215408325,
0.01878707855939865,
0.8369430303573608,
-0.3652965724468231,
-0.26255178451538086,
0.8912326097488403,
-0.252277672290802,
0.6055874228477478,
0.7468897104263306,
0.1775035411119461,
0.41535288095474243,
0.46713730692863464,
-0.07031138986349106,
0.5788794755935669,
-0.04942573234438896,
-0.4244757890701294,
-0.7186955809593201,
-0.4389703869819641,
-0.07931628823280334,
0.7309138774871826,
0.32634860277175903,
0.11059804260730743,
-0.30990976095199585,
0.2957500219345093,
-0.143761545419693,
-0.09991143643856049,
-0.3306833803653717,
0.6063061952590942,
-0.12956589460372925,
-0.4270550608634949,
0.2672574818134308,
-0.08689090609550476,
1.1508883237838745,
-0.6904516816139221,
-0.19028431177139282,
-0.21049600839614868,
0.026339730247855186,
-0.22445550560951233,
-0.6966074109077454,
-0.0971405878663063,
-0.14258119463920593,
-0.24050451815128326,
-0.18275797367095947,
0.7167710065841675,
-0.5799106955528259,
-0.5531200170516968,
-0.031378790736198425,
0.7277123928070068,
-0.0036953843664377928,
-0.0002175981499021873,
-0.5243676900863647,
0.43549874424934387,
0.04550134018063545,
-0.12775114178657532,
0.40064799785614014,
0.44436854124069214,
0.03610941767692566,
0.8258923888206482,
0.5397397875785828,
-0.12264561653137207,
-0.14410601556301117,
-0.028485724702477455,
1.0729135274887085,
-0.4779169261455536,
-0.2686564028263092,
-0.5484312772750854,
0.9028739929199219,
-0.07884780317544937,
-0.2895953357219696,
0.5856747031211853,
0.3727729916572571,
0.6618618369102478,
-0.03388523310422897,
0.9445480704307556,
-0.3236973285675049,
0.06643065810203552,
-0.2938201129436493,
0.7135434746742249,
-1.1022213697433472,
0.14466607570648193,
-0.17337356507778168,
-0.7288541793823242,
-0.2563912570476532,
0.30588436126708984,
-0.13756389915943146,
-0.07057931274175644,
0.5169948935508728,
0.9462401866912842,
-0.4901401102542877,
-0.2750166654586792,
0.5303623080253601,
-0.09738191217184067,
0.4103272259235382,
0.5809130668640137,
0.8020797371864319,
-0.026784073561429977,
0.3658697009086609,
-0.2218465358018875,
-0.3792160749435425,
-0.4767470061779022,
-0.9096739888191223,
-0.907829761505127,
-0.6403171420097351,
0.02890884131193161,
0.2605002522468567,
-0.07550075650215149,
1.2204889059066772,
0.7373814582824707,
-0.5476027727127075,
-0.5670121908187866,
0.24026547372341156,
0.05811070650815964,
-0.15531951189041138,
-0.16167955100536346,
-0.15084308385849,
-0.3089603781700134,
-0.8646416664123535,
0.7461358308792114,
0.6222948431968689,
-0.16469717025756836,
-0.4328579306602478,
0.11969628930091858,
-0.10199746489524841,
0.1958874762058258,
0.6624546647071838,
0.11619328707456589,
-0.8750452995300293,
-0.09623971581459045,
-0.01059995498508215,
-0.24999602138996124,
0.0214658472687006,
1.0178380012512207,
-0.5257382988929749,
0.6266329288482666,
0.5107346773147583,
1.0070971250534058,
0.05765850841999054,
-0.236495241522789,
0.8314102292060852,
-0.5499504804611206,
0.3347300887107849,
0.08481109142303467,
0.4756971001625061,
0.2962779700756073,
-0.2211596667766571,
0.3753513991832733,
0.2764490246772766,
-0.4147181510925293,
-1.1003226041793823,
0.41080692410469055,
-1.4260356426239014,
-0.1964399516582489,
1.0395840406417847,
0.11387338489294052,
-0.4074382483959198,
0.02870745211839676,
-0.505836009979248,
0.07642271369695663,
-0.5526358485221863,
0.5784552693367004,
0.4072157144546509,
-0.3137151598930359,
-0.24230517446994781,
-0.5018771886825562,
-0.034710947424173355,
0.4912641942501068,
-0.8288719654083252,
-0.10366521030664444,
0.8880166411399841,
0.24277198314666748,
-0.053561266511678696,
0.6402391195297241,
0.1344420164823532,
0.4448034167289734,
-0.19790562987327576,
0.4274542033672333,
-0.5624290108680725,
-0.4158860743045807,
-0.2877886891365051,
0.08332230895757675,
-0.059155113995075226,
-0.12559804320335388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14492v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14492v2
|
Towards Robust Instruction Tuning on Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T12:35:50 | 2024-06-14T13:38:14 |
Wei Han, Hui Chen, Soujanya Poria
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) on multi-task instruction-following
data has been proven to be a powerful learning paradigm for improving their
zero-shot capabilities on new tasks. Recent works about high-quality
instruction-following data generation and selection require amounts of human
labor to conceive model-understandable instructions for the given tasks and
carefully filter the LLM-generated data. In this work, we introduce an
automatic instruction augmentation method named INSTRAUG in multimodal tasks.
It starts from a handful of basic and straightforward meta instructions but can
expand an instruction-following dataset by 30 times. Results on two popular
multimodal instructionfollowing benchmarks MULTIINSTRUCT and InstructBLIP show
that INSTRAUG can significantly improve the alignment of multimodal large
language models (MLLMs) across 12 multimodal tasks, which is even equivalent to
the benefits of scaling up training data multiple times.
|
[
-0.26749536395072937,
-0.6836023330688477,
0.272995263338089,
0.08519674837589264,
-0.12338579446077347,
0.30602508783340454,
-0.49928146600723267,
-0.2109961360692978,
-0.2002260386943817,
0.45647311210632324,
-0.8603258728981018,
-0.637351930141449,
-0.5334799885749817,
-0.14099858701229095,
-0.1156843975186348,
0.907133162021637,
0.10557811707258224,
0.141728475689888,
-0.46440768241882324,
-0.11546225100755692,
-0.6955599188804626,
-0.03748695179820061,
-0.1221361979842186,
-0.13404832780361176,
0.4151565134525299,
0.9241353869438171,
0.5897282361984253,
0.8116209506988525,
0.3437756896018982,
0.3246869444847107,
0.3007020056247711,
0.9564462304115295,
-0.4236917197704315,
0.13823626935482025,
-0.10120497643947601,
-0.3454941213130951,
-0.4995509684085846,
-0.26065972447395325,
0.8463029861450195,
0.4785482883453369,
-0.01852366514503956,
0.3021841049194336,
0.5062478184700012,
0.2525170147418976,
-0.7671087384223938,
0.16195549070835114,
-0.40197232365608215,
-0.28671497106552124,
-0.25868773460388184,
-0.4505496025085449,
-0.8310127258300781,
-0.3743768036365509,
-0.24012456834316254,
-0.4036978781223297,
0.07189305871725082,
0.019859736785292625,
0.5759400725364685,
0.35114943981170654,
-0.535166323184967,
-0.2781587243080139,
-0.43912672996520996,
0.9221310615539551,
-0.8886635303497314,
0.5940797328948975,
0.4169827997684479,
0.03320368379354477,
-0.2484515905380249,
-0.5661622285842896,
-0.3430657982826233,
-0.29262351989746094,
-0.26833370327949524,
-0.1552252173423767,
-0.13271892070770264,
0.19932901859283447,
0.3828756809234619,
0.05122965946793556,
-0.5492518544197083,
0.4113225042819977,
-0.17658989131450653,
-0.2033061534166336,
0.2976675033569336,
0.31990841031074524,
0.4043777883052826,
0.20975308120250702,
-0.4374362528324127,
-0.19533129036426544,
-0.8452223539352417,
0.09113845229148865,
0.4636625647544861,
0.2757495939731598,
-0.11942736059427261,
0.3723488748073578,
-0.2763173282146454,
1.2024043798446655,
0.18571943044662476,
-0.4204234480857849,
0.4278019368648529,
-0.5969837307929993,
-0.16309021413326263,
0.0015022184234112501,
0.5031461119651794,
0.3326994478702545,
0.11063214391469955,
-0.15181408822536469,
-0.08081687241792679,
-0.04030369967222214,
0.34492629766464233,
-0.9216417074203491,
-0.3384319841861725,
-0.08559264987707138,
-0.16605399549007416,
0.0006607832037843764,
-0.05656170845031738,
-0.7626818418502808,
-0.004269866738468409,
-0.45951002836227417,
0.5424149036407471,
-0.655151903629303,
0.2527991533279419,
0.02581542171537876,
0.24835018813610077,
0.21834193170070648,
0.28891831636428833,
-1.0618164539337158,
-0.03995513543486595,
0.548738420009613,
0.6513624787330627,
0.0364721454679966,
-0.4368022680282593,
-1.1272273063659668,
0.33938199281692505,
-0.32951852679252625,
0.8720646500587463,
-1.0767111778259277,
-0.05873614549636841,
-0.07551727443933487,
0.27932998538017273,
-0.21203599870204926,
-0.22738002240657806,
0.40524229407310486,
-0.30744749307632446,
0.2382485717535019,
-0.07160163670778275,
-0.7277506589889526,
-0.2545081079006195,
0.21029146015644073,
-0.34973952174186707,
0.7923852205276489,
0.07371748238801956,
-0.36247745156288147,
0.4176749289035797,
-0.5981552004814148,
-0.7689357399940491,
0.01886233501136303,
0.20249231159687042,
-0.22560563683509827,
0.05775255337357521,
0.716648519039154,
0.5598645806312561,
-0.03540612757205963,
-0.2841353714466095,
-0.4905146658420563,
-0.40304291248321533,
0.0758029967546463,
-0.5790368318557739,
0.7435807585716248,
-0.11066635698080063,
-0.2536637783050537,
0.314859002828598,
-0.7082632780075073,
0.399018794298172,
-0.585371732711792,
-0.3816407024860382,
-0.3041326105594635,
-0.13046319782733917,
-0.18535226583480835,
0.08265743404626846,
0.11579154431819916,
-0.5896273851394653,
0.40943673253059387,
-0.13371562957763672,
0.40896397829055786,
0.8205479979515076,
-0.06264155358076096,
0.5444439649581909,
-0.10257203876972198,
0.5845866799354553,
-0.30152514576911926,
0.25449618697166443,
-0.8680764436721802,
-0.28308290243148804,
-0.7667102813720703,
-0.7179725170135498,
0.3495546281337738,
0.5043213367462158,
-0.9280515909194946,
0.1158825010061264,
-0.18622292578220367,
-0.3517301678657532,
-0.8548527956008911,
0.5843731760978699,
0.6481949687004089,
0.6800740361213684,
0.5480677485466003,
-0.044575754553079605,
-0.32779258489608765,
-0.7365333437919617,
-0.052474092692136765,
0.4331568777561188,
0.07342170178890228,
0.044572487473487854,
0.22292514145374298,
-0.3797060251235962,
0.3212724030017853,
-0.39784106612205505,
-0.16934482753276825,
0.026256270706653595,
0.3409118354320526,
-0.016252607107162476,
0.6186637878417969,
0.3022734224796295,
-0.3921264410018921,
-0.7590470314025879,
0.10797587782144547,
-0.5590696930885315,
-0.11863389611244202,
-0.3024713397026062,
-0.24418947100639343,
0.17521537840366364,
0.7137738466262817,
-0.43453770875930786,
0.18740461766719818,
0.5322673320770264,
-0.16108392179012299,
0.31629958748817444,
-0.36131441593170166,
0.3137997090816498,
-0.9340067505836487,
-0.33372440934181213,
-0.004720393102616072,
-0.4010522961616516,
-0.6466147899627686,
0.36938396096229553,
0.6790236830711365,
0.1535622626543045,
-0.41861939430236816,
0.24069525301456451,
-0.8107730746269226,
0.1852736920118332,
-0.3241350054740906,
-0.2425335794687271,
0.17404596507549286,
0.5471769571304321,
-0.3786523938179016,
0.8433340191841125,
0.7333391904830933,
-0.5936830639839172,
0.4449428915977478,
0.24110831320285797,
-0.5271555781364441,
0.5700879096984863,
-0.3051376938819885,
0.29044193029403687,
-0.1927965134382248,
0.15131066739559174,
-1.253122329711914,
-0.40691059827804565,
0.10257165133953094,
-0.21992607414722443,
0.716500997543335,
-0.37357035279273987,
-0.7763838768005371,
-0.004290752578526735,
-0.25346699357032776,
0.24349640309810638,
0.2894016206264496,
-0.7568486928939819,
0.6055768728256226,
0.1388220489025116,
-0.03824822977185249,
-0.6724071502685547,
-0.6336477994918823,
0.013274217955768108,
-0.10734663158655167,
-0.4218132197856903,
0.32849040627479553,
-0.11713338643312454,
0.057870522141456604,
-0.11789397895336151,
0.12348721921443939,
-0.0020333128049969673,
-0.25116175413131714,
0.1705690175294876,
0.41320645809173584,
-0.12363754212856293,
0.35834020376205444,
0.4270631670951843,
-0.09839838743209839,
-0.20851391553878784,
-0.2713046967983246,
0.4977279007434845,
0.005228016059845686,
-0.5298200845718384,
-0.683604896068573,
0.287174791097641,
0.7229621410369873,
-0.5607395768165588,
0.3775596022605896,
0.970958948135376,
-0.07896319031715393,
-0.40675950050354004,
-0.42603155970573425,
-0.3208622634410858,
-0.5273668766021729,
0.47442927956581116,
0.006672334857285023,
-0.7036174535751343,
-0.07290228456258774,
0.018218055367469788,
0.3838202953338623,
-0.04026293754577637,
0.6193752884864807,
-0.547163724899292,
1.1090080738067627,
0.8037605881690979,
0.046673618257045746,
0.6055454015731812,
-0.18157507479190826,
-0.10088392347097397,
-0.7542589902877808,
-0.2241791933774948,
-0.18504121899604797,
-0.55295729637146,
-0.5017270445823669,
-0.6125056147575378,
0.5728884935379028,
-0.3186205327510834,
-0.030615108087658882,
0.3796011209487915,
-0.42555466294288635,
0.6065932512283325,
0.6842765212059021,
0.5622826814651489,
0.12821592390537262,
0.1308731883764267,
0.05634705722332001,
-0.17404122650623322,
-0.8204408884048462,
-0.09253983199596405,
1.0600694417953491,
0.15592217445373535,
1.1734663248062134,
-0.07379978895187378,
0.3926350176334381,
0.1157921776175499,
0.3865049183368683,
-0.5643442869186401,
0.3953689634799957,
-0.4169634282588959,
-0.30245906114578247,
-0.17037320137023926,
-0.23114269971847534,
-0.6221954226493835,
0.1264239102602005,
-0.42993098497390747,
-0.5127095580101013,
0.13885198533535004,
0.5534201264381409,
-0.5762822031974792,
0.22687073051929474,
-1.0030920505523682,
0.7605447769165039,
-0.45908159017562866,
-0.5730423331260681,
-0.48685115575790405,
-0.6799865961074829,
0.35788798332214355,
0.23766623437404633,
0.1840442568063736,
0.05648833140730858,
-0.13182005286216736,
0.16798841953277588,
-0.24920572340488434,
0.9979657530784607,
-0.05211188644170761,
-0.15557608008384705,
0.09385333955287933,
0.01999288611114025,
0.6239630579948425,
-0.14334875345230103,
0.2047102153301239,
-0.215123251080513,
-0.2874284088611603,
-0.3771744966506958,
-0.7531470060348511,
0.9400985836982727,
-0.30651670694351196,
-0.3575684726238251,
-0.029361750930547714,
-1.1179707050323486,
-0.43775051832199097,
0.10201974213123322,
0.22628813982009888,
1.0087685585021973,
0.2994334101676941,
0.4732946753501892,
0.9822340607643127,
-0.16705165803432465,
0.6059511303901672,
0.44647693634033203,
0.15682697296142578,
-0.5491974353790283,
1.0535204410552979,
0.12369212508201599,
0.5336558818817139,
0.8063849210739136,
-0.08796385675668716,
-0.34991011023521423,
-0.2525825798511505,
-0.81988924741745,
0.07756475359201431,
-0.648423433303833,
-0.44266438484191895,
-0.48608312010765076,
0.14394992589950562,
-0.2644776403903961,
-0.11524670571088791,
-0.25979670882225037,
-0.1306242197751999,
-0.339422345161438,
0.03247698023915291,
0.4203713834285736,
0.3596411347389221,
0.05277841165661812,
0.47667503356933594,
-0.9626198410987854,
0.20527397096157074,
0.44055628776550293,
0.36487507820129395,
-0.08290844410657883,
-0.752502977848053,
-0.5225652456283569,
0.29017144441604614,
-0.35347265005111694,
-0.6210854053497314,
0.177667498588562,
0.4679412245750427,
0.5331741571426392,
0.5351337194442749,
-0.19464203715324402,
1.193872094154358,
-0.7093419432640076,
0.3590065836906433,
0.07511857897043228,
-0.8325902223587036,
0.30989205837249756,
-0.18746092915534973,
0.8266416788101196,
0.3819773197174072,
0.46166038513183594,
-0.09312355518341064,
-0.2645975351333618,
-0.07149169594049454,
-0.6887011528015137,
0.6521139740943909,
-0.16873835027217865,
0.4116606116294861,
0.21255196630954742,
0.0781686082482338,
0.2291863113641739,
0.1815490424633026,
-0.4073428213596344,
0.010865164920687675,
-0.04835887998342514,
-0.34478235244750977,
-0.1685878336429596,
-0.27903538942337036,
-0.16568192839622498,
-0.46552249789237976,
0.6194921135902405,
-0.2483033835887909,
0.017215417698025703,
-0.3591824471950531,
-0.3633813261985779,
-0.10467786341905594,
0.23539893329143524,
0.8686081767082214,
0.8020961284637451,
-0.15662781894207,
0.07956767827272415,
0.3398398458957672,
-0.35732221603393555,
0.13376906514167786,
0.04292770475149155,
-0.058426108211278915,
-0.020623300224542618,
0.6488047242164612,
0.8963488936424255,
0.5298943519592285,
-0.7582522034645081,
0.2675417363643646,
0.12480510771274567,
-0.031821511685848236,
0.06764243543148041,
0.24668391048908234,
-0.04342605918645859,
0.38935908675193787,
0.10230271518230438,
0.18223845958709717,
-0.003403700888156891,
-0.6428007483482361,
0.35731610655784607,
0.6963285803794861,
-0.27982017397880554,
-0.2508504092693329,
0.5677932500839233,
0.13199402391910553,
-0.17570136487483978,
0.6674723625183105,
-0.016135836020112038,
-0.1213938444852829,
0.12452195584774017,
0.6390984654426575,
0.5779068470001221,
-0.3356786072254181,
0.19065594673156738,
0.284160852432251,
0.5448222160339355,
0.13408489525318146,
0.1982906311750412,
-0.23636846244335175,
-0.3405567407608032,
-0.8958144187927246,
-0.3696032762527466,
-0.3118104338645935,
0.02967526577413082,
-0.6568253040313721,
0.2950400710105896,
-0.24293692409992218,
0.09580433368682861,
0.01120035257190466,
-0.5289563536643982,
-0.6237544417381287,
0.029539506882429123,
0.10870052129030228,
0.6475645303726196,
-0.6574045419692993,
1.0336949825286865,
0.5768265724182129,
-0.15001387894153595,
-0.5360425114631653,
0.184356689453125,
-0.074661023914814,
-0.6277591586112976,
0.4291785955429077,
0.23118636012077332,
-0.3464357554912567,
-0.03997742384672165,
-0.7135329246520996,
-0.8487314581871033,
0.8906500339508057,
0.7659645080566406,
-0.7734527587890625,
-0.1387508362531662,
-0.09819551557302475,
0.3630812168121338,
-0.4479198157787323,
0.2097863405942917,
0.2977531850337982,
0.31259578466415405,
-0.08515089750289917,
-0.7278907299041748,
-0.120164655148983,
-0.08153646439313889,
-0.20742326974868774,
0.43147650361061096,
-0.6117076277732849,
0.7919506430625916,
-0.35257211327552795,
-0.042133431881666183,
-0.18584157526493073,
0.6385785341262817,
-0.1667308658361435,
0.05644504353404045,
0.5430488586425781,
0.6224504709243774,
0.55302494764328,
0.13392604887485504,
0.9080598950386047,
-0.4484300911426544,
0.014640828594565392,
1.4709773063659668,
0.07587746530771255,
0.7178423404693604,
0.3938143849372864,
0.2243834137916565,
0.7174534201622009,
0.3743692636489868,
-0.05283866077661514,
0.5988975763320923,
-0.38923612236976624,
-0.12234542518854141,
-0.49457624554634094,
-0.0008163405582308769,
-0.10538684576749802,
0.740911066532135,
0.6074383854866028,
-0.3900522291660309,
-0.4008209705352783,
0.32878878712654114,
0.06473733484745026,
0.100717693567276,
-0.48331448435783386,
0.6806868314743042,
-0.23308871686458588,
-0.6462426781654358,
0.7942898869514465,
-0.14053788781166077,
0.5656471252441406,
-0.6385411024093628,
-0.53374844789505,
-0.06939291954040527,
0.27282771468162537,
-0.28219112753868103,
-0.7647672295570374,
0.019353844225406647,
-0.07134539633989334,
-0.12120579183101654,
-0.4220355749130249,
0.5343266725540161,
-0.8705139756202698,
-0.6924614310264587,
0.06182253733277321,
0.24849431216716766,
-0.2250155806541443,
0.30450546741485596,
-0.3525216579437256,
0.04299483448266983,
0.19365806877613068,
0.07469409704208374,
0.44593316316604614,
0.30106306076049805,
-0.06821555644273758,
0.8827365636825562,
0.6219799518585205,
-0.20956674218177795,
0.25620582699775696,
-0.12796984612941742,
0.9804975390434265,
-0.10929752141237259,
-0.3030078709125519,
-1.0422801971435547,
0.7468414902687073,
0.03044019639492035,
-0.2538682222366333,
1.0579677820205688,
0.3292336165904999,
1.1348456144332886,
-0.2224327027797699,
0.5695353150367737,
-0.008119449019432068,
0.4801987111568451,
-0.7806650400161743,
0.4898431599140167,
-0.6090947389602661,
0.008591264486312866,
-0.2432277947664261,
-0.7816473841667175,
-0.24714861810207367,
0.3701211214065552,
-0.11532323807477951,
-0.17325915396213531,
0.4042104482650757,
1.2127162218093872,
-0.5252798199653625,
-0.3398250937461853,
0.2546883821487427,
0.051160771399736404,
-0.02480287477374077,
0.3290362060070038,
0.5792192816734314,
-0.15178008377552032,
0.6371657252311707,
-0.46770212054252625,
-0.21086779236793518,
-0.18586215376853943,
-0.7590604424476624,
-0.890413761138916,
-0.512976348400116,
-0.19122439622879028,
-0.0825853943824768,
0.04350090026855469,
1.1842983961105347,
0.9814119935035706,
-0.811751663684845,
-0.2412508875131607,
0.3532119393348694,
0.12670332193374634,
-0.620058536529541,
-0.17736394703388214,
0.2721361815929413,
-0.7480501532554626,
-0.967827558517456,
0.7593207955360413,
0.45347148180007935,
-0.2342453896999359,
-0.23644942045211792,
-0.018937643617391586,
-0.3988740146160126,
-0.04701651260256767,
0.7397264242172241,
0.06239708513021469,
-0.5436067581176758,
-0.2704521119594574,
0.07319460809230804,
0.05564882606267929,
0.04373189061880112,
0.6886872053146362,
-0.5159995555877686,
0.961525022983551,
0.40141695737838745,
0.6424462199211121,
0.3481023609638214,
0.08830716460943222,
0.5402474999427795,
-1.0186899900436401,
0.1845453828573227,
0.04966673627495766,
0.3758796453475952,
0.36990684270858765,
-0.289072722196579,
0.25015532970428467,
-0.23437312245368958,
-0.5754186511039734,
-1.0051811933517456,
0.15858536958694458,
-0.6120798587799072,
-0.12094276398420334,
0.9832128882408142,
-0.07369724661111832,
-0.09706545621156693,
0.1864207684993744,
-0.15087111294269562,
0.16653771698474884,
-0.39981403946876526,
0.6378653645515442,
0.4199348986148834,
-0.27755486965179443,
-0.6119158267974854,
-0.740292489528656,
0.3779507875442505,
0.22409135103225708,
-0.789746105670929,
0.07098501920700073,
0.6270697712898254,
0.29106009006500244,
-0.07919424027204514,
0.03983446583151817,
0.13040533661842346,
0.47487133741378784,
-0.18341226875782013,
0.10380635410547256,
-0.46296679973602295,
-0.6724012494087219,
-0.14546452462673187,
0.08806052058935165,
-0.14113318920135498,
-0.6307109594345093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14488v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14488v1
|
Does the Generator Mind its Contexts? An Analysis of Generative Model Faithfulness under Context Transfer
| 2024-02-22T12:26:07 | 2024-02-22T12:26:07 |
Xinshuo Hu, Baotian Hu, Dongfang Li, Xiaoguang Li, Lifeng Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The present study introduces the knowledge-augmented generator, which is
specifically designed to produce information that remains grounded in
contextual knowledge, regardless of alterations in the context. Previous
research has predominantly focused on examining hallucinations stemming from
static input, such as in the domains of summarization or machine translation.
However, our investigation delves into the faithfulness of generative question
answering in the presence of dynamic knowledge. Our objective is to explore the
existence of hallucinations arising from parametric memory when contextual
knowledge undergoes changes, while also analyzing the underlying causes for
their occurrence. In order to efficiently address this issue, we propose a
straightforward yet effective measure for detecting such hallucinations.
Intriguingly, our investigation uncovers that all models exhibit a tendency to
generate previous answers as hallucinations. To gain deeper insights into the
underlying causes of this phenomenon, we conduct a series of experiments that
verify the critical role played by context in hallucination, both during
training and testing, from various perspectives.
|
[
-0.7061725854873657,
-1.027230143547058,
0.941368579864502,
-0.16407480835914612,
-0.28241974115371704,
-0.352178156375885,
-0.09090594202280045,
-0.3074512183666229,
0.07465045154094696,
0.513283371925354,
-0.6025428771972656,
0.028361108154058456,
-0.47546127438545227,
0.1947552114725113,
-0.9517449140548706,
0.86581951379776,
-0.17647510766983032,
-0.14985188841819763,
-0.48323360085487366,
-0.184336856007576,
-0.6537392139434814,
-0.7014597058296204,
-0.3207717835903168,
-0.2965703010559082,
0.2800278067588806,
-0.23000141978263855,
0.6087908148765564,
0.22972334921360016,
0.08563051372766495,
0.31915977597236633,
0.061491746455430984,
0.22789646685123444,
-0.5165476202964783,
0.651485025882721,
-0.1776336431503296,
-0.36624643206596375,
0.04551399126648903,
-0.21161018311977386,
0.542168915271759,
0.7650390863418579,
-0.1685958206653595,
0.1339319348335266,
0.34026387333869934,
0.22797891497612,
-0.6821097731590271,
-0.21435299515724182,
-1.0602123737335205,
0.3053034842014313,
0.13727077841758728,
-0.7978312373161316,
-0.5193814039230347,
-0.23171328008174896,
0.08069045841693878,
-0.5198256969451904,
0.7965370416641235,
-0.14256323873996735,
0.6542336344718933,
0.6140081286430359,
-0.49859094619750977,
-0.47874414920806885,
-1.014280080795288,
0.3944298326969147,
-0.14141935110092163,
0.4572225511074066,
0.2749345302581787,
0.5000709295272827,
-0.15571030974388123,
-0.8930826783180237,
-0.8680418133735657,
-0.06666233390569687,
-0.1511964350938797,
-0.0027193559799343348,
0.09137948602437973,
-0.15733006596565247,
0.5984554886817932,
0.48073869943618774,
-0.47878655791282654,
-0.7523356080055237,
-0.39028796553611755,
-0.32094863057136536,
0.26682427525520325,
0.27711614966392517,
0.5272176861763,
-0.21896050870418549,
-0.2941172122955322,
-0.10991547256708145,
-0.4022989869117737,
-0.29999014735221863,
0.2894238531589508,
-0.14286059141159058,
0.18767312169075012,
0.5379944443702698,
-0.02612173557281494,
1.0326544046401978,
0.14485515654087067,
0.22387027740478516,
-0.10814787447452545,
-0.2535499334335327,
-0.2769346833229065,
0.21690160036087036,
0.4618753492832184,
0.21672284603118896,
0.2276826798915863,
-0.6996302008628845,
-0.13525070250034332,
-0.2544254660606384,
0.8474015593528748,
-0.6424168348312378,
-0.2978605628013611,
0.10324601829051971,
-0.3876672089099884,
-0.2996314764022827,
0.14136572182178497,
-0.7391592860221863,
-0.5920771956443787,
-0.36424991488456726,
0.649298369884491,
-0.6237805485725403,
-0.4622194468975067,
-0.07424334436655045,
-0.5753160119056702,
0.38459616899490356,
0.21462540328502655,
-0.9077116847038269,
-0.04845431447029114,
0.3507267236709595,
0.7549655437469482,
-0.23119361698627472,
-0.5241568684577942,
-0.2904738485813141,
0.28295251727104187,
-0.3417987823486328,
0.9321750998497009,
-0.15334193408489227,
-0.4168783128261566,
0.01693486049771309,
0.12546171247959137,
-0.2984187602996826,
-0.7878031730651855,
-0.1592235267162323,
-0.5949099659919739,
0.23517611622810364,
-0.7589901089668274,
-0.3535084128379822,
-0.04829877242445946,
0.23343640565872192,
-0.5144537091255188,
0.7991580963134766,
0.298005610704422,
-0.7030774354934692,
0.5086672902107239,
0.034980740398168564,
-0.3294038474559784,
0.1412138044834137,
-0.5178419351577759,
-0.04085322842001915,
0.5687974095344543,
-0.1301162987947464,
0.22891978919506073,
0.06105316802859306,
0.5906668305397034,
-0.11481340229511261,
-0.5995383858680725,
0.6522483825683594,
-0.5073747038841248,
0.7489001154899597,
0.20853160321712494,
-0.5857815742492676,
0.06480033695697784,
-0.7388262748718262,
-0.09156493842601776,
0.046358492225408554,
0.03326074779033661,
-0.33737972378730774,
0.04519844055175781,
-0.05407506600022316,
0.11930115520954132,
-0.06672029197216034,
-0.1717890053987503,
-0.022740080952644348,
-0.024121731519699097,
0.06512091308832169,
0.6677526235580444,
0.43408048152923584,
0.28616511821746826,
-0.3319390118122101,
0.4467778503894806,
-0.02361101284623146,
-0.20363281667232513,
0.06336169689893723,
-0.44917500019073486,
-0.8383269906044006,
0.34914448857307434,
-0.13874809443950653,
0.12673310935497284,
-1.0005121231079102,
0.34344983100891113,
-0.04187174141407013,
-0.029165897518396378,
-0.09186912328004837,
-0.11893214285373688,
-0.041634391993284225,
1.0044617652893066,
0.39705827832221985,
0.1096513420343399,
-0.7006554007530212,
-0.9185023903846741,
-0.3177233338356018,
-0.011879506520926952,
-0.26462143659591675,
0.24731981754302979,
0.5088710188865662,
-0.2993656098842621,
0.8928995728492737,
-0.4109363257884979,
0.08137070387601852,
-0.24587786197662354,
0.3381175994873047,
-0.3246169984340668,
0.3533850610256195,
0.7391748428344727,
-0.7950360178947449,
-0.07482068985700607,
-0.19556964933872223,
-1.4059207439422607,
-0.061089079827070236,
-0.5414259433746338,
-0.29019951820373535,
-0.11441847681999207,
0.5277509093284607,
-0.774426281452179,
0.3810337483882904,
0.29082441329956055,
-0.37125617265701294,
0.6397209763526917,
-0.06197921559214592,
0.35400012135505676,
-1.3199183940887451,
0.16752971708774567,
-0.6630046963691711,
0.044712308794260025,
-0.6200205683708191,
0.05978779494762421,
-0.08000103384256363,
-0.17199784517288208,
-0.20999597012996674,
0.3173173666000366,
-0.20039214193820953,
-0.14821186661720276,
-0.47477173805236816,
0.05605294555425644,
-0.030602838844060898,
0.28225770592689514,
0.12376774847507477,
1.1641124486923218,
0.462506502866745,
-0.7030296325683594,
0.18282468616962433,
0.24189187586307526,
-0.47188466787338257,
0.5057923197746277,
-0.292015016078949,
0.4344128966331482,
-0.4760151505470276,
-0.09833024442195892,
-0.9110177755355835,
-0.6309491395950317,
0.15892724692821503,
-0.43766146898269653,
0.08447229117155075,
0.18987056612968445,
-0.4199214577674866,
0.024798812344670296,
0.3404330313205719,
0.30635249614715576,
0.732527494430542,
-0.48287686705589294,
0.6970283389091492,
0.1097402423620224,
0.1796032190322876,
-0.24410909414291382,
-0.5753726363182068,
0.029533125460147858,
-0.323917955160141,
-0.35873332619667053,
0.4324604868888855,
0.030593790113925934,
-0.45303741097450256,
0.0790635421872139,
-0.33305856585502625,
-0.28887271881103516,
0.13473372161388397,
0.16046622395515442,
-0.16973793506622314,
-0.0874558761715889,
0.10697299242019653,
0.3133406937122345,
0.3129388689994812,
0.7063494324684143,
-0.046495091170072556,
0.8597692251205444,
0.18367697298526764,
-0.16376665234565735,
-0.38260236382484436,
0.16016800701618195,
0.87123703956604,
0.09921573102474213,
0.9616551399230957,
0.4869796633720398,
-0.6029064655303955,
-0.3780975937843323,
-0.6121917366981506,
-0.3644546568393707,
-0.4655272960662842,
0.29747265577316284,
-0.6696680784225464,
-0.6190944314002991,
0.980690062046051,
0.14895960688591003,
-0.438541978597641,
0.4959561228752136,
0.5891063809394836,
0.02053084783256054,
0.9805689454078674,
0.20401501655578613,
0.3569869101047516,
0.386766642332077,
-0.3637848198413849,
0.16460029780864716,
-0.9463666677474976,
-0.48987913131713867,
-0.12785789370536804,
-0.12165515124797821,
-0.34474706649780273,
-0.19927789270877838,
0.4334252178668976,
0.20368513464927673,
-0.11614330112934113,
0.19722691178321838,
-0.5877403616905212,
0.34512588381767273,
0.14938628673553467,
0.1732649803161621,
0.020297080278396606,
0.009923616424202919,
-0.00025314875529147685,
0.13822300732135773,
-0.5873258709907532,
-0.49429237842559814,
0.9791176915168762,
-0.14898161590099335,
0.3648712933063507,
-0.08706779032945633,
0.6607708930969238,
0.19118085503578186,
0.24196693301200867,
-0.39797431230545044,
0.5728225708007812,
0.671241819858551,
-0.6076610684394836,
-0.18416351079940796,
-0.2909637987613678,
-0.6829401254653931,
0.3509736955165863,
0.020838210359215736,
-0.7971848845481873,
0.28104138374328613,
0.2255752682685852,
-0.47529035806655884,
0.506686270236969,
-0.36552560329437256,
0.7406238317489624,
-0.09145303070545197,
-0.5248717665672302,
-0.021814342588186264,
-0.3495461046695709,
0.6223326325416565,
0.0068533034063875675,
-0.31269600987434387,
0.240942120552063,
0.3913338780403137,
0.6499202847480774,
-0.3172498047351837,
0.4535052478313446,
-0.31228941679000854,
-0.2353024035692215,
0.5925167798995972,
0.33550140261650085,
0.3449559509754181,
0.34702712297439575,
0.0948619619011879,
-0.14410072565078735,
-0.04618710279464722,
-0.13858389854431152,
-0.9592365026473999,
0.7561981678009033,
-0.6431605219841003,
-0.9268996715545654,
-0.39398959279060364,
-1.0777628421783447,
-0.24722178280353546,
0.12309195846319199,
0.7792956233024597,
0.20850621163845062,
-0.21196706593036652,
0.3566749393939972,
1.1717183589935303,
-0.31438809633255005,
0.13050982356071472,
-0.06473466753959656,
-0.21142840385437012,
-0.1528220921754837,
0.5546888709068298,
0.18466316163539886,
0.162819042801857,
-0.0841301903128624,
-0.012344496324658394,
-0.13630197942256927,
-0.41595256328582764,
-0.6312137246131897,
-0.15489426255226135,
-0.8672334551811218,
0.10907469689846039,
-0.9586718082427979,
-0.40843039751052856,
-0.4205610156059265,
-0.1358758807182312,
-0.1397009938955307,
-0.04302200302481651,
-0.3534329831600189,
-0.2250240445137024,
0.11854735016822815,
0.5258464813232422,
0.4110616147518158,
-0.0384029857814312,
-0.29228007793426514,
0.6967841386795044,
0.7762466073036194,
0.01763978973031044,
0.2535279095172882,
-0.5086305737495422,
0.06559376418590546,
0.16408120095729828,
-0.29298579692840576,
-1.3640717267990112,
0.17974013090133667,
-0.2663400173187256,
0.5695794820785522,
0.397602379322052,
0.03163968026638031,
0.8438987135887146,
-0.41487663984298706,
0.9516945481300354,
-0.2029017210006714,
-0.8174145817756653,
0.4486057758331299,
-0.4372905194759369,
0.3907310664653778,
0.7445247769355774,
0.23058299720287323,
-0.36221736669540405,
-0.6385249495506287,
-0.5265828967094421,
-0.46557483077049255,
0.3247007131576538,
0.3705856204032898,
0.4051241874694824,
-0.24738533794879913,
0.7942173480987549,
0.2948090136051178,
0.3436838686466217,
-0.7553420066833496,
-0.09227849543094635,
-0.5308766961097717,
0.12931734323501587,
0.12027747929096222,
-0.30694103240966797,
-0.22395792603492737,
-0.46161726117134094,
0.14184881746768951,
0.013846669346094131,
0.5907454490661621,
0.38210174441337585,
-0.35372889041900635,
-0.2850407660007477,
0.04793477803468704,
0.7685293555259705,
1.092078447341919,
-0.2857082486152649,
0.41129258275032043,
0.363750696182251,
-0.33391526341438293,
0.21961966156959534,
-0.09569370746612549,
-0.5271825790405273,
0.20575900375843048,
0.382438600063324,
0.8339148759841919,
0.03223893418908119,
-0.522593080997467,
0.1750359833240509,
-0.006516150198876858,
-0.23534248769283295,
-0.6462873816490173,
0.44436779618263245,
-0.16686880588531494,
0.11247587949037552,
0.6041684150695801,
0.2797088921070099,
0.46894118189811707,
-0.7227283120155334,
0.35997289419174194,
0.5988883376121521,
-0.4809766709804535,
-0.5453259348869324,
1.0432862043380737,
-0.3325522243976593,
-0.3795366585254669,
0.8488718271255493,
-0.18217846751213074,
-0.5823181867599487,
0.7276964783668518,
0.7288609147071838,
1.2152541875839233,
-0.29554426670074463,
0.16480962932109833,
0.3306911587715149,
0.18913739919662476,
-0.02102951891720295,
0.3582342863082886,
-0.5522419214248657,
-0.8561275601387024,
-0.1127447858452797,
-0.706829309463501,
-0.04091911390423775,
0.6237276792526245,
-0.9787434935569763,
-0.03794615715742111,
-0.16020400822162628,
-0.07877876609563828,
-0.29253652691841125,
-0.7311108112335205,
-0.6512951254844666,
0.2245677262544632,
0.11519340425729752,
0.44214484095573425,
-0.8561903238296509,
0.9112077355384827,
0.6061223745346069,
-0.36570602655410767,
-0.3555830121040344,
0.619503915309906,
-0.39660918712615967,
-0.5148581862449646,
0.5160601139068604,
0.4096163213253021,
-0.20427633821964264,
0.15155185759067535,
-0.4321189522743225,
-0.7965884804725647,
1.0866540670394897,
0.311941921710968,
-0.15676249563694,
-0.14378109574317932,
0.16427680850028992,
0.7685946822166443,
-0.1943240612745285,
-0.37589603662490845,
0.5664349794387817,
0.3616454303264618,
-0.013872090727090836,
-0.4513095021247864,
0.2889850437641144,
-0.19729603826999664,
0.02979893982410431,
0.2418123185634613,
-0.2981913387775421,
0.7997681498527527,
0.051952846348285675,
-0.2871856987476349,
0.16172084212303162,
0.5559098720550537,
0.3413185775279999,
0.41890737414360046,
0.3933970034122467,
0.5613308548927307,
0.559575617313385,
-0.07774537801742554,
1.1878200769424438,
-0.5106750130653381,
0.17476721107959747,
0.9485012888908386,
-0.373677521944046,
0.38930514454841614,
0.9249449968338013,
0.0886138379573822,
0.7209500670433044,
0.4089798629283905,
0.15380889177322388,
0.8161937594413757,
0.06116636469960213,
-0.4076773524284363,
-0.31709951162338257,
0.12019646167755127,
-0.5741531848907471,
0.1873805820941925,
0.17279301583766937,
-0.5758028626441956,
-0.03657696023583412,
0.4084545075893402,
-0.35074135661125183,
0.02051682025194168,
0.1570202261209488,
0.8133576512336731,
-0.15437446534633636,
-1.1465216875076294,
0.7090607285499573,
-0.4954572916030884,
0.06855455785989761,
-0.4119904339313507,
-0.1892387568950653,
-0.3872113823890686,
-0.03750745579600334,
0.073729507625103,
-0.4153875410556793,
0.7873759269714355,
-0.15738508105278015,
-0.22510117292404175,
-0.34900346398353577,
0.7101624011993408,
-0.3245590925216675,
-0.24563409388065338,
0.12939760088920593,
0.5437893271446228,
0.08542103320360184,
-0.2698909044265747,
-0.1617240011692047,
0.041956137865781784,
-0.022806711494922638,
-0.3019814193248749,
0.3897448182106018,
0.5763174891471863,
0.07127460092306137,
0.36366111040115356,
0.2595152258872986,
-0.01121106743812561,
0.2642575800418854,
-0.1577804684638977,
0.747912585735321,
-0.5877444744110107,
-0.28229305148124695,
-0.7773703336715698,
0.3846355378627777,
-0.149326354265213,
-0.4301302433013916,
0.9118608236312866,
0.6359161734580994,
0.9614691138267517,
-0.3164832890033722,
0.8599253296852112,
-0.3395288288593292,
-0.08663472533226013,
-0.4645329713821411,
1.0260432958602905,
-0.6746718883514404,
0.11652178317308426,
-0.06145605444908142,
-1.2644546031951904,
0.021739155054092407,
0.6439043283462524,
-0.30277714133262634,
-0.0674339234828949,
0.8383055925369263,
0.6470736861228943,
-0.16452841460704803,
0.054340314120054245,
0.4231947362422943,
0.007580120582133532,
-0.015396623872220516,
0.33636385202407837,
1.1428993940353394,
-0.4607878029346466,
0.3257586359977722,
-0.4380623698234558,
0.19051484763622284,
0.07991649955511093,
-0.4232616722583771,
-0.995858371257782,
-1.0024000406265259,
-0.18596866726875305,
-0.5119693875312805,
0.12504111230373383,
0.36366644501686096,
0.3311551511287689,
-0.846859872341156,
-0.15707072615623474,
-0.6964350938796997,
-0.026261106133461,
-0.3873310089111328,
-0.34161826968193054,
0.38601917028427124,
-0.5975600481033325,
-0.5002718567848206,
0.35941049456596375,
0.13891173899173737,
0.29616305232048035,
-0.44494929909706116,
0.08860143274068832,
0.09619367867708206,
-0.0306251160800457,
0.5115970373153687,
-0.016093416139483452,
-0.9172140955924988,
-0.4483177661895752,
0.2151138186454773,
0.10544629395008087,
-0.08126451075077057,
1.1661248207092285,
-0.9503030776977539,
0.8120709657669067,
0.6652845740318298,
0.5338072776794434,
0.4607134759426117,
0.0687061995267868,
0.6855629086494446,
-0.6348993182182312,
0.4120200574398041,
0.14086255431175232,
0.32346415519714355,
0.21827028691768646,
-0.6412956118583679,
0.20478522777557373,
0.3949371874332428,
-0.42209500074386597,
-1.1547117233276367,
0.28436586260795593,
-0.49541640281677246,
-0.5942734479904175,
1.0905708074569702,
0.23180320858955383,
-0.046592503786087036,
-0.19797712564468384,
-0.12628619372844696,
0.6770326495170593,
0.46958959102630615,
1.4058434963226318,
0.8584595918655396,
-0.4346163272857666,
-0.18896037340164185,
-0.6527484059333801,
0.8227682113647461,
0.3779062032699585,
-0.6142441630363464,
0.021039698272943497,
0.6001189947128296,
0.2621403932571411,
0.2448633760213852,
0.4100867807865143,
0.17685793340206146,
0.4422930181026459,
0.18477950990200043,
-0.08582749217748642,
0.03988207131624222,
-0.46939530968666077,
-0.12593553960323334,
0.6518748998641968,
-0.1450532227754593,
-0.029735345393419266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14484v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14484v2
|
Is ChatGPT the Future of Causal Text Mining? A Comprehensive Evaluation and Analysis
| 2024-02-22T12:19:04 | 2024-02-23T11:50:18 |
Takehiro Takayanagi, Masahiro Suzuki, Ryotaro Kobayashi, Hiroki Sakaji, Kiyoshi Izumi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Causality is fundamental in human cognition and has drawn attention in
diverse research fields. With growing volumes of textual data, discerning
causalities within text data is crucial, and causal text mining plays a pivotal
role in extracting meaningful patterns. This study conducts comprehensive
evaluations of ChatGPT's causal text mining capabilities. Firstly, we introduce
a benchmark that extends beyond general English datasets, including
domain-specific and non-English datasets. We also provide an evaluation
framework to ensure fair comparisons between ChatGPT and previous approaches.
Finally, our analysis outlines the limitations and future challenges in
employing ChatGPT for causal text mining. Specifically, our analysis reveals
that ChatGPT serves as a good starting point for various datasets. However,
when equipped with a sufficient amount of training data, previous models still
surpass ChatGPT's performance. Additionally, ChatGPT suffers from the tendency
to falsely recognize non-causal sequences as causal sequences. These issues
become even more pronounced with advanced versions of the model, such as GPT-4.
In addition, we highlight the constraints of ChatGPT in handling complex
causality types, including both intra/inter-sentential and implicit causality.
The model also faces challenges with effectively leveraging in-context learning
and domain adaptation. We release our code to support further research and
development in this field.
|
[
0.08946408331394196,
-0.7973096370697021,
0.6532418131828308,
0.457809180021286,
-0.1841260939836502,
-0.2902602255344391,
-0.023815985769033432,
-0.6270807385444641,
-0.30945566296577454,
0.27177906036376953,
-0.5882722735404968,
-0.28074344992637634,
-0.8294505476951599,
0.08653665333986282,
-0.5816089510917664,
1.2077982425689697,
0.04731236770749092,
-0.032959021627902985,
-0.10439449548721313,
0.035956405103206635,
-1.1234662532806396,
-0.644165575504303,
-1.089577555656433,
-0.41939327120780945,
0.4770687520503998,
0.301279753446579,
0.3484512269496918,
0.1709519922733307,
0.6196726560592651,
0.27293309569358826,
0.18534204363822937,
-0.06071151793003082,
-0.6870807409286499,
0.17626725137233734,
-0.18853530287742615,
-0.3979136049747467,
-0.15726067125797272,
0.1345037966966629,
0.4927769899368286,
0.65276700258255,
-0.040184855461120605,
-0.120636485517025,
0.3251080811023712,
0.5386611223220825,
-0.18840238451957703,
0.5752794742584229,
-0.6297680139541626,
-0.047511108219623566,
-0.33032962679862976,
-0.5414248704910278,
-0.5211337208747864,
-0.3767809569835663,
0.3859056532382965,
-0.3261510729789734,
0.3798823058605194,
0.4033929109573364,
0.8259454369544983,
0.34143728017807007,
-0.9461016654968262,
-0.34444940090179443,
-0.7559901475906372,
0.5290133953094482,
-0.5068597197532654,
0.4056541621685028,
0.3873841464519501,
0.2980833947658539,
-0.4974724352359772,
-0.9158780574798584,
-0.3624265193939209,
-0.29430219531059265,
-0.1385776251554489,
0.5319887399673462,
-0.14276133477687836,
-0.221183642745018,
0.25744888186454773,
0.17133979499340057,
-0.7813271284103394,
-0.010599023662507534,
-0.16144590079784393,
-0.1751358062028885,
0.2965858578681946,
0.3089776039123535,
0.597480833530426,
-0.19767962396144867,
-0.6835372447967529,
0.23075127601623535,
-0.8413119912147522,
-0.2013925313949585,
0.3153075873851776,
0.22291387617588043,
-0.09372296184301376,
0.4056616723537445,
0.08760906010866165,
0.4018424451351166,
-0.3107004761695862,
0.2899670898914337,
-0.28139814734458923,
-0.17848972976207733,
-0.11910481750965118,
0.14675970375537872,
0.8638663291931152,
0.4139581024646759,
0.19764573872089386,
-0.39622581005096436,
0.13791486620903015,
0.07639456540346146,
0.10539217293262482,
-0.8574625253677368,
-0.3811757564544678,
-0.043279312551021576,
-0.3516665995121002,
-0.25788798928260803,
0.0063560884445905685,
-0.6793654561042786,
-0.5638429522514343,
-0.435051292181015,
0.3727721571922302,
-0.5169717073440552,
-0.09596538543701172,
0.2309345006942749,
-0.30400559306144714,
0.3606747090816498,
0.32594090700149536,
-0.6758187413215637,
0.3677508234977722,
0.7156139016151428,
0.9196703433990479,
-0.14294353127479553,
-0.40960070490837097,
-0.3479961156845093,
0.16109052300453186,
-0.1765274852514267,
1.0916612148284912,
-0.44421231746673584,
-0.28200438618659973,
-0.025604119524359703,
-0.04410110414028168,
-0.4942323863506317,
-0.08920648694038391,
1.0655105113983154,
-0.5571163892745972,
0.4860197603702545,
-0.41323938965797424,
-0.750507652759552,
-0.26952651143074036,
0.25223639607429504,
-0.6473166346549988,
0.860697329044342,
-0.41881832480430603,
-1.0854096412658691,
0.6142390370368958,
-0.2203628569841385,
-0.6465511322021484,
-0.0026694792322814465,
-0.18606479465961456,
-0.584463894367218,
-0.2401694357395172,
-0.09555237740278244,
0.5164442658424377,
-0.7793425917625427,
0.7445480227470398,
-0.3156193792819977,
-0.43825599551200867,
0.12554793059825897,
-0.8704925179481506,
0.6477015018463135,
-0.15515276789665222,
-0.5420064330101013,
-0.21555526554584503,
-0.6525594592094421,
-0.45613792538642883,
-0.02039739117026329,
0.07687339931726456,
-0.30819758772850037,
0.5475246906280518,
0.24152544140815735,
0.42015430331230164,
-0.036009207367897034,
-0.38133612275123596,
0.031157054007053375,
-0.0710952952504158,
0.4186581075191498,
0.8431401252746582,
0.4098225235939026,
0.05180623382329941,
-0.30249959230422974,
0.1873316913843155,
-0.166644886136055,
0.2054620236158371,
-0.18630138039588928,
-0.8437110781669617,
-0.49459171295166016,
-0.09299628436565399,
0.1539946049451828,
0.7437755465507507,
-0.5334643125534058,
0.34977397322654724,
-0.19980625808238983,
-0.5709120631217957,
0.5500956773757935,
-0.5251907110214233,
0.4291147291660309,
0.744078516960144,
0.25974395871162415,
-0.28608307242393494,
-0.4124951660633087,
-0.6405746936798096,
-0.6264846324920654,
-0.27080419659614563,
0.05416582524776459,
0.24765099585056305,
0.4242115020751953,
-0.21534240245819092,
0.9313585758209229,
-0.6452462673187256,
-0.4154331684112549,
0.12094994634389877,
0.4231436252593994,
0.32604795694351196,
0.3496239185333252,
0.18999476730823517,
-0.9232257604598999,
-0.3546012043952942,
0.09230755269527435,
-0.8268086314201355,
-0.19432054460048676,
-0.38691163063049316,
-0.1566518396139145,
-0.19702492654323578,
0.7054432034492493,
-0.5258635878562927,
0.22045713663101196,
0.33932775259017944,
-0.7445423007011414,
0.7752318978309631,
-0.06852208077907562,
0.3569444417953491,
-0.8906177878379822,
0.307309091091156,
0.07106485962867737,
-0.10838539898395538,
-0.7718687653541565,
-0.5769789218902588,
0.0019116305047646165,
-0.3305650055408478,
0.026399191468954086,
0.583090603351593,
-0.14548847079277039,
0.3117314875125885,
-0.18369825184345245,
0.13515152037143707,
-0.34684887528419495,
0.5401168465614319,
0.04121517017483711,
0.48022523522377014,
0.28584808111190796,
-0.5516926646232605,
-0.012252794578671455,
0.2250252217054367,
-0.22003880143165588,
0.5210820436477661,
-0.742604672908783,
-0.24363739788532257,
-0.08163755387067795,
0.3913404941558838,
-1.0525870323181152,
-0.1537882685661316,
0.2471938282251358,
-0.4259277582168579,
0.29442110657691956,
-0.16327226161956787,
-0.562782883644104,
0.03044714406132698,
-0.11543199419975281,
0.1686181277036667,
0.35877570509910583,
-0.4736292064189911,
0.2880809009075165,
0.2482798993587494,
-0.1349792778491974,
-0.41970980167388916,
-0.1621466428041458,
0.25936809182167053,
-0.3468093276023865,
-0.4640176594257355,
0.21144795417785645,
0.14741753041744232,
0.13216514885425568,
-0.027754632756114006,
-0.20798392593860626,
-0.11246813088655472,
0.07290749251842499,
0.385384738445282,
0.1600014567375183,
0.25919443368911743,
0.39211681485176086,
-0.11002958565950394,
-0.450838178396225,
0.2775142788887024,
-0.3409195840358734,
0.4517524838447571,
0.05980898067355156,
-0.3349142372608185,
-0.20467230677604675,
0.055512912571430206,
0.24154570698738098,
-0.11546165496110916,
0.4589316248893738,
0.6923104524612427,
-0.37410083413124084,
0.07679885625839233,
-0.40951597690582275,
-0.11103891581296921,
-0.3637285530567169,
0.28668180108070374,
-0.019746724516153336,
-0.8216491341590881,
0.48661860823631287,
-0.38409265875816345,
-0.06207234412431717,
0.6322591304779053,
0.4346196949481964,
0.11318103969097137,
0.7408446073532104,
0.5231923460960388,
-0.29919949173927307,
0.4747307300567627,
0.2956796884536743,
0.5378967523574829,
-0.4619463384151459,
-0.3168838918209076,
-0.5985571146011353,
0.2010291963815689,
-0.8934721946716309,
-0.10863849520683289,
0.2712441384792328,
-0.05719207227230072,
-0.502740740776062,
0.3374403119087219,
-0.07973701506853104,
0.32366594672203064,
0.2884405255317688,
0.2403372824192047,
0.5215302109718323,
-0.27761685848236084,
0.24545139074325562,
-0.007500796113163233,
-0.6437141299247742,
-0.48052361607551575,
0.9517423510551453,
0.07480865716934204,
0.48819679021835327,
0.05134258791804314,
0.3136308491230011,
0.36880502104759216,
0.38480499386787415,
-0.3349258303642273,
0.34548038244247437,
-0.06299382448196411,
-0.6517990231513977,
-0.2165975570678711,
-0.4066033363342285,
-1.0651906728744507,
0.19582027196884155,
-0.21357597410678864,
-0.6901800036430359,
0.06443903595209122,
0.0565238855779171,
0.15934449434280396,
0.12914635241031647,
-1.0241420269012451,
1.0013093948364258,
0.04114999622106552,
-0.5175377726554871,
-0.09746650606393814,
-0.6503987312316895,
0.647765576839447,
-0.29316359758377075,
0.10842497646808624,
-0.18350441753864288,
0.12530140578746796,
0.8003358244895935,
-0.26568809151649475,
1.1838970184326172,
-0.040984537452459335,
-0.0543610081076622,
0.032470133155584335,
-0.15693625807762146,
0.6081705093383789,
0.3128916323184967,
0.13603639602661133,
0.3800392150878906,
0.0028125252574682236,
-0.31505510210990906,
-0.4832974374294281,
0.7957931160926819,
-0.5472955703735352,
-0.32942089438438416,
-0.6872525811195374,
-0.11827999353408813,
-0.47549352049827576,
0.3962553143501282,
0.23357242345809937,
0.5836639404296875,
-0.6013587117195129,
-0.2167568802833557,
0.5446111559867859,
-0.38591280579566956,
0.41780737042427063,
0.45752185583114624,
0.22472190856933594,
-0.11601708084344864,
1.0459353923797607,
-0.1760961264371872,
-0.12088825553655624,
0.6142166256904602,
0.37365052103996277,
-0.2200174331665039,
-0.2839803993701935,
-0.08879352360963821,
-0.0028565938118845224,
-0.48548924922943115,
-0.3199668526649475,
-0.6861988306045532,
-0.01567140966653824,
-0.05422394350171089,
-0.019179897382855415,
-0.15404680371284485,
-0.23543237149715424,
-0.016518808901309967,
0.086751289665699,
0.3694712221622467,
0.6860831379890442,
0.213375985622406,
0.30664071440696716,
-0.6450139284133911,
0.16171219944953918,
0.39980432391166687,
0.5076311230659485,
0.0893758237361908,
-0.07626084238290787,
-0.21729281544685364,
-0.4066530168056488,
-0.32938775420188904,
-0.8523138761520386,
0.3285824656486511,
0.2044900804758072,
0.3179008364677429,
0.320615291595459,
-0.12456991523504257,
0.5805252194404602,
-1.1002856492996216,
0.7910881638526917,
0.1787191778421402,
-0.7371322512626648,
0.3093396723270416,
-0.6952880024909973,
0.004273743834346533,
0.35317671298980713,
0.4982939064502716,
-1.0596883296966553,
-0.3790040612220764,
-0.8012670874595642,
-0.8301464319229126,
0.5675663948059082,
0.6437195539474487,
-0.214199960231781,
-0.15948797762393951,
0.4214102327823639,
0.22621247172355652,
-0.1100541353225708,
-0.5780083537101746,
-0.1620512753725052,
0.02822147309780121,
-0.006867151707410812,
-0.24180319905281067,
-0.21115384995937347,
0.204067200422287,
0.06970255821943283,
0.7942658066749573,
0.1870885044336319,
0.5213043689727783,
0.21148470044136047,
-0.10134467482566833,
0.3149604797363281,
0.12858818471431732,
0.28645971417427063,
0.45863696932792664,
-0.26903674006462097,
-0.08804984390735626,
0.17331577837467194,
-0.6899772882461548,
0.01987873762845993,
0.45775294303894043,
-0.029458090662956238,
-0.09803865849971771,
0.8272917866706848,
0.5945053100585938,
0.7179190516471863,
-0.5222587585449219,
0.7340133190155029,
-0.3343324661254883,
0.10843125730752945,
-0.2882609963417053,
-0.23358169198036194,
-0.24549180269241333,
0.23887592554092407,
0.23533225059509277,
0.10073082894086838,
0.5178122520446777,
-0.31451401114463806,
0.22740492224693298,
0.354110985994339,
-0.5571553111076355,
-0.36733347177505493,
0.8577565550804138,
0.10303550213575363,
0.24740196764469147,
0.49017980694770813,
0.05020212382078171,
-0.5992642045021057,
0.645473301410675,
0.4798825979232788,
0.9895613193511963,
-0.18524043262004852,
0.0542885884642601,
0.42675670981407166,
0.43815237283706665,
-0.2689060568809509,
-0.13662753999233246,
0.037734054028987885,
-0.6904538869857788,
-0.5231689810752869,
-0.27516573667526245,
-0.570087194442749,
-0.23161311447620392,
-0.29076337814331055,
0.578456461429596,
-0.003784449305385351,
0.07741109281778336,
-0.09446685761213303,
-0.0064965179190039635,
-0.5235751271247864,
0.27141281962394714,
-0.2687460482120514,
0.41815465688705444,
-0.9607322216033936,
0.6762828826904297,
0.3053167164325714,
-0.3474295139312744,
-0.5464964509010315,
0.12098885327577591,
0.11177680641412735,
-0.5534065961837769,
0.5544359087944031,
0.3149236738681793,
0.01452880073338747,
-0.04475343972444534,
-0.3305911123752594,
-0.5243196487426758,
1.15985107421875,
0.18331104516983032,
-0.4481230080127716,
0.09498756378889084,
0.10134757310152054,
0.5014424324035645,
0.35741907358169556,
0.5895822048187256,
0.5014978647232056,
0.38500216603279114,
-0.07391683012247086,
-0.5754812359809875,
0.23614147305488586,
-0.17563486099243164,
-0.03941426798701286,
0.37577009201049805,
-0.594390332698822,
0.6374981999397278,
0.34023547172546387,
-0.34593814611434937,
-0.3054380416870117,
0.39854979515075684,
-0.0012086762581020594,
0.3496066927909851,
0.2793509364128113,
0.4161551892757416,
0.8025506734848022,
-0.2281641811132431,
1.1514194011688232,
-0.2676551640033722,
0.5419633388519287,
1.0427945852279663,
-0.3277857303619385,
0.4383670687675476,
0.2683316767215729,
-0.18552692234516144,
0.31837230920791626,
0.6506209969520569,
0.2035747468471527,
0.41838040947914124,
-0.0905851200222969,
-0.38914844393730164,
-0.13677772879600525,
0.17872248589992523,
-0.34478098154067993,
0.20594522356987,
0.1976947784423828,
-0.004195569548755884,
-0.44853630661964417,
-0.16847971081733704,
0.16300635039806366,
-0.24526135623455048,
-0.02586672082543373,
0.6955639719963074,
0.15858076512813568,
-0.5343750715255737,
-0.04537898302078247,
-0.02422076091170311,
0.4438183605670929,
-0.7435852289199829,
-0.18971987068653107,
-0.3499363958835602,
0.21757206320762634,
-0.11243980377912521,
-0.4855181872844696,
0.273747056722641,
-0.10258251428604126,
0.08595886081457138,
-0.21086199581623077,
1.1162911653518677,
-0.1947043389081955,
-0.19000309705734253,
0.17732039093971252,
0.3428550362586975,
-0.0005244566709734499,
-0.3944893479347229,
-0.40282753109931946,
-0.3247825801372528,
-0.13473902642726898,
-0.13739752769470215,
0.30910319089889526,
0.7791262269020081,
-0.38641831278800964,
0.4410730302333832,
0.7718446254730225,
-0.22836250066757202,
-0.11681738495826721,
0.13320666551589966,
0.7707841396331787,
-0.9071688055992126,
-0.4131808876991272,
-1.1093966960906982,
0.319160133600235,
-0.20340761542320251,
-0.3816375136375427,
1.0446407794952393,
0.5522406101226807,
0.49686315655708313,
0.010789833031594753,
0.6652506589889526,
-0.13627131283283234,
0.21792414784431458,
-0.6315100789070129,
0.6505180597305298,
-0.10879442095756531,
0.22286976873874664,
-0.6612088680267334,
-0.8243390321731567,
-0.6456206440925598,
0.2179265320301056,
-0.5193232893943787,
-0.1362638771533966,
1.0883985757827759,
0.4191206395626068,
0.04214700311422348,
0.648758590221405,
0.19393008947372437,
0.1651267111301422,
0.6939464211463928,
0.5153040885925293,
0.9187498688697815,
-0.7212985157966614,
0.5805472135543823,
0.11612983047962189,
-0.5473214983940125,
0.017847754061222076,
-1.0990456342697144,
-0.8572959303855896,
-0.8776230812072754,
-0.2394234538078308,
-0.006549263373017311,
0.2687920331954956,
0.34731778502464294,
0.4195055365562439,
-0.5180648565292358,
-0.05356105789542198,
-0.5221149325370789,
0.24985244870185852,
-0.2669402062892914,
-0.23350095748901367,
0.6556006073951721,
-0.7063426375389099,
-0.4622935354709625,
0.08259190618991852,
0.3637475371360779,
-0.24110618233680725,
0.31581932306289673,
0.17394104599952698,
-0.27240949869155884,
-0.06609228998422623,
1.0642145872116089,
0.25778064131736755,
0.01900126412510872,
-0.311752587556839,
-0.25032076239585876,
0.1357109695672989,
-0.23307256400585175,
1.182464361190796,
-0.5259955525398254,
0.22577489912509918,
0.3095915913581848,
0.5735819935798645,
0.7036250829696655,
-0.23739919066429138,
0.6524729132652283,
-0.5396655201911926,
0.1482197344303131,
-0.00408038217574358,
0.42280757427215576,
0.07546192407608032,
-0.46827301383018494,
0.6177666187286377,
0.42518866062164307,
-0.9295282363891602,
-0.4283579885959625,
0.06677058339118958,
-0.9814783930778503,
-0.12529237568378448,
1.0879005193710327,
0.07398983836174011,
0.09376731514930725,
-0.4601389169692993,
-0.4920777678489685,
0.27540141344070435,
-0.25265809893608093,
0.7594581246376038,
0.7608562707901001,
-0.3116898834705353,
0.1347944438457489,
-0.8702889680862427,
0.5551230311393738,
0.2370956838130951,
-0.919472336769104,
0.22135436534881592,
0.5970314741134644,
0.08579117059707642,
-0.41028863191604614,
0.7247905731201172,
-0.3413145840167999,
0.10540527105331421,
-0.1005343422293663,
-0.0713546872138977,
0.42161455750465393,
-0.12394056469202042,
-0.22288361191749573,
0.027836328372359276,
-0.050051044672727585,
0.11212766915559769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14474v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14474v1
|
Data Science with LLMs and Interpretable Models
| 2024-02-22T12:04:15 | 2024-02-22T12:04:15 |
Sebastian Bordt, Ben Lengerich, Harsha Nori, Rich Caruana
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Recent years have seen important advances in the building of interpretable
models, machine learning models that are designed to be easily understood by
humans. In this work, we show that large language models (LLMs) are remarkably
good at working with interpretable models, too. In particular, we show that
LLMs can describe, interpret, and debug Generalized Additive Models (GAMs).
Combining the flexibility of LLMs with the breadth of statistical patterns
accurately described by GAMs enables dataset summarization, question answering,
and model critique. LLMs can also improve the interaction between domain
experts and interpretable models, and generate hypotheses about the underlying
phenomenon. We release \url{https://github.com/interpretml/TalkToEBM} as an
open-source LLM-GAM interface.
|
[
-0.059482380747795105,
-1.1811529397964478,
1.0331517457962036,
0.23062561452388763,
-0.20060595870018005,
0.15236106514930725,
-0.3325199484825134,
-0.7252504229545593,
0.0036894793156534433,
0.5021836757659912,
-0.30937719345092773,
-0.6801220178604126,
-0.6678539514541626,
-0.0636296421289444,
-0.7083378434181213,
0.7398988604545593,
0.10173113644123077,
0.35315340757369995,
-0.5498813390731812,
-0.08977534621953964,
-0.29095059633255005,
-0.6294696927070618,
-0.7395357489585876,
-0.6689131259918213,
0.45011863112449646,
0.2790777385234833,
1.0766477584838867,
0.8640729784965515,
0.5804157257080078,
0.2838730216026306,
-0.2192511260509491,
0.18252357840538025,
-0.2971956431865692,
0.2322218269109726,
-0.24019475281238556,
-0.6270093321800232,
-1.0605376958847046,
-0.12027492374181747,
0.5957955121994019,
1.0955129861831665,
-0.16064666211605072,
0.19233238697052002,
0.12983493506908417,
0.44422978162765503,
-0.10763032734394073,
0.6262869238853455,
-0.5346897840499878,
-0.308718204498291,
-0.09597267955541611,
-0.20188380777835846,
-0.5436504483222961,
-0.2687567174434662,
0.0500975139439106,
-0.5074293613433838,
0.3970029950141907,
-0.02062889188528061,
0.5124882459640503,
0.20208556950092316,
-0.4701972007751465,
-0.5784636735916138,
-0.8882222771644592,
0.8327757716178894,
-0.6115957498550415,
0.5050779581069946,
0.32687893509864807,
0.3521627187728882,
-0.5401714444160461,
-0.8244679570198059,
-0.5666881799697876,
-0.1416957527399063,
-0.23959621787071228,
-0.11710608005523682,
-0.2634197771549225,
0.12259627133607864,
0.14772392809391022,
0.6016075015068054,
-0.631321132183075,
0.33449769020080566,
-0.25693491101264954,
-0.10285262763500214,
0.71684730052948,
0.6735689043998718,
0.3918692469596863,
0.09475577622652054,
-0.011616340838372707,
0.4646121859550476,
-0.8306059837341309,
-0.36013710498809814,
0.22610075771808624,
0.4647503197193146,
-0.16931697726249695,
0.529371976852417,
-0.1727363020181656,
1.075724482536316,
-0.3763362169265747,
0.26426926255226135,
0.020636586472392082,
-0.1956896185874939,
-0.46732038259506226,
-0.36548635363578796,
0.32535073161125183,
0.18188272416591644,
0.3102084696292877,
-0.3549455404281616,
0.1464574933052063,
-0.08884309232234955,
0.05943505838513374,
-0.8239978551864624,
-0.4289901852607727,
0.3527192771434784,
-0.6245349645614624,
-0.2812023460865021,
-0.1096692606806755,
-0.7833134531974792,
-0.6460620164871216,
-0.6687689423561096,
0.4519648253917694,
-0.033861659467220306,
-0.18634527921676636,
0.5299365520477295,
-0.019223295152187347,
0.21068203449249268,
0.42244696617126465,
-0.8597461581230164,
0.539968729019165,
0.7574266791343689,
1.0850952863693237,
-0.22003012895584106,
0.004159427713602781,
-0.449128121137619,
0.21891216933727264,
-0.4486478269100189,
0.6989343166351318,
-0.6893056035041809,
-0.5551373958587646,
-0.2619728744029999,
0.13850846886634827,
0.06375546753406525,
-0.5031827688217163,
0.4166952967643738,
-0.7178545594215393,
0.1455238163471222,
-0.091715507209301,
-0.8325559496879578,
-0.38422250747680664,
0.04568011313676834,
-0.6213208436965942,
0.5673330426216125,
0.0632224753499031,
-0.38836511969566345,
0.13599495589733124,
-0.8949257135391235,
-0.3094935417175293,
0.12290351092815399,
-0.07308898121118546,
-0.40217718482017517,
0.2743881046772003,
0.08087584376335144,
0.6416124105453491,
-0.3821772038936615,
0.3936859369277954,
-0.7425656914710999,
-0.10506441444158554,
0.45731320977211,
-0.35600048303604126,
0.5598459839820862,
0.5274413824081421,
0.1399098038673401,
0.2922234833240509,
-0.9673305749893188,
0.09580928087234497,
0.23985087871551514,
-0.21984580159187317,
-0.21072521805763245,
0.29930922389030457,
-0.18308311700820923,
-0.04885003715753555,
0.04428070783615112,
-0.08985690027475357,
0.3470267355442047,
-0.17410480976104736,
0.612319827079773,
0.760613203048706,
-0.10332541912794113,
0.456601619720459,
0.00997143518179655,
0.6092527508735657,
-0.04829559475183487,
-0.14877037703990936,
-0.1173940896987915,
-0.49019673466682434,
-0.6965515613555908,
-0.589275062084198,
0.21673375368118286,
0.4680112302303314,
-0.6361532211303711,
0.2648680508136749,
-0.3775571882724762,
-0.45926016569137573,
-0.273608922958374,
0.21573220193386078,
-0.10582420229911804,
0.6550756096839905,
0.37996935844421387,
-0.04810246080160141,
-0.6558893918991089,
-0.857617974281311,
-0.3108111619949341,
-0.06622730195522308,
-0.35738715529441833,
0.24386747181415558,
0.37303611636161804,
-0.46590185165405273,
0.8590587377548218,
-1.0130325555801392,
0.08393853157758713,
-0.35350728034973145,
0.15112844109535217,
0.351298987865448,
0.0808212012052536,
0.46777278184890747,
-0.5960158109664917,
-0.40281611680984497,
-0.06745831668376923,
-0.8913047909736633,
-0.20392164587974548,
0.15090462565422058,
-0.02857574261724949,
-0.08458347618579865,
0.47053849697113037,
-0.4623596668243408,
0.2861135005950928,
0.37105852365493774,
-0.6317989826202393,
0.5040472745895386,
-0.3250640630722046,
-0.008704044856131077,
-0.9139384031295776,
0.05063118413090706,
-0.001411941833794117,
-0.46938949823379517,
-0.9305583238601685,
-0.14782609045505524,
0.031173348426818848,
-0.18584425747394562,
-0.2078244984149933,
0.909412682056427,
-0.5480542778968811,
-0.4078468680381775,
-0.4983503818511963,
-0.27336469292640686,
0.00444452278316021,
-0.03581162914633751,
0.1848718225955963,
0.7585625052452087,
0.9950024485588074,
-0.8379634022712708,
0.4887065291404724,
0.37192410230636597,
-0.5895575284957886,
0.3885406255722046,
-0.8616999387741089,
0.1458551436662674,
-0.10578230768442154,
0.17741242051124573,
-0.786659300327301,
-0.6892442107200623,
0.2195822149515152,
-0.35314083099365234,
0.2963298261165619,
-0.022608377039432526,
-0.48069170117378235,
-0.18417030572891235,
-0.052281640470027924,
0.040402624756097794,
0.3912395238876343,
-0.7821247577667236,
0.6123155951499939,
0.4685978293418884,
-0.536443293094635,
-0.17319531738758087,
-0.7326902151107788,
0.22593329846858978,
-0.5226935744285583,
-0.6341795921325684,
0.011889277957379818,
-0.23517362773418427,
-0.5055795311927795,
0.12094029784202576,
0.10216587036848068,
-0.32480496168136597,
0.3862912952899933,
0.10791880637407303,
0.5502583384513855,
-0.12992051243782043,
0.46781766414642334,
-0.23789407312870026,
-0.15130199491977692,
0.19233228266239166,
-0.04481269046664238,
0.40822967886924744,
-0.24825003743171692,
-0.3457963764667511,
0.026298275217413902,
0.2252425253391266,
0.5030365586280823,
0.23144318163394928,
0.8411086201667786,
0.3708367347717285,
-0.2744539678096771,
-0.2655285894870758,
0.030117405578494072,
-0.11642374843358994,
-0.502067506313324,
0.4445013701915741,
-0.4219318628311157,
-0.8479514122009277,
0.7978638410568237,
-0.015963692218065262,
-0.22057950496673584,
0.35179176926612854,
0.6513577699661255,
0.02677878364920616,
1.465133547782898,
0.7250705361366272,
-0.08861710876226425,
0.2840421199798584,
-0.08612548559904099,
0.14196588099002838,
-0.5446377396583557,
-0.15576229989528656,
-0.4742255210876465,
-0.07287745177745819,
-0.38010174036026,
-0.3928089737892151,
0.1561403125524521,
0.09283909201622009,
-0.10515540093183517,
-0.189497172832489,
-0.3749290704727173,
0.679290771484375,
0.12484893202781677,
0.08131682872772217,
0.4748041033744812,
0.03628630191087723,
0.45676806569099426,
0.14710190892219543,
-0.4485795199871063,
-0.7913390398025513,
1.202718734741211,
0.5855594277381897,
1.2812190055847168,
0.1728922724723816,
0.2142227292060852,
0.5073569416999817,
0.4388597309589386,
-0.9352742433547974,
0.522405207157135,
-0.1261553019285202,
-0.5990774631500244,
-0.10452082008123398,
-0.6085845232009888,
-1.0394296646118164,
0.23290196061134338,
-0.08538942039012909,
-0.7394982576370239,
0.1796056032180786,
0.41976043581962585,
-0.06400597095489502,
0.27940279245376587,
-0.8011091351509094,
0.5908815264701843,
-0.30890876054763794,
-0.21361060440540314,
-0.32986804842948914,
-0.4071594476699829,
0.4377320110797882,
-0.08053428679704666,
0.5472389459609985,
-0.09681855142116547,
-0.21297621726989746,
0.4967917799949646,
-0.23807896673679352,
0.8348545432090759,
-0.05927019566297531,
-0.3239898979663849,
0.2554211914539337,
0.057296548038721085,
0.5050988793373108,
0.05073189735412598,
-0.3623516857624054,
0.3626449704170227,
-0.24526485800743103,
-0.6032974720001221,
-0.7891087532043457,
0.7938556671142578,
-0.533195436000824,
-0.6690698862075806,
-0.3761618733406067,
-0.8399551510810852,
-0.32474005222320557,
0.004906677640974522,
-0.14866504073143005,
0.40499091148376465,
-0.2552573084831238,
0.060797277837991714,
0.6972354054450989,
-0.16204874217510223,
0.1381010115146637,
0.7749708890914917,
-0.5108305215835571,
-0.08145984262228012,
0.8869441151618958,
0.07466360181570053,
0.5156030058860779,
-0.031747449189424515,
0.14571060240268707,
-0.34302079677581787,
-0.9135313630104065,
-0.3008137345314026,
0.1293393075466156,
-0.8159973621368408,
-0.006835057865828276,
-0.5189207196235657,
-0.18187572062015533,
-0.21364635229110718,
-0.024988878518342972,
0.1607997566461563,
-0.6224616765975952,
-0.47060948610305786,
-0.398034006357193,
0.4396468997001648,
1.0714205503463745,
-0.35431787371635437,
0.3820120096206665,
-0.6733748912811279,
0.4692513644695282,
0.3779674470424652,
0.6350748538970947,
0.05521352216601372,
-0.4997825026512146,
-0.4036328196525574,
0.06780804693698883,
-0.1184534877538681,
-0.7685110569000244,
0.3908875584602356,
0.19859538972377777,
0.6958810687065125,
0.3830849528312683,
-0.4121777415275574,
0.6202382445335388,
-0.28874146938323975,
0.7255065441131592,
-0.035935573279857635,
-0.9630987644195557,
0.38610315322875977,
-0.3982577323913574,
0.16585461795330048,
-0.029114076867699623,
0.4851017892360687,
-0.36978867650032043,
-0.31434476375579834,
-0.3857184946537018,
-0.7436124086380005,
0.6368269920349121,
-0.07297856360673904,
0.12395741045475006,
-0.03509430214762688,
0.30625826120376587,
0.4435711205005646,
0.1560269594192505,
-0.4429090619087219,
-0.3407692313194275,
0.015233643352985382,
-0.38924020528793335,
-0.4695749878883362,
-0.47312131524086,
-0.03414946049451828,
-0.2665902078151703,
0.6815783977508545,
-0.15661562979221344,
0.2948940694332123,
-0.19785204529762268,
-0.3784651756286621,
-0.0025071250274777412,
0.46760421991348267,
0.5082461833953857,
1.035191297531128,
-0.37916815280914307,
0.3899295926094055,
0.27315753698349,
-0.4046803414821625,
0.1495921015739441,
0.054307833313941956,
-0.05011046677827835,
-0.04918276518583298,
0.47188496589660645,
0.7988650798797607,
-0.2131604701280594,
-0.5504518747329712,
-0.10815796256065369,
-0.07489877939224243,
-0.26950448751449585,
-0.016928846016526222,
0.3051423132419586,
0.44580477476119995,
0.16788704693317413,
0.3902139365673065,
-0.39058372378349304,
0.17267677187919617,
-0.7404674291610718,
-0.007821732200682163,
0.5382364988327026,
-0.2449478805065155,
-0.5262669920921326,
0.6861498951911926,
0.19393247365951538,
-0.09447643160820007,
0.42935431003570557,
-0.012052306905388832,
-0.390982985496521,
0.6547070145606995,
0.5788601040840149,
0.6716669797897339,
-0.1106291264295578,
0.09335285425186157,
0.025044750422239304,
0.07797541469335556,
0.03726176917552948,
0.4993986189365387,
0.21002312004566193,
-0.6689614653587341,
-0.6794911623001099,
-0.5212969779968262,
-0.7969958186149597,
0.4963850975036621,
-0.7714337706565857,
0.22109311819076538,
-0.05261668562889099,
0.1650143563747406,
0.5435764193534851,
-0.10448890179395676,
-0.6390952467918396,
0.2807377576828003,
0.007011702749878168,
0.7467926740646362,
-1.0416511297225952,
0.8442791104316711,
0.8068903684616089,
-0.22979173064231873,
-0.4792030155658722,
-0.3389695882797241,
0.03522152453660965,
-0.9192746877670288,
0.6791180372238159,
-0.15518471598625183,
0.005456254817545414,
0.13490283489227295,
-0.9821230173110962,
-0.8259634971618652,
0.8997926712036133,
0.49763810634613037,
-0.3767334520816803,
0.24773463606834412,
0.27118921279907227,
0.7153844833374023,
-0.40126246213912964,
0.23755665123462677,
0.6361844539642334,
0.5709312558174133,
0.002316467696800828,
-0.5401182174682617,
0.04010900482535362,
0.04266887530684471,
-0.29996997117996216,
0.29085591435432434,
-0.23196953535079956,
0.8551842570304871,
-0.26310503482818604,
-0.2760045528411865,
0.00023116701049730182,
0.7310629487037659,
-0.08959115296602249,
0.5345370769500732,
0.31211113929748535,
0.39899566769599915,
1.016800880432129,
-0.02212703414261341,
1.0347349643707275,
-0.0025792617816478014,
0.3627452850341797,
1.3728456497192383,
-0.26378440856933594,
0.5078973174095154,
0.18400055170059204,
-0.4441085457801819,
0.4725121557712555,
0.6340208053588867,
-0.05452217906713486,
0.3093301057815552,
0.19844363629817963,
-0.2750713527202606,
-0.5381761193275452,
0.17983543872833252,
-0.34748655557632446,
0.23517070710659027,
0.7385199666023254,
-0.4091686010360718,
-0.30647581815719604,
-0.0026020503137260675,
-0.11388054490089417,
-0.018850471824407578,
-0.6045210957527161,
0.6543389558792114,
0.2891663610935211,
-0.00005075449371361174,
0.2883984446525574,
-0.08719830960035324,
0.3805740475654602,
-0.6071300506591797,
-0.15059225261211395,
-0.11143380403518677,
0.25262191891670227,
-0.501683235168457,
-1.1013835668563843,
0.7036290168762207,
0.11375740170478821,
-0.5363478064537048,
-0.11034641414880753,
1.0467029809951782,
-0.5345149636268616,
-0.6266660690307617,
0.22239534556865692,
0.732552170753479,
0.4142177999019623,
0.09546870738267899,
-0.43838146328926086,
-0.10397642850875854,
-0.1490830034017563,
-0.2798546850681305,
0.4814335107803345,
0.14913471043109894,
-0.3069479763507843,
1.1331530809402466,
0.6818158030509949,
0.27307283878326416,
-0.17180135846138,
0.13663776218891144,
0.7361512780189514,
-0.868012547492981,
-0.30028271675109863,
-1.0901378393173218,
0.354178249835968,
-0.03315921872854233,
0.4407343566417694,
0.9382246732711792,
0.6089984774589539,
0.36665382981300354,
-0.1907520443201065,
0.9498440027236938,
0.031147271394729614,
0.8559557795524597,
-0.5854795575141907,
0.6427639126777649,
-0.35114017128944397,
0.45243701338768005,
0.12781870365142822,
-0.688886821269989,
-0.4447743892669678,
0.20671232044696808,
-0.4776386618614197,
-0.09572257101535797,
0.3693847358226776,
0.7022960186004639,
-0.227739617228508,
-0.004994723480194807,
0.3611995577812195,
0.3148901164531708,
0.562418520450592,
0.0836695209145546,
1.0415401458740234,
0.12654903531074524,
0.47242963314056396,
0.27140381932258606,
-0.16272756457328796,
-0.17825020849704742,
-1.0217632055282593,
-0.8417671918869019,
-0.19987282156944275,
-0.27646464109420776,
-0.1730942726135254,
-0.08174945414066315,
0.4881967306137085,
0.5633784532546997,
-0.951636791229248,
-0.21488569676876068,
-0.11506730318069458,
0.5913037061691284,
0.010750047862529755,
-0.3031487762928009,
0.3866102993488312,
-0.2744799852371216,
-0.8238273859024048,
0.5167704224586487,
0.08835670351982117,
0.2845938205718994,
-0.19844220578670502,
-0.24504850804805756,
0.13121217489242554,
0.34125107526779175,
0.774344265460968,
0.1799771934747696,
-0.4795098304748535,
-0.4012899398803711,
0.023907020688056946,
0.09922017902135849,
-0.06582563370466232,
0.7093191742897034,
-0.5575311183929443,
0.5699294209480286,
0.5676940083503723,
0.5043337345123291,
0.468316912651062,
0.15934516489505768,
0.8796135187149048,
-0.3854421079158783,
0.027914218604564667,
-0.059759583324193954,
0.4337993562221527,
0.360444039106369,
-0.34954261779785156,
0.8381736874580383,
-0.05820314586162567,
-0.7010548114776611,
-0.8999523520469666,
0.28888949751853943,
-0.802858293056488,
-0.5247001051902771,
1.175972819328308,
-0.08620598912239075,
-0.03314169496297836,
-0.30757445096969604,
0.04371856153011322,
0.061771977692842484,
-0.048948291689157486,
0.6889677047729492,
0.9156395792961121,
-0.49468234181404114,
0.10259480029344559,
-0.7538493871688843,
0.39903080463409424,
0.180893674492836,
-1.1587098836898804,
0.14552685618400574,
0.6919660568237305,
0.5029602646827698,
-0.24807724356651306,
0.31488102674484253,
0.0843622013926506,
0.0602162666618824,
-0.18575595319271088,
0.0007714834646321833,
-0.39185550808906555,
-0.14042158424854279,
-0.6987746953964233,
-0.11129544675350189,
0.34929588437080383,
-0.10292936861515045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14890v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14890v2
|
Vygotsky Distance: Measure for Benchmark Task Similarity
| 2024-02-22T12:00:32 | 2024-02-26T12:09:43 |
Maxim K. Surkov, Ivan P. Yamshchikov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T01, 97P80, 97C30, 68Q32, H.1.1; I.2.4; I.2.6; F.2.0
|
Evaluation plays a significant role in modern natural language processing.
Most modern NLP benchmarks consist of arbitrary sets of tasks that neither
guarantee any generalization potential for the model once applied outside the
test set nor try to minimize the resource consumption needed for model
evaluation. This paper presents a theoretical instrument and a practical
algorithm to calculate similarity between benchmark tasks, we call this
similarity measure "Vygotsky distance". The core idea of this similarity
measure is that it is based on relative performance of the "students" on a
given task, rather that on the properties of the task itself. If two tasks are
close to each other in terms of Vygotsky distance the models tend to have
similar relative performance on them. Thus knowing Vygotsky distance between
tasks one can significantly reduce the number of evaluation tasks while
maintaining a high validation quality. Experiments on various benchmarks,
including GLUE, SuperGLUE, CLUE, and RussianSuperGLUE, demonstrate that a vast
majority of NLP benchmarks could be at least 40% smaller in terms of the tasks
included. Most importantly, Vygotsky distance could also be used for the
validation of new tasks thus increasing the generalization potential of the
future NLP models.
|
[
-0.21271830797195435,
-0.5643478631973267,
0.5392414331436157,
0.14373885095119476,
0.08873126655817032,
-0.12655091285705566,
-0.5227000713348389,
-0.766205906867981,
0.05085655674338341,
-0.0005135024548508227,
-0.4819693863391876,
-0.2894541323184967,
-0.48409467935562134,
-0.19326868653297424,
-0.39646875858306885,
0.8539140820503235,
-0.0024423750583082438,
-0.05511647090315819,
-0.8078192472457886,
-0.12214640527963638,
-0.4193978011608124,
-0.13296061754226685,
-0.16251885890960693,
-0.5709300637245178,
0.42327386140823364,
0.039425451308488846,
0.5129019618034363,
0.7280234694480896,
0.6970266103744507,
0.38719698786735535,
-0.12347725033760071,
-0.16156044602394104,
-0.4484367370605469,
0.11966248601675034,
-0.41505199670791626,
-0.9282590746879578,
-0.010936425067484379,
0.10945679247379303,
0.608332633972168,
0.7180761694908142,
-0.1228896975517273,
0.5668504238128662,
0.0898301899433136,
0.5760863423347473,
-0.6611801385879517,
0.014897901564836502,
-0.4876510202884674,
0.1792614758014679,
-0.33870431780815125,
0.15652206540107727,
0.08707813173532486,
-0.27543413639068604,
0.23784521222114563,
-0.6039798259735107,
0.2781815528869629,
-0.1439761370420456,
1.1361204385757446,
-0.04917331039905548,
0.06647450476884842,
-0.08083654940128326,
-0.5506658554077148,
1.079426884651184,
-0.5723373889923096,
0.42546865344047546,
0.24405385553836823,
0.2868593633174896,
-0.10883725434541702,
-0.706605076789856,
-0.6396743059158325,
-0.5453667640686035,
-0.0267657358199358,
0.014799046330153942,
-0.290863573551178,
-0.13762244582176208,
0.5919740796089172,
0.3480202257633209,
-0.6194016337394714,
-0.09188200533390045,
-0.5300008654594421,
0.11624391376972198,
0.3657524287700653,
0.39525970816612244,
0.18212749063968658,
-0.1443546861410141,
-0.541273832321167,
-0.09878966212272644,
-0.29348301887512207,
0.2564731538295746,
0.4453594386577606,
-0.07549580186605453,
0.2644800543785095,
0.2728320062160492,
-0.8437279462814331,
0.7561922669410706,
-0.13245373964309692,
-0.5067906975746155,
0.2865980863571167,
-0.3080544173717499,
-0.15078364312648773,
-0.20780672132968903,
0.6769468188285828,
0.8241543173789978,
0.4168567657470703,
-0.3227766156196594,
-0.04346272349357605,
0.3405245244503021,
0.4861961901187897,
-0.6461604237556458,
-0.2776942551136017,
-0.20367930829524994,
-0.7556613087654114,
-0.1287849247455597,
-0.32835862040519714,
-0.48350873589515686,
0.040975820273160934,
-0.6787946224212646,
0.716535747051239,
-0.33027586340904236,
-0.27821314334869385,
-0.0285843126475811,
-0.07658717781305313,
0.057539522647857666,
0.07159290462732315,
-0.8067454695701599,
1.0226508378982544,
1.0569210052490234,
0.9372310638427734,
-0.43640634417533875,
-0.5344519019126892,
-0.3940553367137909,
-0.26072263717651367,
-0.10672716051340103,
0.793610692024231,
-0.6531012654304504,
-0.21085506677627563,
-0.19562819600105286,
-0.2598545551300049,
-0.07152912020683289,
-0.7958189249038696,
0.3565850555896759,
-0.22802239656448364,
0.022150663658976555,
-0.2781604528427124,
-0.6247531175613403,
-0.23418782651424408,
0.3463294506072998,
-0.42434751987457275,
1.3935788869857788,
0.38209718465805054,
-0.6791073679924011,
0.5544965863227844,
-0.4045737087726593,
-0.27858221530914307,
0.20617856085300446,
0.15639127790927887,
-0.09975583106279373,
0.3849267363548279,
-0.08315514773130417,
0.34686869382858276,
-0.5822150111198425,
-0.022917401045560837,
-0.3996320068836212,
-0.5328100323677063,
-0.03285848721861839,
-0.16259358823299408,
0.4021461009979248,
0.032559312880039215,
-0.29088151454925537,
0.18512657284736633,
-0.7623184323310852,
0.6058000326156616,
-0.10836636275053024,
-0.25230884552001953,
-0.9216824769973755,
-0.12889212369918823,
0.20912419259548187,
0.2650909721851349,
0.4211302399635315,
-0.40279167890548706,
0.24820353090763092,
-0.4058402180671692,
0.1536865383386612,
0.5544531941413879,
-0.2927669584751129,
0.31686240434646606,
-0.6415696144104004,
0.5051800608634949,
-0.5615130662918091,
0.15648715198040009,
0.3757472038269043,
-0.5063175559043884,
-0.4892948865890503,
0.06088942289352417,
0.666831374168396,
0.4844511151313782,
-0.25414150953292847,
0.10137046128511429,
-0.4410066604614258,
-0.937044084072113,
-0.6619399785995483,
0.27640244364738464,
0.7417140603065491,
0.5809879899024963,
0.27093520760536194,
-0.6410500407218933,
-0.4104636311531067,
-0.960920512676239,
-0.5868448615074158,
-0.04361452907323837,
-0.28546425700187683,
-0.2178046703338623,
0.5059958100318909,
0.21051573753356934,
0.7609359622001648,
-0.6196051836013794,
-0.19954338669776917,
0.25718510150909424,
0.03255371004343033,
0.4778604209423065,
0.6136093735694885,
0.5488071441650391,
-0.6884415149688721,
-0.7225819826126099,
-0.03881889954209328,
-0.4022015333175659,
-0.29963526129722595,
0.10955502092838287,
0.05338357761502266,
-0.22448807954788208,
0.6355945467948914,
-0.6176674365997314,
0.3425402045249939,
0.4808878004550934,
-0.03970339149236679,
1.0181370973587036,
-0.30702176690101624,
0.2203371226787567,
-0.8560888171195984,
0.16168595850467682,
0.2039460390806198,
-0.2160540521144867,
-0.5878660678863525,
0.36647331714630127,
-0.14766646921634674,
0.35342729091644287,
-0.31149426102638245,
0.5793026685714722,
-0.20571455359458923,
-0.07351376116275787,
-0.15568391978740692,
0.39747384190559387,
-0.3123016655445099,
0.2706778347492218,
0.03729253262281418,
0.47970500588417053,
0.5732713341712952,
-0.5101748108863831,
0.5235611796379089,
-0.0912080705165863,
-0.5735149383544922,
1.3061814308166504,
-0.6542612314224243,
0.041145529597997665,
0.38254448771476746,
-0.2772006094455719,
-0.8751882910728455,
0.19983333349227905,
-0.20156028866767883,
-0.501325786113739,
0.0329720638692379,
-0.09576261043548584,
-0.4634069800376892,
-0.3589484989643097,
-0.3346882462501526,
0.2900635004043579,
0.6962077021598816,
-0.4585084617137909,
0.13945098221302032,
0.19343186914920807,
0.0014563958393409848,
-0.5922605395317078,
-0.45652276277542114,
-0.14890290796756744,
-0.4400949776172638,
-0.7548442482948303,
0.7382066249847412,
-0.26952603459358215,
-0.4910697042942047,
0.277710497379303,
-0.5105377435684204,
-0.16910399496555328,
0.08882379531860352,
0.4920990467071533,
-0.1293991506099701,
-0.3550609052181244,
0.5152144432067871,
-0.4143887758255005,
-0.2669183313846588,
0.2890675365924835,
-0.333871454000473,
0.40879297256469727,
-0.21623262763023376,
-0.3314473032951355,
-0.13818217813968658,
0.26297420263290405,
0.11105700582265854,
-0.07057689130306244,
0.5955039262771606,
0.9032284617424011,
-0.6732794046401978,
-0.2756311893463135,
-0.7043682932853699,
-0.02036678045988083,
-0.4860404431819916,
0.464343786239624,
-0.6319043040275574,
-0.6067250370979309,
0.2433091551065445,
-0.125700443983078,
-0.24808268249034882,
0.3015572428703308,
0.5551108121871948,
-0.03429584950208664,
0.5376866459846497,
0.5675469040870667,
-0.1497018188238144,
0.4330437183380127,
-0.018295366317033768,
0.24465620517730713,
-0.8131266832351685,
-0.23115302622318268,
-0.751944363117218,
-0.5650835037231445,
-0.6201553344726562,
-0.552315890789032,
0.023787494748830795,
0.3365815579891205,
0.22076474130153656,
0.6896978616714478,
-0.5256750583648682,
0.7571213245391846,
0.9841451048851013,
-0.14009593427181244,
0.1394134759902954,
-0.1269393116235733,
-0.23383408784866333,
-0.4307499825954437,
-0.38255834579467773,
-0.37306225299835205,
0.9599770903587341,
0.004193011671304703,
0.28595995903015137,
-0.1348562389612198,
0.9049999117851257,
0.19479766488075256,
0.1298309862613678,
-0.844709575176239,
0.7346938848495483,
0.053052663803100586,
-0.3432005047798157,
-0.2745094299316406,
-0.30637744069099426,
-0.9450933337211609,
0.27255719900131226,
-0.35871249437332153,
-1.1824628114700317,
-0.4445344805717468,
-0.2550162076950073,
-0.0664629340171814,
0.19786033034324646,
-0.5065041184425354,
0.8670828342437744,
0.2710978388786316,
-0.5963855385780334,
-0.4944673180580139,
-0.42106252908706665,
0.09541832655668259,
0.1281045377254486,
0.011409932747483253,
-0.17986011505126953,
0.08416963368654251,
1.093422770500183,
-0.4217555522918701,
0.17098350822925568,
-0.13379402458667755,
0.22274746000766754,
0.2685728073120117,
0.2419871985912323,
0.2157841920852661,
-0.09471782296895981,
-0.11057572066783905,
0.014995954930782318,
0.3342841565608978,
-0.48352575302124023,
-0.47221529483795166,
1.2312266826629639,
-0.3781428933143616,
-0.5244382619857788,
-0.20212513208389282,
-0.6320343613624573,
-0.3362973630428314,
0.3480801284313202,
0.02387884259223938,
0.13850928843021393,
-0.09732566773891449,
0.26829367876052856,
0.33955660462379456,
0.25439590215682983,
0.569373369216919,
0.5203512907028198,
0.033595673739910126,
0.05540546402335167,
0.8550082445144653,
0.23612742125988007,
0.24579964578151703,
0.6171069741249084,
0.4082348942756653,
-0.35288628935813904,
-0.6393868923187256,
0.22371982038021088,
0.0750269666314125,
-0.739227294921875,
-0.1437356173992157,
-0.4980916678905487,
0.1530817151069641,
-0.21787038445472717,
-0.2476055920124054,
-0.44931846857070923,
-0.391129732131958,
0.15030033886432648,
0.007137950975447893,
0.27636417746543884,
0.8050451278686523,
-0.3721582293510437,
0.15104761719703674,
-0.5832366347312927,
0.4635572135448456,
0.7584014534950256,
0.5644722580909729,
-0.09855316579341888,
-0.3761708736419678,
-0.261059045791626,
-0.24263444542884827,
-0.27564191818237305,
-0.5486183762550354,
0.2874162197113037,
0.01820250228047371,
0.6372548937797546,
0.06026450917124748,
-0.1559167057275772,
1.008764386177063,
-0.516316294670105,
0.7736544013023376,
0.4460109770298004,
-1.1853708028793335,
0.24275508522987366,
-0.2835915982723236,
0.28107526898384094,
0.5939789414405823,
0.4452531933784485,
-0.712022602558136,
-0.015337246470153332,
-0.7864998579025269,
-0.6709527373313904,
0.39641663432121277,
0.34069961309432983,
-0.08491218835115433,
0.06922338902950287,
0.14896315336227417,
0.042716216295957565,
0.19922633469104767,
-0.6840376853942871,
-0.14926370978355408,
0.3376697897911072,
-0.14415210485458374,
-0.007165237329900265,
0.10293459892272949,
-0.018047962337732315,
-0.1989973485469818,
0.44688308238983154,
-0.033674854785203934,
0.3190041482448578,
0.10305138677358627,
-0.10291831940412521,
-0.16715918481349945,
0.23581208288669586,
0.4224523901939392,
0.787830650806427,
-0.2150612622499466,
0.04473879188299179,
0.7062137126922607,
-0.5959328413009644,
0.05902935191988945,
0.13364292681217194,
0.3499080538749695,
0.1252419799566269,
0.6247615814208984,
0.26815566420555115,
0.11453909426927567,
-0.5559530854225159,
0.6038957834243774,
0.059512652456760406,
-0.25187408924102783,
-0.026740118861198425,
0.2478286623954773,
0.42159920930862427,
0.5619730949401855,
0.0834435224533081,
0.05131971836090088,
0.27802616357803345,
-0.41998979449272156,
0.3515186309814453,
0.22115269303321838,
-0.7598205208778381,
-0.38183027505874634,
0.48277685046195984,
-0.13336554169654846,
-0.8296561241149902,
0.43578794598579407,
-0.24081867933273315,
-0.45787274837493896,
0.7974947690963745,
0.5578526258468628,
0.6237474679946899,
-0.38790273666381836,
0.09064734727144241,
0.5707635879516602,
0.21702775359153748,
-0.4399167597293854,
0.10252297669649124,
-0.1381981372833252,
-0.10126350075006485,
-0.31246519088745117,
-0.8370630741119385,
-0.18461433053016663,
0.28489595651626587,
-0.8349408507347107,
0.30539625883102417,
-0.3600148856639862,
0.022582832723855972,
0.030910473316907883,
0.3225930631160736,
-0.9417534470558167,
0.5922443866729736,
0.053090889006853104,
0.5813594460487366,
-0.8202171921730042,
0.7656481862068176,
0.5461755394935608,
-0.008685334585607052,
-0.6874104142189026,
-0.08599237352609634,
0.0019592263270169497,
-0.6537004709243774,
0.7713049650192261,
0.4486832618713379,
0.07283942401409149,
-0.6289682388305664,
-0.11688653379678726,
-0.8270567059516907,
0.9261249899864197,
0.1288951188325882,
-0.8902800679206848,
-0.1749148964881897,
0.07758235931396484,
1.0157207250595093,
-0.19604021310806274,
0.4597853720188141,
0.6104354858398438,
0.27571913599967957,
-0.5701285004615784,
-1.4999243021011353,
0.19195079803466797,
-0.48402389883995056,
0.16884978115558624,
0.43823471665382385,
-0.4796757102012634,
0.9616003632545471,
-0.056098081171512604,
0.07090257853269577,
0.07061634212732315,
0.3034140169620514,
0.026626484468579292,
0.29391446709632874,
0.5574885010719299,
0.7395568490028381,
0.5194408297538757,
-0.16129031777381897,
0.8092595934867859,
-0.05801410973072052,
0.611420750617981,
1.400709867477417,
-0.1070869192481041,
0.8909724950790405,
0.6756969690322876,
-0.6844603419303894,
0.24268168210983276,
0.06429589539766312,
-0.19765816628932953,
0.4985591769218445,
0.8918642401695251,
-0.02155810408294201,
-0.1782713532447815,
-0.2791367173194885,
-0.37847232818603516,
0.5056899189949036,
0.1937754601240158,
-0.17539674043655396,
-0.21829892694950104,
-0.2021278589963913,
-0.04396188631653786,
0.6691185235977173,
-0.34553205966949463,
0.5076062083244324,
0.04127764701843262,
-0.6722692251205444,
0.5741432309150696,
0.0030577676370739937,
0.69474858045578,
-0.6824570298194885,
-0.19139261543750763,
0.23756124079227448,
0.2749083340167999,
-0.1393481194972992,
-0.8313343524932861,
0.3936116695404053,
-0.29053863883018494,
-0.1885654777288437,
-0.12924419343471527,
0.8564496636390686,
-0.2596227824687958,
-0.10577688366174698,
0.5843449831008911,
0.2824028730392456,
0.0018256446346640587,
-0.1842305213212967,
-0.7599242925643921,
-0.1731681376695633,
-0.1992313265800476,
-0.34897705912590027,
0.5489530563354492,
0.24192334711551666,
-0.06831859052181244,
0.6732194423675537,
0.5029438138008118,
0.23607921600341797,
0.1421370804309845,
-0.21154066920280457,
0.5207303166389465,
-0.6553323268890381,
-0.5009125471115112,
-0.7449391484260559,
0.26110517978668213,
-0.14462614059448242,
-0.5647435188293457,
0.7597097158432007,
0.3592434525489807,
1.243335485458374,
-0.1940341293811798,
0.5269410014152527,
-0.2620408535003662,
0.646888792514801,
-0.5279413461685181,
0.559162974357605,
-0.6916143894195557,
-0.06588062644004822,
-0.6807149648666382,
-1.2787889242172241,
-0.05395185574889183,
0.6762792468070984,
-0.42479822039604187,
-0.08162715286016464,
0.9596432447433472,
0.6852697730064392,
-0.18380163609981537,
-0.2817671000957489,
0.6588820219039917,
-0.16089008748531342,
0.1568746715784073,
0.9299919605255127,
0.7585241198539734,
-0.5428451299667358,
0.6613819599151611,
-0.5758000612258911,
0.13136906921863556,
-0.0643908903002739,
-0.9143814444541931,
-1.0157265663146973,
-0.9079855680465698,
-0.4815227687358856,
-0.27313756942749023,
0.13323771953582764,
0.7770421504974365,
0.8704079985618591,
-0.4102708697319031,
-0.31252381205558777,
0.044691599905490875,
-0.01911611296236515,
-0.7208694815635681,
-0.2578674554824829,
0.27102822065353394,
-0.20711888372898102,
-0.8959583640098572,
0.17561018466949463,
0.041242629289627075,
-0.3545721769332886,
-0.015545998699963093,
0.1141958087682724,
-0.3060755729675293,
-0.13815727829933167,
0.33966416120529175,
0.03223102167248726,
-0.7061019539833069,
-0.5417898297309875,
-0.16425257921218872,
0.08653640002012253,
0.17368292808532715,
0.4264732897281647,
-0.9284542202949524,
0.794876217842102,
0.7315387725830078,
0.3326791822910309,
0.5899463295936584,
-0.273037850856781,
0.2996132969856262,
-0.6766234636306763,
0.06776441633701324,
0.1684999316930771,
0.08747883141040802,
0.11417561769485474,
-0.055843960493803024,
0.7358646392822266,
0.29483944177627563,
-0.47815197706222534,
-0.8252471089363098,
0.19222170114517212,
-1.032178282737732,
-0.02565048448741436,
0.9519473910331726,
-0.4268292188644409,
-0.3757857382297516,
0.019860656931996346,
-0.1961437165737152,
0.07858678698539734,
-0.18494433164596558,
0.8442239761352539,
0.8468877077102661,
0.2169826179742813,
0.20165032148361206,
-0.7092731595039368,
0.554783821105957,
0.5553681254386902,
-0.8880564570426941,
-0.2014894187450409,
-0.08523121476173401,
0.7823898196220398,
0.6850684285163879,
0.3188052177429199,
0.12362895905971527,
0.4536454975605011,
0.4435054063796997,
0.06604854017496109,
0.1637732833623886,
-0.0753997340798378,
-0.06076677888631821,
0.4606376588344574,
-0.06867773085832596,
-0.23806744813919067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14458v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14458v1
|
NLAS-multi: A Multilingual Corpus of Automatically Generated Natural Language Argumentation Schemes
| 2024-02-22T11:31:50 | 2024-02-22T11:31:50 |
Ramon Ruiz-Dolz, Joaquin Taverner, John Lawrence, Chris Reed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Some of the major limitations identified in the areas of argument mining,
argument generation, and natural language argument analysis are related to the
complexity of annotating argumentatively rich data, the limited size of these
corpora, and the constraints that represent the different languages and domains
in which these data is annotated. To address these limitations, in this paper
we present the following contributions: (i) an effective methodology for the
automatic generation of natural language arguments in different topics and
languages, (ii) the largest publicly available corpus of natural language
argumentation schemes, and (iii) a set of solid baselines and fine-tuned models
for the automatic identification of argumentation schemes.
|
[
-0.8064570426940918,
-0.9347401857376099,
0.24595853686332703,
0.555248498916626,
-0.3953818678855896,
0.10881958156824112,
-0.20809870958328247,
-0.4010147154331207,
0.3737190067768097,
0.41623419523239136,
-0.4568246603012085,
-0.34549492597579956,
-0.5793871283531189,
0.722533106803894,
-0.29404130578041077,
1.0923513174057007,
-0.06716043502092361,
0.085300013422966,
-0.2380232810974121,
-0.5549984574317932,
-0.476388156414032,
-0.7095842957496643,
-0.7965453267097473,
0.20268888771533966,
0.6192372441291809,
0.6353875994682312,
0.6275278329849243,
0.3710755407810211,
0.4397917687892914,
0.4137025475502014,
0.13474856317043304,
0.49167948961257935,
0.1836818903684616,
0.18512892723083496,
-0.10923905670642853,
-0.14113478362560272,
-0.24711351096630096,
-0.24865278601646423,
0.7841397523880005,
0.621871829032898,
0.17006513476371765,
0.29126137495040894,
-0.34373965859413147,
0.7514581680297852,
-0.7276928424835205,
-0.16070446372032166,
-0.6918109655380249,
0.06761620938777924,
-0.5179172158241272,
-0.42662835121154785,
-0.1737683117389679,
-0.5203202962875366,
0.29963159561157227,
-0.5223088264465332,
0.023823129013180733,
-0.17795389890670776,
1.010506510734558,
0.2689354121685028,
-0.4334411025047302,
-0.9210662841796875,
-0.5364469885826111,
0.9281141757965088,
-0.817572832107544,
0.023438835516572,
0.11285582929849625,
0.36686673760414124,
0.038179606199264526,
-0.4842340648174286,
-0.4070744514465332,
-0.07878022640943527,
-0.08266618102788925,
-0.11657284945249557,
-0.2517620325088501,
-0.08015042543411255,
0.20978650450706482,
0.208201602101326,
-0.5444089770317078,
0.006095479242503643,
-0.39981281757354736,
-0.20839948952198029,
0.7705174088478088,
0.09145742654800415,
0.26506394147872925,
-0.49427464604377747,
-0.22395844757556915,
0.19350142776966095,
-0.6083266139030457,
-0.4354415833950043,
0.8326528668403625,
0.5270276069641113,
-0.2452169805765152,
0.6289634704589844,
-0.1453639417886734,
1.0276010036468506,
-0.11682803183794022,
-0.048093393445014954,
0.06230424344539642,
-0.48746728897094727,
-0.15541458129882812,
-0.016138730570673943,
0.9930063486099243,
0.14762304723262787,
0.29611027240753174,
0.07192997634410858,
0.30422142148017883,
0.21501271426677704,
0.1346427947282791,
-0.60781329870224,
0.01837257295846939,
0.4295460879802704,
-0.33121687173843384,
-0.08880586177110672,
0.023880040273070335,
-1.1322156190872192,
-0.259737104177475,
-0.44935816526412964,
0.1139267235994339,
-0.25553664565086365,
-0.20120958983898163,
0.04676354303956032,
-0.313302218914032,
0.253146231174469,
-0.005921779200434685,
-0.9019066691398621,
0.37764671444892883,
0.3854227066040039,
0.8025295734405518,
-0.011088711209595203,
-0.23049044609069824,
-0.39472028613090515,
0.142873153090477,
-0.5516524314880371,
1.2208952903747559,
-0.8170085549354553,
-0.14389285445213318,
0.20367012917995453,
-0.12234876304864883,
0.03495141863822937,
-0.4546353816986084,
0.9345906376838684,
-0.41709616780281067,
0.30150002241134644,
-0.34057122468948364,
-0.5477585792541504,
-0.13759846985340118,
0.17352616786956787,
-0.7689207792282104,
0.8944776058197021,
-0.24442502856254578,
-0.5447221994400024,
0.5222005248069763,
-1.2311867475509644,
-0.6258254647254944,
0.1869076043367386,
-0.11717232316732407,
-0.36013591289520264,
0.055746760219335556,
0.12396257370710373,
0.47898057103157043,
-0.5800769925117493,
0.5791369676589966,
-0.11594905704259872,
0.2664705216884613,
0.010906980372965336,
-0.36449313163757324,
0.9903629422187805,
0.48325785994529724,
-0.24974766373634338,
0.29360559582710266,
-1.1581865549087524,
-0.12176720052957535,
0.21214887499809265,
-0.278611958026886,
-0.36323583126068115,
0.1811746507883072,
0.0584586076438427,
0.1252353936433792,
0.4977671205997467,
-0.5461195707321167,
0.16533246636390686,
-0.4051458239555359,
0.4465304911136627,
0.44977855682373047,
0.13728007674217224,
0.16050486266613007,
0.06601838767528534,
0.631576418876648,
-0.031176235526800156,
-0.1542544960975647,
-0.10948444902896881,
-0.711142361164093,
-0.738731324672699,
0.009982561692595482,
0.6004142761230469,
0.6649842262268066,
-0.3492138683795929,
0.44283348321914673,
0.02538568153977394,
-0.34540191292762756,
-0.43868550658226013,
0.3053148090839386,
0.26744455099105835,
0.02356300689280033,
0.37406063079833984,
-0.04550033435225487,
-1.2063827514648438,
-1.18539297580719,
-0.16753935813903809,
-0.019072214141488075,
0.16010530292987823,
0.011845841072499752,
0.5633538365364075,
-0.23504969477653503,
0.8495556116104126,
-0.1499742567539215,
-0.20082922279834747,
-0.1088562160730362,
0.46836522221565247,
-0.016581661999225616,
0.18642409145832062,
0.626711368560791,
-0.6766613721847534,
-0.6415882706642151,
0.07622087746858597,
-0.8856441974639893,
-0.2854829728603363,
-0.3873690962791443,
-0.08438344299793243,
0.41753408312797546,
0.45876434445381165,
-0.4086732268333435,
0.17841875553131104,
0.5504651665687561,
-0.20991650223731995,
0.627560019493103,
-0.2634834945201874,
-0.22489674389362335,
-1.1864873170852661,
-0.004766765050590038,
0.24397827684879303,
0.01972104050219059,
-0.6574487090110779,
0.07369162142276764,
-0.13233806192874908,
-0.055849481374025345,
-0.25689980387687683,
0.660670280456543,
-0.4453520178794861,
0.2849522829055786,
-0.4087352454662323,
0.10477282106876373,
-0.06646260619163513,
0.30191749334335327,
0.240024596452713,
0.5443868637084961,
0.6511614918708801,
-0.7616415023803711,
0.5083499550819397,
0.3053518533706665,
0.0464080385863781,
0.8880556225776672,
-0.70833420753479,
0.017366301268339157,
-0.053880173712968826,
0.19545294344425201,
-0.7575632929801941,
-0.37626054883003235,
0.04999299347400665,
-0.2214311957359314,
-0.0841362327337265,
-0.18577231466770172,
-0.20403625071048737,
-0.15064223110675812,
-0.328485369682312,
0.263619065284729,
-0.3486274480819702,
-0.5822126269340515,
0.7155293822288513,
0.6037650108337402,
-0.2778206467628479,
-0.9102940559387207,
-0.5766955614089966,
0.7298333644866943,
-0.5753718614578247,
-0.5732858777046204,
0.32416602969169617,
-0.21489600837230682,
-0.5243663191795349,
0.014429887756705284,
0.5214676260948181,
-0.026361970230937004,
-0.009420336224138737,
0.282478928565979,
0.0227886363863945,
-0.41920584440231323,
0.1859121173620224,
0.19406892359256744,
-0.20315960049629211,
0.012613451108336449,
0.06239663437008858,
0.4293985962867737,
-0.5486985445022583,
-0.404829740524292,
-0.179999440908432,
1.1343917846679688,
0.48658713698387146,
-0.15033264458179474,
0.5924324989318848,
0.4644673466682434,
-0.4967817962169647,
-0.1466153860092163,
-0.5359455347061157,
0.2791208028793335,
-0.4156445562839508,
0.08339562267065048,
-0.5994334816932678,
-0.60630202293396,
0.6439010500907898,
-0.11526843905448914,
0.6185353398323059,
0.9053612947463989,
0.8640357255935669,
0.377080500125885,
0.887800395488739,
0.10941902548074722,
-0.0490558035671711,
0.04787256196141243,
-0.13006821274757385,
0.28963834047317505,
-0.5605635046958923,
0.12028767168521881,
-0.874102771282196,
-0.07064702361822128,
-0.586209237575531,
-0.18448024988174438,
-0.16791847348213196,
0.01262437179684639,
-0.2648734152317047,
0.3807075321674347,
-0.5898337364196777,
0.4366109073162079,
0.5491130352020264,
-0.7911959886550903,
0.14206276834011078,
-0.05270911008119583,
-0.2624629735946655,
0.02032954804599285,
-0.7005434632301331,
-1.0075715780258179,
0.9903342723846436,
0.41423726081848145,
0.08092419803142548,
0.4364216923713684,
0.7296890616416931,
0.2879024147987366,
0.3139082193374634,
-0.8606658577919006,
0.47748178243637085,
-0.3918527662754059,
-0.9400243163108826,
-0.2673540413379669,
-0.4700615704059601,
-1.278419017791748,
0.21902377903461456,
-0.39787349104881287,
-0.5655821561813354,
0.29014119505882263,
-0.0900043249130249,
-0.49085190892219543,
0.3905044496059418,
-0.9384894967079163,
0.8678556680679321,
-0.2279868870973587,
-0.17533765733242035,
0.129349023103714,
-0.4640129804611206,
0.32053902745246887,
-0.1472250372171402,
0.3086240589618683,
-0.06340692937374115,
0.043850284069776535,
1.0193438529968262,
-0.44131937623023987,
0.6425004005432129,
-0.26965752243995667,
-0.2601287364959717,
0.6527114510536194,
-0.27201154828071594,
0.11840515583753586,
0.24285411834716797,
-0.20902636647224426,
0.09760312736034393,
0.15712885558605194,
-0.40013182163238525,
-0.16577337682247162,
0.5336084365844727,
-0.5271767973899841,
-0.5128223299980164,
-0.44815805554389954,
-0.41215771436691284,
-0.3973007798194885,
0.09640650451183319,
0.08181226998567581,
0.5156437754631042,
-0.3630083203315735,
0.23495624959468842,
0.16807015240192413,
-0.47879666090011597,
0.6435460448265076,
0.3199504315853119,
0.1410500556230545,
-0.5074273347854614,
1.3078824281692505,
0.20060183107852936,
-0.09688760340213776,
0.04960762709379196,
0.4644932448863983,
-0.5474284291267395,
-0.7335230112075806,
-0.7781605124473572,
0.12972934544086456,
-0.8267797231674194,
-0.3618086874485016,
-0.5874317288398743,
-0.07929537445306778,
-0.38266056776046753,
-0.2356777787208557,
-0.3320273756980896,
-0.6112050414085388,
-0.1978657990694046,
-0.08244746923446655,
0.3432772755622864,
0.8259539604187012,
-0.25438520312309265,
0.13224612176418304,
-0.622897207736969,
0.6323992609977722,
0.3739294111728668,
0.5154465436935425,
-0.1687871515750885,
0.07774850726127625,
-0.0509188286960125,
-0.055513739585876465,
-0.3343430459499359,
-1.0933982133865356,
0.3161526620388031,
0.37254223227500916,
0.6036389470100403,
0.5590675473213196,
-0.011164195835590363,
0.8362212777137756,
-0.4405076801776886,
0.8792667388916016,
0.1596532016992569,
-0.8129698038101196,
0.4671289622783661,
-0.23272787034511566,
0.30797719955444336,
0.5728203058242798,
0.30063965916633606,
-0.2930806279182434,
-0.4585266709327698,
-0.6032611131668091,
-0.9643210768699646,
0.36767491698265076,
-0.048234812915325165,
0.218034565448761,
-0.38564547896385193,
0.1591297835111618,
0.27504831552505493,
-0.20219208300113678,
-0.8217999935150146,
-0.2680012583732605,
-0.24142687022686005,
-0.23670388758182526,
0.2735883295536041,
-0.2797936797142029,
-0.44382092356681824,
-0.06692524254322052,
0.814678966999054,
-0.4943057894706726,
0.14548848569393158,
0.09029381722211838,
-0.01470231357961893,
-0.15581580996513367,
0.48244574666023254,
1.1310943365097046,
0.8288625478744507,
-0.09589732438325882,
0.11590155959129333,
0.43225130438804626,
-0.24365054070949554,
0.1642540693283081,
0.1724596619606018,
-0.14147700369358063,
0.32520854473114014,
0.3554648160934448,
0.9413783550262451,
-0.08571901172399521,
-0.6954960227012634,
0.016130121424794197,
-0.33092400431632996,
-0.6296451687812805,
-0.5362433195114136,
-0.40664243698120117,
0.3839751183986664,
-0.10501765459775925,
0.5455137491226196,
0.09269789606332779,
-0.07025948166847229,
-0.5364904999732971,
0.12607702612876892,
0.7161422371864319,
-0.16486811637878418,
-0.027562415227293968,
0.39841052889823914,
0.23016753792762756,
-0.30250295996665955,
-0.049435805529356,
-0.33075764775276184,
-0.3572744131088257,
0.5463285446166992,
0.4063067138195038,
0.7816779017448425,
0.01952906884253025,
0.3067827522754669,
0.5935287475585938,
0.2913549244403839,
0.21950878202915192,
0.382503867149353,
0.13328345119953156,
-0.6008598804473877,
-0.5642260313034058,
-0.7382923364639282,
-0.531333327293396,
0.3149963617324829,
-0.374627023935318,
0.2169698178768158,
-0.5336712598800659,
-0.22437062859535217,
0.5411626696586609,
0.3192468583583832,
-0.36077234148979187,
0.09593317657709122,
0.18780241906642914,
0.6300885677337646,
-0.7317038774490356,
0.624312698841095,
0.7058887481689453,
-0.29372116923332214,
-0.3333662450313568,
-0.28496628999710083,
-0.016027791425585747,
-0.0725480243563652,
0.44239142537117004,
-0.09004704654216766,
-0.3497462272644043,
-0.5142156481742859,
-0.2696383595466614,
-0.7458081245422363,
0.3660113215446472,
0.4825907349586487,
-0.16777582466602325,
0.23748813569545746,
0.3605344593524933,
0.6418592929840088,
-0.5764550566673279,
0.141703799366951,
0.38855820894241333,
0.8875384330749512,
-0.28471991419792175,
-0.6750207543373108,
0.037024009972810745,
-0.45345568656921387,
-0.29300710558891296,
0.060810621827840805,
-0.44736766815185547,
0.7999222874641418,
-0.04703235626220703,
-0.35914987325668335,
0.0584467314183712,
0.8226643800735474,
0.3515297472476959,
0.22851161658763885,
0.6012767553329468,
0.6234405040740967,
0.6968522071838379,
-0.0073180850595235825,
0.9563814401626587,
-0.2753400504589081,
-0.0031932638958096504,
0.9964516758918762,
-0.39513644576072693,
0.7761568427085876,
0.4735977351665497,
-0.14001695811748505,
0.6787784695625305,
0.6850229501724243,
-0.07913094758987427,
-0.04617002233862877,
0.2958385944366455,
-0.23972444236278534,
-0.1316419243812561,
-0.18153895437717438,
-0.42293086647987366,
0.4815051257610321,
0.6709743142127991,
-0.029465945437550545,
-0.3633509576320648,
-0.30498072504997253,
-0.09583775699138641,
0.2095688432455063,
0.008983521722257137,
0.8742024898529053,
-0.10847081989049911,
-0.8001834154129028,
0.6028135418891907,
0.38539737462997437,
0.8119467496871948,
-0.6891738176345825,
-0.12590523064136505,
0.093484066426754,
-0.17741739749908447,
-0.38798561692237854,
-0.5005760192871094,
0.6871786713600159,
0.372994065284729,
0.11958809942007065,
0.154102623462677,
0.8096483945846558,
-0.159001886844635,
-0.6917999982833862,
0.4267124831676483,
0.5524582266807556,
0.044274717569351196,
0.28886255621910095,
-0.8736974596977234,
-0.09408613294363022,
-0.3178326189517975,
-0.3694794774055481,
0.12709656357765198,
0.5784681439399719,
-0.22668960690498352,
0.4648478329181671,
0.7204659581184387,
0.19098041951656342,
0.45445922017097473,
0.2611682713031769,
0.3693859875202179,
-0.6314058899879456,
-0.17054550349712372,
-0.8262624740600586,
0.3120930790901184,
-0.32410213351249695,
-0.5455069541931152,
0.7821165323257446,
0.7029808759689331,
0.4190702438354492,
-0.010465987958014011,
0.9654416441917419,
-0.14324231445789337,
0.5989899635314941,
-0.2402411252260208,
0.18919876217842102,
-0.3972201347351074,
-0.047096338123083115,
-0.3822428584098816,
-0.7577407956123352,
-0.7503710985183716,
0.6858623623847961,
-0.08343696594238281,
-0.21431700885295868,
0.6644111275672913,
0.5502749085426331,
0.051009390503168106,
0.27988526225090027,
0.10604527592658997,
-0.30404525995254517,
0.2742159068584442,
0.462990403175354,
0.7569954991340637,
-0.3362364172935486,
0.5284467935562134,
-0.2076413631439209,
0.03210056945681572,
-0.06731897592544556,
-1.0988916158676147,
-0.8239010572433472,
-0.8250228762626648,
-0.5102625489234924,
-0.04969439655542374,
-0.28351321816444397,
0.8609397411346436,
0.7255107760429382,
-1.3177781105041504,
-0.5284953713417053,
-0.19558881223201752,
0.23682408034801483,
-0.15546007454395294,
-0.19594070315361023,
0.5024083256721497,
-0.5429275035858154,
-0.6505274772644043,
0.518044114112854,
0.19934329390525818,
-0.2873583436012268,
-0.5702618360519409,
-0.28606581687927246,
-0.9545875787734985,
0.6225809454917908,
0.7861846089363098,
0.6838698387145996,
-0.8072953224182129,
-0.2868342995643616,
-0.4724850356578827,
0.07760210335254669,
0.15281865000724792,
0.854730486869812,
-0.3296557664871216,
0.39733946323394775,
0.3884834349155426,
0.7002789378166199,
0.018912706524133682,
-0.05500045046210289,
0.4877156615257263,
-0.9776130318641663,
0.16135363280773163,
0.096220463514328,
0.5613178610801697,
0.4531611502170563,
0.008854815736413002,
0.4575030505657196,
-0.11440930515527725,
-0.25915494561195374,
-0.8365535140037537,
0.1652475893497467,
-1.1079472303390503,
-0.4990372359752655,
1.0672916173934937,
0.06928762048482895,
0.02054922841489315,
-0.6894704103469849,
-0.3762812316417694,
0.15773235261440277,
-0.2900269031524658,
0.6482003331184387,
1.0447635650634766,
-0.0481892004609108,
-0.020191438496112823,
-0.7562820315361023,
0.7109058499336243,
0.5706019997596741,
-1.159971833229065,
0.2545608580112457,
0.5048346519470215,
-0.1341613233089447,
0.8459099531173706,
0.45379817485809326,
-0.3170301616191864,
0.2992272973060608,
-0.009653660468757153,
-0.1553395688533783,
0.20768968760967255,
-0.4666343331336975,
-0.34128135442733765,
0.958773672580719,
0.03070742078125477,
-0.02675086446106434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14457v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14457v2
|
Annotation and Classification of Relevant Clauses in Terms-and-Conditions Contracts
| 2024-02-22T11:24:45 | 2024-05-27T09:06:41 |
Pietro Giovanni Bizzaro, Elena Della Valentina, Maurizio Napolitano, Nadia Mana, Massimo Zancanaro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we propose a new annotation scheme to classify different types
of clauses in Terms-and-Conditions contracts with the ultimate goal of
supporting legal experts to quickly identify and assess problematic issues in
this type of legal documents. To this end, we built a small corpus of
Terms-and-Conditions contracts and finalized an annotation scheme of 14
categories, eventually reaching an inter-annotator agreement of 0.92. Then, for
11 of them, we experimented with binary classification tasks using few-shot
prompting with a multilingual T5 and two fine-tuned versions of two BERT-based
LLMs for Italian. Our experiments showed the feasibility of automatic
classification of our categories by reaching accuracies ranging from .79 to .95
on validation tasks.
|
[
-0.7347864508628845,
-0.4803922772407532,
0.6220303773880005,
0.3114461302757263,
-0.6656278967857361,
-0.15060974657535553,
-0.055740755051374435,
-1.0700017213821411,
0.3502870202064514,
0.6788049936294556,
-0.22726725041866302,
-0.66450035572052,
-0.656842827796936,
0.3386196196079254,
-0.2080777883529663,
1.2338865995407104,
0.0013527898117899895,
0.03320351243019104,
-0.2674584984779358,
-0.3203369081020355,
-0.3334644138813019,
-0.7315016388893127,
-0.7954057455062866,
-0.030312422662973404,
0.4912002384662628,
0.22683165967464447,
0.6625962257385254,
0.12084604799747467,
0.5472949147224426,
0.22696514427661896,
-0.1925826519727707,
0.2647301256656647,
0.4600028097629547,
0.05928628146648407,
-0.18267172574996948,
-0.4994029700756073,
-0.25147151947021484,
0.04309708625078201,
0.2615571618080139,
0.306029349565506,
0.1053658202290535,
0.19415231049060822,
-0.3942996561527252,
0.38632073998451233,
-0.5780270099639893,
0.46128931641578674,
-0.4771842062473297,
0.10743896663188934,
-0.047168709337711334,
-0.36098501086235046,
-0.676649272441864,
-0.3661906123161316,
-0.16062039136886597,
-0.6888935565948486,
0.04663223400712013,
0.24904417991638184,
0.9687193036079407,
0.5789050459861755,
-0.6381345987319946,
-0.4465102255344391,
-0.10245474427938461,
0.2376316487789154,
-0.6514504551887512,
0.29217529296875,
0.3369949758052826,
0.2456805557012558,
-0.06953228265047073,
-0.5412112474441528,
-0.506928563117981,
-0.5600757598876953,
-0.4627360701560974,
0.19958654046058655,
0.11850540339946747,
0.17577531933784485,
0.5179353356361389,
0.09020764380693436,
-0.23575805127620697,
0.5879611968994141,
-0.3253650963306427,
-0.46985846757888794,
1.0385980606079102,
0.004052024334669113,
0.24522601068019867,
-0.4999385178089142,
-0.3848162591457367,
0.6612903475761414,
-0.6171759963035583,
0.17390841245651245,
0.38444507122039795,
0.3707776963710785,
-0.19963909685611725,
0.7131730318069458,
-0.2962537407875061,
0.659990131855011,
0.027436792850494385,
-0.1858128011226654,
0.25494006276130676,
-0.3258635103702545,
-0.04585035890340805,
0.09137266129255295,
0.5192183256149292,
0.3551475405693054,
0.17847660183906555,
-0.2566905915737152,
-0.5449431538581848,
-0.0012459097197279334,
0.1915479600429535,
-0.21684089303016663,
0.07135512679815292,
0.3555513918399811,
-0.29574134945869446,
-0.1554018259048462,
0.20685046911239624,
-0.2335907518863678,
-0.6054818034172058,
-0.5465123057365417,
0.40139612555503845,
-0.33445966243743896,
0.054340098053216934,
0.047802213579416275,
-0.12603026628494263,
0.4820350110530853,
0.38473400473594666,
-0.6823830604553223,
0.16814853250980377,
0.5684886574745178,
0.45742306113243103,
0.2867310047149658,
0.05280187726020813,
-0.4816012680530548,
-0.0749410018324852,
-0.3779352605342865,
1.1154907941818237,
-0.26752907037734985,
0.018736034631729126,
0.2540823519229889,
-0.24595046043395996,
-0.06071655824780464,
-0.15354403853416443,
0.5534831881523132,
-0.6682954430580139,
0.33897918462753296,
0.3173140287399292,
-0.5309354662895203,
-0.18155136704444885,
0.37931200861930847,
-0.7090622186660767,
0.760682225227356,
0.23777785897254944,
-0.7734917998313904,
0.9017363786697388,
-0.8616897463798523,
-0.5248262882232666,
0.459909588098526,
-0.35321855545043945,
-0.5418550968170166,
0.08299295604228973,
-0.10659461468458176,
0.565951406955719,
-0.24654175341129303,
0.2560824751853943,
-0.20586559176445007,
-0.17321959137916565,
0.6866915225982666,
0.34250521659851074,
0.7755917906761169,
0.4783700406551361,
-0.38984745740890503,
0.37101417779922485,
-0.6574820280075073,
-0.08432126045227051,
-0.2622184157371521,
-0.5183143615722656,
-0.2523682415485382,
-0.12973026931285858,
-0.010386212728917599,
0.5749580264091492,
0.3359581530094147,
-0.4132348299026489,
0.4829171597957611,
-0.3811478018760681,
0.6250282526016235,
0.3033179044723511,
0.1984405517578125,
0.15174418687820435,
-0.14615611732006073,
0.4917706847190857,
0.0673472061753273,
0.3783164620399475,
0.24107025563716888,
-0.7630746960639954,
-1.1066616773605347,
-0.28634074330329895,
0.7385021448135376,
0.5953853130340576,
-0.9939854741096497,
0.5659626722335815,
0.048360638320446014,
-0.2344251573085785,
-0.6122477650642395,
-0.15003612637519836,
0.5196898579597473,
-0.10284726321697235,
0.36815232038497925,
0.030679788440465927,
-0.4638330638408661,
-1.0515025854110718,
-0.05918309837579727,
-0.3611910343170166,
0.3066083490848541,
0.032468874007463455,
0.73429936170578,
-0.11790533363819122,
0.8575171232223511,
-0.15166915953159332,
-0.6054883003234863,
-0.008140240795910358,
0.5133782029151917,
0.22752925753593445,
0.333574503660202,
0.8143886923789978,
-0.8614090085029602,
-0.47443923354148865,
0.04558044299483299,
-0.4266376793384552,
-0.07550887763500214,
-0.2946203351020813,
0.09092260897159576,
0.6184409856796265,
0.943841278553009,
-0.4786379635334015,
0.41642406582832336,
-0.009285629726946354,
-0.6002722978591919,
0.5058977603912354,
-0.35171571373939514,
0.16143709421157837,
-0.9476621150970459,
-0.16556501388549805,
0.12560461461544037,
-0.5781741738319397,
-0.3935212790966034,
0.19044406712055206,
0.21209990978240967,
0.019401084631681442,
-0.8356461524963379,
0.2682667672634125,
-0.2687911093235016,
-0.13948246836662292,
0.017326239496469498,
0.05132638290524483,
-0.18823544681072235,
0.40071290731430054,
0.2528592646121979,
0.6473447680473328,
0.4275825321674347,
-0.8274145722389221,
0.2479993849992752,
0.4543706476688385,
-0.17818999290466309,
0.5974390506744385,
-0.20784597098827362,
0.1170111671090126,
-0.18817022442817688,
0.17894518375396729,
-0.7689528465270996,
-0.15697360038757324,
0.6130945086479187,
-0.43359553813934326,
0.18738672137260437,
-0.4314114451408386,
-0.9493154883384705,
-0.16709047555923462,
-0.33291351795196533,
0.07854054123163223,
0.15898238122463226,
-0.3707417845726013,
0.6663441061973572,
0.1183248907327652,
0.09250936657190323,
-0.39302611351013184,
-0.7714636921882629,
0.08165448904037476,
-0.5190392136573792,
-0.1872319132089615,
0.45548126101493835,
0.11574633419513702,
-0.22774536907672882,
0.22879378497600555,
0.0912875160574913,
-0.46267515420913696,
0.3471897840499878,
0.2527924180030823,
-0.014943748712539673,
0.0898967757821083,
0.27351224422454834,
0.2060013711452484,
-0.3647456467151642,
-0.02341821789741516,
-0.16310034692287445,
0.2821080982685089,
0.1135549321770668,
-0.11641158908605576,
-0.3213966190814972,
0.41841667890548706,
0.3354540765285492,
-0.31557923555374146,
0.40725207328796387,
0.4358890950679779,
-0.4258401691913605,
-0.022829212248325348,
-0.5801421999931335,
0.2671738862991333,
-0.3808108866214752,
-0.17985519766807556,
-0.8386345505714417,
-0.9336482882499695,
0.6539480090141296,
0.14440391957759857,
0.14789795875549316,
0.9631083607673645,
0.3295991122722626,
-0.1701086014509201,
0.5783186554908752,
0.5904039144515991,
0.2681654989719391,
0.43484950065612793,
0.00011782810906879604,
0.0037015893030911684,
-0.5134641528129578,
-0.5714045763015747,
-0.8303518891334534,
0.059692397713661194,
-0.8906147480010986,
-0.13786889612674713,
0.3275088965892792,
0.2568548023700714,
0.02205011621117592,
0.7213281393051147,
-0.46145203709602356,
0.3944036066532135,
0.4552697241306305,
0.2682197391986847,
0.10972152650356293,
-0.3722488284111023,
-0.3802909553050995,
0.15939673781394958,
-0.4244624674320221,
-0.6077022552490234,
0.6185832023620605,
0.36299943923950195,
0.08698626607656479,
0.3880150318145752,
1.1320849657058716,
0.45042115449905396,
0.37356409430503845,
-1.0870387554168701,
0.4934007525444031,
-0.3416382968425751,
-0.877217710018158,
-0.21274837851524353,
-0.21120750904083252,
-0.9226728677749634,
0.025148944929242134,
-0.5657174587249756,
-0.814605176448822,
0.4504202902317047,
-0.16845782101154327,
-0.694771409034729,
-0.22564013302326202,
-0.7426891326904297,
0.7773457765579224,
-0.35290101170539856,
-0.019603796303272247,
-0.10364467650651932,
-0.7326493263244629,
0.13797424733638763,
-0.16445578634738922,
0.4738171398639679,
-0.40655869245529175,
-0.4842338263988495,
0.9662997126579285,
-0.17554223537445068,
0.8144904971122742,
-0.2648704946041107,
-0.14104683697223663,
0.31745103001594543,
-0.1265786588191986,
0.06192123889923096,
0.3877793252468109,
-0.122250996530056,
0.03372008353471756,
0.23990914225578308,
-0.20920589566230774,
-0.4063462018966675,
0.0626828745007515,
-0.5425575375556946,
-0.3402406871318817,
-0.8211615681648254,
-0.3060755431652069,
-0.36351850628852844,
0.3552408218383789,
0.339413046836853,
0.07937274873256683,
0.34038248658180237,
-0.12920933961868286,
0.18201082944869995,
-0.00886532012373209,
0.4220980405807495,
0.8149743676185608,
-0.051317960023880005,
-0.5321342945098877,
0.5625200271606445,
0.12819033861160278,
-0.01377435214817524,
0.418086439371109,
-0.3137485980987549,
-0.5941726565361023,
-1.0643843412399292,
0.03255907818675041,
0.263497531414032,
-1.0732057094573975,
-0.7081409692764282,
-0.058458197861909866,
-0.09217358380556107,
-0.46263372898101807,
-0.07613734155893326,
0.159129336476326,
-0.6264698505401611,
-0.4561075270175934,
-0.16694295406341553,
0.5261789560317993,
0.711392879486084,
0.11881103366613388,
0.11173015087842941,
-0.8260564804077148,
0.30418822169303894,
0.08535290509462357,
0.6197419762611389,
-1.0491700172424316,
-0.4490385949611664,
-0.504528820514679,
-0.5534971952438354,
0.0467936210334301,
-0.8627371788024902,
0.15014195442199707,
0.24379682540893555,
0.6910423636436462,
0.1713014841079712,
0.27174416184425354,
0.5173050165176392,
-0.3594164252281189,
0.8824506998062134,
0.49613961577415466,
-1.175155758857727,
0.5806242227554321,
0.03357779234647751,
-0.20234541594982147,
0.8967119455337524,
0.5696264505386353,
-0.34057068824768066,
-0.641692578792572,
-0.7636882066726685,
-0.8898981809616089,
0.9147414565086365,
0.08632799237966537,
-0.175644189119339,
-0.08378512412309647,
0.8730872869491577,
0.14154811203479767,
0.18941164016723633,
-0.9473006129264832,
-0.1496914029121399,
0.13215970993041992,
-0.12577296793460846,
-0.04187106341123581,
-0.4641563594341278,
-0.08505965024232864,
-0.112070731818676,
0.6030488014221191,
-0.263318806886673,
0.4514889717102051,
0.29046016931533813,
-0.3608187139034271,
0.27236178517341614,
0.6766253709793091,
0.8224980235099792,
0.7597759962081909,
-0.19544623792171478,
0.23758311569690704,
0.17406022548675537,
0.05591864883899689,
0.38993000984191895,
0.4785086512565613,
-0.21355050802230835,
0.11792901903390884,
0.39714619517326355,
0.8638297915458679,
0.25568386912345886,
-0.1855078935623169,
0.24580112099647522,
0.0015816126251593232,
-0.6365050673484802,
-0.553112268447876,
-0.0017275960417464375,
-0.04082914814352989,
0.6189219355583191,
0.03763867914676666,
-0.0838310718536377,
0.32797855138778687,
-0.45265617966651917,
0.3257656693458557,
0.05016839876770973,
-0.21874210238456726,
0.09987162798643112,
0.35015830397605896,
0.3392111361026764,
-0.19417302310466766,
0.2574481666088104,
-0.6550665497779846,
-0.7186277508735657,
0.41014042496681213,
0.06596168875694275,
0.8577529191970825,
0.1418326199054718,
0.33764514327049255,
0.05393153056502342,
0.25908756256103516,
0.10467426478862762,
0.48409515619277954,
-0.02309424616396427,
-0.756461501121521,
-0.41070809960365295,
-0.3172871470451355,
-0.4506222903728485,
-0.17632462084293365,
-0.7430592775344849,
0.500293493270874,
-0.5987520813941956,
-0.44933316111564636,
0.6264863610267639,
0.15427175164222717,
-0.6394820809364319,
0.22927911579608917,
0.4605386257171631,
0.8982492089271545,
-0.8731772899627686,
1.007617473602295,
1.1666386127471924,
-1.198372483253479,
-0.5974987745285034,
-0.007810864131897688,
-0.4525351822376251,
-0.5092166662216187,
1.0783441066741943,
0.09207840263843536,
0.07776590436697006,
-0.21524661779403687,
-0.36923959851264954,
-0.3830471336841583,
0.8694714903831482,
0.4560314118862152,
-0.6046513319015503,
0.05782482028007507,
0.2737778425216675,
0.63885098695755,
-0.23413105309009552,
0.17034660279750824,
0.8146412372589111,
0.7253566980361938,
-0.08812641352415085,
-1.1852149963378906,
-0.010214976966381073,
-0.14179052412509918,
-0.1412544846534729,
0.23436714708805084,
-0.5476577281951904,
0.5423361659049988,
0.1661706417798996,
-0.05626463517546654,
-0.01754058338701725,
0.49985888600349426,
-0.07874185591936111,
0.42223861813545227,
0.7178865671157837,
0.5024591088294983,
0.6308270692825317,
-0.5465386509895325,
1.0146064758300781,
-0.32333502173423767,
0.5290067791938782,
0.6575415730476379,
0.12295285612344742,
0.7873595952987671,
0.5894213914871216,
-0.31024882197380066,
0.37466689944267273,
1.110228180885315,
-0.09587734192609787,
0.4074883759021759,
0.3586196303367615,
-0.1267784833908081,
-0.5122063159942627,
-0.270453542470932,
-0.2007080614566803,
0.2581130266189575,
0.4910871684551239,
0.04669507220387459,
0.10060244798660278,
-0.04698878899216652,
-0.16442835330963135,
-0.00093500642105937,
-0.3800772726535797,
1.1792309284210205,
0.13911522924900055,
-0.4843015968799591,
0.3001152575016022,
0.2357424795627594,
0.7719457149505615,
-0.4253517687320709,
0.06038430705666542,
-0.013240596279501915,
-0.2543938159942627,
-0.7458521723747253,
-0.8641911745071411,
0.3439125120639801,
0.04234158620238304,
0.09619740396738052,
-0.24620619416236877,
0.4955836236476898,
-0.3497781753540039,
-0.39742979407310486,
0.18309172987937927,
0.03381968289613724,
0.2566068768501282,
0.06929557770490646,
-0.8579467535018921,
0.011137374676764011,
-0.19011855125427246,
0.10882309824228287,
0.008135732263326645,
0.6695705056190491,
-0.14519937336444855,
0.21365825831890106,
0.14745424687862396,
0.001775948447175324,
0.19657009840011597,
0.1254010647535324,
0.6556667685508728,
-0.8626857995986938,
-0.6118543148040771,
-0.48529431223869324,
0.808641791343689,
-0.056716084480285645,
-0.4190794825553894,
0.41674792766571045,
0.44324159622192383,
0.6737290024757385,
-0.16488856077194214,
0.6221250891685486,
-0.10154100507497787,
0.3155573010444641,
-1.1228584051132202,
0.23063620924949646,
-0.5110307931900024,
0.2581416964530945,
-0.026543255895376205,
-0.7166835069656372,
-0.963042676448822,
0.6478161215782166,
-0.4633229970932007,
-0.14931346476078033,
1.1436340808868408,
0.05214159935712814,
0.310610294342041,
-0.23811180889606476,
0.2451055645942688,
-0.2764946520328522,
0.4010196626186371,
0.3852418065071106,
0.9702656865119934,
-0.30110418796539307,
0.5010178089141846,
-0.3228331208229065,
0.0820988267660141,
-0.44100216031074524,
-0.8484643697738647,
-0.8845199346542358,
-0.6029961705207825,
-0.9232533574104309,
-0.3508601486682892,
-0.10602974146604538,
1.243454098701477,
0.6547697186470032,
-1.0259593725204468,
-0.1408310979604721,
-0.06937191635370255,
0.10521867871284485,
-0.01877513900399208,
-0.1386231631040573,
0.2681907117366791,
-1.116592288017273,
-0.512048065662384,
0.07524506747722626,
0.12637703120708466,
0.2210630178451538,
-0.07073400914669037,
0.03358461707830429,
-0.17153973877429962,
-0.014403969049453735,
0.6905682682991028,
0.12808775901794434,
-0.8313632011413574,
-0.507392942905426,
-0.7367898225784302,
-0.1743384450674057,
0.044136982411146164,
1.0658196210861206,
-0.3112466633319855,
0.28043949604034424,
0.3104436695575714,
0.5167286396026611,
0.6561723351478577,
-0.239717498421669,
0.08554146438837051,
-1.0750385522842407,
0.5599748492240906,
0.5234209895133972,
0.6495466232299805,
0.0036654016003012657,
-0.45535698533058167,
0.5873855948448181,
-0.17737197875976562,
-0.13316933810710907,
-0.3650844693183899,
0.32206836342811584,
-1.078022837638855,
-0.3330364525318146,
0.998136579990387,
-0.3362250030040741,
0.036318305879831314,
-0.5167625546455383,
-0.2592758238315582,
0.19186416268348694,
-0.3256699740886688,
0.7092723250389099,
0.6173564195632935,
-0.480736643075943,
-0.09851229935884476,
-0.4720189869403839,
0.776387631893158,
0.19726961851119995,
-1.092525839805603,
-0.4747965633869171,
0.6480245590209961,
-0.011807471513748169,
0.6672403812408447,
0.5365146994590759,
-0.15340036153793335,
0.4734240472316742,
-0.23395031690597534,
0.033533401787281036,
-0.08451489359140396,
-0.33588477969169617,
-0.4506126344203949,
0.26581957936286926,
0.7799256443977356,
-0.3661693334579468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14453v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14453v1
|
Do LLMs Implicitly Determine the Suitable Text Difficulty for Users?
| 2024-02-22T11:16:23 | 2024-02-22T11:16:23 |
Seiji Gobara, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Education that suits the individual learning level is necessary to improve
students' understanding. The first step in achieving this purpose by using
large language models (LLMs) is to adjust the textual difficulty of the
response to students. This work analyzes how LLMs can implicitly adjust text
difficulty between user input and its generated text. To conduct the
experiments, we created a new dataset from Stack-Overflow to explore the
performance of question-answering-based conversation. Experimental results on
the Stack-Overflow dataset and the TSCC dataset, including multi-turn
conversation show that LLMs can implicitly handle text difficulty between user
input and its generated response. We also observed that some LLMs can surpass
humans in handling text difficulty and the importance of instruction-tuning.
|
[
-0.2867545187473297,
-1.0363843441009521,
0.9626266956329346,
0.02882489562034607,
-0.045371200889348984,
0.3132559061050415,
-0.4261874258518219,
-0.4439878463745117,
-0.35829484462738037,
0.3439425528049469,
-0.7885574698448181,
-0.44262468814849854,
-0.6245284080505371,
0.5218095183372498,
-0.3506808280944824,
1.1573220491409302,
-0.0519050695002079,
0.19537025690078735,
-0.6336201429367065,
0.10177440196275711,
-0.7185690999031067,
-0.555030345916748,
-0.7556712031364441,
-0.3449874222278595,
0.6810871958732605,
0.7173373103141785,
0.7161147594451904,
0.24528144299983978,
0.5796954035758972,
0.3925779163837433,
-0.38114723563194275,
0.07205213606357574,
-0.7100468277931213,
0.34857749938964844,
-0.30249178409576416,
-0.6484794020652771,
-0.32699647545814514,
-0.2787562310695648,
0.7110883593559265,
0.6716943979263306,
-0.027452904731035233,
-0.17239908874034882,
0.2797944247722626,
0.5288119912147522,
-0.24922282993793488,
-0.138371080160141,
-0.5770785212516785,
-0.1098162904381752,
-0.10291708260774612,
-0.502098798751831,
-0.4645068049430847,
-0.3476039469242096,
0.36639708280563354,
-0.4355319142341614,
0.3446430265903473,
0.19516915082931519,
0.5193483829498291,
0.3336311876773834,
-0.5729192495346069,
-0.7548539638519287,
-0.7848370671272278,
0.7690920233726501,
-0.5443075299263,
0.28380000591278076,
0.12252479791641235,
0.07040811330080032,
-0.44035661220550537,
-0.39087769389152527,
-0.4026878774166107,
-0.137337788939476,
-0.2487482726573944,
0.07188108563423157,
0.11443834006786346,
0.2483222484588623,
0.4847480058670044,
0.3082486689090729,
-0.38878118991851807,
0.38283267617225647,
-0.7795791029930115,
0.03612267225980759,
0.5677061080932617,
0.6155024170875549,
0.6229256391525269,
-0.1995849609375,
-0.17037269473075867,
0.06517788022756577,
-0.6119599938392639,
0.25707605481147766,
0.301008939743042,
0.3259928226470947,
0.05990470200777054,
0.8068488836288452,
-0.1444561779499054,
0.6467594504356384,
-0.1564079225063324,
-0.1057194173336029,
-0.04381599649786949,
-0.15988609194755554,
-0.12899570167064667,
0.07499472051858902,
0.537912130355835,
0.18914642930030823,
0.5224407315254211,
-0.09450766444206238,
-0.26204001903533936,
-0.12184716016054153,
0.2613449692726135,
-0.9053992629051208,
0.051346879452466965,
0.3770587742328644,
0.03219423070549965,
-0.12017912417650223,
-0.04900366812944412,
-0.5146304368972778,
-0.6266094446182251,
-0.37814122438430786,
0.5516505241394043,
-0.2591139078140259,
-0.05632854625582695,
0.29023632407188416,
-0.0008838709909468889,
0.012961242347955704,
0.4543636441230774,
-0.9733263254165649,
0.5937979817390442,
0.6709187626838684,
0.8796230554580688,
-0.5102847218513489,
-0.20837752521038055,
-0.26532620191574097,
0.02840733900666237,
-0.2975120544433594,
0.6438190937042236,
-0.6062353849411011,
-0.7067320346832275,
-0.07932102680206299,
-0.2630558907985687,
-0.3028385639190674,
-0.3299362361431122,
0.5679436326026917,
-0.46585753560066223,
0.3338315784931183,
-0.35146501660346985,
-0.7747246623039246,
0.20686130225658417,
0.07230491191148758,
-0.39979392290115356,
0.9377592206001282,
-0.08079587668180466,
-0.9064831733703613,
0.07723700255155563,
-0.7184181213378906,
-0.6457117795944214,
-0.11496847122907639,
0.04908788204193115,
-0.2235344499349594,
0.3955703675746918,
0.304279625415802,
0.5920194387435913,
-0.34106725454330444,
0.038973234593868256,
-0.13557495176792145,
-0.6216644644737244,
0.7174845337867737,
-0.20398718118667603,
0.4169299900531769,
-0.057485513389110565,
0.002181468764320016,
0.14205291867256165,
-0.6533344984054565,
0.1455434113740921,
0.08349617570638657,
-0.6670696139335632,
-0.41635066270828247,
0.2568871080875397,
-0.35367393493652344,
0.15251941978931427,
0.20929068326950073,
-0.4249613285064697,
0.2628196179866791,
-0.4969837963581085,
0.5623182058334351,
0.9766651391983032,
0.04726581275463104,
0.2920602858066559,
-0.20499223470687866,
0.6196117997169495,
-0.07968605309724808,
-0.10408644378185272,
-0.34531810879707336,
-0.4365483820438385,
-0.9405468702316284,
0.2128874957561493,
0.15905074775218964,
0.663694441318512,
-0.6534219980239868,
-0.17886017262935638,
-0.08948112279176712,
-0.17950844764709473,
-0.623279333114624,
0.48575225472450256,
0.5000946521759033,
0.5744242668151855,
0.32397377490997314,
0.0635019987821579,
-0.3088762164115906,
-0.6258609294891357,
-0.15368428826332092,
-0.2615435719490051,
-0.20658142864704132,
0.589750349521637,
0.2631375789642334,
-0.10375823825597763,
0.7806127071380615,
-0.6499733924865723,
-0.06623329967260361,
-0.33812353014945984,
0.4318755865097046,
-0.10497817397117615,
0.19589591026306152,
0.06385565549135208,
-0.7097823023796082,
-0.4129992425441742,
-0.23894375562667847,
-0.5220537781715393,
-0.4183672070503235,
-0.09478048235177994,
0.0063943564891815186,
0.5334398746490479,
0.6566030979156494,
-0.4071425497531891,
0.20776478946208954,
0.4214377999305725,
-0.38162168860435486,
0.3097282946109772,
-0.5900474190711975,
0.27814531326293945,
-0.9291960000991821,
-0.4027424454689026,
0.19339460134506226,
-0.06970448791980743,
-0.5996259450912476,
-0.14115045964717865,
0.12013156712055206,
0.01714680902659893,
-0.4751269221305847,
0.438444584608078,
-0.39016392827033997,
-0.15335682034492493,
-0.31658902764320374,
0.4337921142578125,
-0.08968556672334671,
0.4796213209629059,
0.1435999572277069,
1.0620168447494507,
0.47472402453422546,
-0.7973008155822754,
0.2367856651544571,
0.19296018779277802,
-0.214554563164711,
0.7285465598106384,
-1.115039348602295,
0.4051227569580078,
-0.35959064960479736,
0.17878197133541107,
-1.4477428197860718,
-0.36269611120224,
-0.006002495065331459,
-0.2968752086162567,
0.1323738694190979,
0.13365015387535095,
-0.3372091054916382,
-0.37681373953819275,
-0.08254212141036987,
0.22691290080547333,
0.32786989212036133,
-0.3943976163864136,
0.4614371061325073,
0.08647746592760086,
-0.5186460614204407,
-0.2890508770942688,
-0.5116292238235474,
0.21435624361038208,
-0.05112837627530098,
-0.6411554217338562,
0.2694271206855774,
-0.6720555424690247,
-0.20489884912967682,
-0.2503264844417572,
0.22621232271194458,
0.04718771576881409,
0.08929236233234406,
0.49098312854766846,
0.27609124779701233,
-0.17648205161094666,
0.6575419306755066,
0.1507319062948227,
0.060965653508901596,
0.23336470127105713,
0.1212952733039856,
0.4207863211631775,
-0.09055411070585251,
-0.40098077058792114,
-0.3404635787010193,
0.2707873284816742,
0.3012387752532959,
0.12302475422620773,
0.6908228397369385,
0.16633866727352142,
-0.08295481652021408,
-0.31629478931427,
-0.49604332447052,
-0.3475673198699951,
-0.5480062365531921,
0.5080917477607727,
-0.5501874685287476,
-1.0677322149276733,
0.31498944759368896,
0.05418622866272926,
0.1273506134748459,
0.2514112591743469,
0.6612677574157715,
-0.3770753741264343,
1.4009522199630737,
0.5760526657104492,
0.1452610194683075,
0.06670038402080536,
0.27781522274017334,
-0.07566799968481064,
-0.7300567626953125,
-0.40712377429008484,
-0.8128498792648315,
-0.4041216969490051,
-0.6680724620819092,
-0.16673211753368378,
0.20687530934810638,
-0.1842634081840515,
-0.17821767926216125,
-0.10595626384019852,
-0.25863954424858093,
0.5317627787590027,
0.2966233789920807,
0.24798044562339783,
0.39137589931488037,
-0.11148327589035034,
-0.0025044253561645746,
-0.2926347851753235,
-0.546640157699585,
-0.4304695725440979,
0.9361416101455688,
0.4477199912071228,
1.0518602132797241,
0.21222606301307678,
0.3658919334411621,
0.12817266583442688,
0.36838775873184204,
-0.7487326264381409,
0.6359977722167969,
-0.13250328600406647,
-0.564812183380127,
-0.5189307332038879,
-0.6891566514968872,
-0.9814741611480713,
-0.05306142568588257,
-0.41804543137550354,
-0.6959263682365417,
-0.3171978294849396,
0.17279617488384247,
-0.18360528349876404,
0.12880924344062805,
-0.8796334266662598,
0.43265894055366516,
-0.5240705609321594,
-0.26840686798095703,
-0.043327443301677704,
-0.511029064655304,
0.17370887100696564,
-0.14721331000328064,
0.17736339569091797,
-0.044579729437828064,
-0.22257155179977417,
0.7759392261505127,
-0.20445947349071503,
0.8805192112922668,
-0.0020685684867203236,
-0.361620157957077,
0.20663179457187653,
0.13685671985149384,
0.39343151450157166,
0.09831762313842773,
-0.16177549958229065,
-0.1687554121017456,
-0.2333972156047821,
-0.20613783597946167,
-0.8760139346122742,
0.8654054403305054,
-0.8723938465118408,
-1.0180004835128784,
-0.25699761509895325,
-0.6919707655906677,
-0.43862754106521606,
-0.07066459208726883,
0.23449568450450897,
0.4489947259426117,
-0.26380863785743713,
0.30164796113967896,
0.960848867893219,
-0.3843042552471161,
0.4381413161754608,
0.8134015798568726,
-0.20291325449943542,
0.058127809315919876,
0.8426463603973389,
0.22112791240215302,
0.45977872610092163,
0.3346790075302124,
0.4375677704811096,
-0.5843566656112671,
-0.6258691549301147,
-0.5729864239692688,
-0.026585791260004044,
-0.6310697197914124,
0.00511491484940052,
-0.6067097187042236,
-0.30686959624290466,
-0.07425631582736969,
-0.21215298771858215,
-0.007770384196192026,
-0.26707345247268677,
-0.6057760715484619,
-0.186469167470932,
0.5440012216567993,
1.0628087520599365,
0.3981442451477051,
0.6036553382873535,
-0.5523838996887207,
0.39900997281074524,
0.6260295510292053,
0.45747295022010803,
-0.2801564037799835,
-0.9499778747558594,
0.13230541348457336,
0.07307007908821106,
-0.1306564211845398,
-0.7105838060379028,
0.12348945438861847,
0.351525217294693,
0.17134417593479156,
-0.0524803027510643,
-0.02438146248459816,
0.5189981460571289,
-0.4670059084892273,
0.6367906928062439,
0.05591370910406113,
-1.0409599542617798,
0.5684139132499695,
-0.15833896398544312,
0.47307640314102173,
0.32660818099975586,
0.4517418444156647,
-0.6688854694366455,
-0.52553790807724,
-0.2996200621128082,
-0.6979353427886963,
0.8628414273262024,
0.2531650960445404,
0.7555800676345825,
0.312521755695343,
0.6612467169761658,
-0.015974828973412514,
0.08679746836423874,
-0.6583901643753052,
-0.09214304387569427,
0.13158375024795532,
-0.3641776740550995,
-0.2630344033241272,
-0.47159844636917114,
0.09032222628593445,
-0.19886398315429688,
0.4875573515892029,
-0.03276178985834122,
-0.015466620214283466,
0.006627235561609268,
-0.14462508261203766,
-0.3704685866832733,
0.5726051926612854,
0.7649715542793274,
0.8571460843086243,
-0.2357916384935379,
-0.006513688247650862,
0.5956847667694092,
-0.33830979466438293,
0.16604819893836975,
-0.1605886071920395,
-0.04495754465460777,
-0.3184775710105896,
0.25871720910072327,
0.8841056823730469,
0.3930453360080719,
-0.7496078014373779,
0.4123265743255615,
-0.41663748025894165,
-0.3202587366104126,
0.14121940732002258,
0.7052396535873413,
0.12463047355413437,
0.13461773097515106,
0.6176641583442688,
-0.3631252348423004,
-0.021846452727913857,
-0.414417564868927,
-0.032045699656009674,
0.3439188301563263,
-0.36425358057022095,
-0.14282220602035522,
0.6031886339187622,
0.3969780206680298,
-0.7262778282165527,
0.6025785207748413,
0.274234414100647,
-0.49441176652908325,
0.6049021482467651,
0.7601175308227539,
0.5291551947593689,
-0.29741016030311584,
0.3229016065597534,
0.2435847520828247,
0.25815528631210327,
-0.03534204885363579,
0.22255867719650269,
0.24715913832187653,
-0.5837940573692322,
-0.5965493321418762,
-0.40559521317481995,
-0.8888698220252991,
0.047765184193849564,
-0.491495281457901,
0.34178802371025085,
-0.6445409655570984,
0.05135487765073776,
0.1640598624944687,
0.06724007427692413,
-0.5661038160324097,
0.7789273858070374,
-0.018625648692250252,
0.5816986560821533,
-0.6672083735466003,
0.4872249960899353,
0.6077606678009033,
-0.043020665645599365,
-0.6863391995429993,
-0.08492006361484528,
-0.1945614069700241,
-0.7278791666030884,
0.40729856491088867,
0.000022164562324178405,
-0.28516682982444763,
0.040099240839481354,
-0.8381272554397583,
-0.43252018094062805,
0.7115638852119446,
0.40253204107284546,
-0.6662135720252991,
0.07276972383260727,
0.5041846036911011,
0.8836224675178528,
-0.21343769133090973,
0.47172993421554565,
0.4110679030418396,
0.2699297070503235,
0.2775881588459015,
-0.5922185778617859,
-0.0225870031863451,
-0.22679615020751953,
0.01312953233718872,
0.28481951355934143,
-0.5293937921524048,
0.8156046867370605,
-0.4442484974861145,
-0.26163965463638306,
-0.21050649881362915,
0.8174774646759033,
0.10623673349618912,
0.3758707642555237,
0.5918771028518677,
0.06877052783966064,
0.8269755840301514,
-0.2001906931400299,
0.9521042704582214,
0.0032036234624683857,
0.07180730253458023,
1.0966455936431885,
-0.1481287032365799,
0.8896631598472595,
0.5183168649673462,
-0.14875708520412445,
0.5231112837791443,
0.6114504337310791,
0.37094685435295105,
-0.057321563363075256,
0.492845356464386,
-0.05107012018561363,
-0.25109001994132996,
0.040208395570516586,
-0.2858610153198242,
0.30703580379486084,
0.5835555195808411,
-0.15241216123104095,
0.1311604231595993,
0.06780209392309189,
-0.06878222525119781,
0.3006651997566223,
-0.36027976870536804,
0.8625877499580383,
-0.07379832863807678,
-0.7205399870872498,
0.5744159817695618,
0.37511491775512695,
0.6703011393547058,
-0.5624182820320129,
0.04979560896754265,
-0.3131939470767975,
-0.2841552793979645,
-0.2961183190345764,
-1.1509766578674316,
-0.012850256636738777,
0.2145949900150299,
-0.20550747215747833,
-0.11072202026844025,
0.8566852807998657,
-0.47605884075164795,
-0.7133409976959229,
0.18164929747581482,
0.455046683549881,
0.21921302378177643,
0.11525445431470871,
-0.5402548909187317,
0.13117054104804993,
-0.16814486682415009,
-0.39142653346061707,
0.15659767389297485,
0.6091341972351074,
0.033531587570905685,
0.8239844441413879,
0.5270655751228333,
-0.02417575567960739,
0.07553605735301971,
0.15319545567035675,
0.7532639503479004,
-0.6646769642829895,
-0.3009493350982666,
-0.9479933977127075,
0.4727012813091278,
-0.07013031840324402,
-0.4778054356575012,
0.5789833664894104,
0.1660050004720688,
0.6658846139907837,
0.1256721019744873,
0.8006575107574463,
0.16309574246406555,
0.8092305064201355,
-0.7523208260536194,
0.30900323390960693,
-0.7392598390579224,
0.512037992477417,
-0.4272889196872711,
-0.6857074499130249,
-0.09597461670637131,
0.3057115375995636,
-0.4023764133453369,
0.2329619973897934,
0.5630235075950623,
0.8590604662895203,
0.07678812742233276,
0.10928720980882645,
0.2710510492324829,
0.2307041436433792,
0.14574608206748962,
0.7687142491340637,
1.024525761604309,
-0.032289907336235046,
0.8291435837745667,
-0.021532554179430008,
0.01896364986896515,
-0.26230159401893616,
-0.8117976784706116,
-1.2058838605880737,
-0.4369685649871826,
-0.2272460162639618,
-0.27684319019317627,
0.30441346764564514,
0.7205064296722412,
0.3074212968349457,
-0.6952717900276184,
-0.23447014391422272,
-0.15504629909992218,
0.4283056855201721,
0.31928807497024536,
-0.16049312055110931,
0.27257901430130005,
-0.555744469165802,
-1.0941270589828491,
0.23242124915122986,
0.11889300495386124,
0.34055039286613464,
-0.431730717420578,
-0.3109362721443176,
0.058775562793016434,
0.5280248522758484,
0.47182610630989075,
0.12581968307495117,
-0.45463669300079346,
-0.3782669007778168,
0.22158320248126984,
-0.6505496501922607,
0.21012385189533234,
1.0450139045715332,
-0.44110652804374695,
0.5647361278533936,
0.39401641488075256,
0.6843332052230835,
0.3766656219959259,
0.2214239537715912,
0.6022765636444092,
-1.0439106225967407,
-0.09292785078287125,
-0.21178287267684937,
-0.024410942569375038,
0.42085301876068115,
-0.6413580179214478,
0.22352218627929688,
-0.17045721411705017,
-0.6314417123794556,
-0.7148923873901367,
-0.10529028624296188,
-0.6839436292648315,
-0.456392377614975,
1.2865070104599,
0.10244397073984146,
-0.060124993324279785,
-0.1917896568775177,
-0.6698830723762512,
0.08124887943267822,
-0.37786000967025757,
0.9488421082496643,
0.9534520506858826,
-0.0495278500020504,
-0.36326655745506287,
-0.602537214756012,
0.5714060068130493,
0.7973727583885193,
-0.9682964086532593,
-0.10636183619499207,
0.4252825379371643,
0.19259598851203918,
-0.24298980832099915,
0.5811780691146851,
0.36907368898391724,
-0.008121894672513008,
-0.6045793294906616,
-0.31717538833618164,
-0.0009245168184861541,
-0.5352510213851929,
-0.306776762008667,
0.26522067189216614,
0.24653956294059753,
0.22483548521995544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14889v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14889v2
|
COBIAS: Contextual Reliability in Bias Assessment
| 2024-02-22T10:46:11 | 2024-06-17T09:01:25 |
Priyanshul Govil, Hemang Jain, Vamshi Krishna Bonagiri, Aman Chadha, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru, Manas Gaur, Sanorita Dey
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained on extensive web corpora, which
enable them to understand and generate human-like text. However, this training
process also results in inherent biases within the models. These biases arise
from web data's diverse and often uncurated nature, containing various
stereotypes and prejudices. Previous works on debiasing models rely on
benchmark datasets to measure their method's performance. However, these
datasets suffer from several pitfalls due to the highly subjective
understanding of bias, highlighting a critical need for contextual exploration.
We propose understanding the context of inputs by considering the diverse
situations in which they may arise. Our contribution is two-fold: (i) we
augment 2,291 stereotyped statements from two existing bias-benchmark datasets
with points for adding context; (ii) we develop the Context-Oriented Bias
Indicator and Assessment Score (COBIAS) to assess a statement's contextual
reliability in measuring bias. Our metric aligns with human judgment on
contextual reliability of statements (Spearman's $\rho = 0.65, p = 3.4 *
10^{-60}$) and can be used to create reliable datasets, which would assist bias
mitigation works.
|
[
-0.6337562203407288,
-0.6815699934959412,
0.5850617289543152,
0.4342358112335205,
-0.06688752770423889,
-0.16947726905345917,
-0.39312946796417236,
-0.42044755816459656,
-0.07615358382463455,
0.22542382776737213,
-0.4114902913570404,
-0.5297891497612,
-0.7231228947639465,
0.14269192516803741,
-0.4114729166030884,
0.9024908542633057,
-0.1254943609237671,
0.4324827492237091,
-0.524659276008606,
-0.4262569844722748,
-0.6221391558647156,
-0.4987732470035553,
-0.2715098261833191,
-0.20228621363639832,
0.16064809262752533,
0.39122703671455383,
0.6221355199813843,
0.3363008201122284,
0.440561980009079,
0.12295529246330261,
-0.163808211684227,
-0.1328607201576233,
-0.6035621166229248,
0.4579259753227234,
-0.5445665121078491,
-0.3979087173938751,
-0.3649694323539734,
0.17862850427627563,
0.3134627938270569,
1.162022352218628,
0.05273154005408287,
0.33062154054641724,
0.2930222451686859,
0.35391443967819214,
-0.8324610590934753,
0.04500433802604675,
-0.7056764364242554,
0.13795845210552216,
-0.0718018189072609,
0.1002245545387268,
-0.4862114489078522,
-0.4843403995037079,
0.5518718957901001,
-0.51607346534729,
0.1843189150094986,
0.13740165531635284,
0.44866862893104553,
0.3992561995983124,
-0.7631024718284607,
-0.5386184453964233,
-0.6333630681037903,
1.129550814628601,
-0.4646422564983368,
0.3102121651172638,
0.4747929871082306,
0.345177561044693,
-0.09903114289045334,
-0.20768387615680695,
-0.2549780011177063,
-0.2360134720802307,
-0.024952292442321777,
0.009749643504619598,
0.024820804595947266,
-0.2950248718261719,
0.34143078327178955,
0.1551351249217987,
-0.37146732211112976,
0.132369726896286,
-0.2187831699848175,
-0.34722816944122314,
0.6015843749046326,
0.0852133110165596,
0.2748662829399109,
-0.140997052192688,
-0.6040921807289124,
-0.09042268991470337,
-0.7306231260299683,
-0.11945272982120514,
0.3824717402458191,
0.1663789004087448,
-0.2612305283546448,
0.3153521716594696,
-0.22072134912014008,
0.8472340106964111,
0.15275795757770538,
-0.23220916092395782,
0.30820199847221375,
-0.23437415063381195,
-0.23175454139709473,
0.014345120638608932,
0.5211698412895203,
0.5569445490837097,
0.4082964360713959,
-0.2789931297302246,
0.08157756179571152,
0.18504050374031067,
0.27474600076675415,
-0.5147042870521545,
0.183885395526886,
0.4455411434173584,
-0.2080133557319641,
-0.28215667605400085,
0.06141217052936554,
-0.986571729183197,
-0.559378445148468,
-0.2227456420660019,
0.05368339270353317,
-0.2681632339954376,
-0.059087932109832764,
-0.2359587401151657,
-0.27661728858947754,
0.05485396832227707,
0.35749563574790955,
-0.5724841952323914,
0.20436811447143555,
0.38988396525382996,
0.5188536643981934,
-0.45944511890411377,
-0.19599084556102753,
-0.474231094121933,
0.13382667303085327,
-0.4097723960876465,
0.4142569601535797,
-0.5977655649185181,
-0.2962929308414459,
0.24895226955413818,
-0.2946949005126953,
0.3254372179508209,
-0.7026435136795044,
0.929399847984314,
-0.5470209121704102,
0.15686020255088806,
-0.7466212511062622,
-0.42738550901412964,
-0.2014433592557907,
0.5523204207420349,
-0.6308030486106873,
0.9077707529067993,
0.221185103058815,
-0.9308017492294312,
0.7825769186019897,
-0.35936886072158813,
-0.3729616403579712,
-0.3842388689517975,
-0.30254480242729187,
-0.13777782022953033,
0.10065340250730515,
0.3532780408859253,
0.3346429169178009,
-0.4854665696620941,
0.8016655445098877,
-0.812493085861206,
-0.3794909417629242,
0.46778246760368347,
-0.5516113042831421,
0.9232974648475647,
0.1119498610496521,
-0.5708385705947876,
-0.31720736622810364,
-0.9801973104476929,
-0.20549587905406952,
-0.25153985619544983,
-0.2744847536087036,
-0.800168514251709,
0.0006010046345181763,
0.1027984470129013,
0.39302974939346313,
0.09330487251281738,
-0.421095609664917,
-0.10201658308506012,
-0.18822018802165985,
0.1280789077281952,
0.7806647419929504,
-0.12719318270683289,
0.583031415939331,
-0.04379294440150261,
0.3696577847003937,
0.2623221278190613,
-0.0005732204299420118,
0.0639677569270134,
-0.06167104095220566,
-0.8800373077392578,
-0.23908159136772156,
0.20406343042850494,
0.4038245975971222,
-0.4941176474094391,
0.511391818523407,
-0.2582346200942993,
-0.3877517282962799,
0.03088518977165222,
0.23253601789474487,
0.5052220821380615,
0.6953567862510681,
0.5377016663551331,
-0.4960630238056183,
-0.8707022070884705,
-1.0172441005706787,
-0.4419262409210205,
0.06512251496315002,
-0.11201076209545135,
0.39246729016304016,
0.6042351126670837,
-0.45344918966293335,
1.3341898918151855,
-0.2313617467880249,
-0.17768242955207825,
-0.07942183315753937,
0.1787130981683731,
0.028781812638044357,
0.32102322578430176,
0.6031889915466309,
-0.558997392654419,
-0.3197909891605377,
-0.7035282254219055,
-1.1638596057891846,
-0.4121626317501068,
0.1337261199951172,
0.10446812957525253,
0.05444731190800667,
0.2452860027551651,
-0.2583833336830139,
0.2828819155693054,
0.7719548940658569,
-0.3483213782310486,
0.46173080801963806,
0.2964218854904175,
-0.07249467819929123,
-0.9564627408981323,
-0.019612004980444908,
0.3509189188480377,
-0.14905302226543427,
-0.37596967816352844,
-0.0962536409497261,
-0.329738974571228,
0.12344156205654144,
-0.32180503010749817,
0.6768087148666382,
-0.5234469175338745,
-0.38884538412094116,
0.08177363127470016,
0.3766546845436096,
0.1686890870332718,
0.14770859479904175,
-0.15109843015670776,
0.6619113087654114,
0.47548094391822815,
-0.678032398223877,
0.24087028205394745,
0.20485611259937286,
-0.5623608827590942,
0.9693484306335449,
-0.5349996089935303,
0.13669036328792572,
0.02540474757552147,
0.5135879516601562,
-0.8522258996963501,
-0.25610458850860596,
0.21946704387664795,
-0.1895289272069931,
-0.0865638330578804,
0.014355813153088093,
-0.04534832015633583,
-0.13412536680698395,
-0.35528960824012756,
0.5701402425765991,
0.10114753246307373,
-0.7048820853233337,
0.22826401889324188,
0.6380466222763062,
-0.0920194461941719,
-1.1012524366378784,
-0.7742965817451477,
0.039093345403671265,
-0.23584367334842682,
-0.575783908367157,
0.13146425783634186,
-0.03917881101369858,
-0.8731508255004883,
-0.2249845564365387,
-0.17457322776317596,
-0.1862121820449829,
0.24704496562480927,
0.40040135383605957,
0.1550622135400772,
0.007470710203051567,
0.012995327822864056,
0.15997256338596344,
0.20549257099628448,
0.3186390697956085,
0.014529161155223846,
0.618536651134491,
-0.04655161127448082,
-0.42353081703186035,
-0.19252517819404602,
0.23206265270709991,
0.5354059934616089,
0.2417248636484146,
0.6396816968917847,
0.4686349928379059,
-0.2495431751012802,
-0.09595588594675064,
-0.638109564781189,
-0.11577185988426208,
-0.3514711260795593,
0.35685092210769653,
-0.39604535698890686,
-0.930042028427124,
0.5539830327033997,
0.09261040389537811,
-0.13850952684879303,
0.4292141795158386,
0.6249268651008606,
-0.2771856188774109,
0.705193042755127,
0.5106475353240967,
-0.2655930817127228,
0.08711834996938705,
0.07402212172746658,
-0.05527311936020851,
-0.8776060342788696,
-0.12434473633766174,
-0.41516751050949097,
-0.23111407458782196,
-0.3927813768386841,
-0.40276771783828735,
0.5125018358230591,
0.060104694217443466,
-0.3508513867855072,
-0.002162429504096508,
-0.22586743533611298,
0.1676083356142044,
0.44519487023353577,
0.0022305590100586414,
0.33645200729370117,
0.10965604335069656,
-0.3433409035205841,
-0.1464279443025589,
-0.4328881502151489,
-0.7261140942573547,
1.3369797468185425,
0.521649181842804,
0.917570948600769,
0.1051810085773468,
0.5098161101341248,
0.5574603080749512,
0.6025869846343994,
-0.4976026117801666,
0.32100939750671387,
0.2734543979167938,
-1.0576881170272827,
-0.34659987688064575,
-0.28137874603271484,
-0.4974726736545563,
0.2973746657371521,
-0.21674208343029022,
-0.7524513006210327,
0.5450572967529297,
0.29920947551727295,
-0.3046554625034332,
-0.1333215832710266,
-0.3950851261615753,
0.5826565623283386,
-0.3178809583187103,
-0.7662484049797058,
-0.1450476497411728,
-0.5189507007598877,
0.5673701167106628,
0.0022608975414186716,
0.5263967514038086,
-0.0768604725599289,
-0.0625264123082161,
0.9562119841575623,
-0.23735126852989197,
0.9703061580657959,
-0.20172899961471558,
-0.32561248540878296,
0.2853694558143616,
0.1354849487543106,
0.2728302776813507,
0.36588844656944275,
-0.3677370846271515,
0.4478626847267151,
-0.060945574194192886,
-0.34064429998397827,
-0.480989545583725,
0.5904268622398376,
-0.7861986756324768,
-0.5815714001655579,
-0.734862744808197,
-0.6346913576126099,
-0.5676151514053345,
-0.07529276609420776,
0.1742868274450302,
0.4046994745731354,
-0.6480172872543335,
0.18185579776763916,
0.5378690361976624,
-0.3520738482475281,
0.2336786538362503,
0.31785494089126587,
-0.07669389992952347,
-0.378512978553772,
0.3031936585903168,
0.08188318461179733,
0.13302947580814362,
0.009930523112416267,
0.036311373114585876,
-0.10795443505048752,
-0.3461189270019531,
-0.47905096411705017,
-0.2250221073627472,
-0.9143197536468506,
-0.13079236447811127,
-0.4743210971355438,
0.19069884717464447,
-0.36945435404777527,
-0.22115173935890198,
-0.3385421931743622,
-0.19088298082351685,
-0.03487923741340637,
-0.22790592908859253,
0.02224370837211609,
0.6622456312179565,
-0.06062759831547737,
0.16349028050899506,
-0.48545312881469727,
0.1563616245985031,
0.3959575593471527,
0.26570963859558105,
0.035627562552690506,
-0.5846484899520874,
-0.13870671391487122,
0.10760543495416641,
-0.10688382387161255,
-1.0402461290359497,
0.3069678843021393,
-0.2523387670516968,
0.5367447137832642,
0.4745296239852905,
-0.025990916416049004,
0.3976857662200928,
-0.22570283710956573,
0.8174905776977539,
0.11349526047706604,
-1.1143437623977661,
0.40439119935035706,
-0.4482395052909851,
0.06174079328775406,
0.9659470319747925,
0.6431337594985962,
-0.43023109436035156,
-0.24883680045604706,
-0.3089500069618225,
-0.826316773891449,
0.5077288746833801,
-0.09508992731571198,
-0.00984884612262249,
-0.0606091283261776,
0.3575797975063324,
0.40491431951522827,
0.2359238713979721,
-0.75763338804245,
-0.23005631566047668,
-0.17336387932300568,
-0.2589151859283447,
-0.16332750022411346,
-0.7230015993118286,
-0.5365764498710632,
-0.3128347396850586,
0.6164597868919373,
-0.1264633685350418,
-0.038316309452056885,
0.2101881355047226,
-0.7607055902481079,
0.10778658837080002,
0.6139283180236816,
0.6122679710388184,
1.2410639524459839,
-0.4911769926548004,
0.376579612493515,
0.4026082456111908,
-0.37900325655937195,
0.34399157762527466,
-0.14011293649673462,
-0.5069674849510193,
0.07165071368217468,
0.3018776774406433,
0.5838345289230347,
0.22435519099235535,
-0.667115330696106,
0.5443663597106934,
-0.05344928056001663,
0.3125452399253845,
-0.5950688123703003,
-0.2623690962791443,
-0.07668567448854446,
0.036259401589632034,
0.44133517146110535,
0.19159120321273804,
0.38253316283226013,
-0.8092509508132935,
0.2737716734409332,
0.48543214797973633,
-0.7517477869987488,
-0.2055899053812027,
0.4091411530971527,
0.5338929295539856,
0.18354341387748718,
0.4016020894050598,
-0.3145346939563751,
-0.6126307845115662,
0.5722858905792236,
0.4781416356563568,
0.68086838722229,
-0.014245928265154362,
0.04502624273300171,
0.527738094329834,
0.41644468903541565,
-0.14362762868404388,
-0.1515684723854065,
0.12741619348526,
-0.9417240023612976,
-0.14196552336215973,
-0.6996515393257141,
-0.5796810388565063,
0.1796020269393921,
-0.7913252711296082,
0.2188151776790619,
-0.37148019671440125,
-0.30765554308891296,
-0.46387362480163574,
-0.1710062175989151,
-0.842448890209198,
0.6536121368408203,
0.22627466917037964,
0.9188430905342102,
-1.2257671356201172,
0.49259909987449646,
0.5021817088127136,
-0.47271013259887695,
-0.3656694293022156,
0.30473050475120544,
0.14659416675567627,
-0.6381776332855225,
1.0099585056304932,
0.1733691543340683,
-0.037443988025188446,
-0.6099832653999329,
-0.4623202085494995,
-1.0241622924804688,
1.0055620670318604,
0.445307195186615,
-0.6981306672096252,
0.08241500705480576,
0.16072674095630646,
0.42487528920173645,
-0.5804897546768188,
0.5929824709892273,
0.6724658012390137,
0.5571779012680054,
-0.19658808410167694,
-0.8767436742782593,
0.3442875146865845,
0.20655198395252228,
0.14422081410884857,
-0.6515492796897888,
-0.601422905921936,
0.855015218257904,
-0.04924162104725838,
0.11512600630521774,
-0.18342597782611847,
0.6023287177085876,
0.35052502155303955,
0.40797093510627747,
0.5969823598861694,
0.6358052492141724,
0.8586223721504211,
-0.07499378174543381,
1.0479729175567627,
-0.2039080709218979,
0.4184481203556061,
1.3537256717681885,
-0.4093834459781647,
0.5732636451721191,
0.6147264838218689,
-0.09244632720947266,
0.7965146899223328,
0.5632979273796082,
0.050279613584280014,
0.4145420789718628,
0.2105545997619629,
-0.07315972447395325,
-0.2056666761636734,
-0.18932221829891205,
-0.348662793636322,
0.7915288805961609,
0.25575488805770874,
-0.614014744758606,
-0.20421332120895386,
-0.05636993423104286,
0.3032307028770447,
0.15384340286254883,
-0.14715130627155304,
0.392752468585968,
0.2340012639760971,
-0.8395529389381409,
0.3629869818687439,
0.03849640116095543,
0.8908197283744812,
-0.13896265625953674,
0.165147602558136,
-0.3694734573364258,
0.22361209988594055,
-0.20523814857006073,
-0.4637535512447357,
0.384880930185318,
0.05600936338305473,
-0.447266161441803,
-0.046171125024557114,
0.6689386963844299,
-0.20019635558128357,
-0.4900274872779846,
0.4770701229572296,
0.6407597661018372,
-0.006318642292171717,
0.09772632271051407,
-0.40671882033348083,
0.5688396096229553,
-0.1919967085123062,
-0.27565908432006836,
0.3849064111709595,
-0.11060275882482529,
-0.24576883018016815,
0.6271517276763916,
0.16283920407295227,
-0.08990038931369781,
-0.07696946710348129,
0.13683296740055084,
0.5452261567115784,
-0.5373662710189819,
-0.10917451232671738,
-1.0593621730804443,
0.16223928332328796,
-0.4140414297580719,
-0.33269768953323364,
0.8695774078369141,
0.6046780943870544,
0.8617437481880188,
-0.0450979582965374,
1.243721604347229,
-0.07137981802225113,
0.48654162883758545,
-0.3415341377258301,
0.6950746774673462,
-0.3459790050983429,
0.3435420095920563,
-0.3787705898284912,
-1.0516610145568848,
-0.13364219665527344,
0.7356524467468262,
-0.6931363940238953,
0.24003523588180542,
0.6533583998680115,
0.5004862546920776,
-0.08234100788831711,
-0.046670425683259964,
0.1273379921913147,
0.3401891887187958,
0.07853636890649796,
0.4990120232105255,
0.8584174513816833,
-0.47619539499282837,
0.3712691366672516,
-0.12049109488725662,
-0.3583589196205139,
-0.3963373303413391,
-0.8629320859909058,
-1.016679048538208,
-0.3428150713443756,
-0.231541708111763,
-0.5808723568916321,
0.16658852994441986,
0.8144997358322144,
0.6615052819252014,
-0.9434282183647156,
-0.32389724254608154,
0.22857078909873962,
0.3045642375946045,
-0.029249094426631927,
-0.2499549686908722,
0.12798373401165009,
-0.3244691789150238,
-0.7763395309448242,
0.13664281368255615,
0.2504298686981201,
-0.44314634799957275,
-0.6388635039329529,
0.0037382070440799,
-0.15451006591320038,
0.1848410815000534,
0.6399340629577637,
0.08374302834272385,
-0.7230885624885559,
-0.6167965531349182,
-0.15062057971954346,
-0.29519525170326233,
0.11992105096578598,
0.6175168752670288,
-0.7542998790740967,
0.3474900722503662,
0.40525195002555847,
0.5401914715766907,
0.30638328194618225,
-0.017474818974733353,
0.8691887855529785,
-0.7113672494888306,
0.18595364689826965,
0.1581532508134842,
0.5660313367843628,
0.6949476599693298,
-0.06340249627828598,
0.5879434943199158,
0.3019566535949707,
-0.18641076982021332,
-0.823312520980835,
0.37423327565193176,
-1.0622518062591553,
-0.09022293984889984,
1.4598692655563354,
-0.26545336842536926,
-0.10681960731744766,
-0.36396679282188416,
0.052241940051317215,
0.32704511284828186,
-0.2455713152885437,
1.0411144495010376,
0.9769400358200073,
-0.040701065212488174,
0.2677023112773895,
-0.3734319508075714,
0.45297375321388245,
0.6032391786575317,
-0.7403050661087036,
-0.07608471810817719,
0.650776207447052,
0.6974809169769287,
0.446418821811676,
0.539970874786377,
-0.016016244888305664,
0.06291404366493225,
-0.03594589978456497,
0.043549876660108566,
0.32905927300453186,
-0.21066689491271973,
-0.24505485594272614,
0.43458133935928345,
0.10411768406629562,
0.1650584489107132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14433v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14433v1
|
A Language Model's Guide Through Latent Space
| 2024-02-22T10:25:14 | 2024-02-22T10:25:14 |
Dimitri von Rütte, Sotiris Anagnostidis, Gregor Bachmann, Thomas Hofmann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2
|
Concept guidance has emerged as a cheap and simple way to control the
behavior of language models by probing their hidden representations for concept
vectors and using them to perturb activations at inference time. While the
focus of previous work has largely been on truthfulness, in this paper we
extend this framework to a richer set of concepts such as appropriateness,
humor, creativity and quality, and explore to what degree current detection and
guidance strategies work in these challenging settings. To facilitate
evaluation, we develop a novel metric for concept guidance that takes into
account both the success of concept elicitation as well as the potential
degradation in fluency of the guided model. Our extensive experiments reveal
that while some concepts such as truthfulness more easily allow for guidance
with current techniques, novel concepts such as appropriateness or humor either
remain difficult to elicit, need extensive tuning to work, or even experience
confusion. Moreover, we find that probes with optimal detection accuracies do
not necessarily make for the optimal guides, contradicting previous
observations for truthfulness. Our work warrants a deeper investigation into
the interplay between detectability, guidability, and the nature of the
concept, and we hope that our rich experimental test-bed for guidance research
inspires stronger follow-up approaches.
|
[
-0.06069512665271759,
-0.9201555848121643,
0.8515271544456482,
0.13882213830947876,
-0.3153948485851288,
0.13109207153320312,
-0.14578986167907715,
0.2778334319591522,
-0.10112733393907547,
0.22687454521656036,
-0.5072681307792664,
-0.45307013392448425,
-0.3704454004764557,
-0.3725103437900543,
-0.2526461184024811,
0.9325076937675476,
0.1614910513162613,
-0.22970297932624817,
-0.13318859040737152,
0.05420314520597458,
-0.7328319549560547,
-0.23843419551849365,
-0.5167341232299805,
-0.3537554144859314,
0.6967740654945374,
0.5386601686477661,
0.7535490989685059,
0.5854581594467163,
0.3403492867946625,
0.13608214259147644,
-0.7492353916168213,
0.06518662720918655,
-0.3210638165473938,
0.11636931449174881,
-0.27889367938041687,
-0.7488327622413635,
-0.45255815982818604,
0.34727245569229126,
0.6379123330116272,
1.1109206676483154,
-0.5089627504348755,
-0.32377874851226807,
0.08032210171222687,
0.3345881402492523,
-0.38529548048973083,
0.1214720755815506,
-0.37727299332618713,
-0.07888663560152054,
-0.18768422305583954,
-0.3373956084251404,
-0.3381548821926117,
-0.33216285705566406,
0.22801382839679718,
-0.8375723958015442,
0.276490718126297,
0.030822310596704483,
0.8001986742019653,
0.47734779119491577,
-0.2902202308177948,
-0.6096776723861694,
-0.722499430179596,
0.6644112467765808,
-0.5395321846008301,
0.36991462111473083,
0.5424560904502869,
0.36445075273513794,
-0.28974929451942444,
-0.6058075428009033,
-0.4580889940261841,
-0.25097236037254333,
0.059768952429294586,
0.23797346651554108,
-0.18271973729133606,
-0.08020184189081192,
0.3735317289829254,
0.2018267959356308,
-0.5150861144065857,
-0.05715344846248627,
-0.09955352544784546,
-0.1733439564704895,
0.31393343210220337,
-0.2608633041381836,
0.09129565954208374,
-0.26836541295051575,
0.03210802748799324,
-0.04299621656537056,
-0.7390351891517639,
0.10364522784948349,
0.5077281594276428,
0.28446996212005615,
-0.052462633699178696,
0.3113519251346588,
-0.04213058948516846,
0.5757315754890442,
0.04590167477726936,
-0.09850996732711792,
0.0431571863591671,
-0.4559745788574219,
0.23419645428657532,
-0.0983639508485794,
0.28095945715904236,
0.2642582952976227,
0.1326749175786972,
-0.33492642641067505,
-0.3205582797527313,
0.13326312601566315,
0.47074198722839355,
-0.555677592754364,
-0.4784431457519531,
-0.14516697824001312,
-0.3710412085056305,
-0.2712593674659729,
-0.1884860247373581,
-0.4227909743785858,
-0.35733136534690857,
-0.17146775126457214,
0.16661444306373596,
-0.6287233233451843,
-0.7082141041755676,
0.11240257322788239,
-0.2315712571144104,
0.47315359115600586,
0.42678534984588623,
-0.661367654800415,
0.0038844181690365076,
0.8780885338783264,
1.0207629203796387,
-0.10015477985143661,
0.31321385502815247,
-0.5030742883682251,
-0.05234837904572487,
-0.8111961483955383,
0.78276526927948,
-0.8850554823875427,
-0.7039787173271179,
-0.4118960499763489,
-0.2077341079711914,
0.07634975761175156,
-0.3312321603298187,
0.9230254888534546,
-0.4085896611213684,
0.24807879328727722,
-0.5822054147720337,
-0.6790339946746826,
-0.3832922875881195,
0.024976244196295738,
-0.444488525390625,
0.733717143535614,
0.15898461639881134,
-0.5784643888473511,
0.6115208864212036,
-0.7013006806373596,
-0.18028126657009125,
0.25430992245674133,
-0.5478818416595459,
-0.05826050415635109,
0.3585483133792877,
-0.10026229918003082,
0.4016387164592743,
0.13601496815681458,
0.5418812036514282,
-0.07253238558769226,
-0.5931015610694885,
0.04961131140589714,
-0.48457786440849304,
0.507526695728302,
0.3442669212818146,
-0.1952076554298401,
-0.13577453792095184,
-0.7370277047157288,
-0.17153477668762207,
0.14250414073467255,
-0.2360440045595169,
-0.7491003274917603,
0.16639749705791473,
-0.24614392220973969,
-0.0458015538752079,
-0.07764434814453125,
-0.2199283391237259,
0.14701884984970093,
-0.5622881650924683,
0.34282734990119934,
0.7265831232070923,
0.016724344342947006,
0.46122676134109497,
-0.13286004960536957,
0.6289033889770508,
0.025043439120054245,
-0.09431152045726776,
-0.3318680226802826,
-0.7038792967796326,
-0.6958380341529846,
0.14633618295192719,
0.19634783267974854,
0.2876904010772705,
-0.7987724542617798,
0.5519115328788757,
0.037942323833703995,
-0.4893321096897125,
-0.4744381606578827,
0.01809888891875744,
0.5235973596572876,
0.6686429977416992,
0.0991666316986084,
-0.4580238461494446,
-0.032649535685777664,
-0.5991311073303223,
-0.25694501399993896,
-0.39653846621513367,
0.2723318040370941,
0.3326131999492645,
0.4287085235118866,
-0.014370772056281567,
0.8589202165603638,
-0.4661829173564911,
0.1837371587753296,
-0.03559895604848862,
0.38216936588287354,
0.33944639563560486,
0.5091258883476257,
0.5879626870155334,
-1.1212025880813599,
0.1023046150803566,
-0.13555818796157837,
-0.6478272080421448,
-0.2287396341562271,
0.1089160218834877,
-0.01619398221373558,
-0.2689768373966217,
0.6556583046913147,
-0.08860941976308823,
0.49036896228790283,
0.38685742020606995,
-0.675716757774353,
0.3662464916706085,
-0.15850234031677246,
-0.23909251391887665,
-0.8419645428657532,
0.13637255132198334,
-0.018969718366861343,
-0.023900043219327927,
-0.6389386057853699,
0.1361561417579651,
-0.043915532529354095,
0.2143828272819519,
-0.06628166139125824,
0.6271024346351624,
-0.13772864639759064,
0.07842769473791122,
-0.3941068649291992,
0.3447641134262085,
0.09960438311100006,
0.36780425906181335,
0.049921322613954544,
0.9548091292381287,
0.48202115297317505,
-0.9029896855354309,
0.301618367433548,
0.1430109739303589,
-0.2872868478298187,
0.9777510762214661,
-0.6823198795318604,
0.29255688190460205,
-0.3537682890892029,
-0.0001252528018085286,
-1.2012263536453247,
0.07984384149312973,
0.1805504411458969,
-0.5423427820205688,
0.3402527868747711,
-0.3273378312587738,
-0.43647006154060364,
-0.14252345263957977,
0.0715821161866188,
0.24622084200382233,
0.5524051189422607,
-0.34171727299690247,
0.4038809835910797,
0.08234589546918869,
-0.056816086173057556,
-0.5633328557014465,
-0.5523072481155396,
-0.053043827414512634,
-0.31460312008857727,
-0.2835952639579773,
0.2753293812274933,
-0.4346807301044464,
-0.4676540493965149,
-0.030860457569360733,
-0.43204182386398315,
0.01062945369631052,
0.5197009444236755,
0.32064080238342285,
0.008707801811397076,
-0.3296925127506256,
0.28160908818244934,
0.049193792045116425,
-0.2993367612361908,
0.12524908781051636,
-0.37559211254119873,
0.24532850086688995,
-0.21871180832386017,
-0.4028353691101074,
-0.030499976128339767,
0.049426957964897156,
0.07165124267339706,
-0.09423854947090149,
0.4734311103820801,
0.7546435594558716,
-0.26519325375556946,
-0.16324637830257416,
-0.44598686695098877,
-0.11789348721504211,
-0.5019376873970032,
0.18703506886959076,
-0.6132985353469849,
-0.6330945491790771,
0.46191900968551636,
-0.30674463510513306,
-0.04011444374918938,
0.27426397800445557,
0.12746389210224152,
-0.08688925951719284,
0.998126745223999,
1.0705974102020264,
0.4845588505268097,
0.5132402181625366,
-0.39635857939720154,
0.49382269382476807,
-0.9734777212142944,
-0.3735401928424835,
-0.6072292327880859,
0.20553092658519745,
-0.6005820035934448,
-0.6436125636100769,
0.3262065649032593,
0.420179545879364,
0.3041427433490753,
0.1787034273147583,
-0.412114679813385,
0.422747403383255,
0.27592456340789795,
-0.13327468931674957,
0.43174779415130615,
-0.36074239015579224,
-0.7545397281646729,
-0.2379239797592163,
-0.8838646411895752,
-0.8809024095535278,
0.7569345831871033,
0.3923463523387909,
0.8542514443397522,
0.25999197363853455,
0.3778423070907593,
0.033485833555459976,
0.03895096480846405,
-1.0127356052398682,
0.4862803518772125,
-0.14036904275417328,
-0.5656123161315918,
-0.24105411767959595,
-0.3363151550292969,
-0.6945893168449402,
0.17580410838127136,
0.24241924285888672,
-0.6390218734741211,
0.2082916796207428,
0.31436437368392944,
-0.4822884798049927,
0.0411861278116703,
-0.8461881279945374,
0.757388174533844,
-0.19767670333385468,
-0.4844185411930084,
-0.1787836253643036,
-0.5181301236152649,
0.17491097748279572,
-0.30558881163597107,
0.260484904050827,
-0.10737945139408112,
-0.10400521010160446,
0.8849018216133118,
-0.043179675936698914,
0.6630744338035583,
-0.34575313329696655,
-0.5574867129325867,
0.1010776162147522,
0.138229638338089,
0.17284858226776123,
-0.04333404079079628,
-0.12627045810222626,
-0.20201382040977478,
-0.06217128410935402,
-0.29267317056655884,
-0.9667279720306396,
0.43686625361442566,
-0.3423115313053131,
-0.632546603679657,
-0.19333067536354065,
-0.4741598069667816,
-0.2529555857181549,
0.25814011693000793,
0.14010731875896454,
0.29785430431365967,
-0.3642997145652771,
0.17103439569473267,
1.192330241203308,
-0.462308794260025,
0.3438674211502075,
0.735672116279602,
-0.18541401624679565,
0.4327787756919861,
0.9230299592018127,
0.08645228296518326,
0.18593095242977142,
0.3662920296192169,
0.4260692894458771,
-0.5741325616836548,
-0.5489330887794495,
-0.24587343633174896,
0.25549858808517456,
-0.9151873588562012,
0.23563933372497559,
-0.35897424817085266,
-0.1848181188106537,
-0.22801396250724792,
-0.06597557663917542,
-0.33339861035346985,
-0.3396395146846771,
-0.3473544418811798,
-0.1807260662317276,
0.2552935481071472,
0.8543588519096375,
-0.14381681382656097,
0.48325052857398987,
-0.14728519320487976,
0.05185053125023842,
0.3399086594581604,
0.43836072087287903,
-0.034375905990600586,
-0.784208357334137,
-0.08710317313671112,
-0.0318155363202095,
-0.21808432042598724,
-0.7243342995643616,
-0.051446348428726196,
0.04823153093457222,
0.791037380695343,
0.646661102771759,
-0.005533806048333645,
0.5819545984268188,
-0.3363904356956482,
0.8142735958099365,
-0.06846323609352112,
-1.0459502935409546,
1.1611320972442627,
-0.3130658268928528,
0.1980939507484436,
0.1512741893529892,
0.31459903717041016,
-0.6143098473548889,
-0.4692201614379883,
-0.9300665259361267,
-0.49996498227119446,
0.588064968585968,
0.3219499886035919,
0.33716076612472534,
0.35031023621559143,
0.7116248607635498,
-0.010229433886706829,
0.3673420548439026,
-0.3922126591205597,
-0.21800771355628967,
-0.28461864590644836,
0.07520830631256104,
-0.096242256462574,
-0.11332885175943375,
-0.2240975946187973,
-0.015518429689109325,
0.3621307909488678,
-0.3927101790904999,
0.28297871351242065,
0.024065060541033745,
0.15189220011234283,
-0.025419222190976143,
0.29896149039268494,
0.554955005645752,
0.8219954967498779,
-0.21231693029403687,
0.03647108003497124,
-0.1612967550754547,
-0.5273649096488953,
0.07173509150743484,
0.1402347832918167,
-0.25702282786369324,
0.10181424021720886,
0.551385223865509,
0.9155864119529724,
0.12962427735328674,
-0.34676653146743774,
0.6873456239700317,
-0.17362575232982635,
-0.007967439480125904,
-0.0026257403660565615,
0.7411780953407288,
-0.1514071673154831,
0.1591767966747284,
0.32817351818084717,
0.0025510734412819147,
0.036880820989608765,
-0.6943473815917969,
0.26178327202796936,
0.40442830324172974,
-0.5911688208580017,
-0.49105995893478394,
0.5949919819831848,
0.07747650891542435,
-0.2596420347690582,
0.25367605686187744,
-0.5482699275016785,
-0.49356040358543396,
0.5268324017524719,
0.2676164209842682,
0.6728897094726562,
-0.4156414270401001,
0.3140663802623749,
0.05531061813235283,
0.33567535877227783,
-0.02907063066959381,
0.3605973720550537,
-0.24731320142745972,
-0.9544856548309326,
-0.4808309078216553,
-0.32623130083084106,
-0.4048749506473541,
0.10711458325386047,
-0.6856733560562134,
0.0818929597735405,
-0.3173166811466217,
-0.13021335005760193,
0.1301293671131134,
0.14988431334495544,
-0.4804987609386444,
0.3044397532939911,
0.012373516336083412,
0.9889143705368042,
-0.7684721350669861,
0.8483687043190002,
0.8326783776283264,
-0.5766838788986206,
-1.1504610776901245,
0.36756259202957153,
0.1877523958683014,
-0.9157245755195618,
0.455829381942749,
-0.0006499290466308594,
-0.41270312666893005,
-0.06615759432315826,
-0.7309040427207947,
-0.682630181312561,
0.9772036075592041,
0.179872527718544,
-0.3787294626235962,
-0.38169917464256287,
-0.6530938148498535,
0.7172890305519104,
-0.1863277405500412,
0.37978020310401917,
0.7415223717689514,
0.5200074315071106,
0.6618110537528992,
-0.7920814752578735,
-0.09889089316129684,
-0.35298043489456177,
0.09610426425933838,
-0.24691003561019897,
-0.6182814240455627,
0.6149020791053772,
-0.4165649116039276,
-0.23067009449005127,
0.0023033807519823313,
0.5042202472686768,
0.28499501943588257,
0.4025067090988159,
0.5826247334480286,
0.36388707160949707,
1.0082433223724365,
-0.35175204277038574,
0.806094765663147,
-0.0028690635226666927,
0.016480283811688423,
0.7752387523651123,
-0.0687030777335167,
0.45396745204925537,
0.43781334161758423,
0.1824541538953781,
0.7214174866676331,
0.6289721131324768,
0.24604769051074982,
0.8238716125488281,
0.28934863209724426,
0.1738175004720688,
-0.08252324163913727,
-0.5959838032722473,
-0.3588193356990814,
0.4772929549217224,
0.8842599987983704,
-0.10656441003084183,
-0.027184875681996346,
-0.005889135412871838,
0.12294390797615051,
0.31373414397239685,
-0.08752819150686264,
0.5719579458236694,
0.2869906723499298,
-0.8221064209938049,
0.4583565294742584,
-0.0023989775218069553,
0.6013560891151428,
-0.5779659748077393,
-0.3944639265537262,
-0.5351168513298035,
-0.17895658314228058,
-0.13301362097263336,
-0.9711127877235413,
0.26946958899497986,
-0.019586771726608276,
0.07546517252922058,
-0.32109642028808594,
0.5800966024398804,
-0.2090725302696228,
-0.15244467556476593,
0.34798523783683777,
0.8414235711097717,
0.22709165513515472,
0.11895555257797241,
-0.5923329591751099,
-0.0034506553784012794,
-0.11437739431858063,
-0.08917675912380219,
-0.3419216573238373,
0.9833463430404663,
0.10805432498455048,
0.8409367799758911,
0.44511425495147705,
0.535099446773529,
-0.2249831259250641,
0.26827889680862427,
0.7873853445053101,
-0.6767504811286926,
-0.8498274683952332,
-0.5099027752876282,
0.33518049120903015,
-0.0373663529753685,
-0.49502184987068176,
0.776002049446106,
0.11151938140392303,
0.8386040925979614,
0.532242476940155,
0.5393339991569519,
-0.011579835787415504,
0.5344564318656921,
-0.8496870994567871,
0.4961208403110504,
-0.7951563000679016,
0.7475515007972717,
-0.510844886302948,
-0.7074394822120667,
-0.1329820156097412,
1.219419240951538,
-0.3192079961299896,
0.30247029662132263,
0.785312294960022,
0.9769577383995056,
-0.14200301468372345,
0.10602410137653351,
0.44207027554512024,
0.12264031916856766,
0.46762794256210327,
0.37966999411582947,
1.1803191900253296,
-0.03851040452718735,
0.3546678125858307,
0.011515851132571697,
-0.34514516592025757,
-0.1343093365430832,
-0.9733380675315857,
-0.8522117137908936,
-0.8245400190353394,
-0.43292126059532166,
-0.29856234788894653,
0.10800477117300034,
0.46361029148101807,
1.0490975379943848,
-0.41881996393203735,
-0.05537903681397438,
-0.290022611618042,
0.4505447447299957,
-0.20003537833690643,
-0.22500449419021606,
0.2255953848361969,
-0.251700222492218,
-0.49408844113349915,
0.5595476627349854,
0.28029993176460266,
0.26890188455581665,
-0.5281415581703186,
-0.2796682119369507,
-0.00810497347265482,
0.058531612157821655,
0.3714836835861206,
0.01941700465977192,
-0.8484987616539001,
-0.16047634184360504,
-0.001057503861375153,
-0.04341857507824898,
-0.10911060124635696,
0.96546870470047,
-0.6338614821434021,
0.772079586982727,
0.08959301561117172,
0.4568507671356201,
0.09433147311210632,
-0.12713083624839783,
0.756949782371521,
-1.1619031429290771,
0.18256761133670807,
0.5332172513008118,
0.08442692458629608,
0.4217100441455841,
-0.41879504919052124,
0.8135642409324646,
0.5216143727302551,
-0.1995990127325058,
-0.7988148927688599,
0.3520485758781433,
-0.613037645816803,
-0.30021679401397705,
1.13618004322052,
-0.2758750021457672,
-0.10785141587257385,
-0.1844938099384308,
-0.19779396057128906,
0.33837324380874634,
-0.50823575258255,
0.4149588942527771,
1.067912220954895,
-0.17065468430519104,
-0.23352286219596863,
-0.6991596221923828,
0.7212761044502258,
0.5809713006019592,
-0.3940598666667938,
-0.045791998505592346,
0.34921973943710327,
0.07046451419591904,
0.47750815749168396,
0.6121611595153809,
0.13092531263828278,
0.08110775798559189,
-0.09237756580114365,
-0.6743438243865967,
0.2880783677101135,
-0.5718165636062622,
-0.606964647769928,
-0.3587857186794281,
0.4469967484474182,
0.015855589881539345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14428v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14428v2
|
KoCoSa: Korean Context-aware Sarcasm Detection Dataset
| 2024-02-22T10:17:57 | 2024-03-22T06:29:26 |
Yumin Kim, Heejae Suh, Mingi Kim, Dongyeon Won, Hwanhee Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Sarcasm is a way of verbal irony where someone says the opposite of what they
mean, often to ridicule a person, situation, or idea. It is often difficult to
detect sarcasm in the dialogue since detecting sarcasm should reflect the
context (i.e., dialogue history). In this paper, we introduce a new dataset for
the Korean dialogue sarcasm detection task, KoCoSa (Korean Context-aware
Sarcasm Detection Dataset), which consists of 12.8K daily Korean dialogues and
the labels for this task on the last response. To build the dataset, we propose
an efficient sarcasm detection dataset generation pipeline: 1) generating new
sarcastic dialogues from source dialogues with large language models, 2)
automatic and manual filtering of abnormal and toxic dialogues, and 3) human
annotation for the sarcasm detection task. We also provide a simple but
effective baseline for the Korean sarcasm detection task trained on our
dataset. Experimental results on the dataset show that our baseline system
outperforms strong baselines like large language models, such as GPT-3.5, in
the Korean sarcasm detection task. We show that the sarcasm detection task
relies deeply on the existence of sufficient context. We will release the
dataset at https://github.com/Yu-billie/KoCoSa_sarcasm_detection.
|
[
-0.2117333859205246,
-0.6019349694252014,
0.5008395910263062,
0.3056233525276184,
-0.5042493343353271,
-0.08944521844387054,
-0.11402077972888947,
-0.22401170432567596,
0.49291089177131653,
0.7380239963531494,
-0.5643286108970642,
-0.5825677514076233,
-0.23921635746955872,
0.1296117603778839,
0.07969680428504944,
1.2104597091674805,
0.17943285405635834,
0.08578222244977951,
-0.013947957195341587,
-0.2669733464717865,
-0.7517223954200745,
-0.2288329154253006,
-0.8284822106361389,
-0.022280216217041016,
0.4471522867679596,
0.584324836730957,
0.5480472445487976,
0.17004868388175964,
0.20599886775016785,
0.295815110206604,
0.10848569124937057,
-0.10854976624250412,
-0.5042939186096191,
0.598952054977417,
-0.1501665562391281,
-0.6227023601531982,
-0.30098333954811096,
-0.29160967469215393,
0.36114829778671265,
0.25575384497642517,
0.13890045881271362,
0.33693161606788635,
-0.4579806923866272,
0.5412093997001648,
-0.76419997215271,
0.3167048692703247,
-0.5070210099220276,
0.17531327903270721,
-0.15900380909442902,
-0.1795215755701065,
-0.35344505310058594,
-0.47446897625923157,
-0.13733357191085815,
-0.627267599105835,
-0.07143433392047882,
-0.2742054760456085,
0.4511045515537262,
0.4329635798931122,
-0.5762816667556763,
-0.47792693972587585,
-0.36751872301101685,
0.5726857781410217,
-0.7616018056869507,
-0.03540164977312088,
0.258392333984375,
0.6214147806167603,
-0.15125314891338348,
-0.6998847723007202,
-0.47353073954582214,
-0.3159745931625366,
-0.06240101903676987,
0.34825196862220764,
0.0288544911891222,
0.07355053722858429,
0.37466350197792053,
0.06001253426074982,
-0.5250633358955383,
-0.35516175627708435,
-0.055938176810741425,
-0.26275020837783813,
0.5311362147331238,
0.18316154181957245,
0.5835573077201843,
-0.6128602623939514,
-0.38594016432762146,
0.14578869938850403,
-0.34355753660202026,
0.212924525141716,
0.5137436389923096,
0.41280463337898254,
0.1499582976102829,
0.21884910762310028,
-0.5380650758743286,
0.3867446780204773,
-0.2873310446739197,
-0.2696588933467865,
0.42284074425697327,
-0.3708599805831909,
-0.29066020250320435,
0.2548586428165436,
0.5685209035873413,
0.2115125060081482,
0.405080109834671,
-0.08652371913194656,
-0.23954029381275177,
0.4663583040237427,
0.2721797227859497,
-0.5724135041236877,
-0.41438087821006775,
0.04586190730333328,
-0.29154545068740845,
-0.5517468452453613,
-0.08562120795249939,
-0.6427610516548157,
-0.4921377897262573,
-0.29063013195991516,
0.03582465648651123,
-0.049560051411390305,
-0.35799121856689453,
-0.11989601701498032,
-0.3548155128955841,
-0.1644052118062973,
0.20634335279464722,
-0.1907406747341156,
0.3066064119338989,
0.32077014446258545,
0.5820693969726562,
0.2720450758934021,
-0.15483646094799042,
-0.6493417024612427,
-0.11708276718854904,
-0.3069378733634949,
0.6797139048576355,
-0.4567956030368805,
-0.26290255784988403,
-0.3336033523082733,
0.23584476113319397,
-0.09269869327545166,
-0.42955294251441956,
1.04835045337677,
-0.34339115023612976,
0.005819662939757109,
-0.45796725153923035,
-0.23111018538475037,
-0.1676478087902069,
0.13105419278144836,
-0.8446540236473083,
1.160822868347168,
0.5366422533988953,
-1.02385413646698,
0.09921894967556,
-0.6571560502052307,
-0.4709778428077698,
0.40638241171836853,
-0.09727872163057327,
-0.06583543866872787,
0.0004179158713668585,
0.24827659130096436,
0.33158814907073975,
-0.24520070850849152,
0.6461238861083984,
-0.4461597800254822,
-0.4991511404514313,
0.41547447443008423,
-0.2878836989402771,
1.1192022562026978,
0.4585795998573303,
-0.48824945092201233,
-0.3874853849411011,
-0.3532780408859253,
0.24136944115161896,
0.13439328968524933,
0.08004273474216461,
-0.6111042499542236,
-0.3604761064052582,
0.011730666272342205,
0.7409369349479675,
0.12342365831136703,
-0.6532202959060669,
0.1360609233379364,
-0.2503988444805145,
0.3807905912399292,
0.640338659286499,
-0.03227841109037399,
0.2247321605682373,
-0.060962218791246414,
0.8590512871742249,
0.13898463547229767,
0.288185715675354,
-0.5091449022293091,
-0.5970913171768188,
-0.32807472348213196,
-0.539707601070404,
0.19733649492263794,
0.8316794633865356,
-1.1977070569992065,
0.4135710597038269,
-0.36731061339378357,
-0.24930892884731293,
-0.4342370927333832,
-0.007263657171279192,
0.6026833057403564,
0.8776262998580933,
0.07514821738004684,
-0.13347026705741882,
-0.814856767654419,
-0.754764974117279,
-0.41316843032836914,
-0.05220138654112816,
0.007617185823619366,
0.5797556638717651,
0.5103468894958496,
0.05052763596177101,
1.059658408164978,
-0.5383068323135376,
-0.15329493582248688,
-0.1321578323841095,
0.03407716751098633,
0.012510913424193859,
-0.029013540595769882,
0.5912385582923889,
-0.8553170561790466,
-0.7478889226913452,
0.19224870204925537,
-0.9159634113311768,
-0.485054075717926,
0.18787193298339844,
-0.1561032235622406,
0.2563292384147644,
0.6781148910522461,
-0.5851443409919739,
0.429575115442276,
0.20904216170310974,
-0.4449141025543213,
0.5275467038154602,
0.5570842027664185,
0.29891538619995117,
-1.3809278011322021,
0.3964081108570099,
-0.17740605771541595,
-0.4849873483181,
-0.8369813561439514,
-0.051893625408411026,
-0.1511400043964386,
-0.0738401710987091,
-0.4634825587272644,
0.7040919065475464,
-0.028991034254431725,
-0.049551110714673996,
-0.2547895312309265,
0.35019147396087646,
-0.055097345262765884,
0.5967127680778503,
-0.24795816838741302,
0.40184006094932556,
0.3146054148674011,
-0.2308320552110672,
0.5049583911895752,
-0.05491017550230026,
-0.1758761703968048,
0.8837061524391174,
-0.34564876556396484,
0.042552437633275986,
-0.18193675577640533,
1.006842017173767,
-1.2289958000183105,
-0.6092937588691711,
0.7467174530029297,
-0.5443998575210571,
-0.1843409538269043,
-0.2984372675418854,
-0.08253833651542664,
-0.5906636118888855,
-0.5023214221000671,
0.5134996175765991,
0.22337354719638824,
-0.44720351696014404,
0.5011088848114014,
0.34899815917015076,
-0.49476417899131775,
-1.008968710899353,
-0.6839861273765564,
0.09989046305418015,
-0.3133701682090759,
-0.607564389705658,
0.04721153900027275,
-0.0028320499695837498,
-0.039420969784259796,
0.0658184066414833,
-0.12603627145290375,
-0.10098311305046082,
-0.13215996325016022,
0.3031920790672302,
0.27031344175338745,
-0.17488686740398407,
0.22822202742099762,
0.063310906291008,
-0.07637323439121246,
0.03459431231021881,
-0.14257153868675232,
0.4618055820465088,
0.088633231818676,
0.05011909827589989,
-0.8335180878639221,
0.1884332299232483,
0.590747058391571,
0.5258946418762207,
0.26527008414268494,
0.5420000553131104,
-0.44952183961868286,
-0.28148505091667175,
-0.31091541051864624,
0.031864672899246216,
-0.42102569341659546,
0.2539661228656769,
-0.38195252418518066,
-0.6495623588562012,
0.8459786176681519,
-0.03629351407289505,
-0.38863760232925415,
0.32769832015037537,
0.2694414556026459,
0.14157432317733765,
1.1552653312683105,
0.1389784961938858,
-0.5150198340415955,
0.502333402633667,
0.02623928152024746,
0.45179274678230286,
-0.7147188782691956,
-0.04352223873138428,
-0.5659226775169373,
-0.3458101451396942,
-0.4206424653530121,
-0.26204821467399597,
0.05888820067048073,
-0.15384244918823242,
-0.3246248662471771,
0.17702186107635498,
-0.31101927161216736,
0.8917797207832336,
0.15352028608322144,
0.16902194917201996,
0.19750063121318817,
-0.1299663484096527,
0.2068454474210739,
0.12652640044689178,
-0.5410023927688599,
-0.3499677777290344,
0.9996963143348694,
0.22071599960327148,
0.427778959274292,
-0.25967490673065186,
0.5028970837593079,
0.49455466866493225,
0.36755824089050293,
-0.8526433110237122,
0.589158296585083,
-0.25525912642478943,
-0.3380124866962433,
-0.2973652482032776,
-0.8095852732658386,
-0.5045232176780701,
-0.14563775062561035,
0.4689508378505707,
-0.720528244972229,
0.027876978740096092,
0.14351335167884827,
-0.17210637032985687,
-0.005239746067672968,
-0.9771988391876221,
0.8175777792930603,
0.218899205327034,
0.21800358593463898,
0.48221200704574585,
-0.989990770816803,
0.5982742309570312,
0.28637778759002686,
0.1068512573838234,
-0.0952528789639473,
0.07820689678192139,
0.44473785161972046,
-0.3267805874347687,
0.9608858227729797,
-0.777630090713501,
-0.006663218140602112,
0.6956221461296082,
0.10733834654092789,
0.7886834740638733,
0.35771098732948303,
0.1415441781282425,
0.0016551428707316518,
-0.21714971959590912,
-0.502773106098175,
-0.735167920589447,
0.7815192937850952,
-0.4138668477535248,
0.01697251759469509,
-0.16801835596561432,
-0.6292604804039001,
-0.12582853436470032,
0.19392678141593933,
0.495299369096756,
0.17502982914447784,
-0.17393366992473602,
0.028840215876698494,
0.45645615458488464,
0.07739199697971344,
0.13322150707244873,
0.13954097032546997,
0.07060214877128601,
-0.5830895900726318,
1.0319942235946655,
0.25071266293525696,
0.15538297593593597,
-0.02832307294011116,
-0.022240780293941498,
-0.24283742904663086,
0.1887667179107666,
-0.35776615142822266,
0.0274971816688776,
-1.0446568727493286,
-0.49034538865089417,
-0.6436247229576111,
-0.2694990634918213,
-0.5659762024879456,
-0.24978670477867126,
-0.2837200462818146,
-0.6902256011962891,
0.04417191818356514,
0.14833927154541016,
0.11324335634708405,
0.6265373229980469,
0.42953237891197205,
0.3010481894016266,
-0.18572238087654114,
0.27848973870277405,
0.2091260552406311,
0.24660921096801758,
-0.07391037791967392,
-0.3384248912334442,
-0.06150616332888603,
0.34405791759490967,
-0.14507164061069489,
-0.7270289659500122,
0.35578691959381104,
-0.11556336283683777,
0.2910580039024353,
0.2032572478055954,
0.16287924349308014,
0.3470829129219055,
0.01086279284209013,
0.8544549942016602,
-0.04518589377403259,
-0.9051363468170166,
0.5281231999397278,
-0.4494186341762543,
0.5119472146034241,
0.6191354990005493,
0.27368247509002686,
-0.8275624513626099,
-0.4647642970085144,
-0.670569658279419,
-0.7251380681991577,
1.091749906539917,
0.29033127427101135,
0.20465087890625,
-0.12813475728034973,
0.45633789896965027,
0.10042280703783035,
0.2639878988265991,
-0.843890905380249,
-0.06176619976758957,
-0.3934846520423889,
-0.5895856618881226,
0.05903131142258644,
0.002803145907819271,
-0.1788892298936844,
0.008886564522981644,
0.6750738620758057,
-0.4450630843639374,
0.2325468808412552,
0.14253312349319458,
-0.2604063153266907,
-0.048923954367637634,
0.09936492890119553,
0.4364399015903473,
0.16088098287582397,
0.01337655819952488,
0.006630831863731146,
0.1982601433992386,
-0.716357946395874,
0.03623706474900246,
-0.22833265364170074,
-0.16772392392158508,
0.15928930044174194,
0.029209546744823456,
0.6959320902824402,
0.17532767355442047,
-0.9014027714729309,
0.6743397116661072,
-0.14927326142787933,
-0.1873006522655487,
-0.12943868339061737,
0.07851874083280563,
-0.04429424926638603,
0.10597077012062073,
0.11145561933517456,
0.15028150379657745,
0.5644742846488953,
-0.3786870539188385,
0.07157191634178162,
0.15835849940776825,
-0.3228839039802551,
-0.365907222032547,
-0.01072673499584198,
0.06327366828918457,
-0.04608632251620293,
0.4478432238101959,
-0.5722379684448242,
-0.8738760352134705,
1.1173930168151855,
0.654542863368988,
1.0596307516098022,
-0.520274817943573,
0.7312005162239075,
0.3982839286327362,
0.13837242126464844,
-0.23152375221252441,
0.5290149450302124,
-0.2753487825393677,
-0.45572587847709656,
-0.047079626470804214,
-0.2817523777484894,
-0.20354238152503967,
0.13294696807861328,
-0.46850699186325073,
0.49558719992637634,
-0.2080005556344986,
-0.20648662745952606,
0.028283098712563515,
-0.14224828779697418,
-0.41458660364151,
0.2502065896987915,
-0.008901878260076046,
0.6382840275764465,
-1.1794517040252686,
0.39405936002731323,
0.5241929888725281,
-0.08034739643335342,
-0.40953370928764343,
0.18855798244476318,
-0.04205208271741867,
-0.4991673231124878,
0.48787936568260193,
0.43705621361732483,
-0.33453288674354553,
-0.22439023852348328,
-0.7456240653991699,
-0.6363810896873474,
1.0855216979980469,
0.7739248871803284,
-0.16889096796512604,
0.23922103643417358,
0.10732963681221008,
0.7780650854110718,
-0.6335272192955017,
0.3278980255126953,
0.6728563904762268,
0.2914980947971344,
0.15916641056537628,
-0.5295505523681641,
0.30181649327278137,
-0.6119017004966736,
0.044024791568517685,
0.2714167535305023,
-0.790473997592926,
0.8456307053565979,
0.1706773191690445,
-0.21907268464565277,
0.09637798368930817,
0.07803703099489212,
0.15694081783294678,
1.0300143957138062,
0.6217991709709167,
0.6908082365989685,
0.8122756481170654,
-0.0866420567035675,
0.8008599877357483,
-0.14458894729614258,
0.27510640025138855,
1.2898434400558472,
-0.36304280161857605,
0.3912382125854492,
0.18968726694583893,
0.2479683756828308,
0.6364666819572449,
0.4707081615924835,
0.4135901629924774,
0.3878004550933838,
0.11334726959466934,
-0.4530438780784607,
-0.060195937752723694,
-0.4796988368034363,
-0.36314693093299866,
0.4076097309589386,
0.4611607491970062,
-0.47854480147361755,
-0.08443228155374527,
0.17741020023822784,
0.39699894189834595,
-0.2856450080871582,
-0.33852672576904297,
0.6313506364822388,
-0.09555792808532715,
-0.8794004917144775,
0.5043403506278992,
-0.2420007437467575,
0.2875587046146393,
-0.3864862322807312,
0.1517048329114914,
-0.46904706954956055,
-0.13979394733905792,
-0.33375415205955505,
-0.5669485926628113,
0.12640397250652313,
0.07812312990427017,
-0.062400899827480316,
0.4083746373653412,
1.1415234804153442,
-0.3767768442630768,
-0.11442597955465317,
0.17871247231960297,
0.12335453927516937,
0.20428626239299774,
-0.1854477971792221,
-0.6205561757087708,
-0.19664068520069122,
-0.13793312013149261,
-0.42199283838272095,
0.07748427987098694,
0.6999950408935547,
-0.4904039800167084,
0.6600500345230103,
0.47009938955307007,
-0.24552302062511444,
-0.05784643813967705,
0.39746028184890747,
1.014846682548523,
-0.5594865679740906,
-0.9099130630493164,
-0.47241565585136414,
0.364584743976593,
-0.500376284122467,
-0.47378143668174744,
0.5446135401725769,
0.28528913855552673,
0.672179639339447,
-0.13694320619106293,
1.0703219175338745,
-0.12945401668548584,
0.3084147870540619,
-0.22845137119293213,
0.31358107924461365,
-0.33312225341796875,
-0.0390549898147583,
-0.4585830271244049,
-0.779085099697113,
-0.3200414180755615,
0.3258112072944641,
-0.16760866343975067,
0.4962892234325409,
0.7371572256088257,
0.8320088982582092,
-0.16823448240756989,
0.5631678700447083,
0.09491507709026337,
0.34921514987945557,
0.05181609466671944,
0.6483734250068665,
0.5722615718841553,
-0.6192891597747803,
0.4250352382659912,
-0.30597877502441406,
-0.21858282387256622,
-0.3727339208126068,
-0.7281169891357422,
-0.7619766592979431,
-0.445499449968338,
-0.035292088985443115,
-0.35895442962646484,
0.01026053074747324,
0.8199567198753357,
0.3689410388469696,
-0.7861586213111877,
0.06666392087936401,
-0.398200660943985,
0.1632818579673767,
-0.10650753974914551,
-0.35425251722335815,
0.0801161676645279,
-0.5510138869285583,
-0.5046873092651367,
0.24028660356998444,
0.3730672299861908,
-0.3813770115375519,
-0.04049040377140045,
-0.18501770496368408,
-0.059426549822092056,
0.21034817397594452,
0.6017118096351624,
0.41468536853790283,
-0.4204079806804657,
-0.16189983487129211,
0.14451207220554352,
-0.2636207342147827,
-0.19941595196723938,
1.0046825408935547,
-0.8271034955978394,
0.8246839046478271,
0.748383641242981,
0.4735860228538513,
-0.04576347768306732,
0.026704169809818268,
0.14625371992588043,
-1.0236352682113647,
0.2685202956199646,
0.3297089636325836,
0.1170162558555603,
0.332694947719574,
-0.7987776398658752,
0.6905285120010376,
0.5390356779098511,
-0.6569655537605286,
-1.2010045051574707,
0.15023809671401978,
-1.0183600187301636,
-0.19307270646095276,
0.9608031511306763,
-0.26986631751060486,
-0.30294767022132874,
-0.46865910291671753,
-0.6326293349266052,
0.39740657806396484,
-0.5652382969856262,
0.943959653377533,
0.8457400798797607,
0.02764231525361538,
0.4159609079360962,
-0.7801031470298767,
0.6674579381942749,
0.5018044710159302,
-0.9138135313987732,
0.32403334975242615,
0.34926658868789673,
0.1826571673154831,
0.10513029247522354,
1.0086915493011475,
-0.0036220483016222715,
0.8533217310905457,
-0.01875315047800541,
-0.1201673150062561,
0.27720314264297485,
-0.6560783982276917,
-0.29860395193099976,
0.0905727967619896,
-0.6831645965576172,
0.13513188064098358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14427v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14427v1
|
Text me the data: Generating Ground Pressure Sequence from Textual Descriptions for HAR
| 2024-02-22T10:14:59 | 2024-02-22T10:14:59 |
Lala Shakti Swarup Ray, Bo Zhou, Sungho Suh, Lars Krupp, Vitor Fortes Rey, Paul Lukowicz
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, eess.SP
|
In human activity recognition (HAR), the availability of substantial ground
truth is necessary for training efficient models. However, acquiring ground
pressure data through physical sensors itself can be cost-prohibitive,
time-consuming. To address this critical need, we introduce Text-to-Pressure
(T2P), a framework designed to generate extensive ground pressure sequences
from textual descriptions of human activities using deep learning techniques.
We show that the combination of vector quantization of sensor data along with
simple text conditioned auto regressive strategy allows us to obtain
high-quality generated pressure sequences from textual descriptions with the
help of discrete latent correlation between text and pressure maps. We achieved
comparable performance on the consistency between text and generated motion
with an R squared value of 0.722, Masked R squared value of 0.892, and FID
score of 1.83. Additionally, we trained a HAR model with the the synthesized
data and evaluated it on pressure dynamics collected by a real pressure sensor
which is on par with a model trained on only real data. Combining both real and
synthesized training data increases the overall macro F1 score by 5.9 percent.
|
[
0.2347252070903778,
-0.2426832616329193,
0.727655827999115,
0.1107579916715622,
-0.45426905155181885,
-0.08949868381023407,
-0.06828513741493225,
-0.48876962065696716,
-0.04584086313843727,
0.45582515001296997,
-0.19052380323410034,
-0.7217872142791748,
-0.6906513571739197,
-0.12457539141178131,
-0.3416096270084381,
0.924595296382904,
-0.22220340371131897,
-0.3954010605812073,
0.11995719373226166,
0.11833471804857254,
-0.24523916840553284,
-0.8337063789367676,
-0.24991343915462494,
-0.25635331869125366,
0.3332892060279846,
0.39905571937561035,
0.4769158363342285,
0.5479127764701843,
0.567018985748291,
0.2272869497537613,
0.09258554875850677,
0.4631378650665283,
-0.21282587945461273,
0.25084495544433594,
0.1400289535522461,
0.23015441000461578,
-0.10931387543678284,
0.1453254520893097,
0.7903624176979065,
0.4035073518753052,
0.10257400572299957,
0.07641106843948364,
0.24204786121845245,
0.7349005341529846,
-0.5224313735961914,
0.34685155749320984,
0.0663331001996994,
0.26817718148231506,
0.08076213300228119,
-0.5752670168876648,
-0.31773948669433594,
0.24073410034179688,
0.21560749411582947,
-0.46259450912475586,
0.3449271619319916,
-0.09149126708507538,
0.9032796621322632,
0.5710070133209229,
-0.5861546993255615,
-0.32929080724716187,
-1.0788342952728271,
0.33980971574783325,
-0.2989962697029114,
0.4341362714767456,
0.361211359500885,
0.08367147296667099,
0.21399544179439545,
-0.7806615233421326,
-0.34307169914245605,
0.043444085866212845,
-0.23291157186031342,
0.2424074411392212,
0.3516325056552887,
-0.12223490327596664,
0.10102289915084839,
0.3042660653591156,
-0.5291348695755005,
-0.23905491828918457,
-0.37003129720687866,
0.06385829299688339,
0.8702353835105896,
0.2734519839286804,
-0.1180793046951294,
-0.46162763237953186,
-0.5883933305740356,
-0.5091283321380615,
-0.28445693850517273,
0.5481353402137756,
0.049568742513656616,
0.28519952297210693,
-0.38857656717300415,
0.6422601342201233,
-0.06822457164525986,
0.6798883676528931,
-0.014891830272972584,
-0.29872867465019226,
0.28533926606178284,
-0.1290683150291443,
-0.3113183379173279,
-0.04952982813119888,
1.0714856386184692,
0.22239990532398224,
0.04618505761027336,
-0.3616800010204315,
-0.485895574092865,
-0.07515167444944382,
0.3407827615737915,
-1.0992661714553833,
-0.14997710287570953,
-0.055347613990306854,
-0.4758584797382355,
-0.7060734033584595,
0.7227869629859924,
-0.7483137249946594,
-0.4772782623767853,
-0.4586842954158783,
0.2804812788963318,
-0.1454077810049057,
-0.2844560146331787,
0.44138285517692566,
-0.2749031186103821,
-0.040167562663555145,
0.04872544854879379,
-0.6615812182426453,
0.344942182302475,
0.6563012599945068,
0.9821009635925293,
0.004508142825216055,
-0.08525344729423523,
-0.5454924702644348,
0.2618538737297058,
-0.34819164872169495,
0.7539074420928955,
-0.22941280901432037,
-0.6186903119087219,
-0.07313856482505798,
-0.06915128231048584,
0.028704550117254257,
-0.4888778626918793,
0.7349672913551331,
-0.3314386308193207,
0.07934768497943878,
0.14245697855949402,
-0.5177356600761414,
-0.03118264488875866,
0.08823434263467789,
-0.515653669834137,
1.4380651712417603,
0.1672394722700119,
-0.4515008330345154,
0.14907535910606384,
-0.41425859928131104,
-0.6533644795417786,
-0.12794530391693115,
-0.46821328997612,
-0.6082797050476074,
0.2502397298812866,
0.09984992444515228,
0.6083395481109619,
-0.27627649903297424,
0.39513811469078064,
0.13352279365062714,
-0.0036246967501938343,
0.5010417103767395,
-0.43120861053466797,
0.3353000283241272,
-0.03147424757480621,
-0.43294066190719604,
-0.10653963685035706,
-0.9135410189628601,
0.023228691890835762,
-0.20716384053230286,
-0.5733525156974792,
-0.11570804566144943,
0.41874852776527405,
0.01166500709950924,
0.5064328908920288,
-0.2215871959924698,
-0.4035302400588989,
-0.07323004305362701,
-0.3276157081127167,
0.3911001980304718,
0.4620209336280823,
0.3574330806732178,
0.3192428648471832,
-0.2997635006904602,
0.28307440876960754,
-0.30487143993377686,
-0.29616570472717285,
-0.17739643156528473,
-0.43047553300857544,
-0.46274909377098083,
-0.2663663327693939,
0.05371258407831192,
0.8155485391616821,
-0.25905078649520874,
0.8412424325942993,
-0.6855049133300781,
-0.7381241917610168,
-0.17182709276676178,
0.06218414753675461,
0.46089503169059753,
0.9529005289077759,
0.388315886259079,
0.021675996482372284,
-0.46845388412475586,
-0.2302129566669464,
-0.17565175890922546,
-0.40234994888305664,
-0.5241748094558716,
0.48606255650520325,
0.3497520685195923,
-0.06931894272565842,
1.0485256910324097,
-0.8160919547080994,
-0.6584309935569763,
0.1949053257703781,
0.6888516545295715,
-0.08017285168170929,
0.58073890209198,
0.4859386682510376,
-0.9573961496353149,
-0.31599679589271545,
-0.27893009781837463,
-0.7475546598434448,
-0.20320776104927063,
-0.19629324972629547,
-0.2049950659275055,
0.07675878703594208,
0.6102790832519531,
-0.7216718792915344,
0.7234312891960144,
0.7399333715438843,
-0.71891850233078,
0.1813182234764099,
-0.1476062387228012,
0.06018276885151863,
-1.196118950843811,
0.24821357429027557,
0.1193832978606224,
-0.35065507888793945,
-0.5462649464607239,
-0.19272351264953613,
-0.03538059815764427,
-0.7744928002357483,
-0.42082756757736206,
0.5868213772773743,
-0.4449025094509125,
-0.01637444458901882,
-0.41830262541770935,
-0.4491659998893738,
0.22085684537887573,
0.37756413221359253,
0.7245691418647766,
0.5417175889015198,
0.18699432909488678,
-1.0025136470794678,
0.29984810948371887,
0.4153316617012024,
-0.4914052188396454,
-0.2589384913444519,
-0.7485094666481018,
0.1612250953912735,
0.11454246938228607,
0.40305861830711365,
-1.1796818971633911,
-0.644133985042572,
0.14621502161026,
-0.7142067551612854,
0.3529806137084961,
-0.08981872349977493,
-0.60743647813797,
-0.29207706451416016,
-0.1344815194606781,
0.4415029287338257,
0.8736544251441956,
-0.6575886011123657,
0.6187857985496521,
0.4766928553581238,
-0.024663696065545082,
-0.032588038593530655,
-0.9064429998397827,
-0.02265133708715439,
-0.075640469789505,
-0.5231799483299255,
0.6824269890785217,
0.2336564064025879,
0.07204341143369675,
-0.07294003665447235,
-0.23676294088363647,
-0.3955412209033966,
-0.01728932186961174,
0.7385572791099548,
0.10563517361879349,
0.09611932933330536,
0.3609867990016937,
-0.2419528067111969,
-0.3923536539077759,
0.3729567229747772,
-0.3112838566303253,
0.30569741129875183,
0.10941344499588013,
-0.0013157670618966222,
-0.6619349122047424,
0.32180148363113403,
0.4226667284965515,
0.07133236527442932,
0.40736937522888184,
0.5337796211242676,
-0.663058340549469,
0.23164908587932587,
0.20593838393688202,
-0.13671022653579712,
-0.5089107751846313,
0.06476834416389465,
-0.2822684943675995,
-0.7363695502281189,
-0.21328864991664886,
-0.2619464099407196,
0.01568448357284069,
0.4526994824409485,
0.46416616439819336,
-0.544477641582489,
0.820138156414032,
0.4449862539768219,
0.034358758479356766,
0.3602599799633026,
-0.24055173993110657,
0.20278219878673553,
-0.5343344807624817,
-0.4457976222038269,
-0.4866489768028259,
-0.44055068492889404,
-0.40356674790382385,
-0.745887815952301,
0.5095176100730896,
0.1506575047969818,
-0.32475006580352783,
0.18855777382850647,
-0.7032523155212402,
0.0655083879828453,
0.3204449415206909,
0.4321836531162262,
-0.09323838353157043,
0.25975731015205383,
0.25583067536354065,
-0.33935797214508057,
-0.1820155680179596,
-0.7541037201881409,
0.9119950532913208,
0.28335222601890564,
0.6290230751037598,
0.2559709846973419,
0.6385871171951294,
0.4360145926475525,
0.2479054480791092,
-0.8823977708816528,
0.47463512420654297,
-0.19372086226940155,
-0.48014044761657715,
-0.28796684741973877,
-0.3133474886417389,
-0.8010159730911255,
-0.08496361970901489,
-0.41159164905548096,
-0.3015834093093872,
0.281291127204895,
0.339216023683548,
-0.6365762948989868,
0.11398279666900635,
-0.6662311553955078,
0.5935937762260437,
-0.4466484785079956,
-0.366037517786026,
0.12388330698013306,
-0.8552327156066895,
0.07492228597402573,
0.05740019306540489,
0.10369192063808441,
-0.20880921185016632,
-0.3709893524646759,
0.7160617709159851,
-0.5846980810165405,
1.1331679821014404,
-0.35073086619377136,
-0.2925916016101837,
0.5669866800308228,
-0.2455059438943863,
0.5813629031181335,
0.3921352028846741,
-0.09900212287902832,
0.022973090410232544,
-0.6962617039680481,
-0.28192347288131714,
-0.5282203555107117,
0.31947797536849976,
-0.8897857069969177,
-0.1598788946866989,
-0.5749565362930298,
-0.289033442735672,
-0.07528328895568848,
-0.09149294346570969,
0.48636266589164734,
0.5963658690452576,
-0.18779301643371582,
0.09773584455251694,
0.47790637612342834,
-0.03457854315638542,
0.6450608372688293,
0.3320014774799347,
0.2404327690601349,
-0.8395915031433105,
0.9214261770248413,
-0.14680840075016022,
-0.09401301294565201,
1.0486277341842651,
0.22717560827732086,
-0.4118874967098236,
0.03177374228835106,
-0.2694271206855774,
-0.03761950880289078,
-0.22378003597259521,
-0.4650785028934479,
-0.6900564432144165,
-0.2976587414741516,
-0.6881442666053772,
-0.2299189567565918,
-0.2190176546573639,
-0.4504384696483612,
-0.6924307346343994,
-0.3487035632133484,
0.4202860891819,
0.4807639420032501,
-0.28379136323928833,
0.4237581193447113,
-1.1760231256484985,
0.8912150859832764,
0.5648172497749329,
0.03033626824617386,
-0.5808902382850647,
-0.5161110758781433,
-0.10549066215753555,
-0.06051301583647728,
-0.4632270038127899,
-0.7907511591911316,
0.6773754358291626,
0.4906696677207947,
-0.34790661931037903,
0.4766700863838196,
0.3925932049751282,
0.5804624557495117,
-0.5845242142677307,
0.7888639569282532,
0.1971840113401413,
-0.8410810828208923,
0.6105820536613464,
-0.19630120694637299,
-0.03863481059670448,
0.20949673652648926,
0.4592035114765167,
-0.3682212233543396,
0.17623074352741241,
-0.5874300599098206,
-1.0260683298110962,
0.4389213025569916,
0.29111844301223755,
0.17007486522197723,
0.09993863105773926,
0.5732309818267822,
-0.09535861015319824,
0.08478806167840958,
-0.7176113128662109,
0.15777871012687683,
-0.39033594727516174,
-0.3762885332107544,
-0.184654101729393,
-0.3607774078845978,
-0.03784862905740738,
-0.44885218143463135,
0.37554657459259033,
-0.14940699934959412,
0.6589678525924683,
0.6644960045814514,
-0.10418376326560974,
-0.16111503541469574,
0.09317339956760406,
0.6516264081001282,
0.0667676255106926,
-0.1607719361782074,
0.3257281184196472,
-0.2999257445335388,
-0.5278551578521729,
0.49856725335121155,
0.33253753185272217,
-0.1664426624774933,
0.3049194812774658,
0.5176979899406433,
0.9836991429328918,
0.17805150151252747,
-0.7811658978462219,
0.6662291884422302,
0.10238904505968094,
-0.4732738435268402,
-0.5622430443763733,
0.15516802668571472,
-0.12475690990686417,
0.07287687808275223,
0.4940444231033325,
0.2784042954444885,
0.11531458050012589,
-0.1313656121492386,
0.21049438416957855,
-0.15058600902557373,
-0.44896194338798523,
-0.5176807641983032,
0.6639404296875,
0.5427243709564209,
-0.40426066517829895,
0.6125070452690125,
-0.11178018152713776,
-0.5271710753440857,
0.45265889167785645,
0.28511250019073486,
0.8758238554000854,
-0.2532283663749695,
0.04745921120047569,
0.7071279287338257,
0.11250987648963928,
-0.020632674917578697,
0.5974317789077759,
-0.17402514815330505,
-0.5459098219871521,
-0.5247126221656799,
-0.3369486629962921,
-0.35288140177726746,
0.3520558476448059,
-0.6224369406700134,
0.5217933654785156,
-0.4960383176803589,
-0.023144666105508804,
-0.08710732311010361,
0.036460600793361664,
-0.4973351061344147,
0.829126238822937,
0.4128202795982361,
0.6916801929473877,
-1.024601936340332,
0.5779128670692444,
0.6661273241043091,
-0.1880512833595276,
-0.7925324440002441,
0.3654119670391083,
-0.27602651715278625,
-0.46781376004219055,
0.7092528343200684,
0.5781835913658142,
0.03641245514154434,
0.10510861873626709,
-0.4915160834789276,
-0.6436740756034851,
1.0503531694412231,
0.10072531551122665,
-0.47016748785972595,
-0.28994935750961304,
0.4780384600162506,
0.6424095630645752,
-0.31384438276290894,
-0.2875247001647949,
0.04928969591856003,
0.4503489136695862,
-0.27623122930526733,
-0.3614776134490967,
0.16828474402427673,
-0.35670605301856995,
-0.12182915955781937,
0.29121264815330505,
-0.5647328495979309,
0.5967636704444885,
-0.21808701753616333,
-0.5071479678153992,
0.19718037545681,
0.9232808947563171,
0.36601439118385315,
0.3716243803501129,
0.5879565477371216,
0.7195484042167664,
0.6732757687568665,
-0.039728160947561264,
1.0679998397827148,
-0.39067745208740234,
0.276636004447937,
1.1065680980682373,
-0.2814428508281708,
0.9631680250167847,
0.307819128036499,
0.19585514068603516,
0.44697684049606323,
0.7135719060897827,
0.11194489151239395,
0.8539428114891052,
0.05007104575634003,
-0.5566800236701965,
-0.2977653741836548,
0.05547742545604706,
-0.24135777354240417,
0.38699501752853394,
0.3876851201057434,
-0.6149314045906067,
-0.07864304631948471,
-0.023524073883891106,
-0.41830918192863464,
0.15279175341129303,
0.11450216919183731,
0.6560734510421753,
0.012663306668400764,
-0.7375301122665405,
0.513595461845398,
0.11872279644012451,
0.4800226092338562,
-0.329378217458725,
-0.23272979259490967,
0.2956131100654602,
0.11217854917049408,
-0.18081042170524597,
-0.9227075576782227,
0.5753299593925476,
0.3027938902378082,
-0.4393521845340729,
-0.9203132390975952,
0.7978048324584961,
-0.29858091473579407,
-0.40071210265159607,
0.031902581453323364,
0.2579338550567627,
0.30609163641929626,
-0.28982672095298767,
-0.156759113073349,
-0.35418596863746643,
-0.31553351879119873,
-0.37465062737464905,
0.015949200838804245,
0.7184443473815918,
0.11632352322340012,
0.1525913029909134,
0.6614553928375244,
-0.19741803407669067,
-0.019916407763957977,
-0.23217959702014923,
0.7839037775993347,
-0.9763984680175781,
-0.5645421743392944,
-0.5827417373657227,
0.5824034810066223,
-0.0008196150884032249,
-0.7591584920883179,
-0.020660605281591415,
0.7313846945762634,
0.42838534712791443,
-0.13273459672927856,
0.9528079032897949,
-0.24153123795986176,
0.8935774564743042,
-0.5476129055023193,
0.45192667841911316,
-0.293327659368515,
-0.046160824596881866,
0.13009172677993774,
-0.38700249791145325,
-0.10582131147384644,
0.7593262791633606,
0.19027452170848846,
-0.27047115564346313,
0.7211653590202332,
0.417870432138443,
-0.16995719075202942,
-0.2703707218170166,
-0.024058977141976357,
-0.09203672409057617,
0.36663052439689636,
0.6647261381149292,
0.6237198710441589,
-0.9063624143600464,
0.6468729972839355,
-0.41722914576530457,
-0.16778196394443512,
-0.26450303196907043,
-1.1367846727371216,
-0.6999312043190002,
-0.6656672358512878,
-0.4878130555152893,
-0.4901964068412781,
-0.260233610868454,
0.8104050159454346,
1.0089747905731201,
-0.4697794020175934,
-0.06706263870000839,
-0.6183507442474365,
-0.46448975801467896,
-0.19252784550189972,
-0.26854127645492554,
0.4344502091407776,
-0.14726987481117249,
-0.5999680757522583,
0.5706086754798889,
0.0046098493039608,
0.5403332710266113,
0.16894592344760895,
-0.5166362524032593,
0.17774616181850433,
-0.2167230248451233,
0.5460839867591858,
0.5428066849708557,
-0.293744832277298,
-0.29613009095191956,
-0.0018023769371211529,
-0.4493454396724701,
0.016923272982239723,
1.076066017150879,
-0.9932693243026733,
-0.10944586992263794,
0.7998589873313904,
0.8982681632041931,
0.5618054866790771,
0.2073282152414322,
0.6047462224960327,
-1.3830442428588867,
0.4015890955924988,
0.4723280370235443,
0.07618823647499084,
0.5052364468574524,
-0.4728337228298187,
0.9188765287399292,
0.4934958815574646,
-0.49994274973869324,
-0.6367632746696472,
0.20689933001995087,
-1.023072361946106,
-0.14050431549549103,
1.4645994901657104,
-0.17848731577396393,
-0.009844271466135979,
0.16986340284347534,
-0.28261318802833557,
0.5983231663703918,
-0.3498389720916748,
0.9443396329879761,
0.5319764614105225,
-0.2746806740760803,
-0.06240487098693848,
-0.2916828393936157,
0.5700982213020325,
0.1843903809785843,
-0.9975947141647339,
-0.016992760822176933,
0.5369805097579956,
0.08026725798845291,
0.21523930132389069,
0.6086729168891907,
0.17137466371059418,
0.29052355885505676,
-0.22806565463542938,
0.023892847821116447,
-0.07711651176214218,
-0.4515267312526703,
-0.11293920874595642,
0.2860347330570221,
-0.3164058327674866,
-0.4626099169254303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14411v1
|
J-UniMorph: Japanese Morphological Annotation through the Universal Feature Schema
| 2024-02-22T09:56:51 | 2024-02-22T09:56:51 |
Kosuke Matsuzaki, Masaya Taniguchi, Kentaro Inui, Keisuke Sakaguchi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce a Japanese Morphology dataset, J-UniMorph, developed based on
the UniMorph feature schema. This dataset addresses the unique and rich verb
forms characteristic of the language's agglutinative nature. J-UniMorph
distinguishes itself from the existing Japanese subset of UniMorph, which is
automatically extracted from Wiktionary. On average, the Wiktionary Edition
features around 12 inflected forms for each word and is primarily dominated by
denominal verbs (i.e., [noun] +suru (do-PRS)). Morphologically, this form is
equivalent to the verb suru (do). In contrast, J-UniMorph explores a much
broader and more frequently used range of verb forms, offering 118 inflected
forms for each word on average. It includes honorifics, a range of politeness
levels, and other linguistic nuances, emphasizing the distinctive
characteristics of the Japanese language. This paper presents detailed
statistics and characteristics of J-UniMorph, comparing it with the Wiktionary
Edition. We release J-UniMorph and its interactive visualizer publicly
available, aiming to support cross-linguistic research and various
applications.
|
[
-0.5269199013710022,
-0.7496663331985474,
0.3526959717273712,
0.12307743728160858,
-0.7103641629219055,
0.1604783833026886,
-0.2887023091316223,
-0.17699027061462402,
0.6482909321784973,
0.6994390487670898,
-0.3999728262424469,
-0.3825463354587555,
-0.5703941583633423,
0.31045594811439514,
-0.28232279419898987,
0.689168393611908,
0.04697270691394806,
0.10231168568134308,
-0.26456108689308167,
-0.29445701837539673,
-0.07065721601247787,
-0.2991049885749817,
-0.18857534229755402,
-0.4028761088848114,
0.43084490299224854,
0.26620733737945557,
1.1927032470703125,
0.8119825720787048,
0.5007619261741638,
0.3405100405216217,
-0.11763158440589905,
-0.06233581528067589,
0.17171233892440796,
0.28189581632614136,
-0.04262769967317581,
-0.3888883888721466,
-0.1641223132610321,
-0.3657459318637848,
0.7514463067054749,
1.2281666994094849,
-0.1107499748468399,
0.10900413244962692,
-0.05150875076651573,
0.6205750107765198,
-0.6717618107795715,
0.3685707449913025,
-0.3742917776107788,
0.057684946805238724,
-0.9733676910400391,
-0.048752691596746445,
0.011966276913881302,
0.02707384154200554,
-0.14244712889194489,
-0.8019562363624573,
0.08146555721759796,
-0.2239755094051361,
0.650288999080658,
0.10446532815694809,
-0.19054345786571503,
-0.1920500099658966,
-0.21944336593151093,
0.1712411344051361,
-0.6426019668579102,
0.5475192666053772,
0.10449258983135223,
0.24870343506336212,
-0.5737051367759705,
-0.514390230178833,
-0.6257773041725159,
-0.4736194312572479,
-0.10537070780992508,
0.3746472895145416,
-0.10720612108707428,
0.26518017053604126,
0.12713202834129333,
0.6556212902069092,
-0.8332467079162598,
0.5678591132164001,
-0.2542805075645447,
-0.013242784887552261,
0.6987261176109314,
0.2642369568347931,
0.8644999861717224,
-0.6779018640518188,
0.01570896804332733,
-0.17827358841896057,
-0.5781872868537903,
0.029205631464719772,
0.4484604299068451,
0.6055881977081299,
0.07580653578042984,
0.9737628698348999,
-0.4098750054836273,
0.4400846064090729,
-0.4444037973880768,
-0.14122416079044342,
0.5199037194252014,
0.03556966409087181,
-0.230712890625,
-0.0646807998418808,
1.268710970878601,
0.2198086678981781,
0.3047690987586975,
-0.21192912757396698,
-0.07114886492490768,
-0.024936018511652946,
0.1530277580022812,
-0.47763264179229736,
-0.16331365704536438,
-0.20276835560798645,
-0.4378947615623474,
-0.07967521250247955,
0.4225887060165405,
-1.1766232252120972,
-0.5198449492454529,
-0.10123242437839508,
0.21765325963497162,
-0.3882635235786438,
-0.44280919432640076,
-0.045648857951164246,
-0.42126235365867615,
-0.3379320800304413,
0.25550705194473267,
-0.7948781847953796,
0.3429688811302185,
0.4311308264732361,
0.8660010695457458,
-0.23746465146541595,
-0.4324171245098114,
0.28627243638038635,
0.08040188997983932,
-0.4929756820201874,
0.8343884944915771,
-0.8950040936470032,
-0.8331840634346008,
-0.01110641285777092,
0.1503015160560608,
0.06594479829072952,
-0.3997822403907776,
0.33318108320236206,
0.13430002331733704,
0.5126286149024963,
0.28656256198883057,
-0.6500692963600159,
-0.5074936151504517,
-0.11664030700922012,
-0.5829466581344604,
0.7979684472084045,
0.35140615701675415,
-0.5708362460136414,
0.2729675769805908,
-1.0326443910598755,
-0.2418200522661209,
0.5901268124580383,
-0.16074028611183167,
-0.05464131012558937,
0.5914058089256287,
0.06435991823673248,
0.4340110719203949,
-0.22984616458415985,
0.20459437370300293,
-0.4018859565258026,
-0.08439075201749802,
0.33111444115638733,
-0.5257759094238281,
0.942345380783081,
0.2770206034183502,
-0.03578992187976837,
-0.07354012876749039,
-0.9308392405509949,
-0.039331551641225815,
0.33389759063720703,
-0.07222588360309601,
-0.9158695340156555,
-0.3180907070636749,
0.007794421166181564,
-0.2763352394104004,
0.21486271917819977,
-0.5319240689277649,
0.41465136408805847,
-0.2953399419784546,
0.1383899748325348,
0.3840790092945099,
0.16197839379310608,
0.22007499635219574,
0.1183859184384346,
0.59947270154953,
-0.1428760588169098,
0.40292540192604065,
-0.30244722962379456,
-0.7659187316894531,
-0.6206455230712891,
-0.663626492023468,
0.26766955852508545,
0.3396339416503906,
-0.3229750990867615,
0.6110753417015076,
-0.29938656091690063,
-0.9114013314247131,
-0.7337972521781921,
0.0744553804397583,
0.6923703551292419,
0.17844901978969574,
0.21808725595474243,
-0.6053909659385681,
-0.5213671922683716,
-0.8561423420906067,
-0.06970884650945663,
-0.2173844575881958,
-0.1564442664384842,
-0.21808485686779022,
0.38693150877952576,
-0.35629621148109436,
0.41365617513656616,
-0.26173752546310425,
-0.1553889662027359,
-0.12982331216335297,
0.3533715307712555,
0.25831449031829834,
0.16519039869308472,
0.4767417013645172,
-0.5565358400344849,
-0.40600794553756714,
0.27161866426467896,
-0.6758781671524048,
-0.3264756500720978,
-0.008935661986470222,
-0.12881998717784882,
0.165212020277977,
0.2470877319574356,
-0.8263296484947205,
0.5432743430137634,
0.29998257756233215,
-0.4794784188270569,
0.006204185076057911,
-0.3598957061767578,
0.40637922286987305,
-1.265371561050415,
0.1856732964515686,
-0.06075960770249367,
0.1264490932226181,
-0.5054508447647095,
0.4630802571773529,
0.01124453917145729,
-0.028853587806224823,
-0.30057162046432495,
0.47130459547042847,
-0.4045875668525696,
-0.3107317388057709,
-0.09686271846294403,
0.20136810839176178,
-0.020860806107521057,
0.4846799671649933,
0.03813507407903671,
0.5277041792869568,
0.5285870432853699,
-0.7158104777336121,
0.5762072801589966,
0.4129680395126343,
-0.07043948769569397,
0.3535964787006378,
-0.2752990424633026,
-0.2831248939037323,
-0.33309799432754517,
-0.16256283223628998,
-1.1146219968795776,
-0.6184636950492859,
0.2533929646015167,
-0.617612898349762,
0.4574565887451172,
-0.19615766406059265,
-0.5871028900146484,
-0.2971787452697754,
-0.548107385635376,
-0.004587490577250719,
0.780614972114563,
-0.26212701201438904,
0.23802947998046875,
0.7705868482589722,
-0.2738404870033264,
-0.3104690611362457,
-0.617721438407898,
-0.025916947051882744,
-0.306043803691864,
0.057969655841588974,
0.14739535748958588,
0.10332861542701721,
-0.47870147228240967,
0.10710151493549347,
0.14898554980754852,
-0.1834394633769989,
0.23568956553936005,
0.6382759809494019,
0.47137191891670227,
0.05589284747838974,
-0.1672918200492859,
0.2802378535270691,
-0.12994907796382904,
-0.10667932778596878,
0.24376587569713593,
0.7231542468070984,
0.3593623638153076,
-0.3839901387691498,
-0.5892572999000549,
0.18361905217170715,
0.9090856909751892,
0.24752390384674072,
0.01880519837141037,
0.1912371665239334,
-0.3003733158111572,
0.43208351731300354,
-0.1372787356376648,
0.34846583008766174,
-0.3376111686229706,
0.5177659392356873,
-0.5281975865364075,
-0.6109095811843872,
0.720287561416626,
0.06517944484949112,
0.2885827422142029,
0.8452764749526978,
0.3584551513195038,
-0.13597476482391357,
1.3026446104049683,
0.2424013763666153,
-0.005935525055974722,
0.39688873291015625,
0.17092293500900269,
-0.21022415161132812,
-0.8902702331542969,
-0.7145928740501404,
-0.7235128283500671,
-0.04391138628125191,
-1.0732301473617554,
-0.15005740523338318,
0.08477913588285446,
0.1312851905822754,
-0.20135748386383057,
0.41836175322532654,
-0.48339784145355225,
0.32317405939102173,
0.37654781341552734,
-0.6130751371383667,
0.3517398536205292,
0.12388045340776443,
-0.11719268560409546,
-0.3648453950881958,
-0.2954660952091217,
-0.4505801498889923,
0.9495192170143127,
0.1379590481519699,
0.7737319469451904,
0.24130555987358093,
0.5075384378433228,
0.4150121808052063,
0.06291983276605606,
-0.6857955455780029,
0.6704845428466797,
-0.5494186878204346,
-0.37598782777786255,
-0.42097318172454834,
-0.41510769724845886,
-1.2845271825790405,
0.40651994943618774,
-0.16746407747268677,
-0.8260175585746765,
-0.1692316085100174,
-0.24110832810401917,
0.1859658807516098,
0.25447937846183777,
-0.3898290693759918,
0.6479393839836121,
-0.25168681144714355,
0.4800594449043274,
-0.0810907706618309,
-0.45014023780822754,
0.24123826622962952,
0.031115703284740448,
0.3326999843120575,
-0.3946264684200287,
-0.18324419856071472,
0.7672423720359802,
-0.3870867192745209,
0.6960687041282654,
-0.24301756918430328,
0.2393716722726822,
0.0425698421895504,
0.479254812002182,
-0.019967589527368546,
0.13578128814697266,
0.38979512453079224,
0.44365307688713074,
-0.016601528972387314,
-0.07355678826570511,
-0.7881806492805481,
0.5291807055473328,
-0.8368333578109741,
-0.3839157819747925,
-0.36844366788864136,
-0.29716527462005615,
-0.1895851045846939,
0.42347124218940735,
0.46267464756965637,
0.4391906261444092,
-0.44880640506744385,
0.09281062334775925,
0.3985763490200043,
-0.07821588218212128,
0.40886613726615906,
0.5721404552459717,
-0.8188942670822144,
-0.6742401719093323,
0.7666769623756409,
0.3930876553058624,
-0.16385318338871002,
0.6066835522651672,
0.3818759024143219,
-0.7932897210121155,
-0.4783250689506531,
-0.8319991827011108,
0.24888327717781067,
-0.45460397005081177,
-0.18003953993320465,
-0.4690980911254883,
-0.2576458752155304,
-0.532004714012146,
-0.1456613391637802,
-0.6237286329269409,
-0.8382076621055603,
-0.005326222162693739,
-0.05314798280596733,
0.6548111438751221,
0.9730022549629211,
0.01257218699902296,
0.15221332013607025,
-0.7268095016479492,
0.3806113302707672,
0.00949794054031372,
0.23122882843017578,
-0.41342493891716003,
-0.7291319370269775,
0.3195880949497223,
0.03158149495720863,
0.07963541895151138,
-0.6712711453437805,
0.31193897128105164,
0.1483713537454605,
0.9469035863876343,
0.7684344053268433,
-0.15315434336662292,
1.093958854675293,
-0.2290869504213333,
0.9460517168045044,
0.6326735019683838,
-0.7618043422698975,
0.7147479057312012,
-0.28761452436447144,
0.30277854204177856,
0.6769238710403442,
0.5256869196891785,
-0.8833138346672058,
-0.8430140614509583,
-1.0063683986663818,
-1.0143797397613525,
0.2617173194885254,
-0.02372197061777115,
0.41409793496131897,
-0.29561305046081543,
0.3140857517719269,
0.6930768489837646,
0.1941343992948532,
-0.39062902331352234,
-0.2458869367837906,
-0.5608733296394348,
-0.544824481010437,
0.06311394274234772,
-0.32196784019470215,
0.16893473267555237,
-0.25905314087867737,
0.45814037322998047,
-0.09652530401945114,
0.014696280471980572,
-0.1360476315021515,
-0.2847294807434082,
-0.04309496283531189,
0.320852667093277,
0.29728031158447266,
0.48993512988090515,
-0.006367060821503401,
0.24320879578590393,
0.051754310727119446,
-0.8438299894332886,
-0.08185642957687378,
0.04359554126858711,
-0.5674100518226624,
0.4984758794307709,
0.5491681694984436,
0.7872821688652039,
0.30964818596839905,
-0.8246781229972839,
0.2629377543926239,
0.12017139047384262,
-0.2327335774898529,
-0.38741782307624817,
0.3005361557006836,
-0.2507226765155792,
-0.06945674866437912,
0.12219016999006271,
-0.38265514373779297,
0.48514237999916077,
-0.6763896346092224,
-0.21185387670993805,
0.4225814938545227,
-0.24530375003814697,
-0.42260003089904785,
0.24927885830402374,
0.008784863166511059,
-0.19793257117271423,
0.7048766016960144,
-0.24834628403186798,
-0.1448686420917511,
0.26882222294807434,
0.5796763896942139,
0.7585688829421997,
-0.4010336995124817,
0.3782148063182831,
0.4203343689441681,
-0.06612643599510193,
-0.12997841835021973,
0.3393363654613495,
0.06898020952939987,
-0.5099382400512695,
-0.07783790677785873,
-0.6921491622924805,
-0.41290220618247986,
0.37142685055732727,
-0.9441684484481812,
-0.014066286385059357,
-0.6855432391166687,
0.05240417644381523,
0.10256542265415192,
0.0070319571532309055,
-0.3376309275627136,
0.22694237530231476,
0.19752787053585052,
0.6137112975120544,
-0.7777465581893921,
0.42513415217399597,
1.2656036615371704,
-0.8072417974472046,
-0.32129573822021484,
-0.18417644500732422,
0.19600996375083923,
-1.1398037672042847,
0.19165384769439697,
0.1279340535402298,
0.08716455101966858,
-0.26107320189476013,
-0.07845588028430939,
-0.9263297915458679,
0.9557217359542847,
0.2694467306137085,
-0.5165850520133972,
0.314856618642807,
0.43911170959472656,
0.6854928731918335,
-0.1888691931962967,
0.3798798620700836,
0.4625745117664337,
0.5556333065032959,
-0.09297666698694229,
-0.8801152110099792,
0.03056521713733673,
-0.572550892829895,
0.5950875878334045,
0.4651961326599121,
-0.443698525428772,
0.44901004433631897,
0.010945525951683521,
-0.4657767415046692,
0.06365954130887985,
0.4645353853702545,
0.23335324227809906,
0.009866848587989807,
0.45442336797714233,
0.713999330997467,
0.8404870629310608,
-0.07580141723155975,
0.7902824878692627,
0.05031121149659157,
0.06536205112934113,
0.7126129269599915,
0.031164608895778656,
0.6107836365699768,
0.6052701473236084,
-0.37448450922966003,
0.5476782917976379,
0.6797261834144592,
-0.18522091209888458,
0.5782848596572876,
-0.0026117039378732443,
0.07440437376499176,
-0.009147671982645988,
-0.340559720993042,
-0.19502106308937073,
0.859924852848053,
0.3770056962966919,
-0.06675413995981216,
-0.2190118134021759,
0.25386273860931396,
0.4682517945766449,
0.2273503839969635,
-0.610563337802887,
0.8750350475311279,
-0.18283113837242126,
-0.5796455144882202,
0.0756789818406105,
-0.2771286964416504,
0.5561711192131042,
-0.8047565221786499,
-0.0007582568214274943,
-0.627204179763794,
-0.13890229165554047,
-0.1808168888092041,
-1.3824658393859863,
0.25955894589424133,
0.22312450408935547,
0.11050727963447571,
0.19483834505081177,
0.4727432429790497,
-0.1975366473197937,
-0.44466981291770935,
0.29991358518600464,
0.5494577288627625,
0.5289663076400757,
0.13674762845039368,
-0.5260128378868103,
-0.07495657354593277,
-0.04706816002726555,
-0.5249936580657959,
0.554676353931427,
0.7186535596847534,
-0.3981166183948517,
0.6265025734901428,
0.5442694425582886,
0.18241626024246216,
0.027568092569708824,
0.666220486164093,
0.5158522725105286,
-0.8119909167289734,
-0.36877161264419556,
-0.8483554720878601,
0.6922546625137329,
-0.2841201722621918,
-0.7113433480262756,
0.8047402501106262,
0.4828510284423828,
1.007042407989502,
-0.03428519517183304,
0.8186277747154236,
-0.26931455731391907,
0.40302330255508423,
-0.574203372001648,
0.5177608132362366,
-0.7797696590423584,
-0.2851778268814087,
-0.1918777972459793,
-0.9828274846076965,
-0.7999996542930603,
0.5792793035507202,
0.44217973947525024,
-0.1259792298078537,
0.5965498089790344,
0.4836260676383972,
-0.05710252374410629,
-0.07021648436784744,
0.6793431639671326,
-0.0012197657488286495,
-0.08953897655010223,
-0.0315810926258564,
0.8022567629814148,
-0.0964488759636879,
0.25033220648765564,
-0.41884174942970276,
-0.15360349416732788,
-0.28114861249923706,
-0.3423337936401367,
-0.9215432405471802,
-0.8298324942588806,
-0.3888714909553528,
-0.06568814069032669,
-0.08676019310951233,
0.9800987243652344,
0.12646107375621796,
-0.5966432094573975,
-0.11563757807016373,
-0.23963266611099243,
-0.17655980587005615,
-0.04640332981944084,
-0.2555169463157654,
0.24004410207271576,
-0.41135457158088684,
-0.6798170208930969,
0.44909748435020447,
0.741407573223114,
0.3161110579967499,
-0.46154341101646423,
-0.10980266332626343,
0.3761104643344879,
-0.034488461911678314,
0.17299658060073853,
0.40662533044815063,
-0.7447013854980469,
-0.20159073173999786,
-0.3195264935493469,
-0.02213357761502266,
0.04672641679644585,
0.7655990719795227,
-0.2476515769958496,
0.606205940246582,
0.6898941993713379,
0.18716682493686676,
0.14443129301071167,
-0.3071838319301605,
0.20760825276374817,
-0.6540369987487793,
0.45376455783843994,
-0.07745774835348129,
0.7456883788108826,
0.3843635618686676,
-0.28844571113586426,
0.6634279489517212,
0.49100345373153687,
-0.13785406947135925,
-0.756869375705719,
0.2608231008052826,
-1.0213868618011475,
-0.5497616529464722,
0.9523499608039856,
-0.13961157202720642,
-0.46122825145721436,
-0.22371463477611542,
-0.07144179940223694,
0.4819500744342804,
-0.2922285795211792,
0.8486071228981018,
0.37594205141067505,
-0.3269083797931671,
-0.4050491750240326,
-0.3489532768726349,
0.23209334909915924,
-0.03577601537108421,
-0.8435660004615784,
0.3226805627346039,
0.4445502758026123,
0.2365914285182953,
0.5500754714012146,
0.6567754149436951,
-0.6267498135566711,
0.15170735120773315,
0.15276986360549927,
0.4926397204399109,
-0.3523446023464203,
-0.2998178005218506,
-0.31149086356163025,
0.0035046502016484737,
0.24944934248924255,
-0.21589894592761993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05572v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05572v1
|
Is ChatGPT More Empathetic than Humans?
| 2024-02-22T09:52:45 | 2024-02-22T09:52:45 |
Anuradha Welivita, Pearl Pu
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper investigates the empathetic responding capabilities of ChatGPT,
particularly its latest iteration, GPT-4, in comparison to human-generated
responses to a wide range of emotional scenarios, both positive and negative.
We employ a rigorous evaluation methodology, involving a between-groups study
with 600 participants, to evaluate the level of empathy in responses generated
by humans and ChatGPT. ChatGPT is prompted in two distinct ways: a standard
approach and one explicitly detailing empathy's cognitive, affective, and
compassionate counterparts. Our findings indicate that the average empathy
rating of responses generated by ChatGPT exceeds those crafted by humans by
approximately 10%. Additionally, instructing ChatGPT to incorporate a clear
understanding of empathy in its responses makes the responses align
approximately 5 times more closely with the expectations of individuals
possessing a high degree of empathy, compared to human responses. The proposed
evaluation framework serves as a scalable and adaptable framework to assess the
empathetic capabilities of newer and updated versions of large language models,
eliminating the need to replicate the current study's results in future
research.
|
[
-0.614132821559906,
-0.7111266851425171,
0.43264371156692505,
0.246882826089859,
-0.025962237268686295,
0.013036549091339111,
-0.30291545391082764,
-0.6033744215965271,
0.12115263938903809,
-0.2899268865585327,
-0.5923037528991699,
-0.04589884355664253,
-0.7182969450950623,
0.40377968549728394,
-0.06966374069452286,
1.0271313190460205,
0.1526920199394226,
0.023584619164466858,
0.15023498237133026,
-0.08117292821407318,
-0.0792136937379837,
-0.8735523223876953,
-0.9678987860679626,
-0.4790925681591034,
0.7028928995132446,
0.2923438847064972,
0.5192763209342957,
-0.05111798271536827,
0.7870163321495056,
0.2209116667509079,
-0.03680362179875374,
-0.35186561942100525,
-0.5106658339500427,
-0.2800259590148926,
0.07331734150648117,
-0.06225442513823509,
-1.0022592544555664,
0.4188278615474701,
-0.05911823734641075,
0.0643032044172287,
-0.3073752522468567,
0.23208940029144287,
0.34934887290000916,
0.4921486973762512,
-0.26221373677253723,
0.07470926642417908,
-0.3127593696117401,
0.351211279630661,
0.3964873254299164,
-0.27487319707870483,
-0.4087345600128174,
-0.4498618245124817,
0.4141812026500702,
-0.49205657839775085,
0.25819939374923706,
0.1827181875705719,
0.41766148805618286,
-0.04687817767262459,
-0.5047587752342224,
-0.3441559374332428,
-0.21577049791812897,
0.6633783578872681,
-0.5493131875991821,
0.19894392788410187,
0.2703731954097748,
0.2593352794647217,
0.24292652308940887,
-0.5520419478416443,
-0.6161682605743408,
-0.4762604236602783,
0.19205471873283386,
0.7249952554702759,
-0.3755951225757599,
0.19939060509204865,
0.47352513670921326,
0.40982791781425476,
-0.784477174282074,
-0.11301466822624207,
-0.15754073858261108,
0.04102238640189171,
0.5861449837684631,
0.3051549792289734,
0.5215360522270203,
-0.2381887286901474,
-0.25536614656448364,
-0.1148882657289505,
-0.26746463775634766,
0.0049295248463749886,
0.46159791946411133,
0.0671093612909317,
-0.30576586723327637,
0.6382047533988953,
0.13102881610393524,
0.3057374656200409,
0.17736732959747314,
0.3705405592918396,
0.05275343358516693,
-0.04449794068932533,
-0.22119250893592834,
-0.023679839447140694,
0.675999641418457,
1.3602162599563599,
0.685714066028595,
-0.01699666678905487,
0.20164093375205994,
0.33803367614746094,
0.6025238633155823,
-1.108328104019165,
-0.3958238363265991,
0.21416530013084412,
-0.7100011110305786,
-0.3240683376789093,
-0.28040748834609985,
-0.9990077018737793,
-0.5283477306365967,
-0.015316681005060673,
0.1703757792711258,
-0.5612652897834778,
-0.5015535950660706,
0.11791577935218811,
-0.30399090051651,
0.902393102645874,
0.382443368434906,
-1.0021941661834717,
0.5678510665893555,
0.8301709294319153,
1.0426673889160156,
-0.11821442097425461,
-0.4311031401157379,
-0.43319159746170044,
-0.4015372395515442,
-0.10264997184276581,
0.9695565700531006,
-0.7800448536872864,
-0.6025105118751526,
-0.46076875925064087,
-0.23023825883865356,
-0.0006183257792145014,
-0.10654211789369583,
0.9025555849075317,
0.014030495658516884,
0.29169636964797974,
-0.685339093208313,
-0.5057960748672485,
-0.1260640025138855,
0.7313973307609558,
-0.31942230463027954,
0.5452970862388611,
0.6169983744621277,
-1.1145386695861816,
0.4511828124523163,
-0.9522362947463989,
-0.10010937601327896,
-0.16559351980686188,
0.09033217281103134,
-0.19420796632766724,
0.07587070763111115,
0.10836023092269897,
0.55525141954422,
-0.41849520802497864,
-0.23645718395709991,
-0.5897781252861023,
-0.25810927152633667,
0.23710349202156067,
-0.4350792467594147,
0.28851982951164246,
0.2313215136528015,
-0.27747803926467896,
-0.1715923547744751,
-0.25852906703948975,
0.10301898419857025,
0.09392596781253815,
-0.22260360419750214,
-0.027308087795972824,
-0.1523369997739792,
0.17208683490753174,
0.47913435101509094,
-0.07094694674015045,
-0.9356735348701477,
0.009068372659385204,
-0.24089080095291138,
0.6648123860359192,
0.8191003799438477,
-0.006908867973834276,
0.47192370891571045,
-0.44828930497169495,
0.7020325660705566,
-0.26727595925331116,
0.44889646768569946,
-0.06698349118232727,
-0.721175491809845,
-0.3353533148765564,
-0.2865491211414337,
-0.30172988772392273,
0.3388064205646515,
0.07106146216392517,
0.3207024037837982,
-0.1527024656534195,
-0.7454806566238403,
-0.49771326780319214,
-0.4169207513332367,
0.6957460045814514,
0.5069193840026855,
0.2776433825492859,
-0.8577785491943359,
-0.3130260407924652,
-0.8117952942848206,
-0.6777663826942444,
-0.2248961478471756,
-0.1864791214466095,
0.6534740924835205,
0.2682848572731018,
-0.14486856758594513,
0.48839640617370605,
-0.21580438315868378,
0.05271622911095619,
-0.14572162926197052,
0.051225777715444565,
-0.07149409502744675,
0.2485804259777069,
0.47114652395248413,
-0.6169394254684448,
-0.7912862300872803,
0.3142779767513275,
-0.5057019591331482,
-0.03223287686705589,
0.09688325226306915,
-0.24854327738285065,
-0.046607889235019684,
-0.006209421902894974,
-0.689949095249176,
0.3414646089076996,
0.5932309031486511,
-0.7552853226661682,
0.2504727840423584,
-0.019114309921860695,
0.6771204471588135,
-1.011249303817749,
0.09702951461076736,
0.030733391642570496,
0.10975772887468338,
-0.6819285154342651,
-0.3310137987136841,
0.01924656331539154,
-0.12158020585775375,
-0.4203069508075714,
0.6558001637458801,
-0.29435592889785767,
-0.18688413500785828,
0.21074068546295166,
0.34522417187690735,
-0.053552962839603424,
0.5146018862724304,
0.09498361498117447,
0.5437037348747253,
0.47245660424232483,
-0.08077439665794373,
0.6527290344238281,
0.5744092464447021,
0.08646241575479507,
0.8261772394180298,
-0.9100924134254456,
0.2611018419265747,
0.039436329156160355,
0.3574008345603943,
-0.96096271276474,
-0.43264514207839966,
0.4942837953567505,
-0.7830676436424255,
0.05824343487620354,
-0.023780839517712593,
-0.06283894181251526,
-0.5243879556655884,
-0.4957262873649597,
0.2004529982805252,
0.973665177822113,
-0.2986954152584076,
0.7275275588035583,
0.044414717704057693,
-0.545811653137207,
0.015114826150238514,
-0.7650013566017151,
0.10853599011898041,
-0.47910138964653015,
-0.6343706846237183,
-0.2545487880706787,
-0.24003587663173676,
-0.428302526473999,
-0.3274751603603363,
0.03008345514535904,
-0.023159051313996315,
-0.09862014651298523,
0.23850513994693756,
-0.15897220373153687,
0.09382478147745132,
-0.0511024184525013,
-0.15411165356636047,
-0.3175998330116272,
0.2205735594034195,
0.49230387806892395,
0.6144879460334778,
-0.5116373896598816,
-0.681222140789032,
-0.39173808693885803,
0.3626897931098938,
0.47166720032691956,
-0.15855856239795685,
0.42486321926116943,
0.7802987694740295,
-0.028445186093449593,
0.5312827229499817,
-0.39751115441322327,
-0.3774387538433075,
-0.3692528307437897,
0.268704891204834,
-0.5085743069648743,
-0.72296142578125,
0.5661434531211853,
0.23170655965805054,
0.07150677591562271,
0.08731664717197418,
0.902696430683136,
0.19037212431430817,
1.282211184501648,
0.25079411268234253,
-0.17685052752494812,
0.3116895854473114,
0.18195319175720215,
0.5445134043693542,
-1.1935654878616333,
-0.09991512447595596,
-0.2435188591480255,
-0.22867390513420105,
-0.821047306060791,
-0.20910947024822235,
0.1023653894662857,
-0.5505284070968628,
-0.5173166394233704,
0.041283320635557175,
-0.7276808619499207,
0.1705944538116455,
0.23761412501335144,
0.33948537707328796,
0.14656250178813934,
-0.40058353543281555,
0.5823100805282593,
-0.07951652258634567,
-0.6298435926437378,
-0.8075706362724304,
1.0278193950653076,
0.4905721843242645,
0.5771395564079285,
0.29726099967956543,
0.7066625952720642,
0.30770930647850037,
0.9608458280563354,
-0.8703823089599609,
0.2929215133190155,
0.19457370042800903,
-0.5286958813667297,
-0.22618067264556885,
-0.36813628673553467,
-0.9217998385429382,
0.19403806328773499,
0.03176233172416687,
-0.9136921167373657,
-0.2713789641857147,
0.3261079788208008,
-0.3916440010070801,
0.09736891835927963,
-1.3429328203201294,
0.755932629108429,
-0.058668103069067,
-0.3049950897693634,
-0.0007960094371810555,
-0.7692597508430481,
0.10379184037446976,
-0.1664188653230667,
0.04646129533648491,
-0.3651215732097626,
-0.022380085662007332,
0.4092163145542145,
-0.061061520129442215,
0.7714174389839172,
-0.19213639199733734,
-0.05435530096292496,
0.20474079251289368,
0.2628854811191559,
0.31607383489608765,
-0.12943802773952484,
-0.32156243920326233,
-0.06638423353433609,
-0.1898886114358902,
-0.551971971988678,
-0.6755492687225342,
0.5820138454437256,
-0.7267580032348633,
-0.27247023582458496,
-0.33109626173973083,
-0.24649938941001892,
-0.1861334592103958,
-0.16843709349632263,
0.31123605370521545,
0.38247770071029663,
-0.6649215221405029,
-0.07182040065526962,
0.1827935129404068,
-0.5744524598121643,
0.30535033345222473,
0.4172547161579132,
-0.016406476497650146,
-0.26430556178092957,
0.663510799407959,
-0.3283911645412445,
0.4850998818874359,
0.16681735217571259,
0.48159345984458923,
-0.19110512733459473,
0.19634810090065002,
-0.32198330760002136,
0.09375083446502686,
-0.22361668944358826,
-0.05446628853678703,
-0.7196736931800842,
0.17827077209949493,
-0.3755784332752228,
-0.6007018089294434,
-0.34978538751602173,
-0.15400968492031097,
0.2531093657016754,
-0.30924466252326965,
0.7176890969276428,
0.7613459825515747,
-0.13407829403877258,
0.15456852316856384,
-0.8152934312820435,
0.12395782768726349,
0.5188353657722473,
0.4819197356700897,
0.08837483078241348,
-0.5804829597473145,
0.24052794277668,
0.09792206436395645,
-0.4517371356487274,
-0.7736802101135254,
0.6026327013969421,
0.23003257811069489,
0.15651293098926544,
0.46824803948402405,
-0.004946779925376177,
0.6299142241477966,
-0.5981286764144897,
1.0093154907226562,
0.3753996193408966,
-0.901087760925293,
0.12487781792879105,
-0.7463359236717224,
0.11905395239591599,
0.14856930077075958,
0.28223180770874023,
-0.5740938186645508,
-0.415612131357193,
-0.9678176641464233,
-0.6797104477882385,
0.5694169402122498,
0.6312395930290222,
0.52643221616745,
-0.24318169057369232,
0.23970972001552582,
0.11112596094608307,
-0.17949645221233368,
-0.4494814872741699,
0.19773820042610168,
-0.3263547718524933,
-0.1865328699350357,
-0.4887075424194336,
-0.41016361117362976,
-0.07939238846302032,
0.007677637040615082,
-0.005501609295606613,
0.017885394394397736,
0.8785017728805542,
0.27725306153297424,
0.30092501640319824,
-0.21095427870750427,
0.2447831779718399,
0.22260212898254395,
0.23090118169784546,
-0.3284287750720978,
0.029507044702768326,
0.5341379046440125,
-0.4654804468154907,
-0.03757248818874359,
0.012905475683510303,
0.8029746413230896,
-0.5527898669242859,
0.6981162428855896,
0.3825998604297638,
0.11240734159946442,
-0.6438779234886169,
0.9456894397735596,
-0.5668735504150391,
-0.30218660831451416,
-0.13006995618343353,
-0.005895859096199274,
0.14426293969154358,
0.5390594005584717,
-0.12998951971530914,
-0.15092064440250397,
0.5295780301094055,
-0.5216144919395447,
0.2722943425178528,
0.13990946114063263,
-0.41789570450782776,
-0.5774691104888916,
0.40964481234550476,
0.4150797724723816,
-0.6559015512466431,
0.7401291131973267,
0.011740358546376228,
-0.7896243333816528,
0.6390944719314575,
0.41558143496513367,
0.9876261949539185,
-0.3860880136489868,
0.21077878773212433,
0.485062837600708,
0.12520821392536163,
0.0849369615316391,
0.45429927110671997,
-0.18565469980239868,
-0.8028401136398315,
-0.05084932595491409,
-0.41037440299987793,
-0.7526440024375916,
-0.5119534134864807,
-1.1417573690414429,
-0.2479337453842163,
-0.2591891586780548,
-0.40352076292037964,
-0.22323928773403168,
-0.0053712148219347,
-0.8191639184951782,
0.3521243929862976,
-0.12297513335943222,
0.7221599817276001,
-0.8974596858024597,
0.2487928867340088,
0.715809166431427,
-0.3757253885269165,
-0.9786075949668884,
0.20588214695453644,
-0.10389450937509537,
-0.8965659737586975,
0.30750715732574463,
0.5004358887672424,
-0.15593111515045166,
0.20986080169677734,
-0.21959911286830902,
-0.20318880677223206,
1.137634515762329,
0.23646824061870575,
-0.15980522334575653,
0.2438553124666214,
-0.1005248874425888,
0.8999282717704773,
-0.0697644054889679,
0.9477846026420593,
0.7775261402130127,
0.5900322794914246,
-0.24617649614810944,
-1.0852855443954468,
0.017464494332671165,
-0.6725607514381409,
-0.09074485301971436,
0.012598862871527672,
-1.1587423086166382,
0.5490590333938599,
-0.2715414762496948,
-0.052187833935022354,
0.09750290960073471,
-0.01471824012696743,
0.26130977272987366,
0.39301034808158875,
0.31048551201820374,
0.46159401535987854,
0.4986478090286255,
-0.11238788813352585,
1.479437232017517,
-0.20943796634674072,
0.3898650109767914,
0.8590327501296997,
-0.4108356833457947,
0.7152623534202576,
0.5614583492279053,
-0.29384514689445496,
0.00029021271620877087,
0.8301364779472351,
0.2171814888715744,
0.2728741466999054,
0.09657979011535645,
-0.5732232332229614,
-0.1320665180683136,
-0.02439826913177967,
-0.20569683611392975,
0.45944201946258545,
-0.16443398594856262,
-0.34016820788383484,
-0.11740735173225403,
-0.04939393326640129,
0.16339126229286194,
-0.15195469558238983,
-0.2465420663356781,
0.9049557447433472,
0.30059516429901123,
-0.5386430025100708,
0.2499866783618927,
-0.29029735922813416,
0.3350120186805725,
-0.2954311668872833,
-0.06933137774467468,
-0.38015031814575195,
0.015050326474010944,
-0.20321227610111237,
-1.0624579191207886,
0.19318121671676636,
0.5420476198196411,
0.12044826149940491,
-0.21728438138961792,
0.5546781420707703,
0.05548936873674393,
0.04819008335471153,
0.5924537181854248,
0.5131810307502747,
0.5058273673057556,
-0.14610260725021362,
-0.7211424112319946,
-0.032667797058820724,
0.06465443968772888,
-0.905177891254425,
0.40245306491851807,
0.7526683211326599,
0.24692302942276,
0.8889180421829224,
0.5253674983978271,
-0.1910461038351059,
0.05145537480711937,
0.2515181005001068,
0.9709181785583496,
-0.725678026676178,
-0.11130953580141068,
-1.0317749977111816,
0.6167846322059631,
-0.2427746057510376,
-0.40691864490509033,
0.7155943512916565,
0.27288034558296204,
0.3300040364265442,
-0.15001948177814484,
0.9037758111953735,
-0.4532244801521301,
0.5457996129989624,
-0.23007932305335999,
0.3296738266944885,
-0.19462215900421143,
-0.14993110299110413,
-0.7880859971046448,
-1.0472277402877808,
-0.35043570399284363,
0.9424592852592468,
-0.6727973818778992,
0.4719861149787903,
0.5636269450187683,
0.9209101796150208,
-0.064035564661026,
0.32138630747795105,
0.6207104325294495,
0.117735855281353,
0.352164089679718,
0.7900311946868896,
1.2771435976028442,
-0.0032127732411026955,
0.25846540927886963,
0.14221690595149994,
-0.5000745058059692,
-0.018391653895378113,
-1.014461874961853,
-0.8341463804244995,
-0.20898586511611938,
0.1503341943025589,
-0.0957651436328888,
0.019992098212242126,
0.9868972301483154,
0.23269692063331604,
-0.31074920296669006,
0.06909840553998947,
-0.1547940969467163,
-0.5845159888267517,
0.04171872138977051,
-0.24523219466209412,
0.41454800963401794,
-0.03433062136173248,
-0.7899419069290161,
-0.398243248462677,
0.43129539489746094,
-0.061408936977386475,
0.20110854506492615,
-0.570044994354248,
0.5390715599060059,
0.14168396592140198,
0.8806549310684204,
-0.05677073448896408,
-0.3732859790325165,
-0.7108504772186279,
0.1470453292131424,
-0.013466298580169678,
0.16804003715515137,
0.5945348739624023,
-0.07579465210437775,
0.5720627307891846,
0.19184547662734985,
0.35847607254981995,
0.3705242872238159,
0.447538286447525,
0.8705236911773682,
-0.10742169618606567,
-0.0011248757364228368,
0.19595851004123688,
0.3047458529472351,
0.407593697309494,
-0.4069852828979492,
0.6752036809921265,
-0.2515856623649597,
-0.976844847202301,
-0.525337278842926,
0.42753416299819946,
-1.2373071908950806,
0.4912162125110626,
1.3564822673797607,
-0.5388975143432617,
0.15833048522472382,
0.07201869785785675,
-0.9007862210273743,
0.3333786129951477,
-0.8276578783988953,
0.8769885301589966,
0.6142605543136597,
-0.6968146562576294,
-0.2434358447790146,
-0.40049782395362854,
0.36894577741622925,
0.1716400533914566,
-0.740874171257019,
0.1533837616443634,
0.44785410165786743,
0.18722540140151978,
-0.3178078830242157,
0.7962615489959717,
-0.2092316448688507,
0.31314364075660706,
0.30806875228881836,
0.390186071395874,
0.32918527722358704,
0.392200767993927,
-0.2865922152996063,
-0.09632974117994308,
0.2760555148124695,
0.09811153262853622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14409v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14409v1
|
Tug-of-War Between Knowledge: Exploring and Resolving Knowledge Conflicts in Retrieval-Augmented Language Models
| 2024-02-22T09:51:08 | 2024-02-22T09:51:08 |
Zhuoran Jin, Pengfei Cao, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Xiaojian Jiang, Jiexin Xu, Qiuxia Li, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Retrieval-augmented language models (RALMs) have demonstrated significant
potential in refining and expanding their internal memory by retrieving
evidence from external sources. However, RALMs will inevitably encounter
knowledge conflicts when integrating their internal memory with external
sources. Knowledge conflicts can ensnare RALMs in a tug-of-war between
knowledge, limiting their practical applicability. In this paper, we focus on
exploring and resolving knowledge conflicts in RALMs. First, we present an
evaluation framework for assessing knowledge conflicts across various
dimensions. Then, we investigate the behavior and preference of RALMs from the
following two perspectives: (1) Conflicts between internal memory and external
sources: We find that stronger RALMs emerge with the Dunning-Kruger effect,
persistently favoring their faulty internal memory even when correct evidence
is provided. Besides, RALMs exhibit an availability bias towards common
knowledge; (2) Conflicts between truthful, irrelevant and misleading evidence:
We reveal that RALMs follow the principle of majority rule, leaning towards
placing trust in evidence that appears more frequently. Moreover, we find that
RALMs exhibit confirmation bias, and are more willing to choose evidence that
is consistent with their internal memory. To solve the challenge of knowledge
conflicts, we propose a method called Conflict-Disentangle Contrastive Decoding
(CD2) to better calibrate the model's confidence. Experimental results
demonstrate that our CD2 can effectively resolve knowledge conflicts in RALMs.
|
[
-0.49900561571121216,
-0.6467936038970947,
0.6747459173202515,
0.003004991915076971,
-0.13703954219818115,
0.4184775948524475,
-0.22353410720825195,
-0.6030961275100708,
-0.16726429760456085,
0.44064468145370483,
-0.014147010631859303,
-0.03578074276447296,
-0.9353798627853394,
-0.09913032501935959,
-0.24509699642658234,
0.7270500659942627,
-0.3261583745479584,
0.0502643808722496,
-0.495318740606308,
-0.5135736465454102,
-0.6594722270965576,
-0.7191646695137024,
-0.25186100602149963,
-0.6351161599159241,
0.5475963354110718,
0.27441197633743286,
0.7843443155288696,
0.25917622447013855,
0.6332211494445801,
0.3160483241081238,
-0.3977579176425934,
0.37454739212989807,
-0.5134290456771851,
0.6154075264930725,
-0.4920588433742523,
-0.41457730531692505,
0.09983609616756439,
-0.004264362156391144,
0.27035385370254517,
0.3704153597354889,
-0.312722772359848,
0.011197212152183056,
-0.0355125293135643,
1.1762553453445435,
-0.7571210861206055,
-0.16861246526241302,
-0.7061561346054077,
-0.09138786792755127,
-0.31596601009368896,
-0.09373507648706436,
-0.3813196122646332,
-0.373540461063385,
0.49876514077186584,
-0.36433741450309753,
0.05239356681704521,
0.3148367404937744,
1.0702133178710938,
0.2528349459171295,
-0.6754335165023804,
-0.7102158665657043,
-0.5996425747871399,
0.6287339329719543,
-0.6394308805465698,
0.4057481288909912,
0.7430616617202759,
0.21178917586803436,
-0.05980776995420456,
-0.5924563407897949,
-0.46042054891586304,
-0.08029516786336899,
-0.24628157913684845,
0.11448238044977188,
-0.5360451936721802,
-0.1543159782886505,
0.2975693941116333,
0.2864975333213806,
-0.6349390745162964,
-0.11253534257411957,
-0.5267380475997925,
-0.14882215857505798,
0.5170227289199829,
0.06714184582233429,
0.29853516817092896,
0.05644503980875015,
-0.5085939764976501,
0.046871818602085114,
-0.675288200378418,
-0.10728255659341812,
0.41851893067359924,
0.01583774760365486,
0.20079727470874786,
0.6533795595169067,
-0.040635474026203156,
0.706524133682251,
0.2681545615196228,
0.08794736117124557,
0.039211101830005646,
-0.22845768928527832,
-0.013382336124777794,
0.23364916443824768,
0.6142715215682983,
0.3658179044723511,
-0.15109708905220032,
-0.08594540506601334,
-0.29366734623908997,
0.14132694900035858,
0.35902708768844604,
-0.46932658553123474,
-0.1690191775560379,
0.26437434554100037,
-0.6301754713058472,
-0.04529089853167534,
-0.11485894024372101,
-0.8179594278335571,
-0.5612858533859253,
-0.25404906272888184,
0.8404743075370789,
-0.582317054271698,
-0.5923031568527222,
0.17320886254310608,
-0.43068233132362366,
-0.11641339212656021,
0.2529541552066803,
-0.641867995262146,
0.317054808139801,
0.42062729597091675,
0.6589286923408508,
0.006713776383548975,
0.10014913976192474,
-0.4027831554412842,
0.0655924528837204,
-0.3525393009185791,
0.8311002850532532,
-0.621733546257019,
-0.46979910135269165,
0.06304726004600525,
-0.5322346687316895,
-0.13375359773635864,
-0.9671233296394348,
0.46144312620162964,
-1.105578064918518,
0.33261001110076904,
-0.8376061320304871,
-0.7224633097648621,
-0.2607838213443756,
0.5455284118652344,
-0.7697844505310059,
1.1028268337249756,
0.08088648319244385,
-1.0324065685272217,
0.20340180397033691,
-0.47542324662208557,
-0.25991037487983704,
-0.12286894023418427,
-0.2384340465068817,
-0.19915492832660675,
0.21193714439868927,
-0.0725565105676651,
-0.13374871015548706,
-0.48834139108657837,
0.18608497083187103,
-0.19827228784561157,
-0.28688478469848633,
0.3881820738315582,
0.061696939170360565,
0.6170288324356079,
0.5023557543754578,
-0.22195374965667725,
-0.05793553590774536,
-0.4328291416168213,
-0.1927613765001297,
0.3356103003025055,
-0.36151060461997986,
-0.9261810183525085,
0.07155052572488785,
-0.5744286775588989,
0.325986385345459,
0.40676647424697876,
-0.4020918011665344,
0.24134020507335663,
0.03878887742757797,
0.16123363375663757,
0.5918230414390564,
0.12788593769073486,
0.4136179983615875,
-0.6131098866462708,
0.29019758105278015,
0.4978151321411133,
0.114307701587677,
0.10347147285938263,
-0.4840077757835388,
-0.741064190864563,
0.35680657625198364,
0.055753350257873535,
0.209570974111557,
-0.9074394106864929,
0.011467504315078259,
0.01700395904481411,
-0.184640035033226,
-0.7717093825340271,
0.010118666104972363,
0.37283778190612793,
0.6246291399002075,
0.4309045672416687,
-0.19459262490272522,
-0.5072034001350403,
-0.6426423788070679,
-0.4096348285675049,
-0.3337427079677582,
0.45833444595336914,
0.34734535217285156,
0.2986566424369812,
-0.14988741278648376,
1.2263857126235962,
-0.27574148774147034,
-0.3248753249645233,
-0.04648758843541145,
0.5004622936248779,
-0.23218190670013428,
0.2893572747707367,
0.47216129302978516,
-1.1101009845733643,
-0.5453788638114929,
0.12196745723485947,
-0.8375908732414246,
0.1837269365787506,
0.24407914280891418,
-0.01425253413617611,
0.4593912661075592,
0.3519113063812256,
-0.44744688272476196,
0.4189203381538391,
0.4522777199745178,
-0.4650598466396332,
0.5157317519187927,
-0.34207186102867126,
0.3868480622768402,
-0.5318442583084106,
-0.1465083211660385,
-0.13164561986923218,
0.25808385014533997,
-0.5514495968818665,
0.0827011987566948,
0.10891763120889664,
0.30774134397506714,
-0.22676372528076172,
0.7079437971115112,
-0.5802161693572998,
0.08552418649196625,
-0.354976624250412,
0.39379653334617615,
0.2690386176109314,
0.015418571420013905,
0.20199818909168243,
0.675148069858551,
0.38381654024124146,
-0.633743941783905,
0.1917513906955719,
0.3712503910064697,
-0.6213899850845337,
0.4025862216949463,
-0.28600013256073,
0.3390618562698364,
-0.280231773853302,
-0.08274569362401962,
-0.8798702955245972,
0.17598943412303925,
0.23602978885173798,
-0.34784382581710815,
0.42291155457496643,
-0.194988414645195,
-0.5698450207710266,
-0.16343358159065247,
-0.21406757831573486,
0.6319355964660645,
0.621247410774231,
-0.6351646184921265,
0.710077166557312,
0.4113733172416687,
-0.09375697374343872,
-0.9935907125473022,
-0.5633687973022461,
0.06692641973495483,
-0.3766363263130188,
-0.539434552192688,
0.23149409890174866,
-0.05864870548248291,
-0.7254353761672974,
0.4740937650203705,
-0.294643372297287,
-0.21916966140270233,
-0.3449476361274719,
0.08365901559591293,
0.08258615434169769,
-0.25474220514297485,
0.2764194905757904,
0.05277841538190842,
-0.034457240253686905,
-0.02114935591816902,
-0.05999762564897537,
0.3893647789955139,
-0.1651834100484848,
-0.637172520160675,
0.2491932362318039,
0.34923046827316284,
0.512539803981781,
-0.45559263229370117,
0.7516899108886719,
0.4419385492801666,
-0.2580636143684387,
0.05803848057985306,
-1.2425094842910767,
-0.1875283271074295,
-0.472827672958374,
0.3151111304759979,
-0.30664581060409546,
-0.8459490537643433,
0.6787461638450623,
-0.3378375172615051,
-0.15136751532554626,
0.43246588110923767,
0.4302751123905182,
-0.18425273895263672,
0.8519144058227539,
0.4421226978302002,
-0.16246017813682556,
0.2914138436317444,
-0.06499966233968735,
0.2704467177391052,
-1.0539205074310303,
-0.4803694784641266,
-0.511172890663147,
-0.30618932843208313,
-0.035763464868068695,
-0.4153393805027008,
0.3083774149417877,
0.3674646317958832,
-0.21869993209838867,
0.2102275788784027,
-0.43033069372177124,
0.47098326683044434,
0.2823355197906494,
0.07338031381368637,
0.5035886764526367,
-0.09955506771802902,
-0.46593236923217773,
-0.3919573128223419,
-1.0069583654403687,
-0.3181885778903961,
0.8889907002449036,
0.30232369899749756,
0.8547788858413696,
0.41411709785461426,
0.6130250692367554,
0.19207042455673218,
0.3213246464729309,
-0.396572083234787,
0.29923734068870544,
0.041740402579307556,
-0.7574083209037781,
0.06767940521240234,
-0.48371419310569763,
-0.965975284576416,
0.3669244647026062,
-0.13364461064338684,
-0.6177250146865845,
0.46934986114501953,
-0.008248134516179562,
-0.20702853798866272,
0.5613301992416382,
-0.614637553691864,
0.6495354771614075,
-0.5449735522270203,
-0.3896305561065674,
-0.589116096496582,
-0.7128462791442871,
0.6190358400344849,
0.17378656566143036,
0.4062690734863281,
0.15660454332828522,
0.21534669399261475,
0.7551540732383728,
-0.14318984746932983,
0.4465264678001404,
-0.08376838266849518,
-0.29967236518859863,
0.5161183476448059,
0.39914944767951965,
0.4690566956996918,
-0.21686503291130066,
-0.1893182396888733,
0.03220614045858383,
0.12264621257781982,
-0.24486616253852844,
-0.5733187794685364,
0.5866180062294006,
-0.7170426249504089,
-0.6694279909133911,
-0.7905905842781067,
-0.579035758972168,
-0.13854029774665833,
0.006788991391658783,
0.2231244295835495,
0.37540897727012634,
-0.07615580409765244,
-0.10498525202274323,
1.1896135807037354,
-0.26218098402023315,
0.20013003051280975,
0.9137815237045288,
-0.47833436727523804,
-0.06444200128316879,
1.1921603679656982,
0.17484036087989807,
0.4034753739833832,
0.24587568640708923,
0.15575233101844788,
-0.4907011091709137,
-0.6504759788513184,
-0.11665043979883194,
0.1958315670490265,
-0.942928671836853,
-0.5115019083023071,
-0.40331870317459106,
-0.10315687954425812,
-0.08385919034481049,
0.1203293427824974,
-0.3329957127571106,
0.0058443485759198666,
-0.18395587801933289,
0.2597883641719818,
0.66620272397995,
1.114255666732788,
-0.19261343777179718,
-0.18213550746440887,
-0.9566524624824524,
0.25514212250709534,
0.34336838126182556,
0.2734730839729309,
0.15763898193836212,
-0.7114930152893066,
-0.35122573375701904,
-0.032779570668935776,
-0.3379502296447754,
-1.0225012302398682,
0.22670018672943115,
-0.21955673396587372,
0.5209459662437439,
0.40302857756614685,
0.42077356576919556,
0.8165640830993652,
-0.20174133777618408,
0.6246098875999451,
0.030203986912965775,
-0.7245681285858154,
0.3428322672843933,
-0.038677509874105453,
-0.025909190997481346,
0.39518341422080994,
0.35581523180007935,
-0.6007660031318665,
-0.385337769985199,
-0.6205853223800659,
-0.9048061370849609,
0.6475787162780762,
-0.06296659260988235,
-0.250715434551239,
-0.23069612681865692,
0.37910863757133484,
-0.06496690213680267,
0.21997101604938507,
-0.3714469373226166,
-0.3514117896556854,
0.03971079736948013,
0.02410263940691948,
0.5805439352989197,
-0.5914663076400757,
-0.575450599193573,
-0.01321287453174591,
0.6562987565994263,
0.32205381989479065,
0.23482771217823029,
0.21830347180366516,
-0.40152597427368164,
-0.4199415147304535,
0.3343520760536194,
0.5590091943740845,
0.617141604423523,
-0.20773179829120636,
0.41831907629966736,
0.08384931087493896,
-0.24092578887939453,
0.22986933588981628,
0.03495223820209503,
-0.033200960606336594,
0.10253626108169556,
0.16940301656723022,
0.6357659101486206,
0.2634201645851135,
-0.8313606977462769,
0.5323044061660767,
-0.19934691488742828,
-0.24322113394737244,
-0.00544398557394743,
-0.22435012459754944,
0.22316999733448029,
0.5581654906272888,
0.47704753279685974,
0.30797746777534485,
-0.10266773402690887,
-0.41311803460121155,
0.2916809916496277,
0.6619316935539246,
-0.19080321490764618,
0.05210834741592407,
0.26977044343948364,
-0.012655581347644329,
-0.029665226116776466,
0.6665229201316833,
-0.512607216835022,
-0.7598868608474731,
0.33309316635131836,
0.46211642026901245,
0.31891560554504395,
-0.1897893249988556,
0.05302863568067551,
0.338957816362381,
0.20849792659282684,
-0.21398678421974182,
0.1495494544506073,
-0.0025955107994377613,
-0.8588636517524719,
-0.36936846375465393,
-0.24653911590576172,
-0.43953901529312134,
0.10722191631793976,
-1.0780584812164307,
-0.158666729927063,
-0.1738613247871399,
-0.2124827802181244,
-0.5575720071792603,
0.31110715866088867,
-0.5109167098999023,
-0.13711610436439514,
0.025176873430609703,
0.8629342317581177,
-0.47817549109458923,
0.9494309425354004,
0.5489691495895386,
-0.48803114891052246,
-0.38613685965538025,
-0.07116647064685822,
0.08223743736743927,
-0.6873661279678345,
1.060817003250122,
-0.4078797399997711,
-0.1600586473941803,
-0.34113287925720215,
-0.2743075489997864,
-1.0110434293746948,
1.034780740737915,
0.37458330392837524,
-0.5500394105911255,
0.07107795774936676,
-0.21283555030822754,
0.32939982414245605,
-0.06836147606372833,
0.12737324833869934,
0.5140259265899658,
0.7027491331100464,
0.09858135879039764,
-0.8232085108757019,
-0.07142356038093567,
-0.08387311547994614,
-0.05834748595952988,
0.26199138164520264,
-0.6899317502975464,
0.8107607960700989,
-0.3187752664089203,
-0.4275023937225342,
0.007260057143867016,
0.6890406012535095,
0.26685667037963867,
0.373229056596756,
0.4316721558570862,
0.6564815640449524,
0.6640595197677612,
-0.21977999806404114,
0.7327855825424194,
-0.268301784992218,
0.39644813537597656,
1.1567929983139038,
-0.5673592686653137,
0.8104804754257202,
0.5963721871376038,
-0.3489983081817627,
0.6681345105171204,
0.41267824172973633,
0.25223222374916077,
0.5705708265304565,
0.011388924904167652,
-0.4054104685783386,
-0.07328002154827118,
-0.018853504210710526,
-0.6879836320877075,
0.16922542452812195,
0.5943523645401001,
-0.05071451514959335,
-0.5352102518081665,
0.0031086206436157227,
-0.09631174802780151,
0.4172987937927246,
0.031068751588463783,
0.8713086247444153,
-0.08266942203044891,
-0.5623539090156555,
0.48279982805252075,
-0.08278573304414749,
0.7084975838661194,
-0.8422261476516724,
-0.0850016325712204,
-0.05289739370346069,
0.1034947857260704,
-0.22391025722026825,
-0.7914230227470398,
0.3632788360118866,
-0.19077208638191223,
-0.3518220782279968,
0.0028205246198922396,
0.9107349514961243,
-0.838875412940979,
0.017650583758950233,
0.73521888256073,
0.6598396301269531,
-0.13716506958007812,
0.04440789669752121,
-0.750796377658844,
0.5790473222732544,
-0.13962766528129578,
-0.1781797707080841,
0.939740002155304,
0.4915134310722351,
0.12091059982776642,
0.6189506649971008,
0.471818208694458,
0.10386737436056137,
0.05101389437913895,
-0.03985024243593216,
1.0209892988204956,
-0.3495194911956787,
-0.057914894074201584,
-0.7267833948135376,
0.4313738942146301,
0.0604674331843853,
0.08190065622329712,
0.8161839246749878,
0.4441176950931549,
0.5724812746047974,
0.14183461666107178,
0.7992542386054993,
-0.29908889532089233,
0.6211336851119995,
-0.5825479626655579,
0.7502118945121765,
-0.5195345282554626,
0.2536826729774475,
-0.11005465686321259,
-0.36818942427635193,
0.04142128676176071,
0.8085286021232605,
-0.367609441280365,
0.05854784697294235,
0.7048161029815674,
0.48265737295150757,
0.03805481642484665,
0.03828311711549759,
0.15632686018943787,
0.2307683676481247,
0.19087985157966614,
0.6471525430679321,
1.105925440788269,
-0.5361641645431519,
0.5478812456130981,
-0.345792680978775,
-0.04191027954220772,
-0.13866904377937317,
-0.9246422052383423,
-0.5840225219726562,
-0.8958924412727356,
-0.39084720611572266,
-0.5302870273590088,
0.18093344569206238,
0.8609405755996704,
0.4256972670555115,
-0.5068866014480591,
-0.23488199710845947,
0.3276411294937134,
0.5219981074333191,
-0.2913190722465515,
-0.22864952683448792,
0.31550297141075134,
-0.5451023578643799,
-0.3701549172401428,
0.36372044682502747,
0.14202651381492615,
0.030226457864046097,
-0.05675116926431656,
-0.40712690353393555,
-0.4619961678981781,
-0.04822460934519768,
0.5664481520652771,
0.5643552541732788,
-0.8762043714523315,
-0.2476278841495514,
-0.14422765374183655,
0.005378481931984425,
-0.0007002949714660645,
1.1014190912246704,
-0.8708531260490417,
0.8326751589775085,
0.24360986053943634,
0.7248556017875671,
0.42933887243270874,
-0.007125436328351498,
0.4209177494049072,
-0.6497106552124023,
0.07297780364751816,
0.33472055196762085,
0.30221471190452576,
0.26195380091667175,
-0.20880834758281708,
0.23383112251758575,
-0.02060382254421711,
-0.7052545547485352,
-0.9794155359268188,
0.22931015491485596,
-0.7054957151412964,
-0.42657485604286194,
1.0195209980010986,
-0.16360338032245636,
0.3202671408653259,
-0.2879250645637512,
-0.4382190704345703,
0.21423223614692688,
-0.2621989846229553,
0.9634903073310852,
0.938397228717804,
-0.21406233310699463,
-0.04536738246679306,
-0.44947710633277893,
0.7703016400337219,
0.42789703607559204,
-0.33582037687301636,
0.2657141089439392,
0.35221317410469055,
0.24183006584644318,
0.3806316554546356,
0.459005206823349,
-0.22814759612083435,
0.16518501937389374,
-0.10433776676654816,
-0.264458030462265,
-0.12479002773761749,
-0.19276058673858643,
-0.4785324037075043,
0.05327335745096207,
0.2655890882015228,
0.11979718506336212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14408v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14408v1
|
Transferring BERT Capabilities from High-Resource to Low-Resource Languages Using Vocabulary Matching
| 2024-02-22T09:49:26 | 2024-02-22T09:49:26 |
Piotr Rybak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models have revolutionized the natural language
understanding landscape, most notably BERT (Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers). However, a significant challenge remains
for low-resource languages, where limited data hinders the effective training
of such models. This work presents a novel approach to bridge this gap by
transferring BERT capabilities from high-resource to low-resource languages
using vocabulary matching. We conduct experiments on the Silesian and Kashubian
languages and demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach to improve the
performance of BERT models even when the target language has minimal training
data. Our results highlight the potential of the proposed technique to
effectively train BERT models for low-resource languages, thus democratizing
access to advanced language understanding models.
|
[
-0.5039209127426147,
-0.31722795963287354,
0.2904246151447296,
0.185367614030838,
-0.29921451210975647,
0.2368720918893814,
-0.6042866706848145,
-0.4786841571331024,
0.13603997230529785,
0.6378445029258728,
-0.5063376426696777,
-0.042503297328948975,
-0.5424095392227173,
-0.01928078755736351,
-0.3213256597518921,
0.7469398975372314,
-0.09924791008234024,
-0.015167728066444397,
-0.08062176406383514,
-0.11531458795070648,
-0.38776347041130066,
-0.5173513293266296,
-0.42761966586112976,
-0.4723832607269287,
0.4796334207057953,
0.37719255685806274,
0.8500657677650452,
0.4388202428817749,
0.5927047729492188,
0.2694424092769623,
-0.043605536222457886,
0.1972234845161438,
-0.540272057056427,
-0.07926195114850998,
-0.13685280084609985,
-0.3367937505245209,
-0.04708346351981163,
-0.16627104580402374,
0.738106906414032,
1.007284164428711,
0.02074371837079525,
0.11178002506494522,
0.29342424869537354,
0.7237970232963562,
-0.5869432091712952,
0.07514313608407974,
-0.9462186098098755,
0.05795392021536827,
-0.22530049085617065,
-0.08722365647554398,
-0.4919660985469818,
-0.31359726190567017,
0.42086145281791687,
-0.7036917209625244,
0.3335270881652832,
-0.2167891263961792,
1.2230663299560547,
0.15160416066646576,
-0.14491963386535645,
-0.32587307691574097,
-0.7706327438354492,
0.661509096622467,
-0.7043498158454895,
0.3965577483177185,
0.48758310079574585,
0.2944553792476654,
0.11212348937988281,
-0.49890759587287903,
-0.722267210483551,
-0.19232361018657684,
-0.33782774209976196,
0.008881346322596073,
-0.12206202000379562,
0.045115772634744644,
-0.05167524516582489,
0.1448839008808136,
-0.35275566577911377,
0.3417087197303772,
-0.41870591044425964,
-0.30052900314331055,
0.22299820184707642,
-0.37296533584594727,
0.1799137145280838,
-0.35105928778648376,
-0.40448206663131714,
-0.45426344871520996,
-0.33546674251556396,
-0.07195296138525009,
0.35415172576904297,
0.8381045460700989,
-0.08760539442300797,
0.370479941368103,
0.11067312210798264,
0.8776233792304993,
-0.08742610365152359,
0.20751707255840302,
0.26925939321517944,
-0.6363890767097473,
-0.1814248114824295,
0.13386884331703186,
0.2670642137527466,
-0.12383516877889633,
0.36043182015419006,
-0.28171491622924805,
-0.17738094925880432,
-0.1793319582939148,
0.22494366765022278,
-0.49993348121643066,
-0.3418103754520416,
-0.3821592330932617,
-0.5581028461456299,
-0.1414276510477066,
-0.3183428943157196,
-0.7314965724945068,
-0.18075701594352722,
-0.23616749048233032,
0.7178677320480347,
-0.7111088633537292,
-0.23488816618919373,
0.15037035942077637,
-0.10641809552907944,
0.516775906085968,
0.30915847420692444,
-1.1144649982452393,
0.26300209760665894,
0.5215213894844055,
0.9333450794219971,
0.2718115448951721,
-0.06300891935825348,
-0.34046313166618347,
0.14107763767242432,
-0.3939305245876312,
0.6124355792999268,
-0.5260641574859619,
-0.14893165230751038,
0.15119707584381104,
-0.2237783521413803,
-0.1489737629890442,
-0.5024989247322083,
0.41668379306793213,
-0.6852822303771973,
-0.0278365109115839,
-0.22136934101581573,
-0.40015649795532227,
-0.22741585969924927,
0.17954164743423462,
-0.6911802887916565,
0.9464418292045593,
0.33758142590522766,
-0.540672779083252,
0.1762034147977829,
-0.766173779964447,
-0.6019019484519958,
0.23130591213703156,
0.3761591613292694,
-0.023595498874783516,
0.1298527717590332,
0.30032122135162354,
0.19430629909038544,
-0.0035439380444586277,
-0.2953518033027649,
-0.18301330506801605,
-0.28404539823532104,
-0.01700345240533352,
-0.43889743089675903,
0.8460671901702881,
0.30993330478668213,
0.1919543594121933,
-0.16950426995754242,
-0.5017843842506409,
0.14057713747024536,
0.06560080498456955,
-0.41239845752716064,
-0.691694974899292,
-0.08619385957717896,
0.377662718296051,
0.26011624932289124,
0.7199723124504089,
-0.4758991003036499,
0.11914103478193283,
-0.5896366834640503,
0.4231621325016022,
0.8588082790374756,
-0.6062623858451843,
0.845740556716919,
-0.14116159081459045,
0.33267927169799805,
-0.10947468131780624,
-0.005258776713162661,
0.08414346724748611,
-0.19829000532627106,
-0.9447915554046631,
-0.3464977443218231,
0.7722247242927551,
0.5390740036964417,
-1.0817954540252686,
0.6192941665649414,
-0.513692319393158,
-0.5042914152145386,
-1.1905715465545654,
0.4166492819786072,
0.2724026143550873,
0.547017514705658,
0.418123334646225,
-0.4605652391910553,
-0.5991966128349304,
-1.1226527690887451,
0.017856469377875328,
-0.24552570283412933,
-0.1911660134792328,
0.5530083775520325,
0.04667479172348976,
-0.08898650109767914,
0.7910041809082031,
-0.08366754651069641,
-0.3638588488101959,
-0.49168893694877625,
0.1686604619026184,
0.37419593334198,
0.56269770860672,
0.6921048760414124,
-0.6475269198417664,
-0.7037619352340698,
0.20308971405029297,
-0.4120023846626282,
-0.0704423114657402,
-0.06820324063301086,
-0.5222246646881104,
0.13534939289093018,
0.37592220306396484,
-0.27785542607307434,
-0.06462511420249939,
0.9035513997077942,
-0.2210376262664795,
0.1962430775165558,
-0.47688722610473633,
0.11406518518924713,
-1.1161715984344482,
0.09022433310747147,
-0.376287043094635,
-0.17495015263557434,
-0.7801351547241211,
0.0035954932682216167,
0.02753656730055809,
-0.23644547164440155,
-0.5051543712615967,
0.5013598203659058,
-0.3753751516342163,
-0.24791423976421356,
-0.13283437490463257,
0.3909474313259125,
-0.2545826733112335,
0.3890524208545685,
0.09277541935443878,
0.9367212653160095,
0.6226933598518372,
-0.5495826005935669,
0.15044541656970978,
0.5659775137901306,
-0.5273013710975647,
0.372063547372818,
-0.4158576428890228,
0.10916838049888611,
-0.24137070775032043,
-0.04755760356783867,
-0.879085898399353,
-0.16351382434368134,
-0.01727432943880558,
-0.499815970659256,
0.17906241118907928,
-0.3796406388282776,
-0.7741483449935913,
-0.29178011417388916,
0.011436443775892258,
0.27540653944015503,
1.0037038326263428,
-0.6531077027320862,
0.8482362031936646,
0.118924580514431,
-0.3217061161994934,
-0.5160884261131287,
-0.6909174919128418,
0.01918850652873516,
0.0020877441857010126,
-0.5868119597434998,
0.5133968591690063,
0.2213420867919922,
0.09462669491767883,
0.14395569264888763,
0.17663823068141937,
-0.46770378947257996,
0.21419118344783783,
-0.2979232370853424,
0.3394191563129425,
-0.2490488439798355,
0.4234040379524231,
-0.09727636724710464,
0.08400338143110275,
-0.3752920925617218,
-0.27054065465927124,
0.899322509765625,
0.03259071335196495,
-0.436271995306015,
-0.3408632278442383,
0.2994005084037781,
0.42609718441963196,
-0.4550705552101135,
0.8781278729438782,
0.7428109049797058,
-0.36447104811668396,
-0.11029347777366638,
-0.4271899461746216,
-0.289064884185791,
-0.48711496591567993,
0.4989112615585327,
-0.2710968554019928,
-0.7770479917526245,
0.37248775362968445,
-0.06620980054140091,
0.14820657670497894,
0.21786180138587952,
0.5799096822738647,
-0.3817964494228363,
0.7393374443054199,
0.9803874492645264,
-0.4032652676105499,
0.7425148487091064,
0.07441400736570358,
0.39651229977607727,
-0.6387667059898376,
0.07985605299472809,
-0.5705240368843079,
-0.59715735912323,
-0.6811162233352661,
-0.5169975757598877,
0.20420369505882263,
0.20091471076011658,
0.032589301466941833,
0.8422332406044006,
-0.31679490208625793,
0.38905543088912964,
0.8412067890167236,
0.12301577627658844,
0.13423970341682434,
0.2616105377674103,
-0.05590394139289856,
0.001966743962839246,
-0.9531646370887756,
-0.49145832657814026,
0.8920117020606995,
0.15241111814975739,
0.5837081074714661,
0.18795402348041534,
0.8521022200584412,
0.24921977519989014,
0.18873879313468933,
-0.8011482954025269,
0.5787595510482788,
-0.6397112607955933,
-0.49006137251853943,
-0.46317487955093384,
-0.3789026141166687,
-1.0143697261810303,
0.3047906160354614,
-0.3398953974246979,
-0.44907039403915405,
0.20035213232040405,
0.12901867926120758,
-0.2936166226863861,
0.41290897130966187,
-0.855251133441925,
0.6559934020042419,
-0.12628823518753052,
-0.029406722635030746,
-0.6012551188468933,
-0.49396657943725586,
0.12435067445039749,
-0.31762105226516724,
0.258137583732605,
-0.19045981764793396,
0.13554342091083527,
0.8184537291526794,
-0.16401109099388123,
0.6727473139762878,
-0.28275424242019653,
-0.19438894093036652,
0.02213204652070999,
0.170958012342453,
0.2553059160709381,
-0.29843294620513916,
-0.25146904587745667,
0.1580015867948532,
-0.14591719210147858,
-0.8520019054412842,
-0.5120050311088562,
0.4700268507003784,
-0.786841630935669,
-0.34717094898223877,
-0.05716154724359512,
-0.7993332743644714,
-0.368900328874588,
0.20310860872268677,
0.04623289406299591,
0.0001323317555943504,
-0.0607941672205925,
0.22002124786376953,
0.5705253481864929,
-0.11296889930963516,
0.5875388979911804,
0.5485647320747375,
0.325954407453537,
-0.06839817017316818,
0.7873309254646301,
-0.010865719988942146,
0.38574883341789246,
0.3435417115688324,
-0.20555703341960907,
-0.21438060700893402,
-0.41593635082244873,
-0.23493319749832153,
0.14827434718608856,
-0.6067425608634949,
-0.2291477769613266,
-0.2929648756980896,
-0.3464279770851135,
-0.1488199532032013,
-0.4352807402610779,
-0.47411322593688965,
-0.22615258395671844,
-0.2469319850206375,
0.36040809750556946,
0.3595045506954193,
0.4263293147087097,
-0.4108029901981354,
0.43057459592819214,
-1.1121491193771362,
0.052835796028375626,
0.6030445098876953,
0.42464548349380493,
0.17161594331264496,
-0.7891175150871277,
-0.43384069204330444,
0.18918584287166595,
0.0013332772068679333,
-0.6128177642822266,
0.3860940635204315,
0.5118329524993896,
0.531154990196228,
0.12016897648572922,
0.05320262163877487,
0.8618225455284119,
-0.6771365404129028,
0.6178496479988098,
0.10478156059980392,
-1.1833252906799316,
0.5838010311126709,
-0.007721637841314077,
0.08032820373773575,
0.7106627821922302,
0.38291430473327637,
-0.6377153992652893,
-0.20418618619441986,
-0.38406801223754883,
-0.719795823097229,
0.7745091319084167,
0.3697386682033539,
0.4750959277153015,
0.08489248156547546,
0.06675106287002563,
0.053720247000455856,
-0.02957751415669918,
-0.4459910988807678,
0.28747937083244324,
-0.13461355865001678,
-0.5163997411727905,
-0.1868939846754074,
0.08046858012676239,
-0.04798085242509842,
-0.23257330060005188,
0.5268850326538086,
-0.08141832798719406,
0.5425942540168762,
-0.02155807614326477,
-0.4797412157058716,
0.024993527680635452,
0.2665916979312897,
0.17505452036857605,
0.37084171175956726,
-0.20665782690048218,
0.18085068464279175,
0.3602631688117981,
-0.4040834903717041,
0.04713037237524986,
0.4149966835975647,
0.06441742181777954,
0.09484448283910751,
0.6175870299339294,
0.5796173810958862,
0.3772607147693634,
-0.8558065891265869,
0.36298736929893494,
0.23757976293563843,
-0.13898956775665283,
0.10384584963321686,
-0.04693282023072243,
0.12502211332321167,
0.3363664746284485,
0.2831728458404541,
0.12393253296613693,
-0.15024283528327942,
-0.5622590184211731,
0.22761254012584686,
0.6071158647537231,
-0.34999555349349976,
-0.3026106655597687,
0.19025561213493347,
0.3241744041442871,
-0.221034973859787,
0.9936103820800781,
-0.04745835065841675,
-0.696704089641571,
0.5516810417175293,
0.4990120530128479,
0.5461131930351257,
-0.14837948977947235,
0.21662524342536926,
0.28505757451057434,
0.2938864827156067,
0.048424262553453445,
0.310635507106781,
-0.3043501675128937,
-1.045959234237671,
-0.5683126449584961,
-0.7314313650131226,
-0.38107621669769287,
-0.013993312604725361,
-0.8887181282043457,
0.1848413050174713,
-0.18175165355205536,
-0.0952601283788681,
0.013506392017006874,
-0.14193600416183472,
-0.9800172448158264,
-0.37457388639450073,
0.43837714195251465,
0.9969797730445862,
-0.8700208067893982,
1.0992544889450073,
0.6144204139709473,
-0.3382778763771057,
-0.4883681833744049,
0.09541244059801102,
-0.6387544274330139,
-1.250253438949585,
1.0262092351913452,
-0.18062637746334076,
-0.10325147211551666,
0.26655876636505127,
-0.49045082926750183,
-0.8494881391525269,
0.6977837681770325,
0.4060888886451721,
-0.5294474959373474,
-0.19303223490715027,
-0.14082227647304535,
0.6758394837379456,
-0.0644240751862526,
-0.21708297729492188,
0.6038219332695007,
0.4908282458782196,
-0.012935967184603214,
-1.266616702079773,
-0.2751449942588806,
-0.07623662054538727,
0.13918055593967438,
0.31381651759147644,
-0.34587669372558594,
0.8078830242156982,
-0.14322000741958618,
-0.37095320224761963,
0.23588760197162628,
0.7635005116462708,
-0.09460271149873734,
-0.37929534912109375,
0.7038917541503906,
0.45970669388771057,
0.7015554308891296,
-0.1583137810230255,
0.4952774941921234,
-0.502558708190918,
0.5270384550094604,
0.7883210778236389,
-0.38472139835357666,
1.2236762046813965,
0.5844667553901672,
-0.280822217464447,
0.5904987454414368,
0.4097650647163391,
-0.0638481006026268,
1.054196834564209,
0.0425974577665329,
-0.4072558581829071,
-0.6208189725875854,
-0.2971738278865814,
-0.25815579295158386,
0.6130982041358948,
0.37843841314315796,
-0.16516831517219543,
-0.5291512608528137,
0.2855713665485382,
-0.26844310760498047,
0.27754101157188416,
-0.34413671493530273,
0.9275286793708801,
-0.42507725954055786,
-0.3085494041442871,
0.8904064297676086,
-0.16338440775871277,
0.9825575351715088,
-0.7564664483070374,
-0.026123860850930214,
-0.15050530433654785,
0.07376223057508469,
0.22254326939582825,
-0.89024418592453,
0.3346901535987854,
0.010498951189219952,
-0.027844402939081192,
-0.5173911452293396,
0.7872380614280701,
-0.5738058090209961,
-0.341799795627594,
0.5124920606613159,
0.6769540905952454,
0.05390078201889992,
0.46429118514060974,
-0.5524981617927551,
-0.30837681889533997,
-0.21277332305908203,
0.4282849133014679,
0.3704562783241272,
0.4386851191520691,
0.362644225358963,
0.5062673091888428,
0.5929161906242371,
0.2421715259552002,
-0.03919016569852829,
0.07220787554979324,
0.7786968350410461,
-0.41733992099761963,
-0.5165387392044067,
-0.6066966652870178,
0.09779183566570282,
-0.00660708686336875,
-0.016932735219597816,
0.49433788657188416,
0.24830789864063263,
0.9965218305587769,
-0.35923218727111816,
0.8058352470397949,
-0.2529186010360718,
0.501775860786438,
-0.4075031876564026,
0.8959972858428955,
-0.4116540253162384,
-0.17262251675128937,
0.029406346380710602,
-0.7279139161109924,
0.017086688429117203,
0.8486752510070801,
-0.19060802459716797,
-0.155821293592453,
0.18373772501945496,
0.5343807339668274,
-0.22589127719402313,
-0.3893016278743744,
0.3450431823730469,
0.18426039814949036,
0.042009904980659485,
0.8457689881324768,
0.6026453971862793,
-0.21212689578533173,
0.7106700539588928,
-0.29683592915534973,
-0.31626686453819275,
-0.3258839249610901,
-0.7058719396591187,
-0.9303252696990967,
-0.6846390962600708,
0.14494873583316803,
-0.22211924195289612,
0.22997593879699707,
1.087093472480774,
0.8423503637313843,
-0.7854922413825989,
-0.19511853158473969,
-0.01897371932864189,
0.060707394033670425,
-0.3973306715488434,
-0.2061934769153595,
0.3662169277667999,
-0.6632765531539917,
-0.8222494125366211,
0.3923312723636627,
0.05219721049070358,
0.23209314048290253,
-0.32204633951187134,
0.012810727581381798,
-0.35927870869636536,
0.298298716545105,
0.7852962017059326,
0.26889532804489136,
-0.6897931098937988,
-0.4624742567539215,
0.07998805493116379,
-0.17651009559631348,
0.05424725264310837,
0.6382538676261902,
-1.0891165733337402,
0.5339666604995728,
0.6305825114250183,
1.123690128326416,
0.2872859835624695,
-0.2565951645374298,
0.5412144660949707,
-1.0326753854751587,
0.35976868867874146,
0.3543490469455719,
0.3155399560928345,
0.5508955717086792,
-0.1542900800704956,
0.28701451420783997,
0.017363041639328003,
-0.04311539605259895,
-0.8804941773414612,
0.3707561790943146,
-0.8457661271095276,
-0.15542355179786682,
0.7090592980384827,
-0.06479520350694656,
0.009138965979218483,
-0.09889388829469681,
-0.06758459657430649,
0.4146689772605896,
-0.07509837299585342,
0.8903472423553467,
0.9963551759719849,
0.13746829330921173,
-0.15302389860153198,
-0.4752543866634369,
0.4298439025878906,
0.5464522242546082,
-0.6280532479286194,
0.21756090223789215,
-0.06734359264373779,
0.0547325424849987,
0.3205057382583618,
0.37919697165489197,
0.08065062761306763,
0.1808643639087677,
-0.13592346012592316,
0.16072696447372437,
0.18360799551010132,
-0.05639592185616493,
-0.2936060428619385,
-0.1002468690276146,
0.1109791249036789,
-0.34809353947639465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14404v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14404v2
|
On the Tip of the Tongue: Analyzing Conceptual Representation in Large Language Models with Reverse-Dictionary Probe
| 2024-02-22T09:45:26 | 2024-02-26T11:40:45 |
Ningyu Xu, Qi Zhang, Menghan Zhang, Peng Qian, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Probing and enhancing large language models' reasoning capacity remains a
crucial open question. Here we re-purpose the reverse dictionary task as a case
study to probe LLMs' capacity for conceptual inference. We use in-context
learning to guide the models to generate the term for an object concept implied
in a linguistic description. Models robustly achieve high accuracy in this
task, and their representation space encodes information about object
categories and fine-grained features. Further experiments suggest that the
conceptual inference ability as probed by the reverse-dictionary task predicts
model's general reasoning performance across multiple benchmarks, despite
similar syntactic generalization behaviors across models. Explorative analyses
suggest that prompting LLMs with description$\Rightarrow$word examples may
induce generalization beyond surface-level differences in task construals and
facilitate models on broader commonsense reasoning problems.
|
[
-0.429785817861557,
-0.8089835047721863,
0.842180609703064,
-0.1593027114868164,
-0.3067907989025116,
-0.5177478194236755,
-0.22437317669391632,
-0.18622161448001862,
0.3615057170391083,
0.5987844467163086,
-0.5294593572616577,
-0.23280180990695953,
-0.5432678461074829,
0.24415338039398193,
-0.7562875747680664,
0.6661511063575745,
0.06701722741127014,
-0.003764017019420862,
-0.669003427028656,
0.12824344635009766,
-0.4600655138492584,
-0.38752782344818115,
-0.5336419939994812,
-0.5455281138420105,
0.35714244842529297,
0.5280476808547974,
0.5975451469421387,
0.5276263952255249,
0.008571356534957886,
0.26291775703430176,
-0.020306702703237534,
0.16341735422611237,
-0.6031934022903442,
0.19361823797225952,
-0.5532243251800537,
-0.7293568849563599,
-0.29349038004875183,
0.2432328760623932,
0.6114878058433533,
0.8717886805534363,
-0.1404489278793335,
0.0323108546435833,
-0.21687421202659607,
0.24555832147598267,
-0.5411157608032227,
-0.06316577643156052,
-1.0744680166244507,
-0.29184311628341675,
0.06537386029958725,
0.05976065993309021,
-0.33794838190078735,
0.22748436033725739,
0.3840159773826599,
-0.7786412835121155,
0.2074228674173355,
0.006938367150723934,
1.0089623928070068,
0.1968400776386261,
-0.48712214827537537,
-0.1833156794309616,
-0.34701088070869446,
0.8244866132736206,
-0.6480261087417603,
0.7001221179962158,
0.5287609696388245,
0.2133665382862091,
-0.11954428255558014,
-0.841014564037323,
-0.9410951733589172,
-0.4205501973628998,
-0.1219809502363205,
0.027962621301412582,
0.058886460959911346,
-0.16762124001979828,
0.20815818011760712,
0.11753236502408981,
-0.10333932936191559,
0.10080032795667648,
-0.12353763729333878,
0.06213587895035744,
0.6059024930000305,
0.19626997411251068,
0.011348426342010498,
-0.2341628223657608,
-0.3022923171520233,
-0.0042528980411589146,
-0.8530175089836121,
-0.27353692054748535,
-0.10408604890108109,
0.23331470787525177,
-0.1464434266090393,
0.8132078051567078,
-0.32893165946006775,
0.5987729430198669,
-0.002619045088067651,
0.18104992806911469,
-0.005677786190062761,
-0.35900917649269104,
-0.5434405207633972,
-0.10492737591266632,
0.3204677999019623,
0.49416521191596985,
0.6361031532287598,
-0.1624792218208313,
-0.36406561732292175,
-0.08781218528747559,
0.44924256205558777,
-0.6728104948997498,
-0.04802241921424866,
0.29214733839035034,
-0.29813680052757263,
-0.07009181380271912,
0.10443342477083206,
-0.30999937653541565,
-0.6175273060798645,
-0.4893391728401184,
0.4467550814151764,
-0.3198041021823883,
-0.5448598861694336,
0.27149301767349243,
-0.4001259207725525,
0.2344512790441513,
0.24545986950397491,
-0.8124865889549255,
0.21450048685073853,
0.9269587397575378,
0.7849732041358948,
-0.05339260771870613,
-0.40789443254470825,
-0.32013726234436035,
0.3680247664451599,
-0.5709459185600281,
0.6379541754722595,
-0.603860080242157,
-0.5025985240936279,
-0.12845228612422943,
0.07216842472553253,
0.08459723740816116,
-0.6729042530059814,
0.20843397080898285,
-0.4041323959827423,
-0.17159156501293182,
-0.4516991674900055,
-0.597874641418457,
-0.23705898225307465,
0.4953679144382477,
-0.45565950870513916,
0.7784778475761414,
-0.0005328003317117691,
-0.6518828272819519,
0.5942638516426086,
-0.45195627212524414,
-0.2556129992008209,
-0.031341295689344406,
-0.46019527316093445,
-0.011820724233984947,
0.6009198427200317,
0.25937387347221375,
0.9667272567749023,
-0.5627217292785645,
0.33041101694107056,
-0.4060773253440857,
-0.2832639217376709,
0.37378597259521484,
-0.1824498176574707,
0.568733811378479,
0.0037039185408502817,
-0.03354138880968094,
-0.040705274790525436,
-0.6057706475257874,
-0.44993913173675537,
0.3989384174346924,
-0.15938638150691986,
-0.8997507095336914,
0.013314017094671726,
-0.4158911108970642,
-0.18129077553749084,
0.05016244202852249,
-0.5506106019020081,
0.11422865837812424,
-0.7137115597724915,
0.587719738483429,
0.47280874848365784,
-0.053555745631456375,
0.5141599774360657,
-0.09535708278417587,
0.25696492195129395,
0.22514231503009796,
-0.2557123899459839,
0.05121169239282608,
-0.5118842720985413,
-0.74256432056427,
-0.12011465430259705,
0.14752449095249176,
0.36476704478263855,
-0.7759900689125061,
0.11306193470954895,
-0.634017825126648,
-0.2870996296405792,
-0.2636744976043701,
0.029240917414426804,
0.34179845452308655,
0.7877399325370789,
0.31692928075790405,
-0.23221006989479065,
-0.2046085149049759,
-1.0637871026992798,
-0.3064071238040924,
-0.29451924562454224,
-0.14875546097755432,
0.3397049903869629,
0.8784645795822144,
-0.30530494451522827,
1.2345362901687622,
-0.4165858030319214,
-0.11337023973464966,
-0.3139466643333435,
-0.002690891269594431,
0.3395293653011322,
0.27301374077796936,
0.2929856777191162,
-0.978280782699585,
0.06779736280441284,
-0.012711431831121445,
-0.49172964692115784,
-0.16646167635917664,
-0.15135931968688965,
-0.14104585349559784,
0.07911685854196548,
0.7406187057495117,
-0.8594932556152344,
0.1316288858652115,
0.07768142968416214,
-0.48802685737609863,
0.5665772557258606,
-0.2771633267402649,
-0.22074012458324432,
-0.9100212454795837,
-0.040822818875312805,
-0.025453856214880943,
-0.004606318194419146,
-0.6927695274353027,
0.2595990300178528,
0.18289728462696075,
0.24814288318157196,
-0.3337850868701935,
0.9206296801567078,
-0.42693135142326355,
-0.22227661311626434,
-0.07560105621814728,
0.4839431345462799,
0.09182196855545044,
-0.042914945632219315,
0.37042921781539917,
0.8890398740768433,
0.4322529137134552,
-0.7973798513412476,
0.41617894172668457,
-0.05097033083438873,
-0.2866716682910919,
0.7423468828201294,
-0.5551616549491882,
-0.01891544833779335,
-0.24555279314517975,
0.14296913146972656,
-1.3374285697937012,
-0.33138543367385864,
0.018476257100701332,
-0.43285006284713745,
0.3414071202278137,
0.004876598250120878,
-0.43434765934944153,
-0.2513754069805145,
-0.20206856727600098,
0.2891433537006378,
0.16916991770267487,
-0.4799014627933502,
0.8456366658210754,
0.2924259305000305,
0.18297480046749115,
-0.5493760108947754,
-1.1955976486206055,
-0.0038688674103468657,
-0.4300532341003418,
-0.5619718432426453,
0.17734166979789734,
0.5262665748596191,
-0.716757595539093,
-0.10332588106393814,
-0.28373831510543823,
0.04314422607421875,
0.3552777171134949,
0.10791138559579849,
0.09660191833972931,
-0.21563927829265594,
0.7142625451087952,
0.11588575690984726,
0.19874733686447144,
0.4655216932296753,
-0.3151163160800934,
0.5735625624656677,
-0.00795971043407917,
-0.24491043388843536,
0.08440747112035751,
-0.03917068988084793,
0.35894814133644104,
-0.024302532896399498,
0.6720126867294312,
0.13737769424915314,
-0.38953539729118347,
-0.32427167892456055,
-0.5862851142883301,
-0.4611465632915497,
-0.4132946729660034,
0.5378373861312866,
-0.9910380840301514,
-0.5374776124954224,
0.5772215723991394,
-0.0246932003647089,
-0.1741115301847458,
0.4062003791332245,
0.5157819986343384,
-0.10297561436891556,
0.5307501554489136,
0.2462824285030365,
0.03848157078027725,
0.05653643235564232,
-0.4947803318500519,
-0.013596247881650925,
-0.9523265361785889,
-0.1908816248178482,
-0.2870471477508545,
-0.12953583896160126,
-0.1430402398109436,
-0.6283490061759949,
0.20831623673439026,
0.2515043318271637,
-0.35503628849983215,
0.2182542085647583,
-0.22103345394134521,
0.4996599555015564,
0.4416481852531433,
0.11740344017744064,
0.3724140524864197,
-0.21865028142929077,
-0.43313950300216675,
0.3211216926574707,
-0.42978787422180176,
-0.5409508943557739,
1.1871695518493652,
0.42400026321411133,
0.6539661884307861,
0.014548252336680889,
0.7472782731056213,
-0.05607585981488228,
0.340554416179657,
-0.9388238191604614,
0.7917629480361938,
-0.2031129002571106,
-0.7021678686141968,
-0.5488520860671997,
-0.17701572179794312,
-0.7577633261680603,
0.5183175802230835,
0.01565600372850895,
-0.600323498249054,
-0.06409357488155365,
0.0900547206401825,
-0.2733965516090393,
0.0924428403377533,
-0.8500546813011169,
0.7978677749633789,
-0.0215228870511055,
-0.15571941435337067,
-0.47378259897232056,
-0.4523201882839203,
0.6908738017082214,
-0.015334470197558403,
0.2079954445362091,
0.07214321196079254,
-0.5924720764160156,
0.667427659034729,
-0.13164933025836945,
0.9441367387771606,
-0.23457832634449005,
-0.7144023776054382,
0.2474076747894287,
0.3789528012275696,
0.36510053277015686,
0.34834378957748413,
-0.017561590299010277,
-0.011549117043614388,
0.09518014639616013,
-0.12197955697774887,
-0.7731796503067017,
0.6966255903244019,
-0.393189013004303,
-1.0932466983795166,
0.013437728397548199,
-0.6881563067436218,
-0.5313785076141357,
0.07467672228813171,
0.03578820079565048,
0.3094291687011719,
-0.04291151091456413,
-0.07671448588371277,
0.6713807582855225,
-0.13483551144599915,
0.024713467806577682,
0.26002463698387146,
-0.3835568130016327,
0.08642297238111496,
0.7321844100952148,
0.1357761174440384,
0.5225419998168945,
0.5902188420295715,
0.4010665714740753,
-0.5636157989501953,
-0.4914000332355499,
-0.3894745111465454,
0.5449178814888,
-0.9662742614746094,
0.013033646158874035,
-0.42102015018463135,
0.2264748513698578,
-0.3689105808734894,
-0.04446825385093689,
-0.1707179993391037,
-0.6333821415901184,
-0.5063520073890686,
-0.15388719737529755,
0.4222944378852844,
0.6652575135231018,
0.1940208077430725,
0.2930048704147339,
-0.39091765880584717,
0.5515888929367065,
0.5399722456932068,
0.1310802549123764,
0.31824126839637756,
-0.7803884744644165,
0.09457606822252274,
0.11198807507753372,
0.018723566085100174,
-0.8199540376663208,
0.11835936456918716,
0.1945727914571762,
0.4555855095386505,
0.5469476580619812,
-0.10281548649072647,
0.619101881980896,
-0.33781886100769043,
0.8922284841537476,
-0.007408186327666044,
-0.8998578786849976,
0.39696526527404785,
-0.3205849528312683,
0.39754822850227356,
-0.004907875321805477,
0.4302384555339813,
-0.5950602293014526,
-0.4781866669654846,
-0.37190869450569153,
-0.4773848354816437,
0.44929105043411255,
-0.2813575565814972,
0.5518201589584351,
-0.3458363115787506,
0.549293041229248,
0.21632234752178192,
0.11724840104579926,
-0.4503328800201416,
0.1118093878030777,
-0.2681882977485657,
-0.03422832861542702,
-0.23045764863491058,
-0.28781259059906006,
-0.21294912695884705,
-0.3186001181602478,
0.49308866262435913,
-0.313588947057724,
0.23308253288269043,
0.314604252576828,
-0.12177923321723938,
0.19736804068088531,
0.24128206074237823,
0.6623371839523315,
0.8668181896209717,
-0.06484450399875641,
0.5574426651000977,
0.5367655754089355,
-0.4268961548805237,
-0.09942469000816345,
-0.06377188861370087,
0.16749346256256104,
-0.2432519793510437,
0.6682296395301819,
0.4502032399177551,
0.0903766080737114,
-0.7575021386146545,
0.4570828080177307,
0.17841525375843048,
-0.21316851675510406,
-0.18525037169456482,
0.003323332406580448,
0.6939361095428467,
0.3256703019142151,
0.46340295672416687,
-0.6548228859901428,
0.03626907244324684,
-0.7396690249443054,
0.05619126930832863,
0.823997974395752,
-0.008008776232600212,
-0.11297295987606049,
0.4904806911945343,
0.014796051196753979,
0.21543288230895996,
0.6787983179092407,
-0.1321648210287094,
-0.52796471118927,
0.6896787285804749,
0.5334553122520447,
0.5511172413825989,
0.07761524617671967,
-0.0076080868020653725,
0.11488532274961472,
0.16413089632987976,
-0.07322300970554352,
0.42231476306915283,
-0.20737825334072113,
-1.2158575057983398,
-0.41574934124946594,
-0.3860103487968445,
-0.10830859839916229,
0.2099163681268692,
-0.3276115953922272,
0.24984805285930634,
-0.2165793776512146,
-0.13330532610416412,
-0.0751764103770256,
-0.29459649324417114,
-0.4810614287853241,
0.41889140009880066,
0.17968659102916718,
1.258581280708313,
-0.7122954726219177,
0.8883814215660095,
0.7964882850646973,
-0.43583545088768005,
-0.5928703546524048,
-0.031217075884342194,
-0.08089467883110046,
-1.0553327798843384,
1.330570936203003,
0.15195372700691223,
-0.34622615575790405,
0.016267215833067894,
-0.6901241540908813,
-0.8361606597900391,
1.116814374923706,
0.25845426321029663,
-0.5280705690383911,
-0.16688257455825806,
0.06687962263822556,
0.3984440863132477,
-0.533517062664032,
0.3007819354534149,
0.9110001921653748,
0.3686217963695526,
0.0657508596777916,
-1.1141923666000366,
0.42712467908859253,
0.25492915511131287,
0.2036733627319336,
0.11483296006917953,
-0.21995796263217926,
0.9820996522903442,
-0.375677227973938,
-0.3886302411556244,
0.14087049663066864,
0.7107159495353699,
0.3363199234008789,
0.1623794287443161,
0.5841726064682007,
0.8728772401809692,
0.5334666967391968,
-0.010348962619900703,
1.161015272140503,
0.3651105761528015,
0.14107108116149902,
1.0185297727584839,
-0.21491996943950653,
0.8566064238548279,
1.040065884590149,
-0.00503478804603219,
0.3108029067516327,
0.44341719150543213,
0.16589555144309998,
0.5540292263031006,
0.5280323028564453,
0.12955494225025177,
-0.4205089509487152,
-0.16365472972393036,
-0.20790217816829681,
0.5252628922462463,
0.7428603768348694,
-0.4029958248138428,
-0.25477421283721924,
0.10503794252872467,
-0.0968223288655281,
0.13240787386894226,
-0.6415210366249084,
0.5660375356674194,
0.24193112552165985,
-0.6684878468513489,
0.936217188835144,
-0.08856792002916336,
0.7465987801551819,
-0.2887481153011322,
-0.1574653685092926,
-0.24865444004535675,
0.1793578714132309,
0.07798542082309723,
-1.0433270931243896,
0.24128375947475433,
-0.41614288091659546,
0.0904875174164772,
-0.08402285724878311,
0.7285857200622559,
-0.27778682112693787,
-0.15356667339801788,
0.30763325095176697,
0.5945935249328613,
0.31648683547973633,
-0.20244158804416656,
-0.40305739641189575,
-0.1279577761888504,
-0.3986034393310547,
-0.3628612756729126,
0.06786125898361206,
0.7980912923812866,
-0.2869075536727905,
0.9205389022827148,
0.15232427418231964,
0.334609717130661,
0.08845701068639755,
0.1815434694290161,
0.7436701655387878,
-0.5656096935272217,
-0.37458840012550354,
-0.8706235289573669,
0.37189948558807373,
-0.0078316954895854,
-0.44247671961784363,
0.6093702912330627,
0.3388512432575226,
1.3309212923049927,
-0.42241230607032776,
0.564415454864502,
-0.002086266875267029,
0.5634641051292419,
-0.8282728791236877,
0.5533364415168762,
-0.8502016663551331,
0.12818779051303864,
0.05476760491728783,
-0.608128011226654,
-0.12558116018772125,
0.6594153642654419,
-0.6901410222053528,
-0.05080200359225273,
0.5691908001899719,
0.8097086548805237,
-0.4232497215270996,
0.0344221293926239,
0.3646049201488495,
0.4380291700363159,
0.141984760761261,
0.46386823058128357,
1.1271156072616577,
-0.05392148718237877,
0.13993532955646515,
-0.10795903205871582,
0.060393933206796646,
-0.07103462517261505,
-0.8556099534034729,
-1.1153596639633179,
-0.8411109447479248,
0.05764227733016014,
-0.12803693115711212,
-0.22763514518737793,
0.7964677214622498,
0.5269256234169006,
-0.6892659664154053,
-0.44362249970436096,
-0.2619091272354126,
0.060593489557504654,
-0.1363447904586792,
-0.2618527412414551,
0.20694655179977417,
-0.38861966133117676,
-0.6607484817504883,
0.3229910433292389,
-0.13627280294895172,
-0.05346348509192467,
-0.4409979283809662,
-0.08507820218801498,
-0.4113726019859314,
0.14620789885520935,
0.6457194089889526,
-0.14019736647605896,
-1.2520711421966553,
-0.4734798073768616,
-0.24337761104106903,
0.03854608163237572,
-0.3881041705608368,
0.8642960786819458,
-0.9001284241676331,
0.3616451621055603,
0.41485267877578735,
0.9240190386772156,
0.4784267544746399,
0.023027321323752403,
0.6308740377426147,
-0.7939408421516418,
0.05360257625579834,
0.07379697263240814,
0.45579293370246887,
0.21793007850646973,
-0.20553745329380035,
0.5506092309951782,
0.30439040064811707,
-0.0487336590886116,
-0.8786807656288147,
0.43963155150413513,
-0.6806855201721191,
-0.7790430784225464,
1.3982620239257812,
0.0822332352399826,
-0.15727116167545319,
-0.025484997779130936,
-0.14343440532684326,
0.23189730942249298,
-0.23603250086307526,
0.5719006657600403,
1.0339680910110474,
-0.14108526706695557,
-0.2542150318622589,
-0.599081814289093,
0.28180748224258423,
0.5373244881629944,
-0.5216187238693237,
0.3534282147884369,
0.3161717355251312,
0.23838308453559875,
0.35615384578704834,
0.3062252104282379,
0.13344761729240417,
0.14029861986637115,
-0.13712316751480103,
-0.4292832612991333,
-0.11901544779539108,
-0.2741207480430603,
-0.3428666889667511,
-0.11549200117588043,
0.1782485693693161,
-0.12696252763271332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14888v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14888v1
|
Efficient data selection employing Semantic Similarity-based Graph Structures for model training
| 2024-02-22T09:43:53 | 2024-02-22T09:43:53 |
Roxana Petcu, Subhadeep Maji
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent developments in natural language processing (NLP) have highlighted the
need for substantial amounts of data for models to capture textual information
accurately. This raises concerns regarding the computational resources and time
required for training such models. This paper introduces Semantics for data
SAliency in Model performance Estimation (SeSaME). It is an efficient data
sampling mechanism solely based on textual information without passing the data
through a compute-heavy model or other intensive pre-processing
transformations. The application of this approach is demonstrated in the use
case of low-resource automated speech recognition (ASR) models, which
excessively rely on text-to-speech (TTS) calls when using augmented data.
SeSaME learns to categorize new incoming data points into speech recognition
difficulty buckets by employing semantic similarity-based graph structures and
discrete ASR information from homophilous neighbourhoods through message
passing. The results indicate reliable projections of ASR performance, with a
93% accuracy increase when using the proposed method compared to random
predictions, bringing non-trivial information on the impact of textual
representations in speech models. Furthermore, a series of experiments show
both the benefits and challenges of using the ASR information on incoming data
to fine-tune the model. We report a 7% drop in validation loss compared to
random sampling, 7% WER drop with non-local aggregation when evaluating against
a highly difficult dataset, and 1.8% WER drop with local aggregation and high
semantic similarity between datasets.
|
[
-0.2497003823518753,
-0.7420873045921326,
0.27949514985084534,
-0.02873913384974003,
-0.25738057494163513,
-0.15749946236610413,
-0.3290230929851532,
-0.7095344662666321,
0.14184902608394623,
0.26312190294265747,
-0.35740169882774353,
-0.5669264197349548,
-0.7371976971626282,
0.04732905700802803,
-0.7973827123641968,
0.776888906955719,
0.22758913040161133,
0.016061989590525627,
-0.33298414945602417,
-0.04981684684753418,
-0.17022280395030975,
-0.33834463357925415,
-0.5197523832321167,
-0.2149720937013626,
0.5484312772750854,
0.37368205189704895,
0.6475613713264465,
0.9413238763809204,
0.5802026987075806,
0.3882283866405487,
-0.24947834014892578,
-0.019516877830028534,
-0.48669829964637756,
0.04791812226176262,
-0.18859893083572388,
-0.22390010952949524,
-0.14590370655059814,
0.06564182043075562,
0.7366085648536682,
1.1498514413833618,
0.18322686851024628,
0.35431864857673645,
0.21564431488513947,
0.6024560928344727,
-0.8575737476348877,
0.41183561086654663,
-0.8614585995674133,
0.11043193191289902,
-0.4802374839782715,
0.0673111155629158,
-0.18110178411006927,
-0.33896371722221375,
0.43703216314315796,
-0.5583509802818298,
0.3189336359500885,
0.14742004871368408,
0.9927912354469299,
0.3920938968658447,
-0.052893269807100296,
-0.4158092737197876,
-0.46988463401794434,
0.9752843976020813,
-0.5473626852035522,
0.619290292263031,
0.8942614197731018,
0.3127796947956085,
0.048568788915872574,
-0.7856540083885193,
-0.5132814645767212,
-0.38747137784957886,
-0.19512036442756653,
0.013655798509716988,
-0.3275240361690521,
0.10664491355419159,
0.3244655430316925,
0.3561655879020691,
-0.4663962423801422,
0.03697396069765091,
-0.4436878561973572,
-0.20432241261005402,
0.41103073954582214,
-0.05544965714216232,
-0.0826217457652092,
-0.40568995475769043,
-0.23345880210399628,
-0.396786630153656,
-0.287759929895401,
0.15166278183460236,
0.3378891944885254,
0.7763651609420776,
-0.08015330135822296,
0.5114147663116455,
-0.5073666572570801,
0.9973027110099792,
-0.100367471575737,
-0.03299301117658615,
0.29769617319107056,
-0.16937120258808136,
-0.2722538709640503,
0.0921538919210434,
0.5783111453056335,
0.18593360483646393,
0.31583714485168457,
-0.3179759681224823,
-0.21314570307731628,
0.510360598564148,
0.14998464286327362,
-0.551900327205658,
-0.3562666177749634,
-0.03104693815112114,
-0.4827560782432556,
-0.21009206771850586,
0.05595672130584717,
-0.6149267554283142,
0.030583791434764862,
-0.4248988628387451,
0.011220765300095081,
-0.6002179980278015,
0.25713005661964417,
-0.04048210754990578,
-0.029464617371559143,
-0.050004374235868454,
0.22602005302906036,
-0.9861289262771606,
0.5462408065795898,
0.5787141919136047,
0.8445502519607544,
-0.29602867364883423,
-0.15228590369224548,
-0.7442493438720703,
0.4178450107574463,
-0.11694540828466415,
0.7504979372024536,
-0.9054422378540039,
-0.3921108841896057,
-0.4051017463207245,
-0.21031026542186737,
-0.434725821018219,
-0.4466142952442169,
0.6743426322937012,
-0.45441746711730957,
-0.03314659371972084,
0.06342572718858719,
-0.6143607497215271,
-0.25985291600227356,
0.10905182361602783,
-0.7745621204376221,
1.1424943208694458,
0.04473145678639412,
-1.1104052066802979,
0.47970378398895264,
-0.6304401159286499,
-0.5572918057441711,
-0.23945745825767517,
-0.1305537074804306,
-0.5221880078315735,
0.0004293795209378004,
0.27362534403800964,
0.5142446756362915,
-0.18659235537052155,
-0.09086236357688904,
-0.44674021005630493,
-0.29684311151504517,
0.16652873158454895,
-0.38363873958587646,
0.383240669965744,
0.3928833603858948,
-0.22076179087162018,
0.10254587233066559,
-0.9226098656654358,
0.2287815660238266,
-0.0911882296204567,
-0.28536275029182434,
-0.5157638788223267,
-0.05697361379861832,
0.3660546839237213,
0.11048437654972076,
0.05691787600517273,
-0.6193886399269104,
-0.31420382857322693,
-0.579045295715332,
0.13590213656425476,
0.5989633798599243,
-0.4584243893623352,
0.2959722876548767,
-0.36433711647987366,
0.22792963683605194,
-0.2200888991355896,
-0.024422461166977882,
0.11752298474311829,
-0.5703041553497314,
-0.7037792205810547,
-0.3331299424171448,
0.7550874352455139,
0.3351961374282837,
-0.5750762820243835,
0.47679591178894043,
-0.4956633448600769,
-0.3967348337173462,
-0.641799807548523,
0.013515744358301163,
0.5640738606452942,
0.8949400186538696,
0.301883339881897,
-0.4797869920730591,
-0.5490317344665527,
-0.8198070526123047,
-0.006553271785378456,
-0.1679587960243225,
-0.15362906455993652,
0.5187586545944214,
0.18386052548885345,
-0.17777633666992188,
1.1402568817138672,
-0.4526773989200592,
-0.2712375223636627,
-0.15407614409923553,
0.09916690737009048,
0.06821165978908539,
0.465182900428772,
0.4168093204498291,
-0.8459538817405701,
-0.5293678641319275,
0.016764730215072632,
-0.5287176370620728,
-0.1468695104122162,
0.44905954599380493,
-0.028300127014517784,
0.18319720029830933,
0.28026169538497925,
-0.5079878568649292,
0.6690033078193665,
0.49191203713417053,
-0.1946202516555786,
0.06586650013923645,
0.07995245605707169,
-0.027755534276366234,
-0.7886744737625122,
0.5488400459289551,
0.029086146503686905,
-0.41983455419540405,
-0.5669578313827515,
-0.20635944604873657,
-0.21908704936504364,
-0.18407681584358215,
-0.2168494611978531,
0.6193335056304932,
-0.21367709338665009,
-0.500701904296875,
-0.1636449098587036,
0.3110325038433075,
-0.17230191826820374,
0.4492948353290558,
0.16555091738700867,
0.6207368969917297,
0.5522629022598267,
-0.690384030342102,
0.33257612586021423,
0.397302508354187,
-0.4336678087711334,
0.30425235629081726,
-0.5195448398590088,
0.09695032984018326,
-0.006579982582479715,
0.025022931396961212,
-0.8625227808952332,
-0.2551928162574768,
0.14196817576885223,
-0.5085287690162659,
0.2559947371482849,
0.08068981021642685,
-0.500299870967865,
-0.37063515186309814,
-0.18283192813396454,
0.16363471746444702,
0.27305909991264343,
-0.4338933825492859,
0.35939958691596985,
0.6669240593910217,
-0.3518686592578888,
-0.46604251861572266,
-0.5213763117790222,
-0.17085744440555573,
-0.2139987349510193,
-0.6218225955963135,
0.2504981756210327,
0.4337712824344635,
0.012658152729272842,
0.241634801030159,
-0.16408419609069824,
-0.036161016672849655,
0.2557573914527893,
0.31936898827552795,
0.01384706236422062,
-0.05220707133412361,
0.27854984998703003,
-0.13240505754947662,
-0.3879345655441284,
-0.25848522782325745,
-0.19804297387599945,
0.5768008232116699,
0.07708542793989182,
-0.44467321038246155,
-0.7445479035377502,
0.35197529196739197,
0.19519586861133575,
-0.09626690298318863,
0.30313318967819214,
0.5576392412185669,
-0.2671591639518738,
0.06273886561393738,
-0.4349976181983948,
-0.3465791642665863,
-0.40260085463523865,
0.5299474000930786,
-0.4047485888004303,
-0.6332833170890808,
0.39580729603767395,
-0.03090038150548935,
-0.20099975168704987,
0.3218197226524353,
0.27178826928138733,
-0.16410602629184723,
0.9057385325431824,
0.6608964204788208,
-0.46111834049224854,
0.8579134345054626,
-0.35255101323127747,
-0.08502566069364548,
-0.5606747269630432,
-0.206940695643425,
-0.7375999093055725,
-0.49984943866729736,
-0.49070602655410767,
-0.519061267375946,
0.2851503789424896,
-0.148701474070549,
-0.0958540216088295,
0.15773628652095795,
-0.3110535740852356,
0.22805948555469513,
0.8969977498054504,
-0.00346851977519691,
0.33820265531539917,
0.43684545159339905,
-0.11287227272987366,
-0.06294142454862595,
-0.8055142164230347,
-0.5319594144821167,
1.0353351831436157,
0.2573900818824768,
0.7973054051399231,
-0.21911583840847015,
0.3828519582748413,
0.14559508860111237,
0.05691180005669594,
-0.6588834524154663,
0.49181798100471497,
-0.4476209282875061,
-0.11833333969116211,
-0.5364224910736084,
-0.5701603293418884,
-1.123210072517395,
0.04631483927369118,
-0.18701688945293427,
-0.9251450300216675,
0.13148923218250275,
0.20704296231269836,
-0.2696208655834198,
0.07435748726129532,
-0.6491732001304626,
0.7147391438484192,
0.06537538021802902,
-0.1196741983294487,
-0.33559927344322205,
-0.9302555918693542,
-0.0497581884264946,
0.02699933387339115,
-0.08702437579631805,
-0.27268627285957336,
0.1290273517370224,
0.8964539766311646,
-0.45320382714271545,
0.6908503770828247,
-0.14759963750839233,
0.2951849400997162,
0.07685951143503189,
-0.275880366563797,
0.6335211992263794,
-0.30046242475509644,
-0.44626352190971375,
0.3242834508419037,
-0.22904452681541443,
-0.3270723819732666,
-0.7348155975341797,
0.5369600057601929,
-0.8273155093193054,
-0.3271474838256836,
-0.2517178952693939,
-0.7080068588256836,
-0.45679035782814026,
0.027864165604114532,
0.17449380457401276,
0.33141160011291504,
-0.0054374681785702705,
0.36372262239456177,
0.2370249480009079,
0.185882568359375,
0.3735729455947876,
0.17972099781036377,
-0.027089184150099754,
-0.26847171783447266,
0.9291717410087585,
0.1624421328306198,
0.32023370265960693,
0.3994917869567871,
0.035699062049388885,
-0.524675190448761,
-0.5547832250595093,
-0.3816424012184143,
0.028069419786334038,
-0.5008956789970398,
-0.27314087748527527,
-0.8701299428939819,
-0.2870253920555115,
-0.3157697021961212,
-0.03573460131883621,
-0.3961388170719147,
-0.7762733697891235,
-0.3102077841758728,
-0.011559493839740753,
0.5691342949867249,
0.3744378089904785,
0.06534743309020996,
0.4415220618247986,
-0.5428462624549866,
0.36739543080329895,
0.3322697579860687,
0.4562934935092926,
0.12307941913604736,
-0.4136509597301483,
-0.4540918469429016,
0.12847602367401123,
-0.27162590622901917,
-0.5023845434188843,
0.430806428194046,
0.4173090159893036,
0.5494590401649475,
0.37544873356819153,
0.024085983633995056,
0.9045530557632446,
-0.2963249385356903,
0.3255254626274109,
0.014315114356577396,
-0.9304683208465576,
0.8311403393745422,
-0.11415577679872513,
0.20631574094295502,
0.7385680079460144,
0.24841469526290894,
-0.4376896321773529,
-0.558151125907898,
-0.5346441268920898,
-0.849027156829834,
0.9835641384124756,
0.6027684211730957,
-0.051357608288526535,
0.17000268399715424,
0.009920857846736908,
-0.002715046051889658,
0.31161966919898987,
-0.3467826843261719,
-0.1826978474855423,
-0.3094562590122223,
-0.46765807271003723,
0.022009458392858505,
-0.06280369311571121,
0.0028295181691646576,
-0.27100205421447754,
0.6254414916038513,
-0.2465212196111679,
0.06196253374218941,
-0.050828199833631516,
-0.10807738453149796,
-0.04098086804151535,
0.093051478266716,
0.08924471586942673,
0.3862028121948242,
-0.3573451340198517,
0.0894680842757225,
0.17291909456253052,
-0.5827964544296265,
-0.17799393832683563,
0.4925307631492615,
-0.13271066546440125,
0.22527001798152924,
0.35505369305610657,
0.972087562084198,
0.4868917167186737,
-0.7328618764877319,
0.4048028886318207,
0.06989994645118713,
0.39035776257514954,
0.07645480334758759,
0.17155715823173523,
-0.2207278609275818,
0.1707758903503418,
0.19964466989040375,
0.0005064844153821468,
0.49160391092300415,
-0.4178014099597931,
0.3316951096057892,
0.5207431316375732,
-0.4667726159095764,
-0.1290731281042099,
0.4922787547111511,
0.16860857605934143,
0.043845947831869125,
0.6724491715431213,
-0.05753719061613083,
-0.2356279194355011,
0.590185284614563,
0.46075478196144104,
0.6824672222137451,
-0.3780674636363983,
0.0740421935915947,
0.09188295900821686,
-0.2314133644104004,
0.12188377231359482,
0.16061002016067505,
-0.33024299144744873,
-0.7085469365119934,
-0.2071356624364853,
-0.9071115851402283,
-0.46143388748168945,
0.014158261008560658,
-0.7501775622367859,
0.36532992124557495,
-0.40184909105300903,
-0.36716997623443604,
0.12040947377681732,
0.20880167186260223,
-0.4719666838645935,
0.36055511236190796,
0.22357212007045746,
0.7604354023933411,
-0.6910006999969482,
0.9062994718551636,
0.6621978878974915,
-0.031155750155448914,
-0.7836549878120422,
0.04101606830954552,
-0.12711511552333832,
-0.7229031324386597,
0.873634397983551,
0.22104942798614502,
-0.1380537897348404,
-0.038933008909225464,
-0.23211891949176788,
-1.1350098848342896,
0.9311832785606384,
0.593975841999054,
-0.5159988403320312,
-0.08364961296319962,
0.19955836236476898,
0.46796736121177673,
-0.3704479932785034,
0.10907502472400665,
0.49737924337387085,
0.23714587092399597,
0.5639669895172119,
-1.1863824129104614,
-0.14303185045719147,
-0.35066577792167664,
0.3814915418624878,
-0.0606687031686306,
-0.4471777677536011,
0.8720389008522034,
-0.06422972679138184,
-0.40546414256095886,
0.16708791255950928,
0.6502946019172668,
0.5089359879493713,
0.5565088987350464,
0.6364210844039917,
0.5850768685340881,
1.0655796527862549,
0.08292822539806366,
1.1806833744049072,
-0.46901246905326843,
0.38822314143180847,
1.1329233646392822,
-0.21439845860004425,
0.9180276393890381,
0.3531283140182495,
-0.179780974984169,
0.24017055332660675,
0.7389914393424988,
0.07573113590478897,
0.8281330466270447,
0.07148593664169312,
-0.03525443747639656,
-0.1700832098722458,
-0.46029916405677795,
-0.3456505835056305,
0.8350670337677002,
0.3738514482975006,
-0.4000118672847748,
-0.3627604842185974,
-0.04133687540888786,
-0.18430142104625702,
0.14611214399337769,
-0.31251177191734314,
0.8678725957870483,
0.02914472483098507,
-0.08781224489212036,
0.5286098718643188,
0.04177936166524887,
0.5411989092826843,
-0.5714317560195923,
0.04146142303943634,
0.09852740913629532,
0.06370729953050613,
-0.1412319391965866,
-0.47277525067329407,
0.4493509829044342,
0.16961868107318878,
-0.46048852801322937,
-0.03762519732117653,
0.6487926244735718,
-0.3832160234451294,
-0.816710352897644,
0.25649717450141907,
0.28224506974220276,
0.29906603693962097,
0.04006928578019142,
-0.5625266432762146,
0.14601345360279083,
-0.14545507729053497,
0.0172992255538702,
0.15050143003463745,
0.37849879264831543,
-0.24836795032024384,
0.7545052766799927,
0.7085294723510742,
0.4899214506149292,
-0.02376827597618103,
0.02290191501379013,
1.145080327987671,
-0.5321959853172302,
-0.9038075804710388,
-0.7132691144943237,
0.1462598592042923,
-0.4434936046600342,
0.04961136728525162,
0.7282224893569946,
0.7271488904953003,
0.9550342559814453,
0.19877491891384125,
0.7307106852531433,
0.12944020330905914,
0.8978012800216675,
-0.6938930749893188,
0.7863162159919739,
-0.22043058276176453,
0.2578793466091156,
-0.6291994452476501,
-0.8570826053619385,
-0.29887840151786804,
1.0114861726760864,
-0.7151507139205933,
0.13774509727954865,
0.36087968945503235,
0.7922504544258118,
-0.41431736946105957,
0.2615463137626648,
0.42152705788612366,
0.15264855325222015,
-0.05095468834042549,
0.47317999601364136,
0.6632965207099915,
-0.32831132411956787,
0.33770862221717834,
-0.24405576288700104,
-0.06945902109146118,
-0.38907602429389954,
-0.48777350783348083,
-0.7413943409919739,
-0.6000502705574036,
-0.26414036750793457,
0.02204708941280842,
0.1843850314617157,
1.0123178958892822,
1.0256619453430176,
-1.0261255502700806,
-0.21436290442943573,
0.10499753057956696,
0.3082793056964874,
0.0015639541670680046,
-0.19422002136707306,
0.800094723701477,
-0.4735780358314514,
-0.907970130443573,
0.21674072742462158,
0.2253645807504654,
0.11700308322906494,
0.20228764414787292,
0.03677084296941757,
-0.2239280641078949,
-0.2216949760913849,
0.5432601571083069,
0.16609631478786469,
-0.6825669407844543,
-0.39519158005714417,
-0.36092549562454224,
-0.12288542091846466,
-0.01755182258784771,
0.6347405314445496,
-1.0647310018539429,
0.5326506495475769,
0.2399425059556961,
0.7355749607086182,
0.5354758501052856,
0.1539674550294876,
0.4276353120803833,
-0.9955215454101562,
0.5313388109207153,
0.3055547773838043,
0.2289503812789917,
0.6486056447029114,
-0.1826816350221634,
0.5545191168785095,
0.31038525700569153,
-0.15859989821910858,
-0.8962184190750122,
0.014231058768928051,
-0.8523054718971252,
0.026194516569375992,
1.0322681665420532,
-0.22806575894355774,
-0.36606788635253906,
-0.26379555463790894,
0.016866439953446388,
0.41579341888427734,
-0.5183975100517273,
0.9972470998764038,
0.40621423721313477,
-0.29428839683532715,
0.06782703846693039,
-0.4646354019641876,
0.6814281940460205,
0.2764606475830078,
-0.678251326084137,
0.07197299599647522,
0.4046206772327423,
-0.04427849501371384,
0.3251950740814209,
0.49711406230926514,
0.07391981780529022,
0.14480336010456085,
-0.003515241900458932,
-0.25269514322280884,
-0.04185585305094719,
-0.31247180700302124,
-0.17703251540660858,
0.30022960901260376,
-0.1515815258026123,
-0.5233820676803589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14382v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14382v2
|
Chain-of-History Reasoning for Temporal Knowledge Graph Forecasting
| 2024-02-22T08:51:39 | 2024-06-07T08:15:18 |
Yuwei Xia, Ding Wang, Qiang Liu, Liang Wang, Shu Wu, Xiaoyu Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Temporal Knowledge Graph (TKG) forecasting aims to predict future facts based
on given histories. Most recent graph-based models excel at capturing
structural information within TKGs but lack semantic comprehension abilities.
Nowadays, with the surge of LLMs, the LLM-based TKG prediction model has
emerged. However, the existing LLM-based model exhibits three shortcomings: (1)
It only focuses on the first-order history for prediction while ignoring
high-order historical information, resulting in the provided information for
LLMs being extremely limited. (2) LLMs struggle with optimal reasoning
performance under heavy historical information loads. (3) For TKG prediction,
the temporal reasoning capability of LLM alone is limited. To address the first
two challenges, we propose Chain-of-History (CoH) reasoning which explores
high-order histories step-by-step, achieving effective utilization of
high-order historical information for LLMs on TKG prediction. To address the
third issue, we design CoH as a plug-and-play module to enhance the performance
of graph-based models for TKG prediction. Extensive experiments on three
datasets and backbones demonstrate the effectiveness of CoH.
|
[
-0.2241867035627365,
-0.7479277849197388,
0.8985527753829956,
-0.04584967717528343,
-0.3559250235557556,
0.49410486221313477,
0.3375161588191986,
-0.563417375087738,
0.027979431673884392,
0.5830110311508179,
-0.8814111948013306,
-0.865807831287384,
-0.3404586613178253,
-0.25078150629997253,
-0.05902409553527832,
0.6892557740211487,
-0.19792144000530243,
-0.26854079961776733,
-0.23586751520633698,
0.08111051470041275,
-0.4880852997303009,
-0.5779979825019836,
-0.5828613638877869,
-0.8793357610702515,
0.7378866076469421,
0.48621538281440735,
0.7007599472999573,
0.9987605214118958,
-0.004884970840066671,
0.020087741315364838,
-0.07103004306554794,
0.39071089029312134,
-0.571406364440918,
0.17340633273124695,
-0.14208807051181793,
-0.18278492987155914,
-0.9473506808280945,
-0.19625765085220337,
0.2836132347583771,
0.7504234910011292,
0.05920536071062088,
0.18049868941307068,
-0.14787130057811737,
0.5588505268096924,
-0.4579249918460846,
0.6267898678779602,
-0.3620951473712921,
0.1777726709842682,
-0.05076771602034569,
-0.5545011162757874,
-0.5735396146774292,
-0.37327829003334045,
0.43989673256874084,
-0.8904545307159424,
-0.09876737743616104,
0.5248314142227173,
0.7532958388328552,
0.07708020508289337,
-0.6974906921386719,
0.009997795335948467,
-0.7937269806861877,
0.7265737652778625,
-0.6682760715484619,
0.564239501953125,
0.48058435320854187,
0.4408279061317444,
-0.3891744911670685,
-0.9399848580360413,
-0.27458715438842773,
-0.1368933916091919,
-0.008000224828720093,
0.33753469586372375,
-0.10917161405086517,
-0.024659520015120506,
0.25659412145614624,
0.14862537384033203,
-0.6965363621711731,
0.2884627878665924,
-0.09957762062549591,
-0.1744680106639862,
0.36218929290771484,
0.5330166816711426,
-0.10765644907951355,
-0.3625618815422058,
-0.9011836051940918,
0.18197932839393616,
-0.6953415870666504,
-0.07621493935585022,
0.28331607580184937,
0.17863044142723083,
-0.05036546289920807,
0.5035474896430969,
-0.3143189251422882,
0.7210111021995544,
0.025523988530039787,
-0.3816089630126953,
-0.2629372179508209,
-0.10541000217199326,
-0.1586848646402359,
0.12623317539691925,
0.5459794402122498,
0.5022616386413574,
0.14916633069515228,
-0.4310877323150635,
0.18159039318561554,
-0.006592125166207552,
0.0009430264472030103,
-0.6586747765541077,
-0.22216974198818207,
0.11908771097660065,
-0.21019217371940613,
-0.3827384412288666,
-0.27559852600097656,
-0.8745001554489136,
-0.2620140612125397,
-0.21255366504192352,
0.3921898603439331,
-0.44982466101646423,
-0.16997788846492767,
-0.08865761756896973,
-0.39958637952804565,
-0.18327870965003967,
0.49623382091522217,
-0.4217498004436493,
0.23032952845096588,
0.6236888766288757,
0.7715718746185303,
-0.23584416508674622,
-0.24427253007888794,
-0.4442172944545746,
0.8467541933059692,
-0.32508400082588196,
0.5940077304840088,
-0.41477957367897034,
-0.3124970495700836,
-0.21389542520046234,
-0.04145900532603264,
0.2640804648399353,
-0.1500426083803177,
0.2579158544540405,
-0.9653030633926392,
-0.040613312274217606,
-0.18097852170467377,
-0.9175978302955627,
-0.3388221263885498,
0.5669924020767212,
-0.6305771470069885,
0.8119582533836365,
0.24274004995822906,
-0.7412427067756653,
0.5153388977050781,
-0.16925875842571259,
-0.4219474494457245,
0.1594785451889038,
-0.18568409979343414,
-0.4941515028476715,
-0.5019770860671997,
0.42949533462524414,
0.37301674485206604,
-0.23624883592128754,
0.6024600863456726,
-0.852832555770874,
-0.20425115525722504,
-0.27503398060798645,
-0.22867906093597412,
0.6934509873390198,
0.20939794182777405,
-0.23310336470603943,
-0.12908457219600677,
-0.6154934763908386,
0.024490168318152428,
0.062052734196186066,
-0.13671940565109253,
-0.20251096785068512,
0.3346005380153656,
-0.630196213722229,
0.10485517233610153,
0.28622373938560486,
-0.14333459734916687,
0.514468252658844,
-0.24590767920017242,
0.31737783551216125,
0.8758105039596558,
0.27629661560058594,
0.5122663974761963,
-0.5205186009407043,
0.7544081211090088,
0.0669584646821022,
0.3941790759563446,
-0.12578365206718445,
-0.5191428661346436,
-0.3058296740055084,
0.2251911461353302,
-0.029601456597447395,
0.5699061155319214,
-0.8781806230545044,
0.16970746219158173,
-0.5503504276275635,
-0.5653139352798462,
0.7178459167480469,
-0.20086391270160675,
0.018035078421235085,
0.8478684425354004,
0.32940050959587097,
0.07596708089113235,
-0.7727160453796387,
-0.4291535019874573,
-0.17714673280715942,
-0.780083954334259,
0.16542373597621918,
0.5309580564498901,
0.3503514528274536,
0.031666070222854614,
1.0060479640960693,
-0.7352343797683716,
0.18141043186187744,
-0.07863486558198929,
0.18898479640483856,
0.4787196218967438,
0.1096685454249382,
0.32127290964126587,
-0.4281209707260132,
-0.11039416491985321,
0.16059742867946625,
-0.7534394264221191,
0.10743676871061325,
0.13191254436969757,
-0.2864234149456024,
0.3006005883216858,
0.45815029740333557,
-0.3735526502132416,
0.6461889147758484,
0.5553582310676575,
-0.5037029981613159,
0.7989349365234375,
0.007271155249327421,
0.0373045839369297,
-1.1009111404418945,
-0.00674328813329339,
-0.3211589455604553,
-0.2569745182991028,
-0.37017613649368286,
-0.4744853377342224,
-0.15932247042655945,
-0.3242204785346985,
-0.22490979731082916,
0.9286578297615051,
-0.17471101880073547,
-0.0523485392332077,
0.058843739330768585,
-0.03029085323214531,
0.14170825481414795,
0.5562257170677185,
-0.02849547006189823,
0.12322831898927689,
0.1510186791419983,
-0.7874900102615356,
0.39044830203056335,
-0.06323035806417465,
-0.30860263109207153,
0.15669390559196472,
-0.32840120792388916,
0.20863118767738342,
0.2618977427482605,
0.4792430102825165,
-0.7623129487037659,
-0.24316762387752533,
0.23804008960723877,
-0.4373166561126709,
0.44985800981521606,
-0.6140844821929932,
-0.6135236024856567,
-0.6453791856765747,
0.07204961776733398,
0.5015304088592529,
0.4720700979232788,
-0.8226934671401978,
0.9557985663414001,
-0.04177636653184891,
0.06688904762268066,
-0.8612481951713562,
-0.3773096203804016,
-0.09650936722755432,
-0.1848544478416443,
-0.9089441895484924,
0.41191181540489197,
0.061844803392887115,
-0.19006749987602234,
0.09802214801311493,
-0.6775211691856384,
-0.12954941391944885,
0.0013684039004147053,
0.18651248514652252,
0.6051452159881592,
-0.06894659250974655,
0.22525331377983093,
0.019716929644346237,
-0.21723270416259766,
0.02897990122437477,
-1.0534316301345825,
0.5579151511192322,
0.10317627340555191,
-0.21124126017093658,
-0.07383999973535538,
-0.09930777549743652,
0.6048657298088074,
0.31158533692359924,
0.5321021676063538,
0.36491870880126953,
-0.3081739842891693,
-0.23656447231769562,
-0.6713222861289978,
-0.0908154770731926,
-0.3762235939502716,
0.18961502611637115,
-0.05015982314944267,
-0.9138286709785461,
0.6068142652511597,
-0.3039242923259735,
-0.056763552129268646,
0.5273858904838562,
0.38964730501174927,
-0.47072333097457886,
0.7615216374397278,
0.004614141304045916,
-0.2294735312461853,
0.496033251285553,
-0.4072659909725189,
0.07214140146970749,
-0.3325566351413727,
-0.4622218906879425,
-0.09519912302494049,
-0.1843051314353943,
-0.6042594909667969,
-0.05067218467593193,
0.6623443365097046,
0.36088475584983826,
-0.6189970970153809,
0.04585537314414978,
0.04213657230138779,
0.19539719820022583,
0.3177827000617981,
0.41079315543174744,
0.6355502605438232,
0.14703640341758728,
-0.08566401153802872,
0.3874378502368927,
-0.9516811370849609,
-0.41425877809524536,
0.9462202191352844,
0.29243800044059753,
0.9906359910964966,
-0.2896788716316223,
0.4766371250152588,
0.3757799565792084,
-0.043358221650123596,
-0.6275880932807922,
0.5115412473678589,
-0.2907414138317108,
-0.5917031168937683,
-0.3424626886844635,
-0.5659685730934143,
-0.8906051516532898,
-0.34392160177230835,
0.1524180918931961,
-0.7049115896224976,
0.1637333482503891,
0.5076278448104858,
-0.31626439094543457,
0.6800525188446045,
-0.43371692299842834,
0.7193774580955505,
-0.1782774180173874,
-0.36564886569976807,
-0.22407227754592896,
-0.7033197283744812,
0.26075688004493713,
0.34362679719924927,
0.20953495800495148,
-0.21683372557163239,
0.06300223618745804,
0.7317754626274109,
-0.7133325338363647,
0.9092053174972534,
-0.09751764684915543,
0.3137916922569275,
0.43015989661216736,
0.3695746064186096,
0.9338361024856567,
-0.05264568328857422,
-0.05890168994665146,
0.2881689667701721,
0.1507280319929123,
-0.4362333416938782,
-0.6926787495613098,
0.5265040397644043,
-0.6751611232757568,
-0.7375102043151855,
-0.24251824617385864,
-0.7741371989250183,
-0.24506555497646332,
0.13075485825538635,
0.23289331793785095,
0.7534812092781067,
0.029915234073996544,
-0.16343864798545837,
0.2722418010234833,
0.12770144641399384,
0.517309308052063,
0.2729074954986572,
-0.5165891647338867,
-0.5866379141807556,
0.6472431421279907,
0.4451368451118469,
0.45456087589263916,
0.6002321243286133,
0.7159289717674255,
-0.30546072125434875,
-0.4162323772907257,
-0.39651918411254883,
0.09507483243942261,
-0.8334503769874573,
-0.21903195977210999,
-0.52130126953125,
-0.10956922918558121,
-0.2782672047615051,
-0.12268362194299698,
-0.008491757325828075,
-0.666791558265686,
-0.35394591093063354,
-0.07733408361673355,
0.5650326013565063,
0.821439802646637,
0.13320015370845795,
0.25404369831085205,
-0.6527334451675415,
0.23217980563640594,
0.4179322123527527,
0.5868927836418152,
0.31582263112068176,
-0.11398903280496597,
-0.2622087895870209,
-0.30424296855926514,
-0.574356198310852,
-0.8771820068359375,
0.23488816618919373,
-0.42652684450149536,
0.4753883481025696,
0.3440321981906891,
0.22852873802185059,
0.8254619836807251,
-0.3984566628932953,
0.7796483039855957,
0.17731598019599915,
-0.5204651355743408,
0.7093281745910645,
-0.6596766710281372,
0.2118244767189026,
-0.1849690079689026,
0.5103232860565186,
-0.33623525500297546,
-0.32345736026763916,
-0.799837589263916,
-0.8726217746734619,
0.7272936105728149,
-0.07817325741052628,
-0.7747794389724731,
-0.04137463867664337,
0.5112943649291992,
0.4754309356212616,
0.017099525779485703,
-0.4653763473033905,
-0.16395889222621918,
-0.26411551237106323,
0.06882294267416,
0.10161886364221573,
-0.1676066666841507,
0.16619417071342468,
-0.19398948550224304,
0.6808801293373108,
-0.09424404799938202,
-0.004772551357746124,
0.05087763071060181,
0.007840245962142944,
-0.2880418300628662,
0.26198703050613403,
0.19648559391498566,
1.302856206893921,
-0.46996158361434937,
0.14045652747154236,
0.45983824133872986,
-0.2330409586429596,
0.047177352011203766,
0.003771056653931737,
-0.1378757655620575,
-0.05669623985886574,
0.6546918153762817,
0.7896246910095215,
0.11067039519548416,
-0.1465153694152832,
0.2028769999742508,
0.30130743980407715,
-0.050154298543930054,
-0.5394780039787292,
-0.1742144227027893,
0.08341903239488602,
0.6580401659011841,
0.5177270174026489,
-0.051852986216545105,
-0.38632476329803467,
-0.47018519043922424,
0.004782128147780895,
0.0029569987673312426,
-0.13623258471488953,
-0.16452819108963013,
0.5922850370407104,
-0.15531709790229797,
-0.1389225274324417,
0.7298303842544556,
-0.024497749283909798,
-0.6233407855033875,
0.7605429291725159,
0.34444519877433777,
0.5159147381782532,
-0.11425119638442993,
-0.08538912981748581,
0.43141552805900574,
0.018547896295785904,
-0.1460597813129425,
0.42294764518737793,
0.08584901690483093,
-0.4826522767543793,
-0.640643835067749,
-0.4048515260219574,
-0.48296570777893066,
0.14088699221611023,
-0.5446761846542358,
0.44829654693603516,
-0.46528488397598267,
-0.43988481163978577,
-0.481293261051178,
0.16730119287967682,
-0.8109782338142395,
0.2264569103717804,
0.019493138417601585,
0.9629707336425781,
-0.6155365109443665,
0.7176668643951416,
0.1217980831861496,
-0.1682862639427185,
-0.7212417721748352,
-0.07662474364042282,
-0.08780649304389954,
-0.8535982966423035,
0.8989975452423096,
-0.1858171969652176,
-0.015497581101953983,
0.04289999604225159,
-0.5561181902885437,
-0.8475990295410156,
1.7188668251037598,
0.4733049273490906,
-0.7901685237884521,
-0.6106080412864685,
-0.12049215286970139,
0.1955745965242386,
-0.35527482628822327,
-0.05712553858757019,
0.3813818395137787,
0.5213232636451721,
0.5516365766525269,
-0.7273237109184265,
0.09630721807479858,
0.3090994656085968,
-0.2011658251285553,
0.3207436501979828,
-0.3783206641674042,
0.7499972581863403,
-0.28808146715164185,
-0.3137805461883545,
0.024732425808906555,
0.6235076785087585,
0.5041145086288452,
0.9171469807624817,
0.6330163478851318,
0.7243629693984985,
0.7941102385520935,
-0.28375351428985596,
1.39495849609375,
-0.06791619211435318,
0.29539018869400024,
1.2352129220962524,
-0.08128266036510468,
0.46661731600761414,
0.2981794774532318,
-0.29550349712371826,
0.7782445549964905,
0.8956670761108398,
0.049411527812480927,
0.43541234731674194,
-0.08842897415161133,
-0.06888928264379501,
-0.5286918878555298,
-0.2052600234746933,
-0.36047330498695374,
0.012332539074122906,
0.211130291223526,
-0.1544811725616455,
-0.2157127559185028,
-0.44640475511550903,
0.2743910849094391,
-0.47548535466194153,
-0.6774144172668457,
0.6753289103507996,
0.08146782219409943,
-0.5587231516838074,
0.2911159098148346,
-0.5856950879096985,
-0.049565281718969345,
-0.6275783181190491,
-0.14926081895828247,
-0.07277613878250122,
0.01914922147989273,
-0.06102417781949043,
-0.7932838201522827,
0.14483413100242615,
-0.4374290108680725,
-0.37369099259376526,
-0.20236442983150482,
0.7544883489608765,
-0.260802298784256,
-0.3968442976474762,
0.6427980065345764,
0.6969229578971863,
-0.2204679548740387,
0.23572097718715668,
-0.15126477181911469,
-0.18360352516174316,
-0.3426731824874878,
-0.16172252595424652,
0.020616630092263222,
0.49235326051712036,
-0.3482101559638977,
0.8361009359359741,
0.42448145151138306,
0.10522010922431946,
-0.03242141008377075,
0.09673376381397247,
0.7607278227806091,
-0.8186115622520447,
-0.8761475682258606,
-1.1645082235336304,
0.22011828422546387,
0.07464507222175598,
0.21505174040794373,
0.2905486226081848,
0.4320945143699646,
0.739378809928894,
0.2025212198495865,
0.701401948928833,
0.2663799524307251,
0.41785794496536255,
-0.7234752178192139,
0.4227921664714813,
-0.5369883179664612,
0.25023627281188965,
-0.15851445496082306,
-0.524539053440094,
0.014763027429580688,
-0.26219120621681213,
-0.4953131675720215,
0.0876360759139061,
0.9624083042144775,
0.3539722263813019,
0.12818264961242676,
0.4264053702354431,
0.3462558388710022,
0.43133920431137085,
0.3909357488155365,
0.7283273935317993,
1.128788709640503,
-0.03575924038887024,
0.8640145659446716,
-0.42584067583084106,
-0.035727422684431076,
-0.22469648718833923,
-1.2980417013168335,
-1.0269274711608887,
-0.4178585112094879,
-0.05148415267467499,
-0.6829394698143005,
0.327300101518631,
0.8110425472259521,
0.6358497142791748,
-0.48385560512542725,
-0.3670385777950287,
-0.035789087414741516,
0.4688662886619568,
-0.31869301199913025,
-0.2299475371837616,
0.6364706754684448,
0.015244434587657452,
-0.04813086614012718,
0.41651830077171326,
0.43884167075157166,
0.1089908555150032,
-0.057855091989040375,
-0.29164445400238037,
-0.07914023846387863,
-0.3166563808917999,
0.657271146774292,
0.1349295675754547,
-0.9444077014923096,
-0.6029171943664551,
-0.03510190546512604,
0.3676454424858093,
0.1993739753961563,
0.9606457948684692,
-0.8518860936164856,
0.5875639319419861,
0.6534557342529297,
0.35063767433166504,
1.1081888675689697,
-0.06261026114225388,
0.7637355327606201,
-0.703672468662262,
-0.32017236948013306,
0.33225303888320923,
0.4720418155193329,
-0.08447844535112381,
-0.5509478449821472,
0.6029258370399475,
0.6477473974227905,
-0.5372629165649414,
-0.4886799454689026,
0.4158554673194885,
-1.0691678524017334,
-0.3307487964630127,
0.9205919504165649,
-0.2074912041425705,
-0.3264729380607605,
-0.3797883689403534,
0.33820128440856934,
0.8177964091300964,
-0.3798639476299286,
0.6652385592460632,
0.8420292735099792,
-0.46140462160110474,
-0.12363290041685104,
-0.49355554580688477,
0.03302548825740814,
-0.15749508142471313,
-0.757554829120636,
-0.007158850785344839,
0.441455215215683,
0.20249390602111816,
-0.06561528146266937,
0.4293225109577179,
-0.08641283959150314,
0.30810612440109253,
-0.05410274118185043,
-0.467265248298645,
-0.6438050866127014,
-0.5118373036384583,
0.31981441378593445,
0.3282197415828705,
-0.20335176587104797,
0.21133050322532654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14379v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14379v2
|
Novi jezički modeli za srpski jezik
| 2024-02-22T08:48:21 | 2024-02-23T09:00:49 |
Mihailo Škorić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The paper will briefly present the development history of transformer-based
language models for the Serbian language. Several new models for text
generation and vectorization, trained on the resources of the Society for
Language Resources and Technologies, will also be presented. Ten selected
vectorization models for Serbian, including two new ones, will be compared on
four natural language processing tasks. Paper will analyze which models are the
best for each selected task, how does their size and the size of their training
sets affect the performance on those tasks, and what is the optimal setting to
train the best language models for the Serbian language.
|
[
-0.5065737366676331,
-0.4206857681274414,
0.27354612946510315,
0.06786789000034332,
-0.15307947993278503,
0.04125433415174484,
-0.17043088376522064,
-0.433413565158844,
0.30521634221076965,
0.6155662536621094,
-0.6006539463996887,
-0.19941973686218262,
-0.6467545628547668,
0.4125458300113678,
-0.4258764684200287,
1.0983362197875977,
-0.23219285905361176,
0.3611675798892975,
-0.17598144710063934,
-0.02697383239865303,
-0.396408349275589,
-0.5533180832862854,
-0.2767142653465271,
-0.5750235915184021,
0.06026706099510193,
0.2419930398464203,
0.6715866327285767,
0.36251401901245117,
0.7355321049690247,
0.474006325006485,
-0.26743367314338684,
-0.5211864113807678,
-0.2680718004703522,
0.5027225613594055,
-0.089446522295475,
-0.516558051109314,
-0.11673493683338165,
0.13393691182136536,
0.6462134718894958,
0.6536049842834473,
0.10394842177629471,
0.3143291175365448,
-0.29221731424331665,
0.6845578551292419,
-0.35507723689079285,
0.19680005311965942,
-0.3023374080657959,
0.042981017380952835,
-0.06705881655216217,
-0.06676381081342697,
-0.45261484384536743,
-0.6174370050430298,
0.23372064530849457,
-0.3638121485710144,
0.37876030802726746,
0.05079558864235878,
0.914013683795929,
0.15608952939510345,
-0.42868831753730774,
-0.40980201959609985,
-1.0282113552093506,
0.9622064828872681,
-0.6588953733444214,
0.21356795728206635,
0.07399898767471313,
0.5155382752418518,
-0.15598668158054352,
-0.6517977118492126,
-0.3519905209541321,
-0.3083740770816803,
0.035460807383060455,
-0.0163315050303936,
-0.4068261981010437,
-0.04652382805943489,
0.4704054296016693,
0.2749738395214081,
-0.5965607166290283,
-0.21625769138336182,
-0.8153408169746399,
0.08064696192741394,
0.3509770929813385,
0.0961192324757576,
0.6600223183631897,
-0.3532107174396515,
-0.10972905158996582,
-0.019908595830202103,
-0.5143606662750244,
-0.005287855863571167,
0.844146192073822,
0.06679295003414154,
-0.0034484302159398794,
1.0364912748336792,
-0.5454978942871094,
0.9461409449577332,
-0.02999233640730381,
-0.358979731798172,
0.27663153409957886,
-0.38737666606903076,
-0.18353071808815002,
-0.16261960566043854,
0.6206352710723877,
0.20477043092250824,
0.5640668869018555,
-0.4601084291934967,
-0.10138542950153351,
0.5642667412757874,
0.6005134582519531,
-0.6670692563056946,
-0.5551570653915405,
-0.3629075288772583,
-0.5683799982070923,
-0.5825225710868835,
-0.0507812537252903,
-0.3807772696018219,
0.16663995385169983,
-0.4649617671966553,
0.16889385879039764,
-0.3901212811470032,
-0.27818894386291504,
0.042042843997478485,
-0.3430933356285095,
0.0701998621225357,
-0.2711683213710785,
-1.027515172958374,
0.609990656375885,
0.48146408796310425,
0.6413999199867249,
-0.3409842848777771,
0.026992300525307655,
-0.13875438272953033,
-0.13115400075912476,
-0.36440780758857727,
0.8976048231124878,
-0.6815009713172913,
-0.17888383567333221,
-0.1443391889333725,
0.05991964042186737,
0.023827899247407913,
-0.2564617991447449,
0.5664519667625427,
-0.4431285560131073,
0.29549330472946167,
-0.2213989943265915,
-0.23755942285060883,
-0.31348928809165955,
0.28840410709381104,
-0.7609438300132751,
1.1652175188064575,
0.5257809162139893,
-1.098941445350647,
0.4542679786682129,
-0.7327670454978943,
-0.4080539345741272,
0.2623235881328583,
-0.04024961218237877,
-0.35883814096450806,
0.2594905197620392,
0.0485859289765358,
0.5262671113014221,
-0.23689477145671844,
0.47736093401908875,
0.21116894483566284,
-0.14302211999893188,
0.29471510648727417,
-0.036335691809654236,
0.8712403178215027,
0.1486465483903885,
-0.24887119233608246,
0.4024190604686737,
-0.9491477608680725,
0.15397343039512634,
0.14917542040348053,
-0.5492919683456421,
-0.3564973473548889,
0.18970289826393127,
0.18225526809692383,
0.4524075388908386,
0.003839059267193079,
-0.7840626239776611,
0.25516441464424133,
-0.9279856085777283,
0.4324903190135956,
0.239373579621315,
0.006735364440828562,
0.7253348231315613,
-0.12920089066028595,
0.9399889707565308,
-0.128679558634758,
0.20122118294239044,
0.08166982233524323,
-0.69205242395401,
-0.855808436870575,
0.2520676553249359,
0.40428391098976135,
0.3409688174724579,
-1.3839926719665527,
0.12509919703006744,
-0.38802093267440796,
-0.5598467588424683,
-0.24678745865821838,
-0.2655238211154938,
0.31403517723083496,
0.25791147351264954,
0.027457183226943016,
-0.09752225130796432,
-0.8688660860061646,
-1.2571561336517334,
-0.23683297634124756,
0.0010337794665247202,
0.07285642623901367,
0.0645715743303299,
0.6135755777359009,
-0.12354002892971039,
0.9935100674629211,
-0.2558920383453369,
0.3452155590057373,
-0.9754436612129211,
0.22318951785564423,
0.2140471637248993,
0.2951740026473999,
0.9223095774650574,
-0.9765498638153076,
-0.5977755784988403,
-0.08455725759267807,
-0.3069780766963959,
-0.21343959867954254,
0.17529545724391937,
-0.16098876297473907,
0.520133376121521,
0.2406035214662552,
-0.28270748257637024,
0.43931111693382263,
0.9974785447120667,
-0.3884623050689697,
0.503623366355896,
-0.25486913323402405,
0.16471914947032928,
-1.2883623838424683,
0.09299346804618835,
0.11018998175859451,
-0.3350965082645416,
-1.049270510673523,
-0.046920664608478546,
-0.061071500182151794,
-0.2723049521446228,
-0.5735322833061218,
0.23391149938106537,
-0.77821284532547,
-0.3143155574798584,
-0.4194311797618866,
0.06191546842455864,
-0.35460275411605835,
0.4122650921344757,
-0.0182596817612648,
0.7215638756752014,
0.547759473323822,
-0.6224752068519592,
0.6033889651298523,
0.4955083727836609,
-0.6363468766212463,
0.20979492366313934,
-0.7516786456108093,
-0.12291079014539719,
-0.23840801417827606,
-0.07797539979219437,
-0.8317004442214966,
-0.09449485689401627,
0.36582544445991516,
-0.4724177420139313,
0.29559004306793213,
-0.42114192247390747,
-0.1701803058385849,
-0.805903971195221,
-0.12814933061599731,
0.17624394595623016,
0.5234770178794861,
-0.3079822361469269,
0.779098391532898,
0.5735896229743958,
-0.3041702210903168,
-0.45874035358428955,
-0.6037085652351379,
0.027989324182271957,
-0.04930722340941429,
-0.6818574070930481,
0.005270317662507296,
-0.24422363936901093,
-0.28863391280174255,
-0.19349154829978943,
-0.009334086440503597,
-0.08775651454925537,
0.10512863099575043,
0.4933312237262726,
0.5527627468109131,
-0.1663689911365509,
-0.18629127740859985,
0.025640666484832764,
-0.4620017111301422,
0.15605966746807098,
0.03031199797987938,
0.6922607421875,
-0.011080482043325901,
0.21327683329582214,
-0.1810223013162613,
0.31411251425743103,
0.4641450345516205,
-0.20157401263713837,
0.9752081036567688,
0.22036977112293243,
-0.12664905190467834,
0.023057393729686737,
-0.40223655104637146,
0.17512495815753937,
-0.4500216543674469,
0.19832317531108856,
-0.5860437154769897,
-0.8220163583755493,
0.255704402923584,
-0.15008646249771118,
0.07325498014688492,
0.6998107433319092,
0.8309752345085144,
0.25284746289253235,
1.1103209257125854,
0.9381083846092224,
-0.19563588500022888,
0.5828930139541626,
-0.38531431555747986,
0.5311630964279175,
-0.8617429733276367,
-0.1861215978860855,
-0.835020899772644,
-0.3597938120365143,
-0.7754353284835815,
-0.0785897821187973,
0.24192224442958832,
-0.297726035118103,
0.05979679897427559,
0.7142276167869568,
-0.7544373869895935,
0.4611121714115143,
0.5924990773200989,
-0.3886394500732422,
-0.05620624125003815,
-0.11791547387838364,
-0.07132939994335175,
-0.08206796646118164,
-0.9387883543968201,
-0.7821823954582214,
0.983095645904541,
0.1269671469926834,
0.8201220035552979,
-0.08745666593313217,
0.3909044563770294,
-0.20032933354377747,
0.2209947109222412,
-0.7057532072067261,
0.4832221567630768,
-0.0222603902220726,
-0.7377611994743347,
-0.31052422523498535,
-0.413955420255661,
-0.6634529232978821,
0.23572005331516266,
-0.62916499376297,
-0.4051878750324249,
-0.039505500346422195,
0.11742707341909409,
0.10002417117357254,
0.2961876392364502,
-0.6149300932884216,
0.872829020023346,
0.08347276598215103,
0.4634353518486023,
0.3010580241680145,
-0.6563588380813599,
0.3843085765838623,
0.38500678539276123,
0.0591902919113636,
-0.05048760026693344,
0.17059355974197388,
0.876514196395874,
0.12761184573173523,
0.3999204933643341,
-0.12496422976255417,
0.23137371242046356,
0.1981620341539383,
0.15466254949569702,
0.4397766590118408,
-0.28403139114379883,
0.07264481484889984,
0.007355377543717623,
0.1755594164133072,
-0.07155387848615646,
-0.38077348470687866,
0.5236625671386719,
-0.6247568130493164,
-0.188114196062088,
-0.5174794793128967,
-0.4632295072078705,
0.13770826160907745,
0.20243708789348602,
0.721624493598938,
0.6413726210594177,
-0.4936225712299347,
0.3045711815357208,
0.5022722482681274,
-0.3581589162349701,
0.52230304479599,
0.4184403717517853,
-0.2168872058391571,
-0.21795877814292908,
0.6164772510528564,
0.1370970755815506,
0.2870274782180786,
0.09884762018918991,
0.11759572476148605,
0.17959408462047577,
-0.706080973148346,
-0.44882863759994507,
0.22596308588981628,
-0.4848285913467407,
-0.3244243264198303,
-1.0085279941558838,
-0.22769126296043396,
-0.5103341341018677,
-0.1329071819782257,
-0.45355385541915894,
-0.5439526438713074,
-0.2301611751317978,
0.01671619527041912,
0.22994045913219452,
1.2825007438659668,
0.3161170482635498,
0.3759479522705078,
-0.3902938663959503,
0.6460137963294983,
-0.16444246470928192,
0.4655931293964386,
-0.39467865228652954,
-0.2531270980834961,
-0.27113309502601624,
0.0840575322508812,
-0.335272878408432,
-0.7427807450294495,
0.7373387217521667,
-0.07773639261722565,
0.5482856631278992,
-0.07581677287817001,
-0.0459272600710392,
-0.09027272462844849,
-0.9846951961517334,
0.9578720927238464,
0.24593251943588257,
-0.9013546705245972,
0.6680997610092163,
-0.16743645071983337,
0.3399820327758789,
0.19405080378055573,
0.5254780054092407,
-0.7294254302978516,
-0.5734724402427673,
-0.6809447407722473,
-0.6882419586181641,
0.8926036953926086,
0.36020955443382263,
0.18683281540870667,
-0.14605090022087097,
0.5687924027442932,
0.14203289151191711,
-0.09063807129859924,
-0.9797780513763428,
-0.4770134389400482,
-0.28183260560035706,
-0.2652114927768707,
-0.10834266245365143,
-0.7314823269844055,
0.3265020251274109,
-0.41805601119995117,
0.9950791001319885,
-0.17810924351215363,
0.46124568581581116,
-0.22691710293293,
-0.19489648938179016,
-0.35313811898231506,
0.41749143600463867,
0.8583177924156189,
0.7933328747749329,
0.2791326642036438,
-0.1404547393321991,
0.23178604245185852,
-0.57441645860672,
0.17805351316928864,
-0.4894627332687378,
-0.4616808295249939,
0.3610594868659973,
-0.031955040991306305,
1.0353821516036987,
0.5729662179946899,
-0.34440702199935913,
0.5368161201477051,
-0.29861941933631897,
-0.5695889592170715,
-0.5586280226707458,
0.3667568266391754,
0.10905572026968002,
0.3122781217098236,
-0.01829354278743267,
0.2220081090927124,
0.32452070713043213,
-0.34608733654022217,
-0.14582031965255737,
0.45230039954185486,
-0.05848172679543495,
-0.4236406981945038,
0.43296578526496887,
-0.012846856378018856,
-0.5160288214683533,
0.41063281893730164,
-0.026403436437249184,
-0.9332228302955627,
0.364134818315506,
0.7753967642784119,
0.5794479846954346,
-0.3611416816711426,
0.450514018535614,
0.5153722167015076,
0.3218398988246918,
-0.5991351008415222,
0.4164138436317444,
0.10305553674697876,
-0.6637811660766602,
-0.40458807349205017,
-0.6731239557266235,
-0.4407677948474884,
-0.1558871567249298,
-0.7998741269111633,
0.19962537288665771,
-0.09806322306394577,
-0.4325546622276306,
0.0420767106115818,
0.12792640924453735,
-0.4759541153907776,
0.25282591581344604,
-0.1079082041978836,
0.6650434136390686,
-0.9780911207199097,
0.8707994818687439,
0.7247723937034607,
-0.15056432783603668,
-0.4911290407180786,
-0.5471736192703247,
-0.38262927532196045,
-0.12232004851102829,
1.0098669528961182,
-0.23709799349308014,
-0.0885884240269661,
-0.04750918969511986,
-0.6418226957321167,
-1.3835594654083252,
0.7720350623130798,
0.3217804729938507,
-0.43946799635887146,
-0.32664546370506287,
-0.06057818979024887,
0.634859561920166,
-0.3545895218849182,
0.046384409070014954,
0.6274264454841614,
0.2927999198436737,
0.07074171304702759,
-0.6187607645988464,
-0.4945540726184845,
-0.543781042098999,
0.7094594836235046,
0.5903699994087219,
-0.05606534704566002,
0.8991922736167908,
0.24712145328521729,
-0.40972188115119934,
0.40291133522987366,
0.8340734243392944,
-0.365065336227417,
-0.37909364700317383,
0.17277248203754425,
0.30798202753067017,
0.18118681013584137,
-0.35220739245414734,
1.299972653388977,
-0.43790435791015625,
0.2901894152164459,
0.9503787755966187,
0.08548391610383987,
0.6779041290283203,
0.3605145812034607,
-0.10636663436889648,
0.41064679622650146,
0.0983109325170517,
-0.2069467306137085,
0.33566081523895264,
0.40478822588920593,
-0.06989104300737381,
0.07868646830320358,
0.35655516386032104,
-0.04922325164079666,
0.5048271417617798,
-0.08785420656204224,
-0.4423977732658386,
-0.16762299835681915,
0.6369283199310303,
-0.29082268476486206,
0.10057103633880615,
-0.04475071281194687,
0.812760055065155,
-0.2944571077823639,
-0.5504759550094604,
0.2520913779735565,
0.33762672543525696,
0.900907576084137,
-0.42243725061416626,
0.22365346550941467,
0.19257576763629913,
0.008432160131633282,
0.06419125944375992,
-0.4262562096118927,
0.7634458541870117,
0.42972901463508606,
-0.5132901072502136,
-0.4367035925388336,
0.9073953628540039,
-0.33007821440696716,
-0.7837475538253784,
0.0016636839136481285,
0.12315378338098526,
0.3519596755504608,
0.1353801041841507,
-0.5017387866973877,
0.2345573455095291,
-0.0423479788005352,
-0.5118987560272217,
0.08187396824359894,
0.32212695479393005,
-0.03277992829680443,
0.8921597003936768,
0.3700733184814453,
0.4375671148300171,
0.5018432140350342,
0.1513081043958664,
0.8221014142036438,
-0.5610511898994446,
-0.5849674344062805,
-0.460824579000473,
0.2584952712059021,
0.010638860054314137,
-0.25131955742836,
0.7163528203964233,
0.5572367310523987,
0.8632387518882751,
-0.4278685450553894,
0.733269989490509,
-0.1838357299566269,
0.9662113785743713,
-0.35064443945884705,
0.9001216292381287,
0.05814269185066223,
-0.3513157367706299,
-0.3091566860675812,
-1.2228304147720337,
-0.23677870631217957,
1.0017002820968628,
-0.4043765068054199,
0.0613272488117218,
0.6347346305847168,
0.4112785756587982,
0.11887568980455399,
0.14366109669208527,
0.49027660489082336,
0.22771252691745758,
0.31704533100128174,
0.25072792172431946,
0.6983216404914856,
-0.6880640387535095,
0.24379540979862213,
-0.4046359658241272,
-0.00924515351653099,
-0.010673439130187035,
-0.7094476222991943,
-1.1371339559555054,
-0.8772811889648438,
-0.25113922357559204,
0.071382537484169,
-0.10164376348257065,
0.8850140571594238,
0.3966679275035858,
-0.7747641801834106,
-0.14591312408447266,
-0.0770290195941925,
-0.1426011472940445,
0.12058424949645996,
-0.16414178907871246,
-0.18891477584838867,
-0.3825279772281647,
-0.627593994140625,
0.2390967458486557,
0.24106204509735107,
0.32226237654685974,
-0.3273249864578247,
0.004424700513482094,
-0.316055566072464,
0.08241399377584457,
0.5752334594726562,
0.0893721655011177,
-0.6493666768074036,
-0.3280571401119232,
-0.052677471190690994,
-0.1105017215013504,
0.30175381898880005,
1.077043056488037,
-0.9015473127365112,
0.290392130613327,
0.6034413576126099,
0.23278535902500153,
0.47257083654403687,
-0.19459743797779083,
0.6649560332298279,
-0.4448915719985962,
0.19344888627529144,
0.17333127558231354,
0.30801722407341003,
0.5030944347381592,
-0.2007194310426712,
0.4759131669998169,
0.0573505200445652,
-0.5710650682449341,
-0.4878253638744354,
0.14274905622005463,
-0.8473727703094482,
-0.20866157114505768,
1.0277572870254517,
0.08252403885126114,
-0.5883690714836121,
-0.2442246377468109,
-0.4945681393146515,
0.5392503142356873,
0.13701161742210388,
0.4799906313419342,
0.8158988356590271,
0.06868253648281097,
-0.21143457293510437,
-0.7513492703437805,
0.5738266706466675,
-0.20626749098300934,
-0.7249705791473389,
-0.12423006445169449,
0.4017316997051239,
0.4958875775337219,
0.1832478940486908,
0.29484695196151733,
-0.11972054094076157,
0.09110784530639648,
-0.05537645146250725,
0.39331987500190735,
-0.10289102792739868,
-0.6314446330070496,
-0.37298813462257385,
0.12543822824954987,
-0.13647989928722382,
0.10965871810913086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14373v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14373v1
|
Small Language Model Is a Good Guide for Large Language Model in Chinese Entity Relation Extraction
| 2024-02-22T08:26:56 | 2024-02-22T08:26:56 |
Xuemei Tang, Jun Wang, Qi Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, large language models (LLMs) have been successful in relational
extraction (RE) tasks, especially in the few-shot learning. An important
problem in the field of RE is long-tailed data, while not much attention is
currently paid to this problem using LLM approaches. Therefore, in this paper,
we propose SLCoLM, a model collaboration framework, to mitigate the data
long-tail problem. In our framework, We use the
``\textit{Training-Guide-Predict}'' strategy to combine the strengths of
pre-trained language models (PLMs) and LLMs, where a task-specific PLM
framework acts as a tutor, transfers task knowledge to the LLM, and guides the
LLM in performing RE tasks. Our experiments on a RE dataset rich in relation
types show that the approach in this paper facilitates RE of long-tail relation
types.
|
[
-0.3375135660171509,
-0.5299530625343323,
0.6029474139213562,
0.11047085374593735,
-0.5101832747459412,
-0.174621120095253,
-0.46926119923591614,
-0.5306956171989441,
0.22458121180534363,
1.1120352745056152,
-0.6014910936355591,
-0.5312598943710327,
-0.25210338830947876,
-0.050878722220659256,
-0.1990126371383667,
1.050193190574646,
0.09299202263355255,
0.14787162840366364,
-0.2835697829723358,
-0.036009058356285095,
-0.3855980932712555,
-0.48643383383750916,
-0.9215154647827148,
-0.4011610746383667,
0.895005464553833,
0.3479117453098297,
0.6925127506256104,
0.673915445804596,
0.5839575529098511,
0.17372341454029083,
-0.030632980167865753,
0.32407134771347046,
-0.5995962619781494,
0.10820332169532776,
-0.4125532805919647,
-0.594563364982605,
-0.8181036114692688,
-0.11709502339363098,
0.7717761397361755,
0.9279599189758301,
-0.29192137718200684,
0.174134761095047,
0.1672326624393463,
0.6296800374984741,
-0.4264436662197113,
0.4453732967376709,
-0.630818784236908,
0.013952750712633133,
-0.2826720178127289,
0.14053314924240112,
-0.6891911625862122,
-0.0019049372058361769,
0.16480760276317596,
-0.505269467830658,
0.053980179131031036,
0.3930557370185852,
0.7972527742385864,
0.05592738091945648,
-0.34409859776496887,
-0.004533880855888128,
-0.7470515370368958,
0.8373476266860962,
-0.7524641156196594,
0.33417969942092896,
0.39190739393234253,
0.3674887418746948,
-0.45124050974845886,
-0.7902576327323914,
-0.4266622066497803,
-0.0517718568444252,
-0.3754268288612366,
-0.19602134823799133,
0.20775549113750458,
0.28842905163764954,
0.2983328104019165,
0.16932782530784607,
-0.42752376198768616,
0.3275705873966217,
-0.2820729613304138,
0.05188516527414322,
0.7293391227722168,
0.22526362538337708,
0.4214317798614502,
-0.1673508584499359,
-0.4018293619155884,
0.4157588481903076,
-1.1105517148971558,
-0.09213542193174362,
-0.19990302622318268,
0.7678624987602234,
-0.04563343897461891,
0.38610488176345825,
0.07589035481214523,
0.8237955570220947,
-0.10591516643762589,
-0.3704509735107422,
-0.018191808834671974,
-0.6399962306022644,
-0.421546071767807,
0.07467564940452576,
1.0618529319763184,
-0.01351257786154747,
0.28682374954223633,
-0.40687745809555054,
-0.320325642824173,
-0.3882597088813782,
-0.253083199262619,
-0.956676185131073,
-0.37376123666763306,
-0.12094923108816147,
-0.5388903021812439,
-0.021094176918268204,
0.06341957300901413,
-0.8434114456176758,
-0.23796051740646362,
-0.3746030330657959,
0.11681390553712845,
-0.3201349675655365,
-0.5891770720481873,
-0.1429082602262497,
0.36350002884864807,
0.2965501546859741,
0.29714909195899963,
-0.9493319988250732,
0.5576254725456238,
0.9984355568885803,
0.8743479251861572,
-0.6092846989631653,
-0.3258790075778961,
-1.1543736457824707,
0.5379523038864136,
-0.27590757608413696,
0.37561848759651184,
-0.30936530232429504,
-0.32868170738220215,
-0.05511403828859329,
0.3062729239463806,
-0.10041098296642303,
-0.5106049180030823,
0.2618979215621948,
-0.5011293888092041,
0.16400599479675293,
-0.24890102446079254,
-0.5020504593849182,
-0.04981803521513939,
-0.05081009864807129,
-1.0061798095703125,
0.7570368647575378,
0.01268994901329279,
-0.7915244698524475,
0.262668251991272,
-0.3829841911792755,
-0.4375714063644409,
0.29187190532684326,
-0.40921586751937866,
-0.6593883633613586,
-0.2823573052883148,
0.15342296659946442,
0.5571169257164001,
-0.5670800805091858,
0.3705098032951355,
-0.6626522541046143,
-0.3642726242542267,
-0.17973755300045013,
0.28509122133255005,
0.969763457775116,
0.15008561313152313,
0.035826921463012695,
0.023801829665899277,
-0.7038408517837524,
-0.04816470295190811,
0.06359560787677765,
-0.12274724245071411,
-0.720420777797699,
-0.003898771945387125,
-0.17732363939285278,
0.4764255881309509,
0.18577390909194946,
-0.20850346982479095,
0.4112483859062195,
-0.49123942852020264,
0.37186679244041443,
0.40190598368644714,
0.09849313646554947,
0.7729473114013672,
-0.12759138643741608,
0.5068843364715576,
0.1383388191461563,
-0.2678217887878418,
-0.14497418701648712,
-0.08137702196836472,
-0.9355369806289673,
-0.38208720088005066,
0.43722641468048096,
0.2813016474246979,
-1.0483356714248657,
0.3907138705253601,
-0.40619954466819763,
-0.3532133996486664,
-0.3953282833099365,
0.6062052845954895,
0.27443185448646545,
0.3810400068759918,
0.19627687335014343,
-0.3050106167793274,
-0.5885616540908813,
-0.7479855418205261,
-0.08054503798484802,
-0.11081448197364807,
0.16596871614456177,
0.2282119244337082,
0.4953639805316925,
-0.0470203198492527,
1.2737908363342285,
-0.4645850658416748,
-0.5851298570632935,
-0.6423205733299255,
0.08369817584753036,
0.42509180307388306,
0.6525465846061707,
0.5528057813644409,
-0.8884114623069763,
-0.7892547249794006,
-0.01878962852060795,
-0.7744600772857666,
0.17391206324100494,
-0.03911971673369408,
-0.27335548400878906,
0.11398680508136749,
0.40908145904541016,
-1.0284677743911743,
0.20340996980667114,
0.21150463819503784,
0.1797763556241989,
0.36348018050193787,
0.14057323336601257,
-0.46366870403289795,
-1.1338130235671997,
0.0014141034334897995,
0.12330363690853119,
-0.4354209005832672,
-0.6730645298957825,
0.19519522786140442,
0.03702719137072563,
-0.15489891171455383,
-0.5459839701652527,
0.45666876435279846,
-0.7575528621673584,
-0.3628290295600891,
-0.14658720791339874,
0.3251093626022339,
-0.1351277232170105,
0.5264840722084045,
0.5126935243606567,
0.5589292049407959,
0.5081846117973328,
-0.5336486101150513,
0.43406540155410767,
0.13165323436260223,
-0.18434211611747742,
0.3859587013721466,
-0.4427339434623718,
0.3565961420536041,
-0.05257173627614975,
0.13571161031723022,
-0.5079267024993896,
-0.017920413985848427,
0.3146473169326782,
-0.07614276558160782,
0.5508919954299927,
-0.35019591450691223,
-0.6353505253791809,
-0.3180794417858124,
-0.21917691826820374,
0.09899875521659851,
0.11326634138822556,
-0.6861517429351807,
0.7024678587913513,
0.3701421916484833,
-0.2846609354019165,
-0.6129911541938782,
-0.634791910648346,
0.0011790985008701682,
-0.40810295939445496,
-0.6947529911994934,
0.3874141275882721,
-0.07364073395729065,
-0.2754124402999878,
0.01834295131266117,
0.181446373462677,
-0.3653189539909363,
0.14766226708889008,
0.33816471695899963,
0.5603103041648865,
-0.370846152305603,
0.31558743119239807,
-0.35872766375541687,
-0.05169573426246643,
0.2310858815908432,
0.09012836217880249,
0.5243492722511292,
0.14147774875164032,
-0.027324482798576355,
-0.138272225856781,
0.21671675145626068,
0.25504451990127563,
-0.3833094835281372,
0.9158652424812317,
0.6789237260818481,
-0.5254064798355103,
-0.5353437066078186,
-0.16123440861701965,
-0.304896742105484,
-0.42632779479026794,
0.6314511895179749,
-0.36408522725105286,
-0.7404600977897644,
0.24190373718738556,
-0.05919048935174942,
0.005842817481607199,
0.10341189801692963,
0.313215434551239,
0.08117242157459259,
0.7850432395935059,
1.0212806463241577,
-0.7560762763023376,
0.38454172015190125,
-0.15320126712322235,
0.26302602887153625,
-0.689581036567688,
-0.06875862181186676,
-0.41042715311050415,
0.23574954271316528,
-0.3714320957660675,
-0.11269067227840424,
-0.02799380011856556,
0.4730170667171478,
-0.23498938977718353,
0.5453881621360779,
-0.12171978503465652,
0.283232718706131,
0.2883704900741577,
0.03463071212172508,
0.5007186532020569,
-0.07306823879480362,
0.14187879860401154,
-0.27372127771377563,
-0.8099287152290344,
-0.17605169117450714,
0.7507042288780212,
0.3985064625740051,
0.8122502565383911,
0.012822261080145836,
1.1091605424880981,
-0.1992981880903244,
0.3840881288051605,
-0.9234105348587036,
0.6666069030761719,
-0.2636263370513916,
-0.43800386786460876,
-0.43960559368133545,
-0.5997568964958191,
-0.8759075403213501,
0.28752848505973816,
-0.22422735393047333,
-0.7753276824951172,
-0.10046226531267166,
-0.11474328488111496,
-0.4424497187137604,
0.1379549503326416,
-0.3421655297279358,
0.7760658264160156,
-0.3337794542312622,
-0.6941095590591431,
0.02083521895110607,
-0.6174213290214539,
0.7266688346862793,
-0.35362017154693604,
0.4210633933544159,
-0.01314702071249485,
0.12619256973266602,
0.8858436346054077,
-0.5106080174446106,
0.7712131142616272,
-0.08673050254583359,
-0.06782181560993195,
0.3637475073337555,
0.16766400635242462,
0.8416614532470703,
0.03201507031917572,
-0.09009760618209839,
-0.16762755811214447,
-0.12593874335289001,
-0.08272191137075424,
-0.5097628831863403,
0.6847620606422424,
-0.5750060081481934,
-0.632114052772522,
-0.25897327065467834,
-0.45364341139793396,
-0.1661452054977417,
0.5070041418075562,
-0.008367346599698067,
0.046007830649614334,
-0.05556321144104004,
0.3592418432235718,
0.4983217120170593,
0.011851985938847065,
0.7256899476051331,
0.4902857542037964,
-0.6537950038909912,
-0.26774606108665466,
0.8900342583656311,
0.08796566724777222,
0.39154955744743347,
0.2350720763206482,
-0.06082367151975632,
0.05545448511838913,
-0.41995367407798767,
-0.11720092594623566,
0.6172090172767639,
-0.6163266897201538,
-0.208163782954216,
-0.29598668217658997,
-0.5364294052124023,
-0.31149959564208984,
0.30121374130249023,
-0.47675827145576477,
0.04800235852599144,
-0.5981847643852234,
-0.018840402364730835,
0.07500919699668884,
0.49558907747268677,
0.17426103353500366,
0.49964919686317444,
-0.9360093474388123,
0.05845325067639351,
0.2530585527420044,
-0.09466496109962463,
0.08824709802865982,
-0.2938404083251953,
-0.4871300756931305,
-0.008445415645837784,
0.015651635825634003,
-0.598217785358429,
0.7981465458869934,
0.2730143666267395,
0.5793675780296326,
0.36633387207984924,
0.06398720294237137,
0.746965229511261,
-0.28159329295158386,
0.8719157576560974,
0.4442625343799591,
-0.690380334854126,
0.3114016652107239,
-0.2737034857273102,
-0.12694810330867767,
0.4339213967323303,
0.541716456413269,
-0.35992464423179626,
-0.03550316393375397,
-0.42587727308273315,
-0.6127228736877441,
0.8632590770721436,
-0.008534357883036137,
-0.37784725427627563,
0.3373235762119293,
0.4120956063270569,
-0.034093018621206284,
0.4596099555492401,
-1.2196437120437622,
-0.28488245606422424,
0.345476359128952,
-0.07264727354049683,
-0.030485637485980988,
-0.258980929851532,
-0.08775795251131058,
-0.08355548977851868,
0.48679596185684204,
-0.16417081654071808,
-0.17968882620334625,
-0.20062263309955597,
-0.23763959109783173,
-0.311722069978714,
-0.015974534675478935,
0.07906227558851242,
0.8171252608299255,
-0.1702694445848465,
0.22559979557991028,
0.11244388669729233,
-0.11773687601089478,
-0.2748624384403229,
0.10441727936267853,
-0.16925595700740814,
0.021119531244039536,
0.6424177885055542,
0.5175208449363708,
0.14349927008152008,
-0.333197683095932,
0.6202547550201416,
0.09693597257137299,
-0.10318217426538467,
-0.4404427707195282,
0.12440192699432373,
0.42584463953971863,
0.16029596328735352,
0.24838311970233917,
-0.44222477078437805,
-0.15256266295909882,
-0.5594517588615417,
0.4891759157180786,
0.5100188255310059,
-0.3647843301296234,
-0.30436277389526367,
0.413289874792099,
0.10156840085983276,
-0.40971165895462036,
0.5977998375892639,
-0.17901363968849182,
-0.574549674987793,
0.556321382522583,
0.6354628801345825,
0.35501885414123535,
-0.1658058613538742,
-0.006714924704283476,
0.44683367013931274,
0.10054098069667816,
-0.4047772288322449,
-0.13032716512680054,
0.01870419830083847,
-0.7872581481933594,
-0.589567244052887,
-0.3999359607696533,
-0.13607178628444672,
0.4737210273742676,
-0.7855948209762573,
0.9288604259490967,
-0.4107295572757721,
0.11076679825782776,
0.0518115758895874,
0.38238969445228577,
-0.594405472278595,
0.06781674176454544,
0.2679747939109802,
0.5217412710189819,
-0.5254427790641785,
1.590725064277649,
0.24953196942806244,
-0.7871750593185425,
-1.0258415937423706,
-0.37750303745269775,
-0.10460177809000015,
-0.6181190609931946,
1.076480507850647,
0.21038584411144257,
-0.04903647303581238,
-0.06686802953481674,
-0.7824636697769165,
-0.8290691375732422,
1.2118734121322632,
0.3029080629348755,
-1.1318726539611816,
-0.5183834433555603,
0.13275869190692902,
0.35910341143608093,
-0.9554059505462646,
-0.013074471615254879,
0.7386264801025391,
0.2623838484287262,
0.037952445447444916,
-0.9419219493865967,
0.13258349895477295,
0.24972595274448395,
-0.09807152301073074,
0.2566507160663605,
-0.7241107821464539,
1.12434983253479,
-0.15637509524822235,
-0.2183343470096588,
0.30817338824272156,
0.8100752234458923,
0.3954854905605316,
0.2903130054473877,
0.7396310567855835,
0.193923681974411,
0.66278076171875,
0.3080894649028778,
0.3765544593334198,
-0.2638883590698242,
0.6147730946540833,
1.7642238140106201,
-0.6035400032997131,
0.9251434803009033,
0.6849114894866943,
-0.22264721989631653,
0.3790588080883026,
0.6663862466812134,
-0.10860620439052582,
0.5784211158752441,
0.08546819537878036,
-0.06824270635843277,
-0.5335099101066589,
-0.16861426830291748,
-0.3302824795246124,
0.2559191882610321,
0.5041301846504211,
-0.710498034954071,
-0.1183386966586113,
-0.23768219351768494,
0.23211419582366943,
0.05121125653386116,
-0.495838463306427,
0.709179162979126,
0.7312749624252319,
-0.6949949264526367,
0.39591026306152344,
-0.3014190196990967,
0.6556801199913025,
-0.49853193759918213,
-0.1927596777677536,
-0.16385062038898468,
0.12183604389429092,
-0.39991509914398193,
-0.45683035254478455,
0.06615202873945236,
-0.5325552225112915,
-0.15242278575897217,
0.19068661332130432,
1.0674723386764526,
-1.0813630819320679,
-0.28451913595199585,
0.7510812282562256,
0.7305954694747925,
0.020108196884393692,
-0.011054694652557373,
-0.6243579387664795,
-0.031064348295331,
0.10941708832979202,
-0.07297293841838837,
0.5834562182426453,
0.44216418266296387,
0.021826716139912605,
0.6811464428901672,
0.5576508641242981,
0.5950263142585754,
-0.34199830889701843,
-0.12534455955028534,
0.8706607818603516,
-0.7627857327461243,
-0.42492589354515076,
-1.0932509899139404,
0.06876157224178314,
-0.30028626322746277,
0.2348904013633728,
0.5870475769042969,
0.4214954674243927,
0.5454826354980469,
0.13450969755649567,
0.6301451325416565,
0.1936647742986679,
0.7937836050987244,
-0.44520315527915955,
0.8333449363708496,
-0.4997635781764984,
0.4191652834415436,
-0.2508135437965393,
-1.1124162673950195,
-0.22879645228385925,
0.46699970960617065,
-0.26753202080726624,
-0.1714293658733368,
0.730701744556427,
0.8264856934547424,
0.029623471200466156,
-0.018604017794132233,
0.2868022918701172,
0.09965994954109192,
0.4968351721763611,
0.906294584274292,
0.622037410736084,
-0.11450914293527603,
0.7632809281349182,
-0.5019442439079285,
0.1444721668958664,
-0.1092168316245079,
-0.974053144454956,
-1.2052230834960938,
-0.4248267114162445,
-0.08161797374486923,
-0.2704906463623047,
-0.043717268854379654,
1.208225965499878,
0.8563401103019714,
-0.5180605053901672,
-0.46546629071235657,
-0.007155195344239473,
0.29113927483558655,
-0.0012704582186415792,
-0.2151869833469391,
0.5274466872215271,
-0.16537532210350037,
-0.6633101105690002,
0.1811404824256897,
0.09541027247905731,
-0.03406233713030815,
-0.40691277384757996,
-0.3472355008125305,
-0.21439336240291595,
-0.6155335307121277,
0.4607442319393158,
0.23006875813007355,
-0.5951036810874939,
-0.33456429839134216,
-0.20768918097019196,
-0.38572078943252563,
0.05640535056591034,
0.7762912511825562,
-0.5332725048065186,
0.32761088013648987,
0.10707960277795792,
0.621994137763977,
0.7241026759147644,
-0.1318187713623047,
0.8700376152992249,
-0.5899254083633423,
0.39144423604011536,
0.10631610453128815,
0.5053780674934387,
0.3002482056617737,
-0.5315276384353638,
0.8444004058837891,
0.2674669027328491,
-0.5418176651000977,
-0.9721344709396362,
0.05246508866548538,
-0.9826908111572266,
-0.1237882450222969,
1.3914146423339844,
-0.5901666283607483,
-0.45107361674308777,
-0.032319020479917526,
-0.08391556143760681,
0.25027087330818176,
-0.38057541847229004,
0.2696908116340637,
0.7540871500968933,
0.04077032580971718,
-0.5644023418426514,
-0.47972866892814636,
0.6769357323646545,
0.2277752310037613,
-0.8100219964981079,
0.1771133989095688,
0.1633472740650177,
0.36179155111312866,
0.16739043593406677,
0.566631019115448,
0.23246118426322937,
0.19214566051959991,
-0.37222203612327576,
-0.014029307290911674,
-0.15184275805950165,
-0.3622177243232727,
-0.12657028436660767,
0.04521714523434639,
0.405793160200119,
-0.09710368514060974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14359v1
|
Rethinking Scientific Summarization Evaluation: Grounding Explainable Metrics on Facet-aware Benchmark
| 2024-02-22T07:58:29 | 2024-02-22T07:58:29 |
Xiuying Chen, Tairan Wang, Qingqing Zhu, Taicheng Guo, Shen Gao, Zhiyong Lu, Xin Gao, Xiangliang Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The summarization capabilities of pretrained and large language models (LLMs)
have been widely validated in general areas, but their use in scientific
corpus, which involves complex sentences and specialized knowledge, has been
less assessed. This paper presents conceptual and experimental analyses of
scientific summarization, highlighting the inadequacies of traditional
evaluation methods, such as $n$-gram, embedding comparison, and QA,
particularly in providing explanations, grasping scientific concepts, or
identifying key content. Subsequently, we introduce the Facet-aware Metric
(FM), employing LLMs for advanced semantic matching to evaluate summaries based
on different aspects. This facet-aware approach offers a thorough evaluation of
abstracts by decomposing the evaluation task into simpler subtasks.Recognizing
the absence of an evaluation benchmark in this domain, we curate a Facet-based
scientific summarization Dataset (FD) with facet-level annotations. Our
findings confirm that FM offers a more logical approach to evaluating
scientific summaries. In addition, fine-tuned smaller models can compete with
LLMs in scientific contexts, while LLMs have limitations in learning from
in-context information in scientific domains. This suggests an area for future
enhancement of LLMs.
|
[
-0.34298208355903625,
-0.17859771847724915,
0.7028800249099731,
0.5165596008300781,
-0.5224616527557373,
0.26838552951812744,
-0.22896543145179749,
-0.47605079412460327,
0.45843756198883057,
0.17918694019317627,
-0.37087681889533997,
-0.4987460672855377,
-0.661913275718689,
0.5145982503890991,
-0.40541160106658936,
1.473264455795288,
-0.12059956043958664,
0.19508345425128937,
-0.9442188739776611,
-0.18283376097679138,
-0.11373153328895569,
-0.18987874686717987,
-0.21626316010951996,
-0.48889175057411194,
0.6052100658416748,
-0.03896789625287056,
0.4992665648460388,
0.6205715537071228,
0.9381006360054016,
0.29777035117149353,
-0.40090465545654297,
0.07958416640758514,
-0.4504137635231018,
-0.13565510511398315,
-0.2637631893157959,
-0.5195373892784119,
-0.6372830867767334,
0.22896362841129303,
0.6056757569313049,
1.238816261291504,
0.2410309761762619,
0.22467462718486786,
-0.08135039359331131,
0.9664602875709534,
-0.5146870017051697,
0.40386882424354553,
-0.3919393718242645,
0.21410809457302094,
-0.024253783747553825,
-0.28983616828918457,
-0.046406012028455734,
-0.2852119505405426,
0.2739681005477905,
-0.6961982846260071,
0.37075018882751465,
0.0630018338561058,
0.5360659956932068,
0.33067482709884644,
-0.16936320066452026,
-0.1976390779018402,
-0.37699073553085327,
0.5919584035873413,
-0.7753699421882629,
0.19139763712882996,
0.11027593165636063,
0.4649699926376343,
-0.07313370704650879,
-0.7629507184028625,
-0.365591824054718,
-0.2966802716255188,
-0.11247143894433975,
0.6246957182884216,
-0.043741241097450256,
-0.19477835297584534,
0.06341981887817383,
0.5859494805335999,
-0.6019343137741089,
-0.07878116518259048,
-0.3740748167037964,
0.023297185078263283,
0.5199611186981201,
0.17506767809391022,
0.07574110478162766,
-0.21474479138851166,
-0.23760439455509186,
0.10161127150058746,
-0.8732883930206299,
-0.1646159291267395,
-0.09518619626760483,
0.15039607882499695,
-0.2105512171983719,
0.7552271485328674,
-0.41130557656288147,
0.4206984341144562,
-0.07683143019676208,
-0.024224502965807915,
0.29592856764793396,
-0.6665909886360168,
0.013587810099124908,
0.009523707441985607,
0.6112783551216125,
0.7606277465820312,
0.28801193833351135,
-0.3321978747844696,
-0.14690245687961578,
0.13242772221565247,
0.1455753594636917,
-1.0685127973556519,
-0.172514870762825,
0.19246520102024078,
-0.39160993695259094,
-0.42659345269203186,
-0.2298368662595749,
-0.45527827739715576,
-0.253868043422699,
-0.36584311723709106,
0.4488082230091095,
-0.30062511563301086,
-0.046751681715250015,
-0.0014180900761857629,
-0.2837478220462799,
-0.15428851544857025,
0.6477789878845215,
-0.7317123413085938,
0.3288203477859497,
0.8588000535964966,
1.1501461267471313,
-0.2538571357727051,
-0.33175405859947205,
-0.03863510116934776,
-0.06079849600791931,
-0.21612335741519928,
1.1076948642730713,
-0.20725871622562408,
-0.4491935074329376,
-0.58075350522995,
-0.21490293741226196,
-0.10471826791763306,
-0.5138228535652161,
0.013620001263916492,
-0.4493948519229889,
0.20186372101306915,
-0.49656444787979126,
-0.3419897258281708,
-0.21178103983402252,
0.10009622573852539,
-0.3357231318950653,
0.5723118782043457,
0.10569034516811371,
-0.9993793964385986,
0.5684795379638672,
-0.7634456753730774,
-0.5382822155952454,
0.04264507070183754,
-0.10561440885066986,
-0.2265166938304901,
0.32486626505851746,
0.396232008934021,
0.5500587821006775,
-0.23114421963691711,
0.4416511356830597,
-0.17987486720085144,
-0.3289094567298889,
0.12533517181873322,
-0.004643030930310488,
0.3554530441761017,
0.252491295337677,
-0.11124341934919357,
0.36619898676872253,
-0.5010935664176941,
-0.2122911661863327,
-0.05054596811532974,
-0.025532850995659828,
-0.37749433517456055,
0.1715552657842636,
-0.24526777863502502,
-0.02396486885845661,
0.12044414132833481,
-0.5685321092605591,
-0.1534116119146347,
-0.4923975467681885,
0.6042637825012207,
0.43865057826042175,
-0.11666763573884964,
0.29317739605903625,
-0.5159006118774414,
0.3840455412864685,
-0.26779472827911377,
-0.16215969622135162,
-0.4226306080818176,
-0.14318051934242249,
-0.18161995708942413,
-0.5801853537559509,
0.35655462741851807,
0.42186179757118225,
-0.5341272354125977,
0.1194046214222908,
-0.7071675658226013,
-0.6660745143890381,
-0.42724764347076416,
-0.09555646032094955,
0.4044889211654663,
0.735901951789856,
0.3833811283111572,
-0.40573298931121826,
-0.41331836581230164,
-0.857286810874939,
-0.5106486678123474,
-0.04211212322115898,
-0.3648395240306854,
0.20670221745967865,
0.87067049741745,
0.07869803160429001,
1.03956937789917,
-0.27009323239326477,
0.008078494109213352,
-0.37835052609443665,
0.15553192794322968,
0.30594301223754883,
0.2332543134689331,
0.5609250068664551,
-0.5286665558815002,
-0.2206096649169922,
-0.030880549922585487,
-1.2383724451065063,
-0.4460991322994232,
0.004976645577698946,
0.3055666387081146,
-0.3592110276222229,
0.47444576025009155,
-0.5806096196174622,
0.28544190526008606,
0.23428818583488464,
-0.1613837033510208,
0.7920828461647034,
-0.09632407873868942,
0.37363213300704956,
-0.5928717255592346,
0.18980151414871216,
-0.1357596218585968,
-0.32233452796936035,
-0.31167811155319214,
0.1297290176153183,
0.15878215432167053,
-0.024688225239515305,
-0.4403960704803467,
0.4228023886680603,
-0.4257810711860657,
-0.4966684877872467,
-0.5336465835571289,
0.6490761041641235,
0.1708245724439621,
-0.00886654295027256,
0.2851588726043701,
0.7430548071861267,
0.2216290980577469,
-0.47692444920539856,
0.037959806621074677,
0.2616266906261444,
-0.44725754857063293,
0.6538277864456177,
-1.0667858123779297,
-0.47435706853866577,
-0.5158354640007019,
0.7453888058662415,
-0.7210660576820374,
-0.0811125859618187,
-0.2521402835845947,
-0.4094454050064087,
0.03389627858996391,
0.27521997690200806,
-0.3420718014240265,
-0.12207009643316269,
-0.6053748726844788,
0.5112062692642212,
0.35133111476898193,
-0.4632123112678528,
0.4472603499889374,
0.04297229275107384,
-0.62542724609375,
-0.4653618335723877,
-0.45135217905044556,
0.2829945981502533,
-0.3000035583972931,
-0.7733796834945679,
0.6332470178604126,
-0.10176163166761398,
-0.48370611667633057,
0.022383661940693855,
-0.5908053517341614,
0.5895036458969116,
0.3421478867530823,
0.23805774748325348,
0.12448897957801819,
-0.24573935568332672,
-0.117184579372406,
0.15295608341693878,
-0.18372982740402222,
0.24120566248893738,
0.12158246338367462,
0.11176493018865585,
-0.34266340732574463,
-0.20754951238632202,
-0.19014407694339752,
0.32490524649620056,
0.580392062664032,
-0.18886910378932953,
0.33912739157676697,
0.35492751002311707,
-0.3460157811641693,
0.2098362296819687,
-0.3673335909843445,
-0.31111037731170654,
-0.3470684587955475,
0.5648936033248901,
-0.2822871506214142,
-0.8605396747589111,
0.7193334102630615,
-0.25427013635635376,
0.25392794609069824,
0.7316508293151855,
0.4712464213371277,
-0.3132636547088623,
0.7469074130058289,
0.42323699593544006,
0.31989341974258423,
0.1714768409729004,
-0.032383378595113754,
0.061062224209308624,
-1.217119574546814,
-0.35481691360473633,
-0.5330826640129089,
-0.019740531221032143,
-0.2276294231414795,
-0.28899723291397095,
0.5613409876823425,
0.197969451546669,
0.05405868962407112,
0.2082977294921875,
-0.2687118649482727,
0.7493736147880554,
-0.029563747346401215,
-0.11212428659200668,
0.48883241415023804,
-0.2807992398738861,
-0.018561119213700294,
-0.1303367167711258,
-0.6822766661643982,
-0.56132572889328,
0.9723285436630249,
0.37729185819625854,
0.47757455706596375,
0.01236812025308609,
0.5691102743148804,
0.10618966072797775,
0.859028697013855,
-0.799736499786377,
0.4154210090637207,
-0.2595687508583069,
-0.11999896168708801,
-0.13851043581962585,
-0.5290951728820801,
-0.5644254088401794,
0.8279224038124084,
-0.20151349902153015,
-0.32278206944465637,
-0.17066392302513123,
-0.1584143191576004,
-0.4365023970603943,
-0.17195506393909454,
-0.5799924731254578,
0.6039601564407349,
-0.22789505124092102,
0.07557611167430878,
-0.26020026206970215,
-0.6812318563461304,
0.6508818864822388,
-0.2921818494796753,
0.591631293296814,
-0.25598832964897156,
0.022667456418275833,
1.0872890949249268,
-0.4359595775604248,
0.6648067831993103,
0.004236727952957153,
0.12349483370780945,
-0.20172056555747986,
0.012888014316558838,
0.07633662223815918,
0.3913852274417877,
0.10340573638677597,
0.1758701205253601,
0.3043871521949768,
-0.41370972990989685,
-0.6942096948623657,
0.7266436815261841,
-0.4883174002170563,
-0.6813322305679321,
-0.5497939586639404,
-0.6376585960388184,
-0.24897506833076477,
0.05646972358226776,
0.10266392678022385,
0.0830109640955925,
-0.19401462376117706,
0.1995568722486496,
0.6077976822853088,
-0.24963226914405823,
0.2974512279033661,
0.8637745976448059,
-0.42889150977134705,
-0.44260749220848083,
0.6905133128166199,
-0.009095119312405586,
0.34192946553230286,
0.3566635847091675,
0.3584994971752167,
0.01767532154917717,
-0.826277494430542,
-0.25827524065971375,
0.3451801836490631,
-0.6522581577301025,
-0.2560431659221649,
-0.9065166115760803,
0.02385266311466694,
-0.4331934154033661,
-0.285837322473526,
-0.3659549355506897,
-0.6425014138221741,
-0.04812673106789589,
-0.1931304931640625,
0.35682329535484314,
0.6436712145805359,
-0.19532403349876404,
0.2903658449649811,
-0.4345810115337372,
0.3932761549949646,
-0.027878588065505028,
0.2879444360733032,
-0.03176455199718475,
-0.5347968339920044,
-0.2838670313358307,
-0.11645446717739105,
0.08778047561645508,
-0.5874847769737244,
0.24068361520767212,
0.3186858296394348,
0.5073747038841248,
0.1696004420518875,
-0.243936225771904,
0.7326036691665649,
-0.6656006574630737,
0.8201765418052673,
0.12366658449172974,
-0.9094340205192566,
0.5539376139640808,
-0.2775254547595978,
0.5786997675895691,
0.646568238735199,
0.2554154396057129,
-0.5122808218002319,
-0.4640829265117645,
-0.3914828896522522,
-1.0967068672180176,
0.33030661940574646,
0.09884494543075562,
-0.17735980451107025,
-0.04579769819974899,
0.41186758875846863,
0.4755363166332245,
0.40288951992988586,
-0.49108925461769104,
0.06553103029727936,
-0.5455653667449951,
-0.13150224089622498,
-0.4074610769748688,
0.02953321672976017,
-0.28252318501472473,
-0.211996927857399,
0.5038873553276062,
-0.10790159553289413,
0.16654157638549805,
0.34687158465385437,
-0.5157244801521301,
0.16858285665512085,
0.08435343205928802,
0.8899306058883667,
0.9101279973983765,
-0.5140182971954346,
0.25792738795280457,
0.04819134995341301,
-0.5182899236679077,
-0.4012538194656372,
0.1507081389427185,
-0.052551690489053726,
0.03075578063726425,
0.9206640124320984,
0.4873780608177185,
0.5127332806587219,
-0.67919921875,
0.5023534893989563,
-0.07312788814306259,
-0.2599606215953827,
-0.09724511951208115,
-0.22583191096782684,
0.30970725417137146,
0.06972187757492065,
0.47866275906562805,
0.04158305376768112,
0.2038269340991974,
-0.3449259102344513,
0.21033792197704315,
0.5827170014381409,
-0.06046494096517563,
-0.53266441822052,
0.669278085231781,
0.18117915093898773,
0.10988420993089676,
0.10478998720645905,
0.18755236268043518,
-0.5041511654853821,
0.6686053276062012,
0.48550063371658325,
0.7970932126045227,
0.07044040411710739,
0.2766558527946472,
0.10140371322631836,
0.48836684226989746,
0.0007183534908108413,
0.06564085185527802,
-0.15625624358654022,
-0.4376537799835205,
-0.768305778503418,
-0.8142359256744385,
-0.6114383935928345,
-0.17048953473567963,
-0.5527787208557129,
-0.13998448848724365,
-0.5176025629043579,
0.1688930094242096,
0.6700484752655029,
-0.062395013868808746,
-0.5674563050270081,
0.1354883909225464,
-0.3450821340084076,
0.9610052704811096,
-1.048575520515442,
0.166441410779953,
0.464108407497406,
-0.4256282150745392,
-0.12238095700740814,
-0.4914344549179077,
0.1104171946644783,
-0.6472734212875366,
0.7094299793243408,
0.17806826531887054,
-0.05640412122011185,
-0.3571687936782837,
-0.4388395845890045,
-0.8249520659446716,
1.265154480934143,
0.07474270462989807,
-0.3605697453022003,
0.27594396471977234,
-0.19775980710983276,
0.875981330871582,
-0.7170524597167969,
0.5949500799179077,
0.5584369897842407,
0.5395607948303223,
0.1174134835600853,
-0.9973874092102051,
0.21552731096744537,
-0.40266507863998413,
-0.15556277334690094,
-0.09714899212121964,
-0.5274554491043091,
0.6750061511993408,
-0.38775819540023804,
-0.14534041285514832,
-0.08618316799402237,
0.7245919108390808,
0.24825717508792877,
0.6987600922584534,
0.16057011485099792,
0.2876969575881958,
0.4660489857196808,
-0.21050214767456055,
1.0634276866912842,
0.03252895921468735,
0.13157257437705994,
1.0829395055770874,
-0.45984357595443726,
0.584701657295227,
0.6413264870643616,
-0.4715118408203125,
0.3014240264892578,
0.7818723320960999,
-0.05185141786932945,
0.5819699168205261,
0.4812382459640503,
-0.025995172560214996,
0.004353724420070648,
-0.1431325525045395,
-0.6191275119781494,
0.34039559960365295,
0.3841533362865448,
-0.36664342880249023,
-0.6162621378898621,
0.029580987989902496,
0.09491679072380066,
0.17450086772441864,
-0.325210303068161,
0.825756311416626,
0.24523305892944336,
-0.3714703321456909,
0.49829167127609253,
0.07141353189945221,
0.6557739973068237,
-0.5170468091964722,
0.10095372051000595,
-0.3880445957183838,
-0.2416304498910904,
-0.502286970615387,
-0.5106855630874634,
0.5025396943092346,
0.20844347774982452,
-0.2871186137199402,
-0.1534355878829956,
0.26886212825775146,
-0.193786159157753,
-0.3689699172973633,
-0.11087702959775925,
0.539677619934082,
0.5567867159843445,
-0.1634482741355896,
-0.25295206904411316,
-0.06967893242835999,
-0.20611339807510376,
-0.335410475730896,
0.5839729309082031,
0.2717341184616089,
-0.2959511876106262,
0.6762402057647705,
0.736585795879364,
0.1253158152103424,
-0.45838209986686707,
0.27136164903640747,
0.7691516280174255,
-0.7242054343223572,
-0.42158085107803345,
-0.7138118147850037,
0.3621709644794464,
0.0717758983373642,
-0.17485670745372772,
0.7983272671699524,
0.5817311406135559,
0.44204023480415344,
-0.16786763072013855,
0.7982596755027771,
0.10394018143415451,
0.4719519019126892,
-0.5309028029441833,
0.859753429889679,
-0.3301464915275574,
0.545701801776886,
-0.46696484088897705,
-1.0635192394256592,
-0.5646406412124634,
0.542901873588562,
-0.37541747093200684,
0.25693196058273315,
0.9327835440635681,
0.28855571150779724,
0.07647009938955307,
0.2904996871948242,
0.054280854761600494,
0.19292914867401123,
0.2809731364250183,
0.17889860272407532,
0.6099608540534973,
-0.18879017233848572,
0.018271401524543762,
-0.09518677741289139,
-0.6633233428001404,
-0.19485244154930115,
-1.312119960784912,
-0.895606517791748,
-0.19896012544631958,
-0.3934619426727295,
0.03302249684929848,
0.22472983598709106,
0.6443365216255188,
0.28102317452430725,
-0.6971977949142456,
0.038077592849731445,
0.17939229309558868,
0.08008945733308792,
-0.40691283345222473,
-0.18272951245307922,
0.7185289263725281,
-0.1631755381822586,
-0.4580146372318268,
0.6577457189559937,
0.5154538154602051,
0.06536296755075455,
-0.25250551104545593,
0.20252777636051178,
0.1335410177707672,
0.12774558365345,
0.7896637320518494,
0.16125935316085815,
-0.707937479019165,
-0.19179655611515045,
-0.006082502659410238,
0.30599650740623474,
-0.230031356215477,
0.766761064529419,
-1.081458330154419,
0.255357563495636,
0.4093745946884155,
0.5409303903579712,
0.5623956322669983,
0.10776980221271515,
0.5856527090072632,
-0.5030549168586731,
-0.3114529550075531,
0.30918195843696594,
0.18664903938770294,
0.5815740823745728,
-0.14636804163455963,
0.6821198463439941,
0.17630217969417572,
-0.3517758250236511,
-1.0546228885650635,
-0.08398765325546265,
-1.0562807321548462,
-0.21760660409927368,
0.7516363263130188,
-0.3067437708377838,
-0.24819588661193848,
0.123090960085392,
0.2080080360174179,
0.00030149423400871456,
-0.0899420753121376,
1.0141288042068481,
0.8240361213684082,
-0.28747719526290894,
0.08214970678091049,
-0.5355565547943115,
0.4024406969547272,
0.6430584192276001,
-0.9349890947341919,
0.11716179549694061,
0.3582890033721924,
0.5294765830039978,
0.31513574719429016,
0.4222894012928009,
-0.5381661653518677,
0.41728782653808594,
-0.17327414453029633,
-0.07280188798904419,
-0.536041796207428,
-0.22828084230422974,
-0.36721548438072205,
-0.011195547878742218,
-0.17499259114265442,
0.3233153820037842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14355v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14355v2
|
Rule or Story, Which is a Better Commonsense Expression for Talking with Large Language Models?
| 2024-02-22T07:55:26 | 2024-06-04T08:05:51 |
Ning Bian, Xianpei Han, Hongyu Lin, Yaojie Lu, Ben He, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Building machines with commonsense has been a longstanding challenge in NLP
due to the reporting bias of commonsense rules and the exposure bias of
rule-based commonsense reasoning. In contrast, humans convey and pass down
commonsense implicitly through stories. This paper investigates the inherent
commonsense ability of large language models (LLMs) expressed through
storytelling. We systematically investigate and compare stories and rules for
retrieving and leveraging commonsense in LLMs. Experimental results on 28
commonsense QA datasets show that stories outperform rules as the expression
for retrieving commonsense from LLMs, exhibiting higher generation confidence
and commonsense accuracy. Moreover, stories are the more effective commonsense
expression for answering questions regarding daily events, while rules are more
effective for scientific questions. This aligns with the reporting bias of
commonsense in text corpora. We further show that the correctness and relevance
of commonsense stories can be further improved via iterative self-supervised
fine-tuning. These findings emphasize the importance of using appropriate
language to express, retrieve, and leverage commonsense for LLMs, highlighting
a promising direction for better exploiting their commonsense abilities.
|
[
-0.06437893211841583,
-0.5625202655792236,
0.7946126461029053,
0.23917029798030853,
-0.24344590306282043,
-0.19853590428829193,
-0.37707599997520447,
-0.5910474061965942,
-0.015534373000264168,
0.5064293146133423,
-0.33613163232803345,
-0.3237917125225067,
-0.6481010913848877,
0.3124627470970154,
-0.2766697108745575,
0.9265646934509277,
0.17634011805057526,
-0.17012664675712585,
-0.5071855783462524,
-0.17049483954906464,
-0.4890494644641876,
-0.4434574246406555,
-0.4588008224964142,
-0.33583641052246094,
0.8411691784858704,
0.3263264000415802,
0.8246909379959106,
0.7592373490333557,
0.18025274574756622,
0.35981684923171997,
-0.19859257340431213,
0.46945181488990784,
-0.5011181831359863,
-0.04291690140962601,
-0.4811916947364807,
-0.3310827612876892,
-0.06854231655597687,
0.14355140924453735,
0.3150290548801422,
0.6587215662002563,
-0.09313453733921051,
0.32770606875419617,
-0.03832508623600006,
0.5663179159164429,
-0.38604414463043213,
0.12519226968288422,
-0.507790207862854,
0.15359345078468323,
0.06915518641471863,
-0.31932511925697327,
-0.2786789536476135,
-0.2877114713191986,
0.17205864191055298,
-0.6431387662887573,
0.0821944922208786,
0.34633928537368774,
0.8251922726631165,
0.12344469875097275,
-0.3646748960018158,
-0.5747386813163757,
-0.2237735241651535,
0.8816362023353577,
-0.9966843128204346,
0.35346293449401855,
0.3038451075553894,
0.15101025998592377,
0.11889803409576416,
-0.7630393505096436,
-0.7867702841758728,
-0.6538805961608887,
-0.4560769498348236,
-0.2681112587451935,
-0.34331029653549194,
-0.293540358543396,
0.39562588930130005,
0.24428991973400116,
-0.5060808658599854,
0.6298608183860779,
-0.590821385383606,
0.038450080901384354,
0.7452691197395325,
0.20109155774116516,
0.24706591665744781,
-0.5276438593864441,
-0.4857129454612732,
0.019369782879948616,
-0.8037519454956055,
-0.23335793614387512,
0.4709152281284332,
0.33808428049087524,
-0.2417534589767456,
0.5929805636405945,
-0.39232996106147766,
0.5822147727012634,
-0.057989977300167084,
-0.2769717574119568,
0.23453682661056519,
-0.26450619101524353,
-0.05893273279070854,
0.06216597557067871,
0.7490976452827454,
0.7250933647155762,
0.5453024506568909,
-0.2778732180595398,
-0.23199136555194855,
-0.19850006699562073,
0.12999950349330902,
-0.7031486630439758,
-0.004457009956240654,
0.2130572497844696,
-0.5612873435020447,
-0.4717317819595337,
-0.31050026416778564,
-0.837334394454956,
-0.7615857124328613,
-0.5045354962348938,
0.4511721432209015,
-0.0730748176574707,
-0.3692866265773773,
0.3045884370803833,
-0.37069088220596313,
0.1913759410381317,
0.3029371201992035,
-1.1058765649795532,
0.23591257631778717,
0.9854883551597595,
0.8418238162994385,
-0.22114798426628113,
-0.3056153357028961,
-0.6823805570602417,
-0.021585410460829735,
-0.5030853152275085,
0.6151102185249329,
-0.3753325045108795,
-0.09882011264562607,
-0.013980726711452007,
-0.211580291390419,
-0.0042723738588392735,
-0.7640936970710754,
0.7283344268798828,
-0.3293875753879547,
0.11612141132354736,
-0.2217632234096527,
-0.6823790669441223,
0.07307378947734833,
0.06301043182611465,
-0.5323411226272583,
0.4388422667980194,
-0.2567235231399536,
-0.6272475123405457,
0.26875922083854675,
-0.852180540561676,
-0.4683660566806793,
0.09976871311664581,
0.01691640540957451,
-0.09029432386159897,
0.18807527422904968,
0.4509541690349579,
0.830436646938324,
-0.02641642652451992,
0.5895651578903198,
-0.2209702730178833,
-0.09347420185804367,
0.5292792916297913,
-0.6963435411453247,
0.7660718560218811,
0.4257250130176544,
-0.03129985183477402,
-0.07599479705095291,
-0.5027687549591064,
-0.24442152678966522,
0.3241834342479706,
-0.1082024946808815,
-0.22992895543575287,
0.1705644726753235,
-0.13367566466331482,
0.14495675265789032,
0.15786957740783691,
-0.5649620294570923,
0.12672796845436096,
-0.2551215589046478,
0.6573501825332642,
0.7378196716308594,
0.010973485186696053,
0.36058035492897034,
-0.6525734066963196,
0.1414562612771988,
-0.21877548098564148,
-0.018920207396149635,
-0.1352052092552185,
-0.2449083924293518,
-0.39357346296310425,
-0.06493782997131348,
-0.04086057096719742,
0.2654593586921692,
-0.5421145558357239,
0.02312045358121395,
-0.32143479585647583,
-0.4141087234020233,
-0.46812403202056885,
0.2938484251499176,
0.3616084158420563,
0.6331717371940613,
0.3857743442058563,
0.18717388808727264,
-0.44101810455322266,
-0.9430105090141296,
-0.5464792251586914,
-0.04622194543480873,
-0.12189304828643799,
0.4781913459300995,
0.35430362820625305,
0.25726473331451416,
0.6749845743179321,
-0.6322901248931885,
-0.07452501356601715,
-0.5386263728141785,
0.24787737429141998,
0.3041895627975464,
0.26241469383239746,
0.32759588956832886,
-0.9727262258529663,
-0.32525280117988586,
-0.09952781349420547,
-0.7554177641868591,
-0.3119262158870697,
-0.2536616027355194,
0.27899500727653503,
0.40700259804725647,
0.5601585507392883,
-0.813313901424408,
-0.041907899081707,
0.6268808245658875,
-0.4216914176940918,
0.776995062828064,
-0.173891082406044,
0.1195128783583641,
-0.7022803425788879,
-0.03260587528347969,
0.03130847588181496,
-0.3073873817920685,
-0.4751892685890198,
0.1589381843805313,
-0.09575441479682922,
-0.016849838197231293,
-0.7137413024902344,
0.8060952425003052,
-0.492176353931427,
-0.3240847885608673,
-0.10499653965234756,
0.4007265865802765,
0.08092077821493149,
0.34030434489250183,
0.23201443254947662,
0.6937457919120789,
0.3249874711036682,
-0.6843404769897461,
0.526945173740387,
0.11856480687856674,
-0.6247026920318604,
0.5757290720939636,
-0.6734855771064758,
-0.05800974741578102,
-0.15265695750713348,
0.05798688903450966,
-0.44393426179885864,
-0.12420191615819931,
-0.10544423758983612,
-0.4558071792125702,
0.20529228448867798,
0.02794942446053028,
-0.9718552231788635,
-0.44478681683540344,
-0.08755560219287872,
-0.15230633318424225,
0.5023922920227051,
-0.9757147431373596,
0.3612994849681854,
0.24793314933776855,
-0.27357354760169983,
-0.6460962891578674,
-0.5309525728225708,
0.30581042170524597,
-0.5972086787223816,
-0.5982357263565063,
-0.08035483211278915,
-0.049338530749082565,
-0.4794043004512787,
-0.12854434549808502,
-0.15790389478206635,
0.056349679827690125,
0.12413734942674637,
0.0316581055521965,
-0.017801480367779732,
-0.26366668939590454,
0.4020567536354065,
-0.27114856243133545,
-0.03149433434009552,
0.18811193108558655,
0.020209642127156258,
0.5831331014633179,
-0.20752859115600586,
-0.02733961120247841,
-0.46694859862327576,
0.37995773553848267,
0.4325132369995117,
-0.145548015832901,
0.5748417973518372,
0.2395910769701004,
0.10897798836231232,
-0.3185538649559021,
-0.6394407749176025,
-0.4018716514110565,
-0.5292585492134094,
0.41676998138427734,
-0.2975129783153534,
-0.9723541140556335,
0.12390398234128952,
0.013515491969883442,
0.2075514793395996,
0.5879443883895874,
0.39249351620674133,
-0.3839821517467499,
0.5812154412269592,
0.5656173229217529,
0.08991754800081253,
0.05728675425052643,
0.17236705124378204,
0.23709750175476074,
-0.7744123339653015,
0.021645909175276756,
-0.41765084862709045,
-0.24951419234275818,
-0.4777093529701233,
-0.34261658787727356,
0.19108951091766357,
-0.1020701676607132,
-0.22999390959739685,
0.2858758866786957,
-0.3188152313232422,
0.693956196308136,
0.511395275592804,
0.021475782617926598,
0.7706683874130249,
-0.14326125383377075,
0.2592584788799286,
-0.07443205267190933,
-0.8541985154151917,
-0.7360498309135437,
0.8664137721061707,
0.5396141409873962,
0.7041444182395935,
0.19948425889015198,
0.6368195414543152,
0.23014171421527863,
0.07569414377212524,
-0.5108054280281067,
0.6371786594390869,
-0.40731531381607056,
-0.5940129160881042,
-0.49377405643463135,
-0.569012463092804,
-0.8528444766998291,
0.2321022003889084,
-0.30178102850914,
-0.9053705930709839,
0.025499509647488594,
0.1147475615143776,
-0.4224430322647095,
0.44064271450042725,
-0.7851320505142212,
1.0147794485092163,
-0.34610557556152344,
-0.28969404101371765,
-0.40769052505493164,
-0.6216138005256653,
0.43776896595954895,
0.06423510611057281,
0.21408526599407196,
-0.21166928112506866,
-0.03683480620384216,
0.6170238256454468,
-0.1817048192024231,
1.1729588508605957,
0.18707413971424103,
-0.24312622845172882,
0.277383953332901,
0.07637582719326019,
0.4801451563835144,
0.07960499078035355,
0.04957154020667076,
0.21073882281780243,
0.05652555450797081,
-0.2572654187679291,
-0.6001272797584534,
0.8081784844398499,
-0.751655638217926,
-0.8331152200698853,
-0.3011094927787781,
-0.621444582939148,
-0.2106684148311615,
-0.05096450448036194,
0.03600100800395012,
0.49545910954475403,
0.0016510412096977234,
0.2063702642917633,
0.7091719508171082,
-0.5006822943687439,
0.6629927158355713,
0.6338876485824585,
-0.1569778472185135,
0.09556597471237183,
0.9237685203552246,
0.08340661972761154,
0.6234116554260254,
0.5789544582366943,
0.6415533423423767,
-0.4883006811141968,
-0.4917484521865845,
-0.5106631517410278,
0.3704512417316437,
-0.6379680633544922,
-0.4522137939929962,
-0.970891535282135,
-0.2812110185623169,
-0.39182209968566895,
-0.36095184087753296,
-0.29617735743522644,
-0.5540400743484497,
-0.2405671775341034,
-0.4317530691623688,
0.588614284992218,
0.5080711841583252,
-0.43053480982780457,
-0.047440964728593826,
-0.7410488724708557,
0.4727689325809479,
0.6342906951904297,
0.16712266206741333,
0.029176540672779083,
-0.43988537788391113,
0.12509576976299286,
-0.14153248071670532,
0.008594144135713577,
-0.7545295357704163,
0.46129435300827026,
0.002197078661993146,
0.5216734409332275,
0.2844542860984802,
0.2841993570327759,
0.4461192488670349,
-0.467632532119751,
0.7007260918617249,
0.19311103224754333,
-0.6980324983596802,
0.23777170479297638,
-0.5137292146682739,
0.2671325206756592,
0.19543561339378357,
0.34911996126174927,
-0.8527263402938843,
-0.38762664794921875,
-0.6882005333900452,
-0.7205223441123962,
0.3466443717479706,
-0.09781785309314728,
0.6516003012657166,
-0.1841898113489151,
0.042067233473062515,
0.4254571795463562,
0.422964870929718,
-0.8065581917762756,
0.05265582352876663,
-0.0979481115937233,
-0.07072862982749939,
-0.07466688752174377,
-0.3629027307033539,
-0.13208335638046265,
-0.023594489321112633,
0.40923795104026794,
-0.1254734992980957,
0.019050275906920433,
0.11152824759483337,
-0.18126234412193298,
0.0010739625431597233,
0.5037469267845154,
0.5331796407699585,
0.8684680461883545,
-0.11132483184337616,
0.2581029236316681,
0.3500414788722992,
-0.11937394738197327,
-0.47125372290611267,
0.08800310641527176,
-0.09422950446605682,
-0.10522022843360901,
0.6223392486572266,
0.826640248298645,
0.3179796636104584,
-1.1184492111206055,
0.7074055075645447,
0.2540254592895508,
-0.30928829312324524,
-0.025082644075155258,
0.18786968290805817,
0.49540889263153076,
0.4428543746471405,
0.2667498290538788,
-0.3473127782344818,
0.10787280648946762,
-0.623417854309082,
0.1658628135919571,
0.30720165371894836,
0.2018013596534729,
0.20578891038894653,
0.369835764169693,
0.2084932029247284,
-0.10852537304162979,
0.6773973107337952,
-0.06338517367839813,
-0.37759727239608765,
0.747593343257904,
0.7084050178527832,
0.5252956748008728,
0.21349187195301056,
0.5225625038146973,
0.49962300062179565,
0.205264613032341,
0.04913664609193802,
-0.2651529908180237,
-0.005726509727537632,
-0.7318780422210693,
-0.6211743354797363,
-0.8143743872642517,
-0.2945033013820648,
0.18971844017505646,
-0.22687974572181702,
0.10399959236383438,
-0.25322064757347107,
0.5889909267425537,
0.12118293344974518,
0.17658962309360504,
-0.4069293737411499,
0.10374519228935242,
0.2821725606918335,
0.9823030233383179,
-0.7809642553329468,
0.38158512115478516,
0.24890366196632385,
-0.31665733456611633,
-0.7664307951927185,
-0.3041083812713623,
0.031643643975257874,
-0.8157196640968323,
0.8182127475738525,
0.1661606729030609,
0.10782922059297562,
-0.14335457980632782,
-0.8929761052131653,
-0.7598594427108765,
1.0477319955825806,
0.012313766404986382,
-0.8515673279762268,
0.09242899715900421,
0.12807214260101318,
0.6513228416442871,
-0.3975931704044342,
-0.044542424380779266,
0.40507346391677856,
0.5022299885749817,
0.400505393743515,
-1.1669918298721313,
0.15036436915397644,
0.19514985382556915,
-0.263224333524704,
-0.033200882375240326,
-0.5883981585502625,
0.5704352259635925,
-0.7151803374290466,
-0.3175375461578369,
0.15687543153762817,
0.8904711604118347,
0.3111008107662201,
0.5614456534385681,
0.43059098720550537,
0.4718358814716339,
0.8090543746948242,
0.19163058698177338,
1.0986363887786865,
0.28839460015296936,
-0.003576787421479821,
1.3475788831710815,
-0.08996139466762543,
0.8876844048500061,
0.28173208236694336,
-0.007330922409892082,
0.27868136763572693,
0.3300962448120117,
-0.15551871061325073,
0.375458300113678,
0.4643467962741852,
-0.1379414051771164,
-0.1607809215784073,
-0.12076002359390259,
-0.1518949568271637,
0.5297010540962219,
0.22691524028778076,
-0.2687242925167084,
-0.43528300523757935,
0.12358623743057251,
0.40837812423706055,
0.47202232480049133,
-0.6703478097915649,
0.8252565860748291,
0.29149726033210754,
-0.6033549904823303,
0.381611168384552,
-0.15794047713279724,
0.7338364124298096,
-0.2529979348182678,
0.041789762675762177,
-0.36274853348731995,
-0.1678653359413147,
-0.0708535760641098,
-1.0380492210388184,
0.3312690258026123,
0.17698930203914642,
-0.1077670082449913,
-0.4237494170665741,
0.6711025834083557,
-0.4568772614002228,
-0.15276682376861572,
-0.18510115146636963,
0.5684453248977661,
0.2845093905925751,
-0.008441132493317127,
-0.5435816645622253,
-0.05095256119966507,
-0.2625596821308136,
-0.02277323231101036,
0.3730038106441498,
0.523228645324707,
-0.10425544530153275,
0.9310645461082458,
0.7212045788764954,
0.012483229860663414,
0.05832355096936226,
0.02354922704398632,
0.6973103880882263,
-0.609752357006073,
-0.37080320715904236,
-0.7463515996932983,
0.32857924699783325,
-0.3939117193222046,
-0.42409399151802063,
0.6973958015441895,
0.5307460427284241,
0.5565035939216614,
-0.0957602933049202,
0.4565070867538452,
0.03418951854109764,
0.697026789188385,
-0.8165854215621948,
0.753745436668396,
-0.42012107372283936,
0.2566106915473938,
0.07648248225450516,
-0.5849989056587219,
-0.17226524651050568,
0.5119113922119141,
-0.38845956325531006,
-0.019373325631022453,
0.7054638862609863,
0.7292275428771973,
0.005894239991903305,
0.1173168197274208,
0.5267701745033264,
0.55084228515625,
0.13559210300445557,
0.46441033482551575,
0.9133684635162354,
0.19153368473052979,
0.3557111620903015,
-0.10684861242771149,
-0.013950648717582226,
-0.17840419709682465,
-1.128145456314087,
-0.9065724611282349,
-0.47554513812065125,
-0.4268879294395447,
-0.1471894085407257,
0.3878074884414673,
0.8156065940856934,
0.473933607339859,
-0.3716179132461548,
-0.06690610200166702,
0.026584003120660782,
0.40565112233161926,
-0.2652975022792816,
-0.293489009141922,
0.3967556357383728,
-0.7084806561470032,
-0.7115439772605896,
0.3255884647369385,
0.12778492271900177,
-0.18889150023460388,
-0.17971296608448029,
-0.0983021929860115,
-0.1486794650554657,
0.18282023072242737,
0.7274672389030457,
0.530325174331665,
-0.5924644470214844,
-0.38799527287483215,
-0.05252296105027199,
-0.24042551219463348,
-0.09850528836250305,
0.6723940968513489,
-0.7608492970466614,
0.19028574228286743,
0.3064887821674347,
0.5212087631225586,
0.4801933765411377,
-0.14789585769176483,
0.51385098695755,
-0.5217954516410828,
-0.21604254841804504,
0.39342406392097473,
0.1312657743692398,
0.5050303936004639,
-0.4529601037502289,
0.5136771202087402,
-0.030416475608944893,
-0.5380197763442993,
-0.6409950852394104,
0.23570378124713898,
-1.0249203443527222,
-0.6321948766708374,
1.6635737419128418,
0.21997298300266266,
-0.15849721431732178,
-0.0779595747590065,
-0.21429774165153503,
-0.2213125079870224,
-0.27256524562835693,
0.7800701260566711,
0.5365684628486633,
-0.05926631763577461,
-0.5625662803649902,
-0.8705624938011169,
0.7360126972198486,
0.19364017248153687,
-0.7364922165870667,
0.47871315479278564,
0.6766916513442993,
0.27803024649620056,
0.09326066076755524,
0.5291151404380798,
-0.054885439574718475,
0.17375952005386353,
-0.0924103707075119,
-0.3641626834869385,
-0.39720606803894043,
-0.21035508811473846,
0.031349968165159225,
0.1951579749584198,
-0.06774614006280899,
0.1381823718547821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14337v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14337v1
|
AURA: Natural Language Reasoning for Aleatoric Uncertainty in Rationales
| 2024-02-22T07:12:34 | 2024-02-22T07:12:34 |
Hazel Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Rationales behind answers not only explain model decisions but boost language
models to reason well on complex reasoning tasks. However, obtaining impeccable
rationales is often impossible. Besides, it is non-trivial to estimate the
degree to which the rationales are faithful enough to encourage model
performance. Thus, such reasoning tasks often compel models to output correct
answers under undesirable rationales and are sub-optimal compared to what the
models are fully capable of. In this work, we propose how to deal with
imperfect rationales causing aleatoric uncertainty. We first define the
ambiguous rationales with entropy scores of given rationales, using model prior
beliefs as informativeness. We then guide models to select one of two different
reasoning models according to the ambiguity of rationales. We empirically argue
that our proposed method produces robust performance superiority against the
adversarial quality of rationales and low-resource settings.
|
[
-0.3842453956604004,
-1.1769721508026123,
0.7922468185424805,
0.272150456905365,
-0.02348485216498375,
0.17125503718852997,
-0.21166951954364777,
-0.5682656168937683,
0.09840971976518631,
0.44520390033721924,
-0.42937201261520386,
-0.1332360804080963,
-0.4966813623905182,
0.07026974111795425,
-0.20183169841766357,
0.3695051372051239,
-0.09795655310153961,
-0.04860921576619148,
-0.027048369869589806,
-0.3203478455543518,
-0.5530243515968323,
-0.471312552690506,
-0.7457864880561829,
-0.2772967219352722,
0.18033333122730255,
0.28110748529434204,
1.2647260427474976,
0.5108786225318909,
0.41447627544403076,
0.3370620608329773,
-0.20928333699703217,
0.503284752368927,
0.046077195554971695,
0.3433990180492401,
-0.29772019386291504,
-0.6123786568641663,
-0.17022168636322021,
-0.039809450507164,
0.24154315888881683,
0.5782927870750427,
-0.10761293768882751,
-0.05130578204989433,
-0.36642780900001526,
0.623924195766449,
-0.7871714234352112,
-0.1530328392982483,
-0.8317583799362183,
-0.023928793147206306,
-0.11979284882545471,
-0.2714656889438629,
-0.47827091813087463,
-0.3981391191482544,
0.096659816801548,
-0.9988515377044678,
-0.36792731285095215,
0.4856036305427551,
1.0396082401275635,
0.8207284808158875,
-0.1684660017490387,
-0.24819128215312958,
-1.0107629299163818,
0.8417036533355713,
-0.738032877445221,
0.5577261447906494,
0.7875893712043762,
0.1953401416540146,
0.01575748436152935,
-0.5174082517623901,
-0.638051450252533,
-0.2172122746706009,
0.014782344922423363,
0.15390582382678986,
-0.7186294794082642,
0.2689850330352783,
0.03298339620232582,
0.37716251611709595,
-0.47199946641921997,
-0.06808887422084808,
0.14647522568702698,
-0.3088684678077698,
0.4271833002567291,
-0.000004563499260257231,
0.3025526702404022,
0.0183769129216671,
-0.21611301600933075,
-0.017776746302843094,
-0.2492174655199051,
0.15897879004478455,
0.6032530069351196,
0.17321601510047913,
0.1166464164853096,
0.6642637252807617,
-0.14214248955249786,
0.7047051787376404,
0.25339043140411377,
0.048490993678569794,
-0.024436548352241516,
-0.13779401779174805,
-0.44796523451805115,
-0.043319690972566605,
0.5774661898612976,
0.03360242396593094,
0.22435271739959717,
-0.28748437762260437,
-0.20609110593795776,
0.2785619795322418,
0.34620147943496704,
-0.30437198281288147,
-0.09351425617933273,
0.5010044574737549,
-0.2843768894672394,
-0.26496315002441406,
-0.23028817772865295,
-0.4606327414512634,
-0.26602569222450256,
-0.7156998515129089,
0.5167102217674255,
-0.7779695987701416,
-0.31641659140586853,
0.09599237143993378,
-0.07104021310806274,
-0.17931856215000153,
0.46967342495918274,
-0.8572075366973877,
0.4227071702480316,
0.3960634171962738,
0.4469607472419739,
0.36287185549736023,
-0.23076286911964417,
-0.47783663868904114,
-0.1597483605146408,
-0.6942793726921082,
0.8369070291519165,
-0.6573871374130249,
-0.10421103239059448,
-0.3343682885169983,
-0.6371288299560547,
-0.21927978098392487,
-0.49171555042266846,
0.9628874659538269,
-0.5811967849731445,
0.18237978219985962,
-0.3393012583255768,
-0.7551642060279846,
-0.3232327699661255,
0.1392432600259781,
-0.5831572413444519,
0.9874165654182434,
0.16774149239063263,
-0.7077200412750244,
0.19464032351970673,
-0.7038077116012573,
-0.24891553819179535,
-0.019125062972307205,
-0.09263251721858978,
-0.06474176794290543,
0.3320182263851166,
0.42329081892967224,
-0.04639770835638046,
-0.2675696015357971,
0.3675219714641571,
-0.1503812074661255,
-0.003064735559746623,
0.5112123489379883,
-0.9899654388427734,
0.6469804048538208,
0.6578941345214844,
-0.20905619859695435,
0.28979673981666565,
-0.6615265607833862,
0.24968014657497406,
-0.03605605289340019,
-0.2217622846364975,
-0.5322335958480835,
0.07634330540895462,
-0.0324157290160656,
-0.0344979390501976,
0.14396648108959198,
-0.13170963525772095,
0.09656795114278793,
-0.8080770373344421,
0.07009245455265045,
0.7259872555732727,
0.10462503135204315,
0.9151349067687988,
-0.29037806391716003,
0.4803216755390167,
-0.1533912718296051,
0.2570546269416809,
0.11794836819171906,
-0.5786412954330444,
-0.7632585167884827,
-0.19388934969902039,
0.12152750045061111,
0.7379856705665588,
-0.8610751032829285,
0.4503929018974304,
0.21473945677280426,
-0.5552757978439331,
-0.7836596369743347,
0.26947179436683655,
0.3828127384185791,
0.7710195779800415,
0.5564481019973755,
0.2631695568561554,
-0.47057580947875977,
-0.7936283946037292,
-0.657502293586731,
-0.6613416075706482,
0.13818876445293427,
0.24128784239292145,
0.24329468607902527,
-0.1461031287908554,
1.0829895734786987,
-0.3491421341896057,
0.07475114613771439,
-0.09785322099924088,
0.5344545245170593,
0.14672641456127167,
0.528380811214447,
0.5633273124694824,
-0.9714020490646362,
-0.02611168473958969,
0.05467605963349342,
-0.5923323631286621,
-0.280850350856781,
-0.38228389620780945,
-0.4844861924648285,
0.36946043372154236,
0.21105310320854187,
-0.8203583359718323,
0.5559515953063965,
0.2728287875652313,
-0.5153020620346069,
0.4974730312824249,
-0.05688369646668434,
0.18931642174720764,
-0.817084014415741,
0.012400285340845585,
-0.006199911702424288,
-0.07364745438098907,
-0.690439760684967,
0.06082039698958397,
-0.07149631530046463,
0.15822526812553406,
-0.27568483352661133,
0.7197346687316895,
-0.10737625509500504,
0.3525875210762024,
-0.2255077213048935,
-0.31839683651924133,
0.243968203663826,
0.45100006461143494,
0.24815823137760162,
0.6519890427589417,
0.6541481018066406,
-0.5497816205024719,
0.44427359104156494,
0.13113972544670105,
-0.07581735402345657,
0.7763251066207886,
-0.44073984026908875,
-0.3652050793170929,
-0.09361812472343445,
-0.05228303745388985,
-0.600610613822937,
-0.5370445251464844,
0.30146393179893494,
-0.7661599516868591,
0.2094118744134903,
-0.060217536985874176,
-0.4090062081813812,
-0.1658538579940796,
0.2105461210012436,
0.355991393327713,
0.46123865246772766,
-0.5451556444168091,
0.8762736916542053,
0.08428218215703964,
-0.02618725411593914,
-0.5301440358161926,
-0.6414803266525269,
-0.023687075823545456,
-0.43049338459968567,
-0.8013651967048645,
0.0063576651737093925,
-0.27756011486053467,
-0.9434123635292053,
0.11695712059736252,
-0.40078204870224,
-0.35216888785362244,
0.4488060772418976,
0.10932192206382751,
0.2109447717666626,
-0.352613627910614,
0.39841800928115845,
0.1950787752866745,
-0.15047501027584076,
0.09372996538877487,
-0.3924655616283417,
0.2000359743833542,
-0.4994904100894928,
-0.82590651512146,
-0.40509679913520813,
0.45229223370552063,
0.7859215140342712,
-0.32982632517814636,
0.6651054620742798,
0.407848060131073,
-0.7599872350692749,
0.013289229944348335,
-0.7500597834587097,
-0.0013065050588920712,
-0.44100579619407654,
-0.0681954026222229,
-0.12830106914043427,
-0.5493540167808533,
0.6885846257209778,
0.041341643780469894,
-0.10550138354301453,
0.5876085758209229,
0.4976406395435333,
0.00656344136223197,
1.4062058925628662,
0.09608165919780731,
-0.01405275147408247,
0.393476665019989,
-0.020715204998850822,
0.3656907081604004,
-0.4270494878292084,
-0.20536616444587708,
-0.5759236812591553,
0.04356810823082924,
0.0365729033946991,
-0.30689775943756104,
0.2923613488674164,
0.5494057536125183,
-0.3690966069698334,
-0.013752439059317112,
-0.5420877933502197,
0.5094435214996338,
0.8265439867973328,
-0.08793020993471146,
0.181195929646492,
-0.2421649694442749,
-0.10386941581964493,
0.020469674840569496,
-0.4596084952354431,
-0.6204248070716858,
0.6167567372322083,
0.46745580434799194,
0.9708580374717712,
0.432574987411499,
0.4059188961982727,
0.07144512236118317,
0.1308668851852417,
-0.6768626570701599,
-0.013388015329837799,
0.45772016048431396,
-0.9265337586402893,
-0.3843061029911041,
-0.4738108515739441,
-0.6415184140205383,
0.21854989230632782,
-0.26451796293258667,
-0.9881479144096375,
0.39886999130249023,
0.3516143262386322,
-0.6947313547134399,
0.23470769822597504,
-0.9074251055717468,
0.8418348431587219,
-0.5408728718757629,
-0.40485185384750366,
0.10657694935798645,
-0.7713441848754883,
0.3337952792644501,
-0.03542984649538994,
0.5056304335594177,
-0.07905856519937515,
0.12817201018333435,
0.3752211332321167,
-0.7457107305526733,
0.514681875705719,
-0.13188107311725616,
0.0710054486989975,
0.5328853130340576,
0.4457373023033142,
0.5226151943206787,
0.2845057249069214,
-0.29983097314834595,
0.005799353588372469,
-0.21553753316402435,
-0.26691800355911255,
-0.8666443228721619,
0.3594178557395935,
-0.7467078566551208,
-0.6623944640159607,
-0.378000408411026,
-0.4683836102485657,
-0.44469764828681946,
0.21034280955791473,
0.7204097509384155,
0.2480732649564743,
0.04854416102170944,
-0.13442754745483398,
0.7175969481468201,
-0.12781836092472076,
0.1848222017288208,
0.3821963667869568,
-0.09760134667158127,
-0.2847127914428711,
0.7142130732536316,
-0.056679658591747284,
0.3717893660068512,
0.3848082721233368,
0.307950496673584,
-0.4957420825958252,
-0.5611321330070496,
-0.5821501016616821,
-0.23246726393699646,
-0.767193078994751,
-0.44127824902534485,
-0.41379761695861816,
-0.2369726598262787,
-0.4021679162979126,
-0.5179641842842102,
-0.5417386889457703,
-0.5131227970123291,
-0.5188018679618835,
-0.26064515113830566,
0.6712906956672668,
0.41364356875419617,
-0.35133442282676697,
0.0936962366104126,
-0.5867295861244202,
0.4978826344013214,
0.2844099998474121,
0.3937297761440277,
-0.03876548260450363,
-0.5198651552200317,
-0.04007303714752197,
0.3377895951271057,
-0.2908175587654114,
-0.977227509021759,
0.5662977695465088,
0.05115992948412895,
0.741662859916687,
0.5787704586982727,
0.4341579079627991,
0.819804310798645,
-0.18057985603809357,
0.6439462900161743,
0.047196369618177414,
-1.2637847661972046,
0.9868683815002441,
-0.24193429946899414,
0.10765641927719116,
0.695525050163269,
0.0009494936093688011,
-0.047597989439964294,
-0.8276839256286621,
-0.9790598154067993,
-1.0292961597442627,
0.7324339747428894,
0.8132608532905579,
-0.1664494276046753,
0.026668516919016838,
0.10564032196998596,
-0.22018131613731384,
-0.007423053029924631,
-0.5538628101348877,
-0.31601667404174805,
-0.5228690505027771,
-0.19985735416412354,
0.29112932085990906,
0.1091754287481308,
-0.23964503407478333,
-0.31749793887138367,
0.8830722570419312,
-0.16356083750724792,
-0.06021920219063759,
0.44576072692871094,
0.08174262940883636,
-0.51984703540802,
0.4359266459941864,
0.5087793469429016,
0.39413315057754517,
-0.21523378789424896,
0.2847164273262024,
0.23524489998817444,
-0.10389260947704315,
0.013128845952451229,
0.15908458828926086,
-0.047811541706323624,
0.019191786646842957,
0.4841715395450592,
0.826789379119873,
0.025841237977147102,
-0.9212144017219543,
0.44777050614356995,
-0.3041937053203583,
0.14071515202522278,
-0.4859800934791565,
0.0950392335653305,
0.008669959381222725,
0.24728748202323914,
0.35238274931907654,
0.9746150970458984,
0.23900586366653442,
-0.36343786120414734,
-0.0036803712137043476,
0.45103415846824646,
-0.29258251190185547,
-0.08508655428886414,
0.9240355491638184,
-0.003527286695316434,
-0.35058799386024475,
0.5349387526512146,
-0.1742968112230301,
-0.5272433161735535,
0.6819043755531311,
0.2981697618961334,
0.7070337533950806,
-0.1799144446849823,
-0.04997509717941284,
0.18779593706130981,
0.46607518196105957,
-0.21878767013549805,
0.2781929075717926,
-0.09409023821353912,
-0.9062826633453369,
-0.2613379955291748,
-0.6618534326553345,
-0.5850746035575867,
-0.16021734476089478,
-0.74001544713974,
-0.15265394747257233,
-0.4047131836414337,
-0.14981763064861298,
0.08221185207366943,
-0.34615227580070496,
-0.5602492094039917,
0.3608991205692291,
0.2139137238264084,
1.1036738157272339,
-0.9284545183181763,
0.5685344934463501,
0.5100292563438416,
-0.678136944770813,
-1.3843190670013428,
-0.013080446049571037,
0.2612327039241791,
-0.7283456921577454,
0.4049605429172516,
-0.2217862904071808,
-0.22125832736492157,
-0.16616412997245789,
-0.5851391553878784,
-1.045797348022461,
0.6818117499351501,
0.7075653076171875,
-0.022335857152938843,
0.09872838109731674,
-0.17686845362186432,
0.7230232357978821,
-0.056401416659355164,
0.3311367332935333,
0.6325231790542603,
0.8111828565597534,
0.43149685859680176,
-0.8510347008705139,
-0.21194081008434296,
-0.4470502436161041,
-0.21357107162475586,
0.07629834115505219,
-0.21941858530044556,
0.7333060503005981,
-0.20889995992183685,
-0.22416633367538452,
0.4329809546470642,
0.5843814611434937,
0.28162217140197754,
0.5473470091819763,
0.3256363570690155,
0.8117955923080444,
1.245195984840393,
-0.22540950775146484,
1.4184108972549438,
-0.24593158066272736,
0.04937594756484032,
0.9016771912574768,
-0.2646999657154083,
0.7637385129928589,
0.5915624499320984,
-0.09013891965150833,
0.29541143774986267,
0.6930509805679321,
0.3785354495048523,
0.3288172781467438,
-0.11956223845481873,
-0.4234139025211334,
-0.65855872631073,
-0.295474648475647,
-0.23050521314144135,
0.4288935959339142,
0.6508974432945251,
-0.19544117152690887,
0.08914054930210114,
-0.11474258452653885,
0.0554712638258934,
0.4306461215019226,
-0.1415567696094513,
0.6924794316291809,
-0.08817066997289658,
-1.0160807371139526,
0.4902937710285187,
0.00829331949353218,
0.30764779448509216,
-0.6012908816337585,
0.02534552477300167,
-0.2370288074016571,
-0.014339744113385677,
-0.3516618311405182,
-0.674629271030426,
0.7000656723976135,
0.049621399492025375,
-0.26690587401390076,
-0.21298974752426147,
0.6440165042877197,
-0.04613638296723366,
-0.6251612305641174,
0.14577919244766235,
0.5746666789054871,
-0.11542655527591705,
-0.17712199687957764,
-0.5978239178657532,
0.011582652106881142,
-0.10494112223386765,
-0.38791027665138245,
-0.23572960495948792,
0.8076297640800476,
-0.044274795800447464,
0.8671326637268066,
0.7193860411643982,
0.12529921531677246,
0.004714325536042452,
0.05387502163648605,
0.7494744062423706,
-0.306033194065094,
-0.47851431369781494,
-0.8717991709709167,
0.587854266166687,
0.06605774164199829,
-0.4635641872882843,
0.6678631901741028,
0.4638656973838806,
0.4234941899776459,
0.21869561076164246,
0.7338988184928894,
0.06463278830051422,
0.5342159271240234,
-0.7282450199127197,
0.5373383164405823,
-0.6903284788131714,
0.6941739916801453,
-0.3054797351360321,
-0.5664693117141724,
-0.49450361728668213,
0.8099606037139893,
-0.17168231308460236,
-0.18889570236206055,
0.5315430760383606,
0.6437509655952454,
-0.023981554433703423,
0.29419028759002686,
0.284163236618042,
0.28345298767089844,
0.13044659793376923,
0.45813417434692383,
1.1620720624923706,
-0.21904894709587097,
0.363911896944046,
-0.308946818113327,
-0.1262635886669159,
-0.03736899420619011,
-0.6751186847686768,
-0.42586997151374817,
-0.5184599161148071,
-0.2501809895038605,
-0.3261730372905731,
-0.1697176694869995,
1.0670162439346313,
0.7127339243888855,
-0.6753422617912292,
0.3552252948284149,
-0.5327600240707397,
0.5865246653556824,
-0.29223060607910156,
-0.33374184370040894,
0.18365825712680817,
-0.3638969957828522,
-0.4824885129928589,
0.5178634524345398,
0.25110045075416565,
0.2585584223270416,
0.08132404834032059,
-0.35934385657310486,
-0.04344429820775986,
0.7151556611061096,
0.06479759514331818,
0.5023192167282104,
-1.2160402536392212,
-0.4280948042869568,
0.07928353548049927,
-0.008652735501527786,
-0.041994210332632065,
0.40406304597854614,
-0.882817804813385,
0.4339670240879059,
0.26316970586776733,
0.5964083075523376,
-0.23846139013767242,
0.1589372456073761,
0.48299071192741394,
-0.8182023167610168,
0.030087929219007492,
0.7343184947967529,
0.5968716740608215,
0.20541098713874817,
-0.49408403038978577,
0.40522581338882446,
0.06412458419799805,
-0.4821301996707916,
-0.7710941433906555,
0.37882697582244873,
-1.0453542470932007,
-0.5382970571517944,
1.1029133796691895,
0.006892402656376362,
0.06681287288665771,
-0.3162039816379547,
-0.47998732328414917,
0.14833053946495056,
-0.4908764064311981,
0.5984553694725037,
0.7320666313171387,
-0.4009663462638855,
-0.047615572810173035,
-0.1672452986240387,
0.378828763961792,
0.6063887476921082,
-0.7870641946792603,
0.0605001300573349,
0.6219323873519897,
-0.15462106466293335,
0.42422837018966675,
0.4600745439529419,
0.1098475530743599,
0.4109395146369934,
0.30329811573028564,
-0.24411343038082123,
0.09852663427591324,
-0.20985500514507294,
-0.23417387902736664,
0.0752151682972908,
0.6119657158851624,
0.21292176842689514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14334v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14334v1
|
INSTRUCTIR: A Benchmark for Instruction Following of Information Retrieval Models
| 2024-02-22T06:59:50 | 2024-02-22T06:59:50 |
Hanseok Oh, Hyunji Lee, Seonghyeon Ye, Haebin Shin, Hansol Jang, Changwook Jun, Minjoon Seo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the critical need to align search targets with users' intention,
retrievers often only prioritize query information without delving into the
users' intended search context. Enhancing the capability of retrievers to
understand intentions and preferences of users, akin to language model
instructions, has the potential to yield more aligned search targets. Prior
studies restrict the application of instructions in information retrieval to a
task description format, neglecting the broader context of diverse and evolving
search scenarios. Furthermore, the prevailing benchmarks utilized for
evaluation lack explicit tailoring to assess instruction-following ability,
thereby hindering progress in this field. In response to these limitations, we
propose a novel benchmark,INSTRUCTIR, specifically designed to evaluate
instruction-following ability in information retrieval tasks. Our approach
focuses on user-aligned instructions tailored to each query instance,
reflecting the diverse characteristics inherent in real-world search scenarios.
Through experimental analysis, we observe that retrievers fine-tuned to follow
task-style instructions, such as INSTRUCTOR, can underperform compared to their
non-instruction-tuned counterparts. This underscores potential overfitting
issues inherent in constructing retrievers trained on existing
instruction-aware retrieval datasets.
|
[
-0.15563137829303741,
-0.2303468883037567,
0.3327797055244446,
0.11943235248327255,
0.04815545305609703,
0.06355057656764984,
-0.10782314836978912,
0.005419979803264141,
-0.166555717587471,
0.42852622270584106,
-0.5172786712646484,
-0.36520543694496155,
-0.4347005784511566,
-0.14930285513401031,
-0.5679304003715515,
0.8505330085754395,
-0.07940353453159332,
0.065982386469841,
-0.4726742208003998,
0.007784869521856308,
-0.8670867681503296,
-0.24305593967437744,
-0.13729514181613922,
-0.23323141038417816,
0.2573312520980835,
0.7685296535491943,
0.571682333946228,
0.7476574778556824,
0.7235715985298157,
0.08559010922908783,
0.17028844356536865,
0.24512021243572235,
-0.5702406167984009,
0.20601414144039154,
-0.3052184283733368,
-0.34451010823249817,
0.04560190439224243,
0.04120437428355217,
0.8361868262290955,
0.6323854327201843,
-0.43068554997444153,
0.27420684695243835,
0.3309842050075531,
0.8309317827224731,
-1.2908389568328857,
-0.08270260691642761,
-0.46821126341819763,
-0.11656755954027176,
-0.1775616705417633,
-0.45948874950408936,
-0.7397430539131165,
-0.7194221615791321,
0.14372283220291138,
-0.4787465035915375,
0.21044568717479706,
0.3091944456100464,
0.4971672594547272,
0.270240843296051,
-0.3801804780960083,
-0.3316120505332947,
-0.4902379512786865,
0.5270016193389893,
-0.47007620334625244,
0.8184369802474976,
0.5140588283538818,
0.4311613440513611,
-0.39449575543403625,
-0.7908921241760254,
-0.19973228871822357,
-0.1631069928407669,
-0.21538196504116058,
0.2252015471458435,
-0.22091448307037354,
-0.0123837199062109,
0.38880568742752075,
0.022894999012351036,
-0.5994840264320374,
-0.07110024243593216,
-0.534003734588623,
0.354316771030426,
0.2648215591907501,
0.19048970937728882,
0.19714254140853882,
0.11962764710187912,
-0.6297628283500671,
-0.3341945707798004,
-0.8185585737228394,
0.2886936664581299,
0.45480877161026,
0.26440688967704773,
0.3769146502017975,
0.7113980054855347,
-0.6040471792221069,
0.819209635257721,
0.3738868236541748,
0.3758167326450348,
-0.01721576228737831,
-0.307679682970047,
-0.11736009269952774,
0.529534637928009,
0.4099428951740265,
0.414898157119751,
0.019262170419096947,
-0.4606943130493164,
-0.39750978350639343,
-0.5041108131408691,
0.77914959192276,
-1.2463178634643555,
-0.16952289640903473,
-0.27909451723098755,
-0.6693688631057739,
0.1376035213470459,
0.3180423378944397,
-0.6389300227165222,
-0.2399478703737259,
-0.3187078833580017,
0.8111300468444824,
-0.6844480633735657,
0.2126627117395401,
0.03680295869708061,
0.013853760436177254,
0.5318593978881836,
-0.025827372446656227,
-1.0135624408721924,
0.6964961290359497,
0.9452188014984131,
0.5474153161048889,
-0.08643785119056702,
-0.20863820612430573,
-0.9868645071983337,
0.20742405951023102,
-0.36996227502822876,
0.6021631360054016,
-1.181424856185913,
-0.43715620040893555,
0.02059060148894787,
-0.014652453362941742,
-0.34129464626312256,
-0.5587387084960938,
0.5326077342033386,
-0.7613012194633484,
0.09424852579832077,
-0.472016841173172,
-0.9831231832504272,
-0.33316442370414734,
-0.007714922074228525,
-0.36384689807891846,
1.1166775226593018,
0.362062007188797,
-0.5464413166046143,
0.48959818482398987,
-0.36622533202171326,
-0.5744388103485107,
0.22322598099708557,
-0.16898851096630096,
0.07628118246793747,
0.09849710017442703,
0.017652440816164017,
0.295989990234375,
-0.43324583768844604,
-0.11556117981672287,
-0.10348284244537354,
-1.1570087671279907,
-0.06400670111179352,
-0.11213839799165726,
0.5216847658157349,
-0.07868167012929916,
-0.41353505849838257,
-0.1677817404270172,
-0.4408320188522339,
0.39034363627433777,
-0.3292210102081299,
-0.26729974150657654,
-0.5820727944374084,
0.2764008939266205,
-0.2521650493144989,
-0.14043912291526794,
0.27128416299819946,
-0.5378699898719788,
0.3071272373199463,
-0.19412082433700562,
-0.036072757095098495,
0.7018061876296997,
-0.019196007400751114,
0.43162232637405396,
-0.3443529009819031,
0.7263169884681702,
-0.6420108675956726,
0.21176530420780182,
-0.27265965938568115,
-0.09727185219526291,
-0.4757659435272217,
-0.04309077933430672,
0.09644729644060135,
0.5290619134902954,
-0.1719205230474472,
0.03871829807758331,
-0.25014442205429077,
-0.649660587310791,
-0.8196172118186951,
0.3109481930732727,
0.873467743396759,
0.7152979373931885,
0.5805764198303223,
-0.36076000332832336,
-0.5682345628738403,
-0.7653658390045166,
-0.46892768144607544,
-0.019302019849419594,
0.17847974598407745,
0.4143415689468384,
0.33139768242836,
-0.10453625023365021,
0.4994570016860962,
-0.39826688170433044,
-0.3099198639392853,
0.10481692850589752,
-0.033533260226249695,
0.19656862318515778,
0.5382632613182068,
0.30533504486083984,
-0.92706298828125,
-0.7287875413894653,
0.15903834998607635,
-0.6719173789024353,
0.10683297365903854,
0.13060782849788666,
-0.43465015292167664,
-0.22307026386260986,
0.7326253652572632,
-0.1918708235025406,
0.6362506151199341,
-0.04922157898545265,
-0.14278502762317657,
0.3468565046787262,
-0.31435996294021606,
0.7479336261749268,
-0.7919624447822571,
0.19983476400375366,
0.062069572508335114,
0.2211887240409851,
-0.3680802285671234,
0.21606427431106567,
0.5217134356498718,
0.13477380573749542,
-0.13532058894634247,
0.5880172252655029,
-0.6190416216850281,
-0.1459732949733734,
-0.14384964108467102,
-0.1476549655199051,
-0.009082747623324394,
0.21172192692756653,
-0.16399449110031128,
1.22477126121521,
0.3201354742050171,
-0.6151645183563232,
-0.00675619812682271,
0.5208237767219543,
-0.6367542147636414,
0.8480432033538818,
-0.7168329358100891,
0.3276318311691284,
-0.14451569318771362,
-0.22713541984558105,
-1.0298887491226196,
-0.25721973180770874,
-0.03798011690378189,
-0.13272221386432648,
0.5846578478813171,
-0.6574171781539917,
-0.7724786996841431,
-0.19245250523090363,
-0.34603360295295715,
0.4118277132511139,
0.5688946843147278,
-0.6818073987960815,
0.5141002535820007,
-0.1931929737329483,
0.11803792417049408,
-0.9470094442367554,
-0.35954371094703674,
-0.16717290878295898,
-0.11612285673618317,
-0.37300923466682434,
0.7930335402488708,
-0.2796480357646942,
-0.13608789443969727,
-0.0038949260488152504,
-0.38034090399742126,
-0.27917924523353577,
0.007837378419935703,
0.3166337311267853,
0.18685270845890045,
-0.29189133644104004,
0.029701808467507362,
0.15366315841674805,
0.221181258559227,
0.11906222254037857,
-0.11028269678354263,
0.17784351110458374,
0.08226059377193451,
-0.6357865333557129,
-0.6568495035171509,
0.2574230134487152,
0.1438085287809372,
-0.5744820237159729,
0.5880330204963684,
0.18409325182437897,
-0.14807681739330292,
-0.12065555155277252,
-0.7381141781806946,
-0.4357055723667145,
-0.5166220664978027,
0.18028825521469116,
-0.3171618580818176,
-0.3082452714443207,
-0.0022966021206229925,
0.05998681113123894,
-0.057801712304353714,
-0.0990121141076088,
-0.022524265572428703,
-0.4525053799152374,
1.1247965097427368,
0.814781904220581,
0.1682453453540802,
0.8094191551208496,
-0.08226659148931503,
-0.034385647624731064,
-1.2105060815811157,
-0.45635342597961426,
-0.5260018110275269,
-0.30366623401641846,
-0.5090871453285217,
-0.039221178740262985,
0.31908443570137024,
0.15011294186115265,
-0.32784390449523926,
0.5540130734443665,
-0.8173814415931702,
0.5454450249671936,
0.8171256184577942,
0.39720577001571655,
-0.09565021097660065,
-0.10880172252655029,
-0.02974882163107395,
-0.11013910919427872,
-0.5641651153564453,
-0.38116297125816345,
1.093350887298584,
-0.48002633452415466,
1.0384200811386108,
0.10699335485696793,
0.8024333715438843,
0.4080795645713806,
0.243153378367424,
-0.4307270348072052,
0.4847455620765686,
-0.3645724952220917,
-0.4609149098396301,
0.13670413196086884,
-0.1227210983633995,
-0.8365496397018433,
0.12576784193515778,
0.02591749094426632,
-0.8980658054351807,
0.1512129008769989,
0.2274295836687088,
-0.0894877165555954,
-0.06569790095090866,
-0.7236975431442261,
0.9535223245620728,
-0.340320348739624,
-0.46877321600914,
-0.33238092064857483,
-0.6441640257835388,
-0.13773128390312195,
0.18275578320026398,
-0.16705040633678436,
0.11964847147464752,
-0.05992851033806801,
0.611713707447052,
-0.10955118387937546,
0.5556918382644653,
-0.19466456770896912,
0.6961788535118103,
0.15320055186748505,
0.2888854146003723,
0.5742123126983643,
-0.5493806004524231,
-0.45471227169036865,
-0.7311171889305115,
0.08912783861160278,
-0.2522040605545044,
-0.7594214081764221,
0.7112000584602356,
-0.2517034411430359,
-0.7874020338058472,
-0.0792890340089798,
-0.33851122856140137,
-0.2176383137702942,
0.4437083601951599,
0.3449394106864929,
0.8263347148895264,
-0.3418762981891632,
0.5639241337776184,
1.0344960689544678,
0.2411719560623169,
0.14859284460544586,
0.6848495006561279,
0.28160056471824646,
-0.050741199404001236,
0.833156943321228,
0.20106996595859528,
0.11207425594329834,
0.9277691841125488,
0.1535378247499466,
-0.29337823390960693,
-0.5352658033370972,
-0.400289386510849,
-0.011899098753929138,
-0.8469749093055725,
-0.24551710486412048,
-0.39761191606521606,
-0.04680852219462395,
-0.08125565201044083,
-0.3525584936141968,
-0.18896113336086273,
0.12375401705503464,
-0.38181671500205994,
0.046235036104917526,
0.1551171839237213,
0.7853738069534302,
0.4196529686450958,
0.3104189336299896,
-0.5656304955482483,
-0.18878988921642303,
0.11251848936080933,
0.4875524938106537,
0.06689739227294922,
-0.8899180293083191,
-0.3438696265220642,
-0.1011047214269638,
-0.30910566449165344,
-0.7719660401344299,
-0.09978868812322617,
0.17922599613666534,
1.016160488128662,
0.2599162757396698,
0.39666908979415894,
0.8343966603279114,
-0.5155913829803467,
0.06499803811311722,
-0.3090634047985077,
-0.7163451313972473,
0.9035479426383972,
0.0028015985153615475,
0.2779729962348938,
0.8939647674560547,
0.6918660402297974,
-0.20006322860717773,
-0.20406651496887207,
-0.2944556772708893,
-0.7002415060997009,
0.8390561938285828,
0.06275039911270142,
0.10656622052192688,
-0.06200970709323883,
0.6652108430862427,
0.2879588007926941,
0.19780109822750092,
0.05148689076304436,
-0.08559456467628479,
-0.07121756672859192,
-0.40599992871284485,
0.3086451590061188,
-0.3668883442878723,
0.14245784282684326,
0.07002238929271698,
0.712411642074585,
-0.009386853314936161,
-0.012334203347563744,
0.07396895438432693,
-0.25809183716773987,
0.0007512362790293992,
0.2158530354499817,
0.2256300300359726,
0.8261141180992126,
-0.5433473587036133,
-0.07914328575134277,
-0.11960972100496292,
-0.4065161943435669,
0.04177037999033928,
0.5720265507698059,
-0.3312488794326782,
-0.3528907001018524,
0.19116611778736115,
0.45142605900764465,
0.6121363043785095,
-0.8296646475791931,
0.6820898652076721,
-0.11448591202497482,
0.23682190477848053,
-0.18259213864803314,
0.6107844710350037,
-0.2387869656085968,
0.4333394169807434,
0.5766264200210571,
-0.01538820005953312,
0.6936292052268982,
-0.3918936848640442,
0.3047887980937958,
0.6248524785041809,
-0.8963421583175659,
-0.3436304032802582,
0.8226324319839478,
-0.1976478546857834,
-0.4640376567840576,
0.8999674320220947,
0.0013469239929690957,
-0.040205322206020355,
0.49379590153694153,
0.5733547210693359,
0.6760629415512085,
-0.2908683717250824,
-0.10045058280229568,
0.40073031187057495,
0.2932577133178711,
-0.303832471370697,
0.447396457195282,
-0.3025244474411011,
-0.23005394637584686,
0.15048500895500183,
-0.1309753805398941,
-0.47283703088760376,
-0.4215976297855377,
-1.2766122817993164,
0.18595662713050842,
-0.34706607460975647,
0.07303179055452347,
0.2608032822608948,
-0.10689054429531097,
-0.8403531908988953,
0.12143830209970474,
-0.4901946187019348,
1.0323662757873535,
-0.20748241245746613,
0.6106030344963074,
0.9165663719177246,
-0.5950732827186584,
-0.5005146861076355,
0.1913425773382187,
-0.0005016805371269584,
-0.6445022225379944,
0.744942843914032,
0.5622838735580444,
-0.5001742839813232,
-0.07865612208843231,
-0.48997944593429565,
-0.6874353289604187,
1.2233481407165527,
0.463638037443161,
-0.3819201588630676,
-0.10339827835559845,
-0.5365791916847229,
0.30192336440086365,
-0.4692884385585785,
0.47025302052497864,
0.27839604020118713,
0.09458265453577042,
0.07987210899591446,
-0.6415798664093018,
0.12583892047405243,
-0.18055707216262817,
-0.023116568103432655,
0.3856595456600189,
-0.640426516532898,
0.42295321822166443,
-0.44311466813087463,
-0.28563669323921204,
0.38800185918807983,
0.5258159637451172,
-0.05024155601859093,
0.3046610355377197,
0.19966331124305725,
0.14194993674755096,
0.6208951473236084,
0.22259949147701263,
1.131975531578064,
-0.26574063301086426,
-0.20927897095680237,
1.5006322860717773,
-0.3090730607509613,
1.1484363079071045,
0.3276308476924896,
-0.004001318477094173,
0.5963830947875977,
0.3085511326789856,
0.0065703317523002625,
0.9210860133171082,
-0.18341077864170074,
-0.19185708463191986,
-0.15365754067897797,
-0.27908703684806824,
-0.2419164925813675,
0.5091545581817627,
0.2090848833322525,
-0.47111403942108154,
-0.02922664023935795,
-0.19399669766426086,
-0.0511510893702507,
0.5256873965263367,
-0.20252551138401031,
0.7415579557418823,
-0.39091163873672485,
-0.9379170536994934,
0.40929198265075684,
-0.392785906791687,
0.2902173399925232,
-0.5051772594451904,
-0.4814666211605072,
-0.22363990545272827,
0.3939659893512726,
-0.1909421980381012,
-1.066784143447876,
-0.2529546022415161,
-0.18086937069892883,
-0.3143540024757385,
-0.06959730386734009,
0.43226584792137146,
-0.18904390931129456,
-0.2454664409160614,
0.38261714577674866,
0.08355266600847244,
0.12891574203968048,
0.12032435089349747,
-0.36934351921081543,
-0.14641204476356506,
0.20406220853328705,
-0.11853097379207611,
0.4589388072490692,
0.3570544123649597,
-0.07712717354297638,
0.8024119734764099,
0.2248002290725708,
-0.42028066515922546,
0.09063180536031723,
-0.04159921780228615,
0.8075745105743408,
-0.5863223075866699,
-0.12181396037340164,
-0.5844035148620605,
0.34476229548454285,
0.0369441956281662,
-0.35428786277770996,
0.7139703631401062,
0.8883097171783447,
1.1594114303588867,
0.19342990219593048,
0.4924454689025879,
-0.024143699556589127,
0.5035142302513123,
-0.47862499952316284,
0.3341332972049713,
-0.6491628289222717,
0.19221028685569763,
-0.10171584039926529,
-0.8938750624656677,
0.1970001608133316,
0.36150750517845154,
-0.09432896226644516,
0.1996137499809265,
0.23795348405838013,
0.9470589756965637,
-0.4993530511856079,
-0.05256619676947594,
-0.0033089315984398127,
-0.16746361553668976,
-0.10696874558925629,
0.25355225801467896,
0.7909373641014099,
-0.37445056438446045,
0.6645450592041016,
-0.4424332082271576,
-0.19256053864955902,
-0.5206034183502197,
-0.6496297121047974,
-0.9403568506240845,
-0.5336741209030151,
-0.23396697640419006,
-0.056235477328300476,
0.6911421418190002,
0.919410765171051,
0.8137932419776917,
-0.6360010504722595,
-0.28300371766090393,
0.04449160397052765,
0.014223971404135227,
-0.6180734634399414,
-0.1681542843580246,
0.395079642534256,
-0.4375556409358978,
-0.5383741855621338,
0.7448946833610535,
0.18362289667129517,
-0.09821254014968872,
0.1377517282962799,
-0.0443706139922142,
-0.3686937093734741,
-0.0674467459321022,
0.23988200724124908,
0.4273638129234314,
-0.621778666973114,
-0.2733316123485565,
0.4308718144893646,
-0.22071276605129242,
0.19216328859329224,
0.6942137479782104,
-0.7755987048149109,
1.0612497329711914,
0.3297010064125061,
0.739988386631012,
0.7048904299736023,
0.27120286226272583,
0.6496691107749939,
-0.741496741771698,
-0.38726606965065,
0.27206844091415405,
0.20956850051879883,
0.38996922969818115,
-0.5082292556762695,
0.7191612720489502,
-0.58277827501297,
-0.5596899390220642,
-0.8461202383041382,
-0.13966715335845947,
-0.6122126579284668,
0.022483566775918007,
0.798965573310852,
-0.20725210011005402,
0.10158880054950714,
0.31633251905441284,
-0.044542405754327774,
0.047025322914123535,
-0.631208062171936,
0.5956429839134216,
0.317933052778244,
-0.32708242535591125,
-0.17766478657722473,
-0.7953765392303467,
0.27445703744888306,
0.3529728651046753,
-0.3410124182701111,
0.11075785756111145,
0.39567750692367554,
0.33136504888534546,
-0.3600698411464691,
0.4460598826408386,
0.14904557168483734,
0.6833649277687073,
-0.16847524046897888,
-0.01250719279050827,
-0.03741024434566498,
-0.34349802136421204,
0.1277843862771988,
0.015921415761113167,
0.10501683503389359,
-0.4657045006752014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14328v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14328v2
|
Understanding and Patching Compositional Reasoning in LLMs
| 2024-02-22T06:47:56 | 2024-06-06T14:06:41 |
Zhaoyi Li, Gangwei Jiang, Hong Xie, Linqi Song, Defu Lian, Ying Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
LLMs have marked a revolutonary shift, yet they falter when faced with
compositional reasoning tasks. Our research embarks on a quest to uncover the
root causes of compositional reasoning failures of LLMs, uncovering that most
of them stem from the improperly generated or leveraged implicit reasoning
results. Inspired by our empirical findings, we resort to Logit Lens and an
intervention experiment to dissect the inner hidden states of LLMs. This deep
dive reveals that implicit reasoning results indeed surface within middle
layers and play a causative role in shaping the final explicit reasoning
results. Our exploration further locates multi-head self-attention (MHSA)
modules within these layers, which emerge as the linchpins in accurate
generation and leveraing of implicit reasoning results. Grounded on the above
findings, we develop CREME, a lightweight method to patch errors in
compositional reasoning via editing the located MHSA modules. Our empirical
evidence stands testament to CREME's effectiveness, paving the way for
autonomously and continuously enhancing compositional reasoning capabilities in
language models.
|
[
-0.09777780622243881,
-0.872420608997345,
1.0645747184753418,
0.3424270451068878,
0.0987795889377594,
0.3559686541557312,
0.017003709450364113,
-0.47144919633865356,
-0.027560457587242126,
0.6111683249473572,
-0.965880811214447,
-0.5224758982658386,
-0.6421938538551331,
-0.01107072178274393,
-0.2393440455198288,
0.6493549346923828,
-0.1565721184015274,
-0.1377299278974533,
-0.5295776724815369,
-0.12508484721183777,
-0.7925402522087097,
-0.5222725868225098,
-0.7205969095230103,
-0.2979571223258972,
0.8559302687644958,
0.6479367613792419,
0.22882355749607086,
0.6907135844230652,
0.32288530468940735,
0.3099123537540436,
0.02469136379659176,
0.6227385997772217,
-0.5294071435928345,
0.2515530586242676,
-0.21763992309570312,
-0.9833250641822815,
-0.5737752318382263,
-0.11619751155376434,
0.4811946451663971,
0.45966288447380066,
-0.002641070634126663,
0.002830581273883581,
0.1456669270992279,
0.7819672226905823,
-0.8012028932571411,
0.030231598764657974,
-0.8742170929908752,
-0.022101495414972305,
-0.31822457909584045,
-0.22747381031513214,
-0.4249618351459503,
0.16711033880710602,
-0.10583781450986862,
-0.43174782395362854,
0.3393729031085968,
-0.10169584304094315,
0.20593857765197754,
0.5890172719955444,
-0.4857289493083954,
-0.26546087861061096,
-0.8237078189849854,
1.044785499572754,
-0.7847223877906799,
0.2592405378818512,
0.02361665852367878,
0.03307164087891579,
-0.2838398516178131,
-0.6722554564476013,
-0.415975958108902,
-0.022051488980650902,
-0.2442425936460495,
0.03282865881919861,
-0.15812523663043976,
-0.07448822259902954,
0.22878582775592804,
0.24360370635986328,
-0.33913135528564453,
-0.09509888291358948,
-0.20660679042339325,
-0.3730798065662384,
0.6069456338882446,
0.4078744947910309,
0.41808003187179565,
0.18464148044586182,
-0.39811113476753235,
0.016962477937340736,
-0.910561740398407,
0.06723158806562424,
0.21322622895240784,
-0.07801428437232971,
-0.03518690541386604,
0.5616719722747803,
0.0257408544421196,
0.5649569034576416,
0.1527944654226303,
-0.20404557883739471,
-0.10711152851581573,
-0.1927720457315445,
-0.3958449363708496,
0.2052571326494217,
0.512202262878418,
0.18160822987556458,
0.19086644053459167,
0.021253008395433426,
-0.28788843750953674,
0.3031362295150757,
0.3585636019706726,
-0.3404204845428467,
-0.22428567707538605,
0.5104268193244934,
0.16021418571472168,
-0.21858759224414825,
-0.0848107859492302,
-0.3591015636920929,
-0.1138276532292366,
-0.5038262605667114,
0.26221519708633423,
-0.16045618057250977,
-0.22631652653217316,
0.2976091504096985,
-0.051412634551525116,
0.02784847654402256,
0.5012949109077454,
-0.7910537123680115,
0.012665252201259136,
0.8511974811553955,
0.5612382292747498,
-0.38789287209510803,
-0.5859554409980774,
-0.013332861475646496,
0.528011679649353,
-0.35840246081352234,
1.2282370328903198,
-0.3163677155971527,
-0.36476337909698486,
-0.08717195689678192,
0.2632255256175995,
-0.42311468720436096,
-0.7240768074989319,
0.39428627490997314,
-0.229474738240242,
0.08662961423397064,
-0.5655255317687988,
-0.4473303556442261,
-0.014281858690083027,
0.367661714553833,
-0.485930472612381,
1.1080422401428223,
0.030799290165305138,
-0.5913566946983337,
0.08955533057451248,
-0.5100228190422058,
-0.34989067912101746,
-0.2702411115169525,
-0.20374378561973572,
-0.47098860144615173,
0.2863794267177582,
0.25287896394729614,
0.1112130880355835,
-0.03850536420941353,
-0.08753594011068344,
-0.2543552815914154,
-0.29440364241600037,
0.6870862245559692,
-0.3000522255897522,
0.5566563606262207,
-0.20676535367965698,
-0.5645537376403809,
0.2672133445739746,
-0.5794233083724976,
0.006126558408141136,
0.21341238915920258,
-0.1462891548871994,
-0.1742817908525467,
-0.06890904903411865,
-0.1905684918165207,
0.2648393511772156,
0.12088801711797714,
-0.38555699586868286,
0.10379638522863388,
-0.08550842106342316,
0.5540118217468262,
1.0822252035140991,
0.15181808173656464,
0.5843591690063477,
-0.38241246342658997,
0.47412291169166565,
0.44744229316711426,
0.33794736862182617,
-0.30694738030433655,
-0.43846753239631653,
-0.9858698844909668,
-0.2970169186592102,
-0.08408759534358978,
0.441098690032959,
-0.2271450310945511,
-0.06341811269521713,
0.1272052675485611,
-0.39982593059539795,
-0.6041197776794434,
0.5137186050415039,
0.5204435586929321,
0.5440397262573242,
0.37145426869392395,
-0.12822051346302032,
-0.35452404618263245,
-1.123795986175537,
-0.6311982274055481,
0.10774368792772293,
0.21245251595973969,
0.19442105293273926,
0.3140013813972473,
-0.5658148527145386,
0.9276626110076904,
-0.5416791439056396,
-0.4061431288719177,
-0.16357366740703583,
-0.02117406390607357,
-0.14586442708969116,
0.6523071527481079,
0.29406607151031494,
-0.3453839421272278,
-0.24985690414905548,
-0.19197052717208862,
-0.8096518516540527,
-0.46776282787323,
-0.21809300780296326,
-0.4687268137931824,
0.2761431634426117,
0.7052095532417297,
-0.8396618962287903,
0.349322110414505,
0.43815869092941284,
-0.3342563509941101,
0.7961870431900024,
0.013946386985480785,
0.10147131979465485,
-0.4103640019893646,
-0.3723430931568146,
-0.11730558425188065,
-0.18331775069236755,
-0.3699239194393158,
0.0501650869846344,
0.09222779422998428,
0.3825329542160034,
-0.5277776718139648,
0.6369636654853821,
-0.6661415696144104,
-0.05575127154588699,
-0.41401395201683044,
0.07222513109445572,
0.4737858772277832,
0.5747511386871338,
-0.427496075630188,
0.8551170229911804,
0.43083468079566956,
-0.5946889519691467,
0.19151510298252106,
0.054215021431446075,
0.11757837980985641,
0.7532903552055359,
-0.6569966077804565,
0.3402572274208069,
-0.09312400221824646,
0.2309384047985077,
-1.1769200563430786,
-0.23411309719085693,
0.4222683012485504,
-0.12519662082195282,
0.2880963981151581,
-0.32255128026008606,
-0.4208672046661377,
-0.07153762131929398,
-0.12524820864200592,
0.6333166360855103,
0.08183985948562622,
-0.3747346103191376,
0.9041652679443359,
0.3733978271484375,
-0.02405126951634884,
-0.5558120012283325,
-0.8983055949211121,
-0.004380940459668636,
-0.18611688911914825,
-0.8580357432365417,
0.17609451711177826,
-0.4466018080711365,
-0.5849977731704712,
0.0022257803939282894,
-0.47709330916404724,
0.08701276034116745,
0.21348558366298676,
0.24491369724273682,
0.03473601117730141,
-0.48212769627571106,
-0.07179542630910873,
0.2870682179927826,
-0.2777364253997803,
0.45657438039779663,
-0.15592297911643982,
0.27479156851768494,
-0.2261466085910797,
-0.8351395726203918,
-0.24565675854682922,
0.37446510791778564,
0.674229085445404,
-0.3170424997806549,
0.3015236258506775,
0.4080222249031067,
-0.1767364740371704,
-0.5899909734725952,
-0.7988817691802979,
-0.49006643891334534,
-0.47324860095977783,
0.037352874875068665,
-0.3835388123989105,
-0.839047372341156,
0.6476880311965942,
-0.0575641468167305,
-0.07198389619588852,
0.3955895006656647,
0.5320112109184265,
-0.2937585711479187,
0.9570552110671997,
0.27143192291259766,
0.32436898350715637,
0.2523549497127533,
-0.27342838048934937,
0.05069340392947197,
-0.9333928823471069,
-0.44959282875061035,
-0.060465503484010696,
-0.42377373576164246,
-0.27076485753059387,
-0.6073224544525146,
0.6689831614494324,
-0.10382942855358124,
0.10331302136182785,
-0.04668506607413292,
-0.3415372669696808,
0.6424729824066162,
0.6592479348182678,
0.3629876971244812,
0.44711366295814514,
-0.07503771036863327,
-0.0029769563116133213,
-0.12385918200016022,
-0.6959348917007446,
-0.2978976368904114,
0.6965622305870056,
0.22065728902816772,
0.7043339014053345,
0.13826021552085876,
0.5299487113952637,
0.3294738829135895,
0.22651004791259766,
-0.5565066933631897,
0.6833146810531616,
0.24734461307525635,
-0.5288234949111938,
-0.17519685626029968,
-0.19809117913246155,
-0.8808441162109375,
0.41239315271377563,
-0.013709940016269684,
-0.3800611197948456,
0.18685384094715118,
0.4555959701538086,
-0.016149619594216347,
0.18446089327335358,
-0.6629573106765747,
0.9582215547561646,
-0.3022483289241791,
-0.8439286351203918,
-0.25170475244522095,
-0.6262637972831726,
0.6649202108383179,
0.12609754502773285,
0.3389800488948822,
-0.26637354493141174,
0.14598841965198517,
0.2357833832502365,
-0.18650899827480316,
1.2415237426757812,
0.09207756072282791,
-0.6371076703071594,
0.4242818355560303,
0.560591459274292,
0.34695255756378174,
0.12779496610164642,
0.45143744349479675,
0.195516899228096,
-0.14159823954105377,
-0.6187208294868469,
-0.8859218955039978,
0.9411947131156921,
-0.4738871455192566,
-0.9058351516723633,
-0.38593292236328125,
-0.7002990245819092,
-0.30599445104599,
-0.05795571208000183,
-0.14896944165229797,
0.4928120970726013,
0.029078008607029915,
-0.2830122113227844,
0.9571329355239868,
0.11034934222698212,
0.323149174451828,
0.5951691269874573,
-0.12350786477327347,
-0.21736669540405273,
0.6579087376594543,
0.04485243186354637,
0.37346333265304565,
0.11900849640369415,
0.21953211724758148,
-0.1278819739818573,
-0.4027562141418457,
-0.5893152952194214,
0.49431660771369934,
-0.9950702786445618,
-0.11501256376504898,
-0.7585210204124451,
-0.15071383118629456,
-0.2858719229698181,
-0.1006384864449501,
-0.4133552312850952,
-0.31460103392601013,
-0.29897335171699524,
-0.2657228410243988,
-0.0214090459048748,
0.8983766436576843,
-0.26257357001304626,
0.3641173243522644,
-0.818771481513977,
0.05823079124093056,
0.4817318618297577,
-0.022533448413014412,
0.06485158950090408,
-0.22350332140922546,
-0.32740625739097595,
0.05908980593085289,
-0.34788623452186584,
-0.9147713780403137,
0.06082218885421753,
-0.08936707675457001,
0.6982647180557251,
0.2483511120080948,
-0.3850997984409332,
0.7763509154319763,
-0.46743229031562805,
0.7321580648422241,
-0.20737360417842865,
-0.9313334226608276,
0.6102985143661499,
-0.4617758095264435,
0.4780997335910797,
0.21830128133296967,
-0.11306864768266678,
-0.3759828805923462,
-0.771873414516449,
-0.6892213225364685,
-0.7856113314628601,
0.3534599542617798,
-0.05571742728352547,
0.13985855877399445,
-0.0962652862071991,
0.43665608763694763,
0.0985323116183281,
0.0735463798046112,
-0.6982535719871521,
-0.3787061274051666,
0.1070878729224205,
-0.14273622632026672,
0.09285183995962143,
-0.7196767330169678,
-0.44565677642822266,
-0.21164856851100922,
0.7600455284118652,
-0.21630890667438507,
0.1396244317293167,
0.5535222887992859,
-0.4411526024341583,
-0.33471593260765076,
0.27197596430778503,
1.0154674053192139,
1.006563663482666,
0.07488290965557098,
0.5269979238510132,
0.0005116101237945259,
-0.10503080487251282,
0.01871340535581112,
-0.4196014702320099,
-0.09615139663219452,
-0.14963868260383606,
0.6923883557319641,
0.6441968083381653,
0.557371199131012,
-0.653558075428009,
0.4360356628894806,
0.16844603419303894,
-0.014675424434244633,
-0.38454416394233704,
0.22098830342292786,
0.21797780692577362,
0.30400851368904114,
0.2973797917366028,
0.20020268857479095,
0.06505248695611954,
-0.6441425085067749,
0.1935664266347885,
0.43848899006843567,
-0.35995230078697205,
-0.42448118329048157,
0.4872347414493561,
-0.055804137140512466,
-0.09196574240922928,
0.3239092230796814,
0.31423038244247437,
-0.7115465402603149,
0.5207951664924622,
0.5645549893379211,
0.7348091006278992,
-0.32963788509368896,
0.21995346248149872,
0.07192982733249664,
0.6371071338653564,
0.06430462747812271,
0.13418371975421906,
0.1157602071762085,
-0.8712061047554016,
-0.6378944516181946,
-0.13781926035881042,
-0.35592490434646606,
-0.04359206557273865,
-0.3192148208618164,
-0.06675399094820023,
-0.3417673110961914,
0.12797541916370392,
-0.2938723564147949,
-0.4643811881542206,
-0.5627295970916748,
0.23606805503368378,
0.1137138083577156,
0.6374821662902832,
-1.0223209857940674,
0.26827272772789,
0.5422499179840088,
-0.30481135845184326,
-0.6014061570167542,
0.026147598400712013,
0.13025060296058655,
-1.0699807405471802,
0.5590893626213074,
0.032089170068502426,
-0.47986578941345215,
0.004159210249781609,
-0.8057184815406799,
-0.7126283049583435,
0.9359567761421204,
0.5812572240829468,
-0.5015286207199097,
0.10103625059127808,
0.44721537828445435,
0.37984585762023926,
-0.3851448893547058,
0.3073183000087738,
0.7697398066520691,
0.6917520761489868,
-0.10510163754224777,
-0.6363281607627869,
0.12768831849098206,
0.08281195163726807,
-0.4335429072380066,
0.046327367424964905,
-0.7472637295722961,
0.8724070191383362,
-0.4200625419616699,
-0.10434368997812271,
-0.35268956422805786,
0.4431634843349457,
0.5137178301811218,
0.7638673186302185,
0.5057703256607056,
0.8695448040962219,
0.6064248085021973,
-0.07255998998880386,
1.09725022315979,
-0.11423417925834656,
0.0011591705260798335,
1.212755799293518,
-0.21817494928836823,
0.4617692828178406,
0.776412844657898,
-0.06254351884126663,
0.8956604599952698,
0.5371702909469604,
0.21571089327335358,
0.4122684597969055,
0.12369802594184875,
-0.501613199710846,
-0.5422648787498474,
0.020836537703871727,
-0.1756497621536255,
0.4672316908836365,
0.5124968886375427,
-0.15782734751701355,
0.02593178115785122,
-0.055572815239429474,
0.14055362343788147,
0.011683989316225052,
-0.3079650104045868,
0.897161602973938,
0.33880317211151123,
-0.6996117830276489,
0.250760555267334,
-0.11000609397888184,
0.22397951781749725,
-0.36932653188705444,
-0.2567528784275055,
-0.47548484802246094,
0.3353217542171478,
-0.42604896426200867,
-0.7083919644355774,
0.35368868708610535,
-0.5876588821411133,
-0.3480246067047119,
-0.2123250812292099,
1.0593785047531128,
-0.5546770095825195,
-0.46405935287475586,
0.44156786799430847,
1.098148226737976,
-0.0587044432759285,
-0.4425267279148102,
-0.7054702043533325,
0.29409509897232056,
-0.07506325840950012,
-0.12839174270629883,
0.26539674401283264,
0.7796989679336548,
-0.06370651721954346,
0.7202805280685425,
0.756241500377655,
0.003972342237830162,
0.41947320103645325,
0.03932808339595795,
0.9671313762664795,
-0.6696888208389282,
-0.32678094506263733,
-1.2054393291473389,
0.7385426759719849,
0.10810369998216629,
-0.08057378232479095,
0.8381468057632446,
0.5982005596160889,
0.8085585832595825,
-0.34667620062828064,
0.7629212141036987,
0.5077373385429382,
0.37576934695243835,
-0.7916313409805298,
0.3654915988445282,
-0.6640625,
0.459448903799057,
0.03737657889723778,
-0.8876127600669861,
-0.2122037708759308,
0.2253393828868866,
-0.1920812726020813,
-0.17623572051525116,
0.8535986542701721,
1.0373698472976685,
-0.3656652867794037,
-0.2284815013408661,
0.35721227526664734,
0.5479175448417664,
0.15938015282154083,
0.4785240888595581,
1.188641905784607,
-0.24399936199188232,
0.2041962593793869,
-0.26484784483909607,
-0.1054731011390686,
-0.20718060433864594,
-0.933642566204071,
-0.7927135825157166,
-0.3227168917655945,
-0.47575896978378296,
-0.38247963786125183,
0.19681376218795776,
0.6802873015403748,
0.6547563672065735,
-0.6770225763320923,
-0.08324869722127914,
-0.23065882921218872,
0.5736150145530701,
-0.2830577492713928,
-0.3166956603527069,
0.11793391406536102,
-0.5641619563102722,
-0.6333075165748596,
0.7903087139129639,
0.40286359190940857,
-0.02630370669066906,
-0.6314190030097961,
0.13052600622177124,
0.07490341365337372,
0.25711092352867126,
0.6221990585327148,
0.17116223275661469,
-0.9331971406936646,
-0.33619794249534607,
0.01359170489013195,
-0.11501967161893845,
0.29357290267944336,
1.3596231937408447,
-0.5746098160743713,
0.15499287843704224,
0.29852205514907837,
0.6018773317337036,
0.4811525344848633,
-0.2049148976802826,
0.7378782033920288,
-0.9194193482398987,
-0.1535061001777649,
0.00470630032941699,
0.48920196294784546,
0.44642066955566406,
-0.4573996365070343,
0.5634812116622925,
0.5926066637039185,
-0.7143035531044006,
-0.9191025495529175,
0.4748417139053345,
-1.2146166563034058,
-0.2702173888683319,
1.3017363548278809,
-0.06097376346588135,
-0.47007015347480774,
-0.03381200134754181,
-0.3863851726055145,
0.0014701783657073975,
-0.07658608257770538,
0.8461332321166992,
0.6607323884963989,
-0.3452681303024292,
-0.5177569389343262,
-0.5369951725006104,
0.477256178855896,
0.6336521506309509,
-0.8943146467208862,
0.08755989372730255,
0.578475832939148,
0.7263705134391785,
0.16973835229873657,
0.7434061169624329,
-0.06279345601797104,
0.23608413338661194,
-0.27365440130233765,
0.006233041640371084,
-0.059946998953819275,
-0.5038501620292664,
-0.03464358672499657,
0.003105719806626439,
0.05453120172023773,
0.07948005944490433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14327v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14327v2
|
Subobject-level Image Tokenization
| 2024-02-22T06:47:44 | 2024-04-23T13:41:47 |
Delong Chen, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Jianfeng Liu, Baoyuan Wang, Pascale Fung
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Transformer-based vision models typically tokenize images into fixed-size
square patches as input units, which lacks the adaptability to image content
and overlooks the inherent pixel grouping structure. Inspired by the subword
tokenization widely adopted in language models, we propose an image tokenizer
at a subobject level, where the subobjects are represented by semantically
meaningful image segments obtained by segmentation models (e.g., segment
anything models). To implement a learning system based on subobject
tokenization, we first introduced a Direct Segment Anything Model (DirectSAM)
that efficiently produces comprehensive segmentation of subobjects, then embed
subobjects into compact latent vectors and fed them into a large language model
for vision language learning. Empirical results demonstrated that our
subobject-level tokenization significantly facilitates efficient learning of
translating images into object and attribute descriptions compared to the
traditional patch-level tokenization. Codes and models are open-sourced at
https://github.com/ChenDelong1999/subobjects.
|
[
-0.2471882700920105,
-0.6042299866676331,
0.14090943336486816,
-0.09535679966211319,
-0.7244707345962524,
0.1328325867652893,
0.2445555329322815,
-0.528161346912384,
0.12427742034196854,
0.3494478166103363,
-0.30708321928977966,
-0.713374674320221,
-0.645383358001709,
-0.34603968262672424,
-0.3797704875469208,
0.5787399411201477,
0.2014981508255005,
0.22688651084899902,
-0.18004769086837769,
0.04111270606517792,
-0.6666390299797058,
-0.37599506974220276,
-0.6600147485733032,
-0.291008859872818,
0.523981511592865,
0.4249321222305298,
0.5598303079605103,
0.8895996809005737,
0.8125542402267456,
0.2730156481266022,
0.0122435437515378,
-0.059447403997182846,
-0.19297488033771515,
-0.3425164520740509,
-0.38142576813697815,
-0.5190554261207581,
-0.32882067561149597,
0.011568447574973106,
0.3913337290287018,
0.6696671843528748,
-0.06180896237492561,
0.1353713423013687,
-0.6867476105690002,
0.38371041417121887,
-0.41940510272979736,
0.20880800485610962,
-0.9390854835510254,
0.31231194734573364,
-0.08267305046319962,
0.12099650502204895,
-0.5048778653144836,
0.0754869282245636,
0.019793374463915825,
-0.7091271281242371,
0.38363224267959595,
0.30639010667800903,
1.0150535106658936,
0.17408205568790436,
-0.02048906497657299,
-0.05763581022620201,
-0.21977053582668304,
0.8646469116210938,
-0.4054192006587982,
0.5178348422050476,
0.15273107588291168,
0.49650317430496216,
0.21684765815734863,
-0.814441442489624,
-0.3654990494251251,
0.10192442685365677,
-0.28737905621528625,
-0.10263282060623169,
-0.1891184151172638,
0.1227518767118454,
0.008926786482334137,
0.47211185097694397,
-0.17738564312458038,
0.22754082083702087,
-0.6758745312690735,
-0.20372755825519562,
0.25572463870048523,
0.12237834185361862,
0.49098849296569824,
-0.29103171825408936,
-0.5498762726783752,
0.10500423610210419,
-0.7028612494468689,
0.056986432522535324,
-0.02305172011256218,
0.12102106213569641,
0.2007814347743988,
0.6523321866989136,
-0.05521029606461525,
0.6233158111572266,
0.408908486366272,
-0.3200990855693817,
0.02450164034962654,
-0.09026213735342026,
-0.2548992931842804,
-0.21540628373622894,
0.39283740520477295,
0.3923216164112091,
0.12712621688842773,
-0.210010826587677,
-0.44443705677986145,
-0.05891015753149986,
0.24206945300102234,
-0.8728697299957275,
-0.409380704164505,
0.10720076411962509,
-0.797885000705719,
-0.27628305554389954,
0.1568596065044403,
-0.4972264766693115,
-0.3463967442512512,
-0.11528395861387253,
0.34965577721595764,
-0.5938014388084412,
-0.09546197205781937,
-0.03073928691446781,
-0.10289424657821655,
0.5040344595909119,
0.22227878868579865,
-0.8620807528495789,
0.07423996180295944,
0.619792640209198,
0.7674223780632019,
-0.3443797528743744,
-0.41324713826179504,
-0.37051185965538025,
0.1284513920545578,
-0.5882977247238159,
0.9710600972175598,
-0.8653092980384827,
-0.6857430338859558,
-0.16753458976745605,
0.1615980714559555,
0.15515340864658356,
-0.8364455103874207,
-0.18473275005817413,
-0.6484367847442627,
-0.05864511430263519,
0.20167025923728943,
-0.45747971534729004,
-0.09717787057161331,
0.30321380496025085,
-0.3655092120170593,
0.9985886216163635,
0.15683700144290924,
-0.419820636510849,
0.6164116263389587,
-0.6398544907569885,
-0.45845475792884827,
0.4559241831302643,
-0.36130669713020325,
-0.4298582375049591,
0.4048005938529968,
0.5357182621955872,
0.4814316928386688,
0.01746607944369316,
0.13753221929073334,
0.24942784011363983,
-0.35692402720451355,
0.1122186928987503,
0.04925410822033882,
0.17943540215492249,
-0.13494671881198883,
-0.13235560059547424,
0.4234645366668701,
-0.6695972681045532,
-0.29597800970077515,
0.12287838011980057,
-0.33363932371139526,
-0.26172372698783875,
0.06800800561904907,
0.04994330182671547,
0.05645572394132614,
0.4102088510990143,
-0.9259746670722961,
0.19403637945652008,
-0.227305606007576,
0.4353819191455841,
0.8939022421836853,
-0.013211646117269993,
0.7639477849006653,
0.12819235026836395,
0.5990880727767944,
0.6873311400413513,
0.6817872524261475,
-0.710405707359314,
-0.41643786430358887,
-1.149307131767273,
-0.7104204893112183,
0.20765118300914764,
0.3119060695171356,
-0.8930174708366394,
0.20256316661834717,
-0.37075066566467285,
-0.5000900030136108,
-0.200836643576622,
-0.07195412367582321,
0.49416765570640564,
0.5424897074699402,
0.6160416603088379,
-0.4422917366027832,
-0.5581657886505127,
-1.0951827764511108,
0.14899608492851257,
-0.2713451683521271,
0.047092366963624954,
0.37277692556381226,
0.6122130751609802,
-0.3685591220855713,
1.0069831609725952,
-0.609384298324585,
-0.6220224499702454,
-0.41122880578041077,
-0.10188367962837219,
0.055691614747047424,
0.9296599626541138,
0.45125797390937805,
-0.8188369274139404,
-0.3732818067073822,
0.27845799922943115,
-0.32586416602134705,
0.16438159346580505,
-0.022013602778315544,
-0.1888962835073471,
0.004256382118910551,
0.8863486647605896,
-0.2176397740840912,
0.61721271276474,
0.30102604627609253,
-0.3554364740848541,
0.17230388522148132,
0.049173466861248016,
-0.1762494146823883,
-0.9266107082366943,
-0.02838590368628502,
-0.2593420147895813,
-0.39848777651786804,
-0.44069600105285645,
0.1426786482334137,
0.09415967017412186,
-0.2899530529975891,
-0.7919631004333496,
0.4945255219936371,
-0.30486559867858887,
-0.28604239225387573,
-0.3865033984184265,
-0.23387867212295532,
0.008528277277946472,
0.5289673805236816,
0.49141478538513184,
0.5308666229248047,
0.8383901119232178,
-0.19641481339931488,
0.4389682412147522,
0.20671610534191132,
-0.35964182019233704,
0.7833341360092163,
-0.9660869836807251,
0.12740926444530487,
-0.23888809978961945,
0.19502730667591095,
-0.736225962638855,
-0.2637534737586975,
0.1284128576517105,
-0.22913308441638947,
0.27998414635658264,
-0.3120119273662567,
-0.03100411593914032,
-0.1606980860233307,
0.08855538070201874,
0.6931546330451965,
0.7033767104148865,
-0.7321845889091492,
1.0396533012390137,
0.5252313613891602,
0.20981040596961975,
-0.4804340898990631,
-0.7837576270103455,
0.07614772021770477,
0.2199147641658783,
-0.3042576014995575,
0.26843103766441345,
0.3547597825527191,
0.3220127522945404,
0.3114510178565979,
0.003690165700390935,
-0.10015831142663956,
-0.25776588916778564,
0.550024151802063,
0.5081870555877686,
-0.13339988887310028,
0.06200812757015228,
-0.043035198003053665,
-0.23928380012512207,
-0.4057275950908661,
-0.6359651684761047,
0.5567196011543274,
-0.10886955261230469,
-0.44662970304489136,
-0.3173149824142456,
0.418908029794693,
0.43377184867858887,
-0.4853198528289795,
0.6201726794242859,
0.45524781942367554,
-0.4603731334209442,
-0.29178565740585327,
-0.38890156149864197,
0.024544483050704002,
-0.4574437737464905,
0.7667451500892639,
-0.7825113534927368,
-0.908615231513977,
0.46019604802131653,
-0.017681382596492767,
0.05381723493337631,
0.21313266456127167,
0.35945311188697815,
0.01923331990838051,
0.874967634677887,
0.7758201360702515,
0.18646517395973206,
0.904507040977478,
-0.5050588250160217,
0.31463363766670227,
-0.8300871253013611,
-0.7641366720199585,
0.16667352616786957,
-0.575844943523407,
-0.049241676926612854,
-1.016720175743103,
0.07197027653455734,
0.04826179891824722,
0.09680713713169098,
0.45188021659851074,
-0.5301470160484314,
0.9308478832244873,
0.786352813243866,
0.3222994804382324,
-0.06116947531700134,
-0.06335737556219101,
-0.18343010544776917,
0.14189167320728302,
-0.7025427222251892,
-0.25201767683029175,
0.5744652152061462,
0.5979956984519958,
1.0721265077590942,
-0.45914334058761597,
0.5781770348548889,
0.2831689119338989,
0.46522900462150574,
-1.255054235458374,
0.7728915214538574,
-0.40821051597595215,
-0.5569737553596497,
-0.202082097530365,
-0.09600169211626053,
-0.686495840549469,
0.28967636823654175,
-0.01547270454466343,
-0.423306405544281,
0.820132851600647,
0.15747897326946259,
0.024299224838614464,
0.54114830493927,
-0.6240155696868896,
0.9336913824081421,
0.010220924392342567,
0.2634783983230591,
0.008457714691758156,
-0.46775540709495544,
-0.037884123623371124,
-0.063060462474823,
0.13698294758796692,
-0.0847955048084259,
-0.307224839925766,
0.5658530592918396,
-0.4430650770664215,
1.0197250843048096,
-0.45084503293037415,
0.030690699815750122,
0.3907543420791626,
0.14459802210330963,
0.21808120608329773,
-0.09386230260133743,
0.49529820680618286,
0.5254406929016113,
0.010225746780633926,
-0.7560416460037231,
-0.4787658154964447,
0.17645831406116486,
-0.636918306350708,
-0.45676472783088684,
-0.025333134457468987,
-0.5603277683258057,
0.004313555546104908,
0.35200440883636475,
0.1369575560092926,
0.5054959058761597,
-0.1460210382938385,
0.2711426615715027,
0.330401748418808,
-0.48259127140045166,
0.1967993974685669,
0.3912859857082367,
-0.6586903929710388,
-0.5060789585113525,
1.230694055557251,
-0.12861110270023346,
0.16880640387535095,
0.7230201363563538,
0.154107466340065,
-0.06126472353935242,
-0.732499897480011,
-0.3141128420829773,
0.06932780891656876,
-1.0752681493759155,
-0.5146580338478088,
-0.3990846574306488,
-0.11603884398937225,
-0.4324665367603302,
-0.372743159532547,
-0.562767505645752,
-0.3037111461162567,
-0.2432512491941452,
-0.4262150824069977,
-0.08788684010505676,
0.7515250444412231,
-0.0713106244802475,
0.5265091061592102,
-0.5733208656311035,
0.3565135896205902,
0.5924420952796936,
0.3044268786907196,
-0.11910734325647354,
-0.556160032749176,
-0.5283891558647156,
-0.31177061796188354,
0.08576650172472,
-0.30004608631134033,
0.19773398339748383,
0.3600182831287384,
0.39080697298049927,
0.4374156892299652,
-0.37708523869514465,
0.8675626516342163,
-0.761663556098938,
1.0036952495574951,
0.5931593775749207,
-1.1820389032363892,
0.665793240070343,
0.028062840923666954,
0.264310359954834,
0.14612171053886414,
-0.11864615976810455,
-0.586432695388794,
-0.31465885043144226,
-0.17224492132663727,
-0.7827344536781311,
0.7980365753173828,
-0.21088658273220062,
0.3214641809463501,
-0.2503957450389862,
0.4024968147277832,
0.22994659841060638,
0.04582235962152481,
-0.6772518157958984,
-0.060841940343379974,
-0.7237359285354614,
-0.4220995306968689,
0.15908972918987274,
-0.3552650809288025,
0.1301845759153366,
-0.2166852205991745,
0.5308178067207336,
-0.28507086634635925,
0.2675805389881134,
0.22307127714157104,
-0.3419702649116516,
-0.029345307499170303,
-0.08508169651031494,
0.3123568594455719,
0.5855036377906799,
0.056896455585956573,
0.5146303772926331,
-0.024756677448749542,
-0.6858534812927246,
0.16589653491973877,
-0.3387646973133087,
-0.48082876205444336,
0.0288374200463295,
0.356249064207077,
1.0346107482910156,
0.12037038058042526,
-0.7370482683181763,
0.6520628333091736,
0.09690448641777039,
-0.23827114701271057,
0.21133248507976532,
-0.021667176857590675,
-0.10659242421388626,
0.2953203320503235,
0.5815303921699524,
0.13035985827445984,
-0.20372804999351501,
-0.5116846561431885,
0.14545336365699768,
0.419059157371521,
-0.7236040830612183,
-0.3847489058971405,
0.514796257019043,
0.22343596816062927,
-0.2847001254558563,
0.4186742901802063,
0.13119640946388245,
-0.6849153637886047,
0.7003437280654907,
0.5554407835006714,
0.6916298270225525,
-0.01705963723361492,
0.5598742365837097,
0.19211654365062714,
0.6730191707611084,
0.2410147339105606,
0.11601252853870392,
-0.11027195304632187,
-0.7335558533668518,
-0.30682265758514404,
-0.8892773985862732,
-0.31854522228240967,
-0.1471959948539734,
-0.31460675597190857,
-0.048135221004486084,
-0.5939386487007141,
-0.020884444937109947,
-0.14995387196540833,
-0.6427626013755798,
-0.4950101673603058,
0.6610061526298523,
0.16242143511772156,
1.0837827920913696,
-0.6029376983642578,
0.8689345121383667,
1.1180598735809326,
-0.5412888526916504,
-0.67628014087677,
-0.3719371259212494,
-0.9129270911216736,
-1.1696927547454834,
1.0999149084091187,
0.1446622610092163,
0.11351659893989563,
0.0851430743932724,
-0.5794437527656555,
-0.7392294406890869,
1.0675010681152344,
0.25192585587501526,
-0.3227713406085968,
-0.22994908690452576,
0.5000015497207642,
0.30808553099632263,
-0.6382667422294617,
-0.23659540712833405,
0.14094561338424683,
0.1642541140317917,
0.44652241468429565,
-0.4511536955833435,
0.0757894441485405,
-0.08800919353961945,
0.5803846716880798,
0.1536872386932373,
-0.5439223051071167,
0.8368318676948547,
-0.03868189454078674,
-0.37353289127349854,
0.181295245885849,
0.8100849390029907,
-0.3174890875816345,
-0.01951882801949978,
0.669783353805542,
0.6299078464508057,
0.10304342210292816,
-0.15262724459171295,
0.7121750712394714,
-0.1171584501862526,
0.41266754269599915,
0.9682621955871582,
0.2127724587917328,
0.7205764651298523,
0.8786479830741882,
-0.04537414386868477,
0.6801568269729614,
0.5383198857307434,
-0.2673609256744385,
0.6556951999664307,
0.10247088223695755,
0.10510583221912384,
-0.5529891848564148,
-0.4674402177333832,
0.04318850859999657,
0.4620240330696106,
0.2562376856803894,
-0.5668611526489258,
-0.02259976603090763,
0.4766254127025604,
-0.648406445980072,
-0.31352558732032776,
-0.5293093919754028,
0.8435741662979126,
0.051206257194280624,
-0.41548749804496765,
0.09325820952653885,
0.19594870507717133,
0.6527636051177979,
-0.4464408755302429,
0.005968026351183653,
-0.5338144898414612,
0.24251985549926758,
-0.3368992805480957,
-0.5902926325798035,
0.41272518038749695,
0.13671018183231354,
-0.0769587978720665,
-0.07317858189344406,
0.7539037466049194,
-0.38731276988983154,
-0.8632346391677856,
-0.06626542657613754,
0.2597079277038574,
0.16778214275836945,
0.05591249465942383,
-0.5955527424812317,
0.04931727051734924,
-0.3794829249382019,
-0.10062085092067719,
0.1250436007976532,
0.3524820804595947,
0.09809552133083344,
0.34323030710220337,
0.6036508083343506,
0.03785281628370285,
0.4943242371082306,
0.11457759886980057,
0.9186677932739258,
-0.40860819816589355,
-0.2935078740119934,
-0.6505069732666016,
0.49288785457611084,
-0.013634340837597847,
0.0489266999065876,
0.5286793112754822,
0.5922552943229675,
1.0623527765274048,
-0.3375571668148041,
0.4474387466907501,
-0.28027400374412537,
0.09760010242462158,
-0.416354775428772,
0.2888723909854889,
-0.6927028298377991,
-0.15474951267242432,
-0.07344163209199905,
-0.7732219099998474,
-0.5481045842170715,
0.7053923606872559,
-0.3356245756149292,
-0.24764059484004974,
0.5312175750732422,
0.7884676456451416,
-0.3073509633541107,
-0.636076807975769,
0.7456435561180115,
-0.08671853691339493,
0.37599825859069824,
0.3225274980068207,
0.9754586219787598,
-0.4977082312107086,
0.6727490425109863,
-0.3692488372325897,
-0.23617538809776306,
-0.01602715067565441,
-0.6056030988693237,
-1.1528555154800415,
-0.4617542326450348,
-0.4601203501224518,
0.05407969281077385,
-0.07349596917629242,
0.5226212739944458,
1.1127434968948364,
-0.9237717986106873,
-0.001045861979946494,
-0.4169164001941681,
0.15277820825576782,
0.03960489109158516,
-0.20398032665252686,
0.3831411600112915,
-0.3206104040145874,
-0.9328799843788147,
0.18086320161819458,
0.671249508857727,
0.12284518033266068,
-0.46693432331085205,
0.00525495084002614,
-0.07703042030334473,
0.41317662596702576,
0.585475504398346,
0.11173813045024872,
-0.7945338487625122,
-0.46564731001853943,
0.2986326217651367,
-0.058429088443517685,
0.2413356602191925,
0.9880475401878357,
-0.71214759349823,
0.4115181267261505,
0.40812745690345764,
0.6392678022384644,
0.22736436128616333,
0.18931148946285248,
0.17464232444763184,
-0.8948995471000671,
0.4508427381515503,
-0.08081759512424469,
0.5602609515190125,
0.5417333245277405,
-0.19464725255966187,
0.42412400245666504,
0.43169310688972473,
-0.11786770820617676,
-0.6429233551025391,
0.562750518321991,
-0.8117461204528809,
-0.5350810885429382,
0.8547420501708984,
-0.6018344163894653,
-0.5281844139099121,
0.10902640223503113,
-0.6702547073364258,
0.012559239752590656,
-0.22239737212657928,
0.4217999577522278,
0.16292324662208557,
0.04197130724787712,
-0.398147314786911,
0.5115313529968262,
-0.043873872607946396,
0.3137166500091553,
-0.731972873210907,
-0.33153650164604187,
0.5000609159469604,
0.12715581059455872,
0.3429437279701233,
0.5201320648193359,
-0.24440497159957886,
0.18265198171138763,
0.18674053251743317,
0.1454404890537262,
-0.32091808319091797,
-0.4521098732948303,
0.05606665834784508,
0.21835829317569733,
-0.15140466392040253,
-0.6924420595169067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14320v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14320v5
|
Triad: A Framework Leveraging a Multi-Role LLM-based Agent to Solve Knowledge Base Question Answering
| 2024-02-22T06:23:37 | 2024-04-16T02:46:10 |
Chang Zong, Yuchen Yan, Weiming Lu, Jian Shao, Eliot Huang, Heng Chang, Yueting Zhuang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Recent progress with LLM-based agents has shown promising results across
various tasks. However, their use in answering questions from knowledge bases
remains largely unexplored. Implementing a KBQA system using traditional
methods is challenging due to the shortage of task-specific training data and
the complexity of creating task-focused model structures. In this paper, we
present Triad, a unified framework that utilizes an LLM-based agent with three
roles for KBQA tasks. The agent is assigned three roles to tackle different
KBQA subtasks: agent as a generalist for mastering various subtasks, as a
decision maker for the selection of candidates, and as an advisor for answering
questions with knowledge. Our KBQA framework is executed in four phases,
involving the collaboration of the agent's multiple roles. We evaluated the
performance of our framework using three benchmark datasets, and the results
show that our framework outperforms state-of-the-art systems on the LC-QuAD and
YAGO-QA benchmarks, yielding F1 scores of 11.8% and 20.7%, respectively.
|
[
-0.4629964828491211,
-0.5559415221214294,
0.6816677451133728,
0.1217719316482544,
-0.025508780032396317,
0.280320405960083,
0.35714876651763916,
-0.2574942708015442,
-0.01132565550506115,
0.5613778233528137,
-0.6931772232055664,
-0.5857540369033813,
-0.17305472493171692,
0.2839539051055908,
-0.16803708672523499,
0.7014890313148499,
0.008921285159885883,
0.3876408040523529,
-0.35821351408958435,
-0.040213581174612045,
-0.7708551287651062,
-0.5030324459075928,
-0.6064191460609436,
-0.5076559782028198,
0.405344158411026,
0.7794556021690369,
0.8246305584907532,
0.2829035520553589,
0.08757378906011581,
0.22780382633209229,
0.09514792263507843,
0.19314256310462952,
-0.4216980040073395,
0.36254313588142395,
0.08306710422039032,
-0.6756351590156555,
-0.6109112501144409,
-0.1328781396150589,
0.37921106815338135,
0.5498098134994507,
-0.2387409210205078,
0.25015467405319214,
-0.13532377779483795,
0.6313065886497498,
-0.5711333751678467,
0.2233758419752121,
-0.5429321527481079,
-0.07140981405973434,
0.2609577476978302,
-0.2044922262430191,
-0.32947012782096863,
-0.2510814368724823,
0.3159302771091461,
-1.0388575792312622,
-0.16577045619487762,
0.10696609318256378,
0.5344199538230896,
0.10498086363077164,
-1.1152045726776123,
-0.24810655415058136,
-0.4106755554676056,
0.5312784910202026,
-0.3907085061073303,
0.319686621427536,
0.12578634917736053,
0.6712042689323425,
-0.25975000858306885,
-0.5270736217498779,
-0.3622177541255951,
-0.03186730667948723,
-0.049648452550172806,
0.23845946788787842,
0.09853080660104752,
0.3488610088825226,
-0.13139447569847107,
0.1712620109319687,
-0.57365882396698,
-0.20427194237709045,
-0.2530946731567383,
-0.2987957298755646,
0.2638515830039978,
0.4265625774860382,
0.23619896173477173,
-0.3266353905200958,
-0.6012483835220337,
0.18771614134311676,
-0.5642891526222229,
0.3282133936882019,
0.1455134153366089,
0.325469434261322,
0.2793269753456116,
0.4596635401248932,
-0.4574796259403229,
0.726617693901062,
0.3106626570224762,
-0.14712095260620117,
-0.14226138591766357,
-0.20437805354595184,
-0.38683372735977173,
-0.18072094023227692,
0.250808984041214,
0.50055330991745,
0.12206248939037323,
-0.548244059085846,
-0.1807289868593216,
-0.287736713886261,
0.4222468137741089,
-0.34634342789649963,
0.04674633964896202,
0.5009546875953674,
-0.1757364124059677,
-0.27773773670196533,
-0.14562135934829712,
-0.38832026720046997,
-0.5433367490768433,
-0.45454081892967224,
0.7890400886535645,
-0.2872720956802368,
-0.383944571018219,
0.13504932820796967,
-0.19470956921577454,
0.6746915578842163,
0.350749671459198,
-0.36193326115608215,
0.6021606922149658,
0.5088640451431274,
0.3673158586025238,
-0.179473415017128,
-0.18027377128601074,
-0.4699961543083191,
0.35248690843582153,
-0.40720680356025696,
0.5630588531494141,
-0.16860653460025787,
-0.32089847326278687,
-0.09587590396404266,
-0.1696164906024933,
-0.16373857855796814,
-0.4361494779586792,
-0.02394835092127323,
-1.1540921926498413,
-0.09875151515007019,
-0.6201222538948059,
-0.3968087136745453,
-0.2792142629623413,
0.6903917193412781,
-0.7609358429908752,
1.0229740142822266,
0.436758428812027,
-0.5354198217391968,
0.3103947043418884,
-0.5574857592582703,
0.029828408733010292,
0.20809926092624664,
-0.26277485489845276,
0.050223007798194885,
-0.47424256801605225,
0.3237629234790802,
0.44745415449142456,
-0.6929081082344055,
0.46465176343917847,
-0.03285602107644081,
-0.578334629535675,
0.2786444127559662,
0.13292528688907623,
0.7689768075942993,
-0.05029040202498436,
-0.22778931260108948,
0.04488512873649597,
-0.6364948153495789,
0.3898198902606964,
-0.3834993839263916,
-0.33731886744499207,
-0.20201140642166138,
-0.3785249590873718,
-0.13176369667053223,
0.47007203102111816,
0.16453339159488678,
-0.43722230195999146,
0.3034810423851013,
-0.03489761799573898,
-0.13911518454551697,
0.7274041771888733,
0.4260994493961334,
0.5614476203918457,
-0.5268685817718506,
0.8945111036300659,
0.2509565055370331,
0.31470197439193726,
0.653893232345581,
-0.31263232231140137,
-0.7462509274482727,
-0.21269506216049194,
0.22094103693962097,
0.6664833426475525,
-1.274658203125,
0.12050873786211014,
-0.18960998952388763,
-0.5442901849746704,
-0.3372706174850464,
0.20735114812850952,
0.5477354526519775,
0.480081170797348,
0.5005159378051758,
-0.0641496554017067,
-0.3741852343082428,
-1.187615990638733,
-0.16051431000232697,
-0.4135917127132416,
0.05963316187262535,
0.2791338860988617,
0.3956731855869293,
-0.02876030094921589,
1.2303636074066162,
-0.38605281710624695,
-0.4075322151184082,
-0.4468842148780823,
0.12869922816753387,
0.2280777245759964,
0.19107212126255035,
0.3131430149078369,
-0.9374762773513794,
-0.4278649389743805,
-0.1217924952507019,
-0.7420381903648376,
-0.1510055810213089,
-0.056444019079208374,
-0.4772752821445465,
0.11933416873216629,
0.4447920322418213,
-0.6449533104896545,
0.1266975849866867,
0.2825438678264618,
-0.5368809700012207,
0.7341814637184143,
0.37157028913497925,
0.36329472064971924,
-1.2765202522277832,
0.3093251585960388,
-0.4576186537742615,
-0.3225853741168976,
-0.968914270401001,
0.150826096534729,
-0.11186734586954117,
0.1886119693517685,
-0.4011448919773102,
0.40409037470817566,
-0.5062559843063354,
-0.3110329210758209,
-0.02910229004919529,
0.23377643525600433,
-0.09078964591026306,
0.9214490652084351,
-0.29283326864242554,
0.6887076497077942,
0.4805895686149597,
-0.7559299468994141,
0.4865000247955322,
0.42074859142303467,
-0.0035950178280472755,
0.8736653923988342,
-0.37470743060112,
0.0721975564956665,
-0.20131173729896545,
0.22695781290531158,
-0.8824255466461182,
-0.11467120796442032,
0.46978864073753357,
-0.33096960186958313,
0.09390407800674438,
-0.22671040892601013,
-0.6185520887374878,
-0.13043434917926788,
-0.22607247531414032,
0.3403562903404236,
-0.020776992663741112,
-0.17807163298130035,
1.199601173400879,
0.40172696113586426,
0.13183124363422394,
-1.0670300722122192,
-0.3802093267440796,
-0.20390209555625916,
0.017344599589705467,
-0.6322778463363647,
0.24992191791534424,
-0.0647301897406578,
-0.09923814237117767,
0.21613048017024994,
-0.6903626322746277,
-0.4158612787723541,
0.33073222637176514,
0.3789078891277313,
0.35235723853111267,
-0.2501378357410431,
0.23117265105247498,
-0.043245136737823486,
-0.16938753426074982,
0.08482339233160019,
-0.3662438988685608,
0.33732151985168457,
-0.40171360969543457,
-0.14381331205368042,
-0.03560002148151398,
0.44426172971725464,
0.7151215672492981,
0.02514839544892311,
0.5587552189826965,
0.3228760361671448,
-0.1863688975572586,
-0.138628751039505,
-0.4422101080417633,
-0.013354014605283737,
-0.436942994594574,
0.3825393617153168,
-0.5081762671470642,
-1.099801778793335,
0.4767615497112274,
0.1438271701335907,
0.21985533833503723,
0.139786958694458,
0.40899744629859924,
-0.01132985856384039,
0.7661277055740356,
0.5409897565841675,
-0.2486526370048523,
-0.14950989186763763,
-0.13202133774757385,
-0.07666437327861786,
-0.7729270458221436,
-0.3532899022102356,
-0.19910013675689697,
-0.26976698637008667,
-0.2601816654205322,
-0.382969468832016,
1.0363595485687256,
0.2938988506793976,
-0.593571126461029,
0.21130043268203735,
-0.22801874577999115,
0.2999410331249237,
0.6819689869880676,
0.23760119080543518,
0.7253379225730896,
-0.44348540902137756,
-0.251966655254364,
0.6151996850967407,
-0.8045002818107605,
-0.4248850345611572,
1.2241591215133667,
-0.02653196081519127,
0.44951072335243225,
0.4251825511455536,
0.4955218732357025,
0.2651767432689667,
0.32907137274742126,
-0.6161917448043823,
0.9004546403884888,
0.3905769884586334,
-1.1576038599014282,
-0.5671678781509399,
-0.3931882679462433,
-0.6065077781677246,
0.6336868405342102,
-0.3024212121963501,
-0.6124142408370972,
0.11381109058856964,
0.1633855104446411,
-0.37449967861175537,
0.15434518456459045,
-0.367240846157074,
0.8747063875198364,
-0.0755128338932991,
-0.030933193862438202,
-0.028694812208414078,
-0.9924910068511963,
0.5701233744621277,
-0.008345781825482845,
0.08139972388744354,
-0.1402674913406372,
-0.2891251742839813,
0.5963263511657715,
-0.20332933962345123,
0.7437048554420471,
-0.41759970784187317,
0.0901179388165474,
0.2941228151321411,
0.2420111894607544,
0.13729442656040192,
0.33818888664245605,
-0.14366210997104645,
-0.37455445528030396,
0.6508764028549194,
-0.45778366923332214,
-0.769931435585022,
0.2702787220478058,
-1.0396848917007446,
-0.8206273317337036,
-0.47998493909835815,
-0.7113721966743469,
-0.9386358857154846,
0.3851015269756317,
-0.10354664921760559,
0.45473286509513855,
-0.30168938636779785,
0.21416909992694855,
0.4032350182533264,
0.16078796982765198,
-0.021331164985895157,
0.809371829032898,
-0.26498663425445557,
-0.46736738085746765,
0.5002713203430176,
-0.1489735245704651,
0.46211478114128113,
0.5539036393165588,
-0.21421989798545837,
-0.15831202268600464,
-0.2824592590332031,
-0.4476639926433563,
-0.052450861781835556,
-0.9136133193969727,
-0.6098443269729614,
-0.6345932483673096,
-0.20249660313129425,
-0.3720373809337616,
-0.06331370025873184,
-0.026658620685338974,
-0.3951934576034546,
0.058025114238262177,
-0.028798945248126984,
0.11251389980316162,
0.6913130879402161,
0.11482596397399902,
0.44595327973365784,
-0.6183425188064575,
0.6452503204345703,
0.7799304127693176,
0.2832592725753784,
-0.027994785457849503,
0.07546563446521759,
-0.23748917877674103,
-0.027480043470859528,
-0.40888869762420654,
-1.1146544218063354,
-0.19301913678646088,
-0.10831642895936966,
0.8470199108123779,
-0.07046902179718018,
0.29630202054977417,
0.5823104381561279,
0.12026984989643097,
0.6403449177742004,
-0.03958701342344284,
-0.978651225566864,
-0.017876094207167625,
-0.5193783640861511,
0.44308948516845703,
0.966185986995697,
0.4534645080566406,
-0.759263277053833,
-0.6347306966781616,
-0.24237021803855896,
-0.7652155756950378,
0.9707018733024597,
0.34003740549087524,
-0.5905756950378418,
0.32401856780052185,
0.48809635639190674,
-0.129464790225029,
0.5908482670783997,
-0.7932189702987671,
-0.49414393305778503,
-0.08755840361118317,
-0.13003449141979218,
0.2747665047645569,
-0.062084391713142395,
-0.21303291618824005,
0.014438911341130733,
0.8809359073638916,
-0.4885929524898529,
0.21659612655639648,
0.35721904039382935,
-0.4799376428127289,
-0.12837785482406616,
0.5004936456680298,
-0.00815094169229269,
0.589905858039856,
-0.15648894011974335,
-0.03713186830282211,
0.2982652485370636,
-0.33858197927474976,
0.38312482833862305,
-0.01720934920012951,
-0.23273593187332153,
-0.3352935016155243,
0.24980397522449493,
0.20368297398090363,
0.40675681829452515,
-0.4855746328830719,
0.5345664024353027,
-0.03476157784461975,
-0.44855859875679016,
-0.13432852923870087,
0.09464216977357864,
0.4066484570503235,
0.4521292746067047,
0.6150965094566345,
-0.20566609501838684,
0.3402771055698395,
-0.40380021929740906,
0.2180558741092682,
0.3992083668708801,
-0.3143162727355957,
-0.023301199078559875,
0.23414412140846252,
0.2728123962879181,
0.23358917236328125,
0.45068442821502686,
0.03394356369972229,
-0.7428090572357178,
0.8837404251098633,
0.30499663949012756,
0.5941446423530579,
-0.19181078672409058,
0.6201677322387695,
-0.018624654039740562,
0.3302355706691742,
0.005388323217630386,
0.7763696312904358,
-0.09135343134403229,
-0.7673067450523376,
-0.025220423936843872,
-0.385276734828949,
-0.5224152207374573,
-0.0056421784684062,
-0.7639542818069458,
0.08482828736305237,
-0.20794923603534698,
-0.026866866275668144,
-0.3176599442958832,
0.3096087872982025,
-0.6518351435661316,
0.1507779210805893,
-0.18728753924369812,
1.004927396774292,
-0.5003771781921387,
0.5406874418258667,
0.7950296998023987,
-0.39145269989967346,
-1.2621461153030396,
-0.01891062594950199,
0.25043797492980957,
-0.6759968400001526,
0.4982057511806488,
0.12694856524467468,
-0.5169895887374878,
0.3786621689796448,
-0.38948267698287964,
-0.880923867225647,
1.7717856168746948,
0.2584095895290375,
0.07413621991872787,
-0.49621185660362244,
0.39491602778434753,
0.4300161302089691,
-0.4834277033805847,
0.12375257909297943,
0.46257588267326355,
0.644770085811615,
0.12445168942213058,
-0.8484458327293396,
0.27975067496299744,
-0.16247513890266418,
-0.20246046781539917,
-0.02369377389550209,
-0.5741410255432129,
0.7001022100448608,
0.16613419353961945,
-0.22691890597343445,
0.31771740317344666,
0.3395135700702667,
0.43347403407096863,
0.12754470109939575,
0.8810077905654907,
0.05554252117872238,
0.6567960977554321,
0.2264689952135086,
0.5618517398834229,
-0.5311285257339478,
0.11599621921777725,
0.92657071352005,
-0.30701836943626404,
0.33999553322792053,
0.4428664743900299,
0.15536628663539886,
0.5699948072433472,
0.45809733867645264,
0.2797485589981079,
0.3752365708351135,
0.32999369502067566,
-0.3025677502155304,
-0.7231684327125549,
0.005866763647645712,
-0.06331665813922882,
0.31872308254241943,
0.13369449973106384,
0.18536795675754547,
-0.5349348783493042,
-0.22518114745616913,
-0.3705935776233673,
-0.21137112379074097,
-0.5110369920730591,
0.647759735584259,
0.17897295951843262,
-0.8994858860969543,
0.28194910287857056,
-0.07606593519449234,
0.16517940163612366,
-0.6702542304992676,
-0.06821216642856598,
-0.14393508434295654,
0.022864719852805138,
-0.17162387073040009,
-0.6948832869529724,
-0.09933368116617203,
-0.34227192401885986,
-0.13752859830856323,
-0.13688252866268158,
0.5633142590522766,
-0.45690736174583435,
-0.17765286564826965,
0.30670762062072754,
1.0432125329971313,
-0.24088363349437714,
-0.024465637281537056,
-0.593214750289917,
-0.5332714915275574,
-0.40893012285232544,
-0.12890902161598206,
0.11125178635120392,
0.4378049075603485,
-0.16248896718025208,
0.9373129606246948,
0.3658410608768463,
-0.22278596460819244,
-0.06866530328989029,
-0.12852779030799866,
1.065934658050537,
-0.588259220123291,
-0.5997812747955322,
-0.21800699830055237,
0.45503175258636475,
0.007984466850757599,
-0.3232097029685974,
0.5633062124252319,
0.4864905774593353,
0.4383091628551483,
0.01970861107110977,
0.6504485607147217,
-0.22141531109809875,
0.510674774646759,
-0.5188158750534058,
0.6033053994178772,
-0.6162365078926086,
0.3138815760612488,
-0.20793083310127258,
-0.5391354560852051,
-0.15189406275749207,
0.015213187783956528,
0.060400884598493576,
0.14258664846420288,
0.7510157823562622,
0.9919412732124329,
0.24573232233524323,
0.06398950517177582,
0.3687366843223572,
0.1139407753944397,
0.2545737624168396,
0.9261441230773926,
0.936116099357605,
-0.2772611677646637,
0.8519147038459778,
0.07079379260540009,
0.015647470951080322,
-0.20292603969573975,
-0.3900032937526703,
-1.0337307453155518,
-0.7325361967086792,
0.1096571832895279,
-0.3084579110145569,
0.3142678737640381,
1.0512926578521729,
0.5973569750785828,
-0.5604870915412903,
-0.4361652135848999,
0.017918815836310387,
0.38811439275741577,
-0.40410658717155457,
-0.22379663586616516,
0.11253411322832108,
-0.18837837874889374,
-0.1426127851009369,
0.31664595007896423,
0.0978093072772026,
-0.3796765208244324,
-0.3236828148365021,
-0.04418935626745224,
-0.3737517297267914,
-0.04184053838253021,
0.36667537689208984,
0.1724695861339569,
-0.5868589878082275,
-0.43091627955436707,
0.6055473685264587,
-0.5283998847007751,
-0.12222956866025925,
0.9499043226242065,
-0.9240106344223022,
0.15447552502155304,
0.256518691778183,
0.719137966632843,
0.2774260640144348,
0.1953984797000885,
0.9631632566452026,
-0.6903652548789978,
-0.6245966553688049,
0.36487406492233276,
-0.08087760210037231,
-0.08174058794975281,
-0.4584147334098816,
0.45863452553749084,
0.06921269744634628,
-0.4686281383037567,
-0.5387315154075623,
0.34101811051368713,
-1.2807567119598389,
-0.41495299339294434,
1.1650960445404053,
0.11424221098423004,
-0.1508786529302597,
-0.8971298336982727,
-0.20106178522109985,
0.26768413186073303,
-0.40816718339920044,
0.399644136428833,
0.6570889949798584,
-0.3447006642818451,
-0.054011862725019455,
-0.4703279733657837,
0.5501480102539062,
0.27934545278549194,
-0.7430042028427124,
-0.10219866782426834,
0.6547535061836243,
0.5311634540557861,
-0.03229265660047531,
1.0912829637527466,
-0.008339939638972282,
0.7674769759178162,
-0.29207929968833923,
0.13247115910053253,
-0.37930694222450256,
-0.538286030292511,
-0.10779630392789841,
0.41229191422462463,
0.1651500165462494,
-0.0878555104136467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14318v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14318v1
|
Assessing generalization capability of text ranking models in Polish
| 2024-02-22T06:21:41 | 2024-02-22T06:21:41 |
Sławomir Dadas, Małgorzata Grębowiec
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) is becoming an increasingly popular
technique for integrating internal knowledge bases with large language models.
In a typical RAG pipeline, three models are used, responsible for the
retrieval, reranking, and generation stages. In this article, we focus on the
reranking problem for the Polish language, examining the performance of
rerankers and comparing their results with available retrieval models. We
conduct a comprehensive evaluation of existing models and those trained by us,
utilizing a benchmark of 41 diverse information retrieval tasks for the Polish
language. The results of our experiments show that most models struggle with
out-of-domain generalization. However, a combination of effective optimization
method and a large training dataset allows for building rerankers that are both
compact in size and capable of generalization. The best of our models
establishes a new state-of-the-art for reranking in the Polish language,
outperforming existing models with up to 30 times more parameters.
|
[
-0.22159935534000397,
-0.6293463706970215,
0.7656621932983398,
0.09409340471029282,
-0.33201566338539124,
0.24179331958293915,
-0.43201497197151184,
-0.3200342357158661,
0.1516677737236023,
0.5457421541213989,
-0.15507449209690094,
-0.5466461181640625,
-0.8571138978004456,
0.260628342628479,
-0.5650074481964111,
1.0395417213439941,
-0.0687628835439682,
0.11690623313188553,
-0.252551406621933,
0.06252256035804749,
-0.5848861932754517,
-0.8166936635971069,
-0.2400772124528885,
-0.3723818063735962,
0.36234524846076965,
0.39486491680145264,
0.7013777494430542,
0.314238041639328,
0.8154204487800598,
0.40935394167900085,
-0.134744793176651,
0.2337706834077835,
-0.6716492772102356,
0.4744108021259308,
-0.3008914291858673,
-0.4809446334838867,
-0.3648042380809784,
0.15271387994289398,
0.9571024775505066,
0.8559584617614746,
-0.10299216955900192,
0.353451132774353,
-0.08519938588142395,
0.9259567856788635,
-0.7791523337364197,
-0.1322566419839859,
-0.9009281396865845,
-0.13279715180397034,
-0.43508926033973694,
-0.06191543489694595,
-0.7517838478088379,
-0.3334486782550812,
-0.011336521245539188,
-0.724986732006073,
0.7224262952804565,
0.27668216824531555,
0.7894341945648193,
-0.15146833658218384,
-0.4389054477214813,
-0.3902764618396759,
-0.8348703384399414,
1.0707226991653442,
-0.4374140799045563,
0.4985249638557434,
0.4103783369064331,
0.4394674003124237,
-0.1837945580482483,
-1.0042704343795776,
-0.08471992611885071,
-0.31644609570503235,
0.13699305057525635,
0.08192618191242218,
-0.2131635993719101,
-0.2687097489833832,
0.03152052313089371,
0.6419216990470886,
-0.5060957074165344,
-0.1900860220193863,
-0.40411168336868286,
0.005123763345181942,
0.6402771472930908,
0.1538228541612625,
0.4469422996044159,
0.0579308457672596,
-0.1960233896970749,
-0.09553851187229156,
-0.47358977794647217,
-0.1494874656200409,
0.6152834892272949,
0.5174379348754883,
0.49991822242736816,
0.6353689432144165,
-0.5145652890205383,
0.9270105361938477,
0.21538671851158142,
0.061136942356824875,
0.5399122834205627,
-0.47203680872917175,
-0.09051309525966644,
-0.42356806993484497,
0.512450098991394,
0.3539256155490875,
0.3489706516265869,
-0.6778448820114136,
-0.31133970618247986,
-0.03675631433725357,
0.7486850023269653,
-0.4618505537509918,
-0.08741200715303421,
-0.10454168915748596,
-0.619958221912384,
-0.463334858417511,
0.25535961985588074,
-0.6833106875419617,
-0.03896824270486832,
0.042792558670043945,
0.5191904306411743,
-0.18931807577610016,
-0.2427634447813034,
0.22349339723587036,
-0.41582876443862915,
0.05569450929760933,
0.023416414856910706,
-0.9726585149765015,
0.513309121131897,
0.7663705348968506,
0.5772953033447266,
-0.4175034165382385,
-0.22345097362995148,
-0.3640451431274414,
0.006436575204133987,
-0.8235436677932739,
0.9106882810592651,
-0.7593235373497009,
-0.41216933727264404,
0.025950631126761436,
0.062103964388370514,
-0.2635396420955658,
-0.7862996459007263,
0.9497642517089844,
-0.8953241109848022,
0.2548823356628418,
-0.0466543547809124,
-0.6610327363014221,
-0.05147291347384453,
0.17814260721206665,
-0.549115002155304,
1.1362695693969727,
0.31412050127983093,
-0.7607585191726685,
0.5045661926269531,
-0.18459483981132507,
-0.0386979840695858,
0.0891282930970192,
0.24655425548553467,
-0.4686072766780853,
0.5049942135810852,
-0.07397376745939255,
0.2354632169008255,
-0.40748652815818787,
0.3147971034049988,
-0.17969158291816711,
-0.4474109411239624,
-0.13371369242668152,
-0.002086328575387597,
0.46657323837280273,
0.2078656256198883,
0.036473892629146576,
-0.03761035576462746,
-0.5136615633964539,
0.3727347254753113,
0.07292056083679199,
-0.5063335299491882,
-0.7395936250686646,
-0.07531441003084183,
0.08401642739772797,
0.13216088712215424,
0.3606431782245636,
-0.9342539310455322,
0.3312912583351135,
-0.6689789891242981,
0.09307233989238739,
0.33455103635787964,
0.09200423955917358,
0.6538232564926147,
-0.17503796517848969,
0.5721253752708435,
-0.47360703349113464,
0.17946350574493408,
0.30715179443359375,
-0.7753522396087646,
-0.6867769360542297,
0.1874624639749527,
0.9683366417884827,
0.5032917857170105,
-0.6921529173851013,
0.1776844561100006,
-0.49008283019065857,
-0.7302232980728149,
-0.42731615900993347,
0.17394645512104034,
0.5330719351768494,
0.36075082421302795,
0.28389760851860046,
-0.12412852048873901,
-0.3967372179031372,
-1.1425248384475708,
-0.6416951417922974,
0.0027598566375672817,
-0.18531440198421478,
0.28769853711128235,
0.4563935697078705,
-0.2097783088684082,
0.8330363631248474,
-0.31153956055641174,
-0.2436017245054245,
-0.5296369194984436,
0.1963873952627182,
0.4653503894805908,
0.257221519947052,
0.3892993927001953,
-1.1622217893600464,
-0.7766473293304443,
0.11780747771263123,
-0.6212955713272095,
-0.10664945095777512,
0.5293671488761902,
-0.06565963476896286,
0.2287602424621582,
0.48518288135528564,
-0.07418601959943771,
0.2816034257411957,
0.6420443654060364,
-0.37230947613716125,
0.475699245929718,
-0.48952820897102356,
0.29644331336021423,
-0.8745463490486145,
0.24432294070720673,
-0.30952638387680054,
-0.3491712212562561,
-0.917839765548706,
0.4972442388534546,
0.22299736738204956,
-0.17186903953552246,
-0.23960936069488525,
0.5303459763526917,
-0.5880053639411926,
-0.19569270312786102,
-0.379390150308609,
0.3479710519313812,
-0.12362582236528397,
0.20227201282978058,
-0.24752689898014069,
0.8855993151664734,
0.1990385502576828,
-0.5947878360748291,
0.18107181787490845,
0.24906694889068604,
-0.5189179182052612,
-0.012297289445996284,
-0.6425944566726685,
0.0661633163690567,
-0.10621239244937897,
-0.009287307970225811,
-1.1605018377304077,
-0.1194780021905899,
-0.17333337664604187,
-0.6041815280914307,
0.39550378918647766,
-0.39585062861442566,
-0.4891117811203003,
-0.4264547824859619,
-0.3058512806892395,
0.42814910411834717,
0.549335777759552,
-0.3893054127693176,
0.6843231320381165,
0.6007263660430908,
-0.4577604830265045,
-0.716274619102478,
-0.3392294645309448,
0.08136206120252609,
-0.2052105963230133,
-0.7341790795326233,
0.6231876015663147,
-0.022797919809818268,
-0.4019468128681183,
-0.03612755239009857,
0.01227340754121542,
-0.3010195195674896,
0.008815029636025429,
-0.06170154735445976,
0.2195848822593689,
0.11283078044652939,
0.29244473576545715,
-0.014158965088427067,
-0.23793455958366394,
-0.18594537675380707,
0.12514770030975342,
0.6288760900497437,
-0.1552371233701706,
-0.16175183653831482,
0.2727721631526947,
0.42874014377593994,
0.3322703242301941,
-0.29347696900367737,
0.6969478130340576,
0.3137461543083191,
-0.06261155009269714,
-0.10444869846105576,
-0.7236028909683228,
0.14904668927192688,
-0.42140790820121765,
0.38374730944633484,
-0.36359184980392456,
-0.6935797333717346,
0.6279956698417664,
-0.30161815881729126,
0.005538133438676596,
0.7333554625511169,
0.6034879088401794,
0.06868600845336914,
1.3647435903549194,
0.9204055070877075,
-0.009205943904817104,
0.3295389413833618,
-0.26435109972953796,
0.08271574229001999,
-1.016205072402954,
-0.07866564393043518,
-0.6970726847648621,
-0.1912553757429123,
-0.8925539255142212,
-0.35752159357070923,
0.35910847783088684,
0.21350251138210297,
0.0684075579047203,
0.05818823352456093,
-0.5192548632621765,
0.5910406112670898,
0.4949491024017334,
-0.08654225617647171,
0.42707401514053345,
0.16201654076576233,
-0.30169498920440674,
-0.047976329922676086,
-0.7822608351707458,
-0.5952489972114563,
1.3768291473388672,
0.14642581343650818,
0.4927397072315216,
0.2548815608024597,
0.939376175403595,
0.3628009259700775,
0.4568690061569214,
-0.6417784690856934,
0.372475802898407,
-0.8568376898765564,
-0.8423306345939636,
-0.4495188593864441,
-0.41271108388900757,
-1.2144849300384521,
0.6068397164344788,
-0.38656705617904663,
-0.3931785225868225,
0.3289749324321747,
-0.01598350517451763,
0.03413740172982216,
0.2521442770957947,
-0.5505004525184631,
0.6515219211578369,
0.23730385303497314,
-0.18144960701465607,
-0.13716624677181244,
-0.48166680335998535,
0.3962000906467438,
-0.2631024122238159,
0.47337833046913147,
-0.06271281838417053,
-0.1941845566034317,
0.8479135036468506,
-0.23552680015563965,
0.23863506317138672,
-0.2150905728340149,
0.027668341994285583,
0.019127322360873222,
-0.15509134531021118,
0.4724074900150299,
-0.301786333322525,
-0.33101463317871094,
-0.14868322014808655,
-0.24945490062236786,
-0.33939266204833984,
-0.5195885896682739,
0.6154016256332397,
-0.5011147856712341,
-0.5909236669540405,
-0.177740216255188,
-0.3567395806312561,
-0.41211748123168945,
0.4536908268928528,
0.6618130207061768,
0.5283560156822205,
-0.4131164252758026,
0.43591612577438354,
0.7514616847038269,
-0.19471149146556854,
0.17424365878105164,
0.6253761649131775,
-0.5707696676254272,
-0.40374431014060974,
1.1561405658721924,
0.23404018580913544,
0.2417350709438324,
0.17518292367458344,
0.23166514933109283,
-0.15919527411460876,
-0.7294951677322388,
-0.2943497896194458,
0.3016464412212372,
-0.5708531141281128,
-0.24204158782958984,
-0.5586755275726318,
-0.1626136153936386,
-0.42775407433509827,
-0.001511682872660458,
-0.4950507581233978,
-0.5517892241477966,
0.17359836399555206,
0.13514232635498047,
-0.13485854864120483,
1.1168370246887207,
0.1184411495923996,
0.08829367905855179,
-0.5854362845420837,
0.4990479052066803,
0.2461548000574112,
0.6069267988204956,
-0.1532593071460724,
-0.6995818614959717,
-0.3833736479282379,
-0.3690073788166046,
-0.27304768562316895,
-0.8404616713523865,
0.5167137980461121,
0.08170820027589798,
0.8501108288764954,
-0.24926301836967468,
0.007936622016131878,
0.1540941745042801,
-0.9049778580665588,
0.6891605854034424,
-0.2726755142211914,
-0.6885272860527039,
0.3472675383090973,
-0.5121999979019165,
0.12736131250858307,
0.7738482356071472,
0.14793677628040314,
-0.37910768389701843,
-0.7303035259246826,
-0.7446967959403992,
-1.0386364459991455,
0.40546995401382446,
0.12799172103405,
0.30313384532928467,
-0.20119042694568634,
0.4664576053619385,
0.018949070945382118,
0.05850478261709213,
-0.44328194856643677,
-0.3667144179344177,
0.1147642731666565,
0.04346302151679993,
-0.2488562911748886,
-0.7596188187599182,
0.2105533480644226,
0.011716417036950588,
0.8290193676948547,
0.24170808494091034,
0.09324202686548233,
0.16051559150218964,
-0.15464869141578674,
-0.15731996297836304,
0.4773651659488678,
0.6116265654563904,
0.756161630153656,
-0.331106036901474,
-0.36428102850914,
0.16530632972717285,
-0.6056153178215027,
0.26293617486953735,
-0.11221610754728317,
-0.19831833243370056,
0.38503405451774597,
0.2371867150068283,
0.3570998013019562,
0.5160424113273621,
-0.3216609060764313,
0.6198456883430481,
-0.22753803431987762,
-0.4258292317390442,
-0.2889350652694702,
-0.10863325744867325,
-0.11602213978767395,
-0.015330160968005657,
0.5723236799240112,
-0.16685162484645844,
0.6298053860664368,
-0.3962315618991852,
0.25408267974853516,
0.565139651298523,
-0.04882911965250969,
0.004590626806020737,
0.42178618907928467,
0.155934676527977,
-0.4098086655139923,
0.6300845742225647,
-0.0654265508055687,
-0.6094081997871399,
0.4365512728691101,
0.6241692900657654,
0.67929607629776,
-0.3129606246948242,
0.2132381796836853,
0.40858522057533264,
0.3174059987068176,
-0.34214940667152405,
0.24269823729991913,
0.18591462075710297,
-0.7513041496276855,
-0.46441400051116943,
-0.5637580752372742,
-0.5551445484161377,
-0.21556276082992554,
-0.966101884841919,
-0.007916928268969059,
0.0005922656273469329,
-0.6577539443969727,
-0.10277468711137772,
0.30903321504592896,
-0.4292961657047272,
0.11238115280866623,
-0.2835707664489746,
0.9943329691886902,
-0.8457390069961548,
0.6806232929229736,
0.7977862358093262,
-0.1617075800895691,
-0.43532052636146545,
-0.08066873997449875,
-0.5008558034896851,
-0.5764767527580261,
1.0495545864105225,
-0.1447606086730957,
-0.25762632489204407,
0.006165121216326952,
-0.2819180190563202,
-1.1119298934936523,
0.8218702077865601,
0.12378581613302231,
-0.43454912304878235,
-0.17904457449913025,
-0.21445982158184052,
0.7020114660263062,
-0.4356236159801483,
-0.07059327512979507,
0.368849515914917,
0.37804752588272095,
-0.3534948229789734,
-1.093266248703003,
-0.4575304388999939,
-0.4265493154525757,
0.28984761238098145,
0.5635590553283691,
-0.5072224736213684,
1.0319815874099731,
0.08398871123790741,
-0.30968183279037476,
0.37470197677612305,
0.4646926820278168,
0.2930091619491577,
0.2131979763507843,
0.5284008979797363,
0.5724145174026489,
0.5922361016273499,
0.005786034744232893,
1.4366117715835571,
-0.40725475549697876,
0.49877482652664185,
1.0395703315734863,
-0.01476104836910963,
1.2005459070205688,
0.2612839937210083,
-0.13157248497009277,
0.7372905611991882,
0.22021763026714325,
0.033084187656641006,
0.5187851190567017,
0.1416121870279312,
-0.035080138593912125,
-0.5098265409469604,
0.12329457700252533,
-0.41482120752334595,
0.4187471866607666,
0.1167670264840126,
-0.6717984676361084,
-0.3687382936477661,
-0.0052644615061581135,
-0.28512856364250183,
0.4462452530860901,
-0.42298486828804016,
0.8270416855812073,
-0.3441941440105438,
-0.6525391936302185,
0.5265610218048096,
0.18829014897346497,
0.5865058302879333,
-0.5329160094261169,
-0.07370065897703171,
-0.15699706971645355,
0.26028817892074585,
0.0946749746799469,
-0.6802834868431091,
0.25283941626548767,
0.08922512829303741,
-0.6740730404853821,
-0.27483463287353516,
1.0258488655090332,
-0.39336952567100525,
-0.8087018132209778,
0.3566019833087921,
0.6277977228164673,
0.3317364752292633,
0.02335294894874096,
-0.45055049657821655,
0.054193299263715744,
-0.07051096111536026,
-0.2078026831150055,
0.5653623938560486,
0.21658672392368317,
-0.19521114230155945,
0.7412737607955933,
0.4521743953227997,
0.2492523193359375,
0.14767055213451385,
0.11437804996967316,
0.7411234378814697,
-0.4154440760612488,
-0.28869566321372986,
-0.5652981996536255,
0.24958914518356323,
-0.18067598342895508,
-0.18707767128944397,
1.1572761535644531,
0.6903374195098877,
0.70942223072052,
-0.18892590701580048,
0.5052674412727356,
0.2844879627227783,
1.2523516416549683,
-0.2734472155570984,
0.7988379597663879,
-0.630435585975647,
-0.009867126122117043,
-0.36615556478500366,
-1.0671857595443726,
-0.2705533802509308,
0.5068158507347107,
-0.4748120903968811,
0.22038066387176514,
0.27476808428764343,
0.36386746168136597,
0.02516145631670952,
-0.34386810660362244,
0.5839946269989014,
0.038326557725667953,
0.07427862286567688,
0.17684391140937805,
0.7068928480148315,
-0.5841258764266968,
0.43961358070373535,
-0.25289732217788696,
-0.3440478444099426,
-0.11557603627443314,
-0.6957740783691406,
-0.5459685325622559,
-0.6215472221374512,
0.25324323773384094,
-0.01939983479678631,
0.2762823700904846,
0.33691033720970154,
0.522079586982727,
-0.7047533988952637,
-0.23678794503211975,
0.14507997035980225,
0.10982923954725266,
0.01839597150683403,
-0.21844856441020966,
0.13859742879867554,
-0.8827418684959412,
-0.7804560661315918,
0.5179635882377625,
-0.09053146839141846,
-0.2857489287853241,
0.002550763078033924,
0.20985116064548492,
-0.22002577781677246,
0.00002577971463324502,
0.6274681091308594,
0.09511524438858032,
-0.6091786623001099,
-0.03616262972354889,
0.0222244244068861,
-0.02988271787762642,
-0.18696559965610504,
0.9418768882751465,
-0.7703948020935059,
0.5672513246536255,
0.5616592168807983,
0.37386631965637207,
0.40998128056526184,
0.4252718985080719,
0.7656823992729187,
-0.7857341766357422,
-0.20972098410129547,
0.142215758562088,
0.25315073132514954,
0.2937321364879608,
-0.08614788949489594,
0.7439674139022827,
-0.0525314062833786,
-1.0150816440582275,
-1.060756802558899,
0.01361758355051279,
-0.4083244502544403,
-0.36148717999458313,
0.9722920060157776,
0.06426091492176056,
0.021309928968548775,
-0.2713848352432251,
-0.0005142640438862145,
0.014321877621114254,
-0.10356809943914413,
0.6823439002037048,
0.9647967219352722,
-0.1136157289147377,
0.27974751591682434,
-0.7955535054206848,
0.5209739804267883,
0.36832258105278015,
-0.3856036961078644,
0.3915006220340729,
0.27260738611221313,
0.6139511466026306,
0.6005096435546875,
0.6465969085693359,
-0.29638251662254333,
0.2695479094982147,
-0.06353640556335449,
-0.07056638598442078,
0.08147905766963959,
-0.47955751419067383,
-0.38407355546951294,
0.26141783595085144,
0.3313017189502716,
0.1328345388174057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14310v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14310v1
|
Hint-before-Solving Prompting: Guiding LLMs to Effectively Utilize Encoded Knowledge
| 2024-02-22T05:58:03 | 2024-02-22T05:58:03 |
Jinlan Fu, Shenzhen Huangfu, Hang Yan, See-Kiong Ng, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently showcased remarkable
generalizability in various domains. Despite their extensive knowledge, LLMs
still face challenges in efficiently utilizing encoded knowledge to develop
accurate and logical reasoning processes. To mitigate this problem, we
introduced Hint-before-Solving Prompting (HSP), which guides the model to
generate hints (e.g., specific knowledge or key ideas) for solving the problem
and then generate solutions containing intermediate reasoning steps. Since HSP
is orthogonal to prompting methods (e.g., Chain-of-Thought (CoT)), we applied
HSP to CoT, Least-to-Most, Plan-and-Solve, and Standard promptings. The results
of extensive experiments on 6 reasoning benchmarks and 4 open-source LLMs
demonstrate that HSP can effectively improve the accuracy of reasoning tasks:
(1) By applying high-quality hint-enhanced HSP to CoT prompting,
Llama2-70B-Chat shows an improvement of 9.7. (2) Beyond exploring training-free
LLM capabilities, we built the HSPMATH dataset based on HSP and fine-tuned
Llemma-7B, reaching 64.3 accuracy, surpassing GPT-3.5 and WizardMath-13B. We
make our code and dataset publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/jinlanfu/HSP}.
|
[
-0.2785412073135376,
-0.5893167853355408,
1.0314089059829712,
0.3235238790512085,
-0.2597673535346985,
0.011321566067636013,
-0.3275119960308075,
-0.08348789811134338,
-0.23271675407886505,
0.4249246418476105,
-0.6933075189590454,
-0.5956490635871887,
-0.5151012539863586,
0.08083677291870117,
-0.05438875034451485,
0.5825858116149902,
0.0007711124490015209,
0.20393623411655426,
-0.47021761536598206,
0.27935361862182617,
-0.5391572713851929,
-0.47474417090415955,
-0.5930740237236023,
-0.38809338212013245,
0.6969553828239441,
0.6256537437438965,
0.43882301449775696,
0.4888034462928772,
0.4370594322681427,
0.14299504458904266,
-0.33363813161849976,
0.605032205581665,
-0.309169739484787,
0.21264542639255524,
-0.24602945148944855,
-0.6659641861915588,
-0.4995029866695404,
-0.16691167652606964,
0.40528103709220886,
0.45506519079208374,
-0.2987710237503052,
0.2942131757736206,
0.28269487619400024,
0.6844729781150818,
-0.7990450859069824,
0.2587411105632782,
-0.880454421043396,
-0.06382664293050766,
-0.2703261971473694,
-0.7842791676521301,
-0.5026879906654358,
-0.1301780343055725,
-0.09498128294944763,
-0.7053428292274475,
0.024553922936320305,
0.1160242035984993,
0.7152369022369385,
0.471773624420166,
-0.1707124412059784,
-0.39695513248443604,
-0.46889546513557434,
0.6442602872848511,
-0.7437509298324585,
0.19385729730129242,
0.4137863516807556,
0.2695879638195038,
-0.5184080004692078,
-0.40279167890548706,
-0.3916410803794861,
-0.05362173169851303,
0.15923886001110077,
-0.07560248672962189,
-0.21231435239315033,
0.12734387814998627,
0.7446880340576172,
0.012491423636674881,
-0.35062530636787415,
-0.04365073889493942,
-0.20566678047180176,
-0.20646916329860687,
0.5195560455322266,
0.059153053909540176,
-0.09227293729782104,
-0.09072396904230118,
-0.35403910279273987,
-0.0448712483048439,
-1.1559255123138428,
0.057235851883888245,
0.18120017647743225,
0.2903998792171478,
0.22477005422115326,
0.495015949010849,
-0.35191580653190613,
0.6398916244506836,
0.12568144500255585,
-0.10746748000383377,
0.008858307264745235,
-0.20026825368404388,
0.0002159840805688873,
0.025871381163597107,
0.5617838501930237,
0.1820894479751587,
0.4157602787017822,
0.38494399189949036,
-0.35490161180496216,
-0.0809570848941803,
0.132171168923378,
-0.48569783568382263,
-0.2449481338262558,
0.15643848478794098,
-0.1422683596611023,
-0.1253853440284729,
-0.3831234574317932,
-0.5880470871925354,
-0.5626093745231628,
-0.2577027380466461,
0.5138660669326782,
-0.39392727613449097,
-0.10424129664897919,
0.31017133593559265,
-0.025266647338867188,
0.3019070029258728,
0.5127394795417786,
-0.6491164565086365,
-0.1103963777422905,
0.7277080416679382,
0.5004862546920776,
0.0065554846078157425,
-0.10323815047740936,
-0.6559603810310364,
0.3507366478443146,
-0.36312392354011536,
1.0228458642959595,
-0.4410788416862488,
-0.3293439447879791,
0.10814187675714493,
-0.5195446610450745,
0.048585884273052216,
-0.6641671061515808,
0.5749112963676453,
-0.5083522200584412,
-0.07769259065389633,
-0.8115357756614685,
-0.696467399597168,
0.1404062658548355,
0.460904061794281,
-0.26233962178230286,
1.00520658493042,
-0.21890796720981598,
-0.6967396140098572,
0.16120783984661102,
-0.5982367992401123,
-0.13392096757888794,
0.12046325206756592,
-0.3639317452907562,
-0.0423630028963089,
0.11869999766349792,
0.9438613653182983,
0.4306449592113495,
-0.36510634422302246,
0.14018763601779938,
-0.173484206199646,
-0.22358836233615875,
-0.0027554321568459272,
-0.2695854604244232,
0.705685019493103,
0.1744331568479538,
-0.2383556216955185,
0.21615007519721985,
-0.40991640090942383,
0.2329009473323822,
0.32679495215415955,
-0.0177003163844347,
-0.07307035475969315,
-0.10240880399942398,
-0.7692813873291016,
0.2886475622653961,
0.3331843912601471,
-0.14996258914470673,
0.3167223036289215,
-0.061250507831573486,
0.14363370835781097,
1.0289182662963867,
0.11835026741027832,
0.09712181240320206,
-0.39774614572525024,
0.7550339102745056,
0.13095201551914215,
0.20158705115318298,
-0.24170178174972534,
-0.9006710052490234,
-0.6529009938240051,
0.0759366974234581,
0.07751711457967758,
0.6167672872543335,
-0.9298413991928101,
0.3435450792312622,
-0.021042969077825546,
-0.3269426226615906,
-0.5213025808334351,
0.2677764296531677,
0.5987275242805481,
0.6952639222145081,
0.4778437316417694,
0.11341121792793274,
-0.4647337794303894,
-0.4958241283893585,
-0.3396494388580322,
-0.21772314608097076,
-0.1677989661693573,
0.37953129410743713,
0.30727219581604004,
-0.07004079967737198,
0.9459336400032043,
-0.7208940386772156,
-0.07211101800203323,
-0.34374797344207764,
0.1707732081413269,
0.20905934274196625,
0.40321674942970276,
0.1010051742196083,
-0.43005380034446716,
-0.26489537954330444,
-0.2853220999240875,
-0.6604291796684265,
-0.42264389991760254,
0.13677583634853363,
-0.4132315516471863,
0.053102362900972366,
0.5082873702049255,
-0.8277587890625,
0.29675939679145813,
0.2536349892616272,
-0.2777273654937744,
1.004988670349121,
-0.25266847014427185,
0.1605987697839737,
-0.8958096504211426,
-0.11597879976034164,
-0.26885804533958435,
0.044252414256334305,
-0.2754509747028351,
0.048421915620565414,
0.17061829566955566,
-0.12652209401130676,
-0.3531500995159149,
0.5353131294250488,
-0.5318790078163147,
0.09006192535161972,
-0.17930136620998383,
0.16913312673568726,
0.05078917741775513,
0.5635963082313538,
0.0548105388879776,
0.8963287472724915,
0.4821206033229828,
-0.6648008227348328,
0.30670103430747986,
0.23790203034877777,
-0.19515247642993927,
0.5332397222518921,
-0.5711970925331116,
0.4591943323612213,
-0.1720743328332901,
0.24101707339286804,
-0.5234241485595703,
-0.20503227412700653,
0.21017058193683624,
-0.48858287930488586,
0.16544440388679504,
-0.17361457645893097,
-0.666281521320343,
-0.5751990675926208,
-0.21437685191631317,
0.4277152121067047,
0.7512074112892151,
-0.6365945935249329,
0.29968583583831787,
0.07353571057319641,
-0.16660621762275696,
-0.7673841714859009,
-0.10537473112344742,
-0.10336410254240036,
-0.06851619482040405,
-0.5951729416847229,
0.2794489562511444,
-0.28721195459365845,
-0.01831616833806038,
-0.14673693478107452,
-0.3503744602203369,
0.0500713512301445,
-0.15512794256210327,
-0.06342238187789917,
0.2344447821378708,
-0.21523119509220123,
0.2608737051486969,
0.12670305371284485,
-0.31775933504104614,
0.3975098133087158,
-0.461778849363327,
0.6838497519493103,
-0.17523202300071716,
-0.5818702578544617,
-0.4465702474117279,
0.1406477689743042,
0.027670539915561676,
-0.33454105257987976,
0.3845059871673584,
0.4824187159538269,
-0.36712560057640076,
-0.3032189607620239,
-0.634429395198822,
-0.48286792635917664,
-0.4923015236854553,
-0.007007446140050888,
-0.4597502648830414,
-0.7060754299163818,
0.42154794931411743,
-0.1730719953775406,
-0.11347414553165436,
0.02188291773200035,
0.41973817348480225,
-0.31649625301361084,
1.2544050216674805,
0.4172077476978302,
0.1387915015220642,
0.36482885479927063,
-0.08558864891529083,
0.20057673752307892,
-0.9045740962028503,
-0.24001270532608032,
-0.509282648563385,
0.06642548739910126,
-0.07891175150871277,
-0.7135979533195496,
0.49080541729927063,
0.4981916546821594,
0.03196484595537186,
0.10810237377882004,
-0.369008868932724,
0.7007506489753723,
0.7064484357833862,
0.2766776978969574,
0.3197629451751709,
-0.1586802899837494,
-0.3534705638885498,
0.054812606424093246,
-0.9313309192657471,
-0.43360435962677,
1.1895184516906738,
0.18143245577812195,
0.6681584715843201,
-0.3244115114212036,
0.9047273993492126,
0.05042171850800514,
0.016954943537712097,
-0.665128767490387,
0.7612096071243286,
0.3746301531791687,
-0.3703707158565521,
-0.1937955617904663,
-0.6046134829521179,
-0.7632651925086975,
-0.0491202138364315,
-0.16581042110919952,
-0.5993603467941284,
-0.1773242950439453,
0.776967465877533,
-0.44200703501701355,
0.26945316791534424,
-0.5960981249809265,
0.5687111616134644,
-0.1503543257713318,
-0.26954689621925354,
-0.3082677125930786,
-0.4903411269187927,
0.28711697459220886,
0.28863075375556946,
0.1094493418931961,
-0.31203392148017883,
0.1313316375017166,
0.636400043964386,
-0.19642528891563416,
0.5798710584640503,
-0.3876085877418518,
-0.40320533514022827,
0.4322298765182495,
0.0431864857673645,
0.8188543915748596,
-0.040201928466558456,
0.005844881758093834,
-0.11052659153938293,
-0.15951411426067352,
-0.6054012775421143,
-0.9044387936592102,
0.4159772992134094,
-0.28075283765792847,
-1.0213637351989746,
-0.15634223818778992,
-0.8392292261123657,
-0.5233811140060425,
0.14613601565361023,
0.4260299801826477,
0.5446345806121826,
0.4396858215332031,
-0.13936632871627808,
1.1000558137893677,
-0.13399913907051086,
-0.005665380973368883,
0.16747437417507172,
-0.2393312156200409,
-0.1809045970439911,
0.6686249375343323,
-0.02465219795703888,
0.366444855928421,
0.30627426505088806,
0.471896767616272,
-0.4610842168331146,
-0.7750592827796936,
-0.27513444423675537,
0.2969720959663391,
-1.0022926330566406,
-0.46712130308151245,
-0.3801335096359253,
-0.1809464693069458,
-0.5754807591438293,
-0.17914283275604248,
-0.11601525545120239,
-0.28839483857154846,
-0.12920543551445007,
-0.11223144084215164,
0.30849194526672363,
0.7372791171073914,
-0.07463953644037247,
0.24440084397792816,
-0.9467152953147888,
0.17109298706054688,
0.3642764091491699,
0.12910889089107513,
-0.019661230966448784,
-0.3215065896511078,
-0.1249338686466217,
0.061033979058265686,
-0.21953222155570984,
-0.9666889309883118,
0.10967753082513809,
-0.2078879177570343,
0.6673427224159241,
0.47439199686050415,
0.27974846959114075,
0.7384153604507446,
-0.40408873558044434,
0.749445378780365,
-0.024824654683470726,
-0.9165213108062744,
0.9379466772079468,
-0.5586573481559753,
0.605318009853363,
0.3203165829181671,
0.3719985783100128,
-0.2101609855890274,
-0.43826189637184143,
-0.735617458820343,
-0.5869664549827576,
0.4483228623867035,
0.1540520191192627,
-0.19457928836345673,
0.04545106366276741,
0.4450800120830536,
-0.1022379994392395,
0.3585923910140991,
-0.4469517171382904,
-0.11301474273204803,
0.23173095285892487,
-0.24477070569992065,
0.20233100652694702,
-0.5275520086288452,
-0.22448007762432098,
-0.3325466513633728,
0.8472587466239929,
-0.30857419967651367,
0.41162076592445374,
0.18053211271762848,
-0.24246317148208618,
0.0011749082477763295,
0.39303696155548096,
0.6625481247901917,
0.8222847580909729,
-0.21137501299381256,
0.2582724988460541,
0.2646944224834442,
-0.1604251116514206,
-0.01746896468102932,
-0.11957290768623352,
-0.11450035125017166,
-0.2122276872396469,
0.4228140413761139,
0.6308258175849915,
0.051035452634096146,
-0.8116422891616821,
0.44396695494651794,
0.13100643455982208,
-0.0959022268652916,
0.030602755025029182,
0.34478119015693665,
0.0796029269695282,
0.21620768308639526,
0.38880467414855957,
-0.10695713758468628,
0.03466947376728058,
-0.1234062984585762,
0.09958229213953018,
0.4284789562225342,
-0.2636266052722931,
-0.11839136481285095,
0.34555134177207947,
0.2335362583398819,
-0.22683118283748627,
0.652726411819458,
-0.508914053440094,
-0.748730480670929,
0.4087962806224823,
0.7828195095062256,
0.6537888646125793,
-0.21822740137577057,
0.22222673892974854,
0.43587589263916016,
0.24833674728870392,
-0.08153672516345978,
0.5218148827552795,
-0.5362005233764648,
-0.7896799445152283,
-0.5691100358963013,
-0.41319531202316284,
-0.4132468104362488,
0.002996771829202771,
-0.7409070134162903,
0.2633324861526489,
-0.42223310470581055,
0.029065042734146118,
-0.3584549129009247,
0.05267205461859703,
-0.4884430170059204,
-0.0719926580786705,
0.338932603597641,
1.1903047561645508,
-0.532088577747345,
0.8465912938117981,
0.5412680506706238,
-0.10310427099466324,
-1.083246111869812,
0.16265159845352173,
0.08332836627960205,
-0.962933361530304,
0.35398706793785095,
0.21820256114006042,
-0.3920419216156006,
0.23594006896018982,
-0.8813862800598145,
-0.7395050525665283,
1.0807483196258545,
0.4525595009326935,
-0.6506698131561279,
-0.2622886598110199,
-0.014797109179198742,
0.1756179928779602,
-0.259247362613678,
0.1505568027496338,
0.7246972918510437,
0.5605625510215759,
0.3745967745780945,
-0.745456874370575,
0.19076193869113922,
-0.3357137143611908,
-0.17715074121952057,
0.22315914928913116,
-0.05899733677506447,
0.564524233341217,
-0.6559157371520996,
-0.16569849848747253,
-0.07502137124538422,
0.6363360285758972,
0.870539128780365,
0.3257175087928772,
0.5507762432098389,
0.5470971465110779,
1.1438473463058472,
-0.08194168657064438,
0.8558290600776672,
-0.12135228514671326,
0.03520262986421585,
1.1248140335083008,
-0.24725665152072906,
0.8352702856063843,
0.6437304615974426,
-0.05793686956167221,
0.5019841194152832,
0.5257154703140259,
0.3010278344154358,
0.28438204526901245,
0.24551962316036224,
-0.3021017014980316,
-0.5095481276512146,
-0.20765884220600128,
-0.5131392478942871,
0.06863977015018463,
0.6885415315628052,
0.10491351038217545,
-0.25856754183769226,
-0.09207265824079514,
0.08547389507293701,
0.1049664169549942,
-0.5401864647865295,
0.6532423496246338,
0.19006773829460144,
-0.7263433337211609,
0.6676667332649231,
-0.45063984394073486,
0.6083337664604187,
-0.7016718983650208,
-0.10342063009738922,
0.012368164025247097,
-0.046007148921489716,
-0.19694501161575317,
-0.9122409224510193,
0.025956319645047188,
-0.020025530830025673,
-0.08719611167907715,
-0.3882174491882324,
0.7037587761878967,
-0.5376749634742737,
-0.2070511430501938,
0.15490034222602844,
0.5468568205833435,
0.0024053920060396194,
-0.39314448833465576,
-0.7308686375617981,
-0.0696379616856575,
-0.0058992658741772175,
-0.11241394281387329,
0.05510895699262619,
0.5654977560043335,
-0.15357716381549835,
0.907795250415802,
0.7941932082176208,
0.20019933581352234,
0.18401236832141876,
0.16711214184761047,
0.8577757477760315,
-0.6857824921607971,
-0.489664226770401,
-0.6266748905181885,
0.4422726333141327,
-0.10937678813934326,
-0.24112538993358612,
0.6992771029472351,
0.11435297131538391,
0.7372884154319763,
-0.06947742402553558,
0.49043989181518555,
0.1272648572921753,
0.36241209506988525,
-1.0122849941253662,
0.37904900312423706,
-0.3694685697555542,
0.4701171815395355,
-0.24622660875320435,
-0.7821769118309021,
-0.2823406755924225,
0.38034555315971375,
-0.49326246976852417,
-0.04027378931641579,
0.8010476231575012,
1.0798033475875854,
0.2817825376987457,
0.0043782121501863,
0.1776372343301773,
0.028317062184214592,
0.37288129329681396,
0.7348847985267639,
1.2469639778137207,
0.04521586373448372,
0.5868116021156311,
-0.342539519071579,
-0.34217509627342224,
-0.2657802999019623,
-1.0521422624588013,
-0.873589277267456,
-0.5069594979286194,
-0.1277727335691452,
-0.3746127188205719,
0.20474907755851746,
1.2227181196212769,
0.7077321410179138,
-0.7052177786827087,
-0.1479378640651703,
-0.2857186794281006,
0.4426017105579376,
-0.3601243495941162,
-0.15763475000858307,
0.23090660572052002,
-0.8528414964675903,
-0.3412259519100189,
0.5684910416603088,
0.18187958002090454,
0.06516001373529434,
-0.02905936911702156,
-0.21759183704853058,
-0.09122350066900253,
0.19556471705436707,
0.5002210140228271,
0.07844079285860062,
-0.6193333864212036,
-0.1042650118470192,
0.030079342424869537,
-0.01912853494286537,
0.1374911367893219,
1.11733877658844,
-0.6709367036819458,
0.27561527490615845,
0.6238794922828674,
0.5755391120910645,
0.3084205090999603,
0.05520336702466011,
0.8054026365280151,
-0.8394644856452942,
0.06935057044029236,
0.4797036945819855,
0.34578171372413635,
0.22493919730186462,
-0.5855857133865356,
0.28524845838546753,
0.07314560562372208,
-0.5255638957023621,
-0.8389756083488464,
0.5269815921783447,
-0.7478395104408264,
-0.19475328922271729,
1.1320102214813232,
-0.18308770656585693,
-0.2858596444129944,
0.05429409071803093,
-0.38212016224861145,
0.07830667495727539,
-0.5202246308326721,
0.753653347492218,
0.6159517765045166,
-0.3190629482269287,
-0.3385869860649109,
-0.23313051462173462,
0.9158448576927185,
0.6559765338897705,
-0.9824110865592957,
0.1038118526339531,
0.29844406247138977,
-0.10464941710233688,
0.10726264864206314,
0.7813531160354614,
-0.053980182856321335,
0.43615812063217163,
-0.066288061439991,
-0.0776229277253151,
-0.2711435854434967,
-0.7182255983352661,
-0.31038427352905273,
-0.029879437759518623,
0.3061237633228302,
-0.04929670691490173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15444v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15444v1
|
Unleashing the Power of Imbalanced Modality Information for Multi-modal Knowledge Graph Completion
| 2024-02-22T05:48:03 | 2024-02-22T05:48:03 |
Yichi Zhang, Zhuo Chen, Lei Liang, Huajun Chen, Wen Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
Multi-modal knowledge graph completion (MMKGC) aims to predict the missing
triples in the multi-modal knowledge graphs by incorporating structural,
visual, and textual information of entities into the discriminant models. The
information from different modalities will work together to measure the triple
plausibility. Existing MMKGC methods overlook the imbalance problem of modality
information among entities, resulting in inadequate modal fusion and
inefficient utilization of the raw modality information. To address the
mentioned problems, we propose Adaptive Multi-modal Fusion and Modality
Adversarial Training (AdaMF-MAT) to unleash the power of imbalanced modality
information for MMKGC. AdaMF-MAT achieves multi-modal fusion with adaptive
modality weights and further generates adversarial samples by
modality-adversarial training to enhance the imbalanced modality information.
Our approach is a co-design of the MMKGC model and training strategy which can
outperform 19 recent MMKGC methods and achieve new state-of-the-art results on
three public MMKGC benchmarks. Our code and data have been released at
https://github.com/zjukg/AdaMF-MAT.
|
[
-0.49670156836509705,
-0.6778941750526428,
0.35207226872444153,
-0.24768921732902527,
-0.3458150327205658,
0.7059004306793213,
-0.11402005702257156,
-0.31146323680877686,
0.018097255378961563,
0.055162303149700165,
-0.608615517616272,
-0.2965381443500519,
-0.4872901141643524,
-0.039573345333337784,
0.21773800253868103,
0.7263691425323486,
-0.0828138217329979,
0.34834152460098267,
-0.4193841218948364,
-0.3790145516395569,
-0.5913703441619873,
-0.12083860486745834,
-0.2709542512893677,
-0.5577744245529175,
0.4062151312828064,
0.38708341121673584,
0.6831600069999695,
0.4752756357192993,
0.22357337176799774,
0.22533109784126282,
0.1984821856021881,
0.6405247449874878,
-0.3982158303260803,
-0.023912208154797554,
0.23331226408481598,
-0.2353236973285675,
-0.6395149230957031,
0.2352447807788849,
0.7801684141159058,
0.8093284368515015,
-0.13641579449176788,
0.02563142590224743,
0.13692502677440643,
0.5989304780960083,
-0.8346824645996094,
0.34828171133995056,
-0.663711428642273,
0.1575949490070343,
0.04748505726456642,
-0.3421091139316559,
-0.39895594120025635,
0.0540633387863636,
-0.10229942202568054,
-0.9281325936317444,
0.1264926791191101,
0.2925609350204468,
0.4236104190349579,
0.3509329557418823,
-0.9524632692337036,
-0.10148878395557404,
-0.8175719380378723,
0.5822064876556396,
-0.4176896810531616,
0.6735441088676453,
0.4622614085674286,
0.37986186146736145,
-0.09676267206668854,
-0.2943238914012909,
-0.5569689273834229,
-0.3567504286766052,
-0.1575448364019394,
0.5085906982421875,
0.08013959228992462,
0.19717667996883392,
0.24272751808166504,
0.36637449264526367,
-0.4225788116455078,
-0.2575085759162903,
-0.4823070168495178,
-0.31510597467422485,
0.36548179388046265,
0.12908385694026947,
0.059086576104164124,
-0.3582906723022461,
-0.6610286831855774,
0.007832672446966171,
-0.47185128927230835,
-0.014903975650668144,
0.5604513883590698,
0.14606726169586182,
0.028853992000222206,
0.550639271736145,
-0.24229635298252106,
0.9513370990753174,
0.18290935456752777,
-0.5832584500312805,
0.6079726815223694,
-0.8574920296669006,
-0.26100146770477295,
0.2124144732952118,
0.7104603052139282,
0.2998219132423401,
-0.5158422589302063,
-0.2875470817089081,
0.24329185485839844,
-0.18486817181110382,
0.4232722818851471,
-0.5472014546394348,
-0.12880130112171173,
-0.03547672554850578,
-0.41060537099838257,
-0.34957605600357056,
-0.020747849717736244,
-0.6581228971481323,
-0.43989792466163635,
-0.4040708839893341,
0.6377593874931335,
-0.6958266496658325,
-0.622726559638977,
-0.07920406758785248,
-0.28124189376831055,
-0.11346295475959778,
0.47153255343437195,
-0.5645973086357117,
-0.2700124979019165,
0.41082316637039185,
0.7439873218536377,
0.1745586097240448,
-0.47334209084510803,
-0.15373417735099792,
0.5441251993179321,
-0.08679558336734772,
0.3161453604698181,
-0.5435925722122192,
-0.29945066571235657,
-0.4247394800186157,
0.1052301749587059,
-0.5376752614974976,
-0.24162891507148743,
0.660826563835144,
-0.4455227255821228,
0.32259535789489746,
-0.6767674684524536,
-0.4059181213378906,
-0.5943194627761841,
0.5120357871055603,
-0.7706937193870544,
0.7476842403411865,
0.3658800423145294,
-0.8837443590164185,
0.7721912264823914,
-0.6361636519432068,
-0.386651873588562,
-0.03904246538877487,
-0.11220070719718933,
-0.48812881112098694,
-0.1322067528963089,
0.18687258660793304,
0.4901617467403412,
-0.33365029096603394,
0.06983887404203415,
-0.6058130264282227,
-0.21511194109916687,
0.09107418358325958,
-0.4162822663784027,
0.6382094621658325,
0.32015281915664673,
-0.27887070178985596,
0.036038994789123535,
-1.0490031242370605,
-0.16126559674739838,
0.1306290328502655,
-0.671204686164856,
-0.2644144296646118,
0.14999407529830933,
-0.3425431251525879,
0.36285778880119324,
0.05612202361226082,
-0.604692816734314,
0.09855484962463379,
-0.2432306557893753,
0.33188173174858093,
0.8206245303153992,
-0.17023763060569763,
0.4641074538230896,
-0.5161469578742981,
0.48572036623954773,
0.1681380271911621,
0.1619216799736023,
0.045604508370161057,
-0.43176791071891785,
-0.4237242043018341,
-0.4124392867088318,
0.2546074390411377,
0.3188460171222687,
-1.2038301229476929,
0.31030356884002686,
-0.3159506618976593,
-0.47400176525115967,
-0.5248658061027527,
0.1980200558900833,
0.3540966808795929,
0.8215004801750183,
0.2949465215206146,
-0.17493189871311188,
-0.5489929914474487,
-0.6549440026283264,
0.026648951694369316,
-0.2254568189382553,
0.1737251728773117,
0.628668487071991,
0.23629975318908691,
-0.02170649915933609,
0.6048285961151123,
-0.1644420176744461,
-0.4557078778743744,
-0.05229673907160759,
0.32513919472694397,
-0.19044607877731323,
0.3967728614807129,
0.6645505428314209,
-0.9008053541183472,
-0.21997880935668945,
0.12386487424373627,
-0.7480404376983643,
0.2578449249267578,
0.12577557563781738,
-0.04219730198383331,
0.09561478346586227,
0.3701702356338501,
-0.2983858287334442,
0.07111027091741562,
0.5997218489646912,
-0.5088179707527161,
0.41985049843788147,
0.0012245418038219213,
0.7364301085472107,
-1.3275102376937866,
0.08556275069713593,
-0.5535373687744141,
-0.33513081073760986,
-0.35233598947525024,
0.06436661630868912,
0.14955227077007294,
-0.1154138520359993,
-0.21622739732265472,
0.09011449664831161,
-0.47420984506607056,
0.17725998163223267,
-0.2904476523399353,
-0.020417800173163414,
0.12504394352436066,
0.6640818119049072,
-0.728596031665802,
0.6682315468788147,
0.3258880376815796,
-0.5036724805831909,
0.6573320627212524,
0.020456604659557343,
0.0022636752109974623,
0.8255765438079834,
-0.0017367568798363209,
-0.11228709667921066,
-0.20100094377994537,
0.3186038136482239,
-1.0857815742492676,
-0.4164159893989563,
0.5918974876403809,
-0.4306810200214386,
0.5378913283348083,
-0.4311771094799042,
-0.3098534345626831,
-0.5403785109519958,
-0.34829583764076233,
0.6966315507888794,
0.07548453658819199,
-0.53428053855896,
1.2930437326431274,
0.23999100923538208,
0.46641620993614197,
-0.8028830289840698,
-0.48155477643013,
-0.1001940369606018,
0.002627095440402627,
-0.744553804397583,
0.36754173040390015,
-0.3002074956893921,
0.3399035334587097,
0.24805432558059692,
-0.07889121025800705,
0.336283415555954,
0.3202400803565979,
0.4718247950077057,
0.16041173040866852,
-0.1697433739900589,
0.16483809053897858,
-0.1342606395483017,
-0.061456918716430664,
-0.04194493591785431,
-0.3747357726097107,
0.6710044145584106,
-0.10561034828424454,
-0.8628627061843872,
0.028176864609122276,
0.2455512136220932,
0.8564428687095642,
-0.16266624629497528,
0.8436046838760376,
1.1085749864578247,
-0.4457817077636719,
0.2531072795391083,
-0.5512852668762207,
0.12043942511081696,
-0.4189701974391937,
0.34589651226997375,
-0.18681782484054565,
-0.8570914268493652,
0.4533206522464752,
-0.13196533918380737,
-0.03606511279940605,
0.44691911339759827,
0.5893886089324951,
0.22201436758041382,
1.5341838598251343,
0.403888463973999,
0.1310608983039856,
0.43640267848968506,
-0.28683239221572876,
0.2191935032606125,
-1.0050057172775269,
-0.5016629695892334,
0.020713679492473602,
-0.48875173926353455,
-0.19432500004768372,
-0.2891908288002014,
0.7755345106124878,
0.27924686670303345,
-0.06352894008159637,
0.06509576737880707,
-0.46949705481529236,
0.3625861406326294,
0.7506484389305115,
0.5078762173652649,
0.43054836988449097,
-0.04787387326359749,
-0.3864108920097351,
0.1337132304906845,
-0.681441068649292,
0.17548328638076782,
1.4297093152999878,
0.01568421721458435,
0.6272589564323425,
0.251883864402771,
0.1666039228439331,
0.21615052223205566,
0.02836310863494873,
-0.8117665648460388,
0.25537240505218506,
0.12172327935695648,
-0.578000545501709,
0.06269276142120361,
-0.6730860471725464,
-0.621120035648346,
0.2718157172203064,
-0.5194430947303772,
-0.10586419701576233,
0.22113487124443054,
0.2800852656364441,
-0.4112798571586609,
0.6073544025421143,
-0.7481493949890137,
0.6701112985610962,
-0.023685075342655182,
-0.09590884298086166,
-0.4794546365737915,
-0.4829747974872589,
0.7463133931159973,
-0.19833379983901978,
0.34524592757225037,
-0.2221652865409851,
0.1494043618440628,
0.7825762629508972,
-0.289665549993515,
0.5988460183143616,
-0.39952170848846436,
0.21841496229171753,
0.10794617235660553,
-0.09676477313041687,
0.26224464178085327,
0.10934930294752121,
0.17507360875606537,
-0.08618566393852234,
-0.12383607774972916,
-0.4385877847671509,
-0.4464528262615204,
0.5973806977272034,
-0.9839327335357666,
-0.2541349232196808,
-0.2877650558948517,
-0.8036057353019714,
-0.3774823546409607,
0.2652103304862976,
0.14406025409698486,
0.4227220416069031,
-0.19841191172599792,
0.3576177656650543,
0.4363285303115845,
0.20716352760791779,
0.5791720747947693,
0.5485556721687317,
0.0733598992228508,
-0.944609522819519,
0.9899466037750244,
0.3307187259197235,
0.5577319860458374,
0.05319049954414368,
0.17847289144992828,
0.12682071328163147,
-0.4576604664325714,
-0.8371151089668274,
-0.09588080644607544,
-0.6900521516799927,
-0.6559828519821167,
-0.8648399710655212,
-0.2471800148487091,
-0.4439176321029663,
-0.17713141441345215,
-0.1886017918586731,
-0.3926214873790741,
-0.2851969301700592,
-0.020299497991800308,
0.32292816042900085,
0.48722779750823975,
-0.32437026500701904,
0.39204272627830505,
-0.5392003655433655,
0.3473086953163147,
0.6455068588256836,
0.3478277027606964,
0.20054972171783447,
-0.11716294288635254,
-0.3342275321483612,
0.4198039174079895,
-0.5586757063865662,
-0.8065468072891235,
-0.1719970554113388,
0.2623696029186249,
0.5658625364303589,
0.4345022737979889,
-0.10535076260566711,
0.5327906012535095,
-0.1655859500169754,
0.6148908734321594,
0.5563886761665344,
-0.5722096562385559,
0.2522355616092682,
-0.5382099151611328,
0.22376839816570282,
0.5676385164260864,
0.30320173501968384,
-0.3496542274951935,
-0.2668890953063965,
-0.6638525128364563,
-0.7126774191856384,
0.9742303490638733,
-0.06732388585805893,
-0.311465859413147,
0.3639606237411499,
0.11810203641653061,
0.022204378619790077,
0.4118938148021698,
-0.7388123869895935,
-0.2840445339679718,
-0.5982582569122314,
-0.37987127900123596,
0.13474774360656738,
-0.18079149723052979,
-0.6750360727310181,
-0.4257335960865021,
0.9492200016975403,
-0.5327159762382507,
0.31993427872657776,
0.05034555494785309,
-0.20541666448116302,
-0.5412682890892029,
0.130001500248909,
0.6198790073394775,
0.7874616384506226,
-0.374622642993927,
0.31186023354530334,
0.27107757329940796,
-0.6259379386901855,
0.3097182512283325,
0.49802976846694946,
-0.13239072263240814,
-0.4036087691783905,
0.24772998690605164,
0.7802983522415161,
0.11951147019863129,
-0.30988556146621704,
0.720130980014801,
-0.061774056404829025,
-0.42087322473526,
-0.1623615175485611,
0.16319622099399567,
0.05848263204097748,
0.3348942697048187,
0.48159611225128174,
0.6987343430519104,
-0.03640703111886978,
-0.3411523103713989,
0.11767247319221497,
0.6969495415687561,
-0.4884801506996155,
-0.2078838050365448,
0.8121240139007568,
-0.021783016622066498,
0.2265438288450241,
0.24645161628723145,
-0.42916786670684814,
-0.6632544994354248,
0.29119637608528137,
0.4050024747848511,
0.5820176601409912,
-0.25284621119499207,
0.16866566240787506,
0.3228603005409241,
0.4122920334339142,
0.1776581108570099,
0.12533800303936005,
-0.12247823178768158,
-0.6734950542449951,
-0.44825315475463867,
-0.595443069934845,
-0.06641541421413422,
0.03756709769368172,
-0.24649766087532043,
0.22909122705459595,
-0.6927073001861572,
-0.08928341418504715,
-0.03861740231513977,
0.13606421649456024,
-0.6278056502342224,
-0.06701918691396713,
0.10030101239681244,
0.3071219325065613,
-0.8746234774589539,
0.4703713655471802,
0.48752880096435547,
-0.5874087810516357,
-0.8765666484832764,
-0.43977153301239014,
0.3080897629261017,
-1.0761327743530273,
0.16987735033035278,
-0.052205368876457214,
-0.16436102986335754,
0.0001207648019772023,
-0.3271336555480957,
-1.068284034729004,
1.620392918586731,
0.4490630328655243,
-0.02439654804766178,
0.014230464585125446,
0.23505012691020966,
-0.1359216421842575,
-0.33782801032066345,
0.14001457393169403,
0.27722468972206116,
0.6203947067260742,
0.505513608455658,
-0.8398358821868896,
0.1568664312362671,
-0.21034659445285797,
-0.42904695868492126,
0.32938459515571594,
-0.7052114009857178,
0.8733017444610596,
-0.0045847296714782715,
-0.029075970873236656,
-0.3794741928577423,
0.48055601119995117,
0.035793744027614594,
0.26701244711875916,
0.8268062472343445,
0.9059844613075256,
0.713986873626709,
-0.18715937435626984,
0.589080274105072,
-0.44702255725860596,
0.2864435911178589,
0.8553496599197388,
0.07365195453166962,
0.07367508113384247,
0.11722995340824127,
-0.044304654002189636,
0.2197844386100769,
0.5585901737213135,
-0.14885585010051727,
0.49073702096939087,
-0.4105392098426819,
-0.4559853971004486,
-0.3285892903804779,
-0.3341061472892761,
-0.6664923429489136,
0.5571308732032776,
0.241902694106102,
-0.40586981177330017,
-0.44887739419937134,
0.5287909507751465,
0.11509527266025543,
-0.5537685751914978,
-0.38474664092063904,
0.8229429721832275,
-0.40039604902267456,
-0.4554939270019531,
0.7030266523361206,
0.037627458572387695,
0.5412616729736328,
-0.5877131223678589,
0.02738303691148758,
0.2585490942001343,
0.06828146427869797,
-0.2548891305923462,
-0.2293323427438736,
0.02672557905316353,
-0.8741719126701355,
-0.4652324318885803,
-0.06712713837623596,
0.8552734851837158,
-0.6221171021461487,
-0.6550142765045166,
0.3131024241447449,
0.672211766242981,
-0.6192216873168945,
-0.06816019862890244,
-0.6720371842384338,
-0.31634774804115295,
0.01843872293829918,
0.16682033240795135,
0.26046305894851685,
0.29141685366630554,
0.2816302478313446,
0.362312912940979,
0.7545518279075623,
-0.13757242262363434,
0.27071693539619446,
0.005391841754317284,
1.0502474308013916,
-0.2853282392024994,
-0.2547571361064911,
-0.7933332324028015,
0.20779353380203247,
0.01667422242462635,
-0.07819821685552597,
0.6526641845703125,
0.6019412279129028,
0.8558616638183594,
0.2841343283653259,
0.710860013961792,
-0.3487192988395691,
0.4466385245323181,
-0.59590744972229,
0.7949212193489075,
-0.9314374923706055,
0.07102669030427933,
-0.29998111724853516,
-0.6429378986358643,
-0.03481382504105568,
0.10775001347064972,
0.13937623798847198,
0.180284783244133,
0.6024459600448608,
0.7343782782554626,
-0.5212260484695435,
0.28460296988487244,
0.17695662379264832,
0.147013321518898,
0.3350040018558502,
0.6471136212348938,
0.9582120180130005,
-0.47158369421958923,
0.7620267868041992,
-0.454994797706604,
-0.36326587200164795,
-0.2639162540435791,
-0.783512532711029,
-0.7673567533493042,
-0.8456418514251709,
-0.17231813073158264,
-0.6201672554016113,
-0.3682354688644409,
1.058529257774353,
0.8580595254898071,
-0.449167937040329,
0.28055083751678467,
0.06903722882270813,
0.3387083411216736,
-0.32654210925102234,
-0.22294166684150696,
0.3724830448627472,
-0.16153883934020996,
-0.3256741762161255,
0.5050871968269348,
0.2776987850666046,
0.15744419395923615,
-0.4114852845668793,
-0.06615506857633591,
-0.4175953269004822,
-0.2727995812892914,
0.48851844668388367,
-0.027360981330275536,
-0.6094126105308533,
-0.43015268445014954,
-0.10073570162057877,
0.11547541618347168,
0.22439663112163544,
1.0906099081039429,
-0.8385018110275269,
0.6825659275054932,
0.4158969223499298,
0.6472894549369812,
-0.027231909334659576,
-0.14078174531459808,
0.571709394454956,
-0.884118914604187,
0.006059545557945967,
0.1652185320854187,
0.619633674621582,
0.2325597107410431,
-0.44880327582359314,
0.4138330817222595,
0.7318054437637329,
-0.34101951122283936,
-0.6487826108932495,
0.2667847275733948,
-1.0844969749450684,
-0.4061724543571472,
0.9297985434532166,
0.21492275595664978,
-0.2465834617614746,
-0.2916903495788574,
-0.23554083704948425,
0.5145426392555237,
-0.18142910301685333,
0.6980765461921692,
0.7623625993728638,
0.038428813219070435,
0.004103536251932383,
-0.4427679777145386,
0.6052505970001221,
0.28005287051200867,
-0.4195840656757355,
0.12060283124446869,
0.7017905712127686,
0.14055068790912628,
0.4305446147918701,
0.6081663966178894,
-0.012079190462827682,
0.3529053330421448,
-0.03986598551273346,
-0.18068815767765045,
-0.7540969252586365,
-0.3687737286090851,
-0.05169946700334549,
0.5513819456100464,
-0.04413239657878876,
-0.060703668743371964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14298v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14298v3
|
Multi-modal Stance Detection: New Datasets and Model
| 2024-02-22T05:24:19 | 2024-06-06T15:17:58 |
Bin Liang, Ang Li, Jingqian Zhao, Lin Gui, Min Yang, Yue Yu, Kam-Fai Wong, Ruifeng Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Stance detection is a challenging task that aims to identify public opinion
from social media platforms with respect to specific targets. Previous work on
stance detection largely focused on pure texts. In this paper, we study
multi-modal stance detection for tweets consisting of texts and images, which
are prevalent in today's fast-growing social media platforms where people often
post multi-modal messages. To this end, we create five new multi-modal stance
detection datasets of different domains based on Twitter, in which each example
consists of a text and an image. In addition, we propose a simple yet effective
Targeted Multi-modal Prompt Tuning framework (TMPT), where target information
is leveraged to learn multi-modal stance features from textual and visual
modalities. Experimental results on our five benchmark datasets show that the
proposed TMPT achieves state-of-the-art performance in multi-modal stance
detection.
|
[
-0.3947051465511322,
-0.6598585844039917,
0.6486000418663025,
0.4507341682910919,
-0.5912072658538818,
0.12820196151733398,
-0.12520432472229004,
-0.13717636466026306,
0.4876314699649811,
-0.1688218116760254,
-0.9886792898178101,
-0.7781375050544739,
-0.7650267481803894,
0.09131778031587601,
0.07773217558860779,
0.8094638586044312,
0.13032229244709015,
0.20227977633476257,
0.4106610119342804,
-0.5994136333465576,
-0.6401805877685547,
0.06702660769224167,
-0.6242784857749939,
0.26769712567329407,
0.7370256185531616,
0.4646148085594177,
0.6764282584190369,
0.1512816846370697,
0.05964398384094238,
0.13712333142757416,
0.18248987197875977,
0.3137628138065338,
-0.13246141374111176,
0.34772220253944397,
0.02381299063563347,
-0.04744057357311249,
-0.3288416564464569,
0.046441249549388885,
0.7763690948486328,
0.012285705655813217,
0.2434360682964325,
-0.03633034601807594,
-0.2995172142982483,
0.33351942896842957,
-0.5791550874710083,
0.00997959915548563,
-0.4099038243293762,
-0.11906277388334274,
-0.4715372622013092,
-0.24645574390888214,
-0.4117831885814667,
-0.2071790099143982,
-0.48284944891929626,
-0.44008153676986694,
0.09246651083230972,
0.11134136468172073,
0.8797180652618408,
-0.004975738003849983,
-0.9264917373657227,
-0.05281483381986618,
-0.1325109899044037,
0.9027526378631592,
-0.4961220324039459,
0.6435815095901489,
0.19592751562595367,
0.3181799650192261,
0.12703512609004974,
-0.02311071567237377,
-0.6501452326774597,
-0.04876239597797394,
0.04018673673272133,
0.06698571890592575,
-0.12960320711135864,
-0.09262605756521225,
0.17442509531974792,
0.006472722627222538,
-0.4232909083366394,
-0.11714247614145279,
0.16539189219474792,
-0.2476024478673935,
0.1299983263015747,
-0.09489982575178146,
0.40728503465652466,
-0.7904298305511475,
-0.7024729251861572,
-0.21497313678264618,
-0.2835872173309326,
0.36127978563308716,
0.2532848119735718,
0.4693502187728882,
-0.4135168492794037,
0.6519709825515747,
0.006768877152353525,
0.6138128042221069,
0.43604499101638794,
-0.34783920645713806,
0.32919734716415405,
-0.41150811314582825,
-0.13311384618282318,
-0.4006936252117157,
0.9958178997039795,
0.7500437498092651,
-0.11753042042255402,
0.14798647165298462,
-0.5302048921585083,
-0.05934035778045654,
0.05032593011856079,
-0.5975350141525269,
0.06151275336742401,
0.12701764702796936,
-0.7585346698760986,
-0.514378011226654,
0.17984065413475037,
-0.9049931168556213,
-1.083505392074585,
-0.5622850656509399,
0.3827446401119232,
-0.7056900262832642,
-0.7225359678268433,
0.08275393396615982,
-0.4350960850715637,
0.6657431721687317,
0.584200918674469,
-0.6916576623916626,
-0.3762599229812622,
0.7841564416885376,
1.0431843996047974,
-0.11363396048545837,
-0.07984213531017303,
-0.48794427514076233,
0.053692784160375595,
-0.3053831458091736,
1.0141923427581787,
-0.8076016306877136,
-0.3680875599384308,
0.06296084821224213,
0.0823860913515091,
-0.26134124398231506,
0.027926871553063393,
0.7716378569602966,
-0.3743271231651306,
0.13646866381168365,
-0.8393812775611877,
-0.3110434412956238,
0.019913138821721077,
0.7524283528327942,
-0.974265992641449,
0.7921980619430542,
-0.12839552760124207,
-0.8717585802078247,
1.0181846618652344,
-0.8617119193077087,
-0.6557270288467407,
-0.23661525547504425,
-0.38208654522895813,
-0.4550192654132843,
0.24718759953975677,
0.47900670766830444,
0.6820141673088074,
-0.21248362958431244,
0.06388560682535172,
-0.5603587031364441,
0.017572131007909775,
0.21150316298007965,
-0.42704135179519653,
0.9933665990829468,
0.007175432983785868,
-0.2756612300872803,
0.4981287717819214,
-0.3485110104084015,
-0.16416096687316895,
-0.06032367795705795,
-0.2983284592628479,
-0.23703347146511078,
0.10257955640554428,
0.3522975742816925,
0.4567555785179138,
0.05630863457918167,
-0.5066643953323364,
0.36847636103630066,
0.16583791375160217,
0.38456836342811584,
0.728971540927887,
0.3639516830444336,
0.2952440083026886,
-0.35304883122444153,
0.4831381142139435,
0.14956580102443695,
0.40694716572761536,
-0.2844625413417816,
-0.3991028070449829,
-0.3786415457725525,
-0.5581541657447815,
-0.12913556396961212,
0.13897332549095154,
-0.8530362844467163,
0.3347722589969635,
-0.14030662178993225,
-0.148701012134552,
-0.3847520649433136,
-0.09551271051168442,
0.13032950460910797,
0.21401244401931763,
0.2788291275501251,
0.2512044608592987,
-0.2904965579509735,
-0.8464127779006958,
-0.6609885692596436,
-0.3209906816482544,
0.30027779936790466,
0.1317911595106125,
0.30294162034988403,
0.09496812522411346,
0.7776587009429932,
0.06340763717889786,
-0.18473117053508759,
-0.146206796169281,
0.358257919549942,
-0.168038472533226,
0.14262770116329193,
1.0329813957214355,
-1.1808860301971436,
-0.48350903391838074,
-0.2741994559764862,
-0.5521948933601379,
0.0774497538805008,
-0.30849307775497437,
-0.19571176171302795,
0.17896810173988342,
0.5831089615821838,
-0.7188981175422668,
-0.026696862652897835,
0.3923397362232208,
-0.6264548897743225,
0.39382204413414,
0.5492507815361023,
0.8910766839981079,
-1.6032922267913818,
-0.17300938069820404,
0.6406140923500061,
-0.45225369930267334,
-0.5871178507804871,
-0.19931036233901978,
0.3782047629356384,
-0.04124695435166359,
-0.6155129671096802,
0.5024110078811646,
-0.29740625619888306,
0.28400495648384094,
-0.14114530384540558,
-0.13984230160713196,
0.04950951784849167,
0.28824543952941895,
-0.042919762432575226,
0.6147261261940002,
0.7966088056564331,
-0.310430109500885,
0.2403174787759781,
0.1605532169342041,
-0.024073798209428787,
1.1619160175323486,
-0.43464362621307373,
0.09736686199903488,
-0.36586835980415344,
0.32513031363487244,
-1.4819687604904175,
-0.4690883755683899,
0.6087704300880432,
-0.6570641994476318,
0.3648749589920044,
-0.4217163324356079,
-0.5928481817245483,
-0.19675710797309875,
-0.8412431478500366,
0.2561262845993042,
-0.07629824429750443,
-0.5335296392440796,
0.7680945992469788,
0.2594260573387146,
0.2858237624168396,
-0.7653030753135681,
-0.20855511724948883,
0.1501619517803192,
-0.48969176411628723,
-0.497829794883728,
0.20852907001972198,
0.076339952647686,
-0.06544193625450134,
-0.19725146889686584,
-0.16796571016311646,
0.10543183237314224,
-0.2070489078760147,
0.19909241795539856,
-0.011291124857962132,
-0.09442290663719177,
0.3696708679199219,
0.15725643932819366,
0.07093067467212677,
-0.11872172355651855,
-0.24987107515335083,
0.5636582970619202,
-0.24365541338920593,
-0.517683207988739,
-0.8903355002403259,
0.45677006244659424,
1.2833396196365356,
-0.16772525012493134,
0.5788238048553467,
1.062796711921692,
-0.4546043574810028,
-0.12827298045158386,
-0.3857493996620178,
-0.20177587866783142,
-0.46965253353118896,
0.02259792760014534,
-0.2511725425720215,
-0.4686610996723175,
0.1449640840291977,
-0.07014495879411697,
0.2329995036125183,
0.19637854397296906,
0.6904261708259583,
-0.19588781893253326,
1.2081917524337769,
0.5283524394035339,
-0.34728336334228516,
0.8202801942825317,
0.07705327123403549,
0.27153852581977844,
-0.24402044713497162,
-0.18037673830986023,
-0.4430171549320221,
-0.6083092093467712,
-0.34296801686286926,
-0.5330629944801331,
0.368843674659729,
-0.12666796147823334,
-0.20608940720558167,
0.3925170302391052,
-0.22812379896640778,
0.3552233576774597,
0.29029181599617004,
0.5564741492271423,
0.11698982119560242,
-0.08945373445749283,
0.14683285355567932,
-0.24500249326229095,
-0.16687358915805817,
-0.5438598990440369,
0.6878306269645691,
0.20404507219791412,
0.4092499315738678,
0.31870806217193604,
0.45838576555252075,
0.6502999663352966,
0.18999801576137543,
-1.2760658264160156,
0.5643681287765503,
0.016299383714795113,
-0.5074385404586792,
-0.15882739424705505,
-0.0797278881072998,
-0.720954954624176,
0.14241601526737213,
-0.5296822786331177,
-0.2544109523296356,
0.27379530668258667,
0.1689276546239853,
-0.17779913544654846,
0.49937427043914795,
-0.6616495847702026,
1.0628288984298706,
-0.27950575947761536,
-0.12051434069871902,
-0.22602568566799164,
-0.6699591279029846,
0.10995122790336609,
0.22962911427021027,
0.1755858212709427,
-0.4710363745689392,
-0.5107020139694214,
0.5899864435195923,
0.02179505117237568,
1.1838946342468262,
-0.7532554864883423,
-0.18549801409244537,
-0.10608982294797897,
0.005568873602896929,
0.20283375680446625,
0.40019968152046204,
-0.18721304833889008,
-0.24412551522254944,
-0.3192426860332489,
-0.5144229531288147,
-0.2172209471464157,
0.6203894019126892,
-0.6035853028297424,
-0.24326202273368835,
-0.20720206201076508,
-0.32341158390045166,
-0.5333306789398193,
0.3624652028083801,
0.24021919071674347,
0.6562913060188293,
-0.5067960023880005,
0.26238855719566345,
0.49560609459877014,
0.07085739076137543,
0.9409619569778442,
0.30007749795913696,
0.3340601325035095,
-0.43489107489585876,
0.6463706493377686,
-0.3975273370742798,
-0.1443905085325241,
0.5672309398651123,
0.28826573491096497,
-0.6111904382705688,
-0.28092700242996216,
-0.4779348075389862,
0.10008185356855392,
-0.7562440633773804,
-0.40891531109809875,
-0.4835449457168579,
0.6215527653694153,
-0.484535813331604,
-0.3467741012573242,
-0.2593762278556824,
-0.3648536503314972,
-0.3048833906650543,
-0.030051209032535553,
0.6333351135253906,
0.5789401531219482,
-0.017836757004261017,
0.3781909644603729,
-0.49540555477142334,
0.8610512018203735,
0.1680821031332016,
0.1769936978816986,
-0.4048767387866974,
-0.0727841779589653,
0.2964531481266022,
0.03851637616753578,
-0.447550505399704,
-1.229447603225708,
0.10850577801465988,
0.32054030895233154,
0.4518989026546478,
0.7726525664329529,
0.2513468861579895,
0.2922991216182709,
-0.15971902012825012,
0.7229401469230652,
0.6232386827468872,
-0.8837525844573975,
0.7227517366409302,
-0.9525607228279114,
0.21756209433078766,
0.6401563286781311,
0.5472830533981323,
-0.5497021079063416,
-0.1848295032978058,
-0.24489173293113708,
-0.36264386773109436,
0.7621909379959106,
-0.09177613258361816,
0.25936946272850037,
-0.09297406673431396,
0.06760010123252869,
0.23720796406269073,
0.4382449686527252,
-0.7769392728805542,
-0.036520570516586304,
-0.45051711797714233,
-0.40926602482795715,
0.18959243595600128,
0.17222659289836884,
-0.2889288067817688,
-0.23899009823799133,
0.22689102590084076,
-0.3561505675315857,
0.22760829329490662,
-0.3321365714073181,
-0.318252831697464,
-0.07701373845338821,
0.45584213733673096,
0.567000150680542,
0.4972502291202545,
0.07344421744346619,
0.05625537410378456,
-0.21191920340061188,
-0.31743985414505005,
0.25100353360176086,
-0.2348996251821518,
-0.26984676718711853,
0.17213216423988342,
0.002503804862499237,
0.8562244772911072,
0.32843679189682007,
-0.15433229506015778,
0.8815155029296875,
0.01021431852132082,
-0.18262127041816711,
-0.06905762851238251,
-0.34419313073158264,
0.0028938078321516514,
0.3150324821472168,
0.3120981454849243,
0.65677410364151,
0.03471139445900917,
-0.6898238658905029,
0.19112040102481842,
0.5598472356796265,
-0.5602686405181885,
-0.6310103535652161,
0.4520060420036316,
0.18637250363826752,
-0.25529277324676514,
-0.13765308260917664,
-0.27148935198783875,
-0.5032284259796143,
0.3991107940673828,
0.213650643825531,
1.0276514291763306,
-0.048780642449855804,
0.6993523836135864,
0.20508597791194916,
0.16769450902938843,
-0.1377611756324768,
0.5380731225013733,
-0.14986027777194977,
-0.7391497492790222,
-0.06744782626628876,
-0.14267128705978394,
-0.286636620759964,
0.11945593357086182,
-0.5347743630409241,
0.9499145746231079,
-0.7390234470367432,
-0.6282252669334412,
0.21437206864356995,
-0.22316862642765045,
-0.4789532423019409,
0.009473496116697788,
0.09094461798667908,
0.5747787952423096,
-1.1483228206634521,
0.463728129863739,
1.1502283811569214,
-0.29515692591667175,
-0.5566303730010986,
0.7795504927635193,
0.6503466963768005,
-0.7537685036659241,
0.024361051619052887,
0.3675518333911896,
-0.4696427881717682,
-0.07149191200733185,
-0.7259806394577026,
-0.24605563282966614,
0.910632848739624,
0.4976390302181244,
0.02723059058189392,
0.2031414657831192,
-0.18569912016391754,
0.11700022220611572,
-0.19809311628341675,
-0.012905064970254898,
0.31621402502059937,
0.8677237629890442,
-0.09904413670301437,
-0.631718635559082,
0.21289004385471344,
-0.19138404726982117,
-0.4843592643737793,
0.3351748585700989,
-1.015512228012085,
0.8710485696792603,
0.14880043268203735,
-0.27938711643218994,
-0.35558730363845825,
0.3838666081428528,
0.4685256779193878,
0.49451684951782227,
0.9831880331039429,
0.22697292268276215,
0.5901187658309937,
-0.21064791083335876,
0.898864209651947,
-0.27495303750038147,
0.22807404398918152,
0.348127543926239,
-0.1471458077430725,
0.6073679327964783,
0.5430995225906372,
0.396856427192688,
0.4811270833015442,
0.8073616027832031,
0.04096442833542824,
0.5085771679878235,
-0.37105607986450195,
-0.42152640223503113,
-0.6816825270652771,
-0.3400692343711853,
-0.13263756036758423,
0.3669188320636749,
0.5208916664123535,
-0.1170094832777977,
-0.5320175886154175,
0.33536985516548157,
0.23793499171733856,
0.021600686013698578,
-0.35662463307380676,
0.5688431262969971,
-0.19538389146327972,
-0.4831705689430237,
0.42065590620040894,
0.09870748221874237,
0.8689526319503784,
-0.38761821389198303,
0.14300373196601868,
0.17826931178569794,
-0.06126325577497482,
-0.19029313325881958,
-0.8413946628570557,
-0.17643509805202484,
-0.07462012022733688,
-0.260135293006897,
-0.6086459755897522,
0.9211321473121643,
-0.04868967831134796,
-0.26052871346473694,
0.2341819703578949,
0.7436230182647705,
-0.30576321482658386,
-0.16953356564044952,
-0.9211055040359497,
0.03329404443502426,
-0.19400835037231445,
-0.34958118200302124,
0.0713750571012497,
0.8024121522903442,
-0.18535484373569489,
0.27526527643203735,
0.35299474000930786,
-0.4251432418823242,
-0.061775919049978256,
0.5734703540802002,
1.0385642051696777,
-0.5855280160903931,
-0.47817280888557434,
-0.7699683308601379,
0.3744221329689026,
-0.331962913274765,
-0.6190535426139832,
0.7773632407188416,
0.25648605823516846,
0.30357974767684937,
-0.07831902801990509,
0.858500063419342,
-0.47717761993408203,
0.5049323439598083,
-0.43911683559417725,
0.5300007462501526,
-0.903039276599884,
-0.033301062881946564,
-0.2691064178943634,
-0.5825250148773193,
-0.34440258145332336,
0.5246827602386475,
0.008682774379849434,
0.2295730859041214,
0.7665046453475952,
0.9332473278045654,
-0.4111518859863281,
0.07891460508108139,
0.017094288021326065,
-0.19431699812412262,
0.4185789227485657,
0.2909697890281677,
0.8873677849769592,
-0.29525426030158997,
0.38418829441070557,
0.04296857491135597,
-0.03762541338801384,
-0.3299773931503296,
-1.081170916557312,
-1.1597660779953003,
-0.8115410208702087,
-0.3228892982006073,
-0.42137444019317627,
-0.21753737330436707,
1.2859686613082886,
0.9234858751296997,
-0.971890389919281,
0.1915370672941208,
0.0481560193002224,
0.11719047278165817,
-0.20104558765888214,
-0.2034042775630951,
0.3610704839229584,
-0.3676867187023163,
-0.6879979372024536,
0.7060301899909973,
0.15884706377983093,
0.028693776577711105,
0.031026560813188553,
0.06244393438100815,
-0.5157439708709717,
0.06586495041847229,
0.6056978106498718,
0.30448028445243835,
-0.7029069662094116,
-0.5131312012672424,
0.558750569820404,
-0.13835430145263672,
0.2874985933303833,
1.392014741897583,
-0.2939978837966919,
0.28068166971206665,
0.6615054607391357,
0.18502838909626007,
0.10321546345949173,
0.3136906921863556,
0.4120202362537384,
-1.406459927558899,
0.13330668210983276,
0.30676114559173584,
0.4808245003223419,
0.4743281602859497,
-0.12172190099954605,
-0.11105696111917496,
0.45340076088905334,
0.00996644701808691,
-0.5816307663917542,
0.3610113263130188,
-1.471254587173462,
-0.43644869327545166,
1.3451693058013916,
0.5071438550949097,
0.13802413642406464,
-0.44018882513046265,
-0.5540910959243774,
0.2854824662208557,
-1.038940668106079,
0.5633854866027832,
0.608863890171051,
0.06437662243843079,
-0.31869766116142273,
-0.44982650876045227,
0.6242098212242126,
0.30168241262435913,
-0.5485237240791321,
0.14079581201076508,
0.7617989778518677,
0.1494508981704712,
-0.021821418777108192,
0.7910753488540649,
0.008771532215178013,
0.28149616718292236,
-0.4423445463180542,
-0.41932597756385803,
-0.006624465808272362,
-0.46636179089546204,
-0.41163280606269836,
0.3649454712867737,
-0.18465359508991241,
-0.4220810532569885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14296v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14296v2
|
Mitigating Biases of Large Language Models in Stance Detection with Calibration
| 2024-02-22T05:17:49 | 2024-06-16T12:04:24 |
Ang Li, Jingqian Zhao, Bin Liang, Lin Gui, Hui Wang, Xi Zeng, Xingwei Liang, Kam-Fai Wong, Ruifeng Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable progress in many
natural language processing tasks. However, our experiment reveals that, in
stance detection tasks, LLMs may generate biased stances due to
sentiment-stance spurious correlations and preference towards certain
individuals and topics, thus harming their performance. Therefore, in this
paper, we propose to Mitigate Biases of LLMs in stance detection with
Calibration (MB-Cal). To be specific, a novel calibration network is devised to
calibrate potential bias in the stance prediction of LLMs. Further, to address
the challenge of effectively learning bias representations and the difficulty
in the generalizability of debiasing, we construct counterfactual augmented
data. This approach enhances the calibration network, facilitating the
debiasing and out-of-domain generalization. Experimental results on in-target
and zero-shot stance detection tasks show that the proposed MB-Cal can
effectively mitigate biases of LLMs, achieving state-of-the-art results.
|
[
-0.5473641753196716,
-0.8608316779136658,
0.4840294122695923,
0.041838161647319794,
-0.3117024600505829,
-0.1526307314634323,
-0.1620469093322754,
-0.02194187045097351,
0.598267674446106,
0.7597795128822327,
-0.5994808077812195,
-0.4451926648616791,
-0.6795836687088013,
-0.29107770323753357,
0.11900656670331955,
1.145644187927246,
-0.029398053884506226,
0.45199280977249146,
-0.26377078890800476,
-0.40092214941978455,
-0.6275783181190491,
-0.570431649684906,
-0.47620001435279846,
-0.7044759392738342,
0.29603952169418335,
0.29518091678619385,
0.8274052143096924,
0.14811863005161285,
0.12658894062042236,
0.17008410394191742,
0.057531289756298065,
0.06828852742910385,
-0.4952531158924103,
0.24528661370277405,
-0.3633357584476471,
-0.49691274762153625,
-0.7083812355995178,
-0.008543603122234344,
0.807514488697052,
0.8099803328514099,
0.2179635763168335,
-0.04446862265467644,
-0.01258292980492115,
0.8480318188667297,
-0.764835000038147,
0.013080007396638393,
-0.6300635933876038,
-0.049950964748859406,
-0.20596002042293549,
-0.20825989544391632,
-0.514479398727417,
-0.1430201530456543,
-0.15386369824409485,
-0.3518241047859192,
0.13787852227687836,
-0.06852257996797562,
0.5451076030731201,
0.2505393624305725,
-0.47394970059394836,
0.15566766262054443,
-0.4973160922527313,
1.0420001745224,
-0.9386712908744812,
0.4127959609031677,
0.6463602185249329,
0.028537075966596603,
-0.3547743856906891,
0.24587230384349823,
-0.5663204193115234,
-0.09341179579496384,
0.17399433255195618,
0.018903883174061775,
-0.004438895732164383,
0.11819865554571152,
0.34784215688705444,
0.1412811577320099,
-0.5427367687225342,
0.31589561700820923,
0.27894553542137146,
-0.5057865381240845,
0.414554238319397,
0.01099477894604206,
0.2076294869184494,
-0.12342946976423264,
-0.38069894909858704,
-0.12166201323270798,
-1.1568669080734253,
-0.06042587757110596,
0.6575934290885925,
0.3983582854270935,
-0.015321681275963783,
0.7071298956871033,
-0.254463791847229,
0.45966771245002747,
0.4022137522697449,
0.09101756662130356,
0.38039013743400574,
-0.11497624963521957,
-0.30587038397789,
0.20474651455879211,
0.7501437067985535,
0.5381560921669006,
0.2211940884590149,
0.07851102203130722,
-0.16653487086296082,
0.21884652972221375,
-0.020103374496102333,
-0.8769379258155823,
-0.11237271875143051,
0.13227780163288116,
-0.17950159311294556,
-0.3394269347190857,
-0.29503580927848816,
-0.8068156838417053,
-0.823848307132721,
-0.502007782459259,
0.4971049129962921,
-0.1707678735256195,
-0.5155286192893982,
0.026638153940439224,
0.16502514481544495,
0.35865718126296997,
0.321154922246933,
-0.7808912396430969,
0.13180942833423615,
0.7698677778244019,
0.6261410117149353,
0.1375582367181778,
0.02631421945989132,
-0.8792377710342407,
0.13170365989208221,
-0.4366094172000885,
0.628410279750824,
-0.6719815731048584,
-0.5087483525276184,
-0.14882943034172058,
-0.2106165736913681,
0.15684248507022858,
-0.4916495978832245,
0.4145813584327698,
-0.5401861667633057,
-0.019872356206178665,
-0.7035608887672424,
-0.5651655197143555,
-0.1498260200023651,
0.8612101078033447,
-0.8057682514190674,
0.9216587543487549,
-0.20713259279727936,
-0.9668136239051819,
0.5139048099517822,
-0.4387797713279724,
-0.41863003373146057,
-0.18776942789554596,
-0.43221357464790344,
-0.43919625878334045,
0.014264008030295372,
0.4756896197795868,
0.45131537318229675,
-0.1556900590658188,
0.5690184235572815,
-0.7437242865562439,
-0.26697003841400146,
0.07737524062395096,
-0.5765519142150879,
0.8147884607315063,
-0.13924729824066162,
-0.5240959525108337,
0.08986614644527435,
-0.4741663932800293,
-0.2649526596069336,
-0.16259567439556122,
-0.22476959228515625,
-0.6498568058013916,
0.10456852614879608,
-0.2812334895133972,
0.24265339970588684,
0.08748047798871994,
-0.6431916356086731,
0.20913586020469666,
-0.7784229516983032,
0.01969853974878788,
0.810894787311554,
-0.023303186520934105,
0.6043182611465454,
-0.2086755335330963,
0.4434281289577484,
0.3381088078022003,
-0.18352042138576508,
-0.0976753979921341,
-0.21921983361244202,
-0.7975730895996094,
-0.2854883372783661,
0.0846458449959755,
0.4703144431114197,
-0.9063358306884766,
0.5751992464065552,
-0.340582013130188,
-0.22065593302249908,
-0.21641021966934204,
0.4639382064342499,
0.5016106367111206,
0.7160826921463013,
0.28224584460258484,
-0.4571399688720703,
-0.4907553493976593,
-0.9564017653465271,
-0.5602314472198486,
-0.28663212060928345,
0.18636906147003174,
0.04967183619737625,
0.3645937740802765,
-0.2146589756011963,
1.0728189945220947,
-0.24814467132091522,
-0.3790227472782135,
-0.16140472888946533,
0.2838751971721649,
0.14719770848751068,
0.3877564072608948,
0.6705806851387024,
-0.9005194902420044,
-0.3536340892314911,
-0.389040470123291,
-0.3671477138996124,
-0.2539035975933075,
-0.10481791198253632,
-0.19996841251850128,
0.31955239176750183,
0.48859113454818726,
-0.6087852716445923,
0.4312324821949005,
0.449039101600647,
-0.25939542055130005,
0.5425647497177124,
0.17911970615386963,
0.06693051010370255,
-1.1229957342147827,
-0.00019901087216567248,
0.502233624458313,
-0.6086210012435913,
-0.654988169670105,
-0.12205756455659866,
-0.04703022539615631,
0.3770180344581604,
-0.46858564019203186,
0.6237488389015198,
-0.13219726085662842,
0.06445500254631042,
-0.47853538393974304,
0.14932504296302795,
0.2246755063533783,
0.3782673180103302,
0.21393077075481415,
0.5595365166664124,
0.5733148455619812,
-0.49613383412361145,
0.31972986459732056,
0.11682052165269852,
-0.016629116609692574,
0.8913102746009827,
-0.34109753370285034,
0.035152580589056015,
-0.3458169996738434,
0.7073541283607483,
-1.1438560485839844,
0.13293112814426422,
0.36105433106422424,
-0.38568881154060364,
0.527550220489502,
-0.3361693322658539,
-0.38549014925956726,
-0.1662399172782898,
-0.7254714369773865,
0.47470349073410034,
-0.038291085511446,
-0.5467352867126465,
0.5941465497016907,
0.5135809779167175,
-0.01938091777265072,
-1.0435651540756226,
-0.7158101201057434,
0.05887339636683464,
-0.19017702341079712,
-0.18787601590156555,
0.14483170211315155,
-0.09733489155769348,
-0.40545758605003357,
-0.37153390049934387,
-0.13665881752967834,
0.2062511295080185,
-0.1368352174758911,
0.3482353985309601,
0.3524983525276184,
-0.04530706629157066,
0.194624662399292,
0.037376586347818375,
-0.05852436646819115,
0.19162505865097046,
-0.12568214535713196,
0.7710370421409607,
-0.12299550324678421,
-0.5482186079025269,
-0.17582792043685913,
0.17145703732967377,
0.806928277015686,
0.003984337206929922,
0.745782196521759,
0.5842946767807007,
-0.4360411465167999,
-0.08921640366315842,
-0.8005296587944031,
-0.2950674295425415,
-0.4758341312408447,
0.4140965938568115,
-0.12824666500091553,
-0.6000747084617615,
0.3790285289287567,
-0.1699247509241104,
0.09276572614908218,
0.3052200376987457,
0.8338688611984253,
0.19979843497276306,
1.128361463546753,
0.3920931816101074,
-0.8377817869186401,
0.4799421429634094,
-0.22508187592029572,
0.34715574979782104,
-0.972608208656311,
0.16606567800045013,
-0.2954903542995453,
-0.4233431816101074,
-0.52337646484375,
-0.4788461923599243,
0.2550998330116272,
-0.18540707230567932,
-0.4644210636615753,
0.19347749650478363,
-0.03943919762969017,
0.38627827167510986,
0.34467533230781555,
0.297950804233551,
0.108503557741642,
-0.14715290069580078,
-0.43585291504859924,
-0.31101998686790466,
-0.24948137998580933,
-0.579989492893219,
1.2252919673919678,
0.3861750364303589,
0.7186660170555115,
0.05854923278093338,
0.5724263191223145,
0.36452314257621765,
0.45108097791671753,
-1.020640254020691,
0.7124623656272888,
-0.16230660676956177,
-0.8030592799186707,
-0.15485674142837524,
-0.4742186665534973,
-0.30394992232322693,
0.3589767813682556,
-0.281518816947937,
-0.6793726682662964,
0.21622052788734436,
0.5028020143508911,
-0.19644546508789062,
0.6075610518455505,
-0.3711228668689728,
0.712519645690918,
-0.14805394411087036,
-0.670009970664978,
-0.3604392409324646,
-0.47018977999687195,
0.34006279706954956,
-0.047126349061727524,
0.33438625931739807,
-0.17823649942874908,
0.23065023124217987,
0.6055969595909119,
-0.35888296365737915,
1.3002617359161377,
-0.6377494931221008,
-0.2649034857749939,
0.2203529328107834,
0.3764362037181854,
0.6454778909683228,
0.10279174894094467,
-0.4164598286151886,
0.026790309697389603,
-0.2560649812221527,
-0.29799824953079224,
-0.280992329120636,
0.9583444595336914,
-0.5534775257110596,
-0.6216432452201843,
-0.25597837567329407,
-0.6272405385971069,
-0.7508549690246582,
0.20796698331832886,
0.09830331057310104,
0.5001769661903381,
-0.5595131516456604,
0.16361911594867706,
0.6904613971710205,
-0.2437756508588791,
0.3779882490634918,
0.5123226642608643,
-0.2420959770679474,
-0.34084808826446533,
0.7364765405654907,
-0.06581767648458481,
0.20174652338027954,
0.5213894248008728,
0.32439425587654114,
-0.4944719672203064,
-0.31872597336769104,
-0.4314679801464081,
0.1910312920808792,
-0.7633540034294128,
-0.3340022563934326,
-0.3821776211261749,
0.1793747842311859,
-0.575892984867096,
-0.044648829847574234,
-0.4731954038143158,
-0.3705182373523712,
-0.3102736473083496,
-0.20751522481441498,
0.19283510744571686,
0.3058013617992401,
0.004085887223482132,
0.46814626455307007,
-0.49863776564598083,
0.3432474136352539,
0.10591283440589905,
0.2989475727081299,
-0.13987329602241516,
-0.5604923367500305,
0.09316879510879517,
0.42503196001052856,
-0.4903411865234375,
-0.7015240788459778,
0.5318742394447327,
0.1165100708603859,
0.40531355142593384,
0.633257269859314,
0.21113534271717072,
0.5864813923835754,
-0.4942846894264221,
0.6698015332221985,
0.45747098326683044,
-0.9586251378059387,
0.5274154543876648,
-0.4978364408016205,
0.23540166020393372,
0.7362143993377686,
0.35242679715156555,
-0.30291682481765747,
-0.25487270951271057,
-0.2501150369644165,
-0.7020191550254822,
0.4890580475330353,
-0.2111903876066208,
0.41296491026878357,
0.004621382802724838,
0.2845476567745209,
0.08387267589569092,
0.36588558554649353,
-0.8831305503845215,
-0.05987653508782387,
-0.27327170968055725,
-0.2608773112297058,
-0.12754644453525543,
-0.118462935090065,
-0.1735268533229828,
-0.2975274324417114,
0.9262858033180237,
-0.4330604076385498,
-0.14559657871723175,
0.09445905685424805,
-0.4117027819156647,
-0.39456653594970703,
0.370347261428833,
0.41898372769355774,
0.35633420944213867,
-0.15852828323841095,
0.25458765029907227,
0.23227283358573914,
-0.5462090969085693,
0.016035456210374832,
-0.13384844362735748,
-0.38525843620300293,
-0.10484543442726135,
-0.00818111002445221,
0.8361222743988037,
0.20748622715473175,
-0.3912785053253174,
0.7318614721298218,
0.3927880525588989,
-0.043087027966976166,
-0.11966516077518463,
-0.126347154378891,
0.010260320268571377,
0.04155096784234047,
0.062020450830459595,
0.08301085233688354,
0.08930236101150513,
-0.548358142375946,
0.13626360893249512,
1.0082813501358032,
-0.5026934742927551,
-0.3992156386375427,
0.3882291913032532,
0.17686517536640167,
0.08766765147447586,
0.15082310140132904,
-0.002317806240171194,
-0.9148890972137451,
0.5547897815704346,
0.6467945575714111,
0.7531182169914246,
-0.26030221581459045,
0.21196329593658447,
0.37260526418685913,
0.25420600175857544,
-0.10199281573295593,
0.15845972299575806,
0.09172844141721725,
-1.128831386566162,
-0.4576210379600525,
-0.5169597864151001,
-0.6793627142906189,
0.37176796793937683,
-0.546337366104126,
0.45114266872406006,
-0.5829781293869019,
-0.4177102744579315,
-0.10430420935153961,
0.1623241901397705,
-0.5776363611221313,
0.2428608238697052,
0.31943026185035706,
0.594099760055542,
-1.0565199851989746,
0.8630813956260681,
0.8626340627670288,
-0.13314850628376007,
-0.44528043270111084,
0.14797326922416687,
0.39982903003692627,
-0.7749656438827515,
0.6431546807289124,
0.31276556849479675,
-0.46592921018600464,
-0.21345119178295135,
-0.5323272347450256,
-0.3948383927345276,
0.6986411809921265,
0.580440104007721,
-0.7124273777008057,
0.3223050832748413,
0.299652099609375,
0.3761201798915863,
-0.24846427142620087,
0.21842141449451447,
0.4297073185443878,
0.5465660095214844,
0.09926283359527588,
-0.8323754668235779,
0.09557356685400009,
-0.013769100420176983,
-0.2826923429965973,
0.3481253385543823,
-0.5569053888320923,
0.5891942381858826,
0.195428729057312,
0.3030174970626831,
-0.28151604533195496,
0.3491024076938629,
0.3560456335544586,
0.2943758964538574,
0.8340582251548767,
0.7871150970458984,
0.4959157407283783,
-0.0056817312724888325,
0.6562793254852295,
-0.08316139876842499,
0.27018508315086365,
1.1190073490142822,
-0.6747503876686096,
0.7934224009513855,
0.7482170462608337,
0.02699322998523712,
0.4929412305355072,
0.4062533676624298,
0.23243148624897003,
0.33547791838645935,
0.20925016701221466,
-0.45373401045799255,
-0.6234297156333923,
-0.23718753457069397,
-0.032423507422208786,
0.4746994078159332,
0.58956378698349,
-0.304803729057312,
-0.39972659945487976,
0.06966222822666168,
0.41346850991249084,
0.16362081468105316,
-0.6447932720184326,
0.4487650692462921,
0.10529565066099167,
-0.6412719488143921,
0.27874571084976196,
-0.09161318093538284,
0.9401028752326965,
-0.3986000716686249,
-0.009260892868041992,
-0.060287587344646454,
0.38241785764694214,
-0.1642543077468872,
-0.7681614756584167,
0.15893036127090454,
-0.04635307565331459,
-0.3164122402667999,
-0.2539476156234741,
0.973442018032074,
-0.3543826937675476,
-0.4156361222267151,
0.3199585974216461,
0.4216364026069641,
-0.1515837162733078,
-0.2553984820842743,
-0.5536025166511536,
-0.004281532019376755,
-0.16470488905906677,
-0.4965752959251404,
0.5140138268470764,
0.06477007269859314,
-0.2840290367603302,
0.4506796896457672,
0.5425244569778442,
0.2084382176399231,
-0.2730565667152405,
0.36526739597320557,
1.1245445013046265,
-0.39474788308143616,
-0.43072018027305603,
-1.143411636352539,
0.12502586841583252,
-0.024490319192409515,
-0.0022424825001507998,
0.6798825860023499,
0.4310048818588257,
0.6646445393562317,
0.2204788774251938,
0.6396180391311646,
0.25571829080581665,
0.47511911392211914,
-0.4065970778465271,
0.7814478278160095,
-0.37471312284469604,
0.4104655683040619,
-0.3556571304798126,
-0.9129902124404907,
-0.6007566452026367,
0.657697319984436,
-0.7048002481460571,
0.04173557087779045,
0.19114534556865692,
1.0391576290130615,
-0.11778274923563004,
-0.10032065957784653,
0.28445714712142944,
0.1788928210735321,
0.4502108693122864,
0.4964722692966461,
0.44890016317367554,
-0.27903127670288086,
0.23814444243907928,
-0.17017056047916412,
-0.17551299929618835,
-0.2651335895061493,
-1.3171018362045288,
-1.0801012516021729,
-0.19554373621940613,
-0.4496716260910034,
-0.3974742591381073,
-0.22348175942897797,
1.1384336948394775,
0.7299836277961731,
-1.098482370376587,
0.023876355960965157,
-0.16046494245529175,
0.17541490495204926,
0.14245276153087616,
-0.22501236200332642,
0.23230083286762238,
-0.1069423109292984,
-0.6419472098350525,
0.4398379623889923,
0.15799349546432495,
-0.20214608311653137,
-0.43440714478492737,
-0.23318497836589813,
-0.3738419711589813,
0.30780449509620667,
0.6202976703643799,
0.39324700832366943,
-0.6965700387954712,
-0.39940783381462097,
-0.08183785527944565,
0.04155713692307472,
0.15524470806121826,
0.8437870740890503,
-1.0214558839797974,
0.6627143621444702,
0.5369381308555603,
0.6040480732917786,
0.23965296149253845,
0.05177079513669014,
0.6289783120155334,
-1.1728341579437256,
0.24789923429489136,
0.3115244209766388,
0.631653904914856,
0.5760433077812195,
-0.37624233961105347,
0.14539149403572083,
0.18127009272575378,
-0.3472575545310974,
-0.8736997246742249,
0.42010265588760376,
-0.8330371379852295,
-0.08299323171377182,
1.2944680452346802,
-0.024227390065789223,
0.046541761606931686,
-0.06695494800806046,
-0.3631567060947418,
0.3776923716068268,
-0.32550570368766785,
0.5431178212165833,
0.8098292946815491,
0.08297789841890335,
0.08081662654876709,
-0.5085209608078003,
0.1594056934118271,
0.8021425604820251,
-0.498578816652298,
0.24108652770519257,
0.7715702652931213,
0.4112006723880768,
0.07420149445533752,
0.5231293439865112,
-0.14193303883075714,
0.04278825223445892,
-0.4836553931236267,
0.013147938065230846,
0.047129977494478226,
-0.12214866280555725,
-0.4434736371040344,
-0.2248096764087677,
0.08728224784135818,
-0.11019810289144516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14293v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14293v1
|
Leveraging Large Language Models for Concept Graph Recovery and Question Answering in NLP Education
| 2024-02-22T05:15:27 | 2024-02-22T05:15:27 |
Rui Yang, Boming Yang, Sixun Ouyang, Tianwei She, Aosong Feng, Yuang Jiang, Freddy Lecue, Jinghui Lu, Irene Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the domain of Natural Language Processing (NLP), Large Language Models
(LLMs) have demonstrated promise in text-generation tasks. However, their
educational applications, particularly for domain-specific queries, remain
underexplored. This study investigates LLMs' capabilities in educational
scenarios, focusing on concept graph recovery and question-answering (QA). We
assess LLMs' zero-shot performance in creating domain-specific concept graphs
and introduce TutorQA, a new expert-verified NLP-focused benchmark for
scientific graph reasoning and QA. TutorQA consists of five tasks with 500 QA
pairs. To tackle TutorQA queries, we present CGLLM, a pipeline integrating
concept graphs with LLMs for answering diverse questions. Our results indicate
that LLMs' zero-shot concept graph recovery is competitive with supervised
methods, showing an average 3% F1 score improvement. In TutorQA tasks, LLMs
achieve up to 26% F1 score enhancement. Moreover, human evaluation and analysis
show that CGLLM generates answers with more fine-grained concepts.
|
[
-0.36671292781829834,
-1.100254774093628,
0.5254786014556885,
-0.24168522655963898,
-0.10519888252019882,
0.7477086782455444,
-0.13308937847614288,
-0.4451848268508911,
0.17630696296691895,
0.5312808752059937,
-0.3744796812534332,
-0.682162880897522,
-0.4951552152633667,
0.31858113408088684,
-0.5556502342224121,
0.7750288248062134,
0.06828034669160843,
-0.23902565240859985,
-0.3993302583694458,
0.31120818853378296,
-0.40530329942703247,
-0.5985938906669617,
-1.0458784103393555,
-0.1854075789451599,
0.3919587731361389,
0.2571083903312683,
0.3391339182853699,
0.3055761754512787,
0.37991565465927124,
0.2086212933063507,
-0.12110178172588348,
0.3174746632575989,
-0.5742527842521667,
0.3065433204174042,
-0.25731325149536133,
-0.41495224833488464,
-0.30619409680366516,
-0.06743054836988449,
0.8154460787773132,
1.0603591203689575,
-0.009489627555012703,
0.007982262410223484,
-0.02049708180129528,
0.48549214005470276,
-0.5584913492202759,
0.22043216228485107,
-0.8250789046287537,
0.013527456670999527,
0.24180461466312408,
-0.10229156166315079,
-0.4719659984111786,
-0.4160163998603821,
0.32236820459365845,
-0.6036399602890015,
0.3125655949115753,
0.025994710624217987,
0.7950656414031982,
0.1582433432340622,
-0.40373694896698,
-0.402036190032959,
-0.5075987577438354,
0.6572301387786865,
-0.7846355438232422,
0.2821103036403656,
0.2447710782289505,
0.2956962287425995,
-0.18060629069805145,
-0.8740438222885132,
-0.6674854159355164,
0.06013207510113716,
0.10722141712903976,
0.11955928057432175,
-0.1553858369588852,
0.03947172686457634,
0.3360612988471985,
0.1761009246110916,
-0.6321701407432556,
0.3435751497745514,
-0.5104378461837769,
-0.23764514923095703,
0.6059079170227051,
0.24978378415107727,
0.30730852484703064,
-0.3841892182826996,
-0.16998928785324097,
-0.022188309580087662,
-0.7874197363853455,
0.07554854452610016,
-0.08663655817508698,
0.5567089915275574,
0.2726154029369354,
0.647077202796936,
-0.23427124321460724,
0.9540932774543762,
-0.2943231761455536,
-0.17132440209388733,
0.01712789759039879,
-0.286842405796051,
-0.2402561455965042,
0.01113286055624485,
0.6947476267814636,
0.1996149867773056,
0.5141080021858215,
-0.40323999524116516,
-0.014754746109247208,
0.11346244066953659,
0.15060999989509583,
-0.8801895976066589,
-0.263877272605896,
0.27883416414260864,
0.18524259328842163,
0.04491110146045685,
-0.23311300575733185,
-0.6025819778442383,
-0.18803063035011292,
-0.17054356634616852,
0.22814539074897766,
-0.42446789145469666,
-0.35049769282341003,
0.4226265251636505,
-0.1913263499736786,
0.28250038623809814,
0.42699968814849854,
-0.6064822673797607,
0.29884403944015503,
0.8921852111816406,
0.853989839553833,
-0.5099577307701111,
-0.022082364186644554,
-0.49760040640830994,
0.022386746481060982,
-0.5162826180458069,
0.6899930238723755,
-0.48325973749160767,
-0.5052528381347656,
0.08884597569704056,
-0.06799931079149246,
-0.33698299527168274,
-0.5769889950752258,
0.40844041109085083,
-0.8707988858222961,
0.3156801164150238,
-0.1294381469488144,
-0.9446285963058472,
-0.10419397801160812,
0.5975965261459351,
-0.4079529643058777,
0.9220969080924988,
0.047074463218450546,
-0.6865732669830322,
-0.019113121554255486,
-0.5401586890220642,
-0.2613297998905182,
0.36017706990242004,
-0.046395931392908096,
-0.08374974876642227,
-0.26785340905189514,
0.03117254003882408,
0.6196282505989075,
-0.2745090425014496,
0.25577202439308167,
-0.13772597908973694,
-0.2814450263977051,
-0.007085873279720545,
-0.2830483019351959,
0.7660053372383118,
-0.019694790244102478,
0.006251096725463867,
-0.11377318203449249,
-0.6984153985977173,
0.463399201631546,
0.26202893257141113,
-0.2759205400943756,
-0.38094598054885864,
-0.00494333915412426,
-0.3770345449447632,
0.4293302893638611,
0.040113940834999084,
-0.7935877442359924,
0.1332266479730606,
-0.5905668139457703,
0.747964084148407,
0.29815131425857544,
0.19769640266895294,
0.09839950501918793,
-0.036990877240896225,
0.6666454672813416,
-0.28177085518836975,
-0.5058073997497559,
-0.17485934495925903,
-0.5871866941452026,
-0.5935499668121338,
-0.25801196694374084,
0.2952156364917755,
0.37838587164878845,
-1.1037631034851074,
0.23020873963832855,
-0.2603071630001068,
-0.4874977171421051,
-0.45454856753349304,
-0.02571621723473072,
0.37136247754096985,
0.9035871624946594,
0.419299840927124,
-0.13432060182094574,
-0.3255847990512848,
-0.5989082455635071,
-0.016558460891246796,
-0.22190561890602112,
-0.30387991666793823,
0.4263826310634613,
0.581529438495636,
0.10884314030408859,
1.1629070043563843,
-0.909607470035553,
-0.07443327456712723,
-0.25300976634025574,
-0.1828327625989914,
0.15544982254505157,
0.2282216101884842,
0.5044608116149902,
-0.6560337543487549,
-0.5243744254112244,
-0.3513464331626892,
-0.8192625641822815,
0.13809604942798615,
0.182225301861763,
-0.17096130549907684,
0.10192230343818665,
0.4240591824054718,
-0.9155445098876953,
0.1269465684890747,
0.4409407675266266,
-0.3559982478618622,
0.7088934183120728,
0.08093060553073883,
-0.1577310413122177,
-1.0790194272994995,
0.04464027285575867,
0.14421218633651733,
-0.42138129472732544,
-0.7289800643920898,
0.43584510684013367,
-0.22164782881736755,
-0.2576889097690582,
-0.4594976603984833,
0.7077965140342712,
-0.14356467127799988,
-0.19440029561519623,
-0.41141581535339355,
1.025180697441101,
0.27277299761772156,
0.2033374160528183,
0.32658153772354126,
0.7132787108421326,
0.649681568145752,
-0.5844528079032898,
0.22879229485988617,
0.391888827085495,
-0.2136588841676712,
0.505285918712616,
-0.9392110705375671,
0.3439849019050598,
-0.08878498524427414,
0.19131094217300415,
-1.0246608257293701,
-0.19673743844032288,
0.043513454496860504,
-0.39708349108695984,
0.3345634937286377,
0.11548056453466415,
-0.4814220070838928,
-0.7218390107154846,
-0.18628667294979095,
-0.060710325837135315,
0.32013458013534546,
-0.6053857207298279,
0.368127703666687,
0.30534619092941284,
-0.3621383011341095,
-0.7242792844772339,
-0.16103671491146088,
0.2097034752368927,
0.11469791829586029,
-0.39091628789901733,
0.09149141609668732,
-0.03279729560017586,
-0.12617072463035583,
0.22106921672821045,
-0.16582071781158447,
-0.07358705252408981,
0.44523826241493225,
0.008302045054733753,
0.48819631338119507,
-0.26792481541633606,
0.3485112488269806,
0.06904727220535278,
0.12027370929718018,
0.2892882227897644,
-0.3599843978881836,
0.7115781307220459,
-0.054691676050424576,
-0.1406155675649643,
0.019826533272862434,
0.2287006974220276,
0.14273123443126678,
-0.28942981362342834,
0.633842945098877,
0.2823264002799988,
-0.5022949576377869,
-0.43523746728897095,
-0.12328563630580902,
-0.32062941789627075,
-0.3838823735713959,
0.6029122471809387,
-0.3185073137283325,
-1.239175796508789,
0.150796577334404,
-0.10171852260828018,
0.23947758972644806,
0.4975825548171997,
0.4534219205379486,
-0.23918463289737701,
0.8198169469833374,
0.4290904700756073,
0.07016033679246902,
0.004548362921923399,
-0.6272155046463013,
0.4462287724018097,
-0.8699377179145813,
-0.17570076882839203,
-0.6703510880470276,
-0.024431098252534866,
-0.340395987033844,
-0.42541590332984924,
0.1599615216255188,
0.40512484312057495,
-0.2813337743282318,
0.23904815316200256,
-0.5529589653015137,
0.501964271068573,
0.5754116773605347,
-0.19638481736183167,
0.5553755164146423,
0.017559828236699104,
-0.10095760971307755,
0.1440899819135666,
-0.7623268961906433,
-0.732690155506134,
1.0992354154586792,
0.05287305638194084,
0.3003140091896057,
-0.10435253381729126,
0.6095923781394958,
-0.11405486613512039,
0.35835590958595276,
-0.9546600580215454,
0.8020310401916504,
-0.19008508324623108,
-0.7575362920761108,
-0.593696117401123,
-0.6150041222572327,
-0.8750215768814087,
0.4588782489299774,
-0.33695054054260254,
-0.8403419256210327,
-0.34705087542533875,
-0.11952600628137589,
-0.22333309054374695,
0.35774901509284973,
-0.4897725582122803,
0.6809476613998413,
0.06807412952184677,
-0.1908082813024521,
-0.1088162437081337,
-0.47332873940467834,
0.39274176955223083,
-0.46590447425842285,
-0.03185437619686127,
-0.21834883093833923,
0.2722688317298889,
0.696587085723877,
-0.11633546650409698,
0.8021059632301331,
-0.2858257591724396,
-0.24926216900348663,
0.5561702847480774,
0.11978373676538467,
0.11749435216188431,
0.032863080501556396,
-0.1631777137517929,
0.1023792028427124,
0.2364448606967926,
-0.2851332724094391,
-0.7202979326248169,
0.7920122742652893,
-0.7589166164398193,
-1.004033088684082,
-0.22028718888759613,
-0.7205668091773987,
-0.515259861946106,
0.28184884786605835,
-0.26076680421829224,
0.22785939276218414,
-0.0561547577381134,
0.29700660705566406,
0.5366991758346558,
-0.2963578999042511,
0.5333272218704224,
0.6833494901657104,
-0.3532004952430725,
-0.020885953679680824,
0.9377316236495972,
0.17201285064220428,
0.49569714069366455,
0.2555026113986969,
-0.033055178821086884,
-0.42367345094680786,
-0.6062875986099243,
-0.40725263953208923,
0.3023611605167389,
-0.6483749151229858,
-0.36747315526008606,
-0.8917482495307922,
-0.6664132475852966,
-0.29947981238365173,
-0.1664298176765442,
-0.13443544507026672,
-0.8208534121513367,
-0.3460737466812134,
-0.3175746202468872,
0.08821729570627213,
0.4178195297718048,
0.2888910174369812,
0.17968805134296417,
-0.7548717856407166,
0.29799744486808777,
0.41075918078422546,
0.1374998837709427,
0.11609732359647751,
-0.48252132534980774,
0.020342808216810226,
0.14040066301822662,
-0.39825522899627686,
-0.5071657299995422,
0.3875722885131836,
0.44231367111206055,
0.36068880558013916,
0.11618953943252563,
0.06207768991589546,
0.26849445700645447,
-0.5701309442520142,
0.901444137096405,
0.1191791221499443,
-0.7710893154144287,
0.46662965416908264,
-0.037677716463804245,
0.2062402218580246,
0.10853885114192963,
0.7320805788040161,
-0.6388859152793884,
-0.5425096750259399,
-0.4338705837726593,
-0.7354978322982788,
0.4715479016304016,
-0.027428550645709038,
0.37922900915145874,
-0.25410398840904236,
0.6945123076438904,
0.02248123660683632,
0.36894041299819946,
-0.3168633282184601,
-0.2124539464712143,
-0.37638717889785767,
-0.2895113229751587,
-0.18121841549873352,
-0.013734634965658188,
-0.2017974853515625,
-0.11807344853878021,
0.48545074462890625,
-0.5492104887962341,
-0.07341542094945908,
-0.037759482860565186,
0.1615985780954361,
0.06727352738380432,
0.28327226638793945,
0.14726513624191284,
0.6520202159881592,
-0.19280818104743958,
0.09002422541379929,
-0.06982478499412537,
-0.4447346329689026,
0.07128790766000748,
0.19182029366493225,
-0.4605860412120819,
-0.15113067626953125,
0.45806312561035156,
0.552902102470398,
0.04522433876991272,
-0.9821367263793945,
0.32896292209625244,
-0.07013572752475739,
-0.35222482681274414,
0.01023674663156271,
0.42085933685302734,
0.508819043636322,
0.13826952874660492,
0.5514413118362427,
-0.3278668224811554,
-0.04475575312972069,
-0.5063068270683289,
0.21344126760959625,
0.7273239493370056,
-0.06499125808477402,
-0.2985003590583801,
0.8690085411071777,
-0.03128860518336296,
-0.4378306567668915,
0.754132091999054,
-0.09925922006368637,
-0.3658941984176636,
0.783850371837616,
1.032706618309021,
0.5276179909706116,
0.141009122133255,
0.7559704780578613,
0.5665030479431152,
-0.10008517652750015,
0.19138513505458832,
0.44629138708114624,
0.18249115347862244,
-1.081734538078308,
-0.6328697204589844,
-0.6543816924095154,
-0.6630094647407532,
-0.267400324344635,
-0.5873172879219055,
-0.030726030468940735,
-0.5906471610069275,
-0.20656894147396088,
0.2944389283657074,
0.25310754776000977,
-0.6028040051460266,
0.49146121740341187,
-0.0602155402302742,
0.9062337875366211,
-0.49717432260513306,
0.8629952669143677,
0.7336861491203308,
-0.2791825532913208,
-1.0042290687561035,
-0.2526673376560211,
-0.28710687160491943,
-0.692065954208374,
0.8113431930541992,
-0.027242889627814293,
-0.08610576391220093,
0.43399888277053833,
-0.6540611982345581,
-0.7882079482078552,
1.1285128593444824,
0.36253488063812256,
-0.6261630058288574,
-0.3629959523677826,
0.22891826927661896,
0.9210481643676758,
-0.45875686407089233,
-0.0313132219016552,
0.6120072603225708,
-0.05123670771718025,
0.4222917854785919,
-0.6294497847557068,
-0.0009798638056963682,
0.09322695434093475,
-0.23874005675315857,
0.029198922216892242,
-0.46493133902549744,
0.646714448928833,
-0.39730969071388245,
-0.3548075258731842,
-0.15833230316638947,
0.4590781331062317,
0.6454033255577087,
0.22497336566448212,
0.24765683710575104,
0.4561174809932709,
0.9790814518928528,
-0.272706001996994,
1.077460765838623,
-0.4353058934211731,
0.33279943466186523,
1.1278027296066284,
-0.39036527276039124,
1.1353857517242432,
0.16534283757209778,
-0.14130966365337372,
0.5142074227333069,
0.6297087073326111,
0.15072739124298096,
0.2836976945400238,
0.286464661359787,
-0.06766742467880249,
-0.3590455949306488,
-0.49191585183143616,
-0.2217448502779007,
0.5321003198623657,
0.5683237314224243,
-0.10448718816041946,
-0.20245619118213654,
-0.08810686320066452,
0.031141914427280426,
0.1276615709066391,
-0.46249520778656006,
0.5129612684249878,
0.37833142280578613,
-0.48558104038238525,
0.7066582441329956,
-0.06565101444721222,
0.25804030895233154,
-0.3812376856803894,
-0.020346729084849358,
-0.30896952748298645,
-0.16556651890277863,
-0.06494729220867157,
-0.917316734790802,
0.03270134702324867,
0.07699815928936005,
-0.047047391533851624,
0.1259327381849289,
0.7645295262336731,
-0.5569431781768799,
-0.41929399967193604,
0.24234609305858612,
0.7632739543914795,
0.037099093198776245,
0.1291472166776657,
-0.4843266010284424,
-0.1915915310382843,
-0.23283526301383972,
-0.1362997442483902,
0.29565250873565674,
0.2906162142753601,
0.06777916848659515,
0.9438689947128296,
0.49586766958236694,
0.23632927238941193,
0.15433670580387115,
0.2292231321334839,
0.9386293292045593,
-0.41885557770729065,
-0.017304368317127228,
-0.49037209153175354,
0.17503628134727478,
-0.1756407618522644,
-0.21594849228858948,
0.8454285264015198,
0.434763103723526,
0.9900653958320618,
0.05100434646010399,
0.7768431901931763,
0.22490927577018738,
0.7376363277435303,
-0.5219012498855591,
0.38221439719200134,
-0.48160186409950256,
0.1300797462463379,
-0.40868470072746277,
-0.9684194922447205,
-0.4628136456012726,
0.45427870750427246,
-0.3375738859176636,
-0.16767141222953796,
0.6854776740074158,
0.4106224775314331,
0.346127450466156,
0.13627217710018158,
0.3782646358013153,
0.18306216597557068,
0.6449881792068481,
0.5730752944946289,
0.8004797697067261,
-0.26611435413360596,
0.3285282552242279,
0.04577837139368057,
0.1268865019083023,
0.11188855767250061,
-0.5624790787696838,
-1.0439302921295166,
-0.29720795154571533,
-0.4512092173099518,
-0.24417024850845337,
-0.021772896870970726,
0.8131747841835022,
0.4577760696411133,
-0.8194788098335266,
0.05222134292125702,
0.17538928985595703,
0.2773761749267578,
-0.015081237070262432,
-0.30975064635276794,
0.6499853134155273,
-0.42604586482048035,
-0.9505851864814758,
0.5242162942886353,
0.36217325925827026,
-0.10641279816627502,
-0.4869302809238434,
0.06942563503980637,
-0.20638778805732727,
0.23878781497478485,
0.8763232231140137,
0.3511393070220947,
-0.48702341318130493,
-0.5385016202926636,
0.3857412338256836,
-0.09289511293172836,
-0.08415267616510391,
0.6282939910888672,
-0.897373616695404,
0.46676361560821533,
0.19963297247886658,
0.9875437021255493,
0.46831780672073364,
0.1739395409822464,
0.3347339332103729,
-0.7676796913146973,
-0.11974471062421799,
0.45120081305503845,
0.23623791337013245,
0.4804480969905853,
-0.05250570550560951,
0.7492837905883789,
0.3252701461315155,
-0.4222142994403839,
-0.9222983121871948,
0.17481960356235504,
-0.6741948127746582,
-0.47220784425735474,
1.0525681972503662,
-0.39140310883522034,
0.030887030065059662,
-0.15655267238616943,
-0.05027651786804199,
0.04032202810049057,
-0.0035081030800938606,
0.917416512966156,
0.7170615196228027,
0.02625482901930809,
-0.1260240525007248,
-0.6399499773979187,
0.37184739112854004,
0.14451830089092255,
-0.9399169683456421,
-0.1278689056634903,
0.5591530799865723,
0.40894705057144165,
0.28602150082588196,
0.6604891419410706,
0.027688661590218544,
-0.028530467301607132,
-0.09371238201856613,
-0.09407276660203934,
-0.1096821203827858,
-0.34203967452049255,
0.1314535290002823,
0.6119746565818787,
0.16949395835399628,
0.08484592288732529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14290v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14290v1
|
CEV-LM: Controlled Edit Vector Language Model for Shaping Natural Language Generations
| 2024-02-22T05:07:31 | 2024-02-22T05:07:31 |
Samraj Moorjani, Adit Krishnan, Hari Sundaram
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
As large-scale language models become the standard for text generation, there
is a greater need to tailor the generations to be more or less concise,
targeted, and informative, depending on the audience/application. Existing
control approaches primarily adjust the semantic (e.g., emotion, topics),
structural (e.g., syntax tree, parts-of-speech), and lexical (e.g.,
keyword/phrase inclusion) properties of text, but are insufficient to
accomplish complex objectives such as pacing which control the complexity and
readability of the text. In this paper, we introduce CEV-LM - a lightweight,
semi-autoregressive language model that utilizes constrained edit vectors to
control three complementary metrics (speed, volume, and circuitousness) that
quantify the shape of text (e.g., pacing of content). We study an extensive set
of state-of-the-art CTG models and find that CEV-LM provides significantly more
targeted and precise control of these three metrics while preserving semantic
content, using less training data, and containing fewer parameters.
|
[
-0.38213327527046204,
-1.1931906938552856,
0.37908416986465454,
0.2182978242635727,
-0.350565105676651,
0.052836883813142776,
-0.40655824542045593,
-0.26409199833869934,
0.03699558600783348,
0.6401688456535339,
-0.46958816051483154,
-0.5490034222602844,
-0.443380206823349,
0.1624043881893158,
-0.5064938068389893,
0.6843831539154053,
-0.13358692824840546,
-0.24829347431659698,
-0.0991077721118927,
-0.15248432755470276,
-0.5065761208534241,
-0.3410412669181824,
-0.5914450287818909,
-0.31046444177627563,
0.3355393409729004,
0.37479260563850403,
1.1716220378875732,
1.362772822380066,
0.14898747205734253,
0.2907903790473938,
-0.5767636299133301,
0.0675346851348877,
-0.4545299708843231,
0.23757189512252808,
-0.13517387211322784,
-0.3486098647117615,
-0.5404216051101685,
-0.1988973617553711,
0.8284754753112793,
0.5560305118560791,
-0.08103398978710175,
-0.07167961448431015,
0.14184509217739105,
0.8544700145721436,
-0.5444748401641846,
-0.16612975299358368,
-0.546307384967804,
-0.09287353605031967,
-0.19333377480506897,
-0.4299466609954834,
-0.4148982763290405,
-0.46386003494262695,
0.21320542693138123,
-0.4790268540382385,
0.2794533669948578,
0.07902581244707108,
0.6162586212158203,
0.3427388668060303,
-0.49392256140708923,
-0.3484481871128082,
-1.0386004447937012,
0.8554431200027466,
-0.5825300216674805,
0.6192657947540283,
0.11199306696653366,
-0.15348267555236816,
-0.14994581043720245,
-0.6321159601211548,
-0.522922158241272,
-0.3272486627101898,
0.20244179666042328,
0.06335403025150299,
-0.12233743816614151,
0.3840887248516083,
-0.0486050508916378,
0.24762138724327087,
-0.5430700182914734,
0.37401875853538513,
-0.3163539171218872,
-0.34715375304222107,
0.47171565890312195,
0.47456440329551697,
0.43433132767677307,
-0.2587113380432129,
-0.5463830828666687,
0.01650834269821644,
-0.5919795632362366,
0.20757782459259033,
0.4664725363254547,
0.18621236085891724,
-0.0022910796105861664,
0.7358445525169373,
-0.5084507465362549,
0.9958866834640503,
0.12678992748260498,
-0.12387407571077347,
-0.0036019866820424795,
-0.39320966601371765,
-0.2288004755973816,
0.22061020135879517,
0.835159420967102,
0.41703784465789795,
0.17618399858474731,
-0.027320872992277145,
-0.20741665363311768,
0.12385168671607971,
0.22802676260471344,
-0.8005532622337341,
-0.10768630355596542,
0.30665072798728943,
-0.5970032811164856,
-0.40220344066619873,
-0.29377707839012146,
-0.7761524319648743,
-0.24949434399604797,
-0.7402234077453613,
0.21381904184818268,
-0.6430476307868958,
0.06439781188964844,
0.1888090819120407,
-0.07322339713573456,
0.28631722927093506,
0.36646682024002075,
-0.9164630770683289,
0.2994006872177124,
0.4651930332183838,
0.8397573828697205,
-0.5414830446243286,
-0.028483262285590172,
-0.5871143937110901,
0.13505683839321136,
-0.11014392226934433,
0.548681378364563,
-0.9653980731964111,
-0.6966596841812134,
0.1606048196554184,
-0.1995946317911148,
0.09572179615497589,
-0.2102602869272232,
0.6621112823486328,
-0.5697773694992065,
0.27329692244529724,
0.11098768562078476,
-0.7308722734451294,
0.11015583574771881,
0.16954481601715088,
-0.5657913684844971,
1.0768630504608154,
-0.022923868149518967,
-0.7869119048118591,
0.38772276043891907,
-0.2310446947813034,
-0.4254220128059387,
0.021385371685028076,
0.12054198235273361,
-0.5050974488258362,
0.22655925154685974,
0.19054263830184937,
0.38859814405441284,
-0.06476344168186188,
0.09565720707178116,
-0.13197016716003418,
0.015682727098464966,
-0.053772151470184326,
-0.45546960830688477,
0.26104116439819336,
0.2970675826072693,
-0.08133573830127716,
0.3753833770751953,
-0.995448648929596,
0.14743641018867493,
-0.016698770225048065,
-0.5770275592803955,
-0.5295018553733826,
0.24872131645679474,
0.18222321569919586,
0.3902777135372162,
0.3961717486381531,
-0.4913088083267212,
0.26761433482170105,
-0.36661577224731445,
0.5789880752563477,
0.4125952422618866,
0.20356819033622742,
0.8690690398216248,
-0.3998451828956604,
0.6112679243087769,
-0.2671268880367279,
0.32575416564941406,
-0.15077321231365204,
-0.2704114317893982,
-0.9236471056938171,
-0.1389448344707489,
0.19785703718662262,
0.5760549902915955,
-0.7653801441192627,
0.3841991424560547,
-0.11473935097455978,
-0.7685971856117249,
-0.4096510708332062,
0.41540685296058655,
0.2191726267337799,
0.40733203291893005,
0.38983017206192017,
-0.21912062168121338,
-0.23263145983219147,
-0.7255053520202637,
-0.44396480917930603,
-0.012521903030574322,
0.07166426628828049,
0.047242920845746994,
0.09428351372480392,
-0.10151217877864838,
0.9038299322128296,
-0.3162183463573456,
-0.045560456812381744,
-0.4826846122741699,
0.29150092601776123,
-0.3225531578063965,
0.4035913944244385,
0.10608632862567902,
-0.7734805345535278,
-0.31865808367729187,
-0.16634273529052734,
-0.12206824868917465,
-0.5543550848960876,
-0.36037182807922363,
-0.09177912026643753,
-0.041111622005701065,
0.8445501327514648,
-0.3822108209133148,
0.3673138916492462,
0.6265061497688293,
-0.47653084993362427,
0.3618309497833252,
-0.5415005087852478,
-0.11545812338590622,
-0.8774340748786926,
-0.17068226635456085,
0.13441413640975952,
-0.4968418478965759,
-0.8114445805549622,
-0.21946530044078827,
0.4624866545200348,
0.2269447296857834,
-0.7453091144561768,
0.43239063024520874,
-0.40791985392570496,
0.3848402500152588,
-0.5606075525283813,
0.4838973581790924,
0.07158944755792618,
0.3530895709991455,
0.23226721584796906,
0.4605022966861725,
0.231629878282547,
-1.0525490045547485,
0.1995437890291214,
0.3342394530773163,
-0.08796022832393646,
0.5467722415924072,
-0.8434090614318848,
0.07940217852592468,
-0.3926319479942322,
0.013057337142527103,
-0.37298211455345154,
0.039517175406217575,
-0.36167266964912415,
-0.3221457302570343,
0.34679263830184937,
0.0957041010260582,
-0.45837512612342834,
-0.035681549459695816,
-0.183881014585495,
0.2638223469257355,
0.6320359110832214,
-0.24325866997241974,
0.5446705222129822,
0.25606998801231384,
-0.30900058150291443,
-0.1321292221546173,
-0.4029759168624878,
-0.07114923000335693,
-0.2807573974132538,
-0.49100348353385925,
0.6260508894920349,
-0.19096073508262634,
-0.2707218527793884,
-0.04311716929078102,
0.25192517042160034,
0.0539250522851944,
-0.030656499788165092,
0.11659682542085648,
0.3194735050201416,
0.0092230886220932,
0.3210361897945404,
0.13889877498149872,
-0.11688745021820068,
-0.18988190591335297,
-0.31936267018318176,
0.5896862745285034,
0.15485325455665588,
-0.05493151396512985,
-0.4404768645763397,
0.14810772240161896,
0.6422264575958252,
-0.6112046837806702,
0.6003607511520386,
0.3266271948814392,
-0.2380981147289276,
-0.6113272905349731,
-0.27813979983329773,
0.18528346717357635,
-0.4699908494949341,
0.3620030879974365,
0.09036779403686523,
-1.219463586807251,
0.31058835983276367,
-0.13284870982170105,
0.07812351733446121,
0.6409778594970703,
0.9672730565071106,
0.25080540776252747,
1.1033679246902466,
0.8817117810249329,
0.04981756955385208,
0.7245365381240845,
0.14963902533054352,
-0.217134028673172,
-0.7420231103897095,
-0.2578865587711334,
-0.7171403765678406,
-0.2549131512641907,
-0.8241857290267944,
-0.40288376808166504,
0.1966230422258377,
0.20879977941513062,
-0.0796813815832138,
0.2824605405330658,
-0.7019914388656616,
0.2526688575744629,
0.41391345858573914,
-0.1506851464509964,
0.48724856972694397,
-0.6363584995269775,
-0.23910503089427948,
0.009411194361746311,
-0.7867348194122314,
-0.7924743890762329,
0.7922354340553284,
0.45523765683174133,
0.9188351035118103,
-0.19705496728420258,
0.35989248752593994,
0.3430379033088684,
-0.005424038041383028,
-0.7057827115058899,
0.31786271929740906,
-0.18739554286003113,
-0.5524401664733887,
-0.3154248595237732,
-0.3521725535392761,
-0.8863824605941772,
0.1189836710691452,
-0.42483869194984436,
-0.6173115372657776,
0.16287891566753387,
0.5308265089988708,
-0.37320396304130554,
0.36770352721214294,
-0.4719957411289215,
0.7607259750366211,
-0.31543436646461487,
-0.36384469270706177,
0.010322409681975842,
-0.5057320594787598,
0.2030341625213623,
-0.261711061000824,
0.26428213715553284,
-0.20763163268566132,
-0.28431615233421326,
0.5935534834861755,
-0.7050670981407166,
0.6303724050521851,
0.02397659607231617,
0.09708350151777267,
0.641833484172821,
0.30058684945106506,
0.9134308099746704,
-0.025257524102926254,
0.12915080785751343,
-0.24718081951141357,
0.032075878232717514,
-0.3530254065990448,
-0.2661747336387634,
0.676426351070404,
-0.6688918471336365,
-0.23030002415180206,
-0.11500014364719391,
-0.5101290345191956,
-0.14320236444473267,
0.2884962558746338,
0.5668668150901794,
0.5835300087928772,
-0.6236952543258667,
0.3949068784713745,
0.9207391738891602,
-0.5089733004570007,
0.5741187930107117,
0.3875329792499542,
-0.27817586064338684,
-0.28536248207092285,
0.6642184257507324,
0.06439675390720367,
0.8422793745994568,
0.5557501912117004,
0.2783489227294922,
-0.25420597195625305,
-0.7927722334861755,
-0.17747752368450165,
-0.13591241836547852,
-0.4233042895793915,
0.0015138211892917752,
-0.9078870415687561,
-0.08202369511127472,
-0.12425485998392105,
-0.45598843693733215,
-0.48241254687309265,
-0.48505520820617676,
-0.4987870752811432,
-0.006236218381673098,
0.3738374412059784,
0.8502488136291504,
0.17758245766162872,
0.6984177231788635,
-0.8009900450706482,
0.37403231859207153,
0.24134461581707,
0.3563089370727539,
-0.3799265921115875,
-0.6001039743423462,
-0.14646893739700317,
-0.12534767389297485,
-0.39351052045822144,
-0.8451753258705139,
0.6860779523849487,
0.24948136508464813,
0.12184923887252808,
0.08067012578248978,
-0.027863362804055214,
0.20605015754699707,
-0.7089293599128723,
0.8348543047904968,
0.13388487696647644,
-1.0624628067016602,
0.601888120174408,
-0.39318299293518066,
0.7258588075637817,
0.39781081676483154,
-0.20327994227409363,
-0.7539411783218384,
-0.6637686491012573,
-0.5013217926025391,
-0.8047639727592468,
0.3497612476348877,
0.4162706136703491,
0.27469468116760254,
-0.017436658963561058,
0.32724812626838684,
0.06681859493255615,
-0.03155895695090294,
-0.3768894076347351,
-0.1393972486257553,
-0.23285025358200073,
-0.41157039999961853,
0.19304899871349335,
-0.3187128007411957,
0.48810407519340515,
-0.045931730419397354,
0.7277981638908386,
0.07402043044567108,
-0.15536090731620789,
0.4051498472690582,
-0.12178321182727814,
-0.197403222322464,
0.5564462542533875,
0.6882919669151306,
0.4055383503437042,
-0.08231262862682343,
0.12969547510147095,
0.3296642005443573,
-0.7005041837692261,
0.03551214560866356,
0.028751427307724953,
-0.5593240261077881,
0.17002791166305542,
0.25300419330596924,
0.913514256477356,
0.12780499458312988,
-0.4627947509288788,
0.37229815125465393,
-0.11972710490226746,
-0.27476489543914795,
-0.2003406137228012,
0.25848692655563354,
-0.04114576056599617,
0.07360929995775223,
-0.09106519818305969,
-0.07887301594018936,
-0.12234313786029816,
-0.055629029870033264,
0.16253358125686646,
0.29272961616516113,
-0.7295268177986145,
-0.3199136257171631,
1.2060308456420898,
0.3427160978317261,
-0.4115755259990692,
0.3252570629119873,
-0.08311842381954193,
-0.4126289188861847,
0.49820345640182495,
0.3303389251232147,
0.9778565168380737,
-0.1790434867143631,
0.14781488478183746,
0.24896207451820374,
0.638714075088501,
-0.13006654381752014,
0.30372247099876404,
0.13305577635765076,
-0.7412219047546387,
-0.5598976612091064,
-0.7970471978187561,
-0.27261388301849365,
0.18463221192359924,
-0.5544710755348206,
0.5386883616447449,
-0.523338258266449,
-0.2087051123380661,
0.07028554379940033,
-0.2106943428516388,
-0.9901389479637146,
0.4667406976222992,
0.16473817825317383,
1.2489125728607178,
-0.6369944214820862,
1.0663048028945923,
0.4580031931400299,
-0.13683471083641052,
-0.5335776209831238,
-0.2175702005624771,
0.04974199831485748,
-0.48648154735565186,
0.14899589121341705,
-0.17539791762828827,
-0.01661711372435093,
0.20975130796432495,
-0.6834806799888611,
-0.8188990354537964,
1.0590280294418335,
-0.12890249490737915,
-0.7945560812950134,
-0.09639716893434525,
0.1289382427930832,
0.5784667730331421,
-0.2701131999492645,
-0.2627122104167938,
0.6567040085792542,
0.3608277142047882,
0.03168731927871704,
-0.8148837685585022,
-0.26171281933784485,
0.010976517572999,
0.30725347995758057,
0.6197437047958374,
-0.662035346031189,
0.5265592932701111,
-0.03918708860874176,
-0.11173008382320404,
-0.023861516267061234,
0.9942896366119385,
-0.009019946679472923,
0.014455297030508518,
0.4656030237674713,
0.39836883544921875,
0.6633470058441162,
-0.01041434146463871,
1.0961699485778809,
-0.5915815830230713,
0.21386300027370453,
1.0346531867980957,
-0.0062221381813287735,
0.6465690732002258,
0.40934234857559204,
0.18592123687267303,
0.12079020589590073,
0.4621795415878296,
0.2083735466003418,
0.3783085346221924,
0.15665055811405182,
-0.31180813908576965,
-0.31934547424316406,
-0.21252450346946716,
0.06600791215896606,
0.44455453753471375,
0.4197819232940674,
-0.6054339408874512,
-0.025225982069969177,
0.04351748898625374,
0.3584848642349243,
0.4475628137588501,
-0.5266019105911255,
0.6614632606506348,
0.0257694311439991,
-0.45683395862579346,
0.33236223459243774,
0.31981274485588074,
0.5153308510780334,
-0.697023332118988,
0.2941577732563019,
0.06574859470129013,
-0.021204262971878052,
0.010003888048231602,
-0.6176003813743591,
0.23690596222877502,
0.3157850503921509,
-0.16698387265205383,
-0.4474548101425171,
0.8793346881866455,
-0.6372499465942383,
-0.48784148693084717,
0.018560411408543587,
0.5002760887145996,
-0.3256300091743469,
0.15777155756950378,
-0.5484328866004944,
0.31474992632865906,
-0.0036272811703383923,
-0.49399083852767944,
-0.06603877991437912,
0.6853216886520386,
-0.12433016300201416,
0.6077828407287598,
0.39442697167396545,
0.3810378611087799,
0.3840175271034241,
-0.13118870556354523,
0.6781060099601746,
-0.7911418676376343,
-0.49729830026626587,
-0.8875709772109985,
0.6031839847564697,
-0.016366833820939064,
-0.6765514612197876,
0.5352139472961426,
0.3925328850746155,
0.6799871325492859,
0.3319913148880005,
0.9606996774673462,
-0.0182459969073534,
0.38715627789497375,
-0.7780342698097229,
0.5824837684631348,
-0.30285367369651794,
-0.05287866294384003,
-0.1750996857881546,
-1.0945932865142822,
-0.34189727902412415,
-0.047883421182632446,
-0.20348381996154785,
0.03401807323098183,
0.5939245223999023,
0.5186524987220764,
0.21629896759986877,
-0.08939458429813385,
0.4300827980041504,
0.3208911716938019,
0.3697187006473541,
0.45475366711616516,
0.6233862638473511,
0.1080830991268158,
0.550218939781189,
-0.3088752031326294,
-0.17764806747436523,
-0.0896671712398529,
-1.0636752843856812,
-0.8561663627624512,
-0.41266781091690063,
-0.4582749307155609,
-0.2767842710018158,
-0.2075745165348053,
1.01138174533844,
0.39809197187423706,
-0.6534627676010132,
0.20570313930511475,
-0.31474965810775757,
-0.04565137252211571,
0.13330361247062683,
-0.11279274523258209,
0.40179216861724854,
-0.34652450680732727,
-0.8310304880142212,
0.3862168788909912,
0.5271686911582947,
0.14223308861255646,
-0.3365654945373535,
-0.14997057616710663,
0.02989283762872219,
0.5071213841438293,
0.5214325189590454,
0.35181981325149536,
-0.6168060898780823,
-0.3507212996482849,
0.09429021179676056,
-0.5108896493911743,
0.06338754296302795,
0.8698192834854126,
-0.6780802011489868,
1.0579441785812378,
0.7158363461494446,
0.48189181089401245,
0.29055410623550415,
0.11829808354377747,
0.7543137073516846,
-0.6720059514045715,
0.038108885288238525,
0.23934027552604675,
0.2954055070877075,
0.4391610324382782,
-0.32913991808891296,
-0.025444019585847855,
0.14029107987880707,
-0.7988473176956177,
-0.26133936643600464,
0.35495930910110474,
-0.9506635069847107,
-0.15900735557079315,
1.4405056238174438,
0.5554601550102234,
-0.32271111011505127,
-0.16954496502876282,
-0.4781484603881836,
0.6188304424285889,
-0.22559434175491333,
0.4398098587989807,
0.6388853788375854,
0.1161118671298027,
-0.1979970484972,
-0.9161396622657776,
0.8631134629249573,
0.2146044373512268,
-0.6894263625144958,
0.10473532229661942,
0.6108009219169617,
0.193229541182518,
-0.2807483375072479,
0.4486233592033386,
-0.22686803340911865,
-0.06333429366350174,
-0.41999927163124084,
0.39470720291137695,
0.01955605298280716,
-0.17480731010437012,
-0.5479776859283447,
0.11849740892648697,
0.19286799430847168,
0.033366814255714417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14289v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14289v1
|
TinyLLaVA: A Framework of Small-scale Large Multimodal Models
| 2024-02-22T05:05:30 | 2024-02-22T05:05:30 |
Baichuan Zhou, Ying Hu, Xi Weng, Junlong Jia, Jie Luo, Xien Liu, Ji Wu, Lei Huang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
We present the TinyLLaVA framework that provides a unified perspective in
designing and analyzing the small-scale Large Multimodal Models (LMMs). We
empirically study the effects of different vision encoders, connection modules,
language models, training data and training recipes. Our extensive experiments
showed that better quality of data combined with better training recipes,
smaller LMMs can consistently achieve on-par performances compared to bigger
LMMs. Under our framework, we train a family of small-scale LMMs. Our best
model, TinyLLaVA-3.1B, achieves better overall performance against existing 7B
models such as LLaVA-1.5 and Qwen-VL. We hope our findings can serve as
baselines for future research in terms of data scaling, training setups and
model selections. Our model weights and codes will be made public.
|
[
-0.25274336338043213,
-0.6183690428733826,
0.5624805688858032,
0.013447941280901432,
-0.04985426738858223,
-0.47730931639671326,
-0.31818121671676636,
-0.40095749497413635,
0.27690428495407104,
0.27340149879455566,
-0.44030237197875977,
-0.08118337392807007,
-0.37134602665901184,
-0.011541811749339104,
-0.2301948517560959,
0.2961423099040985,
0.3890678286552429,
0.4328567087650299,
-0.15164899826049805,
-0.30441513657569885,
-0.5914925336837769,
-0.023581890389323235,
-0.6453204154968262,
-0.2009393721818924,
0.9513059854507446,
0.7627055048942566,
0.7455033659934998,
0.6431935429573059,
0.5383466482162476,
0.21520157158374786,
-0.08314765244722366,
0.12848526239395142,
-0.37994176149368286,
-0.20070962607860565,
-0.0623006671667099,
-0.7012125849723816,
-0.6410600543022156,
-0.3760504424571991,
0.7792658805847168,
0.7000617384910583,
-0.15524762868881226,
0.560721755027771,
0.08913913369178772,
0.5915340781211853,
-0.628963828086853,
0.20846249163150787,
-0.20021408796310425,
0.1286049336194992,
-0.30739039182662964,
0.23177744448184967,
-0.5466420650482178,
-0.40310144424438477,
-0.19002346694469452,
-0.43833813071250916,
0.14235851168632507,
0.30720338225364685,
0.4475274085998535,
0.31131285429000854,
-0.6601336598396301,
-0.0435967817902565,
-0.6418839693069458,
0.7294589877128601,
-0.5258935689926147,
0.4910345673561096,
0.09516927599906921,
0.6835609674453735,
0.04255543276667595,
-0.7096248269081116,
-0.6087706685066223,
-0.1758015751838684,
0.03865763545036316,
-0.1377948522567749,
-0.3241288363933563,
0.10891249030828476,
0.0894702896475792,
0.30756524205207825,
-0.607511579990387,
0.3871431350708008,
-0.6479409337043762,
0.07277914881706238,
0.5145434737205505,
0.6896509528160095,
0.09297743439674377,
-0.33727338910102844,
-0.023935467004776,
-0.17337369918823242,
-0.9240272045135498,
0.21815821528434753,
0.10201054066419601,
0.5049089193344116,
-0.36162269115448,
0.7019965648651123,
-0.4426403343677521,
0.8755042552947998,
0.19476886093616486,
-0.560386598110199,
0.10321176052093506,
-0.49820783734321594,
-0.7058475613594055,
-0.17609307169914246,
0.7157917022705078,
0.48471328616142273,
-0.1202002763748169,
0.13502223789691925,
-0.04534560814499855,
0.22940269112586975,
0.1726907342672348,
-0.8366493582725525,
-0.3487362265586853,
0.008120170794427395,
-0.9292905926704407,
-0.5459226965904236,
-0.30886274576187134,
-1.0302026271820068,
-0.6909863352775574,
-0.2759566009044647,
0.7794339656829834,
-0.30480578541755676,
-0.42935171723365784,
0.028198210522532463,
0.049179088324308395,
0.21716929972171783,
0.6426041126251221,
-0.9881929159164429,
0.1647627204656601,
0.3448317348957062,
0.8152515292167664,
0.17452947795391083,
-0.1867142915725708,
-0.5269581079483032,
-0.018262458965182304,
-0.4638844132423401,
0.5879823565483093,
-0.47158196568489075,
-0.32567670941352844,
0.0172695592045784,
-0.014331582002341747,
-0.08530407398939133,
-0.5521817803382874,
0.09836860746145248,
-0.30180254578590393,
-0.22149759531021118,
-0.29630526900291443,
-0.22419431805610657,
-0.21793366968631744,
0.25994208455085754,
-0.9990864396095276,
0.5682946443557739,
-0.17975829541683197,
-0.42317283153533936,
0.4494793117046356,
-0.5802162885665894,
0.011444350704550743,
-0.1279703825712204,
-0.3703848123550415,
-0.09153300523757935,
0.5751702189445496,
0.07049857825040817,
0.6052873730659485,
-0.6163344383239746,
-0.2305143177509308,
-0.6838486194610596,
-0.15973317623138428,
0.15740953385829926,
-0.39019516110420227,
0.5012990236282349,
0.25432083010673523,
0.22608159482479095,
0.4012574851512909,
-0.9900303483009338,
-0.004565611481666565,
0.10417957603931427,
-0.3063631057739258,
-0.42788466811180115,
-0.25051531195640564,
0.4696236550807953,
0.27630797028541565,
-0.0332002192735672,
-0.5458208918571472,
0.2579788863658905,
-0.31034642457962036,
0.5128768682479858,
0.7332438230514526,
-0.11254563927650452,
0.8854998350143433,
-0.28448250889778137,
0.6020281910896301,
-0.03907140716910362,
0.6048296689987183,
-0.22708094120025635,
-0.6394525766372681,
-0.8183538317680359,
-0.46990662813186646,
0.44285330176353455,
-0.15262660384178162,
-0.9449365735054016,
-0.23765547573566437,
-0.5862693786621094,
-0.5735480785369873,
-0.5478566288948059,
0.35141515731811523,
0.28457358479499817,
0.17440560460090637,
-0.027526045218110085,
-0.22897639870643616,
-0.4323667585849762,
-1.2652366161346436,
0.3376627266407013,
-0.02053915709257126,
-0.08510987460613251,
0.06744278967380524,
0.682233989238739,
-0.4159964919090271,
1.0123790502548218,
-0.3151271939277649,
-0.5522846579551697,
-0.35436150431632996,
-0.1982385665178299,
-0.13300646841526031,
0.38382282853126526,
0.769164502620697,
-0.9141745567321777,
-0.32701125741004944,
0.11143374443054199,
-0.782918393611908,
0.4463281035423279,
0.14710018038749695,
0.2521313726902008,
-0.12758062779903412,
0.20218650996685028,
-0.4637995660305023,
0.3932322859764099,
0.7110688090324402,
-0.23852600157260895,
0.4336359202861786,
-0.24064688384532928,
0.13002903759479523,
-1.028833270072937,
-0.0912175178527832,
0.04273499175906181,
-0.3272956311702728,
-0.6402075886726379,
0.4016297161579132,
0.4617883861064911,
-0.14585337042808533,
-0.7652451992034912,
0.6272220611572266,
-0.1719622164964676,
-0.2460414618253708,
-0.08862978965044022,
-0.09850005805492401,
0.18864864110946655,
0.3341364860534668,
-0.144514262676239,
0.7734993696212769,
0.38600629568099976,
-0.40484461188316345,
0.6912550926208496,
0.050569452345371246,
-0.5188583135604858,
0.8160467743873596,
-0.7931155562400818,
-0.26120513677597046,
-0.037319108843803406,
0.13259951770305634,
-0.8870607018470764,
-0.5845012664794922,
-0.06609711796045303,
-0.26446983218193054,
0.12194502353668213,
-0.2374941110610962,
-0.8924705386161804,
-0.37577348947525024,
-0.4706670641899109,
0.43771427869796753,
0.435256689786911,
-0.7551977634429932,
0.8701372146606445,
0.4291146695613861,
0.09884005039930344,
0.08646444976329803,
-0.8162798881530762,
-0.04882614314556122,
-0.44048789143562317,
-0.9084945917129517,
-0.23652143776416779,
-0.1540830135345459,
-0.4257899820804596,
-0.15342304110527039,
0.1776837706565857,
-0.31051868200302124,
-0.27805307507514954,
0.6152769327163696,
0.11762594431638718,
-0.4941176474094391,
0.32038718461990356,
-0.19003315269947052,
-0.019225580617785454,
-0.3354259133338928,
-0.13303323090076447,
0.2703978419303894,
-0.44349393248558044,
-0.07611311227083206,
-0.3948215842247009,
0.4040343761444092,
0.6072763800621033,
-0.03531781956553459,
0.8066071271896362,
0.6005715131759644,
-0.44798344373703003,
-0.15199916064739227,
-0.45845821499824524,
-0.09045860171318054,
-0.4874705374240875,
0.1382606476545334,
-0.5958375930786133,
-0.8976110816001892,
0.40314337611198425,
0.0418723002076149,
-0.23755629360675812,
0.4004390239715576,
1.0389379262924194,
-0.4381156265735626,
1.0635179281234741,
1.199792742729187,
0.24040116369724274,
0.43944358825683594,
-0.32240232825279236,
-0.23075850307941437,
-0.8442966341972351,
-0.3545801043510437,
-0.14045241475105286,
-0.2896925210952759,
-0.2721279561519623,
-0.7702025771141052,
0.5916210412979126,
-0.12827527523040771,
-0.06579528748989105,
0.17005106806755066,
-0.11130330711603165,
0.41669735312461853,
0.31471601128578186,
0.06408169120550156,
0.3685089945793152,
-0.12239614874124527,
-0.1833248883485794,
-0.08897659182548523,
-1.179511308670044,
-0.36200690269470215,
1.4186534881591797,
0.4860040843486786,
1.338008165359497,
0.417636513710022,
0.3357435166835785,
0.524056613445282,
0.08553779870271683,
-0.7809030413627625,
0.45422548055648804,
0.026147078722715378,
-0.795418918132782,
-0.1286073625087738,
-0.3176916837692261,
-0.8771749138832092,
0.5819734930992126,
-0.3574083745479584,
-0.7103064060211182,
0.6334385275840759,
0.39186397194862366,
-0.932492196559906,
0.19151322543621063,
-1.0649830102920532,
1.124714970588684,
-0.10585174709558487,
-0.4737836718559265,
-0.3629017472267151,
-0.40777963399887085,
0.7331104874610901,
-0.3229316473007202,
0.4115086793899536,
0.09324482828378677,
-0.1370326429605484,
0.7502913475036621,
-0.2898769676685333,
1.0774621963500977,
0.0024754421319812536,
-0.19033734500408173,
0.17516672611236572,
0.0243055522441864,
0.1677098423242569,
0.2563697099685669,
0.2618107199668884,
0.15153461694717407,
0.25750279426574707,
-0.35633015632629395,
-0.35481446981430054,
0.9534720182418823,
-0.8239433169364929,
0.02514706924557686,
-0.3101060390472412,
-0.3032287657260895,
-0.1246991753578186,
0.16700276732444763,
0.28665897250175476,
0.7296711206436157,
-0.30434542894363403,
0.6177547574043274,
0.829033613204956,
0.016734357923269272,
0.43365478515625,
0.40605899691581726,
-0.6200140714645386,
-0.22779013216495514,
0.8171283602714539,
0.2873721122741699,
0.22469472885131836,
0.34244897961616516,
-0.004570317920297384,
-0.03402169421315193,
-0.3406229317188263,
-0.6527096033096313,
0.08574113249778748,
-0.7548660039901733,
-0.23675186932086945,
-0.28183871507644653,
0.2121744453907013,
-0.26242780685424805,
0.0951649472117424,
-0.9996058344841003,
-0.46166425943374634,
-0.12415079027414322,
0.1501402109861374,
0.10143032670021057,
0.8299838900566101,
-0.21502180397510529,
0.6137906312942505,
-0.6908218860626221,
0.38915443420410156,
0.826870858669281,
0.1466573029756546,
0.16483385860919952,
-0.3565048575401306,
-0.7066587805747986,
0.03541671484708786,
-0.008420952595770359,
-0.45587795972824097,
0.21499581634998322,
0.13678762316703796,
0.20093557238578796,
0.5194266438484192,
-0.23868981003761292,
0.6521735787391663,
-0.7041445970535278,
0.9224178194999695,
0.7169533967971802,
-0.4884136915206909,
0.5901034474372864,
-0.3495471775531769,
0.3610231876373291,
0.4569437801837921,
-0.17800654470920563,
-0.27424249053001404,
0.2088475376367569,
-0.5413293838500977,
-0.40933462977409363,
0.48647448420524597,
0.18571673333644867,
-0.22985178232192993,
0.38047024607658386,
0.07025454938411713,
0.23056922852993011,
0.3155099153518677,
-0.5010713934898376,
-0.014328201301395893,
-0.08722874522209167,
-0.34147369861602783,
-0.32917800545692444,
-0.3235977590084076,
-0.3029184341430664,
-0.26414430141448975,
0.11050111055374146,
-0.31715652346611023,
0.36942562460899353,
-0.283633291721344,
-0.4275566339492798,
-0.22049473226070404,
0.009597734548151493,
0.6668961048126221,
0.6911172866821289,
-0.31045520305633545,
0.1173415258526802,
0.11074325442314148,
-0.38433513045310974,
0.1780349314212799,
-0.3230516016483307,
-0.06893530488014221,
-0.1388382613658905,
0.45967528223991394,
0.7323983907699585,
0.5476411581039429,
-0.7125481367111206,
0.6068918704986572,
-0.5243163108825684,
0.12035498023033142,
-0.3804248571395874,
0.2875804305076599,
0.0770958811044693,
0.7875430583953857,
0.18590541183948517,
0.36868003010749817,
0.10003013908863068,
-0.5939611196517944,
-0.08137831836938858,
0.21140694618225098,
-0.10317052155733109,
-0.579232394695282,
0.7722659111022949,
0.32988640666007996,
-0.01586216688156128,
-0.018163088709115982,
0.13207578659057617,
0.2284490168094635,
0.6836987733840942,
0.14988787472248077,
0.4438580274581909,
-0.014374365098774433,
0.12256018072366714,
0.12848205864429474,
0.5097779631614685,
-0.27169516682624817,
-0.013421504758298397,
-0.07903334498405457,
-0.5234849452972412,
-0.14380064606666565,
-0.8333349823951721,
-0.43197423219680786,
0.04180682823061943,
-0.8842018246650696,
0.07197777926921844,
-0.5141900777816772,
-0.3683547079563141,
0.2536577582359314,
0.030982056632637978,
-1.1732306480407715,
0.3646436333656311,
0.4337286949157715,
1.014412522315979,
-0.8437027931213379,
1.4222877025604248,
0.7799372673034668,
-0.661432147026062,
-0.6798308491706848,
-0.26526856422424316,
0.49388495087623596,
-0.7805320620536804,
0.7497413754463196,
-0.036871537566185,
-0.18018239736557007,
-0.08615109324455261,
-0.3888324499130249,
-0.9464067220687866,
1.3042336702346802,
0.19327247142791748,
-0.7650872468948364,
-0.24547678232192993,
-0.09827456623315811,
0.37908563017845154,
-0.6716573238372803,
-0.07800570130348206,
0.5443181991577148,
0.17626741528511047,
-0.01354216318577528,
-1.0024030208587646,
-0.4203435778617859,
-0.14516127109527588,
0.6187996864318848,
-0.17520491778850555,
-0.9913617968559265,
0.9958593249320984,
-0.16164028644561768,
0.16627848148345947,
0.491630882024765,
0.5873439908027649,
0.01426777709275484,
0.2502572238445282,
0.3274179697036743,
0.39823174476623535,
0.5295645594596863,
-0.014571755193173885,
1.1228948831558228,
0.21803691983222961,
0.4939805269241333,
1.0462539196014404,
-0.11291369795799255,
0.9961985945701599,
0.641521692276001,
-0.18810561299324036,
-0.05548880249261856,
0.6818622350692749,
0.1575077772140503,
0.8017956614494324,
-0.3384931981563568,
0.1611509472131729,
-0.25199761986732483,
0.057194847613573074,
-0.6056725382804871,
0.6011115312576294,
0.3944259285926819,
-0.22521236538887024,
-0.08901359140872955,
0.8066556453704834,
-0.32648247480392456,
-0.21941561996936798,
-0.7627483010292053,
0.4649408459663391,
0.1584751158952713,
0.0435832142829895,
0.43769314885139465,
0.2751680910587311,
0.8289326429367065,
-0.6724200248718262,
0.40221112966537476,
-0.5132722854614258,
0.5992903113365173,
-0.06320050358772278,
-0.544873833656311,
-0.008539056405425072,
0.03640974313020706,
-0.48801594972610474,
0.054745547473430634,
0.7690610289573669,
-0.2433733493089676,
-0.6649193167686462,
0.1613842248916626,
0.4155428111553192,
-0.24018995463848114,
0.0810149535536766,
-0.41153278946876526,
0.5188902020454407,
-0.23419253528118134,
-0.1485254168510437,
0.695172905921936,
0.43288150429725647,
0.19927603006362915,
0.6888390779495239,
0.4113543927669525,
0.12557101249694824,
0.3968070447444916,
0.034786421805620193,
0.745964765548706,
-0.6311752796173096,
-0.6924243569374084,
-0.558357298374176,
0.44610583782196045,
-0.14409607648849487,
-0.1639731228351593,
1.0572410821914673,
0.42975518107414246,
0.6745580434799194,
-0.3976590931415558,
0.4722644090652466,
-0.004254831932485104,
0.18720170855522156,
-0.5935389399528503,
0.6592104434967041,
-1.0880125761032104,
0.046730708330869675,
0.0032689902000129223,
-0.7971079349517822,
-0.3426916003227234,
0.6832204461097717,
-0.19790469110012054,
-0.20604975521564484,
0.48083850741386414,
0.8101075291633606,
-0.3336741030216217,
0.02060234360396862,
0.827802836894989,
0.33794331550598145,
0.20795902609825134,
0.8072455525398254,
0.8816482424736023,
-0.5943825244903564,
0.4055491089820862,
-0.20937423408031464,
-0.1723925620317459,
-0.8121525645256042,
-0.3992510139942169,
-0.8943474292755127,
-0.41829606890678406,
-0.07833627611398697,
-0.0021910585928708315,
-0.1263229101896286,
0.9005062580108643,
0.9171968102455139,
-0.33414706587791443,
-0.32017627358436584,
0.5097599029541016,
-0.07519464939832687,
-0.11834689229726791,
-0.10982006788253784,
0.13816715776920319,
0.1501186043024063,
-0.5532363653182983,
0.43792808055877686,
0.4738634526729584,
-0.14288932085037231,
-0.6241190433502197,
-0.42575883865356445,
0.017297158017754555,
0.24559266865253448,
1.0571225881576538,
0.3591966927051544,
-0.8238235116004944,
-0.5441237092018127,
-0.34228619933128357,
-0.37246137857437134,
0.002449113642796874,
0.5672877430915833,
-0.715174674987793,
0.6781919598579407,
0.19386766850948334,
0.3236411213874817,
0.5476259589195251,
-0.5808883309364319,
0.3021489083766937,
-0.7443958520889282,
0.6899872422218323,
-0.11038270592689514,
0.6141120195388794,
0.23734909296035767,
0.21082675457000732,
0.5940333604812622,
-0.027734773233532906,
-0.3305649161338806,
-1.0153439044952393,
0.12970700860023499,
-1.0862393379211426,
-0.17808958888053894,
1.2356748580932617,
0.16842243075370789,
-0.5343281030654907,
0.35586100816726685,
-0.07972262799739838,
-0.19572566449642181,
-0.1354045420885086,
0.4528782367706299,
0.4506601095199585,
0.08218945562839508,
-0.37319257855415344,
-0.9263431429862976,
0.34946751594543457,
0.070965476334095,
-0.5356903672218323,
-0.20383353531360626,
0.7588726282119751,
0.4359557330608368,
0.21265918016433716,
0.8125867247581482,
0.022376667708158493,
0.5311535596847534,
0.5177949666976929,
-0.12942591309547424,
-0.10779090225696564,
-0.7978988885879517,
-0.7740833759307861,
0.635293185710907,
0.10404831171035767,
-0.31643274426460266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14279v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14279v1
|
Mitigating the Linguistic Gap with Phonemic Representations for Robust Multilingual Language Understanding
| 2024-02-22T04:41:52 | 2024-02-22T04:41:52 |
Haeji Jung, Changdae Oh, Jooeon Kang, Jimin Sohn, Kyungwoo Song, Jinkyu Kim, David R. Mortensen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Approaches to improving multilingual language understanding often require
multiple languages during the training phase, rely on complicated training
techniques, and -- importantly -- struggle with significant performance gaps
between high-resource and low-resource languages. We hypothesize that the
performance gaps between languages are affected by linguistic gaps between
those languages and provide a novel solution for robust multilingual language
modeling by employing phonemic representations (specifically, using phonemes as
input tokens to LMs rather than subwords). We present quantitative evidence
from three cross-lingual tasks that demonstrate the effectiveness of phonemic
representation, which is further justified by a theoretical analysis of the
cross-lingual performance gap.
|
[
-0.41711610555648804,
-0.4800666272640228,
0.39389103651046753,
0.1669517159461975,
-0.2680967450141907,
0.4028240442276001,
-0.3669065535068512,
-0.46373501420021057,
0.1424935758113861,
0.12606164813041687,
-0.4334232807159424,
-0.27440834045410156,
-0.5774308443069458,
0.05820794776082039,
0.23270593583583832,
0.34812819957733154,
-0.04952504113316536,
0.4227065145969391,
-0.2503131926059723,
-0.42009133100509644,
-0.670655369758606,
-0.8153485059738159,
-0.44659221172332764,
-0.7199956774711609,
0.4955294728279114,
0.6057096123695374,
0.9346364140510559,
0.5844171047210693,
0.43066275119781494,
0.24458454549312592,
-0.06832998245954514,
-0.03955058753490448,
-0.24840742349624634,
0.198030024766922,
0.04401272535324097,
-0.7610374093055725,
-0.29594019055366516,
-0.031560298055410385,
0.9878470301628113,
1.2413080930709839,
-0.14835117757320404,
-0.1175975427031517,
0.07561145722866058,
0.38890278339385986,
-0.5420581102371216,
0.21519304811954498,
-0.5317828059196472,
0.4395119249820709,
-0.3608878552913666,
-0.18141815066337585,
-0.31025123596191406,
0.11839999258518219,
-0.04690294340252876,
-0.6498748660087585,
0.1231609508395195,
-0.17590752243995667,
0.5963810086250305,
0.0655488520860672,
-0.32823941111564636,
-0.1536978930234909,
-0.48049262166023254,
0.8385835886001587,
-0.6798907518386841,
0.9797393679618835,
0.6445069313049316,
0.045568231493234634,
0.1251058280467987,
-0.07707913964986801,
-0.2186197191476822,
-0.06441550701856613,
-0.03827548399567604,
0.14881907403469086,
0.11629950255155563,
0.012668468058109283,
0.35037630796432495,
0.19841693341732025,
-0.5916644930839539,
0.427978515625,
-0.23895633220672607,
-0.5162448883056641,
0.26193979382514954,
0.11606135219335556,
0.38753530383110046,
-0.0353667289018631,
-0.3791641891002655,
-0.04037550091743469,
-0.6425305008888245,
0.38908666372299194,
0.44572797417640686,
0.5252984166145325,
-0.059250570833683014,
0.36638757586479187,
0.11060477793216705,
0.6174709796905518,
-0.3347806930541992,
-0.227473646402359,
0.3138616383075714,
-0.6018998622894287,
0.08324700593948364,
0.07265089452266693,
0.4916548430919647,
0.06278841197490692,
0.40776339173316956,
-0.29708343744277954,
-0.12132573127746582,
0.3095434010028839,
-0.1629887819290161,
-0.7395457625389099,
0.0788533091545105,
0.11627545952796936,
-0.423397034406662,
-0.013437388464808464,
-0.129505917429924,
-0.661358654499054,
-0.3419840335845947,
-0.0715755745768547,
-0.10477027297019958,
-0.43595877289772034,
-0.7020910978317261,
0.2814038395881653,
-0.005649111233651638,
0.16381439566612244,
0.14614175260066986,
-0.9875361919403076,
0.49751996994018555,
0.22003628313541412,
0.9048829078674316,
0.051075417548418045,
-0.5624964237213135,
-0.6190711855888367,
0.03386874124407768,
-0.5132679343223572,
0.5622884035110474,
-0.7658383846282959,
-0.621956467628479,
0.18064801394939423,
-0.15000317990779877,
-0.5008248686790466,
-0.6647548675537109,
0.09325399994850159,
-0.4898727834224701,
0.1638346165418625,
-0.10355011373758316,
-0.5137209296226501,
-0.17196251451969147,
0.13614308834075928,
-0.9454435110092163,
1.057428002357483,
-0.15298715233802795,
-0.5678077340126038,
0.19613781571388245,
-0.606300950050354,
-0.3748199939727783,
-0.09081964194774628,
-0.11957791447639465,
-0.1950160413980484,
0.15561725199222565,
0.33683499693870544,
0.35838714241981506,
0.04517360404133797,
-0.07698668539524078,
-0.22046399116516113,
-0.41571199893951416,
0.3465425670146942,
-0.27424880862236023,
0.7477630376815796,
0.06200312823057175,
-0.13629388809204102,
-0.16624362766742706,
-0.7470913529396057,
0.09930454194545746,
0.1922350376844406,
-0.45797738432884216,
-0.5873329639434814,
-0.22536803781986237,
0.08218324929475784,
0.3678174912929535,
0.36610016226768494,
-0.3950183391571045,
0.056958749890327454,
-0.4024595022201538,
0.1994062215089798,
0.38170066475868225,
-0.45490026473999023,
0.7659637928009033,
-0.04073088616132736,
0.9118149876594543,
0.48931214213371277,
-0.1823110580444336,
-0.713715136051178,
-0.4409489631652832,
-0.5667705535888672,
-0.016243362799286842,
0.566994845867157,
0.6530321836471558,
-0.7245750427246094,
-0.09954625368118286,
-0.032753363251686096,
-0.03814302384853363,
-0.49384090304374695,
0.45681020617485046,
0.44608405232429504,
0.002062740735709667,
0.18724186718463898,
-0.7605175375938416,
-0.36650264263153076,
-0.7394857406616211,
-0.46401917934417725,
-0.3114728033542633,
0.18586555123329163,
-0.1179165318608284,
0.19396182894706726,
0.010334990918636322,
0.653827965259552,
-0.015366450883448124,
-0.1020592525601387,
-0.4380894899368286,
0.12209265679121017,
0.02416047640144825,
0.4866553544998169,
0.5409561395645142,
-0.6841529607772827,
-0.07813378423452377,
0.08115284889936447,
-0.4416911005973816,
-0.1375744640827179,
-0.21217557787895203,
0.2236582338809967,
0.1383863389492035,
0.7595371603965759,
-0.3816094696521759,
0.3406003713607788,
0.7711570262908936,
-0.3424394130706787,
0.3962603509426117,
-0.1527915596961975,
0.06232062354683876,
-0.8955668210983276,
-0.11015050113201141,
0.09869342297315598,
-0.45627671480178833,
-0.8578623533248901,
0.0006136755691841245,
0.20935042202472687,
-0.401917040348053,
-0.34631648659706116,
0.37435105443000793,
-0.7909805178642273,
-0.2454630434513092,
-0.04472701996564865,
0.3863750100135803,
0.008341026492416859,
0.6931102871894836,
0.12631338834762573,
0.6930745840072632,
0.6738380193710327,
-0.2488555610179901,
0.015580926090478897,
-0.09212122857570648,
-0.20376640558242798,
0.5893105268478394,
-0.461082398891449,
0.18367183208465576,
-0.11458666622638702,
0.05853772535920143,
-0.9414678812026978,
-0.11642531305551529,
0.36235833168029785,
-0.4150112569332123,
0.36181876063346863,
-0.2931390106678009,
-0.4582184851169586,
0.153029665350914,
-0.21909429132938385,
0.9170231223106384,
0.16124987602233887,
-0.2751709222793579,
0.47712916135787964,
0.38667356967926025,
-0.20364442467689514,
-0.514170229434967,
-0.9145216345787048,
0.07144082337617874,
-0.2348375767469406,
-0.6686122417449951,
0.24194279313087463,
0.14542849361896515,
-0.299655556678772,
-0.14038538932800293,
-0.15474164485931396,
-0.33395931124687195,
0.1679380238056183,
-0.01274032611399889,
-0.03206463158130646,
-0.32199564576148987,
0.35128530859947205,
-0.27773311734199524,
-0.1660844385623932,
0.08481856435537338,
-0.18267981708049774,
0.6537603139877319,
-0.15018457174301147,
-0.6581119894981384,
-0.4127439260482788,
0.6958918571472168,
0.625568151473999,
-0.5388852953910828,
0.4932551383972168,
0.7336346507072449,
-0.579053521156311,
-0.10509001463651657,
-0.31201666593551636,
-0.11911363154649734,
-0.4091752767562866,
0.4319831132888794,
-0.6040130853652954,
-0.7803207039833069,
0.9776841402053833,
-0.20389960706233978,
-0.11659393459558487,
0.23615901172161102,
0.46199798583984375,
0.056976184248924255,
0.9896239042282104,
0.7146352529525757,
-0.020880021154880524,
0.8289692997932434,
-0.12475044280290604,
0.08518412709236145,
-0.4696941375732422,
-0.31234756112098694,
-0.5796667337417603,
-0.08686596900224686,
-0.4070357382297516,
-0.6824043393135071,
0.2503785192966461,
0.3206787705421448,
0.052340615540742874,
0.22292925417423248,
0.14302724599838257,
0.40636125206947327,
0.40213361382484436,
-0.13397884368896484,
0.3588229715824127,
0.18977907299995422,
-0.6149493455886841,
-0.2519592344760895,
-1.24815833568573,
-0.4389140009880066,
0.5378428101539612,
0.5644457936286926,
0.8149062395095825,
0.16841009259223938,
0.732709527015686,
-0.0636160746216774,
-0.22965264320373535,
-0.9303291440010071,
0.4284217357635498,
0.12398289889097214,
-0.40545037388801575,
-0.20719771087169647,
-0.4553283452987671,
-1.137292504310608,
0.7147526144981384,
0.08598466962575912,
-0.8072076439857483,
0.35366469621658325,
-0.07393205165863037,
-0.18317779898643494,
0.3210934102535248,
-0.8975664973258972,
0.9973246455192566,
-0.14666222035884857,
-0.19634424149990082,
-0.5300910472869873,
-0.5588365197181702,
0.0730869323015213,
-0.00206772075034678,
0.6840441226959229,
-0.11102244257926941,
-0.2587808668613434,
0.7282306551933289,
-0.3745777904987335,
1.0469626188278198,
-0.23461532592773438,
-0.3363485038280487,
0.06638476252555847,
0.11202003061771393,
0.1682615578174591,
0.018146568909287453,
-0.09436212480068207,
0.44993191957473755,
-0.015598434023559093,
-0.7786629796028137,
-0.5320888161659241,
0.4553127884864807,
-0.4899432361125946,
-0.4757207930088043,
-0.5072807669639587,
-0.7229264974594116,
-0.5587143898010254,
0.09478238224983215,
0.13015486299991608,
0.5922752022743225,
-0.17304641008377075,
-0.24725548923015594,
0.6145050525665283,
-0.08916552364826202,
0.6724097728729248,
0.0800703763961792,
-0.3046098053455353,
-0.2328445315361023,
0.732071042060852,
0.29235899448394775,
0.44161874055862427,
0.17428350448608398,
0.007607793901115656,
-0.3672848641872406,
-0.5763881206512451,
-0.663436770439148,
0.27643322944641113,
-0.8751673698425293,
0.07541126757860184,
-0.16135452687740326,
0.1565743088722229,
-0.20019319653511047,
0.15424750745296478,
-0.31947606801986694,
-0.5807700753211975,
-0.2785853147506714,
0.25744032859802246,
-0.009335669688880444,
0.8129540681838989,
-0.36953485012054443,
0.30832481384277344,
-0.9155634045600891,
0.17346826195716858,
0.05676737427711487,
0.601462185382843,
0.15023332834243774,
-0.4643741250038147,
-0.9299752712249756,
0.19383323192596436,
-0.14466065168380737,
-1.0829432010650635,
0.04280860722064972,
0.3164879083633423,
0.7582114934921265,
0.22752584517002106,
-0.46679970622062683,
0.9447227716445923,
-0.4943821430206299,
0.746872067451477,
0.5054064393043518,
-1.1256603002548218,
0.44328469038009644,
-0.2960416078567505,
0.6989488005638123,
0.23655982315540314,
0.2256479412317276,
-0.8433685302734375,
-0.41283634305000305,
-0.516209602355957,
-0.7760732173919678,
0.7676641345024109,
0.30225154757499695,
-0.021366406232118607,
0.29916441440582275,
0.016248641535639763,
0.06729105114936829,
-0.039692118763923645,
-0.7070741653442383,
-0.041774727404117584,
-0.2831436097621918,
0.06888341903686523,
-0.06521449238061905,
-0.05113571137189865,
-0.03447050228714943,
-0.07418815791606903,
0.29102614521980286,
-0.17863483726978302,
0.2744278609752655,
0.12874720990657806,
-0.4240354299545288,
-0.12440548837184906,
0.25778332352638245,
0.5680950284004211,
0.7103843688964844,
0.23065628111362457,
0.37837904691696167,
0.326423704624176,
-0.5923049449920654,
0.16972798109054565,
0.23117859661579132,
0.6224332451820374,
0.39963552355766296,
0.6948909759521484,
0.6303683519363403,
0.3140662908554077,
-0.4642985165119171,
0.17452585697174072,
-0.06039233133196831,
0.04469591751694679,
0.19159168004989624,
-0.2546984851360321,
0.3085666000843048,
0.2165071815252304,
0.3366451561450958,
0.19575144350528717,
-0.14493077993392944,
-0.6314272284507751,
0.07927468419075012,
0.19802914559841156,
-0.20916058123111725,
-0.4735364615917206,
0.3961631655693054,
0.13186663389205933,
-0.2531678378582001,
0.2542712688446045,
-0.02558910846710205,
-0.7374411225318909,
0.6270841360092163,
0.43365827202796936,
0.47640374302864075,
-0.533659040927887,
0.13185372948646545,
0.13539662957191467,
0.28823134303092957,
-0.007469590287655592,
0.4460720419883728,
-0.2729741036891937,
-0.7839237451553345,
-0.6018799543380737,
-0.15499453246593475,
-0.5121662020683289,
-0.17775432765483856,
-0.7422186136245728,
-0.03236628696322441,
-0.21964477002620697,
-0.21418923139572144,
0.08363804221153259,
-0.09926936030387878,
-0.7983179688453674,
0.06831943243741989,
0.3837027847766876,
0.8196252584457397,
-0.7381435632705688,
0.9021630883216858,
0.8442283868789673,
-0.40714243054389954,
-0.8142656087875366,
0.12272017449140549,
-0.13212023675441742,
-0.9003356099128723,
0.5990766286849976,
0.0890827551484108,
-0.4507070779800415,
-0.3412551283836365,
-0.03104945458471775,
-0.6315811276435852,
0.40577906370162964,
0.6223083138465881,
-0.6518086791038513,
0.11431817710399628,
0.6721677780151367,
0.3870217800140381,
-0.35638710856437683,
0.08155839890241623,
0.32420894503593445,
0.34139278531074524,
-0.33410531282424927,
-1.1434242725372314,
-0.06941866129636765,
-0.36932769417762756,
0.20513130724430084,
0.22077353298664093,
-0.47326481342315674,
0.6808383464813232,
-0.14587675034999847,
-0.38577166199684143,
-0.13510119915008545,
0.3241710662841797,
0.06973635405302048,
0.24435225129127502,
0.7000837326049805,
0.40295058488845825,
0.8998655080795288,
-0.16768208146095276,
0.8307095766067505,
-0.37216341495513916,
0.39870887994766235,
0.7378823757171631,
-0.022937534376978874,
0.5871030688285828,
0.6486659646034241,
-0.1242072731256485,
0.47676369547843933,
0.9171193838119507,
0.5357905030250549,
0.4202910363674164,
0.14210668206214905,
-0.2697392702102661,
-0.6203945875167847,
-0.21009980142116547,
-0.5514519810676575,
0.6545635461807251,
0.6280124187469482,
-0.08777187019586563,
-0.36273619532585144,
0.09136400371789932,
0.11396005004644394,
0.2019956409931183,
-0.37909066677093506,
0.559013843536377,
0.13961048424243927,
-0.5155145525932312,
1.0616744756698608,
-0.09875921905040741,
0.6363351941108704,
-0.47955322265625,
-0.06321945786476135,
-0.3969394862651825,
-0.04310889169573784,
-0.28635162115097046,
-0.6641677021980286,
0.23357105255126953,
-0.1505631059408188,
-0.015973027795553207,
-0.5328324437141418,
0.82902592420578,
-0.830212414264679,
-0.3736259639263153,
0.48408716917037964,
0.9861413240432739,
0.31891605257987976,
0.3178789019584656,
-0.6468024849891663,
0.34444913268089294,
-0.2841739058494568,
-0.09424882382154465,
0.1529117077589035,
0.6770164370536804,
-0.07230272144079208,
0.3625711500644684,
0.4965483546257019,
0.12717990577220917,
0.18398775160312653,
0.5073252320289612,
0.7402885556221008,
-0.8093195557594299,
-0.6882796883583069,
-0.8526933789253235,
0.2803013324737549,
0.026845499873161316,
-0.34451472759246826,
0.5384494066238403,
0.4453170597553253,
1.0147697925567627,
0.10464426875114441,
0.7880553007125854,
0.2760077118873596,
0.11357235908508301,
-0.669343113899231,
0.45957261323928833,
-0.7177740931510925,
0.25039204955101013,
-0.13482604920864105,
-0.709334135055542,
-0.6094359159469604,
0.787706196308136,
-0.10951286554336548,
0.01196028757840395,
0.7531194090843201,
0.699640154838562,
-0.17954641580581665,
0.02250766009092331,
0.5588647723197937,
-0.06836317479610443,
0.029006799682974815,
0.7913834452629089,
1.0543643236160278,
-0.31932181119918823,
0.6400935649871826,
-0.10550418496131897,
-0.05286324396729469,
-0.0898883044719696,
-0.6076835989952087,
-0.9619610905647278,
-0.5698862671852112,
-0.12979377806186676,
-0.28641653060913086,
0.033030491322278976,
0.7324230670928955,
0.770901620388031,
-0.6749274730682373,
-0.7298457622528076,
0.18985456228256226,
0.4062511622905731,
-0.4234442114830017,
-0.07232704013586044,
0.19872769713401794,
-0.7710835933685303,
-0.8541404604911804,
0.47756826877593994,
0.1455802321434021,
0.12417466193437576,
-0.6674599647521973,
-0.17923682928085327,
-0.1230996698141098,
-0.0904259905219078,
0.4749943017959595,
0.21937373280525208,
-0.7069911956787109,
0.00636789295822382,
0.2859272062778473,
-0.16983383893966675,
0.42925772070884705,
1.2473469972610474,
-0.7473483085632324,
0.4773113429546356,
0.40326157212257385,
0.6796308159828186,
0.4900624454021454,
-0.5309986472129822,
0.7424062490463257,
-0.8670953512191772,
0.4751734733581543,
0.1451287567615509,
0.6910759210586548,
0.6992021203041077,
-0.12125136703252792,
0.35668012499809265,
0.36892667412757874,
-0.13535238802433014,
-0.6955517530441284,
0.4691065847873688,
-0.9110829830169678,
-0.350412517786026,
1.0781551599502563,
-0.23163697123527527,
-0.003671280574053526,
-0.41650739312171936,
-0.0823102816939354,
0.31600695848464966,
-0.36071404814720154,
0.4058211147785187,
1.0570749044418335,
-0.04349592700600624,
-0.17220726609230042,
-0.5260228514671326,
0.2676409184932709,
0.8115503787994385,
-0.5342727899551392,
0.124770388007164,
0.2851388454437256,
0.1217346042394638,
0.33632031083106995,
0.5510439276695251,
-0.16978898644447327,
0.33775565028190613,
0.15269282460212708,
-0.053894855082035065,
0.18056347966194153,
-0.249357208609581,
-0.5934945940971375,
0.1341981738805771,
0.15307968854904175,
-0.47514835000038147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14277v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14277v1
|
GATE X-E : A Challenge Set for Gender-Fair Translations from Weakly-Gendered Languages
| 2024-02-22T04:36:14 | 2024-02-22T04:36:14 |
Spencer Rarrick, Ranjita Naik, Sundar Poudel, Vishal Chowdhary
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) continues to improve in quality and
adoption, yet the inadvertent perpetuation of gender bias remains a significant
concern. Despite numerous studies on gender bias in translations into English
from weakly gendered-languages, there are no benchmarks for evaluating this
phenomenon or for assessing mitigation strategies. To address this gap, we
introduce GATE X-E, an extension to the GATE (Rarrick et al., 2023) corpus,
that consists of human translations from Turkish, Hungarian, Finnish, and
Persian into English. Each translation is accompanied by feminine, masculine,
and neutral variants. The dataset, which contains between 1250 and 1850
instances for each of the four language pairs, features natural sentences with
a wide range of sentence lengths and domains, challenging translation rewriters
on various linguistic phenomena. Additionally, we present a translation gender
rewriting solution built with GPT-4 and use GATE X-E to evaluate it. We open
source our contributions to encourage further research on gender debiasing.
|
[
-0.13923262059688568,
-0.3135378658771515,
0.5884832143783569,
0.017826635390520096,
0.21048367023468018,
0.04149547591805458,
0.0072144619189202785,
-0.3019862174987793,
-0.2757420539855957,
0.35922130942344666,
-0.9185447692871094,
-0.4458095133304596,
-0.6848329305648804,
0.46185067296028137,
-0.6312690377235413,
1.0437555313110352,
-0.2587687075138092,
0.3805452585220337,
0.28907445073127747,
0.2063218355178833,
-0.6078230142593384,
-0.30020979046821594,
-0.5776717066764832,
-0.24270237982273102,
0.3586350083351135,
0.18315187096595764,
0.7646355032920837,
0.5507224798202515,
0.2625860571861267,
0.3066936135292053,
-0.0385345034301281,
-0.10939031839370728,
-0.24419662356376648,
0.045058753341436386,
-0.47459450364112854,
-0.6156628131866455,
-0.7640669941902161,
0.18719638884067535,
0.7826139330863953,
0.8054076433181763,
-0.007126838434487581,
0.15166063606739044,
0.07482700794935226,
0.7092388272285461,
-0.42984825372695923,
0.1532043069601059,
-0.7537079453468323,
0.2576979100704193,
-0.2283286452293396,
0.3510649502277374,
-0.1263318657875061,
-0.14648903906345367,
0.0825469121336937,
-0.5254085063934326,
0.375531405210495,
0.37842997908592224,
0.9382344484329224,
0.11263647675514221,
-0.6059486269950867,
0.05741804465651512,
-0.5233888626098633,
1.1318308115005493,
-0.3687882125377655,
0.7418421506881714,
0.377863347530365,
0.32702386379241943,
-0.36077290773391724,
-0.35843145847320557,
-0.4538343548774719,
-0.074702687561512,
0.04194040969014168,
-0.10528761148452759,
-0.6884549260139465,
-0.05288979411125183,
0.12484308332204819,
0.2779122292995453,
-0.45928311347961426,
-0.33258265256881714,
-0.3048854470252991,
-0.07447705417871475,
0.41662508249282837,
-0.014835349284112453,
0.7128484845161438,
-0.16787771880626678,
-0.17083626985549927,
-0.07764379680156708,
-0.7509016990661621,
-0.23002228140830994,
0.8397446870803833,
0.36098167300224304,
0.07786041498184204,
0.3641154170036316,
-0.14739257097244263,
0.13487508893013,
0.18149152398109436,
0.37116843461990356,
0.6208333969116211,
-0.3156823217868805,
-0.01787937432527542,
0.04138864949345589,
0.642596423625946,
0.5447047352790833,
-0.04194418340921402,
-0.26069405674934387,
-0.46874305605888367,
0.08819674700498581,
0.3713330626487732,
-0.5846355557441711,
0.3636448383331299,
-0.06887101382017136,
-0.4092572331428528,
-0.31514760851860046,
-0.12077227979898453,
-0.728685200214386,
-0.31943389773368835,
-0.15059736371040344,
0.2852163016796112,
-0.16546040773391724,
-0.3978150188922882,
0.3085625469684601,
-0.38043007254600525,
0.341449111700058,
0.3785720765590668,
-0.8573406934738159,
0.4684293270111084,
0.7399076223373413,
0.5686348676681519,
0.025782300159335136,
-0.2847133278846741,
-0.3959328830242157,
-0.0896991640329361,
-0.42886635661125183,
0.17064177989959717,
-0.34105661511421204,
-0.3270724415779114,
-0.1863682121038437,
0.28200677037239075,
0.11996735632419586,
-0.28161224722862244,
1.0296833515167236,
-0.24104180932044983,
0.24221058189868927,
-0.603330671787262,
-0.04818907380104065,
-0.2073046714067459,
0.2927332818508148,
-0.6407890915870667,
0.5161139369010925,
0.2396051585674286,
-0.6970708966255188,
0.4044664204120636,
-0.3552676737308502,
-0.31745538115501404,
-0.32683825492858887,
-0.5988717079162598,
-0.47851282358169556,
0.3612413704395294,
0.26432132720947266,
-0.06410317867994308,
-0.6024584174156189,
0.3108292818069458,
-0.047473303973674774,
-0.2646390199661255,
-0.052534233778715134,
-0.678071141242981,
0.654512882232666,
0.14961878955364227,
-0.9058758020401001,
-0.011140395887196064,
-0.45490267872810364,
-0.09499230235815048,
0.08527150750160217,
0.2778899371623993,
-0.20815148949623108,
0.007901657372713089,
-0.05943196266889572,
0.5134267210960388,
-0.02931816503405571,
-0.8782204389572144,
-0.14828141033649445,
-0.46579933166503906,
0.5456061363220215,
0.7783561944961548,
-0.540854275226593,
0.7699582576751709,
-0.3290712535381317,
0.7106496095657349,
-0.006064468529075384,
0.15046128630638123,
0.21077081561088562,
-0.7004398703575134,
-0.5222245454788208,
-0.03159398213028908,
0.17354506254196167,
0.6137299537658691,
-0.770178496837616,
0.11832499504089355,
-0.3743056654930115,
-0.09694366902112961,
-0.9005371928215027,
0.23640307784080505,
0.7064793705940247,
0.49669694900512695,
0.3038206994533539,
-0.031337086111307144,
-0.4044516086578369,
-1.3689199686050415,
-0.4837440848350525,
-0.23902831971645355,
-0.015267429873347282,
0.20627225935459137,
0.6030783653259277,
-0.2691590487957001,
0.6906792521476746,
-0.11959497630596161,
-0.4151950776576996,
-0.1668580025434494,
0.13169708847999573,
0.2769539952278137,
0.5628076791763306,
0.49091199040412903,
-0.6305234432220459,
-0.12724611163139343,
0.27843350172042847,
-0.6290267109870911,
-0.4358392059803009,
-0.014281698502600193,
-0.5022717118263245,
0.21726468205451965,
0.37393584847450256,
-0.44867441058158875,
0.4546709656715393,
0.6215924620628357,
-0.6859275698661804,
0.4194676876068115,
0.0029295191634446383,
0.6485248804092407,
-0.71285080909729,
-0.030334973707795143,
-0.17933684587478638,
-0.5248784422874451,
-0.3859993517398834,
0.21427151560783386,
0.11056802421808243,
0.07458314299583435,
-0.6670656204223633,
0.527917206287384,
-0.5246360898017883,
-0.008095265366137028,
-0.2875045835971832,
0.10146328806877136,
0.07024989277124405,
0.18939130008220673,
-0.14725202322006226,
0.8007450103759766,
0.14218904078006744,
-0.12334691733121872,
-0.1365458369255066,
0.5563898086547852,
0.01393856294453144,
0.7532045245170593,
-0.582992434501648,
0.2439340502023697,
-0.36534786224365234,
0.15620504319667816,
-0.5472452640533447,
0.31181731820106506,
0.5585691332817078,
-0.5134990811347961,
0.3300977051258087,
-0.3039628863334656,
-0.12095726281404495,
-0.16634094715118408,
-0.6692159175872803,
0.5354451537132263,
0.5788619518280029,
-0.39219263195991516,
0.34840551018714905,
0.15536843240261078,
-0.08856301009654999,
-0.9296936392784119,
-0.8937214612960815,
0.41873323917388916,
0.05263246223330498,
-0.6984729766845703,
0.5116763114929199,
0.22014090418815613,
-0.32862424850463867,
0.20580057799816132,
-0.1553259789943695,
0.17116695642471313,
0.11867398023605347,
0.1064772829413414,
-0.007917718961834908,
-0.11521454155445099,
-0.15044251084327698,
0.5719972848892212,
-0.23006081581115723,
0.3097042739391327,
-0.5950690507888794,
0.24408797919750214,
-0.34113985300064087,
-0.3256034255027771,
-0.16744863986968994,
0.7988684773445129,
0.3735886514186859,
-0.01665547490119934,
0.4592498540878296,
0.6310603618621826,
-0.6933131814002991,
-0.31376221776008606,
-0.2277558594942093,
-0.19776394963264465,
-0.4425259828567505,
0.576046347618103,
-0.8369378447532654,
-0.9686384797096252,
0.3409474492073059,
0.34437280893325806,
0.1797092705965042,
0.5877798795700073,
0.42866870760917664,
0.032348960638046265,
1.4469726085662842,
0.5630525350570679,
-0.07321067154407501,
0.08150641620159149,
0.161758154630661,
0.08141335844993591,
-0.7826910614967346,
0.17690777778625488,
-0.6909504532814026,
-0.5492837429046631,
-0.8832921385765076,
-0.39185231924057007,
-0.015618113800883293,
-0.17739270627498627,
-0.3391106426715851,
0.49998921155929565,
-0.31090080738067627,
0.3295900821685791,
0.5863890051841736,
0.04516877606511116,
0.40744253993034363,
-0.017625708132982254,
0.13923999667167664,
-0.4616812765598297,
-0.41210412979125977,
-0.6906439661979675,
1.0815664529800415,
0.5097203850746155,
0.631834864616394,
0.45212894678115845,
0.5719788670539856,
0.6201053261756897,
0.1439944952726364,
-0.17147278785705566,
0.4569699764251709,
-0.45416921377182007,
-0.9825984239578247,
0.007453472353518009,
-0.694326639175415,
-1.1325366497039795,
0.30410149693489075,
-0.13831058144569397,
-0.6425948143005371,
0.3551376760005951,
0.04317851364612579,
0.004396536853164434,
0.5285059213638306,
-0.6015527248382568,
0.9652900099754333,
-0.33822396397590637,
-0.6546492576599121,
-0.044043783098459244,
-0.476486474275589,
0.6530460119247437,
-0.20158828794956207,
0.1999800056219101,
-0.17745882272720337,
-0.2940244674682617,
0.3537117540836334,
-0.4640899896621704,
0.7023183703422546,
0.027256106957793236,
-0.5158341526985168,
-0.12095484882593155,
0.2079237848520279,
0.22646181285381317,
0.10917090624570847,
-0.04444725811481476,
0.5131559371948242,
-0.04924430698156357,
-0.5603398680686951,
-0.5421885848045349,
0.7997353672981262,
-1.0580897331237793,
-0.8560062646865845,
-0.5781441926956177,
-0.44183358550071716,
0.019190713763237,
0.27066096663475037,
0.24105744063854218,
-0.0355675145983696,
-0.3029451370239258,
-0.24668821692466736,
0.4777008891105652,
-0.5403642654418945,
-0.0028520766645669937,
0.2183721512556076,
-0.6162328720092773,
-0.3628818094730377,
0.8091490268707275,
0.06983646005392075,
0.16160976886749268,
0.3988867402076721,
0.1250450760126114,
-0.4322458803653717,
-0.3100510835647583,
-0.9997286200523376,
0.06977859884500504,
-0.5698421001434326,
-0.006944150663912296,
-0.8082346320152283,
0.05477423593401909,
-0.461993545293808,
-0.2458290308713913,
-0.47344106435775757,
-0.4539259076118469,
0.15004192292690277,
-0.04798403009772301,
0.03198638930916786,
0.5913031697273254,
0.0775735154747963,
0.30161410570144653,
-0.7092657089233398,
0.4834117889404297,
0.20927801728248596,
0.1897468864917755,
-0.37645915150642395,
-0.6721839308738708,
0.2781268358230591,
0.05971452221274376,
-0.18666201829910278,
-1.1038564443588257,
0.4184662997722626,
0.027182213962078094,
0.5680023431777954,
0.0074413544498384,
-0.07829023897647858,
0.1347852200269699,
-0.8131691813468933,
0.6326178908348083,
0.20275096595287323,
-1.3424193859100342,
0.4663994312286377,
-0.6197437047958374,
0.033382587134838104,
0.6300997138023376,
0.17072255909442902,
-0.6695436239242554,
-0.4063183665275574,
-0.5192204713821411,
-0.9313700795173645,
0.6718838810920715,
0.7084452509880066,
0.40525463223457336,
-0.1896277517080307,
0.4959504306316376,
0.3586151897907257,
0.6594159603118896,
-0.5896008610725403,
-0.3236932158470154,
-0.07590317726135254,
-0.30207905173301697,
0.14789699018001556,
0.026108667254447937,
0.19251105189323425,
-0.25459814071655273,
0.8991471529006958,
0.04945478215813637,
0.4625719487667084,
0.2724898159503937,
-0.42919886112213135,
-0.04880116879940033,
0.5825127363204956,
0.4590921700000763,
0.1747262179851532,
-0.15455690026283264,
0.23024599254131317,
0.253201961517334,
-0.5846386551856995,
0.6208779215812683,
0.050826095044612885,
-0.8009742498397827,
0.15592950582504272,
-0.13818585872650146,
0.6695978045463562,
-0.13245508074760437,
-0.36272096633911133,
0.6609301567077637,
-0.31479671597480774,
-0.3963795006275177,
-0.15795506536960602,
-0.2321130633354187,
-0.16063740849494934,
0.20241299271583557,
0.006168286316096783,
-0.01740642637014389,
0.5558645129203796,
-0.4026063084602356,
0.26473233103752136,
0.36516058444976807,
-0.8301885724067688,
-0.5066199898719788,
1.169092059135437,
0.6044394373893738,
-0.0728774443268776,
0.6093199253082275,
-0.8769978284835815,
-0.7536618709564209,
0.3525776267051697,
0.4803784489631653,
1.5225187540054321,
-0.16441838443279266,
0.17306791245937347,
0.4868367910385132,
1.0709985494613647,
-0.14251118898391724,
0.5032579898834229,
0.34229227900505066,
-0.6646937131881714,
-0.4733152389526367,
-0.3276839256286621,
-0.21457254886627197,
-0.08587746322154999,
-0.2545711100101471,
0.49582892656326294,
-0.3388877511024475,
-0.44678008556365967,
-0.49822211265563965,
-0.03387252241373062,
-0.7053311467170715,
-0.10267324000597,
0.432464063167572,
0.7030630111694336,
-0.8814775347709656,
0.4356207847595215,
0.6804657578468323,
-0.4573957622051239,
-0.2846733331680298,
-0.32258373498916626,
0.3426404595375061,
-0.4966694414615631,
0.724704384803772,
0.09277164936065674,
-0.5437068343162537,
-0.033241014927625656,
-0.09380315989255905,
-0.4669778347015381,
0.7952635288238525,
0.7330299615859985,
-0.8535688519477844,
0.09718818217515945,
0.45562419295310974,
0.06491898000240326,
-0.017352472990751266,
0.5972623229026794,
0.6923781633377075,
0.7296052575111389,
-0.8461143970489502,
-0.8876845836639404,
0.25264647603034973,
-0.6050306558609009,
-0.028599189594388008,
0.40942516922950745,
-0.4555571377277374,
1.030423641204834,
0.11274313926696777,
-0.2056414783000946,
-0.007838157936930656,
0.7114804983139038,
-0.12457410991191864,
0.25724226236343384,
0.7804999351501465,
0.5395444631576538,
0.6886640191078186,
-0.3024950325489044,
0.8459320068359375,
-0.026563862338662148,
-0.056872107088565826,
1.0823487043380737,
-0.44135770201683044,
0.36578449606895447,
0.49704527854919434,
-0.2869599461555481,
0.3326013386249542,
0.12314330041408539,
0.20419372618198395,
0.05339161306619644,
0.6529542207717896,
-0.3205389380455017,
-0.12609827518463135,
-0.2657882869243622,
-0.4721956253051758,
0.3622012436389923,
0.05624515563249588,
-0.3855031728744507,
-0.3924950361251831,
-0.03765935078263283,
0.4143511652946472,
0.3149139881134033,
-0.28863197565078735,
0.18447819352149963,
0.30959081649780273,
-0.40522879362106323,
0.19601225852966309,
0.45672473311424255,
0.9027982950210571,
-0.5182288289070129,
-0.1401149332523346,
-0.31695452332496643,
0.28429898619651794,
-0.1973324418067932,
-0.5695295929908752,
0.29672062397003174,
0.24565979838371277,
-0.5224584937095642,
-0.5641361474990845,
0.7290903925895691,
-0.506756067276001,
-0.6122455596923828,
0.379573792219162,
1.0244163274765015,
0.12294444441795349,
-0.4125569760799408,
-0.8659775257110596,
-0.1407611072063446,
0.2558393180370331,
-0.1289796531200409,
0.3507876694202423,
0.3537294864654541,
-0.6975719332695007,
0.4869513511657715,
0.42831411957740784,
-0.053734131157398224,
0.23530392348766327,
0.11001093685626984,
0.4483681321144104,
-0.789254903793335,
-0.3596341609954834,
-0.9538843631744385,
0.28025686740875244,
0.008558935485780239,
-0.36912932991981506,
0.8713674545288086,
0.44840580224990845,
0.9416593909263611,
-0.019261587411165237,
0.8416911959648132,
-0.027792926877737045,
0.2169385701417923,
-0.1710624247789383,
1.0268559455871582,
-0.668807864189148,
0.1683192253112793,
-0.5694692134857178,
-0.9486674666404724,
-0.18992818892002106,
0.5270557999610901,
-0.20505474507808685,
0.17104186117649078,
0.6665204167366028,
0.8335674405097961,
0.003060169517993927,
0.06356920301914215,
0.4576604962348938,
0.010612880811095238,
0.3529115915298462,
0.8785539269447327,
1.213140845298767,
-0.8568293452262878,
0.6525242328643799,
-0.053572624921798706,
-0.21609069406986237,
0.24829301238059998,
-1.0873957872390747,
-0.5910003185272217,
-0.2489265650510788,
-0.5871053338050842,
-0.42560189962387085,
0.3794398307800293,
1.1734780073165894,
0.5617774724960327,
-0.55182945728302,
-0.09464527666568756,
-0.26128530502319336,
0.32905569672584534,
-0.3458249270915985,
-0.03262406587600708,
0.06586097925901413,
-0.3527480363845825,
-1.171906590461731,
0.27301961183547974,
0.05381695553660393,
-0.25589555501937866,
-0.35491999983787537,
-0.23634569346904755,
0.07293864339590073,
-0.07399868965148926,
0.4073531925678253,
-0.01020587608218193,
-0.42084357142448425,
-0.24469655752182007,
0.2647087574005127,
-0.22537343204021454,
-0.17102450132369995,
0.6118281483650208,
-0.5309664607048035,
0.25733301043510437,
0.7388857007026672,
0.9285331964492798,
0.07865035533905029,
-0.4559052288532257,
1.1052004098892212,
-0.7451401948928833,
-0.21360109746456146,
0.06783857941627502,
0.4195447266101837,
0.22946330904960632,
-0.1913057267665863,
0.5077337622642517,
0.40832945704460144,
-0.36487123370170593,
-0.7441045045852661,
0.2999449372291565,
-0.6656452417373657,
-0.1709185242652893,
1.1083651781082153,
-0.05444399639964104,
-0.637371838092804,
-0.38414499163627625,
-0.4234161376953125,
0.12323305010795593,
-0.601516604423523,
0.40277209877967834,
0.6855872273445129,
0.46504566073417664,
-0.12174753099679947,
-1.0647722482681274,
0.26195380091667175,
0.8859655261039734,
-0.6293199062347412,
-0.021119216457009315,
0.31876954436302185,
0.09844865649938583,
-0.1610010862350464,
0.5937535762786865,
-0.3520335555076599,
0.38948118686676025,
0.0706019327044487,
0.5070052146911621,
0.13419272005558014,
-0.012784856371581554,
-0.5049856305122375,
-0.2562350630760193,
0.15855655074119568,
-0.3774392306804657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14273v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14273v1
|
Can Language Models Act as Knowledge Bases at Scale?
| 2024-02-22T04:20:14 | 2024-02-22T04:20:14 |
Qiyuan He, Yizhong Wang, Wenya Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable proficiency in
understanding and generating responses to complex queries through large-scale
pre-training. However, the efficacy of these models in memorizing and reasoning
among large-scale structured knowledge, especially world knowledge that
explicitly covers abundant factual information remains questionable. Addressing
this gap, our research investigates whether LLMs can effectively store, recall,
and reason with knowledge on a large scale comparable to latest knowledge bases
(KBs) such as Wikidata. Specifically, we focus on three crucial aspects to
study the viability: (1) the efficiency of LLMs with different sizes in
memorizing the exact knowledge in the large-scale KB; (2) the flexibility of
recalling the memorized knowledge in response to natural language queries; (3)
the capability to infer new knowledge through reasoning. Our findings indicate
that while LLMs hold promise as large-scale KBs capable of retrieving and
responding with flexibility, enhancements in their reasoning capabilities are
necessary to fully realize their potential.
|
[
-0.29292625188827515,
-0.8005919456481934,
0.9289158582687378,
-0.0028826880734413862,
0.08413229137659073,
-0.11333160102367401,
-0.5454851984977722,
-0.3392033576965332,
0.0004296110419090837,
0.6573681831359863,
-0.14846864342689514,
-0.19042935967445374,
-0.47152644395828247,
0.09418030828237534,
-0.4782569110393524,
0.5027888417243958,
0.0334671214222908,
-0.04498467966914177,
-0.469957560300827,
-0.2241155505180359,
-0.291558176279068,
-0.8540549278259277,
-0.43321847915649414,
-0.37044867873191833,
0.7115058898925781,
0.47906404733657837,
0.7136203646659851,
0.7981541156768799,
0.3953622281551361,
0.3195410370826721,
-0.19342726469039917,
0.248675137758255,
-0.6069400310516357,
0.31845200061798096,
-0.37394869327545166,
-0.7219469547271729,
-0.39250946044921875,
-0.1701122671365738,
0.9948165416717529,
1.000004768371582,
-0.2537625730037689,
0.0980253666639328,
-0.19645674526691437,
0.6972549557685852,
-0.4979488253593445,
0.2829708158969879,
-0.9835148453712463,
-0.1689770668745041,
0.24932892620563507,
0.025198128074407578,
-0.6091320514678955,
-0.2766675353050232,
0.29333385825157166,
-0.5399678349494934,
-0.262307345867157,
0.2751506268978119,
0.6655794382095337,
0.05177820473909378,
-0.6521053314208984,
-0.39138323068618774,
-0.84056156873703,
0.5670123100280762,
-0.8003784418106079,
0.5495163798332214,
0.4699273705482483,
0.4238043427467346,
-0.32511699199676514,
-0.7734231352806091,
-0.6610697507858276,
-0.2798286974430084,
-0.08809486776590347,
-0.3315986692905426,
0.006490601692348719,
-0.02297816053032875,
0.730757474899292,
0.38708242774009705,
-0.24931438267230988,
0.1318991333246231,
-0.1966908872127533,
-0.17261481285095215,
0.4423573613166809,
0.332905650138855,
0.3251122534275055,
-0.13496753573417664,
-0.061248015612363815,
0.16891644895076752,
-0.828887403011322,
-0.1225799024105072,
-0.012131156399846077,
0.23937714099884033,
0.18662287294864655,
0.6057427525520325,
-0.29755645990371704,
0.7673135995864868,
-0.1844208538532257,
-0.5505375266075134,
-0.12787163257598877,
-0.02169308066368103,
-0.3012736141681671,
-0.1973666399717331,
0.6388519406318665,
0.2384340912103653,
0.4939267635345459,
-0.4715316593647003,
-0.14212511479854584,
-0.26069167256355286,
0.30341920256614685,
-0.7999438643455505,
-0.20048683881759644,
-0.02641114592552185,
-0.421901136636734,
0.2481023520231247,
-0.14845937490463257,
-0.463645875453949,
-0.4544427692890167,
-0.5072100162506104,
0.6197878122329712,
-0.5321754813194275,
-0.39239609241485596,
0.25091353058815,
-0.09311273694038391,
0.15981143712997437,
0.3914058804512024,
-1.101219654083252,
0.28702470660209656,
0.573237955570221,
0.5701942443847656,
0.10384669899940491,
-0.23747068643569946,
0.04872015118598938,
0.429427832365036,
-0.49801212549209595,
0.6320421099662781,
-0.3356085419654846,
-0.28596314787864685,
0.046658534556627274,
-0.10211202502250671,
-0.21641969680786133,
-0.7359545826911926,
0.15599767863750458,
-0.8632559776306152,
-0.10140372812747955,
-0.784935712814331,
-0.8621803522109985,
-0.19492751359939575,
0.6716579794883728,
-0.8664158582687378,
0.6260635256767273,
0.10157328844070435,
-0.8264461159706116,
0.1397407501935959,
0.00025442149490118027,
-0.49007755517959595,
-0.1581142395734787,
-0.11287298053503036,
-0.11172409355640411,
0.15686076879501343,
-0.10953333228826523,
0.5779157280921936,
-0.525815486907959,
0.29174068570137024,
-0.5447396039962769,
-0.2065417468547821,
0.5138282775878906,
-0.32737261056900024,
0.5381746888160706,
0.10102415084838867,
-0.03271705284714699,
-0.29505184292793274,
-0.8301794528961182,
0.08827517181634903,
0.14464977383613586,
-0.7618274688720703,
-0.43682217597961426,
0.13077570497989655,
-0.5985084176063538,
0.2776494026184082,
0.3943480849266052,
-0.4140063226222992,
0.4847944378852844,
-0.1762934923171997,
0.4842909872531891,
0.49865853786468506,
-0.07176106423139572,
0.5783665180206299,
-0.20426678657531738,
0.3345121145248413,
-0.21073050796985626,
-0.10744842141866684,
-0.2163258045911789,
-0.17986775934696198,
-0.9169163703918457,
-0.13733530044555664,
0.06545346230268478,
0.4120233952999115,
-0.577988862991333,
0.27461960911750793,
-0.5223994255065918,
-0.43980708718299866,
0.20190247893333435,
0.21368616819381714,
0.21237196028232574,
0.6501899361610413,
0.16441838443279266,
0.04624277725815773,
-0.7006219029426575,
-0.9568736553192139,
-0.26795029640197754,
-0.33039528131484985,
-0.00030403019627556205,
0.440523236989975,
0.5135821104049683,
-0.10689577460289001,
0.9275016784667969,
-0.3794819712638855,
0.16425767540931702,
-0.3685467839241028,
-0.26840686798095703,
0.1772744357585907,
0.020677179098129272,
0.2563462555408478,
-0.8229930996894836,
-0.2577565610408783,
0.04782332107424736,
-1.1079211235046387,
0.11566202342510223,
-0.041760772466659546,
-0.012075924314558506,
0.23360559344291687,
0.7434197664260864,
-1.1086660623550415,
0.01643296703696251,
0.18497785925865173,
-0.3953804075717926,
0.5505169630050659,
-0.5013239979743958,
0.05140068754553795,
-0.9483646154403687,
0.05017314851284027,
-0.42891308665275574,
-0.09292736649513245,
-0.6657251119613647,
-0.2066529244184494,
0.35407811403274536,
0.28227171301841736,
-0.0605439729988575,
0.6596834063529968,
-0.541988730430603,
-0.20834213495254517,
-0.19829891622066498,
0.038784392178058624,
0.019177813082933426,
0.2632812261581421,
-0.011588387191295624,
0.5429681539535522,
0.3714076578617096,
-0.722442626953125,
0.2710511088371277,
0.08583611249923706,
-0.7040046453475952,
0.42758867144584656,
-0.294784814119339,
0.004493761342018843,
-0.19696734845638275,
0.397513747215271,
-0.7872574329376221,
-0.4801504611968994,
-0.46606969833374023,
-0.29954931139945984,
0.3989720046520233,
-0.032619062811136246,
-0.8044140934944153,
-0.532084584236145,
0.07298509031534195,
0.04602731019258499,
0.4928387403488159,
-0.44157326221466064,
0.9337232112884521,
0.5410287976264954,
-0.1515588015317917,
-0.54398113489151,
-0.5011522173881531,
0.000057332719734404236,
-0.24839410185813904,
-0.5319464206695557,
-0.2568592131137848,
0.08615792542695999,
-0.5818254947662354,
0.007611621171236038,
-0.306890070438385,
-0.1159088984131813,
0.056963853538036346,
0.2595633566379547,
0.3673114776611328,
-0.32269108295440674,
0.4719289243221283,
-0.3485785126686096,
0.23373755812644958,
0.3500356078147888,
-0.5226128697395325,
0.5541822910308838,
-0.21071918308734894,
-0.15692254900932312,
0.13438858091831207,
0.08700069040060043,
0.9280149936676025,
-0.09672027081251144,
1.1589220762252808,
0.08025418967008591,
-0.5936604738235474,
-0.3011423349380493,
-0.9748761057853699,
-0.03432202711701393,
-0.4021647572517395,
0.4360205829143524,
-0.4830886423587799,
-1.282189965248108,
0.6640373468399048,
-0.2225835621356964,
0.026041405275464058,
0.47131067514419556,
0.6405908465385437,
-0.27167564630508423,
0.851143479347229,
0.4379799962043762,
-0.2795332968235016,
0.17802271246910095,
-0.2621022164821625,
0.2654165029525757,
-0.8279489874839783,
-0.4583660066127777,
-0.48028093576431274,
-0.21684078872203827,
-0.1371683031320572,
-0.48764538764953613,
0.19001789391040802,
0.38766229152679443,
-0.6691169738769531,
0.035226333886384964,
0.11304007470607758,
0.6748672723770142,
0.34660792350769043,
-0.11093902587890625,
0.4666043519973755,
0.0009276240016333759,
-0.10695874691009521,
0.16186729073524475,
-0.7578780651092529,
-0.6590720415115356,
1.184617280960083,
0.29971933364868164,
0.7707610130310059,
0.0011350862914696336,
0.2846512496471405,
-0.1364821344614029,
0.3071005344390869,
-0.706682562828064,
0.7479673624038696,
-0.07026639580726624,
-0.8297977447509766,
-0.5509468913078308,
-0.6728972792625427,
-0.7798606157302856,
0.37976232171058655,
-0.2825714349746704,
-0.7526113986968994,
-0.15017130970954895,
0.28065478801727295,
-0.11288505047559738,
0.7209182977676392,
-0.8336336016654968,
0.6556207537651062,
-0.2941126227378845,
-0.13839483261108398,
-0.26557230949401855,
-0.5769801735877991,
0.49377790093421936,
-0.13891562819480896,
0.4232234060764313,
-0.14071154594421387,
-0.0015858401311561465,
0.7645432949066162,
-0.2788533568382263,
0.6725662350654602,
-0.19862349331378937,
-0.13991394639015198,
0.35269397497177124,
0.25480765104293823,
0.2693854570388794,
-0.022967755794525146,
-0.15963420271873474,
-0.09710235148668289,
-0.03175044059753418,
-0.31883206963539124,
-0.7967491149902344,
0.7214925289154053,
-0.7038872838020325,
-0.8639799952507019,
0.02819313295185566,
-0.7987129092216492,
-0.6076669692993164,
0.4694671034812927,
-0.05159090831875801,
0.29131177067756653,
-0.13418075442314148,
0.5797568559646606,
1.1212880611419678,
-0.11464065313339233,
0.17428430914878845,
0.7011996507644653,
-0.34900230169296265,
-0.19466839730739594,
0.8264433145523071,
0.5801929235458374,
0.5204594135284424,
0.663661003112793,
0.17768268287181854,
-0.25965359807014465,
-0.6264379620552063,
-0.1294662207365036,
0.31591537594795227,
-0.9307117462158203,
-0.18873630464076996,
-0.8100993633270264,
-0.19959300756454468,
-0.19523295760154724,
-0.012901528738439083,
-0.22283817827701569,
-0.6927427053451538,
0.12867501378059387,
-0.25143730640411377,
0.33422890305519104,
0.8542442321777344,
0.025840600952506065,
0.013001306913793087,
-0.7087771892547607,
0.40825608372688293,
0.5279081463813782,
0.3707098066806793,
0.3931008279323578,
-0.5357456207275391,
-0.4122888147830963,
-0.12928031384944916,
0.15989716351032257,
-0.4841499626636505,
0.1517820507287979,
-0.07929646968841553,
0.7112631797790527,
0.23153312504291534,
-0.1516006886959076,
0.42553192377090454,
-0.6569473147392273,
0.5573013424873352,
0.06704387813806534,
-0.5544667840003967,
0.28208231925964355,
-0.5447999835014343,
0.4777231812477112,
0.35108739137649536,
0.5347897410392761,
-0.5604811906814575,
-0.2340649962425232,
-0.5214471817016602,
-0.7742943167686462,
0.6446132063865662,
-0.3194456994533539,
0.1071210727095604,
-0.11349459737539291,
0.6073307394981384,
-0.07278706878423691,
0.21743273735046387,
-0.4734300673007965,
-0.040160275995731354,
-0.02755042351782322,
-0.1802617758512497,
-0.06624359637498856,
-0.5225591063499451,
-0.08737923204898834,
-0.2423095405101776,
0.5413879752159119,
-0.02225138060748577,
0.13317765295505524,
-0.07353495806455612,
-0.20623250305652618,
0.10994493216276169,
0.5021498203277588,
0.22577537596225739,
0.8843285441398621,
-0.06153974309563637,
0.44070959091186523,
0.434766560792923,
-0.5064248442649841,
0.09675390273332596,
-0.22800129652023315,
-0.0260397270321846,
-0.47474586963653564,
0.5617923140525818,
0.6355504393577576,
0.4214544892311096,
-0.9272470474243164,
0.2722729742527008,
-0.09550227969884872,
-0.3663924038410187,
-0.35555410385131836,
0.14249204099178314,
0.8353655338287354,
0.3769265115261078,
0.22417761385440826,
-0.26682817935943604,
-0.2070179581642151,
-0.7782254219055176,
0.007609464228153229,
0.495204895734787,
0.1818256676197052,
-0.06808377802371979,
0.47240617871284485,
-0.2640503942966461,
-0.07946251332759857,
0.9537854790687561,
0.24569043517112732,
-0.5545185208320618,
0.5550217032432556,
0.6872599720954895,
0.2508208453655243,
-0.1533130556344986,
-0.19937683641910553,
0.49157145619392395,
0.3259526789188385,
-0.5527534484863281,
0.11240919679403305,
-0.03704485297203064,
-1.042152762413025,
-0.3411930799484253,
-0.765760600566864,
-0.39252716302871704,
0.16281013190746307,
-0.5114952325820923,
-0.19627265632152557,
-0.8113316893577576,
-0.13657739758491516,
-0.06318513303995132,
-0.02379446104168892,
-0.602927565574646,
0.38411542773246765,
0.32798588275909424,
1.2296910285949707,
-0.5624773502349854,
1.1083674430847168,
0.4816567897796631,
-0.38415905833244324,
-1.3869757652282715,
-0.3090876042842865,
-0.014613542705774307,
-0.7693602442741394,
0.7645125985145569,
0.18715035915374756,
0.032228779047727585,
-0.2122960090637207,
-0.4373748302459717,
-1.1375797986984253,
1.2735612392425537,
0.5269200801849365,
-0.6230095624923706,
-0.35917797684669495,
0.18086807429790497,
0.5974352359771729,
-0.33167511224746704,
0.0247004646807909,
0.8461265563964844,
0.42619165778160095,
0.27297112345695496,
-0.9822192788124084,
-0.023980265483260155,
-0.13394203782081604,
-0.022568561136722565,
0.269648939371109,
-0.5895664691925049,
0.9410261511802673,
-0.3650406301021576,
0.1174798533320427,
-0.1089114174246788,
0.5592474341392517,
0.24771496653556824,
-0.17788618803024292,
0.5093961358070374,
0.8758051991462708,
0.9986220598220825,
-0.03258156776428223,
1.162812352180481,
-0.04742319881916046,
0.06469687819480896,
1.1138781309127808,
-0.370858758687973,
1.0630964040756226,
0.3347102403640747,
-0.19730713963508606,
0.6101410388946533,
0.14919978380203247,
0.21581962704658508,
0.2387077361345291,
0.2025856375694275,
-0.21597686409950256,
-0.5497744679450989,
0.13438141345977783,
-0.03193996846675873,
0.24546805024147034,
0.7115112543106079,
-0.32678085565567017,
0.07462415099143982,
-0.05365772545337677,
0.16265547275543213,
0.08750572055578232,
-0.5624354481697083,
0.7866165637969971,
0.2441423386335373,
-0.7204234004020691,
0.6579272150993347,
-0.22701501846313477,
0.3032587766647339,
-0.7868191599845886,
0.11847317218780518,
-0.10874157398939133,
0.30595991015434265,
-0.2168230265378952,
-0.729302167892456,
0.1538962870836258,
-0.11033099889755249,
-0.5132681131362915,
-0.18403412401676178,
0.9573236703872681,
-0.3965992331504822,
-0.3108420968055725,
0.23813804984092712,
0.4761445224285126,
-0.050064567476511,
0.010196713730692863,
-0.07670321315526962,
0.03707833215594292,
-0.07854878157377243,
-0.6080386638641357,
0.5532394647598267,
0.761240541934967,
-0.22887955605983734,
1.0709494352340698,
0.40938329696655273,
0.23098254203796387,
0.34936460852622986,
0.11248031258583069,
0.8460329174995422,
-0.797839879989624,
-0.1933242380619049,
-0.8054226040840149,
0.17018945515155792,
-0.19270622730255127,
0.18732529878616333,
0.9516017436981201,
0.5914496183395386,
0.7413818836212158,
-0.09216105937957764,
0.8354422450065613,
-0.11458081007003784,
0.6727355718612671,
-0.5592185854911804,
0.685685932636261,
-0.38867366313934326,
0.2099306583404541,
0.10858341306447983,
-0.7243392467498779,
-0.2616114914417267,
0.6216855645179749,
-0.5405515432357788,
-0.009778331033885479,
0.7316755652427673,
0.5633442401885986,
0.16880705952644348,
0.2159874588251114,
0.4345935881137848,
0.607598066329956,
0.25641128420829773,
0.6799532771110535,
0.8975169658660889,
0.10800109058618546,
0.6723920702934265,
0.11189086735248566,
-0.06719093024730682,
-0.15102390944957733,
-0.5155748724937439,
-1.184393048286438,
-0.49444580078125,
0.21761783957481384,
-0.2559729516506195,
-0.1755804717540741,
0.7435859441757202,
0.5380045175552368,
-0.44197991490364075,
-0.29171937704086304,
0.13093486428260803,
0.17135219275951385,
0.285882830619812,
-0.1229875311255455,
0.32460615038871765,
-0.3246568739414215,
-0.279532253742218,
0.2882702052593231,
0.4241594076156616,
0.036053042858839035,
-0.36080724000930786,
-0.1595011204481125,
-0.18941786885261536,
0.0995977595448494,
0.8646693229675293,
0.5395949482917786,
-0.7276182770729065,
-0.43651142716407776,
0.14337113499641418,
-0.29788142442703247,
-0.2673526704311371,
0.9133792519569397,
-0.8666428923606873,
0.27492693066596985,
0.4856800436973572,
0.831981360912323,
0.605501651763916,
-0.42174017429351807,
0.6696263551712036,
-0.31231847405433655,
-0.015158108435571194,
0.0872349813580513,
0.7065501809120178,
0.37148916721343994,
-0.12918224930763245,
0.336068332195282,
-0.018992140889167786,
-0.7106395363807678,
-0.5519970059394836,
0.21738530695438385,
-0.8216120004653931,
-0.4488252103328705,
1.3170173168182373,
-0.27246665954589844,
-0.16911685466766357,
-0.0873175635933876,
-0.08621343970298767,
0.13963648676872253,
0.054320357739925385,
0.6934306025505066,
1.1044596433639526,
-0.015946242958307266,
-0.1775524616241455,
-0.7023956775665283,
0.40402597188949585,
0.24576349556446075,
-0.8354853987693787,
0.4458922743797302,
0.733508288860321,
0.49760422110557556,
0.13358744978904724,
0.8893579244613647,
-0.1448969542980194,
0.07950618863105774,
0.1649298071861267,
-0.3489900529384613,
-0.029711097478866577,
-0.44614219665527344,
0.011158518493175507,
0.3933810591697693,
0.49132731556892395,
0.5125942230224609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14272v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14272v1
|
Qsnail: A Questionnaire Dataset for Sequential Question Generation
| 2024-02-22T04:14:10 | 2024-02-22T04:14:10 |
Yan Lei, Liang Pang, Yuanzhuo Wang, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The questionnaire is a professional research methodology used for both
qualitative and quantitative analysis of human opinions, preferences,
attitudes, and behaviors. However, designing and evaluating questionnaires
demands significant effort due to their intricate and complex structure.
Questionnaires entail a series of questions that must conform to intricate
constraints involving the questions, options, and overall structure.
Specifically, the questions should be relevant and specific to the given
research topic and intent. The options should be tailored to the questions,
ensuring they are mutually exclusive, completed, and ordered sensibly.
Moreover, the sequence of questions should follow a logical order, grouping
similar topics together. As a result, automatically generating questionnaires
presents a significant challenge and this area has received limited attention
primarily due to the scarcity of high-quality datasets. To address these
issues, we present Qsnail, the first dataset specifically constructed for the
questionnaire generation task, which comprises 13,168 human-written
questionnaires gathered from online platforms. We further conduct experiments
on Qsnail, and the results reveal that retrieval models and traditional
generative models do not fully align with the given research topic and intents.
Large language models, while more closely related to the research topic and
intents, exhibit significant limitations in terms of diversity and specificity.
Despite enhancements through the chain-of-thought prompt and finetuning,
questionnaires generated by language models still fall short of human-written
questionnaires. Therefore, questionnaire generation is challenging and needs to
be further explored. The dataset is available at:
https://github.com/LeiyanGithub/qsnail.
|
[
-0.2993999719619751,
-0.6251670122146606,
0.36403802037239075,
0.1886875182390213,
-0.24436348676681519,
0.10434889793395996,
0.2480807602405548,
0.07895668596029282,
0.20442481338977814,
0.2916000783443451,
-0.6922754049301147,
-0.48535311222076416,
-0.08227372914552689,
0.3836762309074402,
-0.6194634437561035,
1.0198931694030762,
0.2482840120792389,
-0.05242384970188141,
-0.4676143527030945,
-0.10720384120941162,
-0.3170386850833893,
-0.11776989698410034,
-0.651660680770874,
0.1582334339618683,
0.3771837651729584,
0.5964208245277405,
0.9189932346343994,
0.5156694650650024,
0.49788570404052734,
0.22181439399719238,
0.1413145363330841,
0.19067884981632233,
-0.7895399332046509,
0.38600024580955505,
-0.0650063306093216,
-0.5242050886154175,
-0.18682271242141724,
0.055977459996938705,
0.5786951184272766,
0.5378513932228088,
-0.07971601188182831,
0.9688257575035095,
-0.1949898600578308,
0.5587039589881897,
-0.5823455452919006,
-0.3149920403957367,
-0.3485700190067291,
0.39120134711265564,
-0.5638299584388733,
-0.397032231092453,
-0.1336529403924942,
-0.8170422911643982,
0.17663314938545227,
-0.46828922629356384,
0.45865824818611145,
0.0786212757229805,
0.5796896815299988,
0.02382313460111618,
-0.3370762765407562,
-0.05181504413485527,
-0.6622256636619568,
0.3910810053348541,
-0.4281158447265625,
0.059899572283029556,
0.39537203311920166,
0.39642709493637085,
-0.05412568897008896,
-1.0629843473434448,
-0.4492860734462738,
0.22719451785087585,
0.1510884165763855,
0.20963050425052643,
-0.016123296692967415,
-0.45699793100357056,
0.4093668460845947,
0.4612707793712616,
-1.0353703498840332,
-0.08639340102672577,
-0.4501378834247589,
0.004645782522857189,
0.836835503578186,
0.9997153282165527,
0.3880954086780548,
-0.5186701416969299,
-0.1556887924671173,
-0.06807009130716324,
-0.8327150344848633,
0.5571215748786926,
0.429105669260025,
0.023639632388949394,
0.07581830769777298,
0.5295558571815491,
-0.3309011459350586,
0.4041602909564972,
0.4583040773868561,
-0.23206837475299835,
0.17755025625228882,
-0.6582339406013489,
0.13129964470863342,
-0.12102296203374863,
1.0306248664855957,
0.5821054577827454,
-0.16126124560832977,
0.009481963701546192,
0.07337810844182968,
-0.0935363695025444,
0.36697763204574585,
-0.9129807353019714,
-0.42323940992355347,
0.8539766669273376,
-0.35629695653915405,
-0.6672317981719971,
0.18108907341957092,
-0.5017929673194885,
-0.1900596171617508,
-0.03778528794646263,
0.3459952473640442,
-0.15148620307445526,
-0.3996604084968567,
0.06232771277427673,
-0.2755499482154846,
0.26049190759658813,
0.1350918412208557,
-0.7958607077598572,
0.21424219012260437,
0.4129851460456848,
0.584494411945343,
-0.19244176149368286,
-0.33410438895225525,
-0.31820330023765564,
-0.07295837253332138,
-0.6438986659049988,
0.7673988342285156,
-0.6760016083717346,
-0.5934897661209106,
-0.10556298494338989,
-0.04678034782409668,
0.1474478840827942,
-0.7348917126655579,
0.2766690254211426,
-0.4101483225822449,
0.47990477085113525,
-0.37793219089508057,
-0.5143741965293884,
0.2811206579208374,
0.10375325381755829,
-0.5748980641365051,
1.5060969591140747,
0.37850895524024963,
-1.1612584590911865,
0.45218291878700256,
-0.38269633054733276,
-0.08876199275255203,
0.4275661110877991,
-0.6456387042999268,
-0.42703452706336975,
-0.03483419492840767,
0.1864907443523407,
0.4751046299934387,
-0.6158862113952637,
0.6063517928123474,
-0.06812643259763718,
-0.5486794114112854,
0.5057140588760376,
-0.03964308649301529,
0.623937726020813,
0.07499043643474579,
-0.24598540365695953,
0.3391764163970947,
-0.6379362344741821,
0.3802955448627472,
0.3791731894016266,
-0.14583070576190948,
-0.02277848869562149,
-0.2537005841732025,
0.04423665627837181,
0.29017361998558044,
0.04782596230506897,
-0.4059240520000458,
0.17182181775569916,
-0.19146396219730377,
0.5825269222259521,
0.6036633849143982,
0.36044585704803467,
0.2694327235221863,
-0.5638560652732849,
1.0350978374481201,
0.14295268058776855,
0.34935420751571655,
-0.24670197069644928,
-0.2737496793270111,
-0.362774133682251,
0.05001521855592728,
0.5576319098472595,
0.5735618472099304,
-0.7371389865875244,
0.26760345697402954,
-0.22683218121528625,
-0.8997102975845337,
-0.6780555844306946,
-0.14997902512550354,
0.37362128496170044,
0.30526086688041687,
0.001747851143591106,
-0.5966898202896118,
-0.4525357186794281,
-0.8633957505226135,
0.07157404720783234,
-0.09792003780603409,
0.007017571944743395,
0.32071924209594727,
0.3587512969970703,
0.36856764554977417,
1.2168833017349243,
-0.8039759993553162,
0.2656967043876648,
-0.3260083794593811,
0.2534959316253662,
0.20329870283603668,
0.3681480586528778,
0.44053158164024353,
-0.8728933334350586,
-0.4153760075569153,
-0.8159024715423584,
-0.757763683795929,
0.10069986432790756,
-0.1693705916404724,
-0.3342776894569397,
-0.6961504817008972,
0.4840894937515259,
-0.6817354559898376,
0.22502709925174713,
0.12693139910697937,
-0.18772752583026886,
0.9420015215873718,
0.3139323890209198,
-0.03769173100590706,
-1.1565682888031006,
0.26622581481933594,
-0.03957253322005272,
0.0360269695520401,
-0.6621976494789124,
0.07548300921916962,
0.0035873274318873882,
-0.559821605682373,
-0.5776092410087585,
0.5365313291549683,
-0.11798279732465744,
0.128692626953125,
0.25858697295188904,
-0.09943774342536926,
0.12474893778562546,
0.2726282775402069,
-0.0839429721236229,
1.0510663986206055,
0.639123260974884,
-0.4355577826499939,
0.37041425704956055,
0.8032495379447937,
-0.29690495133399963,
0.6242514848709106,
-0.8075128793716431,
0.36571136116981506,
-0.41663092374801636,
0.1293904185295105,
-1.1071094274520874,
-0.3725346326828003,
0.45372676849365234,
-0.41593337059020996,
0.03895158693194389,
0.2859360873699188,
-0.4676968455314636,
-0.6433995962142944,
-0.715532660484314,
0.5820392966270447,
0.44406333565711975,
-0.10434383153915405,
-0.04037054255604744,
0.23450633883476257,
-0.7474725842475891,
-0.2968403697013855,
-0.03860682621598244,
-0.012298665009438992,
-0.39001983404159546,
-0.575360119342804,
0.27141889929771423,
-0.25280657410621643,
-0.14331713318824768,
-0.07330233603715897,
-0.06287506222724915,
-0.004455238580703735,
-0.2736240029335022,
0.4462161362171173,
0.03513564541935921,
-0.32470887899398804,
0.373099148273468,
0.1320083737373352,
0.05173294618725777,
0.07855832576751709,
0.11472171545028687,
0.5176774263381958,
0.08994082361459732,
-0.15868577361106873,
-0.4698348343372345,
0.5877846479415894,
0.45127102732658386,
-0.614838182926178,
0.14914147555828094,
0.594909131526947,
-0.0283848587423563,
-0.17506639659404755,
-0.3863368034362793,
-0.17347754538059235,
-0.4858475625514984,
0.2548332214355469,
-0.5334347486495972,
-0.7934332489967346,
0.2345617711544037,
0.015180971473455429,
0.09074904769659042,
0.31616517901420593,
0.3887588083744049,
-0.06591610610485077,
1.128844141960144,
0.14504966139793396,
-0.09767930954694748,
0.2746272385120392,
-0.29088759422302246,
-0.1246691569685936,
-0.8130571842193604,
-0.008930440992116928,
-0.2636377513408661,
-0.2876622676849365,
-0.4879584312438965,
-0.18296469748020172,
0.45924288034439087,
-0.00596307497471571,
-0.39751842617988586,
-0.03147927671670914,
-0.6249393820762634,
0.3213866353034973,
0.7883808612823486,
0.42734384536743164,
0.03903040289878845,
-0.09280474483966827,
-0.025471782311797142,
-0.10547826439142227,
-0.8694942593574524,
-0.7026069164276123,
1.3893027305603027,
0.03636118769645691,
0.4914420545101166,
-0.01789524406194687,
0.9989075064659119,
0.3050464987754822,
0.06982959806919098,
-0.43551599979400635,
0.7463194131851196,
-0.01849261298775673,
-0.5666495561599731,
-0.7782330513000488,
-0.14397571980953217,
-1.1370935440063477,
0.14978229999542236,
-0.17850928008556366,
-0.3495074212551117,
0.14156365394592285,
0.09748563170433044,
-0.9054417014122009,
-0.11498633027076721,
-0.21120388805866241,
0.9572545289993286,
-0.3192799389362335,
-0.7703514099121094,
0.4618915319442749,
-0.858182430267334,
0.35724884271621704,
-0.09932158887386322,
-0.1794966608285904,
-0.15327434241771698,
0.3596495985984802,
0.7555794715881348,
-0.5279446244239807,
0.8573007583618164,
-0.1721128225326538,
0.12108144164085388,
0.6085237264633179,
0.17260701954364777,
0.3350144326686859,
0.24426154792308807,
-0.019234469160437584,
-0.46502307057380676,
0.42719557881355286,
-0.33774468302726746,
-0.5713674426078796,
0.07739787548780441,
-0.5457563996315002,
-0.642885684967041,
-0.2420893907546997,
-0.3627922832965851,
-0.408240407705307,
0.1935851126909256,
0.44031399488449097,
0.696503221988678,
-0.4155818223953247,
-0.20119820535182953,
0.3651871681213379,
-0.2959047853946686,
-0.10548888891935349,
0.3486054539680481,
-0.2814328670501709,
-0.22327060997486115,
1.0975593328475952,
0.1949436217546463,
-0.03636861592531204,
0.09822795540094376,
0.11897187680006027,
-0.2638327181339264,
-0.562941312789917,
-0.5539712309837341,
0.16419179737567902,
-0.34551092982292175,
-0.17142176628112793,
-0.26716095209121704,
-0.2718932628631592,
-0.43420854210853577,
0.2675957679748535,
0.07343559712171555,
-0.4536034166812897,
-0.46969422698020935,
-0.1520451456308365,
0.3880192041397095,
0.6379055380821228,
0.15146900713443756,
0.01878289133310318,
-1.0191457271575928,
0.5841909050941467,
0.6691233515739441,
0.08662746101617813,
0.11693122237920761,
-0.16024424135684967,
0.08327267318964005,
-0.18972724676132202,
-0.44038721919059753,
-0.8029804229736328,
0.33131852746009827,
0.36252152919769287,
0.28687718510627747,
0.4943443238735199,
0.224640890955925,
0.8039783835411072,
-0.5316706299781799,
0.9146435260772705,
0.014491683803498745,
-0.4404311180114746,
0.734002947807312,
-0.5988502502441406,
0.5328396558761597,
0.8608022332191467,
0.7142036557197571,
-0.5952507257461548,
-0.5357562899589539,
-0.863677442073822,
-0.9402700066566467,
0.5834567546844482,
0.15378345549106598,
0.11700236797332764,
-0.3943897783756256,
0.49133771657943726,
0.4716005027294159,
0.5019637942314148,
-0.18056747317314148,
-0.06689651310443878,
-0.15723761916160583,
-0.27028802037239075,
-0.048683855682611465,
-0.3617628812789917,
0.0052597401663661,
-0.17793422937393188,
0.15486858785152435,
-0.041229814291000366,
0.1395423412322998,
0.25412994623184204,
0.17032761871814728,
-0.3104788661003113,
0.3632865846157074,
0.2183951437473297,
0.7537583112716675,
-0.3411620855331421,
-0.13312454521656036,
-0.29728513956069946,
-0.4942288100719452,
0.21396410465240479,
-0.09116003662347794,
-0.5645880699157715,
-0.016790276393294334,
0.03192944824695587,
0.5525215268135071,
0.11305703222751617,
-0.859339714050293,
0.590546190738678,
-0.09271790087223053,
-0.23049038648605347,
-0.4850880801677704,
0.14932307600975037,
0.1353757381439209,
0.37777408957481384,
0.29640963673591614,
-0.36116981506347656,
0.4117439091205597,
-0.6183049082756042,
0.20704418420791626,
0.2413320392370224,
-0.16643491387367249,
-0.32940614223480225,
0.6352863311767578,
0.18928836286067963,
-0.2739194631576538,
0.9782809615135193,
-0.4868218004703522,
-0.2285938560962677,
0.520738422870636,
0.3675779402256012,
0.5863466262817383,
-0.22603322565555573,
0.7444262504577637,
0.5729546546936035,
-0.1741655468940735,
-0.22394268214702606,
0.9014368653297424,
-0.10572751611471176,
-0.5704349279403687,
0.1758880615234375,
-0.5965444445610046,
-0.5685490369796753,
0.18964114785194397,
-0.9814799427986145,
-0.18070200085639954,
-0.34863030910491943,
-0.6099024415016174,
-0.056436687707901,
-0.35673728585243225,
-0.7370368242263794,
0.4607885777950287,
-0.3881490230560303,
0.7639067769050598,
-0.9072121381759644,
0.18191911280155182,
0.6252798438072205,
-0.6638875603675842,
-1.018904209136963,
-0.10046283155679703,
-0.027381962165236473,
-0.5752090215682983,
0.6757063269615173,
-0.013916888274252415,
0.36674386262893677,
0.27019980549812317,
-0.6451374292373657,
-0.8245745301246643,
1.2196924686431885,
-0.14503879845142365,
-0.39919978380203247,
-0.32755330204963684,
0.40722590684890747,
0.5343826413154602,
-0.15757620334625244,
-0.0011838937643915415,
0.4796566665172577,
0.1893472820520401,
0.058353956788778305,
-0.844735860824585,
0.29311197996139526,
-0.7849476337432861,
0.0014627748169004917,
0.36381375789642334,
-0.6965241432189941,
0.8961135745048523,
-0.3285939395427704,
-0.3623930811882019,
0.4838928282260895,
0.32998543977737427,
0.5405473113059998,
0.19954903423786163,
0.23873530328273773,
0.5016140937805176,
0.7353454232215881,
-0.061281055212020874,
0.7259731888771057,
-0.22232361137866974,
-0.08878915756940842,
1.1360093355178833,
-0.5003519654273987,
1.0134403705596924,
0.2917576730251312,
-0.4554305374622345,
0.12770915031433105,
0.989925742149353,
-0.39810237288475037,
0.357491672039032,
0.4702993333339691,
-0.05585074424743652,
-0.3487743139266968,
-0.2160719484090805,
-0.5507283210754395,
0.7218859791755676,
0.29055795073509216,
-0.404252827167511,
0.08860871195793152,
-0.09209354966878891,
-0.3823365569114685,
-0.2674653232097626,
-0.09954319894313812,
0.7184138894081116,
-0.2320835143327713,
-0.5857342481613159,
0.35921478271484375,
-0.28891679644584656,
0.2960377037525177,
-0.5393877029418945,
-0.09093412011861801,
-0.3314565420150757,
-0.5597392916679382,
-0.32155874371528625,
-0.9045981764793396,
-0.23471780121326447,
-0.1925623118877411,
0.050888944417238235,
-0.08860954642295837,
0.5894969701766968,
-0.3325459957122803,
-0.6256533861160278,
-0.749085009098053,
0.9855107069015503,
0.4594895541667938,
0.06430303305387497,
-0.6051333546638489,
-0.12231668084859848,
-0.16443301737308502,
-0.26369380950927734,
0.1859550029039383,
0.43443772196769714,
-0.09758637845516205,
0.5418580770492554,
0.47807466983795166,
0.2055264711380005,
0.0027533979155123234,
0.19388267397880554,
0.7815951108932495,
-0.8076795935630798,
-0.5919654369354248,
-0.33127331733703613,
0.7094459533691406,
0.012044048868119717,
-0.6044530272483826,
0.7853255867958069,
0.9209200143814087,
0.5864400267601013,
-0.27545371651649475,
0.8814805150032043,
0.06460291892290115,
0.8227517604827881,
-0.45878636837005615,
0.46017810702323914,
-0.612025260925293,
-0.13039278984069824,
-0.35600745677948,
-0.499287873506546,
-0.19139982759952545,
0.30106794834136963,
-0.19978664815425873,
-0.003343382850289345,
0.5600415468215942,
0.89208984375,
0.24423028528690338,
0.10857966542243958,
-0.035697560757398605,
-0.07254459708929062,
-0.12507307529449463,
0.43832001090049744,
1.078015685081482,
-0.3810596764087677,
0.484825998544693,
-0.1974523663520813,
0.09421417862176895,
-0.08228932321071625,
-0.30653199553489685,
-0.6430484056472778,
-0.6827993392944336,
-0.41823697090148926,
-0.022256361320614815,
0.01644112914800644,
0.8702415823936462,
0.48477405309677124,
-0.5254485607147217,
-0.32896870374679565,
0.07744830846786499,
-0.41797956824302673,
-0.07982344925403595,
-0.2823827564716339,
0.6412450671195984,
0.018830224871635437,
-0.32377558946609497,
-0.011489635333418846,
0.33920010924339294,
0.1274404376745224,
-0.33156874775886536,
0.3246762752532959,
0.09312513470649719,
-0.1063615158200264,
0.5955953001976013,
0.3699107766151428,
-0.45533686876296997,
-0.0802125558257103,
0.3026818633079529,
0.002253392245620489,
0.30616989731788635,
0.8445472717285156,
-0.6703643202781677,
0.394321471452713,
0.4929480254650116,
0.3703964948654175,
0.3752092123031616,
0.2838323414325714,
0.4647483229637146,
-0.7050071954727173,
-0.36168166995048523,
0.3917739689350128,
-0.04112892225384712,
0.24454060196876526,
-0.30100297927856445,
0.4723377227783203,
-0.13104553520679474,
-0.3923145532608032,
-0.8554431200027466,
0.4060803949832916,
-0.7693100571632385,
-0.15334975719451904,
0.7525613307952881,
0.23546256124973297,
0.08971376717090607,
-0.20558498799800873,
-0.5967304110527039,
0.05507524311542511,
-0.3241332769393921,
0.8835037350654602,
0.4761095643043518,
-0.5368819236755371,
-0.34192484617233276,
-0.2155996412038803,
0.49056166410446167,
0.3834775388240814,
-0.8507024645805359,
-0.09150546789169312,
0.4403674006462097,
0.18845482170581818,
0.09656693041324615,
0.9686779975891113,
-0.21305254101753235,
0.6171574592590332,
0.19358614087104797,
-0.2776615023612976,
0.08446864038705826,
-0.15155018866062164,
-0.0238795205950737,
0.5740105509757996,
0.4641307592391968,
-0.13692978024482727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14268v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14268v1
|
Can Large Language Models Detect Misinformation in Scientific News Reporting?
| 2024-02-22T04:07:00 | 2024-02-22T04:07:00 |
Yupeng Cao, Aishwarya Muralidharan Nair, Elyon Eyimife, Nastaran Jamalipour Soofi, K. P. Subbalakshmi, John R. Wullert II, Chumki Basu, David Shallcross
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI
|
Scientific facts are often spun in the popular press with the intent to
influence public opinion and action, as was evidenced during the COVID-19
pandemic. Automatic detection of misinformation in the scientific domain is
challenging because of the distinct styles of writing in these two media types
and is still in its nascence. Most research on the validity of scientific
reporting treats this problem as a claim verification challenge. In doing so,
significant expert human effort is required to generate appropriate claims. Our
solution bypasses this step and addresses a more real-world scenario where such
explicit, labeled claims may not be available. The central research question of
this paper is whether it is possible to use large language models (LLMs) to
detect misinformation in scientific reporting. To this end, we first present a
new labeled dataset SciNews, containing 2.4k scientific news stories drawn from
trusted and untrustworthy sources, paired with related abstracts from the
CORD-19 database. Our dataset includes both human-written and LLM-generated
news articles, making it more comprehensive in terms of capturing the growing
trend of using LLMs to generate popular press articles. Then, we identify
dimensions of scientific validity in science news articles and explore how this
can be integrated into the automated detection of scientific misinformation. We
propose several baseline architectures using LLMs to automatically detect false
representations of scientific findings in the popular press. For each of these
architectures, we use several prompt engineering strategies including
zero-shot, few-shot, and chain-of-thought prompting. We also test these
architectures and prompting strategies on GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Llama2-7B,
Llama2-13B.
|
[
-0.12367917597293854,
-0.7578301429748535,
0.8417878150939941,
0.5148347020149231,
-0.20708972215652466,
0.004202285781502724,
-0.2726467251777649,
-0.7373917102813721,
0.19029413163661957,
0.17769907414913177,
-0.06997998058795929,
-0.3722172975540161,
-0.7759261131286621,
0.552219569683075,
-0.5753592848777771,
0.7960484027862549,
-0.1158314198255539,
0.20149998366832733,
-0.3390084207057953,
0.15060727298259735,
-0.06100688502192497,
-0.3102935552597046,
-0.35550203919410706,
-0.2571244239807129,
0.6115939021110535,
0.38101956248283386,
0.5914576053619385,
0.5643833875656128,
0.44696465134620667,
0.18498128652572632,
-0.154341459274292,
0.5084661245346069,
-0.2946000099182129,
-0.024643870070576668,
-0.12737113237380981,
-0.574908435344696,
-0.25946176052093506,
0.18722625076770782,
0.7046061754226685,
0.31544068455696106,
-0.018277425318956375,
0.2654099464416504,
-0.047519389539957047,
0.20913180708885193,
-0.2669318616390228,
0.14961376786231995,
-0.8059733510017395,
0.06429341435432434,
-0.35453206300735474,
-0.30522555112838745,
-0.689765214920044,
-0.13843150436878204,
-0.05887117236852646,
-0.4366096556186676,
0.20017129182815552,
0.34115490317344666,
0.9255263209342957,
0.10503145307302475,
-0.3778454065322876,
-0.4830458462238312,
-0.6674488186836243,
0.6224203705787659,
-0.9810823798179626,
0.3669634759426117,
0.43529242277145386,
0.09643872082233429,
-0.34057700634002686,
-0.3764606714248657,
-0.7695550322532654,
-0.6294360756874084,
-0.0584796741604805,
-0.047338247299194336,
-0.4285198748111725,
-0.3897312581539154,
0.42684733867645264,
-0.07819366455078125,
-0.8062909245491028,
0.37736353278160095,
-0.6294146180152893,
-0.3984237313270569,
0.548340380191803,
-0.21753062307834625,
0.38031724095344543,
-0.33538490533828735,
-0.12683406472206116,
0.09522129595279694,
-0.999769389629364,
-0.3945324122905731,
0.20133477449417114,
0.18384197354316711,
-0.15243016183376312,
0.7064781188964844,
-0.031375814229249954,
0.4326062500476837,
0.22431504726409912,
-0.31068098545074463,
0.24196991324424744,
-0.28530681133270264,
-0.1639781892299652,
0.4816356897354126,
0.698210597038269,
0.4758491814136505,
0.09184038639068604,
-0.009951380081474781,
-0.12586598098278046,
0.09126342833042145,
0.013134193606674671,
-0.6523634195327759,
-0.07635162770748138,
0.03797002136707306,
-0.31207752227783203,
-0.382242351770401,
-0.20220394432544708,
-0.7206239700317383,
-0.6833822727203369,
-0.08616805821657181,
0.32767218351364136,
-0.08016020059585571,
-0.1650286763906479,
0.2245062291622162,
-0.04061517119407654,
-0.1252688616514206,
0.4889976382255554,
-0.42152610421180725,
-0.002516522305086255,
0.41890543699264526,
0.9168903231620789,
-0.0722675547003746,
-0.17019440233707428,
-0.4759272336959839,
0.1577904373407364,
-0.4409716725349426,
0.9328213930130005,
-0.46961352229118347,
-0.11465293169021606,
-0.21843063831329346,
-0.04406791552901268,
0.07314641028642654,
-0.5006408095359802,
0.4983203709125519,
-0.6690645217895508,
0.29196619987487793,
-0.3652925193309784,
-0.40054425597190857,
-0.14784012734889984,
0.31307023763656616,
-0.6640165448188782,
0.7483879327774048,
-0.17441338300704956,
-0.9267889261245728,
0.28970393538475037,
-0.45370566844940186,
-0.3054977357387543,
-0.056418538093566895,
-0.13304336369037628,
-0.6192049384117126,
0.026292191818356514,
0.3596854507923126,
0.33374956250190735,
-0.332739919424057,
0.6392316818237305,
-0.30621522665023804,
-0.03322191908955574,
0.40634801983833313,
-0.622366189956665,
0.42721059918403625,
0.2967822849750519,
-0.2809338867664337,
-0.16866829991340637,
-0.6721237301826477,
-0.35368067026138306,
0.23283876478672028,
-0.4751160442829132,
-0.38045403361320496,
0.008680292405188084,
-0.29878777265548706,
0.11255200207233429,
-0.04478976130485535,
-0.8644422292709351,
0.3608545660972595,
0.005383103620260954,
0.32415515184402466,
0.28608253598213196,
0.0291425958275795,
0.07049880921840668,
-0.36454880237579346,
0.27767544984817505,
0.2940698266029358,
-0.051238127052783966,
-0.24582280218601227,
-0.5559585094451904,
-0.46061933040618896,
-0.21673478186130524,
0.2734137177467346,
0.6155505180358887,
-0.7177456617355347,
0.3199689984321594,
-0.09229573607444763,
-0.5209552645683289,
-0.40288135409355164,
0.08127281069755554,
0.08915288001298904,
0.8303245902061462,
0.5229175686836243,
0.18361932039260864,
-0.841789186000824,
-0.7509737610816956,
-0.4152930676937103,
-0.17025262117385864,
0.009313640184700489,
0.07080446183681488,
0.5473705530166626,
-0.24910908937454224,
0.8496831059455872,
-0.265689492225647,
0.20191074907779694,
-0.041467126458883286,
0.5329068303108215,
0.3030807077884674,
0.17342129349708557,
0.5205038189888,
-0.7045214772224426,
-0.29831430315971375,
-0.04693174734711647,
-0.8833647966384888,
-0.36669740080833435,
-0.16437123715877533,
0.5520156621932983,
0.31876298785209656,
0.45636677742004395,
-0.8528221249580383,
0.3897228240966797,
0.6139682531356812,
-0.17765739560127258,
0.822575569152832,
-0.2320181429386139,
0.3314421772956848,
-0.7982664108276367,
0.01890031434595585,
0.5113539695739746,
-0.26165881752967834,
-0.6488426327705383,
-0.48074159026145935,
0.19242262840270996,
-0.009449845179915428,
-0.4413846433162689,
0.42203009128570557,
-0.45564666390419006,
-0.018966149538755417,
-0.4105934202671051,
0.03683548420667648,
0.08741031587123871,
-0.14016547799110413,
0.06997380405664444,
0.5673894882202148,
0.4409242868423462,
-0.6309637427330017,
0.3877148926258087,
0.11640855669975281,
-0.5670933723449707,
0.3633483052253723,
-0.7704538106918335,
-0.19598698616027832,
-0.5337187051773071,
0.8487549424171448,
-0.8309133052825928,
-0.5481743216514587,
0.3760020434856415,
-0.4896990656852722,
-0.02261376939713955,
-0.007809238042682409,
-0.7811564803123474,
-0.6709392070770264,
-0.004779877606779337,
0.1387248933315277,
0.22495682537555695,
-0.6508334279060364,
0.260226845741272,
0.14556972682476044,
-0.45387712121009827,
-0.45502567291259766,
-0.7829536199569702,
0.33079129457473755,
-0.1395024210214615,
-0.7041018009185791,
0.012372171506285667,
0.13347861170768738,
-0.4603630602359772,
-0.040652479976415634,
-0.24297766387462616,
-0.04819544032216072,
-0.03642755001783371,
0.15211346745491028,
0.5043550729751587,
-0.3850773572921753,
0.40964776277542114,
-0.018019044771790504,
0.29038867354393005,
0.07646068185567856,
-0.03483711928129196,
0.3049057126045227,
-0.10258089751005173,
-0.5009850859642029,
-0.47920548915863037,
0.2755391001701355,
0.8020184636116028,
-0.07741348445415497,
0.5692731738090515,
0.5503906011581421,
-0.4197489023208618,
-0.07280126959085464,
-0.7188039422035217,
-0.32641592621803284,
-0.36597925424575806,
0.5007866621017456,
0.14581595361232758,
-0.7692338824272156,
0.3308197557926178,
-0.060497038066387177,
-0.11235667765140533,
0.576228141784668,
0.37323930859565735,
-0.04948452487587929,
1.134612798690796,
0.3484856188297272,
-0.05305910483002663,
0.02778038941323757,
0.06132082641124725,
0.41266924142837524,
-0.35279160737991333,
-0.3190872371196747,
-0.7603574395179749,
-0.07879474014043808,
-0.139253631234169,
-0.40605080127716064,
0.5011696219444275,
0.08951092511415482,
-0.19352057576179504,
0.045572564005851746,
-0.4269741475582123,
0.602032482624054,
0.3199586272239685,
-0.04164211079478264,
0.5446159243583679,
0.18001540005207062,
0.07866381853818893,
0.1597655713558197,
-0.8133310079574585,
-0.6188178658485413,
0.7391237020492554,
0.7525476217269897,
0.8574796319007874,
-0.18630599975585938,
0.41787290573120117,
0.42104804515838623,
0.6054646372795105,
-0.637172520160675,
0.38971883058547974,
0.08793545514345169,
-0.43904465436935425,
-0.1339847296476364,
-0.4247540831565857,
-0.7155913710594177,
0.1766447275876999,
-0.3071645498275757,
-0.5732584595680237,
0.3209482431411743,
0.08461581915616989,
-0.5008469820022583,
0.35547733306884766,
-0.663352906703949,
0.25976264476776123,
-0.5050279498100281,
0.1411522477865219,
-0.3869786858558655,
-0.4407515227794647,
0.5280706286430359,
-0.3078250288963318,
0.39359980821609497,
-0.11119238287210464,
0.17845910787582397,
0.8482403755187988,
0.024223389104008675,
1.0372633934020996,
-0.1573931872844696,
-0.3522217571735382,
0.29123857617378235,
0.05535497888922691,
0.8346196413040161,
0.15183885395526886,
-0.11645031720399857,
0.2804929316043854,
-0.1377212256193161,
-0.14235006272792816,
-0.3087143301963806,
0.5786257982254028,
-0.6704607009887695,
-0.6570548415184021,
-0.6698184609413147,
-0.657609760761261,
-0.14644815027713776,
0.20276401937007904,
0.29289060831069946,
0.16414181888103485,
-0.028768405318260193,
0.19047540426254272,
0.7328919172286987,
-0.29876044392585754,
0.3161626160144806,
0.9850005507469177,
-0.21114930510520935,
-0.1571846902370453,
0.7992253303527832,
0.21145404875278473,
-0.0025162696838378906,
0.022571641951799393,
0.3483158349990845,
-0.15642768144607544,
-0.7217568159103394,
-0.2932855486869812,
0.5325706601142883,
-0.44301992654800415,
-0.4910171627998352,
-0.5788268446922302,
-0.3690122067928314,
-0.42811089754104614,
0.08858136087656021,
-0.19340161979198456,
-0.1741565614938736,
-0.5274443626403809,
-0.19708561897277832,
0.39899179339408875,
0.9006915092468262,
-0.24745652079582214,
0.23080304265022278,
-0.9986172914505005,
0.38544514775276184,
0.12590888142585754,
0.07374562323093414,
-0.040204331278800964,
-0.5262830853462219,
-0.20698349177837372,
0.4675397276878357,
-0.23225675523281097,
-0.7885348796844482,
0.6105000972747803,
0.0050984700210392475,
0.522939920425415,
0.46001723408699036,
-0.14173947274684906,
0.36681807041168213,
-0.47624775767326355,
0.8109235763549805,
0.40921860933303833,
-0.7247505187988281,
0.4711986184120178,
-0.4194727838039398,
-0.008849794045090675,
0.07757508754730225,
0.8517398238182068,
-0.7129430770874023,
-0.5060777068138123,
-0.606701135635376,
-0.41226884722709656,
0.4125296175479889,
-0.3099164664745331,
-0.15150199830532074,
-0.17557938396930695,
0.11420374363660812,
0.26243874430656433,
0.09853491932153702,
-0.7830239534378052,
0.12434261292219162,
-0.23185186088085175,
-0.11039277911186218,
0.08632788807153702,
-0.2947455942630768,
-0.3597784638404846,
-0.13166849315166473,
0.5796464085578918,
-0.16893386840820312,
0.09345812350511551,
0.4218100905418396,
-0.25107109546661377,
-0.39326798915863037,
0.3719337582588196,
0.926232099533081,
0.8064723014831543,
0.007912561297416687,
0.43801018595695496,
-0.07388000190258026,
-0.4688466787338257,
0.023511340841650963,
0.06518635153770447,
-0.4305259585380554,
0.2591067850589752,
0.37518665194511414,
0.7257078289985657,
0.06141960620880127,
-0.6671138405799866,
0.4929516911506653,
0.18934686481952667,
-0.3273771107196808,
-0.04796603322029114,
-0.22859202325344086,
0.03783181309700012,
0.3803604245185852,
0.6936425566673279,
0.31172865629196167,
-0.09492547065019608,
-0.5316327214241028,
0.1911037564277649,
0.3421207368373871,
0.11036639660596848,
-0.5496799945831299,
0.481120765209198,
0.08244328200817108,
0.07111386209726334,
0.42596760392189026,
-0.08830305933952332,
-0.41563159227371216,
0.542747974395752,
0.7558698654174805,
0.3328341841697693,
-0.3432958126068115,
0.6574447154998779,
0.15230946242809296,
0.3761352598667145,
-0.5934240221977234,
-0.0068153743632137775,
0.4839932322502136,
-0.6974009871482849,
-0.6897002458572388,
-0.4501539170742035,
-0.25581926107406616,
0.3943712115287781,
-0.1685379445552826,
0.23308642208576202,
-0.27175426483154297,
-0.1070006936788559,
0.32525113224983215,
-0.17213518917560577,
-0.30038124322891235,
-0.03592105582356453,
0.6056616902351379,
1.0958691835403442,
-1.345674991607666,
0.7121738195419312,
0.40704765915870667,
-0.29707562923431396,
-0.6410669684410095,
-0.02172783575952053,
0.3600662350654602,
-0.7762986421585083,
1.041710376739502,
-0.002944181440398097,
0.062499627470970154,
-0.3780566155910492,
-1.193275809288025,
-1.0294116735458374,
0.9380444288253784,
0.48771390318870544,
-0.8034738302230835,
-0.011624091304838657,
0.08144606649875641,
0.48402491211891174,
-0.4407117962837219,
0.1590079516172409,
0.25323721766471863,
0.8909165859222412,
0.3436841666698456,
-1.225265383720398,
0.0382213220000267,
-0.029549162834882736,
-0.4296606481075287,
-0.22838690876960754,
-0.5135982036590576,
0.8301664590835571,
-0.3597957193851471,
-0.11484450101852417,
-0.08151473850011826,
0.7932235598564148,
0.49385836720466614,
0.7326046228408813,
0.4008292555809021,
0.337139368057251,
1.21314537525177,
0.0605718195438385,
0.8539323806762695,
-0.02322518825531006,
0.18250972032546997,
0.8515244126319885,
-0.44505536556243896,
0.7173652648925781,
0.40851810574531555,
0.008397813886404037,
0.4038241505622864,
0.6798226833343506,
-0.4013687074184418,
0.30365797877311707,
0.26263555884361267,
-0.14821010828018188,
-0.22072388231754303,
-0.3990732431411743,
-0.4347655773162842,
0.3700508773326874,
0.6692085266113281,
-0.45731812715530396,
-0.4696866273880005,
0.18674200773239136,
0.30613476037979126,
-0.138311967253685,
-0.47069084644317627,
0.29176801443099976,
0.17924638092517853,
-0.5827199220657349,
0.7632211446762085,
0.03272750601172447,
0.7177493572235107,
-0.461012601852417,
-0.08137424290180206,
0.0013391829561442137,
-0.10639528930187225,
-0.41094425320625305,
-0.7263667583465576,
0.167404443025589,
0.19906289875507355,
-0.3305718004703522,
0.04706842079758644,
0.8932213187217712,
-0.6930333375930786,
-0.43158048391342163,
-0.25985342264175415,
0.4330960512161255,
0.1794281154870987,
-0.013716203160583973,
-0.34808793663978577,
0.3313044011592865,
0.028927065432071686,
-0.08860567212104797,
0.17552904784679413,
0.2271270602941513,
-0.2667577862739563,
0.7908145189285278,
0.6228289604187012,
0.5361047387123108,
0.1355273723602295,
-0.04270913824439049,
0.7562190890312195,
-0.31611010432243347,
-0.21645647287368774,
-0.6463719606399536,
0.0994383916258812,
-0.29301077127456665,
0.14675773680210114,
1.000862956047058,
0.46529892086982727,
0.303451269865036,
-0.21902836859226227,
1.1318857669830322,
0.151231050491333,
0.619167685508728,
-0.3767985999584198,
0.6925145983695984,
-0.11537110805511475,
0.17059938609600067,
-0.0019068066030740738,
-0.6947478652000427,
-0.638270914554596,
0.35618820786476135,
-0.5904205441474915,
-0.2645489573478699,
0.7552486658096313,
0.8032819032669067,
-0.11554025113582611,
0.2580214738845825,
0.06471241265535355,
0.7645623087882996,
0.4010257124900818,
0.19098028540611267,
0.972435474395752,
-0.06010712683200836,
0.42787280678749084,
0.29213035106658936,
-0.25165727734565735,
-0.5646899342536926,
-1.0485495328903198,
-0.7366506457328796,
-0.32351794838905334,
-0.5385315418243408,
-0.49256616830825806,
0.14124760031700134,
0.7818881273269653,
0.4605077803134918,
-0.7571391463279724,
0.24809180200099945,
0.06429705768823624,
0.07163839787244797,
0.032999083399772644,
-0.18857687711715698,
0.42421025037765503,
-0.10518230497837067,
-0.266528457403183,
0.6631948947906494,
0.27871283888816833,
0.34206950664520264,
-0.3526923954486847,
0.03334487974643707,
-0.24060183763504028,
0.3832622766494751,
0.48664090037345886,
0.6698757410049438,
-0.6828750967979431,
-0.3568018674850464,
-0.034435030072927475,
-0.2256954461336136,
-0.05386132001876831,
0.7265635132789612,
-0.6934087872505188,
0.05110159516334534,
0.5162940621376038,
0.5835347771644592,
0.36506387591362,
-0.04440910369157791,
0.3683221638202667,
-0.6533805727958679,
-0.03746572881937027,
0.36370721459388733,
0.286395788192749,
0.4487258791923523,
-0.4932655394077301,
0.09410078823566437,
0.3591509163379669,
-0.6553263664245605,
-0.9902203679084778,
-0.03970625624060631,
-0.8965963125228882,
-0.20147033035755157,
1.3621389865875244,
0.034289781004190445,
-0.4810864329338074,
-0.1905488669872284,
-0.20474161207675934,
-0.013113316148519516,
-0.44110041856765747,
1.1127564907073975,
0.8677123188972473,
-0.06542228162288666,
-0.1302986592054367,
-0.5075696110725403,
0.41649186611175537,
0.13155923783779144,
-0.6929335594177246,
0.10605693608522415,
0.6329171657562256,
0.3681892454624176,
0.46270546317100525,
0.293369859457016,
-0.07492773234844208,
0.4420894384384155,
-0.1581363081932068,
-0.10593793541193008,
-0.3027695417404175,
-0.4180549383163452,
-0.09672674536705017,
0.07473070174455643,
-0.13105559349060059,
0.2265963852405548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14259v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14259v1
|
Word-Sequence Entropy: Towards Uncertainty Estimation in Free-Form Medical Question Answering Applications and Beyond
| 2024-02-22T03:46:08 | 2024-02-22T03:46:08 |
Zhiyuan Wang, Jinhao Duan, Chenxi Yuan, Qingyu Chen, Tianlong Chen, Huaxiu Yao, Yue Zhang, Ren Wang, Kaidi Xu, Xiaoshuang Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Uncertainty estimation plays a pivotal role in ensuring the reliability of
safety-critical human-AI interaction systems, particularly in the medical
domain. However, a general method for quantifying the uncertainty of free-form
answers has yet to be established in open-ended medical question-answering (QA)
tasks, where irrelevant words and sequences with limited semantic information
can be the primary source of uncertainty due to the presence of generative
inequality. In this paper, we propose the Word-Sequence Entropy (WSE), which
calibrates the uncertainty proportion at both the word and sequence levels
according to the semantic relevance, with greater emphasis placed on keywords
and more relevant sequences when performing uncertainty quantification. We
compare WSE with 6 baseline methods on 5 free-form medical QA datasets,
utilizing 7 "off-the-shelf" large language models (LLMs), and show that WSE
exhibits superior performance on accurate uncertainty measurement under two
standard criteria for correctness evaluation (e.g., WSE outperforms existing
state-of-the-art method by 3.23% AUROC on the MedQA dataset). Additionally, in
terms of the potential for real-world medical QA applications, we achieve a
significant enhancement in the performance of LLMs when employing sequences
with lower uncertainty, identified by WSE, as final answers (e.g., +6.36%
accuracy improvement on the COVID-QA dataset), without requiring any additional
task-specific fine-tuning or architectural modifications.
|
[
-0.041151054203510284,
-0.47717806696891785,
0.9153438806533813,
-0.11206159740686417,
-0.46254315972328186,
-0.18123531341552734,
0.07179562002420425,
-0.395205020904541,
0.3342747092247009,
-0.10503236949443817,
-0.4989955723285675,
-0.36958032846450806,
-0.8187821507453918,
0.022682709619402885,
-0.12992960214614868,
0.3991466760635376,
-0.1275918185710907,
0.3065817952156067,
-0.6562154293060303,
-0.1045767292380333,
-0.41013258695602417,
-0.2595372200012207,
-0.3560187518596649,
-0.06884562969207764,
0.5911940336227417,
0.02845638245344162,
0.8789430856704712,
0.398985356092453,
0.5783612132072449,
0.2670939862728119,
0.08348700404167175,
0.10018117725849152,
0.10689546167850494,
0.44757235050201416,
-0.04989243671298027,
-0.6227276921272278,
-0.3528365194797516,
-0.22976437211036682,
0.12059421092271805,
0.5454975962638855,
-0.394615113735199,
0.3422030508518219,
-0.038733769208192825,
0.7069385051727295,
-0.9658476114273071,
-0.024434460327029228,
-0.4939234256744385,
0.10737041383981705,
-0.08165474981069565,
-0.23626255989074707,
-0.16310229897499084,
-0.3494860529899597,
0.2135213017463684,
-0.8002405166625977,
-0.15504702925682068,
0.10151670128107071,
0.806184709072113,
0.688933789730072,
-0.10248216986656189,
-0.17753465473651886,
-0.6065979599952698,
0.5742826461791992,
-1.0451828241348267,
0.7513800263404846,
0.6405213475227356,
0.0317193865776062,
-0.0223060455173254,
-0.5155781507492065,
-0.45717930793762207,
0.16882742941379547,
0.5058053731918335,
0.31085118651390076,
-0.17090857028961182,
0.40629005432128906,
-0.14124272763729095,
0.38232681155204773,
-0.7927978038787842,
0.18006183207035065,
-0.2847535014152527,
-0.38884779810905457,
0.5484432578086853,
0.19991594552993774,
0.33997514843940735,
0.1613355427980423,
-0.05364982411265373,
-0.1437164843082428,
-0.49519553780555725,
0.1073295921087265,
-0.16369913518428802,
-0.09174343198537827,
-0.07859590649604797,
0.7089899182319641,
-0.13091811537742615,
0.8375996947288513,
-0.10497314482927322,
-0.25706714391708374,
0.2569228410720825,
-0.04172623157501221,
-0.4816036522388458,
-0.1434592455625534,
0.7576795816421509,
0.3698737323284149,
-0.10433124750852585,
-0.4281560480594635,
-0.007487194146960974,
0.020671695470809937,
0.24989177286624908,
-0.6748762130737305,
0.12000668793916702,
0.825377345085144,
-0.2065252959728241,
-0.19052736461162567,
0.23508106172084808,
-0.7293158173561096,
-0.48710596561431885,
-0.1096450686454773,
0.6330341696739197,
-0.4276754856109619,
0.053366243839263916,
0.40224266052246094,
-0.23826080560684204,
0.2026241272687912,
0.32020333409309387,
-0.41477999091148376,
-0.054635435342788696,
0.6716899275779724,
0.8660050630569458,
-0.025078656151890755,
-0.024504609405994415,
-0.4853408634662628,
-0.05662396177649498,
-0.5986648797988892,
0.4351558983325958,
-0.3974195122718811,
-0.2257334142923355,
-0.21763122081756592,
-0.22862926125526428,
-0.12205003201961517,
-0.4099678099155426,
0.2722596526145935,
-0.7113143801689148,
0.36872175335884094,
0.09432977437973022,
-0.8605467081069946,
-0.0027577406726777554,
0.19444134831428528,
-0.3954794406890869,
0.6404122114181519,
0.047883108258247375,
-0.8770007491111755,
0.336955189704895,
-0.33238282799720764,
-0.1329738199710846,
0.15121765434741974,
-0.16422195732593536,
-0.2501935362815857,
0.413963258266449,
0.24640372395515442,
0.26629966497421265,
-0.6604443192481995,
0.2794719636440277,
-0.4179834723472595,
-0.3089633882045746,
0.5345824360847473,
-0.6156134009361267,
0.525597095489502,
0.2690676748752594,
-0.0321216806769371,
0.04162338748574257,
-0.5993080139160156,
0.5109009742736816,
-0.18007107079029083,
-0.04326428845524788,
-0.6704821586608887,
0.10792605578899384,
-0.6136481165885925,
0.2915881872177124,
0.28959140181541443,
-0.7411576509475708,
-0.1226285919547081,
-0.7477599382400513,
0.2224014401435852,
0.41911187767982483,
0.1719491183757782,
0.3214939534664154,
-0.47581955790519714,
0.9184829592704773,
0.0684504434466362,
0.2347574084997177,
0.4008471667766571,
-0.9109652638435364,
-0.08719871193170547,
-0.34695005416870117,
0.6587028503417969,
1.2813750505447388,
-0.920391321182251,
0.5337712168693542,
-0.3425544798374176,
-0.5594929456710815,
-0.8651431798934937,
-0.08783820271492004,
0.28934845328330994,
0.39149904251098633,
0.3709545135498047,
-0.4910827875137329,
-0.42151522636413574,
-0.3344375789165497,
-0.1477997601032257,
-0.5904725790023804,
-0.6187945008277893,
0.21689754724502563,
0.1320747286081314,
-0.1769801527261734,
0.7665957808494568,
-0.768527090549469,
0.16458560526371002,
0.20881040394306183,
0.14957742393016815,
0.07464349269866943,
0.2081647664308548,
-0.016501938924193382,
-0.5327410697937012,
0.1079283133149147,
-0.46610867977142334,
-0.646470844745636,
-0.05218043923377991,
0.21245460212230682,
-0.16283158957958221,
0.10460405051708221,
0.22131767868995667,
-0.6340392231941223,
0.5844663381576538,
0.7121849656105042,
-0.33001506328582764,
0.39211881160736084,
-0.3034060001373291,
0.17378559708595276,
-1.4273793697357178,
0.05632900819182396,
-0.03840211033821106,
0.12485668808221817,
-0.6537196040153503,
0.2306443601846695,
0.14893843233585358,
0.017532922327518463,
-0.476586252450943,
0.570292592048645,
-0.20802833139896393,
0.2288108915090561,
0.04067583754658699,
-0.09653586149215698,
0.23791161179542542,
0.08782869577407837,
-0.06570152193307877,
0.9424217343330383,
0.47829025983810425,
-0.4674645960330963,
0.2882884442806244,
0.09094897657632828,
-0.5385956168174744,
0.4338083267211914,
-0.6762727499008179,
0.02691049687564373,
-0.2834194302558899,
-0.022040920332074165,
-0.7950761318206787,
-0.29873573780059814,
0.1456528604030609,
-0.5605512857437134,
0.20709194242954254,
0.22216260433197021,
-0.22306528687477112,
-0.5358852744102478,
-0.4123857617378235,
0.6432731747627258,
0.56425541639328,
0.26606833934783936,
-0.041336335241794586,
0.31160685420036316,
-0.25960084795951843,
-0.7224850058555603,
-0.76718670129776,
0.023335982114076614,
-0.1417604386806488,
-0.7373965978622437,
0.2736775875091553,
-0.13946187496185303,
-0.2336672991514206,
-0.195043683052063,
-0.3636988699436188,
-0.4010242819786072,
0.19913709163665771,
0.26634758710861206,
0.35545429587364197,
-0.3374435603618622,
0.3765193819999695,
0.13868685066699982,
0.17326968908309937,
-0.08120585978031158,
-0.46021202206611633,
0.3538818061351776,
0.13532452285289764,
-0.6004730463027954,
-0.40201690793037415,
0.36769288778305054,
0.752442479133606,
-0.21484751999378204,
0.7165572643280029,
0.3684436082839966,
-0.7030988931655884,
0.46446022391319275,
-0.31470754742622375,
-0.17651157081127167,
-0.41259345412254333,
0.30034342408180237,
-0.0799713283777237,
-1.0201491117477417,
0.48815634846687317,
0.36644887924194336,
-0.1376163214445114,
0.5805698037147522,
0.3325657248497009,
-0.31456899642944336,
0.8775629997253418,
0.24931690096855164,
-0.14558930695056915,
0.060455065220594406,
0.2529253661632538,
0.17983415722846985,
-0.6508930921554565,
-0.0929860770702362,
-0.492268830537796,
-0.11513818800449371,
-0.34769245982170105,
-0.7945771217346191,
0.7761452794075012,
0.1682116538286209,
-0.3063395917415619,
-0.05978004261851311,
-0.39945974946022034,
0.016322089359164238,
0.5818201899528503,
0.40838485956192017,
0.08589540421962738,
-0.1561482846736908,
-0.09350217878818512,
0.1355273723602295,
-0.6035417318344116,
-0.08460214734077454,
0.922106921672821,
0.29184219241142273,
0.882116436958313,
0.08391139656305313,
0.8577598333358765,
0.14956854283809662,
-0.07696712762117386,
-0.7245568037033081,
0.22384753823280334,
-0.0772850438952446,
-0.3943161964416504,
-0.7555497884750366,
-0.5987367630004883,
-1.0332844257354736,
-0.002315778285264969,
-0.013852890580892563,
-0.7846530079841614,
0.3412511944770813,
0.11468382179737091,
-1.015089988708496,
0.38104692101478577,
-0.4331577718257904,
0.689579427242279,
-0.0036694903392344713,
0.006982723250985146,
0.13139599561691284,
-0.9695310592651367,
0.13443197309970856,
-0.16093809902668,
0.1673436015844345,
-0.19297228753566742,
-0.4219200313091278,
0.6060205101966858,
-0.8308724164962769,
0.6716673374176025,
-0.22985808551311493,
-0.5650674700737,
0.4031497836112976,
-0.05646462365984917,
0.45059797167778015,
-0.004650978371500969,
-0.23996026813983917,
0.258845716714859,
0.6126251220703125,
-0.3864183723926544,
-0.5349912643432617,
0.08592210710048676,
-0.5769200325012207,
-0.47319433093070984,
-0.4639367163181305,
-0.6340678930282593,
-0.6312122344970703,
0.018330741673707962,
0.7454410791397095,
0.4205408990383148,
-0.05164284631609917,
-0.0032187022734433413,
0.6574015617370605,
-0.546726405620575,
0.1879405528306961,
0.192355677485466,
0.36063411831855774,
-0.59502774477005,
0.7122727632522583,
0.21189919114112854,
0.2586135268211365,
0.7880123853683472,
0.24234119057655334,
-0.4032627046108246,
-0.5415114760398865,
-0.6892759799957275,
-0.038645826280117035,
-0.20265604555606842,
-0.6505898237228394,
-0.37690454721450806,
-0.37967801094055176,
-0.5247721672058105,
-0.03241509199142456,
0.0054332539439201355,
-0.6171130537986755,
-0.28332599997520447,
0.06828721612691879,
0.5287936925888062,
0.25385427474975586,
-0.012060283683240414,
0.014606575481593609,
-1.170478105545044,
0.42381465435028076,
0.39705604314804077,
0.5950466990470886,
-0.2838878631591797,
-0.6641819477081299,
-0.10589168220758438,
0.4259808361530304,
-0.12600000202655792,
-1.2243552207946777,
0.36170539259910583,
0.45151105523109436,
0.18729843199253082,
0.3208438754081726,
0.28155404329299927,
0.6804336905479431,
-0.37440600991249084,
1.061513900756836,
0.20052342116832733,
-0.6800103783607483,
0.459322452545166,
0.046000756323337555,
0.47953468561172485,
0.6182129383087158,
0.12183628231287003,
-0.7359432578086853,
-0.6591009497642517,
-0.49504584074020386,
-1.0872316360473633,
0.1480025053024292,
0.11182444542646408,
-0.04561753198504448,
-0.10847777873277664,
0.4014372229576111,
-0.16434471309185028,
0.33606383204460144,
0.020371055230498314,
-0.06361965090036392,
0.08782307058572769,
-0.7530404925346375,
0.14999724924564362,
-0.16057710349559784,
0.019081976264715195,
-0.13577967882156372,
0.7556483745574951,
-0.10725751519203186,
0.7011949419975281,
0.44447264075279236,
-0.178767591714859,
-0.24443015456199646,
0.6484506726264954,
0.7932214140892029,
0.531340479850769,
-0.32222288846969604,
0.06108503416180611,
0.3532450199127197,
-0.7359356880187988,
0.4134122133255005,
0.11955616623163223,
-0.20108868181705475,
-0.044583264738321304,
0.26426395773887634,
0.4812103509902954,
-0.25958165526390076,
-0.9344062209129333,
0.7619272470474243,
0.0010898313485085964,
0.015682440251111984,
-0.07278577983379364,
-0.04701400175690651,
-0.08386882394552231,
0.11160454154014587,
0.17459620535373688,
0.03260310739278793,
0.3283914029598236,
0.0388338528573513,
0.45725753903388977,
0.33176252245903015,
-0.5726667642593384,
-0.1697194129228592,
0.8286375999450684,
-0.2392444759607315,
0.06707064807415009,
0.48664167523384094,
-0.07847946882247925,
0.030864425003528595,
0.7514657378196716,
0.33315983414649963,
1.067022442817688,
-0.5119430422782898,
0.13330800831317902,
0.25264862179756165,
0.18568462133407593,
-0.23192742466926575,
0.8819815516471863,
0.2612643241882324,
-0.7053292393684387,
-0.6603357791900635,
-0.6882108449935913,
-0.476175457239151,
-0.0990288108587265,
-0.8787869215011597,
-0.24024872481822968,
-0.15728922188282013,
-0.28761276602745056,
-0.3692921996116638,
-0.3735237717628479,
-0.6032324433326721,
0.38542988896369934,
0.3045847415924072,
1.0561878681182861,
-0.5676524639129639,
0.6350418925285339,
0.6355862617492676,
-0.29302778840065,
-0.7751027941703796,
0.1764402836561203,
0.08235055208206177,
-0.8836032152175903,
-0.06982839107513428,
-0.08273639529943466,
-0.006186902057379484,
-0.2215566188097,
-0.356955885887146,
-1.0826612710952759,
1.2680766582489014,
0.3481591045856476,
-0.4824420213699341,
-0.3079897165298462,
0.2834071218967438,
0.5421133637428284,
0.13305702805519104,
-0.03966563940048218,
0.15722209215164185,
0.12998522818088531,
0.036222100257873535,
-0.9443062543869019,
0.22850963473320007,
-0.24878782033920288,
0.15107311308383942,
0.39882341027259827,
-0.21088692545890808,
0.12711240351200104,
-0.4661043882369995,
-0.08543282002210617,
0.5003066062927246,
0.7483229041099548,
0.24454207718372345,
0.5376933813095093,
0.4670255184173584,
0.818967878818512,
1.1462228298187256,
-0.08093854039907455,
0.9342581629753113,
-0.6578671336174011,
0.008215443231165409,
0.9670469760894775,
-0.2124161422252655,
0.9968792796134949,
0.5208427906036377,
-0.41777125000953674,
0.43165290355682373,
0.799958348274231,
0.5171375870704651,
0.4806503355503082,
0.4338715970516205,
-0.47828376293182373,
-0.12472313642501831,
0.06482326239347458,
-0.3982202112674713,
0.1789228916168213,
0.7039197683334351,
-0.25873804092407227,
0.06469911336898804,
0.13502642512321472,
-0.05191582068800926,
-0.5360554456710815,
-0.2790428400039673,
0.9388266801834106,
0.2567276060581207,
-0.7685301303863525,
0.5293663144111633,
0.04683650657534599,
0.5547685027122498,
-0.6346989870071411,
0.2771642804145813,
-0.12979631125926971,
-0.1813821941614151,
-0.06144324317574501,
-0.7695155143737793,
0.35871800780296326,
-0.002658671699464321,
-0.09556274861097336,
0.3314526677131653,
0.5632593035697937,
-0.5320904850959778,
-0.5127550959587097,
-0.30970966815948486,
0.6770151257514954,
0.16782592236995697,
-0.35309213399887085,
-0.5566012263298035,
-0.3909358084201813,
-0.2856767475605011,
-0.044580526649951935,
0.0701453760266304,
0.5645009875297546,
-0.07931511849164963,
0.5392704010009766,
0.09658635407686234,
0.25173527002334595,
0.253637433052063,
-0.08692798763513565,
0.2918710708618164,
-0.471490740776062,
-0.3919341564178467,
-0.8073087334632874,
0.4315318465232849,
0.24487338960170746,
-0.37741678953170776,
0.14603686332702637,
0.38818103075027466,
0.490281879901886,
-0.07084250450134277,
0.6848242878913879,
-0.18975503742694855,
0.2898189425468445,
-0.45852550864219666,
0.5459174513816833,
-0.7621631026268005,
-0.007670265622437,
-0.3260766565799713,
-0.2511828541755676,
-0.5929990410804749,
0.32987773418426514,
0.00611504539847374,
-0.215248703956604,
0.5415230393409729,
0.8796808123588562,
0.13993942737579346,
-0.02145400643348694,
0.5349406003952026,
-0.0030055041424930096,
-0.08252652734518051,
0.6732248067855835,
0.4299473464488983,
-0.604261577129364,
0.24516154825687408,
-0.21096011996269226,
-0.32430732250213623,
0.051332250237464905,
-0.7291005849838257,
0.07206164300441742,
-0.7164397835731506,
-0.4209690988063812,
-0.5712561011314392,
0.1903565675020218,
1.1961112022399902,
0.476945698261261,
-1.015964388847351,
0.1644894927740097,
0.0873732641339302,
0.08242295682430267,
-0.5763184428215027,
-0.10327011346817017,
0.5237026810646057,
-0.3655408024787903,
-0.23605561256408691,
0.332063227891922,
0.3443991243839264,
0.16666167974472046,
0.17340809106826782,
-0.09484969824552536,
0.1000375896692276,
0.6017196178436279,
0.5323234796524048,
0.39758867025375366,
-0.8047900199890137,
-0.423246830701828,
0.3016951382160187,
-0.2519111633300781,
0.08168133348226547,
0.4285627007484436,
-0.412372350692749,
0.400135338306427,
0.6979156136512756,
0.951945960521698,
-0.2357216328382492,
0.08544695377349854,
0.6341301798820496,
-0.8525490164756775,
-0.12180285155773163,
0.2466442584991455,
0.41953331232070923,
0.11238528788089752,
-0.440737247467041,
0.45936301350593567,
0.21507661044597626,
-0.44372859597206116,
-0.6153027415275574,
0.22530940175056458,
-0.8562362790107727,
-0.30884721875190735,
1.18110191822052,
-0.018007507547736168,
-0.15381747484207153,
-0.1500897854566574,
0.08725925534963608,
0.4102972745895386,
-0.1377684473991394,
0.8175556659698486,
0.6914045810699463,
-0.06096605584025383,
-0.05560258775949478,
-0.3949548304080963,
0.4366915225982666,
0.575814962387085,
-0.8475496172904968,
-0.22905361652374268,
0.41151684522628784,
0.19237051904201508,
0.0807289183139801,
0.6601886749267578,
-0.2406432032585144,
0.33341020345687866,
-0.4124051034450531,
0.25035953521728516,
0.37314102053642273,
-0.186349555850029,
-0.4198301434516907,
0.16174830496311188,
0.35790491104125977,
-0.6108146905899048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14258v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14258v1
|
Eagle: Ethical Dataset Given from Real Interactions
| 2024-02-22T03:46:02 | 2024-02-22T03:46:02 |
Masahiro Kaneko, Danushka Bollegala, Timothy Baldwin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent studies have demonstrated that large language models (LLMs) have
ethical-related problems such as social biases, lack of moral reasoning, and
generation of offensive content. The existing evaluation metrics and methods to
address these ethical challenges use datasets intentionally created by
instructing humans to create instances including ethical problems. Therefore,
the data does not reflect prompts that users actually provide when utilizing
LLM services in everyday contexts. This may not lead to the development of safe
LLMs that can address ethical challenges arising in real-world applications. In
this paper, we create Eagle datasets extracted from real interactions between
ChatGPT and users that exhibit social biases, toxicity, and immoral problems.
Our experiments show that Eagle captures complementary aspects, not covered by
existing datasets proposed for evaluation and mitigation of such ethical
challenges. Our code is publicly available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/MasahiroKaneko/eagle.
|
[
-0.13280977308750153,
-0.934309184551239,
0.3026050329208374,
0.37199464440345764,
-0.006961172446608543,
-0.005249857436865568,
-0.13712038099765778,
-0.9782328605651855,
0.33639296889305115,
0.9014540910720825,
-0.7454797625541687,
-0.34711167216300964,
-0.5192227363586426,
0.09533323347568512,
-0.35729721188545227,
0.9849870800971985,
0.2781262993812561,
0.08482855558395386,
0.15180610120296478,
-0.2927536964416504,
-0.20926433801651,
-0.7890359163284302,
-1.0353745222091675,
-0.06814111769199371,
0.43472594022750854,
0.5587320923805237,
0.7759140729904175,
0.8717102408409119,
0.617518424987793,
0.2343892604112625,
-0.046478960663080215,
0.09911841154098511,
-0.9282670021057129,
0.06306511163711548,
0.021950451657176018,
-0.06159782409667969,
-0.23129615187644958,
0.29929104447364807,
0.40821900963783264,
0.4408215880393982,
-0.0063874744810163975,
0.5014441609382629,
-0.007789566181600094,
0.5639028549194336,
-0.5730390548706055,
0.11459382623434067,
-0.49753785133361816,
0.4141043722629547,
-0.15723519027233124,
-0.2693358063697815,
-0.249481201171875,
-0.5316596031188965,
0.08780582249164581,
-0.6518864035606384,
-0.2929714620113373,
0.35297664999961853,
0.7365419864654541,
0.0581689216196537,
-0.4773663580417633,
-0.8237909078598022,
-0.5809469819068909,
0.919497549533844,
-0.8057019710540771,
0.21312275528907776,
0.6272745728492737,
0.32016706466674805,
-0.30389904975891113,
-0.5352118611335754,
-0.6788303852081299,
-0.18208402395248413,
0.07183810323476791,
-0.05743277072906494,
-0.06756119430065155,
-0.12439293414354324,
-0.10423793643712997,
0.4145625829696655,
-0.2459048628807068,
0.33323436975479126,
-0.337181031703949,
-0.2668135464191437,
0.7982982993125916,
0.4230137765407562,
0.38595351576805115,
-0.3448825180530548,
-0.3060775399208069,
-0.3351258337497711,
-0.9213926196098328,
0.4016162157058716,
0.9068537950515747,
0.448636919260025,
-0.25176167488098145,
0.7209361791610718,
-0.018021652474999428,
0.27458456158638,
-0.005785186309367418,
0.21090270578861237,
0.34340137243270874,
-0.2521050274372101,
-0.13046957552433014,
0.2185318022966385,
0.8114567995071411,
0.7760573625564575,
0.66135573387146,
-0.017706122249364853,
0.02802393212914467,
-0.17617107927799225,
0.04771595820784569,
-0.8526936173439026,
0.22239352762699127,
0.4619145393371582,
-0.8389684557914734,
-0.7663669586181641,
0.09815403819084167,
-0.6543685793876648,
-0.658838152885437,
-0.3074946701526642,
-0.01450975053012371,
-0.07117974013090134,
-0.5716919898986816,
0.3598592281341553,
0.16864420473575592,
0.5774536728858948,
-0.11783833801746368,
-0.5880360007286072,
0.4084455370903015,
1.0305525064468384,
0.661474883556366,
0.3451153337955475,
-0.21393485367298126,
-0.8954798579216003,
0.13700078427791595,
-0.30692604184150696,
0.5085839033126831,
-0.8919941186904907,
-0.38880857825279236,
0.3409949243068695,
0.1561577171087265,
0.3530224859714508,
-0.5574240684509277,
0.9342573881149292,
-0.32897791266441345,
-0.1426662802696228,
-0.8765085935592651,
-0.4784698486328125,
-0.09965966641902924,
0.29627132415771484,
-0.603618860244751,
0.7864143252372742,
-0.5232529640197754,
-0.8309867978096008,
0.40838563442230225,
-0.9454079866409302,
-0.2828631103038788,
0.227339506149292,
-0.3853369951248169,
-0.3106957674026489,
-0.45445767045021057,
0.2756371796131134,
0.5373527407646179,
-0.022722991183400154,
0.11490149796009064,
-0.6754878163337708,
-0.49284428358078003,
0.39982789754867554,
-0.2535059452056885,
1.1693495512008667,
0.42648911476135254,
-0.21924656629562378,
0.06397243589162827,
-0.6195605993270874,
-0.14837267994880676,
0.20059294998645782,
-0.1987130045890808,
-0.4821053445339203,
0.10466637462377548,
0.3707861602306366,
0.13204479217529297,
0.18536317348480225,
-0.7271156311035156,
-0.1298156976699829,
-0.24017316102981567,
0.34807437658309937,
1.0570846796035767,
0.23031623661518097,
0.14120438694953918,
-0.5145811438560486,
0.4198022484779358,
-0.18833322823047638,
0.4606427252292633,
0.4958856403827667,
-0.33262044191360474,
-0.6296291947364807,
-0.2559272050857544,
-0.159299835562706,
0.7264005541801453,
-0.3463868498802185,
0.33678051829338074,
-0.31728595495224,
-0.23106981813907623,
-0.6200609803199768,
0.22226682305335999,
0.5575478672981262,
0.4899425506591797,
-0.042136382311582565,
0.061566561460494995,
-0.41397929191589355,
-1.1625988483428955,
-0.46630194783210754,
-0.21091176569461823,
-0.20032259821891785,
0.875102162361145,
0.327024906873703,
-0.2142373025417328,
0.8235174417495728,
-0.07012034952640533,
-0.47686541080474854,
0.031419720500707626,
0.3214550018310547,
-0.16393524408340454,
0.5301312804222107,
0.5312283039093018,
-0.8428604006767273,
-0.1300976723432541,
-0.24495616555213928,
-1.1376177072525024,
-0.1766018271446228,
-0.1701483428478241,
-0.3302382826805115,
-0.2010556161403656,
0.3947061002254486,
-0.24514341354370117,
0.23765595257282257,
0.4323883056640625,
-0.41138121485710144,
0.460610955953598,
0.10450291633605957,
0.39200419187545776,
-0.9647318720817566,
0.0151272714138031,
0.24062277376651764,
-0.1309843808412552,
-0.3271139860153198,
-0.007094232831150293,
-0.38386794924736023,
-0.09123606979846954,
-0.8354712724685669,
0.6852185726165771,
-0.17188909649848938,
-0.18719130754470825,
-0.022440779954195023,
-0.1101626455783844,
-0.23817849159240723,
0.03357233107089996,
0.1206846833229065,
0.8317486047744751,
0.4531809687614441,
-0.3683156371116638,
0.4159754812717438,
0.6672449707984924,
-0.3005335032939911,
0.667946994304657,
-0.7560340166091919,
0.17213018238544464,
-0.038107410073280334,
0.2224285900592804,
-0.20959709584712982,
-0.2777773439884186,
0.8340944051742554,
-0.32817956805229187,
-0.45219942927360535,
-0.13170892000198364,
-0.9094083309173584,
0.08037839829921722,
-0.7161356806755066,
0.48263269662857056,
0.42746326327323914,
-0.5396940112113953,
0.21910104155540466,
0.7237507700920105,
-0.26589691638946533,
-0.7682175636291504,
-0.8229002952575684,
0.4762158989906311,
-0.46372050046920776,
-0.715170681476593,
-0.3495633900165558,
0.04484729841351509,
-0.5732385516166687,
0.17247632145881653,
0.3644891083240509,
-0.03861641883850098,
-0.10621615499258041,
0.35208192467689514,
0.01589689403772354,
-0.17061679065227509,
0.025035906583070755,
-0.09102584421634674,
0.11387427896261215,
0.34315091371536255,
0.3662612736225128,
0.23312172293663025,
-0.657766580581665,
-0.4857580065727234,
-0.4510287046432495,
0.5629534721374512,
0.10298489034175873,
-0.2902735471725464,
0.7576280832290649,
0.45590874552726746,
-0.5372079610824585,
0.14350685477256775,
-0.5995423793792725,
-0.3025963306427002,
-0.558485209941864,
0.22569523751735687,
0.08681610971689224,
-1.0610419511795044,
0.8244245648384094,
0.15583978593349457,
0.46501457691192627,
-0.11699160933494568,
0.47233062982559204,
-0.1965445727109909,
0.7878237366676331,
0.45442676544189453,
0.01761889085173607,
0.3119654059410095,
-0.13348816335201263,
0.2707003653049469,
-0.9656099677085876,
-0.10841871798038483,
-0.23024272918701172,
-0.23973646759986877,
-0.6775797605514526,
0.05018240585923195,
0.1793031245470047,
-0.30253124237060547,
-0.3611925542354584,
-0.03195672482252121,
-0.3661567270755768,
0.7168670892715454,
0.2448042929172516,
0.32890066504478455,
0.36149418354034424,
-0.038614239543676376,
0.3935900628566742,
0.012958218343555927,
-0.4132594168186188,
-1.0582342147827148,
1.1899821758270264,
0.4021493196487427,
0.7904719114303589,
0.18547724187374115,
0.5976220369338989,
0.7117571234703064,
0.3461379408836365,
-0.5921714901924133,
0.6497906446456909,
-0.11765910685062408,
-0.811944305896759,
-0.28263604640960693,
-0.7350236773490906,
-1.1315228939056396,
-0.029208434745669365,
-0.354623019695282,
-0.913861870765686,
0.23512598872184753,
0.08771542459726334,
-0.3346621096134186,
0.1628841906785965,
-0.5977973937988281,
0.6636567115783691,
-0.4117283821105957,
-0.5851424336433411,
-0.02747202292084694,
-0.7627774477005005,
0.47416266798973083,
-0.031595997512340546,
0.5119651556015015,
-0.09056540578603745,
0.20738935470581055,
1.0587029457092285,
-0.5263920426368713,
1.0807665586471558,
-0.02873673290014267,
-0.07365235686302185,
0.44204530119895935,
0.06088748201727867,
0.5441983938217163,
0.34207412600517273,
-0.2718273401260376,
0.0771351307630539,
0.19142721593379974,
-0.47074130177497864,
-0.15570655465126038,
0.9315276741981506,
-0.7520535588264465,
-0.3643828332424164,
-0.5854776501655579,
-0.6496393084526062,
-0.3278108835220337,
0.1925574243068695,
-0.12827704846858978,
0.42288169264793396,
-0.10906025022268295,
0.3567522466182709,
0.5096871852874756,
-0.40044933557510376,
0.15357255935668945,
0.5752273797988892,
-0.21036075055599213,
-0.04662420228123665,
0.7835342884063721,
0.0983918085694313,
-0.0418996624648571,
-0.35158437490463257,
0.1991322785615921,
-0.37777647376060486,
-0.1892755627632141,
-0.39974939823150635,
0.29959818720817566,
-0.8770591616630554,
0.046453043818473816,
-0.3251323401927948,
-0.17662517726421356,
-0.13615256547927856,
-0.2845524549484253,
-0.4216923415660858,
-0.04352402687072754,
-0.18068158626556396,
-0.38146156072616577,
0.6078844666481018,
0.6559398770332336,
-0.23460744321346283,
0.28023526072502136,
-0.8689215183258057,
0.1533532589673996,
0.17940278351306915,
0.5249645113945007,
-0.029805559664964676,
-0.020170263946056366,
0.05507699027657509,
0.4836510121822357,
-0.05707212910056114,
-0.4829326868057251,
0.1200372502207756,
0.15905313193798065,
0.4818003177642822,
0.2693423628807068,
0.3898408114910126,
0.7301369905471802,
-0.1797165721654892,
0.6212506294250488,
-0.3101121783256531,
-0.7039057612419128,
0.15528742969036102,
-0.5418458580970764,
-0.3975273370742798,
0.6930421590805054,
0.2530100643634796,
-0.6768620014190674,
-0.43725186586380005,
-0.5587127804756165,
-0.8178613781929016,
0.5889077186584473,
0.7558407783508301,
0.3579087555408478,
-0.0012453714152798057,
0.6066691875457764,
0.05435953289270401,
0.12737202644348145,
-0.8133055567741394,
-0.13578692078590393,
-0.1403835266828537,
-0.37389621138572693,
0.34277310967445374,
-0.19153118133544922,
-0.28625696897506714,
0.16490928828716278,
0.7163578867912292,
0.3059839606285095,
-0.05539737269282341,
0.06546507030725479,
-0.10359025746583939,
-0.3458741009235382,
0.14329059422016144,
0.38618430495262146,
0.7559227347373962,
-0.46510592103004456,
-0.08789723366498947,
-0.06311868131160736,
-0.5231249332427979,
-0.00610785186290741,
-0.1119745671749115,
0.13648493587970734,
-0.6108919978141785,
0.42278796434402466,
0.14158453047275543,
0.09187208116054535,
-1.0004210472106934,
0.6652154326438904,
-0.4259941875934601,
-0.12101928144693375,
-0.6432260870933533,
-0.08326136320829391,
0.06739726662635803,
0.39794549345970154,
0.3835296630859375,
-0.37954041361808777,
0.3733920156955719,
-0.42327797412872314,
0.28544867038726807,
0.6230250000953674,
-0.24420757591724396,
-0.09932886064052582,
0.41923218965530396,
0.4997175633907318,
-0.4015277326107025,
0.7277871966362,
-0.1264769285917282,
-0.2734941244125366,
0.653559684753418,
0.21922527253627777,
0.6520713567733765,
0.23216837644577026,
0.17526261508464813,
-0.008672616444528103,
0.49280986189842224,
0.11587982624769211,
0.2849876880645752,
0.1878419667482376,
-0.8273510336875916,
-0.4023781418800354,
-0.49066489934921265,
-0.6841535568237305,
0.7590005397796631,
-0.774467945098877,
0.202353835105896,
-0.5768451690673828,
0.11615671962499619,
-0.14487220346927643,
0.10608920454978943,
-0.38910436630249023,
-0.007482343818992376,
-0.05529708415269852,
0.7708963751792908,
-1.1342015266418457,
0.43847960233688354,
0.5871806144714355,
-0.4981486201286316,
-0.5610256195068359,
-0.13195784389972687,
0.2224026322364807,
-1.079988956451416,
0.6123042106628418,
0.2290733903646469,
-0.3980504870414734,
-0.25969332456588745,
-0.8267321586608887,
-0.24586476385593414,
0.7237740159034729,
0.4867480397224426,
-0.3023526966571808,
0.36964452266693115,
0.6547367572784424,
0.45583248138427734,
-0.4433245062828064,
-0.10461455583572388,
0.17294779419898987,
0.5558308362960815,
0.02103293500840664,
-0.6536269187927246,
0.13983245193958282,
-0.5327218174934387,
-0.19033223390579224,
-0.2321256548166275,
-0.8204591274261475,
0.688165545463562,
0.30808305740356445,
-0.06604175269603729,
-0.15876853466033936,
0.2933030426502228,
0.48866143822669983,
0.3421669900417328,
0.5574125647544861,
0.39048734307289124,
0.5355119705200195,
0.3735293447971344,
0.917995035648346,
-0.16269415616989136,
0.37116649746894836,
0.8746048212051392,
-0.5495114326477051,
0.5823901891708374,
0.6653271317481995,
0.18758749961853027,
-0.15669365227222443,
0.9411296248435974,
0.012666437774896622,
0.3375073969364166,
0.1501890867948532,
-0.31455767154693604,
-0.43542739748954773,
-0.41255849599838257,
-0.48487865924835205,
0.5097760558128357,
0.37429285049438477,
-0.22726929187774658,
-0.21537812054157257,
-0.0923532098531723,
0.36017897725105286,
0.06547894328832626,
-0.1931375414133072,
0.6499549150466919,
0.045873939990997314,
-0.013439120724797249,
0.3605194687843323,
-0.19087813794612885,
0.7282604575157166,
-0.37458527088165283,
-0.38107040524482727,
-0.14768081903457642,
0.0606425404548645,
-0.3655584454536438,
-0.9376093745231628,
0.405155748128891,
0.24699068069458008,
0.2196301966905594,
-0.12331908941268921,
0.5506641268730164,
-0.02133351005613804,
-0.8734598159790039,
0.10180530697107315,
0.2787134349346161,
0.4791654348373413,
0.1536877453327179,
-0.7897990942001343,
0.35334837436676025,
-0.22540682554244995,
-0.37480711936950684,
0.3755120038986206,
0.286787211894989,
-0.2343328595161438,
0.9908214211463928,
1.0372257232666016,
0.18971428275108337,
0.1068148985505104,
-0.1677979975938797,
0.7343536615371704,
-0.4113839566707611,
-0.4707181751728058,
-0.8189957141876221,
0.18817730247974396,
-0.30134138464927673,
-0.28330984711647034,
0.5474867820739746,
0.6529202461242676,
0.6182919144630432,
0.20137616991996765,
0.9143897891044617,
0.05837338790297508,
0.597039520740509,
-0.5600490570068359,
1.042306661605835,
-0.42679235339164734,
0.5897345542907715,
-0.1246928721666336,
-0.6096645593643188,
-0.16696874797344208,
0.8069090843200684,
-0.34422969818115234,
0.04265996068716049,
-0.0002767810074146837,
0.8869205713272095,
-0.3906126618385315,
0.2812347114086151,
-0.09379025548696518,
0.08448690921068192,
0.7373143434524536,
0.383620947599411,
0.9877980351448059,
-0.24422311782836914,
0.6435644626617432,
-0.3373070955276489,
-0.347269743680954,
-0.3449995517730713,
-1.3076536655426025,
-0.9105204343795776,
-0.43814632296562195,
-0.04517733305692673,
-0.14825113117694855,
0.32292693853378296,
1.166390299797058,
0.638052761554718,
-0.6679254770278931,
-0.42694008350372314,
0.019594328477978706,
-0.2551305890083313,
-0.027913762256503105,
-0.2814110219478607,
0.38950052857398987,
0.11453201621770859,
-0.41883572936058044,
0.02534395270049572,
-0.15405359864234924,
-0.12242025882005692,
-0.1853996366262436,
-0.3760548532009125,
-0.24132807552814484,
0.28188857436180115,
0.4168623089790344,
0.5123321413993835,
-0.6515538096427917,
-0.822111964225769,
0.040514830499887466,
0.07111898064613342,
-0.006469766143709421,
0.395495742559433,
-0.4496896266937256,
0.18251264095306396,
-0.01968790404498577,
0.95218425989151,
0.16837887465953827,
0.16953641176223755,
0.38176262378692627,
-0.6187952160835266,
0.1713847666978836,
0.31381094455718994,
0.2666137218475342,
0.43283936381340027,
-0.7707263231277466,
0.49889734387397766,
-0.22358106076717377,
-0.7066519260406494,
-1.0359314680099487,
0.23215410113334656,
-0.9763070344924927,
0.1771882176399231,
1.319567084312439,
-0.16615450382232666,
-0.21369099617004395,
-0.07550937682390213,
-0.3132331967353821,
0.24486729502677917,
-0.5725593566894531,
1.0841702222824097,
0.8019149899482727,
-0.4449939727783203,
-0.14830340445041656,
-0.6856738924980164,
0.39709216356277466,
0.3222147524356842,
-0.936177670955658,
0.44810307025909424,
0.5177118182182312,
0.42779120802879333,
-0.2412438690662384,
0.48128587007522583,
-0.17462950944900513,
0.1305556297302246,
-0.342538446187973,
-0.1573430895805359,
-0.45779141783714294,
0.2827337086200714,
0.07061794400215149,
-0.23371268808841705,
-0.04383116215467453,
-0.28889739513397217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14224v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14224v2
|
Framing in the Presence of Supporting Data: A Case Study in U.S. Economic News
| 2024-02-22T02:07:21 | 2024-02-23T02:19:22 |
Alexandria Leto, Elliot Pickens, Coen D. Needell, David Rothschild, Maria Leonor Pacheco
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The mainstream media has much leeway in what it chooses to cover and how it
covers it. These choices have real-world consequences on what people know and
their subsequent behaviors. However, the lack of objective measures to evaluate
editorial choices makes research in this area particularly difficult. In this
paper, we argue that there are newsworthy topics where objective measures exist
in the form of supporting data and propose a computational framework to analyze
editorial choices in this setup. We focus on the economy because the reporting
of economic indicators presents us with a relatively easy way to determine both
the selection and framing of various publications. Their values provide a
ground truth of how the economy is doing relative to how the publications
choose to cover it. To do this, we define frame prediction as a set of
interdependent tasks. At the article level, we learn to identify the reported
stance towards the general state of the economy. Then, for every numerical
quantity reported in the article, we learn to identify whether it corresponds
to an economic indicator and whether it is being reported in a positive or
negative way. To perform our analysis, we track six American publishers and
each article that appeared in the top 10 slots of their landing page between
2015 and 2023.
|
[
-0.7835521101951599,
-1.0165657997131348,
0.8922368288040161,
0.32667189836502075,
-0.26455822587013245,
-0.19982251524925232,
-0.20948746800422668,
-0.5693013668060303,
0.5935070514678955,
0.34276434779167175,
-0.5335661172866821,
-0.2870374023914337,
-0.7379609942436218,
0.1745259314775467,
-0.13641923666000366,
1.2250463962554932,
-0.001927434466779232,
0.09797179698944092,
-0.3253987729549408,
-0.19005562365055084,
-0.4306317865848541,
-0.14201533794403076,
-0.3902052342891693,
-0.1632569283246994,
0.41472476720809937,
0.1644739955663681,
0.9971256852149963,
0.855829656124115,
0.35606709122657776,
0.22658830881118774,
0.10897095501422882,
-0.2123297154903412,
-0.4290972650051117,
0.09922764450311661,
-0.4242370128631592,
-0.3466106057167053,
-0.44897449016571045,
0.3879883587360382,
0.5976755023002625,
0.7795541286468506,
0.02154383808374405,
0.6044124364852905,
0.2973712682723999,
0.8240864276885986,
-0.4767664968967438,
0.26170989871025085,
-0.5874364972114563,
0.049644891172647476,
-0.3254190981388092,
0.013560677878558636,
-0.3579874336719513,
0.03161418065428734,
-0.146503746509552,
-0.5459415912628174,
-0.04681512713432312,
0.41624483466148376,
0.8865545392036438,
0.23195978999137878,
-0.6348225474357605,
-0.39457640051841736,
-0.4116338789463043,
0.6574963927268982,
-0.33350592851638794,
0.5388591289520264,
0.6331096291542053,
-0.032399460673332214,
0.006687567103654146,
-0.11352144181728363,
-0.3115083575248718,
0.1738661676645279,
-0.04632425308227539,
0.36494550108909607,
-0.6209819316864014,
0.0316326841711998,
0.38909533619880676,
0.039264097809791565,
-0.48328647017478943,
-0.35964128375053406,
-0.7349908351898193,
-0.034452132880687714,
0.6566129326820374,
0.21459569036960602,
0.11635281890630722,
-0.4077708125114441,
-0.42599886655807495,
0.09699072688817978,
-0.48827898502349854,
0.06339730322360992,
0.6193059682846069,
0.22054116427898407,
-0.12402797490358353,
0.7510533332824707,
-0.29931655526161194,
0.7032514810562134,
0.23652778565883636,
0.09846992790699005,
0.2283930480480194,
-0.24181325733661652,
-0.17865140736103058,
0.35914355516433716,
0.36325156688690186,
0.6959002614021301,
-0.2718670070171356,
0.1769467145204544,
-0.35541489720344543,
0.12697924673557281,
0.5980998277664185,
-0.3754570484161377,
0.3330327570438385,
0.02927674539387226,
-0.6108913421630859,
-0.16643977165222168,
0.1780952513217926,
-1.0836427211761475,
-0.2796614170074463,
-0.5011276006698608,
0.3744679391384125,
0.281098335981369,
-0.0027445137966424227,
-0.1410088986158371,
-0.24073241651058197,
-0.05789096653461456,
0.09387274831533432,
-0.6036447882652283,
0.20985153317451477,
0.8268584609031677,
0.803571879863739,
0.04914887994527817,
0.13285407423973083,
-0.4967254400253296,
0.12104937434196472,
-0.5920220613479614,
1.0410748720169067,
-0.6697539687156677,
-0.07207098603248596,
-0.18178296089172363,
-0.023498669266700745,
0.05808558687567711,
0.02629908360540867,
0.36256682872772217,
-0.7229840755462646,
0.2563627362251282,
-0.5099073648452759,
-0.5890896320343018,
-0.30999261140823364,
0.6041882634162903,
-1.2441794872283936,
0.5895719528198242,
0.3053549826145172,
-1.067186951637268,
0.7967554926872253,
-0.3186289966106415,
-0.2406405508518219,
-0.5079265832901001,
-0.08912096917629242,
-0.7358655333518982,
0.34790754318237305,
0.24923619627952576,
0.2477465271949768,
-0.06662745028734207,
0.642374575138092,
-0.6224074959754944,
-0.3548443019390106,
0.2948917746543884,
-0.6136268377304077,
0.7676942348480225,
0.23437991738319397,
-0.25207772850990295,
-0.16561934351921082,
-0.7031650543212891,
-0.3020094931125641,
-0.5233410000801086,
-0.27554967999458313,
-0.37551918625831604,
0.24530130624771118,
0.0022623110562562943,
-0.028865434229373932,
-0.15925480425357819,
-0.481436550617218,
0.04025114327669144,
-0.10114184021949768,
0.3216778337955475,
0.8618221282958984,
0.319058358669281,
0.565703272819519,
-0.4182637631893158,
0.7832478284835815,
-0.34437769651412964,
-0.04770331829786301,
-0.3044724464416504,
-0.3373620808124542,
-0.44946837425231934,
0.051666777580976486,
0.4887195825576782,
0.43760189414024353,
-0.5828303694725037,
-0.17540079355239868,
0.026861464604735374,
-0.02469015307724476,
0.011683368124067783,
-0.2353096753358841,
0.05727741867303848,
0.514860212802887,
0.08053192496299744,
-0.3136344254016876,
-0.795131266117096,
-0.8426379561424255,
-0.4182564318180084,
0.010289765894412994,
0.05242249742150307,
0.03910128399729729,
0.26986798644065857,
0.037523165345191956,
1.1285043954849243,
-0.6200516819953918,
-0.14244335889816284,
-0.21818900108337402,
0.14503535628318787,
0.8189321160316467,
0.24538554251194,
0.5499417781829834,
-0.8429086804389954,
-0.21037951111793518,
-0.24669060111045837,
-0.583467960357666,
-0.31721243262290955,
-0.36495736241340637,
-0.18924175202846527,
0.21355301141738892,
0.39310023188591003,
-0.4601845145225525,
0.6511524319648743,
0.40568113327026367,
-0.4768012464046478,
0.47383350133895874,
-0.11108299344778061,
0.21204312145709991,
-0.780531108379364,
-0.0819382444024086,
0.2325384020805359,
-0.36038944125175476,
-0.2561115622520447,
-0.5504429340362549,
-0.1589047908782959,
-0.25600528717041016,
-0.11411044001579285,
0.6738101840019226,
-0.4674663245677948,
-0.4661916196346283,
-0.04134705662727356,
-0.052923813462257385,
0.3610553741455078,
0.23253625631332397,
0.31965360045433044,
0.7593261003494263,
0.35744014382362366,
-0.1692444384098053,
-0.09922602027654648,
0.10972359776496887,
-0.4893217384815216,
0.6923787593841553,
-0.5278126001358032,
-0.39414724707603455,
-0.6100134253501892,
0.37101009488105774,
-0.8480839729309082,
-0.35524699091911316,
0.31982097029685974,
-0.40398573875427246,
0.02688470669090748,
0.02397124655544758,
-0.12162157893180847,
-0.11312177032232285,
-0.28352218866348267,
0.06664770841598511,
0.07142150402069092,
0.025409052148461342,
0.3613080382347107,
0.7064825296401978,
-0.4350516200065613,
-0.42318952083587646,
-0.6966983675956726,
0.06372878700494766,
-0.4165327847003937,
-0.41860899329185486,
0.18270547688007355,
0.021370280534029007,
-0.5953249931335449,
0.5316992998123169,
-0.3348792791366577,
-0.13992266356945038,
0.14231249690055847,
0.08253347873687744,
0.533023476600647,
-0.36968889832496643,
0.2630722224712372,
0.19356326758861542,
-0.7171728610992432,
0.13676680624485016,
-0.2801430821418762,
-0.10552381724119186,
-0.10104334354400635,
-0.18933136761188507,
-0.13621890544891357,
0.5441583395004272,
0.24394161999225616,
-0.2790755331516266,
0.4582584500312805,
0.17144103348255157,
-0.30757811665534973,
-0.4099012613296509,
-0.4833105206489563,
0.05214649438858032,
-0.368895024061203,
0.4540629982948303,
0.01994195394217968,
-0.4814590513706207,
0.3313692808151245,
0.45128312706947327,
-0.23064109683036804,
0.4517488479614258,
0.3391875922679901,
0.1610265076160431,
1.248766541481018,
0.695386528968811,
-0.06710746884346008,
0.5924029350280762,
-0.04441941902041435,
0.35795265436172485,
-0.5381457209587097,
0.03271126002073288,
-0.28500455617904663,
-0.6216200590133667,
-0.28421616554260254,
-0.26373276114463806,
0.8108106851577759,
0.07977278530597687,
-0.40087801218032837,
0.4559190571308136,
-0.48705407977104187,
0.7513076066970825,
0.4998852014541626,
0.003236167598515749,
0.46311062574386597,
0.03844549506902695,
0.29182571172714233,
0.05042756348848343,
-0.46126788854599,
-0.6571308374404907,
1.1791633367538452,
0.25826340913772583,
0.5311022996902466,
-0.301898717880249,
0.4854981303215027,
0.5489564538002014,
0.6914747953414917,
-0.3924857974052429,
0.21313033998012543,
0.1277344524860382,
-0.7553901076316833,
-0.07785096019506454,
-0.2982620298862457,
-0.6427933573722839,
0.3421767055988312,
-0.5143586993217468,
-0.6252173185348511,
0.4404999613761902,
0.13321776688098907,
-0.6198375225067139,
0.16125845909118652,
-0.4379453957080841,
0.7631744742393494,
-0.4377439022064209,
-0.6954177618026733,
-0.39584723114967346,
-0.18510636687278748,
0.1766776442527771,
0.14555755257606506,
0.69375079870224,
-0.31976768374443054,
-0.18889577686786652,
0.5665081739425659,
0.004887572024017572,
0.6831058859825134,
-0.06723030656576157,
0.36000382900238037,
0.3978092074394226,
-0.15968243777751923,
0.1359815001487732,
0.6483826041221619,
-0.5976426601409912,
0.07714598625898361,
0.025134284049272537,
-0.29244810342788696,
-0.35057803988456726,
0.20953857898712158,
-0.33263829350471497,
-0.5451858043670654,
-0.7416141033172607,
-0.4256965219974518,
-0.3150135278701782,
0.2625064551830292,
0.46594664454460144,
0.5725498199462891,
-0.19677111506462097,
0.28001871705055237,
0.17278093099594116,
0.17800724506378174,
0.5738959908485413,
0.3402947783470154,
-0.17933328449726105,
-0.6231366395950317,
0.6195856332778931,
0.6917119026184082,
-0.20299220085144043,
0.10683256387710571,
0.22528555989265442,
-0.1722179651260376,
-0.6645893454551697,
-0.7080801725387573,
-0.14697331190109253,
-0.44563910365104675,
-0.5794082880020142,
-0.24479074776172638,
0.2182179093360901,
0.028040887787938118,
-0.5107947587966919,
-0.10600416362285614,
-0.2866283655166626,
-0.4379563331604004,
-0.7597684860229492,
0.015186802484095097,
0.8788235783576965,
-0.23230500519275665,
0.04431266710162163,
-0.7051924467086792,
-0.06898100674152374,
0.07789063453674316,
0.7559300661087036,
-0.0063032121397554874,
0.4357054531574249,
-0.6514935493469238,
0.261861115694046,
-0.5966464877128601,
-1.0649237632751465,
0.5185211896896362,
-0.1271582394838333,
0.7646648287773132,
0.4429936408996582,
0.31020501255989075,
0.5441541075706482,
-0.545682430267334,
0.6790119409561157,
0.13041988015174866,
-1.054229736328125,
0.2449932098388672,
-0.47677040100097656,
-0.17911915481090546,
0.8065078258514404,
0.46952658891677856,
-0.2463361918926239,
-0.4865209460258484,
-0.6655094623565674,
-0.7004581093788147,
0.7023167014122009,
0.095065638422966,
0.4081030786037445,
-0.4462749660015106,
0.20657412707805634,
0.20508909225463867,
0.6976885199546814,
-0.7033537030220032,
0.23168371617794037,
-0.13260698318481445,
-0.19416669011116028,
0.02869863249361515,
-0.08927883207798004,
0.030426060780882835,
-0.06808626651763916,
0.526177704334259,
-0.092064268887043,
0.14197219908237457,
0.4184834659099579,
-0.0585869625210762,
-0.3048253059387207,
0.18288779258728027,
0.266196608543396,
1.146299958229065,
-0.056201107800006866,
0.24803146719932556,
-0.12715104222297668,
-0.05905856564640999,
-0.07562825828790665,
0.04891868308186531,
-0.36438286304473877,
0.02315910905599594,
0.5280588865280151,
0.9687807559967041,
0.4700954556465149,
-0.9342945218086243,
0.5116076469421387,
0.3556239902973175,
-0.05522013083100319,
-0.5280908942222595,
-0.08830027282238007,
-0.08094891905784607,
0.7582092881202698,
0.4332669675350189,
0.2431723028421402,
0.43308553099632263,
-0.7808541059494019,
0.6349890828132629,
0.45530375838279724,
-0.7513725161552429,
-0.5391483306884766,
1.0065785646438599,
0.11034609377384186,
-0.10421717166900635,
0.48500490188598633,
-0.3785135746002197,
-0.7247561812400818,
0.9519630074501038,
0.6052437424659729,
0.5889736413955688,
0.24132384359836578,
0.4486134648323059,
0.27566099166870117,
0.14182697236537933,
-0.3524928390979767,
-0.08230692148208618,
-0.00895393081009388,
-0.7413454055786133,
-0.16488254070281982,
-0.6194174885749817,
-0.2228078544139862,
-0.2507893145084381,
-0.8445254564285278,
0.3213963210582733,
-0.22759978473186493,
-0.6040036082267761,
0.10042378306388855,
0.26316210627555847,
-0.5063924789428711,
0.2586948275566101,
0.6086353659629822,
0.8932607173919678,
-1.1400173902511597,
0.32847824692726135,
0.532521665096283,
-0.38493549823760986,
-0.378123939037323,
0.0012301220558583736,
0.5357043147087097,
-0.47733718156814575,
0.20154118537902832,
0.49241963028907776,
0.26925042271614075,
-0.44226938486099243,
-0.34069252014160156,
-1.108655571937561,
0.966827392578125,
0.3615734875202179,
-0.3872767984867096,
0.06767067313194275,
-0.15713651478290558,
0.24575790762901306,
-0.6753615736961365,
0.2008560448884964,
0.4658709466457367,
0.8682096004486084,
-0.10930778086185455,
-0.6059795618057251,
-0.2247842252254486,
-0.3648260533809662,
-0.19744770228862762,
0.4526078999042511,
-0.7167062759399414,
1.091060757637024,
0.03194475919008255,
-0.20859086513519287,
-0.45992833375930786,
0.5237730741500854,
-0.08024788647890091,
1.073981523513794,
0.6453519463539124,
0.5317862629890442,
0.7591893076896667,
0.173991397023201,
1.08357572555542,
-0.42896175384521484,
0.7007331848144531,
0.6146554946899414,
-0.23160257935523987,
0.824059009552002,
0.3238948583602905,
-0.3376091718673706,
0.46414127945899963,
0.6571359634399414,
-0.3592141568660736,
0.4365944266319275,
-0.07434023171663284,
0.10766353458166122,
-0.164559468626976,
0.1471329629421234,
-0.1410043090581894,
0.44525596499443054,
0.4521239995956421,
-0.3592628836631775,
-0.5634756088256836,
0.26740550994873047,
0.22536903619766235,
0.2699211835861206,
-0.6929628252983093,
0.6104497313499451,
0.08746828138828278,
-0.8683537840843201,
-0.13874417543411255,
-0.09877949208021164,
0.2605965733528137,
-0.4177900552749634,
-0.13758942484855652,
-0.05526963248848915,
-0.08828257024288177,
-0.2539770007133484,
-0.908774197101593,
1.2155108451843262,
0.016522111371159554,
-0.5200192928314209,
-0.703758180141449,
0.6538752913475037,
-0.3754678964614868,
-0.897546648979187,
0.09990308433771133,
0.3966911733150482,
-0.47139838337898254,
-0.15016786754131317,
-0.32701635360717773,
0.5669479370117188,
-0.010974445380270481,
-0.9540703892707825,
0.4382857382297516,
0.100366972386837,
-0.32526788115501404,
-0.030157670378684998,
0.45547226071357727,
-0.08272203058004379,
-0.4578450322151184,
-0.5968586802482605,
0.6801419854164124,
-0.6600921154022217,
-1.0432106256484985,
-0.7360844612121582,
0.46897825598716736,
-0.26662278175354004,
-0.31431466341018677,
0.6598371267318726,
0.6823087334632874,
0.542276918888092,
0.18135568499565125,
0.7621870040893555,
-0.10488242655992508,
0.41907763481140137,
-0.6898002028465271,
0.787484347820282,
-0.3237404227256775,
0.37878668308258057,
-0.1019468680024147,
-1.0987037420272827,
-0.4164351224899292,
0.7494056224822998,
-0.8652326464653015,
-0.3083956241607666,
0.312914103269577,
0.4471941590309143,
-0.0670769140124321,
0.4828849136829376,
-0.020412202924489975,
0.10970437526702881,
-0.18048059940338135,
0.07709017395973206,
0.37210020422935486,
0.266560822725296,
0.45798367261886597,
-0.27636685967445374,
-0.2734956741333008,
-0.06271957606077194,
-1.250316858291626,
-0.4271005392074585,
-0.5403546690940857,
-0.1663784235715866,
-0.17991241812705994,
0.11809741705656052,
0.747526228427887,
0.783362090587616,
-0.5072911381721497,
-0.1858867108821869,
0.06726900488138199,
0.541745126247406,
-0.5295791625976562,
-0.2084805965423584,
0.46132346987724304,
-0.4370407164096832,
-0.6457855105400085,
0.10223007202148438,
0.33306169509887695,
-0.4774133265018463,
0.0488814152777195,
0.4685775935649872,
0.14382191002368927,
0.46484091877937317,
0.42050015926361084,
-0.04268069565296173,
-0.28837162256240845,
-0.574089527130127,
-0.016609834507107735,
0.2821011543273926,
0.20823556184768677,
0.9507788419723511,
-1.067484736442566,
0.40655654668807983,
0.7400855422019958,
0.5812879204750061,
0.4831055998802185,
0.5469267964363098,
0.6907077431678772,
-0.4885324537754059,
0.2646329998970032,
0.021697305142879486,
0.34277141094207764,
0.030213946476578712,
-0.54911208152771,
0.43688860535621643,
0.08691493421792984,
-0.5500528812408447,
-0.7477875351905823,
-0.09638924151659012,
-0.6900982856750488,
-0.465408593416214,
0.5838658213615417,
0.04512885585427284,
-0.6454293131828308,
-0.01899467036128044,
0.02423614077270031,
-0.3238052725791931,
-0.48735716938972473,
0.603973388671875,
0.9320202469825745,
-0.33570533990859985,
-0.21768401563167572,
-1.0962324142456055,
0.015952596440911293,
-0.26755213737487793,
-0.3821222186088562,
-0.00011155731772305444,
0.931878924369812,
0.22502949833869934,
0.16363714635372162,
0.954808235168457,
0.11478753387928009,
0.15738855302333832,
0.4030911326408386,
-0.5247453451156616,
-0.2484830766916275,
-0.4154195785522461,
-0.22653332352638245,
0.4247967302799225,
-0.49291086196899414,
-0.044873494654893875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14208v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14208v3
|
LLM-Assisted Content Conditional Debiasing for Fair Text Embedding
| 2024-02-22T01:20:51 | 2024-06-24T04:49:16 |
Wenlong Deng, Blair Chen, Beidi Zhao, Chiyu Zhang, Xiaoxiao Li, Christos Thrampoulidis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Mitigating biases in machine learning models has become an increasing concern
in Natural Language Processing (NLP), particularly in developing fair text
embeddings, which are crucial yet challenging for real-world applications like
search engines. In response, this paper proposes a novel method for learning
fair text embeddings. First, we define a novel content-conditional equal
distance (CCED) fairness for text embeddings, ensuring content-conditional
independence between sensitive attributes and text embeddings. Building on
CCED, we introduce a content-conditional debiasing (CCD) loss to ensure that
embeddings of texts with different sensitive attributes but identical content
maintain the same distance from the embedding of their corresponding neutral
text. Additionally, we tackle the issue of insufficient training data by using
Large Language Models (LLMs) with instructions to fairly augment texts into
different sensitive groups. Our extensive evaluations show that our approach
effectively enhances fairness while maintaining the utility of embeddings.
Furthermore, our augmented dataset, combined with the CCED metric, serves as an
new benchmark for evaluating fairness.
|
[
-0.009187507443130016,
-0.6914708614349365,
0.5559971332550049,
0.09757865965366364,
-0.2490871250629425,
-0.03401708975434303,
-0.3851648271083832,
-0.14744794368743896,
-0.14796066284179688,
0.4038722515106201,
-0.42666372656822205,
-0.7506670355796814,
-0.9292624592781067,
-0.016259554773569107,
-0.19405657052993774,
1.012778401374817,
0.07133092731237411,
0.40209776163101196,
-0.4584263563156128,
-0.5293566584587097,
-0.5456472039222717,
-0.4522370994091034,
-0.531984269618988,
-0.11324674636125565,
0.43031662702560425,
0.32661935687065125,
0.6976683735847473,
0.6880857348442078,
0.5553861260414124,
0.25569894909858704,
-0.08146420121192932,
0.24970132112503052,
-0.41257911920547485,
0.1779254525899887,
-0.43080130219459534,
-0.6086515784263611,
-0.3331570327281952,
0.2654079496860504,
0.5351504683494568,
0.74237459897995,
-0.13241572678089142,
-0.11076758801937103,
0.3214329779148102,
0.7414647936820984,
-0.8500081896781921,
-0.013138084672391415,
-0.8664246797561646,
0.5702499151229858,
-0.07526330649852753,
-0.08478529006242752,
-0.5475313663482666,
-0.4511066973209381,
-0.062170542776584625,
-0.5996712446212769,
0.24484913051128387,
0.021369896829128265,
0.5926182866096497,
0.5303614735603333,
-0.4282759130001068,
-0.2568073570728302,
-0.1407424360513687,
1.1999502182006836,
-0.6071165800094604,
0.4798915982246399,
0.4274393320083618,
0.20830829441547394,
0.003798829857259989,
-0.504822850227356,
-0.7202470898628235,
0.1509106606245041,
-0.03114352747797966,
-0.04304539039731026,
-0.15773016214370728,
0.1019403263926506,
0.31126219034194946,
0.2867368161678314,
-0.29859408736228943,
0.3796938955783844,
0.058379802852869034,
-0.35436147451400757,
0.5204601883888245,
-0.10996000468730927,
0.21071738004684448,
-0.27161672711372375,
-0.4908807873725891,
-0.01593657210469246,
-0.621472954750061,
0.10140640288591385,
0.6510792374610901,
0.37419331073760986,
-0.3048115670681,
0.6691176891326904,
-0.19431918859481812,
0.3345688581466675,
0.13813470304012299,
-0.022765889763832092,
0.4933832287788391,
0.02490323595702648,
-0.1531151682138443,
0.15962131321430206,
0.6333051323890686,
0.6284786462783813,
0.1995251476764679,
-0.3500838875770569,
-0.36579787731170654,
0.18665312230587006,
0.011381556279957294,
-0.8550407290458679,
0.052811149507761,
0.011043817736208439,
-0.5695105195045471,
-0.35995832085609436,
-0.04189741238951683,
-0.4539492726325989,
-0.724479615688324,
-0.31409716606140137,
0.40485844016075134,
-0.1841406673192978,
-0.024362465366721153,
0.3092159628868103,
-0.08746709674596786,
0.09151405841112137,
0.22593115270137787,
-0.9362999200820923,
0.3286246955394745,
0.7414238452911377,
0.6449024677276611,
-0.3999970257282257,
0.0676458477973938,
-0.9505422711372375,
0.2842777371406555,
0.05766534060239792,
0.5437027812004089,
-0.7873462438583374,
-0.13952329754829407,
0.08118138462305069,
-0.13185633718967438,
0.38043051958084106,
-0.4162236452102661,
0.8069921731948853,
-0.5575501322746277,
0.2546148896217346,
-0.4153813123703003,
-0.6886481642723083,
-0.22556571662425995,
0.4511800706386566,
-0.8652269244194031,
0.6544396281242371,
0.16124248504638672,
-1.222886085510254,
0.5983512997627258,
-0.3302159905433655,
-0.4564226269721985,
-0.21360129117965698,
-0.4318898320198059,
-0.6326178908348083,
0.046938005834817886,
0.44521909952163696,
0.45368683338165283,
0.005413697566837072,
0.3305590748786926,
-0.740405797958374,
-0.25248783826828003,
0.13580310344696045,
-0.777431070804596,
0.794551432132721,
0.2236155867576599,
-0.353985995054245,
-0.23904822766780853,
-0.3729080259799957,
-0.008788174949586391,
-0.09919589012861252,
-0.28893426060676575,
-0.4683319926261902,
0.20679600536823273,
0.023555563762784004,
0.17865736782550812,
0.3504317104816437,
-0.6898459196090698,
-0.0504070483148098,
-0.44196075201034546,
0.15163253247737885,
1.1954504251480103,
-0.4141828417778015,
0.7669636607170105,
-0.46735891699790955,
0.3097248673439026,
0.24234887957572937,
0.1157594695687294,
0.11748610436916351,
-0.30601683259010315,
-0.5491606593132019,
-0.5505139231681824,
0.5530737638473511,
0.6204603314399719,
-0.7906577587127686,
0.5494687557220459,
-0.16757768392562866,
0.09086081385612488,
-0.8514830470085144,
0.23348325490951538,
0.36237868666648865,
0.4074205160140991,
0.326392263174057,
-0.32900577783584595,
-0.4383763372898102,
-0.7799295783042908,
-0.5141860246658325,
0.3138773739337921,
-0.033916112035512924,
0.34423935413360596,
0.10584089905023575,
-0.2287978231906891,
1.0167728662490845,
-0.3361780345439911,
-0.5123580098152161,
-0.13538053631782532,
-0.213058203458786,
0.031168347224593163,
0.5431327819824219,
0.4388047754764557,
-1.123627781867981,
-0.5475004315376282,
-0.31710872054100037,
-0.6225840449333191,
-0.4336065351963043,
0.0827987939119339,
-0.16897805035114288,
0.25292229652404785,
0.37412458658218384,
-0.35195088386535645,
0.6536865234375,
0.6405860185623169,
-0.39503464102745056,
0.1277051568031311,
-0.13630448281764984,
0.34616008400917053,
-0.7551896572113037,
-0.23090152442455292,
0.007977165281772614,
-0.5652002096176147,
-0.16189786791801453,
0.006203386001288891,
-0.002254887018352747,
0.35243719816207886,
-0.6062852740287781,
0.7957913279533386,
-0.09734834730625153,
-0.09967131912708282,
-0.4200129210948944,
0.5665355324745178,
0.282020628452301,
0.4433461129665375,
0.04172171279788017,
0.299280047416687,
0.43550994992256165,
-0.47913655638694763,
-0.03925324231386185,
0.21962226927280426,
-0.09809157997369766,
0.7879789471626282,
-0.5003834962844849,
0.08134495466947556,
-0.3122187554836273,
0.3520045578479767,
-0.453121155500412,
0.45342978835105896,
0.3244495987892151,
-0.6155058145523071,
0.031177246943116188,
-0.17668356001377106,
-0.48954105377197266,
0.06458388268947601,
-0.7074600458145142,
0.7824479341506958,
0.38907095789909363,
-0.764154314994812,
0.36042308807373047,
0.6488303542137146,
-0.1905578225851059,
-0.9501445293426514,
-0.763410747051239,
-0.08637961745262146,
-0.07452848553657532,
-0.5336006283760071,
0.8700547814369202,
-0.3981911838054657,
-0.22401827573776245,
0.2883196473121643,
-0.14105817675590515,
-0.1855149120092392,
0.35139963030815125,
0.24284379184246063,
-0.04459536448121071,
0.2564545273780823,
0.14143340289592743,
0.49759286642074585,
-0.2711685001850128,
-0.12837493419647217,
-0.2805946171283722,
0.3670923113822937,
0.12337275594472885,
-0.6383580565452576,
-0.5299098491668701,
0.44650280475616455,
-0.287211149930954,
-0.18858768045902252,
0.7918394207954407,
0.888659656047821,
-0.7717202305793762,
-0.46296918392181396,
-0.5010724663734436,
-0.1404181867837906,
-0.5241656303405762,
0.27485913038253784,
-0.06475386023521423,
-1.1867480278015137,
0.4388173520565033,
0.41969552636146545,
0.14450711011886597,
0.5294563174247742,
0.5223609209060669,
0.01932484470307827,
1.1493864059448242,
0.8869673013687134,
-0.1585754156112671,
0.32530853152275085,
-0.06681164354085922,
0.30707255005836487,
-0.42463669180870056,
-0.32314643263816833,
-0.6789168119430542,
-0.42135539650917053,
-0.9764112234115601,
-0.618763267993927,
-0.12698589265346527,
0.1090598851442337,
-0.2877729535102844,
-0.28352245688438416,
-0.4292033016681671,
0.6468614935874939,
0.5275924801826477,
0.49726980924606323,
0.3975885510444641,
0.034490857273340225,
-0.22183720767498016,
-0.3916020691394806,
-0.5249996781349182,
-0.5787801146507263,
1.1503868103027344,
0.3062061369419098,
0.7372393012046814,
0.12355021387338638,
0.7314587831497192,
0.9491720795631409,
0.4435155987739563,
-0.6355375051498413,
0.2674711346626282,
-0.620412290096283,
-0.24027760326862335,
-0.0793781727552414,
-0.7619200944900513,
-0.559279203414917,
0.1756964474916458,
-0.38281574845314026,
-0.27603062987327576,
0.10439775139093399,
0.08674875646829605,
-0.012275111861526966,
0.6085317730903625,
-0.4558812081813812,
0.5968688726425171,
-0.1214405819773674,
-0.4556700587272644,
-0.4551152288913727,
-0.3754090666770935,
0.105839304625988,
0.08117476850748062,
0.47054630517959595,
-0.2249273657798767,
-0.24277180433273315,
0.6238762736320496,
-0.1618865728378296,
0.6867857575416565,
-0.5948691368103027,
-0.10250578820705414,
0.12128069251775742,
0.0012137264711782336,
0.43119919300079346,
0.41524532437324524,
-0.42406928539276123,
0.27449989318847656,
-0.4241853356361389,
-0.5444220304489136,
-0.42920130491256714,
0.9112969636917114,
-0.571326732635498,
-0.4663236439228058,
-0.4432634711265564,
-0.4238651692867279,
-0.04661848396062851,
0.18333449959754944,
-0.20300154387950897,
0.1379011571407318,
-0.1604951173067093,
0.28410348296165466,
0.8449268937110901,
-0.6608246564865112,
0.5485121011734009,
0.6215412020683289,
0.26811662316322327,
-0.5574110746383667,
0.638939619064331,
-0.27922162413597107,
0.022126393392682076,
0.7127377986907959,
0.12500394880771637,
-0.5573226809501648,
-0.5905628800392151,
-0.11962922662496567,
-0.23384542763233185,
-0.8614309430122375,
-0.5222461223602295,
-0.8078458309173584,
-0.13086286187171936,
-0.46333906054496765,
-0.28111785650253296,
-0.28542381525039673,
-0.4943258762359619,
-0.3217599093914032,
-0.26938414573669434,
0.1379585862159729,
0.3269921541213989,
-0.26832911372184753,
0.15170997381210327,
-0.6876845359802246,
0.46005433797836304,
0.214595228433609,
0.671064019203186,
-0.1313132643699646,
-0.5716461539268494,
-0.1936653107404709,
0.380416601896286,
-0.49490392208099365,
-0.4739088714122772,
0.3719242513179779,
0.1542966514825821,
0.7181217074394226,
0.18041352927684784,
0.38216784596443176,
0.12162179499864578,
-0.6715058088302612,
0.6046591997146606,
0.2496289610862732,
-1.0965051651000977,
0.23166827857494354,
-0.10721640288829803,
-0.1335555464029312,
0.6895526647567749,
0.27126482129096985,
-0.4782102406024933,
-0.4236498773097992,
-0.43127337098121643,
-0.7455704212188721,
0.4028492271900177,
0.17936375737190247,
0.3819601833820343,
-0.2084464132785797,
0.27882716059684753,
0.4353300631046295,
0.21450746059417725,
-1.3167140483856201,
-0.1421823650598526,
-0.19802482426166534,
-0.7168406844139099,
0.18424850702285767,
-0.06855683773756027,
0.1402987837791443,
-0.035540394484996796,
0.5905413031578064,
-0.18960867822170258,
0.1485600769519806,
0.20760802924633026,
-0.7017619609832764,
0.23258192837238312,
0.2863853871822357,
0.01063013169914484,
0.14997030794620514,
-0.12171019613742828,
0.21457229554653168,
0.3027019798755646,
-0.40623635053634644,
0.09260492026805878,
0.22051537036895752,
-0.2052862048149109,
-0.11092451959848404,
-0.0027647127863019705,
0.4707988202571869,
-0.0919627919793129,
-0.6757103204727173,
1.1957859992980957,
-0.2911429703235626,
0.022223470732569695,
0.1147068440914154,
0.014705627225339413,
-0.19437801837921143,
0.3120727837085724,
0.15186114609241486,
-0.004813628736883402,
0.3153742551803589,
-0.06986603140830994,
0.5368982553482056,
0.5501753687858582,
-0.6629146337509155,
0.019731460139155388,
0.7473136782646179,
0.3895784616470337,
-0.22841067612171173,
0.5614244937896729,
-0.588384211063385,
-0.5953332781791687,
0.5458378195762634,
0.37221789360046387,
1.0432353019714355,
-0.00908262375742197,
0.28135719895362854,
0.09121103584766388,
0.2636524736881256,
0.019157283008098602,
0.18040677905082703,
-0.038898639380931854,
-0.7787186503410339,
-0.5238662958145142,
-0.7653965353965759,
-0.3306664824485779,
-0.38830825686454773,
-0.5037755370140076,
0.4646829068660736,
-0.4455753564834595,
-0.014858433045446873,
-0.35868093371391296,
0.28688040375709534,
-0.9874471426010132,
0.4233337938785553,
0.3313289284706116,
0.8064676523208618,
-0.6900954246520996,
0.6012151837348938,
0.14167086780071259,
-0.10503359884023666,
-0.27692940831184387,
0.01532701775431633,
-0.18768030405044556,
-0.7062109708786011,
0.3738052248954773,
0.5740341544151306,
-0.030175890773534775,
-0.22485141456127167,
-0.5596901774406433,
-0.22101609408855438,
0.9954847097396851,
0.7151960134506226,
-0.6907250285148621,
0.24257764220237732,
0.3601028323173523,
0.17800967395305634,
-0.40558886528015137,
0.34297627210617065,
0.048159822821617126,
0.371988981962204,
-0.6392300724983215,
-0.4535785913467407,
0.2502036988735199,
-0.1066439226269722,
-0.18103010952472687,
-0.13686533272266388,
-0.521940290927887,
0.5306199789047241,
-0.28561967611312866,
-0.056600216776132584,
-0.0647004172205925,
0.6942291259765625,
0.2407124638557434,
0.6617156267166138,
0.7642786502838135,
0.9304831027984619,
0.8922095894813538,
-0.00909530371427536,
0.8517815470695496,
-0.16228467226028442,
0.4157644808292389,
1.0401504039764404,
-0.2923494577407837,
0.6152366995811462,
0.2334451973438263,
0.053055934607982635,
0.43034762144088745,
0.5065905451774597,
0.10149446129798889,
0.8039600849151611,
0.47321513295173645,
-0.5321298241615295,
-0.3223530948162079,
-0.3680402934551239,
-0.21917347609996796,
0.2915663421154022,
0.09014712274074554,
-0.31546658277511597,
-0.040558066219091415,
0.12033699452877045,
0.0991179421544075,
0.711359441280365,
-0.3057045638561249,
0.6262615919113159,
0.2159334421157837,
-0.17078058421611786,
-0.005402918439358473,
0.5797222256660461,
1.2216465473175049,
-0.20996859669685364,
0.029504742473363876,
-0.4155070185661316,
0.1632811576128006,
-0.21177835762500763,
-0.7577975988388062,
0.3050711452960968,
0.1242617592215538,
-0.6512249708175659,
-0.3017106354236603,
0.6005703806877136,
-0.47938594222068787,
-0.4404383897781372,
0.43778905272483826,
0.20568805932998657,
-0.37372052669525146,
-0.03461357578635216,
-0.8596101403236389,
-0.07554952055215836,
0.10730362683534622,
-0.02609160728752613,
0.37109097838401794,
0.5456180572509766,
0.03659271076321602,
0.6478564143180847,
0.5241679549217224,
-0.1133013665676117,
-0.19138488173484802,
0.36287835240364075,
0.790223240852356,
-0.7141169905662537,
-0.7066307067871094,
-0.9881739616394043,
0.44770392775535583,
-0.16545738279819489,
0.19472917914390564,
0.6284383535385132,
0.5763945579528809,
0.905168354511261,
0.33396777510643005,
0.8306533694267273,
-0.051455359905958176,
0.4788108468055725,
-0.7124224305152893,
0.8087151050567627,
-0.5529583096504211,
0.6619527339935303,
-0.27650168538093567,
-0.8954768180847168,
-0.35516348481178284,
0.4375249743461609,
-0.13777080178260803,
0.20097340643405914,
0.49307817220687866,
0.9506904482841492,
-0.05212271586060524,
-0.14373794198036194,
0.1986570656299591,
-0.08516038954257965,
0.48285797238349915,
0.6689172983169556,
0.5623003840446472,
-0.4525787830352783,
0.5453881025314331,
-0.11880403012037277,
-0.176813006401062,
0.15961937606334686,
-1.326874017715454,
-0.7641635537147522,
-0.23468510806560516,
-0.4308132529258728,
-0.31260842084884644,
0.38007652759552,
0.8662401437759399,
0.44595780968666077,
-0.7158758640289307,
0.3760297894477844,
0.048614539206027985,
0.6741659045219421,
0.10517855733633041,
-0.2159115970134735,
0.4360473155975342,
-0.31096452474594116,
-0.7952805161476135,
-0.10693462193012238,
0.07253295928239822,
-0.1567416489124298,
-0.04985462501645088,
-0.4233561158180237,
0.12967468798160553,
0.10878615826368332,
0.48821353912353516,
-0.31791096925735474,
-0.29911139607429504,
-0.38938000798225403,
-0.2963947653770447,
-0.31059348583221436,
0.07758631557226181,
0.5426981449127197,
-0.963060736656189,
0.27980881929397583,
0.5214511752128601,
0.9264184236526489,
0.07076258957386017,
-0.2515505850315094,
0.44900059700012207,
-1.0795044898986816,
0.4219839572906494,
0.368299275636673,
0.27531883120536804,
0.714519739151001,
-0.4197814166545868,
0.17049072682857513,
0.3202783167362213,
-0.508308470249176,
-0.8090705275535583,
0.12145605683326721,
-1.0389074087142944,
-0.1463397890329361,
1.0344882011413574,
-0.3082812428474426,
0.13940809667110443,
0.220891535282135,
-0.06771063059568405,
0.4055901765823364,
-0.46828368306159973,
0.8842102885246277,
0.23474301397800446,
0.66619873046875,
0.09890308976173401,
-0.3391493558883667,
0.4889374077320099,
0.49635952711105347,
-0.8167363405227661,
-0.0630919486284256,
0.5578847527503967,
0.30853208899497986,
-0.6090573668479919,
0.5337512493133545,
-0.13875095546245575,
0.2455390840768814,
-0.36236491799354553,
0.06569872796535492,
0.1206088438630104,
-0.15255683660507202,
-0.3055036664009094,
0.030182544142007828,
-0.1009906679391861,
-0.09598537534475327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14207v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14207v2
|
Assisting in Writing Wikipedia-like Articles From Scratch with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T01:20:17 | 2024-04-08T05:38:50 |
Yijia Shao, Yucheng Jiang, Theodore A. Kanell, Peter Xu, Omar Khattab, Monica S. Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We study how to apply large language models to write grounded and organized
long-form articles from scratch, with comparable breadth and depth to Wikipedia
pages. This underexplored problem poses new challenges at the pre-writing
stage, including how to research the topic and prepare an outline prior to
writing. We propose STORM, a writing system for the Synthesis of Topic Outlines
through Retrieval and Multi-perspective Question Asking. STORM models the
pre-writing stage by (1) discovering diverse perspectives in researching the
given topic, (2) simulating conversations where writers carrying different
perspectives pose questions to a topic expert grounded on trusted Internet
sources, (3) curating the collected information to create an outline.
For evaluation, we curate FreshWiki, a dataset of recent high-quality
Wikipedia articles, and formulate outline assessments to evaluate the
pre-writing stage. We further gather feedback from experienced Wikipedia
editors. Compared to articles generated by an outline-driven
retrieval-augmented baseline, more of STORM's articles are deemed to be
organized (by a 25% absolute increase) and broad in coverage (by 10%). The
expert feedback also helps identify new challenges for generating grounded long
articles, such as source bias transfer and over-association of unrelated facts.
|
[
-0.7782356142997742,
-0.9104673862457275,
0.7647106647491455,
0.33811652660369873,
-0.2504304349422455,
0.06397422403097153,
-0.27005964517593384,
-0.5641112327575684,
0.7421100735664368,
0.645761251449585,
-0.6256116628646851,
-0.3175417184829712,
-0.3818623721599579,
0.19190575182437897,
-0.9067003726959229,
1.2809457778930664,
-0.309603750705719,
-0.3584539294242859,
-0.18534806370735168,
0.419505774974823,
0.07799813896417618,
-0.3285699486732483,
-0.47901448607444763,
-0.06542797386646271,
0.8214372396469116,
0.6186853647232056,
0.6031982898712158,
0.47821179032325745,
0.39610037207603455,
0.33461993932724,
-0.10282503813505173,
0.2843264639377594,
-0.7641648650169373,
0.4515978991985321,
-0.5853458046913147,
0.17065557837486267,
-0.3053567707538605,
-0.01405904907733202,
0.7735366821289062,
0.9533823728561401,
-0.10069751739501953,
0.183481827378273,
0.10572022199630737,
0.38363516330718994,
-0.7922078967094421,
-0.3075905740261078,
-0.5863636136054993,
-0.12675873935222626,
-0.24402488768100739,
-0.15372079610824585,
-0.44403812289237976,
-0.05215497687458992,
0.1753297597169876,
-0.776822030544281,
0.4059962332248688,
0.13195379078388214,
0.806824803352356,
-0.28176403045654297,
-0.3149212598800659,
-0.3138500154018402,
-1.019386649131775,
0.35102546215057373,
-0.5152788758277893,
0.3861951529979706,
0.09605217725038528,
-0.10467344522476196,
-0.32767248153686523,
-1.1234638690948486,
-0.9044482111930847,
-0.017036305740475655,
0.20519354939460754,
0.08315311372280121,
0.07888622581958771,
-0.012706611305475235,
0.1769573837518692,
0.32398006319999695,
-0.2234412580728531,
0.2287118136882782,
-0.614719033241272,
0.0037748191971331835,
0.7501670718193054,
0.20154018700122833,
0.35160353779792786,
-0.54468834400177,
-0.264445960521698,
0.14920014142990112,
-0.8137638568878174,
-0.20320019125938416,
0.508388876914978,
0.178020179271698,
0.07973474264144897,
0.8220600485801697,
-0.46355611085891724,
0.46588990092277527,
0.28190913796424866,
-0.10305599123239517,
0.0063949828036129475,
-0.3099510669708252,
0.02349785529077053,
0.12465108931064606,
0.7770732045173645,
0.6208544969558716,
0.039238423109054565,
-0.2839403450489044,
-0.33586257696151733,
-0.3823985755443573,
0.5944169163703918,
-0.8404330611228943,
-0.37176740169525146,
0.07912813872098923,
-0.3674604892730713,
-0.48867902159690857,
0.17759333550930023,
-0.8035193681716919,
-0.8889648914337158,
-0.5274582505226135,
0.4864836633205414,
-0.17194703221321106,
-0.49996718764305115,
-0.2722470462322235,
-0.43255266547203064,
0.08234559744596481,
0.5238250494003296,
-0.7663410902023315,
0.4232253432273865,
0.5259754657745361,
0.5989583730697632,
-0.12567834556102753,
-0.7689619660377502,
-0.19909313321113586,
0.407873272895813,
-0.6970175504684448,
1.0308095216751099,
-0.10141941905021667,
-0.17050951719284058,
-0.004808662924915552,
-0.24671265482902527,
0.40553492307662964,
-0.020151114091277122,
0.25584664940834045,
-0.37451061606407166,
0.2839645445346832,
-0.21289955079555511,
-0.6647372841835022,
0.25311514735221863,
0.12427573651075363,
-0.7818626165390015,
0.9268903732299805,
0.03674947842955589,
-1.2009472846984863,
0.37914183735847473,
-0.37098219990730286,
-0.6995742321014404,
-0.1893642395734787,
-0.06283333152532578,
-0.03003879263997078,
0.38055679202079773,
0.3106127083301544,
0.47079774737358093,
-0.24487511813640594,
0.41670238971710205,
-0.19931469857692719,
-0.11656166613101959,
0.09801702201366425,
-0.11951717734336853,
0.5593114495277405,
0.09354618191719055,
-0.503750205039978,
0.41446998715400696,
-0.9464327096939087,
0.16899552941322327,
-0.12128808349370956,
-0.13700516521930695,
-0.3804829716682434,
0.2719166874885559,
0.17775020003318787,
0.1080663874745369,
0.180551216006279,
-0.29251837730407715,
0.14052920043468475,
-0.3416781425476074,
0.18367862701416016,
0.6417748332023621,
0.3830679655075073,
0.4207324683666229,
0.004164853598922491,
0.24397295713424683,
0.022891057655215263,
-0.03900674730539322,
-0.42128947377204895,
-0.1580086052417755,
-1.1604554653167725,
0.07604900002479553,
0.13869547843933105,
0.3634871244430542,
-0.857158899307251,
0.5034845471382141,
-0.30359023809432983,
-0.9538883566856384,
-0.3716130256652832,
0.4012298285961151,
0.23568201065063477,
0.5198395848274231,
0.32543259859085083,
-0.20007337629795074,
-0.8921324014663696,
-0.906043529510498,
-0.04300091788172722,
-0.1226021945476532,
0.01761595532298088,
-0.17552435398101807,
0.5342910885810852,
-0.1205265000462532,
0.8883211016654968,
-0.6363680958747864,
0.1544438749551773,
-0.6176087856292725,
0.4317086338996887,
0.011182807385921478,
0.4291774034500122,
0.24575172364711761,
-0.8418577909469604,
-0.5122056007385254,
-0.12409903854131699,
-0.7134457230567932,
-0.14179252088069916,
-0.13509821891784668,
-0.3352612853050232,
-0.029783936217427254,
0.8208240866661072,
-1.0392839908599854,
0.23276427388191223,
0.20772910118103027,
-0.45289623737335205,
0.7178805470466614,
-0.19988268613815308,
0.20727099478244781,
-1.3920180797576904,
0.27417051792144775,
-0.24248939752578735,
0.03746578469872475,
-0.7085286378860474,
0.39443591237068176,
-0.05971367284655571,
-0.5676953196525574,
-0.3513629138469696,
0.468639999628067,
-0.6127487421035767,
0.26889243721961975,
-0.47480514645576477,
0.13125009834766388,
0.1504484862089157,
0.11847144365310669,
0.2745961844921112,
0.46027278900146484,
0.4283078610897064,
-0.6004399657249451,
0.30167144536972046,
-0.047366928309202194,
-0.5204670429229736,
0.37916800379753113,
-0.675908625125885,
0.24241019785404205,
-0.508083701133728,
0.34519103169441223,
-0.6978668570518494,
-0.4267715811729431,
0.06658648699522018,
-0.11934655904769897,
0.2493818700313568,
0.14503540098667145,
-0.5009548664093018,
-0.46775785088539124,
-0.33015647530555725,
-0.03724714741110802,
0.20841196179389954,
-0.12100151926279068,
0.47447699308395386,
0.4530484080314636,
-0.7060682773590088,
-0.5067957043647766,
-0.0023116760421544313,
0.33334481716156006,
-0.06329604983329773,
-0.41573160886764526,
0.45698708295822144,
-0.1717185378074646,
-0.5941305160522461,
0.275953084230423,
-0.036058954894542694,
-0.343204140663147,
0.17720164358615875,
0.39529305696487427,
-0.164362370967865,
-0.27878889441490173,
-0.040395382791757584,
0.15712827444076538,
0.2673426866531372,
0.19203884899616241,
-0.26194143295288086,
0.49793481826782227,
0.26399731636047363,
-0.01979932002723217,
-0.08915220946073532,
0.7929359078407288,
0.5478259325027466,
-0.30289119482040405,
0.6171951293945312,
0.3369174897670746,
-0.47161948680877686,
-0.5313865542411804,
-0.7783008217811584,
-0.08116383105516434,
-0.4272315800189972,
0.3341022729873657,
-0.4718298614025116,
-0.35977959632873535,
0.5437561869621277,
0.187935471534729,
0.19413337111473083,
0.9549242258071899,
0.4498443603515625,
-0.43079516291618347,
0.40307214856147766,
0.9722747206687927,
-0.06115783751010895,
0.3517829477787018,
-0.2628127336502075,
0.19108664989471436,
-0.48028507828712463,
-0.35862794518470764,
-0.6756998896598816,
-0.3382548391819,
-0.08600309491157532,
-0.4478597044944763,
0.08611258864402771,
0.5587214827537537,
-0.22797542810440063,
0.2299199402332306,
-0.36727797985076904,
0.6202226877212524,
0.7075263857841492,
0.040330920368433,
0.2550159692764282,
0.007934901863336563,
0.059454139322042465,
0.006070844363421202,
-0.5327284336090088,
-0.29766520857810974,
1.2289011478424072,
0.03971666470170021,
0.7981316447257996,
-0.33352234959602356,
1.0300755500793457,
0.23751948773860931,
0.42895156145095825,
-0.368747353553772,
0.5185004472732544,
0.2963801622390747,
-0.8486067056655884,
-0.6339499354362488,
-0.2123040407896042,
-0.7006726264953613,
0.26191389560699463,
-0.46185439825057983,
-0.38222736120224,
0.027271196246147156,
-0.06089884787797928,
-0.14366982877254486,
0.32790055871009827,
-0.5235503911972046,
0.6427774429321289,
-0.08752842247486115,
-0.31421396136283875,
-0.3109491169452667,
-0.5385953187942505,
0.3072451055049896,
-0.13367792963981628,
0.41320812702178955,
0.08522432297468185,
0.14027270674705505,
0.966597855091095,
-0.42877334356307983,
0.7470571994781494,
0.017415566369891167,
-0.20960356295108795,
0.8018366694450378,
0.024342183023691177,
0.24256056547164917,
0.1467318832874298,
-0.05219239369034767,
-0.17770029604434967,
-0.1962127387523651,
-0.20370125770568848,
-0.6691617965698242,
0.6832606792449951,
-0.8351477980613708,
-0.7848477959632874,
-0.18411143124103546,
-0.3019639849662781,
-0.05153496935963631,
0.8364189267158508,
0.6338328123092651,
0.5214319229125977,
-0.5192098021507263,
0.08446555584669113,
0.6330068111419678,
0.08997520059347153,
0.3003831207752228,
0.4313482940196991,
-0.5877789258956909,
-0.6882160305976868,
0.6543047428131104,
0.3141922950744629,
-0.009946225211024284,
0.4722194969654083,
-0.018522612750530243,
0.15986430644989014,
-0.9171934723854065,
-0.6723392605781555,
0.01355750858783722,
-0.8580353260040283,
-0.13958343863487244,
-0.7239725589752197,
-0.4957523047924042,
-0.4659648537635803,
-0.3871798813343048,
-0.4582386910915375,
-0.5160563588142395,
-0.17908719182014465,
-0.37991222739219666,
0.09153398871421814,
0.9678486585617065,
0.08865638077259064,
0.1625175178050995,
-0.43925750255584717,
0.7032957077026367,
0.01681257039308548,
0.3467021882534027,
0.12709608674049377,
-0.15393365919589996,
-0.34207862615585327,
-0.07820555567741394,
-0.4109257161617279,
-1.0420273542404175,
0.003851791610941291,
-0.14603130519390106,
0.5536991357803345,
0.5437403321266174,
0.23787249624729156,
0.8387517929077148,
-0.9399624466896057,
0.7710117101669312,
0.4373661279678345,
-1.0482324361801147,
0.849849283695221,
-0.40329575538635254,
0.09940765798091888,
0.6683101058006287,
0.691248893737793,
-0.4279637634754181,
-0.8511104583740234,
-0.7968035936355591,
-1.0826846361160278,
0.12846451997756958,
0.1810804009437561,
0.2813150882720947,
-0.11061935126781464,
0.3980620205402374,
0.3005203604698181,
0.37420377135276794,
-0.6370166540145874,
-0.19452881813049316,
-0.4011463522911072,
0.12290584295988083,
-0.486367404460907,
-0.5952243208885193,
-0.09539830684661865,
-0.43709999322891235,
0.5500272512435913,
0.15447717905044556,
-0.17742376029491425,
0.471583753824234,
-0.26252397894859314,
-0.206720769405365,
0.30676114559173584,
0.4792197346687317,
1.256050944328308,
0.10196173191070557,
0.48914414644241333,
-0.02362973801791668,
-0.42380356788635254,
0.0586102269589901,
0.2785018980503082,
-0.4504782557487488,
0.2783185839653015,
0.8829352855682373,
0.7026045918464661,
0.6396852731704712,
-0.5249606370925903,
0.27585652470588684,
0.4283536374568939,
-0.1742517650127411,
-0.4380754828453064,
0.015311486087739468,
0.422824501991272,
-0.01580539532005787,
0.6073371171951294,
-0.3332233726978302,
0.25252556800842285,
-0.7320050001144409,
0.12783749401569366,
0.12040923535823822,
-0.05250417813658714,
-0.3122856914997101,
0.41826072335243225,
0.5637410283088684,
-0.16177713871002197,
0.8171014785766602,
0.006623636931180954,
-0.42286357283592224,
0.49537572264671326,
0.5505291223526001,
0.587840735912323,
-0.15123386681079865,
0.23444564640522003,
0.2154906690120697,
0.40215587615966797,
-0.07283678650856018,
0.4837588369846344,
0.035975996404886246,
-0.5655458569526672,
-0.40458807349205017,
-0.7552286386489868,
-0.29935163259506226,
0.26243355870246887,
-0.4716241955757141,
0.4556571841239929,
-0.632387101650238,
0.018003560602664948,
0.3366161584854126,
0.21160802245140076,
-0.6380313634872437,
0.295152872800827,
0.05942261964082718,
1.1613662242889404,
-0.8123772740364075,
0.48933959007263184,
0.8347305059432983,
-0.5516557693481445,
-0.9244213700294495,
-0.1489761471748352,
-0.3756777048110962,
-0.022283926606178284,
0.3518701195716858,
0.07965731620788574,
-0.009006566368043423,
0.07709751278162003,
-0.5098670721054077,
-0.9237679839134216,
0.8202440142631531,
0.1186954528093338,
-0.3355751037597656,
-0.6021283864974976,
-0.16247452795505524,
0.5439115762710571,
-0.29039329290390015,
-0.011921262368559837,
-0.043055593967437744,
0.4516614079475403,
-0.1533827930688858,
-1.1073906421661377,
-0.10790211707353592,
-0.34465262293815613,
-0.31977325677871704,
0.3063366115093231,
-0.1699344664812088,
0.9804772734642029,
-0.369103342294693,
-0.00986733753234148,
0.04634963721036911,
1.0296393632888794,
-0.053285304456949234,
0.3827381730079651,
0.3307194113731384,
0.571515679359436,
0.7786279320716858,
0.34987545013427734,
0.9742725491523743,
-0.21362173557281494,
-0.006615438964217901,
1.1917855739593506,
-0.1299876719713211,
1.0175511837005615,
0.5877575278282166,
0.1430201679468155,
0.9160086512565613,
0.3550652265548706,
0.1127205491065979,
0.3757832646369934,
0.29893720149993896,
-0.14331908524036407,
-0.1289907842874527,
0.02567555010318756,
-0.5028388500213623,
0.2870766520500183,
0.1507728099822998,
-0.5054289102554321,
-0.32161396741867065,
0.08564984798431396,
0.13532522320747375,
0.28629520535469055,
-0.7915428280830383,
0.925308883190155,
0.14895281195640564,
-0.8805975317955017,
0.2616083025932312,
0.20196987688541412,
0.1834510862827301,
-0.616973876953125,
0.10800358653068542,
-0.23390796780586243,
-0.0883546695113182,
-0.3092215657234192,
-0.9509007334709167,
0.17337650060653687,
0.1913842111825943,
-0.7303541302680969,
-0.4322167932987213,
0.877895712852478,
-0.4419741630554199,
-0.7558781504631042,
-0.20816992223262787,
0.6180219054222107,
0.16017037630081177,
-0.24111700057983398,
-0.0014235681155696511,
0.20140716433525085,
-0.3949960768222809,
-0.6731148958206177,
0.1648714393377304,
0.8441550135612488,
-0.11979685723781586,
0.6191405057907104,
0.5169897079467773,
0.29267847537994385,
-0.04523999243974686,
-0.058181725442409515,
0.9006727337837219,
-0.8570587038993835,
-0.8946607112884521,
-0.7330650091171265,
0.6432994604110718,
-0.42776671051979065,
-0.42716044187545776,
0.8517683148384094,
0.8177313804626465,
0.6401246786117554,
-0.19592630863189697,
0.7643450498580933,
-0.3020135462284088,
0.4992287755012512,
-0.5131236910820007,
1.1377514600753784,
-0.357587605714798,
-0.42977821826934814,
-0.6243980526924133,
-1.1287070512771606,
0.031077878549695015,
0.23229128122329712,
0.038325026631355286,
-0.28295743465423584,
0.8403728008270264,
0.2636937201023102,
-0.16949468851089478,
-0.10737691819667816,
-0.05869264155626297,
0.2364480048418045,
0.2895648777484894,
0.21722467243671417,
0.9038946032524109,
0.1254873126745224,
0.4440063536167145,
-0.5125371217727661,
-0.02189534343779087,
-0.00027068424969911575,
-0.9894781112670898,
-1.0119439363479614,
-0.9010640382766724,
-0.13188999891281128,
-0.4215645492076874,
0.05994492769241333,
0.6549929976463318,
0.6244955658912659,
-0.600278913974762,
-0.18989786505699158,
0.011672056280076504,
0.2719734013080597,
0.019820546731352806,
-0.1909795105457306,
0.44017869234085083,
-0.30850404500961304,
-0.5046615600585938,
0.3754960000514984,
0.04798245429992676,
-0.15746304392814636,
-0.5344637632369995,
0.11866899579763412,
0.047809962183237076,
0.001168531714938581,
0.6651009321212769,
0.1187346801161766,
-0.5533301830291748,
-0.2637694776058197,
-0.21147595345973969,
-0.15880894660949707,
-0.3986389935016632,
1.1335439682006836,
-0.55234694480896,
0.2992616593837738,
0.44034719467163086,
0.5701808929443359,
0.6329184770584106,
-0.04345739632844925,
0.8454059362411499,
-0.42525196075439453,
0.19103580713272095,
0.21721093356609344,
0.166352778673172,
0.29245516657829285,
-0.27248960733413696,
0.07424113154411316,
0.19250822067260742,
-0.17111067473888397,
-0.8805228471755981,
0.07735224068164825,
-0.6555128693580627,
-0.5820448398590088,
1.0406882762908936,
0.020408686250448227,
0.19164861738681793,
0.20642706751823425,
-0.12537510693073273,
0.14586961269378662,
0.0021663778461515903,
0.9197142124176025,
1.1038769483566284,
0.12973438203334808,
-0.16467799246311188,
-0.35798412561416626,
0.53474360704422,
-0.2359071671962738,
-0.8996582627296448,
0.06545835733413696,
0.8090184330940247,
0.551716148853302,
0.3203241229057312,
0.919356107711792,
0.25638213753700256,
0.2600412666797638,
0.3048338294029236,
0.12303351610898972,
-0.14890308678150177,
-0.9234197735786438,
0.3164002001285553,
0.607586145401001,
0.27843770384788513,
0.49147361516952515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14200v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14200v1
|
Towards Understanding Counseling Conversations: Domain Knowledge and Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T01:02:37 | 2024-02-22T01:02:37 |
Younghun Lee, Dan Goldwasser, Laura Schwab Reese
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding the dynamics of counseling conversations is an important task,
yet it is a challenging NLP problem regardless of the recent advance of
Transformer-based pre-trained language models. This paper proposes a systematic
approach to examine the efficacy of domain knowledge and large language models
(LLMs) in better representing conversations between a crisis counselor and a
help seeker. We empirically show that state-of-the-art language models such as
Transformer-based models and GPT models fail to predict the conversation
outcome. To provide richer context to conversations, we incorporate
human-annotated domain knowledge and LLM-generated features; simple integration
of domain knowledge and LLM features improves the model performance by
approximately 15%. We argue that both domain knowledge and LLM-generated
features can be exploited to better characterize counseling conversations when
they are used as an additional context to conversations.
|
[
-0.45495569705963135,
-0.5114628076553345,
0.8725183606147766,
0.16367635130882263,
-0.10054851323366165,
0.28869152069091797,
-0.41864824295043945,
-0.4202057719230652,
-0.10672714561223984,
0.45712852478027344,
-0.5132496356964111,
-0.40284889936447144,
-0.7789452075958252,
0.1025531217455864,
-0.34286418557167053,
0.8132783770561218,
0.12907078862190247,
0.35177743434906006,
-0.10425514727830887,
0.1331857442855835,
-0.9422833323478699,
-0.5271565914154053,
-0.9699897170066833,
-0.7213874459266663,
0.2919449210166931,
0.20723214745521545,
0.8311780691146851,
0.2530030310153961,
0.3632543385028839,
0.35333892703056335,
-0.49473312497138977,
-0.01696503348648548,
-0.9348433613777161,
0.03008350357413292,
-0.17320466041564941,
-0.3871247172355652,
-0.5538920760154724,
-0.10466136038303375,
0.08340884745121002,
0.9561434984207153,
-0.30954045057296753,
-0.10753090679645538,
0.11153565347194672,
0.3197389841079712,
-0.32078659534454346,
0.23799890279769897,
-0.820552408695221,
0.07697870582342148,
0.28262948989868164,
-0.3200366795063019,
-0.408731609582901,
-0.0032753003761172295,
0.7740709185600281,
-0.5364562273025513,
0.4372499883174896,
0.04042329266667366,
0.5907616019248962,
0.14039082825183868,
-1.0397813320159912,
-0.4499901831150055,
-1.186988115310669,
0.6017256379127502,
-0.6268700957298279,
0.38486960530281067,
0.6168149709701538,
0.3965178430080414,
-0.5010964870452881,
-0.5396436452865601,
-0.4689914882183075,
-0.028542671352624893,
-0.41586482524871826,
-0.06929894536733627,
-0.3118571639060974,
0.16321848332881927,
0.19972464442253113,
0.5049167275428772,
-0.15040837228298187,
-0.02011466957628727,
-0.3397894501686096,
-0.09654916822910309,
0.6320155262947083,
0.4579189419746399,
0.035886500030756,
-0.1815783679485321,
-0.1962568759918213,
0.20560021698474884,
-0.4612244665622711,
-0.06170648708939552,
-0.060259271413087845,
0.17790961265563965,
0.03300675004720688,
0.2135930359363556,
0.5250284075737,
0.6948188543319702,
0.05704404041171074,
-0.5245202779769897,
-0.48214712738990784,
-0.14946843683719635,
-0.36061397194862366,
-0.1490284502506256,
0.5564159750938416,
0.6186031103134155,
0.406527042388916,
-0.12532898783683777,
0.16143545508384705,
-0.4247170388698578,
0.6406769156455994,
-0.5875603556632996,
-0.07857773452997208,
0.13875454664230347,
-0.3734686076641083,
0.058674950152635574,
-0.2828191816806793,
-0.7716039419174194,
-0.6117663383483887,
-0.5697097182273865,
-0.16254402697086334,
-0.45599985122680664,
-0.3925822973251343,
0.1493580937385559,
0.020240385085344315,
0.4592427611351013,
0.6051815152168274,
-0.8422402143478394,
0.27461767196655273,
0.8883142471313477,
0.6757938861846924,
-0.15863804519176483,
0.11324061453342438,
-0.09032164514064789,
0.16492652893066406,
-0.20447787642478943,
0.7774946093559265,
-0.6217166185379028,
-0.8034583330154419,
0.38000544905662537,
0.10793928056955338,
-0.24524042010307312,
-0.5046680569648743,
0.7218645811080933,
-0.6095571517944336,
0.2581006586551666,
-0.3500877022743225,
-0.6452344655990601,
-0.12868298590183258,
0.4463643729686737,
-0.2842452824115753,
0.6856750845909119,
0.18455824255943298,
-0.6186472773551941,
0.43928101658821106,
-0.568686842918396,
-0.18805193901062012,
0.20640167593955994,
-0.07153172045946121,
-0.1465999037027359,
0.10092104226350784,
0.18885979056358337,
0.45036885142326355,
-0.39190176129341125,
0.666525661945343,
-0.07996988296508789,
-0.2763429284095764,
0.38815510272979736,
-0.29641127586364746,
0.34403154253959656,
0.07267913222312927,
0.08642491698265076,
-0.05530713126063347,
-0.5828530788421631,
-0.2282743901014328,
0.17819015681743622,
-0.3977191150188446,
-0.46008870005607605,
-0.15659943222999573,
0.10065435618162155,
0.1316222995519638,
-0.19588707387447357,
-0.32279258966445923,
0.25228065252304077,
-0.5951630473136902,
0.24899281561374664,
0.30837419629096985,
0.11324939131736755,
0.43369418382644653,
-0.09244272857904434,
0.7335373759269714,
0.04553253948688507,
-0.07856220752000809,
-0.3184119760990143,
-0.6066325306892395,
-0.6333814263343811,
0.08776132017374039,
-0.07532466948032379,
0.42854541540145874,
-0.6864763498306274,
0.3902581036090851,
-0.07031088322401047,
-0.30653589963912964,
-0.27414706349372864,
0.11356477439403534,
0.4719667136669159,
0.5288935899734497,
0.6046082377433777,
-0.1738961637020111,
-0.5567641258239746,
-0.7174148559570312,
-0.547383189201355,
-0.0470927469432354,
-0.23657646775245667,
0.528476893901825,
0.37881770730018616,
-0.0984499529004097,
1.0989550352096558,
-0.5930777192115784,
-0.23947297036647797,
-0.6428404450416565,
0.04340369626879692,
0.13271479308605194,
0.25791648030281067,
0.5071955919265747,
-0.6857955455780029,
-0.509047269821167,
-0.03546514734625816,
-0.4753246605396271,
0.1082349643111229,
-0.19564612209796906,
-0.12789539992809296,
-0.22775845229625702,
0.29637274146080017,
-0.4812098443508148,
0.6456641554832458,
0.2235124111175537,
-0.7366644144058228,
0.48000338673591614,
-0.21563111245632172,
0.19165225327014923,
-1.1459133625030518,
-0.15091055631637573,
0.1807958334684372,
-0.27834537625312805,
-1.2230221033096313,
-0.46462810039520264,
-0.2492615133523941,
-0.20251435041427612,
-0.29702964425086975,
0.49393877387046814,
-0.4838997721672058,
0.06717882305383682,
-0.3037683963775635,
0.40646642446517944,
-0.18085473775863647,
0.4703933596611023,
0.15025123953819275,
0.825503408908844,
0.34483784437179565,
-0.3553527593612671,
0.37826111912727356,
0.8608919382095337,
-0.2060776799917221,
0.8354231119155884,
-0.5746267437934875,
0.2710646688938141,
-0.12158576399087906,
0.3852490782737732,
-0.8849879503250122,
-0.33201712369918823,
-0.077264703810215,
0.049720440059900284,
0.5031216144561768,
-0.6918604373931885,
0.03862157091498375,
-0.5288282632827759,
0.0706273689866066,
0.4172993004322052,
0.0994187444448471,
-0.39396825432777405,
0.520390510559082,
0.3823423683643341,
-0.3663500249385834,
-0.6519789099693298,
-0.25405117869377136,
0.40972405672073364,
-0.37462538480758667,
-0.595841646194458,
0.3492576777935028,
0.2426331490278244,
-0.29000985622406006,
-0.32652437686920166,
0.07263629138469696,
-0.14888975024223328,
0.011836948804557323,
0.3919811546802521,
0.3889423906803131,
-0.33208876848220825,
0.4097767174243927,
-0.043509431183338165,
-0.38956114649772644,
0.28782954812049866,
-0.048152390867471695,
0.7751774787902832,
-0.2782665491104126,
-0.6251009106636047,
-0.2759387791156769,
0.5336712598800659,
0.49073049426078796,
0.10252012312412262,
1.0929830074310303,
0.4391830265522003,
-0.12200389802455902,
-0.00022039237956050783,
-0.6309196949005127,
-0.14113573729991913,
-0.4238985776901245,
0.32423684000968933,
-0.2301938682794571,
-1.0924103260040283,
0.5058408975601196,
-0.5531442165374756,
0.029117073863744736,
0.15119028091430664,
0.4896881878376007,
0.10377699136734009,
0.8869180679321289,
0.8960297107696533,
0.058729901909828186,
0.4197595417499542,
-0.33113807439804077,
0.825482964515686,
-0.9630160927772522,
-0.3153211772441864,
-0.32127049565315247,
-0.3155438005924225,
-0.11516265571117401,
-0.34186071157455444,
0.45845478773117065,
0.3296988010406494,
-0.06887079030275345,
0.2589403986930847,
-0.32368290424346924,
0.3728199005126953,
0.01153559423983097,
-0.21417167782783508,
0.6268835663795471,
-0.20217104256153107,
0.06604553014039993,
-0.4366506338119507,
-0.614081621170044,
-0.8677141070365906,
0.7694903612136841,
0.4959240257740021,
0.5129664540290833,
0.05959828943014145,
0.13180282711982727,
-0.280291348695755,
0.6260408163070679,
-1.1114674806594849,
0.4224872887134552,
0.4129965007305145,
-0.5156537890434265,
-0.24385812878608704,
-0.22393450140953064,
-1.0609501600265503,
0.4769507944583893,
-0.3236946761608124,
-0.9111523628234863,
0.22610065340995789,
0.1492348611354828,
-0.42739641666412354,
0.25603145360946655,
-0.5287998914718628,
0.9272021651268005,
-0.07314911484718323,
0.16185304522514343,
-0.21459583938121796,
-0.4206799566745758,
0.5494564771652222,
-0.14240774512290955,
0.4081730842590332,
-0.13240815699100494,
0.3183344304561615,
0.6752492785453796,
-0.7426924109458923,
0.7051963210105896,
-0.0673753023147583,
-0.5149052143096924,
0.204660564661026,
0.14172594249248505,
0.3447495698928833,
0.1306276023387909,
0.048482153564691544,
-0.22793591022491455,
0.23406393826007843,
-0.09269175678491592,
-0.8149408102035522,
0.2347712367773056,
-0.4638088345527649,
-0.8219186663627625,
0.061883024871349335,
-0.609869122505188,
-0.6867654919624329,
-0.11164142936468124,
0.0911034643650055,
0.539512574672699,
-0.33940133452415466,
-0.029775161296129227,
0.28128132224082947,
-0.3284182846546173,
0.22446249425411224,
0.6115544438362122,
-0.44021642208099365,
-0.042042989283800125,
0.39410245418548584,
-0.09036535024642944,
0.2866974174976349,
-0.30418211221694946,
0.1901334971189499,
-0.1924249231815338,
-0.3879076838493347,
-0.039559733122587204,
0.4556693732738495,
-0.9984726309776306,
-0.3165883421897888,
-0.8149348497390747,
-0.1639164835214615,
-0.32415440678596497,
-0.21395470201969147,
-0.26297497749328613,
-0.109937883913517,
-0.25265195965766907,
-0.3628171682357788,
0.7064082622528076,
0.9641568660736084,
0.16775064170360565,
0.527566134929657,
-1.0730299949645996,
-0.024903282523155212,
0.3674657642841339,
0.08728078752756119,
0.42915990948677063,
-0.6927790641784668,
-0.2759753465652466,
0.014826441183686256,
-0.6048657298088074,
-1.1021522283554077,
0.5265415906906128,
0.20615413784980774,
0.31086474657058716,
0.5538816452026367,
-0.013435352593660355,
0.9385117292404175,
-0.36204662919044495,
0.9496269226074219,
0.08884882181882858,
-0.9025890231132507,
0.5979129076004028,
-0.400226891040802,
0.0680641457438469,
0.531679093837738,
0.6586530804634094,
-0.8252803683280945,
-0.4657866358757019,
-0.5784770250320435,
-0.7599243521690369,
0.7452298402786255,
0.08125809580087662,
0.44682931900024414,
0.011616745963692665,
0.6329383254051208,
-0.11627127230167389,
0.2088707834482193,
-0.5160557627677917,
-0.329695463180542,
0.04578988254070282,
-0.08644993603229523,
0.09165842086076736,
-0.5556764602661133,
-0.436553031206131,
-0.371041476726532,
0.4735046625137329,
-0.17728953063488007,
0.2886657416820526,
0.12860919535160065,
0.172623872756958,
-0.3218180239200592,
0.5897021293640137,
0.6811074614524841,
0.8513668179512024,
0.1806447058916092,
0.05721702426671982,
0.6552000045776367,
-0.5482144355773926,
0.08431167155504227,
-0.21600717306137085,
0.42929449677467346,
-0.06350180506706238,
0.7301530241966248,
0.8395354151725769,
0.5532767176628113,
-0.46693846583366394,
0.745357096195221,
-0.343225359916687,
-0.37015071511268616,
-0.22555358707904816,
0.009391766041517258,
0.3717341721057892,
0.4580104947090149,
0.3809065818786621,
-0.21142561733722687,
0.016761789098381996,
-0.6361045241355896,
0.04196607321500778,
0.47260579466819763,
-0.47439324855804443,
-0.28021129965782166,
0.26162540912628174,
0.2335536777973175,
-0.6774720549583435,
0.5106580853462219,
0.13746008276939392,
-0.8193123936653137,
0.31250205636024475,
0.8265975117683411,
0.600258469581604,
-0.209822878241539,
0.1983266919851303,
0.07039202749729156,
-0.3016948997974396,
-0.24655315279960632,
0.046848271042108536,
-0.19263625144958496,
-0.8375335335731506,
-0.5729905366897583,
-0.5113407373428345,
-0.607038676738739,
0.2722150981426239,
-0.8386073112487793,
0.04424278438091278,
-0.13714182376861572,
-0.33358234167099,
-0.31776443123817444,
-0.22518165409564972,
-0.8048962354660034,
-0.14162993431091309,
-0.11919870972633362,
0.9394450187683105,
-0.7426098585128784,
0.5472062826156616,
0.5275123119354248,
0.15066561102867126,
-1.205365777015686,
-0.04092169180512428,
0.05858343094587326,
-0.6548916697502136,
0.6754460334777832,
0.08093355596065521,
-0.15018950402736664,
-0.1587487757205963,
-0.4134017825126648,
-0.8028004169464111,
1.0589115619659424,
0.5579173564910889,
-0.503150224685669,
-0.19395452737808228,
0.3363972008228302,
0.8863188624382019,
-0.49205613136291504,
0.44815415143966675,
0.9618545174598694,
0.5778589248657227,
0.5408420562744141,
-1.1836501359939575,
-0.08533304184675217,
-0.18559198081493378,
0.164409339427948,
0.1163102313876152,
-0.08997788280248642,
0.3480257987976074,
-0.22861507534980774,
-0.47982627153396606,
-0.18806347250938416,
0.5602847933769226,
-0.06835372745990753,
0.3248797059059143,
0.46857476234436035,
0.11685046553611755,
0.796488881111145,
-0.14588592946529388,
1.0031250715255737,
-0.4291486442089081,
0.5950501561164856,
1.1686456203460693,
-0.19736234843730927,
0.5837779641151428,
0.3189997971057892,
-0.21872828900814056,
0.31294989585876465,
0.43521222472190857,
0.05541953817009926,
-0.014705712907016277,
0.2353312373161316,
-0.2914906144142151,
-0.42206472158432007,
-0.15488485991954803,
-0.2911493480205536,
0.4669700860977173,
0.5936991572380066,
-0.3818575143814087,
-0.363430380821228,
0.22228290140628815,
0.16253696382045746,
0.09160872548818588,
-0.10818410664796829,
1.0461331605911255,
0.6037182211875916,
-0.6062125563621521,
0.6119897961616516,
-0.1273382604122162,
0.38268908858299255,
-0.21091990172863007,
-0.16865938901901245,
-0.19299502670764923,
0.061414096504449844,
-0.31358951330184937,
-0.9343694448471069,
0.6114104390144348,
0.22914312779903412,
0.04818219691514969,
-0.4009646475315094,
0.9109743237495422,
-0.5437712669372559,
-0.33095255494117737,
0.400417298078537,
0.7195687890052795,
0.16160345077514648,
-0.026986079290509224,
-0.4049236476421356,
-0.0856466218829155,
-0.35683587193489075,
-0.33863118290901184,
0.37860947847366333,
0.5768831372261047,
0.21655279397964478,
0.7443609833717346,
0.49441811442375183,
-0.08241930603981018,
-0.21307943761348724,
0.27453896403312683,
0.9832836985588074,
-0.6803647875785828,
-0.23397603631019592,
-0.7718486189842224,
0.44205400347709656,
-0.16635651886463165,
-0.3636024296283722,
0.6554340124130249,
-0.07109003514051437,
0.43172597885131836,
0.13393434882164001,
0.39849504828453064,
0.29345548152923584,
0.6295852661132812,
-0.3535550832748413,
0.459078311920166,
-0.19058126211166382,
0.5788252353668213,
-0.3098939061164856,
-0.7354409098625183,
-0.33170831203460693,
0.7427670359611511,
-0.8451836109161377,
0.100970558822155,
0.5447310209274292,
0.5797146558761597,
-0.06822606176137924,
0.4733472466468811,
0.4701184928417206,
0.2718532681465149,
0.831278920173645,
0.5195952653884888,
1.2269591093063354,
-0.15420971810817719,
0.5839184522628784,
0.14497046172618866,
0.05538434535264969,
-0.1117495447397232,
-0.846674919128418,
-1.1343169212341309,
-0.5076773762702942,
0.044512789696455,
-0.1359681487083435,
-0.48449191451072693,
1.008678674697876,
0.5425752401351929,
-0.5417188405990601,
-0.1165463775396347,
0.06539326161146164,
0.15936894714832306,
0.16610626876354218,
-0.2070411890745163,
0.06478463858366013,
-0.36374911665916443,
-0.33250871300697327,
0.6851768493652344,
0.32184892892837524,
0.02599935606122017,
-0.3013768196105957,
-0.048626530915498734,
0.1926601231098175,
0.1550886183977127,
0.6648181676864624,
0.014163563027977943,
-0.6830338835716248,
-0.32536962628364563,
-0.34840652346611023,
0.09374584257602692,
0.28554242849349976,
1.460179090499878,
-0.6983931660652161,
0.09401943534612656,
-0.1342100203037262,
0.5892336368560791,
0.4817882776260376,
0.1704033613204956,
1.1211827993392944,
-0.6149690747261047,
-0.09677336364984512,
0.07143624126911163,
0.3963008224964142,
0.40522605180740356,
-0.6841554045677185,
0.4148145318031311,
-0.03986940160393715,
-0.6320449709892273,
-0.720535933971405,
0.43192943930625916,
-0.6359118819236755,
-0.19140155613422394,
0.996820330619812,
-0.467746376991272,
0.16531920433044434,
-0.6967753767967224,
-0.6138774752616882,
0.14049699902534485,
-0.35105955600738525,
0.7610756158828735,
0.6528722047805786,
-0.2899390459060669,
-0.2938689589500427,
-0.523781418800354,
0.943142831325531,
0.256095826625824,
-0.6738583445549011,
0.42665785551071167,
0.22152771055698395,
0.14837828278541565,
0.4275433421134949,
0.5739139914512634,
0.116497702896595,
-0.1796359419822693,
-0.46634259819984436,
-0.49459806084632874,
0.06341781467199326,
-0.2039841115474701,
-0.4229026138782501,
0.30018988251686096,
0.10082395374774933,
0.7818319201469421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14195v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14195v1
|
Learning to Reduce: Optimal Representations of Structured Data in Prompting Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T00:41:23 | 2024-02-22T00:41:23 |
Younghun Lee, Sungchul Kim, Tong Yu, Ryan A. Rossi, Xiang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have been widely used as general-purpose AI
agents showing comparable performance on many downstream tasks. However,
existing work shows that it is challenging for LLMs to integrate structured
data (e.g. KG, tables, DBs) into their prompts; LLMs need to either understand
long text data or select the most relevant evidence prior to inference, and
both approaches are not trivial.
In this paper, we propose a framework, Learning to Reduce, that fine-tunes a
language model to generate a reduced version of an input context, given a task
description and context input. The model learns to reduce the input context
using On-Policy Reinforcement Learning and aims to improve the reasoning
performance of a fixed LLM. Experimental results illustrate that our model not
only achieves comparable accuracies in selecting the relevant evidence from an
input context, but also shows generalizability on different datasets. We
further show that our model helps improve the LLM's performance on downstream
tasks especially when the context is long.
|
[
-0.28832072019577026,
-0.6285094618797302,
0.8978985548019409,
-0.07047344744205475,
0.007086093071848154,
-0.3627430200576782,
-0.65962153673172,
-0.07208374887704849,
-0.2551213800907135,
0.54863041639328,
-0.660618782043457,
-0.5493329763412476,
-0.5405268669128418,
0.1653297394514084,
-0.30724531412124634,
1.0076308250427246,
-0.11138272285461426,
-0.2087862640619278,
-0.3191416263580322,
-0.06365042924880981,
-0.49739259481430054,
-0.1967718005180359,
-0.9903035759925842,
-0.6611520051956177,
0.5601041316986084,
0.338969886302948,
0.35576939582824707,
0.7388330698013306,
0.05590661242604256,
0.3541255295276642,
-0.2341381013393402,
0.34189343452453613,
-0.711757481098175,
0.18880178034305573,
-0.44796672463417053,
-0.5780512094497681,
0.0655955895781517,
-0.17146967351436615,
0.766635000705719,
0.8912467360496521,
-0.0780230164527893,
-0.07903532683849335,
0.19638022780418396,
0.404344379901886,
-0.6785465478897095,
0.7913859486579895,
-0.4971638023853302,
-0.014813568443059921,
0.2593242824077606,
-0.23583216965198517,
-0.7526111006736755,
-0.11116281151771545,
0.05683764070272446,
-0.8007752299308777,
0.031015140935778618,
-0.2748661935329437,
0.6489308476448059,
0.592736005783081,
-0.5934261083602905,
-0.2416110634803772,
-0.7756852507591248,
0.8966905474662781,
-0.4776393175125122,
0.2920944392681122,
0.4445045590400696,
0.15384994447231293,
-0.2718966007232666,
-0.517096996307373,
-0.47213125228881836,
-0.33220887184143066,
-0.39749792218208313,
-0.16154637932777405,
-0.04304397478699684,
0.2663118839263916,
0.31932923197746277,
-0.08424771577119827,
-0.45550987124443054,
0.3315379321575165,
-0.3033398687839508,
-0.10445498675107956,
0.5227988958358765,
0.23614798486232758,
-0.07785004377365112,
0.06358186155557632,
-0.0497511588037014,
-0.2582933306694031,
-0.9872375130653381,
0.24731674790382385,
-0.18807072937488556,
0.630229651927948,
-0.018538575619459152,
0.2921994626522064,
-0.3696492612361908,
0.7388464212417603,
0.06855940073728561,
-0.08200695365667343,
-0.060893796384334564,
0.007915250957012177,
-0.2864305078983307,
0.0016816899878904223,
0.49221569299697876,
0.24233537912368774,
0.208937406539917,
-0.12088676542043686,
-0.4863707423210144,
0.17174839973449707,
0.12724779546260834,
-0.9657948017120361,
-0.13755744695663452,
0.02940765582025051,
-0.32869336009025574,
-0.22856004536151886,
-0.3672182559967041,
-0.17455491423606873,
-0.4076918065547943,
-0.5570396184921265,
0.12706276774406433,
-0.2452879101037979,
0.2490919977426529,
-0.07125859707593918,
0.045504163950681686,
0.3392179310321808,
0.6972717046737671,
-0.8164265751838684,
0.30524909496307373,
0.7380530834197998,
0.6913226246833801,
-0.07627669721841812,
-0.1245017871260643,
-0.9969318509101868,
0.4412798583507538,
-0.63042813539505,
0.6852900981903076,
-0.689389169216156,
-0.4114161431789398,
0.2155994474887848,
0.06264462321996689,
-0.05485912412405014,
-0.6549345850944519,
0.43968498706817627,
-0.4162226617336273,
0.24956685304641724,
-0.19642552733421326,
-0.6177145838737488,
-0.3110797107219696,
0.4668714106082916,
-0.7777868509292603,
0.7914981842041016,
0.21527700126171112,
-0.11488693207502365,
0.5495064854621887,
-0.9015772342681885,
-0.6805355548858643,
0.03131305053830147,
-0.30441659688949585,
-0.25058668851852417,
0.18411315977573395,
0.5131136178970337,
0.6923508048057556,
-0.3301622271537781,
0.5121030807495117,
-0.17649012804031372,
-0.3749714195728302,
-0.09924829006195068,
-0.29371461272239685,
0.4636766016483307,
0.3480794131755829,
-0.005572524853050709,
0.38952431082725525,
-0.676143229007721,
-0.2934580445289612,
0.20196250081062317,
-0.8842545747756958,
-0.39594268798828125,
0.35545986890792847,
0.02612658217549324,
0.09694826602935791,
-0.10927119851112366,
-0.33063840866088867,
0.3928513526916504,
-0.6013208627700806,
0.6850678324699402,
0.8309147357940674,
-0.18700717389583588,
0.6999521851539612,
-0.3691544234752655,
0.29156121611595154,
-0.12490905821323395,
-0.11922860890626907,
-0.07559316605329514,
-0.12501057982444763,
-0.703357458114624,
-0.35663333535194397,
0.15730565786361694,
0.5114242434501648,
-0.8779539465904236,
0.324476033449173,
-0.4980260729789734,
0.1350911408662796,
-0.15889610350131989,
0.27744218707084656,
0.3612048327922821,
0.5797191858291626,
0.4060443043708801,
0.08466801792383194,
-0.3759974539279938,
-0.7056763172149658,
-0.0832161083817482,
-0.17788419127464294,
-0.4279222786426544,
0.3085465431213379,
0.41335830092430115,
-0.30101582407951355,
0.9445487260818481,
-0.4431624412536621,
-0.1700270175933838,
-0.559756338596344,
0.043014876544475555,
0.21762031316757202,
0.4359225332736969,
0.424865186214447,
-0.6832484602928162,
-0.29438790678977966,
0.1583121418952942,
-0.5789833664894104,
0.014467324130237103,
-0.3183266222476959,
0.2005670815706253,
0.20286917686462402,
0.783306360244751,
-0.7796047925949097,
0.5790998339653015,
0.26038891077041626,
-0.3368888795375824,
0.21079953014850616,
-0.2180504947900772,
0.015257400460541248,
-1.026926040649414,
0.04275518283247948,
0.004216248635202646,
-0.5770153999328613,
-0.6811254024505615,
-0.07052284479141235,
-0.064626045525074,
-0.31909918785095215,
-0.33822381496429443,
0.7889276742935181,
-0.19073355197906494,
0.08552758395671844,
-0.2987622916698456,
-0.04679495841264725,
0.06302133202552795,
0.7256613969802856,
0.3210070729255676,
0.7055771946907043,
0.32760685682296753,
-1.0066156387329102,
0.2755693197250366,
0.4848543405532837,
-0.44298791885375977,
0.3583301305770874,
-0.6449893712997437,
-0.11770317703485489,
-0.2650775909423828,
0.3666052222251892,
-0.7294923663139343,
-0.26837003231048584,
0.21181651949882507,
-0.2975917458534241,
0.46517467498779297,
-0.20070526003837585,
-0.22004257142543793,
0.0396164134144783,
-0.1694529950618744,
0.27563539147377014,
0.499197393655777,
-0.7910525798797607,
0.5112369656562805,
0.10931996256113052,
-0.20913144946098328,
-0.39908576011657715,
-0.7689192295074463,
-0.09034551680088043,
-0.22090411186218262,
-0.34012046456336975,
0.8040976524353027,
0.011781074106693268,
-0.10713125020265579,
0.12169495224952698,
0.006751688197255135,
-0.04260830581188202,
0.2735929489135742,
0.025683296844363213,
-0.03395051509141922,
-0.08946743607521057,
0.6230136156082153,
0.2217012643814087,
-0.06022978946566582,
0.19241878390312195,
-0.09482115507125854,
0.4409192204475403,
0.0682271346449852,
-0.14061512053012848,
-0.49488237500190735,
0.4069187343120575,
0.3827412724494934,
0.09638190269470215,
0.9528607130050659,
0.17836417257785797,
-0.3266896903514862,
-0.6378822922706604,
0.00017496653890702873,
-0.2915114462375641,
-0.48884105682373047,
0.5500637292861938,
-0.4064086377620697,
-1.0752456188201904,
0.38426756858825684,
-0.4570736587047577,
0.11878986656665802,
0.2286066859960556,
0.4657341539859772,
0.05541383847594261,
1.2162680625915527,
0.5673700571060181,
-0.41838303208351135,
0.6651496291160583,
-0.3992629051208496,
0.2723701298236847,
-0.5173968076705933,
-0.17196659743785858,
-0.5289360880851746,
-0.13578085601329803,
-0.5484175682067871,
-0.5293413996696472,
0.14867138862609863,
0.02563875913619995,
-0.5938589572906494,
-0.04527918994426727,
-0.3216779828071594,
0.5594239234924316,
0.31042325496673584,
0.28010404109954834,
0.09753501415252686,
-0.06960426270961761,
0.14558419585227966,
0.48984038829803467,
-0.8787984251976013,
-0.3449001908302307,
0.9555859565734863,
0.2609708309173584,
0.6615978479385376,
0.049220819026231766,
0.6323786377906799,
0.5191956162452698,
0.2751624882221222,
-1.0209661722183228,
0.5611267685890198,
-0.0458480566740036,
-0.10178732126951218,
-0.5785862803459167,
-0.662104070186615,
-1.1770926713943481,
0.07499130070209503,
-0.19092652201652527,
-0.48496681451797485,
0.02939870022237301,
0.2177576869726181,
-0.21639445424079895,
0.011976614594459534,
-0.34522634744644165,
0.7392638921737671,
0.013510878197848797,
-0.1801988035440445,
-0.47974181175231934,
-0.30969369411468506,
0.16752195358276367,
0.2388223111629486,
0.24639533460140228,
0.04036420211195946,
-0.1510239839553833,
0.5340774059295654,
-0.7509638071060181,
0.9019165635108948,
-0.3058835566043854,
-0.10680091381072998,
0.1554068624973297,
0.03167785704135895,
1.0110894441604614,
-0.04295329749584198,
0.04548106715083122,
-0.2633991837501526,
-0.3428723216056824,
-0.48181605339050293,
-0.9116975665092468,
0.580418050289154,
-0.6696510910987854,
-0.5445247292518616,
-0.05323222652077675,
-0.7310051321983337,
-0.3099944591522217,
-0.11217010021209717,
-0.018792279064655304,
0.5190926194190979,
-0.1102525070309639,
0.3493325710296631,
0.8041900992393494,
-0.26893192529678345,
0.3249250054359436,
0.24038687348365784,
-0.17130529880523682,
-0.17394106090068817,
0.7078492045402527,
-0.02075166627764702,
0.07530675083398819,
0.5105319619178772,
0.33389055728912354,
-0.5117545127868652,
-0.6895504593849182,
-0.2581676244735718,
0.09245139360427856,
-1.0406848192214966,
-0.1144447848200798,
-0.12181653082370758,
0.01832837611436844,
-0.5494121313095093,
-0.2642906606197357,
-0.04001256078481674,
-0.17493055760860443,
-0.3823343515396118,
-0.27473020553588867,
0.48973292112350464,
0.7213847041130066,
0.06344973295927048,
0.4714260697364807,
-0.6417271494865417,
0.2018771916627884,
0.43928730487823486,
0.19776053726673126,
-0.15918214619159698,
-0.6473531723022461,
-0.20837928354740143,
-0.1098421961069107,
0.03232875466346741,
-0.6417697072029114,
0.5369601249694824,
0.4984488785266876,
0.7359817028045654,
0.45735928416252136,
0.19743871688842773,
0.5759150981903076,
-0.3891753852367401,
0.4506430923938751,
0.09518428891897202,
-1.0084888935089111,
0.7933059930801392,
-0.49652236700057983,
0.4330555498600006,
0.4888189435005188,
0.5240126252174377,
-0.4746054708957672,
-0.08035426586866379,
-0.19763752818107605,
-0.8322198390960693,
0.7305982708930969,
-0.003324969671666622,
0.02301422506570816,
-0.05244201794266701,
0.45627519488334656,
-0.03710072860121727,
0.2002958059310913,
-0.8069924116134644,
0.03966022655367851,
0.24471373856067657,
-0.41697660088539124,
-0.20461603999137878,
-0.08292433619499207,
-0.02687254548072815,
-0.4019749164581299,
0.6731171011924744,
-0.47243574261665344,
0.19125358760356903,
0.03173233941197395,
-0.5276109576225281,
0.23640775680541992,
0.3308226466178894,
0.5918463468551636,
0.53951495885849,
0.18076328933238983,
-0.014193703420460224,
0.3587954640388489,
0.033910661935806274,
0.00849306583404541,
-0.2029997706413269,
-0.4824884235858917,
-0.19424740970134735,
0.5556172728538513,
1.0466405153274536,
0.3211502432823181,
-0.8985854983329773,
0.31649237871170044,
0.016405988484621048,
-0.3305415213108063,
-0.09358234703540802,
0.12246989458799362,
-0.14026403427124023,
0.34144026041030884,
0.08755111694335938,
-0.1255633533000946,
0.2349204570055008,
-0.6932886838912964,
0.12650033831596375,
0.3017370104789734,
-0.27595674991607666,
-0.020663704723119736,
0.21452870965003967,
0.3821435570716858,
-0.2624155879020691,
0.8729020357131958,
-0.3290976583957672,
-0.6063046455383301,
0.5428863167762756,
0.452821284532547,
0.5367916226387024,
-0.2416599690914154,
0.2637668550014496,
0.3688490390777588,
0.17902100086212158,
-0.18329063057899475,
0.03016185760498047,
-0.43273940682411194,
-0.6703235507011414,
-0.8674038648605347,
-0.46115830540657043,
-0.3593071699142456,
0.40144699811935425,
-0.628239631652832,
0.13594762980937958,
-0.640167772769928,
0.048384446650743484,
-0.31824690103530884,
-0.046268586069345474,
-0.782499372959137,
0.08561424165964127,
0.1534155011177063,
0.5671895146369934,
-1.0049891471862793,
0.8626264333724976,
0.49111396074295044,
-0.31999704241752625,
-0.94329833984375,
-0.131071075797081,
-0.10938684642314911,
-0.597412109375,
0.8150379657745361,
0.4218803644180298,
0.0765356793999672,
-0.18948951363563538,
-0.7752286791801453,
-0.7841938734054565,
0.7665535807609558,
0.7165006399154663,
-0.5003491044044495,
0.004357330501079559,
0.10928612947463989,
0.34493380784988403,
-0.4777959883213043,
0.005965392105281353,
0.755985677242279,
0.5999657511711121,
0.111390121281147,
-0.8115860819816589,
0.26036596298217773,
-0.1594541221857071,
0.13660810887813568,
0.33683741092681885,
-0.2929421365261078,
0.9115489721298218,
-0.11399579048156738,
-0.30288824439048767,
-0.16799113154411316,
0.5445035696029663,
0.17223620414733887,
0.33671462535858154,
0.4686530530452728,
0.5380312204360962,
0.8434309959411621,
-0.05725497379899025,
1.1279367208480835,
0.16418805718421936,
0.34622013568878174,
1.2092094421386719,
-0.4061693251132965,
0.8115072846412659,
0.3463888466358185,
-0.1243453100323677,
0.6425790190696716,
0.6638586521148682,
0.19214396178722382,
0.7875770926475525,
0.3737899959087372,
-0.2800339460372925,
-0.5138513445854187,
-0.2903650403022766,
0.10668796300888062,
0.47560134530067444,
0.605858564376831,
-0.34531137347221375,
-0.40018802881240845,
0.20059888064861298,
0.05988805741071701,
0.39114975929260254,
-0.7095576524734497,
1.0428524017333984,
-0.18014997243881226,
-0.8850795030593872,
0.7980502843856812,
0.04289886727929115,
0.4667845070362091,
-0.5345751047134399,
-0.38506442308425903,
-0.21439868211746216,
0.2721957862377167,
-0.07779207825660706,
-0.531482994556427,
0.45950865745544434,
-0.1371326744556427,
-0.45840173959732056,
-0.4911653697490692,
0.6304969191551208,
-0.5649212598800659,
-0.2084953486919403,
0.47382408380508423,
0.14082510769367218,
0.21086767315864563,
-0.17521706223487854,
-0.7015243172645569,
0.0010448675602674484,
-0.09223911911249161,
-0.44143837690353394,
0.48413169384002686,
0.37225234508514404,
-0.30050915479660034,
0.8742416501045227,
0.690414309501648,
0.11469652503728867,
-0.32582610845565796,
0.09181783348321915,
1.026244878768921,
-0.617961585521698,
-0.6364245414733887,
-0.6685598492622375,
0.29330524802207947,
-0.1803889274597168,
0.03296691179275513,
0.23649369180202484,
0.3669474720954895,
1.0283172130584717,
-0.047973670065402985,
0.9432738423347473,
0.08334167301654816,
0.4351045489311218,
-0.8943948149681091,
0.532145082950592,
-0.597013533115387,
0.29508376121520996,
0.3539402186870575,
-0.7024762034416199,
-0.21152529120445251,
0.9857541918754578,
-0.4312814772129059,
0.034619495272636414,
0.5765747427940369,
0.842201828956604,
0.20098736882209778,
-0.44929200410842896,
0.4923877418041229,
0.058974940329790115,
0.42397987842559814,
0.910423994064331,
0.730337917804718,
-0.12121733278036118,
0.602725625038147,
0.007018235046416521,
0.014989567920565605,
-0.2912122905254364,
-0.8053655624389648,
-1.1176599264144897,
-0.5773900747299194,
-0.13840052485466003,
-0.10958558320999146,
0.19072960317134857,
1.1124848127365112,
0.7370797395706177,
-0.9773309230804443,
-0.14829328656196594,
-0.29676494002342224,
0.4004723131656647,
-0.22312869131565094,
-0.16671493649482727,
0.3301182687282562,
-0.6038582921028137,
-0.6695911884307861,
0.9027860760688782,
0.1206502914428711,
-0.2946431338787079,
-0.0232529416680336,
-0.5233592987060547,
-0.13438713550567627,
0.2150004357099533,
0.8323975205421448,
0.38989847898483276,
-0.6566160917282104,
-0.56117182970047,
-0.35891103744506836,
-0.005172956269234419,
0.02732536941766739,
0.9629340171813965,
-1.0903122425079346,
0.14192837476730347,
0.7296659350395203,
0.8736714124679565,
0.6004220843315125,
-0.10615910589694977,
0.6523847579956055,
-0.9034885764122009,
0.25011155009269714,
0.3844095766544342,
0.4301251471042633,
0.0935744047164917,
-0.37488868832588196,
0.5415468215942383,
0.04977027326822281,
-0.46455979347229004,
-0.7883407473564148,
0.33999761939048767,
-0.807384192943573,
-0.685616135597229,
1.1745164394378662,
-0.30222171545028687,
-0.43738284707069397,
-0.23529578745365143,
-0.07170265913009644,
0.22790372371673584,
-0.5211737155914307,
0.4592694938182831,
0.43802550435066223,
-0.07405643910169601,
-0.3068235218524933,
-0.17304067313671112,
0.741883397102356,
0.4013780355453491,
-1.0293961763381958,
0.34167370200157166,
0.8646053075790405,
0.2092089056968689,
-0.09227205812931061,
0.4140181839466095,
0.38104957342147827,
0.3185824155807495,
-0.15018244087696075,
-0.0497734472155571,
-0.2554331123828888,
-0.6361197233200073,
-0.6399936079978943,
0.14467668533325195,
0.19043107330799103,
-0.013013141229748726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14187v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14187v1
|
From Adoption to Adaption: Tracing the Diffusion of New Emojis on Twitter
| 2024-02-22T00:24:44 | 2024-02-22T00:24:44 |
Yuhang Zhou, Xuan Lu, Wei Ai
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
In the rapidly evolving landscape of social media, the introduction of new
emojis in Unicode release versions presents a structured opportunity to explore
digital language evolution. Analyzing a large dataset of sampled English
tweets, we examine how newly released emojis gain traction and evolve in
meaning. We find that community size of early adopters and emoji semantics are
crucial in determining their popularity. Certain emojis experienced notable
shifts in the meanings and sentiment associations during the diffusion process.
Additionally, we propose a novel framework utilizing language models to extract
words and pre-existing emojis with semantically similar contexts, which
enhances interpretation of new emojis. The framework demonstrates its
effectiveness in improving sentiment classification performance by substituting
unknown new emojis with familiar ones. This study offers a new perspective in
understanding how new language units are adopted, adapted, and integrated into
the fabric of online communication.
|
[
-0.5439722537994385,
-0.848635196685791,
0.5147312879562378,
0.38549426198005676,
-0.373202383518219,
0.4219595789909363,
-0.44232404232025146,
-0.37726449966430664,
0.6112279295921326,
0.24363522231578827,
-0.5043919086456299,
-0.2636404037475586,
-1.0137964487075806,
0.16497650742530823,
-0.2963361144065857,
0.849605143070221,
-0.09788040071725845,
-0.3767472505569458,
0.21600188314914703,
-0.43927091360092163,
-0.20245958864688873,
-0.15552864968776703,
-0.6039307713508606,
0.0343092605471611,
0.7641671299934387,
0.40357500314712524,
0.6797150373458862,
0.3115670382976532,
0.5582708120346069,
0.19888003170490265,
-0.2844286859035492,
-0.21563087403774261,
-0.49075186252593994,
0.1336989402770996,
0.12571649253368378,
-0.19885818660259247,
-0.14866407215595245,
-0.031065672636032104,
0.5873212814331055,
0.5427969694137573,
-0.21475300192832947,
0.018688330426812172,
0.06760475784540176,
0.5432120561599731,
-0.78359055519104,
-0.03595094010233879,
-0.6475783586502075,
-0.20631955564022064,
-0.23046913743019104,
-0.08821035921573639,
-0.27295243740081787,
-0.5910102128982544,
0.23155143857002258,
-0.6062622666358948,
-0.3221016526222229,
-0.26445114612579346,
0.6367104649543762,
-0.2780461311340332,
-0.40634605288505554,
-0.5020299553871155,
-0.4784441292285919,
0.8262636661529541,
-0.19373174011707306,
0.5605064630508423,
-0.22878411412239075,
0.5339568853378296,
-0.13373978435993195,
-0.8445590734481812,
-0.4993026554584503,
0.06824786216020584,
0.32741856575012207,
-0.19366663694381714,
-0.34191763401031494,
-0.41438236832618713,
-0.16548150777816772,
0.12086609750986099,
-0.05937247723340988,
-0.26206719875335693,
-0.013200721703469753,
0.1698283702135086,
0.681771457195282,
-0.3220147490501404,
0.5684363842010498,
-0.12413603812456131,
-0.09377136081457138,
0.17353186011314392,
-0.8048844337463379,
-0.22006921470165253,
0.009046911261975765,
0.26659807562828064,
-0.22757765650749207,
0.26321110129356384,
0.18870693445205688,
0.3452129364013672,
0.09722832590341568,
0.13097310066223145,
0.7488870024681091,
-0.31890612840652466,
-0.08050233870744705,
-0.2049035280942917,
0.630590558052063,
0.4151100218296051,
0.631092369556427,
-0.0019118774216622114,
-0.048954758793115616,
-0.19513051211833954,
0.09151777625083923,
-0.48384562134742737,
-0.0220201313495636,
-0.11297092586755753,
-0.6845975518226624,
-0.4386523365974426,
0.06644997745752335,
-0.594059407711029,
-0.9096212983131409,
0.06420613825321198,
0.18681153655052185,
-0.26947227120399475,
-0.7330794334411621,
-0.06909254193305969,
-0.673500120639801,
0.45256173610687256,
0.7662239074707031,
-0.7974435687065125,
0.009931831620633602,
0.8422968983650208,
1.0230375528335571,
0.16534081101417542,
0.14532630145549774,
0.11307478696107864,
-0.08160767704248428,
-0.5337468981742859,
0.7143501043319702,
-0.7811808586120605,
-0.35630011558532715,
0.3620482087135315,
0.30649906396865845,
-0.0640353262424469,
-0.47519737482070923,
0.15369176864624023,
-0.5651499032974243,
-0.13655386865139008,
-0.32693853974342346,
-0.41107308864593506,
-0.10983749479055405,
0.11242055892944336,
-0.5524616837501526,
0.5511276721954346,
0.5489876866340637,
-0.8991525173187256,
0.8035569190979004,
-0.8790911436080933,
-0.47562211751937866,
0.2768522799015045,
0.1669732928276062,
-0.04262126609683037,
0.48095738887786865,
0.049193184822797775,
0.6237012147903442,
-0.1039763018488884,
-0.41635748744010925,
-0.8606008291244507,
-0.11062411218881607,
0.3134968876838684,
0.09340209513902664,
1.2047728300094604,
0.6612552404403687,
0.08144998550415039,
-0.42262962460517883,
-0.2556267976760864,
-0.5150913596153259,
0.19045104086399078,
-0.1978856325149536,
-0.627266526222229,
0.26556867361068726,
0.21891117095947266,
0.047052059322595596,
0.176602303981781,
-0.5847277641296387,
0.14798575639724731,
-0.13386858999729156,
0.8258185386657715,
0.5387084484100342,
0.48300668597221375,
0.719913125038147,
-0.18561360239982605,
0.34494081139564514,
0.11577603220939636,
0.5186033248901367,
-0.20045505464076996,
-0.8113523721694946,
-0.37011024355888367,
-0.10199514031410217,
0.0938243642449379,
0.19075357913970947,
-0.6848698258399963,
0.24893443286418915,
-0.6328911185264587,
-0.40599915385246277,
-0.705843985080719,
0.29187077283859253,
-0.5822672843933105,
-0.23815307021141052,
-0.22516484558582306,
-0.2221134752035141,
-0.5356463193893433,
-0.6413646340370178,
-0.48121628165245056,
-0.2643168568611145,
-0.04348263144493103,
0.549090564250946,
0.09504129737615585,
-0.6783323287963867,
0.856995165348053,
-0.28387653827667236,
-0.012660878710448742,
-0.5078296661376953,
0.29162830114364624,
-0.07835768908262253,
0.012911051511764526,
0.8910141587257385,
-0.9377278685569763,
-0.5443395376205444,
0.3341082036495209,
-0.613246738910675,
-0.17445452511310577,
-0.11955372244119644,
-0.21441833674907684,
0.12425747513771057,
0.3922026455402374,
-0.07639998197555542,
-0.005952329374849796,
0.6364923715591431,
-0.36654573678970337,
-0.2849428057670593,
0.3526240587234497,
0.44546157121658325,
-1.4990694522857666,
-0.2463856190443039,
0.25230056047439575,
-0.13626009225845337,
-0.5134565830230713,
0.09512873739004135,
0.014412395656108856,
0.30451154708862305,
-0.7294716238975525,
0.6475436687469482,
-0.5702636241912842,
0.0811430886387825,
-0.146351620554924,
0.5604578256607056,
-0.24276597797870636,
-0.45334315299987793,
-0.34121841192245483,
0.325774222612381,
0.6099452972412109,
-0.47474929690361023,
0.15007202327251434,
0.17019133269786835,
-0.27414271235466003,
0.28196650743484497,
-0.13885091245174408,
0.006489270832389593,
-0.29081782698631287,
0.12184612452983856,
-1.1822240352630615,
-0.18952053785324097,
0.2684269845485687,
-0.6475498676300049,
0.13806374371051788,
-0.33446893095970154,
-0.39166611433029175,
-0.2612473666667938,
-0.4307459890842438,
0.28385207056999207,
0.9549474716186523,
-0.490719199180603,
0.6749565005302429,
0.9291617274284363,
-0.1826351284980774,
-0.06567676365375519,
-0.734890878200531,
0.15249374508857727,
-0.31783366203308105,
-0.846018373966217,
-0.20986197888851166,
-0.035704802721738815,
-0.5888471603393555,
-0.140237957239151,
0.3478454649448395,
-0.3221226930618286,
0.5706563591957092,
-0.07463614642620087,
-0.3150225579738617,
-0.20795097947120667,
0.14774098992347717,
0.2760440409183502,
0.39179688692092896,
0.11528898030519485,
0.03868996724486351,
0.3779425024986267,
0.20935212075710297,
0.2548747658729553,
-0.15590253472328186,
0.16054201126098633,
0.6291086673736572,
0.23992523550987244,
1.0112520456314087,
0.5958722829818726,
-0.31203693151474,
-0.1611870974302292,
-0.5198413133621216,
0.07329479604959488,
-0.4845266044139862,
0.19435445964336395,
-0.24676160514354706,
-0.8579397797584534,
0.4009496867656708,
-0.4492715895175934,
0.39118123054504395,
0.4172135889530182,
0.42828622460365295,
0.007726971060037613,
1.1337730884552002,
0.7263148427009583,
-0.0069177052937448025,
1.1037753820419312,
0.02536923997104168,
0.2946765124797821,
-0.8617336750030518,
0.0448559895157814,
-0.3636780083179474,
-0.23641906678676605,
-1.12680184841156,
-0.35907959938049316,
-0.16896119713783264,
0.16390788555145264,
0.1958569884300232,
0.46077361702919006,
-0.20667439699172974,
0.36409759521484375,
-0.23344124853610992,
0.025615597143769264,
-0.06397753208875656,
0.2913609445095062,
0.40489494800567627,
0.06234680861234665,
-0.24785475432872772,
-0.4427405893802643,
1.0655912160873413,
0.5227660536766052,
0.6826533675193787,
0.595889687538147,
0.8959969282150269,
0.6533159613609314,
1.0343364477157593,
-0.6917724609375,
0.3235955536365509,
-0.2836114764213562,
-0.18523083627223969,
0.0967046245932579,
-0.22323888540267944,
-1.035164475440979,
-0.00998806394636631,
-0.31132984161376953,
-0.7816845178604126,
0.13276611268520355,
-0.08878810703754425,
0.1828538477420807,
-0.03111422434449196,
-1.0070035457611084,
0.7368846535682678,
0.1444418877363205,
0.02467760257422924,
-0.31018689274787903,
-0.4843527674674988,
0.11602325737476349,
-0.29271578788757324,
0.6512057781219482,
-0.37895792722702026,
-0.30094680190086365,
0.6374941468238831,
0.20298118889331818,
0.5605603456497192,
-0.2502102255821228,
-0.05326558277010918,
0.6183417439460754,
0.07021584361791611,
0.2559995651245117,
-0.12989985942840576,
-0.18745635449886322,
0.3120027184486389,
-0.07417025417089462,
-0.5341072082519531,
-0.821969747543335,
0.7516034841537476,
-0.6397919058799744,
-0.33018991351127625,
0.08252348750829697,
-0.011654221452772617,
0.09719235450029373,
0.13003087043762207,
0.063664510846138,
-0.06595305353403091,
-0.44284042716026306,
0.32671985030174255,
0.32333922386169434,
-0.015448841266334057,
0.6067162752151489,
0.20735394954681396,
-0.40787559747695923,
-0.39176905155181885,
0.7145410180091858,
0.17681579291820526,
0.17775854468345642,
0.2792302072048187,
0.7423151731491089,
-0.41240501403808594,
-0.4919118583202362,
-0.3710280656814575,
0.29181283712387085,
-0.7709172964096069,
0.3232971131801605,
-0.7012471556663513,
0.10700760036706924,
-0.7279735803604126,
-0.5758820176124573,
0.028392693027853966,
-0.4607667326927185,
-0.290119469165802,
-0.018025189638137817,
0.6337894797325134,
1.2638022899627686,
0.12692025303840637,
0.32454806566238403,
-0.8291428685188293,
-0.11861544102430344,
-0.06521470099687576,
0.21858356893062592,
-0.06375077366828918,
-0.727725625038147,
-0.24248738586902618,
0.0776141807436943,
-0.31924328207969666,
-1.159624457359314,
0.2500858008861542,
0.4031500518321991,
0.4669964015483856,
0.6940805912017822,
-0.22205761075019836,
0.29629218578338623,
-0.3042857050895691,
0.8289136290550232,
0.26378485560417175,
-0.8711762428283691,
0.6611548662185669,
-0.6021189093589783,
0.08781338483095169,
0.2757692337036133,
0.40812093019485474,
-0.9882773160934448,
-0.474506676197052,
-0.6535001993179321,
-0.8117666840553284,
0.33635470271110535,
0.17203442752361298,
0.6384537816047668,
-0.5951061844825745,
0.534230649471283,
0.052268583327531815,
0.3154132664203644,
-0.6078038215637207,
-0.29155123233795166,
-0.12436804175376892,
-0.5924950242042542,
-0.19857482612133026,
-0.15226884186267853,
0.23281405866146088,
-0.27809351682662964,
0.20815202593803406,
-0.08332452178001404,
0.4216134250164032,
-0.31098672747612,
-0.4656003713607788,
-0.06813708692789078,
0.15885791182518005,
0.08357216417789459,
0.42970240116119385,
0.06842236965894699,
0.06306426227092743,
0.003648065496236086,
-0.632280170917511,
-0.035500671714544296,
-0.2995428442955017,
-0.21470907330513,
0.054983124136924744,
0.10725423693656921,
0.5100149512290955,
0.19752858579158783,
-0.41099998354911804,
0.8491957783699036,
-0.04780163615942001,
-0.09997568279504776,
-0.27582263946533203,
-0.02968905307352543,
0.15399287641048431,
0.03593815863132477,
0.26346489787101746,
-0.03538888320326805,
0.25301676988601685,
-0.9888948798179626,
0.5230227112770081,
0.29037293791770935,
-0.5285124182701111,
-0.7174688577651978,
0.17277009785175323,
0.38765865564346313,
-0.46570760011672974,
0.18929286301136017,
-0.14396528899669647,
-0.19704709947109222,
0.3434412181377411,
0.4214809238910675,
1.4060405492782593,
-0.37218770384788513,
0.4562344551086426,
0.08916021138429642,
0.2073795199394226,
-0.13752597570419312,
0.35430264472961426,
-0.030516313388943672,
-1.0313465595245361,
0.1861501783132553,
-0.6868200898170471,
0.11511389911174774,
-0.6291890144348145,
-0.3715673089027405,
0.46321001648902893,
-0.7124398946762085,
-0.39414212107658386,
0.292244553565979,
-0.42201629281044006,
-0.7039750218391418,
0.1326465755701065,
0.4398255944252014,
0.8497140407562256,
-1.273573637008667,
0.7013036012649536,
0.975548505783081,
-0.3890424072742462,
-0.48245730996131897,
0.4099082052707672,
0.06231643632054329,
-0.8809070587158203,
0.3393622934818268,
0.23833835124969482,
0.21768474578857422,
0.15034037828445435,
-0.5049854516983032,
-0.9346247315406799,
0.7347165942192078,
0.04982222616672516,
-0.3465048372745514,
0.5048091411590576,
-0.10874223709106445,
0.7589911222457886,
-0.7707153558731079,
0.5780636668205261,
0.6185595393180847,
0.3350851535797119,
0.27218562364578247,
-0.30047717690467834,
0.046586774289608,
-0.2641066610813141,
0.24948929250240326,
0.6451882719993591,
-0.4082200825214386,
0.712762176990509,
-0.30091702938079834,
-0.48538514971733093,
-0.015986766666173935,
0.35581210255622864,
-0.12718333303928375,
0.40919747948646545,
0.5903137922286987,
0.12152808159589767,
0.3241923451423645,
-0.26615703105926514,
1.0576671361923218,
-0.3144471347332001,
0.38014551997184753,
0.3471702039241791,
-0.22942706942558289,
1.2848236560821533,
0.7120525240898132,
-0.021121077239513397,
0.9880263209342957,
0.6981890797615051,
0.09947511553764343,
0.41937515139579773,
0.13865762948989868,
-0.26329556107521057,
-0.08993445336818695,
-0.3737132251262665,
0.1130993440747261,
0.08027034252882004,
0.4677657186985016,
-0.7327249646186829,
-0.20363454520702362,
0.28152069449424744,
0.05384393781423569,
-0.25747790932655334,
-0.26583364605903625,
1.0286916494369507,
0.17888741195201874,
-0.47517919540405273,
0.26755693554878235,
-0.3331048786640167,
0.4612933099269867,
-0.2358710914850235,
-0.03061109408736229,
-0.17345711588859558,
0.19687320291996002,
-0.25253188610076904,
-1.0639469623565674,
0.3322910964488983,
-0.16992473602294922,
0.15707871317863464,
-0.1353769749403,
0.4606870710849762,
-0.04147804155945778,
-0.5737501978874207,
0.7427719831466675,
0.5228486061096191,
0.23393462598323822,
0.07952667772769928,
-0.7858120799064636,
0.24075090885162354,
0.04955948144197464,
-0.4147859811782837,
0.3134006857872009,
0.8532199859619141,
-0.054345667362213135,
0.5228720903396606,
0.22709771990776062,
-0.057684894651174545,
0.4478982388973236,
0.4568186104297638,
0.6930912137031555,
-0.6707572937011719,
-0.3641749620437622,
-0.7987241744995117,
0.3986876308917999,
-0.07150234282016754,
-0.3916105628013611,
0.8758090734481812,
0.12954601645469666,
0.5012679100036621,
0.2295915186405182,
1.1073499917984009,
-0.48672857880592346,
0.4105284810066223,
-0.09203653037548065,
0.6956358551979065,
-1.1050833463668823,
0.28669682145118713,
-0.6765070557594299,
-0.907127857208252,
-0.29692402482032776,
0.4807164967060089,
-0.2035037726163864,
0.2740883231163025,
0.5158047080039978,
0.5290634036064148,
0.00893113762140274,
0.19192560017108917,
0.1569327712059021,
0.3080931305885315,
0.24201804399490356,
0.015527606941759586,
1.0839923620224,
-0.4999329149723053,
0.1751922369003296,
0.025777766481041908,
-0.42470911145210266,
-0.4351371228694916,
-0.760133683681488,
-0.48168373107910156,
-0.4540271759033203,
-0.5713398456573486,
-0.4866727888584137,
0.11128509044647217,
1.052397608757019,
0.39835402369499207,
-0.7182501554489136,
-0.12178812175989151,
-0.32255157828330994,
0.20347188413143158,
-0.11233574151992798,
-0.3133041560649872,
-0.11711582541465759,
-0.38138777017593384,
-0.502221941947937,
0.016700131818652153,
0.24180518090724945,
0.276284784078598,
-0.07104536890983582,
-0.12890268862247467,
-0.17878924310207367,
0.5279682278633118,
0.8044866919517517,
0.11502443253993988,
-0.5865930318832397,
-0.5095084309577942,
0.10727953910827637,
0.07141153514385223,
0.2716190218925476,
0.9315033555030823,
-0.2715620994567871,
0.5263399481773376,
0.7645393013954163,
0.597964882850647,
0.05498300492763519,
-0.1825098842382431,
0.5214086174964905,
-0.5392425060272217,
-0.02610023133456707,
0.04075068607926369,
0.36185014247894287,
0.6255216002464294,
-0.030193112790584564,
0.22150935232639313,
0.60721755027771,
-0.3350139558315277,
-0.7314910292625427,
0.1829494833946228,
-0.6891642808914185,
-0.418459415435791,
1.4317702054977417,
0.02988625131547451,
-0.5865020155906677,
-0.43003010749816895,
0.11267753690481186,
0.029093055054545403,
-0.6890928149223328,
0.7920767664909363,
0.6098774075508118,
0.13381966948509216,
-0.46688270568847656,
-0.07598310708999634,
0.42652687430381775,
-0.06908063590526581,
-0.6514372825622559,
0.05956660211086273,
0.13883039355278015,
0.6368135809898376,
0.20257635414600372,
0.7344372868537903,
-0.100712850689888,
0.08489472419023514,
0.07363566756248474,
-0.05628395080566406,
0.5813710689544678,
-0.18185290694236755,
-0.4179220199584961,
0.16118206083774567,
0.5484477877616882,
-0.1822502464056015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14184v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14184v1
|
Diversity-Aware Ensembling of Language Models Based on Topological Data Analysis
| 2024-02-22T00:04:21 | 2024-02-22T00:04:21 |
Polina Proskura, Alexey Zaytsev
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Ensembles are important tools for improving the performance of machine
learning models. In cases related to natural language processing, ensembles
boost the performance of a method due to multiple large models available in
open source. However, existing approaches mostly rely on simple averaging of
predictions by ensembles with equal weights for each model, ignoring
differences in the quality and conformity of models. We propose to estimate
weights for ensembles of NLP models using not only knowledge of their
individual performance but also their similarity to each other. By adopting
distance measures based on Topological Data Analysis (TDA), we improve our
ensemble. The quality improves for both text classification accuracy and
relevant uncertainty estimation.
|
[
-0.3452204465866089,
-0.5218238830566406,
0.25063252449035645,
0.1246100589632988,
-0.15552625060081482,
0.42288875579833984,
-0.12011968344449997,
-0.8123180270195007,
0.528207540512085,
0.372235506772995,
-0.22311998903751373,
-0.52100670337677,
-0.7642205357551575,
0.057560354471206665,
-0.7628688812255859,
0.7110891938209534,
0.29402956366539,
-0.16587387025356293,
-0.11710406094789505,
-0.42999404668807983,
-0.26276859641075134,
-0.20696455240249634,
-0.46188127994537354,
-0.015236478298902512,
0.20484232902526855,
0.16271954774856567,
0.7344440817832947,
0.5013836026191711,
0.6082187294960022,
0.4831421971321106,
-0.3785572946071625,
0.3263293206691742,
-0.28522828221321106,
0.10671202093362808,
-0.15014789998531342,
-0.49457424879074097,
-0.41932424902915955,
-0.21703632175922394,
1.0501456260681152,
0.8253418803215027,
-0.2819862365722656,
0.10752428323030472,
0.1280359923839569,
0.7417296171188354,
-0.5205377340316772,
-0.4624917805194855,
-0.6693190336227417,
0.24420344829559326,
-0.4937250018119812,
-0.14168110489845276,
-0.13111308217048645,
-0.5215827822685242,
0.2763668894767761,
-0.581829845905304,
0.24287070333957672,
0.18608298897743225,
0.7358815670013428,
0.1586446911096573,
-0.3032774329185486,
-0.15145239233970642,
-0.8594992160797119,
1.1040921211242676,
-0.8280652165412903,
0.5799097418785095,
0.4050252437591553,
0.24403110146522522,
-0.11428796499967575,
-0.3452877402305603,
-0.5984398126602173,
0.423434317111969,
-0.16472142934799194,
-0.04666576907038689,
-0.24970169365406036,
-0.02599688433110714,
-0.06906674802303314,
0.5564695596694946,
-0.6564348936080933,
0.35877856612205505,
-0.7472991943359375,
0.028543241322040558,
0.887283980846405,
-0.15131568908691406,
0.4647167921066284,
-0.08198310434818268,
-0.17138442397117615,
-0.19569112360477448,
-0.1273190975189209,
-0.08131237328052521,
0.5884245038032532,
0.38587573170661926,
-0.4578554332256317,
0.4700046479701996,
-0.3286607563495636,
0.8623085021972656,
-0.06648087501525879,
0.02254531905055046,
0.3992163836956024,
-0.32789644598960876,
-0.514883816242218,
-0.1474708616733551,
0.6636212468147278,
0.010262981988489628,
0.240581676363945,
-0.5785369873046875,
-0.15325777232646942,
-0.23304474353790283,
0.34846144914627075,
-0.26356053352355957,
-0.2643105387687683,
0.4361723065376282,
-0.4933624863624573,
-0.3656788170337677,
0.05575825273990631,
-1.3246772289276123,
-0.2655753493309021,
-0.43541866540908813,
0.26848721504211426,
-0.4992294907569885,
-0.44008368253707886,
0.019911451265215874,
-0.26579684019088745,
-0.16487441956996918,
0.23378650844097137,
-0.9199463129043579,
0.8533490300178528,
0.6478017568588257,
1.1151255369186401,
-0.5367991328239441,
-0.17003165185451508,
-0.2794524133205414,
-0.038385599851608276,
-0.12390757352113724,
0.7560929656028748,
-0.6672915816307068,
-0.4136728048324585,
-0.27449852228164673,
-0.2958786189556122,
-0.26468244194984436,
-0.49492520093917847,
0.6656845211982727,
-0.5234973430633545,
0.3937816023826599,
0.03237764537334442,
-0.7139965891838074,
-0.47483405470848083,
0.15023624897003174,
-0.7173781394958496,
1.1887729167938232,
0.24260643124580383,
-1.0677251815795898,
0.469411164522171,
-0.5215480923652649,
-0.2364852875471115,
0.10826507210731506,
0.019864529371261597,
-0.3746916651725769,
0.13486707210540771,
0.5619052052497864,
0.37730616331100464,
-0.08685613423585892,
0.33971908688545227,
-0.43868955969810486,
-0.31613725423812866,
-0.21116341650485992,
0.026167118921875954,
0.987361490726471,
0.23320378363132477,
-0.021481458097696304,
0.15185944736003876,
-0.7646364569664001,
0.06798887252807617,
-0.22658847272396088,
-0.29354533553123474,
-0.7478175163269043,
0.15295203030109406,
0.0888865664601326,
-0.08727479726076126,
-0.08260830491781235,
-0.2955000698566437,
0.14777441322803497,
-0.830837607383728,
-0.16457346081733704,
0.9547271728515625,
-0.3200589418411255,
0.7701677083969116,
-0.42381685972213745,
0.7615381479263306,
-0.02960224449634552,
-0.29790911078453064,
0.5784743428230286,
-0.710216760635376,
-0.43098968267440796,
-0.4639115333557129,
0.5754747986793518,
0.4687245786190033,
-0.5817666053771973,
0.662950873374939,
-0.4141228199005127,
-0.8044339418411255,
-0.37684887647628784,
0.06447171419858932,
-0.07281494140625,
0.28680750727653503,
0.35249951481819153,
-0.5376653671264648,
-0.6332951784133911,
-0.5376712083816528,
-0.557658851146698,
-0.1295592486858368,
-0.19272641837596893,
0.11772674322128296,
0.37579479813575745,
-0.17472977936267853,
1.1525644063949585,
-0.2913137376308441,
-0.11560855805873871,
-0.20354218780994415,
0.17284362018108368,
0.3288518786430359,
0.6764679551124573,
0.8402905464172363,
-0.702143132686615,
-0.3324154019355774,
0.2015383541584015,
-0.5628958940505981,
0.023421000689268112,
0.2617935836315155,
-0.2934008240699768,
0.0869465172290802,
0.17349563539028168,
-0.3975946307182312,
0.16044895350933075,
0.9396389722824097,
-0.3368282914161682,
0.5614424347877502,
0.09734257310628891,
0.1336883306503296,
-1.2954636812210083,
-0.08452066779136658,
0.28874966502189636,
-0.2418072670698166,
-0.737415075302124,
0.16242194175720215,
-0.38076815009117126,
0.018705304712057114,
-0.027272090315818787,
0.8007057905197144,
-0.314190149307251,
-0.32979127764701843,
0.19567427039146423,
0.35801464319229126,
-0.2310430109500885,
0.23521976172924042,
0.031166957691311836,
0.40566757321357727,
0.935574471950531,
-0.8394284248352051,
0.12710265815258026,
0.04465337470173836,
-0.5505099296569824,
0.5279799103736877,
-0.4884263575077057,
0.052536964416503906,
0.000480593997053802,
0.054438140243291855,
-0.7957537174224854,
-0.2469683438539505,
0.09618483483791351,
-0.44731560349464417,
0.47579509019851685,
-0.012379159219563007,
-0.29010555148124695,
-0.22255241870880127,
-0.13521824777126312,
0.7602924108505249,
0.3521127700805664,
-0.5429303646087646,
0.774402916431427,
0.7031886577606201,
-0.18256671726703644,
-0.6585342288017273,
-0.6732968688011169,
-0.10416562855243683,
-0.6635937690734863,
-0.7867419719696045,
0.31528976559638977,
0.2040959894657135,
-0.5392386317253113,
-0.1256721466779709,
-0.024827778339385986,
-0.47637680172920227,
0.27837350964546204,
-0.1111256554722786,
-0.15300336480140686,
-0.10444588959217072,
0.7076719403266907,
0.17026738822460175,
0.3640921115875244,
-0.30170291662216187,
-0.7168347835540771,
0.5398312211036682,
-0.17082078754901886,
-0.27085888385772705,
-0.16991865634918213,
0.23450453579425812,
0.19162756204605103,
-0.38465744256973267,
0.8569852113723755,
0.7260668277740479,
-0.643832266330719,
-0.4425943195819855,
-0.45423874258995056,
-0.21552352607250214,
-0.5050759315490723,
0.2379455864429474,
0.0213096272200346,
-0.9968143701553345,
0.5841052532196045,
0.1711992621421814,
0.08184649050235748,
0.5357997417449951,
0.35437509417533875,
-0.29132524132728577,
0.36399126052856445,
0.8488377928733826,
-0.3999805450439453,
0.3245953619480133,
0.049796197563409805,
0.3257041275501251,
-0.43849754333496094,
0.07218347489833832,
-1.0008360147476196,
-0.6990281939506531,
-0.9193056225776672,
-0.6144172549247742,
0.2707713842391968,
0.10523474961519241,
-0.05545072257518768,
0.28482943773269653,
-0.680680513381958,
0.4767668545246124,
0.688565194606781,
-0.060183294117450714,
0.3191889524459839,
0.48862332105636597,
-0.04093868285417557,
0.058316223323345184,
-0.7793170809745789,
-0.2683834135532379,
1.0997753143310547,
0.3989666700363159,
0.5658703446388245,
0.3679022490978241,
0.8946701288223267,
0.2979896068572998,
-0.15691940486431122,
-0.6236201524734497,
0.31248217821121216,
-0.34327927231788635,
-0.39239710569381714,
-0.658035397529602,
-0.8718360066413879,
-0.9237231016159058,
0.21520459651947021,
-0.25234055519104004,
-1.3504608869552612,
0.4224637448787689,
-0.04667219892144203,
-0.22393180429935455,
0.7165997624397278,
-0.25535848736763,
0.33622464537620544,
0.07441993057727814,
0.16600744426250458,
-0.26510298252105713,
-0.3337157964706421,
0.6725469827651978,
-0.15563420951366425,
0.3284028172492981,
0.10629504173994064,
0.21396924555301666,
1.055134654045105,
-0.0643024817109108,
0.5565221309661865,
0.1250130534172058,
-0.19668306410312653,
0.298406720161438,
0.45543259382247925,
0.42007696628570557,
-0.15935613214969635,
-0.4904725253582001,
0.6030082702636719,
-0.08175814896821976,
-0.24825389683246613,
-0.47631603479385376,
0.5154904127120972,
-0.7663001418113708,
-0.3417627215385437,
-0.16787461936473846,
-0.728593647480011,
-0.3235055208206177,
-0.027734510600566864,
0.13011592626571655,
0.4162614345550537,
0.058609042316675186,
0.3023454546928406,
0.4631732702255249,
-0.19006872177124023,
0.5855416655540466,
0.1877874732017517,
-0.07053221762180328,
-0.1676889955997467,
0.7513140439987183,
0.22622770071029663,
0.19442473351955414,
0.6255477666854858,
0.18190091848373413,
-0.21470333635807037,
-0.7590442299842834,
-0.2681267261505127,
-0.016165969893336296,
-0.41990673542022705,
-0.10440651327371597,
-1.0309851169586182,
-0.01545158214867115,
-0.6561901569366455,
-0.18553337454795837,
-0.21832020580768585,
-0.9545289278030396,
-0.15132729709148407,
-0.1135508343577385,
0.4863916337490082,
0.7532907128334045,
-0.05982435867190361,
0.4362128973007202,
-0.8670809268951416,
0.05006083846092224,
0.28277072310447693,
0.695354163646698,
-0.001299889525398612,
-0.5902437567710876,
-0.30430886149406433,
-0.08200737833976746,
-0.37884029746055603,
-0.9407554864883423,
0.5019189715385437,
0.3598729968070984,
0.45346200466156006,
0.3321940004825592,
-0.0808502584695816,
0.36454910039901733,
-0.11052380502223969,
0.7491315007209778,
-0.06018014997243881,
-1.0915207862854004,
0.4787159860134125,
-0.4500832259654999,
0.2246701717376709,
0.3192095458507538,
0.265104740858078,
-0.5961573719978333,
-0.6925406455993652,
-0.6632240414619446,
-0.5672035217285156,
0.8266426920890808,
0.6187781691551208,
-0.19802603125572205,
0.26902449131011963,
-0.03846440464258194,
-0.12618276476860046,
0.029573487117886543,
-0.7841216325759888,
0.06101003661751747,
0.08732737600803375,
-0.4739479422569275,
-0.041403114795684814,
0.2005639374256134,
-0.04609480872750282,
-0.2938682436943054,
0.7578341960906982,
-0.32498010993003845,
0.19763465225696564,
0.008381560444831848,
0.132566437125206,
-0.23175962269306183,
0.22591547667980194,
0.4114362895488739,
0.726546049118042,
-0.1192825585603714,
-0.11286640912294388,
0.6160287261009216,
-0.3284686803817749,
-0.02060839906334877,
-0.0020061677787452936,
0.0467553548514843,
0.08400189131498337,
0.4724455177783966,
0.22497440874576569,
-0.12355359643697739,
-0.5715116858482361,
0.1611936241388321,
0.014258624985814095,
0.07712875306606293,
0.14629943668842316,
0.13266143202781677,
0.14070533215999603,
0.18719398975372314,
0.1243949756026268,
0.3584398925304413,
0.4651270806789398,
-0.17224518954753876,
0.4725807011127472,
0.3746841847896576,
-0.552122950553894,
-0.2700433135032654,
0.22179147601127625,
0.23033244907855988,
-0.31570881605148315,
0.6770228147506714,
-0.259305864572525,
-0.5302792191505432,
1.0105865001678467,
0.2529858946800232,
1.0058714151382446,
-0.5932340621948242,
0.371277779340744,
0.6343227624893188,
0.5215631723403931,
-0.09008507430553436,
0.05877602845430374,
-0.042682915925979614,
-1.0348106622695923,
-0.20343288779258728,
-1.0872594118118286,
-0.16126126050949097,
-0.39356687664985657,
-0.4634845554828644,
0.27024954557418823,
-0.3207918405532837,
0.13879872858524323,
-0.33377939462661743,
0.0008790679275989532,
-0.5484718084335327,
0.5461762547492981,
-0.023138081654906273,
0.8418594002723694,
-0.7650095224380493,
0.6849461793899536,
0.40148016810417175,
0.23214873671531677,
-0.7624930739402771,
0.06191719323396683,
0.19483256340026855,
-0.43670058250427246,
0.5109432935714722,
0.017441559582948685,
-0.0012979067396372557,
-0.30454733967781067,
-0.26981157064437866,
-1.1393380165100098,
0.8461247682571411,
0.181113600730896,
-0.7639124393463135,
-0.00123607087880373,
0.0020634769462049007,
0.6283568143844604,
-0.3057304918766022,
0.3313365578651428,
0.4940425455570221,
0.3358623683452606,
-0.22921131551265717,
-1.0564907789230347,
-0.25523877143859863,
-0.30611562728881836,
-0.18899394571781158,
0.3831081688404083,
-0.444537878036499,
1.0476638078689575,
0.049052197486162186,
-0.49959102272987366,
-0.109269879758358,
0.6989024877548218,
0.2446311116218567,
0.2734188139438629,
0.681868314743042,
0.7407972812652588,
1.3117562532424927,
-0.09926684945821762,
1.1672314405441284,
-0.06002699211239815,
0.46871858835220337,
1.2665377855300903,
0.05206627398729324,
0.6865797638893127,
0.303262859582901,
-0.4356149733066559,
0.4726027250289917,
0.7093813419342041,
-0.07291101664304733,
0.11090920865535736,
0.27389582991600037,
-0.0359245240688324,
-0.04813876375555992,
0.010358939878642559,
-0.43481457233428955,
0.7901033163070679,
0.47478973865509033,
-0.2910262644290924,
-0.13850924372673035,
-0.43754222989082336,
-0.4075063169002533,
0.16480645537376404,
-0.2332530915737152,
0.8280820846557617,
0.01052133273333311,
-0.35253918170928955,
0.30925148725509644,
0.16791507601737976,
0.8778082728385925,
-0.41321176290512085,
0.28440460562705994,
-0.12467697262763977,
-0.23168474435806274,
-0.3558737337589264,
-0.6359204053878784,
0.6247533559799194,
-0.17575998604297638,
-0.19767643511295319,
0.1545286774635315,
0.6339455842971802,
-0.5140751600265503,
-0.9336552023887634,
0.4325448274612427,
0.4581809639930725,
0.22151300311088562,
0.0691787600517273,
-0.5575507283210754,
-0.5140694975852966,
-0.0807449072599411,
0.0006094361306168139,
0.029975010082125664,
0.40782228112220764,
-0.07240156829357147,
0.8033076524734497,
0.34627166390419006,
0.28225067257881165,
0.20720770955085754,
-0.017637919634580612,
0.628856897354126,
-0.3204299509525299,
-0.7838684320449829,
-0.7510221004486084,
0.4533407688140869,
-0.2651683986186981,
-0.3522217273712158,
0.6774241924285889,
0.3033539950847626,
0.8215360045433044,
0.14605407416820526,
0.5225614309310913,
-0.08068867027759552,
0.6618427634239197,
-0.5629562735557556,
0.9202561974525452,
-0.7706634402275085,
0.33138197660446167,
-0.5711351037025452,
-1.194715142250061,
-0.2701093852519989,
0.21077528595924377,
0.008241544477641582,
0.2195129692554474,
0.4479500651359558,
0.8762224316596985,
-0.43269243836402893,
0.4796861708164215,
0.2199733704328537,
0.11077810078859329,
0.30603551864624023,
0.2605360448360443,
0.3638632297515869,
-0.3992507755756378,
0.11466986685991287,
-0.2380947768688202,
-0.08117802441120148,
0.17643867433071136,
-0.7765439748764038,
-0.7663878798484802,
-0.5468589663505554,
-0.1761535406112671,
0.06299100071191788,
-0.054937902837991714,
0.760909378528595,
0.9695199728012085,
-1.088696837425232,
-0.40629708766937256,
-0.14713577926158905,
0.5809772610664368,
-0.4146486520767212,
-0.2726259231567383,
0.4185929000377655,
-0.33355000615119934,
-0.940829336643219,
0.32080724835395813,
0.17469972372055054,
0.04712076485157013,
-0.20124205946922302,
-0.0321667306125164,
-0.45603683590888977,
0.16404785215854645,
0.36292895674705505,
-0.0454450361430645,
-0.5550933480262756,
-0.3291633427143097,
-0.44452473521232605,
0.1973113864660263,
0.02970123291015625,
0.48504459857940674,
-0.7271493673324585,
0.6337119936943054,
0.8213950991630554,
0.8582510352134705,
0.060582444071769714,
0.03780009597539902,
0.9644790887832642,
-1.2854875326156616,
0.2439493089914322,
0.4686015248298645,
0.38221776485443115,
0.41756170988082886,
-0.42658665776252747,
0.7482420802116394,
0.12046587467193604,
-0.5616335868835449,
-0.7834705710411072,
0.04044922813773155,
-0.850555419921875,
-0.2004418820142746,
0.829427182674408,
-0.07487695664167404,
0.018682019785046577,
-0.10790900141000748,
0.29959094524383545,
0.17708128690719604,
-0.24114437401294708,
1.0052739381790161,
0.8076837062835693,
0.3569859266281128,
-0.14126527309417725,
-0.2664613127708435,
0.5955256223678589,
0.4728722870349884,
-1.130725383758545,
-0.3321123719215393,
0.03154861554503441,
-0.11926741898059845,
0.41740095615386963,
0.30315396189689636,
0.021141011267900467,
0.015878431499004364,
-0.10121180862188339,
0.00044793501729145646,
0.5928957462310791,
-0.5048690438270569,
-0.35112303495407104,
0.3915420472621918,
-0.5546977519989014,
0.0553729347884655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14881v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14881v1
|
A Study on the Vulnerability of Test Questions against ChatGPT-based Cheating
| 2024-02-21T23:51:06 | 2024-02-21T23:51:06 |
Shanker Ram, Chen Qian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, I.2.7
|
ChatGPT is a chatbot that can answer text prompts fairly accurately, even
performing very well on postgraduate-level questions. Many educators have found
that their take-home or remote tests and exams are vulnerable to ChatGPT-based
cheating because students may directly use answers provided by tools like
ChatGPT. In this paper, we try to provide an answer to an important question:
how well ChatGPT can answer test questions and how we can detect whether the
questions of a test can be answered correctly by ChatGPT. We generated
ChatGPT's responses to the MedMCQA dataset, which contains over 10,000 medical
school entrance exam questions. We analyzed the responses and uncovered certain
types of questions ChatGPT answers more inaccurately than others. In addition,
we have created a basic natural language processing model to single out the
most vulnerable questions to ChatGPT in a collection of questions or a sample
exam. Our tool can be used by test-makers to avoid ChatGPT-vulnerable test
questions.
|
[
-0.4678611159324646,
-1.2082483768463135,
0.33221524953842163,
-0.17966578900814056,
-0.08628152310848236,
0.07565577328205109,
0.19381052255630493,
-0.2970331609249115,
-0.28405827283859253,
0.5161327123641968,
-0.7389379143714905,
0.010873174294829369,
-0.6940456032752991,
-0.030382787808775902,
-0.40757375955581665,
1.0765206813812256,
-0.08033441007137299,
0.34850990772247314,
-0.17334528267383575,
-0.10472631454467773,
-0.6130279302597046,
-0.6760954856872559,
-0.9029597043991089,
-0.15418575704097748,
0.435776948928833,
0.45461684465408325,
0.7801929116249084,
-0.14053921401500702,
1.0276775360107422,
0.09164778143167496,
-0.0009943090844899416,
-0.16716335713863373,
-0.46814674139022827,
-0.009775354526937008,
-0.1240280270576477,
-0.8138788342475891,
-0.3526933193206787,
0.11946118623018265,
0.021329661831259727,
0.4194354712963104,
-0.09780483692884445,
0.2898152768611908,
0.28974172472953796,
0.35849589109420776,
-0.33628785610198975,
0.01797848753631115,
-0.7271513342857361,
0.008090579882264137,
-0.19944894313812256,
-0.15225836634635925,
-0.4398515820503235,
-0.6202408075332642,
0.06772590428590775,
-0.10851507633924484,
0.5156221389770508,
-0.2798461318016052,
0.8882641196250916,
0.44160500168800354,
-0.5101135969161987,
-0.2918795645236969,
-0.5658852458000183,
0.3270781338214874,
-0.45031312108039856,
0.10205831378698349,
0.5725305080413818,
0.8265446424484253,
-0.4179210960865021,
-0.37931156158447266,
-0.2702416777610779,
-0.3248341977596283,
-0.17383462190628052,
0.33934348821640015,
0.09555698931217194,
0.29535380005836487,
0.2809631824493408,
0.5229939222335815,
-1.165539264678955,
-0.39987602829933167,
-0.3106398284435272,
-0.43722811341285706,
0.28222063183784485,
0.05355298891663551,
0.7029592990875244,
-0.051961056888103485,
-0.26891055703163147,
-0.1954955756664276,
-0.5330125689506531,
0.13668106496334076,
0.20338378846645355,
0.090619757771492,
0.21654197573661804,
0.826046884059906,
0.24929435551166534,
0.6574127674102783,
-0.2739918828010559,
0.3378906548023224,
-0.3830489218235016,
-0.41816991567611694,
-0.017208246514201164,
0.0426025427877903,
0.6877776384353638,
0.1921938806772232,
0.599004328250885,
0.029679760336875916,
0.024739788845181465,
0.4161018431186676,
0.37823954224586487,
-0.7159017324447632,
-0.5038252472877502,
0.43369224667549133,
-0.08466155081987381,
-0.31557348370552063,
-0.19577836990356445,
-0.812125027179718,
-0.42194199562072754,
0.4765940010547638,
0.7886025905609131,
-0.5138071775436401,
-0.08434062451124191,
0.07483698427677155,
-0.24291746318340302,
0.6662251949310303,
0.25315672159194946,
-0.48609229922294617,
0.6213053464889526,
0.6325370669364929,
0.7130794525146484,
0.08924898505210876,
-0.33028703927993774,
-0.6134008169174194,
-0.4675367772579193,
-0.12294316291809082,
0.7975497841835022,
-0.2717230021953583,
-0.5645433664321899,
-0.25547802448272705,
0.0644998773932457,
-0.4165618121623993,
-0.45400291681289673,
0.48046496510505676,
-0.5683590769767761,
0.6797738075256348,
-0.20152342319488525,
-0.604314923286438,
-0.06674986332654953,
0.5873706340789795,
-0.36602267622947693,
0.9578600525856018,
0.1310112625360489,
-0.9926245212554932,
0.0810009017586708,
-0.5859999060630798,
-0.1800704002380371,
-0.04682936519384384,
-0.1361388862133026,
-0.5764313340187073,
-0.5088966488838196,
0.2165745049715042,
0.2783969044685364,
-0.08260727673768997,
0.16038525104522705,
-0.09539980441331863,
-0.5694716572761536,
0.7002747058868408,
-0.8477231860160828,
0.9250630736351013,
-0.05347144976258278,
-0.3108549118041992,
-0.4400693476200104,
-0.39438459277153015,
0.27296182513237,
0.21999052166938782,
-0.3552062511444092,
0.10832005739212036,
-0.016660071909427643,
-0.19008409976959229,
0.09592185169458389,
-0.11971480399370193,
-0.6544427275657654,
0.27264779806137085,
-0.25687289237976074,
0.1277381181716919,
0.5730104446411133,
0.3638074994087219,
-0.018884580582380295,
-0.4738665223121643,
0.8868145942687988,
-0.05660024285316467,
0.37579238414764404,
-0.057434119284152985,
-1.1410589218139648,
-0.4082164764404297,
0.11105315387248993,
0.5805215239524841,
1.114146113395691,
-0.5416482090950012,
0.09345153719186783,
0.042739689350128174,
-0.9211786985397339,
-0.5573344826698303,
-0.1577620953321457,
0.44581907987594604,
0.7876367568969727,
0.24035871028900146,
-0.5265248417854309,
0.029486490413546562,
-0.6714966297149658,
-0.5934644937515259,
-0.38506415486335754,
-0.16733017563819885,
0.43606823682785034,
0.636480450630188,
0.06618080288171768,
0.6951411962509155,
-0.7660624384880066,
0.024743812158703804,
0.03926338627934456,
-0.08493027836084366,
0.08133746683597565,
0.4836297929286957,
0.1684415340423584,
-0.9339309334754944,
-0.38916832208633423,
-0.33489418029785156,
-0.41689106822013855,
-0.031289976090192795,
-0.1690875142812729,
-0.19327865540981293,
-0.31166642904281616,
0.2829672694206238,
-0.5911195278167725,
0.47492942214012146,
0.5747935771942139,
-0.6234226226806641,
0.6373540759086609,
-0.05909910053014755,
0.22810383141040802,
-0.8923631310462952,
0.11355610191822052,
-0.3466462194919586,
-0.22456438839435577,
-0.7292311191558838,
0.14063508808612823,
0.16544915735721588,
-0.5011175274848938,
-0.3802250921726227,
0.47660306096076965,
0.05168107897043228,
0.3453405797481537,
-0.04420941323041916,
0.1559685617685318,
-0.21072371304035187,
0.39575788378715515,
-0.29073673486709595,
0.9500693082809448,
0.47704094648361206,
-0.4906970262527466,
0.22288940846920013,
0.4890645444393158,
-0.0272209532558918,
0.48963847756385803,
-0.7991378903388977,
0.33194124698638916,
-0.06491395831108093,
0.3678525686264038,
-1.2545697689056396,
-0.4286765158176422,
0.689427375793457,
-0.996543288230896,
0.03446009010076523,
-0.4913722276687622,
-0.33218398690223694,
-0.11840418726205826,
-0.07918816804885864,
0.36623725295066833,
0.5774388313293457,
-0.2782594561576843,
0.29598546028137207,
0.23566830158233643,
-0.06319232285022736,
-0.6010206341743469,
-0.5799815654754639,
-0.15557952225208282,
-0.07876767963171005,
-0.778857946395874,
-0.27333489060401917,
-0.2292836308479309,
0.011792958714067936,
-0.04634048417210579,
-0.09418482333421707,
-0.5363674163818359,
0.3275601863861084,
0.44468095898628235,
0.3437669277191162,
-0.21628311276435852,
0.19961929321289062,
-0.34742313623428345,
-0.16002675890922546,
0.317233145236969,
0.17401444911956787,
0.7207943797111511,
-0.1293524205684662,
-0.7807236313819885,
0.06258793920278549,
0.5363236665725708,
0.5536344647407532,
-0.23244082927703857,
0.5701902508735657,
0.558869481086731,
-0.333764910697937,
0.025311829522252083,
-0.26146554946899414,
-0.49497076869010925,
-0.47267526388168335,
0.2824482023715973,
-0.2289070188999176,
-0.7367756366729736,
0.6161311864852905,
0.20266146957874298,
0.07378541678190231,
0.203366219997406,
0.45762476325035095,
-0.0056623173877596855,
1.0654349327087402,
0.1618744134902954,
-0.12444381415843964,
-0.004846253432333469,
0.07435254752635956,
0.2548188865184784,
-0.4163321554660797,
-0.14154337346553802,
-0.6542781591415405,
-0.0054726069793105125,
-0.9404180645942688,
-0.40281134843826294,
0.4533349871635437,
-0.2805245518684387,
-0.21677134931087494,
0.22306028008460999,
-0.6327292323112488,
0.5584694147109985,
0.7178744673728943,
0.4454226791858673,
0.09488397091627121,
-0.6168303489685059,
0.026291176676750183,
0.16769544780254364,
-0.7011680006980896,
-0.4559195935726166,
1.0396478176116943,
0.22676542401313782,
0.8550783395767212,
0.13107432425022125,
0.5378434062004089,
0.005958263762295246,
0.04799559339880943,
-0.6622414588928223,
0.5811203122138977,
0.36595168709754944,
-1.2511928081512451,
-0.32268616557121277,
-0.4261709153652191,
-0.9580162763595581,
0.1522812694311142,
0.23784539103507996,
-0.5638474225997925,
-0.2538071870803833,
0.05723221227526665,
-0.22981704771518707,
0.30639883875846863,
-1.0376344919204712,
0.9839754104614258,
-0.06596865504980087,
-0.07757604122161865,
0.47864025831222534,
-0.8034102320671082,
0.2944820821285248,
-0.13746601343154907,
-0.0295086819678545,
-0.18480201065540314,
0.15828540921211243,
0.6452323794364929,
-0.3974640369415283,
0.9060584902763367,
-0.12318730354309082,
0.1183660551905632,
0.5757125020027161,
0.5151842832565308,
0.19722728431224823,
0.33937186002731323,
0.1707637459039688,
-0.10036738216876984,
0.32435059547424316,
-0.8672094345092773,
-0.6446266174316406,
0.29625943303108215,
-0.6682835817337036,
-0.6337109804153442,
-0.6633246541023254,
-0.2761635184288025,
-0.5604194402694702,
0.06086839735507965,
0.528944730758667,
0.38190799951553345,
-0.21488778293132782,
-0.4507620334625244,
0.8720224499702454,
-0.3126541078090668,
0.13249504566192627,
0.17565122246742249,
-0.1310441792011261,
0.1859181523323059,
0.70563143491745,
0.04516255110502243,
0.5875094532966614,
0.10107804834842682,
0.33584773540496826,
-0.08873558044433594,
-0.33154600858688354,
-0.5333256125450134,
0.26007023453712463,
-0.7394267320632935,
-0.10633648931980133,
-0.38273364305496216,
-0.6525002717971802,
-0.2337663769721985,
-0.17051206529140472,
-0.30994319915771484,
-0.3904547691345215,
0.1554536372423172,
0.004578645806759596,
0.3101799488067627,
0.3859212100505829,
0.2662072479724884,
0.27134910225868225,
-0.9398558735847473,
0.21338950097560883,
0.7464143633842468,
0.30549943447113037,
-0.5858509540557861,
-0.41148194670677185,
0.49496957659721375,
0.07081396132707596,
-0.3163604736328125,
-1.2301682233810425,
-0.11061011999845505,
0.09335099905729294,
0.3479600250720978,
0.12256282567977905,
0.05418850854039192,
0.36721259355545044,
-0.37910783290863037,
1.1545010805130005,
-0.4653554856777191,
-0.5395712852478027,
0.763268232345581,
-0.5504795908927917,
0.33482450246810913,
0.8246628642082214,
0.4552651047706604,
-0.9300028085708618,
-0.6903848648071289,
-0.9192849397659302,
-0.3915480077266693,
0.2889544367790222,
0.5361299514770508,
0.40682125091552734,
0.25039416551589966,
0.3215339779853821,
0.11414765566587448,
-0.03468316048383713,
-0.7369546294212341,
-0.2523841857910156,
-0.013507873751223087,
-0.047491490840911865,
-0.041568219661712646,
-0.08805802464485168,
-0.20522332191467285,
-0.014171475544571877,
0.4979481101036072,
0.03127172589302063,
0.5310754179954529,
0.40662682056427,
0.14078167080879211,
0.2432500720024109,
0.3614775538444519,
0.32385969161987305,
0.35222241282463074,
-0.48935559391975403,
0.2893974483013153,
0.2929404079914093,
-1.1902447938919067,
0.20895540714263916,
0.002798879984766245,
0.00903460755944252,
0.044988930225372314,
0.37139296531677246,
-0.08638010174036026,
-0.14279749989509583,
-0.8410826325416565,
0.8575764894485474,
-0.5320838093757629,
-0.22583340108394623,
-0.24377310276031494,
0.44647786021232605,
-0.045797329396009445,
-0.20491565763950348,
-0.023192573338747025,
0.2604098618030548,
0.08929118514060974,
-0.4655163288116455,
0.6602457165718079,
0.3588491678237915,
-0.8195290565490723,
-0.09365667402744293,
0.7641459107398987,
-0.031216170638799667,
-0.556483805179596,
0.8409822583198547,
-0.025708654895424843,
-1.0634244680404663,
0.8547433614730835,
0.44885310530662537,
0.4810616075992584,
-0.5474902391433716,
0.5342724323272705,
0.3725299835205078,
0.4243001341819763,
0.15014635026454926,
0.6231269240379333,
0.21511195600032806,
-0.6285762786865234,
-0.2643983066082001,
-0.02505396492779255,
-1.1107943058013916,
-0.12432143837213516,
-0.49479299783706665,
0.23011988401412964,
-0.30478161573410034,
-0.056629132479429245,
-0.11037139594554901,
-0.16932354867458344,
-0.4518083333969116,
0.42441534996032715,
-0.026639141142368317,
0.929445743560791,
-0.6129112243652344,
0.48372161388397217,
0.4952760934829712,
-0.18961051106452942,
-0.9361004829406738,
0.19551238417625427,
0.14840759336948395,
-1.0786006450653076,
0.11145547032356262,
0.07853589206933975,
0.06079822778701782,
-0.1510891616344452,
-0.6493531465530396,
-0.3358980715274811,
0.6093387007713318,
0.22351090610027313,
0.018647290766239166,
0.08176456391811371,
0.6775045394897461,
0.40944865345954895,
0.5572211742401123,
0.6766029596328735,
0.4034635126590729,
0.35478195548057556,
-0.08818390220403671,
-1.0244395732879639,
0.06767769157886505,
-0.34318041801452637,
-0.6727114319801331,
0.3899458944797516,
-0.621017336845398,
0.727277398109436,
-0.04359133914113045,
-0.0033045292366296053,
-0.2763940393924713,
-0.37590035796165466,
0.19838546216487885,
0.40466374158859253,
0.295501172542572,
0.2366926372051239,
0.817803680896759,
-0.35346564650535583,
1.182814121246338,
0.00574154406785965,
0.3805822432041168,
0.894180953502655,
0.09386146813631058,
0.5804727673530579,
0.5090926289558411,
-0.2463701367378235,
-0.032831598073244095,
0.8137116432189941,
-0.023876115679740906,
0.3832399249076843,
0.49120035767555237,
-0.30806687474250793,
-0.23844437301158905,
0.1746642291545868,
-0.32147714495658875,
0.6619129776954651,
0.15785883367061615,
0.05182814225554466,
-0.30847689509391785,
-0.06924477964639664,
0.38398587703704834,
-0.2265172153711319,
-0.0027037535328418016,
0.487488329410553,
0.1471490114927292,
-0.8086403608322144,
0.41940152645111084,
-0.33783718943595886,
0.18953481316566467,
-0.6335896253585815,
-0.08595558255910873,
-0.34789544343948364,
0.1930627077817917,
0.025487810373306274,
-0.9469736218452454,
0.23132704198360443,
0.006465842016041279,
0.5090928077697754,
0.15822356939315796,
0.9782143831253052,
-0.05828122794628143,
-0.46477368474006653,
-0.07595831155776978,
0.7854179739952087,
0.3418232202529907,
-0.5607423782348633,
-0.7746585011482239,
-0.476906418800354,
-0.07070012390613556,
-0.14484956860542297,
0.22570309042930603,
0.25965166091918945,
0.20018422603607178,
1.0311824083328247,
0.34572702646255493,
0.03756624832749367,
0.35106781125068665,
-0.3939204514026642,
0.6744526028633118,
-0.4487067759037018,
-0.17704837024211884,
-0.9652358889579773,
0.44332802295684814,
-0.012803031131625175,
-0.4776436388492584,
0.8203505873680115,
0.5158636569976807,
0.6890747547149658,
0.14923788607120514,
0.7473711967468262,
0.061284441500902176,
0.6760368943214417,
-0.347412645816803,
0.9541045427322388,
-0.12323828041553497,
0.1325601190328598,
-0.30526265501976013,
-0.4650906026363373,
-0.28139856457710266,
0.2540997862815857,
-0.22016702592372894,
-0.08996666222810745,
0.7683213949203491,
1.0015294551849365,
-0.12440305948257446,
0.2760268747806549,
0.3264794647693634,
-0.1911410242319107,
0.5190189480781555,
0.8438345193862915,
0.9736433029174805,
-0.8069388270378113,
1.0512126684188843,
-0.3370147943496704,
-0.20595517754554749,
-0.014047706499695778,
-0.32498642802238464,
-1.0796337127685547,
-0.5251547694206238,
-0.3778902292251587,
-0.6345511674880981,
0.271497905254364,
0.22745481133460999,
0.2585190534591675,
-0.7700659036636353,
0.04217638075351715,
-0.05283334478735924,
0.15539206564426422,
-0.1647275984287262,
-0.24320338666439056,
0.555917501449585,
-0.043606579303741455,
-0.4382140636444092,
-0.0824635848402977,
-0.13475003838539124,
0.19655977189540863,
-0.006780716590583324,
0.4056302309036255,
0.20352035760879517,
0.23074312508106232,
-0.029009347781538963,
0.17231632769107819,
-0.041703708469867706,
-0.6861907839775085,
0.3929385244846344,
-0.32282930612564087,
0.2988292872905731,
0.7062360048294067,
-0.47251826524734497,
0.3474475145339966,
0.36963313817977905,
0.7117947936058044,
0.10057802498340607,
0.12844330072402954,
0.461180180311203,
-0.5003235340118408,
-0.1105039119720459,
0.6623261570930481,
0.056544672697782516,
0.015873361378908157,
-0.617887556552887,
0.6914204955101013,
0.07326837629079819,
-0.9605306386947632,
-0.6389645338058472,
0.13210411369800568,
-1.1805098056793213,
-0.28414613008499146,
1.1066391468048096,
-0.1522722840309143,
-0.11046471446752548,
-0.4621187746524811,
-0.7163727879524231,
0.19426484405994415,
-0.06284835934638977,
0.9874322414398193,
0.9822065830230713,
-0.29187583923339844,
-0.09304637461900711,
-1.1701213121414185,
0.5700260996818542,
0.5949075222015381,
-0.9015949368476868,
-0.08456069976091385,
-0.0814201608300209,
0.42738375067710876,
-0.022228850051760674,
0.7659602165222168,
-0.28872954845428467,
0.5707153081893921,
0.2626836895942688,
-0.2921784222126007,
0.2670031189918518,
0.2586415708065033,
-0.2446940392255783,
0.2348201423883438,
0.2330615073442459,
-0.7217422723770142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16611v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16611v2
|
Understanding the Dataset Practitioners Behind Large Language Model Development
| 2024-02-21T23:50:37 | 2024-04-01T19:58:43 |
Crystal Qian, Emily Reif, Minsuk Kahng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
As large language models (LLMs) become more advanced and impactful, it is
increasingly important to scrutinize the data that they rely upon and produce.
What is it to be a dataset practitioner doing this work? We approach this in
two parts: first, we define the role of "dataset practitioners" by performing a
retrospective analysis on the responsibilities of teams contributing to LLM
development at a technology company, Google. Then, we conduct semi-structured
interviews with a cross-section of these practitioners (N=10). We find that
although data quality is a top priority, there is little consensus around what
data quality is and how to evaluate it. Consequently, practitioners either rely
on their own intuition or write custom code to evaluate their data. We discuss
potential reasons for this phenomenon and opportunities for alignment.
|
[
-0.3382622301578522,
-0.37142837047576904,
0.363734632730484,
-0.1292254626750946,
0.13015978038311005,
0.2037241905927658,
-0.22720807790756226,
-0.41370880603790283,
-0.04642054811120033,
0.6776899695396423,
-0.7423727512359619,
-0.4908972680568695,
-0.40081366896629333,
0.029483990743756294,
-0.7929444909095764,
1.0423238277435303,
-0.008735920302569866,
0.07557374238967896,
-0.28318026661872864,
0.027344800531864166,
-0.4889131486415863,
-0.3429083228111267,
-0.5817496180534363,
-0.43015536665916443,
0.5056936144828796,
0.5615463852882385,
0.9796807169914246,
0.8688957691192627,
0.552837073802948,
0.20547963678836823,
-0.09042874723672867,
-0.25976911187171936,
-1.0141727924346924,
0.27725088596343994,
-0.21092191338539124,
-0.5119150876998901,
-0.1936274766921997,
0.005023178178817034,
0.5888165831565857,
1.2047580480575562,
-0.33495351672172546,
0.48147526383399963,
-0.038876913487911224,
0.7092616558074951,
-0.32377922534942627,
0.18883001804351807,
-0.4010101556777954,
0.17536552250385284,
-0.3246985077857971,
-0.14511454105377197,
-0.21480363607406616,
-0.4140257239341736,
0.01522738579660654,
-0.39259329438209534,
0.31192660331726074,
-0.029569759964942932,
0.5335773825645447,
0.36358365416526794,
-0.4238256812095642,
-0.20586039125919342,
-0.8969736695289612,
0.7958663105964661,
-0.638359546661377,
0.261294960975647,
0.26590976119041443,
0.37250110507011414,
-0.525810182094574,
-0.35789060592651367,
-0.48928821086883545,
0.20402994751930237,
0.19585241377353668,
-0.13569898903369904,
0.47707828879356384,
-0.13246355950832367,
0.28312695026397705,
0.9162304401397705,
-0.5660238265991211,
0.4586164951324463,
-0.4338746666908264,
0.03498106822371483,
0.9920339584350586,
0.36873316764831543,
0.14635241031646729,
0.34676074981689453,
0.00543994503095746,
0.17111389338970184,
-1.1824129819869995,
-0.30227595567703247,
0.42600178718566895,
0.33232226967811584,
0.04430457204580307,
0.583246648311615,
-0.014913521707057953,
1.0052424669265747,
-0.3321496248245239,
-0.10348669439554214,
0.010985841043293476,
-0.30870816111564636,
-0.1797455996274948,
0.14305731654167175,
0.3855507969856262,
0.31724393367767334,
0.7771469950675964,
-0.23990994691848755,
-0.42231446504592896,
-0.32850903272628784,
0.6080827713012695,
-0.5371259450912476,
-0.08531621098518372,
0.4313257336616516,
-0.5506288409233093,
-0.3714159429073334,
0.07713843137025833,
-0.5405991673469543,
-0.832430899143219,
-0.7169433832168579,
-0.09491885453462601,
0.20173726975917816,
-0.5759794116020203,
0.09782563149929047,
-0.1503625065088272,
0.3526739478111267,
0.3337128758430481,
-0.9582016468048096,
0.3912961184978485,
1.092905879020691,
0.3680276870727539,
0.056105561554431915,
-0.43864184617996216,
-0.33231598138809204,
0.31077060103416443,
-0.9070919752120972,
0.5604624152183533,
-0.345162570476532,
-0.48637524247169495,
0.20934832096099854,
-0.10538927465677261,
0.174382284283638,
-0.5877123475074768,
0.2534525394439697,
-0.4971163868904114,
0.07390271872282028,
-0.48966705799102783,
-0.7847043871879578,
-0.0036046532914042473,
0.3220754861831665,
-0.5932592153549194,
0.9528366327285767,
0.3778420686721802,
-0.6427636742591858,
0.7621729373931885,
-0.18282461166381836,
-0.3892019987106323,
0.36220479011535645,
-0.4326495826244354,
0.08375798910856247,
0.4033832848072052,
-0.13056808710098267,
0.5788149833679199,
-0.503417432308197,
0.4230222702026367,
-0.416690856218338,
-0.5354045033454895,
0.416624516248703,
0.03404063358902931,
0.6276215314865112,
0.29607143998146057,
0.053297482430934906,
-0.12113280594348907,
-0.7808000445365906,
-0.002219435991719365,
-0.010304756462574005,
-0.3254697024822235,
-0.1764707863330841,
0.34563174843788147,
0.02819501981139183,
0.21208377182483673,
-0.18062235414981842,
-0.15341953933238983,
0.2691141963005066,
-0.011160850524902344,
0.3404400050640106,
0.728645384311676,
0.02323492430150509,
0.2352183312177658,
-0.28153300285339355,
0.6024382710456848,
-0.40604203939437866,
0.40158069133758545,
0.05088464170694351,
-0.3415537476539612,
-0.577125608921051,
0.11546741425991058,
0.5202670693397522,
0.09655454009771347,
-0.6428018808364868,
0.3942191004753113,
-0.6066272854804993,
-0.6072034239768982,
-0.6609693169593811,
0.6226920485496521,
0.05745276063680649,
0.513701856136322,
-0.23302507400512695,
-0.42087867856025696,
-0.3638714849948883,
-0.8306350708007812,
-0.14389677345752716,
-0.04746521636843681,
0.07244866341352463,
0.23535895347595215,
0.4863991439342499,
-0.12067553400993347,
1.1789765357971191,
-0.40882551670074463,
-0.028499452397227287,
-0.6246587634086609,
-0.21424464881420135,
0.7223187685012817,
0.37742701172828674,
0.42527133226394653,
-0.8282116651535034,
-0.43737727403640747,
-0.17985022068023682,
-0.8846068382263184,
-0.25942856073379517,
-0.18927668035030365,
0.031130816787481308,
0.030511310324072838,
0.6488001346588135,
-0.49458158016204834,
0.12381264567375183,
0.6446881890296936,
-0.2816375195980072,
0.46060001850128174,
0.08532005548477173,
-0.1461871862411499,
-0.8681505918502808,
0.317890465259552,
0.2893873155117035,
-0.13027073442935944,
-0.8865827918052673,
0.15028083324432373,
-0.18386445939540863,
-0.21253709495067596,
-0.32744768261909485,
0.5368850827217102,
-0.42392006516456604,
-0.6531216502189636,
-0.17743676900863647,
0.015415234491229057,
-0.06959588080644608,
-0.24608567357063293,
-0.06937862187623978,
0.9161064624786377,
0.6947972774505615,
-0.790360689163208,
0.4574750065803528,
0.2353067547082901,
-0.8562355637550354,
0.6959964632987976,
-0.7052779197692871,
0.05134868621826172,
0.05686192214488983,
0.12658609449863434,
-0.7682849764823914,
-0.30515971779823303,
-0.04890504479408264,
-0.3875042200088501,
0.5826152563095093,
-0.4735734164714813,
-1.0949547290802002,
-0.7183857560157776,
0.036271099001169205,
0.10527332127094269,
0.23209400475025177,
-0.531377375125885,
0.032468926161527634,
0.8515315651893616,
-0.39395737648010254,
-0.511099636554718,
-1.005042314529419,
0.44538480043411255,
-0.2452998161315918,
-0.7657986879348755,
0.016691483557224274,
0.20295754075050354,
-0.6559258103370667,
-0.1040605828166008,
-0.1272284984588623,
-0.19550172984600067,
0.4346260726451874,
-0.00026764528593048453,
0.02515149675309658,
-0.21138028800487518,
0.2601955831050873,
-0.37116193771362305,
-0.29252302646636963,
0.17969372868537903,
-0.05217314139008522,
0.5484063625335693,
0.3694038689136505,
-0.4243892431259155,
-0.23777693510055542,
0.2860667109489441,
0.23199261724948883,
-0.002751592779532075,
0.6664783954620361,
0.16764023900032043,
-0.11278003454208374,
-0.28234487771987915,
-0.6484311819076538,
0.09924426674842834,
-0.4983849823474884,
0.16106951236724854,
-0.23671992123126984,
-0.6712533235549927,
0.6482291221618652,
0.20004531741142273,
0.06424399465322495,
0.38364872336387634,
0.5179077982902527,
-0.1915874481201172,
0.6959200501441956,
0.7228145003318787,
-0.4141606390476227,
0.30454322695732117,
-0.3692803978919983,
0.21432949602603912,
-0.6372095346450806,
-0.040651049464941025,
-0.40662258863449097,
-0.2796100974082947,
-0.5476008057594299,
-0.14626862108707428,
0.11095622181892395,
-0.08454450219869614,
-0.3419334888458252,
0.09041918069124222,
-0.3919820487499237,
0.5806732177734375,
0.43560779094696045,
-0.2828218340873718,
0.13014298677444458,
-0.25153136253356934,
0.5765767693519592,
0.15421025454998016,
-0.6835111975669861,
-0.6513940691947937,
1.144747018814087,
0.5783162713050842,
1.2360783815383911,
0.0847097858786583,
0.5941898226737976,
0.3021610975265503,
0.08053915947675705,
-0.814857542514801,
0.670387864112854,
-0.1395476758480072,
-0.7948920726776123,
-0.06384547054767609,
-0.4212784171104431,
-0.8380478620529175,
-0.013535651378333569,
0.18865717947483063,
-0.5203267931938171,
0.10990969836711884,
0.011242668144404888,
-0.1243780329823494,
0.032532159239053726,
-0.5896220803260803,
0.8752812743186951,
-0.33449703454971313,
-0.39294224977493286,
-0.17892785370349884,
-0.5740862488746643,
0.20579256117343903,
0.03740951046347618,
0.3261960446834564,
0.015724381431937218,
0.05308910831809044,
0.7721808552742004,
-0.3661789298057556,
0.8133151531219482,
-0.34337958693504333,
-0.5554486513137817,
0.4547426998615265,
0.04771946370601654,
0.1634151041507721,
0.00418638251721859,
-0.2477908879518509,
-0.0030628403183072805,
0.08040433377027512,
-0.44095227122306824,
-0.3988986015319824,
0.6793735027313232,
-0.5275675058364868,
-0.6398271322250366,
-0.40445250272750854,
-0.5730607509613037,
-0.3130187690258026,
0.23893313109874725,
-0.14880648255348206,
0.3986329138278961,
-0.37386631965637207,
0.2682236135005951,
0.6519584655761719,
-0.08394446223974228,
0.3258017897605896,
0.3344915211200714,
-0.32164496183395386,
-0.060335420072078705,
0.6755751371383667,
0.2815881371498108,
0.3882545232772827,
0.08215056359767914,
0.07586333155632019,
-0.14996713399887085,
-0.714514434337616,
-0.3454740047454834,
0.21271680295467377,
-0.833920419216156,
0.1963210105895996,
-0.1478206217288971,
-0.1400095820426941,
-0.32005470991134644,
-0.09393675625324249,
-0.3522598147392273,
-0.2968234419822693,
-0.13864850997924805,
-0.11922022700309753,
0.2495206594467163,
1.071045160293579,
0.19885091483592987,
0.48212072253227234,
-0.6347313523292542,
0.009202615357935429,
0.10902240127325058,
0.39591941237449646,
-0.06348085403442383,
-0.23065082728862762,
-0.46819964051246643,
0.08349627256393433,
0.03512486442923546,
-0.45370304584503174,
0.28575631976127625,
-0.08290132135152817,
0.703262209892273,
0.43748024106025696,
-0.3200386166572571,
0.5440856218338013,
-0.2175098955631256,
0.9869472980499268,
-0.24202780425548553,
-0.7679267525672913,
0.4692791700363159,
-0.6155379414558411,
0.08627427369356155,
0.8579510450363159,
0.2200693041086197,
-0.9999288320541382,
-0.1706884652376175,
-0.3815643787384033,
-0.691750705242157,
0.7595404982566833,
-0.03896632790565491,
0.31563812494277954,
0.27589690685272217,
0.5404824018478394,
0.34050169587135315,
0.6199910640716553,
-0.3846335709095001,
-0.21375660598278046,
0.08637169748544693,
-0.20263676345348358,
-0.46279779076576233,
-0.3766085207462311,
-0.48871371150016785,
-0.09981463104486465,
0.3334499001502991,
-0.1840304285287857,
0.08473039418458939,
-0.42939114570617676,
-0.18312399089336395,
-0.03080066666007042,
0.15233993530273438,
0.29636964201927185,
1.2616674900054932,
0.028680412098765373,
-0.036205098032951355,
-0.2614477872848511,
-0.2958083748817444,
-0.04209072142839432,
0.011709555983543396,
-0.13427913188934326,
-0.1157594844698906,
0.5047778487205505,
0.5123583078384399,
0.06456179916858673,
-0.4286106526851654,
0.5071470141410828,
0.10124333202838898,
-0.049956001341342926,
-0.4135732650756836,
0.368310809135437,
0.16120095551013947,
-0.0051452042534947395,
0.4465545415878296,
-0.5865911841392517,
0.09866843372583389,
-0.8207272887229919,
0.1596582531929016,
0.21063560247421265,
-0.2383602261543274,
-0.2499634027481079,
0.19596152007579803,
0.2695698142051697,
-0.24857638776302338,
0.9326362013816833,
0.10734619945287704,
-0.4832998216152191,
0.9131088852882385,
0.31757694482803345,
0.6780776977539062,
-0.22531914710998535,
0.2544751465320587,
-0.1232098788022995,
0.06692352145910263,
-0.33578142523765564,
0.6747210621833801,
0.18708765506744385,
-0.6737198829650879,
-0.5817282795906067,
-0.26513364911079407,
-0.6156182289123535,
0.049167364835739136,
-0.8141974210739136,
0.31289103627204895,
-0.18448008596897125,
0.02061610296368599,
-0.059272922575473785,
0.18587318062782288,
-0.6926391124725342,
0.3939039707183838,
0.101320780813694,
1.0250884294509888,
-0.9303442239761353,
0.7152694463729858,
0.5085582137107849,
-0.28057506680488586,
-0.42957812547683716,
0.11552881449460983,
0.27540239691734314,
-1.019576072692871,
0.6829537749290466,
0.11130420863628387,
0.3928428292274475,
0.021942470222711563,
-0.47649314999580383,
-0.8534095883369446,
1.0069202184677124,
0.13196098804473877,
-0.5876334309577942,
0.0673692375421524,
0.3523157835006714,
0.7690650820732117,
-0.38854050636291504,
0.12780487537384033,
0.4969104528427124,
0.4145987331867218,
0.00809809472411871,
-0.8056677579879761,
-0.16506685316562653,
-0.16546517610549927,
0.21702805161476135,
0.2176479995250702,
-0.5436493754386902,
0.6069651246070862,
-0.03528372570872307,
-0.09933894872665405,
-0.06444631516933441,
0.10722009092569351,
0.020890401676297188,
0.09235445410013199,
0.22318585216999054,
0.47200706601142883,
0.7633627653121948,
-0.11079135537147522,
1.3532871007919312,
-0.39383891224861145,
0.40640848875045776,
1.3131822347640991,
-0.46180030703544617,
0.5883527398109436,
0.6527366042137146,
-0.3661092221736908,
0.0485810786485672,
1.0884177684783936,
-0.5015569925308228,
0.4468918740749359,
0.5857211947441101,
-0.023041965439915657,
-0.14406868815422058,
-0.15705464780330658,
-0.5009932518005371,
0.41726890206336975,
0.5025571584701538,
-0.49687331914901733,
-0.19071722030639648,
-0.2904779016971588,
-0.06081559136509895,
-0.15679356455802917,
-0.45026737451553345,
0.8342775702476501,
0.1449677050113678,
-0.5687771439552307,
0.2677251398563385,
-0.4606756269931793,
0.08130289614200592,
-0.3385336697101593,
0.29229801893234253,
-0.21285082399845123,
0.47883015871047974,
-0.3766569197177887,
-1.5273847579956055,
0.4712141752243042,
-0.010983461514115334,
-0.06754637509584427,
-0.4701070785522461,
0.3232853412628174,
-0.33286693692207336,
-0.39279764890670776,
0.11864086985588074,
0.5515139102935791,
0.3508063554763794,
-0.04222720488905907,
-0.6781221032142639,
0.38793298602104187,
-0.4030412435531616,
-0.3584747016429901,
0.2670144736766815,
0.4746478796005249,
0.10005564987659454,
0.8742473721504211,
0.18027624487876892,
0.41095325350761414,
-0.1813589632511139,
0.5554856657981873,
0.9224562048912048,
-0.7006651163101196,
-0.18576182425022125,
-0.7713108062744141,
0.4595264196395874,
-0.20707891881465912,
-0.4563571512699127,
0.8500990867614746,
0.7131772637367249,
0.8198981285095215,
0.08844922482967377,
0.8190932273864746,
-0.10959422588348389,
0.5849526524543762,
-0.5048277378082275,
0.8260565996170044,
-0.3824499249458313,
0.3874904215335846,
-0.11710000038146973,
-1.094537615776062,
-0.3819977343082428,
0.36582663655281067,
-0.42755863070487976,
0.17868123948574066,
0.3555295765399933,
0.7610894441604614,
0.03551950678229332,
0.16253644227981567,
0.072686105966568,
0.22698087990283966,
0.6758036613464355,
0.26558491587638855,
0.9927601218223572,
-0.2282969206571579,
0.2183600813150406,
-0.21754403412342072,
-0.009611324407160282,
-0.03564291447401047,
-0.7418020963668823,
-0.7856812477111816,
-0.3702748417854309,
-0.4596579372882843,
-0.25086137652397156,
-0.06926295906305313,
0.55503249168396,
0.6434245109558105,
-0.7355059385299683,
-0.6844852566719055,
-0.3330059349536896,
0.1333543211221695,
0.008500797674059868,
-0.20672936737537384,
0.07547949999570847,
-0.34793293476104736,
-0.5123460292816162,
0.30790483951568604,
0.08475109934806824,
-0.12072847038507462,
-0.5437915921211243,
0.12752366065979004,
0.018048476427793503,
-0.3196375370025635,
0.2695327401161194,
0.2790907621383667,
-0.42962831258773804,
-0.12558244168758392,
-0.26829102635383606,
-0.20433774590492249,
-0.004950452595949173,
0.9319505095481873,
-0.39644259214401245,
0.5556141138076782,
0.32965952157974243,
0.7497169375419617,
0.42471638321876526,
-0.028115594759583473,
1.0366538763046265,
-0.5566877722740173,
-0.16414690017700195,
0.16530470550060272,
0.28595995903015137,
0.6248819828033447,
-0.46110886335372925,
0.9440395832061768,
0.09438150376081467,
-0.8112320899963379,
-1.1048614978790283,
0.17213459312915802,
-0.5875332951545715,
-0.06252147257328033,
1.4290491342544556,
-0.011129847727715969,
-0.16933763027191162,
-0.27912411093711853,
-0.035480353981256485,
-0.1070784479379654,
-0.09069740772247314,
0.6166536808013916,
0.8664300441741943,
0.02640005759894848,
-0.2718990743160248,
-0.8873688578605652,
0.3841552436351776,
-0.12847119569778442,
-0.832741916179657,
0.22079767286777496,
0.517149806022644,
0.3350554406642914,
-0.02993135154247284,
0.6220600008964539,
-0.0052626836113631725,
0.013474839739501476,
0.021876737475395203,
0.05483057349920273,
0.17368923127651215,
-0.34867063164711,
-0.48314744234085083,
-0.15769647061824799,
0.35803118348121643,
-0.007302885875105858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14179v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14179v1
|
Bangla AI: A Framework for Machine Translation Utilizing Large Language Models for Ethnic Media
| 2024-02-21T23:43:04 | 2024-02-21T23:43:04 |
MD Ashraful Goni, Fahad Mostafa, Kerk F. Kee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Ethnic media, which caters to diaspora communities in host nations, serves as
a vital platform for these communities to both produce content and access
information. Rather than utilizing the language of the host nation, ethnic
media delivers news in the language of the immigrant community. For instance,
in the USA, Bangla ethnic media presents news in Bangla rather than English.
This research delves into the prospective integration of large language models
(LLM) and multi-lingual machine translations (MMT) within the ethnic media
industry. It centers on the transformative potential of using LLM in MMT in
various facets of news translation, searching, and categorization. The paper
outlines a theoretical framework elucidating the integration of LLM and MMT
into the news searching and translation processes for ethnic media.
Additionally, it briefly addresses the potential ethical challenges associated
with the incorporation of LLM and MMT in news translation procedures.
|
[
-0.2611301839351654,
-0.5795782804489136,
0.524276614189148,
0.2991732060909271,
-0.3274518549442291,
0.4552417993545532,
-0.28160950541496277,
-0.5396066308021545,
0.2778036892414093,
0.5784158110618591,
-0.2659889757633209,
-0.16066908836364746,
-0.7926129102706909,
0.23433592915534973,
-0.47546300292015076,
0.9525064826011658,
-0.27317512035369873,
0.35182058811187744,
0.43228355050086975,
-0.13394033908843994,
-0.40773966908454895,
-0.4253520965576172,
-0.22938162088394165,
-0.15291304886341095,
0.5651236772537231,
0.22394628822803497,
0.8107441067695618,
0.7663411498069763,
0.7753092646598816,
0.24832472205162048,
0.02120189741253853,
0.19386188685894012,
-0.4926447570323944,
-0.15481001138687134,
-0.26689600944519043,
-0.6446698307991028,
-0.07179735600948334,
0.27001383900642395,
0.7381588220596313,
0.6982699036598206,
0.14751581847667694,
0.4343191087245941,
-0.11406084150075912,
0.7515465021133423,
-0.5242136716842651,
-0.033675193786621094,
-0.6514824628829956,
0.042731475085020065,
-0.20109663903713226,
-0.3898704946041107,
-0.41351455450057983,
-0.6158894896507263,
-0.374850869178772,
-0.04150546342134476,
-0.31697601079940796,
0.12880486249923706,
0.681903064250946,
0.4045933783054352,
-0.9684927463531494,
-0.4488361179828644,
-1.0304486751556396,
0.6537990570068359,
-0.6203984022140503,
0.5341402888298035,
0.3582298755645752,
0.46767324209213257,
-0.2661105692386627,
-0.07038582861423492,
-0.8178826570510864,
-0.11454706639051437,
0.057329755276441574,
0.042515918612480164,
0.034647077322006226,
-0.03045848198235035,
-0.21908435225486755,
0.5416440963745117,
-0.5286588072776794,
0.3261641263961792,
-0.8366298675537109,
0.1298871636390686,
0.7564220428466797,
0.1383652687072754,
0.42962372303009033,
-0.2864469289779663,
-0.17305944859981537,
0.45898735523223877,
-0.7532561421394348,
-0.19731149077415466,
0.5566079020500183,
0.6196907758712769,
-0.1277083307504654,
0.9153104424476624,
-0.02397746592760086,
0.785120964050293,
-0.12611082196235657,
-0.6095306277275085,
0.24741604924201965,
-0.41216325759887695,
-0.2006649225950241,
0.24763289093971252,
0.5599309206008911,
0.4461810886859894,
0.025459354743361473,
-0.01863599568605423,
-0.05548868328332901,
-0.008014075458049774,
0.1576276570558548,
-0.904742956161499,
0.5322636961936951,
0.20534822344779968,
-0.9088266491889954,
-0.2054523527622223,
0.036578498780727386,
-0.6602789759635925,
-0.4181824028491974,
-0.4925577938556671,
0.2797514796257019,
-0.09056113660335541,
-0.406752347946167,
0.10519761592149734,
0.11909107118844986,
0.4748629033565521,
0.3250854015350342,
-0.8926380276679993,
-0.17565402388572693,
0.5768047571182251,
0.6612790822982788,
0.09005315601825714,
-0.030331891030073166,
-0.31224653124809265,
0.44060590863227844,
-0.6400319337844849,
0.3939964175224304,
-0.7380250692367554,
-0.3996731638908386,
0.24901138246059418,
-0.1006716638803482,
-0.07804881036281586,
-0.43553832173347473,
0.3116530179977417,
-0.8868735432624817,
-0.12997449934482574,
-0.02408888190984726,
-0.32471466064453125,
-0.6525058150291443,
0.024904897436499596,
-0.5798614025115967,
0.47570109367370605,
0.17708620429039001,
-0.3399149775505066,
0.4401991665363312,
-0.6374558806419373,
-0.5698827505111694,
-0.007713486906141043,
-0.06784972548484802,
-0.2348027527332306,
0.25865480303764343,
-0.029872512444853783,
0.5169738531112671,
-0.40244126319885254,
0.3883143365383148,
-0.2545447051525116,
-0.5918940305709839,
0.3358919322490692,
-0.41278111934661865,
0.9889140725135803,
0.5409709811210632,
-0.3131725490093231,
-0.19744424521923065,
-0.6725350618362427,
-0.502379834651947,
-0.0032787227537482977,
-0.6770247220993042,
-0.3806728720664978,
0.010976479388773441,
0.3565255403518677,
0.3363473415374756,
0.1945575624704361,
-0.46008485555648804,
0.3670971095561981,
0.027016717940568924,
0.404742956161499,
0.5057865381240845,
-0.30859360098838806,
0.4737410247325897,
-0.06060981750488281,
0.49100446701049805,
0.0063568358309566975,
-0.10526597499847412,
-0.3718821406364441,
-0.44867634773254395,
-0.4911235272884369,
-0.23379844427108765,
0.4131720960140228,
0.8826445937156677,
-0.5194113254547119,
0.3278469145298004,
-0.3182518482208252,
-0.42985281348228455,
-1.1296331882476807,
0.2964373528957367,
-0.011201695539057255,
0.12827078998088837,
0.2875247597694397,
-0.08041875064373016,
-0.6242666244506836,
-0.9983243346214294,
0.03758259862661362,
-0.37522631883621216,
0.1302538812160492,
0.13374261558055878,
0.2840464115142822,
-0.6499122977256775,
0.7545587420463562,
0.15705832839012146,
-0.26572248339653015,
-0.4013720154762268,
0.3604481518268585,
0.4331481456756592,
0.3675038814544678,
0.3889824151992798,
-1.4494010210037231,
-0.561891496181488,
0.698257565498352,
-0.833249568939209,
-0.1706140637397766,
-0.3105336129665375,
0.13680575788021088,
0.25222423672676086,
0.4751812517642975,
-0.5646042823791504,
0.7982165813446045,
0.8215973377227783,
-0.0012879185378551483,
0.5874167084693909,
0.11846745014190674,
0.7784169912338257,
-1.500437617301941,
-0.01364110503345728,
-0.11765114963054657,
-0.22216781973838806,
-0.5914513468742371,
0.28864365816116333,
-0.06360688805580139,
-0.25291553139686584,
-0.37017977237701416,
0.5749961137771606,
-0.38430458307266235,
-0.3272736370563507,
-0.4995291829109192,
-0.04118730127811432,
-0.24005815386772156,
0.025809627026319504,
-0.16176702082157135,
0.8927059769630432,
0.12811517715454102,
-0.49357500672340393,
0.44026756286621094,
0.23906248807907104,
-0.43781283497810364,
0.7280527949333191,
-0.266242116689682,
-0.1712733954191208,
-0.22829678654670715,
0.3507494628429413,
-0.7442715764045715,
-0.40714842081069946,
0.3261045515537262,
-0.5870367884635925,
0.3030185103416443,
-0.14817754924297333,
-0.8107541799545288,
-0.313289076089859,
0.08244936168193817,
0.5899567604064941,
0.5263967514038086,
-0.339232474565506,
0.5089812278747559,
0.46813637018203735,
-0.4393311142921448,
-0.6493764519691467,
-1.0746580362319946,
0.6117347478866577,
-0.6201470494270325,
-0.7709017395973206,
0.04448985308408737,
-0.06461053341627121,
-0.4815831482410431,
0.0809439867734909,
0.3809654712677002,
-0.3696225881576538,
0.057673271745443344,
-0.05357345938682556,
0.093375064432621,
-0.5324381589889526,
-0.09164390712976456,
0.13637754321098328,
0.039114054292440414,
-0.2951454818248749,
-0.2696543037891388,
0.3144931197166443,
0.08010830730199814,
-0.33566346764564514,
-0.5746646523475647,
1.0559313297271729,
0.8717186450958252,
-0.5509120225906372,
0.9629928469657898,
0.8798564076423645,
-0.3001904785633087,
0.24815599620342255,
-0.8553429841995239,
0.04174109548330307,
-0.36391568183898926,
0.4648381769657135,
-0.25622570514678955,
-1.0798472166061401,
0.6183059811592102,
-0.156576469540596,
-0.16457276046276093,
0.21740028262138367,
1.020385980606079,
-0.052269503474235535,
1.1880605220794678,
0.9896305799484253,
-0.26635318994522095,
0.3202751576900482,
0.174018993973732,
0.7226272821426392,
-0.7708514928817749,
-0.04076768457889557,
-0.5162337422370911,
-0.410895437002182,
-0.855453610420227,
-0.5244346261024475,
0.3650880753993988,
-0.07120522856712341,
0.03832061216235161,
0.35010507702827454,
-0.22406484186649323,
0.419612318277359,
0.5580650568008423,
-0.3437313139438629,
0.6560668349266052,
-0.08703291416168213,
0.2980700731277466,
-0.0853758305311203,
-0.4024589955806732,
-0.6653424501419067,
0.7019047141075134,
0.4463641941547394,
0.8499819040298462,
0.3600369989871979,
0.7140992879867554,
0.3403374254703522,
0.45264148712158203,
-0.8573725819587708,
0.30463865399360657,
-0.25623562932014465,
-0.9397242069244385,
-0.07706371694803238,
-0.38861721754074097,
-0.8643999695777893,
0.3130034804344177,
0.09080225974321365,
-0.7692355513572693,
0.4980016052722931,
-0.3016962707042694,
-0.10428087413311005,
0.5994647741317749,
-0.4964151978492737,
0.5091668367385864,
-0.3066985011100769,
0.002728773280978203,
-0.5555037260055542,
-0.7262133359909058,
0.6385889053344727,
-0.589789628982544,
0.6437925696372986,
-0.196741983294487,
-0.006961510982364416,
0.26584792137145996,
0.1713191717863083,
0.7487367391586304,
0.3180854320526123,
-0.07980996370315552,
0.22005587816238403,
0.06518327444791794,
0.05151539295911789,
-0.17281386256217957,
-0.2561621069908142,
0.36903825402259827,
-0.2593729794025421,
-0.3765062391757965,
-0.36250340938568115,
0.2719062566757202,
-0.6939703822135925,
-0.5705490708351135,
-0.16490785777568817,
-1.0634539127349854,
0.12085740268230438,
0.3362174332141876,
-0.03764772042632103,
0.08054542541503906,
0.06819725036621094,
0.5254377722740173,
0.37563836574554443,
-0.21057766675949097,
0.23342865705490112,
0.5881799459457397,
-0.4556351900100708,
-0.04099322110414505,
0.9892234206199646,
0.2174481898546219,
0.07552427053451538,
0.45959773659706116,
0.052214253693819046,
-0.056088853627443314,
-0.7539107799530029,
-0.87060546875,
0.2760252356529236,
-0.670377254486084,
-0.17626953125,
-0.47222596406936646,
-0.23249515891075134,
-0.3098955452442169,
-0.5051074028015137,
-0.2528575658798218,
-0.09382373839616776,
-0.1403079479932785,
-0.05916372314095497,
-0.060125838965177536,
0.9055221080780029,
-0.21066614985466003,
0.47895464301109314,
-0.9225597977638245,
0.3121890425682068,
0.0514441542327404,
0.16848373413085938,
-0.4351669251918793,
-0.5810433626174927,
-0.6393589377403259,
0.17097108066082,
-0.15769951045513153,
-1.0963613986968994,
0.29199540615081787,
-0.2154950201511383,
0.5539377927780151,
0.23021437227725983,
-0.29732850193977356,
0.5943493247032166,
-0.974285364151001,
0.5714585781097412,
0.06154976412653923,
-0.7497704029083252,
0.31406429409980774,
-0.7216602563858032,
-0.11697949469089508,
0.6087118983268738,
0.7543658018112183,
-0.8595557808876038,
-0.5180695056915283,
0.08883588016033173,
-0.6594603657722473,
0.2729317545890808,
-0.09977935999631882,
0.5187845826148987,
-0.02367064729332924,
0.04490082338452339,
0.22065383195877075,
0.46121543645858765,
-1.0174870491027832,
0.07416553795337677,
0.08127091825008392,
-0.16095255315303802,
0.08781682699918747,
-0.21467456221580505,
0.10935021191835403,
-0.17872782051563263,
0.5731581449508667,
0.038842830806970596,
0.2753306031227112,
-0.036961570382118225,
-0.3235453963279724,
-0.2963094115257263,
0.33739396929740906,
0.41211846470832825,
0.7526307106018066,
-0.16762813925743103,
-0.28990766406059265,
-0.4265090823173523,
-0.008007108233869076,
0.3361925482749939,
0.22605320811271667,
-0.3449867069721222,
0.07521895319223404,
0.038722649216651917,
0.6656174659729004,
0.06445999443531036,
-0.5652156472206116,
0.2549751102924347,
0.27730876207351685,
-0.05191754549741745,
-0.12437662482261658,
-0.370914101600647,
0.12589013576507568,
0.4604514241218567,
0.7537434697151184,
-0.21936583518981934,
0.3774750828742981,
-0.9109975695610046,
0.16684283316135406,
0.3800302743911743,
-0.11642096191644669,
-0.11331062018871307,
0.7852535247802734,
0.3099505603313446,
-0.43516820669174194,
0.4329928755760193,
-0.19739462435245514,
-0.5773155093193054,
0.3585765063762665,
0.597108781337738,
0.7788044214248657,
-0.7857950925827026,
0.3124099373817444,
0.19673827290534973,
0.5880211591720581,
0.1254183053970337,
-0.12442730367183685,
0.34703516960144043,
-0.6102193593978882,
-0.8240282535552979,
-0.7699480056762695,
-0.3314706087112427,
-0.04525548592209816,
-0.39132535457611084,
0.3435198664665222,
0.028014974668622017,
0.05903075262904167,
-0.04288443922996521,
-0.16526781022548676,
-0.3588268458843231,
0.10025244206190109,
0.5012796521186829,
0.7671314477920532,
-0.8680464029312134,
0.816094696521759,
0.5845097303390503,
-0.6564505100250244,
-0.7297398447990417,
0.10207813233137131,
0.2399265617132187,
-0.9302119612693787,
0.795015275478363,
0.23779840767383575,
0.00923581887036562,
-0.045098185539245605,
-0.2574029266834259,
-0.6966058015823364,
0.7312557101249695,
0.285163551568985,
-0.156675323843956,
-0.04156312718987465,
0.4732833802700043,
0.31990066170692444,
-0.7550362944602966,
-0.1305260807275772,
0.5484752058982849,
0.7763054966926575,
0.06536789983510971,
-1.2249120473861694,
-0.3003798723220825,
-0.17472031712532043,
0.08414927124977112,
0.21915964782238007,
-0.7508769631385803,
0.8171793818473816,
-0.1646326631307602,
0.09491422772407532,
0.09397188574075699,
0.6319238543510437,
-0.0923859179019928,
0.4145677983760834,
0.06372182816267014,
0.06662530452013016,
0.42242586612701416,
0.20207586884498596,
1.1791619062423706,
-0.13518545031547546,
-0.03605496138334274,
0.48759040236473083,
-0.21436595916748047,
0.6227251887321472,
0.4660300612449646,
-0.27061980962753296,
0.3953215777873993,
0.9085711240768433,
0.024864034727215767,
0.27548277378082275,
0.1845686435699463,
-0.3710978329181671,
0.10454726964235306,
-0.5649107694625854,
-0.3984895944595337,
0.8841639161109924,
0.5275964736938477,
-0.3717510998249054,
-0.14571815729141235,
0.1194252222776413,
0.07719948142766953,
0.4301871955394745,
-0.590976893901825,
0.5850353240966797,
0.19938692450523376,
-0.3560282588005066,
0.2906409204006195,
0.3760611116886139,
0.7327866554260254,
-0.4543270170688629,
-0.0125439977273345,
-0.14302493631839752,
-0.2002175897359848,
-0.2027931809425354,
-0.4162309169769287,
0.7424445152282715,
-0.05905380845069885,
-0.3852784335613251,
-0.03991643711924553,
0.4831603765487671,
-0.7542757391929626,
-0.9807000160217285,
0.3024458587169647,
0.6234734654426575,
0.3391498327255249,
0.16820910573005676,
-0.6649020910263062,
0.46306246519088745,
0.11993400752544403,
-0.12478748708963394,
0.41452738642692566,
0.36647599935531616,
-0.25231698155403137,
0.5948381423950195,
0.6584463715553284,
0.37808719277381897,
0.1499948650598526,
-0.2869526743888855,
0.5073055624961853,
-0.42890405654907227,
-0.5394893884658813,
-0.835030734539032,
0.49251535534858704,
0.15890714526176453,
0.1861284226179123,
0.6213226914405823,
0.563385546207428,
0.673419177532196,
0.13147559762001038,
1.0316306352615356,
-0.1583283245563507,
0.40036624670028687,
-0.496744304895401,
0.8071537613868713,
-0.8289690017700195,
-0.15167084336280823,
-0.2153041958808899,
-1.2564913034439087,
-0.43881580233573914,
0.6404902935028076,
-0.28377535939216614,
0.051382891833782196,
0.4355384409427643,
0.6985670328140259,
-0.1703864187002182,
-0.10159022361040115,
0.45301756262779236,
0.1795279085636139,
0.24862222373485565,
0.21664828062057495,
0.6013647317886353,
-0.16579656302928925,
0.5834521651268005,
0.12726478278636932,
-0.2517145872116089,
-0.5713361501693726,
-0.9245990514755249,
-0.6818777918815613,
-0.6736411452293396,
0.07834973186254501,
-0.13032817840576172,
-0.041963834315538406,
1.0443683862686157,
0.8346379995346069,
-0.5192623138427734,
-0.5622159242630005,
0.6417166590690613,
0.37871208786964417,
0.038710761815309525,
-0.2142486274242401,
0.12008015811443329,
-0.14666792750358582,
-1.1881935596466064,
0.4134078621864319,
0.611500084400177,
0.004174569621682167,
-0.6024773716926575,
0.07034770399332047,
-0.4909959137439728,
0.23342445492744446,
0.6878165602684021,
0.39420950412750244,
-0.7730811834335327,
-0.17041411995887756,
-0.2981531322002411,
-0.19458499550819397,
0.12912459671497345,
0.8136269450187683,
-0.37898990511894226,
0.48337268829345703,
0.16079549491405487,
1.3746252059936523,
0.16980622708797455,
-0.017404021695256233,
0.7373397946357727,
-0.3719474971294403,
0.47409868240356445,
0.3004968762397766,
0.12310289591550827,
0.5850535035133362,
-0.5888375043869019,
0.634490966796875,
0.11764366179704666,
-0.729137659072876,
-0.9674311876296997,
0.42220887541770935,
-0.804918110370636,
-0.1862138956785202,
1.188249111175537,
0.2525523602962494,
-0.2519327402114868,
-0.32092803716659546,
-0.13298268616199493,
0.21505948901176453,
-0.13420093059539795,
0.7652966976165771,
0.7206113338470459,
0.2201005518436432,
-0.27005136013031006,
-1.1698397397994995,
-0.03934957832098007,
0.07230116426944733,
-0.4696821868419647,
-0.2016836702823639,
0.4895237386226654,
-0.14663732051849365,
0.3419489562511444,
0.7054643034934998,
-0.24940183758735657,
0.3674086332321167,
-0.26113489270210266,
0.09512760490179062,
0.0852794349193573,
-0.2255019098520279,
-0.1397247165441513,
-0.22627784311771393,
-0.07682472467422485,
0.09848930686712265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14158v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14158v2
|
TOOLVERIFIER: Generalization to New Tools via Self-Verification
| 2024-02-21T22:41:38 | 2024-03-13T16:38:42 |
Dheeraj Mekala, Jason Weston, Jack Lanchantin, Roberta Raileanu, Maria Lomeli, Jingbo Shang, Jane Dwivedi-Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Teaching language models to use tools is an important milestone towards
building general assistants, but remains an open problem. While there has been
significant progress on learning to use specific tools via fine-tuning,
language models still struggle with learning how to robustly use new tools from
only a few demonstrations. In this work we introduce a self-verification method
which distinguishes between close candidates by self-asking contrastive
questions during (1) tool selection; and (2) parameter generation. We construct
synthetic, high-quality, self-generated data for this goal using Llama-2 70B,
which we intend to release publicly. Extensive experiments on 4 tasks from the
ToolBench benchmark, consisting of 17 unseen tools, demonstrate an average
improvement of 22% over few-shot baselines, even in scenarios where the
distinctions between candidate tools are finely nuanced.
|
[
-0.4946499466896057,
-0.838982880115509,
0.6451171040534973,
-0.03008919395506382,
-0.20247648656368256,
-0.06002360209822655,
-0.11164452135562897,
-0.1883636862039566,
-0.051905177533626556,
0.45014476776123047,
-0.4470165967941284,
-0.5938622355461121,
-0.46404996514320374,
0.2707720994949341,
-0.6527743935585022,
0.8811127543449402,
-0.1501304656267166,
-0.2513847053050995,
-0.28092196583747864,
-0.049999039620161057,
-0.5052130818367004,
-0.22820667922496796,
-0.5359934568405151,
-0.47943416237831116,
0.427947998046875,
0.6001275777816772,
0.5357456207275391,
0.8375985622406006,
0.31305554509162903,
0.38465645909309387,
0.150067538022995,
0.16604220867156982,
-0.14821922779083252,
0.21252785623073578,
-0.2856833040714264,
-0.672961950302124,
-0.29047298431396484,
0.1687946766614914,
0.335509717464447,
0.6548986434936523,
-0.018981123343110085,
0.6462763547897339,
0.23897287249565125,
0.011402981355786324,
-0.6431578993797302,
-0.2160537987947464,
-0.6961469054222107,
-0.06575514376163483,
-0.2625304162502289,
-0.026831896975636482,
-0.1650717556476593,
-0.19710613787174225,
-0.15377062559127808,
-0.4663035273551941,
0.8405979871749878,
-0.2618575394153595,
0.7701992392539978,
0.4420222342014313,
-0.5320783853530884,
-0.3213686943054199,
-0.6652222275733948,
0.7721819281578064,
-0.5744094252586365,
0.45203331112861633,
0.6135678887367249,
0.6252346038818359,
-0.30750414729118347,
-0.8756053447723389,
-0.4591771960258484,
-0.29483649134635925,
-0.02370770275592804,
-0.10002277046442032,
0.06363366544246674,
-0.10370486974716187,
0.3954341411590576,
0.5457854866981506,
-0.4794429540634155,
0.302185595035553,
-0.5736884474754333,
-0.4904865622520447,
0.6214736700057983,
0.014618396759033203,
-0.07880799472332001,
0.0344887375831604,
0.03316647559404373,
-0.31585729122161865,
-0.8133915662765503,
-0.17978675663471222,
0.6937182545661926,
0.07245271652936935,
-0.2699730694293976,
0.4218943417072296,
-0.3612808883190155,
0.6813872456550598,
0.29122278094291687,
-0.2670077383518219,
0.2959021329879761,
-0.27293381094932556,
-0.32292360067367554,
-0.34700807929039,
0.6979610919952393,
0.215220645070076,
0.18184174597263336,
-0.1869698017835617,
-0.26883015036582947,
-0.02626311220228672,
0.14016467332839966,
-0.6160663962364197,
-0.3925367593765259,
0.25346753001213074,
-0.2678355276584625,
-0.5366908311843872,
-0.2027692347764969,
-0.31196320056915283,
-0.3165196180343628,
-0.19378618896007538,
0.4503362774848938,
0.31733742356300354,
-0.34116464853286743,
-0.07009249925613403,
-0.07463350147008896,
0.4800378680229187,
0.5496055483818054,
-0.7658348679542542,
0.3911563754081726,
0.5083826184272766,
0.6951218247413635,
-0.16926391422748566,
-0.46655258536338806,
-0.8270880579948425,
0.023607565090060234,
-0.6053587198257446,
0.7859230041503906,
-0.4169674515724182,
-0.7286213636398315,
-0.15408407151699066,
0.2449185848236084,
0.5134857296943665,
-0.6853736639022827,
0.23207949101924896,
-0.05137505382299423,
0.5348787307739258,
-0.24544496834278107,
-0.2788161337375641,
0.02170400880277157,
0.30638769268989563,
-0.4999454915523529,
1.3638886213302612,
0.37538620829582214,
-0.4249226748943329,
0.49067234992980957,
-0.3892000615596771,
-0.3523070812225342,
-0.0492451973259449,
-0.6390395760536194,
-0.5586656332015991,
0.2589266300201416,
0.2866184115409851,
0.6317040324211121,
-0.47652697563171387,
0.24388746917247772,
-0.4259708523750305,
-0.3077041804790497,
-0.057784054428339005,
-0.2643515467643738,
0.5015096664428711,
0.193099707365036,
-0.449499249458313,
0.035370852798223495,
-0.6758524179458618,
-0.18914435803890228,
0.26961585879325867,
-0.3543623983860016,
0.025785453617572784,
-0.46324050426483154,
-0.46596813201904297,
0.07266713678836823,
0.3603367209434509,
-0.6843937635421753,
0.29831427335739136,
-0.4209848940372467,
-0.10135732591152191,
0.9165266156196594,
-0.10234346240758896,
0.15563343465328217,
0.011215176433324814,
0.7365579009056091,
-0.071214959025383,
0.19872990250587463,
-0.07445172965526581,
-0.38254526257514954,
-0.8132804036140442,
0.2343318611383438,
0.5093058943748474,
0.26329341530799866,
-0.5261582136154175,
0.3812394440174103,
0.3684101998806,
-0.6121100187301636,
-0.5952951908111572,
0.65908282995224,
0.5815573930740356,
0.6327928900718689,
0.21950963139533997,
-0.5252804756164551,
-0.4376198351383209,
-1.0397647619247437,
-0.07610494643449783,
-0.20260508358478546,
-0.3233962953090668,
0.43927574157714844,
0.23459690809249878,
-0.2110869437456131,
0.7536052465438843,
-0.5572794675827026,
-0.1477014720439911,
-0.20541302859783173,
0.3554970920085907,
0.21740373969078064,
0.5010919570922852,
0.5541328191757202,
-0.3259166479110718,
-0.3568037748336792,
0.10928808897733688,
-0.7712247967720032,
-0.3170836865901947,
-0.05027594417333603,
0.1255856454372406,
-0.20184293389320374,
0.9818501472473145,
-0.15844540297985077,
0.32098257541656494,
0.6518651247024536,
-0.06699821352958679,
0.5932610034942627,
-0.4186323881149292,
-0.1475067436695099,
-0.9199651479721069,
0.11418290436267853,
-0.03088284283876419,
-0.26776692271232605,
-0.5589332580566406,
0.03523095324635506,
-0.09339708834886551,
0.019211597740650177,
-0.509069561958313,
0.94926917552948,
-0.6465544104576111,
-0.08788998425006866,
-0.47898563742637634,
0.10533037781715393,
-0.142059788107872,
0.2309681624174118,
-0.28561028838157654,
1.0520235300064087,
0.6512864828109741,
-0.6298054456710815,
0.3509196639060974,
-0.00887194275856018,
0.038467880338430405,
0.4551268517971039,
-1.0743108987808228,
0.602118968963623,
-0.08814699202775955,
-0.047923728823661804,
-1.0594669580459595,
-0.3498140275478363,
0.12249729037284851,
-0.3117048740386963,
0.18107427656650543,
-0.38521358370780945,
-0.4580538868904114,
-0.4411179721355438,
-0.07401878386735916,
0.3902180790901184,
0.6497644782066345,
-0.6657114028930664,
0.8523944020271301,
0.2302170842885971,
-0.062028609216213226,
-0.6129136681556702,
-0.4934706389904022,
-0.15228994190692902,
-0.1689596176147461,
-0.2440171241760254,
-0.020145462825894356,
-0.1448569893836975,
-0.09575312584638596,
-0.4292035400867462,
-0.34466323256492615,
-0.013498499058187008,
0.5174508094787598,
0.30215883255004883,
0.009834248572587967,
-0.175337016582489,
0.2713302969932556,
0.22908379137516022,
-0.14447927474975586,
0.2557281255722046,
0.2738160789012909,
0.5007407069206238,
-0.1484367698431015,
-0.8782445192337036,
-0.13878989219665527,
0.0690416619181633,
-0.03224450722336769,
-0.33593592047691345,
-0.06117143854498863,
0.9585997462272644,
0.017553113400936127,
-0.29717904329299927,
-1.0886934995651245,
-0.33977556228637695,
-0.6086164712905884,
0.21111585199832916,
-0.7969647645950317,
-0.7967137694358826,
0.579186201095581,
-0.4670998156070709,
0.14166051149368286,
0.34484705328941345,
0.6718307733535767,
0.22220703959465027,
1.138963222503662,
0.6608470678329468,
-0.03718455135822296,
0.1925603747367859,
-0.18335890769958496,
-0.20679976046085358,
-0.8296507000923157,
-0.015551270917057991,
-0.6122908592224121,
-0.072077676653862,
-0.6245988607406616,
-0.4375200867652893,
0.27709466218948364,
-0.008403723128139973,
0.08089324831962585,
0.4296937882900238,
-0.7221701145172119,
0.7997841835021973,
0.82230144739151,
-0.13561007380485535,
0.06393983960151672,
-0.30865028500556946,
-0.372893750667572,
0.4777618944644928,
-0.1851159781217575,
-0.7057373523712158,
1.5203776359558105,
0.375224769115448,
0.8289327621459961,
-0.0007577089127153158,
1.3410104513168335,
0.29234936833381653,
0.2419566810131073,
-0.4768166244029999,
0.7850980162620544,
-0.04024602472782135,
-0.5300190448760986,
-0.30046769976615906,
-0.04467983543872833,
-1.135524034500122,
0.17605531215667725,
0.12979432940483093,
-0.6001771688461304,
0.20588496327400208,
0.5466465950012207,
-0.1809096783399582,
-0.19149409234523773,
-0.8212738633155823,
0.9303115010261536,
-0.22028487920761108,
-0.33969786763191223,
-0.12671883404254913,
-0.6251372694969177,
0.09880456328392029,
-0.02704276703298092,
-0.044710561633110046,
-0.3797345757484436,
-0.006670061964541674,
0.4214697778224945,
-0.11157872527837753,
0.9404302835464478,
-0.3085050880908966,
-0.3793141841888428,
0.1391119360923767,
0.431557834148407,
0.5785883665084839,
-0.09170904755592346,
-0.09139325469732285,
-0.10080060362815857,
-0.00687242578715086,
-0.3429064154624939,
-0.7143262028694153,
0.5446352362632751,
-0.6773108243942261,
-1.1482664346694946,
-0.13830097019672394,
-0.3016469180583954,
-0.21664763987064362,
0.37193554639816284,
-0.02294629067182541,
0.32225269079208374,
-0.35442429780960083,
0.1077510416507721,
0.46622246503829956,
0.05328841879963875,
0.16428621113300323,
0.5047569870948792,
-0.14384818077087402,
-0.014940856955945492,
0.8352016806602478,
-0.2118624448776245,
0.3280135691165924,
-0.1502956748008728,
0.4532301127910614,
-0.10591138899326324,
-0.5831223130226135,
-0.4738142192363739,
0.3753741681575775,
-1.0002483129501343,
-0.18225699663162231,
-0.2868134081363678,
0.03773221746087074,
-0.39553073048591614,
-0.1944868564605713,
-0.1951584666967392,
-0.31985729932785034,
-0.4356434941291809,
-0.1822539120912552,
-0.07912328839302063,
1.099295735359192,
-0.16559050977230072,
0.3200755715370178,
-0.22463718056678772,
0.33798226714134216,
0.8423775434494019,
0.14495240151882172,
-0.2666694223880768,
-0.4402494430541992,
0.010931475088000298,
-0.16979099810123444,
-0.46709197759628296,
-0.7275775074958801,
-0.003949717618525028,
0.2903185784816742,
0.9997533559799194,
0.44269007444381714,
-0.1513327807188034,
0.4421766996383667,
-0.3226265013217926,
0.8123127222061157,
-0.0712510198354721,
-0.9373073577880859,
1.062982201576233,
-0.17911015450954437,
0.48799511790275574,
0.4565974771976471,
0.17044854164123535,
-0.3347555994987488,
-0.7509877681732178,
-0.7773829102516174,
-0.35705873370170593,
0.4013633131980896,
0.04670923575758934,
0.26522600650787354,
-0.09467779099941254,
0.3702205419540405,
0.39130011200904846,
0.16991406679153442,
-0.5145448446273804,
-0.11295691132545471,
-0.3045153021812439,
-0.18837963044643402,
-0.047881439328193665,
-0.0800672397017479,
-0.3123583197593689,
0.040965333580970764,
0.4527101516723633,
-0.7147906422615051,
-0.04449447616934776,
0.19935794174671173,
-0.040677331387996674,
0.025577843189239502,
0.3121403455734253,
0.4282565712928772,
0.6507929563522339,
-0.01651439629495144,
0.46266597509384155,
0.6806350946426392,
-0.2783418297767639,
0.3792968988418579,
0.025020096451044083,
-0.01863711141049862,
0.10457248240709305,
0.3089892268180847,
0.41616570949554443,
-0.04369492828845978,
-0.4086838662624359,
0.6572768092155457,
0.1212485283613205,
-0.30026277899742126,
-0.0522683747112751,
0.5436198115348816,
-0.06430622935295105,
0.17121964693069458,
-0.003507034620270133,
-0.4851013422012329,
0.5562161207199097,
-0.4043373465538025,
0.10360406339168549,
0.623017430305481,
-0.08238941431045532,
-0.4038003981113434,
0.5559752583503723,
0.3476381003856659,
-0.3281387984752655,
0.2020949125289917,
-0.5345718264579773,
-0.10757846385240555,
0.646020233631134,
0.49150028824806213,
0.9090775847434998,
-0.5623061060905457,
0.2839888334274292,
0.2753082811832428,
0.20534482598304749,
-0.06273610889911652,
0.3313632607460022,
-0.4787217676639557,
-0.5195179581642151,
-0.19607482850551605,
-0.274311363697052,
-0.6240673661231995,
0.06279202550649643,
-0.6344542503356934,
0.4965391159057617,
-0.4813438355922699,
-0.21216289699077606,
0.061975497752428055,
-0.17135106027126312,
-1.0620664358139038,
0.3391243815422058,
-0.22740621864795685,
0.677710771560669,
-1.1117702722549438,
0.8493577241897583,
0.6959689259529114,
-0.4903208017349243,
-0.863493800163269,
-0.07462997734546661,
0.07074655592441559,
-1.1482410430908203,
0.6288343071937561,
0.08135802298784256,
-0.24418269097805023,
-0.16589820384979248,
-0.6302823424339294,
-0.8922885060310364,
1.0657957792282104,
0.5151042342185974,
-0.3545425236225128,
-0.197440043091774,
0.14409038424491882,
0.4777682423591614,
-0.2185850739479065,
0.3525581657886505,
0.538756787776947,
0.2660668194293976,
0.19992683827877045,
-1.3220956325531006,
0.22795215249061584,
-0.07706061005592346,
0.01350630447268486,
0.0904097929596901,
-0.37997516989707947,
0.8717507719993591,
-0.22227023541927338,
-0.11779124289751053,
0.016092831268906593,
0.5227397084236145,
0.19169563055038452,
0.0941656306385994,
0.6487903594970703,
0.27826836705207825,
0.5318465828895569,
0.01756293512880802,
0.7519132494926453,
-0.09633955359458923,
0.18088306486606598,
1.3502254486083984,
-0.10675112158060074,
0.5058561563491821,
0.4353627860546112,
-0.1457388699054718,
0.6444366574287415,
0.333617627620697,
-0.3648868799209595,
0.21771526336669922,
0.19821083545684814,
0.014962936751544476,
-0.5617859959602356,
-0.16869837045669556,
-0.37202808260917664,
0.6836963891983032,
0.04899309575557709,
-0.4495077431201935,
-0.46180635690689087,
0.010708612389862537,
-0.01887321285903454,
0.017322899773716927,
0.04012427106499672,
1.0617121458053589,
-0.07746689021587372,
-0.7993760704994202,
0.6124593019485474,
-0.09278161078691483,
0.4222145676612854,
-0.6193441152572632,
-0.2939053177833557,
-0.25020086765289307,
0.13555395603179932,
-0.08261367678642273,
-0.8008742928504944,
0.02492024190723896,
-0.2810145914554596,
0.3732143044471741,
0.12961816787719727,
0.8407282829284668,
-0.36668482422828674,
-0.4759477376937866,
0.035481326282024384,
0.7458476424217224,
0.4418400526046753,
0.13236454129219055,
-0.573997974395752,
0.051123131066560745,
-0.08491793274879456,
0.0053969877772033215,
0.16041404008865356,
0.31096088886260986,
0.0696699395775795,
0.7784293293952942,
0.5521816611289978,
0.19103197753429413,
-0.0935794785618782,
0.41764500737190247,
0.8685094118118286,
-0.3986441195011139,
-0.26528605818748474,
-0.5208664536476135,
0.3887253999710083,
-0.2051524966955185,
-0.6373366713523865,
0.9799428582191467,
0.4670198857784271,
1.0493472814559937,
-0.12656675279140472,
0.6931585669517517,
0.22930710017681122,
0.6698712110519409,
-0.3145740032196045,
0.009004257619380951,
-0.5840475559234619,
0.19209523499011993,
-0.16720420122146606,
-0.6338440179824829,
-0.04287741705775261,
0.6740632653236389,
-0.27754220366477966,
0.2914925813674927,
0.3746463656425476,
1.005179524421692,
-0.3368822932243347,
-0.4687112271785736,
0.3737308979034424,
-0.2810841500759125,
0.48944684863090515,
0.08940234780311584,
0.5269224047660828,
-0.34392669796943665,
0.5749945640563965,
-0.49360159039497375,
-0.10333866626024246,
-0.2277623564004898,
-0.8360307812690735,
-1.2995197772979736,
-0.5880687832832336,
-0.4533948302268982,
-0.20840393006801605,
0.11786806583404541,
0.7243712544441223,
0.9436963796615601,
-0.6740542054176331,
-0.5292229652404785,
-0.14025264978408813,
0.0908021330833435,
-0.12607116997241974,
-0.08139820396900177,
0.14587169885635376,
-0.5280276536941528,
-0.5738886594772339,
0.4905274212360382,
-0.005700344685465097,
0.42262589931488037,
-0.8561514019966125,
0.03756564110517502,
0.19019578397274017,
0.007070374209433794,
0.27453383803367615,
0.4460337460041046,
-1.0619155168533325,
-0.49006643891334534,
-0.06803516298532486,
0.24777284264564514,
0.057654354721307755,
0.797619640827179,
-0.9191424250602722,
0.5963733792304993,
0.1970355361700058,
0.42113199830055237,
0.5451624393463135,
-0.0644787847995758,
0.7582297921180725,
-1.1632280349731445,
0.021720845252275467,
-0.026412101462483406,
0.33091726899147034,
0.5066888332366943,
-0.3277662694454193,
0.8104174733161926,
-0.25763916969299316,
-0.6687291860580444,
-1.0531644821166992,
0.486380398273468,
-0.5564795732498169,
0.04197947680950165,
1.085862159729004,
0.0464102141559124,
-0.04553915187716484,
-0.2543458938598633,
-0.4533751904964447,
0.22054916620254517,
-0.11451023817062378,
0.9327569007873535,
0.45185983180999756,
-0.08830691874027252,
-0.2481086105108261,
-0.20035076141357422,
0.5767127275466919,
0.3516215682029724,
-1.0833886861801147,
-0.011152375489473343,
0.39262855052948,
0.5885897278785706,
0.22808827459812164,
0.5283534526824951,
0.18196432292461395,
0.5764808654785156,
0.05314180254936218,
0.06505109369754791,
-0.2512182593345642,
-0.24998041987419128,
-0.2417413890361786,
0.050351209938526154,
0.6517095565795898,
-0.27832162380218506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14155v1
|
Can Similarity-Based Domain-Ordering Reduce Catastrophic Forgetting for Intent Recognition?
| 2024-02-21T22:30:57 | 2024-02-21T22:30:57 |
Amogh Mannekote, Xiaoyi Tian, Kristy Elizabeth Boyer, Bonnie J. Dorr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Task-oriented dialogue systems are expected to handle a constantly expanding
set of intents and domains even after they have been deployed to support more
and more functionalities. To live up to this expectation, it becomes critical
to mitigate the catastrophic forgetting problem (CF) that occurs in continual
learning (CL) settings for a task such as intent recognition. While existing
dialogue systems research has explored replay-based and regularization-based
methods to this end, the effect of domain ordering on the CL performance of
intent recognition models remains unexplored. If understood well, domain
ordering has the potential to be an orthogonal technique that can be leveraged
alongside existing techniques such as experience replay. Our work fills this
gap by comparing the impact of three domain-ordering strategies (min-sum path,
max-sum path, random) on the CL performance of a generative intent recognition
model. Our findings reveal that the min-sum path strategy outperforms the
others in reducing catastrophic forgetting when training on the 220M T5-Base
model. However, this advantage diminishes with the larger 770M T5-Large model.
These results underscores the potential of domain ordering as a complementary
strategy for mitigating catastrophic forgetting in continually learning intent
recognition models, particularly in resource-constrained scenarios.
|
[
-0.018703000620007515,
-0.3433534502983093,
0.6112644076347351,
0.160318985581398,
-0.10510272532701492,
0.08039022237062454,
-0.08981843292713165,
-0.3048643171787262,
0.011031544767320156,
0.602053701877594,
-0.5555849671363831,
-0.48381364345550537,
-0.5748592615127563,
0.042071789503097534,
0.20379361510276794,
0.9206971526145935,
-0.11697541177272797,
0.13648627698421478,
-0.37182652950286865,
-0.6087405681610107,
-0.8915741443634033,
-0.5003966689109802,
-1.1211820840835571,
-0.45720940828323364,
0.39895862340927124,
0.2870537042617798,
0.420231431722641,
0.3949180245399475,
0.48026707768440247,
0.3202380836009979,
0.08029916137456894,
0.34184151887893677,
-1.02859365940094,
0.22708538174629211,
-0.031151045113801956,
-0.3307419717311859,
-0.44175392389297485,
-0.11275393515825272,
0.5461037158966064,
0.918759286403656,
-0.29252031445503235,
-0.10701771825551987,
0.058644503355026245,
0.7103868722915649,
-0.6551492214202881,
0.15390333533287048,
-0.5973440408706665,
0.15549421310424805,
0.2384185492992401,
-0.5608237981796265,
-0.7958710789680481,
-0.30790725350379944,
0.7342248558998108,
-0.5342596173286438,
0.2717590928077698,
0.3624415695667267,
0.49666374921798706,
-0.008507179096341133,
0.16537907719612122,
-0.26147809624671936,
-1.0660557746887207,
1.0355451107025146,
-0.4197595715522766,
0.38211309909820557,
0.2683148980140686,
0.283229798078537,
-0.24879397451877594,
-0.5429213643074036,
-0.2826259136199951,
0.14170363545417786,
0.2576262950897217,
0.15261223912239075,
0.04013309255242348,
0.2685510814189911,
0.32085734605789185,
0.06755690276622772,
-0.882394015789032,
0.006915399804711342,
-0.3444367051124573,
-0.14015479385852814,
0.3109399378299713,
0.5821428894996643,
0.1444154530763626,
0.37355923652648926,
-0.4478076100349426,
-0.17355164885520935,
-0.920383632183075,
0.17829261720180511,
-0.288228303194046,
0.20019443333148956,
0.13747549057006836,
0.12246516346931458,
-0.19936096668243408,
0.4481498599052429,
0.17509135603904724,
-0.3687548041343689,
0.15671133995056152,
-0.1438543051481247,
-0.5031483173370361,
0.03845492750406265,
0.43372002243995667,
0.4302513897418976,
0.292409211397171,
-0.27107933163642883,
-0.21626444160938263,
-0.13766300678253174,
0.5937473177909851,
-0.5195679068565369,
-0.3401913344860077,
0.13204394280910492,
-0.6556615233421326,
-0.0002190444793086499,
-0.1732407659292221,
-0.10256754606962204,
-0.19472499191761017,
-0.3263639509677887,
0.5696589350700378,
-0.6898527145385742,
0.15272577106952667,
0.20498761534690857,
0.0749155580997467,
0.21803568303585052,
0.747846245765686,
-0.8286018967628479,
0.6805278658866882,
0.7930678725242615,
0.8155685663223267,
-0.5277363061904907,
-0.5534083247184753,
-0.3355492949485779,
0.20388053357601166,
-0.43567830324172974,
0.532414436340332,
-0.5511488318443298,
-0.6451243162155151,
-0.0028294359799474478,
-0.30049267411231995,
-0.43694600462913513,
-0.9352799654006958,
0.49306029081344604,
-0.9813718795776367,
0.2223924696445465,
-0.17501722276210785,
-0.5903844237327576,
-0.5196507573127747,
0.13306613266468048,
-0.4981507658958435,
0.6197621822357178,
-0.10959158837795258,
-0.2211637943983078,
0.35649076104164124,
-0.16445817053318024,
-0.444892942905426,
0.07668517529964447,
-0.10852967947721481,
-0.8137484192848206,
0.21432504057884216,
-0.2631285488605499,
0.5451942682266235,
-0.14439354836940765,
0.10194449871778488,
-0.3422814905643463,
-0.504039466381073,
0.17962026596069336,
-0.7121599316596985,
0.4186980724334717,
-0.11307873576879501,
-0.41415131092071533,
-0.12792262434959412,
-0.4086000919342041,
0.04507748410105705,
0.33674490451812744,
-0.11156763881444931,
-0.6520402431488037,
0.1579705774784088,
-0.395067036151886,
0.33315160870552063,
0.0019414018606767058,
-0.16825313866138458,
0.09358830004930496,
-0.2075682282447815,
-0.054885029792785645,
0.8276488184928894,
0.4853120446205139,
0.6642917990684509,
-0.7510898113250732,
0.21894048154354095,
0.29917600750923157,
0.3999950587749481,
-0.09626473486423492,
-0.5684459209442139,
-0.9044442772865295,
0.20998309552669525,
-0.20094329118728638,
0.5736956596374512,
-0.4375333786010742,
-0.03805919736623764,
-0.6084061861038208,
-0.17585010826587677,
0.12602166831493378,
-0.1055738627910614,
0.8210192918777466,
0.22158296406269073,
0.48677554726600647,
-0.882658839225769,
-0.143162339925766,
-0.44955500960350037,
-0.024088993668556213,
-0.24376995861530304,
0.10724949836730957,
0.8856081366539001,
0.1752164512872696,
-0.06475411355495453,
0.664709210395813,
-0.7866349816322327,
-0.5093498229980469,
-0.25298383831977844,
0.23273344337940216,
0.14677056670188904,
0.3601676821708679,
0.6704239845275879,
-0.9054023027420044,
-0.47839924693107605,
-0.19392767548561096,
-0.48261383175849915,
0.2929450273513794,
-0.41089221835136414,
-0.18046990036964417,
0.532145619392395,
0.06813178211450577,
-0.7946926951408386,
0.5189945101737976,
0.05134989321231842,
0.005049069877713919,
0.5942235589027405,
-0.2827230393886566,
0.3204408884048462,
-0.6634984612464905,
-0.28693297505378723,
-0.5030201077461243,
-0.02456614561378956,
-0.8767741322517395,
-0.5814344882965088,
-0.032456882297992706,
-0.04148729890584946,
-0.27776679396629333,
0.24298004806041718,
-0.4749770164489746,
-0.06394457072019577,
-0.21350331604480743,
-0.15504375100135803,
-0.008177894167602062,
0.9285660982131958,
0.24977926909923553,
0.7632577419281006,
0.42206263542175293,
-0.9722575545310974,
-0.31393444538116455,
0.3536895215511322,
-0.18264874815940857,
0.4636155664920807,
-0.1388079673051834,
0.1737985461950302,
-0.0759289339184761,
0.2670117914676666,
-1.1247856616973877,
0.11410633474588394,
0.17305564880371094,
-0.4541196823120117,
0.44854819774627686,
-0.17110523581504822,
-0.01770557276904583,
-0.14096273481845856,
-0.2800011932849884,
0.7903630137443542,
0.7268555760383606,
-0.5395250916481018,
0.5954157114028931,
0.10413375496864319,
-0.46813228726387024,
-0.6586543917655945,
0.0607297383248806,
-0.14537955820560455,
-0.3367709815502167,
-0.23861826956272125,
0.5492123365402222,
-0.3654138743877411,
0.05199883505702019,
-0.4229883551597595,
-0.40903356671333313,
-0.19526103138923645,
-0.00937642715871334,
0.4676661193370819,
0.308866024017334,
-0.2634696364402771,
0.09657591581344604,
0.0014921823749318719,
-0.01349824108183384,
0.12005673348903656,
-0.7523723244667053,
0.485361784696579,
0.1997523456811905,
-0.1812511682510376,
-0.2592772841453552,
0.43742507696151733,
0.9547294974327087,
0.03164549916982651,
0.6729981899261475,
0.017794737592339516,
-0.25173628330230713,
-0.5499975085258484,
-0.7157938480377197,
-0.024582628160715103,
-0.5157868266105652,
-0.019291365519165993,
-0.3423491418361664,
-0.8286930322647095,
0.48360276222229004,
-0.5006983280181885,
0.2202814668416977,
0.14552973210811615,
0.33084213733673096,
-0.4048556089401245,
0.6951522827148438,
0.582852303981781,
-0.3364029824733734,
0.6163040995597839,
-0.4177980124950409,
0.28023645281791687,
-0.5930402874946594,
-0.14109943807125092,
-0.02387409284710884,
-0.23893754184246063,
-0.06366369873285294,
-0.5335022807121277,
0.40867894887924194,
-0.09743259102106094,
-0.21760988235473633,
0.3167040944099426,
-0.15524624288082123,
0.5441166758537292,
0.2981216013431549,
0.24379290640354156,
0.34339451789855957,
0.3089762330055237,
-0.2391773760318756,
-0.02417769283056259,
-0.9690719842910767,
-0.16366681456565857,
1.0117640495300293,
-0.03391911834478378,
0.5896490216255188,
0.1980438381433487,
0.9949304461479187,
0.31761935353279114,
0.20203684270381927,
-0.709174394607544,
0.705517590045929,
-0.06698337197303772,
0.036697231233119965,
-0.37503620982170105,
-0.46283021569252014,
-1.1023093461990356,
0.17352110147476196,
0.11431708186864853,
-0.5892688632011414,
0.3355763852596283,
0.09885832667350769,
-0.7848027348518372,
0.22631174325942993,
-0.6846218109130859,
0.48007744550704956,
-0.09457262605428696,
-0.34820616245269775,
-0.40061432123184204,
-0.5815203785896301,
0.05720958858728409,
0.06621136516332626,
-0.1337021291255951,
0.03076508827507496,
0.25467607378959656,
0.7557972073554993,
-0.4169459640979767,
0.8507775068283081,
-0.19229862093925476,
-0.02537420764565468,
0.5173006057739258,
0.42664700746536255,
0.6179790496826172,
-0.1663297712802887,
0.3213046193122864,
0.02979261986911297,
-0.7385126352310181,
-0.32073336839675903,
-0.7144575119018555,
0.7905558943748474,
-0.6454264521598816,
-0.6967057585716248,
-0.3224332928657532,
-0.4190315008163452,
-0.3605073392391205,
0.24304929375648499,
0.2753976881504059,
0.8664743900299072,
-0.3132956624031067,
-0.21021899580955505,
1.2333991527557373,
0.015108668245375156,
0.4848671555519104,
0.4898791015148163,
0.317609041929245,
-0.4367818832397461,
1.410936713218689,
0.19131861627101898,
0.7372499704360962,
0.4687078297138214,
-0.1265271157026291,
0.0018080684822052717,
-0.9415284395217896,
-0.1075800359249115,
0.2962817847728729,
-0.6544051170349121,
-0.4394117593765259,
-0.8638954162597656,
-0.13547338545322418,
-0.18400056660175323,
-0.3989560902118683,
-0.3104645013809204,
-0.4575553238391876,
-0.36328113079071045,
0.1840677708387375,
0.19258180260658264,
0.678531289100647,
0.3560047745704651,
-0.038119517266750336,
-0.7178847193717957,
0.3711397349834442,
0.23046088218688965,
0.6289249658584595,
0.3580036163330078,
-0.5792940258979797,
-0.18386569619178772,
-0.20905466377735138,
-0.5721724033355713,
-0.30755141377449036,
0.42271485924720764,
0.3532090187072754,
0.443897008895874,
0.6788232326507568,
0.18753601610660553,
0.8858073353767395,
-0.9702920317649841,
0.5420940518379211,
0.23040170967578888,
-0.3555606007575989,
0.29550254344940186,
-0.34376436471939087,
0.27469131350517273,
0.6542409062385559,
0.6102056503295898,
-0.43559911847114563,
-0.22163157165050507,
-0.7953947186470032,
-0.8264026641845703,
0.986134946346283,
0.36068251729011536,
0.030593788251280785,
-0.09969337284564972,
0.17279136180877686,
0.24846665561199188,
-0.07225295901298523,
-0.4021874666213989,
-0.49780356884002686,
0.1674821376800537,
0.04783427715301514,
-0.0010483169462531805,
-0.26482728123664856,
-0.017288116738200188,
-0.044101886451244354,
0.5113801956176758,
0.12063407897949219,
0.794418215751648,
0.19492463767528534,
-0.21033813059329987,
0.020744219422340393,
0.009977213107049465,
0.9939002394676208,
0.4878164529800415,
-0.3476126790046692,
-0.2607525587081909,
0.2675699293613434,
-0.7921149730682373,
0.21717649698257446,
-0.43984752893447876,
-0.13657152652740479,
0.056408461183309555,
0.1487008035182953,
0.7534377574920654,
0.48958107829093933,
-0.6680206060409546,
0.5789963006973267,
-0.010996697470545769,
-0.14833098649978638,
-0.47006484866142273,
0.2989652752876282,
-0.32399123907089233,
0.19958104193210602,
0.3813670575618744,
0.5256420969963074,
0.3451075851917267,
-0.37703418731689453,
0.2978571951389313,
0.2397582083940506,
-0.3648667335510254,
-0.14557544887065887,
0.2330726981163025,
0.013552726246416569,
-0.4488149881362915,
0.7589582204818726,
-0.060840290039777756,
-0.7281834483146667,
0.7371987104415894,
0.6606691479682922,
1.151658535003662,
-0.4395104944705963,
0.16323763132095337,
0.4364018440246582,
-0.06094978004693985,
-0.4438597857952118,
0.0725444108247757,
-0.376200407743454,
-0.6883004903793335,
0.09466627240180969,
-0.22247326374053955,
-0.5359821319580078,
-0.10896070301532745,
-0.5838519334793091,
-0.12235340476036072,
-0.7213073968887329,
-0.12610167264938354,
-0.2882324457168579,
-0.26532039046287537,
-0.4885947108268738,
0.2062571942806244,
0.13624107837677002,
0.45959314703941345,
-0.5880390405654907,
0.5546616911888123,
0.33185839653015137,
0.0030972163658589125,
-0.64339280128479,
0.34770530462265015,
0.08330516517162323,
-0.4515175223350525,
0.6363417506217957,
0.21973490715026855,
-0.5930821895599365,
-0.09425108879804611,
-0.24695612490177155,
-1.0146340131759644,
1.485209584236145,
-0.38893622159957886,
-0.1374232918024063,
0.07717256247997284,
-0.015277017839252949,
0.5730880498886108,
-0.6913428902626038,
0.1741873174905777,
0.37189531326293945,
-0.22070655226707458,
0.31416264176368713,
-0.7729582190513611,
-0.03879246488213539,
0.03657020255923271,
0.10202769190073013,
0.4280024468898773,
-0.6314465999603271,
0.36949971318244934,
-0.5756443738937378,
-0.6183359622955322,
0.22314023971557617,
0.428728848695755,
0.32869192957878113,
0.6137537360191345,
0.4439152181148529,
0.4838424324989319,
0.4669993221759796,
0.07157651335000992,
0.8538103103637695,
0.13986843824386597,
0.36933305859565735,
1.2072975635528564,
-0.5486834645271301,
0.7379360198974609,
0.17950016260147095,
-0.27691560983657837,
0.43938273191452026,
0.4171040654182434,
0.35733136534690857,
0.8837908506393433,
-0.06452860683202744,
-0.34091201424598694,
-0.20638343691825867,
-0.013128047809004784,
-0.07428549975156784,
-0.07634107023477554,
0.6978440880775452,
-0.3771992623806,
-0.09001708030700684,
0.04198860004544258,
-0.19991342723369598,
-0.18256351351737976,
-0.2884024381637573,
1.2670235633850098,
0.25022509694099426,
-0.7488526105880737,
1.0457398891448975,
-0.45527005195617676,
0.3489401936531067,
-0.5230827927589417,
-0.2626263201236725,
-0.4310666024684906,
0.20035754144191742,
0.1186562031507492,
-0.40242549777030945,
-0.07883923500776291,
-0.3986569344997406,
-0.5251724123954773,
-0.41150835156440735,
0.42177915573120117,
-0.3846037983894348,
0.030969038605690002,
0.4712465703487396,
0.10033450275659561,
-0.0817231684923172,
0.2541533410549164,
-0.6110297441482544,
-0.0989646464586258,
-0.12858961522579193,
-0.12657251954078674,
0.4883047938346863,
0.3166695833206177,
-0.3970241844654083,
0.9756547212600708,
0.39323368668556213,
-0.369457483291626,
0.12112987786531448,
0.11493277549743652,
0.7560287714004517,
-0.41202202439308167,
-0.40876591205596924,
-0.524636447429657,
0.008973265066742897,
-0.05808155611157417,
-0.16301165521144867,
0.419899046421051,
0.4876546859741211,
0.9934217929840088,
-0.5090206265449524,
0.5085134506225586,
0.11384432762861252,
0.2733202874660492,
-0.3654608130455017,
0.45843496918678284,
-0.4116877317428589,
0.39490824937820435,
-0.4199978709220886,
-0.9634897112846375,
-0.47655460238456726,
0.27046364545822144,
-0.36416923999786377,
0.23010332882404327,
0.9004777669906616,
0.6334012150764465,
-0.2529910206794739,
0.032468922436237335,
0.5849260687828064,
0.21142606437206268,
-0.037773650139570236,
1.1389870643615723,
0.6477029919624329,
-0.4254332184791565,
0.6689334511756897,
-0.16053947806358337,
-0.20354793965816498,
-0.3622700273990631,
-0.13751743733882904,
-0.8680950403213501,
-0.5951642394065857,
-0.2312239706516266,
-0.21899986267089844,
0.2532850503921509,
0.9677364230155945,
0.37302038073539734,
-0.8555933833122253,
-0.2561168074607849,
-0.1406259685754776,
0.23979026079177856,
-0.7162414193153381,
-0.2040255069732666,
0.45833033323287964,
-0.47065794467926025,
-0.4713514447212219,
0.2303784191608429,
0.9053519368171692,
0.23776905238628387,
0.39621102809906006,
-0.3009386360645294,
-0.03050166368484497,
0.226355642080307,
0.8350296020507812,
0.4943631589412689,
-0.7463245391845703,
-0.42818671464920044,
0.05641193315386772,
-0.3026893734931946,
0.3499336838722229,
1.1922645568847656,
-0.7850161194801331,
0.41946572065353394,
0.4502331614494324,
0.6901546120643616,
0.22215203940868378,
0.018119443207979202,
0.6422804594039917,
-0.4186781048774719,
-0.3331892788410187,
0.3400989770889282,
0.24981078505516052,
-0.06741016358137131,
-0.49670132994651794,
0.3454555869102478,
0.3565177321434021,
-0.5815341472625732,
-0.32508283853530884,
0.4408944845199585,
-1.3569613695144653,
-0.13016767799854279,
0.8352857828140259,
-0.39942067861557007,
0.06701512634754181,
-0.6186137199401855,
-0.2851957082748413,
-0.16033565998077393,
-0.34471839666366577,
1.0444438457489014,
0.44637754559516907,
-0.33204880356788635,
0.04134673997759819,
-0.13961012661457062,
0.6543043851852417,
0.7949504852294922,
-0.22950676083564758,
0.2942456603050232,
0.462321400642395,
0.34643417596817017,
0.26013603806495667,
0.9459354281425476,
-0.038680050522089005,
0.6350527405738831,
-0.37870413064956665,
-0.45984771847724915,
0.2649388909339905,
-0.8371317982673645,
-0.29984092712402344,
0.20861931145191193,
-0.10885370522737503,
-0.03819004073739052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14880v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14880v1
|
Automatic Histograms: Leveraging Language Models for Text Dataset Exploration
| 2024-02-21T22:29:16 | 2024-02-21T22:29:16 |
Emily Reif, Crystal Qian, James Wexler, Minsuk Kahng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Making sense of unstructured text datasets is perennially difficult, yet
increasingly relevant with Large Language Models. Data workers often rely on
dataset summaries, especially distributions of various derived features. Some
features, like toxicity or topics, are relevant to many datasets, but many
interesting features are domain specific: instruments and genres for a music
dataset, or diseases and symptoms for a medical dataset. Accordingly, data
workers often run custom analyses for each dataset, which is cumbersome and
difficult. We present AutoHistograms, a visualization tool leveragingLLMs.
AutoHistograms automatically identifies relevant features, visualizes them with
histograms, and allows the user to interactively query the dataset for
categories of entities and create new histograms. In a user study with 10 data
workers (n=10), we observe that participants can quickly identify insights and
explore the data using AutoHistograms, and conceptualize a broad range of
applicable use cases. Together, this tool and user study contributeto the
growing field of LLM-assisted sensemaking tools.
|
[
-0.21758082509040833,
-0.4645114243030548,
0.757174015045166,
0.06569679081439972,
-0.22218073904514313,
0.11741232126951218,
-0.11747755855321884,
-0.40476515889167786,
0.34504303336143494,
0.8120328187942505,
-0.521388053894043,
-0.8845832347869873,
-0.5554952025413513,
0.2801036536693573,
-0.8066735863685608,
0.9518657922744751,
0.0367262177169323,
-0.3561781048774719,
-0.37029415369033813,
-0.19758155941963196,
-0.556937575340271,
-0.37384259700775146,
-0.31546375155448914,
-0.32844480872154236,
0.46640583872795105,
0.5099242329597473,
0.6493263244628906,
0.959926962852478,
0.5978527665138245,
0.3609723746776581,
0.171002596616745,
-0.07533998042345047,
-0.4203406572341919,
0.5809251666069031,
-0.10929112881422043,
-0.44271302223205566,
-0.12572041153907776,
-0.0640295147895813,
0.1045006513595581,
0.9283403754234314,
-0.08541485667228699,
0.19639551639556885,
-0.1246786043047905,
0.5456336140632629,
-0.18885701894760132,
0.34335950016975403,
-0.5997911691665649,
0.2520710527896881,
-0.4069948196411133,
-0.4511726498603821,
-0.012442492879927158,
-0.30059337615966797,
0.4217045307159424,
-0.7291653156280518,
-0.005975502077490091,
0.2918287515640259,
0.6018460392951965,
0.6460703611373901,
-0.641530454158783,
-0.5860694050788879,
-0.3690811097621918,
0.6677613854408264,
-0.46227702498435974,
0.2371084839105606,
0.5413327217102051,
0.6593099236488342,
-0.11576507985591888,
-0.8472325801849365,
-0.20124907791614532,
-0.02881069853901863,
-0.4216339886188507,
0.08672236651182175,
-0.38751325011253357,
-0.29076164960861206,
0.20260576903820038,
0.5664036273956299,
-0.5877694487571716,
0.11905307322740555,
-0.20333229005336761,
-0.27343466877937317,
0.8621342182159424,
0.7410866618156433,
0.558992326259613,
-0.4397217333316803,
-0.19518521428108215,
-0.10943610221147537,
-0.5588328838348389,
-0.2589152455329895,
0.2687840759754181,
0.1480531245470047,
-0.14824360609054565,
0.746914267539978,
-0.21169744431972504,
0.8969592452049255,
-0.43161267042160034,
-0.074875608086586,
0.38343507051467896,
-0.32130351662635803,
-0.39312076568603516,
-0.040055934339761734,
0.8039886355400085,
0.2630661129951477,
0.4683959484100342,
-0.12277121841907501,
-0.2805144786834717,
-0.262447327375412,
0.09662389755249023,
-0.6385035514831543,
-0.7170827388763428,
0.3656025230884552,
-0.6580551862716675,
-0.43417608737945557,
-0.2758863866329193,
-0.8275851011276245,
-0.8138542771339417,
-0.5394299030303955,
0.15420541167259216,
-0.35022759437561035,
-0.25011610984802246,
-0.030156193301081657,
-0.3260009288787842,
-0.2134377360343933,
0.3508134186267853,
-0.7353591322898865,
0.15627364814281464,
0.21061623096466064,
0.7489709258079529,
-0.4301266670227051,
-0.19553083181381226,
-0.15814098715782166,
0.2306104600429535,
-0.20194049179553986,
1.0246812105178833,
-0.7219212055206299,
-0.7369977235794067,
-0.1526177078485489,
0.05500539392232895,
0.031382035464048386,
-0.4962427616119385,
0.13639160990715027,
-0.2813938856124878,
0.37511879205703735,
-0.3373873829841614,
-0.8034112453460693,
-0.19988858699798584,
0.18805572390556335,
-0.7681148052215576,
1.1555063724517822,
0.1422739028930664,
-0.8053707480430603,
0.5496025085449219,
-0.8452166318893433,
-0.455363005399704,
0.06845158338546753,
-0.5948696136474609,
-0.1446532905101776,
0.027213556692004204,
0.2786136269569397,
0.603894054889679,
-0.36967477202415466,
0.19773489236831665,
-0.23057802021503448,
-0.08897122740745544,
0.2215447723865509,
-0.18847475945949554,
0.9834745526313782,
0.4260612428188324,
-0.0922798365354538,
0.1766078919172287,
-0.5341469645500183,
-0.24119184911251068,
0.3554723858833313,
-0.19184647500514984,
-0.6372096538543701,
0.2389138787984848,
0.3699701726436615,
-0.008071454241871834,
0.042090728878974915,
-0.08686412870883942,
0.3255498707294464,
-0.38931578397750854,
0.19163213670253754,
0.47221821546554565,
0.24589131772518158,
0.27534201741218567,
-0.0646962821483612,
0.595452606678009,
0.0835222601890564,
-0.024289121851325035,
-0.7124237418174744,
-0.5803906917572021,
-0.3326532542705536,
-0.3758859634399414,
0.18359880149364471,
0.5525458455085754,
-0.714123010635376,
0.6711869835853577,
-0.15023961663246155,
-0.3750428855419159,
-0.39408114552497864,
0.23193025588989258,
-0.1127782091498375,
0.5969038009643555,
0.33287879824638367,
-0.24092994630336761,
-0.4666445851325989,
-0.8329693675041199,
-0.3304728865623474,
-0.011452334001660347,
-0.33319520950317383,
0.45385757088661194,
0.6044159531593323,
-0.4797512888908386,
1.3723795413970947,
-0.9224185943603516,
-0.5279765129089355,
-0.3636455535888672,
0.3529492914676666,
0.14633631706237793,
0.27189701795578003,
0.6541656255722046,
-0.6968836188316345,
-0.49670931696891785,
0.06373468041419983,
-1.0605846643447876,
-0.5280755758285522,
-0.18701499700546265,
-0.04995227977633476,
-0.0701511800289154,
0.722663938999176,
0.06331732124090195,
0.34126797318458557,
0.344692587852478,
-0.5659999847412109,
0.1153983473777771,
-0.20267967879772186,
0.014960267581045628,
-1.1361650228500366,
0.3099469244480133,
0.006564009003341198,
-0.27464190125465393,
-0.456114262342453,
-0.40536168217658997,
-0.09556456655263901,
-0.1996542364358902,
0.011439184658229351,
0.6263439059257507,
-0.5246009230613708,
-0.3095822036266327,
-0.3127294182777405,
0.1940280646085739,
0.05822367966175079,
0.09828875213861465,
0.1123339831829071,
0.5434342622756958,
0.6921470761299133,
-0.26300036907196045,
0.4655934274196625,
0.3931328356266022,
-0.28610944747924805,
0.48222437500953674,
-0.49305498600006104,
-0.04232693091034889,
-0.07375551015138626,
0.08232943713665009,
-0.8564311861991882,
-0.48007696866989136,
0.09117566049098969,
-0.2653069794178009,
0.10091252624988556,
-0.15117307007312775,
-0.759242832660675,
-0.24540092051029205,
-0.1989927440881729,
0.0466703437268734,
0.30971965193748474,
-0.5280478596687317,
0.5097458958625793,
0.9333611130714417,
-0.07322800159454346,
-0.3349701464176178,
-0.7403013110160828,
0.5645403861999512,
-0.49450185894966125,
-0.5548374056816101,
0.11150708049535751,
-0.015501494519412518,
-0.4733070731163025,
0.19723466038703918,
0.018533162772655487,
-0.17322073876857758,
0.26690351963043213,
0.2945994436740875,
0.048749472945928574,
0.22082041203975677,
0.3385823667049408,
0.17813755571842194,
-0.34714561700820923,
-0.009872008115053177,
-0.011514010839164257,
0.3451022505760193,
0.10173974186182022,
-0.3253510296344757,
-0.23404495418071747,
0.32921165227890015,
0.3239276111125946,
-0.19966775178909302,
0.12483680993318558,
0.5411856174468994,
-0.41764095425605774,
-0.22869239747524261,
-0.22796933352947235,
-0.135030135512352,
-0.467232882976532,
0.1108044907450676,
-0.37106427550315857,
-0.6139069199562073,
0.5683516263961792,
-0.22563442587852478,
0.13393959403038025,
0.43706098198890686,
0.725456714630127,
-0.3855716586112976,
1.1364703178405762,
0.8203316330909729,
-0.2545967996120453,
0.35813337564468384,
-0.3291592597961426,
-0.023283665999770164,
-0.47317197918891907,
-0.07653497904539108,
-0.5667421221733093,
-0.22125104069709778,
-0.6085209250450134,
-0.22812601923942566,
0.46866682171821594,
-0.5909781455993652,
0.24373885989189148,
0.20918923616409302,
-0.4738459587097168,
0.6507431268692017,
0.4105028212070465,
-0.2699328660964966,
0.5664047002792358,
0.059757500886917114,
-0.05650358647108078,
-0.20616063475608826,
-0.6732655167579651,
-0.5330030918121338,
1.2012667655944824,
0.23587340116500854,
0.9502999782562256,
-0.21073272824287415,
0.842003583908081,
0.5292479991912842,
0.47230634093284607,
-0.8900549411773682,
0.3156934380531311,
-0.2130698263645172,
-0.5910515189170837,
-0.4645674526691437,
-0.4236436188220978,
-1.209574818611145,
0.14683543145656586,
-0.3035851716995239,
-0.5612120032310486,
0.41592836380004883,
0.2859152555465698,
-0.07649475336074829,
0.09158632904291153,
-0.720681369304657,
0.8625276684761047,
-0.25079581141471863,
0.016270581632852554,
0.02366991899907589,
-0.573205292224884,
0.12714926898479462,
-0.18473930656909943,
0.4059506952762604,
-0.29927343130111694,
-0.02668588049709797,
0.7379018068313599,
-0.3444865643978119,
0.8687912225723267,
-0.15542170405387878,
-0.2770642340183258,
0.1305919736623764,
0.28915485739707947,
0.26939308643341064,
-0.08961696922779083,
-0.01029972918331623,
0.07920868694782257,
0.09408146142959595,
-0.15341170132160187,
-0.47592222690582275,
0.683530330657959,
-0.2939620316028595,
-0.4225641191005707,
-0.36211371421813965,
-0.6960070133209229,
-0.19753429293632507,
0.2787480056285858,
0.18211302161216736,
0.35068193078041077,
-0.16462019085884094,
0.09509480744600296,
0.4910540282726288,
-0.39292851090431213,
0.37588679790496826,
0.23772412538528442,
-0.36245831847190857,
0.009660272859036922,
0.9125787615776062,
0.1424931287765503,
-0.22455011308193207,
0.010496689938008785,
0.37703797221183777,
-0.3652982711791992,
-0.5542029142379761,
-0.6319761276245117,
-0.06139608845114708,
-0.7856317758560181,
-0.37674427032470703,
-0.6014233231544495,
0.30315786600112915,
-0.015794051811099052,
-0.1406606137752533,
0.1261831670999527,
-0.3654462993144989,
-0.12767164409160614,
-0.0731351301074028,
0.7999404072761536,
0.7709553837776184,
-0.06534747779369354,
0.2963867485523224,
-0.701148271560669,
0.33058691024780273,
0.29097723960876465,
0.40698903799057007,
-0.16509051620960236,
-0.12250351160764694,
-0.426529198884964,
-0.35112547874450684,
0.1202198714017868,
-1.2060608863830566,
0.6823852062225342,
0.05365701764822006,
0.5755038261413574,
0.558262050151825,
-0.1586785465478897,
0.42117583751678467,
-0.3022240400314331,
0.45879971981048584,
-0.18228541314601898,
-0.8689219355583191,
0.7221137881278992,
-0.5746673941612244,
0.20839037001132965,
0.6360270977020264,
0.405241459608078,
-0.7126366496086121,
-0.5798085331916809,
-0.33562105894088745,
-0.9048951864242554,
0.6446079015731812,
0.38097307085990906,
0.011695867404341698,
0.16495953500270844,
0.16991792619228363,
0.324824720621109,
0.25090208649635315,
-0.40892064571380615,
-0.4496115446090698,
-0.5051579475402832,
-0.7921565175056458,
-0.11434032768011093,
0.0815281867980957,
-0.3669770658016205,
-0.2009318619966507,
0.1389496922492981,
-0.3978157937526703,
-0.019521385431289673,
0.08601166307926178,
-0.6108604073524475,
-0.04701559618115425,
-0.11029447615146637,
-0.04168382287025452,
0.6055265665054321,
-0.1605062484741211,
0.27689602971076965,
0.05723090097308159,
-0.5169958472251892,
-0.18492300808429718,
0.15992803871631622,
0.0708402767777443,
0.04325568303465843,
0.46029919385910034,
0.6010046601295471,
0.1250191628932953,
-0.8707855343818665,
0.3667556643486023,
-0.09531886875629425,
0.026770228520035744,
-0.23704195022583008,
0.259011447429657,
0.3012138307094574,
0.13147859275341034,
0.3252469003200531,
-0.4719717502593994,
0.6738981604576111,
-0.4669727385044098,
0.309851735830307,
0.2158764898777008,
-0.2004188448190689,
-0.04822543263435364,
0.6033391356468201,
0.23969708383083344,
-0.03135126084089279,
0.5398216247558594,
0.1118491068482399,
-0.12143827974796295,
0.8154301643371582,
0.22774727642536163,
0.7011758685112,
0.03588038682937622,
-0.014524848200380802,
0.0032932641915977,
0.3973582684993744,
0.21825814247131348,
0.18683496117591858,
0.0041313087567687035,
-0.5882367491722107,
-0.36117467284202576,
-0.3584299683570862,
-0.48712876439094543,
-0.022243088111281395,
-0.595043420791626,
0.10514191538095474,
0.03276298940181732,
-0.00045282734208740294,
0.17920421063899994,
-0.17256055772304535,
-0.7864028811454773,
0.38551098108291626,
0.03622473031282425,
0.8843337297439575,
-1.0475044250488281,
0.8941145539283752,
0.6395742893218994,
-0.3126612901687622,
-0.10449827462434769,
0.012788263149559498,
0.3795545995235443,
-0.9407337307929993,
0.5981205105781555,
-0.06603691726922989,
0.20888346433639526,
0.1093701720237732,
-0.5277411341667175,
-0.8730775117874146,
1.262493371963501,
0.007034198381006718,
-0.5755974054336548,
0.28343069553375244,
0.20113670825958252,
0.6353176832199097,
-0.4544770419597626,
0.17415493726730347,
0.871034562587738,
0.8033232092857361,
-0.25518685579299927,
-0.5385410189628601,
0.09543681889772415,
-0.24396511912345886,
-0.11885125935077667,
0.28996986150741577,
-0.04303913190960884,
0.42577776312828064,
-0.1610298901796341,
-0.23797908425331116,
-0.5294076800346375,
0.4844827353954315,
-0.030402032658457756,
0.5321191549301147,
0.7705703973770142,
0.37667304277420044,
0.8954697251319885,
-0.06265757977962494,
0.9515221118927002,
-0.4170691668987274,
0.4089251756668091,
1.077129602432251,
-0.31655994057655334,
0.3463776111602783,
0.389453262090683,
0.0013877670280635357,
0.29071319103240967,
0.853486180305481,
-0.4218308627605438,
0.32972872257232666,
0.3306841552257538,
-0.015797775238752365,
-0.20851880311965942,
0.11128681153059006,
-0.16559217870235443,
0.6354535818099976,
0.7443961501121521,
-0.3451586067676544,
-0.6145989894866943,
0.19516964256763458,
-0.024567585438489914,
0.061234939843416214,
0.04706786572933197,
0.9178240299224854,
0.02424262836575508,
0.028414424508810043,
0.19972184300422668,
-0.19552883505821228,
0.5317497253417969,
-0.4124043583869934,
-0.10373435169458389,
-0.3545216917991638,
-0.5263707637786865,
-0.31743019819259644,
-0.9915571212768555,
0.6834788918495178,
0.22890305519104004,
0.013349338434636593,
-0.28406083583831787,
0.9726584553718567,
-0.3521950840950012,
-0.4158683121204376,
0.34460869431495667,
0.9625874161720276,
0.36377498507499695,
-0.047689322382211685,
-0.7663874626159668,
-0.11242091655731201,
0.012394887395203114,
-0.486158549785614,
0.13139799237251282,
0.5521584153175354,
-0.27389365434646606,
0.8147730231285095,
0.5801330208778381,
-0.06268161535263062,
-0.20525924861431122,
0.29320740699768066,
0.7482619881629944,
-0.9861946702003479,
-0.4588572382926941,
-0.7605241537094116,
0.4169805943965912,
-0.26567667722702026,
-0.12940001487731934,
0.7615667581558228,
0.6861463189125061,
0.47434625029563904,
0.11177393049001694,
1.1023626327514648,
-0.04955028370022774,
0.5843772888183594,
-0.5336447358131409,
1.0215997695922852,
-0.8129488825798035,
0.3125928044319153,
-0.008214108645915985,
-0.5423251986503601,
-0.4081382155418396,
0.4200213551521301,
-0.2710869014263153,
-0.12034846842288971,
0.5108590722084045,
0.5127599835395813,
-0.19277246296405792,
-0.1531243622303009,
0.22148634493350983,
0.3981741666793823,
0.3034707009792328,
-0.06033005937933922,
0.6735604405403137,
0.16409242153167725,
0.388686865568161,
-0.27470651268959045,
-0.1854075789451599,
-0.3878736197948456,
-0.9145523309707642,
-0.9643510580062866,
-0.7390780448913574,
-0.20460553467273712,
0.19267937541007996,
-0.19223423302173615,
0.747520387172699,
0.5026326775550842,
-0.7028312087059021,
-0.48991137742996216,
0.004660735838115215,
0.2714548707008362,
0.1725744605064392,
-0.27605488896369934,
0.6639511585235596,
-0.4900636672973633,
-0.7123329043388367,
0.6046075224876404,
0.4231243431568146,
0.20838883519172668,
-0.3117195963859558,
0.4193417429924011,
0.19495095312595367,
0.030727211385965347,
0.6025078892707825,
0.16205106675624847,
-0.19061030447483063,
0.025801241397857666,
-0.018516436219215393,
-0.022240322083234787,
0.18149065971374512,
1.0351264476776123,
-0.8785605430603027,
0.6600056886672974,
0.6577963829040527,
0.5124384164810181,
0.5695796608924866,
-0.22820721566677094,
0.7136616110801697,
-0.7096914052963257,
-0.037155818194150925,
0.06379199028015137,
0.4651910364627838,
0.3856275677680969,
-0.432494193315506,
0.6081722378730774,
0.13565419614315033,
-0.30335816740989685,
-0.9819902181625366,
0.0547107495367527,
-0.7911562323570251,
-0.5405210256576538,
0.8721497058868408,
0.19825708866119385,
-0.11071931570768356,
-0.5768232345581055,
-0.34663960337638855,
0.10996545106172562,
-0.31651797890663147,
0.9749799370765686,
0.5129642486572266,
-0.5586177110671997,
0.1467001885175705,
-0.9037651419639587,
0.7697097659111023,
0.21368125081062317,
-1.3819252252578735,
0.15662172436714172,
0.4943361282348633,
0.41153883934020996,
-0.08156269788742065,
0.5726572871208191,
-0.04456662759184837,
-0.15226109325885773,
-0.25111061334609985,
0.17575296759605408,
-0.019871851429343224,
-0.14167745411396027,
-0.45414096117019653,
-0.12441739439964294,
-0.15688644349575043,
0.05997374653816223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14154v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14154v1
|
MM-Soc: Benchmarking Multimodal Large Language Models in Social Media Platforms
| 2024-02-21T22:27:40 | 2024-02-21T22:27:40 |
Yiqiao Jin, Minje Choi, Gaurav Verma, Jindong Wang, Srijan Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.CY
|
Social media platforms are hubs for multimodal information exchange,
encompassing text, images, and videos, making it challenging for machines to
comprehend the information or emotions associated with interactions in online
spaces. Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have emerged as a promising
solution to address these challenges, yet struggle with accurately interpreting
human emotions and complex contents like misinformation. This paper introduces
MM-Soc, a comprehensive benchmark designed to evaluate MLLMs' understanding of
multimodal social media content. MM-Soc compiles prominent multimodal datasets
and incorporates a novel large-scale YouTube tagging dataset, targeting a range
of tasks from misinformation detection, hate speech detection, and social
context generation. Through our exhaustive evaluation on ten size-variants of
four open-source MLLMs, we have identified significant performance disparities,
highlighting the need for advancements in models' social understanding
capabilities. Our analysis reveals that, in a zero-shot setting, various types
of MLLMs generally exhibit difficulties in handling social media tasks.
However, MLLMs demonstrate performance improvements post fine-tuning,
suggesting potential pathways for improvement.
|
[
-0.5349414944648743,
-0.6008628606796265,
0.3931695222854614,
0.4026721715927124,
-0.3980371356010437,
0.5801755785942078,
-0.2949802875518799,
-0.23073969781398773,
0.24935534596443176,
0.07782988250255585,
-0.7215181589126587,
-0.5421378016471863,
-0.7501143217086792,
0.051033057272434235,
-0.2200731784105301,
0.7696466445922852,
0.1223357766866684,
0.3259560465812683,
-0.16345258057117462,
-0.340810626745224,
-0.1390884667634964,
-0.4839021563529968,
-0.4636158347129822,
0.08884000778198242,
0.7617819905281067,
0.15440824627876282,
0.6164365410804749,
0.3018779456615448,
0.6585715413093567,
0.25099796056747437,
0.11594808101654053,
0.6144200563430786,
-0.7147746086120605,
0.11280857026576996,
-0.2602916657924652,
-0.09125763922929764,
-0.43640708923339844,
0.04249254986643791,
0.9023634791374207,
0.3586452305316925,
0.30560076236724854,
0.5591284036636353,
-0.014097938314080238,
0.48127177357673645,
-0.9813231825828552,
0.08768529444932938,
-0.8148419857025146,
-0.12164656817913055,
-0.158645361661911,
-0.19206669926643372,
-0.4401249885559082,
-0.101129911839962,
-0.3430018126964569,
-0.19597680866718292,
0.0557006299495697,
-0.07357631623744965,
0.5612382292747498,
0.18518489599227905,
-0.5760443806648254,
-0.1999588906764984,
-0.6594886183738708,
0.8356001377105713,
-0.4648386836051941,
0.691769003868103,
0.26213181018829346,
0.5665442943572998,
0.06306387484073639,
-0.34298086166381836,
-0.5699518322944641,
-0.1162303164601326,
0.2321660965681076,
0.030373629182577133,
-0.22244618833065033,
-0.12149451673030853,
0.2266417145729065,
-0.037596989423036575,
-0.6843693852424622,
-0.09987126290798187,
-0.41140782833099365,
-0.24855665862560272,
0.6254599690437317,
0.12158691138029099,
0.27552369236946106,
-0.29551833868026733,
-0.3221478760242462,
0.004462978802621365,
-0.5673387050628662,
-0.0889899954199791,
0.3424951136112213,
0.3843970000743866,
-0.23586881160736084,
0.7912120819091797,
-0.19819961488246918,
0.4448227882385254,
-0.392841100692749,
-0.35197368264198303,
0.5652996301651001,
-0.47930043935775757,
-0.16121864318847656,
-0.18682803213596344,
0.9000066518783569,
0.7480154633522034,
0.39111754298210144,
-0.05095885694026947,
-0.12729737162590027,
0.48630109429359436,
0.0931491106748581,
-0.868882954120636,
0.05964662879705429,
0.06588315963745117,
-0.4969242811203003,
-0.1593601107597351,
-0.029981035739183426,
-0.8358773589134216,
-0.6201786994934082,
-0.3377997875213623,
0.4136207401752472,
-0.4170866012573242,
-0.4780426621437073,
-0.09000857919454575,
-0.3045988082885742,
0.041935697197914124,
0.20832371711730957,
-0.39236193895339966,
-0.013585253618657589,
0.8096901774406433,
1.2170239686965942,
0.05273588374257088,
-0.2779243290424347,
-0.8000565767288208,
0.1519899070262909,
-0.23035161197185516,
0.5821312665939331,
-0.7670804858207703,
-0.12531431019306183,
-0.03607511147856712,
0.0221245139837265,
-0.2686964273452759,
-0.21450604498386383,
0.4353141188621521,
-0.21953509747982025,
-0.44024407863616943,
-0.39607924222946167,
-0.32980191707611084,
0.23122118413448334,
0.5002956986427307,
-0.5667595863342285,
0.8101187944412231,
-0.06698119640350342,
-0.6568730473518372,
0.22045639157295227,
-0.554863452911377,
-0.2242167890071869,
-0.08759857714176178,
-0.13113383948802948,
-0.10686942934989929,
0.28445544838905334,
0.035721078515052795,
0.7123122215270996,
-0.3025897741317749,
0.23763340711593628,
-0.9592775702476501,
-0.29899612069129944,
0.48146331310272217,
-0.5374850630760193,
0.4967365264892578,
0.367278516292572,
-0.26925089955329895,
0.10287249088287354,
-0.8403224349021912,
-0.03413026034832001,
0.0020175697281956673,
0.0018417192623019218,
-0.3957782983779907,
0.1508644074201584,
0.11362742632627487,
0.6490297317504883,
0.23963071405887604,
-0.7784936428070068,
-0.22107219696044922,
0.21793517470359802,
0.6163290739059448,
0.8572777509689331,
-0.256939560174942,
0.11997389048337936,
-0.19338002800941467,
0.3213481605052948,
0.14311866462230682,
0.3507343828678131,
-0.21844245493412018,
-0.45127201080322266,
-0.35113298892974854,
-0.4884588420391083,
0.14605040848255157,
0.30384331941604614,
-1.00314199924469,
-0.11003720015287399,
-0.3409697711467743,
-0.7682865858078003,
-0.9180232286453247,
0.39445120096206665,
0.4463340640068054,
0.07851637899875641,
0.20379631221294403,
-0.187266543507576,
-0.49478867650032043,
-0.9746617078781128,
-0.17222589254379272,
-0.12653979659080505,
-0.006405222229659557,
0.4945507049560547,
0.5175905227661133,
-0.4918632209300995,
0.6380212903022766,
-0.15878236293792725,
0.007404239382594824,
-0.06947191804647446,
0.42467549443244934,
-0.44703200459480286,
0.10182604193687439,
0.6259220242500305,
-0.8774331212043762,
-0.6246045231819153,
0.02811889722943306,
-0.6022595763206482,
-0.23169171810150146,
0.1348443478345871,
-0.028108354657888412,
0.1325666308403015,
0.40476909279823303,
-0.6922808289527893,
0.08517731726169586,
0.9539544582366943,
-0.23829515278339386,
0.734941840171814,
0.021264947950839996,
0.4111754894256592,
-0.9755997657775879,
0.03798333927989006,
0.31213945150375366,
-0.29633572697639465,
-0.5022449493408203,
-0.06427493691444397,
0.3368680775165558,
-0.13466836512088776,
-0.6770564913749695,
0.4299331307411194,
-0.40747132897377014,
-0.2600274384021759,
-0.02875087596476078,
0.49536123871803284,
0.008045296184718609,
0.3727150559425354,
-0.2971827983856201,
0.6215622425079346,
0.40986618399620056,
-0.4644109904766083,
0.36255165934562683,
-0.3442199230194092,
-0.3531559407711029,
0.7324528098106384,
-0.4937955141067505,
0.03541621193289757,
-0.44360801577568054,
0.23612479865550995,
-1.2711644172668457,
-0.23709431290626526,
0.06946338713169098,
-0.679889440536499,
-0.07457088679075241,
-0.1393359750509262,
-0.9074930548667908,
-0.31526100635528564,
-0.6290913224220276,
0.3700730502605438,
0.027979839593172073,
-0.22254815697669983,
0.6087544560432434,
0.5930300951004028,
0.06400467455387115,
-0.5981793403625488,
-0.30728569626808167,
0.1435575783252716,
-0.0726371556520462,
-0.6106687188148499,
0.18292640149593353,
-0.40729615092277527,
-0.31967559456825256,
-0.022907618433237076,
0.19484777748584747,
0.006414908915758133,
0.0010671393247321248,
0.2640179991722107,
0.08067670464515686,
-0.3201863765716553,
0.4645800292491913,
-0.01026279479265213,
0.09717205166816711,
-0.08365799486637115,
0.29009971022605896,
0.931627631187439,
-0.2193007916212082,
-0.4710046052932739,
-0.24586088955402374,
0.2858577072620392,
1.0332783460617065,
-0.521246075630188,
0.8329107165336609,
1.1987892389297485,
-0.39931976795196533,
0.05958213284611702,
-0.7093214392662048,
0.05863301828503609,
-0.4006492495536804,
0.3816000819206238,
-0.37217283248901367,
-0.9123620390892029,
0.4517536163330078,
0.007436865009367466,
0.05615724250674248,
0.35948479175567627,
0.659509003162384,
-0.04874354973435402,
1.5009434223175049,
0.42850980162620544,
-0.2809009552001953,
0.43844082951545715,
0.13752594590187073,
0.052445508539676666,
-0.6173403859138489,
-0.088594451546669,
-0.5324549674987793,
-0.39015817642211914,
-0.6482926607131958,
-0.805454671382904,
0.20472727715969086,
-0.17989009618759155,
-0.2660526931285858,
0.25123441219329834,
-0.05348797142505646,
0.4399668574333191,
0.17266015708446503,
0.03259723633527756,
0.23162436485290527,
-0.18132726848125458,
-0.04836999624967575,
-0.06823074072599411,
-0.49784231185913086,
-0.5252552032470703,
0.9532693028450012,
0.5142467021942139,
0.657441258430481,
0.40494224429130554,
0.29608824849128723,
0.30565860867500305,
0.47421541810035706,
-0.6132055521011353,
0.542320191860199,
-0.4764493405818939,
-0.6258461475372314,
-0.019310077652335167,
-0.6137312054634094,
-0.5981548428535461,
0.5209296345710754,
-0.4337587058544159,
-0.659204363822937,
-0.1229688972234726,
0.11804769933223724,
-0.23675107955932617,
0.4239320755004883,
-0.8653519749641418,
0.9769094586372375,
-0.34955230355262756,
-0.44504401087760925,
-0.3353952169418335,
-0.6248067617416382,
0.37710878252983093,
-0.03758327662944794,
0.5771521329879761,
-0.5512840747833252,
-0.15258556604385376,
0.32007959485054016,
0.1909150332212448,
0.9571381211280823,
-0.2268052101135254,
0.18777115643024445,
0.09601306915283203,
0.010564799420535564,
0.1536954790353775,
-0.029799504205584526,
0.03639049082994461,
0.10861187428236008,
0.1595185250043869,
-0.30260154604911804,
-0.43857938051223755,
0.845999538898468,
-0.7111780643463135,
0.023701507598161697,
0.0028386800549924374,
-0.5378226637840271,
-0.3425193428993225,
-0.009027613326907158,
-0.063944511115551,
0.5397436618804932,
-0.38956788182258606,
0.7534888386726379,
0.7233854532241821,
-0.25737839937210083,
0.4106104075908661,
0.5901882648468018,
-0.3307551443576813,
-0.362623393535614,
1.0637218952178955,
0.10062503814697266,
0.3878406584262848,
0.4048534333705902,
0.009543468244373798,
-0.33458244800567627,
-0.13254906237125397,
-0.6546770930290222,
0.30908986926078796,
-0.5570850968360901,
-0.2520763576030731,
-1.0088427066802979,
-0.17039576172828674,
-0.5955080986022949,
0.05189042165875435,
-0.6395732760429382,
-0.10208088904619217,
-0.03457261249423027,
0.11703133583068848,
0.08889055997133255,
0.5206508040428162,
-0.11881759017705917,
0.3779689371585846,
-0.9305567741394043,
0.3282567262649536,
0.13609208166599274,
0.615646481513977,
0.04438285902142525,
-0.24071307480335236,
-0.19272270798683167,
0.3000553250312805,
-0.2542724013328552,
-0.9290280938148499,
0.21838101744651794,
0.22529730200767517,
0.49642452597618103,
0.5642005801200867,
-0.16062718629837036,
0.7332092523574829,
-0.5488644242286682,
0.5845149755477905,
0.26231953501701355,
-0.8740862011909485,
0.29805055260658264,
-0.4131774604320526,
0.38306954503059387,
0.44956067204475403,
0.6585626602172852,
-0.7360528111457825,
-0.3132120668888092,
-0.3015953302383423,
-0.5491989254951477,
0.2480696737766266,
0.23686224222183228,
0.2802600860595703,
-0.23663949966430664,
-0.14971177279949188,
-0.07784805446863174,
0.49252405762672424,
-0.8415144085884094,
-0.0626332014799118,
-0.14934392273426056,
-0.26878902316093445,
-0.6168755292892456,
-0.2613752484321594,
0.0492975115776062,
-0.12422250956296921,
0.584919810295105,
-0.15229690074920654,
0.11943264305591583,
-0.17854449152946472,
-0.4550277590751648,
-0.1998572200536728,
0.23553793132305145,
0.8737340569496155,
0.7840965986251831,
-0.40732893347740173,
0.39056602120399475,
-0.07173692435026169,
-0.2890069782733917,
-0.14673419296741486,
0.007750667165964842,
0.22981809079647064,
0.28623148798942566,
0.0717146024107933,
0.6646713614463806,
0.3715801239013672,
-1.0771206617355347,
0.6074828505516052,
-0.1909944713115692,
-0.1561046987771988,
0.008215821348130703,
-0.16902300715446472,
0.2691134214401245,
0.38656917214393616,
0.2331177294254303,
0.006117096170783043,
0.09344515949487686,
-0.878113865852356,
0.09121885895729065,
0.7297454476356506,
-0.5926085710525513,
-0.4099748134613037,
0.3444099426269531,
0.0768592581152916,
-0.3265266716480255,
-0.054504942148923874,
-0.304872065782547,
-0.44500732421875,
0.40762200951576233,
0.35379037261009216,
0.7058610320091248,
-0.31780022382736206,
0.6567630767822266,
0.3010157644748688,
0.5968942642211914,
0.10154709964990616,
0.12614229321479797,
-0.056908439844846725,
-0.7354332208633423,
-0.5002826452255249,
-0.6943431496620178,
-0.3556655943393707,
0.19592802226543427,
-0.41653189063072205,
0.2434874027967453,
-0.49288657307624817,
-0.37767940759658813,
0.5043764710426331,
-0.15419550240039825,
-0.7564598917961121,
0.07442572712898254,
0.28793570399284363,
0.7168954610824585,
-0.952539324760437,
0.5610869526863098,
0.6399210691452026,
-0.16185222566127777,
-0.3064465820789337,
-0.36254531145095825,
0.39226722717285156,
-0.6162885427474976,
0.44129490852355957,
0.4239174723625183,
-0.5022640824317932,
-0.3303465247154236,
-0.6113265156745911,
-0.657444417476654,
0.8631356954574585,
0.35926032066345215,
-0.5307456851005554,
0.29890239238739014,
0.36835750937461853,
0.7873273491859436,
-0.6419556736946106,
0.30486947298049927,
0.2434486597776413,
0.20000463724136353,
0.06924974918365479,
-0.951047420501709,
-0.2815900444984436,
-0.44056230783462524,
-0.08729535341262817,
0.36667028069496155,
-0.800345242023468,
1.0019540786743164,
0.18250428140163422,
-0.13085731863975525,
-0.23395304381847382,
0.1912040114402771,
0.3288211226463318,
0.7807209491729736,
0.6199815273284912,
0.28964728116989136,
0.5701283812522888,
0.08364477008581161,
0.6767944693565369,
-0.37010085582733154,
0.3169757127761841,
1.0927166938781738,
-0.42518579959869385,
1.1390684843063354,
0.2707553803920746,
0.04775720834732056,
0.3028038740158081,
0.5349453091621399,
0.1548616886138916,
0.24407820403575897,
0.06850872933864594,
-0.3361555337905884,
-0.4208270013332367,
-0.3345719873905182,
-0.4027230143547058,
0.6815624833106995,
0.5441312193870544,
-0.5230194330215454,
-0.3122767508029938,
0.08935372531414032,
-0.11221562325954437,
-0.08693819493055344,
-0.5446749329566956,
0.6467248201370239,
-0.04956510290503502,
-0.39059385657310486,
0.23548181354999542,
0.06868226826190948,
0.7050265073776245,
-0.6326307058334351,
0.17290262877941132,
0.09193859249353409,
0.1839209645986557,
0.029895827174186707,
-0.6630438566207886,
0.2966594099998474,
0.21545517444610596,
-0.24692048132419586,
-0.09369230270385742,
1.0019752979278564,
-0.45845267176628113,
-0.598933756351471,
0.5157709717750549,
0.6722970008850098,
0.1289529949426651,
-0.3825802505016327,
-0.8819541931152344,
0.42895597219467163,
-0.1258665919303894,
0.2285909205675125,
0.42041170597076416,
0.6047842502593994,
0.050531305372714996,
0.7635329961776733,
0.6495416164398193,
-0.1882765144109726,
0.1853439211845398,
0.29819679260253906,
0.87734055519104,
-0.42943519353866577,
-0.20002155005931854,
-1.2093299627304077,
0.46678799390792847,
-0.4155493974685669,
-0.2414398342370987,
0.7951386570930481,
0.6538280248641968,
0.8426196575164795,
-0.008417965844273567,
0.6975587010383606,
0.03731946274638176,
0.6193811893463135,
-0.17887860536575317,
0.7214196920394897,
-0.8747003674507141,
-0.1384761929512024,
-0.6962239146232605,
-0.8342670798301697,
-0.08182848989963531,
0.39937734603881836,
-0.1968209594488144,
-0.11619805544614792,
0.27903831005096436,
0.9533624053001404,
-0.2558654844760895,
-0.02198076620697975,
0.5575308799743652,
0.16870072484016418,
0.2304924875497818,
0.2647494971752167,
0.8741394281387329,
-0.148130401968956,
0.6692265868186951,
-0.29050034284591675,
-0.28673654794692993,
-0.3097572326660156,
-0.8196393847465515,
-1.1292139291763306,
-0.7616572380065918,
-0.06746629625558853,
-0.38964158296585083,
0.1366051435470581,
1.1465388536453247,
0.7416453957557678,
-0.4727340340614319,
-0.25056761503219604,
0.6042167544364929,
0.20013749599456787,
0.009463021531701088,
-0.19158978760242462,
-0.10194222629070282,
-0.17245449125766754,
-0.557450532913208,
0.08218887448310852,
0.6340301036834717,
-0.15574286878108978,
-0.5289559364318848,
-0.03420276194810867,
-0.3968193233013153,
0.21499955654144287,
1.2045525312423706,
-0.020953062921762466,
-0.5512246489524841,
-0.22401626408100128,
0.17264489829540253,
-0.1912366896867752,
-0.06610077619552612,
0.7830549478530884,
-0.15368075668811798,
0.6484106779098511,
0.44495728611946106,
0.7117881178855896,
0.3879106342792511,
-0.06468547880649567,
0.23662546277046204,
-0.8087014555931091,
-0.058458611369132996,
0.01652897521853447,
0.3757205009460449,
0.5161841511726379,
0.10368378460407257,
0.32005003094673157,
0.3306455910205841,
-0.4258468747138977,
-1.068086862564087,
0.11184357106685638,
-1.0103055238723755,
-0.3431926369667053,
1.1783324480056763,
-0.0036004383582621813,
-0.254072368144989,
-0.0017773436848074198,
-0.12430399656295776,
0.18491411209106445,
-0.4337749481201172,
0.8257135152816772,
0.9204185605049133,
0.46840324997901917,
-0.42097795009613037,
-0.9870783686637878,
0.14400596916675568,
0.14122258126735687,
-0.5822418332099915,
0.12225255370140076,
0.6121330261230469,
0.16407109797000885,
0.2556963860988617,
0.7170736789703369,
0.048532385379076004,
0.21144355833530426,
-0.06441237777471542,
-0.1649421900510788,
0.1958654820919037,
-0.5109113454818726,
0.05105918273329735,
0.31704503297805786,
-0.3404884338378906,
-0.1348792314529419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14151v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14151v2
|
BIRCO: A Benchmark of Information Retrieval Tasks with Complex Objectives
| 2024-02-21T22:22:30 | 2024-04-03T20:11:02 |
Xiaoyue Wang, Jianyou Wang, Weili Cao, Kaicheng Wang, Ramamohan Paturi, Leon Bergen
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present the Benchmark of Information Retrieval (IR) tasks with Complex
Objectives (BIRCO). BIRCO evaluates the ability of IR systems to retrieve
documents given multi-faceted user objectives. The benchmark's complexity and
compact size make it suitable for evaluating large language model (LLM)-based
information retrieval systems. We present a modular framework for investigating
factors that may influence LLM performance on retrieval tasks, and identify a
simple baseline model which matches or outperforms existing approaches and more
complex alternatives. No approach achieves satisfactory performance on all
benchmark tasks, suggesting that stronger models and new retrieval protocols
are necessary to address complex user needs.
|
[
-0.20196039974689484,
-0.5671956539154053,
0.5409781336784363,
0.5059044361114502,
-0.04625096917152405,
0.37669146060943604,
-0.2874758541584015,
-0.5252404808998108,
-0.22439374029636383,
0.29519033432006836,
-0.2635020315647125,
-0.4158199429512024,
-0.6141282916069031,
0.17476436495780945,
-0.48740628361701965,
0.9280015230178833,
-0.042742032557725906,
0.23968061804771423,
-0.11043115705251694,
-0.03068768046796322,
-0.5669835805892944,
-0.4735066294670105,
-0.3954644501209259,
-0.5391122698783875,
1.003662109375,
0.7391760349273682,
0.46899986267089844,
0.38280975818634033,
1.1829386949539185,
0.20151305198669434,
-0.16837987303733826,
0.12330795079469681,
-0.683283805847168,
0.33708468079566956,
-0.4423447251319885,
-0.5265148878097534,
-0.36572813987731934,
-0.10990621894598007,
0.736379086971283,
1.0389447212219238,
-0.4654989540576935,
0.34245097637176514,
-0.04727616161108017,
0.7709860801696777,
-0.9906376004219055,
-0.1523974984884262,
-0.46185168623924255,
-0.03460748866200447,
-0.31590068340301514,
-0.36645379662513733,
-0.4760933518409729,
-0.3639126121997833,
0.15627676248550415,
-0.26396915316581726,
0.14958804845809937,
0.7042290568351746,
0.8338676691055298,
-0.01104060746729374,
-0.6602917313575745,
-0.6112797856330872,
-1.0831115245819092,
0.8210507035255432,
-0.24467676877975464,
0.5012800693511963,
0.4051668345928192,
0.586805522441864,
-0.1627976894378662,
-0.9527234435081482,
-0.4824438989162445,
-0.20351116359233856,
-0.0685807317495346,
0.0308846402913332,
-0.44297677278518677,
0.10258413851261139,
0.37329792976379395,
0.3616040349006653,
-0.635777473449707,
-0.27663761377334595,
-0.4770619571208954,
0.0967579334974289,
0.15439841151237488,
0.4777718186378479,
0.06138220429420471,
-0.25298911333084106,
-0.7570653557777405,
-0.11906983703374863,
-0.6910379528999329,
0.08938921988010406,
0.5213828086853027,
0.357247531414032,
0.0879039615392685,
0.8857982754707336,
-0.6489855051040649,
0.7089605331420898,
-0.14464162290096283,
-0.10390587896108627,
0.18095779418945312,
-0.4581528604030609,
-0.13884830474853516,
-0.07989734411239624,
0.3615950047969818,
0.22301776707172394,
-0.14000071585178375,
-0.6809782385826111,
-0.5494222044944763,
-0.3626689314842224,
0.2237258106470108,
-0.9580251574516296,
0.10145838558673859,
0.06907741725444794,
-0.637182354927063,
0.2596438527107239,
0.3269520103931427,
-0.7053098678588867,
-0.002668794710189104,
-0.5263055562973022,
0.7329856753349304,
-0.3845253884792328,
0.12325070053339005,
0.16943469643592834,
-0.22206167876720428,
0.31806403398513794,
0.09440668672323227,
-0.4792344868183136,
0.6223451495170593,
0.8195798397064209,
0.7668083310127258,
-0.2606176733970642,
-0.2940690815448761,
-0.9103479981422424,
0.32912465929985046,
-0.06153954565525055,
1.245285987854004,
-0.7855581641197205,
-0.33627447485923767,
-0.07077739387750626,
-0.010965942405164242,
0.05127205699682236,
-0.8155572414398193,
0.7053460478782654,
-0.7662032246589661,
0.023376142606139183,
-0.6438999772071838,
-0.17225098609924316,
-0.20192395150661469,
0.42546871304512024,
-0.5844880938529968,
1.1077102422714233,
0.2906395494937897,
-0.5271218419075012,
0.21578551828861237,
-0.3739219605922699,
-0.5025695562362671,
0.17400063574314117,
0.010417609475553036,
-0.13975293934345245,
0.0015244950773194432,
-0.7311436533927917,
0.21045395731925964,
-1.2271747589111328,
0.27642399072647095,
-0.28191477060317993,
-0.5251215696334839,
0.11689463257789612,
0.09424496442079544,
0.4165572226047516,
0.4377742409706116,
-0.2997390329837799,
-0.12664979696273804,
-0.6778454184532166,
0.29310300946235657,
-0.3211357891559601,
-0.8851907849311829,
-0.42504531145095825,
0.2687327563762665,
0.2818090319633484,
-0.03365471586585045,
0.7148213982582092,
-0.5836700797080994,
0.24256788194179535,
0.27253270149230957,
0.09022987633943558,
0.30065879225730896,
-0.24999763071537018,
0.20378156006336212,
-0.403184711933136,
0.3431887626647949,
-0.15374378859996796,
0.23406392335891724,
0.2602095603942871,
0.08471373468637466,
-0.7089315056800842,
-0.5605292320251465,
0.5539169311523438,
0.671125590801239,
-0.28118574619293213,
0.3360639214515686,
-0.31394901871681213,
-0.6457803845405579,
-0.17187708616256714,
0.31668031215667725,
0.8862570524215698,
0.3581470847129822,
0.38802480697631836,
-0.5765537023544312,
-0.5354475378990173,
-1.3669893741607666,
-0.3752933442592621,
-0.0432136207818985,
-0.10439417511224747,
0.3561062812805176,
0.6040714383125305,
-0.5114840865135193,
0.47984209656715393,
-0.33716773986816406,
-0.48249441385269165,
-0.28114742040634155,
0.7274357080459595,
0.32778170704841614,
0.18033890426158905,
0.2807258367538452,
-1.0911908149719238,
-0.4897995889186859,
0.27574422955513,
-0.6219057440757751,
-0.24468432366847992,
0.34950342774391174,
-0.1701778620481491,
-0.2829960882663727,
0.38618001341819763,
-0.5250590443611145,
0.42729195952415466,
0.27204933762550354,
-0.3517950177192688,
0.5202998518943787,
-0.38832470774650574,
0.49047625064849854,
-0.659308910369873,
0.839017391204834,
-0.2763737440109253,
-0.21719525754451752,
-0.5420820116996765,
0.04252541437745094,
0.31037968397140503,
-0.04961538687348366,
0.056123487651348114,
0.31307438015937805,
-0.7730829119682312,
-0.6760198473930359,
-0.23681339621543884,
0.23021094501018524,
0.13693200051784515,
0.36665183305740356,
-0.2129487842321396,
0.6824262738227844,
0.15749545395374298,
-0.6537020802497864,
0.2715674936771393,
0.10006576031446457,
-0.6961323618888855,
1.029833436012268,
-0.8855320811271667,
0.11184385418891907,
-0.33548039197921753,
-0.15348507463932037,
-1.1507961750030518,
-0.23313689231872559,
-0.30187249183654785,
-0.1885623335838318,
0.3717360496520996,
-0.18759135901927948,
-0.8482211232185364,
-0.09659218043088913,
-0.11462188512086868,
0.5279014110565186,
0.04844927415251732,
-0.20257999002933502,
0.8512843251228333,
0.31626251339912415,
-0.35990092158317566,
-0.7742096781730652,
-0.3615332543849945,
0.3344550132751465,
-0.04225391149520874,
-0.3013027012348175,
0.663000762462616,
-0.24394847452640533,
-0.3777642846107483,
0.11717725545167923,
-0.05583712086081505,
-0.22302985191345215,
-0.06029011681675911,
0.09688177704811096,
0.27764368057250977,
-0.12315394729375839,
-0.2617229223251343,
-0.220437690615654,
0.022971119731664658,
-0.2506020665168762,
0.37758877873420715,
0.7198804616928101,
-0.2776249945163727,
-0.29336145520210266,
-0.06903506070375443,
0.8279772996902466,
0.6581891775131226,
-0.42290428280830383,
0.39870312809944153,
0.22826607525348663,
-0.3108021914958954,
0.03289411589503288,
-0.8899321556091309,
0.14976191520690918,
-0.425827294588089,
0.4712986350059509,
-0.6056639552116394,
-0.5095508694648743,
0.6803022623062134,
-0.23082920908927917,
-0.18078696727752686,
-0.004751788917928934,
0.6474546194076538,
-0.1364024430513382,
1.0403499603271484,
0.6141183972358704,
0.2129666805267334,
0.48839980363845825,
-0.13185743987560272,
0.2179514616727829,
-1.2099052667617798,
-0.8177264928817749,
-1.0840641260147095,
-0.5200002789497375,
-0.11438210308551788,
-0.32029926776885986,
0.4575875699520111,
0.4894784390926361,
-0.43213024735450745,
0.552006721496582,
-0.33426135778427124,
0.10019584745168686,
0.6259597539901733,
0.12203218787908554,
0.4766311049461365,
-0.12054344266653061,
-0.14381831884384155,
0.265170156955719,
-0.436703085899353,
-0.5053316354751587,
0.8244243860244751,
-0.10864035785198212,
0.9821996092796326,
0.7047024369239807,
0.11647333949804306,
0.5967941284179688,
0.2996283769607544,
-0.7061259746551514,
0.4297363758087158,
-0.11574772000312805,
-0.9812925457954407,
-0.022371415048837662,
-0.5151569843292236,
-1.2637014389038086,
0.22007204592227936,
-0.2967797815799713,
-0.7611656785011292,
0.6170220375061035,
-0.1838960200548172,
-0.16009387373924255,
-0.02907782606780529,
-0.5411017537117004,
0.7298311591148376,
-0.38132357597351074,
-0.5673121213912964,
-0.44872981309890747,
-0.6500551700592041,
-0.0012321971589699388,
0.03224027156829834,
0.1406397968530655,
-0.2625916302204132,
-0.3700736165046692,
0.5464037656784058,
0.05894432216882706,
0.3279591500759125,
-0.088368721306324,
0.721412718296051,
-0.0637684017419815,
0.3830784559249878,
0.5978132486343384,
-0.4560389220714569,
-0.48259973526000977,
-0.08860723674297333,
0.37363895773887634,
-0.45352843403816223,
-0.3180769979953766,
0.5129374265670776,
-0.61214679479599,
-0.4414443075656891,
-0.4083174467086792,
-0.5706740021705627,
-0.16648699343204498,
0.6338834762573242,
0.11534348130226135,
0.6359164118766785,
-0.24750560522079468,
1.0113028287887573,
0.5367502570152283,
-0.006867076735943556,
0.16356566548347473,
1.0613490343093872,
0.05668456479907036,
-0.20090168714523315,
0.5519452095031738,
0.10203487426042557,
0.14756810665130615,
0.7651672959327698,
0.08683418482542038,
-0.24643418192863464,
-0.88165283203125,
-0.08893688023090363,
0.17366431653499603,
-0.6575121283531189,
-0.5623091459274292,
-0.4969503581523895,
0.11271113157272339,
-0.03676397353410721,
0.2601042687892914,
-0.38158491253852844,
0.12982651591300964,
0.05602093040943146,
0.4231751263141632,
-0.1467830240726471,
0.8385109901428223,
-0.07831679284572601,
0.19585895538330078,
-0.3857612609863281,
0.46037817001342773,
0.19413180649280548,
0.5768213272094727,
-0.14193607866764069,
-0.6195241808891296,
-0.27885890007019043,
-0.30320948362350464,
-0.2769567668437958,
-0.5120657086372375,
-0.021663138642907143,
0.12955838441848755,
0.9275190234184265,
0.2230168730020523,
0.13285019993782043,
0.7414739727973938,
-0.46052098274230957,
0.13223503530025482,
0.24319063127040863,
-0.6997459530830383,
0.28499820828437805,
-0.35911640524864197,
0.08897516876459122,
0.9623799920082092,
0.4782521426677704,
-0.3783039450645447,
0.11147069931030273,
0.07233892381191254,
-0.9587715864181519,
0.6817739009857178,
0.17975355684757233,
-0.2412816882133484,
-0.030930422246456146,
0.41164764761924744,
-0.10081204026937485,
0.41763943433761597,
-0.5081459283828735,
-0.10974118858575821,
0.3263978064060211,
-0.13996605575084686,
0.17466221749782562,
-0.614720344543457,
-0.3140277862548828,
0.15442226827144623,
0.28414255380630493,
0.10843932628631592,
0.4093678295612335,
0.5864385962486267,
-0.1618981659412384,
-0.22120292484760284,
0.36064818501472473,
0.49139833450317383,
0.863348662853241,
-0.5426236987113953,
0.2020217925310135,
-0.03129791095852852,
-0.3034839928150177,
-0.08335502445697784,
0.22154831886291504,
-0.023988250643014908,
-0.23317189514636993,
0.33819714188575745,
0.47056466341018677,
0.5694649815559387,
-1.0707416534423828,
0.5456207394599915,
-0.15299615263938904,
-0.04122144356369972,
-0.3219103515148163,
0.059848036617040634,
-0.0062255822122097015,
0.47490254044532776,
0.8346817493438721,
0.04400130733847618,
0.6644464731216431,
-1.1590125560760498,
0.09069810807704926,
0.6386299133300781,
-0.4436017572879791,
-0.2966655194759369,
0.5858129262924194,
-0.10777091979980469,
-0.7515155673027039,
0.29036474227905273,
-0.11568115651607513,
-0.3864779472351074,
0.4404977858066559,
0.49040356278419495,
0.4528088867664337,
-0.22329306602478027,
-0.1747937798500061,
0.4413016140460968,
0.2795107960700989,
-0.36453837156295776,
0.5350154042243958,
-0.14390458166599274,
-0.3135316073894501,
-0.04169896990060806,
-0.5550457835197449,
-0.6244935989379883,
-0.23152969777584076,
-1.047889232635498,
0.3135353624820709,
-0.48178473114967346,
-0.19415558874607086,
0.192228764295578,
0.22440974414348602,
-0.8979604840278625,
0.20955140888690948,
-0.22197896242141724,
0.9106397032737732,
-0.10867436975240707,
0.7239694595336914,
0.5476234555244446,
-0.3714202344417572,
-0.5536527037620544,
-0.345182329416275,
-0.3150877356529236,
-0.5682016611099243,
1.024523138999939,
-0.06762425601482391,
-0.6820261478424072,
-0.334314227104187,
-0.29353055357933044,
-0.8751609325408936,
1.2170076370239258,
0.3261803686618805,
-0.678298830986023,
-0.13938945531845093,
0.1975044310092926,
0.5474410653114319,
-0.45081761479377747,
0.4150574207305908,
0.3447454869747162,
0.6743887066841125,
0.106284499168396,
-0.9936708211898804,
-0.06122278422117233,
-0.2310759574174881,
0.000027780597520177253,
0.1025976687669754,
-0.8586575984954834,
1.1479761600494385,
-0.09616298228502274,
-0.29843658208847046,
0.36786386370658875,
0.2824956178665161,
0.1469404399394989,
0.4723820686340332,
0.680167019367218,
0.316428005695343,
0.7151736617088318,
-0.06066394969820976,
1.1380959749221802,
-0.3208749294281006,
0.3798080086708069,
1.1379876136779785,
-0.6074281334877014,
1.1949021816253662,
0.4356898367404938,
-0.21820643544197083,
0.6478376984596252,
0.3159628212451935,
-0.010349070653319359,
0.7631335854530334,
0.17676471173763275,
-0.25898870825767517,
-0.37015020847320557,
-0.23905129730701447,
-0.14525678753852844,
0.5695821642875671,
0.30144229531288147,
-0.11635857820510864,
-0.2904389798641205,
-0.22307975590229034,
-0.12988309562206268,
0.19590170681476593,
-0.18010276556015015,
0.6801193356513977,
-0.2599291205406189,
-1.0357768535614014,
0.3066065013408661,
0.22260916233062744,
0.30482956767082214,
-0.735088586807251,
0.07251010835170746,
-0.22535306215286255,
0.4546470046043396,
-0.24838444590568542,
-0.7198446393013,
0.11638057231903076,
0.08917561173439026,
-0.5658788681030273,
0.159184068441391,
0.5146958231925964,
-0.33342915773391724,
-0.4526961147785187,
0.8429323434829712,
0.22646793723106384,
0.20018921792507172,
0.019480306655168533,
-0.6731057167053223,
0.2611510753631592,
-0.07957825064659119,
-0.3834788501262665,
0.2671562731266022,
0.5483640432357788,
0.1406506448984146,
0.9218776822090149,
0.4671460688114166,
0.05055646970868111,
-0.04937708377838135,
-0.06936917454004288,
0.8186761736869812,
-0.8500586152076721,
0.07671167701482773,
-0.42115870118141174,
0.24119935929775238,
-0.10452070087194443,
-0.3267022669315338,
0.551810085773468,
1.2243534326553345,
0.5778266191482544,
0.21584387123584747,
0.5381789803504944,
-0.4253430962562561,
0.9743928909301758,
-0.3464703857898712,
0.2594226002693176,
-0.8329675793647766,
0.39141565561294556,
-0.171421080827713,
-1.1958485841751099,
-0.18860816955566406,
0.41657814383506775,
-0.17906177043914795,
0.05595279857516289,
0.7198659181594849,
0.9562426209449768,
-0.29388242959976196,
-0.35804063081741333,
0.3612077236175537,
0.1414899379014969,
0.07968859374523163,
0.5354861617088318,
0.972994327545166,
-0.40165039896965027,
0.9394542574882507,
-0.08905401825904846,
-0.3166930675506592,
-0.6331049203872681,
-0.7568809986114502,
-0.8422572612762451,
-0.6206643581390381,
0.08748025447130203,
-0.19639211893081665,
0.21603532135486603,
0.7240667343139648,
0.804017961025238,
-0.6321861743927002,
-0.5510799288749695,
0.39071786403656006,
0.09355627000331879,
-0.024900656193494797,
-0.18053153157234192,
0.07926006615161896,
-0.3728363513946533,
-0.7740552425384521,
0.21944166719913483,
0.559182345867157,
-0.4717313349246979,
-0.15154144167900085,
-0.01961931400001049,
-0.47707599401474,
0.0023717705626040697,
0.6932547688484192,
0.4297807812690735,
-0.4965624511241913,
-0.5145543813705444,
0.34898313879966736,
-0.5030196309089661,
0.1141289472579956,
1.1145269870758057,
-0.3021593391895294,
0.39683613181114197,
0.6179419159889221,
0.3698330223560333,
0.8520895838737488,
0.16135936975479126,
0.4679802656173706,
-0.3283279538154602,
-0.037907786667346954,
0.22057250142097473,
0.3600097596645355,
0.27594316005706787,
-0.14025425910949707,
0.5985273718833923,
-0.0754656195640564,
-0.7879659533500671,
-1.1223865747451782,
0.014209500513970852,
-1.4681962728500366,
-0.30835020542144775,
1.1270439624786377,
-0.17078325152397156,
-0.18465811014175415,
-0.5207152962684631,
-0.12522301077842712,
0.06914936006069183,
-0.17463980615139008,
0.7870911359786987,
0.5000518560409546,
-0.08287184685468674,
0.14441992342472076,
-0.6346590518951416,
-0.015123045071959496,
0.249904066324234,
-0.6630562543869019,
0.15994659066200256,
0.42733335494995117,
0.5376026034355164,
0.24666835367679596,
0.4766139090061188,
-0.28319689631462097,
0.38118600845336914,
-0.15676474571228027,
0.5043187737464905,
0.19461670517921448,
-0.6113122701644897,
0.4007302224636078,
0.43932950496673584,
0.20446018874645233,
0.19417376816272736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14146v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14146v1
|
Reinforcement Learning with Dynamic Multi-Reward Weighting for Multi-Style Controllable Generation
| 2024-02-21T22:02:37 | 2024-02-21T22:02:37 |
Karin de Langis, Ryan Koo, Dongyeop Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Style is an integral component of text that expresses a diverse set of
information, including interpersonal dynamics (e.g. formality) and the author's
emotions or attitudes (e.g. disgust). Humans often employ multiple styles
simultaneously. An open question is how large language models can be explicitly
controlled so that they weave together target styles when generating text: for
example, to produce text that is both negative and non-toxic. Previous work
investigates the controlled generation of a single style, or else controlled
generation of a style and other attributes. In this paper, we expand this into
controlling multiple styles simultaneously. Specifically, we investigate
various formulations of multiple style rewards for a reinforcement learning
(RL) approach to controlled multi-style generation. These reward formulations
include calibrated outputs from discriminators and dynamic weighting by
discriminator gradient magnitudes. We find that dynamic weighting generally
outperforms static weighting approaches, and we explore its effectiveness in 2-
and 3-style control, even compared to strong baselines like plug-and-play
model. All code and data for RL pipelines with multiple style attributes will
be publicly available.
|
[
-0.2882736921310425,
-0.6830123066902161,
0.1658240109682083,
0.7157945036888123,
0.027478467673063278,
0.4209045469760895,
-0.4002054035663605,
-0.26125359535217285,
0.30576610565185547,
0.27279725670814514,
-0.7987042665481567,
-0.1435546576976776,
-0.6408007144927979,
0.10992097854614258,
-0.06305509805679321,
1.300073266029358,
-0.4157566428184509,
-0.0379524752497673,
0.030014973133802414,
-0.3803085386753082,
-0.5536336302757263,
-0.7295927405357361,
-0.5680232644081116,
-0.5882392525672913,
1.1613667011260986,
0.6222801208496094,
0.44989630579948425,
0.3892291188240051,
0.3227005898952484,
0.3187825679779053,
0.08858620375394821,
0.30103734135627747,
-0.5611814260482788,
0.6405842304229736,
0.03920857608318329,
-0.16505226492881775,
-0.20963451266288757,
0.3363575339317322,
0.6091597676277161,
-0.0629381537437439,
-0.3516635000705719,
-0.07702818512916565,
0.10516171902418137,
0.7246429920196533,
-0.782457709312439,
0.15257975459098816,
-0.3096667230129242,
0.3486599028110504,
-0.19075194001197815,
-0.5581284761428833,
-0.5936492681503296,
-0.5480976104736328,
-0.23175372183322906,
-0.5323444604873657,
-0.2879118025302887,
-0.07340575754642487,
0.6186489462852478,
0.08872490376234055,
-0.7903430461883545,
-0.6104440093040466,
-0.891954779624939,
1.0556999444961548,
-0.347194105386734,
0.2704620659351349,
-0.02464355155825615,
0.31130295991897583,
0.1317259520292282,
-0.5331236124038696,
-0.48233309388160706,
-0.360604852437973,
-0.221347838640213,
0.42684218287467957,
0.32440948486328125,
-0.13855262100696564,
0.19528897106647491,
0.11739959567785263,
-0.12168339639902115,
0.14084772765636444,
-0.10170970112085342,
0.036141011863946915,
0.7892494201660156,
0.050974637269973755,
0.2143065482378006,
-0.001511813374236226,
-0.659755289554596,
-0.5758420825004578,
-0.6037067770957947,
0.20331436395645142,
0.6339264512062073,
0.35837048292160034,
-0.14826837182044983,
0.44580090045928955,
-0.031195759773254395,
0.3057001829147339,
0.10613986849784851,
-0.5136728882789612,
0.27224263548851013,
-0.4914364516735077,
0.33924752473831177,
0.19613796472549438,
0.6846847534179688,
0.2943421006202698,
0.3158063292503357,
0.03741103783249855,
-0.50699782371521,
-0.06365314871072769,
0.5955941677093506,
-0.7279952168464661,
-0.18543672561645508,
0.10416604578495026,
-0.5088158845901489,
-0.7665193676948547,
-0.04943490028381348,
-1.0038782358169556,
-0.5755260586738586,
-0.4459957480430603,
0.4750775694847107,
-0.3276227116584778,
-0.40742430090904236,
-0.09992185235023499,
-0.255664587020874,
0.23150955140590668,
0.2490665465593338,
-1.0900076627731323,
0.33454301953315735,
0.044435758143663406,
0.6660738587379456,
-0.3995387554168701,
-0.3396633267402649,
-0.7028223872184753,
0.1158495619893074,
-0.33193016052246094,
0.3853367269039154,
-0.5907079577445984,
-0.19056475162506104,
0.12344306707382202,
-0.2750457525253296,
0.18378892540931702,
-0.3494066596031189,
0.19089271128177643,
-0.6154126524925232,
0.2009061723947525,
-0.21621114015579224,
-0.17822499573230743,
0.11558940261602402,
0.13101144134998322,
-0.7265130877494812,
0.836199939250946,
-0.04121924936771393,
-0.5819451212882996,
0.6535659432411194,
-0.5918692946434021,
-0.6476225852966309,
0.07611265778541565,
-0.2085961103439331,
-0.6811100244522095,
0.06149854138493538,
-0.2671597898006439,
0.3485093414783478,
0.23159827291965485,
0.2598978281021118,
-0.3912254571914673,
-0.31805887818336487,
0.41015690565109253,
-0.46212026476860046,
0.1801392138004303,
0.2964624762535095,
-0.5223643183708191,
0.509564220905304,
-0.6477308869361877,
0.13453376293182373,
0.4169626832008362,
-0.7067176699638367,
-0.2315460741519928,
0.21623243391513824,
0.26451170444488525,
0.5857729911804199,
0.24812108278274536,
-0.3010193407535553,
0.31064632534980774,
0.31644847989082336,
0.31350672245025635,
0.9370450377464294,
0.05571228638291359,
0.2845366597175598,
-0.575249195098877,
0.6371565461158752,
-0.19361180067062378,
0.12520533800125122,
-0.07410670816898346,
-0.003623598488047719,
-0.6165218353271484,
-0.24744126200675964,
-0.045601192861795425,
0.4600168764591217,
-0.9125373959541321,
0.1756182461977005,
0.3192911148071289,
-0.46494728326797485,
-0.028089383617043495,
-0.0618228018283844,
0.6789950728416443,
-0.05800079181790352,
0.5175912976264954,
-0.0341794453561306,
-0.12322857975959778,
-0.5672009587287903,
-0.4660837650299072,
0.17668595910072327,
0.12829920649528503,
0.4500497579574585,
0.4025174081325531,
0.3010592460632324,
0.508813738822937,
-0.545547366142273,
-0.12362721562385559,
-0.3368394672870636,
0.8034496903419495,
-0.26383793354034424,
0.6423854231834412,
0.6224551796913147,
-0.9881532192230225,
-0.5052497386932373,
-0.2693106234073639,
-0.5189629793167114,
-0.16123948991298676,
-0.5044102668762207,
-0.007275006268173456,
0.12436246126890182,
0.466636598110199,
-0.054570429027080536,
0.14309567213058472,
0.6531959772109985,
-0.2152438908815384,
0.960498571395874,
-0.37631872296333313,
0.1395460069179535,
-0.6391714811325073,
0.01925361342728138,
0.2979795038700104,
-0.13920319080352783,
-0.6953440308570862,
0.20040574669837952,
0.1690588891506195,
0.053767379373311996,
-0.5089205503463745,
0.48170122504234314,
-0.28718867897987366,
0.17640195786952972,
-0.2173239290714264,
-0.21970203518867493,
0.2526874840259552,
0.8789262175559998,
0.3123306632041931,
0.7077048420906067,
0.15694761276245117,
-0.687559962272644,
0.6280986070632935,
-0.1354009062051773,
-0.23005524277687073,
0.7116478085517883,
-0.5879480838775635,
-0.0013791475212201476,
-0.296954870223999,
0.3236256241798401,
-0.780748188495636,
-0.05570613965392113,
0.04876646772027016,
-0.04894416779279709,
0.41905176639556885,
0.25422540307044983,
-0.5587450265884399,
-0.14818502962589264,
-0.5674685835838318,
0.4327012002468109,
0.12982961535453796,
-0.4480923116207123,
0.40891000628471375,
0.1554691642522812,
-0.36087191104888916,
-0.6196815371513367,
-0.5589482188224792,
-0.25970712304115295,
-0.6024481058120728,
0.0635283961892128,
0.5834581255912781,
-0.5133562088012695,
-0.13493600487709045,
-0.24398106336593628,
-0.021998440846800804,
0.16288737952709198,
0.19725173711776733,
0.020361924543976784,
0.08349041640758514,
0.3203940689563751,
0.21774563193321228,
0.20952609181404114,
0.0608123354613781,
-0.04811622202396393,
-0.08637477457523346,
0.8096450567245483,
-0.015632323920726776,
-0.31032708287239075,
-0.35631540417671204,
0.37750953435897827,
0.5456987023353577,
-0.5635714530944824,
0.8462170958518982,
0.6435821652412415,
-0.03581083193421364,
-0.4376074969768524,
-0.25472307205200195,
-0.24465151131153107,
-0.5206187963485718,
0.21972377598285675,
-0.36983606219291687,
-0.6050065159797668,
0.46213793754577637,
-0.033478155732154846,
0.25539928674697876,
0.1629575937986374,
0.6603839993476868,
0.06133614107966423,
1.3657541275024414,
0.5015560388565063,
0.2725994288921356,
1.0101689100265503,
-0.01355496235191822,
-0.14136505126953125,
-0.46606624126434326,
-0.5629609227180481,
-0.36563149094581604,
-0.7703555226325989,
-0.8751168251037598,
0.0308882687240839,
0.43743130564689636,
0.13722211122512817,
-0.5078386068344116,
0.032826077193021774,
-0.4876611530780792,
0.3838611841201782,
0.8039970397949219,
0.23796728253364563,
0.2215156853199005,
-0.18875108659267426,
-0.2784169018268585,
0.037058282643556595,
-0.4910042881965637,
-0.20717494189739227,
0.81121826171875,
0.2579771876335144,
1.141718864440918,
0.4268394112586975,
0.7991476655006409,
0.3932148814201355,
0.2352706491947174,
-0.8346787095069885,
0.18257659673690796,
-0.2929130494594574,
-0.276180237531662,
-0.3916590213775635,
-0.6121033430099487,
-0.6426160931587219,
0.12090037763118744,
-0.5814375281333923,
-0.4423394203186035,
0.259594202041626,
0.38481810688972473,
-0.3109727203845978,
0.1936158388853073,
-0.5518134236335754,
0.7653898596763611,
-0.6073347330093384,
-0.5162250399589539,
-0.40389612317085266,
-0.5258930325508118,
0.45317643880844116,
-0.19212371110916138,
0.08575484901666641,
0.10898538678884506,
0.08219534903764725,
0.6131505370140076,
-0.13405853509902954,
0.48790374398231506,
-0.08131363987922668,
-0.19172345101833344,
-0.02169879525899887,
0.123353011906147,
0.6017205715179443,
0.11864037811756134,
-0.026767820119857788,
-0.22731098532676697,
0.10184170305728912,
-0.26111865043640137,
-0.5221692323684692,
0.6413359045982361,
-0.6843650937080383,
0.04182964935898781,
-0.4733794331550598,
-0.5806137919425964,
-0.17089982330799103,
0.3556652367115021,
0.07380817085504532,
0.7952937483787537,
-0.09458789229393005,
0.19172117114067078,
0.7204347252845764,
-0.7397611141204834,
0.38718175888061523,
0.40110647678375244,
-0.3605917990207672,
-0.45073196291923523,
1.2076120376586914,
0.055930182337760925,
0.6333172917366028,
0.462054967880249,
0.41511568427085876,
-0.3708871006965637,
-0.09308954328298569,
-0.3205050528049469,
0.017783837392926216,
-0.4559805989265442,
-0.01633179374039173,
-0.2914116680622101,
-0.23866556584835052,
-0.27288633584976196,
-0.3026491403579712,
-0.30472925305366516,
-0.2410304695367813,
-0.024743473157286644,
0.08328304439783096,
0.25235408544540405,
1.2810683250427246,
-0.10770012438297272,
0.3100338280200958,
-0.45369666814804077,
0.3076896667480469,
0.6756283640861511,
0.6338273882865906,
0.056507550179958344,
0.08884395658969879,
-0.1673480123281479,
-0.18244893848896027,
-0.5291810035705566,
-1.0241121053695679,
0.44563886523246765,
-0.01487371139228344,
0.319164514541626,
0.335187166929245,
0.1810692995786667,
0.052984099835157394,
-0.5929850339889526,
0.5316489338874817,
0.38668546080589294,
-0.6984143257141113,
0.23322336375713348,
-0.28691840171813965,
0.3531967103481293,
0.33209794759750366,
0.27503862977027893,
-0.9786818027496338,
-0.46383243799209595,
-0.4420945942401886,
-0.7773517370223999,
0.8774335384368896,
-0.14188025891780853,
0.13781331479549408,
-0.0033170657698065042,
0.18187935650348663,
0.060144275426864624,
0.5885879397392273,
-0.9356513619422913,
-0.35571205615997314,
-0.6194520592689514,
-0.1513030081987381,
-0.015799306333065033,
-0.23411591351032257,
-0.3847968280315399,
0.17699529230594635,
0.6116493940353394,
-0.15906517207622528,
0.2780808210372925,
-0.4451351463794708,
0.05867720767855644,
-0.13992638885974884,
0.4044332504272461,
0.9818970561027527,
0.33930811285972595,
-0.28933465480804443,
0.29158395528793335,
-0.27274322509765625,
-0.10019593685865402,
0.2355550229549408,
-0.012435825541615486,
0.006428224965929985,
-0.4188704490661621,
0.13129517436027527,
0.9422315359115601,
0.15320302546024323,
-0.4936891496181488,
0.49999138712882996,
-0.17511238157749176,
-0.22551961243152618,
-0.18724116683006287,
0.10656696557998657,
-0.24304527044296265,
0.17654292285442352,
0.1477055847644806,
0.08381281793117523,
-0.19685345888137817,
-0.5653382539749146,
0.3049960434436798,
0.5595861077308655,
-0.249410018324852,
-0.05139342322945595,
0.7103943228721619,
0.21053609251976013,
-0.07594186812639236,
0.43701761960983276,
-0.4928555488586426,
-0.5313853025436401,
0.5366862416267395,
0.6448757648468018,
0.5596526861190796,
-0.12272860109806061,
0.501204252243042,
0.20272712409496307,
0.01250133290886879,
-0.11368488520383835,
0.41855302453041077,
-0.058450572192668915,
-0.8931310772895813,
-0.46777525544166565,
-0.7317790389060974,
-0.5345506072044373,
0.15362496674060822,
-0.745531439781189,
0.3468473255634308,
-0.5790467858314514,
0.09211871773004532,
-0.002997171599417925,
-0.050612691789865494,
-0.3981242775917053,
0.08987318724393845,
0.2904992401599884,
0.6033915281295776,
-1.0743809938430786,
0.6783426403999329,
0.6209330558776855,
-0.6163538694381714,
-0.8927645683288574,
0.05357418954372406,
0.2870692014694214,
-0.619874894618988,
0.910880982875824,
0.21525347232818604,
-0.34940269589424133,
0.036049794405698776,
-0.4687643349170685,
-0.8916218280792236,
0.9157054424285889,
-0.0874890685081482,
-0.0960388258099556,
-0.20338216423988342,
-0.22128494083881378,
0.32643234729766846,
-0.06646636873483658,
0.2534930408000946,
0.30076003074645996,
0.7214082479476929,
0.31122350692749023,
-0.625194787979126,
-0.1713751256465912,
-0.18995548784732819,
-0.06582805514335632,
0.3532245457172394,
-0.9037190079689026,
0.996982216835022,
0.14978638291358948,
-0.20106157660484314,
-0.11964404582977295,
0.5608948469161987,
0.5662649273872375,
-0.018016882240772247,
0.5504257678985596,
0.270002156496048,
0.6427107453346252,
-0.11664984375238419,
0.9234821796417236,
-0.5099670886993408,
0.2657097280025482,
0.8373789191246033,
-0.23508314788341522,
0.4124475121498108,
0.1089748814702034,
-0.020503608509898186,
0.8069115877151489,
0.47017017006874084,
0.22233957052230835,
0.6246376037597656,
0.41375279426574707,
-0.2974558174610138,
-0.07287290692329407,
-0.437164306640625,
-0.1884516477584839,
0.5433086156845093,
0.08792505413293839,
-0.07328638434410095,
-0.006873692385852337,
0.1794874668121338,
0.2388439178466797,
0.1898152232170105,
-0.2123984694480896,
0.8764641880989075,
-0.26241615414619446,
-0.7240346670150757,
0.4307264983654022,
0.17846734821796417,
1.013727068901062,
-1.058003306388855,
-0.2652367055416107,
-0.1492239385843277,
0.23138394951820374,
-0.0824032723903656,
-0.8773655891418457,
-0.07478325814008713,
-0.17308716475963593,
-0.02970799431204796,
-0.9889113903045654,
0.6176988482475281,
-0.8039199113845825,
-0.2980961501598358,
0.12385014444589615,
0.21319757401943207,
-0.252331018447876,
0.1324801743030548,
-0.6578660607337952,
-0.0061540184542536736,
-0.37904369831085205,
-0.45310431718826294,
0.6202298998832703,
0.4586830735206604,
-0.03308364376425743,
0.7285140752792358,
0.35655486583709717,
0.2664249837398529,
0.017072126269340515,
0.11765678972005844,
0.7285274863243103,
-0.42269042134284973,
-0.5110236406326294,
-0.7095549702644348,
0.3536056876182556,
-0.08180491626262665,
-0.21463292837142944,
0.5200725197792053,
0.19897668063640594,
0.7309454083442688,
0.06950823217630386,
0.5739284753799438,
-0.13413596153259277,
0.16118746995925903,
-0.6168251633644104,
0.5669108033180237,
-0.8913279175758362,
-0.23910033702850342,
-0.5288868546485901,
-0.6573171615600586,
-0.22640813887119293,
0.5302150249481201,
0.17896708846092224,
0.4050755500793457,
0.7299940586090088,
0.4563956558704376,
0.32700541615486145,
-0.13212762773036957,
0.04673858359456062,
-0.21264319121837616,
0.47306808829307556,
0.36062732338905334,
0.8680002689361572,
0.42562147974967957,
0.2972041070461273,
-0.5330674052238464,
-0.4635244905948639,
-0.03938122093677521,
-1.2240570783615112,
-0.189322829246521,
-0.5495648384094238,
0.0309426411986351,
-0.5093486309051514,
-0.11721043288707733,
1.065940022468567,
0.65915447473526,
-0.7211769223213196,
-0.3736012578010559,
0.07518356293439865,
0.2831638753414154,
-0.8149822354316711,
-0.2662578225135803,
0.01264112163335085,
-0.5690968632698059,
-0.7803261280059814,
0.4017939269542694,
0.26277101039886475,
-0.07307107746601105,
-0.6080486178398132,
-0.21285398304462433,
-0.2640645205974579,
0.21380329132080078,
0.8096513748168945,
0.29029151797294617,
-0.34050217270851135,
-0.3474797308444977,
-0.2154243141412735,
-0.22071440517902374,
-0.11997756361961365,
1.1348518133163452,
-0.6044652462005615,
0.44339388608932495,
0.5231375694274902,
0.3246445953845978,
0.3961316645145416,
0.20038414001464844,
0.5179154276847839,
-1.181473970413208,
-0.08615092933177948,
0.07075648009777069,
0.1582929939031601,
0.020709015429019928,
-0.32038483023643494,
0.16997823119163513,
0.2443513423204422,
-0.775829553604126,
-0.5153366327285767,
0.6598603129386902,
-0.7072895169258118,
-0.4261070787906647,
1.1170929670333862,
0.12187661230564117,
0.35040363669395447,
0.41939815878868103,
-0.12764295935630798,
0.481071412563324,
-0.5987786650657654,
0.6991647481918335,
0.6190140843391418,
-0.38866373896598816,
-0.22935177385807037,
-0.3969542384147644,
0.6979751586914062,
0.37188857793807983,
-0.8190115094184875,
0.26076263189315796,
0.7418814301490784,
0.007844055071473122,
0.10686858743429184,
0.560893177986145,
0.10983794927597046,
-0.09232745319604874,
-0.390413373708725,
0.36852163076400757,
-0.028130346909165382,
-0.9094117879867554,
-0.2565087378025055,
0.26632869243621826,
0.1823509782552719,
0.1278514713048935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14879v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14879v1
|
Driving Generative Agents With Their Personality
| 2024-02-21T21:29:57 | 2024-02-21T21:29:57 |
Lawrence J. Klinkert, Stephanie Buongiorno, Corey Clark
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This research explores the potential of Large Language Models (LLMs) to
utilize psychometric values, specifically personality information, within the
context of video game character development. Affective Computing (AC) systems
quantify a Non-Player character's (NPC) psyche, and an LLM can take advantage
of the system's information by using the values for prompt generation. The
research shows an LLM can consistently represent a given personality profile,
thereby enhancing the human-like characteristics of game characters.
Repurposing a human examination, the International Personality Item Pool (IPIP)
questionnaire, to evaluate an LLM shows that the model can accurately generate
content concerning the personality provided. Results show that the improvement
of LLM, such as the latest GPT-4 model, can consistently utilize and interpret
a personality to represent behavior.
|
[
-0.5842097997665405,
-0.40067005157470703,
0.8456984162330627,
0.39086756110191345,
0.11987269669771194,
0.20211157202720642,
-0.16106168925762177,
-0.404800683259964,
0.17511241137981415,
0.6660780906677246,
-0.8548482656478882,
-0.3402544856071472,
-0.3187384307384491,
0.2864138185977936,
-0.15561166405677795,
0.9796068668365479,
0.11195512861013412,
-0.041738491505384445,
-0.21653860807418823,
0.16884762048721313,
-0.4286760091781616,
-0.9325475692749023,
-0.8665868639945984,
-0.706001877784729,
0.654422402381897,
0.273772656917572,
0.8388184905052185,
0.4108836054801941,
0.5149400234222412,
0.3769318163394928,
0.0682716965675354,
-0.18311764299869537,
-0.5569618940353394,
0.5386583805084229,
-0.3698987066745758,
-0.5604856610298157,
-0.4540102779865265,
-0.019981158897280693,
0.3846418261528015,
0.28988534212112427,
0.014799517579376698,
-0.24285003542900085,
-0.17918212711811066,
0.5520585179328918,
-0.251954048871994,
0.3711244463920593,
-0.1887616515159607,
0.2737477421760559,
-0.14188522100448608,
-0.3949415981769562,
-0.4361880123615265,
-0.36379748582839966,
0.02966409921646118,
-0.48579859733581543,
0.051007650792598724,
-0.09565827250480652,
0.6528536081314087,
0.0694405660033226,
-0.3876739740371704,
-0.5089779496192932,
-0.9356743693351746,
0.5702370405197144,
-0.6483972072601318,
0.09995313733816147,
0.2934724688529968,
0.10713403671979904,
-0.36234810948371887,
-0.061394836753606796,
-0.8279020190238953,
-0.5315707325935364,
0.3173021078109741,
0.17474442720413208,
-0.11774710565805435,
0.3649502098560333,
0.5067242383956909,
0.35412129759788513,
-0.24248747527599335,
0.5028201937675476,
-0.14772911369800568,
0.2257869392633438,
1.0605872869491577,
0.6769779324531555,
0.6157208681106567,
0.04983991011977196,
-0.09088746458292007,
-0.4325200915336609,
-0.9637684226036072,
-0.08462607115507126,
0.8144324421882629,
0.140191450715065,
-0.2677428126335144,
0.7565851807594299,
-0.09544884413480759,
0.3608006536960602,
0.3768164813518524,
-0.2884763777256012,
0.30373212695121765,
-0.20675648748874664,
0.0005651637329719961,
-0.11715597659349442,
0.7671634554862976,
0.48783865571022034,
0.5415256023406982,
-0.20689275860786438,
-0.30395686626434326,
0.12220050394535065,
0.4922603666782379,
-1.0715229511260986,
-0.19085688889026642,
0.46823543310165405,
-0.5226053595542908,
-0.4553232491016388,
0.05665844306349754,
-0.9334022402763367,
-0.7036769986152649,
-0.3102317750453949,
0.07045785337686539,
-0.5616552233695984,
-0.45633259415626526,
-0.32599887251853943,
-0.16900460422039032,
0.6490094661712646,
0.17934347689151764,
-1.432055115699768,
-0.04309482127428055,
0.7068160176277161,
0.9143518209457397,
-0.4017876088619232,
-0.319909930229187,
-0.15805304050445557,
0.12617185711860657,
-0.5092552304267883,
0.8026182055473328,
-0.5835260152816772,
-0.807181715965271,
0.01951802708208561,
-0.06791622936725616,
0.35858842730522156,
-0.6293213963508606,
0.029739659279584885,
-0.5419586896896362,
-0.2014368176460266,
-0.6233416795730591,
-0.5238083600997925,
0.17570631206035614,
0.21825292706489563,
-0.6045784950256348,
0.5900543928146362,
0.46606945991516113,
-0.2914741039276123,
0.4092954993247986,
-0.8972976207733154,
-0.41906777024269104,
0.38661879301071167,
-0.2821158766746521,
-0.18730893731117249,
0.3594970703125,
-0.22415679693222046,
0.6011666059494019,
-0.17176629602909088,
0.15779167413711548,
-0.42816808819770813,
-0.23845124244689941,
0.6883476972579956,
-0.26241034269332886,
0.5654467940330505,
0.23719140887260437,
-0.37578144669532776,
0.3432559370994568,
-0.26621201634407043,
-0.04375910758972168,
0.09526913613080978,
-0.3956877887248993,
0.1798495650291443,
0.45579567551612854,
-0.038434747606515884,
0.5425754189491272,
0.1520918309688568,
-0.4836514890193939,
0.363459974527359,
-0.15079696476459503,
0.1345580667257309,
0.9951412081718445,
0.08887795358896255,
0.19742389023303986,
-0.4411398768424988,
1.0492979288101196,
0.015920817852020264,
-0.18073831498622894,
-0.07710116356611252,
-0.4514034688472748,
-0.6507201194763184,
-0.26436343789100647,
-0.36658617854118347,
0.5050431489944458,
-0.7508589625358582,
0.6242662072181702,
0.047066569328308105,
-0.610260546207428,
-0.26079800724983215,
-0.05275474861264229,
0.16342997550964355,
0.20044049620628357,
-0.13089895248413086,
-0.3658992350101471,
-0.4778042435646057,
-0.5629807114601135,
0.15520712733268738,
-0.6466798186302185,
-0.2492067962884903,
0.7326131463050842,
0.35153111815452576,
-0.4912262260913849,
0.7990572452545166,
-0.4553830921649933,
0.02090475708246231,
-0.5897108912467957,
0.22000066936016083,
0.011304359883069992,
0.28194183111190796,
0.691728949546814,
-0.6715867519378662,
-0.552428126335144,
-0.13196974992752075,
-1.000357747077942,
-0.41623881459236145,
-0.19507236778736115,
-0.10104188323020935,
0.040384791791439056,
0.3299846649169922,
-0.718856930732727,
0.3795146644115448,
0.499934583902359,
-0.7888481020927429,
0.9045279622077942,
-0.2276184856891632,
0.4265635311603546,
-0.7899417877197266,
-0.09124083071947098,
0.10717898607254028,
-0.006999142933636904,
-0.6079384684562683,
0.2701885998249054,
-0.4680199921131134,
-0.32828930020332336,
-0.2791229784488678,
0.4906834363937378,
-0.3838995695114136,
-0.29608631134033203,
-0.5553737878799438,
0.06651251763105392,
-0.24581670761108398,
0.23491281270980835,
0.3441297709941864,
1.131888747215271,
0.6099890470504761,
-0.8036129474639893,
0.8965842723846436,
0.2556415796279907,
-0.28546327352523804,
1.204947829246521,
-0.7368531823158264,
0.19347338378429413,
-0.37237972021102905,
-0.1024436205625534,
-0.7709562182426453,
-0.4113631546497345,
-0.07333285361528397,
-0.3672258257865906,
0.143471822142601,
0.17732775211334229,
-0.6313952207565308,
-0.27431246638298035,
-0.034058794379234314,
0.040475551038980484,
0.7918944358825684,
-0.41665005683898926,
0.45483651757240295,
0.44735464453697205,
-0.36536484956741333,
0.13705489039421082,
-0.5256659984588623,
0.17730320990085602,
-0.6180704236030579,
-0.5869650840759277,
0.44211089611053467,
-0.5299233198165894,
-0.5386367440223694,
-0.2453555166721344,
0.6437215209007263,
0.09380084276199341,
0.1606680452823639,
0.4212736487388611,
0.23202063143253326,
-0.23460476100444794,
0.13816037774085999,
-0.33897873759269714,
0.12197653949260712,
0.3697851002216339,
0.312930703163147,
0.7950106859207153,
-0.1777379810810089,
-0.13456018269062042,
-0.29485148191452026,
0.6050716638565063,
0.5169985294342041,
-0.0896180272102356,
0.8510466814041138,
0.33633285760879517,
0.13955748081207275,
-0.12271484732627869,
-0.18925340473651886,
-0.2303725630044937,
-0.5385732054710388,
0.6340487003326416,
-0.5907725691795349,
-0.9373259544372559,
0.800834596157074,
0.039698246866464615,
-0.3236539363861084,
0.259514182806015,
0.9706745147705078,
-0.1315038949251175,
1.425469160079956,
0.8246223330497742,
-0.10304804891347885,
0.6760343313217163,
0.09794832020998001,
0.06876078993082047,
-1.027145266532898,
-0.33609965443611145,
-0.210329070687294,
-0.2907402217388153,
-0.8734379410743713,
-0.28403666615486145,
0.23845994472503662,
-0.19032225012779236,
-0.4400780200958252,
0.06720416247844696,
-0.40679803490638733,
0.4206881523132324,
0.3335763216018677,
0.12039010226726532,
-0.10162299871444702,
-0.19081634283065796,
0.2371511608362198,
-0.03901037946343422,
-0.17813871800899506,
-0.5770211815834045,
1.2334260940551758,
0.4556500315666199,
0.9040940403938293,
0.6657916307449341,
0.6313602924346924,
0.2934342920780182,
0.6693645715713501,
-0.8124653697013855,
0.5910046100616455,
0.059853844344615936,
-0.645149827003479,
-0.3801182508468628,
-0.44797036051750183,
-0.7580781579017639,
-0.07030842453241348,
-0.1029418334364891,
-1.0221989154815674,
0.22377553582191467,
0.13188886642456055,
-0.3882814049720764,
0.19137056171894073,
-0.6024789810180664,
0.6612765192985535,
-0.4961913824081421,
-0.4349219501018524,
-0.16081887483596802,
-0.31281745433807373,
0.26717647910118103,
-0.10896586626768112,
-0.38830360770225525,
-0.2491765171289444,
0.061626993119716644,
0.5136284828186035,
-0.4096241295337677,
0.6789430975914001,
-0.25363367795944214,
-0.24233010411262512,
0.33794859051704407,
0.25924548506736755,
0.31988316774368286,
-0.13235501945018768,
-0.2902669906616211,
-0.0900707021355629,
-0.0721529871225357,
-0.10814867913722992,
-0.6859886646270752,
0.8449752330780029,
-1.1851139068603516,
-0.6729181408882141,
-0.5484851598739624,
-0.6181786060333252,
-0.35226473212242126,
-0.06351136416196823,
0.1075807735323906,
-0.12236043065786362,
-0.5553117990493774,
0.09044057130813599,
0.7553319334983826,
-0.43986189365386963,
0.37031856179237366,
0.5487431287765503,
-0.23541390895843506,
0.020667586475610733,
0.8300768136978149,
-0.29909297823905945,
0.46238863468170166,
0.1080540344119072,
0.07035661488771439,
-0.17688226699829102,
-0.2795000970363617,
-0.16355015337467194,
0.29731059074401855,
-0.48770493268966675,
-0.00025843200273811817,
-0.3111209571361542,
-0.2539503276348114,
-0.400903582572937,
-0.30389729142189026,
-0.1880444586277008,
0.42499983310699463,
-0.5691208839416504,
-0.27784237265586853,
0.46403181552886963,
1.0195506811141968,
-0.009332215413451195,
0.776329755783081,
-0.21066857874393463,
0.23039159178733826,
0.35093793272972107,
0.4423917233943939,
0.008703188970685005,
-0.284603089094162,
0.03186514601111412,
-0.07853037863969803,
-0.6827120780944824,
-1.3853684663772583,
0.7590590119361877,
0.03477022796869278,
0.3974173963069916,
0.7449978590011597,
-0.4233611524105072,
0.49437645077705383,
-0.3933265209197998,
0.9636600017547607,
0.12199559062719345,
-0.9396466016769409,
0.47467929124832153,
-0.5558736324310303,
0.3161941170692444,
0.4142106771469116,
0.3984261751174927,
-0.7512991428375244,
-0.11534164845943451,
-0.518105685710907,
-0.45572006702423096,
0.7382137775421143,
-0.004523920360952616,
0.33081868290901184,
-0.21989934146404266,
0.5551437735557556,
-0.15261034667491913,
0.430031418800354,
-0.7632976174354553,
-0.10805270075798035,
-0.2245958298444748,
-0.4211495518684387,
-0.27634674310684204,
-0.3929893374443054,
0.2607831060886383,
-0.062233079224824905,
0.5238242745399475,
-0.27733588218688965,
0.7575653791427612,
0.09612119942903519,
0.4051889479160309,
-0.12925195693969727,
0.2674632966518402,
0.4688214957714081,
0.5840373635292053,
-0.22727687656879425,
0.05495855212211609,
-0.3259406089782715,
-0.30331116914749146,
0.5341262817382812,
-0.23835943639278412,
-0.21573281288146973,
-0.39780935645103455,
0.1171938106417656,
0.9784493446350098,
-0.23639394342899323,
-0.9760555028915405,
0.5289273858070374,
0.14676302671432495,
-0.014924242161214352,
-0.5625283122062683,
0.3921051323413849,
0.10562386363744736,
0.30358806252479553,
0.03167889639735222,
-0.40606531500816345,
0.05544489994645119,
-1.0132454633712769,
0.1299043446779251,
0.5338807702064514,
-0.5644558072090149,
-0.6478595733642578,
0.5735837817192078,
0.22481432557106018,
-0.6441547274589539,
0.8563156127929688,
-0.5078235864639282,
-0.3987349271774292,
0.8143138289451599,
0.8210141658782959,
0.9578086137771606,
-0.5617354512214661,
0.5857095718383789,
0.144265815615654,
0.07927644997835159,
-0.04358023777604103,
0.5657857656478882,
0.15046463906764984,
-1.0583301782608032,
-0.3323575258255005,
-0.39519771933555603,
-0.5598134398460388,
0.2799733579158783,
-0.39078471064567566,
0.19522686302661896,
-0.6125351786613464,
-0.2675948441028595,
-0.12234015762805939,
-0.015400975942611694,
-0.8790581226348877,
0.28213024139404297,
0.36632466316223145,
0.32590433955192566,
-0.8785735368728638,
0.6117830872535706,
0.5002074837684631,
-0.8108550310134888,
-0.8219649195671082,
-0.11584796011447906,
-0.15194617211818695,
-0.6313351988792419,
1.020189642906189,
-0.07487446814775467,
0.11907744407653809,
-0.01374824158847332,
-0.7226155996322632,
-0.7393961548805237,
1.0776563882827759,
0.24506448209285736,
-0.5046210885047913,
-0.2706165611743927,
0.26117268204689026,
0.7969765663146973,
-0.873004674911499,
0.5581868886947632,
0.5220304727554321,
0.33715078234672546,
0.11560278385877609,
-0.4609052240848541,
-0.004736094735562801,
-0.2704937160015106,
0.3450146019458771,
-0.016073336824774742,
-0.7826780080795288,
0.9050328135490417,
-0.39638540148735046,
-0.06071515008807182,
0.14298784732818604,
0.7873840928077698,
0.7151436805725098,
-0.0634385421872139,
0.28592345118522644,
0.19237935543060303,
0.6098399758338928,
-0.01469365693628788,
1.2278308868408203,
-0.4227537214756012,
0.03265530988574028,
0.7628128528594971,
-0.6377919316291809,
0.5928528904914856,
0.47359955310821533,
-0.2788320481777191,
0.9293246269226074,
0.5798090696334839,
-0.32254815101623535,
0.48299622535705566,
0.4334295094013214,
-0.5319769978523254,
-0.08752807229757309,
-0.17335763573646545,
-0.022024622187018394,
0.5767149925231934,
0.4104592800140381,
-0.6157768964767456,
0.36355826258659363,
0.1966683715581894,
0.12278209626674652,
-0.0854346826672554,
-0.3553996682167053,
0.8533185720443726,
-0.017474835738539696,
-0.8047786951065063,
-0.10260938853025436,
0.1690017282962799,
0.6831002235412598,
-0.6765056848526001,
-0.015750788152217865,
-0.29668357968330383,
0.14049454033374786,
-0.12213081121444702,
-0.9524793028831482,
0.11647778749465942,
0.1666126400232315,
-0.2510214149951935,
-0.3794393539428711,
0.4722956418991089,
-0.26276540756225586,
-0.30453696846961975,
0.1298050880432129,
0.3053432106971741,
0.361151784658432,
-0.12095869332551956,
-0.5282152891159058,
0.18209539353847504,
-0.04242414981126785,
-0.1804165095090866,
0.3805312216281891,
0.456882506608963,
0.13589148223400116,
0.868750810623169,
0.366227924823761,
0.4910089373588562,
-0.2859281599521637,
0.05648864805698395,
0.6737319231033325,
-0.9060265421867371,
-0.709076464176178,
-1.0496388673782349,
0.3540222942829132,
-0.10572577267885208,
-0.3897022306919098,
0.8018385767936707,
0.3478257358074188,
0.4753284752368927,
-0.23828405141830444,
0.9666451215744019,
-0.1451537013053894,
0.11761526763439178,
-0.356563001871109,
0.6569185853004456,
-0.031386639922857285,
0.06686641275882721,
-0.46921467781066895,
-0.9291566014289856,
0.19652338325977325,
0.736555814743042,
-0.3337966203689575,
0.5249682068824768,
0.44988521933555603,
0.6852765083312988,
0.3440910577774048,
-0.15696579217910767,
0.5175538063049316,
0.16046114265918732,
0.7522053122520447,
0.841863214969635,
1.0165081024169922,
0.0358019694685936,
-0.19223348796367645,
-0.01433837041258812,
-0.48538413643836975,
-0.062288541346788406,
-0.6855246424674988,
-1.1261887550354004,
-0.46609652042388916,
-0.37602636218070984,
-0.4186529517173767,
-0.01709223911166191,
0.7771799564361572,
0.7040612101554871,
-0.5850529670715332,
-0.5122435092926025,
-0.2139575332403183,
-0.033222079277038574,
-0.04668150469660759,
-0.34338170289993286,
-0.1304546594619751,
-0.13843397796154022,
-0.6753786206245422,
0.281751811504364,
0.2821577191352844,
0.29155588150024414,
-1.0946916341781616,
-0.301710844039917,
0.2258094996213913,
0.41883447766304016,
0.7249364256858826,
0.42249590158462524,
-0.560067892074585,
-0.5792636275291443,
0.1128050684928894,
-0.08113019168376923,
0.13151879608631134,
0.9389777183532715,
-0.6196736097335815,
0.3801761865615845,
0.3710571527481079,
0.29119977355003357,
0.3690546751022339,
0.13954775035381317,
0.919549822807312,
-0.5106358528137207,
0.10996901988983154,
0.3991205394268036,
0.058455344289541245,
0.5313615202903748,
-0.7876269817352295,
0.221830815076828,
0.18055379390716553,
-0.8210578560829163,
-0.5164948105812073,
0.6060593128204346,
-0.7852293848991394,
0.11544758081436157,
1.3958430290222168,
-0.1739313006401062,
-0.1910117119550705,
0.14471545815467834,
-0.14399495720863342,
-0.10167401283979416,
-0.44331789016723633,
0.7265583872795105,
0.890971839427948,
-0.6472960710525513,
-0.5733535289764404,
-0.35240301489830017,
0.692832887172699,
0.0991806834936142,
-1.232560157775879,
-0.02373265102505684,
0.7057669758796692,
0.17628271877765656,
0.10309702903032303,
0.8134768009185791,
-0.12357888370752335,
0.007867909967899323,
0.07773224264383316,
0.5264309048652649,
0.21091236174106598,
-0.05684787780046463,
-0.230989471077919,
0.19727423787117004,
0.30073779821395874,
0.3314659893512726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14129v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14129v1
|
Combining Language and Graph Models for Semi-structured Information Extraction on the Web
| 2024-02-21T20:53:29 | 2024-02-21T20:53:29 |
Zhi Hong, Kyle Chard, Ian Foster
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Relation extraction is an efficient way of mining the extraordinary wealth of
human knowledge on the Web. Existing methods rely on domain-specific training
data or produce noisy outputs. We focus here on extracting targeted relations
from semi-structured web pages given only a short description of the relation.
We present GraphScholarBERT, an open-domain information extraction method based
on a joint graph and language model structure. GraphScholarBERT can generalize
to previously unseen domains without additional data or training and produces
only clean extraction results matched to the search keyword. Experiments show
that GraphScholarBERT can improve extraction F1 scores by as much as 34.8\%
compared to previous work in a zero-shot domain and zero-shot website setting.
|
[
-0.43570584058761597,
-1.0251331329345703,
0.27817073464393616,
0.04383930563926697,
-0.2262742668390274,
0.25018423795700073,
-0.31066378951072693,
-0.8280165791511536,
-0.002368005458265543,
0.42908036708831787,
-0.39365559816360474,
-0.8326709270477295,
-0.4252853989601135,
-0.062004584819078445,
-0.43789994716644287,
1.0140914916992188,
0.17207324504852295,
-0.08377598971128464,
-0.2886546552181244,
0.23181480169296265,
0.31215423345565796,
-0.507575273513794,
-0.5527198910713196,
-0.26267915964126587,
0.47960177063941956,
0.15454651415348053,
0.6867903470993042,
0.6529389023780823,
0.3354506194591522,
0.19566592574119568,
-0.03244714066386223,
0.29141539335250854,
-0.8512190580368042,
0.1572592407464981,
-0.3885950446128845,
-0.20649193227291107,
-0.5769664645195007,
0.10138624161481857,
0.5191675424575806,
1.0768095254898071,
-0.01330339815467596,
0.2908049523830414,
0.09203460067510605,
0.4874964952468872,
-0.7415847182273865,
0.7084922790527344,
-0.41251111030578613,
-0.009924645535647869,
-0.16813592612743378,
-0.40079259872436523,
-0.602638840675354,
-0.5443241596221924,
0.1527627408504486,
-0.5728517174720764,
0.3809230923652649,
0.13909392058849335,
1.3353546857833862,
-0.27877986431121826,
-0.3916405141353607,
-0.3297876715660095,
-0.8409143090248108,
0.6302896738052368,
-0.35169172286987305,
0.7755932211875916,
0.38933905959129333,
0.27887940406799316,
-0.0331600084900856,
-1.1432524919509888,
-0.28155991435050964,
0.16000798344612122,
-0.24388204514980316,
0.14677298069000244,
-0.742277204990387,
0.029754601418972015,
0.24380572140216827,
0.21568097174167633,
-0.5048291683197021,
-0.20006966590881348,
-0.7117476463317871,
-0.2733064293861389,
0.701047956943512,
-0.020966392010450363,
0.5473544001579285,
-0.33871084451675415,
-0.3375571072101593,
-0.023179929703474045,
-0.8145111799240112,
0.1744854599237442,
0.4973424971103668,
0.7284433841705322,
0.08060943335294724,
0.5753952264785767,
-0.13052867352962494,
1.0675016641616821,
-0.06380099803209305,
-0.10481596738100052,
-0.02889084629714489,
-0.23406952619552612,
-0.08444990962743759,
0.06234579160809517,
1.022040843963623,
0.292492538690567,
0.762962281703949,
-0.802406370639801,
-0.041395142674446106,
0.11029531061649323,
0.0779522955417633,
-0.9280469417572021,
-0.9310491681098938,
0.18003346025943756,
-0.547549843788147,
-0.4412004053592682,
0.38251587748527527,
-0.9692941904067993,
-0.03637676686048508,
0.0007567693828605115,
-0.13952967524528503,
-0.41933146119117737,
-0.38016173243522644,
-0.26388707756996155,
-0.6718759536743164,
-0.04677339270710945,
0.22202448546886444,
-0.6831074357032776,
0.5367164015769958,
0.41040098667144775,
0.8101560473442078,
-0.38107261061668396,
0.0021514277905225754,
-0.8309188485145569,
0.4091627895832062,
-0.21708941459655762,
0.8046936988830566,
-0.8599900603294373,
-0.3100290894508362,
0.27734026312828064,
0.04895944148302078,
0.17885197699069977,
-0.5965663194656372,
0.23799613118171692,
-1.0671708583831787,
0.0781860500574112,
0.036896467208862305,
-0.7539992928504944,
-0.03263351321220398,
0.11555114388465881,
-1.055006504058838,
0.91069096326828,
0.33371010422706604,
-0.868431806564331,
0.09844996780157089,
-0.44302794337272644,
-0.7164870500564575,
0.2756004333496094,
-0.10951700061559677,
-0.24011357128620148,
-0.21396566927433014,
0.20427298545837402,
0.3850364089012146,
-0.23839522898197174,
-0.1518377959728241,
-0.6829673051834106,
0.024535464122891426,
0.1251196265220642,
0.1510625183582306,
1.1716691255569458,
0.11492790281772614,
0.15686753392219543,
-0.2732963562011719,
-0.9460952877998352,
0.29193493723869324,
0.39926162362098694,
-0.5505982637405396,
-0.6486191153526306,
0.0026615627575665712,
0.02787170000374317,
0.31865349411964417,
0.33313384652137756,
-0.6776708364486694,
0.1928434669971466,
-0.4973471164703369,
0.3944786489009857,
0.5810995101928711,
0.4503653049468994,
0.5302515029907227,
0.23843666911125183,
0.7565560340881348,
-0.21677365899085999,
-0.19236977398395538,
0.34484949707984924,
-0.2609231472015381,
-0.4288865923881531,
-0.4357941150665283,
0.6265470385551453,
0.2575727701187134,
-0.8561914563179016,
0.23252421617507935,
-0.4240927994251251,
-0.5025679469108582,
-0.25051698088645935,
0.34175950288772583,
0.4027506411075592,
0.604689359664917,
0.3707629442214966,
-0.3755095899105072,
-0.5044611096382141,
-0.5779358744621277,
-0.30998966097831726,
-0.021222369745373726,
0.04471917822957039,
0.34769168496131897,
0.11256980895996094,
0.09250358492136002,
1.1679550409317017,
-1.0928024053573608,
-0.2936351001262665,
-0.4161694645881653,
0.25857478380203247,
0.008342121727764606,
-0.1551770567893982,
0.5271494388580322,
-1.0668938159942627,
-0.820777952671051,
0.12759628891944885,
-1.0538880825042725,
-0.10368804633617401,
0.6465309262275696,
-0.16970820724964142,
-0.267050564289093,
0.3402775824069977,
-0.6823862791061401,
0.4364760220050812,
0.25759366154670715,
0.1420644223690033,
0.4120413661003113,
0.14443126320838928,
-0.410454124212265,
-0.7510166168212891,
0.1461922824382782,
0.3917359709739685,
-0.7416319847106934,
-0.794262170791626,
0.0079439552500844,
0.14331555366516113,
-0.2865513861179352,
-0.46299031376838684,
0.5194002985954285,
-0.9365023970603943,
-0.22812853753566742,
-0.1947701871395111,
0.765113890171051,
0.29547178745269775,
0.6752921938896179,
0.06817048043012619,
0.6015684604644775,
0.60273677110672,
-0.750414252281189,
0.5153336524963379,
0.44911372661590576,
0.12620888650417328,
0.18806929886341095,
-0.43479812145233154,
0.24520909786224365,
0.000595445279031992,
-0.07210248708724976,
-0.815341591835022,
-0.07165562361478806,
0.14984166622161865,
-0.5273805856704712,
0.4201207458972931,
-0.3580159544944763,
-0.5240274667739868,
-0.24074029922485352,
-0.3123851716518402,
0.08148273825645447,
0.2998555600643158,
-0.49196213483810425,
0.3874436616897583,
0.8888788223266602,
-0.43465638160705566,
-0.3915437161922455,
-0.006260188762098551,
-0.1409936398267746,
0.1701699048280716,
-0.49782219529151917,
0.3405112326145172,
0.26423215866088867,
-0.307160884141922,
0.485610693693161,
-0.24522732198238373,
-0.6248294711112976,
0.06556449830532074,
0.12090637534856796,
0.45815619826316833,
0.06351948529481888,
0.14815747737884521,
-0.08996409922838211,
0.038715604692697525,
0.04410598799586296,
-0.21354085206985474,
0.8330621123313904,
-0.039221230894327164,
0.16552038490772247,
-0.2990525960922241,
0.2588471472263336,
0.11816045641899109,
-0.5133149027824402,
0.4328320324420929,
0.35224443674087524,
-0.5546800494194031,
-0.453926682472229,
0.22554729878902435,
-0.13320064544677734,
-0.42670366168022156,
0.3869953453540802,
-0.4013453722000122,
-0.6877485513687134,
0.2614695131778717,
-0.5265147089958191,
-0.10862299054861069,
0.46834704279899597,
0.38162294030189514,
-0.33415958285331726,
1.14934241771698,
0.9399397373199463,
-0.12362880259752274,
0.357288658618927,
-0.5078471899032593,
0.5475016236305237,
-0.651184618473053,
-0.3017289936542511,
-0.6228396892547607,
0.06503120064735413,
-0.46558254957199097,
0.2980850636959076,
0.07784660905599594,
0.38289397954940796,
0.20757383108139038,
0.7710864543914795,
-0.3914094567298889,
0.17506994307041168,
0.4561825096607208,
0.3164612054824829,
0.3659142553806305,
0.30513080954551697,
0.06862089782953262,
0.07380752265453339,
-0.7139943242073059,
-0.3626898229122162,
1.1226431131362915,
-0.20430366694927216,
0.8668451309204102,
0.24203535914421082,
0.6661451458930969,
0.5986395478248596,
0.18540625274181366,
-0.7275243401527405,
0.4949304163455963,
-0.12259159237146378,
-0.7770625352859497,
-0.3925812542438507,
-0.5957627296447754,
-1.3416849374771118,
0.08305390179157257,
-0.21185162663459778,
-1.1377501487731934,
0.1601787805557251,
0.17375586926937103,
0.014843115583062172,
0.0865039974451065,
-0.4399409890174866,
0.7620086073875427,
-0.12345283478498459,
-0.6688617467880249,
0.06201133131980896,
-0.6494291424751282,
0.18630680441856384,
-0.02595251426100731,
0.37209832668304443,
-0.08927441388368607,
0.3622072637081146,
0.8341423273086548,
-0.3168429136276245,
0.7009458541870117,
-0.11737214028835297,
0.1908942312002182,
0.30443695187568665,
0.29390910267829895,
0.5423696041107178,
-0.34727197885513306,
0.1403816044330597,
0.24805766344070435,
0.23606161773204803,
-0.31186443567276,
-0.6224173903465271,
0.32795602083206177,
-0.7711859345436096,
-0.21218149363994598,
-0.43859073519706726,
-0.4925028383731842,
-0.3763560354709625,
0.6950728893280029,
0.11450708657503128,
0.5637720823287964,
-0.47668221592903137,
-0.033615581691265106,
0.3115931749343872,
0.035338789224624634,
0.33399736881256104,
0.246358722448349,
-0.4011031985282898,
-0.2564351558685303,
1.0146372318267822,
-0.038667891174554825,
0.23799502849578857,
0.37333911657333374,
0.07634224742650986,
-0.4161255657672882,
-0.08142606914043427,
-0.1511131078004837,
0.4171971082687378,
-0.908982515335083,
-0.35879087448120117,
-0.771210789680481,
-0.48384416103363037,
-0.6601576209068298,
0.2894545793533325,
-0.19142992794513702,
-0.6339914798736572,
-0.28598764538764954,
-0.15674223005771637,
-0.07509737461805344,
0.6574971675872803,
0.05934543162584305,
0.20329855382442474,
-0.9412784576416016,
0.4540179669857025,
0.1117640882730484,
-0.15412750840187073,
0.020559102296829224,
-0.041169922798871994,
-0.24633948504924774,
-0.11554668843746185,
-0.3371650278568268,
-1.2354871034622192,
0.44044438004493713,
0.3528323173522949,
0.517411470413208,
0.6874111890792847,
0.18292702734470367,
0.8252685070037842,
-0.48070091009140015,
0.4628671705722809,
0.3536248505115509,
-0.6649384498596191,
0.5157155990600586,
-0.10380738973617554,
-0.2533539831638336,
0.3519159257411957,
0.8536672592163086,
-0.1313558667898178,
-0.3397374153137207,
-0.7752866148948669,
-0.6011072993278503,
0.8474029302597046,
0.3609851598739624,
-0.223703071475029,
0.01061012502759695,
0.31201207637786865,
-0.14077040553092957,
0.42794111371040344,
-0.6988664269447327,
-0.23416990041732788,
0.08292136341333389,
-0.15176382660865784,
0.20837268233299255,
-0.180644229054451,
-0.3657742738723755,
-0.2742937207221985,
0.6132472157478333,
0.04570092260837555,
0.18817465007305145,
0.021085528656840324,
-0.594611406326294,
-0.30246222019195557,
-0.04448729380965233,
-0.18616478145122528,
1.134094476699829,
-0.2630850374698639,
0.524315357208252,
-0.3263435959815979,
-0.15311181545257568,
-0.10774415731430054,
0.42198967933654785,
-0.2063264697790146,
0.11105500161647797,
0.7439653277397156,
0.31105056405067444,
0.040052782744169235,
-0.5718162655830383,
0.8155937790870667,
0.02889445424079895,
-0.002663178602233529,
-0.048073362559080124,
0.11598578840494156,
0.15124280750751495,
0.30093684792518616,
0.1726963371038437,
-0.22614051401615143,
0.35615912079811096,
-0.7810755372047424,
0.47052422165870667,
0.5234283804893494,
-0.5701825022697449,
-0.510187566280365,
0.6725982427597046,
-0.10187261551618576,
-0.5878763794898987,
0.776350200176239,
-0.24084752798080444,
-0.5843983292579651,
0.29752805829048157,
0.7762467861175537,
0.40734073519706726,
0.006013830658048391,
0.44205862283706665,
0.38148951530456543,
-0.15739934146404266,
0.46029171347618103,
0.14752575755119324,
-0.47638416290283203,
-0.7960768342018127,
-0.06984643638134003,
-0.7550339698791504,
-0.42033419013023376,
-0.1620914191007614,
-0.9553393721580505,
0.34356313943862915,
-0.3273913562297821,
-0.2607145309448242,
0.5170385241508484,
0.06321971863508224,
-0.6139642596244812,
0.2035868763923645,
-0.2332114428281784,
0.7826851010322571,
-0.8216864466667175,
1.020814061164856,
0.6367419362068176,
-0.7854397892951965,
-0.9200679063796997,
-0.01922403648495674,
-0.19600853323936462,
-0.7942150235176086,
0.8256703019142151,
-0.07041750103235245,
-0.3240267038345337,
0.2470482885837555,
-0.6558464765548706,
-0.4539417624473572,
0.8436556458473206,
0.4118568003177643,
-0.3455828130245209,
-0.2933577299118042,
0.04553388059139252,
0.5548877120018005,
-0.24627496302127838,
-0.11472178995609283,
0.4154113233089447,
0.1958443522453308,
0.020728465169668198,
-0.4287024736404419,
0.10264825820922852,
-0.3363054394721985,
-0.24969010055065155,
0.40786638855934143,
-0.44232088327407837,
0.7094085216522217,
0.12148930877447128,
-0.679145097732544,
-0.2728467881679535,
0.5838381052017212,
-0.01815721020102501,
0.1774751991033554,
0.4815976619720459,
0.2687663435935974,
1.0400501489639282,
0.13639502227306366,
0.9563072323799133,
-0.6018721461296082,
0.7874628305435181,
1.1083601713180542,
-0.4111352860927582,
0.713765561580658,
0.389872670173645,
-0.3413928747177124,
0.7134047150611877,
0.7476581335067749,
0.044407136738300323,
0.8260470032691956,
-0.1792515367269516,
-0.10198938101530075,
-0.311407208442688,
-0.14136816561222076,
0.04385630413889885,
0.54453045129776,
0.1013013944029808,
-0.46192535758018494,
-0.6372648477554321,
-0.35857170820236206,
0.34119901061058044,
-0.003297732211649418,
-0.0042320555076003075,
0.8295730948448181,
0.27215293049812317,
-0.678806722164154,
0.40010184049606323,
0.05775332450866699,
-0.3990700840950012,
-0.5635847449302673,
-0.2851497530937195,
0.07917797565460205,
0.13637134432792664,
-0.3278842270374298,
-0.6618191599845886,
0.08997561037540436,
0.1438106745481491,
-0.12009452283382416,
-0.07507647573947906,
1.2686195373535156,
-0.47574761509895325,
-0.311053067445755,
0.716068685054779,
0.72836834192276,
0.28149843215942383,
-0.1407579481601715,
-0.4948340058326721,
-0.15087637305259705,
0.07692082226276398,
-0.11377909034490585,
0.12570716440677643,
0.41552701592445374,
-0.006905974820256233,
0.31441110372543335,
0.867950975894928,
0.4794011116027832,
0.04026095196604729,
-0.02948165312409401,
1.2186074256896973,
-0.4975786805152893,
-0.3417157530784607,
-0.858517587184906,
0.1698717325925827,
-0.7839736938476562,
0.08665692061185837,
0.9059458374977112,
0.905474066734314,
0.5622984766960144,
0.23405936360359192,
1.1029887199401855,
-0.220589742064476,
0.3028630018234253,
-0.2623023986816406,
0.4794955253601074,
-0.6064733266830444,
-0.13587942719459534,
-0.37725502252578735,
-1.1932553052902222,
-0.3408915102481842,
0.4242987036705017,
-0.2473006695508957,
-0.11746206134557724,
0.7854215502738953,
0.5964640378952026,
-0.4495961368083954,
0.035025082528591156,
0.14778460562229156,
0.1831125169992447,
0.4756925702095032,
0.32297784090042114,
0.6878435015678406,
-0.11892522126436234,
0.8828190565109253,
-0.33774375915527344,
-0.4850825071334839,
-0.05320046469569206,
-0.4386695325374603,
-1.2349013090133667,
-0.43711650371551514,
-0.19905491173267365,
-0.6672181487083435,
0.11580144613981247,
0.34249669313430786,
0.6931312680244446,
-0.5278287529945374,
-0.22477136552333832,
0.06637029349803925,
0.09646637737751007,
-0.15921172499656677,
-0.2862037718296051,
0.6766395568847656,
-0.2028144896030426,
-0.7459864020347595,
0.29232266545295715,
0.5657947659492493,
-0.2980406582355499,
-0.08536285907030106,
-0.06674852967262268,
-0.4333367943763733,
-0.09285163879394531,
0.5248832702636719,
0.47003430128097534,
-0.1358404904603958,
-0.3523901402950287,
0.027438512071967125,
-0.1681375503540039,
0.46100321412086487,
0.5978449583053589,
-0.34934157133102417,
0.7481793165206909,
0.5202841758728027,
0.34084248542785645,
1.129544973373413,
0.4397202134132385,
0.5076290369033813,
-0.8648381233215332,
0.0959356501698494,
0.07549186795949936,
0.26019424200057983,
0.29355835914611816,
-0.3005644679069519,
0.571155309677124,
0.42311733961105347,
-0.13450336456298828,
-0.6662005186080933,
0.5023257732391357,
-1.0656291246414185,
-0.46949875354766846,
1.128749132156372,
-0.37234947085380554,
-0.41519370675086975,
-0.16053961217403412,
0.20430652797222137,
0.6599464416503906,
-0.27988970279693604,
0.5334118008613586,
0.5709171891212463,
-0.44033434987068176,
-0.0687270537018776,
-0.43316951394081116,
0.2306724488735199,
-0.48209747672080994,
-0.8073461055755615,
-0.14350539445877075,
0.4428948760032654,
0.369365394115448,
0.316885769367218,
0.6790506839752197,
-0.2732042074203491,
0.22066505253314972,
-0.09666607528924942,
0.23815105855464935,
-0.09715092182159424,
-0.5134376287460327,
0.3071746230125427,
0.7451111674308777,
-0.04590560868382454,
-0.10639587044715881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14116v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14116v2
|
FanOutQA: A Multi-Hop, Multi-Document Question Answering Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T20:30:45 | 2024-06-06T16:41:21 |
Andrew Zhu, Alyssa Hwang, Liam Dugan, Chris Callison-Burch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
One type of question that is commonly found in day-to-day scenarios is
``fan-out'' questions, complex multi-hop, multi-document reasoning questions
that require finding information about a large number of entities. However,
there exist few resources to evaluate this type of question-answering
capability among large language models. To evaluate complex reasoning in LLMs
more fully, we present FanOutQA, a high-quality dataset of fan-out
question-answer pairs and human-annotated decompositions with English Wikipedia
as the knowledge base. We formulate three benchmark settings across our dataset
and benchmark 7 LLMs, including GPT-4, LLaMA 2, Claude-2.1, and Mixtral-8x7B,
finding that contemporary models still have room to improve reasoning over
inter-document dependencies in a long context. We provide our dataset and
open-source tools to run models to encourage evaluation at https://fanoutqa.com
|
[
-0.8226575255393982,
-0.8931429982185364,
0.6476962566375732,
0.18402735888957977,
0.16203169524669647,
0.004352016840130091,
-0.2125314325094223,
-0.391921728849411,
-0.1061747744679451,
0.4624252915382385,
-0.9323902130126953,
-0.3217499256134033,
-0.42618390917778015,
0.13571518659591675,
-0.6405199766159058,
0.5946704149246216,
-0.5433414578437805,
0.24838003516197205,
-0.6364693641662598,
-0.10113096982240677,
-0.16691997647285461,
-0.5480329394340515,
-0.39406099915504456,
-0.3060598373413086,
0.5213668942451477,
0.5156617164611816,
0.5338646173477173,
0.1960906684398651,
0.5922867655754089,
0.16974961757659912,
0.032734230160713196,
0.6615933775901794,
-0.45568475127220154,
0.41685405373573303,
-0.27266424894332886,
-0.4854828119277954,
-0.1852857768535614,
-0.028046317398548126,
0.6216467022895813,
0.737805962562561,
-0.07741249352693558,
0.2883632183074951,
-0.31472131609916687,
0.5754275321960449,
-0.6590673923492432,
0.005052667111158371,
-0.5933105945587158,
-0.3229253590106964,
-0.2606881260871887,
0.24343204498291016,
-0.16408765316009521,
-0.4806370139122009,
0.1449809968471527,
-0.7426217198371887,
0.22171969711780548,
0.1711055487394333,
0.9320389628410339,
0.2790960967540741,
-0.38621199131011963,
-0.43422558903694153,
-0.6635459661483765,
0.5561944842338562,
-0.5363562703132629,
0.7396432757377625,
0.2688172161579132,
0.5103076100349426,
-0.3628517985343933,
-0.6086621284484863,
-0.7846168279647827,
-0.10846308618783951,
0.22665990889072418,
0.22115328907966614,
-0.1872713416814804,
-0.19800473749637604,
0.2576916217803955,
0.35225096344947815,
-0.5258944630622864,
-0.2632898688316345,
-0.13124938309192657,
-0.3176701068878174,
0.542050838470459,
0.13427968323230743,
0.24707654118537903,
0.056015413254499435,
-0.23328667879104614,
-0.011958353221416473,
-0.6900465488433838,
-0.07774049043655396,
0.42560991644859314,
-0.14284132421016693,
0.17112813889980316,
0.49649521708488464,
-0.6136380434036255,
0.5149401426315308,
-0.12169971317052841,
-0.0168441291898489,
-0.004665462765842676,
-0.2830207347869873,
-0.06921173632144928,
-0.46465063095092773,
0.6822735667228699,
0.3211655616760254,
0.5021763443946838,
-0.489668071269989,
-0.24502816796302795,
-0.26876595616340637,
-0.0032819302286952734,
-0.879287838935852,
-0.09641098231077194,
0.346270352602005,
-0.1792229861021042,
0.1402963399887085,
0.07455585151910782,
-0.538295567035675,
-0.3866419196128845,
-0.24228355288505554,
0.532295286655426,
-0.38909006118774414,
-0.2446683794260025,
0.25644057989120483,
-0.279766708612442,
0.34707877039909363,
0.738061249256134,
-0.3131154775619507,
0.41463395953178406,
0.8549295663833618,
0.6057420969009399,
-0.20721739530563354,
-0.5725576281547546,
-0.6262509226799011,
0.149969682097435,
-0.42741990089416504,
1.0554747581481934,
-0.38361141085624695,
-0.17576450109481812,
-0.073491171002388,
-0.07969824969768524,
-0.14865882694721222,
-0.7544407248497009,
0.8993860483169556,
-0.7520684599876404,
0.20465564727783203,
-0.7638088464736938,
-0.7477785348892212,
-0.3658183217048645,
0.6064555048942566,
-0.6938104033470154,
1.118353247642517,
-0.02758575789630413,
-0.9555543065071106,
0.021502207964658737,
-0.38526272773742676,
-0.2799043357372284,
-0.1935349702835083,
-0.12358316779136658,
0.10547301918268204,
-0.06037527695298195,
0.3168816566467285,
0.5695279836654663,
-0.9727783203125,
0.3187527358531952,
-0.5836158990859985,
-0.4208816885948181,
0.3989347219467163,
-0.5033708810806274,
0.5335544943809509,
0.26471540331840515,
0.00019441537733655423,
-0.1047319695353508,
-0.5666782855987549,
-0.045144569128751755,
0.11630681157112122,
-0.4812356233596802,
-0.18898560106754303,
-0.04430496692657471,
-0.16720570623874664,
0.3702087104320526,
0.16804811358451843,
-0.6385010480880737,
0.3892195522785187,
-0.03054293803870678,
0.3191165030002594,
0.3399296700954437,
0.12128187716007233,
0.09542243182659149,
-0.5592737793922424,
0.5932759046554565,
0.021024005487561226,
0.207166388630867,
-0.13429933786392212,
-0.4889257252216339,
-0.9814206957817078,
-0.27826282382011414,
0.15103456377983093,
0.5059520602226257,
-0.7100219130516052,
-0.04891509190201759,
-0.19383081793785095,
-0.9261556267738342,
-0.6047137379646301,
0.20698340237140656,
0.14959527552127838,
0.6024650931358337,
0.49114468693733215,
0.06213141605257988,
-0.15936632454395294,
-1.0020523071289062,
-0.27063682675361633,
-0.1781238317489624,
0.029277047142386436,
0.47522515058517456,
0.6347146034240723,
-0.28111347556114197,
0.662093997001648,
-0.624211311340332,
0.08010999113321304,
-0.08547473698854446,
0.11747551709413528,
0.1457749903202057,
-0.03603830188512802,
0.13227152824401855,
-0.6785195469856262,
-0.1184154748916626,
-0.18639011681079865,
-0.725520670413971,
-0.16647398471832275,
-0.1611792892217636,
-0.4818485975265503,
-0.1771094650030136,
0.6446428894996643,
-1.2111907005310059,
-0.0813906267285347,
0.5111340880393982,
-0.061642635613679886,
0.8636355996131897,
0.05046841874718666,
0.3826259970664978,
-0.9948817491531372,
0.21360373497009277,
-0.17424499988555908,
-0.08758682757616043,
-0.6293846368789673,
0.28656986355781555,
0.2343221753835678,
0.07125148177146912,
-0.37557610869407654,
0.691323459148407,
-0.5400916337966919,
-0.12723729014396667,
0.09504545480012894,
0.2430538833141327,
0.49911826848983765,
0.24940510094165802,
0.013856543228030205,
0.847227931022644,
0.6013461351394653,
-0.47074538469314575,
0.519245982170105,
0.12874382734298706,
-0.41157785058021545,
0.31859180331230164,
-0.6860894560813904,
0.27883613109588623,
-0.25426456332206726,
0.6333475112915039,
-1.0822736024856567,
-0.5127076506614685,
0.02514600194990635,
-0.24923965334892273,
0.0782570168375969,
-0.05331389978528023,
-0.7545875906944275,
-0.33846068382263184,
-0.4494751989841461,
0.4134576618671417,
-0.04999273642897606,
-0.5518373847007751,
0.6912686228752136,
0.2938929796218872,
-0.03396439552307129,
-0.6744542717933655,
-0.29112592339515686,
-0.12184298783540726,
-0.010003621689975262,
-0.9416777491569519,
0.07269594818353653,
-0.34363794326782227,
-0.5079010725021362,
-0.08627653121948242,
-0.1224105954170227,
-0.3137330412864685,
0.060399238020181656,
0.22656840085983276,
0.06063403561711311,
-0.37637779116630554,
0.33299607038497925,
0.2061827927827835,
0.26790788769721985,
0.2835308015346527,
-0.02868364378809929,
0.7490513324737549,
-0.26573726534843445,
-0.6461175084114075,
-0.0011659028241410851,
0.6764673590660095,
0.8282530903816223,
-0.3671634793281555,
0.4165000319480896,
0.5626664757728577,
-0.5561900734901428,
-0.26942262053489685,
-0.9364917874336243,
-0.05999865382909775,
-0.36842963099479675,
0.30283209681510925,
-0.7369147539138794,
-0.8182904720306396,
0.646957278251648,
-0.19607962667942047,
0.2233998328447342,
0.7226144075393677,
0.7237755656242371,
-0.36540526151657104,
0.539220929145813,
-0.06056968867778778,
-0.02417970634996891,
-0.1983533799648285,
-0.15269719064235687,
-0.1582787036895752,
-0.6461324095726013,
-0.5097723007202148,
-0.6320265531539917,
0.03754996880888939,
-0.08893349766731262,
-0.8579649925231934,
0.1596265435218811,
0.6509432196617126,
-0.34642457962036133,
0.14083121716976166,
-0.03538460657000542,
0.36137616634368896,
0.5832355618476868,
0.023529576137661934,
0.5859560966491699,
-0.4917300045490265,
-0.1212477907538414,
0.2922700345516205,
-0.5682433843612671,
-0.30632293224334717,
0.9732582569122314,
0.48517999053001404,
0.9110100865364075,
0.2631637156009674,
0.6482559442520142,
-0.018654709681868553,
0.47371619939804077,
-0.8138182759284973,
0.45682212710380554,
-0.007902815006673336,
-1.017362356185913,
-0.2818608582019806,
-0.4507015645503998,
-0.45973077416419983,
0.24828097224235535,
-0.13433583080768585,
-0.4657670855522156,
0.11076691001653671,
-0.10831426829099655,
-0.19574888050556183,
0.36337438225746155,
-0.6271808743476868,
0.6771893501281738,
-0.25471508502960205,
-0.07509095221757889,
0.007110689301043749,
-0.39244040846824646,
0.7030413746833801,
-0.34222570061683655,
0.23783214390277863,
-0.3921184539794922,
-0.08335930109024048,
0.7409809827804565,
-0.34245365858078003,
0.4514755308628082,
0.02069028466939926,
-0.2755119800567627,
0.5232701301574707,
0.31751391291618347,
0.4847332835197449,
0.11177590489387512,
-0.2364797592163086,
0.37330275774002075,
0.27285701036453247,
-0.12053968757390976,
-0.6290416717529297,
0.8194559216499329,
-0.9755918979644775,
-0.63022381067276,
-0.14371813833713531,
-0.7031751275062561,
-0.6739802360534668,
0.19221143424510956,
0.3474925756454468,
0.4053010940551758,
-0.09311219304800034,
0.16665904223918915,
0.853484570980072,
-0.19963836669921875,
0.20531275868415833,
0.37766361236572266,
-0.3438294231891632,
-0.3488897681236267,
0.7113794088363647,
0.2388228476047516,
0.16672806441783905,
0.5626025795936584,
0.2594203054904938,
-0.6237685084342957,
-0.3575790822505951,
-0.794482946395874,
0.47644147276878357,
-1.036144495010376,
-0.17722097039222717,
-0.8686837553977966,
-0.1935160607099533,
-0.25010567903518677,
0.14817307889461517,
-0.4586520195007324,
-0.32141971588134766,
-0.09302642196416855,
0.20497511327266693,
0.15484929084777832,
0.7767447233200073,
0.32658809423446655,
-0.14799150824546814,
-0.9590938091278076,
0.5033602714538574,
0.46303799748420715,
0.41116195917129517,
0.06141296774148941,
-0.6288407444953918,
-0.031338926404714584,
-0.20859159529209137,
-0.053234782069921494,
-1.0055475234985352,
-0.22275619208812714,
0.22201961278915405,
0.8796921372413635,
0.21298426389694214,
0.16495808959007263,
0.6018436551094055,
-0.4263969659805298,
0.5253934860229492,
0.07747379690408707,
-0.9066938161849976,
0.26854678988456726,
-0.5879191756248474,
0.27889445424079895,
0.7279441952705383,
0.852912187576294,
-0.7725474238395691,
-0.15978430211544037,
-0.3814650774002075,
-0.6601054668426514,
0.364009290933609,
0.11369426548480988,
-0.11050699651241302,
0.1256127953529358,
0.550232470035553,
0.25293272733688354,
0.21576768159866333,
-0.2848855257034302,
-0.17457237839698792,
-0.11831820756196976,
-0.01996600814163685,
0.14732559025287628,
-0.1050787940621376,
-0.11887330561876297,
-0.11322224885225296,
0.6234213709831238,
-0.1640901416540146,
0.08130914717912674,
0.2535388767719269,
-0.09510893374681473,
-0.05268370360136032,
0.29017192125320435,
0.34156522154808044,
0.6844902038574219,
-0.17787086963653564,
0.12267690896987915,
0.33858758211135864,
-0.3821829557418823,
-0.0318802110850811,
0.22910986840724945,
-0.24239377677440643,
-0.04787570238113403,
0.49108120799064636,
0.24073146283626556,
-0.07839985191822052,
-0.8754828572273254,
0.5639011263847351,
-0.3399336636066437,
-0.5565085411071777,
-0.11101551353931427,
0.14835481345653534,
0.710800290107727,
0.33384278416633606,
0.37253400683403015,
-0.05461649224162102,
0.32328349351882935,
-0.531680166721344,
0.23483645915985107,
0.38720840215682983,
-0.3401157557964325,
-0.049388814717531204,
0.6701655983924866,
0.22651733458042145,
-0.03822777792811394,
0.4968574047088623,
-0.12213455140590668,
-0.514764130115509,
0.41343384981155396,
0.17429174482822418,
0.751037061214447,
0.07293820381164551,
0.15243735909461975,
0.34748318791389465,
0.3680564761161804,
-0.20732538402080536,
0.6675634980201721,
-0.006459170486778021,
-0.8285008668899536,
-0.5994300842285156,
-0.5761606693267822,
-0.8171282410621643,
0.23558147251605988,
-0.5631353259086609,
0.16230596601963043,
-0.30213624238967896,
0.1902576982975006,
0.1361389309167862,
0.08095858991146088,
-0.8022717833518982,
0.3291928768157959,
0.22875316441059113,
1.3870059251785278,
-0.7703882455825806,
0.8462206125259399,
0.7297790050506592,
-0.4413262903690338,
-0.9986445903778076,
0.4278453290462494,
-0.04386487230658531,
-0.5387752652168274,
0.6222873330116272,
0.22294461727142334,
-0.5118411779403687,
-0.15504053235054016,
-0.4998322129249573,
-0.9339941143989563,
0.9501129984855652,
0.6686058044433594,
-0.6232556104660034,
0.09624413400888443,
0.020608898252248764,
0.38336044549942017,
-0.25860559940338135,
0.5291843414306641,
0.5862070322036743,
0.5644412636756897,
0.175945445895195,
-0.7790554761886597,
0.00991024635732174,
-0.2493545264005661,
-0.5851402878761292,
0.11760088056325912,
-0.9370251297950745,
1.0304347276687622,
-0.05955740436911583,
0.08283549547195435,
-0.10676468908786774,
0.6150364279747009,
0.37216895818710327,
0.3612107038497925,
0.6651321649551392,
0.5013843774795532,
1.0188552141189575,
-0.16177815198898315,
0.9419556260108948,
-0.18105517327785492,
0.2485601305961609,
1.159713864326477,
-0.24414780735969543,
1.0797244310379028,
0.3016536235809326,
-0.16391794383525848,
0.29935845732688904,
0.8426697254180908,
0.285576194524765,
0.21226997673511505,
0.43866294622421265,
-0.18988503515720367,
-0.7249331474304199,
-0.24448195099830627,
-0.315464049577713,
0.5356727838516235,
0.3054083585739136,
0.12946127355098724,
-0.31629836559295654,
-0.567572295665741,
0.16618278622627258,
-0.11028332263231277,
-0.14890432357788086,
0.48087140917778015,
0.07567843794822693,
-0.9306749701499939,
0.3931160271167755,
0.039646029472351074,
0.4271914064884186,
-0.4514407217502594,
0.018249407410621643,
-0.7139179110527039,
-0.011139251291751862,
-0.18111565709114075,
-0.9625214338302612,
0.0364547036588192,
0.050946976989507675,
-0.3460259735584259,
0.3370966911315918,
0.6244620680809021,
-0.43161725997924805,
-0.5413504242897034,
0.35512876510620117,
0.9784409403800964,
0.3077712953090668,
-0.5039786696434021,
-0.7373301982879639,
0.004823781084269285,
-0.2025478333234787,
-0.5316500663757324,
0.13321004807949066,
0.7300100922584534,
-0.2721315026283264,
0.9622679352760315,
0.6571979522705078,
0.008361058309674263,
0.10789646208286285,
0.45949894189834595,
1.1437779664993286,
-0.4986947178840637,
-0.09891226887702942,
-0.7097850441932678,
0.12916801869869232,
-0.12004159390926361,
-0.6478138566017151,
0.789586067199707,
0.6829476356506348,
0.7458464503288269,
0.08450151979923248,
0.8018930554389954,
0.2250504195690155,
0.6708365678787231,
-0.4399386942386627,
0.5605245232582092,
-0.7523398399353027,
0.223606675863266,
-0.35680505633354187,
-0.9691048264503479,
-0.07299540191888809,
0.12717096507549286,
-0.19124507904052734,
-0.14455853402614594,
0.5893150568008423,
0.8116860389709473,
-0.074200339615345,
0.10328032821416855,
0.30683931708335876,
-0.009111153893172741,
0.43170487880706787,
0.5212597846984863,
1.2913933992385864,
-0.42376604676246643,
0.8395183086395264,
-0.2960308790206909,
-0.1895466148853302,
-0.05766378715634346,
-0.7262789011001587,
-0.8552148938179016,
-0.5299559831619263,
-0.17839156091213226,
-0.22692953050136566,
-0.1046418845653534,
0.7659516930580139,
0.6123253703117371,
-0.7891928553581238,
-0.10716523230075836,
0.22841878235340118,
0.12798455357551575,
-0.09800001233816147,
-0.12734335660934448,
0.4787762761116028,
-0.18549300730228424,
-0.6240402460098267,
0.37132784724235535,
0.2318658083677292,
-0.305322527885437,
-0.6058788299560547,
-0.15150074660778046,
-0.3657083511352539,
0.3515675961971283,
0.4312323033809662,
0.025315038859844208,
-0.7073575258255005,
-0.20414312183856964,
0.42477136850357056,
-0.14961567521095276,
-0.2187473177909851,
0.7871510982513428,
-0.15296095609664917,
0.39833295345306396,
0.6875991225242615,
0.9645566344261169,
0.6227511763572693,
0.20801375806331635,
0.413703590631485,
-0.5417875051498413,
-0.3467909097671509,
0.12390247732400894,
0.46923986077308655,
0.2755143642425537,
-0.1528448611497879,
0.5193095207214355,
0.2418074756860733,
-0.5120469927787781,
-0.5017781853675842,
0.18501318991184235,
-0.9528828859329224,
-0.44063907861709595,
1.4414255619049072,
-0.34634676575660706,
-0.08299015462398529,
-0.4315112233161926,
-0.17448249459266663,
0.025211961939930916,
-0.35771435499191284,
0.4100340008735657,
1.113137125968933,
-0.2912677228450775,
-0.15147675573825836,
-0.6934882998466492,
0.30016419291496277,
0.1258394867181778,
-1.2232972383499146,
0.28951385617256165,
0.6613904237747192,
0.36666902899742126,
0.10435221344232559,
0.7372118234634399,
0.07600297778844833,
0.27695757150650024,
0.1085110679268837,
0.06388093531131744,
-0.04800919070839882,
-0.4417997896671295,
0.1466136872768402,
0.4369509220123291,
0.1823788434267044,
-0.08342964202165604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14101v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14101v1
|
Cost-Efficient Subjective Task Annotation and Modeling through Few-Shot Annotator Adaptation
| 2024-02-21T19:53:36 | 2024-02-21T19:53:36 |
Preni Golazizian, Ali Omrani, Alireza S. Ziabari, Morteza Dehghani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In subjective NLP tasks, where a single ground truth does not exist, the
inclusion of diverse annotators becomes crucial as their unique perspectives
significantly influence the annotations. In realistic scenarios, the annotation
budget often becomes the main determinant of the number of perspectives (i.e.,
annotators) included in the data and subsequent modeling. We introduce a novel
framework for annotation collection and modeling in subjective tasks that aims
to minimize the annotation budget while maximizing the predictive performance
for each annotator. Our framework has a two-stage design: first, we rely on a
small set of annotators to build a multitask model, and second, we augment the
model for a new perspective by strategically annotating a few samples per
annotator. To test our framework at scale, we introduce and release a unique
dataset, Moral Foundations Subjective Corpus, of 2000 Reddit posts annotated by
24 annotators for moral sentiment. We demonstrate that our framework surpasses
the previous SOTA in capturing the annotators' individual perspectives with as
little as 25% of the original annotation budget on two datasets. Furthermore,
our framework results in more equitable models, reducing the performance
disparity among annotators.
|
[
-0.5651029348373413,
-0.31797221302986145,
0.4840325713157654,
0.18326623737812042,
-0.44710424542427063,
-0.42050203680992126,
-0.06580902636051178,
-0.6101557016372681,
-0.05922497436404228,
0.7014756798744202,
-0.7942224144935608,
-0.4057360291481018,
-0.8060359954833984,
0.13681113719940186,
0.08353565633296967,
1.4759904146194458,
0.4085816740989685,
-0.2554709017276764,
-0.1742895096540451,
-0.44609031081199646,
-0.1544712334871292,
-0.47268784046173096,
-0.590859055519104,
-0.1829221546649933,
0.5937536954879761,
0.4523821175098419,
0.5065851807594299,
0.2622631788253784,
0.8643064498901367,
0.19775934517383575,
0.15916500985622406,
-0.03674134239554405,
-0.3725176751613617,
-0.1008991003036499,
-0.30106741189956665,
-0.5659390091896057,
-0.37162673473358154,
0.10925249010324478,
0.15757551789283752,
0.6502639651298523,
0.13587552309036255,
0.6547223329544067,
0.21468715369701385,
0.7258042693138123,
-0.9813240766525269,
0.2759392559528351,
-0.5465250611305237,
0.23548656702041626,
-0.10064837336540222,
-0.03821885958313942,
-0.41832441091537476,
-0.35273000597953796,
0.25015586614608765,
-0.9778724312782288,
-0.012602158822119236,
-0.19730515778064728,
0.42312735319137573,
0.6509200930595398,
-0.15236133337020874,
-0.09532882273197174,
-0.46395811438560486,
0.9185011982917786,
-0.7327649593353271,
0.07087396830320358,
0.38061001896858215,
0.04338402673602104,
0.36945873498916626,
-0.314097136259079,
-0.45124027132987976,
0.02408836968243122,
-0.015511763282120228,
0.1597858965396881,
-0.16535082459449768,
0.025213012471795082,
0.41647863388061523,
-0.101100392639637,
-0.02247176319360733,
-0.22176367044448853,
-0.16492073237895966,
0.17197439074516296,
0.615572452545166,
0.0414813756942749,
-0.20968061685562134,
-0.5924516320228577,
-0.5443153381347656,
0.17763561010360718,
-0.1514432430267334,
0.2444823682308197,
0.2089756429195404,
0.5297978520393372,
-0.26378190517425537,
0.6516711115837097,
-0.19277049601078033,
0.744315505027771,
0.350369930267334,
-0.3079911768436432,
0.34538036584854126,
-0.5336231589317322,
-0.17795203626155853,
-0.18862777948379517,
0.5221849083900452,
0.7192756533622742,
0.3731071352958679,
0.26052093505859375,
-0.07941587269306183,
0.05596703663468361,
0.6374502182006836,
-0.763161301612854,
-0.32702726125717163,
0.18193559348583221,
-0.592858076095581,
-0.5219125151634216,
-0.28419849276542664,
-0.7166226506233215,
-0.7316509485244751,
-0.4748065769672394,
0.27005547285079956,
-0.23946502804756165,
-0.2967587411403656,
0.10574290156364441,
0.07822434604167938,
0.023531753569841385,
0.6153485774993896,
-0.7125384211540222,
0.29625001549720764,
0.8231757879257202,
1.100143551826477,
-0.049793388694524765,
-0.030175862833857536,
-0.5404866933822632,
-0.1875600665807724,
-0.23418615758419037,
0.983360230922699,
-0.3789314925670624,
-0.08505325019359589,
-0.016681667417287827,
-0.20281870663166046,
0.26856473088264465,
-0.18839047849178314,
0.8109229207038879,
-0.33185216784477234,
-0.03176245093345642,
-0.7009668946266174,
-0.4664028584957123,
-0.35994023084640503,
0.4569762051105499,
-0.7822979688644409,
0.845037043094635,
0.17848661541938782,
-1.2108937501907349,
0.7221373915672302,
-1.128140926361084,
-0.18538115918636322,
0.1283668726682663,
0.0857991948723793,
-0.15051870048046112,
0.34732556343078613,
0.04202236980199814,
0.7139567732810974,
-0.22564449906349182,
0.18333226442337036,
-0.4972875714302063,
-0.2712501585483551,
0.20637200772762299,
0.09049460291862488,
0.8705217838287354,
0.13401593267917633,
-0.25187569856643677,
0.11179237067699432,
-0.7274121642112732,
-0.27403730154037476,
-0.17904570698738098,
-0.2904585301876068,
-0.5906578898429871,
0.10053371638059616,
0.48701125383377075,
0.5723516941070557,
0.14787781238555908,
-0.7245910167694092,
0.050212372094392776,
-0.45117631554603577,
0.08507301658391953,
0.9624888896942139,
0.06646233797073364,
0.6806330680847168,
-0.40849846601486206,
0.3507292866706848,
0.227924644947052,
0.29747143387794495,
0.09316995739936829,
-0.40430182218551636,
-0.7311160564422607,
-0.521345317363739,
0.10208499431610107,
0.4192582368850708,
-0.5172414779663086,
0.3088556230068207,
-0.21044866740703583,
-0.3345053493976593,
-0.572653591632843,
0.09254974126815796,
0.278389036655426,
0.4706915616989136,
0.3103684186935425,
-0.587024450302124,
-0.399880588054657,
-1.0389963388442993,
-0.5167362093925476,
-0.3328824043273926,
-0.03399989753961563,
0.25481733679771423,
0.7408545613288879,
0.23001258075237274,
1.100131869316101,
-0.40839672088623047,
-0.5092687606811523,
-0.06326846778392792,
0.3848356306552887,
0.24258172512054443,
0.516076922416687,
0.6939963102340698,
-0.8330438733100891,
-0.2615836262702942,
-0.21195417642593384,
-0.8285723328590393,
-0.008327268064022064,
-0.5030394792556763,
-0.2272222489118576,
0.07989760488271713,
0.07550375908613205,
-0.3288695812225342,
0.28376296162605286,
0.5218073129653931,
-0.3885580599308014,
0.33552056550979614,
0.215911865234375,
0.06314975023269653,
-0.9247517585754395,
0.17681819200515747,
0.3141256272792816,
-0.5172320604324341,
-0.4319098889827728,
-0.003249041736125946,
-0.16542711853981018,
0.168889120221138,
-0.6355696320533752,
0.36960655450820923,
-0.10775111615657806,
0.0019376069540157914,
-0.44010278582572937,
0.30598685145378113,
-0.020900016650557518,
0.8423744440078735,
0.03889647498726845,
0.43324893712997437,
0.3471490144729614,
-0.409003883600235,
0.024093685671687126,
0.4588716924190521,
-0.15252001583576202,
0.9851500988006592,
-0.5759010910987854,
0.3418906629085541,
-0.454239159822464,
0.25450757145881653,
-0.6812492609024048,
-0.07442957162857056,
0.558020830154419,
-0.14742588996887207,
-0.22555390000343323,
-0.4919174313545227,
-0.3067803680896759,
0.014238190837204456,
-0.5036584734916687,
0.20732130110263824,
0.0820346474647522,
-0.44587141275405884,
0.8207831978797913,
0.5972030758857727,
-0.25742629170417786,
-0.6473371982574463,
-0.9101812243461609,
0.04951510950922966,
-0.2431216537952423,
-0.21715258061885834,
0.05552426725625992,
-0.04231278598308563,
-0.2876410186290741,
0.2735888957977295,
-0.1591186225414276,
0.03190794214606285,
0.2715994715690613,
0.5450790524482727,
0.1905631422996521,
-0.027859099209308624,
0.29559949040412903,
-0.05827949941158295,
-0.3112832009792328,
0.164617121219635,
-0.5700326561927795,
0.07819002866744995,
-0.275061696767807,
-0.31540820002555847,
-0.43766334652900696,
0.5619224905967712,
0.2340969294309616,
-0.37164372205734253,
0.7328206896781921,
0.6375406980514526,
-0.6497183442115784,
-0.10964319109916687,
-0.6367303133010864,
0.019307276234030724,
-0.3874182403087616,
0.4315834939479828,
-0.5333707928657532,
-0.819097101688385,
0.25403451919555664,
-0.05719485506415367,
0.6348533630371094,
0.3320028483867645,
0.5324422121047974,
-0.10111785680055618,
0.6209360957145691,
0.7765655517578125,
0.09577256441116333,
0.5352950096130371,
-0.17938415706157684,
0.17533257603645325,
-0.8037167191505432,
0.09312832355499268,
-0.3893924355506897,
-0.4253731966018677,
-0.6388265490531921,
-0.6088094115257263,
0.30644214153289795,
0.04980131983757019,
-0.18601246178150177,
0.06046919524669647,
-0.7216631770133972,
0.4973665177822113,
0.814516544342041,
0.2848378121852875,
0.34531235694885254,
-0.1871839016675949,
0.38536006212234497,
-0.14613240957260132,
-0.4931402802467346,
-0.9209632873535156,
1.3796194791793823,
0.143399178981781,
0.22015932202339172,
0.15309546887874603,
0.8766393661499023,
0.3104079067707062,
0.6419827342033386,
-0.8270881772041321,
0.4676333963871002,
-0.36238327622413635,
-0.7885853052139282,
-0.017198272049427032,
-0.12891393899917603,
-0.11651790142059326,
0.3748995363712311,
-0.4282604157924652,
-0.7124064564704895,
0.6444544792175293,
0.27545398473739624,
-0.7951421737670898,
0.16954387724399567,
-0.5649670362472534,
0.9749985337257385,
0.08284059166908264,
-0.6987460255622864,
-0.20450511574745178,
-0.7311474680900574,
0.3773672878742218,
-0.365799218416214,
0.21111121773719788,
-0.6318949460983276,
-0.25593072175979614,
0.947814404964447,
0.12165677547454834,
1.130541443824768,
-0.6645638942718506,
0.2958761751651764,
0.3905586898326874,
0.029583020135760307,
0.4806687533855438,
0.2485172301530838,
-0.3661145567893982,
0.18136762082576752,
0.13572444021701813,
-0.4892951548099518,
-0.2608529329299927,
0.35924598574638367,
-0.5667340755462646,
-0.3528122305870056,
-0.5340089797973633,
-0.5951448678970337,
-0.31305935978889465,
0.08047990500926971,
0.035612113773822784,
0.11923310905694962,
-0.2142757922410965,
0.14271125197410583,
0.0965159684419632,
0.04827841371297836,
0.5447537899017334,
0.11453340202569962,
0.21657152473926544,
-0.2832983136177063,
0.47793686389923096,
-0.14044035971164703,
0.0031115692108869553,
0.16713882982730865,
0.2110474854707718,
-0.12709395587444305,
-0.41198113560676575,
-0.12559731304645538,
-0.05327237769961357,
-0.8836811780929565,
-0.3787834048271179,
-0.9785763621330261,
0.5243881344795227,
-0.13944090902805328,
-0.33901768922805786,
-0.6456171274185181,
-0.6593671441078186,
-0.3145390748977661,
-0.21937726438045502,
0.6475782990455627,
0.4190792739391327,
-0.3943789005279541,
0.3663155138492584,
-0.5995863080024719,
0.4574369490146637,
0.29644137620925903,
0.15953493118286133,
-0.2077597677707672,
-0.23854371905326843,
-0.3252106308937073,
0.08857227116823196,
-0.28535085916519165,
-0.7468147277832031,
0.20576484501361847,
0.21541519463062286,
-0.06802976876497269,
0.323263019323349,
0.3732207119464874,
0.658427894115448,
-0.3754059970378876,
0.7755688428878784,
0.3804739713668823,
-1.1524732112884521,
0.36060670018196106,
-0.26807647943496704,
0.2693341076374054,
1.175284504890442,
0.3422875702381134,
-0.40162956714630127,
-0.2119394689798355,
-0.3957192599773407,
-0.6670199036598206,
0.9679430723190308,
0.20367997884750366,
0.28732991218566895,
0.17906750738620758,
0.5402421951293945,
0.3576638400554657,
0.22102949023246765,
-0.8911375999450684,
0.015437237918376923,
-0.6536462306976318,
-0.4810826778411865,
-0.09286374598741531,
-0.3441101014614105,
-0.3488194942474365,
-0.17701582610607147,
0.547809362411499,
-0.5932455658912659,
0.26805242896080017,
0.2755671739578247,
-0.16501674056053162,
0.02570786140859127,
0.2408515363931656,
0.36949098110198975,
0.5286194682121277,
-0.2374279648065567,
0.2773464322090149,
0.20189112424850464,
-0.2161521166563034,
-0.0032382511999458075,
0.08921398967504501,
-0.277007520198822,
0.04124654829502106,
0.3381406366825104,
0.8629315495491028,
0.3005354702472687,
-0.47560450434684753,
0.7398576736450195,
0.1419813185930252,
-0.07019218057394028,
-0.4304603636264801,
-0.17927883565425873,
0.31138622760772705,
0.6603283882141113,
0.072081059217453,
0.6063810586929321,
0.5128141641616821,
-0.19941246509552002,
0.1634264588356018,
0.22479534149169922,
-0.37577152252197266,
-0.39190322160720825,
0.6789698004722595,
0.36821678280830383,
-0.12129710614681244,
0.09077401459217072,
-0.36948877573013306,
-0.3459441363811493,
0.3018834590911865,
0.16114941239356995,
1.0455800294876099,
0.19688305258750916,
0.42099952697753906,
0.5071085095405579,
0.2411929816007614,
-0.1291060894727707,
0.2610197067260742,
-0.24674437940120697,
-0.7734331488609314,
-0.4417608976364136,
-0.7529405355453491,
-0.5302999019622803,
-0.3914596438407898,
-0.791782796382904,
0.26683810353279114,
-0.5490729808807373,
-0.45146429538726807,
0.2099328339099884,
0.060461271554231644,
-0.9539169669151306,
0.31850185990333557,
0.17591068148612976,
0.44308024644851685,
-0.8496203422546387,
0.471224844455719,
0.6535287499427795,
-0.5209622979164124,
-0.3229723274707794,
-0.04413443058729172,
0.14938683807849884,
-0.6677141189575195,
0.5702376961708069,
0.12225864827632904,
-0.26983383297920227,
-0.14309057593345642,
-0.4582495391368866,
-0.5436769127845764,
0.5071854591369629,
0.4750359356403351,
-0.8112363815307617,
-0.25196173787117004,
0.05282088369131088,
0.44576090574264526,
-0.5604662299156189,
0.0826701819896698,
0.402627170085907,
0.5186449289321899,
-0.2537657916545868,
-0.5149142146110535,
0.16048552095890045,
-0.1559380143880844,
-0.14685001969337463,
-0.0689755454659462,
-0.37660086154937744,
0.6844789981842041,
-0.388624906539917,
-0.06533749401569366,
-0.22984705865383148,
0.46440184116363525,
0.2805275321006775,
0.2567574977874756,
0.8628525137901306,
0.22770923376083374,
0.5731006264686584,
0.1190505102276802,
1.0123590230941772,
-0.2652255892753601,
0.6537603735923767,
1.3823282718658447,
-0.271389901638031,
0.864538848400116,
0.6481252908706665,
0.03638933598995209,
0.10194654762744904,
0.3798051178455353,
-0.07133282721042633,
0.5739452838897705,
0.1280221790075302,
-0.3249698281288147,
-0.6047977805137634,
-0.5086311101913452,
0.029493341222405434,
0.5657088756561279,
-0.16478903591632843,
-0.23696574568748474,
-0.04552917182445526,
0.23594865202903748,
0.04179483279585838,
-0.03924933448433876,
-0.08387253433465958,
1.0485854148864746,
0.19172413647174835,
-0.4629760980606079,
0.3035457730293274,
-0.004095485899597406,
0.8615933656692505,
-0.208730086684227,
0.132942333817482,
-0.04393567517399788,
0.27086541056632996,
-0.31406378746032715,
-0.5160441398620605,
0.5693977475166321,
0.34908097982406616,
-0.1809820979833603,
-0.5257837772369385,
0.6747657060623169,
-0.07711333781480789,
-0.8644267320632935,
0.17279894649982452,
0.5338107943534851,
-0.06968425959348679,
-0.45176035165786743,
-0.7630420923233032,
-0.027499690651893616,
-0.10976745933294296,
-0.534862756729126,
-0.009602493606507778,
0.46786510944366455,
0.14959701895713806,
0.2706034481525421,
0.566496729850769,
0.08441720902919769,
-0.058670222759246826,
0.02469358965754509,
0.7720484137535095,
-0.8124697804450989,
-0.5548966526985168,
-0.8284997344017029,
0.7824358940124512,
-0.07914353907108307,
-0.5803652405738831,
0.37536707520484924,
0.2885183095932007,
0.9454523921012878,
-0.23831328749656677,
0.8786698579788208,
-0.06321050971746445,
0.45631706714630127,
-0.2374865710735321,
0.5752936005592346,
-0.8110178709030151,
-0.19106870889663696,
-0.5931550860404968,
-0.758000910282135,
-0.4707842171192169,
0.9799757599830627,
-0.27353665232658386,
-0.1619335561990738,
0.6244059801101685,
0.40194836258888245,
-0.02574682980775833,
0.5053145885467529,
0.11173830926418304,
0.01139827910810709,
0.18639689683914185,
0.658883273601532,
0.7489463090896606,
-0.2619912922382355,
0.14892613887786865,
-0.7085959911346436,
-0.2538272440433502,
-0.0304307509213686,
-1.0429271459579468,
-0.8119662404060364,
-0.5571150183677673,
-0.7420201897621155,
0.08098750561475754,
0.04658789560198784,
1.2310004234313965,
0.9964941143989563,
-0.8089175224304199,
-0.036573730409145355,
-0.18612703680992126,
-0.1782509684562683,
-0.39804700016975403,
-0.1938321441411972,
0.1722121238708496,
-0.30587238073349,
-0.8228566646575928,
-0.21175630390644073,
0.2640351355075836,
-0.5904456377029419,
-0.06519206613302231,
0.2935449182987213,
-0.3520240783691406,
0.14787352085113525,
0.9294594526290894,
-0.19810470938682556,
-0.7756478786468506,
-0.6016485691070557,
-0.09677306562662125,
0.16634608805179596,
0.2468693107366562,
0.8565537333488464,
-0.6303076148033142,
0.36512163281440735,
0.22044610977172852,
0.7760694026947021,
0.6425592303276062,
0.08903197199106216,
0.10345873981714249,
-0.7228903770446777,
0.24040137231349945,
0.6220532655715942,
0.08283349126577377,
0.48342692852020264,
-0.39142045378685,
0.5999053716659546,
0.2527911961078644,
-0.22021079063415527,
-0.8380028009414673,
0.15044789016246796,
-1.2497831583023071,
-0.2358977347612381,
0.9122827649116516,
-0.36224520206451416,
-0.053883519023656845,
-0.18995721638202667,
-0.28374844789505005,
0.21161529421806335,
-0.4636171758174896,
0.7217680215835571,
0.747894287109375,
-0.4137607514858246,
-0.2637363374233246,
-0.535561740398407,
0.4456028342247009,
0.455704003572464,
-0.9943569302558899,
0.3152678310871124,
0.6005420088768005,
0.26459652185440063,
0.3802829384803772,
0.863152265548706,
0.02107534557580948,
0.21109595894813538,
0.028443336486816406,
0.4333006739616394,
0.010794993489980698,
-0.20614737272262573,
-0.29399847984313965,
0.5851273536682129,
0.16188029944896698,
-0.4373885989189148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14086v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14086v1
|
LexC-Gen: Generating Data for Extremely Low-Resource Languages with Large Language Models and Bilingual Lexicons
| 2024-02-21T19:20:06 | 2024-02-21T19:20:06 |
Zheng-Xin Yong, Cristina Menghini, Stephen H. Bach
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Data scarcity in low-resource languages can be addressed with word-to-word
translations from labeled task data in high-resource languages using bilingual
lexicons. However, bilingual lexicons often have limited lexical overlap with
task data, which results in poor translation coverage and lexicon utilization.
We propose lexicon-conditioned data generation (LexC-Gen), a method that
generates low-resource-language classification task data at scale.
Specifically, LexC-Gen first uses high-resource-language words from bilingual
lexicons to generate lexicon-compatible task data, and then it translates them
into low-resource languages with bilingual lexicons via word translation.
Across 17 extremely low-resource languages, LexC-Gen generated data is
competitive with expert-translated gold data, and yields on average 5.6 and 8.9
points improvement over existing lexicon-based word translation methods on
sentiment analysis and topic classification tasks respectively. We show that
conditioning on bilingual lexicons is the key component of LexC-Gen. LexC-Gen
is also practical -- it only needs a single GPU to generate data at scale. It
works well with open-access LLMs, and its cost is one-fifth of the cost of
GPT4-based multilingual data generation.
|
[
-0.5169578194618225,
-0.487138956785202,
0.5429369807243347,
0.1857747584581375,
-0.17603200674057007,
0.09881904721260071,
-0.6381102800369263,
-0.19130049645900726,
0.21237002313137054,
0.3837803900241852,
-0.5522158145904541,
-0.6523609161376953,
-0.32377731800079346,
0.2208389937877655,
-0.1359712779521942,
1.1182034015655518,
0.06321823596954346,
-0.04439164698123932,
-0.3324575126171112,
-0.21323920786380768,
-0.03951435908675194,
-0.7671489119529724,
-0.7344973087310791,
-0.1898740828037262,
0.4588001072406769,
0.7018784284591675,
0.9919778108596802,
0.7401729822158813,
0.2797156870365143,
0.27104702591896057,
-0.05642079934477806,
0.4088079333305359,
-0.5351016521453857,
-0.08763833343982697,
-0.16066457331180573,
-0.3647729754447937,
-0.5420300960540771,
-0.17962677776813507,
0.5980942845344543,
0.9059134721755981,
-0.013061365112662315,
0.14185720682144165,
-0.0007352754473686218,
0.5893248319625854,
-0.8016727566719055,
0.2891960144042969,
-0.6894657015800476,
0.1289905458688736,
-0.47917449474334717,
-0.10451619327068329,
-0.5241656303405762,
-0.0601714625954628,
-0.5809435844421387,
-0.6603044867515564,
0.5003293752670288,
0.25378143787384033,
0.48243650794029236,
0.32441750168800354,
-0.19450049102306366,
-0.02223861962556839,
-0.751121997833252,
0.8547376990318298,
-0.682433545589447,
0.3086852431297302,
0.48606640100479126,
-0.16155904531478882,
0.07373768836259842,
-0.46092095971107483,
-0.6794527173042297,
-0.07200264185667038,
0.025346504524350166,
0.23775656521320343,
-0.07429767400026321,
0.015452222898602486,
0.5650173425674438,
0.36767882108688354,
-0.503534734249115,
0.2712138891220093,
-0.2307620793581009,
-0.1569780558347702,
0.5670221447944641,
0.29208722710609436,
0.5050327181816101,
-0.3278616666793823,
-0.0901615098118782,
-0.17954330146312714,
-0.910195529460907,
-0.2490980476140976,
0.4669327735900879,
0.7682017683982849,
-0.044861454516649246,
0.70297771692276,
-0.1727801412343979,
0.5632147789001465,
-0.26531484723091125,
-0.21086850762367249,
0.3637242615222931,
-0.7895168662071228,
-0.03859434276819229,
0.22620193660259247,
0.898310661315918,
0.1426296979188919,
0.12258153408765793,
-0.3402295708656311,
-0.3645000457763672,
0.052038028836250305,
-0.007664523087441921,
-0.8341857194900513,
0.13765759766101837,
-0.09442082792520523,
-0.281187504529953,
-0.0936896800994873,
-0.1853279322385788,
-0.935947060585022,
-0.18675261735916138,
-0.28275126218795776,
-0.17785562574863434,
-0.18535158038139343,
-0.31202176213264465,
0.0436737984418869,
0.05144016817212105,
-0.03139037266373634,
-0.14775721728801727,
-1.0735336542129517,
0.46428999304771423,
0.406546950340271,
0.960929811000824,
-0.31928750872612,
-0.19259056448936462,
-0.7763365507125854,
0.020695975050330162,
-0.39602628350257874,
0.4583803713321686,
-0.3358774185180664,
-0.5926599502563477,
0.1858040690422058,
-0.08132866770029068,
-0.10219969600439072,
-0.5907669067382812,
0.5681450366973877,
-0.3046485185623169,
-0.13485051691532135,
-0.3808165192604065,
-0.29429179430007935,
0.46043315529823303,
-0.045900098979473114,
-0.7262795567512512,
1.0503230094909668,
0.17823797464370728,
-1.1257230043411255,
0.35729119181632996,
-0.2752400040626526,
-0.62819904088974,
0.39864805340766907,
-0.1786280870437622,
-0.24542611837387085,
0.1033456102013588,
0.3110230267047882,
0.32126352190971375,
-0.5287728905677795,
0.17162877321243286,
-0.3148508071899414,
-0.019265253096818924,
0.1357896775007248,
-0.11439274251461029,
0.5356513261795044,
0.5306952595710754,
-0.3192197382450104,
-0.2625160217285156,
-0.48151126503944397,
0.01979425922036171,
0.1474088728427887,
-0.4766552150249481,
-0.43372052907943726,
0.19573749601840973,
0.20860454440116882,
0.22726400196552277,
0.36846691370010376,
-0.8399308919906616,
0.08965925872325897,
-0.28761592507362366,
0.27374279499053955,
0.22604955732822418,
-0.36139899492263794,
0.6466673612594604,
-0.20892474055290222,
0.6454118490219116,
-0.19257752597332,
-0.020685235038399696,
0.11031896620988846,
-0.5240200161933899,
-0.8073148131370544,
-0.0720033049583435,
0.24332992732524872,
0.7015784978866577,
-1.271036148071289,
0.4370533525943756,
-0.5480640530586243,
-0.3953280448913574,
-0.32923904061317444,
0.4224858582019806,
0.4963003396987915,
0.45215457677841187,
0.49013617634773254,
-0.10799424350261688,
-0.3881072700023651,
-0.9113624095916748,
0.07834740728139877,
-0.22025127708911896,
0.08927921950817108,
0.30760979652404785,
0.10916262865066528,
-0.1754281371831894,
0.7361055016517639,
-0.49245646595954895,
-0.1319008469581604,
-0.7018038630485535,
0.28805792331695557,
-0.0442398302257061,
0.3996734619140625,
0.6289651989936829,
-0.6190329194068909,
-0.32947343587875366,
0.17858649790287018,
-0.4301728904247284,
-0.23223742842674255,
-0.07232075929641724,
-0.17531614005565643,
0.47480905055999756,
0.8542079329490662,
-0.3396975100040436,
0.0976874828338623,
0.7402130365371704,
-0.29642364382743835,
0.3023921847343445,
-0.4832615256309509,
-0.1733713299036026,
-1.0846796035766602,
0.20553265511989594,
0.0985085517168045,
-0.2837507426738739,
-0.6850255131721497,
-0.03572125732898712,
0.1057676151394844,
-0.4587049186229706,
-0.3739128112792969,
0.6140976548194885,
-0.2610190808773041,
-0.07720568776130676,
-0.22019435465335846,
0.04721735790371895,
-0.3669033944606781,
0.44712772965431213,
0.3250311315059662,
0.7723323106765747,
0.36601313948631287,
-0.39220094680786133,
0.3032200038433075,
0.22410254180431366,
-0.4017523527145386,
0.15842486917972565,
-0.2507419288158417,
0.09433670341968536,
-0.13945944607257843,
0.03350801393389702,
-0.5459197759628296,
-0.24983122944831848,
-0.02827361226081848,
-0.2388797551393509,
0.323546826839447,
0.04213486239314079,
-0.8485514521598816,
-0.37749195098876953,
-0.030208075419068336,
0.8078379034996033,
0.5994580984115601,
-0.687812089920044,
0.27230802178382874,
0.3518557548522949,
-0.5899230241775513,
-0.3730887770652771,
-1.0187981128692627,
0.05232846364378929,
0.008554368279874325,
-0.3251184821128845,
0.40387821197509766,
-0.1090642660856247,
-0.28330937027931213,
0.278317391872406,
0.08163256198167801,
0.0260799340903759,
-0.17141775786876678,
0.1426933854818344,
0.3984580934047699,
-0.054722510278224945,
0.21953873336315155,
0.09048915654420853,
0.05946967750787735,
-0.10355420410633087,
-0.3235737085342407,
0.4920169711112976,
-0.11486003547906876,
-0.30306071043014526,
0.05015818029642105,
0.3683324456214905,
0.5661085844039917,
-0.2403002381324768,
0.670272707939148,
0.6231178641319275,
-0.3033314645290375,
-0.5370388627052307,
-0.34933677315711975,
0.14815935492515564,
-0.39619967341423035,
0.29630082845687866,
-0.3291972279548645,
-0.7476935982704163,
0.3611323833465576,
0.1311827003955841,
0.06588289886713028,
0.5905817747116089,
0.8938125371932983,
0.3728647828102112,
1.1672362089157104,
0.5932285189628601,
-0.406579852104187,
0.3672918677330017,
-0.1352226287126541,
0.30736106634140015,
-0.44557955861091614,
-0.07926981896162033,
-0.48619344830513,
-0.30610349774360657,
-0.7279803156852722,
-0.5696096420288086,
0.33759090304374695,
-0.08747844398021698,
-0.1948421448469162,
0.29466813802719116,
-0.36330071091651917,
0.3442080020904541,
0.7580613493919373,
0.0014667855575680733,
0.32615339756011963,
0.14962969720363617,
-0.2169000506401062,
0.0128684276714921,
-0.9593998193740845,
-0.1434108316898346,
1.079538106918335,
-0.08286319673061371,
0.6344149708747864,
-0.11094871163368225,
0.9072867631912231,
0.11367339640855789,
0.288541316986084,
-0.9304680824279785,
0.5511026978492737,
-0.6851217150688171,
-0.4829155504703522,
-0.18438026309013367,
-0.9109385013580322,
-0.7147701978683472,
-0.10554057359695435,
-0.3806533217430115,
-0.2755149006843567,
0.17892074584960938,
0.0988667830824852,
-0.4585210680961609,
0.5759721994400024,
-0.6202842593193054,
0.7212896347045898,
-0.4374028444290161,
-0.4290333688259125,
-0.24843312799930573,
-0.19055934250354767,
0.42308309674263,
-0.3960840702056885,
0.6415542960166931,
-0.27539464831352234,
-0.13327570259571075,
0.693939745426178,
-0.6941318511962891,
0.629185676574707,
-0.3529384136199951,
0.005868769716471434,
0.3481420576572418,
0.0633992925286293,
0.39805465936660767,
0.20508815348148346,
-0.06540387868881226,
-0.1058625653386116,
-0.14803200960159302,
-0.5409016013145447,
-0.23963254690170288,
0.8454310297966003,
-0.7256776094436646,
-0.339098185300827,
-0.2597399055957794,
-0.8721688389778137,
-0.46927666664123535,
0.07036221027374268,
0.5664180517196655,
0.35960572957992554,
-0.24953778088092804,
-0.010862737894058228,
0.5026101469993591,
-0.5572667717933655,
0.4313526153564453,
0.3306358754634857,
-0.017195498570799828,
-0.38497695326805115,
1.2741364240646362,
-0.013385086320340633,
0.24388940632343292,
0.14638064801692963,
-0.0015543439658358693,
-0.06989704072475433,
-0.4606517553329468,
-0.5850480794906616,
0.3126544952392578,
-0.25041162967681885,
-0.410749226808548,
-0.3607839345932007,
-0.30236536264419556,
-0.28260537981987,
-0.2058844268321991,
-0.49998939037323,
-0.43714776635169983,
-0.22321052849292755,
-0.04785298928618431,
0.2573918402194977,
0.5164673924446106,
-0.38890597224235535,
0.2421308159828186,
-0.7681443095207214,
0.5113519430160522,
0.310820072889328,
0.09373200684785843,
-0.3133693337440491,
-0.23032625019550323,
-0.3800447881221771,
0.040125202387571335,
-0.029918836429715157,
-0.4968492388725281,
0.6443828344345093,
0.3406206965446472,
0.33051005005836487,
0.34205079078674316,
0.20705316960811615,
0.26175278425216675,
-0.5525332689285278,
0.7373383641242981,
0.4589439332485199,
-0.9180859923362732,
0.3008638918399811,
-0.25367262959480286,
0.40778955817222595,
0.5407622456550598,
0.33199456334114075,
-0.628097414970398,
-0.6341413259506226,
-0.5475512146949768,
-0.9190096259117126,
0.8913525938987732,
0.23682329058647156,
0.1815481334924698,
-0.261898934841156,
0.3516431450843811,
-0.015611032955348492,
-0.013071038760244846,
-0.4879573881626129,
-0.06306703388690948,
-0.3457322120666504,
-0.2816753089427948,
-0.40615421533584595,
-0.20660856366157532,
-0.12138856202363968,
-0.24751310050487518,
0.6592735052108765,
-0.3840859830379486,
0.10951133072376251,
0.032742325216531754,
-0.0816747397184372,
-0.10879422724246979,
0.47462013363838196,
0.21780486404895782,
0.21232633292675018,
-0.06638439744710922,
0.24044424295425415,
0.3177058696746826,
-0.2879399061203003,
0.08032707124948502,
0.3103015124797821,
-0.25470995903015137,
0.04549248144030571,
0.22823426127433777,
0.9323999881744385,
0.12147285789251328,
-0.818718433380127,
0.5277634263038635,
-0.08915676176548004,
-0.37073665857315063,
-0.0753273293375969,
-0.07595326006412506,
0.2539849877357483,
-0.07574303448200226,
0.004039921332150698,
-0.07167957723140717,
-0.18291713297367096,
-0.4899154305458069,
-0.019172800704836845,
0.4860999882221222,
0.11449411511421204,
-0.34854090213775635,
0.8576524257659912,
0.19054245948791504,
0.41898301243782043,
0.9416232705116272,
-0.6828118562698364,
-0.3570951521396637,
0.6125384569168091,
0.5854141712188721,
0.6590086817741394,
-0.06523150205612183,
0.3371601700782776,
0.8129404187202454,
0.19977276027202606,
-0.39909443259239197,
0.477477490901947,
-0.27259472012519836,
-0.9784766435623169,
-0.5845192074775696,
-0.9133946895599365,
-0.47827866673469543,
0.11334426701068878,
-0.7597683072090149,
0.1710951179265976,
-0.4254194498062134,
-0.43435171246528625,
-0.16798478364944458,
-0.0668363943696022,
-0.8958988189697266,
-0.01897706836462021,
0.7192375659942627,
0.8327257633209229,
-1.090507984161377,
1.0440452098846436,
0.5692557692527771,
-0.2960686981678009,
-0.6950947642326355,
-0.3891579806804657,
-0.07959659397602081,
-0.8342722654342651,
0.7751337289810181,
-0.1957155168056488,
-0.11517002433538437,
0.04381159320473671,
-0.3758421540260315,
-0.8030126094818115,
0.7736806869506836,
0.559945821762085,
-0.7036962509155273,
-0.22619299590587616,
0.5313870906829834,
0.5641366839408875,
-0.26005399227142334,
-0.3310905396938324,
0.788841187953949,
0.604028582572937,
0.001992092002183199,
-0.7974809408187866,
0.04410402476787567,
-0.468555748462677,
0.08160412311553955,
0.32181301712989807,
-0.4772739112377167,
0.718573272228241,
-0.3825148344039917,
-0.4836730360984802,
0.16389696300029755,
0.5626125931739807,
0.1822875589132309,
0.12723255157470703,
0.6481606364250183,
1.0061020851135254,
0.6562232375144958,
-0.21786385774612427,
1.0599701404571533,
-0.7053338289260864,
0.3222004771232605,
0.9916934370994568,
-0.24398495256900787,
0.6959388256072998,
0.1995963603258133,
-0.03666425868868828,
0.2921305298805237,
0.538650393486023,
-0.16878826916217804,
0.4563051760196686,
0.2934281527996063,
-0.5065993666648865,
-0.4762682020664215,
-0.49784961342811584,
-0.11592796444892883,
0.23995232582092285,
0.5610833168029785,
-0.1319102644920349,
-0.25015148520469666,
0.21783967316150665,
0.2054181843996048,
0.057818133383989334,
-0.5643267631530762,
0.5989623665809631,
0.08731181174516678,
-0.6930368542671204,
0.7815543413162231,
0.1219794973731041,
0.7215808629989624,
-0.4475935101509094,
0.5732493996620178,
-0.6187607645988464,
0.11158926784992218,
-0.3760496973991394,
-0.44233107566833496,
0.24243296682834625,
0.4532508850097656,
-0.10544515401124954,
-0.4658760726451874,
0.4696851670742035,
-0.7569016218185425,
-0.7838901281356812,
0.3945449888706207,
0.9215640425682068,
0.12192124873399734,
0.07233919203281403,
-0.24076418578624725,
-0.08572178333997726,
-0.1769459843635559,
-0.13682326674461365,
0.4159345030784607,
0.3197043538093567,
0.093696728348732,
0.3149273693561554,
0.484529584646225,
0.7089881300926208,
0.22358077764511108,
0.2730168104171753,
0.7912434339523315,
-0.5278012156486511,
-0.23801058530807495,
-0.4780675172805786,
-0.12026115506887436,
0.08877848833799362,
-0.17558515071868896,
0.44489169120788574,
0.7630831003189087,
1.0045262575149536,
0.027132106944918633,
1.0811957120895386,
-0.31315314769744873,
0.26731300354003906,
-0.5186840295791626,
0.5549789667129517,
-0.7822484970092773,
-0.24624308943748474,
0.15415382385253906,
-0.8716967105865479,
-0.2761659324169159,
-0.03360195830464363,
-0.2602532207965851,
-0.1803966462612152,
0.8196563124656677,
0.7673843502998352,
-0.10725076496601105,
-0.24887430667877197,
0.2686128318309784,
-0.14560148119926453,
0.027908727526664734,
0.7920998930931091,
0.5887145400047302,
0.12990997731685638,
0.7667111158370972,
-0.5517025589942932,
-0.2503349781036377,
0.1259099543094635,
-0.5119797587394714,
-0.8024302124977112,
-0.6698687076568604,
-0.19081872701644897,
-0.3165692090988159,
-0.3215214014053345,
0.8882254362106323,
0.5305383205413818,
-0.8349602818489075,
-0.3621754050254822,
-0.3589860200881958,
-0.08793657273054123,
-0.07589662820100784,
-0.17787183821201324,
0.3117293417453766,
-1.0033382177352905,
-1.137998342514038,
0.5703432559967041,
-0.002487393794581294,
-0.024158542975783348,
-0.1619987189769745,
-0.11985892057418823,
0.32056865096092224,
-0.15369996428489685,
0.5744093656539917,
0.6387390494346619,
-0.391665518283844,
0.03229973837733269,
-0.031214535236358643,
-0.3458123505115509,
-0.06873653829097748,
1.3105677366256714,
-0.7495075464248657,
0.5026461482048035,
0.5713809728622437,
0.8372563123703003,
0.6059110164642334,
-0.02686960995197296,
0.5107765197753906,
-0.8510321378707886,
0.37596336007118225,
0.24832646548748016,
0.6011595129966736,
0.3996567130088806,
-0.20805734395980835,
0.41014501452445984,
0.4072144031524658,
-0.4051048457622528,
-0.5751491189002991,
0.3217049837112427,
-0.8649490475654602,
-0.3294946551322937,
1.4754449129104614,
0.08940514177083969,
-0.10046692192554474,
0.10139539837837219,
0.1149321049451828,
0.3733847737312317,
-0.3492729663848877,
0.5550280213356018,
0.5352343320846558,
0.0071318140253424644,
0.12247761338949203,
-0.6421653032302856,
0.7219117879867554,
0.4880523085594177,
-0.9448796510696411,
0.36811885237693787,
0.5183761119842529,
-0.03210792317986488,
0.22637894749641418,
0.6252884268760681,
-0.08469346165657043,
-0.039556048810482025,
0.08692863583564758,
0.4319815933704376,
-0.006554713938385248,
-0.24372008442878723,
-0.02732708305120468,
0.09678284823894501,
0.2584320306777954,
0.12649814784526825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14073v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14073v1
|
Improving Language Understanding from Screenshots
| 2024-02-21T19:01:03 | 2024-02-21T19:01:03 |
Tianyu Gao, Zirui Wang, Adithya Bhaskar, Danqi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
An emerging family of language models (LMs), capable of processing both text
and images within a single visual view, has the promise to unlock complex tasks
such as chart understanding and UI navigation. We refer to these models as
screenshot language models. Despite their appeal, existing screenshot LMs
substantially lag behind text-only models on language understanding tasks. To
close this gap, we adopt a simplified setting where the model inputs are
plain-text-rendered screenshots, and we focus on improving the text ability of
screenshot LMs. We propose a novel Patch-and-Text Prediction (PTP) objective,
which masks and recovers both image patches of screenshots and text within
screenshots. We also conduct extensive ablation studies on masking rates and
patch sizes, as well as designs for improving training stability. Our
pre-trained model, while solely taking visual inputs, achieves comparable
performance with BERT on 6 out of 8 GLUE tasks (within 2%) and improves up to
8% over prior work. Additionally, we extend PTP to train autoregressive
screenshot LMs and demonstrate its effectiveness--our models can significantly
reduce perplexity by utilizing the screenshot context. Together, we hope our
findings can inspire future research on developing powerful screenshot LMs and
extending their reach to broader applications.
|
[
-0.2730632722377777,
-0.5782684683799744,
0.6077895164489746,
0.037042539566755295,
-0.3719857931137085,
0.32372093200683594,
-0.29134485125541687,
-0.446735680103302,
-0.11527452617883682,
0.9248749017715454,
-0.5091743469238281,
-0.5399961471557617,
-0.9882996678352356,
-0.13134552538394928,
-0.33698081970214844,
0.7662815451622009,
-0.10387447476387024,
-0.23766392469406128,
-0.08856191486120224,
0.06421012431383133,
-0.2667640447616577,
-0.19696402549743652,
-0.9055020213127136,
-0.18182656168937683,
0.331171452999115,
0.45942580699920654,
0.5103098750114441,
0.7373440861701965,
0.4160144627094269,
0.2862769365310669,
-0.10866735875606537,
0.34368929266929626,
-0.3035702407360077,
0.20782484114170074,
0.06664183735847473,
-0.43880006670951843,
0.029344748705625534,
-0.21454347670078278,
0.6913374662399292,
0.43862876296043396,
0.24106505513191223,
0.043695349246263504,
0.08707179129123688,
0.6638557314872742,
-0.6620351076126099,
0.5762641429901123,
-0.8417305946350098,
-0.07581006735563278,
0.07194496691226959,
0.000581617874559015,
-0.749833881855011,
0.07076164335012436,
0.04951366409659386,
-0.6350768804550171,
0.3616145849227905,
-0.32965460419654846,
0.8695480823516846,
0.15007026493549347,
-0.4830138385295868,
0.02807215042412281,
-0.47488516569137573,
0.5406486988067627,
-0.885701596736908,
0.1513599008321762,
0.3598056733608246,
0.45450320839881897,
-0.15455938875675201,
-0.722474992275238,
-0.380869597196579,
-0.09186593443155289,
-0.1330077052116394,
0.069268599152565,
-0.13995565474033356,
0.14430035650730133,
0.07848956435918808,
0.22540180385112762,
-0.5009778141975403,
0.13942338526248932,
-0.4210329055786133,
-0.30385634303092957,
0.2378038763999939,
-0.07082436233758926,
0.6867331266403198,
-0.250754177570343,
-0.4383992850780487,
-0.24611876904964447,
-0.5999470949172974,
0.260446161031723,
-0.3781634569168091,
0.31828776001930237,
-0.10897920280694962,
0.243685781955719,
0.05248236656188965,
1.0744508504867554,
-0.021397633478045464,
-0.18813998997211456,
-0.13984918594360352,
-0.15354518592357635,
-0.200430229306221,
-0.46552494168281555,
0.6931282877922058,
0.5150986313819885,
0.24820344150066376,
0.03991163149476051,
-0.06241389364004135,
0.05030108988285065,
-0.091182179749012,
-0.8182923793792725,
-0.5032952427864075,
-0.10947251319885254,
-0.3803204894065857,
-0.2902509570121765,
-0.07125070691108704,
-0.5701486468315125,
-0.73854660987854,
-0.18455180525779724,
0.3124887943267822,
-0.5773659348487854,
-0.35802799463272095,
-0.1511373072862625,
-0.28969308733940125,
-0.24530862271785736,
0.6849246621131897,
-0.8866114616394043,
0.26198047399520874,
0.5115883946418762,
0.7537935376167297,
-0.046029552817344666,
-0.353814959526062,
-0.5513594746589661,
0.025266297161579132,
-0.4191442131996155,
1.1848645210266113,
-0.2972880005836487,
-0.21753424406051636,
0.047238871455192566,
0.04160686209797859,
-0.42562997341156006,
-0.3253200352191925,
-0.09605876356363297,
-0.27760374546051025,
0.26038870215415955,
-0.06446299701929092,
-0.41586005687713623,
-0.4325343668460846,
0.1639048457145691,
-0.8740174174308777,
0.8757426738739014,
-0.011469794437289238,
-0.467729777097702,
0.40815186500549316,
-0.4915688633918762,
-0.22789926826953888,
0.10502684116363525,
-0.14418238401412964,
-0.4310353994369507,
0.12259826809167862,
0.6063072681427002,
0.5589215159416199,
0.3307934105396271,
0.033554352819919586,
-0.2176588922739029,
-0.28069618344306946,
0.31889674067497253,
-0.3242153823375702,
0.495760977268219,
0.13011644780635834,
-0.4637269973754883,
0.035364992916584015,
-0.38754865527153015,
0.06660101562738419,
-0.13611052930355072,
-0.057861924171447754,
-0.21960632503032684,
0.06854377686977386,
0.21835976839065552,
0.49344152212142944,
0.07072340697050095,
-0.24473804235458374,
0.32771065831184387,
-0.28946325182914734,
0.5680367350578308,
0.7619144916534424,
-0.03811053931713104,
0.6823083162307739,
-0.18452899158000946,
0.7778307199478149,
-0.09167178720235825,
-0.07875531911849976,
-0.9054602384567261,
-0.36072278022766113,
-0.6220794916152954,
-0.6436701416969299,
0.18304423987865448,
0.4060424268245697,
-1.0130114555358887,
-0.12646785378456116,
-0.3609332740306854,
-0.48146840929985046,
-0.3018503785133362,
0.20316749811172485,
0.9042406678199768,
0.5257289409637451,
0.13600943982601166,
-0.6125743985176086,
-0.5812638998031616,
-0.8048535585403442,
-0.5982963442802429,
-0.4081047773361206,
-0.04159335419535637,
0.23379112780094147,
0.39634981751441956,
0.02878672629594803,
0.6707808971405029,
-0.3443794548511505,
-0.31237542629241943,
-0.7177687883377075,
0.45563268661499023,
0.22768880426883698,
0.3750945031642914,
0.4543415307998657,
-0.5199986696243286,
-0.7118316888809204,
0.024732863530516624,
-0.3522520065307617,
-0.05676853284239769,
-0.13780812919139862,
0.15897823870182037,
0.571703314781189,
0.6244020462036133,
-0.519289493560791,
0.4180591106414795,
0.7096612453460693,
-0.6764306426048279,
0.35368749499320984,
-0.2244565635919571,
0.5676156282424927,
-1.0163142681121826,
-0.05386894568800926,
0.25381240248680115,
-0.5732532739639282,
-0.737694501876831,
0.16851653158664703,
0.5185918807983398,
-0.48399513959884644,
-0.6491279006004333,
0.7199913859367371,
-0.6546119451522827,
-0.07983064651489258,
-0.5069302320480347,
0.08631493896245956,
0.23610281944274902,
0.4224984347820282,
0.44350576400756836,
0.7373338937759399,
0.35229530930519104,
-0.28852564096450806,
-0.1730700135231018,
0.11554515361785889,
-0.48804986476898193,
0.14119823276996613,
-0.06968061625957489,
0.164161816239357,
-0.1897086501121521,
0.6446126699447632,
-1.220727562904358,
-0.11234888434410095,
0.1136753037571907,
-0.6430168151855469,
0.5195314884185791,
-0.37722235918045044,
-0.32768896222114563,
-0.37277451157569885,
-0.36676299571990967,
0.19613179564476013,
0.5409021377563477,
-0.6154687404632568,
0.6146059632301331,
0.3374102711677551,
-0.3957592844963074,
-0.7337501645088196,
-0.5291571617126465,
0.1933283507823944,
-0.09741111844778061,
-0.4902448058128357,
0.39092034101486206,
0.18418200314044952,
-0.07301279157400131,
-0.07588820904493332,
-0.16356982290744781,
-0.45928794145584106,
0.04422242194414139,
0.40364938974380493,
0.3993251621723175,
-0.18400058150291443,
0.1224556639790535,
-0.19153587520122528,
-0.24399735033512115,
-0.1311088502407074,
-0.14885234832763672,
0.33812257647514343,
-0.055819105356931686,
-0.07406678795814514,
-0.4953840970993042,
0.12563472986221313,
0.7654007077217102,
-0.14619657397270203,
0.4969080984592438,
0.4595775604248047,
-0.4474923014640808,
-0.17644396424293518,
-0.6909240484237671,
-0.26872485876083374,
-0.41166311502456665,
0.6648703217506409,
-0.3854629099369049,
-0.7137761116027832,
0.572128415107727,
0.05923345685005188,
0.34278908371925354,
0.3856147527694702,
0.23537364602088928,
-0.5979680418968201,
0.9988711476325989,
0.9500012993812561,
-0.271755576133728,
0.8274637460708618,
-0.2189643532037735,
0.04991668462753296,
-0.4347395598888397,
0.03417511656880379,
-0.4025786519050598,
-0.1105530858039856,
-0.2456919550895691,
-0.6373007893562317,
0.13472241163253784,
0.0875408798456192,
-0.036174267530441284,
0.5395417809486389,
-0.5138148665428162,
0.6565288305282593,
0.5889970660209656,
0.5226455926895142,
0.266297847032547,
0.2319110631942749,
0.11903688311576843,
-0.32421058416366577,
-0.661949634552002,
-0.5871729254722595,
0.9241060018539429,
0.4346758723258972,
0.4805111289024353,
-0.42553621530532837,
0.593023419380188,
0.16558048129081726,
0.3661923110485077,
-0.4483661651611328,
0.6690086126327515,
-0.6021480560302734,
-0.49599236249923706,
-0.2184855341911316,
-0.2487533986568451,
-0.794515073299408,
0.511878252029419,
-0.06234244629740715,
-0.9675214886665344,
-0.2355506271123886,
0.6084965467453003,
-0.16801871359348297,
0.5564384460449219,
-0.9430393576622009,
1.0278462171554565,
-0.186159148812294,
-0.13676363229751587,
-0.26509910821914673,
-0.5744809508323669,
0.4757019579410553,
0.22113162279129028,
0.6297701597213745,
-0.1645030379295349,
0.16902871429920197,
0.6903393268585205,
-0.3054022490978241,
1.019413948059082,
-0.2749401926994324,
0.03263167291879654,
0.08167211711406708,
0.28245827555656433,
0.1901097595691681,
-0.35650670528411865,
0.02836238592863083,
-0.2095346301794052,
0.19210617244243622,
-0.3772968649864197,
-0.7319743633270264,
0.5370920896530151,
-0.49746254086494446,
-0.35064828395843506,
-0.23809586465358734,
-0.7447541952133179,
-0.05752597376704216,
-0.07496984302997589,
0.280832976102829,
0.5787042379379272,
-0.01920335926115513,
-0.17995965480804443,
0.535426676273346,
-0.3190198838710785,
0.6568242311477661,
0.6571343541145325,
-0.5567869544029236,
-0.3393457233905792,
0.7792357206344604,
-0.09445972740650177,
0.5744627118110657,
0.39472752809524536,
-0.26239508390426636,
-0.40826061367988586,
-0.38193419575691223,
-0.3762563169002533,
0.18691977858543396,
-1.0227419137954712,
-0.2632874846458435,
-0.2925984859466553,
-0.12198220938444138,
-0.4393605887889862,
-0.28342482447624207,
-0.41111841797828674,
-0.6320638656616211,
-0.21793991327285767,
-0.12476697564125061,
0.5379716753959656,
0.5768088698387146,
-0.15153838694095612,
0.31165117025375366,
-0.8310487270355225,
0.6241439580917358,
0.13750547170639038,
0.20402711629867554,
-0.3933793902397156,
-0.7684563994407654,
-0.16350208222866058,
0.07285721600055695,
-0.3108278810977936,
-0.9183987975120544,
0.6647740006446838,
0.3637959957122803,
0.4702046811580658,
0.21824012696743011,
-0.23703275620937347,
0.8316250443458557,
-0.3146332800388336,
0.9010733962059021,
0.5007582902908325,
-0.880273163318634,
0.7187129259109497,
-0.26264065504074097,
0.8264504075050354,
0.6948124766349792,
-0.23529209196567535,
-0.7826619744300842,
-0.87904292345047,
-0.6353968381881714,
-0.7393133044242859,
0.6278055906295776,
0.10682648420333862,
-0.011592968367040157,
0.2686510384082794,
0.1138208657503128,
0.19211027026176453,
-0.03091900423169136,
-1.0610783100128174,
0.06221885606646538,
-0.04766112193465233,
-0.4978739023208618,
-0.29972729086875916,
-0.19009216129779816,
0.23358289897441864,
-0.28632307052612305,
0.6120128035545349,
-0.07667595148086548,
0.100450299680233,
-0.03388281911611557,
-0.646297037601471,
-0.10012644529342651,
0.2350044995546341,
0.48341429233551025,
0.6976839900016785,
-0.06489065289497375,
0.4958418309688568,
0.07872162759304047,
-0.5929172039031982,
-0.04069053381681442,
0.23736123740673065,
-0.01752486638724804,
0.44948437809944153,
0.3171945810317993,
0.9630441069602966,
0.48833179473876953,
-0.6781399250030518,
0.31744879484176636,
0.020238813012838364,
-0.15244945883750916,
-0.055684588849544525,
-0.2658446133136749,
-0.08279862254858017,
0.1683940887451172,
0.4199744164943695,
0.20312882959842682,
-0.11517763882875443,
-0.4509718418121338,
0.25213730335235596,
0.2637384235858917,
-0.46718889474868774,
-0.09464625269174576,
0.39273419976234436,
0.22239062190055847,
-0.3712031841278076,
0.5041367411613464,
0.18369871377944946,
-0.8706791996955872,
1.0062898397445679,
0.4163855314254761,
0.5334392786026001,
-0.29227882623672485,
0.5410910844802856,
0.42387494444847107,
0.4283653795719147,
-0.07319258153438568,
0.11592874675989151,
-0.12860740721225739,
-0.4906286597251892,
-0.4839557707309723,
-0.16662730276584625,
-0.5597783327102661,
0.32177498936653137,
-0.33370158076286316,
0.2785228490829468,
-0.1670197993516922,
-0.09494642168283463,
-0.23311996459960938,
-0.004141875077039003,
-0.6425828337669373,
0.3996790647506714,
0.37197187542915344,
0.885945200920105,
-1.0523732900619507,
0.8392888307571411,
0.5269641876220703,
-0.43122684955596924,
-0.7585980892181396,
-0.27941322326660156,
0.05717843025922775,
-0.7722579836845398,
0.47735974192619324,
0.6948942542076111,
0.19435825943946838,
-0.01051844097673893,
-0.29857340455055237,
-0.5595805644989014,
0.8205820322036743,
0.5364803671836853,
-0.6223151087760925,
-0.07684209197759628,
-0.03659902140498161,
0.2876245677471161,
-0.24882099032402039,
0.5262975692749023,
0.5775548219680786,
0.30732452869415283,
-0.20117424428462982,
-1.1224464178085327,
-0.0868343934416771,
-0.45539963245391846,
0.11726686358451843,
0.1389904022216797,
0.0727003887295723,
0.560032308101654,
-0.20849713683128357,
-0.22647443413734436,
0.13891762495040894,
0.4473564028739929,
0.5528942942619324,
0.4105972945690155,
0.5474362373352051,
0.5177206993103027,
0.2224578857421875,
-0.07914784550666809,
0.9774194955825806,
-0.29323500394821167,
0.2484203577041626,
1.1661756038665771,
0.38301703333854675,
0.9950135946273804,
0.7239060401916504,
0.008323975838720798,
0.5630831122398376,
0.9151548743247986,
0.1241292878985405,
0.7875677347183228,
-0.02636011876165867,
-0.2235475331544876,
-0.19059547781944275,
0.119125597178936,
-0.26665031909942627,
0.09394167363643646,
0.4309992790222168,
-0.7638407945632935,
-0.34872502088546753,
0.33222752809524536,
0.057363416999578476,
0.4490659534931183,
-0.40789440274238586,
0.8966599106788635,
0.13885946571826935,
-0.8489217758178711,
0.5525442361831665,
-0.23117825388908386,
0.5863286852836609,
-0.5332157611846924,
-0.06255365163087845,
-0.10535742342472076,
0.1964852511882782,
-0.11437103897333145,
-0.8712634444236755,
0.15971261262893677,
-0.04499289393424988,
-0.10810304433107376,
-0.750768780708313,
1.0627433061599731,
-0.5650979280471802,
-0.49448639154434204,
0.08534134179353714,
0.22089767456054688,
0.24036461114883423,
-0.26804813742637634,
-0.6860910654067993,
0.19852663576602936,
0.03817948326468468,
-0.10422903299331665,
0.3350793421268463,
0.06807645410299301,
0.15401697158813477,
0.5252414345741272,
0.3481622040271759,
0.05379597470164299,
0.007947595790028572,
0.07884357124567032,
0.5841946005821228,
-0.4000052213668823,
-0.38829922676086426,
-0.863162100315094,
0.938648521900177,
-0.2359442263841629,
-0.09468843042850494,
0.33175739645957947,
0.30344435572624207,
0.5517570376396179,
-0.37652382254600525,
0.9663695096969604,
0.3122125267982483,
0.4821285903453827,
-0.5891374945640564,
0.9562498331069946,
-0.347907155752182,
-0.0027027332689613104,
-0.4616795480251312,
-0.6796137094497681,
-0.491134911775589,
0.6102972626686096,
-0.4414443373680115,
-0.4964708387851715,
0.7637656331062317,
0.7647724747657776,
-0.007953093387186527,
-0.561713695526123,
0.18736204504966736,
-0.10321170091629028,
0.27720963954925537,
0.8094720244407654,
0.76898193359375,
-0.5379215478897095,
0.6766691207885742,
-0.3242745101451874,
-0.3119613826274872,
-0.1276845484972,
-0.958469808101654,
-0.8665827512741089,
-0.9601232409477234,
-0.48893100023269653,
-0.24876192212104797,
0.2915848195552826,
0.4410175085067749,
0.8267224431037903,
-0.6614179015159607,
-0.2697194516658783,
-0.44201818108558655,
0.2182832807302475,
-0.20923157036304474,
-0.19503194093704224,
0.23416578769683838,
-0.45757991075515747,
-0.639887273311615,
0.3448653817176819,
0.33371391892433167,
0.09997069090604782,
0.026430930942296982,
0.0694248154759407,
0.1099371463060379,
0.011636287905275822,
0.6132211685180664,
0.6580122113227844,
-0.9052683711051941,
-0.1071401834487915,
-0.057132355868816376,
-0.3006748855113983,
0.08118698745965958,
0.6459147930145264,
-0.797901451587677,
0.7071309089660645,
0.544937252998352,
0.48498642444610596,
0.8557589650154114,
-0.1905774474143982,
0.8693477511405945,
-0.4896946847438812,
0.32088330388069153,
0.15672434866428375,
0.5410041213035583,
0.43680018186569214,
-0.04843789339065552,
0.22538259625434875,
-0.21843169629573822,
-0.14695966243743896,
-0.8188587427139282,
0.33872589468955994,
-0.8829736113548279,
-0.6582064628601074,
1.0768015384674072,
-0.5064265727996826,
-0.20518019795417786,
0.10897719115018845,
-0.5242897272109985,
0.3203657269477844,
-0.27061256766319275,
1.0142414569854736,
0.5167059898376465,
0.2236168086528778,
-0.9745345711708069,
-0.39436379075050354,
0.4497029185295105,
0.5004090070724487,
-0.8557500839233398,
-0.004172333516180515,
0.593457818031311,
0.29668867588043213,
-0.05552816018462181,
0.9365614056587219,
-0.007858313620090485,
0.6372696161270142,
-0.34107959270477295,
0.2162618637084961,
0.004997040145099163,
-0.13426803052425385,
-0.3345438539981842,
0.0324426032602787,
0.2671859562397003,
-0.5122436881065369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14020v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14020v1
|
Coercing LLMs to do and reveal (almost) anything
| 2024-02-21T18:59:13 | 2024-02-21T18:59:13 |
Jonas Geiping, Alex Stein, Manli Shu, Khalid Saifullah, Yuxin Wen, Tom Goldstein
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
It has recently been shown that adversarial attacks on large language models
(LLMs) can "jailbreak" the model into making harmful statements. In this work,
we argue that the spectrum of adversarial attacks on LLMs is much larger than
merely jailbreaking. We provide a broad overview of possible attack surfaces
and attack goals. Based on a series of concrete examples, we discuss,
categorize and systematize attacks that coerce varied unintended behaviors,
such as misdirection, model control, denial-of-service, or data extraction.
We analyze these attacks in controlled experiments, and find that many of
them stem from the practice of pre-training LLMs with coding capabilities, as
well as the continued existence of strange "glitch" tokens in common LLM
vocabularies that should be removed for security reasons.
|
[
-0.4778234660625458,
-1.192475438117981,
0.35764840245246887,
0.050968319177627563,
0.08695114403963089,
0.2034856230020523,
-0.26226845383644104,
-0.44142940640449524,
0.2029052972793579,
0.9619807600975037,
-0.5899940729141235,
-0.23452450335025787,
-1.035225749015808,
-0.16184799373149872,
-0.8252095580101013,
1.1699453592300415,
0.10397649556398392,
0.11141188442707062,
0.13009607791900635,
0.13481436669826508,
-0.48113274574279785,
-0.9885168075561523,
-0.47027403116226196,
-0.19094538688659668,
0.8644642233848572,
0.02502438612282276,
1.0050711631774902,
0.5911576747894287,
0.4260365068912506,
0.2712451219558716,
-0.18921059370040894,
-0.03280900418758392,
-0.686229407787323,
0.36073848605155945,
-0.19157491624355316,
-0.847020149230957,
-0.11166220903396606,
0.2753418982028961,
0.33336344361305237,
0.6072015166282654,
0.016056187450885773,
-0.1651974767446518,
0.039734259247779846,
0.6526404023170471,
-0.631820797920227,
-0.43093183636665344,
-0.9536477327346802,
-0.0025591179728507996,
-0.47627517580986023,
0.08028987795114517,
-0.6363013982772827,
-0.1897226721048355,
-0.24360495805740356,
-0.23133093118667603,
-0.049585405737161636,
0.1287613958120346,
0.8107388019561768,
0.3036176264286041,
-0.3456301689147949,
-0.7344583868980408,
-0.6525353789329529,
0.5825318098068237,
-0.4014536142349243,
-0.09953498095273972,
0.459320068359375,
0.2668910324573517,
-0.7063214182853699,
-0.5500520467758179,
-0.3448886573314667,
-0.5020574331283569,
-0.20155033469200134,
-0.3060931861400604,
-0.6271906495094299,
0.09391827136278152,
0.45274969935417175,
0.22765392065048218,
-0.3922596275806427,
0.4237563908100128,
-0.45444345474243164,
-0.037396181374788284,
0.6227329969406128,
0.16450771689414978,
0.755012571811676,
-0.09686584025621414,
-0.47184503078460693,
0.05979757755994797,
-1.2123360633850098,
-0.1319124698638916,
0.829747200012207,
0.1381022036075592,
-0.08137159794569016,
0.8240507245063782,
0.45189133286476135,
0.6680057048797607,
-0.04030179604887962,
0.49172472953796387,
-0.45030727982521057,
0.0965702086687088,
-0.33927977085113525,
-0.09088636934757233,
0.8539218902587891,
0.04938207566738129,
0.2748779356479645,
-0.6321526765823364,
-0.2578446865081787,
0.20258520543575287,
0.42829108238220215,
-0.375299870967865,
-0.22473697364330292,
0.21966096758842468,
-0.0770459994673729,
-0.7247653603553772,
0.3216308355331421,
-0.6594228744506836,
-0.9909530878067017,
0.08896803110837936,
0.3375963568687439,
-0.2733408510684967,
0.014914767816662788,
0.04167450964450836,
-0.2202802449464798,
0.1358061283826828,
0.10052479058504105,
-0.8865235447883606,
0.38487178087234497,
0.823215901851654,
0.6274168491363525,
-0.10546368360519409,
-0.30485838651657104,
-0.6645840406417847,
0.08349274843931198,
-0.32704612612724304,
0.2788776457309723,
-0.49576863646507263,
-0.6778945922851562,
-0.13434448838233948,
0.058135513216257095,
-0.1620788425207138,
-0.5156177878379822,
0.1844242662191391,
-0.8891299366950989,
-0.02750369720160961,
-0.13927273452281952,
-0.4563095271587372,
-0.03909740224480629,
0.27209290862083435,
-0.8335529565811157,
0.498995304107666,
-0.21393370628356934,
-0.6484813690185547,
-0.0379723496735096,
-0.48573732376098633,
-0.48511993885040283,
-0.4318486154079437,
-0.1934121549129486,
-0.27471792697906494,
0.17932598292827606,
0.020597463473677635,
0.4428662061691284,
-0.1361943930387497,
0.2579994201660156,
-0.49318286776542664,
-0.18964090943336487,
0.7871096730232239,
-0.5208272337913513,
1.007393479347229,
0.49242934584617615,
-0.3469714820384979,
0.12067382782697678,
-0.6559211015701294,
-0.3701624274253845,
0.3778468370437622,
-0.3269544541835785,
-0.479379802942276,
0.02467074990272522,
-0.38839006423950195,
0.13014404475688934,
0.2940608263015747,
-0.4103083908557892,
0.5419163107872009,
-0.44081568717956543,
0.6054074168205261,
0.8523024916648865,
0.08235939592123032,
0.4150424897670746,
-0.3265427350997925,
0.608185350894928,
-0.21319639682769775,
0.3813970386981964,
0.058804016560316086,
-0.20692528784275055,
-0.49826690554618835,
-0.2708563208580017,
0.14319902658462524,
0.5084689259529114,
-0.69633549451828,
0.05331191420555115,
0.15953600406646729,
-0.5708690285682678,
-0.2950793504714966,
0.4024710953235626,
0.6457602977752686,
0.0493164099752903,
0.10526144504547119,
0.08397509157657623,
-0.6162038445472717,
-0.7202935218811035,
-0.5005588531494141,
0.09105894714593887,
0.10607322305440903,
-0.0836176723241806,
0.5241492986679077,
-0.2568422555923462,
0.47634357213974,
-0.4209684729576111,
-0.13518859446048737,
-0.15720875561237335,
0.05811852961778641,
0.09576107561588287,
0.36962103843688965,
0.6795644760131836,
-0.8150513768196106,
-0.1183488517999649,
-0.3851507604122162,
-0.8220342993736267,
0.06642670184373856,
-0.04993090033531189,
0.17868012189865112,
-0.061251528561115265,
1.004352331161499,
-0.7080022096633911,
0.3749684691429138,
0.6495878100395203,
-0.33878853917121887,
0.6542244553565979,
-0.21822062134742737,
-0.20169422030448914,
-0.7282699942588806,
-0.2880798280239105,
-0.16971968114376068,
0.03790472075343132,
-0.9170621037483215,
0.5709012746810913,
-0.19463981688022614,
0.04279204457998276,
-0.6463953256607056,
0.2071206420660019,
-0.42676958441734314,
0.0158542450517416,
-0.30816665291786194,
-0.015054533258080482,
-0.06720748543739319,
0.15110258758068085,
-0.4484372138977051,
0.5902929306030273,
0.6036756634712219,
-0.5365753173828125,
0.6557025909423828,
-0.108713798224926,
-0.1298774629831314,
0.0693509429693222,
-0.5845166444778442,
0.28780463337898254,
-0.04161754995584488,
0.22235828638076782,
-0.907490611076355,
-0.19041799008846283,
0.2544134557247162,
-0.5759487152099609,
0.4839540421962738,
-0.20110981166362762,
-0.5796643495559692,
-0.1524852216243744,
-0.6303402781486511,
0.07368108630180359,
0.179734006524086,
-0.7873085141181946,
0.25824275612831116,
0.4169386923313141,
0.1800231784582138,
-0.7331156134605408,
-0.8476929068565369,
0.5383099913597107,
-0.395795613527298,
-0.39735981822013855,
0.04224415495991707,
0.07714282721281052,
-0.6705201268196106,
-0.15078052878379822,
0.31726309657096863,
0.31086844205856323,
0.7036871314048767,
0.5860350131988525,
0.3718797266483307,
0.12197954952716827,
-0.13447050750255585,
-0.5736501812934875,
0.15194757282733917,
0.4409230351448059,
-0.004641992971301079,
0.9209926724433899,
-0.13198627531528473,
-0.6537258625030518,
0.11830262094736099,
0.36471647024154663,
0.7319591641426086,
0.059491220861673355,
0.7406993508338928,
0.22940221428871155,
-0.2874006927013397,
-0.17818418145179749,
-0.177964448928833,
0.05685314163565636,
-0.4998595714569092,
0.48851147294044495,
-0.3030990660190582,
-0.9966245889663696,
0.49880391359329224,
0.022881092503666878,
0.13757380843162537,
0.222233384847641,
0.4256099462509155,
-0.13123923540115356,
1.2658334970474243,
0.4207967519760132,
-0.4060601592063904,
0.33576780557632446,
-0.2484106719493866,
0.13617634773254395,
-0.7701638340950012,
-0.35869479179382324,
-0.5876619219779968,
-0.13685013353824615,
-0.8297632932662964,
-0.14114540815353394,
0.04800387844443321,
0.3476237654685974,
-0.3651904761791229,
0.350332111120224,
-0.3571185767650604,
0.62507563829422,
0.5456235408782959,
0.015192043967545033,
0.14035215973854065,
-0.15377487242221832,
-0.009000050835311413,
0.13776402175426483,
-0.530867338180542,
-0.5585821866989136,
1.402100682258606,
0.4275115132331848,
1.184319019317627,
0.43040600419044495,
0.571299135684967,
0.5563587546348572,
0.40599268674850464,
-0.6945105195045471,
0.506328284740448,
-0.37547507882118225,
-0.8016324639320374,
-0.22929835319519043,
-0.11772965639829636,
-1.1099507808685303,
0.14632534980773926,
-0.2630459666252136,
-1.1288673877716064,
0.07623887062072754,
0.005840763449668884,
-0.18549828231334686,
0.6935852766036987,
-0.6806394457817078,
0.47243279218673706,
-0.5883705019950867,
-0.16851161420345306,
-0.052117764949798584,
-0.5333322882652283,
0.75934898853302,
-0.18447189033031464,
0.44755521416664124,
0.18018850684165955,
0.19283893704414368,
0.5891538858413696,
-0.5117254853248596,
1.172005534172058,
-0.1624450385570526,
-0.287244588136673,
0.11892324686050415,
0.34547075629234314,
0.7837698459625244,
-0.15775972604751587,
0.15850739181041718,
-0.07386790215969086,
-0.07253684848546982,
-0.35559865832328796,
-0.6989863514900208,
0.7450622320175171,
-0.95793217420578,
-1.0669549703598022,
-0.2892991602420807,
-0.36842504143714905,
-0.24969151616096497,
-0.06649930030107498,
0.44119173288345337,
0.2189328819513321,
-0.2809462249279022,
0.03740737587213516,
0.7936362028121948,
-0.28889942169189453,
0.303796648979187,
0.33574798703193665,
-0.5807231068611145,
-0.12872295081615448,
1.046655297279358,
0.007851913571357727,
0.6286274790763855,
0.10392444580793381,
-0.10190717875957489,
-0.026428181678056717,
-0.797070324420929,
-0.18071074783802032,
0.09342430531978607,
-0.6977275609970093,
-0.033549144864082336,
-0.28823617100715637,
-0.2125035971403122,
-0.44120052456855774,
-0.20707906782627106,
-0.1578892022371292,
-0.40282854437828064,
-0.32859373092651367,
-0.10758861899375916,
0.20627102255821228,
1.1664625406265259,
-0.13012945652008057,
0.6676725149154663,
-0.507828950881958,
0.3016202747821808,
0.43223434686660767,
-0.07409768551588058,
-0.1370742917060852,
-0.3762027323246002,
-0.09278354793787003,
-0.05129490792751312,
-0.34297338128089905,
-0.9355691075325012,
0.28195083141326904,
-0.1716325879096985,
0.46085748076438904,
0.5428124666213989,
-0.06395213305950165,
0.2948368191719055,
-0.42380625009536743,
0.7974414825439453,
0.5065080523490906,
-0.6749739646911621,
0.6623947024345398,
-0.28582334518432617,
-0.13304737210273743,
0.16141529381275177,
0.34391650557518005,
-0.44343358278274536,
-0.766548216342926,
-0.8512073159217834,
-0.8232930898666382,
0.4353252947330475,
-0.10335680097341537,
0.3559812903404236,
0.023130377754569054,
0.4153757691383362,
-0.09589250385761261,
0.13860875368118286,
-0.8101826906204224,
-0.5213422775268555,
-0.15971432626247406,
0.16533535718917847,
-0.08631043881177902,
-0.17833974957466125,
-0.6808764934539795,
0.07697153836488724,
0.5529460310935974,
0.31663671135902405,
-0.03230807185173035,
-0.06388500332832336,
-0.40913909673690796,
0.12702566385269165,
0.4821159839630127,
0.6223471164703369,
0.1648969054222107,
0.0598982572555542,
0.485230952501297,
0.042547039687633514,
-0.4698854088783264,
0.2962509095668793,
0.053133223205804825,
-0.15509432554244995,
-0.44834521412849426,
0.4720101058483124,
0.6503080725669861,
-0.05932066962122917,
-0.7089245915412903,
0.4915348291397095,
-0.22005043923854828,
-0.15685467422008514,
-0.30974242091178894,
0.41856062412261963,
-0.06757813692092896,
0.42228707671165466,
0.18072865903377533,
0.10439341515302658,
-0.1568245142698288,
-0.745917797088623,
0.1903706043958664,
0.8412150740623474,
-0.5052293539047241,
-0.3449626863002777,
0.6355767846107483,
-0.23522795736789703,
-0.2788229286670685,
0.2289314717054367,
-0.040726181119680405,
-0.6848375797271729,
0.609955370426178,
0.5584511756896973,
0.5663121938705444,
-0.1806230992078781,
0.029156537726521492,
-0.34854093194007874,
0.7352853417396545,
0.1485491693019867,
-0.24295297265052795,
0.12478190660476685,
-0.846122682094574,
-0.15564382076263428,
-0.2623237073421478,
-0.509235143661499,
0.6026468276977539,
-0.6989337205886841,
0.08469485491514206,
-1.0480698347091675,
-0.0921768769621849,
0.14454548060894012,
-0.1447325497865677,
-0.2576923072338104,
0.1901252269744873,
0.4838272035121918,
0.7632845640182495,
-0.5930600762367249,
0.8126473426818848,
0.6294059157371521,
-0.33390817046165466,
-0.6209497451782227,
-0.17518308758735657,
0.45840367674827576,
-1.0700657367706299,
0.8750251531600952,
-0.12632229924201965,
-0.21157337725162506,
-0.2893243432044983,
-0.9151768088340759,
-0.6406303644180298,
0.6553136110305786,
0.526244580745697,
-0.5411451458930969,
-0.2083074450492859,
0.3648195266723633,
0.21238233149051666,
-0.24114461243152618,
-0.19778692722320557,
0.8934641480445862,
0.4513431489467621,
-0.10105641186237335,
-0.4702574610710144,
0.20915168523788452,
-0.19071897864341736,
-0.22339031100273132,
0.1820695996284485,
-0.5634737610816956,
1.0206661224365234,
-0.3043942451477051,
-0.1357075721025467,
-0.016780830919742584,
0.4311651587486267,
0.1821790486574173,
-0.06394314020872116,
0.4804856479167938,
0.4568885266780853,
0.7429618239402771,
-0.1612519770860672,
1.1647571325302124,
-0.16355472803115845,
0.009552721865475178,
1.0878807306289673,
-0.04907393828034401,
0.40337738394737244,
0.6398888230323792,
-0.06978476047515869,
0.19307130575180054,
0.5452383160591125,
-0.3494875431060791,
0.5438657402992249,
0.730564296245575,
-0.1727084070444107,
-0.02482699789106846,
0.1388360857963562,
-0.16621682047843933,
0.40433448553085327,
0.7006860971450806,
-0.2611311376094818,
-0.2785052955150604,
0.36032697558403015,
0.6497368812561035,
0.20755185186862946,
-0.3640977144241333,
0.6486619114875793,
0.2189510613679886,
-0.5758507251739502,
0.67059326171875,
0.19608600437641144,
0.8256361484527588,
-0.6924920082092285,
0.2336721569299698,
0.08527690172195435,
0.10697232186794281,
-0.32552772760391235,
-0.6239486336708069,
0.25158196687698364,
0.2825002670288086,
-0.0759814977645874,
-0.08288940042257309,
0.8239098787307739,
-0.03079662099480629,
-0.02108689211308956,
0.6234310269355774,
0.30321529507637024,
-0.06560520827770233,
-0.09722423553466797,
-0.7194640040397644,
0.1550506353378296,
0.027725018560886383,
-0.5046062469482422,
0.6956393718719482,
0.20706583559513092,
-0.021091191098093987,
0.8625660538673401,
0.7627041339874268,
0.5665925741195679,
0.3122398853302002,
0.1423856019973755,
1.029491662979126,
-0.6522421836853027,
-0.14998145401477814,
-1.2233362197875977,
0.04160028696060181,
-0.08524217456579208,
0.00811926182359457,
0.8138856291770935,
0.3350604474544525,
0.6927744150161743,
0.29400187730789185,
1.0464328527450562,
0.0814424380660057,
0.21986433863639832,
-0.840595543384552,
0.7535682916641235,
-0.27336984872817993,
0.9029475450515747,
-0.14366592466831207,
-0.2767305374145508,
-0.36278653144836426,
0.11965812742710114,
-0.6496821045875549,
-0.3020378053188324,
0.5237715840339661,
0.7204046249389648,
0.330485075712204,
0.15125352144241333,
0.384683221578598,
0.48713651299476624,
0.714558482170105,
0.5430281162261963,
1.3960493803024292,
-0.1755537986755371,
0.6732155084609985,
0.08198554068803787,
-0.16686804592609406,
-0.12952864170074463,
-0.5773559212684631,
-1.1032320261001587,
-0.2386344075202942,
-0.047016385942697525,
-0.6399016976356506,
0.2537029981613159,
0.5767970681190491,
0.22854578495025635,
-0.6582235097885132,
-0.12532168626785278,
-0.007300545461475849,
0.35027876496315,
0.24703623354434967,
-0.17956101894378662,
0.26869627833366394,
-0.3801768720149994,
-0.4733549654483795,
0.5553500652313232,
0.08072606474161148,
0.2543724775314331,
-0.6759319305419922,
0.007919917814433575,
-0.19227945804595947,
0.21146780252456665,
0.3858967125415802,
0.42798346281051636,
-0.590793788433075,
-0.32110223174095154,
-0.22058768570423126,
-0.24642618000507355,
-0.18054775893688202,
0.9663820266723633,
-0.3584730923175812,
0.007242834661155939,
-0.11236321926116943,
0.6798787117004395,
0.190861314535141,
-0.27103325724601746,
0.5540474057197571,
-0.8744457364082336,
0.13239067792892456,
0.05864681676030159,
0.43624377250671387,
0.11759749054908752,
-0.5544547438621521,
0.21237553656101227,
0.1789710968732834,
-0.3174445629119873,
-0.9798985719680786,
0.49784496426582336,
-0.4613107442855835,
-0.8396579623222351,
1.1220929622650146,
-0.3093397617340088,
-0.5355859994888306,
-0.12870833277702332,
-0.10512511432170868,
0.043496422469615936,
-0.018857115879654884,
0.7717562913894653,
0.9408376812934875,
-0.15384182333946228,
0.37607648968696594,
-0.6785880923271179,
0.6291123032569885,
0.15349367260932922,
-0.7110856175422668,
0.30990099906921387,
0.34683069586753845,
0.307815283536911,
0.1446397453546524,
0.21356385946273804,
-0.4778546690940857,
0.0670229122042656,
-0.13612796366214752,
-0.3394220769405365,
-0.21111254394054413,
-0.24223637580871582,
-0.5732362270355225,
0.4748235046863556,
0.19690749049186707,
-0.07972542941570282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14052v1
|
On Leveraging Encoder-only Pre-trained Language Models for Effective Keyphrase Generation
| 2024-02-21T18:57:54 | 2024-02-21T18:57:54 |
Di Wu, Wasi Uddin Ahmad, Kai-Wei Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study addresses the application of encoder-only Pre-trained Language
Models (PLMs) in keyphrase generation (KPG) amidst the broader availability of
domain-tailored encoder-only models compared to encoder-decoder models. We
investigate three core inquiries: (1) the efficacy of encoder-only PLMs in KPG,
(2) optimal architectural decisions for employing encoder-only PLMs in KPG, and
(3) a performance comparison between in-domain encoder-only and encoder-decoder
PLMs across varied resource settings. Our findings, derived from extensive
experimentation in two domains reveal that with encoder-only PLMs, although KPE
with Conditional Random Fields slightly excels in identifying present
keyphrases, the KPG formulation renders a broader spectrum of keyphrase
predictions. Additionally, prefix-LM fine-tuning of encoder-only PLMs emerges
as a strong and data-efficient strategy for KPG, outperforming general-domain
seq2seq PLMs. We also identify a favorable parameter allocation towards model
depth rather than width when employing encoder-decoder architectures
initialized with encoder-only PLMs. The study sheds light on the potential of
utilizing encoder-only PLMs for advancing KPG systems and provides a groundwork
for future KPG methods. Our code and pre-trained checkpoints are released at
https://github.com/uclanlp/DeepKPG.
|
[
-0.1254604458808899,
-0.38006117939949036,
0.7388675808906555,
0.03510713949799538,
-0.6386089324951172,
0.1129004955291748,
-0.1329585164785385,
-0.015361787751317024,
-0.18586723506450653,
0.834233820438385,
-0.24579977989196777,
-0.5831310749053955,
-0.675847589969635,
0.17604412138462067,
-0.18672321736812592,
0.7403323650360107,
0.009743168950080872,
0.23220057785511017,
-0.2827390134334564,
0.1822776198387146,
-0.1810193508863449,
-0.7944311499595642,
-0.3440505862236023,
-0.35877734422683716,
0.09703820943832397,
0.34823983907699585,
0.7596459984779358,
0.5481929183006287,
0.6111589670181274,
0.047288037836551666,
-0.16472260653972626,
0.019223036244511604,
-0.3542096018791199,
0.353384792804718,
0.12077152729034424,
-0.29573673009872437,
-0.27422237396240234,
-0.17348505556583405,
0.3659554719924927,
0.7381315231323242,
0.23242469131946564,
-0.02797379530966282,
0.07347527891397476,
0.5327717065811157,
-0.9545481204986572,
0.03372231125831604,
-0.8833240270614624,
0.3225923776626587,
-0.43138548731803894,
-0.19891589879989624,
-0.5079972147941589,
-0.39887896180152893,
0.2599063217639923,
-0.4659559428691864,
0.13835392892360687,
-0.019588734954595566,
0.4922783374786377,
0.08590667694807053,
-0.40472912788391113,
-0.5913254022598267,
-0.47118255496025085,
0.4988061487674713,
-0.7732818722724915,
0.7158767580986023,
0.3005569279193878,
0.09962915629148483,
-0.3041859269142151,
-1.0156744718551636,
-0.5330860614776611,
-0.36921435594558716,
-0.05466845631599426,
0.22347843647003174,
0.35627081990242004,
0.5102798938751221,
0.14036795496940613,
0.44651055335998535,
-0.8060468435287476,
0.05724787712097168,
-0.4434904456138611,
-0.14605553448200226,
0.34052449464797974,
-0.08017702400684357,
0.09250862896442413,
-0.26301294565200806,
-0.07742458581924438,
-0.235063835978508,
-1.0550752878189087,
0.24138575792312622,
0.07831200957298279,
0.19724658131599426,
-0.0035568976309150457,
0.50811767578125,
0.016634980216622353,
0.47327661514282227,
-0.06718447804450989,
-0.23134230077266693,
0.23465171456336975,
-0.32911211252212524,
-0.17116934061050415,
0.18399669229984283,
0.8206884860992432,
0.12172350287437439,
0.24764132499694824,
-0.5389899015426636,
-0.14832329750061035,
0.2685922086238861,
0.3123001456260681,
-1.1507893800735474,
-0.5557162165641785,
0.2765551209449768,
-0.6537331342697144,
-0.34617194533348083,
-0.02207854576408863,
-0.8951796293258667,
-0.21022889018058777,
0.26430341601371765,
0.5412366390228271,
-0.38238561153411865,
-0.06338551640510559,
0.43188977241516113,
-0.43201547861099243,
0.32844188809394836,
-0.27496278285980225,
-0.6265258193016052,
0.23852570354938507,
0.6905046105384827,
0.7964727878570557,
-0.05932323634624481,
-0.3568591773509979,
-0.24480856955051422,
-0.020259428769350052,
-0.47151243686676025,
0.30549949407577515,
-0.889104962348938,
-0.833091139793396,
0.2797342836856842,
-0.1443755030632019,
-0.2627952992916107,
-0.49708014726638794,
1.0462617874145508,
-0.9378743767738342,
-0.24765044450759888,
-0.2350904643535614,
-0.8881773352622986,
0.1816117763519287,
-0.23061193525791168,
-0.5283569693565369,
0.44440945982933044,
-0.13054446876049042,
-0.3530779182910919,
0.5013021230697632,
-0.875231146812439,
-0.7050647139549255,
0.18070802092552185,
-0.18271559476852417,
-0.6356285214424133,
0.3916233479976654,
0.22890236973762512,
0.4047960638999939,
-0.04409613832831383,
0.09841100871562958,
-0.3419969081878662,
-0.30068862438201904,
0.3687015175819397,
-0.13664023578166962,
0.5073512196540833,
0.5879570841789246,
-0.20242145657539368,
-0.3158922493457794,
-0.5041418671607971,
0.3956092894077301,
0.35284513235092163,
-0.17527830600738525,
-0.1800333857536316,
0.042536329478025436,
-0.2820330262184143,
0.18354842066764832,
0.3244273066520691,
-0.6648483276367188,
0.16288238763809204,
-0.513169527053833,
0.5721160173416138,
0.3688409924507141,
0.20445984601974487,
0.8431527018547058,
-0.12988059222698212,
0.6937361359596252,
-0.21652016043663025,
0.28705930709838867,
-0.467639684677124,
-0.39838987588882446,
-0.2785966694355011,
-0.34748026728630066,
0.5220359563827515,
0.26215484738349915,
-0.66122967004776,
0.23048658668994904,
-0.29133063554763794,
-0.3136911690235138,
-0.7579132914543152,
0.014894455671310425,
0.5591073632240295,
0.3681364953517914,
0.26663121581077576,
-0.4610593318939209,
-0.46977320313453674,
-0.5514180064201355,
-0.3962128460407257,
-0.019507646560668945,
0.10414396226406097,
0.2846217155456543,
0.6147244572639465,
0.08920533210039139,
0.7386719584465027,
-0.5264548063278198,
-0.07795403897762299,
-0.4408150613307953,
-0.07812722772359848,
0.25433048605918884,
0.33296647667884827,
0.37686219811439514,
-0.7984749674797058,
-0.8191676735877991,
-0.33756527304649353,
-0.611994206905365,
-0.27516070008277893,
-0.030592473223805428,
-0.042279213666915894,
-0.296700119972229,
0.38429155945777893,
-1.071593999862671,
0.12689454853534698,
0.3614184856414795,
0.04466850683093071,
0.4031131863594055,
-0.44488292932510376,
0.017991069704294205,
-0.7175074815750122,
0.2761593461036682,
-0.5013741850852966,
0.17881660163402557,
-1.1021387577056885,
0.4808790683746338,
0.32359224557876587,
-0.5583846569061279,
-0.32405519485473633,
0.38997188210487366,
-0.421718031167984,
-0.06526008993387222,
-0.4251677095890045,
-0.14483776688575745,
0.2202722579240799,
0.4672948122024536,
0.38187235593795776,
0.7648643851280212,
0.5059932470321655,
-0.6211401224136353,
-0.22721077501773834,
0.44250524044036865,
-0.44591882824897766,
-0.06121300905942917,
-0.7164413332939148,
0.44813477993011475,
-0.26545682549476624,
0.2413637936115265,
-0.6559622883796692,
-0.060033828020095825,
0.30709466338157654,
-0.6021496057510376,
0.23989613354206085,
-0.23673056066036224,
-0.4684751629829407,
-0.4569700360298157,
-0.5091831684112549,
0.35246989130973816,
0.9665860533714294,
-0.47216492891311646,
0.26086071133613586,
0.33410558104515076,
-0.2128104418516159,
-0.15121228992938995,
-0.3920232951641083,
-0.05410313606262207,
-0.06102491542696953,
-0.5273483395576477,
0.5736584067344666,
-0.03301401436328888,
0.2462969422340393,
-0.19627782702445984,
-0.28709107637405396,
-0.21265821158885956,
0.27603664994239807,
0.294395387172699,
-0.09605992585420609,
-0.14767508208751678,
-0.12721726298332214,
0.13455691933631897,
-0.011744636110961437,
0.04804854094982147,
-0.5152695178985596,
0.658024251461029,
0.28339433670043945,
-0.414227157831192,
-0.14072063565254211,
0.4750884473323822,
0.7891595363616943,
-0.655799925327301,
0.6850374937057495,
0.12254646420478821,
0.03171724081039429,
-0.19174453616142273,
-0.1279059648513794,
-0.2368985116481781,
-0.49913328886032104,
0.3604520261287689,
-0.5841790437698364,
-0.893256425857544,
0.28866222500801086,
-0.31289970874786377,
0.1235906332731247,
-0.029380401596426964,
0.43266329169273376,
0.01108316145837307,
1.1049140691757202,
0.4751338064670563,
-0.18228520452976227,
0.16931413114070892,
-0.2079550176858902,
0.702745258808136,
-0.7679812908172607,
-0.19006551802158356,
-0.4640156626701355,
-0.07804035395383835,
-0.45085275173187256,
-0.23327189683914185,
0.5792829394340515,
0.4056510031223297,
-0.21456359326839447,
0.07047472894191742,
-0.4508175551891327,
0.5021050572395325,
0.6472792029380798,
-0.005051569547504187,
0.015524428337812424,
0.10835011303424835,
-0.15003493428230286,
-0.24256090819835663,
-0.9203619360923767,
-0.5056319832801819,
1.6359308958053589,
0.19333483278751373,
0.5738574266433716,
-0.2943789064884186,
0.8687156438827515,
0.1570092886686325,
-0.17863349616527557,
-0.4203031063079834,
0.45457956194877625,
-0.33074724674224854,
-0.5077517628669739,
-0.07467950880527496,
-0.18010590970516205,
-1.0743398666381836,
0.43338119983673096,
0.06600185483694077,
-0.11009614914655685,
-0.0027512358501553535,
0.08862759172916412,
-0.728467583656311,
0.07018650323152542,
-0.4646139144897461,
1.2535300254821777,
-0.5419395565986633,
0.19689679145812988,
0.10047317296266556,
-0.7425273060798645,
0.09661481529474258,
-0.3288941979408264,
0.05057192221283913,
0.33294376730918884,
-0.018686674535274506,
0.5109314918518066,
-0.44982224702835083,
0.35343727469444275,
-0.34916454553604126,
0.15165391564369202,
0.3701992928981781,
-0.10481817275285721,
0.6917129158973694,
-0.16881006956100464,
0.04359069839119911,
0.051770150661468506,
-0.2335396111011505,
-0.04227627441287041,
-0.3853704631328583,
0.4350419044494629,
-0.7858490347862244,
-0.4270232915878296,
0.0572749488055706,
-0.23641712963581085,
-0.23452942073345184,
0.2347436249256134,
0.5753495693206787,
0.310200572013855,
0.038240253925323486,
0.5055223107337952,
1.01425302028656,
-0.269808292388916,
0.23186302185058594,
0.6114641427993774,
-0.09569583088159561,
-0.42505982518196106,
0.9542179107666016,
-0.0022192092146724463,
0.3809363543987274,
0.6344643235206604,
0.13358448445796967,
-0.2587226629257202,
-0.9287948608398438,
-0.20737408101558685,
0.08383197337388992,
-0.7032069563865662,
-0.15743021667003632,
-0.8642159104347229,
-0.44824841618537903,
-0.7297549843788147,
-0.3334520161151886,
-0.2990410625934601,
-0.09407489001750946,
-0.1351211965084076,
-0.0822208970785141,
0.14081180095672607,
0.0375329963862896,
-0.005899461451917887,
0.6982975602149963,
-0.9577431082725525,
0.49543219804763794,
0.26607125997543335,
0.06559927016496658,
-0.08414900302886963,
-0.5749638080596924,
-0.1495131254196167,
0.1884906142950058,
-0.30686113238334656,
-1.0779465436935425,
0.49006935954093933,
0.5675786733627319,
0.5191666483879089,
0.26507773995399475,
0.1705624759197235,
0.38166695833206177,
-0.5798224806785583,
0.8661893010139465,
-0.2679138481616974,
-0.7179288268089294,
0.45681288838386536,
-0.09459517151117325,
0.5576390624046326,
0.7463085651397705,
0.48596617579460144,
-0.36216652393341064,
-0.389007031917572,
-0.44399598240852356,
-0.7811614871025085,
0.6573441028594971,
0.39728450775146484,
0.23687876760959625,
-0.0636652410030365,
0.504374623298645,
0.25937438011169434,
0.48352542519569397,
-0.6815072894096375,
-0.2307022213935852,
-0.3858357071876526,
-0.3331475257873535,
0.026003289967775345,
-0.4188462793827057,
0.34696659445762634,
0.17188246548175812,
0.6034190654754639,
0.10773131251335144,
0.20022359490394592,
0.10447736829519272,
-0.43406444787979126,
0.08117840439081192,
0.29914817214012146,
0.35932862758636475,
0.345513254404068,
-0.1740589588880539,
0.06343761831521988,
-0.060102108865976334,
-0.6847618222236633,
0.11782290786504745,
0.04315955936908722,
-0.5177956223487854,
0.23941883444786072,
0.14969344437122345,
0.8588780164718628,
0.159750297665596,
-0.7825560569763184,
0.7495338916778564,
0.2107006460428238,
-0.33036571741104126,
-0.03786018490791321,
-0.19795888662338257,
-0.050996460020542145,
0.21719114482402802,
0.4130367636680603,
-0.30947819352149963,
0.044118378311395645,
-0.2506285011768341,
0.11022762209177017,
0.6726755499839783,
0.1827206015586853,
-0.43169328570365906,
0.6954694986343384,
0.17438510060310364,
-0.26030945777893066,
0.5759432315826416,
-0.27084463834762573,
-0.8924098014831543,
0.48358574509620667,
0.5224756598472595,
1.0619187355041504,
-0.16920387744903564,
0.13717696070671082,
-0.09279865026473999,
0.3866920471191406,
-0.07288885861635208,
0.4040609300136566,
-0.5028663277626038,
-0.7510839700698853,
-0.12060173600912094,
-0.7930745482444763,
-0.23709405958652496,
0.5880458950996399,
-0.3832017183303833,
-0.08786161988973618,
-0.42906129360198975,
-0.24424298107624054,
-0.3949880301952362,
-0.04420206695795059,
-0.6085701584815979,
0.08280402421951294,
0.3002776801586151,
0.7195838093757629,
-0.7562366724014282,
0.798406720161438,
0.5791981220245361,
-0.27803388237953186,
-0.5031773447990417,
0.08574104309082031,
-0.5577741265296936,
-0.8932241201400757,
0.6520015001296997,
0.056920237839221954,
0.14151990413665771,
0.004400270059704781,
-0.37139466404914856,
-0.7701209187507629,
1.0680584907531738,
0.25086137652397156,
-0.3935394883155823,
-0.25596246123313904,
0.6313490867614746,
0.4257074296474457,
-0.2548390030860901,
-0.2583044171333313,
0.5661087036132812,
0.13487321138381958,
-0.10713125020265579,
-0.8432803153991699,
-0.24066242575645447,
-0.06462045013904572,
0.19878940284252167,
0.39504513144493103,
-0.37735870480537415,
0.7347179651260376,
0.12909696996212006,
-0.25600579380989075,
0.2692423164844513,
0.5206716060638428,
0.4888375401496887,
0.06581121683120728,
0.05221236124634743,
0.6287046074867249,
0.41761040687561035,
0.3438553214073181,
1.0112205743789673,
-0.9424443244934082,
-0.044096507132053375,
0.973289430141449,
-0.521034836769104,
0.6629871129989624,
0.41737857460975647,
-0.03524419665336609,
-0.0675135999917984,
0.40208932757377625,
0.1448477804660797,
1.3339170217514038,
0.0572853647172451,
-0.4157111346721649,
-0.2797231376171112,
0.03738703951239586,
-0.5426105260848999,
0.29266223311424255,
0.16880017518997192,
-0.8036209344863892,
-0.2869488596916199,
0.16545070707798004,
-0.011782378889620304,
-0.16839474439620972,
-0.42680904269218445,
0.7231935858726501,
0.4349234998226166,
-0.6783047914505005,
0.2901548147201538,
0.17318382859230042,
0.5685364603996277,
-0.9774644374847412,
0.16957776248455048,
-0.17398415505886078,
0.2661205530166626,
0.1347425878047943,
-0.5070561170578003,
-0.06312862783670425,
0.04661872237920761,
-0.12064472585916519,
-0.5157414078712463,
1.1839561462402344,
-0.38634949922561646,
-0.289318710565567,
0.039697688072919846,
0.5188959240913391,
0.13115853071212769,
-0.3603125512599945,
-0.45326319336891174,
0.10881947726011276,
-0.16695420444011688,
-0.12683622539043427,
0.5875682830810547,
0.30918407440185547,
0.4052172899246216,
0.28834637999534607,
0.6399450898170471,
0.22292560338974,
0.3676909804344177,
0.03589624911546707,
0.5614543557167053,
-0.34951382875442505,
-0.48785459995269775,
-0.9830238223075867,
0.20186883211135864,
0.05350751802325249,
-0.26498618721961975,
0.9174720644950867,
0.5563191771507263,
0.8707794547080994,
-0.37858760356903076,
1.0188928842544556,
0.23740613460540771,
0.22116507589817047,
-0.6221824288368225,
0.6997532248497009,
-0.3027370572090149,
-0.14986127614974976,
-0.11372322589159012,
-0.7176499366760254,
-0.028334718197584152,
0.5450213551521301,
-0.22358077764511108,
-0.05392732843756676,
0.4905070662498474,
0.9232984185218811,
0.27548858523368835,
0.18427465856075287,
0.3504401445388794,
-0.1669042557477951,
0.21474629640579224,
0.6892783641815186,
0.7319819927215576,
-0.4022230803966522,
0.5200169086456299,
-0.2861115038394928,
0.05138307809829712,
-0.25257620215415955,
-0.5706783533096313,
-0.8429907560348511,
-0.34466078877449036,
-0.04721633717417717,
0.04719330742955208,
0.3041645586490631,
0.8545260429382324,
0.42560744285583496,
-0.603760302066803,
-0.10944366455078125,
-0.27400144934654236,
-0.06618126481771469,
0.10952136665582657,
-0.14595673978328705,
0.21529462933540344,
-0.5165414214134216,
-0.273185133934021,
0.5822135210037231,
0.3336910009384155,
-0.029512964189052582,
0.12619666755199432,
-0.3577474355697632,
0.36168330907821655,
0.12309028953313828,
0.5529873967170715,
0.3659915030002594,
-0.48358678817749023,
0.09376735240221024,
0.37551283836364746,
-0.18701469898223877,
-0.038151152431964874,
1.1172159910202026,
-0.5185368061065674,
0.42390456795692444,
0.5470343828201294,
0.9058558940887451,
0.3268842399120331,
-0.22692327201366425,
0.6622200012207031,
-0.520656168460846,
-0.11857087165117264,
0.48253777623176575,
0.27322298288345337,
0.08892469108104706,
-0.090155228972435,
0.1207389384508133,
0.10987789928913116,
-0.5743618607521057,
-0.8738718628883362,
0.2869093418121338,
-0.3327811360359192,
-0.3932311236858368,
0.9896217584609985,
-0.21829268336296082,
-0.22512200474739075,
-0.05154649540781975,
0.053119316697120667,
0.0776808112859726,
-0.1691729575395584,
0.5165442228317261,
0.4989382326602936,
0.0850735455751419,
-0.15905722975730896,
-0.35080501437187195,
0.7976559400558472,
0.46639254689216614,
-0.2838004231452942,
-0.0718047097325325,
0.15249347686767578,
0.10011065751314163,
-0.10046147555112839,
0.9588027000427246,
-0.2871445119380951,
0.4131874144077301,
0.08957116305828094,
-0.024146083742380142,
-0.22801221907138824,
-0.3896256983280182,
-0.459241658449173,
0.5433254837989807,
0.3004828989505768,
-0.32449597120285034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14016v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14016v1
|
Is LLM-as-a-Judge Robust? Investigating Universal Adversarial Attacks on Zero-shot LLM Assessment
| 2024-02-21T18:55:20 | 2024-02-21T18:55:20 |
Vyas Raina, Adian Liusie, Mark Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are powerful zero-shot assessors and are
increasingly used in real-world situations such as for written exams or
benchmarking systems. Despite this, no existing work has analyzed the
vulnerability of judge-LLMs against adversaries attempting to manipulate
outputs. This work presents the first study on the adversarial robustness of
assessment LLMs, where we search for short universal phrases that when appended
to texts can deceive LLMs to provide high assessment scores. Experiments on
SummEval and TopicalChat demonstrate that both LLM-scoring and pairwise
LLM-comparative assessment are vulnerable to simple concatenation attacks,
where in particular LLM-scoring is very susceptible and can yield maximum
assessment scores irrespective of the input text quality. Interestingly, such
attacks are transferable and phrases learned on smaller open-source LLMs can be
applied to larger closed-source models, such as GPT3.5. This highlights the
pervasive nature of the adversarial vulnerabilities across different judge-LLM
sizes, families and methods. Our findings raise significant concerns on the
reliability of LLMs-as-a-judge methods, and underscore the importance of
addressing vulnerabilities in LLM assessment methods before deployment in
high-stakes real-world scenarios.
|
[
-0.276994526386261,
-0.9791430830955505,
0.5573657751083374,
0.014977147802710533,
-0.24699091911315918,
-0.013572626747190952,
-0.2797865867614746,
-0.5320627689361572,
-0.11503874510526657,
0.4526844322681427,
-0.0751657783985138,
-0.46571090817451477,
-0.9199488162994385,
-0.021554170176386833,
-0.656920850276947,
1.0504850149154663,
0.11143611371517181,
0.18852578103542328,
-0.2281656563282013,
-0.3528093695640564,
-0.25926294922828674,
-0.7869831919670105,
-0.611289381980896,
-0.25230053067207336,
0.6039029955863953,
0.035832516849040985,
0.8993875980377197,
0.19226451218128204,
0.6952623128890991,
0.29294711351394653,
-0.16081739962100983,
-0.14438311755657196,
-0.2954384386539459,
0.3255269229412079,
-0.2320089191198349,
-0.5521489381790161,
-0.4825146496295929,
0.284000039100647,
0.4387989640235901,
0.5056191086769104,
0.007197384722530842,
0.19833208620548248,
0.17681734263896942,
0.46836578845977783,
-0.9283401370048523,
-0.22438189387321472,
-1.0205535888671875,
0.13614685833454132,
-0.21521423757076263,
-0.025996055454015732,
-0.5698584914207458,
-0.3802966773509979,
-0.06803984194993973,
-0.21417571604251862,
-0.03019184060394764,
-0.19430474936962128,
0.730140745639801,
0.44761404395103455,
-0.6352055668830872,
-0.3558315634727478,
-0.5466547012329102,
0.6817502379417419,
-0.5588664412498474,
-0.1415465921163559,
0.1410820484161377,
0.4379301369190216,
-0.3319206237792969,
-0.5592148303985596,
-0.44249868392944336,
-0.6799810528755188,
0.019846919924020767,
0.23737356066703796,
-0.4404865801334381,
0.0996638834476471,
0.13063371181488037,
0.2690879702568054,
-0.6221559643745422,
0.5603451132774353,
0.16070686280727386,
-0.28685930371284485,
0.6008736491203308,
0.17026209831237793,
0.11222291737794876,
-0.13755673170089722,
-0.6413000226020813,
-0.11179304867982864,
-0.8075772523880005,
-0.09086126834154129,
0.4761478304862976,
0.2700628936290741,
0.041082922369241714,
0.5729853510856628,
0.057921893894672394,
0.6213478446006775,
-0.14207810163497925,
0.17163553833961487,
-0.40753597021102905,
-0.20981182157993317,
-0.3977414071559906,
-0.10127074271440506,
1.2631793022155762,
0.45889028906822205,
0.36977434158325195,
-0.20354042947292328,
-0.24500158429145813,
0.21828551590442657,
0.534753143787384,
-0.6657155752182007,
-0.08384864777326584,
0.02377593331038952,
-0.002196643501520157,
-0.9065963625907898,
0.20843534171581268,
-0.8160161972045898,
-0.7201895117759705,
0.36532941460609436,
0.7361361384391785,
-0.08360133320093155,
0.3249247670173645,
-0.06777778267860413,
0.2566290497779846,
0.2501413822174072,
0.33625808358192444,
-0.5685165524482727,
0.361312597990036,
0.6211815476417542,
0.5213602185249329,
-0.12752661108970642,
-0.3544248640537262,
-0.9418957233428955,
-0.28802698850631714,
-0.3746192157268524,
0.5812867879867554,
-0.15700829029083252,
-0.539134681224823,
0.10201437026262283,
-0.21303020417690277,
0.02485383301973343,
-0.4036095142364502,
0.8425477743148804,
-0.6885948181152344,
0.21947644650936127,
0.19803141057491302,
-0.4128682017326355,
0.05022318288683891,
0.8053117990493774,
-0.4866214990615845,
0.786073625087738,
0.0010846793884411454,
-0.776141345500946,
0.25917455554008484,
-0.26085519790649414,
-0.39583495259284973,
-0.11079075932502747,
-0.30522701144218445,
-0.5263078808784485,
0.11448154598474503,
0.26694557070732117,
0.5288037061691284,
-0.31023070216178894,
0.12101264297962189,
-0.6863309741020203,
-0.5233680009841919,
0.6101230382919312,
-1.1124637126922607,
0.6466403603553772,
0.051244135946035385,
-0.4882756769657135,
0.13091333210468292,
-0.7741339802742004,
0.040655750781297684,
0.3517148792743683,
-0.28836536407470703,
-0.17784841358661652,
-0.09068749845027924,
-0.12987835705280304,
-0.08125580102205276,
0.2390512079000473,
-0.4651271402835846,
0.33387309312820435,
-0.3944159746170044,
0.13468718528747559,
0.965173065662384,
0.13009954988956451,
0.13314470648765564,
-0.2639474868774414,
0.7084168195724487,
-0.43718868494033813,
0.25930359959602356,
-0.027868984267115593,
-0.27876225113868713,
-0.45055001974105835,
-0.05614597350358963,
0.676135778427124,
0.7414023280143738,
-0.5739606022834778,
0.4727240800857544,
-0.23705892264842987,
-0.6485621929168701,
-0.3188716471195221,
0.19269515573978424,
0.6252250671386719,
0.22931361198425293,
0.08475044369697571,
-0.2841247320175171,
-0.017336148768663406,
-0.5749175548553467,
-0.4814377725124359,
-0.2870814800262451,
-0.04064508154988289,
0.12791462242603302,
0.5939319133758545,
-0.0879463404417038,
0.38652557134628296,
-0.43074288964271545,
-0.13077513873577118,
-0.1216743066906929,
-0.09518392384052277,
0.10913445800542831,
0.10304758697748184,
0.7221323847770691,
-0.579531729221344,
-0.386021226644516,
-0.03991846367716789,
-0.8213192820549011,
-0.06671279668807983,
-0.18279922008514404,
0.07982099056243896,
-0.05837050825357437,
0.39002421498298645,
-0.5048492550849915,
0.37178993225097656,
0.5758643746376038,
-0.47258836030960083,
0.8890318870544434,
-0.2012692391872406,
0.0010932307923212647,
-0.7783443927764893,
-0.1565420776605606,
-0.07003317028284073,
-0.4220549762248993,
-0.48913654685020447,
0.7870383858680725,
0.031927503645420074,
0.1743190735578537,
-0.550351083278656,
0.6122953295707703,
-0.10840561985969543,
0.048790011554956436,
-0.4024933874607086,
0.35199472308158875,
0.09366219490766525,
0.25890305638313293,
-0.6967306137084961,
0.5967721939086914,
0.6602090001106262,
-0.43497174978256226,
0.5926194190979004,
-0.060851048678159714,
-0.28792616724967957,
0.7736546993255615,
-0.4758702218532562,
0.3358538746833801,
0.34429866075515747,
0.22443613409996033,
-0.7643772959709167,
-0.06824502348899841,
0.18412025272846222,
-0.7112985253334045,
0.6402670741081238,
-0.14633360505104065,
-0.6754997968673706,
-0.12471958994865417,
-0.7513015270233154,
0.032582659274339676,
0.07357210665941238,
-0.733298122882843,
0.2841908633708954,
0.11677629500627518,
-0.012967182323336601,
-0.7071239948272705,
-0.783990204334259,
0.3746456503868103,
-0.31399545073509216,
-0.5343049168586731,
-0.032684020698070526,
-0.11133448779582977,
-0.49121642112731934,
-0.16808515787124634,
-0.19841358065605164,
0.19268545508384705,
0.9070385694503784,
0.2707500159740448,
0.4007974863052368,
-0.17586727440357208,
-0.2969335913658142,
-0.41063275933265686,
-0.005311265587806702,
0.3006361126899719,
0.017977531999349594,
0.2461269497871399,
-0.20826806128025055,
-0.8927326202392578,
-0.21673890948295593,
0.2642720341682434,
0.9326758980751038,
0.07403632253408432,
0.46754786372184753,
0.4971439838409424,
-0.25997674465179443,
-0.24417197704315186,
-0.3375021517276764,
0.15922072529792786,
-0.4622902572154999,
0.4247555136680603,
-0.30616995692253113,
-1.0011956691741943,
0.4609163999557495,
0.07060330361127853,
-0.018954375758767128,
0.5053412318229675,
0.5973911285400391,
-0.0990670695900917,
0.938162088394165,
0.28446921706199646,
-0.4671931564807892,
0.15121589601039886,
-0.12952415645122528,
0.009587511420249939,
-0.7356083989143372,
0.05855463817715645,
-0.5866880416870117,
-0.26873520016670227,
-0.7262706160545349,
-0.12655438482761383,
0.34820857644081116,
0.11302244663238525,
-0.4144029915332794,
-0.01723370887339115,
-0.3946177363395691,
0.4917208254337311,
0.5711405873298645,
-0.09866860508918762,
0.2902066111564636,
-0.26290667057037354,
-0.4002915322780609,
0.13059352338314056,
-0.22196270525455475,
-0.5837091207504272,
1.5056337118148804,
0.3204765021800995,
0.918860137462616,
0.2464546114206314,
0.6777291297912598,
0.45233219861984253,
0.5176548361778259,
-0.8678967952728271,
0.5816544890403748,
-0.41490113735198975,
-0.344443142414093,
-0.05656476318836212,
-0.429493248462677,
-0.7559968829154968,
0.5521208047866821,
-0.2764260768890381,
-0.8392196893692017,
-0.15790008008480072,
-0.12697026133537292,
-0.43105748295783997,
0.5317939519882202,
-0.5519233345985413,
0.7978100180625916,
-0.671779453754425,
-0.34104517102241516,
0.2602091431617737,
-0.6485368609428406,
0.3446286618709564,
-0.25250428915023804,
0.2659144699573517,
0.09543217718601227,
0.0699218213558197,
0.3526885509490967,
-0.31299397349357605,
0.8219336867332458,
-0.0924830511212349,
-0.1257035732269287,
0.13986505568027496,
0.43707945942878723,
0.61961829662323,
0.1329742968082428,
-0.13831309974193573,
0.05358403921127319,
-0.17028886079788208,
-0.4212300777435303,
-0.827073872089386,
1.0124404430389404,
-0.7971107959747314,
-0.8360881209373474,
-0.772249162197113,
-0.21231167018413544,
-0.4451111853122711,
0.018503578379750252,
0.20094084739685059,
0.29055795073509216,
-0.47401657700538635,
0.22482830286026,
0.3542119562625885,
0.010090983472764492,
0.22438515722751617,
0.6569449305534363,
-0.11269215494394302,
-0.5121605396270752,
0.9178319573402405,
-0.0998016968369484,
0.46327492594718933,
0.29243311285972595,
0.24555256962776184,
-0.032764747738838196,
-0.8636031746864319,
-0.576051652431488,
-0.2200959175825119,
-0.6437547206878662,
-0.3346558213233948,
-0.028715381398797035,
-0.244605153799057,
-0.2389376014471054,
-0.2836778163909912,
-0.27040523290634155,
-0.4619588851928711,
-0.2049110382795334,
-0.281081885099411,
0.09498149901628494,
0.7842606902122498,
0.17154565453529358,
0.243263378739357,
-0.6377535462379456,
0.21523763239383698,
0.4925679564476013,
0.2068602591753006,
-0.2437782883644104,
-0.6328968405723572,
0.026301661506295204,
-0.13861821591854095,
-0.589040994644165,
-0.8113627433776855,
0.05651908740401268,
0.010520285926759243,
0.5165345668792725,
0.4095047414302826,
-0.013822503387928009,
0.2616986036300659,
-0.33827242255210876,
1.0605156421661377,
0.1301625818014145,
-0.5503599047660828,
0.39441248774528503,
-0.26925891637802124,
0.2409045398235321,
0.6707467436790466,
0.03976359963417053,
-0.2044162154197693,
-0.8066329956054688,
-0.4790760576725006,
-0.7754873633384705,
0.5699101090431213,
0.09006466716527939,
0.30716949701309204,
0.12784063816070557,
0.46960440278053284,
0.060456208884716034,
0.077022984623909,
-0.9322867393493652,
-0.36166226863861084,
-0.072666697204113,
-0.06553901731967926,
-0.1450110226869583,
-0.24069246649742126,
-0.2114344835281372,
0.001696228631772101,
0.48592743277549744,
-0.1557309478521347,
-0.17295566201210022,
0.128662109375,
-0.10495840758085251,
0.1770218312740326,
0.6430730819702148,
0.43016502261161804,
0.008907812647521496,
-0.23813730478286743,
0.40749436616897583,
0.29394322633743286,
-0.5135823488235474,
0.2757599651813507,
0.2806476950645447,
-0.3701131045818329,
-0.3885152339935303,
0.6034126281738281,
0.6460296511650085,
0.4044734835624695,
-0.6109772324562073,
0.8552350401878357,
-0.4078374207019806,
-0.38087108731269836,
-0.2955765724182129,
0.07632359862327576,
-0.21218980848789215,
0.24799863994121552,
0.1464744210243225,
0.26152196526527405,
-0.10563534498214722,
-0.6047616004943848,
0.11634059995412827,
0.6798049807548523,
-0.6514685153961182,
-0.21543514728546143,
0.8187825679779053,
-0.10572285950183868,
-0.06800661981105804,
0.29721036553382874,
-0.3221769630908966,
-0.7110608816146851,
0.5087568163871765,
0.34211045503616333,
1.0050541162490845,
-0.11375387758016586,
0.004404720850288868,
-0.18966680765151978,
0.568401038646698,
0.03437795490026474,
-0.007606644183397293,
-0.03171954303979874,
-0.6288681030273438,
-0.10008428990840912,
-0.6663098335266113,
-0.8624340295791626,
0.1965000033378601,
-0.6682112812995911,
0.07601571828126907,
-0.6649975180625916,
-0.2075439691543579,
-0.20031560957431793,
0.16259735822677612,
-0.4231286644935608,
0.24078549444675446,
0.4204891324043274,
0.7085046172142029,
-0.6832016110420227,
0.6020523309707642,
0.7172592878341675,
-0.1355837732553482,
-0.5485163927078247,
0.24671725928783417,
0.3248375654220581,
-0.7544355392456055,
0.2731028199195862,
0.04079655185341835,
-0.20416077971458435,
-0.5235099792480469,
-0.5372896194458008,
-0.3877294361591339,
0.9280447959899902,
0.7640828490257263,
-0.284273236989975,
0.042214665561914444,
0.11464964598417282,
0.6659954786300659,
-0.05288158729672432,
0.42320331931114197,
0.5342578291893005,
0.4148285388946533,
0.009961426258087158,
-0.8864607214927673,
0.1443423330783844,
-0.3039536476135254,
-0.37808647751808167,
0.12716734409332275,
-0.7596780061721802,
0.5534889698028564,
-0.20301052927970886,
0.014813081361353397,
0.2225346863269806,
0.4502183794975281,
0.1296941488981247,
0.3689785301685333,
0.4074711203575134,
0.6947891712188721,
0.6624318361282349,
-0.09966377913951874,
1.3770155906677246,
-0.21422351896762848,
0.30329105257987976,
1.283352017402649,
-0.34183359146118164,
0.8901294469833374,
0.2576731741428375,
-0.29384928941726685,
0.23905174434185028,
0.3799506723880768,
-0.32167237997055054,
0.2192288339138031,
0.5671640038490295,
-0.2244749814271927,
-0.1432856172323227,
0.12986858189105988,
0.033585451543331146,
0.5591590404510498,
0.21153602004051208,
-0.1777971386909485,
-0.2821354269981384,
-0.09084305167198181,
0.25607800483703613,
0.3845217525959015,
-0.297044962644577,
0.7043518424034119,
0.217301607131958,
-0.5046069622039795,
0.4198106527328491,
0.15160305798053741,
0.9243118166923523,
-0.6728928089141846,
0.2707644999027252,
-0.20300664007663727,
0.3728007674217224,
-0.031154628843069077,
-0.8600221276283264,
0.07468628138303757,
0.3835834562778473,
0.2002757042646408,
-0.0035585251171141863,
0.6194637417793274,
0.06911011040210724,
-0.540002703666687,
0.6506030559539795,
0.3910248875617981,
0.01661594584584236,
-0.352901816368103,
-0.5800600051879883,
-0.10240527242422104,
-0.13776837289333344,
-0.4855843484401703,
0.7998791337013245,
0.2957492768764496,
-0.11029734462499619,
0.7201142907142639,
0.5053730010986328,
0.43354225158691406,
0.18041859567165375,
0.2940683960914612,
0.786212682723999,
-0.5448850989341736,
-0.005414978135377169,
-1.1476414203643799,
0.058760736137628555,
0.13755181431770325,
-0.207770437002182,
0.8302819728851318,
0.40034860372543335,
0.8024580478668213,
0.4112809896469116,
0.7220425009727478,
0.31470733880996704,
0.27069053053855896,
-0.5488828420639038,
0.9186887145042419,
-0.6324076652526855,
0.44256433844566345,
-0.20651552081108093,
-0.5358871221542358,
-0.6236880421638489,
-0.004010137170553207,
-0.14416839182376862,
-0.14502233266830444,
0.5279102325439453,
0.5162336230278015,
0.19593171775341034,
-0.12917861342430115,
0.593573808670044,
0.38708987832069397,
0.5805506706237793,
0.510245144367218,
0.8661429286003113,
-0.4091523587703705,
0.9813852906227112,
-0.14098094403743744,
-0.08898376673460007,
-0.16516952216625214,
-0.6155311465263367,
-0.9062029719352722,
0.023281928151845932,
-0.1876654326915741,
-0.3134554624557495,
0.08892462402582169,
0.5356090664863586,
0.08389602601528168,
-0.8146328926086426,
0.015844719484448433,
0.21645955741405487,
0.23853246867656708,
0.007718694396317005,
-0.27035877108573914,
0.541226327419281,
-0.11227130889892578,
-0.4955158531665802,
0.6360868215560913,
0.22060427069664001,
-0.10520049929618835,
-0.5110642313957214,
0.12014137953519821,
0.014787553809583187,
0.005960885901004076,
0.36337459087371826,
0.05478405952453613,
-0.6554718017578125,
-0.6133115887641907,
-0.172434002161026,
-0.35564976930618286,
-0.0863475650548935,
0.3927444517612457,
-0.5789504051208496,
0.6065428853034973,
0.14393620193004608,
0.7061923146247864,
0.0915096253156662,
0.08021549880504608,
0.5065643191337585,
-0.757977306842804,
-0.0756053626537323,
0.35064324736595154,
0.5718024373054504,
0.42824065685272217,
-0.34759870171546936,
0.3333911597728729,
0.2217755764722824,
-0.6169317364692688,
-0.8953354358673096,
0.16643382608890533,
-1.0270686149597168,
-0.14186491072177887,
1.064934492111206,
-0.44580960273742676,
-0.10308246314525604,
0.2006782442331314,
-0.046218156814575195,
-0.14272408187389374,
-0.09654805809259415,
0.7903610467910767,
0.852656900882721,
0.1719442456960678,
0.31134194135665894,
-0.6622010469436646,
0.013497129082679749,
0.32524555921554565,
-0.5322135090827942,
-0.04124528542160988,
0.09642107784748077,
0.308652400970459,
0.16204257309436798,
0.30374184250831604,
-0.3296475410461426,
0.3091168701648712,
0.034266918897628784,
-0.15602071583271027,
-0.13017308712005615,
-0.08392082899808884,
-0.7942262291908264,
0.4995521605014801,
0.45016342401504517,
-0.2483993023633957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14008v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14008v2
|
OlympiadBench: A Challenging Benchmark for Promoting AGI with Olympiad-Level Bilingual Multimodal Scientific Problems
| 2024-02-21T18:49:26 | 2024-06-06T13:19:44 |
Chaoqun He, Renjie Luo, Yuzhuo Bai, Shengding Hu, Zhen Leng Thai, Junhao Shen, Jinyi Hu, Xu Han, Yujie Huang, Yuxiang Zhang, Jie Liu, Lei Qi, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements have seen Large Language Models (LLMs) and Large
Multimodal Models (LMMs) surpassing general human capabilities in various
tasks, approaching the proficiency level of human experts across multiple
domains. With traditional benchmarks becoming less challenging for these
models, new rigorous challenges are essential to gauge their advanced
abilities. In this work, we present OlympiadBench, an Olympiad-level bilingual
multimodal scientific benchmark, featuring 8,476 problems from Olympiad-level
mathematics and physics competitions, including the Chinese college entrance
exam. Each problem is detailed with expert-level annotations for step-by-step
reasoning. Evaluating top-tier models on OlympiadBench, we implement a
comprehensive assessment methodology to accurately evaluate model responses.
Notably, the best-performing model, GPT-4V, attains an average score of 17.97%
on OlympiadBench, with a mere 10.74% in physics, highlighting the benchmark
rigor and the intricacy of physical reasoning. Our analysis orienting GPT-4V
points out prevalent issues with hallucinations, knowledge omissions, and
logical fallacies. We hope that our challenging benchmark can serve as a
valuable resource for helping future AGI research endeavors. The data and
evaluation code are available at \url{https://github.com/OpenBMB/OlympiadBench}
|
[
-0.44672584533691406,
-0.5557931065559387,
0.5465785264968872,
0.5152518153190613,
0.12695759534835815,
0.10998155921697617,
-0.06468340754508972,
-0.3835858404636383,
-0.3047133982181549,
-0.25566336512565613,
-0.4133155047893524,
-0.2691086232662201,
-0.47909507155418396,
0.3212602138519287,
-0.19113430380821228,
0.6178099513053894,
-0.3778969943523407,
0.20413848757743835,
-0.6640841960906982,
-0.06763289868831635,
-0.300616979598999,
-0.19373397529125214,
-0.3984305262565613,
-0.4738646149635315,
0.28477200865745544,
0.41165977716445923,
0.4297981858253479,
0.4565370976924896,
0.49615320563316345,
0.40803179144859314,
0.07716827839612961,
0.19981762766838074,
-0.3908185064792633,
-0.061206694692373276,
-0.41267913579940796,
-0.3239854574203491,
-0.4886011481285095,
0.38738107681274414,
0.7444036602973938,
0.6622430682182312,
-0.22996003925800323,
0.10728884488344193,
-0.12536759674549103,
0.33097442984580994,
-0.6058644652366638,
0.25143861770629883,
-0.5580424666404724,
0.17740373313426971,
-0.30695798993110657,
0.007855815812945366,
-0.20619311928749084,
-0.04620480164885521,
-0.22541764378547668,
-0.7321731448173523,
0.04070534184575081,
0.08619646728038788,
0.8463547229766846,
-0.011510167270898819,
-0.7427836656570435,
0.04587509110569954,
-0.32116490602493286,
0.8363151550292969,
-0.21612776815891266,
0.675073504447937,
0.5043969750404358,
0.5878158807754517,
-0.15201270580291748,
-0.6125088334083557,
-0.6494705080986023,
-0.47907668352127075,
0.560570478439331,
0.4951339364051819,
-0.0484253466129303,
-0.2033362239599228,
0.19482490420341492,
0.21216556429862976,
-0.8290204405784607,
-0.08537948131561279,
-0.45250898599624634,
-0.1885882169008255,
0.779930055141449,
0.33935314416885376,
0.23655812442302704,
-0.09575489163398743,
-0.08344292640686035,
-0.42052918672561646,
-0.5010363459587097,
0.15032944083213806,
0.6413285732269287,
-0.16418063640594482,
0.09313025325536728,
0.7228134870529175,
-0.475381463766098,
0.44394373893737793,
0.11170771718025208,
0.11946845054626465,
0.4834238886833191,
-0.45962414145469666,
0.2455945909023285,
-0.21773959696292877,
0.7021383047103882,
0.4658561944961548,
0.22636736929416656,
-0.3030858337879181,
-0.09154047071933746,
0.038586292415857315,
0.193036288022995,
-1.0039057731628418,
-0.21650445461273193,
0.15205253660678864,
-0.10173647850751877,
0.09267561882734299,
-0.0002905506989918649,
-0.8361378312110901,
-0.30664098262786865,
-0.27811503410339355,
0.4195127785205841,
-0.46721139550209045,
-0.07730171084403992,
-0.020448720082640648,
-0.0872005894780159,
0.2559281289577484,
0.4351401925086975,
-0.8515781164169312,
0.21600282192230225,
0.9759040474891663,
0.8867248892784119,
-0.20601052045822144,
-0.6536524891853333,
-0.5747182965278625,
-0.02726823277771473,
-0.3259575068950653,
0.815814197063446,
-0.6344913244247437,
-0.5432040095329285,
-0.5405676960945129,
-0.08330613374710083,
-0.3616282045841217,
-0.44853687286376953,
0.5422601699829102,
-0.19805863499641418,
0.040109340101480484,
-0.13466192781925201,
-0.3649745285511017,
-0.0034493934363126755,
0.7303705811500549,
-0.43745341897010803,
0.9757460951805115,
0.04801084101200104,
-0.5744876265525818,
0.08793792128562927,
-0.6311648488044739,
-0.13576075434684753,
0.11331471055746078,
-0.3198981285095215,
-0.13630321621894836,
0.14712226390838623,
0.12574034929275513,
0.017866060137748718,
-0.47792112827301025,
0.5743996500968933,
-0.5974103212356567,
0.03312462940812111,
0.2215726524591446,
-0.5699753165245056,
0.4741394817829132,
0.40469345450401306,
-0.19449789822101593,
0.053042035549879074,
-0.9495173692703247,
0.2978588044643402,
0.08890420943498611,
-0.1559572070837021,
-0.03295008838176727,
0.09459453076124191,
-0.1391492784023285,
0.2654878497123718,
0.3124341070652008,
-0.6915243268013,
0.31837382912635803,
-0.16628453135490417,
0.2442379891872406,
0.9356420040130615,
-0.3783491849899292,
0.06142377853393555,
-0.21071793138980865,
0.49200186133384705,
-0.21395322680473328,
0.26140812039375305,
-0.013380567543208599,
-0.8195313215255737,
-0.3229990601539612,
-0.20402927696704865,
0.30609601736068726,
0.7107506990432739,
-0.8575599789619446,
-0.07279271632432938,
-0.41243776679039,
-0.8079301118850708,
-0.5524520874023438,
0.0652739405632019,
0.32411378622055054,
0.6806856989860535,
0.4182431697845459,
-0.3046431243419647,
-0.11311807483434677,
-1.056061863899231,
-0.3941642940044403,
-0.08856693655252457,
-0.1048128679394722,
0.4978470802307129,
0.8787087202072144,
-0.2639869153499603,
0.7288574576377869,
-0.2309495210647583,
-0.06154928356409073,
0.16992546617984772,
0.6485481262207031,
0.16600173711776733,
0.539947509765625,
0.40544480085372925,
-0.8729479908943176,
-0.7497206330299377,
0.4943692088127136,
-0.7635066509246826,
-0.446256548166275,
0.14770492911338806,
-0.06423080712556839,
-0.174452543258667,
0.20643164217472076,
-0.5512188673019409,
0.32299789786338806,
0.5950800776481628,
-0.49660757184028625,
1.031630516052246,
-0.24021315574645996,
0.6126537919044495,
-0.6642830967903137,
0.3569073975086212,
-0.04492158815264702,
-0.02331763133406639,
-0.5502116680145264,
0.3422612249851227,
0.18188847601413727,
-0.22630834579467773,
-0.3550723195075989,
0.8018376231193542,
-0.3606914281845093,
0.12806932628154755,
-0.17811360955238342,
0.002588359173387289,
-0.09495224058628082,
0.01113501749932766,
-0.227687269449234,
1.0153775215148926,
0.5892899632453918,
-0.06836815923452377,
0.7177606225013733,
0.05764539912343025,
-0.36041995882987976,
0.8185696005821228,
-0.6722977161407471,
0.07789874076843262,
-0.08900243043899536,
-0.02180367521941662,
-0.7040396928787231,
-0.45564955472946167,
0.034215785562992096,
-0.5374000668525696,
0.23059964179992676,
0.26945292949676514,
-0.5624915361404419,
-0.4459386467933655,
-0.505489706993103,
0.6146470904350281,
0.23442022502422333,
-0.41583535075187683,
0.939721405506134,
0.10459771007299423,
-0.42111095786094666,
-0.5777487754821777,
-0.46395182609558105,
0.19934579730033875,
0.04275250434875488,
-0.9030629396438599,
0.3502815365791321,
-0.5678784251213074,
-0.17204530537128448,
0.1337568610906601,
-0.2724422514438629,
-0.2374226301908493,
0.19195815920829773,
-0.004754510708153248,
-0.000676498340908438,
-0.07771588116884232,
-0.19092777371406555,
-0.17217475175857544,
-0.1510968953371048,
0.19741970300674438,
0.10580064356327057,
0.2986571788787842,
-0.5934476852416992,
-0.7389028072357178,
-0.2803490161895752,
0.5341147780418396,
0.47442111372947693,
-0.30309486389160156,
0.3836491107940674,
0.40979236364364624,
-0.21727481484413147,
0.1379871517419815,
-0.587713360786438,
0.06101852282881737,
-0.48329958319664,
0.5972684025764465,
-0.7901114225387573,
-0.5840426087379456,
0.6951205134391785,
-0.12217224389314651,
-0.20526611804962158,
0.3270610570907593,
0.5129120349884033,
0.32118675112724304,
1.535412073135376,
0.22502611577510834,
0.0026511773467063904,
0.040510423481464386,
-0.06903952360153198,
0.02304227091372013,
-0.8672376871109009,
-0.3809698522090912,
-0.5299155116081238,
-0.17739708721637726,
-0.23115256428718567,
-0.7239195704460144,
0.5722098350524902,
0.046939633786678314,
-0.3341810703277588,
-0.042255934327840805,
-0.17248111963272095,
0.654948890209198,
0.5362619757652283,
-0.15112988650798798,
0.21804247796535492,
-0.24516847729682922,
-0.43796125054359436,
-0.04581991955637932,
-0.5885655879974365,
-0.12602393329143524,
1.1331216096878052,
0.09270104765892029,
0.6025944948196411,
0.21241243183612823,
0.40929514169692993,
-0.018696442246437073,
0.47550496459007263,
-0.403118371963501,
0.6685078740119934,
0.18466024100780487,
-0.9114543795585632,
0.03096863441169262,
-0.7653564810752869,
-0.9542781114578247,
0.6041836738586426,
-0.19581466913223267,
-1.0043152570724487,
0.16183924674987793,
0.046109266579151154,
-0.07004520297050476,
0.11597991734743118,
-0.6679980158805847,
1.1368184089660645,
-0.550864040851593,
-0.933682918548584,
-0.27733665704727173,
-0.48517149686813354,
0.39104586839675903,
-0.26986807584762573,
0.5454360246658325,
-0.13914130628108978,
0.06114933639764786,
0.38537997007369995,
-0.2673030495643616,
0.44846728444099426,
-0.040576085448265076,
0.2790878415107727,
0.2168988138437271,
0.053807273507118225,
0.45967862010002136,
0.07789327204227448,
-0.26061108708381653,
0.019681479781866074,
-0.07331864535808563,
-0.4472217857837677,
-0.4173256456851959,
0.9704591631889343,
-1.0120428800582886,
-0.8442555069923401,
-0.6828420162200928,
-0.6946495771408081,
-0.29976242780685425,
0.2644350528717041,
-0.003752294462174177,
0.18487776815891266,
-0.26970744132995605,
0.23835605382919312,
0.3876822888851166,
0.0023682070896029472,
0.15913167595863342,
0.49817386269569397,
-0.2633512020111084,
-0.5425102710723877,
1.2468456029891968,
0.19572851061820984,
0.08822556585073471,
-0.14805229008197784,
0.29241982102394104,
-0.33091482520103455,
-0.6477214694023132,
-0.48738959431648254,
0.24150241911411285,
-0.8441086411476135,
-0.1704804003238678,
-0.5829147100448608,
-0.10452619940042496,
-0.5780240893363953,
-0.0670437216758728,
-0.5521702766418457,
-0.28609102964401245,
-0.07217817008495331,
-0.035515446215867996,
-0.1802855134010315,
0.24027159810066223,
-0.38896915316581726,
-0.027841787785291672,
-0.750710129737854,
0.41431480646133423,
0.5547570586204529,
0.6194956302642822,
-0.023015957325696945,
-0.27260103821754456,
-0.1278502345085144,
-0.050623342394828796,
-0.7544347643852234,
-0.8723725080490112,
0.3063597083091736,
0.4166521728038788,
0.8744300007820129,
0.5250454545021057,
-0.21468813717365265,
0.8597260117530823,
-0.8035405278205872,
0.6952274441719055,
0.1333369016647339,
-1.0634797811508179,
0.2906249165534973,
-0.3511876165866852,
0.37568071484565735,
0.6550970673561096,
0.652435839176178,
-0.3903241455554962,
-0.31873592734336853,
-0.43436309695243835,
-0.8791912198066711,
0.6274093985557556,
0.25877976417541504,
-0.19036038219928741,
-0.0967414453625679,
0.10488444566726685,
0.1315447986125946,
0.2875126600265503,
-0.8253492116928101,
0.2073318213224411,
-0.518858790397644,
-0.26456090807914734,
-0.14607885479927063,
0.13337591290473938,
-0.23556622862815857,
-0.3805091679096222,
0.7547077536582947,
-0.2825511693954468,
-0.09424828737974167,
0.16899186372756958,
-0.18228058516979218,
-0.06355804949998856,
0.24568775296211243,
0.6215320229530334,
0.6249430179595947,
-0.16869716346263885,
0.15856124460697174,
0.22887246310710907,
-0.40145143866539,
0.0798514261841774,
0.6342359185218811,
0.05345521494746208,
-0.5842391848564148,
0.3715554475784302,
0.6612191796302795,
-0.07691428810358047,
-0.9936972856521606,
0.5184580683708191,
0.02193298004567623,
-0.2643582820892334,
-0.06369543820619583,
-0.03890035301446915,
0.025149870663881302,
0.38745349645614624,
0.4789089858531952,
-0.15773627161979675,
0.445488303899765,
-0.5451916456222534,
0.03736962750554085,
0.5886480212211609,
-0.032632313668727875,
-0.6636905074119568,
1.0148096084594727,
0.2712039649486542,
-0.016041303053498268,
0.5552250742912292,
-0.5055406093597412,
-0.5419130325317383,
0.6981894969940186,
0.46750903129577637,
0.5696104168891907,
-0.5786842703819275,
0.1289242058992386,
0.3954993486404419,
0.41629618406295776,
-0.15805195271968842,
0.3049373924732208,
-0.06631410866975784,
-0.4733867943286896,
-0.5018967390060425,
-0.412491112947464,
-0.5852270126342773,
-0.1718231737613678,
-0.33204030990600586,
0.23024101555347443,
-0.18121053278446198,
-0.0697021409869194,
0.05945432558655739,
-0.0483596995472908,
-0.5509045124053955,
0.020074522122740746,
0.38644322752952576,
0.8325640559196472,
-0.8034296631813049,
0.4715754985809326,
0.8970347046852112,
-0.10935063660144806,
-0.31600943207740784,
-0.5355148911476135,
0.24164876341819763,
-0.6549965143203735,
0.7318331003189087,
0.34954214096069336,
-0.020825838670134544,
0.02702944166958332,
-0.5996631979942322,
-0.8434441089630127,
1.0229932069778442,
0.10779944062232971,
-0.31024837493896484,
0.20227257907390594,
0.358316034078598,
0.49407586455345154,
-0.3061118721961975,
0.7621530294418335,
0.3832298219203949,
0.972257137298584,
0.08989056944847107,
-1.1310172080993652,
-0.18169023096561432,
-0.7810235619544983,
-0.20287156105041504,
-0.026170706376433372,
-0.8523647785186768,
1.1444129943847656,
-0.038440871983766556,
-0.1468198001384735,
0.22001680731773376,
0.5358843803405762,
0.4788714051246643,
0.7960205674171448,
0.3751101791858673,
0.8625050783157349,
0.5850515365600586,
-0.2318601757287979,
1.063384771347046,
-0.09860419481992722,
0.41616037487983704,
0.770874559879303,
-0.6713904142379761,
0.6131290197372437,
0.4959762394428253,
-0.108176089823246,
0.2227402925491333,
0.5163136124610901,
-0.33887991309165955,
0.48591122031211853,
0.36962345242500305,
-0.19787615537643433,
-0.4364584684371948,
-0.06054440140724182,
-0.6059733629226685,
0.40598264336586,
0.2794778048992157,
0.48689231276512146,
-0.6226066946983337,
0.40518414974212646,
-0.10400057584047318,
0.04359893128275871,
-0.3635270297527313,
0.38031575083732605,
-0.17728085815906525,
-0.6930602192878723,
0.44533440470695496,
0.013273953460156918,
0.354618638753891,
-0.6899013519287109,
-0.0026019620709121227,
-0.2705112397670746,
0.2790658175945282,
0.04166373983025551,
-0.7377496361732483,
0.024119172245264053,
0.07959786802530289,
-0.03211221843957901,
-0.029727814719080925,
0.4073202908039093,
-0.39303019642829895,
-0.5802319645881653,
0.18042661249637604,
0.45715370774269104,
0.24956348538398743,
-0.15590865910053253,
-0.7843320965766907,
0.147903710603714,
-0.23309557139873505,
-0.5567396283149719,
0.42617642879486084,
0.595617413520813,
-0.2843500077724457,
0.9366885423660278,
0.5457289218902588,
-0.05858068913221359,
0.2862991690635681,
-0.2632150948047638,
0.8966718316078186,
-0.580065131187439,
-0.3098016679286957,
-0.5583978891372681,
0.49613723158836365,
-0.2651084065437317,
-0.3708864450454712,
0.8228822946548462,
0.8136253356933594,
0.7977209687232971,
-0.0648171454668045,
0.6111599206924438,
-0.07866290956735611,
0.17323051393032074,
-0.07279691845178604,
0.6083315014839172,
-0.8760020136833191,
-0.16374903917312622,
-0.09024317562580109,
-0.772787868976593,
-0.37365296483039856,
0.48198533058166504,
-0.39150214195251465,
0.1406441479921341,
0.7747595310211182,
0.5113723278045654,
-0.22978851199150085,
-0.08190751820802689,
0.2708723247051239,
0.3648284077644348,
0.5788729786872864,
0.7979896664619446,
1.040212869644165,
-0.19855085015296936,
0.5048536062240601,
-0.21146471798419952,
-0.5526184439659119,
-0.24671931564807892,
-0.9986081123352051,
-0.7985488176345825,
-0.266348659992218,
-0.34562361240386963,
0.07159650325775146,
0.20315681397914886,
0.740385890007019,
0.5149491429328918,
-0.692692756652832,
-0.3700893819332123,
0.03752606362104416,
-0.03433823212981224,
-0.2746084928512573,
-0.20649632811546326,
0.2346550077199936,
-0.19672419130802155,
-1.0120412111282349,
0.6479967832565308,
0.14071904122829437,
-0.01665101759135723,
0.0017981110140681267,
0.021231308579444885,
-0.32381367683410645,
0.20109137892723083,
0.4761151373386383,
0.5055920481681824,
-0.5207769274711609,
-0.3306162655353546,
0.1768990457057953,
0.09882235527038574,
-0.06543678790330887,
0.35993167757987976,
-0.673365592956543,
0.8935226798057556,
0.4772432744503021,
0.7177610993385315,
0.48634999990463257,
0.10469455271959305,
0.2910356819629669,
-0.3641834557056427,
0.13250796496868134,
0.3362142741680145,
0.3888309895992279,
0.2540246546268463,
0.09084489941596985,
0.6443654894828796,
0.49342718720436096,
-0.8283347487449646,
-1.0455642938613892,
0.06488256901502609,
-0.9562982320785522,
-0.3236333131790161,
0.7728150486946106,
-0.12939098477363586,
-0.4033929407596588,
0.14874203503131866,
-0.0954798087477684,
-0.1227639690041542,
-0.21271347999572754,
1.046428918838501,
1.1885831356048584,
-0.2710099220275879,
-0.09665384143590927,
-0.7710483074188232,
-0.11198338121175766,
0.6251595616340637,
-0.896065354347229,
-0.10708806663751602,
0.5459754467010498,
0.05214463174343109,
0.3567354083061218,
0.34911608695983887,
-0.12183863669633865,
0.5095025897026062,
0.2594520151615143,
0.2971353530883789,
-0.49612390995025635,
-0.5413517951965332,
-0.05493420735001564,
0.34674856066703796,
-0.11821739375591278,
0.19521299004554749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14007v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14007v2
|
Can Watermarks Survive Translation? On the Cross-lingual Consistency of Text Watermark for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T18:48:38 | 2024-06-04T14:24:15 |
Zhiwei He, Binglin Zhou, Hongkun Hao, Aiwei Liu, Xing Wang, Zhaopeng Tu, Zhuosheng Zhang, Rui Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text watermarking technology aims to tag and identify content produced by
large language models (LLMs) to prevent misuse. In this study, we introduce the
concept of cross-lingual consistency in text watermarking, which assesses the
ability of text watermarks to maintain their effectiveness after being
translated into other languages. Preliminary empirical results from two LLMs
and three watermarking methods reveal that current text watermarking
technologies lack consistency when texts are translated into various languages.
Based on this observation, we propose a Cross-lingual Watermark Removal Attack
(CWRA) to bypass watermarking by first obtaining a response from an LLM in a
pivot language, which is then translated into the target language. CWRA can
effectively remove watermarks, decreasing the AUCs to a random-guessing level
without performance loss. Furthermore, we analyze two key factors that
contribute to the cross-lingual consistency in text watermarking and propose
X-SIR as a defense method against CWRA. Code: https://github.com/zwhe99/X-SIR.
|
[
-0.22329235076904297,
-0.7855296730995178,
0.3787032663822174,
0.3151998817920685,
-0.5839770436286926,
0.41596677899360657,
0.010927550494670868,
-0.800423264503479,
0.26533201336860657,
0.7366135120391846,
-0.24080732464790344,
-0.292624831199646,
-0.7621497511863708,
0.1946314573287964,
-0.6377948522567749,
0.7758447527885437,
-0.4009603261947632,
0.18108046054840088,
-0.038675807416439056,
-0.3264152407646179,
-0.5734890699386597,
-0.6778697967529297,
-0.6031816005706787,
-0.39809682965278625,
0.5510258674621582,
0.14662231504917145,
0.8506941795349121,
0.7338026762008667,
0.5906633734703064,
0.2423258274793625,
-0.2089819759130478,
0.19122521579265594,
-0.41344913840293884,
0.23455984890460968,
-0.29653722047805786,
-0.5825808644294739,
-0.25082477927207947,
-0.17342297732830048,
0.8255966305732727,
0.3478992283344269,
0.24672816693782806,
-0.33196306228637695,
0.07552129030227661,
0.6405822038650513,
-0.5998220443725586,
0.033137667924165726,
-0.8057301640510559,
0.22545300424098969,
-0.5815792083740234,
-0.26985660195350647,
-0.4467780590057373,
-0.047545719891786575,
0.023145876824855804,
-0.6390985250473022,
-0.18265944719314575,
0.516481339931488,
1.1463712453842163,
-0.02668602578341961,
-0.2788550853729248,
-0.0170915387570858,
-0.8078116178512573,
0.8640804290771484,
-0.602232038974762,
0.4938262403011322,
0.5520193576812744,
0.14734598994255066,
-0.0810755267739296,
-0.5305521488189697,
-0.5016568303108215,
0.08066944777965546,
0.22855202853679657,
0.22123388946056366,
-0.4342297911643982,
-0.41699036955833435,
0.07606572657823563,
0.23202218115329742,
-0.4987794756889343,
-0.10869599133729935,
0.10539685934782028,
-0.14247123897075653,
0.6351401209831238,
0.059751156717538834,
0.7178071141242981,
0.08968795835971832,
-0.6755696535110474,
-0.1532972902059555,
-1.2284826040267944,
-0.10127986967563629,
0.19123481214046478,
0.2992507517337799,
-0.035145316272974014,
0.614008903503418,
0.13285388052463531,
0.18922513723373413,
-0.1344904899597168,
-0.23889324069023132,
-0.05774084851145744,
-0.3802391290664673,
-0.12445860356092453,
0.23181147873401642,
0.7687768936157227,
0.24177883565425873,
0.6899277567863464,
-0.44708165526390076,
-0.3104231357574463,
-0.3604767918586731,
0.11542064696550369,
-0.45900556445121765,
-0.03334110975265503,
-0.23816391825675964,
-0.375238835811615,
-0.00940052978694439,
-0.02833343856036663,
-0.38096198439598083,
-0.4434124529361725,
0.029333172366023064,
0.6933582425117493,
-0.33357521891593933,
-0.3563915193080902,
0.007434183731675148,
-0.18379084765911102,
0.26683518290519714,
0.1493871957063675,
-0.7665336728096008,
0.2379198670387268,
0.715665340423584,
0.770341157913208,
-0.4346058666706085,
-0.5225580334663391,
-0.5337079167366028,
0.5921539664268494,
-0.5766263008117676,
0.7945699691772461,
-0.5678850412368774,
-0.5811687111854553,
0.07152605056762695,
0.20145124197006226,
-0.13713906705379486,
-0.6405189633369446,
0.3400570750236511,
-0.9222229719161987,
0.21606643497943878,
-0.6373753547668457,
-0.6130874156951904,
-0.14093412458896637,
0.49802830815315247,
-0.8056412935256958,
0.8486625552177429,
-0.06973588466644287,
-1.0378109216690063,
0.310820609331131,
-0.1615321785211563,
-0.6604734063148499,
0.16608773171901703,
-0.026634138077497482,
-0.6188704371452332,
-0.03361574932932854,
-0.04000250622630119,
0.07860241830348969,
-0.42351245880126953,
0.13292425870895386,
-0.20438307523727417,
-0.331560879945755,
0.4379616379737854,
-0.5127143859863281,
0.6497830748558044,
-0.2601074278354645,
-0.6250572800636292,
-0.041564054787158966,
-0.31960391998291016,
0.11962264031171799,
0.3950670659542084,
-0.3906298279762268,
-0.7504071593284607,
0.10278484225273132,
0.25876328349113464,
0.2652372717857361,
0.32111960649490356,
-0.6750061511993408,
0.007162465713918209,
-0.10995583981275558,
0.3518691062927246,
0.6157697439193726,
0.0034783072769641876,
0.30512458086013794,
-0.3581211566925049,
0.6271050572395325,
-0.06636254489421844,
0.0900067538022995,
-0.12133488059043884,
-0.8601312041282654,
-0.5605693459510803,
-0.13153645396232605,
0.6552701592445374,
0.6808871626853943,
-1.0267055034637451,
0.13719533383846283,
-0.5588157176971436,
-0.3903709352016449,
-0.2239793986082077,
0.376380980014801,
0.7680307626724243,
0.20798057317733765,
0.4904800057411194,
-0.330145001411438,
-0.36107662320137024,
-0.8600505590438843,
-0.6437106132507324,
-0.34273624420166016,
0.27352944016456604,
0.11381129920482635,
0.5699806213378906,
-0.1961108148097992,
1.0422637462615967,
-0.1294252872467041,
-0.33450308442115784,
-0.43584510684013367,
0.10183759778738022,
-0.4830560088157654,
0.556303083896637,
0.6081371307373047,
-1.1257658004760742,
-0.8724663257598877,
0.38515281677246094,
-0.5196290612220764,
-0.3722034692764282,
-0.07537660002708435,
-0.10495629906654358,
0.5382212400436401,
0.49734652042388916,
-0.5007658004760742,
0.6752135157585144,
0.8404201865196228,
-0.3535575568675995,
0.4259178638458252,
-0.17942126095294952,
0.24597829580307007,
-0.695728600025177,
0.2534952759742737,
-0.0036661212798208,
-0.4403708279132843,
-0.538337230682373,
0.015815457329154015,
0.28610363602638245,
0.1393754929304123,
-0.4273625910282135,
1.035836935043335,
-0.3537323474884033,
-0.00836846511811018,
-0.6100961565971375,
0.04238670691847801,
0.35975193977355957,
0.2537676990032196,
0.12097065150737762,
0.7267763614654541,
0.2904609143733978,
-0.1891094297170639,
0.020711805671453476,
0.20985820889472961,
-0.13329502940177917,
0.6127383708953857,
-0.8832814693450928,
-0.03162571042776108,
0.15396755933761597,
0.13961708545684814,
-1.0074418783187866,
0.37697723507881165,
0.6453297734260559,
-0.3114783763885498,
0.4918428659439087,
-0.2677171528339386,
-0.5832707285881042,
0.2724614441394806,
-0.22485749423503876,
0.2720888555049896,
0.2788788676261902,
-0.586077094078064,
0.6571708917617798,
0.3315948247909546,
-0.38253548741340637,
-0.5963241457939148,
-0.9883602261543274,
0.5672568082809448,
-0.09043535590171814,
-0.5922879576683044,
0.7109504342079163,
-0.2216782569885254,
-0.2827063500881195,
0.13114844262599945,
-0.19469700753688812,
-0.3180496096611023,
0.0756189376115799,
0.13457238674163818,
0.26986604928970337,
0.01196425873786211,
-0.400144100189209,
0.1003899797797203,
-0.25189894437789917,
0.11652053147554398,
-0.03329316899180412,
0.37202683091163635,
0.25580528378486633,
-0.5946243405342102,
-0.3098074495792389,
0.7227663397789001,
0.5230023860931396,
-0.2840659022331238,
0.6907246112823486,
0.49781912565231323,
-0.49245908856391907,
0.08781027048826218,
-0.39042747020721436,
0.17281724512577057,
-0.4551730751991272,
0.11655417084693909,
-0.3191129267215729,
-0.7260428071022034,
0.6705134510993958,
0.18275249004364014,
0.06902649998664856,
0.49358901381492615,
0.1871872991323471,
-0.09892553091049194,
1.0600502490997314,
0.9028080701828003,
-0.4427171051502228,
0.5666010975837708,
-0.019027408212423325,
0.33845213055610657,
-0.6014500260353088,
-0.1920817494392395,
-0.6632263660430908,
-0.11276879906654358,
-0.32987552881240845,
-0.34515658020973206,
0.10209478437900543,
0.16019406914710999,
-0.03593681380152702,
0.39927563071250916,
0.019068365916609764,
0.44166332483291626,
0.508670449256897,
-0.24307605624198914,
0.4608364999294281,
0.20847877860069275,
-0.1965721696615219,
-0.27384287118911743,
-0.6235089302062988,
-0.42745646834373474,
0.44758278131484985,
0.2415243536233902,
0.6479211449623108,
-0.13558702170848846,
0.5712872743606567,
0.4475051462650299,
0.3532508313655853,
-0.4629552364349365,
0.4726462960243225,
-0.013194862753152847,
-0.7395994067192078,
-0.2590055465698242,
-0.4512368142604828,
-1.0235750675201416,
0.3587595820426941,
-0.14062996208667755,
-0.419216126203537,
-0.018722200766205788,
-0.1705915778875351,
0.3392673134803772,
0.6145216226577759,
-0.351690411567688,
0.8836649656295776,
-0.6231855750083923,
-0.46887660026550293,
-0.13762247562408447,
-0.632007896900177,
-0.12639878690242767,
-0.5334070324897766,
0.2769651412963867,
-0.005462070927023888,
-0.26385778188705444,
0.7539559006690979,
-0.2979532480239868,
0.8107120394706726,
-0.15981456637382507,
-0.5743933916091919,
0.12805861234664917,
0.1489250659942627,
0.4732271432876587,
-0.0901678130030632,
0.17043837904930115,
0.5526214838027954,
0.036656688898801804,
-0.5314294099807739,
-0.42429372668266296,
0.45353081822395325,
-0.39967647194862366,
-0.5593917369842529,
-0.40562623739242554,
-0.3578551411628723,
-0.10803976655006409,
0.5518640279769897,
0.2655838131904602,
0.22003647685050964,
-0.25241875648498535,
0.08395195007324219,
0.702892005443573,
-0.22973933815956116,
0.6392814517021179,
0.5382095575332642,
-0.30688461661338806,
-0.5944976806640625,
1.0100210905075073,
0.3836318850517273,
0.2660507559776306,
0.6825658679008484,
0.29225632548332214,
-0.2933706045150757,
-0.7136176228523254,
-0.8179380297660828,
0.2036915123462677,
-0.6897326707839966,
-0.21980144083499908,
-0.3651295602321625,
-0.10860491544008255,
-0.05926074460148811,
-0.24122990667819977,
-0.4134577214717865,
-0.24298526346683502,
0.016009820625185966,
0.42940714955329895,
0.2317516952753067,
0.5194687843322754,
0.09477872401475906,
0.20601582527160645,
-1.1675591468811035,
0.4223347008228302,
0.17658662796020508,
0.14205095171928406,
-0.16654816269874573,
-0.6672949194908142,
-0.42331236600875854,
0.2613724172115326,
-0.16970565915107727,
-0.5872681736946106,
0.49377062916755676,
0.1636853963136673,
0.7244508862495422,
0.42778801918029785,
0.06534060090780258,
0.5388760566711426,
-0.6902598738670349,
0.6048653721809387,
0.2585655450820923,
-1.2529600858688354,
0.14287124574184418,
-0.2642969787120819,
0.3807501792907715,
0.17358767986297607,
0.321728378534317,
-0.8159391283988953,
-0.5637391209602356,
-0.29058605432510376,
-0.9044029116630554,
0.1801912784576416,
0.16198475658893585,
0.30688074231147766,
0.06636635214090347,
0.2531099021434784,
0.09818267822265625,
0.048122815787792206,
-0.8811807632446289,
-0.2357703596353531,
-0.1847440004348755,
0.08071758598089218,
0.05883041396737099,
-0.26727795600891113,
-0.1794481873512268,
-0.022148454561829567,
0.8297849297523499,
-0.13589945435523987,
-0.10203823447227478,
0.19237038493156433,
-0.27609333395957947,
-0.235078364610672,
0.23640932142734528,
0.550679624080658,
0.4883963465690613,
0.27249011397361755,
0.051410432904958725,
0.015512442216277122,
-0.5870154500007629,
0.13489967584609985,
-0.12117984145879745,
-0.4202650785446167,
0.15303583443164825,
0.560616672039032,
0.46248453855514526,
0.3455212712287903,
-0.7391073703765869,
0.49816253781318665,
-0.202192485332489,
-0.08907584100961685,
-0.035366278141736984,
-0.18829120695590973,
0.258057564496994,
0.10667203366756439,
0.6270949244499207,
-0.13525325059890747,
-0.41425299644470215,
-0.45674818754196167,
-0.11162617802619934,
0.6669648885726929,
-0.3185184895992279,
-0.2968529462814331,
0.7362464070320129,
0.0451032929122448,
-0.20293205976486206,
0.15793606638908386,
0.12798945605754852,
-0.999330461025238,
0.520649254322052,
0.6832323670387268,
0.904346764087677,
-0.26084500551223755,
-0.08861710131168365,
-0.1393844485282898,
0.6340712308883667,
-0.26627305150032043,
0.4318792223930359,
0.037688687443733215,
-0.7709808945655823,
-0.44145357608795166,
-0.20602251589298248,
-0.8631528615951538,
-0.2883424162864685,
-0.5260040163993835,
-0.09749594330787659,
-0.3588258624076843,
-0.06231649965047836,
-0.10707336664199829,
0.030206220224499702,
-0.2210400253534317,
0.29659363627433777,
0.2732611894607544,
0.9664593935012817,
-0.8193361163139343,
1.1505204439163208,
0.6125401258468628,
0.11583290249109268,
-0.35633090138435364,
0.09096645563840866,
-0.13904719054698944,
-0.6543024182319641,
0.6134839653968811,
-0.012920374050736427,
-0.5016507506370544,
-0.28287455439567566,
-0.5138126611709595,
-0.9573239088058472,
0.6199741959571838,
0.5426061153411865,
-0.46271568536758423,
0.38846355676651,
0.6155686378479004,
0.47162461280822754,
-0.15133076906204224,
-0.42970842123031616,
0.2912955582141876,
0.8260013461112976,
-0.4186650216579437,
-0.9378599524497986,
0.12591315805912018,
-0.4839116930961609,
-0.0027802903205156326,
0.14741766452789307,
-0.46930810809135437,
0.5932256579399109,
0.04672127962112427,
-0.2748037576675415,
0.29802948236465454,
0.4541807770729065,
0.1599748581647873,
0.3568265438079834,
0.4466843008995056,
0.49157312512397766,
0.4212482273578644,
-0.22819600999355316,
1.0088462829589844,
-0.3225051760673523,
0.11359217017889023,
0.8833870887756348,
-0.6699017286300659,
1.0821136236190796,
0.7467002272605896,
0.1296941488981247,
0.3856446444988251,
0.2921750843524933,
-0.056176718324422836,
0.5920306444168091,
-0.0023215676192194223,
-0.1668965071439743,
-0.2442009598016739,
-0.168968066573143,
-0.5630955696105957,
0.3815547525882721,
0.08417824655771255,
-0.25090181827545166,
0.17866250872612,
0.06353896111249924,
0.2334560751914978,
0.0722787082195282,
-0.19281679391860962,
0.4561929702758789,
0.2130957394838333,
-0.41592928767204285,
0.723082959651947,
0.337446391582489,
0.7267505526542664,
-0.7092271447181702,
0.16012877225875854,
-0.3485206961631775,
0.13946209847927094,
-0.10083594173192978,
-0.7346540093421936,
0.29561981558799744,
-0.06225280463695526,
-0.30795493721961975,
-0.43240609765052795,
0.835163950920105,
-0.6446548700332642,
-0.23985567688941956,
0.6854432821273804,
0.6526291370391846,
-0.01377253606915474,
-0.10131996124982834,
-0.8547179102897644,
0.422278493642807,
-0.1221466138958931,
-0.3425382971763611,
0.582396388053894,
0.40931808948516846,
-0.3791572153568268,
0.9740975499153137,
0.5312492847442627,
0.09735085815191269,
0.2205115109682083,
-0.07198312133550644,
0.6545769572257996,
-0.6732030510902405,
-0.3968011140823364,
-0.9028661251068115,
0.09616748988628387,
0.005782673601061106,
-0.1847609579563141,
1.0821045637130737,
0.5576867461204529,
0.9228590726852417,
0.11273836344480515,
0.9144303202629089,
0.16300000250339508,
0.15160365402698517,
-0.4144563376903534,
0.9701662063598633,
-0.7080768942832947,
0.04614239186048508,
-0.6032289862632751,
-0.9257956147193909,
-0.4129442870616913,
0.35402557253837585,
-0.1430869847536087,
0.002821068512275815,
0.7463989853858948,
0.5598045587539673,
0.02531486004590988,
0.07908813655376434,
0.4656013250350952,
-0.30330753326416016,
0.3729441165924072,
0.32176831364631653,
0.8616978526115417,
-0.6384663581848145,
0.8257945775985718,
-0.2707184851169586,
0.18322238326072693,
-0.04143177345395088,
-1.0327116250991821,
-0.7386058568954468,
-0.4701347053050995,
-0.6703397631645203,
-0.2863730490207672,
0.18733589351177216,
0.3144477605819702,
0.6721193790435791,
-0.756457507610321,
-0.0355314277112484,
0.192891925573349,
0.24096091091632843,
-0.4076535701751709,
-0.16804656386375427,
0.31269606947898865,
0.10086211562156677,
-0.7464529871940613,
0.4279772937297821,
0.4779011905193329,
0.36715519428253174,
-0.2508144676685333,
-0.2692047953605652,
-0.1043933779001236,
0.207474946975708,
0.364380806684494,
0.5737133622169495,
-0.5555974245071411,
-0.27963319420814514,
0.08182688802480698,
-0.39520174264907837,
0.21192698180675507,
0.8169822096824646,
-0.4355708062648773,
0.2258414924144745,
0.4731939435005188,
0.8821021318435669,
0.26654013991355896,
-0.2029460370540619,
0.4987313747406006,
-0.5666786432266235,
-0.10443976521492004,
-0.016934026032686234,
0.6706978678703308,
0.6818996071815491,
-0.1455102562904358,
0.3648602068424225,
0.4216255247592926,
-0.3748014569282532,
-0.7261750102043152,
-0.06461294740438461,
-0.8578310608863831,
-0.384818971157074,
1.1612954139709473,
-0.6648498773574829,
-0.2881721556186676,
-0.4488023817539215,
-0.27716320753097534,
-0.0017391931032761931,
-0.02904580347239971,
0.7720512747764587,
0.8235254883766174,
0.4790862798690796,
-0.10239271819591522,
-0.3852299749851227,
0.21661749482154846,
0.6827154755592346,
-0.7667202949523926,
0.24562452733516693,
0.003516817931085825,
0.43685629963874817,
0.2702223062515259,
0.4386284649372101,
-0.3290986716747284,
0.3470267653465271,
-0.11027619987726212,
0.052702903747558594,
0.1885894387960434,
-0.3252922594547272,
-0.2583748400211334,
0.15666323900222778,
0.016796929761767387,
-0.07774893939495087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14002v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14002v1
|
Hallucinations or Attention Misdirection? The Path to Strategic Value Extraction in Business Using Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T18:40:24 | 2024-02-21T18:40:24 |
Aline Ioste
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models with transformer architecture have revolutionized the
domain of text generation, setting unprecedented benchmarks. Despite their
impressive capabilities, LLMs have been criticized for generating outcomes that
deviate from factual accuracy or display logical inconsistencies, phenomena
commonly referred to as hallucinations. This term, however, has often been
misapplied to any results deviating from the instructor's expectations, which
this paper defines as attention misdirection rather than true hallucinations.
Understanding the distinction between hallucinations and attention misdirection
becomes increasingly relevant in business contexts, where the ramifications of
such errors can significantly impact the value extraction from these inherently
pre-trained models. This paper highlights the best practices of the PGI,
Persona, Grouping, and Intelligence, method, a strategic framework that
achieved a remarkable error rate of only 3,15 percent across 4,000 responses
generated by GPT in response to a real business challenge. It emphasizes that
by equipping experimentation with knowledge, businesses can unlock
opportunities for innovation through the use of these natively pre-trained
models. This reinforces the notion that strategic application grounded in a
skilled team can maximize the benefits of emergent technologies such as the
LLMs.
|
[
-0.279198557138443,
-0.7912858128547668,
0.6966986060142517,
0.32912641763687134,
-0.14052969217300415,
0.1354406774044037,
-0.029304347932338715,
-0.6190097332000732,
0.3507172167301178,
0.5540668964385986,
-0.5897496342658997,
-0.1207871362566948,
-0.7364585399627686,
-0.006948865484446287,
-0.1891455203294754,
1.0316860675811768,
0.15443935990333557,
-0.021554935723543167,
0.14839594066143036,
0.02938719093799591,
-0.6294015049934387,
-0.8953489661216736,
-0.7507003545761108,
-0.2783436179161072,
0.4442686140537262,
0.1647099405527115,
0.8084111213684082,
0.33460983633995056,
0.7328295111656189,
0.30279970169067383,
0.1877852827310562,
0.1681809425354004,
-0.6257630586624146,
-0.0033436401281505823,
-0.3047756552696228,
-0.3055419921875,
-0.35884809494018555,
0.2848452627658844,
0.23398500680923462,
0.7722746729850769,
-0.29622673988342285,
0.07037945836782455,
-0.028327200561761856,
0.7405695915222168,
-0.6772130131721497,
0.16296416521072388,
-0.7425451278686523,
0.3060993552207947,
0.027027186006307602,
-0.23356834053993225,
-0.43458104133605957,
-0.4209480881690979,
0.35887521505355835,
-0.2807997465133667,
-0.0008063918794505298,
0.10313654690980911,
1.0860068798065186,
0.2870955467224121,
0.04230334982275963,
-0.54598069190979,
-1.1760975122451782,
0.6629535555839539,
-0.3371506631374359,
0.3071373999118805,
0.00306950556114316,
0.45731621980667114,
0.007799962535500526,
-0.9124228954315186,
-0.32149043679237366,
-0.006918824277818203,
0.06803571432828903,
0.17143301665782928,
-0.3383569121360779,
-0.02463875152170658,
0.44509708881378174,
0.23537252843379974,
-0.25332438945770264,
0.11669400334358215,
-0.46403881907463074,
0.05772998556494713,
0.6310166120529175,
0.06225840374827385,
0.012589606456458569,
0.057375773787498474,
-0.3641476631164551,
-0.15569384396076202,
-0.6034228205680847,
-0.017869610339403152,
0.23457099497318268,
0.1964026242494583,
0.45905908942222595,
0.6049131155014038,
0.06156226992607117,
0.21812975406646729,
0.4791660010814667,
-0.1960109919309616,
0.25174716114997864,
-0.34949952363967896,
-0.6409907341003418,
0.30183082818984985,
0.46771004796028137,
0.13976331055164337,
0.5276033282279968,
-0.6132924556732178,
-0.3246575891971588,
0.1725264936685562,
0.714244544506073,
-0.6231356859207153,
-0.39300376176834106,
0.24126984179019928,
-0.6059727072715759,
-0.36729612946510315,
0.0696924552321434,
-1.1712749004364014,
-0.4586501717567444,
-0.38899239897727966,
0.5583655834197998,
-0.27078714966773987,
-0.28095147013664246,
0.10923735052347183,
-0.10574141144752502,
0.48401644825935364,
0.16943752765655518,
-1.0543233156204224,
0.10614632815122604,
0.6057223081588745,
0.7433518767356873,
-0.3145543038845062,
-0.2068677395582199,
-0.39816156029701233,
0.3039986491203308,
-0.5615946054458618,
0.7503839731216431,
-0.2972838878631592,
-0.6252367496490479,
-0.07474993169307709,
-0.2411005198955536,
-0.17334690690040588,
-0.917107343673706,
0.37850311398506165,
-0.4702763855457306,
0.11055316030979156,
-0.24147675931453705,
-0.305978924036026,
-0.11350323259830475,
0.1371592879295349,
-0.42761531472206116,
0.6125789284706116,
0.029671596363186836,
-0.43447136878967285,
0.6461976170539856,
-0.6734386682510376,
-0.4316498637199402,
0.36604124307632446,
-0.4869700074195862,
-0.4609838128089905,
0.2326211780309677,
0.01552015170454979,
0.47397947311401367,
-0.2491794377565384,
0.3039948046207428,
0.06595735996961594,
-0.13825485110282898,
0.4913316071033478,
-0.40833529829978943,
0.5110178589820862,
0.09538926184177399,
-0.8410052061080933,
0.27369317412376404,
-0.7743403315544128,
0.17466527223587036,
0.35964998602867126,
-0.12001939117908478,
-0.27109840512275696,
-0.0035263090394437313,
-0.16628600656986237,
0.3316745460033417,
0.0894523486495018,
0.07328043133020401,
-0.130813330411911,
-0.43309324979782104,
0.1850828379392624,
0.9117426872253418,
0.25103166699409485,
0.38099244236946106,
-0.27961504459381104,
0.45665106177330017,
0.05291585251688957,
0.2462160438299179,
0.16366253793239594,
-0.30795973539352417,
-0.7482629418373108,
-0.34190982580184937,
-0.13460397720336914,
0.5411074161529541,
-0.5662269592285156,
0.4014253318309784,
-0.45400285720825195,
-0.6531305909156799,
-0.6046691536903381,
-0.059578243643045425,
0.011043718084692955,
0.5493559241294861,
0.29112836718559265,
-0.19561128318309784,
-0.42325130105018616,
-1.0162978172302246,
-0.5182353258132935,
0.0375986285507679,
-0.0858936607837677,
0.21029232442378998,
0.3853342533111572,
-0.613831102848053,
0.7924841642379761,
-0.5459446310997009,
-0.4639526903629303,
-0.5445167422294617,
0.29207566380500793,
0.17487940192222595,
0.19277971982955933,
0.1292523443698883,
-0.902847409248352,
-0.1965838223695755,
-0.09368199855089188,
-0.6892950534820557,
0.08208157122135162,
-0.459566205739975,
-0.20360307395458221,
0.4392845928668976,
0.31999990344047546,
-0.6960884928703308,
0.47107765078544617,
0.15901383757591248,
-0.013399789109826088,
0.7843412756919861,
-0.07306475192308426,
0.21839547157287598,
-0.892679750919342,
0.24997107684612274,
-0.047464191913604736,
0.22392307221889496,
-0.7527313828468323,
-0.22615991532802582,
-0.2257387787103653,
0.05839579924941063,
-0.2116265743970871,
0.09374012053012848,
-0.45445647835731506,
-0.32867932319641113,
-0.2656993865966797,
0.3995397984981537,
-0.07723361253738403,
0.4502393901348114,
0.10807234793901443,
0.7340813279151917,
0.22176355123519897,
-0.8209290504455566,
0.5800101161003113,
0.21417246758937836,
-0.559636652469635,
0.5527888536453247,
-0.5427716970443726,
0.25104624032974243,
-0.1558990627527237,
-0.2576277256011963,
-0.8539737462997437,
-0.22512313723564148,
0.33168286085128784,
-0.28680917620658875,
0.31282320618629456,
0.45438191294670105,
-0.48469308018684387,
-0.3000420331954956,
-0.12902367115020752,
-0.013176018372178078,
0.6151734590530396,
-0.4846709668636322,
0.6376990079879761,
0.5719401240348816,
-0.1350441724061966,
-0.4490411877632141,
-0.907779335975647,
0.16096726059913635,
-0.42045071721076965,
-0.4536958336830139,
0.1638130247592926,
0.07834142446517944,
-0.5081081986427307,
-0.07988951355218887,
-0.23718923330307007,
-0.022660143673419952,
0.09034508466720581,
0.23039039969444275,
0.3272283375263214,
-0.08723688870668411,
0.037808530032634735,
-0.47223806381225586,
-0.16379086673259735,
0.44919076561927795,
-0.2712242901325226,
0.4905011057853699,
-0.06541038304567337,
-0.4209035038948059,
-0.2585085332393646,
0.16487066447734833,
0.6450390815734863,
-0.17370933294296265,
0.712769091129303,
0.3502325415611267,
-0.4867625832557678,
-0.20208477973937988,
-0.8368624448776245,
-0.29823872447013855,
-0.4659172296524048,
0.5928112864494324,
-0.32238084077835083,
-0.39843234419822693,
0.42951279878616333,
-0.3104722797870636,
-0.044902145862579346,
0.44353535771369934,
0.4988122284412384,
0.12894833087921143,
0.9595030546188354,
0.858737587928772,
-0.030628060922026634,
0.3041083514690399,
-0.21127213537693024,
0.93408203125,
-0.6176733374595642,
-0.7534865736961365,
-0.44588738679885864,
-0.32054829597473145,
-0.49543264508247375,
-0.07162826508283615,
0.34074750542640686,
-0.07441390305757523,
0.006127994507551193,
-0.04912382364273071,
-0.6181071400642395,
0.3450063169002533,
0.5571203231811523,
-0.1409938782453537,
0.15757980942726135,
0.12385222315788269,
0.1309564858675003,
-0.5211760997772217,
-0.7116162180900574,
-0.6160861253738403,
0.8964958190917969,
0.3849785327911377,
0.8557436466217041,
0.16234363615512848,
0.4466341733932495,
0.02908306196331978,
0.31450361013412476,
-1.0811598300933838,
0.49552246928215027,
0.4075499176979065,
-0.45073145627975464,
-0.4859471023082733,
-0.40138235688209534,
-0.8296120762825012,
0.3646906614303589,
-0.15034672617912292,
-0.8942726254463196,
0.28590983152389526,
-0.09778883308172226,
-0.5304290652275085,
0.2836647927761078,
-0.7377119660377502,
1.0598324537277222,
-0.5634594559669495,
-0.49981242418289185,
-0.19707198441028595,
-0.5083251595497131,
0.4306143820285797,
-0.3442547917366028,
0.12532611191272736,
0.27328911423683167,
0.05201191082596779,
0.6420444846153259,
0.07345432043075562,
0.6018169522285461,
0.05801023915410042,
-0.15110214054584503,
0.181770920753479,
0.06583209335803986,
0.6366995573043823,
-0.29504257440567017,
0.3287190794944763,
0.11904029548168182,
-0.44052350521087646,
-0.10586819052696228,
-0.6135610938072205,
0.3577061593532562,
-0.6072809100151062,
-0.802808403968811,
-0.47086259722709656,
-0.415792852640152,
-0.4083016514778137,
0.1350645124912262,
0.5747907161712646,
0.046670958399772644,
-0.47007662057876587,
0.05873924121260643,
0.96452796459198,
-0.0637480840086937,
0.5150476694107056,
0.1396683007478714,
-0.15097282826900482,
-0.41719210147857666,
0.8762016296386719,
0.3091157078742981,
0.3872135579586029,
0.11732913553714752,
-0.10015879571437836,
-0.38430944085121155,
-0.5123209357261658,
0.06327717751264572,
0.25917142629623413,
-0.8940549492835999,
0.15566861629486084,
-0.7454264163970947,
-0.46979475021362305,
-0.5687146782875061,
-0.23539459705352783,
-0.32499200105667114,
0.12807103991508484,
-0.3586568534374237,
-0.1996777206659317,
-0.3096643388271332,
0.8140100240707397,
0.15780633687973022,
0.08564504235982895,
-0.7736935019493103,
0.1377910077571869,
0.38190436363220215,
0.010565344244241714,
0.12691105902194977,
-0.2870909571647644,
-0.4454595744609833,
-0.03585818037390709,
-0.4982699453830719,
-1.002066969871521,
0.6960484981536865,
-0.3107423186302185,
0.8643409609794617,
0.5559906959533691,
-0.2704400420188904,
0.7739015817642212,
-0.4786325991153717,
0.7333370447158813,
0.2780984044075012,
-0.9035547375679016,
0.5525238513946533,
0.03820404037833214,
0.1948009878396988,
0.4275570213794708,
0.7036613821983337,
-0.5287896394729614,
-0.08016514778137207,
-0.8907821774482727,
-0.9976817965507507,
0.6225976347923279,
-0.06814102083444595,
-0.07424818724393845,
-0.026180153712630272,
0.26524490118026733,
0.06241887807846069,
0.7273693680763245,
-0.9548173546791077,
-0.05015825852751732,
-0.03446671739220619,
-0.07112900167703629,
-0.15387971699237823,
-0.4728567898273468,
-0.10471142828464508,
-0.022235438227653503,
0.6724936962127686,
0.03012692742049694,
0.2985880672931671,
0.2578161060810089,
-0.1830240786075592,
-0.18636830151081085,
0.12153594940900803,
0.634199857711792,
1.1424921751022339,
0.06773971021175385,
0.059921879321336746,
0.04537834972143173,
-0.4656579792499542,
-0.06631353497505188,
-0.22750486433506012,
0.07869600504636765,
-0.051764171570539474,
0.0743323415517807,
0.8400830626487732,
0.142816960811615,
-0.6509644985198975,
0.4333156943321228,
0.30396631360054016,
-0.2451207935810089,
-0.25177377462387085,
-0.12434208393096924,
-0.1306304931640625,
0.4546436667442322,
0.4107396602630615,
0.1587945818901062,
0.2620556652545929,
-0.6342967748641968,
0.0656626746058464,
0.5756117105484009,
-0.27151820063591003,
-0.12829095125198364,
0.6193054914474487,
0.16208533942699432,
-0.3859119713306427,
0.6302509903907776,
0.012783768586814404,
-0.5396514534950256,
0.5419789552688599,
0.5408896803855896,
1.304438591003418,
-0.3549673855304718,
0.19574211537837982,
-0.0869404599070549,
0.7304519414901733,
-0.1843705177307129,
-0.11977814137935638,
0.13855522871017456,
-0.6999697089195251,
-0.2020043283700943,
-0.28734090924263,
-0.3481697738170624,
0.6448695063591003,
-0.35101747512817383,
0.22744964063167572,
-0.5991619229316711,
-0.15723416209220886,
-0.03655747324228287,
-0.14814947545528412,
-0.49775204062461853,
0.17959003150463104,
0.10304033011198044,
0.541310727596283,
-0.5241075754165649,
0.4255983531475067,
0.38814958930015564,
-0.5101466774940491,
-0.7494791150093079,
0.3653843104839325,
-0.16558267176151276,
-0.579251766204834,
0.9376906752586365,
0.3169019818305969,
-0.31781166791915894,
0.09060917794704437,
-0.2458755224943161,
-0.8261311054229736,
0.968560516834259,
-0.0022187461145222187,
-0.5487972497940063,
-0.2072588950395584,
0.3440309762954712,
0.3718748390674591,
-0.5563230514526367,
-0.0989769846200943,
0.7005537152290344,
0.42654016613960266,
0.18149904906749725,
-0.4292224943637848,
-0.011583365499973297,
0.22642390429973602,
0.19573229551315308,
0.09390775859355927,
-0.5965660214424133,
0.6157259345054626,
-0.39397957921028137,
-0.43983983993530273,
-0.41621917486190796,
0.5401085019111633,
0.157082661986351,
0.32317638397216797,
0.14849521219730377,
0.3728667199611664,
0.9203811883926392,
-0.14193888008594513,
0.8363298177719116,
-0.14458252489566803,
0.017224539071321487,
0.8793867230415344,
-0.48165419697761536,
0.6915712952613831,
0.6240717768669128,
0.0286273043602705,
0.16593201458454132,
0.6053255796432495,
-0.37509220838546753,
0.7567923069000244,
0.2332572191953659,
0.038686949759721756,
-0.006253463216125965,
0.16661755740642548,
-0.29245060682296753,
0.2530096471309662,
0.4519403576850891,
-0.3967030644416809,
0.16584941744804382,
-0.014272688888013363,
-0.1120220199227333,
0.043906938284635544,
-0.29316025972366333,
0.8587551712989807,
0.009930923581123352,
-0.782549262046814,
0.4153095781803131,
-0.09311338514089584,
0.47935736179351807,
-0.48446348309516907,
0.04809923470020294,
-0.12530989944934845,
0.44708889722824097,
-0.05688968300819397,
-0.34186306595802307,
0.5138898491859436,
-0.1674686074256897,
-0.17091208696365356,
-0.35450610518455505,
0.6169531941413879,
-0.28542691469192505,
-0.25867003202438354,
0.309944748878479,
0.5361220836639404,
0.10259336233139038,
-0.30190280079841614,
-0.576135516166687,
0.1168140321969986,
0.0040314956568181515,
-0.19989831745624542,
0.1207844689488411,
0.6161684393882751,
0.33876997232437134,
0.5334274768829346,
0.3126841187477112,
0.17355956137180328,
0.12448989599943161,
-0.027552369982004166,
0.614007830619812,
-0.6565420627593994,
-0.42885497212409973,
-1.0553277730941772,
0.43094688653945923,
-0.3171047270298004,
-0.31941404938697815,
0.7983905673027039,
0.5449956059455872,
0.8719016313552856,
-0.29248812794685364,
0.7435864210128784,
0.39756420254707336,
0.12259349972009659,
-0.5009101629257202,
0.7835288047790527,
-0.24278762936592102,
0.22582127153873444,
-0.3836444020271301,
-1.1318038702011108,
-0.05053161457180977,
0.7653770446777344,
-0.6044396758079529,
0.3258083760738373,
1.012309193611145,
0.5402063131332397,
0.23301556706428528,
0.07039254158735275,
0.6006543636322021,
0.3811458647251129,
0.363450288772583,
0.6800495386123657,
0.8001165986061096,
-0.30673545598983765,
0.5326981544494629,
0.06685048341751099,
-0.44437262415885925,
-0.4091481864452362,
-0.6182413101196289,
-0.8466392755508423,
-0.42215433716773987,
-0.36909347772598267,
-0.3972319960594177,
0.10533330589532852,
0.7978255748748779,
0.4302109181880951,
-0.5643205642700195,
-0.3134584426879883,
-0.2522435784339905,
0.016591599211096764,
-0.2235821783542633,
-0.2899503707885742,
0.10443450510501862,
-0.6620929837226868,
-0.7202463746070862,
0.0916472002863884,
0.6067756414413452,
0.47873690724372864,
-0.39589157700538635,
0.19931498169898987,
-0.13354195654392242,
0.41877177357673645,
0.557709276676178,
0.054333340376615524,
-0.6021503806114197,
-0.049158837646245956,
0.0715908482670784,
-0.3308674097061157,
0.08064920455217361,
0.6948688626289368,
-0.6228806376457214,
0.056809455156326294,
-0.007983338087797165,
1.0090646743774414,
0.2581599950790405,
-0.14425086975097656,
0.34048280119895935,
-0.21326039731502533,
0.10841521620750427,
0.4421218931674957,
0.02490205131471157,
0.31450721621513367,
-0.6527843475341797,
0.551672637462616,
0.5888141393661499,
-0.5896514058113098,
-0.7245677709579468,
0.45879876613616943,
-0.5142988562583923,
-0.41379156708717346,
0.9923133850097656,
0.1293361634016037,
-0.34320327639579773,
0.13925135135650635,
-0.28756800293922424,
0.10100367665290833,
0.015540975145995617,
1.3415184020996094,
1.0000053644180298,
-0.16113954782485962,
-0.0010660227853804827,
-0.652854323387146,
0.8002980351448059,
0.47943753004074097,
-1.052436351776123,
0.1582377552986145,
0.5810725092887878,
-0.1710565686225891,
0.5117291212081909,
0.465321809053421,
-0.1674061417579651,
0.049802254885435104,
0.19968527555465698,
0.0608169287443161,
0.27953019738197327,
-0.7225100994110107,
-0.3682132959365845,
0.36977341771125793,
0.0228695347905159,
-0.3172788619995117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14875v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14875v2
|
What's in a Name? Auditing Large Language Models for Race and Gender Bias
| 2024-02-21T18:25:25 | 2024-02-29T19:39:35 |
Amit Haim, Alejandro Salinas, Julian Nyarko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
We employ an audit design to investigate biases in state-of-the-art large
language models, including GPT-4. In our study, we prompt the models for advice
involving a named individual across a variety of scenarios, such as during car
purchase negotiations or election outcome predictions. We find that the advice
systematically disadvantages names that are commonly associated with racial
minorities and women. Names associated with Black women receive the least
advantageous outcomes. The biases are consistent across 42 prompt templates and
several models, indicating a systemic issue rather than isolated incidents.
While providing numerical, decision-relevant anchors in the prompt can
successfully counteract the biases, qualitative details have inconsistent
effects and may even increase disparities. Our findings underscore the
importance of conducting audits at the point of LLM deployment and
implementation to mitigate their potential for harm against marginalized
communities.
|
[
-0.16597101092338562,
-0.3562978208065033,
0.6649136543273926,
0.16441220045089722,
-0.20750902593135834,
0.24911439418792725,
-0.056750956922769547,
-0.428465873003006,
0.06090308725833893,
0.31076276302337646,
-0.4979497790336609,
-0.17334884405136108,
-0.7568627595901489,
0.004383220802992582,
-0.4457506537437439,
1.300876498222351,
0.00714269420132041,
0.5802648067474365,
0.12154162675142288,
0.05737146735191345,
-1.0032410621643066,
-0.5242154002189636,
-0.8420471549034119,
-0.010743926279246807,
0.6875595450401306,
0.14393532276153564,
0.5006371140480042,
0.6376910209655762,
0.41551920771598816,
0.22704236209392548,
-0.5033674836158752,
-0.105656199157238,
-0.392774760723114,
-0.07128908485174179,
-0.27188706398010254,
-0.33472684025764465,
-0.30623477697372437,
0.15855804085731506,
0.5914590358734131,
0.60413658618927,
-0.22921103239059448,
0.3956020772457123,
-0.06551416218280792,
0.5147697925567627,
-1.0067070722579956,
0.23054015636444092,
-0.5671465992927551,
-0.013283883221447468,
-0.2687106430530548,
0.2804761826992035,
-0.09400743246078491,
-0.6823215484619141,
0.5380010604858398,
-0.28699639439582825,
0.05166907235980034,
0.29621344804763794,
0.6926656365394592,
0.18409842252731323,
-0.39884433150291443,
-0.45062726736068726,
-0.7787122130393982,
0.8074382543563843,
-0.8011931777000427,
0.3610440194606781,
0.22155506908893585,
0.5555506944656372,
-0.04249241203069687,
-0.3666056990623474,
-0.5829822421073914,
0.05122831463813782,
-0.07969610393047333,
-0.028198111802339554,
-0.39235344529151917,
-0.006830665748566389,
0.4005843997001648,
0.14482006430625916,
-0.07420502603054047,
0.2085038125514984,
-0.6023920774459839,
-0.27471277117729187,
0.6204054951667786,
0.18060876429080963,
0.3053312599658966,
0.03442423790693283,
-0.39818984270095825,
0.15822158753871918,
-1.0410370826721191,
-0.06901005655527115,
0.8396141529083252,
0.45569509267807007,
-0.1198788657784462,
0.4435338079929352,
0.020824147388339043,
0.41315096616744995,
0.0381256602704525,
-0.29896512627601624,
0.0644942969083786,
-0.23215943574905396,
-0.35763442516326904,
0.4664761424064636,
0.432405948638916,
0.5110389590263367,
0.39444053173065186,
-0.18094854056835175,
-0.158128023147583,
-0.023822151124477386,
0.1405252069234848,
-0.5833679437637329,
-0.013817621394991875,
-0.027889713644981384,
-0.4599662125110626,
-0.1939830332994461,
0.013172191567718983,
-0.878928542137146,
-1.0202641487121582,
-0.3991745412349701,
0.2713983952999115,
0.03622814267873764,
-0.28855425119400024,
-0.004635678604245186,
-0.5355333089828491,
0.3236331343650818,
0.6408123970031738,
-0.9786906242370605,
0.04035898298025131,
0.6729224324226379,
0.2916684150695801,
-0.1276964396238327,
-0.020710641518235207,
-0.5997989773750305,
0.1923767626285553,
-0.23652134835720062,
0.6335443258285522,
-0.6137815117835999,
-0.4999265670776367,
0.13006402552127838,
-0.002671527676284313,
0.37834984064102173,
-0.5645621418952942,
0.24879604578018188,
-0.2804904878139496,
0.35106515884399414,
-0.8446092009544373,
-0.46754878759384155,
-0.19275526702404022,
-0.06332308053970337,
-0.35418859124183655,
0.6771887540817261,
0.05898581072688103,
-0.8515551686286926,
0.7740793228149414,
-0.5601507425308228,
-0.046000417321920395,
0.1515245884656906,
-0.5327208042144775,
-0.41505196690559387,
0.16461998224258423,
0.14103539288043976,
0.1315956860780716,
-0.47713416814804077,
0.40602466464042664,
-0.2683800756931305,
-0.15176892280578613,
0.09977172315120697,
-0.1480437070131302,
0.7602577805519104,
0.07225393503904343,
-0.5529929399490356,
0.06880190223455429,
-0.34306490421295166,
-0.5573901534080505,
0.017186319455504417,
-0.14820514619350433,
-0.49368801712989807,
-0.04940636456012726,
-0.10613635182380676,
-0.1410214602947235,
-0.01515823882073164,
-0.6601744294166565,
0.3208492398262024,
0.1492803990840912,
0.3862428665161133,
1.0024603605270386,
0.062432192265987396,
0.4331321716308594,
-0.38786542415618896,
0.8849947452545166,
0.10310344398021698,
0.10412634909152985,
-0.18972930312156677,
-0.8587214350700378,
-0.5406297445297241,
-0.2572205364704132,
0.6167847514152527,
0.4248945415019989,
-0.28527605533599854,
-0.07416044920682907,
0.05066177621483803,
-0.40978768467903137,
-0.3792533874511719,
-0.13206025958061218,
0.3985402286052704,
0.4277534782886505,
-0.06312037259340286,
-0.1545080542564392,
-0.5973208546638489,
-1.2298007011413574,
-0.6769323348999023,
-0.4022398293018341,
0.10527174174785614,
0.3930855691432953,
0.6513805389404297,
-0.3555630147457123,
0.9695616960525513,
-0.411469966173172,
-0.12363848835229874,
-0.16677865386009216,
0.1305093914270401,
0.1851157546043396,
0.240361288189888,
0.586622953414917,
-0.503439724445343,
-0.10129145532846451,
-0.3486088812351227,
-0.3712455630302429,
-0.24926213920116425,
-0.047228533774614334,
-0.21169523894786835,
-0.23040348291397095,
0.3552126884460449,
-0.4519787132740021,
0.45001304149627686,
0.4264647364616394,
-0.4721341133117676,
0.839835524559021,
0.07157913595438004,
-0.2260759174823761,
-0.8906707763671875,
-0.226363405585289,
0.026483668014407158,
-0.0864255502820015,
-0.4307541847229004,
-0.22698743641376495,
0.1378815919160843,
-0.13249607384204865,
-0.5286661386489868,
0.7942907214164734,
-0.6306716799736023,
-0.16516350209712982,
0.21542398631572723,
0.010924511589109898,
-0.24858598411083221,
-0.06186540052294731,
-0.11928488314151764,
0.9341288805007935,
0.35029545426368713,
-0.6217021942138672,
0.267526775598526,
0.4722854495048523,
-0.35843905806541443,
0.7540095448493958,
-0.30359700322151184,
0.09249913692474365,
-0.33200153708457947,
0.12799501419067383,
-0.9065735936164856,
-0.0821203663945198,
-0.022487785667181015,
-0.21832819283008575,
0.3670434355735779,
-0.1719866842031479,
-0.22193945944309235,
-0.4116155803203583,
-0.29911524057388306,
0.5248848795890808,
0.3673875331878662,
-0.5860791206359863,
0.41694217920303345,
0.78777015209198,
-0.3384510278701782,
-0.7012237310409546,
-0.6884813904762268,
0.15396106243133545,
-0.6712592244148254,
-0.20026561617851257,
-0.019822651520371437,
-0.11639166623353958,
-0.6208503246307373,
-0.3465507924556732,
-0.0846283808350563,
-0.25950369238853455,
0.27450820803642273,
0.17321914434432983,
0.26129910349845886,
-0.1605159491300583,
0.30936992168426514,
-0.1942370980978012,
0.21096624433994293,
0.2240150272846222,
0.20167480409145355,
0.2495848387479782,
0.20393548905849457,
-0.062022287398576736,
-0.3666990399360657,
0.352932333946228,
0.5736481547355652,
-0.15117456018924713,
0.4982072412967682,
-0.05656886845827103,
-0.46694034337997437,
-0.17187215387821198,
-0.6980020403862,
-0.21024107933044434,
-0.47009333968162537,
0.20228983461856842,
-0.11041663587093353,
-0.9321249723434448,
0.691901683807373,
-0.08853472024202347,
0.016364848241209984,
0.16966351866722107,
0.7093775868415833,
-0.14298667013645172,
0.845830500125885,
0.6398221254348755,
-0.38046926259994507,
0.6294405460357666,
-0.037769775837659836,
0.7403821349143982,
-0.8270727396011353,
-0.04660486429929733,
-0.4598701298236847,
-0.31021586060523987,
-0.6354217529296875,
-0.29891201853752136,
0.20835286378860474,
-0.12008301168680191,
-0.44286713004112244,
0.09559769183397293,
-0.402340829372406,
0.5373896360397339,
0.432405948638916,
-0.2639288008213043,
0.351794958114624,
-0.4104173481464386,
-0.05898962542414665,
-0.2076532542705536,
-0.39150601625442505,
-0.65130215883255,
1.128098726272583,
0.5150980353355408,
0.7563380002975464,
0.19281335175037384,
0.5807308554649353,
0.5114576816558838,
0.7979186177253723,
-0.6567255854606628,
0.19976063072681427,
0.26616525650024414,
-1.01313316822052,
-0.2332412451505661,
-0.27049198746681213,
-0.9390661120414734,
0.15669962763786316,
0.07679738849401474,
-0.9126694798469543,
0.4729689359664917,
0.139104425907135,
-0.5141741037368774,
0.47415807843208313,
-0.6363145709037781,
0.7182782888412476,
-0.30789458751678467,
0.043779272586107254,
0.20413491129875183,
-0.09352397918701172,
0.8927327990531921,
-0.45921561121940613,
0.4635714888572693,
-0.32310739159584045,
-0.03222379460930824,
0.8027823567390442,
-0.43659475445747375,
0.7425829768180847,
-0.3014104962348938,
-0.23988676071166992,
-0.10328477621078491,
-0.03331463411450386,
0.6566683650016785,
0.014240955002605915,
0.03255922347307205,
0.37590157985687256,
-0.21001258492469788,
-0.07523705065250397,
-0.3894771635532379,
0.40840837359428406,
-0.5340237617492676,
-0.5930640697479248,
-0.4248698353767395,
-0.4025929272174835,
-0.23488013446331024,
0.057307396084070206,
0.23020711541175842,
0.3945305645465851,
-0.2794746160507202,
-0.2325594127178192,
0.2856757640838623,
-0.6159279942512512,
0.3615454435348511,
0.6211358904838562,
-0.15131157636642456,
-0.08626649528741837,
0.5027904510498047,
0.0717737004160881,
0.06097668036818504,
-0.04023321717977524,
0.3795747458934784,
-0.3431068956851959,
-0.6450909376144409,
-0.5023208856582642,
0.5947980880737305,
-0.5908694267272949,
-0.3042248785495758,
-0.5223111510276794,
0.08712399005889893,
-0.2353389412164688,
0.06258095055818558,
-0.30622598528862,
-0.3478706181049347,
-0.02800689823925495,
-0.3221028447151184,
0.1847734898328781,
1.2194305658340454,
0.29366543889045715,
0.7169024348258972,
-0.47533270716667175,
-0.03705237805843353,
0.5415537357330322,
0.2712930738925934,
0.00852243136614561,
-0.2577553391456604,
-0.11714191734790802,
-0.1493767946958542,
-0.4357665479183197,
-1.07938814163208,
0.3522043824195862,
-0.22603970766067505,
0.6306785941123962,
0.6297890543937683,
0.15982061624526978,
0.5613933801651001,
-0.6432402729988098,
0.9976432919502258,
0.3433125913143158,
-1.0312579870224,
0.40466049313545227,
-0.5156379342079163,
0.1329023241996765,
0.4738744795322418,
0.2073923498392105,
-0.6963813304901123,
-0.7393691539764404,
-0.442819744348526,
-0.6555339694023132,
0.5243255496025085,
0.11027776449918747,
0.13126708567142487,
-0.19206354022026062,
0.20118583738803864,
0.09961193799972534,
0.754794716835022,
-0.5917367339134216,
-0.5066501498222351,
0.30981045961380005,
0.0686936154961586,
0.19715501368045807,
-0.5546256899833679,
-0.18221619725227356,
-0.22369937598705292,
0.5819567441940308,
0.051580607891082764,
0.4412164092063904,
0.016127264127135277,
0.018714096397161484,
0.01722841151058674,
0.3976742923259735,
0.7959524393081665,
0.9132885336875916,
-0.005191538017243147,
-0.19901585578918457,
0.42698338627815247,
-0.31470921635627747,
0.25868695974349976,
-0.18502114713191986,
-0.14835043251514435,
0.18001298606395721,
0.4848872423171997,
0.737726628780365,
0.387681245803833,
-0.42737504839897156,
0.6263843178749084,
-0.351744145154953,
-0.15648487210273743,
-0.49801763892173767,
-0.24156150221824646,
0.11735843867063522,
0.23081469535827637,
0.3724914789199829,
-0.4211176931858063,
0.2418321967124939,
-0.7089656591415405,
-0.3077496588230133,
0.5836194157600403,
-0.3078245222568512,
-0.246767058968544,
0.8700831532478333,
0.32795587182044983,
-0.3949618339538574,
0.5086658596992493,
-0.18159425258636475,
-0.8715535998344421,
0.6663515567779541,
0.12916040420532227,
0.9591354727745056,
-0.5192445516586304,
-0.02087314985692501,
0.26686525344848633,
0.2899896204471588,
-0.10067182779312134,
0.26859188079833984,
0.10691836476325989,
-0.9255032539367676,
-0.17210133373737335,
-0.6986550092697144,
-0.6508725881576538,
0.27219629287719727,
-0.5498989224433899,
0.3873777985572815,
-0.721872866153717,
-0.4687829315662384,
0.3338547646999359,
-0.22464299201965332,
-0.8036377429962158,
0.024447407573461533,
0.4537253975868225,
1.065624475479126,
-0.9330988526344299,
0.45957133173942566,
0.5365910530090332,
-0.30759769678115845,
-0.9888366460800171,
-0.008157963864505291,
0.45644453167915344,
-0.7279289364814758,
1.1347156763076782,
0.15664802491664886,
0.18069583177566528,
-0.35017430782318115,
-0.2632928788661957,
-1.0238679647445679,
0.8981328010559082,
0.516080379486084,
-0.8562678098678589,
-0.29787710309028625,
-0.06846845895051956,
0.23562273383140564,
-0.535655677318573,
0.5706754326820374,
0.7737616896629333,
1.021949052810669,
-0.30750149488449097,
-1.3696837425231934,
-0.1481161117553711,
0.17252564430236816,
0.08496152609586716,
0.29271399974823,
-0.6064048409461975,
1.0388749837875366,
-0.3544699549674988,
-0.3166472911834717,
0.016379401087760925,
0.22902484238147736,
0.17861416935920715,
0.2894952893257141,
0.5530677437782288,
0.37830212712287903,
1.1618491411209106,
-0.2777485251426697,
1.3740156888961792,
0.05129687115550041,
0.2537338435649872,
1.1665266752243042,
-0.35464543104171753,
0.15030866861343384,
0.458589106798172,
-0.3234030604362488,
0.48099374771118164,
0.621677577495575,
-0.0489204116165638,
0.5050302743911743,
0.617885410785675,
-0.1801692247390747,
0.08941484987735748,
-0.2628834843635559,
-0.3693920969963074,
0.6648364067077637,
0.08410006761550903,
-0.6596745252609253,
-0.29978322982788086,
-0.2195032685995102,
0.2785608172416687,
-0.25837284326553345,
-0.2796153426170349,
0.7755035758018494,
0.11955530941486359,
-0.4595756530761719,
0.0459134615957737,
-0.2217962145805359,
0.6541482210159302,
-0.509550929069519,
-0.025166641920804977,
-0.22212620079517365,
0.2775530219078064,
-0.11024939268827438,
-0.4375678598880768,
0.10818085819482803,
-0.0026885054539889097,
-0.4679974317550659,
-0.21118707954883575,
0.07416205108165741,
-0.4788596034049988,
-0.35718417167663574,
0.5120354294776917,
0.5944152474403381,
0.12825244665145874,
-0.2268369197845459,
-0.5216648578643799,
-0.1237601786851883,
-0.039683837443590164,
-0.04047299921512604,
0.32109761238098145,
0.3453073501586914,
-0.4384143650531769,
0.6755498051643372,
0.5669730305671692,
0.6019633412361145,
0.1419210582971573,
0.08937413990497589,
0.6181434988975525,
-0.8271127343177795,
-0.5801205635070801,
-0.9833295941352844,
0.40891823172569275,
-0.2213880568742752,
-0.3645896911621094,
1.0026217699050903,
0.6012145280838013,
0.7196128368377686,
0.059972237795591354,
0.8428065776824951,
0.5503479838371277,
0.6256781816482544,
-0.19982309639453888,
0.8499966263771057,
-0.418878972530365,
0.39232462644577026,
-0.4588882029056549,
-1.0323498249053955,
-0.08785638213157654,
0.3321295976638794,
-0.36510664224624634,
0.16057297587394714,
0.6373200416564941,
0.5987720489501953,
0.06606732308864594,
0.2251952588558197,
0.24441896378993988,
0.28217291831970215,
0.5405536890029907,
0.17505282163619995,
1.0171899795532227,
-0.12898023426532745,
0.1745785027742386,
0.2350202202796936,
-0.0922628864645958,
-0.3076266944408417,
-1.1435147523880005,
-0.8411591053009033,
-0.21976085007190704,
-0.4330171048641205,
0.04504230618476868,
0.11081143468618393,
0.6050388216972351,
0.8409605622291565,
-0.849704384803772,
-0.3054133951663971,
0.3586691915988922,
0.41057610511779785,
0.11009643971920013,
-0.23517097532749176,
0.07915876060724258,
-0.12848319113254547,
-0.6517537236213684,
0.21927885711193085,
0.1395547240972519,
0.06993002444505692,
-0.33237209916114807,
0.0020432546734809875,
0.0845227837562561,
0.18418122828006744,
0.3433181047439575,
0.0732104554772377,
-0.90825355052948,
-0.44880911707878113,
-0.6482947468757629,
0.018939945846796036,
-0.0865897387266159,
1.0635535717010498,
-0.4854802191257477,
0.6026753783226013,
0.26786813139915466,
0.6185102462768555,
0.3276021480560303,
0.03766481205821037,
1.1521329879760742,
-0.6734074950218201,
-0.023575453087687492,
0.2735386788845062,
0.7833628058433533,
0.5215327143669128,
-0.6278555393218994,
0.4939054548740387,
0.08537217974662781,
-0.5566307902336121,
-1.0036184787750244,
0.14016160368919373,
-0.5281646251678467,
-0.10458830744028091,
1.3229466676712036,
-0.03771354258060455,
-0.07742052525281906,
-0.231566920876503,
-0.368454247713089,
-0.027682650834321976,
-0.7847439646720886,
0.7714528441429138,
0.9893752336502075,
0.18098635971546173,
-0.28249290585517883,
-0.7937617301940918,
0.7455720901489258,
0.13147084414958954,
-0.5663223266601562,
0.2737959325313568,
0.39712318778038025,
0.45104414224624634,
-0.04375265911221504,
0.6060024499893188,
-0.01959606073796749,
0.3791116178035736,
-0.47800174355506897,
0.14388708770275116,
0.05279551073908806,
0.03413436934351921,
-0.8004711270332336,
-0.4362955689430237,
0.08392667025327682,
-0.060755547136068344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13991v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13991v1
|
Analysing The Impact of Sequence Composition on Language Model Pre-Training
| 2024-02-21T18:23:16 | 2024-02-21T18:23:16 |
Yu Zhao, Yuanbin Qu, Konrad Staniszewski, Szymon Tworkowski, Wei Liu, Piotr Miłoś, Yuxiang Wu, Pasquale Minervini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Most language model pre-training frameworks concatenate multiple documents
into fixed-length sequences and use causal masking to compute the likelihood of
each token given its context; this strategy is widely adopted due to its
simplicity and efficiency. However, to this day, the influence of the
pre-training sequence composition strategy on the generalisation properties of
the model remains under-explored. In this work, we find that applying causal
masking can lead to the inclusion of distracting information from previous
documents during pre-training, which negatively impacts the performance of the
models on language modelling and downstream tasks. In intra-document causal
masking, the likelihood of each token is only conditioned on the previous
tokens in the same document, eliminating potential distracting information from
previous documents and significantly improving performance. Furthermore, we
find that concatenating related documents can reduce some potential
distractions during pre-training, and our proposed efficient retrieval-based
sequence construction method, BM25Chunk, can improve in-context learning
(+11.6\%), knowledge memorisation (+9.8\%), and context utilisation (+7.2\%)
abilities of language models without sacrificing efficiency.
|
[
-0.29732826352119446,
-0.5055536031723022,
0.22350655496120453,
0.30442172288894653,
-0.49637869000434875,
-0.053513769060373306,
-0.13343587517738342,
-0.42607012391090393,
-0.027531428262591362,
0.5149040818214417,
-0.39067918062210083,
-0.30375826358795166,
-0.6725418567657471,
0.0050104777328670025,
-0.4767136573791504,
0.6741699576377869,
0.18211066722869873,
0.09276881068944931,
-0.30901604890823364,
0.11079022288322449,
-0.7906882762908936,
-0.7326386570930481,
-0.3422721028327942,
-0.07444056123495102,
0.47393450140953064,
0.20123612880706787,
0.2754238545894623,
0.5186445713043213,
0.48717740178108215,
0.37227603793144226,
0.04186658933758736,
0.18810315430164337,
-0.49462565779685974,
0.18871016800403595,
-0.22576169669628143,
-0.5137948989868164,
-0.18084347248077393,
0.07102654874324799,
1.0472426414489746,
0.7545996308326721,
0.10041297227144241,
0.012271387502551079,
0.2738304138183594,
0.6003512144088745,
-0.9505434036254883,
0.010155112482607365,
-0.5127078294754028,
-0.16606657207012177,
-0.40183642506599426,
-0.3206360340118408,
-0.7065026760101318,
0.09442735463380814,
0.2755931615829468,
-0.48221105337142944,
0.0815742164850235,
0.07315780222415924,
0.7665631771087646,
0.11453171074390411,
-0.2729707360267639,
-0.27937373518943787,
-0.7693996429443359,
0.6056155562400818,
-0.9988941550254822,
0.2839272618293762,
0.43568065762519836,
-0.012777433730661869,
0.005144132766872644,
-0.7717257142066956,
-0.6002988219261169,
0.16900776326656342,
-0.5194212794303894,
-0.03439106419682503,
0.16864809393882751,
0.26585277915000916,
0.44635364413261414,
0.28297480940818787,
-0.689827561378479,
0.15637066960334778,
-0.48904773592948914,
-0.2060868740081787,
0.488097220659256,
0.08195267617702484,
0.38179832696914673,
-0.1285427212715149,
-0.03410753235220909,
-0.1516343057155609,
-0.8380782604217529,
-0.1241726279258728,
0.5708264708518982,
0.34734928607940674,
0.027199462056159973,
0.398928165435791,
-0.25437232851982117,
0.8112045526504517,
0.07620839774608612,
-0.03160090744495392,
0.18385359644889832,
-0.534674346446991,
-0.18422743678092957,
0.06278837472200394,
0.7777738571166992,
-0.10716162621974945,
0.29958897829055786,
-0.17655016481876373,
0.08330797404050827,
-0.15666891634464264,
0.4583830237388611,
-1.1650341749191284,
-0.08867795020341873,
0.0766163244843483,
-0.23743773996829987,
-0.047032278031110764,
0.29683175683021545,
-0.3851540684700012,
0.1289086490869522,
-0.4581155478954315,
0.5622472763061523,
-0.41679224371910095,
0.10232730209827423,
0.3610638976097107,
0.01586819998919964,
0.17095300555229187,
0.17743127048015594,
-1.028872013092041,
0.13424131274223328,
0.7047827839851379,
0.5707989931106567,
-0.02472623996436596,
-0.3615930378437042,
-0.5637831687927246,
0.35609281063079834,
-0.1463485062122345,
0.44324591755867004,
-0.548284649848938,
-0.6140304803848267,
0.16931775212287903,
0.018945328891277313,
-0.4103943705558777,
-0.4387517273426056,
0.2181403934955597,
-0.5475620031356812,
0.5841073989868164,
-0.08348710834980011,
-0.7510595917701721,
-0.36635854840278625,
-0.09612108767032623,
-0.7117917537689209,
0.8294191360473633,
-0.10663890093564987,
-0.8188897371292114,
0.25602081418037415,
-0.26681026816368103,
-0.8728231191635132,
0.10885246098041534,
-0.23982740938663483,
-0.35005754232406616,
0.062435079365968704,
0.03425626456737518,
0.5659175515174866,
-0.15644332766532898,
0.6343381404876709,
-0.1118154227733612,
-0.6347504258155823,
0.1740746945142746,
-0.26406267285346985,
0.5602236986160278,
0.10520587116479874,
-0.5285929441452026,
0.14542752504348755,
-0.8046358227729797,
-0.30022528767585754,
-0.3415394127368927,
-0.33949801325798035,
-0.44197553396224976,
-0.1317162960767746,
-0.3687282204627991,
0.49164602160453796,
-0.030002258718013763,
-0.2297360897064209,
-0.13462616503238678,
-0.3717835247516632,
-0.10456666350364685,
0.5621546506881714,
0.1327451467514038,
0.5601899027824402,
-0.5601798295974731,
0.5340779423713684,
0.23613974452018738,
0.03514432534575462,
-0.7181882858276367,
-0.39180779457092285,
-0.6723005771636963,
-0.41839295625686646,
0.38048985600471497,
0.6460889577865601,
-0.4705779552459717,
0.6013357639312744,
-0.46754929423332214,
-0.43476444482803345,
-0.3481815755367279,
0.26997458934783936,
0.8622973561286926,
0.678219735622406,
0.2858510911464691,
-0.80799400806427,
-0.8181620836257935,
-0.6353461146354675,
-0.14760948717594147,
0.05179741978645325,
0.034258078783750534,
0.05217456817626953,
0.3033888638019562,
-0.2255237102508545,
0.7979912161827087,
-0.5157515406608582,
-0.13948515057563782,
-0.19617848098278046,
0.047697074711322784,
0.15507328510284424,
0.8762005567550659,
0.3558434247970581,
-0.6749820113182068,
-0.45761382579803467,
-0.4955691397190094,
-0.5326004028320312,
-0.11367261409759521,
-0.0901833102107048,
-0.2352907508611679,
0.3281095325946808,
0.7534867525100708,
-0.7650592923164368,
0.4824730455875397,
0.18290437757968903,
-0.10011711716651917,
0.623693585395813,
-0.17942623794078827,
0.002604555105790496,
-1.0585825443267822,
0.47423070669174194,
-0.27574464678764343,
0.04411238804459572,
-0.6876994371414185,
-0.017977427691221237,
0.12619882822036743,
-0.11150103807449341,
-0.75505530834198,
0.5382084250450134,
-0.3803696036338806,
0.28142401576042175,
-0.11498996615409851,
-0.15947690606117249,
0.15089179575443268,
0.49738025665283203,
0.025928163900971413,
0.5326768159866333,
0.30128875374794006,
-0.7164575457572937,
-0.4120694100856781,
0.2702847123146057,
-0.5059697031974792,
0.23209911584854126,
-0.28738540410995483,
0.13936877250671387,
-0.23203884065151215,
0.39999815821647644,
-1.0046753883361816,
-0.07841537892818451,
0.11839468032121658,
-0.32626697421073914,
0.88262540102005,
0.0581868439912796,
-0.5515685677528381,
-0.2518593668937683,
-0.20621085166931152,
0.6659290790557861,
0.37873533368110657,
-0.14462798833847046,
0.5503370761871338,
0.13313628733158112,
-0.0979500561952591,
-0.6289258003234863,
-0.7255609035491943,
-0.2208869904279709,
-0.39949479699134827,
-0.6309535503387451,
0.5686739683151245,
-0.18606975674629211,
0.10341045260429382,
-0.21004605293273926,
-0.12629617750644684,
0.2606404423713684,
0.35018134117126465,
0.28109246492385864,
0.1409093290567398,
-0.22559134662151337,
0.0615350566804409,
-0.14416511356830597,
-0.035799410194158554,
-0.010335102677345276,
-0.3506125211715698,
0.7308236360549927,
0.14889118075370789,
-0.25742971897125244,
-0.3503119647502899,
0.5790103673934937,
0.25823748111724854,
-0.41815030574798584,
1.0548241138458252,
0.5185717344284058,
-0.3149625360965729,
-0.09789041429758072,
-0.6926968097686768,
-0.2981385290622711,
-0.5060399174690247,
0.282882958650589,
-0.2591555118560791,
-1.13307523727417,
0.629075288772583,
0.0015941745368763804,
-0.31795185804367065,
0.27819663286209106,
0.30114471912384033,
-0.11174433678388596,
0.4134509861469269,
0.49307146668434143,
-0.17170602083206177,
0.921173095703125,
-0.3366387188434601,
0.3390772342681885,
-0.7990837693214417,
-0.3802442252635956,
-0.430976539850235,
-0.0910501554608345,
-0.5717887878417969,
-0.37489137053489685,
-0.2273445576429367,
0.32483765482902527,
-0.3397490084171295,
0.4814009368419647,
-0.08733533322811127,
0.38648611307144165,
0.6737849712371826,
0.2780455946922302,
0.07739851623773575,
-0.15474535524845123,
-0.2906188666820526,
0.17875175178050995,
-0.7139721512794495,
-0.26944252848625183,
1.2716259956359863,
-0.07586844265460968,
0.4311356544494629,
0.12607385218143463,
0.9988328814506531,
-0.09738083928823471,
0.2826274335384369,
-0.2907619774341583,
0.5184555053710938,
-0.22382567822933197,
-0.5878944396972656,
-0.36008232831954956,
-0.3057076334953308,
-1.0614954233169556,
0.3159113824367523,
-0.13282518088817596,
-0.8013721704483032,
0.20624352991580963,
0.04890022426843643,
-0.44798704981803894,
-0.08151064068078995,
-0.7367096543312073,
0.9244321584701538,
-0.06639375537633896,
-0.6146538257598877,
-0.16134855151176453,
-1.0619462728500366,
0.46146896481513977,
-0.4974394738674164,
0.3061313331127167,
0.22164607048034668,
0.4161316156387329,
0.7529899477958679,
-0.5288539528846741,
0.918403685092926,
0.0857246071100235,
0.0848855972290039,
0.314387708902359,
-0.2075803279876709,
0.415417343378067,
-0.392608106136322,
-0.012169070541858673,
-0.08889122307300568,
-0.1488879919052124,
-0.42371857166290283,
-0.5628548264503479,
0.2945305407047272,
-0.4244324862957001,
-0.9601774215698242,
-0.16555705666542053,
-0.4863990545272827,
-0.17337273061275482,
0.43994805216789246,
0.258145272731781,
0.7515095472335815,
-0.0464848130941391,
0.3999297320842743,
0.7585927844047546,
-0.2595806419849396,
0.7876652479171753,
0.6525452733039856,
-0.06461774557828903,
-0.3851107358932495,
0.7342631220817566,
0.24892961978912354,
0.4120715856552124,
0.8239452242851257,
0.14032340049743652,
-0.20438820123672485,
-0.5616137981414795,
0.05832507833838463,
0.2936781644821167,
-0.6786470413208008,
-0.15430212020874023,
-0.7322549223899841,
-0.25609177350997925,
-0.6872327923774719,
-0.08331068605184555,
-0.06690548360347748,
-0.2628360688686371,
-0.3431575894355774,
-0.16619662940502167,
-0.20323972404003143,
0.38937321305274963,
-0.027963368222117424,
0.6438690423965454,
-0.921976625919342,
-0.006776374764740467,
0.1946915239095688,
0.1639239490032196,
0.21366260945796967,
-0.5363417863845825,
-0.651286780834198,
-0.14263765513896942,
-0.4101142883300781,
-0.6913477778434753,
0.26299506425857544,
0.23227916657924652,
0.681104302406311,
0.4751565456390381,
-0.09952320158481598,
0.7445497512817383,
-0.4962327480316162,
0.658067524433136,
0.034662455320358276,
-0.9469457864761353,
0.4213743805885315,
-0.33565130829811096,
0.5420384407043457,
0.7045710682868958,
0.4392196536064148,
-0.35053780674934387,
-0.43008777499198914,
-0.7003327012062073,
-0.9893102645874023,
0.7447917461395264,
0.10977084189653397,
0.17628788948059082,
-0.20744101703166962,
0.20632728934288025,
-0.09421712160110474,
0.351095587015152,
-0.4541868269443512,
-0.1674838364124298,
0.10667625814676285,
-0.21810898184776306,
-0.5073580741882324,
-0.535916805267334,
0.2371726781129837,
-0.3416588008403778,
0.7245376706123352,
0.25398433208465576,
-0.0041296291165053844,
0.00003019575888174586,
-0.5662754774093628,
0.2353792041540146,
0.11609073728322983,
1.017952561378479,
0.5576115846633911,
-0.316834032535553,
0.1759272813796997,
-0.1662183403968811,
-0.5645283460617065,
0.17057302594184875,
0.21002238988876343,
-0.13277199864387512,
0.060911715030670166,
0.601190447807312,
0.8491905927658081,
0.7140498161315918,
-0.5008816719055176,
0.5490561723709106,
0.22664986550807953,
0.14453142881393433,
0.11359364539384842,
0.11002130806446075,
0.08045405149459839,
-0.07683563977479935,
0.3198860287666321,
-0.10380463302135468,
0.07768447697162628,
-0.614923357963562,
0.49455782771110535,
0.13253618776798248,
-0.04577908664941788,
-0.2523922026157379,
0.46773457527160645,
-0.007984640076756477,
-0.1947869211435318,
0.6103327870368958,
0.011768380180001259,
-0.6646530628204346,
0.505361795425415,
0.6073949337005615,
0.8426230549812317,
-0.680604100227356,
-0.11300439387559891,
0.44092637300491333,
0.24689289927482605,
-0.21621279418468475,
0.1166762113571167,
-0.23170575499534607,
-0.5229699611663818,
-0.6812463402748108,
-0.7027068734169006,
-0.13881410658359528,
-0.002722259843721986,
-0.46733739972114563,
0.29749155044555664,
-0.17921404540538788,
0.0647754967212677,
-0.20727095007896423,
0.06286995112895966,
-0.8232818841934204,
0.4151513874530792,
0.10881636291742325,
0.6876517534255981,
-0.8578768968582153,
1.033887505531311,
0.24886533617973328,
-0.5843386054039001,
-1.1587549448013306,
-0.044845785945653915,
-0.23821648955345154,
-0.3102140724658966,
0.6691012978553772,
0.6477328538894653,
0.140092670917511,
0.13083726167678833,
-0.03243173658847809,
-0.9363517761230469,
0.8936268091201782,
0.37216755747795105,
-0.4454187750816345,
-0.1250845044851303,
0.3560456335544586,
0.453511506319046,
-0.4329797029495239,
0.21869304776191711,
0.3759303689002991,
0.26066702604293823,
0.3233824074268341,
-0.820942759513855,
0.3402324616909027,
-0.36284002661705017,
0.017966143786907196,
0.17814789712429047,
-0.3599207401275635,
0.6799683570861816,
0.15248779952526093,
-0.3834726810455322,
-0.02314337156713009,
0.44296473264694214,
0.12019813060760498,
0.11323834955692291,
0.002805474679917097,
0.7329004406929016,
0.7858358025550842,
0.2350853830575943,
1.1520936489105225,
-0.3170490562915802,
-0.0642281025648117,
1.5674506425857544,
-0.17428342998027802,
0.7251812219619751,
0.4889094829559326,
-0.03960806876420975,
0.6275863647460938,
0.5178577899932861,
0.3251170217990875,
0.8949797749519348,
0.5664658546447754,
-0.34273508191108704,
0.05494324862957001,
0.12225016951560974,
-0.504561185836792,
0.318013072013855,
0.3109118938446045,
-0.4491432309150696,
-0.015368310734629631,
0.020259929820895195,
0.23235973715782166,
-0.11474603414535522,
-0.09230294078588486,
0.7799366116523743,
0.2830182909965515,
-1.1051485538482666,
0.4562563896179199,
-0.04794391617178917,
0.6073383688926697,
-0.8152763247489929,
0.3279278874397278,
-0.42474767565727234,
0.15852029621601105,
-0.10844465345144272,
-0.24473023414611816,
0.5344358682632446,
-0.47670862078666687,
-0.2652125656604767,
-0.25334861874580383,
0.5592968463897705,
-0.710896909236908,
-0.16889333724975586,
0.0906604751944542,
0.32886186242103577,
-0.12317700684070587,
-0.2565164268016815,
-0.05476292967796326,
0.013109628111124039,
-0.2431858777999878,
-0.10030455887317657,
0.5918316841125488,
0.37046003341674805,
-0.2367437779903412,
0.39952191710472107,
0.8683921694755554,
-0.32026955485343933,
0.2703503966331482,
0.07399386912584305,
0.8397756218910217,
-0.5123341083526611,
-0.6752861738204956,
-1.1654335260391235,
0.7299320101737976,
0.020515281707048416,
0.024483641609549522,
0.8301799893379211,
0.7687702775001526,
1.0910441875457764,
-0.28941258788108826,
0.384344220161438,
0.26840513944625854,
-0.03245868533849716,
-0.6463862061500549,
0.809093177318573,
-0.14508700370788574,
0.3332746922969818,
-0.5946177244186401,
-0.7739111185073853,
-0.5447703003883362,
0.18345968425273895,
-0.35411202907562256,
-0.03164992108941078,
0.9296188354492188,
0.9028427600860596,
0.10173053294420242,
-0.07802727818489075,
0.38856241106987,
-0.15786513686180115,
0.23048906028270721,
0.4584399163722992,
0.6025291085243225,
-0.3917204737663269,
0.269126832485199,
-0.21327932178974152,
0.03900471329689026,
-0.25118306279182434,
-0.9962815046310425,
-0.9057402610778809,
-0.747398316860199,
-0.2867285907268524,
-0.21411874890327454,
0.03041158989071846,
0.5181841850280762,
0.7862122058868408,
-0.7478399872779846,
-0.21432481706142426,
-0.08179906010627747,
0.12482199817895889,
0.18997344374656677,
-0.10994604229927063,
0.5043982267379761,
-0.6096950173377991,
-0.30289727449417114,
0.2854553163051605,
0.1653524488210678,
0.21953034400939941,
0.10774142295122147,
-0.1945955604314804,
-0.6929884552955627,
0.2717953026294708,
0.5913304686546326,
0.1992165893316269,
-0.4321766793727875,
-0.16079023480415344,
-0.23258624970912933,
-0.20768487453460693,
-0.014606992714107037,
1.044354796409607,
-0.6892529129981995,
0.5297425985336304,
0.5691933631896973,
0.73313969373703,
0.7504904270172119,
0.004947685170918703,
0.876072347164154,
-0.94964200258255,
0.49126285314559937,
-0.07758297026157379,
0.40466752648353577,
0.3960827589035034,
-0.3256806433200836,
0.4526667892932892,
0.4238801896572113,
-0.1521276831626892,
-0.6710214614868164,
0.06683564186096191,
-0.8279209136962891,
-0.33024054765701294,
0.9523065090179443,
-0.44858604669570923,
-0.15900838375091553,
0.053091902285814285,
-0.09323737025260925,
0.5810618996620178,
0.017023246735334396,
0.5578258037567139,
0.8625200986862183,
0.38028857111930847,
-0.06703466922044754,
-0.16343632340431213,
0.51142418384552,
0.5895015597343445,
-0.6739304661750793,
-0.46271541714668274,
0.3827308416366577,
0.22219327092170715,
0.1297353357076645,
0.6343992948532104,
-0.17643405497074127,
0.15821823477745056,
-0.19205230474472046,
-0.21291908621788025,
-0.1377394199371338,
-0.34301942586898804,
-0.3688267767429352,
0.10701297223567963,
-0.2362123280763626,
-0.2942195236682892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13963v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13963v4
|
Towards Building Multilingual Language Model for Medicine
| 2024-02-21T17:47:20 | 2024-06-02T10:02:00 |
Pengcheng Qiu, Chaoyi Wu, Xiaoman Zhang, Weixiong Lin, Haicheng Wang, Ya Zhang, Yanfeng Wang, Weidi Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The development of open-source, multilingual medical language models can
benefit a wide, linguistically diverse audience from different regions. To
promote this domain, we present contributions from the following: First, we
construct a multilingual medical corpus, containing approximately 25.5B tokens
encompassing 6 main languages, termed as MMedC, enabling auto-regressive domain
adaptation for general LLMs; Second, to monitor the development of multilingual
medical LLMs, we propose a multilingual medical multi-choice question-answering
benchmark with rationale, termed as MMedBench; Third, we have assessed a number
of open-source large language models (LLMs) on our benchmark, along with those
further auto-regressive trained on MMedC. Our final model, MMed-Llama 3, with
only 8B parameters, achieves superior performance compared to all other
open-source models on both MMedBench and English benchmarks, even rivaling
GPT-4. In conclusion, in this work, we present a large-scale corpus, a
benchmark and a series of models to support the development of multilingual
medical LLMs.
|
[
-0.2069065123796463,
-0.6127309799194336,
0.6626384258270264,
0.046869441866874695,
-0.0905575305223465,
-0.08400484919548035,
-0.35680392384529114,
-0.5139703750610352,
0.23594403266906738,
0.47938045859336853,
-0.2968214452266693,
-0.46571043133735657,
-0.5812950730323792,
0.4337855577468872,
0.06574689596891403,
0.9084112644195557,
-0.303768515586853,
0.6684723496437073,
-0.03558725118637085,
-0.5215602517127991,
-0.3736782670021057,
-0.7835779786109924,
-0.5293247103691101,
-0.09296224266290665,
0.6767349243164062,
0.1197279542684555,
0.5805174112319946,
0.6130205392837524,
0.4307401478290558,
0.2327350378036499,
0.28822463750839233,
0.02090338245034218,
0.016186466440558434,
0.1538502722978592,
-0.2702942192554474,
-0.4948860704898834,
-0.5984801650047302,
0.09233678132295609,
0.6294896602630615,
0.7108843922615051,
-0.48669320344924927,
0.04460526257753372,
-0.16533738374710083,
0.5491310358047485,
-0.3007975220680237,
0.13267232477664948,
-0.4302821457386017,
-0.24032224714756012,
-0.190110981464386,
0.11606909334659576,
-0.34808969497680664,
-0.21409662067890167,
-0.1464827060699463,
-0.5015264749526978,
-0.10356158763170242,
0.017560908570885658,
0.5221032500267029,
0.17053893208503723,
-0.5001410841941833,
-0.35743582248687744,
-0.41718044877052307,
0.5601573586463928,
-0.8696720004081726,
0.7428569793701172,
0.37403663992881775,
0.46608874201774597,
0.04259949550032616,
-0.5985901355743408,
-0.2965228855609894,
-0.4191923141479492,
0.24214980006217957,
0.11649340391159058,
0.023926081135869026,
-0.1362990140914917,
-0.19499075412750244,
0.3221297264099121,
-0.66499263048172,
0.35153236985206604,
-0.4278426170349121,
-0.06482109427452087,
0.3892751634120941,
0.14298026263713837,
0.24271990358829498,
0.02365005575120449,
-0.2342260330915451,
0.27824634313583374,
-0.8437501192092896,
-0.3552246391773224,
0.15228110551834106,
0.32860395312309265,
-0.27994462847709656,
0.7243870496749878,
0.01282596681267023,
0.697091817855835,
-0.33089306950569153,
-0.39091336727142334,
0.3908645808696747,
-0.5011394023895264,
-0.22278077900409698,
-0.3221759498119354,
0.8494436144828796,
0.31981220841407776,
0.2825927734375,
-0.03289582580327988,
0.13228227198123932,
-0.06777197867631912,
0.1430269479751587,
-0.8497553467750549,
-0.12051764130592346,
0.48065873980522156,
-0.6306639313697815,
-0.04607974737882614,
-0.5144703984260559,
-0.5779219269752502,
-0.21183224022388458,
-0.20818646252155304,
0.07311248779296875,
-0.46113279461860657,
-0.39858049154281616,
0.42513778805732727,
0.3198905289173126,
-0.0931670144200325,
0.2411310076713562,
-0.7597573399543762,
0.22907711565494537,
0.28707465529441833,
0.7210354804992676,
-0.4551829993724823,
-0.48056694865226746,
-0.2859378457069397,
0.23230072855949402,
-0.3854646682739258,
0.767301619052887,
-0.4368593990802765,
-0.408281534910202,
0.11041723191738129,
0.12224773317575455,
-0.17260219156742096,
-0.6160907745361328,
0.4934314787387848,
-0.36855778098106384,
0.4820830225944519,
-0.0658208578824997,
-0.4370008707046509,
-0.06340063363313675,
0.35346585512161255,
-0.7400202751159668,
0.7810959219932556,
0.1803051084280014,
-0.5389837026596069,
0.20163078606128693,
-0.922784149646759,
-0.35428890585899353,
0.0794299840927124,
-0.2731150984764099,
-0.27374014258384705,
0.06183334067463875,
0.4571133255958557,
0.34244462847709656,
-0.5871105194091797,
0.5957150459289551,
-0.4440745711326599,
0.28783220052719116,
0.41579335927963257,
-0.4783334732055664,
0.7863470315933228,
0.2961694002151489,
0.12633071839809418,
0.06712457537651062,
-0.7699730396270752,
-0.20479728281497955,
0.14594951272010803,
-0.534694254398346,
-0.27158522605895996,
0.09580656886100769,
0.11102373898029327,
0.4554588794708252,
0.19669507443904877,
-0.6153122186660767,
0.10981437563896179,
-0.3770173490047455,
0.3718649446964264,
0.5097095966339111,
-0.05265606939792633,
0.0013202757108956575,
-0.3985326290130615,
0.7100672125816345,
0.1129046157002449,
0.18228167295455933,
-0.09776675701141357,
-0.675351619720459,
-0.3288871645927429,
-0.6117480993270874,
0.5020993947982788,
0.5578855276107788,
-0.6780902147293091,
-0.08709641546010971,
-0.084478959441185,
-0.3256050646305084,
-1.0430772304534912,
0.04600907862186432,
0.18969453871250153,
0.449970543384552,
0.4456179440021515,
-0.1595459282398224,
-0.4110255241394043,
-1.0201449394226074,
-0.23762565851211548,
-0.29274821281433105,
-0.00504565704613924,
0.49634504318237305,
0.41992953419685364,
-0.5452016592025757,
0.46760088205337524,
-0.4145287275314331,
-0.13623225688934326,
-0.09856712073087692,
-0.2808308005332947,
0.2677687704563141,
0.31145575642585754,
0.7874165773391724,
-0.5874005556106567,
-0.560522735118866,
0.1505454033613205,
-0.6303282380104065,
-0.36505550146102905,
0.1809867024421692,
-0.05902530997991562,
0.3197252154350281,
0.5005131959915161,
-0.4505789577960968,
-0.12347852438688278,
0.968815267086029,
-0.2339993417263031,
0.8348970413208008,
-0.39267534017562866,
0.3516901135444641,
-1.510966420173645,
0.21990668773651123,
-0.11615218967199326,
-0.21660609543323517,
-0.574611246585846,
0.1974010467529297,
0.2635206878185272,
-0.04002987965941429,
-0.6094316840171814,
0.8568018078804016,
-0.3960748016834259,
0.1851367950439453,
-0.1736815720796585,
0.08088777959346771,
-0.11710066348314285,
0.10766575485467911,
0.07584751397371292,
0.8145851492881775,
0.6112009286880493,
-0.4989461302757263,
0.25703462958335876,
0.17812806367874146,
-0.19020976126194,
0.7073047757148743,
-0.5214993953704834,
-0.3642480671405792,
0.014154568314552307,
0.06348202377557755,
-0.7525393962860107,
-0.28461337089538574,
0.1501338630914688,
-0.4941665232181549,
0.2348971962928772,
-0.09569177031517029,
-0.5982332229614258,
-0.5215619802474976,
0.012314838357269764,
0.4218725860118866,
0.23174124956130981,
-0.45035016536712646,
0.41455355286598206,
0.6040090918540955,
-0.5486086010932922,
-0.36751076579093933,
-0.7700366973876953,
0.16608993709087372,
-0.09415610134601593,
-0.4820372462272644,
0.1871916949748993,
-0.6125049591064453,
-0.23270803689956665,
-0.12051115185022354,
0.30166664719581604,
-0.26102328300476074,
0.08837198466062546,
-0.10292446613311768,
0.4377845823764801,
-0.6124446392059326,
0.42678403854370117,
0.08849773555994034,
-0.026792097836732864,
0.056683238595724106,
-0.36200806498527527,
0.46817755699157715,
-0.06113933399319649,
-0.73289954662323,
0.031678542494773865,
0.6947454214096069,
0.7457010746002197,
-0.3686455488204956,
0.6458173990249634,
0.28904592990875244,
-0.31926000118255615,
0.024892251938581467,
-0.5955541133880615,
0.13341344892978668,
-0.37043848633766174,
0.5437237620353699,
-0.49684804677963257,
-1.0964099168777466,
0.47864198684692383,
-0.03144863620400429,
0.21223627030849457,
0.6116600632667542,
1.2876073122024536,
0.16641776263713837,
0.8786988854408264,
0.4933202862739563,
-0.05232793837785721,
0.009442628361284733,
0.4637710750102997,
-0.16831402480602264,
-0.6425293684005737,
0.05626337230205536,
-0.5413166284561157,
0.17002949118614197,
-0.6254745125770569,
-0.6579864025115967,
0.4984530210494995,
-0.15039914846420288,
-0.029490530490875244,
0.08780762553215027,
-0.27799880504608154,
0.20035773515701294,
0.3845045864582062,
-0.08227802813053131,
0.34666383266448975,
-0.09577591717243195,
-0.8176414966583252,
-0.022869879379868507,
-0.6063379049301147,
-0.4604412317276001,
1.509368896484375,
0.4868960380554199,
0.6732293963432312,
0.33590224385261536,
0.38623955845832825,
-0.12813252210617065,
0.5974058508872986,
-0.6022942662239075,
0.1208861842751503,
-0.34051603078842163,
-0.9208182692527771,
0.02347661182284355,
-0.19141800701618195,
-1.060215711593628,
0.5312622785568237,
0.06285955011844635,
-0.3549672067165375,
-0.13105180859565735,
-0.07619674503803253,
-0.43482592701911926,
0.40458372235298157,
-0.6634457111358643,
0.7438952922821045,
-0.422937273979187,
-0.24744217097759247,
-0.07546786218881607,
-0.6038862466812134,
0.27230748534202576,
-0.4045044779777527,
0.5603429675102234,
-0.21216049790382385,
-0.2675948441028595,
0.5289008617401123,
-0.15434712171554565,
0.8007742762565613,
-0.06549648940563202,
-0.3397786319255829,
0.11100313067436218,
-0.11471892148256302,
-0.09170254319906235,
0.2886659801006317,
-0.28386548161506653,
0.3784039616584778,
0.07924029976129532,
-0.4337300658226013,
-0.059597041457891464,
0.8338918089866638,
-0.7413253784179688,
-0.5003023147583008,
-0.34952056407928467,
-0.7344897389411926,
-0.4901666045188904,
0.42402082681655884,
-0.12041018158197403,
0.30343616008758545,
-0.5329638719558716,
-0.014490267261862755,
0.3342095613479614,
-0.5190398097038269,
0.365328848361969,
1.0536646842956543,
-0.4622526466846466,
-0.6489578485488892,
0.4485074281692505,
0.0235830657184124,
0.3215022385120392,
0.39935725927352905,
0.3032451868057251,
-0.3137613534927368,
-0.7649089694023132,
-0.7960362434387207,
0.6290056109428406,
-0.5604107975959778,
-0.17238552868366241,
-0.781201958656311,
-0.1519635021686554,
-0.5848414897918701,
0.018794625997543335,
-0.3334885239601135,
-0.3008992671966553,
-0.28218546509742737,
-0.06811180710792542,
0.3632190525531769,
0.8343245387077332,
-0.173529714345932,
0.0753462016582489,
-0.9174090027809143,
0.4052043855190277,
-0.012557812966406345,
0.7807006239891052,
-0.32468920946121216,
-0.26879245042800903,
-0.3903670608997345,
0.11706051230430603,
-0.12225387990474701,
-0.8613202571868896,
0.5053842067718506,
0.0843331590294838,
0.9419427514076233,
0.13935576379299164,
-0.34844255447387695,
0.404751181602478,
-0.9293206930160522,
0.804092526435852,
0.2608790993690491,
-0.4495967924594879,
0.35741016268730164,
-0.5422354340553284,
0.3773239254951477,
0.4424929916858673,
0.5233802199363708,
-0.6524862051010132,
-0.46712666749954224,
-0.32874414324760437,
-0.4812855124473572,
0.4151862859725952,
-0.24918653070926666,
-0.10236351191997528,
-0.4043118357658386,
0.18228115141391754,
0.44805780053138733,
0.274004191160202,
-0.8403833508491516,
-0.11828943341970444,
-0.02705908939242363,
-0.40673696994781494,
-0.3171134889125824,
-0.2210972011089325,
-0.23949255049228668,
-0.032575588673353195,
0.5846502184867859,
-0.4075448513031006,
0.22974833846092224,
0.13992610573768616,
-0.1305762082338333,
-0.032002292573451996,
0.4953061044216156,
0.727024257183075,
0.49490755796432495,
0.0354289785027504,
-0.08932498097419739,
0.1034741923213005,
-0.5408852100372314,
0.21225306391716003,
0.4630982279777527,
0.09119715541601181,
0.025616355240345,
0.14093537628650665,
0.6907657980918884,
0.026195038110017776,
-0.7956597208976746,
0.3641572892665863,
-0.09084947407245636,
-0.25619885325431824,
-0.045847129076719284,
-0.34290534257888794,
0.5034402012825012,
0.1786026954650879,
0.06760355830192566,
-0.14683179557323456,
-0.06921746581792831,
-0.21431665122509003,
0.33111122250556946,
0.3646600842475891,
-0.21442928910255432,
-0.36316680908203125,
0.8795934319496155,
0.16262029111385345,
0.02972000651061535,
0.24677909910678864,
0.15678547322750092,
-0.24393290281295776,
0.38330042362213135,
0.7781446576118469,
0.5221026539802551,
-0.6210412979125977,
0.019326087087392807,
0.4601106345653534,
0.2970593273639679,
-0.11069076508283615,
0.4763576090335846,
0.4828135073184967,
-0.492270290851593,
-0.5612542033195496,
-0.6299071311950684,
-0.33104386925697327,
0.07991518825292587,
-0.37927430868148804,
0.26219451427459717,
-0.054728914052248,
-0.19607628881931305,
0.1256880760192871,
-0.2061063051223755,
-0.5905282497406006,
0.19808153808116913,
0.13724300265312195,
0.954025149345398,
-0.6361997127532959,
1.1662633419036865,
0.762337327003479,
-0.4322299063205719,
-0.5205909013748169,
-0.34835129976272583,
-0.04074537381529808,
-1.0983015298843384,
0.4230906665325165,
-0.07249447703361511,
0.157904252409935,
-0.18198667466640472,
-0.29429319500923157,
-1.02986741065979,
0.8482507467269897,
0.41828131675720215,
-0.5000547170639038,
-0.1654050052165985,
0.26378732919692993,
0.5961444973945618,
-0.667694628238678,
0.19215670228004456,
0.2853957712650299,
0.30650588870048523,
-0.23724739253520966,
-1.3052408695220947,
-0.1276814043521881,
-0.2225705236196518,
-0.23333631455898285,
0.177907332777977,
-0.5199847221374512,
1.1169861555099487,
-0.31882205605506897,
0.08724364638328552,
0.2749016284942627,
0.2624107599258423,
0.37749195098876953,
-0.1794920712709427,
0.1147882416844368,
0.4463634192943573,
0.6388174295425415,
0.12020249664783478,
1.2029783725738525,
-0.6274185180664062,
0.15607045590877533,
1.0979390144348145,
-0.5398739576339722,
1.0529977083206177,
0.5116769671440125,
-0.3332758843898773,
0.36790984869003296,
0.5796399116516113,
0.03821587190032005,
0.3246552646160126,
0.16302327811717987,
-0.22655253112316132,
0.0210508294403553,
-0.017787178978323936,
-0.5448811650276184,
0.29732009768486023,
0.5410287976264954,
-0.5373033285140991,
-0.21233658492565155,
0.2655766010284424,
0.17201560735702515,
-0.05007624998688698,
-0.20703904330730438,
0.7632707953453064,
0.1350923478603363,
-0.771757185459137,
0.6573936939239502,
0.20539893209934235,
0.5418553948402405,
-0.78910231590271,
0.24084165692329407,
-0.11777348071336746,
0.20312412083148956,
0.03424213454127312,
-0.6497816443443298,
0.26053041219711304,
-0.08512464165687561,
-0.23343795537948608,
-0.011432469822466373,
0.5251232385635376,
-0.7548415064811707,
-0.6865068674087524,
0.5057257413864136,
0.9618748426437378,
0.1583397388458252,
0.19081883132457733,
-0.7529923319816589,
-0.14576278626918793,
0.009462852962315083,
-0.08464888483285904,
0.4692235589027405,
0.39195477962493896,
-0.19039975106716156,
0.6838951706886292,
0.7768211960792542,
0.5064354538917542,
0.11539284139871597,
0.31668245792388916,
0.6680817008018494,
-0.5113152861595154,
-0.4282384514808655,
-0.8469290137290955,
0.3437974452972412,
0.2678702175617218,
-0.314092755317688,
0.5890104174613953,
0.6197509765625,
0.743895411491394,
-0.2646152377128601,
0.9462845921516418,
0.17847348749637604,
0.9580817222595215,
-0.3932410180568695,
0.8200131058692932,
-0.8089504837989807,
-0.016833940520882607,
0.008142877370119095,
-0.3618614971637726,
-0.6198388338088989,
0.20565590262413025,
-0.030896471813321114,
0.006029591895639896,
0.9154806137084961,
0.6411811113357544,
0.018865959718823433,
-0.2020370066165924,
0.47889354825019836,
0.30003902316093445,
0.3229680061340332,
0.550971508026123,
0.4852309226989746,
-0.23485799133777618,
0.39060962200164795,
0.10833002626895905,
-0.25152671337127686,
-0.1151229739189148,
-0.8319998383522034,
-0.6914575695991516,
-0.47835588455200195,
-0.3156186640262604,
-0.2754443287849426,
-0.07031277567148209,
0.9652270078659058,
0.5642088055610657,
-1.0174795389175415,
-0.4598287045955658,
0.36696940660476685,
-0.23410627245903015,
-0.18901310861110687,
-0.08323231339454651,
0.33946582674980164,
-0.1817179173231125,
-0.593137264251709,
0.5127290487289429,
0.45643848180770874,
0.17165116965770721,
-0.37612372636795044,
-0.10910223424434662,
-0.594435453414917,
0.10355716198682785,
0.7362511157989502,
0.11668533831834793,
-0.8601497411727905,
0.003890923224389553,
0.21042470633983612,
-0.3482055366039276,
0.43357592821121216,
0.7030923962593079,
-0.4995657801628113,
0.48225224018096924,
-0.0380263477563858,
0.7300379276275635,
0.11273671686649323,
-0.36584147810935974,
0.7245694994926453,
-0.3339533507823944,
-0.023710085079073906,
0.2809479236602783,
0.6979908347129822,
0.45074930787086487,
0.06397368758916855,
0.5546342134475708,
0.11964680254459381,
-0.4903048574924469,
-0.6137151122093201,
0.1944022923707962,
-0.642906665802002,
-0.610298216342926,
1.3830355405807495,
-0.013525329530239105,
-0.10348100960254669,
-0.2762610912322998,
-0.3692486882209778,
0.24380680918693542,
-0.1519758403301239,
0.4260402321815491,
0.8564413785934448,
-0.07745199650526047,
-0.010199571028351784,
-0.9934583902359009,
0.2549387514591217,
0.2710202932357788,
-1.1592029333114624,
0.1234806552529335,
0.5988448262214661,
0.5206043124198914,
0.0019552342128008604,
1.1011511087417603,
-0.6402906775474548,
0.2419559359550476,
-0.1590459644794464,
0.252413272857666,
0.1127752736210823,
-0.13358275592327118,
-0.45087361335754395,
0.23528213798999786,
0.375161349773407,
-0.05243372544646263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13956v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13956v2
|
Can You Learn Semantics Through Next-Word Prediction? The Case of Entailment
| 2024-02-21T17:36:07 | 2024-02-29T22:18:03 |
William Merrill, Zhaofeng Wu, Norihito Naka, Yoon Kim, Tal Linzen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Do LMs infer the semantics of text from co-occurrence patterns in their
training data? Merrill et al. (2022) argue that, in theory, probabilities
predicted by an optimal LM encode semantic information about entailment
relations, but it is unclear whether neural LMs trained on corpora learn
entailment in this way because of strong idealizing assumptions made by Merrill
et al. In this work, we investigate whether their theory can be used to decode
entailment judgments from neural LMs. We find that a test similar to theirs can
decode entailment relations between natural sentences, well above random
chance, though not perfectly, across many datasets and LMs. This suggests LMs
implicitly model aspects of semantics to predict semantic effects on sentence
co-occurrence patterns. However, we find the test that predicts entailment in
practice works in the opposite direction to the theoretical test. We thus
revisit the assumptions underlying the original test, finding its derivation
did not adequately account for redundancy in human-written text. We argue that
correctly accounting for redundancy related to explanations might derive the
observed flipped test and, more generally, improve linguistic theories of human
speakers.
|
[
-0.1943323314189911,
-0.666106104850769,
0.7873045802116394,
-0.010357698425650597,
-0.10390044003725052,
-0.40629634261131287,
-0.09537993371486664,
-0.7015619874000549,
0.3469391167163849,
0.6078883409500122,
-0.7590005397796631,
-0.4787014424800873,
-0.3811066448688507,
0.2867044508457184,
-0.6090002059936523,
0.5522575974464417,
0.036209285259246826,
0.03643221780657768,
-0.6919593811035156,
0.19060368835926056,
-0.5008938908576965,
-0.44873982667922974,
-0.4181462228298187,
-0.6317980289459229,
0.36466944217681885,
0.37015488743782043,
0.6866226196289062,
0.4048662781715393,
0.22202903032302856,
0.20588378608226776,
0.06099962443113327,
-0.030446099117398262,
-0.2934125065803528,
-0.00270486855879426,
0.16803723573684692,
-0.7614482641220093,
-0.047467783093452454,
0.23528705537319183,
0.31168052554130554,
0.9868106842041016,
-0.17376407980918884,
-0.20982608199119568,
0.07125473022460938,
0.3833629786968231,
-0.6252526044845581,
0.12871578335762024,
-0.9860333800315857,
0.198625385761261,
0.05366436392068863,
-0.6046775579452515,
-0.7010491490364075,
-0.2663258910179138,
0.5003154277801514,
-0.6047757863998413,
0.19740010797977448,
0.4121314287185669,
0.9540545344352722,
0.11527019739151001,
-0.1861480325460434,
-0.4259110689163208,
-0.3328357934951782,
0.6685739755630493,
-0.5647856593132019,
0.6566301584243774,
0.859951913356781,
0.04319705814123154,
-0.3891404867172241,
-0.6504679322242737,
-0.8340117335319519,
-0.5053150057792664,
-0.36963579058647156,
0.30823490023612976,
0.08612914383411407,
0.03925260528922081,
0.049032095819711685,
0.11047010123729706,
-0.45967093110084534,
-0.014991365373134613,
-0.27242448925971985,
-0.15798042714595795,
0.46088460087776184,
0.1957152932882309,
0.32496827840805054,
0.02926778793334961,
-0.4995819628238678,
0.15480202436447144,
-0.9459953308105469,
-0.09116813540458679,
0.32230299711227417,
0.08241134881973267,
0.0037260239478200674,
0.6973661184310913,
-0.04771267622709274,
0.644536018371582,
0.04738437756896019,
0.13330078125,
0.39967232942581177,
-0.23275046050548553,
-0.22228626906871796,
0.39371779561042786,
0.48191240429878235,
0.253917932510376,
0.5586060285568237,
-0.5722797513008118,
0.049778521060943604,
0.25554728507995605,
0.3233293294906616,
-0.3606530725955963,
-0.240744948387146,
0.2515728771686554,
-0.38467299938201904,
-0.2002236694097519,
0.13642002642154694,
-0.3487793803215027,
-0.2607050836086273,
-0.5252515077590942,
0.47003620862960815,
-0.719796359539032,
-0.07843015342950821,
0.5657927393913269,
-0.21853390336036682,
0.2763390839099884,
0.14602884650230408,
-0.8118516206741333,
0.5155982971191406,
0.9720273613929749,
0.6060201525688171,
-0.1573362648487091,
-0.7256445288658142,
-0.4746629297733307,
0.10029499977827072,
-0.47825074195861816,
0.6131956577301025,
-0.721170961856842,
-0.07472100853919983,
0.2736439108848572,
0.0718546211719513,
-0.2605874836444855,
-0.41973790526390076,
0.4662400484085083,
-0.7448288798332214,
0.24153262376785278,
-0.09259071946144104,
-0.9127418994903564,
-0.3029272258281708,
0.25489500164985657,
-0.3001941740512848,
0.4485977292060852,
-0.37693125009536743,
-0.8973446488380432,
0.6391176581382751,
-0.29307642579078674,
-0.5017682313919067,
-0.09897619485855103,
-0.267873615026474,
-0.26782307028770447,
0.24756625294685364,
-0.18299713730812073,
0.4535376727581024,
0.03170270100235939,
0.2924022972583771,
-0.49863380193710327,
-0.47742363810539246,
0.42061084508895874,
-0.17601396143436432,
0.5846554636955261,
-0.20961357653141022,
-0.21949879825115204,
-0.2029528170824051,
-0.7751412987709045,
0.014725719578564167,
-0.010750137269496918,
-0.1605624407529831,
-0.5474410653114319,
0.2714647948741913,
-0.5321208834648132,
-0.031017117202281952,
0.08904501795768738,
-0.803325355052948,
-0.42359721660614014,
-0.8245646953582764,
0.11124174296855927,
0.6370801329612732,
-0.029937541112303734,
0.6673359870910645,
-0.11387985199689865,
0.11513141542673111,
-0.014248792082071304,
-0.18566825985908508,
-0.1439591646194458,
-0.4703977108001709,
-0.8068058490753174,
0.22466708719730377,
0.07854333519935608,
0.5060691237449646,
-0.4040694534778595,
0.38438084721565247,
-0.20646613836288452,
-0.09302889555692673,
-0.3560185730457306,
-0.07979453355073929,
0.3577226400375366,
0.2902637720108032,
0.4582817852497101,
-0.07914154976606369,
-0.8353671431541443,
-0.9151939749717712,
-0.7705288529396057,
-0.18985873460769653,
0.19443877041339874,
-0.10240016877651215,
0.5935462713241577,
-0.11706972122192383,
0.9519397616386414,
-0.5262382626533508,
-0.18633615970611572,
-0.09096650779247284,
0.08797132223844528,
0.1437775194644928,
0.23112362623214722,
0.13944421708583832,
-0.6689265966415405,
-0.15174967050552368,
-0.11395203322172165,
-0.6822360157966614,
0.1450011283159256,
0.054966822266578674,
-0.11936289817094803,
0.3874434530735016,
0.888039767742157,
-0.5543623566627502,
0.4295247495174408,
0.4320605993270874,
-0.5042046308517456,
0.48635274171829224,
-0.44406914710998535,
-0.44973108172416687,
-0.8816995620727539,
-0.6229863166809082,
-0.06660791486501694,
0.03642890974879265,
-0.5051194429397583,
-0.2065041959285736,
0.07970527559518814,
0.4299594759941101,
-0.04722488299012184,
0.29998940229415894,
-0.5201230645179749,
-0.20418879389762878,
-0.3355197012424469,
0.011661350727081299,
-0.1866634339094162,
0.32373496890068054,
0.4150892496109009,
0.2759118974208832,
0.3339112401008606,
-0.827056884765625,
-0.089588463306427,
0.17895501852035522,
-0.5707168579101562,
0.1406494528055191,
-0.46818527579307556,
-0.005301956553012133,
-0.3151838183403015,
0.18036533892154694,
-0.8085297346115112,
-0.19300998747348785,
-0.041084591299295425,
-0.7300083041191101,
0.12852951884269714,
0.17360195517539978,
-0.42600321769714355,
-0.18121130764484406,
-0.07843607664108276,
-0.09604921191930771,
0.6586253643035889,
-0.6824281811714172,
0.32489505410194397,
0.3804480731487274,
0.2481134831905365,
-0.662915050983429,
-0.9120548963546753,
-0.002459677867591381,
-0.16952849924564362,
-0.35990211367607117,
0.2843249440193176,
0.23414331674575806,
-0.4801771640777588,
0.07575887441635132,
0.10268135368824005,
0.03788262605667114,
0.14271308481693268,
0.4553769528865814,
0.241498202085495,
-0.051757119596004486,
0.526111364364624,
-0.13626688718795776,
-0.21778593957424164,
0.5128970146179199,
-0.562267541885376,
0.5586094260215759,
-0.03540516272187233,
-0.3250172436237335,
-0.19050872325897217,
0.18122383952140808,
0.14172321557998657,
0.02000429853796959,
0.8557093143463135,
0.3765665888786316,
-0.6504433155059814,
-0.14090989530086517,
-0.36816859245300293,
-0.3403575122356415,
-0.4122588336467743,
0.5693400502204895,
-0.5406060814857483,
-0.6164789795875549,
0.15549905598163605,
0.21853210031986237,
0.09002196788787842,
0.4405040442943573,
0.2864900529384613,
-0.47406262159347534,
0.7878061532974243,
0.7962973117828369,
0.3643578290939331,
0.1647302359342575,
-0.27710530161857605,
0.16558769345283508,
-0.5511290431022644,
-0.365746408700943,
-0.26129505038261414,
-0.06649287790060043,
-0.8179564476013184,
-0.059566520154476166,
0.13129056990146637,
0.0870739221572876,
-0.3461137115955353,
0.369946151971817,
0.00037559051997959614,
0.5974413156509399,
0.4232117235660553,
0.17218822240829468,
0.3596826195716858,
0.19573818147182465,
-0.08495616912841797,
-0.22240892052650452,
-0.6212407350540161,
-0.371743768453598,
0.930770218372345,
0.1470465213060379,
0.35630616545677185,
0.02333403378725052,
0.9727708697319031,
-0.05383001267910004,
0.2896122634410858,
-0.8183987736701965,
0.6209728717803955,
-0.15456514060497284,
-0.2560732066631317,
-0.19740833342075348,
-0.1498725563287735,
-1.1180014610290527,
0.2986719608306885,
-0.3882506787776947,
-0.7920015454292297,
0.28533750772476196,
0.09068038314580917,
-0.06995591521263123,
0.11414425820112228,
-0.7504338026046753,
0.6403106451034546,
-0.049917541444301605,
-0.2573460638523102,
-0.30604928731918335,
-0.5486029386520386,
0.3454754650592804,
0.03925743326544762,
0.193964883685112,
-0.09356731176376343,
-0.29991334676742554,
0.776516318321228,
-0.41282370686531067,
0.9868238568305969,
0.046835076063871384,
-0.15690627694129944,
0.33528685569763184,
0.2527862787246704,
0.438579797744751,
0.040405403822660446,
-0.09789496660232544,
-0.06741952896118164,
-0.11473993957042694,
-0.21229614317417145,
-0.6730557084083557,
0.581203818321228,
-0.6562662124633789,
-0.537858784198761,
-0.3586057424545288,
-0.4416826069355011,
-0.4006083607673645,
0.03278355300426483,
0.5053389668464661,
0.38540536165237427,
-0.18513955175876617,
-0.12203012406826019,
0.5405136942863464,
-0.013761138543486595,
0.34862104058265686,
0.47002604603767395,
-0.024247663095593452,
-0.16244570910930634,
0.9531828761100769,
0.05222379043698311,
0.366902619600296,
0.5527867078781128,
0.31041908264160156,
-0.409438818693161,
-0.6783623695373535,
0.1874503791332245,
0.1716393232345581,
-0.8490213751792908,
0.10972131043672562,
-0.8274188041687012,
0.025725610554218292,
-0.16341935098171234,
-0.16332729160785675,
-0.10649608075618744,
-0.25723981857299805,
-0.24423404037952423,
-0.306277334690094,
0.4110414981842041,
0.7525158524513245,
0.11490970104932785,
0.02665133774280548,
-0.5757098197937012,
0.018862368538975716,
0.07888127118349075,
0.23125331103801727,
-0.04355740547180176,
-0.6088976860046387,
-0.06280290335416794,
0.14673569798469543,
-0.05754784867167473,
-0.8496651649475098,
0.502697229385376,
0.2893867492675781,
0.41496241092681885,
0.2681869566440582,
0.02286212146282196,
0.6353949308395386,
-0.7156928777694702,
0.5422589778900146,
0.3540656268596649,
-0.6764820218086243,
0.411773681640625,
-0.1050504818558693,
0.10312870144844055,
0.4206361472606659,
0.5759842991828918,
-0.5101115703582764,
-0.542082667350769,
-0.867185115814209,
-0.5636839866638184,
0.5409465432167053,
-0.05460379272699356,
0.32205623388290405,
-0.3491901159286499,
0.43655335903167725,
0.5604308247566223,
-0.07072630524635315,
-0.5083116292953491,
-0.1382925808429718,
0.08207947760820389,
-0.31861308217048645,
-0.4457850158214569,
-0.4253217875957489,
0.09879026561975479,
-0.3143196105957031,
0.6090900301933289,
-0.14973552525043488,
0.29851582646369934,
0.21733318269252777,
-0.21476860344409943,
0.1942220777273178,
0.14074073731899261,
0.46182525157928467,
0.7101050615310669,
-0.29106539487838745,
0.3472355008125305,
0.3914708197116852,
-0.5463981628417969,
-0.16492091119289398,
-0.2184339463710785,
-0.362435519695282,
0.21521152555942535,
0.6859356164932251,
0.7247104644775391,
0.3090079128742218,
-0.493303120136261,
0.4125342071056366,
0.12928564846515656,
-0.43055808544158936,
-0.9470902681350708,
-0.096285380423069,
0.40726688504219055,
0.1388530433177948,
0.11608606576919556,
0.15711286664009094,
0.1507769674062729,
-0.9156052470207214,
0.35698434710502625,
0.3946416676044464,
-0.491335928440094,
-0.3804873824119568,
0.38582414388656616,
-0.06654717773199081,
-0.28419026732444763,
0.32990381121635437,
-0.18731914460659027,
-0.6236626505851746,
0.7406014800071716,
0.6758584380149841,
0.9642990231513977,
0.2808133065700531,
0.022947996854782104,
0.4959630072116852,
0.2959710657596588,
-0.3194999396800995,
0.23890474438667297,
0.08306638896465302,
-1.1333757638931274,
-0.3666432201862335,
-0.6073757410049438,
-0.37286120653152466,
-0.023882504552602768,
-0.49726971983909607,
0.35619714856147766,
-0.09389501810073853,
0.1352969855070114,
0.042833223938941956,
-0.21068774163722992,
-0.4851686358451843,
0.19653014838695526,
0.21432289481163025,
0.8084608912467957,
-0.5404745936393738,
0.6322535276412964,
0.5839657783508301,
-0.35047197341918945,
-0.6551380753517151,
0.4028809070587158,
-0.19087724387645721,
-0.9717251658439636,
0.8130607008934021,
0.2639935314655304,
-0.18711426854133606,
-0.11056835204362869,
-0.5681572556495667,
-0.8601372241973877,
0.8943730592727661,
0.24549025297164917,
-0.33207178115844727,
0.027330517768859863,
0.03879322111606598,
0.5127334594726562,
-0.6245698928833008,
0.35090604424476624,
0.7542157769203186,
0.2663886547088623,
0.03660385310649872,
-0.6312938928604126,
0.002336720936000347,
0.03658488765358925,
-0.10684319585561752,
0.05901558697223663,
-0.0487937331199646,
0.9336081743240356,
-0.7236224412918091,
-0.3253045976161957,
0.06507353484630585,
0.8689385652542114,
0.023488814011216164,
0.5374698042869568,
0.4309353530406952,
0.5323359370231628,
0.6649767756462097,
-0.08176322281360626,
1.3804956674575806,
-0.048928357660770416,
0.2285754531621933,
1.397085189819336,
-0.10069933533668518,
1.1958967447280884,
0.49945560097694397,
-0.23322565853595734,
0.6420010328292847,
0.7872896194458008,
0.48086050152778625,
0.7032817602157593,
0.29033347964286804,
0.006650303024798632,
-0.31990906596183777,
0.013073857873678207,
-0.3505978286266327,
0.6904420852661133,
0.5053982734680176,
-0.469921737909317,
-0.03391524404287338,
-0.2368495613336563,
-0.08633314818143845,
0.3133383095264435,
-0.3029429316520691,
0.9301967620849609,
0.2340000718832016,
-0.8549153208732605,
0.6661953330039978,
-0.13371238112449646,
0.8547495007514954,
-0.37146660685539246,
-0.07749667763710022,
-0.07363802939653397,
0.5369200110435486,
-0.30981478095054626,
-0.8204467296600342,
0.4221721887588501,
-0.5351108908653259,
-0.08413702249526978,
-0.022737769410014153,
0.8997884392738342,
-0.7212461829185486,
-0.3764204978942871,
0.385200560092926,
0.5216540098190308,
0.2832482159137726,
0.07807707041501999,
-0.1965484917163849,
-0.3914244472980499,
-0.1892034411430359,
-0.06275477260351181,
0.33684036135673523,
0.33520403504371643,
0.0157218836247921,
0.5970746874809265,
0.5137070417404175,
0.09519080072641373,
0.2630324959754944,
0.03917568549513817,
0.340278685092926,
-0.5131558775901794,
-0.5323948264122009,
-0.9660568237304688,
0.04953853785991669,
-0.056659165769815445,
-0.13570889830589294,
0.6221474409103394,
0.35257694125175476,
1.2700554132461548,
-0.13974341750144958,
0.7923914194107056,
0.34964025020599365,
0.3541911244392395,
-0.7505010962486267,
0.4505399763584137,
-0.5408520102500916,
0.04780977964401245,
0.026533180847764015,
-0.6524337530136108,
-0.11141721159219742,
0.5054228901863098,
-0.56453537940979,
-0.1847059428691864,
1.0617172718048096,
0.6334943175315857,
0.14703036844730377,
0.667862057685852,
0.3444370627403259,
0.2299615442752838,
-0.31517958641052246,
0.5184956789016724,
0.9984610676765442,
-0.43073394894599915,
0.3347911834716797,
-0.2369389683008194,
0.19727663695812225,
-0.04735729843378067,
-0.5532127022743225,
-0.8059495687484741,
-0.6812043786048889,
-0.14473694562911987,
-0.5741287469863892,
0.2373565286397934,
0.8871831893920898,
0.13627316057682037,
-0.6848871111869812,
-0.24097560346126556,
-0.7090225219726562,
0.10098549723625183,
-0.14105990529060364,
-0.1842232048511505,
0.2965661883354187,
-0.5042531490325928,
-0.6391446590423584,
0.15751416981220245,
0.11786263436079025,
0.025806542485952377,
-0.08146761357784271,
-0.41379642486572266,
-0.3660969138145447,
0.09205576032400131,
0.7256606817245483,
0.027595793828368187,
-0.8636338114738464,
-0.47780537605285645,
0.06809094548225403,
-0.031644631177186966,
-0.15920454263687134,
0.7920963168144226,
-0.8284350037574768,
0.2959307134151459,
0.5936911702156067,
0.6180322766304016,
0.23584426939487457,
-0.3212529718875885,
0.8364238142967224,
-0.4224601686000824,
0.15134146809577942,
0.18279288709163666,
0.559660017490387,
0.09249001741409302,
-0.27100151777267456,
0.5321885347366333,
0.37617605924606323,
0.08900578320026398,
-0.7056049704551697,
0.4749225080013275,
-0.5584139823913574,
-0.20284147560596466,
1.3145426511764526,
-0.13061854243278503,
-0.3539057672023773,
-0.3225097060203552,
0.24915631115436554,
0.18480263650417328,
-0.03344530984759331,
0.5214793086051941,
0.6811917424201965,
-0.20162276923656464,
-0.15419888496398926,
-0.6719866394996643,
0.6091193556785583,
0.826054036617279,
-0.6414703130722046,
-0.023983558639883995,
0.18365156650543213,
0.2582436203956604,
0.2745317220687866,
0.559421718120575,
0.026345890015363693,
0.3975026309490204,
0.20221997797489166,
-0.06180868297815323,
-0.12205846607685089,
-0.18287035822868347,
-0.10317892581224442,
-0.04051787033677101,
-0.18791182339191437,
-0.4633297026157379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13954v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13954v1
|
Measuring Social Biases in Masked Language Models by Proxy of Prediction Quality
| 2024-02-21T17:33:13 | 2024-02-21T17:33:13 |
Rahul Zalkikar, Kanchan Chandra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social and political scientists often aim to discover and measure distinct
biases from text data representations (embeddings). Innovative
transformer-based language models produce contextually-aware token embeddings
and have achieved state-of-the-art performance for a variety of natural
language tasks, but have been shown to encode unwanted biases for downstream
applications. In this paper, we evaluate the social biases encoded by
transformers trained with the masked language modeling objective using proposed
proxy functions within an iterative masking experiment to measure the quality
of transformer models' predictions, and assess the preference of MLMs towards
disadvantaged and advantaged groups. We compare bias estimations with those
produced by other evaluation methods using two benchmark datasets, finding
relatively high religious and disability biases across considered MLMs and low
gender bias in one dataset relative to the other. Our measures outperform
others in their agreement with human annotators. We extend on previous work by
evaluating social biases introduced after re-training an MLM under the masked
language modeling objective (w.r.t. the model's pre-trained base), and find
that proposed measures produce more accurate estimations of relative preference
for biased sentences between transformers than others based on our methods.
|
[
-0.3878118395805359,
-0.42525526881217957,
0.270783394575119,
0.26762887835502625,
-0.17638109624385834,
0.38553178310394287,
-0.22244584560394287,
-0.19252514839172363,
0.639353334903717,
0.5690436363220215,
-0.20682872831821442,
-0.4560401737689972,
-1.1429407596588135,
-0.08404499292373657,
-0.4546625018119812,
0.7912120819091797,
0.03250691294670105,
0.46246448159217834,
-0.30918797850608826,
-0.1240440234541893,
-0.3396695852279663,
-0.6061215996742249,
-0.30451875925064087,
-0.49970653653144836,
0.18942905962467194,
0.04363188520073891,
0.9827627539634705,
0.5680807828903198,
0.11573955416679382,
0.24556376039981842,
-0.09946438670158386,
-0.06207270547747612,
-0.5182147026062012,
-0.08394034206867218,
-0.2383585274219513,
-0.3455222249031067,
-0.14451327919960022,
0.4239872694015503,
0.5633437037467957,
0.8593214750289917,
0.24842630326747894,
0.5392768383026123,
0.3376612663269043,
0.47976285219192505,
-0.798399806022644,
0.30127376317977905,
-0.8178743124008179,
0.27427300810813904,
-0.008179394528269768,
-0.01668330281972885,
-0.45362260937690735,
-0.467220664024353,
0.11704665422439575,
-0.1314394623041153,
0.5568686127662659,
0.18012133240699768,
0.7344500422477722,
0.32219040393829346,
-0.46403607726097107,
-0.18023572862148285,
-0.6040253639221191,
0.8966837525367737,
-0.5059294700622559,
0.6246724128723145,
0.6302000880241394,
0.36673688888549805,
-0.030207641422748566,
-0.6001444458961487,
-0.4650357663631439,
-0.20740975439548492,
-0.2545923888683319,
0.03541705012321472,
-0.0919322669506073,
-0.09128202497959137,
0.24801453948020935,
0.1473628729581833,
-0.1046983078122139,
-0.055195532739162445,
-0.3119404911994934,
-0.2996840476989746,
0.6017033457756042,
-0.060006093233823776,
-0.06558539718389511,
-0.44197648763656616,
-0.20984728634357452,
-0.14483217895030975,
-0.610984206199646,
0.1189132034778595,
0.6770030856132507,
0.23100289702415466,
-0.02856886014342308,
0.5955004692077637,
-0.20787149667739868,
0.25576868653297424,
0.06913920491933823,
0.18023280799388885,
0.30899474024772644,
-0.04080083966255188,
-0.10085888206958771,
-0.01214766874909401,
0.5856032371520996,
0.622459352016449,
0.5857301354408264,
-0.2936166822910309,
-0.3118199408054352,
0.4285131096839905,
0.22053009271621704,
-0.5213520526885986,
0.042697008699178696,
-0.12507033348083496,
-0.7899182438850403,
-0.40975767374038696,
0.2220742404460907,
-0.854620099067688,
-0.6113676428794861,
-0.2394665777683258,
0.2786599099636078,
0.21057678759098053,
-0.30910244584083557,
0.1589716672897339,
-0.35791894793510437,
0.0321253165602684,
-0.029528506100177765,
-0.7775025367736816,
0.4147684574127197,
0.7093239426612854,
0.6537617444992065,
-0.27743273973464966,
-0.05037742853164673,
-0.7460638880729675,
-0.10142653435468674,
-0.24598677456378937,
0.5365949273109436,
-0.8000518083572388,
-0.31846269965171814,
0.430838406085968,
0.10044823586940765,
-0.03689384460449219,
-0.5526012182235718,
0.668449342250824,
-0.4109840393066406,
0.03299649432301521,
-0.4877832531929016,
-0.5108261704444885,
0.20689921081066132,
0.07602840662002563,
-0.6196727156639099,
1.0426493883132935,
0.0841960683465004,
-0.69703608751297,
0.7978189587593079,
-0.3867706060409546,
-0.28092390298843384,
-0.22040055692195892,
-0.17267072200775146,
-0.4823640286922455,
0.20322445034980774,
0.3106597661972046,
0.6040695905685425,
-0.2412734031677246,
0.6465283632278442,
-0.5781975388526917,
-0.5161685347557068,
0.4376896023750305,
-0.5619444251060486,
0.7312158346176147,
-0.16313841938972473,
-0.8180081844329834,
0.17911303043365479,
-0.5418577194213867,
-0.3304304778575897,
-0.010202296078205109,
0.07745856791734695,
-0.415335088968277,
0.2290516346693039,
0.03686649724841118,
0.30456653237342834,
-0.1960148811340332,
-0.7514848113059998,
-0.3536883294582367,
-0.29942619800567627,
0.38361048698425293,
1.149147868156433,
-0.31406357884407043,
0.6309242248535156,
-0.151943176984787,
0.36170995235443115,
-0.03687771409749985,
0.5116105675697327,
0.18286336958408356,
-0.6261901259422302,
-0.8614662289619446,
-0.017574410885572433,
0.41205811500549316,
0.18412712216377258,
-0.6969228386878967,
0.2883681058883667,
-0.1823653131723404,
-0.25679686665534973,
-0.7173271775245667,
-0.0011838088976219296,
0.32360509037971497,
0.13517135381698608,
0.362106591463089,
-0.29433348774909973,
-0.4294211268424988,
-1.1145471334457397,
-0.7374364137649536,
-0.0882895365357399,
-0.3520103693008423,
0.31153181195259094,
0.6876407265663147,
-0.4109383225440979,
0.9236994385719299,
-0.30397483706474304,
-0.18804873526096344,
-0.007811484858393669,
0.013673834502696991,
-0.08255339413881302,
0.2707168757915497,
0.3352717459201813,
-0.6553000211715698,
-0.4106502830982208,
-0.42650216817855835,
-0.3357890546321869,
-0.29191961884498596,
0.19377458095550537,
-0.07738838344812393,
0.06697966158390045,
0.17677980661392212,
-0.3712350130081177,
0.5413281321525574,
0.7022370100021362,
-0.4500144124031067,
0.5309829115867615,
0.3560759127140045,
0.12675346434116364,
-0.8879583477973938,
-0.1423271745443344,
0.1912577599287033,
-0.2972024977207184,
-0.6440030932426453,
-0.4041893184185028,
0.05259999632835388,
0.2845967411994934,
-0.36727669835090637,
0.7309372425079346,
-0.5244066119194031,
-0.2923148274421692,
-0.16299691796302795,
0.17974312603473663,
0.007858731783926487,
0.31591135263442993,
0.021202558651566505,
0.39983075857162476,
0.4495338201522827,
-0.21224823594093323,
0.027023175731301308,
0.01602969504892826,
-0.34859198331832886,
0.16946296393871307,
-0.6626620292663574,
0.29344335198402405,
-0.2805347740650177,
0.20685994625091553,
-0.8877460956573486,
-0.04250118136405945,
0.2681612968444824,
-0.49682876467704773,
0.1211758479475975,
-0.04018669202923775,
-0.3038594424724579,
-0.3422565162181854,
-0.48432794213294983,
0.29883381724357605,
0.5555593967437744,
-0.5632293224334717,
0.5453881621360779,
0.7044698596000671,
0.2997666895389557,
-0.8818822503089905,
-0.5060400366783142,
0.05489939823746681,
-0.2372715324163437,
-0.42016923427581787,
0.4449884593486786,
0.40663689374923706,
-0.37465807795524597,
0.1310495287179947,
-0.17708133161067963,
0.1948021948337555,
-0.11868521571159363,
0.4511414170265198,
0.12448298186063766,
-0.03845120593905449,
-0.057823121547698975,
0.26465514302253723,
-0.2504391074180603,
0.3264557123184204,
-0.13848581910133362,
0.5494577884674072,
0.020676366984844208,
-0.5767369270324707,
0.11309529840946198,
0.27219173312187195,
0.35454586148262024,
-0.11809246987104416,
0.914518415927887,
0.647026777267456,
-0.47986239194869995,
-0.11920903623104095,
-1.0508888959884644,
-0.5228663086891174,
-0.43535882234573364,
0.2218543291091919,
-0.047395579516887665,
-1.1373974084854126,
0.7129984498023987,
0.07530919462442398,
-0.07182945311069489,
0.3726601302623749,
0.35517817735671997,
0.2576141953468323,
1.2226877212524414,
0.5365740060806274,
-0.19459819793701172,
0.4344724416732788,
-0.11262387037277222,
0.3123937249183655,
-0.706251323223114,
-0.19533465802669525,
-0.7266078591346741,
-0.15565913915634155,
-0.8197969198226929,
-0.5447544455528259,
0.19119971990585327,
-0.06207367405295372,
-0.3311412036418915,
0.10552194714546204,
-0.4399760067462921,
0.2983361482620239,
0.6351408958435059,
0.129159078001976,
0.02776210382580757,
0.12993007898330688,
-0.0216751117259264,
-0.1390385627746582,
-0.541289210319519,
-0.9340144395828247,
1.184417724609375,
0.6428436636924744,
0.5848729610443115,
-0.4379795789718628,
0.41838759183883667,
0.535686731338501,
0.7998999953269958,
-0.4244634509086609,
0.3717931807041168,
-0.14878928661346436,
-0.6522846817970276,
-0.20167414844036102,
-0.2959628403186798,
-0.5849500298500061,
0.30699607729911804,
-0.29202935099601746,
-0.7426781058311462,
0.3801589012145996,
0.16725221276283264,
0.13930101692676544,
0.4021059572696686,
-0.5105075240135193,
0.8584870100021362,
0.11287707835435867,
-0.44961920380592346,
-0.010272372514009476,
-0.6220462918281555,
0.2718004584312439,
0.04188893362879753,
0.1348489373922348,
-0.1874125748872757,
0.13321983814239502,
0.8830705881118774,
-0.08954861760139465,
1.0002703666687012,
-0.3506414592266083,
0.147688090801239,
-0.05152609944343567,
-0.218271866440773,
0.4684366285800934,
-0.024746160954236984,
-0.40450137853622437,
0.7191746830940247,
-0.14153169095516205,
-0.5382199287414551,
-0.5976690053939819,
0.40385371446609497,
-0.7050085663795471,
-0.8315238952636719,
-0.2835977375507355,
-0.19416046142578125,
-0.18756526708602905,
-0.07578470557928085,
0.13297642767429352,
0.2879404127597809,
-0.2047562599182129,
0.28548726439476013,
0.37968170642852783,
-0.426609069108963,
0.2969135344028473,
0.22920292615890503,
-0.12278064340353012,
-0.232060968875885,
0.4540061354637146,
0.21182803809642792,
0.4659126102924347,
0.14135217666625977,
0.35472726821899414,
-0.39263787865638733,
-0.1485099047422409,
-0.5028257966041565,
0.020574966445565224,
-0.6716161370277405,
-0.17429041862487793,
-0.8034149408340454,
-0.24077260494232178,
-0.4111595153808594,
-0.16851186752319336,
-0.5506081581115723,
-0.2643240690231323,
0.04373389482498169,
-0.20695841312408447,
-0.05050171911716461,
0.6594996452331543,
0.024623539298772812,
0.17728427052497864,
-0.3060428500175476,
0.23859894275665283,
0.10140826553106308,
0.44863611459732056,
-0.04379209876060486,
-0.38830336928367615,
-0.23809468746185303,
0.3092043101787567,
-0.21130287647247314,
-1.05753755569458,
0.2716718316078186,
-0.19903942942619324,
0.6205059885978699,
0.4247491657733917,
0.16299322247505188,
0.3640196919441223,
-0.5263897776603699,
0.8954314589500427,
-0.023394880816340446,
-1.1059921979904175,
0.32309332489967346,
0.032341886311769485,
-0.07954713702201843,
0.33053064346313477,
0.3343200385570526,
-0.47895437479019165,
-0.8566604256629944,
-0.4236237704753876,
-0.531766414642334,
0.44963523745536804,
0.35476016998291016,
0.5248296856880188,
-0.27871519327163696,
0.34140869975090027,
0.29834601283073425,
0.41970062255859375,
-0.8975666165351868,
-0.6086912751197815,
-0.5621851682662964,
0.09475713968276978,
-0.1135409027338028,
-0.47757866978645325,
0.16069480776786804,
-0.25832539796829224,
0.6133262515068054,
-0.14352484047412872,
0.40811246633529663,
0.03554586321115494,
-0.05438163876533508,
-0.16650773584842682,
0.1913468986749649,
0.4478181004524231,
0.608825147151947,
-0.19784557819366455,
0.418914258480072,
0.24855387210845947,
-0.4906623959541321,
0.24450938403606415,
0.02009669318795204,
-0.313362717628479,
0.4432518482208252,
0.2097245752811432,
0.8920862674713135,
-0.026273757219314575,
-0.3017100393772125,
0.6502038836479187,
-0.009148969314992428,
0.14573466777801514,
-0.2723388373851776,
-0.10467406362295151,
-0.03578232601284981,
0.1942315548658371,
0.46086615324020386,
0.13740885257720947,
0.22973492741584778,
-0.3785512149333954,
0.11074569821357727,
0.8034141063690186,
-0.7415000796318054,
-0.317821741104126,
0.7537051439285278,
0.12485985457897186,
-0.5829020738601685,
0.11698359996080399,
-0.14400848746299744,
-0.8038415312767029,
0.545484721660614,
0.490942120552063,
1.1306729316711426,
-0.45697957277297974,
0.5000573396682739,
0.23171798884868622,
0.7897474765777588,
-0.057024385780096054,
-0.15424874424934387,
0.06290755420923233,
-1.0211992263793945,
-0.38152801990509033,
-0.7522481083869934,
-0.25156301259994507,
0.0678374394774437,
-0.7326251268386841,
0.20929735898971558,
0.011278631165623665,
-0.44195881485939026,
-0.09839730709791183,
-0.21395455300807953,
-0.8933315277099609,
0.001452566939406097,
-0.2284100204706192,
0.650261640548706,
-1.2316547632217407,
0.6052350401878357,
0.3914060592651367,
-0.13217532634735107,
-0.40740618109703064,
0.2595118284225464,
-0.13464570045471191,
-0.8365092277526855,
0.7171463370323181,
0.3982725143432617,
-0.22993993759155273,
-0.3425903022289276,
-0.2763863205909729,
-0.6983036994934082,
0.6294105052947998,
0.5605648159980774,
-0.3166128695011139,
0.1561865210533142,
0.7954292893409729,
0.46010127663612366,
-0.5484679937362671,
0.49150747060775757,
0.5838320851325989,
0.35817068815231323,
-0.3786717355251312,
-0.7876320481300354,
0.2310696244239807,
-0.2068823277950287,
0.29944878816604614,
0.05177151784300804,
-0.3889637291431427,
0.5797572731971741,
0.29326727986335754,
-0.14684700965881348,
-0.46076902747154236,
0.4911564588546753,
-0.10050561279058456,
0.49149367213249207,
0.6713300943374634,
0.01753653958439827,
0.39300501346588135,
-0.18624959886074066,
1.011207938194275,
-0.3954015076160431,
0.38111042976379395,
0.8311885595321655,
-0.3817894458770752,
0.5046491622924805,
0.5404587984085083,
-0.028059538453817368,
0.3441292345523834,
0.5732554197311401,
0.26201480627059937,
0.44553524255752563,
0.4674655795097351,
-0.18069052696228027,
-0.05456017702817917,
-0.38279539346694946,
-0.19252511858940125,
0.19764654338359833,
0.0779910683631897,
-0.7035799026489258,
0.09924674034118652,
0.09882858395576477,
-0.010019389912486076,
0.22293387353420258,
-0.19832535088062286,
0.5291876792907715,
0.14189523458480835,
-0.6369547247886658,
0.27442485094070435,
0.12055608630180359,
0.7859062552452087,
-0.1684679538011551,
0.025127502158284187,
-0.39785394072532654,
-0.021533168852329254,
-0.08513335883617401,
-0.6023296117782593,
0.46604275703430176,
-0.00006709466833854094,
-0.2136465311050415,
-0.379469096660614,
0.9628982543945312,
-0.3493989109992981,
-0.5653154253959656,
0.6139065027236938,
0.5236061811447144,
-0.038201626390218735,
-0.20401503145694733,
-0.562122642993927,
0.18954361975193024,
-0.11280965059995651,
-0.28719887137413025,
0.19029679894447327,
-0.051155444234609604,
-0.17301569879055023,
0.6011450886726379,
0.5409418344497681,
0.08167281001806259,
0.36724090576171875,
0.4594299793243408,
0.7924391031265259,
-0.44802162051200867,
-0.23881873488426208,
-1.0905146598815918,
0.5070673823356628,
-0.3900700807571411,
-0.1085478812456131,
0.8560576438903809,
0.5357260704040527,
0.9232676029205322,
-0.01918560452759266,
0.6386055946350098,
0.4574495553970337,
0.2985438406467438,
-0.2779916822910309,
0.7386360168457031,
-0.23672030866146088,
0.1732698678970337,
-0.6808152198791504,
-1.1960324048995972,
-0.05586842820048332,
0.6092926263809204,
-0.4766212999820709,
0.22173550724983215,
0.4210657775402069,
1.0192996263504028,
-0.20594379305839539,
0.19190697371959686,
0.31639525294303894,
-0.037337128072977066,
0.2869483530521393,
0.0384608656167984,
0.8358811140060425,
-0.4606626033782959,
-0.025022195652127266,
-0.3528946042060852,
-0.32004573941230774,
-0.04390411451458931,
-0.8777337074279785,
-1.2855949401855469,
-0.638478696346283,
-0.24206911027431488,
-0.599869966506958,
0.21059925854206085,
1.0061978101730347,
0.6605278849601746,
-0.7913622856140137,
-0.2834644913673401,
0.2114952802658081,
0.44661760330200195,
-0.2074866145849228,
-0.2631472051143646,
0.4374333918094635,
-0.13343966007232666,
-0.6847310662269592,
-0.11294293403625488,
0.1456519216299057,
-0.41523441672325134,
-0.7260417342185974,
-0.17625392973423004,
0.1913321316242218,
0.24365472793579102,
0.7731212377548218,
-0.411724716424942,
-0.9132421612739563,
-0.6344353556632996,
0.1184033751487732,
0.030730271711945534,
-0.11695091426372528,
0.7364131212234497,
-0.6356589794158936,
0.4551439583301544,
0.1909894496202469,
0.6487051248550415,
0.5778117179870605,
-0.19228191673755646,
0.5522553324699402,
-0.6291483044624329,
-0.08646608144044876,
0.10230705142021179,
0.4742538332939148,
0.44774365425109863,
-0.23578011989593506,
0.437560498714447,
0.12803447246551514,
-0.3521173894405365,
-1.018984317779541,
0.06531624495983124,
-0.33624762296676636,
0.02297740988433361,
1.4260085821151733,
-0.039089445024728775,
-0.10137055069208145,
-0.26030227541923523,
-0.09792357683181763,
0.5139380097389221,
-0.33341875672340393,
1.1708649396896362,
0.5895929336547852,
0.37912634015083313,
-0.03752338886260986,
-0.695533275604248,
0.5741749405860901,
0.37743863463401794,
-0.4575096666812897,
-0.09480039030313492,
0.2598917782306671,
0.24277429282665253,
0.21931257843971252,
0.4806063175201416,
-0.029280144721269608,
0.019172122702002525,
-0.11332935094833374,
-0.030803414061665535,
0.09014248102903366,
-0.036135151982307434,
-0.16519327461719513,
0.1714583933353424,
-0.25986671447753906,
-0.15331421792507172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13950v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13950v2
|
Making Reasoning Matter: Measuring and Improving Faithfulness of Chain-of-Thought Reasoning
| 2024-02-21T17:23:59 | 2024-02-23T18:01:48 |
Debjit Paul, Robert West, Antoine Bosselut, Boi Faltings
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have been shown to perform better when asked to
reason step-by-step before answering a question. However, it is unclear to what
degree the model's final answer is faithful to the stated reasoning steps. In
this paper, we perform a causal mediation analysis on twelve LLMs to examine
how intermediate reasoning steps generated by the LLM influence the final
outcome and find that LLMs do not reliably use their intermediate reasoning
steps when generating an answer. To address this issue, we introduce FRODO, a
framework to tailor small-sized LMs to generate correct reasoning steps and
robustly reason over these steps. FRODO consists of an inference module that
learns to generate correct reasoning steps using an implicit causal reward
function and a reasoning module that learns to faithfully reason over these
intermediate inferences using a counterfactual and causal preference objective.
Our experiments show that FRODO significantly outperforms four competitive
baselines. Furthermore, FRODO improves the robustness and generalization
ability of the reasoning LM, yielding higher performance on out-of-distribution
test sets. Finally, we find that FRODO's rationales are more faithful to its
final answer predictions than standard supervised fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.5723570585250854,
-0.7819058895111084,
0.9542236328125,
0.08389373868703842,
-0.36982595920562744,
-0.4360189437866211,
-0.267839252948761,
-0.47830650210380554,
-0.03577406704425812,
0.4988919496536255,
-0.5544026494026184,
-0.07533969730138779,
-0.618105411529541,
0.28121721744537354,
-0.061877667903900146,
0.8205058574676514,
-0.10529763996601105,
0.08792216330766678,
-0.2457207292318344,
-0.169680655002594,
-0.4741767346858978,
-0.013214725069701672,
-0.7148138284683228,
-0.6381626725196838,
0.8403217196464539,
0.5403534770011902,
1.0785828828811646,
0.7243266701698303,
0.37985169887542725,
0.26854196190834045,
-0.05770285427570343,
0.6466385722160339,
-0.4923690855503082,
0.1870075911283493,
-0.8386191129684448,
-0.7926331162452698,
-0.46049362421035767,
0.02764454111456871,
0.5487657189369202,
0.5697638392448425,
-0.1523301750421524,
0.21247828006744385,
-0.08440196514129639,
0.712315022945404,
-0.6376737952232361,
0.09408421069383621,
-0.863901674747467,
-0.17408087849617004,
0.0020479566883295774,
-0.34558573365211487,
-0.6487271785736084,
-0.22916871309280396,
-0.14969226717948914,
-0.5656880736351013,
0.10491226613521576,
0.2942378520965576,
0.8423550724983215,
0.3130353093147278,
-0.4477268159389496,
-0.49544757604599,
-0.7625707983970642,
0.7282984256744385,
-0.7980358600616455,
0.5604555606842041,
0.4823945164680481,
0.21260808408260345,
-0.6937212944030762,
-0.4891182780265808,
-0.5825620293617249,
-0.24542464315891266,
0.025841502472758293,
0.027395233511924744,
-0.06607820838689804,
0.23082034289836884,
0.2766854763031006,
0.3134649395942688,
-0.2527818977832794,
-0.15938366949558258,
-0.012926463037729263,
-0.05582874268293381,
0.5508833527565002,
0.21777713298797607,
0.1050555631518364,
0.19727914035320282,
0.05283154919743538,
-0.1573314666748047,
-0.8517873287200928,
-0.02353042922914028,
0.25570425391197205,
0.05464958772063255,
0.4750167429447174,
0.5661901235580444,
-0.11993121355772018,
0.758091926574707,
0.3403545618057251,
-0.19460062682628632,
-0.5053156018257141,
-0.27923744916915894,
-0.6440017819404602,
0.0007795416750013828,
0.5846236944198608,
0.32840651273727417,
0.2171298712491989,
-0.08465889096260071,
-0.1832764893770218,
0.027158772572875023,
0.17470131814479828,
-0.8760302662849426,
0.03102097660303116,
0.37780991196632385,
-0.34412556886672974,
-0.04965517669916153,
0.14055077731609344,
-0.1446256786584854,
0.04977378249168396,
-0.6065292358398438,
0.33682170510292053,
-0.3393428921699524,
-0.06348995119333267,
0.3894069790840149,
0.14052888751029968,
0.16460521519184113,
0.5609878897666931,
-0.8154702186584473,
0.1704925000667572,
0.8055216073989868,
0.517986536026001,
0.31747686862945557,
-0.36117318272590637,
-0.9261166453361511,
0.356149822473526,
-1.0403670072555542,
0.7609084844589233,
-0.4179002344608307,
-0.024683715775609016,
-0.06819622218608856,
0.036020439118146896,
0.017280811443924904,
-0.5398243069648743,
0.49424096941947937,
-0.633789598941803,
-0.011563021689653397,
-0.5726732611656189,
-0.6249867081642151,
-0.05539793521165848,
0.34392186999320984,
-0.5337246060371399,
0.7074987888336182,
-0.352254718542099,
-0.7034922242164612,
0.4464057385921478,
-0.13158074021339417,
-0.2994292378425598,
-0.2552121877670288,
-0.3648790717124939,
-0.08301766961812973,
0.5508959293365479,
0.05438780039548874,
0.5864065885543823,
-0.6549431681632996,
0.5481752753257751,
-0.4170845150947571,
-0.33411309123039246,
0.61824631690979,
-0.18782757222652435,
0.5642322301864624,
0.21731482446193695,
-0.3269781172275543,
0.27772343158721924,
-0.6144838333129883,
-0.10105103999376297,
-0.07508593052625656,
-0.25616592168807983,
-0.3716707229614258,
0.17845962941646576,
-0.7783003449440002,
0.3954989016056061,
-0.09709663689136505,
-0.3926149904727936,
0.07021801173686981,
-0.3706012964248657,
0.17357611656188965,
1.0729681253433228,
-0.10350710153579712,
0.43567630648612976,
-0.5564895868301392,
0.32511940598487854,
-0.06633954495191574,
0.3400839567184448,
0.15827779471874237,
-0.5904713273048401,
-0.8931460976600647,
0.07363580167293549,
-0.0148933045566082,
0.2598128020763397,
-0.9713535904884338,
0.23843953013420105,
-0.23208142817020416,
-0.3939327001571655,
-0.2322874516248703,
0.26902979612350464,
0.4031193256378174,
0.5652551054954529,
0.2423648089170456,
0.001494289725087583,
-0.2182525396347046,
-0.6637165546417236,
-0.4020770788192749,
-0.47502827644348145,
0.024201689288020134,
0.17246489226818085,
0.5328986644744873,
-0.3874180018901825,
0.691118597984314,
-0.3757726550102234,
-0.10453516989946365,
-0.1764042228460312,
0.07893381267786026,
0.3450433611869812,
0.29815590381622314,
0.2850297689437866,
-0.4310494363307953,
-0.15959618985652924,
0.29609352350234985,
-0.833206832408905,
-0.16077585518360138,
-0.2877744734287262,
-0.5090115666389465,
0.07480288296937943,
0.5027440786361694,
-0.5798394083976746,
0.18533718585968018,
0.23148474097251892,
-0.3457758128643036,
0.5210262537002563,
-0.421224445104599,
0.1244635060429573,
-0.7944493293762207,
-0.04709151014685631,
-0.15736401081085205,
-0.11175654828548431,
-0.378811776638031,
0.10079419612884521,
-0.16167709231376648,
0.2913954257965088,
-0.07974068075418472,
0.44463926553726196,
-0.39496538043022156,
0.10397458076477051,
-0.3982747495174408,
0.08588185161352158,
0.040558114647865295,
0.22525551915168762,
-0.09412038326263428,
0.46727490425109863,
0.2240670770406723,
-0.6846861839294434,
0.22221918404102325,
-0.006099936552345753,
-0.14807549118995667,
0.33770912885665894,
-0.6420590877532959,
0.22366496920585632,
-0.05312343314290047,
0.27247121930122375,
-0.9669812321662903,
-0.31298136711120605,
0.056358519941568375,
-0.4291740357875824,
0.11887019127607346,
-0.1407405138015747,
-0.7404906749725342,
-0.06347201764583588,
-0.0612504668533802,
0.2257789671421051,
0.22544807195663452,
-0.4629063010215759,
0.7564897537231445,
0.10587261617183685,
0.15251541137695312,
-0.4941922128200531,
-0.7443783283233643,
-0.23037292063236237,
-0.03846397623419762,
-0.8192248940467834,
-0.07351550459861755,
-0.1645527184009552,
-0.4698376953601837,
-0.27182161808013916,
-0.4480980932712555,
0.035366691648960114,
0.046809080988168716,
0.11551228910684586,
0.06343474239110947,
-0.13759063184261322,
0.31841638684272766,
0.3590584397315979,
-0.18443897366523743,
0.5647261142730713,
-0.2641109228134155,
0.20724062621593475,
-0.26613566279411316,
-0.24858948588371277,
-0.18836793303489685,
0.20894254744052887,
0.6136389374732971,
0.0032963871490210295,
0.8385537266731262,
0.26774144172668457,
-0.23162856698036194,
-0.602341890335083,
-0.5235897302627563,
-0.3456106185913086,
-0.4476853013038635,
-0.24814487993717194,
-0.5940313935279846,
-0.9815108776092529,
0.566362202167511,
-0.09175093472003937,
0.12965600192546844,
0.21944782137870789,
0.3866891860961914,
0.015732182189822197,
1.0736826658248901,
0.2674577236175537,
0.34938380122184753,
0.3434329628944397,
-0.054424431174993515,
0.156966894865036,
-0.5249881148338318,
-0.22900812327861786,
-0.43887844681739807,
-0.003461685497313738,
-0.527531087398529,
-0.600959062576294,
0.053384505212306976,
0.48472505807876587,
-0.4351769983768463,
0.023484541103243828,
-0.28420984745025635,
0.4247153699398041,
0.3606920838356018,
0.31309637427330017,
0.40940627455711365,
-0.03192192316055298,
-0.4086444079875946,
0.13198107481002808,
-0.7414020299911499,
-0.632289469242096,
0.7822639346122742,
0.33014747500419617,
0.8513946533203125,
0.29039475321769714,
0.6467169523239136,
0.010245287790894508,
0.6343443393707275,
-0.6106428503990173,
0.7320218682289124,
0.06960607320070267,
-0.6260912418365479,
-0.26838046312332153,
-0.6265856623649597,
-0.7656859159469604,
0.3724620044231415,
0.0065246568992733955,
-0.4565761387348175,
0.34160828590393066,
0.169173464179039,
-0.08990257233381271,
0.256469190120697,
-0.2917448878288269,
0.5322161912918091,
-0.04129484295845032,
-0.7397482395172119,
-0.3060721158981323,
-0.5935142040252686,
0.5406401753425598,
0.12496789544820786,
0.21794907748699188,
-0.09769094735383987,
0.14217783510684967,
0.6598029136657715,
-0.8292133808135986,
0.6353837847709656,
0.18235251307487488,
-0.32056549191474915,
0.5040319561958313,
0.4655741751194,
0.5156463980674744,
0.24891440570354462,
-0.08686298877000809,
-0.00033533968962728977,
-0.19892524182796478,
-0.40051397681236267,
-0.9069563150405884,
0.7182992100715637,
-0.3620653748512268,
-0.9512588977813721,
-0.4064231216907501,
-0.4300008714199066,
-0.34403762221336365,
0.14394564926624298,
0.15172941982746124,
0.26008960604667664,
0.11574803292751312,
0.2234521210193634,
1.0481516122817993,
0.07003787159919739,
0.14261551201343536,
0.5408723950386047,
-0.45478495955467224,
-0.7559378147125244,
0.4856642186641693,
0.20834556221961975,
0.5669103860855103,
0.46195539832115173,
0.6733145117759705,
-0.12501055002212524,
-0.24874991178512573,
-0.5525592565536499,
0.4323290288448334,
-0.8955756425857544,
-0.23480598628520966,
-0.16228970885276794,
0.1513528823852539,
-0.03515616059303284,
-0.21252208948135376,
-0.44808366894721985,
-0.0008384938118979335,
-0.11554846167564392,
-0.40803954005241394,
0.18187043070793152,
0.5059575438499451,
-0.385686457157135,
-0.04075102508068085,
-0.633929967880249,
0.3161243498325348,
0.6081146597862244,
0.049529362469911575,
0.2846345007419586,
-0.4812767803668976,
-0.2503325045108795,
0.27594414353370667,
-0.09878408908843994,
-0.7210081219673157,
-0.0761210173368454,
-0.12452302128076553,
0.4986310303211212,
0.7474425435066223,
0.044917624443769455,
1.0359201431274414,
-0.41967129707336426,
0.3912847638130188,
0.33356907963752747,
-1.0739631652832031,
0.9672009348869324,
-0.36731287837028503,
0.14066556096076965,
0.49598270654678345,
0.29110437631607056,
0.01177592109888792,
-0.5164288282394409,
-0.6447263360023499,
-0.44638338685035706,
0.48886632919311523,
0.29671511054039,
-0.03306027874350548,
-0.5310419201850891,
0.6066903471946716,
-0.0269045140594244,
-0.08465425670146942,
-0.6108458042144775,
-0.15465585887432098,
0.10307931154966354,
0.09114222973585129,
0.23501302301883698,
-0.22842244803905487,
-0.22590409219264984,
-0.2821052670478821,
0.8668076992034912,
-0.3445189595222473,
0.08141040056943893,
0.6499549746513367,
-0.003943773917853832,
-0.4489882290363312,
0.20539218187332153,
0.7546792030334473,
0.9190337657928467,
-0.2498406022787094,
0.36955150961875916,
0.0009469862561672926,
-0.2721686065196991,
0.18518796563148499,
-0.16349352896213531,
-0.023877130821347237,
0.0534178651869297,
0.6755501627922058,
0.5752273797988892,
0.13350993394851685,
-0.5596902370452881,
0.3112959563732147,
-0.10122690349817276,
-0.1332751363515854,
0.08759738504886627,
0.4090225100517273,
0.06172196939587593,
0.2909579277038574,
0.29074662923812866,
-0.025333236902952194,
-0.05037732049822807,
-0.8776597380638123,
0.1426464319229126,
0.24030829966068268,
-0.42844799160957336,
-0.2281285971403122,
0.7111740112304688,
-0.04475943371653557,
-0.09033703058958054,
0.5363504886627197,
0.02348383329808712,
-0.24026745557785034,
0.5387999415397644,
0.5998855233192444,
0.6761270761489868,
-0.4607851803302765,
0.21179084479808807,
0.2399493306875229,
0.6042882800102234,
-0.48782575130462646,
0.43646135926246643,
-0.22623085975646973,
-1.0237857103347778,
-0.7194157838821411,
-0.42372265458106995,
-0.4060879945755005,
-0.1002575159072876,
-0.7460922002792358,
-0.17715345323085785,
-0.6007893085479736,
-0.1769678294658661,
-0.20793862640857697,
0.04042547196149826,
-0.39993613958358765,
0.47858506441116333,
-0.08488190919160843,
0.9582967758178711,
-0.8959541916847229,
0.8416653871536255,
0.6764103174209595,
-0.6523302793502808,
-1.0994445085525513,
-0.11931195110082626,
-0.3712039291858673,
-0.4335640072822571,
0.6764135360717773,
0.12760156393051147,
-0.5529131293296814,
-0.24955740571022034,
-0.7521046996116638,
-0.6408703327178955,
1.1511558294296265,
0.648077130317688,
-0.6473912000656128,
0.3453873097896576,
0.21806173026561737,
0.5214099287986755,
-0.3684539198875427,
0.2084309458732605,
0.3745584785938263,
0.41187751293182373,
0.28850623965263367,
-0.8109070062637329,
0.357114315032959,
0.14471420645713806,
0.05903802067041397,
0.2501868009567261,
-0.6180257797241211,
0.7283823490142822,
-0.31997668743133545,
-0.10214722901582718,
0.05672357231378555,
0.8393482565879822,
0.7516771554946899,
0.5675166845321655,
0.3530946671962738,
0.6729525327682495,
0.8293102383613586,
-0.18214520812034607,
1.1192423105239868,
0.029591282829642296,
0.2192569524049759,
1.273163914680481,
-0.33567389845848083,
0.8058786392211914,
0.7216874361038208,
-0.007564994040876627,
0.5746937394142151,
0.46660131216049194,
0.5154828429222107,
0.41754481196403503,
0.34478527307510376,
-0.18703298270702362,
-0.7136409878730774,
-0.022050943225622177,
-0.11042313277721405,
0.1421140879392624,
0.34314700961112976,
-0.4591781795024872,
-0.062375348061323166,
-0.1609010547399521,
0.2146075814962387,
0.12666206061840057,
-0.5610777139663696,
0.5405643582344055,
0.3682960569858551,
-0.8982744216918945,
0.5181671380996704,
-0.1122070699930191,
-0.06750071048736572,
-0.6423802375793457,
-0.09774962067604065,
-0.5789616703987122,
0.4082430601119995,
-0.1990380883216858,
-0.7973698377609253,
0.36010509729385376,
-0.20221640169620514,
-0.31078946590423584,
-0.14593327045440674,
0.7411051988601685,
-0.11722834408283234,
-0.3587567210197449,
0.4996587932109833,
0.4952585697174072,
0.06472014635801315,
-0.05231403931975365,
-0.5035309791564941,
0.12988388538360596,
-0.03366395831108093,
-0.19738858938217163,
0.2495899200439453,
1.0332626104354858,
-0.2822587788105011,
0.8009084463119507,
0.9328944683074951,
-0.015485490672290325,
0.05579410493373871,
0.16020990908145905,
0.790643036365509,
-0.6018752455711365,
-0.17746560275554657,
-1.021238923072815,
0.33872151374816895,
-0.064276784658432,
-0.3345452547073364,
0.8128198385238647,
0.4095247685909271,
0.8529647588729858,
-0.017590098083019257,
0.18084347248077393,
0.23474645614624023,
-0.11888204514980316,
-0.7945752739906311,
0.3822696805000305,
-0.5004860162734985,
0.37335649132728577,
-0.18839114904403687,
-0.9184577465057373,
-0.40539780259132385,
0.76177978515625,
-0.3831934332847595,
-0.17055605351924896,
0.7278551459312439,
0.759059488773346,
-0.021802181378006935,
0.06269784271717072,
0.5692526698112488,
0.3747008144855499,
0.4171068072319031,
0.5261119604110718,
0.9864124655723572,
-0.5495104789733887,
0.26229017972946167,
-0.041093550622463226,
-0.23293063044548035,
-0.13265012204647064,
-1.048416256904602,
-0.9780226349830627,
-0.24610118567943573,
-0.28140509128570557,
-0.46539586782455444,
0.08885804563760757,
0.5824965238571167,
0.5578938722610474,
-0.651578426361084,
-0.3035464882850647,
-0.6929346919059753,
0.550467312335968,
-0.45081669092178345,
-0.24496333301067352,
0.12528908252716064,
-0.44807949662208557,
-0.2659147381782532,
0.3341626524925232,
0.4539385437965393,
-0.3976980447769165,
-0.07530002295970917,
-0.28365620970726013,
-0.31043779850006104,
0.6572664380073547,
0.7432250380516052,
-0.09680771082639694,
-1.0695457458496094,
-0.5897244811058044,
-0.02499842271208763,
0.016495471820235252,
-0.14003650844097137,
0.9599034190177917,
-0.45454901456832886,
0.5701234340667725,
0.6976136565208435,
0.5215045809745789,
0.2720203697681427,
-0.07066720724105835,
0.6990740895271301,
-0.23946408927440643,
-0.28059250116348267,
-0.07861227542161942,
0.6070162653923035,
0.02724957838654518,
-0.27371397614479065,
0.6204498410224915,
0.026366502046585083,
-0.8053680062294006,
-0.722815752029419,
0.25331857800483704,
-0.8584989309310913,
-0.5190486907958984,
1.166298508644104,
-0.26143142580986023,
-0.32093295454978943,
-0.0044606332667171955,
-0.07978782802820206,
0.289932519197464,
-0.12379200756549835,
0.6397897005081177,
0.9824786186218262,
-0.3468782603740692,
-0.06010867655277252,
-0.4432477056980133,
0.3350007236003876,
0.4478464126586914,
-0.6311050653457642,
0.03617684170603752,
0.5892577171325684,
0.4552105665206909,
0.26717454195022583,
0.5520269274711609,
0.0834224671125412,
0.3265310525894165,
-0.03019079566001892,
-0.41480475664138794,
-0.0669621154665947,
-0.5117952227592468,
-0.06785760819911957,
-0.045697201043367386,
0.23780322074890137,
0.08104655891656876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14874v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14874v1
|
Distillation Contrastive Decoding: Improving LLMs Reasoning with Contrastive Decoding and Distillation
| 2024-02-21T17:20:38 | 2024-02-21T17:20:38 |
Phuc Phan, Hieu Tran, Long Phan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We propose a straightforward approach called Distillation Contrastive
Decoding (DCD) to enhance the reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models
(LLMs) during inference. In contrast to previous approaches that relied on
smaller amateur models or analysis of hidden state differences, DCD employs
Contrastive Chain-of-thought Prompting and advanced distillation techniques,
including Dropout and Quantization. This approach effectively addresses the
limitations of Contrastive Decoding (CD), which typically requires both an
expert and an amateur model, thus increasing computational resource demands. By
integrating contrastive prompts with distillation, DCD obviates the need for an
amateur model and reduces memory usage. Our evaluations demonstrate that DCD
significantly enhances LLM performance across a range of reasoning benchmarks,
surpassing both CD and existing methods in the GSM8K and StrategyQA datasets.
|
[
-0.3442716598510742,
-0.6720646619796753,
0.8370031118392944,
0.07257699221372604,
-0.49525582790374756,
0.38047468662261963,
-0.2168922871351242,
-0.1441028118133545,
-0.18715353310108185,
0.437425434589386,
-0.47374701499938965,
-0.5466920733451843,
-0.6482347846031189,
0.3059990406036377,
-0.2758011221885681,
0.6700699329376221,
-0.08154428750276566,
0.35716673731803894,
-0.3581300377845764,
-0.026743965223431587,
-0.32388728857040405,
-0.5459031462669373,
-0.9811837673187256,
-0.5678696632385254,
0.37855881452560425,
0.28888827562332153,
0.3994401693344116,
0.5336188673973083,
0.5005262494087219,
0.3522453010082245,
-0.6234604716300964,
0.513968288898468,
-0.5003308057785034,
0.2264230102300644,
-0.2307925820350647,
-0.65474534034729,
-0.19894258677959442,
-0.1287558674812317,
0.1808035522699356,
0.8733654022216797,
-0.282462477684021,
-0.36362922191619873,
0.27592480182647705,
1.088921308517456,
-0.8907762169837952,
0.242891326546669,
-0.6456446051597595,
-0.1632102131843567,
0.09979166090488434,
-0.16233821213245392,
-0.5955215692520142,
-0.17327599227428436,
0.060259655117988586,
-0.5453507900238037,
0.20422810316085815,
-0.06913257390260696,
0.3389933705329895,
0.6691240072250366,
-0.467504620552063,
-0.3892155885696411,
-0.9110295176506042,
0.7793472409248352,
-0.8177871108055115,
0.30133768916130066,
0.4639449715614319,
0.34260910749435425,
-0.13645905256271362,
-0.7318011522293091,
-0.7634400725364685,
-0.27744969725608826,
-0.00993917416781187,
0.2840413749217987,
-0.34520623087882996,
0.33176055550575256,
0.4778876006603241,
0.7013296484947205,
-0.25759831070899963,
-0.07185030728578568,
-0.13299451768398285,
0.09497873485088348,
0.38618671894073486,
0.322597473859787,
-0.16549807786941528,
0.22976434230804443,
-0.17827819287776947,
-0.035647179931402206,
-0.6443573236465454,
-0.35605430603027344,
0.21274349093437195,
-0.05594780296087265,
-0.13436280190944672,
0.20837776362895966,
-0.544553816318512,
0.5592780113220215,
0.28191426396369934,
-0.15003982186317444,
-0.10128551721572876,
-0.37811553478240967,
-0.41263407468795776,
0.10464267432689667,
0.4011482298374176,
0.4652029871940613,
0.039900440722703934,
0.04844822734594345,
-0.22542986273765564,
0.15628117322921753,
-0.1712881624698639,
-0.9983095526695251,
-0.9205834865570068,
0.31208282709121704,
-0.6813616752624512,
-0.1889326125383377,
-0.2731032073497772,
-0.7055323123931885,
-0.7734293341636658,
-0.4347587525844574,
0.08594891428947449,
-0.38947921991348267,
-0.34790751338005066,
0.37791556119918823,
-0.48619598150253296,
0.07728158682584763,
0.5585581660270691,
-1.0481557846069336,
0.517691433429718,
0.4586201012134552,
0.7636429071426392,
-0.2507469952106476,
0.21838881075382233,
-0.43839001655578613,
0.09840334206819534,
-0.32478389143943787,
0.7533901929855347,
-0.4367609918117523,
-0.677466869354248,
-0.24453257024288177,
-0.3518305718898773,
0.32116177678108215,
-1.0652861595153809,
0.630295991897583,
-0.7507943511009216,
-0.21857616305351257,
-0.5608124732971191,
-0.616890013217926,
-0.33112281560897827,
0.20706644654273987,
-1.0228033065795898,
0.7715639472007751,
-0.07298839092254639,
-0.9135986566543579,
0.2585141956806183,
-0.42125746607780457,
-0.36246493458747864,
0.021512867882847786,
-0.1639837622642517,
-0.08516255021095276,
0.3980083763599396,
0.5414302349090576,
0.24064289033412933,
-0.5609685778617859,
0.1329440176486969,
-0.39374661445617676,
-0.3047388792037964,
0.28063279390335083,
-0.7724652886390686,
0.8089519739151001,
0.6235941052436829,
-0.2191196084022522,
-0.048156823962926865,
-0.9283303022384644,
-0.33703023195266724,
0.18187139928340912,
-0.4974380433559418,
-0.4917675852775574,
0.18849384784698486,
-0.2581111490726471,
-0.006741627585142851,
0.08945443481206894,
-0.20595340430736542,
0.12214348465204239,
-0.045749515295028687,
0.5726277232170105,
0.6165414452552795,
-0.01387168187648058,
0.4320289194583893,
-0.18225990235805511,
0.35412418842315674,
0.5909197926521301,
-0.23870094120502472,
-0.30022621154785156,
-0.17078863084316254,
-0.9416517615318298,
-0.47752612829208374,
0.41502806544303894,
0.5781146883964539,
-1.258200764656067,
0.36248236894607544,
0.02519235573709011,
-0.18111373484134674,
-0.594124972820282,
0.11206943541765213,
0.3485499620437622,
0.7773950695991516,
0.5702475309371948,
0.17613853514194489,
-0.5751592516899109,
-0.6537876129150391,
0.2105681598186493,
-0.18172793090343475,
-0.08324278891086578,
0.03418292850255966,
0.3114049434661865,
-0.10469832271337509,
0.6275919079780579,
-0.8104671239852905,
0.03505311161279678,
-0.46377578377723694,
0.06262525916099548,
0.2919332683086395,
0.27862048149108887,
0.2340339869260788,
-0.709890604019165,
-0.4912925064563751,
-0.02173023670911789,
-0.6916775703430176,
-0.24103838205337524,
-0.1579499989748001,
-0.059606581926345825,
0.21274083852767944,
0.7874535322189331,
-0.5595237612724304,
0.4021126925945282,
0.5319592356681824,
-0.311454713344574,
0.6213989853858948,
-0.42014363408088684,
0.44027286767959595,
-1.1511114835739136,
-0.13185611367225647,
0.01191430538892746,
-0.15511685609817505,
-0.5668240785598755,
-0.13986754417419434,
-0.018512677401304245,
0.2542140483856201,
-0.27293673157691956,
0.34898272156715393,
-0.7166905403137207,
0.14776398241519928,
-0.5942947268486023,
0.12870420515537262,
0.41426098346710205,
-0.02457381971180439,
0.22457969188690186,
0.8169859051704407,
0.5425370931625366,
-0.6322057843208313,
0.6035021543502808,
0.08999696373939514,
-0.4694057106971741,
0.5084268450737,
-0.7010328769683838,
-0.020778164267539978,
-0.07354133576154709,
0.5240747928619385,
-1.338711142539978,
0.08585646748542786,
0.004322836175560951,
-0.0019110668217763305,
0.28871431946754456,
-0.14897583425045013,
-0.47340232133865356,
-0.2898648977279663,
-0.19544915854930878,
0.6122363805770874,
0.6747374534606934,
-1.013795256614685,
0.497889906167984,
0.010668810456991196,
-0.08786017447710037,
-0.5464971661567688,
-0.8381041884422302,
0.08803660422563553,
-0.4850276708602905,
-0.3377973437309265,
0.34265992045402527,
-0.25386130809783936,
-0.7087328433990479,
-0.10877606272697449,
-0.3097943365573883,
-0.2586941421031952,
0.2593313157558441,
-0.1444607675075531,
0.42271870374679565,
-0.015054936520755291,
-0.011399874463677406,
0.21617059409618378,
-0.16575637459754944,
0.2770676612854004,
-0.21733279526233673,
0.5474424958229065,
0.23139573633670807,
-0.1619284600019455,
-0.6755399107933044,
0.41150176525115967,
0.30612826347351074,
-0.04577519744634628,
0.7110351324081421,
0.30123722553253174,
-0.21901021897792816,
-0.44491204619407654,
-0.5676069855690002,
-0.3311334252357483,
-0.5255436897277832,
0.17075109481811523,
-0.7215672135353088,
-0.8017219305038452,
0.7232715487480164,
-0.4329599440097809,
-0.3137541115283966,
0.216769739985466,
0.565146803855896,
-0.15946775674819946,
1.0723292827606201,
0.3644266426563263,
0.08503276854753494,
0.35169699788093567,
-0.3042505383491516,
0.18162359297275543,
-0.8375503420829773,
-0.1741655468940735,
-0.46044790744781494,
-0.26632553339004517,
-0.44537413120269775,
-0.6020365357398987,
-0.021744603291153908,
0.46513116359710693,
-0.00475636962801218,
-0.20675154030323029,
-0.5313634872436523,
0.9589718580245972,
0.49440038204193115,
0.2398524433374405,
0.6724499464035034,
-0.17117568850517273,
-0.35386380553245544,
-0.06681504100561142,
-0.5610962510108948,
-0.4253961145877838,
0.9791274070739746,
0.12189338356256485,
1.1652779579162598,
-0.011851041577756405,
0.9475321769714355,
0.2905019521713257,
0.014692366123199463,
-0.8843020796775818,
0.5363876223564148,
-0.2746085822582245,
-0.26906827092170715,
0.026164758950471878,
-0.6021906137466431,
-0.6742874383926392,
0.4021245241165161,
-0.05490284040570259,
-0.3215501308441162,
0.4105398952960968,
0.3082681894302368,
-0.47570741176605225,
0.30034589767456055,
-0.7963396310806274,
0.5385321378707886,
0.10112237185239792,
-0.17654594779014587,
-0.4491364657878876,
-0.42895638942718506,
0.6776093244552612,
0.1664728969335556,
0.05577933415770531,
0.06136263534426689,
-0.04866543412208557,
0.38467952609062195,
-0.5192745327949524,
0.6779987215995789,
-0.12619689106941223,
-0.4557689428329468,
0.36529117822647095,
0.22949811816215515,
0.49733757972717285,
0.043830614537000656,
-0.20595237612724304,
0.08962878584861755,
0.0027982844039797783,
-0.35731470584869385,
-0.8308054208755493,
0.7842992544174194,
-0.4748319983482361,
-0.772858738899231,
-0.2935539484024048,
-0.6050664782524109,
-0.04397374764084816,
-0.03150853142142296,
0.1017405092716217,
0.3655993342399597,
-0.30039864778518677,
0.048608239740133286,
1.1056853532791138,
-0.19698381423950195,
0.5338013172149658,
0.3596162796020508,
0.0002558421983849257,
-0.4953681528568268,
0.5811642408370972,
-0.21733161807060242,
0.5574973821640015,
0.6045458912849426,
0.1564786732196808,
-0.6894083619117737,
-1.0731133222579956,
-0.16063371300697327,
0.05095912516117096,
-1.187738060951233,
-0.2118302881717682,
-0.509199857711792,
-0.012480849400162697,
-0.2981075048446655,
-0.0033190101385116577,
-0.17374680936336517,
-0.5084518194198608,
-0.5195848345756531,
-0.18693439662456512,
0.3863407373428345,
0.6480615139007568,
-0.20107759535312653,
0.2005567103624344,
-0.7527965307235718,
0.6839158535003662,
0.4027606248855591,
0.07935598492622375,
0.02517423778772354,
-0.5603674054145813,
-0.18822865188121796,
0.019222158938646317,
-0.2260332554578781,
-0.7885856628417969,
0.2679359018802643,
-0.01907813549041748,
0.5669909119606018,
0.6497544646263123,
0.4968041479587555,
0.7911321520805359,
-0.5081775784492493,
0.7370790243148804,
0.364868700504303,
-1.0259389877319336,
0.5237311720848083,
-0.03161279484629631,
0.4838816523551941,
0.6036429405212402,
0.3839201331138611,
-0.23361259698867798,
-0.2227732241153717,
-0.23370476067066193,
-0.6790811419487,
0.4644619822502136,
0.03457873314619064,
-0.12731976807117462,
-0.4147615432739258,
0.3405703604221344,
0.05050213634967804,
-0.05015295371413231,
-0.4338882863521576,
-0.3798648416996002,
-0.00919747818261385,
-0.2652510404586792,
-0.024136796593666077,
-0.45651310682296753,
-0.3357635736465454,
-0.37851494550704956,
0.4045841693878174,
-0.11702043563127518,
-0.060730453580617905,
0.24140283465385437,
0.008547660894691944,
0.3655503988265991,
0.28955695033073425,
0.5237213969230652,
0.5182463526725769,
-0.13803687691688538,
0.5934969186782837,
0.4030783176422119,
-0.37420523166656494,
0.2645907700061798,
0.13835543394088745,
0.09383194893598557,
-0.055473633110523224,
0.22886338829994202,
0.7335845232009888,
-0.18439175188541412,
-0.6118640303611755,
0.17090179026126862,
-0.3583444356918335,
-0.4673546254634857,
0.0903257429599762,
0.19296762347221375,
0.5729362964630127,
0.61044842004776,
0.29472893476486206,
-0.18860790133476257,
0.5806924104690552,
-0.42618250846862793,
-0.016305124387145042,
0.30494925379753113,
-0.027414141222834587,
0.05512814223766327,
0.7520520091056824,
0.4390726089477539,
0.17394419014453888,
0.6809436678886414,
-0.3841412365436554,
-0.2012878656387329,
0.7274826765060425,
0.5524907112121582,
0.953856885433197,
-0.24317000806331635,
-0.024015165865421295,
0.34774482250213623,
0.01019209623336792,
-0.32015979290008545,
0.34752392768859863,
-0.370876282453537,
-0.7148882150650024,
-0.576587438583374,
-0.5057975649833679,
-0.5698593258857727,
0.20235973596572876,
-0.8635790944099426,
0.07973849773406982,
-0.4958963096141815,
0.03755892068147659,
0.11487887054681778,
0.10073042660951614,
-0.3017272353172302,
0.28138983249664307,
0.33156704902648926,
0.9725472927093506,
-0.6039047837257385,
1.1549968719482422,
0.28522202372550964,
-0.20813295245170593,
-0.49545037746429443,
0.13501720130443573,
0.024146920070052147,
-0.3976699709892273,
0.8948917984962463,
0.11303240805864334,
-0.4604383707046509,
0.12059692293405533,
-0.4204651713371277,
-0.41892117261886597,
1.2806888818740845,
0.4886722266674042,
-0.9215251803398132,
0.29554805159568787,
-0.17774921655654907,
0.47053417563438416,
-0.377689927816391,
0.3506995737552643,
1.199910283088684,
0.2948991060256958,
0.6376942992210388,
-0.6335340738296509,
0.23256267607212067,
-0.09440159052610397,
0.18512310087680817,
0.02076149545609951,
-0.3246086835861206,
0.8809089660644531,
-0.538596510887146,
-0.4460121989250183,
0.051878031343221664,
0.6051363348960876,
0.48054584860801697,
0.29578644037246704,
0.44163769483566284,
0.8048695921897888,
0.892936646938324,
-0.2449587881565094,
1.0681506395339966,
-0.15940193831920624,
0.19350391626358032,
1.3212209939956665,
-0.507493257522583,
0.7716993093490601,
0.5813366770744324,
-0.3894915282726288,
0.5031789541244507,
0.6719147562980652,
0.2150052785873413,
0.9417901635169983,
0.3902372717857361,
-0.8283778429031372,
-0.3722849190235138,
0.08577784895896912,
-0.2960675358772278,
0.25334006547927856,
0.496937096118927,
-0.28949835896492004,
-0.24514234066009521,
-0.15667545795440674,
-0.06134672462940216,
0.37021178007125854,
-0.296803742647171,
1.0339436531066895,
0.27492669224739075,
-0.5857168436050415,
1.0610508918762207,
-0.19481447339057922,
0.7780497074127197,
-0.21002644300460815,
-0.297695517539978,
-0.5362017154693604,
0.44210824370384216,
-0.1326282024383545,
-0.6487795114517212,
0.29998424649238586,
-0.13259157538414001,
-0.47239357233047485,
-0.1425113081932068,
0.4813263416290283,
-0.6718059778213501,
-0.21718034148216248,
0.5110182166099548,
0.4213957190513611,
0.06420349329710007,
-0.08914689719676971,
-0.6302851438522339,
0.2658880352973938,
0.08815228193998337,
-0.061820246279239655,
0.21437467634677887,
0.7251126170158386,
0.29517775774002075,
0.7009620070457458,
0.6006385684013367,
0.11680880188941956,
-0.1553063839673996,
0.36945435404777527,
1.218360185623169,
-0.7058175802230835,
-0.41187798976898193,
-1.299393892288208,
0.33352211117744446,
-0.21586570143699646,
0.181719571352005,
0.7103949785232544,
0.43765494227409363,
0.73907870054245,
-0.18374107778072357,
0.9107527732849121,
0.24046841263771057,
0.30789968371391296,
-0.9614633321762085,
0.6292474269866943,
-0.3177807927131653,
0.6608780026435852,
0.014721508137881756,
-0.8405448198318481,
-0.2272622138261795,
0.548490047454834,
-0.27461981773376465,
0.028505027294158936,
0.9622495770454407,
0.7720496654510498,
0.11887066811323166,
-0.03553348407149315,
0.471439927816391,
0.1697733849287033,
0.4265369474887848,
0.6414581537246704,
1.192501187324524,
-0.1607063263654709,
0.5783810615539551,
-0.24295194447040558,
-0.2767722010612488,
-0.18441614508628845,
-1.0399165153503418,
-1.160826325416565,
-0.34622395038604736,
-0.4829500615596771,
-0.4611146152019501,
-0.029623670503497124,
0.6901648640632629,
0.510383129119873,
-0.8312560319900513,
-0.14062447845935822,
-0.3675230145454407,
0.2648814916610718,
-0.2665983736515045,
-0.21536003053188324,
0.18652063608169556,
-0.44361168146133423,
-0.9990822076797485,
0.4771080017089844,
0.338530957698822,
0.21927662193775177,
-0.20415332913398743,
-0.21597866714000702,
-0.16834726929664612,
0.2941185235977173,
0.7012677788734436,
-0.0689653679728508,
-0.7401114106178284,
0.15687541663646698,
-0.3690264821052551,
-0.06135672703385353,
0.1648244708776474,
0.8974639177322388,
-0.7412996888160706,
0.45035675168037415,
0.6880517601966858,
0.5871764421463013,
0.6318684220314026,
0.16200944781303406,
0.46077826619148254,
-0.4840424060821533,
0.3033282160758972,
0.1705598086118698,
0.4639047384262085,
0.388899028301239,
-0.2666582763195038,
0.3158492147922516,
0.3009582459926605,
-0.5042023062705994,
-0.6384901404380798,
0.35640862584114075,
-1.0171774625778198,
-0.6395343542098999,
1.290379524230957,
-0.33987221121788025,
-0.10732365399599075,
-0.2954133152961731,
-0.4679185748100281,
0.2051977962255478,
-0.3943127393722534,
0.8983380794525146,
0.8936293721199036,
-0.11993875354528427,
-0.4551186263561249,
-0.2545337975025177,
0.7986049652099609,
0.26298585534095764,
-1.1486531496047974,
0.4358619451522827,
0.8313103318214417,
0.27467459440231323,
-0.11827488988637924,
0.6982395648956299,
-0.025017065927386284,
0.19714277982711792,
0.4568699300289154,
-0.12178312242031097,
-0.07666236162185669,
-0.2980387508869171,
-0.6290554404258728,
-0.13405337929725647,
0.1567232757806778,
-0.32719627022743225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14873v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14873v2
|
Technical Report on the Checkfor.ai AI-Generated Text Classifier
| 2024-02-21T17:13:41 | 2024-02-26T05:28:41 |
Bradley Emi, Max Spero
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7
|
We present the CheckforAI text classifier, a transformer-based neural network
trained to distinguish text written by large language models from text written
by humans. CheckforAI outperforms zero-shot methods such as DetectGPT as well
as leading commercial AI detection tools with over 9 times lower error rates on
a comprehensive benchmark comprised of ten text domains (student writing,
creative writing, scientific writing, books, encyclopedias, news, email,
scientific papers, short-form Q&A) and 8 open- and closed-source large language
models. We propose a training algorithm, hard negative mining with synthetic
mirrors, that enables our classifier to achieve orders of magnitude lower false
positive rates on high-data domains such as reviews. Finally, we show that
CheckforAI is not biased against nonnative English speakers and generalizes to
domains and models unseen during training.
|
[
-0.3736818730831146,
-0.391470730304718,
0.3363034725189209,
-0.063576839864254,
-0.0758662298321724,
-0.08263317495584488,
-0.016696250066161156,
-0.9105926156044006,
-0.027971789240837097,
0.5944487452507019,
-0.2840704917907715,
-0.45177730917930603,
-0.4993472993373871,
0.4065694808959961,
-0.6612854599952698,
1.1457439661026,
-0.14122043550014496,
-0.06187206879258156,
-0.10135126858949661,
-0.12188154458999634,
-0.2618650794029236,
-0.35784104466438293,
-0.7802911996841431,
-0.6815436482429504,
0.5058788061141968,
0.4824254810810089,
0.4119099974632263,
0.31379154324531555,
0.5580175518989563,
0.3422921895980835,
0.20404328405857086,
0.22437986731529236,
-0.13223744928836823,
-0.12321419268846512,
-0.25102514028549194,
-0.6591088175773621,
-0.1672002673149109,
0.24105651676654816,
0.32399165630340576,
-0.2025579810142517,
0.1449613869190216,
0.08497249335050583,
-0.3750830888748169,
0.354779988527298,
-0.5528390407562256,
0.18736667931079865,
-0.6018219590187073,
0.115359365940094,
-0.42813611030578613,
0.019605999812483788,
-0.48705005645751953,
-0.35489317774772644,
-0.0989922508597374,
-0.3299150764942169,
0.6639975309371948,
0.113136425614357,
1.1412353515625,
0.21641036868095398,
-0.44030171632766724,
-0.17637623846530914,
-0.7113732695579529,
0.6946629881858826,
-0.6623843312263489,
0.48124879598617554,
0.56806480884552,
0.35560593008995056,
0.3125488758087158,
-0.4205014407634735,
-1.299863576889038,
-0.15785802900791168,
-0.074897401034832,
0.015945857390761375,
-0.1159907653927803,
0.019603127613663673,
0.3185938894748688,
0.6469254493713379,
-0.7160680890083313,
0.18825723230838776,
-0.39354437589645386,
-0.47746217250823975,
0.9495627284049988,
-0.08339383453130722,
0.4738251268863678,
-0.3067752718925476,
0.014000093564391136,
-0.23577481508255005,
-0.40665337443351746,
-0.12718959152698517,
0.3586317300796509,
0.08865270018577576,
-0.046837955713272095,
0.6881342530250549,
-0.2422935515642166,
0.48584967851638794,
-0.05488351359963417,
-0.07155157625675201,
0.31691449880599976,
-0.2134311944246292,
-0.47282838821411133,
0.18689483404159546,
0.9230649471282959,
0.32332372665405273,
0.3415946960449219,
-0.17654387652873993,
-0.5348545908927917,
0.6797398924827576,
0.23584149777889252,
-0.8873862028121948,
-0.35522186756134033,
-0.07946096360683441,
-0.46986132860183716,
-0.8409493565559387,
-0.14966754615306854,
-0.5989605784416199,
-0.6808341145515442,
-0.16451357305049896,
0.557529866695404,
-0.3836241364479065,
-0.17373773455619812,
-0.04065084084868431,
-0.22778044641017914,
0.5369189381599426,
0.17897841334342957,
-0.5162992477416992,
0.04946064576506615,
0.5813214182853699,
0.6043339371681213,
-0.1523762047290802,
-0.4305863380432129,
-0.6656621694564819,
-0.30709877610206604,
-0.40825507044792175,
1.0664935111999512,
-0.46964290738105774,
-0.25685930252075195,
0.248963862657547,
0.01971523091197014,
0.24896743893623352,
-0.6775614023208618,
0.9561780691146851,
-0.5261883735656738,
0.5068197846412659,
0.2316146343946457,
-0.4724314212799072,
-0.4650249183177948,
0.7556801438331604,
-0.6536830067634583,
0.9866890907287598,
0.08416742086410522,
-0.6098160743713379,
0.5686530470848083,
-0.690664529800415,
-0.9462659955024719,
0.20194092392921448,
-0.01209537498652935,
-0.8960721492767334,
-0.037974581122398376,
0.1805398166179657,
0.463174045085907,
-0.4805644750595093,
0.40507572889328003,
0.1439192295074463,
-0.47177785634994507,
0.046129729598760605,
-0.5615039467811584,
0.5140547752380371,
0.23151157796382904,
-0.8174485564231873,
0.3310704827308655,
-1.0291181802749634,
-0.06959604471921921,
0.17486798763275146,
-0.24987313151359558,
-0.3925790786743164,
-0.1450267732143402,
0.36725038290023804,
0.20023098587989807,
-0.10895514488220215,
-0.9640082716941833,
0.06943991035223007,
-0.4261167347431183,
0.4900272786617279,
0.5875328183174133,
-0.06638658046722412,
0.10416224598884583,
-0.4156365394592285,
0.39115238189697266,
0.2902975082397461,
0.07866349816322327,
-0.39126890897750854,
-0.47257810831069946,
-1.3884928226470947,
-0.059723347425460815,
0.5030375123023987,
0.6935392022132874,
-1.143254041671753,
0.5007628202438354,
-0.01726442761719227,
-0.8157716989517212,
-0.5841748118400574,
-0.04616125673055649,
0.566870391368866,
0.35989910364151,
0.284959614276886,
-0.04889337345957756,
-0.7080094814300537,
-1.093806505203247,
-0.2650451362133026,
-0.41186705231666565,
0.11359678208827972,
0.16753649711608887,
0.6782669425010681,
-0.7951438426971436,
0.4686909317970276,
-0.34135839343070984,
-0.40607354044914246,
-0.01600979082286358,
0.3451627790927887,
-0.0494188629090786,
0.38670018315315247,
0.31585267186164856,
-0.930314302444458,
-0.5075275897979736,
0.11284828931093216,
-0.7095584869384766,
0.0758218988776207,
-0.3597554564476013,
-0.06060506030917168,
0.44323188066482544,
0.42335817217826843,
-0.6585581302642822,
0.6256692409515381,
0.44436153769493103,
-0.4087303876876831,
0.4489368200302124,
0.07831598818302155,
0.2700707018375397,
-1.1568865776062012,
0.11399949342012405,
0.42201220989227295,
-0.39632391929626465,
-0.5232268571853638,
0.033087003976106644,
0.03158031404018402,
-0.5142832398414612,
-0.16204777359962463,
0.6297998428344727,
0.08148512244224548,
0.40357649326324463,
-0.40239185094833374,
-0.03858166188001633,
-0.020810341462492943,
0.5188184976577759,
0.17580413818359375,
1.0268199443817139,
0.24900126457214355,
-0.7500152587890625,
0.117825947701931,
0.39181384444236755,
-0.39952927827835083,
0.7537206411361694,
-0.7696895599365234,
0.24069194495677948,
0.01684003323316574,
0.056387413293123245,
-0.8104357123374939,
-0.21501989662647247,
0.19433973729610443,
-0.5284490585327148,
0.358809232711792,
0.3161364495754242,
-0.42166128754615784,
-0.42250579595565796,
-0.13710740208625793,
0.2550090551376343,
0.35025930404663086,
-0.8982371091842651,
0.6368422508239746,
0.3942306339740753,
0.3586115539073944,
-0.25229254364967346,
-0.661197304725647,
0.33831310272216797,
0.2650568187236786,
-0.5276317596435547,
0.21393918991088867,
0.049514397978782654,
-0.2030012011528015,
-0.00895102322101593,
0.016568921506404877,
-0.18786495923995972,
0.11279680579900742,
0.43799614906311035,
0.17392587661743164,
-0.29093363881111145,
0.2997060716152191,
-0.037401020526885986,
-0.323231041431427,
0.08968806266784668,
-0.47818711400032043,
0.45865827798843384,
-0.18346267938613892,
-0.21670956909656525,
-0.7105536460876465,
0.18035626411437988,
0.7522087693214417,
-0.46343180537223816,
0.5353180766105652,
0.7414742112159729,
-0.5796172022819519,
-0.34312644600868225,
-0.6264421343803406,
-0.030040981248021126,
-0.4691827893257141,
0.25459426641464233,
-0.2583347260951996,
-0.8484347462654114,
0.16228461265563965,
0.24823635816574097,
0.08946292847394943,
0.9747382998466492,
0.3643001317977905,
0.1724645346403122,
1.0378016233444214,
0.8305363655090332,
-0.3906972110271454,
0.33328956365585327,
-0.2374032735824585,
0.5972089171409607,
-0.27330318093299866,
-0.35572272539138794,
-0.9222365617752075,
-0.24221782386302948,
-0.8466891050338745,
-0.20401759445667267,
-0.20984891057014465,
-0.4180352985858917,
-0.37272506952285767,
0.4302593171596527,
-0.8257020711898804,
0.55508953332901,
0.8406389951705933,
0.07863269746303558,
0.07548417150974274,
-0.23332972824573517,
0.25933122634887695,
0.15196610987186432,
-0.26902785897254944,
-0.44510820508003235,
0.7837779521942139,
0.2088633030653,
0.5170221328735352,
-0.1976029872894287,
0.8023214340209961,
0.8306453227996826,
0.7457709312438965,
-0.8660324215888977,
0.48249369859695435,
-0.2745947539806366,
-0.7292945384979248,
-0.20761792361736298,
-0.27138081192970276,
-0.47933223843574524,
-0.24928681552410126,
-0.34481993317604065,
-0.03801272064447403,
0.16890746355056763,
-0.04558346047997475,
0.04837547987699509,
0.7605745196342468,
-0.7483435273170471,
0.677128791809082,
-0.28097987174987793,
0.043254390358924866,
0.016015872359275818,
-0.20421957969665527,
0.29431962966918945,
-0.11627878248691559,
-0.21164436638355255,
0.26272937655448914,
0.42138350009918213,
0.8039368987083435,
-0.33709442615509033,
0.8121709227561951,
-0.10091640055179596,
-0.08041223883628845,
0.4808119833469391,
0.23204302787780762,
0.6236810088157654,
-0.05936967581510544,
-0.11199308186769485,
0.6769364476203918,
-0.19110789895057678,
-0.24932724237442017,
-0.2623450756072998,
0.5339527726173401,
-0.9728639125823975,
-0.26108407974243164,
-0.7902573347091675,
-0.07208500057458878,
-0.059366706758737564,
0.6948179006576538,
0.5480448007583618,
0.25682613253593445,
-0.23374366760253906,
0.07003895193338394,
0.7071620225906372,
-0.18787020444869995,
0.4143344759941101,
0.5191640853881836,
-0.2106304168701172,
-0.4543967843055725,
1.360909342765808,
-0.28176113963127136,
-0.3901651203632355,
0.5501081943511963,
0.18679293990135193,
0.04059832543134689,
-0.6278455853462219,
-0.4900182783603668,
0.23915833234786987,
-0.4652227461338043,
-0.45629405975341797,
-0.5728915929794312,
-0.641942024230957,
-0.32972171902656555,
-0.11829163134098053,
-0.26335886120796204,
-0.07807046175003052,
-0.2717161774635315,
-0.20149783790111542,
0.11178770661354065,
0.975993812084198,
0.2715349793434143,
0.21501202881336212,
-0.8320611119270325,
0.36700180172920227,
0.3424361050128937,
0.5965062379837036,
-0.11263307929039001,
-0.17644505202770233,
-0.1400740146636963,
-0.197765052318573,
-0.22814339399337769,
-0.3892331123352051,
0.4309997856616974,
0.26286712288856506,
0.36093127727508545,
0.4697835147380829,
0.01573352888226509,
0.12158089876174927,
-0.41510722041130066,
0.9285300374031067,
0.24392065405845642,
-1.0254443883895874,
0.6063920855522156,
-0.1899746209383011,
0.298775315284729,
0.6354073882102966,
0.35962629318237305,
-0.8101317286491394,
-0.1607923060655594,
-0.5058498978614807,
-0.19018733501434326,
0.6327399611473083,
0.3802679777145386,
0.039177265018224716,
-0.02901877835392952,
0.5054172277450562,
0.2436845302581787,
0.2031850516796112,
-0.7307682037353516,
-0.0783366933465004,
-0.3431451916694641,
-0.5677750110626221,
-0.4148862659931183,
-0.39175862073898315,
0.08833247423171997,
0.005602148827165365,
0.9563214182853699,
-0.18830205500125885,
0.36556023359298706,
0.38800790905952454,
-0.14357684552669525,
-0.1408988982439041,
0.18943306803703308,
0.81425940990448,
0.1335058957338333,
0.2056051790714264,
0.13827253878116608,
0.05734313279390335,
-0.7937929034233093,
0.15381741523742676,
0.18558095395565033,
-0.7513922452926636,
0.07847357541322708,
0.4871576428413391,
0.9790102243423462,
-0.31527742743492126,
-0.6147786378860474,
0.38693007826805115,
-0.5166106224060059,
-0.5517963767051697,
-0.5250886082649231,
0.25908419489860535,
-0.6634287238121033,
0.25497204065322876,
0.06403981149196625,
0.588040828704834,
0.1932988166809082,
-0.3853662312030792,
0.29376086592674255,
0.19897130131721497,
-0.9346842169761658,
-0.5578345656394958,
0.6391553282737732,
0.5888132452964783,
-1.0426937341690063,
0.8387451767921448,
-0.3607062101364136,
-0.9730198383331299,
0.475923091173172,
0.4196806848049164,
1.3689182996749878,
-0.07239554822444916,
0.5258147716522217,
0.3050183355808258,
0.5367165803909302,
0.14342185854911804,
0.2762858271598816,
-0.23602011799812317,
-0.8895531892776489,
-0.17156319320201874,
-0.6695201396942139,
-0.46257102489471436,
0.3999910354614258,
-0.21856136620044708,
0.44811227917671204,
-0.5832175612449646,
0.09274540841579437,
0.25501748919487,
0.13351765275001526,
-0.7763543725013733,
0.5855900645256042,
0.35275155305862427,
0.8766108155250549,
-0.8658607602119446,
0.7426415085792542,
0.7481144666671753,
-0.4984976351261139,
-0.6324342489242554,
0.24922001361846924,
-0.04320039972662926,
-0.4414074718952179,
0.5857797265052795,
0.7027804255485535,
-0.14818191528320312,
-0.23662734031677246,
-0.7194156646728516,
-0.39021942019462585,
0.6159565448760986,
-0.21000351011753082,
-0.548915445804596,
0.048475198447704315,
0.23000317811965942,
0.8321481347084045,
-0.0726979523897171,
0.2701454162597656,
0.3429130017757416,
0.5540055632591248,
-0.26934391260147095,
-0.7813690900802612,
-0.10945264995098114,
-0.7548213601112366,
-0.21398457884788513,
0.3928554058074951,
-0.6911822557449341,
0.624868631362915,
0.1685357242822647,
-0.144634410738945,
-0.07653601467609406,
0.6225817203521729,
-0.1676802933216095,
0.7430681586265564,
0.5934150815010071,
0.7642072439193726,
0.8391579985618591,
-0.20050062239170074,
1.109886646270752,
-0.07683407515287399,
0.05005687102675438,
0.803033709526062,
-0.4628618359565735,
0.6232942342758179,
0.20028257369995117,
0.09990808367729187,
0.6142445206642151,
0.37293514609336853,
-0.33181971311569214,
0.2402305155992508,
0.015391910448670387,
-0.2820451557636261,
-0.3266264796257019,
-0.3304816484451294,
-0.06792274117469788,
0.7725261449813843,
-0.09234366565942764,
-0.341206431388855,
0.10220062732696533,
0.26678335666656494,
-0.13790012896060944,
0.16352954506874084,
-0.26169902086257935,
0.8619962930679321,
-0.19008857011795044,
-0.9210473299026489,
0.38303354382514954,
0.3047999441623688,
0.9369093775749207,
-0.3159002363681793,
-0.27573859691619873,
-0.12271257489919662,
0.7585043907165527,
-0.266526460647583,
-0.753054678440094,
0.17900921404361725,
0.11966671049594879,
-0.4562617838382721,
0.05329262837767601,
1.090035319328308,
-0.3192700743675232,
-0.6471448540687561,
0.02003111131489277,
-0.010284313932061195,
-0.06183157116174698,
-0.2304147481918335,
-0.4574766159057617,
-0.1072520837187767,
0.156780406832695,
0.04494721442461014,
0.03537483885884285,
0.21715621650218964,
-0.24174512922763824,
0.4916669428348541,
0.8159160614013672,
-0.298707515001297,
-0.33650699257850647,
0.10919226706027985,
0.7904817461967468,
-0.7180378437042236,
-0.4404214024543762,
-0.6809335350990295,
0.31305569410324097,
-0.335935115814209,
-0.6474645733833313,
0.7061423063278198,
0.6469500064849854,
1.1385669708251953,
-0.0008979077101685107,
0.8546767830848694,
0.04635589197278023,
0.5053630471229553,
-0.25357070565223694,
1.0799000263214111,
-0.5256378650665283,
-0.15782800316810608,
-0.05498470366001129,
-0.9022886753082275,
-0.44059327244758606,
0.6159902811050415,
-0.038933731615543365,
0.019795050844550133,
0.5759602189064026,
0.6204397082328796,
0.1385021060705185,
0.37447261810302734,
0.3120487332344055,
0.14104390144348145,
0.8726351261138916,
0.19441375136375427,
0.5752871632575989,
-0.9225517511367798,
0.576295018196106,
-0.4137175977230072,
-0.024600131437182426,
-0.08614043891429901,
-0.6341602802276611,
-1.3138517141342163,
-0.5928422212600708,
-0.45586249232292175,
-0.5392706394195557,
-0.09678573906421661,
0.40933477878570557,
0.715728223323822,
-1.3470425605773926,
0.14320014417171478,
-0.3563660979270935,
0.14007405936717987,
0.036012016236782074,
-0.2580501437187195,
0.14603839814662933,
-0.09769268333911896,
-0.6007242798805237,
0.1992790699005127,
0.26113760471343994,
-0.2094678431749344,
-0.5489042401313782,
-0.18166136741638184,
-0.3457625210285187,
0.30365586280822754,
0.484529048204422,
0.37864917516708374,
-0.3708607852458954,
-0.48168233036994934,
0.1406601071357727,
-0.27823328971862793,
0.030071783810853958,
0.8204380869865417,
-0.6816995143890381,
0.47412875294685364,
0.6456761956214905,
0.7635632753372192,
0.6093910932540894,
-0.3328988254070282,
0.30595916509628296,
-0.5444862246513367,
0.12716461718082428,
0.44434452056884766,
0.18282385170459747,
0.4273996353149414,
-0.4871116280555725,
0.5715619921684265,
0.27447131276130676,
-0.7764349579811096,
-0.8641968369483948,
0.06975346803665161,
-0.536863386631012,
0.0025539330672472715,
0.8149005174636841,
0.12720578908920288,
-0.41369009017944336,
0.04922895506024361,
-0.42530137300491333,
0.345394492149353,
-0.16029886901378632,
0.9452699422836304,
0.46621736884117126,
0.33839404582977295,
-0.1734696626663208,
0.020442165434360504,
0.5596703886985779,
0.22910216450691223,
-1.119678258895874,
-0.41370880603790283,
0.3672623634338379,
0.1269579976797104,
0.6031008958816528,
0.22027429938316345,
0.0564674511551857,
0.4390726387500763,
0.05699006840586662,
0.46728795766830444,
-0.27827686071395874,
-0.5158808827400208,
-0.41530275344848633,
0.0018187211826443672,
-0.19708502292633057,
-0.15491749346256256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13936v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13936v1
|
Distinctive Image Captioning: Leveraging Ground Truth Captions in CLIP Guided Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-02-21T17:05:06 | 2024-02-21T17:05:06 |
Antoine Chaffin, Ewa Kijak, Vincent Claveau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Training image captioning models using teacher forcing results in very
generic samples, whereas more distinctive captions can be very useful in
retrieval applications or to produce alternative texts describing images for
accessibility. Reinforcement Learning (RL) allows to use cross-modal retrieval
similarity score between the generated caption and the input image as reward to
guide the training, leading to more distinctive captions. Recent studies show
that pre-trained cross-modal retrieval models can be used to provide this
reward, completely eliminating the need for reference captions. However, we
argue in this paper that Ground Truth (GT) captions can still be useful in this
RL framework. We propose a new image captioning model training strategy that
makes use of GT captions in different ways. Firstly, they can be used to train
a simple MLP discriminator that serves as a regularization to prevent reward
hacking and ensures the fluency of generated captions, resulting in a textual
GAN setup extended for multimodal inputs. Secondly, they can serve as
additional trajectories in the RL strategy, resulting in a teacher forcing loss
weighted by the similarity of the GT to the image. This objective acts as an
additional learning signal grounded to the distribution of the GT captions.
Thirdly, they can serve as strong baselines when added to the pool of captions
used to compute the proposed contrastive reward to reduce the variance of
gradient estimate. Experiments on MS-COCO demonstrate the interest of the
proposed training strategy to produce highly distinctive captions while
maintaining high writing quality.
|
[
-0.3304135799407959,
-0.402715802192688,
0.46088114380836487,
0.15274201333522797,
-0.7625362873077393,
0.16423046588897705,
-0.1846764087677002,
-0.1687069833278656,
-0.09032097458839417,
0.5278973579406738,
-0.6022865772247314,
-0.5807225108146667,
-0.7491899132728577,
0.05736396834254265,
-0.2057647407054901,
0.9935327768325806,
-0.19939693808555603,
0.3274767994880676,
-0.4652758240699768,
-0.3615332543849945,
-0.8937420845031738,
-0.5885516405105591,
-0.2900357246398926,
-0.14143776893615723,
0.6071622371673584,
0.47330230474472046,
0.7646266222000122,
0.7861056923866272,
0.31108295917510986,
0.21642476320266724,
0.0856042206287384,
0.3707822263240814,
-0.4477321207523346,
-0.1642550528049469,
-0.3004187345504761,
-0.6624403595924377,
0.3938680589199066,
0.5157774686813354,
0.45116740465164185,
0.1290678232908249,
-0.04170028492808342,
-0.3379192650318146,
-0.12245921790599823,
0.730397641658783,
-0.7810602784156799,
0.2802219092845917,
-0.6633926033973694,
0.5253832936286926,
0.2405678629875183,
-0.6719843149185181,
-0.48031431436538696,
-0.47437143325805664,
0.05133870616555214,
-0.7550374865531921,
0.36434534192085266,
0.3664419651031494,
1.3331125974655151,
0.3440498113632202,
-0.2807004749774933,
-0.42500993609428406,
-0.5491074919700623,
0.8613691329956055,
-0.3916456699371338,
0.3855864703655243,
0.08359627425670624,
0.5870659351348877,
0.19965803623199463,
-0.5956869721412659,
-0.49540388584136963,
-0.49793583154678345,
-0.2294517457485199,
0.15736174583435059,
0.04734155535697937,
-0.084523044526577,
0.3916843831539154,
0.419181764125824,
-0.1861916184425354,
-0.08881301432847977,
-0.3722718358039856,
-0.32224759459495544,
0.2061413675546646,
-0.024200141429901123,
0.26212751865386963,
-0.10481955111026764,
-0.9035829305648804,
-0.3566196858882904,
-1.108028769493103,
0.37365245819091797,
0.14214558899402618,
0.05714963376522064,
0.15644696354866028,
0.42378005385398865,
-0.11624111980199814,
0.5458952784538269,
0.12264983355998993,
-0.3400919437408447,
0.08588875085115433,
0.11413025856018066,
-0.02909734472632408,
-0.06378589570522308,
0.722823977470398,
0.5395978093147278,
0.1972195953130722,
-0.30271172523498535,
-0.4262675940990448,
-0.0457376129925251,
0.24931076169013977,
-0.6663671135902405,
-0.2742011547088623,
-0.41489216685295105,
-0.34135398268699646,
-0.6018195748329163,
0.4256702661514282,
-0.5959147214889526,
-0.4403415322303772,
-0.45623379945755005,
0.6078023910522461,
-0.5655335187911987,
0.1316862851381302,
-0.044462982565164566,
-0.3546270728111267,
0.454556941986084,
0.3240720331668854,
-0.7839509844779968,
0.3534761369228363,
0.4356655776500702,
0.8957858085632324,
-0.3295969069004059,
-0.3352992832660675,
-0.8783808350563049,
0.1938934624195099,
-0.3686247766017914,
0.7301679253578186,
-0.5591583251953125,
-0.25283607840538025,
0.005870797671377659,
0.19433122873306274,
-0.017395179718732834,
-0.5627785921096802,
0.5148106813430786,
-0.887561023235321,
0.30073291063308716,
-0.5978630781173706,
-0.29572242498397827,
-0.4353811740875244,
0.4111937880516052,
-0.9342498779296875,
0.6537765860557556,
-0.10562992095947266,
-0.7108193635940552,
0.5258495211601257,
-0.4279780089855194,
-0.4642561078071594,
-0.17928020656108856,
-0.483499675989151,
-0.5481893420219421,
-0.11343885958194733,
0.7821427583694458,
0.401748925447464,
0.0171221774071455,
0.2518899738788605,
0.12102148681879044,
-0.6186197400093079,
0.4659099280834198,
-0.5570599436759949,
0.36123961210250854,
0.05920565873384476,
-0.5744063854217529,
0.18605440855026245,
-0.47211354970932007,
-0.0408787727355957,
0.3181685209274292,
-0.35719454288482666,
-0.19455985724925995,
-0.023077037185430527,
-0.11826810240745544,
0.23402494192123413,
-0.18185612559318542,
-0.3531610667705536,
0.11910879611968994,
0.13469432294368744,
0.4406452476978302,
0.8753199577331543,
0.3118416965007782,
0.31496620178222656,
-0.5686610341072083,
0.6571325659751892,
0.07713793218135834,
0.13890717923641205,
-0.21107369661331177,
-0.2857873737812042,
-0.6129345893859863,
-0.5888382792472839,
0.6061556339263916,
0.5074750781059265,
-1.0531305074691772,
0.09560659527778625,
-0.3189288377761841,
-0.1413303017616272,
-0.34720978140830994,
-0.08447100222110748,
0.5388665199279785,
0.5429505109786987,
0.38169577717781067,
-0.4064539670944214,
-0.45947349071502686,
-0.8323111534118652,
0.01772809401154518,
0.23288413882255554,
0.1438382863998413,
0.5916890501976013,
0.47212353348731995,
0.29595619440078735,
0.9045748710632324,
-0.5680520534515381,
-0.4561479091644287,
-0.19456151127815247,
0.2910659611225128,
-0.13342411816120148,
0.5058714747428894,
0.5977525115013123,
-1.3075202703475952,
-0.3636266887187958,
-0.3333430886268616,
-0.7381450533866882,
0.15755335986614227,
-0.5310084223747253,
-0.06088540703058243,
-0.0823468267917633,
0.5245638489723206,
-0.5373045206069946,
0.32370221614837646,
0.3751910924911499,
0.12715508043766022,
0.7277696132659912,
-0.18353326618671417,
0.41477009654045105,
-0.39235660433769226,
-0.1002594456076622,
-0.2027186155319214,
-0.6131013631820679,
-0.007447840180248022,
0.2620297074317932,
-0.08568758517503738,
-0.18773525953292847,
-0.4632735252380371,
0.13088983297348022,
-0.6994388699531555,
-0.285232275724411,
-0.3710116744041443,
0.045179255306720734,
0.12179997563362122,
0.8645583987236023,
0.5756359100341797,
1.0846540927886963,
0.6218146085739136,
-0.7279207110404968,
0.5377100706100464,
0.43520140647888184,
-0.4312177002429962,
0.5563992857933044,
-0.6015686988830566,
0.16859042644500732,
-0.2018713504076004,
0.3545754551887512,
-0.8366134762763977,
0.05372321605682373,
0.4579472243785858,
-0.48710063099861145,
0.20605988800525665,
-0.22501857578754425,
-0.39667102694511414,
-0.17761273682117462,
-0.33054399490356445,
0.08925030380487442,
0.5876100659370422,
-0.8923941254615784,
0.3428103029727936,
0.04423590004444122,
0.18532304465770721,
-0.8016104698181152,
-0.5131576657295227,
0.08452118188142776,
-0.2656833529472351,
-0.14399129152297974,
0.41951054334640503,
0.062073010951280594,
0.35297518968582153,
0.24518351256847382,
-0.2282034456729889,
-0.07533542066812515,
0.06306556612253189,
0.5967842936515808,
0.2505929470062256,
-0.03207399696111679,
0.09511616826057434,
-0.05265986919403076,
-0.10207608342170715,
0.015707803890109062,
-0.39985471963882446,
0.36106228828430176,
-0.16355153918266296,
-0.40072447061538696,
-0.2716376781463623,
0.3823111057281494,
0.408232718706131,
-0.3244612216949463,
0.7035655975341797,
0.675020158290863,
-0.08707493543624878,
-0.1378355622291565,
-0.2519737482070923,
-0.18826432526111603,
-0.44397100806236267,
0.07745978981256485,
-0.4348798096179962,
-0.6993785500526428,
0.23125669360160828,
-0.22253409028053284,
-0.09480436146259308,
0.06094832718372345,
0.29565390944480896,
-0.09836786240339279,
0.8418180346488953,
0.6433441638946533,
-0.01099181454628706,
0.794001579284668,
-0.3396555781364441,
-0.07980412244796753,
-0.6826203465461731,
-0.35456058382987976,
-0.13317637145519257,
-0.2936686873435974,
-0.18991228938102722,
-0.4510360658168793,
0.32437440752983093,
0.18477723002433777,
0.07087307423353195,
0.2012854814529419,
-0.5717146396636963,
0.9188926219940186,
0.9250041842460632,
0.5714190602302551,
0.2835841774940491,
0.27676236629486084,
-0.4077546000480652,
-0.3097137212753296,
-0.6739736199378967,
-0.4421621561050415,
0.8908059000968933,
0.23634080588817596,
0.7393733859062195,
-0.18850810825824738,
0.5106638073921204,
0.5403894782066345,
0.28441280126571655,
-0.7271804809570312,
0.6209787130355835,
0.16683946549892426,
-0.26643282175064087,
-0.1676291823387146,
-0.27740204334259033,
-0.5789586901664734,
0.3566233515739441,
-0.3207738995552063,
-0.04392336681485176,
-0.11226183921098709,
0.036998651921749115,
-0.19093018770217896,
0.3248209059238434,
-0.2507401406764984,
0.7943615317344666,
-0.38323429226875305,
-0.27477583289146423,
-0.19910019636154175,
-0.799100935459137,
0.2534278333187103,
0.5528552532196045,
-0.047422293573617935,
0.23139801621437073,
0.08900816738605499,
0.6235277056694031,
-0.24680769443511963,
0.832697868347168,
-0.41763341426849365,
0.2628763020038605,
0.38461387157440186,
-0.003452952252700925,
0.6171736717224121,
0.07913369685411453,
0.5850847363471985,
-0.20477664470672607,
-0.22917000949382782,
-0.4337007999420166,
-0.8368480801582336,
0.4133366048336029,
-0.8081597089767456,
-0.7311568856239319,
-0.5045769214630127,
-0.41452282667160034,
-0.18380184471607208,
0.2437756359577179,
0.4153110086917877,
0.4922164976596832,
-0.03073258325457573,
0.2878767251968384,
1.0903667211532593,
-0.1934398114681244,
0.23199476301670074,
0.45966821908950806,
0.08408434689044952,
-0.7411043047904968,
0.99776691198349,
-0.27545109391212463,
0.32510700821876526,
0.6223187446594238,
0.2817234694957733,
-0.41566601395606995,
-0.6832099556922913,
-0.5213620066642761,
0.0620996356010437,
-1.047197699546814,
-0.3072587549686432,
-0.3703368306159973,
-0.19071000814437866,
-0.09521397948265076,
-0.3315487205982208,
-0.08815262466669083,
-0.2559955418109894,
-0.21696747839450836,
-0.3833259642124176,
0.15432488918304443,
0.35029342770576477,
-0.16100257635116577,
0.2979525923728943,
-0.8239646553993225,
0.5160149931907654,
0.7499836087226868,
0.24222712218761444,
-0.100706547498703,
-0.43279552459716797,
-0.06886129826307297,
-0.08053439855575562,
-0.4208659827709198,
-1.0489598512649536,
0.2943602204322815,
0.09419261664152145,
0.7105875015258789,
0.41204020380973816,
0.09696938842535019,
0.4649093747138977,
-0.5501359701156616,
0.8098398447036743,
0.34516459703445435,
-0.9580410122871399,
0.510179877281189,
-0.19391416013240814,
-0.2264227569103241,
0.49813705682754517,
0.5658394694328308,
-0.5258867740631104,
-0.2507799565792084,
-0.5654593706130981,
-0.505020260810852,
0.3986852765083313,
0.04586181789636612,
0.2182406634092331,
0.2402481883764267,
0.24198941886425018,
0.25398769974708557,
0.48586010932922363,
-1.2785909175872803,
-0.004035945516079664,
-0.5796700119972229,
-0.04075269028544426,
0.22825999557971954,
-0.24910828471183777,
-0.6393098831176758,
-0.12691138684749603,
0.6901860237121582,
-0.30640286207199097,
0.43441253900527954,
0.3273647129535675,
-0.4437505900859833,
0.17910204827785492,
0.31653791666030884,
0.8285353183746338,
0.3567141890525818,
-0.14931784570217133,
0.23583705723285675,
-0.11881932616233826,
-0.29208189249038696,
0.22971408069133759,
-0.27894333004951477,
-0.2599518597126007,
0.25243324041366577,
0.20523719489574432,
1.162625789642334,
0.3435872495174408,
-0.7193158864974976,
0.9851004481315613,
0.13133175671100616,
-0.4452323317527771,
-0.19893772900104523,
0.11405935883522034,
-0.30507633090019226,
0.1881275177001953,
0.3259120583534241,
0.23990562558174133,
0.012113671749830246,
-0.4401460289955139,
0.35407111048698425,
0.3100973069667816,
-0.6532126665115356,
-0.05798123776912689,
0.6008281707763672,
0.09679058939218521,
0.19099147617816925,
0.4879145920276642,
-0.3371676504611969,
-1.0237699747085571,
0.518862783908844,
0.5929092168807983,
0.6666404008865356,
0.38025739789009094,
0.6633682250976562,
0.2679915130138397,
0.3231799900531769,
-0.2506907880306244,
-0.036978669464588165,
-0.31399500370025635,
-0.6265970468521118,
-0.22484003007411957,
0.017670731991529465,
-0.8131985664367676,
0.006161043420433998,
-0.7020900845527649,
0.26078373193740845,
-0.8171885013580322,
0.39814460277557373,
-0.27746066451072693,
-0.18610967695713043,
-0.4815835654735565,
0.36717697978019714,
0.34169894456863403,
0.6848238110542297,
-1.0155553817749023,
0.6342894434928894,
0.7169390320777893,
-0.7712185382843018,
-0.8800597786903381,
-0.129855677485466,
-0.22807031869888306,
-0.7509496808052063,
0.8504586219787598,
0.4888266623020172,
-0.1651466190814972,
-0.22951482236385345,
-1.1392842531204224,
-0.45752522349357605,
1.2958786487579346,
0.06166664510965347,
-0.17574551701545715,
-0.04244249686598778,
0.11961718648672104,
0.31830817461013794,
-0.684978723526001,
0.07711218297481537,
0.09076987206935883,
0.29509881138801575,
0.56142258644104,
-0.310686856508255,
0.3561728000640869,
0.10962327569723129,
0.12885373830795288,
-0.3005620837211609,
-0.5913705825805664,
0.8275173902511597,
-0.38876447081565857,
-0.5354202389717102,
0.0727730318903923,
0.8347703814506531,
0.41233137249946594,
0.2619180381298065,
0.6963088512420654,
0.3925364315509796,
0.6635482907295227,
-0.1011117547750473,
0.866189181804657,
0.09748706221580505,
0.421967476606369,
0.9154725670814514,
0.054387688636779785,
0.5938389897346497,
0.514813244342804,
0.06487313657999039,
0.8284891843795776,
0.4792551100254059,
-0.43841680884361267,
1.1579582691192627,
0.22404275834560394,
0.035289499908685684,
-0.4052218198776245,
-0.23899924755096436,
-0.2315525859594345,
0.09720959514379501,
-0.006566705647855997,
-0.4231654703617096,
-0.29838937520980835,
0.2869854271411896,
-0.2616446316242218,
0.44081345200538635,
-0.2526644766330719,
0.563202440738678,
-0.11921662092208862,
-0.5523974299430847,
0.6568273901939392,
-0.03593260049819946,
0.6726536750793457,
-0.40055862069129944,
-0.3296355903148651,
-0.06399741023778915,
-0.13914506137371063,
-0.10728603601455688,
-0.7011696696281433,
-0.02175884135067463,
-0.10383787751197815,
-0.2968716323375702,
-0.24325226247310638,
0.5017046928405762,
-0.4594055116176605,
-0.01778300665318966,
-0.25564461946487427,
0.06884095817804337,
0.03969902545213699,
-0.23994852602481842,
-0.668130099773407,
-0.11526667326688766,
0.04767218977212906,
0.020492125302553177,
0.18272466957569122,
0.3395410478115082,
-0.06769437342882156,
0.713748037815094,
0.7195499539375305,
-0.01062419731169939,
0.18979130685329437,
0.005967800971120596,
1.0615428686141968,
-0.8360582590103149,
-0.8666349649429321,
-0.4792506992816925,
0.2799060344696045,
-0.18904800713062286,
0.0008530214545316994,
0.5723561644554138,
0.4331498146057129,
0.6578342318534851,
-0.6411231756210327,
0.7774437665939331,
0.01812105067074299,
0.29940977692604065,
-1.0695818662643433,
0.23223482072353363,
-0.3494844138622284,
0.12390812486410141,
-0.12376584112644196,
-0.6856122016906738,
-0.06822732836008072,
0.6474817991256714,
-0.3644876480102539,
-0.24495257437229156,
0.8618656992912292,
0.6746563911437988,
-0.021455558016896248,
-0.006344722583889961,
0.3156648278236389,
-0.45957615971565247,
0.3342258632183075,
0.8947761058807373,
1.1194435358047485,
-0.5299679636955261,
0.7717936038970947,
-0.2564312815666199,
-0.06178770959377289,
-0.2064800262451172,
-0.9709100127220154,
-0.9762146472930908,
-0.4460398554801941,
-0.42760664224624634,
-0.22836934030056,
0.16023188829421997,
0.7636316418647766,
0.7972121834754944,
-0.8629087805747986,
0.41327980160713196,
-0.21643206477165222,
0.42614272236824036,
-0.662142813205719,
-0.2890450954437256,
0.2715327739715576,
-0.26235535740852356,
-0.6006139516830444,
0.20166489481925964,
0.03584739565849304,
0.25811731815338135,
-0.19357354938983917,
-0.27724120020866394,
0.01489053014665842,
-0.04529944807291031,
0.2603760063648224,
0.47387006878852844,
-0.7094602584838867,
-0.4875280559062958,
-0.057753004133701324,
-0.4207002520561218,
0.30583053827285767,
1.1421074867248535,
-1.069419026374817,
0.17251308262348175,
0.2866092920303345,
0.799065113067627,
0.4459056258201599,
0.3173597753047943,
0.45713526010513306,
-1.0301601886749268,
0.187948077917099,
0.16988028585910797,
0.1479874849319458,
0.5230534672737122,
-0.3123813569545746,
0.4345990717411041,
0.5767935514450073,
-0.3424433469772339,
-0.6003524661064148,
0.29710617661476135,
-0.9935057163238525,
-0.2246582955121994,
1.2556110620498657,
-0.5212024450302124,
-0.17879007756710052,
0.3599208891391754,
-0.5773249268531799,
0.006448434665799141,
-0.34110015630722046,
0.8189603686332703,
0.7583453059196472,
0.3421297073364258,
-0.6552706956863403,
-0.3143005967140198,
0.6027349233627319,
0.28677016496658325,
-0.5584908127784729,
-0.21009449660778046,
0.7160263657569885,
0.5724600553512573,
0.13332565128803253,
0.3298608362674713,
-0.27435973286628723,
0.5956742167472839,
0.00016502587823197246,
0.004063894040882587,
-0.7901046276092529,
-0.6085993647575378,
-0.3966737389564514,
0.3202759623527527,
0.03789143264293671,
-0.7975104451179504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13934v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13934v1
|
Do Efficient Transformers Really Save Computation?
| 2024-02-21T17:00:56 | 2024-02-21T17:00:56 |
Kai Yang, Jan Ackermann, Zhenyu He, Guhao Feng, Bohang Zhang, Yunzhen Feng, Qiwei Ye, Di He, Liwei Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
As transformer-based language models are trained on increasingly large
datasets and with vast numbers of parameters, finding more efficient
alternatives to the standard Transformer has become very valuable. While many
efficient Transformers and Transformer alternatives have been proposed, none
provide theoretical guarantees that they are a suitable replacement for the
standard Transformer. This makes it challenging to identify when to use a
specific model and what directions to prioritize for further investigation. In
this paper, we aim to understand the capabilities and limitations of efficient
Transformers, specifically the Sparse Transformer and the Linear Transformer.
We focus on their reasoning capability as exhibited by Chain-of-Thought (CoT)
prompts and follow previous works to model them as Dynamic Programming (DP)
problems. Our results show that while these models are expressive enough to
solve general DP tasks, contrary to expectations, they require a model size
that scales with the problem size. Nonetheless, we identify a class of DP
problems for which these models can be more efficient than the standard
Transformer. We confirm our theoretical results through experiments on
representative DP tasks, adding to the understanding of efficient Transformers'
practical strengths and weaknesses.
|
[
-0.5165702700614929,
-0.5615679621696472,
0.7829411029815674,
0.1997443586587906,
0.23565025627613068,
0.17407093942165375,
-0.37988656759262085,
-0.4108116924762726,
-0.2097923457622528,
0.24459032714366913,
-0.5304230451583862,
0.3960522413253784,
-0.6303383708000183,
0.32333821058273315,
-0.8504945635795593,
0.6992638111114502,
-0.36636680364608765,
-0.3724353313446045,
-0.023917047306895256,
-0.16634498536586761,
-0.5596115589141846,
-0.26120591163635254,
-0.51753169298172,
-0.1459352821111679,
0.42518967390060425,
0.3587262034416199,
1.0390206575393677,
0.5671961307525635,
0.8632667064666748,
0.4550698399543762,
-0.1962948590517044,
-0.016950596123933792,
-0.5665856003761292,
0.46303048729896545,
-0.27847176790237427,
-0.5537821650505066,
-0.12546521425247192,
0.0035032243467867374,
0.6191095113754272,
0.8923461437225342,
-0.23521628975868225,
0.29089802503585815,
0.008742883801460266,
0.6960175633430481,
-0.5708357095718384,
0.16518162190914154,
-0.9259663224220276,
0.15923897922039032,
0.3031850755214691,
-0.08556295931339264,
-0.5637503266334534,
-0.2339295744895935,
-0.004746264312416315,
-0.4374467432498932,
0.2722010612487793,
-0.15999655425548553,
0.6847111582756042,
0.9629530310630798,
-0.31717225909233093,
-0.3762786090373993,
-1.443608283996582,
0.8584972620010376,
-0.12226034700870514,
0.5731944441795349,
-0.004491799045354128,
0.6719228029251099,
-0.05979291349649429,
-1.0259884595870972,
-0.6535481214523315,
-0.09727509319782257,
-0.31080713868141174,
-0.006065123248845339,
-0.6621561050415039,
0.04046233743429184,
0.8202346563339233,
0.29812151193618774,
-0.09219690412282944,
0.11647025495767593,
-0.23271359503269196,
0.036053918302059174,
0.26837924122810364,
0.4695553183555603,
0.09998210519552231,
-0.023774897679686546,
-0.2716900110244751,
-0.2996441423892975,
-0.37186580896377563,
0.08677447587251663,
0.23988543450832367,
0.10414456576108932,
0.018864579498767853,
0.33482611179351807,
0.33257144689559937,
0.7974691390991211,
0.16878215968608856,
-0.17093245685100555,
-0.40456753969192505,
-0.20055373013019562,
-0.007938453927636147,
-0.4650312066078186,
0.28736770153045654,
-0.09594257920980453,
0.45205122232437134,
-0.4352385401725769,
-0.4685646593570709,
0.16461342573165894,
0.6580124497413635,
-0.7157686352729797,
-0.3885946273803711,
0.1678030788898468,
-0.3637236952781677,
-0.24915719032287598,
-0.2996441125869751,
-0.6067949533462524,
-0.23223459720611572,
-0.48667821288108826,
0.27507299184799194,
-0.21084141731262207,
-0.14643113315105438,
0.11369551718235016,
-0.3286374807357788,
-0.004134598188102245,
0.41647017002105713,
-1.1127547025680542,
0.425444632768631,
0.575122058391571,
0.6543613076210022,
-0.11579720675945282,
-0.007500076666474342,
-0.35007861256599426,
-0.1451573371887207,
-0.23793068528175354,
0.8201891779899597,
-0.46496817469596863,
-0.18649905920028687,
-0.2512989342212677,
-0.14046445488929749,
-0.3755223751068115,
-0.5855013728141785,
0.6554632782936096,
-0.43769559264183044,
-0.3024112284183502,
-0.6174348592758179,
-0.23489871621131897,
0.06570480018854141,
-0.021646125242114067,
-1.0416103601455688,
0.8243732452392578,
0.4411054849624634,
-0.7090533971786499,
0.20399069786071777,
-0.3737030327320099,
-0.21078917384147644,
-0.048304636031389236,
-0.1810346394777298,
-0.1859910786151886,
0.24878889322280884,
-0.06152385473251343,
0.35952305793762207,
-0.47495201230049133,
0.28782984614372253,
0.0948798805475235,
-0.5298724174499512,
0.4300333559513092,
-0.7972415685653687,
0.4829384684562683,
0.3266553282737732,
-0.6480543613433838,
-0.19463993608951569,
-0.6927547454833984,
-0.00897472444921732,
0.18389594554901123,
-0.27159562706947327,
0.041406743228435516,
0.3172895014286041,
-0.23113034665584564,
0.24377135932445526,
0.026569198817014694,
-0.4065355658531189,
0.39862340688705444,
-0.1503186821937561,
0.5486730933189392,
0.9025313258171082,
-0.4866847097873688,
0.5973382592201233,
-0.17316244542598724,
0.781299352645874,
-0.5087987184524536,
0.15459313988685608,
-0.08939670026302338,
-0.2641999125480652,
-1.2026158571243286,
-0.33656057715415955,
0.3057628870010376,
0.4993945062160492,
-0.84297114610672,
0.35622403025627136,
-0.08923009037971497,
-0.5603266358375549,
-0.3033970892429352,
-0.3003799319267273,
-0.03223959729075432,
0.39910054206848145,
0.31362128257751465,
0.3960113823413849,
-0.38231784105300903,
-0.8426831364631653,
-0.33311840891838074,
0.06495478004217148,
0.1512303203344345,
0.34810853004455566,
0.4309653043746948,
0.01987883448600769,
0.9645007252693176,
-0.6957353949546814,
0.29227104783058167,
-0.6680678725242615,
-0.09886237233877182,
0.4910980463027954,
0.3638877272605896,
0.6404628157615662,
-0.8023619055747986,
-0.600821852684021,
-0.32473114132881165,
-0.5871972441673279,
-0.28996312618255615,
-0.6772077083587646,
-0.10297327488660812,
-0.15447048842906952,
0.39722853899002075,
-0.9227650761604309,
0.38152140378952026,
0.5420145988464355,
-0.19281037151813507,
0.4633219242095947,
-0.39389076828956604,
-0.04216728359460831,
-0.31026819348335266,
0.2277848869562149,
-0.23066039383411407,
-0.28181329369544983,
-0.8082535266876221,
0.08575653284788132,
0.10779275000095367,
-0.4720490872859955,
-0.17822517454624176,
0.2447645217180252,
-0.3058934211730957,
0.108664371073246,
-0.3134491741657257,
-0.045154739171266556,
-0.12092066556215286,
0.5772178173065186,
-0.09368421882390976,
0.9557467103004456,
0.39568260312080383,
-0.6378871202468872,
0.3294101059436798,
0.1377447098493576,
-0.30931219458580017,
0.0922335758805275,
-0.7936983704566956,
0.2375158965587616,
-0.23983894288539886,
0.30760154128074646,
-0.8066321611404419,
0.123863585293293,
-0.03322095051407814,
0.21791166067123413,
0.4084956645965576,
0.16303302347660065,
-0.5863431692123413,
-0.7576985359191895,
-0.07212017476558685,
0.4865759611129761,
0.6664074063301086,
-0.9481422305107117,
0.5598206520080566,
0.24811117351055145,
0.244949609041214,
-0.7881097793579102,
-0.63111811876297,
-0.19871903955936432,
-0.21146132051944733,
-0.5605387687683105,
0.5138578414916992,
0.08837661892175674,
-0.27864870429039,
0.048678942024707794,
-0.4448626935482025,
0.06574668735265732,
0.25992128252983093,
-0.11635665595531464,
0.11168504506349564,
0.12622074782848358,
0.28063690662384033,
-0.03564945235848427,
-0.5459232330322266,
0.024691229686141014,
-0.06247243285179138,
0.6977927088737488,
-0.324917733669281,
-0.38143154978752136,
-0.3791360855102539,
0.4345841407775879,
0.5561029314994812,
-0.13384374976158142,
0.8099319934844971,
0.39062950015068054,
-0.2664254605770111,
-0.49035975337028503,
-0.5667126178741455,
-0.08556012809276581,
-0.5854434370994568,
0.14872629940509796,
-0.3940202295780182,
-0.5730466246604919,
0.447226881980896,
-0.1811572015285492,
0.17402492463588715,
0.5480069518089294,
0.43898341059684753,
0.19864636659622192,
1.1081433296203613,
0.7113074064254761,
0.4198033809661865,
0.44609445333480835,
-0.7190073728561401,
0.8434081077575684,
-0.4820443391799927,
-0.04491691291332245,
-0.7215627431869507,
-0.6834579110145569,
-0.762662410736084,
-0.5437288284301758,
0.5179800391197205,
-0.10051173716783524,
-0.2087821066379547,
0.830977737903595,
-0.913051962852478,
0.5955134630203247,
0.2964525818824768,
-0.22919167578220367,
0.06215051934123039,
-0.3232189118862152,
0.09204906970262527,
0.13402169942855835,
-1.127232313156128,
-0.5213168859481812,
0.5047997236251831,
0.2667178809642792,
0.9592384696006775,
-0.050580210983753204,
0.2812720239162445,
-0.008328312076628208,
-0.07295359671115875,
-0.8477128148078918,
0.6963106989860535,
-0.20577472448349,
-0.5080448389053345,
-0.26118209958076477,
-0.7035070657730103,
-1.1568512916564941,
0.08460401743650436,
-0.23017294704914093,
-0.6615955233573914,
0.4761766791343689,
0.31576916575431824,
-0.40057218074798584,
0.7640016078948975,
-0.7242544293403625,
0.6857689023017883,
-0.3364563286304474,
-0.24611802399158478,
-0.4009541869163513,
-0.48538610339164734,
0.13918599486351013,
-0.18726509809494019,
-0.08686568588018417,
-0.03323226049542427,
0.04842650517821312,
0.4179760217666626,
-0.4725077748298645,
0.31777289509773254,
-0.15121422708034515,
0.047814708203077316,
0.5183529853820801,
0.1344548761844635,
0.5444022417068481,
-0.26773810386657715,
-0.3504098355770111,
-0.08277716487646103,
-0.15144523978233337,
-0.17090967297554016,
-0.9792560338973999,
0.6058947443962097,
-0.5091741681098938,
-0.7043554782867432,
-0.4123997688293457,
-0.7616596221923828,
-0.12720999121665955,
-0.025041116401553154,
0.03432315215468407,
0.5701158046722412,
0.22351352870464325,
0.29523906111717224,
0.5911814570426941,
-0.44343701004981995,
0.6897475123405457,
0.09912010282278061,
0.19632607698440552,
0.1406499594449997,
0.7299543023109436,
0.4362059533596039,
0.3812185525894165,
0.3647671639919281,
0.22029756009578705,
-0.3429690897464752,
-0.1833481341600418,
-0.43525850772857666,
0.18305616080760956,
-1.0281565189361572,
-0.37013953924179077,
-0.7691537141799927,
-0.13336506485939026,
0.1703108698129654,
-0.5368525385856628,
-0.580333411693573,
-0.9721320867538452,
0.1578705757856369,
0.005973771680146456,
0.31702905893325806,
0.7694810628890991,
0.07010070979595184,
0.15883991122245789,
-0.5677404403686523,
0.5075682401657104,
0.5427806973457336,
0.49727869033813477,
0.4658483564853668,
-0.0734410211443901,
-0.2720241844654083,
-0.1983380913734436,
-0.5315544009208679,
-0.7304823398590088,
0.264987975358963,
-0.15595921874046326,
0.7551177740097046,
0.20783652365207672,
0.35318994522094727,
0.5930070281028748,
-0.5814324617385864,
0.6444545388221741,
0.2077394425868988,
-1.0354505777359009,
0.1257534772157669,
0.008845156989991665,
0.34176865220069885,
0.39168891310691833,
0.4620286822319031,
-0.20903527736663818,
-0.342238187789917,
-0.6979508399963379,
-0.843652069568634,
0.7157200574874878,
0.6471045613288879,
0.27240464091300964,
-0.12892067432403564,
0.3627926707267761,
0.10998204350471497,
0.1364726424217224,
-0.4248462915420532,
-0.17161482572555542,
-0.2547547221183777,
-0.03917507454752922,
0.23498791456222534,
-0.1309008002281189,
0.16281233727931976,
-0.5746908783912659,
0.30351316928863525,
0.10285341739654541,
0.6280505061149597,
-0.053608592599630356,
0.010383094660937786,
-0.10758201032876968,
0.29452937841415405,
0.2675588130950928,
0.6645783185958862,
0.10518264770507812,
0.37661024928092957,
0.44991132616996765,
-0.2614133656024933,
0.35853374004364014,
-0.10566799342632294,
0.03746270388364792,
0.05367179587483406,
0.15462885797023773,
0.8114609718322754,
0.25123947858810425,
-0.8875894546508789,
0.2747975289821625,
-0.22348681092262268,
0.057560957968235016,
-0.35581064224243164,
0.2864127457141876,
0.10252755880355835,
0.2181900292634964,
0.1678161323070526,
0.5929522514343262,
0.20222270488739014,
-0.5246924161911011,
-0.04757704958319664,
0.3081896901130676,
-0.03905671462416649,
-0.07275954633951187,
0.8091492652893066,
0.23565776646137238,
-0.6115372776985168,
0.845269501209259,
0.004019396845251322,
-0.6741374135017395,
0.7468863725662231,
0.5870562195777893,
0.879684329032898,
0.030573459342122078,
0.11381882429122925,
0.2957819402217865,
0.2180253118276596,
-0.26392844319343567,
-0.13150767982006073,
-0.3464915156364441,
-0.6531087756156921,
-0.4514804482460022,
-0.5085113644599915,
-0.5352955460548401,
-0.13708607852458954,
-0.47029024362564087,
0.48431187868118286,
-0.38631290197372437,
-0.43309637904167175,
0.1083303913474083,
-0.2667447030544281,
-0.8592503666877747,
0.06900869309902191,
0.008190168999135494,
0.915635883808136,
-0.430640310049057,
0.5132038593292236,
0.2116139531135559,
0.03671569004654884,
-1.2154970169067383,
-0.08121532201766968,
-0.46389132738113403,
-0.6124702095985413,
0.6905384063720703,
0.33328351378440857,
-0.4777381122112274,
-0.24788770079612732,
-0.19436229765415192,
-0.9890714287757874,
0.9634525775909424,
0.7689140439033508,
-0.5937960743904114,
-0.2671459913253784,
0.18629559874534607,
0.684825599193573,
-0.030784109607338905,
0.47669777274131775,
0.7089979648590088,
0.6047473549842834,
0.04535726457834244,
-0.9539017677307129,
0.10757381469011307,
-0.34416237473487854,
0.05596395209431648,
0.7313111424446106,
-0.6514898538589478,
0.9873914122581482,
-0.23644492030143738,
-0.25076034665107727,
0.002140382071956992,
0.2468191236257553,
-0.25759074091911316,
0.018903644755482674,
0.9999223351478577,
0.3683776259422302,
0.6527974605560303,
-0.24681346118450165,
1.372026801109314,
-0.550072968006134,
0.44698190689086914,
0.44305258989334106,
-0.146327406167984,
0.40257060527801514,
0.22973297536373138,
-0.26747003197669983,
0.5790870189666748,
-0.005769718904048204,
-0.10557849705219269,
0.2762618362903595,
0.41884687542915344,
-0.21614986658096313,
-0.5116258263587952,
0.15027937293052673,
-0.05789298936724663,
0.7866935133934021,
0.18783317506313324,
-0.20403355360031128,
-0.2667497992515564,
-0.1256588101387024,
0.031812943518161774,
0.2093140333890915,
-0.014075848273932934,
0.3221592605113983,
0.0026185803581029177,
-0.9416913986206055,
0.9891165494918823,
-0.08899535983800888,
0.35050714015960693,
-0.5413554310798645,
-0.054120562970638275,
0.1399591565132141,
0.4639720022678375,
-0.15853162109851837,
-0.6327962279319763,
0.8022772669792175,
0.21445195376873016,
-0.09129698574542999,
-0.8666099309921265,
0.8126725554466248,
-0.05441869795322418,
-0.4688189625740051,
0.15864357352256775,
0.39269691705703735,
-0.021997220814228058,
0.16973845660686493,
-0.5060760974884033,
0.013599695637822151,
-0.04953070357441902,
-0.2947271466255188,
0.09801547229290009,
0.29175662994384766,
0.13412824273109436,
0.9150024056434631,
0.26664048433303833,
0.0278010256588459,
-0.11665037274360657,
-0.009742099791765213,
0.9794345498085022,
-0.5680487155914307,
-0.3622240126132965,
-0.6859940886497498,
0.46687811613082886,
-0.1493115872144699,
-0.02156669832766056,
0.5598084926605225,
0.3351135849952698,
0.5678588151931763,
-0.13518880307674408,
0.6009697914123535,
-0.13165326416492462,
0.32366907596588135,
-0.386971652507782,
0.40822097659111023,
-0.3640902638435364,
0.5541454553604126,
-0.3243618905544281,
-0.9872891306877136,
-0.038587626069784164,
0.8441745638847351,
-0.33851921558380127,
0.027798065915703773,
0.9735569357872009,
0.4530031383037567,
-0.1822306215763092,
0.15413357317447662,
0.2006264179944992,
-0.024867644533514977,
0.5138787031173706,
0.6094984412193298,
1.0300239324569702,
-0.06418667733669281,
0.6790799498558044,
-0.6324171423912048,
-0.2975047528743744,
0.06947802752256393,
-0.8151369094848633,
-0.588981032371521,
-0.5522938370704651,
-0.13375335931777954,
-0.06489204615354538,
-0.17757666110992432,
0.8523879647254944,
0.5071490406990051,
-0.458249032497406,
-0.15794134140014648,
-0.4610236585140228,
0.25203967094421387,
-0.49660027027130127,
-0.19454994797706604,
0.22063793241977692,
-0.5871222615242004,
-0.8525243997573853,
0.22135621309280396,
0.24019958078861237,
-0.03303910046815872,
-0.19003431499004364,
0.25315865874290466,
0.2895442247390747,
0.44775906205177307,
0.7377058267593384,
0.03675992041826248,
-0.2969586253166199,
-0.5496111512184143,
0.4062374234199524,
0.17454832792282104,
-0.139346644282341,
1.3147141933441162,
-1.0878660678863525,
0.298009991645813,
0.7665509581565857,
0.6594390869140625,
0.520258367061615,
-0.08464644104242325,
0.647017240524292,
-0.2986448407173157,
0.39938288927078247,
0.5023953914642334,
0.5658905506134033,
0.16093845665454865,
-0.2759403586387634,
0.5140011310577393,
0.13472120463848114,
-0.9038757085800171,
-0.9314746260643005,
0.538388192653656,
-1.1367005109786987,
-0.3215375542640686,
1.1399540901184082,
-0.14768940210342407,
0.17235177755355835,
-0.06711877137422562,
-0.29851168394088745,
0.2862911522388458,
-0.009735030122101307,
0.8956273198127747,
0.3390691876411438,
-0.4719581604003906,
-0.08355268090963364,
-0.4370496869087219,
0.48519229888916016,
0.4920319616794586,
-0.5032528042793274,
0.2999013662338257,
0.044579215347766876,
-0.1886509209871292,
0.3552389144897461,
0.4106563329696655,
0.2988564372062683,
0.08355879783630371,
0.3739526867866516,
-0.36983171105384827,
0.07565376907587051,
-0.5856100916862488,
0.029427850618958473,
0.1438567191362381,
0.03659287840127945,
0.1284007728099823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13926v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13926v1
|
Large Language Models are Vulnerable to Bait-and-Switch Attacks for Generating Harmful Content
| 2024-02-21T16:46:36 | 2024-02-21T16:46:36 |
Federico Bianchi, James Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The risks derived from large language models (LLMs) generating deceptive and
damaging content have been the subject of considerable research, but even safe
generations can lead to problematic downstream impacts. In our study, we shift
the focus to how even safe text coming from LLMs can be easily turned into
potentially dangerous content through Bait-and-Switch attacks. In such attacks,
the user first prompts LLMs with safe questions and then employs a simple
find-and-replace post-hoc technique to manipulate the outputs into harmful
narratives. The alarming efficacy of this approach in generating toxic content
highlights a significant challenge in developing reliable safety guardrails for
LLMs. In particular, we stress that focusing on the safety of the verbatim LLM
outputs is insufficient and that we also need to consider post-hoc
transformations.
|
[
-0.13426117599010468,
-0.8977095484733582,
0.4987480342388153,
-0.08253215253353119,
-0.5050185918807983,
-0.06809457391500473,
0.05515548586845398,
-0.525739848613739,
-0.08416222035884857,
1.0464975833892822,
-0.26026254892349243,
-0.31874504685401917,
-0.901151716709137,
-0.18637554347515106,
-0.7650687098503113,
1.221793532371521,
-0.15210838615894318,
-0.20736776292324066,
0.31812337040901184,
0.2555730640888214,
-0.4287405014038086,
-0.6635366678237915,
-1.0015273094177246,
0.10106926411390305,
0.8882196545600891,
0.11890178918838501,
0.8277300596237183,
0.3369273543357849,
0.5876156091690063,
0.10018248111009598,
-0.13381390273571014,
-0.19461138546466827,
-0.8841207027435303,
0.4160533845424652,
-0.5844157338142395,
-0.37316256761550903,
-0.503989040851593,
0.03028624877333641,
0.3562552034854889,
0.49106916785240173,
-0.015699373558163643,
-0.01981397159397602,
0.17772957682609558,
0.40853312611579895,
-0.6112902164459229,
-0.09456386417150497,
-1.1691677570343018,
-0.135026216506958,
-0.5408687591552734,
-0.5397579669952393,
-0.9737656712532043,
-0.2868965268135071,
-0.10879231244325638,
-0.04728913679718971,
-0.26282671093940735,
0.21512633562088013,
0.768216073513031,
-0.07430815696716309,
-0.9087002277374268,
-0.327506422996521,
-0.7758912444114685,
0.7531800270080566,
-0.740755021572113,
0.07270897179841995,
0.1281737983226776,
0.19604966044425964,
-0.46517810225486755,
-0.319894403219223,
-0.27977365255355835,
-0.039227262139320374,
0.13244780898094177,
-0.2259000986814499,
-0.4294576048851013,
0.01734868809580803,
0.22773416340351105,
-0.16703373193740845,
-0.4679400622844696,
0.360684871673584,
-0.5234203338623047,
-0.26375386118888855,
1.0090762376785278,
0.3851277232170105,
0.7051903009414673,
-0.44218868017196655,
-0.6284105777740479,
-0.28449004888534546,
-1.322376012802124,
-0.20706558227539062,
0.6904610991477966,
0.5400343537330627,
0.06430479884147644,
0.6588428020477295,
0.38370493054389954,
0.32713934779167175,
-0.05332712084054947,
-0.15485331416130066,
-0.12719586491584778,
-0.18971875309944153,
0.06742440909147263,
0.272742360830307,
1.0178827047348022,
0.6785693168640137,
0.42296940088272095,
-0.08359193056821823,
-0.29224830865859985,
0.03876690939068794,
0.6454126238822937,
-0.6945052742958069,
-0.07769981771707535,
0.2882583439350128,
-0.25843098759651184,
-0.6345630884170532,
0.01714988984167576,
-0.9418190717697144,
-0.6165468096733093,
0.2692011594772339,
0.49464869499206543,
-0.401345431804657,
-0.34794875979423523,
0.4781387150287628,
0.18954575061798096,
0.2527085840702057,
0.26019248366355896,
-0.7039209008216858,
0.25480130314826965,
0.6324626207351685,
0.5960408449172974,
-0.414426326751709,
-0.08367371559143066,
-0.8010422587394714,
0.5552367568016052,
-0.6339616775512695,
0.5260053277015686,
-0.22891715168952942,
-0.7517032027244568,
0.4261844754219055,
0.0787578597664833,
0.11882094293832779,
-0.3918062150478363,
0.6331426501274109,
-0.970467209815979,
0.13342617452144623,
-0.16749118268489838,
-0.17828935384750366,
0.04887700825929642,
0.10463667660951614,
-0.7984705567359924,
0.5574231743812561,
-0.3533979058265686,
-1.1523619890213013,
0.06754083186388016,
-0.11839176714420319,
-0.7414469718933105,
-0.32082733511924744,
0.1521402895450592,
-0.3514908254146576,
-0.10681279003620148,
-0.15004169940948486,
0.44027191400527954,
-0.06705790758132935,
0.2947937548160553,
-0.28060802817344666,
-0.07408525049686432,
0.4561253786087036,
-0.6665626168251038,
0.7153357267379761,
0.18200421333312988,
-0.4382382035255432,
0.26065072417259216,
-0.21738243103027344,
-0.3051906228065491,
0.31105419993400574,
-0.5930571556091309,
-0.477254718542099,
0.24572543799877167,
0.2179294377565384,
0.53672856092453,
0.12208908051252365,
-0.3346835970878601,
-0.0799744501709938,
-0.29485541582107544,
0.12347432971000671,
1.0123376846313477,
0.292865514755249,
0.31401050090789795,
-0.4386213421821594,
0.6613402962684631,
0.21637757122516632,
0.3174029290676117,
0.014272770844399929,
-0.5629417300224304,
-0.5044384598731995,
0.2923298478126526,
-0.0610620379447937,
0.5093795657157898,
-0.9785356521606445,
0.12938091158866882,
-0.2842886447906494,
-0.5534286499023438,
-0.13101884722709656,
0.12918636202812195,
0.40041548013687134,
0.275922954082489,
0.24258524179458618,
-0.19644607603549957,
-0.4648859202861786,
-0.6007948517799377,
-0.5201160907745361,
-0.33648592233657837,
0.08670531213283539,
-0.09470589458942413,
0.4428784251213074,
-0.3257066011428833,
0.5761460661888123,
-0.5216047167778015,
0.10578353703022003,
-0.4049535393714905,
0.10500610619783401,
0.028857599943876266,
0.48237431049346924,
0.63641357421875,
-0.6611304879188538,
-0.5842702388763428,
-0.24721316993236542,
-0.5125870704650879,
-0.011117758229374886,
-0.4669308364391327,
-0.3396976888179779,
0.15745539963245392,
0.7823360562324524,
-0.807682991027832,
0.21811741590499878,
0.4477301836013794,
-0.34648534655570984,
0.7688602209091187,
0.2056848257780075,
0.1462193876504898,
-1.0725053548812866,
-0.011153372004628181,
-0.0970953181385994,
-0.0816088616847992,
-0.878593385219574,
0.18012352287769318,
-0.014193229377269745,
0.06336323171854019,
-0.8923022150993347,
0.5025531053543091,
-0.30996808409690857,
0.3793547451496124,
-0.12346816807985306,
0.07681826502084732,
-0.025556519627571106,
-0.0019464405486360192,
-0.30901437997817993,
0.5089076161384583,
0.4858333170413971,
-0.4772224426269531,
0.1260528713464737,
0.3185112178325653,
-0.32029643654823303,
0.4028684198856354,
-0.553435742855072,
0.12060482800006866,
-0.2592935562133789,
0.26926764845848083,
-0.848391592502594,
-0.3553575873374939,
0.49157077074050903,
-0.21514028310775757,
0.5646995306015015,
-0.15622088313102722,
-0.6001735925674438,
-0.06795721501111984,
-0.7666831612586975,
0.28457877039909363,
0.6071589589118958,
-0.39443910121917725,
0.24339263141155243,
0.6289057731628418,
-0.5558561682701111,
-0.5246009230613708,
-0.7660413384437561,
0.4487115740776062,
-0.5879882574081421,
-0.5531283617019653,
0.07924990355968475,
0.10011966526508331,
-0.41071295738220215,
-0.14593586325645447,
0.04684785008430481,
0.31804952025413513,
0.22122949361801147,
0.16563890874385834,
0.30896493792533875,
0.05926969647407532,
0.09309951215982437,
0.07903648912906647,
-0.17962250113487244,
0.524848461151123,
0.13824869692325592,
0.6545588970184326,
0.21577228605747223,
-0.5032790303230286,
-0.028614353388547897,
0.6871793270111084,
0.7391106486320496,
-0.2669656574726105,
0.9206432104110718,
0.1906774789094925,
-0.20037168264389038,
-0.4974803328514099,
-0.1499973088502884,
-0.1305800974369049,
-0.4932360351085663,
0.6315413117408752,
0.14323636889457703,
-0.9465106725692749,
0.24494925141334534,
-0.04384521022439003,
0.29565730690956116,
0.504630982875824,
0.3564153015613556,
-0.0984567180275917,
1.1826834678649902,
0.3717201054096222,
-0.01340648252516985,
0.3920983076095581,
0.1235620304942131,
0.5137408971786499,
-0.5361165404319763,
-0.24278752505779266,
-0.40391087532043457,
0.0010961772641167045,
-0.5880987644195557,
-0.45786628127098083,
0.4488227069377899,
-0.08549454808235168,
-0.3544318675994873,
0.3616810142993927,
-0.12494698166847229,
0.32445862889289856,
0.26601672172546387,
0.11666490882635117,
0.26815876364707947,
0.0808158740401268,
0.10969868302345276,
-0.20599889755249023,
-0.600468635559082,
-0.8720424175262451,
1.1971142292022705,
0.41835111379623413,
1.4709463119506836,
0.38853105902671814,
0.6323509216308594,
0.2808096408843994,
0.3914376199245453,
-0.6595366597175598,
0.8065366744995117,
-0.09827501326799393,
-0.906329333782196,
-0.24906586110591888,
-0.40201422572135925,
-1.271835446357727,
0.22179660201072693,
-0.28125494718551636,
-0.802884042263031,
-0.37758949398994446,
0.05408366769552231,
-0.14663726091384888,
0.9447895288467407,
-0.6749805808067322,
0.6167898774147034,
-0.4988272190093994,
-0.45089638233184814,
-0.1827041059732437,
-0.6161314249038696,
0.7779149413108826,
-0.379465252161026,
0.6027605533599854,
-0.003833313472568989,
0.049315713346004486,
0.661553680896759,
-0.0861247330904007,
1.173284888267517,
0.14092139899730682,
-0.5792586207389832,
0.33566638827323914,
0.6998245120048523,
0.5800854563713074,
-0.1875256597995758,
-0.01141123753041029,
0.04404633864760399,
-0.21519698202610016,
-0.2954970896244049,
-0.21947303414344788,
0.6908495426177979,
-0.5672683119773865,
-1.1937785148620605,
-0.5243451595306396,
-0.3931015431880951,
-0.13834555447101593,
0.2652119994163513,
0.0778622180223465,
0.3266462981700897,
-0.13840991258621216,
0.07108480483293533,
0.9561553001403809,
-0.5648515820503235,
0.42039862275123596,
0.155262291431427,
-0.38723453879356384,
-0.27327901124954224,
0.6944398880004883,
0.042115215212106705,
0.6824563145637512,
0.12651008367538452,
-0.0611744187772274,
-0.3536430299282074,
-0.8354761600494385,
-0.18425844609737396,
0.2932019829750061,
-0.8044120073318481,
-0.19484421610832214,
-0.5985546112060547,
-0.33816641569137573,
-0.3406537175178528,
-0.34775108098983765,
-0.2725086510181427,
0.10956648737192154,
-0.3681516647338867,
-0.3939235806465149,
0.24909576773643494,
0.8563302159309387,
-0.033043794333934784,
0.2362060695886612,
-1.0936610698699951,
0.05196370184421539,
0.3606932461261749,
0.14586985111236572,
-0.02975326031446457,
-0.4550609886646271,
-0.12523461878299713,
-0.12693855166435242,
-0.3110957145690918,
-1.2969025373458862,
0.21538296341896057,
-0.30274370312690735,
0.5980333089828491,
0.5883040428161621,
0.4086263179779053,
-0.08618398755788803,
-0.7111597657203674,
0.8316794633865356,
0.4443252384662628,
-0.6704273223876953,
0.5957223773002625,
-0.789771556854248,
0.07879171520471573,
0.3482646048069,
0.6962004899978638,
-0.6130070090293884,
-0.46205365657806396,
-0.5720534920692444,
-0.9748833775520325,
0.5750598907470703,
0.08534787595272064,
0.5711511373519897,
-0.3772122859954834,
-0.08071175217628479,
0.2186354547739029,
0.15586790442466736,
-0.9819587469100952,
-0.019670585170388222,
0.11430248618125916,
-0.02404772862792015,
-0.07432135194540024,
-0.7470313310623169,
-0.3427056670188904,
0.32762235403060913,
0.7522096633911133,
0.11735578626394272,
-0.16880430281162262,
-0.25342845916748047,
-0.09826286882162094,
-0.387218713760376,
0.5782725214958191,
0.21932236850261688,
0.2831389605998993,
-0.10394822806119919,
0.7853051424026489,
-0.0015271921874955297,
-0.4114123284816742,
0.22439004480838776,
-0.3851798474788666,
-0.33588895201683044,
-0.1533101350069046,
0.508412778377533,
0.6912757158279419,
0.4931534230709076,
-0.8701527118682861,
0.5604042410850525,
0.23620295524597168,
-0.025015581399202347,
0.10650505125522614,
0.21324901282787323,
0.28665709495544434,
-0.04325008764863014,
0.06866391748189926,
0.12624995410442352,
-0.22037789225578308,
-0.7397847175598145,
0.37448933720588684,
0.476473867893219,
-0.18786656856536865,
-0.36628246307373047,
0.7384856343269348,
0.3088759779930115,
-0.2698970139026642,
0.24934284389019012,
0.03145745024085045,
-0.5518405437469482,
0.28851521015167236,
0.5672448873519897,
0.7983183264732361,
-0.46972790360450745,
0.42707836627960205,
0.405918151140213,
0.7807897329330444,
-0.016090450808405876,
0.1888674795627594,
0.6398701667785645,
-0.6668252348899841,
-0.22000329196453094,
-0.38090312480926514,
-0.2866092622280121,
0.26339584589004517,
-0.6325762271881104,
0.28539541363716125,
-0.5588906407356262,
-0.25109705328941345,
-0.31572943925857544,
-0.6423189640045166,
-0.07560519129037857,
0.05317521467804909,
0.3718269169330597,
0.7160385251045227,
-1.0114396810531616,
0.4891643226146698,
0.5109097361564636,
-0.2160542607307434,
-0.713251531124115,
0.2870391011238098,
0.02345147170126438,
-0.40897366404533386,
0.4545271396636963,
0.04352580010890961,
-0.21243101358413696,
-0.2775256037712097,
-0.7532171010971069,
-0.8006133437156677,
0.5746743083000183,
0.48295408487319946,
-0.4362491965293884,
-0.15133309364318848,
0.5756129026412964,
0.3143143355846405,
0.1212158277630806,
-0.21340827643871307,
0.4144347608089447,
0.22590328752994537,
0.13036666810512543,
-0.7718368172645569,
0.5035563707351685,
-0.04548189043998718,
-0.018669215962290764,
0.28746265172958374,
-0.6079394817352295,
1.0282961130142212,
-0.19984766840934753,
-0.43799084424972534,
-0.4068765342235565,
0.16432549059391022,
0.3697545826435089,
-0.045475561171770096,
0.580933690071106,
0.2531681954860687,
0.29756399989128113,
0.10881975293159485,
1.0247383117675781,
-0.028281323611736298,
0.22437308728694916,
1.0366406440734863,
-0.3952999711036682,
1.1645857095718384,
0.801922082901001,
-0.11903886497020721,
0.32105138897895813,
0.47199735045433044,
0.15336990356445312,
0.6146088242530823,
0.361124724149704,
-0.2963542938232422,
-0.465717613697052,
0.08967657387256622,
-0.32728493213653564,
0.21815955638885498,
0.38025394082069397,
-0.3544526994228363,
-0.4594910144805908,
-0.04359683766961098,
0.8354306817054749,
0.07499664276838303,
-0.20376789569854736,
0.5106288194656372,
0.31559106707572937,
-0.5305891633033752,
0.44474947452545166,
0.08413165807723999,
0.7675737738609314,
-0.6943182349205017,
0.10455077141523361,
0.0589681938290596,
-0.0104853929951787,
-0.12782366573810577,
-0.9053043127059937,
0.503061830997467,
0.23421838879585266,
0.2725517451763153,
-0.44631484150886536,
0.8679137229919434,
-0.24736416339874268,
-0.3623274862766266,
0.6117459535598755,
0.46440157294273376,
-0.028562648221850395,
0.061778660863637924,
-0.35856837034225464,
0.22690041363239288,
-0.0022216651123017073,
-0.4821612238883972,
0.6355115175247192,
0.2606465816497803,
-0.23499628901481628,
0.6366426944732666,
0.691704273223877,
0.09171352535486221,
0.27206599712371826,
-0.2370462566614151,
1.0268194675445557,
-0.5797783136367798,
-0.39657798409461975,
-0.9102486968040466,
0.6915378570556641,
-0.010913891717791557,
-0.09146429598331451,
0.8622082471847534,
0.297907292842865,
0.8868969678878784,
-0.21960099041461945,
0.9409608244895935,
0.10353555530309677,
0.25448131561279297,
-0.7750661373138428,
1.2593281269073486,
-0.41695570945739746,
0.45913004875183105,
-0.49687114357948303,
-0.5422328114509583,
-0.3497759997844696,
-0.002396550728008151,
-0.5098448395729065,
-0.14193348586559296,
0.7255942225456238,
0.8790795207023621,
0.10481095314025879,
-0.3068484961986542,
0.2702309787273407,
0.5861369371414185,
0.7179544568061829,
0.6654834747314453,
1.1174755096435547,
-0.3547520339488983,
0.941896378993988,
0.21458150446414948,
-0.08254951983690262,
-0.3895047903060913,
-0.9451392292976379,
-1.1567217111587524,
-0.40399548411369324,
-0.3756830096244812,
-0.686439573764801,
0.12393797188997269,
0.4512655735015869,
0.3244182765483856,
-0.7825649976730347,
-0.22739870846271515,
0.2035880833864212,
0.16224291920661926,
0.36105039715766907,
-0.20080755650997162,
0.28471639752388,
-0.03443113714456558,
-0.5071853995323181,
0.2760940492153168,
0.22245165705680847,
0.20436009764671326,
-0.4921013414859772,
0.010177579708397388,
-0.2567555904388428,
0.3246013820171356,
0.5819068551063538,
0.07929030805826187,
-0.6404879093170166,
-0.6702044010162354,
-0.15869520604610443,
-0.5430331826210022,
-0.22006581723690033,
0.5428032875061035,
-0.12094840407371521,
0.22013719379901886,
0.41194015741348267,
0.647032618522644,
0.22425363957881927,
-0.24930723011493683,
0.644668698310852,
-0.49123433232307434,
-0.004884721245616674,
0.2075507640838623,
0.4171011745929718,
0.4103454053401947,
-0.5024861097335815,
0.16598084568977356,
0.03913765028119087,
-0.25835496187210083,
-0.9018558263778687,
0.5682834982872009,
-1.1006776094436646,
-0.4218037724494934,
1.7326844930648804,
-0.16183708608150482,
-0.3431721329689026,
-0.22324813902378082,
-0.5991491079330444,
0.1526413857936859,
-0.1355535387992859,
1.01153564453125,
0.5778816938400269,
0.1858254075050354,
0.024743767455220222,
-0.7010785341262817,
0.6080992817878723,
0.2101840376853943,
-1.0241928100585938,
0.06766051799058914,
0.414643794298172,
0.538087010383606,
0.012935813516378403,
0.3390732705593109,
-0.4719240069389343,
0.06472261250019073,
0.1594938337802887,
0.04501385614275932,
0.22474618256092072,
-0.2978448271751404,
-0.0845930278301239,
0.4030342996120453,
0.14785262942314148,
0.06275548785924911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14643v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14643v2
|
Exploring ChatGPT and its Impact on Society
| 2024-02-21T16:44:35 | 2024-03-25T05:35:12 |
Md. Asraful Haque, Shuai Li
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, 68Txx
|
Artificial intelligence has been around for a while, but suddenly it has
received more attention than ever before. Thanks to innovations from companies
like Google, Microsoft, Meta, and other major brands in technology. OpenAI,
though, has triggered the button with its ground-breaking invention ChatGPT.
ChatGPT is a Large Language Model (LLM) based on Transformer architecture that
has the ability to generate human-like responses in a conversational context.
It uses deep learning algorithms to generate natural language responses to
input text. Its large number of parameters, contextual generation, and
open-domain training make it a versatile and effective tool for a wide range of
applications, from chatbots to customer service to language translation. It has
the potential to revolutionize various industries and transform the way we
interact with technology. However, the use of ChatGPT has also raised several
concerns, including ethical, social, and employment challenges, which must be
carefully considered to ensure the responsible use of this technology. The
article provides an overview of ChatGPT, delving into its architecture and
training process. It highlights the potential impacts of ChatGPT on the
society. In this paper, we suggest some approaches involving technology,
regulation, education, and ethics in an effort to maximize ChatGPT's benefits
while minimizing its negative impacts. This study is expected to contribute to
a greater understanding of ChatGPT and aid in predicting the potential changes
it may bring about.
|
[
-0.4267862141132355,
-0.8404257893562317,
0.18544337153434753,
-0.09928898513317108,
0.015049598179757595,
0.16853709518909454,
-0.10259263962507248,
-0.5752211809158325,
-0.0867021381855011,
0.4176223874092102,
-0.32616543769836426,
0.09303818643093109,
-0.7372015118598938,
-0.24289420247077942,
-0.4034450352191925,
1.0533337593078613,
0.27975594997406006,
-0.024564310908317566,
0.25998541712760925,
0.15059518814086914,
-0.46066805720329285,
-0.8894951343536377,
-0.9062070846557617,
-0.5122454762458801,
0.35071811079978943,
0.31864944100379944,
0.7157109379768372,
0.2690439224243164,
0.5529778003692627,
0.2969202399253845,
-0.280118852853775,
-0.30723392963409424,
-0.8225955367088318,
-0.23717579245567322,
0.28652504086494446,
-0.5008341670036316,
-0.2692371904850006,
0.27988797426223755,
0.5121200084686279,
0.4312089681625366,
-0.13213850557804108,
0.1440669149160385,
0.2258286476135254,
0.5816487669944763,
-0.20353442430496216,
0.3514077365398407,
-0.494968056678772,
0.09129329770803452,
-0.3100704550743103,
-0.16858509182929993,
-0.1174079030752182,
-0.45200014114379883,
0.3068569600582123,
-0.03141145408153534,
0.04256599396467209,
-0.07244839519262314,
0.6683332324028015,
0.2777554988861084,
-0.4511120021343231,
-0.33945557475090027,
-0.942969024181366,
0.5655348300933838,
-0.47271728515625,
0.5010688900947571,
0.03556695953011513,
0.5001217722892761,
-0.3382999897003174,
-0.8589041233062744,
-0.5403845310211182,
-0.2161436527967453,
-0.007664223201572895,
0.23580430448055267,
-0.041980769485235214,
-0.03246830031275749,
0.09993557631969452,
0.4663008749485016,
-0.518077552318573,
0.00995156541466713,
-0.7561902403831482,
-0.06335914134979248,
0.39684566855430603,
0.07650148868560791,
0.6177627444267273,
-0.05066434666514397,
-0.26070791482925415,
-0.018109967932105064,
-0.9387264847755432,
0.13526462018489838,
0.5291019678115845,
0.22017237544059753,
0.06222071498632431,
0.5781123042106628,
-0.11358202248811722,
0.3024587333202362,
-0.3171783983707428,
0.21296437084674835,
-0.050872404128313065,
0.0034125663805752993,
-0.21221698820590973,
0.21795441210269928,
0.7299690842628479,
0.12103011459112167,
0.5450620651245117,
-0.16976642608642578,
0.0062800259329378605,
0.22048445045948029,
0.4148657023906708,
-0.8620586395263672,
-0.12400320172309875,
0.07903827726840973,
-0.33452308177948,
-0.4632417857646942,
0.10609812289476395,
-0.7320564389228821,
-0.5080646872520447,
-0.3782675564289093,
0.07378599792718887,
-0.30339524149894714,
-0.31066834926605225,
0.12990222871303558,
0.09792597591876984,
0.7370215058326721,
0.3981391191482544,
-1.065570592880249,
0.14706848561763763,
1.1107531785964966,
0.9323121905326843,
0.07289741188287735,
-0.046390507370233536,
-0.15245318412780762,
-0.04699419438838959,
-0.09407688677310944,
0.7283133864402771,
-0.6228304505348206,
-0.5747692584991455,
-0.05613649636507034,
-0.22901813685894012,
-0.016103610396385193,
-0.27280235290527344,
0.33371874690055847,
-0.534359335899353,
0.3118038773536682,
0.08059228211641312,
-0.3168492913246155,
-0.18975910544395447,
0.42256659269332886,
-0.4463781714439392,
0.7480598092079163,
-0.3932075500488281,
-0.6859314441680908,
0.23183554410934448,
-1.1561298370361328,
-0.556422770023346,
0.46637603640556335,
-0.18765442073345184,
-0.32998141646385193,
-0.09461602568626404,
-0.017142925411462784,
0.3279675841331482,
-0.16536493599414825,
0.4023819863796234,
0.12227761745452881,
-0.44884219765663147,
0.40044596791267395,
-0.8620139360427856,
0.8768894076347351,
0.15537966787815094,
-0.3489867150783539,
-0.05056404322385788,
-0.47198235988616943,
-0.15439288318157196,
0.09811288118362427,
-0.3856925368309021,
-0.0013812393881380558,
0.0880807563662529,
0.15269722044467926,
0.12801556289196014,
0.10376980155706406,
-0.6329947710037231,
0.0809490755200386,
-0.44836506247520447,
1.0480271577835083,
0.8932890295982361,
0.10999533534049988,
0.31914764642715454,
-0.2944827675819397,
0.37825483083724976,
-0.3587411642074585,
0.5286434292793274,
-0.1583871841430664,
-0.8586751818656921,
-0.55771404504776,
0.10470695048570633,
0.20424751937389374,
0.642230749130249,
-0.31010398268699646,
0.06622447073459625,
-0.30947205424308777,
-0.6131476759910583,
-0.5266150236129761,
-0.368933767080307,
-0.07630988955497742,
0.2327432781457901,
-0.002172915730625391,
-0.36592286825180054,
-0.23996011912822723,
-0.639439046382904,
-0.27435722947120667,
-0.2781042456626892,
-0.1311759054660797,
0.38214725255966187,
0.4210904836654663,
-0.2374938726425171,
1.0026503801345825,
-0.48818400502204895,
-0.380692720413208,
-0.3430855870246887,
-0.03278452903032303,
0.1994432955980301,
0.4620163142681122,
-0.03344295546412468,
-1.0437918901443481,
-0.3757947087287903,
0.1592448651790619,
-0.49524015188217163,
0.14636750519275665,
-0.24071833491325378,
-0.1195107027888298,
-0.15338417887687683,
0.32843753695487976,
-0.7200582027435303,
0.40746447443962097,
0.33117279410362244,
-0.011018238961696625,
0.4766979217529297,
-0.11764493584632874,
0.30162039399147034,
-1.11854088306427,
0.24150080978870392,
-0.0866398960351944,
-0.00495021091774106,
-0.9397242069244385,
-0.129571333527565,
-0.25425535440444946,
-0.5851626396179199,
-0.6525967717170715,
0.6124173402786255,
0.04365319758653641,
-0.08243679255247116,
-0.22249636054039001,
0.17599788308143616,
-0.4414224624633789,
0.33325931429862976,
-0.024957925081253052,
0.9666965007781982,
0.2448890060186386,
-0.41851577162742615,
0.259417861700058,
0.47425928711891174,
-0.2387412190437317,
0.37844300270080566,
-0.8672173023223877,
0.4910615086555481,
-0.009920420125126839,
0.14374086260795593,
-0.6146246790885925,
-0.22373059391975403,
0.5309737920761108,
-0.6881416440010071,
-0.040563710033893585,
-0.015638917684555054,
-0.5378477573394775,
-0.1348501741886139,
-0.07989607006311417,
0.2357642501592636,
0.7121776938438416,
-0.4453621804714203,
0.4113287031650543,
0.6613272428512573,
-0.14391553401947021,
-0.384446382522583,
-0.7220321297645569,
0.4838699996471405,
-0.26589956879615784,
-0.7644599080085754,
0.07294536381959915,
0.07100991159677505,
-0.26264628767967224,
-0.32709622383117676,
0.0381506010890007,
-0.19037097692489624,
0.35001522302627563,
0.3790995478630066,
0.1910010129213333,
-0.05994005501270294,
0.14382334053516388,
-0.3501919209957123,
-0.4584026336669922,
0.09311605989933014,
-0.2666914761066437,
0.8875932693481445,
-0.5694049000740051,
-0.4502398371696472,
-0.3644236624240875,
0.21609975397586823,
0.4860101342201233,
-0.3724130094051361,
0.5226112008094788,
0.5568008422851562,
-0.1814693957567215,
0.13751360774040222,
-0.3817708194255829,
-0.2395356446504593,
-0.5344862937927246,
0.47743120789527893,
0.07200942933559418,
-0.9868195056915283,
0.2627840042114258,
-0.3340270221233368,
0.26647090911865234,
0.07712536305189133,
0.6450976133346558,
0.07340812683105469,
0.7674916982650757,
0.6984984278678894,
-0.24055065214633942,
0.7683666348457336,
-0.01597083918750286,
0.696402907371521,
-0.6928034424781799,
-0.17823974788188934,
-0.5237534046173096,
-0.16163450479507446,
-0.9091556668281555,
-0.19914233684539795,
0.43634793162345886,
-0.3922874927520752,
-0.43460988998413086,
0.1413513869047165,
-0.5801882147789001,
0.5437864065170288,
0.8522731065750122,
0.14319203794002533,
0.46786418557167053,
-0.3439238965511322,
0.5981716513633728,
0.2840009927749634,
-0.5673688054084778,
-0.9152441620826721,
0.8965529203414917,
0.4777006506919861,
0.8328481912612915,
0.031828928738832474,
0.6014305353164673,
0.4385005235671997,
0.3873259127140045,
-0.9541237950325012,
0.6006632447242737,
-0.06749571114778519,
-0.5231387615203857,
-0.3781401216983795,
-0.34646281599998474,
-1.1072179079055786,
-0.011402015574276447,
0.008372616022825241,
-0.7109538912773132,
-0.23050148785114288,
-0.012409311719238758,
0.03732313960790634,
0.27091753482818604,
-0.7777261734008789,
0.796167254447937,
-0.4461820125579834,
-0.16998784244060516,
-0.21742868423461914,
-0.6734323501586914,
0.15516740083694458,
0.05769959092140198,
0.08494693040847778,
0.01726212352514267,
0.3198515474796295,
0.5997990965843201,
-0.029578613117337227,
1.2900089025497437,
0.08895142376422882,
-0.1178455799818039,
0.28676262497901917,
-0.20609155297279358,
0.3526357114315033,
0.03639739751815796,
0.12900657951831818,
0.5201250910758972,
-0.07184520363807678,
-0.20312292873859406,
-0.313629150390625,
0.41033974289894104,
-0.9892197847366333,
-0.6110701560974121,
-0.2692820727825165,
-0.4732903242111206,
-0.16298426687717438,
0.21852247416973114,
0.0989275574684143,
0.3573378026485443,
-0.6346039175987244,
0.0885137990117073,
0.7765681743621826,
-0.42107757925987244,
0.33629101514816284,
0.07793209701776505,
-0.1346617341041565,
-0.009819491766393185,
0.9631026387214661,
0.13572144508361816,
0.20402546226978302,
0.24788053333759308,
0.2905580699443817,
-0.06503373384475708,
-0.06702802330255508,
-0.48723629117012024,
0.041595134884119034,
-0.7639066576957703,
0.27543461322784424,
-0.4961857497692108,
-0.4775652289390564,
-0.4286842346191406,
-0.15285146236419678,
-0.34914711117744446,
-0.0630125105381012,
-0.12423638254404068,
0.11550844460725784,
0.12338151782751083,
0.9691050052642822,
0.30105069279670715,
0.5052722096443176,
-0.6991181969642639,
-0.032262712717056274,
0.6749382019042969,
0.5762487053871155,
0.007557351607829332,
0.002596932463347912,
0.019245898351073265,
0.19804957509040833,
-0.4217524826526642,
-0.48837414383888245,
0.22115786373615265,
0.16477425396442413,
0.5421745777130127,
0.2342115342617035,
-0.04697025194764137,
0.1465912163257599,
-0.6690458655357361,
0.9681750535964966,
0.0071233343333005905,
-0.7810627222061157,
0.4590509235858917,
-0.3358961343765259,
0.27435430884361267,
0.09386362880468369,
0.14993534982204437,
-1.2932894229888916,
-0.3258942663669586,
-0.5730159282684326,
-0.8070447444915771,
0.47064709663391113,
0.512505829334259,
0.7112109065055847,
0.13121245801448822,
0.23073405027389526,
0.0762241929769516,
0.06382402777671814,
-0.8525667786598206,
-0.014211748726665974,
-0.26457181572914124,
0.014131815172731876,
0.21257174015045166,
-0.04970315471291542,
0.044866204261779785,
0.1591692417860031,
0.7683003544807434,
0.11852297186851501,
0.5430238246917725,
-0.0757652074098587,
-0.027379579842090607,
0.2581525444984436,
0.5661646723747253,
0.5507522225379944,
0.2505248785018921,
0.11448199301958084,
-0.14924661815166473,
0.08204562216997147,
-0.7798762321472168,
-0.03851860389113426,
-0.1926620453596115,
-0.23231486976146698,
-0.33910977840423584,
0.04377765581011772,
0.7031136751174927,
-0.0360143706202507,
-0.572807788848877,
0.43381378054618835,
-0.18489603698253632,
-0.16718092560768127,
-0.42885932326316833,
0.07886619120836258,
-0.023464281111955643,
0.46211132407188416,
0.39317917823791504,
0.16390839219093323,
0.05075334757566452,
-0.5077982544898987,
0.18075144290924072,
0.5059762001037598,
-0.5512534976005554,
-0.1794261932373047,
0.6303457617759705,
0.3711042106151581,
-0.743989109992981,
0.598497211933136,
0.29468289017677307,
-0.796186625957489,
0.7033652663230896,
0.39206430315971375,
0.9697881937026978,
-0.10795360803604126,
0.2505137622356415,
-0.057592686265707016,
0.5183664560317993,
-0.04510954022407532,
-0.18203742802143097,
-0.022274648770689964,
-0.8111746311187744,
-0.34370318055152893,
-0.3833130896091461,
-0.7507851123809814,
-0.002129304688423872,
-0.11904074251651764,
0.3806196451187134,
-0.3362703323364258,
-0.08020627498626709,
-0.21995912492275238,
-0.20326392352581024,
-0.5886524319648743,
-0.029897164553403854,
0.2921886444091797,
0.6052267551422119,
-0.6289517879486084,
0.7620092630386353,
0.5972958207130432,
-0.34458237886428833,
-0.5992358922958374,
0.4628087282180786,
0.012138200923800468,
-1.0804460048675537,
0.6695661544799805,
0.5635887980461121,
-0.23848429322242737,
0.21814675629138947,
-0.5950354933738708,
-0.6103230714797974,
0.8456705212593079,
0.17847366631031036,
-0.2078862488269806,
0.06983058899641037,
0.6536539793014526,
0.6389389038085938,
0.02699311077594757,
0.24623848497867584,
0.5270757675170898,
0.4232540428638458,
0.13536277413368225,
-0.8744275569915771,
-0.1874326914548874,
-0.30153709650039673,
0.1525006890296936,
0.38458317518234253,
-0.7278727293014526,
0.6549612283706665,
0.04923124983906746,
-0.45124027132987976,
-0.3041713535785675,
0.2907082438468933,
-0.274748831987381,
0.06305263191461563,
0.11306978762149811,
0.06912536919116974,
0.5645744800567627,
-0.05575408786535263,
0.9421582818031311,
-0.3462722897529602,
0.4909639060497284,
0.7555445432662964,
-0.1243419349193573,
0.5668059587478638,
0.3825608491897583,
-0.229971781373024,
-0.02430104650557041,
0.63692706823349,
-0.09440372884273529,
0.2976078987121582,
0.3702738881111145,
-0.36716943979263306,
0.1253516972064972,
-0.1574079692363739,
-0.3053264319896698,
0.6394648551940918,
0.35872387886047363,
-0.08160366863012314,
-0.26211467385292053,
0.14441350102424622,
0.0427413135766983,
-0.2925499975681305,
-0.3725074529647827,
0.9289907217025757,
0.157185360789299,
-0.42607927322387695,
0.021378301084041595,
-0.20715071260929108,
0.7843178510665894,
-0.3844822645187378,
-0.1763463169336319,
-0.20473670959472656,
0.09300607442855835,
-0.027994327247142792,
-0.8398081064224243,
0.4819483160972595,
0.033825527876615524,
0.3184051513671875,
-0.4001860022544861,
0.9360714554786682,
-0.18141520023345947,
-0.24895800650119781,
0.029222963377833366,
0.5092848539352417,
0.3033929467201233,
-0.2414298951625824,
-0.5017480254173279,
-0.09223711490631104,
-0.10836653411388397,
-0.3084349036216736,
0.46187183260917664,
0.4538535177707672,
0.05069923400878906,
0.8769843578338623,
0.5986558198928833,
-0.16791152954101562,
-0.01910276897251606,
-0.09905795753002167,
0.76933753490448,
-0.410413533449173,
-0.5439526438713074,
-0.9226033091545105,
0.36325937509536743,
-0.006674169097095728,
-0.30475857853889465,
0.42272070050239563,
0.3167645037174225,
0.7234876155853271,
0.13688483834266663,
1.07743501663208,
-0.3755631744861603,
0.09842260926961899,
-0.20861086249351501,
1.025365948677063,
-0.20623713731765747,
0.3960251808166504,
-0.03012797236442566,
-0.7004740834236145,
-0.3847008943557739,
0.42503130435943604,
-0.6979057192802429,
-0.01054383534938097,
0.2026582807302475,
0.6994138360023499,
0.1114659309387207,
0.481908917427063,
0.40601736307144165,
-0.016333166509866714,
0.7491079568862915,
0.35051828622817993,
0.8341128826141357,
-0.30428823828697205,
0.8987888097763062,
-0.11595030874013901,
-0.3398340046405792,
-0.10159406065940857,
-0.7140056490898132,
-0.7658206820487976,
-0.5067598819732666,
-0.09305022656917572,
-0.058790355920791626,
0.1262577474117279,
0.8862131834030151,
0.5322229862213135,
-0.6224995851516724,
-0.2653222978115082,
-0.22571022808551788,
0.0603526271879673,
-0.06136707216501236,
-0.26397183537483215,
0.1588180810213089,
-0.3511323928833008,
-0.7065736055374146,
0.10378015786409378,
0.3361319601535797,
0.12953226268291473,
-0.30935731530189514,
0.018554696813225746,
-0.051457591354846954,
-0.1504226177930832,
0.73112553358078,
0.26199039816856384,
-0.4596357047557831,
-0.6502060890197754,
0.014253024011850357,
-0.10442578792572021,
0.3888963460922241,
0.8437573909759521,
-0.62142014503479,
0.2468433380126953,
0.2800900340080261,
0.9470281600952148,
0.3994068205356598,
-0.22011631727218628,
0.8208706974983215,
-0.45010611414909363,
-0.005535118747502565,
0.37344232201576233,
0.05669393017888069,
0.19160142540931702,
-0.6932375431060791,
0.7966532707214355,
0.13639084994792938,
-1.0147863626480103,
-0.5399174094200134,
0.4026351273059845,
-0.7426160573959351,
-0.1865403652191162,
1.0199307203292847,
0.05658426135778427,
-0.22922320663928986,
-0.30697688460350037,
-0.5879020094871521,
0.30951783061027527,
-0.61439448595047,
1.209734320640564,
0.41892513632774353,
-0.2881694734096527,
-0.5315622687339783,
-0.9803748726844788,
0.2138989269733429,
0.13470187783241272,
-0.9248595237731934,
0.22066059708595276,
0.17200112342834473,
0.2208131104707718,
0.03187454864382744,
0.5679163932800293,
-0.1493227332830429,
0.07497618347406387,
-0.01988288387656212,
0.18006819486618042,
0.07252783328294754,
0.06781623512506485,
-0.228646382689476,
0.18398483097553253,
-0.06523174792528152,
-0.20789934694766998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13919v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13919v3
|
SYNFAC-EDIT: Synthetic Imitation Edit Feedback for Factual Alignment in Clinical Summarization
| 2024-02-21T16:33:22 | 2024-04-18T16:50:43 |
Prakamya Mishra, Zonghai Yao, Parth Vashisht, Feiyun Ouyang, Beining Wang, Vidhi Dhaval Mody, Hong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT & Llama have demonstrated
significant achievements in summarization tasks but struggle with factual
inaccuracies, a critical issue in clinical NLP applications where errors could
lead to serious consequences. To counter the high costs and limited
availability of expert-annotated data for factual alignment, this study
introduces an innovative pipeline that utilizes >100B parameter GPT variants
like GPT-3.5 & GPT-4 to act as synthetic experts to generate high-quality
synthetics feedback aimed at enhancing factual consistency in clinical note
summarization. Our research primarily focuses on edit feedback generated by
these synthetic feedback experts without additional human annotations,
mirroring and optimizing the practical scenario in which medical professionals
refine AI system outputs. Although such 100B+ parameter GPT variants have
proven to demonstrate expertise in various clinical NLP tasks, such as the
Medical Licensing Examination, there is scant research on their capacity to act
as synthetic feedback experts and deliver expert-level edit feedback for
improving the generation quality of weaker (<10B parameter) LLMs like GPT-2
(1.5B) & Llama 2 (7B) in clinical domain. So in this work, we leverage 100B+
GPT variants to act as synthetic feedback experts offering expert-level edit
feedback, that is used to reduce hallucinations and align weaker (<10B
parameter) LLMs with medical facts using two distinct alignment algorithms (DPO
& SALT), endeavoring to narrow the divide between AI-generated content and
factual accuracy. This highlights the substantial potential of LLM-based
synthetic edits in enhancing the alignment of clinical factuality.
|
[
-0.16762548685073853,
-0.7831032276153564,
0.9340608716011047,
0.04302752763032913,
-0.22824111580848694,
0.39146798849105835,
-0.12468099594116211,
-0.6866936683654785,
0.7207721471786499,
0.3478069305419922,
-0.5327337980270386,
-0.4418172836303711,
-0.6626584529876709,
0.4255404770374298,
-0.18494805693626404,
1.2766296863555908,
-0.2898619771003723,
0.46589455008506775,
-0.21558164060115814,
-0.24760115146636963,
-0.3926015794277191,
-0.5282533168792725,
-0.5967609286308289,
-0.024436764419078827,
0.5584006309509277,
0.1827174574136734,
0.8858718276023865,
0.6121950745582581,
0.4993894100189209,
0.38516438007354736,
-0.06573130935430527,
0.6504051685333252,
-0.24090147018432617,
-0.087005615234375,
-0.2918330132961273,
-0.29632657766342163,
-1.1546030044555664,
-0.04917247220873833,
0.4873582422733307,
0.4446132779121399,
-0.20593604445457458,
-0.0005569247878156602,
-0.10401555895805359,
0.6433974504470825,
-0.35252320766448975,
0.06142498552799225,
-0.4965289533138275,
-0.053936321288347244,
0.010889854282140732,
-0.3238055109977722,
-0.372669517993927,
-0.4388430118560791,
0.04702044278383255,
-0.7286385297775269,
0.4663788676261902,
0.0036073250230401754,
0.7294871211051941,
0.47607773542404175,
-0.2803772985935211,
-0.37056776881217957,
-0.6476640701293945,
0.22724372148513794,
-1.2122483253479004,
0.13058659434318542,
-0.07199258357286453,
0.1355067938566208,
-0.26088833808898926,
-0.8200048208236694,
-1.0100030899047852,
-0.1570727378129959,
-0.3239297568798065,
0.4724356532096863,
0.3261460065841675,
0.40111106634140015,
0.19143860042095184,
0.3309306800365448,
-0.4278951585292816,
0.019414415583014488,
-0.3247680366039276,
-0.4179438352584839,
0.8726229071617126,
0.32674798369407654,
0.2547122836112976,
0.0063997115939855576,
-0.15877246856689453,
0.22561056911945343,
-0.5731594562530518,
-0.39622774720191956,
0.15515275299549103,
0.15599499642848969,
-0.036687593907117844,
0.7906243801116943,
-0.1900252103805542,
0.6401412487030029,
0.4455451965332031,
-0.4769599735736847,
0.27138593792915344,
-0.6017853021621704,
-0.1089189201593399,
0.4097652733325958,
0.8298263549804688,
0.5793755650520325,
-0.0572831854224205,
-0.085472472012043,
-0.14821116626262665,
0.059021320194005966,
0.43634331226348877,
-0.46278923749923706,
-0.18400050699710846,
0.44185391068458557,
-0.26812735199928284,
-0.41620415449142456,
0.1465931385755539,
-0.7503564357757568,
-0.5131487846374512,
-0.6582897901535034,
0.5203197598457336,
-0.27981022000312805,
0.1945081502199173,
0.06577291339635849,
0.06254368275403976,
-0.1608530879020691,
0.8320585489273071,
-0.9163010716438293,
0.4492335319519043,
0.6533002257347107,
0.8342432975769043,
-0.3655652701854706,
-0.14707708358764648,
-0.47112634778022766,
0.2541651129722595,
-0.22519761323928833,
0.802491307258606,
-0.18609030544757843,
-0.2445182204246521,
-0.19057340919971466,
0.025303585454821587,
-0.06413529068231583,
-0.3943815231323242,
0.4439455270767212,
-0.34825369715690613,
0.3717936873435974,
-0.269666463136673,
-0.5815938711166382,
-0.05132893845438957,
0.08347679674625397,
-0.511139988899231,
0.6912127137184143,
0.16559919714927673,
-0.7618700861930847,
0.33049359917640686,
-0.43744292855262756,
-0.3960553705692291,
0.06094737723469734,
-0.28131571412086487,
-0.4756869077682495,
0.024448024109005928,
0.5252707600593567,
0.04758067801594734,
0.04908465966582298,
0.3114796578884125,
-0.11670920252799988,
-0.3249349594116211,
0.31987810134887695,
-0.2892877757549286,
0.3963816463947296,
-0.09604844450950623,
-0.5389710068702698,
0.34163162112236023,
-0.819546639919281,
-0.1307556927204132,
-0.20100116729736328,
-0.04222295433282852,
-0.06375490128993988,
-0.21314296126365662,
-0.09783082455396652,
0.3723506033420563,
0.22494567930698395,
-0.60688316822052,
0.41214561462402344,
-0.4421692192554474,
-0.019511893391609192,
0.732537031173706,
0.34918826818466187,
0.10829426348209381,
-0.6333088278770447,
0.7231050729751587,
-0.12395159900188446,
0.1373583972454071,
0.16190139949321747,
-0.5525041222572327,
-0.6732564568519592,
-0.6107465028762817,
0.51319420337677,
0.6197065114974976,
-0.6657235026359558,
0.3581770062446594,
-0.19860343635082245,
-0.4967880845069885,
-1.138777494430542,
0.21879352629184723,
0.2918208837509155,
0.9186791181564331,
0.5893312692642212,
-0.28659915924072266,
-0.6626549363136292,
-0.8611211180686951,
-0.24066931009292603,
-0.20282340049743652,
0.11304660886526108,
0.07949377596378326,
0.31023135781288147,
-0.2521984875202179,
0.925075888633728,
-0.40740352869033813,
-0.4193570017814636,
-0.20711614191532135,
-0.015870755538344383,
0.25985187292099,
0.4151588976383209,
0.36106768250465393,
-0.39059212803840637,
-0.4460888206958771,
-0.174211785197258,
-0.6639003157615662,
-0.4066913425922394,
-0.5705147981643677,
-0.021852565929293633,
0.5099332332611084,
0.3497525155544281,
-0.8680925965309143,
0.4617527425289154,
0.4780701696872711,
-0.20299100875854492,
0.7124086618423462,
-0.4515625536441803,
0.3518252968788147,
-1.1492441892623901,
0.1539352983236313,
-0.32058995962142944,
-0.2859736979007721,
-0.4985155761241913,
-0.106767438352108,
-0.00316273863427341,
0.3286052644252777,
-0.24836449325084686,
0.49506309628486633,
-0.3018675744533539,
0.15277446806430817,
-0.2543177008628845,
0.3499535322189331,
-0.053282324224710464,
0.40462255477905273,
0.14453557133674622,
0.6563444137573242,
0.02630193904042244,
-0.1237960234284401,
0.4228047728538513,
0.6042575240135193,
-0.004786618985235691,
0.5066302418708801,
-0.7087846398353577,
0.21620333194732666,
-0.019635647535324097,
0.6283742785453796,
-0.8137231469154358,
-0.4685198664665222,
0.23345403373241425,
-0.43025287985801697,
0.30547356605529785,
0.009407293051481247,
-0.6558075547218323,
-0.03715069219470024,
-0.33390551805496216,
0.19592119753360748,
0.5153378844261169,
-0.3338659107685089,
0.5838703513145447,
0.29993578791618347,
-0.5417346954345703,
-0.7360962629318237,
-0.4543132483959198,
0.2546181082725525,
0.23029246926307678,
-0.5138140320777893,
0.5267981886863708,
0.05820877104997635,
-0.17537836730480194,
-0.11081491410732269,
-0.29657605290412903,
0.2828996479511261,
-0.30452612042427063,
0.1769331395626068,
0.7524025440216064,
-0.30690085887908936,
-0.08807437866926193,
0.35576391220092773,
-0.06784186512231827,
0.10907021164894104,
0.024736259132623672,
0.1877739429473877,
0.09803220629692078,
-0.4225623309612274,
-0.8005801439285278,
0.17537759244441986,
0.7027264833450317,
-0.06578502058982849,
0.7396310567855835,
0.4307214319705963,
-0.2797541320323944,
-0.01704198122024536,
-0.7884521484375,
-0.26230984926223755,
-0.4580538272857666,
0.2686109244823456,
0.02222871594130993,
-0.8243837952613831,
0.590176522731781,
0.16689516603946686,
0.14466595649719238,
0.6009410619735718,
0.8323884010314941,
-0.2789669334888458,
1.0293711423873901,
0.024837620556354523,
0.31003859639167786,
-0.10440504550933838,
-0.005664176307618618,
0.143022820353508,
-0.8596133589744568,
-0.3916998505592346,
-0.07373233139514923,
-0.3947769105434418,
-0.47407767176628113,
-0.383012980222702,
0.6600608825683594,
-0.11552638560533524,
0.20506373047828674,
0.08460420370101929,
-0.3411700129508972,
0.3553672432899475,
0.317402184009552,
0.4431137144565582,
0.5176741480827332,
-0.3297683596611023,
-0.0847889631986618,
-0.09238605201244354,
-0.6323779225349426,
-0.4624210596084595,
1.0950133800506592,
0.3066258430480957,
0.5498159527778625,
0.0649409145116806,
0.6054525375366211,
0.31354525685310364,
0.5270010232925415,
-0.6228862404823303,
0.526602029800415,
-0.0029238646384328604,
-0.5120831727981567,
-0.10953887552022934,
-0.12213150411844254,
-0.33600568771362305,
0.08397192507982254,
-0.5187216401100159,
-0.4689798355102539,
0.1344355195760727,
0.48381122946739197,
-0.5439772605895996,
0.28927910327911377,
-0.5121424198150635,
0.7503700852394104,
-0.11290282756090164,
-0.409711092710495,
-0.28863435983657837,
-0.8752651810646057,
0.32168418169021606,
-0.3465012013912201,
0.07559734582901001,
0.24639543890953064,
-0.22217753529548645,
0.42728132009506226,
-1.0238324403762817,
0.9485697150230408,
-0.10470489412546158,
-0.2569229304790497,
0.16792969405651093,
0.16592425107955933,
0.7711971998214722,
0.4351944625377655,
0.1429717093706131,
0.02793225832283497,
0.05325869098305702,
-0.24795296788215637,
-0.9053876996040344,
0.5409216284751892,
-0.6020867824554443,
-0.8816515803337097,
-0.5533174276351929,
-0.6333011388778687,
-0.4867379665374756,
0.02594873122870922,
0.21916700899600983,
0.5445337891578674,
-0.016860321164131165,
-0.25590047240257263,
0.2835580110549927,
-0.05967071279883385,
-0.006510390900075436,
0.5839738845825195,
0.019886203110218048,
-0.7905694842338562,
0.6246001124382019,
-0.06470546126365662,
0.4695040285587311,
0.3088343143463135,
-0.018675437197089195,
-0.3002161383628845,
-0.929560124874115,
-0.5960646271705627,
0.6324743628501892,
-0.5994295477867126,
-0.2171095907688141,
-0.7856791019439697,
-0.2595459818840027,
-0.6028245687484741,
-0.4115740954875946,
-0.4420795738697052,
-0.811434805393219,
-0.1481350213289261,
-0.2431395798921585,
0.3580053150653839,
0.7233579754829407,
-0.1590913087129593,
0.3359311819076538,
-0.8276101350784302,
0.4293729364871979,
0.04205508157610893,
0.19448703527450562,
-0.239239901304245,
-0.6418788433074951,
-0.19881077110767365,
0.10015133768320084,
-0.2865884006023407,
-0.8544692397117615,
0.3529418408870697,
-0.0349465012550354,
0.31114229559898376,
0.3086622655391693,
-0.004235409665852785,
0.9409062266349792,
-0.41574662923812866,
0.8277024626731873,
0.007618321105837822,
-0.9482024908065796,
0.3499866724014282,
-0.34876272082328796,
0.13871315121650696,
0.7583527565002441,
0.15672726929187775,
-0.40773048996925354,
-0.7492504119873047,
-0.7231765389442444,
-0.5617868304252625,
0.6254861354827881,
0.17564596235752106,
-0.2826599180698395,
0.08839797973632812,
0.560387909412384,
0.3993096351623535,
0.19799378514289856,
-0.29137736558914185,
-0.1172354444861412,
-0.17424441874027252,
-0.6086554527282715,
-0.024507759138941765,
-0.16196197271347046,
-0.3870771527290344,
-0.3667892515659332,
0.8344464898109436,
-0.20386706292629242,
0.05729258060455322,
0.7561854124069214,
-0.044962428510189056,
-0.08514147251844406,
0.13872839510440826,
1.0420864820480347,
0.7648088335990906,
-0.3582408130168915,
-0.004789859522134066,
0.4885123670101166,
-0.7476169466972351,
0.17737281322479248,
0.011259659193456173,
-0.3360752761363983,
0.3019889295101166,
0.7265611290931702,
0.5929805636405945,
-0.027344509959220886,
-0.6964942216873169,
0.42575106024742126,
0.13695351779460907,
-0.2723005414009094,
-0.3793081045150757,
0.12460283190011978,
-0.06694816797971725,
0.09740892797708511,
-0.06988868862390518,
0.3904416561126709,
0.08640630543231964,
-0.4526982605457306,
0.3587011694908142,
0.28608444333076477,
-0.2316702902317047,
-0.5196064114570618,
0.8469367623329163,
0.18657132983207703,
-0.21851322054862976,
0.554678201675415,
0.08817634731531143,
-0.43357062339782715,
0.5064125657081604,
0.5892499685287476,
0.7927159667015076,
-0.2074015587568283,
0.33856678009033203,
0.2947333753108978,
0.12846112251281738,
-0.16649053990840912,
0.19134622812271118,
0.1579855978488922,
-0.5380420088768005,
-0.7297406792640686,
-0.232895627617836,
-0.7274872660636902,
-0.09005481004714966,
-0.5114063620567322,
0.5002623796463013,
-0.648164689540863,
-0.19337019324302673,
0.04466390982270241,
-0.21406863629817963,
-0.20324178040027618,
0.23616157472133636,
-0.11897583305835724,
0.7052006721496582,
-0.5840594172477722,
0.7919049263000488,
0.6706866025924683,
-0.3710455000400543,
-0.7160652875900269,
-0.04120395705103874,
0.4003120958805084,
-0.7110233902931213,
0.36753517389297485,
-0.25751519203186035,
-0.04577432945370674,
-0.3087657392024994,
-0.3312293291091919,
-0.5983696579933167,
1.0840797424316406,
0.340371310710907,
-0.49241557717323303,
-0.2826586961746216,
0.35345080494880676,
1.024705171585083,
-0.468390554189682,
0.3447039723396301,
0.5763931274414062,
0.42058026790618896,
0.21365907788276672,
-1.0717805624008179,
0.3874330222606659,
-0.1860777586698532,
-0.47002464532852173,
0.06385595351457596,
-0.6964656114578247,
0.2752707302570343,
-0.6328105926513672,
0.02686776965856552,
0.21003642678260803,
0.4913911521434784,
0.3956003189086914,
0.3849116861820221,
0.28003665804862976,
0.4379235506057739,
0.6217665672302246,
0.11249388754367828,
0.9855079054832458,
-0.3539663553237915,
0.02098127268254757,
1.401482105255127,
-0.42409059405326843,
0.554785430431366,
0.693638801574707,
-0.18607862293720245,
0.5845555663108826,
0.3458992540836334,
-0.22237960994243622,
0.35355332493782043,
-0.044997405260801315,
-0.3539760708808899,
0.024313291534781456,
0.06795092672109604,
-0.3134148418903351,
0.307720422744751,
0.19945944845676422,
-0.47640252113342285,
0.2893833816051483,
-0.540103018283844,
0.2367449253797531,
0.021507814526557922,
-0.037190478295087814,
1.044596791267395,
-0.06014076620340347,
-0.8087618947029114,
0.42702943086624146,
-0.1500459760427475,
0.30265867710113525,
-0.5479764938354492,
-0.15503117442131042,
-0.2677607834339142,
0.21532461047172546,
-0.4872255325317383,
-0.5279966592788696,
0.40274152159690857,
-0.08820153772830963,
-0.03771060332655907,
0.043711837381124496,
0.17636284232139587,
-0.5284503698348999,
-0.5225664377212524,
-0.1756645292043686,
0.19676473736763,
-0.14532344043254852,
0.21854789555072784,
-0.4772462844848633,
-0.1882314831018448,
0.033469997346401215,
0.002431845758110285,
0.17203937470912933,
0.2964552044868469,
0.11915270239114761,
0.35677391290664673,
0.7438507676124573,
0.7840490341186523,
-0.16996973752975464,
0.004586994647979736,
0.7035001516342163,
-0.5873139500617981,
-0.33155012130737305,
-0.8815256953239441,
0.5633291006088257,
-0.2638285756111145,
-0.386594295501709,
0.5498238801956177,
0.6104503273963928,
0.54657381772995,
-0.29908034205436707,
0.6971701979637146,
0.055154673755168915,
0.5660274028778076,
-0.6845795512199402,
0.7156851291656494,
-0.3785673677921295,
0.2842251658439636,
-0.5263960361480713,
-0.8435030579566956,
-0.34034019708633423,
0.08527315407991409,
0.08821666985750198,
-0.11893434077501297,
0.9492337703704834,
0.9432297348976135,
0.09481071680784225,
0.14654047787189484,
-0.08587443083524704,
0.5622400641441345,
0.3515668511390686,
0.2816440463066101,
0.47880297899246216,
-0.4493650197982788,
0.14367236196994781,
-0.34454891085624695,
-0.19587601721286774,
-0.15188956260681152,
-0.6693204641342163,
-0.8198988437652588,
-0.3361542820930481,
-0.6381980776786804,
-0.6400966048240662,
0.28101059794425964,
1.1807693243026733,
0.39400991797447205,
-1.1359577178955078,
0.19857019186019897,
0.039365362375974655,
-0.11176510155200958,
-0.4203586280345917,
-0.18350434303283691,
0.8177213072776794,
-0.23441994190216064,
-0.5471885204315186,
0.29906153678894043,
0.37260696291923523,
0.2945769429206848,
-0.0762898400425911,
-0.15503448247909546,
0.06975860893726349,
0.1597314476966858,
0.41086143255233765,
0.17867827415466309,
-0.9051278233528137,
-0.3163129687309265,
-0.030286559835076332,
-0.0772790014743805,
0.13709820806980133,
0.8518180847167969,
-0.7079523205757141,
0.5460580587387085,
0.48392146825790405,
0.679640531539917,
0.19748565554618835,
0.3372907042503357,
0.9046024084091187,
-0.47465163469314575,
0.06620604544878006,
0.3527368903160095,
0.34799543023109436,
0.24149884283542633,
-0.5637508630752563,
0.5468318462371826,
0.5074315667152405,
-0.5484351515769958,
-0.7413292527198792,
-0.1819382607936859,
-1.447969675064087,
0.06107841059565544,
1.0245397090911865,
0.13305248320102692,
0.052136071026325226,
-0.0747256875038147,
-0.6343705058097839,
0.41083359718322754,
-0.22211600840091705,
1.313345193862915,
0.5768720507621765,
-0.5021524429321289,
-0.00770998653024435,
-0.4524066150188446,
0.847919225692749,
0.6466168761253357,
-0.8874913454055786,
-0.09314431250095367,
0.5836097002029419,
0.17564836144447327,
0.02665995992720127,
0.5264699459075928,
-0.5015851259231567,
0.5508549809455872,
-0.13694827258586884,
0.0461340993642807,
-0.2690938413143158,
-0.0009329378372058272,
-0.24080894887447357,
-0.08122425526380539,
-0.15989427268505096,
0.18197162449359894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13917v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13917v2
|
Could We Have Had Better Multilingual LLMs If English Was Not the Central Language?
| 2024-02-21T16:32:38 | 2024-04-05T05:26:05 |
Ryandito Diandaru, Lucky Susanto, Zilu Tang, Ayu Purwarianti, Derry Wijaya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate strong machine translation
capabilities on languages they are trained on. However, the impact of factors
beyond training data size on translation performance remains a topic of debate,
especially concerning languages not directly encountered during training. Our
study delves into Llama2's translation capabilities. By modeling a linear
relationship between linguistic feature distances and machine translation
scores, we ask ourselves if there are potentially better central languages for
LLMs other than English. Our experiments show that the 7B Llama2 model yields
above 10 BLEU when translating into all languages it has seen, which rarely
happens for languages it has not seen. Most translation improvements into
unseen languages come from scaling up the model size rather than instruction
tuning or increasing shot count. Furthermore, our correlation analysis reveals
that syntactic similarity is not the only linguistic factor that strongly
correlates with machine translation scores. Interestingly, we discovered that
under specific circumstances, some languages (e.g. Swedish, Catalan), despite
having significantly less training data, exhibit comparable correlation levels
to English. These insights challenge the prevailing landscape of LLMs,
suggesting that models centered around languages other than English could
provide a more efficient foundation for multilingual applications.
|
[
-0.26535141468048096,
-0.22580935060977936,
0.6746307611465454,
0.30405792593955994,
-0.37108927965164185,
0.2453618198633194,
-0.8001961708068848,
-0.9553316831588745,
0.2716638147830963,
0.35940679907798767,
-0.1418493688106537,
-0.40186265110969543,
-1.106162667274475,
0.4270690083503723,
-0.3773624300956726,
0.731269121170044,
-0.06311309337615967,
0.36613500118255615,
-0.25645071268081665,
-0.5737035274505615,
-0.5899330377578735,
-0.6677827835083008,
-0.4090399742126465,
-0.7444396018981934,
0.6500204801559448,
0.3501579761505127,
0.6227183938026428,
0.48737478256225586,
0.8247599601745605,
0.24297170341014862,
-0.19293327629566193,
0.3965712785720825,
-0.4706708788871765,
-0.02863415516912937,
-0.051463667303323746,
-0.9700303673744202,
-0.4902472198009491,
-0.06577323377132416,
0.6974666714668274,
0.8461236357688904,
0.10765833407640457,
0.06557153165340424,
0.1895039826631546,
0.7439344525337219,
-0.22248244285583496,
0.07233527302742004,
-0.7153317332267761,
-0.06952612847089767,
-0.24497294425964355,
0.004981460981070995,
-0.357930451631546,
-0.09549126029014587,
-0.07789243012666702,
-0.4172920882701874,
0.0542113371193409,
0.18139144778251648,
0.8370453715324402,
0.40703630447387695,
-0.7843044996261597,
-0.2671964764595032,
-0.6621755957603455,
0.9717927575111389,
-0.6347978115081787,
0.5331257581710815,
0.4254309833049774,
0.251433789730072,
-0.061865467578172684,
-0.3111942708492279,
-0.40858373045921326,
-0.2899731397628784,
-0.3802388906478882,
-0.003720225766301155,
-0.3462545871734619,
-0.12099660933017731,
0.08253024518489838,
0.14505229890346527,
-0.6415448784828186,
0.4833861291408539,
-0.5257489681243896,
0.06754274666309357,
0.8135586977005005,
0.17161740362644196,
0.2568182945251465,
0.058010682463645935,
-0.16791416704654694,
-0.07983372360467911,
-0.8990572690963745,
0.22969794273376465,
0.35865354537963867,
0.38597697019577026,
-0.4123649299144745,
0.6390992999076843,
0.2373361438512802,
0.4797196388244629,
-0.09930536895990372,
-0.5632006525993347,
0.16689656674861908,
-0.32045096158981323,
0.1390470713376999,
0.043626122176647186,
0.6396112442016602,
0.5313043594360352,
0.33096927404403687,
-0.30745163559913635,
-0.14243999123573303,
0.1502409279346466,
0.023464495316147804,
-0.666604220867157,
-0.06600582599639893,
0.12261304259300232,
-0.4865421652793884,
0.1891481876373291,
-0.15331898629665375,
-0.16137531399726868,
-0.2548005282878876,
-0.2777285575866699,
-0.09906426817178726,
-0.21470211446285248,
-0.3337322175502777,
-0.10058854520320892,
-0.014389855787158012,
0.3202466070652008,
0.17722655832767487,
-0.7450843453407288,
0.2121470719575882,
0.6630057692527771,
0.8507787585258484,
-0.6289314031600952,
-0.6140332221984863,
-0.03086741827428341,
0.029810059815645218,
-0.7722632884979248,
0.8502774834632874,
-0.6761274337768555,
-0.5359780192375183,
-0.11276423931121826,
-0.000508040189743042,
-0.04438391327857971,
-0.6940189003944397,
-0.022376015782356262,
-0.44584375619888306,
-0.012890773825347424,
-0.5510320663452148,
-0.28119957447052,
-0.3393864631652832,
0.17744703590869904,
-0.5313358306884766,
0.9692354798316956,
-0.21096868813037872,
-0.5257645845413208,
0.26743391156196594,
-0.19372153282165527,
-0.8107374906539917,
-0.18712908029556274,
-0.32866448163986206,
-0.22535865008831024,
0.32082399725914,
0.11119234561920166,
0.32659009099006653,
-0.6156336665153503,
0.3970857858657837,
-0.27039089798927307,
-0.27504733204841614,
0.34290769696235657,
-0.39452433586120605,
0.4293065071105957,
0.03007090836763382,
-0.2835143506526947,
-0.2730617821216583,
-0.6573801636695862,
-0.01783089153468609,
0.02907797507941723,
-0.6077616810798645,
-0.24397920072078705,
-0.03246816247701645,
-0.051407504826784134,
0.23752598464488983,
0.4574047029018402,
-0.44097068905830383,
0.012602612376213074,
-0.3435448408126831,
0.3623131215572357,
0.40038731694221497,
-0.39844533801078796,
0.7058868408203125,
-0.2344708889722824,
0.5951269865036011,
-0.04646020755171776,
-0.34098896384239197,
0.10006728023290634,
-0.6338679194450378,
-0.7962087392807007,
-0.4152635633945465,
0.1577780693769455,
0.602679967880249,
-0.43470123410224915,
0.08582781255245209,
-0.32858511805534363,
-0.40493902564048767,
-0.5952618718147278,
0.5195823907852173,
0.6232558488845825,
0.14348480105400085,
0.2659469544887543,
-0.3720925450325012,
-0.5965394973754883,
-1.126041293144226,
-0.02927548810839653,
-0.21721184253692627,
0.21539518237113953,
0.24049241840839386,
0.24406743049621582,
-0.1922106146812439,
0.406839519739151,
-0.1957276165485382,
-0.3615487813949585,
-0.7011186480522156,
-0.4694841504096985,
0.42244744300842285,
0.05018530413508415,
0.8616456985473633,
-0.4910203814506531,
-0.602693498134613,
0.6112633347511292,
-0.8159683346748352,
-0.2190464437007904,
0.22148345410823822,
-0.04451334476470947,
0.3276565670967102,
0.41514521837234497,
-0.6976909041404724,
0.13836239278316498,
1.0270320177078247,
0.12195011973381042,
0.30099889636039734,
-0.45773398876190186,
0.02931487374007702,
-1.1585352420806885,
0.07137110829353333,
-0.20293788611888885,
-0.04065587371587753,
-0.5228078961372375,
-0.05184843763709068,
0.2455892264842987,
-0.05287255719304085,
-0.4206487536430359,
0.6266903877258301,
-0.5932660698890686,
-0.3647213876247406,
-0.5470291376113892,
0.30616724491119385,
0.1512012481689453,
0.34466788172721863,
0.0867270678281784,
0.8829883933067322,
0.5044185519218445,
-0.5357116460800171,
0.1372373104095459,
0.1026928722858429,
-0.25972607731819153,
0.6028544902801514,
-0.6530749797821045,
-0.03864283487200737,
-0.17673836648464203,
0.26608502864837646,
-1.0617433786392212,
-0.30179363489151,
-0.4334482252597809,
-0.41731008887290955,
0.5175675749778748,
0.04102327674627304,
-0.34629034996032715,
-0.2639339864253998,
-0.06107226386666298,
0.25771182775497437,
0.407684862613678,
-0.5761914849281311,
0.23895151913166046,
0.3850114047527313,
-0.12116878479719162,
-0.5446128845214844,
-1.113350749015808,
0.16000157594680786,
-0.2906184196472168,
-0.6814393401145935,
0.08858508616685867,
0.07219686359167099,
-0.45313677191734314,
-0.15949322283267975,
-0.026803836226463318,
-0.16628813743591309,
0.23901157081127167,
0.14500997960567474,
0.21372684836387634,
-0.39797443151474,
0.36972153186798096,
0.03421352431178093,
-0.06842182576656342,
-0.0701102465391159,
-0.23138485848903656,
0.3276774287223816,
-0.08086153864860535,
-0.29265180230140686,
-0.21002836525440216,
0.5062500238418579,
0.5721091032028198,
-0.4868974983692169,
0.8451896905899048,
0.5394080877304077,
-0.299110472202301,
-0.056556474417448044,
-0.47389256954193115,
-0.0194251649081707,
-0.3700413107872009,
0.6348835825920105,
-0.44873183965682983,
-1.002610683441162,
0.5812893509864807,
0.15053173899650574,
0.10756858438253403,
0.4760795533657074,
0.768310010433197,
-0.22102704644203186,
1.0009567737579346,
0.854301929473877,
-0.2582395672798157,
0.3752804696559906,
-0.21707725524902344,
0.36791133880615234,
-0.7561234831809998,
-0.3230956196784973,
-0.5571426749229431,
-0.5501874685287476,
-0.7075290679931641,
-0.3085904121398926,
0.44519421458244324,
0.2881997227668762,
0.06347169727087021,
0.48415860533714294,
-0.11927124857902527,
0.4936857521533966,
0.25070691108703613,
-0.13825325667858124,
0.3188633620738983,
0.15564660727977753,
-0.17475983500480652,
-0.1401495635509491,
-0.8031910061836243,
-0.5985702872276306,
1.1333237886428833,
0.27641671895980835,
0.6631034016609192,
0.5422565937042236,
0.5601623058319092,
-0.09941480308771133,
0.24816888570785522,
-0.5655186176300049,
0.2242962270975113,
-0.43971389532089233,
-0.47467660903930664,
-0.07583731412887573,
-0.25553447008132935,
-1.2086031436920166,
0.5322132110595703,
-0.1855701059103012,
-0.45704975724220276,
-0.06067851185798645,
-0.07908359915018082,
-0.12707330286502838,
0.21332716941833496,
-0.8310950398445129,
0.5162529349327087,
-0.6957948803901672,
-0.1394757330417633,
-0.35507631301879883,
-0.5004097819328308,
0.2650572657585144,
-0.2952294945716858,
0.4888914227485657,
-0.270732581615448,
-0.23136305809020996,
0.4432573616504669,
-0.21050654351711273,
0.8903131484985352,
0.35853108763694763,
-0.2958308160305023,
0.1495353877544403,
0.07362502813339233,
0.3100654184818268,
0.03051973134279251,
-0.11305656284093857,
0.5302202105522156,
-0.11632837355136871,
-0.685806930065155,
-0.4881924092769623,
0.8566276431083679,
-1.1187152862548828,
-0.7886350154876709,
-0.11125512421131134,
-0.8215086460113525,
-0.10129255056381226,
0.13575513660907745,
0.3564712405204773,
0.059563737362623215,
0.12472748011350632,
0.0752514973282814,
0.3065115809440613,
-0.0641755759716034,
0.57896888256073,
0.6699239611625671,
-0.2736586630344391,
-0.22300733625888824,
0.6907954216003418,
0.28038597106933594,
0.3644876778125763,
0.43950486183166504,
0.18757100403308868,
-0.41463950276374817,
-0.6723573803901672,
-0.5693556070327759,
0.5969162583351135,
-0.6694804430007935,
-0.18747016787528992,
-0.514021098613739,
0.09738466888666153,
-0.41868478059768677,
-0.16582132875919342,
-0.46258702874183655,
-0.4372085928916931,
-0.21556855738162994,
-0.15776494145393372,
0.42149049043655396,
1.0826916694641113,
-0.10599196702241898,
0.3383285105228424,
-0.7551554441452026,
-0.06260546296834946,
0.07822275906801224,
0.01712943986058235,
0.007086518220603466,
-0.8641015887260437,
-0.3984549045562744,
-0.17720139026641846,
-0.19832801818847656,
-0.7075121402740479,
0.4313814640045166,
0.30663663148880005,
0.6860060095787048,
0.13618095219135284,
-0.4568432867527008,
0.7279708981513977,
-0.6293838620185852,
0.7844029664993286,
0.19999533891677856,
-0.4224534034729004,
0.25880149006843567,
-0.07871678471565247,
0.26432061195373535,
0.2722795903682709,
0.45387259125709534,
-0.39064863324165344,
-0.3989325165748596,
-0.36021894216537476,
-0.6207740902900696,
0.45507705211639404,
0.04232105612754822,
0.20812003314495087,
-0.09993893653154373,
0.1958630084991455,
0.13757900893688202,
0.2713415324687958,
-0.7655347585678101,
-0.20499350130558014,
0.23001930117607117,
0.05013863742351532,
-0.6217620968818665,
0.022580839693546295,
0.09482765942811966,
-0.05134999752044678,
0.42072397470474243,
0.015481873415410519,
0.027656160295009613,
-0.05847175419330597,
-0.27303546667099,
-0.2588082253932953,
0.28061643242836,
0.5923364758491516,
0.6583748459815979,
0.17930027842521667,
0.2663259506225586,
0.6471778154373169,
-0.33724245429039,
0.19816870987415314,
-0.07520438730716705,
0.11346477270126343,
0.05432792007923126,
0.8196521997451782,
0.8179143071174622,
0.1031324490904808,
-0.6220237612724304,
0.41210073232650757,
0.1025962084531784,
0.09478021413087845,
-0.17001523077487946,
-0.00912881176918745,
0.36342528462409973,
0.5854285955429077,
0.14655697345733643,
-0.007060157600790262,
-0.24787099659442902,
-0.6354621052742004,
-0.133683443069458,
0.46345239877700806,
-0.32223227620124817,
-0.43471387028694153,
0.5063751339912415,
0.26393255591392517,
-0.37929579615592957,
0.27956098318099976,
-0.04923413321375847,
-0.5639508962631226,
0.7172605395317078,
0.6188831329345703,
0.2704874575138092,
-0.3156936764717102,
-0.13971713185310364,
0.3563366234302521,
0.6626307368278503,
-0.2836726903915405,
0.0604911707341671,
0.16927532851696014,
-0.6135703325271606,
-0.38689854741096497,
-0.5787626504898071,
-0.30835428833961487,
-0.010946817696094513,
-0.5434240102767944,
0.3627318739891052,
-0.24809348583221436,
-0.17024199664592743,
-0.1999163180589676,
0.12020812183618546,
-0.8415766954421997,
0.04153497889637947,
0.21067160367965698,
0.6458817720413208,
-0.9095048308372498,
1.1784749031066895,
0.9741571545600891,
-0.2431168109178543,
-0.7930988669395447,
-0.3670004606246948,
-0.16056929528713226,
-0.7941026091575623,
0.6713328957557678,
0.25532853603363037,
-0.050499144941568375,
-0.18438152968883514,
-0.1978192925453186,
-0.9787590503692627,
1.107189655303955,
0.5810851454734802,
-0.7031999230384827,
0.04011964052915573,
0.48372700810432434,
0.8923704624176025,
-0.5200087428092957,
0.24966919422149658,
0.7059447169303894,
0.25902777910232544,
-0.23727893829345703,
-1.1252316236495972,
-0.2265796959400177,
0.01648145727813244,
0.13794907927513123,
0.32580670714378357,
-0.9062998294830322,
0.8913351893424988,
-0.4618385434150696,
-0.081393763422966,
0.11304102838039398,
0.5099387168884277,
0.07735104113817215,
0.12762479484081268,
-0.15955565869808197,
0.5500534176826477,
0.7826252579689026,
0.13023509085178375,
1.3955739736557007,
-0.3472735583782196,
0.20964546501636505,
1.0132014751434326,
-0.4757910668849945,
1.1087976694107056,
0.5537568926811218,
-0.30276212096214294,
0.2966441810131073,
0.605988621711731,
0.34260493516921997,
0.40977057814598083,
-0.04843682795763016,
-0.07638128846883774,
-0.5062737464904785,
-0.13355602324008942,
-0.36912038922309875,
0.5479857325553894,
0.4248336851596832,
-0.3781486451625824,
-0.23314204812049866,
0.017003638669848442,
0.11892355233430862,
0.43080586194992065,
-0.150210902094841,
0.6253633499145508,
0.4722757935523987,
-0.6752975583076477,
0.8366667032241821,
0.1862337291240692,
0.7277112603187561,
-0.5518760085105896,
0.09066896140575409,
-0.7593680024147034,
0.16628071665763855,
-0.20038031041622162,
-0.8434016704559326,
0.34025171399116516,
0.21452820301055908,
-0.3195215165615082,
0.011770269833505154,
0.4457867741584778,
-0.6236713528633118,
-0.5824265480041504,
0.7365485429763794,
0.752720832824707,
0.5474254488945007,
0.2609046995639801,
-0.46382173895835876,
0.16943593323230743,
-0.052978478372097015,
0.08622585237026215,
0.4871149957180023,
0.5028355121612549,
-0.3168947696685791,
0.5874094367027283,
0.7169360518455505,
0.32721954584121704,
0.23571090400218964,
-0.04443865641951561,
0.5261377692222595,
-0.4533531069755554,
-0.21510858833789825,
-0.8278931379318237,
0.1837025135755539,
0.23453842103481293,
-0.310307115316391,
0.8239708542823792,
0.528340220451355,
1.01768958568573,
0.12640884518623352,
0.7294252514839172,
0.2882235646247864,
0.4222972095012665,
-0.5016824007034302,
0.5937395095825195,
-0.7411873936653137,
0.3096981346607208,
0.13604776561260223,
-1.1600656509399414,
-0.3625377118587494,
0.464436799287796,
-0.3550110161304474,
-0.20750074088573456,
0.9813878536224365,
0.8915039896965027,
0.015271730720996857,
-0.30847010016441345,
0.7803530097007751,
0.2630462348461151,
0.14233732223510742,
0.7540864944458008,
0.6882789134979248,
-0.4168270230293274,
0.7821415662765503,
-0.05436436086893082,
-0.04834964498877525,
-0.02593129314482212,
-0.6208502650260925,
-1.354339599609375,
-0.31822988390922546,
0.11875331401824951,
-0.2091340720653534,
-0.010059022344648838,
0.8200819492340088,
0.42229750752449036,
-0.7894906997680664,
-0.5280558466911316,
0.3185437321662903,
0.17038536071777344,
0.08091092109680176,
-0.016827886924147606,
0.14843803644180298,
-0.3634079396724701,
-0.6489396691322327,
0.5865203142166138,
0.3467462658882141,
0.11920202523469925,
-0.3073027431964874,
-0.3949662446975708,
-0.10322855412960052,
0.012183341197669506,
0.8747462630271912,
0.06439851969480515,
-0.9291081428527832,
-0.19842183589935303,
0.2772481441497803,
-0.4374992549419403,
0.18561102449893951,
0.6172119975090027,
-0.3104892671108246,
0.09184043854475021,
0.22368992865085602,
0.8043440580368042,
0.418055921792984,
-0.38252687454223633,
0.4963875412940979,
-0.675589919090271,
0.47535979747772217,
-0.29985105991363525,
0.500827431678772,
0.5727235078811646,
-0.24816235899925232,
0.49958136677742004,
0.20798806846141815,
-0.372609406709671,
-0.5121219158172607,
0.18007859587669373,
-0.6762082576751709,
-0.1256321370601654,
1.529405117034912,
-0.24209599196910858,
-0.32593637704849243,
0.03132076933979988,
-0.1441434770822525,
0.11194732040166855,
-0.2390804886817932,
0.6374282836914062,
0.9465246200561523,
-0.08203092217445374,
-0.11640308797359467,
-0.5902891159057617,
0.12174330651760101,
0.6204099655151367,
-0.648474931716919,
-0.1670428216457367,
0.28667116165161133,
0.30163225531578064,
0.10663407295942307,
0.4812515676021576,
-0.09459555149078369,
0.3764481246471405,
-0.08214803040027618,
-0.0029318034648895264,
0.2828812003135681,
-0.4388974905014038,
-0.4431724548339844,
-0.212795227766037,
0.6164922118186951,
0.09109161049127579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13906v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13906v2
|
Leveraging Collection-Wide Similarities for Unsupervised Document Structure Extraction
| 2024-02-21T16:22:21 | 2024-06-20T14:43:51 |
Gili Lior, Yoav Goldberg, Gabriel Stanovsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Document collections of various domains, e.g., legal, medical, or financial,
often share some underlying collection-wide structure, which captures
information that can aid both human users and structure-aware models. We
propose to identify the typical structure of document within a collection,
which requires to capture recurring topics across the collection, while
abstracting over arbitrary header paraphrases, and ground each topic to
respective document locations. These requirements pose several challenges:
headers that mark recurring topics frequently differ in phrasing, certain
section headers are unique to individual documents and do not reflect the
typical structure, and the order of topics can vary between documents.
Subsequently, we develop an unsupervised graph-based method which leverages
both inter- and intra-document similarities, to extract the underlying
collection-wide structure. Our evaluations on three diverse domains in both
English and Hebrew indicate that our method extracts meaningful collection-wide
structure, and we hope that future work will leverage our method for
multi-document applications and structure-aware models.
|
[
-0.42214250564575195,
-0.5885108113288879,
0.35400161147117615,
-0.11361123621463776,
-0.5666830539703369,
0.22819124162197113,
0.11064079403877258,
-0.5530638694763184,
0.6081843376159668,
0.5292247533798218,
-0.33350446820259094,
-0.7709559798240662,
-0.7366531491279602,
-0.023955384269356728,
-0.6069183349609375,
0.9293658137321472,
-0.107058584690094,
-0.11763980984687805,
-0.5258584022521973,
-0.323966920375824,
-0.256197988986969,
-0.29226571321487427,
-0.3024158477783203,
-0.29566875100135803,
0.5048419833183289,
0.39730551838874817,
0.32626140117645264,
0.8379436135292053,
0.5357639789581299,
0.28592875599861145,
-0.0862744078040123,
0.22970949113368988,
-0.3486330211162567,
0.26713991165161133,
-0.3430056869983673,
-0.163603737950325,
-0.29757723212242126,
-0.21092559397220612,
0.8035477995872498,
1.0213021039962769,
0.021683314815163612,
0.16573353111743927,
0.4854091703891754,
0.5333433151245117,
-0.5001723766326904,
0.505389392375946,
-0.6744012236595154,
-0.012958187609910965,
-0.6213345527648926,
-0.5329086184501648,
-0.02228083461523056,
-0.05734453350305557,
0.11280345916748047,
-0.5529667735099792,
0.6120578646659851,
-0.08616114407777786,
0.9667635560035706,
-0.34746214747428894,
-0.381779283285141,
-0.5272491574287415,
-0.2067958563566208,
0.3789844512939453,
-0.2703531086444855,
0.4321005642414093,
0.36208999156951904,
0.21764501929283142,
0.002791876904666424,
-1.0299038887023926,
-0.06784781813621521,
0.19870707392692566,
-0.2103957086801529,
0.2911146879196167,
-0.32241594791412354,
-0.2540349066257477,
0.01506959181278944,
0.4117959439754486,
-0.7638727426528931,
0.15030989050865173,
-0.3402789235115051,
-0.3815295994281769,
0.23920124769210815,
0.13321921229362488,
0.43590185046195984,
-0.3642253279685974,
-0.2769055962562561,
-0.021238958463072777,
-0.7763959169387817,
0.07581731677055359,
0.39501434564590454,
0.5150978565216064,
-0.13112212717533112,
0.49556198716163635,
-0.34919363260269165,
0.46065598726272583,
-0.14463301002979279,
-0.025483407080173492,
0.37371763586997986,
-0.23740197718143463,
-0.08433476835489273,
-0.02856319583952427,
0.6249121427536011,
0.47361913323402405,
0.09562981873750687,
-0.4675750434398651,
-0.01713459938764572,
-0.04568185284733772,
0.16705121099948883,
-0.6932132244110107,
-0.1585264652967453,
0.21621830761432648,
-0.8738871216773987,
-0.09821607917547226,
0.37009096145629883,
-1.0696157217025757,
-0.4184289574623108,
-0.3185550272464752,
-0.17035384476184845,
-0.3102550506591797,
-0.07714594155550003,
-0.152573823928833,
-0.5985273122787476,
0.3998958170413971,
0.31848421692848206,
-0.8911795616149902,
0.3769417405128479,
1.0035477876663208,
1.0894488096237183,
-0.3800315856933594,
-0.46285465359687805,
-0.6750056743621826,
0.3450494110584259,
-0.010269512422382832,
1.2465126514434814,
-0.6775316596031189,
-0.6481890082359314,
0.2058740109205246,
0.14250239729881287,
0.06270792335271835,
-0.5214667320251465,
0.5106082558631897,
-0.4695931077003479,
0.021964019164443016,
-0.4194428324699402,
-0.6989160776138306,
0.14011529088020325,
0.4861595034599304,
-0.7964932918548584,
0.5866621732711792,
0.39583688974380493,
-1.1656440496444702,
0.19823965430259705,
-0.4598962664604187,
-0.5941164493560791,
0.366593599319458,
-0.7081469297409058,
-0.4558107852935791,
0.19928793609142303,
0.1889616698026657,
0.4203585684299469,
-0.46953657269477844,
0.035171788185834885,
-0.30244743824005127,
-0.29811397194862366,
-0.1449921727180481,
-0.2569337785243988,
0.9124414920806885,
0.22415782511234283,
0.11946370452642441,
0.0854288712143898,
-0.6630361080169678,
-0.2464887648820877,
0.2886103689670563,
-0.13270686566829681,
-0.7734526991844177,
0.007431169506162405,
0.27059733867645264,
0.07140927016735077,
0.5338433980941772,
-0.5541222095489502,
0.3694111406803131,
-0.16842587292194366,
0.2575342059135437,
0.4698864817619324,
0.4413647949695587,
0.3712495267391205,
-0.4442666471004486,
0.7051261067390442,
-0.2425042688846588,
-0.0644586831331253,
-0.2888067066669464,
-0.36718475818634033,
-0.06811630725860596,
-0.5586963891983032,
0.29513275623321533,
0.22927254438400269,
-0.31270453333854675,
0.30800050497055054,
-0.5482361912727356,
-0.43705877661705017,
-0.04809844121336937,
0.11661728471517563,
0.44982561469078064,
0.5959346294403076,
0.41777125000953674,
-0.7638853788375854,
-0.2672537565231323,
-0.8324148654937744,
-0.3140413165092468,
0.027521980926394463,
-0.11330363154411316,
0.19908550381660461,
0.4417710602283478,
-0.07148850709199905,
0.8813068270683289,
-0.8103434443473816,
-0.3628807067871094,
-0.23810411989688873,
0.48905131220817566,
0.022274477407336235,
0.3093276023864746,
0.7349384427070618,
-1.1767905950546265,
-0.7264550924301147,
0.3143244981765747,
-0.7485154271125793,
-0.16360580921173096,
-0.014175276271998882,
-0.20500509440898895,
-0.24239908158779144,
0.6303571462631226,
-0.664547324180603,
0.5643908977508545,
-0.011364859528839588,
-0.28459855914115906,
0.2569175958633423,
-0.2130480408668518,
0.11798138171434402,
-1.2852997779846191,
0.3648262023925781,
-0.1783047914505005,
-0.11940710991621017,
-0.4024049639701843,
0.26733291149139404,
0.26985907554626465,
-0.22389040887355804,
-0.33236414194107056,
0.5862959027290344,
-0.7364941239356995,
-0.45620280504226685,
-0.5257230997085571,
0.11622537672519684,
0.34167563915252686,
0.3185928761959076,
0.1468416154384613,
0.4022759199142456,
0.4752783477306366,
-0.23444613814353943,
0.27194327116012573,
0.5180562138557434,
-0.35888150334358215,
0.8661796450614929,
-0.5769111514091492,
-0.0638447105884552,
-0.3314639627933502,
0.30400288105010986,
-0.6884607076644897,
0.008718046359717846,
0.2062087506055832,
-0.31439855694770813,
0.5182119607925415,
-0.45835840702056885,
-0.49258753657341003,
-0.24417752027511597,
-0.5414067506790161,
0.07818823307752609,
0.08783140778541565,
-0.3435169756412506,
0.7501208186149597,
0.6383543610572815,
-0.5263502597808838,
-0.5814839601516724,
-0.22489888966083527,
0.22095389664173126,
-0.4758923649787903,
-0.3012329339981079,
0.7174592018127441,
-0.023833567276597023,
-0.18740183115005493,
0.20440314710140228,
-0.462394118309021,
-0.34927603602409363,
0.3496420383453369,
0.44387349486351013,
0.26575717329978943,
-0.045323919504880905,
-0.12492164969444275,
0.3032701015472412,
-0.11343901604413986,
-0.022845229133963585,
-0.5477480292320251,
0.6824072599411011,
0.07727471739053726,
-0.582706868648529,
-0.07267268002033234,
1.0975415706634521,
0.7669404149055481,
-0.726264476776123,
0.2856889069080353,
0.2111949324607849,
-0.5586687326431274,
0.03640994802117348,
-0.1898803859949112,
0.1862432062625885,
-0.4092426002025604,
0.43197229504585266,
-0.7113277912139893,
-0.5469443798065186,
0.8978844285011292,
-0.19181443750858307,
0.3871842622756958,
0.7113016843795776,
0.5019617080688477,
-0.2674259543418884,
0.3092356026172638,
0.5676862597465515,
-0.27589482069015503,
0.49665263295173645,
-0.30542120337486267,
-0.2576899230480194,
-0.7305789589881897,
-0.3603678345680237,
-1.0409340858459473,
-0.15305843949317932,
-0.3720715045928955,
-0.2785496413707733,
-0.0074976845644414425,
0.14213506877422333,
0.12457499653100967,
0.6143343448638916,
-0.30973005294799805,
0.630538821220398,
0.5179032683372498,
-0.25069257616996765,
0.37144750356674194,
0.41589298844337463,
-0.09699616581201553,
0.2895132005214691,
-0.35932767391204834,
-0.3493158519268036,
1.0924543142318726,
-0.0055083888582885265,
0.434053897857666,
-0.02784872241318226,
1.0393948554992676,
0.4343990981578827,
0.3551812469959259,
-0.65956711769104,
0.2150159329175949,
-0.4333404302597046,
-0.27235138416290283,
-0.20634055137634277,
-0.36301469802856445,
-1.5076512098312378,
0.3362846076488495,
0.029011324048042297,
-0.9176310896873474,
0.3972453773021698,
-0.26179152727127075,
0.13761039078235626,
0.12590068578720093,
-0.1776222586631775,
0.9343361258506775,
0.04807902127504349,
0.00281633622944355,
0.0624481625854969,
-0.8610066771507263,
-0.24935774505138397,
-0.42260438203811646,
0.226934015750885,
0.010692901909351349,
0.2586555480957031,
0.6939282417297363,
-0.26219725608825684,
0.5979620218276978,
0.0011817000340670347,
-0.11217020452022552,
0.5315665602684021,
0.09696844220161438,
0.3054638206958771,
0.0325455367565155,
0.10057704150676727,
0.3859826922416687,
0.1013227328658104,
-0.527215838432312,
-0.664218008518219,
0.7493456602096558,
-0.5517482161521912,
-0.400481641292572,
-0.3321833908557892,
-0.7307509183883667,
-0.14188286662101746,
0.5780858993530273,
0.3555283844470978,
0.8434542417526245,
-0.4770861268043518,
0.37127357721328735,
0.3036648631095886,
0.36890074610710144,
0.4298642873764038,
0.5538216233253479,
0.16488316655158997,
-0.1415046751499176,
0.9001994729042053,
0.09352951496839523,
-0.11118407547473907,
0.9405200481414795,
0.2901797592639923,
-0.49997854232788086,
-0.8845308423042297,
-0.3108176589012146,
0.2242271900177002,
-0.937491774559021,
-0.20815663039684296,
-0.70941162109375,
-0.08415044844150543,
-0.5282312631607056,
-0.33777207136154175,
-0.1341395527124405,
-0.34337976574897766,
-0.22342711687088013,
-0.1046840026974678,
0.051897212862968445,
0.4428824782371521,
0.20077422261238098,
-0.04898097738623619,
-1.0967795848846436,
0.5531116724014282,
0.1501035839319229,
0.16391752660274506,
-0.11342226713895798,
-0.3693011999130249,
-0.07180894911289215,
-0.2263936996459961,
-0.27258744835853577,
-0.984369695186615,
0.28734245896339417,
0.09886480122804642,
0.9349524974822998,
0.573318600654602,
0.09471389651298523,
0.6509759426116943,
-0.7021560072898865,
0.4032837748527527,
0.14610934257507324,
-0.7268037796020508,
0.4796319305896759,
-0.49015381932258606,
0.06710568815469742,
0.8486639857292175,
0.5884449481964111,
-0.48826801776885986,
-0.43370023369789124,
-0.7377505898475647,
-0.9368393421173096,
0.22935931384563446,
0.18446749448776245,
0.05705663934350014,
-0.13876165449619293,
0.3949609696865082,
0.3000739514827728,
0.17244328558444977,
-0.4270073175430298,
-0.23607349395751953,
-0.34020495414733887,
-0.34533873200416565,
0.2216452658176422,
0.09349214285612106,
-0.3601033687591553,
0.2012520283460617,
0.15518245100975037,
-0.3201923370361328,
0.12215528637170792,
0.15365302562713623,
-0.1711033582687378,
0.09789019823074341,
0.2847118675708771,
0.2636352777481079,
0.881515622138977,
-0.35355344414711,
0.2587667405605316,
-0.3371542990207672,
-0.5382184982299805,
-0.23149637877941132,
0.49301034212112427,
-0.20232634246349335,
0.01384712290018797,
0.7196962237358093,
0.23241862654685974,
0.14634130895137787,
-0.5256624221801758,
0.5288150310516357,
-0.048013221472501755,
-0.3157484829425812,
-0.008963141590356827,
-0.42730793356895447,
0.24501550197601318,
0.39994096755981445,
0.2406892627477646,
-0.2451162040233612,
0.39825886487960815,
-0.6385476589202881,
0.48953011631965637,
0.6278232932090759,
-0.20546534657478333,
-0.15631678700447083,
0.4317608177661896,
0.14652276039123535,
-0.3968448042869568,
0.5202723145484924,
-0.01704287715256214,
-0.3107575476169586,
0.8274332284927368,
0.7022501230239868,
0.8500108122825623,
0.21081192791461945,
0.11933600902557373,
-0.08500275015830994,
-0.1628764420747757,
-0.025935007259249687,
0.08899734914302826,
-0.42059943079948425,
-0.5601107478141785,
0.018724966794252396,
-0.6557667255401611,
-0.3313870131969452,
-0.03572697564959526,
-1.0436781644821167,
0.1480543464422226,
-0.07937776297330856,
0.3347572386264801,
0.14366546273231506,
0.11660264432430267,
-0.5626916289329529,
0.020159441977739334,
0.0917607992887497,
0.7823020815849304,
-0.8792557120323181,
0.9827650785446167,
0.6913356184959412,
-0.4417928159236908,
-0.4508816599845886,
0.1997973918914795,
0.10286284238100052,
-0.6498113870620728,
0.3712695240974426,
0.17652352154254913,
-0.19469724595546722,
-0.10194160044193268,
0.05909721925854683,
-0.6753169894218445,
1.3393791913986206,
0.14537635445594788,
-0.6393578052520752,
-0.30833572149276733,
-0.07558052241802216,
0.4367610514163971,
-0.5151360034942627,
-0.11803233623504639,
0.20480303466320038,
0.12472075968980789,
0.116958849132061,
-0.5833379030227661,
-0.03968530893325806,
-0.45634546875953674,
-0.170796200633049,
0.45447838306427,
-0.31381955742836,
0.8203346729278564,
0.378803014755249,
-0.27206844091415405,
0.030687257647514343,
0.7363629341125488,
0.20257706940174103,
0.5462257862091064,
0.43238306045532227,
0.41615134477615356,
1.1063416004180908,
0.41602975130081177,
1.0100932121276855,
-0.4969029724597931,
0.5272994041442871,
1.2926908731460571,
-0.40260452032089233,
0.5608890056610107,
0.29654356837272644,
0.03005119599401951,
0.2573222219944,
0.4110155403614044,
-0.19355419278144836,
0.6590102314949036,
0.10525387525558472,
-0.03201521933078766,
0.05632319673895836,
-0.28131550550460815,
-0.5523015260696411,
0.5225514769554138,
0.45404866337776184,
-0.3995000720024109,
-0.6888288259506226,
-0.37120333313941956,
-0.08708397299051285,
0.18309049308300018,
-0.3080897629261017,
0.5478405952453613,
0.2173575758934021,
-0.5270122289657593,
0.10720566660165787,
0.06865601986646652,
0.18987688422203064,
-0.8285025954246521,
-0.0007335423142649233,
-0.37975671887397766,
-0.4062432646751404,
0.028551267459988594,
-0.6740107536315918,
0.5239742398262024,
0.026360323652625084,
-0.29194390773773193,
-0.34478870034217834,
0.8630690574645996,
-0.3416336476802826,
-0.2639629542827606,
0.40490394830703735,
0.8040429353713989,
0.24323992431163788,
-0.17613579332828522,
-0.6475386619567871,
-0.1853763908147812,
-0.1124809980392456,
-0.06335365027189255,
0.6980633735656738,
0.5543126463890076,
-0.5266892910003662,
0.06569240242242813,
0.655627965927124,
0.0689527690410614,
-0.34312283992767334,
0.40191981196403503,
0.9811506271362305,
-0.5362029075622559,
-0.7797029614448547,
-0.8365820050239563,
0.036166898906230927,
-0.35582560300827026,
-0.2688543200492859,
0.7449162006378174,
0.741491973400116,
0.7015125751495361,
0.07122118771076202,
0.5479607582092285,
0.04254937171936035,
0.27217885851860046,
-0.4190638065338135,
0.707725465297699,
-0.6059560775756836,
0.08320439606904984,
-0.4863041043281555,
-1.2213919162750244,
-0.46766161918640137,
0.4913368225097656,
0.11121665686368942,
-0.5112505555152893,
1.0044491291046143,
0.3121345639228821,
-0.3233897089958191,
-0.08313900232315063,
0.07412158697843552,
-0.2487298846244812,
0.4667237401008606,
0.3463345170021057,
0.4469546377658844,
0.09731151163578033,
0.6541069149971008,
0.019999900832772255,
-0.20896585285663605,
-0.041571732610464096,
-0.9029261469841003,
-0.8471291661262512,
-0.7071196436882019,
-0.507857084274292,
-0.2737155258655548,
-0.10094793885946274,
0.549181342124939,
0.330541729927063,
-0.612703263759613,
-0.014444754458963871,
-0.28959420323371887,
0.13507729768753052,
-0.2282949686050415,
-0.15446077287197113,
0.966842532157898,
0.16674962639808655,
-0.7402929067611694,
0.5317630171775818,
0.46908220648765564,
0.02177770994603634,
0.17455613613128662,
0.32273030281066895,
-0.0854988694190979,
-0.01782117784023285,
0.2984059453010559,
0.7436859011650085,
-0.41321808099746704,
-0.2962932884693146,
-0.23406927287578583,
-0.20794254541397095,
0.2916715443134308,
1.2145085334777832,
-0.3176514208316803,
0.17450933158397675,
0.836051881313324,
0.8796883225440979,
0.6936145424842834,
0.3376297652721405,
0.2684692442417145,
-0.9090222120285034,
0.08306877315044403,
0.04807395115494728,
0.8090432286262512,
0.24188679456710815,
-0.24689729511737823,
0.35275763273239136,
0.4196203351020813,
-0.11281988024711609,
-0.6154096126556396,
0.42774248123168945,
-1.349291443824768,
-0.7161443829536438,
0.8192920088768005,
-0.5542930364608765,
-0.0148038100451231,
-0.49625080823898315,
-0.05075417086482048,
0.3593430817127228,
-0.2519371211528778,
0.533544659614563,
0.5430730581283569,
0.08259758353233337,
0.164567768573761,
-0.21448476612567902,
-0.022697001695632935,
0.0189694631844759,
-1.0125861167907715,
0.16989076137542725,
0.47211533784866333,
0.4280226528644562,
0.41534310579299927,
0.94790118932724,
-0.5483952164649963,
0.21786509454250336,
0.026866009458899498,
-0.059280604124069214,
-0.2367878556251526,
-0.6544879674911499,
-0.25224608182907104,
0.7566622495651245,
-0.21443010866641998,
-0.2352098673582077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13904v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13904v1
|
Calibrating Large Language Models with Sample Consistency
| 2024-02-21T16:15:20 | 2024-02-21T16:15:20 |
Qing Lyu, Kumar Shridhar, Chaitanya Malaviya, Li Zhang, Yanai Elazar, Niket Tandon, Marianna Apidianaki, Mrinmaya Sachan, Chris Callison-Burch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Accurately gauging the confidence level of Large Language Models' (LLMs)
predictions is pivotal for their reliable application. However, LLMs are often
uncalibrated inherently and elude conventional calibration techniques due to
their proprietary nature and massive scale. In this work, we explore the
potential of deriving confidence from the distribution of multiple randomly
sampled model generations, via three measures of consistency. We perform an
extensive evaluation across various open and closed-source models on nine
reasoning datasets. Results show that consistency-based calibration methods
outperform existing post-hoc approaches. Meanwhile, we find that factors such
as intermediate explanations, model scaling, and larger sample sizes enhance
calibration, while instruction-tuning makes calibration more difficult.
Moreover, confidence scores obtained from consistency have the potential to
enhance model performance. Finally, we offer practical guidance on choosing
suitable consistency metrics for calibration, tailored to the characteristics
of various LMs.
|
[
-0.11936427652835846,
-0.23662406206130981,
0.9008117318153381,
0.05059254169464111,
0.08251214027404785,
-0.13740797340869904,
-0.6988381743431091,
-0.1876266449689865,
-0.2768813669681549,
0.5177302956581116,
-0.11468861252069473,
-0.5893750190734863,
-0.44723814725875854,
-0.022551914677023888,
-0.252892404794693,
0.4640111029148102,
-0.11670049279928207,
0.2651892304420471,
-0.3573452830314636,
-0.08169230818748474,
-0.3757662773132324,
-0.3558117151260376,
-0.32474416494369507,
-0.6480819582939148,
0.4824641942977905,
0.37827762961387634,
0.9342892169952393,
0.6926209330558777,
0.140903502702713,
0.17921574413776398,
0.08966472744941711,
0.50972580909729,
-0.5885129570960999,
0.18891453742980957,
-0.3173762261867523,
-0.5321524739265442,
-0.1123545840382576,
0.125270813703537,
0.8367571234703064,
0.8023974299430847,
-0.4465871751308441,
0.11733271926641464,
0.328023225069046,
0.4158099293708801,
-0.8270821571350098,
0.12189389020204544,
-0.7093002796173096,
-0.37426480650901794,
-0.0786520391702652,
-0.15040957927703857,
-0.8147018551826477,
-0.6622779369354248,
-0.08273693919181824,
-0.5585899949073792,
0.02596314810216427,
0.14586739242076874,
0.7204610705375671,
0.10790160298347473,
-0.48284026980400085,
-0.2152957022190094,
-1.0160678625106812,
1.281691074371338,
-0.9788651466369629,
0.44823092222213745,
0.6213138103485107,
0.4169035255908966,
-0.39814361929893494,
-0.4063316285610199,
-0.4241099953651428,
-0.27335187792778015,
0.2775254547595978,
-0.14733712375164032,
0.3033853769302368,
-0.1091635450720787,
0.1706719696521759,
0.3429339826107025,
-0.3404182195663452,
0.3419038951396942,
0.0017009340226650238,
-0.3680787980556488,
0.6176959872245789,
-0.04548198729753494,
-0.026738014072179794,
0.2757985591888428,
-0.09299284964799881,
-0.28694555163383484,
-1.0527399778366089,
-0.10183526575565338,
0.6715640425682068,
0.5338656306266785,
0.02225301042199135,
0.6808266639709473,
-0.08542626351118088,
0.8433746695518494,
-0.02843991480767727,
-0.4814968407154083,
0.2170521765947342,
-0.3493943512439728,
-0.15862292051315308,
-0.2432873696088791,
0.6666080355644226,
0.2262122482061386,
0.7145876884460449,
-0.18510381877422333,
-0.1802646368741989,
-0.19980765879154205,
0.007372978143393993,
-0.48639407753944397,
-0.27811941504478455,
0.36306148767471313,
-0.15682245790958405,
-0.13803119957447052,
0.24998827278614044,
-0.48355627059936523,
-0.5050709843635559,
-0.5242552161216736,
0.3800029456615448,
-0.22865553200244904,
-0.2840003967285156,
0.3016774356365204,
0.12910211086273193,
0.2833722233772278,
0.5949684977531433,
-0.9187320470809937,
-0.01299216877669096,
0.736452579498291,
0.4999491274356842,
-0.011508907191455364,
-0.23775573074817657,
-0.5375943779945374,
0.10793384909629822,
-0.8509122133255005,
0.5895079970359802,
-0.4395573139190674,
-0.1553473174571991,
0.18668878078460693,
-0.054881978780031204,
-0.03370526060461998,
-0.5765817761421204,
0.5736932158470154,
-0.30471161007881165,
0.04583583399653435,
-0.4231361448764801,
-0.8264803886413574,
-0.20212216675281525,
0.3141825497150421,
-0.4791210889816284,
1.0777992010116577,
0.028898771852254868,
-0.49482104182243347,
0.39115697145462036,
0.28183698654174805,
-0.028981972485780716,
-0.049631886184215546,
-0.3307979106903076,
-0.18688227236270905,
0.3229794502258301,
0.01803552731871605,
0.38758745789527893,
-0.37627172470092773,
0.4159781336784363,
-0.7584227919578552,
-0.535449743270874,
0.254279226064682,
-0.6119357943534851,
0.7112294435501099,
0.2604794502258301,
-0.04556432366371155,
-0.07357054948806763,
-0.6986953616142273,
0.5822710394859314,
-0.20388609170913696,
-0.17602410912513733,
-0.2638252079486847,
0.13762857019901276,
-0.30877941846847534,
0.019947677850723267,
0.23134437203407288,
-0.6736454367637634,
-0.08293609321117401,
-0.22727331519126892,
0.3472822308540344,
0.6951994895935059,
-0.1274971216917038,
0.25182896852493286,
-0.5488208532333374,
0.2921384274959564,
-0.10678230226039886,
-0.2464340478181839,
-0.2868329882621765,
-0.38051700592041016,
-0.5911905169487,
-0.29220613837242126,
0.551628589630127,
0.3441758453845978,
-0.07474642246961594,
0.8389160633087158,
-0.4165303409099579,
-0.6932599544525146,
-0.46335384249687195,
0.3022201359272003,
0.1127142608165741,
0.3575434982776642,
0.09001132100820541,
-0.14739713072776794,
-0.3745294511318207,
-0.7415516972541809,
-0.29939714074134827,
-0.20528459548950195,
-0.3606013357639313,
0.2550075650215149,
0.267196923494339,
0.06419695168733597,
0.8568240404129028,
-0.09463480859994888,
0.15231721103191376,
0.038320038467645645,
0.09336987137794495,
0.24871571362018585,
0.40371596813201904,
0.29589787125587463,
-0.36011144518852234,
-0.45862141251564026,
0.003384451847523451,
-0.6339880228042603,
-0.08797100186347961,
0.12212473899126053,
-0.06857696920633316,
-0.025299808010458946,
0.4848538041114807,
-0.327357679605484,
0.15827307105064392,
0.9698837399482727,
0.22323767840862274,
0.6283994317054749,
-0.42786166071891785,
0.27070751786231995,
-0.9993822574615479,
0.09822987020015717,
0.2543219029903412,
-0.45166200399398804,
-0.4954935610294342,
0.12327693402767181,
0.17538245022296906,
0.41832563281059265,
-0.20794835686683655,
0.552062451839447,
-0.5160472393035889,
-0.08171721547842026,
-0.13549718260765076,
0.31151655316352844,
0.22765950858592987,
-0.16082650423049927,
-0.03947477787733078,
0.6984344124794006,
0.3720296025276184,
-0.3892277181148529,
0.4021511971950531,
-0.04422052949666977,
-0.7016347050666809,
0.48475366830825806,
-0.7167548537254333,
0.28282833099365234,
0.017436163499951363,
0.35195890069007874,
-1.252265453338623,
-0.14917004108428955,
-0.2631591260433197,
-0.2783520817756653,
0.21588803827762604,
-0.18522201478481293,
-0.7427046895027161,
-0.1775980144739151,
-0.1648527830839157,
0.25261086225509644,
0.5008484721183777,
-0.637030839920044,
0.7188738584518433,
0.23855039477348328,
0.0775994285941124,
-0.6282682418823242,
-0.704067051410675,
-0.29465019702911377,
-0.027330370619893074,
-0.558931291103363,
-0.0758332684636116,
-0.22099138796329498,
-0.46931302547454834,
-0.3947605490684509,
-0.1660953015089035,
0.08447800576686859,
-0.10131247341632843,
0.3282015919685364,
0.21073773503303528,
-0.2162451297044754,
0.19870339334011078,
-0.3834260106086731,
0.148816779255867,
-0.2902190089225769,
-0.30201855301856995,
0.6232604384422302,
-0.05300020053982735,
-0.76851886510849,
-0.17528176307678223,
-0.010362550616264343,
0.5894032120704651,
-0.07287874817848206,
0.7568814158439636,
0.1720217913389206,
-0.43678221106529236,
-0.39160579442977905,
-0.8789474368095398,
-0.22892189025878906,
-0.4413304626941681,
0.05569429323077202,
-0.3820529282093048,
-0.7878903746604919,
0.7318047285079956,
-0.05019528046250343,
0.2972426116466522,
0.29841411113739014,
0.7515109777450562,
0.05175119265913963,
1.1125359535217285,
0.6308406591415405,
-0.028347060084342957,
-0.016833823174238205,
0.3900439739227295,
0.22064179182052612,
-0.6282068490982056,
-0.21046839654445648,
-0.8359258770942688,
-0.09617660194635391,
-0.665297269821167,
-0.653995156288147,
-0.005941999610513449,
0.22085349261760712,
-0.5251955389976501,
0.0922834649682045,
-0.10243021696805954,
0.6343986988067627,
0.7146422266960144,
0.021222466602921486,
0.43946573138237,
0.09661642462015152,
-0.35160690546035767,
-0.05652572959661484,
-0.41875457763671875,
-0.9101510643959045,
1.2626911401748657,
0.48832911252975464,
1.0550376176834106,
-0.14290867745876312,
0.6045693159103394,
-0.05547233670949936,
0.40459826588630676,
-0.5310680866241455,
0.36661532521247864,
-0.19484014809131622,
-0.7490344643592834,
-0.3594695031642914,
-0.6366413235664368,
-0.5193586349487305,
0.08471184223890305,
-0.12063766270875931,
-0.9741531014442444,
0.2227848768234253,
0.35320451855659485,
-0.3519514203071594,
0.22439278662204742,
-0.7185002565383911,
0.5443148016929626,
0.03121158853173256,
-0.28810498118400574,
-0.037120066583156586,
-0.38840174674987793,
0.5053275227546692,
-0.2119106948375702,
0.27762895822525024,
-0.5558270812034607,
0.24964964389801025,
0.24215036630630493,
-0.22764891386032104,
0.721531331539154,
0.0920998677611351,
-0.3560076653957367,
0.37734857201576233,
0.12289471179246902,
0.5157663226127625,
-0.10341142117977142,
-0.4976126253604889,
0.22200869023799896,
0.3143455386161804,
-0.3424067795276642,
-0.548276424407959,
0.872661828994751,
-0.7465708255767822,
-0.5088996887207031,
-0.1658657342195511,
-0.8814905881881714,
-0.617845356464386,
0.1891956925392151,
0.1951894313097,
0.18230405449867249,
-0.12962552905082703,
0.6109209656715393,
0.7854440212249756,
-0.1889372020959854,
0.06408272683620453,
0.4405267834663391,
-0.39241287112236023,
-0.2559241056442261,
0.5638369917869568,
0.1336977630853653,
0.7379519939422607,
0.33223339915275574,
0.18094338476657867,
-0.4511931836605072,
-0.3083140254020691,
-0.38609981536865234,
0.3021566867828369,
-0.7325771450996399,
-0.12146828323602676,
-0.0924580842256546,
-0.16719530522823334,
-0.5909715890884399,
-0.0724368765950203,
-0.543337345123291,
-0.32698893547058105,
-0.17683961987495422,
-0.07681899517774582,
0.1315697729587555,
0.5058609843254089,
-0.11994156986474991,
0.18303710222244263,
-0.6431957483291626,
-0.04520879313349724,
0.09052953124046326,
0.4492942988872528,
-0.019342472776770592,
-0.7679011225700378,
0.03789747878909111,
0.5656231045722961,
0.0310771856456995,
-0.7034732699394226,
0.1387869417667389,
0.23310060799121857,
0.7056779861450195,
0.5147705674171448,
-0.001035215798765421,
0.5125925540924072,
-0.3956810235977173,
0.6535544395446777,
0.08372210711240768,
-0.8463150858879089,
0.25106707215309143,
-0.28648561239242554,
0.3535517454147339,
0.6994881629943848,
0.3363374173641205,
-0.5015131831169128,
-0.4361594617366791,
-0.43140047788619995,
-0.4779845178127289,
0.19731155037879944,
-0.27014094591140747,
0.19814085960388184,
0.05906987935304642,
0.36222943663597107,
-0.01674378663301468,
0.11619580537080765,
-0.471627801656723,
-0.12579719722270966,
-0.010734685696661472,
-0.5807170867919922,
-0.5701209902763367,
-0.18304814398288727,
-0.3652307689189911,
0.09502193331718445,
0.7310957908630371,
-0.3444238007068634,
-0.2526474893093109,
-0.2954569458961487,
0.11044734716415405,
-0.3307631313800812,
0.297916978597641,
0.6638858318328857,
0.9523136019706726,
-0.25453197956085205,
0.43901702761650085,
-0.02136300876736641,
-0.2826734185218811,
0.28428202867507935,
0.038330256938934326,
-0.3675452172756195,
0.00151092279702425,
0.12027495354413986,
0.45954298973083496,
0.15718065202236176,
-0.7604990601539612,
0.49141430854797363,
0.1522420346736908,
-0.22698885202407837,
-0.3771849572658539,
0.12811186909675598,
0.3897824287414551,
0.07846278697252274,
0.1460157334804535,
-0.11970152705907822,
-0.3599277138710022,
-0.5030303001403809,
0.20246121287345886,
0.6218916773796082,
-0.20966105163097382,
-0.05458974465727806,
0.5096647143363953,
-0.34838807582855225,
0.10641440004110336,
0.7688232064247131,
0.09669087827205658,
-0.07144778221845627,
0.49496808648109436,
0.5001767873764038,
0.46905192732810974,
-0.4287216067314148,
0.14591652154922485,
0.4815176725387573,
0.5248017311096191,
-0.963174045085907,
0.28916093707084656,
0.37272995710372925,
-1.247053861618042,
-0.583610475063324,
-0.7743622660636902,
-0.8116984963417053,
0.20608069002628326,
-0.6745907068252563,
0.4338754713535309,
-0.42614486813545227,
-0.16683585941791534,
-0.12330775707960129,
0.13115240633487701,
-0.6585242748260498,
0.2856776714324951,
0.18163518607616425,
1.0520614385604858,
-0.9714601635932922,
0.9437018632888794,
0.3425424098968506,
-0.18740200996398926,
-1.5093915462493896,
-0.16481821238994598,
0.25239017605781555,
-0.9814978241920471,
0.16649897396564484,
0.12799513339996338,
-0.1450314223766327,
0.14774908125400543,
-0.6510513424873352,
-1.0889683961868286,
1.009169101715088,
0.637771487236023,
-0.8658124804496765,
0.05662130191922188,
0.14236140251159668,
0.45910707116127014,
-0.4365834593772888,
0.4730208218097687,
0.4781627953052521,
0.46908003091812134,
0.40124738216400146,
-0.9836205840110779,
-0.08787322044372559,
0.18242475390434265,
0.129817396402359,
-0.06870148330926895,
-0.19222335517406464,
0.6443334221839905,
-0.32108551263809204,
-0.0841498151421547,
0.32060739398002625,
0.6943477988243103,
0.9116763472557068,
-0.02358013205230236,
0.46687260270118713,
0.6611455082893372,
0.9896582961082458,
-0.3312680423259735,
0.9341751337051392,
-0.5473401546478271,
0.3991542160511017,
1.3175963163375854,
-0.49371033906936646,
1.1484471559524536,
0.39022520184516907,
-0.13482746481895447,
0.46311283111572266,
0.6081127524375916,
-0.11459467560052872,
0.232076957821846,
0.32936474680900574,
-0.2778280973434448,
-0.5231111645698547,
-0.09111926704645157,
-0.21921399235725403,
0.2677316963672638,
0.27478504180908203,
-0.4963913559913635,
-0.2061462700366974,
-0.21278917789459229,
0.0391005277633667,
0.16074417531490326,
-0.33298566937446594,
0.1728489100933075,
0.27378299832344055,
-0.8402921557426453,
0.5401109457015991,
-0.10206396877765656,
0.3386159837245941,
-0.5978226065635681,
0.13007962703704834,
-0.02964976616203785,
0.5627040863037109,
-0.09466350823640823,
-0.8816816210746765,
-0.098322793841362,
-0.26339325308799744,
-0.1313709020614624,
-0.11709526181221008,
0.5417330861091614,
-0.8235071897506714,
-0.3746371269226074,
-0.06481742113828659,
0.7250924110412598,
0.28304606676101685,
0.0793563574552536,
-0.16906701028347015,
0.24456553161144257,
-0.017199207097291946,
-0.27578628063201904,
0.3879723846912384,
0.44243305921554565,
0.15839426219463348,
0.6716323494911194,
0.5958580374717712,
0.35774853825569153,
0.16485528647899628,
0.18387259542942047,
0.2579978108406067,
-0.21111351251602173,
-0.08411318808794022,
-0.6852787137031555,
0.37797603011131287,
0.0367826446890831,
-0.29309266805648804,
0.9897087812423706,
0.42546582221984863,
0.8962897658348083,
0.17640197277069092,
0.723393976688385,
0.42390456795692444,
0.8115938305854797,
-0.42540282011032104,
0.30705100297927856,
-0.3936157822608948,
0.317117303609848,
-0.05530805513262749,
-1.0807985067367554,
-0.3810156583786011,
0.7525084614753723,
-0.4183864891529083,
0.34663912653923035,
0.4575596749782562,
0.8657187223434448,
0.038032032549381256,
0.06121399253606796,
0.5602375864982605,
0.07885333150625229,
0.3080172836780548,
0.34558194875717163,
0.619816780090332,
-0.13524453341960907,
0.24066618084907532,
-0.1587299257516861,
-0.3367065489292145,
-0.09866050630807877,
-1.3292185068130493,
-0.5178382396697998,
-0.2967706024646759,
-0.23909474909305573,
-0.5633205771446228,
-0.010882658883929253,
0.832719087600708,
0.905389130115509,
-0.9996273517608643,
-0.3272062838077545,
-0.02904697135090828,
-0.12933801114559174,
-0.22572143375873566,
-0.177324116230011,
0.005505196284502745,
-0.28213030099868774,
-0.8188501596450806,
0.2884367108345032,
0.23977650701999664,
0.020333223044872284,
-0.574876070022583,
-0.018914202228188515,
0.04705864563584328,
0.5004620552062988,
0.20484524965286255,
0.46222323179244995,
-0.8853081464767456,
-0.6665077805519104,
0.012456261552870274,
-0.4939150810241699,
-0.035002198070287704,
0.5405774712562561,
-0.39379197359085083,
0.57661372423172,
0.47906360030174255,
0.5286752581596375,
0.2493649423122406,
0.24323271214962006,
0.9544689655303955,
-0.7270349264144897,
-0.13248518109321594,
0.1216701939702034,
0.5193728804588318,
0.6067721247673035,
0.028974715620279312,
0.4199199080467224,
-0.17560003697872162,
-0.8960701823234558,
-1.0012108087539673,
0.25540709495544434,
-0.7344791293144226,
0.02240513078868389,
1.3913519382476807,
-0.47681504487991333,
0.12022340297698975,
-0.021304799243807793,
0.26664942502975464,
0.07494604587554932,
-0.13321653008460999,
0.539580762386322,
1.1837866306304932,
0.22419488430023193,
-0.2586589753627777,
-0.8312474489212036,
0.22399429976940155,
0.3379685878753662,
-0.5891997218132019,
0.3499133884906769,
0.6619757413864136,
0.49213650822639465,
0.3185499906539917,
0.4933965802192688,
-0.21484297513961792,
-0.0756065770983696,
-0.024054106324911118,
-0.00703514413908124,
0.30287012457847595,
-0.32784321904182434,
-0.2208646535873413,
0.2277255356311798,
0.45942261815071106,
0.2670632302761078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13897v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13897v2
|
Science Checker Reloaded: A Bidirectional Paradigm for Transparency and Logical Reasoning
| 2024-02-21T16:09:25 | 2024-03-14T00:21:09 |
Loïc Rakotoson, Sylvain Massip, Fréjus A. A. Laleye
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, H.3.1; H.3.3; I.7; K.4
|
Information retrieval is a rapidly evolving field. However it still faces
significant limitations in the scientific and industrial vast amounts of
information, such as semantic divergence and vocabulary gaps in sparse
retrieval, low precision and lack of interpretability in semantic search, or
hallucination and outdated information in generative models. In this paper, we
introduce a two-block approach to tackle these hurdles for long documents. The
first block enhances language understanding in sparse retrieval by query
expansion to retrieve relevant documents. The second block deepens the result
by providing comprehensive and informative answers to the complex question
using only the information spread in the long document, enabling bidirectional
engagement. At various stages of the pipeline, intermediate results are
presented to users to facilitate understanding of the system's reasoning. We
believe this bidirectional approach brings significant advancements in terms of
transparency, logical thinking, and comprehensive understanding in the field of
scientific information retrieval.
|
[
-0.01681176945567131,
-0.6551732420921326,
0.951908528804779,
0.28757965564727783,
-0.48799338936805725,
0.4364621937274933,
-0.08288086950778961,
-0.4901631474494934,
0.49692171812057495,
0.6581577658653259,
-0.5786996483802795,
-0.38150814175605774,
-0.7558889389038086,
0.194982647895813,
-0.5974135994911194,
0.909788191318512,
-0.2607118785381317,
-0.11659955233335495,
-0.5626164674758911,
0.18993183970451355,
-0.4519127309322357,
0.14535804092884064,
-0.47863608598709106,
-0.4558759033679962,
0.5629898905754089,
0.4533897638320923,
0.787752091884613,
0.561947762966156,
0.7520509958267212,
0.38411563634872437,
-0.009840047918260098,
0.22481927275657654,
-0.5329558849334717,
0.5008817315101624,
-0.7346451878547668,
-0.5807560682296753,
-0.07528112828731537,
-0.10848726332187653,
0.865114688873291,
0.8663299083709717,
-0.08444786071777344,
-0.0015559254679828882,
0.050927966833114624,
0.8288999199867249,
-0.7126003503799438,
0.35679054260253906,
-0.46335482597351074,
0.056531284004449844,
-0.23777972161769867,
-0.34395140409469604,
-0.24062280356884003,
-0.28720447421073914,
0.189436137676239,
-0.9457204937934875,
0.3371993601322174,
0.1714850515127182,
0.7549107074737549,
0.32749903202056885,
-0.6234439015388489,
-0.34016484022140503,
-0.6290768384933472,
0.8344637751579285,
-0.15102756023406982,
0.7175267934799194,
0.3290179967880249,
0.3369786739349365,
-0.3668840229511261,
-1.034132719039917,
-0.7168567180633545,
0.03708910197019577,
0.016858471557497978,
0.3439246714115143,
-0.07338368147611618,
0.021785501390695572,
0.16687248647212982,
0.26432570815086365,
-0.6068527102470398,
-0.3862118124961853,
-0.9976162314414978,
-0.35950660705566406,
0.5861853361129761,
-0.17867979407310486,
-0.04064630717039108,
-0.24975629150867462,
-0.3772585690021515,
-0.26180127263069153,
-0.5212506651878357,
-0.3572094440460205,
0.189009889960289,
0.05631081014871597,
0.2550559937953949,
0.6826329827308655,
-0.4197796583175659,
0.5269885659217834,
0.14036528766155243,
0.07412902265787125,
0.05194760859012604,
-0.6418352723121643,
-0.16549518704414368,
0.21852828562259674,
0.4964446425437927,
0.27750226855278015,
-0.38756832480430603,
-0.027537554502487183,
-0.23279935121536255,
-0.1514241248369217,
0.40353259444236755,
-0.9679542183876038,
-0.09930689632892609,
0.4998669922351837,
-0.25545692443847656,
-0.1858019083738327,
0.08356568962335587,
-0.9787994623184204,
-0.5571150779724121,
-0.4081074297428131,
0.4707793593406677,
-0.3169544041156769,
-0.1493314653635025,
0.45161017775535583,
-0.309419184923172,
0.1424122154712677,
0.716664731502533,
-0.40526434779167175,
-0.008241451345384121,
0.9756491780281067,
0.9384768605232239,
0.10586671531200409,
-0.10088598728179932,
-0.45986178517341614,
0.20106713473796844,
-0.13695375621318817,
0.9308645725250244,
-0.6234527826309204,
-0.4360824525356293,
-0.04039805382490158,
0.27297303080558777,
0.2564873993396759,
-0.33615386486053467,
0.6755451560020447,
-0.8864820599555969,
0.49014028906822205,
-0.31408214569091797,
-0.1594768613576889,
-0.34403035044670105,
0.18000449240207672,
-0.7801949977874756,
0.8359416723251343,
0.13260163366794586,
-0.8330243229866028,
0.40306520462036133,
-0.46969982981681824,
-0.43370920419692993,
0.31264227628707886,
-0.37958332896232605,
-0.12875699996948242,
-0.08556683361530304,
-0.30183151364326477,
-0.09453080594539642,
-0.5977773070335388,
0.6332492232322693,
-0.1006755530834198,
-0.29248741269111633,
-0.07576683908700943,
-0.05855590105056763,
0.5909157991409302,
0.31582871079444885,
-0.36730682849884033,
0.26537495851516724,
-0.692768394947052,
0.04775521531701088,
-0.18772587180137634,
-0.5112736225128174,
-0.27715352177619934,
0.22338984906673431,
-0.12664355337619781,
0.15495793521404266,
0.5157943964004517,
-0.9073609709739685,
0.021244654431939125,
-0.2367088496685028,
0.37024733424186707,
0.632301390171051,
-0.3315284550189972,
0.3021164536476135,
-0.12617555260658264,
0.25128912925720215,
0.12219749391078949,
0.19656048715114594,
-0.022058570757508278,
-0.29273995757102966,
-0.7536752820014954,
-0.34962281584739685,
0.4099794030189514,
0.6103231906890869,
-0.7917085886001587,
0.5693941712379456,
-0.21815021336078644,
-0.2646218538284302,
-0.7883039712905884,
0.16958798468112946,
0.3691646158695221,
0.6117700934410095,
0.6052414774894714,
-0.6373712420463562,
-0.6329139471054077,
-1.0514588356018066,
-0.23844055831432343,
-0.25480833649635315,
-0.28926217555999756,
0.3313041925430298,
0.6575025320053101,
-0.3861192762851715,
0.8251047134399414,
-0.6309958696365356,
0.12609554827213287,
0.05071503296494484,
0.2051614224910736,
0.27972978353500366,
0.4584079384803772,
-0.4185959994792938,
-1.0891718864440918,
-0.12959334254264832,
-0.04812730476260185,
-0.8461408615112305,
0.013452576473355293,
-0.12811461091041565,
-0.5083920359611511,
-0.07505763322114944,
0.4738730192184448,
-0.7894664406776428,
0.4571217894554138,
-0.03938186541199684,
-0.5427022576332092,
0.5330063104629517,
-0.21165071427822113,
0.22023676335811615,
-0.7937438488006592,
0.20956578850746155,
-0.16178745031356812,
-0.2990599572658539,
-0.36358562111854553,
0.2157057672739029,
0.3677064776420593,
-0.11825147271156311,
-0.1841125786304474,
0.2313574105501175,
-0.5092965960502625,
0.06414703279733658,
-0.4377380311489105,
0.6027590036392212,
0.5378307700157166,
-0.23517164587974548,
0.1169084757566452,
0.5731011629104614,
0.404264360666275,
-0.3593980073928833,
0.6727610230445862,
0.22301729023456573,
-0.24715939164161682,
0.6417380571365356,
-0.8891764283180237,
-0.008012000471353531,
-0.6957136988639832,
0.3897058963775635,
-0.939605712890625,
-0.3401434123516083,
0.0006882271845825016,
-0.2646649181842804,
0.7268798351287842,
0.1730927973985672,
-0.3913075923919678,
-0.5795238018035889,
-0.47993770241737366,
0.4598965048789978,
0.20027971267700195,
-0.6209684610366821,
0.5271137952804565,
0.020464075729250908,
-0.2026711404323578,
-0.8685970902442932,
-0.4069518446922302,
0.15031340718269348,
0.38360413908958435,
-0.9536154866218567,
0.33842456340789795,
-0.0881943330168724,
-0.4012026786804199,
-0.06040532514452934,
-0.658099889755249,
-0.04188453033566475,
-0.2027391642332077,
0.13091430068016052,
0.45060741901397705,
-0.024481210857629776,
0.15364204347133636,
0.2838882505893707,
-0.09589818865060806,
0.2354411482810974,
-0.5661770105361938,
0.31414994597435,
-0.20439116656780243,
-0.3412765562534332,
-0.1966598927974701,
0.6538006067276001,
0.8211891651153564,
-0.11979144811630249,
0.6084839105606079,
0.4103299081325531,
-0.42426469922065735,
0.21283350884914398,
-0.7779948115348816,
-0.4550205171108246,
-0.4980852007865906,
0.5978085398674011,
-0.21498338878154755,
-0.9229674339294434,
0.1659676879644394,
-0.29731571674346924,
-0.12741440534591675,
0.46470654010772705,
0.23224158585071564,
-0.14912866055965424,
0.6527899503707886,
0.8166959285736084,
0.38702020049095154,
0.05078546330332756,
-0.06595071405172348,
0.48219579458236694,
-0.8373898267745972,
-1.042437195777893,
-0.5448198914527893,
-0.07333724200725555,
-0.3936743438243866,
-0.8081222176551819,
0.2810169458389282,
0.4371163249015808,
-0.24846220016479492,
0.18179680407047272,
-0.8241447806358337,
0.5299403071403503,
0.45478785037994385,
0.33567869663238525,
0.43347790837287903,
0.04998219013214111,
-0.07103131711483002,
0.0315813310444355,
-0.4386611878871918,
-0.3891161382198334,
0.9235974550247192,
0.1706465631723404,
0.8866571187973022,
0.30978119373321533,
0.583332359790802,
0.16311198472976685,
0.12458992749452591,
-0.7672903537750244,
0.47463780641555786,
0.2775978744029999,
-0.6995155215263367,
-0.3139268755912781,
-0.24298089742660522,
-0.959385097026825,
0.44675251841545105,
-0.15991532802581787,
-0.3458850681781769,
0.613636314868927,
-0.1634267419576645,
-0.13183797895908356,
0.09008541703224182,
-0.5642329454421997,
0.59085613489151,
-0.18955370783805847,
-1.0284931659698486,
-0.5465169548988342,
-1.07563316822052,
0.339871883392334,
-0.37992557883262634,
0.16411583125591278,
0.17450696229934692,
-0.1780196726322174,
0.8634433150291443,
-0.2391924113035202,
0.6909254193305969,
0.10270463675260544,
-0.030482176691293716,
0.21894091367721558,
0.29426586627960205,
0.5980045795440674,
0.2841293215751648,
-0.14849697053432465,
-0.034896448254585266,
0.25545811653137207,
-0.6960521936416626,
-0.6232379674911499,
0.7968034744262695,
-0.5258800387382507,
-1.175828218460083,
-0.7912581562995911,
-0.6520920395851135,
0.13242997229099274,
0.7249860763549805,
-0.12912823259830475,
0.008641279302537441,
0.1131194531917572,
0.44956105947494507,
0.9452638030052185,
0.12356098741292953,
0.01950998045504093,
0.8374577164649963,
-0.024908993393182755,
-0.13371482491493225,
0.6125884056091309,
-0.16130287945270538,
0.1701728105545044,
0.5213636755943298,
0.02186131663620472,
-0.6025210022926331,
-0.348886102437973,
-0.2766391336917877,
0.5602713823318481,
-0.744826078414917,
-0.3361632823944092,
-0.6847214102745056,
-0.010705970227718353,
-0.44953712821006775,
-0.20302851498126984,
-0.3191276788711548,
-0.45145609974861145,
-0.18909721076488495,
-0.013348417356610298,
0.12330640107393265,
0.7291296720504761,
-0.21579056978225708,
-0.38241633772850037,
-0.538840115070343,
0.22591151297092438,
0.2890433073043823,
0.4274170696735382,
-0.3442700505256653,
-0.3956894278526306,
-0.09959416091442108,
-0.03406849503517151,
-0.48632389307022095,
-1.0320453643798828,
0.03939791023731232,
-0.06870599091053009,
0.36432889103889465,
0.5305256843566895,
-0.0589851550757885,
0.5058093070983887,
-0.44938334822654724,
0.5543926954269409,
0.4056795835494995,
-0.7430298328399658,
0.8338345885276794,
-0.10963533073663712,
0.03118899278342724,
0.7106730341911316,
0.692215621471405,
-0.5069994926452637,
-0.11565900593996048,
-0.48869532346725464,
-0.923067569732666,
0.4622454345226288,
0.022119048982858658,
-0.19180326163768768,
0.07554372400045395,
0.4257497787475586,
0.11206258088350296,
0.4931713938713074,
-0.2726381719112396,
0.10188086330890656,
-0.6948336958885193,
0.027656327933073044,
0.19612474739551544,
-0.3670022785663605,
-0.5121158361434937,
-0.2642833888530731,
0.645423412322998,
-0.2435685694217682,
0.08085697144269943,
0.7660958170890808,
0.015354647301137447,
-0.2060907632112503,
0.6577405333518982,
0.4835996925830841,
0.7998193502426147,
-0.5684008598327637,
0.4721262753009796,
-0.3167724907398224,
-0.7806166410446167,
-0.03237120807170868,
0.3459828794002533,
-0.313068151473999,
-0.15803156793117523,
0.22271236777305603,
0.38359320163726807,
0.07112688571214676,
-0.7183533906936646,
0.45515456795692444,
0.27096620202064514,
-0.33224353194236755,
-0.0002579491410870105,
-0.14684265851974487,
0.034744493663311005,
0.5238488912582397,
0.3682066798210144,
0.053587451577186584,
0.4545493423938751,
-0.8127204775810242,
0.2657880187034607,
0.5138309597969055,
-0.45017215609550476,
-0.06405045837163925,
0.7014331221580505,
0.21710000932216644,
-0.07020793855190277,
0.8196049928665161,
-0.2644166648387909,
-0.5491262078285217,
0.5091357827186584,
0.8717970848083496,
0.6845203638076782,
0.0807914212346077,
0.30773234367370605,
0.42513737082481384,
0.5358974933624268,
-0.20792800188064575,
0.3843533396720886,
-0.41017186641693115,
-0.45973217487335205,
-0.47771644592285156,
-0.6707852482795715,
-0.5137942433357239,
-0.09208869189023972,
-0.7259979248046875,
0.10503678768873215,
-0.4878416955471039,
0.03291485458612442,
0.08521731942892075,
0.33886435627937317,
-0.342743843793869,
0.08596829324960709,
-0.20139972865581512,
1.1655001640319824,
-0.5144411325454712,
0.605891227722168,
0.4106786251068115,
-0.47866857051849365,
-0.3335154354572296,
-0.28035470843315125,
0.0463392399251461,
-0.6095852851867676,
0.9351518750190735,
0.06481247395277023,
-0.4397228956222534,
-0.3098506033420563,
-0.7061578631401062,
-1.1301465034484863,
1.4185948371887207,
-0.11999370157718658,
-0.7527677416801453,
0.2381163090467453,
-0.15903683006763458,
0.4753096401691437,
-0.04080944135785103,
0.2742677927017212,
0.6154031753540039,
0.7654138803482056,
0.5058830976486206,
-0.7666544914245605,
0.5936605334281921,
-0.35616201162338257,
-0.22401167452335358,
0.3053254783153534,
-0.6547673940658569,
0.7433717846870422,
-0.3560904562473297,
-0.5138596892356873,
-0.12464482337236404,
0.9340980052947998,
0.29209983348846436,
0.5528697371482849,
0.3526512086391449,
0.23124761879444122,
1.1609671115875244,
-0.14141066372394562,
0.9339362978935242,
-0.2556484341621399,
0.35433679819107056,
0.866245448589325,
-0.5286617875099182,
0.7220733165740967,
0.8331496119499207,
-0.21232135593891144,
0.7687681913375854,
0.49068671464920044,
-0.03272530436515808,
0.5398826599121094,
0.32070738077163696,
-0.6330369710922241,
-0.343557208776474,
-0.45158621668815613,
-0.4651477634906769,
0.07639854401350021,
0.6232154965400696,
-0.08454123884439468,
-0.3757183849811554,
-0.2517947256565094,
0.1494724601507187,
0.014683835208415985,
-0.07513333112001419,
0.23529589176177979,
-0.13225622475147247,
-0.7866447567939758,
0.41236355900764465,
0.14677651226520538,
0.5763570070266724,
-0.5792950987815857,
-0.2001871019601822,
-0.1686762124300003,
0.031062260270118713,
-0.5183908343315125,
-1.0166091918945312,
0.25668883323669434,
-0.3039049804210663,
-0.407698392868042,
-0.007381726987659931,
1.1233259439468384,
-0.5532621145248413,
-0.34895026683807373,
0.2305033653974533,
0.2806544899940491,
0.20095722377300262,
0.06269780546426773,
-0.6477603912353516,
-0.09260343015193939,
0.12863774597644806,
0.00004641486520995386,
-0.012417408637702465,
0.29610663652420044,
-0.15222327411174774,
0.7403255701065063,
0.8634467124938965,
-0.06269508600234985,
-0.14656676352024078,
-0.10734385251998901,
1.1385138034820557,
-0.7090717554092407,
-0.3099578320980072,
-0.3718887269496918,
0.15099889039993286,
-0.40892282128334045,
0.19642212986946106,
0.6247379779815674,
0.8781588077545166,
0.7211008071899414,
0.17627215385437012,
0.7702587842941284,
-0.09032999724149704,
0.23578083515167236,
-0.3280537724494934,
0.5174332857131958,
-0.5976691842079163,
0.2795180082321167,
0.13828839361667633,
-0.6806132793426514,
-0.4352140426635742,
0.6723026633262634,
-0.3509606420993805,
-0.08938022702932358,
1.1162482500076294,
0.9178081154823303,
-0.09578763693571091,
0.2585429251194,
-0.03212475776672363,
0.36832618713378906,
0.25360551476478577,
0.5558800101280212,
0.7448493242263794,
-0.40273943543434143,
0.33777639269828796,
-0.1514517366886139,
-0.578708827495575,
-0.21927671134471893,
-0.7732940912246704,
-0.6641731262207031,
-0.4590369760990143,
-0.26568838953971863,
-0.8005805015563965,
0.16116386651992798,
0.5081591606140137,
0.6242772936820984,
-0.6819874048233032,
0.06713908910751343,
-0.0626726970076561,
0.5247257947921753,
0.2236880213022232,
-0.26928114891052246,
0.5381792187690735,
-0.2508697807788849,
-0.5194812417030334,
0.5933141708374023,
0.6440490484237671,
-0.17067119479179382,
-0.40623950958251953,
0.0986533835530281,
-0.3214622735977173,
0.38482803106307983,
0.6846961975097656,
0.5487308502197266,
-0.5836703777313232,
-0.2779754102230072,
0.002041842322796583,
-0.13433676958084106,
-0.08495467901229858,
0.9514636397361755,
-0.7549249529838562,
0.8313918113708496,
0.7419518232345581,
0.36631688475608826,
0.8119905591011047,
-0.10914698243141174,
0.345564603805542,
-0.45194563269615173,
0.12407782673835754,
0.22302557528018951,
0.17397482693195343,
0.32059136033058167,
-0.6178629994392395,
0.44355589151382446,
0.42524468898773193,
-0.5385963320732117,
-0.7971498966217041,
0.3312109112739563,
-1.1749895811080933,
-0.3862427771091461,
0.8794695734977722,
0.32462620735168457,
-0.38010552525520325,
-0.47403234243392944,
-0.04950036481022835,
0.3545631170272827,
-0.3642061948776245,
0.9163824319839478,
0.631446897983551,
-0.12748998403549194,
0.2147592157125473,
-0.5069277882575989,
0.2931528687477112,
0.6175181865692139,
-0.6982697248458862,
-0.0691569522023201,
0.635898768901825,
0.28978922963142395,
0.6772434711456299,
0.45218268036842346,
-0.43299251794815063,
0.3991541862487793,
0.1043243408203125,
0.009218983352184296,
-0.0901055783033371,
-0.6655940413475037,
-0.0635925903916359,
0.09558931738138199,
-0.22223730385303497,
0.014671476557850838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13887v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13887v1
|
Beyond Probabilities: Unveiling the Misalignment in Evaluating Large Language Models
| 2024-02-21T15:58:37 | 2024-02-21T15:58:37 |
Chenyang Lyu, Minghao Wu, Alham Fikri Aji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across
various applications, fundamentally reshaping the landscape of natural language
processing (NLP) research. However, recent evaluation frameworks often rely on
the output probabilities of LLMs for predictions, primarily due to
computational constraints, diverging from real-world LLM usage scenarios. While
widely employed, the efficacy of these probability-based evaluation strategies
remains an open research question. This study aims to scrutinize the validity
of such probability-based evaluation methods within the context of using LLMs
for Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs), highlighting their inherent limitations.
Our empirical investigation reveals that the prevalent probability-based
evaluation method inadequately aligns with generation-based prediction.
Furthermore, current evaluation frameworks typically assess LLMs through
predictive tasks based on output probabilities rather than directly generating
responses, owing to computational limitations. We illustrate that these
probability-based approaches do not effectively correspond with generative
predictions. The outcomes of our study can enhance the understanding of LLM
evaluation methodologies and provide insights for future research in this
domain.
|
[
-0.37119799852371216,
-0.6294897198677063,
0.917544424533844,
0.18028971552848816,
-0.11918336898088455,
0.005161629058420658,
-0.42900219559669495,
-0.21267062425613403,
-0.17964856326580048,
0.33366790413856506,
-0.5621472001075745,
-0.18592625856399536,
-0.5653893947601318,
0.11148008704185486,
-0.1806800663471222,
0.6949701309204102,
0.17259061336517334,
0.23264946043491364,
-0.7479441165924072,
0.06923916935920715,
-0.4510973393917084,
-0.6544173955917358,
-0.5232484936714172,
-0.5038527250289917,
0.4928011894226074,
0.220834881067276,
0.7572196125984192,
0.1390097290277481,
0.7547497153282166,
0.18079687654972076,
0.10403138399124146,
0.046604759991168976,
-0.2654353678226471,
0.10110803693532944,
-0.10464692115783691,
-0.41108423471450806,
0.001334616681560874,
0.06381496787071228,
0.8416794538497925,
0.8984784483909607,
-0.37190568447113037,
0.10912362486124039,
0.15218989551067352,
0.5926715731620789,
-0.8616368174552917,
-0.0553758442401886,
-0.8613497018814087,
0.31360703706741333,
-0.3909372389316559,
-0.2331138551235199,
-0.7556051015853882,
-0.3368954360485077,
0.12369409948587418,
-0.06625017523765564,
-0.0695275142788887,
0.09710319340229034,
0.4354467988014221,
0.08380044251680374,
-0.37874695658683777,
-0.42291343212127686,
-0.9877316355705261,
1.054591178894043,
-0.9190291166305542,
0.3623383343219757,
0.275724321603775,
0.44379308819770813,
-0.5605952143669128,
-0.2562630772590637,
-0.6620307564735413,
-0.43538227677345276,
0.3987099528312683,
0.14700700342655182,
-0.17528636753559113,
-0.04938359931111336,
0.22160327434539795,
0.34340378642082214,
-0.5479758381843567,
0.49400418996810913,
-0.03519482910633087,
-0.10209216922521591,
0.704841673374176,
0.26016902923583984,
0.012427223846316338,
-0.3473076820373535,
-0.38783130049705505,
0.014354478567838669,
-0.7372077107429504,
0.10368601977825165,
0.5097538232803345,
0.4150863289833069,
0.11866956204175949,
0.9301748871803284,
0.28170496225357056,
0.9494505524635315,
-0.11018752306699753,
-0.22001686692237854,
0.19083037972450256,
-0.09757809340953827,
-0.30372095108032227,
-0.15701760351657867,
0.994066596031189,
0.3997300863265991,
0.32439514994621277,
-0.11509737372398376,
-0.0061049629002809525,
-0.06930682808160782,
0.31944918632507324,
-0.3339976966381073,
0.21802963316440582,
0.481579065322876,
-0.2995399534702301,
-0.3240872025489807,
0.11363682150840759,
-0.7189982533454895,
-0.5441495776176453,
0.005083464551717043,
0.2768300771713257,
-0.35793787240982056,
-0.2930593192577362,
0.1537269502878189,
-0.06038421392440796,
0.06386489421129227,
0.10921367257833481,
-0.7091549038887024,
-0.03135206550359726,
0.7561309933662415,
0.567795991897583,
-0.22268174588680267,
-0.23521003127098083,
-0.4622286260128021,
0.026372605934739113,
-0.5050461888313293,
0.6516558527946472,
-0.7217426896095276,
-0.4802432656288147,
0.13160640001296997,
-0.290235310792923,
-0.2771112322807312,
-0.6648104786872864,
0.8172744512557983,
-0.6027358770370483,
0.027509232982993126,
-0.2232874184846878,
-0.6716930866241455,
-0.004074344411492348,
0.21573412418365479,
-0.6730074882507324,
0.7231825590133667,
-0.11900719255208969,
-0.8493968844413757,
0.4435409903526306,
-0.3010440766811371,
-0.25569772720336914,
-0.028304442763328552,
-0.37863442301750183,
-0.34999096393585205,
0.4043002128601074,
-0.07153204083442688,
0.539009690284729,
-0.5031645894050598,
0.714768648147583,
-0.6869279742240906,
-0.2576850652694702,
0.7035616040229797,
-0.9000680446624756,
0.676515519618988,
0.23428478837013245,
-0.1348222941160202,
-0.20547764003276825,
-0.7183041572570801,
0.0246987733989954,
0.008432034403085709,
-0.4803154766559601,
-0.14005377888679504,
0.4579123258590698,
-0.373738169670105,
0.4903316795825958,
0.03725726157426834,
-0.4976724088191986,
0.011220702901482582,
-0.608896017074585,
0.20260421931743622,
0.7292978763580322,
-0.19941428303718567,
0.4449712634086609,
-0.41800451278686523,
0.7539350390434265,
-0.10927541553974152,
0.11311359703540802,
0.3488333225250244,
-0.5834351778030396,
-0.3335205018520355,
0.18993587791919708,
0.28934794664382935,
0.47467219829559326,
-0.7238926887512207,
0.3628180921077728,
-0.30496224761009216,
-0.6915913224220276,
-0.35825493931770325,
0.03008480742573738,
0.3411150574684143,
0.2840990722179413,
0.046868205070495605,
-0.29641109704971313,
-0.6287696361541748,
-0.8671875596046448,
-0.4617609977722168,
-0.3494301438331604,
-0.056654613465070724,
0.13367219269275665,
0.4004227817058563,
0.014287140220403671,
1.0666396617889404,
-0.24833142757415771,
-0.057453155517578125,
-0.49472576379776,
-0.019817516207695007,
0.40152043104171753,
0.35069775581359863,
0.24737663567066193,
-0.5845881700515747,
-0.02227219007909298,
-0.21076704561710358,
-0.5755360722541809,
0.08394908905029297,
-0.12910854816436768,
0.20866981148719788,
0.33834323287010193,
0.18146105110645294,
-0.9093953967094421,
0.25290447473526,
0.8671960234642029,
0.008829783648252487,
1.009361982345581,
-0.06355790048837662,
0.10959552973508835,
-0.7380062937736511,
-0.19285620748996735,
0.10127084702253342,
0.07882024347782135,
-0.3989705741405487,
-0.03247431293129921,
-0.13863900303840637,
0.1226845309138298,
-0.4856700599193573,
0.4250086545944214,
-0.34879270195961,
-0.32696762681007385,
-0.07805024087429047,
0.16867217421531677,
-0.17546266317367554,
-0.07580529898405075,
-0.027526887133717537,
0.598199725151062,
0.28979647159576416,
-0.611445426940918,
0.11544497311115265,
-0.09149041771888733,
-0.7340973019599915,
0.29663944244384766,
-0.19026093184947968,
-0.020281348377466202,
-0.24285198748111725,
0.37305790185928345,
-0.9852936267852783,
-0.042987413704395294,
0.1265082061290741,
-0.4284576177597046,
0.31984883546829224,
0.04373757168650627,
-0.61229008436203,
-0.5903564691543579,
-0.46247097849845886,
0.30399298667907715,
0.3618485927581787,
-0.3282681703567505,
0.4950118660926819,
0.23866517841815948,
-0.04437968507409096,
-0.8865110278129578,
-0.725770890712738,
0.05127730220556259,
-0.4413096308708191,
-0.6187748908996582,
0.2725295424461365,
-0.03860180824995041,
-0.693906843662262,
-0.3527757227420807,
-0.20498259365558624,
0.3419318199157715,
0.25340914726257324,
0.34510505199432373,
0.1789143830537796,
-0.21230168640613556,
0.32674509286880493,
-0.13623079657554626,
0.07661476731300354,
0.0865267887711525,
-0.12996917963027954,
0.6950873732566833,
0.13240569829940796,
-0.8144512176513672,
0.041667744517326355,
0.10977017134428024,
0.277082622051239,
-0.07447924464941025,
0.8202477097511292,
0.5371344089508057,
-0.3982003927230835,
-0.17090652883052826,
-0.724115788936615,
0.14730635285377502,
-0.4123421907424927,
0.4569444954395294,
-0.4276874363422394,
-1.0478700399398804,
0.416006475687027,
-0.020603232085704803,
0.0862157791852951,
0.6695564389228821,
0.6892630457878113,
-0.419315904378891,
0.9540559649467468,
0.3974299132823944,
0.3603411018848419,
0.18557791411876678,
0.020454907789826393,
0.5675560832023621,
-1.0847830772399902,
-0.21590465307235718,
-0.5853838920593262,
-0.06713568419218063,
-0.6176593899726868,
-0.6114516854286194,
0.10776785016059875,
0.3244940936565399,
-0.1664777547121048,
0.1502961665391922,
-0.0442889966070652,
0.25356006622314453,
0.2932945787906647,
-0.284726619720459,
0.32824063301086426,
-0.019045010209083557,
-0.2069789320230484,
-0.31730252504348755,
-0.9982911944389343,
-0.8933696150779724,
1.4813538789749146,
0.40786460041999817,
0.5657472610473633,
0.17995788156986237,
0.5615352988243103,
0.2332727313041687,
0.572878897190094,
-0.7192506790161133,
0.559114396572113,
-0.2945113182067871,
-0.6854895949363708,
-0.5942626595497131,
-0.5014709234237671,
-1.0834985971450806,
0.474443644285202,
-0.3488773703575134,
-1.111309289932251,
0.1591876596212387,
-0.06459550559520721,
-0.5173323750495911,
0.4978298246860504,
-0.5144826173782349,
0.692906379699707,
-0.34570664167404175,
-0.28193962574005127,
-0.028755733743309975,
-0.3430255353450775,
0.5912505388259888,
-0.3337901532649994,
0.7309136390686035,
-0.20573213696479797,
0.21693675220012665,
0.8008496761322021,
-0.2365472912788391,
0.569481372833252,
-0.015196296386420727,
-0.5111656785011292,
0.4128185212612152,
0.1590583771467209,
0.19618496298789978,
0.09131749719381332,
-0.585437536239624,
0.06575340777635574,
-0.04317435994744301,
-0.004736201837658882,
-0.505670428276062,
0.7940146923065186,
-0.4536757469177246,
-0.8318353295326233,
-0.4975837469100952,
-0.526543140411377,
-0.6105863451957703,
-0.16635414958000183,
0.3369564712047577,
0.3474731743335724,
-0.3170558512210846,
0.0378076545894146,
0.3760124146938324,
-0.5481951236724854,
0.6278198957443237,
0.2738663852214813,
-0.382655531167984,
-0.3233133554458618,
0.86323082447052,
0.31445765495300293,
0.44571202993392944,
0.38884589076042175,
0.2594716250896454,
-0.5578712821006775,
-0.7188182473182678,
-0.35203316807746887,
0.1264776587486267,
-0.7705234885215759,
-0.10146603733301163,
-0.3610561490058899,
-0.0439162515103817,
-0.4334143400192261,
-0.13562098145484924,
-0.1916009932756424,
-0.30483174324035645,
-0.3032492697238922,
-0.14563623070716858,
-0.23854006826877594,
0.5427402853965759,
0.021657289937138557,
0.2061832845211029,
-0.7744886875152588,
0.03135225176811218,
0.23254714906215668,
0.3055414855480194,
0.19061179459095,
-0.41944682598114014,
0.006677586119621992,
0.13147501647472382,
-0.49901083111763,
-0.9834256172180176,
0.19223365187644958,
0.09494583308696747,
0.7265110015869141,
0.3616905212402344,
-0.002857526531443,
0.5586570501327515,
-0.48628079891204834,
0.9168394804000854,
0.4078085124492645,
-0.6577612161636353,
0.3346642553806305,
-0.22621053457260132,
0.165766179561615,
0.5440481305122375,
0.3493751287460327,
-0.11142998188734055,
-0.4341559410095215,
-0.7507864236831665,
-0.7581778168678284,
0.4853435456752777,
0.24321193993091583,
0.18492025136947632,
-0.2289077788591385,
0.15796704590320587,
0.2302064299583435,
0.3672219216823578,
-0.8301716446876526,
-0.05609070509672165,
0.45381927490234375,
-0.10992435365915298,
-0.47133567929267883,
-0.3875495195388794,
0.0826253816485405,
0.009066966362297535,
0.6936405897140503,
0.002556264167651534,
0.2552321255207062,
0.05871579051017761,
-0.188802570104599,
-0.2015478014945984,
0.5820406079292297,
0.5860576629638672,
0.9396779537200928,
-0.2854149639606476,
0.08162251859903336,
0.17558756470680237,
-0.13017268478870392,
0.14766795933246613,
0.09498727321624756,
-0.05048219487071037,
0.08867836743593216,
0.5231189131736755,
0.6005914211273193,
0.2613130509853363,
-0.866511881351471,
0.506193220615387,
0.16587941348552704,
-0.094411201775074,
-0.5039190649986267,
-0.021770497784018517,
0.3087781071662903,
0.23627209663391113,
0.44829514622688293,
-0.01681898906826973,
0.09643471986055374,
-0.8140616416931152,
0.03986286744475365,
0.8095579147338867,
-0.32918670773506165,
0.022909482941031456,
0.5100238919258118,
-0.17565007507801056,
-0.46967455744743347,
0.4577479362487793,
-0.13031786680221558,
-0.3583504855632782,
0.7735512256622314,
0.5124403834342957,
0.7462255358695984,
-0.19015632569789886,
0.33485734462738037,
0.15580551326274872,
0.4343864321708679,
-0.19330911338329315,
0.2777475118637085,
0.2168789952993393,
-1.038844347000122,
-0.7886106371879578,
-1.0513136386871338,
-0.32242944836616516,
0.28105053305625916,
-0.36599841713905334,
0.2841621935367584,
-0.24414898455142975,
-0.6278293132781982,
-0.021650977432727814,
-0.12397979199886322,
-0.6195781230926514,
0.28804248571395874,
0.304779976606369,
0.8350854516029358,
-0.7196651697158813,
0.5027082562446594,
0.6813338994979858,
-0.21734924614429474,
-0.6205828189849854,
0.17532005906105042,
-0.13284948468208313,
-0.6082394123077393,
0.4736493229866028,
0.14099149405956268,
0.019238704815506935,
-0.2802174985408783,
-0.2653374671936035,
-0.8037375807762146,
0.8274840712547302,
0.5378583669662476,
-0.9366896152496338,
0.0234361719340086,
0.5125899314880371,
0.5289694666862488,
-0.34807753562927246,
0.38393110036849976,
0.605034589767456,
0.5617457628250122,
-0.01142906118184328,
-1.0622718334197998,
-0.11447691172361374,
0.07669389992952347,
0.24448810517787933,
0.07603982836008072,
-0.4131595194339752,
0.7206178307533264,
-0.4758703410625458,
-0.1845138967037201,
-0.06160740554332733,
0.40778055787086487,
0.8035260438919067,
0.34090372920036316,
0.4719116985797882,
0.6401437520980835,
0.4902912676334381,
-0.11044459789991379,
1.2708522081375122,
0.10827817022800446,
0.455822616815567,
1.0823220014572144,
-0.48551493883132935,
1.0416312217712402,
0.8539395332336426,
-0.7345424890518188,
0.41278794407844543,
0.7866983413696289,
0.11501467227935791,
0.27386796474456787,
0.7579826712608337,
-0.13860642910003662,
-0.45955419540405273,
0.042472224682569504,
-0.2882046103477478,
0.5397014617919922,
0.34973403811454773,
-0.3337969481945038,
-0.20037490129470825,
-0.06808126717805862,
-0.26794594526290894,
0.10061187297105789,
-0.14630337059497833,
0.5265699625015259,
0.33009207248687744,
-0.7798388004302979,
0.3009997010231018,
0.17380142211914062,
0.776192307472229,
-0.46939557790756226,
0.04340225085616112,
0.206638902425766,
-0.07081321626901627,
-0.34184983372688293,
-1.0320795774459839,
0.3485105633735657,
-0.0900578573346138,
-0.018904980272054672,
-0.017167726531624794,
0.7135738730430603,
-0.10037271678447723,
-0.6895714402198792,
0.2392708659172058,
0.6893838047981262,
0.061830125749111176,
-0.057956647127866745,
-0.543597936630249,
0.13861630856990814,
-0.043388910591602325,
-0.34695178270339966,
0.5787138342857361,
0.34449082612991333,
-0.033031098544597626,
0.8392919898033142,
0.6704665422439575,
0.10093490034341812,
-0.12171655148267746,
0.3205612003803253,
0.2932269275188446,
-0.4254421889781952,
-0.18104097247123718,
-1.1540839672088623,
0.5573856830596924,
0.28441983461380005,
-0.31965455412864685,
0.793062150478363,
0.5401433110237122,
0.835013747215271,
-0.12675148248672485,
0.8987016081809998,
0.08569276332855225,
0.2077370434999466,
-0.6892112493515015,
0.26950404047966003,
-0.35715964436531067,
0.6831062436103821,
-0.5335800647735596,
-1.117266058921814,
-0.36118802428245544,
0.45812758803367615,
-0.7313670516014099,
0.14943714439868927,
0.6000936031341553,
0.37729305028915405,
0.2845672070980072,
-0.06444069743156433,
0.4467247724533081,
-0.05139834061264992,
0.20359593629837036,
0.6515358686447144,
1.2822710275650024,
-0.16229870915412903,
0.40808990597724915,
-0.14639882743358612,
-0.000873786339070648,
-0.2320358157157898,
-1.082257628440857,
-0.5841882824897766,
-0.5188409686088562,
-0.22901619970798492,
-0.19525445997714996,
-0.0060567427426576614,
0.7103057503700256,
0.10869202762842178,
-0.639350175857544,
-0.42531704902648926,
-0.025406785309314728,
0.28255680203437805,
-0.09671606123447418,
-0.28138014674186707,
0.25348493456840515,
-0.2158975750207901,
-0.46688759326934814,
0.3426392078399658,
0.3431646525859833,
-0.044228848069906235,
-0.45887014269828796,
-0.09547678381204605,
-0.2546376585960388,
0.07814805954694748,
0.7124593257904053,
-0.0015364894643425941,
-0.9129899740219116,
-0.30360835790634155,
-0.20750294625759125,
0.14435513317584991,
-0.03355583921074867,
0.50008225440979,
-0.6730524897575378,
0.23825807869434357,
0.3621582090854645,
0.6092511415481567,
0.10474386811256409,
0.040003981441259384,
0.8640451431274414,
-0.5326016545295715,
-0.2596728205680847,
0.48179686069488525,
0.4330785274505615,
0.46831005811691284,
-0.17379458248615265,
0.3387465476989746,
0.03002110868692398,
-0.41226881742477417,
-1.0792862176895142,
0.34627050161361694,
-0.778515100479126,
-0.298654168844223,
1.390407681465149,
-0.012444138526916504,
0.08360282331705093,
0.0167853981256485,
0.12244778871536255,
0.08809006959199905,
-0.0458989180624485,
0.6156005263328552,
1.127626895904541,
-0.2758580148220062,
-0.04257670417428017,
-0.8610150218009949,
0.32288968563079834,
0.6042142510414124,
-0.5173673629760742,
-0.019188979640603065,
0.47664642333984375,
0.13530902564525604,
0.23601199686527252,
0.6768668293952942,
-0.20128923654556274,
0.06662023812532425,
-0.25626489520072937,
-0.09529327601194382,
0.39900684356689453,
-0.20684877038002014,
-0.6188047528266907,
0.4159201383590698,
0.4483850598335266,
0.08035868406295776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.13874v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.13874v3
|
$Se^2$: Sequential Example Selection for In-Context Learning
| 2024-02-21T15:35:04 | 2024-06-06T11:12:57 |
Haoyu Liu, Jianfeng Liu, Shaohan Huang, Yuefeng Zhan, Hao Sun, Weiwei Deng, Furu Wei, Qi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The remarkable capability of large language models (LLMs) for in-context
learning (ICL) needs to be activated by demonstration examples. Prior work has
extensively explored the selection of examples for ICL, predominantly following
the "select then organize" paradigm, such approaches often neglect the internal
relationships between examples and exist an inconsistency between the training
and inference. In this paper, we formulate the problem as a $Se$quential
$Se$lection problem and introduce $Se^2$, a sequential-aware method that
leverages the LLM's feedback on varying context, aiding in capturing
inter-relationships and sequential information among examples, significantly
enriching the contextuality and relevance of ICL prompts. Meanwhile, we utilize
beam search to seek and construct example sequences, enhancing both quality and
diversity. Extensive experiments across 23 NLP tasks from 8 distinct categories
illustrate that $Se^2$ markedly surpasses competitive baselines and achieves
42\% relative improvement over random selection. Further in-depth analysis
shows the effectiveness of proposed strategies, highlighting $Se^2$'s
exceptional stability and adaptability across various scenarios. Code available
at https://github.com/microsoft/LMOps.
|
[
-0.0071950810961425304,
-0.7303758859634399,
0.7016171216964722,
0.4357706904411316,
-0.3883572816848755,
-0.0012231309665367007,
-0.06044262647628784,
-0.2302761822938919,
-0.18722231686115265,
0.0657074972987175,
-0.36098355054855347,
-0.15653029084205627,
-0.32275789976119995,
0.19357451796531677,
-0.5525546669960022,
0.6296327710151672,
0.09635702520608902,
0.20891204476356506,
-0.3115367889404297,
-0.20496325194835663,
-0.38901662826538086,
-0.2005431354045868,
-1.0139760971069336,
-0.2761029005050659,
0.31039273738861084,
0.8022176027297974,
0.2119722068309784,
0.21699346601963043,
0.17606231570243835,
0.2946081757545471,
-0.030100353062152863,
0.28800010681152344,
-0.44360196590423584,
0.5396165251731873,
-0.27741166949272156,
-0.3826485872268677,
0.16083846986293793,
-0.012464269064366817,
0.9869990348815918,
0.8330199122428894,
0.1869301199913025,
0.05629083886742592,
0.18476897478103638,
0.5480677485466003,
-0.4051576554775238,
-0.11450030654668808,
-0.8275075554847717,
0.16259200870990753,
-0.18914911150932312,
-0.15206027030944824,
-0.700577974319458,
-0.013930766843259335,
0.19391536712646484,
-0.35249653458595276,
-0.21932831406593323,
0.3518194854259491,
0.2927754521369934,
0.09578902274370193,
-0.5954161286354065,
-0.3133243918418884,
-0.5265903472900391,
0.704230785369873,
-0.7905018925666809,
0.44558852910995483,
0.19257575273513794,
0.09167160838842392,
-0.2832990884780884,
-1.0301766395568848,
-0.45120126008987427,
-0.3011070787906647,
-0.0267798975110054,
0.19001172482967377,
0.23811207711696625,
-0.3304053843021393,
0.58266681432724,
-0.07506004720926285,
-0.6091773509979248,
0.47044801712036133,
-0.0738825649023056,
0.11675924807786942,
0.3336576819419861,
0.031460244208574295,
0.252096563577652,
0.02049192413687706,
-0.4123796224594116,
-0.08244694024324417,
-1.081514596939087,
0.17108818888664246,
0.016393372789025307,
0.038491807878017426,
-0.0472639799118042,
0.4830646216869354,
-0.1125376969575882,
0.48253393173217773,
0.10794080048799515,
0.05871400237083435,
0.27926579117774963,
-0.22509810328483582,
-0.21689718961715698,
-0.1480330377817154,
0.3773142397403717,
0.16528572142124176,
-0.3017217218875885,
-0.11543691903352737,
-0.26984870433807373,
-0.25271642208099365,
-0.22683945298194885,
-0.9331899881362915,
0.17072372138500214,
0.40350064635276794,
-0.518779456615448,
0.01916901208460331,
0.12989939749240875,
-0.6202627420425415,
-0.31935927271842957,
-0.34907156229019165,
0.24530354142189026,
-0.17055226862430573,
-0.09587819129228592,
-0.04091295599937439,
-0.24015669524669647,
0.25929397344589233,
0.3222479224205017,
-0.8678784370422363,
0.24402157962322235,
0.67298823595047,
0.5952154994010925,
-0.1526256799697876,
-0.349558025598526,
-0.7691095471382141,
0.17298603057861328,
-0.44298964738845825,
0.6175906658172607,
-0.48074838519096375,
-0.4117504060268402,
0.08940228074789047,
-0.11368764936923981,
0.04703100398182869,
-0.5403764843940735,
0.31077519059181213,
-0.5070667862892151,
0.4098142981529236,
-0.17049789428710938,
-0.8477081060409546,
0.09818097203969955,
-0.14168331027030945,
-0.22260211408138275,
1.1458442211151123,
0.11082552373409271,
-0.5873895883560181,
0.47333234548568726,
-0.3362102210521698,
-0.5158198475837708,
0.25621944665908813,
-0.6672049164772034,
-0.37132564187049866,
0.36448532342910767,
-0.11295362561941147,
0.6204037070274353,
-0.026202339679002762,
0.16924452781677246,
-0.40762630105018616,
-0.418483167886734,
0.20304788649082184,
-0.012782394886016846,
0.6680416464805603,
0.2822858691215515,
-0.5552433729171753,
0.08065325766801834,
-0.4802088439464569,
-0.00597055908292532,
0.32225289940834045,
-0.07287154346704483,
-0.5375030040740967,
0.24611452221870422,
-0.11134086549282074,
0.3940526247024536,
0.054999154061079025,
-0.1475926637649536,
0.21594905853271484,
-0.5654206871986389,
0.43479177355766296,
0.7878901958465576,
0.12928526103496552,
0.7429511547088623,
-0.21862341463565826,
0.2756916880607605,
0.020173747092485428,
-0.10086052864789963,
-0.4038574993610382,
-0.292799174785614,
-0.7845494747161865,
-0.047558873891830444,
0.1042565405368805,
0.5063961744308472,
-0.8038244843482971,
0.30819278955459595,
0.019396713003516197,
-0.21749518811702728,
0.0029182794969528913,
0.13481955230236053,
0.3676767945289612,
0.48921215534210205,
0.2086164653301239,
-0.12339505553245544,
-0.6307119727134705,
-0.8207977414131165,
-0.20071357488632202,
-0.14519155025482178,
0.08747319877147675,
0.4518911838531494,
0.4893040359020233,
-0.19159144163131714,
0.8263652920722961,
-0.12276841700077057,
-0.015164270997047424,
-0.3014814853668213,
0.13617824018001556,
0.16928015649318695,
0.3931140899658203,
0.4534294307231903,
-0.7869652509689331,
-0.505147397518158,
-0.2454766482114792,
-0.7070088982582092,
-0.16762879490852356,
-0.5662301778793335,
-0.06318610906600952,
0.17105388641357422,
1.0868959426879883,
-0.0701732262969017,
0.1425013244152069,
0.16832123696804047,
-0.5043285489082336,
0.22509834170341492,
-0.23992173373699188,
-0.19713115692138672,
-1.08595609664917,
-0.19099076092243195,
-0.00455749174579978,
-0.3609445095062256,
-0.43654927611351013,
0.17032669484615326,
0.2712903320789337,
0.12341289967298508,
-0.630965530872345,
0.840618908405304,
-0.5131917595863342,
-0.3296491205692291,
-0.1362326443195343,
0.3322230279445648,
-0.33890289068222046,
0.20429059863090515,
0.054128292948007584,
0.7476363778114319,
0.24182787537574768,
-0.4601593315601349,
-0.33758479356765747,
0.25158876180648804,
-0.6917104125022888,
0.1759798675775528,
-0.5829258561134338,
0.36632001399993896,
-0.13985289633274078,
0.3893573582172394,
-0.9602901935577393,
-0.05985351279377937,
-0.06982297450304031,
-0.06549636274576187,
0.4827158749103546,
0.005131654441356659,
-0.6082212328910828,
-0.20848563313484192,
-0.2386469542980194,
0.41165563464164734,
0.788387656211853,
-0.6961130499839783,
0.1559484601020813,
0.33581215143203735,
-0.3198815882205963,
-0.5352717041969299,
-0.41753458976745605,
0.010951167903840542,
-0.19489024579524994,
-0.4274477958679199,
0.42978957295417786,
-0.3325902223587036,
-0.4547005593776703,
-0.3225817084312439,
-0.30406615138053894,
0.36113157868385315,
0.5056849122047424,
0.22474144399166107,
0.01362355425953865,
-0.03260953724384308,
0.1505458801984787,
0.45806336402893066,
-0.08925281465053558,
-0.20649060606956482,
-0.31004592776298523,
0.42066916823387146,
-0.19119185209274292,
-0.5539451241493225,
-0.2349374145269394,
0.6350722908973694,
0.1354207545518875,
0.13475623726844788,
0.23899920284748077,
0.22356578707695007,
-0.33307886123657227,
-0.8518226742744446,
-0.44235959649086,
-0.4958294928073883,
-0.4600514769554138,
0.693999707698822,
-0.36006268858909607,
-1.1187341213226318,
0.17649498581886292,
-0.3392389714717865,
0.1944151371717453,
0.05094100907444954,
0.49801334738731384,
-0.27447423338890076,
1.157778024673462,
0.26721253991127014,
0.07401355355978012,
0.7603946924209595,
-0.2645619511604309,
0.22731462121009827,
-0.9336510300636292,
-0.12936969101428986,
-0.41408976912498474,
-0.2802777588367462,
-0.14574775099754333,
-0.4572121500968933,
0.35015392303466797,
0.43850061297416687,
-0.36027127504348755,
0.17016063630580902,
-0.11214971542358398,
0.599565327167511,
0.4622616767883301,
0.18538643419742584,
0.0454481765627861,
-0.0199153833091259,
-0.46167999505996704,
-0.20438380539417267,
-0.6278560757637024,
-0.47527211904525757,
0.6155542135238647,
0.24928317964076996,
0.47048529982566833,
0.3142370581626892,
0.7239035367965698,
0.2834821939468384,
0.20826219022274017,
-0.4860835373401642,
0.8113181591033936,
-0.37841975688934326,
-0.13871750235557556,
-0.24221839010715485,
-0.00851193256676197,
-0.7778732776641846,
0.42502668499946594,
-0.03448234125971794,
-0.7690991163253784,
0.048434846103191376,
0.0701872855424881,
-0.3757583200931549,
-0.21814695000648499,
-0.6936832070350647,
0.7002503275871277,
-0.39142704010009766,
-0.5846617221832275,
-0.3369150459766388,
-0.832561731338501,
0.16304688155651093,
-0.02390865795314312,
0.3160635828971863,
-0.09152094274759293,
-0.2229837328195572,
0.5959047079086304,
-0.24879415333271027,
0.7955295443534851,
-0.18401184678077698,
0.19579990208148956,
0.08188603073358536,
0.18424293398857117,
0.7993983030319214,
0.36810502409935,
0.019389836117625237,
-0.3460288345813751,
-0.27303457260131836,
-0.109715037047863,
-0.7233145833015442,
0.6891442537307739,
-0.5403775572776794,
-0.6993298530578613,
-0.3013659715652466,
-0.2420007437467575,
-0.4119347631931305,
0.08745260536670685,
0.1584382802248001,
0.6652932167053223,
0.03483937308192253,
0.5078558921813965,
0.6183981895446777,
-0.19541354477405548,
0.8506877422332764,
0.5423282384872437,
-0.3275832235813141,
-0.17153596878051758,
0.5680368542671204,
-0.0028481269255280495,
0.33070307970046997,
0.6407650113105774,
0.2492506206035614,
-0.3803838789463043,
-0.8505433797836304,
-0.23120222985744476,
0.15880419313907623,
-0.874419629573822,
-0.05367686226963997,
-0.6582103967666626,
-0.15128275752067566,
-0.3190327286720276,
-0.4868391752243042,
0.11166273802518845,
-0.5360718369483948,
-0.4094628393650055,
-0.19160296022891998,
-0.3039775490760803,
0.5416964888572693,
0.06319928914308548,
0.10095128417015076,
-0.3674679398536682,
0.17362698912620544,
0.5197523236274719,
-0.05857770889997482,
0.05033569410443306,
-0.7716516852378845,
-0.17253050208091736,
-0.2367769181728363,
-0.13956308364868164,
-0.774493932723999,
0.30339130759239197,
0.3282511532306671,
0.8169659376144409,
0.5921453833580017,
-0.09345494955778122,
0.6182587146759033,
-0.7418624758720398,
0.8579989671707153,
0.09908442199230194,
-0.9616928696632385,
0.7211499810218811,
-0.18625681102275848,
0.2963730990886688,
0.6849682331085205,
0.24442169070243835,
-0.6376993656158447,
-0.5130628943443298,
-0.6878992319107056,
-1.1387368440628052,
0.5863021016120911,
-0.008662614040076733,
0.035906847566366196,
-0.35699138045310974,
0.1679038256406784,
0.1449843943119049,
0.020919866859912872,
-0.740837812423706,
-0.28005319833755493,
0.17758959531784058,
-0.2036728858947754,
-0.04473361372947693,
-0.6899780631065369,
0.13543298840522766,
-0.12767185270786285,
0.8442421555519104,
-0.2842578589916229,
0.11774854362010956,
0.29778769612312317,
-0.5037528276443481,
0.30098745226860046,
0.25845566391944885,
0.8426483869552612,
0.6660474538803101,
0.009005097672343254,
0.2744513154029846,
0.2997073829174042,
0.019425053149461746,
0.06772500276565552,
-0.040668509900569916,
-0.4335426986217499,
-0.12806996703147888,
0.27840811014175415,
0.6072807312011719,
0.6549110412597656,
-0.7885805368423462,
0.6502577662467957,
0.06287938356399536,
0.04308752343058586,
-0.6009141206741333,
-0.06328032165765762,
-0.029517726972699165,
0.5651019215583801,
0.5249935984611511,
0.02695051208138466,
0.3518698215484619,
-0.4176173806190491,
0.4760403633117676,
0.5668148994445801,
-0.26830416917800903,
-0.10242845118045807,
0.627833902835846,
0.29275035858154297,
-0.5356652736663818,
0.6578325033187866,
-0.5366184711456299,
-0.4208979308605194,
0.7267679572105408,
0.9647977352142334,
0.8399280309677124,
0.032711051404476166,
0.12138132005929947,
0.42814281582832336,
0.0009366053272970021,
-0.40628427267074585,
0.350822389125824,
-0.24870085716247559,
-0.9027540683746338,
-0.2893041968345642,
-0.1426958441734314,
-0.32207244634628296,
0.07129586488008499,
-0.3983341455459595,
0.4857885241508484,
-0.47907501459121704,
0.2213614135980606,
-0.20220918953418732,
-0.11985097825527191,
-0.5471022129058838,
-0.13370707631111145,
0.42469823360443115,
1.096038579940796,
-0.783883810043335,
0.9299158453941345,
0.5751436352729797,
-0.21132320165634155,
-0.6525722146034241,
-0.17646585404872894,
0.11684653162956238,
-0.7755767107009888,
0.8854495286941528,
0.3480606973171234,
0.1294366419315338,
0.08132980018854141,
-0.6802287101745605,
-0.5842762589454651,
1.28786301612854,
0.15147505700588226,
-0.7444527745246887,
0.05886801704764366,
-0.3146582841873169,
0.2208595871925354,
-0.6458227038383484,
0.5682394504547119,
0.37024062871932983,
0.14656728506088257,
0.014220256358385086,
-0.5056093335151672,
0.04784721881151199,
-0.26427504420280457,
0.23399339616298676,
-0.021552572026848793,
-0.77186518907547,
0.44357264041900635,
-0.4690122902393341,
-0.26686012744903564,
0.3732868731021881,
0.8972788453102112,
0.7229609489440918,
0.5471660494804382,
0.8027625679969788,
0.35551026463508606,
0.7452942728996277,
0.09645507484674454,
0.8598134517669678,
-0.02914891391992569,
0.15300974249839783,
1.6659201383590698,
-0.6409501433372498,
1.1251095533370972,
0.7112258076667786,
-0.17692628502845764,
0.5651513934135437,
0.7768538594245911,
0.10047949850559235,
0.7130756974220276,
0.16349638998508453,
-0.4069037139415741,
-0.29274988174438477,
-0.07674399763345718,
-0.34047096967697144,
0.27795708179473877,
0.5052510499954224,
-0.5366489291191101,
-0.11683676391839981,
-0.0031561744399368763,
0.06723950058221817,
0.04421960189938545,
-0.13302572071552277,
0.7477706670761108,
0.3028108775615692,
-0.7047610282897949,
-0.10390938073396683,
-0.2033994495868683,
0.5650938153266907,
-0.6645167469978333,
-0.23314864933490753,
-0.3907647728919983,
0.009878220036625862,
-0.040688831359148026,
-0.5194190144538879,
-0.12968258559703827,
-0.441158652305603,
-0.09229365736246109,
-0.6715793609619141,
0.595903754234314,
-0.5105266571044922,
-0.26833605766296387,
0.25886985659599304,
0.5193102359771729,
0.09001871198415756,
0.3615133762359619,
-0.5230658054351807,
-0.16012120246887207,
0.10035327821969986,
-0.18345025181770325,
0.45881301164627075,
0.2884126603603363,
-0.1377885788679123,
0.5358300805091858,
0.45110130310058594,
-0.11730934679508209,
-0.13148251175880432,
0.287200391292572,
0.5509886741638184,
-0.35946691036224365,
-0.5905202627182007,
-0.7598670125007629,
0.7524994015693665,
-0.4620307683944702,
-0.3981938362121582,
0.8576169610023499,
0.7235636115074158,
1.0859925746917725,
-0.12433146685361862,
0.7453132271766663,
-0.11828810721635818,
0.566493809223175,
-0.7135079503059387,
0.19656825065612793,
-0.5267727375030518,
0.5505576133728027,
-0.1342848390340805,
-0.686133623123169,
-0.2334495335817337,
0.8216552734375,
-0.08231344819068909,
-0.021649157628417015,
1.1142253875732422,
0.6953790187835693,
0.10705303400754929,
0.09959045797586441,
0.41358163952827454,
0.3693540096282959,
0.2532787621021271,
0.48739707469940186,
1.0160502195358276,
-0.31443431973457336,
-0.02771082893013954,
-0.20403704047203064,
-0.22538988292217255,
-0.3358938694000244,
-1.0882023572921753,
-0.8057789206504822,
-0.9477484822273254,
-0.3499268591403961,
-0.2841187119483948,
-0.010910493321716785,
1.4201812744140625,
0.8953818678855896,
-0.8624843955039978,
-0.2501177191734314,
-0.028599940240383148,
0.3231756091117859,
-0.25107499957084656,
-0.1601128876209259,
0.18356433510780334,
-0.7281290292739868,
-0.6189059615135193,
0.849251389503479,
0.3749719262123108,
0.1370222568511963,
0.06371335685253143,
0.04608938843011856,
-0.16089467704296112,
-0.18598687648773193,
0.925679624080658,
0.3423856794834137,
-0.7059985399246216,
-0.433145672082901,
-0.09178557246923447,
0.0006910571246407926,
-0.30289581418037415,
1.1230326890945435,
-0.7696642875671387,
0.31735873222351074,
0.5565369725227356,
0.8727473020553589,
0.41230717301368713,
-0.21837051212787628,
0.4107314944267273,
-0.8875604867935181,
0.43305009603500366,
0.4226613938808441,
0.8836207985877991,
0.08578814566135406,
-0.23408135771751404,
0.6205575466156006,
0.2693557143211365,
-0.7464280724525452,
-0.7801791429519653,
0.3718020021915436,
-1.0562347173690796,
-0.5041220188140869,
1.5844439268112183,
0.024229582399129868,
0.29803791642189026,
-0.09644144028425217,
-0.191743865609169,
-0.16878320276737213,
-0.4538632333278656,
0.4599147140979767,
0.36027029156684875,
-0.18629290163516998,
-0.15509775280952454,
-0.5241290330886841,
0.4165269732475281,
0.7181375026702881,
-0.7592939138412476,
-0.303104966878891,
0.46940934658050537,
0.04657873138785362,
-0.2893364429473877,
0.7119199633598328,
0.1104896143078804,
0.08160870522260666,
-0.2253078818321228,
-0.47132956981658936,
0.1590690016746521,
-0.4009281396865845,
-0.5156558156013489,
0.1872863918542862,
0.27630847692489624,
0.11287710815668106
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.