id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16107v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16107v6
|
Knowledge Fusion of Chat LLMs: A Preliminary Technical Report
| 2024-02-25T15:11:58 | 2024-05-29T03:58:10 |
Fanqi Wan, Ziyi Yang, Longguang Zhong, Xiaojun Quan, Xinting Huang, Wei Bi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, FuseLLM introduced the concept of knowledge fusion to transfer the
collective knowledge of multiple structurally varied LLMs into a target LLM
through lightweight continual training. In this report, we extend the
scalability and flexibility of the FuseLLM framework to realize the fusion of
chat LLMs, resulting in FusionChat. FusionChat comprises two main stages.
Firstly, we undertake knowledge fusion for structurally and scale-varied source
LLMs to derive multiple target LLMs of identical structure and size via
lightweight fine-tuning. Then, these target LLMs are merged within the
parameter space, wherein we propose a novel method for determining the merging
weights based on the variation ratio of parameter matrices before and after
fine-tuning. We validate our approach using three prominent chat LLMs with
diverse architectures and scales, namely NH2-Mixtral-8x7B, NH2-Solar-10.7B, and
OpenChat-3.5-7B. Experimental results spanning various chat domains demonstrate
the superiority of FusionChat-7B across a broad spectrum of chat LLMs at 7B and
34B scales, even surpassing GPT-3.5 (March) and approaching
Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct.
|
[
-0.40350064635276794,
-0.5768508911132812,
0.266666978597641,
0.3494502604007721,
-0.1845984309911728,
0.379772812128067,
-0.24933114647865295,
-0.6770244836807251,
0.2998042702674866,
0.39037957787513733,
-0.5129207372665405,
-0.3191577196121216,
-0.4348301589488983,
-0.2586125433444977,
-0.48711761832237244,
0.7832802534103394,
-0.10945171117782593,
0.28260481357574463,
-0.402111679315567,
-0.26397082209587097,
-0.699286162853241,
-0.20260584354400635,
-0.5080766677856445,
-0.4568014442920685,
0.6077377796173096,
0.5903148055076599,
0.5172006487846375,
0.4341699481010437,
0.7454214692115784,
0.34616726636886597,
-0.21029400825500488,
0.34191229939460754,
-0.9037520289421082,
0.10711623728275299,
-0.09845051914453506,
-0.63252854347229,
-0.39651986956596375,
-0.023729071021080017,
0.6754540801048279,
0.7640812993049622,
-0.150969460606575,
0.1619112193584442,
0.2935396432876587,
0.6753461360931396,
-0.3505992591381073,
0.04533715546131134,
-0.8535619974136353,
-0.06541948020458221,
-0.1137794628739357,
0.0761670172214508,
-0.351900190114975,
-0.21631920337677002,
0.013145851902663708,
-0.3185344636440277,
-0.07313857972621918,
0.5253726243972778,
0.5997113585472107,
0.3536677956581116,
-0.4130757749080658,
0.10337169468402863,
-0.9204940795898438,
0.7932990789413452,
-0.5133647322654724,
0.5006704330444336,
0.0071597169153392315,
0.7120628356933594,
-0.15251803398132324,
-0.5769849419593811,
-0.27458685636520386,
-0.1358834058046341,
-0.1738608032464981,
0.11839665472507477,
-0.03487066924571991,
0.05449947714805603,
-0.16728642582893372,
0.5028320550918579,
-0.6291536688804626,
0.47141075134277344,
-0.6062426567077637,
-0.3887929320335388,
0.6181134581565857,
0.266240656375885,
0.23177304863929749,
0.014705043286085129,
-0.7476441264152527,
0.06090870127081871,
-0.7770872712135315,
-0.4763377904891968,
0.16601181030273438,
0.31631043553352356,
-0.4759673476219177,
0.6595177054405212,
-0.3015925884246826,
0.8803040981292725,
0.17936840653419495,
-0.285146027803421,
0.05983677878975868,
-0.6562038660049438,
-0.14010970294475555,
0.14942795038223267,
0.7393810153007507,
0.43777891993522644,
-0.510800302028656,
-0.15286393463611603,
0.11334363371133804,
-0.04966730996966362,
0.11013943701982498,
-0.42104247212409973,
-0.015293478965759277,
0.11404868215322495,
-0.4655774235725403,
-0.22392472624778748,
-0.2763897776603699,
-0.5197607278823853,
-0.635096549987793,
-0.15677116811275482,
0.5033120512962341,
-0.5735664963722229,
-0.3778752386569977,
0.09117817878723145,
-0.28557267785072327,
0.5597044825553894,
0.6375504732131958,
-0.8160998225212097,
0.34148043394088745,
0.6580074429512024,
0.7925728559494019,
-0.5638329386711121,
-0.16839802265167236,
0.0407215841114521,
0.17493094503879547,
-0.020506232976913452,
0.8519560694694519,
-0.25116997957229614,
-0.5427624583244324,
-0.3334214389324188,
-0.5756723284721375,
-0.156392440199852,
-0.5285024046897888,
0.1816476732492447,
-0.504307210445404,
0.4092235267162323,
-0.11526084691286087,
-0.8747143149375916,
-0.09874922037124634,
0.5438928008079529,
-0.44051027297973633,
0.7738173604011536,
0.34942084550857544,
-0.6862869262695312,
0.280009388923645,
-0.37588512897491455,
-0.2740190327167511,
0.34292367100715637,
-0.18469077348709106,
-0.06517276167869568,
-0.20615820586681366,
-0.05562625080347061,
0.4249158203601837,
-0.5006588101387024,
-0.27360954880714417,
-0.5853614211082458,
-0.3047909736633301,
0.04369835928082466,
-0.21416525542736053,
0.33974984288215637,
0.2771398425102234,
-0.0072203404270112514,
0.22131937742233276,
-0.5430454611778259,
-0.01654791831970215,
-0.1886899173259735,
-0.3627898097038269,
-0.023772556334733963,
-0.0396883450448513,
-0.1076326072216034,
0.06619101762771606,
0.6448802947998047,
-0.41718029975891113,
0.2518264055252075,
-0.4082843065261841,
0.3191969394683838,
0.4555957615375519,
0.10196685045957565,
0.785123348236084,
-0.6993337869644165,
0.18542362749576569,
0.0005233422853052616,
0.21273034811019897,
0.12627209722995758,
-0.48080581426620483,
-0.868188738822937,
-0.3263407349586487,
0.1631671041250229,
0.520021915435791,
-0.7382534742355347,
0.6509166955947876,
-0.2599217891693115,
-0.963758111000061,
-0.2914004623889923,
0.33788618445396423,
0.301994264125824,
0.3833238184452057,
0.27982208132743835,
-0.22720110416412354,
-0.7207551598548889,
-0.850368857383728,
-0.19698159396648407,
-0.4095521867275238,
-0.13926732540130615,
0.3779318928718567,
0.1476830691099167,
-0.140334814786911,
0.7708261609077454,
-0.48298215866088867,
-0.3763284981250763,
-0.4573354423046112,
-0.0249549001455307,
-0.08714649826288223,
0.5698735117912292,
0.43183645606040955,
-0.8205487132072449,
-0.5272226929664612,
0.18230973184108734,
-0.7588828802108765,
0.2130323350429535,
-0.11867110431194305,
-0.19349363446235657,
-0.11468315869569778,
0.5048322677612305,
-0.6268380880355835,
-0.03504043072462082,
0.6101292967796326,
-0.06891049444675446,
0.39061930775642395,
0.09665244817733765,
0.32015132904052734,
-1.53219473361969,
-0.4079628586769104,
-0.28224217891693115,
-0.1512787789106369,
-0.5167635679244995,
-0.1735435128211975,
0.04161596670746803,
0.0689607635140419,
-0.7517760992050171,
0.6448414325714111,
-0.4605654776096344,
-0.11838996410369873,
-0.2738647162914276,
0.3290598392486572,
-0.4061056673526764,
0.4535180628299713,
-0.357688844203949,
0.4162207841873169,
0.56669682264328,
-0.626611590385437,
0.8222967982292175,
0.19125598669052124,
-0.16291047632694244,
0.7624164819717407,
-0.46668878197669983,
-0.048046670854091644,
0.19665224850177765,
0.27943071722984314,
-1.3088797330856323,
-0.32069462537765503,
0.20435044169425964,
-0.3607226312160492,
0.2804531157016754,
-0.0823821872472763,
-0.36337223649024963,
-0.36941707134246826,
-0.2766090929508209,
0.3357979655265808,
0.6305501461029053,
-0.3774486780166626,
0.72367924451828,
0.42746737599372864,
0.0661197081208229,
-0.1830003708600998,
-0.5355612635612488,
-0.04133226349949837,
-0.41625526547431946,
-0.9249244332313538,
0.4818841218948364,
-0.25503095984458923,
-0.2349633425474167,
0.062214694917201996,
-0.30924952030181885,
-0.08621402084827423,
-0.17335756123065948,
0.455465167760849,
0.3379887640476227,
-0.18065498769283295,
0.13820914924144745,
0.12562452256679535,
0.08200744539499283,
-0.2858092486858368,
-0.3832055330276489,
0.6681981086730957,
-0.26842251420021057,
-0.7765681147575378,
-0.1614788919687271,
0.06599140912294388,
0.5259725451469421,
0.1992024928331375,
0.8873232007026672,
0.6840410232543945,
-0.18021580576896667,
0.004853580612689257,
-0.9502449631690979,
-0.23411475121974945,
-0.5122060179710388,
0.23208209872245789,
-0.13025474548339844,
-1.4224138259887695,
0.8279826045036316,
-0.3263641595840454,
0.21184097230434418,
0.5463597774505615,
0.6571825742721558,
-0.2177673578262329,
0.6725819110870361,
0.7168952822685242,
-0.26651012897491455,
0.46930834650993347,
0.05192851647734642,
-0.12079587578773499,
-0.6977317333221436,
-0.45265477895736694,
-0.4451606273651123,
-0.6660348176956177,
-0.5273924469947815,
-0.5169975161552429,
0.5238041281700134,
-0.018384434282779694,
-0.03358703851699829,
0.4947602450847626,
-0.29265329241752625,
0.4744928479194641,
0.27052435278892517,
0.3221060037612915,
0.2585984468460083,
-0.13508178293704987,
0.043596137315034866,
0.09741989523172379,
-0.8661176562309265,
-0.09024947136640549,
0.9927660822868347,
0.21367371082305908,
0.9769548773765564,
0.15231172740459442,
0.8528659343719482,
0.13156716525554657,
0.2564694285392761,
-0.6795805096626282,
0.7034087181091309,
0.17198708653450012,
-0.48442381620407104,
-0.36978548765182495,
-0.6381919980049133,
-0.6867663264274597,
0.3646261394023895,
-0.35509219765663147,
-0.6852091550827026,
-0.15292029082775116,
0.0968116745352745,
0.005408741533756256,
0.3830588757991791,
-0.8361454010009766,
0.4576112627983093,
-0.11027328670024872,
0.08123737573623657,
-0.571679413318634,
-0.79997318983078,
0.916288435459137,
-0.16225935518741608,
0.07808862626552582,
-0.35752344131469727,
-0.041434112936258316,
0.8028871417045593,
-0.22575683891773224,
0.9415808320045471,
0.20959049463272095,
-0.02652590721845627,
0.23120111227035522,
0.05267583578824997,
0.209329754114151,
0.0020077533554285765,
0.1239166259765625,
0.1854979246854782,
-0.21383419632911682,
-0.27967509627342224,
-0.6115632057189941,
0.7780358195304871,
-1.025185227394104,
-0.5390349626541138,
0.13436661660671234,
-0.8314785361289978,
-0.549826979637146,
0.2648468315601349,
0.2637064754962921,
0.18881013989448547,
-0.22698022425174713,
0.6507663130760193,
0.7640730738639832,
0.178666889667511,
0.16778239607810974,
0.6176811456680298,
-0.19523166120052338,
-0.37377917766571045,
0.8266797065734863,
-0.10613587498664856,
0.5385293960571289,
0.7404665350914001,
0.011543546803295612,
-0.14963601529598236,
-0.5252701640129089,
-0.07566089183092117,
0.18049921095371246,
-0.49858370423316956,
-0.5192666053771973,
-0.35438618063926697,
-0.6606545448303223,
-0.39016786217689514,
-0.11595935374498367,
-0.6377319693565369,
-0.452102929353714,
-0.24249601364135742,
0.019805623218417168,
0.3940708041191101,
0.6537014842033386,
-0.040583208203315735,
0.5555583834648132,
-1.1174265146255493,
0.28517842292785645,
0.5252291560173035,
0.44543981552124023,
-0.26272016763687134,
-0.5389248728752136,
-0.2883792519569397,
0.2442425936460495,
-0.20349356532096863,
-0.6902546882629395,
-0.037017133086919785,
0.19092637300491333,
0.8808432817459106,
0.3900783956050873,
-0.00006238784408196807,
0.4780493378639221,
-0.13975867629051208,
0.8977627158164978,
0.568683922290802,
-0.5740357041358948,
0.6356276869773865,
-0.4189516305923462,
0.30989015102386475,
0.4879366457462311,
0.4196544289588928,
-0.4425502121448517,
-0.6902089715003967,
-0.6799483895301819,
-0.6004153490066528,
0.5854455828666687,
0.2667282521724701,
-0.07031898945569992,
0.49306535720825195,
0.40438440442085266,
0.10330566018819809,
-0.024185771122574806,
-0.22568988800048828,
-0.33994027972221375,
0.14189057052135468,
-0.3538065254688263,
0.05911601707339287,
-0.2131267935037613,
-0.45172014832496643,
-0.23448693752288818,
0.3575465679168701,
-0.04296291992068291,
0.16984599828720093,
-0.304872989654541,
-0.08726535737514496,
-0.037585627287626266,
0.12678295373916626,
0.5651091933250427,
0.6030511260032654,
-0.17464075982570648,
0.07540921121835709,
0.6105101108551025,
-0.43784359097480774,
0.01219899021089077,
-0.039285093545913696,
0.11647795140743256,
-0.4236992299556732,
0.416268527507782,
0.8368597626686096,
0.7302979826927185,
-0.3430768847465515,
0.03244606778025627,
-0.2400897890329361,
-0.6243190765380859,
0.30672314763069153,
0.624891996383667,
0.3110184967517853,
0.5195339918136597,
0.18264877796173096,
0.09686915576457977,
-0.15321378409862518,
-0.22660988569259644,
0.27880191802978516,
0.5648902058601379,
-0.3048606812953949,
-0.162960484623909,
0.4278414249420166,
0.423964262008667,
0.057147398591041565,
0.440205454826355,
0.027154957875609398,
-0.27669626474380493,
0.2514117658138275,
0.4151797592639923,
0.524262547492981,
-0.2015588879585266,
0.019816137850284576,
0.168592169880867,
0.1934576779603958,
-0.05327151343226433,
0.07781863212585449,
-0.1902514547109604,
-1.0355888605117798,
-0.29670512676239014,
-0.6444459557533264,
-0.8370629549026489,
-0.2934747040271759,
-0.40392592549324036,
0.27699509263038635,
-0.32338014245033264,
0.05310708284378052,
-0.16582128405570984,
0.18760617077350616,
-0.32344529032707214,
-0.12815499305725098,
0.15895505249500275,
0.883055567741394,
-0.6114906668663025,
0.5595560073852539,
0.8143628835678101,
-0.11425283551216125,
-1.0678818225860596,
-0.5269315838813782,
0.37719929218292236,
-1.0642406940460205,
0.27337926626205444,
-0.2947532534599304,
-0.015603763982653618,
0.052105896174907684,
-0.6822631359100342,
-0.9674429297447205,
1.4322328567504883,
0.4447314441204071,
-0.4022258222103119,
0.06381534785032272,
0.2503547668457031,
0.2652050256729126,
-0.3518713116645813,
0.07592382282018661,
0.3976387083530426,
0.39208295941352844,
1.0415887832641602,
-1.3213484287261963,
-0.09014248102903366,
-0.015254348516464233,
-0.08183201402425766,
0.13620717823505402,
-0.8627722859382629,
0.687549889087677,
-0.0157004427164793,
-0.1650882512331009,
-0.11342170834541321,
1.021615982055664,
0.2841646373271942,
-0.1742583066225052,
0.6503550410270691,
0.47297993302345276,
0.7210314869880676,
-0.20392394065856934,
0.4015433192253113,
-0.5377383828163147,
0.29223474860191345,
0.994055986404419,
-0.3383174538612366,
0.6767659187316895,
0.3289690613746643,
-0.22777485847473145,
0.25322121381759644,
0.6025298237800598,
0.03130162134766579,
0.2940092980861664,
-0.06828820705413818,
-0.2825760841369629,
-0.21767297387123108,
-0.03970027342438698,
-0.6269952654838562,
0.5903779864311218,
0.44994333386421204,
0.2204464077949524,
-0.5398228168487549,
0.06086459010839462,
-0.24612870812416077,
-0.36772817373275757,
-0.27432048320770264,
1.1528805494308472,
0.186399444937706,
-0.4248174726963043,
0.5182519555091858,
-0.15498191118240356,
0.744288980960846,
-0.8717969059944153,
0.16114076972007751,
-0.24600213766098022,
0.18540740013122559,
-0.20155613124370575,
-0.8829845786094666,
0.352712482213974,
-0.44356289505958557,
0.007298292592167854,
-0.2920249402523041,
1.3302950859069824,
-0.672996997833252,
-0.04006334766745567,
-0.003434449667111039,
0.6011760830879211,
0.028810571879148483,
-0.03745478391647339,
-0.5184540152549744,
0.2627660632133484,
-0.02313333749771118,
0.02473362162709236,
0.7392545342445374,
0.19179750978946686,
0.3330913186073303,
0.7460305094718933,
0.4800671339035034,
0.10867508500814438,
0.1069437637925148,
-0.11922673135995865,
1.1733068227767944,
-0.39408257603645325,
-0.43129944801330566,
-0.6507588624954224,
0.34624144434928894,
-0.06585662811994553,
-0.0752774327993393,
1.0714004039764404,
0.42596447467803955,
0.6122671365737915,
0.17366386950016022,
0.4998595714569092,
-0.18971766531467438,
0.3187941014766693,
-0.5181332230567932,
0.7936251759529114,
-0.45385029911994934,
0.27555719017982483,
0.1560077667236328,
-0.9083526730537415,
-0.06817157566547394,
-0.005800783168524504,
0.03137883543968201,
-0.03774138540029526,
0.5008861422538757,
0.7037051320075989,
0.1796821653842926,
0.2593400180339813,
0.34643107652664185,
0.07916604727506638,
0.37077394127845764,
0.6259932518005371,
0.7888491153717041,
-0.24369481205940247,
0.8049485683441162,
-0.04482848569750786,
-0.24165192246437073,
-0.48109936714172363,
-0.5744715332984924,
-0.7430956959724426,
-0.6541705131530762,
-0.2910754978656769,
-0.21862050890922546,
-0.34197330474853516,
0.604640543460846,
0.8921749591827393,
-0.4208824336528778,
-0.3090623617172241,
0.12832829356193542,
0.6299936175346375,
-0.11891555041074753,
-0.23556016385555267,
-0.04575201869010925,
-0.5246308445930481,
-0.28602778911590576,
0.5666958093643188,
0.4088658094406128,
0.22707471251487732,
-0.49439162015914917,
-0.18031390011310577,
-0.023926515132188797,
-0.02736079692840576,
0.5768676400184631,
0.30359503626823425,
-0.4019779562950134,
-0.3489746153354645,
-0.1418970376253128,
-0.34950771927833557,
-0.08835376054048538,
0.6485474705696106,
-0.6749115586280823,
0.06375840306282043,
0.643673837184906,
0.5534717440605164,
0.5653125047683716,
-0.2658960819244385,
0.6307485699653625,
-1.0213106870651245,
0.16104184091091156,
0.14155781269073486,
0.352346807718277,
0.1673315167427063,
-0.16917423903942108,
0.33186396956443787,
0.3031381666660309,
-0.4352048635482788,
-0.6772103905677795,
0.18395699560642242,
-1.5227137804031372,
-0.11142463982105255,
1.235493779182434,
0.21263787150382996,
-0.11928242444992065,
0.00551208620890975,
-0.30741846561431885,
0.23892857134342194,
-0.0937977135181427,
0.5249053835868835,
0.5656600594520569,
-0.3859108090400696,
-0.2969381511211395,
0.09712627530097961,
0.45710673928260803,
0.2077564299106598,
-1.0963340997695923,
-0.16432543098926544,
0.4281231760978699,
0.20845910906791687,
0.26287364959716797,
0.6268136501312256,
-0.004400296602398157,
0.19118048250675201,
0.2884990870952606,
-0.10562010109424591,
0.010063220746815205,
-0.2179623246192932,
0.11155509948730469,
0.3606317937374115,
0.0596020482480526,
-0.1586700677871704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16102v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16102v1
|
Interpreting Predictive Probabilities: Model Confidence or Human Label Variation?
| 2024-02-25T15:00:13 | 2024-02-25T15:00:13 |
Joris Baan, Raquel Fernández, Barbara Plank, Wilker Aziz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the rise of increasingly powerful and user-facing NLP systems, there is
growing interest in assessing whether they have a good representation of
uncertainty by evaluating the quality of their predictive distribution over
outcomes. We identify two main perspectives that drive starkly different
evaluation protocols. The first treats predictive probability as an indication
of model confidence; the second as an indication of human label variation. We
discuss their merits and limitations, and take the position that both are
crucial for trustworthy and fair NLP systems, but that exploiting a single
predictive distribution is limiting. We recommend tools and highlight exciting
directions towards models with disentangled representations of uncertainty
about predictions and uncertainty about human labels.
|
[
-0.3041250705718994,
-0.04515278339385986,
0.6452735066413879,
0.346292644739151,
0.03945300728082657,
0.3506680727005005,
0.1644095927476883,
-0.8783227205276489,
0.018814565613865852,
0.1453140825033188,
-0.48401087522506714,
-0.23452332615852356,
-1.087254524230957,
-0.17804181575775146,
-0.3696220815181732,
0.8927645087242126,
0.2476651519536972,
0.36131855845451355,
-0.5076896548271179,
0.17831243574619293,
-0.29273101687431335,
-0.7175371646881104,
-0.43631500005722046,
-0.6768176555633545,
0.35839593410491943,
-0.22083541750907898,
1.3081942796707153,
0.32009321451187134,
0.8624864220619202,
0.18902668356895447,
-0.3065463900566101,
-0.41495171189308167,
-0.04155271127820015,
-0.01435787882655859,
-0.3588707447052002,
-0.6036174297332764,
-0.41323304176330566,
0.3747738003730774,
0.5076170563697815,
1.199005365371704,
-0.1997217833995819,
0.030098728835582733,
0.16830532252788544,
0.4882556200027466,
-0.919662594795227,
0.08412175625562668,
-0.3323632478713989,
0.1458130180835724,
0.044302571564912796,
0.09935104846954346,
-0.6002830266952515,
-0.14803139865398407,
0.53010493516922,
-0.3780008554458618,
0.041210778057575226,
0.1411076784133911,
0.5689793825149536,
0.34567153453826904,
-0.37052029371261597,
-0.23110747337341309,
-0.9663374423980713,
0.977515697479248,
-0.6875830888748169,
0.3550669550895691,
0.6024355292320251,
0.5536512732505798,
-0.38639700412750244,
-0.8851408362388611,
-0.40655601024627686,
-0.24054092168807983,
0.0842011496424675,
0.22020447254180908,
-0.35530418157577515,
0.05565844476222992,
-0.1241150051355362,
0.3899783194065094,
-0.34017083048820496,
0.31703120470046997,
0.010788561776280403,
-0.2607346177101135,
0.9045771956443787,
-0.11735841631889343,
0.013251491822302341,
-0.029890084639191628,
-0.41422227025032043,
-0.2638314962387085,
-0.25624778866767883,
0.00027118241996504366,
0.7773646712303162,
0.22841070592403412,
0.006106903310865164,
0.3684529960155487,
-0.14187100529670715,
0.8711748123168945,
-0.1790016144514084,
-0.22391869127750397,
0.2513487637042999,
-0.09454241394996643,
-0.20110692083835602,
-0.15252186357975006,
0.9426200985908508,
0.4005460739135742,
-0.08580584824085236,
-0.08807667344808578,
-0.1970801204442978,
0.22026188671588898,
0.2362072765827179,
-0.21346056461334229,
-0.4727896749973297,
0.41614416241645813,
-0.5346510410308838,
-0.6918633580207825,
0.5370791554450989,
-0.6428262591362,
-0.8405939340591431,
0.0318363755941391,
0.33659687638282776,
-0.20666542649269104,
-0.3937775492668152,
0.6442938446998596,
-0.35201242566108704,
-0.2827705442905426,
0.35139036178588867,
-1.0377633571624756,
0.287596732378006,
0.8813206553459167,
0.30871474742889404,
-0.38072454929351807,
-0.04188936576247215,
0.012706335633993149,
-0.13189390301704407,
-0.44140809774398804,
0.41465696692466736,
-0.5235086679458618,
-0.26875749230384827,
-0.009698580950498581,
-0.15968914330005646,
0.08448238670825958,
-0.5414391160011292,
0.7038882374763489,
-0.509215235710144,
0.04677775874733925,
-0.07656966149806976,
-0.6962935924530029,
-0.19556953012943268,
-0.0479746088385582,
-0.8922092318534851,
0.6930260062217712,
0.21070687472820282,
-1.022801160812378,
0.7582749724388123,
-0.16530656814575195,
0.08330554515123367,
0.2097809910774231,
0.07234494388103485,
-0.11660081893205643,
0.2786194980144501,
-0.11348752677440643,
0.37851783633232117,
-0.1980224996805191,
0.5245059728622437,
-0.7289379835128784,
-0.12459726631641388,
1.0204133987426758,
-0.8332011103630066,
0.7391071915626526,
0.30481258034706116,
-0.03501610830426216,
-0.37514999508857727,
-0.8127489686012268,
0.08690479397773743,
-0.22381021082401276,
-0.1527075171470642,
-0.18933381140232086,
0.47889071702957153,
0.21942687034606934,
0.24574297666549683,
0.3232159912586212,
-0.3425748348236084,
-0.043749283999204636,
-0.42800378799438477,
0.412325918674469,
0.5588151812553406,
0.06747201830148697,
0.5558084845542908,
-0.18524698913097382,
0.7942451238632202,
0.26483073830604553,
0.42867183685302734,
0.3173583745956421,
-0.9341239333152771,
-0.18010349571704865,
0.02066517248749733,
0.7138231992721558,
0.5018965005874634,
-0.43536919355392456,
0.38417595624923706,
0.1576099395751953,
-0.6502100229263306,
-0.7313594222068787,
-0.2964659035205841,
0.30186697840690613,
0.2627137005329132,
0.16870643198490143,
-0.4165456295013428,
-0.4241842031478882,
-0.9768466353416443,
-0.49349895119667053,
-0.6202027201652527,
-0.29857733845710754,
-0.11309739947319031,
0.6068263053894043,
-0.36801567673683167,
0.9609235525131226,
-0.5270055532455444,
0.056793149560689926,
-0.10045404732227325,
0.41168734431266785,
0.290370374917984,
0.6722263097763062,
0.2995619773864746,
-1.138559341430664,
-0.24827593564987183,
-0.21681340038776398,
-0.47396552562713623,
0.30866482853889465,
-0.12923721969127655,
0.08447331935167313,
0.10885308682918549,
-0.027911704033613205,
-0.33889856934547424,
0.6865485906600952,
0.6578423380851746,
-0.3164355456829071,
0.8774070739746094,
-0.21125225722789764,
0.017122015357017517,
-0.6909907460212708,
-0.36353108286857605,
0.14561127126216888,
-0.30710890889167786,
-0.6873188018798828,
0.013799944892525673,
-0.2236529290676117,
0.336466908454895,
-0.24662959575653076,
0.3630344271659851,
-0.2822127640247345,
-0.28685858845710754,
0.07061788439750671,
-0.10147219896316528,
0.31598150730133057,
-0.24209514260292053,
0.1845395267009735,
0.3933776021003723,
0.5669236183166504,
-0.3640553057193756,
0.1723182648420334,
0.19546909630298615,
-0.6503891348838806,
0.31094855070114136,
-0.6057316064834595,
-0.046610988676548004,
-0.06123153120279312,
0.2890304923057556,
-0.993050754070282,
-0.6239452362060547,
0.37644416093826294,
-0.7548364996910095,
0.5186769366264343,
0.13688747584819794,
-0.4292413592338562,
-0.5956974625587463,
-0.17475874722003937,
0.029855871573090553,
0.5708612203598022,
-0.24083447456359863,
0.1514805257320404,
0.4250975549221039,
0.05197834223508835,
-1.168209195137024,
-0.9946321845054626,
-0.11371275782585144,
-0.06398453563451767,
-0.40787407755851746,
0.2945380210876465,
0.13621217012405396,
-0.7550997734069824,
-0.012782576493918896,
-0.3611415922641754,
-0.30001285672187805,
0.515446126461029,
0.4179037809371948,
0.1477566659450531,
-0.0011042520636692643,
0.3199686110019684,
-0.015035501681268215,
-0.14444328844547272,
0.14920169115066528,
-0.5323655605316162,
0.08943042904138565,
-0.11302850395441055,
-0.5423052310943604,
-0.622225821018219,
0.3669423758983612,
0.03928128257393837,
0.030005183070898056,
0.8233139514923096,
0.46418970823287964,
-0.5273054838180542,
0.30283552408218384,
-0.25624045729637146,
-0.1677515059709549,
-0.3682415187358856,
0.4262913763523102,
-0.2942427396774292,
-0.46502143144607544,
0.5346706509590149,
-0.01678297482430935,
-0.3007603883743286,
0.6361250281333923,
0.4744013249874115,
-0.7551124095916748,
1.189186453819275,
0.9218019843101501,
0.16666138172149658,
0.19841203093528748,
0.013830883428454399,
0.21070609986782074,
-0.35210156440734863,
-0.21407544612884521,
-0.5348310470581055,
-0.13085545599460602,
-0.7577023506164551,
-0.5682460069656372,
-0.14090339839458466,
0.5580455660820007,
0.07046418637037277,
0.004124132450670004,
-0.6904916167259216,
0.31565847992897034,
0.7027865052223206,
0.10794954746961594,
0.45072394609451294,
-0.2556973695755005,
0.2953835725784302,
-0.4032973647117615,
-0.6749703884124756,
-0.9769338965415955,
1.29817533493042,
0.8040578961372375,
0.7349592447280884,
-0.012042393907904625,
0.7129122018814087,
0.3997209966182709,
0.4096170663833618,
-0.4866724908351898,
0.04700182005763054,
-0.21462087333202362,
-1.1158113479614258,
-0.36692509055137634,
-0.10350054502487183,
-0.8121671080589294,
0.19536834955215454,
-0.6773794889450073,
-1.1079192161560059,
0.6844269037246704,
0.3296682834625244,
-0.402208149433136,
0.4414926767349243,
-0.6275425553321838,
0.8769910335540771,
-0.10119196027517319,
0.024940960109233856,
0.2210872620344162,
-1.0232949256896973,
0.3938344120979309,
-0.13008162379264832,
0.21437664330005646,
-0.2000879943370819,
-0.06993573158979416,
0.6819813251495361,
-0.07650308310985565,
0.7742102146148682,
-0.09706229716539383,
-0.058998480439186096,
0.4531797468662262,
0.0895996242761612,
0.20465388894081116,
0.16790956258773804,
-0.4101996123790741,
0.062448836863040924,
0.4566822052001953,
-0.26613885164260864,
-0.6946334838867188,
0.01791042648255825,
-0.8573166728019714,
-0.42093923687934875,
-0.5919792056083679,
-0.5837255716323853,
-0.30678656697273254,
-0.2071300894021988,
0.6363308429718018,
0.20983660221099854,
-0.3157457709312439,
0.15222041308879852,
0.46116527915000916,
-0.3313720226287842,
0.05147910118103027,
-0.26224806904792786,
-0.3008582293987274,
-0.0654335767030716,
0.6249094605445862,
-0.004128058906644583,
0.5250009298324585,
0.5427241921424866,
0.21146951615810394,
-0.6667043566703796,
-0.5916868448257446,
0.0923585295677185,
-0.04753489792346954,
-0.9610331654548645,
0.05244462564587593,
-0.4625355303287506,
0.05036468431353569,
-0.5035570859909058,
-0.13032780587673187,
-0.4103901982307434,
-0.7248542308807373,
-0.6081423163414001,
-0.29135677218437195,
0.10364989191293716,
0.8763422966003418,
-0.2870553433895111,
0.6418518424034119,
-0.3668229877948761,
0.06515256315469742,
0.22089044749736786,
0.37796851992607117,
-0.3267812728881836,
-0.4244821071624756,
0.08080266416072845,
0.3238418698310852,
-0.2666184902191162,
-1.4064213037490845,
0.4608328938484192,
-0.028268074616789818,
0.4750182628631592,
0.5707085132598877,
0.24321909248828888,
0.07856471091508865,
-0.016278604045510292,
0.7941873073577881,
0.5033614635467529,
-0.8512038588523865,
0.30086350440979004,
-0.21314643323421478,
-0.17848342657089233,
0.6834083795547485,
0.9118345379829407,
-0.4675474464893341,
-0.4873410761356354,
-0.9793748259544373,
-0.636193573474884,
0.5901204347610474,
-0.04139479994773865,
-0.1785833239555359,
0.11678206920623779,
0.37203845381736755,
0.46148496866226196,
0.3553678095340729,
-0.827274739742279,
-0.42603448033332825,
-0.4164460599422455,
-0.1442258656024933,
-0.5481832027435303,
-0.5894555449485779,
-0.24549706280231476,
0.05654267221689224,
0.29210853576660156,
0.06621159613132477,
0.44695428013801575,
0.02492164820432663,
0.26374608278274536,
0.24719205498695374,
0.38218098878860474,
0.26004558801651,
0.8361457586288452,
-0.7144557237625122,
0.24626193940639496,
-0.2458006888628006,
-0.5173729658126831,
0.3677143156528473,
0.10934408009052277,
-0.2725856900215149,
0.36082175374031067,
0.5852068662643433,
0.812278151512146,
-0.028254322707653046,
-0.42716363072395325,
0.5260571837425232,
0.13843399286270142,
-0.2737889885902405,
-0.3977029323577881,
-0.1588389277458191,
0.3109135329723358,
0.1430036425590515,
0.4473702311515808,
0.4306688606739044,
0.6051273345947266,
-0.5939833521842957,
0.1304391771554947,
0.11920758336782455,
-0.7093740105628967,
-0.36795544624328613,
0.9411752820014954,
-0.027907848358154297,
-0.42183616757392883,
0.46439170837402344,
-0.3554101288318634,
-0.4182771146297455,
0.7385606169700623,
0.29508963227272034,
0.698086678981781,
-0.15748080611228943,
0.624535083770752,
0.17959937453269958,
0.3940829634666443,
-0.3029922842979431,
0.2278720885515213,
0.35619834065437317,
-0.8892180919647217,
-0.44982901215553284,
-0.6060593724250793,
-0.8543632626533508,
-0.16698604822158813,
-1.257794976234436,
0.01600605808198452,
-0.021467845886945724,
-0.6945774555206299,
0.2476082146167755,
-0.14244596660137177,
-0.5464844107627869,
0.4653220474720001,
0.25782784819602966,
0.9469484686851501,
-1.1361801624298096,
0.6862461566925049,
0.7796806693077087,
-0.15065711736679077,
-0.677868664264679,
0.04499111324548721,
-0.04182147979736328,
-0.27784737944602966,
0.6622554063796997,
0.01934926025569439,
0.23649922013282776,
-0.33543694019317627,
-0.5821093320846558,
-0.7902746200561523,
0.7936112284660339,
0.23551097512245178,
-0.6439444422721863,
0.11857911944389343,
0.23320598900318146,
0.6708771586418152,
-0.23681755363941193,
0.241939514875412,
0.7380218505859375,
0.4630615711212158,
-0.11998655647039413,
-0.7114561796188354,
-0.30404824018478394,
0.3375118374824524,
0.29833051562309265,
-0.1985558122396469,
0.14629068970680237,
0.7381574511528015,
-0.3832332491874695,
-0.35782724618911743,
-0.11814424395561218,
0.6448509097099304,
0.4216409921646118,
0.5555680990219116,
0.4541711211204529,
0.11853960156440735,
0.9907673597335815,
-0.36017540097236633,
1.5863685607910156,
-0.042799122631549835,
0.557904064655304,
1.314085841178894,
-0.21698187291622162,
1.0340075492858887,
0.6977420449256897,
-0.916480541229248,
0.3761988580226898,
1.173311471939087,
0.25514090061187744,
0.5899158120155334,
0.33592429757118225,
-0.17642386257648468,
-0.4408699870109558,
-0.0070925927720963955,
-0.4161827862262726,
0.48768699169158936,
0.5470844507217407,
-0.27891820669174194,
0.12300325185060501,
-0.05708615481853485,
-0.3355540633201599,
0.10920548439025879,
0.030801549553871155,
0.36860597133636475,
0.21667751669883728,
-0.5843378901481628,
0.13251276314258575,
0.006593217141926289,
0.6728143095970154,
-0.3168832063674927,
0.17721250653266907,
0.2098960131406784,
0.08781427890062332,
-0.2572481632232666,
-1.173338770866394,
0.17375996708869934,
-0.5941851735115051,
-0.2558791935443878,
-0.2086046189069748,
0.7530236840248108,
-0.09386689960956573,
-0.5378284454345703,
0.36043789982795715,
0.485931396484375,
0.3730214536190033,
-0.13370051980018616,
-0.9204939007759094,
-0.16876916587352753,
-0.0029089278541505337,
-0.47754690051078796,
0.22867870330810547,
0.1949567049741745,
0.06959205865859985,
1.024611473083496,
0.2848113775253296,
0.07795990258455276,
0.2154533714056015,
-0.0367962121963501,
0.31929969787597656,
-0.19818682968616486,
-0.2668619453907013,
-0.6938257813453674,
0.523378312587738,
0.083475261926651,
-0.31738197803497314,
0.4215484857559204,
0.05262681096792221,
0.5869766473770142,
-0.30240970849990845,
0.718845784664154,
0.06592058390378952,
0.4317692220211029,
-0.10953958332538605,
0.550744354724884,
-0.36756110191345215,
0.09314357489347458,
-0.4128456115722656,
-0.7048524618148804,
-0.4446510374546051,
0.6684584021568298,
-0.30061477422714233,
0.057008594274520874,
0.44252312183380127,
0.1777247190475464,
0.3221556544303894,
0.08917269855737686,
0.37727439403533936,
-0.1618821620941162,
-0.04783696308732033,
0.6137180924415588,
1.2362163066864014,
-0.47801658511161804,
0.251189649105072,
-0.560245156288147,
-0.2909741699695587,
-0.3616686165332794,
-1.1434446573257446,
-0.15627555549144745,
-0.7367414236068726,
-0.5584518313407898,
-0.4437529742717743,
-0.19712243974208832,
0.544788122177124,
0.7910913228988647,
-0.734687864780426,
-0.01895889826118946,
0.0012728279689326882,
0.29447558522224426,
-0.5855345129966736,
-0.16717205941677094,
0.14617617428302765,
-0.05298307165503502,
-0.7622941732406616,
-0.07908277213573456,
0.16986502707004547,
0.6002627015113831,
-0.35572123527526855,
-0.1395513415336609,
0.13523222506046295,
0.047565191984176636,
0.2510630488395691,
0.12340523302555084,
-0.9341930150985718,
-0.2448430210351944,
-0.12746167182922363,
-0.1754625290632248,
-0.16739466786384583,
0.07076211273670197,
-0.5203794240951538,
0.7328636050224304,
0.48421433568000793,
0.35098540782928467,
0.3610368072986603,
0.029533153399825096,
0.807797372341156,
-0.4857771098613739,
0.2716430127620697,
0.5647559762001038,
0.35770779848098755,
0.24554158747196198,
-0.45231539011001587,
0.662966787815094,
-0.0671146884560585,
-0.4935799539089203,
-1.206070065498352,
0.6029369235038757,
-0.965437650680542,
-0.37303149700164795,
0.8091373443603516,
-0.4132024347782135,
0.13872130215168,
-0.21212853491306305,
0.3491746783256531,
-0.10605425387620926,
0.0407918244600296,
0.5305964946746826,
1.0156033039093018,
-0.17158132791519165,
0.21280811727046967,
-1.0550283193588257,
0.6901148557662964,
0.4119468033313751,
-0.4231586754322052,
-0.10887223482131958,
0.11345178633928299,
-0.04407064616680145,
0.6277883648872375,
0.5506913065910339,
-0.0817389115691185,
0.2370988428592682,
0.398364394903183,
0.36573174595832825,
0.4785362184047699,
-0.3667663633823395,
-0.5762413144111633,
0.061180077493190765,
0.36613157391548157,
-0.15156643092632294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00813v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00813v3
|
UrbanGPT: Spatio-Temporal Large Language Models
| 2024-02-25T12:37:29 | 2024-05-19T01:58:03 |
Zhonghang Li, Lianghao Xia, Jiabin Tang, Yong Xu, Lei Shi, Long Xia, Dawei Yin, Chao Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Spatio-temporal prediction aims to forecast and gain insights into the
ever-changing dynamics of urban environments across both time and space. Its
purpose is to anticipate future patterns, trends, and events in diverse facets
of urban life, including transportation, population movement, and crime rates.
Although numerous efforts have been dedicated to developing neural network
techniques for accurate predictions on spatio-temporal data, it is important to
note that many of these methods heavily depend on having sufficient labeled
data to generate precise spatio-temporal representations. Unfortunately, the
issue of data scarcity is pervasive in practical urban sensing scenarios.
Consequently, it becomes necessary to build a spatio-temporal model with strong
generalization capabilities across diverse spatio-temporal learning scenarios.
Taking inspiration from the remarkable achievements of large language models
(LLMs), our objective is to create a spatio-temporal LLM that can exhibit
exceptional generalization capabilities across a wide range of downstream urban
tasks. To achieve this objective, we present the UrbanGPT, which seamlessly
integrates a spatio-temporal dependency encoder with the instruction-tuning
paradigm. This integration enables LLMs to comprehend the complex
inter-dependencies across time and space, facilitating more comprehensive and
accurate predictions under data scarcity. To validate the effectiveness of our
approach, we conduct extensive experiments on various public datasets, covering
different spatio-temporal prediction tasks. The results consistently
demonstrate that our UrbanGPT, with its carefully designed architecture,
consistently outperforms state-of-the-art baselines. These findings highlight
the potential of building large language models for spatio-temporal learning,
particularly in zero-shot scenarios where labeled data is scarce.
|
[
-0.45361948013305664,
-0.6929231286048889,
0.8059861063957214,
0.18471494317054749,
0.028902078047394753,
0.09682346880435944,
-0.34715747833251953,
-0.5241208076477051,
-0.1404639482498169,
0.1367090344429016,
-0.1868513524532318,
-0.49994269013404846,
-0.47868335247039795,
-0.4141536355018616,
-0.3246121406555176,
0.8013381958007812,
-0.07842998206615448,
0.04962378740310669,
0.174716055393219,
0.18215328454971313,
-0.4525003731250763,
-0.35107892751693726,
-0.7850463390350342,
-0.4253707528114319,
0.5476159453392029,
0.4050154983997345,
0.7012764811515808,
1.0400992631912231,
0.2352578341960907,
0.20144349336624146,
0.17102934420108795,
0.048375796526670456,
-0.31357380747795105,
-0.2752384543418884,
0.010504855774343014,
0.3341611325740814,
-0.29282382130622864,
-0.4036991000175476,
0.6606098413467407,
0.9242130517959595,
-0.35195738077163696,
-0.08564198017120361,
0.0050087617710232735,
0.3305310010910034,
-0.3916175365447998,
0.4346824288368225,
-0.5540041327476501,
0.05197756364941597,
-0.09420274198055267,
-0.1547526717185974,
-0.03623168542981148,
-0.13905709981918335,
0.24492250382900238,
-0.5306481719017029,
0.3515594005584717,
-0.03803052753210068,
0.5285685658454895,
0.3739017844200134,
-0.46943408250808716,
0.05700499191880226,
-1.2254127264022827,
0.6008750796318054,
-0.36981338262557983,
0.5277857780456543,
0.4556730091571808,
0.5621883869171143,
-0.09760519862174988,
-0.5087102055549622,
-0.3607555031776428,
-0.19730229675769806,
0.12547637522220612,
0.3561394214630127,
0.18968579173088074,
0.07436580210924149,
0.002442512195557356,
-0.18127521872520447,
-0.9663826823234558,
0.24579910933971405,
-0.3210853040218353,
0.34704238176345825,
0.35439565777778625,
0.35507234930992126,
-0.03618695214390755,
-0.13966862857341766,
-0.5348349809646606,
0.06347653269767761,
-0.5757423639297485,
-0.1356021612882614,
0.07851173728704453,
0.4048117399215698,
-0.12143933027982712,
0.14306621253490448,
-0.27507108449935913,
0.4796777367591858,
-0.3050728738307953,
0.2561749815940857,
-0.06574531644582748,
-0.21292833983898163,
-0.2019886076450348,
-0.07966936379671097,
0.9557774066925049,
0.20851832628250122,
0.3181096911430359,
-0.4183120131492615,
-0.013614578172564507,
-0.43599459528923035,
0.14233815670013428,
-0.7083456516265869,
-0.5632871985435486,
0.3950788080692291,
0.09639767557382584,
-0.08336735516786575,
0.022190986201167107,
-1.1648077964782715,
-0.2239144742488861,
-0.40592899918556213,
-0.17862506210803986,
-0.5092933177947998,
-0.17930671572685242,
0.35156744718551636,
0.23880645632743835,
0.07440199702978134,
0.4916188716888428,
-1.1778240203857422,
-0.051344648003578186,
0.5208582878112793,
0.7913833856582642,
-0.010855603031814098,
-0.7391512989997864,
0.027561817318201065,
0.7414146661758423,
-0.2704198956489563,
0.921127200126648,
-0.7045584917068481,
-0.1147235780954361,
-0.0274770800024271,
-0.24662289023399353,
-0.15369293093681335,
-0.314973384141922,
0.4270070791244507,
-0.32243475317955017,
-0.3716384172439575,
0.09639201313257217,
-0.18213410675525665,
-0.2067212015390396,
0.2040700614452362,
-0.40963485836982727,
1.3062593936920166,
0.06033157557249069,
-0.44061312079429626,
0.5251553058624268,
-0.6917927861213684,
-0.44845646619796753,
0.4452199339866638,
-0.06616079062223434,
-0.5071922540664673,
-0.03844129666686058,
0.5128244161605835,
0.6259603500366211,
-0.11949217319488525,
0.6621525287628174,
-0.4142777919769287,
-0.43165549635887146,
-0.02544310688972473,
-0.6033107042312622,
0.2720736563205719,
0.15258945524692535,
-0.49056121706962585,
-0.05466126650571823,
-0.7748363614082336,
-0.3114411234855652,
0.20958316326141357,
-0.6660636067390442,
-0.106017105281353,
0.35082489252090454,
0.3998573422431946,
-0.013425271026790142,
0.25368380546569824,
-0.7484866976737976,
0.40022239089012146,
-0.22704896330833435,
0.43226513266563416,
0.8260537385940552,
-0.23383842408657074,
0.44022274017333984,
-0.21603448688983917,
0.3573589324951172,
-0.11804930865764618,
0.16595858335494995,
-0.08660876750946045,
-0.5461483597755432,
-0.4793649911880493,
-0.246768981218338,
0.04651255160570145,
0.7300894856452942,
-0.67745041847229,
0.4263353645801544,
-0.9267771244049072,
-0.507876455783844,
-0.08844804018735886,
-0.1952221840620041,
-0.16508319973945618,
0.28152555227279663,
0.43924686312675476,
0.26554930210113525,
-0.8218836784362793,
-0.16551704704761505,
0.26969316601753235,
0.060447484254837036,
-0.1768132895231247,
0.4854297935962677,
0.49020880460739136,
-0.4403258264064789,
0.7595069408416748,
-0.40218743681907654,
-0.0026640663854777813,
-0.24863605201244354,
0.12690220773220062,
-0.04225274547934532,
0.4439939558506012,
0.574760913848877,
-0.6377297043800354,
-0.4060376286506653,
0.22590839862823486,
-0.43214643001556396,
0.05555398762226105,
-0.09438223391771317,
-0.10214409977197647,
-0.26891475915908813,
0.25037848949432373,
-0.6540105938911438,
0.602276086807251,
0.48586535453796387,
-0.28334131836891174,
0.5385204553604126,
-0.32540884613990784,
0.085542693734169,
-0.9530271291732788,
-0.1950889229774475,
-0.10368315130472183,
-0.17707239091396332,
-0.6330934166908264,
-0.01962331496179104,
-0.24384592473506927,
-0.5074604153633118,
-0.36456555128097534,
0.5925261974334717,
-0.1259242743253708,
-0.21441586315631866,
-0.09058436006307602,
-0.16683067381381989,
-0.2865220010280609,
0.55281662940979,
0.36105406284332275,
0.6517860889434814,
0.6196931600570679,
-0.5629957318305969,
0.4439816474914551,
0.06173209846019745,
-0.5510120391845703,
-0.12891885638237,
-0.5701674222946167,
0.24034181237220764,
-0.17994852364063263,
0.23938815295696259,
-0.9464640617370605,
-0.4478719234466553,
0.06667478382587433,
-0.24334099888801575,
0.0019464786164462566,
-0.5671266913414001,
-0.9082781672477722,
-0.4468494951725006,
0.18852050602436066,
0.5180220603942871,
0.23929734528064728,
-0.6905420422554016,
0.6877262592315674,
0.175755113363266,
-0.015035438351333141,
-0.26634177565574646,
-0.7341511845588684,
0.04145537316799164,
-0.1482003629207611,
-0.23155097663402557,
-0.14811626076698303,
-0.10294989496469498,
0.20905831456184387,
-0.033053986728191376,
0.35226699709892273,
-0.35049012303352356,
0.0757562443614006,
0.29966285824775696,
0.1223718672990799,
0.03944117948412895,
0.2301458865404129,
-0.239174485206604,
-0.26943889260292053,
-0.13004176318645477,
-0.7291883826255798,
0.851263165473938,
0.007839958183467388,
-0.40264588594436646,
0.17172667384147644,
0.36356863379478455,
0.7498241662979126,
-0.3468543291091919,
0.5457099080085754,
0.9137735366821289,
-0.4128454327583313,
-0.13834774494171143,
-0.2452382743358612,
0.11248461902141571,
-0.445046991109848,
0.6308505535125732,
-0.2975102365016937,
-0.9500354528427124,
0.4758791923522949,
-0.22284255921840668,
-0.09590388089418411,
-0.04813559725880623,
0.5978031158447266,
-0.40112951397895813,
1.018330693244934,
0.32584431767463684,
-0.0778159648180008,
0.6237409710884094,
-0.23150840401649475,
0.3254479169845581,
-0.7144043445587158,
-0.24603737890720367,
-0.3165169060230255,
-0.3220420181751251,
-0.562217652797699,
-0.5967103838920593,
0.4368686079978943,
-0.24662065505981445,
-0.6281710267066956,
0.2337777465581894,
-0.5644828081130981,
0.5606322884559631,
0.5129950046539307,
0.059964776039123535,
-0.0850534439086914,
0.2786893844604492,
0.022747348994016647,
0.15818513929843903,
-0.7960766553878784,
-0.34811845421791077,
1.1028274297714233,
0.37774717807769775,
0.48809343576431274,
0.07715808600187302,
0.3717104196548462,
0.07219727337360382,
0.09555530548095703,
-0.6288770437240601,
0.5221570730209351,
-0.5122271776199341,
-0.4224267899990082,
-0.40854668617248535,
-0.5225932002067566,
-1.2696396112442017,
-0.024082671850919724,
-0.03179129585623741,
-0.926251232624054,
0.17922163009643555,
0.010780313052237034,
-0.6673792004585266,
0.7486281394958496,
-0.5319556593894958,
0.828301191329956,
-0.4890708029270172,
-0.22486630082130432,
-0.01126372441649437,
-0.2846135199069977,
-0.11981034278869629,
-0.027046676725149155,
0.2979021966457367,
-0.4562263786792755,
0.0804501324892044,
0.32166963815689087,
0.011540357023477554,
1.0389132499694824,
-0.20339542627334595,
0.1972590684890747,
0.11787419021129608,
0.11510353535413742,
0.4239502251148224,
0.18769003450870514,
0.061082787811756134,
0.48949429392814636,
-0.1199757531285286,
-0.5346304774284363,
-0.4848012328147888,
0.6190269589424133,
-0.9928104877471924,
0.15218527615070343,
-0.18721580505371094,
-1.0039074420928955,
-0.10254130512475967,
0.06690582633018494,
0.2754044234752655,
0.7713097929954529,
-0.22111113369464874,
-0.15769173204898834,
0.692781925201416,
-0.20165640115737915,
0.5619020462036133,
0.5250066518783569,
-0.35381218791007996,
-0.46025654673576355,
1.0872802734375,
0.14163285493850708,
-0.16990579664707184,
0.7287653088569641,
0.3797888159751892,
-0.1919824779033661,
-0.796991765499115,
-0.5560563206672668,
-0.0794464498758316,
-0.4073048532009125,
-0.06993438303470612,
-0.5092086791992188,
-0.09012765437364578,
-0.5205301642417908,
-0.5415961146354675,
-0.5435004234313965,
-0.1411140114068985,
-0.15678918361663818,
-0.1826154738664627,
0.35303041338920593,
1.159312129020691,
-0.1435694694519043,
0.3381340503692627,
-0.7912982106208801,
0.10484383255243301,
0.28021523356437683,
0.5162009000778198,
0.11376123875379562,
-0.28199049830436707,
-0.5417470932006836,
0.08790955692529678,
-0.03535714000463486,
-0.4537968039512634,
0.4142726957798004,
-0.0007921080105006695,
0.19079707562923431,
0.35352134704589844,
-0.19816648960113525,
0.7020213007926941,
-0.8321659564971924,
0.6283068060874939,
-0.1308516263961792,
-0.366047203540802,
0.6247646808624268,
-0.9399680495262146,
0.7116925120353699,
0.24695159494876862,
0.3366069495677948,
-0.3842982053756714,
-0.2791869044303894,
-0.3746437132358551,
-1.0879842042922974,
0.39465123414993286,
-0.11099659651517868,
0.032325707376003265,
-0.1121523529291153,
0.30895885825157166,
0.1426914781332016,
0.21195615828037262,
-0.6518399715423584,
0.04534761980175972,
-0.4957452714443207,
-0.25602778792381287,
-0.23382921516895294,
-0.3500377833843231,
0.23375140130519867,
-0.5412670373916626,
0.2009710818529129,
-0.16222339868545532,
0.5814473032951355,
0.08106500655412674,
0.31289932131767273,
-0.08048675954341888,
0.49502044916152954,
0.6941392421722412,
0.5718615651130676,
-0.49849361181259155,
0.2055162489414215,
0.31794437766075134,
-0.6232368350028992,
0.1279669553041458,
0.4748181402683258,
-0.4495536684989929,
-0.2010820358991623,
0.3116247057914734,
0.9852985739707947,
0.40483808517456055,
-0.6040736436843872,
0.22904106974601746,
0.26619669795036316,
-0.018430739641189575,
-0.5917392373085022,
-0.3601420521736145,
-0.10150688141584396,
0.2720228433609009,
0.4946632385253906,
0.16092520952224731,
0.12614686787128448,
-0.421907514333725,
0.18347856402397156,
0.035349905490875244,
-0.38237038254737854,
-0.3552674353122711,
0.8280104398727417,
0.04521765932440758,
0.011422496289014816,
0.7046627402305603,
-0.4279399514198303,
-0.689534604549408,
0.712188184261322,
0.30728232860565186,
1.0326145887374878,
-0.16964492201805115,
0.03795643523335457,
0.49202683568000793,
0.38279780745506287,
0.07923438400030136,
0.2148715704679489,
0.020000150427222252,
-0.873339056968689,
-0.6754276752471924,
-0.8023750185966492,
-0.2260604202747345,
0.2921837866306305,
-0.36187824606895447,
-0.132350355386734,
-0.6626728177070618,
-0.12555843591690063,
-0.5640968084335327,
0.016115115955471992,
-0.6878094673156738,
0.19770686328411102,
0.3543420433998108,
0.7724353075027466,
-0.8169231414794922,
0.9151818156242371,
1.0019490718841553,
-0.0819392129778862,
-1.0197350978851318,
0.1658490151166916,
-0.2680690884590149,
-0.7167596817016602,
0.5708444714546204,
0.05352898687124252,
-0.08235447108745575,
0.018976712599396706,
-0.6823827624320984,
-0.8702822327613831,
1.1182149648666382,
0.34210404753685,
-0.8221415281295776,
-0.23441217839717865,
0.6409327983856201,
0.6195141673088074,
-0.3410817086696625,
0.30064657330513,
0.6552623510360718,
0.5281561613082886,
0.27796289324760437,
-0.9245374798774719,
-0.19023668766021729,
0.146429643034935,
0.10705307871103287,
0.38134852051734924,
-0.5972917079925537,
0.7645724415779114,
-0.3092420697212219,
-0.02074355073273182,
-0.01343583408743143,
0.4659518599510193,
0.0336543507874012,
0.2996668517589569,
0.20460867881774902,
0.8603948950767517,
0.46851155161857605,
-0.5010598301887512,
1.1898037195205688,
-0.2660430669784546,
0.3118748068809509,
1.2586721181869507,
-0.09907866269350052,
0.8483620882034302,
-0.07431264221668243,
-0.07287091016769409,
0.2916041314601898,
0.6860111951828003,
-0.19150947034358978,
0.7425013184547424,
-0.11088801175355911,
-0.32479068636894226,
-0.3384053111076355,
-0.18267597258090973,
-0.048966944217681885,
0.67606121301651,
0.4949992299079895,
0.15549837052822113,
-0.3734143376350403,
0.14456364512443542,
-0.03645002096891403,
-0.2202804684638977,
-0.4958541691303253,
0.6789376139640808,
-0.313418447971344,
-0.34238407015800476,
0.21612544357776642,
-0.22988733649253845,
0.40383803844451904,
-0.6003754138946533,
-0.13947658240795135,
-0.11142311990261078,
0.18779508769512177,
0.011037158779799938,
-1.122666358947754,
0.2519592344760895,
-0.2996279299259186,
-0.1384064108133316,
-0.3098313808441162,
0.4932471513748169,
-0.7369911074638367,
-0.38010984659194946,
0.5865967869758606,
0.21056891977787018,
0.16004879772663116,
0.019705310463905334,
-0.5745020508766174,
0.03349674493074417,
-0.04368172585964203,
-0.08569444715976715,
0.3639901578426361,
0.7029981017112732,
0.2092975229024887,
0.9387221336364746,
0.6963853240013123,
0.4283604025840759,
0.3558477759361267,
0.2037176638841629,
0.6282362341880798,
-0.3757668435573578,
-0.40286341309547424,
-0.630874514579773,
0.454794317483902,
0.317327618598938,
-0.13225652277469635,
0.4268763065338135,
0.6375438570976257,
0.8491432070732117,
-0.048966336995363235,
0.934766948223114,
0.060174278914928436,
0.5002834796905518,
-0.5119246244430542,
0.5391215682029724,
-0.2873584032058716,
0.298901230096817,
0.1090337485074997,
-0.7850074172019958,
-0.21283884346485138,
0.5637251138687134,
-0.5646293759346008,
0.2505476772785187,
0.42825978994369507,
0.4964129328727722,
-0.2800540328025818,
-0.23318861424922943,
0.45826002955436707,
0.08947058022022247,
0.3959644138813019,
1.1008398532867432,
0.9369148015975952,
-0.277192085981369,
0.8670493364334106,
-0.42335930466651917,
-0.10123927891254425,
-0.02008621208369732,
-0.7296609282493591,
-0.8547239899635315,
-0.6365635395050049,
-0.1274452954530716,
0.2094193547964096,
0.24215202033519745,
0.7524191737174988,
0.9354517459869385,
-0.81568843126297,
-0.2463938593864441,
-0.281784325838089,
-0.2932719886302948,
-0.08441147208213806,
-0.3033839762210846,
0.42792627215385437,
0.11640581488609314,
-0.8264814019203186,
0.6131952404975891,
0.5327785015106201,
0.4390815198421478,
-0.07842201739549637,
0.017196809872984886,
-0.06616179645061493,
-0.1219078078866005,
0.4790995717048645,
0.3423853814601898,
-0.35071128606796265,
-0.5656285881996155,
-0.26875394582748413,
-0.04445556178689003,
0.20282912254333496,
0.7745053768157959,
-0.5944632291793823,
0.38088151812553406,
0.22906628251075745,
0.6219125390052795,
0.585335373878479,
-0.0966036468744278,
0.5647461414337158,
-0.9782537817955017,
0.2676515579223633,
0.22197721898555756,
0.5181105136871338,
0.47616642713546753,
-0.4416263699531555,
0.6174638271331787,
0.10533688962459564,
-0.9285342693328857,
-0.38597047328948975,
0.42046016454696655,
-0.842930018901825,
-0.2296311855316162,
1.2327088117599487,
0.039299558848142624,
0.03978472203016281,
-0.5695605874061584,
0.09104523807764053,
0.25451937317848206,
-0.627643346786499,
0.8593397736549377,
0.43683120608329773,
-0.02442147210240364,
-0.4562501907348633,
-1.00071120262146,
0.13589616119861603,
-0.019771503284573555,
-0.7230831384658813,
0.3505232036113739,
0.40757161378860474,
0.15006674826145172,
0.0415504053235054,
0.5639656782150269,
0.35692301392555237,
0.19416001439094543,
-0.03292180597782135,
0.20908765494823456,
-0.23601892590522766,
-0.655474841594696,
-0.15066511929035187,
0.15203344821929932,
-0.171177476644516,
-0.15415947139263153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16065v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16065v1
|
Training a Bilingual Language Model by Mapping Tokens onto a Shared Character Space
| 2024-02-25T11:26:39 | 2024-02-25T11:26:39 |
Aviad Rom, Kfir Bar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We train a bilingual Arabic-Hebrew language model using a transliterated
version of Arabic texts in Hebrew, to ensure both languages are represented in
the same script. Given the morphological, structural similarities, and the
extensive number of cognates shared among Arabic and Hebrew, we assess the
performance of a language model that employs a unified script for both
languages, on machine translation which requires cross-lingual knowledge. The
results are promising: our model outperforms a contrasting model which keeps
the Arabic texts in the Arabic script, demonstrating the efficacy of the
transliteration step. Despite being trained on a dataset approximately 60%
smaller than that of other existing language models, our model appears to
deliver comparable performance in machine translation across both translation
directions.
|
[
-0.05400676280260086,
-0.1409500241279602,
0.20092558860778809,
0.25485938787460327,
-0.3764350712299347,
0.4241397976875305,
0.05117623507976532,
-0.5746513605117798,
0.2395843267440796,
0.5218417048454285,
-0.45250216126441956,
-0.7725836038589478,
-0.7089555263519287,
0.15252962708473206,
-0.4690578877925873,
0.9296496510505676,
-0.2357773780822754,
0.6837546229362488,
0.08070772141218185,
-0.5615634322166443,
-0.5711804032325745,
-0.5860632061958313,
-0.4915880560874939,
-0.5298250913619995,
0.5614516139030457,
0.3591405749320984,
1.0790928602218628,
0.798892080783844,
0.5889370441436768,
0.27557095885276794,
0.21837911009788513,
-0.02988564595580101,
-0.2532113194465637,
-0.14211638271808624,
-0.13700245320796967,
-0.5544146299362183,
-0.20924808084964752,
-0.3017139732837677,
0.8106141686439514,
1.101059079170227,
-0.006371139548718929,
0.01996837556362152,
-0.3626498579978943,
0.3774755895137787,
-0.2985439896583557,
0.2606799006462097,
-0.6323336958885193,
0.2544310390949249,
-0.16806037724018097,
-0.03377861902117729,
-0.3810916841030121,
-0.34572991728782654,
0.10532647371292114,
-0.4413982331752777,
0.23511070013046265,
0.4056365489959717,
0.7354755997657776,
-0.08807285875082016,
-0.7610979080200195,
-0.2851310074329376,
-0.6157183051109314,
0.8440383076667786,
-0.4316565990447998,
0.4577195346355438,
0.39643344283103943,
0.25624051690101624,
0.24904344975948334,
-0.5091084241867065,
-0.41920706629753113,
-0.31786689162254333,
-0.2966529130935669,
0.005384691059589386,
-0.12623240053653717,
-0.07470197975635529,
0.007519290316849947,
0.1871802806854248,
-0.7303969264030457,
0.32971426844596863,
-0.45400649309158325,
-0.44925862550735474,
0.5081266760826111,
0.1534305065870285,
1.1245990991592407,
0.0356317013502121,
-0.6351210474967957,
-0.2784546911716461,
-0.8218249082565308,
0.093581922352314,
0.49964848160743713,
0.46067216992378235,
-0.1646064966917038,
0.7179983258247375,
0.18916651606559753,
0.40760400891304016,
-0.17875756323337555,
0.02652992121875286,
0.36923810839653015,
-0.4810182452201843,
-0.09135839343070984,
0.4182911515235901,
0.6771033406257629,
0.300884485244751,
0.317790150642395,
-0.5328775644302368,
-0.36143991351127625,
-0.05184344947338104,
0.309511661529541,
-0.7682704925537109,
0.2988790273666382,
-0.20641598105430603,
-0.36922362446784973,
0.1476747989654541,
0.12468449026346207,
-0.3250359296798706,
-0.04075215384364128,
-0.36024895310401917,
0.39269739389419556,
-0.6173738837242126,
-0.19779540598392487,
0.1347605288028717,
-0.20496946573257446,
0.22265329957008362,
0.12692593038082123,
-1.3237336874008179,
0.49291059374809265,
0.8579319715499878,
0.8544818162918091,
-0.2851840853691101,
-0.7390109300613403,
-0.5031865835189819,
0.21258635818958282,
-0.48257896304130554,
0.4870986044406891,
-0.5984914302825928,
-0.44975173473358154,
0.41619905829429626,
-0.15760034322738647,
-0.4351192116737366,
-0.6427493691444397,
0.29201748967170715,
-0.9340821504592896,
-0.04850495979189873,
-0.2579851448535919,
-0.4768141806125641,
-0.2779846787452698,
-0.01646842435002327,
-1.00747811794281,
0.989122748374939,
0.39277419447898865,
-0.8981192111968994,
0.45047101378440857,
-0.4152391254901886,
-0.5326924324035645,
0.01777542755007744,
-0.140802800655365,
-0.3810442090034485,
0.13400495052337646,
0.21490344405174255,
0.09462131559848785,
-0.2676223814487457,
0.17695176601409912,
-0.11359518766403198,
-0.5536671280860901,
0.20849785208702087,
-0.055688418447971344,
0.9602088928222656,
0.06861156970262527,
-0.1917266845703125,
0.158944234251976,
-0.6449537873268127,
-0.03784646838903427,
-0.04451516270637512,
-0.42025026679039,
-0.4102003276348114,
-0.4116642475128174,
0.4604242742061615,
0.27182456851005554,
0.48117130994796753,
-0.5595070719718933,
0.2808602750301361,
-0.5511850714683533,
-0.09370598196983337,
0.3639145493507385,
-0.4346839487552643,
0.7821906805038452,
-0.34058281779289246,
0.6671692728996277,
0.2909366190433502,
-0.3446098864078522,
-0.23780453205108643,
-0.4689246714115143,
-0.876387894153595,
-0.33401864767074585,
0.4321855902671814,
0.5771099925041199,
-0.5801868438720703,
0.44143742322921753,
-0.329163521528244,
-0.3793555796146393,
-0.7750707268714905,
0.20164206624031067,
0.6242291331291199,
0.24779510498046875,
0.39955002069473267,
-0.8832226395606995,
-0.6631168723106384,
-1.0119363069534302,
-0.5261267423629761,
-0.21195660531520844,
0.19538085162639618,
-0.05185864493250847,
0.7074617743492126,
-0.3560585379600525,
0.7655268907546997,
0.1633557677268982,
-0.10162921249866486,
-0.596692681312561,
0.5764592885971069,
0.008841995149850845,
0.512601912021637,
0.5151797533035278,
-0.6649273633956909,
-1.0553992986679077,
0.5462356209754944,
-0.6693158149719238,
-0.1178155466914177,
-0.01888209581375122,
-0.0868108719587326,
0.19511191546916962,
0.5822463035583496,
-0.40502452850341797,
0.7157241702079773,
0.6969099640846252,
-0.49524345993995667,
0.3078092932701111,
-0.38877397775650024,
0.27062851190567017,
-1.1657310724258423,
0.2272171825170517,
-0.3914148509502411,
-0.3820476531982422,
-0.7649335265159607,
0.19644960761070251,
0.1506904810667038,
-0.1636398285627365,
-0.46386662125587463,
0.7628308534622192,
-0.49485576152801514,
-0.358528733253479,
-0.2746776342391968,
-0.3347715139389038,
-0.23681588470935822,
0.5777650475502014,
0.244681254029274,
1.0122014284133911,
0.6323804259300232,
-0.03464288264513016,
0.20169289410114288,
0.25925853848457336,
-0.5575860142707825,
0.2847939729690552,
-0.6863659024238586,
0.20603209733963013,
-0.12478313595056534,
0.15793627500534058,
-0.9888811111450195,
-0.13451410830020905,
0.10686909407377243,
-0.17741447687149048,
0.5682511925697327,
-0.1397916078567505,
-0.7234500050544739,
-0.11450695991516113,
0.0873372033238411,
0.9043914079666138,
0.5394216179847717,
-0.4220213294029236,
0.6006107926368713,
0.18951597809791565,
-0.35238420963287354,
-0.7239965796470642,
-0.7544382214546204,
0.03238767385482788,
-0.16060282289981842,
-0.7278466820716858,
0.5236490964889526,
0.24990959465503693,
-0.10916976630687714,
0.0019417721778154373,
0.033034682273864746,
-0.41845348477363586,
-0.04309677705168724,
0.3510206639766693,
0.2259579300880432,
-0.36564913392066956,
0.17068573832511902,
0.18525062501430511,
-0.2551632225513458,
-0.2264566272497177,
-0.38156870007514954,
0.8581807017326355,
-0.04918073117733002,
-0.8935853838920593,
-0.7073469758033752,
0.8324182629585266,
0.8202670812606812,
-0.34678155183792114,
1.3186079263687134,
0.6662546992301941,
-0.351057767868042,
0.06057771295309067,
-0.34597480297088623,
0.04586709290742874,
-0.36529627442359924,
0.5822367668151855,
-0.3949432969093323,
-0.7244955897331238,
0.8424190878868103,
-0.1119929850101471,
-0.10818304866552353,
0.47915545105934143,
0.769303560256958,
0.07654529809951782,
1.1989957094192505,
0.8788043856620789,
-0.45220011472702026,
0.36377811431884766,
0.027971236035227776,
0.24805773794651031,
-0.24457651376724243,
-0.36151134967803955,
-0.7673746347427368,
-0.34033820033073425,
-0.4854717254638672,
-0.6217564344406128,
0.23259873688220978,
0.11078112572431564,
-0.2880289852619171,
0.6313037276268005,
0.17484751343727112,
0.5312093496322632,
0.8343502283096313,
-0.3164633810520172,
0.4043753743171692,
0.5230249762535095,
-0.7441537976264954,
-0.23034249246120453,
-0.6951637268066406,
-0.5155842304229736,
1.13005793094635,
0.2925446331501007,
0.5240122675895691,
0.11324338614940643,
0.9439162015914917,
0.14794139564037323,
0.22425386309623718,
-0.451515257358551,
0.22712033987045288,
0.029840433970093727,
-0.7736084461212158,
-0.1957172155380249,
-0.3484016954898834,
-1.0737704038619995,
0.26126861572265625,
0.1680906116962433,
-0.6472741365432739,
-0.3193194568157196,
-0.27811846137046814,
-0.012421810068190098,
0.23403677344322205,
-0.6109508872032166,
0.9124449491500854,
-0.22345958650112152,
0.029357027262449265,
-0.5583872199058533,
-0.8144422769546509,
-0.06584763526916504,
-0.2907801568508148,
0.040391433984041214,
0.1663445681333542,
0.14088529348373413,
0.8137003183364868,
-0.6332296133041382,
0.8111346364021301,
0.18265651166439056,
0.09913089126348495,
0.2789035439491272,
0.19167853891849518,
0.19128650426864624,
-0.2581007182598114,
-0.11546309292316437,
0.5769372582435608,
0.07128651440143585,
-0.7209249138832092,
-0.5286635160446167,
0.40775322914123535,
-1.2910505533218384,
-0.3554631471633911,
-0.6006765365600586,
-1.0016975402832031,
-0.11037510633468628,
0.31546202301979065,
0.09949486702680588,
0.2712530493736267,
-0.4995685815811157,
-0.06212610751390457,
0.2582378089427948,
-0.3003455698490143,
0.357388973236084,
0.5468430519104004,
-0.5712004899978638,
-0.3785603642463684,
0.7312367558479309,
-0.014311808161437511,
0.274519145488739,
0.5675743222236633,
-0.102829210460186,
-0.3013845384120941,
-0.3640754222869873,
-0.7933254837989807,
0.4365515112876892,
-0.7762545347213745,
0.07480354607105255,
-0.4385490119457245,
-0.38380491733551025,
-0.3435238003730774,
-0.2116607427597046,
-0.45803990960121155,
-0.41427046060562134,
-0.10504414886236191,
0.05444476380944252,
-0.038631051778793335,
0.9075412154197693,
-0.058325283229351044,
0.39889705181121826,
-1.0307393074035645,
0.0854174867272377,
0.22286655008792877,
-0.006069951690733433,
-0.09296611696481705,
-0.6822375059127808,
-0.5498862862586975,
0.14882642030715942,
-0.1819685399532318,
-0.8603944182395935,
0.5702083110809326,
-0.026540551334619522,
0.4443731904029846,
0.28416571021080017,
-0.5439983010292053,
0.6700263023376465,
-0.9107837080955505,
0.5323379039764404,
0.6610686182975769,
-0.9478929042816162,
0.03526448458433151,
-0.3290669023990631,
0.3824101388454437,
0.540019154548645,
0.7652449011802673,
-0.9381845593452454,
-0.2800721526145935,
-0.3448564112186432,
-0.5425354242324829,
0.8078693747520447,
0.18454912304878235,
0.3090859055519104,
0.17292509973049164,
-0.03623510152101517,
0.5202937722206116,
0.26273342967033386,
-0.7767606377601624,
-0.26793429255485535,
0.08166222274303436,
-0.5164496302604675,
-0.13232862949371338,
-0.11667896062135696,
-0.2170623391866684,
-0.40915969014167786,
0.3652472496032715,
0.009430359117686749,
0.3673189878463745,
-0.2894751727581024,
-0.3910752534866333,
-0.30910181999206543,
0.11492622643709183,
0.40262889862060547,
0.6502252221107483,
0.034856729209423065,
0.20304107666015625,
0.10414285212755203,
-0.38570624589920044,
0.23173752427101135,
0.05347350239753723,
-0.2672522962093353,
0.21208596229553223,
0.6491826772689819,
0.8478686809539795,
0.24378688633441925,
-0.651437520980835,
0.4966275691986084,
0.0585075207054615,
-0.028724951669573784,
0.05859706923365593,
-0.194778710603714,
0.44685086607933044,
0.19030126929283142,
0.24176643788814545,
0.24351279437541962,
-0.16181932389736176,
-0.8756679892539978,
0.16802790760993958,
0.4547387361526489,
-0.4295624792575836,
-0.6117725968360901,
0.33162450790405273,
0.017727309837937355,
-0.6019113659858704,
0.7182983160018921,
-0.06012323126196861,
-1.0066938400268555,
0.7119505405426025,
0.9464402198791504,
0.7422389388084412,
-0.3418087959289551,
0.3004210889339447,
0.40679940581321716,
0.19242598116397858,
-0.008777270093560219,
0.18079465627670288,
-0.11078015714883804,
-0.6797943711280823,
-0.08050862699747086,
-0.7428048253059387,
-0.29074305295944214,
-0.3614225387573242,
-0.6913606524467468,
0.2859901785850525,
-0.2777884900569916,
0.07000906020402908,
-0.24706920981407166,
-0.0016446008812636137,
-0.9894092082977295,
0.0564255528151989,
0.25631317496299744,
0.8217784762382507,
-1.062885046005249,
1.045539140701294,
0.5695638060569763,
-0.6946762204170227,
-0.858521044254303,
-0.0933258906006813,
-0.28822168707847595,
-1.3024998903274536,
1.2587740421295166,
0.40613842010498047,
-0.24597279727458954,
-0.13232599198818207,
-0.14316178858280182,
-1.0348234176635742,
1.0565848350524902,
0.3801562786102295,
-0.4755556881427765,
-0.21490950882434845,
0.8190506100654602,
0.6974502801895142,
-0.571151852607727,
0.2615356743335724,
0.3301958441734314,
0.15378625690937042,
0.13175486028194427,
-1.2527544498443604,
-0.2599864900112152,
-0.18835248053073883,
0.068056121468544,
0.057159580290317535,
-0.5320692658424377,
0.8043837547302246,
-0.048431117087602615,
-0.4133271276950836,
0.30590805411338806,
0.7824862599372864,
-0.07146532833576202,
0.42651882767677307,
0.23816776275634766,
0.7768160700798035,
0.7342392802238464,
0.2741909623146057,
0.9487926959991455,
-0.6567630767822266,
0.3047976493835449,
0.9625214338302612,
-0.5417094230651855,
0.8653902411460876,
0.6590094566345215,
-0.0404411144554615,
0.7720708847045898,
0.33555108308792114,
0.30103591084480286,
0.6626636981964111,
0.13946960866451263,
-0.3715084195137024,
-0.26597410440444946,
-0.30708688497543335,
-0.4877866506576538,
0.532293438911438,
-0.04462959244847298,
-0.6538794636726379,
-0.38049811124801636,
-0.06146766617894173,
0.10842818021774292,
0.19181613624095917,
-0.15245108306407928,
0.5984762907028198,
-0.001770148635841906,
-1.0167829990386963,
0.48216819763183594,
0.5083540081977844,
0.20123861730098724,
-0.6361387968063354,
0.12101228535175323,
-0.2742530107498169,
0.13950394093990326,
0.2638041079044342,
-0.26174411177635193,
0.4061667323112488,
0.06763749569654465,
-0.10264414548873901,
-0.48521560430526733,
0.45807746052742004,
-0.7248214483261108,
-0.8519648313522339,
0.49890241026878357,
0.6428210139274597,
0.15977895259857178,
0.37743106484413147,
-0.6285561919212341,
0.08706332743167877,
-0.050847865641117096,
0.2517135739326477,
0.49390143156051636,
0.3734297454357147,
-0.1073748841881752,
0.47268858551979065,
0.5996149182319641,
0.12001855671405792,
0.4584255516529083,
0.3187638521194458,
0.6981320381164551,
-0.6109524369239807,
-0.5166910886764526,
-0.8577566146850586,
0.33825525641441345,
0.029955217614769936,
-0.2868005335330963,
0.8899784088134766,
0.6869166493415833,
0.9955607056617737,
-0.19983935356140137,
0.6898079514503479,
0.35955604910850525,
0.33003172278404236,
-0.3507726192474365,
0.738689661026001,
-0.6109892129898071,
-0.14191776514053345,
0.13601256906986237,
-0.7798489332199097,
-0.4283877909183502,
0.685093879699707,
-0.23811696469783783,
0.15384186804294586,
0.9014793634414673,
0.970443069934845,
-0.27414897084236145,
0.010745188221335411,
0.45440673828125,
-0.21792800724506378,
-0.043154750019311905,
0.7816534042358398,
0.8760144114494324,
-0.5957658886909485,
0.27897822856903076,
0.1140601709485054,
0.06478893756866455,
-0.30736932158470154,
-0.5110217332839966,
-1.2630985975265503,
-0.6373427510261536,
-0.1165207028388977,
-0.2940573990345001,
0.005612569861114025,
0.9978645443916321,
0.6991612315177917,
-0.8349264860153198,
-0.6723297238349915,
-0.1847500503063202,
-0.09581182897090912,
-0.1480095386505127,
-0.02493644692003727,
0.3581086993217468,
-0.4012366831302643,
-0.9223675727844238,
0.289375901222229,
0.43757811188697815,
0.05260443687438965,
-0.3597131669521332,
-0.36048728227615356,
-0.3493294417858124,
0.22313320636749268,
0.06192561984062195,
0.20832587778568268,
-0.6638825535774231,
-0.19313205778598785,
0.12567751109600067,
-0.7429548501968384,
0.17023585736751556,
1.04366135597229,
-0.4356084167957306,
0.5438460111618042,
0.4898103177547455,
0.9217497706413269,
0.6196542978286743,
-0.18050095438957214,
0.7158993482589722,
-0.6980083584785461,
0.29062384366989136,
0.1465010941028595,
0.4323194921016693,
0.40602612495422363,
-0.03145759552717209,
0.086180679500103,
0.15718457102775574,
-0.34364935755729675,
-0.5373974442481995,
0.4144565463066101,
-0.8836456537246704,
0.0520363450050354,
1.0530484914779663,
-0.46285977959632874,
-0.1829092800617218,
-0.11954654008150101,
-0.3416455388069153,
0.5716460347175598,
-0.1657569259405136,
0.8010713458061218,
0.9091499447822571,
0.5001804232597351,
0.32122254371643066,
-0.16394582390785217,
0.2769998610019684,
0.916141152381897,
-0.3404846787452698,
-0.2525871992111206,
0.11260326206684113,
0.273434042930603,
0.21293620765209198,
0.5454579591751099,
0.025431813672184944,
0.4427511394023895,
0.32238730788230896,
0.15616965293884277,
0.18919584155082703,
-0.5637929439544678,
-0.45385250449180603,
0.1714266538619995,
0.15589173138141632,
-0.0289122574031353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16063v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16063v3
|
Citation-Enhanced Generation for LLM-based Chatbots
| 2024-02-25T11:24:41 | 2024-03-04T01:53:35 |
Weitao Li, Junkai Li, Weizhi Ma, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) exhibit powerful general intelligence across
diverse scenarios, including their integration into chatbots. However, a vital
challenge of LLM-based chatbots is that they may produce hallucinated content
in responses, which significantly limits their applicability. Various efforts
have been made to alleviate hallucination, such as retrieval augmented
generation and reinforcement learning with human feedback, but most of them
require additional training and data annotation. In this paper, we propose a
novel post-hoc Citation-Enhanced Generation (CEG) approach combined with
retrieval argumentation. Unlike previous studies that focus on preventing
hallucinations during generation, our method addresses this issue in a post-hoc
way. It incorporates a retrieval module to search for supporting documents
relevant to the generated content, and employs a natural language
inference-based citation generation module. Once the statements in the
generated content lack of reference, our model can regenerate responses until
all statements are supported by citations. Note that our method is a
training-free plug-and-play plugin that is capable of various LLMs. Experiments
on various hallucination-related datasets show our framework outperforms
state-of-the-art methods in both hallucination detection and response
regeneration on three benchmarks. Our codes and dataset will be publicly
available.
|
[
-0.40808629989624023,
-0.944326639175415,
0.5298401713371277,
-0.03517428785562515,
-0.3801966905593872,
-0.04410720616579056,
-0.33102095127105713,
-0.33738958835601807,
0.4180111289024353,
0.6047731041908264,
-0.5271399021148682,
-0.41583335399627686,
-0.26149576902389526,
0.2738836705684662,
-0.15330666303634644,
0.8620737791061401,
0.486431360244751,
0.08147407323122025,
-0.558664083480835,
0.1342468410730362,
-0.5402430891990662,
-0.6712570190429688,
-0.4278012812137604,
-0.3442297577857971,
0.6631866693496704,
0.35939136147499084,
0.6624547839164734,
0.08907725661993027,
0.3738171458244324,
0.24360670149326324,
0.02859034389257431,
0.7602646350860596,
-0.5229978561401367,
0.4521145522594452,
-0.3844223618507385,
0.030909480527043343,
-0.37550100684165955,
-0.3392474055290222,
0.36121082305908203,
0.5190222263336182,
-0.07535997778177261,
-0.1842951476573944,
0.20155538618564606,
0.4804741144180298,
-0.6259135603904724,
-0.08104914426803589,
-1.3648102283477783,
-0.25152066349983215,
0.15487727522850037,
-0.7946176528930664,
-0.7918067574501038,
-0.616789698600769,
0.02717721275985241,
-0.5619572997093201,
0.23247945308685303,
0.03034103289246559,
0.8627822995185852,
0.24817568063735962,
-0.13423335552215576,
-0.5373401045799255,
-0.59080970287323,
0.7861718535423279,
-0.6013187766075134,
0.22868612408638,
0.45821061730384827,
0.17413921654224396,
-0.5136674642562866,
-0.7128692269325256,
-0.536077618598938,
-0.40256279706954956,
-0.09484519064426422,
-0.04234539717435837,
-0.15724240243434906,
-0.1435813009738922,
0.20462627708911896,
0.015066022984683514,
-0.5473735928535461,
-0.19377721846103668,
-0.2054908573627472,
-0.3025917708873749,
0.6248090863227844,
-0.19014787673950195,
0.030647581443190575,
-0.4763963222503662,
-0.3752860426902771,
-0.09176617115736008,
-0.7719898223876953,
-0.7724167704582214,
0.4212402105331421,
0.5260762572288513,
0.402866393327713,
0.4638773500919342,
-0.07857392728328705,
0.20728150010108948,
0.120724156498909,
0.21249142289161682,
0.5265436172485352,
-0.08227601647377014,
-0.118954136967659,
0.16393795609474182,
0.8100027441978455,
0.20615579187870026,
0.2599976062774658,
-0.4391689598560333,
-0.013889282010495663,
-0.10878381133079529,
0.47352156043052673,
-0.8883681297302246,
-0.364305317401886,
0.20227928459644318,
-0.24946391582489014,
-0.453567236661911,
0.10220903903245926,
-0.7701622843742371,
-0.6096779704093933,
-0.22558192908763885,
0.3461022973060608,
-0.5503003001213074,
-0.4104231595993042,
-0.028235800564289093,
0.053949419409036636,
0.4422033727169037,
0.33435019850730896,
-0.7006524801254272,
-0.09107645601034164,
0.500395655632019,
0.7691106200218201,
-0.287083238363266,
0.02230982668697834,
-0.8956551551818848,
0.20990394055843353,
-0.23944446444511414,
1.1297686100006104,
-0.8142014741897583,
-0.6268039345741272,
0.3695351779460907,
0.151932030916214,
0.038747258484363556,
-0.818500280380249,
0.7568649649620056,
-0.690070390701294,
0.18429499864578247,
-0.23070695996284485,
-0.49396759271621704,
0.013466894626617432,
0.2695251405239105,
-0.5095394849777222,
1.1621276140213013,
-0.1353023499250412,
-0.8065715432167053,
0.18039481341838837,
-0.5140272378921509,
-0.40231069922447205,
0.3037607967853546,
-0.38205021619796753,
-0.6225870251655579,
0.14198707044124603,
0.28999096155166626,
0.4033956229686737,
-0.25427672266960144,
0.6651637554168701,
-0.510836124420166,
-0.22976478934288025,
0.24437959492206573,
-0.3264007568359375,
0.4894501566886902,
0.2390943467617035,
-0.16837549209594727,
0.473379522562027,
-0.8881089091300964,
0.14809225499629974,
0.2107696831226349,
-0.16411954164505005,
-0.23863066732883453,
0.21204593777656555,
0.04327080026268959,
0.16178393363952637,
0.16443301737308502,
-0.44699400663375854,
-0.05232761427760124,
-0.24072948098182678,
0.18862511217594147,
0.671013355255127,
0.4016554057598114,
0.24352742731571198,
-0.33551982045173645,
0.31203505396842957,
-0.17219278216362,
-0.16158610582351685,
-0.25878676772117615,
-0.31454262137413025,
-0.6545554995536804,
-0.14782719314098358,
-0.13791108131408691,
0.3655221164226532,
-1.010722279548645,
0.856070339679718,
-0.4086720943450928,
-0.3920406103134155,
-0.28662583231925964,
0.1464526355266571,
0.1864524483680725,
0.5094955563545227,
0.6475324034690857,
0.15587356686592102,
-0.9331748485565186,
-0.7172871828079224,
-0.03307994455099106,
-0.2688995897769928,
-0.39302635192871094,
0.6628376841545105,
0.3802097737789154,
-0.41885772347450256,
0.7388654947280884,
-0.22355292737483978,
-0.03223264589905739,
-0.34475335478782654,
0.13776829838752747,
-0.2136177271604538,
0.5478325486183167,
0.1350092887878418,
-0.5509735345840454,
-0.14631406962871552,
-0.01578403264284134,
-0.958212673664093,
-0.401080846786499,
-0.4723200798034668,
-0.6689518690109253,
0.2911035120487213,
0.6617289781570435,
-0.6265619993209839,
0.27366963028907776,
0.0838947594165802,
-0.11735894531011581,
0.629531979560852,
-0.048534635454416275,
0.04705493897199631,
-1.0620862245559692,
0.2734355330467224,
-0.32603126764297485,
-0.18413828313350677,
-0.42279523611068726,
-0.1024262085556984,
-0.169020876288414,
-0.17837996780872345,
-0.40382421016693115,
0.4919496774673462,
-0.3084231913089752,
0.12091515213251114,
-0.7301869988441467,
0.48457071185112,
-0.07534182071685791,
0.4133787155151367,
0.5460714101791382,
0.43769657611846924,
0.4037168025970459,
-0.5790301561355591,
0.1017080619931221,
0.40475356578826904,
0.037981897592544556,
0.45518791675567627,
-0.7313992977142334,
0.5676965117454529,
-0.04060015082359314,
0.33417215943336487,
-0.895091712474823,
-0.3031837046146393,
0.2268286794424057,
-0.6196226477622986,
0.02736901491880417,
0.062393222004175186,
-0.6355977654457092,
-0.18415263295173645,
-0.3960438668727875,
-0.001772020710632205,
0.40363049507141113,
-0.9047772288322449,
0.5762158036231995,
0.20200012624263763,
-0.07845710963010788,
-0.17516621947288513,
-0.22895218431949615,
0.22234134376049042,
-0.2533396780490875,
-0.6742203831672668,
0.41327965259552,
-0.3178357183933258,
-0.07510924339294434,
-0.38910412788391113,
0.016958631575107574,
0.36846527457237244,
0.0666070505976677,
0.2040334939956665,
0.42325422167778015,
-0.11415381729602814,
0.39048418402671814,
0.17824165523052216,
-0.04741125553846359,
0.05685952305793762,
-0.06355047225952148,
0.9636468291282654,
-0.026467498391866684,
-0.3195287883281708,
-0.417466938495636,
0.39264410734176636,
0.11906633526086807,
-0.017856845632195473,
0.5811129212379456,
0.6888399124145508,
-0.2811160981655121,
-0.2539217472076416,
-0.6961228251457214,
-0.5871847867965698,
-0.5439978241920471,
0.26252639293670654,
-0.1815265268087387,
-0.7334391474723816,
0.2896893322467804,
-0.22337089478969574,
0.22036318480968475,
0.2580094039440155,
0.7640436887741089,
0.04834461212158203,
0.679655134677887,
0.021695183590054512,
0.38342738151550293,
0.49106425046920776,
0.1550607979297638,
0.11519904434680939,
-0.7238238453865051,
-0.3580019474029541,
-0.554761528968811,
-0.05431875213980675,
-0.4657823145389557,
-0.569869339466095,
-0.13047416508197784,
0.16505472362041473,
-0.16565696895122528,
0.22525089979171753,
-0.6987714767456055,
0.37763625383377075,
0.4726654589176178,
0.26209354400634766,
0.2988450527191162,
0.24930566549301147,
0.042027898132801056,
0.015371224842965603,
-0.3942990005016327,
-0.8883292078971863,
1.0502203702926636,
-0.019334234297275543,
0.5597132444381714,
0.0017963038990274072,
0.8599175810813904,
0.4253673553466797,
0.4195312559604645,
-0.648222804069519,
0.8469346761703491,
0.5488819479942322,
-0.41463735699653625,
-0.29869118332862854,
-0.4639008939266205,
-1.0877963304519653,
0.3809409439563751,
-0.3228206932544708,
-0.7397451400756836,
0.03381238132715225,
0.07942356169223785,
-0.11815910786390305,
0.07296115159988403,
-0.44360873103141785,
0.460727721452713,
-0.03430243954062462,
-0.6757068037986755,
-0.18257421255111694,
-0.4538719654083252,
0.28858017921447754,
-0.08666887134313583,
-0.014543320052325726,
-0.07809805870056152,
0.2894926369190216,
0.6305281519889832,
-0.4283580780029297,
0.7584545612335205,
-0.34051644802093506,
-0.11630096286535263,
0.5904157757759094,
0.11290010064840317,
0.7779176235198975,
0.35187286138534546,
-0.23889796435832977,
-0.11280085146427155,
-0.3279535472393036,
-0.3209483325481415,
-0.4791746735572815,
0.854046642780304,
-0.41632065176963806,
-0.8733212351799011,
-0.17511627078056335,
-0.5180214643478394,
-0.3964044153690338,
-0.0467921681702137,
0.06662538647651672,
0.0150484973564744,
-0.30652332305908203,
0.5179249048233032,
0.6295763850212097,
-0.5684679746627808,
0.43556293845176697,
0.25050660967826843,
-0.27123335003852844,
-0.6406611204147339,
0.936673641204834,
-0.3390754759311676,
0.02813066728413105,
0.09426860511302948,
0.24601897597312927,
-0.3900440037250519,
-0.5152431130409241,
-0.1468048393726349,
0.34485548734664917,
-0.48520606756210327,
-0.3544691503047943,
-0.8329415917396545,
-0.31856611371040344,
-0.5186503529548645,
-0.24208354949951172,
-0.16802333295345306,
-0.17203044891357422,
-0.42100393772125244,
-0.24466320872306824,
0.5347359776496887,
0.2635992467403412,
-0.041222330182790756,
0.16638053953647614,
-0.6407134532928467,
0.16024717688560486,
0.1795082837343216,
0.00271251006051898,
0.2329559326171875,
-0.6256973743438721,
-0.06531704217195511,
-0.14430107176303864,
-0.6420978903770447,
-0.7802734375,
0.39726853370666504,
0.227924644947052,
0.6360946893692017,
0.40284693241119385,
0.40178540349006653,
0.7661356329917908,
-0.48517337441444397,
0.8115543127059937,
0.1893087774515152,
-0.6602541208267212,
0.7920504808425903,
-0.3808354437351227,
0.06532085686922073,
0.4317721128463745,
0.22394989430904388,
-0.12637582421302795,
-0.491083562374115,
-0.6896586418151855,
-0.9824941754341125,
0.3139212131500244,
0.43912121653556824,
0.49221229553222656,
-0.6337708234786987,
0.2469358742237091,
0.3305087387561798,
0.06719876080751419,
-0.7670722007751465,
0.07358662784099579,
-0.2977551519870758,
0.0809200182557106,
0.40542757511138916,
-0.24932807683944702,
0.019798027351498604,
-0.11602075397968292,
0.825517475605011,
-0.1567436009645462,
0.25707384943962097,
0.25630319118499756,
-0.31482037901878357,
0.1215924471616745,
0.2039164900779724,
0.4847757816314697,
0.42341697216033936,
-0.17531760036945343,
0.10557297617197037,
0.09327515214681625,
-0.21213051676750183,
-0.24915392696857452,
0.11915182322263718,
-0.06073182076215744,
0.3142866790294647,
0.14759986102581024,
0.554894208908081,
0.15845806896686554,
-0.9253023862838745,
0.32499435544013977,
0.0972597748041153,
-0.33497509360313416,
-0.5115697383880615,
0.11748189479112625,
0.11936388164758682,
0.35588860511779785,
0.5649522542953491,
-0.2207920104265213,
0.03520576283335686,
-0.34302717447280884,
0.5677136778831482,
0.5830814242362976,
-0.24533475935459137,
-0.29685813188552856,
0.7465203404426575,
0.4196695387363434,
-0.5043449401855469,
0.46023061871528625,
-0.35008522868156433,
-0.13001343607902527,
0.13931071758270264,
0.6894441843032837,
1.0652143955230713,
-0.09629430621862411,
0.3754141926765442,
0.7599053382873535,
-0.12842805683612823,
0.20188163220882416,
0.36493924260139465,
-0.4239339530467987,
-0.664814829826355,
-0.10464687645435333,
-0.5664974451065063,
-0.2781485617160797,
0.37528806924819946,
-0.5892793536186218,
0.3874076008796692,
-0.3035089373588562,
-0.27501776814460754,
-0.27155449986457825,
-0.08297558128833771,
-0.501686155796051,
-0.15162411332130432,
0.3361615240573883,
0.467428058385849,
-0.4682844579219818,
0.906946063041687,
0.311028391122818,
-0.4575141668319702,
-0.2295876294374466,
0.10083230584859848,
-0.2893066108226776,
-0.5803391337394714,
0.47076529264450073,
0.17499083280563354,
-0.2838435471057892,
-0.08711275458335876,
-0.65779048204422,
-0.620911717414856,
1.041033148765564,
0.44290077686309814,
-0.5230271220207214,
-0.0705440565943718,
-0.043382689356803894,
0.48483389616012573,
-0.5042579770088196,
0.28099867701530457,
0.3658302128314972,
0.22715282440185547,
0.5700505971908569,
-0.5573381781578064,
0.3145359754562378,
-0.41987547278404236,
0.07404608279466629,
-0.27661749720573425,
-0.3556646704673767,
0.25486376881599426,
-0.3140753209590912,
-0.29659101366996765,
0.3035964369773865,
0.9359009861946106,
0.9132959842681885,
0.2900511920452118,
0.4348068833351135,
0.0630229264497757,
1.101223111152649,
0.15099003911018372,
0.6629793047904968,
-0.30046719312667847,
0.09211181849241257,
1.5065560340881348,
-0.49941080808639526,
1.060255765914917,
0.6591863036155701,
0.22331602871418,
0.6829293370246887,
0.5207860469818115,
-0.21866098046302795,
0.5102038979530334,
0.4276617169380188,
-0.3266657888889313,
-0.5108252167701721,
-0.36252743005752563,
-0.5012500286102295,
0.18669529259204865,
0.33701959252357483,
-0.7058408856391907,
-0.09165071696043015,
0.012446070089936256,
0.18712212145328522,
0.30297645926475525,
0.012616957537829876,
0.9121004939079285,
-0.06620465219020844,
-0.6571170091629028,
0.8520932793617249,
-0.5134114623069763,
0.6194382309913635,
-0.3602864742279053,
-0.18851745128631592,
-0.249053955078125,
-0.03719416260719299,
-0.16802389919757843,
-0.3176332414150238,
0.3677130341529846,
0.14045582711696625,
0.043593116104602814,
-0.0669199749827385,
0.8289231061935425,
-0.32034963369369507,
-0.3948477804660797,
0.4059569537639618,
0.6270546317100525,
0.4494752883911133,
-0.1706458330154419,
-0.3621833622455597,
0.14269070327281952,
0.09776019304990768,
-0.4380641281604767,
0.22588372230529785,
0.4619707763195038,
0.037837907671928406,
0.4673469364643097,
0.7693818211555481,
-0.11143793165683746,
-0.0005607469938695431,
0.4985238015651703,
0.9700825810432434,
-0.5771470069885254,
-0.19388532638549805,
-0.8617909550666809,
0.4499390721321106,
-0.5691432952880859,
-0.13847573101520538,
0.6756106019020081,
0.7084797024726868,
0.5683572292327881,
-0.07327469438314438,
0.9395197629928589,
0.03817349672317505,
0.4722512364387512,
-0.423723429441452,
0.637069821357727,
-0.40240544080734253,
0.5504205822944641,
-0.4300507605075836,
-0.8834585547447205,
-0.3357667028903961,
0.7229393124580383,
-0.3065522015094757,
0.07357028126716614,
0.5992665886878967,
1.1009881496429443,
0.25165241956710815,
0.09146195650100708,
0.5045209527015686,
0.013212043792009354,
0.5443742275238037,
0.3976462185382843,
0.9127923250198364,
-0.22925421595573425,
1.0439434051513672,
0.20135778188705444,
0.10439115017652512,
-0.4156915247440338,
-0.7838457226753235,
-1.150444746017456,
-0.481889545917511,
-0.5125352144241333,
-0.6949591636657715,
0.06962219625711441,
1.0895318984985352,
0.5270020365715027,
-0.7236865162849426,
0.15210863947868347,
-0.2069525271654129,
-0.05763913691043854,
0.1590876430273056,
-0.25303468108177185,
0.5057023763656616,
-0.7904877066612244,
-0.7080309987068176,
0.5169564485549927,
0.04648347944021225,
-0.16549430787563324,
-0.23845838010311127,
-0.3124643564224243,
-0.23373112082481384,
0.39519280195236206,
0.7767097353935242,
0.17345841228961945,
-0.8193262815475464,
-0.5016276240348816,
0.12428505718708038,
-0.04326609522104263,
0.19889339804649353,
0.7011179327964783,
-1.040310263633728,
0.38957732915878296,
0.34024572372436523,
0.6829251050949097,
0.4094034731388092,
0.12127858400344849,
0.43519678711891174,
-0.765181303024292,
0.11083108186721802,
0.3916211426258087,
0.3573570251464844,
0.550626277923584,
-0.25342726707458496,
0.4664965569972992,
0.2446214109659195,
-0.6352328062057495,
-1.0411396026611328,
0.13468493521213531,
-0.9641225934028625,
-0.23072320222854614,
1.5092136859893799,
0.06396433711051941,
-0.014452305622398853,
-0.13890986144542694,
-0.4027757942676544,
0.3124125301837921,
-0.6169040203094482,
1.1956499814987183,
0.5488477945327759,
-0.08900858461856842,
-0.13909819722175598,
-0.3201809525489807,
0.42172011733055115,
0.2645970582962036,
-1.0703238248825073,
0.5120401382446289,
0.6909740567207336,
-0.15102368593215942,
0.25228026509284973,
0.39058542251586914,
-0.26368290185928345,
0.25677070021629333,
0.08796899020671844,
0.25954365730285645,
0.025360679253935814,
-0.28310081362724304,
0.0574071891605854,
0.2695348560810089,
-0.04094063863158226,
-0.2387978881597519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12077v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12077v1
|
Evaluating Robustness of Generative Search Engine on Adversarial Factual Questions
| 2024-02-25T11:22:19 | 2024-02-25T11:22:19 |
Xuming Hu, Xiaochuan Li, Junzhe Chen, Yinghui Li, Yangning Li, Xiaoguang Li, Yasheng Wang, Qun Liu, Lijie Wen, Philip S. Yu, Zhijiang Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Generative search engines have the potential to transform how people seek
information online, but generated responses from existing large language models
(LLMs)-backed generative search engines may not always be accurate.
Nonetheless, retrieval-augmented generation exacerbates safety concerns, since
adversaries may successfully evade the entire system by subtly manipulating the
most vulnerable part of a claim. To this end, we propose evaluating the
robustness of generative search engines in the realistic and high-risk setting,
where adversaries have only black-box system access and seek to deceive the
model into returning incorrect responses. Through a comprehensive human
evaluation of various generative search engines, such as Bing Chat,
PerplexityAI, and YouChat across diverse queries, we demonstrate the
effectiveness of adversarial factual questions in inducing incorrect responses.
Moreover, retrieval-augmented generation exhibits a higher susceptibility to
factual errors compared to LLMs without retrieval. These findings highlight the
potential security risks of these systems and emphasize the need for rigorous
evaluation before deployment.
|
[
-0.3898375928401947,
-1.0495065450668335,
0.5609636306762695,
0.009670371189713478,
0.05948764830827713,
0.27687445282936096,
-0.11468329280614853,
-0.44109460711479187,
-0.13147884607315063,
0.2841605246067047,
-0.3617965579032898,
-0.3484403192996979,
-0.5181721448898315,
0.0877251848578453,
-0.6783571243286133,
0.761030375957489,
0.33775755763053894,
-0.39490821957588196,
-0.2754603624343872,
-0.03177189454436302,
-0.29943951964378357,
-0.6788454651832581,
-0.5879272818565369,
0.16520628333091736,
0.38956403732299805,
-0.15084399282932281,
1.2121634483337402,
0.08126109093427658,
0.5617555379867554,
0.36427071690559387,
-0.20138822495937347,
0.24771550297737122,
-0.6964796781539917,
0.40218842029571533,
-0.3088963031768799,
-0.7280339598655701,
-0.10005441308021545,
-0.16552230715751648,
0.26686418056488037,
0.47177571058273315,
-0.3022578954696655,
0.003950441721826792,
0.1404574066400528,
0.36688855290412903,
-1.0320883989334106,
-0.15781278908252716,
-1.094036340713501,
0.05112553387880325,
-0.11743035912513733,
-0.2883951663970947,
-0.4977569580078125,
-0.5524296164512634,
0.18745848536491394,
-0.6366748809814453,
0.5187864303588867,
0.06763553619384766,
1.0427392721176147,
0.3416491448879242,
-0.44717368483543396,
-0.36719241738319397,
-0.9447495937347412,
0.3758895993232727,
-0.44751760363578796,
0.14280575513839722,
0.48168137669563293,
0.47208544611930847,
-0.48140740394592285,
-0.7241057753562927,
-0.5105634927749634,
-0.40407127141952515,
0.018307331949472427,
0.1219053566455841,
-0.5022567510604858,
0.09310819953680038,
0.4008265733718872,
0.37806448340415955,
-0.9015175104141235,
0.036347128450870514,
-0.20142929255962372,
-0.4379349648952484,
0.6015841960906982,
0.021321430802345276,
0.5527774691581726,
-0.1798924058675766,
-0.3984210789203644,
-0.4191645383834839,
-0.7778246402740479,
-0.25562453269958496,
0.6119194626808167,
0.18769533932209015,
0.1541229635477066,
0.7179112434387207,
0.03065214678645134,
0.5696628093719482,
0.1598634570837021,
0.15745247900485992,
-0.10465290397405624,
-0.5186215043067932,
-0.1659151315689087,
0.032310035079717636,
0.790912389755249,
0.2861965596675873,
0.04318785294890404,
-0.46481791138648987,
-0.3437882661819458,
0.32463040947914124,
0.9496782422065735,
-0.6678720712661743,
0.049627553671598434,
0.21964366734027863,
-0.2336573600769043,
-0.6573781967163086,
0.15655307471752167,
-0.8939278721809387,
-0.6247914433479309,
0.44038495421409607,
0.6518374681472778,
-0.3417607545852661,
0.009670218452811241,
0.023076215758919716,
-0.13341599702835083,
0.18834646046161652,
0.2846391499042511,
-0.6575096249580383,
0.012162396684288979,
0.5860092043876648,
0.7604742050170898,
0.07535969465970993,
-0.10337799787521362,
-0.6741829514503479,
-0.10472162812948227,
-0.41356733441352844,
0.6423786878585815,
-0.12300308048725128,
-0.8106366395950317,
0.3176365792751312,
-0.16791458427906036,
-0.11374742537736893,
-0.5508764386177063,
0.8815085291862488,
-1.1513601541519165,
0.07034806162118912,
-0.3123321831226349,
-0.26885104179382324,
0.0362241268157959,
0.6480457186698914,
-0.7404744029045105,
0.6857628226280212,
-0.15482540428638458,
-0.9593266844749451,
0.272920697927475,
-0.39992743730545044,
-0.5899059176445007,
0.13434463739395142,
-0.24553529918193817,
-0.5602652430534363,
0.067582868039608,
0.33060747385025024,
0.1590108573436737,
-0.3224606215953827,
0.24888747930526733,
-0.6481698155403137,
-0.39066988229751587,
0.6280540227890015,
-0.9945194125175476,
1.0583782196044922,
0.35703521966934204,
-0.5073966979980469,
-0.06526736915111542,
-0.5921422839164734,
0.01680365577340126,
0.3662017285823822,
-0.3963916301727295,
-0.4150453507900238,
0.01792282611131668,
-0.12625856697559357,
0.010145386680960655,
0.27648621797561646,
-0.43921536207199097,
-0.08053724467754364,
-0.5567442774772644,
0.10812319070100784,
0.8628690838813782,
0.10755561292171478,
0.052509605884552,
-0.2662748396396637,
0.7503945827484131,
-0.20586131513118744,
0.1737256497144699,
0.11848147958517075,
-0.4645550549030304,
-0.501589834690094,
0.014318253844976425,
0.39919906854629517,
0.6728914976119995,
-1.0533888339996338,
0.5597798824310303,
-0.2781886160373688,
-0.40448784828186035,
-0.3932975232601166,
0.009279279969632626,
0.35335588455200195,
0.4459429979324341,
0.062325313687324524,
-0.010986769571900368,
-0.35933420062065125,
-0.6896073222160339,
-0.2240072786808014,
-0.5472582578659058,
-0.16762977838516235,
0.471987247467041,
0.5181828141212463,
-0.3765416741371155,
0.6380998492240906,
-0.5671137571334839,
0.3932909667491913,
0.13880549371242523,
0.19694693386554718,
-0.3420150578022003,
0.08850250393152237,
0.5864217281341553,
-1.178126573562622,
-0.17788100242614746,
-0.08955730497837067,
-1.0629603862762451,
0.22478681802749634,
-0.15378856658935547,
-0.17514900863170624,
0.10299041867256165,
0.10119662433862686,
-0.9434294104576111,
0.534798800945282,
0.5041139721870422,
-0.26188603043556213,
0.700222373008728,
-0.27404284477233887,
0.2685403823852539,
-0.9270809292793274,
0.3361522853374481,
-0.11925719678401947,
-0.18203964829444885,
-0.48822715878486633,
0.497313916683197,
-0.02024451270699501,
-0.3829360008239746,
-0.2849411368370056,
0.10968206822872162,
-0.14738242328166962,
-0.1578913927078247,
-0.19774897396564484,
0.20072729885578156,
0.11248193681240082,
-0.06252145767211914,
-0.5192204713821411,
1.283752202987671,
0.44151514768600464,
-0.5777487754821777,
0.5264409780502319,
0.30979007482528687,
-0.5996657609939575,
0.48713672161102295,
-0.6988117694854736,
0.25231045484542847,
-0.11201434582471848,
0.14802195131778717,
-0.875968337059021,
-0.3852022588253021,
0.10134116560220718,
-0.6682549118995667,
0.3319332003593445,
0.011506672948598862,
-0.6242160797119141,
-0.24433429539203644,
-0.4830873906612396,
0.19538891315460205,
0.3413662910461426,
-0.6705527305603027,
0.34871670603752136,
0.2666887938976288,
-0.19126203656196594,
-0.8388696312904358,
-0.5167800784111023,
0.5637836456298828,
-0.2573680579662323,
-0.8703300356864929,
0.30740538239479065,
-0.03327123448252678,
-0.29717957973480225,
0.16941608488559723,
-0.14322035014629364,
0.10427024215459824,
0.6566458344459534,
0.10619036853313446,
0.38217735290527344,
-0.1182149350643158,
-0.12450066953897476,
-0.22863003611564636,
0.09857532382011414,
0.20049673318862915,
-0.047044653445482254,
0.40285447239875793,
-0.2261616587638855,
-0.6929095983505249,
-0.1114085391163826,
0.19527359306812286,
0.7052819728851318,
-0.2686457633972168,
0.8485690951347351,
0.5630273222923279,
-0.5418353080749512,
0.04071101173758507,
-0.5717220306396484,
-0.13459758460521698,
-0.5101919770240784,
0.354706734418869,
-0.17402903735637665,
-0.6968057155609131,
0.5764161944389343,
0.15380139648914337,
-0.21009062230587006,
0.4804289937019348,
0.5041027665138245,
-0.037902478128671646,
1.3589792251586914,
0.2671225070953369,
0.02259724587202072,
0.09044323861598969,
-0.07821047306060791,
0.18689613044261932,
-0.5188078284263611,
-0.28744134306907654,
-0.6694798469543457,
0.09202659130096436,
-1.005518913269043,
-0.12837597727775574,
0.6249260902404785,
-0.09599749743938446,
-0.13841602206230164,
0.30523577332496643,
-0.24455182254314423,
0.11382164806127548,
0.6112155318260193,
0.3232676684856415,
0.11585870385169983,
0.2554243803024292,
-0.16400663554668427,
0.0496365912258625,
-0.5976360440254211,
-0.5931390523910522,
1.2272366285324097,
0.170552596449852,
0.9921379089355469,
0.4394393265247345,
0.3678186535835266,
0.5099295973777771,
0.1865321546792984,
-0.5967433452606201,
0.43017566204071045,
-0.06922194361686707,
-1.0064284801483154,
-0.25125598907470703,
-0.6432393193244934,
-0.9788170456886292,
0.3107617199420929,
-0.41031843423843384,
-0.49991726875305176,
0.2095516175031662,
0.06103794276714325,
-0.5342400074005127,
0.32514679431915283,
-0.5796962380409241,
0.609726071357727,
-0.5296257138252258,
-0.3418270945549011,
-0.08874653279781342,
-0.6999213099479675,
0.38527852296829224,
-0.1795186549425125,
-0.06782025098800659,
0.37695062160491943,
0.20529769361019135,
0.31263622641563416,
-0.3006426692008972,
0.7699852585792542,
0.047702357172966,
-0.11716149002313614,
0.36989930272102356,
0.27191776037216187,
0.6904208064079285,
0.17723891139030457,
-0.12277336418628693,
-0.15130864083766937,
-0.24697186052799225,
-0.4803421199321747,
-0.8521936535835266,
0.8465261459350586,
-0.6836130023002625,
-0.9945390224456787,
-0.6029613614082336,
-0.2614920139312744,
-0.3507996201515198,
0.24642179906368256,
0.528641939163208,
0.166331946849823,
-0.48338890075683594,
0.36683255434036255,
0.8898898363113403,
-0.41867467761039734,
-0.05892298370599747,
0.22454015910625458,
0.18858109414577484,
-0.4124802052974701,
0.9204301238059998,
-0.11192569881677628,
0.2902280390262604,
0.23334945738315582,
0.08385488390922546,
-0.5643744468688965,
-0.5862190127372742,
-0.6788386702537537,
-0.12865307927131653,
-0.6832053661346436,
-0.2485480010509491,
-0.4095003008842468,
-0.2589658498764038,
-0.3241378962993622,
-0.0020622669253498316,
-0.20112083852291107,
-0.1181950494647026,
-0.28201019763946533,
-0.23114541172981262,
-0.14526396989822388,
0.4586844742298126,
0.22613441944122314,
-0.1643596738576889,
-0.6733493804931641,
0.3247964382171631,
0.7157345414161682,
0.07269670814275742,
-0.23038548231124878,
-0.3870982229709625,
0.032968293875455856,
0.23708300292491913,
-0.601315438747406,
-0.9108904600143433,
0.08977838605642319,
-0.006014685612171888,
0.547737717628479,
0.49521389603614807,
0.33886030316352844,
0.5171554684638977,
-0.30378609895706177,
0.7879488468170166,
-0.05059574544429779,
-0.5063469409942627,
0.6041383147239685,
-0.2924761474132538,
-0.027393288910388947,
0.5848223567008972,
0.4238092601299286,
-0.12517355382442474,
-0.14249777793884277,
-0.7329661846160889,
-0.6762445569038391,
0.3214571475982666,
0.6466696858406067,
0.2088078260421753,
0.052702680230140686,
0.4157138764858246,
-0.2195657342672348,
0.2218972146511078,
-0.41942885518074036,
-0.3405238091945648,
-0.45894408226013184,
-0.015305803157389164,
0.0944756418466568,
-0.34963342547416687,
-0.4120776951313019,
0.3706720769405365,
0.5784833431243896,
-0.030127028003335,
0.2588743567466736,
0.11782730370759964,
-0.10450179129838943,
-0.07058803737163544,
0.4621037542819977,
0.5670149326324463,
0.4431033432483673,
-0.3037283420562744,
0.44301629066467285,
0.19747424125671387,
-0.40164878964424133,
0.3149105906486511,
0.4347272217273712,
-0.5419687032699585,
-0.27406027913093567,
0.40925610065460205,
0.7215063571929932,
0.0041116694919764996,
-0.8855364322662354,
0.6780056953430176,
-0.34976884722709656,
0.09725916385650635,
-0.1724848449230194,
0.11232325434684753,
-0.11229201406240463,
-0.05792943015694618,
0.36078786849975586,
0.3686530888080597,
0.36105313897132874,
-0.6663010120391846,
0.07750538736581802,
0.8026419281959534,
-0.20805200934410095,
-0.35003989934921265,
0.8482353091239929,
0.10920736938714981,
-0.18625883758068085,
0.5764482617378235,
-0.24837630987167358,
-0.7615639567375183,
0.5257574915885925,
0.6577027440071106,
1.1153355836868286,
-0.16737566888332367,
0.22376741468906403,
0.10393508523702621,
0.6852100491523743,
-0.05912312492728233,
-0.0725092962384224,
0.0035674285609275103,
-0.6703916192054749,
-0.19135703146457672,
-0.47963792085647583,
-0.3890474736690521,
0.3599938452243805,
-0.6906909942626953,
-0.0593332014977932,
-0.39095333218574524,
-0.42808663845062256,
-0.10689787566661835,
-0.15141776204109192,
-0.4961698055267334,
0.2939388155937195,
0.08412716537714005,
0.7160504460334778,
-0.5432882308959961,
0.04462863504886627,
0.9993091821670532,
-0.3852154314517975,
-0.15603631734848022,
0.4600127339363098,
-0.01454133540391922,
-0.7922905087471008,
0.43139541149139404,
-0.07695998251438141,
-0.4829939007759094,
-0.38597503304481506,
-0.6138491034507751,
-0.6293228268623352,
1.0115149021148682,
0.7132155299186707,
-0.25992918014526367,
-0.14652447402477264,
0.12216019630432129,
0.5933519601821899,
0.2642444670200348,
0.07976233959197998,
0.2477530837059021,
0.21005260944366455,
0.13956740498542786,
-0.7021626234054565,
0.23289959132671356,
-0.17524753510951996,
0.2976730167865753,
-0.18225130438804626,
-0.4935118854045868,
0.35327431559562683,
-0.23590782284736633,
-0.6811349987983704,
0.13249444961547852,
0.49643874168395996,
0.17460264265537262,
0.27432364225387573,
0.5530133247375488,
0.7122683525085449,
0.7863290309906006,
-0.07346844673156738,
1.3186900615692139,
-0.23490652441978455,
0.38206109404563904,
0.6046629548072815,
-0.2883281111717224,
0.7478802800178528,
0.14757531881332397,
-0.2500855326652527,
0.1407645344734192,
0.37617915868759155,
0.11015360802412033,
0.4712442457675934,
0.02572464570403099,
-0.6584697961807251,
-0.39028674364089966,
0.011583056300878525,
-0.35116031765937805,
0.3912833631038666,
0.45233607292175293,
-0.13154931366443634,
-0.2879240810871124,
-0.08401802182197571,
0.01645018719136715,
0.2957710325717926,
0.184292733669281,
0.6700499653816223,
-0.1408296376466751,
-0.6624597907066345,
0.8258540630340576,
0.09582225233316422,
0.4873727262020111,
-0.4091253876686096,
0.19244226813316345,
-0.12874257564544678,
0.08139539510011673,
-0.1798371523618698,
-0.7093445062637329,
0.243190735578537,
0.2893404960632324,
0.07142324000597,
0.2853754758834839,
0.9039273858070374,
0.03549418970942497,
-0.5250601768493652,
0.12325923144817352,
0.17441120743751526,
-0.27780845761299133,
-0.23951509594917297,
-0.7775793075561523,
0.13128480315208435,
-0.076213039457798,
-0.20560520887374878,
0.39974746108055115,
0.09741243720054626,
0.16730594635009766,
0.9528052806854248,
0.7730605006217957,
0.11287246644496918,
0.1241990402340889,
-0.14209970831871033,
0.9179722666740417,
-0.36700117588043213,
-0.3237673044204712,
-0.7267681360244751,
0.21001987159252167,
-0.16535916924476624,
0.008831356652081013,
1.0031616687774658,
0.44552555680274963,
0.7898702621459961,
0.13701589405536652,
1.177709698677063,
-0.11335207521915436,
0.1182052493095398,
-0.45184066891670227,
0.8663211464881897,
-0.5192063450813293,
0.4547848105430603,
-0.06496673822402954,
-0.7660131454467773,
-0.2857971489429474,
0.39406636357307434,
-0.20160746574401855,
0.06811472773551941,
0.25440630316734314,
0.9762129187583923,
-0.11721611768007278,
0.01838473603129387,
0.5174327492713928,
0.3017560839653015,
0.5722159743309021,
0.20960195362567902,
0.9994266033172607,
-0.602528989315033,
0.9899600744247437,
-0.14262817800045013,
-0.203851118683815,
-0.4406086802482605,
-0.6152240037918091,
-0.6804082989692688,
-0.2890748381614685,
-0.16432423889636993,
-0.8077709674835205,
0.4936942160129547,
0.5570321679115295,
0.3622063398361206,
-0.7579621076583862,
0.20241349935531616,
-0.07980801165103912,
0.18399368226528168,
0.10376068204641342,
-0.2337471842765808,
0.3984936475753784,
-0.2900625467300415,
-0.592986524105072,
0.6377831101417542,
0.16904203593730927,
0.19065096974372864,
-0.5676902532577515,
0.11519118398427963,
-0.02788609452545643,
0.05317007005214691,
0.5209798812866211,
0.42606914043426514,
-0.6245813369750977,
-0.45513883233070374,
0.17243298888206482,
-0.36495399475097656,
-0.22670763731002808,
0.49254336953163147,
-0.49448588490486145,
0.9018409848213196,
0.5289694666862488,
1.0715043544769287,
0.3002547323703766,
0.42324116826057434,
0.5750992298126221,
-0.6364301443099976,
-0.09485062956809998,
0.2775800824165344,
0.22740092873573303,
0.6159284710884094,
-0.6297962665557861,
0.1392778754234314,
0.30348294973373413,
-0.5416677594184875,
-1.0088249444961548,
0.3161686360836029,
-0.5480517745018005,
-0.08000282198190689,
1.0315316915512085,
-0.27408772706985474,
0.021327923983335495,
-0.1007983535528183,
-0.0566805861890316,
0.08767026662826538,
-0.15900661051273346,
1.2436790466308594,
0.6994141936302185,
0.15958775579929352,
0.32978707551956177,
-0.5617983341217041,
0.28932228684425354,
0.39123815298080444,
-0.6341709494590759,
-0.12157595157623291,
0.3552955389022827,
0.22905126214027405,
0.43380266427993774,
0.09574569761753082,
-0.200369194149971,
0.4173138737678528,
0.23473459482192993,
-0.3674808442592621,
0.15393896400928497,
-0.16363604366779327,
-0.3793030083179474,
0.41162458062171936,
0.33573076128959656,
-0.26667189598083496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16061v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16061v2
|
How Large Language Models Encode Context Knowledge? A Layer-Wise Probing Study
| 2024-02-25T11:15:42 | 2024-03-04T13:37:48 |
Tianjie Ju, Weiwei Sun, Wei Du, Xinwei Yuan, Zhaochun Ren, Gongshen Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous work has showcased the intriguing capability of large language
models (LLMs) in retrieving facts and processing context knowledge. However,
only limited research exists on the layer-wise capability of LLMs to encode
knowledge, which challenges our understanding of their internal mechanisms. In
this paper, we devote the first attempt to investigate the layer-wise
capability of LLMs through probing tasks. We leverage the powerful generative
capability of ChatGPT to construct probing datasets, providing diverse and
coherent evidence corresponding to various facts. We employ $\mathcal V$-usable
information as the validation metric to better reflect the capability in
encoding context knowledge across different layers. Our experiments on
conflicting and newly acquired knowledge show that LLMs: (1) prefer to encode
more context knowledge in the upper layers; (2) primarily encode context
knowledge within knowledge-related entity tokens at lower layers while
progressively expanding more knowledge within other tokens at upper layers; and
(3) gradually forget the earlier context knowledge retained within the
intermediate layers when provided with irrelevant evidence. Code is publicly
available at https://github.com/Jometeorie/probing_llama.
|
[
-0.3328917324542999,
-0.9442372918128967,
0.7266639471054077,
-0.0017985622398555279,
-0.21692723035812378,
-0.10023856163024902,
-0.3628457188606262,
-0.42410460114479065,
-0.05125514045357704,
0.6520430445671082,
-0.31730034947395325,
-0.4188717305660248,
-0.6065049171447754,
-0.12715885043144226,
-0.6528375744819641,
0.8092886209487915,
0.07923461496829987,
-0.026379216462373734,
-0.43186089396476746,
-0.028132125735282898,
-0.2923993766307831,
-0.8088725805282593,
-0.5581806898117065,
-0.43953707814216614,
0.5970320105552673,
0.3853527903556824,
0.33043548464775085,
0.4805285930633545,
0.30288806557655334,
0.2939889132976532,
-0.35949385166168213,
0.3344813585281372,
-0.6880625486373901,
0.24304445087909698,
0.023740246891975403,
-0.6485301852226257,
-0.2995569407939911,
-0.14887848496437073,
0.7682152390480042,
0.7095740437507629,
-0.14071598649024963,
0.2541350722312927,
0.2153540551662445,
0.4208464026451111,
-0.5739299058914185,
0.21041887998580933,
-0.9650962352752686,
-0.047888126224279404,
-0.31504571437835693,
-0.47727110981941223,
-0.6282254457473755,
0.2072647660970688,
0.2639256417751312,
-0.35372593998908997,
0.007744131609797478,
0.039329010993242264,
0.6901528835296631,
0.1354275643825531,
-0.8406842947006226,
-0.18788905441761017,
-0.7247658967971802,
0.6877763867378235,
-0.5396633744239807,
0.4699358642101288,
0.4360099732875824,
0.3561911880970001,
-0.1977023184299469,
-0.795155942440033,
-0.5617782473564148,
-0.29888010025024414,
-0.1971612572669983,
-0.06546216458082199,
-0.09782470762729645,
-0.13556309044361115,
0.345003604888916,
0.4335704743862152,
-0.1963590383529663,
0.05221238359808922,
-0.2190454602241516,
-0.3728184700012207,
0.28033775091171265,
0.03794271871447563,
0.28974559903144836,
-0.2820715606212616,
-0.5733518004417419,
-0.0390307642519474,
-0.9081947207450867,
0.17251168191432953,
0.09714702516794205,
0.13834288716316223,
-0.21687039732933044,
0.7096132636070251,
-0.16207437217235565,
0.4713643789291382,
-0.233123779296875,
-0.014930101111531258,
0.1345372349023819,
-0.2548205554485321,
-0.3481631577014923,
0.06378436088562012,
0.6454400420188904,
0.07047209143638611,
0.08500625193119049,
-0.25496646761894226,
-0.2880333662033081,
-0.3062300384044647,
0.22405819594860077,
-0.6971606016159058,
0.07848133146762848,
0.18497297167778015,
-0.20502100884914398,
-0.055519819259643555,
-0.16504961252212524,
-0.33541950583457947,
-0.39377039670944214,
-0.2741747796535492,
0.4394991397857666,
-0.5905705094337463,
-0.2915888726711273,
0.38424956798553467,
-0.03279249370098114,
0.6934731602668762,
0.42227792739868164,
-0.6997430324554443,
0.12946869432926178,
0.9138967990875244,
0.6705330014228821,
0.03642507269978523,
-0.3468265235424042,
-0.46606332063674927,
0.2688535153865814,
-0.23940807580947876,
0.633280873298645,
-0.5717055797576904,
-0.12310230731964111,
0.09066356718540192,
-0.06801626086235046,
-0.0788518562912941,
-0.47878506779670715,
0.5980772972106934,
-0.946603000164032,
0.09502056241035461,
-0.666523277759552,
-0.6672782897949219,
-0.31143030524253845,
0.5734121799468994,
-0.5648238658905029,
0.9049825072288513,
-0.065995953977108,
-0.9535120725631714,
0.3042439818382263,
-0.3701835870742798,
-0.27598944306373596,
0.08654838055372238,
-0.3835383355617523,
-0.09352842718362808,
0.1997041255235672,
0.36372053623199463,
0.6269570589065552,
-0.3705019950866699,
0.2160039097070694,
-0.23992811143398285,
-0.3131016492843628,
0.6144197583198547,
-0.48697972297668457,
0.7309858202934265,
0.06931334733963013,
-0.1566607654094696,
-0.11410444974899292,
-0.5373756885528564,
-0.13369090855121613,
0.33130285143852234,
-0.6131611466407776,
-0.3306017518043518,
0.05282808840274811,
-0.36139121651649475,
-0.10439125448465347,
0.23081129789352417,
-0.5869188904762268,
0.30167216062545776,
-0.049187034368515015,
0.6619360446929932,
0.5871446132659912,
0.08399420231580734,
0.36469346284866333,
-0.1332017332315445,
0.2713575065135956,
0.41773369908332825,
-0.13644342124462128,
-0.17233186960220337,
-0.3593467175960541,
-0.9069565534591675,
-0.00035740749444812536,
0.2359020859003067,
0.37910017371177673,
-0.831534743309021,
0.05046077072620392,
-0.4323330819606781,
-0.21242299675941467,
-0.2438955008983612,
0.03448391705751419,
0.2814195454120636,
0.6076098680496216,
0.24205398559570312,
-0.32294243574142456,
-0.5459656715393066,
-0.881732165813446,
-0.07980342954397202,
-0.22851675748825073,
-0.13432127237319946,
0.6412805914878845,
0.589138388633728,
-0.42382144927978516,
0.8571667671203613,
-0.31893256306648254,
-0.1083245724439621,
-0.2276780903339386,
-0.10050681233406067,
0.08531921356916428,
0.2782488167285919,
0.5127469897270203,
-0.7068631052970886,
-0.05654784291982651,
0.17939403653144836,
-0.8106287121772766,
-0.01290265191346407,
-0.0023019444197416306,
-0.29595181345939636,
-0.1561041623353958,
0.6318874955177307,
-0.7254597544670105,
-0.008701478131115437,
0.6826912760734558,
-0.1286102682352066,
0.4395330250263214,
-0.10661987960338593,
0.09073081612586975,
-0.8823702335357666,
-0.014153223484754562,
-0.14915692806243896,
-0.32446223497390747,
-0.7952855229377747,
0.21743156015872955,
0.37342485785484314,
0.26370275020599365,
-0.3210788369178772,
0.4569612741470337,
-0.6584483981132507,
-0.2005922794342041,
-0.16759391129016876,
0.24758051335811615,
-0.01307886652648449,
0.500072717666626,
-0.03290672227740288,
0.7340485453605652,
0.7589094638824463,
-0.6550099849700928,
0.18422561883926392,
0.030499687418341637,
-0.7373725771903992,
0.2320457100868225,
-0.4373686611652374,
0.4033588767051697,
-0.15373431146144867,
0.332002729177475,
-0.7924762964248657,
-0.4158746898174286,
0.06386016309261322,
-0.38228923082351685,
0.2263845056295395,
-0.3765769600868225,
-0.6143437027931213,
0.04851203411817551,
0.04822712019085884,
0.6900191307067871,
0.562393069267273,
-0.5790092349052429,
0.6002521514892578,
0.6984993815422058,
0.16153724491596222,
-0.6736398935317993,
-0.8160242438316345,
0.16001737117767334,
-0.3612794578075409,
-0.5822306871414185,
0.27913618087768555,
0.1437334567308426,
-0.22630110383033752,
-0.167790949344635,
-0.19331222772598267,
-0.008294097147881985,
0.038281336426734924,
0.12382347136735916,
-0.09080708026885986,
-0.49362921714782715,
0.06149672716856003,
-0.05286562070250511,
0.2000766396522522,
0.4607251286506653,
-0.3947802186012268,
0.8412522077560425,
-0.28780117630958557,
-0.6718500852584839,
0.02095070853829384,
0.08510279655456543,
0.4763404130935669,
-0.2788844406604767,
0.8896196484565735,
0.5860515236854553,
-0.41106465458869934,
-0.422295480966568,
-0.775058925151825,
-0.1455269306898117,
-0.5051546692848206,
0.3368566036224365,
-0.5126601457595825,
-1.3340076208114624,
0.9462738037109375,
-0.1683902144432068,
-0.14307603240013123,
0.3066924810409546,
0.43022656440734863,
0.05461134389042854,
0.7441143989562988,
0.47758740186691284,
-0.1348201483488083,
0.31091028451919556,
-0.29270362854003906,
0.1283320039510727,
-1.220749855041504,
-0.37875863909721375,
-0.3448620140552521,
-0.0976458415389061,
-0.43139252066612244,
-0.6601649522781372,
0.5184164047241211,
0.2902117371559143,
-0.18575045466423035,
0.08938819169998169,
-0.06002173572778702,
0.7132807970046997,
0.3679795265197754,
0.35527828335762024,
0.3373090326786041,
-0.06245674937963486,
-0.14460331201553345,
0.3190353810787201,
-0.7987672686576843,
-0.4034765958786011,
1.015443205833435,
0.6399699449539185,
0.6117703914642334,
0.20009870827198029,
0.5214749574661255,
-0.02583356201648712,
0.09343352168798447,
-0.8161658048629761,
0.7821921706199646,
-0.0031526554375886917,
-0.5008742213249207,
-0.2132381647825241,
-0.6239203810691833,
-0.788923442363739,
0.3411128520965576,
0.14943745732307434,
-0.6767998337745667,
0.16055233776569366,
0.1439908742904663,
-0.04010535776615143,
0.43723830580711365,
-0.6564740538597107,
0.5155922174453735,
-0.29146209359169006,
-0.29589831829071045,
-0.09209999442100525,
-0.4595606327056885,
0.48902085423469543,
0.015478046610951424,
0.18683971464633942,
0.09532590955495834,
-0.02466573193669319,
0.5165740847587585,
-0.0037314491346478462,
1.021838903427124,
-0.09835894405841827,
-0.6182159781455994,
0.2674783766269684,
0.328228622674942,
0.4211559593677521,
0.24101915955543518,
0.0024274238385260105,
0.3200285732746124,
-0.12494053691625595,
-0.48180341720581055,
-0.4338315427303314,
0.5753180980682373,
-0.6867336630821228,
-0.8193836808204651,
-0.1791258454322815,
-0.4780140221118927,
-0.3291943371295929,
0.17157778143882751,
0.13530944287776947,
0.5164309740066528,
-0.13266462087631226,
0.5694757699966431,
0.8938273191452026,
-0.20858639478683472,
0.06557703763246536,
0.39884617924690247,
-0.24468474090099335,
0.18981696665287018,
0.6217270493507385,
-0.00009878724813461304,
0.35605713725090027,
0.7468569874763489,
0.23742881417274475,
-0.16419556736946106,
-0.7511550784111023,
-0.4216153025627136,
0.017719782888889313,
-0.9325085878372192,
-0.07896880060434341,
-0.6163302659988403,
-0.5986654162406921,
-0.22757230699062347,
0.23834975063800812,
-0.34948936104774475,
-0.06704065203666687,
-0.03551630675792694,
-0.11412810534238815,
0.15907447040081024,
0.6087358593940735,
0.15713362395763397,
0.11101775616407394,
-0.6204113960266113,
0.006588044576346874,
0.47564461827278137,
0.2318793386220932,
0.15661880373954773,
-0.6678825616836548,
-0.3263000547885895,
0.2521519064903259,
0.078584223985672,
-0.8194827437400818,
0.16752569377422333,
0.04316605627536774,
0.6857934594154358,
0.42337730526924133,
-0.04462618753314018,
0.5291343927383423,
-0.48520252108573914,
0.8597607016563416,
-0.42953458428382874,
-0.9172245264053345,
0.38855037093162537,
-0.5498378276824951,
0.39551451802253723,
0.13792067766189575,
0.24747616052627563,
-0.5641945600509644,
-0.3144870102405548,
-0.2606174945831299,
-0.8062642216682434,
0.6591570973396301,
0.1718589812517166,
0.5559688806533813,
0.0645170733332634,
0.5872406959533691,
0.14044933021068573,
0.1533190757036209,
-0.7989346385002136,
-0.01152077317237854,
-0.03321405127644539,
0.2737666368484497,
0.050459153950214386,
-0.6036615967750549,
-0.49157410860061646,
-0.15944679081439972,
0.2555353045463562,
-0.2134932428598404,
0.45582279562950134,
0.2147737294435501,
-0.39474910497665405,
0.2200486809015274,
0.43515336513519287,
0.5705408453941345,
0.6172513365745544,
-0.16796962916851044,
0.6559358239173889,
0.4000750780105591,
-0.5246179103851318,
-0.16805027425289154,
-0.20874185860157013,
-0.08381742984056473,
-0.36594146490097046,
0.727543830871582,
1.0471415519714355,
0.3392208218574524,
-0.5717734694480896,
0.4057420492172241,
-0.19709134101867676,
-0.21239013969898224,
-0.3030189871788025,
0.2435990273952484,
0.17551907896995544,
0.36554810404777527,
0.36788490414619446,
-0.2919931709766388,
0.05360125005245209,
-0.6661582589149475,
0.021268680691719055,
0.5276433825492859,
-0.03759272024035454,
-0.3052944242954254,
0.3031279146671295,
-0.015899144113063812,
0.015200243331491947,
0.5945836901664734,
-0.13014225661754608,
-0.658860981464386,
0.48338159918785095,
0.659396767616272,
0.6239928007125854,
0.050339069217443466,
0.07282109558582306,
0.20567521452903748,
0.32499420642852783,
-0.019272081553936005,
0.06576225906610489,
-0.34166350960731506,
-1.1127018928527832,
-0.518667995929718,
-0.578614354133606,
-0.45524245500564575,
0.4815199375152588,
-0.6113991737365723,
-0.09634155035018921,
-0.28351709246635437,
0.10045464336872101,
-0.27170494198799133,
-0.2208237498998642,
-0.8993796110153198,
-0.0015718359500169754,
0.22369952499866486,
0.9027751684188843,
-0.571814775466919,
0.9876956343650818,
0.6113710403442383,
-0.08425859361886978,
-0.7078755497932434,
0.28269892930984497,
0.05788132920861244,
-1.1597766876220703,
0.7025635242462158,
0.24661661684513092,
-0.29430222511291504,
-0.06893940269947052,
-0.7216031551361084,
-1.0154205560684204,
1.1936957836151123,
0.5540997982025146,
-0.4559254050254822,
0.0699673742055893,
0.3724282681941986,
0.5319838523864746,
-0.4693942368030548,
0.3336813449859619,
0.5235933661460876,
0.2956421673297882,
0.1260724514722824,
-0.8805444836616516,
0.11965787410736084,
-0.3320363759994507,
-0.13266828656196594,
-0.012773171998560429,
-0.5964388251304626,
0.8644010424613953,
-0.10264093428850174,
-0.4124230742454529,
-0.24398697912693024,
0.6245023012161255,
0.10777397453784943,
0.10189276933670044,
0.5904695391654968,
0.40577054023742676,
0.6489559412002563,
-0.10464908182621002,
1.1343436241149902,
-0.31045424938201904,
0.1504531055688858,
0.9377773404121399,
-0.1983897089958191,
0.860498309135437,
0.5184533596038818,
0.05761907622218132,
0.5782545208930969,
0.5880507230758667,
0.30481892824172974,
0.4193994700908661,
0.15900570154190063,
-0.2849120497703552,
-0.3573048412799835,
-0.17310260236263275,
-0.3909236192703247,
0.7140964269638062,
0.47539031505584717,
-0.25218960642814636,
-0.053522739559412,
-0.18588241934776306,
0.020176533609628677,
-0.29154276847839355,
-0.22667965292930603,
0.902265727519989,
0.1871633678674698,
-0.6159156560897827,
0.5546665191650391,
0.07614577561616898,
0.47027724981307983,
-0.66905277967453,
0.12395898997783661,
-0.3812931776046753,
0.021490763872861862,
-0.06818491965532303,
-0.9747592806816101,
-0.009114529006183147,
-0.03159105405211449,
0.03907380998134613,
-0.3311803638935089,
0.8507452011108398,
-0.4169316291809082,
-0.08530756086111069,
0.4115747809410095,
0.689810574054718,
0.045625124126672745,
-0.10119394212961197,
-0.22837772965431213,
0.2741832733154297,
-0.09999117255210876,
-0.5977157950401306,
0.4780910909175873,
0.8822749853134155,
0.017881473526358604,
0.7274300456047058,
0.5657472610473633,
0.0994875431060791,
0.17629054188728333,
0.3536307215690613,
1.0595650672912598,
-0.5661645531654358,
-0.20931313931941986,
-0.9354251027107239,
0.5673452615737915,
-0.014104108326137066,
-0.16315630078315735,
0.8431956171989441,
0.429774671792984,
1.196642518043518,
0.12762890756130219,
0.5806708931922913,
0.0653342679142952,
0.10741294920444489,
-0.9336813688278198,
0.6520994901657104,
-0.5195466876029968,
0.663021445274353,
0.03700307756662369,
-0.7088544368743896,
0.013217657804489136,
0.4292464554309845,
-0.3477282226085663,
0.09205622225999832,
0.5079252123832703,
0.7395028471946716,
-0.4432162642478943,
0.12260128557682037,
0.17088189721107483,
0.5062362551689148,
0.3911990523338318,
0.6962541937828064,
1.0854586362838745,
-0.18817800283432007,
0.32353895902633667,
-0.26531416177749634,
-0.18395666778087616,
-0.15699335932731628,
-0.9416422843933105,
-1.0365307331085205,
-0.7657136917114258,
0.04690781608223915,
-0.18082834780216217,
-0.2309660166501999,
0.4300304651260376,
0.7324366569519043,
-0.47104135155677795,
-0.2512756288051605,
0.026479970663785934,
0.005844787694513798,
-0.010334010235965252,
-0.19983848929405212,
0.31868720054626465,
-0.19898313283920288,
-0.4524918794631958,
0.5738048553466797,
0.07477662712335587,
-0.11105445772409439,
-0.47241950035095215,
0.017108969390392303,
0.03590693324804306,
0.06926093995571136,
0.7638530135154724,
0.06309942156076431,
-0.645700991153717,
-0.5378850698471069,
0.06269657611846924,
-0.19951924681663513,
-0.009623555466532707,
1.0116918087005615,
-0.705441415309906,
0.21473750472068787,
0.6711261868476868,
0.8717320561408997,
0.6197189688682556,
-0.29534071683883667,
0.5315210223197937,
-1.0136562585830688,
0.02047424390912056,
0.04787759482860565,
0.624253511428833,
0.4489104747772217,
-0.4275639057159424,
0.36706817150115967,
-0.0861792117357254,
-0.654695451259613,
-0.9530473351478577,
0.4584193229675293,
-1.1085902452468872,
-0.14594198763370514,
1.3587896823883057,
-0.12207150459289551,
-0.26981502771377563,
0.23844024538993835,
-0.1780238300561905,
0.23172889649868011,
-0.12161828577518463,
0.8436099886894226,
0.7784504294395447,
-0.1069379448890686,
-0.4180188775062561,
-0.8194130659103394,
0.3711399435997009,
0.41080397367477417,
-0.7047862410545349,
0.1721469908952713,
0.3552633225917816,
0.3211005926132202,
0.07976249605417252,
0.6105667352676392,
-0.0049420609138906,
-0.01301552727818489,
0.001325275981798768,
-0.43019020557403564,
-0.17130528390407562,
-0.32345351576805115,
-0.16306790709495544,
0.29405948519706726,
0.02533530443906784,
-0.0038122348487377167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16058v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16058v1
|
Say More with Less: Understanding Prompt Learning Behaviors through Gist Compression
| 2024-02-25T11:07:08 | 2024-02-25T11:07:08 |
Xinze Li, Zhenghao Liu, Chenyan Xiong, Shi Yu, Yukun Yan, Shuo Wang, Ge Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) require lengthy prompts as the input context to
produce output aligned with user intentions, a process that incurs extra costs
during inference. In this paper, we propose the Gist COnditioned deCOding
(Gist-COCO) model, introducing a novel method for compressing prompts which
also can assist the prompt interpretation and engineering. Gist-COCO employs an
encoder-decoder based language model and then incorporates an additional
encoder as a plugin module to compress prompts with inputs using gist tokens.
It finetunes the compression plugin module and uses the representations of gist
tokens to emulate the raw prompts in the vanilla language model. By verbalizing
the representations of gist tokens into gist prompts, the compression ability
of Gist-COCO can be generalized to different LLMs with high compression rates.
Our experiments demonstrate that Gist-COCO outperforms previous prompt
compression models in both passage and instruction compression tasks. Further
analysis on gist verbalization results suggests that our gist prompts serve
different functions in aiding language models. They may directly provide
potential answers, generate the chain-of-thought, or simply repeat the inputs.
All data and codes are available at https://github.com/OpenMatch/Gist-COCO .
|
[
-0.4018181264400482,
-0.9941659569740295,
0.5777708292007446,
-0.0004980828380212188,
-0.3259834051132202,
0.25819793343544006,
-0.6566506028175354,
-0.11382816731929779,
0.25340038537979126,
0.1444408893585205,
-0.9563919901847839,
-0.5151429176330566,
-0.6665149927139282,
0.3694421350955963,
-0.13166867196559906,
1.1343268156051636,
0.2031233161687851,
0.1975979059934616,
-0.46100229024887085,
0.1803646832704544,
-0.8663605451583862,
-0.6127625703811646,
-0.8013741374015808,
-0.13632617890834808,
0.47280171513557434,
0.7200874090194702,
0.6264784336090088,
0.25277766585350037,
0.1568560153245926,
0.22413600981235504,
-0.35057467222213745,
-0.12777835130691528,
-0.5830556750297546,
0.17232899367809296,
0.23070378601551056,
-0.4107900857925415,
-0.017815295606851578,
0.011363638564944267,
0.14418762922286987,
0.7141887545585632,
-0.1667468547821045,
0.12657500803470612,
0.28496530652046204,
0.45532581210136414,
-0.5012089014053345,
0.5680910348892212,
-0.26829594373703003,
0.02033085562288761,
0.5163570046424866,
-0.10665182024240494,
-0.7411831617355347,
-0.39059996604919434,
-0.01892215944826603,
-0.7557040452957153,
0.11496007442474365,
0.02704821340739727,
0.752464771270752,
0.2876149117946625,
-0.2349231094121933,
-0.45603325963020325,
-0.26168736815452576,
0.40533211827278137,
-0.47346222400665283,
0.3864179849624634,
0.4907340109348297,
0.3716471195220947,
-0.034953534603118896,
-0.595058023929596,
-0.5164525508880615,
-0.4689929187297821,
-0.25931161642074585,
-0.01602497510612011,
-0.04595421999692917,
0.28759831190109253,
0.6665754914283752,
0.20493197441101074,
-0.7252072095870972,
-0.18352025747299194,
-0.45862898230552673,
-0.21967469155788422,
0.11074644327163696,
-0.02925262600183487,
0.44829314947128296,
-0.2787904441356659,
-0.40129631757736206,
-0.46650052070617676,
-0.6461326479911804,
0.4761732816696167,
0.24380025267601013,
0.24732768535614014,
-0.4040941596031189,
0.5793133974075317,
-0.2310451716184616,
0.7459335327148438,
0.13091455399990082,
0.027235381305217743,
-0.007472552824765444,
0.02639266848564148,
-0.38656601309776306,
0.08361449092626572,
0.677456259727478,
0.2861090898513794,
0.6165539622306824,
0.09427867084741592,
-0.16704000532627106,
0.3016641438007355,
-0.06596909463405609,
-0.8459835052490234,
-0.31275734305381775,
-0.18075360357761383,
-0.20352251827716827,
-0.14401446282863617,
0.13925088942050934,
-0.7251831889152527,
-0.6036001443862915,
-0.4120948910713196,
0.10133849084377289,
-0.47778552770614624,
0.09006144851446152,
0.4158853590488434,
-0.36659783124923706,
0.13858367502689362,
0.30043596029281616,
-0.9256806969642639,
0.46262499690055847,
0.6561881899833679,
1.1405267715454102,
0.02734960801899433,
0.04705795645713806,
-0.7557297945022583,
-0.3376271724700928,
-0.16923406720161438,
0.6740755438804626,
-0.7191682457923889,
-0.608576238155365,
0.005537192337214947,
0.14929473400115967,
-0.18771962821483612,
0.0015938744181767106,
0.7851864695549011,
-0.5297409892082214,
0.13278193771839142,
-0.3378954231739044,
-0.378694623708725,
-0.4023993909358978,
0.48691391944885254,
-0.7427672147750854,
0.6702266931533813,
0.28846579790115356,
-0.72206050157547,
0.023412588983774185,
-0.5194912552833557,
-0.38363566994667053,
0.15618635714054108,
-0.18146854639053345,
0.011873777955770493,
0.35099169611930847,
0.6538137793540955,
0.506834864616394,
-0.3397482931613922,
0.4132213592529297,
-0.20677225291728973,
-0.49680638313293457,
0.3868391215801239,
-0.6505143046379089,
0.6312784552574158,
0.2780952751636505,
0.08979909121990204,
0.1046963706612587,
-0.34792545437812805,
-0.21278204023838043,
0.2594119906425476,
-0.4771098494529724,
-0.17591221630573273,
-0.38892853260040283,
-0.42061373591423035,
0.16889850795269012,
0.1427723616361618,
-0.410513699054718,
0.6704988479614258,
-0.30915266275405884,
0.7328687906265259,
0.5317005515098572,
0.14927037060260773,
0.587888777256012,
-0.2785314619541168,
1.0256240367889404,
-0.21557819843292236,
0.25773224234580994,
-0.6788817644119263,
-0.49018537998199463,
-0.7863762974739075,
-0.28010985255241394,
0.2888326942920685,
0.409991055727005,
-1.0731762647628784,
0.08714405447244644,
-0.7162784934043884,
-0.11559300869703293,
-0.49657177925109863,
-0.05093061551451683,
0.04907999560236931,
0.757568359375,
0.2960282266139984,
0.028225800022482872,
-0.5444620251655579,
-0.447786420583725,
0.139954075217247,
-0.2201971560716629,
-0.21489842236042023,
0.32247117161750793,
0.3561219274997711,
0.08747328817844391,
0.9561399817466736,
-0.7273195385932922,
0.0946643203496933,
-0.4265505373477936,
0.1457001268863678,
0.5332737565040588,
0.356105774641037,
0.22953461110591888,
-0.4157183766365051,
-0.47475653886795044,
-0.22971193492412567,
-0.46060898900032043,
-0.0690990462899208,
-0.143686443567276,
0.11984660476446152,
-0.19057045876979828,
0.5663431882858276,
-0.9147656559944153,
0.3450663089752197,
0.6469410061836243,
-0.3767785429954529,
0.6239641904830933,
-0.22241923213005066,
0.29758593440055847,
-0.6853529214859009,
-0.13376553356647491,
-0.3330887258052826,
-0.5118702054023743,
-0.3563954830169678,
0.18610741198062897,
0.14534056186676025,
-0.7331193685531616,
-0.49201834201812744,
0.5052934885025024,
-0.7876883149147034,
0.01583867520093918,
-0.16752506792545319,
0.11504235863685608,
0.4322136342525482,
0.895783543586731,
0.15009313821792603,
1.0698567628860474,
0.7887416481971741,
-0.7558711767196655,
0.42188069224357605,
0.2886442542076111,
-0.4502829611301422,
0.2856927812099457,
-1.0170680284500122,
0.35302770137786865,
-0.2632558345794678,
0.5931023955345154,
-0.9783980846405029,
-0.32076922059059143,
0.5608348846435547,
-0.7441570162773132,
0.33407071232795715,
-0.582883358001709,
-0.5369752645492554,
-0.5087714195251465,
-0.6387596130371094,
0.3615337908267975,
0.8963237404823303,
-0.7162246704101562,
0.4317554235458374,
-0.08620966225862503,
-0.4469822645187378,
-0.30824723839759827,
-0.7836559414863586,
0.04269390553236008,
-0.2719406485557556,
-0.6130709052085876,
-0.11827228963375092,
-0.6229054927825928,
0.25881507992744446,
-0.2518429756164551,
-0.03147687390446663,
0.1642017662525177,
0.3535814881324768,
0.41249504685401917,
0.3566170632839203,
-0.2740967571735382,
0.24312523007392883,
0.20443493127822876,
-0.05284306779503822,
0.141954243183136,
-0.5419323444366455,
0.7899860739707947,
0.12048596143722534,
-0.20465435087680817,
-0.2856109142303467,
0.40398937463760376,
0.4757997691631317,
0.04647759348154068,
0.8580245971679688,
0.20912320911884308,
-0.13957582414150238,
-0.046040263026952744,
-0.10562524944543839,
-0.28025707602500916,
-0.5637496113777161,
-0.2433478832244873,
-0.35020968317985535,
-1.0185401439666748,
0.42307353019714355,
-0.22660838067531586,
-0.30606162548065186,
-0.009121238254010677,
0.29908546805381775,
0.09126868098974228,
1.1427594423294067,
0.6065139174461365,
0.004030073992908001,
0.7422212362289429,
-0.4226958155632019,
0.12722903490066528,
-0.8734455704689026,
-0.25584059953689575,
-0.5822988748550415,
-0.1329285353422165,
-0.11659091711044312,
-0.6578795909881592,
0.37978705763816833,
0.4685562252998352,
-0.2552225887775421,
0.39741453528404236,
-0.7616492509841919,
0.7515232563018799,
0.33310914039611816,
0.19237816333770752,
0.06332159787416458,
0.03929046913981438,
-0.39622846245765686,
0.30844494700431824,
-0.8039328455924988,
-0.4505191743373871,
0.4113272428512573,
0.20626628398895264,
1.0492337942123413,
0.05015593767166138,
0.37377363443374634,
0.42422300577163696,
0.004226336721330881,
-1.2182130813598633,
0.4396720230579376,
0.3658435642719269,
-0.11464015394449234,
-0.048277512192726135,
-0.25438061356544495,
-1.0501084327697754,
-0.16377468407154083,
0.010293463245034218,
-0.8805356025695801,
0.1484113186597824,
0.15736186504364014,
-0.4667574465274811,
-0.25803637504577637,
-0.9836481809616089,
0.6331177353858948,
-0.0300575140863657,
0.04001516103744507,
0.009698842652142048,
-0.5707423090934753,
0.4035264253616333,
0.37614715099334717,
0.3621329963207245,
-0.02094915881752968,
0.004226990044116974,
0.697075366973877,
-0.3495784103870392,
1.0997291803359985,
-0.19858455657958984,
-0.07450124621391296,
0.45521482825279236,
0.19502554833889008,
0.9089772701263428,
0.41147345304489136,
-0.17949450016021729,
0.012241562828421593,
-0.30885669589042664,
-0.2897259294986725,
-1.044087529182434,
0.8090093731880188,
-0.5976144075393677,
-0.6888942122459412,
-0.3100051283836365,
-0.15711112320423126,
-0.05894830450415611,
-0.15864816308021545,
0.5623685121536255,
0.5750048756599426,
-0.020255891606211662,
-0.1785542070865631,
0.7309143543243408,
-0.3022363781929016,
0.5219317674636841,
0.3236753046512604,
-0.06181292608380318,
-0.5140510201454163,
0.794140636920929,
-0.15481992065906525,
0.21853038668632507,
0.3540882468223572,
0.4313718378543854,
-0.32778409123420715,
-0.18307018280029297,
-0.47837090492248535,
0.09260184317827225,
-1.1077405214309692,
-0.5657899975776672,
-0.723839282989502,
0.035974711179733276,
-0.7168526649475098,
-0.4544459581375122,
0.2923732399940491,
-0.49473682045936584,
-0.6438503861427307,
-0.44181081652641296,
0.6679526567459106,
0.622275173664093,
0.09011488407850266,
0.8164080381393433,
-0.8545492887496948,
0.21853899955749512,
0.17763559520244598,
0.09006115049123764,
0.116451695561409,
-0.6647387146949768,
-0.3825840950012207,
0.1613151729106903,
-0.10135241597890854,
-1.1327760219573975,
0.42728716135025024,
0.13442513346672058,
0.21956545114517212,
0.4791991412639618,
0.504268229007721,
0.5861762166023254,
-0.44307082891464233,
1.0822550058364868,
0.4571808874607086,
-1.1535422801971436,
0.6271698474884033,
0.026458343490958214,
0.5038465261459351,
0.5127653479576111,
0.3768348693847656,
-0.8409721255302429,
-0.12058594822883606,
-0.4868377447128296,
-0.7946076393127441,
0.6753148436546326,
-0.1764260232448578,
0.5332114100456238,
-0.3798382878303528,
0.19969183206558228,
0.3051376938819885,
0.12104824930429459,
-0.7405406832695007,
0.03692169860005379,
-0.2843747138977051,
-0.27124783396720886,
-0.08363976329565048,
-0.51540207862854,
0.035913772881031036,
-0.24665363132953644,
0.4083092510700226,
-0.5202071070671082,
0.5082765817642212,
0.14218410849571228,
-0.6160897612571716,
0.375856876373291,
0.42159369587898254,
0.6553929448127747,
-0.03557032346725464,
0.26892948150634766,
0.31022411584854126,
0.2977229058742523,
-0.0867762342095375,
0.2970706522464752,
-0.21289505064487457,
-0.00268136290833354,
-0.02883726917207241,
0.6163811087608337,
1.2953193187713623,
0.31753814220428467,
-0.6519432067871094,
0.7897400259971619,
-0.5170526504516602,
0.12876200675964355,
-0.1596076786518097,
0.3165458142757416,
0.07153402268886566,
-0.07286084443330765,
-0.0054629179649055,
-0.09643839299678802,
0.17996150255203247,
-0.370104044675827,
-0.07906879484653473,
0.17359931766986847,
-0.4599170684814453,
-0.5114810466766357,
0.4542579650878906,
0.3535895049571991,
-0.3759864568710327,
0.76579749584198,
-0.30576807260513306,
-0.710946261882782,
0.4666328728199005,
0.3774721324443817,
0.7820128798484802,
0.1716156303882599,
0.33279651403427124,
0.626285970211029,
0.017228199169039726,
-0.12890954315662384,
0.10277567058801651,
-0.7991872429847717,
-0.28408804535865784,
-0.6167424321174622,
-0.48602724075317383,
-0.29627054929733276,
-0.20652788877487183,
-0.752448320388794,
0.6092931032180786,
-0.5913835763931274,
-0.12450528889894485,
-0.4811929762363434,
-0.10638239979743958,
-0.8171676993370056,
-0.05423473194241524,
0.17271371185779572,
1.1129738092422485,
-0.7818772196769714,
0.6597791910171509,
0.5050460696220398,
-0.544594407081604,
-0.9801967144012451,
-0.13421794772148132,
0.03657453879714012,
-0.824563205242157,
0.46018052101135254,
0.48208945989608765,
-0.12453065067529678,
0.07231222093105316,
-0.9317392706871033,
-0.7373653054237366,
0.8314263820648193,
0.8377652168273926,
-0.7581771016120911,
-0.303458571434021,
-0.21293283998966217,
0.2572847902774811,
-0.333727091550827,
0.5223264694213867,
0.4843621253967285,
0.5014563202857971,
0.3685527741909027,
-0.40187346935272217,
0.1895378977060318,
-0.09492071717977524,
-0.18625620007514954,
-0.1653795689344406,
-0.2809531092643738,
0.7754454016685486,
-0.5315560102462769,
-0.6482340693473816,
0.21340441703796387,
0.5231871604919434,
0.06131855770945549,
0.017699090763926506,
0.4068079888820648,
0.04967037960886955,
0.9745294451713562,
0.07839733362197876,
1.3601624965667725,
-0.43368273973464966,
0.4351760149002075,
1.1344877481460571,
0.10063641518354416,
0.3074243664741516,
0.2994847595691681,
0.22004982829093933,
0.6867799162864685,
0.9038105010986328,
0.12938427925109863,
0.563572108745575,
0.5264076590538025,
-0.33958426117897034,
-0.25097206234931946,
-0.48190397024154663,
-0.19637146592140198,
-0.0028102670330554247,
0.3689081370830536,
-0.10105720907449722,
0.024630162864923477,
0.5064694881439209,
0.20726561546325684,
-0.030189406126737595,
-0.23710648715496063,
0.936417818069458,
0.29453790187835693,
-0.772702693939209,
0.9073980450630188,
-0.14100682735443115,
0.758984386920929,
-0.6474252939224243,
-0.06928899139165878,
-0.3532350957393646,
-0.4433967173099518,
0.001965615199878812,
-0.6037331819534302,
-0.03573077172040939,
0.30081799626350403,
-0.26307711005210876,
-0.32549726963043213,
0.54735267162323,
-0.3962482213973999,
-0.3820299208164215,
0.3311363160610199,
0.24161402881145477,
0.2808835208415985,
-0.09610547125339508,
-0.5233874320983887,
0.32678931951522827,
-0.17008888721466064,
-0.2899436950683594,
0.10524347424507141,
0.6155861616134644,
0.030886240303516388,
0.8021106719970703,
0.6764921545982361,
0.04731675237417221,
-0.07836101949214935,
0.30577564239501953,
1.0826750993728638,
-0.6325593590736389,
-0.632358968257904,
-0.9214174747467041,
0.4109133183956146,
0.07612282782793045,
-0.11079023778438568,
0.4321708679199219,
0.192972332239151,
0.6669179201126099,
-0.27577897906303406,
0.5795840620994568,
-0.02182803303003311,
-0.08654660731554031,
-0.7977084517478943,
0.3798273801803589,
-0.21150889992713928,
0.34262216091156006,
-0.014577863737940788,
-0.3774031400680542,
0.055686917155981064,
0.6032423377037048,
-0.13000568747520447,
-0.0440676175057888,
0.7447559237480164,
0.6071520447731018,
0.08883356302976608,
-0.11271783709526062,
0.6256701946258545,
-0.163654163479805,
0.32710179686546326,
0.7272809743881226,
1.1188240051269531,
-0.15750454366207123,
0.6856765151023865,
-0.05025505647063255,
0.11353098601102829,
-0.16739590466022491,
-0.8036743998527527,
-0.980644166469574,
-0.4203285574913025,
-0.33176910877227783,
-0.2280552238225937,
-0.023073071613907814,
1.2085262537002563,
0.9401988387107849,
-0.5158007740974426,
0.16438055038452148,
-0.25488871335983276,
0.5679850578308105,
-0.20197845995426178,
-0.2840622365474701,
0.15766042470932007,
-0.37691327929496765,
-0.7686100006103516,
0.5933160781860352,
-0.0635887011885643,
0.269697368144989,
-0.005250939168035984,
-0.4032568335533142,
0.10681109130382538,
0.21940799057483673,
0.5661473274230957,
0.06664777547121048,
-0.3745465576648712,
-0.46802687644958496,
0.07291406393051147,
-0.08255640417337418,
0.24701659381389618,
1.198091983795166,
-1.3186026811599731,
0.21485008299350739,
0.7035298347473145,
0.5022199749946594,
0.36648666858673096,
0.25033095479011536,
0.6099603176116943,
-1.082931637763977,
0.16771703958511353,
0.12696219980716705,
0.5702451467514038,
0.5961674451828003,
-0.7719594836235046,
0.475180447101593,
0.0746377483010292,
-0.3001658320426941,
-0.5327997207641602,
0.33917129039764404,
-0.994468092918396,
-0.42868494987487793,
1.3216724395751953,
-0.5577695369720459,
-0.3772740960121155,
0.13719619810581207,
-0.6271350383758545,
0.5363975167274475,
-0.9149551391601562,
0.2908850908279419,
0.7495433688163757,
0.05517154932022095,
-0.5860382318496704,
-0.23746247589588165,
0.41006091237068176,
0.09206274151802063,
-0.6663035750389099,
0.3606310784816742,
0.5853623151779175,
0.225030779838562,
-0.10327386856079102,
0.3772498667240143,
0.411541223526001,
0.24134190380573273,
0.025675801560282707,
-0.050395313650369644,
-0.4688722789287567,
-0.4210474491119385,
-0.945499837398529,
0.09987121820449829,
0.27448946237564087,
-0.17017166316509247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16050v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16050v1
|
LSTP: Language-guided Spatial-Temporal Prompt Learning for Long-form Video-Text Understanding
| 2024-02-25T10:27:46 | 2024-02-25T10:27:46 |
Yuxuan Wang, Yueqian Wang, Pengfei Wu, Jianxin Liang, Dongyan Zhao, Zilong Zheng
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Despite progress in video-language modeling, the computational challenge of
interpreting long-form videos in response to task-specific linguistic queries
persists, largely due to the complexity of high-dimensional video data and the
misalignment between language and visual cues over space and time. To tackle
this issue, we introduce a novel approach called Language-guided
Spatial-Temporal Prompt Learning (LSTP). This approach features two key
components: a Temporal Prompt Sampler (TPS) with optical flow prior that
leverages temporal information to efficiently extract relevant video content,
and a Spatial Prompt Solver (SPS) that adeptly captures the intricate spatial
relationships between visual and textual elements. By harmonizing TPS and SPS
with a cohesive training strategy, our framework significantly enhances
computational efficiency, temporal understanding, and spatial-temporal
alignment. Empirical evaluations across two challenging tasks--video question
answering and temporal question grounding in videos--using a variety of
video-language pretrainings (VLPs) and large language models (LLMs) demonstrate
the superior performance, speed, and versatility of our proposed LSTP paradigm.
|
[
-0.1561218947172165,
-1.096927523612976,
0.8890329003334045,
0.51212477684021,
-0.32482585310935974,
0.24078579246997833,
-0.43757304549217224,
-0.26857075095176697,
-0.07945875823497772,
0.28298038244247437,
-0.9539129137992859,
-0.503496527671814,
-0.49076128005981445,
0.048629194498062134,
-0.206158846616745,
0.6603258848190308,
-0.17934122681617737,
0.11524789780378342,
0.1291767954826355,
-0.12083041667938232,
-0.7274512648582458,
-0.27217817306518555,
-0.8381849527359009,
-0.1232999786734581,
0.7233180999755859,
0.25045067071914673,
0.5354256629943848,
0.5299230217933655,
0.25505301356315613,
0.3031739592552185,
-0.17991796135902405,
0.13044430315494537,
-0.2639119327068329,
0.2222251147031784,
-0.26451075077056885,
-0.06559658795595169,
0.027638370171189308,
-0.4145486056804657,
0.8386606574058533,
0.9148581624031067,
-0.04045551270246506,
0.0028976285830140114,
0.0566289983689785,
0.7157999277114868,
-0.49248006939888,
0.11390737444162369,
-0.2430751919746399,
0.5464710593223572,
-0.10564008355140686,
-0.6439743041992188,
-0.3366925120353699,
-0.26409435272216797,
0.37027108669281006,
-0.7335614562034607,
0.45277169346809387,
-0.03900747746229172,
0.5850828289985657,
0.5816781520843506,
-0.35846376419067383,
-0.026783406734466553,
-0.8001261353492737,
0.4935290515422821,
-0.1864241361618042,
0.8158596158027649,
0.29075726866722107,
0.7520692944526672,
-0.011887593194842339,
-0.5028495788574219,
-0.4546498656272888,
-0.07697563618421555,
0.22384244203567505,
0.09970901906490326,
0.09132228791713715,
0.0772540345788002,
0.34418755769729614,
-0.20103368163108826,
-1.0594123601913452,
0.3208421766757965,
-0.2638317942619324,
0.03503435477614403,
0.17614707350730896,
0.11412151902914047,
0.4458656907081604,
-0.220503032207489,
-0.5130565166473389,
-0.06353658437728882,
-0.42883312702178955,
0.2819534242153168,
-0.2717643678188324,
0.4770423173904419,
-0.25409024953842163,
0.6116452813148499,
-0.09096287190914154,
0.7812331318855286,
0.11064336448907852,
-0.07191052287817001,
-0.0162658728659153,
-0.2361047863960266,
-0.30981752276420593,
0.0652589276432991,
0.5912990570068359,
0.24596667289733887,
0.22959350049495697,
0.03330456092953682,
0.0974411740899086,
-0.2088788002729416,
-0.25595715641975403,
-0.7386038899421692,
0.007882731966674328,
0.14443621039390564,
-0.2419898957014084,
0.07066760212182999,
-0.1518440693616867,
-0.9355242252349854,
-0.4351891279220581,
-0.5170740485191345,
0.25378674268722534,
-0.47466784715652466,
-0.08114307373762131,
0.2537737190723419,
-0.16062162816524506,
0.3412650525569916,
0.6169330477714539,
-0.9527013897895813,
0.004901249427348375,
0.5970560312271118,
0.9242516160011292,
-0.236666738986969,
-0.6072899699211121,
-0.9473979473114014,
0.34799906611442566,
-0.15774840116500854,
0.859321117401123,
-0.5439128279685974,
-0.19960620999336243,
0.1991981714963913,
-0.07974567264318466,
-0.004180924501270056,
-0.2874923646450043,
0.24440991878509521,
-0.6250445246696472,
0.4865674078464508,
-0.32151705026626587,
-0.28786352276802063,
0.07317306101322174,
0.4484636187553406,
-0.6219368577003479,
1.164117455482483,
-0.004859486594796181,
-0.42695534229278564,
0.5130934119224548,
-0.5018795728683472,
-0.028287911787629128,
0.16735722124576569,
-0.46548381447792053,
-0.15456993877887726,
-0.03696141391992569,
0.5657785534858704,
0.4596911668777466,
0.15845727920532227,
0.6536784768104553,
-0.13722676038742065,
-0.1444043517112732,
0.0026603539008647203,
-0.5612372159957886,
0.4058855473995209,
0.29472941160202026,
-0.18468013405799866,
0.16296662390232086,
-0.5645114779472351,
-0.04534824192523956,
0.16606801748275757,
-0.14345958828926086,
-0.1619855910539627,
0.10820887982845306,
-0.009667287580668926,
0.27105507254600525,
0.20594608783721924,
-0.3087935447692871,
0.17751707136631012,
-0.2915232479572296,
0.38745027780532837,
0.7778154015541077,
-0.027852864935994148,
0.829716145992279,
0.15472696721553802,
0.5818954110145569,
-0.09958432614803314,
0.07064409554004669,
-0.547824501991272,
-0.08991959691047668,
-0.22999350726604462,
-0.02693629078567028,
-0.39383095502853394,
0.6938516497612,
-1.064030647277832,
0.24420176446437836,
-0.34967270493507385,
-0.2726098299026489,
0.18813499808311462,
0.07549544423818588,
0.2731459140777588,
0.6919057965278625,
0.4471372365951538,
0.1913931518793106,
-0.483629047870636,
-0.29324832558631897,
-0.30013173818588257,
-0.16044194996356964,
-0.09377571195363998,
0.3613433837890625,
0.42040112614631653,
0.09426198154687881,
0.9783334136009216,
-0.7070437073707581,
-0.190066859126091,
-0.5348829627037048,
0.16498364508152008,
0.358225554227829,
0.1526266187429428,
0.5242823362350464,
-0.7267665863037109,
-0.48225948214530945,
-0.1775062084197998,
-0.7797145247459412,
-0.3093905448913574,
-0.336473286151886,
0.07920879870653152,
0.17249727249145508,
0.7549465894699097,
-0.6177784204483032,
0.3230990767478943,
0.40596577525138855,
-0.775631308555603,
0.600121259689331,
-0.2923795282840729,
0.2419738471508026,
-0.9037318229675293,
-0.22013871371746063,
0.01149323396384716,
-0.21644903719425201,
-0.5128372311592102,
0.04483557492494583,
-0.2233600616455078,
-0.8570071458816528,
-0.7678108811378479,
0.794308066368103,
-0.42595720291137695,
-0.230384960770607,
-0.06772260367870331,
0.3055945038795471,
-0.01731709949672222,
0.7222499251365662,
0.6400379538536072,
0.7424168586730957,
0.3914758265018463,
-0.6527025699615479,
0.3459714949131012,
0.1812964528799057,
-0.291586309671402,
0.5349427461624146,
-0.6421815752983093,
-0.013406088575720787,
-0.5025002360343933,
0.3945123553276062,
-0.8349201083183289,
-0.17326287925243378,
0.06484178453683853,
-0.4412234127521515,
0.12671557068824768,
-0.2016901820898056,
-0.4385503828525543,
-0.11373112350702286,
-0.019180186092853546,
0.8237234354019165,
0.2655195891857147,
-0.7606551647186279,
0.7309145927429199,
-0.15777823328971863,
-0.45496121048927307,
-0.6521899104118347,
-0.6121760010719299,
0.05850596725940704,
-0.1633472442626953,
-0.6459882259368896,
0.27265465259552,
-0.11739145964384079,
-0.06414945423603058,
-0.1815035194158554,
-0.12670327723026276,
-0.3751673698425293,
-0.11643221974372864,
-0.049817465245723724,
-0.015659907832741737,
-0.14634370803833008,
0.23519912362098694,
-0.021317947655916214,
-0.281734824180603,
0.022482439875602722,
-0.41977810859680176,
0.7456333041191101,
0.12644162774085999,
-0.5113934278488159,
-0.41940179467201233,
0.7579381465911865,
0.1104474887251854,
-0.2735944092273712,
0.42345118522644043,
0.7689748406410217,
-0.38233280181884766,
-0.38766324520111084,
-0.2775210738182068,
-0.09535187482833862,
-0.4785042405128479,
0.6970192790031433,
-0.12792308628559113,
-1.045931339263916,
0.21779276430606842,
-0.027770113199949265,
0.04156167432665825,
-0.03912171721458435,
0.22341884672641754,
-0.45581215620040894,
0.9069182872772217,
0.7532456517219543,
-0.023665597662329674,
1.099203109741211,
-0.06653871387243271,
0.008511093445122242,
0.015163443051278591,
-0.47885969281196594,
-0.5587864518165588,
-0.2547009587287903,
-0.05079081654548645,
-0.6231228709220886,
0.5111414790153503,
0.06227576732635498,
-0.7232613563537598,
-0.11797570437192917,
-0.14608007669448853,
0.8743321895599365,
0.3370814919471741,
0.26858967542648315,
0.07701319456100464,
0.35267648100852966,
0.041814640164375305,
-0.6057989597320557,
-0.6172431707382202,
-0.03544902801513672,
0.2873719036579132,
0.41333264112472534,
0.5661370754241943,
0.20562294125556946,
0.5048811435699463,
0.24725718796253204,
-0.5774068236351013,
-0.8086034655570984,
0.8078019618988037,
-0.20217512547969818,
0.02560405060648918,
-0.37144577503204346,
-0.2762483060359955,
-0.8508176803588867,
-0.04910925403237343,
-0.08674786239862442,
-0.6013169884681702,
-0.11227444559335709,
0.23288458585739136,
-0.47136300802230835,
0.32944926619529724,
-0.555720329284668,
0.8894222974777222,
-0.6365227103233337,
-0.4927769899368286,
-0.19815298914909363,
-0.734247088432312,
-0.17581818997859955,
0.35389116406440735,
0.22871923446655273,
0.1680041402578354,
-0.137821227312088,
0.4715922176837921,
-0.38528531789779663,
1.0698412656784058,
-0.5921894907951355,
-0.0625573918223381,
0.14028124511241913,
0.17105157673358917,
0.352266788482666,
0.09594161808490753,
0.5534260272979736,
-0.1325748711824417,
-0.2518552541732788,
-0.3394220769405365,
-1.028974175453186,
0.23167063295841217,
-0.6553082466125488,
-0.33975863456726074,
-0.4884117543697357,
-0.4727606177330017,
-0.07384510338306427,
0.32860639691352844,
0.1399557739496231,
0.6542981863021851,
-0.197002112865448,
-0.1444014459848404,
1.149137258529663,
-0.5584070086479187,
0.7400342226028442,
0.43598344922065735,
-0.4055158197879791,
-0.6328510642051697,
0.6610917448997498,
-0.3577180504798889,
0.13397878408432007,
0.9542140364646912,
0.1752471625804901,
-0.434287428855896,
-0.4697951078414917,
-0.3256154954433441,
0.3188442885875702,
-0.6946538686752319,
0.025216734036803246,
-0.2895662486553192,
-0.11974387615919113,
-0.15199695527553558,
-0.4565429091453552,
-0.2112681120634079,
-0.28011658787727356,
-0.37369823455810547,
-0.14250408113002777,
0.2313591092824936,
0.29759481549263,
0.1776277720928192,
0.48825201392173767,
-0.9986674785614014,
0.5418105125427246,
0.38163262605667114,
0.34663107991218567,
-0.38203132152557373,
-0.5475740432739258,
-0.11320240795612335,
-0.27463841438293457,
-0.13379624485969543,
-0.9348458051681519,
0.5131126642227173,
0.393682599067688,
0.20387449860572815,
0.3780795633792877,
-0.3711329996585846,
1.0108991861343384,
-0.9974426627159119,
1.1792552471160889,
0.20600003004074097,
-0.8339381217956543,
1.0245158672332764,
-0.5548579692840576,
0.6572748422622681,
0.37323087453842163,
0.24502238631248474,
-0.7252863049507141,
-0.026196669787168503,
-0.21970762312412262,
-0.7476919293403625,
0.3470652401447296,
-0.15552130341529846,
-0.1467551738023758,
0.05373525619506836,
0.3443337678909302,
-0.03447415679693222,
-0.01663389429450035,
-0.826690673828125,
0.05069360136985779,
-0.24411386251449585,
-0.2410251349210739,
-0.38985249400138855,
-0.2354561984539032,
0.012948913499712944,
-0.09500940144062042,
0.15866497159004211,
-0.3128986954689026,
0.31734713912010193,
0.5808345675468445,
-0.4197643995285034,
0.040970779955387115,
0.5258437991142273,
0.7266725301742554,
0.45138949155807495,
-0.09320423007011414,
0.10863606631755829,
0.1653943806886673,
-0.4735206067562103,
0.08957735449075699,
0.15828968584537506,
-0.0842292383313179,
0.18056485056877136,
0.5990029573440552,
0.7628830671310425,
0.308927983045578,
-0.8653479218482971,
0.5404606461524963,
-0.01752755045890808,
-0.17610080540180206,
-0.5977146029472351,
-0.3201352655887604,
-0.400881826877594,
0.6063972115516663,
0.5210189819335938,
-0.08680598437786102,
-0.06086578220129013,
-0.2664004862308502,
0.06413368135690689,
0.2354542464017868,
-0.3232770264148712,
-0.4606750011444092,
0.7217572331428528,
0.07736263424158096,
-0.43360722064971924,
0.5984793305397034,
-0.003604685189202428,
-0.5759138464927673,
0.48688173294067383,
0.5411542057991028,
0.9724812507629395,
0.009921062737703323,
0.3402847349643707,
0.3833322525024414,
0.09992163628339767,
-0.15305595099925995,
0.5764170289039612,
-0.5291802883148193,
-0.4941413402557373,
-0.9176996350288391,
-0.23084765672683716,
-0.3322177231311798,
-0.08069396018981934,
-0.42537882924079895,
0.3241834342479706,
-0.5482375025749207,
0.11330157518386841,
-0.4362664222717285,
0.04334099218249321,
-0.5389010310173035,
0.13288183510303497,
0.5327593088150024,
1.2078486680984497,
-0.9621172547340393,
0.6111433506011963,
0.6918547749519348,
-0.20608635246753693,
-0.7492793202400208,
-0.22019779682159424,
-0.00990958884358406,
-0.7321357131004333,
1.095733642578125,
0.19384226202964783,
-0.09901607781648636,
-0.1857997626066208,
-0.6364672183990479,
-0.708544135093689,
1.1485295295715332,
0.4770701825618744,
-0.6224754452705383,
-0.5025065541267395,
0.4208217263221741,
0.5482454895973206,
0.0007111172308214009,
0.12356016039848328,
0.30423790216445923,
0.16447825729846954,
0.18208476901054382,
-0.8430272936820984,
-0.2651914358139038,
-0.15883900225162506,
-0.17356254160404205,
0.42169931530952454,
-0.28096216917037964,
0.39385145902633667,
-0.31904420256614685,
-0.2463620901107788,
-0.022514719516038895,
1.0262659788131714,
0.7422683238983154,
0.7744511961936951,
0.5546018481254578,
0.5185239911079407,
0.616474986076355,
-0.11392593383789062,
0.590237557888031,
0.04878411069512367,
0.13831675052642822,
1.2086246013641357,
-0.06530702114105225,
0.8567802906036377,
0.7888261079788208,
-0.052691277116537094,
0.4495006203651428,
0.6977540850639343,
0.3312293589115143,
0.6392909288406372,
-0.12064094096422195,
-0.3663148880004883,
-0.2818022668361664,
-0.273627370595932,
-0.3206217885017395,
0.2507396638393402,
0.3718039393424988,
-0.13439315557479858,
-0.5686405897140503,
0.08277465403079987,
-0.24911250174045563,
0.3780781924724579,
-0.6491368412971497,
0.6518375277519226,
-0.01447078213095665,
-0.6248776912689209,
0.23796586692333221,
-0.5203090310096741,
0.5607118606567383,
-0.8969228863716125,
-0.23088295757770538,
-0.1498793661594391,
0.009201675653457642,
-0.06815558671951294,
-1.070593237876892,
0.22167494893074036,
0.21567650139331818,
-0.2033456712961197,
-0.7896188497543335,
0.45736706256866455,
-0.7011247277259827,
-0.14047566056251526,
0.15768353641033173,
0.5268609523773193,
-0.024515165016055107,
0.03885842114686966,
-0.7690906524658203,
-0.005340417381376028,
-0.2260468453168869,
-0.009559313766658306,
0.1597926765680313,
0.7298912405967712,
-0.041290875524282455,
0.8003329038619995,
0.37136608362197876,
0.17477428913116455,
-0.1465313732624054,
0.5008598566055298,
0.6525158286094666,
-1.0295424461364746,
-0.8511015176773071,
-0.8808348178863525,
0.5176421403884888,
0.15168137848377228,
-0.24519264698028564,
0.47338664531707764,
0.3349345326423645,
0.7987828254699707,
-0.03205863758921623,
0.3745162785053253,
0.16491909325122833,
0.3382675349712372,
-1.1345226764678955,
0.20721447467803955,
-0.41677340865135193,
0.29793721437454224,
-0.3287673592567444,
-0.699325442314148,
-0.59916752576828,
0.34712299704551697,
-0.28740131855010986,
0.001729192677885294,
0.8576521873474121,
0.443549245595932,
0.07166043668985367,
-0.16178692877292633,
0.06322424858808517,
-0.0027434516232460737,
0.6088338494300842,
0.8936303853988647,
1.082147240638733,
0.005248249974101782,
0.55357426404953,
-0.2223254144191742,
-0.12197452783584595,
0.16323502361774445,
-1.2288264036178589,
-0.9492044448852539,
-0.6949748396873474,
-0.016277961432933807,
-0.053293656557798386,
0.14700904488563538,
1.1842819452285767,
0.45100757479667664,
-0.30539464950561523,
-0.21742676198482513,
-0.20400261878967285,
-0.07127116620540619,
-0.20765943825244904,
-0.21052633225917816,
0.5006715059280396,
-0.3999839425086975,
-0.6657927632331848,
0.6720629334449768,
0.27058637142181396,
0.27065184712409973,
-0.08156835287809372,
-0.10037154704332352,
0.08158789575099945,
-0.5655540823936462,
0.8327764868736267,
0.6391565203666687,
-0.5209444165229797,
-0.2676202356815338,
0.35020768642425537,
0.10419576615095139,
-0.05986521765589714,
1.0851619243621826,
-0.9427956342697144,
0.3396371006965637,
0.7155930995941162,
0.7991135120391846,
0.48509564995765686,
0.030604124069213867,
0.6818720698356628,
-1.0908938646316528,
0.5185746550559998,
0.3121813237667084,
0.45810651779174805,
0.2294410914182663,
-0.4237116575241089,
0.27029210329055786,
0.2217588871717453,
-0.5729115009307861,
-0.6907123327255249,
0.5606773495674133,
-1.3634525537490845,
-0.37315186858177185,
1.060431957244873,
0.24644161760807037,
-0.2950648367404938,
0.041138987988233566,
-0.32401031255722046,
0.13584370911121368,
-0.5047964453697205,
0.4760371446609497,
0.3204523026943207,
0.02703901380300522,
-0.5981781482696533,
-0.5289776921272278,
0.44579026103019714,
0.5863240361213684,
-0.6481648683547974,
0.0026292679831385612,
0.7755175232887268,
0.12588132917881012,
-0.12978485226631165,
0.6345576643943787,
0.19875773787498474,
0.5665867924690247,
-0.4125550091266632,
-0.30199024081230164,
-0.22764933109283447,
-0.7591211199760437,
-0.8133081793785095,
0.21753796935081482,
-0.08759309351444244,
-0.057384323328733444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16048v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16048v1
|
LLMs with Chain-of-Thought Are Non-Causal Reasoners
| 2024-02-25T10:13:04 | 2024-02-25T10:13:04 |
Guangsheng Bao, Hongbo Zhang, Linyi Yang, Cunxiang Wang, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper explores the role of the Chain of Thought (CoT) in Large Language
Models (LLMs) reasoning. Despite its potential to improve task performance, our
analysis reveals a surprising frequency of correct answers following incorrect
CoTs and vice versa. We employ causal analysis to assess the cause-effect
relationship between CoTs/instructions and answers in LLMs, uncovering the
Structural Causal Model (SCM) that LLMs approximate. By comparing the implied
SCM with that of human reasoning, we highlight discrepancies between LLM and
human reasoning processes. We further examine the factors influencing the
causal structure of the implied SCM, revealing that in-context learning,
supervised fine-tuning, and reinforcement learning on human feedback
significantly impact the causal relations. We release the code and results at
https://github.com/StevenZHB/CoT_Causal_Analysis.
|
[
-0.2102871984243393,
-1.0576903820037842,
0.9886159300804138,
0.13652706146240234,
-0.19731804728507996,
0.0485881045460701,
-0.16609066724777222,
-0.5787333846092224,
0.11896409839391708,
0.6284266710281372,
-0.4948345124721527,
-0.17546646296977997,
-0.661436915397644,
0.12263592332601547,
-0.44088858366012573,
0.8376479744911194,
-0.2515982687473297,
0.04466184973716736,
-0.3094024360179901,
0.06638321280479431,
-0.5601488947868347,
-0.5820406675338745,
-0.9131694436073303,
-0.48574480414390564,
1.0019018650054932,
0.15049894154071808,
0.5405410528182983,
0.45780420303344727,
0.29705262184143066,
0.27194443345069885,
-0.20727840065956116,
0.3273285925388336,
-0.5660169720649719,
0.15926964581012726,
-0.7398291230201721,
-0.804619550704956,
-0.4923645555973053,
-0.10190053284168243,
0.5365049839019775,
0.767552375793457,
0.06523710489273071,
0.2745625674724579,
0.05205747112631798,
0.9728796482086182,
-0.7853565216064453,
-0.0406884104013443,
-0.6704756617546082,
-0.2481318861246109,
0.058543961495161057,
-0.532641589641571,
-0.7231592535972595,
-0.2524793744087219,
0.09909448027610779,
-0.20337262749671936,
0.14911195635795593,
0.3877682685852051,
0.5240017771720886,
0.34598520398139954,
-0.8001170754432678,
-0.40175727009773254,
-0.8098260164260864,
0.6313480734825134,
-0.5833187103271484,
0.36432287096977234,
0.36624523997306824,
-0.09462615847587585,
-0.7753944993019104,
-0.4439374506473541,
-0.6077036261558533,
-0.2652673125267029,
-0.038114797323942184,
-0.02564050443470478,
0.028998326510190964,
0.30383551120758057,
0.36770322918891907,
0.211100772023201,
-0.30007967352867126,
0.22436462342739105,
-0.44002005457878113,
0.004484233446419239,
0.6402035355567932,
0.2856960594654083,
0.3293803334236145,
0.02586081437766552,
-0.6446885466575623,
0.21431748569011688,
-1.111201524734497,
-0.023675894364714622,
0.26039135456085205,
0.16688814759254456,
-0.19339671730995178,
0.5822323560714722,
0.05415688455104828,
0.9652288556098938,
0.0602576844394207,
-0.16068458557128906,
-0.27079087495803833,
-0.14015555381774902,
-0.5092800259590149,
0.3579808175563812,
0.6882073283195496,
0.16829465329647064,
0.298774391412735,
-0.28861793875694275,
-0.14652515947818756,
0.281032532453537,
0.3943491280078888,
-0.3087526261806488,
-0.00045127098564989865,
0.19904980063438416,
-0.32153600454330444,
-0.22840440273284912,
0.13013464212417603,
-0.38387036323547363,
-0.2928941547870636,
-0.564395546913147,
0.2271878868341446,
0.0551084503531456,
-0.12540167570114136,
0.12926262617111206,
-0.1242489442229271,
0.17860642075538635,
0.31632253527641296,
-0.5147241353988647,
0.5325726270675659,
0.610684335231781,
0.6383700370788574,
-0.1418551802635193,
-0.31577056646347046,
-0.5234039425849915,
0.39478179812431335,
-0.7568723559379578,
0.8922993540763855,
-0.2558562159538269,
-0.15177562832832336,
-0.19355769455432892,
0.094422347843647,
-0.2199734002351761,
-0.3149978518486023,
0.3753091096878052,
-0.6466967463493347,
0.0647534504532814,
-0.7300893068313599,
-0.6937010288238525,
-0.16731971502304077,
0.2134651243686676,
-0.7119699716567993,
0.9050430655479431,
-0.23662875592708588,
-0.8765150308609009,
0.32231876254081726,
-0.40365344285964966,
-0.49223458766937256,
-0.19910301268100739,
-0.4611595869064331,
-0.048126671463251114,
0.36536821722984314,
-0.07736636698246002,
0.31028005480766296,
-0.8335155844688416,
0.7316756844520569,
-0.4727671146392822,
-0.46334269642829895,
0.6605827808380127,
-0.48600342869758606,
0.6633457541465759,
0.09894964098930359,
-0.6085935831069946,
0.4105885326862335,
-0.576159656047821,
-0.15080048143863678,
0.01595684513449669,
-0.23528730869293213,
-0.3605429232120514,
0.4184178113937378,
-0.3856006860733032,
0.7462536692619324,
-0.010129154659807682,
-0.302117258310318,
0.13138090074062347,
-0.2577569782733917,
0.32255756855010986,
1.1001930236816406,
0.2983960509300232,
0.3073565363883972,
-0.36392492055892944,
0.3461630940437317,
0.08184539526700974,
0.1541844755411148,
0.31363752484321594,
-0.43304333090782166,
-0.9084952473640442,
-0.006806253921240568,
-0.14262299239635468,
0.29708045721054077,
-0.788288414478302,
0.21750935912132263,
0.06761817634105682,
-0.20037178695201874,
-0.014858233742415905,
0.14824625849723816,
0.6868033409118652,
0.48117905855178833,
0.23433008790016174,
-0.16256335377693176,
-0.6117962002754211,
-0.7659977674484253,
-0.3936119079589844,
-0.5477797389030457,
0.26671358942985535,
0.07339068502187729,
0.62516188621521,
-0.23545418679714203,
0.7652058601379395,
-0.5298718810081482,
0.05360574275255203,
-0.2688978314399719,
-0.020171433687210083,
0.20914006233215332,
0.1642332524061203,
0.14615271985530853,
-0.4309130311012268,
0.061749596148729324,
-0.2402419000864029,
-0.8451083302497864,
-0.0864642858505249,
-0.263597697019577,
-0.4176630973815918,
0.38451457023620605,
0.7937936782836914,
-0.5615358352661133,
0.4235071539878845,
0.30799296498298645,
-0.49511075019836426,
0.8580176830291748,
-0.3569965958595276,
0.006337219849228859,
-0.8352136611938477,
0.016776710748672485,
-0.02888333424925804,
-0.03953488543629646,
-0.40793752670288086,
-0.045955903828144073,
-0.15725299715995789,
0.2822123169898987,
-0.5022717714309692,
0.38230574131011963,
-0.4834931492805481,
-0.30312609672546387,
-0.41356515884399414,
0.5201265215873718,
-0.06917872279882431,
0.6556196212768555,
-0.053510770201683044,
0.7252783179283142,
0.4581133723258972,
-0.889778196811676,
0.11948065459728241,
-0.030674325302243233,
-0.2756515443325043,
0.41522496938705444,
-0.7125468850135803,
0.1472061276435852,
-0.16131746768951416,
0.44252732396125793,
-1.1070572137832642,
-0.01052179653197527,
0.11109296977519989,
-0.09637284278869629,
0.01710446923971176,
0.1691100150346756,
-0.7880060076713562,
-0.5621885061264038,
-0.1573689877986908,
0.3473187983036041,
0.06337858736515045,
-0.6410576105117798,
0.28726476430892944,
0.376956969499588,
0.30148443579673767,
-0.4390946924686432,
-0.6347278952598572,
-0.10516916960477829,
-0.10299292951822281,
-0.4359881281852722,
0.13414211571216583,
0.14031867682933807,
-0.5553876161575317,
-0.011961963027715683,
-0.5298569202423096,
-0.044185515493154526,
0.18592484295368195,
0.3260428011417389,
0.4683968424797058,
-0.12420890480279922,
0.5683016777038574,
-0.019024984911084175,
-0.0006932637770660222,
0.6265050172805786,
-0.3531794548034668,
0.4405825436115265,
-0.1743992120027542,
-0.25791314244270325,
-0.2939258813858032,
-0.01007916685193777,
0.7157565951347351,
0.06409142911434174,
0.9816439747810364,
-0.043656591325998306,
-0.13749819993972778,
-0.2532542049884796,
-0.6146697402000427,
-0.03558725491166115,
-0.4207669198513031,
0.0528239868581295,
-0.3233979046344757,
-1.0112476348876953,
0.48582005500793457,
-0.2232263684272766,
-0.38041597604751587,
0.5426348447799683,
0.6346123218536377,
-0.224916011095047,
0.8496575951576233,
0.39208096265792847,
-0.21636062860488892,
0.319136381149292,
-0.23873090744018555,
0.45349329710006714,
-1.1526145935058594,
-0.3345021605491638,
-0.28133058547973633,
-0.28327926993370056,
-0.8290521502494812,
-0.4859459400177002,
0.27873939275741577,
0.44262954592704773,
-0.5827950835227966,
0.29351434111595154,
-0.21169742941856384,
0.5431374907493591,
0.22290633618831635,
0.3338400721549988,
0.2427346408367157,
-0.4910462498664856,
-0.3638785183429718,
0.6979005336761475,
-0.9490779042243958,
-0.6405550241470337,
0.8755275011062622,
0.2058219313621521,
1.0320377349853516,
0.11049039661884308,
0.511756956577301,
0.13534489274024963,
0.11507309228181839,
-0.4587586522102356,
0.6532589197158813,
0.20861981809139252,
-0.703864574432373,
-0.22611525654792786,
-0.4699368476867676,
-0.9995461106300354,
0.3023475408554077,
-0.17271818220615387,
-1.0011975765228271,
0.27404874563217163,
0.1497487872838974,
-0.06325958669185638,
0.5275968909263611,
-0.6008513569831848,
0.5731897354125977,
-0.3563551902770996,
-0.7923256754875183,
-0.44823652505874634,
-0.7598903775215149,
0.6560273170471191,
0.09605087339878082,
0.2398390769958496,
0.060158561915159225,
0.17399048805236816,
0.9069626927375793,
-0.516547441482544,
1.1217756271362305,
0.20779633522033691,
-0.37838587164878845,
0.6620417833328247,
0.05405742675065994,
0.6582247614860535,
-0.04020695760846138,
0.11122773587703705,
0.09332020580768585,
-0.08928133547306061,
-0.3977246582508087,
-0.6613501310348511,
0.9431386590003967,
-0.7386876344680786,
-0.956316351890564,
-0.5273330807685852,
-0.5100080966949463,
-0.23922263085842133,
-0.07751617580652237,
0.028249353170394897,
0.4449058175086975,
-0.013128655031323433,
-0.16189970076084137,
0.6815776228904724,
-0.28792619705200195,
0.37550023198127747,
0.369767963886261,
-0.2734338343143463,
-0.20819850265979767,
0.37057432532310486,
0.04860246181488037,
0.6379914283752441,
0.4848199784755707,
0.28788357973098755,
-0.24245235323905945,
-0.13197438418865204,
-0.15075521171092987,
0.45391443371772766,
-0.8972849249839783,
-0.1465531289577484,
-0.499326229095459,
-0.07650937139987946,
0.0017716664588078856,
-0.26006221771240234,
-0.1994074136018753,
-0.21524633467197418,
-0.08956611901521683,
-0.45110341906547546,
0.28348982334136963,
1.0993257761001587,
0.22599731385707855,
0.1474132090806961,
-0.378788024187088,
0.29463520646095276,
0.328835129737854,
0.3476305603981018,
0.5129944682121277,
-0.025961847975850105,
-0.30651625990867615,
-0.005507494788616896,
-0.5449082255363464,
-0.9220478534698486,
-0.12132678925991058,
-0.4164705276489258,
0.5974341034889221,
0.4861675202846527,
0.06913210451602936,
0.9855162501335144,
-0.4808341860771179,
0.791904628276825,
0.4198419749736786,
-1.1147348880767822,
0.6455127000808716,
-0.1599978506565094,
0.3348810374736786,
0.20991429686546326,
0.27893704175949097,
-0.4648202657699585,
-0.7481547594070435,
-0.6117982864379883,
-0.795505166053772,
0.6166963577270508,
0.16351935267448425,
-0.45522341132164,
-0.6379580497741699,
0.42214497923851013,
-0.18849974870681763,
-0.07893586158752441,
-0.687557578086853,
-0.2405156046152115,
0.5046078562736511,
0.234788715839386,
-0.058242473751306534,
-0.5068790912628174,
0.027639921754598618,
-0.3016834259033203,
0.6997008919715881,
0.004490302875638008,
0.360278844833374,
0.5857541561126709,
-0.325728178024292,
-0.6041516065597534,
0.35748809576034546,
0.8928120136260986,
1.131330966949463,
-0.0246113371104002,
0.5639556646347046,
0.4390549659729004,
0.07780522108078003,
0.2014942169189453,
-0.7131936550140381,
0.2546316981315613,
-0.3508615493774414,
0.8239496946334839,
0.96031254529953,
0.5874788165092468,
-0.5823266506195068,
0.3580944836139679,
0.06828497350215912,
-0.09067826718091965,
-0.27969011664390564,
0.2530016303062439,
0.14854030311107635,
0.33411070704460144,
0.17575983703136444,
0.15960858762264252,
0.0544816255569458,
-0.796183705329895,
0.13780789077281952,
0.3590984046459198,
-0.5013338327407837,
-0.36545267701148987,
0.7206563949584961,
0.015968916937708855,
-0.2988053858280182,
0.4669179618358612,
0.09288714826107025,
-0.6867817640304565,
0.7640771269798279,
0.8488574624061584,
0.8005410432815552,
-0.10786497592926025,
0.16375401616096497,
0.30121123790740967,
0.48579704761505127,
-0.20167629420757294,
0.3456902503967285,
-0.11563294380903244,
-0.596463680267334,
-0.8578558564186096,
-0.34507742524147034,
-0.2475527673959732,
-0.09259648621082306,
-0.7143740057945251,
0.30939504504203796,
-0.4281823933124542,
-0.16665136814117432,
-0.2958047091960907,
-0.16380256414413452,
-0.5779975652694702,
0.3325859606266022,
0.09589780122041702,
0.7131667733192444,
-0.8825125694274902,
0.9738734364509583,
0.28874891996383667,
-0.5707826018333435,
-0.9835427403450012,
0.1592118740081787,
-0.17432980239391327,
-0.6042959690093994,
1.1172943115234375,
0.05178305134177208,
-0.7017388343811035,
-0.29122763872146606,
-0.46929463744163513,
-0.9942291975021362,
1.0714396238327026,
0.3518177568912506,
-0.8104284405708313,
0.004547384101897478,
0.062252476811409,
0.7163959741592407,
-0.31430041790008545,
0.21647335588932037,
0.40675514936447144,
0.14351055026054382,
0.10413040965795517,
-0.8337490558624268,
0.44011807441711426,
0.19986113905906677,
0.2038612812757492,
0.5956310629844666,
-0.5503199100494385,
0.7193765044212341,
-0.5526300668716431,
-0.20416727662086487,
-0.20657575130462646,
0.42830607295036316,
0.47522059082984924,
0.27913978695869446,
0.450598806142807,
0.47487494349479675,
0.8915429711341858,
0.20284484326839447,
1.3895678520202637,
-0.2252768874168396,
0.2889742851257324,
1.3678746223449707,
-0.36510923504829407,
0.8085029721260071,
0.8859700560569763,
-0.303841769695282,
0.9619079232215881,
0.5272589325904846,
0.5062859058380127,
0.5122602581977844,
0.6120522022247314,
-0.12367410957813263,
-0.2733252942562103,
0.15999862551689148,
-0.1366618275642395,
0.2463509887456894,
0.2958877384662628,
-0.4935091435909271,
-0.013239080086350441,
-0.2687917947769165,
-0.0678941011428833,
-0.019271790981292725,
-0.500253438949585,
0.8299955129623413,
0.36494743824005127,
-0.7477751970291138,
0.6675367951393127,
-0.1907379925251007,
0.23582150042057037,
-0.341933935880661,
0.0995807871222496,
0.1324111819267273,
0.24425175786018372,
-0.2549181282520294,
-0.640195369720459,
0.5216834545135498,
-0.09974830597639084,
-0.40413662791252136,
-0.07564821094274521,
0.7682785391807556,
-0.2294931262731552,
-0.3947654664516449,
0.7610844373703003,
0.5110467672348022,
0.015244467183947563,
0.16860519349575043,
-0.3830811083316803,
0.001785736414603889,
-0.3443927466869354,
-0.17686031758785248,
0.2715975046157837,
0.5380129218101501,
-0.5845060348510742,
0.7491352558135986,
0.7177272439002991,
0.10124624520540237,
0.04478251188993454,
0.12770429253578186,
1.0161972045898438,
-0.9288272857666016,
-0.41057640314102173,
-1.390907645225525,
0.29546797275543213,
-0.017849795520305634,
-0.2144375592470169,
0.6997033357620239,
0.4066118001937866,
0.79694002866745,
-0.06345681846141815,
0.40155839920043945,
0.1407472789287567,
0.0093724075704813,
-0.7339277863502502,
0.5194782614707947,
-0.33230772614479065,
0.5405527949333191,
-0.5097206830978394,
-0.7963868975639343,
-0.24364955723285675,
0.3737797737121582,
-0.8597838282585144,
-0.24385268986225128,
1.4126055240631104,
0.5707138180732727,
0.3120264410972595,
0.24594737589359283,
0.29699379205703735,
0.45462629199028015,
0.31718650460243225,
0.6808972954750061,
1.0538493394851685,
-0.34186458587646484,
-0.006244473159313202,
0.16584068536758423,
-0.1617952585220337,
0.016574349254369736,
-0.850264310836792,
-1.1883310079574585,
-0.5769402980804443,
-0.33628585934638977,
-0.28465431928634644,
0.21818430721759796,
1.0161041021347046,
0.3624401390552521,
-0.7140554189682007,
-0.5969242453575134,
-0.7813284993171692,
0.7974346876144409,
-0.3566872775554657,
-0.21045944094657898,
0.45916780829429626,
-0.6386997699737549,
0.053583625704050064,
0.22189687192440033,
0.39643794298171997,
-0.4600900113582611,
-0.13963598012924194,
-0.12535738945007324,
-0.7045634388923645,
0.39433038234710693,
1.0691843032836914,
-0.12941601872444153,
-1.1271892786026,
-0.4044570028781891,
-0.17032364010810852,
-0.0363190732896328,
-0.1039884015917778,
1.1439095735549927,
-0.7957556247711182,
0.3005864918231964,
0.35245993733406067,
0.3065700829029083,
0.4751063585281372,
-0.32072877883911133,
0.6887044906616211,
-0.5597198009490967,
0.049941614270210266,
-0.202039897441864,
0.5965366363525391,
-0.035591088235378265,
-0.6559243202209473,
0.44633781909942627,
0.1668071746826172,
-0.7152261734008789,
-0.7063315510749817,
0.3898400664329529,
-0.8773325681686401,
-0.5603739023208618,
1.235588788986206,
-0.00023713942209724337,
-0.6027824282646179,
-0.11097810417413712,
-0.26898980140686035,
0.39661097526550293,
-0.04605789855122566,
0.8811389207839966,
0.7593896389007568,
-0.40146657824516296,
0.02243296056985855,
-0.2736498713493347,
0.2511383295059204,
0.10801403969526291,
-0.8585627675056458,
0.09123033285140991,
0.41758719086647034,
0.28057610988616943,
-0.019412454217672348,
0.7258138060569763,
-0.044510021805763245,
0.1680356115102768,
-0.15078288316726685,
-0.05548403412103653,
0.29149943590164185,
-0.5078073143959045,
-0.04073399677872658,
-0.039519067853689194,
0.21436333656311035,
-0.03264816850423813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16041v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16041v2
|
Detecting Machine-Generated Texts by Multi-Population Aware Optimization for Maximum Mean Discrepancy
| 2024-02-25T09:44:56 | 2024-02-29T14:46:44 |
Shuhai Zhang, Yiliao Song, Jiahao Yang, Yuanqing Li, Bo Han, Mingkui Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have exhibited remarkable
performance in generating human-like texts. However, machine-generated texts
(MGTs) may carry critical risks, such as plagiarism issues, misleading
information, or hallucination issues. Therefore, it is very urgent and
important to detect MGTs in many situations. Unfortunately, it is challenging
to distinguish MGTs and human-written texts because the distributional
discrepancy between them is often very subtle due to the remarkable performance
of LLMs. In this paper, we seek to exploit \textit{maximum mean discrepancy}
(MMD) to address this issue in the sense that MMD can well identify
distributional discrepancies. However, directly training a detector with MMD
using diverse MGTs will incur a significantly increased variance of MMD since
MGTs may contain \textit{multiple text populations} due to various LLMs. This
will severely impair MMD's ability to measure the difference between two
samples. To tackle this, we propose a novel \textit{multi-population} aware
optimization method for MMD called MMD-MP, which can \textit{avoid variance
increases} and thus improve the stability to measure the distributional
discrepancy. Relying on MMD-MP, we develop two methods for paragraph-based and
sentence-based detection, respectively. Extensive experiments on various LLMs,
\eg, GPT2 and ChatGPT, show superior detection performance of our MMD-MP. The
source code is available at \url{https://github.com/ZSHsh98/MMD-MP}.
|
[
-0.5986981987953186,
-0.804054856300354,
0.37482455372810364,
0.32605111598968506,
-0.26556557416915894,
0.16736388206481934,
-0.2062145322561264,
-0.08254554867744446,
0.14778366684913635,
0.4348125457763672,
-0.7134741544723511,
-0.5483262538909912,
-0.6842857003211975,
0.35483992099761963,
-0.14792099595069885,
0.7729792594909668,
-0.08815674483776093,
-0.23642697930335999,
-0.1539592295885086,
-0.24542386829853058,
-0.4158991277217865,
-0.6464975476264954,
-0.5279757380485535,
-0.13716697692871094,
0.29520392417907715,
0.36018282175064087,
0.4172828793525696,
0.7532627582550049,
0.43993714451789856,
0.33577337861061096,
0.020053835585713387,
0.9864456057548523,
-0.5525267124176025,
0.19489015638828278,
0.28056561946868896,
-0.22064702212810516,
-0.0773717612028122,
-0.06052757054567337,
0.7658607363700867,
0.11272956430912018,
-0.30833399295806885,
-0.0955287516117096,
0.1492590606212616,
0.5890412330627441,
-0.83840411901474,
0.14199776947498322,
-0.8030681014060974,
0.12747064232826233,
-0.3909224271774292,
-0.45176973938941956,
-0.5869554877281189,
-0.22782321274280548,
-0.1993790566921234,
-0.523350179195404,
0.5421398282051086,
-0.008142830803990364,
0.7256798148155212,
0.3955322802066803,
-0.37929007411003113,
-0.39835113286972046,
-0.6580918431282043,
1.0046377182006836,
-0.46813201904296875,
0.33023393154144287,
0.19006600975990295,
0.1720581203699112,
-0.5505852699279785,
-0.0922466367483139,
-0.8950212001800537,
-0.14532595872879028,
0.20662707090377808,
0.4003102779388428,
-0.33918043971061707,
-0.14300528168678284,
0.254129022359848,
0.13703112304210663,
-0.7571804523468018,
0.2598893344402313,
0.18884888291358948,
-0.38718557357788086,
0.43894851207733154,
0.12245155870914459,
0.11685969680547714,
-0.10734225064516068,
-0.3434821665287018,
-0.2986413836479187,
-0.5067630410194397,
-0.38609540462493896,
0.6631566286087036,
0.0569569393992424,
-0.11779860407114029,
0.5017012357711792,
0.07162182033061981,
0.41119974851608276,
-0.16041800379753113,
-0.15349699556827545,
0.5841739177703857,
-0.24635036289691925,
0.08210966736078262,
-0.3376637101173401,
0.9235571026802063,
0.4461198151111603,
0.4776509404182434,
0.23606443405151367,
-0.27109476923942566,
0.3190447688102722,
-0.25306838750839233,
-0.699559211730957,
-0.14110003411769867,
0.07536129653453827,
-0.4824374318122864,
-0.3528992831707001,
0.034480348229408264,
-1.1531641483306885,
-0.8107254505157471,
-0.07678759843111038,
0.14207755029201508,
-0.3347877860069275,
-0.5486423969268799,
0.25080177187919617,
-0.18383091688156128,
-0.18468673527240753,
0.08893653005361557,
-1.0307492017745972,
-0.06923078745603561,
0.46173226833343506,
0.9163779020309448,
-0.19325923919677734,
-0.3259972333908081,
-0.5229784846305847,
0.12541478872299194,
-0.2759875953197479,
1.1757564544677734,
-0.29469120502471924,
-0.4949547350406647,
-0.024717073887586594,
-0.5140852332115173,
-0.3381462097167969,
-0.8732032775878906,
0.7391682267189026,
-0.12222525477409363,
0.20186948776245117,
-0.014932624995708466,
-0.6046687960624695,
0.2782013416290283,
0.41141435503959656,
-0.7809980511665344,
1.1876614093780518,
0.0057549141347408295,
-1.0809959173202515,
0.5858064293861389,
-0.723110556602478,
-0.2377440333366394,
-0.3078595995903015,
-0.2626131474971771,
-1.064034342765808,
-0.0022162359673529863,
0.7191454172134399,
0.4611709713935852,
-0.09155242145061493,
0.26058441400527954,
-0.49834397435188293,
-0.22428077459335327,
0.5710314512252808,
-0.9803091287612915,
0.5914298295974731,
0.23004020750522614,
-0.09920085221529007,
0.051925480365753174,
-0.8994159698486328,
-0.2894292175769806,
0.14211344718933105,
-0.46479281783103943,
-0.27400991320610046,
0.40441420674324036,
0.07547054439783096,
0.13422784209251404,
0.07623142749071121,
-0.4267498850822449,
0.10358783602714539,
-0.1231120377779007,
0.18434792757034302,
1.0114836692810059,
0.1281203329563141,
0.09135778248310089,
-0.4770532250404358,
0.3893452286720276,
0.2939441204071045,
0.05076396092772484,
-0.2535547614097595,
-0.4652613401412964,
-0.6347390413284302,
-0.6091958284378052,
0.10983939468860626,
0.739874541759491,
-0.9149083495140076,
0.6887007355690002,
-0.10890286415815353,
-0.2817869782447815,
-0.3894217312335968,
0.14236752688884735,
0.1846114546060562,
0.21294575929641724,
0.2792559564113617,
-0.012138879857957363,
-0.6704548001289368,
-0.7362051606178284,
-0.30906054377555847,
-0.25086885690689087,
-0.15212774276733398,
0.11482881009578705,
0.36815589666366577,
-0.27255603671073914,
0.9176526665687561,
-0.9442412257194519,
-0.4444510340690613,
-0.19646185636520386,
0.2285386025905609,
0.051790449768304825,
0.3593600392341614,
0.4596969187259674,
-0.8860480785369873,
-0.478208065032959,
-0.0904761254787445,
-0.7011390328407288,
-0.5925704836845398,
-0.4611172378063202,
-0.1503709852695465,
0.18902716040611267,
0.3997116982936859,
-0.770074725151062,
0.1364782452583313,
0.5130337476730347,
-0.06262259185314178,
1.017414927482605,
-0.45454156398773193,
0.05016763135790825,
-1.248084306716919,
-0.2310403734445572,
0.4178014099597931,
-0.05887991562485695,
-0.6194312572479248,
-0.039431918412446976,
0.22325654327869415,
0.1867130994796753,
-0.1740662008523941,
0.3359037935733795,
-0.5217110514640808,
0.03859426826238632,
-0.34351691603660583,
0.21586060523986816,
-0.24893534183502197,
0.2981035113334656,
-0.2027541697025299,
1.025625228881836,
0.23895977437496185,
-0.45791569352149963,
0.17862895131111145,
0.14216996729373932,
-0.06585273891687393,
0.726130485534668,
-0.10897152870893478,
0.03366929292678833,
-0.26590514183044434,
0.37395748496055603,
-0.8435608148574829,
-0.06477245688438416,
0.33872509002685547,
-0.6760724186897278,
0.046409595757722855,
0.1254858672618866,
-0.9283861517906189,
-0.5618399381637573,
-0.5307456254959106,
-0.02247833088040352,
0.1607523113489151,
-0.6379167437553406,
0.4426860511302948,
0.38668203353881836,
0.16676969826221466,
-0.7412833571434021,
-0.40787434577941895,
0.004812745843082666,
-0.38880372047424316,
-0.7513226270675659,
0.08211031556129456,
-0.3259579539299011,
-0.07841000705957413,
-0.5245538949966431,
-0.06851527839899063,
-0.24976570904254913,
-0.08957716822624207,
-0.1450822353363037,
0.26000329852104187,
-0.12502209842205048,
0.28572091460227966,
0.16657891869544983,
-0.4302850663661957,
-0.1324351578950882,
-0.2966778874397278,
0.8207767009735107,
0.1375986933708191,
-0.48746082186698914,
-0.28523144125938416,
0.4597983658313751,
0.6742010712623596,
-0.44029751420021057,
0.8241770267486572,
0.9799004793167114,
-0.2674250304698944,
-0.3131115436553955,
-0.7476295232772827,
0.007985152304172516,
-0.5138041973114014,
0.5312166213989258,
-0.46299612522125244,
-0.7544997930526733,
0.5809574723243713,
-0.10325874388217926,
0.0034860894083976746,
0.3576472997665405,
0.7296358942985535,
0.14670899510383606,
1.2047815322875977,
0.376107782125473,
-0.24358190596103668,
0.621415913105011,
-0.057445086538791656,
0.017458150163292885,
-0.7262208461761475,
0.09560611844062805,
-0.6416582465171814,
-0.009035681374371052,
-0.7327715158462524,
-0.5508046746253967,
0.4050760567188263,
-0.13211268186569214,
-0.10643032938241959,
0.08810785412788391,
-0.5721201300621033,
0.7598771452903748,
0.5541123151779175,
0.24880830943584442,
0.45425480604171753,
-0.010449769906699657,
-0.24969623982906342,
-0.13993464410305023,
-0.35063448548316956,
-0.44774705171585083,
1.2426860332489014,
0.09298130869865417,
0.6134698987007141,
0.167822927236557,
0.8193021416664124,
0.2606962025165558,
0.2138233631849289,
-0.36971285939216614,
0.5631713271141052,
-0.49707990884780884,
-0.2360406368970871,
-0.06266877800226212,
-0.8105210661888123,
-1.0745031833648682,
0.713435709476471,
-0.32303956151008606,
-0.6783639192581177,
-0.040299754589796066,
0.1627436727285385,
0.14084720611572266,
0.4370408058166504,
-0.9833917021751404,
0.7458511590957642,
0.24036097526550293,
0.11316940933465958,
-0.15535074472427368,
-0.32635048031806946,
0.37853145599365234,
-0.337843120098114,
0.24308453500270844,
-0.2356874644756317,
-0.06440439820289612,
0.3675616979598999,
-0.08009090274572372,
0.593927264213562,
-0.31070923805236816,
-0.09690351039171219,
0.17079877853393555,
-0.13243690133094788,
0.7122160792350769,
-0.09352745860815048,
-0.051393281668424606,
-0.1500512957572937,
-0.38839784264564514,
-0.470051109790802,
-0.3412526845932007,
0.5211076140403748,
-0.7290759086608887,
-0.3211161494255066,
-0.20753617584705353,
-0.7251796126365662,
0.03452175110578537,
0.20650330185890198,
0.5160671472549438,
0.2239835113286972,
-0.23029258847236633,
-0.11756019294261932,
0.9166061282157898,
-0.31086695194244385,
0.5353610515594482,
0.3378480076789856,
-0.0578618124127388,
-0.3602747619152069,
0.9766497611999512,
-0.039083052426576614,
0.3362433910369873,
0.6011584401130676,
0.4231276214122772,
-0.4123806953430176,
-0.7608469128608704,
-0.7028917670249939,
0.08780085295438766,
-0.5688545107841492,
-0.149626225233078,
-0.7094272971153259,
-0.08049081265926361,
-0.22323687374591827,
0.055059030652046204,
-0.16184425354003906,
-0.0025680065155029297,
-0.5319036245346069,
0.08567464351654053,
0.05803924798965454,
0.13560575246810913,
-0.15723232924938202,
0.4578821659088135,
-0.8104402422904968,
0.47876134514808655,
-0.08639641106128693,
0.10289834439754486,
-0.18490730226039886,
-0.13472150266170502,
-0.041267115622758865,
0.09586388617753983,
-0.6389785408973694,
-0.9166308641433716,
0.5357182025909424,
0.18523408472537994,
0.5926186442375183,
0.7030255198478699,
0.1618383228778839,
0.5451028347015381,
-0.5130741596221924,
0.32714563608169556,
0.2593296468257904,
-0.8714425563812256,
0.3205174505710602,
-0.45396682620048523,
0.39275631308555603,
0.22098004817962646,
-0.08158860355615616,
-0.7294201254844666,
-0.8384546041488647,
-0.3496582806110382,
-0.5924180746078491,
0.410971075296402,
0.3996674418449402,
0.15488898754119873,
-0.20349758863449097,
-0.0780152827501297,
0.041745465248823166,
0.024909861385822296,
-0.8084497451782227,
-0.19506891071796417,
0.14610397815704346,
-0.5510134100914001,
0.1329932063817978,
-0.08484470844268799,
0.11690972745418549,
0.29174867272377014,
0.5591388940811157,
-0.23579418659210205,
0.5496389269828796,
0.0505044050514698,
-0.2001030445098877,
-0.03602711111307144,
0.2710508108139038,
0.8537466526031494,
0.4121359884738922,
-0.05980406701564789,
0.29198959469795227,
0.1437111794948578,
-0.8856257200241089,
0.3027152121067047,
0.35882043838500977,
-0.18123647570610046,
0.12431918829679489,
0.260836660861969,
0.4528968632221222,
-0.14263835549354553,
-0.777357280254364,
0.4973759949207306,
0.02332180179655552,
-0.24920134246349335,
-0.25612837076187134,
-0.03688410669565201,
0.05560951307415962,
0.27722445130348206,
0.545936107635498,
0.3717604875564575,
0.016906602308154106,
0.06135443598031998,
0.518274188041687,
0.483224481344223,
0.18323297798633575,
0.08069687336683273,
0.622042179107666,
0.04627182334661484,
-0.2037932574748993,
0.39288437366485596,
-0.4997313916683197,
-0.7280882000923157,
0.7495089769363403,
0.6545103788375854,
0.8067498207092285,
-0.42265745997428894,
0.28176695108413696,
0.11715531349182129,
0.42074844241142273,
-0.23770548403263092,
0.0751018300652504,
0.29080164432525635,
-1.197068452835083,
-0.45586395263671875,
-0.29581648111343384,
-0.19515661895275116,
0.11271738260984421,
-0.2573937773704529,
0.47063693404197693,
-0.2534480690956116,
-0.12903352081775665,
0.20543129742145538,
-0.0805099606513977,
-0.2634187340736389,
-0.22914603352546692,
0.03967900574207306,
0.4860231280326843,
-0.9026826620101929,
0.6264813542366028,
0.18477071821689606,
-0.10570327937602997,
-0.41369932889938354,
0.2923887073993683,
0.2831169366836548,
-0.7423437237739563,
0.013554949313402176,
0.4427931606769562,
-0.10381069034337997,
0.0395992137491703,
-0.24187210202217102,
-0.5056949853897095,
0.8852413892745972,
0.34620970487594604,
-0.5627167820930481,
0.30033013224601746,
0.14486883580684662,
0.34441009163856506,
-0.2367936223745346,
0.3015764057636261,
0.48570534586906433,
0.49894779920578003,
0.10017535090446472,
-0.6933380961418152,
-0.07883992791175842,
0.004682688973844051,
-0.03579559177160263,
0.7551891207695007,
-0.5912454724311829,
0.8714249730110168,
-0.07878051698207855,
-0.2958637475967407,
0.10343477129936218,
0.44108283519744873,
0.7543943524360657,
0.5740776062011719,
0.6680191159248352,
0.7161062955856323,
1.030565619468689,
-0.0507027842104435,
0.7597522735595703,
0.13641142845153809,
0.670955240726471,
0.7946279048919678,
-0.3016286790370941,
0.6908701062202454,
0.3538706302642822,
-0.3768690228462219,
-0.0247880220413208,
0.7494866251945496,
-0.2538285255432129,
0.4260692000389099,
0.5197466611862183,
-0.775553286075592,
-0.16060321033000946,
0.25940263271331787,
-0.3467774987220764,
0.22574101388454437,
0.31436461210250854,
-0.3665394186973572,
-0.35370317101478577,
0.10080448538064957,
0.2487708032131195,
0.26192936301231384,
-0.08498258143663406,
0.5068303942680359,
-0.24257615208625793,
-0.3780795931816101,
0.4980272352695465,
0.2509017884731293,
1.066940188407898,
-0.35989850759506226,
0.07431873679161072,
-0.2900457978248596,
0.5051509737968445,
0.03103741817176342,
-0.5274310111999512,
0.20561853051185608,
0.10434915870428085,
-0.31541532278060913,
0.042158156633377075,
0.8942542672157288,
-0.539700984954834,
-0.5811140537261963,
0.13079947233200073,
0.6339618563652039,
0.10600463300943375,
-0.2545827627182007,
-0.687295138835907,
0.038735728710889816,
0.267130047082901,
-0.06624745577573776,
0.3649694621562958,
0.6537449359893799,
-0.0976351797580719,
0.8907559514045715,
0.988673210144043,
0.15692926943302155,
0.14144055545330048,
0.25309640169143677,
0.6907846927642822,
-0.24294061958789825,
-0.7006230354309082,
-1.3541672229766846,
0.10348687320947647,
-0.38414084911346436,
-0.41194549202919006,
0.5092433094978333,
0.7873384952545166,
0.6014851331710815,
-0.20164978504180908,
0.7733005285263062,
0.16196976602077484,
0.6746832132339478,
-0.6033341884613037,
0.6982058882713318,
-0.14654168486595154,
0.47406530380249023,
-0.47408297657966614,
-1.2679164409637451,
-0.5945150256156921,
0.6719538569450378,
-0.008364318870007992,
-0.13348263502120972,
0.6811097264289856,
1.071528673171997,
-0.05661927908658981,
0.08527209609746933,
0.3113105893135071,
-0.017536522820591927,
0.7254536151885986,
0.6753267645835876,
0.8863586187362671,
-0.08366841822862625,
1.039824366569519,
0.22428540885448456,
-0.40850260853767395,
-0.14571376144886017,
-0.843114972114563,
-0.859864354133606,
-0.4759853184223175,
-0.22830191254615784,
-0.1557699590921402,
0.0552968829870224,
0.8753208518028259,
0.6402887105941772,
-0.5291433930397034,
-0.12321501970291138,
-0.24828751385211945,
0.298933744430542,
-0.3211771547794342,
-0.2800893783569336,
0.46188104152679443,
-0.11113124340772629,
-0.8334241509437561,
0.12300295382738113,
0.21213003993034363,
0.3181714415550232,
-0.23975437879562378,
-0.037206683307886124,
-0.22322092950344086,
0.12904766201972961,
0.48551124334335327,
-0.11608248203992844,
-0.43060821294784546,
-0.25042566657066345,
-0.2284674495458603,
-0.04824576526880264,
0.264914870262146,
0.8538045287132263,
-0.3627745807170868,
0.47289836406707764,
0.3302977979183197,
0.5909219980239868,
0.5746889710426331,
-0.010519691742956638,
0.36621320247650146,
-1.1608716249465942,
0.09631170332431793,
0.048988789319992065,
0.2738467752933502,
0.40805384516716003,
-0.38977932929992676,
0.43786555528640747,
0.5247967839241028,
-0.6808586120605469,
-0.7102323174476624,
0.35847601294517517,
-0.9008737206459045,
-0.2249506711959839,
1.0333764553070068,
-0.09398665279150009,
0.22731857001781464,
-0.10079190135002136,
-0.39082765579223633,
0.3919411599636078,
-0.680234432220459,
0.8922026753425598,
0.9372953772544861,
-0.06668545305728912,
-0.3201085329055786,
-0.8057852387428284,
0.19930638372898102,
0.15067103505134583,
-1.0496808290481567,
0.24483554065227509,
0.6242933869361877,
0.07879582792520523,
0.02395850047469139,
0.7429667711257935,
0.0394948273897171,
0.06834918260574341,
0.2170601785182953,
0.003466240130364895,
-0.006059744395315647,
0.02027401700615883,
-0.00180770771112293,
0.011863630264997482,
-0.30730900168418884,
-0.6605809926986694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16040v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16040v4
|
EHRNoteQA: An LLM Benchmark for Real-World Clinical Practice Using Discharge Summaries
| 2024-02-25T09:41:50 | 2024-06-27T04:28:12 |
Sunjun Kweon, Jiyoun Kim, Heeyoung Kwak, Dongchul Cha, Hangyul Yoon, Kwanghyun Kim, Jeewon Yang, Seunghyun Won, Edward Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Discharge summaries in Electronic Health Records (EHRs) are crucial for
clinical decision-making, but their length and complexity make information
extraction challenging, especially when dealing with accumulated summaries
across multiple patient admissions. Large Language Models (LLMs) show promise
in addressing this challenge by efficiently analyzing vast and complex data.
Existing benchmarks, however, fall short in properly evaluating LLMs'
capabilities in this context, as they typically focus on single-note
information or limited topics, failing to reflect the real-world inquiries
required by clinicians. To bridge this gap, we introduce EHRNoteQA, a novel
benchmark built on the MIMIC-IV EHR, comprising 962 different QA pairs each
linked to distinct patients' discharge summaries. Every QA pair is initially
generated using GPT-4 and then manually reviewed and refined by three
clinicians to ensure clinical relevance. EHRNoteQA includes questions that
require information across multiple discharge summaries and covers eight
diverse topics, mirroring the complexity and diversity of real clinical
inquiries. We offer EHRNoteQA in two formats: open-ended and multi-choice
question answering, and propose a reliable evaluation method for each. We
evaluate 27 LLMs using EHRNoteQA and examine various factors affecting the
model performance (e.g., the length and number of discharge summaries).
Furthermore, to validate EHRNoteQA as a reliable proxy for expert evaluations
in clinical practice, we measure the correlation between the LLM performance on
EHRNoteQA, and the LLM performance manually evaluated by clinicians. Results
show that LLM performance on EHRNoteQA have higher correlation with
clinician-evaluated performance (Spearman: 0.78, Kendall: 0.62) compared to
other benchmarks, demonstrating its practical relevance in evaluating LLMs in
clinical settings.
|
[
-0.2049371302127838,
-0.5469620823860168,
0.9711635708808899,
-0.0167482178658247,
-0.11262661963701248,
0.11858350783586502,
-0.03195701539516449,
-0.3987945020198822,
0.14606662094593048,
0.5771529674530029,
-0.27598533034324646,
-0.6691770553588867,
-0.5320419073104858,
0.15239886939525604,
-0.2464146763086319,
0.9800312519073486,
-0.17472867667675018,
0.19313274323940277,
-0.23443616926670074,
-0.35559457540512085,
-0.25498610734939575,
-0.49666982889175415,
-0.4838409125804901,
-0.25148090720176697,
0.5235897302627563,
0.2447015643119812,
0.3296336233615875,
0.42856112122535706,
0.7059955596923828,
0.252688467502594,
-0.16556964814662933,
0.31447988748550415,
-0.4140765964984894,
0.33182603120803833,
0.2989656627178192,
-0.45807865262031555,
-0.7451696395874023,
-0.2299160212278366,
0.8362606167793274,
0.5181918740272522,
-0.5588269233703613,
0.36794155836105347,
-0.1579928994178772,
0.61464524269104,
-0.7451326847076416,
-0.17338958382606506,
-0.39496129751205444,
0.16719481348991394,
-0.07140698283910751,
-0.020325828343629837,
-0.17861633002758026,
-0.6848465800285339,
0.2727696895599365,
-0.394510954618454,
0.1550610363483429,
0.0045397342182695866,
0.7798188328742981,
0.14690889418125153,
-0.41968318819999695,
-0.3015710413455963,
-0.5330100655555725,
0.5937678813934326,
-0.782585084438324,
0.48034414649009705,
0.16906008124351501,
0.6764148473739624,
0.09021661430597305,
-0.8691937327384949,
-0.3824078440666199,
-0.3853466212749481,
-0.11026766151189804,
0.5832102298736572,
-0.16566960513591766,
0.3242785632610321,
0.4854297637939453,
0.37825724482536316,
-0.6138547658920288,
0.08652794361114502,
-0.45919039845466614,
-0.10194437205791473,
0.48548462986946106,
0.559546172618866,
0.1871432065963745,
-0.25719934701919556,
-0.2601000666618347,
0.10024219006299973,
-0.6815378665924072,
-0.02069384604692459,
-0.008272695355117321,
-0.32185861468315125,
-0.26892033219337463,
0.5291301012039185,
-0.3165384531021118,
0.36246904730796814,
-0.08712170273065567,
-0.23376895487308502,
0.10969226062297821,
-0.01595439203083515,
-0.1357647031545639,
0.007786503992974758,
0.8277609348297119,
0.5847211480140686,
0.07560436427593231,
-0.10594536364078522,
-0.08893704414367676,
-0.2616307735443115,
0.3784215450286865,
-0.8381685018539429,
-0.3233962655067444,
0.6020323038101196,
-0.5311886072158813,
-0.11284051835536957,
0.045327141880989075,
-1.0840100049972534,
-0.2700961232185364,
-0.0044133891351521015,
0.33597445487976074,
-0.2343275547027588,
-0.1417199969291687,
-0.10886406898498535,
-0.04199280962347984,
0.10320257395505905,
0.516976535320282,
-0.49449610710144043,
0.695766270160675,
0.8739468455314636,
0.9544916749000549,
-0.34174230694770813,
-0.1932447999715805,
-0.8669641613960266,
-0.1440039724111557,
-0.3134203255176544,
0.7125884890556335,
-0.1606360822916031,
-0.38987475633621216,
0.26504161953926086,
-0.23333778977394104,
-0.15182656049728394,
-0.9177883863449097,
0.7037045359611511,
-0.27968311309814453,
0.10453718155622482,
-0.16820083558559418,
-0.6953492164611816,
0.09204886853694916,
0.3545839190483093,
-0.7618963122367859,
1.0238276720046997,
0.26616084575653076,
-0.5503740310668945,
0.3236120045185089,
-0.2566683292388916,
-0.039495255798101425,
0.17579984664916992,
-0.47984397411346436,
-0.5319800972938538,
0.13859474658966064,
-0.05398283526301384,
0.43212077021598816,
-0.5879375338554382,
0.3298810124397278,
-0.13657313585281372,
-0.23830613493919373,
0.17822200059890747,
-0.2140538990497589,
0.35503819584846497,
0.17685583233833313,
-0.104362852871418,
-0.059816695749759674,
-0.5525267124176025,
0.2764603793621063,
-0.17487546801567078,
-0.2985307574272156,
-0.16742196679115295,
-0.154668390750885,
0.06411956250667572,
0.2989300787448883,
-0.08701670169830322,
-0.49830564856529236,
-0.09935446083545685,
-0.3580111265182495,
0.23477709293365479,
0.3884378671646118,
0.27249598503112793,
-0.01398911327123642,
-0.930034875869751,
0.799196720123291,
-0.14879989624023438,
0.13072417676448822,
-0.36316055059432983,
-0.5681159496307373,
-0.5177873969078064,
-0.6635482311248779,
0.2621736526489258,
0.42026036977767944,
-0.2969135642051697,
0.16672861576080322,
-0.3537876009941101,
-0.6136497259140015,
-0.7575445175170898,
-0.028485527262091637,
0.6613584160804749,
0.7032636404037476,
0.47803014516830444,
-0.3105738162994385,
-0.2598748803138733,
-1.0153069496154785,
-0.3425169587135315,
-0.2610876262187958,
-0.12142988294363022,
0.4538435935974121,
0.6095936894416809,
-0.0704469159245491,
0.6964355111122131,
-0.5265232920646667,
-0.23374836146831512,
-0.4344310760498047,
0.27669641375541687,
0.2835611402988434,
0.0860905572772026,
0.19376760721206665,
-0.5456636548042297,
-0.4791223704814911,
0.012079490348696709,
-0.8174778819084167,
-0.3915845453739166,
-0.15098686516284943,
-0.15135440230369568,
-0.2056300938129425,
0.22616377472877502,
-0.6412012577056885,
0.31174415349960327,
0.46637922525405884,
0.015981372445821762,
0.7711273431777954,
-0.5458652973175049,
0.39089131355285645,
-0.9877681136131287,
0.22420582175254822,
-0.05422264710068703,
-0.3129407465457916,
-0.5713003277778625,
0.23062944412231445,
0.34873268008232117,
0.19061221182346344,
-0.40902024507522583,
0.6860986948013306,
-0.34348273277282715,
0.014031276106834412,
0.22227415442466736,
0.12017828226089478,
0.1314300149679184,
0.11395244300365448,
-0.014751547016203403,
0.5028215050697327,
0.2786182761192322,
-0.4853597581386566,
0.47627219557762146,
0.27177077531814575,
-0.31105566024780273,
0.7025604844093323,
-0.8760536909103394,
-0.039743512868881226,
0.06683185696601868,
0.4081708788871765,
-0.8690854907035828,
-0.3055608570575714,
-0.14763158559799194,
-0.09382079541683197,
0.0822620838880539,
-0.14786067605018616,
-0.3895161747932434,
-0.2868420481681824,
-0.4243757128715515,
0.5476996898651123,
0.7102264165878296,
-0.2882841229438782,
0.8202482461929321,
0.25091350078582764,
-0.4085025489330292,
-0.3855712413787842,
-0.3776666224002838,
0.007058771327137947,
-0.29709795117378235,
-0.37937256693840027,
0.5909044742584229,
-0.04697084799408913,
-0.46812117099761963,
-0.2776855528354645,
-0.012263331562280655,
-0.26032859086990356,
-0.059480782598257065,
0.35179248452186584,
0.25189727544784546,
-0.23026150465011597,
0.19097861647605896,
0.21339228749275208,
0.08696144819259644,
0.3196525573730469,
0.19294984638690948,
0.39114442467689514,
-0.02688719891011715,
-0.693594217300415,
-0.5854420065879822,
0.5686814188957214,
0.8220062851905823,
-0.21445222198963165,
0.5285845398902893,
0.3665974736213684,
-0.6250929236412048,
-0.20000480115413666,
-0.9862852096557617,
-0.1627863049507141,
-0.36406993865966797,
0.5042919516563416,
-0.3259400725364685,
-0.4749196171760559,
0.6318216919898987,
-0.1965893656015396,
0.26414111256599426,
0.346066415309906,
0.557856559753418,
-0.26007401943206787,
0.7291813492774963,
0.1364075094461441,
0.14085842669010162,
-0.09358096122741699,
-0.18438756465911865,
0.02058054506778717,
-1.1088404655456543,
-0.3838732838630676,
-0.3998897671699524,
0.06422074884176254,
-0.5462859869003296,
-0.41978374123573303,
0.8561607003211975,
0.0942099466919899,
-0.0928887128829956,
-0.1128825843334198,
-0.1392621546983719,
0.14627718925476074,
0.19445544481277466,
0.35174137353897095,
0.5557899475097656,
-0.36443662643432617,
-0.28731390833854675,
-0.08635202795267105,
-0.5862390398979187,
-0.6406038999557495,
1.2983332872390747,
0.46800872683525085,
0.5689061284065247,
0.4247840940952301,
0.9319996237754822,
0.32976290583610535,
0.4924846887588501,
-0.7176710963249207,
0.3950206935405731,
0.012592190876603127,
-0.32922765612602234,
-0.08534756302833557,
-0.5499276518821716,
-0.620143473148346,
0.37059077620506287,
-0.3060515820980072,
-0.5877866744995117,
-0.27753499150276184,
0.09301701933145523,
-0.7066794633865356,
0.16780731081962585,
-0.3675399124622345,
0.7277759909629822,
-0.38228142261505127,
-0.3657158613204956,
-0.16626858711242676,
-0.4562060534954071,
0.3512130677700043,
-0.36190810799598694,
0.23242567479610443,
-0.04353616386651993,
-0.28063106536865234,
0.6401237845420837,
-0.5151888728141785,
0.3893209397792816,
0.26106545329093933,
-0.11559396237134933,
0.013533851131796837,
0.10216043144464493,
0.304430216550827,
0.3530215919017792,
-0.02998095192015171,
0.20369762182235718,
0.3791610598564148,
-0.19808803498744965,
-0.6233810186386108,
0.6275444626808167,
-0.548157274723053,
-0.47891464829444885,
-0.5016230940818787,
-0.13970892131328583,
-0.37768691778182983,
0.06239190325140953,
0.3963741064071655,
0.796882152557373,
-0.6010480523109436,
0.00018249564163852483,
0.6498543620109558,
-0.35854750871658325,
0.02369905635714531,
0.5513849854469299,
-0.17190000414848328,
-0.3479824364185333,
0.4268070459365845,
0.1462712436914444,
0.49383407831192017,
0.4792378842830658,
0.2118762731552124,
-0.5112587809562683,
-0.5670512318611145,
-0.6926148533821106,
0.4657509922981262,
-0.647267758846283,
-0.04772745445370674,
-1.086437702178955,
-0.3243443965911865,
-0.11769876629114151,
0.05024731531739235,
-0.31534379720687866,
-0.18210642039775848,
0.0649808868765831,
0.030671847984194756,
0.1541544646024704,
0.839701771736145,
0.3077530860900879,
-0.03782578185200691,
-0.9811051487922668,
0.5964409708976746,
0.4236263036727905,
0.24318668246269226,
0.025341153144836426,
-0.7341164946556091,
-0.1411096751689911,
-0.21373601257801056,
-0.39756229519844055,
-1.0968600511550903,
0.4053463637828827,
0.3865903913974762,
0.8059793710708618,
0.37687045335769653,
0.06846492737531662,
0.5951118469238281,
-0.7797977924346924,
0.6298477649688721,
0.20171311497688293,
-0.6593624949455261,
0.41306841373443604,
-0.42284703254699707,
0.3021109104156494,
0.6095278263092041,
0.47677290439605713,
-0.6470719575881958,
-0.44432076811790466,
-0.5531083345413208,
-0.8429244756698608,
0.4289714992046356,
0.24976187944412231,
-0.20148010551929474,
0.0449889674782753,
0.34821537137031555,
0.013528243638575077,
0.12966449558734894,
-0.07884786278009415,
-0.2935713529586792,
0.29766714572906494,
-0.5148100256919861,
0.016583159565925598,
-0.3066047132015228,
-0.3315800726413727,
0.015445421449840069,
0.209757000207901,
0.024352792650461197,
0.30889755487442017,
0.4360803961753845,
-0.1475173532962799,
0.040955811738967896,
0.4454045593738556,
0.4288210868835449,
0.8066056370735168,
-0.3183824121952057,
0.007242368068546057,
0.4995180070400238,
-0.6555435061454773,
-0.053112827241420746,
0.1188684031367302,
0.06868449598550797,
0.28170084953308105,
0.5514515042304993,
0.23798616230487823,
0.3724096119403839,
-1.114250898361206,
0.5180042386054993,
-0.20598085224628448,
-0.25975361466407776,
-0.4334416091442108,
-0.007575892843306065,
-0.09920626133680344,
0.13135427236557007,
0.33507096767425537,
-0.31006255745887756,
0.4124564826488495,
-0.54099041223526,
0.35798579454421997,
0.15539462864398956,
-0.4358380138874054,
-0.1930699497461319,
0.5615599155426025,
0.055086005479097366,
-0.18530994653701782,
0.4162435829639435,
0.1974106729030609,
-0.43423202633857727,
0.868415892124176,
0.3319166302680969,
0.8249979615211487,
-0.174729123711586,
0.28365281224250793,
0.6695127487182617,
0.00381448888219893,
-0.32453396916389465,
0.3503884971141815,
0.1423758864402771,
-0.36588233709335327,
-0.14077472686767578,
-0.4985136389732361,
-0.872535765171051,
0.07351639866828918,
-1.1330835819244385,
0.1428634226322174,
-0.5016914010047913,
-0.22040826082229614,
-0.1299828439950943,
-0.19035707414150238,
-0.6863512396812439,
0.22228936851024628,
0.02933632954955101,
0.840249240398407,
-0.5795959234237671,
0.4290648102760315,
0.6266771554946899,
-0.18145234882831573,
-0.7221072316169739,
-0.08194002509117126,
0.3030529022216797,
-0.47529855370521545,
0.4208175539970398,
0.11602253466844559,
-0.12227114289999008,
-0.21001794934272766,
0.14596639573574066,
-0.39590248465538025,
1.2880619764328003,
0.033987730741500854,
-0.6532588005065918,
0.037780750542879105,
0.07381106913089752,
0.8122724294662476,
-0.4681784212589264,
0.8985325694084167,
0.621382474899292,
0.1169731616973877,
-0.21440258622169495,
-1.2192240953445435,
0.06972094625234604,
-0.2899881601333618,
-0.23386786878108978,
0.16727781295776367,
-0.7367181181907654,
0.78811115026474,
-0.3939705789089203,
-0.19747257232666016,
0.3896692991256714,
0.1937927007675171,
0.618598222732544,
0.48592281341552734,
0.11109428107738495,
0.6084080338478088,
0.8899158835411072,
-0.16623814404010773,
1.0402708053588867,
-0.31384268403053284,
0.2625853717327118,
1.2601068019866943,
-0.6031298041343689,
1.0839464664459229,
0.27783095836639404,
-0.28103822469711304,
0.40028131008148193,
0.3939148485660553,
0.24629665911197662,
0.289485901594162,
0.2562803030014038,
-0.5086383819580078,
-0.20514439046382904,
-0.16625568270683289,
-0.6261183023452759,
0.2940574586391449,
0.31459924578666687,
-0.5449392795562744,
-0.063918836414814,
-0.29415950179100037,
-0.03266611695289612,
0.05935358256101608,
-0.12674057483673096,
0.9710007309913635,
0.2650664150714874,
-0.7870568633079529,
0.5963075160980225,
-0.109534353017807,
0.263397753238678,
-0.6242212057113647,
-0.3725595474243164,
-0.33892351388931274,
0.06323807686567307,
-0.24863672256469727,
-0.5743138194084167,
-0.06100413203239441,
0.3690279424190521,
0.02555203251540661,
-0.0032468249555677176,
0.17241835594177246,
-0.26531901955604553,
-0.3423033654689789,
0.20791947841644287,
0.7692145705223083,
0.19933119416236877,
-0.033441778272390366,
-0.5970224142074585,
-0.15600603818893433,
-0.3584515452384949,
-0.061122674494981766,
0.315937876701355,
0.49750515818595886,
0.08728846162557602,
0.7936944961547852,
0.3980194926261902,
0.5694683790206909,
0.02961982600390911,
0.3603810966014862,
0.893957257270813,
-0.5918351411819458,
-0.435747891664505,
-0.8001888990402222,
0.40981706976890564,
-0.205552875995636,
-0.7497599720954895,
0.514962911605835,
0.762937605381012,
0.47703173756599426,
0.15120454132556915,
0.7940144538879395,
0.28342655301094055,
0.8987909555435181,
-0.7661392092704773,
0.7182506918907166,
-0.5541861653327942,
0.38310861587524414,
-0.15106764435768127,
-0.6730635166168213,
-0.02720296010375023,
0.38308700919151306,
-0.21204015612602234,
0.19934269785881042,
0.7847036719322205,
0.5946048498153687,
0.032190363854169846,
-0.09053397923707962,
0.519386351108551,
0.26224035024642944,
0.41021639108657837,
0.7012271881103516,
0.9326851963996887,
-0.43753600120544434,
0.25732314586639404,
-0.25302380323410034,
-0.3290809988975525,
-0.2883143723011017,
-0.6508885622024536,
-0.8964084386825562,
-0.2565668821334839,
-0.24205075204372406,
-0.21695740520954132,
0.25334030389785767,
1.1323214769363403,
0.701898455619812,
-0.7844139933586121,
-0.16221673786640167,
0.2693633735179901,
-0.18061301112174988,
-0.28352126479148865,
-0.1391972452402115,
0.40616652369499207,
0.025597505271434784,
-0.5181445479393005,
0.038580771535634995,
0.3484404385089874,
-0.17464883625507355,
-0.2246706336736679,
-0.19908146560192108,
0.21992607414722443,
-0.18375839293003082,
0.38697168231010437,
0.22760306298732758,
-0.8156877756118774,
0.28700554370880127,
0.026779508218169212,
-0.41183915734291077,
0.10899222642183304,
0.7864530682563782,
-0.5576411485671997,
0.6538398265838623,
0.36553755402565,
0.6756578087806702,
0.4059017300605774,
0.2829333245754242,
0.49495846033096313,
-0.24896349012851715,
-0.4818694293498993,
0.5495811700820923,
0.43059006333351135,
0.03555390238761902,
-0.2880007326602936,
0.23218022286891937,
-0.15541256964206696,
-0.5824060440063477,
-0.728339433670044,
0.07270074635744095,
-0.8862618803977966,
0.22522827982902527,
1.2430188655853271,
-0.48783060908317566,
0.15107378363609314,
-0.5304126739501953,
-0.19103361666202545,
-0.05452561378479004,
-0.47549623250961304,
0.8816128969192505,
0.5178408026695251,
-0.22463060915470123,
-0.3536841571331024,
-1.0728418827056885,
0.5636435747146606,
0.4653775691986084,
-1.0711838006973267,
-0.073503278195858,
0.5481211543083191,
0.21618115901947021,
-0.20296891033649445,
0.8326430320739746,
-0.22744792699813843,
0.6829033493995667,
-0.28028208017349243,
-0.29566672444343567,
0.11984454095363617,
-0.31664371490478516,
-0.4567837417125702,
0.22476963698863983,
0.001526317442767322,
0.08240348100662231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16039v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16039v1
|
Understanding Public Perceptions of AI Conversational Agents: A Cross-Cultural Analysis
| 2024-02-25T09:34:22 | 2024-02-25T09:34:22 |
Zihan Liu, Han Li, Anfan Chen, Renwen Zhang, Yi-Chieh Lee
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, H.5.2
|
Conversational Agents (CAs) have increasingly been integrated into everyday
life, sparking significant discussions on social media. While previous research
has examined public perceptions of AI in general, there is a notable lack in
research focused on CAs, with fewer investigations into cultural variations in
CA perceptions. To address this gap, this study used computational methods to
analyze about one million social media discussions surrounding CAs and compared
people's discourses and perceptions of CAs in the US and China. We find Chinese
participants tended to view CAs hedonically, perceived voice-based and
physically embodied CAs as warmer and more competent, and generally expressed
positive emotions. In contrast, US participants saw CAs more functionally, with
an ambivalent attitude. Warm perception was a key driver of positive emotions
toward CAs in both countries. We discussed practical implications for designing
contextually sensitive and user-centric CAs to resonate with various users'
preferences and needs.
|
[
-0.4595087468624115,
-0.5703528523445129,
0.2142966389656067,
0.4697529673576355,
-0.17121154069900513,
0.434346467256546,
-0.2726238965988159,
-0.9389171004295349,
0.4916711747646332,
0.06380374729633331,
-0.2715758681297302,
-0.4667249321937561,
-0.24913915991783142,
0.023969102650880814,
-0.08995866775512695,
0.817986249923706,
0.2686215341091156,
0.09554002434015274,
0.04640180617570877,
-0.14649640023708344,
-0.025042491033673286,
-0.8002657294273376,
-0.7273838520050049,
-0.5825067162513733,
0.6534676551818848,
0.03132196515798569,
1.2201486825942993,
0.006496079731732607,
0.24871084094047546,
0.26287397742271423,
0.11851882934570312,
-0.11751491576433182,
-0.38006100058555603,
-0.10264179855585098,
-0.023659391328692436,
-0.4530532956123352,
-0.32824134826660156,
0.1554182469844818,
0.06323256343603134,
0.42203226685523987,
-0.024726495146751404,
0.011542444117367268,
-0.022543372586369514,
0.3749442994594574,
-0.6339056491851807,
0.22610057890415192,
-0.3712660074234009,
0.41103824973106384,
0.06297385692596436,
-0.11644025146961212,
-0.30899783968925476,
-0.28016453981399536,
0.5703970789909363,
-0.7046366333961487,
0.02437608689069748,
-0.36042022705078125,
0.9053428769111633,
0.2086728811264038,
-0.8505693674087524,
-0.28832677006721497,
-1.0964196920394897,
0.7748296856880188,
-0.42877909541130066,
0.2121277004480362,
0.3797137141227722,
0.36252638697624207,
0.08793654292821884,
-0.4355015158653259,
-0.7879891395568848,
-0.3736541271209717,
-0.08878220617771149,
0.36743342876434326,
-0.3377538025379181,
0.01532754022628069,
0.12486951053142548,
0.0178691316395998,
-0.6278716325759888,
-0.04322698712348938,
-0.36063534021377563,
-0.3645305633544922,
1.07444167137146,
0.14627712965011597,
0.9036359190940857,
0.1101079210639,
-0.23035307228565216,
-0.16213588416576385,
-0.4412810206413269,
0.5729309916496277,
0.18073710799217224,
0.3124324083328247,
-0.6482912302017212,
-0.05563337355852127,
-0.19015684723854065,
0.2594926357269287,
-0.20591050386428833,
-0.05660947412252426,
0.25933030247688293,
-0.09588377922773361,
-0.22337332367897034,
0.10973553359508514,
0.6935778260231018,
0.5589426755905151,
0.6794531941413879,
-0.0059037278406322,
0.19332900643348694,
0.1952497363090515,
0.4813489615917206,
-0.8217195868492126,
-0.07339052855968475,
0.15280283987522125,
-0.8137649297714233,
-0.05264086648821831,
0.5008244514465332,
-0.4652421474456787,
-0.8155224323272705,
-0.36410847306251526,
0.013017836958169937,
0.25692400336265564,
-0.4828300178050995,
-0.26079505681991577,
-0.06919239461421967,
0.5783644914627075,
0.4271430969238281,
-0.567266047000885,
0.24370194971561432,
0.6800733804702759,
0.835981011390686,
-0.22485969960689545,
-0.24821338057518005,
0.18622322380542755,
-0.2527250051498413,
-0.41001614928245544,
0.6459742188453674,
-0.6333730220794678,
-0.6216545701026917,
0.124155692756176,
-0.05541975796222687,
-0.025790836662054062,
-0.22475209832191467,
0.14614595472812653,
-0.5571107268333435,
0.14950914680957794,
-0.7984324097633362,
0.3902745842933655,
-0.08147013932466507,
0.4636373519897461,
-0.4902874231338501,
0.4135096073150635,
-0.21365898847579956,
-0.6184231042861938,
0.5025081038475037,
-0.7606778740882874,
-0.7444788217544556,
-0.06172756850719452,
-0.36230355501174927,
0.15433061122894287,
-0.07206393033266068,
0.3621038794517517,
0.42246758937835693,
-0.42911842465400696,
-0.038985203951597214,
-0.3278397023677826,
-0.6706166863441467,
0.6453276872634888,
-0.6387954950332642,
1.0641512870788574,
0.7209270000457764,
-0.5302267670631409,
0.11366312950849533,
-0.1835787147283554,
-0.2829879820346832,
0.11421980708837509,
0.0360613651573658,
-0.3635868728160858,
0.09767944365739822,
-0.12364965677261353,
0.3525809049606323,
0.22749769687652588,
-0.701906681060791,
-0.10167248547077179,
-0.4614930748939514,
0.6528597474098206,
0.5106886625289917,
0.008810815401375294,
0.24755707383155823,
-0.4643741548061371,
0.6027975082397461,
0.20303352177143097,
0.49449238181114197,
0.04079541563987732,
-0.5319658517837524,
-0.5380586385726929,
0.1948496401309967,
-0.5549006462097168,
0.5053132176399231,
-0.7016994953155518,
-0.12063495814800262,
-0.053549133241176605,
-0.8791380524635315,
-0.5331712961196899,
-0.24381500482559204,
0.20576436817646027,
0.24062246084213257,
0.015554934740066528,
-0.18601122498512268,
0.12139493227005005,
-0.8728217482566833,
-0.07981821894645691,
-0.7633507251739502,
-0.0036362505052238703,
0.9093776941299438,
0.2067718654870987,
-0.23842844367027283,
0.9437879323959351,
-0.42371082305908203,
0.03734763711690903,
-0.25894635915756226,
0.24929474294185638,
-0.295541375875473,
0.11563116312026978,
0.6687613129615784,
-1.1094093322753906,
-0.9036598205566406,
0.3203570544719696,
-0.8449400067329407,
0.022909531369805336,
-0.30831339955329895,
0.06495305150747299,
0.48114335536956787,
0.20095966756343842,
-0.45119860768318176,
0.8034616708755493,
0.43036431074142456,
-0.035801246762275696,
0.34699544310569763,
0.1484251618385315,
0.6781092286109924,
-1.0405193567276,
0.13140499591827393,
0.21322889626026154,
0.3746843636035919,
-0.8955835700035095,
-0.13609731197357178,
-0.24295951426029205,
-0.4145118296146393,
-0.867774248123169,
0.5869840383529663,
-0.2555515468120575,
-0.3435730040073395,
-0.35971182584762573,
0.1256418228149414,
-0.0035838421899825335,
0.5246416330337524,
0.28940343856811523,
1.0003477334976196,
0.6306902766227722,
-0.5204378366470337,
0.48921188712120056,
0.07321145385503769,
-0.1641514003276825,
0.48506009578704834,
-0.9419206380844116,
0.24915598332881927,
-0.09380681067705154,
0.7500776052474976,
-0.9009611010551453,
-0.19514599442481995,
0.3612779974937439,
-0.6351078152656555,
-0.4840411841869354,
0.4879617989063263,
-0.07017495483160019,
-0.3455717861652374,
-0.2720155715942383,
0.5572499632835388,
0.3664647340774536,
-0.4770243167877197,
0.6524555683135986,
0.42002880573272705,
-0.20880432426929474,
-0.6211782097816467,
-0.9104223847389221,
0.32794997096061707,
-0.18941393494606018,
-0.8100408315658569,
0.23192067444324493,
0.0713353306055069,
-0.8829912543296814,
-0.39180347323417664,
0.19291767477989197,
-0.23360000550746918,
0.36299532651901245,
0.40484368801116943,
0.026603303849697113,
-0.1531788408756256,
0.009921412914991379,
-0.2296222299337387,
-0.07228728383779526,
0.2869895100593567,
0.2938055098056793,
0.42133036255836487,
-0.3110225796699524,
-0.725261926651001,
-0.9972434043884277,
0.2807035744190216,
0.7256012558937073,
-0.25740960240364075,
0.5964394211769104,
0.6934624314308167,
-0.46452710032463074,
-0.08452710509300232,
-0.3199748992919922,
-0.3253905773162842,
-0.48718276619911194,
0.07907819002866745,
-0.06990287452936172,
-0.5664533376693726,
0.7871567010879517,
0.48293301463127136,
0.22214911878108978,
0.023916514590382576,
0.73445725440979,
-0.002994911279529333,
1.3457950353622437,
0.4973711371421814,
-0.6444306373596191,
0.5025417804718018,
0.11710020899772644,
0.2899348735809326,
-0.25610896944999695,
-0.10184566676616669,
-0.673920214176178,
-0.5553661584854126,
-0.5943124890327454,
0.0012942934408783913,
0.40271496772766113,
-0.7987247705459595,
-0.3091849982738495,
0.058827098459005356,
-0.5590767860412598,
0.3282287120819092,
0.45140665769577026,
-0.008142633363604546,
-0.06326368451118469,
-0.22569426894187927,
0.36157217621803284,
0.15973106026649475,
-0.24337977170944214,
-0.61614990234375,
0.6049277186393738,
0.4105221629142761,
0.7399094104766846,
0.20854099094867706,
0.3428260087966919,
0.6697933673858643,
0.32349976897239685,
-0.6818018555641174,
0.5561425089836121,
0.0006164395599626005,
-0.6846613883972168,
-0.30778926610946655,
-0.1085754781961441,
-1.1126230955123901,
0.17994430661201477,
-0.17188020050525665,
-0.945461094379425,
0.18359138071537018,
-0.09405861794948578,
-0.5300692915916443,
0.007553847040981054,
-0.6610317230224609,
0.7039209604263306,
-0.3757413923740387,
-0.14983731508255005,
-0.4607255458831787,
-0.8317230343818665,
0.1986527293920517,
0.3060179054737091,
0.12300616502761841,
-0.09026073664426804,
0.26936206221580505,
0.3128625452518463,
-0.20899659395217896,
1.1629648208618164,
-0.2707314193248749,
-0.20390339195728302,
0.583832323551178,
-0.10473845154047012,
0.15226691961288452,
-0.04823761060833931,
-0.24690279364585876,
0.3732577860355377,
-0.01342754252254963,
-0.6149517297744751,
-0.778461754322052,
0.5394738912582397,
-1.4017747640609741,
-0.7508037090301514,
-0.38471168279647827,
-0.4850538372993469,
-0.029273400083184242,
-0.223812997341156,
0.0489080436527729,
0.2816084027290344,
-0.55335932970047,
0.12891331315040588,
0.1867404580116272,
-0.6567744612693787,
0.34250110387802124,
0.516665518283844,
0.094765804708004,
0.11309456080198288,
0.9792486429214478,
0.1090221181511879,
0.32589736580848694,
0.33730536699295044,
0.2650505006313324,
0.07618722319602966,
0.06323789805173874,
-0.30151745676994324,
-0.015136761590838432,
-0.5662511587142944,
0.46170634031295776,
-0.43273118138313293,
-0.35856232047080994,
-0.6408635973930359,
-0.46714356541633606,
-0.1938123106956482,
-0.016842903569340706,
-0.41832324862480164,
0.01734134368598461,
-0.03651343658566475,
0.7707760334014893,
0.06969301402568817,
0.49306532740592957,
-0.4715960621833801,
0.03425681218504906,
0.4611646234989166,
0.03277847170829773,
0.3128705322742462,
-0.1316671371459961,
-0.3292970359325409,
0.27787157893180847,
-0.36583617329597473,
-0.8376877307891846,
0.3525991141796112,
-0.0503213070333004,
0.5076010227203369,
1.0016976594924927,
0.4238449037075043,
0.777570903301239,
0.25714394450187683,
1.5198349952697754,
-0.28196659684181213,
-0.8003723621368408,
0.34907281398773193,
-0.33258530497550964,
0.2282181978225708,
0.2976996600627899,
0.4824579656124115,
-0.8392080068588257,
-0.36637869477272034,
-0.4103924632072449,
-0.48674213886260986,
0.6818506717681885,
0.07255510985851288,
0.7428871989250183,
0.10879706591367722,
0.07284747064113617,
0.059012673795223236,
0.08964681625366211,
-0.7921690940856934,
-0.4761078357696533,
-0.486494779586792,
0.12296469509601593,
-0.18644529581069946,
0.11303507536649704,
-0.14353804290294647,
0.22989587485790253,
0.4513795077800751,
-0.012629990465939045,
0.3082534074783325,
0.1751290112733841,
-0.006449807435274124,
-0.19749169051647186,
0.20549876987934113,
0.7933093905448914,
0.5723387002944946,
-0.07604333758354187,
0.09427063912153244,
0.09649007767438889,
-0.40639227628707886,
-0.0874675065279007,
-0.1859508752822876,
-0.12476150691509247,
-0.3716978430747986,
0.4426501989364624,
0.6129077076911926,
-0.22186382114887238,
-0.5536376237869263,
0.5780767798423767,
-0.28077319264411926,
0.005154341459274292,
-0.362659215927124,
0.08185441792011261,
0.015528429299592972,
0.3508756160736084,
0.5049262642860413,
-0.10181836783885956,
0.3333030045032501,
-0.971676766872406,
-0.08012794703245163,
0.7004974484443665,
-0.5985685586929321,
-0.7164465188980103,
0.5734888315200806,
0.7531725168228149,
-0.547669529914856,
0.389632910490036,
-0.08296190202236176,
-0.6836647987365723,
0.7368102073669434,
0.47753989696502686,
1.038110613822937,
0.08825710415840149,
0.46562889218330383,
-0.05138082429766655,
0.27730727195739746,
0.32940223813056946,
0.06599670648574829,
-0.5251662135124207,
-1.1286060810089111,
0.2562076151371002,
0.05149582028388977,
-0.7453029751777649,
-0.14947287738323212,
-0.6718550324440002,
0.08993407338857651,
-0.5192209482192993,
-0.45237240195274353,
-0.09475068747997284,
0.20307296514511108,
-0.7646558880805969,
0.3055049180984497,
0.49828097224235535,
0.5919634103775024,
-0.9578178524971008,
0.7270503044128418,
0.961292564868927,
-0.5268681049346924,
-0.6442195177078247,
0.3891434371471405,
0.374357134103775,
-0.9270797967910767,
0.5776383280754089,
0.2341179996728897,
-0.2808895409107208,
-0.5594560503959656,
-0.7137709259986877,
-0.6098583936691284,
1.184051752090454,
0.12725095450878143,
0.09655863791704178,
0.18614542484283447,
0.5129297375679016,
0.9423123002052307,
-0.4281580448150635,
0.6486169695854187,
0.5327432751655579,
0.3405216336250305,
0.12277999520301819,
-1.058485746383667,
-0.11754683405160904,
-0.6704847812652588,
-0.13073550164699554,
-0.2086051106452942,
-1.3170872926712036,
0.8131797909736633,
0.08863043785095215,
-0.44045203924179077,
-0.2518148422241211,
0.6121517419815063,
0.1600019484758377,
1.0657261610031128,
0.5017735958099365,
-0.2958861291408539,
0.5825259685516357,
0.23455598950386047,
0.7894835472106934,
-0.5276807546615601,
-0.3631642460823059,
0.4987391531467438,
-0.7944381833076477,
0.4030258059501648,
0.09350039809942245,
-0.08691971749067307,
0.7688944339752197,
0.6302947998046875,
0.3043878376483917,
0.017100222408771515,
0.08341631293296814,
-0.4055573642253876,
-0.08164072036743164,
-0.654694139957428,
-0.44678276777267456,
0.6759045124053955,
0.31889811158180237,
-0.10834148526191711,
0.03450387343764305,
0.21791473031044006,
0.13205379247665405,
0.16364453732967377,
-0.1866065412759781,
0.964765727519989,
0.031122669577598572,
-0.7357888221740723,
0.11745993793010712,
-0.07638347148895264,
0.5949756503105164,
-0.34846511483192444,
0.10400673002004623,
-0.3362749516963959,
-0.2535914182662964,
-0.30170831084251404,
-0.5997632145881653,
0.24891158938407898,
0.18455946445465088,
0.09563639014959335,
-0.2307351678609848,
0.8325502872467041,
0.025789791718125343,
-0.0907430574297905,
0.38694870471954346,
0.3688046932220459,
0.7193824052810669,
-0.1469988226890564,
-0.9587022662162781,
0.23497815430164337,
0.1453896015882492,
-0.371491938829422,
0.23241212964057922,
0.41451114416122437,
-0.45471760630607605,
0.8780514597892761,
0.5931860208511353,
-0.03241269290447235,
-0.46183377504348755,
0.2023814171552658,
0.7694118618965149,
-0.6920350790023804,
-0.6337523460388184,
-0.7291265726089478,
0.561662495136261,
-0.015249334275722504,
-0.5411196351051331,
0.5710459351539612,
0.05679779872298241,
0.5935848355293274,
0.3448188006877899,
1.0657963752746582,
-0.009327760897576809,
0.08247193694114685,
0.05472435802221298,
1.0286016464233398,
-0.4594619870185852,
0.1875658631324768,
-0.4433530867099762,
-0.7857592701911926,
-0.1078682392835617,
0.5672600269317627,
-0.5424259305000305,
0.2512228488922119,
0.06650174409151077,
0.8861726522445679,
0.2806762158870697,
0.4915846586227417,
0.379451185464859,
0.08856985718011856,
0.6779395937919617,
0.3753652572631836,
0.9996045827865601,
0.05328388139605522,
0.41573402285575867,
-0.3134574592113495,
-0.2588202953338623,
-0.11060060560703278,
-0.5739520192146301,
-1.0480765104293823,
-0.5827375054359436,
-0.10824009776115417,
-0.18303325772285461,
-0.16523271799087524,
1.435712456703186,
0.653032124042511,
-0.8396220207214355,
-0.46185314655303955,
0.46317726373672485,
0.1862288862466812,
-0.04193860664963722,
-0.3175008296966553,
0.3166963458061218,
-0.006421815603971481,
-0.79511559009552,
0.06931760907173157,
0.1365676373243332,
0.08029606193304062,
-0.6524331569671631,
-0.21663087606430054,
0.2847515344619751,
0.4538898169994354,
0.6569029092788696,
0.598863422870636,
-0.8580564856529236,
-0.48873522877693176,
0.27575695514678955,
-0.40834367275238037,
-0.025097863748669624,
0.7125940918922424,
-0.6711263060569763,
0.5324423313140869,
0.37653475999832153,
0.5337880253791809,
0.11561423540115356,
0.6023364067077637,
0.8628973960876465,
-0.35154494643211365,
0.28874966502189636,
0.1034918874502182,
-0.02169697731733322,
0.2882234752178192,
-0.49149325489997864,
0.2428739219903946,
0.16561895608901978,
-0.7185243368148804,
-0.6739047765731812,
0.14391577243804932,
-0.9564588665962219,
-0.4116245210170746,
1.1322641372680664,
-0.18109993636608124,
0.06203919276595116,
-0.2712913751602173,
-0.466142475605011,
0.2853436768054962,
-0.8043830394744873,
1.131923794746399,
0.6778929829597473,
-0.2823321521282196,
0.1976972222328186,
-0.2297777533531189,
0.38218262791633606,
0.2823008596897125,
-0.8039494156837463,
-0.047244615852832794,
0.3460291028022766,
-0.33827510476112366,
0.36092010140419006,
0.6411860585212708,
0.3691209852695465,
0.4445723593235016,
-0.01319318637251854,
0.054457880556583405,
0.04841966927051544,
-0.38598576188087463,
-0.09002278000116348,
0.031914133578538895,
-0.1049119085073471,
0.027140898630023003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16038v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16038v1
|
Deep Learning Approaches for Improving Question Answering Systems in Hepatocellular Carcinoma Research
| 2024-02-25T09:32:17 | 2024-02-25T09:32:17 |
Shuning Huo, Yafei Xiang, Hanyi Yu, Mengran Zhu, Yulu Gong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In recent years, advancements in natural language processing (NLP) have been
fueled by deep learning techniques, particularly through the utilization of
powerful computing resources like GPUs and TPUs. Models such as BERT and GPT-3,
trained on vast amounts of data, have revolutionized language understanding and
generation. These pre-trained models serve as robust bases for various tasks
including semantic understanding, intelligent writing, and reasoning, paving
the way for a more generalized form of artificial intelligence. NLP, as a vital
application of AI, aims to bridge the gap between humans and computers through
natural language interaction. This paper delves into the current landscape and
future prospects of large-scale model-based NLP, focusing on the
question-answering systems within this domain. Practical cases and developments
in artificial intelligence-driven question-answering systems are analyzed to
foster further exploration and research in the realm of large-scale NLP.
|
[
-0.44786199927330017,
-0.8521053791046143,
0.8366786241531372,
-0.09666194766759872,
-0.030282974243164062,
0.3114742338657379,
-0.14442281424999237,
-0.5732028484344482,
-0.25289100408554077,
0.6560628414154053,
-0.5729169845581055,
-0.3179694414138794,
-0.5073826313018799,
0.10097956657409668,
-0.5731601119041443,
0.9066842198371887,
0.2961650490760803,
0.42583733797073364,
-0.3215670585632324,
0.007169407792389393,
-0.38413378596305847,
-0.5724718570709229,
-0.8161630034446716,
-0.4732591509819031,
0.7617869973182678,
0.35212546586990356,
0.9190165996551514,
0.27644217014312744,
0.6989454627037048,
0.2318372130393982,
-0.3126826584339142,
-0.1312999725341797,
0.00135557702742517,
0.2900010347366333,
-0.13665100932121277,
-0.27623599767684937,
-0.16462823748588562,
-0.18598483502864838,
0.5299306511878967,
1.1662399768829346,
-0.26804226636886597,
-0.3599218428134918,
-0.06928786635398865,
0.7133632898330688,
-0.3787538409233093,
-0.04321170970797539,
-0.6292778253555298,
0.21759825944900513,
0.13318917155265808,
-0.22696760296821594,
-0.3024332523345947,
-0.6307332515716553,
0.46082162857055664,
-0.4210009276866913,
0.12069560587406158,
-0.14697127044200897,
0.7241806387901306,
0.4173543453216553,
-0.2949363589286804,
-0.4732707738876343,
-0.6790042519569397,
0.48279163241386414,
-1.21639084815979,
0.16602396965026855,
0.30483558773994446,
0.6277498006820679,
-0.3017689883708954,
-0.7500072121620178,
-0.3192829489707947,
-0.3701419532299042,
-0.06949850171804428,
-0.13593778014183044,
0.1835501790046692,
0.33080998063087463,
0.14657685160636902,
0.5538772940635681,
-0.7203054428100586,
0.2636626660823822,
-0.3838648796081543,
0.12417615950107574,
0.6503521203994751,
0.2584829032421112,
0.457782119512558,
0.040282320231199265,
-0.1632920652627945,
0.08642055094242096,
-0.7882293462753296,
-0.1884009689092636,
-0.053430285304784775,
0.3766220211982727,
0.3665004372596741,
0.5896536111831665,
-0.4458182454109192,
0.7893077731132507,
-0.33117201924324036,
0.39564913511276245,
-0.10727738589048386,
-0.18238310515880585,
-0.6272217035293579,
0.03933468833565712,
0.5848602056503296,
-0.09464940428733826,
0.3257932662963867,
-0.277433842420578,
0.30081602931022644,
-0.13852372765541077,
0.483292818069458,
-0.8426637649536133,
-0.13881781697273254,
0.537700891494751,
-0.513329803943634,
-0.22912469506263733,
-0.3656400442123413,
-0.7918713688850403,
-0.5224928259849548,
-0.1391853392124176,
0.4242866337299347,
-0.3763473331928253,
-0.1762266457080841,
0.49809911847114563,
-0.1397334784269333,
0.4694353938102722,
0.35565483570098877,
-0.7873947024345398,
0.3715115189552307,
0.627803385257721,
0.2604372501373291,
0.016145838424563408,
-0.08373121172189713,
-0.5517533421516418,
0.14003276824951172,
-0.4580577611923218,
0.7162868976593018,
-0.6692672371864319,
-0.20872750878334045,
0.2211691439151764,
-0.08455595374107361,
-0.14480319619178772,
-0.5750417709350586,
0.47063949704170227,
-0.7992744445800781,
0.4395205080509186,
-0.366443008184433,
-0.9159376621246338,
-0.17320846021175385,
0.34163740277290344,
-0.5899404287338257,
0.6896183490753174,
-0.07793127000331879,
-0.6036261320114136,
0.1051994264125824,
-0.9564759135246277,
-0.4824177324771881,
0.3730776309967041,
-0.02426009066402912,
-0.2339840531349182,
0.1694808304309845,
0.40229180455207825,
0.6748729348182678,
-0.4471451938152313,
0.4331381022930145,
-0.13514652848243713,
-0.29017767310142517,
0.16004526615142822,
-0.27055391669273376,
0.984398365020752,
0.5193590521812439,
-0.46518072485923767,
0.1019759252667427,
-0.4859963655471802,
0.2068987339735031,
0.04021451622247696,
-0.4712328612804413,
-0.14200420677661896,
0.17368698120117188,
-0.3496168255805969,
0.1548142284154892,
0.24461543560028076,
-0.6156049370765686,
0.33559155464172363,
-0.6023738384246826,
0.4993417263031006,
0.22407300770282745,
0.043159183114767075,
0.1371808499097824,
-0.005752806551754475,
0.41542625427246094,
-0.21282532811164856,
0.1913823038339615,
-0.12319067120552063,
-0.7547094225883484,
-0.5605148077011108,
0.46112847328186035,
0.19997775554656982,
0.7066993713378906,
-0.9815362691879272,
0.20767879486083984,
-0.08508174866437912,
-0.4291900098323822,
-0.40647125244140625,
-0.07827463001012802,
0.11307872086763382,
0.47795167565345764,
0.6878356337547302,
-0.07074804604053497,
-0.2930864691734314,
-0.9825014472007751,
-0.31433025002479553,
-0.3083381950855255,
-0.25482144951820374,
0.47432273626327515,
0.33983615040779114,
-0.10138486325740814,
0.6271658539772034,
-0.7459121942520142,
-0.29889151453971863,
-0.3993064761161804,
0.13623079657554626,
0.19304125010967255,
0.3697792887687683,
0.18799826502799988,
-0.8181618452072144,
-0.5114984512329102,
0.2083890587091446,
-0.7655363082885742,
0.06651871651411057,
-0.08330734074115753,
0.1595415621995926,
-0.04727388918399811,
0.7477701902389526,
-0.5924480557441711,
0.5578911900520325,
0.34237730503082275,
-0.3165137767791748,
0.27855098247528076,
-0.4019106924533844,
0.340481162071228,
-0.9062341451644897,
0.1366691142320633,
-0.1837492138147354,
-0.12472144514322281,
-1.008825421333313,
0.11770959943532944,
-0.22589851915836334,
-0.029038984328508377,
-0.35643622279167175,
0.30231335759162903,
-0.32040950655937195,
-0.2979085445404053,
-0.4581359624862671,
-0.18918822705745697,
-0.004357489291578531,
0.40140610933303833,
0.3378024399280548,
0.7161298990249634,
0.2854442298412323,
-0.3796035647392273,
0.2116994857788086,
0.3851967453956604,
-0.4803244173526764,
0.20728865265846252,
-0.8106471300125122,
0.09018124639987946,
-0.017265545204281807,
0.2149970382452011,
-0.9597460627555847,
-0.19847410917282104,
-0.09218113869428635,
-0.6881681680679321,
0.2964792549610138,
0.2294480800628662,
-0.5288016200065613,
-0.7007358074188232,
0.03805134445428848,
0.2525201737880707,
0.4410943388938904,
-0.282595157623291,
0.28919440507888794,
0.2702733874320984,
-0.6182445883750916,
-0.6149469614028931,
-0.7141424417495728,
0.5122078657150269,
0.12342049181461334,
-0.3444284498691559,
0.13285325467586517,
-0.19240114092826843,
-0.1633368879556656,
-0.20651639997959137,
0.3426559269428253,
-0.49122950434684753,
0.32972535490989685,
-0.2627065181732178,
-0.08831941336393356,
-0.28599926829338074,
0.3683549165725708,
0.20950859785079956,
0.22516022622585297,
0.2297903597354889,
-0.13494518399238586,
0.6996685266494751,
-0.28922244906425476,
-0.34544873237609863,
-0.642292320728302,
0.7421424984931946,
0.5726472735404968,
-0.3005528450012207,
0.637897789478302,
0.7102533578872681,
-0.5891087651252747,
0.2638077437877655,
-0.5065338611602783,
-0.3590800166130066,
-0.3600747585296631,
0.3634224236011505,
-0.03406102582812309,
-1.1169540882110596,
0.2700789272785187,
-0.017817849293351173,
0.18795248866081238,
0.5956896543502808,
0.9097175002098083,
-0.2932548224925995,
1.1162660121917725,
0.7082900404930115,
-0.1635848879814148,
0.20918606221675873,
-0.027130043134093285,
0.23667116463184357,
-0.6992915868759155,
-0.11144394427537918,
-0.9592598676681519,
-0.1361723244190216,
-0.651792049407959,
-0.3942215144634247,
0.3651251196861267,
-0.26184576749801636,
-0.40605607628822327,
0.22884799540042877,
-0.7374406456947327,
0.2273569107055664,
0.5674286484718323,
0.14422962069511414,
0.30620384216308594,
-0.24355296790599823,
0.053919218480587006,
0.240720734000206,
-0.8579119443893433,
-0.23635506629943848,
1.0973753929138184,
0.6175030469894409,
0.5568171143531799,
-0.11451216042041779,
0.4408104121685028,
0.21143649518489838,
0.2769140303134918,
-0.5224444270133972,
0.37344247102737427,
-0.29773882031440735,
-1.082776427268982,
-0.6629814505577087,
-0.23215371370315552,
-0.991237461566925,
-0.031839367002248764,
-0.10543487221002579,
-0.6218986511230469,
0.3030811548233032,
-0.07721766829490662,
-0.6662541031837463,
0.6631895303726196,
-0.330640584230423,
0.6774787902832031,
-0.20676426589488983,
-0.19194599986076355,
-0.13625982403755188,
-1.1448521614074707,
0.06783320754766464,
0.490431547164917,
-0.0631815567612648,
0.060981761664152145,
0.009574957191944122,
0.5960065126419067,
-0.3358917534351349,
0.7687604427337646,
-0.4060421884059906,
-0.32972317934036255,
0.301437109708786,
-0.1636422574520111,
0.26473212242126465,
0.16561567783355713,
-0.28232908248901367,
0.009642901830375195,
0.046119239181280136,
-0.575291097164154,
-0.15298150479793549,
0.5612089037895203,
-0.615879476070404,
-0.5839837193489075,
-0.12355279177427292,
-0.6563571095466614,
-0.5092989802360535,
0.10071087628602982,
0.14583039283752441,
0.10218441486358643,
-0.01791224628686905,
0.4719860255718231,
1.03281569480896,
-0.742415189743042,
0.5694056749343872,
-0.12926828861236572,
-0.005616195034235716,
-0.26928842067718506,
0.712812602519989,
-0.4008012115955353,
0.33592623472213745,
0.5859312415122986,
0.24151714146137238,
-0.21503446996212006,
-0.9024326801300049,
-0.5867186188697815,
-0.15180790424346924,
-0.47327670454978943,
-0.2334279716014862,
-0.9182882308959961,
-0.6130344271659851,
-0.38449034094810486,
-0.25888243317604065,
-0.256927490234375,
-0.19146114587783813,
-0.4147697389125824,
-0.029063576832413673,
0.26805174350738525,
0.6769133806228638,
0.0660361647605896,
0.32580506801605225,
-0.8254851698875427,
0.3714514374732971,
0.6908131241798401,
0.43974414467811584,
-0.01768384873867035,
-0.24949021637439728,
-0.19165794551372528,
0.15117621421813965,
0.012361949309706688,
-0.7765973210334778,
0.5395860075950623,
0.35629183053970337,
0.4374326169490814,
0.026461312547326088,
-0.3255119025707245,
0.2858976125717163,
-0.24272114038467407,
0.9143057465553284,
0.04903533682227135,
-0.5137685537338257,
0.6635586023330688,
-0.6822920441627502,
0.5857833623886108,
0.8991329669952393,
0.4511907398700714,
-0.6445019245147705,
-0.32225340604782104,
-0.517497718334198,
-0.6734433770179749,
0.4399949014186859,
0.1474498063325882,
0.11868341267108917,
0.09753519296646118,
0.6532621383666992,
0.2998415231704712,
0.5747063755989075,
-0.5882218480110168,
-0.07645060867071152,
-0.16218969225883484,
-0.1352008432149887,
-0.14472553133964539,
-0.23525173962116241,
-0.10094153881072998,
-0.43153178691864014,
0.5369978547096252,
-0.5652300715446472,
0.46409302949905396,
0.37765446305274963,
0.027130939066410065,
-0.07901082932949066,
0.5444830060005188,
0.5704378485679626,
0.4494457244873047,
-0.34367597103118896,
-0.23984964191913605,
0.36861392855644226,
-0.44911065697669983,
-0.019125716760754585,
0.12806011736392975,
-0.07326079905033112,
-0.2018565833568573,
0.36883848905563354,
0.497306227684021,
-0.3616032600402832,
-0.8095486760139465,
0.5295814871788025,
-0.3328346610069275,
-0.3669995069503784,
-0.28426074981689453,
-0.052960578352212906,
0.41892144083976746,
0.24222233891487122,
0.660750150680542,
-0.09218250960111618,
0.5184286236763,
-0.6146280169487,
0.16545328497886658,
0.51912522315979,
-0.8954194784164429,
0.13204219937324524,
0.6284893155097961,
-0.059731625020504,
-0.13912127912044525,
0.8460787534713745,
0.376750111579895,
-0.4828703701496124,
0.9212356209754944,
0.28875866532325745,
0.8194354772567749,
-0.26341158151626587,
0.2548067569732666,
0.31566017866134644,
0.3296499252319336,
0.0975760966539383,
0.49400973320007324,
-0.03028077818453312,
-0.4185522198677063,
-0.5538482069969177,
-0.6071925163269043,
-0.5544151663780212,
0.4142221510410309,
-0.4580859839916229,
-0.1849903017282486,
-0.6663795709609985,
0.2969806492328644,
0.19865642488002777,
0.34337615966796875,
-0.5752432346343994,
0.7476552724838257,
0.48800337314605713,
1.0150730609893799,
-0.6763403415679932,
0.9989275336265564,
0.6703784465789795,
-0.1835322231054306,
-0.46918052434921265,
-0.004167539533227682,
-0.412977933883667,
-0.49112820625305176,
0.48454907536506653,
0.19039304554462433,
0.21148881316184998,
0.015595651231706142,
-0.8482717871665955,
-0.7597768902778625,
0.9037375450134277,
0.06628834456205368,
-0.47036558389663696,
-0.27930670976638794,
0.3503112494945526,
0.973847508430481,
-0.3787058889865875,
0.10663699358701706,
0.7423893809318542,
0.6811445951461792,
0.051368169486522675,
-0.8814444541931152,
-0.21430398523807526,
-0.08407442271709442,
-0.07004061341285706,
-0.07652560621500015,
-0.2940710186958313,
0.7990989685058594,
-0.3823435604572296,
0.13393738865852356,
0.489854633808136,
0.5853843688964844,
-0.14158634841442108,
0.15095022320747375,
0.23487286269664764,
0.6813472509384155,
0.5536367893218994,
-0.15613551437854767,
1.0328398942947388,
0.19469889998435974,
0.11061614006757736,
0.7463419437408447,
-0.17650699615478516,
0.8319241404533386,
0.4453659951686859,
-0.2397555261850357,
0.6184156537055969,
0.6785313487052917,
0.08136279135942459,
0.3844522535800934,
0.30412614345550537,
-0.1611049324274063,
-0.5409954190254211,
-0.011790578253567219,
-0.5342391729354858,
0.22001783549785614,
0.7266674041748047,
-0.3300418555736542,
-0.19878579676151276,
0.02112133800983429,
-0.14824341237545013,
0.1504325419664383,
-0.23075124621391296,
1.2448320388793945,
0.02758079394698143,
-0.6746498346328735,
0.6068910360336304,
-0.31353503465652466,
0.5625230073928833,
-0.4062528610229492,
-0.07611069828271866,
-0.2342681735754013,
-0.025610556825995445,
-0.2106827050447464,
-0.9922485947608948,
0.5087980628013611,
-0.21516643464565277,
0.02559368498623371,
0.0756700187921524,
0.7484620809555054,
-0.30507633090019226,
-0.43483442068099976,
0.33515021204948425,
0.5913169980049133,
0.03199319168925285,
-0.212173193693161,
-0.7389169931411743,
-0.2038968801498413,
0.030251644551753998,
-0.34200429916381836,
0.30109861493110657,
0.040887054055929184,
0.072552889585495,
0.9113092422485352,
0.5594712495803833,
0.002917248522862792,
-0.10484518855810165,
0.067087322473526,
0.9668996930122375,
-0.8799874186515808,
-0.13338011503219604,
-0.5744675397872925,
0.2368985116481781,
-0.16211441159248352,
-0.2498665302991867,
0.13178090751171112,
0.29274874925613403,
0.46020612120628357,
0.0962391346693039,
0.9099100232124329,
-0.11233705282211304,
0.7266860604286194,
-0.3089379668235779,
0.8854634761810303,
-0.7143405675888062,
0.29930537939071655,
-0.22131860256195068,
-0.6532929539680481,
-0.8008728623390198,
0.16594256460666656,
-0.4457905888557434,
0.13670851290225983,
0.7251636385917664,
0.4583970606327057,
0.370442271232605,
0.30042654275894165,
0.4004405438899994,
0.4044639468193054,
0.5789788961410522,
0.8288484215736389,
0.6938907504081726,
-0.5871604084968567,
0.485424667596817,
-0.22338692843914032,
-0.030802931636571884,
-0.4482555687427521,
-0.6347072124481201,
-0.7682073712348938,
-0.7812471389770508,
-0.07333321124315262,
-0.026546163484454155,
0.25229087471961975,
0.5954837799072266,
0.656836986541748,
-0.9483305215835571,
-0.2152167707681656,
-0.3139176666736603,
0.2167736440896988,
-0.1255817711353302,
-0.15003494918346405,
0.47137200832366943,
-0.5149867534637451,
-0.6061834096908569,
0.5190975666046143,
0.3382783830165863,
-0.1233973577618599,
-0.41774284839630127,
0.16926999390125275,
-0.7174042463302612,
0.1388629525899887,
0.7103422284126282,
0.5436955094337463,
-0.3969244062900543,
-0.0846952348947525,
0.27845773100852966,
-0.20429342985153198,
0.1984376460313797,
0.6427700519561768,
-1.042617917060852,
0.13384908437728882,
0.5748029351234436,
1.1361865997314453,
0.3548305630683899,
-0.161826491355896,
0.68593430519104,
-0.2490706443786621,
-0.31430843472480774,
0.748276948928833,
0.036156315356492996,
0.5210370421409607,
-0.6429829001426697,
0.39888104796409607,
-0.21966452896595,
-0.8090069890022278,
-0.5956206917762756,
0.15370751917362213,
-0.8773979544639587,
-0.9229610562324524,
0.8964250683784485,
0.026740210130810738,
-0.058786824345588684,
-0.41385313868522644,
-0.20670902729034424,
0.07251464575529099,
-0.13607268035411835,
0.9512738585472107,
0.40305498242378235,
-0.3194517195224762,
-0.1894349306821823,
-0.8578912615776062,
0.8335395455360413,
0.6451833844184875,
-1.404255986213684,
0.12410891801118851,
0.40149950981140137,
-0.01912780851125717,
-0.011450163088738918,
0.4406023323535919,
-0.2791714072227478,
0.5798367857933044,
-0.41423845291137695,
0.16306526958942413,
0.40825581550598145,
-0.40472352504730225,
-0.3128628134727478,
0.5675032138824463,
0.1741364449262619,
0.18675488233566284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16035v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16035v1
|
Text Understanding and Generation Using Transformer Models for Intelligent E-commerce Recommendations
| 2024-02-25T09:19:11 | 2024-02-25T09:19:11 |
Yafei Xiang, Hanyi Yu, Yulu Gong, Shuning Huo, Mengran Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the rapid development of artificial intelligence technology, Transformer
structural pre-training model has become an important tool for large language
model (LLM) tasks. In the field of e-commerce, these models are especially
widely used, from text understanding to generating recommendation systems,
which provide powerful technical support for improving user experience and
optimizing service processes. This paper reviews the core application scenarios
of Transformer pre-training model in e-commerce text understanding and
recommendation generation, including but not limited to automatic generation of
product descriptions, sentiment analysis of user comments, construction of
personalized recommendation system and automated processing of customer service
conversations. Through a detailed analysis of the model's working principle,
implementation process, and application effects in specific cases, this paper
emphasizes the unique advantages of pre-trained models in understanding complex
user intentions and improving the quality of recommendations. In addition, the
challenges and improvement directions for the future are also discussed, such
as how to further improve the generalization ability of the model, the ability
to handle large-scale data sets, and technical strategies to protect user
privacy. Ultimately, the paper points out that the application of Transformer
structural pre-training models in e-commerce has not only driven technological
innovation, but also brought substantial benefits to merchants and consumers,
and looking forward, these models will continue to play a key role in
e-commerce and beyond.
|
[
-0.4536411464214325,
-0.723546028137207,
0.4900977909564972,
0.1714891791343689,
-0.30561789870262146,
-0.1789422631263733,
-0.1192682608962059,
-0.7138026356697083,
-0.12399699538946152,
0.696750819683075,
-0.7445560097694397,
-0.4154808521270752,
-0.36773163080215454,
0.16579197347164154,
-0.708557665348053,
1.2299046516418457,
0.03800034150481224,
-0.000002217619339717203,
-0.1496320515871048,
0.43980124592781067,
-0.4852698743343353,
-0.7813290953636169,
-0.5250644683837891,
-0.410392165184021,
0.18097342550754547,
0.25899916887283325,
0.4109440743923187,
0.11775568127632141,
0.6923786401748657,
0.447819322347641,
0.26179131865501404,
-0.19477322697639465,
-0.5071699619293213,
0.19436416029930115,
-0.12317144125699997,
-0.8002977967262268,
-0.6257836222648621,
-0.05539998784661293,
0.20226706564426422,
0.4290769100189209,
-0.35004666447639465,
0.19505156576633453,
0.05894726887345314,
0.6247959733009338,
-0.34751060605049133,
-0.026326440274715424,
-0.46854352951049805,
0.08311979472637177,
0.0668594241142273,
-0.007766117807477713,
-0.6554669141769409,
-0.19510610401630402,
0.5956982374191284,
-0.7928503751754761,
0.43895089626312256,
0.5205631256103516,
1.103193759918213,
0.2242933064699173,
-0.4996018707752228,
-0.4001781642436981,
-1.3779551982879639,
0.7168128490447998,
-0.5073644518852234,
0.5704456567764282,
0.3846701383590698,
0.5323953628540039,
-0.022676553577184677,
-1.0870789289474487,
-0.49145936965942383,
-0.09454600512981415,
-0.4776025414466858,
0.38462382555007935,
-0.47200360894203186,
0.049315012991428375,
0.2082112729549408,
0.42468714714050293,
-0.4663030505180359,
0.03307110443711281,
-0.34104588627815247,
0.15050989389419556,
0.5662543773651123,
0.15259017050266266,
0.16592687368392944,
-0.01867884024977684,
-0.14397022128105164,
-0.07466620206832886,
-0.4938217103481293,
0.2393631935119629,
0.5531600713729858,
0.03659164533019066,
-0.06794454157352448,
0.31705987453460693,
-0.28396645188331604,
0.6627065539360046,
0.3089286684989929,
-0.17376786470413208,
0.2070605456829071,
-0.4556347131729126,
-0.3454059064388275,
-0.11580058187246323,
0.6095403432846069,
0.2721709907054901,
0.5797901153564453,
-0.03585302084684372,
-0.16431276500225067,
-0.15888960659503937,
0.6941954493522644,
-0.8963913321495056,
-0.1558389514684677,
0.07407145202159882,
-0.8952510356903076,
-0.33574390411376953,
0.3414216637611389,
-0.6036599278450012,
0.0037685870192945004,
-0.4792044758796692,
0.07307898998260498,
0.00628252886235714,
-0.178381085395813,
0.3694467842578888,
0.05858790874481201,
0.14840629696846008,
0.19692683219909668,
-0.8065168857574463,
0.49100542068481445,
0.556553304195404,
0.4596596360206604,
-0.0212249793112278,
-0.1053541824221611,
0.04507678747177124,
0.23982356488704681,
0.14582224190235138,
0.9522610902786255,
-0.4793171286582947,
-0.35358962416648865,
0.14980407059192657,
0.16548128426074982,
0.06712090969085693,
-0.34235095977783203,
0.644922137260437,
-0.676980197429657,
0.11357921361923218,
0.23930272459983826,
-0.5174144506454468,
-0.33555731177330017,
0.4815465807914734,
-0.7356727123260498,
0.4555860459804535,
-0.2536255419254303,
-0.538580060005188,
0.362085223197937,
-0.5969400405883789,
-0.6770204901695251,
0.21233762800693512,
0.28203028440475464,
-0.7735949158668518,
0.20591731369495392,
0.34323304891586304,
0.5847370624542236,
-0.5807262063026428,
0.24222224950790405,
-0.05786258727312088,
-0.3284803330898285,
0.32080498337745667,
-0.3077071011066437,
0.3121582567691803,
0.2633265554904938,
-0.4382971525192261,
0.05402900278568268,
-0.46706271171569824,
-0.2584614157676697,
0.26381778717041016,
0.0700315535068512,
-0.07171288877725601,
0.1829853653907776,
0.4106927216053009,
0.05429482460021973,
0.24331675469875336,
-0.3161970376968384,
-0.057473961263895035,
-0.5612579584121704,
0.5661623477935791,
0.618545651435852,
-0.10784842818975449,
0.4626140892505646,
-0.11869566142559052,
0.8042964339256287,
0.1237778589129448,
0.5773056149482727,
-0.7156646847724915,
-0.3490646481513977,
-0.7609513401985168,
0.2639799118041992,
0.38218531012535095,
0.5261964797973633,
-0.5420774817466736,
0.6204791069030762,
-0.1877562701702118,
-0.6740855574607849,
-0.16192355751991272,
-0.19247391819953918,
0.1563662886619568,
0.2613244950771332,
0.2907017469406128,
-0.057855527848005295,
-0.5171512365341187,
-0.9627891182899475,
-0.58598393201828,
-0.1221446841955185,
-0.04136185348033905,
0.3498605489730835,
0.20644673705101013,
-0.6194655299186707,
0.9998188614845276,
-0.746964156627655,
-0.3768652379512787,
-0.6106955409049988,
-0.08233625441789627,
0.38273870944976807,
0.16644218564033508,
0.37727710604667664,
-1.1918209791183472,
-0.4858134984970093,
-0.03743109852075577,
-0.3185749053955078,
-0.014894678257405758,
-0.23053568601608276,
-0.05138443782925606,
-0.1236935704946518,
0.20698456466197968,
-0.34335389733314514,
0.5071256160736084,
0.460787832736969,
-0.3100886940956116,
0.4847570061683655,
-0.38123270869255066,
0.27914130687713623,
-1.259129524230957,
-0.18184956908226013,
0.5559631586074829,
-0.30948418378829956,
-0.9576744437217712,
-0.29540443420410156,
-0.12295541167259216,
-0.2413218766450882,
-0.3193764090538025,
0.13775812089443207,
-0.16658081114292145,
0.11780135333538055,
-0.3306100070476532,
-0.052241064608097076,
0.18022137880325317,
0.2801834046840668,
0.09300651401281357,
0.5759628415107727,
0.15134797990322113,
-0.7999118566513062,
0.20639026165008545,
0.39337190985679626,
-0.46469613909721375,
0.5343586802482605,
-0.9063708186149597,
-0.027277257293462753,
-0.052871108055114746,
0.31997188925743103,
-0.7612701058387756,
0.1001223623752594,
0.12225399166345596,
-0.18860286474227905,
0.13253410160541534,
0.13591855764389038,
-0.4204484224319458,
-0.6930453181266785,
0.06350059062242508,
0.2679857313632965,
0.5396737456321716,
-0.5139291882514954,
0.9506412744522095,
0.36229828000068665,
-0.20043277740478516,
-0.33684197068214417,
-0.5432170033454895,
-0.031936630606651306,
-0.24166461825370789,
-0.6571069359779358,
0.6216126680374146,
-0.25725871324539185,
-0.02491702139377594,
-0.18229126930236816,
0.12513704597949982,
0.07124163210391998,
0.1949162483215332,
0.2851632535457611,
0.38005751371383667,
-0.14024752378463745,
0.26646649837493896,
0.03632182255387306,
-0.5655802488327026,
0.10099411010742188,
-0.5552650094032288,
0.5602778792381287,
-0.27507051825523376,
-0.38097429275512695,
-0.5801731944084167,
0.1245938241481781,
0.12662555277347565,
-0.2018580436706543,
0.6027429699897766,
0.44569694995880127,
-0.13162526488304138,
-0.1337166577577591,
-0.7987419962882996,
-0.38599082827568054,
-0.5645826458930969,
0.6019406914710999,
-0.4010896682739258,
-0.8142108917236328,
0.07723738998174667,
-0.5198428630828857,
-0.04783116653561592,
0.48260101675987244,
0.5301659107208252,
-0.29704049229621887,
1.2725465297698975,
1.2111914157867432,
0.03899114951491356,
0.6795063018798828,
-0.021200435236096382,
0.9116409420967102,
-0.41591569781303406,
-0.30352187156677246,
-0.7183739542961121,
-0.250229150056839,
-0.6056495904922485,
0.27645671367645264,
0.1334536373615265,
0.08521498739719391,
-0.2952939569950104,
0.39416560530662537,
-0.5067393779754639,
0.4202839434146881,
0.4539332389831543,
0.21777567267417908,
0.4282929599285126,
0.21459493041038513,
0.18635150790214539,
0.028477074578404427,
-0.37457793951034546,
-0.7489273548126221,
1.008873462677002,
0.3578468859195709,
0.8300710916519165,
-0.22744879126548767,
0.1604497730731964,
0.3078095316886902,
0.20514671504497528,
-0.8890337944030762,
0.3155955672264099,
-0.3405722379684448,
-0.3075399100780487,
-0.012760688550770283,
-0.15370120108127594,
-0.7898884415626526,
-0.12662756443023682,
-0.3684636950492859,
-0.2869432270526886,
0.008994043804705143,
0.37230077385902405,
-0.2871624529361725,
0.1507887989282608,
-0.709114670753479,
0.8158870935440063,
-0.6192979216575623,
-0.10476970672607422,
-0.20769357681274414,
-0.41412895917892456,
0.09275446832180023,
-0.23115476965904236,
0.29343172907829285,
0.37395018339157104,
0.2272418588399887,
0.9037244319915771,
-0.04901745542883873,
0.6451452374458313,
-0.010523732751607895,
0.04555806890130043,
0.11495833098888397,
-0.32813188433647156,
0.656000554561615,
-0.2473495900630951,
0.022677332162857056,
0.18522436916828156,
-0.10521240532398224,
0.08262553066015244,
-0.6076620221138,
0.10645392537117004,
-0.8184197545051575,
-0.8075804710388184,
0.03736092522740364,
-0.2002333700656891,
-0.16388249397277832,
0.2874082922935486,
0.3661053776741028,
0.11708974093198776,
-0.35974976420402527,
0.4056243598461151,
0.7027303576469421,
-0.24425052106380463,
0.35829469561576843,
0.42536863684654236,
-0.29934775829315186,
-0.2700103521347046,
0.6587361097335815,
-0.19172927737236023,
-0.07948017120361328,
0.462396502494812,
0.28050529956817627,
-0.27644866704940796,
-0.5468848943710327,
-0.1870519518852234,
0.1935790628194809,
-0.6925724744796753,
-0.1428353190422058,
-0.892120361328125,
-0.04188435152173042,
-0.31825095415115356,
-0.27552294731140137,
-0.06134016066789627,
-0.07056049257516861,
-0.18453402817249298,
-0.3699851334095001,
0.26953327655792236,
1.1321775913238525,
0.6076653003692627,
0.8226159811019897,
-1.0109822750091553,
0.22879467904567719,
0.2699677050113678,
0.33981189131736755,
0.1453896164894104,
-0.2705575227737427,
-0.733640193939209,
0.00022531699505634606,
-0.34439051151275635,
-0.6290794610977173,
0.33628538250923157,
-0.032210350036621094,
0.6073360443115234,
0.6925802826881409,
-0.16674436628818512,
0.38065364956855774,
-0.6067282557487488,
0.8846086263656616,
0.28964751958847046,
-1.00917649269104,
0.5109416246414185,
-0.19703228771686554,
0.12515856325626373,
0.3977549374103546,
0.6306828260421753,
-0.5027135610580444,
0.016256021335721016,
-0.47953101992607117,
-0.7983778715133667,
0.7946538925170898,
0.08764475584030151,
0.40058183670043945,
0.3255055844783783,
0.46108487248420715,
0.3072422444820404,
0.43479210138320923,
-0.8706029653549194,
-0.32888588309288025,
-0.36618542671203613,
-0.3140619397163391,
-0.23736828565597534,
-0.4030716121196747,
0.3496309518814087,
-0.12160585820674896,
0.9283549785614014,
0.08792957663536072,
0.1437094658613205,
-0.23124080896377563,
-0.3392406105995178,
0.0014875715132802725,
0.3098089098930359,
0.46270620822906494,
0.5107761025428772,
0.2522083520889282,
-0.3659842610359192,
0.08551729470491409,
-0.7170071005821228,
0.14288558065891266,
-0.06836283951997757,
-0.14608682692050934,
-0.3886096775531769,
0.13710123300552368,
0.7077003121376038,
0.06852099299430847,
-0.5295374393463135,
0.6288940906524658,
-0.40620896220207214,
-0.07360526919364929,
-0.45447421073913574,
-0.07402831315994263,
0.07378072291612625,
0.18653471767902374,
0.24199044704437256,
0.13565975427627563,
0.2916618287563324,
-0.3065178692340851,
0.08564716577529907,
0.19522525370121002,
-0.4572530686855316,
-0.3885563910007477,
0.432862788438797,
0.2862167954444885,
-0.5385897159576416,
0.7282376885414124,
0.39926910400390625,
-0.7410478591918945,
0.5221688151359558,
0.8971158266067505,
0.9993739724159241,
-0.35179010033607483,
0.20830769836902618,
0.09780765324831009,
0.4700779318809509,
-0.1570630818605423,
-0.12996530532836914,
-0.2750677764415741,
-0.9075456261634827,
-0.13954800367355347,
-0.7458850741386414,
-0.32081425189971924,
-0.22080259025096893,
-0.5786572098731995,
0.6598193049430847,
-0.19344249367713928,
-0.2719411849975586,
-0.2192593365907669,
-0.22991080582141876,
-1.04476797580719,
0.5152251124382019,
-0.05772868171334267,
0.4765976667404175,
-0.7848097681999207,
0.6464018225669861,
0.533519983291626,
-0.3718927204608917,
-0.853592574596405,
0.02513951063156128,
-0.3893855810165405,
-0.4016958177089691,
0.8266178965568542,
0.36665040254592896,
-0.45478057861328125,
-0.022215787321329117,
-0.22403210401535034,
-0.5326226353645325,
1.086660623550415,
0.08974295109510422,
-1.0145665407180786,
-0.15065516531467438,
0.5237166881561279,
0.6306107044219971,
-0.6648270487785339,
0.8315364718437195,
0.6212406158447266,
0.5637848973274231,
0.08818715065717697,
-0.4571631848812103,
-0.09964059293270111,
-0.42661646008491516,
0.2308630794286728,
0.06026200205087662,
-0.368354469537735,
0.7233722805976868,
0.24614743888378143,
-0.13462050259113312,
-0.08960550278425217,
0.38994479179382324,
-0.13946282863616943,
0.18966332077980042,
0.6917608380317688,
0.5366615653038025,
0.5060631036758423,
-0.04104822129011154,
1.062230110168457,
-0.4369518458843231,
0.29878154397010803,
0.8962877988815308,
-0.3270193934440613,
0.6707378029823303,
-0.01919657737016678,
-0.1744883507490158,
0.8668035268783569,
0.6975746750831604,
-0.17504793405532837,
0.2852286100387573,
0.006492157466709614,
0.12340965121984482,
-0.2683964669704437,
0.002177091548219323,
-0.3737589716911316,
0.2844811677932739,
0.23429565131664276,
-0.5099518895149231,
0.04994846507906914,
0.29104360938072205,
-0.4067363142967224,
-0.035046618431806564,
-0.2584092319011688,
1.048073410987854,
0.15313653647899628,
-0.3420160412788391,
0.007853876799345016,
0.05090644583106041,
0.8007288575172424,
-0.6475660800933838,
-0.0007139738299883902,
0.1969309151172638,
0.34069034457206726,
-0.3381405472755432,
-0.2900826334953308,
0.21991601586341858,
0.14878183603286743,
-0.4717828333377838,
-0.5353144407272339,
1.0536706447601318,
0.05658108741044998,
-0.6579171419143677,
0.48186445236206055,
0.36793020367622375,
-0.13295525312423706,
-0.18798992037773132,
-0.7202178239822388,
-0.26308491826057434,
-0.07308576256036758,
-0.6560234427452087,
0.09452136605978012,
0.2948415279388428,
0.25465869903564453,
0.46519628167152405,
0.762628972530365,
-0.22961823642253876,
-0.10902267694473267,
0.3716764450073242,
0.5923641920089722,
-0.7791141867637634,
-0.8399173021316528,
-0.8592994809150696,
0.5940176844596863,
-0.1571308970451355,
-0.0010516480542719364,
0.7594586610794067,
0.3841260075569153,
0.9705173969268799,
-0.11102388799190521,
0.766220211982727,
0.5122698545455933,
0.3229091763496399,
-0.34634071588516235,
0.8894386887550354,
-0.4329669773578644,
0.40230119228363037,
-0.277681827545166,
-1.3236536979675293,
-0.25378578901290894,
0.4688165783882141,
-0.6185125708580017,
0.28178489208221436,
0.7938745617866516,
0.4778521955013275,
-0.12680333852767944,
0.6078270077705383,
0.3870697617530823,
0.2038419246673584,
0.42149683833122253,
0.1560448855161667,
0.887539803981781,
-0.5551612973213196,
0.7208981513977051,
-0.10468912869691849,
-0.13840681314468384,
-0.2404840737581253,
-0.7751869559288025,
-0.9863243699073792,
-0.5877901315689087,
-0.004319287370890379,
0.027555063366889954,
-0.20510393381118774,
0.9071590304374695,
0.8110241293907166,
-0.7645017504692078,
-0.4456864595413208,
-0.2710597813129425,
-0.07817499339580536,
-0.24586185812950134,
-0.19007162749767303,
0.12296603620052338,
-0.3370833694934845,
-0.7673708200454712,
0.0948328897356987,
0.3656422197818756,
0.14195005595684052,
-0.23551008105278015,
0.13965831696987152,
0.03754962235689163,
0.14185397326946259,
0.7575635313987732,
-0.3035314679145813,
-0.5309086441993713,
0.04025688022375107,
0.26126378774642944,
0.38227489590644836,
0.014285451732575893,
1.259200930595398,
-0.8745023608207703,
0.2943747341632843,
0.36038103699684143,
0.6795724034309387,
0.7712597250938416,
-0.00276932492852211,
0.8039616346359253,
-0.029515942558646202,
0.028497016057372093,
0.04714801907539368,
0.4638379216194153,
0.15165463089942932,
-0.5963483452796936,
0.1559763252735138,
-0.16705496609210968,
-0.5812408328056335,
-0.4057144224643707,
0.5296827554702759,
-0.5267313122749329,
-0.31282782554626465,
0.5638747215270996,
-0.22731854021549225,
-0.22501061856746674,
-0.41508379578590393,
-0.26205965876579285,
0.2737833261489868,
-0.13431669771671295,
0.7687866687774658,
0.5806741714477539,
0.18456587195396423,
-0.19517183303833008,
-0.15019845962524414,
0.19571708142757416,
0.34518080949783325,
-1.0703707933425903,
-0.10671846568584442,
0.13905733823776245,
-0.004654608201235533,
0.1555483490228653,
0.1945219784975052,
0.24138173460960388,
-0.016795001924037933,
-0.3925016224384308,
0.008476682007312775,
-0.17961786687374115,
-0.6212751269340515,
-0.333224356174469,
0.3446763753890991,
-0.08387131989002228,
0.31876927614212036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16034v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16034v2
|
Emotion Classification in Short English Texts using Deep Learning Techniques
| 2024-02-25T09:17:22 | 2024-03-10T15:58:56 |
Siddhanth Bhat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Detecting emotions in limited text datasets from under-resourced languages
presents a formidable obstacle, demanding specialized frameworks and
computational strategies. This study conducts a thorough examination of deep
learning techniques for discerning emotions in short English texts. Deep
learning approaches employ transfer learning and word embedding, notably BERT,
to attain superior accuracy. To evaluate these methods, we introduce the
"SmallEnglishEmotions" dataset, comprising 6372 varied short English texts
annotated with five primary emotion categories. Our experiments reveal that
transfer learning and BERT-based text embedding outperform alternative methods
in accurately categorizing the text in the dataset.
|
[
-0.291319876909256,
-0.46773388981819153,
0.5512848496437073,
0.08492811769247055,
-0.5412536263465881,
0.18895873427391052,
-0.4982767403125763,
-0.7100133299827576,
0.13280709087848663,
-0.009303688071668148,
-0.4871823489665985,
-0.45410099625587463,
-0.7599030137062073,
0.409772127866745,
-0.2459583729505539,
0.776385486125946,
-0.26763275265693665,
0.0973493680357933,
-0.10074622929096222,
-0.33640700578689575,
-0.4589756727218628,
-0.38450419902801514,
-0.632087767124176,
-0.38372498750686646,
0.7944510579109192,
0.7862062454223633,
0.6045740842819214,
0.01802840828895569,
0.6315509080886841,
0.2880425453186035,
-0.004340019542723894,
0.1582711935043335,
-0.481247216463089,
0.13270016014575958,
0.024619704112410545,
-0.5422331094741821,
0.272308886051178,
-0.041035160422325134,
0.36552923917770386,
0.21744833886623383,
0.3047700822353363,
-0.1470404714345932,
0.22708088159561157,
0.9083479046821594,
-0.740399181842804,
0.11422982066869736,
-0.22499346733093262,
0.602118968963623,
-0.3736737370491028,
0.04550720006227493,
-0.5399442911148071,
-0.5903962254524231,
0.48956021666526794,
-0.07692372053861618,
-0.05888191983103752,
0.1935960352420807,
0.660396158695221,
0.1954634189605713,
-0.7840916514396667,
-0.7982020974159241,
-0.41145431995391846,
1.055496335029602,
-0.5743651986122131,
0.32848337292671204,
0.19987516105175018,
0.17019852995872498,
0.47194090485572815,
-0.68599534034729,
-0.5943339467048645,
-0.17336909472942352,
-0.3785935342311859,
0.17121465504169464,
-0.3205096125602722,
0.20177865028381348,
-0.027842804789543152,
0.34235039353370667,
-0.6209481954574585,
0.5286329388618469,
-0.3302110433578491,
0.10514684021472931,
0.7468137741088867,
0.23383107781410217,
0.2978784143924713,
-0.5230692028999329,
-0.12878404557704926,
-0.1850351244211197,
-0.5376008749008179,
0.12980997562408447,
0.31589585542678833,
0.30276283621788025,
-0.08861695975065231,
0.37459370493888855,
0.2955441474914551,
-0.08956798166036606,
-0.11113391071557999,
0.16325436532497406,
0.3229910731315613,
0.23363378643989563,
-0.45605942606925964,
0.2420288622379303,
0.8548233509063721,
0.3977307081222534,
0.5716108679771423,
0.19746938347816467,
-0.24443964660167694,
0.09647300839424133,
0.11553046852350235,
-0.8995260000228882,
-0.29009562730789185,
0.37052416801452637,
-0.7316358685493469,
-0.38892826437950134,
-0.3658149540424347,
-1.1085567474365234,
-0.7505884766578674,
-0.09810875356197357,
0.3714450001716614,
-0.4792996346950531,
0.1096605733036995,
0.06200871616601944,
-0.0577106848359108,
0.00625084200873971,
0.19357332587242126,
-0.8393839001655579,
0.09783127903938293,
0.5197075605392456,
0.766935408115387,
-0.30912572145462036,
-0.17404161393642426,
0.008927206508815289,
-0.40598899126052856,
-0.429655522108078,
0.7354711294174194,
-0.6272509098052979,
-0.34185028076171875,
0.4003640115261078,
0.20461690425872803,
0.05830641835927963,
-0.3795989155769348,
0.7086685299873352,
-0.2679198086261749,
0.6129788756370544,
-0.10012979805469513,
-0.8475610613822937,
-0.25180381536483765,
0.13669688999652863,
-0.6836040616035461,
1.080288052558899,
-0.21246983110904694,
-0.693569004535675,
0.08355297148227692,
-0.5740232467651367,
-0.7904647588729858,
-0.18215878307819366,
0.11088350415229797,
-0.3323073387145996,
0.5780825614929199,
0.09643828123807907,
1.013044834136963,
-0.18203788995742798,
-0.2789858877658844,
-0.32735252380371094,
-0.4833410680294037,
0.21698088943958282,
-0.26011794805526733,
0.4616699814796448,
0.4376162588596344,
-0.4321725368499756,
-0.2469450682401657,
-0.4961848258972168,
-0.00674182316288352,
0.24141038954257965,
-0.08161509037017822,
-0.7475740909576416,
0.0391390435397625,
-0.04741211608052254,
0.07507877796888351,
0.15425518155097961,
-0.550276517868042,
0.1611936092376709,
-0.4919184744358063,
0.20216147601604462,
0.6960935592651367,
-0.05979648977518082,
0.6333810091018677,
0.05145575478672981,
0.502041220664978,
0.006898947060108185,
-0.03588613122701645,
0.07886248826980591,
-0.4324198067188263,
-0.8021376132965088,
0.08309244364500046,
0.24368879199028015,
0.549450159072876,
-0.5336894392967224,
0.4514748752117157,
-0.05936227738857269,
-0.5334673523902893,
-1.0276765823364258,
-0.07583265751600266,
0.2752682566642761,
0.37063297629356384,
0.429777055978775,
0.12949137389659882,
-0.40574911236763,
-0.7047610878944397,
-0.23413382470607758,
0.04481487721204758,
0.1231042891740799,
0.5157567858695984,
0.46252942085266113,
-0.5244309306144714,
0.4841843545436859,
-0.5664584040641785,
-0.3381049335002899,
-0.08627308160066605,
0.7344377636909485,
-0.1957094818353653,
0.28348150849342346,
0.7751646041870117,
-0.7197707295417786,
-0.8206921219825745,
0.13539068400859833,
-0.6723496913909912,
0.002199069829657674,
-0.15406204760074615,
0.15208736062049866,
0.36800819635391235,
0.11661241203546524,
-0.481304794549942,
0.3518941402435303,
0.5652039647102356,
-0.09189795702695847,
0.188534677028656,
-0.0018069164361804724,
0.27017730474472046,
-0.914756178855896,
-0.3616926968097687,
0.01758764684200287,
-0.211839959025383,
-0.48585253953933716,
-0.31795555353164673,
0.28988441824913025,
0.0734233632683754,
-0.7194406986236572,
0.6380810141563416,
-0.4788088798522949,
0.1962457001209259,
-0.47778645157814026,
0.21618419885635376,
0.20351272821426392,
0.19759772717952728,
0.10114302486181259,
0.360720157623291,
0.3305160701274872,
-0.2568124532699585,
0.7376729846000671,
0.24755364656448364,
-0.3779177665710449,
0.4930082857608795,
-0.16158589720726013,
0.32412785291671753,
-0.43980416655540466,
-0.04417726770043373,
-1.075463056564331,
-0.1261095255613327,
-0.037234097719192505,
-0.3069414794445038,
0.39510640501976013,
0.053164251148700714,
-0.30715692043304443,
-0.5159337520599365,
-0.6098368167877197,
0.19225254654884338,
0.9888982176780701,
-0.7335259318351746,
0.4172230362892151,
0.08850260823965073,
-0.28870660066604614,
-0.6080815196037292,
-1.0701661109924316,
-0.16292181611061096,
-0.29000410437583923,
-0.3052639663219452,
0.05179005116224289,
-0.03484197333455086,
-0.1980588436126709,
0.1665974110364914,
0.23923322558403015,
-0.4034241735935211,
0.10994372516870499,
0.18493250012397766,
-0.17968273162841797,
-0.04746553301811218,
0.6437576413154602,
0.46436959505081177,
0.1776076853275299,
0.19729027152061462,
0.25203225016593933,
0.21488170325756073,
-0.25121909379959106,
-0.130997896194458,
-0.48489126563072205,
0.5953513979911804,
0.4700077772140503,
0.1392224282026291,
0.5321140885353088,
0.9184574484825134,
-0.6078659296035767,
-0.6683705449104309,
-0.2878688871860504,
-0.16768749058246613,
-0.4660387337207794,
0.42173442244529724,
-0.21796441078186035,
-1.050036072731018,
0.3596078157424927,
-0.15534524619579315,
-0.35456666350364685,
0.5929508805274963,
0.6041457056999207,
-0.8206402063369751,
0.960673987865448,
0.7148481607437134,
-0.4932677149772644,
0.3725130558013916,
-0.04350893199443817,
0.24933238327503204,
-0.2617265284061432,
-0.05839817598462105,
-0.6810468435287476,
-0.8218031525611877,
-0.7517125010490417,
-0.20701885223388672,
-0.17718958854675293,
-0.2142731249332428,
-0.08775530010461807,
0.06586020439863205,
-0.5387054681777954,
0.7868342399597168,
0.2516671121120453,
-0.011711487546563148,
-0.22053231298923492,
-0.09008500725030899,
0.16049893200397491,
-0.5668543577194214,
-0.24965861439704895,
-0.3174511790275574,
0.6314446926116943,
0.536728024482727,
0.9556376338005066,
0.028673380613327026,
1.009110450744629,
0.647219717502594,
0.4523255527019501,
-1.3630478382110596,
0.27330654859542847,
-0.6096559762954712,
-0.3212059438228607,
-0.2861019968986511,
-0.31521713733673096,
-1.0805482864379883,
-0.17125993967056274,
-0.20634858310222626,
-0.7127862572669983,
0.454327255487442,
-0.07894432544708252,
-0.29705795645713806,
0.25592678785324097,
-1.0540485382080078,
0.9179416298866272,
-0.4863370954990387,
-0.0060507142916321754,
-0.37845948338508606,
-0.6468839645385742,
0.26540252566337585,
-0.23761922121047974,
0.19355244934558868,
-0.21093325316905975,
-0.04202165827155113,
0.8177273273468018,
-0.15824036300182343,
0.9163463711738586,
-0.2299855500459671,
-0.010810241103172302,
0.3316231667995453,
0.2280283421278,
0.6909945607185364,
-0.27832674980163574,
0.028438374400138855,
-0.1006874218583107,
-0.17819544672966003,
-0.2377917319536209,
-0.5350399017333984,
0.7282091379165649,
-0.7503439784049988,
0.03889181464910507,
-0.47511833906173706,
-0.19072359800338745,
-0.2306220382452011,
0.164969339966774,
0.28419214487075806,
-0.15657523274421692,
-0.19094252586364746,
0.479497492313385,
0.605622410774231,
-0.3429725170135498,
0.740483283996582,
0.2684710621833801,
0.004914293996989727,
-0.2471468150615692,
0.9097948670387268,
0.06822563707828522,
-0.24698613584041595,
0.5217450857162476,
0.4690225422382355,
-0.42606669664382935,
-0.47061920166015625,
-0.01217060349881649,
0.022413261234760284,
-0.7398605942726135,
-0.4135870635509491,
-0.3573048412799835,
0.10330267995595932,
-0.2903534173965454,
-0.5369712710380554,
-0.5051248669624329,
0.057679880410432816,
-0.6390277743339539,
-0.45093634724617004,
0.41673579812049866,
0.9185242652893066,
-0.05748878791928291,
0.28985610604286194,
-1.2983956336975098,
0.14684396982192993,
0.5962474942207336,
0.3465782403945923,
0.00836518406867981,
-0.4201875329017639,
-0.39528951048851013,
-0.23168917000293732,
-0.14835135638713837,
-1.1170064210891724,
0.833602786064148,
0.49921905994415283,
-0.050714801996946335,
0.5267003178596497,
0.4524092376232147,
0.49463188648223877,
-0.5344642400741577,
0.9884651899337769,
0.20085370540618896,
-1.175750970840454,
0.7206432223320007,
0.17697463929653168,
-0.13840794563293457,
0.608057975769043,
0.9135274291038513,
-0.7237184047698975,
0.08845029771327972,
-0.4147002696990967,
-0.821528434753418,
0.4474102258682251,
-0.0009972775587812066,
0.3500809371471405,
-0.18658675253391266,
0.2919695973396301,
0.2614717185497284,
0.13148100674152374,
-0.6474858522415161,
-0.19780783355236053,
0.2166784405708313,
-0.9425737261772156,
-0.1709638237953186,
-0.44952788949012756,
0.07487666606903076,
-0.22930186986923218,
0.34329652786254883,
-0.22386156022548676,
0.4199882447719574,
0.2425186038017273,
-0.49764788150787354,
-0.030860424041748047,
0.2984769642353058,
0.5024721026420593,
-0.0846802294254303,
-0.3841347396373749,
0.13841627538204193,
0.44298383593559265,
-0.4535745084285736,
0.408541738986969,
0.09990191459655762,
0.33704376220703125,
0.3608170747756958,
0.42336344718933105,
0.8663994073867798,
0.23882685601711273,
-0.6391666531562805,
0.9808411598205566,
-0.19757452607154846,
-0.06875242292881012,
-0.08341183513402939,
-0.41822510957717896,
0.06336681544780731,
0.516704261302948,
0.27683886885643005,
-0.2506253123283386,
0.4250929355621338,
-0.44556188583374023,
0.14037814736366272,
0.17670661211013794,
-0.5857802629470825,
-0.33433014154434204,
0.07543356716632843,
0.5678200125694275,
-0.17511427402496338,
0.6700063943862915,
-0.22910234332084656,
-0.5424962043762207,
0.5055983662605286,
0.16145657002925873,
1.2632620334625244,
-0.26158207654953003,
0.14203307032585144,
-0.21268543601036072,
0.3780044913291931,
-0.04638493433594704,
0.5166734457015991,
0.15357673168182373,
-0.7249699831008911,
-0.6203672289848328,
-0.4208305776119232,
-0.8096482753753662,
-0.008643688634037971,
-0.7387917041778564,
0.14893805980682373,
-0.28628069162368774,
0.06898166984319687,
-0.13519342243671417,
0.3712817132472992,
-0.9337627291679382,
0.6258196830749512,
0.6770738363265991,
0.933412492275238,
-1.156479001045227,
1.0141525268554688,
0.7290745973587036,
-0.02383766695857048,
-0.6250249147415161,
-0.06868094205856323,
0.028912615031003952,
-0.7502771615982056,
0.8654672503471375,
0.48563167452812195,
-0.041058335453271866,
-0.06130313128232956,
-0.6484417915344238,
-0.2650429606437683,
0.7604524493217468,
0.17707154154777527,
-0.779342770576477,
0.13614819943904877,
0.09307988733053207,
0.8490927815437317,
-0.25733834505081177,
0.26156526803970337,
0.49774160981178284,
0.49356815218925476,
-0.43963927030563354,
-0.4522095322608948,
-0.24545393884181976,
-0.034612663090229034,
-0.39383646845817566,
0.2698059380054474,
-0.7175384759902954,
0.6205024123191833,
0.061132270842790604,
-0.37303104996681213,
-0.08447718620300293,
0.9036821722984314,
-0.40438830852508545,
0.5193276405334473,
0.465740829706192,
0.5473561882972717,
1.1945265531539917,
-0.2848070561885834,
0.9603655934333801,
0.05946322903037071,
0.7583627700805664,
0.7586758732795715,
-0.43172916769981384,
1.0856192111968994,
0.35243311524391174,
-0.27601945400238037,
0.6638463139533997,
0.8888203501701355,
0.019095836207270622,
0.629658579826355,
0.2159668207168579,
-0.1815187931060791,
0.07779630273580551,
-0.03811539709568024,
-0.22557349503040314,
0.2617376446723938,
0.4154749810695648,
-0.4152146279811859,
0.11926091462373734,
0.6946702599525452,
0.030195748433470726,
-0.108982615172863,
-0.39797908067703247,
0.8540754914283752,
0.3031652867794037,
-0.1297903060913086,
0.14493311941623688,
-0.33940157294273376,
1.1038858890533447,
-0.4010971784591675,
0.20735342800617218,
-0.5359233617782593,
0.27152693271636963,
-0.21049737930297852,
-1.2487742900848389,
0.30526256561279297,
0.20594097673892975,
-0.04875686392188072,
-0.3949839770793915,
1.1007161140441895,
-0.44125309586524963,
-0.32174551486968994,
0.5614435076713562,
0.2641589343547821,
0.32113704085350037,
-0.07553322613239288,
-0.6524674892425537,
-0.08958468586206436,
-0.03864118456840515,
-0.5555333495140076,
0.3719521164894104,
0.9512201547622681,
0.35071828961372375,
0.4192812144756317,
0.089383564889431,
-0.05699276924133301,
-0.12097607553005219,
-0.017628854140639305,
0.4922141432762146,
-1.0226401090621948,
-0.3207559883594513,
-0.9481079578399658,
0.5981382131576538,
-0.018022695556282997,
-0.25373023748397827,
0.5697335600852966,
0.19078631699085236,
0.7116982340812683,
-0.4728695750236511,
0.8068588376045227,
0.08767320960760117,
0.5455068349838257,
-0.36689743399620056,
0.5643149614334106,
-0.7388585805892944,
-0.378425657749176,
-0.3699474036693573,
-0.5415395498275757,
-0.43065354228019714,
0.6227186918258667,
-0.21171557903289795,
-0.26162955164909363,
1.0036147832870483,
0.13068413734436035,
0.14932593703269958,
0.1472736895084381,
0.36510899662971497,
0.24556206166744232,
0.0519060343503952,
0.824759304523468,
1.079569697380066,
-0.4903242290019989,
0.4855044186115265,
-0.6493017077445984,
0.09166768193244934,
-0.5975437760353088,
-1.1371880769729614,
-0.7734776139259338,
-0.39815565943717957,
-0.31618261337280273,
-0.3024727702140808,
-0.0016810002271085978,
1.0335025787353516,
0.47039321064949036,
-1.0269123315811157,
0.12995769083499908,
0.2914081811904907,
0.29447126388549805,
0.08931602537631989,
-0.3109906017780304,
0.5822799205780029,
-0.4751938581466675,
-1.0451723337173462,
0.38137370347976685,
0.1542242467403412,
0.3516651391983032,
0.0871027484536171,
-0.1626354306936264,
0.08217647671699524,
0.16537728905677795,
0.7701093554496765,
0.22230777144432068,
-0.30453434586524963,
-0.736414909362793,
-0.15670529007911682,
-0.49178653955459595,
-0.04984601214528084,
0.599026083946228,
-0.44322168827056885,
0.23413781821727753,
0.8284342885017395,
1.03128182888031,
0.3642199635505676,
-0.2351464182138443,
0.09394777566194534,
-1.2094687223434448,
0.1802556961774826,
0.665887713432312,
0.5754797458648682,
0.2252616584300995,
-0.6258264780044556,
0.42043885588645935,
0.20293420553207397,
-0.7932717800140381,
-0.815169095993042,
-0.05322442948818207,
-1.0232768058776855,
-0.36460068821907043,
0.8513965606689453,
-0.30162790417671204,
-0.1991180032491684,
0.39609938859939575,
-0.39911776781082153,
0.06555255502462387,
-0.3866834044456482,
0.7533285021781921,
0.8778915405273438,
-0.22955477237701416,
-0.40597763657569885,
-0.2282988280057907,
0.7396195530891418,
0.7619478106498718,
-0.8919604420661926,
-0.13731250166893005,
0.5269639492034912,
-0.22460705041885376,
0.1502191424369812,
0.13848967850208282,
0.3938552737236023,
-0.01415881235152483,
-0.34299343824386597,
0.19142957031726837,
0.37481456995010376,
-0.30801522731781006,
-0.6719218492507935,
0.35612285137176514,
-0.20224830508232117,
-0.3529152274131775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16030v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16030v1
|
Don't Forget Your Reward Values: Language Model Alignment via Value-based Calibration
| 2024-02-25T08:45:10 | 2024-02-25T08:45:10 |
Xin Mao, Feng-Lin Li, Huimin Xu, Wei Zhang, Anh Tuan Luu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) significantly
enhances the generation quality of Large Language Models (LLMs), recent studies
have raised concerns regarding the complexity and instability associated with
the Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) algorithm, proposing a series of
order-based calibration methods as viable alternatives. This paper delves
further into current order-based methods, examining their inefficiencies in
utilizing reward values and addressing misalignment issues. Building upon these
findings, we propose a novel \textbf{V}alue-based \textbf{C}ali\textbf{B}ration
(VCB) method to better align LLMs with human preferences. Experimental results
demonstrate that VCB surpasses existing alignment methods on AI assistant and
summarization datasets, providing impressive generalizability, robustness, and
stability in diverse settings.
|
[
-0.06107569858431816,
-0.13872112333774567,
0.3364458382129669,
0.15808217227458954,
0.01155655737966299,
0.08721858263015747,
-0.05008097365498543,
-0.09645869582891464,
0.27363941073417664,
0.5089030861854553,
-0.5701281428337097,
-0.16765449941158295,
-0.2939243018627167,
-0.2583743929862976,
0.33382588624954224,
1.0377942323684692,
0.018414316698908806,
0.23593643307685852,
-0.39258867502212524,
-0.4555152356624603,
-0.671811044216156,
-0.5906733274459839,
-0.45338544249534607,
-0.637399435043335,
0.7834112644195557,
0.6044335961341858,
0.9648423194885254,
1.023169755935669,
0.4714300036430359,
0.27728623151779175,
-0.04701025038957596,
0.5449361801147461,
-0.6038616895675659,
-0.07113856077194214,
-0.1551159769296646,
-0.36406785249710083,
-0.6260151863098145,
-0.02522345446050167,
0.3099178969860077,
0.6118937730789185,
-0.6206174492835999,
-0.002583713037893176,
-0.21519073843955994,
1.0095009803771973,
-1.0710594654083252,
0.05952899903059006,
-0.2875405550003052,
-0.20883598923683167,
0.0716143548488617,
-0.29240867495536804,
-0.528756856918335,
-0.90010005235672,
0.1579308807849884,
-0.5014424920082092,
-0.37286537885665894,
0.13485310971736908,
1.2078129053115845,
0.4464391767978668,
-0.32505789399147034,
-0.2312449812889099,
-0.6175659894943237,
1.280595064163208,
-0.6172146201133728,
0.27223631739616394,
0.4412898123264313,
0.26615482568740845,
-0.3479367792606354,
-0.20270149409770966,
-0.48769432306289673,
-0.06618987023830414,
0.05350029841065407,
0.32417967915534973,
0.1433328092098236,
0.16740533709526062,
-0.11504797637462616,
0.24618074297904968,
-0.39878007769584656,
0.31727170944213867,
-0.06377756595611572,
-0.19609969854354858,
0.6408576369285583,
0.17709027230739594,
0.10940787941217422,
0.17686931788921356,
-0.22500233352184296,
-0.67829430103302,
-1.0037769079208374,
0.4198310375213623,
0.5731274485588074,
0.24490424990653992,
0.12839214503765106,
0.5785671472549438,
0.05544376000761986,
0.7816492915153503,
0.3494621217250824,
-0.3048474192619324,
0.33124926686286926,
-0.2708083987236023,
-0.2026997208595276,
0.2971198260784149,
0.7050497531890869,
0.5175936818122864,
0.2610064148902893,
-0.05419061332941055,
-0.1580779105424881,
-0.10067454725503922,
0.3715422451496124,
-0.48300451040267944,
-0.02902044914662838,
0.26228684186935425,
-0.16287340223789215,
-0.4401301443576813,
-0.0036702740471810102,
-0.26300451159477234,
-0.29622188210487366,
-0.4985414743423462,
0.3818437159061432,
-0.27342310547828674,
-0.05817866697907448,
0.03377718850970268,
0.1715112030506134,
0.46651265025138855,
0.3733085095882416,
-1.3982892036437988,
0.11910221725702286,
0.7070762515068054,
0.47109565138816833,
0.009481566026806831,
-0.3245786726474762,
-0.807051420211792,
0.1801905333995819,
-0.6578783988952637,
0.6523830890655518,
-0.3874494135379791,
-0.3209656774997711,
-0.0358445942401886,
-0.23918938636779785,
0.10037253797054291,
-0.7730823755264282,
0.45353153347969055,
-0.6005234122276306,
0.35409411787986755,
-0.644843578338623,
-0.4168458878993988,
-0.007402870804071426,
0.23025786876678467,
-0.541241466999054,
0.9441666007041931,
0.22460460662841797,
-0.4971991181373596,
0.31129392981529236,
-0.2572864890098572,
-0.20735126733779907,
-0.08192460983991623,
-0.2572028636932373,
-0.6083299517631531,
0.10745992511510849,
0.31079334020614624,
0.07069295644760132,
-0.14230097830295563,
0.474710613489151,
-0.2591870427131653,
-0.5195662379264832,
0.389301061630249,
-0.45681890845298767,
0.6300254464149475,
0.09881680458784103,
-0.17708981037139893,
0.405667245388031,
-0.4314998686313629,
0.18013998866081238,
-0.09867317229509354,
-0.4120951294898987,
-0.2857038974761963,
0.3049135208129883,
-0.3500789999961853,
0.19321274757385254,
0.3887104392051697,
-0.23551148176193237,
0.16883975267410278,
-0.7628953456878662,
0.30820122361183167,
1.166245460510254,
-0.3424112796783447,
0.6780456900596619,
-0.7467779517173767,
0.5746350884437561,
-0.022772734984755516,
0.05073637142777443,
0.04850537329912186,
0.04501675069332123,
-0.6333410143852234,
-0.09480325877666473,
0.40830931067466736,
0.8732017278671265,
-0.3747568726539612,
0.7326598763465881,
-0.4475766718387604,
-0.368061363697052,
-0.6887024641036987,
0.05979223921895027,
0.6109231114387512,
0.5727130174636841,
0.249698206782341,
-0.39873358607292175,
-0.25280728936195374,
-0.9887281656265259,
-0.07610724121332169,
-0.689936101436615,
-0.03433612361550331,
0.3787762224674225,
-0.03127855062484741,
0.014774500392377377,
0.9864164590835571,
-0.39204323291778564,
-0.03755961358547211,
-0.03663446754217148,
0.11608324199914932,
0.08252403885126114,
0.3971714973449707,
0.40150293707847595,
-0.6154170036315918,
-0.11931628733873367,
0.04471391439437866,
-0.4410383999347687,
-0.3066776394844055,
-0.11835659295320511,
-0.2694646120071411,
0.31606027483940125,
0.2965388298034668,
-0.15704582631587982,
-0.07955446094274521,
0.6292528510093689,
-0.015430230647325516,
0.3608654737472534,
-0.33239731192588806,
0.1788897067308426,
-0.9380925297737122,
-0.06377582252025604,
-0.11356104165315628,
-0.4609142243862152,
-0.24410876631736755,
-0.3660068213939667,
0.3740963041782379,
0.26718267798423767,
-0.5623992681503296,
0.558885931968689,
-0.17435240745544434,
0.12058596312999725,
-0.3269828259944916,
0.03939150646328926,
-0.005898434668779373,
0.513218104839325,
0.13326896727085114,
0.8990378379821777,
-0.009691375307738781,
-0.5625537633895874,
0.24879619479179382,
0.22863326966762543,
0.011258790269494057,
0.880987823009491,
-0.4430598020553589,
0.03407968208193779,
-0.41352444887161255,
0.10493891686201096,
-0.8824133276939392,
-0.023776540532708168,
0.28128430247306824,
-0.4696316123008728,
0.4343600869178772,
0.07959531247615814,
-0.12202174216508865,
0.001014241948723793,
-0.5137977004051208,
0.52580326795578,
0.42320603132247925,
-0.5495296716690063,
0.3568189740180969,
0.6053082942962646,
-0.22077494859695435,
-1.1509759426116943,
-0.23872005939483643,
-0.08934641629457474,
-0.2733839452266693,
-0.3235771059989929,
0.5820320248603821,
-0.39194780588150024,
-0.22119827568531036,
-0.21173712611198425,
-0.3417675197124481,
0.19090192019939423,
-0.0050751580856740475,
0.23699428141117096,
0.5369387865066528,
-0.10163111984729767,
0.10136425495147705,
0.05117615684866905,
-0.3259713649749756,
-0.17503519356250763,
-0.1933884173631668,
0.3328683078289032,
-0.3556821942329407,
-0.12053672224283218,
-0.235512375831604,
0.08477632701396942,
0.5363067388534546,
-0.22139587998390198,
0.7152231335639954,
0.1784110963344574,
-0.14679601788520813,
0.11560878902673721,
-0.6702316403388977,
-0.025708382949233055,
-0.5123790502548218,
0.37309372425079346,
-0.026302548125386238,
-0.8063049912452698,
0.2198181301355362,
-0.0196620412170887,
0.18548715114593506,
0.10349265486001968,
0.7508363723754883,
-0.2838228940963745,
1.0660443305969238,
0.7567793130874634,
-0.40090885758399963,
0.781201958656311,
0.2171742469072342,
0.3425491452217102,
-0.5893232226371765,
-0.23197315633296967,
-0.41862043738365173,
-0.3653787076473236,
-0.6178668141365051,
-0.14060094952583313,
0.14934681355953217,
0.25637054443359375,
-0.6564580798149109,
0.2898818254470825,
-0.33163440227508545,
0.775115430355072,
0.5905303359031677,
0.12359271943569183,
0.09249168634414673,
-0.065521240234375,
0.1059068813920021,
-0.3049366772174835,
-0.6210294365882874,
-0.6450183391571045,
1.0393885374069214,
0.13819468021392822,
0.802065908908844,
0.154630646109581,
0.7691550850868225,
0.1764199137687683,
0.5649753212928772,
-0.8150925636291504,
0.2774246335029602,
-0.15798841416835785,
-0.045956920832395554,
-0.5338559150695801,
-0.5399632453918457,
-0.9541981816291809,
0.17190589010715485,
0.12725277245044708,
-0.7497209310531616,
0.37447047233581543,
0.522077739238739,
-0.6608825325965881,
-0.11453165858983994,
-0.7792871594429016,
0.9054252505302429,
-0.6513012051582336,
-0.39644378423690796,
-0.040956612676382065,
-0.670889139175415,
0.08142398297786713,
0.2745765745639801,
0.2532501518726349,
-0.20541968941688538,
-0.08053644746541977,
0.6354527473449707,
-0.7663044929504395,
0.44481801986694336,
0.04703247919678688,
-0.09394146502017975,
0.06839459389448166,
0.05833201855421066,
0.5936360955238342,
-0.11110016703605652,
-0.0007708259508945048,
-0.10541148483753204,
-0.08183937519788742,
-0.5815686583518982,
-0.5119132399559021,
0.8938510417938232,
-0.9749203324317932,
-0.4428417980670929,
-0.6485419869422913,
-0.7206041216850281,
-0.34819161891937256,
0.04886540398001671,
-0.04207513481378555,
-0.016812806949019432,
-0.11247667670249939,
-0.05014777556061745,
0.7169573903083801,
-0.3099847137928009,
0.47036314010620117,
0.37251460552215576,
0.2005133032798767,
-0.8367791771888733,
1.1526763439178467,
0.030195843428373337,
0.4160499572753906,
0.7597864270210266,
0.2806147336959839,
-0.32224687933921814,
-0.1107393130660057,
-0.48438560962677,
0.46694907546043396,
-0.5292701125144958,
-0.44279998540878296,
-0.18041901290416718,
0.06746046990156174,
-0.37802496552467346,
-0.6004887819290161,
-0.6270226240158081,
-0.3349161446094513,
-0.19772234559059143,
-0.12778067588806152,
0.15394257009029388,
0.26630258560180664,
-0.10615716129541397,
0.4832085967063904,
-0.6384809017181396,
0.08553322404623032,
0.30123552680015564,
0.2801927924156189,
-0.2054997831583023,
-0.3421638011932373,
-0.35530003905296326,
0.27026328444480896,
-0.5741579532623291,
-0.8595775365829468,
0.4932548701763153,
-0.18299317359924316,
0.4703435003757477,
0.3390945494174957,
-0.018573669716715813,
0.9374700784683228,
-0.2874718904495239,
0.6114515662193298,
0.34905457496643066,
-1.0161813497543335,
0.4335918724536896,
-0.07113521546125412,
0.26392218470573425,
0.7127140760421753,
0.15182259678840637,
-0.6805224418640137,
0.048540689051151276,
-0.45996376872062683,
-1.1852351427078247,
0.8695384860038757,
-0.07509631663560867,
0.1083257719874382,
0.1451990157365799,
0.3576458990573883,
-0.1729775369167328,
0.39239248633384705,
-0.9156042337417603,
-0.23155148327350616,
-0.23587849736213684,
-0.6110842227935791,
0.01380958966910839,
-0.1367604285478592,
-0.06205993518233299,
0.031734514981508255,
0.8951842188835144,
-0.1995881050825119,
0.0056160129606723785,
-0.08191172033548355,
-0.1652706116437912,
-0.4088737368583679,
0.3048167824745178,
0.7945441603660583,
0.8840528130531311,
-0.45023155212402344,
-0.15554660558700562,
0.07149451225996017,
-0.1601506769657135,
0.47885259985923767,
-0.21329109370708466,
-0.14754384756088257,
-0.473032683134079,
0.07466936111450195,
0.740445613861084,
0.15981537103652954,
-0.9797842502593994,
0.7135443091392517,
0.02018769085407257,
-0.0302345659583807,
-0.25171932578086853,
0.20432612299919128,
0.14423887431621552,
0.1401427686214447,
-0.04079650714993477,
-0.13289013504981995,
-0.28403788805007935,
-0.3947625160217285,
0.0035310275852680206,
0.4767354428768158,
-0.6388077139854431,
0.04621684178709984,
0.5708417892456055,
-0.0749741867184639,
-0.4536203145980835,
0.8094810843467712,
-0.07307061553001404,
-0.2604886591434479,
0.6466233730316162,
0.49192291498184204,
0.7381497621536255,
-0.4100324511528015,
0.31905341148376465,
0.299369215965271,
0.34778159856796265,
-0.4665113091468811,
0.2304486781358719,
-0.05862119048833847,
-0.8629989624023438,
-0.6258826851844788,
-0.5145961046218872,
-0.706099271774292,
-0.055987872183322906,
-0.613520622253418,
0.32806649804115295,
-0.4645695388317108,
-0.1267206370830536,
-0.23594804108142853,
-0.09394118189811707,
-0.39748692512512207,
0.15965591371059418,
0.03538782149553299,
0.2759421169757843,
-0.9344963431358337,
0.6756231188774109,
0.6577205061912537,
-0.5627151727676392,
-1.0147571563720703,
-0.15711301565170288,
0.08557768166065216,
-0.9391101598739624,
0.6829612851142883,
-0.11067807674407959,
-0.25527408719062805,
-0.13569185137748718,
-0.45790544152259827,
-0.916431725025177,
1.151107907295227,
0.5826821327209473,
-0.6610949635505676,
-0.11958026885986328,
-0.011411726474761963,
0.39325833320617676,
-0.30276957154273987,
0.5707046985626221,
0.4929508864879608,
0.4578644335269928,
0.2572982907295227,
-0.8800505995750427,
-0.16900138556957245,
-0.043795034289360046,
0.2520858347415924,
0.43151941895484924,
-0.9146314859390259,
0.369760125875473,
-0.22077712416648865,
0.11484105885028839,
-0.04627194628119469,
0.6637998223304749,
0.5161268711090088,
0.02897663228213787,
0.3266277611255646,
0.7336677312850952,
0.8140073418617249,
-0.12325025349855423,
0.8209113478660583,
-0.005408427212387323,
0.17557720839977264,
1.0887451171875,
-0.38011786341667175,
0.7545700073242188,
0.7532501220703125,
-0.27727922797203064,
0.45234841108322144,
0.87850022315979,
0.2252136468887329,
0.7295225262641907,
0.4013223350048065,
-0.01383961457759142,
-0.25363898277282715,
-0.16292139887809753,
-0.18904204666614532,
0.06623811274766922,
0.20425130426883698,
-0.09199101477861404,
-0.059717051684856415,
-0.41019150614738464,
0.13219939172267914,
0.2551153302192688,
-0.2934666872024536,
0.8844640851020813,
-0.03929596394300461,
-0.9813133478164673,
0.6515183448791504,
0.13674962520599365,
0.4973847568035126,
-0.6658101677894592,
-0.06488588452339172,
-0.4338427782058716,
0.40053504705429077,
-0.13546864688396454,
-0.4115827679634094,
0.1254848837852478,
-0.33737000823020935,
-0.34691327810287476,
-0.5364187955856323,
0.014499646611511707,
-0.5295039415359497,
-0.3330094516277313,
0.013807274401187897,
0.2593810558319092,
-0.14119935035705566,
0.21396571397781372,
-0.615023136138916,
-0.06445687264204025,
0.025683745741844177,
-0.15362095832824707,
0.4630802273750305,
0.1778428703546524,
-0.3713299632072449,
0.5484569668769836,
0.4153648912906647,
0.21680359542369843,
-0.25236544013023376,
0.12740878760814667,
0.37614136934280396,
-0.7490087747573853,
-0.513022780418396,
-1.0054796934127808,
0.4942317008972168,
0.13525919616222382,
-0.24426892399787903,
0.30372118949890137,
0.5070978999137878,
1.1906569004058838,
0.16679030656814575,
0.5046858191490173,
0.32314255833625793,
0.16258415579795837,
-0.45429953932762146,
0.3970947265625,
-0.49114081263542175,
0.40578508377075195,
-0.328668475151062,
-0.852060854434967,
-0.49689429998397827,
0.7832773923873901,
-0.4111647605895996,
0.08227432519197464,
0.5700160264968872,
1.0993791818618774,
0.10977452993392944,
-0.3172096908092499,
0.16370023787021637,
-0.17166125774383545,
0.39187851548194885,
0.7391204833984375,
0.5588473677635193,
-0.38132819533348083,
0.6038500666618347,
-0.1620120257139206,
-0.4002729058265686,
-0.374595046043396,
-1.0232828855514526,
-0.3631118834018707,
-0.3696017265319824,
-0.4341433048248291,
-0.5781495571136475,
0.20258887112140656,
1.296040415763855,
0.747746467590332,
-0.9129875898361206,
-0.7431556582450867,
-0.09524078667163849,
0.4687454402446747,
-0.5358486771583557,
-0.17035792768001556,
0.4921101927757263,
-0.2995513677597046,
-0.701194703578949,
0.1711692065000534,
0.5507081151008606,
0.13918739557266235,
0.01289493590593338,
-0.5738577246665955,
-0.14380210638046265,
0.25525131821632385,
0.35219740867614746,
0.5118403434753418,
-0.847817063331604,
-0.275188684463501,
0.11533492803573608,
-0.2844600975513458,
0.3854645788669586,
0.8203497529029846,
-0.7191973924636841,
0.5191778540611267,
0.5412010550498962,
0.8707826137542725,
0.17047061026096344,
0.28151869773864746,
0.8614316582679749,
-0.6131108999252319,
-0.11908216774463654,
0.35137739777565,
0.30208250880241394,
0.26314935088157654,
-0.3335932493209839,
0.22287942469120026,
0.021175531670451164,
-0.7273415327072144,
-0.8019865155220032,
0.42670777440071106,
-1.0275862216949463,
-0.06983935832977295,
0.6232373714447021,
0.00659361993893981,
-0.3366905748844147,
0.3221822679042816,
-0.319000244140625,
0.15331138670444489,
-0.5887949466705322,
1.0201380252838135,
0.8511519432067871,
-0.19829235970973969,
-0.2961897850036621,
-0.12027476727962494,
0.3609752953052521,
0.8926869034767151,
-0.7383549809455872,
0.17172101140022278,
0.7958781123161316,
0.04363635927438736,
0.04806799069046974,
0.78528892993927,
-0.2786829173564911,
0.3400035798549652,
-0.5180181264877319,
0.14369267225265503,
0.002600506180897355,
-0.24343650043010712,
-0.41903361678123474,
-0.037849459797143936,
0.5103989243507385,
-0.19335685670375824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16029v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16029v5
|
GraphWiz: An Instruction-Following Language Model for Graph Problems
| 2024-02-25T08:41:32 | 2024-07-03T06:39:59 |
Nuo Chen, Yuhan Li, Jianheng Tang, Jia Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive success across several
fields, but their proficiency in understanding and resolving complex graph
problems is less explored. To bridge this gap, we introduce GraphInstruct, a
novel and comprehensive instruction-tuning dataset designed to equip language
models with the ability to tackle a broad spectrum of graph problems using
explicit reasoning paths. Utilizing GraphInstruct, we build GraphWiz, an
open-source language model capable of resolving various graph problem types
while generating clear reasoning processes. To enhance the model's capability
and reliability, we incorporate the Direct Preference Optimization (DPO)
framework into the graph problem-solving context. The enhanced model,
GraphWiz-DPO, achieves an average accuracy of 65% across nine tasks with
different complexity levels, surpassing GPT-4 which has an average accuracy of
43.8%. Moreover, our research delves into the delicate balance between training
data volume and model performance, highlighting the potential for overfitting
with increased data. We also explore the transferability of the model's
reasoning ability across different graph tasks, indicating the model's
adaptability and practical application potential. Our investigation offers a
new blueprint and valuable insights for developing LLMs specialized in graph
reasoning and problem-solving.
|
[
-0.12382341921329498,
-0.895081102848053,
0.6431879997253418,
-0.09616678953170776,
0.1578284054994583,
0.4614212214946747,
-0.15302371978759766,
-0.24429801106452942,
-0.2216905802488327,
0.8092119693756104,
-0.6785680651664734,
-0.7107358574867249,
-0.6626095175743103,
-0.19845230877399445,
-0.26082196831703186,
0.73881995677948,
-0.26437610387802124,
-0.07268072664737701,
-0.3105577826499939,
0.2790611684322357,
-0.3813486099243164,
-0.09167177230119705,
-0.6408196091651917,
-0.4514118731021881,
0.41030049324035645,
0.6607403755187988,
0.7705689668655396,
0.6884548664093018,
0.1823955923318863,
0.29379773139953613,
-0.012621804140508175,
0.6634635925292969,
-0.7158594727516174,
-0.1722273975610733,
-0.019767338410019875,
-0.24681727588176727,
-0.43149352073669434,
0.06590136140584946,
0.6120805144309998,
1.1483371257781982,
-0.03097820281982422,
0.07807940989732742,
-0.040513776242733,
0.8459830284118652,
-0.4347914457321167,
0.6056573390960693,
-0.6063276529312134,
-0.06540781259536743,
0.020576266571879387,
-0.0019091174472123384,
-0.8608152270317078,
-0.4850744903087616,
-0.048762816935777664,
-0.7176469564437866,
0.07087539881467819,
0.1668422818183899,
0.6143295168876648,
0.19790758192539215,
-0.5573529601097107,
-0.24541254341602325,
-0.5275999307632446,
0.27230000495910645,
-0.6187822222709656,
0.438495010137558,
0.4397248327732086,
0.13748395442962646,
-0.5289288759231567,
-0.8697549104690552,
-0.3321278691291809,
-0.0813116803765297,
0.304361492395401,
-0.045593708753585815,
-0.2999096214771271,
0.31507107615470886,
0.29570773243904114,
0.010733167640864849,
-0.4896565079689026,
0.3554786145687103,
-0.2514564096927643,
-0.06665832549333572,
0.42374011874198914,
0.3617061376571655,
0.6908953785896301,
0.023613881319761276,
-0.0011414753971621394,
0.06946736574172974,
-0.7444393634796143,
0.21134407818317413,
0.7142939567565918,
0.597110390663147,
0.047494176775217056,
0.4448419511318207,
-0.432644248008728,
1.1994800567626953,
0.07383394241333008,
0.053246308118104935,
0.15229666233062744,
0.044650156050920486,
-0.010943506844341755,
0.025126028805971146,
0.5036829113960266,
0.31437596678733826,
0.4957307279109955,
-0.32461991906166077,
0.0349305123090744,
-0.04354402422904968,
0.10072068125009537,
-0.9654927253723145,
-0.7873802781105042,
0.1333273947238922,
-0.0433269664645195,
-0.22221671044826508,
-0.2004462033510208,
-0.2600187659263611,
-0.4078524708747864,
-0.30809512734413147,
0.11372789740562439,
-0.6317542791366577,
-0.1890624314546585,
0.5669125318527222,
-0.15732620656490326,
-0.2745894193649292,
0.36104217171669006,
-0.9552355408668518,
0.18416063487529755,
0.7806433439254761,
0.6897913813591003,
-0.11038624495267868,
-0.34874388575553894,
-0.5170053243637085,
0.27511531114578247,
-0.7222066521644592,
0.7445482611656189,
-0.9399430751800537,
-0.3924594223499298,
-0.09619495272636414,
0.07521337270736694,
-0.3016318678855896,
-0.3352120816707611,
0.44854867458343506,
-0.6102617979049683,
-0.11054878681898117,
-0.18570195138454437,
-0.941192626953125,
-0.20503512024879456,
0.08019079267978668,
-0.5913448929786682,
0.958050012588501,
0.43122902512550354,
-0.8280996084213257,
0.06207338348031044,
-0.4296431541442871,
-0.5918248891830444,
0.28730571269989014,
-0.16134627163410187,
-0.3197702467441559,
-0.18215052783489227,
0.24670185148715973,
0.15461550652980804,
-0.05048590525984764,
0.042137306183576584,
-0.388284832239151,
-0.6103696227073669,
-0.12307998538017273,
-0.13904821872711182,
1.1246471405029297,
-0.2000061571598053,
-0.14963732659816742,
0.18427784740924835,
-0.5670529007911682,
0.45809614658355713,
0.35026922821998596,
-0.24159975349903107,
-0.21473458409309387,
0.18369877338409424,
-0.5643059015274048,
0.06791515648365021,
0.2624923884868622,
-0.692050576210022,
0.44144198298454285,
-0.4457584321498871,
0.644778847694397,
1.090927004814148,
-0.19067685306072235,
0.3464837372303009,
0.20651252567768097,
0.4056205749511719,
-0.43342265486717224,
0.3455331027507782,
0.039577972143888474,
-0.5563228726387024,
-0.6111714839935303,
-0.1496664434671402,
0.06433167308568954,
0.526952862739563,
-0.7106625437736511,
0.22446396946907043,
-0.38831162452697754,
-0.461290180683136,
-0.20495858788490295,
0.17130018770694733,
0.26731574535369873,
1.0149680376052856,
0.3128681480884552,
0.22685836255550385,
-0.21478332579135895,
-0.7129297256469727,
0.03866470605134964,
-0.03560589998960495,
0.34296441078186035,
0.6232597231864929,
0.17538540065288544,
-0.33031025528907776,
0.7744463682174683,
-1.0645965337753296,
0.08396058529615402,
-0.5685855746269226,
-0.34861087799072266,
0.2933975160121918,
0.046553224325180054,
0.5098237991333008,
-0.5572892427444458,
-0.8914075493812561,
0.15242798626422882,
-0.4286882281303406,
-0.1494780033826828,
0.580470860004425,
-0.35870108008384705,
-0.004204607103019953,
0.36349138617515564,
-0.658437967300415,
0.1862678974866867,
0.601128101348877,
-0.4679180085659027,
0.5688247084617615,
-0.1716807782649994,
-0.01165248267352581,
-0.604240894317627,
-0.2760038673877716,
-0.16210293769836426,
-0.13710986077785492,
-0.46184563636779785,
-0.1100049614906311,
0.05005451291799545,
-0.42605119943618774,
-0.06165939196944237,
0.4370128810405731,
-0.38604819774627686,
-0.02348225563764572,
-0.38610145449638367,
0.1633809506893158,
0.300240695476532,
0.44546428322792053,
-0.3397393822669983,
0.7928471565246582,
0.6763895750045776,
-0.44507044553756714,
0.6717165112495422,
0.4161536693572998,
-0.4561770260334015,
0.012816846370697021,
-0.5700072646141052,
0.485726535320282,
-0.1531534343957901,
0.16833306849002838,
-1.0196908712387085,
-0.2852664887905121,
0.4045889973640442,
-0.22296199202537537,
0.4874942898750305,
-0.6389123797416687,
-0.6494847536087036,
-0.7009931206703186,
0.018511466681957245,
-0.01641632802784443,
0.42962342500686646,
-0.6413223743438721,
0.37798866629600525,
0.3560211956501007,
-0.2673671543598175,
-0.7027143239974976,
-0.24108998477458954,
-0.027405062690377235,
0.31968390941619873,
-0.6771273016929626,
0.3335631787776947,
-0.1121029257774353,
0.03559117391705513,
0.22192583978176117,
-0.2380482703447342,
-0.11259668320417404,
0.06948636472225189,
0.09565188735723495,
0.42118287086486816,
0.11292237788438797,
0.1410302370786667,
0.1563071608543396,
-0.22930528223514557,
-0.0013287593610584736,
-0.4301895797252655,
0.6484875679016113,
-0.0067371465265750885,
-0.5472429394721985,
-0.19821758568286896,
0.1431959867477417,
0.08181457966566086,
-0.43213725090026855,
0.3591153621673584,
0.1481451839208603,
0.018263567239046097,
-0.7083038091659546,
0.07308588176965714,
0.04618922993540764,
-0.5389747619628906,
0.8244833946228027,
-0.345878005027771,
-0.6927987337112427,
0.18977025151252747,
-0.3143440783023834,
0.04086722806096077,
-0.05700770020484924,
0.19233334064483643,
-0.2654397785663605,
1.4116994142532349,
0.5320499539375305,
-0.1217273697257042,
0.699748694896698,
-0.4040859639644623,
0.3640809953212738,
-0.552486777305603,
-0.0931684672832489,
-0.28001052141189575,
-0.042574357241392136,
-0.4750089645385742,
-0.40161991119384766,
0.18890509009361267,
-0.05897567421197891,
-0.5707585215568542,
0.15438233315944672,
-0.6800545454025269,
0.7215101718902588,
0.28836947679519653,
0.47980570793151855,
0.13771912455558777,
0.1712874472141266,
0.14480383694171906,
0.15380972623825073,
-0.9614742398262024,
-0.252861350774765,
0.9730782508850098,
0.015340691432356834,
0.7126271724700928,
-0.12349559366703033,
0.5202677249908447,
0.22673743963241577,
0.19207972288131714,
-0.7351714372634888,
0.604058027267456,
-0.6343142986297607,
-0.4481778144836426,
-0.442031592130661,
-0.627832293510437,
-0.8993330597877502,
-0.10366914421319962,
0.17703308165073395,
-0.856216549873352,
-0.3270726501941681,
0.34384405612945557,
0.21025831997394562,
0.5601168274879456,
-0.7540283203125,
1.0086461305618286,
-0.4028313159942627,
-0.2324763536453247,
-0.2136281430721283,
-0.28636953234672546,
0.11828290671110153,
0.4214758574962616,
0.15883006155490875,
-0.5161594152450562,
0.1306164264678955,
0.29208242893218994,
-0.3910210430622101,
0.90876305103302,
-0.3457953929901123,
-0.0520203560590744,
0.42525288462638855,
0.20288240909576416,
0.8579239249229431,
-0.5098473429679871,
-0.24306882917881012,
-0.03728055581450462,
-0.3457777202129364,
-0.3992493748664856,
-0.9399176239967346,
0.7267918586730957,
-0.8278837203979492,
-0.765653133392334,
0.2367926985025406,
-0.7462649345397949,
-0.4883994460105896,
0.5352095365524292,
0.13356509804725647,
0.7515665888786316,
-0.028881678357720375,
-0.18638202548027039,
0.7873955368995667,
-0.14222516119480133,
0.03779524937272072,
0.2416999489068985,
-0.3120858073234558,
-0.1553441435098648,
1.186254620552063,
0.3198893964290619,
0.385151207447052,
0.20612940192222595,
0.2594003677368164,
-0.04449176788330078,
-0.8265242576599121,
-0.736167848110199,
0.09945281594991684,
-1.0859311819076538,
-0.069271981716156,
-0.49923157691955566,
-0.2730778753757477,
-0.2307893931865692,
-0.12428682297468185,
-0.5623650550842285,
-0.2622012197971344,
0.0015265214024111629,
-0.34065675735473633,
0.522117555141449,
0.6784117817878723,
0.4390619397163391,
0.033986274152994156,
-0.46329182386398315,
0.1245012879371643,
0.16600894927978516,
0.7079996466636658,
-0.041585084050893784,
-0.3986099064350128,
-0.43004125356674194,
0.07362217456102371,
-0.14914578199386597,
-0.7756451368331909,
0.0032117031514644623,
0.11418024450540543,
0.7483674883842468,
0.1750197857618332,
0.20806288719177246,
0.38249558210372925,
-0.7013934850692749,
0.2433345764875412,
-0.025009844452142715,
-0.831933319568634,
0.5115484595298767,
-0.4030981659889221,
0.05493703484535217,
0.2784935534000397,
0.43814030289649963,
-0.22635352611541748,
-0.19618308544158936,
-0.3522632122039795,
-0.874042809009552,
0.6903066635131836,
-0.05255495011806488,
0.30593228340148926,
-0.0271761491894722,
0.6177873015403748,
0.03763583302497864,
0.001919967238791287,
-0.4717905521392822,
-0.36727163195610046,
-0.31207937002182007,
-0.42586347460746765,
0.03012452833354473,
-0.059855181723833084,
-0.10632854700088501,
-0.30745890736579895,
0.7070979475975037,
-0.38902905583381653,
0.031787123531103134,
-0.3455580174922943,
-0.028806010261178017,
-0.08449392020702362,
-0.06807653605937958,
0.08604360371828079,
0.8570272326469421,
-0.037935346364974976,
0.07688647508621216,
-0.04304230958223343,
-0.37050285935401917,
0.14763645827770233,
0.2934006154537201,
-0.382335364818573,
-0.23061615228652954,
0.4168334901332855,
0.9969754219055176,
0.12126415222883224,
-0.6784337759017944,
0.4318573474884033,
0.3344272971153259,
0.06613381952047348,
0.039422377943992615,
0.48083001375198364,
0.39943811297416687,
0.03816758096218109,
0.19847123324871063,
-0.2713763117790222,
0.2538168430328369,
-0.2267683446407318,
-0.031165312975645065,
0.506413459777832,
-0.39278700947761536,
-0.17633692920207977,
0.3837861716747284,
0.35735324025154114,
-0.3699646592140198,
1.1167607307434082,
-0.21502147614955902,
-0.6078540086746216,
0.9685112237930298,
0.7788339853286743,
0.43587324023246765,
0.0253371000289917,
0.47382450103759766,
0.3054274022579193,
0.15850654244422913,
0.15708795189857483,
0.1280481070280075,
0.10108325630426407,
-1.0877147912979126,
-0.4752681255340576,
-0.00007512639422202483,
-0.6033504009246826,
-0.22735273838043213,
-0.45274534821510315,
0.2135111540555954,
-0.5607998967170715,
-0.2319810539484024,
0.08192285895347595,
0.09725835174322128,
-0.4092830717563629,
0.07571595162153244,
0.022545944899320602,
0.8404892683029175,
-0.6969839930534363,
0.7596810460090637,
0.6252474784851074,
-0.21137838065624237,
-0.8944698572158813,
-0.09578423202037811,
-0.21767057478427887,
-0.9018542170524597,
0.7468053698539734,
0.2065500020980835,
-0.5190567970275879,
0.3858140707015991,
-0.8595042824745178,
-0.7976894378662109,
0.8731284737586975,
0.8670037984848022,
-0.5166074633598328,
-0.16692112386226654,
-0.01796133443713188,
0.20575864613056183,
-0.3500232994556427,
-0.06949225813150406,
0.391001433134079,
0.30447569489479065,
0.007444001268595457,
-0.5039965510368347,
-0.013575170189142227,
-0.09652876853942871,
-0.20986713469028473,
0.3869125247001648,
-0.9161920547485352,
0.8331157565116882,
-0.5972027778625488,
-0.13332010805606842,
-0.3885726034641266,
0.27072975039482117,
0.31282317638397217,
0.2664506137371063,
0.41017523407936096,
0.31709426641464233,
0.9630911350250244,
0.12784245610237122,
1.2078642845153809,
-0.5748307108879089,
0.2383423149585724,
1.279896855354309,
-0.3334122598171234,
0.4627843499183655,
0.0002958923578262329,
-0.3584589958190918,
0.8492733240127563,
0.7355481386184692,
0.0696973204612732,
0.48712801933288574,
0.14407378435134888,
0.015266668982803822,
-0.5471115708351135,
0.05144230276346207,
-0.1469896286725998,
0.40968093276023865,
0.32516759634017944,
-0.25948572158813477,
-0.06551767885684967,
-0.29697632789611816,
0.16921721398830414,
0.2048524171113968,
-0.3896796405315399,
0.2649940550327301,
-0.14179658889770508,
-0.32285210490226746,
0.2641974985599518,
-0.07088178396224976,
-0.01358590368181467,
-0.629239559173584,
-0.18688520789146423,
-0.16687645018100739,
0.09591981023550034,
-0.24711132049560547,
-0.9705095887184143,
-0.05448020622134209,
-0.2678946256637573,
-0.3509450852870941,
0.027222542092204094,
0.7546034455299377,
-0.17423762381076813,
-0.6387565732002258,
0.49447041749954224,
0.3513471186161041,
-0.10619792342185974,
0.19771793484687805,
-0.6982522010803223,
0.10560233145952225,
0.2465347945690155,
-0.17972497642040253,
0.1913578361272812,
0.4253690838813782,
0.0007842358318157494,
1.074157953262329,
0.4567869007587433,
0.1036541610956192,
-0.10384120792150497,
0.3627162277698517,
1.0639903545379639,
-0.29330456256866455,
-0.4526240825653076,
-0.659713625907898,
0.23749195039272308,
-0.27025291323661804,
-0.08212777972221375,
0.8360346555709839,
0.6401811838150024,
0.7585209012031555,
0.15299145877361298,
0.9378617405891418,
0.2112523317337036,
0.3662671446800232,
-0.5397487282752991,
0.37234851717948914,
-0.26151761412620544,
0.025142425671219826,
-0.42209506034851074,
-0.6554327607154846,
0.05409092828631401,
0.48440995812416077,
-0.623603105545044,
0.13163337111473083,
0.16373498737812042,
0.6064317226409912,
-0.07109477370977402,
-0.1663123369216919,
-0.015762824565172195,
0.06597872078418732,
0.3489547073841095,
0.7648206949234009,
0.7433930039405823,
-0.020411942154169083,
0.7345571517944336,
-0.21134205162525177,
-0.30768638849258423,
-0.09561775624752045,
-0.665107250213623,
-0.9365725517272949,
-0.2051926851272583,
-0.45175015926361084,
-0.3091421127319336,
0.22785036265850067,
0.781919538974762,
0.6817440986633301,
-0.4698018729686737,
-0.02738870494067669,
-0.294354110956192,
0.43892332911491394,
-0.1896740198135376,
-0.20195330679416656,
0.5238600969314575,
-0.3776486814022064,
-0.8100875616073608,
0.573133647441864,
0.3763827979564667,
-0.04819497466087341,
-0.09723266959190369,
-0.14226004481315613,
0.1565767377614975,
0.15175558626651764,
0.5354014039039612,
0.22784541547298431,
-0.33005550503730774,
-0.5503119826316833,
0.13129760324954987,
-0.1857694387435913,
0.19493821263313293,
0.7856642007827759,
-0.2936641573905945,
0.7295231223106384,
0.4464203715324402,
0.5910500884056091,
0.7094699740409851,
-0.05754588544368744,
0.49302223324775696,
-0.46584218740463257,
0.16590724885463715,
0.0811423510313034,
0.3719891607761383,
0.4415966868400574,
-0.5363628268241882,
0.4517378807067871,
0.19376645982265472,
-0.35915225744247437,
-0.8176447153091431,
0.671598494052887,
-0.509090781211853,
-0.6404404044151306,
1.0256834030151367,
-0.28220629692077637,
-0.05084678530693054,
-0.0845848098397255,
-0.1770918071269989,
0.31463077664375305,
-0.27047964930534363,
0.607363760471344,
0.6174710392951965,
-0.7477840781211853,
-0.3381494879722595,
-0.4722953140735626,
0.34665578603744507,
-0.13469776511192322,
-0.6654840111732483,
0.3849961459636688,
0.6926271915435791,
0.5093542337417603,
-0.2583306133747101,
0.6628317832946777,
0.17106717824935913,
0.14093808829784393,
0.42424580454826355,
0.07852011173963547,
-0.7074118256568909,
-0.35037466883659363,
0.31544846296310425,
0.11129011958837509,
0.3027450442314148,
-0.09526557475328445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16024v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16024v2
|
HiGPT: Heterogeneous Graph Language Model
| 2024-02-25T08:07:22 | 2024-05-19T02:28:56 |
Jiabin Tang, Yuhao Yang, Wei Wei, Lei Shi, Long Xia, Dawei Yin, Chao Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Heterogeneous graph learning aims to capture complex relationships and
diverse relational semantics among entities in a heterogeneous graph to obtain
meaningful representations for nodes and edges. Recent advancements in
heterogeneous graph neural networks (HGNNs) have achieved state-of-the-art
performance by considering relation heterogeneity and using specialized message
functions and aggregation rules. However, existing frameworks for heterogeneous
graph learning have limitations in generalizing across diverse heterogeneous
graph datasets. Most of these frameworks follow the "pre-train" and "fine-tune"
paradigm on the same dataset, which restricts their capacity to adapt to new
and unseen data. This raises the question: "Can we generalize heterogeneous
graph models to be well-adapted to diverse downstream learning tasks with
distribution shifts in both node token sets and relation type heterogeneity?''
To tackle those challenges, we propose HiGPT, a general large graph model with
Heterogeneous graph instruction-tuning paradigm. Our framework enables learning
from arbitrary heterogeneous graphs without the need for any fine-tuning
process from downstream datasets. To handle distribution shifts in
heterogeneity, we introduce an in-context heterogeneous graph tokenizer that
captures semantic relationships in different heterogeneous graphs, facilitating
model adaptation. We incorporate a large corpus of heterogeneity-aware graph
instructions into our HiGPT, enabling the model to effectively comprehend
complex relation heterogeneity and distinguish between various types of graph
tokens. Furthermore, we introduce the Mixture-of-Thought (MoT) instruction
augmentation paradigm to mitigate data scarcity by generating diverse and
informative instructions. Through comprehensive evaluations, our proposed
framework demonstrates exceptional performance in terms of generalization
performance.
|
[
-0.38141748309135437,
-1.217508316040039,
0.16830365359783173,
0.08738113939762115,
-0.13275146484375,
0.02310001850128174,
-0.12217455357313156,
-0.3934383690357208,
-0.0232524536550045,
0.44227081537246704,
-0.42058515548706055,
-0.5385720133781433,
-0.4916214644908905,
-0.22462016344070435,
0.2140144556760788,
1.1689928770065308,
-0.13020865619182587,
-0.11903410404920578,
0.16357991099357605,
-0.2521599233150482,
-0.4860427677631378,
-0.34376537799835205,
-0.5039570927619934,
-0.527427613735199,
0.5588315725326538,
0.2119005173444748,
0.8328278660774231,
1.041416883468628,
0.3714680075645447,
0.1749660223722458,
0.02588191255927086,
0.04267939552664757,
-0.7904571294784546,
-0.269441157579422,
-0.21036814153194427,
-0.05280488729476929,
-0.48380905389785767,
0.045444291085004807,
0.809586763381958,
1.0498496294021606,
-0.01667633093893528,
0.08197589218616486,
0.14401017129421234,
0.1866125911474228,
-0.6335183382034302,
0.49533554911613464,
-0.700606107711792,
0.26584768295288086,
-0.0673324465751648,
0.038413990288972855,
-0.32420167326927185,
-0.28534939885139465,
0.2651481032371521,
-0.7184110879898071,
0.2314334660768509,
0.26513639092445374,
0.9348055124282837,
0.10418754070997238,
-0.404735267162323,
0.08458925783634186,
-0.6837425231933594,
0.2735627591609955,
-0.5646219253540039,
0.36703914403915405,
0.08319613337516785,
0.5312309265136719,
0.15797701478004456,
-1.1390039920806885,
-0.376703143119812,
-0.034080423414707184,
0.14914880692958832,
0.141734316945076,
0.04772401973605156,
0.10788550227880478,
0.3169052302837372,
0.3360852301120758,
-0.31778237223625183,
0.33078625798225403,
-0.007327231578528881,
-0.3292473256587982,
0.04205145314335823,
0.16426940262317657,
0.2729906141757965,
-0.22509324550628662,
-0.5699567198753357,
-0.04233797267079353,
-0.633047878742218,
-0.315660297870636,
0.600129246711731,
0.5994770526885986,
-0.1789308786392212,
0.34609484672546387,
-0.0773470401763916,
0.6628091335296631,
0.026131771504878998,
0.15629534423351288,
0.43739309906959534,
-0.22008433938026428,
-0.2488134205341339,
-0.09241551160812378,
0.6947339773178101,
-0.008749437518417835,
0.19090254604816437,
-0.2311648726463318,
-0.12810614705085754,
-0.1574706733226776,
-0.06311684101819992,
-1.0271004438400269,
-0.5072920918464661,
-0.3334129750728607,
-0.5017776489257812,
-0.07710088044404984,
0.05936431884765625,
-0.9274023771286011,
-0.009775352664291859,
-0.15125049650669098,
0.23479442298412323,
-0.40726640820503235,
-0.2313963621854782,
0.10607583820819855,
-0.13231921195983887,
-0.11604606360197067,
0.2678469121456146,
-0.9205819368362427,
0.32092994451522827,
0.5611128807067871,
0.6749722361564636,
-0.12180574238300323,
-0.7430812120437622,
-0.7884400486946106,
0.40147945284843445,
-0.006199088413268328,
0.48107650876045227,
-0.7708849310874939,
-0.1582750827074051,
0.03325994312763214,
0.10102905333042145,
-0.5018540620803833,
-0.16460895538330078,
0.22287900745868683,
-0.6305980682373047,
0.3121032118797302,
-0.16730543971061707,
-0.5514240264892578,
-0.07629825919866562,
0.4938110411167145,
-0.6161543726921082,
0.8592996597290039,
0.6642491221427917,
-1.0359746217727661,
0.10840971767902374,
-0.7572579979896545,
-0.5636001229286194,
0.3146911561489105,
-0.20383502542972565,
-0.530724048614502,
-0.38830476999282837,
0.07843748480081558,
0.3914981782436371,
-0.2914083003997803,
-0.08569800108671188,
-0.5729451179504395,
-0.4808102548122406,
-0.37691450119018555,
-0.3862629532814026,
0.7716930508613586,
0.10970252752304077,
-0.2554812729358673,
0.1898461878299713,
-0.4102391004562378,
0.11982119083404541,
0.0939614549279213,
-0.5636096000671387,
-0.13910925388336182,
-0.2000107318162918,
0.14088432490825653,
0.3721165060997009,
0.07595711201429367,
-0.4510170817375183,
0.12149259448051453,
-0.37251099944114685,
0.8367823958396912,
0.8947777152061462,
0.2808822691440582,
0.4318665564060211,
-0.0414879210293293,
0.4162074327468872,
-0.14167535305023193,
0.045976318418979645,
-0.12001598626375198,
-0.5633680820465088,
-0.34138429164886475,
-0.2048521488904953,
0.41857314109802246,
0.6775410771369934,
-0.6886832118034363,
0.3812060058116913,
-0.5196509957313538,
-0.12372484058141708,
-0.08091846853494644,
0.0032010474242269993,
0.32815828919410706,
0.8836302757263184,
0.3871012032032013,
-0.23832865059375763,
-0.2925926148891449,
-0.536821722984314,
0.041319720447063446,
-0.06123209744691849,
0.2451503574848175,
0.7153123617172241,
0.4785206913948059,
-0.7982837557792664,
0.7115525007247925,
-0.8187997937202454,
-0.0171547569334507,
-0.09337790310382843,
0.12933918833732605,
-0.12003465741872787,
0.49507686495780945,
0.5439484715461731,
-0.8939073085784912,
-0.6201321482658386,
0.4405377209186554,
-0.6629239320755005,
0.3338073790073395,
0.39707237482070923,
-0.3011312484741211,
-0.3060629367828369,
0.6628742814064026,
-0.4805082082748413,
0.2746087610721588,
0.4998873770236969,
-0.277341365814209,
0.533535361289978,
-0.3313251733779907,
-0.1846093088388443,
-1.1298298835754395,
-0.08924403786659241,
-0.12470462918281555,
-0.2277025580406189,
-0.2417203187942505,
0.1360224485397339,
-0.0077546644024550915,
-0.5109959244728088,
-0.35720378160476685,
0.35102707147598267,
-0.377934068441391,
-0.10346885770559311,
-0.06805054098367691,
-0.12295199930667877,
-0.1335093080997467,
0.5864588618278503,
-0.2893570363521576,
0.5984801054000854,
0.6170114874839783,
-0.49490976333618164,
0.6771591901779175,
0.362850546836853,
0.13653548061847687,
0.47102800011634827,
-0.5704489350318909,
0.2915562391281128,
-0.1600831300020218,
0.33155664801597595,
-0.8950254917144775,
-0.5295701622962952,
0.4610160291194916,
-0.08578648418188095,
0.31191107630729675,
-0.5666139125823975,
-0.3870067596435547,
-0.5324397683143616,
0.1045035794377327,
0.3558887541294098,
0.6266471147537231,
-0.6094486713409424,
0.7529160380363464,
0.2065175324678421,
0.09020278602838516,
-0.5501691699028015,
-0.39476972818374634,
-0.061350297182798386,
-0.11216719448566437,
-0.5955016613006592,
0.2420990914106369,
0.05105483531951904,
0.35178956389427185,
0.4143134355545044,
-0.021181445568799973,
-0.17040148377418518,
0.11280664801597595,
0.23783451318740845,
0.32649165391921997,
-0.609427273273468,
0.38738390803337097,
-0.11113376915454865,
-0.18936388194561005,
-0.06280100345611572,
-0.8951323628425598,
0.9346084594726562,
-0.2616121768951416,
-0.589714527130127,
-0.12546738982200623,
0.10604684054851532,
0.22502179443836212,
-0.5097754001617432,
0.6543805003166199,
1.016210675239563,
-0.39515799283981323,
-0.16695603728294373,
-0.004583731293678284,
-0.07846613228321075,
-0.40514513850212097,
0.8116961121559143,
-0.6656995415687561,
-1.0649889707565308,
0.5805761218070984,
-0.4631362557411194,
-0.24760858714580536,
0.4213719666004181,
0.5746810436248779,
-0.010015846230089664,
0.8860437273979187,
0.6237195134162903,
-0.32245975732803345,
0.6439527273178101,
-0.25559937953948975,
0.4990503787994385,
-0.6861008405685425,
0.18919844925403595,
-0.412969708442688,
-0.16753822565078735,
-0.9126335978507996,
-0.21382153034210205,
0.2118232548236847,
-0.1390312761068344,
-0.6365765333175659,
0.14748306572437286,
-0.4157397449016571,
0.6585085391998291,
0.3204875886440277,
0.23105250298976898,
-0.10701141506433487,
0.26616305112838745,
-0.098417729139328,
0.3859957754611969,
-0.8774339556694031,
-0.2009676694869995,
0.9121768474578857,
0.35210224986076355,
0.7372093200683594,
-0.11657565832138062,
0.5988798141479492,
0.17482058703899384,
0.37967753410339355,
-0.6090835332870483,
0.20714347064495087,
-0.2692680060863495,
-0.335184246301651,
-0.5845639109611511,
-0.7670132517814636,
-0.9897339344024658,
0.15994100272655487,
-0.03901851922273636,
-0.8662161231040955,
0.08976603299379349,
0.33044058084487915,
-0.07403979450464249,
0.5851019024848938,
-0.848934531211853,
1.2404389381408691,
0.25583815574645996,
-0.4007967710494995,
0.12503589689731598,
-0.8249104022979736,
0.2019743174314499,
0.15482862293720245,
0.01743984967470169,
-0.17354793846607208,
0.2541366517543793,
0.29294553399086,
-0.16535259783267975,
0.9280303716659546,
-0.3219900131225586,
0.1816210150718689,
0.3864813446998596,
0.005829428788274527,
0.7902370691299438,
0.04771747067570686,
-0.1331421285867691,
-0.02641895040869713,
-0.3322567641735077,
-0.6801023483276367,
-0.46602773666381836,
0.7079841494560242,
-0.9530394077301025,
-0.3259008228778839,
0.15131206810474396,
-0.8543028831481934,
-0.4215767979621887,
0.5139828324317932,
0.5809699892997742,
0.30315056443214417,
-0.4416370987892151,
-0.04740697517991066,
0.6608619689941406,
0.11961537599563599,
0.10709229856729507,
-0.25182369351387024,
-0.10481703281402588,
-0.22256265580654144,
1.256035566329956,
0.03127311170101166,
0.6145842671394348,
0.25484699010849,
0.3735271096229553,
-0.12687905132770538,
-0.48411500453948975,
-0.5802863836288452,
0.17258575558662415,
-0.9804345369338989,
0.14568762481212616,
-0.9013682007789612,
-0.34315940737724304,
-0.41316455602645874,
-0.07483205199241638,
-0.22120912373065948,
-0.11846601217985153,
-0.2818869948387146,
-0.09145624190568924,
0.04898280277848244,
0.4754348695278168,
0.20686323940753937,
0.4662386178970337,
-0.5779567956924438,
0.24548223614692688,
0.61518394947052,
0.42878806591033936,
-0.03562413901090622,
-0.25341829657554626,
-0.33775147795677185,
0.2018798589706421,
-0.07124854624271393,
-0.6741554141044617,
-0.0051092831417918205,
0.18415366113185883,
0.4395156502723694,
0.1845063418149948,
-0.26077237725257874,
0.3980466425418854,
-0.4373300075531006,
0.3241874575614929,
0.25494834780693054,
-0.7631173729896545,
0.12088730186223984,
-0.6067825555801392,
0.1058916300535202,
0.2543160915374756,
0.34983202815055847,
-0.5158903002738953,
0.2272218018770218,
-0.6870213747024536,
-0.6122744083404541,
0.52778559923172,
-0.1088334172964096,
0.4257281720638275,
0.1327638328075409,
0.38968053460121155,
0.05092116817831993,
0.28079909086227417,
-0.6902903318405151,
0.003934687469154596,
-0.767467200756073,
-0.32093459367752075,
-0.07959868013858795,
0.07553159445524216,
-0.24680669605731964,
-0.2460511475801468,
0.35705095529556274,
-0.6342183351516724,
0.354469895362854,
-0.3027525842189789,
0.048353083431720734,
-0.12183115631341934,
0.24738726019859314,
-0.1900499016046524,
0.6102563738822937,
-0.2831243574619293,
0.347415953874588,
0.13273492455482483,
-0.5335298180580139,
0.046292174607515335,
0.5280768275260925,
-0.3360232412815094,
-0.22299319505691528,
0.374639093875885,
1.1871274709701538,
-0.05085144564509392,
-0.33635446429252625,
0.47806286811828613,
0.15956275165081024,
-0.09624886512756348,
0.4146423041820526,
0.21800190210342407,
0.37138593196868896,
-0.18824118375778198,
-0.1667967587709427,
0.1740117073059082,
-0.022695129737257957,
-0.7303481101989746,
0.13860300183296204,
0.16207118332386017,
-0.6494694352149963,
-0.3069463074207306,
0.5321455597877502,
0.135818749666214,
-0.3314068913459778,
0.9470012187957764,
-0.48759832978248596,
-0.6331565976142883,
0.655642569065094,
0.9706633687019348,
0.6465931534767151,
-0.10901366919279099,
0.274328351020813,
0.28696173429489136,
0.08370128273963928,
0.10520810633897781,
-0.026474077254533768,
0.08583834022283554,
-1.0414472818374634,
-0.18413759768009186,
-0.30209454894065857,
-0.1654469519853592,
-0.21989399194717407,
-0.36838027834892273,
-0.01950419321656227,
-0.7031508684158325,
0.003059800248593092,
0.17442280054092407,
-0.2884034812450409,
-0.72809237241745,
0.20354577898979187,
-0.2824495732784271,
0.4818662106990814,
-0.8570821285247803,
0.8145655989646912,
0.7606827020645142,
-0.43725648522377014,
-1.0701056718826294,
0.18525460362434387,
-0.3817140758037567,
-0.9233353137969971,
0.5284156799316406,
0.0011095056543126702,
0.05068839713931084,
0.4273609519004822,
-0.5903022289276123,
-0.522078275680542,
0.8603641390800476,
0.5051150321960449,
-0.2061433345079422,
-0.39306166768074036,
0.22630248963832855,
0.3659459352493286,
-0.6208046674728394,
-0.10014133155345917,
0.3704594373703003,
0.37735533714294434,
0.34874996542930603,
-0.6123436093330383,
-0.01012951135635376,
-0.12268917262554169,
0.09542059898376465,
0.393345445394516,
-0.6827551126480103,
1.4891117811203003,
-0.12361858785152435,
-0.11098119616508484,
-0.5381094217300415,
0.4179425537586212,
-0.09168598055839539,
0.308950275182724,
0.4366932809352875,
0.5569866895675659,
0.8821274638175964,
-0.01375953946262598,
1.2002938985824585,
-0.11673454940319061,
0.5396950244903564,
1.3032375574111938,
-0.5654224157333374,
0.24560660123825073,
0.2464156299829483,
0.011927200481295586,
0.37797704339027405,
0.6509864330291748,
0.009919364005327225,
0.4704022705554962,
0.22637444734573364,
-0.19104135036468506,
-0.3567512333393097,
-0.11699657142162323,
-0.5109224915504456,
0.22568383812904358,
0.23631857335567474,
-0.16286925971508026,
-0.5024833679199219,
0.07068609446287155,
-0.11661867052316666,
-0.005633839406073093,
-0.23206770420074463,
0.44382184743881226,
-0.1041472777724266,
-0.32170262932777405,
0.5706206560134888,
0.1547580361366272,
0.3060426414012909,
-0.545009195804596,
-0.12605947256088257,
0.19387580454349518,
0.10514500737190247,
-0.2120102047920227,
-0.531594455242157,
0.049998924136161804,
-0.4534883201122284,
-0.235789492726326,
0.1168624758720398,
0.882016122341156,
-0.168193981051445,
-0.1829957216978073,
0.3243471086025238,
0.711208701133728,
-0.2864965796470642,
-0.006157985422760248,
-0.7088518142700195,
-0.10467560589313507,
0.0581255704164505,
-0.14343920350074768,
0.31973665952682495,
0.903786301612854,
-0.23505397140979767,
0.5402511954307556,
0.6489694714546204,
-0.1432797610759735,
0.22892141342163086,
0.1920541226863861,
1.0326149463653564,
-0.31396645307540894,
-0.7985489964485168,
-0.5980988144874573,
0.04325871542096138,
0.0422930009663105,
-0.4588364064693451,
0.7647805213928223,
0.5341028571128845,
0.9480264186859131,
0.020003542304039,
0.9380860328674316,
-0.05766763165593147,
0.027966545894742012,
-0.5218132138252258,
0.3530605435371399,
-0.16980992257595062,
0.02612689882516861,
-0.27947378158569336,
-0.9808704257011414,
0.03235768526792526,
0.5427640676498413,
-0.5365263819694519,
0.28486964106559753,
0.5380749702453613,
0.5311516523361206,
-0.6671096086502075,
0.2344532608985901,
-0.008096296340227127,
0.16711105406284332,
0.30942878127098083,
0.6908172369003296,
0.8033740520477295,
-0.29106462001800537,
0.3942156136035919,
0.07817155122756958,
-0.07799210399389267,
-0.2839353382587433,
-0.6582188010215759,
-0.8701164126396179,
-0.39870455861091614,
-0.36975306272506714,
-0.49344539642333984,
0.3034316897392273,
0.8389235138893127,
0.9700325131416321,
-0.35568997263908386,
-0.012174095958471298,
-0.32917988300323486,
0.22350770235061646,
-0.16859720647335052,
-0.23383906483650208,
0.5744708776473999,
-0.3075219392776489,
-0.5627644062042236,
-0.06687235832214355,
0.311758428812027,
0.3381079435348511,
0.021157706156373024,
-0.3787596523761749,
-0.18814535439014435,
-0.25528696179389954,
0.4520081579685211,
0.2889470160007477,
-0.055124521255493164,
-0.4618261456489563,
-0.09854482114315033,
-0.35108399391174316,
0.4646424353122711,
0.7732878923416138,
-0.3333003520965576,
0.2669201195240021,
0.46587663888931274,
0.943172037601471,
0.9289742112159729,
-0.04475712403655052,
0.21296857297420502,
-0.7996818423271179,
0.3983592092990875,
0.5066031813621521,
0.22114713490009308,
0.25082969665527344,
-0.5420913696289062,
0.4616658389568329,
0.5926142930984497,
-0.21379326283931732,
-0.6309816241264343,
0.5928979516029358,
-0.7744567394256592,
-0.3688125014305115,
0.8740963935852051,
-0.38040074706077576,
-0.34674644470214844,
-0.13431580364704132,
-0.07732801139354706,
0.5943735837936401,
-0.15113723278045654,
0.3451473116874695,
0.5412052273750305,
-0.01579047553241253,
0.019204156473279,
-0.5297303795814514,
0.05191502347588539,
-0.012580502778291702,
-1.0863817930221558,
0.07110897451639175,
0.5405092835426331,
0.4763776659965515,
-0.10165554285049438,
0.6951552033424377,
0.029396478086709976,
0.12797683477401733,
0.22986774146556854,
-0.06503493338823318,
-0.21860536932945251,
-0.1940254271030426,
0.07554642111063004,
0.5169512629508972,
-0.10692057013511658,
-0.1767505407333374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16021v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16021v1
|
TMT: Tri-Modal Translation between Speech, Image, and Text by Processing Different Modalities as Different Languages
| 2024-02-25T07:46:57 | 2024-02-25T07:46:57 |
Minsu Kim, Jee-weon Jung, Hyeongseop Rha, Soumi Maiti, Siddhant Arora, Xuankai Chang, Shinji Watanabe, Yong Man Ro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, eess.AS
|
The capability to jointly process multi-modal information is becoming an
essential task. However, the limited number of paired multi-modal data and the
large computational requirements in multi-modal learning hinder the
development. We propose a novel Tri-Modal Translation (TMT) model that
translates between arbitrary modalities spanning speech, image, and text. We
introduce a novel viewpoint, where we interpret different modalities as
different languages, and treat multi-modal translation as a well-established
machine translation problem. To this end, we tokenize speech and image data
into discrete tokens, which provide a unified interface across modalities and
significantly decrease the computational cost. In the proposed TMT, a
multi-modal encoder-decoder conducts the core translation, whereas
modality-specific processing is conducted only within the tokenization and
detokenization stages. We evaluate the proposed TMT on all six modality
translation tasks. TMT outperforms single model counterparts consistently,
demonstrating that unifying tasks is beneficial not only for practicality but
also for performance.
|
[
-0.19581696391105652,
-0.7019195556640625,
0.4827875792980194,
0.1399114429950714,
-0.8586752414703369,
0.3356423079967499,
-0.20547398924827576,
-0.4834650158882141,
-0.09644166380167007,
0.17035411298274994,
-0.30755555629730225,
-0.40624096989631653,
-0.4729352593421936,
0.09920111298561096,
-0.3877439796924591,
0.7480795383453369,
-0.15821127593517303,
0.454019159078598,
0.331048846244812,
-0.01245587132871151,
-0.661563515663147,
-0.2946113646030426,
-0.4361657500267029,
-0.29449889063835144,
0.507719099521637,
0.15901899337768555,
0.7707727551460266,
0.5958834290504456,
0.4762333035469055,
0.1818084716796875,
0.20541271567344666,
0.29232296347618103,
-0.031648822128772736,
-0.10596665740013123,
-0.052908822894096375,
-0.4416939616203308,
-0.2980552613735199,
-0.10697855800390244,
0.8455007672309875,
0.7633132338523865,
0.4020806550979614,
0.06762893497943878,
-0.19871112704277039,
0.2217807173728943,
-0.2825973927974701,
-0.01625370979309082,
-0.42569977045059204,
-0.023587124422192574,
-0.4679352343082428,
-0.4506678879261017,
-0.3715318739414215,
-0.12558019161224365,
-0.08992967009544373,
-0.4544026553630829,
-0.006793658249080181,
0.10132627934217453,
0.4480568468570709,
0.36676397919654846,
-0.9666580557823181,
0.2148633450269699,
-0.8524765372276306,
0.7412376999855042,
-0.4870067834854126,
0.6085262894630432,
0.10492836683988571,
0.4289797246456146,
0.1750722974538803,
-0.7346307635307312,
-0.6154144406318665,
-0.14241164922714233,
0.06004982814192772,
-0.0705418586730957,
-0.04371238127350807,
0.162347212433815,
-0.24587030708789825,
0.43021753430366516,
-0.381373792886734,
-0.1499561071395874,
-0.35867971181869507,
-0.08984680473804474,
0.10434252768754959,
0.16718652844429016,
0.6964632272720337,
-0.4299624562263489,
-0.8054755926132202,
0.16518789529800415,
-0.27265554666519165,
-0.028807906433939934,
-0.2007497102022171,
0.453480988740921,
-0.3199699819087982,
0.6343106627464294,
0.24510672688484192,
0.7479156851768494,
-0.1168963834643364,
-0.24795754253864288,
0.3219189941883087,
-0.7194780111312866,
-0.26592040061950684,
-0.1113722026348114,
0.7747308611869812,
0.4298637807369232,
-0.20311668515205383,
-0.6113329529762268,
-0.2285904884338379,
0.045173920691013336,
0.21091468632221222,
-0.625699520111084,
0.34139588475227356,
0.19463172554969788,
-0.6594989895820618,
-0.3835026025772095,
-0.11803866922855377,
-0.5199359655380249,
-0.055128611624240875,
-0.4455481469631195,
0.7475842833518982,
-0.6048084497451782,
-0.5060684680938721,
0.345905601978302,
-0.08001375198364258,
0.13833749294281006,
0.24241890013217926,
-0.5288486480712891,
0.2423250824213028,
0.46316781640052795,
1.0843205451965332,
-0.36955955624580383,
-0.4761311411857605,
-0.26393526792526245,
0.611704409122467,
-0.324690580368042,
0.5913390517234802,
-0.841132640838623,
-0.40773826837539673,
-0.33675122261047363,
-0.22358117997646332,
-0.45360657572746277,
-0.08290991932153702,
0.39896389842033386,
-0.4464908838272095,
0.47505784034729004,
-0.195893794298172,
-0.12375838309526443,
-0.3914630115032196,
0.2527081370353699,
-0.8017184734344482,
0.6702163815498352,
-0.012364890426397324,
-0.5903758406639099,
0.15573933720588684,
-1.0208193063735962,
-0.6793267726898193,
0.19366106390953064,
-0.19981880486011505,
-0.16526535153388977,
0.4157121777534485,
0.1780288815498352,
0.3150183856487274,
-0.7517226934432983,
0.4795645475387573,
-0.15959885716438293,
-0.3466870188713074,
0.47907835245132446,
-0.6192951798439026,
0.615723192691803,
0.16034391522407532,
-0.2958788275718689,
0.09889674186706543,
-0.5149562358856201,
0.04656142368912697,
-0.03452001139521599,
-0.42512911558151245,
-0.280689001083374,
-0.32003793120384216,
0.6312200427055359,
0.6209078431129456,
0.3863352835178375,
-0.679470419883728,
0.16476589441299438,
-0.022502029314637184,
0.829654335975647,
0.4754590690135956,
0.05624543875455856,
0.45205727219581604,
-0.4670677185058594,
0.2877420485019684,
0.3147718906402588,
0.14420001208782196,
-0.1133652850985527,
-0.2945963144302368,
-0.4098590016365051,
-0.582444429397583,
0.30177706480026245,
0.3643500506877899,
-1.1361076831817627,
-0.17826439440250397,
-0.5190558433532715,
-0.19068469107151031,
-0.7672550678253174,
-0.38445156812667847,
0.4525958299636841,
0.5432135462760925,
0.6143490076065063,
-0.29394859075546265,
-0.40193313360214233,
-0.9294763803482056,
-0.48927411437034607,
0.0627094954252243,
0.02001853659749031,
0.09828389436006546,
0.2175123244524002,
-0.12025466561317444,
0.5908483266830444,
0.0791354849934578,
-0.44556906819343567,
-0.27637094259262085,
0.4813235402107239,
-0.05185168609023094,
0.6273182034492493,
0.4990959167480469,
-1.0255687236785889,
-0.3059414029121399,
0.34384292364120483,
-0.5182029604911804,
0.09622415900230408,
-0.3350212574005127,
0.08460807055234909,
0.18773356080055237,
0.34298890829086304,
-0.5442119836807251,
0.2895599603652954,
0.4805520176887512,
-0.1403164118528366,
0.03351934254169464,
-0.010881995782256126,
0.5184381008148193,
-1.6436774730682373,
0.4380493760108948,
-0.4242647588253021,
-0.469026654958725,
-0.7147620320320129,
-0.09162981808185577,
0.21498069167137146,
-0.19727876782417297,
-0.6443056464195251,
0.3238760530948639,
-0.3589501678943634,
-0.1442563682794571,
-0.12937162816524506,
-0.18960964679718018,
0.02996177226305008,
0.6740858554840088,
-0.05543858930468559,
0.8806241750717163,
0.4841530919075012,
-0.4534665644168854,
0.20126721262931824,
0.06543847918510437,
0.06956148147583008,
0.8887073397636414,
-0.5573982000350952,
0.2558786869049072,
-0.020648812875151634,
0.23330223560333252,
-0.9205335974693298,
-0.29978063702583313,
0.2780824303627014,
-0.36600640416145325,
0.31327715516090393,
0.045088574290275574,
-0.5794740319252014,
-0.12228699028491974,
-0.09834112226963043,
1.070294976234436,
-0.0005125249736011028,
-0.23663584887981415,
0.8718536496162415,
0.309333860874176,
0.1386135220527649,
-0.3083471953868866,
-0.9303172826766968,
0.570207417011261,
-0.17366918921470642,
-0.4379357695579529,
0.5778834819793701,
-0.010361382737755775,
0.19033028185367584,
0.2601860463619232,
-0.2837335169315338,
-0.3367684483528137,
-0.13519780337810516,
0.02747664973139763,
0.2124885469675064,
-0.013499596156179905,
0.42845800518989563,
0.04856916889548302,
-0.10288166254758835,
-0.3122684359550476,
-0.7108256816864014,
0.5866817235946655,
-0.2833802103996277,
-0.3473265767097473,
-0.6800934672355652,
0.7662263512611389,
1.1190069913864136,
-0.4818599224090576,
0.5262435674667358,
0.9608762264251709,
-0.4876934289932251,
0.30209073424339294,
-0.42860957980155945,
0.1489374190568924,
-0.3709179162979126,
0.4409676790237427,
-0.8170455694198608,
-0.7395929098129272,
0.20552782714366913,
-0.20702223479747772,
0.0942070409655571,
0.28821951150894165,
0.6621034145355225,
-0.04231186583638191,
1.2139804363250732,
0.5539198517799377,
0.23657508194446564,
0.7315238118171692,
-0.012457141652703285,
0.3315536677837372,
-0.7324388027191162,
-0.4876954257488251,
-0.24006615579128265,
-0.6198748350143433,
-0.2870738208293915,
-0.7577016949653625,
0.7029120922088623,
-0.18238259851932526,
-0.16647350788116455,
0.3333067297935486,
-0.41549360752105713,
0.5518762469291687,
0.5570802092552185,
0.4682491719722748,
0.6073873043060303,
-0.0031314464285969734,
-0.34502336382865906,
-0.09113425761461258,
-0.42864328622817993,
-0.45477989315986633,
1.0253275632858276,
0.1275705099105835,
0.4982336163520813,
0.28893429040908813,
0.44226527214050293,
0.2043396383523941,
0.0018444628221914172,
-0.8485541939735413,
0.4550085663795471,
-0.3777400851249695,
-0.6750280261039734,
-0.03227066993713379,
-0.39029282331466675,
-0.7587989568710327,
0.42653319239616394,
-0.06707292795181274,
-0.3876456022262573,
0.10486467182636261,
-0.3026069700717926,
0.0023329174146056175,
0.7541175484657288,
-0.5957794189453125,
0.7953789830207825,
-0.5829514265060425,
-0.09683942049741745,
-0.4448857605457306,
-0.8729375600814819,
0.3974875509738922,
-0.3147461712360382,
0.30330270528793335,
-0.0003813514776993543,
-0.5769100189208984,
0.3265562951564789,
0.01956957019865513,
0.8728553056716919,
0.02561359293758869,
0.1836424618959427,
-0.1896289438009262,
0.4220505654811859,
-0.1525857299566269,
-0.0897011086344719,
0.08890026062726974,
0.37023741006851196,
0.22101467847824097,
-0.3715628981590271,
-0.39344677329063416,
0.22018256783485413,
-0.8913117051124573,
-0.1703266054391861,
-0.1863139122724533,
-1.2530512809753418,
-0.239188089966774,
0.6938990354537964,
0.24939696490764618,
0.5697484016418457,
-0.28619393706321716,
0.2418137937784195,
0.18109118938446045,
0.1969868242740631,
0.7107123136520386,
0.4503169655799866,
-0.0896410197019577,
-0.8331714272499084,
0.9138392806053162,
-0.08705349266529083,
0.47250527143478394,
0.7164443135261536,
0.06605653464794159,
-0.2926503121852875,
-0.47458967566490173,
-0.6576995849609375,
0.31575924158096313,
-0.4379473030567169,
-0.29147404432296753,
-0.6979057192802429,
0.12926934659481049,
-0.07214400172233582,
0.0013413102133199573,
-0.5748149156570435,
-0.7761380076408386,
-0.39484015107154846,
0.3417084813117981,
-0.1632729470729828,
0.7467432618141174,
-0.24883846938610077,
0.25083085894584656,
-0.8586996793746948,
0.816318929195404,
0.37669000029563904,
0.48522675037384033,
-0.20728199183940887,
-0.4380110204219818,
-0.28077787160873413,
0.2365858256816864,
-0.2621789872646332,
-0.9031612277030945,
0.4001350998878479,
0.218816876411438,
0.35981419682502747,
0.04986273869872093,
-0.10726627707481384,
0.7902914881706238,
-0.450971394777298,
0.6839463710784912,
0.6498720645904541,
-1.2678325176239014,
0.28965455293655396,
-0.44793999195098877,
0.40825536847114563,
0.37968313694000244,
0.12652945518493652,
-0.8927987813949585,
-0.11198306828737259,
-0.1980026215314865,
-0.5035518407821655,
0.7810807824134827,
0.15784111618995667,
-0.12081650644540787,
0.16697359085083008,
-0.04293248802423477,
0.2607729434967041,
0.4340127408504486,
-0.774166464805603,
0.07528999447822571,
-0.44112786650657654,
-0.21302147209644318,
0.18959428369998932,
0.0709630474448204,
-0.4653215706348419,
-0.29607701301574707,
0.1910271942615509,
-0.14176923036575317,
0.5031224489212036,
0.034383587539196014,
-0.4521797001361847,
-0.3129507303237915,
0.5017066597938538,
0.703310489654541,
0.28060096502304077,
0.0012153723509982228,
0.5384014844894409,
-0.06520425528287888,
-0.2624998986721039,
0.24114032089710236,
0.09682314842939377,
-0.07130714505910873,
0.12431813031435013,
0.008903532288968563,
0.9171664714813232,
0.43257033824920654,
-0.16276241838932037,
0.5624114274978638,
-0.1756792962551117,
-0.0010524195386096835,
0.23324665427207947,
-0.5270825028419495,
-0.0002656134311109781,
0.4394826591014862,
0.48030886054039,
0.6276309490203857,
0.10894492268562317,
-0.37865397334098816,
0.10752204060554504,
0.2919712960720062,
-0.260814368724823,
-0.7105162739753723,
0.8973656296730042,
0.28878286480903625,
-0.4084934592247009,
0.07041718065738678,
0.18152791261672974,
-0.45360568165779114,
0.13065917789936066,
0.7664064168930054,
1.1999913454055786,
-0.22969384491443634,
0.26420682668685913,
0.011938831768929958,
0.37344786524772644,
-0.06266874074935913,
0.37184226512908936,
-0.2277287244796753,
-0.33631330728530884,
-0.38267117738723755,
-0.3742952048778534,
-0.30076152086257935,
-0.08203179389238358,
-0.5029302835464478,
0.2910488545894623,
-0.09279857575893402,
-0.3103010654449463,
-0.19357889890670776,
-0.37321212887763977,
-0.7671423554420471,
0.036689139902591705,
0.3248152434825897,
0.4878696799278259,
-0.7608746886253357,
0.9325107932090759,
0.914386510848999,
-0.6399146318435669,
-0.6202027201652527,
-0.021986138075590134,
-0.16229814291000366,
-0.7027174830436707,
0.40166980028152466,
0.07393047213554382,
-0.38664230704307556,
0.26672908663749695,
-0.3996182382106781,
-0.9084879755973816,
1.0733822584152222,
0.7545151710510254,
-0.09962449967861176,
-0.373647004365921,
0.6778213381767273,
0.3133073151111603,
-0.42937901616096497,
-0.05047694221138954,
0.45944732427597046,
0.46327313780784607,
0.14327391982078552,
-1.4164316654205322,
0.08888806402683258,
-0.30270901322364807,
0.3170211613178253,
0.1034746766090393,
-0.6865541338920593,
1.0920863151550293,
0.020374124869704247,
-0.45538121461868286,
-0.11148573458194733,
0.2333506941795349,
-0.08481629192829132,
0.2032579630613327,
0.38338857889175415,
0.36532485485076904,
0.5245603919029236,
0.01258155144751072,
0.8696421384811401,
-0.44375258684158325,
0.2296084612607956,
0.889043927192688,
0.21191935241222382,
0.5043777823448181,
0.9150078296661377,
0.19430044293403625,
0.1398252248764038,
0.44919028878211975,
0.39517101645469666,
0.6225494742393494,
-0.38479727506637573,
-0.5314823389053345,
-0.6191330552101135,
-0.592851459980011,
-0.4673856198787689,
0.6793465614318848,
0.3187398612499237,
-0.30474743247032166,
-0.5487857460975647,
0.3554631471633911,
-0.21059004962444305,
-0.11241885274648666,
-0.30869677662849426,
0.44833609461784363,
0.21407991647720337,
-0.29565536975860596,
0.7533987164497375,
0.07287310063838959,
0.4113613963127136,
-0.328205943107605,
0.11212158203125,
0.036001451313495636,
-0.06844785809516907,
-0.11251061409711838,
-0.5876548886299133,
0.29607921838760376,
-0.30121323466300964,
-0.16595764458179474,
-0.4940311312675476,
0.47540736198425293,
-0.7219988703727722,
-0.4053182899951935,
0.034344110637903214,
0.8046877384185791,
0.0021495951805263758,
-0.0035371563863009214,
-0.5276773571968079,
0.2947651445865631,
-0.1832810342311859,
0.0060904668644070625,
-0.04562295228242874,
0.7104348540306091,
-0.17916236817836761,
0.5000630021095276,
0.49056580662727356,
-0.036469656974077225,
0.29682043194770813,
0.08302339166402817,
1.087226152420044,
-0.7710053324699402,
-0.5993117094039917,
-0.6965178847312927,
0.5615318417549133,
0.21119992434978485,
-0.10096748173236847,
0.30041566491127014,
0.4892304837703705,
0.6176618337631226,
-0.03891291096806526,
0.9021351337432861,
-0.19785135984420776,
0.26699671149253845,
-0.41662123799324036,
0.36069321632385254,
-0.8452541828155518,
0.059758566319942474,
-0.12151522934436798,
-0.7189849615097046,
-0.6859065890312195,
0.3066534698009491,
-0.26498568058013916,
-0.12362745404243469,
1.0235623121261597,
0.3960338234901428,
-0.32305875420570374,
0.13318730890750885,
0.4237244129180908,
0.025663848966360092,
0.46205028891563416,
0.8871822357177734,
0.648674726486206,
-0.6878584623336792,
0.8486534357070923,
-0.12883248925209045,
0.03527678921818733,
-0.1200224980711937,
-0.7024301886558533,
-0.9316184520721436,
-0.797599732875824,
0.0729738101363182,
-0.11502044647932053,
-0.35201796889305115,
1.0332980155944824,
0.6965467929840088,
-0.5564285516738892,
-0.18753410875797272,
-0.15507332980632782,
0.01334301196038723,
-0.2283652126789093,
-0.08660732209682465,
0.175879567861557,
-0.3979533910751343,
-1.0159070491790771,
0.5907918214797974,
0.566696286201477,
0.20247037708759308,
-0.18988561630249023,
0.10854903608560562,
-0.14427797496318817,
-0.08643778413534164,
0.5330595970153809,
0.13761679828166962,
-0.9342983961105347,
-0.4267852008342743,
0.16941291093826294,
-0.39445987343788147,
0.29593902826309204,
1.1847889423370361,
-0.6385199427604675,
0.8359267115592957,
0.39626768231391907,
0.8242361545562744,
0.7204884886741638,
-0.14486099779605865,
0.780937910079956,
-0.6594855189323425,
0.1966361701488495,
0.39133861660957336,
0.06241999939084053,
0.34763529896736145,
-0.03774372488260269,
0.29449403285980225,
0.38495293259620667,
-0.15336723625659943,
-0.8677617907524109,
0.47855836153030396,
-1.3067256212234497,
-0.35237497091293335,
0.8657932281494141,
0.3120715618133545,
-0.2165241688489914,
-0.3053677976131439,
-0.3662496507167816,
0.7656890749931335,
-0.27958205342292786,
0.705463707447052,
0.35178491473197937,
0.10589800775051117,
-0.41675251722335815,
-0.4357573390007019,
0.10590802878141403,
0.43082597851753235,
-0.49213510751724243,
-0.2678019106388092,
0.4151896834373474,
0.33342528343200684,
-0.03844505175948143,
0.5679277181625366,
-0.4658207595348358,
0.41228970885276794,
-0.24580198526382446,
0.17876651883125305,
-0.4799709916114807,
-0.29863449931144714,
-0.4273548126220703,
0.38545528054237366,
-0.2742292881011963,
-0.7806942462921143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00812v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00812v2
|
LoRA Meets Dropout under a Unified Framework
| 2024-02-25T07:09:10 | 2024-05-27T02:16:43 |
Sheng Wang, Liheng Chen, Jiyue Jiang, Boyang Xue, Lingpeng Kong, Chuan Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the remarkable capabilities, large language models (LLMs) have emerged
as essential elements in numerous NLP applications, while parameter-efficient
finetuning, especially LoRA, has gained popularity as a lightweight approach
for model customization. Meanwhile, various dropout methods, initially designed
for full finetuning with all the parameters updated, alleviates overfitting
associated with excessive parameter redundancy. Hence, a possible contradiction
arises from negligible trainable parameters of LoRA and the effectiveness of
previous dropout methods, which has been largely overlooked. To fill this gap,
we first confirm that parameter-efficient LoRA is also overfitting-prone. We
then revisit transformer-specific dropout methods, and establish their
equivalence and distinctions mathematically and empirically. Building upon this
comparative analysis, we introduce a unified framework for a comprehensive
investigation, which instantiates these methods based on dropping position,
structural pattern and compensation measure. Through this framework, we reveal
the new preferences and performance comparisons of them when involved with
limited trainable parameters. This framework also allows us to amalgamate the
most favorable aspects into a novel dropout method named HiddenKey. Extensive
experiments verify the remarkable superiority and sufficiency of HiddenKey
across multiple models and tasks, which highlights it as the preferred approach
for high-performance and parameter-efficient finetuning of LLMs.
|
[
-0.6218310594558716,
-0.7024752497673035,
0.3336339294910431,
-0.032298605889081955,
-0.007584302686154842,
-0.07370070368051529,
-0.36253631114959717,
-0.4700931906700134,
0.22172771394252777,
0.5495316982269287,
-0.7018354535102844,
-0.5024740099906921,
-0.5435478091239929,
-0.0617193877696991,
-0.8819534778594971,
1.1391010284423828,
-0.19696348905563354,
-0.4271054267883301,
0.11132790148258209,
-0.2630481719970703,
-0.44923532009124756,
-0.39931681752204895,
-0.5204970240592957,
-0.8357457518577576,
0.8557643294334412,
0.20198188722133636,
0.7600542902946472,
0.6333097815513611,
0.6773291230201721,
0.2428506761789322,
-0.5269955992698669,
-0.041716452687978745,
-0.3740844428539276,
-0.2566537857055664,
-0.18527184426784515,
-0.7119573950767517,
-0.20115292072296143,
-0.014362946152687073,
0.5759311318397522,
1.0212634801864624,
-0.35284626483917236,
0.12625128030776978,
0.17247755825519562,
0.7158761620521545,
-0.8145912885665894,
-0.1334819793701172,
-0.795630931854248,
0.5520382523536682,
-0.319771409034729,
-0.05194159224629402,
-0.43459352850914,
-0.27545154094696045,
0.03180960193276405,
-0.590218186378479,
0.26028674840927124,
-0.3740907609462738,
1.0751537084579468,
0.7409352660179138,
-0.31494140625,
0.023610742762684822,
-1.0716361999511719,
0.9156027436256409,
-0.8432187438011169,
0.37001848220825195,
0.36154812574386597,
0.39007872343063354,
0.05700364708900452,
-0.5220180153846741,
-0.3536684513092041,
-0.2579062879085541,
-0.010817073285579681,
0.0599861741065979,
-0.21478241682052612,
0.15389637649059296,
0.3898526728153229,
0.5094045400619507,
0.035702984780073166,
0.6913880109786987,
-0.33495965600013733,
0.05465725064277649,
0.23253412544727325,
0.1322748064994812,
0.1577703356742859,
-0.1834687739610672,
-0.27379974722862244,
0.10146739333868027,
-1.1467241048812866,
-0.08070521801710129,
0.3772103786468506,
0.5688656568527222,
-0.177035853266716,
0.48307785391807556,
-0.2829906642436981,
0.30090993642807007,
0.11178755015134811,
-0.02343609184026718,
0.04120782017707825,
0.09327702224254608,
-0.34269702434539795,
-0.21023981273174286,
0.7492453455924988,
0.14398320019245148,
-0.012760363519191742,
-0.2810872793197632,
-0.027113227173686028,
-0.005242220591753721,
0.19187124073505402,
-0.6320655345916748,
-0.005665234290063381,
0.29552286863327026,
-0.5321994423866272,
-0.46673384308815,
-0.21851082146167755,
-0.5945566296577454,
-0.41624903678894043,
-0.29128068685531616,
0.38557344675064087,
-0.20695887506008148,
-0.23080334067344666,
0.17073874175548553,
0.04133149981498718,
0.4711095094680786,
0.3430007994174957,
-1.0716965198516846,
0.3685835897922516,
0.7406843304634094,
0.8213817477226257,
-0.5592734813690186,
-0.1758360117673874,
-0.6164792776107788,
0.17660389840602875,
-0.1761506050825119,
0.5067352652549744,
-0.13695527613162994,
-0.14200539886951447,
0.3019447922706604,
-0.3092869222164154,
-0.0954621210694313,
-0.5498895645141602,
0.7823245525360107,
-0.585720419883728,
0.3083268404006958,
-0.1069217398762703,
-0.45171067118644714,
-0.30978259444236755,
-0.04716213420033455,
-0.8601731657981873,
0.9445473551750183,
0.01729823276400566,
-0.7316749095916748,
0.3658188581466675,
-0.9868232607841492,
-0.489218533039093,
0.05323651060461998,
-0.19985736906528473,
-0.39132800698280334,
0.33926254510879517,
0.13833832740783691,
0.489896297454834,
-0.45918771624565125,
0.04686485975980759,
-0.13937798142433167,
-0.5002999305725098,
0.23489847779273987,
-0.7366622090339661,
0.7660391330718994,
0.13904723525047302,
-0.3938682973384857,
-0.2976997494697571,
-1.0490950345993042,
0.2900348901748657,
0.08147729933261871,
-0.8209085464477539,
-0.3473590612411499,
0.08999629318714142,
0.3706240952014923,
0.052242450416088104,
-0.10139047354459763,
-0.5573391914367676,
0.14057409763336182,
-0.8845880031585693,
0.83913254737854,
0.5950969457626343,
-0.31170693039894104,
0.5455014705657959,
0.09360625594854355,
0.44543468952178955,
-0.23422014713287354,
0.28366678953170776,
0.13083979487419128,
-0.14020268619060516,
-1.0638967752456665,
-0.4194202125072479,
0.5453155636787415,
0.4238833487033844,
-0.31524422764778137,
0.7010430693626404,
0.036972492933273315,
-0.3593079149723053,
-0.5384213328361511,
0.02693650871515274,
0.49297553300857544,
0.27802106738090515,
0.29039961099624634,
-0.04238535836338997,
-0.4992356300354004,
-0.792929470539093,
-0.2277395874261856,
0.17330163717269897,
-0.15424121916294098,
-0.13457025587558746,
0.35424965620040894,
-0.39897605776786804,
1.3393582105636597,
-0.5830658674240112,
-0.5589431524276733,
-0.4748034179210663,
-0.22371108829975128,
0.5441824197769165,
0.4904237687587738,
0.6345043182373047,
-0.5514944195747375,
-0.2257699966430664,
0.24758684635162354,
-0.7752642631530762,
-0.02462748996913433,
0.11694382131099701,
0.024590278044342995,
0.4393073618412018,
0.4099511504173279,
-0.9921466112136841,
0.6403074264526367,
0.6311412453651428,
0.08120857924222946,
0.38646695017814636,
-0.03479006513953209,
-0.2901742160320282,
-1.3210422992706299,
0.253133088350296,
-0.2519916296005249,
-0.07746154814958572,
-0.6973075270652771,
0.28506898880004883,
0.045968059450387955,
-0.1440771520137787,
-0.6174828410148621,
0.5154494643211365,
-0.3323744535446167,
0.05022795870900154,
-0.17012760043144226,
0.19763390719890594,
0.1752733439207077,
0.521777331829071,
-0.21863660216331482,
0.180569127202034,
0.3183640241622925,
-0.5546734929084778,
0.19118601083755493,
0.3750826418399811,
-0.37183958292007446,
0.2558555006980896,
-0.9518249034881592,
0.038824133574962616,
-0.08187129348516464,
0.08170735090970993,
-0.7279139757156372,
-0.2596140205860138,
0.061478253453969955,
0.09143289178609848,
0.2289092093706131,
-0.32858219742774963,
-0.48450541496276855,
-0.3943771719932556,
-0.30300775170326233,
0.06671242415904999,
0.48258501291275024,
-0.746092677116394,
0.7195999026298523,
0.13049495220184326,
0.05164498835802078,
-0.8992446064949036,
-0.9664561152458191,
-0.2122197300195694,
-0.5350583791732788,
-0.26595667004585266,
0.33335378766059875,
-0.26100680232048035,
-0.03611603379249573,
-0.3422944247722626,
-0.2603529095649719,
-0.21527427434921265,
0.17154757678508759,
0.5279313921928406,
0.12280785292387009,
-0.2431773692369461,
0.17954976856708527,
0.3722831904888153,
-0.44168663024902344,
-0.021856240928173065,
0.17945140600204468,
0.7165776491165161,
-0.07692437618970871,
-0.7392726540565491,
-0.6378390192985535,
0.4407685399055481,
0.39337411522865295,
-0.13791689276695251,
0.7702628374099731,
0.5470607280731201,
-0.2715132236480713,
-0.2971288859844208,
-0.6292684078216553,
-0.1354866623878479,
-0.5700930953025818,
0.5703455209732056,
-0.4981682002544403,
-0.7449776530265808,
0.8478149771690369,
-0.015205477364361286,
0.49584174156188965,
0.44442275166511536,
0.436422735452652,
-0.0750054121017456,
0.6068569421768188,
1.1730430126190186,
-0.11296118795871735,
0.5639623403549194,
-0.5765770077705383,
0.46053871512413025,
-0.5831366181373596,
0.0016881577903404832,
-0.6023060083389282,
-0.3526645004749298,
-0.5673308372497559,
0.032292552292346954,
0.0673045814037323,
0.3649846911430359,
-0.19599145650863647,
0.4538925290107727,
-0.4647655487060547,
0.7999727129936218,
0.6863430738449097,
-0.17065522074699402,
0.6571962833404541,
0.20892228186130524,
-0.009516863152384758,
-0.26341769099235535,
-0.6407397389411926,
-0.21041864156723022,
0.8626518249511719,
0.46509021520614624,
0.9556300044059753,
0.10999658703804016,
0.9098517298698425,
0.19703532755374908,
0.09259950369596481,
-1.0298115015029907,
0.4869616627693176,
-0.1813284009695053,
-0.44534000754356384,
-0.5643656253814697,
-0.2808268368244171,
-0.9819012880325317,
0.3628319203853607,
-0.20498934388160706,
-0.6838515996932983,
0.14460571110248566,
0.23661154508590698,
-0.6920478940010071,
0.5307506322860718,
-0.5799255967140198,
0.5315205454826355,
0.09186556190252304,
0.11211585253477097,
-0.06729643791913986,
-0.6583865284919739,
0.16288220882415771,
-0.35248103737831116,
-0.007526859641075134,
-0.2384471893310547,
-0.10197799652814865,
0.6817823052406311,
-0.588559627532959,
0.9629074335098267,
0.06701774895191193,
-0.6593555808067322,
0.043562181293964386,
0.16162477433681488,
0.6500855684280396,
-0.09899969398975372,
-0.23890617489814758,
0.47183796763420105,
-0.05222797766327858,
-0.028781257569789886,
-0.9481346011161804,
0.7389193773269653,
-0.9064218997955322,
-0.20982146263122559,
-0.07084053754806519,
-0.43376097083091736,
-0.24244478344917297,
0.3363165557384491,
0.7066004276275635,
0.5241932272911072,
0.0168759785592556,
0.3739071786403656,
0.6282240748405457,
-0.2605472207069397,
0.9345042109489441,
0.5003208518028259,
-0.23723851144313812,
-0.40414121747016907,
0.6153382062911987,
0.21347349882125854,
0.4196634888648987,
0.6244603991508484,
0.46660467982292175,
-0.23572379350662231,
-0.6066071391105652,
-0.12569688260555267,
0.30328983068466187,
-0.8645063638687134,
-0.28624919056892395,
-0.5403188467025757,
-0.6315643787384033,
0.10381323844194412,
-0.28401848673820496,
-0.8362033367156982,
-0.5480104088783264,
-0.22714658081531525,
-0.19052714109420776,
0.42884907126426697,
0.6552427411079407,
-0.003132507437840104,
0.6071068048477173,
-0.7081639170646667,
0.29246580600738525,
0.28385815024375916,
0.5982475280761719,
0.03017164207994938,
-0.7825218439102173,
-0.2718476951122284,
-0.14800716936588287,
-0.23164789378643036,
-0.38847050070762634,
0.26137465238571167,
0.3559624254703522,
0.5825002193450928,
0.6489530205726624,
0.14975443482398987,
0.5373044013977051,
-0.6772100329399109,
0.6050570011138916,
0.5331323146820068,
-1.024150013923645,
0.6049315929412842,
-0.49224141240119934,
0.1774316132068634,
0.43819883465766907,
0.057677656412124634,
-0.5318427085876465,
-0.2799493968486786,
-0.4874977767467499,
-1.2707409858703613,
0.5987212061882019,
0.30469003319740295,
0.38662707805633545,
0.33146071434020996,
0.32618117332458496,
0.32735902070999146,
0.31192365288734436,
-0.9940364956855774,
-0.4581771492958069,
0.09547092765569687,
-0.193804070353508,
0.1628057211637497,
-0.10009026527404785,
-0.282209575176239,
-0.021523304283618927,
0.39592182636260986,
-0.1700190305709839,
0.09608788788318634,
-0.4953440725803375,
-0.07609518617391586,
-0.0938844382762909,
0.5392680764198303,
0.3957902491092682,
0.7296728491783142,
-0.020262470468878746,
-0.1886860430240631,
0.28369995951652527,
-0.43692877888679504,
-0.06923002004623413,
-0.07002941519021988,
-0.6886600852012634,
0.2511237859725952,
0.4196762442588806,
0.8176809549331665,
0.34930384159088135,
-0.587895929813385,
0.38395431637763977,
0.17075814306735992,
-0.3066617250442505,
-0.25243598222732544,
0.11635644733905792,
-0.061625175178050995,
0.18324580788612366,
0.4563833177089691,
0.20743004977703094,
0.1906173676252365,
-0.20432040095329285,
-0.1595257818698883,
0.43520811200141907,
-0.47854191064834595,
-0.11136072874069214,
0.5115087628364563,
0.3820204734802246,
-0.42756935954093933,
0.40232574939727783,
0.46956077218055725,
-0.04573499411344528,
0.4343348741531372,
0.49305519461631775,
0.9478387236595154,
0.08939342945814133,
0.3478749990463257,
-0.17709828913211823,
0.2923332154750824,
-0.12525597214698792,
-0.05522274598479271,
-0.011596372351050377,
-0.5954267978668213,
-0.7510918378829956,
-0.7227995991706848,
-0.42744311690330505,
0.43588632345199585,
-0.9564511775970459,
0.15107135474681854,
-0.47845542430877686,
-0.25185781717300415,
-0.07754340022802353,
0.0006202455260790884,
-0.5283620953559875,
0.0029022693634033203,
-0.10277620702981949,
0.6785653829574585,
-0.7831011414527893,
0.4596056640148163,
0.31872040033340454,
-0.4957036077976227,
-0.8327495455741882,
0.011359254829585552,
-0.21177354454994202,
-0.620936930179596,
0.6679832339286804,
0.10337895154953003,
-0.23056751489639282,
-0.16500981152057648,
-0.48797807097435,
-1.3079057931900024,
0.8397584557533264,
0.8328043818473816,
-0.7051591873168945,
-0.2825866937637329,
0.3519063889980316,
0.4859786927700043,
0.14783117175102234,
0.10336527228355408,
0.740426778793335,
0.13613219559192657,
0.10233398526906967,
-0.9964361190795898,
-0.15055157244205475,
0.037537701427936554,
0.2300063967704773,
0.512935996055603,
-0.711656391620636,
0.7160015106201172,
-0.23418988287448883,
-0.22544150054454803,
0.2610481083393097,
0.5102276802062988,
0.0845453292131424,
0.04976055771112442,
0.2919037640094757,
0.5660174489021301,
0.633976399898529,
-0.11361460387706757,
0.8435658812522888,
-0.10319112241268158,
0.6257157325744629,
1.2318302392959595,
-0.3254021108150482,
1.2684061527252197,
0.5429664850234985,
-0.4670616686344147,
0.2373938411474228,
0.45640695095062256,
0.23770323395729065,
0.6154526472091675,
0.16897636651992798,
-0.0564090758562088,
-0.05970398709177971,
0.1201731413602829,
-0.49072033166885376,
0.5093337297439575,
0.11207421869039536,
-0.2372949719429016,
-0.28330597281455994,
0.18954426050186157,
0.11923431605100632,
0.0005781411309726536,
-0.36344683170318604,
0.6298290491104126,
0.30086463689804077,
-0.29381150007247925,
0.8498594760894775,
-0.05626869946718216,
0.8135595321655273,
-0.577292799949646,
0.19537393748760223,
-0.6831266283988953,
0.38345906138420105,
-0.3907369077205658,
-0.49125075340270996,
0.16381581127643585,
-0.07610034942626953,
-0.4295401871204376,
-0.08096667379140854,
0.36633041501045227,
-0.29964566230773926,
-0.31977808475494385,
0.3388850688934326,
0.4876852035522461,
0.08716252446174622,
-0.04126216843724251,
-0.5118589401245117,
0.21454936265945435,
-0.26354050636291504,
-0.16471363604068756,
0.30550864338874817,
0.2632027268409729,
0.19408591091632843,
0.9049171805381775,
0.5549444556236267,
0.17381559312343597,
0.15076826512813568,
0.7786845564842224,
0.7900888919830322,
-0.6406658887863159,
-0.6042079329490662,
-0.9734348058700562,
0.382732093334198,
0.01143230777233839,
-0.3758281469345093,
0.7914628982543945,
0.2620429992675781,
0.5562649369239807,
-0.19154949486255646,
0.6894403696060181,
0.019012896344065666,
0.7433992028236389,
-0.7410374879837036,
1.02275550365448,
-0.5676530599594116,
0.4217343330383301,
-0.6069105863571167,
-1.1923879384994507,
-0.4112091064453125,
0.37633511424064636,
-0.003026344580575824,
0.10814971476793289,
0.7508715391159058,
0.5703915953636169,
-0.14675605297088623,
-0.31926852464675903,
0.5569688081741333,
0.03773842379450798,
0.3035421073436737,
0.4150897264480591,
0.9039090275764465,
-0.7071093320846558,
0.7574156522750854,
0.027234885841608047,
0.15828685462474823,
-0.35418713092803955,
-0.7700572609901428,
-0.9698100090026855,
-0.3803624212741852,
-0.41162723302841187,
-0.013505279086530209,
0.013837355189025402,
0.7522202730178833,
0.8824409246444702,
-0.795432448387146,
-0.07485871762037277,
-0.08145786076784134,
0.19377495348453522,
-0.24140647053718567,
-0.2003507763147354,
0.4687836766242981,
-0.13076242804527283,
-0.7154229283332825,
0.37561774253845215,
0.28896278142929077,
0.13378621637821198,
-0.4723721444606781,
0.11054036021232605,
0.1306619942188263,
0.12417380511760712,
0.8535178899765015,
0.5086835026741028,
-1.0615110397338867,
-0.1103360652923584,
-0.3502410352230072,
-0.08796008676290512,
0.17166352272033691,
0.7473916411399841,
-0.5731953382492065,
-0.17653626203536987,
0.294086217880249,
0.7687022089958191,
0.32800233364105225,
-0.17286591231822968,
0.4138179421424866,
-0.9920952320098877,
0.31007859110832214,
-0.01893123984336853,
0.17237018048763275,
0.27649345993995667,
-0.20253252983093262,
0.6609275937080383,
-0.11735043674707413,
-0.3519435226917267,
-1.0644632577896118,
0.404489129781723,
-0.9524810910224915,
0.07222816348075867,
1.1423304080963135,
0.08074626326560974,
-0.12146665155887604,
0.005163201596587896,
-0.14218129217624664,
0.012917015701532364,
-0.32364124059677124,
0.7997894883155823,
0.31935614347457886,
0.0070128473453223705,
-0.20371906459331512,
-0.5236660838127136,
0.5856103897094727,
0.5816709995269775,
-0.942084789276123,
0.1073630228638649,
0.3185938894748688,
0.277272492647171,
0.4602597653865814,
0.2986087501049042,
0.18571984767913818,
0.04839096963405609,
-0.26730915904045105,
0.27347055077552795,
0.11626554280519485,
-0.3912476599216461,
-0.5941609144210815,
0.4568746089935303,
0.05148377642035484,
-0.28452304005622864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16009v1
|
PST-Bench: Tracing and Benchmarking the Source of Publications
| 2024-02-25T06:56:43 | 2024-02-25T06:56:43 |
Fanjin Zhang, Kun Cao, Yukuo Cen, Jifan Yu, Da Yin, Jie Tang
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.CL
|
Tracing the source of research papers is a fundamental yet challenging task
for researchers. The billion-scale citation relations between papers hinder
researchers from understanding the evolution of science efficiently. To date,
there is still a lack of an accurate and scalable dataset constructed by
professional researchers to identify the direct source of their studied papers,
based on which automatic algorithms can be developed to expand the evolutionary
knowledge of science. In this paper, we study the problem of paper source
tracing (PST) and construct a high-quality and ever-increasing dataset
PST-Bench in computer science. Based on PST-Bench, we reveal several intriguing
discoveries, such as the differing evolution patterns across various topics. An
exploration of various methods underscores the hardness of PST-Bench,
pinpointing potential directions on this topic. The dataset and codes have been
available at https://github.com/THUDM/paper-source-trace.
|
[
-0.24197031557559967,
-0.3262960910797119,
0.9215858578681946,
0.2225039154291153,
-0.19129973649978638,
0.4198034107685089,
0.03324848413467407,
-0.30107977986335754,
0.12244322150945663,
0.24435093998908997,
-0.49551868438720703,
0.003379631321877241,
-0.7151073217391968,
0.0533410981297493,
-0.6012392640113831,
0.8393696546554565,
-0.08802524954080582,
0.05527906492352486,
-0.22619318962097168,
-0.1555825173854828,
0.04555875062942505,
-0.34307482838630676,
-0.27467599511146545,
-0.19659090042114258,
0.2245139330625534,
0.17795027792453766,
0.06950775533914566,
0.9771865010261536,
0.7634815573692322,
0.16408352553844452,
-0.15158794820308685,
0.1327114999294281,
-0.6502854228019714,
0.3295208513736725,
-0.432949036359787,
-0.2996109426021576,
0.0856325775384903,
-0.18390989303588867,
0.7130202651023865,
0.5127571821212769,
0.02993496134877205,
0.5959950089454651,
-0.0009005710016936064,
1.0224721431732178,
-0.6491977572441101,
0.2083335518836975,
-0.37239697575569153,
-0.12192358076572418,
-0.7865205407142639,
-0.7342965006828308,
-0.4266926050186157,
-0.5212692022323608,
0.031525421887636185,
-0.4819672107696533,
0.6377619504928589,
-0.2535795271396637,
0.8178231120109558,
0.10783520340919495,
-0.2553843855857849,
-0.26117363572120667,
-0.7887305021286011,
0.5128906965255737,
-0.16506065428256989,
0.1247161328792572,
0.14150798320770264,
0.6462677717208862,
-0.16242901980876923,
-0.9625786542892456,
0.046998463571071625,
-0.17365387082099915,
0.1938934624195099,
0.11395148932933807,
0.061341237276792526,
-0.7466535568237305,
0.3318880498409271,
0.0644364207983017,
-0.5317296385765076,
-0.6457198262214661,
-0.4377022385597229,
0.13299542665481567,
0.47667357325553894,
-0.10092633962631226,
-0.04909779503941536,
-0.05270540341734886,
-0.1854894757270813,
-0.26600944995880127,
-0.5487307906150818,
-0.29823940992355347,
0.23297420144081116,
0.5211170315742493,
0.32897353172302246,
0.2878660261631012,
-0.09899880737066269,
0.6037389039993286,
0.13713981211185455,
-0.07096604257822037,
0.18204724788665771,
-0.37621045112609863,
0.34755900502204895,
-0.05757826566696167,
0.47008126974105835,
-0.19281400740146637,
-0.20712144672870636,
-0.302546888589859,
0.2123631089925766,
-0.26126572489738464,
0.28756752610206604,
-0.6682100892066956,
-0.45074644684791565,
-0.24720707535743713,
-0.47328677773475647,
-0.2664739787578583,
0.15643569827079773,
-0.8814859390258789,
-0.8581773042678833,
-0.39116179943084717,
0.4175092577934265,
-0.4912776052951813,
-0.593212902545929,
-0.2836686372756958,
-0.35056445002555847,
0.2462357133626938,
0.4683627188205719,
-0.3039492666721344,
0.2151184380054474,
0.6900402307510376,
0.998162031173706,
-0.037015706300735474,
-0.16359680891036987,
-0.4048854410648346,
0.37105321884155273,
-0.3131270408630371,
1.0224616527557373,
-0.4334274232387543,
-0.2541317641735077,
-0.364129900932312,
-0.01609538309276104,
0.192276269197464,
-0.18555866181850433,
0.6508373022079468,
-0.2765726149082184,
-0.08899010717868805,
-1.1405045986175537,
-0.39672961831092834,
-0.13990038633346558,
-0.04457143321633339,
-0.5771780610084534,
0.9432236552238464,
0.2756121754646301,
-0.9844412803649902,
0.18531279265880585,
-0.6058306694030762,
-0.3242814242839813,
0.2875991761684418,
-0.36614134907722473,
-0.391676127910614,
0.33769240975379944,
0.03133000433444977,
-0.16973133385181427,
-0.620496928691864,
0.4213698208332062,
-0.3241649866104126,
-0.36377304792404175,
-0.024118516594171524,
0.09113336354494095,
1.2970871925354004,
0.3392530679702759,
-0.5764241814613342,
-0.4809669256210327,
-1.076539158821106,
-0.1297554075717926,
0.3114083409309387,
0.061677027493715286,
-0.4023396968841553,
0.3818448781967163,
0.07720963656902313,
0.07814817875623703,
0.2059548795223236,
-0.5565213561058044,
0.14229725301265717,
0.5559834241867065,
0.6384888887405396,
0.7585490345954895,
0.17008695006370544,
-0.06482820212841034,
-0.43724948167800903,
0.3325319290161133,
-0.4376644790172577,
-0.04580102860927582,
-0.16576294600963593,
-0.2833615243434906,
-0.29485955834388733,
-0.16556696593761444,
0.4913442134857178,
0.26621177792549133,
-0.24111340939998627,
0.09858302772045135,
-0.21792848408222198,
-0.8578007817268372,
-0.195863738656044,
-0.2314062863588333,
0.16209296882152557,
0.727469265460968,
0.26967358589172363,
-0.19040948152542114,
-0.6203028559684753,
-0.7881713509559631,
-0.6077151298522949,
-0.11713555455207825,
-0.11395280063152313,
0.2085469514131546,
0.36076658964157104,
0.21590116620063782,
1.1483232975006104,
-0.6200433969497681,
0.10293392837047577,
0.3409487307071686,
0.5835557579994202,
-0.022597646340727806,
0.5502261519432068,
0.803288996219635,
-0.7012550830841064,
-0.5965781211853027,
-0.2643367350101471,
-0.655232310295105,
-0.5114200115203857,
-0.1527295708656311,
-0.25123363733291626,
-0.4000113904476166,
0.7163748145103455,
-0.29078012704849243,
-0.10153429210186005,
0.06638059765100479,
-0.24996747076511383,
0.7715487480163574,
0.04072063788771629,
0.2785364091396332,
-1.0406628847122192,
0.7263424396514893,
0.1784065216779709,
0.0917162299156189,
-0.1754910945892334,
0.2066902220249176,
0.3592904806137085,
-0.4496292173862457,
0.1001996323466301,
0.1140831932425499,
-0.7204087376594543,
-0.26629194617271423,
-0.22295545041561127,
-0.1912512332201004,
0.03962748125195503,
0.10334271192550659,
-0.04914605990052223,
0.733690083026886,
0.5148885846138,
-0.07856755703687668,
0.11463287472724915,
0.07249823212623596,
-0.1907019317150116,
0.6495558619499207,
-0.1508513242006302,
0.27281802892684937,
-0.19982628524303436,
0.36402735114097595,
-0.9850947260856628,
0.11201082915067673,
-0.18039336800575256,
-0.3009413480758667,
0.2444940060377121,
-0.415055513381958,
-0.8546428084373474,
-0.4073137640953064,
-0.3230403959751129,
0.23504893481731415,
0.28342825174331665,
-0.5847430229187012,
0.323213666677475,
0.22348742187023163,
-0.3676729202270508,
-0.34031808376312256,
-0.37080997228622437,
0.15731048583984375,
0.032510071992874146,
-0.4825078845024109,
0.391860693693161,
-0.23089447617530823,
-0.21681685745716095,
0.0749213919043541,
-0.5369158387184143,
-0.11953476071357727,
-0.20304158329963684,
0.20149098336696625,
-0.09331922233104706,
-0.27828553318977356,
0.03256252035498619,
-0.21133986115455627,
-0.12164421379566193,
0.26975977420806885,
-0.288611501455307,
0.3716127276420593,
-0.11934540420770645,
-0.4469054639339447,
-0.14439953863620758,
0.2252083569765091,
0.8846269249916077,
-0.24066802859306335,
0.15652132034301758,
0.35794323682785034,
-0.25604426860809326,
-0.1339767724275589,
-0.6737320423126221,
-0.1367674618959427,
-0.4417688548564911,
0.12807215750217438,
-0.4039115011692047,
-0.2126951515674591,
0.5350770950317383,
-0.6120567321777344,
-0.1591721475124359,
0.5745977163314819,
-0.03064083866775036,
0.11479423940181732,
0.8162006139755249,
0.603948712348938,
-0.06275533139705658,
0.4958433210849762,
-0.07034577429294586,
0.12805205583572388,
-0.7335329055786133,
-0.13315340876579285,
-1.2915228605270386,
-0.23225820064544678,
-0.6363058686256409,
-0.07297156006097794,
0.12960192561149597,
0.05537888780236244,
-0.4868384599685669,
0.5831202268600464,
-0.9201264977455139,
0.6003516912460327,
0.6235253214836121,
0.22641851007938385,
0.36849161982536316,
0.048512499779462814,
0.08932715654373169,
-0.1490791290998459,
-0.26317840814590454,
-0.07981915771961212,
1.0843369960784912,
0.060594744980335236,
0.5580796003341675,
-0.20952753722667694,
0.8203535079956055,
0.3292122781276703,
0.21654172241687775,
-0.11435911804437637,
0.45707619190216064,
-0.018140573054552078,
-0.5984485745429993,
0.025602402165532112,
-0.5079364776611328,
-0.5299804210662842,
0.06058318912982941,
0.24630242586135864,
-0.5854546427726746,
0.6849104762077332,
-0.14355187118053436,
-0.06160019710659981,
0.3649945855140686,
-0.5921251773834229,
0.546310544013977,
-0.4190044403076172,
-0.7495824098587036,
-0.05250656232237816,
-0.6087824106216431,
0.26768285036087036,
-0.31562548875808716,
0.05797958746552467,
-0.03734930232167244,
0.07923819869756699,
1.051375150680542,
-0.5319435000419617,
0.2920626699924469,
-0.38343873620033264,
0.21003302931785583,
0.30318427085876465,
0.3387579619884491,
0.7224631309509277,
0.11446886509656906,
-0.2885855436325073,
-0.19931663572788239,
0.14926616847515106,
-0.7951077818870544,
-0.09506778419017792,
0.8104913234710693,
-0.6822133660316467,
-0.30984511971473694,
-0.9244261980056763,
-0.4368807077407837,
-0.5396071672439575,
0.4925791919231415,
0.380767822265625,
0.27781644463539124,
-0.07647737115621567,
0.26771265268325806,
0.5150114297866821,
0.09623970091342926,
0.2869385778903961,
1.004744052886963,
0.19322767853736877,
-0.12618298828601837,
1.1077113151550293,
0.38974297046661377,
-0.4047335088253021,
0.23395195603370667,
0.36335790157318115,
-0.15854857861995697,
-0.8824611902236938,
-0.1392880529165268,
0.3858335614204407,
-0.49222055077552795,
-0.4360578656196594,
-0.22798824310302734,
-0.1695866882801056,
-0.15136806666851044,
-0.3551270067691803,
-0.332724004983902,
-0.5489993095397949,
-0.08289621025323868,
0.050577353686094284,
0.502189040184021,
0.44804075360298157,
-0.2953543961048126,
0.03432484716176987,
-0.4048502445220947,
0.2564866542816162,
0.3231162428855896,
0.5869265794754028,
-0.06857682019472122,
-0.07146736979484558,
-0.045493315905332565,
-0.19981649518013,
-0.5201874375343323,
-1.0296754837036133,
0.32398176193237305,
-0.1263936311006546,
0.369610995054245,
0.29988667368888855,
0.15937195718288422,
0.7247335910797119,
-0.3746509850025177,
0.643696665763855,
0.08468146622180939,
-0.783730685710907,
0.764858067035675,
-0.9240878820419312,
0.21722102165222168,
1.0116758346557617,
0.4279748201370239,
-0.1136535182595253,
-0.18982429802417755,
-0.887484610080719,
-0.823302149772644,
0.9330441355705261,
0.10908187180757523,
-0.5697047114372253,
0.2978082597255707,
0.4481821358203888,
0.19041913747787476,
0.11127068847417831,
-0.27624306082725525,
0.11079767346382141,
-0.3951745927333832,
0.250698059797287,
0.162873774766922,
-0.030648525804281235,
-0.3861871659755707,
-0.2811717092990875,
0.6964792013168335,
0.10805065184831619,
0.19245509803295135,
0.17356330156326294,
-0.15044352412223816,
-0.5338042974472046,
-0.0374070480465889,
0.5138185024261475,
1.3679291009902954,
-0.8317176103591919,
0.26232945919036865,
-0.6050081253051758,
-0.6420193314552307,
0.0522271990776062,
0.5609358549118042,
-0.4274712800979614,
0.228311225771904,
0.17413994669914246,
0.08150682598352432,
-0.22193647921085358,
-0.48731398582458496,
0.2676491141319275,
0.10971926152706146,
-0.27306628227233887,
-0.10353080183267593,
-0.38540711998939514,
0.36613011360168457,
0.13136599957942963,
1.0227166414260864,
0.22475220263004303,
0.18970204889774323,
-0.4516493082046509,
0.4188224673271179,
0.1968676596879959,
-0.09273017197847366,
-0.2890233099460602,
0.4708406627178192,
0.12145315110683441,
-0.2977118194103241,
0.46828365325927734,
-0.23564304411411285,
-0.3134123980998993,
0.8355268239974976,
0.587946891784668,
0.7721261382102966,
-0.21068619191646576,
0.36595213413238525,
0.5031935572624207,
0.20328116416931152,
-0.36479732394218445,
0.15899814665317535,
-0.22943344712257385,
0.1780095249414444,
-0.24904108047485352,
-0.5220926403999329,
-0.6788148880004883,
0.5599606037139893,
-0.7681826949119568,
0.22779041528701782,
-0.3731817603111267,
0.13336911797523499,
0.4116058349609375,
0.3619821071624756,
-0.2938876748085022,
-0.28747060894966125,
-0.18350201845169067,
1.0614765882492065,
-0.9756723642349243,
0.6380434632301331,
0.4773566424846649,
-0.2793189287185669,
-0.3170178532600403,
0.08916555345058441,
0.3122042715549469,
-0.49750304222106934,
0.5005822777748108,
-0.1003941148519516,
-0.08671704679727554,
-0.002468193182721734,
-0.6723547577857971,
-1.1418718099594116,
1.0106929540634155,
0.5488304495811462,
-0.5562574863433838,
0.1900852918624878,
-0.14488643407821655,
0.6190666556358337,
0.16079159080982208,
0.20102594792842865,
0.2702745795249939,
0.6572903990745544,
-0.019787991419434547,
-0.4032854735851288,
0.2591538727283478,
-0.4748241901397705,
-0.03298034891486168,
0.5006296038627625,
-0.7116912603378296,
1.0211069583892822,
0.22849202156066895,
-0.05057423561811447,
-0.13227705657482147,
0.24350354075431824,
0.38592490553855896,
0.32835063338279724,
0.16993507742881775,
0.40250325202941895,
0.5767543911933899,
-0.17696841061115265,
0.5228650569915771,
-0.3468035161495209,
0.544101893901825,
1.0522741079330444,
-0.34273096919059753,
0.5884177088737488,
0.46527954936027527,
-0.4022979736328125,
0.4963190257549286,
0.700124204158783,
-0.5567234754562378,
0.6635670065879822,
0.34848204255104065,
-0.032589495182037354,
0.07527194172143936,
0.11001389473676682,
-0.7688351273536682,
0.013968762010335922,
0.38958725333213806,
-0.36291342973709106,
-0.7604318261146545,
-0.27524229884147644,
-0.056831687688827515,
-0.05062466859817505,
-0.07243810594081879,
0.44815725088119507,
-0.26524102687835693,
-0.6127346158027649,
0.46665826439857483,
-0.26941004395484924,
0.2824840843677521,
-0.8850314021110535,
0.03967301920056343,
-0.32061877846717834,
0.17766189575195312,
-0.09654997289180756,
-0.5130214095115662,
0.2709180414676666,
-0.01798434928059578,
-0.1785489171743393,
-0.5064332485198975,
0.6736094355583191,
0.15280935168266296,
-0.40697965025901794,
0.15686467289924622,
0.6096662282943726,
-0.0237553883343935,
-0.12594611942768097,
-0.6815590858459473,
0.08651519566774368,
-0.1282798945903778,
-0.4020659625530243,
0.6058696508407593,
0.5970944166183472,
-0.009350843727588654,
0.26470115780830383,
0.5737242698669434,
0.18134665489196777,
-0.14077334105968475,
-0.382221519947052,
0.7317602038383484,
-0.6218293905258179,
-0.5503915548324585,
-0.5411523580551147,
-0.12563033401966095,
-0.3525044620037079,
-0.2723466455936432,
0.7177233695983887,
0.8523575663566589,
0.3629939556121826,
-0.06773476302623749,
0.8916162252426147,
-0.4196603298187256,
0.7989426255226135,
0.2757730484008789,
0.7834676504135132,
-0.3110508620738983,
0.03861384093761444,
-0.47690027952194214,
-0.8758583664894104,
-0.15688765048980713,
0.4258972704410553,
-0.09710422158241272,
-0.19759100675582886,
0.8232889175415039,
0.47225329279899597,
-0.499406635761261,
0.2957945168018341,
-0.5646941065788269,
0.18145661056041718,
0.4716689884662628,
0.20150285959243774,
0.45371440052986145,
-0.1491074115037918,
0.8057169318199158,
-0.4937162697315216,
-0.6530609130859375,
-0.49277040362358093,
-1.1610338687896729,
-0.17453338205814362,
-0.9174083471298218,
-0.3770439922809601,
-0.42545974254608154,
0.533611536026001,
0.1507018655538559,
0.765675961971283,
-0.7877532839775085,
-0.30038952827453613,
-0.6869951486587524,
-0.2889593243598938,
-0.8219192624092102,
-0.2532334625720978,
1.0862054824829102,
-0.32583102583885193,
-0.11736505478620529,
0.3942945897579193,
0.08098006993532181,
-0.12940730154514313,
-0.057454872876405716,
0.26971328258514404,
-0.560680091381073,
0.022976823151111603,
0.33847007155418396,
0.9469743967056274,
-0.05013936012983322,
-0.10357043892145157,
0.13840007781982422,
-0.08161493390798569,
0.11293711513280869,
1.2290706634521484,
-0.6020829677581787,
0.5380851030349731,
0.9080913662910461,
0.661020040512085,
1.1946117877960205,
0.015968620777130127,
0.5368548035621643,
-0.7356898188591003,
-0.19745711982250214,
0.4450448751449585,
0.24030855298042297,
0.3314587473869324,
-0.09411060065031052,
0.9434314966201782,
0.5780938267707825,
-0.6656116843223572,
-1.290008306503296,
0.008614812977612019,
-1.1654309034347534,
-0.6610173583030701,
0.6586812734603882,
0.1377345770597458,
-0.06024807319045067,
-0.05229513347148895,
-0.1533588469028473,
0.27086910605430603,
-0.247113898396492,
1.3091950416564941,
0.8207345008850098,
-0.6540385484695435,
-0.23650887608528137,
-0.4920901656150818,
0.7424409985542297,
0.25380516052246094,
-0.8262841701507568,
0.41845622658729553,
0.25094085931777954,
0.2960057854652405,
0.7820214629173279,
0.562940776348114,
-0.2143990844488144,
0.44064801931381226,
0.3652549684047699,
-0.3960602581501007,
-0.24586383998394012,
-0.1482156664133072,
0.08717507123947144,
0.6062145829200745,
0.09226163476705551,
-0.15747201442718506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16006v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16006v2
|
ASETF: A Novel Method for Jailbreak Attack on LLMs through Translate Suffix Embeddings
| 2024-02-25T06:46:27 | 2024-06-04T02:59:58 |
Hao Wang, Hao Li, Minlie Huang, Lei Sha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The safety defense methods of Large language models(LLMs) stays limited
because the dangerous prompts are manually curated to just few known attack
types, which fails to keep pace with emerging varieties. Recent studies found
that attaching suffixes to harmful instructions can hack the defense of LLMs
and lead to dangerous outputs. However, similar to traditional text adversarial
attacks, this approach, while effective, is limited by the challenge of the
discrete tokens. This gradient based discrete optimization attack requires over
100,000 LLM calls, and due to the unreadable of adversarial suffixes, it can be
relatively easily penetrated by common defense methods such as perplexity
filters. To cope with this challenge, in this paper, we proposes an Adversarial
Suffix Embedding Translation Framework (ASETF), aimed at transforming
continuous adversarial suffix embeddings into coherent and understandable text.
This method greatly reduces the computational overhead during the attack
process and helps to automatically generate multiple adversarial samples, which
can be used as data to strengthen LLMs security defense. Experimental
evaluations were conducted on Llama2, Vicuna, and other prominent LLMs,
employing harmful directives sourced from the Advbench dataset. The results
indicate that our method significantly reduces the computation time of
adversarial suffixes and achieves a much better attack success rate to existing
techniques, while significantly enhancing the textual fluency of the prompts.
In addition, our approach can be generalized into a broader method for
generating transferable adversarial suffixes that can successfully attack
multiple LLMs, even black-box LLMs, such as ChatGPT and Gemini.
|
[
-0.44505491852760315,
-0.9421632289886475,
0.26311448216438293,
0.43812236189842224,
-0.43595993518829346,
0.3422022759914398,
-0.206243097782135,
-0.18747834861278534,
0.1766115128993988,
0.6683218479156494,
-0.7696830034255981,
-0.7523566484451294,
-0.8391108512878418,
0.24692746996879578,
-0.4175301492214203,
0.6802559494972229,
-0.05013737455010414,
0.16398204863071442,
0.18103928864002228,
0.036894284188747406,
-0.33607566356658936,
-0.4345133900642395,
-0.7633281946182251,
0.0183037668466568,
0.22993992269039154,
0.3465249538421631,
0.6461814045906067,
0.7299260497093201,
0.5824713110923767,
0.22854672372341156,
0.021546978503465652,
0.24856799840927124,
-0.28521475195884705,
0.18090175092220306,
0.046817805618047714,
-0.25004810094833374,
-0.393197625875473,
-0.22587917745113373,
0.34303563833236694,
0.173135906457901,
-0.07157609611749649,
-0.22808250784873962,
-0.27366676926612854,
0.6467995047569275,
-0.525749921798706,
-0.42178913950920105,
-0.8676156401634216,
0.17535388469696045,
-0.43999332189559937,
-0.2329939305782318,
-0.26577314734458923,
-0.30722832679748535,
-0.2614213228225708,
-0.43060755729675293,
-0.1825283020734787,
0.22818346321582794,
0.8011640310287476,
0.4155732989311218,
-0.43921247124671936,
-0.4719603955745697,
-0.2548389434814453,
0.45584985613822937,
-0.6587232351303101,
0.12616316974163055,
0.2551996409893036,
0.20419903099536896,
-0.6552751660346985,
-0.5864992737770081,
-0.2886180579662323,
-0.26389840245246887,
0.2883777320384979,
0.0646522268652916,
-0.32328662276268005,
0.26667001843452454,
0.19137915968894958,
0.2266809195280075,
-0.40114739537239075,
0.22625122964382172,
-0.13079208135604858,
-0.17853687703609467,
0.5372259616851807,
0.022046206519007683,
0.7324553728103638,
-0.30254414677619934,
-0.9147652983665466,
0.06779249012470245,
-1.2854893207550049,
-0.10227444022893906,
0.6289841532707214,
0.29732149839401245,
0.17354343831539154,
0.45161330699920654,
0.08080513775348663,
0.24977849423885345,
-0.040499601513147354,
0.004664112813770771,
-0.09105684608221054,
-0.11723987013101578,
-0.105056993663311,
0.22045351564884186,
1.052573800086975,
0.3893423080444336,
0.3392815887928009,
-0.4320051670074463,
-0.19753195345401764,
-0.12247392535209656,
0.3800632953643799,
-1.1325241327285767,
0.0013141619274392724,
0.18891149759292603,
-0.026498833671212196,
-0.6212604641914368,
0.2061588019132614,
-0.7449546456336975,
-0.5729005932807922,
0.45671576261520386,
0.12212991714477539,
-0.7764038443565369,
0.11184410750865936,
0.08075147867202759,
-0.09745268523693085,
0.16213040053844452,
0.06190883740782738,
-0.7429510951042175,
0.4458881914615631,
0.6418071389198303,
0.7223834991455078,
-0.1378430873155594,
-0.19856113195419312,
-0.7154017090797424,
0.22860364615917206,
-0.24971389770507812,
0.6635362505912781,
-0.30771496891975403,
-0.8358330130577087,
0.0005914115463383496,
-0.19004954397678375,
-0.08035526424646378,
-0.3867466449737549,
0.562995433807373,
-0.8602769374847412,
-0.4978770911693573,
-0.036103829741477966,
-0.4277673065662384,
-0.14510563015937805,
0.33859676122665405,
-0.6427851319313049,
0.7313739657402039,
-0.42925333976745605,
-0.6202310919761658,
-0.0006827478646300733,
-0.5995841026306152,
-0.7884620428085327,
-0.02654663287103176,
-0.13296468555927277,
-0.3505224883556366,
0.009056070819497108,
0.5879054069519043,
0.3881867527961731,
-0.5357606410980225,
0.2049521505832672,
-0.24908055365085602,
-0.24045094847679138,
0.43311169743537903,
-0.4894343316555023,
0.7428427338600159,
0.2631605565547943,
-0.3971198499202728,
0.2429952621459961,
-0.4362962245941162,
-0.20668897032737732,
0.21884262561798096,
-0.34658634662628174,
-0.4188813269138336,
0.1070595383644104,
-0.20313560962677002,
0.09824913740158081,
0.07894214987754822,
-0.7482501864433289,
0.3137829005718231,
-0.6269109845161438,
0.45917269587516785,
0.8351626992225647,
0.28710004687309265,
0.43046292662620544,
0.16391628980636597,
0.6857702136039734,
-0.22404034435749054,
0.19418630003929138,
-0.07374425232410431,
-0.40678298473358154,
-0.4959273934364319,
-0.49820277094841003,
0.3471830189228058,
0.7978447079658508,
-1.1258821487426758,
0.3244490325450897,
-0.215159609913826,
-0.09720193594694138,
-0.5240907073020935,
0.4706966280937195,
0.6023414731025696,
0.07737579196691513,
0.3822490870952606,
0.07029663771390915,
-0.5120751857757568,
-0.703647255897522,
-0.48281192779541016,
-0.03827187046408653,
0.03424551337957382,
0.15891851484775543,
0.4868226945400238,
-0.3020322620868683,
0.4494971036911011,
-0.5281641483306885,
-0.22127331793308258,
-0.1389361321926117,
-0.25700417160987854,
-0.03903552144765854,
0.41783732175827026,
0.5758301019668579,
-0.7015747427940369,
-0.33840876817703247,
-0.2764975428581238,
-0.6527099609375,
-0.2347363531589508,
-0.10927046835422516,
-0.29712072014808655,
-0.022947637364268303,
0.8720143437385559,
-0.42953261733055115,
0.41818493604660034,
0.22226926684379578,
-0.6771584153175354,
0.3390202224254608,
0.10388544201850891,
0.1307864785194397,
-1.0725668668746948,
-0.26878660917282104,
-0.21190838515758514,
-0.4680146872997284,
-0.5890299677848816,
0.5617665648460388,
0.08486945927143097,
-0.051509540528059006,
-0.6139836311340332,
0.5505325198173523,
-0.4537679851055145,
0.3011694848537445,
-0.08084109425544739,
0.19965526461601257,
-0.2667171359062195,
0.24285204708576202,
-0.47137871384620667,
0.7524814605712891,
0.4460368752479553,
-0.36058807373046875,
0.5737622976303101,
0.41317397356033325,
0.07305638492107391,
0.3303161561489105,
-0.509005606174469,
0.218141570687294,
0.15811942517757416,
0.06311938166618347,
-0.8349080085754395,
0.0624285563826561,
0.4855470359325409,
-0.519105076789856,
0.5307952165603638,
-0.34936100244522095,
-0.6422870755195618,
-0.2659609317779541,
-0.7980656623840332,
-0.02855624072253704,
0.5067796111106873,
-0.7803550362586975,
0.6082116961479187,
0.16689561307430267,
-0.03288285806775093,
-0.835192859172821,
-0.7810929417610168,
0.4412064850330353,
-0.506321370601654,
-0.9091586470603943,
0.5468841791152954,
0.0367966927587986,
-0.2182246893644333,
0.03069809265434742,
-0.09688159823417664,
0.30501464009284973,
0.5637158751487732,
0.3846397399902344,
0.36921364068984985,
-0.1749456226825714,
-0.2054646909236908,
0.14133158326148987,
-0.1379469335079193,
0.2724030613899231,
-0.37697696685791016,
0.42019546031951904,
-0.09834993630647659,
-0.40884751081466675,
-0.01594240963459015,
0.4184430241584778,
0.5717828869819641,
-0.05745813623070717,
0.8381481766700745,
0.4642205536365509,
-0.2982041835784912,
-0.5188289880752563,
-0.3958490490913391,
-0.1281660795211792,
-0.5305278301239014,
0.3613506257534027,
-0.46762222051620483,
-0.9151378870010376,
0.5448227524757385,
-0.42937159538269043,
0.027204010635614395,
0.22843937575817108,
0.22951267659664154,
0.14996379613876343,
0.811532199382782,
0.40154704451560974,
-0.08202004432678223,
0.4897441864013672,
-0.10460697114467621,
0.1788221001625061,
-0.935099720954895,
-0.31079596281051636,
-0.11234511435031891,
-0.09701084345579147,
-0.3827953636646271,
-0.4619877338409424,
0.22617870569229126,
0.4530264437198639,
-0.3461593985557556,
0.38353827595710754,
-0.17661969363689423,
0.42098966240882874,
0.15069761872291565,
-0.021641137078404427,
0.18124739825725555,
0.30286145210266113,
-0.4179462492465973,
-0.06320340931415558,
-0.3315529525279999,
-0.3945034146308899,
1.1692882776260376,
0.46048521995544434,
0.8057113289833069,
0.5130735635757446,
0.6915348172187805,
0.34622204303741455,
0.37974846363067627,
-0.8134750723838806,
0.7122630476951599,
-0.5659517049789429,
-0.22947712242603302,
-0.10080713033676147,
-0.43765711784362793,
-0.6642818450927734,
0.31640008091926575,
-0.06432419270277023,
-0.9252873063087463,
-0.0970071479678154,
-0.12772595882415771,
-0.345093697309494,
0.6294150948524475,
-0.3883659243583679,
0.6124024391174316,
-0.3139117658138275,
-0.23524044454097748,
0.03703618049621582,
-0.5151371359825134,
0.4818441867828369,
-0.12209201604127884,
0.16850651800632477,
-0.18139362335205078,
-0.2160428762435913,
0.7081082463264465,
-0.8631652593612671,
0.6173118352890015,
-0.2825966775417328,
-0.0036159909795969725,
0.20748519897460938,
0.24004602432250977,
0.7841255068778992,
0.4059232771396637,
-0.10095874965190887,
0.00581521587446332,
-0.3660465180873871,
-0.2312350869178772,
-0.7247176766395569,
0.8991447687149048,
-0.6919654607772827,
-1.016392469406128,
-0.28406375646591187,
-0.19644795358181,
-0.1099788099527359,
0.1141139343380928,
0.38045236468315125,
0.3774283528327942,
-0.33933573961257935,
-0.0683320164680481,
0.759346604347229,
-0.3191806972026825,
0.5169075727462769,
0.527753472328186,
-0.1475241631269455,
-0.6796364784240723,
1.0066566467285156,
-0.03247905150055885,
0.1331280618906021,
0.2522275447845459,
-0.09789495170116425,
-0.3162801265716553,
-0.7925723791122437,
-0.8913489580154419,
0.05097987502813339,
-0.8212672472000122,
-0.6400691866874695,
-0.5660035610198975,
-0.24018540978431702,
-0.31003421545028687,
-0.42514386773109436,
-0.37547874450683594,
-0.4564517140388489,
-0.07046434283256531,
-0.17550717294216156,
0.6902588605880737,
0.6310647130012512,
0.06569411605596542,
0.324429988861084,
-0.5588831305503845,
0.2701742649078369,
0.0249545369297266,
0.13833335041999817,
-0.05133676901459694,
-0.49697113037109375,
0.21613670885562897,
-0.23117409646511078,
-0.17934024333953857,
-1.131718635559082,
0.512397289276123,
0.14905080199241638,
0.3194209337234497,
0.39686328172683716,
0.33417460322380066,
0.6468057036399841,
-0.7537713050842285,
0.5036371350288391,
0.23828712105751038,
-0.9232956171035767,
0.5347075462341309,
-0.262420117855072,
-0.0691591277718544,
0.5710259675979614,
0.031028762459754944,
-0.2647605240345001,
-0.2336670458316803,
-0.5213237404823303,
-1.4022940397262573,
0.6582355499267578,
0.3924345374107361,
0.12581288814544678,
-0.05490308254957199,
0.46481648087501526,
-0.32736727595329285,
0.25816673040390015,
-0.2673921287059784,
-0.6928996443748474,
-0.14117054641246796,
-0.17999239265918732,
0.34951052069664,
-0.30333346128463745,
-0.20463694632053375,
-0.015779271721839905,
0.9392589926719666,
0.10049518197774887,
0.21286875009536743,
0.10111819207668304,
-0.2718842029571533,
0.32031553983688354,
0.3508794903755188,
0.31986334919929504,
-0.33386966586112976,
-0.08151417225599289,
0.2876608967781067,
0.4684399366378784,
-0.8419328927993774,
0.3663173317909241,
0.29164034128189087,
-0.17889045178890228,
-0.43956440687179565,
0.15435630083084106,
0.7215290069580078,
0.036592669785022736,
-0.6404886841773987,
0.711111843585968,
-0.28417956829071045,
0.04014987871050835,
-0.5734079480171204,
0.030123461037874222,
0.008060027845203876,
0.04899067431688309,
0.3765406310558319,
0.26192206144332886,
0.11475115269422531,
-0.3276170790195465,
0.3672526776790619,
0.4075325131416321,
-0.5486577749252319,
-0.07373378425836563,
0.6201167106628418,
0.37415289878845215,
-0.33624809980392456,
0.5790093541145325,
-0.4346475601196289,
-0.8713021278381348,
0.7760329842567444,
0.8073141574859619,
0.9498350024223328,
-0.3299747407436371,
-0.012846977449953556,
-0.06437677890062332,
0.5931930541992188,
-0.0015934420516714454,
0.131892591714859,
0.17429156601428986,
-0.728803277015686,
-0.09309206902980804,
-0.6569006443023682,
0.010137801989912987,
0.1609874963760376,
-0.4400024712085724,
0.1896582543849945,
-0.9266210794448853,
-0.06068417429924011,
-0.1828538179397583,
-0.1641271710395813,
-0.24198809266090393,
0.002865835325792432,
0.2666166424751282,
1.0952457189559937,
-0.5992224216461182,
0.6305297613143921,
0.9156829118728638,
-0.1589520275592804,
-0.5590710639953613,
0.17013730108737946,
0.3713201880455017,
-0.7980064749717712,
0.5033585429191589,
0.17720670998096466,
-0.6081256866455078,
0.1390993744134903,
-0.4534934461116791,
-0.8085852861404419,
0.9172618985176086,
0.5716035962104797,
-0.208231121301651,
0.10467298328876495,
-0.11045292019844055,
0.11705639213323593,
-0.3876381814479828,
-0.04692104458808899,
0.7894416451454163,
0.4833691716194153,
0.19408629834651947,
-0.23352274298667908,
0.6920320391654968,
-0.6250847578048706,
0.11947009712457657,
0.2424747496843338,
-0.4998483955860138,
0.4840359389781952,
-0.23996692895889282,
-0.4804869592189789,
0.20225031673908234,
0.6117645502090454,
0.25501465797424316,
-0.18504475057125092,
0.3067508637905121,
0.47299724817276,
0.5461351871490479,
-0.24208369851112366,
1.2951804399490356,
-0.23453928530216217,
-0.08455417305231094,
0.8268993496894836,
-0.03149789944291115,
0.7891504168510437,
0.6261760592460632,
-0.03537370264530182,
0.33224165439605713,
0.5144743323326111,
-0.2312479466199875,
0.7257859706878662,
0.6537750959396362,
-0.44363677501678467,
-0.17182719707489014,
-0.06445851922035217,
-0.09634163230657578,
0.08005809038877487,
0.8122764229774475,
-0.1635955572128296,
-0.19620464742183685,
0.43516960740089417,
0.5502915978431702,
0.19696493446826935,
-0.32542622089385986,
0.6708663702011108,
0.3831039071083069,
-0.3661263585090637,
0.5529178380966187,
0.6143950819969177,
0.9499301910400391,
-0.6777940988540649,
0.20038996636867523,
-0.04320569336414337,
0.2529483735561371,
-0.3165857493877411,
-0.47196197509765625,
0.20748159289360046,
0.29437267780303955,
0.021670151501893997,
0.025550754740834236,
0.7935560345649719,
-0.2039618045091629,
-0.3630005419254303,
0.7207959890365601,
0.12482485920190811,
0.059373047202825546,
-0.08300097286701202,
-0.7938565015792847,
0.14925937354564667,
0.22095684707164764,
-0.38206443190574646,
0.24036036431789398,
0.12101971358060837,
-0.1504104882478714,
0.7592089176177979,
0.6813057661056519,
0.2354629933834076,
0.1850598305463791,
0.15794268250465393,
1.0403538942337036,
-0.5113195776939392,
-0.5137568712234497,
-1.2563717365264893,
0.3528311848640442,
-0.23730064928531647,
-0.13908156752586365,
0.8816983699798584,
0.2835075259208679,
0.39121660590171814,
0.17996738851070404,
0.8909002542495728,
-0.031247802078723907,
-0.1198401227593422,
-0.853812038898468,
0.8000319004058838,
-0.28399381041526794,
0.8879646062850952,
-0.15412206947803497,
-0.4582509696483612,
-0.4741564691066742,
0.3750820457935333,
-0.45707130432128906,
-0.22880542278289795,
0.8351423144340515,
0.7743483781814575,
0.14877888560295105,
0.05502839758992195,
0.24915094673633575,
0.23692111670970917,
0.4443089962005615,
0.6195679306983948,
0.8043317198753357,
-0.6895726323127747,
0.7170485854148865,
0.10143418610095978,
-0.08441165834665298,
-0.15359999239444733,
-0.7010572552680969,
-1.3834458589553833,
-0.07852878421545029,
-0.2844722867012024,
-0.500149667263031,
0.5348948836326599,
1.0845706462860107,
0.44963520765304565,
-0.8275809288024902,
0.15809418261051178,
-0.22005657851696014,
0.2595551013946533,
0.15037761628627777,
-0.15792037546634674,
0.48825207352638245,
-0.17193730175495148,
-0.43022942543029785,
0.8319473266601562,
0.2911822199821472,
0.1584768444299698,
-0.14284349977970123,
-0.11411444842815399,
-0.24422143399715424,
0.31945908069610596,
0.23566479980945587,
0.2175285965204239,
-0.7847543954849243,
-0.13151726126670837,
-0.13719838857650757,
-0.1954769492149353,
-0.1408146172761917,
0.7106407880783081,
-0.4082799255847931,
0.3537823259830475,
0.2559889554977417,
0.9432646632194519,
0.18645966053009033,
0.16627237200737,
0.7427479028701782,
-1.0849348306655884,
0.2033093124628067,
-0.024432267993688583,
0.4472584128379822,
0.4891464114189148,
-0.7542825937271118,
0.41122934222221375,
0.21453168988227844,
0.006700947880744934,
-0.7855933904647827,
0.4195541739463806,
-0.5385222434997559,
-0.5777177810668945,
1.377525806427002,
-0.535337507724762,
-0.5361490845680237,
-0.2535640597343445,
-0.12666070461273193,
0.03822803497314453,
-0.7556958198547363,
0.32358136773109436,
0.465427964925766,
0.22591523826122284,
0.19767653942108154,
-0.6649363040924072,
0.8513651490211487,
0.3098424971103668,
-0.6139927506446838,
0.01304636336863041,
-0.08923925459384918,
0.38881972432136536,
0.06352013349533081,
0.29718202352523804,
-0.4012105464935303,
0.14235030114650726,
0.14799021184444427,
-0.16495318710803986,
-0.6625158190727234,
-0.2517718970775604,
-0.48384568095207214,
0.2571296691894531,
-0.0033476301468908787,
-0.25735291838645935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15992v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15992v1
|
A Machine Learning Approach to Detect Customer Satisfaction From Multiple Tweet Parameters
| 2024-02-25T05:16:43 | 2024-02-25T05:16:43 |
Md Mahmudul Hasan, Dr. Shaikh Anowarul Fattah
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Since internet technologies have advanced, one of the primary factors in
company development is customer happiness. Online platforms have become
prominent places for sharing reviews. Twitter is one of these platforms where
customers frequently post their thoughts. Reviews of flights on these platforms
have become a concern for the airline business. A positive review can help the
company grow, while a negative one can quickly ruin its revenue and reputation.
So it's vital for airline businesses to examine the feedback and experiences of
their customers and enhance their services to remain competitive. But studying
thousands of tweets and analyzing them to find the satisfaction of the customer
is quite a difficult task. This tedious process can be made easier by using a
machine learning approach to analyze tweets to determine client satisfaction
levels. Some work has already been done on this strategy to automate the
procedure using machine learning and deep learning techniques. However, they
are all purely concerned with assessing the text's sentiment. In addition to
the text, the tweet also includes the time, location, username, airline name,
and so on. This additional information can be crucial for improving the model's
outcome. To provide a machine learning based solution, this work has broadened
its perspective to include these qualities. And it has come as no surprise that
the additional features beyond text sentiment analysis produce better outcomes
in machine learning based models.
|
[
-0.5121915340423584,
-0.6852208375930786,
0.3840690553188324,
0.6780382990837097,
-0.3028033673763275,
0.34858977794647217,
0.0320364348590374,
-0.5761451721191406,
0.32846367359161377,
0.4089493155479431,
-0.8036821484565735,
-0.45464807748794556,
-0.5599504709243774,
0.08935832977294922,
-0.31222036480903625,
0.9222496747970581,
-0.2610000967979431,
0.16385678946971893,
0.1600719839334488,
-0.21050213277339935,
-0.2924870550632477,
-0.6046173572540283,
-0.8397577404975891,
-0.24507486820220947,
0.6088407635688782,
0.41692739725112915,
0.40795451402664185,
-0.06053483858704567,
0.7459406852722168,
0.298889696598053,
0.168483704328537,
0.3008878231048584,
-0.3270276188850403,
0.3791888952255249,
0.22206556797027588,
-0.005188405513763428,
-0.07843604683876038,
-0.10340812802314758,
0.4562254250049591,
0.7613360285758972,
-0.0708487257361412,
0.19054923951625824,
0.37660926580429077,
0.8201789855957031,
-0.2614075541496277,
0.04581465944647789,
-0.41941922903060913,
0.25525468587875366,
0.3111776113510132,
-0.27811914682388306,
0.007481167558580637,
-0.7242022752761841,
0.16399304568767548,
-0.41216036677360535,
0.037791263312101364,
-0.12504032254219055,
1.2481786012649536,
0.24946187436580658,
-0.6744017601013184,
-0.40233853459358215,
-0.951042115688324,
1.0172245502471924,
-0.508204996585846,
0.40400055050849915,
0.13413360714912415,
0.46228110790252686,
0.052133142948150635,
-0.22674913704395294,
-0.31553488969802856,
-0.19213107228279114,
-0.06014668196439743,
0.15151053667068481,
0.04895472899079323,
-0.17365683615207672,
-0.06481806188821793,
0.012158575467765331,
-0.5370773673057556,
0.0627921000123024,
0.07975597679615021,
0.011822248809039593,
0.42496636509895325,
0.014592919498682022,
0.039220236241817474,
-0.2474028617143631,
-0.3051503002643585,
0.09022023528814316,
0.21309290826320648,
0.3802804946899414,
0.3096272051334381,
0.15223073959350586,
0.16904105246067047,
0.37949538230895996,
-0.5353065729141235,
0.3312910199165344,
0.01532325241714716,
0.01673995517194271,
0.4470771253108978,
0.017030131071805954,
-0.5084241628646851,
-0.055190764367580414,
0.8192611932754517,
0.41743770241737366,
0.3813447952270508,
-0.12731795012950897,
-0.4811500608921051,
-0.0426812469959259,
0.3604244887828827,
-0.9051249623298645,
0.0980137437582016,
0.6748354434967041,
-0.9554141163825989,
-0.6275550723075867,
0.34774476289749146,
-0.6656472086906433,
-0.5305469632148743,
-0.5127955675125122,
0.1888684183359146,
-0.4971161484718323,
-0.48437294363975525,
-0.03708556666970253,
-0.2606540024280548,
0.2506798207759857,
0.4937096834182739,
-0.5275754928588867,
-0.1625981628894806,
0.843481183052063,
0.8421282768249512,
0.1559913158416748,
-0.31197071075439453,
-0.37373974919319153,
-0.00638164859265089,
-0.5870761275291443,
1.0031821727752686,
-0.43010374903678894,
-0.2797479033470154,
0.13078953325748444,
-0.20118576288223267,
0.04788495600223541,
-0.3940902352333069,
0.7502961754798889,
-0.6679670214653015,
0.12638722360134125,
-0.31120800971984863,
-0.8023127317428589,
-0.4726371765136719,
0.5367863178253174,
-0.4950784742832184,
0.6896747946739197,
0.19093383848667145,
-0.6932885646820068,
0.582130491733551,
-0.8594235181808472,
-0.6850019693374634,
0.21819843351840973,
-0.06846940517425537,
-0.9992489814758301,
0.39971062541007996,
0.49846288561820984,
0.6528461575508118,
0.2549379765987396,
0.036400701850652695,
-0.8668592572212219,
-0.1584959626197815,
0.45778003334999084,
0.07342830300331116,
0.9387543797492981,
0.49324679374694824,
-0.13777531683444977,
0.08342757076025009,
-0.32222893834114075,
0.3346615731716156,
-0.09892679750919342,
-0.4066823124885559,
0.019112873822450638,
-0.13878202438354492,
0.35471370816230774,
0.24977214634418488,
0.16759958863258362,
-0.6046316027641296,
0.06254243105649948,
-0.3334077000617981,
0.2454422116279602,
0.5143762826919556,
0.7763302326202393,
0.1187668889760971,
-0.29944759607315063,
0.46007245779037476,
0.271114319562912,
0.5206047892570496,
0.1948813647031784,
-0.4499227702617645,
-0.7593925595283508,
0.03391211852431297,
0.08980284631252289,
0.4458557367324829,
-0.433190256357193,
0.6466732621192932,
-0.2651796042919159,
-0.7598638534545898,
-0.7653972506523132,
0.27853500843048096,
-0.1465003788471222,
0.2849849462509155,
0.06311386078596115,
0.13987135887145996,
-0.9597771167755127,
-0.600139856338501,
-0.6132522225379944,
-0.20905539393424988,
0.040546126663684845,
0.07027877122163773,
0.3062838315963745,
-0.4139241576194763,
0.7734750509262085,
-0.5440382361412048,
-0.5661832094192505,
-0.19547583162784576,
0.23080074787139893,
0.31467050313949585,
0.2620678246021271,
0.6306431293487549,
-1.080275535583496,
-0.9178305268287659,
0.3493744730949402,
-0.9782882928848267,
0.17938005924224854,
-0.237233966588974,
-0.05814273655414581,
0.4106203019618988,
0.045740384608507156,
-0.4332350790500641,
0.4513527750968933,
0.345323383808136,
0.019776687026023865,
0.35803210735321045,
0.17275464534759521,
0.5845901370048523,
-1.1042009592056274,
0.09313493967056274,
0.41021212935447693,
-0.10693562775850296,
-0.6781747341156006,
-0.3768880367279053,
-0.1906442940235138,
-0.1422307938337326,
-0.20601579546928406,
0.1798039823770523,
-0.049566835165023804,
-0.07571332901716232,
-0.508621096611023,
-0.3865177035331726,
0.19479738175868988,
0.43972569704055786,
-0.1453985869884491,
0.2994708716869354,
0.4455842077732086,
-0.4887506365776062,
0.5371699929237366,
0.1202741414308548,
-0.30148565769195557,
0.489150732755661,
-0.42219817638397217,
-0.03753533959388733,
-0.13014955818653107,
0.26731157302856445,
-1.2574689388275146,
-0.21530741453170776,
0.29951581358909607,
-1.142477035522461,
-0.2951379120349884,
-0.04929172247648239,
-0.5801649689674377,
-0.3972163796424866,
-0.32183223962783813,
-0.26876550912857056,
0.40317386388778687,
-0.43605315685272217,
0.7777255177497864,
0.41995060443878174,
-0.0012012707302346826,
-0.4432150721549988,
-0.5850927233695984,
0.24954935908317566,
-0.35439708828926086,
-0.6138908267021179,
-0.005020106211304665,
0.18044887483119965,
-0.05691660940647125,
0.032510384917259216,
-0.007248362060636282,
-0.37373292446136475,
0.3584814965724945,
0.4575658440589905,
0.14050129055976868,
0.01250256784260273,
0.11007723212242126,
-0.16785825788974762,
-0.03212622553110123,
0.056289948523044586,
-0.5481449961662292,
0.5137270092964172,
-0.44721055030822754,
0.06465113162994385,
-1.047689437866211,
0.629692018032074,
0.48946958780288696,
-0.16850633919239044,
0.963771402835846,
1.034140944480896,
-0.6081405282020569,
-0.12019357085227966,
-0.7208966016769409,
-0.1021011620759964,
-0.4385526180267334,
0.28165531158447266,
-0.579174280166626,
-0.4483572840690613,
0.5971561670303345,
-0.14725665748119354,
-0.05562242493033409,
0.560068666934967,
0.5596613883972168,
-0.5933142304420471,
1.2636613845825195,
0.8930622935295105,
-0.29704251885414124,
0.6039021611213684,
-0.2625288963317871,
0.4225701093673706,
-0.1404523402452469,
-0.46665504574775696,
-0.7647731900215149,
-0.3334243893623352,
-0.8295488357543945,
0.3894328773021698,
0.09029136598110199,
-0.02556181699037552,
-0.14933735132217407,
0.17975406348705292,
-0.45455002784729004,
0.216248020529747,
0.3789094388484955,
0.23007403314113617,
0.02132187783718109,
0.26913177967071533,
-0.06665483862161636,
0.10407155007123947,
-0.20075251162052155,
-0.6226934194564819,
0.6644524931907654,
0.5181776285171509,
0.5290616154670715,
0.07211246341466904,
0.8647361397743225,
0.4841045141220093,
0.3169596493244171,
-0.8344318866729736,
0.3900016248226166,
-0.22846655547618866,
-0.352710485458374,
-0.2557312548160553,
-0.8178298473358154,
-0.7655502557754517,
-0.201729878783226,
-0.07618392258882523,
-0.5187362432479858,
0.0012778298696503043,
-0.17302580177783966,
-0.345767617225647,
0.11900225281715393,
-0.8622459173202515,
0.7108138203620911,
-0.3573387861251831,
-0.042227208614349365,
-0.1517103612422943,
-0.4807990491390228,
0.16288049519062042,
-0.2950496971607208,
-0.14072664082050323,
-0.10688551515340805,
-0.27678459882736206,
0.9192320108413696,
-0.3053150773048401,
0.6678469777107239,
-0.33529233932495117,
0.05331379175186157,
0.08131052553653717,
0.0470876581966877,
0.24823014438152313,
-0.008152737282216549,
-0.38660717010498047,
0.20876555144786835,
-0.04922384396195412,
-0.5373519062995911,
-0.5936535000801086,
0.8595801591873169,
-1.1572133302688599,
0.059669964015483856,
-0.22654502093791962,
-0.10051869601011276,
-0.567563533782959,
0.38643547892570496,
0.006617518607527018,
0.10057540982961655,
0.07854277640581131,
0.1771281212568283,
0.11983111500740051,
-0.10754576325416565,
0.7579891085624695,
0.04558708891272545,
-0.4691675305366516,
-0.6281694173812866,
0.9718270897865295,
0.11336924135684967,
-0.299488365650177,
0.5764557123184204,
0.22882162034511566,
-0.6514727473258972,
-0.38666215538978577,
-0.030268173664808273,
0.08563460409641266,
-0.6940116882324219,
-0.10726950317621231,
-0.8323492407798767,
-0.2729061245918274,
-0.6241086721420288,
0.05057559534907341,
-0.2205653339624405,
-0.22942933440208435,
-0.39806675910949707,
0.013333911076188087,
0.10717736184597015,
0.7236627340316772,
0.31591203808784485,
0.47208696603775024,
-0.9784691333770752,
0.46836721897125244,
-0.04462020844221115,
0.5852926969528198,
0.29247885942459106,
-0.08193608373403549,
-0.540492594242096,
-0.02434764802455902,
-0.621900200843811,
-0.8434367775917053,
0.5077530741691589,
0.018330292776226997,
0.4964396357536316,
0.7746172547340393,
-0.013584588654339314,
0.7063468098640442,
0.09564726799726486,
0.5810196399688721,
0.31656888127326965,
-0.8807267546653748,
0.6274479627609253,
-0.2631972134113312,
0.022600742056965828,
0.514671802520752,
0.6740817427635193,
-0.8316605687141418,
-0.34933874011039734,
-0.6461212635040283,
-0.38506558537483215,
0.501183807849884,
0.3393724858760834,
-0.012241067364811897,
0.4508764147758484,
0.3351597189903259,
0.17051155865192413,
0.6200932264328003,
-0.5401996374130249,
0.03731554001569748,
-0.5339645743370056,
-0.22649598121643066,
-0.1084708571434021,
-0.10572036355733871,
0.3827275335788727,
-0.055162835866212845,
0.8090725541114807,
0.10062786191701889,
0.25552403926849365,
-0.13137751817703247,
0.15104074776172638,
-0.2845742106437683,
0.006130806636065245,
0.3498811423778534,
0.7236723899841309,
-0.5596475601196289,
-0.11242420971393585,
-0.18289311230182648,
-0.023430312052369118,
-0.030760282650589943,
-0.01215875893831253,
0.08940578252077103,
0.3352951407432556,
0.3548157811164856,
0.50124591588974,
-0.685123085975647,
-0.15991005301475525,
0.41960829496383667,
-0.1830933541059494,
-0.32307517528533936,
-0.4910142123699188,
-0.20988237857818604,
-0.05929432809352875,
0.10034216940402985,
0.74835604429245,
0.5618456602096558,
0.4103042483329773,
-0.3175731599330902,
0.4443354606628418,
0.3649574816226959,
-0.695165753364563,
-0.003458702005445957,
0.18440517783164978,
0.43620699644088745,
-0.5931350588798523,
0.5738362669944763,
-0.15351814031600952,
-0.9333285689353943,
0.4912920892238617,
-0.15719769895076752,
1.258677363395691,
-0.24755962193012238,
0.4375820457935333,
0.14122864603996277,
0.20599974691867828,
0.22157499194145203,
0.4488750398159027,
0.22654348611831665,
-0.600604236125946,
-0.5000649094581604,
-0.6227470636367798,
-0.4731135368347168,
0.21726952493190765,
-0.5499671101570129,
0.43133577704429626,
-0.6186372637748718,
-0.4981180429458618,
0.2516154944896698,
0.4593770503997803,
-0.7454237341880798,
0.5653508305549622,
0.18703091144561768,
0.5139217376708984,
-0.8619527816772461,
0.5703043937683105,
0.7013579607009888,
-0.508897602558136,
-0.8278052806854248,
0.5303925275802612,
-0.32939738035202026,
-0.5525965094566345,
0.7148039937019348,
0.7542201280593872,
-0.2049400508403778,
-0.13909104466438293,
-0.25146451592445374,
-0.03496486321091652,
0.33626407384872437,
-0.08528762310743332,
-0.4153032600879669,
0.31200721859931946,
0.4220593571662903,
0.7248231768608093,
-0.4519554674625397,
0.2762382924556732,
0.12881211936473846,
0.3409142792224884,
0.035538461059331894,
-0.5728445053100586,
-0.2049906700849533,
-0.12904566526412964,
0.2087993174791336,
0.14894768595695496,
-0.5834317207336426,
0.5441765785217285,
-0.01695362664759159,
0.09741316735744476,
-0.25680166482925415,
0.6904173493385315,
0.1084970235824585,
0.5373568534851074,
0.7625512480735779,
0.4647303819656372,
0.6689327359199524,
0.12257374823093414,
0.9287395477294922,
-0.13427269458770752,
0.8098462224006653,
0.7215940356254578,
-0.14731355011463165,
1.061325192451477,
0.7583215832710266,
0.06753923743963242,
0.3879978060722351,
1.0193098783493042,
-0.2906576693058014,
0.5243058204650879,
-0.048640456050634384,
-0.04681585356593132,
-0.4406498670578003,
-0.2436017096042633,
-0.21205487847328186,
0.1992812305688858,
0.10456790775060654,
-0.13696156442165375,
-0.2233661562204361,
0.3451140820980072,
-0.29989323019981384,
-0.19590657949447632,
-0.14227814972400665,
1.0144137144088745,
0.12690113484859467,
-0.8817777037620544,
0.45447319746017456,
0.12213239073753357,
0.24333064258098602,
-0.318655788898468,
0.024118129163980484,
-0.23127661645412445,
0.5068579316139221,
-0.5216666460037231,
-1.0985242128372192,
0.4262571334838867,
-0.0251819659024477,
-0.0860423818230629,
-0.4087963402271271,
0.6814839839935303,
0.030971907079219818,
-1.0114290714263916,
0.567511260509491,
0.5895047783851624,
0.11069606989622116,
-0.5463809967041016,
-1.0484689474105835,
0.20247343182563782,
0.30933815240859985,
-0.3400336503982544,
-0.21033033728599548,
0.5632408857345581,
0.39750534296035767,
0.8706502914428711,
0.621679961681366,
-0.08493323624134064,
-0.013731349259614944,
0.38460105657577515,
0.642392098903656,
-0.6935639977455139,
-0.9213204979896545,
-1.0086941719055176,
0.3142155706882477,
-0.4814828932285309,
-0.0317695252597332,
0.7658440470695496,
0.659834086894989,
0.46761852502822876,
-0.11148825287818909,
1.0626047849655151,
0.16298244893550873,
1.1293749809265137,
-0.11261944472789764,
0.6257468461990356,
-0.7664614915847778,
0.5179758071899414,
-0.2930281460285187,
-0.7807796001434326,
-0.512385904788971,
0.5675688982009888,
-0.4762527346611023,
0.3858954608440399,
0.7347978949546814,
0.5675431489944458,
-0.09041425585746765,
0.24564987421035767,
0.1605728715658188,
-0.05970451235771179,
0.7695037126541138,
0.39889445900917053,
1.1538989543914795,
-0.43998491764068604,
1.000144124031067,
-0.2792876362800598,
-0.12131085991859436,
-0.8874054551124573,
-0.8337351083755493,
-0.9736725091934204,
-0.5138123035430908,
-0.46898990869522095,
-0.7109363079071045,
-0.08144471794366837,
0.8193729519844055,
0.7461100220680237,
-0.8430997133255005,
-0.27785131335258484,
-0.1313076913356781,
0.20023593306541443,
-0.40272778272628784,
-0.3116726577281952,
0.269941121339798,
-0.7392624616622925,
-0.33595743775367737,
-0.3458518981933594,
0.16263684630393982,
0.2003624141216278,
-0.16585476696491241,
0.007945575751364231,
-0.015730425715446472,
-0.05091532692313194,
0.26761746406555176,
-0.22099247574806213,
-0.5396720767021179,
-0.028039850294589996,
0.062266360968351364,
-0.2982521057128906,
0.15270327031612396,
0.579189658164978,
-0.34077900648117065,
-0.04266049340367317,
0.5079759359359741,
0.9681310057640076,
0.5465653538703918,
0.05131598562002182,
0.18354444205760956,
-0.6670606732368469,
-0.3908906579017639,
0.3649995028972626,
0.19733966886997223,
0.42122963070869446,
-0.4858771860599518,
0.14151440560817719,
0.12369487434625626,
-0.600624680519104,
-0.5714857578277588,
0.0702633187174797,
-1.3510117530822754,
-0.45647016167640686,
1.0499625205993652,
-0.011202817782759666,
-0.08001741766929626,
-0.12973709404468536,
-0.24116036295890808,
0.33824390172958374,
-0.8128609657287598,
1.0872520208358765,
0.7063124775886536,
-0.46101099252700806,
-0.0730539858341217,
-0.46078062057495117,
0.3483911156654358,
0.30852559208869934,
-0.9739793539047241,
-0.38973212242126465,
-0.06970732659101486,
0.30264726281166077,
0.05407632514834404,
0.4570969343185425,
0.5008094906806946,
0.16826361417770386,
-0.2377576231956482,
-0.31316670775413513,
0.0706591010093689,
-0.23118963837623596,
-0.24449437856674194,
0.6719049215316772,
0.07857249677181244,
-0.7818337678909302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15991v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15991v1
|
$C^3$: Confidence Calibration Model Cascade for Inference-Efficient Cross-Lingual Natural Language Understanding
| 2024-02-25T05:07:56 | 2024-02-25T05:07:56 |
Taixi Lu, Haoyu Wang, Huajie Shao, Jing Gao, Huaxiu Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Cross-lingual natural language understanding (NLU) is a critical task in
natural language processing (NLP). Recent advancements have seen multilingual
pre-trained language models (mPLMs) significantly enhance the performance of
these tasks. However, mPLMs necessitate substantial resources and incur high
computational costs during inference, posing challenges for deployment in
real-world and real-time systems. Existing model cascade methods seek to
enhance inference efficiency by greedily selecting the lightest model capable
of processing the current input from a variety of models, based on model
confidence scores. Nonetheless, deep models tend to exhibit overconfidence, and
confidence distributions vary across languages. This leads to the emission of
confident but incorrect predictions by smaller models, hindering their ability
to generalize effectively across test languages. In this study, we introduce a
confidence calibration model cascade ($C^3$) method. This approach, simple yet
effective, involves calibration prior to cascade inference, thereby enhancing
cascade accuracy through more reliable predictions. Extensive experiments
conducted on three cross-lingual benchmarks demonstrate that $C^3$
significantly outperforms all state-of-the-art baselines.
|
[
-0.2579856812953949,
-0.5631109476089478,
0.3479636609554291,
0.5782627463340759,
-0.0807819664478302,
0.0824098140001297,
-0.24701790511608124,
-0.5591045022010803,
-0.298186331987381,
0.20406100153923035,
-0.22603918612003326,
-0.4830566644668579,
-0.45095181465148926,
0.04562564939260483,
-0.03182864934206009,
0.6063240170478821,
-0.049121126532554626,
0.5349255800247192,
0.029041007161140442,
0.09814409911632538,
-0.36939743161201477,
-0.36945292353630066,
-0.6986463665962219,
-0.5733768343925476,
0.6583709716796875,
0.34783321619033813,
0.8565722703933716,
0.261625736951828,
0.15046623349189758,
0.1068778857588768,
-0.06273806840181351,
0.0919540673494339,
-0.5147926807403564,
-0.27978619933128357,
-0.08528732508420944,
-0.6758402585983276,
-0.3439677953720093,
0.058107536286115646,
0.6597118973731995,
0.9959745407104492,
-0.05060438811779022,
-0.10158432275056839,
0.42351555824279785,
0.6340281367301941,
-1.2026468515396118,
0.16384196281433105,
-0.680636465549469,
0.07633604109287262,
0.03312338516116142,
-0.13163354992866516,
-0.7643399834632874,
-0.3680441677570343,
0.13117390871047974,
-0.9181987643241882,
0.0698801651597023,
0.16564489901065826,
0.6524321436882019,
0.2506489157676697,
-0.47808554768562317,
-0.09629669785499573,
-0.6175922155380249,
1.1625370979309082,
-0.8276951909065247,
0.7295264601707458,
0.5654866099357605,
0.37075498700141907,
-0.051054902374744415,
-0.5861602425575256,
-0.5844454765319824,
-0.20403511822223663,
-0.03134157136082649,
0.1792462319135666,
-0.16075031459331512,
0.03487635776400566,
-0.002524877665564418,
0.38567009568214417,
-0.5459312200546265,
0.21386153995990753,
0.10612142831087112,
-0.26600518822669983,
0.30075907707214355,
-0.20046325027942657,
0.2605487108230591,
-0.15104758739471436,
-0.2942250072956085,
-0.18838877975940704,
-0.808081328868866,
0.051286645233631134,
0.3216926157474518,
0.49558505415916443,
-0.0971553847193718,
0.35751858353614807,
-0.14969994127750397,
0.7346680164337158,
0.12880301475524902,
-0.259206622838974,
0.07995187491178513,
-0.2909861207008362,
-0.4712541103363037,
0.09724359959363937,
0.6069425344467163,
0.22088785469532013,
0.4391014277935028,
-0.144876629114151,
0.19526571035385132,
-0.1265837848186493,
0.05970972776412964,
-0.7527062892913818,
-0.18807809054851532,
0.21571287512779236,
-0.20404963195323944,
-0.11575786769390106,
-0.06481996178627014,
-0.5028274655342102,
-0.21576935052871704,
-0.33271971344947815,
0.3499837815761566,
-0.4827660918235779,
-0.28566694259643555,
0.16608525812625885,
0.23970097303390503,
0.397379606962204,
0.38826027512550354,
-0.7985141277313232,
0.3007378578186035,
0.7537288069725037,
0.6983586549758911,
-0.20015305280685425,
-0.5136889219284058,
-0.6853829622268677,
0.14200076460838318,
-0.6241041421890259,
0.38328349590301514,
-0.24178121984004974,
-0.4238649606704712,
-0.05555177107453346,
-0.13425485789775848,
-0.3433888852596283,
-0.3442630171775818,
0.6724658608436584,
-0.5738016366958618,
0.14020876586437225,
-0.1484781950712204,
-0.2933710217475891,
-0.44058722257614136,
0.4751640856266022,
-0.6696851253509521,
1.1223267316818237,
0.09707333892583847,
-0.9919721484184265,
0.236975759267807,
-0.15781930088996887,
-0.38966354727745056,
0.09961128979921341,
-0.06545397639274597,
-0.08562122285366058,
-0.07249356806278229,
0.5224068760871887,
0.4554126560688019,
-0.5745185017585754,
0.40623483061790466,
-0.48884695768356323,
-0.5612465739250183,
-0.07298821210861206,
-0.6130905151367188,
0.9993742108345032,
0.1158343181014061,
-0.31311824917793274,
-0.26108914613723755,
-0.5959516763687134,
0.11483611166477203,
-0.3780098557472229,
-0.2593863606452942,
-0.41977086663246155,
-0.0883510559797287,
0.00328613119199872,
0.18678979575634003,
0.021809570491313934,
-0.5366689562797546,
-0.20805571973323822,
-0.4741365313529968,
-0.07201305031776428,
0.4071044623851776,
-0.12551386654376984,
0.5686414837837219,
-0.07998666912317276,
0.5706968903541565,
0.1518925428390503,
0.2243812531232834,
0.06447036564350128,
-0.5952951908111572,
-0.7734379768371582,
-0.2054278552532196,
0.47595471143722534,
0.7328749299049377,
-0.8968209028244019,
0.20821912586688995,
-0.41769835352897644,
-0.5671873688697815,
-0.5397195816040039,
0.20689186453819275,
0.5103166699409485,
0.7189731597900391,
0.6197835803031921,
0.029161361977458,
-0.28555771708488464,
-0.8885044455528259,
-0.6991479396820068,
-0.2648777365684509,
-0.28440117835998535,
0.1436971127986908,
0.3211318254470825,
-0.12315751612186432,
0.7717536687850952,
-0.3140597641468048,
-0.1393272578716278,
-0.3283168375492096,
0.551372766494751,
0.1673300564289093,
0.6074634790420532,
0.42142942547798157,
-0.8570812344551086,
-0.6768224835395813,
0.14424511790275574,
-0.34349316358566284,
0.02756035327911377,
-0.115742526948452,
-0.18967919051647186,
0.23593389987945557,
0.28028666973114014,
-0.41531652212142944,
0.3879856467247009,
0.8993803858757019,
0.09372459352016449,
0.554146409034729,
-0.04715464636683464,
0.22148941457271576,
-1.018053650856018,
0.1368018537759781,
0.1289772242307663,
-0.28785181045532227,
-0.7252834439277649,
0.10077769309282303,
0.40903887152671814,
0.2915768325328827,
-0.6308423280715942,
0.6324899792671204,
-0.5081453323364258,
0.19594289362430573,
0.02322082407772541,
0.2620551884174347,
0.19669902324676514,
0.49627798795700073,
0.3422936499118805,
0.35071036219596863,
0.575117290019989,
-0.6369759440422058,
-0.1230563372373581,
-0.13107430934906006,
-0.31378448009490967,
0.7287943959236145,
-0.37769126892089844,
-0.10405313223600388,
0.187551349401474,
0.5875205397605896,
-0.7740973830223083,
-0.13595202565193176,
0.014073006808757782,
-0.5260472893714905,
0.3477592468261719,
-0.23793818056583405,
-0.3488273620605469,
-0.21925193071365356,
-0.2491254210472107,
0.6554444432258606,
0.22036463022232056,
-0.7505041360855103,
0.9472792148590088,
0.2432853728532791,
0.00566893070936203,
-1.1816043853759766,
-1.2117462158203125,
-0.04091142490506172,
0.2089732438325882,
-0.43679192662239075,
0.36510056257247925,
-0.14224208891391754,
-0.12495356053113937,
-0.3984675407409668,
-0.13438574969768524,
-0.1317596733570099,
0.05042789876461029,
0.23726552724838257,
0.3597293794155121,
-0.19879645109176636,
-0.12776900827884674,
-0.00085782865062356,
-0.09188234061002731,
0.002492232248187065,
-0.21363204717636108,
0.3127487897872925,
-0.21513493359088898,
-0.4958737790584564,
-0.6506139039993286,
0.2508947253227234,
0.4394320249557495,
0.014185920357704163,
0.7577648758888245,
0.7469896078109741,
-0.6973508596420288,
-0.29454925656318665,
-0.6845723986625671,
-0.016717903316020966,
-0.3870389461517334,
0.1723082959651947,
-0.5316981673240662,
-0.837737500667572,
0.33061927556991577,
0.12976804375648499,
-0.00277207070030272,
0.41823941469192505,
0.4589197039604187,
0.20486624538898468,
1.2979215383529663,
0.5878313779830933,
-0.0871666967868805,
0.11588243395090103,
-0.08341073244810104,
0.5835013389587402,
-0.9428122043609619,
-0.27406033873558044,
-0.7159242033958435,
-0.003793952986598015,
-0.6572365760803223,
-0.8424782156944275,
0.050477784126996994,
0.476529985666275,
-0.3219771683216095,
0.2299216091632843,
0.013237539678812027,
0.41625410318374634,
0.4819107949733734,
0.024168429896235466,
0.4592195153236389,
-0.2759675681591034,
-0.41044414043426514,
-0.08857198059558868,
-0.7147840857505798,
-0.35886797308921814,
0.7750434279441833,
0.39182618260383606,
0.7905901074409485,
0.18251574039459229,
0.43580949306488037,
-0.16042284667491913,
0.7430320382118225,
-0.8373659253120422,
0.22592385113239288,
0.001107105053961277,
-0.6775036454200745,
-0.055865637958049774,
-0.6726157069206238,
-0.47538119554519653,
0.36082586646080017,
-0.08137647807598114,
-0.900019109249115,
0.5471332669258118,
0.4654344320297241,
-0.4732424020767212,
0.45254969596862793,
-0.7010258436203003,
0.8272836804389954,
0.01398127805441618,
-0.4619150161743164,
-0.14212676882743835,
-0.6450996398925781,
0.7851805090904236,
-0.254677414894104,
0.402063250541687,
-0.16273820400238037,
0.008298828266561031,
0.3894026577472687,
-0.23829986155033112,
0.760739266872406,
-0.13125066459178925,
-0.30098670721054077,
0.1404874473810196,
0.5073131322860718,
0.5310145616531372,
0.3339814841747284,
-0.4141436219215393,
0.22477439045906067,
0.03801954910159111,
-0.4525598883628845,
-0.527926504611969,
1.008165955543518,
-0.5137969851493835,
-0.33571967482566833,
-0.3935224711894989,
-0.6664432883262634,
-0.49842000007629395,
0.13775044679641724,
0.199621319770813,
0.26616281270980835,
-0.30103799700737,
0.27664175629615784,
0.3431260287761688,
-0.4103759229183197,
0.49083611369132996,
0.47380027174949646,
-0.19036109745502472,
-0.3671070635318756,
0.7258221507072449,
-0.10649047046899796,
0.5967091917991638,
0.7049445509910583,
0.1420070379972458,
-0.44486087560653687,
-0.32677167654037476,
-0.265535444021225,
0.037582654505968094,
-0.7797366976737976,
-0.3538453280925751,
-0.7160940766334534,
-0.05200490355491638,
-0.526527464389801,
-0.3543296754360199,
-0.48900607228279114,
-0.4098189175128937,
-0.33027321100234985,
0.08785239607095718,
-0.03392382711172104,
0.4414193630218506,
-0.24700802564620972,
0.38940638303756714,
-0.6303548812866211,
0.3914962112903595,
0.32272544503211975,
0.3993311822414398,
0.21580734848976135,
-0.48815345764160156,
-0.2101062834262848,
0.3436512351036072,
-0.2009967714548111,
-0.767788290977478,
0.4713432788848877,
0.16826124489307404,
0.48952925205230713,
0.3302077651023865,
-0.012385981157422066,
0.9698333144187927,
-0.2837476432323456,
0.891467809677124,
0.2868281900882721,
-1.2854132652282715,
0.23276150226593018,
-0.09634217619895935,
0.530604898929596,
0.7737681865692139,
0.5767332911491394,
-0.6075381636619568,
-0.3146885335445404,
-0.4608840048313141,
-0.7139355540275574,
0.576483428478241,
0.09188642352819443,
-0.10474737733602524,
-0.05630473047494888,
0.1089470162987709,
-0.1575944572687149,
-0.14030511677265167,
-0.9591507911682129,
-0.08226945251226425,
-0.2049381136894226,
-0.22783683240413666,
-0.33004555106163025,
-0.0071312966756522655,
0.12861599028110504,
-0.36979940533638,
0.9913822412490845,
-0.48759955167770386,
-0.2963283360004425,
0.2924204170703888,
-0.4537888765335083,
-0.12576232850551605,
0.22110220789909363,
0.3554026186466217,
0.6501079797744751,
-0.3840460181236267,
0.38712480664253235,
0.5679436326026917,
-0.6400126218795776,
-0.10593269765377045,
0.12531661987304688,
0.014028307050466537,
-0.12550099194049835,
0.3873145878314972,
0.43756166100502014,
0.5568780303001404,
-0.3101631999015808,
0.623836874961853,
-0.33331963419914246,
-0.12480241805315018,
-0.0003641227667685598,
-0.16952627897262573,
0.3364223837852478,
-0.15412378311157227,
0.4650224447250366,
0.22264735400676727,
0.12087670713663101,
-0.3473522961139679,
0.12116026133298874,
0.4037734270095825,
-0.6977521181106567,
-0.05059140920639038,
0.5912578701972961,
0.09263831377029419,
-0.12570662796497345,
0.5222145318984985,
-0.07265318930149078,
-0.5878512263298035,
0.3503589630126953,
0.5890753865242004,
0.8138468861579895,
-0.44241422414779663,
0.18963591754436493,
0.6291597485542297,
0.37505996227264404,
-0.3354519307613373,
0.16618677973747253,
-0.09532351791858673,
-0.8436183333396912,
-0.7688157558441162,
-0.906158447265625,
-0.7049092054367065,
-0.017160488292574883,
-0.7664875388145447,
0.20555342733860016,
-0.25663822889328003,
0.06849195808172226,
-0.1895560473203659,
0.09592348337173462,
-0.7152409553527832,
0.5124464631080627,
0.2935941219329834,
1.283182978630066,
-0.7697176337242126,
0.9945425987243652,
0.06007488816976547,
-0.10565300285816193,
-1.0370793342590332,
0.19010944664478302,
0.08638134598731995,
-0.7016525268554688,
0.598533034324646,
0.4068695604801178,
-0.7213547229766846,
0.23182755708694458,
-0.4365823566913605,
-0.6599299311637878,
1.0035533905029297,
0.507335364818573,
-0.6123142838478088,
0.14103007316589355,
0.17087429761886597,
0.4084317088127136,
-0.5206955671310425,
0.553300142288208,
0.7852875590324402,
0.5654112100601196,
0.11823507398366928,
-0.7588931918144226,
0.030243562534451485,
-0.1154307946562767,
0.2032497674226761,
-0.05263767018914223,
-0.23306550085544586,
0.7699579000473022,
-0.2706759572029114,
-0.24377013742923737,
-0.0031127119436860085,
0.7144769430160522,
0.6108197569847107,
-0.031572017818689346,
0.7893306016921997,
0.44807714223861694,
0.7045169472694397,
-0.20487260818481445,
1.2999794483184814,
-0.47735193371772766,
0.3957425653934479,
1.4002325534820557,
-0.2542254626750946,
1.2150285243988037,
0.6673490405082703,
0.05961735174059868,
0.6438300013542175,
0.852441668510437,
0.44652554392814636,
0.20216162502765656,
0.15136797726154327,
-0.3592791259288788,
-0.41151919960975647,
-0.10881171375513077,
-0.22404512763023376,
0.25036677718162537,
0.3930771052837372,
-0.12066315859556198,
-0.08395595848560333,
-0.2840921878814697,
0.22214961051940918,
-0.2166842669248581,
-0.3090830147266388,
0.2935219705104828,
0.24156440794467926,
-1.0369282960891724,
0.7286148071289062,
-0.061537399888038635,
0.5848277807235718,
-0.48540231585502625,
0.006050982512533665,
-0.14580677449703217,
0.45077651739120483,
-0.1698264628648758,
-0.557167112827301,
0.005467994604259729,
-0.07885397970676422,
0.17574189603328705,
-0.1922014057636261,
0.38307464122772217,
-0.5088993310928345,
-0.6992166042327881,
0.6901147961616516,
0.4345884919166565,
-0.014163357205688953,
-0.2885153293609619,
-0.7472992539405823,
-0.1561412811279297,
-0.11940132826566696,
-0.23345276713371277,
-0.08046694844961166,
0.11021184921264648,
0.11913740634918213,
0.5870969295501709,
0.6856475472450256,
0.14748582243919373,
0.017020689323544502,
0.5840559005737305,
0.4854380786418915,
-0.325540155172348,
-0.46131110191345215,
-0.7412657141685486,
0.5865445733070374,
0.0026673946995288134,
-0.2729721665382385,
0.7174313068389893,
0.5714219212532043,
0.970695436000824,
0.18078741431236267,
0.6286367774009705,
0.1216946691274643,
0.3997115194797516,
-0.45997029542922974,
0.5769433379173279,
-0.6260856986045837,
0.17982862889766693,
-0.48094442486763,
-0.9297044277191162,
-0.8810176849365234,
0.5649796724319458,
-0.2614540755748749,
0.09498865157365799,
1.0065088272094727,
0.9299108386039734,
-0.2323807328939438,
0.22185800969600677,
0.347489595413208,
0.2701451778411865,
0.181809201836586,
0.6860108971595764,
0.661978542804718,
-0.5068693161010742,
0.4699406027793884,
-0.54019695520401,
-0.38695600628852844,
-0.14934083819389343,
-1.2429749965667725,
-0.7215492725372314,
-0.2689726948738098,
-0.0709846168756485,
-0.315730482339859,
-0.14411887526512146,
0.6330669522285461,
0.9860381484031677,
-1.0199613571166992,
-0.25251680612564087,
-0.26121294498443604,
0.22218726575374603,
-0.3386896848678589,
-0.2246524542570114,
0.25750723481178284,
-0.3820953965187073,
-0.8561221957206726,
0.37767472863197327,
0.26377245783805847,
0.06544018536806107,
-0.4597935378551483,
-0.36783042550086975,
-0.5670589804649353,
0.28967365622520447,
0.4587397277355194,
0.230202779173851,
-0.8948397040367126,
-0.24177595973014832,
0.00041422966751269996,
-0.21494996547698975,
0.1016196608543396,
0.7146950960159302,
-0.7255487442016602,
0.43140220642089844,
0.5226901173591614,
0.6515433192253113,
0.5779794454574585,
0.07709471881389618,
0.9780310988426208,
-0.7938345670700073,
0.08056893944740295,
0.20059563219547272,
0.4395545423030853,
0.7042644619941711,
-0.32157769799232483,
0.4468533992767334,
-0.11020679026842117,
-0.40950581431388855,
-0.9446979761123657,
0.11398018151521683,
-0.8274502754211426,
-0.24189786612987518,
0.9223031401634216,
-0.3244459927082062,
-0.25664275884628296,
-0.10600998252630234,
-0.009474191814661026,
0.513095498085022,
-0.039081472903490067,
0.33251652121543884,
0.6690526604652405,
0.019242404028773308,
-0.16020384430885315,
-0.6389308571815491,
0.6655463576316833,
0.7289745807647705,
-0.8311994075775146,
0.22957837581634521,
0.14709854125976562,
0.12874844670295715,
0.37846943736076355,
0.34399130940437317,
-0.05105367675423622,
0.3194993734359741,
-0.10548228770494461,
0.1792924702167511,
0.5737007260322571,
-0.48900970816612244,
-0.4137830436229706,
0.1597876250743866,
-0.029124772176146507,
0.12475968897342682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15987v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15987v2
|
Likelihood-based Mitigation of Evaluation Bias in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-25T04:52:02 | 2024-03-01T06:44:44 |
Masanari Ohi, Masahiro Kaneko, Ryuto Koike, Mengsay Loem, Naoaki Okazaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are widely used to evaluate natural language
generation tasks as automated metrics. However, the likelihood, a measure of
LLM's plausibility for a sentence, can vary due to superficial differences in
sentences, such as word order and sentence structure. It is therefore possible
that there might be a likelihood bias if LLMs are used for evaluation: they
might overrate sentences with higher likelihoods while underrating those with
lower likelihoods. In this paper, we investigate the presence and impact of
likelihood bias in LLM-based evaluators. We also propose a method to mitigate
the likelihood bias. Our method utilizes highly biased instances as few-shot
examples for in-context learning. Our experiments in evaluating the
data-to-text and grammatical error correction tasks reveal that several LLMs we
test display a likelihood bias. Furthermore, our proposed method successfully
mitigates this bias, also improving evaluation performance (in terms of
correlation of models with human scores) significantly.
|
[
-0.3407573103904724,
-1.0628526210784912,
0.7656117081642151,
0.13147707283496857,
0.04332499951124191,
-0.25342777371406555,
-0.48501697182655334,
-0.22789135575294495,
-0.11576486378908157,
0.5527760982513428,
-0.4031994342803955,
-0.44674181938171387,
-0.5159178972244263,
0.10256845504045486,
-0.22526435554027557,
1.077371597290039,
0.04922744259238243,
0.2670288681983948,
-0.7077955007553101,
-0.045522257685661316,
-0.4332329034805298,
-0.6984734535217285,
-0.48131462931632996,
-0.45598268508911133,
0.37455087900161743,
0.20575807988643646,
0.5810173749923706,
0.1720414161682129,
0.48912596702575684,
0.2066350281238556,
-0.100272998213768,
0.08307906240224838,
-0.5559859275817871,
0.10561946779489517,
-0.30370017886161804,
-0.5337746739387512,
-0.44059497117996216,
-0.09641093760728836,
1.0201374292373657,
1.0299417972564697,
0.29016831517219543,
0.10781455785036087,
0.4570803940296173,
0.77913498878479,
-1.076413869857788,
-0.02613040618598461,
-0.7198383212089539,
0.044773321598768234,
-0.23281297087669373,
-0.3042590022087097,
-0.5707500576972961,
-0.2676585912704468,
0.12077344954013824,
-0.27562084794044495,
0.23380789160728455,
-0.018812021240592003,
0.46842870116233826,
0.15652810037136078,
-0.41687601804733276,
-0.09485708177089691,
-0.6731153130531311,
1.1619791984558105,
-0.8801449537277222,
0.12232241779565811,
0.5040918588638306,
0.031769633293151855,
-0.6088932752609253,
-0.2070837914943695,
-0.38756242394447327,
-0.4122064709663391,
-0.04009522870182991,
0.06655902415513992,
-0.17421145737171173,
0.2041330337524414,
0.47809267044067383,
0.305888295173645,
-0.4463268220424652,
0.3501599431037903,
-0.08988679200410843,
-0.28745442628860474,
0.7216148376464844,
0.08692290633916855,
0.030156442895531654,
-0.16583439707756042,
-0.16323764622211456,
0.06126624345779419,
-0.8400089144706726,
-0.15686728060245514,
0.48960527777671814,
0.25389185547828674,
0.070339635014534,
0.8605690598487854,
-0.2935660481452942,
0.6767198443412781,
0.046409763395786285,
-0.001607558922842145,
0.23499365150928497,
-0.1838536113500595,
-0.5104935765266418,
0.01549028605222702,
0.637135922908783,
0.4061126410961151,
0.17851756513118744,
0.04178226366639137,
-0.4705004394054413,
0.3022218346595764,
0.1500329226255417,
-0.686593770980835,
0.0996747612953186,
0.1699131727218628,
-0.39460062980651855,
-0.4076424539089203,
-0.03670158609747887,
-0.8105871677398682,
-0.523441731929779,
-0.14732575416564941,
0.6432046294212341,
-0.16939511895179749,
0.21053339540958405,
-0.028589678928256035,
0.15200890600681305,
-0.17953817546367645,
0.10501948744058609,
-0.766296923160553,
0.41422581672668457,
0.6384703516960144,
0.43608295917510986,
-0.1861104518175125,
-0.2580562233924866,
-1.122687816619873,
-0.12178317457437515,
-0.27365627884864807,
0.6611426472663879,
-0.5410332679748535,
-0.29787540435791016,
0.19445767998695374,
-0.366571307182312,
-0.11834750324487686,
-0.6626783013343811,
0.750956118106842,
-0.42275986075401306,
0.6418824195861816,
-0.13970732688903809,
-1.0692965984344482,
-0.13881440460681915,
0.15948790311813354,
-0.591787576675415,
1.084583044052124,
0.10257504135370255,
-1.0329395532608032,
0.690183162689209,
-0.6412915587425232,
-0.5835157036781311,
-0.1729567050933838,
-0.33996203541755676,
-0.6541408896446228,
0.5377762913703918,
0.5085391402244568,
0.5528272390365601,
-0.3253176510334015,
0.45688003301620483,
-0.3352848291397095,
-0.6295166015625,
0.4339722692966461,
-0.8772873282432556,
0.6075514554977417,
0.009047606028616428,
-0.5921944975852966,
0.28738918900489807,
-0.7537328600883484,
-0.06300023198127747,
-0.18898551166057587,
-0.5599293112754822,
-0.49496400356292725,
0.15282633900642395,
0.11786602437496185,
0.029451871290802956,
-0.06017351895570755,
-0.44256624579429626,
0.06293004751205444,
-0.646726131439209,
-0.008308786898851395,
0.7177109122276306,
0.2086886614561081,
0.6477373242378235,
-0.5302300453186035,
0.5041103959083557,
-0.21651798486709595,
0.14122392237186432,
0.04724206402897835,
-0.3605309724807739,
-0.8423046469688416,
-0.2777253985404968,
0.26458725333213806,
0.294196754693985,
-0.4961044490337372,
0.6746520400047302,
-0.19580553472042084,
-0.20156832039356232,
-0.3120332658290863,
0.3716614246368408,
0.4186786413192749,
0.42557650804519653,
0.15312445163726807,
-0.22196082770824432,
-0.3864327073097229,
-0.8941875696182251,
-0.5994008183479309,
-0.09302687644958496,
-0.32836276292800903,
0.10717049241065979,
0.498639851808548,
-0.1509929746389389,
1.1613733768463135,
-0.24569319188594818,
-0.31136220693588257,
-0.509041965007782,
0.011135876178741455,
0.17616064846515656,
0.3630931079387665,
0.3907461166381836,
-0.4847605228424072,
-0.061221588402986526,
-0.4383513927459717,
-0.5092324614524841,
-0.46179986000061035,
-0.4056456387042999,
-0.12516215443611145,
0.6097816228866577,
0.4017654359340668,
-0.5934468507766724,
0.5061644315719604,
0.484917014837265,
-0.30227577686309814,
0.6211370825767517,
-0.13737407326698303,
-0.010056203231215477,
-0.7830925583839417,
0.04486725479364395,
0.25081050395965576,
-0.1317443996667862,
-0.39301490783691406,
0.00882724579423666,
0.014222817495465279,
0.42524927854537964,
-0.4509536921977997,
0.6452690362930298,
-0.2794717848300934,
-0.20644478499889374,
-0.2290261685848236,
0.14222609996795654,
0.23964816331863403,
0.2750641107559204,
-0.006542536895722151,
0.47074824571609497,
0.3462178707122803,
-0.6616036295890808,
0.01749659888446331,
-0.11391756683588028,
-0.6802242994308472,
0.5472843050956726,
-0.24848364293575287,
0.11305840313434601,
-0.19619375467300415,
0.4151654839515686,
-0.8678394556045532,
-0.14724895358085632,
0.20871292054653168,
-0.14022879302501678,
0.198191836476326,
-0.019781921058893204,
-0.6793626546859741,
-0.17199547588825226,
-0.5471670031547546,
0.3609369993209839,
0.14249654114246368,
-0.5884276628494263,
0.3276054859161377,
-0.013053204864263535,
0.009920730255544186,
-0.5420421361923218,
-0.507131814956665,
-0.08680707216262817,
-0.581597089767456,
-0.5392537117004395,
0.36702197790145874,
-0.15503251552581787,
-0.5578314661979675,
-0.36938637495040894,
-0.03790917992591858,
0.15063776075839996,
0.24075676500797272,
0.18775546550750732,
0.4815554618835449,
-0.11444209516048431,
0.4189717769622803,
0.1663714349269867,
0.20502778887748718,
0.19468510150909424,
-0.24172554910182953,
0.4996434450149536,
0.1329505443572998,
-0.5321751832962036,
-0.2333463430404663,
0.11342345923185349,
0.4360242784023285,
0.021245665848255157,
0.6379229426383972,
0.5194643139839172,
-0.4538063704967499,
-0.22484111785888672,
-0.9419997930526733,
-0.4015522003173828,
-0.4052291810512543,
0.6234650611877441,
-0.17584706842899323,
-0.7986873984336853,
0.19317007064819336,
0.1159856766462326,
0.238530695438385,
0.40519851446151733,
0.6449666619300842,
-0.07151270657777786,
0.7731623649597168,
0.43412479758262634,
-0.4269443154335022,
0.39190611243247986,
-0.03557504341006279,
0.17739616334438324,
-0.912946879863739,
0.13697655498981476,
-0.3331776261329651,
-0.31299152970314026,
-0.4174053370952606,
-0.4597582519054413,
0.3721376657485962,
0.22061870992183685,
-0.08631173521280289,
-0.24500666558742523,
-0.04100870341062546,
0.4056639075279236,
0.4763617217540741,
0.11181847006082535,
0.3724963963031769,
0.3861507177352905,
-0.2947538197040558,
-0.16433866322040558,
-0.8096989393234253,
-0.6663512587547302,
1.4124876260757446,
0.5670639872550964,
0.607012152671814,
-0.04405475780367851,
0.5688459277153015,
0.4122740924358368,
0.4197283983230591,
-0.8290979862213135,
0.40270787477493286,
-0.04207474738359451,
-0.6327425837516785,
-0.40856561064720154,
-0.5976324081420898,
-0.6578025221824646,
0.41870975494384766,
-0.48241448402404785,
-0.8963008522987366,
-0.09886530786752701,
0.08819758147001266,
-0.43873336911201477,
0.25686946511268616,
-0.47073182463645935,
0.7325354814529419,
-0.29742106795310974,
-0.8395956754684448,
-0.18945947289466858,
-0.19303759932518005,
0.4300837218761444,
-0.37873825430870056,
0.4379465878009796,
0.0905151292681694,
0.26885199546813965,
0.6559991240501404,
-0.3898577392101288,
0.9795066714286804,
-0.10683745890855789,
-0.2286691814661026,
0.19200272858142853,
0.13318634033203125,
0.5622140169143677,
0.12593340873718262,
-0.3536072075366974,
0.05323713645339012,
-0.46468493342399597,
-0.3211551904678345,
-0.6389198303222656,
0.633732795715332,
-0.3861849308013916,
-0.576005220413208,
-0.2571485936641693,
-0.6707528829574585,
-0.43093401193618774,
-0.15268294513225555,
0.5684670805931091,
0.49679189920425415,
-0.315181165933609,
0.046181660145521164,
0.36485353112220764,
-0.49233150482177734,
0.48036089539527893,
0.278669148683548,
-0.34789276123046875,
-0.1878250241279602,
0.4875309467315674,
-0.10017421096563339,
0.5203560590744019,
0.35155969858169556,
0.4533877670764923,
-0.36346304416656494,
-0.4626240134239197,
-0.34100183844566345,
0.14148180186748505,
-0.7231862545013428,
-0.0956420823931694,
-0.38292086124420166,
-0.016282470896840096,
-0.28639718890190125,
-0.10597382485866547,
-0.18665063381195068,
-0.39937224984169006,
-0.19914031028747559,
-0.05995313450694084,
0.08665195852518082,
0.6925270557403564,
0.2975709140300751,
0.3762441575527191,
-0.5063722729682922,
-0.08335168659687042,
0.035482779145240784,
0.25799277424812317,
0.04262916371226311,
-0.8057531714439392,
-0.23752988874912262,
-0.03616315871477127,
-0.32104843854904175,
-0.4189052879810333,
0.3529195487499237,
0.3155030906200409,
0.5602837800979614,
0.3982386291027069,
0.007940573617815971,
0.49609896540641785,
-0.34953486919403076,
0.6851921677589417,
0.06163083761930466,
-1.0158193111419678,
0.5704090595245361,
-0.14794600009918213,
0.472165584564209,
0.5026015043258667,
0.030933864414691925,
-0.19689947366714478,
-0.608974814414978,
-0.38102054595947266,
-0.8433127403259277,
0.40450695157051086,
0.47560107707977295,
0.20881101489067078,
-0.057180725038051605,
0.2947703003883362,
0.11948664486408234,
0.16602247953414917,
-0.8484209179878235,
-0.06890837103128433,
0.4637245535850525,
-0.13623754680156708,
-0.16756442189216614,
-0.5776253342628479,
-0.04009002819657326,
-0.10843455046415329,
0.7469028234481812,
-0.1348847597837448,
-0.10070454329252243,
0.27444690465927124,
-0.5601690411567688,
-0.2149481177330017,
0.6155188679695129,
0.6219609975814819,
0.7257021069526672,
-0.20641721785068512,
0.004310787655413151,
0.41088494658470154,
-0.3294706642627716,
-0.09436449408531189,
-0.060319893062114716,
-0.4465823471546173,
0.08739086240530014,
0.6402599215507507,
0.7243123650550842,
0.4474862217903137,
-0.7526370882987976,
0.5841861963272095,
0.13757584989070892,
0.03236287087202072,
-0.3215133845806122,
-0.06282752007246017,
-0.21875722706317902,
0.21366268396377563,
0.45337074995040894,
0.0510835163295269,
0.2512514591217041,
-0.4860721826553345,
0.2512880563735962,
0.612545371055603,
-0.3654138147830963,
0.00820797961205244,
0.4766552746295929,
0.08799072355031967,
-0.061074841767549515,
0.5480148792266846,
-0.056138429790735245,
-0.5866135358810425,
0.5558566451072693,
0.5711070895195007,
0.9037957787513733,
-0.09374585002660751,
-0.0957942008972168,
0.26616227626800537,
0.32143867015838623,
-0.026652153581380844,
-0.029256902635097504,
0.14045760035514832,
-0.7241519093513489,
-0.611012876033783,
-0.8453617095947266,
-0.1279406100511551,
0.4016117453575134,
-0.4962644875049591,
0.4739699363708496,
-0.3158406615257263,
-0.38707128167152405,
-0.05330711603164673,
0.013879664242267609,
-0.5918943285942078,
0.13978131115436554,
0.4602590501308441,
0.6846122145652771,
-0.8920276165008545,
0.7440047860145569,
0.6206758618354797,
-0.18243397772312164,
-0.37546753883361816,
0.35044893622398376,
0.08608730882406235,
-0.20755943655967712,
0.6868994235992432,
0.2871703803539276,
0.02076154761016369,
-0.3457179665565491,
-0.09615869075059891,
-0.6105660200119019,
0.6162789463996887,
0.4223894476890564,
-0.8722184896469116,
0.17856088280677795,
0.2927747666835785,
0.48764312267303467,
-0.524856448173523,
0.4408234655857086,
0.6705639362335205,
0.358719140291214,
-0.28559625148773193,
-1.031112790107727,
-0.03881385177373886,
0.05329737067222595,
0.1472516804933548,
-0.0406622514128685,
-0.11052563041448593,
0.49235647916793823,
-0.16376672685146332,
0.019701886922121048,
0.0316203273832798,
0.533146858215332,
0.5162677764892578,
0.3175537586212158,
0.6062343120574951,
0.30607378482818604,
0.8063780665397644,
0.22064970433712006,
1.2486720085144043,
0.08803343027830124,
0.42249712347984314,
1.4053527116775513,
-0.4078274667263031,
0.8516837358474731,
0.7369681000709534,
-0.2506285011768341,
0.2649434506893158,
0.4938177168369293,
-0.013142243959009647,
0.23539839684963226,
0.775673508644104,
-0.5236169695854187,
-0.16549630463123322,
-0.09524364024400711,
0.049545083194971085,
0.42792078852653503,
0.33014392852783203,
-0.5857263803482056,
-0.10435482114553452,
0.14068904519081116,
0.13851529359817505,
0.29221001267433167,
-0.400603711605072,
0.49590227007865906,
0.03750145807862282,
-0.7100712656974792,
0.4876974821090698,
-0.003799004480242729,
1.0268490314483643,
-0.21616284549236298,
0.025495614856481552,
-0.3145750164985657,
0.30926910042762756,
-0.44262054562568665,
-0.4964566230773926,
0.2314179539680481,
0.15587113797664642,
-0.3081241250038147,
0.11181890219449997,
0.6559452414512634,
-0.31700119376182556,
-0.9086913466453552,
0.4188482463359833,
0.3839828073978424,
0.07478923350572586,
-0.4653306305408478,
-0.37209752202033997,
0.2860492765903473,
-0.0012151370756328106,
-0.43123698234558105,
0.44693219661712646,
0.034327853471040726,
-0.3443424701690674,
0.47028622031211853,
0.48072272539138794,
0.12685774266719818,
0.10022696107625961,
0.5519137978553772,
0.6666980385780334,
-0.28691717982292175,
-0.1810341477394104,
-1.2714958190917969,
0.3730658292770386,
-0.08388487994670868,
-0.07962504029273987,
0.7613949179649353,
0.8876902461051941,
0.8763087391853333,
-0.05918342247605324,
0.8735593557357788,
0.21706034243106842,
0.37721821665763855,
-0.7475101351737976,
0.7871626615524292,
-0.3981444537639618,
0.7606807947158813,
-0.5696378350257874,
-1.4621747732162476,
-0.6290982365608215,
0.5939090847969055,
-0.5653019547462463,
0.13730080425739288,
0.6551114916801453,
0.7427724599838257,
-0.009940224699676037,
-0.21401731669902802,
0.4897652268409729,
0.192527174949646,
0.20868349075317383,
0.5209424495697021,
0.8632498383522034,
-0.4166439175605774,
0.34613916277885437,
-0.3420635163784027,
-0.2590807378292084,
-0.29982733726501465,
-0.9262844324111938,
-1.100622534751892,
-0.17600291967391968,
-0.45838555693626404,
-0.3409089744091034,
0.2054334133863449,
1.040433645248413,
0.35882052779197693,
-0.7645822763442993,
-0.4014837145805359,
-0.10790149867534637,
0.20271053910255432,
-0.04243461787700653,
-0.282262921333313,
0.5182818174362183,
-0.5595782995223999,
-0.8581349849700928,
0.47023555636405945,
0.23526006937026978,
-0.2707188129425049,
-0.3507678806781769,
-0.025297900661826134,
-0.11036541312932968,
0.034372638911008835,
0.7859275341033936,
-0.295071005821228,
-0.8666179776191711,
-0.4493805766105652,
-0.26110026240348816,
-0.036102619022130966,
0.07741431146860123,
0.6896314024925232,
-0.95148104429245,
0.4703368842601776,
0.39394599199295044,
0.4595557153224945,
0.2533721625804901,
-0.04627343267202377,
0.9795140027999878,
-0.9324377179145813,
0.07447735965251923,
0.17972174286842346,
0.5104957222938538,
0.43990659713745117,
-0.5468220114707947,
0.4443525969982147,
0.10044211894273758,
-0.4977918267250061,
-0.7624840140342712,
0.05989329516887665,
-0.636908233165741,
-0.22993192076683044,
1.2985010147094727,
-0.11727388203144073,
0.0014358906773850322,
0.06060481444001198,
-0.09230267256498337,
0.17976514995098114,
-0.23297539353370667,
0.9105392098426819,
0.8052732944488525,
0.0024812028277665377,
0.14499525725841522,
-0.795122504234314,
0.46272119879722595,
0.8802985548973083,
-0.7332005500793457,
0.07261689752340317,
0.6958355903625488,
0.3842436671257019,
-0.1384948194026947,
0.3255901038646698,
-0.1366366595029831,
0.19687503576278687,
-0.39227524399757385,
0.0258630383759737,
0.4086090624332428,
-0.13544848561286926,
-0.7436228394508362,
-0.04091736674308777,
0.1609376072883606,
-0.010213140398263931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15985v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15985v1
|
Phonetic and Lexical Discovery of a Canine Language using HuBERT
| 2024-02-25T04:35:45 | 2024-02-25T04:35:45 |
Xingyuan Li, Sinong Wang, Zeyu Xie, Mengyue Wu, Kenny Q. Zhu
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
This paper delves into the pioneering exploration of potential communication
patterns within dog vocalizations and transcends traditional linguistic
analysis barriers, which heavily relies on human priori knowledge on limited
datasets to find sound units in dog vocalization. We present a self-supervised
approach with HuBERT, enabling the accurate classification of phoneme labels
and the identification of vocal patterns that suggest a rudimentary vocabulary
within dog vocalizations. Our findings indicate a significant acoustic
consistency in these identified canine vocabulary, covering the entirety of
observed dog vocalization sequences. We further develop a web-based dog
vocalization labeling system. This system can highlight phoneme n-grams,
present in the vocabulary, in the dog audio uploaded by users.
|
[
-0.535361647605896,
-0.43169355392456055,
0.32393303513526917,
0.7189645767211914,
0.17289507389068604,
0.04722968116402626,
-0.2686302959918976,
-0.658876359462738,
0.6755099296569824,
0.23712658882141113,
-0.3053227365016937,
-0.6335852146148682,
-0.21572215855121613,
0.13490118086338043,
-0.34513282775878906,
0.5957779288291931,
0.3898946940898895,
0.0817246064543724,
0.19818490743637085,
0.008923057466745377,
0.015583796426653862,
-0.5299973487854004,
-0.9250662326812744,
-0.3937980830669403,
0.6762994527816772,
0.30712267756462097,
0.5234856009483337,
0.7142679691314697,
0.3092343807220459,
0.29555436968803406,
0.011576548218727112,
-0.1698572039604187,
-0.0074006011709570885,
0.06637021899223328,
0.016185419633984566,
-0.26336291432380676,
-0.5645052194595337,
0.3495038151741028,
0.6461464166641235,
0.8117644190788269,
-0.624666690826416,
-0.08285389840602875,
-0.26861172914505005,
0.42587074637413025,
-0.5147613286972046,
0.25639501214027405,
-0.5342711210250854,
0.04796499386429787,
-0.5681207180023193,
-0.30778002738952637,
-0.3324233591556549,
-0.19902031123638153,
0.12040292471647263,
-0.8279736042022705,
0.4644484519958496,
-0.10435432195663452,
1.123328685760498,
-0.12234924733638763,
-0.1255892813205719,
-0.521606981754303,
-0.6858807802200317,
0.9276451468467712,
-0.626071572303772,
0.6392755508422852,
1.0965062379837036,
0.059171564877033234,
-0.33777686953544617,
-0.954095721244812,
-0.3718833029270172,
-0.5379754304885864,
-0.12949442863464355,
0.013934627175331116,
-0.3045673966407776,
0.0943986177444458,
0.1289331316947937,
0.3839206099510193,
-0.5509982705116272,
0.08649551868438721,
-0.3877220153808594,
-0.3953842520713806,
0.8389681577682495,
-0.08950967341661453,
0.5002159476280212,
-0.1246585100889206,
-0.17030231654644012,
-0.12164492160081863,
-0.1788218766450882,
0.2483360320329666,
0.2755897343158722,
0.3753744065761566,
-0.08877228945493698,
0.39375585317611694,
-0.23623573780059814,
0.5276607275009155,
0.19359040260314941,
-0.44118574261665344,
0.5382340550422668,
0.05864784121513367,
-0.06162773072719574,
0.473955363035202,
0.8903210759162903,
0.11797277629375458,
0.07729703933000565,
-0.267300009727478,
-0.22763954102993011,
-0.2619650959968567,
0.3315742015838623,
-0.44324997067451477,
-0.518238365650177,
0.010884654708206654,
-0.529803991317749,
-0.4565340280532837,
0.1338997632265091,
-0.048019878566265106,
-0.23362389206886292,
-0.21587775647640228,
0.429351270198822,
-0.6937065124511719,
-0.3708047568798065,
0.2745514214038849,
-0.682575523853302,
0.4665958285331726,
0.09157761186361313,
-1.3521596193313599,
0.5342946648597717,
0.38992154598236084,
0.6136878728866577,
0.2815672755241394,
-0.5290572047233582,
-0.3175071179866791,
0.35706087946891785,
-0.7261101007461548,
0.543769896030426,
-0.4155234694480896,
-0.40284809470176697,
-0.31116896867752075,
0.18210093677043915,
0.12960132956504822,
-0.9301794171333313,
0.46184220910072327,
-0.24888846278190613,
-0.10079120844602585,
-0.2340065836906433,
-0.6359266042709351,
-0.271549791097641,
-0.037144552916288376,
-0.4967806041240692,
1.2793707847595215,
0.23239189386367798,
-0.8030969500541687,
0.304784893989563,
-0.3843753933906555,
-0.5126853585243225,
0.29410678148269653,
-0.22373828291893005,
-0.010759439319372177,
0.16429825127124786,
0.055321790277957916,
0.5925100445747375,
0.13578082621097565,
0.3695501387119293,
-0.2907137870788574,
-0.21038028597831726,
0.3403140902519226,
0.17188256978988647,
0.8276523947715759,
-0.07724137604236603,
-0.32273393869400024,
-0.15085986256599426,
-1.2350493669509888,
0.3867865800857544,
0.20847903192043304,
-0.3797815442085266,
-0.705927312374115,
-0.06745053827762604,
-0.15999607741832733,
-0.1377839893102646,
0.42070549726486206,
-0.7304375171661377,
0.25968432426452637,
-0.0849558636546135,
0.19693754613399506,
0.28355672955513,
-0.21788136661052704,
0.17683997750282288,
-0.32722654938697815,
0.24761272966861725,
-0.5104807019233704,
0.22657600045204163,
0.0493096262216568,
-0.5610681772232056,
-0.7462230324745178,
-0.5266509652137756,
0.5022129416465759,
0.6350240707397461,
0.25225913524627686,
0.6262465119361877,
0.06647860258817673,
-0.5557436347007751,
-0.6336565017700195,
0.019200829789042473,
-0.08622532337903976,
0.22023838758468628,
0.30916041135787964,
-0.5794006586074829,
-0.5766087770462036,
-1.3061110973358154,
0.22321701049804688,
-0.403234601020813,
-0.28701525926589966,
0.4184419810771942,
-0.010957015678286552,
-0.3472641110420227,
0.848307192325592,
-0.25488919019699097,
-0.18668243288993835,
-0.24650631844997406,
0.555519700050354,
0.11193607747554779,
0.34407538175582886,
0.5243178009986877,
-0.26586681604385376,
-0.5249806642532349,
0.2352980375289917,
-0.9330622553825378,
-0.5412449836730957,
0.18569210171699524,
0.07610201835632324,
-0.2204001545906067,
0.8805853128433228,
-0.3888382911682129,
0.3251086473464966,
0.2846694886684418,
0.42675352096557617,
0.3679446876049042,
-0.14874267578125,
-0.018388379365205765,
-0.48310425877571106,
-0.015098514035344124,
-0.08440128713846207,
-0.034989502280950546,
-0.8756816387176514,
-0.47739434242248535,
0.19656261801719666,
0.13656306266784668,
0.04277762398123741,
0.28808295726776123,
-0.5943236947059631,
-0.21575553715229034,
-0.34922632575035095,
0.29489850997924805,
-0.08329466730356216,
0.14562304317951202,
0.38676008582115173,
0.5657208561897278,
1.1290596723556519,
-0.6527498364448547,
0.25441765785217285,
0.3538323640823364,
-0.026026960462331772,
0.42133262753486633,
-0.5242258906364441,
0.16562438011169434,
-0.021860066801309586,
0.10632717609405518,
-0.709735631942749,
-0.1973964273929596,
0.195082426071167,
-0.82691890001297,
0.42735612392425537,
-0.20212522149085999,
-0.2100881189107895,
0.05535219982266426,
-0.26884761452674866,
0.09904229640960693,
0.28653934597969055,
-0.5219403505325317,
0.17022477090358734,
0.6504349112510681,
-0.3474227786064148,
-0.4689369201660156,
-0.16963818669319153,
0.38892805576324463,
-0.1347658336162567,
-0.8879314064979553,
0.5212926864624023,
0.13677792251110077,
-0.36414840817451477,
-0.22564776241779327,
-0.06984901428222656,
-0.31649255752563477,
0.100835882127285,
0.2043233960866928,
-0.1710178703069687,
-0.5182334184646606,
0.5113216042518616,
-0.32887035608291626,
0.0556393601000309,
0.17813506722450256,
-0.28370004892349243,
0.4360624849796295,
-0.263314813375473,
0.2539430558681488,
-0.6837039589881897,
0.4092685878276825,
0.5754733681678772,
-0.06217658892273903,
0.29185211658477783,
1.0383697748184204,
-0.4755544364452362,
-0.1626577526330948,
-0.7135675549507141,
-0.20603381097316742,
-0.49038606882095337,
0.08542133867740631,
-0.41163337230682373,
-0.39313867688179016,
0.41486161947250366,
-0.24394795298576355,
-0.6380136013031006,
0.13221661746501923,
-0.018461667001247406,
-0.5739858150482178,
0.781086802482605,
0.8820213079452515,
-0.35542961955070496,
0.4007609784603119,
-0.1678091585636139,
0.1172889694571495,
-0.9283881783485413,
-0.34631040692329407,
-0.46034371852874756,
-0.07979081571102142,
-0.8403114676475525,
-0.0987086221575737,
0.07039238512516022,
0.5290529131889343,
0.21660491824150085,
0.20607855916023254,
-0.3872181475162506,
0.30232033133506775,
0.903752863407135,
-0.2995959222316742,
0.10691474378108978,
0.2260861098766327,
-0.4020552933216095,
-0.2523109018802643,
-0.6012528538703918,
-0.4289727807044983,
0.6498720645904541,
0.4431721568107605,
0.7374733686447144,
0.176591157913208,
0.9972642660140991,
0.28439995646476746,
-0.05206874758005142,
-1.0995197296142578,
0.5949939489364624,
0.16305212676525116,
-0.6596675515174866,
-0.7150667905807495,
-0.07028727978467941,
-1.1581019163131714,
0.16273535788059235,
-0.10679557919502258,
-1.1955337524414062,
0.04165390133857727,
-0.1797139048576355,
0.1218639388680458,
-0.04984663054347038,
-0.44136810302734375,
0.6884303689002991,
-0.35198312997817993,
-0.09557212889194489,
-0.1952911764383316,
-0.7506187558174133,
0.2166273444890976,
-0.05859260633587837,
0.06007622554898262,
-0.39327332377433777,
-0.04829925671219826,
0.7797656059265137,
-0.6322264671325684,
0.7852138876914978,
0.02560124732553959,
-0.3197515606880188,
0.30965176224708557,
-0.10464172065258026,
0.3214908540248871,
-0.08275202661752701,
0.22833457589149475,
0.20897498726844788,
-0.10795509070158005,
-0.38053664565086365,
-0.45005592703819275,
0.6095854043960571,
-0.5064155459403992,
-0.37189409136772156,
-0.4140283763408661,
-0.07768251746892929,
-0.4491158425807953,
0.2693919241428375,
0.40319308638572693,
0.21934989094734192,
-0.27705350518226624,
-0.04791455343365669,
0.5598729252815247,
-0.32095953822135925,
0.4898623824119568,
1.0907622575759888,
-0.3954183757305145,
-0.4802834391593933,
1.1461527347564697,
-0.013261468149721622,
0.011200187727808952,
0.23141483962535858,
0.5416736602783203,
-0.32715925574302673,
-0.5418887734413147,
-0.3330022394657135,
0.7329503893852234,
-0.45180490612983704,
0.2643510401248932,
-0.5860910415649414,
-0.44849854707717896,
-0.3936794698238373,
-0.06428375095129013,
-0.5417805910110474,
-0.47845420241355896,
-0.10182518512010574,
0.07787896692752838,
0.20328769087791443,
1.3065434694290161,
-0.7100768685340881,
0.4163839817047119,
-0.9292978048324585,
0.21684925258159637,
0.4666310250759125,
0.3849593997001648,
-0.027474433183670044,
-0.26977530121803284,
-0.2502495348453522,
-0.24899818003177643,
-0.33694860339164734,
-1.0853307247161865,
0.3798896074295044,
0.3614548146724701,
0.7996101975440979,
0.4137098789215088,
-0.14566314220428467,
0.7125231027603149,
-0.38149699568748474,
0.529241144657135,
0.18112055957317352,
-1.110550880432129,
0.9238390922546387,
-0.7102036476135254,
-0.06491529941558838,
0.2584071159362793,
0.5653468370437622,
-0.9403953552246094,
-0.7170716524124146,
-0.9653260707855225,
-0.8181423544883728,
0.5840345621109009,
0.3437986671924591,
-0.13634617626667023,
-0.15110282599925995,
0.14044533669948578,
0.06057748943567276,
0.20156638324260712,
-0.3627638816833496,
-0.4277213513851166,
-0.15864811837673187,
0.36252743005752563,
-0.05236199498176575,
-0.13862845301628113,
-0.015246758237481117,
-0.7061622738838196,
0.9268905520439148,
-0.023280693218111992,
0.11001705378293991,
0.430528849363327,
0.07415959984064102,
-0.0025620232336223125,
0.387074738740921,
0.900692880153656,
0.552196741104126,
-0.5513216853141785,
0.07791969180107117,
-0.0030713570304214954,
-0.793630063533783,
0.09628573805093765,
0.08836544305086136,
0.05957216024398804,
0.6016005277633667,
0.35658174753189087,
0.6230816841125488,
-0.0637558177113533,
-0.44281846284866333,
0.5637547969818115,
-0.0685744434595108,
-0.34896618127822876,
-0.6672760248184204,
-0.2740592956542969,
0.3217554986476898,
0.06602209806442261,
0.3879869878292084,
-0.2544761598110199,
0.3866795599460602,
-0.510840654373169,
0.36441126465797424,
0.5957566499710083,
-0.49716299772262573,
-0.436420738697052,
0.3140188455581665,
-0.04960344359278679,
-0.17655891180038452,
0.7401307225227356,
-0.4771188199520111,
-0.36172568798065186,
0.43331000208854675,
0.5570917129516602,
0.8885424733161926,
-0.5531936883926392,
0.43277090787887573,
0.33975812792778015,
0.31549638509750366,
-0.06920134276151657,
0.21358487010002136,
-0.26454347372055054,
-0.8469018340110779,
0.05929579958319664,
-0.6368088126182556,
-0.27490681409835815,
0.847907543182373,
-1.0314708948135376,
0.3892543613910675,
-0.3893948197364807,
-0.4424089193344116,
0.7785962224006653,
-0.28933289647102356,
0.0588218979537487,
0.1988830715417862,
0.4702693223953247,
0.6063714623451233,
-0.47115081548690796,
0.9356979131698608,
0.7160505056381226,
-0.04093428701162338,
-1.041831612586975,
0.0851902887225151,
0.0006951658870093524,
-0.6843575835227966,
1.0309544801712036,
0.09958354383707047,
-0.48771756887435913,
-0.131868377327919,
-0.6430388689041138,
-0.9507175087928772,
0.8050073385238647,
-0.01139793824404478,
-0.28800535202026367,
0.3705279529094696,
-0.11758806556463242,
0.45925483107566833,
-0.08613522350788116,
-0.020244324579834938,
0.5772189497947693,
0.48236367106437683,
0.03791062533855438,
-1.4264963865280151,
-0.2777360677719116,
-0.4548790156841278,
-0.25261828303337097,
0.28162717819213867,
-0.5455948710441589,
0.6991298794746399,
-0.3260524570941925,
-0.40834981203079224,
-0.039685603231191635,
0.43491241335868835,
-0.11175365000963211,
0.39614614844322205,
0.24146029353141785,
0.5152742862701416,
1.180590271949768,
0.29794609546661377,
0.44308438897132874,
-0.15675786137580872,
0.29757970571517944,
1.0804892778396606,
-0.21166518330574036,
0.8959806561470032,
0.27574190497398376,
-0.4753001630306244,
0.3959345817565918,
0.5720926523208618,
-0.12423767149448395,
0.23844105005264282,
0.7889737486839294,
-0.6686946153640747,
-0.35404130816459656,
-0.4369211494922638,
-0.43797042965888977,
0.7555125951766968,
0.6100401878356934,
-0.3582649827003479,
0.06597474962472916,
-0.14463184773921967,
-0.1570693552494049,
-0.40142667293548584,
-0.08627966791391373,
0.9433153867721558,
-0.04488874971866608,
-0.219496488571167,
1.1328678131103516,
0.1201280727982521,
0.6763230562210083,
-0.5492608547210693,
-0.060978300869464874,
-0.14071054756641388,
-0.0412471666932106,
-0.43662649393081665,
-0.48027101159095764,
0.17724554240703583,
-0.49021202325820923,
-0.22178249061107635,
-0.0024305873084813356,
0.9109471440315247,
-0.4520110487937927,
-0.1200634017586708,
0.43795129656791687,
0.46361303329467773,
0.6175889372825623,
-0.023378154262900352,
-0.23127968609333038,
-0.18992094695568085,
-0.027002796530723572,
0.16612017154693604,
0.259456604719162,
0.4337867796421051,
-0.13487176597118378,
0.8411729335784912,
0.28915947675704956,
0.256197452545166,
0.5537145733833313,
0.34444403648376465,
0.28584080934524536,
-0.9701812863349915,
-0.3456369936466217,
-0.36974725127220154,
0.07945352792739868,
-0.25443944334983826,
-0.02837790548801422,
0.7967667579650879,
0.7887961268424988,
0.9404052495956421,
-0.22881481051445007,
1.2114685773849487,
-0.1109011322259903,
0.6463117003440857,
-0.2778589427471161,
0.5166244506835938,
-0.4662686288356781,
0.08074984699487686,
-0.18194103240966797,
-0.4385022819042206,
-0.1604098379611969,
0.9520633220672607,
0.07952909916639328,
-0.21298252046108246,
0.8473311066627502,
0.943774402141571,
-0.198297917842865,
0.2701159119606018,
0.6244966387748718,
-0.11493086069822311,
-0.10082978755235672,
-0.20724926888942719,
1.2285188436508179,
-0.2792441248893738,
0.4110354781150818,
-0.5649580359458923,
-0.17178544402122498,
-0.0071401940658688545,
-0.4799453020095825,
-0.7944760918617249,
-0.805320143699646,
-0.46946975588798523,
-0.25370943546295166,
-0.05733036994934082,
0.8067465424537659,
0.8753212094306946,
-0.7546201348304749,
-0.5721346139907837,
0.15263418853282928,
-0.20132014155387878,
-0.2276877909898758,
-0.29493847489356995,
0.0871710404753685,
-0.6447840929031372,
-0.47475454211235046,
0.7248508930206299,
0.4793597459793091,
0.6264132261276245,
-0.07934598624706268,
-0.18229246139526367,
-0.008801784366369247,
0.16916535794734955,
0.4538861811161041,
0.6180419921875,
-0.9189081192016602,
-0.13235333561897278,
0.19585874676704407,
-0.2962445616722107,
0.41125044226646423,
1.0503122806549072,
-0.42526426911354065,
0.3228341341018677,
0.20811161398887634,
0.1529259979724884,
0.6493949294090271,
0.008743882179260254,
0.40695229172706604,
-1.0200706720352173,
-0.03839575871825218,
0.08892413973808289,
0.07313687354326248,
0.442503958940506,
-0.16889427602291107,
0.45010000467300415,
0.28843751549720764,
-0.31333374977111816,
-0.40903225541114807,
0.13725627958774567,
-1.3421968221664429,
-0.15610873699188232,
0.9601304531097412,
-0.09142111241817474,
-0.10820674896240234,
-0.37515801191329956,
-0.39988842606544495,
-0.05998823046684265,
-0.5407277345657349,
0.6672931909561157,
1.0195996761322021,
-0.6172064542770386,
-0.12596705555915833,
-0.850361168384552,
0.7559317350387573,
0.15945975482463837,
-0.4071195125579834,
-0.1357879936695099,
0.3075559735298157,
0.5563350319862366,
0.49011239409446716,
1.0497556924819946,
0.06836535036563873,
0.03718049079179764,
0.19470898807048798,
0.29824933409690857,
0.41942596435546875,
-0.3574247658252716,
-0.047406043857336044,
-0.06379184871912003,
0.47193893790245056,
-0.6637454628944397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15967v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15967v1
|
Direct Punjabi to English speech translation using discrete units
| 2024-02-25T03:03:34 | 2024-02-25T03:03:34 |
Prabhjot Kaur, L. Andrew M. Bush, Weisong Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Speech-to-speech translation is yet to reach the same level of coverage as
text-to-text translation systems. The current speech technology is highly
limited in its coverage of over 7000 languages spoken worldwide, leaving more
than half of the population deprived of such technology and shared experiences.
With voice-assisted technology (such as social robots and speech-to-text apps)
and auditory content (such as podcasts and lectures) on the rise, ensuring that
the technology is available for all is more important than ever. Speech
translation can play a vital role in mitigating technological disparity and
creating a more inclusive society. With a motive to contribute towards speech
translation research for low-resource languages, our work presents a direct
speech-to-speech translation model for one of the Indic languages called
Punjabi to English. Additionally, we explore the performance of using a
discrete representation of speech called discrete acoustic units as input to
the Transformer-based translation model. The model, abbreviated as Unit-to-Unit
Translation (U2UT), takes a sequence of discrete units of the source language
(the language being translated from) and outputs a sequence of discrete units
of the target language (the language being translated to). Our results show
that the U2UT model performs better than the Speech-to-Unit Translation (S2UT)
model by a 3.69 BLEU score.
|
[
-0.06499456614255905,
-0.5097619295120239,
0.4171299934387207,
0.6562045812606812,
-0.4905128479003906,
0.09033510833978653,
-0.47828516364097595,
-0.4615504741668701,
-0.011403094977140427,
0.16275162994861603,
-0.4366312325000763,
-0.18487194180488586,
-0.5236262083053589,
0.5238123536109924,
-0.6997956037521362,
0.34847456216812134,
0.3711201548576355,
0.2795759439468384,
0.048696521669626236,
0.15491513907909393,
-0.7888448238372803,
-0.17853322625160217,
-0.5312915444374084,
-0.5230116248130798,
0.3806116580963135,
0.5201983451843262,
0.6944089531898499,
0.49126169085502625,
0.574944019317627,
0.2384480983018875,
-0.040411755442619324,
-0.06311611086130142,
-0.23534606397151947,
0.04827490076422691,
-0.20486082136631012,
-0.4088611304759979,
-0.1846357136964798,
-0.10136470943689346,
0.8655479550361633,
0.7683139443397522,
-0.11346133053302765,
-0.06809842586517334,
-0.029844535514712334,
0.4432530999183655,
-0.14710326492786407,
0.19766105711460114,
-0.5759690403938293,
-0.032678961753845215,
-0.500939667224884,
-0.005095953121781349,
-0.9062924981117249,
-0.5884141325950623,
-0.10576261579990387,
-0.4831535220146179,
-0.3984954059123993,
-0.16046462953090668,
0.3683028221130371,
0.4074326455593109,
-0.5828272104263306,
-0.39719659090042114,
-1.4302366971969604,
0.751011312007904,
-0.7742760181427002,
0.6471769213676453,
0.3212142288684845,
0.1066679060459137,
0.16806456446647644,
-0.8334081768989563,
-0.6728951334953308,
-0.13597124814987183,
-0.3091276288032532,
0.2170138657093048,
-0.374862402677536,
-0.0973498597741127,
-0.06790658086538315,
0.36069217324256897,
-0.6379653811454773,
0.13852643966674805,
-0.49992093443870544,
0.23087258636951447,
0.7874438762664795,
-0.10488016158342361,
0.4890953600406647,
-0.5307358503341675,
-0.2531980574131012,
-0.09740784019231796,
-0.5515246987342834,
0.07580532133579254,
0.06932912766933441,
0.613305389881134,
-0.29484421014785767,
0.6656163334846497,
-0.05938605219125748,
0.46445992588996887,
0.2907378375530243,
-0.41986653208732605,
0.09778410941362381,
-0.2848298251628876,
-0.23970842361450195,
0.5265054106712341,
0.7667585611343384,
-0.08399656414985657,
0.23153886198997498,
-0.17524519562721252,
-0.09875743836164474,
0.17768888175487518,
0.05046634003520012,
-0.6529812812805176,
0.04855942353606224,
0.0914146825671196,
-0.17703275382518768,
-0.05516337975859642,
-0.410170316696167,
-0.412130206823349,
-0.012045789510011673,
-0.3945247530937195,
0.28362345695495605,
-0.8391351103782654,
-0.67933589220047,
0.08705409616231918,
0.37705639004707336,
0.6496706008911133,
0.1852569878101349,
-0.9459086656570435,
0.40087801218032837,
0.5407314896583557,
0.9359424710273743,
-0.22075255215168,
0.050000160932540894,
-0.18921513855457306,
0.2727976143360138,
-0.6280389428138733,
0.8353018760681152,
-0.6955394148826599,
-0.8209860920906067,
0.07931920886039734,
-0.29800495505332947,
-0.4028284251689911,
-0.35233649611473083,
0.6965999603271484,
-0.34805676341056824,
0.09284596145153046,
0.051429081708192825,
-0.42988598346710205,
-0.052424874156713486,
-0.4657551348209381,
-0.45491519570350647,
0.8785092234611511,
0.16765744984149933,
-0.3852934241294861,
0.014447188004851341,
-0.7274966835975647,
-0.8725069165229797,
0.6054310202598572,
-0.3191852271556854,
-0.14922882616519928,
0.27083757519721985,
0.12038107961416245,
0.1932685375213623,
-0.3991817831993103,
0.26752838492393494,
0.3485565185546875,
-0.39868855476379395,
0.3078209161758423,
-0.5673767328262329,
0.9342437386512756,
0.5113828182220459,
-0.34321311116218567,
0.11950667947530746,
-0.46014729142189026,
-0.010223880410194397,
0.03474850952625275,
-0.07868191599845886,
-0.35042163729667664,
0.025911007076501846,
0.3348056674003601,
0.22367997467517853,
-0.04132718965411186,
-0.7236992120742798,
0.054235052317380905,
-0.5163571238517761,
0.5605323910713196,
0.47812309861183167,
-0.3260532021522522,
0.785636305809021,
-0.04160211235284805,
0.31240367889404297,
-0.0029424589592963457,
0.08363017439842224,
-0.051502928137779236,
-0.759453296661377,
-0.34742510318756104,
-0.3981182277202606,
0.6271606087684631,
0.7691076993942261,
-0.5723683834075928,
0.3047487437725067,
-0.6771916151046753,
-0.5478572845458984,
-1.017451524734497,
-0.13617034256458282,
0.016702480614185333,
0.3696747422218323,
0.17396463453769684,
-0.2313680499792099,
-0.40951815247535706,
-0.892504096031189,
0.15271329879760742,
-0.39644089341163635,
-0.3413222134113312,
-0.032599158585071564,
0.11353464424610138,
-0.398481547832489,
0.8189198970794678,
-0.1350383460521698,
-0.5929228663444519,
-0.5039535760879517,
-0.06716708093881607,
0.11475058645009995,
0.5356641411781311,
0.18078330159187317,
-1.0035492181777954,
-0.718590497970581,
0.3292160928249359,
-0.8173132538795471,
-0.24143394827842712,
-0.4330710172653198,
0.03219613805413246,
0.2076243907213211,
0.3546280860900879,
-0.7475717067718506,
0.4986802935600281,
0.6999064683914185,
-0.15757477283477783,
0.07741515338420868,
-0.03715939447283745,
0.20809905230998993,
-1.2074849605560303,
0.055306922644376755,
-0.17960013449192047,
-0.22556601464748383,
-0.7290500402450562,
0.16417023539543152,
0.2355012148618698,
-0.319715291261673,
-0.6660921573638916,
0.3136025667190552,
-0.12597568333148956,
-0.010920653119683266,
-0.08848617970943451,
0.38915395736694336,
-0.2933322787284851,
0.14477097988128662,
0.030699750408530235,
1.2535518407821655,
0.2766726315021515,
-0.4321759343147278,
0.34419533610343933,
0.632841169834137,
-0.25739118456840515,
0.7115573883056641,
-0.5676044821739197,
0.2227211892604828,
0.27485501766204834,
0.1692640483379364,
-1.0092271566390991,
-0.19522972404956818,
0.02126559428870678,
-0.7366576194763184,
0.4016113877296448,
0.18800576031208038,
-0.42631450295448303,
-0.10836506634950638,
0.009238071739673615,
0.5875316262245178,
0.7022631764411926,
-0.36542654037475586,
0.6545694470405579,
0.412318617105484,
-0.5760498046875,
0.037574928253889084,
-0.851411759853363,
0.3368692398071289,
-0.06362634152173996,
-0.8067147731781006,
0.5154464244842529,
-0.16783507168293,
-0.3791198134422302,
-0.04985526204109192,
0.08052407950162888,
-0.1996781975030899,
-0.23162272572517395,
0.3136453926563263,
-0.024027423933148384,
-0.2677053213119507,
0.09779973328113556,
0.16377487778663635,
-0.09584137052297592,
0.012839062139391899,
-0.24577030539512634,
0.6938555240631104,
-0.016740979626774788,
-0.3172014057636261,
-0.7567847371101379,
1.0078587532043457,
0.660941481590271,
-0.26254695653915405,
0.5532349348068237,
0.5701907277107239,
-0.5058038830757141,
0.086296945810318,
-0.39621129631996155,
-0.04468085616827011,
-0.4477372169494629,
0.27885207533836365,
-0.7789993286132812,
-0.38338541984558105,
0.3222914934158325,
-0.30783623456954956,
-0.23623913526535034,
0.7296223044395447,
0.6520730257034302,
-0.11492281407117844,
1.0847643613815308,
0.6820775270462036,
-0.18439912796020508,
0.25093910098075867,
-0.025775114074349403,
0.6091806292533875,
-0.7155114412307739,
-0.4670422673225403,
-0.5682862997055054,
-0.08844181150197983,
-0.708771288394928,
-0.30062443017959595,
0.29683542251586914,
0.08731298893690109,
0.1992497742176056,
0.5395715236663818,
-0.568584144115448,
0.09592140465974808,
0.739628255367279,
-0.0832853689789772,
0.5614121556282043,
0.1191827580332756,
-0.09477175027132034,
-0.48910510540008545,
-0.5787923336029053,
-0.4072505831718445,
0.7221184968948364,
0.28794482350349426,
0.6255308389663696,
0.3872082233428955,
0.5967047810554504,
0.5076651573181152,
0.097456194460392,
-0.9115810394287109,
0.45089155435562134,
-0.313083291053772,
-0.35311073064804077,
-0.5375033020973206,
-0.3693470060825348,
-0.8615162372589111,
0.07170439511537552,
0.23169007897377014,
-0.3094072639942169,
0.2605498731136322,
-0.5172463655471802,
-0.2982863783836365,
0.3010384738445282,
-0.8498162627220154,
0.2829321324825287,
-0.2053992599248886,
-0.13310135900974274,
-0.36059242486953735,
-0.39856958389282227,
0.32975685596466064,
-0.3097964823246002,
0.38829487562179565,
0.07044423371553421,
0.2009543776512146,
0.5724872946739197,
-0.027146542444825172,
0.5260586142539978,
0.20523354411125183,
-0.25344017148017883,
0.09413590282201767,
-0.004754466470330954,
0.14691708981990814,
0.19151468575000763,
-0.2157634198665619,
0.354857474565506,
-0.05345311388373375,
-0.4339001178741455,
-0.282142698764801,
0.6509273648262024,
-0.9650939702987671,
-0.4932350516319275,
-0.5340983271598816,
-0.7928087115287781,
0.01729670539498329,
0.17089173197746277,
0.4760996997356415,
0.2555769383907318,
-0.04287426546216011,
0.348756343126297,
0.7019122838973999,
-0.14213301241397858,
0.6499329209327698,
0.512022852897644,
-0.25745710730552673,
-0.3359156548976898,
0.6067900657653809,
0.34487050771713257,
0.2506899833679199,
0.4706110954284668,
0.06791774928569794,
-0.5775458216667175,
-0.45452404022216797,
-0.6590882539749146,
0.3892727494239807,
-0.3986594080924988,
-0.311024010181427,
-0.4809676706790924,
-0.5697218775749207,
-0.837007999420166,
-0.2085707187652588,
-0.4793958067893982,
-0.5103657841682434,
0.06823775172233582,
0.0049315402284264565,
0.34646958112716675,
1.1047942638397217,
-0.46729469299316406,
0.45292678475379944,
-0.41524139046669006,
0.35501959919929504,
0.6081042289733887,
0.2413802295923233,
-0.3849985897541046,
-0.9289926290512085,
-0.21357408165931702,
0.14940792322158813,
-0.1553645133972168,
-0.9915626645088196,
0.6421467065811157,
0.37444546818733215,
0.13312864303588867,
0.1071278303861618,
0.3881417214870453,
0.8308881521224976,
-0.8868874907493591,
0.7280881404876709,
0.26662421226501465,
-1.0211422443389893,
0.7970452904701233,
-0.2805751860141754,
0.43093860149383545,
0.2343299388885498,
0.30933499336242676,
-0.8313968181610107,
-0.3995417654514313,
-0.2175503820180893,
-1.0427157878875732,
0.5992676615715027,
0.4761246144771576,
0.3484653830528259,
-0.0806659609079361,
0.050491850823163986,
-0.12939955294132233,
-0.1497451514005661,
-0.7411260604858398,
-0.2847236692905426,
-0.15501968562602997,
-0.15596461296081543,
-0.007709702476859093,
-0.22167730331420898,
0.06356941163539886,
-0.4675988256931305,
0.7268943190574646,
0.36301493644714355,
0.5488529801368713,
0.27423402667045593,
-0.29054349660873413,
-0.37380558252334595,
0.5320274233818054,
0.85233074426651,
0.4476889371871948,
-0.3766569197177887,
-0.10524237900972366,
0.1604943573474884,
-0.7312608957290649,
0.29939520359039307,
0.2523849308490753,
-0.41925978660583496,
0.48524054884910583,
0.16173391044139862,
0.4883931875228882,
0.2930065989494324,
-0.24008427560329437,
0.4398009479045868,
-0.25845205783843994,
0.03911709040403366,
-0.7465471625328064,
-0.4283423125743866,
0.24877923727035522,
0.04747717082500458,
0.7478383779525757,
0.1254628747701645,
-0.04291320592164993,
-0.43654865026474,
0.34924444556236267,
-0.04124385491013527,
-0.4239923655986786,
-0.3229796588420868,
0.8968628644943237,
0.5859111547470093,
-0.7687492966651917,
0.6543110609054565,
-0.11614018678665161,
-0.1122683733701706,
0.07441724091768265,
0.8502770066261292,
0.9757103323936462,
-0.9231509566307068,
0.28664159774780273,
0.25884777307510376,
0.4855908751487732,
-0.01524439174681902,
-0.047201551496982574,
0.16215217113494873,
-0.21257224678993225,
-0.8808009624481201,
-0.5834745168685913,
-0.578797459602356,
0.21246778964996338,
-0.8550253510475159,
-0.030171087011694908,
0.09152888506650925,
-0.059031207114458084,
-0.0880989357829094,
-0.0071937814354896545,
-0.583650529384613,
0.1748173087835312,
0.3319470286369324,
0.9683732986450195,
-0.9074549674987793,
1.3924165964126587,
0.44604459404945374,
-0.5375603437423706,
-1.0125449895858765,
-0.2007886916399002,
-0.2510877847671509,
-0.5614450573921204,
0.7062111496925354,
-0.0938623696565628,
-0.2671949863433838,
0.3935292661190033,
-0.10659996420145035,
-0.8001996278762817,
0.9160885214805603,
0.514059841632843,
-0.8579901456832886,
-0.06508677452802658,
0.8359388709068298,
0.3967301547527313,
-0.306243360042572,
0.2364460825920105,
0.5235588550567627,
0.3935365378856659,
-0.015029385685920715,
-1.15384840965271,
-0.2318580150604248,
-0.14194636046886444,
0.29752644896507263,
-0.1450638771057129,
-0.4629576504230499,
0.8725816607475281,
0.1726742833852768,
-0.3510960042476654,
-0.01499665342271328,
0.7695128917694092,
-0.16041429340839386,
0.2370253950357437,
0.2741101384162903,
0.31238633394241333,
0.5254226922988892,
-0.14545592665672302,
1.0833921432495117,
-0.33140403032302856,
0.11127228289842606,
0.865192711353302,
-0.5230941772460938,
1.2670652866363525,
0.516592264175415,
-0.3657844364643097,
0.37207579612731934,
0.36823445558547974,
0.5660709142684937,
0.6695945858955383,
-0.12953579425811768,
-0.7650623917579651,
-0.06056755408644676,
-0.3767869770526886,
-0.6205767393112183,
0.643373966217041,
0.4472799301147461,
-0.03632692992687225,
-0.026175295934081078,
0.316591739654541,
-0.052113428711891174,
0.6223887205123901,
-0.33911633491516113,
0.8156519532203674,
0.2894037067890167,
-0.4137208163738251,
0.6290550827980042,
0.07492166757583618,
0.7863633036613464,
-0.672421932220459,
0.06329935789108276,
-0.5881446003913879,
0.1849205493927002,
-0.2674696445465088,
-0.5665207505226135,
0.5212979316711426,
0.2046026587486267,
-0.15285705029964447,
-0.5269522666931152,
0.46216055750846863,
-0.6178082227706909,
-0.8189478516578674,
0.5397481322288513,
0.44172653555870056,
0.11420098692178726,
-0.014469949528574944,
-0.25246578454971313,
0.1700490117073059,
0.13376779854297638,
0.1192644014954567,
0.31990063190460205,
0.476369708776474,
0.141388937830925,
0.5281135439872742,
0.4429253041744232,
0.3303729295730591,
0.22000598907470703,
-0.0716819167137146,
0.5284333825111389,
-0.5177405476570129,
-0.31412002444267273,
-0.7354626059532166,
0.511462390422821,
-0.0027737568598240614,
-0.007791119161993265,
0.8132275938987732,
0.6850335597991943,
1.1295355558395386,
-0.11343502998352051,
0.8714142441749573,
-0.06550303101539612,
0.5409578680992126,
-0.151978999376297,
0.7787090539932251,
-0.0678555965423584,
0.16072514653205872,
-0.1398889273405075,
-0.7741908431053162,
-0.24308373034000397,
0.9161435961723328,
-0.29520365595817566,
-0.6222501397132874,
0.6848573088645935,
0.5884867906570435,
-0.07089226692914963,
0.10974220931529999,
0.8415965437889099,
0.1600288301706314,
0.25400903820991516,
0.36288750171661377,
0.5252167582511902,
-0.7198392748832703,
0.8256557583808899,
-0.2866353690624237,
-0.1374003291130066,
0.020406922325491905,
-0.39643892645835876,
-0.2656492590904236,
-0.7579686641693115,
-0.33455216884613037,
-0.22423461079597473,
0.0324055440723896,
0.9178735017776489,
0.7754274010658264,
-0.9250764846801758,
-0.6758366823196411,
0.20173312723636627,
-0.0038302787579596043,
-0.2132130265235901,
-0.17241227626800537,
0.2021886110305786,
-0.26787373423576355,
-0.9515823125839233,
0.6282565593719482,
0.3314655125141144,
-0.2074882984161377,
-0.0703667625784874,
-0.20057103037834167,
-0.47651907801628113,
0.34544482827186584,
0.9507479071617126,
0.21347327530384064,
-0.8258383274078369,
-0.3004593253135681,
0.09837459772825241,
-0.2487882673740387,
0.29214510321617126,
0.5947363376617432,
-0.782587468624115,
0.3394796848297119,
0.02936534956097603,
0.7293908596038818,
0.40309038758277893,
-0.22587133944034576,
0.6547204256057739,
-0.9758642911911011,
0.2663390040397644,
0.3389430344104767,
-0.010663414373993874,
0.5390148162841797,
-0.2150421291589737,
0.5653090476989746,
0.14812692999839783,
-0.5196290016174316,
-0.953752875328064,
0.31598636507987976,
-1.0025973320007324,
0.004275260493159294,
1.1112185716629028,
0.0558895617723465,
-0.013292256742715836,
-0.06274384260177612,
-0.2406749129295349,
0.5868819952011108,
-0.5732458233833313,
0.6588891744613647,
0.36606618762016296,
0.025310231372714043,
-0.38550281524658203,
-0.5642829537391663,
0.3820357620716095,
0.4471355974674225,
-0.4313165247440338,
-0.08528352528810501,
0.1237005665898323,
0.03235854208469391,
0.33370310068130493,
0.7962489128112793,
-0.16731269657611847,
0.11774567514657974,
0.08591742813587189,
-0.04973737522959709,
0.30734097957611084,
-0.06756629794836044,
-0.513172447681427,
0.04654809832572937,
0.20447401702404022,
-0.3665221035480499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00811v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00811v1
|
Cognitive Bias in High-Stakes Decision-Making with LLMs
| 2024-02-25T02:35:56 | 2024-02-25T02:35:56 |
Jessica Echterhoff, Yao Liu, Abeer Alessa, Julian McAuley, Zexue He
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) offer significant potential as tools to support
an expanding range of decision-making tasks. However, given their training on
human (created) data, LLMs can inherit both societal biases against protected
groups, as well as be subject to cognitive bias. Such human-like bias can
impede fair and explainable decisions made with LLM assistance. Our work
introduces BiasBuster, a framework designed to uncover, evaluate, and mitigate
cognitive bias in LLMs, particularly in high-stakes decision-making tasks.
Inspired by prior research in psychology and cognitive sciences, we develop a
dataset containing 16,800 prompts to evaluate different cognitive biases (e.g.,
prompt-induced, sequential, inherent). We test various bias mitigation
strategies, amidst proposing a novel method using LLMs to debias their own
prompts. Our analysis provides a comprehensive picture on the presence and
effects of cognitive bias across different commercial and open-source models.
We demonstrate that our self-help debiasing effectively mitigate cognitive bias
without having to manually craft examples for each bias type.
|
[
-0.5171879529953003,
-0.9696565866470337,
0.7851352095603943,
0.3467455208301544,
0.10579259693622589,
-0.023194389417767525,
-0.40589356422424316,
-0.22597119212150574,
0.030998090282082558,
0.7987928986549377,
-0.8268003463745117,
-0.3491927981376648,
-0.7749021053314209,
-0.19780544936656952,
0.2506076693534851,
1.0693583488464355,
0.05118325725197792,
0.3717817962169647,
-0.4972740709781647,
0.17225542664527893,
-0.8891681432723999,
-0.6028599143028259,
-0.8271480798721313,
-0.5592280626296997,
0.4303435683250427,
0.6114758253097534,
0.667425811290741,
0.30586695671081543,
0.40786078572273254,
0.12511171400547028,
-0.19166786968708038,
-0.24682746827602386,
-0.6326091885566711,
0.14993663132190704,
-0.4604094922542572,
-0.54136061668396,
-0.5197750329971313,
0.20675286650657654,
0.16465799510478973,
0.5328790545463562,
-0.1175297349691391,
0.4024868607521057,
0.25168368220329285,
0.6582890152931213,
-0.9054405689239502,
0.21155676245689392,
-0.7968841791152954,
0.09804919362068176,
-0.20895959436893463,
-0.02252681367099285,
-0.46259963512420654,
-0.39511409401893616,
0.21466468274593353,
-0.5738162398338318,
0.2943781912326813,
0.10664203763008118,
0.41920095682144165,
0.6356833577156067,
-0.21777118742465973,
-0.3727193772792816,
-0.6302497982978821,
0.963995099067688,
-0.39548173546791077,
0.02576732635498047,
0.5616479516029358,
0.31906840205192566,
-0.2140338122844696,
-0.034984469413757324,
-0.30631425976753235,
-0.13370035588741302,
0.18312643468379974,
0.2425915002822876,
-0.1126677393913269,
0.1816338747739792,
0.49781185388565063,
-0.06799766421318054,
-0.3055545389652252,
0.3756774961948395,
-0.12773293256759644,
-0.3291855752468109,
0.5603051781654358,
0.1682610958814621,
-0.19032225012779236,
-0.365480899810791,
-0.4458046853542328,
-0.06995072215795517,
-0.6555258631706238,
-0.04164084792137146,
0.3768117427825928,
0.028739430010318756,
0.1319587379693985,
0.6563215255737305,
-0.207294300198555,
0.4074234962463379,
0.4201327860355377,
0.001074343454092741,
-0.09755000472068787,
0.004159360658377409,
-0.23339128494262695,
0.3461030423641205,
0.4063114821910858,
0.5771361589431763,
0.8640519380569458,
0.21558856964111328,
-0.09446165710687637,
0.4768185615539551,
0.12224811315536499,
-0.5811310410499573,
-0.018769528716802597,
0.31715232133865356,
-0.4552268385887146,
-0.3146302103996277,
-0.4319985806941986,
-0.9112837910652161,
-1.00496506690979,
-0.32667991518974304,
0.22157824039459229,
-0.12670812010765076,
-0.004288566764444113,
0.3224605619907379,
-0.1298302859067917,
0.15345817804336548,
0.4470294415950775,
-0.569128692150116,
0.07879021018743515,
0.3931959271430969,
0.42216381430625916,
-0.4218662977218628,
-0.0795334056019783,
-0.500379204750061,
0.24620185792446136,
-0.1924498826265335,
0.8597238659858704,
-0.6005239486694336,
-0.6192585229873657,
-0.055083345621824265,
-0.31945687532424927,
0.3852686583995819,
-0.7066479921340942,
0.9596553444862366,
-0.35342323780059814,
0.17858152091503143,
-0.5679448843002319,
-0.35213303565979004,
0.01071251928806305,
0.38929861783981323,
-0.6196509003639221,
1.0836365222930908,
-0.17204634845256805,
-0.8236077427864075,
0.7711662650108337,
-0.554263710975647,
-0.31271278858184814,
0.07121399790048599,
-0.5196146965026855,
-0.2512849271297455,
0.048363663256168365,
0.491202175617218,
0.46419665217399597,
-0.6549671292304993,
0.4144634008407593,
-0.5805033445358276,
-0.13970030844211578,
0.3637385368347168,
-0.6721091866493225,
0.7456328272819519,
0.047930311411619186,
-0.5576946139335632,
0.1525985449552536,
-0.4648245573043823,
-0.21581082046031952,
0.06030426174402237,
-0.2689492106437683,
-0.6123310923576355,
0.07810720056295395,
-0.06093870475888252,
0.4971067011356354,
0.32269975543022156,
-0.41980376839637756,
0.16316832602024078,
0.15735039114952087,
0.2150975614786148,
1.2979437112808228,
0.11288200318813324,
0.3037847578525543,
-0.3610394299030304,
0.5747185349464417,
0.18238303065299988,
0.41390731930732727,
0.18177631497383118,
-0.34305885434150696,
-0.7166505455970764,
-0.47992196679115295,
-0.030351387336850166,
0.5221238732337952,
-0.5009033679962158,
0.48811689019203186,
-0.10054522752761841,
-0.1867954581975937,
-0.56705242395401,
0.12897098064422607,
0.2364359200000763,
0.4825476408004761,
0.30512115359306335,
-0.0944305956363678,
-0.42958396673202515,
-1.037482500076294,
-0.5022015571594238,
0.09386900067329407,
-0.07454986870288849,
0.27033883333206177,
0.4485752582550049,
-0.318233847618103,
1.1921137571334839,
-0.6719876527786255,
-0.5064404010772705,
-0.012849509716033936,
-0.025963740423321724,
0.1342383325099945,
0.4351027011871338,
0.12832830846309662,
-0.46400728821754456,
0.1108991727232933,
-0.6675436496734619,
-0.6473695635795593,
-0.33643510937690735,
-0.3959542512893677,
-0.4247826039791107,
0.13453462719917297,
0.46173638105392456,
-0.7174111604690552,
0.4138033092021942,
0.2610907554626465,
-0.44620659947395325,
0.6541332006454468,
-0.11481081694364548,
-0.05090002715587616,
-0.7628926038742065,
-0.1891387701034546,
0.11186854541301727,
0.047232501208782196,
-0.09537432342767715,
-0.4579169452190399,
-0.10901474207639694,
0.29417169094085693,
-0.0577976368367672,
0.6484622359275818,
-0.40334150195121765,
-0.0006526644574478269,
-0.29722681641578674,
0.4540835916996002,
-0.07396973669528961,
0.32728850841522217,
0.1675695776939392,
0.541104793548584,
0.4478568434715271,
-0.649560272693634,
0.08465052396059036,
0.38377320766448975,
-0.4570082128047943,
0.9945923089981079,
-0.5748932361602783,
-0.003572652116417885,
-0.40777286887168884,
0.5593892335891724,
-0.8582561612129211,
-0.06508023291826248,
0.21340157091617584,
-0.254036009311676,
-0.21319498121738434,
-0.1904909312725067,
-0.25974738597869873,
-0.5431023240089417,
-0.40471649169921875,
0.4359382390975952,
0.3850403428077698,
-0.5138845443725586,
0.5299463272094727,
0.4448460042476654,
-0.38856038451194763,
-0.791652262210846,
-0.8002845644950867,
0.08151523023843765,
-0.3728841543197632,
-0.38839539885520935,
0.2656267583370209,
-0.43502336740493774,
-0.49446621537208557,
-0.21419048309326172,
-0.15121568739414215,
0.23975205421447754,
0.06973744928836823,
0.5335935354232788,
0.48280519247055054,
0.25448551774024963,
0.18743596971035004,
-0.021552057936787605,
-0.23976895213127136,
0.3825559914112091,
-0.5253878831863403,
0.5755103230476379,
0.22656245529651642,
-0.5995498299598694,
0.04497760534286499,
0.055658940225839615,
0.6132839918136597,
-0.34304991364479065,
0.32564952969551086,
0.31763437390327454,
-0.37554001808166504,
-0.2467833012342453,
-1.1275529861450195,
-0.2594994604587555,
-0.44703713059425354,
0.2664046585559845,
-0.20297688245773315,
-0.8086639046669006,
0.3729875385761261,
-0.0701322853565216,
0.00882566999644041,
0.1627865731716156,
0.9556448459625244,
0.08945504575967789,
0.9527140259742737,
0.19813168048858643,
-0.3642001152038574,
0.504722535610199,
-0.003097178414463997,
-0.059223275631666183,
-0.7299231290817261,
-0.07816912233829498,
-0.32011130452156067,
-0.27917036414146423,
-0.4389660656452179,
-0.681169331073761,
0.3002777099609375,
-0.1377953588962555,
-0.39266109466552734,
-0.34990745782852173,
-0.5212863087654114,
0.5292539596557617,
0.6500834822654724,
0.25029081106185913,
0.30193376541137695,
-0.1118914783000946,
-0.13980244100093842,
-0.14867927134037018,
-0.6193469762802124,
-0.6623084545135498,
1.1416009664535522,
0.28845012187957764,
1.0890275239944458,
-0.23334887623786926,
0.49504536390304565,
0.6786139607429504,
0.24587300419807434,
-0.8420507311820984,
0.5646507740020752,
0.3839707374572754,
-1.0329318046569824,
-0.3155752122402191,
-0.40761420130729675,
-0.8204513192176819,
0.27617961168289185,
-0.4456791281700134,
-0.5318218469619751,
0.2690909206867218,
0.23351015150547028,
-0.43481335043907166,
0.07769613713026047,
-0.4531000554561615,
0.5699487924575806,
-0.44923660159111023,
-0.7239493727684021,
-0.4332376718521118,
-0.34750896692276,
0.36277738213539124,
-0.26023924350738525,
0.41834282875061035,
-0.40005818009376526,
0.004403289407491684,
0.8781857490539551,
0.2274283617734909,
0.9858586192131042,
-0.36615991592407227,
-0.28467103838920593,
0.31112033128738403,
0.23052667081356049,
0.6752903461456299,
0.30849510431289673,
-0.30354782938957214,
0.1457442343235016,
-0.19532404839992523,
-0.5565796494483948,
-0.40279674530029297,
0.7351899743080139,
-0.588731586933136,
-0.7786823511123657,
-0.4478635787963867,
-0.6440709829330444,
-0.3027426600456238,
0.13745693862438202,
0.19139471650123596,
0.07274257391691208,
-0.5020357966423035,
-0.13345956802368164,
0.7713815569877625,
-0.24571733176708221,
0.34435877203941345,
0.5480220317840576,
-0.00761856883764267,
-0.4765305519104004,
0.285489559173584,
0.15488697588443756,
0.18179550766944885,
-0.03834400698542595,
0.3277481496334076,
-0.2081567645072937,
-0.4243357181549072,
-0.20954705774784088,
0.06690288335084915,
-0.7795044779777527,
-0.02294285222887993,
-0.3382822275161743,
0.30539485812187195,
-0.3236457407474518,
-0.29179126024246216,
-0.19420145452022552,
-0.29273131489753723,
-0.0260281004011631,
-0.3738901913166046,
0.33400389552116394,
0.7856839299201965,
0.12183684855699539,
0.36766570806503296,
-0.31953006982803345,
0.24032710492610931,
0.24238401651382446,
0.30263635516166687,
0.05132784694433212,
-0.25873714685440063,
-0.1350586712360382,
-0.058982186019420624,
-0.27965259552001953,
-0.6908599734306335,
0.09102855622768402,
-0.524309515953064,
0.6125656962394714,
0.5156340003013611,
0.357160359621048,
0.4210578203201294,
-0.30144333839416504,
0.7099655866622925,
0.1457042098045349,
-0.9231904149055481,
0.45974841713905334,
-0.35569173097610474,
0.40628913044929504,
0.728019118309021,
0.29381996393203735,
-0.49334391951560974,
-0.17819905281066895,
-0.4981553852558136,
-0.7327554821968079,
0.6208001971244812,
0.06494512408971786,
-0.20805050432682037,
-0.14801466464996338,
0.3977663516998291,
0.03140226751565933,
0.20544059574604034,
-0.7190156579017639,
-0.15446737408638,
0.055068209767341614,
-0.26308581233024597,
-0.21070708334445953,
-0.398904412984848,
-0.27015385031700134,
-0.07908764481544495,
0.6818527579307556,
-0.19140145182609558,
-0.07311898469924927,
0.4371870160102844,
-0.3467594385147095,
-0.16109324991703033,
0.45233991742134094,
0.3010101020336151,
0.47739550471305847,
-0.09956872463226318,
0.19643016159534454,
0.570844829082489,
-0.4497600197792053,
0.1405348777770996,
0.03368478640913963,
-0.29586946964263916,
-0.475210964679718,
0.20078004896640778,
0.5091591477394104,
0.17420694231987,
-0.8638952374458313,
0.46913596987724304,
0.08023951202630997,
0.048087552189826965,
-0.4796784222126007,
-0.10191965103149414,
0.10002145916223526,
0.2926379144191742,
0.31941157579421997,
-0.047830015420913696,
0.06927350908517838,
-0.23848077654838562,
0.0232552383095026,
0.6987043619155884,
-0.5472270846366882,
0.10735782980918884,
0.4902828335762024,
0.3878362774848938,
0.02180102840065956,
0.385741263628006,
0.14007970690727234,
-0.4254678785800934,
0.46713921427726746,
0.3354770839214325,
0.8773166537284851,
-0.1457710862159729,
0.0296489205211401,
0.054785750806331635,
0.5187488794326782,
-0.08280474692583084,
0.12486911565065384,
0.02041100338101387,
-0.8608206510543823,
-0.34344449639320374,
-0.33884701132774353,
-0.49292340874671936,
0.15089541673660278,
-0.6904198527336121,
0.386282354593277,
-0.5670750141143799,
-0.6263719201087952,
-0.13931618630886078,
-0.035041920840740204,
-0.8630548119544983,
0.14942336082458496,
0.31714141368865967,
0.8819556832313538,
-0.620829701423645,
0.6045291423797607,
0.5638594031333923,
-0.27191802859306335,
-0.1120322048664093,
0.24873289465904236,
0.1293085664510727,
-0.9122639298439026,
0.6426246762275696,
0.11826617270708084,
-0.3541504740715027,
-0.2228335291147232,
-0.4751252233982086,
-0.7885595560073853,
0.9917091131210327,
0.5053274035453796,
-0.6552755832672119,
-0.2744733989238739,
0.11314480751752853,
0.0300153698772192,
-0.25861579179763794,
0.5663384795188904,
0.7453997731208801,
0.8680192232131958,
-0.2322673499584198,
-0.5918826460838318,
0.19101965427398682,
0.391905277967453,
-0.13025502860546112,
-0.007867320440709591,
-0.6471775770187378,
0.7068005800247192,
-0.20217005908489227,
0.1745355725288391,
-0.4940580725669861,
0.3901171088218689,
0.5289797782897949,
0.3071894347667694,
0.7108022570610046,
0.3198835849761963,
1.03791344165802,
0.1499183028936386,
0.6402192711830139,
-0.2600701153278351,
0.1402544528245926,
1.3366001844406128,
-0.6490988731384277,
0.4370339512825012,
0.6694234013557434,
0.1642257422208786,
0.47929757833480835,
0.575508713722229,
-0.028553055599331856,
0.1325017213821411,
0.6245479583740234,
-0.2136792540550232,
-0.5704452991485596,
-0.32601112127304077,
-0.02027842588722706,
0.3624461591243744,
0.5435180068016052,
-0.2515334486961365,
-0.05685855820775032,
0.10277026891708374,
0.29668882489204407,
0.09735383093357086,
-0.4376527965068817,
0.5682302713394165,
0.0500299446284771,
-0.9241868853569031,
0.35137906670570374,
-0.2420847862958908,
1.0149967670440674,
-0.5584021806716919,
0.2506188750267029,
-0.04588410630822182,
0.5343511700630188,
-0.15405507385730743,
-0.8708557486534119,
-0.21791429817676544,
0.05913444235920906,
-0.529312014579773,
-0.26671844720840454,
0.770725667476654,
-0.1598849892616272,
-0.37445470690727234,
0.6473627090454102,
0.661008894443512,
-0.18345555663108826,
-0.47108447551727295,
-0.8132311701774597,
0.0629902333021164,
-0.06538120657205582,
-0.4674891233444214,
0.0724577084183693,
0.2817431390285492,
-0.4799578785896301,
0.8833752870559692,
0.5073891878128052,
0.08008819818496704,
-0.10085758566856384,
0.07879345118999481,
0.6603192687034607,
-0.9182500839233398,
-0.3929283320903778,
-1.031813621520996,
0.05358084291219711,
-0.21433481574058533,
-0.2681361436843872,
0.8243131041526794,
0.505662739276886,
0.7174745202064514,
-0.08350235968828201,
1.194040060043335,
0.3385198712348938,
0.2776419520378113,
-0.45285049080848694,
0.573208212852478,
-0.04106895253062248,
0.2526153028011322,
-0.3167790174484253,
-0.7566033005714417,
-0.04989685118198395,
0.42806369066238403,
-0.8010283708572388,
0.24005788564682007,
0.3925189971923828,
0.8199300765991211,
0.15691930055618286,
-0.024952754378318787,
0.1411963403224945,
0.13536223769187927,
0.3018077313899994,
0.6136412620544434,
1.1078569889068604,
0.2667218744754791,
0.5613856911659241,
0.11521009355783463,
-0.5060725212097168,
-0.3204803168773651,
-0.9979428648948669,
-1.1052813529968262,
-0.09907068312168121,
-0.15164893865585327,
-0.3302195370197296,
0.17160674929618835,
1.2937753200531006,
0.7253438830375671,
-0.6111985445022583,
-0.32423925399780273,
0.031250905245542526,
0.34645622968673706,
-0.0116164181381464,
-0.242977112531662,
0.1611660122871399,
-0.24735982716083527,
-0.4735315442085266,
0.21823175251483917,
0.03249373286962509,
-0.03736363723874092,
-0.4487542510032654,
-0.18391115963459015,
-0.11720303446054459,
0.6331577897071838,
0.5605289340019226,
-0.2710677683353424,
-0.7877119779586792,
-0.29039642214775085,
-0.15880417823791504,
-0.12038151919841766,
-0.008973411284387112,
0.9771182537078857,
-0.9433732032775879,
0.32523399591445923,
0.36605942249298096,
0.45598793029785156,
0.5617740750312805,
-0.017051633447408676,
0.5529215931892395,
-0.4025222659111023,
0.07295669615268707,
0.2652146816253662,
0.37005695700645447,
0.36915141344070435,
-0.5295303463935852,
0.41644087433815,
0.115086130797863,
-0.6030514240264893,
-0.47935470938682556,
0.38042736053466797,
-0.8948462009429932,
-0.5011689066886902,
1.2964333295822144,
0.2670305371284485,
-0.05048272758722305,
-0.13711227476596832,
-0.7520866394042969,
0.1640612930059433,
-0.6602410078048706,
0.9475278258323669,
0.9216122627258301,
-0.09618652611970901,
0.18567614257335663,
-0.5920392274856567,
0.6094889640808105,
0.7417719960212708,
-0.7287082076072693,
0.6486877202987671,
0.7709329724311829,
0.2979380488395691,
-0.047958411276340485,
0.5440086722373962,
0.0396132729947567,
-0.007961536757647991,
-0.33309224247932434,
0.5349839329719543,
0.06704796105623245,
-0.19276855885982513,
-0.6035670638084412,
-0.05998334288597107,
0.26785027980804443,
0.012831289321184158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15951v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15951v1
|
GreenLLaMA: A Framework for Detoxification with Explanations
| 2024-02-25T01:56:47 | 2024-02-25T01:56:47 |
Md Tawkat Islam Khondaker, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed, Laks V. S. Lakshmanan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Prior works on detoxification are scattered in the sense that they do not
cover all aspects of detoxification needed in a real-world scenario. Notably,
prior works restrict the task of developing detoxification models to only a
seen subset of platforms, leaving the question of how the models would perform
on unseen platforms unexplored. Additionally, these works do not address
non-detoxifiability, a phenomenon whereby the toxic text cannot be detoxified
without altering the meaning. We propose GreenLLaMA, the first comprehensive
end-to-end detoxification framework, which attempts to alleviate the
aforementioned limitations. We first introduce a cross-platform pseudo-parallel
corpus applying multi-step data processing and generation strategies leveraging
ChatGPT. We then train a suite of detoxification models with our cross-platform
corpus. We show that our detoxification models outperform the SoTA model
trained with human-annotated parallel corpus. We further introduce explanation
to promote transparency and trustworthiness. GreenLLaMA additionally offers a
unique paraphrase detector especially dedicated for the detoxification task to
tackle the non-detoxifiable cases. Through experimental analysis, we
demonstrate the effectiveness of our cross-platform corpus and the robustness
of GreenLLaMA against adversarial toxicity.
|
[
-0.0303010456264019,
-0.8260782361030579,
0.8673091530799866,
0.07141481339931488,
-0.14663949608802795,
-0.03430107980966568,
-0.13987517356872559,
-0.44508787989616394,
0.1500844806432724,
0.33013877272605896,
-0.6668808460235596,
-0.9232054352760315,
-0.5991875529289246,
0.06289445608854294,
-0.6421107053756714,
1.2820661067962646,
0.1594439446926117,
-0.026647403836250305,
0.1536988615989685,
-0.00880429707467556,
-0.28583845496177673,
-0.1783236712217331,
-0.7395159602165222,
-0.3589971661567688,
0.7907247543334961,
0.4802442193031311,
0.936340868473053,
0.06825731694698334,
0.18946045637130737,
0.17907026410102844,
-0.04480239376425743,
0.0038388557732105255,
-0.8073782920837402,
-0.06205899268388748,
-0.45174169540405273,
-0.7366819381713867,
0.08428842574357986,
0.09556171298027039,
0.17684714496135712,
0.24237790703773499,
-0.11100441217422485,
-0.05035513639450073,
-0.19318853318691254,
0.5975636839866638,
-0.7436455488204956,
-0.1435645967721939,
-0.6265836358070374,
0.4402002990245819,
-0.029524926096200943,
-0.40608933568000793,
-0.286611407995224,
-0.4444931447505951,
-0.1757558435201645,
-0.8179254531860352,
-0.2279721051454544,
-0.011941046454012394,
1.0159435272216797,
0.3832528591156006,
-0.19186607003211975,
-0.19215510785579681,
-0.6408660411834717,
0.6052945256233215,
-0.6353706121444702,
0.30699285864830017,
0.31603187322616577,
0.4666566550731659,
-0.12178339064121246,
-0.8143322467803955,
-0.6071780323982239,
-0.3702872097492218,
0.0922832265496254,
0.4567742943763733,
-0.22869709134101868,
0.00452102767303586,
-0.321971595287323,
0.3609342575073242,
-0.774303138256073,
-0.05161798372864723,
-0.5767461657524109,
-0.2922065854072571,
0.2091127336025238,
0.10733289271593094,
0.8501412272453308,
0.14423394203186035,
-0.800001323223114,
0.24854479730129242,
-0.8492293357849121,
-0.4357418119907379,
0.4351973831653595,
0.19960889220237732,
0.023187527433037758,
0.2941981554031372,
-0.029964599758386612,
-0.05439170449972153,
-0.20896285772323608,
0.32096758484840393,
0.027323158457875252,
-0.46175655722618103,
-0.30950069427490234,
0.09554663300514221,
0.8086022138595581,
0.6405525803565979,
0.03131318837404251,
-0.597099244594574,
0.34774208068847656,
0.0575251579284668,
0.5076557993888855,
-1.1605656147003174,
-0.542165219783783,
0.7642630934715271,
-0.6816962361335754,
-0.3165435492992401,
-0.3476283550262451,
-1.077251672744751,
-0.3063502311706543,
-0.07574132829904556,
0.39017724990844727,
-0.6339235305786133,
-0.5280935764312744,
0.2745581865310669,
-0.3137577474117279,
-0.09017529338598251,
0.39080163836479187,
-0.6851038336753845,
0.23738469183444977,
0.6338732838630676,
1.2116608619689941,
-0.1357281506061554,
-0.03451385349035263,
-0.3643460273742676,
0.08761230856180191,
-0.3262976109981537,
0.7506745457649231,
-0.7637110352516174,
-0.23487916588783264,
-0.09158990532159805,
-0.022572414949536324,
-0.020602941513061523,
-0.6222454309463501,
0.6100664138793945,
-0.46711045503616333,
0.24211877584457397,
-0.42891836166381836,
-0.3059060275554657,
-0.61855548620224,
0.3395794928073883,
-0.25799813866615295,
0.7575230002403259,
-0.19443035125732422,
-0.830017626285553,
0.11816681176424026,
-0.7548955678939819,
0.001611977000720799,
0.10900955647230148,
0.13729339838027954,
-0.10778061300516129,
0.06150045245885849,
-0.28402867913246155,
0.2317672222852707,
-0.32525891065597534,
0.34693050384521484,
-0.5990707278251648,
-0.4894184172153473,
-0.044733926653862,
-0.3649226725101471,
1.0794403553009033,
0.7324787378311157,
-0.3161073625087738,
0.48546120524406433,
-0.5240879058837891,
0.1913985311985016,
-0.006958812475204468,
-0.1871270090341568,
-0.37520745396614075,
-0.29161903262138367,
0.6264569759368896,
0.5489572286605835,
0.28182297945022583,
-0.5743374824523926,
-0.6364818811416626,
-0.11723307520151138,
0.6490548253059387,
0.5986478924751282,
0.09411906450986862,
-0.03867703676223755,
-0.4374774694442749,
0.7440678477287292,
-0.0078681455925107,
0.1969914734363556,
-0.057460103183984756,
-0.6143543720245361,
-0.2789771854877472,
-0.22468508780002594,
-0.1817939579486847,
0.777369499206543,
-0.3124431073665619,
0.2439940869808197,
-0.2071363627910614,
-0.8314853310585022,
0.006591056939214468,
0.2083759754896164,
0.573145866394043,
0.39619335532188416,
0.7733922600746155,
-0.012918626889586449,
-0.2601139545440674,
-1.0323339700698853,
-0.1382277011871338,
-0.2168252319097519,
-0.06377949565649033,
-0.06788666546344757,
0.6910022497177124,
-0.4369688928127289,
0.6366583704948425,
-0.32662928104400635,
-0.21959705650806427,
0.019239729270339012,
0.04870251193642616,
-0.003581584431231022,
0.3087373673915863,
0.4156824052333832,
-0.7632574439048767,
-0.34651902318000793,
0.06273096054792404,
-0.8683121800422668,
-0.24212534725666046,
-0.3462311327457428,
-0.4400489032268524,
-0.7307156324386597,
0.618423581123352,
-0.43311914801597595,
0.19505201280117035,
0.39009949564933777,
-0.022621920332312584,
0.5942683219909668,
-0.48296356201171875,
-0.0970781072974205,
-0.9213605523109436,
0.3843013346195221,
0.310962975025177,
-0.2820032238960266,
-0.8880832195281982,
0.4696294069290161,
0.13028943538665771,
-0.37024715542793274,
-0.6426129937171936,
0.4667937755584717,
-0.12203085422515869,
0.34160077571868896,
-0.45160359144210815,
0.1916833221912384,
0.12980599701404572,
0.43530380725860596,
0.32829222083091736,
0.5332017540931702,
0.2877507209777832,
-0.4488106966018677,
0.03738432750105858,
0.18471302092075348,
0.2045922875404358,
0.7463452219963074,
-0.678921639919281,
-0.1339765340089798,
-0.15481701493263245,
0.6082759499549866,
-0.9822080135345459,
0.0927058607339859,
0.8084633350372314,
-0.002464323304593563,
-0.04637157544493675,
-0.004733834881335497,
-0.5613974332809448,
-0.09735455363988876,
-0.345743328332901,
0.03588201105594635,
0.5016202926635742,
-0.6212276816368103,
0.11484944820404053,
0.4436640739440918,
0.036331307142972946,
-0.28334560990333557,
-0.6327390670776367,
0.5359522700309753,
-0.8098518252372742,
-0.37812942266464233,
0.48779383301734924,
-0.262555867433548,
-0.28091922402381897,
-0.29875004291534424,
-0.30213236808776855,
-0.20581547915935516,
0.3052750527858734,
0.26309633255004883,
-0.13044549524784088,
0.039342887699604034,
0.22931282222270966,
0.2342858463525772,
-0.29186052083969116,
0.3073776662349701,
-0.23144634068012238,
0.30931544303894043,
-0.259612500667572,
-0.23327895998954773,
-0.7221364974975586,
0.5386270880699158,
0.44597867131233215,
-0.06263300031423569,
0.6514108777046204,
0.7137411832809448,
-0.6244485974311829,
-0.17040905356407166,
0.02408532053232193,
0.08658622950315475,
-0.5004604458808899,
0.27929630875587463,
-0.0962332934141159,
-0.42326220870018005,
0.5454188585281372,
-0.3399190604686737,
0.22802503407001495,
0.336448609828949,
0.9214149713516235,
0.09421838074922562,
0.4840623140335083,
0.30778729915618896,
0.3620339035987854,
0.3294488191604614,
-0.022316038608551025,
0.35362210869789124,
-0.7054997682571411,
-0.40387213230133057,
-0.43200358748435974,
-0.41472408175468445,
-0.14534007012844086,
-0.5874526500701904,
0.16916528344154358,
0.13238491117954254,
-0.28545501828193665,
0.4220519959926605,
-0.6220355033874512,
0.5110288262367249,
0.30746275186538696,
0.2992457151412964,
0.25977209210395813,
-0.30975136160850525,
-0.355577290058136,
0.11594953387975693,
-0.3441390097141266,
-0.8224122524261475,
0.9931026101112366,
0.5907676815986633,
0.5593027472496033,
0.08242344111204147,
0.8965259790420532,
0.20577239990234375,
0.574403703212738,
-0.35920846462249756,
0.6100426912307739,
0.024863896891474724,
-0.9826732277870178,
-0.04888034984469414,
-0.20616872608661652,
-0.6127690672874451,
0.3897823989391327,
0.03396555408835411,
-0.9171092510223389,
0.27933913469314575,
-0.07215692102909088,
-0.5101445317268372,
0.267645001411438,
-0.8566406965255737,
0.9758132100105286,
-0.15942633152008057,
-0.6129796504974365,
-0.37580493092536926,
-0.8030931949615479,
0.6492050886154175,
-0.39539751410484314,
0.4713729918003082,
-0.3971344530582428,
-0.12398887425661087,
0.5508803725242615,
-0.7473638653755188,
0.8943904042243958,
-0.26805323362350464,
-0.4021633267402649,
0.2741206884384155,
0.07446692138910294,
0.2015269696712494,
0.4144574701786041,
-0.0779941976070404,
0.5631032586097717,
0.23232896625995636,
-0.29815417528152466,
-0.27830761671066284,
0.7589383721351624,
-0.43509912490844727,
-0.4514094293117523,
-0.21145452558994293,
-0.5695880055427551,
-0.09751763939857483,
0.33928897976875305,
0.18874168395996094,
-0.2771105170249939,
-0.19764314591884613,
0.01690499298274517,
0.6774564385414124,
-0.6630982756614685,
0.09797123819589615,
0.15487347543239594,
-0.35190749168395996,
-0.04709937050938606,
1.0232003927230835,
-0.23885835707187653,
0.2920066714286804,
0.6221097707748413,
0.46665453910827637,
-0.4661983549594879,
-0.9644523859024048,
-0.10042989253997803,
-0.1401194930076599,
-0.9387651681900024,
0.23201264441013336,
-0.8028407692909241,
-0.07744381576776505,
0.12494830787181854,
-0.03409035503864288,
-0.15454749763011932,
-0.20702342689037323,
-0.4256553649902344,
-0.30329492688179016,
0.3639194667339325,
0.28655752539634705,
-0.4118218421936035,
0.14653520286083221,
-0.8370976448059082,
0.5404261946678162,
-0.012933309189975262,
-0.061860308051109314,
-0.04739028960466385,
-0.19706937670707703,
-0.163320392370224,
0.1853358894586563,
-0.3530227243900299,
-1.2875815629959106,
0.43743857741355896,
0.25240740180015564,
0.6101744771003723,
0.6790118217468262,
0.16312187910079956,
0.7450304627418518,
-0.6324701309204102,
0.8036895394325256,
0.3512687683105469,
-0.7177838683128357,
0.6088219285011292,
-0.4697103798389435,
-0.05038502439856529,
0.805359423160553,
0.42767852544784546,
-0.8028505444526672,
-0.8714898228645325,
-0.3263675272464752,
-0.914384126663208,
0.2568495273590088,
0.4823729991912842,
0.2781902551651001,
-0.43693315982818604,
0.3731825351715088,
0.4832807183265686,
0.006769492756575346,
-0.5984029769897461,
0.0018188459798693657,
-0.5761547684669495,
-0.36516034603118896,
0.06088995188474655,
-0.03157621622085571,
-0.4635270833969116,
0.2238048017024994,
0.7270147204399109,
-0.04848707839846611,
0.21903777122497559,
0.035615287721157074,
-0.4333845376968384,
0.0023828446865081787,
0.41605520248413086,
0.5160444974899292,
0.7200300097465515,
-0.2541877329349518,
0.14083409309387207,
-0.07934635132551193,
-0.40205785632133484,
0.17439743876457214,
0.009012346155941486,
-0.11331053078174591,
-0.0646868348121643,
0.009121962822973728,
0.45667949318885803,
0.34613746404647827,
-0.8878988027572632,
0.08540919423103333,
-0.12985976040363312,
-0.3141452372074127,
-0.26579540967941284,
0.32782047986984253,
0.43346336483955383,
0.2974171042442322,
0.3349989354610443,
0.010933388955891132,
0.3933637738227844,
-0.6259797811508179,
0.303676575422287,
0.5721701383590698,
-0.39836716651916504,
-0.3130933344364166,
1.3107783794403076,
0.06264061480760574,
-0.08600310981273651,
0.2660738527774811,
0.12757498025894165,
-0.32261189818382263,
0.6330189108848572,
0.558411717414856,
0.8910996913909912,
0.2011968195438385,
0.5992267727851868,
0.3831689655780792,
0.32512277364730835,
0.10718824714422226,
0.2023133486509323,
-0.1666949838399887,
-0.37293541431427,
0.12863872945308685,
-0.6918745636940002,
-0.4007028341293335,
0.3271430730819702,
-0.5058817267417908,
-0.1124628335237503,
-0.8870092630386353,
0.07996779680252075,
0.12724971771240234,
-0.22425003349781036,
-0.30671849846839905,
0.22543089091777802,
0.1952986866235733,
0.9923799633979797,
-1.213195562362671,
0.6446906328201294,
0.49456122517585754,
-0.7998515963554382,
-0.217515230178833,
0.42036405205726624,
0.27843236923217773,
-0.9201882481575012,
0.7026869654655457,
0.6598502397537231,
-0.024520447477698326,
-0.1302834004163742,
-0.04245404526591301,
-0.45379799604415894,
0.9561008810997009,
0.45175936818122864,
-0.46403107047080994,
-0.21309559047222137,
-0.10751117765903473,
0.6967360973358154,
0.18400335311889648,
0.5621720552444458,
0.30460649728775024,
0.7841853499412537,
0.06686241179704666,
-0.44678065180778503,
0.4467979669570923,
-0.5316202640533447,
0.3056385815143585,
-0.18844954669475555,
-0.8110467791557312,
0.4653276205062866,
-0.21022778749465942,
-0.3097769320011139,
0.22260937094688416,
0.48734942078590393,
0.211661696434021,
0.23727473616600037,
0.38058412075042725,
0.8485156297683716,
0.9420329332351685,
0.09481576830148697,
0.8734775185585022,
-0.3859572410583496,
0.19981232285499573,
1.0851787328720093,
-0.4306759238243103,
0.6068761944770813,
0.5069509744644165,
-0.28792962431907654,
0.6510999798774719,
1.1770222187042236,
0.1230473518371582,
0.8307571411132812,
0.3703277111053467,
-0.37223130464553833,
-0.4382425844669342,
-0.010765565559267998,
-0.4410315454006195,
-0.070798859000206,
0.6117376089096069,
-0.5088382363319397,
-0.9123119115829468,
0.07156021147966385,
0.17752911150455475,
0.13016252219676971,
-0.050674133002758026,
0.40585216879844666,
0.2209518402814865,
-0.45952901244163513,
0.5689089894294739,
0.0972403734922409,
0.4854702055454254,
-0.5985835194587708,
0.056254494935274124,
-0.12717649340629578,
0.1790951043367386,
-0.3576277792453766,
-0.5122568011283875,
0.6531609296798706,
-0.1714978963136673,
0.08921662718057632,
-0.5235525965690613,
0.6059146523475647,
-0.4250372648239136,
-0.30316516757011414,
0.5120983719825745,
0.2952609658241272,
0.5556504130363464,
-0.13394762575626373,
-1.1055443286895752,
-0.22148455679416656,
-0.10476431995630264,
-0.12338005006313324,
0.5256341099739075,
0.3810180127620697,
0.00015008363698143512,
0.6281904578208923,
1.0324959754943848,
0.011754189617931843,
0.11610434204339981,
-0.19541628658771515,
0.545432984828949,
-0.40244194865226746,
-0.7188553810119629,
-0.9490878582000732,
0.36332058906555176,
0.05057327076792717,
-0.19208857417106628,
0.7581988573074341,
0.5509476065635681,
0.33050107955932617,
0.2197537124156952,
0.841999888420105,
0.17794319987297058,
0.07019738107919693,
-0.531443178653717,
1.0379836559295654,
-0.7850288152694702,
0.25309592485427856,
-0.06342361867427826,
-0.7883521318435669,
-0.24863697588443756,
0.7055574059486389,
-0.22706390917301178,
0.11380873620510101,
1.0256047248840332,
0.8426076769828796,
-0.0462784580886364,
0.4969438314437866,
0.16788050532341003,
0.23401083052158356,
0.537459671497345,
0.8592526316642761,
0.6677997708320618,
-0.1744743138551712,
0.6781654357910156,
-0.0529121458530426,
-0.2921723425388336,
-0.3038170635700226,
-0.9963585138320923,
-0.8690878748893738,
-0.3377578556537628,
-0.49370336532592773,
-0.37795552611351013,
0.3447057604789734,
0.42136630415916443,
0.6754550933837891,
-0.6481898427009583,
0.33064016699790955,
-0.6731176972389221,
0.13809660077095032,
-0.5084323883056641,
-0.21404138207435608,
0.18185579776763916,
-0.3454272449016571,
-0.7768486738204956,
0.6317448616027832,
0.5072293281555176,
-0.47036585211753845,
-0.4703860580921173,
-0.1101093590259552,
-0.3664368987083435,
0.020169047638773918,
0.16322866082191467,
0.64105623960495,
-0.731652557849884,
-0.3625589609146118,
-0.5560097694396973,
-0.025338465347886086,
0.13857097923755646,
0.30594027042388916,
-0.5446702241897583,
0.42083093523979187,
0.43464675545692444,
0.6849072575569153,
0.36574485898017883,
-0.25754314661026,
0.48744872212409973,
-0.22821611166000366,
-0.009953253902494907,
0.14304375648498535,
0.3373385965824127,
0.1805213838815689,
-0.5994114279747009,
0.4316934645175934,
0.09324245899915695,
-0.2090691328048706,
-0.6797100901603699,
0.11791232228279114,
-0.7211752533912659,
-0.5195253491401672,
1.3559963703155518,
-0.5728050470352173,
-0.2899751663208008,
-0.4737837016582489,
-0.02683483064174652,
0.17670226097106934,
-0.16985560953617096,
0.759937584400177,
0.7891092300415039,
0.1334448605775833,
-0.013272741809487343,
-0.8917465209960938,
0.03797958791255951,
0.32418742775917053,
-1.2965275049209595,
0.18272250890731812,
0.5046414136886597,
0.79686039686203,
0.259960412979126,
0.9023849964141846,
-0.3918013870716095,
0.3122144937515259,
-0.050296176224946976,
-0.3064170777797699,
-0.18776704370975494,
-0.29761698842048645,
-0.12982027232646942,
0.35098201036453247,
-0.558480441570282,
-0.30026569962501526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00810v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00810v1
|
Bootstrapping Cognitive Agents with a Large Language Model
| 2024-02-25T01:40:30 | 2024-02-25T01:40:30 |
Feiyu Zhu, Reid Simmons
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models contain noisy general knowledge of the world, yet are
hard to train or fine-tune. On the other hand cognitive architectures have
excellent interpretability and are flexible to update but require a lot of
manual work to instantiate. In this work, we combine the best of both worlds:
bootstrapping a cognitive-based model with the noisy knowledge encoded in large
language models. Through an embodied agent doing kitchen tasks, we show that
our proposed framework yields better efficiency compared to an agent based
entirely on large language models. Our experiments indicate that large language
models are a good source of information for cognitive architectures, and the
cognitive architecture in turn can verify and update the knowledge of large
language models to a specific domain.
|
[
-0.07513952255249023,
-0.6490626335144043,
0.8782353401184082,
0.17307955026626587,
0.11124306917190552,
0.18601641058921814,
-0.7737689018249512,
-1.0342732667922974,
0.1359253078699112,
0.47945964336395264,
-0.3371838331222534,
-0.19159695506095886,
-0.6143425703048706,
-0.4690806567668915,
-0.38511282205581665,
0.6531674265861511,
0.2178143858909607,
0.156746506690979,
-0.3151019215583801,
0.03696269169449806,
-0.48070189356803894,
-0.3966238796710968,
-0.8565270304679871,
-0.732919454574585,
0.3001549541950226,
0.12749378383159637,
1.0885919332504272,
0.44590985774993896,
0.08156267553567886,
0.5102657079696655,
0.18622879683971405,
0.14101049304008484,
-0.22779297828674316,
0.39314013719558716,
-0.4833616316318512,
-0.506019115447998,
-0.375520259141922,
-0.08049289882183075,
0.24653823673725128,
0.7212802767753601,
-0.21353469789028168,
0.21612432599067688,
0.10417971760034561,
0.4947188198566437,
-0.7538634538650513,
1.0096768140792847,
-0.5999775528907776,
-0.30915507674217224,
0.2020721137523651,
0.006092878058552742,
-0.6273449659347534,
-0.17817369103431702,
-0.12994630634784698,
-0.9490940570831299,
-0.1579880714416504,
-0.09399698674678802,
0.6813892126083374,
0.38376617431640625,
-0.2575954496860504,
-0.4359947741031647,
-1.0641348361968994,
0.8921655416488647,
-0.4265899658203125,
0.29993709921836853,
0.7237226963043213,
0.4981520473957062,
-0.09213396906852722,
-0.7435743808746338,
-0.44534334540367126,
-0.4676223397254944,
-0.0940137431025505,
-0.05014660954475403,
-0.1812514364719391,
-0.0995321124792099,
0.01648065820336342,
0.11722161620855331,
-0.10444697737693787,
0.24771516025066376,
-0.18671225011348724,
-0.271701455116272,
0.6251331567764282,
0.14589472115039825,
0.4889147877693176,
0.31178250908851624,
-0.21415795385837555,
-0.4267973005771637,
-0.19210462272167206,
-0.1242821142077446,
0.10927052050828934,
0.27825626730918884,
-0.048968665301799774,
0.2975764572620392,
-0.2600880265235901,
0.7157244086265564,
-0.048958610743284225,
0.02796379290521145,
0.18709275126457214,
0.020352216437458992,
-0.17992174625396729,
-0.07226662337779999,
0.5274508595466614,
0.40349721908569336,
0.6647798418998718,
-0.5616070032119751,
-0.5936101675033569,
0.339118093252182,
0.6456971764564514,
-0.6408401131629944,
-0.18026533722877502,
0.3868124783039093,
-0.2226906567811966,
-0.3660188615322113,
-0.19209295511245728,
-0.5059347748756409,
-0.4167877435684204,
-0.5574484467506409,
0.47165647149086,
-0.6217169165611267,
-0.43848514556884766,
0.3047277331352234,
-0.17387133836746216,
0.5290815830230713,
0.6550922393798828,
-1.1170819997787476,
0.6776537299156189,
0.9012722373008728,
0.5815178155899048,
0.11373767256736755,
-0.23243950307369232,
-0.5111525058746338,
0.22204017639160156,
-0.7763247489929199,
0.7437343001365662,
-0.6276348233222961,
0.09911859035491943,
0.15474730730056763,
0.08541028946638107,
0.015179756097495556,
-0.5646003484725952,
-0.020052215084433556,
-0.9618078470230103,
-0.0327124185860157,
-0.4463038742542267,
-0.40311485528945923,
-0.20242275297641754,
0.34156832098960876,
-0.7383068203926086,
0.9778023958206177,
0.3881177306175232,
-0.19580857455730438,
0.3701239228248596,
-0.6677955389022827,
-0.5965331792831421,
0.2785645127296448,
-0.2451101839542389,
0.061876751482486725,
0.029934201389551163,
0.1778937429189682,
0.7376577854156494,
-0.7156032919883728,
0.33907148241996765,
0.01143311895430088,
-0.35833540558815,
0.4682304859161377,
-0.04891607165336609,
0.9167888164520264,
0.42059919238090515,
-0.5140316486358643,
-0.006932960357517004,
-0.770699679851532,
0.06041589751839638,
0.2932799756526947,
-0.4546648859977722,
-0.4765681028366089,
0.12592412531375885,
0.1942114531993866,
0.06559360772371292,
0.32078126072883606,
-0.35467568039894104,
0.1215396597981453,
-0.10694083571434021,
0.49405235052108765,
0.8629807829856873,
-0.16353610157966614,
0.7386425733566284,
-0.7023561000823975,
0.41458043456077576,
-0.09087077528238297,
-0.03937521204352379,
0.028652293607592583,
-0.4180007576942444,
-0.603848934173584,
-0.6218624114990234,
0.3316071331501007,
0.2977903485298157,
-1.0274094343185425,
0.2639724314212799,
-0.30617865920066833,
-0.4718872606754303,
-0.41573747992515564,
0.07874833792448044,
0.298220694065094,
-0.031208496540784836,
0.287275493144989,
-0.38447707891464233,
-0.16491994261741638,
-0.6382668614387512,
-0.16581815481185913,
-0.2588880956172943,
-0.2360888421535492,
0.06834328174591064,
0.43095073103904724,
-0.044725123792886734,
0.5558779835700989,
-0.4287560284137726,
-0.060426369309425354,
-0.21631093323230743,
0.08093646913766861,
-0.18606017529964447,
0.7445822358131409,
0.5811842679977417,
-0.5920724272727966,
-0.21468375623226166,
0.2092071771621704,
-0.914493203163147,
0.1430380791425705,
-0.351620078086853,
-0.3288814127445221,
-0.059900712221860886,
0.7312453985214233,
-1.018932580947876,
0.1159418597817421,
0.22177773714065552,
-0.23595817387104034,
0.5017213821411133,
-0.2521948218345642,
0.0835072323679924,
-1.0135072469711304,
-0.03852096572518349,
-0.23382338881492615,
-0.338522732257843,
-0.5457392930984497,
0.584470808506012,
0.09965778142213821,
0.14677169919013977,
-0.22603739798069,
0.5263662338256836,
-0.9005934596061707,
-0.11398875713348389,
-0.3548922836780548,
-0.05367202311754227,
-0.1316736787557602,
0.7685604095458984,
0.19306014478206635,
0.5326180458068848,
0.7609217166900635,
-0.8475357294082642,
0.5200933218002319,
-0.0760907307267189,
-0.766325831413269,
0.4517485201358795,
-0.40462398529052734,
0.12057464569807053,
-0.12767520546913147,
0.34579524397850037,
-0.9060869812965393,
-0.4818820655345917,
0.18915240466594696,
-0.26337122917175293,
0.5292705297470093,
0.12216174602508545,
-0.7218378782272339,
-0.1119268387556076,
-0.1249747946858406,
0.4601779282093048,
0.7110724449157715,
-0.6101868748664856,
0.8967165350914001,
0.33713191747665405,
0.18056093156337738,
-0.47639089822769165,
-0.8888816237449646,
0.06573464721441269,
0.16074588894844055,
-0.43042659759521484,
0.14447946846485138,
0.03395560383796692,
-0.6254894137382507,
0.035539112985134125,
0.0160962026566267,
-0.20766673982143402,
0.1803501397371292,
0.36470723152160645,
0.104806087911129,
-0.46911147236824036,
0.5343369841575623,
-0.3426052927970886,
-0.14082397520542145,
0.2801668643951416,
-0.6721914410591125,
0.7157881259918213,
-0.04964949190616608,
-0.332912415266037,
-0.26249960064888,
0.11982480436563492,
1.0443898439407349,
-0.28103452920913696,
0.9846468567848206,
0.4064290523529053,
-0.5529954433441162,
-0.40306606888771057,
-0.8512078523635864,
-0.2388463020324707,
-0.489263117313385,
0.34879130125045776,
-0.3110343813896179,
-0.3977198004722595,
0.5131698846817017,
-0.1846476048231125,
0.18706762790679932,
0.23091381788253784,
0.5995298027992249,
0.11861983686685562,
0.47266924381256104,
0.6314406394958496,
-0.13372056186199188,
0.5021025538444519,
-0.2487034648656845,
-0.16298186779022217,
-0.637870728969574,
-0.3794092833995819,
-0.6759042143821716,
-0.4146268963813782,
-0.27341607213020325,
-0.8533354997634888,
-0.13913166522979736,
-0.5875839591026306,
-0.4379635155200958,
0.3899199664592743,
-0.4811060428619385,
0.45366331934928894,
0.6284809112548828,
0.25550922751426697,
0.38812056183815,
0.0194755457341671,
-0.09992953389883041,
0.41442668437957764,
-0.6405038237571716,
-0.5583136677742004,
0.966237485408783,
0.11434581875801086,
0.8634428381919861,
0.10999132692813873,
0.2553979456424713,
0.15875163674354553,
0.28663182258605957,
-0.8852302432060242,
0.718004047870636,
0.33657804131507874,
-0.8218597173690796,
-0.3982491195201874,
-0.30761706829071045,
-1.0952197313308716,
0.25528088212013245,
-0.3761017918586731,
-0.8554509878158569,
0.27958354353904724,
-0.074346162378788,
-0.11697700619697571,
0.4354434907436371,
-0.7624397277832031,
0.6719517707824707,
-0.09352696686983109,
-0.42993247509002686,
-0.47391363978385925,
-0.5905572772026062,
0.2989426553249359,
-0.17109085619449615,
0.4957641363143921,
0.111800916492939,
-0.32110854983329773,
0.6358595490455627,
-0.5860193967819214,
1.038774847984314,
-0.13618826866149902,
-0.21294820308685303,
0.4666033983230591,
0.2560507655143738,
0.6461907029151917,
-0.4520081579685211,
-0.16691304743289948,
0.06097356602549553,
-0.027766095474362373,
-0.7566138505935669,
-0.8473799228668213,
0.6123279333114624,
-0.9241034388542175,
-0.4962517321109772,
-0.3453062176704407,
-0.6688627004623413,
-0.41438770294189453,
0.0020759543403983116,
0.10665212571620941,
0.3480798900127411,
-0.3645583987236023,
0.19591480493545532,
0.4990991950035095,
-0.08220131695270538,
0.4063691794872284,
0.6889476776123047,
-0.1512707769870758,
0.22573323547840118,
0.6453344821929932,
0.24666471779346466,
0.4787912964820862,
0.5694290399551392,
-0.0285053588449955,
0.07427974790334702,
-0.29261085391044617,
-0.2624633014202118,
-0.009620044380426407,
-0.7081869840621948,
-0.11806853860616684,
-0.616762101650238,
-0.23214907944202423,
-0.09347447007894516,
-0.39152392745018005,
-0.7671422958374023,
-0.5516958832740784,
0.11776518821716309,
-0.1251647174358368,
0.24722468852996826,
1.0124605894088745,
-0.07178755104541779,
0.25765419006347656,
-0.3870600461959839,
0.26050934195518494,
0.6695906519889832,
0.2787908613681793,
0.6363298296928406,
-0.1711493581533432,
-0.5414185523986816,
0.05408669635653496,
-0.11488519608974457,
-0.8069714903831482,
0.015327495522797108,
-0.1182231530547142,
0.3902033865451813,
0.4465005099773407,
0.23687584698200226,
0.5879405736923218,
-0.3353053033351898,
0.9409245252609253,
0.2625197172164917,
-0.8516545295715332,
0.051011405885219574,
-0.26401370763778687,
0.5395401120185852,
0.2733851671218872,
0.1724083125591278,
-0.20127864181995392,
-0.6575960516929626,
-0.5889142751693726,
-0.8118454217910767,
0.7254910469055176,
0.20154374837875366,
0.3050664961338043,
-0.1222953349351883,
0.11129393428564072,
0.04445915296673775,
0.23874254524707794,
-0.5848729610443115,
0.18394450843334198,
-0.035751886665821075,
-0.15730270743370056,
-0.234353706240654,
-0.052535414695739746,
-0.26490727066993713,
-0.1509362906217575,
0.806613564491272,
-0.13965527713298798,
0.35931187868118286,
-0.08796293288469315,
-0.3980533182621002,
-0.3854232430458069,
0.27316707372665405,
0.09486756473779678,
0.5675524473190308,
0.14518098533153534,
0.35646215081214905,
0.1567336767911911,
-0.5085988640785217,
0.28822144865989685,
-0.27025938034057617,
-0.03369337320327759,
-0.3674677312374115,
0.7723780870437622,
0.44320061802864075,
0.5969173312187195,
-0.835848867893219,
0.5767284035682678,
0.07478353381156921,
-0.27729183435440063,
-0.33817827701568604,
0.26177889108657837,
0.5039816498756409,
0.6391423344612122,
0.3048105239868164,
0.34657061100006104,
-0.09783997386693954,
-0.895959198474884,
-0.035826802253723145,
0.5376821756362915,
-0.1333422064781189,
-0.3258165121078491,
0.6458571553230286,
-0.1633521020412445,
-0.21199733018875122,
0.7937107086181641,
-0.12473667412996292,
-0.2364310771226883,
0.7329007983207703,
0.5292320251464844,
0.7830146551132202,
-0.24217508733272552,
0.28464603424072266,
0.1700952649116516,
0.641552746295929,
-0.41002804040908813,
-0.10861684381961823,
-0.4604399502277374,
-0.8376085162162781,
-0.5401394963264465,
-0.5393884778022766,
-0.3183205723762512,
0.18968121707439423,
-0.7535122632980347,
-0.11825111508369446,
-0.6040380001068115,
-0.07920314371585846,
0.11248773336410522,
-0.08141004294157028,
-1.0150818824768066,
0.29144102334976196,
0.09518440067768097,
0.704359233379364,
-0.7140209078788757,
0.82891845703125,
0.9736276268959045,
-0.38489747047424316,
-1.0104318857192993,
0.03924553468823433,
-0.22296838462352753,
-1.1158630847930908,
0.5387763977050781,
-0.02210603468120098,
-0.32899078726768494,
-0.3440837860107422,
-0.898474395275116,
-0.8294737339019775,
1.2698765993118286,
0.6834331154823303,
-0.43231460452079773,
-0.16718541085720062,
-0.10218571871519089,
0.7435519099235535,
-0.4941076338291168,
0.19168253242969513,
0.3344322443008423,
0.5953584909439087,
0.2590731084346771,
-0.739652156829834,
0.60392826795578,
-0.2634833753108978,
-0.05644723400473595,
0.0004384940257295966,
-0.9360818862915039,
0.718580424785614,
-0.16012269258499146,
-0.16692063212394714,
0.15829795598983765,
0.7230172157287598,
-0.3781493306159973,
0.2843407392501831,
0.5949201583862305,
0.30548587441444397,
0.94864422082901,
0.13287292420864105,
1.0333412885665894,
-0.553209662437439,
-0.031826768070459366,
1.2575442790985107,
-0.24374069273471832,
0.8690433502197266,
0.2358701378107071,
0.05011548846960068,
0.7178746461868286,
0.32887351512908936,
0.31805041432380676,
0.32665616273880005,
0.21077607572078705,
-0.12280546128749847,
-0.6932458281517029,
0.1931954324245453,
-0.1819639652967453,
0.5870095491409302,
0.4151630997657776,
-0.19621476531028748,
-0.04518476501107216,
-0.015399398282170296,
0.1594027727842331,
0.15110571682453156,
-0.14511871337890625,
0.8546043038368225,
0.048682887107133865,
-1.0370216369628906,
0.610501229763031,
-0.007373429369181395,
0.15629081428050995,
-0.684751033782959,
0.04571421816945076,
0.2018195539712906,
0.17411048710346222,
-0.06970829516649246,
-0.4138800799846649,
0.1051594689488411,
-0.1906222701072693,
-0.0003889693471137434,
-0.32837384939193726,
0.6819398999214172,
-0.26408448815345764,
-0.21040382981300354,
0.6118539571762085,
0.7458935379981995,
0.2248731255531311,
-0.3471320569515228,
-0.40584734082221985,
0.06552828848361969,
-0.453678697347641,
-0.3887243866920471,
0.4768046736717224,
0.5448922514915466,
-0.1701437085866928,
0.720209002494812,
0.6500799655914307,
-0.04106311500072479,
-0.1971023827791214,
-0.29391542077064514,
1.0692075490951538,
-0.6838710904121399,
-0.59110426902771,
-0.6794434785842896,
0.40875720977783203,
-0.10282895714044571,
0.1556171029806137,
0.4162806272506714,
0.35241052508354187,
0.6570048332214355,
-0.2635625898838043,
0.6616726517677307,
-0.04329049214720726,
-0.0933569073677063,
-0.6498607993125916,
0.8001814484596252,
-0.5401869416236877,
0.41624557971954346,
-0.27556395530700684,
-1.0093742609024048,
0.0586865097284317,
0.7921978831291199,
-0.33541956543922424,
0.2170628160238266,
0.9249095916748047,
0.863907516002655,
-0.24338126182556152,
0.11344839632511139,
0.5604671239852905,
0.7106106877326965,
-0.002897708909586072,
0.6585752367973328,
0.907932698726654,
-0.1010051816701889,
0.16978707909584045,
-0.0052607981488108635,
-0.48667240142822266,
-0.15151283144950867,
-0.6185783743858337,
-0.8873386383056641,
-0.8754922151565552,
-0.4354958236217499,
-0.4983736276626587,
0.16640347242355347,
1.0540456771850586,
1.1490857601165771,
-0.5486278533935547,
-0.4279443621635437,
0.17064671218395233,
0.02627512998878956,
-0.8756763339042664,
-0.18449081480503082,
0.08835935592651367,
-0.6395642161369324,
-0.6108416318893433,
0.4453480541706085,
0.08074820041656494,
-0.22031979262828827,
-0.3170066773891449,
-0.12073736637830734,
-0.106866255402565,
0.7082236409187317,
0.7293953895568848,
0.17733195424079895,
-0.41418689489364624,
-0.34705740213394165,
-0.3617105782032013,
-0.3180098831653595,
-0.07347286492586136,
0.7932978272438049,
-0.8848522305488586,
0.44240570068359375,
0.06541898101568222,
0.7005133032798767,
0.8796634078025818,
-0.365184485912323,
0.6955761313438416,
-0.4184807538986206,
0.2925340235233307,
0.1346430480480194,
0.3537887930870056,
0.34977948665618896,
-0.5347569584846497,
0.5658771395683289,
-0.039158813655376434,
-0.5054081082344055,
-0.4478178322315216,
0.23574532568454742,
-1.1394437551498413,
-0.7180773019790649,
1.2233966588974,
-0.041099850088357925,
-0.624869167804718,
-0.18431320786476135,
-0.1464744210243225,
0.2731059491634369,
-0.4195937216281891,
0.843802273273468,
0.9194728136062622,
0.3436296880245209,
0.2981337904930115,
-0.6504634022712708,
0.3803671598434448,
0.38829395174980164,
-0.636993944644928,
0.13055549561977386,
0.5498605966567993,
0.42313656210899353,
0.3700624704360962,
0.8357852101325989,
-0.09942327439785004,
0.29902908205986023,
0.48984426259994507,
0.27195924520492554,
-0.06615835428237915,
-0.2886629104614258,
0.01534891128540039,
0.31898391246795654,
0.3205784261226654,
-0.29935887455940247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16906v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16906v6
|
Debug like a Human: A Large Language Model Debugger via Verifying Runtime Execution Step-by-step
| 2024-02-25T00:56:27 | 2024-06-06T06:01:41 |
Li Zhong, Zilong Wang, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are leading significant progress in code
generation. Beyond one-pass code generation, recent works further integrate
unit tests and program verifiers into LLMs to iteratively refine the generated
programs. However, these works consider the generated programs as an
indivisible entity, which falls short for LLMs in debugging the programs,
especially when the programs contain complex logic flows and data operations.
In contrast, when human developers debug programs, they typically set
breakpoints and selectively examine runtime execution information. The
execution flow and the intermediate variables play a crucial role in the
debugging process, yet they are underutilized in the existing literature on
code generation. In this study, we introduce Large Language Model Debugger
(LDB), a novel debugging framework that enables LLMs to refine their generated
programs with the runtime execution information. Specifically, LDB segments the
programs into basic blocks and tracks the values of intermediate variables
after each block throughout the runtime execution. This allows LLMs to
concentrate on simpler code units within the overall execution flow, verify
their correctness against the task description block by block, and efficiently
pinpoint any potential errors. Experiments demonstrate that LDB consistently
enhances the baseline performance by up to 9.8% across the HumanEval, MBPP, and
TransCoder benchmarks, archiving new state-of-the-art performance in code
debugging for various LLM selections.
|
[
-0.260127454996109,
-1.0403698682785034,
0.5217248797416687,
0.12554650008678436,
-0.2358665019273758,
0.318081259727478,
-0.2415621429681778,
-0.46061229705810547,
-0.23583966493606567,
0.802913248538971,
-0.3611000180244446,
-0.6296647787094116,
-0.3304623067378998,
-0.020583737641572952,
-0.28613895177841187,
0.7466329336166382,
0.08803167194128036,
-0.19302666187286377,
-0.02239052951335907,
0.17412212491035461,
-0.43648001551628113,
-0.46181318163871765,
-0.7049031853675842,
-0.40238556265830994,
0.2366921603679657,
0.2957577705383301,
0.6860222816467285,
0.6567464470863342,
0.38396942615509033,
0.31278228759765625,
0.003282726276665926,
0.0822334811091423,
-0.42138439416885376,
0.0791250616312027,
-0.1586284041404724,
-0.4114842414855957,
-0.45170560479164124,
-0.3214244544506073,
0.40422293543815613,
0.622312605381012,
-0.09164659678936005,
0.3386709988117218,
0.00925538595765829,
0.6691781878471375,
-0.40625712275505066,
0.018043946474790573,
-0.3822908401489258,
-0.03584130480885506,
-0.35404130816459656,
-0.2825795114040375,
-0.4990698993206024,
-0.4872375428676605,
-0.4118446111679077,
0.19329658150672913,
0.1500139832496643,
0.00488823838531971,
0.7424939274787903,
0.44033849239349365,
-0.5428056716918945,
-0.20454084873199463,
-0.7358079552650452,
0.6535646319389343,
-0.9053562879562378,
0.4503389298915863,
0.016305865719914436,
0.12783470749855042,
-0.34305381774902344,
-0.5077173113822937,
-0.5986931920051575,
-0.5645752549171448,
0.008692326955497265,
-0.5595427751541138,
-0.0767824575304985,
0.006341633852571249,
0.5212538838386536,
0.40789416432380676,
-0.5589902997016907,
0.35337191820144653,
-0.37392401695251465,
-0.14961430430412292,
0.4199351966381073,
0.281253457069397,
0.3715912997722626,
-0.2702352702617645,
-0.31393611431121826,
0.04272815212607384,
-0.9613434076309204,
0.09538789093494415,
0.5652316808700562,
0.17585627734661102,
-0.03163187578320503,
0.42161163687705994,
-0.1077016219496727,
0.9955868721008301,
-0.002595162019133568,
-0.05894305557012558,
0.11317282170057297,
-0.21434307098388672,
-0.1311427652835846,
0.013779183849692345,
0.6879730224609375,
0.22972877323627472,
0.4099588990211487,
-0.12059006839990616,
-0.2780047655105591,
-0.16511166095733643,
0.31931379437446594,
-1.058268427848816,
-0.23172207176685333,
0.28852179646492004,
-0.4016927182674408,
-0.4139178693294525,
-0.21539022028446198,
-0.587830126285553,
-0.5179360508918762,
-0.32646867632865906,
0.0905284509062767,
-0.40407755970954895,
-0.26400578022003174,
0.041349995881319046,
0.3784978985786438,
0.5451760292053223,
0.24678866565227509,
-0.7946094870567322,
0.03716152533888817,
0.7700637578964233,
0.611212968826294,
-0.07729317247867584,
-0.09913847595453262,
-0.8402606248855591,
0.20609430968761444,
-0.6803178787231445,
0.5950611233711243,
-0.35929587483406067,
-0.2500431537628174,
-0.22821514308452606,
-0.10412503033876419,
0.1084517389535904,
-0.8274281620979309,
0.061244167387485504,
-0.5019826889038086,
-0.42799270153045654,
-0.10303163528442383,
-0.5455032587051392,
0.010884043760597706,
0.3424903452396393,
-0.6885361075401306,
1.0206483602523804,
0.0795801430940628,
-0.6074091792106628,
0.12246416509151459,
-0.5171376466751099,
-0.36336398124694824,
0.0400250181555748,
-0.4954361319541931,
-0.1749679297208786,
0.27052199840545654,
-0.015055145137012005,
0.5167007446289062,
-0.6148403882980347,
0.3534374535083771,
-0.3240739703178406,
-0.4929005801677704,
0.1996912658214569,
-0.12803825736045837,
0.9245179891586304,
-0.019761720672249794,
-0.510327935218811,
0.1791311502456665,
-0.9451981782913208,
0.17486822605133057,
0.08918054401874542,
-0.6298247575759888,
-0.1521434187889099,
0.01697446033358574,
-0.2605462074279785,
0.19718438386917114,
0.2406269907951355,
-0.5769820213317871,
0.24525675177574158,
-0.09545621275901794,
0.25630810856819153,
0.9503574371337891,
0.017875488847494125,
-0.05051379278302193,
0.09764881432056427,
0.8785371780395508,
0.019040632992982864,
0.007943484000861645,
-0.3113411068916321,
-0.18225164711475372,
-0.6647157669067383,
-0.2498256266117096,
0.31343352794647217,
0.5745397806167603,
-0.5944153070449829,
0.6187025308609009,
-0.003989818040281534,
-0.4749053120613098,
-0.4454159438610077,
0.5135895013809204,
0.3926907479763031,
0.591179609298706,
0.03343068063259125,
0.08212227374315262,
-0.38267332315444946,
-0.9908003211021423,
-0.17327219247817993,
-0.3716508746147156,
-0.11847781389951706,
0.17189668118953705,
0.4336010217666626,
-0.48630601167678833,
0.7369989156723022,
-0.6867328882217407,
0.3115096986293793,
-0.6012822985649109,
0.14096170663833618,
0.22280444204807281,
0.5432662963867188,
0.40351206064224243,
-0.4372081756591797,
-0.22952613234519958,
-0.07291142642498016,
-0.5311715006828308,
-0.46664002537727356,
-0.24278464913368225,
-0.23917479813098907,
0.36298567056655884,
0.7732215523719788,
-0.34404411911964417,
0.269157737493515,
0.7566003203392029,
-0.7800037860870361,
0.8219922780990601,
-0.349818617105484,
0.08443333953619003,
-0.7047888040542603,
0.28196123242378235,
-0.36749082803726196,
-0.4370686411857605,
-0.18724465370178223,
0.21945969760417938,
0.20108099281787872,
-0.10509776324033737,
-0.17390985786914825,
0.4261793792247772,
-0.3229981064796448,
-0.1925390064716339,
-0.3300932049751282,
-0.23426735401153564,
0.084508515894413,
0.22993811964988708,
-0.21344035863876343,
0.6220902800559998,
0.5224161148071289,
-0.4473147690296173,
0.6945048570632935,
-0.3288078308105469,
-0.5216749906539917,
0.40828025341033936,
-0.9710222482681274,
0.3714597821235657,
-0.08536310493946075,
0.0983862653374672,
-1.0156303644180298,
-0.03686520457267761,
-0.14856278896331787,
-0.1480371057987213,
0.41088399291038513,
-0.08244255185127258,
-0.9588271379470825,
-0.35716161131858826,
-0.07754316926002502,
-0.027178004384040833,
0.6380766034126282,
-0.6672700643539429,
0.3606421649456024,
0.05958423763513565,
-0.08316555619239807,
-0.38393479585647583,
-0.535895049571991,
0.040841493755578995,
-0.17222805321216583,
-0.7792788147926331,
0.015502342954277992,
-0.3454028367996216,
-0.4656476676464081,
-0.4009340703487396,
-0.1801338940858841,
-0.19976375997066498,
0.3387768864631653,
0.19788235425949097,
0.47405290603637695,
-0.2070971131324768,
0.11252891272306442,
0.01843428798019886,
-0.18225786089897156,
0.2381652593612671,
0.26443415880203247,
0.5206705927848816,
-0.19432947039604187,
-0.4211153984069824,
-0.18447448313236237,
0.2199431210756302,
0.5858091711997986,
-0.3168996274471283,
0.6326308846473694,
0.7214794754981995,
-0.14854548871517181,
-0.45259326696395874,
-0.5123956799507141,
-0.21137674152851105,
-0.4633806645870209,
0.29375678300857544,
-0.4821583032608032,
-0.7890477776527405,
0.5784205198287964,
-0.2888873517513275,
0.046460699290037155,
0.055809859186410904,
0.480221152305603,
0.3859342038631439,
0.8173249959945679,
0.7238674163818359,
0.08421636372804642,
0.15283972024917603,
-0.07593526691198349,
0.309329628944397,
-0.8235225081443787,
-0.08379674702882767,
-0.5300834774971008,
-0.26084330677986145,
-0.36435380578041077,
-0.7021491527557373,
-0.0494966059923172,
0.6050106287002563,
-0.27251139283180237,
0.21656760573387146,
-0.3171524107456207,
0.7039574980735779,
0.34585145115852356,
0.007703515235334635,
0.44586414098739624,
-0.5334906578063965,
-0.17851842939853668,
-0.025956762954592705,
-0.2746066749095917,
-0.6958677768707275,
0.9072861075401306,
0.48118865489959717,
1.0859018564224243,
0.22495773434638977,
0.948326826095581,
0.29431813955307007,
0.2540101408958435,
-0.4900820255279541,
0.6529715657234192,
-0.06475905328989029,
-0.6364295482635498,
-0.1322557032108307,
-0.4479967951774597,
-0.5584192276000977,
0.2635122239589691,
0.3593854606151581,
-0.8476290702819824,
0.00020253151888027787,
0.45918023586273193,
-0.6241331100463867,
0.22044090926647186,
-0.672944188117981,
1.2283788919448853,
-0.2950226068496704,
-0.49428698420524597,
-0.27045896649360657,
-0.3697768449783325,
0.6023977398872375,
-0.3106185495853424,
0.08182309567928314,
-0.17641599476337433,
0.006017898675054312,
0.3936106860637665,
-0.47312742471694946,
0.8922992944717407,
-0.2706116735935211,
-0.6413848400115967,
0.26196566224098206,
0.476719468832016,
0.699386477470398,
0.047126248478889465,
-0.037289708852767944,
0.11495034396648407,
-0.16504471004009247,
-0.201070174574852,
-0.504372775554657,
0.9461735486984253,
-0.3047735393047333,
-0.5462132692337036,
-0.07772846519947052,
-0.29460060596466064,
-0.0460813045501709,
0.08992733061313629,
-0.10244643688201904,
0.5125640034675598,
0.015143206343054771,
0.34226781129837036,
0.7670757174491882,
-0.7493318915367126,
0.3758794665336609,
0.6969862580299377,
-0.46648165583610535,
0.13722628355026245,
0.48405206203460693,
-0.23468545079231262,
0.3505568206310272,
0.17593173682689667,
0.16372597217559814,
-0.06173548847436905,
-0.44894224405288696,
-0.5967350006103516,
0.16430483758449554,
-0.5852019786834717,
-0.3220868706703186,
-0.42542141675949097,
0.03213222697377205,
-0.14311926066875458,
-0.1787416636943817,
-0.650408923625946,
-0.056980520486831665,
-0.03391424939036369,
-0.14489780366420746,
0.1701393872499466,
0.6000567674636841,
-0.028848400339484215,
0.19666370749473572,
-0.811324417591095,
0.5776278972625732,
0.2795461118221283,
0.3346870243549347,
-0.02740328200161457,
-0.3551633656024933,
-0.22939984500408173,
-0.17065981030464172,
-0.29611319303512573,
-0.7748286128044128,
0.2422490417957306,
-0.0746142640709877,
0.29509514570236206,
0.38255757093429565,
0.05747561156749725,
0.7057257294654846,
-0.6461440920829773,
0.7898239493370056,
-0.009702702984213829,
-1.2299129962921143,
0.6490238308906555,
-0.2836141288280487,
0.39409002661705017,
0.16216203570365906,
-0.10166052728891373,
-0.19640283286571503,
-0.458259642124176,
-0.3665447235107422,
-0.9468830227851868,
0.6528127193450928,
-0.12696193158626556,
0.06469928473234177,
-0.2103184312582016,
0.2507137954235077,
0.1023954302072525,
0.11521467566490173,
-0.7017459869384766,
-0.06503932923078537,
0.30853188037872314,
-0.013543123379349709,
0.0076124537736177444,
-0.2565898299217224,
0.018646802753210068,
-0.11842646449804306,
0.32005575299263,
-0.1620887964963913,
0.04944940656423569,
-0.18854950368404388,
-0.2382524013519287,
-0.22974970936775208,
0.3129231631755829,
0.5138331651687622,
1.000718355178833,
-0.3987533152103424,
0.2961476743221283,
-0.10379388183355331,
-0.08972837775945663,
0.13983722031116486,
-0.07124003767967224,
0.055012453347444534,
0.06424310058355331,
0.4789031445980072,
0.7386745810508728,
0.07453955709934235,
-1.1759644746780396,
0.4136647880077362,
0.06558074802160263,
0.3214242160320282,
-0.3164721727371216,
0.3919961750507355,
0.38052991032600403,
0.5585408806800842,
0.24381130933761597,
-0.4307503402233124,
0.10974213480949402,
-0.5367615818977356,
0.04769901558756828,
0.2058274894952774,
0.03249865025281906,
-0.40046557784080505,
0.5932513475418091,
0.290622353553772,
-0.16090837121009827,
0.7595949172973633,
-0.07524199783802032,
-0.20922046899795532,
0.8157576322555542,
0.6532683372497559,
0.8906028866767883,
-0.3230002224445343,
0.05692623555660248,
0.3057682514190674,
0.40284401178359985,
0.10232754051685333,
0.3485238552093506,
-0.026844674721360207,
-0.49723321199417114,
-0.7967491149902344,
-0.8770722150802612,
-0.316670298576355,
0.25625449419021606,
-0.5511713624000549,
0.200887531042099,
-0.3614733815193176,
0.03894476965069771,
0.027720190584659576,
-0.17875611782073975,
-0.5472612977027893,
0.03726201504468918,
0.3807840049266815,
0.9337912797927856,
-0.5505653619766235,
1.0809252262115479,
0.5957726836204529,
-0.20265989005565643,
-0.6757581233978271,
0.04825105518102646,
-0.16968590021133423,
-0.4460463523864746,
1.2204642295837402,
0.3091365098953247,
-0.10464563220739365,
0.03386325761675835,
-0.3897057771682739,
-0.6422094106674194,
0.9466066360473633,
0.7724853754043579,
-0.744713544845581,
-0.08137267827987671,
0.0994902178645134,
0.4804215729236603,
-0.2547060251235962,
0.06222653388977051,
0.649318516254425,
0.3983784019947052,
-0.03934245929121971,
-0.7548992037773132,
0.4015958309173584,
0.020632989704608917,
0.25355589389801025,
0.3883284032344818,
-0.42064404487609863,
0.9015650749206543,
-0.4862977862358093,
0.24594423174858093,
-0.13463714718818665,
0.33552464842796326,
0.47554630041122437,
-0.17438837885856628,
0.4425674378871918,
0.3976190388202667,
0.5910981893539429,
0.030708180740475655,
1.1681004762649536,
-0.5272802710533142,
0.2283625453710556,
1.2313727140426636,
-0.32833653688430786,
0.8007174134254456,
0.4925040602684021,
-0.14697040617465973,
0.7350623607635498,
0.29695215821266174,
0.17516613006591797,
0.16039954125881195,
0.6242420673370361,
-0.1804465502500534,
-0.4469051957130432,
0.2942870259284973,
-0.24804818630218506,
0.6098029613494873,
0.201485738158226,
-0.5931401252746582,
-0.2891085743904114,
-0.0746232345700264,
0.1534840166568756,
-0.2508024275302887,
-0.11734301596879959,
0.4044228792190552,
-0.06941714137792587,
-0.4964810013771057,
0.8769477605819702,
0.19116321206092834,
0.39750561118125916,
-0.6268582940101624,
-0.18808886408805847,
-0.3874027132987976,
0.645974338054657,
-0.0720149427652359,
-0.6032751202583313,
0.5045645833015442,
0.31198355555534363,
-0.20171013474464417,
-0.2038835883140564,
0.6318910717964172,
-0.2884633243083954,
-0.18525131046772003,
0.4442656636238098,
0.28355494141578674,
0.2143343836069107,
-0.22744625806808472,
-0.5761135220527649,
0.5218380093574524,
0.33927613496780396,
-0.6046813726425171,
0.16333350539207458,
0.5534942746162415,
0.07041814178228378,
0.7217416763305664,
0.5199470520019531,
0.1466047763824463,
0.20875968039035797,
0.05556553974747658,
0.733006477355957,
-1.0450093746185303,
-0.340568870306015,
-1.2019935846328735,
0.6657429933547974,
-0.01787268929183483,
-0.1061241626739502,
0.7330300807952881,
0.5172528624534607,
0.612189531326294,
-0.20917946100234985,
0.6171526312828064,
-0.2863011360168457,
0.5265824198722839,
-0.414200097322464,
0.48979246616363525,
-0.15874823927879333,
0.5563773512840271,
-0.1755988895893097,
-0.9377491474151611,
-0.12731492519378662,
0.5806287527084351,
-0.029178353026509285,
0.010999790392816067,
0.48941224813461304,
0.8341075778007507,
0.061385855078697205,
-0.5759990811347961,
0.35160258412361145,
0.3033682405948639,
0.6741447448730469,
0.5329016447067261,
0.7231229543685913,
0.023260070011019707,
0.4615917205810547,
-0.13930219411849976,
-0.28997358679771423,
-0.18581877648830414,
-0.9475767016410828,
-0.982114851474762,
0.020313216373324394,
-0.5360209941864014,
-0.4481630325317383,
-0.026412026956677437,
0.6904817819595337,
0.6174342632293701,
-0.5447267293930054,
-0.46328338980674744,
-0.11505486816167831,
0.10953767597675323,
0.06263364851474762,
-0.28102079033851624,
0.1627037525177002,
-0.3777588903903961,
-0.7145658135414124,
0.29762038588523865,
0.24871155619621277,
-0.12373626232147217,
-0.7115140557289124,
-0.22795318067073822,
0.01680830679833889,
0.15461768209934235,
0.6775455474853516,
0.15422821044921875,
-0.6122816801071167,
-0.17489565908908844,
-0.41913729906082153,
-0.2322254478931427,
-0.2819536328315735,
0.7541640996932983,
-0.8324853777885437,
0.34687697887420654,
0.5145748257637024,
0.5695191621780396,
0.17480532824993134,
-0.007153695914894342,
0.6706556677818298,
-0.7597014904022217,
0.07025691866874695,
0.11740550398826599,
0.2804155647754669,
0.3244374990463257,
-0.39613091945648193,
0.5434119701385498,
-0.03467151150107384,
-0.6032811403274536,
-1.0424917936325073,
0.3781226873397827,
-0.6760894656181335,
-0.36724787950515747,
1.099177360534668,
-0.30788952112197876,
-0.26066985726356506,
0.2082493156194687,
-0.24110962450504303,
-0.014132794924080372,
-0.22825254499912262,
0.7144038081169128,
0.6067693829536438,
-0.24854157865047455,
-0.1696874052286148,
-0.6598943471908569,
0.3859530985355377,
-0.04222278669476509,
-1.0056871175765991,
0.48221778869628906,
0.7908830046653748,
0.46928760409355164,
0.02579675428569317,
0.5388638377189636,
-0.2038840800523758,
0.036364346742630005,
-0.06373520940542221,
0.5031235218048096,
-0.14545108377933502,
-0.11140228062868118,
-0.1998242884874344,
0.04754962772130966,
0.26231876015663147,
-0.13039740920066833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15938v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15938v3
|
Generalization or Memorization: Data Contamination and Trustworthy Evaluation for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-24T23:54:41 | 2024-05-31T17:49:03 |
Yihong Dong, Xue Jiang, Huanyu Liu, Zhi Jin, Bin Gu, Mengfei Yang, Ge Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG, cs.SE
|
Recent statements about the impressive capabilities of large language models
(LLMs) are usually supported by evaluating on open-access benchmarks.
Considering the vast size and wide-ranging sources of LLMs' training data, it
could explicitly or implicitly include test data, leading to LLMs being more
susceptible to data contamination. However, due to the opacity of training
data, the black-box access of models, and the rapid growth of synthetic
training data, detecting and mitigating data contamination for LLMs faces
significant challenges. In this paper, we propose CDD, which stands for
Contamination Detection via output Distribution for LLMs. CDD necessitates only
the sampled texts to detect data contamination, by identifying the peakedness
of LLM's output distribution. To mitigate the impact of data contamination in
evaluation, we also present TED: Trustworthy Evaluation via output
Distribution, based on the correction of LLM's output distribution. To
facilitate this study, we introduce two benchmarks, i.e., DetCon and ComiEval,
for data contamination detection and contamination mitigation evaluation tasks.
Extensive experimental results show that CDD achieves the average relative
improvements of 21.8\%-30.2\% over other contamination detection approaches in
terms of Accuracy, F1 Score, and AUC metrics, and can effectively detect
implicit contamination. TED substantially mitigates performance improvements up
to 66.9\% attributed to data contamination across various contamination setups.
In real-world applications, we reveal that ChatGPT exhibits a high potential to
suffer from data contamination on HumanEval benchmark.
|
[
-0.32726672291755676,
-1.0452759265899658,
0.7038230299949646,
-0.10524335503578186,
-0.2755633592605591,
0.05402850732207298,
-0.46242696046829224,
-0.30617010593414307,
-0.4975985586643219,
0.7389059066772461,
-0.2979094982147217,
-0.8954127430915833,
-0.7431502938270569,
-0.3309982717037201,
-0.6451659202575684,
1.0698761940002441,
-0.005603470373898745,
-0.27073249220848083,
-0.28942179679870605,
-0.10889402031898499,
-0.3808917999267578,
-0.7947566509246826,
-0.7407945990562439,
-0.3057000935077667,
0.3435552418231964,
0.34019914269447327,
0.710206925868988,
0.8665645122528076,
0.6137362718582153,
0.3308018147945404,
-0.32727861404418945,
0.2946730852127075,
-0.6882285475730896,
0.3693459630012512,
-0.27366241812705994,
-0.5330106616020203,
-0.37254342436790466,
-0.11046234518289566,
0.6234197020530701,
0.48052388429641724,
-0.20763447880744934,
-0.0792810320854187,
0.23336926102638245,
0.7522583603858948,
-0.8694279789924622,
0.16159212589263916,
-0.657796323299408,
0.007867333479225636,
-0.2813338041305542,
-0.3745275139808655,
-0.6259069442749023,
-0.448624849319458,
-0.1351424902677536,
-0.5880622863769531,
0.28243112564086914,
-0.15071767568588257,
0.8045816421508789,
0.38922375440597534,
-0.35130855441093445,
-0.22204245626926422,
-1.0955400466918945,
1.0628076791763306,
-0.5098592042922974,
0.33552515506744385,
0.5461680889129639,
0.4142100512981415,
-0.203988716006279,
-0.6211024522781372,
-0.45482173562049866,
-0.12849074602127075,
0.15565750002861023,
0.09581311047077179,
-0.2703135013580322,
-0.01268590148538351,
0.2511498034000397,
0.42140334844589233,
-0.4568297863006592,
0.17052727937698364,
-0.09440910816192627,
-0.32983529567718506,
0.551782488822937,
0.11754901707172394,
0.47391584515571594,
0.06781598180532455,
-0.5735138654708862,
-0.4310842454433441,
-1.077859878540039,
-0.35612455010414124,
0.4198512136936188,
0.049847375601530075,
-0.1815919429063797,
0.23913957178592682,
-0.12022176384925842,
0.32383427023887634,
-0.19835436344146729,
-0.06175317242741585,
0.24954213201999664,
-0.6638216376304626,
-0.4770587086677551,
-0.22835500538349152,
0.8687574863433838,
0.07775626331567764,
0.4967779219150543,
-0.1563422977924347,
-0.23938049376010895,
-0.0437358021736145,
0.2034907191991806,
-0.6561837196350098,
-0.4042198657989502,
0.310494601726532,
-0.21927426755428314,
-0.4349251389503479,
-0.053554732352495193,
-0.7058629393577576,
-0.5874788165092468,
-0.4495939612388611,
0.3662849962711334,
-0.47889646887779236,
-0.2887554168701172,
0.07710353285074234,
0.10999099910259247,
-0.374492347240448,
0.5507489442825317,
-0.8984501957893372,
0.2967086434364319,
1.007866621017456,
0.5838847160339355,
-0.34642812609672546,
0.09950035065412521,
-0.690118670463562,
0.420087993144989,
-0.30961892008781433,
0.7502148747444153,
-0.4928591549396515,
-0.467457115650177,
0.12187468260526657,
-0.27113664150238037,
0.04215151444077492,
-1.081822395324707,
0.9829900860786438,
-0.4553609788417816,
-0.12055905163288116,
-0.018576789647340775,
-0.7057206034660339,
-0.1088065430521965,
0.1507790982723236,
-0.7752589583396912,
1.1177046298980713,
-0.01701403222978115,
-1.1319719552993774,
0.5984074473381042,
-0.22377175092697144,
-0.2687115967273712,
0.12333674728870392,
-0.2346271425485611,
-0.5578974485397339,
-0.13721336424350739,
0.19375109672546387,
0.41896387934684753,
-0.0796726793050766,
0.4553714394569397,
-0.4606172740459442,
-0.4696134924888611,
0.26713132858276367,
-0.8917683362960815,
0.7529051899909973,
0.3300115764141083,
-0.2967902719974518,
0.19477693736553192,
-0.8739684224128723,
0.16257262229919434,
-0.16364623606204987,
-0.47306394577026367,
-0.5870060920715332,
0.03142454847693443,
0.12799270451068878,
-0.03358583524823189,
-0.1459987461566925,
-0.35014259815216064,
-0.11915028095245361,
-0.02488921582698822,
0.15647631883621216,
1.0583772659301758,
0.22244112193584442,
0.2773820161819458,
-0.518062949180603,
0.4044296145439148,
0.39977988600730896,
0.31788647174835205,
-0.15589377284049988,
-0.31496667861938477,
-0.6760178208351135,
-0.6311765313148499,
0.36460691690444946,
0.48741158843040466,
-0.6693992614746094,
0.6711214780807495,
-0.4446181356906891,
-0.5086589455604553,
-0.22076430916786194,
0.349592000246048,
0.4436478316783905,
0.35399171710014343,
0.20643892884254456,
-0.19104453921318054,
-0.30341437458992004,
-0.7572183012962341,
-0.06954321265220642,
0.021911880001425743,
-0.3644273281097412,
0.3982882499694824,
0.4257557690143585,
-0.30175453424453735,
0.7787668108940125,
-0.4320985674858093,
-0.4147908687591553,
-0.022769834846258163,
-0.009681661613285542,
0.026417750865221024,
0.596089780330658,
0.20435941219329834,
-0.6095677018165588,
-0.438244491815567,
0.06287491321563721,
-0.7514345645904541,
-0.13575884699821472,
0.012752535752952099,
-0.1798657774925232,
0.10762964189052582,
0.6837487816810608,
-0.42489883303642273,
0.3540383577346802,
0.5449733138084412,
0.04824639484286308,
0.48767364025115967,
-0.47970688343048096,
0.07279473543167114,
-0.7157198190689087,
0.1914212852716446,
-0.06786216050386429,
-0.39813748002052307,
-0.6610389947891235,
0.1342681497335434,
0.21183569729328156,
0.29599612951278687,
-0.5343661308288574,
0.32489731907844543,
-0.13967850804328918,
0.07374405115842819,
0.02326936647295952,
0.5533440113067627,
0.06588322669267654,
-0.02900402620434761,
-0.06473258882761002,
0.7624387145042419,
0.383767306804657,
-0.5563207864761353,
0.326694518327713,
0.21471895277500153,
-0.6016741991043091,
0.4785883128643036,
-0.6008254885673523,
0.2616564929485321,
0.12697023153305054,
0.34928858280181885,
-1.0280530452728271,
0.11049597710371017,
0.28467679023742676,
-0.1854172796010971,
0.4316663444042206,
-0.05840335786342621,
-1.0091636180877686,
0.11609040200710297,
-0.33449819684028625,
0.4245956838130951,
0.42146313190460205,
-0.9475904107093811,
0.003229830414056778,
0.1561727374792099,
0.05540328472852707,
-0.6218570470809937,
-0.5893293023109436,
-0.07204660773277283,
-0.45324990153312683,
-0.7701594829559326,
-0.06873670965433121,
-0.2633599638938904,
-0.2765677869319916,
-0.21172980964183807,
-0.2387153059244156,
-0.23664268851280212,
0.3871228098869324,
0.3477972745895386,
0.19856920838356018,
-0.02525748498737812,
0.25158774852752686,
0.03933645039796829,
-0.09772602468729019,
0.08160356432199478,
0.23462717235088348,
0.6003903746604919,
0.42829832434654236,
-0.48675307631492615,
-0.3548562228679657,
0.04261094704270363,
0.2916194796562195,
-0.07167588174343109,
0.584936261177063,
0.49463191628456116,
-0.37044334411621094,
-0.6544583439826965,
-0.5260210037231445,
-0.02390521578490734,
-0.5703375339508057,
0.28345784544944763,
-0.212776318192482,
-0.39617589116096497,
0.3372412919998169,
-0.18529808521270752,
-0.20751379430294037,
0.20379097759723663,
0.4775101840496063,
0.002456097165122628,
0.6662343144416809,
0.4852220416069031,
-0.030214916914701462,
0.3506598472595215,
-0.1708841472864151,
0.11635276675224304,
-0.8648856282234192,
-0.08172035217285156,
-0.6150466203689575,
0.07672085613012314,
-0.5097611546516418,
-0.6386504769325256,
0.22300508618354797,
0.02257496863603592,
-0.14803223311901093,
0.05286550894379616,
-0.3671436607837677,
0.6171921491622925,
0.5523295402526855,
0.12087004631757736,
0.8742236495018005,
-0.0655604898929596,
-0.4153982698917389,
0.03057357482612133,
-0.267428457736969,
-0.6803547143936157,
1.4459006786346436,
0.4716528356075287,
0.9348781108856201,
-0.09820424020290375,
1.0500071048736572,
0.45077672600746155,
0.3650968372821808,
-0.3679320812225342,
0.5031378269195557,
-0.2375503033399582,
-0.6879850029945374,
-0.23689453303813934,
-0.6234523057937622,
-0.935017466545105,
0.26299312710762024,
0.07128824293613434,
-0.7313043475151062,
0.21451154351234436,
-0.12245026230812073,
0.09530285000801086,
0.3529582917690277,
-0.7217999696731567,
0.6029970049858093,
0.018114065751433372,
-0.3979915976524353,
-0.26630160212516785,
-0.35968834161758423,
0.7104323506355286,
-0.45936691761016846,
0.4228503704071045,
-0.07919714599847794,
0.10042250156402588,
0.5202559232711792,
-0.25789594650268555,
0.6494003534317017,
0.02849324233829975,
-0.576403021812439,
0.06144965812563896,
0.12128891795873642,
0.598389744758606,
0.007720412686467171,
0.13121138513088226,
0.17922253906726837,
0.014646446332335472,
-0.09685401618480682,
-0.39132046699523926,
0.769706666469574,
-0.6833865642547607,
-0.4398016035556793,
-0.47286084294319153,
-0.7424675226211548,
-0.2314981073141098,
0.132781982421875,
0.3077128529548645,
0.21266688406467438,
-0.2435237467288971,
0.42859408259391785,
0.9592523574829102,
-0.5575122833251953,
0.36948585510253906,
0.4095276892185211,
-0.14028339087963104,
-0.24732740223407745,
0.8790876865386963,
-0.09692642092704773,
0.7977848052978516,
0.41933462023735046,
0.10145499557256699,
-0.2520604729652405,
-0.7615454196929932,
-0.1999240666627884,
0.17911548912525177,
-0.9467319846153259,
-0.2422744631767273,
-0.4702939987182617,
-0.1716558039188385,
-0.06827487796545029,
0.21675017476081848,
-0.31985926628112793,
-0.21336033940315247,
-0.23495323956012726,
-0.21213462948799133,
0.04867786914110184,
0.6852433681488037,
-0.08981406688690186,
0.32938525080680847,
-0.6778550148010254,
0.3168189525604248,
-0.03623354807496071,
0.41711288690567017,
-0.12099268287420273,
-0.36153629422187805,
-0.14537660777568817,
0.23382894694805145,
-0.5877531170845032,
-0.49497535824775696,
0.3292049467563629,
0.08825799077749252,
0.5248920321464539,
0.8069294095039368,
0.12762010097503662,
0.32746604084968567,
-0.2715654671192169,
0.5032739639282227,
-0.034461185336112976,
-1.0841021537780762,
0.46513402462005615,
-0.5358246564865112,
-0.05309975892305374,
0.3970719277858734,
0.08618050813674927,
-0.5492547750473022,
-0.9657544493675232,
-0.665981650352478,
-0.7398218512535095,
0.6399839520454407,
0.25044935941696167,
-0.014559343457221985,
0.04005718231201172,
0.1026836484670639,
0.14433394372463226,
0.14507703483104706,
-0.3632694482803345,
-0.31424275040626526,
0.14545179903507233,
-0.17534907162189484,
-0.14550580084323883,
-0.3566427528858185,
-0.28197911381721497,
0.17963054776191711,
0.6467311382293701,
0.2709006667137146,
-0.11061372607946396,
-0.05277247726917267,
-0.2996288537979126,
-0.06306244432926178,
0.43813395500183105,
0.4693705439567566,
0.6935440897941589,
-0.33057957887649536,
0.31082314252853394,
-0.13753685355186462,
-0.7742618322372437,
0.2602914273738861,
-0.20982883870601654,
-0.44080212712287903,
-0.004760907497256994,
0.3375071585178375,
0.22380994260311127,
0.23131226003170013,
-0.8165889978408813,
0.6053001880645752,
-0.037781696766614914,
-0.02544468082487583,
-0.20998603105545044,
0.36514827609062195,
0.3329722285270691,
-0.08657083660364151,
0.2706439793109894,
-0.0683959349989891,
0.2618587017059326,
-0.5411663055419922,
0.6305533647537231,
0.34689441323280334,
-0.13316339254379272,
-0.06491348892450333,
0.6923232078552246,
0.020102104172110558,
0.26273149251937866,
0.6578401923179626,
-0.04497513175010681,
-0.2855460047721863,
0.7997199892997742,
0.4046788215637207,
0.6564945578575134,
-0.5249132513999939,
0.1778624802827835,
0.2033138871192932,
0.3302987217903137,
0.04480829834938049,
0.07783965021371841,
0.08709188550710678,
-0.8270133137702942,
-0.3501940071582794,
-0.31758785247802734,
-0.5056549906730652,
0.4658801555633545,
-0.8134190440177917,
0.318766325712204,
-0.5810621976852417,
0.022826721891760826,
0.11058958619832993,
-0.03705571964383125,
-0.616271436214447,
0.3034074902534485,
0.16132983565330505,
0.6908847093582153,
-0.9566878080368042,
1.0130208730697632,
0.0503852479159832,
-0.23536522686481476,
-0.5518994331359863,
0.0504022054374218,
-0.022124284878373146,
-0.789300262928009,
0.8404962420463562,
0.030152447521686554,
0.34452325105667114,
-0.4087730050086975,
-0.287573903799057,
-0.6965839266777039,
0.9769726991653442,
0.5551149845123291,
-0.5620773434638977,
0.3559253215789795,
0.3292982876300812,
0.5536600351333618,
0.11366351693868637,
0.4085274934768677,
0.8456923365592957,
0.6964290142059326,
-0.0806892067193985,
-0.8137364983558655,
0.31143176555633545,
-0.016774965450167656,
-0.01921105571091175,
0.25255265831947327,
-0.388538122177124,
0.6236945986747742,
-0.10658422857522964,
-0.6023719906806946,
0.14236275851726532,
0.0643770769238472,
0.3344557285308838,
0.3162386119365692,
0.44389405846595764,
0.6370792984962463,
0.8985282778739929,
-0.33092960715293884,
1.0163482427597046,
0.029401320964097977,
0.5893223285675049,
1.3161076307296753,
-0.32687726616859436,
0.7852482199668884,
0.2833433747291565,
-0.403536319732666,
0.09068024158477783,
0.42754143476486206,
-0.2738049626350403,
0.6432865262031555,
0.6367784142494202,
-0.5525185465812683,
0.05987156182527542,
-0.17709621787071228,
-0.3377029001712799,
0.2621113359928131,
0.257467657327652,
-0.4320942461490631,
-0.4625716805458069,
-0.030250990763306618,
0.24584151804447174,
0.2394271194934845,
0.058947425335645676,
0.7654929757118225,
-0.06615958362817764,
-0.372662216424942,
0.7939881682395935,
-0.1704411804676056,
0.46156221628189087,
-0.3786323070526123,
-0.04793887585401535,
-0.4628674387931824,
0.5404406189918518,
-0.3665391504764557,
-0.6480604410171509,
0.3105449676513672,
-0.1605387181043625,
0.015526765957474709,
-0.1794712096452713,
0.5813909769058228,
-0.5278446674346924,
-0.16569609940052032,
0.5715078115463257,
0.43238794803619385,
0.1726720780134201,
-0.24430222809314728,
-0.22697128355503082,
0.43008655309677124,
-0.040040794759988785,
-0.10551947355270386,
0.5387769341468811,
0.5032653212547302,
0.006334616336971521,
0.9341381192207336,
0.7775462865829468,
0.29032599925994873,
0.19523130357265472,
0.2490161657333374,
0.7894731760025024,
-0.2883841395378113,
-0.2571505606174469,
-0.793758749961853,
0.16976551711559296,
0.02266010083258152,
0.10172545164823532,
0.7571017742156982,
0.7653942704200745,
0.8222349286079407,
-0.030157778412103653,
0.9681285619735718,
0.4269557297229767,
0.5331659913063049,
-0.5212035179138184,
0.7815388441085815,
0.022714322432875633,
0.6269363164901733,
-0.31620416045188904,
-1.0292993783950806,
-0.2625196874141693,
0.2529059946537018,
-0.1809598207473755,
0.09115630388259888,
0.9620766043663025,
0.6388441324234009,
-0.29073938727378845,
-0.006615339778363705,
0.4678173065185547,
0.3723374307155609,
0.777529776096344,
0.5959224700927734,
0.7679257988929749,
-0.34574151039123535,
0.8099225759506226,
-0.4998930096626282,
-0.2527907192707062,
-0.07381927967071533,
-0.870245635509491,
-0.7417194843292236,
-0.33589187264442444,
-0.5623408555984497,
-0.22370606660842896,
0.1706048548221588,
0.1778707653284073,
0.6135943531990051,
-0.8872463703155518,
0.016232645139098167,
-0.2843661904335022,
0.343806654214859,
-0.3489321768283844,
-0.237375408411026,
0.6799067258834839,
-0.4555630683898926,
-1.1032079458236694,
0.26949822902679443,
-0.04747533053159714,
0.0010880101472139359,
-0.13253434002399445,
0.2732733190059662,
0.14932787418365479,
0.00568931782618165,
0.38569095730781555,
-0.08481547981500626,
-0.5574528574943542,
-0.5934913754463196,
-0.41729775071144104,
-0.24296697974205017,
0.1585758477449417,
0.46547478437423706,
-0.5173634886741638,
0.5130243897438049,
0.481675386428833,
0.5286772847175598,
0.4686945974826813,
0.20685921609401703,
0.5358290672302246,
-0.9520149827003479,
0.006478871684521437,
0.02520642802119255,
0.31696513295173645,
0.48024922609329224,
-0.5834845900535583,
0.7929227948188782,
0.002693801885470748,
-0.6740233302116394,
-0.9957793951034546,
-0.01917305402457714,
-1.092703938484192,
0.043462034314870834,
1.5510140657424927,
-0.5403872132301331,
0.03666575253009796,
-0.21337264776229858,
-0.07968553155660629,
0.2462078332901001,
-0.3739505410194397,
0.8446364402770996,
0.8979887962341309,
0.4158483147621155,
0.13021105527877808,
-0.9401637315750122,
0.4037196934223175,
0.23234237730503082,
-1.1223502159118652,
0.4627307057380676,
0.5730502605438232,
0.6857870221138,
0.013792730867862701,
0.4146656095981598,
-0.5290350914001465,
0.1131688579916954,
-0.07894846796989441,
-0.09246671944856644,
-0.007966945879161358,
-0.20317380130290985,
-0.41606903076171875,
-0.031513795256614685,
-0.1333751231431961,
-0.4527479410171509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15933v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15933v1
|
Bridging the Gap between 2D and 3D Visual Question Answering: A Fusion Approach for 3D VQA
| 2024-02-24T23:31:34 | 2024-02-24T23:31:34 |
Wentao Mo, Yang Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In 3D Visual Question Answering (3D VQA), the scarcity of fully annotated
data and limited visual content diversity hampers the generalization to novel
scenes and 3D concepts (e.g., only around 800 scenes are utilized in ScanQA and
SQA dataset). Current approaches resort supplement 3D reasoning with 2D
information. However, these methods face challenges: either they use top-down
2D views that introduce overly complex and sometimes question-irrelevant visual
clues, or they rely on globally aggregated scene/image-level representations
from 2D VLMs, losing the fine-grained vision-language correlations. To overcome
these limitations, our approach utilizes question-conditional 2D view selection
procedure, pinpointing semantically relevant 2D inputs for crucial visual
clues. We then integrate this 2D knowledge into the 3D-VQA system via a
two-branch Transformer structure. This structure, featuring a Twin-Transformer
design, compactly combines 2D and 3D modalities and captures fine-grained
correlations between modalities, allowing them mutually augmenting each other.
Integrating proposed mechanisms above, we present BridgeQA, that offers a fresh
perspective on multi-modal transformer-based architectures for 3D-VQA.
Experiments validate that BridgeQA achieves state-of-the-art on 3D-VQA datasets
and significantly outperforms existing solutions. Code is available at
$\href{https://github.com/matthewdm0816/BridgeQA}{\text{this URL}}$.
|
[
-0.7903900742530823,
-0.7075784206390381,
0.6953040957450867,
0.014402505941689014,
-0.2174176126718521,
0.0774511843919754,
0.6414515972137451,
-0.5589150786399841,
-0.07022689282894135,
0.5831336379051208,
-0.5598122477531433,
-0.08468244224786758,
-0.2998794913291931,
0.00971399899572134,
-0.29065385460853577,
0.3049152195453644,
-0.19130249321460724,
0.16385114192962646,
-0.6875501871109009,
-0.04550624266266823,
-0.5268112421035767,
-0.07995938509702682,
-0.33647680282592773,
-0.07985749840736389,
0.4256128668785095,
0.5077316164970398,
0.7692148685455322,
0.3346284031867981,
0.5612558126449585,
0.2767556607723236,
-0.15525971353054047,
0.24474288523197174,
-0.38089632987976074,
0.0071757179684937,
-0.18175043165683746,
-0.5866994857788086,
-0.157338947057724,
-0.22793614864349365,
0.4672344923019409,
0.7533581852912903,
0.2272566854953766,
0.023372067138552666,
-0.11062727123498917,
0.8803812265396118,
-0.691810131072998,
-0.09466110169887543,
-0.30789753794670105,
0.021376552060246468,
-0.0426839217543602,
0.1308424025774002,
0.25012364983558655,
-0.22961661219596863,
0.35933414101600647,
-0.5239585041999817,
0.2768215835094452,
0.023654460906982422,
0.9612081050872803,
0.6131095290184021,
-0.7400166988372803,
0.3922022879123688,
-0.6528749465942383,
0.25706636905670166,
-0.11166048794984818,
0.5568063855171204,
0.19670477509498596,
0.9176836013793945,
0.3863019645214081,
-0.8199606537818909,
-0.8319666385650635,
0.20663298666477203,
-0.18932098150253296,
0.6439359784126282,
-0.2684037685394287,
-0.023595066741108894,
0.14757323265075684,
0.6693035364151001,
-0.8645275235176086,
-0.06240294873714447,
-0.7781235575675964,
-0.26049453020095825,
0.45822224020957947,
0.13994692265987396,
0.1680576354265213,
-0.5703303813934326,
-0.85475754737854,
-0.40041524171829224,
-0.5209349989891052,
0.3010232150554657,
0.10643041133880615,
-0.0948767215013504,
-0.2503819167613983,
0.750607430934906,
-0.3896655738353729,
0.6360412240028381,
0.1487252116203308,
0.4403151273727417,
0.17406105995178223,
-0.6812439560890198,
-0.2891339957714081,
-0.3506530523300171,
0.4875525236129761,
0.6872775554656982,
-0.12186642736196518,
0.01941080391407013,
-0.06688524782657623,
0.022958768531680107,
0.3802068531513214,
-0.4852255880832672,
-0.3913186490535736,
0.4637106657028198,
-0.276628702878952,
0.1203245148062706,
0.21349884569644928,
-0.9860513210296631,
-0.6188665628433228,
-0.08794757723808289,
0.7831326723098755,
-0.04218748211860657,
-0.4601445198059082,
0.2500622868537903,
-0.6765691637992859,
0.6652200222015381,
0.4923495352268219,
-0.6523467302322388,
0.0389583483338356,
0.3992239832878113,
0.5085669159889221,
-0.0267048217356205,
-0.038291800767183304,
-0.2574010193347931,
0.22618471086025238,
-0.3755393922328949,
0.887413740158081,
-0.13177505135536194,
-0.3530774712562561,
0.037297215312719345,
-0.08873960375785828,
0.05369342863559723,
-0.6233411431312561,
0.19432058930397034,
-0.7000715136528015,
0.652231752872467,
-0.5076335668563843,
0.09852061420679092,
-0.2581250071525574,
0.40587061643600464,
-1.072830080986023,
0.9276720285415649,
0.5893601179122925,
-0.747407078742981,
0.013731315732002258,
-0.18846020102500916,
-0.20139822363853455,
0.15227410197257996,
-0.6065160632133484,
-0.22286474704742432,
-0.05216575786471367,
0.5611425638198853,
0.012200107797980309,
-0.4695720970630646,
-0.19065271317958832,
-0.13860973715782166,
-0.246286541223526,
-0.16272370517253876,
-0.20736195147037506,
0.6479972004890442,
0.0005009472370147705,
-0.2974291145801544,
0.06191951036453247,
-0.4408116042613983,
-0.17532630264759064,
0.25526919960975647,
0.09160933643579483,
-0.20340189337730408,
-0.35509684681892395,
-0.035520732402801514,
0.573097288608551,
0.21006612479686737,
-0.45124152302742004,
0.15061905980110168,
-0.5424355268478394,
0.07808584719896317,
0.34600892663002014,
0.010057732462882996,
0.5711748600006104,
-0.3407926559448242,
0.5459415316581726,
0.3487633764743805,
0.2884533107280731,
-0.1430482268333435,
-0.6546306014060974,
-0.8286523222923279,
-0.058781713247299194,
-0.03016546368598938,
0.8687584400177002,
-1.5077884197235107,
-0.18696679174900055,
-0.1496565341949463,
-0.27893027663230896,
-0.5619106888771057,
-0.05253935232758522,
0.3190329968929291,
0.4803042411804199,
0.6662224531173706,
-0.19877134263515472,
-0.6205553412437439,
-1.2669702768325806,
0.23876631259918213,
-0.3172903060913086,
-0.4726324677467346,
0.09768224507570267,
0.2906440496444702,
0.16234678030014038,
0.9232589602470398,
-0.5240200757980347,
-0.3343067169189453,
-0.4394412040710449,
-0.2832838296890259,
0.12905851006507874,
0.2345483899116516,
0.5031685829162598,
-1.4501841068267822,
-0.05056501552462578,
-0.03014150634407997,
-0.7241992950439453,
0.021147217601537704,
-0.17547589540481567,
-0.30522727966308594,
-0.12299145013093948,
0.7156795859336853,
-0.6725966334342957,
0.5969880223274231,
0.5643020272254944,
-0.3180709183216095,
0.15699364244937897,
0.22162020206451416,
0.12444069236516953,
-1.1471463441848755,
-0.10960177332162857,
-0.15266422927379608,
0.12619826197624207,
-0.6914739608764648,
-0.11697226762771606,
0.12763430178165436,
0.1556500941514969,
-0.6438547372817993,
0.6961584091186523,
-0.32483357191085815,
-0.025839006528258324,
-0.1493796706199646,
0.41026750206947327,
0.4478670060634613,
0.7255215048789978,
0.1350538283586502,
0.41059306263923645,
0.4386685788631439,
-0.32526564598083496,
0.45659521222114563,
0.6204344034194946,
-0.3049219846725464,
0.7393091917037964,
-0.8671368360519409,
-0.09199969470500946,
-0.3864500820636749,
0.3068939745426178,
-1.340871810913086,
-0.2160092294216156,
0.35356977581977844,
-0.4510437846183777,
-0.04467932879924774,
-0.07041679322719574,
-0.18612278997898102,
-0.5960836410522461,
-0.22977367043495178,
0.7401533126831055,
0.25069698691368103,
-0.6836242079734802,
0.9534679055213928,
0.39117103815078735,
0.003669582074508071,
-0.47438865900039673,
-0.7560584545135498,
0.05347157642245293,
0.05683620646595955,
-0.9432417154312134,
0.445652037858963,
0.09080677479505539,
-0.3060416877269745,
0.0556725412607193,
-0.42873942852020264,
-0.16794228553771973,
-0.21696536242961884,
0.4014657437801361,
0.6821935772895813,
-0.24637141823768616,
-0.1562844216823578,
0.19164103269577026,
-0.23553381860256195,
0.15114974975585938,
-0.14428123831748962,
0.18217766284942627,
-0.21639524400234222,
-0.4211687445640564,
-0.1493469476699829,
0.7347685694694519,
0.7606921792030334,
-0.34100887179374695,
0.36685219407081604,
0.7508289217948914,
-0.4173259437084198,
0.05326337739825249,
-0.6406819820404053,
-0.07232536375522614,
-0.4430110454559326,
0.41995513439178467,
-0.6613717675209045,
-1.1330089569091797,
0.20093968510627747,
0.015041345730423927,
0.0496852770447731,
0.5155194997787476,
0.6145182847976685,
-0.39497703313827515,
0.9663257002830505,
0.6416954398155212,
0.39131438732147217,
0.11238279193639755,
-0.36469635367393494,
0.46495774388313293,
-0.9239663481712341,
-0.7493576407432556,
-0.2273842990398407,
-0.31601953506469727,
-0.3211468458175659,
-0.9353397488594055,
0.8340939283370972,
0.3778277635574341,
-0.22636809945106506,
0.1703648418188095,
-0.3111940324306488,
0.4645235240459442,
0.6933426856994629,
-0.033633891493082047,
0.21324871480464935,
-0.25047972798347473,
-0.09434304386377335,
0.3848079442977905,
-0.8676983118057251,
-0.01200841087847948,
0.4764212667942047,
0.24723519384860992,
0.3871268928050995,
0.5289496779441833,
0.13530659675598145,
-0.17175506055355072,
-0.3893261253833771,
-0.530157744884491,
0.38669657707214355,
0.16775667667388916,
-0.605963408946991,
-0.35473349690437317,
-0.2313852161169052,
-0.6976377964019775,
0.6187875270843506,
-0.3210706114768982,
-0.4707518219947815,
0.6062316298484802,
0.20025767385959625,
-0.6506662368774414,
0.39841461181640625,
-0.5682429075241089,
0.8529900908470154,
-0.12443753331899643,
-0.47972571849823,
-0.033223818987607956,
-1.135499119758606,
0.7661204934120178,
0.07506592571735382,
0.06790805608034134,
0.10238964855670929,
0.019959812983870506,
0.15940113365650177,
-0.23310156166553497,
0.5245635509490967,
-0.01533319242298603,
-0.15798193216323853,
0.2717629373073578,
0.05240916088223457,
0.027266904711723328,
0.4371870160102844,
0.4540747404098511,
0.4476196765899658,
0.33202290534973145,
-0.4865078926086426,
-0.8440384268760681,
0.35291144251823425,
-0.662585437297821,
-0.817901611328125,
-0.291563481092453,
-0.5110214352607727,
-0.6782008409500122,
-0.008481469005346298,
0.25601470470428467,
0.33570152521133423,
0.045918338000774384,
0.24957124888896942,
0.6185397505760193,
-0.1307687610387802,
0.3336166441440582,
0.15591661632061005,
-0.40767785906791687,
-0.49581247568130493,
0.510610818862915,
-0.45948120951652527,
0.39682140946388245,
0.7931265830993652,
-0.04814991354942322,
-0.5007103085517883,
-0.22825083136558533,
-0.9437953233718872,
0.14968949556350708,
-0.5782230496406555,
-0.3902052044868469,
-0.5089520812034607,
-0.6403253078460693,
-0.3400810658931732,
-0.21544642746448517,
-0.2773662507534027,
-0.6332291960716248,
0.16444513201713562,
-0.21108287572860718,
0.02423482947051525,
0.4952012002468109,
-0.1959409862756729,
-0.05966705083847046,
-0.8935844302177429,
1.0971603393554688,
1.0298619270324707,
0.31481730937957764,
-0.1356765180826187,
-0.2487623244524002,
-0.10661384463310242,
0.16981947422027588,
-0.08296792209148407,
-0.6923946738243103,
-0.11309526115655899,
-0.2386387288570404,
0.57527756690979,
0.11645391583442688,
-0.02035275101661682,
0.6462642550468445,
-0.3010171353816986,
1.0278737545013428,
0.3785378634929657,
-0.658319890499115,
0.5534960031509399,
-0.10863163322210312,
0.732211709022522,
0.5416272282600403,
0.3085472285747528,
-0.5312392711639404,
-0.16982460021972656,
-0.3043783903121948,
-0.8652297854423523,
0.5739306211471558,
0.40157192945480347,
-0.08227886259555817,
0.2772388458251953,
0.03249576315283775,
-0.055037081241607666,
0.012555424124002457,
-0.15633422136306763,
-0.30242258310317993,
-0.7109941244125366,
0.12110719084739685,
0.23819999396800995,
-0.23932430148124695,
-0.4240005314350128,
-0.347002238035202,
0.13478538393974304,
-0.20296719670295715,
0.11375811696052551,
0.30853578448295593,
-0.07809688150882721,
-0.054795898497104645,
-0.10061381757259369,
0.22181721031665802,
0.6380584836006165,
-0.006785152480006218,
0.2660406827926636,
0.2644325792789459,
-0.4509051442146301,
-0.2406766563653946,
0.1650448441505432,
-0.09545376151800156,
-0.0457870289683342,
0.24520578980445862,
0.852319061756134,
0.020733267068862915,
-0.6015897393226624,
0.772361159324646,
-0.2812046408653259,
-0.6104571223258972,
-0.08118680119514465,
-0.046073999255895615,
0.10469956696033478,
0.7832819223403931,
0.46604201197624207,
0.17522086203098297,
0.2310890406370163,
-0.2769283056259155,
0.2793554663658142,
0.33143776655197144,
-0.47544988989830017,
-0.14564386010169983,
0.7705327272415161,
0.35884836316108704,
0.15307927131652832,
0.6475270390510559,
0.3234097361564636,
-0.513342559337616,
0.6201357841491699,
0.04255640506744385,
0.7784901857376099,
-0.22129391133785248,
0.3144301176071167,
0.546789824962616,
0.4531114399433136,
0.252079039812088,
0.41042864322662354,
-0.2294568419456482,
-0.6816380620002747,
-0.22748270630836487,
-0.48986509442329407,
-0.4299692213535309,
-0.04472748190164566,
-0.7697441577911377,
0.19300507009029388,
-0.10367771983146667,
0.333671510219574,
-0.2776266932487488,
-0.2895125150680542,
-0.7237330079078674,
0.3508097529411316,
0.7522308230400085,
0.909184992313385,
-0.7088959813117981,
0.7079893350601196,
0.5262450575828552,
-0.4770157039165497,
-0.5100127458572388,
-0.08020517230033875,
0.3613830804824829,
-0.8098593354225159,
0.22224153578281403,
0.00521480618044734,
-0.38559451699256897,
-0.17503727972507477,
-0.30611348152160645,
-1.0210787057876587,
1.1586889028549194,
-0.07158961892127991,
-0.3956948518753052,
-0.2434435486793518,
0.47501063346862793,
0.3200500011444092,
0.07630451023578644,
0.30335474014282227,
0.6518210768699646,
0.5033130049705505,
0.874390721321106,
-0.7798634171485901,
-0.15673820674419403,
-0.6116312146186829,
0.2447880655527115,
0.2078084796667099,
-0.442282110452652,
0.564609706401825,
-0.33987289667129517,
-0.28631457686424255,
0.13959456980228424,
0.8635501265525818,
0.22210630774497986,
0.30649641156196594,
0.9075742959976196,
0.42010849714279175,
0.26966825127601624,
-0.18846791982650757,
0.805042028427124,
-0.13630712032318115,
-0.041243914514780045,
1.045838713645935,
-0.06063055619597435,
0.6334617137908936,
0.6869366765022278,
-0.05977576971054077,
0.5042666792869568,
0.5975756049156189,
-0.007971621118485928,
0.5106542110443115,
-0.02848837524652481,
-0.05923932045698166,
-0.599220335483551,
0.006390840280801058,
-0.45974960923194885,
0.5356849431991577,
0.32386723160743713,
0.3217383325099945,
-0.46783268451690674,
0.1125686764717102,
-0.4828752875328064,
-0.05094635859131813,
-0.19370034337043762,
0.6633234024047852,
0.1589154601097107,
-0.6098616123199463,
0.467172235250473,
-0.4409424066543579,
0.09979617595672607,
-0.5578663349151611,
-0.36609113216400146,
-0.6213304996490479,
-0.17116327583789825,
-0.1617092490196228,
-1.0092473030090332,
0.29588782787323,
-0.28949883580207825,
-0.2680010497570038,
-0.2623099982738495,
0.18176491558551788,
-0.533974289894104,
-0.3995833694934845,
0.0374225415289402,
0.9643312692642212,
-0.32338812947273254,
-0.1929791420698166,
-0.43379512429237366,
0.04537536948919296,
-0.01903485879302025,
0.01726086251437664,
0.16094864904880524,
0.3976660966873169,
-0.18767870962619781,
0.39957135915756226,
0.345217227935791,
-0.5049058794975281,
-0.0824059545993805,
0.1750059723854065,
1.1469202041625977,
-0.47085052728652954,
-0.28770148754119873,
-0.24902738630771637,
0.9289451241493225,
-0.15896974503993988,
-0.4894537925720215,
0.7825417518615723,
0.6316387057304382,
0.9978203177452087,
0.2063075602054596,
0.6805166006088257,
-0.14542728662490845,
0.42083075642585754,
-0.6374392509460449,
0.31656280159950256,
-1.0127842426300049,
0.361113041639328,
-0.11509747058153152,
-0.9017123579978943,
-0.4698486030101776,
0.2524247169494629,
-0.1475324034690857,
-0.18767620623111725,
0.8740206956863403,
0.8868711590766907,
-0.07897526025772095,
0.08225803822278976,
0.43863579630851746,
0.11037170141935349,
0.2072668969631195,
0.8539847731590271,
1.092614769935608,
-0.5054064989089966,
0.8346176147460938,
-0.4130859375,
-0.20221355557441711,
-0.16655181348323822,
-0.2087641805410385,
-0.7086198925971985,
-1.0689777135849,
-0.20261645317077637,
-0.3093017339706421,
-0.18767279386520386,
0.22924268245697021,
0.41899001598358154,
-0.5129938125610352,
0.029477862641215324,
0.1761702001094818,
0.23986242711544037,
-0.3772258758544922,
-0.1676768660545349,
0.5238966345787048,
0.23761452734470367,
-0.6620373129844666,
0.4368424117565155,
0.5342134237289429,
0.0018558945739641786,
-0.38894033432006836,
0.25527793169021606,
-0.14344564080238342,
0.05145857483148575,
0.6539853811264038,
0.32482409477233887,
-0.7609931826591492,
-0.29685020446777344,
0.25442856550216675,
-0.24555784463882446,
0.19418670237064362,
0.6134912967681885,
-1.0830575227737427,
0.6981312036514282,
0.8260499835014343,
0.6713147759437561,
0.631586492061615,
0.1790311336517334,
0.6268578171730042,
-0.2891463041305542,
-0.17816129326820374,
0.35997334122657776,
0.21493789553642273,
0.23645932972431183,
-0.06723728775978088,
0.38471657037734985,
0.1159932017326355,
-0.1018923744559288,
-0.3211342692375183,
0.5457813739776611,
-1.4076422452926636,
-0.44116464257240295,
0.9289648532867432,
0.36330676078796387,
-0.22260485589504242,
-0.3389798402786255,
-0.4780365228652954,
-0.04932108521461487,
0.3948591947555542,
0.7641243934631348,
0.15454640984535217,
-0.20336583256721497,
-0.5272219777107239,
-0.5657728314399719,
0.5494695901870728,
0.38631686568260193,
-0.8188617825508118,
-0.29133695363998413,
0.712411642074585,
-0.23425893485546112,
0.1684645414352417,
0.24259522557258606,
-0.17019127309322357,
0.7997047305107117,
0.1949670910835266,
-0.1100335568189621,
-0.1444603055715561,
-0.5103291273117065,
-0.3779791593551636,
0.4847553074359894,
-0.6803703308105469,
-0.4692823588848114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15931v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15931v1
|
Frustratingly Simple Prompting-based Text Denoising
| 2024-02-24T23:23:06 | 2024-02-24T23:23:06 |
Jungyeul Park, Mengyang Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces a novel perspective on the automated essay scoring
(AES) task, challenging the conventional view of the ASAP dataset as a static
entity. Employing simple text denoising techniques using prompting, we explore
the dynamic potential within the dataset. While acknowledging the previous
emphasis on building regression systems, our paper underscores how making minor
changes to a dataset through text denoising can enhance the final results.
|
[
-0.3820069134235382,
-0.9640952944755554,
0.6283723711967468,
0.23521621525287628,
-0.01790800504386425,
0.23671959340572357,
0.1394081562757492,
-0.4383184611797333,
0.289477676153183,
0.30123770236968994,
-0.8458384275436401,
-0.4308547079563141,
-0.4834660291671753,
0.6949076056480408,
-0.6726874113082886,
1.0238112211227417,
-0.10323292016983032,
-0.3471125066280365,
-0.1321965605020523,
-0.05915600433945656,
-0.5275949835777283,
0.12826815247535706,
-1.4087445735931396,
-0.1408488005399704,
0.38301610946655273,
0.576633632183075,
0.3741800785064697,
0.7297918796539307,
0.564336895942688,
0.2713673710823059,
0.1424144208431244,
-0.12699852883815765,
-0.1696503907442093,
0.5452666878700256,
0.3013923764228821,
-0.6780667304992676,
0.02435947209596634,
-0.0322406068444252,
0.8398683071136475,
0.8232135772705078,
0.03341411426663399,
0.18257229030132294,
0.4363318979740143,
0.8434414863586426,
-0.48813802003860474,
0.23433955013751984,
-0.619542121887207,
0.19038747251033783,
-0.050759706646203995,
-0.05603736266493797,
-0.4856327772140503,
-0.37940624356269836,
0.054894398897886276,
-0.4440343379974365,
0.3820333480834961,
0.19389238953590393,
0.7762897610664368,
0.6553152799606323,
-0.562909722328186,
-0.25471052527427673,
-0.7891977429389954,
0.8977084755897522,
-0.12610231339931488,
-0.07685870677232742,
0.29649773240089417,
0.07787639647722244,
0.07136110961437225,
-0.675545334815979,
-0.41519874334335327,
-0.057086676359176636,
0.0749938115477562,
0.062251120805740356,
-0.32610884308815,
0.4989955425262451,
0.4892970621585846,
0.35451915860176086,
-0.28919196128845215,
0.009048580192029476,
-0.4197877049446106,
-0.04046202823519707,
0.6416579484939575,
0.1863202601671219,
0.28422266244888306,
-0.3372757136821747,
-0.17772850394248962,
0.05920377001166344,
-0.41217461228370667,
0.6242325901985168,
0.30125775933265686,
0.5027791261672974,
-0.005087217316031456,
0.3588133454322815,
-0.06998568773269653,
0.7281413078308105,
0.08909373730421066,
0.2199542373418808,
0.10328707098960876,
0.3729550838470459,
-0.18319359421730042,
0.1634518802165985,
0.30317994952201843,
0.5757009983062744,
0.15916961431503296,
0.12438638508319855,
-0.4858418107032776,
0.42648687958717346,
0.46664512157440186,
-0.30259424448013306,
-0.2386491596698761,
0.2942884862422943,
-0.6590304970741272,
-0.6784628033638,
-0.012656981125473976,
-1.0409092903137207,
-0.4217824935913086,
-0.5510625243186951,
0.5240648984909058,
-0.2517690062522888,
0.4136272370815277,
-0.13793820142745972,
-0.30808770656585693,
0.17392145097255707,
0.589544951915741,
-0.7905327677726746,
0.7145764827728271,
0.2215985208749771,
0.8280221223831177,
-0.14151692390441895,
-0.07470960915088654,
-0.46126776933670044,
-0.17437276244163513,
-0.621387779712677,
1.214128017425537,
-0.6291888952255249,
-0.6849002838134766,
0.04287064075469971,
-0.0882987380027771,
-0.20392169058322906,
-0.445282518863678,
0.6703096628189087,
-0.3431064188480377,
0.16530926525592804,
-0.6779559254646301,
-0.5757927298545837,
-0.23925073444843292,
0.09219080954790115,
-0.7410152554512024,
1.4415119886398315,
0.02335367538034916,
-0.41358160972595215,
0.3399359881877899,
-0.7958371639251709,
-0.39979881048202515,
0.28863707184791565,
-0.35566380620002747,
-0.07528287917375565,
0.14120371639728546,
0.39180535078048706,
0.23420627415180206,
0.0790429562330246,
-0.1548309177160263,
-0.137122243642807,
-0.5263217687606812,
-0.12911354005336761,
-1.0075551271438599,
0.5043955445289612,
0.4575556218624115,
-0.25520238280296326,
-0.45639342069625854,
-0.9959301352500916,
-0.013139045797288418,
-0.17024889588356018,
-0.44384458661079407,
-0.5378938913345337,
-0.10847513377666473,
-0.1781286895275116,
-0.14366894960403442,
0.2794858515262604,
-0.5045140385627747,
0.3731231689453125,
-0.43494534492492676,
0.06885381042957306,
1.0294698476791382,
0.44970592856407166,
0.3085002899169922,
-0.9016868472099304,
0.8623915910720825,
-0.4948226809501648,
-0.1993836611509323,
-0.5840007662773132,
-0.7974334359169006,
-0.4869864583015442,
-0.44762948155403137,
0.34822848439216614,
0.8383587002754211,
-0.7276642322540283,
0.2097138613462448,
0.13225704431533813,
-0.18230760097503662,
-0.6231071949005127,
0.05783475935459137,
0.28677669167518616,
0.8370969295501709,
0.42833212018013,
-0.0005821772501803935,
-0.5005554556846619,
-0.7092750668525696,
-0.5340605974197388,
-0.24327239394187927,
-0.2514685392379761,
0.06589775532484055,
0.1432671695947647,
0.03015652857720852,
0.9515470862388611,
-0.7280949354171753,
-0.3482349216938019,
-0.1982133388519287,
0.680335521697998,
0.022872792556881905,
0.5161578059196472,
0.6895499229431152,
-0.6652616858482361,
-0.699521005153656,
-0.7808780670166016,
-0.6510043144226074,
-0.6070098876953125,
-0.42967644333839417,
0.503580629825592,
0.11395926773548126,
0.9959012269973755,
-0.44574081897735596,
0.7796109914779663,
0.26675891876220703,
-0.27213144302368164,
0.5916861891746521,
-0.1269911527633667,
0.6726581454277039,
-0.8246891498565674,
0.05181526765227318,
0.29199326038360596,
-0.11847110092639923,
-0.5472379922866821,
-0.0968780443072319,
-0.3530276417732239,
-0.2188066989183426,
-0.12659156322479248,
0.5642419457435608,
-0.29479554295539856,
0.3570241928100586,
-0.1945830136537552,
-0.2711752653121948,
0.3115444481372833,
0.22732952237129211,
-0.3775376081466675,
0.886837363243103,
0.2940914034843445,
-0.7381906509399414,
0.20259405672550201,
0.6384565234184265,
-0.14298999309539795,
0.7196090221405029,
-0.6267616748809814,
-0.042140472680330276,
-0.701747715473175,
0.15966883301734924,
-1.599905252456665,
-0.44192174077033997,
-0.004518086090683937,
-0.4180402159690857,
0.3698309063911438,
-0.30226126313209534,
0.09146597981452942,
-0.42794668674468994,
-0.8115720748901367,
0.23452307283878326,
0.6247685551643372,
-0.3582504987716675,
0.5650164484977722,
0.2619808316230774,
-0.9368922710418701,
-0.5133591890335083,
-0.6067284941673279,
0.3290269374847412,
-0.2642807960510254,
-0.19763624668121338,
0.62091463804245,
-0.15395168960094452,
-0.566137433052063,
0.016636015847325325,
-0.11825191974639893,
-0.2149808406829834,
-0.05556738004088402,
0.4226052165031433,
0.5080540776252747,
-0.15891152620315552,
0.38093167543411255,
0.5908415913581848,
-0.0998854786157608,
0.33541396260261536,
0.20841869711875916,
0.1671590358018875,
0.030026255175471306,
-0.2473001778125763,
-0.9162116646766663,
0.673795759677887,
0.49940797686576843,
0.34215247631073,
0.5392417907714844,
-0.09212270379066467,
-0.6623179316520691,
-0.3997575640678406,
-0.3345984220504761,
-0.34508129954338074,
-0.5808031558990479,
-0.15174894034862518,
-0.3865579068660736,
-0.5622565746307373,
0.642267107963562,
-0.28289082646369934,
0.3780040442943573,
0.7801524996757507,
-0.14434947073459625,
-0.5692824721336365,
1.3416686058044434,
0.6990575790405273,
-0.0901665911078453,
0.5520150661468506,
-0.24108825623989105,
0.12132444232702255,
-0.37110164761543274,
-0.10499066859483719,
-1.0664348602294922,
-0.4772922098636627,
-0.4087030291557312,
0.25937461853027344,
0.3946858048439026,
-0.13929812610149384,
-0.04031827300786972,
-0.2831037640571594,
-0.7818394899368286,
0.7430871725082397,
0.4773181676864624,
0.15149369835853577,
0.008887265808880329,
0.2100946456193924,
-0.1431368887424469,
-0.3948725759983063,
-0.45914211869239807,
-0.7005648612976074,
1.130421757698059,
0.21241360902786255,
0.5975930690765381,
-0.3430163562297821,
0.7793565392494202,
1.019989252090454,
0.1335907280445099,
-0.7107469439506531,
0.6521203517913818,
-0.28072381019592285,
-0.2780061662197113,
-0.51730877161026,
-0.23989348113536835,
-1.0181968212127686,
-0.3200032711029053,
-0.45849308371543884,
-0.8556134700775146,
0.13495032489299774,
0.2601589262485504,
-1.076592206954956,
0.1456475555896759,
-0.8872511982917786,
0.44988173246383667,
0.5032464265823364,
-0.19822141528129578,
0.04360582306981087,
-0.509178638458252,
0.06988511979579926,
0.09452362358570099,
0.5261175632476807,
0.08253015577793121,
-0.03636263310909271,
1.247590184211731,
-0.34242093563079834,
0.8747112154960632,
-0.4252540171146393,
0.113520547747612,
0.5780228972434998,
0.210859015583992,
0.6855548620223999,
-0.026937492191791534,
-0.27862417697906494,
-0.35671094059944153,
0.16549043357372284,
-0.3086276948451996,
-0.5749141573905945,
0.6600452065467834,
-0.5285174250602722,
-0.5289922952651978,
-0.5379713177680969,
-0.23055577278137207,
-0.26103004813194275,
0.19568988680839539,
0.22407713532447815,
0.6073871850967407,
0.010018459521234035,
0.23033201694488525,
0.8601289987564087,
-0.031059160828590393,
0.6788495182991028,
0.26645269989967346,
-0.12594816088676453,
-0.16579075157642365,
0.7308523654937744,
0.32386818528175354,
-0.316447913646698,
0.2928331196308136,
0.13409386575222015,
-0.5381247997283936,
-0.5371711254119873,
-0.4121261239051819,
-0.000002561193468864076,
-0.8880072832107544,
-0.12854966521263123,
-0.8605602383613586,
-0.12135103344917297,
-0.5653243660926819,
-0.8127184510231018,
-0.14773964881896973,
-0.698431670665741,
-0.4055691659450531,
-0.4648474156856537,
0.47587913274765015,
0.9685590863227844,
-0.07729049026966095,
0.37532415986061096,
-1.0060850381851196,
0.6624591946601868,
0.38153234124183655,
0.29980939626693726,
-0.2598209083080292,
-0.6679322719573975,
0.1528344452381134,
-0.09823204576969147,
-0.2161884903907776,
-0.8264715075492859,
0.3886708617210388,
0.22261279821395874,
0.4088621139526367,
0.5540920495986938,
0.4857296347618103,
0.6244838833808899,
-0.41297653317451477,
1.1519933938980103,
-0.14455866813659668,
-0.8596466779708862,
0.7028451561927795,
-0.32947710156440735,
0.1873692274093628,
1.17525315284729,
0.513573169708252,
-0.5144930481910706,
-0.5241113305091858,
-0.6693589687347412,
-0.9630613923072815,
0.7192609310150146,
0.0595737025141716,
0.24001146852970123,
0.20886239409446716,
0.8651611804962158,
0.13553546369075775,
0.45760491490364075,
-0.5840585231781006,
-0.34538009762763977,
0.13316035270690918,
-0.8562759757041931,
-0.022874316200613976,
-0.42646360397338867,
0.1184835359454155,
-0.5129846334457397,
0.6537126302719116,
0.015027063898742199,
0.4111730456352234,
0.2994883060455322,
0.32768961787223816,
-0.36555951833724976,
0.004533735569566488,
0.3616507947444916,
0.0475785993039608,
-0.16107717156410217,
0.022223317995667458,
0.3153832256793976,
-0.7413002848625183,
0.41490039229393005,
0.0781392753124237,
-0.6205738186836243,
0.11287760734558105,
0.35119736194610596,
0.44605955481529236,
0.0182704608887434,
-0.49137407541275024,
0.3544766902923584,
-0.1415150761604309,
-0.2776808738708496,
-0.29827815294265747,
0.2788672149181366,
-0.6628702282905579,
-0.34444621205329895,
0.7803378105163574,
0.6683494448661804,
0.3881749212741852,
-0.23522475361824036,
0.5128920078277588,
0.2393464744091034,
-0.619755208492279,
-0.22425685822963715,
0.8219596147537231,
0.30392250418663025,
-0.6233050227165222,
0.6183596253395081,
-0.10574910789728165,
-0.3727635443210602,
0.900429904460907,
0.2304970771074295,
0.903278648853302,
-0.5575767755508423,
0.3579764664173126,
0.369061678647995,
0.4896793067455292,
-0.3467531204223633,
0.6431229114532471,
-0.15536533296108246,
-0.5457034707069397,
-0.15576928853988647,
-0.6393575668334961,
-0.5957851409912109,
0.4353199303150177,
-0.6862340569496155,
0.5658929347991943,
-0.7018764615058899,
0.07358582317829132,
0.2733921706676483,
0.053332675248384476,
-0.3791680634021759,
0.7141751646995544,
-0.20025470852851868,
0.942140519618988,
-1.217449426651001,
0.366741418838501,
0.8295865058898926,
-0.06030922755599022,
-0.8915129899978638,
0.21857203543186188,
0.40676000714302063,
-0.553308367729187,
0.1138087585568428,
0.4458823800086975,
-0.19558897614479065,
0.28377628326416016,
-0.5699517130851746,
-0.6737531423568726,
0.5299322605133057,
0.1498708575963974,
-0.2200709879398346,
-0.31588807702064514,
0.10136828571557999,
0.5787535905838013,
-0.21756242215633392,
0.1449344903230667,
0.4734661877155304,
0.7209298610687256,
-0.14748327434062958,
-0.3019029498100281,
-0.08605588227510452,
-0.5862913727760315,
-0.3788348436355591,
0.05574014037847519,
-0.3779231607913971,
0.8882388472557068,
0.084029421210289,
-0.10462761670351028,
-0.2580805718898773,
0.15050625801086426,
-0.24007387459278107,
0.8264515399932861,
0.7282120585441589,
0.43134456872940063,
0.858367919921875,
-0.037627991288900375,
0.8889788389205933,
-0.27620214223861694,
-0.1088101714849472,
0.7114330530166626,
-0.3742457330226898,
0.5761950612068176,
0.5324152112007141,
-0.34712833166122437,
0.6618659496307373,
0.5931078791618347,
0.12042407691478729,
0.3290131688117981,
-0.3089558482170105,
-0.6353082656860352,
-0.017341027036309242,
0.10109512507915497,
-0.02771107107400894,
0.6022728681564331,
0.5258066058158875,
-0.17137356102466583,
-0.26075953245162964,
0.26937177777290344,
-0.24542953073978424,
0.3510136008262634,
-0.30585089325904846,
0.8851608633995056,
0.026009684428572655,
-0.8766389489173889,
0.13813841342926025,
0.10311620682477951,
0.45029598474502563,
-0.6781365275382996,
-0.3639702796936035,
-0.1396467536687851,
-0.16600525379180908,
-0.14588943123817444,
-0.5510557293891907,
0.7797380685806274,
0.10611575841903687,
-0.4171094000339508,
-0.5468842387199402,
0.8875805139541626,
-0.13937342166900635,
-0.48320794105529785,
-0.1550983488559723,
0.19326020777225494,
-0.08396628499031067,
0.004891504999250174,
-0.6753663420677185,
-0.1824907809495926,
0.1621442288160324,
-0.5419673919677734,
0.08228367567062378,
0.5288732647895813,
-0.007901184260845184,
0.6859804391860962,
0.6147139668464661,
0.045059677213430405,
-0.2661731243133545,
-0.3320476710796356,
0.4370020925998688,
-0.7631375789642334,
-0.9622710347175598,
-0.6900050044059753,
0.3080872595310211,
-0.0928439050912857,
-0.3627908527851105,
0.7414223551750183,
0.5189050436019897,
0.40157410502433777,
0.03377639874815941,
1.1370598077774048,
0.09385748952627182,
1.0620489120483398,
-0.49049827456474304,
0.715057909488678,
-0.47029387950897217,
0.7338827252388,
-0.4676366448402405,
-0.6349815130233765,
-0.4407735764980316,
0.5852398872375488,
-0.15718619525432587,
-0.0033726715482771397,
0.7249332666397095,
0.723869264125824,
0.22645853459835052,
0.4910835921764374,
0.3305056393146515,
0.16366322338581085,
0.11428328603506088,
0.00838761031627655,
0.7528963685035706,
-0.49140340089797974,
0.322808176279068,
-0.2300805300474167,
-0.5513516664505005,
-0.20434272289276123,
-0.7700474262237549,
-0.5517032146453857,
-0.6419721841812134,
-0.599867582321167,
-0.27169269323349,
-0.010422896593809128,
1.1182634830474854,
-0.028639497235417366,
-0.9144283533096313,
0.17992080748081207,
-0.5638997554779053,
0.17715059220790863,
-0.4664246439933777,
-0.3617898225784302,
0.30575019121170044,
-0.5176405310630798,
-0.675356924533844,
0.4881473779678345,
0.293390691280365,
0.5037679672241211,
0.15314188599586487,
0.4343085289001465,
0.062033191323280334,
0.6777276992797852,
0.31394100189208984,
0.4174482226371765,
-0.0899590402841568,
-0.5288136601448059,
-0.1255863606929779,
-0.008716962300240993,
0.008234304375946522,
0.6788146495819092,
-1.094008445739746,
0.21254801750183105,
0.31261661648750305,
0.6186587810516357,
-0.07121104747056961,
0.06705054640769958,
0.37570831179618835,
-0.8551620244979858,
0.17244398593902588,
0.4250245988368988,
0.2064351886510849,
0.0902334675192833,
-0.7259960770606995,
0.07364952564239502,
0.5770427584648132,
-0.6236934065818787,
-1.091566562652588,
-0.004044240340590477,
-0.727258563041687,
-0.4221087396144867,
0.7328798770904541,
-0.008160645142197609,
-0.21622368693351746,
-0.7090465426445007,
-0.5343700647354126,
0.028204768896102905,
-0.6224759817123413,
1.487423062324524,
0.7388837933540344,
-0.2118898630142212,
-0.16363392770290375,
-0.46491122245788574,
1.1031414270401,
0.4861501455307007,
-0.7153298854827881,
-0.01959533803164959,
0.5256956219673157,
0.013760903850197792,
-0.0313185378909111,
0.9290732741355896,
0.38011929392814636,
0.27693432569503784,
0.4622248113155365,
-0.26307615637779236,
0.16472408175468445,
-0.721354067325592,
-0.7852028012275696,
0.530117928981781,
-0.03795615956187248,
-0.27837935090065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15930v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15930v1
|
Evaluating Prompting Strategies for Grammatical Error Correction Based on Language Proficiency
| 2024-02-24T23:17:56 | 2024-02-24T23:17:56 |
Min Zeng, Jiexin Kuang, Mengyang Qiu, Jayoung Song, Jungyeul Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The writing examples of English language learners may be different from those
of native speakers. Given that there is a significant differences in second
language (L2) learners' error types by their proficiency levels, this paper
attempts to reduce overcorrection by examining the interaction between LLM's
performance and L2 language proficiency. Our method focuses on zero-shot and
few-shot prompting and fine-tuning models for GEC for learners of English as a
foreign language based on the different proficiency. We investigate GEC results
and find that overcorrection happens primarily in advanced language learners'
writing (proficiency C) rather than proficiency A (a beginner level) and
proficiency B (an intermediate level). Fine-tuned LLMs, and even few-shot
prompting with writing examples of English learners, actually tend to exhibit
decreased recall measures. To make our claim concrete, we conduct a
comprehensive examination of GEC outcomes and their evaluation results based on
language proficiency.
|
[
-0.039181675761938095,
-1.1545788049697876,
0.5969830751419067,
-0.03933393955230713,
0.3547046184539795,
0.20500297844409943,
-0.4324055314064026,
-0.24948152899742126,
-0.2003905028104782,
-0.05103841796517372,
-0.3718084394931793,
-0.7228402495384216,
-0.5451834201812744,
0.35454148054122925,
-0.19206503033638,
0.9321117997169495,
-0.16407717764377594,
0.13728345930576324,
-0.45616236329078674,
-0.0014250498497858644,
-0.7479391098022461,
-0.39386510848999023,
-1.005505919456482,
-0.23779670894145966,
0.6567769646644592,
0.9534541964530945,
0.230282261967659,
0.17480219900608063,
0.25567033886909485,
0.3349653482437134,
-0.14271441102027893,
0.33247247338294983,
-0.6043639779090881,
-0.08538540452718735,
-0.24813567101955414,
-0.8213163018226624,
-0.49351412057876587,
-0.07317477464675903,
0.7484612464904785,
0.3914004862308502,
-0.17994700372219086,
-0.02970399148762226,
0.37010905146598816,
0.7491160035133362,
-0.8682759404182434,
0.08883535861968994,
-0.5554269552230835,
-0.11587543785572052,
-0.24228829145431519,
-0.18112416565418243,
-0.5911735892295837,
-0.37996065616607666,
-0.30603235960006714,
-0.42145106196403503,
0.42713260650634766,
-0.2410038858652115,
0.7100918292999268,
-0.08259344846010208,
-0.1961844116449356,
-0.46045413613319397,
-0.6671521663665771,
0.7165656089782715,
-0.7623323798179626,
0.12600736320018768,
0.6677571535110474,
-0.03148007392883301,
-0.002947589149698615,
-0.19746866822242737,
-0.6586875319480896,
-0.32842686772346497,
-0.06313320994377136,
0.5003595352172852,
-0.2929139733314514,
0.15970471501350403,
0.4256104528903961,
0.13049936294555664,
-0.571526288986206,
0.3777969479560852,
-0.6016324162483215,
-0.11337832361459732,
0.42465466260910034,
0.15984418988227844,
0.25067684054374695,
0.005771920550614595,
0.08571857959032059,
0.14759576320648193,
-0.8938528299331665,
0.43876469135284424,
0.6515435576438904,
0.4524415135383606,
0.015215291641652584,
0.516085147857666,
-0.19940106570720673,
0.7295114994049072,
0.06931416690349579,
-0.1958010345697403,
0.04116358235478401,
-0.18055428564548492,
0.016608865931630135,
-0.09785250574350357,
0.29017531871795654,
0.7957485318183899,
0.7005199193954468,
0.11378508806228638,
-0.1554800570011139,
0.27612996101379395,
-0.010036698542535305,
-0.3153707683086395,
0.0661749392747879,
0.010080893523991108,
-0.013550142757594585,
0.0365631990134716,
0.21670401096343994,
-0.6421972513198853,
-0.13735097646713257,
-0.208341583609581,
0.6419156789779663,
-0.31571030616760254,
0.11212356388568878,
0.15884971618652344,
0.03125136345624924,
0.03475067391991615,
0.2235642522573471,
-1.0854812860488892,
0.5044893622398376,
0.8091908693313599,
1.0086126327514648,
-0.1750541627407074,
-0.7710747718811035,
-0.5438075065612793,
-0.012682589702308178,
-0.3882785439491272,
0.7922924160957336,
-0.15554451942443848,
-0.7394601702690125,
0.6314862370491028,
-0.006680632010102272,
-0.4324391782283783,
-0.5075444579124451,
0.39421388506889343,
-0.3555220365524292,
0.2865082919597626,
-0.4219371974468231,
-0.8584951162338257,
-0.19635498523712158,
0.28322818875312805,
-0.4416048228740692,
1.0354264974594116,
0.17063018679618835,
-0.3279435932636261,
0.5193890929222107,
-0.330798476934433,
-0.728664219379425,
-0.17536567151546478,
-0.023637549951672554,
-0.28217536211013794,
0.13949136435985565,
0.1397656351327896,
0.5286542773246765,
0.14284324645996094,
-0.008620432578027248,
0.18859857320785522,
-0.582297682762146,
0.08982397615909576,
-0.31374746561050415,
0.39529719948768616,
-0.17061196267604828,
-0.26811450719833374,
-0.03235045075416565,
-0.8194396495819092,
0.13109490275382996,
-0.009380582720041275,
-0.6753302812576294,
-0.11732684820890427,
0.022431936115026474,
-0.39405086636543274,
0.020328618586063385,
0.03914308175444603,
-0.49549636244773865,
0.3031010031700134,
-0.43048566579818726,
0.21073341369628906,
0.5046411752700806,
0.1744653433561325,
0.3994944989681244,
-0.5595386624336243,
0.599882960319519,
-0.3412652015686035,
-0.040606580674648285,
-0.2897699773311615,
-0.4542786777019501,
-1.145447015762329,
0.2604182958602905,
0.025756360962986946,
0.9694696664810181,
-0.31970325112342834,
0.3821796178817749,
-0.027211114764213562,
-0.20096808671951294,
-0.5735141634941101,
0.6300572752952576,
0.8963934183120728,
0.5841090083122253,
0.4354109764099121,
-0.12266288697719574,
-0.5332645773887634,
-0.39977818727493286,
-0.3292465806007385,
-0.5544120073318481,
0.12314662337303162,
0.014243049547076225,
0.3638271987438202,
0.13505373895168304,
0.7629682421684265,
-0.3978557288646698,
-0.5446198582649231,
-0.5945385098457336,
0.1781996786594391,
0.07561938464641571,
0.4359590709209442,
0.49355989694595337,
0.2185063362121582,
-0.7508820295333862,
0.11789323389530182,
-0.3793804347515106,
-0.23404282331466675,
-0.274567574262619,
0.16816996037960052,
0.9856269359588623,
0.8845682740211487,
-0.3690531551837921,
0.47405409812927246,
0.2581348121166229,
-0.17826658487319946,
0.48012712597846985,
-0.5217076539993286,
0.3282308578491211,
-0.5767558217048645,
-0.036322157829999924,
-0.03833763673901558,
0.05480624735355377,
-0.6040656566619873,
-0.03147352486848831,
0.21000197529792786,
0.31229841709136963,
-0.24476562440395355,
0.3496822118759155,
-0.46139585971832275,
0.20384454727172852,
-0.10024617612361908,
0.1359066367149353,
0.05622221529483795,
0.30026549100875854,
-0.10625211149454117,
0.7535138726234436,
0.4330679178237915,
-0.3872305154800415,
0.12162323296070099,
0.020195668563246727,
-0.28505435585975647,
0.5698062777519226,
-0.5956209897994995,
0.2884044051170349,
-0.40652725100517273,
-0.14321264624595642,
-1.4615386724472046,
-0.1292194128036499,
0.025629164651036263,
-0.6433993577957153,
0.6567254662513733,
-0.08745896816253662,
-0.14610442519187927,
-0.4221482276916504,
-0.44394102692604065,
-0.10357068479061127,
0.6793221235275269,
-0.23608873784542084,
0.1092764139175415,
-0.3386678099632263,
-0.4068858027458191,
-0.43144670128822327,
-0.8108282089233398,
-0.09578406065702438,
0.17833107709884644,
-0.5116730332374573,
0.0020797415636479855,
0.010119962505996227,
-0.3173977732658386,
-0.2013636976480484,
0.26637503504753113,
0.3367702066898346,
-0.07767008244991302,
0.13926325738430023,
0.27055156230926514,
-0.35554882884025574,
0.22291643917560577,
-0.022480666637420654,
-0.1419779509305954,
0.012959970161318779,
0.19431741535663605,
0.3521949350833893,
-0.15181735157966614,
-0.5622037053108215,
-0.45034101605415344,
0.34655094146728516,
0.24799056351184845,
0.0517101027071476,
0.6659113168716431,
0.19067826867103577,
-0.2444411963224411,
-0.1418623924255371,
-0.9191389083862305,
-0.11416073888540268,
-0.4227599501609802,
0.42297181487083435,
-0.27504321932792664,
-0.5462657809257507,
0.7651371359825134,
0.5026171207427979,
-0.08505768328905106,
0.29920685291290283,
0.48522114753723145,
-0.3111256957054138,
0.722786545753479,
0.4113476872444153,
-0.24120377004146576,
0.2986302077770233,
-0.3040362596511841,
0.12158260494470596,
-0.35004690289497375,
-0.3592175841331482,
-0.671827495098114,
-0.21165946125984192,
-0.20171648263931274,
-0.34283292293548584,
0.11383479833602905,
0.39353063702583313,
-0.13483601808547974,
0.09462834149599075,
0.048174407333135605,
0.842013955116272,
0.6275384426116943,
0.0020439259242266417,
0.4371272325515747,
0.15890702605247498,
-0.19659164547920227,
-0.47588658332824707,
-0.7239560484886169,
-0.4664188623428345,
0.8326491713523865,
0.33076244592666626,
0.730366587638855,
0.22344915568828583,
0.5847299695014954,
0.13116227090358734,
0.10350693017244339,
-1.0779527425765991,
0.42763230204582214,
-0.26015037298202515,
-0.44501203298568726,
-0.4208964407444,
0.009895949624478817,
-0.8222567439079285,
-0.11677966266870499,
-0.22465291619300842,
-0.5992521047592163,
-0.02585649862885475,
0.4040375351905823,
-0.6500294804573059,
0.24970895051956177,
-0.8170212507247925,
0.6708120107650757,
-0.062181342393159866,
-0.4245908856391907,
-0.22593232989311218,
-0.45828327536582947,
0.12789428234100342,
0.23178213834762573,
0.06730691343545914,
0.19186823070049286,
-0.026034964248538017,
0.2888715863227844,
-0.33356916904449463,
1.0252400636672974,
-0.14237827062606812,
-0.163247749209404,
0.6723065376281738,
0.2595876157283783,
0.7186313271522522,
-0.2566174864768982,
-0.1636231243610382,
-0.1750289797782898,
-0.4920773208141327,
-0.2767156660556793,
-0.6495108008384705,
0.6865637302398682,
-0.69452303647995,
-0.7046396732330322,
-0.34761613607406616,
-0.12475737929344177,
-0.35300412774086,
-0.21635685861110687,
0.7175999879837036,
0.3058229088783264,
-0.4016917943954468,
-0.13415955007076263,
0.30051928758621216,
0.10285156220197678,
0.5959985256195068,
0.8253152966499329,
0.1032513678073883,
-0.24231958389282227,
0.7778268456459045,
0.5750676393508911,
0.6274111270904541,
0.18387185037136078,
0.1466037631034851,
-0.2647278904914856,
-0.7975862622261047,
-0.3871467709541321,
0.23297281563282013,
-0.8840822577476501,
-0.17690977454185486,
-0.356259286403656,
-0.13411028683185577,
-0.6654848456382751,
-0.5879608392715454,
0.03506471961736679,
-0.12951788306236267,
-0.4939453601837158,
-0.46544528007507324,
0.4250728189945221,
0.820186197757721,
-0.2373679131269455,
0.5435068011283875,
-0.7338206171989441,
-0.20124082267284393,
0.4368995428085327,
0.07569561898708344,
0.2733269929885864,
-0.8522512912750244,
-0.18193742632865906,
-0.25778284668922424,
-0.3030271530151367,
-0.7666860818862915,
0.009003577753901482,
0.5044816732406616,
0.5364017486572266,
0.4069107174873352,
-0.5718161463737488,
0.9273201823234558,
-0.6656014919281006,
0.907747209072113,
0.1832990199327469,
-1.157257318496704,
0.716028094291687,
-0.29646921157836914,
0.338239461183548,
0.6616621017456055,
0.256249338388443,
-0.8933929204940796,
-0.4662461280822754,
-0.525296688079834,
-0.6949252486228943,
0.6257730722427368,
-0.06418880075216293,
0.19082202017307281,
-0.303973913192749,
0.4178019165992737,
-0.1265355497598648,
-0.12497366964817047,
-0.5352371335029602,
-0.0031976858153939247,
0.22009122371673584,
-0.11864402890205383,
-0.24317209422588348,
-0.6490674018859863,
0.030108919367194176,
-0.17916743457317352,
0.8902877569198608,
-0.13445459306240082,
-0.22378723323345184,
0.3648509085178375,
-0.22746984660625458,
-0.5184200406074524,
0.5486422181129456,
0.9722301959991455,
0.6055407524108887,
0.09428619593381882,
0.048891399055719376,
0.7258016467094421,
-0.34955495595932007,
0.11095937341451645,
-0.42305201292037964,
-0.3624296188354492,
0.05785301327705383,
0.9292747974395752,
0.5895629525184631,
0.24827897548675537,
-0.32877883315086365,
0.5498992204666138,
0.4994257986545563,
-0.2662258744239807,
-0.07815758883953094,
0.2536582052707672,
0.09782366454601288,
-0.05903852730989456,
0.08069346845149994,
0.027975350618362427,
-0.050574805587530136,
-0.626548707485199,
0.07695398479700089,
0.2903561294078827,
-0.33264195919036865,
-0.3802511990070343,
0.2520541250705719,
0.3904877305030823,
-0.4016806483268738,
0.45852968096733093,
-0.4343262314796448,
-0.4200243651866913,
0.6801050305366516,
0.7261737585067749,
0.5013417601585388,
-0.5740163326263428,
0.4211944341659546,
0.7918696999549866,
0.5188295245170593,
-0.23769541084766388,
0.5493077635765076,
0.25601497292518616,
-0.664023756980896,
-0.5504022240638733,
-0.03391827642917633,
-0.18953050673007965,
0.13102994859218597,
-0.8306957483291626,
0.40922579169273376,
-0.7179811596870422,
-0.07892108708620071,
-0.1322871893644333,
-0.002751826075837016,
-0.3631422221660614,
0.002189681166782975,
0.12472674995660782,
0.7251306176185608,
-1.170965552330017,
0.5325580835342407,
0.7166814804077148,
-0.5038068294525146,
-0.8120554685592651,
-0.17215532064437866,
0.4026162922382355,
-0.9442846179008484,
0.5591933131217957,
-0.015980154275894165,
-0.32479768991470337,
-0.0685424879193306,
-0.26940619945526123,
-0.3734484612941742,
0.6788128614425659,
0.06825779378414154,
-0.941317081451416,
0.11197541654109955,
0.23033864796161652,
0.7746941447257996,
-0.09400150924921036,
0.23077744245529175,
0.7494082450866699,
0.44929149746894836,
0.05074966326355934,
-0.9183334112167358,
-0.16655996441841125,
0.02066936530172825,
0.09930809587240219,
0.033553145825862885,
-0.551186740398407,
0.8328180313110352,
-0.6106870770454407,
-0.3251129388809204,
0.4272264242172241,
0.3974159061908722,
0.14755766093730927,
0.41102951765060425,
0.25422024726867676,
0.46406179666519165,
0.7919899821281433,
-0.08330985903739929,
0.6323482990264893,
0.12804082036018372,
0.4998062252998352,
1.184051752090454,
-0.4273608326911926,
1.2734031677246094,
0.5503373742103577,
-0.47101274132728577,
0.5427343249320984,
0.20669317245483398,
-0.07898098975419998,
0.12792940437793732,
0.28622087836265564,
-0.4608609974384308,
-0.08818701654672623,
0.10406195372343063,
-0.2441115826368332,
0.211103156208992,
0.4241419732570648,
-0.32573825120925903,
-0.2860182523727417,
-0.048954837024211884,
0.3588339686393738,
0.7007802128791809,
-0.6510781645774841,
0.926762580871582,
-0.136827290058136,
-1.040248990058899,
0.8355168700218201,
0.03991317376494408,
0.7192037105560303,
-0.4377540647983551,
-0.054169755429029465,
-0.5443342924118042,
0.24038492143154144,
-0.5975388288497925,
-1.0741289854049683,
0.2319907397031784,
0.31984472274780273,
-0.44685572385787964,
0.11974363774061203,
0.7973946928977966,
-0.8587478399276733,
-0.4766204357147217,
0.26535898447036743,
0.5240088701248169,
0.17939122021198273,
0.20954087376594543,
-0.4377177655696869,
-0.15627434849739075,
-0.0005770481657236814,
0.05691677704453468,
-0.12813501060009003,
0.15564759075641632,
0.04519730806350708,
0.28683069348335266,
0.48653092980384827,
0.3484984040260315,
0.08434563875198364,
0.6091306209564209,
0.17840498685836792,
-0.49438583850860596,
-0.29264578223228455,
-1.016111135482788,
0.6638701558113098,
0.12404364347457886,
-0.6401978135108948,
0.7561535835266113,
0.4706145226955414,
0.9574185609817505,
-0.47140365839004517,
0.6828734874725342,
0.10514412075281143,
0.6260251998901367,
-0.87639981508255,
0.3412925899028778,
-0.3255004584789276,
0.06846632808446884,
-0.22960691154003143,
-0.6248700618743896,
-0.4765132665634155,
0.6854481101036072,
-0.2503604292869568,
-0.04358001425862312,
0.8117440342903137,
1.1069165468215942,
0.2932189404964447,
-0.19561047852039337,
0.6441629528999329,
0.087543785572052,
-0.10882708430290222,
0.777107834815979,
0.9329131841659546,
-0.4218131899833679,
0.4410943388938904,
-0.03549954667687416,
-0.12655125558376312,
-0.391182005405426,
-0.710776150226593,
-1.0436209440231323,
-0.31054621934890747,
-0.33025574684143066,
-0.5640636086463928,
0.37263789772987366,
0.7155863046646118,
0.13229379057884216,
-1.0321253538131714,
-0.185685396194458,
-0.35290563106536865,
0.07512608170509338,
-0.1456894427537918,
-0.18316279351711273,
0.16761769354343414,
-0.7659097909927368,
-0.9086493849754333,
0.35478663444519043,
0.0742606446146965,
0.43542101979255676,
-0.16851961612701416,
-0.27227845788002014,
-0.1660408228635788,
-0.11301892250776291,
0.6073740720748901,
0.6069085001945496,
-0.8547053933143616,
-0.3941153883934021,
0.2321694791316986,
-0.30894148349761963,
0.17103338241577148,
0.9353039860725403,
-0.44499751925468445,
0.49856963753700256,
0.7064371109008789,
0.25996410846710205,
0.036064550280570984,
0.022886188700795174,
0.48529309034347534,
-1.0394521951675415,
0.08178836852312088,
0.009294498711824417,
0.25061336159706116,
0.342720091342926,
-0.49896565079689026,
0.4118565320968628,
0.2017098218202591,
-0.5911011099815369,
-0.4044452905654907,
0.061307474970817566,
-0.5774152874946594,
-0.04778740182518959,
1.3654468059539795,
-0.4240156412124634,
0.21921154856681824,
-0.07948123663663864,
-0.5521959066390991,
0.1398572474718094,
-0.4152756929397583,
0.6256765127182007,
1.3393406867980957,
-0.04667617380619049,
-0.015915725380182266,
-0.5610578060150146,
0.6959094405174255,
0.8834973573684692,
-0.6470215916633606,
0.01597500592470169,
0.5464410781860352,
0.343808114528656,
0.16891245543956757,
0.623710036277771,
0.01593398116528988,
0.6529666781425476,
-0.12250663340091705,
-0.04820028692483902,
0.016241980716586113,
-0.5248838663101196,
-0.8748093843460083,
-0.14485536515712738,
0.4783930778503418,
-0.16520783305168152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15929v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15929v1
|
QuaCer-C: Quantitative Certification of Knowledge Comprehension in LLMs
| 2024-02-24T23:16:57 | 2024-02-24T23:16:57 |
Isha Chaudhary, Vedaant V. Jain, Gagandeep Singh
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance on
several benchmarks. However, traditional studies do not provide formal
guarantees on the performance of LLMs. In this work, we propose a novel
certification framework for LLM, QuaCer-C, wherein we formally certify the
knowledge-comprehension capabilities of popular LLMs. Our certificates are
quantitative - they consist of high-confidence, tight bounds on the probability
that the target LLM gives the correct answer on any relevant knowledge
comprehension prompt. Our certificates for the Llama, Vicuna, and Mistral LLMs
indicate that the knowledge comprehension capability improves with an increase
in the number of parameters and that the Mistral model is less performant than
the rest in this evaluation.
|
[
-0.2316797822713852,
-0.6410625576972961,
0.9524331092834473,
0.3252742886543274,
-0.19686314463615417,
0.37162357568740845,
-0.05830277502536774,
-0.43466293811798096,
-0.33333098888397217,
0.3135870695114136,
-0.03499717637896538,
-0.7130754590034485,
-0.512730598449707,
0.0001536932832095772,
-0.61223304271698,
0.37200191617012024,
-0.05453277379274368,
0.331681489944458,
-0.6984425187110901,
0.09475138038396835,
-0.2067711502313614,
-0.7565383315086365,
-0.7704260349273682,
-0.26139768958091736,
0.5981481671333313,
0.21884740889072418,
0.7147814035415649,
0.5454760789871216,
0.44136306643486023,
0.2780829668045044,
-0.4950939416885376,
-0.04327552765607834,
-0.3426842987537384,
0.024097014218568802,
-0.07746978104114532,
-0.9262767434120178,
-0.6589154601097107,
-0.09920158237218857,
0.8594561815261841,
0.6395077109336853,
-0.14882014691829681,
0.1592256724834442,
0.05243778973817825,
0.6478537917137146,
-0.9045253992080688,
0.09789961576461792,
-0.4844953715801239,
-0.07954853773117065,
0.12269613146781921,
-0.14253388345241547,
-0.5937872529029846,
-0.7238650918006897,
-0.018794160336256027,
-0.8057252168655396,
-0.20801322162151337,
0.07994747161865234,
0.42131152749061584,
0.5380468368530273,
-0.7527864575386047,
-0.06693606078624725,
-0.8611453175544739,
0.6314563751220703,
-0.513911247253418,
0.7261158227920532,
0.45847246050834656,
0.6671778559684753,
0.02816016972064972,
-0.9125939607620239,
-0.6965036392211914,
-0.3656262755393982,
0.23484665155410767,
0.17386376857757568,
0.0348682627081871,
0.34605643153190613,
0.1300244927406311,
0.5841885209083557,
-0.5438945889472961,
0.039476435631513596,
-0.43372905254364014,
-0.2223048359155655,
0.4310353696346283,
0.36362823843955994,
0.02544151060283184,
0.2864813804626465,
-0.5800427198410034,
-0.07350538671016693,
-0.8405724763870239,
0.19279126822948456,
-0.09686702489852905,
-0.4377536177635193,
-0.17761006951332092,
0.5696814060211182,
-0.44512319564819336,
0.7386116981506348,
-0.19070576131343842,
-0.7213186025619507,
-0.1415872424840927,
-0.10877028107643127,
-0.256404310464859,
-0.014609978534281254,
0.4560535252094269,
0.17313706874847412,
0.3235138952732086,
-0.21845920383930206,
-0.15102076530456543,
0.14581556618213654,
-0.2546856701374054,
-0.7233602404594421,
-0.20648892223834991,
0.5087260603904724,
-0.13889454305171967,
-0.23537643253803253,
-0.007934353314340115,
-0.08874835073947906,
-0.28653085231781006,
-0.4400665760040283,
0.6332908272743225,
-0.3042420744895935,
-0.13758942484855652,
0.4893122911453247,
-0.18527452647686005,
0.5599326491355896,
0.39849239587783813,
-0.28263550996780396,
0.25127753615379333,
0.8369085192680359,
0.6501401662826538,
-0.142607644200325,
-0.18565641343593597,
-0.0724375918507576,
0.24110986292362213,
-0.6021426916122437,
0.7714637517929077,
-0.5867159962654114,
-0.21790125966072083,
0.12456118315458298,
-0.3030721843242645,
-0.14949671924114227,
-0.3405033349990845,
0.4219217598438263,
-1.1618518829345703,
0.05397075414657593,
-0.3533027470111847,
-0.79780513048172,
-0.4168967008590698,
0.5789539813995361,
-0.6144806742668152,
1.0370566844940186,
0.34595176577568054,
-0.8869818449020386,
0.4205724895000458,
-0.08230827003717422,
-0.16952620446681976,
0.2346780002117157,
-0.2525910437107086,
0.011837349273264408,
-0.3185030221939087,
-0.049978747963905334,
0.35414478182792664,
-0.6604128479957581,
0.3172580599784851,
-0.29864537715911865,
-0.6294967532157898,
0.9215255975723267,
-0.4974445700645447,
0.6846026182174683,
0.2087472677230835,
-0.05255292356014252,
0.1311369389295578,
-0.8335443735122681,
0.22796182334423065,
-0.2000409960746765,
-0.5002393126487732,
-0.1510726362466812,
-0.354546457529068,
-0.33474746346473694,
0.1788497269153595,
0.5072197318077087,
-0.31991130113601685,
-0.1079229861497879,
-0.2693656384944916,
0.46097010374069214,
0.3908866047859192,
0.31489238142967224,
0.5644340515136719,
-0.5939523577690125,
1.1086152791976929,
0.005353500135242939,
0.36219730973243713,
0.10230525583028793,
-0.3794368505477905,
-0.9253724813461304,
-0.6894632577896118,
0.666654646396637,
0.7351112961769104,
-0.9279857277870178,
0.2907314896583557,
-0.23230668902397156,
-0.7156400084495544,
-0.38292258977890015,
0.08581657707691193,
0.5383589267730713,
0.3064964711666107,
0.22363057732582092,
0.18759725987911224,
-0.11647161096334457,
-0.5716955065727234,
-0.21352265775203705,
-0.41158369183540344,
-0.022464117035269737,
-0.00636212807148695,
0.3033161759376526,
-0.07778899371623993,
0.9396088719367981,
-0.4413789212703705,
-0.130316823720932,
-0.24168278276920319,
-0.23795749247074127,
0.05443347617983818,
0.20726758241653442,
0.42657470703125,
-0.587719738483429,
-0.4839622378349304,
-0.12377632409334183,
-0.5902488231658936,
0.12091121077537537,
0.09554535895586014,
-0.16192150115966797,
0.04897651821374893,
0.8525471091270447,
-0.24765130877494812,
0.18302251398563385,
0.7561262249946594,
-0.2350243777036667,
0.5905904769897461,
-0.14187996089458466,
0.16079267859458923,
-0.8143097162246704,
0.06363047659397125,
-0.2523530125617981,
-0.46888700127601624,
-0.4668988883495331,
0.22520340979099274,
0.25939348340034485,
0.13263066112995148,
-0.7237881422042847,
0.6999989151954651,
-0.36201101541519165,
0.10178939253091812,
0.0929785966873169,
0.3761659264564514,
0.11168175935745239,
0.2866705656051636,
0.16087140142917633,
0.7954780459403992,
0.6751182079315186,
-1.0337730646133423,
0.2307901531457901,
0.3780381977558136,
-0.37858185172080994,
0.783272385597229,
-1.0179953575134277,
-0.009609765373170376,
0.020483890548348427,
0.3689136803150177,
-0.9173914790153503,
-0.32365792989730835,
0.04126675799489021,
-0.55037522315979,
-0.0673537626862526,
-0.22724232077598572,
-0.43563610315322876,
-0.279569149017334,
-0.15567082166671753,
0.7416175007820129,
0.42303967475891113,
-0.5961564779281616,
0.590721070766449,
0.12449312955141068,
0.03726111352443695,
-0.44130077958106995,
-0.8566373586654663,
-0.18719732761383057,
-0.2285296767950058,
-0.6716616153717041,
-0.034072693437337875,
-0.28902849555015564,
-0.3929952085018158,
-0.24984759092330933,
0.018818730488419533,
-0.36009421944618225,
0.31812870502471924,
0.24066653847694397,
0.15249603986740112,
-0.38341012597084045,
0.11931326985359192,
0.36072269082069397,
-0.2642562687397003,
0.2609238624572754,
-0.2262265533208847,
0.21212926506996155,
-0.086035817861557,
-0.6973084807395935,
-0.43287718296051025,
0.005119697656482458,
0.7407962083816528,
-0.4520872235298157,
0.7986302971839905,
0.37370529770851135,
-0.40544483065605164,
-0.10208836197853088,
-0.7045255899429321,
-0.06486749649047852,
-0.5065767168998718,
0.006888024043291807,
-0.65436190366745,
-1.4122971296310425,
0.5110986828804016,
-0.1586472988128662,
-0.24690347909927368,
0.2541970908641815,
0.33143898844718933,
0.09058395773172379,
0.9641725420951843,
0.280876100063324,
-0.045065734535455704,
0.15248847007751465,
-0.11143997311592102,
0.08552589267492294,
-0.7450228333473206,
-0.46665701270103455,
-0.6815497279167175,
0.11289791017770767,
-0.42415812611579895,
-0.6607215404510498,
0.7456423044204712,
0.5556910037994385,
-0.5370820760726929,
-0.1141371876001358,
-0.36899489164352417,
0.5562472939491272,
0.48009732365608215,
0.09740649163722992,
0.8331223726272583,
-0.29477497935295105,
-0.17446283996105194,
0.05725431814789772,
-0.8230202198028564,
-0.9036998152732849,
0.9752437472343445,
0.5695666670799255,
0.5357811450958252,
0.4205339252948761,
0.5774685740470886,
0.14729037880897522,
0.33101487159729004,
-0.7581301331520081,
0.6775605082511902,
0.17877857387065887,
-0.7915840744972229,
-0.40461480617523193,
-0.402739554643631,
-0.8641323447227478,
0.38687822222709656,
-0.23224203288555145,
-0.4708501100540161,
0.2900511622428894,
0.11649836599826813,
-0.44233348965644836,
-0.02451189234852791,
-0.3291442096233368,
0.6640514731407166,
-0.23515290021896362,
0.03063488006591797,
-0.2149825394153595,
-0.3141288757324219,
0.7346121072769165,
-0.21106752753257751,
0.1327635943889618,
-0.1680801808834076,
-0.493682861328125,
0.6786780953407288,
-0.1711329072713852,
0.7079463005065918,
-0.1920551359653473,
-0.1847413033246994,
0.4335378408432007,
0.3906758725643158,
0.4126342236995697,
0.3944171369075775,
-0.23854592442512512,
-0.18591231107711792,
0.5356559753417969,
-0.4353504180908203,
-0.5087095499038696,
0.37028059363365173,
-0.658717691898346,
-0.48893237113952637,
-0.4882689118385315,
-0.25042060017585754,
-0.4747160077095032,
0.10029289126396179,
0.2128426730632782,
0.1618342101573944,
-0.43676382303237915,
0.27095577120780945,
1.0202122926712036,
-0.17369672656059265,
-0.009824270382523537,
0.7157291173934937,
-0.1464284062385559,
-0.8510222434997559,
0.7110158801078796,
-0.1728137731552124,
0.4719140827655792,
0.6657959222793579,
0.016981257125735283,
-0.4851716160774231,
-0.8119069337844849,
-0.1056147962808609,
0.24654190242290497,
-0.9998682141304016,
-0.27536696195602417,
-0.6035794019699097,
-0.46408724784851074,
-0.18998956680297852,
-0.1338677853345871,
-0.023180508986115456,
-0.6504724025726318,
-0.283850759267807,
-0.09173993766307831,
0.44478827714920044,
0.8118576407432556,
0.18354441225528717,
0.5243578553199768,
-0.7246500253677368,
0.2122124582529068,
0.5822437405586243,
0.1784081608057022,
-0.024633681401610374,
-0.894844651222229,
-0.24441960453987122,
-0.06164511293172836,
-0.12358573824167252,
-0.7256205677986145,
-0.0014379825443029404,
0.11487434059381485,
0.7014092803001404,
0.5879520177841187,
0.3297385275363922,
0.6084151864051819,
0.05320797488093376,
0.8175952434539795,
0.07767795026302338,
-1.2297227382659912,
0.31668832898139954,
-0.40766116976737976,
0.22953881323337555,
0.6978659629821777,
0.4379076361656189,
-0.42966705560684204,
-0.8035092353820801,
-0.5386269092559814,
-0.697600781917572,
0.029862692579627037,
-0.11644390970468521,
-0.052780140191316605,
-0.051128219813108444,
0.5982930660247803,
-0.20476189255714417,
0.10653343051671982,
-0.6019902229309082,
-0.04828430339694023,
0.2639821767807007,
-0.170048788189888,
0.020033400505781174,
-0.6338840126991272,
-0.13825945556163788,
-0.236471027135849,
0.6463350653648376,
-0.18912005424499512,
0.08139754831790924,
0.4558933675289154,
-0.3993666172027588,
0.259065181016922,
0.3724553883075714,
0.6604728698730469,
0.9328864812850952,
0.16825640201568604,
0.3562566936016083,
0.5021058320999146,
-0.2821806073188782,
0.33203306794166565,
-0.21401511132717133,
-0.1014149859547615,
-0.33285149931907654,
0.5801191926002502,
0.25837746262550354,
0.44601020216941833,
-0.5247648358345032,
0.7260786890983582,
-0.13069404661655426,
-0.5214955806732178,
-0.6763707399368286,
0.3748416006565094,
0.47895023226737976,
0.5809717178344727,
0.34397533535957336,
-0.4509580135345459,
0.17474517226219177,
-0.059188127517700195,
-0.028689060360193253,
0.14322757720947266,
-0.37434762716293335,
-0.08026154339313507,
0.7627594470977783,
0.1539331078529358,
0.2910793125629425,
0.3489505350589752,
-0.39596331119537354,
-0.6815692782402039,
0.40459808707237244,
0.4929119646549225,
0.5556949973106384,
-0.2799800634384155,
0.19055373966693878,
0.5508190393447876,
0.2533490061759949,
-0.3169558346271515,
0.6340608596801758,
-0.19359168410301208,
-0.6113774180412292,
-0.6571117043495178,
-0.6819284558296204,
-0.8302563428878784,
-0.20574572682380676,
-0.9067542552947998,
-0.14589060842990875,
-0.6457328796386719,
-0.26137012243270874,
-0.5347161889076233,
-0.05860617011785507,
-0.5688697695732117,
0.36588552594184875,
0.02085484005510807,
1.4296835660934448,
-0.7778558135032654,
0.9584580659866333,
0.5705826878547668,
-0.3470468819141388,
-1.0081796646118164,
-0.19473481178283691,
-0.32380348443984985,
-0.7615076899528503,
0.46439218521118164,
-0.3570443093776703,
-0.2048289179801941,
0.19855709373950958,
-0.4137871563434601,
-0.8771427273750305,
1.586840271949768,
0.6082984209060669,
-0.7644472718238831,
0.1887568235397339,
0.43224650621414185,
0.5497946739196777,
-0.1091528832912445,
0.11320195347070694,
0.8243353366851807,
0.7209603190422058,
0.3340509831905365,
-0.790955126285553,
0.16596080362796783,
0.2283872663974762,
0.16137875616550446,
-0.20952288806438446,
-0.59421306848526,
0.39949318766593933,
-0.15307265520095825,
-0.13138070702552795,
0.3811206817626953,
0.9160436391830444,
0.9043594002723694,
0.46862560510635376,
0.4088578224182129,
0.4027556777000427,
1.119827151298523,
-0.2113744169473648,
0.9511711597442627,
-0.5763593912124634,
-0.04650023952126503,
1.1253526210784912,
-0.05157387629151344,
1.2269601821899414,
0.2944479286670685,
-0.4982490837574005,
0.46378660202026367,
0.732865571975708,
0.3584292531013489,
0.030668925493955612,
0.34303712844848633,
-0.4958180785179138,
-0.6767148375511169,
-0.1282242387533188,
-0.5013807415962219,
0.32163286209106445,
0.38062259554862976,
-0.14463403820991516,
0.47040119767189026,
-0.31962817907333374,
-0.017529835924506187,
0.16238915920257568,
-0.3877471387386322,
0.7545463442802429,
0.5892900228500366,
-0.5091283917427063,
0.7013076543807983,
-0.016972480341792107,
0.30807772278785706,
-0.3733906149864197,
0.35573774576187134,
-0.29526740312576294,
0.1841026097536087,
-0.2559641897678375,
-0.736971378326416,
0.05306925252079964,
-0.22686749696731567,
0.12307660281658173,
0.25373685359954834,
0.5931655168533325,
-0.5286470055580139,
-0.453514963388443,
0.18320506811141968,
0.6513482332229614,
0.17508633434772491,
-0.34410274028778076,
-0.42935046553611755,
0.03604986146092415,
-0.28344371914863586,
-0.10375405848026276,
0.06093757972121239,
0.7591186165809631,
-0.03387904167175293,
1.000487208366394,
0.5324910283088684,
0.10135885328054428,
0.22602388262748718,
0.2208305299282074,
0.702033519744873,
-0.5741530656814575,
-0.6107902526855469,
-0.5109967589378357,
0.5860679745674133,
0.1884629726409912,
-0.1571742743253708,
0.69276362657547,
0.5909286141395569,
0.7334655523300171,
0.04505341500043869,
0.6746364831924438,
0.49723196029663086,
0.2658833861351013,
-0.707609236240387,
0.7138748168945312,
-0.355095237493515,
0.3958631455898285,
0.0682414099574089,
-1.0843561887741089,
-0.5532121062278748,
0.4433788061141968,
-0.3268245458602905,
0.24282506108283997,
0.8774863481521606,
0.7887284755706787,
0.16118715703487396,
-0.14453765749931335,
0.8059849739074707,
0.1577872931957245,
0.07040192931890488,
0.6293018460273743,
1.3089507818222046,
-0.3247357904911041,
0.7284192442893982,
0.02637217566370964,
-0.246441051363945,
-0.15020304918289185,
-0.7459432482719421,
-1.11583411693573,
-0.5754189491271973,
-0.4572826027870178,
-0.38226476311683655,
0.09237167239189148,
0.49115636944770813,
0.7250467538833618,
-0.5875949859619141,
-0.05099564790725708,
-0.02233130671083927,
0.20002444088459015,
-0.11804017424583435,
-0.17381806671619415,
0.1711898297071457,
-0.2171165645122528,
-0.28781822323799133,
0.3479168713092804,
0.0648035779595375,
0.30212634801864624,
-0.4947408139705658,
-0.5958045125007629,
0.4118524193763733,
0.41306084394454956,
0.5976045727729797,
0.1864679902791977,
-0.7488336563110352,
0.016627095639705658,
-0.026158342137932777,
-0.3271962106227875,
-0.12730535864830017,
0.7697927355766296,
-0.6615673899650574,
0.0133053595200181,
0.6121155023574829,
0.47978493571281433,
0.47746527194976807,
-0.050624992698431015,
0.46136826276779175,
-0.34147006273269653,
0.08547596633434296,
0.305709570646286,
0.3582993149757385,
0.26039502024650574,
-0.27458348870277405,
0.2942032217979431,
-0.23893310129642487,
-0.6947627067565918,
-0.7201587557792664,
0.19915524125099182,
-1.2051384449005127,
-0.07759755104780197,
1.3620738983154297,
-0.2908903956413269,
-0.22912172973155975,
-0.40515613555908203,
-0.020545342937111855,
0.09046197682619095,
-0.16166198253631592,
0.34641218185424805,
0.44484272599220276,
0.3813253343105316,
-0.2232508808374405,
-0.33560189604759216,
0.3707204759120941,
0.40498846769332886,
-0.7239351868629456,
-0.08421038836240768,
0.3173994719982147,
0.48217496275901794,
-0.09900924563407898,
0.8085149526596069,
-0.45617297291755676,
0.5503086447715759,
-0.10680611431598663,
0.041570160537958145,
0.015540625900030136,
-0.4588841199874878,
-0.4676220118999481,
0.17959091067314148,
1.1238067150115967,
0.015861252322793007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15925v1
|
MultiContrievers: Analysis of Dense Retrieval Representations
| 2024-02-24T23:01:21 | 2024-02-24T23:01:21 |
Seraphina Goldfarb-Tarrant, Pedro Rodriguez, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Patrick Lewis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Dense retrievers compress source documents into (possibly lossy) vector
representations, yet there is little analysis of what information is lost
versus preserved, and how it affects downstream tasks. We conduct the first
analysis of the information captured by dense retrievers compared to the
language models they are based on (e.g., BERT versus Contriever). We use 25
MultiBert checkpoints as randomized initialisations to train MultiContrievers,
a set of 25 contriever models. We test whether specific pieces of information
-- such as gender and occupation -- can be extracted from contriever vectors of
wikipedia-like documents. We measure this extractability via information
theoretic probing. We then examine the relationship of extractability to
performance and gender bias, as well as the sensitivity of these results to
many random initialisations and data shuffles. We find that (1) contriever
models have significantly increased extractability, but extractability usually
correlates poorly with benchmark performance 2) gender bias is present, but is
not caused by the contriever representations 3) there is high sensitivity to
both random initialisation and to data shuffle, suggesting that future
retrieval research should test across a wider spread of both.
|
[
-0.5328348278999329,
-0.5531200766563416,
0.3681676983833313,
0.026210090145468712,
0.11029000580310822,
0.0484529584646225,
-0.2762059271335602,
-0.5883698463439941,
-0.09500284492969513,
0.206633523106575,
-0.5909404158592224,
0.0025551882572472095,
-0.90096116065979,
0.08937010914087296,
-0.7693760991096497,
0.7042672634124756,
0.23555447161197662,
0.34413328766822815,
-0.055431365966796875,
-0.16970370709896088,
-0.5710409283638,
-0.756947934627533,
-0.5653923749923706,
-0.18018431961536407,
0.6625671982765198,
0.5753695964813232,
0.55003821849823,
0.27706822752952576,
0.41393807530403137,
0.3297938406467438,
-0.11965078860521317,
0.003782468382269144,
-0.8415982127189636,
0.20007862150669098,
-0.14433985948562622,
-0.4058997333049774,
0.5558017492294312,
0.30980396270751953,
0.7039183974266052,
0.6148824095726013,
-0.3890203535556793,
0.24641720950603485,
0.26392462849617004,
0.6074177622795105,
-0.7482547163963318,
-0.06173153221607208,
-0.7644919157028198,
0.05253733694553375,
-0.21668648719787598,
-0.13773679733276367,
-0.5487304329872131,
-0.5003450512886047,
0.5341545343399048,
-0.47766798734664917,
0.7338911890983582,
0.28001388907432556,
0.6081071496009827,
-0.028530722483992577,
-0.44857317209243774,
-0.6299684047698975,
-0.8758776187896729,
1.0731722116470337,
-0.14103908836841583,
0.698530912399292,
-0.03234701603651047,
0.4752275347709656,
-0.12911449372768402,
-0.6031787395477295,
-0.5322636961936951,
-0.3605639636516571,
-0.19493582844734192,
-0.04385080188512802,
-0.03165905550122261,
-0.15488511323928833,
0.380384236574173,
0.32101064920425415,
-0.44747400283813477,
0.01262859907001257,
-0.6063315272331238,
-0.24453991651535034,
0.5212160348892212,
-0.1723351627588272,
0.3413294553756714,
-0.1681433767080307,
-0.38231945037841797,
-0.32695508003234863,
-0.3742068111896515,
0.06983557343482971,
0.5860616564750671,
0.1808696836233139,
0.14990366995334625,
0.8125664591789246,
-0.023212188854813576,
0.21018292009830475,
0.016720304265618324,
0.11973895877599716,
0.17029623687267303,
-0.37893548607826233,
0.18782083690166473,
0.24812400341033936,
0.6664847135543823,
-0.09123893827199936,
0.491454154253006,
-0.4290109872817993,
0.09539242833852768,
-0.36530542373657227,
0.3911221921443939,
-0.8289334774017334,
-0.2596307098865509,
0.2346530705690384,
-0.9072049260139465,
0.0499969981610775,
0.24405531585216522,
-0.6923840641975403,
-0.4743812382221222,
-0.5155324339866638,
0.11279081553220749,
-0.8072285652160645,
-0.4452545940876007,
-0.004154758527874947,
-0.8370895385742188,
0.380802184343338,
0.291461706161499,
-0.934487521648407,
0.21436268091201782,
0.617895245552063,
0.6207537055015564,
-0.25471973419189453,
-0.31069353222846985,
-0.47455263137817383,
0.08244309574365616,
-0.05370929837226868,
0.7140457630157471,
-0.5757567882537842,
-0.25065457820892334,
0.05625883489847183,
-0.04327290877699852,
-0.14672210812568665,
-0.5430232286453247,
0.6331915259361267,
-0.4325948655605316,
0.041525401175022125,
-0.7903927564620972,
-0.5482407212257385,
-0.1896854043006897,
0.23518650233745575,
-1.0970534086227417,
1.1822665929794312,
0.03668461740016937,
-1.0339019298553467,
0.5270905494689941,
-0.1751537173986435,
0.21355703473091125,
-0.16070668399333954,
-0.5877858996391296,
-0.11457967013120651,
0.23472949862480164,
-0.08028928935527802,
0.3876320719718933,
-0.3986297845840454,
0.23526425659656525,
-0.534367024898529,
-0.4408056437969208,
0.3973578214645386,
-0.4889201521873474,
0.9351391196250916,
0.08251053839921951,
-0.06691713631153107,
-0.46107351779937744,
-0.7797315120697021,
-0.17872577905654907,
0.014359871856868267,
-0.48799967765808105,
-0.564518392086029,
0.21862976253032684,
0.1962285190820694,
0.3767305612564087,
0.25569653511047363,
-0.8049225211143494,
0.05880327150225639,
0.2190035879611969,
0.09335123002529144,
0.62795090675354,
-0.03261762112379074,
0.5703203082084656,
-0.22450228035449982,
0.27075618505477905,
0.3674289584159851,
0.10054834187030792,
0.29008030891418457,
-0.23052795231342316,
-0.5950613617897034,
-0.27945375442504883,
0.3238058090209961,
0.39878302812576294,
-0.6944403052330017,
-0.16274824738502502,
-0.19816315174102783,
-0.7169665098190308,
-0.4331585764884949,
0.22506903111934662,
0.31134939193725586,
0.2232121378183365,
0.22813236713409424,
-0.2954893112182617,
-0.6701648831367493,
-1.09757399559021,
-0.5897400379180908,
-0.011988557875156403,
0.11388249695301056,
0.26678362488746643,
0.5587573647499084,
-0.15094706416130066,
0.7638814449310303,
-0.4215297996997833,
0.029784655198454857,
-0.12089705467224121,
0.42297813296318054,
0.12025705724954605,
0.7259426116943359,
0.5388681888580322,
-1.0050071477890015,
-0.021824663504958153,
-0.22203393280506134,
-0.8619621396064758,
0.44463014602661133,
-0.054327014833688736,
-0.2584521770477295,
-0.38069432973861694,
0.5955591797828674,
-0.9018100500106812,
0.11139701306819916,
0.2539050877094269,
-0.1290227174758911,
0.8082438707351685,
-0.2666190564632416,
-0.032637130469083786,
-0.5667093396186829,
0.2999218702316284,
0.050735265016555786,
0.08565612137317657,
-0.4502164125442505,
0.008793800137937069,
0.1526549607515335,
-0.036957260221242905,
-0.597928524017334,
0.3425602316856384,
-0.734524130821228,
-0.2077837884426117,
0.2207467406988144,
0.03392200171947479,
-0.005374504718929529,
0.33914878964424133,
-0.10014207661151886,
0.7780640125274658,
0.05840988829731941,
-0.7326451539993286,
-0.0012718954822048545,
0.29838818311691284,
-0.35437560081481934,
0.5431638956069946,
-0.5299543738365173,
0.21673408150672913,
-0.7375918030738831,
0.1277061551809311,
-1.1438828706741333,
-0.02263701520860195,
-0.06637659668922424,
-0.461342453956604,
0.4693544805049896,
-0.05400480702519417,
-0.6800119280815125,
-0.3444351553916931,
-0.422617107629776,
0.3403242826461792,
-0.01183047704398632,
-0.41339191794395447,
0.6171424984931946,
0.3954600691795349,
-0.015648074448108673,
-0.9034755229949951,
-0.6348658204078674,
-0.39638182520866394,
-0.23018591105937958,
-0.3332137167453766,
0.138336643576622,
-0.31480515003204346,
-0.19985808432102203,
-0.15536756813526154,
-0.06965559720993042,
-0.31047284603118896,
0.19171656668186188,
0.10037271678447723,
-0.005410608369857073,
-0.01980971172451973,
0.2543528079986572,
-0.0733502060174942,
0.08274897187948227,
0.21462197601795197,
-0.06927289068698883,
0.4970962703227997,
0.0991063117980957,
-0.08909231424331665,
-0.033295389264822006,
0.6940494179725647,
0.21616126596927643,
-0.29349157214164734,
1.0387420654296875,
0.9693202972412109,
-0.4897686541080475,
-0.05968299135565758,
-0.851549506187439,
-0.24111348390579224,
-0.45052486658096313,
0.29907315969467163,
-0.3946455121040344,
-0.7681329250335693,
0.6739640235900879,
-0.008934530429542065,
0.17452175915241241,
0.7030007839202881,
0.39944013953208923,
-0.3608541786670685,
0.8390496969223022,
0.7676350474357605,
0.1173701211810112,
0.6960561871528625,
-0.5419759750366211,
-0.13944540917873383,
-0.805848240852356,
-0.7100085616111755,
-1.0228252410888672,
-0.4365590214729309,
-0.7655698657035828,
0.059775616973638535,
-0.014022077433764935,
0.24598121643066406,
-0.3547767102718353,
0.3483118712902069,
-0.6374526619911194,
0.485564261674881,
0.7246849536895752,
0.12666979432106018,
0.14471405744552612,
-0.01912015490233898,
-0.14274679124355316,
-0.3238675892353058,
-0.8849495649337769,
-0.33039286732673645,
1.143236756324768,
0.15413415431976318,
0.7512097954750061,
0.2752073407173157,
0.6682767868041992,
0.2352365255355835,
0.3746088445186615,
-0.47563880681991577,
0.14691460132598877,
-0.3203531503677368,
-0.9772867560386658,
-0.07551535218954086,
-0.5846168398857117,
-1.1540091037750244,
0.4370979964733124,
-0.38351255655288696,
-0.7605336308479309,
0.7909521460533142,
-0.26266008615493774,
-0.27559611201286316,
0.018354259431362152,
-0.8192514777183533,
0.7375722527503967,
-0.21612074971199036,
-0.2381698191165924,
-0.18004967272281647,
-0.559945285320282,
0.6623427271842957,
-0.026479976251721382,
0.22573137283325195,
-0.2010185420513153,
0.06690314412117004,
1.0040911436080933,
0.09762716293334961,
0.48177972435951233,
-0.2505089342594147,
0.023399807512760162,
0.3218352496623993,
0.26110512018203735,
0.2587100565433502,
0.12864969670772552,
-0.3496464490890503,
0.14450454711914062,
0.2986905574798584,
-0.35205113887786865,
-0.4677971601486206,
0.5529431700706482,
-1.0004827976226807,
-0.24233317375183105,
-0.45920005440711975,
-0.5186299085617065,
0.2223176807165146,
0.31993532180786133,
0.3186336159706116,
0.5940210223197937,
-0.42692989110946655,
0.4282837212085724,
0.955612063407898,
-0.21406523883342743,
0.46229231357574463,
0.31449609994888306,
0.18541020154953003,
-0.12548784911632538,
0.717705249786377,
0.5428024530410767,
-0.045885421335697174,
0.4149415194988251,
0.053506240248680115,
-0.44904449582099915,
-0.36126023530960083,
-0.14355352520942688,
0.12590259313583374,
-0.9261963367462158,
-0.01014656014740467,
-0.8102330565452576,
-0.2239525467157364,
-0.1133337914943695,
0.1974012404680252,
-0.39463505148887634,
-0.40985211730003357,
-0.5447081923484802,
0.08380594104528427,
0.06382334977388382,
0.6618565320968628,
0.07033435255289078,
0.3061714768409729,
-0.7640733122825623,
0.422492653131485,
0.29827040433883667,
0.07477657496929169,
0.20980305969715118,
-0.27557137608528137,
-0.3584163784980774,
-0.10043933242559433,
-0.3657177686691284,
-0.9511120915412903,
0.13121134042739868,
0.11654037237167358,
0.846342146396637,
0.3500951826572418,
-0.13772715628147125,
0.5362412333488464,
-0.4858379364013672,
0.6643763184547424,
0.1855344921350479,
-0.6895089149475098,
0.1976318210363388,
-0.1327604055404663,
0.033487122505903244,
0.9436640739440918,
0.6048535108566284,
-0.3482916057109833,
-0.36155492067337036,
-0.8257333040237427,
-0.5864837765693665,
0.6496507525444031,
0.23762962222099304,
0.08087366819381714,
-0.1506313979625702,
0.6705284118652344,
0.3582763671875,
0.3124123513698578,
-0.45737922191619873,
-0.2889651358127594,
0.0010283704614266753,
-0.12512564659118652,
-0.033470772206783295,
-0.5923733115196228,
0.004829161800444126,
-0.12855391204357147,
0.23981274664402008,
0.07424768060445786,
0.44652003049850464,
0.35964956879615784,
-0.4585661292076111,
0.2172689586877823,
0.10671922564506531,
0.27232736349105835,
0.6974575519561768,
-0.43881943821907043,
0.38609257340431213,
-0.03378552570939064,
-0.562126636505127,
0.21575480699539185,
0.26392537355422974,
0.10385499894618988,
0.29430365562438965,
0.3582802712917328,
0.2028254121541977,
0.46980395913124084,
-0.6610091924667358,
0.5106009244918823,
-0.5406973361968994,
0.07188452780246735,
-0.5711776614189148,
0.02517138607800007,
-0.04766298457980156,
0.4404624104499817,
0.6846954226493835,
0.11048033833503723,
0.5764421224594116,
-0.6622127890586853,
0.19889205694198608,
0.66905677318573,
-0.2998492121696472,
-0.12861409783363342,
0.7033633589744568,
-0.04255448281764984,
0.052758146077394485,
0.9161521196365356,
-0.08607032150030136,
-0.28754228353500366,
0.6692059636116028,
0.1471736878156662,
0.6736094951629639,
-0.08318524807691574,
0.008476967923343182,
0.6165454387664795,
0.5683655738830566,
-0.3571169078350067,
0.3096410930156708,
0.07318022102117538,
-0.7019717693328857,
-0.2903989255428314,
-0.28201642632484436,
-0.31219935417175293,
-0.1404329091310501,
-0.8079625368118286,
0.2295483499765396,
-0.13038486242294312,
-0.17676179111003876,
0.2538692355155945,
0.2587120234966278,
-1.1840956211090088,
0.1309662163257599,
0.06084116920828819,
1.006685495376587,
-0.569607138633728,
0.5890835523605347,
0.1432914286851883,
-0.6651406288146973,
-0.6564638018608093,
-0.24177516996860504,
-0.19954873621463776,
-0.5259108543395996,
0.6473096609115601,
0.49007636308670044,
0.23016926646232605,
-0.0016289666527882218,
-0.8103888630867004,
-1.1145033836364746,
1.2006243467330933,
0.809982180595398,
-0.6330668330192566,
-0.2423495054244995,
-0.09061655402183533,
0.20145300030708313,
-0.03701251372694969,
0.812809407711029,
0.7454423308372498,
0.3985622525215149,
-0.2155611217021942,
-0.5273197889328003,
0.017777472734451294,
-0.03954598307609558,
0.06846708804368973,
-0.10654078423976898,
-0.6784233450889587,
1.162992238998413,
0.05413287505507469,
-0.3499840795993805,
-0.12379807978868484,
0.7222868800163269,
0.4382466971874237,
-0.04153874143958092,
0.3370184302330017,
0.3130461573600769,
1.0914924144744873,
-0.04399528354406357,
1.4029772281646729,
-0.055250946432352066,
0.44845137000083923,
0.978056013584137,
0.0738024190068245,
0.7590646147727966,
0.657802164554596,
0.06470811367034912,
0.511963427066803,
0.6500980257987976,
0.13968349993228912,
0.42330697178840637,
0.24423159658908844,
0.03801639750599861,
-0.021752508357167244,
-0.08664840459823608,
-0.40993210673332214,
0.370262086391449,
0.26548755168914795,
-0.41362711787223816,
-0.27072006464004517,
-0.19690394401550293,
-0.05292774736881256,
-0.2172500640153885,
-0.044396717101335526,
0.6069178581237793,
0.22437062859535217,
-0.7041140198707581,
0.5238579511642456,
-0.02286645956337452,
0.49217477440834045,
-0.5268252491950989,
-0.03955654799938202,
-0.1966884881258011,
0.1766040027141571,
-0.1803206503391266,
-0.6937144994735718,
0.1790987104177475,
-0.3187080919742584,
-0.4400712251663208,
-0.008981682360172272,
0.9115754961967468,
-0.6995322108268738,
-0.4842096269130707,
0.5109601616859436,
0.6801348328590393,
0.14021748304367065,
-0.25580281019210815,
-0.7299165725708008,
0.18835099041461945,
-0.1609249711036682,
-0.2568458020687103,
0.17256326973438263,
0.7449843883514404,
0.03037741407752037,
0.7133004069328308,
0.7076042294502258,
-0.1084485724568367,
0.5463998913764954,
-0.007057621609419584,
0.8084696531295776,
-0.6682795286178589,
-0.029979899525642395,
-0.9371681809425354,
0.3855181038379669,
-0.17543074488639832,
-0.2990416884422302,
0.9215917587280273,
0.8205729722976685,
0.665631115436554,
-0.029069937765598297,
0.6099498271942139,
-0.006343943066895008,
0.29127249121665955,
-0.46170148253440857,
0.6875798106193542,
-0.30664724111557007,
-0.23847873508930206,
-0.30241185426712036,
-1.1684740781784058,
0.19462037086486816,
0.23196257650852203,
0.036058470606803894,
-0.0216667577624321,
0.7077733874320984,
0.4765867590904236,
-0.39955317974090576,
0.11150642484426498,
-0.12782326340675354,
0.030023077502846718,
0.29659613966941833,
0.5377276539802551,
1.0811409950256348,
-0.4565792977809906,
0.7161312103271484,
-0.06697490811347961,
-0.03640657663345337,
-0.15470242500305176,
-0.6380401253700256,
-0.7444338202476501,
-0.4885621964931488,
-0.02428095042705536,
-0.32610443234443665,
-0.17709290981292725,
0.5013890266418457,
0.6965494155883789,
-0.5311605930328369,
-0.24803674221038818,
0.1059647649526596,
0.304132878780365,
-0.18004155158996582,
-0.19685450196266174,
0.21215730905532837,
-0.3565773665904999,
-0.5575918555259705,
0.11420666426420212,
-0.29827234148979187,
-0.11238318681716919,
-0.48327624797821045,
-0.12231246381998062,
-0.48946309089660645,
0.003677966073155403,
0.47556155920028687,
0.12955939769744873,
-0.2931795120239258,
-0.24514442682266235,
-0.1896948367357254,
-0.19127365946769714,
0.02033102512359619,
1.0070782899856567,
-0.6467441320419312,
0.5863431096076965,
0.5187437534332275,
0.67999666929245,
0.8314951658248901,
-0.02498815394937992,
0.47876065969467163,
-0.9689967632293701,
0.3363479971885681,
0.07735652476549149,
0.39160940051078796,
0.385768324136734,
-0.362867146730423,
0.4058821201324463,
0.14157387614250183,
-0.4377247393131256,
-0.7201177477836609,
-0.10762813687324524,
-0.8097230195999146,
-0.24891187250614166,
1.0838404893875122,
0.164719358086586,
-0.0595293827354908,
-0.22869031131267548,
-0.2494436353445053,
0.5055676698684692,
-0.5367980003356934,
0.6215036511421204,
1.037126898765564,
0.19893799722194672,
-0.2876848876476288,
-1.0186508893966675,
0.48207369446754456,
0.20152056217193604,
-0.49913933873176575,
-0.13768717646598816,
0.38491350412368774,
0.396639347076416,
0.33023425936698914,
0.6745269298553467,
-0.13975510001182556,
0.23693615198135376,
-0.08405672758817673,
0.12980790436267853,
0.3175928592681885,
-0.33465099334716797,
-0.2699795961380005,
0.3493375778198242,
-0.028648577630519867,
-0.12645532190799713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15911v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15911v1
|
PRP: Propagating Universal Perturbations to Attack Large Language Model Guard-Rails
| 2024-02-24T21:27:13 | 2024-02-24T21:27:13 |
Neal Mangaokar, Ashish Hooda, Jihye Choi, Shreyas Chandrashekaran, Kassem Fawaz, Somesh Jha, Atul Prakash
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are typically aligned to be harmless to humans.
Unfortunately, recent work has shown that such models are susceptible to
automated jailbreak attacks that induce them to generate harmful content. More
recent LLMs often incorporate an additional layer of defense, a Guard Model,
which is a second LLM that is designed to check and moderate the output
response of the primary LLM. Our key contribution is to show a novel attack
strategy, PRP, that is successful against several open-source (e.g., Llama 2)
and closed-source (e.g., GPT 3.5) implementations of Guard Models. PRP
leverages a two step prefix-based attack that operates by (a) constructing a
universal adversarial prefix for the Guard Model, and (b) propagating this
prefix to the response. We find that this procedure is effective across
multiple threat models, including ones in which the adversary has no access to
the Guard Model at all. Our work suggests that further advances are required on
defenses and Guard Models before they can be considered effective.
|
[
-0.3137578070163727,
-1.14205002784729,
0.463590532541275,
0.3132862150669098,
-0.27545610070228577,
0.033334217965602875,
-0.14632374048233032,
-0.39373764395713806,
0.14522014558315277,
0.9247055053710938,
-0.2653573155403137,
-0.3705521821975708,
-0.7433265447616577,
-0.16188962757587433,
-0.580985963344574,
0.7739494442939758,
0.2508823275566101,
-0.04083709418773651,
0.4298536777496338,
0.33666303753852844,
-0.5498848557472229,
-0.8285287618637085,
-0.7138762474060059,
-0.1620560735464096,
0.4955660104751587,
0.2779256999492645,
0.864527702331543,
0.37920859456062317,
0.7239201068878174,
0.1972520351409912,
-0.22278839349746704,
-0.1021668016910553,
-0.17527058720588684,
0.5134919285774231,
-0.21641607582569122,
-0.3559982180595398,
-0.5669378638267517,
-0.12265922129154205,
0.7294974327087402,
0.27198466658592224,
-0.1324465572834015,
-0.052234720438718796,
-0.16554377973079681,
0.5341669917106628,
-0.5501836538314819,
-0.46181851625442505,
-0.9743945598602295,
-0.11275667697191238,
-0.5348892211914062,
0.1126873791217804,
-0.8185972571372986,
-0.04577195271849632,
-0.1374145746231079,
-0.2008247822523117,
-0.014087514020502567,
-0.08593429625034332,
0.6583325266838074,
-0.023884132504463196,
-0.3367857038974762,
0.006311535369604826,
-0.8515514135360718,
0.46223533153533936,
-0.6861192584037781,
0.047909803688526154,
0.10921526700258255,
0.14142894744873047,
-0.691651463508606,
-0.8317509889602661,
-0.5348257422447205,
-0.573345422744751,
0.1800653636455536,
-0.2367541790008545,
-0.49182766675949097,
0.21450170874595642,
0.19707870483398438,
0.07732152193784714,
-0.5022843480110168,
0.320594847202301,
-0.2746432423591614,
-0.11092974990606308,
0.6272273063659668,
-0.00936230830848217,
0.5842353105545044,
-0.10855355113744736,
-0.740692675113678,
-0.2734459936618805,
-1.1921947002410889,
-0.2172839492559433,
0.7412751913070679,
0.27771738171577454,
-0.1199299544095993,
0.49146586656570435,
0.14774222671985626,
0.8346691727638245,
-0.14124275743961334,
0.12653176486492157,
-0.36998602747917175,
-0.028206614777445793,
-0.19115637242794037,
-0.07515153288841248,
1.014752984046936,
-0.04454953223466873,
0.35749098658561707,
-0.22189678251743317,
-0.12808792293071747,
0.14026698470115662,
0.5866572260856628,
-0.6314681768417358,
-0.3770476281642914,
0.15914936363697052,
0.0356510765850544,
-0.5120416283607483,
0.1770091950893402,
-0.82861328125,
-0.7057368755340576,
0.19106607139110565,
0.39069437980651855,
-0.34098464250564575,
-0.4056558310985565,
0.2321546971797943,
0.03822252154350281,
0.29468968510627747,
0.09421037137508392,
-0.8964272737503052,
0.5418534874916077,
0.9358401894569397,
0.859342634677887,
0.12525932490825653,
-0.25388577580451965,
-0.536012589931488,
0.30623942613601685,
-0.47439703345298767,
0.7553231716156006,
-0.4840124249458313,
-0.7365834712982178,
-0.1987379491329193,
-0.2506577968597412,
0.029018403962254524,
-0.25766801834106445,
0.8154435753822327,
-0.849323570728302,
-0.19746516644954681,
0.059361886233091354,
-0.16401158273220062,
0.018917765468358994,
0.17542493343353271,
-0.6772173047065735,
0.5414379835128784,
-0.22488422691822052,
-0.9284268021583557,
-0.22618360817432404,
-0.7439315915107727,
-0.46706056594848633,
-0.15273678302764893,
0.04680846258997917,
-0.19132579863071442,
0.23319324851036072,
0.12331291288137436,
0.2935810387134552,
-0.23541758954524994,
0.1405237317085266,
-0.4429674446582794,
-0.018570585176348686,
0.26769381761550903,
-0.4479961097240448,
0.7446616291999817,
0.2803359627723694,
-0.05905141308903694,
0.3042791485786438,
-0.5247983932495117,
-0.013202962465584278,
0.5615639090538025,
-0.015290183946490288,
-0.5323218703269958,
0.24487142264842987,
-0.3436671495437622,
0.05299227312207222,
0.09774205088615417,
-0.47945576906204224,
0.641440212726593,
-0.3961901366710663,
0.4352274537086487,
0.9616777300834656,
0.3430820107460022,
0.3567555546760559,
-0.006609049625694752,
0.5956887006759644,
-0.2988840341567993,
0.41856011748313904,
-0.1766047328710556,
-0.5606194138526917,
-0.3778698444366455,
-0.24880750477313995,
0.3428424894809723,
0.6200757622718811,
-0.34855833649635315,
0.14712491631507874,
-0.04883827641606331,
-0.6299139261245728,
-0.3228558301925659,
0.22443264722824097,
0.498798668384552,
0.28397223353385925,
0.36218059062957764,
-0.6461911201477051,
-0.6423394680023193,
-0.8616693019866943,
-0.4795858860015869,
-0.4375046491622925,
-0.06155547872185707,
-0.36512330174446106,
0.19738800823688507,
-0.20847588777542114,
0.7155903577804565,
-0.6243009567260742,
-0.09548007696866989,
-0.30176612734794617,
0.12095361202955246,
0.19518515467643738,
0.5401439070701599,
0.5077939629554749,
-0.7105585932731628,
-0.38319963216781616,
-0.31235483288764954,
-0.35603398084640503,
-0.1726205050945282,
-0.10139396041631699,
-0.12351992726325989,
-0.12405654788017273,
0.3526114821434021,
-0.6744236946105957,
0.19584140181541443,
0.6082401871681213,
-0.5156021118164062,
0.886488676071167,
-0.1807597130537033,
-0.2547965347766876,
-0.9381500482559204,
-0.14077097177505493,
0.1425471007823944,
-0.08771556615829468,
-1.1315505504608154,
0.6072039604187012,
-0.024863943457603455,
-0.21343791484832764,
-0.4316892921924591,
0.6449101567268372,
-0.28655532002449036,
0.11829517781734467,
-0.37469813227653503,
-0.05312046781182289,
-0.13344107568264008,
0.05248080939054489,
0.013103737495839596,
0.5603746771812439,
0.5742677450180054,
-0.5762864947319031,
0.392729252576828,
0.18656833469867706,
-0.040281832218170166,
0.2652151882648468,
-0.7962482571601868,
0.5503998398780823,
-0.047272395342588425,
0.4349155128002167,
-0.8522692918777466,
-0.2831166982650757,
0.4439357817173004,
-0.6538184285163879,
0.6282951831817627,
-0.5197625160217285,
-0.5610785484313965,
-0.28426021337509155,
-0.4845651090145111,
0.002608490874990821,
0.5113092660903931,
-0.4370461702346802,
0.32042446732521057,
0.4601171314716339,
-0.20943991839885712,
-0.6602522134780884,
-0.6511695981025696,
0.6156607270240784,
-0.357482373714447,
-0.7831606268882751,
0.29463836550712585,
0.009552390314638615,
-0.6756837368011475,
-0.35225358605384827,
-0.0812596008181572,
-0.08374198526144028,
0.615361750125885,
0.2629960775375366,
0.2818128168582916,
-0.019993923604488373,
-0.2520526051521301,
-0.45173996686935425,
-0.12158727645874023,
0.2846057116985321,
-0.2920815944671631,
0.8309372067451477,
0.04589582607150078,
-0.6457728147506714,
-0.30521833896636963,
0.3220564126968384,
0.6416589021682739,
-0.3531033992767334,
0.775741457939148,
0.37666577100753784,
-0.02741527557373047,
-0.33959537744522095,
-0.4509686231613159,
-0.3182530105113983,
-0.4906046688556671,
0.46882423758506775,
-0.4074314832687378,
-0.6870065331459045,
0.3494071960449219,
0.04862705618143082,
0.2538970708847046,
0.27820947766304016,
0.34798189997673035,
0.18232300877571106,
1.0115221738815308,
0.7149673700332642,
-0.31508883833885193,
0.5033512711524963,
-0.03182419762015343,
0.3382251560688019,
-0.9053104519844055,
-0.15895752608776093,
-0.6766396760940552,
0.03579578176140785,
-0.48884642124176025,
-0.3462391793727875,
0.18922777473926544,
0.520840585231781,
-0.45391401648521423,
0.6410665512084961,
-0.41907161474227905,
0.3330070674419403,
0.4985387921333313,
0.02506929077208042,
0.31908687949180603,
0.10595306009054184,
-0.10296487808227539,
0.1294938027858734,
-0.42667415738105774,
-0.6421077847480774,
1.3682769536972046,
0.7695596814155579,
1.0358043909072876,
0.4665650427341461,
0.5617746114730835,
0.5947921872138977,
0.3562144935131073,
-0.4754919111728668,
0.7131072878837585,
-0.15743117034435272,
-0.5639928579330444,
-0.06285145878791809,
-0.2712441384792328,
-0.8246095776557922,
0.5910583138465881,
-0.018352050334215164,
-1.04964280128479,
-0.2169055938720703,
0.20469918847084045,
-0.27696236968040466,
0.697213888168335,
-0.8635417222976685,
0.734154462814331,
-0.5204833149909973,
-0.404376357793808,
-0.24622738361358643,
-0.6798673868179321,
0.8175075650215149,
-0.1946662962436676,
0.14601844549179077,
-0.009141238406300545,
-0.07246923446655273,
0.5470187664031982,
-0.20641840994358063,
0.9015335440635681,
-0.22990617156028748,
-0.2846105396747589,
0.3200072944164276,
0.471558153629303,
0.7908096313476562,
0.13173089921474457,
0.036172036081552505,
0.010711907409131527,
-0.38815268874168396,
-0.36453789472579956,
-0.39855721592903137,
0.6883673667907715,
-0.6445551514625549,
-1.2190736532211304,
-0.38782382011413574,
-0.16534103453159332,
-0.22924646735191345,
0.06488674879074097,
-0.11387967318296432,
0.23171871900558472,
-0.23836824297904968,
-0.07518719881772995,
0.8166537284851074,
-0.24483323097229004,
0.42749667167663574,
0.8152594566345215,
-0.2220151126384735,
-0.3487697243690491,
0.48119083046913147,
-0.26079872250556946,
0.6182593703269958,
0.2599206566810608,
0.13179180026054382,
-0.15982256829738617,
-0.7041090726852417,
-0.28534021973609924,
0.26060619950294495,
-0.4971160590648651,
-0.2064521312713623,
-0.5277544856071472,
-0.21882686018943787,
-0.5568987727165222,
0.12306174635887146,
-0.28786343336105347,
-0.28021740913391113,
0.14631961286067963,
-0.11292169988155365,
0.38338208198547363,
0.8577613830566406,
-0.20930498838424683,
0.5629684925079346,
-0.8001405000686646,
0.35721850395202637,
0.34441906213760376,
0.23442861437797546,
-0.022190822288393974,
-0.7883230447769165,
0.22270236909389496,
-0.07358036190271378,
-0.6025175452232361,
-1.3180053234100342,
0.43804818391799927,
-0.13925383985042572,
0.45034322142601013,
0.4761447608470917,
0.2060876041650772,
0.38167351484298706,
-0.6504647731781006,
0.7260538935661316,
0.3428943455219269,
-0.8719925284385681,
0.5447802543640137,
-0.3598090708255768,
0.04485246166586876,
0.20738562941551208,
0.2545148432254791,
-0.6404197216033936,
-0.42363065481185913,
-0.795124351978302,
-0.854910135269165,
0.5931350588798523,
-0.059538692235946655,
0.3796145021915436,
-0.025679606944322586,
0.2476324588060379,
-0.4431818425655365,
-0.005609041079878807,
-0.9471843242645264,
-0.18086102604866028,
0.13000881671905518,
0.39323124289512634,
0.21315212547779083,
-0.5845295190811157,
-0.26015377044677734,
0.20124484598636627,
0.7370015978813171,
0.19815121591091156,
0.12531377375125885,
0.2166059911251068,
-0.11017013341188431,
-0.041819434612989426,
0.6036062836647034,
0.5469556450843811,
0.4507097601890564,
-0.14825290441513062,
0.3305106461048126,
0.0018736837664619088,
-0.6320234537124634,
0.35848525166511536,
-0.10739416629076004,
-0.30020028352737427,
-0.17851309478282928,
0.3609061539173126,
0.6120190024375916,
-0.08348067849874496,
-0.508037269115448,
0.4159291386604309,
-0.03775259107351303,
0.10035254806280136,
-0.3181765079498291,
0.06438557803630829,
-0.03780372068285942,
0.09660162776708603,
0.3723532557487488,
0.07439520955085754,
-0.4045262336730957,
-0.5395849347114563,
0.27548983693122864,
0.6776965260505676,
-0.32011961936950684,
-0.5629870891571045,
0.6429129838943481,
0.07154471427202225,
-0.4794069826602936,
0.35012704133987427,
-0.06918113678693771,
-0.8117457628250122,
0.6251718997955322,
0.8531941175460815,
0.9069643616676331,
-0.6519713401794434,
0.049257390201091766,
0.20474007725715637,
0.8065302968025208,
-0.21103008091449738,
-0.008581522852182388,
0.1810053288936615,
-0.6429403424263,
-0.6756797432899475,
-0.5583633184432983,
-0.5403744578361511,
0.45864883065223694,
-0.3097594380378723,
0.23727431893348694,
-0.8564181923866272,
-0.08107469975948334,
-0.14145568013191223,
-0.197209432721138,
-0.05296871066093445,
-0.09426512569189072,
0.5030109286308289,
1.1276888847351074,
-0.7988362908363342,
1.1082308292388916,
0.7233225107192993,
-0.3834885060787201,
-0.7672166228294373,
0.26206788420677185,
0.1416640728712082,
-0.5351501703262329,
0.75644451379776,
-0.08509352803230286,
-0.11979749798774719,
-0.16046355664730072,
-0.5476112961769104,
-0.8097309470176697,
0.44395023584365845,
0.4947572946548462,
-0.5272475481033325,
-0.09653116017580032,
-0.02001451700925827,
0.35983508825302124,
-0.02398211508989334,
0.038680221885442734,
0.5521991848945618,
0.5794131755828857,
-0.19146622717380524,
-0.7671574354171753,
0.1302100419998169,
0.06544383615255356,
0.0027138502337038517,
0.4792010486125946,
-0.6965159177780151,
0.8161073923110962,
-0.29834315180778503,
-0.24830347299575806,
0.07870899140834808,
0.6339048147201538,
0.3553296625614166,
-0.29867640137672424,
0.37984317541122437,
0.7076535820960999,
0.2973446249961853,
0.017592396587133408,
1.1782511472702026,
-0.3351776599884033,
0.038697224110364914,
1.1201938390731812,
-0.44374704360961914,
1.0291240215301514,
0.47016090154647827,
-0.3873565196990967,
0.3961406350135803,
0.2804952561855316,
-0.11112471669912338,
0.3979465365409851,
0.6244494318962097,
-0.44727468490600586,
-0.07090756297111511,
0.11375602334737778,
-0.3615688383579254,
0.359109491109848,
0.42461061477661133,
-0.16451841592788696,
-0.3527224063873291,
-0.21881003677845,
0.5240905284881592,
0.2654295563697815,
-0.3204790949821472,
0.5985214114189148,
0.20153643190860748,
-0.6411351561546326,
0.5085662603378296,
0.5755003094673157,
0.7215288877487183,
-1.2038099765777588,
0.07307936251163483,
-0.1710188388824463,
0.2549148499965668,
-0.16155341267585754,
-0.614892303943634,
0.2810702323913574,
0.4257199168205261,
-0.07478635013103485,
-0.19892618060112,
0.8210304379463196,
-0.09153130650520325,
-0.07104874402284622,
0.6161463260650635,
0.0643974244594574,
-0.19247856736183167,
-0.28275972604751587,
-0.6520457863807678,
0.09466088563203812,
0.02248316816985607,
-0.4748658239841461,
0.7308717966079712,
-0.20565208792686462,
-0.19505654275417328,
0.7700973153114319,
0.8346518874168396,
0.45725715160369873,
0.15437883138656616,
-0.010677782818675041,
0.8317104578018188,
-0.37804755568504333,
-0.3580775856971741,
-1.2806940078735352,
0.25134479999542236,
-0.021309806033968925,
0.09624943882226944,
0.989775538444519,
0.24392715096473694,
0.5833268165588379,
0.1430273801088333,
0.7868414521217346,
-0.20714741945266724,
0.39139190316200256,
-0.47209376096725464,
0.5251526236534119,
-0.0358298197388649,
0.6592648029327393,
-0.3187032639980316,
-0.7917115092277527,
-0.5506475567817688,
0.20082062482833862,
-0.34805163741111755,
-0.40704888105392456,
0.5569438338279724,
0.8666090369224548,
0.12817513942718506,
-0.1472785770893097,
0.2190064787864685,
0.3637193441390991,
0.5964008569717407,
0.47182556986808777,
0.8893950581550598,
-0.1452886164188385,
0.6123626828193665,
-0.1910509318113327,
-0.16059260070323944,
0.1350030153989792,
-0.9889615178108215,
-0.735633134841919,
-0.14398595690727234,
0.05731707066297531,
-0.6808993220329285,
0.36213621497154236,
0.7275574207305908,
0.6345062255859375,
-0.8043822050094604,
-0.3462047278881073,
-0.12251360714435577,
0.19965961575508118,
0.05689336359500885,
-0.21847769618034363,
0.2851371467113495,
-0.3215579390525818,
-0.226596862077713,
0.7962618470191956,
0.09918426722288132,
0.04480104148387909,
-0.5475651621818542,
0.11337559670209885,
-0.35730257630348206,
0.17057287693023682,
0.24938903748989105,
0.6630406975746155,
-0.7050254940986633,
-0.2271566092967987,
-0.337854266166687,
-0.05805462598800659,
-0.1665695309638977,
0.8346867561340332,
-0.46040645241737366,
0.2524721920490265,
0.42467576265335083,
0.6525530219078064,
0.1219182014465332,
0.20276249945163727,
0.8582351207733154,
-0.9131181836128235,
0.34575745463371277,
0.21810701489448547,
0.3889855444431305,
0.3243544101715088,
-0.2669760584831238,
0.52899169921875,
0.30023476481437683,
-0.4537202715873718,
-1.008128046989441,
0.739497184753418,
-0.5372155904769897,
-0.5480396747589111,
1.19465172290802,
-0.22702692449092865,
-0.191105917096138,
0.11080724745988846,
-0.10912381112575531,
-0.11187202483415604,
-0.42684003710746765,
0.6960422396659851,
0.5031207203865051,
0.15996822714805603,
0.03645383194088936,
-0.7315493226051331,
0.44077470898628235,
0.35220640897750854,
-0.6663972735404968,
0.25526297092437744,
0.25146961212158203,
0.3674059212207794,
0.318388968706131,
0.34577247500419617,
-0.32381096482276917,
0.08626769483089447,
0.011390021070837975,
0.1040085107088089,
-0.2592964172363281,
-0.5663305521011353,
-0.6107625961303711,
0.45489463210105896,
0.5270940661430359,
-0.05545223876833916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00809v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00809v1
|
Abdelhak at SemEval-2024 Task 9 : Decoding Brainteasers, The Efficacy of Dedicated Models Versus ChatGPT
| 2024-02-24T20:00:03 | 2024-02-24T20:00:03 |
Abdelhak Kelious, Mounir Okirim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study introduces a dedicated model aimed at solving the BRAINTEASER task
9 , a novel challenge designed to assess models lateral thinking capabilities
through sentence and word puzzles. Our model demonstrates remarkable efficacy,
securing Rank 1 in sentence puzzle solving during the test phase with an
overall score of 0.98. Additionally, we explore the comparative performance of
ChatGPT, specifically analyzing how variations in temperature settings affect
its ability to engage in lateral thinking and problem-solving. Our findings
indicate a notable performance disparity between the dedicated model and
ChatGPT, underscoring the potential of specialized approaches in enhancing
creative reasoning in AI.
|
[
-0.2141977846622467,
-0.9017175436019897,
0.6009945273399353,
0.32066601514816284,
-0.2433892786502838,
0.21842099726200104,
0.04636210948228836,
-0.46891283988952637,
0.16267965734004974,
0.5291396975517273,
-0.7182765007019043,
-0.09165867418050766,
-0.7047016024589539,
0.21006926894187927,
-0.190180242061615,
0.8444059491157532,
0.0318969264626503,
0.11139252036809921,
-0.17392855882644653,
-0.11038704961538315,
-0.8507991433143616,
-0.5097994208335876,
-0.8148460388183594,
-0.5465807318687439,
0.21499399840831757,
0.2536229193210602,
0.7583469748497009,
0.22535660862922668,
0.9347048997879028,
0.32947540283203125,
-0.0719032734632492,
-0.09601277112960815,
-0.43561288714408875,
0.20339655876159668,
-0.30551576614379883,
-0.4552348554134369,
-0.43798744678497314,
0.04220300167798996,
0.25268110632896423,
0.6680516600608826,
-0.2911889851093292,
0.030472151935100555,
-0.03923368081450462,
0.8468343615531921,
-0.3894573152065277,
0.13367488980293274,
-0.6700063347816467,
0.07888642698526382,
-0.03918861970305443,
-0.14233741164207458,
-0.4201047718524933,
-0.21246470510959625,
0.20412051677703857,
-0.3476918935775757,
0.017099665477871895,
-0.01770392619073391,
0.48136231303215027,
0.658702552318573,
-0.6386893391609192,
-0.07454507052898407,
-0.36994367837905884,
0.6167483329772949,
-0.6218598484992981,
0.4868795573711395,
0.3431483507156372,
0.35134828090667725,
-0.07783756405115128,
-0.7716368436813354,
-0.27408063411712646,
-0.2079497128725052,
0.32249724864959717,
0.32214319705963135,
-0.4207179844379425,
-0.040126316249370575,
0.3422616422176361,
0.12089119851589203,
-0.7475439310073853,
-0.08147481828927994,
-0.6230624318122864,
-0.1434473842382431,
0.6818647980690002,
0.47657909989356995,
0.36137157678604126,
-0.07072892040014267,
-0.2749498188495636,
0.1407393366098404,
-0.4189254641532898,
0.33739471435546875,
0.28542107343673706,
-0.1963675171136856,
-0.0025428764056414366,
0.6639795899391174,
-0.22734835743904114,
0.37030157446861267,
0.029720116406679153,
0.4909753203392029,
0.22996461391448975,
-0.1010795533657074,
-0.12461462616920471,
-0.06981518119573593,
0.4742256999015808,
0.47039279341697693,
0.10593601316213608,
-0.3600890338420868,
-0.13901257514953613,
0.24131841957569122,
0.46760091185569763,
-0.7460274696350098,
-0.7916882038116455,
0.2116893082857132,
-0.35471296310424805,
-0.2499838024377823,
-0.4446326494216919,
-0.422715425491333,
-0.5078668594360352,
-0.11423300206661224,
0.7669908404350281,
-0.6798441410064697,
-0.2706751525402069,
0.40707701444625854,
-0.4280933439731598,
0.3994165062904358,
0.4186919629573822,
-0.7318382263183594,
0.2293817102909088,
0.6764888763427734,
0.7229764461517334,
-0.4480595290660858,
-0.3582115173339844,
-0.06485547870397568,
-0.12064091116189957,
-0.34502077102661133,
1.0813171863555908,
-0.7380207777023315,
-0.3724932372570038,
-0.5618777871131897,
-0.08392596989870071,
-0.43683913350105286,
-0.38201087713241577,
0.6287685632705688,
-0.5899127125740051,
0.034756261855363846,
-0.6172794699668884,
-0.5077123641967773,
-0.4906165301799774,
0.45100387930870056,
-0.6533512473106384,
0.8507351875305176,
-0.06127217039465904,
-0.8585200309753418,
-0.03088034875690937,
-1.0768071413040161,
-0.3205891251564026,
0.2880091965198517,
-0.28587380051612854,
-0.15526698529720306,
0.1116127148270607,
0.368368923664093,
0.26940712332725525,
-0.29496490955352783,
0.12378305941820145,
-0.17239825427532196,
-0.30858319997787476,
0.599417507648468,
-0.34920749068260193,
1.1414942741394043,
-0.029411599040031433,
-0.4386315643787384,
0.14785407483577728,
-0.5625789761543274,
0.2723127603530884,
0.47037190198898315,
-0.21424129605293274,
0.19630937278270721,
-0.11912942677736282,
-0.3065429627895355,
0.09384645521640778,
0.375942200422287,
-0.5095917582511902,
0.2128281593322754,
-0.3871559500694275,
0.6546035408973694,
0.6904441714286804,
0.2519943416118622,
0.39443254470825195,
-0.3930998146533966,
0.8371927738189697,
0.07945652306079865,
-0.13100188970565796,
-0.115760937333107,
-0.9399406909942627,
-0.7630308270454407,
0.019008668139576912,
0.22488883137702942,
0.8551605343818665,
-0.7648504376411438,
0.06619896739721298,
0.0774681493639946,
-0.738418698310852,
-0.4946199357509613,
-0.30403050780296326,
0.2028498351573944,
0.6691890358924866,
0.39529097080230713,
-0.26413819193840027,
-0.4048805236816406,
-1.1984221935272217,
-0.6248507499694824,
0.2006712257862091,
0.21913671493530273,
0.165353462100029,
0.8904059529304504,
-0.15216562151908875,
0.48751363158226013,
-0.48508983850479126,
0.009333447553217411,
-0.5432769656181335,
0.13709114491939545,
0.26161229610443115,
0.5683656334877014,
0.44589951634407043,
-0.7356430292129517,
-0.4163427948951721,
-0.1280112862586975,
-0.8900226950645447,
-0.0025421304162591696,
0.156701922416687,
-0.013562214560806751,
0.15320159494876862,
0.3553890883922577,
-0.7991625070571899,
0.6981869339942932,
0.4362388253211975,
-0.6628618240356445,
0.610541045665741,
-0.12073104828596115,
0.48227888345718384,
-0.5633179545402527,
0.076735720038414,
-0.34890884160995483,
0.07537361979484558,
-0.8996506929397583,
0.1981641948223114,
0.04810193553566933,
-0.44511914253234863,
-0.1885649710893631,
0.1235302984714508,
-0.3955134153366089,
0.19046786427497864,
-0.4058185815811157,
-0.2658633589744568,
-0.07259432971477509,
0.6387990713119507,
0.037928350269794464,
0.6461390256881714,
0.5411916375160217,
-0.28589072823524475,
0.27157318592071533,
0.2912198007106781,
-0.3460398018360138,
0.2438139170408249,
-1.153555989265442,
0.570789635181427,
-0.2840002775192261,
0.14457657933235168,
-1.1168369054794312,
-0.13380950689315796,
0.1456892490386963,
-0.5591269731521606,
-0.025605235248804092,
0.2230178266763687,
-0.16793671250343323,
-0.3684483766555786,
0.027973009273409843,
0.5095043778419495,
0.7147251963615417,
-0.12793774902820587,
0.8100075125694275,
0.5223983526229858,
-0.15456733107566833,
-0.45751652121543884,
-0.8145272731781006,
0.03255535289645195,
-0.5270366072654724,
-0.8556816577911377,
0.34258830547332764,
-0.236292764544487,
-0.15982787311077118,
-0.13958854973316193,
-0.14348521828651428,
-0.10054690390825272,
0.27266913652420044,
0.27017292380332947,
0.05501207709312439,
-0.013853974640369415,
-0.336007684469223,
-0.13878773152828217,
-0.15827810764312744,
0.5114871859550476,
0.21968810260295868,
0.5751405954360962,
-0.4823862910270691,
-0.4737740755081177,
-0.3439807593822479,
0.6198812127113342,
0.3834535777568817,
-0.5097787380218506,
0.6934754848480225,
0.6396607160568237,
-0.3743492662906647,
-0.1435900181531906,
-0.6636509299278259,
-0.3676462471485138,
-0.5407752990722656,
0.39683014154434204,
-0.6672984957695007,
-0.8038088083267212,
0.8332643508911133,
0.19083845615386963,
-0.1369212418794632,
0.2884424924850464,
0.5972445607185364,
-0.0721120685338974,
1.2704087495803833,
0.5325299501419067,
0.3541164994239807,
-0.1075950637459755,
-0.3511611521244049,
0.44813114404678345,
-0.8032285571098328,
-0.5249808430671692,
-0.3003676235675812,
-0.5632874369621277,
-0.4485228359699249,
-0.27422770857810974,
0.6361187100410461,
-0.07248404622077942,
-0.3614339828491211,
0.3261623978614807,
-0.8164793252944946,
0.6593382954597473,
0.7282087802886963,
0.41408631205558777,
0.012265242636203766,
-0.310608446598053,
-0.08825741708278656,
-0.30375343561172485,
-0.8063367605209351,
-0.09855139255523682,
1.0398328304290771,
0.2925569713115692,
0.37237003445625305,
0.3147173821926117,
0.5863959789276123,
0.057730428874492645,
-0.2484273612499237,
-0.648705244064331,
0.8171826601028442,
0.2973491847515106,
-0.8068358898162842,
-0.25411444902420044,
-0.1854676455259323,
-1.0872091054916382,
0.5303199291229248,
0.13078047335147858,
-0.9692731499671936,
-0.0709332823753357,
-0.15179021656513214,
-0.387766033411026,
-0.03094504587352276,
-0.7546276450157166,
1.2049119472503662,
-0.2313828468322754,
-0.34204426407814026,
-0.4613981246948242,
-0.6221948862075806,
0.20922470092773438,
0.1403714269399643,
-0.06177908927202225,
-0.28081443905830383,
-0.05818283185362816,
1.0072489976882935,
-0.03220347687602043,
0.558190643787384,
-0.22064340114593506,
0.20474864542484283,
0.3480454087257385,
0.3544393479824066,
0.44335150718688965,
-0.03476797044277191,
-0.13215194642543793,
0.07706505060195923,
0.15685240924358368,
-0.5438544750213623,
-0.6944359540939331,
0.43885523080825806,
-0.8388583064079285,
-1.210925579071045,
-0.5480902194976807,
-0.9239742159843445,
-0.3863805830478668,
0.2706816494464874,
0.3139435052871704,
0.3682667315006256,
-0.2095383256673813,
0.43401047587394714,
0.6196642518043518,
-0.18922893702983856,
0.43989017605781555,
0.574802815914154,
-0.012581806629896164,
-0.3294609785079956,
0.5744636058807373,
0.22576643526554108,
-0.046274662017822266,
0.14795160293579102,
0.17333322763442993,
-0.09179046750068665,
-0.7324878573417664,
-0.0321679562330246,
-0.140781432390213,
-0.8548679351806641,
-0.13592052459716797,
-0.8313111066818237,
-0.4931676983833313,
-0.4230796694755554,
-0.2767407298088074,
-0.46278825402259827,
-0.6258966326713562,
0.06991906464099884,
-0.05118707939982414,
0.15183588862419128,
0.5793818235397339,
-0.10307741165161133,
0.09135223180055618,
-0.46424245834350586,
0.20091663300991058,
0.13377641141414642,
-0.1867869645357132,
-0.12110782414674759,
-0.5854957103729248,
-0.02295282483100891,
0.08927913010120392,
-0.5677042603492737,
-1.1449627876281738,
0.4598608613014221,
-0.2604449987411499,
0.6304749250411987,
0.0626017302274704,
-0.06364590674638748,
0.5875514149665833,
-0.5148069262504578,
0.8510289192199707,
0.09760114550590515,
-0.7957705855369568,
0.7025970220565796,
-0.5659760236740112,
0.8694272041320801,
0.39570921659469604,
0.5179986953735352,
-0.21311141550540924,
-0.2609121799468994,
-0.8147571086883545,
-0.5631972551345825,
0.5064499974250793,
0.41862353682518005,
-0.08748335391283035,
0.15702371299266815,
0.09166942536830902,
0.07494425028562546,
0.015408232808113098,
-0.6813806891441345,
-0.06316232681274414,
-0.13104817271232605,
0.05363930016756058,
0.03679697588086128,
-0.17503996193408966,
0.004405464045703411,
-0.6095983386039734,
0.5434082746505737,
0.14963878691196442,
0.46176987886428833,
0.12946876883506775,
0.0005608620122075081,
0.24081507325172424,
0.24122563004493713,
0.31666842103004456,
0.6846891045570374,
-0.10445480048656464,
0.02545398660004139,
0.46145787835121155,
-0.3920908570289612,
-0.02887934446334839,
0.17545555531978607,
-0.07388631999492645,
-0.32628417015075684,
0.413795530796051,
0.7332897782325745,
0.22962181270122528,
-0.5869352221488953,
0.43980762362480164,
0.012223834171891212,
-0.23317143321037292,
-0.36188438534736633,
0.3261397182941437,
0.31745272874832153,
0.6250699758529663,
0.3650868833065033,
0.42692142724990845,
0.6074003577232361,
-0.48557472229003906,
0.10296998918056488,
0.4584154784679413,
-0.13740494847297668,
-0.49122294783592224,
0.8673382997512817,
0.20544372498989105,
-0.3752562999725342,
0.8398727774620056,
-0.17718686163425446,
-0.9671778678894043,
0.9783046841621399,
0.5999311804771423,
0.7468957304954529,
-0.4365701973438263,
0.03614024072885513,
0.22587400674819946,
0.4489608407020569,
0.05979267135262489,
0.7195615768432617,
-0.0327824205160141,
-0.9228696823120117,
-0.26760250329971313,
-0.04013281315565109,
-0.3736113905906677,
0.12495724111795425,
-0.6020466089248657,
0.00869323406368494,
-0.2050895392894745,
-0.3791445195674896,
0.20737811923027039,
0.09296261519193649,
-0.9601176381111145,
-0.006299588829278946,
-0.05163121968507767,
0.9115816950798035,
-0.4873691201210022,
0.75083327293396,
0.8376492261886597,
-0.36899974942207336,
-0.7648874521255493,
-0.4199194610118866,
0.043331313878297806,
-0.8347074389457703,
0.6657693386077881,
0.3208831250667572,
-0.08467365056276321,
0.2118579000234604,
-0.3259105682373047,
-0.8388650417327881,
1.1664924621582031,
0.4736488163471222,
-0.1454000473022461,
-0.29047641158103943,
0.2269149273633957,
0.3706647455692291,
-0.22322237491607666,
0.43683284521102905,
0.7354123592376709,
0.4122380018234253,
0.09523335099220276,
-1.1305986642837524,
-0.006866047624498606,
-0.5485261678695679,
-0.14328894019126892,
0.01912250742316246,
-0.8031270503997803,
0.893112301826477,
-0.3685157299041748,
-0.19173003733158112,
-0.04628903046250343,
0.7267016172409058,
0.34541818499565125,
0.3749411404132843,
0.14294134080410004,
0.7498820424079895,
0.6357676386833191,
0.06005088984966278,
0.8738937973976135,
-0.25191614031791687,
0.003190654329955578,
0.9963076710700989,
-0.3144894540309906,
0.864220917224884,
0.3601838946342468,
-0.08924242854118347,
0.34975042939186096,
0.30448469519615173,
-0.021756719797849655,
0.7524242997169495,
0.0394509993493557,
-0.0992908850312233,
-0.38203611969947815,
0.037509363144636154,
-0.4955672323703766,
0.834815263748169,
0.4362781047821045,
0.0018379249377176166,
-0.11960507929325104,
0.20272217690944672,
-0.17698177695274353,
0.10237478464841843,
-0.34159421920776367,
0.48022884130477905,
0.1887691766023636,
-0.9245052337646484,
0.47600096464157104,
-0.001045827753841877,
0.30629661679267883,
-0.24076126515865326,
0.07653256505727768,
-0.1229701116681099,
0.5254841446876526,
-0.017574243247509003,
-0.8854622840881348,
0.4639229476451874,
-0.31450408697128296,
0.18270593881607056,
-0.23011964559555054,
0.9166563749313354,
-0.11612551659345627,
-0.5014875531196594,
-0.007528924848884344,
0.6814338564872742,
0.22162950038909912,
-0.21472787857055664,
-0.9803061485290527,
0.4302845001220703,
0.15283721685409546,
-0.5616050958633423,
0.04180010408163071,
0.4921935498714447,
0.23412369191646576,
1.056266188621521,
0.16924342513084412,
-0.439833402633667,
-0.02125537022948265,
-0.29445210099220276,
0.69145667552948,
-0.7788174152374268,
-0.6903776526451111,
-0.9637000560760498,
0.5164738893508911,
-0.09032562375068665,
-0.42198264598846436,
1.031341314315796,
0.7573251724243164,
0.5844230055809021,
-0.3257472515106201,
0.6132850646972656,
-0.01869954727590084,
0.2691987156867981,
-0.3623265027999878,
0.714448094367981,
-0.17984668910503387,
-0.01217115018516779,
0.052206579595804214,
-0.7732163667678833,
-0.06172960251569748,
0.7392138838768005,
-0.718306303024292,
0.05730278417468071,
1.0331701040267944,
0.8222172856330872,
-0.03031258098781109,
0.6562301516532898,
0.3676323890686035,
0.08416329324245453,
0.19016259908676147,
1.0589936971664429,
1.1228666305541992,
-0.43033212423324585,
0.2649165093898773,
-0.3535393178462982,
-0.1983569860458374,
0.06135186180472374,
-0.5840835571289062,
-1.3681879043579102,
-0.7710252404212952,
-0.4723980724811554,
-0.22515052556991577,
0.26622942090034485,
0.7228623628616333,
0.40579599142074585,
-0.6087210774421692,
-0.08716192841529846,
-0.23847976326942444,
-0.3261028528213501,
-0.31605565547943115,
-0.21965064108371735,
0.29710718989372253,
-0.2614622414112091,
-0.49904149770736694,
0.5263861417770386,
0.2451145499944687,
-0.23345698416233063,
-0.06751441210508347,
0.156839057803154,
-0.18845580518245697,
0.31560781598091125,
0.5185461640357971,
-0.10188934206962585,
-0.6072560548782349,
-0.2132791131734848,
0.16944096982479095,
0.14047394692897797,
0.04576227813959122,
0.7471385598182678,
-0.8712080717086792,
-0.08286400139331818,
0.694917619228363,
0.8228546380996704,
0.6290692687034607,
-0.04192863404750824,
0.6011112928390503,
0.18393267691135406,
0.15414568781852722,
0.728080689907074,
0.3956805467605591,
0.19830797612667084,
-0.3776668310165405,
0.798015296459198,
0.1617010086774826,
-0.8973674178123474,
-0.7797586917877197,
0.33458420634269714,
-1.0962437391281128,
-0.39692097902297974,
0.9581102132797241,
-0.05406857281923294,
-0.3750399053096771,
0.09206381440162659,
-0.2779120206832886,
0.017930980771780014,
-0.2390565425157547,
0.8695379495620728,
0.7774569988250732,
-0.5686427354812622,
-0.47418832778930664,
-0.7539541125297546,
0.42848607897758484,
0.7520536184310913,
-0.48467180132865906,
-0.2701578140258789,
0.2913728654384613,
0.24855659902095795,
-0.12069330364465714,
0.7091348767280579,
-0.029815908521413803,
0.4833008348941803,
0.37574803829193115,
-0.3713104724884033,
-0.3101617693901062,
-0.207235649228096,
-0.09233003109693527,
0.4271816611289978,
-0.09780514240264893,
-0.03402118757367134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15873v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15873v2
|
SemEval-2024 Task 8: Weighted Layer Averaging RoBERTa for Black-Box Machine-Generated Text Detection
| 2024-02-24T17:44:56 | 2024-04-09T10:19:48 |
Ayan Datta, Aryan Chandramania, Radhika Mamidi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This document contains the details of the authors' submission to the
proceedings of SemEval 2024's Task 8: Multigenerator, Multidomain, and
Multilingual Black-Box Machine-Generated Text Detection Subtask A (monolingual)
and B. Detection of machine-generated text is becoming an increasingly
important task, with the advent of large language models (LLMs). In this paper,
we lay out how using weighted averages of RoBERTa layers lets us capture
information about text that is relevant to machine-generated text detection.
|
[
-0.2707376480102539,
-0.929344117641449,
0.6898261308670044,
0.32738834619522095,
-0.20242606103420258,
-0.18520952761173248,
-0.0015696665504947305,
-0.5333048105239868,
0.14710818231105804,
0.82530677318573,
-0.5372408032417297,
-0.5396355390548706,
-0.888215959072113,
0.2170654535293579,
-0.53251713514328,
1.1997350454330444,
0.09494882076978683,
-0.34440940618515015,
-0.30255573987960815,
-0.1725860834121704,
-0.33178994059562683,
-0.6421660780906677,
-0.8385564684867859,
-0.3154081702232361,
0.6385184526443481,
0.2952999174594879,
0.1701202243566513,
0.29297417402267456,
0.5294580459594727,
0.4024312496185303,
0.14556998014450073,
0.28871095180511475,
-0.16982170939445496,
0.3949674963951111,
0.01599850133061409,
-0.32185491919517517,
-0.9088643789291382,
0.26859748363494873,
0.8105883598327637,
0.16791053116321564,
0.04384944215416908,
0.43009883165359497,
-0.01905861310660839,
0.4752921760082245,
-0.49750781059265137,
-0.1854225993156433,
-0.6521825790405273,
0.1636105328798294,
-0.5038372278213501,
-0.7638115286827087,
-0.7329171299934387,
0.1992179900407791,
-0.25614866614341736,
-0.28454118967056274,
0.045243095606565475,
0.175113245844841,
0.5401896238327026,
0.2277480959892273,
-0.6010507345199585,
-0.4439489245414734,
-0.4895677864551544,
1.117257833480835,
-0.6189172267913818,
0.1974342167377472,
0.3115551769733429,
0.02184569090604782,
-0.09628873318433762,
-0.6473954916000366,
-0.4078238904476166,
0.014511694200336933,
0.2823908030986786,
0.28730911016464233,
-0.43944504857063293,
-0.3481177091598511,
0.4044513702392578,
0.13542799651622772,
-0.5739172697067261,
0.03918807581067085,
-0.5393354892730713,
-0.3075966536998749,
0.6246826648712158,
0.0914473831653595,
0.5865066051483154,
-0.24157263338565826,
-0.6073643565177917,
0.15840378403663635,
-0.29599660634994507,
-0.15757986903190613,
0.4900287091732025,
0.06665805727243423,
-0.28454670310020447,
0.5229827761650085,
0.08253869414329529,
0.8235162496566772,
-0.25544631481170654,
-0.4062516391277313,
0.4686115086078644,
-0.5127565264701843,
-0.25953322649002075,
0.10897140204906464,
0.9481780529022217,
0.23893702030181885,
0.3370361924171448,
0.10713028162717819,
-0.34277138113975525,
-0.04876421391963959,
0.5164517164230347,
-0.813206672668457,
-0.2007744014263153,
0.37767574191093445,
-0.6530027985572815,
-0.6270931959152222,
-0.13659539818763733,
-0.8039594292640686,
-0.2642204165458679,
-0.09309764206409454,
0.4596661329269409,
-0.11002979427576065,
-0.24525237083435059,
-0.0901029035449028,
-0.3694649636745453,
0.011637315154075623,
0.47541430592536926,
-0.2590145468711853,
0.3230994641780853,
0.41334572434425354,
0.5946040153503418,
-0.4094735085964203,
-0.4738188087940216,
-1.0417096614837646,
0.16520008444786072,
-0.1993631273508072,
1.046858549118042,
-0.43552806973457336,
-0.02654673531651497,
-0.2494077980518341,
0.2923336327075958,
0.16197045147418976,
-0.49301859736442566,
0.6991453170776367,
-0.48338639736175537,
0.5182123184204102,
0.06661197543144226,
-0.35276657342910767,
-0.23018626868724823,
0.3347201943397522,
-0.5397409200668335,
1.2740814685821533,
0.09764918684959412,
-0.8374891877174377,
0.3307211399078369,
-0.45751145482063293,
-0.5540863871574402,
0.32567575573921204,
0.12032686918973923,
-0.9907428026199341,
0.11646156013011932,
0.2807842195034027,
0.7014938592910767,
-0.29972395300865173,
-0.014261006377637386,
-0.2349741905927658,
-0.23239153623580933,
0.455757737159729,
-0.5000415444374084,
0.9784329533576965,
0.21106074750423431,
-0.5254072546958923,
0.25796106457710266,
-0.8220871686935425,
0.14599566161632538,
0.20182110369205475,
-0.41018155217170715,
-0.485023558139801,
-0.09140095859766006,
0.3402632474899292,
0.2117122858762741,
0.6123419404029846,
-0.4637567102909088,
-0.14361269772052765,
0.12952452898025513,
0.2626364827156067,
0.7518436312675476,
0.13595277070999146,
0.43158021569252014,
-0.34554851055145264,
0.9021837711334229,
0.34566956758499146,
-0.1407654583454132,
-0.41384536027908325,
-0.6591522693634033,
-0.6165461540222168,
-0.3774811625480652,
0.48981621861457825,
0.6066676378250122,
-0.6099641919136047,
0.23359599709510803,
0.1742299646139145,
-0.30947309732437134,
-0.2883172333240509,
0.4273504912853241,
0.45282629132270813,
0.06410491466522217,
0.36190441250801086,
-0.3002701699733734,
-0.6508815288543701,
-0.7840662002563477,
-0.1747353971004486,
0.24878253042697906,
0.0011905544670298696,
0.19285446405410767,
0.7396901249885559,
-0.17991109192371368,
-0.006965292617678642,
-0.5119543671607971,
-0.47885915637016296,
-0.31355929374694824,
0.35083356499671936,
0.028153380379080772,
0.4096985459327698,
0.8257675170898438,
-0.7353135943412781,
-0.6550164818763733,
-0.14844930171966553,
-0.8767443895339966,
-0.4689886271953583,
0.04300982505083084,
-0.22324363887310028,
0.23172324895858765,
0.6373327374458313,
-0.28817516565322876,
0.2513769567012787,
0.7351152300834656,
-0.2947109639644623,
0.38071006536483765,
-0.41170182824134827,
0.3980062007904053,
-1.3480554819107056,
-0.2880188524723053,
0.32655391097068787,
-0.6408151388168335,
-0.7173447608947754,
0.30366480350494385,
0.17301341891288757,
-0.15645039081573486,
-0.1911187320947647,
0.5067691206932068,
-0.7310670018196106,
-0.3558282256126404,
-0.6288940906524658,
0.4197271168231964,
0.02958865836262703,
0.31033459305763245,
-0.4109317362308502,
1.0102689266204834,
0.3436950743198395,
-0.5190915465354919,
0.2007177472114563,
-0.25153329968452454,
-0.24771934747695923,
1.0846972465515137,
-0.7208912968635559,
0.22986797988414764,
-0.16287271678447723,
0.1621580272912979,
-0.9084171652793884,
0.04967650771141052,
0.17657768726348877,
-0.7416352033615112,
0.1893518567085266,
-0.09047167748212814,
-0.3641904592514038,
-0.23575031757354736,
-0.5088081955909729,
0.5014997124671936,
0.45148685574531555,
-0.09542682766914368,
0.826980710029602,
0.8891518115997314,
-0.19335852563381195,
-0.4931422472000122,
-0.8530833721160889,
0.34290334582328796,
-0.4611596167087555,
-0.3509458899497986,
0.4039546251296997,
-0.0942741185426712,
-0.17368994653224945,
0.035046834498643875,
0.2859879732131958,
-0.11222388595342636,
0.3931354284286499,
0.16475582122802734,
0.0638689175248146,
-0.17574121057987213,
-0.3252268135547638,
-0.1779455989599228,
-0.21981903910636902,
0.13150377571582794,
-0.5579357743263245,
0.6444169878959656,
0.3594519793987274,
-0.14114736020565033,
-0.26165467500686646,
0.5421120524406433,
0.6414748430252075,
-0.4910027086734772,
0.6281003952026367,
1.0147427320480347,
-0.5153528451919556,
-0.6584569215774536,
-0.3199318051338196,
0.32526227831840515,
-0.4103532135486603,
0.2666240632534027,
-0.4084863066673279,
-0.7695817351341248,
0.5673094391822815,
0.3906814754009247,
-0.20322716236114502,
0.6013837456703186,
0.8513379693031311,
-0.10506412386894226,
1.2445313930511475,
0.760402500629425,
-0.161953866481781,
0.5182522535324097,
-0.10557220131158829,
0.07508024573326111,
-1.0955709218978882,
0.0027562605682760477,
-0.7360262274742126,
-0.17304301261901855,
-0.7158002257347107,
-0.5815770626068115,
0.5361929535865784,
-0.28284192085266113,
0.0023428250569850206,
0.3699534237384796,
-0.6751587986946106,
0.18325726687908173,
0.863145112991333,
0.34623053669929504,
0.19780443608760834,
0.05378471314907074,
-0.057731401175260544,
0.15210916101932526,
-0.2404138296842575,
-0.3380432426929474,
1.1530897617340088,
0.2805343270301819,
0.5234524011611938,
0.1731930375099182,
0.8787418603897095,
0.7165706753730774,
0.02903641015291214,
-0.6512303948402405,
0.6356867551803589,
-0.4375300407409668,
-0.5555528402328491,
-0.2534080147743225,
-0.35687392950057983,
-0.997864305973053,
0.21148581802845,
-0.0025892083067446947,
-0.5484145283699036,
-0.14249807596206665,
-0.019830988720059395,
0.15610192716121674,
0.015131616033613682,
-0.35787853598594666,
0.8699707388877869,
-0.24467863142490387,
-0.13217462599277496,
-0.32040756940841675,
-0.09786161035299301,
0.265555739402771,
-0.26781895756721497,
0.31541720032691956,
-0.27530398964881897,
-0.14500899612903595,
0.8697537779808044,
-0.052096638828516006,
0.6694263815879822,
-0.4194994568824768,
-0.2396189570426941,
0.4624477028846741,
0.11989112943410873,
0.607910692691803,
-0.35620149970054626,
0.00852203369140625,
-0.015900051221251488,
-0.22753605246543884,
-0.5495864748954773,
-0.2354738861322403,
0.6007669568061829,
-0.5280401706695557,
-0.42957454919815063,
-0.620331346988678,
-0.6105460524559021,
0.3388260006904602,
0.3119145333766937,
0.155609592795372,
0.6207243204116821,
0.14666220545768738,
0.4540334939956665,
0.6266524195671082,
-0.3699750006198883,
0.2917240858078003,
0.566351592540741,
-0.2743479013442993,
-0.49347230792045593,
1.0198286771774292,
0.34276169538497925,
-0.03673421964049339,
0.5702042579650879,
0.10278590768575668,
0.025618039071559906,
-0.9111374020576477,
-0.42960304021835327,
-0.1405949741601944,
-0.6518526673316956,
-0.4592835307121277,
-1.0765682458877563,
-0.48555266857147217,
-0.2618647813796997,
-0.061641573905944824,
0.2166721522808075,
-0.3690607249736786,
-0.3331385850906372,
0.08295952528715134,
0.168170765042305,
0.7258406281471252,
0.3988662362098694,
0.29205599427223206,
-0.6064355373382568,
0.44392669200897217,
0.1602633148431778,
-0.2588408291339874,
-0.05394775792956352,
-0.8486145734786987,
-0.3163112699985504,
-0.14744490385055542,
-0.37763917446136475,
-0.7569210529327393,
0.5541343688964844,
0.12124043703079224,
0.6984286308288574,
-0.01812216080725193,
-0.1717085838317871,
0.5243303775787354,
-0.6113415956497192,
0.7824609279632568,
-0.019187377765774727,
-0.8725793957710266,
0.6711785793304443,
-0.44225427508354187,
0.7142288684844971,
0.07715386897325516,
0.212983176112175,
-0.29944461584091187,
-0.7708434462547302,
-0.5073225498199463,
-0.5963948965072632,
0.6305493712425232,
0.20499111711978912,
0.20255997776985168,
0.08030176907777786,
0.07743969559669495,
-0.20893551409244537,
0.33209556341171265,
-1.2148467302322388,
-0.03836653381586075,
-0.06853198260068893,
-0.7099425792694092,
-0.0900764986872673,
-0.5725995302200317,
0.023339176550507545,
0.20966891944408417,
0.6804620027542114,
-0.23978625237941742,
0.5715915560722351,
-0.14957939088344574,
-0.37799322605133057,
-0.25622716546058655,
0.38097214698791504,
0.9769138097763062,
0.4764488935470581,
0.11540545523166656,
0.5069327354431152,
0.38364291191101074,
-0.45402801036834717,
0.08352106064558029,
0.11790718138217926,
-0.4432092607021332,
-0.26270315051078796,
0.6930917501449585,
0.5975602865219116,
0.30309194326400757,
-0.40531983971595764,
0.5837676525115967,
0.0872645229101181,
-0.3210841417312622,
-0.535096287727356,
0.1383325755596161,
-0.018206238746643066,
0.29353392124176025,
0.5042720437049866,
0.046432480216026306,
0.36179986596107483,
-0.596520721912384,
0.5359542965888977,
0.7194082736968994,
-0.3059147000312805,
-0.3622615933418274,
0.7898935675621033,
0.022544028237462044,
-0.3918900489807129,
0.12729866802692413,
-0.2972279489040375,
-0.9523530602455139,
0.8684106469154358,
0.7204796671867371,
0.9472751021385193,
-0.3286440670490265,
0.14472565054893494,
0.2490789294242859,
0.4415292739868164,
0.18990091979503632,
0.54429692029953,
-0.029513422399759293,
-0.825766921043396,
-0.2854350209236145,
-0.7896478772163391,
-0.15282081067562103,
0.1728932410478592,
-0.43169474601745605,
0.37208738923072815,
-0.33284324407577515,
-0.25791236758232117,
0.46140122413635254,
0.23819710314273834,
-0.5437473654747009,
0.23184464871883392,
-0.00027304235845804214,
0.7031686902046204,
-0.8180562257766724,
0.7166708111763,
0.8049821853637695,
-0.4140077829360962,
-0.5831776857376099,
-0.11523959785699844,
0.2621634602546692,
-0.9190269708633423,
0.6287559866905212,
0.08650866150856018,
-0.13452117145061493,
-0.13328061997890472,
-0.4424046277999878,
-0.7272471189498901,
0.9432385563850403,
0.04291249066591263,
-0.17286935448646545,
0.08808305859565735,
-0.14733360707759857,
0.50693678855896,
-0.6507254838943481,
0.3010300397872925,
0.0650644302368164,
0.5625995397567749,
-0.3098650872707367,
-0.6982466578483582,
0.008641703985631466,
-0.43619585037231445,
-0.126839280128479,
0.40887346863746643,
-0.6531620025634766,
1.0833709239959717,
0.16984310746192932,
0.0925513505935669,
-0.05022944509983063,
0.6168319582939148,
0.3684787154197693,
0.4163614809513092,
0.581959068775177,
0.789204478263855,
0.654853105545044,
0.017601100727915764,
0.9610504508018494,
-0.3782128095626831,
0.2010577917098999,
1.0489827394485474,
-0.3244410455226898,
0.7393313050270081,
0.027261944487690926,
-0.33254632353782654,
0.577967643737793,
0.557137131690979,
-0.2756690979003906,
0.309696227312088,
-0.09685149043798447,
-0.286848783493042,
-0.18319030106067657,
-0.01565426215529442,
-0.10227121412754059,
0.6728901863098145,
0.26403069496154785,
-0.5274874567985535,
0.021117769181728363,
0.276767760515213,
0.14222054183483124,
0.06950107216835022,
-0.45615988969802856,
0.8767077922821045,
0.1372705101966858,
-0.7314973473548889,
0.1659892350435257,
0.2939726412296295,
0.7652056813240051,
-0.4630148112773895,
-0.0750131830573082,
0.15504586696624756,
0.3396492600440979,
-0.24676206707954407,
-0.833297848701477,
0.051298025995492935,
0.13980238139629364,
-0.4063470661640167,
-0.33300280570983887,
1.090380311012268,
-0.7709270119667053,
-0.9452943205833435,
0.5094015002250671,
0.38402941823005676,
0.22283409535884857,
0.09114629775285721,
-0.8864558339118958,
0.25011780858039856,
-0.031605351716279984,
-0.2540718913078308,
0.39738309383392334,
0.8665124773979187,
-0.08849412947893143,
0.5610287189483643,
0.49093005061149597,
0.23627591133117676,
0.202234148979187,
0.2273845076560974,
0.4769480228424072,
-0.6089329123497009,
-0.41928917169570923,
-0.7202315926551819,
0.4522419273853302,
-0.12184805423021317,
-0.1782790869474411,
1.0931388139724731,
0.6148333549499512,
0.7673734426498413,
0.004873663652688265,
0.7978703379631042,
-0.12269458919763565,
0.610110342502594,
-0.6812933087348938,
0.4661770462989807,
-0.9379979968070984,
0.1589418202638626,
-0.4086448848247528,
-1.0629637241363525,
0.009787417016923428,
0.5670743584632874,
-0.01385269034653902,
0.34725186228752136,
0.8219927549362183,
0.5875497460365295,
-0.1622539758682251,
-0.2983091473579407,
0.4419146478176117,
0.1710975170135498,
0.23057274520397186,
0.4424884021282196,
0.6013185381889343,
-0.7052319049835205,
0.4610506296157837,
-0.1353752315044403,
-0.14504799246788025,
-0.11122308671474457,
-1.0833150148391724,
-1.0614473819732666,
-0.7027655243873596,
-0.38922154903411865,
-0.4070441722869873,
-0.102768674492836,
0.6156473159790039,
0.6999005675315857,
-1.154600977897644,
-0.37845179438591003,
0.26655855774879456,
0.23951682448387146,
-0.15528705716133118,
-0.25899752974510193,
0.08250197768211365,
-0.465346097946167,
-0.9974262714385986,
0.3023122251033783,
0.6470370888710022,
-0.0034526700619608164,
-0.5245542526245117,
0.1412990391254425,
-0.3485722243785858,
0.11009283363819122,
0.8173443078994751,
-0.3581746816635132,
-0.4610944390296936,
-0.3298562467098236,
-0.22363458573818207,
-0.2967403531074524,
0.03732529655098915,
0.8583008050918579,
-0.4758230745792389,
0.20034728944301605,
0.6779391765594482,
0.367371529340744,
0.6501092314720154,
0.08733885735273361,
0.6218894124031067,
-0.842499852180481,
0.3279680907726288,
-0.03283349797129631,
0.4713604748249054,
0.35440829396247864,
-0.5394518971443176,
0.47031909227371216,
0.2448633909225464,
-0.7528165578842163,
-1.0259435176849365,
0.023611029610037804,
-1.0172454118728638,
-0.37470608949661255,
0.9189547896385193,
-0.1365053802728653,
-0.516515851020813,
-0.08786415308713913,
-0.015288264490664005,
-0.06830018013715744,
-0.2532804310321808,
0.24766620993614197,
0.7490823268890381,
0.09009025990962982,
-0.7441059947013855,
-0.9280833005905151,
0.3582390248775482,
0.13731783628463745,
-1.0262402296066284,
-0.26984214782714844,
0.37926971912384033,
0.3890302777290344,
0.26365742087364197,
0.964442253112793,
-0.16831766068935394,
0.34681975841522217,
-0.05785838142037392,
-0.01956770196557045,
0.10663650184869766,
-0.7234206795692444,
-0.1672041267156601,
0.48434126377105713,
-0.046560414135456085,
0.022882593795657158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15862v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15862v2
|
SportQA: A Benchmark for Sports Understanding in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-24T17:12:10 | 2024-06-18T03:29:51 |
Haotian Xia, Zhengbang Yang, Yuqing Wang, Rhys Tracy, Yun Zhao, Dongdong Huang, Zezhi Chen, Yan Zhu, Yuan-fang Wang, Weining Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A deep understanding of sports, a field rich in strategic and dynamic
content, is crucial for advancing Natural Language Processing (NLP). This holds
particular significance in the context of evaluating and advancing Large
Language Models (LLMs), given the existing gap in specialized benchmarks. To
bridge this gap, we introduce SportQA, a novel benchmark specifically designed
for evaluating LLMs in the context of sports understanding. SportQA encompasses
over 70,000 multiple-choice questions across three distinct difficulty levels,
each targeting different aspects of sports knowledge from basic historical
facts to intricate, scenario-based reasoning tasks. We conducted a thorough
evaluation of prevalent LLMs, mainly utilizing few-shot learning paradigms
supplemented by chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting. Our results reveal that while
LLMs exhibit competent performance in basic sports knowledge, they struggle
with more complex, scenario-based sports reasoning, lagging behind human
expertise. The introduction of SportQA marks a significant step forward in NLP,
offering a tool for assessing and enhancing sports understanding in LLMs.
|
[
-0.28826257586479187,
-0.5225912928581238,
0.687981367111206,
0.11888695508241653,
-0.19358433783054352,
0.4382932782173157,
-0.2636435031890869,
-0.5000937581062317,
-0.26207223534584045,
-0.05297042056918144,
-0.7766172289848328,
-0.49639448523521423,
-0.6750531792640686,
0.013659244403243065,
-0.22407054901123047,
0.7157237529754639,
-0.2593613266944885,
0.27050453424453735,
-0.2657928168773651,
-0.5060796141624451,
-0.6725627779960632,
-0.6820859909057617,
-0.9126713871955872,
-0.6057168841362,
0.28007492423057556,
-0.11936485767364502,
0.4219857156276703,
0.229705810546875,
0.5516480207443237,
0.3266635537147522,
-0.4763883352279663,
0.38408544659614563,
-0.7052130699157715,
0.4917009472846985,
-0.419005423784256,
-0.48473310470581055,
-0.36640915274620056,
0.11017013341188431,
0.8298953771591187,
0.9466447830200195,
0.035135529935359955,
0.4597948491573334,
-0.014594254083931446,
0.6402606964111328,
-0.765070378780365,
0.028850877657532692,
-0.5351202487945557,
0.19442331790924072,
-0.20212243497371674,
-0.2984914481639862,
-0.11858377605676651,
-0.03166443109512329,
0.04803258925676346,
-0.5895193219184875,
0.07676126807928085,
0.07613644748926163,
0.5966957211494446,
0.24741452932357788,
-0.5711584091186523,
-0.004735494032502174,
-0.7158637046813965,
0.7199100852012634,
-0.6227530241012573,
0.7965080142021179,
0.41402971744537354,
0.5211146473884583,
-0.3402441740036011,
-0.3417506217956543,
-0.4993877112865448,
-0.08281546831130981,
0.44739311933517456,
0.3450123071670532,
-0.06308197230100632,
-0.12155570834875107,
0.3876428008079529,
0.08493448793888092,
-0.674060583114624,
0.1069081574678421,
-0.16179628670215607,
0.29325225949287415,
0.8010603785514832,
0.30964019894599915,
0.0424276702105999,
0.07306268811225891,
-0.3092995584011078,
0.1597614586353302,
-0.6532514691352844,
0.4733208119869232,
0.1074327751994133,
0.22178085148334503,
0.013877189718186855,
0.36267513036727905,
-0.7799887657165527,
0.538332998752594,
-0.07384185492992401,
-0.22850048542022705,
0.25463345646858215,
-0.16337770223617554,
-0.3857714533805847,
-0.02128102257847786,
0.6362850666046143,
0.23163747787475586,
0.0679457038640976,
-0.49840861558914185,
0.008541293442249298,
-0.35754337906837463,
0.12225031852722168,
-0.5765368938446045,
0.004435065668076277,
0.31197938323020935,
-0.41862252354621887,
0.08083929866552353,
-0.012964542955160141,
-0.4400253891944885,
-0.6750182509422302,
-0.34381839632987976,
0.5318099856376648,
-0.3788781464099884,
0.04539167508482933,
0.4168644845485687,
-0.33256709575653076,
0.6818355917930603,
0.360726922750473,
-0.6989747881889343,
0.20181599259376526,
1.0487205982208252,
0.6979861855506897,
-0.1466560810804367,
-0.24296490848064423,
-0.6936926245689392,
0.18014290928840637,
-0.4235171377658844,
1.0281678438186646,
-0.5070803761482239,
0.08199717104434967,
0.19489087164402008,
-0.48509687185287476,
0.2750610411167145,
-0.4682784080505371,
0.6835106611251831,
-0.6708430051803589,
-0.1970980316400528,
-0.3595440685749054,
-0.7181287407875061,
-0.33934488892555237,
0.5975695252418518,
-0.5283169746398926,
1.3104965686798096,
-0.041595518589019775,
-0.398739218711853,
1.0196114778518677,
-0.4468058943748474,
-0.4739469289779663,
0.44305044412612915,
-0.1136380285024643,
-0.08414482325315475,
0.16825498640537262,
0.38359513878822327,
0.3892589509487152,
-0.5578321814537048,
0.26315608620643616,
-0.5719030499458313,
-0.3653448224067688,
0.39467713236808777,
-0.47541049122810364,
0.3778555691242218,
-0.1111927255988121,
-0.20966771245002747,
-0.1623079627752304,
-0.5753529071807861,
0.24549180269241333,
-0.07812370359897614,
-0.3839019238948822,
-0.3934791386127472,
0.20941536128520966,
-0.36405476927757263,
0.5151832103729248,
-0.024138446897268295,
-0.2553339898586273,
0.1075214371085167,
-0.5748782157897949,
0.36168909072875977,
0.5796197652816772,
-0.11537156254053116,
0.39654290676116943,
-0.2124311625957489,
0.6385369896888733,
-0.2387438416481018,
0.1719071865081787,
0.11018146574497223,
-0.4043816328048706,
-0.3970404267311096,
-0.14259126782417297,
0.2955322861671448,
0.23458431661128998,
-0.6634114384651184,
0.1848328411579132,
-0.3261141777038574,
-0.6671037673950195,
-0.4468258321285248,
0.31997233629226685,
0.22379039227962494,
0.3673918545246124,
0.4538506269454956,
-0.12499350309371948,
-0.4085251986980438,
-0.5639902949333191,
-0.628084123134613,
-0.19588491320610046,
0.0392213873565197,
0.46070346236228943,
0.6424102187156677,
0.3104346692562103,
0.6275708079338074,
-0.3016173541545868,
-0.2315039187669754,
-0.3838525414466858,
0.2587476074695587,
0.3601640462875366,
0.12801603972911835,
0.4995105564594269,
-0.7346522808074951,
-0.3467850983142853,
-0.2605038583278656,
-0.774924635887146,
-0.0943717509508133,
-0.17976440489292145,
-0.4082353413105011,
-0.32306867837905884,
0.3144734501838684,
-0.6648020148277283,
0.41224294900894165,
0.561588704586029,
-0.5296105742454529,
0.6077303886413574,
0.015830643475055695,
0.5005969405174255,
-0.5251249670982361,
0.22143596410751343,
0.074184849858284,
-0.3049663305282593,
-0.5831665992736816,
0.16408705711364746,
-0.3108772933483124,
0.3439668118953705,
-0.5454505085945129,
0.644073486328125,
-0.3433264493942261,
-0.3332665264606476,
-0.20536258816719055,
0.2594467103481293,
0.18916767835617065,
0.16351667046546936,
0.3081800043582916,
0.6908259987831116,
0.44610273838043213,
-0.7583658695220947,
0.4156460464000702,
0.4512396454811096,
-0.7245416641235352,
0.6645065546035767,
-0.5574461817741394,
0.002273628721013665,
-0.19146791100502014,
0.4030798077583313,
-0.8640165328979492,
-0.09352027624845505,
0.08745665103197098,
-0.35120388865470886,
0.06090893596410751,
-0.1798120141029358,
-0.35642704367637634,
-0.5853376388549805,
-0.1784343272447586,
0.7995392680168152,
0.20196768641471863,
-0.4266384541988373,
0.5962046980857849,
0.5745816230773926,
-0.020174365490674973,
-0.7162560820579529,
-0.30660688877105713,
0.15073561668395996,
-0.2891332805156708,
-0.19340920448303223,
0.0761822834610939,
-0.22930002212524414,
-0.24083630740642548,
-0.3064238131046295,
-0.6258007884025574,
-0.557555615901947,
0.38889607787132263,
0.04468665271997452,
0.10303647071123123,
-0.5283241868019104,
0.3698853850364685,
-0.10522032529115677,
0.28222131729125977,
0.20515179634094238,
-0.23995506763458252,
0.6312047243118286,
0.020233523100614548,
-0.1224525049328804,
-0.4313647747039795,
0.2801549732685089,
0.14939981698989868,
-0.1960255205631256,
0.7783734202384949,
0.3092191517353058,
-0.30310627818107605,
-0.5892783403396606,
-0.447797954082489,
0.08059482276439667,
-0.43621572852134705,
0.5185582041740417,
-0.7148175835609436,
-1.027130365371704,
0.24764448404312134,
-0.23663166165351868,
0.031297218054533005,
0.49915170669555664,
0.678916335105896,
-0.5471089482307434,
1.0751919746398926,
0.09589608013629913,
-0.06024760380387306,
-0.057488664984703064,
-0.0028392088133841753,
0.041692521423101425,
-0.7699729800224304,
-0.4590798318386078,
-0.6419651508331299,
-0.6574258208274841,
-0.08764083683490753,
-0.6629751324653625,
0.09457863122224808,
0.2692141830921173,
-0.705675482749939,
0.31895795464515686,
-0.08911784738302231,
0.8461639881134033,
0.35886743664741516,
0.22352202236652374,
0.3270537853240967,
-0.6576933860778809,
0.04630228132009506,
-0.1751749962568283,
-0.9001714587211609,
-0.31331226229667664,
0.8189297318458557,
0.37024325132369995,
0.613891065120697,
0.5607971549034119,
0.6916935443878174,
0.26434090733528137,
0.29976674914360046,
-1.195993423461914,
0.4003034830093384,
-0.17065490782260895,
-0.9452863931655884,
-0.34319007396698,
-0.4973958730697632,
-0.7711221575737,
0.21827132999897003,
-0.6388159394264221,
-0.5508805513381958,
-0.09071236848831177,
0.03804047033190727,
-0.7407640814781189,
0.34454503655433655,
-0.006248068064451218,
0.5721868276596069,
-0.4111810326576233,
-0.46567538380622864,
0.03847246244549751,
-0.10370416194200516,
0.6193390488624573,
-0.1709868311882019,
0.43830668926239014,
-0.38637223839759827,
-0.2776998281478882,
0.8401904106140137,
-0.06224328279495239,
0.416309654712677,
0.21386826038360596,
-0.007990669459104538,
0.08431082218885422,
0.2974734604358673,
-0.17044369876384735,
0.10204242169857025,
-0.1073802262544632,
-0.019460627809166908,
0.22518835961818695,
-0.49364569783210754,
-0.6179224252700806,
0.49059760570526123,
-0.5691385269165039,
-0.678671658039093,
-0.6388863325119019,
-0.46211346983909607,
-0.813853919506073,
0.06841375678777695,
-0.15045882761478424,
0.30633094906806946,
-0.3611619174480438,
0.5748531222343445,
0.6356909871101379,
-0.336452454328537,
0.28993797302246094,
0.5827538967132568,
0.04182327538728714,
-0.037059858441352844,
0.3590986728668213,
-0.16697299480438232,
-0.1045055240392685,
0.5333445072174072,
0.22945772111415863,
-0.759706437587738,
-0.8889238834381104,
-0.10340046137571335,
0.24736689031124115,
-0.8613713383674622,
-0.5717498660087585,
-0.26010334491729736,
-0.11500798910856247,
-0.31186652183532715,
0.12329413741827011,
-0.4094277024269104,
-0.169471874833107,
0.02666209451854229,
-0.16084857285022736,
0.05396566167473793,
0.926886796951294,
0.14700937271118164,
0.23108232021331787,
-0.9019566774368286,
0.5203127861022949,
0.23757122457027435,
0.7593402862548828,
-0.009372632950544357,
-1.000151515007019,
-0.11276132613420486,
-0.11710583418607712,
-0.08385852724313736,
-0.6833817958831787,
0.2731221914291382,
0.40365326404571533,
0.9707819819450378,
0.2865501642227173,
0.0005536290700547397,
0.7889423370361328,
-0.8256228566169739,
0.9704806804656982,
0.37132158875465393,
-1.1208016872406006,
0.366196870803833,
-0.2800464630126953,
0.4799290895462036,
0.8924657702445984,
0.6177585124969482,
-0.5355066061019897,
-0.1258113831281662,
-0.42831748723983765,
-0.6529455184936523,
0.5926312804222107,
-0.07072346657514572,
0.07746385037899017,
-0.030446330085396767,
0.5469777584075928,
0.14527742564678192,
0.21532493829727173,
-0.6381359100341797,
-0.0004195957735646516,
0.10404114425182343,
-0.02073836885392666,
-0.14080797135829926,
-0.0672730803489685,
-0.06698311865329742,
-0.33562609553337097,
0.6991115808486938,
-0.10270709544420242,
-0.12313933670520782,
-0.001199802733026445,
-0.20831181108951569,
0.014575498178601265,
0.12977731227874756,
0.3941528797149658,
0.7383270859718323,
-0.05011715739965439,
0.07119504362344742,
0.650843620300293,
-0.11087971180677414,
0.07128541171550751,
-0.219715878367424,
0.014874273911118507,
-0.14309477806091309,
0.6781209111213684,
0.6637474894523621,
0.7089935541152954,
-0.9329678416252136,
0.458191841840744,
0.018558619543910027,
-0.6540853977203369,
0.15528468787670135,
0.03203403204679489,
0.10364103317260742,
0.543163001537323,
0.44560104608535767,
-0.145545095205307,
0.4080575704574585,
-0.8847357630729675,
0.3740592896938324,
0.6284996867179871,
-0.5233110189437866,
-0.14965392649173737,
0.9852008819580078,
0.2754893898963928,
-0.12601521611213684,
0.1466362178325653,
0.007167125586420298,
-0.820303201675415,
0.34141939878463745,
0.18781279027462006,
0.48028987646102905,
0.12413057684898376,
0.36826443672180176,
0.672211229801178,
0.12884321808815002,
-0.2726854979991913,
0.32339537143707275,
-0.1227254644036293,
-0.7548803091049194,
-0.7429559826850891,
-0.878972589969635,
-0.475056529045105,
0.25022727251052856,
-0.5365551114082336,
0.0332481823861599,
-0.48355740308761597,
-0.44052252173423767,
0.3105681836605072,
0.2374865561723709,
-1.1482691764831543,
0.45599839091300964,
0.8415223360061646,
1.2926931381225586,
-0.7093091607093811,
0.6798326969146729,
0.5456927418708801,
-0.5406599640846252,
-0.8339822888374329,
0.03382646292448044,
-0.010308271273970604,
-0.6728854775428772,
1.1660668849945068,
0.05477229133248329,
-0.17866486310958862,
-0.29999053478240967,
-0.5654170513153076,
-0.4793037474155426,
0.9768714904785156,
0.06618338823318481,
-0.36151769757270813,
-0.06795820593833923,
0.32699641585350037,
0.5286423563957214,
-0.2109890878200531,
0.3857104480266571,
0.9626904129981995,
0.4030795991420746,
0.3499617874622345,
-0.9213996529579163,
-0.08364962041378021,
0.097331702709198,
-0.22989000380039215,
-0.008610693737864494,
-0.6399427056312561,
0.4675920009613037,
0.02412942238152027,
0.0510697141289711,
0.17149513959884644,
0.7679364085197449,
0.3938460350036621,
0.2460748851299286,
0.3345319628715515,
0.24733634293079376,
0.8512824177742004,
-0.19485537707805634,
0.8570082783699036,
0.15817664563655853,
0.32684484124183655,
1.3671631813049316,
-0.5863051414489746,
1.1655715703964233,
0.15895991027355194,
-0.41777512431144714,
0.2101057916879654,
0.4101475477218628,
0.13255645334720612,
0.12856988608837128,
0.4617428779602051,
-0.3582810163497925,
-0.8926604986190796,
0.05976841226220131,
-0.2524174153804779,
1.1570007801055908,
0.1302989423274994,
-0.07286687940359116,
-0.3662665784358978,
-0.23018820583820343,
-0.09648840874433517,
0.384410560131073,
-0.6328681707382202,
0.8851056098937988,
0.13326141238212585,
-0.7082107067108154,
0.2751229405403137,
-0.22191542387008667,
0.6074809432029724,
-0.6673734784126282,
-0.06512749940156937,
-0.06156904250383377,
0.053554411977529526,
0.12082123011350632,
-1.279815673828125,
0.08655307441949844,
0.272103488445282,
-0.04622834548354149,
-0.16158495843410492,
0.5048021674156189,
-0.4297037124633789,
-0.2324666678905487,
0.3302752375602722,
0.6349933743476868,
0.20876723527908325,
-0.18622350692749023,
-1.0327104330062866,
0.15832804143428802,
-0.4974568486213684,
-0.1989128142595291,
0.3907504677772522,
0.7260009050369263,
0.3018089830875397,
0.688152015209198,
0.6193861365318298,
0.3170970380306244,
0.014451483264565468,
0.23876258730888367,
0.6232208013534546,
-0.6383563280105591,
-0.36954084038734436,
-0.8126642107963562,
0.2749103903770447,
-0.2933795154094696,
-0.6946031451225281,
0.6107330918312073,
0.793408215045929,
0.4757676422595978,
-0.007151818368583918,
0.6892424821853638,
0.24291402101516724,
0.4296416640281677,
-0.6340305805206299,
0.9357025623321533,
-0.6188080310821533,
0.10002419352531433,
0.053468022495508194,
-0.6797688603401184,
-0.5622875094413757,
0.5316547751426697,
-0.4791160821914673,
-0.08709211647510529,
0.4853508770465851,
0.038329947739839554,
0.08216960728168488,
0.06951214373111725,
0.5161625742912292,
0.061338212341070175,
0.25166746973991394,
0.8045299053192139,
0.9768970608711243,
-0.538196861743927,
0.6989691853523254,
0.10891667008399963,
-0.2782570421695709,
-0.06418140977621078,
-0.9749520421028137,
-1.2640314102172852,
-0.4954727292060852,
-0.2432432323694229,
-0.3802430331707001,
0.19255103170871735,
1.1752487421035767,
0.7178480625152588,
-0.8937891721725464,
-0.16636495292186737,
0.4280928075313568,
-0.12035638839006424,
-0.4633246660232544,
-0.14664326608181,
0.22415055334568024,
-0.5286890268325806,
-0.7714859843254089,
0.5587460398674011,
0.27183622121810913,
-0.435033917427063,
0.024721400812268257,
-0.21775460243225098,
-0.5810899138450623,
0.3832258880138397,
1.0219640731811523,
0.6058623790740967,
-0.6771199703216553,
-0.3824608325958252,
0.07807449251413345,
0.055208783596754074,
0.008413557894527912,
0.7056507468223572,
-1.0478342771530151,
0.3185381293296814,
0.5420791506767273,
0.9081071019172668,
0.42120328545570374,
0.041672129184007645,
0.5859236717224121,
-0.5338534116744995,
0.009418677538633347,
0.5046183466911316,
0.210732564330101,
0.05831408500671387,
0.12513673305511475,
0.49460655450820923,
0.21121639013290405,
-0.268546462059021,
-0.788836658000946,
-0.02107762172818184,
-1.0044012069702148,
-0.41814300417900085,
1.196975588798523,
0.06985243409872055,
-0.16411587595939636,
-0.23859208822250366,
-0.07883244007825851,
0.13901576399803162,
-0.10015042126178741,
0.7017566561698914,
0.9496487975120544,
-0.07079435884952545,
-0.1424477994441986,
-0.798890233039856,
0.7898068428039551,
0.2461944818496704,
-0.7331886887550354,
0.07952424138784409,
0.30956414341926575,
0.07648732513189316,
-0.44505074620246887,
0.5898374319076538,
0.33667781949043274,
0.42663657665252686,
-0.03860069811344147,
-0.36902594566345215,
0.18112650513648987,
-0.3516591191291809,
-0.026547575369477272,
0.29639747738838196,
-0.01892245002090931,
0.03977876156568527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15861v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15861v4
|
MATHWELL: Generating Age-Appropriate Educational Math Word Problems
| 2024-02-24T17:08:45 | 2024-04-16T13:52:01 |
Bryan R Christ, Jonathan Kropko, Thomas Hartvigsen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Math word problems are critical K-8 educational tools, but writing them is
time-consuming and requires domain expertise. We suggest that language models
can support K-8 math education by automatically generating problems. To be
educational, generated problems must be 1) solvable, 2) accurate, and 3)
appropriate. Existing datasets are unlabeled for these criteria, making them
ill-suited for training problem generators. To address this gap, we use domain
expert annotation to curate a high-quality synthetic training dataset for this
task. We show the value of this data by using it to iteratively finetune
Llama-2 (70B) to create MATHWELL, a K-8 word problem generator. Domain experts
find MATHWELL has a 40% higher share of problems that have executable solutions
and meet all criteria than existing open-source models, with 74% of its
problems with executable solutions being solvable, accurate, and appropriate.
MATHWELL achieves 94.9% of GPT-4 Turbo's performance on this task while
outputting problems written at a more appropriate reading level for K-8
students. MATHWELL's performance despite being trained by finetuning only
highlights the quality of our synthetic data for training age-appropriate word
problem generators. We release our model, data, and annotations.
|
[
-0.13988758623600006,
-0.6028591394424438,
0.384120374917984,
0.1775018721818924,
0.0581454373896122,
0.02181096002459526,
-0.013495449908077717,
-0.22966141998767853,
-0.32874825596809387,
0.27288922667503357,
-0.6677923798561096,
-0.2442575842142105,
-0.6706803441047668,
0.24487771093845367,
-0.2674243748188019,
1.0717487335205078,
-0.21974743902683258,
-0.04096669703722,
-0.43641197681427,
0.14153428375720978,
-0.6002264022827148,
-0.39449775218963623,
-0.6069649457931519,
-0.5604430437088013,
0.17764189839363098,
0.48373815417289734,
0.7132877707481384,
0.7693095803260803,
0.4560602605342865,
0.33091869950294495,
0.24232040345668793,
0.37449929118156433,
-0.6549391746520996,
0.20162822306156158,
-0.07234515994787216,
-0.334944486618042,
-0.3911401927471161,
0.23474670946598053,
0.21212638914585114,
0.8979884386062622,
-0.13442997634410858,
0.125333771109581,
-0.15150664746761322,
0.6247767806053162,
-0.4327559173107147,
0.4459667503833771,
-1.0159193277359009,
0.34653523564338684,
-0.36848247051239014,
-0.16671805083751678,
-0.08497133105993271,
-0.55478835105896,
-0.05281869322061539,
-1.0812709331512451,
0.29979363083839417,
0.17652367055416107,
0.5560155510902405,
0.2753407657146454,
-0.14446374773979187,
-0.7060404419898987,
-0.47183412313461304,
0.821593701839447,
-0.7856954336166382,
0.22698204219341278,
0.6804640293121338,
0.37560194730758667,
-0.45738518238067627,
-0.539736270904541,
-0.7629128694534302,
-0.04835659638047218,
0.2690453827381134,
0.15350866317749023,
-0.14047451317310333,
-0.3232532739639282,
0.5218868255615234,
0.422782301902771,
-0.48455286026000977,
0.010149449110031128,
-0.8062335848808289,
-0.46593886613845825,
0.7584862112998962,
0.5534423589706421,
0.3814970552921295,
0.004522587638348341,
0.11898791790008545,
0.06534859538078308,
-0.8860177993774414,
-0.0077777220867574215,
0.7053521275520325,
0.2842694818973541,
0.3226272761821747,
0.7583271861076355,
-0.05681629106402397,
0.7007851004600525,
-0.051019929349422455,
-0.22599826753139496,
0.14128844439983368,
0.031062621623277664,
-0.02651173435151577,
0.10162424296140671,
0.5213574767112732,
0.18402831256389618,
0.8027511835098267,
-0.11191229522228241,
-0.5850505828857422,
0.48541611433029175,
0.08393273502588272,
-0.7754976153373718,
-0.565531849861145,
0.11173893511295319,
0.1981980800628662,
-0.49622148275375366,
-0.22059109807014465,
-0.5392807126045227,
-0.43607285618782043,
-0.6169614791870117,
0.6071661114692688,
-0.4991427958011627,
-0.07748550921678543,
0.15837301313877106,
-0.22973263263702393,
-0.34769758582115173,
0.21897052228450775,
-0.848228931427002,
0.0782417505979538,
0.5451534986495972,
0.4347027540206909,
0.06779830157756805,
-0.27570006251335144,
-0.6533673405647278,
0.07479272782802582,
-0.5209104418754578,
0.7640270590782166,
-0.7148050665855408,
-0.5825716257095337,
0.11691872775554657,
-0.1622220277786255,
-0.02737325429916382,
-0.7831276655197144,
0.15424132347106934,
-0.19977392256259918,
0.4402541220188141,
0.022093743085861206,
-0.696243941783905,
0.3288087546825409,
0.1983596831560135,
-0.4816605746746063,
1.0289241075515747,
0.4692070782184601,
-0.5865373611450195,
0.15228861570358276,
-0.5516010522842407,
-0.23002976179122925,
0.3783920407295227,
-0.2642141878604889,
-0.4567449390888214,
0.12433439493179321,
0.37103068828582764,
0.16980186104774475,
-0.036258526146411896,
0.488803505897522,
-0.012816340662539005,
-0.1810702234506607,
0.1924172341823578,
-0.4174340069293976,
0.5966996550559998,
0.24351325631141663,
-0.4608739912509918,
-0.4006294310092926,
-0.8830306529998779,
0.30103233456611633,
0.36064961552619934,
-0.24635136127471924,
-0.2984198033809662,
-0.1210777536034584,
-0.29583680629730225,
-0.04495494067668915,
0.30338501930236816,
-0.6324508190155029,
0.26890087127685547,
-0.5499221682548523,
0.3337300717830658,
0.759445309638977,
-0.0854296013712883,
0.18902184069156647,
-0.48831093311309814,
0.6635351181030273,
0.07096108049154282,
-0.07968047261238098,
-0.11811718344688416,
-0.7187363505363464,
-0.7525397539138794,
0.1654399335384369,
0.22461310029029846,
0.6452012062072754,
-0.9218647480010986,
0.219243124127388,
-0.16103923320770264,
-0.6514748930931091,
-0.5544523596763611,
0.32487401366233826,
0.4523037374019623,
0.7878398895263672,
0.32244762778282166,
-0.02004910446703434,
-0.3255397081375122,
-0.7895631790161133,
-0.35593685507774353,
0.16939236223697662,
0.02610233798623085,
0.39203062653541565,
0.44586023688316345,
-0.24179965257644653,
1.090645670890808,
-0.7412655353546143,
-0.49014145135879517,
0.09029200673103333,
0.4654453992843628,
0.05772821977734566,
0.42978382110595703,
0.30295589566230774,
-0.456768274307251,
-0.43724367022514343,
0.05360002443194389,
-0.6833966374397278,
-0.689590573310852,
0.13738472759723663,
-0.1967773139476776,
0.05134280025959015,
-0.01631896384060383,
-0.5107833743095398,
0.6213845610618591,
0.2483309656381607,
-0.2714107632637024,
0.5900120735168457,
-0.17709818482398987,
-0.08620390295982361,
-0.934909462928772,
0.04960854351520538,
-0.030451709404587746,
-0.06386160105466843,
-0.4737321138381958,
0.03822547569870949,
-0.16822189092636108,
-0.8036639094352722,
-0.1448797881603241,
0.4904276132583618,
-0.29753637313842773,
0.21274521946907043,
-0.28268495202064514,
0.31078284978866577,
0.055794864892959595,
0.1909952312707901,
-0.20608265697956085,
1.0491900444030762,
0.17930403351783752,
-0.485983669757843,
0.6134480237960815,
0.20541371405124664,
-0.28640255331993103,
0.5783523321151733,
-0.6099107265472412,
0.27061721682548523,
-0.16528119146823883,
0.02731136791408062,
-0.5814302563667297,
-0.287788987159729,
0.21172243356704712,
-0.6276881098747253,
0.09536097198724747,
0.27034860849380493,
-0.15066516399383545,
-0.4845987856388092,
-0.23124416172504425,
0.30955249071121216,
0.5351555943489075,
-0.346802294254303,
0.1702776849269867,
0.4877353310585022,
-0.42908138036727905,
-0.5266122817993164,
-0.5558448433876038,
-0.13627710938453674,
0.06875310093164444,
-0.44018223881721497,
0.055552951991558075,
-0.2617785930633545,
-0.24015866219997406,
0.4478132128715515,
-0.2601797580718994,
-0.3767983317375183,
-0.062277451157569885,
0.18075837194919586,
0.19563864171504974,
-0.05481409654021263,
0.1539154052734375,
0.21453385055065155,
-0.2743965983390808,
0.2101774364709854,
-0.19987893104553223,
0.15510694682598114,
0.09766902029514313,
-0.16115687787532806,
0.13074378669261932,
0.5260055661201477,
0.25528982281684875,
-0.23747612535953522,
0.2136380970478058,
0.44018229842185974,
-0.8125953674316406,
-0.6838792562484741,
-0.16327770054340363,
-0.10150930285453796,
-0.45788106322288513,
0.21478232741355896,
-0.2652837336063385,
-0.8451434373855591,
0.24527963995933533,
-0.007915765047073364,
0.4786422550678253,
0.5862300992012024,
0.5167052745819092,
0.06931204348802567,
1.1115849018096924,
0.34964969754219055,
0.16264939308166504,
-0.023817678913474083,
-0.46319496631622314,
0.4548386037349701,
-0.42607641220092773,
-0.4160483777523041,
-0.41169917583465576,
-0.21013876795768738,
-0.3040974736213684,
-0.19481821358203888,
0.39105117321014404,
0.0657806247472763,
-0.2736802101135254,
0.37684011459350586,
-0.8391578793525696,
0.5249837636947632,
0.4249623715877533,
-0.2937590181827545,
0.17984680831432343,
0.37329551577568054,
-0.21899713575839996,
-0.521949052810669,
-0.6296414732933044,
-0.4002854824066162,
0.9217860698699951,
-0.046869147568941116,
0.8050483465194702,
0.13457335531711578,
0.6596043109893799,
0.3201029896736145,
0.6547504663467407,
-0.9075107574462891,
0.4217933118343353,
-0.20675812661647797,
-0.9148896336555481,
-0.374708354473114,
-0.6442194581031799,
-1.101511001586914,
-0.2162390649318695,
-0.2325437068939209,
-0.5153109431266785,
-0.144232377409935,
0.29165881872177124,
-0.40370723605155945,
-0.005983536597341299,
-0.7049024701118469,
0.5790095925331116,
0.00741268927231431,
-0.2985624670982361,
-0.14059586822986603,
-0.15937817096710205,
0.3937671184539795,
-0.530379056930542,
0.43033313751220703,
-0.4528888165950775,
0.23851341009140015,
0.7432575225830078,
-0.9888696074485779,
0.7506341934204102,
-0.3421230614185333,
-0.40143856406211853,
0.6672230958938599,
0.380135715007782,
0.34312471747398376,
-0.11859943717718124,
0.029138565063476562,
-0.21433469653129578,
0.06550998985767365,
-0.1290537714958191,
-0.815374493598938,
0.9451800584793091,
-0.9319868087768555,
-0.8285326957702637,
-0.5998106002807617,
-0.7515773177146912,
-0.3409477472305298,
0.23832561075687408,
0.2068260759115219,
1.0007100105285645,
0.46232420206069946,
-0.02053133212029934,
0.5261186361312866,
-0.0018388692988082767,
0.35273104906082153,
0.3303567171096802,
-0.20552219450473785,
-0.7220895886421204,
1.5121159553527832,
0.729534924030304,
-0.0890939012169838,
-0.09876270592212677,
0.49231404066085815,
-0.27110323309898376,
-0.11100399494171143,
-0.6400211453437805,
0.018500007688999176,
-0.84581059217453,
-0.5996432900428772,
-0.17173559963703156,
-0.6491844058036804,
-0.43312570452690125,
-0.376136839389801,
-0.058692917227745056,
-0.5744249820709229,
-0.2759856879711151,
0.07439292967319489,
0.5241602659225464,
0.897633969783783,
-0.14622847735881805,
0.3624681532382965,
-0.8772871494293213,
0.21878460049629211,
0.678072452545166,
0.19550080597400665,
-0.09857849776744843,
-0.5488002896308899,
-0.13956834375858307,
0.14118483662605286,
-0.7368502020835876,
-0.6887221932411194,
0.3793182969093323,
0.5686556100845337,
0.4029141068458557,
0.09908714145421982,
0.07742877304553986,
0.7098329067230225,
-0.7739182710647583,
0.862786054611206,
0.08426756411790848,
-1.0066463947296143,
0.5597835779190063,
-0.3079976737499237,
0.3014604449272156,
0.24634972214698792,
0.4437660574913025,
-0.4078722298145294,
-0.29128241539001465,
-0.6843687891960144,
-0.7821324467658997,
0.4562944173812866,
0.37378641963005066,
0.41289326548576355,
-0.07338209450244904,
0.3626837134361267,
0.41195622086524963,
0.293797105550766,
-0.4287252128124237,
-0.03603105619549751,
-0.5133135914802551,
-0.7619973421096802,
0.33689427375793457,
-0.03845244646072388,
-0.1075102686882019,
-0.25543180108070374,
0.8255037665367126,
-0.12607523798942566,
0.2891823649406433,
-0.09199213981628418,
-0.06268879771232605,
-0.4615878462791443,
0.07664814591407776,
0.6528864502906799,
0.9529294371604919,
0.13925081491470337,
0.18428871035575867,
-0.013924445025622845,
-0.8306481242179871,
0.3170871138572693,
0.4253598153591156,
-0.0748957097530365,
-0.0947212278842926,
0.423117458820343,
0.6479299068450928,
0.016102321445941925,
-0.7400031685829163,
0.5113167762756348,
0.11110720038414001,
-0.5289745330810547,
-0.4727973937988281,
0.37100011110305786,
-0.06463027745485306,
-0.04722088202834129,
0.43856939673423767,
-0.18102099001407623,
0.02402666211128235,
-0.1256185621023178,
0.12387538701295853,
0.2697173058986664,
0.002679541241377592,
-0.4234597086906433,
0.8039759993553162,
0.33526411652565,
-0.6797972321510315,
0.9066792130470276,
-0.24206215143203735,
-0.5767147541046143,
0.6185073852539062,
0.9884414672851562,
0.4970286190509796,
-0.2461124211549759,
0.17239952087402344,
0.39217323064804077,
0.13771560788154602,
0.2371288686990738,
0.5898962616920471,
0.12832246720790863,
-0.7777536511421204,
-0.46127769351005554,
-0.38589513301849365,
-0.4599619209766388,
0.38673606514930725,
-0.5071690678596497,
0.14912071824073792,
-0.5975739359855652,
-0.31379422545433044,
0.02831033244729042,
0.24711854755878448,
-0.8723796010017395,
0.6559200882911682,
0.05901597440242767,
0.7200849056243896,
-0.8292461633682251,
0.36374861001968384,
0.8540579080581665,
-0.11213131248950958,
-1.0632717609405518,
-0.4496656060218811,
-0.0894288420677185,
-1.1221355199813843,
0.5617850422859192,
0.32024669647216797,
-0.034627482295036316,
0.46282005310058594,
-0.8680098056793213,
-0.5657798647880554,
0.9362070560455322,
0.24147702753543854,
-0.6417527198791504,
0.12401650100946426,
0.4726617634296417,
0.31427377462387085,
-0.2807725965976715,
-0.0241608414798975,
0.2872656285762787,
0.43852391839027405,
0.0008342916262336075,
-0.6469780206680298,
-0.2679591178894043,
-0.6214997172355652,
0.011423885822296143,
0.23837225139141083,
-0.2514725923538208,
0.7061204314231873,
-0.23770438134670258,
-0.13296744227409363,
-0.10562334954738617,
0.6202884912490845,
0.6401136517524719,
0.6446439623832703,
0.3612557351589203,
0.9405712485313416,
0.7670381665229797,
-0.19536523520946503,
0.673331618309021,
-0.46551334857940674,
0.2559710443019867,
0.6765522956848145,
0.027661457657814026,
0.4936842918395996,
0.20852795243263245,
-0.20325353741645813,
0.19405311346054077,
0.6192063093185425,
0.005252826027572155,
0.45143887400627136,
0.5708467960357666,
-0.2585594654083252,
-0.38443705439567566,
-0.23316606879234314,
-0.5562154650688171,
0.28116267919540405,
0.5087438821792603,
0.014382978901267052,
-0.3833986818790436,
-0.1495635211467743,
0.22492118179798126,
0.2501648962497711,
-0.3685452342033386,
0.2698740065097809,
0.4361303150653839,
-0.40587061643600464,
0.39908814430236816,
-0.011956079863011837,
0.38271674513816833,
-0.5028108954429626,
-0.3435167074203491,
-0.43773552775382996,
0.11077682673931122,
-0.20789648592472076,
-0.7717968821525574,
0.10891330242156982,
0.2336316704750061,
-0.13519205152988434,
0.1078406572341919,
0.7729548215866089,
-0.7816721796989441,
-0.8953201770782471,
-0.6653222441673279,
0.5121484994888306,
0.27013733983039856,
0.4000171720981598,
-0.42944979667663574,
-0.039227183908224106,
-0.2873094975948334,
-0.15085943043231964,
0.11483693867921829,
0.799693763256073,
-0.11922599375247955,
0.5637000203132629,
0.6990317106246948,
0.3328951895236969,
0.15409190952777863,
-0.04191111773252487,
0.7611829042434692,
-0.2763966917991638,
-0.2279256135225296,
-0.5598137974739075,
0.5264760851860046,
-0.048138245940208435,
-0.7661396861076355,
0.6646062135696411,
0.34233909845352173,
0.7866728901863098,
-0.12810677289962769,
1.0494978427886963,
0.11369384080171585,
0.34306052327156067,
-0.22816362977027893,
0.6166484355926514,
-0.43710705637931824,
-0.18698768317699432,
-0.07073833793401718,
-1.062768578529358,
-0.1470528542995453,
0.8563022017478943,
-0.3635355234146118,
0.16201019287109375,
0.5386017560958862,
0.6225916743278503,
0.0503959059715271,
0.16489797830581665,
0.3239971399307251,
-0.26723527908325195,
0.4454438388347626,
0.8228035569190979,
0.8337643146514893,
-0.4654137194156647,
0.32977625727653503,
-0.4605047404766083,
-0.2206190675497055,
0.14556021988391876,
-0.8642510771751404,
-0.8548699617385864,
-0.4075583815574646,
-0.2590316832065582,
-0.25010251998901367,
-0.09341505169868469,
0.9940878748893738,
0.2689470946788788,
-0.7005361318588257,
0.06181376054883003,
-0.04118653014302254,
-0.17756257951259613,
0.18947988748550415,
-0.24470743536949158,
0.21428723633289337,
-0.4358275830745697,
-0.751018762588501,
0.34552687406539917,
-0.10770522803068161,
0.20020829141139984,
-0.4752931296825409,
0.1985263079404831,
0.6451148986816406,
0.3273893892765045,
0.41543957591056824,
0.20073574781417847,
-0.3898341655731201,
-0.4675179719924927,
0.08497393131256104,
-0.11612780392169952,
-0.37647637724876404,
0.7937058806419373,
-0.6326483488082886,
0.6564335823059082,
0.2681083679199219,
1.0078715085983276,
-0.054611776024103165,
-0.04258519783616066,
0.5204336643218994,
-0.5836901068687439,
-0.025099504739046097,
0.26745840907096863,
0.07831595093011856,
0.5715718865394592,
-0.4980604946613312,
0.43604639172554016,
0.773922324180603,
-0.6353641152381897,
-0.8224582672119141,
0.0886354148387909,
-0.09179740399122238,
0.06261026114225388,
1.0834027528762817,
-0.07710331678390503,
-0.20628462731838226,
0.0639328733086586,
-0.24995708465576172,
0.17674337327480316,
-0.2398708313703537,
0.9399097561836243,
0.8214299082756042,
0.045264288783073425,
0.09997952729463577,
-0.59944748878479,
0.5132526755332947,
0.328296422958374,
-0.7051263451576233,
-0.09964798390865326,
0.5524277091026306,
0.23400112986564636,
0.07930082827806473,
0.48126792907714844,
0.09421870857477188,
0.20638446509838104,
0.2802311182022095,
0.01269691064953804,
-0.6112529039382935,
-0.41385617852211,
0.250081866979599,
0.049359239637851715,
0.10259448736906052,
0.12083812803030014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15833v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15833v1
|
Prompt Perturbation Consistency Learning for Robust Language Models
| 2024-02-24T15:00:58 | 2024-02-24T15:00:58 |
Yao Qiang, Subhrangshu Nandi, Ninareh Mehrabi, Greg Ver Steeg, Anoop Kumar, Anna Rumshisky, Aram Galstyan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance on a
number of natural language processing tasks, such as question answering and
text summarization. However, their performance on sequence labeling tasks such
as intent classification and slot filling (IC-SF), which is a central component
in personal assistant systems, lags significantly behind discriminative models.
Furthermore, there is a lack of substantive research on the robustness of LLMs
to various perturbations in the input prompts. The contributions of this paper
are three-fold. First, we show that fine-tuning sufficiently large LLMs can
produce IC-SF performance comparable to discriminative models. Next, we
systematically analyze the performance deterioration of those fine-tuned models
due to three distinct yet relevant types of input perturbations - oronyms,
synonyms, and paraphrasing. Finally, we propose an efficient mitigation
approach, Prompt Perturbation Consistency Learning (PPCL), which works by
regularizing the divergence between losses from clean and perturbed samples.
Our experiments demonstrate that PPCL can recover on average 59% and 69% of the
performance drop for IC and SF tasks, respectively. Furthermore, PPCL beats the
data augmentation approach while using ten times fewer augmented data samples.
|
[
-0.28528016805648804,
-0.9332066178321838,
0.7289949655532837,
0.1663215309381485,
0.003176290076225996,
0.031744152307510376,
-0.4145115911960602,
0.05852508544921875,
-0.33253952860832214,
0.5682165622711182,
-0.5125334858894348,
-0.6104268431663513,
-0.5919656157493591,
0.37657707929611206,
-0.05798729509115219,
0.7500283122062683,
0.013514901511371136,
-0.06112409755587578,
-0.2161117047071457,
0.018143542110919952,
-0.6598703861236572,
-0.5881952047348022,
-0.7287346124649048,
-0.1564677506685257,
0.4435054659843445,
0.6377126574516296,
0.7203203439712524,
0.7355523109436035,
0.11632001399993896,
0.33165881037712097,
-0.2916308045387268,
0.3140345513820648,
-0.4389539957046509,
0.5433911681175232,
0.08119925111532211,
-0.33799901604652405,
-0.262864887714386,
-0.10945642739534378,
0.86813884973526,
0.9048495292663574,
-0.1496105194091797,
-0.2942277193069458,
0.6332586407661438,
0.3192974328994751,
-0.6442264318466187,
0.11499961465597153,
-0.7250005006790161,
-0.13660606741905212,
-0.26638302206993103,
-0.11841363459825516,
-0.5285537838935852,
-0.18769966065883636,
0.01252332516014576,
-0.5751441717147827,
0.1375901848077774,
-0.10681547969579697,
0.8701982498168945,
0.5013232231140137,
-0.08082500845193863,
-0.04005728289484978,
-0.6496248245239258,
0.894855260848999,
-0.8042005300521851,
0.4202084541320801,
0.6884037852287292,
-0.03024902567267418,
-0.5825086236000061,
-0.4195963442325592,
-0.5957126617431641,
-0.41293880343437195,
-0.023544415831565857,
-0.29460811614990234,
-0.03686976805329323,
0.33946043252944946,
0.5016725063323975,
0.16316674649715424,
-0.45767346024513245,
0.49674463272094727,
0.4598701298236847,
-0.4847041666507721,
0.18242506682872772,
0.3414970636367798,
0.14748802781105042,
0.11508394032716751,
-0.2570677697658539,
-0.29049864411354065,
-0.7907596826553345,
0.4366685748100281,
0.5830621719360352,
0.5080258846282959,
0.013648485764861107,
0.40829622745513916,
-0.14566299319267273,
0.8291029334068298,
0.41301971673965454,
-0.4321582615375519,
0.0947197824716568,
-0.45573824644088745,
-0.164564847946167,
-0.19469988346099854,
0.7909592390060425,
-0.22850416600704193,
0.1315808892250061,
-0.04312312602996826,
-0.3169776201248169,
-0.2520035207271576,
-0.13201235234737396,
-0.4670652747154236,
-0.369255930185318,
0.060276102274656296,
-0.04410463944077492,
-0.02403930015861988,
0.005552910268306732,
-0.48641565442085266,
-0.4833124279975891,
-0.3766022026538849,
0.2535240650177002,
-0.4217910170555115,
0.2248411327600479,
0.13422206044197083,
0.3753573000431061,
0.15893200039863586,
0.5995117425918579,
-0.9612150192260742,
0.3665132224559784,
0.6124106049537659,
0.6543727517127991,
-0.2427072376012802,
-0.3269058167934418,
-0.9766164422035217,
-0.01847023516893387,
-0.18343497812747955,
0.8059091567993164,
-0.6072587370872498,
-0.4447551965713501,
0.06319373100996017,
-0.01178748719394207,
-0.10209529846906662,
-0.705157458782196,
0.5605757236480713,
-0.37510448694229126,
0.20600804686546326,
-0.4899138808250427,
-0.5644944906234741,
0.1443648338317871,
0.2984260022640228,
-0.47105926275253296,
0.9051733613014221,
-0.03535173833370209,
-0.7462512850761414,
0.24141046404838562,
-0.18884803354740143,
-0.5007609128952026,
-0.10137050598859787,
-0.14149625599384308,
-0.671059787273407,
-0.02281453274190426,
0.23253554105758667,
0.6028474569320679,
0.011495819315314293,
0.33070307970046997,
-0.459598571062088,
-0.4508011043071747,
0.21437494456768036,
-0.5184520483016968,
0.6383558511734009,
-0.027366720139980316,
-0.12207110226154327,
0.3334466516971588,
-0.8256905674934387,
-0.4566896855831146,
-0.24155539274215698,
-0.6511320471763611,
-0.25065556168556213,
0.10649683326482773,
-0.2576133608818054,
0.10756658017635345,
0.28543171286582947,
-0.5022293329238892,
0.23581281304359436,
-0.3763554096221924,
0.17421412467956543,
0.9797245860099792,
0.058969635516405106,
0.28372886776924133,
-0.33310386538505554,
0.4404446482658386,
0.0936129167675972,
-0.06634683161973953,
-0.6102620959281921,
-0.30521032214164734,
-0.5398848652839661,
-0.43472036719322205,
0.35801076889038086,
0.5811896920204163,
-0.6761422157287598,
0.7325550317764282,
0.036934539675712585,
-0.10077182203531265,
-0.22883334755897522,
0.5080081224441528,
0.4428872764110565,
1.0308303833007812,
0.36850300431251526,
-0.1939467340707779,
-0.45708075165748596,
-0.664616048336029,
-0.2684539258480072,
-0.23973985016345978,
-0.30711811780929565,
0.16051876544952393,
-0.10523786395788193,
-0.15508076548576355,
0.8682544827461243,
-0.1616210639476776,
-0.31264933943748474,
-0.16593249142169952,
0.15572240948677063,
0.23996667563915253,
0.5266392230987549,
0.140692800283432,
-0.5053752660751343,
-0.6205017566680908,
-0.2330128699541092,
-0.2457636445760727,
-0.3505341112613678,
-0.23404870927333832,
0.3189047574996948,
0.2544389069080353,
0.5280694961547852,
-0.29927536845207214,
0.23803456127643585,
0.4916781485080719,
-0.27596762776374817,
0.7248029112815857,
-0.16463962197303772,
-0.06976284831762314,
-0.8742051124572754,
0.05339512601494789,
0.22184978425502777,
-0.47277018427848816,
-0.6861876249313354,
-0.531093418598175,
-0.05512940138578415,
0.08652991056442261,
-0.32555463910102844,
0.5439052581787109,
-0.37508028745651245,
0.14345945417881012,
-0.289233535528183,
0.01886126957833767,
-0.04728700965642929,
0.4649001955986023,
-0.13140346109867096,
0.8411840796470642,
0.585983157157898,
-0.9180669188499451,
-0.06345883011817932,
0.4062710702419281,
0.05249421298503876,
0.25844907760620117,
-0.7372074127197266,
0.21166536211967468,
-0.21233512461185455,
0.1095268726348877,
-1.50509512424469,
-0.4257522225379944,
0.1787085086107254,
-0.46612632274627686,
0.594291627407074,
0.017301667481660843,
-0.6319864392280579,
0.08317924290895462,
-0.431791752576828,
0.16250057518482208,
0.46904468536376953,
-0.6257069706916809,
0.5585782527923584,
0.21784333884716034,
-0.25285008549690247,
-0.6460191011428833,
-0.34109026193618774,
-0.12109963595867157,
-0.10646568983793259,
-0.4438480734825134,
0.29963818192481995,
-0.0542965792119503,
-0.08615542203187943,
-0.365448534488678,
-0.11621672660112381,
0.1159711480140686,
0.5207962393760681,
0.15886273980140686,
0.19157400727272034,
-0.0470295213162899,
0.13324809074401855,
0.10725279897451401,
-0.02118404023349285,
-0.1887618750333786,
-0.048835624009370804,
0.7260767817497253,
-0.020404933020472527,
-0.22142241895198822,
-0.8052200078964233,
0.0866236686706543,
0.4472239315509796,
-0.04685473442077637,
0.6536980271339417,
0.515479564666748,
-0.3527918756008148,
0.03361760824918747,
-0.6801525950431824,
-0.3914496600627899,
-0.5251619219779968,
0.24839527904987335,
-0.42939403653144836,
-1.067278265953064,
0.6823320388793945,
0.03261234983801842,
0.16735458374023438,
0.27126848697662354,
0.4889504313468933,
-0.18345879018306732,
1.1801267862319946,
0.7712544202804565,
-0.14061620831489563,
0.696693480014801,
0.20078161358833313,
-0.07935794442892075,
-0.7578862309455872,
-0.1634635627269745,
-0.6612527370452881,
-0.05889284610748291,
-0.34182289242744446,
-0.05489965155720711,
0.4138723313808441,
0.21124795079231262,
-0.34483802318573,
0.12272553890943527,
-0.11158495396375656,
0.2619819641113281,
0.4656599164009094,
0.09511274099349976,
0.27391335368156433,
0.08881398290395737,
-0.3078424334526062,
-0.16323870420455933,
-0.6044804453849792,
-0.7034642100334167,
0.8220561146736145,
0.47156646847724915,
0.8743695020675659,
-0.10248701274394989,
0.4925738275051117,
0.14691206812858582,
-0.046265777200460434,
-0.5072076916694641,
0.5255974531173706,
-0.28510016202926636,
0.060409724712371826,
-0.35811296105384827,
-0.33093786239624023,
-1.0313379764556885,
-0.0538010336458683,
-0.24452261626720428,
-0.8549319505691528,
0.3043544590473175,
0.6066910624504089,
-0.5647400617599487,
0.1808227300643921,
-0.44495466351509094,
0.6382280588150024,
0.010168159380555153,
-0.5818206071853638,
0.20697616040706635,
-0.7106764316558838,
0.2703900635242462,
0.07354151457548141,
-0.1705254465341568,
-0.06452537328004837,
-0.2628236413002014,
0.4626868963241577,
-0.2212962657213211,
0.9755638241767883,
-0.2393413484096527,
-0.2832272946834564,
-0.008932680822908878,
0.125364288687706,
0.7528203725814819,
0.1890641301870346,
-0.0045287469401955605,
-0.022695880383253098,
-0.30957287549972534,
-0.46937400102615356,
-0.5401644706726074,
0.7168322801589966,
-0.6364362835884094,
-0.7012336850166321,
-0.16617055237293243,
-0.5082219243049622,
-0.6738155484199524,
0.11315568536520004,
0.42525941133499146,
0.4704152047634125,
0.1531744748353958,
0.19724835455417633,
1.3238455057144165,
-0.2867042124271393,
0.5550019145011902,
0.3392370343208313,
0.059267230331897736,
-0.36603373289108276,
0.6486102342605591,
0.0382065623998642,
0.12277263402938843,
0.4742496907711029,
0.2550806403160095,
-0.407419890165329,
-0.7412562966346741,
-0.14053498208522797,
0.2648589611053467,
-0.4601213335990906,
-0.27961310744285583,
-0.71328204870224,
0.18101724982261658,
-0.5770710110664368,
-0.032083794474601746,
-0.23412258923053741,
-0.07933791726827621,
-0.7057468891143799,
0.21742939949035645,
0.07566442340612411,
0.46645715832710266,
0.23021289706230164,
0.4488891065120697,
-0.6960678100585938,
0.10311149805784225,
0.22377365827560425,
0.36270982027053833,
-0.217124804854393,
-0.7215645909309387,
0.06696128845214844,
-0.13220104575157166,
-0.420820951461792,
-0.9693604707717896,
0.2079877257347107,
0.24418264627456665,
0.6544651985168457,
0.6354132890701294,
0.10217446833848953,
0.602039635181427,
-0.33364301919937134,
0.937496542930603,
0.03658415004611015,
-0.9478213787078857,
0.4501535892486572,
-0.5030580759048462,
0.6288633346557617,
0.7068223357200623,
0.48420849442481995,
-0.3368069529533386,
-0.38649410009384155,
-0.4437577724456787,
-0.9050520062446594,
0.4768637418746948,
-0.26837942004203796,
0.04345713183283806,
-0.09732232242822647,
0.5259782671928406,
0.2469201534986496,
0.18360978364944458,
-0.47793132066726685,
-0.09594835340976715,
0.07026202231645584,
-0.4089759588241577,
-0.24259862303733826,
-0.47930312156677246,
0.2223651111125946,
-0.10785222053527832,
0.6282713413238525,
-0.2909868657588959,
0.05829201638698578,
0.28277212381362915,
-0.12069875001907349,
-0.028308294713497162,
0.2551504671573639,
0.7813466191291809,
0.38691169023513794,
0.05098116770386696,
0.19200517237186432,
0.183448925614357,
-0.34235984086990356,
0.18570297956466675,
0.11263763159513474,
-0.3318447470664978,
-0.12629321217536926,
0.24553124606609344,
0.7694445848464966,
0.1988016963005066,
-0.8546690344810486,
0.36861032247543335,
-0.11939771473407745,
0.015004465356469154,
-0.13467249274253845,
0.12838886678218842,
-0.40022575855255127,
-0.06862687319517136,
0.3375512957572937,
0.13658098876476288,
0.1755104809999466,
-0.36891892552375793,
0.22377252578735352,
0.5223504900932312,
-0.3991076350212097,
-0.5339440703392029,
0.6323041915893555,
-0.10042215138673782,
-0.2496013045310974,
0.5561622977256775,
-0.08863172680139542,
-0.5443043112754822,
0.16452187299728394,
0.5384837985038757,
0.8135170936584473,
-0.4426612854003906,
-0.026530997827649117,
0.3663848638534546,
0.03692027926445007,
-0.3150416910648346,
0.14085057377815247,
-0.2733764052391052,
-0.5456028580665588,
-0.6040616035461426,
-0.5486503839492798,
-0.42156311869621277,
0.43243151903152466,
-0.3640112578868866,
0.29853516817092896,
-0.7984466552734375,
-0.13895513117313385,
-0.3245912492275238,
0.08024455606937408,
-0.47158029675483704,
-0.06156573072075844,
0.06340357661247253,
0.717110276222229,
-0.7860744595527649,
0.8228445053100586,
0.8208819627761841,
-0.10547803342342377,
-0.9385364651679993,
0.3264862895011902,
-0.04478010907769203,
-0.28308549523353577,
0.30219566822052,
0.07976000756025314,
-0.10887935757637024,
-0.018844163045287132,
-0.6123949885368347,
-0.9542338252067566,
0.6872912645339966,
0.7212463021278381,
-0.6611496210098267,
-0.030339282006025314,
-0.16379952430725098,
0.45982226729393005,
-0.19302992522716522,
0.00417195213958621,
0.551711916923523,
0.46685656905174255,
-0.03943178057670593,
-0.9834716320037842,
0.07453911751508713,
0.07157586514949799,
0.22633835673332214,
-0.02422124333679676,
-0.3795545697212219,
0.9178815484046936,
-0.1237446591258049,
-0.3030858039855957,
0.41538533568382263,
0.7432364225387573,
0.4244230091571808,
0.029641442000865936,
0.5338612198829651,
0.4134161174297333,
0.9728689789772034,
-0.24672572314739227,
1.0368317365646362,
-0.0818052813410759,
0.2065223902463913,
1.153929352760315,
-0.3331010341644287,
0.779329240322113,
0.5517231225967407,
-0.1517373025417328,
0.3514143228530884,
0.7532517313957214,
0.16228030622005463,
0.3809197247028351,
0.10875631123781204,
-0.2718031108379364,
-0.3051479458808899,
-0.08000455051660538,
0.09469228237867355,
0.2522771954536438,
0.35398492217063904,
-0.1130339652299881,
-0.13491874933242798,
0.21049052476882935,
0.06402694433927536,
0.5076479315757751,
-0.2718220055103302,
0.9574393630027771,
-0.27106037735939026,
-0.8623183369636536,
0.7071160078048706,
-0.014279074966907501,
0.8423020243644714,
-0.5151633620262146,
-0.1617988795042038,
-0.291831374168396,
0.18299877643585205,
-0.1287233978509903,
-0.5455471873283386,
0.11913038045167923,
-0.27993252873420715,
-0.2659938931465149,
-0.128303661942482,
0.7571688294410706,
-0.5925430059432983,
-0.02016463503241539,
-0.16229669749736786,
0.10884744673967361,
-0.1679466813802719,
0.10758642852306366,
-0.43063655495643616,
0.31735336780548096,
-0.06340782344341278,
-0.18863441050052643,
0.5131744146347046,
0.17376220226287842,
0.0021527616772800684,
0.7238448858261108,
0.5042881965637207,
0.03583062067627907,
0.22356660664081573,
-0.23418177664279938,
0.8343724012374878,
-0.15906403958797455,
-0.35194575786590576,
-0.9819220900535583,
0.3869790732860565,
0.09287630021572113,
-0.3269210457801819,
0.9498036503791809,
0.29359617829322815,
0.8624192476272583,
-0.06088031455874443,
0.589247465133667,
0.3362921178340912,
0.6101720929145813,
-0.6377851963043213,
0.23530299961566925,
-0.17895059287548065,
0.6431437730789185,
-0.2312001734972,
-0.7770741581916809,
-0.5859752893447876,
0.47381800413131714,
-0.2768862247467041,
0.08020339161157608,
0.22707262635231018,
0.6612414717674255,
0.09949822723865509,
-0.36540526151657104,
0.5429706573486328,
0.3155987560749054,
0.42976096272468567,
0.30432364344596863,
0.7684155702590942,
-0.19143037497997284,
0.2915187180042267,
-0.1835135519504547,
-0.24315769970417023,
-0.2096206098794937,
-0.7910850644111633,
-0.7792918682098389,
-0.6274005174636841,
-0.4584701955318451,
-0.5310568809509277,
0.17396940290927887,
1.001193642616272,
0.6138051748275757,
-0.9579673409461975,
-0.08282329142093658,
-0.26760417222976685,
0.3339012563228607,
-0.1976076066493988,
-0.23636122047901154,
0.2551577687263489,
-0.8996794819831848,
-0.8238559365272522,
0.4338991045951843,
0.2541359066963196,
0.18143999576568604,
-0.22585374116897583,
-0.16542740166187286,
-0.19556280970573425,
0.0019412161782383919,
0.36095601320266724,
0.604748010635376,
-0.7978919744491577,
-0.21193265914916992,
0.18173353374004364,
-0.04110211879014969,
0.21074511110782623,
0.7211020588874817,
-0.9208201766014099,
0.37795162200927734,
0.573684811592102,
0.9899389147758484,
-0.05841626226902008,
0.3388662338256836,
0.5972089767456055,
-1.1206475496292114,
-0.049540404230356216,
0.3612588047981262,
0.5229945182800293,
0.5153759121894836,
-0.5704076886177063,
-0.06020558997988701,
0.14129512012004852,
-0.7452147006988525,
-0.9162452816963196,
0.3538842499256134,
-0.9153585433959961,
-0.1226041242480278,
1.251619577407837,
-0.3531939685344696,
-0.13683706521987915,
-0.36694565415382385,
-0.3100983202457428,
0.1440436840057373,
-0.5274548530578613,
0.7103224992752075,
0.5512793064117432,
-0.3710574805736542,
-0.2561195194721222,
-0.00723664928227663,
0.6833336353302002,
0.6683698892593384,
-0.5213238000869751,
0.18179170787334442,
0.6067306995391846,
0.4541514813899994,
0.09929131716489792,
0.4534502327442169,
-0.006863855756819248,
0.31609681248664856,
-0.48071199655532837,
-0.2521570324897766,
-0.22948546707630157,
-0.5687904953956604,
-0.8056141138076782,
0.4121762216091156,
0.4886743426322937,
-0.10758491605520248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00808v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00808v1
|
IPED: An Implicit Perspective for Relational Triple Extraction based on Diffusion Model
| 2024-02-24T14:18:11 | 2024-02-24T14:18:11 |
Jianli Zhao, Changhao Xu, Bin Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Relational triple extraction is a fundamental task in the field of
information extraction, and a promising framework based on table filling has
recently gained attention as a potential baseline for entity relation
extraction. However, inherent shortcomings such as redundant information and
incomplete triple recognition remain problematic. To address these challenges,
we propose an Implicit Perspective for relational triple Extraction based on
Diffusion model (IPED), an innovative approach for extracting relational
triples. Our classifier-free solution adopts an implicit strategy using block
coverage to complete the tables, avoiding the limitations of explicit tagging
methods. Additionally, we introduce a generative model structure, the
block-denoising diffusion model, to collaborate with our implicit perspective
and effectively circumvent redundant information disruptions. Experimental
results on two popular datasets demonstrate that IPED achieves state-of-the-art
performance while gaining superior inference speed and low computational
complexity. To support future research, we have made our source code publicly
available online.
|
[
-0.39649587869644165,
-0.8609848618507385,
0.7653578519821167,
0.5280597805976868,
-0.2114834189414978,
-0.009748621843755245,
0.4898022711277008,
-0.49405762553215027,
-0.10550796985626221,
0.4404015839099884,
-0.18049407005310059,
-0.6250329613685608,
-0.6855144500732422,
-0.06217821314930916,
-0.5190700888633728,
0.9820638298988342,
-0.3493376076221466,
-0.144405797123909,
-0.2917344570159912,
0.05652499198913574,
-0.41804239153862,
0.18847759068012238,
-0.6810051202774048,
-0.2664124667644501,
0.25092047452926636,
0.4356217384338379,
0.21955066919326782,
0.7389387488365173,
0.15414083003997803,
0.13059014081954956,
0.025517186149954796,
0.13451747596263885,
-0.388802170753479,
0.24489045143127441,
0.015830930322408676,
-0.08074761182069778,
-0.7382657527923584,
0.1511557698249817,
0.9194889664649963,
0.858600378036499,
-0.24426548182964325,
0.06069768965244293,
0.04533733054995537,
0.920322597026825,
-0.7553637027740479,
0.6015574336051941,
-0.6694750785827637,
0.236472025513649,
-0.1489812135696411,
0.18385367095470428,
-0.26142197847366333,
-0.5473150610923767,
0.2501971423625946,
-0.6963571906089783,
0.2004028856754303,
0.026189137250185013,
0.6440812349319458,
0.004796895664185286,
-0.5309374928474426,
0.16052469611167908,
-1.0162104368209839,
0.11440928280353546,
-0.1300135999917984,
0.1136929839849472,
0.07535530626773834,
0.027351858094334602,
-0.08591350167989731,
-0.6352279782295227,
-0.7459169626235962,
0.009476419538259506,
-0.004912013188004494,
0.032522886991500854,
-0.2906596064567566,
-0.07533800601959229,
0.30895960330963135,
0.38787949085235596,
-0.0975915938615799,
-0.2806769013404846,
-0.2945193946361542,
0.4234267473220825,
0.4830264449119568,
-0.27353155612945557,
0.281421035528183,
-0.022919107228517532,
-0.5477938652038574,
0.3633115589618683,
-0.9228234887123108,
-0.456561803817749,
0.24917462468147278,
0.1109892874956131,
-0.03894335404038429,
0.45814746618270874,
-0.2005855292081833,
0.657390296459198,
0.06674731522798538,
0.08656805008649826,
0.141195148229599,
-0.04637860879302025,
-0.1206362247467041,
-0.0077834660187363625,
0.8382705450057983,
0.2093317061662674,
0.13506358861923218,
-0.2946431040763855,
0.010015133768320084,
-0.40657612681388855,
0.0016384577611461282,
-0.7959832549095154,
-0.34366175532341003,
0.4548306167125702,
-0.22612804174423218,
-0.33037498593330383,
0.24649494886398315,
-1.1797515153884888,
-0.4571945369243622,
0.054785337299108505,
0.24217000603675842,
-0.23608556389808655,
-0.9827328324317932,
-0.11443489044904709,
-0.382987916469574,
-0.09421708434820175,
0.3833952248096466,
-0.7020479440689087,
0.6450677514076233,
0.7303701639175415,
1.2618459463119507,
-0.5898102521896362,
0.045333944261074066,
-0.4194439947605133,
0.9314073920249939,
-0.19400541484355927,
0.742801308631897,
-0.3696478605270386,
-0.5787110924720764,
-0.2193102389574051,
-0.4014562666416168,
0.11585680395364761,
-0.5589374303817749,
-0.003866987070068717,
-0.7437269687652588,
0.05227958783507347,
-0.0068322233855724335,
-0.459119588136673,
-0.2464737445116043,
0.1843033879995346,
-1.2006511688232422,
1.1350364685058594,
0.07775359600782394,
-0.9465475082397461,
0.4737691879272461,
-0.8964810371398926,
-0.26985517144203186,
0.3868931531906128,
-0.18094299733638763,
-0.6526259779930115,
-0.11938808113336563,
0.1703636646270752,
0.4054255187511444,
-0.2525477111339569,
0.47155019640922546,
-0.6177331209182739,
-0.37108275294303894,
-0.21812766790390015,
-0.05483116954565048,
0.7768086194992065,
-0.0937793180346489,
-0.5447869896888733,
-0.10519131273031235,
-0.8440674543380737,
-0.2141799032688141,
0.2297266274690628,
-0.08295098692178726,
-0.4890509843826294,
0.12966138124465942,
-0.3772047162055969,
0.22753791511058807,
-0.22489017248153687,
-0.637654185295105,
0.42406144738197327,
-0.24530304968357086,
0.03499263897538185,
0.6710151433944702,
0.5460061430931091,
0.6214799284934998,
-0.0050743743777275085,
0.3388299345970154,
0.3561306893825531,
-0.06781364977359772,
0.3218265473842621,
-0.6306277513504028,
-0.48763251304626465,
-0.7362908720970154,
0.5307187438011169,
0.5304679274559021,
-0.7026075124740601,
0.057315532118082047,
-0.6086759567260742,
-0.23109492659568787,
-0.2649134695529938,
0.014490345492959023,
0.26405444741249084,
0.6248054504394531,
0.5237258672714233,
0.04529886320233345,
-0.337415486574173,
-0.9032227993011475,
-0.13626277446746826,
-0.11713631451129913,
-0.00178080378100276,
0.3668089210987091,
0.6554398536682129,
-0.056146759539842606,
0.9597036838531494,
-0.7864557504653931,
-0.3616224527359009,
-0.13857579231262207,
0.356152206659317,
0.15204884111881256,
0.7337321043014526,
0.08888085931539536,
-1.0130400657653809,
-0.8154090642929077,
-0.000108842556073796,
-0.8024661540985107,
-0.18348544836044312,
0.20001953840255737,
-0.3376210629940033,
-0.06975707411766052,
0.2996029555797577,
-0.7166196703910828,
0.5712331533432007,
-0.02215738780796528,
0.05635649338364601,
0.186809241771698,
0.1978316754102707,
-0.1952257603406906,
-0.7788769602775574,
0.14810608327388763,
0.07128309458494186,
-0.27365410327911377,
-0.7702155113220215,
0.04775729030370712,
0.2259162813425064,
0.013509034179151058,
-0.38044142723083496,
0.574548602104187,
-0.9297370910644531,
-0.17611198127269745,
-0.06121327355504036,
0.2800139784812927,
0.10620815306901932,
0.32530367374420166,
0.2581407129764557,
0.5343186259269714,
0.4721650779247284,
-0.7026622295379639,
0.22336213290691376,
0.16341513395309448,
-0.0970803052186966,
0.7799798250198364,
-0.5118894577026367,
0.17621149122714996,
-0.35731416940689087,
0.2957037389278412,
-0.7296000719070435,
-0.09636687487363815,
0.756576418876648,
0.072262242436409,
0.6107704043388367,
-0.6455436944961548,
-0.3808786869049072,
-0.27735984325408936,
-0.3413490653038025,
0.46865609288215637,
0.2465187907218933,
-0.6830569505691528,
0.8101106286048889,
0.7065451741218567,
-0.28818145394325256,
-0.7745491862297058,
-0.2501218020915985,
-0.19804543256759644,
-0.2612943649291992,
-0.4290253818035126,
0.8462467193603516,
0.07836772501468658,
-0.4626160264015198,
0.43715700507164,
-0.4821334183216095,
-0.46157535910606384,
0.05291970446705818,
0.44306305050849915,
0.4132780432701111,
0.07956703007221222,
0.0761653259396553,
0.05559847503900528,
-0.0804896354675293,
0.20190325379371643,
-0.4259827733039856,
0.3303702771663666,
-0.1502348631620407,
-0.17171171307563782,
-0.4198753535747528,
0.7424228191375732,
0.2831946611404419,
0.10113506764173508,
0.886333703994751,
0.3950652480125427,
-0.6802083253860474,
-0.12982229888439178,
-0.5693743228912354,
0.3976750373840332,
-0.36116063594818115,
0.12003861367702484,
-0.44084274768829346,
-0.5892648696899414,
0.3241020143032074,
-0.2932220697402954,
-0.15886928141117096,
0.6192001104354858,
-0.08499295264482498,
-0.030739016830921173,
1.1698516607284546,
0.7467219829559326,
0.2967892587184906,
0.26637503504753113,
-0.36628302931785583,
-0.18955089151859283,
-1.0238890647888184,
-0.63113933801651,
-0.3391754925251007,
0.10216429829597473,
-0.30864083766937256,
-0.11597071588039398,
0.5028972625732422,
0.3824523389339447,
-0.1764063537120819,
-0.2830214202404022,
-0.33012765645980835,
0.6406641006469727,
0.5294449925422668,
0.3032371401786804,
0.5998339653015137,
0.09786223620176315,
0.008354508318006992,
0.2667265832424164,
-0.20059910416603088,
-0.18638499081134796,
1.0135589838027954,
0.08317882567644119,
0.3401696979999542,
0.46036282181739807,
0.703329861164093,
0.3045435845851898,
0.6440857648849487,
-0.4515703618526459,
0.4824608862400055,
0.41390302777290344,
-0.6728202700614929,
-0.14220017194747925,
-0.6731516718864441,
-0.6887689828872681,
0.5532616376876831,
-0.21165409684181213,
-0.7053279280662537,
0.34968915581703186,
0.0767667144536972,
-0.12911511957645416,
0.4666827917098999,
-0.6283860802650452,
0.6714416146278381,
0.2669036388397217,
-0.9199023842811584,
0.055643919855356216,
-0.4910736083984375,
0.9147941470146179,
-0.31946316361427307,
0.13442368805408478,
-0.35126927495002747,
-0.21674056351184845,
0.5566009879112244,
-0.557812511920929,
0.3849341869354248,
-0.6465752124786377,
0.061550721526145935,
-0.03118434175848961,
0.19558322429656982,
0.5146282911300659,
0.5572242736816406,
0.06365776807069778,
0.24739331007003784,
-0.13927212357521057,
-0.43699145317077637,
-0.5603070855140686,
0.7854640483856201,
-0.48462730646133423,
-0.8256432414054871,
-0.7426700592041016,
-0.3854581117630005,
-0.1776004433631897,
0.5617020130157471,
-0.24538102746009827,
-0.08376435190439224,
-0.2884353995323181,
-0.15055187046527863,
0.7754207849502563,
0.14170947670936584,
0.6736556887626648,
0.637724757194519,
-0.3697691857814789,
-0.32929617166519165,
0.6375532746315002,
-0.04486759006977081,
0.10371154546737671,
0.2961478531360626,
-0.03564373403787613,
-0.23722395300865173,
-0.759231686592102,
-0.4709400534629822,
0.38838404417037964,
-0.4656808078289032,
-0.22919918596744537,
-1.1165534257888794,
-0.09210299700498581,
-0.15211021900177002,
0.267841100692749,
-0.32369527220726013,
-0.36412861943244934,
-0.40235087275505066,
-0.2127147912979126,
0.12392603605985641,
1.0853805541992188,
-0.2632506191730499,
0.27296242117881775,
-0.5946232080459595,
0.6220018267631531,
0.5613422989845276,
0.558234691619873,
-0.02989330142736435,
0.3936455547809601,
0.12248366326093674,
-0.1305924504995346,
-0.15240974724292755,
-1.2851548194885254,
0.3651043772697449,
0.08847826719284058,
0.5335633158683777,
0.10716874152421951,
-0.08256647735834122,
0.7482657432556152,
-0.5151479840278625,
0.4839388430118561,
0.016763735562562943,
-1.1203590631484985,
0.5277711749076843,
-0.2030005007982254,
-0.15929146111011505,
0.5296922922134399,
0.7734675407409668,
-0.09400975704193115,
0.0439419262111187,
-0.7433570027351379,
-1.0747588872909546,
0.8689401745796204,
0.2882712781429291,
-0.34107547998428345,
-0.027671588584780693,
0.454237163066864,
0.14275136590003967,
0.5154378414154053,
-1.1543370485305786,
-0.41634735465049744,
-0.03036290965974331,
0.0783124640583992,
0.710200846195221,
-0.48202767968177795,
-0.21981610357761383,
-0.22081153094768524,
0.8762561678886414,
0.2969532907009125,
0.40929916501045227,
0.17723122239112854,
-0.2807014584541321,
-0.032138850539922714,
-0.02374272793531418,
0.10066873580217361,
0.5851448178291321,
-0.547805905342102,
0.16643433272838593,
-0.1224505677819252,
-0.5891523957252502,
0.25145983695983887,
0.5637074708938599,
-0.4924701452255249,
-0.09666115790605545,
-0.02733124978840351,
0.516313910484314,
-0.2615051865577698,
-0.004977943375706673,
1.0129051208496094,
-0.2655658721923828,
-0.09652039408683777,
-0.5024499893188477,
-0.08740275353193283,
-0.0687331035733223,
0.10439077764749527,
0.3859425187110901,
0.12164584547281265,
0.4558836817741394,
-0.09748388081789017,
0.13165771961212158,
0.49897363781929016,
-0.5019576549530029,
-0.10996986925601959,
0.7640807628631592,
0.17561395466327667,
0.05073431879281998,
0.8296533823013306,
-0.3741907775402069,
-0.10199455171823502,
0.4187476336956024,
0.5768948793411255,
0.8433560132980347,
-0.14438556134700775,
0.3209035396575928,
0.2974849045276642,
0.013432852923870087,
-0.31748446822166443,
0.25826495885849,
-0.32663553953170776,
-0.7072662115097046,
-0.3246936798095703,
-0.314860075712204,
-0.17657409608364105,
0.19749656319618225,
-0.7587485313415527,
0.2050226926803589,
-0.48627346754074097,
0.1953037530183792,
-0.04798579216003418,
-0.06353563070297241,
-0.42648932337760925,
-0.2216407209634781,
-0.03645149990916252,
0.666944682598114,
-0.7409372925758362,
0.8468215465545654,
0.07180125266313553,
-0.5486696362495422,
-0.4291972219944,
0.15386557579040527,
-0.11275193095207214,
-0.5560815930366516,
0.8919894099235535,
0.32913267612457275,
-0.2516506612300873,
0.37083449959754944,
-0.46368762850761414,
-0.8438725471496582,
1.0546952486038208,
0.13297252357006073,
-0.10551238059997559,
-0.07580707967281342,
-0.17164842784404755,
0.018830645829439163,
-0.49018964171409607,
0.39389485120773315,
0.6470544934272766,
0.4954858124256134,
0.3176846504211426,
-0.21765799820423126,
0.21434907615184784,
-0.5520027279853821,
0.19277939200401306,
0.32820677757263184,
-0.15818487107753754,
0.8290674686431885,
-0.11214513331651688,
-0.5943449139595032,
-0.27544543147087097,
0.668815553188324,
0.31697186827659607,
0.16314272582530975,
0.7249248027801514,
0.4579709768295288,
0.831015944480896,
-0.14450868964195251,
0.9662543535232544,
0.038239751011133194,
0.07540751993656158,
1.2021058797836304,
-0.6783835291862488,
0.6769869327545166,
0.2715291976928711,
-0.24711990356445312,
0.8720788955688477,
0.27444255352020264,
0.16056646406650543,
0.6550058722496033,
0.05134657025337219,
-0.7502396106719971,
0.23663996160030365,
-0.01603258028626442,
-0.5002912282943726,
0.08945516496896744,
0.6109213829040527,
-0.1519010066986084,
0.01846195198595524,
-0.39607927203178406,
0.270017147064209,
-0.3571723699569702,
-0.25092703104019165,
0.9622499942779541,
-0.2586374282836914,
-0.5205088257789612,
0.3088127076625824,
-0.23644468188285828,
0.260020911693573,
-0.17757940292358398,
-0.6608951091766357,
-0.27942225337028503,
-0.3381285071372986,
-0.2181684523820877,
-0.6219951510429382,
0.2030780166387558,
-0.19892814755439758,
-0.37986671924591064,
-0.3875136971473694,
0.6358613967895508,
-0.5534906983375549,
-0.20212924480438232,
0.20616444945335388,
0.631178081035614,
-0.024339353665709496,
-0.35851699113845825,
-0.5064727067947388,
-0.17825615406036377,
-0.02175896428525448,
-0.14690367877483368,
0.04801391065120697,
0.43875572085380554,
0.04102368280291557,
0.4456135928630829,
0.5315809845924377,
0.3768661320209503,
-0.16869033873081207,
-0.17581693828105927,
0.869485080242157,
-0.6721857786178589,
-0.3609877824783325,
-1.0733200311660767,
0.608812689781189,
-0.7958762049674988,
0.17293035984039307,
0.5100973844528198,
0.6407119631767273,
0.5201468467712402,
0.00416340958327055,
0.7747393250465393,
-0.044530488550662994,
0.7077153921127319,
-0.49153947830200195,
0.4161875247955322,
-0.2983303964138031,
0.6930443644523621,
-0.5243355631828308,
-1.1264479160308838,
-0.6179754137992859,
0.33348631858825684,
-0.1864578127861023,
0.07291825860738754,
0.8092899918556213,
0.49587056040763855,
-0.12535865604877472,
0.13279493153095245,
-0.2369331270456314,
0.30250483751296997,
0.382463663816452,
0.28991013765335083,
0.9245051741600037,
-0.3129386007785797,
0.58783358335495,
-0.3553609251976013,
-0.42694780230522156,
0.05930504947900772,
-1.2683687210083008,
-0.5295599102973938,
-0.5473241806030273,
-0.4756966829299927,
-0.399936705827713,
0.015769552439451218,
0.48886337876319885,
0.6743667125701904,
-0.38500529527664185,
0.12136329710483551,
-0.6216650605201721,
0.5865289568901062,
-0.06952047348022461,
-0.30543434619903564,
0.4228241741657257,
0.296747624874115,
-0.7621991634368896,
0.3005591332912445,
0.3918900787830353,
0.36242246627807617,
-0.04398161172866821,
0.47186192870140076,
-0.4912196099758148,
-0.41681718826293945,
0.3841649889945984,
0.33285340666770935,
-0.3965115547180176,
-0.15386828780174255,
-0.5934448838233948,
0.10545294731855392,
0.276484876871109,
0.4100617468357086,
-0.87375807762146,
0.3361840844154358,
0.29953381419181824,
0.2716830372810364,
1.1905816793441772,
0.17909333109855652,
0.8563969135284424,
-0.9283178448677063,
0.07252949476242065,
0.12173333019018173,
0.19180215895175934,
0.34984108805656433,
-0.48020511865615845,
0.8504887819290161,
0.5451816916465759,
-0.2622813582420349,
-0.8952668905258179,
0.27027568221092224,
-0.8373692631721497,
-0.3173489570617676,
1.129610538482666,
-0.1073639765381813,
-0.20232760906219482,
-0.5124667882919312,
0.06277348101139069,
0.37711629271507263,
-0.4366658926010132,
0.6261314153671265,
0.4387212097644806,
-0.2758237421512604,
-0.18072687089443207,
-0.5394167304039001,
0.6524963974952698,
-0.10812442749738693,
-0.8624731302261353,
0.005285992287099361,
0.7251933813095093,
0.40138107538223267,
0.005282227415591478,
1.0321382284164429,
-0.2797018885612488,
0.004148910287767649,
-0.019063347950577736,
0.2881671190261841,
-0.13808709383010864,
-0.5206484198570251,
-0.31826385855674744,
0.6299540400505066,
-0.14470191299915314,
-0.041572634130716324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15818v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15818v1
|
Linguistic Intelligence in Large Language Models for Telecommunications
| 2024-02-24T14:01:07 | 2024-02-24T14:01:07 |
Tasnim Ahmed, Nicola Piovesan, Antonio De Domenico, Salimur Choudhury
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as a significant advancement in the
field of Natural Language Processing (NLP), demonstrating remarkable
capabilities in language generation and other language-centric tasks. Despite
their evaluation across a multitude of analytical and reasoning tasks in
various scientific domains, a comprehensive exploration of their knowledge and
understanding within the realm of natural language tasks in the
telecommunications domain is still needed. This study, therefore, seeks to
evaluate the knowledge and understanding capabilities of LLMs within this
domain. To achieve this, we conduct an exhaustive zero-shot evaluation of four
prominent LLMs-Llama-2, Falcon, Mistral, and Zephyr. These models require fewer
resources than ChatGPT, making them suitable for resource-constrained
environments. Their performance is compared with state-of-the-art, fine-tuned
models. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work to extensively
evaluate and compare the understanding of LLMs across multiple language-centric
tasks in this domain. Our evaluation reveals that zero-shot LLMs can achieve
performance levels comparable to the current state-of-the-art fine-tuned
models. This indicates that pretraining on extensive text corpora equips LLMs
with a degree of specialization, even within the telecommunications domain. We
also observe that no single LLM consistently outperforms others, and the
performance of different LLMs can fluctuate. Although their performance lags
behind fine-tuned models, our findings underscore the potential of LLMs as a
valuable resource for understanding various aspects of this field that lack
large annotated data.
|
[
-0.32842496037483215,
-0.9023444652557373,
0.6862119436264038,
0.07417543232440948,
-0.27188506722450256,
0.17049646377563477,
-0.47434762120246887,
-0.7075703144073486,
0.1298653483390808,
0.6940972208976746,
-0.5102789998054504,
-0.5710967779159546,
-0.6325675249099731,
0.41896405816078186,
-0.3789847493171692,
0.7058156132698059,
0.28045326471328735,
-0.09518156945705414,
0.09236123412847519,
-0.12506026029586792,
-0.4793725609779358,
-0.6434270143508911,
-0.4565560519695282,
-0.6254780888557434,
0.35184234380722046,
0.4420545697212219,
0.6377034783363342,
0.4065283238887787,
0.5021369457244873,
0.2872610092163086,
-0.3262791037559509,
0.06971549242734909,
-0.5449395179748535,
0.01551439892500639,
-0.07523240149021149,
-0.5466758012771606,
-0.480299174785614,
-0.14526034891605377,
0.7581701278686523,
0.8384442329406738,
-0.08712323755025864,
0.34777751564979553,
-0.1488001048564911,
0.6540513634681702,
-0.394724041223526,
0.19356033205986023,
-1.1364784240722656,
0.13916179537773132,
-0.20569540560245514,
-0.38469797372817993,
-0.4944347143173218,
-0.07351771742105484,
0.22518092393875122,
-0.5895602107048035,
-0.033204060047864914,
0.1138884648680687,
0.7135719656944275,
0.42566385865211487,
-0.5196340084075928,
-0.3684806227684021,
-0.8266335725784302,
0.8901561498641968,
-0.8091212511062622,
0.4487239718437195,
0.09685977548360825,
0.23922216892242432,
-0.03894927352666855,
-0.48741835355758667,
-0.5450065732002258,
-0.28812041878700256,
0.30607062578201294,
0.16514135897159576,
-0.21978573501110077,
0.06469447165727615,
0.29998379945755005,
0.22080321609973907,
-0.40284979343414307,
0.7297835946083069,
-0.36269307136535645,
0.020741377025842667,
0.5369366407394409,
0.27880769968032837,
0.047471024096012115,
-0.0935593843460083,
-0.17717501521110535,
0.45937487483024597,
-0.7514511346817017,
-0.05219388008117676,
0.2421891987323761,
0.3071100115776062,
-0.1493331491947174,
0.7584845423698425,
-0.3799884021282196,
0.6831491589546204,
-0.14433762431144714,
-0.11117049306631088,
0.13333696126937866,
-0.25977444648742676,
-0.5906586647033691,
0.1286112368106842,
0.9210766553878784,
-0.039142075926065445,
0.5927042365074158,
-0.31855252385139465,
-0.19399937987327576,
-0.13357427716255188,
0.2881242036819458,
-0.8102748394012451,
0.13617852330207825,
0.24178647994995117,
-0.3892245590686798,
-0.15466125309467316,
-0.2902989983558655,
-0.3557034730911255,
-0.2398225963115692,
-0.4610182046890259,
0.18076571822166443,
-0.3847868740558624,
-0.5044187903404236,
0.5358070731163025,
0.1976376324892044,
0.31504350900650024,
0.2897511124610901,
-0.9513875246047974,
0.14680097997188568,
0.8505535125732422,
0.8944026231765747,
-0.00678274454548955,
-0.2232164889574051,
-0.41796213388442993,
-0.05751260742545128,
-0.4078429043292999,
0.7269103527069092,
-0.5583441257476807,
-0.25943246483802795,
0.09936577826738358,
-0.2576572895050049,
-0.15754632651805878,
-0.6143357157707214,
0.6873534321784973,
-0.9444738030433655,
-0.24601705372333527,
-0.09669087827205658,
-0.5862401723861694,
-0.36920875310897827,
0.20998568832874298,
-0.5754092335700989,
0.7672944068908691,
0.07144484668970108,
-0.5733708739280701,
0.1930534690618515,
-0.7166014909744263,
-0.3207159638404846,
0.3785749077796936,
-0.08799656480550766,
-0.22286151349544525,
0.27398067712783813,
-0.12522025406360626,
0.6494368314743042,
-0.6077855229377747,
0.29709139466285706,
-0.4350703954696655,
-0.45098233222961426,
0.3757167458534241,
-0.3577297627925873,
0.7291054725646973,
0.25278404355049133,
-0.32643944025039673,
0.017942264676094055,
-0.6376309394836426,
0.10388413071632385,
0.12366129457950592,
-0.2293541133403778,
-0.06748058646917343,
-0.03783012926578522,
-0.06347188353538513,
0.2494480311870575,
0.16938073933124542,
-0.5935012102127075,
0.05294264480471611,
-0.4803825914859772,
0.6429043412208557,
0.4564012885093689,
-0.17427533864974976,
0.4497792720794678,
-0.09295926243066788,
0.44193407893180847,
-0.03881527855992317,
0.06007777899503708,
-0.23571045696735382,
-0.33666616678237915,
-0.9821985960006714,
-0.0874125137925148,
0.12188304960727692,
0.5352104902267456,
-0.6897910833358765,
0.23199494183063507,
-0.5985152125358582,
-0.5739180445671082,
-0.35461896657943726,
0.4406071603298187,
0.1802455633878708,
0.3119308054447174,
0.3212825059890747,
-0.06454350054264069,
-0.20110170543193817,
-0.9498490691184998,
-0.16289207339286804,
0.02138420380651951,
0.0582553893327713,
0.4007669985294342,
0.4021492898464203,
-0.25238558650016785,
0.7948142290115356,
-0.2794854938983917,
-0.2681926488876343,
-0.47635677456855774,
-0.028009099885821342,
0.5257852673530579,
-0.07159525901079178,
0.5228482484817505,
-0.5257624387741089,
-0.3017411530017853,
0.26557332277297974,
-0.9434313178062439,
-0.17202536761760712,
-0.15440157055854797,
0.2287777066230774,
0.2686484456062317,
0.40625399351119995,
-0.8122597932815552,
0.0975678563117981,
0.49729999899864197,
-0.10379531234502792,
0.6999194025993347,
-0.11189783364534378,
-0.11371148377656937,
-0.7628505229949951,
0.08225645124912262,
0.27410608530044556,
-0.0773635059595108,
-0.9749776124954224,
-0.09715498238801956,
-0.0590968132019043,
-0.06634963303804398,
-0.5095314979553223,
0.4240870773792267,
-0.6590189337730408,
-0.3614148199558258,
-0.34643036127090454,
0.25243934988975525,
-0.24811995029449463,
0.3781457543373108,
0.23435969650745392,
0.8001890778541565,
0.5735470652580261,
-0.6320732831954956,
0.3081856369972229,
0.13778796792030334,
-0.6579248309135437,
0.20665252208709717,
-0.8780872821807861,
0.11956126242876053,
-0.0383983850479126,
0.052235569804906845,
-0.6719792485237122,
-0.08505428582429886,
-0.06168987229466438,
-0.2372494488954544,
0.058295838534832,
-0.08798916637897491,
-0.6538630723953247,
-0.11591828614473343,
0.03701693192124367,
0.35039907693862915,
0.34239545464515686,
-0.2851870656013489,
0.4295828640460968,
0.3721103072166443,
-0.38836342096328735,
-0.6159444451332092,
-0.6499348282814026,
0.4536867141723633,
-0.28278201818466187,
-0.5750449895858765,
0.24081993103027344,
0.12166085839271545,
-0.3016009032726288,
-0.26476573944091797,
0.028266731649637222,
-0.12261535972356796,
0.2703222334384918,
0.28308361768722534,
0.25346389412879944,
-0.5188500881195068,
0.13632933795452118,
-0.19152863323688507,
-0.1410924792289734,
0.2404325157403946,
-0.37975919246673584,
0.6038764119148254,
-0.26349765062332153,
-0.49441829323768616,
-0.6123975515365601,
0.15159890055656433,
0.6777133941650391,
-0.33619824051856995,
0.7285395860671997,
0.516603410243988,
-0.1302390992641449,
-0.35582324862480164,
-0.8193110227584839,
0.09823397547006607,
-0.4605298340320587,
0.42781534790992737,
-0.40437933802604675,
-1.26724374294281,
0.5011220574378967,
-0.18039396405220032,
0.2005171775817871,
0.5094379186630249,
0.6072413325309753,
0.22910283505916595,
0.6179102063179016,
0.869435727596283,
-0.14919807016849518,
0.3559623658657074,
-0.32954147458076477,
0.39621949195861816,
-0.7981988787651062,
-0.3558208644390106,
-0.5637322664260864,
-0.01848646253347397,
-0.4497401714324951,
-0.29283949732780457,
0.36771655082702637,
0.009340805932879448,
-0.36403295397758484,
0.2631731629371643,
-0.2532186806201935,
0.49737438559532166,
0.2282504290342331,
-0.20346589386463165,
0.5025072693824768,
0.1471002846956253,
-0.006057830061763525,
0.2967672646045685,
-0.8240464329719543,
-0.8785073161125183,
1.1326414346694946,
0.5469879508018494,
0.6640016436576843,
0.2663882076740265,
0.2929942309856415,
0.04375988245010376,
0.27505022287368774,
-1.0282013416290283,
0.5443564653396606,
-0.2528184652328491,
-0.36314770579338074,
-0.3063996136188507,
-0.5875190496444702,
-0.7243214845657349,
0.11394234746694565,
-0.23121707141399384,
-0.8037227392196655,
-0.18616436421871185,
-0.28227925300598145,
-0.5050305724143982,
0.36642926931381226,
-0.6405064463615417,
0.5368664264678955,
-0.4281860589981079,
-0.2940386235713959,
-0.4123598635196686,
-0.437744677066803,
0.5531594157218933,
-0.5062716603279114,
0.11666018515825272,
-0.3785300552845001,
-0.21469852328300476,
0.5171371698379517,
-0.06554973125457764,
0.8166587352752686,
0.16462360322475433,
-0.31371134519577026,
0.2340666502714157,
0.12146294862031937,
0.07151977717876434,
0.025939349085092545,
-0.7155036926269531,
0.6808875203132629,
0.005329917650669813,
-0.16210012137889862,
-0.3333669602870941,
0.729945957660675,
-0.8538700938224792,
-0.6070351600646973,
-0.22631102800369263,
-0.6056998372077942,
-0.23546120524406433,
0.34169596433639526,
0.12031874060630798,
0.5581430792808533,
-0.012062055990099907,
0.39002469182014465,
0.6328394412994385,
-0.36413997411727905,
0.6651831865310669,
0.6574550271034241,
-0.09060503542423248,
-0.07810799777507782,
0.6287962794303894,
0.23413467407226562,
0.4482966959476471,
0.4117046892642975,
-0.1916143298149109,
-0.5971347689628601,
-0.9534046649932861,
-0.4658518433570862,
0.3719150424003601,
-0.6292567849159241,
-0.22107192873954773,
-0.7653006315231323,
-0.5536980628967285,
-0.10570814460515976,
0.03499280661344528,
-0.24668259918689728,
-0.29487714171409607,
-0.4645503759384155,
0.18031148612499237,
0.17040173709392548,
0.9253857731819153,
0.45215103030204773,
0.5623207092285156,
-0.8553354144096375,
0.23243486881256104,
0.007799411658197641,
0.5277494192123413,
0.1102861538529396,
-0.6920667290687561,
-0.34385809302330017,
0.09772977232933044,
-0.334532231092453,
-0.5909385681152344,
0.34388816356658936,
0.3018139898777008,
0.6746857762336731,
0.3274010717868805,
-0.001831921748816967,
0.45014795660972595,
-0.5295859575271606,
0.8179494738578796,
0.22273744642734528,
-0.9754596948623657,
0.20151905715465546,
-0.4378834664821625,
0.3183497190475464,
0.3027658462524414,
0.3485022485256195,
-0.3977528214454651,
-0.19908198714256287,
-0.5395447611808777,
-0.4853154122829437,
0.6446238160133362,
0.19580039381980896,
0.3660401403903961,
0.08764828741550446,
0.49282872676849365,
-0.06249001994729042,
0.15612944960594177,
-0.6555342674255371,
-0.045820217579603195,
0.02549963817000389,
0.026542529463768005,
-0.13023079931735992,
-0.32208991050720215,
0.13628588616847992,
0.027557019144296646,
0.4966931939125061,
-0.1920572966337204,
0.12485665082931519,
0.05088958144187927,
-0.16515381634235382,
-0.017507806420326233,
0.5390976071357727,
0.7045937776565552,
0.9216733574867249,
-0.12319328635931015,
0.10023661702871323,
0.5107499361038208,
-0.3600042462348938,
0.04089508578181267,
-0.17820540070533752,
0.07070201635360718,
0.07983331382274628,
0.4196297824382782,
0.7454693913459778,
0.21240302920341492,
-0.7341086268424988,
0.45138314366340637,
-0.024275433272123337,
-0.2957245409488678,
-0.4718329906463623,
0.18805156648159027,
0.18122002482414246,
0.3189486861228943,
0.43738943338394165,
-0.03661652281880379,
-0.07952368259429932,
-0.41608738899230957,
-0.10756491124629974,
0.7376759052276611,
-0.24411042034626007,
-0.32310375571250916,
0.5911121964454651,
0.2516186833381653,
-0.3443338871002197,
0.5263592600822449,
-0.16176097095012665,
-0.5027304887771606,
0.7075796723365784,
0.6402220726013184,
0.7498259544372559,
0.08765463531017303,
0.07818325608968735,
0.14008429646492004,
0.4915371835231781,
-0.07207906991243362,
-0.08810266107320786,
-0.0189480260014534,
-0.9099143743515015,
-0.8474770784378052,
-0.854098916053772,
-0.4475271999835968,
0.3896844983100891,
-0.330639511346817,
0.38475653529167175,
-0.6060615181922913,
-0.2950356900691986,
0.2398618906736374,
0.21757742762565613,
-0.740371823310852,
0.05619674175977707,
0.29693102836608887,
1.1969038248062134,
-0.5495192408561707,
0.9534292817115784,
0.5888710021972656,
-0.08339471369981766,
-0.846177875995636,
-0.13108894228935242,
-0.0428243987262249,
-0.8957497477531433,
1.0398691892623901,
0.2978303134441376,
-0.4376758337020874,
0.2226647436618805,
-0.17230704426765442,
-0.6476867198944092,
1.1561529636383057,
0.519053041934967,
-0.6928227543830872,
0.17704851925373077,
0.5448455810546875,
0.5221827030181885,
-0.4035710394382477,
0.7703420519828796,
0.5911280512809753,
0.16504386067390442,
0.10944835096597672,
-1.2393128871917725,
-0.1597837209701538,
-0.15123507380485535,
0.018909811973571777,
0.18684177100658417,
-0.8135518431663513,
0.6858662366867065,
-0.23908433318138123,
-0.3216727077960968,
0.0014972970820963383,
0.5233197212219238,
0.09221404790878296,
0.21350084245204926,
0.4952341616153717,
0.3747565746307373,
0.5328462719917297,
0.06904071569442749,
0.778228759765625,
-0.5346560478210449,
0.24876558780670166,
0.8053925037384033,
-0.621445894241333,
0.996002197265625,
0.23528535664081573,
0.021966204047203064,
0.26198074221611023,
0.4944112002849579,
0.16655996441841125,
0.04683614894747734,
0.16125765442848206,
-0.3802611827850342,
-0.4570702910423279,
-0.36424535512924194,
-0.18672358989715576,
0.7722390294075012,
0.4307634234428406,
-0.09604649245738983,
-0.28669071197509766,
-0.31878313422203064,
-0.03611816465854645,
-0.07261975109577179,
-0.37615811824798584,
0.8067334294319153,
0.3357688784599304,
-0.5027667284011841,
0.8646474480628967,
0.17228329181671143,
0.8538726568222046,
-0.6574278473854065,
0.21800477802753448,
-0.06128832697868347,
0.010587258264422417,
-0.3190777897834778,
-0.9115035533905029,
0.4124320447444916,
0.415084570646286,
0.041432935744524,
-0.18754778802394867,
0.6378375291824341,
-0.09860697388648987,
-0.32080671191215515,
0.3887084722518921,
0.5375142693519592,
0.305074006319046,
-0.1338738203048706,
-0.5514869689941406,
0.2788441479206085,
-0.09291280806064606,
-0.1136774867773056,
0.2697945535182953,
0.5613594055175781,
0.1949274241924286,
0.9817115068435669,
0.7645712494850159,
0.2921944260597229,
-0.032701704651117325,
0.21926343441009521,
0.7110058665275574,
-0.6002473831176758,
-0.12858885526657104,
-1.0207910537719727,
0.198677197098732,
-0.04044877737760544,
-0.37438637018203735,
0.6681980490684509,
0.5250064134597778,
0.6428913474082947,
-0.013713501393795013,
0.7806569337844849,
0.3443513810634613,
0.17263734340667725,
-0.6597998142242432,
0.6863883137702942,
-0.40846067667007446,
0.6131922602653503,
-0.019907614216208458,
-1.0452277660369873,
-0.26484283804893494,
0.3372781574726105,
-0.6340146660804749,
-0.11919617652893066,
0.4549046456813812,
0.7992506623268127,
-0.21159401535987854,
0.3187188506126404,
0.49580392241477966,
0.198878675699234,
0.3694393038749695,
0.6890254616737366,
0.9849323034286499,
-0.21569277346134186,
0.5931267738342285,
-0.018110862001776695,
-0.10934751480817795,
-0.2783754765987396,
-1.0564193725585938,
-1.0120337009429932,
-0.27677589654922485,
-0.08903976529836655,
0.17234347760677338,
-0.17758555710315704,
0.8647413849830627,
0.7772596478462219,
-0.49354833364486694,
-0.4729355275630951,
-0.025244278833270073,
0.036991432309150696,
0.19115665555000305,
-0.15458804368972778,
0.0464584082365036,
-0.5606257319450378,
-0.5270736813545227,
0.42007747292518616,
0.653805136680603,
-0.14563515782356262,
-0.2927761971950531,
0.023833665996789932,
0.0050091855227947235,
0.11533253639936447,
0.9294301867485046,
0.10901101678609848,
-0.8898106813430786,
-0.25481724739074707,
0.2894938290119171,
-0.1138017550110817,
-0.08288198709487915,
0.6153872013092041,
-0.7552704811096191,
0.06016983836889267,
0.2692711651325226,
0.878167450428009,
0.27693918347358704,
-0.09269102662801743,
0.2774661183357239,
-0.41115182638168335,
0.14440450072288513,
0.25212350487709045,
0.3232797086238861,
0.30214160680770874,
-0.34452584385871887,
0.46098047494888306,
-0.017080724239349365,
-0.832542896270752,
-0.6851315498352051,
0.2840801775455475,
-1.161097526550293,
-0.13658960163593292,
1.4339590072631836,
0.04184573143720627,
0.03030771017074585,
-0.25153401494026184,
0.024402912706136703,
0.2020864188671112,
-0.2083309292793274,
0.6175490617752075,
0.5632808804512024,
-0.08927573263645172,
-0.30394113063812256,
-1.1355079412460327,
0.13000409305095673,
0.5871159434318542,
-0.9490389823913574,
0.0772295668721199,
0.33642464876174927,
0.46747907996177673,
0.020525893196463585,
0.6839598417282104,
0.15645356476306915,
-0.1241331547498703,
-0.2992747724056244,
-0.2371424287557602,
-0.2796657681465149,
-0.25507649779319763,
-0.3115362524986267,
0.181280717253685,
0.25415995717048645,
0.11548315733671188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15814v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15814v2
|
On Efficiently Representing Regular Languages as RNNs
| 2024-02-24T13:42:06 | 2024-06-18T15:14:18 |
Anej Svete, Robin Shing Moon Chan, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CC, cs.LG
|
Recent work by Hewitt et al. (2020) provides an interpretation of the
empirical success of recurrent neural networks (RNNs) as language models (LMs).
It shows that RNNs can efficiently represent bounded hierarchical structures
that are prevalent in human language. This suggests that RNNs' success might be
linked to their ability to model hierarchy. However, a closer inspection of
Hewitt et al.'s (2020) construction shows that it is not inherently limited to
hierarchical structures. This poses a natural question: What other classes of
LMs can RNNs efficiently represent? To this end, we generalize Hewitt et al.'s
(2020) construction and show that RNNs can efficiently represent a larger class
of LMs than previously claimed -- specifically, those that can be represented
by a pushdown automaton with a bounded stack and a specific stack update
function. Altogether, the efficiency of representing this diverse class of LMs
with RNN LMs suggests novel interpretations of their inductive bias.
|
[
-0.08074893057346344,
-0.3181304335594177,
0.4045872986316681,
0.3375304639339447,
0.11339252442121506,
0.21150264143943787,
-0.3879038095474243,
-0.41410738229751587,
0.22548508644104004,
0.31993234157562256,
-0.22471866011619568,
-0.2655183672904968,
-0.4724281430244446,
0.5185273289680481,
-0.6565306782722473,
0.8333717584609985,
0.21779730916023254,
0.030779387801885605,
-0.05263242498040199,
-0.17858771979808807,
-0.18360652029514313,
-0.6180795431137085,
-0.5380822420120239,
-0.6383509635925293,
0.634084165096283,
-0.19926294684410095,
1.1295015811920166,
1.20718514919281,
0.5309668183326721,
0.3657865822315216,
-0.23111288249492645,
-0.06841184943914413,
-0.43304893374443054,
0.1725292056798935,
0.2965288460254669,
-0.36560824513435364,
-0.2372395396232605,
0.006329351104795933,
0.9827926158905029,
1.1188029050827026,
-0.1888425052165985,
-0.13290941715240479,
0.10990829020738602,
0.8313851952552795,
-0.15802530944347382,
0.0559958815574646,
-0.7148171067237854,
0.2770238220691681,
-0.3142300248146057,
-0.2480435073375702,
-0.7100992202758789,
-0.40841391682624817,
0.18102718889713287,
-0.39453819394111633,
0.12007260322570801,
-0.0569068044424057,
0.9361905455589294,
0.37486979365348816,
-0.21818549931049347,
-0.04390683025121689,
-0.8182206749916077,
0.7989102005958557,
-0.6408942341804504,
0.47041839361190796,
0.06697290390729904,
0.3168441355228424,
-0.46168819069862366,
-0.6855093240737915,
-0.05278216302394867,
-0.6862651705741882,
-0.27553629875183105,
-0.05938836187124252,
-0.07728420943021774,
0.2864145040512085,
0.43068841099739075,
0.9417212605476379,
-0.508405864238739,
0.27649572491645813,
-0.10279221087694168,
-0.15093180537223816,
0.35108864307403564,
0.3743734359741211,
0.3656352162361145,
-0.16167309880256653,
-0.4318086504936218,
0.29366034269332886,
-0.72028648853302,
-0.2073078751564026,
0.20454750955104828,
0.33079561591148376,
0.08735629171133041,
0.49704238772392273,
-0.02312120608985424,
1.2887568473815918,
-0.22926673293113708,
0.12435895204544067,
-0.06848667562007904,
-0.10962831228971481,
-0.3046704828739166,
-0.4036732614040375,
0.6951932311058044,
0.014345573261380196,
0.8594418168067932,
-0.4047902822494507,
-0.18058647215366364,
0.042633652687072754,
0.32449644804000854,
-0.5260246992111206,
-0.42323875427246094,
-0.031034935265779495,
-0.8015850186347961,
-0.394273966550827,
0.08474484831094742,
-0.48429074883461,
-0.27243921160697937,
-0.2529449760913849,
-0.09706994146108627,
-0.1596892774105072,
-0.1164383664727211,
0.1086365282535553,
0.033581603318452835,
-0.01913360506296158,
0.18922355771064758,
-0.6743358969688416,
0.604490339756012,
0.7652700543403625,
0.8973346948623657,
-0.10388787090778351,
-0.1801851987838745,
-0.27455833554267883,
-0.12592582404613495,
-0.5477175116539001,
0.4819834232330322,
-0.5893934369087219,
-0.1065705269575119,
0.22688674926757812,
-0.23960520327091217,
-0.013986469246447086,
-0.6585619449615479,
-0.03673923760652542,
-0.6921312212944031,
0.16487263143062592,
0.1493762880563736,
-0.6495556831359863,
0.11699230223894119,
0.042334623634815216,
-1.0111370086669922,
0.7136809825897217,
0.20911896228790283,
-0.6237001419067383,
-0.1297856569290161,
-0.3332008123397827,
-0.5617049932479858,
-0.028980595991015434,
-0.3316231966018677,
-0.20582392811775208,
0.17134904861450195,
-0.2893691062927246,
0.27591872215270996,
-0.26580771803855896,
0.18160995841026306,
-0.1024407148361206,
-0.2770465910434723,
0.5617389678955078,
-0.46671685576438904,
0.9087804555892944,
0.46538257598876953,
-0.270854115486145,
-0.010046247392892838,
-0.8101646900177002,
-0.05723031982779503,
-0.003711820114403963,
-0.7020576000213623,
-0.3465532064437866,
0.028631219640374184,
-0.2634620666503906,
0.10409648716449738,
0.16188202798366547,
-0.500101625919342,
0.4291090965270996,
-0.3825671374797821,
0.49679383635520935,
0.7564504742622375,
-0.32436370849609375,
0.6425118446350098,
-0.32409241795539856,
0.570646345615387,
-0.268056184053421,
-0.08994023501873016,
-0.37757840752601624,
-0.5738438367843628,
-0.8321612477302551,
-0.312061607837677,
0.6564705967903137,
0.35978153347969055,
-0.3392917811870575,
0.2745370864868164,
-0.29062581062316895,
-0.02305726148188114,
-0.6196881532669067,
-0.09930509328842163,
0.35376325249671936,
0.4436728358268738,
0.1572207361459732,
-0.32171401381492615,
-0.9792402982711792,
-1.1095168590545654,
-0.5692935585975647,
-0.17676395177841187,
0.043762002140283585,
0.2267882078886032,
0.21140602231025696,
-0.1346493810415268,
0.8074493408203125,
-0.02904808521270752,
-0.011276770383119583,
-0.3176807165145874,
0.05864201486110687,
0.37102341651916504,
0.4242311716079712,
0.22175201773643494,
-0.6385031938552856,
-0.4831642508506775,
0.013803830370306969,
-0.6762105226516724,
0.020196784287691116,
-0.32813337445259094,
0.1944592297077179,
0.22050970792770386,
0.30964958667755127,
-0.4053729772567749,
0.6210955381393433,
0.3216830790042877,
-0.05506282299757004,
0.30508509278297424,
0.03821210935711861,
-0.15026959776878357,
-0.7484472393989563,
-0.09110824018716812,
0.07746046036481857,
-0.5920698642730713,
-0.7134388089179993,
0.029458992183208466,
-0.07173087447881699,
-0.25816476345062256,
-0.04623184725642204,
0.5811090469360352,
-0.6161494851112366,
-0.31884872913360596,
-0.1320333033800125,
0.09839626401662827,
-0.3482557535171509,
0.39519110321998596,
0.35918644070625305,
0.37414994835853577,
0.4456343650817871,
-0.662682831287384,
0.1816316694021225,
-0.03137628734111786,
-0.4461740553379059,
-0.08914536237716675,
-0.7140423655509949,
-0.014361796900629997,
-0.24079462885856628,
0.5464484095573425,
-0.6400384902954102,
-0.1940728724002838,
0.013884817250072956,
-0.44130393862724304,
0.32945773005485535,
-0.2861081659793854,
-0.3310169279575348,
-0.3742464482784271,
0.012062245979905128,
0.3228178024291992,
0.598192036151886,
-0.6375987529754639,
0.3913981020450592,
0.37020573019981384,
0.2133868783712387,
-0.6169975399971008,
-0.9473246335983276,
0.21516679227352142,
0.00019849046657327563,
-0.47771841287612915,
0.14116552472114563,
0.1688716560602188,
-0.5418573021888733,
0.20902232825756073,
0.07562411576509476,
-0.0021231789141893387,
0.1256037801504135,
0.18865612149238586,
0.16998882591724396,
-0.3768956661224365,
-0.02238314226269722,
-0.7651970386505127,
-0.31435906887054443,
-0.16256889700889587,
-0.5018996000289917,
0.44976404309272766,
-0.3674167990684509,
-0.10404530167579651,
-0.6792281866073608,
0.5454764366149902,
0.42770764231681824,
-0.11471986770629883,
0.7037808299064636,
0.10795719176530838,
-0.5072771310806274,
-0.16997738182544708,
-0.39935368299484253,
-0.15246450901031494,
-0.4111030101776123,
0.3843959867954254,
-0.33549052476882935,
-1.0682270526885986,
0.5887807607650757,
0.1882244050502777,
0.28641825914382935,
0.45191600918769836,
0.4986136257648468,
-0.003953903913497925,
1.0454940795898438,
0.533684492111206,
-0.27396151423454285,
0.5744442939758301,
-0.22945623099803925,
-0.0005734694423153996,
-0.8792852759361267,
-0.2843917906284332,
-0.6656001806259155,
-0.5079779624938965,
-0.8045740127563477,
-0.33210688829421997,
-0.06167414039373398,
-0.13307981193065643,
-0.47773173451423645,
0.546039342880249,
-0.6138813495635986,
0.3299989402294159,
0.5327131152153015,
-0.24413448572158813,
0.362745463848114,
0.13326753675937653,
-0.0834425836801529,
-0.21299079060554504,
-1.068204402923584,
-0.5751514434814453,
0.7022485733032227,
0.8110628128051758,
1.0671466588974,
-0.004095155745744705,
0.8090825080871582,
0.16055229306221008,
0.6165339350700378,
-0.7099328637123108,
0.5837316513061523,
-0.4081774055957794,
-0.7492983341217041,
-0.09917145222425461,
-0.8825926184654236,
-1.1528583765029907,
0.22945883870124817,
0.1867544800043106,
-0.6647763848304749,
0.4055541157722473,
0.16810090839862823,
-0.3946615159511566,
0.6457736492156982,
-0.3624178469181061,
0.5992302298545837,
-0.19391515851020813,
-0.01856546849012375,
-0.0227118618786335,
-0.8173230886459351,
0.31419333815574646,
0.5679153203964233,
0.04058326035737991,
0.1991347372531891,
-0.12690401077270508,
0.7427815198898315,
-0.5134732723236084,
0.8075135350227356,
0.05398627743124962,
0.013914558105170727,
0.42927974462509155,
0.4293895959854126,
0.4833940267562866,
-0.12726609408855438,
-0.2847815752029419,
0.09531136602163315,
-0.40041959285736084,
-0.48175984621047974,
-0.8004059195518494,
0.666587769985199,
-0.4413312077522278,
-0.4540606439113617,
-0.6510248780250549,
-0.8093215227127075,
-0.07265549898147583,
0.03498290106654167,
0.12046382576227188,
0.9066321849822998,
-0.15819840133190155,
0.3915855884552002,
0.7083846926689148,
-0.024629589170217514,
0.47391581535339355,
0.12266533076763153,
-0.42173856496810913,
-0.3129501938819885,
0.6834572553634644,
0.3100792467594147,
0.45057520270347595,
0.6193341612815857,
0.15263180434703827,
-0.1844760924577713,
-0.48249030113220215,
-0.5793087482452393,
0.09972130507230759,
-0.5408129096031189,
-0.11383601278066635,
-0.5470463037490845,
-0.4975140392780304,
-0.14344191551208496,
0.08364629745483398,
-0.37895694375038147,
-0.944923460483551,
-0.11895228922367096,
-0.11749867349863052,
0.3051247298717499,
1.298262357711792,
-0.2778876721858978,
-0.11269251257181168,
-0.5976369976997375,
0.2985653877258301,
0.4417157471179962,
0.4992126226425171,
0.4532226324081421,
-0.614766538143158,
-0.2529660761356354,
-0.08681220561265945,
0.18571171164512634,
-0.724007248878479,
0.07306236028671265,
0.241219624876976,
0.5722999572753906,
0.31418105959892273,
-0.26327553391456604,
0.6080619096755981,
-0.7131139636039734,
0.7320910692214966,
0.13111282885074615,
-0.4698757231235504,
0.2025165855884552,
-0.42160263657569885,
0.192849799990654,
0.40205472707748413,
0.553451657295227,
-0.5667161345481873,
-0.5687741041183472,
-0.7933897376060486,
-0.6792042255401611,
0.408430278301239,
0.2632821202278137,
0.27795374393463135,
-0.35083362460136414,
0.5831373929977417,
-0.03993581607937813,
0.05652076378464699,
-0.9522945284843445,
-0.6054254174232483,
-0.17505225539207458,
-0.3368224799633026,
0.3446986675262451,
-0.3898765444755554,
-0.001227882574312389,
0.04314029589295387,
0.3996221423149109,
0.3313506543636322,
0.46900343894958496,
0.3410344123840332,
-0.13535580039024353,
0.06172242760658264,
0.22006481885910034,
0.681521475315094,
0.42255061864852905,
-0.13651502132415771,
0.46927252411842346,
-0.1434764564037323,
-0.22430332005023956,
0.13493561744689941,
-0.06339263170957565,
-0.32464370131492615,
0.20303982496261597,
0.6519620418548584,
0.6728625893592834,
0.2844993472099304,
-0.268962025642395,
0.009101182222366333,
-0.03059559501707554,
0.16246652603149414,
-0.1857668161392212,
-0.18637631833553314,
-0.006112243980169296,
-0.11238564550876617,
0.3422628343105316,
0.4240378141403198,
-0.051926303654909134,
-0.7934333086013794,
0.4613115191459656,
0.3342428505420685,
-0.5840861201286316,
-0.2929301857948303,
0.6186551451683044,
0.39480212330818176,
-0.8173625469207764,
0.7686200141906738,
-0.10884064435958862,
-0.7173988223075867,
0.5136655569076538,
0.8592434525489807,
0.886769711971283,
-0.19294701516628265,
-0.1209145113825798,
0.566855788230896,
0.4211861193180084,
-0.24807855486869812,
0.024019913747906685,
0.01917511783540249,
-0.6996856927871704,
-0.5429142713546753,
-0.5249560475349426,
-0.25557848811149597,
0.04378132522106171,
-0.8185281753540039,
-0.3211691677570343,
-0.6461973786354065,
-0.1141403540968895,
-0.28180497884750366,
-0.34022969007492065,
-0.5315078496932983,
0.17316152155399323,
0.2308892458677292,
1.109230399131775,
-0.48290619254112244,
0.6198065876960754,
0.5318484306335449,
-0.36475518345832825,
-0.8154361844062805,
-0.09731612354516983,
-0.035199590027332306,
-0.704366147518158,
0.7922229766845703,
-0.06717093288898468,
-0.20560793578624725,
-0.015159486792981625,
-0.3752463757991791,
-0.7136315703392029,
0.5371392369270325,
0.22398161888122559,
-0.6762412190437317,
-0.12497285008430481,
0.025377750396728516,
0.6369712948799133,
-0.7430174946784973,
0.06962145864963531,
0.3316565454006195,
0.37309861183166504,
-0.2937270998954773,
-0.8503970503807068,
0.03206748142838478,
-0.44753193855285645,
0.445699542760849,
0.23879976570606232,
-0.43266329169273376,
0.7727050185203552,
-0.2937186658382416,
-0.35797378420829773,
0.5709636211395264,
1.0166497230529785,
0.1031714528799057,
-0.044851213693618774,
0.39707913994789124,
0.654037594795227,
0.6323696374893188,
-0.2613406777381897,
1.626255750656128,
-0.05911504849791527,
0.1755136102437973,
1.205040454864502,
0.09148398786783218,
0.6604947447776794,
0.19598522782325745,
-0.2988651692867279,
0.9069402813911438,
0.6236559152603149,
0.13713598251342773,
0.47916126251220703,
0.7253057360649109,
-0.0637500062584877,
-0.4596831202507019,
-0.06295514851808548,
-0.4661000967025757,
-0.001868187915533781,
0.041680045425891876,
-0.41963890194892883,
-0.17551112174987793,
-0.207834392786026,
-0.19821174442768097,
0.5027908086776733,
-0.38258349895477295,
0.590438723564148,
0.3966960608959198,
-0.4886647164821625,
0.6281960606575012,
-0.161525696516037,
0.6495004296302795,
-0.42997536063194275,
-0.09864537417888641,
-0.12981881201267242,
-0.06422565877437592,
-0.3944915235042572,
-0.644591212272644,
0.3259982466697693,
-0.00006826270691817626,
-0.2626231908798218,
-0.3942842185497284,
0.7773640155792236,
-0.6015774011611938,
-0.3254169225692749,
0.1622801572084427,
0.24038377404212952,
0.34560659527778625,
0.49846288561820984,
-0.4957391321659088,
0.10418017208576202,
-0.05308942124247551,
-0.19159726798534393,
0.1848679631948471,
0.3697299361228943,
0.011961355805397034,
0.9418778419494629,
0.4019072651863098,
0.36638692021369934,
0.41897252202033997,
0.4508064091205597,
0.436422199010849,
-0.867965817451477,
-0.2158038467168808,
-0.7781198024749756,
0.5844730734825134,
-0.06587423384189606,
-0.18982821702957153,
0.7715402245521545,
0.6106448173522949,
0.6976097226142883,
-0.10018625110387802,
0.6871462464332581,
0.02591094747185707,
0.5941683053970337,
-0.3850831091403961,
0.570412814617157,
-0.3313080966472626,
0.33423808217048645,
-0.0075566936284303665,
-0.7741891741752625,
-0.6625474095344543,
1.1125428676605225,
-0.16524851322174072,
0.28544384241104126,
0.5518675446510315,
0.6444746851921082,
0.20188230276107788,
0.08622266352176666,
0.27703532576560974,
0.275237113237381,
-0.028103111311793327,
0.4160398244857788,
1.251103401184082,
-0.43240514397621155,
0.4518193304538727,
-0.39139702916145325,
-0.21407531201839447,
-0.13108769059181213,
-0.8931372761726379,
-0.7998548150062561,
-0.46020904183387756,
-0.36331766843795776,
-0.5489591360092163,
0.05210180580615997,
0.9294895529747009,
0.7603471875190735,
-0.8828376531600952,
-0.4385684132575989,
-0.25891977548599243,
0.5729107856750488,
-0.23131851851940155,
-0.20570477843284607,
0.24502010643482208,
-0.36842238903045654,
-0.6378554701805115,
0.5807026624679565,
0.3710933327674866,
-0.04539875313639641,
-0.38987043499946594,
-0.2267746478319168,
-0.16292120516300201,
-0.12793603539466858,
0.5769829750061035,
0.6468316912651062,
-0.6993434429168701,
-0.28812333941459656,
0.3123236298561096,
-0.3788348138332367,
0.17606045305728912,
1.2106075286865234,
-0.9610790610313416,
0.27047595381736755,
0.5578151345252991,
0.91368168592453,
0.08974175900220871,
-0.03701956197619438,
0.7939206957817078,
-0.5775204300880432,
0.05864611268043518,
0.5674692988395691,
0.4058229625225067,
0.48680830001831055,
-0.014899118803441525,
0.6094201803207397,
-0.02243998274207115,
-0.6251157522201538,
-0.8694886565208435,
0.7284426093101501,
-0.743132472038269,
0.003922003321349621,
1.2846914529800415,
-0.06302765756845474,
-0.27412909269332886,
-0.4461217224597931,
0.26453396677970886,
0.08298535645008087,
-0.21725714206695557,
0.7222751975059509,
0.4480212330818176,
-0.23094551265239716,
-0.013758269138634205,
-0.5842655301094055,
0.5641804933547974,
0.5929142832756042,
-0.2836572229862213,
0.0317906029522419,
0.19401559233665466,
0.18733035027980804,
0.29104170203208923,
0.7232152819633484,
-0.43008193373680115,
0.2286207526922226,
-0.3591555058956146,
-0.1226433590054512,
-0.22124642133712769,
-0.4864771366119385,
-0.5390186309814453,
-0.09150054305791855,
0.19141821563243866,
-0.09825959801673889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15813v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15813v3
|
Measuring Bargaining Abilities of LLMs: A Benchmark and A Buyer-Enhancement Method
| 2024-02-24T13:36:58 | 2024-06-04T08:12:04 |
Tian Xia, Zhiwei He, Tong Ren, Yibo Miao, Zhuosheng Zhang, Yang Yang, Rui Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.GT
|
Bargaining is an important and unique part of negotiation between humans. As
LLM-driven agents learn to negotiate and act like real humans, how to evaluate
agents' bargaining abilities remains an open problem. For the first time, we
formally described the Bargaining task as an asymmetric incomplete information
game, defining the gains of the Buyer and Seller in multiple bargaining
processes. It allows us to quantitatively assess an agent's performance in the
Bargain task. We collected a real product price dataset, AmazonHistoryPrice,
and conducted evaluations of various LLM agents' bargaining abilities. We find
that playing a Buyer is much harder than a Seller, and increasing model size
can not effectively improve the Buyer's performance. To address the challenge,
we propose a novel approach called OG-Narrator that integrates a deterministic
Offer Generator to control the price range of Buyer's offers, and an LLM
Narrator to create natural language sentences for generated offers.
Experimental results show that OG-Narrator improves the buyer's deal rates from
26.67% to 88.88% and brings a ten times multiplication of profits on all
baselines, even a model that has not been aligned.
|
[
-0.48639535903930664,
-0.5799607634544373,
0.5911645293235779,
-0.06282514333724976,
-0.27833035588264465,
0.11142686754465103,
-0.46792706847190857,
-0.8384976387023926,
0.1394469290971756,
0.19620877504348755,
-0.40881720185279846,
-0.29537707567214966,
-0.5572758913040161,
0.10006177425384521,
0.07470536977052689,
0.7590687274932861,
0.3158051371574402,
0.0587531141936779,
-0.12160692363977432,
-0.07727768272161484,
-0.21061868965625763,
-0.29303574562072754,
-0.9261549115180969,
-0.1904681771993637,
0.26373961567878723,
0.16323669254779816,
0.90240079164505,
0.6464657187461853,
0.30502232909202576,
0.38538113236427307,
-0.2456730753183365,
0.13917183876037598,
-0.4704665243625641,
0.3543083071708679,
-0.2779156565666199,
-0.5869101285934448,
-0.7431634664535522,
0.3552100360393524,
0.45621219277381897,
0.5812758803367615,
-0.2404869794845581,
0.21623945236206055,
0.21394799649715424,
0.5011084079742432,
-0.647395670413971,
0.10101179778575897,
-0.7535227537155151,
0.08348729461431503,
0.1628447324037552,
-0.31784194707870483,
-0.38042885065078735,
-0.33625906705856323,
0.047510985285043716,
-0.7501509785652161,
0.02190237119793892,
-0.08618956059217453,
0.8657054901123047,
0.38685041666030884,
-0.45977988839149475,
-0.48113465309143066,
-0.7064119577407837,
0.5925158858299255,
-0.689785361289978,
0.4054197072982788,
0.33478614687919617,
0.2457764595746994,
-0.29557710886001587,
-0.5959826707839966,
-0.24512030184268951,
-0.7244946360588074,
-0.03947902470827103,
0.4777277708053589,
-0.5582035183906555,
0.09279054403305054,
0.4137367308139801,
0.46766197681427,
-0.2494727075099945,
0.2910192310810089,
-0.44050154089927673,
-0.11540238559246063,
0.8955331444740295,
0.37508976459503174,
0.16175176203250885,
-0.07703369855880737,
-0.7952998876571655,
0.07422204315662384,
-0.237493634223938,
0.3392183780670166,
0.8191593885421753,
0.25255948305130005,
0.10517745465040207,
0.8353804349899292,
-0.45342788100242615,
0.7571133375167847,
0.08961845934391022,
-0.2939533591270447,
0.0014229248045012355,
-0.3281758725643158,
-0.29526084661483765,
-0.03480077162384987,
0.6540823578834534,
0.5197502374649048,
-0.022772962227463722,
-0.1816530078649521,
-0.2579132318496704,
0.04636058956384659,
0.3761354684829712,
-0.44860929250717163,
0.051368627697229385,
0.1736263930797577,
-0.61313396692276,
-0.25081002712249756,
-0.08207258582115173,
-0.7349708080291748,
-0.35099515318870544,
-0.3352530002593994,
0.4823792576789856,
-0.2600843608379364,
-0.1025603860616684,
0.08197764307260513,
-0.4841097891330719,
0.43616801500320435,
0.18411892652511597,
-0.5374507308006287,
0.7069388628005981,
0.4694978892803192,
0.6400457620620728,
0.09039166569709778,
-0.558303713798523,
-0.5734429955482483,
0.09799524396657944,
-0.42332321405410767,
0.8250238299369812,
-0.1597268283367157,
-0.37313610315322876,
-0.21836566925048828,
-0.5589951276779175,
-0.08791040629148483,
-0.6102991700172424,
0.5531503558158875,
-0.44109249114990234,
0.21137283742427826,
-0.0022292197681963444,
-0.7809664011001587,
0.17522265017032623,
0.6370067596435547,
-0.6075188517570496,
0.81654292345047,
0.028139753267169,
-0.24281123280525208,
0.4697553515434265,
-0.570651113986969,
-0.3698773682117462,
0.1038590595126152,
-0.14151088893413544,
-0.1696849912405014,
0.33975666761398315,
0.2400929033756256,
0.3322635591030121,
-0.5667566657066345,
-0.004425633233040571,
-0.05039888992905617,
-0.3706726133823395,
0.799173891544342,
-0.591163158416748,
0.6569195985794067,
0.12546437978744507,
-0.4112451374530792,
-0.2168949842453003,
-0.38609832525253296,
0.011410209350287914,
0.15202383697032928,
-0.6942692995071411,
0.10622194409370422,
-0.2339150607585907,
-0.3291746973991394,
-0.031323935836553574,
0.41364482045173645,
-0.3239850401878357,
0.3088029623031616,
-0.3934115767478943,
0.014527253806591034,
0.6717010736465454,
0.045920148491859436,
0.5434907078742981,
-0.7455066442489624,
0.8374069929122925,
-0.5115570425987244,
0.44902873039245605,
0.04438895359635353,
-0.38375505805015564,
-0.6589068174362183,
-0.5785215497016907,
0.39281919598579407,
0.33331090211868286,
-0.6388530731201172,
0.37511810660362244,
-0.13527129590511322,
-0.6065841317176819,
-0.523219645023346,
-0.01383772399276495,
0.4253075122833252,
0.19093677401542664,
0.19415421783924103,
-0.4597635269165039,
-0.32114559412002563,
-0.7746430039405823,
-0.7219200730323792,
-0.4055916666984558,
-0.40636077523231506,
0.35650166869163513,
-0.18064585328102112,
0.21643789112567902,
0.6342548131942749,
-0.5611137747764587,
-0.65565025806427,
-0.32898974418640137,
0.33069366216659546,
0.12337226420640945,
0.13677112758159637,
0.5627009868621826,
-0.2811911702156067,
-0.4012250304222107,
-0.028432369232177734,
-0.5596514344215393,
-0.041301947087049484,
-0.3250924348831177,
-0.18325234949588776,
0.43618515133857727,
0.602906346321106,
-0.8810591697692871,
0.5337594747543335,
0.25631293654441833,
-0.6071251034736633,
0.8133466243743896,
-0.6558182239532471,
0.29968297481536865,
-0.6145170331001282,
-0.22226017713546753,
-0.06030751019716263,
-0.26742929220199585,
-0.5017105340957642,
0.2239736169576645,
-0.29441574215888977,
0.0631665363907814,
-0.4585368037223816,
0.3185778558254242,
-0.9358534216880798,
-0.5723624229431152,
-0.39181387424468994,
0.5741506218910217,
-0.04259246960282326,
0.5430589914321899,
0.01419492531567812,
0.5707491636276245,
0.4400365352630615,
-0.8837129473686218,
0.39215749502182007,
0.2460905909538269,
-0.43858855962753296,
1.072296142578125,
-0.4515848755836487,
0.17134803533554077,
0.03233584016561508,
0.23197819292545319,
-0.6715769171714783,
0.09101574122905731,
0.4668666422367096,
-0.5299791097640991,
0.18953397870063782,
-0.26145973801612854,
-0.2612393796443939,
-0.018590047955513,
-0.34402692317962646,
0.016037004068493843,
0.612097442150116,
-0.45338600873947144,
1.0522955656051636,
-0.016532979905605316,
-0.24331322312355042,
-0.6135266423225403,
-0.2947911322116852,
0.4208506643772125,
-0.3143842816352844,
-0.4687082767486572,
0.303105890750885,
-0.29556941986083984,
-0.4070225656032562,
0.08195870369672775,
-0.09236694127321243,
0.03636854887008667,
0.1980774849653244,
-0.06487056612968445,
0.2243964970111847,
-0.19358372688293457,
0.12612569332122803,
-0.02505260892212391,
-0.5499499440193176,
0.11168280988931656,
-0.013513450510799885,
0.4139972925186157,
0.09755536168813705,
-0.3412792682647705,
-0.3247259259223938,
0.048399969935417175,
0.366420179605484,
-0.05129031836986542,
0.3513743281364441,
0.26898273825645447,
-0.11468975245952606,
-0.0980774536728859,
-0.6647558212280273,
-0.19452109932899475,
-0.412105917930603,
0.22165872156620026,
-0.6756204962730408,
-0.27281928062438965,
0.5197100639343262,
-0.1369439959526062,
-0.10130887478590012,
0.3542223870754242,
0.4810016453266144,
-0.030884990468621254,
0.7428942322731018,
0.20814384520053864,
0.0564698688685894,
0.3186997175216675,
-0.12059921771287918,
-0.1293937861919403,
-0.8379386067390442,
-0.3461054861545563,
-0.48962005972862244,
-0.7062219977378845,
-0.22378917038440704,
-0.3733339309692383,
0.2057333141565323,
0.31846123933792114,
-0.35817548632621765,
0.2255181521177292,
-0.3724527359008789,
0.6833841800689697,
0.8047123551368713,
0.4666859805583954,
0.8158613443374634,
-0.365313857793808,
0.17174066603183746,
-0.1962847113609314,
-0.3879023790359497,
-0.544364333152771,
1.0222197771072388,
0.31842485070228577,
0.42116349935531616,
0.4322763681411743,
0.5232237577438354,
0.3659673035144806,
0.08209002017974854,
-1.0259900093078613,
0.8455648422241211,
0.2779691815376282,
-0.5001140832901001,
-0.6585471630096436,
-0.5200052857398987,
-1.1318049430847168,
0.498800128698349,
-0.31210723519325256,
-0.8592799305915833,
0.39482739567756653,
-0.07465989142656326,
-0.3859630823135376,
0.18782946467399597,
-0.4621919095516205,
0.7817419767379761,
-0.7737519145011902,
-0.15620385110378265,
-0.28427568078041077,
-0.31614816188812256,
0.005998579319566488,
0.17453135550022125,
0.15946345031261444,
-0.4131680130958557,
-0.6819666624069214,
0.5445348024368286,
-0.11939206719398499,
0.607546865940094,
-0.3369213044643402,
0.16978076100349426,
0.0247977115213871,
0.4596458375453949,
0.7445768713951111,
-0.13101914525032043,
-0.13545432686805725,
-0.019051266834139824,
-0.42650124430656433,
-0.4926705062389374,
-0.8352818489074707,
0.19061845541000366,
-0.5953443050384521,
-0.6858631372451782,
-0.21982844173908234,
-0.6522966027259827,
-0.33361127972602844,
-0.07666346430778503,
0.37069228291511536,
0.19889000058174133,
-0.5822180509567261,
0.0616159588098526,
0.06522063165903091,
-0.01388153713196516,
0.32478928565979004,
0.7175920605659485,
-0.11066832393407822,
-0.5258330702781677,
0.659331738948822,
0.03523869067430496,
0.573718249797821,
-0.016669156029820442,
0.2419828325510025,
-0.25964149832725525,
-0.7682212591171265,
-0.19194817543029785,
0.034769006073474884,
-0.831847071647644,
-0.4136732220649719,
-0.48597022891044617,
-0.05455319583415985,
0.05131728574633598,
-0.3759327232837677,
-0.22350576519966125,
-0.3126913607120514,
-0.3327094316482544,
-0.5292486548423767,
0.34230881929397583,
0.6797065138816833,
-0.39725449681282043,
0.2854394316673279,
-0.42853930592536926,
0.4500068426132202,
0.7098286151885986,
0.20534947514533997,
0.07281206548213959,
-0.5197545289993286,
-0.2240840494632721,
0.14005421102046967,
-0.21811896562576294,
-0.7685683965682983,
0.3521954417228699,
0.03575918450951576,
0.9950934052467346,
0.4540153443813324,
0.5093986392021179,
0.6216028332710266,
0.07474862784147263,
0.9378045201301575,
0.3316168487071991,
-1.1797152757644653,
0.1815091222524643,
-0.3010873794555664,
0.07761230319738388,
0.3720413148403168,
0.056447502225637436,
-0.032966312021017075,
-0.6883552670478821,
-0.8022488355636597,
-0.9417130351066589,
0.9209120869636536,
0.4897083640098572,
0.02812010794878006,
0.22351892292499542,
-0.02693650685250759,
0.13136234879493713,
0.26742491126060486,
-0.5243439674377441,
-0.21045450866222382,
0.14088016748428345,
0.03153521567583084,
-0.1857852339744568,
-0.4214053153991699,
-0.1538752168416977,
-0.14921584725379944,
0.5996463894844055,
-0.14905492961406708,
0.1982775777578354,
0.18380294740200043,
-0.2753245532512665,
0.008569451048970222,
0.3946531414985657,
0.3204328417778015,
0.6752801537513733,
-0.26742249727249146,
0.10338592529296875,
0.30344080924987793,
-0.09350539743900299,
0.2200736105442047,
0.3488621413707733,
0.2777732312679291,
-0.24825270473957062,
0.3426543176174164,
0.6125762462615967,
0.4325704574584961,
-0.7439202666282654,
0.39858105778694153,
-0.1514129936695099,
-0.6166221499443054,
-0.2684158682823181,
0.0985117182135582,
0.16649118065834045,
0.997254490852356,
0.5197516679763794,
-0.08901715278625488,
0.46196210384368896,
-0.6467220783233643,
0.06393434852361679,
0.3279593884944916,
-0.4558180272579193,
0.1123865619301796,
0.5915771722793579,
0.1257474273443222,
-0.6005311012268066,
0.7821935415267944,
-0.31785961985588074,
-0.4412972927093506,
0.8288770318031311,
0.32137516140937805,
0.8728935122489929,
-0.12876863777637482,
0.48425543308258057,
0.007966510951519012,
0.5958281755447388,
-0.03343823924660683,
0.2726266384124756,
-0.23145294189453125,
-0.7465613484382629,
-0.003899230621755123,
0.05789440497756004,
-0.6201788783073425,
-0.15088053047657013,
-0.9548282623291016,
0.08390785753726959,
-0.019216371700167656,
-0.37869566679000854,
0.18257372081279755,
0.26140066981315613,
-0.9180063605308533,
0.049540359526872635,
-0.0529717355966568,
0.6721319556236267,
-0.4855746924877167,
0.21608155965805054,
0.4582807123661041,
-0.6117798089981079,
-0.5531183481216431,
0.09745510667562485,
-0.1611952930688858,
-0.5843231678009033,
0.35442060232162476,
-0.06261290609836578,
-0.04318644851446152,
0.005652826279401779,
-0.461743026971817,
-0.5023463368415833,
1.2328846454620361,
0.9955657720565796,
-0.35781776905059814,
0.058362748473882675,
0.03549349308013916,
0.6012678146362305,
-0.5546354055404663,
0.4931429922580719,
0.7496656775474548,
0.6607242822647095,
0.05386669933795929,
-0.9502251148223877,
0.12138057500123978,
-0.07737061381340027,
-0.16749243438243866,
-0.01386762410402298,
-0.4690638780593872,
0.7521102428436279,
-0.20037688314914703,
-0.2044060379266739,
0.467277854681015,
0.3483580946922302,
0.3360157310962677,
0.5927122831344604,
0.7253099083900452,
0.4808008670806885,
0.9515810608863831,
0.019713275134563446,
1.1509822607040405,
-0.04251011461019516,
0.3032909035682678,
1.285923957824707,
-0.3308519124984741,
0.8696547746658325,
0.11840680986642838,
-0.3394711911678314,
0.3020114600658417,
0.3747846782207489,
0.008135859854519367,
0.09167135506868362,
0.319876492023468,
-0.1952793300151825,
-0.5272662043571472,
-0.1376601755619049,
-0.1390732079744339,
0.5053558349609375,
0.13597449660301208,
-0.4726514220237732,
-0.04494481533765793,
-0.1125095784664154,
-0.04007580876350403,
0.2970178425312042,
-0.17196621000766754,
1.1887811422348022,
0.10284879803657532,
-0.3496292531490326,
0.2994040250778198,
-0.26089873909950256,
0.4570414423942566,
-0.5512117743492126,
0.16447320580482483,
-0.3605358898639679,
0.03539547324180603,
0.11247653514146805,
-0.5899689197540283,
0.044218502938747406,
-0.2689509391784668,
-0.0553111657500267,
-0.01338465791195631,
0.6076206564903259,
-0.39394333958625793,
-0.2780899703502655,
0.5839636921882629,
0.7360401153564453,
0.3480137586593628,
-0.23090718686580658,
-0.5916897654533386,
-0.01985727623105049,
-0.22174818813800812,
-0.517258882522583,
0.3641557991504669,
0.3125561773777008,
0.45930129289627075,
0.5077822804450989,
0.5587415099143982,
0.1519356518983841,
-0.23270386457443237,
-0.23778079450130463,
0.5535363554954529,
-0.922344446182251,
-0.5054826140403748,
-0.6511262059211731,
0.7850636839866638,
-0.47895997762680054,
-0.14465481042861938,
0.7435560822486877,
0.6910606026649475,
0.8389376997947693,
0.09664274752140045,
0.546890914440155,
0.3750731945037842,
0.3500521779060364,
-0.6367034316062927,
0.6235836148262024,
-0.4391571581363678,
0.37598761916160583,
0.024677878245711327,
-1.1884926557540894,
0.20575226843357086,
0.34690773487091064,
-0.16399361193180084,
0.039202965795993805,
0.6930244565010071,
0.4075299799442291,
0.07536301761865616,
0.02509700506925583,
0.6967370510101318,
0.25984981656074524,
-0.0669025331735611,
0.3770006000995636,
1.2076053619384766,
-0.3691983222961426,
1.015694499015808,
-0.12801046669483185,
-0.2440563142299652,
-0.03401561453938484,
-0.7013773322105408,
-0.8733548521995544,
-0.2599148154258728,
-0.5690882802009583,
-0.2826193571090698,
0.10948240756988525,
0.917485773563385,
0.5049617886543274,
0.01961289718747139,
-0.6266816258430481,
0.35313689708709717,
0.1989259272813797,
-0.8169497847557068,
-0.18285956978797913,
0.10466273128986359,
-0.4479265511035919,
-0.8078536987304688,
0.6954864263534546,
0.2157917469739914,
0.054341014474630356,
-0.1711985170841217,
-0.35752907395362854,
0.1689390391111374,
0.5315576791763306,
0.3755825459957123,
0.18396326899528503,
-0.5689534544944763,
0.057199738919734955,
-0.1332704722881317,
0.03774590417742729,
0.0013584272237494588,
0.9390581250190735,
-0.8153263330459595,
0.613919198513031,
0.04551677033305168,
0.3354453444480896,
0.5828152298927307,
0.12176576256752014,
0.8120437860488892,
-0.46682825684547424,
0.23654650151729584,
0.29265454411506653,
0.3305140733718872,
-0.0520845390856266,
-0.47160449624061584,
0.6327202320098877,
-0.25572121143341064,
-0.5141880512237549,
-0.7773994207382202,
0.33876410126686096,
-0.8561930656433105,
-0.41866984963417053,
0.9012280106544495,
-0.19143112003803253,
0.12622176110744476,
-0.2604389786720276,
-0.3196883499622345,
0.05622270703315735,
-0.5586854219436646,
0.8244717121124268,
0.3723115026950836,
-0.07657960802316666,
-0.12959375977516174,
-0.265702486038208,
0.291066437959671,
0.09015270322561264,
-0.7691283822059631,
-0.059431809931993484,
0.7829148769378662,
-0.30063560605049133,
-0.02364957518875599,
0.7853940725326538,
0.19933389127254486,
0.4009469747543335,
0.32978567481040955,
0.061578430235385895,
-0.31085941195487976,
-0.14104719460010529,
-0.35548827052116394,
0.25853052735328674,
0.5633531212806702,
-0.4503670036792755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15810v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15810v2
|
OAG-Bench: A Human-Curated Benchmark for Academic Graph Mining
| 2024-02-24T13:15:54 | 2024-06-20T04:15:12 |
Fanjin Zhang, Shijie Shi, Yifan Zhu, Bo Chen, Yukuo Cen, Jifan Yu, Yelin Chen, Lulu Wang, Qingfei Zhao, Yuqing Cheng, Tianyi Han, Yuwei An, Dan Zhang, Weng Lam Tam, Kun Cao, Yunhe Pang, Xinyu Guan, Huihui Yuan, Jian Song, Xiaoyan Li, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
With the rapid proliferation of scientific literature, versatile academic
knowledge services increasingly rely on comprehensive academic graph mining.
Despite the availability of public academic graphs, benchmarks, and datasets,
these resources often fall short in multi-aspect and fine-grained annotations,
are constrained to specific task types and domains, or lack underlying real
academic graphs. In this paper, we present OAG-Bench, a comprehensive,
multi-aspect, and fine-grained human-curated benchmark based on the Open
Academic Graph (OAG). OAG-Bench covers 10 tasks, 20 datasets, 70+ baselines,
and 120+ experimental results to date. We propose new data annotation
strategies for certain tasks and offer a suite of data pre-processing codes,
algorithm implementations, and standardized evaluation protocols to facilitate
academic graph mining. Extensive experiments reveal that even advanced
algorithms like large language models (LLMs) encounter difficulties in
addressing key challenges in certain tasks, such as paper source tracing and
scholar profiling. We also introduce the Open Academic Graph Challenge
(OAG-Challenge) to encourage community input and sharing. We envisage that
OAG-Bench can serve as a common ground for the community to evaluate and
compare algorithms in academic graph mining, thereby accelerating algorithm
development and advancement in this field. OAG-Bench is accessible at
https://www.aminer.cn/data/.
|
[
-0.5721647143363953,
-0.5235629677772522,
0.5572319626808167,
-0.24612335860729218,
0.015684431418776512,
0.3728622496128082,
-0.2339850515127182,
-0.609140932559967,
0.006345717236399651,
0.2811276912689209,
-0.4283105432987213,
-0.9781996011734009,
-0.3313736021518707,
0.045801255851984024,
-0.2907826602458954,
0.9842551350593567,
-0.4554143249988556,
0.11276977509260178,
-0.7232484817504883,
-0.4925040602684021,
-0.1258009821176529,
-0.3426614999771118,
-0.5600674748420715,
-0.5650960803031921,
0.59111487865448,
0.3003217279911041,
0.1786113828420639,
0.6909613609313965,
0.5697126388549805,
0.20680665969848633,
0.03318846970796585,
0.36467278003692627,
-0.6785491108894348,
-0.0582667700946331,
-0.20894137024879456,
-0.2838808000087738,
-0.5678132176399231,
0.0742454007267952,
0.6558715105056763,
1.1507980823516846,
-0.01985701359808445,
0.5372477173805237,
-0.002283998765051365,
0.7354771494865417,
-0.7360906600952148,
0.5834246873855591,
-0.2715629041194916,
-0.19402091205120087,
-0.9131932258605957,
0.3146779239177704,
-0.21549180150032043,
-0.39555707573890686,
-0.18308769166469574,
-0.652800977230072,
0.1349964439868927,
0.30925145745277405,
0.8415120244026184,
0.023988066241145134,
-0.11093728989362717,
0.3142625689506531,
-0.3321809470653534,
0.588445782661438,
-0.15347282588481903,
0.19299159944057465,
0.434686541557312,
0.5911773443222046,
-0.18567760288715363,
-0.8327710032463074,
-0.2084067016839981,
0.17414335906505585,
-0.2573598623275757,
-0.17273001372814178,
0.09070795774459839,
-0.1650254726409912,
-0.07975960522890091,
0.36862578988075256,
-0.39138758182525635,
0.08254942297935486,
-0.33814099431037903,
-0.03577645868062973,
0.5056618452072144,
0.14154958724975586,
-0.05172686651349068,
0.08899278193712234,
-0.32121700048446655,
-0.19936615228652954,
-0.7051401138305664,
0.04243498295545578,
0.4513448476791382,
0.3890708088874817,
0.2557768225669861,
0.3552110493183136,
-0.6095505356788635,
0.6415565013885498,
-0.4374854862689972,
0.4250597655773163,
0.4729050099849701,
-0.35064947605133057,
0.15136593580245972,
0.060922082513570786,
0.8813778758049011,
0.29731225967407227,
0.13620266318321228,
-0.374368280172348,
-0.09334449470043182,
0.09988322854042053,
0.1844519078731537,
-0.783628523349762,
-0.39449042081832886,
0.02870030887424946,
-0.38554391264915466,
-0.1852521151304245,
0.23345772922039032,
-0.9939738512039185,
-0.7160888910293579,
-0.14247184991836548,
-0.004506225232034922,
-0.4235911965370178,
-0.029343413189053535,
-0.1448262482881546,
-0.1749083250761032,
-0.2558908462524414,
0.35727423429489136,
-0.3952510952949524,
0.5488495230674744,
0.7900669574737549,
1.0487604141235352,
-0.21400560438632965,
-0.4093824326992035,
-0.6864224076271057,
0.1552974432706833,
-0.06728338450193405,
1.1097277402877808,
-0.8635451197624207,
-0.3587794899940491,
0.1286323219537735,
-0.16791099309921265,
0.11251301318407059,
-0.41816648840904236,
0.8892610669136047,
-0.24103370308876038,
-0.09780643880367279,
-0.578945517539978,
-0.455782949924469,
-0.0795404314994812,
0.17882214486598969,
-0.659309983253479,
1.2206116914749146,
0.4513949751853943,
-0.5866994261741638,
0.4449615478515625,
-1.1172059774398804,
-0.29061606526374817,
0.37566953897476196,
-0.4593369960784912,
-0.24563412368297577,
-0.13074985146522522,
0.2524474561214447,
0.2040044218301773,
-0.5706347227096558,
0.07817109674215317,
-0.7115713357925415,
-0.323097288608551,
-0.019352829083800316,
0.2958167493343353,
0.5104166269302368,
0.01367286778986454,
-0.057136666029691696,
0.055871833115816116,
-0.9361183643341064,
0.12229054421186447,
0.4994216859340668,
-0.007155880331993103,
-0.6028853058815002,
0.3003075122833252,
0.27999502420425415,
-0.16491687297821045,
0.22574053704738617,
-0.9346708059310913,
0.35768428444862366,
-0.02522941865026951,
0.713975727558136,
0.7919813394546509,
-0.11994711309671402,
0.05900736153125763,
-0.38623884320259094,
0.046747151762247086,
-0.3487853705883026,
-0.061357468366622925,
-0.11908402293920517,
-0.46497678756713867,
-0.29111894965171814,
-0.4874993860721588,
0.6379695534706116,
0.286498486995697,
-0.2183636724948883,
0.4743683934211731,
-0.526897132396698,
-0.7919952869415283,
-0.9635713696479797,
0.16423660516738892,
0.5377331376075745,
0.5606610178947449,
0.5455893278121948,
-0.6858428120613098,
-0.24031679332256317,
-0.7098296284675598,
-0.3726155757904053,
-0.13603916764259338,
-0.11574599891901016,
0.5193970799446106,
0.5216693878173828,
-0.17321039736270905,
1.0950913429260254,
-0.9764756560325623,
-0.9142670631408691,
0.39091774821281433,
0.6083038449287415,
-0.08602997660636902,
0.23983243107795715,
0.6903321743011475,
-0.37064823508262634,
-0.47641584277153015,
0.17675690352916718,
-0.7421233654022217,
-0.4535336494445801,
0.3405159115791321,
-0.24567246437072754,
0.0503166988492012,
0.44892340898513794,
-0.4062819182872772,
0.3985430896282196,
0.16789548099040985,
-0.4384678900241852,
0.3741477131843567,
0.03561058267951012,
0.27784493565559387,
-0.3007466495037079,
0.4886193573474884,
0.11213244497776031,
-0.38615092635154724,
-0.17862096428871155,
0.2507566809654236,
-0.06749836355447769,
-0.06048445403575897,
0.025597620755434036,
0.7110754251480103,
-0.2378610521554947,
0.06067384406924248,
-0.06843873858451843,
0.4154675602912903,
0.16035149991512299,
0.3075599670410156,
-0.2894571125507355,
0.5187912583351135,
0.4372112452983856,
-0.14684519171714783,
-0.0005471698241308331,
0.4889962375164032,
-0.5972496271133423,
0.9803748726844788,
-0.567122757434845,
0.2144719809293747,
-0.12218305468559265,
0.40245726704597473,
-0.9510314464569092,
-0.33387160301208496,
0.03846965357661247,
-0.11744558811187744,
0.14038866758346558,
-0.10187193006277084,
-0.7811715602874756,
-0.3950064480304718,
-0.44099557399749756,
0.3995262086391449,
0.30300575494766235,
-0.7250422835350037,
0.3391192853450775,
0.5666250586509705,
-0.20835566520690918,
-0.22648827731609344,
-0.3394332528114319,
-0.031685419380664825,
0.13349609076976776,
-0.5680775046348572,
0.741502583026886,
0.05086791142821312,
-0.21748323738574982,
0.3320520520210266,
-0.0961095467209816,
-0.07505589723587036,
0.030183523893356323,
0.5616468787193298,
0.15289825201034546,
0.16601970791816711,
-0.03486017510294914,
-0.14862942695617676,
-0.04686889424920082,
0.18113769590854645,
-0.22195547819137573,
0.6126338839530945,
-0.31396520137786865,
-0.6325671672821045,
-0.05369105935096741,
0.22931905090808868,
0.28050628304481506,
-0.4583204984664917,
0.36044225096702576,
0.8343803286552429,
-0.45788800716400146,
-0.05185823515057564,
-0.3344351053237915,
-0.03284437209367752,
-0.4214209318161011,
0.24568845331668854,
-0.12800706923007965,
-0.6112769842147827,
0.4201239049434662,
-0.4414660334587097,
0.4352857172489166,
0.5264334678649902,
0.21620123088359833,
-0.06258505582809448,
0.9743965864181519,
0.18055394291877747,
-0.39792394638061523,
0.3025931417942047,
-0.23625445365905762,
-0.035655807703733444,
-0.9373916387557983,
-0.3234711289405823,
-1.0118203163146973,
-0.5824053883552551,
-0.22085359692573547,
-0.27261120080947876,
0.2492338865995407,
0.13611558079719543,
-0.3746028244495392,
0.126085102558136,
-0.6615363359451294,
0.5487561225891113,
0.7220698595046997,
0.028385477140545845,
0.36708247661590576,
-0.012598023749887943,
-0.02613290399312973,
0.16326504945755005,
-0.2547655403614044,
-0.4755079448223114,
1.1883262395858765,
0.1482638567686081,
0.6386719346046448,
-0.21101996302604675,
0.8986732959747314,
0.3005242347717285,
0.5213868618011475,
-0.21445709466934204,
0.5844385623931885,
-0.23426929116249084,
-0.6119653582572937,
-0.23727209866046906,
-0.40845903754234314,
-0.9823187589645386,
-0.005638355389237404,
-0.18100352585315704,
-1.0956612825393677,
0.1351301670074463,
-0.17714516818523407,
-0.13732483983039856,
0.36980950832366943,
-0.5151370167732239,
1.009509563446045,
-0.09379013627767563,
-0.4681006669998169,
-0.09183722734451294,
-0.3845123052597046,
-0.008875788189470768,
-0.14863820374011993,
0.4994773268699646,
-0.2879572808742523,
0.14816126227378845,
0.8143032193183899,
-0.4400872588157654,
0.7535836696624756,
-0.5431367754936218,
0.4740038216114044,
0.34218335151672363,
-0.13293012976646423,
0.6354641914367676,
0.1644516885280609,
-0.12659069895744324,
0.695916473865509,
0.023774011060595512,
-0.5145537853240967,
0.043060507625341415,
1.0700830221176147,
-0.911249041557312,
-0.2914125621318817,
-0.5619671940803528,
-0.3762953579425812,
-0.21253237128257751,
0.5759196877479553,
-0.07749471068382263,
0.09623947739601135,
-0.5269084572792053,
0.3153521716594696,
0.1291353553533554,
0.19747555255889893,
0.3153170347213745,
0.36429905891418457,
-0.38477402925491333,
-0.4320400655269623,
1.0125372409820557,
0.37305930256843567,
-0.2281082719564438,
0.0322728231549263,
0.08678174018859863,
-0.2542632520198822,
-0.8654351234436035,
-0.5061013102531433,
0.14894191920757294,
-0.6966531872749329,
-0.24198822677135468,
-0.5323441028594971,
0.059841349720954895,
-0.36152973771095276,
-0.18803280591964722,
-0.17228202521800995,
-0.21553374826908112,
-0.13995830714702606,
0.04885098710656166,
0.370087593793869,
0.6660733222961426,
0.265059232711792,
0.03319063037633896,
-0.5725659132003784,
0.21499094367027283,
0.09393975138664246,
0.9729706048965454,
-0.05358996242284775,
0.16211767494678497,
-0.24539290368556976,
-0.14086411893367767,
-0.4808254539966583,
-0.21153803169727325,
-0.10817278921604156,
0.4671834707260132,
0.6261856555938721,
0.3331632614135742,
0.21942606568336487,
0.6643003225326538,
-0.639548659324646,
0.5516027212142944,
0.008217007853090763,
-0.6104603409767151,
0.1861259937286377,
-0.4222125709056854,
0.3309013545513153,
1.164548397064209,
0.40509045124053955,
-0.1160905510187149,
-0.27234044671058655,
-0.40492668747901917,
-1.0986676216125488,
0.705778956413269,
0.09862805902957916,
-0.5320848226547241,
0.1185162141919136,
0.2999153137207031,
0.3994644284248352,
0.31661394238471985,
-0.4368031322956085,
-0.22398774325847626,
-0.30413296818733215,
-0.22112149000167847,
-0.0941457748413086,
0.3418043255805969,
-0.5994380116462708,
-0.09000208228826523,
0.5322128534317017,
-0.33197638392448425,
0.026495156809687614,
0.10384610295295715,
0.023347392678260803,
-0.38485243916511536,
0.12439722567796707,
-0.08084623515605927,
0.6574004292488098,
-0.6559429168701172,
-0.06089705973863602,
0.028211042284965515,
-0.3605843186378479,
-0.25801926851272583,
0.6713860034942627,
-0.36132562160491943,
-0.023370947688817978,
0.16705796122550964,
0.5155237913131714,
0.052430156618356705,
-0.8365208506584167,
0.24992400407791138,
0.014670669101178646,
-0.2511894404888153,
-0.28622910380363464,
0.09283597767353058,
0.04596132040023804,
0.05975043401122093,
0.5419098734855652,
0.15238799154758453,
0.20986665785312653,
-0.6826465725898743,
-0.06014993414282799,
0.48097798228263855,
-0.5665396451950073,
-0.17967426776885986,
0.7881195545196533,
0.1550840586423874,
-0.23540574312210083,
0.4646804928779602,
-0.38796842098236084,
-0.07211246341466904,
0.2252400517463684,
0.017874401062726974,
0.6833335757255554,
0.231284037232399,
0.06188473850488663,
0.22520071268081665,
-0.07063668966293335,
-0.15876920521259308,
0.2299242466688156,
0.22622881829738617,
-0.0915285125374794,
-0.2774259150028229,
-0.8149250149726868,
-0.4807075560092926,
-0.019399043172597885,
-0.7459802627563477,
0.4444543421268463,
-0.48804527521133423,
-0.18166543543338776,
0.5921931862831116,
0.11470977216959,
-0.7982820272445679,
-0.0136912502348423,
0.007116254884749651,
1.006890892982483,
-0.4506157636642456,
0.8212782144546509,
0.9842968583106995,
-0.26467400789260864,
0.10713927447795868,
-0.4408031404018402,
0.18946412205696106,
-0.689955472946167,
0.2262062132358551,
0.40745770931243896,
0.028459036722779274,
-0.10954216867685318,
-0.38286450505256653,
-0.5219169855117798,
1.2275166511535645,
0.14237557351589203,
-0.5946046710014343,
0.14538247883319855,
0.18864059448242188,
0.6051256060600281,
-0.4148541986942291,
0.19160620868206024,
0.6939468383789062,
0.8473706245422363,
-0.0933513417840004,
-0.5934704542160034,
0.18836157023906708,
-0.3620871901512146,
-0.36613157391548157,
0.7575873136520386,
-0.7368057370185852,
1.020909309387207,
0.21969835460186005,
-0.1544511914253235,
0.009385093115270138,
0.45980748534202576,
0.12299051135778427,
0.6305496096611023,
0.6208760142326355,
0.7892642617225647,
0.9761970043182373,
-0.4405568540096283,
1.0178362131118774,
-0.3449794054031372,
0.3152802884578705,
1.0870952606201172,
-0.858875036239624,
0.8668904900550842,
0.3073013722896576,
-0.36022669076919556,
0.8000112771987915,
0.5601152181625366,
-0.3695398271083832,
0.5600566267967224,
0.1884961724281311,
-0.058792226016521454,
-0.22469624876976013,
-0.6397323608398438,
-0.5054553747177124,
0.25566190481185913,
0.23589730262756348,
-0.06507030129432678,
-0.5419452786445618,
-0.29534655809402466,
-0.04960053786635399,
0.4080962836742401,
-0.5596870183944702,
0.6296699047088623,
-0.15922032296657562,
-0.6463903188705444,
0.43329694867134094,
0.13269111514091492,
0.2826232612133026,
-0.6571606397628784,
0.03405687212944031,
0.09634985774755478,
0.19070102274417877,
-0.3205047845840454,
-0.7715669274330139,
0.003659648122265935,
-0.04326801747083664,
0.019189933314919472,
-0.20343877375125885,
0.7731905579566956,
-0.2270822376012802,
-0.33198368549346924,
0.3342928886413574,
0.32442325353622437,
-0.04028236120939255,
-0.34832075238227844,
-0.42018622159957886,
-0.018234219402074814,
-0.40883517265319824,
-0.11325732618570328,
0.8633666634559631,
0.346726655960083,
-0.3599848747253418,
0.3356519043445587,
0.749935507774353,
0.04568653181195259,
-0.3833688795566559,
0.13299596309661865,
1.1534850597381592,
-0.5122179985046387,
-0.3968754708766937,
-0.6034370064735413,
0.26031821966171265,
-0.4957873523235321,
-0.3295827805995941,
0.4841826856136322,
0.6587239503860474,
0.958096444606781,
0.1321641057729721,
1.055416464805603,
-0.29090678691864014,
0.5798386335372925,
-0.05740068107843399,
0.8335039019584656,
-0.48324650526046753,
-0.18749535083770752,
-0.15439391136169434,
-0.9520725011825562,
-0.23885461688041687,
0.4276609420776367,
-0.3308463394641876,
-0.11717380583286285,
0.7023409605026245,
0.32866787910461426,
0.013333642855286598,
0.16783754527568817,
-0.28479626774787903,
0.08983614295721054,
0.4003690183162689,
0.4296031892299652,
0.22408054769039154,
-0.1728665679693222,
0.7962613701820374,
-0.18231311440467834,
-0.43025273084640503,
-0.5108098983764648,
-0.897831380367279,
-1.1837390661239624,
-0.4750659167766571,
-0.48695963621139526,
-0.2568748891353607,
-0.10798964649438858,
0.8106187582015991,
0.6711433529853821,
-0.8985278606414795,
-0.12290564179420471,
-0.24797354638576508,
-0.03574303537607193,
-0.5613425374031067,
-0.18241454660892487,
0.47652703523635864,
-0.30916979908943176,
-0.7289985418319702,
0.46277812123298645,
0.23816172778606415,
-0.23732024431228638,
-0.49853524565696716,
0.11484773457050323,
-0.42308714985847473,
-0.05855628848075867,
0.23771853744983673,
0.4926750659942627,
-0.20627674460411072,
-0.4037429392337799,
-0.17301027476787567,
-0.04370124265551567,
0.1616867035627365,
0.6171230673789978,
-0.6874160170555115,
0.636245846748352,
0.4287715256214142,
0.6848028302192688,
0.7338526844978333,
0.10484334081411362,
0.25702187418937683,
-1.0484474897384644,
-0.07211308926343918,
0.1126975491642952,
0.6511436104774475,
0.31457605957984924,
0.018123986199498177,
0.9832533001899719,
0.3729257583618164,
-0.6658774614334106,
-1.246921181678772,
-0.13029845058918,
-0.8811363577842712,
-0.36697638034820557,
0.6841368675231934,
-0.44190606474876404,
-0.42176637053489685,
-0.25465986132621765,
-0.28131619095802307,
-0.049274761229753494,
-0.6887543201446533,
1.1502585411071777,
0.9183608293533325,
-0.0480228066444397,
0.43306633830070496,
-0.527626097202301,
0.3648441433906555,
0.052795227617025375,
-1.0879286527633667,
0.24143840372562408,
0.40379098057746887,
-0.16074004769325256,
0.5265003442764282,
0.4452798068523407,
-0.11895822733640671,
0.14433366060256958,
-0.0627470538020134,
0.24370844662189484,
-0.5231154561042786,
-0.3431237041950226,
0.2529163062572479,
0.7472065687179565,
0.1770309954881668,
-0.029214954003691673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15809v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15809v1
|
Empowering Large Language Model Agents through Action Learning
| 2024-02-24T13:13:04 | 2024-02-24T13:13:04 |
Haiteng Zhao, Chang Ma, Guoyin Wang, Jing Su, Lingpeng Kong, Jingjing Xu, Zhi-Hong Deng, Hongxia Yang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Model (LLM) Agents have recently garnered increasing interest
yet they are limited in their ability to learn from trial and error, a key
element of intelligent behavior. In this work, we argue that the capacity to
learn new actions from experience is fundamental to the advancement of learning
in LLM agents. While humans naturally expand their action spaces and develop
skills through experiential learning, LLM agents typically operate within fixed
action spaces, limiting their potential for growth. To address these
challenges, our study explores open-action learning for language agents. We
introduce a framework LearnAct with an iterative learning strategy to create
and improve actions in the form of Python functions. In each iteration, LLM
revises and updates the currently available actions based on the errors
identified in unsuccessful training tasks, thereby enhancing action
effectiveness. Our experimental evaluations across Robotic Planning and
Alfworld environments reveal that after learning on a few training task
instances, our approach to open-action learning markedly improves agent
performance for the type of task (by 32 percent in AlfWorld compared to
ReAct+Reflexion, for instance) highlighting the importance of experiential
action learning in the development of more intelligent LLM agents.
|
[
0.2972263991832733,
-0.744367778301239,
0.4962753355503082,
-0.059814758598804474,
0.23577305674552917,
0.2241639345884323,
-0.42854049801826477,
-0.038896843791007996,
0.18111810088157654,
0.42974528670310974,
-0.4699050486087799,
-0.4493817687034607,
-0.43880149722099304,
-0.16719800233840942,
0.03204547241330147,
0.817604660987854,
-0.29066675901412964,
-0.1296762377023697,
0.00572917191311717,
-0.34962406754493713,
-0.3318370282649994,
-0.19340910017490387,
-0.9744604229927063,
-0.6246951818466187,
0.6298060417175293,
0.4868454933166504,
0.6917822360992432,
0.3798481523990631,
0.33049437403678894,
0.4377334713935852,
0.18458950519561768,
0.3804456293582916,
-0.5537016987800598,
0.09859474748373032,
-0.4771338105201721,
-0.5477166771888733,
-0.36781251430511475,
-0.12280142307281494,
0.8045572638511658,
0.6969558596611023,
-0.5205803513526917,
-0.1912849396467209,
-0.08929502964019775,
0.6615077257156372,
-0.45269620418548584,
0.6532745361328125,
-0.3429153561592102,
0.1770658791065216,
0.27129802107810974,
-0.0814298465847969,
-0.38449954986572266,
-0.13133127987384796,
-0.05615456774830818,
-0.7226757407188416,
-0.0824846550822258,
0.022345256060361862,
0.3904179334640503,
0.3369479477405548,
-0.1707492619752884,
-0.37245193123817444,
-0.9675261974334717,
0.6678159236907959,
-0.6352238059043884,
0.2613661587238312,
0.17962777614593506,
0.3293451964855194,
-0.44666939973831177,
-0.6696386933326721,
-0.6437291502952576,
-0.3654458820819855,
0.1141337901353836,
0.0057817380875349045,
0.01725480891764164,
0.09877890348434448,
0.43278929591178894,
0.043079767376184464,
-0.4354931712150574,
0.29595357179641724,
-0.23846867680549622,
0.03012092411518097,
0.5100340247154236,
0.21479815244674683,
0.29161885380744934,
0.3152909278869629,
-0.2599550187587738,
-0.6330227851867676,
-0.7250056862831116,
0.3976699709892273,
0.30290937423706055,
0.5436149835586548,
-0.017003366723656654,
0.6104737520217896,
-0.19610784947872162,
0.3772653639316559,
-0.43014806509017944,
-0.13659554719924927,
0.08537761867046356,
0.18059852719306946,
-0.4622329771518707,
-0.17969295382499695,
0.4977359175682068,
-0.12234096974134445,
0.20998945832252502,
-0.13693773746490479,
-0.3904593586921692,
-0.33148762583732605,
0.5888558626174927,
-0.5824494361877441,
0.04627411440014839,
0.415800541639328,
-0.07637222111225128,
-0.004391241353005171,
0.24064254760742188,
-0.44310516119003296,
-0.6904993057250977,
-0.2451367974281311,
0.6934723258018494,
-0.6446806192398071,
-0.4377897083759308,
0.22946971654891968,
-0.08717215061187744,
0.4798005223274231,
0.6177362203598022,
-0.7224830389022827,
0.3449302315711975,
0.7337258458137512,
0.5562027096748352,
0.10833027958869934,
-0.8063733577728271,
-0.9019415378570557,
0.11438753455877304,
-0.7181333303451538,
0.6472609043121338,
-0.5906518697738647,
-0.12170354276895523,
0.3488042950630188,
-0.07512456923723221,
-0.37144872546195984,
-0.6997280120849609,
0.10848014801740646,
-0.6341826319694519,
-0.23125578463077545,
0.02877676859498024,
-0.4195782244205475,
-0.5623294115066528,
0.35984641313552856,
-0.6570966839790344,
0.6866000890731812,
0.44328030943870544,
0.025774572044610977,
0.4873240292072296,
-1.1580784320831299,
-0.4554676413536072,
0.0844695121049881,
-0.21113638579845428,
-0.27855655550956726,
0.2546084523200989,
-0.11884865164756775,
0.4395247995853424,
0.10872336477041245,
-0.039793286472558975,
-0.31419286131858826,
-0.17995235323905945,
0.41388043761253357,
-0.13629493117332458,
0.43760010600090027,
-0.12930946052074432,
-0.3593082129955292,
0.4629318416118622,
-0.37337908148765564,
0.11046243458986282,
0.22953954339027405,
-0.6738389134407043,
-0.14840461313724518,
0.2580423057079315,
-0.4361748695373535,
0.25902989506721497,
-0.09877582639455795,
-0.3204874098300934,
0.4527271091938019,
-0.5464195013046265,
0.17074929177761078,
0.8573831915855408,
-0.10705182701349258,
0.5817565321922302,
-0.37063726782798767,
0.4879990816116333,
-0.0711173340678215,
0.017979418858885765,
-0.4330170750617981,
-0.04962177202105522,
-0.7972494959831238,
-0.19654050469398499,
-0.02900645136833191,
0.24909484386444092,
-0.975354015827179,
0.2281079888343811,
-0.19901828467845917,
-0.37451428174972534,
-0.17967095971107483,
0.4929449260234833,
0.27096202969551086,
0.09702961891889572,
0.15079201757907867,
-0.4022838771343231,
-0.19648057222366333,
-0.2061898410320282,
-0.23627471923828125,
-0.3208307921886444,
0.2974463403224945,
0.4448900520801544,
0.7468565702438354,
-0.21576698124408722,
0.7897560000419617,
-0.35921040177345276,
-0.4189453125,
-0.6519070267677307,
0.1434539407491684,
0.09544149786233902,
0.28794291615486145,
0.2827047109603882,
-0.7570750117301941,
-0.2804988920688629,
0.25304877758026123,
-0.8814221024513245,
0.36899545788764954,
-0.18160629272460938,
0.07374441623687744,
0.34232285618782043,
0.5582670569419861,
-0.623386800289154,
0.4946005940437317,
0.31756535172462463,
-0.4371410012245178,
0.22347930073738098,
-0.6589068174362183,
-0.07389049977064133,
-0.6592674851417542,
-0.0633196011185646,
-0.25562313199043274,
-0.1922082155942917,
-0.7450588941574097,
0.39496520161628723,
0.09193406999111176,
-0.23017755150794983,
-0.7803468704223633,
0.8921684622764587,
-0.4009701609611511,
-0.3339007496833801,
-0.42369672656059265,
0.10717997699975967,
-0.453971803188324,
0.9319021701812744,
0.29402586817741394,
0.41402527689933777,
0.6097695231437683,
-0.7820035219192505,
0.2670760452747345,
0.14960424602031708,
-0.21222609281539917,
0.11171750724315643,
-0.43376749753952026,
0.14657984673976898,
-0.06492478400468826,
0.1409168541431427,
-0.8124790191650391,
-0.5192885398864746,
0.2050248235464096,
-0.32060524821281433,
0.33531737327575684,
0.29630404710769653,
-0.48022347688674927,
-0.26102912425994873,
-0.24779146909713745,
-0.05463377386331558,
0.3597431480884552,
-0.6579426527023315,
1.0585635900497437,
0.05662110075354576,
-0.01563844084739685,
-0.6726392507553101,
-0.2683853507041931,
-0.1863945573568344,
-0.006746573373675346,
-0.3212583065032959,
-0.209737166762352,
0.02187151461839676,
-0.4691409468650818,
-0.12095541507005692,
-0.12785013020038605,
0.12253185361623764,
0.28173670172691345,
0.36695319414138794,
-0.1645958423614502,
-0.061587922275066376,
0.3702133297920227,
-0.15376371145248413,
0.021777816116809845,
-0.060010530054569244,
-0.31320372223854065,
0.7606085538864136,
-0.12667126953601837,
-0.6783918738365173,
-0.0746055617928505,
0.23241719603538513,
0.7136127352714539,
-0.3594522774219513,
0.8193554282188416,
0.1840260922908783,
-0.3127131760120392,
-0.6424318552017212,
-0.0057226382195949554,
-0.11703455448150635,
-0.4893842041492462,
0.5921983122825623,
0.03880609571933746,
-0.741998553276062,
0.25339871644973755,
-0.5071455836296082,
0.466560959815979,
-0.0316578671336174,
0.4551415741443634,
-0.18875230848789215,
0.6995581984519958,
1.1418758630752563,
0.12166129797697067,
0.7144264578819275,
-0.4434024691581726,
0.22002309560775757,
-0.7011415958404541,
-0.2792983949184418,
-0.25778689980506897,
-0.4569511413574219,
-0.10805945098400116,
-0.8514036536216736,
0.17885902523994446,
0.04137152433395386,
-0.6076216697692871,
0.23500873148441315,
0.24931718409061432,
0.3085361123085022,
0.47588393092155457,
0.15934151411056519,
0.12597055733203888,
0.13540728390216827,
-0.03269234299659729,
0.18129558861255646,
-0.6182756423950195,
-0.49378836154937744,
1.1113985776901245,
0.3525792360305786,
0.8271358013153076,
0.5191895961761475,
0.8064406514167786,
0.32654377818107605,
0.4753555953502655,
-1.0707249641418457,
0.5812321901321411,
0.20572112500667572,
-0.08130782097578049,
-0.7179473638534546,
-0.09591454267501831,
-1.0429701805114746,
0.21854932606220245,
-0.08667177706956863,
-0.5992324948310852,
-0.03819166496396065,
0.11171887069940567,
-0.277517169713974,
0.37762102484703064,
-0.5634918212890625,
0.671248197555542,
-0.3884747326374054,
-0.4183102548122406,
-0.5307384133338928,
-0.29697057604789734,
-0.15261581540107727,
-0.028318671509623528,
0.1970396190881729,
0.15303421020507812,
-0.4680381715297699,
0.4686625599861145,
-0.3577534556388855,
1.200414776802063,
-0.36757388710975647,
-0.41678130626678467,
0.30058056116104126,
0.14780430495738983,
0.8778352737426758,
-0.27129051089286804,
-0.06684858351945877,
-0.288086473941803,
-0.880153238773346,
-0.3963540196418762,
-0.8999497890472412,
0.26161351799964905,
-0.777012050151825,
-0.5952967405319214,
-0.3454229235649109,
-0.605787456035614,
-0.3133176565170288,
0.19193649291992188,
-0.44143983721733093,
0.34423327445983887,
-0.37187594175338745,
0.28530290722846985,
0.7919431924819946,
-0.42697569727897644,
0.8815504312515259,
1.1099247932434082,
-0.38993167877197266,
-0.3978818953037262,
0.8001469969749451,
-0.040001437067985535,
0.4697945713996887,
0.528411328792572,
0.12131195515394211,
-0.13733471930027008,
-0.5545400977134705,
-0.15393275022506714,
0.4321241080760956,
-0.7345964908599854,
-0.0022342747543007135,
-0.5668843984603882,
0.022077389061450958,
-0.39237672090530396,
-0.1817430555820465,
-0.31840699911117554,
-0.07564544677734375,
-0.05296187475323677,
-0.15700069069862366,
0.25401678681373596,
0.7716944217681885,
-0.21801859140396118,
0.4809087812900543,
-0.4794754683971405,
0.1589941829442978,
0.42592787742614746,
0.18870994448661804,
0.10707714408636093,
-0.40480053424835205,
-0.33780208230018616,
-0.030620792880654335,
-0.5065211653709412,
-0.44688746333122253,
0.5860597491264343,
0.4937618374824524,
0.707725465297699,
0.5643194913864136,
0.028976960107684135,
0.42945271730422974,
-0.45368269085884094,
0.6564855575561523,
0.11242130398750305,
-0.5892015099525452,
0.6257700324058533,
-0.3188827633857727,
0.2779569923877716,
0.11787571012973785,
0.37242311239242554,
-0.5715386867523193,
-0.3748704195022583,
-0.838746964931488,
-0.8523035049438477,
0.9435279965400696,
-0.040426209568977356,
0.3173002302646637,
0.19780151546001434,
0.2068207859992981,
0.11405491083860397,
0.4180489182472229,
-0.7864733934402466,
0.050353243947029114,
0.08517342805862427,
-0.004070814233273268,
-0.3678078353404999,
0.24921569228172302,
-0.3099609613418579,
-0.06756231933832169,
0.6544877886772156,
-0.7212417721748352,
0.2941312789916992,
0.07296324521303177,
-0.30483949184417725,
-0.2464756816625595,
0.24268969893455505,
0.5682227611541748,
0.5618993639945984,
0.22532060742378235,
-0.10346006602048874,
0.15183581411838531,
-0.4180561900138855,
0.06712860614061356,
-0.14765778183937073,
0.25347328186035156,
-0.5364072918891907,
0.6926167607307434,
0.9222024083137512,
0.27516311407089233,
-1.243614912033081,
0.5439520478248596,
0.07517675310373306,
-0.1698492467403412,
-0.5380614995956421,
0.6250622272491455,
0.018100952729582787,
0.7248134613037109,
0.3715614378452301,
0.02473289519548416,
-0.30336517095565796,
-0.9621187448501587,
0.2021457850933075,
0.2819606065750122,
-0.6023862957954407,
-0.15510322153568268,
0.13883663713932037,
0.04510285332798958,
-0.7554560899734497,
0.5985669493675232,
-0.20817403495311737,
-0.490709125995636,
0.802182674407959,
0.5987867712974548,
0.9205159544944763,
-0.25908419489860535,
0.4437558948993683,
0.23034948110580444,
0.42087748646736145,
-0.21625353395938873,
0.3072449266910553,
-0.2519945800304413,
-0.8638001680374146,
-0.44991275668144226,
-0.561292290687561,
-0.6870911121368408,
0.1027679443359375,
-0.3817456066608429,
0.25433674454689026,
-0.7020272016525269,
0.4163949191570282,
-0.6088520288467407,
0.13739219307899475,
-0.5353310108184814,
0.16892965137958527,
-0.02776445634663105,
0.9960132837295532,
-0.8453521132469177,
0.8976083397865295,
1.0738458633422852,
-0.4569310247898102,
-1.1071288585662842,
0.18011194467544556,
-0.14616507291793823,
-0.8861159682273865,
0.7849161624908447,
0.2694433927536011,
-0.0337706059217453,
-0.04130679741501808,
-0.6621170043945312,
-0.832886815071106,
1.2238863706588745,
0.22861142456531525,
-0.36310631036758423,
0.030330203473567963,
0.038860879838466644,
0.6683629155158997,
-0.49688422679901123,
0.21281203627586365,
0.3364214301109314,
0.24375253915786743,
0.06858024001121521,
-0.5374863743782043,
-0.048787232488393784,
-0.0644853264093399,
-0.15779660642147064,
0.2896915078163147,
-0.8536583185195923,
0.8456689715385437,
-0.7379056215286255,
-0.17849643528461456,
0.00553876394405961,
0.8760377168655396,
0.30831626057624817,
0.277384877204895,
0.5020438432693481,
0.48228904604911804,
0.8973718881607056,
0.050627369433641434,
0.9770949482917786,
0.2690373957157135,
0.3415035903453827,
1.148975133895874,
-0.641693115234375,
1.1339093446731567,
0.32410216331481934,
0.051054440438747406,
0.6217606663703918,
0.26036307215690613,
0.3622938394546509,
0.5255656242370605,
0.1164277195930481,
-0.3510875999927521,
-0.3229708671569824,
0.26396846771240234,
0.37199002504348755,
0.5611936450004578,
0.6069363355636597,
-0.2871195077896118,
-0.4548625648021698,
0.4431705176830292,
-0.006199403200298548,
0.22369186580181122,
-0.5147984027862549,
0.8776983618736267,
-0.09424522519111633,
-0.7205849885940552,
0.17446894943714142,
-0.31022700667381287,
0.2651192843914032,
-0.8446107506752014,
-0.5204084515571594,
-0.15939348936080933,
0.5442138314247131,
-0.024510415270924568,
-0.6564337015151978,
0.1269615888595581,
-0.16928325593471527,
0.18205539882183075,
-0.2565120756626129,
0.577724277973175,
-0.34619995951652527,
0.1013595312833786,
0.5883566737174988,
0.5029820203781128,
0.18777278065681458,
0.05016282573342323,
-0.5575891137123108,
-0.06526997685432434,
-0.09068804979324341,
-0.41195520758628845,
0.46009084582328796,
0.4922964870929718,
-0.15059317648410797,
1.0394710302352905,
0.4380601644515991,
0.23748630285263062,
-0.20987309515476227,
-0.27774032950401306,
0.8785267472267151,
-0.7009651064872742,
-0.30168119072914124,
-0.6193618774414062,
0.6571118235588074,
-0.10492675751447678,
-0.1477985382080078,
0.3940962553024292,
0.19428806006908417,
0.9691761136054993,
-0.07498575001955032,
0.8460766673088074,
-0.3452766537666321,
0.32419925928115845,
-0.5925495028495789,
0.564121425151825,
-0.5405979752540588,
0.20055407285690308,
-0.022827880457043648,
-0.6543372869491577,
-0.1401013880968094,
0.5540723204612732,
-0.2919652760028839,
0.064170703291893,
0.8658568859100342,
0.880138099193573,
0.0993371456861496,
-0.21242693066596985,
0.6761460304260254,
0.31144678592681885,
0.5923528075218201,
0.5379462838172913,
0.7897841334342957,
-0.2960362434387207,
0.4095817506313324,
-0.062021635472774506,
-0.39764776825904846,
-0.1309216022491455,
-0.7815586924552917,
-0.9533559083938599,
-0.479328989982605,
-0.25911375880241394,
-0.21461139619350433,
-0.02554456703364849,
1.2745524644851685,
0.40483108162879944,
-0.5879880785942078,
-0.3899035155773163,
-0.2090354859828949,
0.248332217335701,
-0.8415423631668091,
-0.14788313210010529,
0.25899049639701843,
-0.7069015502929688,
-0.9059470295906067,
0.546216607093811,
0.36732593178749084,
-0.09917674213647842,
-0.17592968046665192,
-0.5627045631408691,
-0.17201003432273865,
0.10686971247196198,
0.6802875399589539,
0.9014615416526794,
-0.5163949728012085,
-0.21141570806503296,
-0.10948123037815094,
0.10409195721149445,
-0.04296048358082771,
1.0703171491622925,
-0.780625581741333,
0.32218897342681885,
0.16880030930042267,
0.8774961829185486,
0.1157534047961235,
-0.3805525004863739,
0.7010535001754761,
-0.6517414450645447,
0.10249976068735123,
0.12227752059698105,
0.3654439449310303,
0.1753174066543579,
-0.21914376318454742,
0.6493951678276062,
0.06183571740984917,
-0.42347925901412964,
-0.6558045148849487,
0.11511155217885971,
-0.7078713774681091,
-0.3041662573814392,
1.378799557685852,
-0.3750198483467102,
-0.5541124939918518,
0.044871143996715546,
-0.43164849281311035,
0.22028882801532745,
-0.48695799708366394,
0.5609084963798523,
0.4355664849281311,
-0.3565746545791626,
-0.15504369139671326,
-0.47128692269325256,
0.4329026937484741,
0.16688619554042816,
-1.0308760404586792,
0.45454761385917664,
0.3601020872592926,
0.0596211701631546,
0.24322539567947388,
0.6016333699226379,
0.09533997625112534,
0.5238916277885437,
-0.047954756766557693,
0.20427638292312622,
-0.1235814020037651,
-0.8041836023330688,
-0.6151594519615173,
0.19293886423110962,
0.37023594975471497,
0.006736946292221546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00807v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00807v1
|
Enhancing Cloud-Based Large Language Model Processing with Elasticsearch and Transformer Models
| 2024-02-24T12:31:22 | 2024-02-24T12:31:22 |
Chunhe Ni, Jiang Wu, Hongbo Wang, Wenran Lu, Chenwei Zhang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.DC, cs.DL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are a class of generative AI models built using
the Transformer network, capable of leveraging vast datasets to identify,
summarize, translate, predict, and generate language. LLMs promise to
revolutionize society, yet training these foundational models poses immense
challenges. Semantic vector search within large language models is a potent
technique that can significantly enhance search result accuracy and relevance.
Unlike traditional keyword-based search methods, semantic search utilizes the
meaning and context of words to grasp the intent behind queries and deliver
more precise outcomes. Elasticsearch emerges as one of the most popular tools
for implementing semantic search an exceptionally scalable and robust search
engine designed for indexing and searching extensive datasets. In this article,
we delve into the fundamentals of semantic search and explore how to harness
Elasticsearch and Transformer models to bolster large language model processing
paradigms. We gain a comprehensive understanding of semantic search principles
and acquire practical skills for implementing semantic search in real-world
model application scenarios.
|
[
-0.40622395277023315,
-0.8084519505500793,
0.9073852896690369,
-0.022398188710212708,
-0.03553871437907219,
0.12839332222938538,
-0.27103134989738464,
-0.5229255557060242,
0.21181517839431763,
0.8503045439720154,
-0.7843638062477112,
-0.6205264329910278,
-0.7197384238243103,
0.15156780183315277,
-0.9040309190750122,
0.36007189750671387,
-0.0036209160462021828,
0.1034286841750145,
-0.23412543535232544,
0.1301826685667038,
-0.3519556522369385,
-0.51181960105896,
-0.5677140951156616,
-0.29792577028274536,
0.3795260488986969,
0.23337893187999725,
1.0195162296295166,
0.8460001945495605,
0.5552139282226562,
0.40949469804763794,
-0.37177717685699463,
0.006178546696901321,
-0.6082863807678223,
0.6792914271354675,
-0.2607247531414032,
-0.7594017386436462,
0.05083887279033661,
-0.25223326683044434,
0.666126549243927,
0.5182931423187256,
-0.22841647267341614,
-0.12062529474496841,
-0.4239750802516937,
0.42730456590652466,
-0.5246367454528809,
0.3030955493450165,
-1.274067759513855,
-0.01704496517777443,
-0.3810618817806244,
-0.23007832467556,
-0.16313889622688293,
0.06903155893087387,
0.15933464467525482,
-0.573060929775238,
0.5716953277587891,
-0.009117401205003262,
0.7031247615814209,
0.38467326760292053,
-0.47083884477615356,
-0.19675448536872864,
-0.7037184238433838,
0.8329086899757385,
-0.6588308811187744,
0.7468955516815186,
0.41154617071151733,
0.5202630162239075,
-0.5573897957801819,
-1.0789183378219604,
-0.5990932583808899,
-0.2355618178844452,
0.11948439478874207,
-0.19816365838050842,
0.08399440348148346,
0.21556058526039124,
0.1154928058385849,
0.4457339942455292,
-0.4387679398059845,
0.6012195944786072,
-0.26120057702064514,
-0.016773857176303864,
0.6069102883338928,
0.448211669921875,
0.3927842378616333,
-0.03977654501795769,
-0.11508969962596893,
-0.26994264125823975,
-0.7253773212432861,
-0.0812181681394577,
0.03846806660294533,
0.5072150230407715,
0.43961966037750244,
0.7697640657424927,
-0.3664076328277588,
0.7626053094863892,
-0.5195861458778381,
-0.06662479788064957,
-0.1152367889881134,
-0.19768936932086945,
-0.04829517751932144,
0.08514223247766495,
0.42010560631752014,
0.06935172528028488,
-0.1812361478805542,
-0.5364243984222412,
-0.6213741898536682,
0.3040533661842346,
0.6146040558815002,
-0.8117545247077942,
0.3644460439682007,
0.3498075306415558,
-0.4115454852581024,
-0.21208001673221588,
0.08522449433803558,
-0.6332595944404602,
-0.3025757372379303,
-0.5490323305130005,
0.10493151843547821,
-0.16003187000751495,
0.04349995031952858,
0.37037724256515503,
-0.2611630856990814,
0.6044846773147583,
0.2420729249715805,
-0.8263144493103027,
0.5089683532714844,
1.2265796661376953,
0.6535334587097168,
-0.019077293574810028,
-0.3671587407588959,
-0.5230341553688049,
0.08662671595811844,
-0.398775577545166,
0.725828230381012,
-0.8350016474723816,
-0.3953045606613159,
0.37548625469207764,
0.18821121752262115,
0.18333649635314941,
-0.4617317318916321,
0.9048055410385132,
-1.1478855609893799,
-0.017436491325497627,
0.09350728243589401,
-0.7918340563774109,
-0.3731767535209656,
0.13711941242218018,
-0.8502461910247803,
1.108352541923523,
-0.007786693517118692,
-0.36559855937957764,
0.2579600214958191,
-0.7048277258872986,
-0.4127653241157532,
0.5134015083312988,
-0.06184348464012146,
-0.28574737906455994,
0.4099702835083008,
0.4232866168022156,
0.7878092527389526,
-0.922800600528717,
0.24869602918624878,
-0.2924675941467285,
-0.356866717338562,
0.06672891974449158,
0.01637389324605465,
0.2202322781085968,
0.0499676913022995,
-0.40764281153678894,
0.08984124660491943,
-0.5599811673164368,
0.09328306466341019,
0.4931214451789856,
-0.06560651957988739,
-0.47238877415657043,
0.4251553416252136,
0.3856469690799713,
0.17556250095367432,
0.3546753525733948,
-0.4290928840637207,
0.0908253863453865,
-0.5585569739341736,
0.7655654549598694,
0.37222012877464294,
-0.4133172929286957,
0.3680643141269684,
0.041124895215034485,
0.4850732386112213,
-0.16097411513328552,
0.06751599162817001,
-0.2649211287498474,
-0.2861223816871643,
-0.7345965504646301,
-0.10779503732919693,
0.16209439933300018,
0.3475482165813446,
-0.6159648895263672,
0.6546550989151001,
-0.5149475932121277,
-0.7543448805809021,
-0.9198780059814453,
0.292288601398468,
-0.21514858305454254,
0.16953714191913605,
0.3791603446006775,
0.14404907822608948,
-0.5447736382484436,
-0.9477331042289734,
-0.10945942252874374,
0.31289294362068176,
-0.1852821260690689,
0.3187207579612732,
0.39195188879966736,
-0.8357709050178528,
0.9207631349563599,
-0.6391979455947876,
-0.4815632104873657,
-0.22428639233112335,
-0.10164986550807953,
0.24084065854549408,
-0.03156425058841705,
0.2582332491874695,
-1.3623943328857422,
-0.033056918531656265,
0.006431603338569403,
-0.5085456371307373,
0.03700670599937439,
0.3108236789703369,
-0.034117087721824646,
0.07091866433620453,
0.8329814672470093,
-0.6889081001281738,
0.24301618337631226,
0.5970263481140137,
-0.19436956942081451,
0.08593621850013733,
-0.22180579602718353,
-0.07129424065351486,
-1.021866798400879,
0.015706267207860947,
-0.15244415402412415,
-0.370048850774765,
-0.34078821539878845,
0.6570108532905579,
-0.009466989897191525,
-0.26273781061172485,
-0.47381141781806946,
0.4489140510559082,
-0.31023818254470825,
-0.2331342101097107,
-0.5272165536880493,
0.3392639458179474,
-0.04614115506410599,
-0.13479937613010406,
0.16760428249835968,
0.8704084753990173,
0.7053846120834351,
-0.7980624437332153,
0.7326529622077942,
0.3334839642047882,
-0.41447901725769043,
0.17897838354110718,
-0.8261117339134216,
0.05914650112390518,
-0.3532950282096863,
0.4173698127269745,
-0.8177656531333923,
-0.1993502974510193,
-0.7618848085403442,
-0.0707160234451294,
-0.0008048771996982396,
0.03190956264734268,
-0.8194441199302673,
-0.5606806874275208,
-0.2853231430053711,
0.15577882528305054,
0.3994676470756531,
-0.8135293126106262,
0.832563579082489,
0.6468673944473267,
-0.1743631660938263,
-0.42232614755630493,
-0.4634115695953369,
0.32574462890625,
-0.0650051087141037,
-0.8513574600219727,
0.8348023295402527,
0.3154403865337372,
-0.07698625326156616,
0.07391179352998734,
0.1280575841665268,
-0.1185406893491745,
0.4324339032173157,
0.13304199278354645,
0.3312396705150604,
-0.2296736091375351,
0.15609700977802277,
-0.20997826755046844,
-0.19043324887752533,
-0.06923728436231613,
-0.3855089843273163,
1.0176801681518555,
-0.1524229198694229,
-0.3282332718372345,
-0.09721022844314575,
0.4066166579723358,
0.9785534739494324,
-0.46817147731781006,
0.9407109022140503,
0.45267876982688904,
-0.45051902532577515,
-0.30074265599250793,
-0.7896219491958618,
-0.39221614599227905,
-0.4793164134025574,
0.5773811936378479,
-0.3889600336551666,
-1.2893836498260498,
0.6275217533111572,
-0.16111227869987488,
-0.16312505304813385,
0.7681950926780701,
0.7593941688537598,
0.05894271284341812,
1.2464405298233032,
0.8264659643173218,
-0.19898097217082977,
0.4683462083339691,
-0.1719343066215515,
0.35322487354278564,
-0.8905858993530273,
-0.2025614082813263,
-0.835706889629364,
-0.1052030399441719,
-1.0104490518569946,
-0.40367749333381653,
0.3808671236038208,
-0.17539666593074799,
-0.23146674036979675,
0.4325585961341858,
-0.519566535949707,
0.5001733899116516,
0.5482451319694519,
-0.001235702889971435,
0.14387314021587372,
-0.03563345596194267,
0.028289565816521645,
-0.05490142107009888,
-0.514263927936554,
-0.35342708230018616,
0.8750388622283936,
0.39461037516593933,
0.8638671636581421,
-0.011503481306135654,
0.35214507579803467,
0.05542280524969101,
-0.19481882452964783,
-1.1667029857635498,
0.5321425795555115,
-0.26359349489212036,
-0.5080331563949585,
-0.5324597358703613,
-0.3373401165008545,
-1.2832913398742676,
0.4255425035953522,
-0.3069837689399719,
-0.41221553087234497,
-0.31356099247932434,
-0.341278076171875,
0.25085511803627014,
0.27837494015693665,
-0.21983946859836578,
0.6829782128334045,
-0.5699498653411865,
-0.09887231141328812,
-0.591654896736145,
-0.4682343900203705,
0.07987497746944427,
-0.22721196711063385,
0.11663423478603363,
0.046303924173116684,
-0.2714175581932068,
0.5147304534912109,
-0.31196916103363037,
0.47998157143592834,
0.2223057597875595,
-0.0497489757835865,
-0.039935167878866196,
0.11560055613517761,
0.8596130013465881,
-0.18398895859718323,
-0.049507804214954376,
0.24482208490371704,
-0.0027333570178598166,
-0.30317285656929016,
-0.5739336013793945,
0.7912359237670898,
-0.7348260283470154,
-0.7735339999198914,
-0.18226908147335052,
-0.4282015264034271,
-0.04657692089676857,
0.3543241620063782,
0.09137003123760223,
0.007476103026419878,
-0.3162771165370941,
0.5651150941848755,
0.7098444700241089,
-0.21429185569286346,
0.1692286878824234,
0.5617241263389587,
-0.4250295162200928,
-0.09425684064626694,
0.6630332469940186,
-0.018710685893893242,
-0.17453980445861816,
0.8043326139450073,
0.27927812933921814,
-0.6296827793121338,
-0.418481707572937,
-0.03401179984211922,
0.3661763668060303,
-0.7052001953125,
-0.13456237316131592,
-0.827582836151123,
-0.35681360960006714,
-0.48731037974357605,
-0.29968664050102234,
-0.5039867162704468,
-0.07929807901382446,
-0.14739377796649933,
-0.05352146923542023,
0.5363428592681885,
0.661188542842865,
0.7341574430465698,
0.37861594557762146,
-0.8314114809036255,
0.30844253301620483,
0.26915207505226135,
0.5291755795478821,
-0.042225420475006104,
-0.279264897108078,
-0.06344964355230331,
-0.058191169053316116,
-0.045568499714136124,
-0.444907546043396,
0.5787896513938904,
-0.006194358691573143,
0.7317876815795898,
-0.02256637252867222,
-0.19944782555103302,
0.5841037631034851,
-0.6470248103141785,
0.8576868176460266,
-0.1229560524225235,
-0.9722484350204468,
0.5808250904083252,
-0.30555158853530884,
0.13530854880809784,
0.3604700267314911,
0.39598122239112854,
-0.8112730383872986,
-0.19161370396614075,
-0.6657958030700684,
-1.312575101852417,
0.6831825375556946,
0.08825190365314484,
0.2912304699420929,
0.2334980070590973,
0.328702837228775,
-0.14495949447155,
0.23492203652858734,
-0.36643877625465393,
0.030553363263607025,
0.02670576423406601,
-0.13603830337524414,
-0.3479323089122772,
-0.3277720808982849,
-0.0016785116167739034,
-0.11464107036590576,
0.6907358765602112,
-0.2046610563993454,
0.13386070728302002,
-0.09757910668849945,
-0.21636056900024414,
0.11928563565015793,
0.17588339745998383,
0.3509325385093689,
0.3049466907978058,
-0.014945429749786854,
0.11972389370203018,
0.10394540429115295,
-0.262709379196167,
-0.03608523681759834,
0.1602456271648407,
-0.09875989705324173,
0.00820292066782713,
0.14459502696990967,
0.933113157749176,
0.3151976466178894,
-1.0209338665008545,
0.5030801296234131,
-0.1995820552110672,
0.06476668268442154,
-0.674665629863739,
0.1084163635969162,
0.3800056278705597,
0.19027285277843475,
0.3634490668773651,
-0.6457065939903259,
0.35415732860565186,
-0.3598187267780304,
0.07925175130367279,
0.7127832174301147,
-0.03157297149300575,
-0.02042955346405506,
0.7911946773529053,
-0.053288012742996216,
-0.3614673316478729,
0.9116480350494385,
0.4312666654586792,
-0.8619248270988464,
0.6258562207221985,
0.6350720524787903,
0.9951783418655396,
-0.1801665872335434,
-0.08131168782711029,
-0.17232646048069,
0.3299652934074402,
-0.3978646993637085,
0.010137164033949375,
-0.09730885922908783,
-0.7523758411407471,
-0.522435188293457,
-0.8386172652244568,
-0.5459707379341125,
0.3525109887123108,
-0.38474130630493164,
0.6269126534461975,
-0.18458683788776398,
0.04119570553302765,
0.18500283360481262,
-0.16337282955646515,
-0.9269952774047852,
0.1772545725107193,
0.2157389223575592,
1.1313152313232422,
-0.5760897994041443,
0.5654095411300659,
0.810941219329834,
-0.18999333679676056,
-0.574997067451477,
-0.2711118459701538,
-0.12681761384010315,
-0.9641470313072205,
0.8403683304786682,
0.11248660087585449,
-0.19325634837150574,
-0.10235798358917236,
-0.6227114200592041,
-1.102052092552185,
1.0996191501617432,
0.373093843460083,
-0.5631782412528992,
-0.07190051674842834,
0.39175084233283997,
0.7713510394096375,
-0.3521064519882202,
0.31955593824386597,
0.577482283115387,
0.34628307819366455,
0.2622082233428955,
-0.6956347227096558,
-0.0843745768070221,
0.03994181752204895,
0.7141366600990295,
0.35701367259025574,
-0.3791133165359497,
0.670577347278595,
0.4481985569000244,
-0.03304554894566536,
-0.17107424139976501,
0.6409111618995667,
0.08526905626058578,
-0.0007029882399365306,
0.38016900420188904,
0.5586007237434387,
0.7162205576896667,
-0.0502350814640522,
1.3081333637237549,
-0.5622010827064514,
0.27799147367477417,
0.7199501991271973,
-0.5464116334915161,
1.157981276512146,
0.3199898600578308,
0.014308873564004898,
0.16590499877929688,
0.5659099817276001,
0.019364923238754272,
0.2693893015384674,
0.15527178347110748,
-0.3446807861328125,
-0.40990275144577026,
-0.23686127364635468,
0.015285653062164783,
0.765752911567688,
0.590551495552063,
-0.3733375370502472,
-0.3750320374965668,
-0.12469460070133209,
-0.06916983425617218,
0.23837749660015106,
-0.4273848831653595,
0.8189124464988708,
0.0007602153345942497,
-0.5452523827552795,
0.40548083186149597,
0.4142664670944214,
0.7012199759483337,
-0.7309524416923523,
0.0302811898291111,
0.18246950209140778,
0.25094926357269287,
-0.19318249821662903,
-0.7213570475578308,
0.2790514826774597,
-0.20692065358161926,
-0.333953320980072,
-0.15552830696105957,
0.8287745118141174,
-0.375476211309433,
-0.5897656083106995,
0.6606066823005676,
0.30896642804145813,
-0.1091807559132576,
-0.26145321130752563,
-0.6701897382736206,
0.23177963495254517,
-0.5048058032989502,
-0.26572638750076294,
0.2892507314682007,
0.3816028833389282,
-0.1570342630147934,
0.847179651260376,
0.8515114784240723,
0.2280004620552063,
0.08608481287956238,
0.05326032266020775,
0.8435194492340088,
-0.844464123249054,
-0.585415244102478,
-0.717583954334259,
0.02454826980829239,
0.06432195007801056,
0.08194410055875778,
0.3920137882232666,
0.4960663616657257,
0.897128701210022,
0.009685314260423183,
0.7402791976928711,
0.1782977133989334,
0.5018466114997864,
-0.6463915109634399,
0.526544988155365,
-0.612553596496582,
0.15176677703857422,
0.04750118404626846,
-1.2255990505218506,
-0.44223952293395996,
0.6119769811630249,
-0.2713199257850647,
-0.11097845435142517,
0.3808910548686981,
1.018269658088684,
-0.20486003160476685,
0.08254589140415192,
0.5225703716278076,
0.29256048798561096,
0.6731895208358765,
0.10828684270381927,
0.812688946723938,
-0.3684907853603363,
0.1272304505109787,
0.06346774101257324,
0.036395639181137085,
-0.3902996778488159,
-0.8358793258666992,
-0.5188862681388855,
-0.8337907195091248,
0.14926636219024658,
-0.20568011701107025,
-0.24823537468910217,
0.9347302317619324,
0.6339054703712463,
-0.5285340547561646,
-0.2597396969795227,
-0.3496145009994507,
0.14868392050266266,
-0.06194944679737091,
-0.250932514667511,
0.2525652348995209,
-0.6872497797012329,
-0.8602835536003113,
0.66358882188797,
0.2282380312681198,
-0.13667885959148407,
-0.501436710357666,
0.10368132591247559,
-0.006133933085948229,
0.024948405101895332,
0.7023924589157104,
-0.02129020355641842,
-0.6663004755973816,
0.020516956225037575,
0.04004783183336258,
-0.24941490590572357,
-0.15834175050258636,
0.9590854644775391,
-0.8889374136924744,
0.41530293226242065,
0.5464820265769958,
1.2680591344833374,
0.7773651480674744,
-0.3496033251285553,
0.6281405091285706,
-0.24913185834884644,
0.25399303436279297,
0.29595839977264404,
0.5123445987701416,
0.46446192264556885,
-0.5210527181625366,
0.5157492756843567,
0.03725409135222435,
-0.5605835318565369,
-0.6901992559432983,
0.19126303493976593,
-0.8704947829246521,
-0.3520840108394623,
1.0815191268920898,
0.4180973768234253,
-0.4699264168739319,
0.0442657470703125,
-0.11432136595249176,
0.05885423347353935,
-0.1677055060863495,
0.7050521373748779,
0.6531279683113098,
0.1665324866771698,
-0.011610058136284351,
-0.6900709271430969,
0.15643252432346344,
0.36821746826171875,
-0.5739322304725647,
0.052601803094148636,
0.28864914178848267,
0.1205860897898674,
0.12229610979557037,
-0.07017482817173004,
-0.2503298819065094,
-0.027802279219031334,
-0.23636113107204437,
0.17220236361026764,
0.05582430213689804,
-0.12831921875476837,
-0.48302528262138367,
0.25409460067749023,
0.14769010245800018,
0.23532737791538239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00806v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00806v1
|
Enhanced User Interaction in Operating Systems through Machine Learning Language Models
| 2024-02-24T12:17:06 | 2024-02-24T12:17:06 |
Chenwei Zhang, Wenran Lu, Chunhe Ni, Hongbo Wang, Jiang Wu
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
With the large language model showing human-like logical reasoning and
understanding ability, whether agents based on the large language model can
simulate the interaction behavior of real users, so as to build a reliable
virtual recommendation A/B test scene to help the application of recommendation
research is an urgent, important and economic value problem. The combination of
interaction design and machine learning can provide a more efficient and
personalized user experience for products and services. This personalized
service can meet the specific needs of users and improve user satisfaction and
loyalty. Second, the interactive system can understand the user's views and
needs for the product by providing a good user interface and interactive
experience, and then use machine learning algorithms to improve and optimize
the product. This iterative optimization process can continuously improve the
quality and performance of the product to meet the changing needs of users. At
the same time, designers need to consider how these algorithms and tools can be
combined with interactive systems to provide a good user experience. This paper
explores the potential applications of large language models, machine learning
and interaction design for user interaction in recommendation systems and
operating systems. By integrating these technologies, more intelligent and
personalized services can be provided to meet user needs and promote continuous
improvement and optimization of products. This is of great value for both
recommendation research and user experience applications.
|
[
-0.5730350613594055,
-0.9242517948150635,
0.7137545347213745,
0.19584831595420837,
0.09636135399341583,
0.17309124767780304,
-0.11626387387514114,
-0.7594437599182129,
0.06796054542064667,
0.5871803760528564,
-0.578948974609375,
-0.0787879005074501,
-0.0033070435747504234,
-0.035035789012908936,
-0.13512147963047028,
0.7569257020950317,
-0.0458381287753582,
0.11503489315509796,
-0.4010230600833893,
0.02001405879855156,
-0.6762216091156006,
-0.9191747307777405,
-0.6736457347869873,
-0.5476749539375305,
0.3783543109893799,
0.210467129945755,
0.8055419325828552,
0.05237725377082825,
0.5565909743309021,
0.5155118107795715,
0.2224048525094986,
0.24992480874061584,
-0.23553331196308136,
0.35228413343429565,
-0.19516444206237793,
-0.22662203013896942,
-0.28679513931274414,
-0.11574654281139374,
0.4607447683811188,
0.8124794363975525,
-0.10119946300983429,
-0.3538919985294342,
0.073074109852314,
0.7328938841819763,
-0.38955771923065186,
0.24423809349536896,
0.06058630719780922,
0.12925463914871216,
0.32781660556793213,
-0.13069888949394226,
-0.4114895164966583,
-0.45104071497917175,
0.3783024549484253,
-0.9264978170394897,
-0.4148874282836914,
0.5044729709625244,
0.7281696200370789,
0.095536008477211,
-0.3004845678806305,
-0.4596438705921173,
-1.0017542839050293,
1.0854190587997437,
-0.713550865650177,
0.6490548849105835,
0.33126112818717957,
0.34265851974487305,
-0.542210042476654,
-0.46171659231185913,
-0.5992281436920166,
-0.7385583519935608,
-0.18319463729858398,
-0.27995529770851135,
-0.23998227715492249,
0.18993063271045685,
0.3583216965198517,
0.2817188799381256,
-0.23190423846244812,
0.27410417795181274,
-0.34768328070640564,
-0.1809673011302948,
0.6357558369636536,
0.1751263290643692,
0.5393086075782776,
0.35596829652786255,
-0.4485331177711487,
-0.3295063376426697,
-0.521350085735321,
0.3885033130645752,
0.4543757140636444,
0.18266282975673676,
0.1348859816789627,
0.5260276794433594,
-0.3643435537815094,
0.9109342098236084,
-0.18669842183589935,
-0.10373549163341522,
0.31554150581359863,
-0.3353695273399353,
-0.38027748465538025,
-0.12856735289096832,
0.7546124458312988,
0.44555774331092834,
0.5290365815162659,
-0.019121024757623672,
-0.17413097620010376,
0.04014686122536659,
0.24112768471240997,
-0.8518021106719971,
-0.04568030312657356,
0.14978934824466705,
-0.5275918841362,
-0.37124496698379517,
0.11688996851444244,
-0.464561402797699,
-0.4381488263607025,
-0.7746595144271851,
0.37186291813850403,
-0.48299264907836914,
-0.30009618401527405,
0.19837474822998047,
-0.263401597738266,
-0.3281755745410919,
0.5155801177024841,
-0.8359472155570984,
0.505723774433136,
0.6583299040794373,
0.4132975935935974,
-0.32122325897216797,
-0.3579404056072235,
-0.5674257278442383,
0.21167398989200592,
-0.2055892050266266,
0.602932870388031,
-0.8764755725860596,
-0.4806431233882904,
0.09498986601829529,
0.05988031253218651,
0.18315914273262024,
-0.5968663692474365,
0.32134225964546204,
-0.6612829566001892,
0.2745625972747803,
-0.16408012807369232,
-0.6291935443878174,
-0.48789259791374207,
0.07543137669563293,
-0.4282287359237671,
0.8747881054878235,
0.2824159562587738,
-0.37554630637168884,
0.29698291420936584,
-1.0660679340362549,
-0.6345869898796082,
0.11886622756719589,
0.12693649530410767,
-0.29586294293403625,
0.17090240120887756,
0.01858695223927498,
0.5287458896636963,
-0.14632534980773926,
0.17508096992969513,
-0.6828628778457642,
-0.4809187054634094,
0.5850721597671509,
0.03025439940392971,
0.5943424105644226,
0.5116317272186279,
0.02329792082309723,
0.35262900590896606,
-0.5101094841957092,
0.06187479570508003,
0.04011787846684456,
-0.5119725465774536,
-0.5432884097099304,
0.1678369790315628,
0.41675642132759094,
0.1050204262137413,
0.523695170879364,
-0.5531300902366638,
0.3511955142021179,
-0.2614487409591675,
0.47927629947662354,
0.5647090077400208,
-0.1252993494272232,
0.3148095905780792,
-0.09962745010852814,
0.4637422561645508,
0.20966920256614685,
0.06776516884565353,
-0.47624433040618896,
-0.42750000953674316,
-0.5236338973045349,
0.0738205835223198,
0.26029640436172485,
0.6937418580055237,
-0.8592710494995117,
0.40869393944740295,
0.3401387929916382,
-0.1185598224401474,
-0.44508498907089233,
0.3463345766067505,
0.3270226716995239,
0.3140142261981964,
0.11948408931493759,
-0.3280544579029083,
-0.8361971974372864,
-0.7034611701965332,
-0.1806354820728302,
-0.33744895458221436,
-0.20578457415103912,
0.6742824912071228,
0.12604375183582306,
-0.6252757906913757,
1.1032562255859375,
-0.5582093596458435,
0.005150839686393738,
-0.20657113194465637,
-0.2537490427494049,
0.16337448358535767,
0.2560846209526062,
0.47648128867149353,
-0.8049021363258362,
-0.4532014727592468,
0.4853432774543762,
-0.9587917327880859,
-0.06502746045589447,
0.23569217324256897,
0.08084463328123093,
0.3511626124382019,
0.2457188069820404,
-0.05607106536626816,
0.08911450207233429,
0.49222227931022644,
-0.49019068479537964,
0.5028936266899109,
-0.6895872354507446,
0.4225793182849884,
-0.93846595287323,
0.0004908200353384018,
0.5207186937332153,
-0.20058542490005493,
-0.690405547618866,
-0.05471999570727348,
-0.1259600818157196,
-0.3453870117664337,
-0.2331313043832779,
0.8223989009857178,
-0.20953580737113953,
-0.1745026558637619,
-0.5482162833213806,
-0.05346402898430824,
-0.05100267007946968,
0.34110283851623535,
-0.025022821500897408,
0.9464698433876038,
0.43501853942871094,
-0.6739187836647034,
0.5896497964859009,
0.1994638890028,
-0.526161789894104,
0.6214595437049866,
-0.6988884210586548,
-0.03566230088472366,
0.2108353227376938,
-0.05809682980179787,
-0.9519817233085632,
-0.2065788209438324,
0.08944886177778244,
-0.09171469509601593,
-0.03906439617276192,
0.16823910176753998,
-0.4846022129058838,
-0.5185460448265076,
-0.08515298366546631,
-0.05766110494732857,
0.5677799582481384,
-0.5880807042121887,
0.4498348534107208,
0.47057148814201355,
-0.3184928297996521,
-0.3580644726753235,
-0.28739815950393677,
0.13651655614376068,
-0.21195898950099945,
-0.8272749185562134,
0.09310837835073471,
-0.3477363884449005,
-0.4147137999534607,
-0.13341040909290314,
0.49689561128616333,
0.007067687343806028,
0.26307225227355957,
0.5531929731369019,
0.5714814066886902,
-0.29299870133399963,
0.21141774952411652,
0.041314613074064255,
-0.21567073464393616,
-0.16832230985164642,
-0.41748133301734924,
0.3851813077926636,
-0.4132884442806244,
-0.30018967390060425,
-0.866117000579834,
0.5161949992179871,
0.5799074769020081,
-0.0427132174372673,
0.6271182894706726,
0.6808156371116638,
-0.03624493628740311,
0.2179344892501831,
-0.7182992100715637,
-0.3095988929271698,
-0.5795055627822876,
0.3886936902999878,
-0.49055320024490356,
-1.1282421350479126,
0.14575700461864471,
-0.40628713369369507,
-0.04483846202492714,
0.06129823997616768,
0.6431251764297485,
-0.37285637855529785,
1.4560874700546265,
1.0130287408828735,
-0.3673819899559021,
0.9008525013923645,
0.06444235146045685,
0.544502317905426,
-0.70717453956604,
-0.17486260831356049,
-0.5299553871154785,
-0.19509784877300262,
-0.6174108386039734,
0.1861497014760971,
0.21412339806556702,
0.008754532784223557,
-0.2914692461490631,
0.31236034631729126,
-0.4930199384689331,
0.17130517959594727,
0.8411668539047241,
0.1913326382637024,
0.2191009521484375,
0.3291463255882263,
-0.35969868302345276,
0.027825133875012398,
-0.27628690004348755,
-0.5169281363487244,
0.679460883140564,
0.6153828501701355,
0.9727575182914734,
-0.16600200533866882,
0.21854650974273682,
0.7048791646957397,
0.04410912096500397,
-0.7800502777099609,
0.47781792283058167,
0.060631055384874344,
-0.2342408001422882,
-0.4891088306903839,
-0.41299882531166077,
-0.7598240971565247,
-0.08580101281404495,
-0.30664971470832825,
-0.9812206029891968,
0.24640972912311554,
0.22445765137672424,
-0.2806259095668793,
0.01591912843286991,
-1.0660065412521362,
0.6115009188652039,
-0.2559593617916107,
-0.5123552680015564,
-0.394991397857666,
-0.25924623012542725,
-0.05691366642713547,
0.143050417304039,
0.17210634052753448,
0.14584319293498993,
0.19469842314720154,
0.7765926122665405,
-0.2801440358161926,
0.6691606044769287,
-0.3177417516708374,
-0.012432441115379333,
0.009576326236128807,
0.05131404846906662,
0.519771158695221,
-0.39709872007369995,
-0.4230453372001648,
-0.04919186607003212,
0.18162979185581207,
-0.11319040507078171,
-0.528738796710968,
0.9830425381660461,
-0.9721606969833374,
-0.7289265394210815,
-0.13938413560390472,
-0.6176021695137024,
-0.23547667264938354,
0.2335422933101654,
-0.5549651980400085,
0.26614513993263245,
-0.33600902557373047,
0.2800543010234833,
0.4960879385471344,
-0.2883809208869934,
0.3902888596057892,
0.5167988538742065,
-0.6585604548454285,
-0.377288818359375,
1.1292717456817627,
-0.24226750433444977,
-0.09209581464529037,
0.24440525472164154,
0.3669697642326355,
-0.20495851337909698,
-0.4204292595386505,
-0.4623224139213562,
0.1141245886683464,
-0.3088224530220032,
0.25385627150535583,
-0.782479465007782,
-0.001708319177851081,
-0.3078344166278839,
-0.32977285981178284,
0.23228825628757477,
-0.24515414237976074,
-0.05920828878879547,
-0.019824618473649025,
0.39104166626930237,
0.9300733804702759,
0.11019740253686905,
0.5474398136138916,
-0.6136576533317566,
0.24213182926177979,
0.28513336181640625,
0.5082972645759583,
0.05586167797446251,
0.06717535108327866,
-0.5768752098083496,
-0.021240534260869026,
-0.4615364968776703,
-0.6015638113021851,
0.34481164813041687,
-0.08095203340053558,
0.8460285663604736,
0.9118212461471558,
-0.22354449331760406,
0.1725606471300125,
-0.34908527135849,
0.6180745959281921,
0.26928532123565674,
-0.7212216854095459,
0.3928329050540924,
-0.2729646861553192,
0.04037649184465408,
0.2962642014026642,
0.43813779950141907,
-0.7371178269386292,
0.18260961771011353,
-0.25998446345329285,
-0.40688881278038025,
0.8741808533668518,
-0.04806569591164589,
-0.011963620781898499,
0.44168800115585327,
0.18471792340278625,
0.07452104985713959,
0.39237841963768005,
-0.2979183793067932,
-0.10014817118644714,
0.13112416863441467,
-0.06055867671966553,
-0.31693875789642334,
-0.39827215671539307,
0.08331932127475739,
-0.21855467557907104,
0.9350301623344421,
-0.03972404822707176,
0.09283767640590668,
-0.25598007440567017,
0.19026504456996918,
-0.16500504314899445,
0.08141767233610153,
0.5550808906555176,
0.6243436932563782,
-0.18819750845432281,
-0.3601478636264801,
0.00463482178747654,
-0.19622257351875305,
0.12017156183719635,
-0.018656568601727486,
-0.03560753911733627,
-0.3990262448787689,
-0.1915077418088913,
0.9625246524810791,
0.05189038813114166,
-0.8167408108711243,
0.15233853459358215,
-0.2010277807712555,
0.2282935082912445,
-0.2583761513233185,
0.5166687369346619,
0.25571388006210327,
0.24991419911384583,
0.3503817319869995,
0.012909180484712124,
0.37518826127052307,
-0.9154574871063232,
0.014380931854248047,
0.5295902490615845,
-0.6969193816184998,
0.028949404135346413,
0.23289503157138824,
0.3843236565589905,
-0.8825220465660095,
0.6554189324378967,
0.29988276958465576,
-0.4714965224266052,
0.42388615012168884,
0.6712377071380615,
0.5793468952178955,
-0.4932181239128113,
0.018255069851875305,
0.06660251319408417,
-0.048793476074934006,
0.1451568454504013,
0.12038363516330719,
-0.3804662525653839,
-0.6362529397010803,
-0.29223179817199707,
-0.7280337810516357,
-0.7782106995582581,
-0.1455363631248474,
-0.24721316993236542,
0.43325573205947876,
-0.3543490767478943,
-0.13557042181491852,
0.17544998228549957,
0.33767884969711304,
-0.5780642032623291,
0.2991100251674652,
0.09714590013027191,
0.5699947476387024,
-0.849129319190979,
0.6492481827735901,
0.8939450979232788,
-0.2615002989768982,
-0.3087892532348633,
-0.4187469482421875,
-0.22573231160640717,
-0.5622991919517517,
0.694680392742157,
0.07986486703157425,
-0.18480712175369263,
-0.4242687225341797,
-0.33978626132011414,
-0.4417355954647064,
0.6437112092971802,
0.1566298007965088,
-0.5691195726394653,
0.03310272842645645,
0.12764987349510193,
0.6495339274406433,
-0.6827161312103271,
0.5364682674407959,
0.482002854347229,
0.7103323340415955,
0.19419164955615997,
-0.8006321787834167,
-0.027682660147547722,
-0.48602235317230225,
0.4157133102416992,
0.24792015552520752,
-0.3182562589645386,
0.45774441957473755,
-0.1780615746974945,
0.25638189911842346,
0.1024269312620163,
0.6227631568908691,
0.3783039152622223,
0.6224697232246399,
0.4653041660785675,
0.3615441620349884,
0.6376481652259827,
0.024862637743353844,
1.2965304851531982,
-0.23467768728733063,
0.022800838574767113,
0.7530452609062195,
-0.4662112295627594,
0.8479257225990295,
0.48865076899528503,
-0.4301847517490387,
0.6728418469429016,
0.774037778377533,
0.02087877131998539,
0.4052155911922455,
0.06769251823425293,
-0.3537500500679016,
-0.2541269063949585,
-0.22656291723251343,
-0.39495110511779785,
-0.04643208160996437,
0.5451360940933228,
-0.36413076519966125,
0.17118842899799347,
0.5563097596168518,
-0.03603062406182289,
-0.006808037403970957,
0.09483958035707474,
1.0804412364959717,
0.06302020698785782,
-0.6750155687332153,
0.2588622570037842,
0.18008002638816833,
0.5840166807174683,
-0.5159221887588501,
-0.2770267426967621,
0.06370848417282104,
0.34338250756263733,
-0.28961673378944397,
-0.8088592290878296,
-0.17590920627117157,
-0.2784292995929718,
-0.4466581344604492,
-0.2703823149204254,
0.9354773163795471,
-0.0176759734749794,
-0.638248085975647,
0.38716745376586914,
0.22441907227039337,
0.2874442934989929,
-0.023493444547057152,
-0.6557280421257019,
0.2778375446796417,
0.045669715851545334,
-0.22645269334316254,
0.4635651111602783,
0.3337222933769226,
-0.04217482730746269,
0.9895806908607483,
1.0184590816497803,
0.00878383219242096,
-0.21500477194786072,
-0.03629946708679199,
0.7519793510437012,
-0.5367394685745239,
-0.7192785739898682,
-0.6807193756103516,
0.30612725019454956,
-0.2779294550418854,
0.02281877212226391,
0.616695761680603,
0.5380262136459351,
0.7398908734321594,
-0.1387932002544403,
1.006550908088684,
0.11492805182933807,
0.526370644569397,
-0.30298274755477905,
0.5906696319580078,
-0.5281710028648376,
0.2512136399745941,
-0.31374722719192505,
-0.9244377017021179,
0.044711485505104065,
0.4349400997161865,
-0.5860854387283325,
0.4877173900604248,
0.43625640869140625,
0.6740678548812866,
-0.28989338874816895,
0.14157620072364807,
0.7344403862953186,
0.14271539449691772,
0.40499719977378845,
0.26904359459877014,
0.8561546206474304,
-0.1854504644870758,
0.10562878847122192,
-0.12591925263404846,
-0.5078832507133484,
-0.846969723701477,
-0.6860514879226685,
-0.899783730506897,
-0.8490144610404968,
-0.024774426594376564,
-0.3734365403652191,
0.3148673176765442,
0.977889358997345,
0.8591117858886719,
-0.9302601218223572,
-0.5922994017601013,
0.196123406291008,
0.15253104269504547,
-0.26564615964889526,
-0.24292363226413727,
0.10730841755867004,
-0.34564343094825745,
-0.887572169303894,
0.5249661207199097,
0.39364832639694214,
0.021461132913827896,
-0.6852589845657349,
-0.28597545623779297,
0.08397137373685837,
-0.05210854485630989,
0.825825572013855,
0.4814950227737427,
-0.5931934118270874,
-0.032296277582645416,
-0.0267433263361454,
0.022187840193510056,
-0.020219076424837112,
0.8952390551567078,
-1.0782816410064697,
0.5931675434112549,
0.4812573492527008,
0.7306080460548401,
0.49227628111839294,
-0.05222730711102486,
0.9399175047874451,
-0.03620709851384163,
0.06562686711549759,
-0.3094322085380554,
0.41325005888938904,
0.3210992217063904,
-0.6243229508399963,
0.25058597326278687,
-0.10657121986150742,
-0.6270483732223511,
-0.6150384545326233,
0.27885693311691284,
-0.9830000400543213,
-0.2861413359642029,
0.8922854661941528,
-0.30039453506469727,
-0.2203550785779953,
-0.28480178117752075,
-0.6974099278450012,
-0.038890812546014786,
-0.7319199442863464,
0.9448761940002441,
0.7450174689292908,
-0.32610753178596497,
-0.04479891061782837,
-0.650130569934845,
0.2811606526374817,
0.28600192070007324,
-0.8851671814918518,
-0.18041090667247772,
0.4494081735610962,
0.14161784946918488,
0.21639542281627655,
0.10593225806951523,
0.24849894642829895,
0.20317643880844116,
-0.45863762497901917,
0.16351106762886047,
-0.44079819321632385,
-0.29089343547821045,
-0.15920646488666534,
0.3123505711555481,
0.19514602422714233,
-0.09668853878974915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15764v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15764v2
|
Look Before You Leap: Problem Elaboration Prompting Improves Mathematical Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-24T08:40:30 | 2024-03-27T01:23:58 |
Haoran Liao, Jidong Tian, Shaohua Hu, Hao He, Yaohui Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) still grapple with complex tasks like
mathematical reasoning. Despite significant efforts invested in improving
prefix prompts or reasoning process, the crucial role of problem context might
have been neglected. Accurate recognition of inputs is fundamental for solving
mathematical tasks, as ill-formed problems could potentially mislead LLM's
reasoning. In this study, we propose a new approach named Problem Elaboration
Prompting (PEP) to enhance the mathematical capacities of LLMs. Specifically,
PEP decomposes and elucidates the problem context before reasoning, therefore
enhancing the context modeling and parsing efficiency. Experiments across
datasets and models demonstrate promising performances: (1) PEP demonstrates an
overall enhancement in various mathematical tasks. For instance, with the
GPT-3.5 model, PEP exhibits improvements of 9.93% and 8.80% on GSM8k through
greedy decoding and self-consistency, respectively. (2) PEP can be easily
implemented and integrated with other prompting methods. (3) PEP shows
particular strength in handling distraction problems.
|
[
-0.4431261420249939,
-0.6563838720321655,
0.7210189700126648,
0.44285064935684204,
-0.08018839359283447,
-0.12924252450466156,
-0.10883796960115433,
-0.17684221267700195,
0.0088115269318223,
0.003452692646533251,
-0.6175525188446045,
-0.14890359342098236,
-0.48345544934272766,
0.2058940976858139,
-0.2431638538837433,
0.673930287361145,
0.08383367210626602,
-0.1003873348236084,
-0.5932905077934265,
0.5753589868545532,
-0.5459043979644775,
-0.2703966796398163,
-0.6907630562782288,
-0.2628409266471863,
0.43916818499565125,
0.36849313974380493,
0.3469858169555664,
0.4927314221858978,
0.20832592248916626,
0.33870407938957214,
-0.49821096658706665,
0.22943301498889923,
-0.16930338740348816,
0.19210489094257355,
-0.24016514420509338,
-0.5213043689727783,
-0.3745841681957245,
-0.04810924828052521,
0.372618168592453,
0.7810550928115845,
-0.18877959251403809,
-0.11346612125635147,
0.4238390624523163,
0.5945366024971008,
-0.8924047350883484,
0.4039655923843384,
-0.543039083480835,
-0.1466905027627945,
0.15460601449012756,
-0.4818021357059479,
-0.4003421664237976,
-0.0722101703286171,
0.36627477407455444,
-0.8819266557693481,
0.16881632804870605,
-0.366925984621048,
0.5094319581985474,
0.5076168179512024,
-0.2840399742126465,
-0.4715888202190399,
-0.6040815711021423,
0.8034335374832153,
-0.5417212843894958,
0.3313613533973694,
0.5005636215209961,
0.059902872890233994,
-0.4153209328651428,
-0.5559741258621216,
-0.4569643437862396,
-0.011015989817678928,
-0.16255639493465424,
-0.08421840518712997,
-0.30975672602653503,
-0.24424020946025848,
0.6950348019599915,
-0.03275101259350777,
-0.25300005078315735,
-0.3269311189651489,
-0.31115853786468506,
-0.226002499461174,
0.4964785575866699,
-0.03695201501250267,
0.13728420436382294,
-0.2613806426525116,
-0.04378322511911392,
0.07197371870279312,
-0.9222874641418457,
0.1301242858171463,
-0.023850230500102043,
0.1505918651819229,
0.09475884586572647,
0.3927335739135742,
-0.04675331339240074,
0.5927159190177917,
0.03095872700214386,
0.007326154503971338,
0.11013756692409515,
-0.24670624732971191,
-0.17210371792316437,
-0.05190204456448555,
0.08997370302677155,
0.2518743574619293,
0.591071605682373,
0.66633141040802,
-0.04619220644235611,
-0.10910645127296448,
0.0880221575498581,
-0.736823558807373,
-0.41533949971199036,
0.12372008711099625,
0.06851658970117569,
0.10105901956558228,
-0.21802328526973724,
-0.6876804232597351,
-0.22981154918670654,
-0.4828055799007416,
0.24275606870651245,
-0.5940917730331421,
-0.12639188766479492,
0.21140475571155548,
0.1016869843006134,
0.18914754688739777,
0.8679550886154175,
-0.8600606918334961,
-0.15196245908737183,
1.0708976984024048,
0.8012733459472656,
0.2241666316986084,
-0.1394282728433609,
-0.7735761404037476,
0.06816065311431885,
-0.3601393699645996,
0.8602452874183655,
-0.3716391623020172,
-0.5700433254241943,
0.0036965259350836277,
-0.14139042794704437,
-0.15530799329280853,
-0.6219220161437988,
0.8349360227584839,
-0.3683983385562897,
0.0981176346540451,
-0.2617604434490204,
-0.5029613971710205,
-0.11428950726985931,
0.4189886450767517,
-0.4333471953868866,
1.0171377658843994,
-0.15776404738426208,
-0.5302321910858154,
0.2396083027124405,
-0.8624187707901001,
-0.4768833518028259,
0.27951937913894653,
-0.20139874517917633,
-0.2243628203868866,
0.3648344874382019,
1.0136737823486328,
0.27089232206344604,
0.23656603693962097,
0.04301157221198082,
0.09745626896619797,
-0.20755484700202942,
0.2607611119747162,
-0.22917857766151428,
0.6068723797798157,
0.20840643346309662,
-0.23409350216388702,
-0.18814216554164886,
-0.4127715229988098,
0.260066419839859,
0.22267067432403564,
-0.048375826328992844,
-0.7271389961242676,
0.1322503387928009,
-0.5122199654579163,
0.12408610433340073,
0.23772580921649933,
-0.18176712095737457,
0.3385337293148041,
-0.5544289350509644,
0.5116393566131592,
0.7958351969718933,
0.06967916339635849,
0.1797144114971161,
-0.21975331008434296,
0.7755058407783508,
-0.01997237838804722,
-0.13201233744621277,
-0.8853270411491394,
-0.8277857303619385,
-0.45123687386512756,
-0.24871495366096497,
0.293770432472229,
0.5804486274719238,
-0.5953419208526611,
0.2893175780773163,
-0.02041812241077423,
-0.028465570881962776,
-0.20054668188095093,
-0.1424422413110733,
0.3414615988731384,
0.7259036898612976,
0.35670530796051025,
0.3806891143321991,
-0.35726067423820496,
-0.6951130032539368,
-0.40287521481513977,
-0.12767046689987183,
-0.3415456712245941,
0.44573014974594116,
0.48638495802879333,
0.11550278216600418,
0.9575951099395752,
-0.736563503742218,
0.014076555147767067,
-0.2371370941400528,
0.28549930453300476,
0.3184923827648163,
0.5352794528007507,
0.25115612149238586,
-0.9488060474395752,
-0.5837385654449463,
-0.2421409636735916,
-0.16439051926136017,
-0.6301618218421936,
-0.045953165739774704,
-0.1035768911242485,
0.04237758740782738,
0.5637938976287842,
-0.5902191400527954,
0.573753297328949,
0.20408016443252563,
-0.4256562888622284,
0.6168115139007568,
-0.24130481481552124,
0.2252197265625,
-0.8863955736160278,
0.05472113937139511,
0.038505785167217255,
-0.11636471748352051,
-0.5093312859535217,
-0.11083739250898361,
0.28214579820632935,
-0.3314366042613983,
-0.5702018141746521,
0.46988362073898315,
-0.4861966669559479,
0.02769840694963932,
-0.1892959326505661,
0.2712510824203491,
0.21810942888259888,
0.14067630469799042,
-0.009363837540149689,
1.204992413520813,
0.469644695520401,
-0.8699533939361572,
-0.13705790042877197,
0.28341397643089294,
-0.409796804189682,
0.6714314818382263,
-0.8190371990203857,
0.06638293713331223,
-0.24763503670692444,
0.11208831518888474,
-0.9952392578125,
-0.17538118362426758,
0.12354855984449387,
-0.6308014392852783,
0.12097040563821793,
-0.3413185477256775,
-0.21125169098377228,
-0.5104153156280518,
-0.2658484876155853,
0.6945289373397827,
0.5130519866943359,
-0.7153124809265137,
0.4754728376865387,
0.01843263953924179,
-0.4380609393119812,
-0.6428363919258118,
-0.42353782057762146,
-0.21935614943504333,
-0.19550621509552002,
-0.4996257424354553,
0.48640015721321106,
-0.3587677776813507,
-0.2440526932477951,
-0.1013861894607544,
-0.1954631209373474,
-0.025309719145298004,
0.06703753769397736,
-0.04481085017323494,
0.3437088429927826,
0.020391572266817093,
0.26949307322502136,
0.042979903519153595,
-0.16526176035404205,
0.318828284740448,
-0.3850494921207428,
0.47288793325424194,
0.06024818494915962,
-0.2836996018886566,
-0.5777334570884705,
0.3396228551864624,
0.4664038419723511,
-0.35126909613609314,
0.2306658923625946,
-0.05289353057742119,
-0.6227898001670837,
-0.34295931458473206,
-0.2789071798324585,
-0.30290067195892334,
-0.5322496891021729,
0.19457967579364777,
-0.5214248895645142,
-0.6497380137443542,
0.33812233805656433,
-0.3016011416912079,
-0.019586900249123573,
0.04810207337141037,
0.5315840840339661,
-0.007452752906829119,
1.1959314346313477,
0.5442311763763428,
0.356395423412323,
0.6508920192718506,
-0.15694878995418549,
0.4029836058616638,
-1.0564957857131958,
-0.4888801872730255,
-0.4919045865535736,
-0.16806936264038086,
-0.021435491740703583,
-0.6518833041191101,
0.5724111199378967,
0.48345038294792175,
0.1021268293261528,
0.21768860518932343,
-0.42373767495155334,
0.9622288942337036,
0.21771934628486633,
-0.010595987550914288,
0.2444772571325302,
0.12378758192062378,
-0.3367822766304016,
-0.4872353971004486,
-0.6787636876106262,
-0.3040071129798889,
0.9107251167297363,
0.14445310831069946,
0.6394161581993103,
-0.08343996107578278,
0.7427907586097717,
0.008844563737511635,
0.3487873375415802,
-1.1889852285385132,
0.6205441951751709,
0.4591461718082428,
-0.4506143629550934,
-0.34276118874549866,
-0.5376155972480774,
-1.176025629043579,
0.2882010042667389,
0.11605469137430191,
-0.8755245804786682,
0.186431884765625,
0.43571871519088745,
-0.7020000219345093,
-0.1779688447713852,
-0.7550156712532043,
0.6974231004714966,
-0.143384650349617,
-0.4187714159488678,
-0.14300690591335297,
0.026025032624602318,
0.22073744237422943,
-0.049093082547187805,
0.495706170797348,
-0.14228138327598572,
-0.39199236035346985,
0.5992206931114197,
-0.500338077545166,
0.4547193944454193,
-0.16328029334545135,
-0.5359483361244202,
0.4552200436592102,
0.4189278185367584,
0.7306579947471619,
0.2739180028438568,
-0.01602627895772457,
-0.30043941736221313,
-0.2873910665512085,
-0.3285816013813019,
-1.1778507232666016,
0.7006778717041016,
-0.12632423639297485,
-1.0550636053085327,
-0.2856762409210205,
-0.7090255618095398,
-0.1718815267086029,
0.14639976620674133,
0.12276746332645416,
0.3994126617908478,
0.15795813500881195,
-0.01661984995007515,
0.7053677439689636,
-0.0937453955411911,
0.6310075521469116,
0.42833057045936584,
-0.2771362364292145,
-0.3467296063899994,
0.42521724104881287,
0.0791541263461113,
0.17238570749759674,
0.16661253571510315,
0.3672701120376587,
-0.6196534633636475,
-0.4072625935077667,
-0.2740630507469177,
0.16922317445278168,
-0.75992751121521,
-0.359476238489151,
-0.5517444610595703,
0.11610051989555359,
-0.5587068200111389,
-0.3296542465686798,
-0.3109014332294464,
-0.3851425349712372,
-0.1389077603816986,
0.1664440631866455,
0.38124358654022217,
0.5609343647956848,
-0.13410072028636932,
0.15966688096523285,
-0.7440453171730042,
-0.10865792632102966,
0.4479811191558838,
0.07036852836608887,
0.20951007306575775,
-0.5697655081748962,
-0.21841955184936523,
-0.17051424086093903,
-0.4398493766784668,
-0.8759687542915344,
0.7285645008087158,
0.03821386769413948,
0.5458850264549255,
0.4441847801208496,
0.0814829021692276,
0.800436794757843,
-0.6532459855079651,
0.7187811732292175,
0.05019422620534897,
-1.4194477796554565,
0.9062554836273193,
-0.3324185609817505,
0.4382721483707428,
0.030689669772982597,
0.6407800316810608,
-0.30345290899276733,
0.09402371942996979,
-0.6738179326057434,
-0.8640291690826416,
0.4941973388195038,
0.27809688448905945,
0.06403294950723648,
-0.07815709710121155,
0.43447455763816833,
-0.3227600157260895,
0.1309608668088913,
-0.5470400452613831,
0.11320481449365616,
0.028538687154650688,
0.23576964437961578,
-0.045712560415267944,
-0.1900259405374527,
-0.1023487001657486,
-0.5872873663902283,
0.49789243936538696,
-0.28261667490005493,
0.34678590297698975,
0.5444992184638977,
0.021209247410297394,
-0.3085225820541382,
0.38048073649406433,
0.8135526180267334,
1.007872462272644,
0.28114983439445496,
0.1622857302427292,
0.33609476685523987,
-0.2115015834569931,
0.08161117881536484,
0.08059246838092804,
-0.12622082233428955,
-0.07852715253829956,
0.44476768374443054,
0.27611684799194336,
0.3047209680080414,
-0.7078784108161926,
0.44296523928642273,
0.19190773367881775,
-0.17766036093235016,
-0.15457205474376678,
0.1073298379778862,
0.17614184319972992,
0.23301422595977783,
0.6066253185272217,
-0.3774614930152893,
0.15623581409454346,
-0.34329158067703247,
0.33125269412994385,
0.32487449049949646,
0.30532610416412354,
-0.05558854341506958,
0.3870163559913635,
0.04965982586145401,
-0.5996353626251221,
0.6074087023735046,
-0.1465023010969162,
-1.030405879020691,
0.8968441486358643,
0.9646120667457581,
0.5390902757644653,
-0.6621072888374329,
0.18102368712425232,
0.6638516187667847,
0.11170277744531631,
0.029144877567887306,
0.36565911769866943,
-0.24387086927890778,
-0.5245316028594971,
-0.9854599833488464,
-0.2094564288854599,
-0.4249441921710968,
0.3038366138935089,
-0.6048405170440674,
0.4626297950744629,
-0.41003450751304626,
0.13237614929676056,
0.04664766415953636,
-0.040076855570077896,
-0.3273952603340149,
-0.0041332547552883625,
0.1303260326385498,
0.9448210597038269,
-0.4545556902885437,
0.5297573208808899,
0.7619975805282593,
0.2310807704925537,
-0.9564690589904785,
0.3739034831523895,
-0.01981591247022152,
-0.6758354902267456,
0.6752968430519104,
0.352419376373291,
-0.04887888953089714,
0.11593647301197052,
-0.6737980842590332,
-0.807953417301178,
0.7774879336357117,
0.25352269411087036,
-0.8090044260025024,
0.06658373028039932,
-0.20529785752296448,
0.2811771035194397,
-0.5281978249549866,
0.2311829775571823,
0.437869131565094,
0.5759634375572205,
0.4581676125526428,
-0.8511058688163757,
0.14561958611011505,
-0.3416078984737396,
-0.017172591760754585,
0.42485368251800537,
-0.09887643158435822,
1.0313940048217773,
-0.6881962418556213,
-0.29795539379119873,
-0.03951149061322212,
0.5260459184646606,
0.5506321787834167,
0.44239023327827454,
0.6494038105010986,
0.4018740653991699,
0.9472445249557495,
0.04392031580209732,
0.9311067461967468,
-0.1498919576406479,
0.3398742079734802,
0.9507067203521729,
-0.09031856805086136,
0.8695645332336426,
0.6323490738868713,
-0.2612379491329193,
0.44635114073753357,
0.5963577032089233,
0.2927281856536865,
0.4281666576862335,
0.4131956994533539,
-0.32187944650650024,
-0.4390632212162018,
-0.004138275049626827,
-0.6240668296813965,
0.17946571111679077,
0.8521432876586914,
-0.21441878378391266,
-0.4434623420238495,
-0.025312362238764763,
-0.09890255331993103,
0.211831733584404,
-0.6195111274719238,
0.3921927213668823,
0.25721439719200134,
-0.9118741750717163,
0.8320382833480835,
-0.1768629103899002,
0.37174510955810547,
-0.371009886264801,
-0.3606595993041992,
-0.25244832038879395,
0.12165402621030807,
-0.18977577984333038,
-0.7531360983848572,
0.3619133532047272,
-0.03270978853106499,
-0.1057867705821991,
-0.21771124005317688,
0.5462571382522583,
-0.45480120182037354,
-0.3989778459072113,
0.10130424052476883,
0.7027336359024048,
0.20359234511852264,
-0.3394869267940521,
-0.758767306804657,
-0.01175982877612114,
-0.15731008350849152,
-0.16038723289966583,
0.028420960530638695,
0.7930697202682495,
-0.11498869955539703,
0.766719400882721,
0.8924127221107483,
-0.11019851267337799,
-0.13914813101291656,
-0.06595012545585632,
1.0260871648788452,
-0.6911754608154297,
-0.8604370951652527,
-1.0065165758132935,
0.48366254568099976,
0.06215810030698776,
-0.21192501485347748,
0.8695794343948364,
0.32938340306282043,
0.7967249155044556,
-0.22316548228263855,
0.3656105101108551,
0.12237977236509323,
0.41083061695098877,
-0.5041885375976562,
0.1898878514766693,
-0.5476345419883728,
0.563560426235199,
-0.4326351284980774,
-0.9257633090019226,
-0.4838416576385498,
0.9579505920410156,
-0.7452949285507202,
0.08578447997570038,
0.7190952897071838,
0.81623375415802,
-0.027287354692816734,
0.01004788652062416,
0.3002399802207947,
-0.1659366488456726,
0.3308050036430359,
0.9245160222053528,
1.2144445180892944,
0.060183025896549225,
0.5661073923110962,
-0.09352162480354309,
-0.4763719141483307,
-0.3620004653930664,
-1.218094825744629,
-0.9227886199951172,
-0.27264535427093506,
-0.42705070972442627,
-0.4516250193119049,
-0.0631692036986351,
1.1819214820861816,
0.7376033663749695,
-0.6938954591751099,
0.13655370473861694,
-0.30970293283462524,
0.42609456181526184,
-0.31432947516441345,
-0.23299579322338104,
0.2671392261981964,
-0.5357723236083984,
-1.0842591524124146,
0.6362612843513489,
0.14511339366436005,
0.26585206389427185,
-0.1626264750957489,
-0.015726948156952858,
-0.05061740428209305,
0.3361934721469879,
0.6367700099945068,
0.33604511618614197,
-0.39839598536491394,
-0.04623948037624359,
-0.012081175111234188,
0.15399719774723053,
0.3111714720726013,
1.3846848011016846,
-0.9170994758605957,
0.24159099161624908,
0.5281418561935425,
0.6742969155311584,
0.29354068636894226,
0.2012283354997635,
0.6128337383270264,
-0.5404840707778931,
0.22929616272449493,
0.34022057056427,
0.36717841029167175,
0.15449711680412292,
-0.6792294383049011,
0.3884727358818054,
0.34657493233680725,
-0.3972470760345459,
-0.7854153513908386,
0.5070747137069702,
-0.48269787430763245,
-0.3818027377128601,
0.8867605924606323,
-0.4829805791378021,
-0.34448471665382385,
-0.05132386460900307,
-0.3650195896625519,
-0.1008697971701622,
-0.549856960773468,
0.7759302854537964,
0.792592465877533,
-0.46839970350265503,
-0.43995365500450134,
-0.36150604486465454,
0.639252245426178,
1.1032495498657227,
-0.8668988347053528,
0.2533451020717621,
0.408832848072052,
-0.00913382787257433,
0.33164501190185547,
0.28860175609588623,
-0.16082622110843658,
0.4008147120475769,
-0.25000548362731934,
-0.4884259104728699,
-0.289261132478714,
-0.7147412896156311,
-0.5149613618850708,
0.09119271486997604,
-0.0837877094745636,
-0.028279535472393036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17786v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17786v1
|
Stepwise Self-Consistent Mathematical Reasoning with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-24T08:22:39 | 2024-02-24T08:22:39 |
Zilong Zhao, Yao Rong, Dongyang Guo, Emek Gözlüklü, Emir Gülboy, Enkelejda Kasneci
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Using Large Language Models for complex mathematical reasoning is difficult,
primarily due to the complexity of multi-step reasoning. The main challenges of
this process include (1) selecting critical intermediate results to advance the
procedure, and (2) limited exploration of potential solutions. To address these
issues, we introduce a novel algorithm, namely Stepwise Self-Consistent
Chain-of-Thought (SSC-CoT). SSC-CoT employs a strategy of selecting
intermediate steps based on the intersection of various reasoning chains.
Additionally, SSC-CoT enables the model to discover critical intermediate steps
by querying a knowledge graph comprising relevant domain knowledge. To validate
SSC-CoT, we present a new dataset, TriMaster100, tailored for complex
trigonometry problems. This dataset contains 100 questions, with each solution
broken down into scored intermediate steps, facilitating a comprehensive
evaluation of the mathematical reasoning process. On TriMaster100, SSC-CoT
triples the effectiveness of the state-of-the-art methods. Furthermore, we
benchmark SSC-CoT on the widely recognized complex mathematical question
dataset, MATH level 5, and it surpasses the second-best method by 7.2% in
accuracy. Code and the TriMaster100 dataset can be found at:
https://github.com/zhao-zilong/ssc-cot.
|
[
-0.3961063325405121,
-0.7159384489059448,
0.9691893458366394,
0.38187772035598755,
-0.11201310157775879,
0.5170966982841492,
-0.21290192008018494,
-0.18461422622203827,
-0.0839531347155571,
0.5401277542114258,
-0.7772103548049927,
-0.7095686793327332,
-0.26299285888671875,
0.0858641117811203,
-0.25351250171661377,
0.7328840494155884,
-0.4813665747642517,
0.3028886616230011,
-0.2027384340763092,
-0.23674482107162476,
-0.290150910615921,
-0.45699542760849,
-0.6576356887817383,
-0.23644506931304932,
0.2506089508533478,
0.48872026801109314,
0.7524060010910034,
0.5201185345649719,
0.6563975811004639,
0.17903335392475128,
-0.15036500990390778,
0.4220162332057953,
-0.32680654525756836,
0.23322910070419312,
-0.2235914170742035,
-0.31200337409973145,
-0.391865998506546,
-0.3506983816623688,
0.35554683208465576,
0.7761112451553345,
-0.32887357473373413,
0.16673162579536438,
-0.048077426850795746,
0.8844631314277649,
-0.624035656452179,
0.09833412617444992,
-0.24291151762008667,
-0.1899738609790802,
-0.17996671795845032,
0.02547040581703186,
-0.26747673749923706,
-0.5180436968803406,
-0.031097063794732094,
-0.3695995509624481,
0.11730920523405075,
0.03745182231068611,
0.375103622674942,
0.2784726023674011,
-0.30899596214294434,
-0.4129886031150818,
-0.9629559516906738,
0.7619981169700623,
-0.5936669707298279,
0.6036999821662903,
0.3226426839828491,
0.470765084028244,
-0.18229275941848755,
-0.4336718022823334,
-0.38410860300064087,
-0.2088870108127594,
0.2900925576686859,
-0.0024631551932543516,
0.01944086328148842,
0.04104384034872055,
0.5092121362686157,
0.3264285922050476,
-0.5714602470397949,
-0.3642939031124115,
-0.45646151900291443,
-0.23672336339950562,
0.8063694834709167,
0.23461312055587769,
0.39464086294174194,
-0.142095148563385,
-0.4238925874233246,
-0.10052122920751572,
-0.7324144840240479,
-0.06947381049394608,
0.3202691078186035,
0.20426826179027557,
-0.05716767907142639,
0.5211722254753113,
-0.2040577381849289,
0.6711044311523438,
0.04179968684911728,
0.11146865785121918,
0.09968876838684082,
-0.38847610354423523,
0.06718479096889496,
0.07536998391151428,
0.7701631188392639,
-0.09496381878852844,
0.5944015979766846,
0.21409186720848083,
-0.11560767143964767,
-0.18542250990867615,
0.2248646318912506,
-0.39934200048446655,
-0.4038454294204712,
0.49297600984573364,
0.1229887530207634,
-0.14594581723213196,
-0.11902738362550735,
-0.5405521988868713,
-0.006738401483744383,
-0.5208858251571655,
0.33758968114852905,
-0.6202670931816101,
-0.06027057766914368,
0.2871301472187042,
0.2977595925331116,
0.0380200520157814,
0.588812530040741,
-0.45541611313819885,
0.32794255018234253,
0.8704959154129028,
0.9281188249588013,
-0.33599013090133667,
-0.3022626042366028,
-0.32570478320121765,
0.1022491380572319,
-0.8741913437843323,
0.8183646202087402,
-0.42400047183036804,
-0.10500261187553406,
-0.27167484164237976,
-0.231402188539505,
0.07963480055332184,
-0.46769875288009644,
0.6752515435218811,
-0.381658673286438,
0.011733844876289368,
-0.414434015750885,
-0.591387152671814,
-0.061048611998558044,
0.49686768651008606,
-0.706487238407135,
1.3329728841781616,
-0.0024998553562909365,
-0.589045524597168,
-0.15811491012573242,
-0.40097054839134216,
-0.23633982241153717,
-0.054000042378902435,
-0.39003312587738037,
-0.2882784307003021,
-0.0030684706289321184,
0.32505884766578674,
0.15311409533023834,
-0.5556902289390564,
0.3017679750919342,
-0.6877109408378601,
-0.11314024776220322,
0.04765969514846802,
-0.4320879280567169,
0.9326357245445251,
0.26450812816619873,
-0.3687700927257538,
-0.02946878783404827,
-0.6136053204536438,
0.32232940196990967,
0.08846280723810196,
0.2261466383934021,
-0.3281950354576111,
-0.3388420343399048,
-0.39501067996025085,
0.36775484681129456,
0.28384047746658325,
-0.552501916885376,
0.2496604025363922,
-0.04678893834352493,
0.26793625950813293,
0.8097259402275085,
0.19386522471904755,
0.07186709344387054,
-0.07263213396072388,
0.5196699500083923,
0.03407927230000496,
0.37238600850105286,
0.006132021546363831,
-0.28694629669189453,
-0.7324610948562622,
-0.04997484013438225,
0.37311020493507385,
0.432500422000885,
-0.7877343893051147,
0.49160125851631165,
0.025932511314749718,
-0.6000256538391113,
-0.15258774161338806,
-0.01258843019604683,
0.4893490672111511,
0.3943285346031189,
0.5843423008918762,
0.06072748824954033,
-0.1873551905155182,
-0.7457983493804932,
-0.37809962034225464,
-0.07877995073795319,
0.05933953449130058,
0.16958940029144287,
0.4746476411819458,
0.14153987169265747,
0.6460562944412231,
-0.9370535016059875,
0.0021199951879680157,
-0.10548054426908493,
0.2943815290927887,
0.19780705869197845,
0.6578343510627747,
0.16873207688331604,
-0.4543570578098297,
-0.5109718441963196,
-0.10669618099927902,
-0.7556734681129456,
0.07982422411441803,
-0.230805903673172,
-0.657845139503479,
-0.14327915012836456,
0.6273506879806519,
-0.2540319263935089,
0.5643084645271301,
0.40703272819519043,
-0.26165348291397095,
0.7301861643791199,
-0.3780922293663025,
0.24715030193328857,
-0.8975339531898499,
-0.05479477345943451,
0.0762743204832077,
-0.46423080563545227,
-0.5713210105895996,
-0.05513586848974228,
0.3391916751861572,
0.0859631821513176,
-0.20845261216163635,
0.3532952666282654,
-0.3665964901447296,
0.021346215158700943,
0.0031662755645811558,
-0.0806131437420845,
-0.06410987675189972,
0.598008930683136,
0.04830172657966614,
0.7045459151268005,
0.5964120626449585,
-0.5783072710037231,
0.38714489340782166,
0.19628147780895233,
-0.20179982483386993,
0.6290414929389954,
-0.7368147373199463,
0.3170853853225708,
0.03604704886674881,
0.40566009283065796,
-1.0074704885482788,
-0.06350158900022507,
0.10687131434679031,
-0.3305627405643463,
-0.03389929234981537,
-0.04665582627058029,
-0.41231298446655273,
-0.5066384673118591,
-0.2396341860294342,
0.9806798696517944,
0.10481344163417816,
-0.5724464654922485,
0.9042654037475586,
0.09460022300481796,
-0.10030781477689743,
-0.4294925332069397,
-0.36751917004585266,
-0.11587688326835632,
0.22282353043556213,
-0.515832245349884,
0.10363420844078064,
-0.34589841961860657,
-0.06521918624639511,
-0.39810654520988464,
-0.5694176554679871,
-0.058869242668151855,
-0.23317864537239075,
-0.01696188561618328,
0.4880641996860504,
0.0005152994417585433,
0.1357671171426773,
0.19784113764762878,
-0.26604095101356506,
0.24974200129508972,
-0.37382927536964417,
0.8970125317573547,
-0.36041393876075745,
-0.6960999369621277,
-0.5097218155860901,
0.17584186792373657,
0.7160161733627319,
-0.2761023938655853,
0.19315502047538757,
0.1851072460412979,
-0.5987206101417542,
-0.38745224475860596,
-0.6095582842826843,
0.0009660409414209425,
-0.3906475305557251,
-0.0687989890575409,
-0.663112998008728,
-0.541505753993988,
0.6059589982032776,
-0.2606787085533142,
0.09345134347677231,
0.7201001644134521,
0.34343597292900085,
-0.16596005856990814,
1.220041036605835,
0.1668493002653122,
0.3886685371398926,
0.16141866147518158,
-0.5497937798500061,
0.31901565194129944,
-0.9646921157836914,
-0.3577662408351898,
-0.5249858498573303,
-0.03935060650110245,
-0.31552237272262573,
-0.6867645978927612,
0.5145068168640137,
0.16018836200237274,
-0.6388368606567383,
0.42218708992004395,
-0.4683016240596771,
0.5556467771530151,
0.3270222544670105,
0.3372383117675781,
0.4307286739349365,
-0.0889638215303421,
-0.5407904386520386,
0.20861458778381348,
-0.5220615267753601,
-0.1981664001941681,
0.9635189175605774,
0.12889525294303894,
0.9382116198539734,
-0.00799266155809164,
0.7147218585014343,
0.16316306591033936,
-0.04191490262746811,
-0.6682494282722473,
0.4558887183666229,
-0.10301171988248825,
-0.8633578419685364,
-0.5181573033332825,
-0.7965062856674194,
-0.40944182872772217,
0.006249385420233011,
0.16476497054100037,
-0.5407276749610901,
0.14891305565834045,
0.017941171303391457,
-0.6723008155822754,
0.42525526881217957,
-0.3314513564109802,
0.6715463995933533,
-0.5762681365013123,
-0.42345210909843445,
-0.18769244849681854,
-0.5743641257286072,
0.23858007788658142,
-0.2356596738100052,
0.19959288835525513,
-0.31764787435531616,
0.08845088630914688,
0.6103664636611938,
-0.5987975597381592,
0.4703684151172638,
0.11755695194005966,
-0.2145308256149292,
0.550484836101532,
0.7596802711486816,
0.47995811700820923,
0.054984211921691895,
0.15645620226860046,
0.36136314272880554,
0.4443838596343994,
-0.6202961802482605,
-0.6971730589866638,
0.6856240630149841,
-0.6007202863693237,
-0.4989583492279053,
-0.7402540445327759,
-0.37945324182510376,
-0.5839231014251709,
0.28979623317718506,
0.02068815380334854,
0.5865926146507263,
0.047933947294950485,
0.09913817793130875,
0.6198261380195618,
0.22529372572898865,
0.3364865481853485,
0.05338899418711662,
-0.26885995268821716,
-0.8483715653419495,
0.6707760691642761,
0.2576444447040558,
0.4615386724472046,
0.1633118838071823,
0.42774319648742676,
-0.4830019176006317,
-0.20111672580242157,
-0.6889024972915649,
0.4736586809158325,
-0.6544503569602966,
-0.41286325454711914,
-0.40416374802589417,
-0.5269424915313721,
-0.21144382655620575,
-0.09414197504520416,
-0.7934516072273254,
-0.522267758846283,
0.0885903611779213,
0.10725216567516327,
0.11067944765090942,
0.7531575560569763,
-0.010661795735359192,
-0.1234360784292221,
-0.7666227221488953,
0.45533761382102966,
0.3328551650047302,
0.5519537925720215,
0.15210619568824768,
-0.28070881962776184,
0.04228745028376579,
0.1921399086713791,
-0.23675164580345154,
-0.6003388166427612,
-0.08572623133659363,
-0.15854132175445557,
0.3704793453216553,
0.31856006383895874,
0.29216426610946655,
0.9809039235115051,
-0.42262977361679077,
0.6231686472892761,
0.4581891596317291,
-1.3891383409500122,
0.5363641977310181,
-0.2062252163887024,
0.48352164030075073,
0.8122177720069885,
0.6096346974372864,
-0.5573025345802307,
-0.27699926495552063,
-0.818665087223053,
-0.5586056113243103,
0.5313801169395447,
0.5438780784606934,
-0.4199815094470978,
0.23277592658996582,
0.5605915188789368,
0.04815195873379707,
-0.07067004591226578,
-0.2700674831867218,
-0.027697354555130005,
0.08445834368467331,
-0.5477331876754761,
0.21095922589302063,
0.07222253084182739,
-0.315561980009079,
-0.30304616689682007,
0.578028678894043,
-0.4617253839969635,
-0.08239031583070755,
0.4240032434463501,
0.10729715973138809,
-0.2620433568954468,
-0.08418034017086029,
0.37838706374168396,
1.1603435277938843,
-0.034468330442905426,
0.32207298278808594,
0.4834674000740051,
-0.5635910034179688,
0.10750462859869003,
-0.1516100913286209,
-0.17052219808101654,
-0.191347137093544,
0.557750940322876,
0.25175780057907104,
0.2017076313495636,
-0.5340515971183777,
0.46210184693336487,
-0.07263793796300888,
-0.2296570986509323,
-0.40848591923713684,
0.06745985895395279,
-0.05703413113951683,
0.23162581026554108,
0.3515419065952301,
0.2864346504211426,
0.04484157636761665,
-0.34000924229621887,
0.2870478332042694,
0.2353774756193161,
-0.5996910929679871,
-0.19458265602588654,
0.4240238070487976,
-0.15812407433986664,
-0.19133932888507843,
0.6140413880348206,
0.19415394961833954,
-0.6880051493644714,
0.7035759687423706,
0.2411513328552246,
0.9778275489807129,
-0.3749086856842041,
0.36653003096580505,
0.7535011172294617,
0.12372684478759766,
-0.5251724720001221,
0.6356112360954285,
-0.3277582824230194,
-0.44848206639289856,
-0.41524454951286316,
-0.550596296787262,
-0.6211005449295044,
-0.4637472629547119,
-0.7289222478866577,
0.46602970361709595,
-0.7264107465744019,
0.055560410022735596,
-0.026703009381890297,
0.03094104863703251,
-0.6045373678207397,
0.3808833658695221,
0.266501247882843,
0.8981508612632751,
-0.646077036857605,
0.7163199782371521,
0.22291892766952515,
-0.3296833336353302,
-1.0920825004577637,
0.2571910321712494,
-0.04419277235865593,
-0.8850685358047485,
0.06958413869142532,
-0.01751049980521202,
-0.6767421960830688,
-0.16666093468666077,
-0.7594568133354187,
-1.1563090085983276,
1.0388092994689941,
0.2889401912689209,
-0.8309125900268555,
-0.07772210985422134,
0.23411573469638824,
0.5574652552604675,
-0.42542338371276855,
0.4258226752281189,
0.5439484119415283,
0.2671074867248535,
0.9630950689315796,
-0.8423162698745728,
0.18408185243606567,
0.16627976298332214,
0.13158856332302094,
0.29076656699180603,
-0.8487341403961182,
0.7930890321731567,
-0.3247629702091217,
-0.06357967108488083,
-0.04326342046260834,
0.7102823853492737,
0.7098590135574341,
0.4306940734386444,
0.8250101208686829,
0.5326710939407349,
0.8793712854385376,
-0.11461876332759857,
0.6246715784072876,
-0.5414611101150513,
0.8413406610488892,
1.1843456029891968,
-0.2563479542732239,
0.802969217300415,
0.16045133769512177,
-0.4427284002304077,
0.6852699518203735,
0.7433024048805237,
0.24175968766212463,
0.07869342714548111,
0.15694640576839447,
-0.07729771733283997,
-0.9464344382286072,
0.22571222484111786,
-0.4669404923915863,
0.4120531976222992,
0.21456104516983032,
0.013506692834198475,
-0.3567109704017639,
-0.37904372811317444,
0.20162814855575562,
-0.09704840183258057,
-0.3630591332912445,
0.6354318857192993,
0.18054381012916565,
-0.7191318869590759,
0.7010210752487183,
-0.4709140956401825,
-0.1359875649213791,
-0.6210097670555115,
-0.20389635860919952,
-0.2836693525314331,
0.2712901532649994,
-0.24941305816173553,
-1.176501989364624,
0.2868908941745758,
0.004363120999187231,
0.2990166246891022,
-0.06879578530788422,
0.364462673664093,
-0.4477706849575043,
-0.9843054413795471,
0.13335645198822021,
0.6889950633049011,
0.0011338811600580812,
-0.3057270348072052,
-0.7366294860839844,
0.1123356744647026,
0.13791878521442413,
0.10172197222709656,
-0.31328973174095154,
0.7128152251243591,
-0.2503407895565033,
0.7549068331718445,
0.7535179853439331,
0.012025456875562668,
-0.12648819386959076,
0.19077248871326447,
1.0501197576522827,
-1.0123237371444702,
-0.6042863726615906,
-0.8080469369888306,
0.20427951216697693,
-0.20504651963710785,
-0.4849890470504761,
0.5479615330696106,
0.8312183618545532,
0.8065982460975647,
0.2659126818180084,
0.528572678565979,
0.1449374109506607,
0.36211925745010376,
-0.5233226418495178,
0.29079771041870117,
-0.5107051730155945,
0.30561497807502747,
-0.3120073080062866,
-1.0338284969329834,
-0.5291599035263062,
0.4459051489830017,
-0.4077531397342682,
0.13261952996253967,
1.2099661827087402,
0.3958713114261627,
-0.2271178513765335,
0.4732372760772705,
0.1950785219669342,
0.10884066671133041,
0.4783708453178406,
0.5776731967926025,
0.7717078924179077,
-0.3670605719089508,
0.6152564287185669,
-0.5111241340637207,
-0.4189784824848175,
0.06640282273292542,
-0.5666158199310303,
-0.7894586324691772,
-0.5224760174751282,
-0.34508731961250305,
-0.7013753652572632,
-0.12622147798538208,
1.149370789527893,
0.6561914086341858,
-1.029896855354309,
-0.3300759494304657,
-0.48222142457962036,
0.2027226984500885,
-0.4701227843761444,
-0.15590529143810272,
0.5491331815719604,
-0.34491753578186035,
-0.5247741341590881,
-0.03468994423747063,
0.48976171016693115,
-0.13954631984233856,
-0.5925244688987732,
0.0824182778596878,
-0.27197274565696716,
0.3107181191444397,
0.36017996072769165,
0.15629109740257263,
-0.649639904499054,
-0.3225384056568146,
0.1493922621011734,
-0.12920039892196655,
0.2670373320579529,
1.107442855834961,
-0.33509454131126404,
0.6485314965248108,
0.5818048119544983,
0.35933881998062134,
0.8572710156440735,
0.1858649104833603,
0.5319892168045044,
-0.12597937881946564,
-0.36591097712516785,
0.4734989106655121,
0.284324049949646,
0.26722636818885803,
-0.4079510569572449,
0.6813979148864746,
0.23289281129837036,
-0.4393357038497925,
-0.5861875414848328,
0.3634408414363861,
-1.1279350519180298,
-0.2616001069545746,
1.0972317457199097,
-0.10025342553853989,
-0.713129460811615,
0.056137338280677795,
-0.2966824173927307,
0.11639676243066788,
-0.24814243614673615,
0.7750602960586548,
0.8703847527503967,
-0.5995765924453735,
-0.03867362439632416,
-0.2297724187374115,
0.39700770378112793,
0.41010087728500366,
-0.8749681115150452,
0.2703404426574707,
0.3281794488430023,
0.45478543639183044,
0.33150574564933777,
0.2874561846256256,
-0.2681206464767456,
0.15433913469314575,
-0.07113385945558548,
-0.1286560744047165,
0.13329344987869263,
-0.8111810088157654,
-0.12970426678657532,
0.20417426526546478,
-0.32254016399383545,
-0.040246620774269104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15758v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15758v2
|
Chimera: A Lossless Decoding Method for Accelerating Large Language Models Inference by Fusing all Tokens
| 2024-02-24T08:10:39 | 2024-04-18T16:23:16 |
Ziqian Zeng, Jiahong Yu, Qianshi Pang, Zihao Wang, Huiping Zhuang, Hongen Shao, Xiaofeng Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across
various tasks. However, their widespread application is hindered by the
resource-intensive decoding process. To address this challenge, current
approaches have incorporated additional decoding heads to enable parallel
prediction of multiple subsequent tokens, thereby achieving inference
acceleration. Nevertheless, the accuracy of these decoding heads falls short of
the auto-regressive decoding approach.
In light of these limitations, we propose Chimera, a novel framework
specifically designed for speculative sampling. Within this framework, we
introduce a lightweight draft model that effectively utilizes previously
generated tokens to predict subsequent words. To ensure both accuracy and
efficiency, we present two strategies within the lightweight draft model.
Firstly, we focus on capturing short-range dependencies at the bottom layer.
Secondly, we leverage the readily available representations from the original
LLM.Through empirical evaluation on the Vicuna and LlaMA-2 series, Chimera
demonstrates impressive results, achieving an average latency speedup ratio of
2.7x compared to the vanilla auto-regressive decoding approach. This highlights
the potential of our proposed framework in significantly improving the
efficiency of large language models during the decoding process.
|
[
-0.08896154165267944,
-0.6389489769935608,
0.5196827054023743,
0.31490057706832886,
-0.5826171636581421,
0.28005251288414,
-0.13758397102355957,
-0.6989002227783203,
0.42786797881126404,
0.46051034331321716,
-0.43796393275260925,
-0.34026333689689636,
-0.6961243152618408,
0.18223202228546143,
-0.6110206246376038,
0.49761301279067993,
0.22647853195667267,
0.1547326296567917,
0.18069790303707123,
-0.006459814961999655,
-0.4625432789325714,
-0.24602028727531433,
-0.48121482133865356,
-0.272205114364624,
0.46645525097846985,
0.3050517141819,
0.6259214878082275,
0.983552873134613,
0.04251900687813759,
0.31196966767311096,
-0.10452946275472641,
0.13997535407543182,
-0.5918288230895996,
0.02004692703485489,
-0.027306176722049713,
-0.8082669377326965,
-0.32565465569496155,
-0.1204308345913887,
0.5990904569625854,
0.7875678539276123,
-0.19614630937576294,
0.14109504222869873,
-0.03088657557964325,
0.2877308130264282,
-0.6270458698272705,
0.1385742574930191,
-1.0708472728729248,
-0.27124637365341187,
-0.32298168540000916,
-0.40731269121170044,
-0.4587206542491913,
-0.2381054311990738,
-0.1353953778743744,
-0.3479841351509094,
0.32950037717819214,
0.27843156456947327,
0.4551372826099396,
0.14296329021453857,
-0.041550613939762115,
-0.022472500801086426,
-0.7188892960548401,
0.9149616360664368,
-0.9733304977416992,
0.43538472056388855,
0.47751832008361816,
0.24137689173221588,
-0.30643370747566223,
-0.5167556405067444,
-0.6718241572380066,
-0.033097006380558014,
0.2848908305168152,
-0.21921060979366302,
-0.200913667678833,
-0.13798676431179047,
-0.017819151282310486,
0.2995973229408264,
-0.4185844957828522,
0.4049319326877594,
-0.32953378558158875,
-0.2715197205543518,
0.46933865547180176,
0.21371258795261383,
0.07711920887231827,
-0.06782824546098709,
-0.13709871470928192,
-0.23664696514606476,
-0.6900234222412109,
-0.21247857809066772,
0.2625354528427124,
0.45603227615356445,
-0.48396843671798706,
0.6841164231300354,
-0.21969972550868988,
0.5642226338386536,
0.13773709535598755,
-0.13241177797317505,
0.05326474457979202,
-0.23194320499897003,
-0.30150336027145386,
0.08523143082857132,
0.6745784282684326,
0.09949132055044174,
-0.12168043106794357,
-0.24122028052806854,
-0.10843798518180847,
0.2957194149494171,
-0.1293691247701645,
-1.0112378597259521,
-0.17931434512138367,
0.399495393037796,
-0.716289222240448,
-0.29846227169036865,
-0.011087127961218357,
-1.0064581632614136,
-0.4097784459590912,
-0.08959789574146271,
-0.10006780177354813,
-0.5038636326789856,
-0.16202856600284576,
0.4874432682991028,
-0.0774536058306694,
0.3895423412322998,
0.4117206633090973,
-0.8871681094169617,
0.07253696024417877,
0.6806934475898743,
0.803639829158783,
-0.12858468294143677,
-0.3004608452320099,
-0.6008660793304443,
0.09201990813016891,
-0.6524845957756042,
1.1339178085327148,
-0.7266854047775269,
-0.3375742435455322,
-0.17011046409606934,
-0.10738832503557205,
0.19672322273254395,
-0.22007742524147034,
0.5419489145278931,
-0.6972392797470093,
-0.01776355504989624,
-0.1232076957821846,
-0.6748957633972168,
-0.2922682464122772,
-0.04018152505159378,
-0.7412184476852417,
0.734732985496521,
0.24362823367118835,
-0.8358539342880249,
0.3488475978374481,
0.13358499109745026,
-0.25661295652389526,
0.06750740110874176,
-0.2692916989326477,
-0.09703180193901062,
0.42631280422210693,
0.3504696190357208,
0.5797448754310608,
-0.9394979476928711,
0.22422868013381958,
-0.6893529891967773,
-0.8441827297210693,
0.02987784892320633,
-0.6022070050239563,
0.5878353118896484,
0.19077029824256897,
-0.3779814839363098,
0.07583711296319962,
-0.7159826755523682,
-0.11908336728811264,
0.23092050850391388,
-0.35248222947120667,
-0.35083135962486267,
0.1379377841949463,
0.12280100584030151,
-0.032336100935935974,
-0.06270701438188553,
-0.40639153122901917,
0.14198026061058044,
-0.49168550968170166,
0.24099905788898468,
0.8082157373428345,
-0.1651357263326645,
0.3277163803577423,
-0.18974609673023224,
0.7792462110519409,
0.013638759031891823,
-0.2520293593406677,
-0.3934200704097748,
-0.37066420912742615,
-0.6385230422019958,
-0.45176467299461365,
0.45774927735328674,
0.3243355453014374,
-0.972080647945404,
0.6946669816970825,
-0.4341657757759094,
-0.6123114824295044,
-0.6765215992927551,
0.24386481940746307,
0.1574922353029251,
0.15409359335899353,
0.28422990441322327,
-0.05885232612490654,
-0.5705807209014893,
-0.7685580849647522,
-0.2594510614871979,
-0.3019941747188568,
-0.0675572082400322,
-0.17542152106761932,
0.08259359002113342,
-0.3895377218723297,
0.6440001726150513,
-0.3359088599681854,
0.04319501668214798,
-0.6355821490287781,
0.18624858558177948,
0.3261359632015228,
0.48314228653907776,
0.6467885971069336,
-0.3071705102920532,
-0.09224709868431091,
-0.05154410004615784,
-0.46785053610801697,
-0.08804858475923538,
-0.31461209058761597,
-0.24355988204479218,
0.1284262090921402,
0.5924290418624878,
-0.4977993071079254,
0.22064213454723358,
0.9352862238883972,
-0.5050878524780273,
0.4216291308403015,
-0.0742524117231369,
0.146001935005188,
-1.2789744138717651,
0.09893824905157089,
-0.17363663017749786,
-0.23575837910175323,
-0.3436316251754761,
0.08028154075145721,
0.06563166528940201,
0.06817298382520676,
-0.200625941157341,
0.6528750061988831,
-0.5845581293106079,
0.02151782438158989,
-0.6829639673233032,
-0.10964743793010712,
-0.11902642995119095,
0.2814820110797882,
0.09155700355768204,
0.9189911484718323,
0.491074800491333,
-0.41670992970466614,
-0.10807875543832779,
0.05588163435459137,
-0.2829693853855133,
-0.01148267462849617,
-0.7053890824317932,
0.014029781334102154,
-0.27962714433670044,
0.5388163328170776,
-0.8720428943634033,
-0.21257415413856506,
0.22833622992038727,
-0.25538188219070435,
0.2424948811531067,
0.021768584847450256,
-0.561458945274353,
-0.2634323835372925,
-0.4470456540584564,
0.7504078149795532,
0.6779778003692627,
-0.45774218440055847,
0.9295510053634644,
0.3879897892475128,
-0.1369561403989792,
-0.5871498584747314,
-0.7110647559165955,
0.19765539467334747,
-0.09431090205907822,
-0.14593268930912018,
0.1343833953142166,
0.008953808806836605,
-0.011463778093457222,
-0.11453519761562347,
0.04508938640356064,
0.1330735981464386,
0.04938025772571564,
0.07030794024467468,
0.455456018447876,
-0.2836090326309204,
-0.11831207573413849,
0.16456036269664764,
-0.22688961029052734,
-0.09966771304607391,
-0.3813819885253906,
0.8812289237976074,
0.08762185275554657,
-0.21490564942359924,
-0.607879102230072,
0.508281409740448,
0.6578993201255798,
-0.12511052191257477,
0.756502091884613,
0.5213482975959778,
-0.3501514494419098,
-0.49179181456565857,
-0.7946134805679321,
-0.2619907557964325,
-0.45931512117385864,
0.2953827679157257,
-0.3324951231479645,
-0.9093347787857056,
0.6820042729377747,
0.001829999266192317,
0.06212296709418297,
0.5171777009963989,
0.6268746852874756,
0.3196699023246765,
0.8653720617294312,
0.9527081847190857,
-0.49419474601745605,
0.3428679406642914,
-0.17194506525993347,
0.1800701916217804,
-0.5142392516136169,
-0.17041197419166565,
-0.8566593527793884,
-0.05089281499385834,
-0.3781200349330902,
-1.0766777992248535,
-0.18000230193138123,
0.3598000705242157,
0.28833329677581787,
0.4568474590778351,
-0.10015766322612762,
0.37551912665367126,
0.3134264647960663,
-0.17862467467784882,
0.46700555086135864,
0.21189624071121216,
-0.17228972911834717,
0.1695297509431839,
-0.987018346786499,
-0.3208734095096588,
1.047842025756836,
0.41288167238235474,
1.1998965740203857,
-0.19466689229011536,
0.4435456097126007,
0.21587388217449188,
0.43372654914855957,
-0.7931022047996521,
0.5319979190826416,
-0.0973614752292633,
-0.3889470100402832,
-0.02222546748816967,
-0.5389765501022339,
-0.7871034741401672,
0.31273090839385986,
-0.44063708186149597,
-0.6003625988960266,
0.4286612272262573,
0.2616570293903351,
-0.31102418899536133,
0.48933666944503784,
-0.34545546770095825,
0.38825851678848267,
0.04005158692598343,
-0.3062015771865845,
-0.48604488372802734,
-0.3655698299407959,
0.7934834361076355,
-0.5218472480773926,
0.0647687017917633,
-0.28029727935791016,
-0.14068594574928284,
0.565108060836792,
-0.2460308074951172,
0.9695373773574829,
0.16881197690963745,
-0.4238477945327759,
0.29619279503822327,
0.23236288130283356,
0.5765303373336792,
0.004494632128626108,
-0.37299463152885437,
0.3248344361782074,
0.10544787347316742,
-0.6294196844100952,
-0.5402213931083679,
0.6270325779914856,
-0.4539252817630768,
-0.23187856376171112,
-0.444426566362381,
-0.5945179462432861,
-0.3517611622810364,
0.26747098565101624,
0.23455050587654114,
0.4854748845100403,
-0.1366063803434372,
0.14624901115894318,
0.3212831914424896,
-0.28543582558631897,
0.2950277626514435,
0.3977701663970947,
-0.16468508541584015,
-0.4045381546020508,
0.6855918169021606,
-0.28725534677505493,
0.09856213629245758,
0.3215271830558777,
0.10852918028831482,
-0.508264422416687,
-0.9651225209236145,
-0.4433431625366211,
0.566082239151001,
-0.5345441699028015,
-0.3761526346206665,
-0.8263677358627319,
0.24767842888832092,
-0.49493688344955444,
-0.1759604662656784,
-0.4777778387069702,
-0.2527225613594055,
-0.22912119328975677,
0.029195576906204224,
0.26236966252326965,
0.5164533257484436,
0.13101062178611755,
0.3837324380874634,
-1.060512900352478,
0.4782542884349823,
-0.16204863786697388,
0.3383617401123047,
0.43832144141197205,
-0.4646145701408386,
-0.2656291425228119,
-0.13859985768795013,
0.345455139875412,
-0.7737842202186584,
0.38269564509391785,
0.011616356670856476,
0.47361063957214355,
0.6478455662727356,
0.10409920662641525,
0.9700574278831482,
-0.4430343210697174,
0.5773360729217529,
0.1986304372549057,
-0.8452954292297363,
0.052767906337976456,
-0.36493349075317383,
0.44195014238357544,
0.7611085772514343,
0.19053491950035095,
-0.40878087282180786,
-0.5489336252212524,
-0.42162784934043884,
-0.8113032579421997,
0.5624511241912842,
-0.059730809181928635,
0.2871117889881134,
-0.273112028837204,
0.357558935880661,
0.37163713574409485,
0.15336757898330688,
-0.28439831733703613,
0.0561697892844677,
0.0009069648222066462,
-0.22938689589500427,
-0.35310429334640503,
-0.48700517416000366,
0.16819608211517334,
-0.16355152428150177,
0.6292176842689514,
-0.47738343477249146,
0.28849464654922485,
-0.045594170689582825,
0.04888560622930527,
-0.21151472628116608,
0.0962417721748352,
0.3090081214904785,
0.4668237268924713,
-0.16778430342674255,
0.12514030933380127,
0.09694679081439972,
-0.35308170318603516,
0.12971657514572144,
0.22849005460739136,
-0.20849677920341492,
-0.02066362090408802,
0.7926694750785828,
0.6722058653831482,
0.3387822210788727,
-1.0675569772720337,
0.1797388345003128,
-0.2506762146949768,
0.01967858523130417,
-0.000028782569643226452,
-0.14140699803829193,
0.2740634083747864,
0.29635119438171387,
0.4377985894680023,
0.047763075679540634,
0.10370637476444244,
-0.6540899872779846,
0.2543751001358032,
0.4174553155899048,
-0.0647384524345398,
-0.35672780871391296,
0.8304761052131653,
0.11060163378715515,
0.24029766023159027,
0.4259544014930725,
-0.05178156495094299,
-0.2165287286043167,
0.40191754698753357,
0.7215909361839294,
1.1830296516418457,
-0.07910197228193283,
0.027793364599347115,
0.26004672050476074,
0.2174515277147293,
-0.3902462124824524,
0.41303977370262146,
-0.026276500895619392,
-0.6967676877975464,
-0.6430341005325317,
-1.0429669618606567,
-0.05918837711215019,
0.035519618541002274,
-0.4675943851470947,
0.006793862208724022,
-0.5088642239570618,
-0.07108405232429504,
-0.35972338914871216,
-0.1380787193775177,
-0.5552352666854858,
-0.04640074074268341,
0.1486508995294571,
1.2458761930465698,
-0.8229039311408997,
0.9922779202461243,
0.1526176631450653,
-0.04207121208310127,
-1.156598687171936,
0.3420368731021881,
-0.024282867088913918,
-0.7341344356536865,
0.26534539461135864,
0.15162397921085358,
-0.6243883371353149,
-0.032468490302562714,
-0.27278631925582886,
-0.8665734529495239,
0.9964492321014404,
0.5189933776855469,
-0.6462704539299011,
-0.16892103850841522,
-0.2073596566915512,
0.40139225125312805,
-0.529972493648529,
0.26031607389450073,
0.7285051941871643,
0.26026785373687744,
0.29350030422210693,
-0.4116710424423218,
0.34828072786331177,
-0.19276340305805206,
0.366989403963089,
-0.1776416003704071,
-0.4822677969932556,
0.7290998697280884,
-0.2381167709827423,
-0.4370269477367401,
0.6497355103492737,
1.1192128658294678,
0.4770745635032654,
-0.15790465474128723,
0.5085183382034302,
0.266096293926239,
0.63370680809021,
0.19885776937007904,
1.2672597169876099,
-0.6270970702171326,
0.08301059901714325,
1.0085631608963013,
-0.26592734456062317,
1.1122262477874756,
0.47102996706962585,
0.03623577579855919,
0.3470529019832611,
0.6522022485733032,
0.14345590770244598,
0.28090083599090576,
-0.024565421044826508,
-0.12347886711359024,
-0.4964432716369629,
-0.16158050298690796,
-0.37827956676483154,
0.7069692611694336,
0.26047465205192566,
-0.3305637240409851,
-0.43433454632759094,
-0.23972924053668976,
-0.02006632834672928,
0.05954856798052788,
-0.1830083727836609,
0.40438151359558105,
0.16886179149150848,
-0.5432275533676147,
0.7430111765861511,
0.45130616426467896,
1.0396673679351807,
-0.7774685025215149,
-0.14198049902915955,
-0.2806493639945984,
0.1771545261144638,
0.1819215714931488,
-0.19451701641082764,
0.10493882745504379,
-0.04398188367486,
0.04857882112264633,
0.1631409078836441,
0.5618100762367249,
-0.5515427589416504,
-0.949609100818634,
0.5705175995826721,
0.6034635901451111,
0.042347315698862076,
0.12242761999368668,
-0.5943399667739868,
0.5349577069282532,
-0.07282080501317978,
-0.12137807905673981,
0.15624640882015228,
0.32213273644447327,
-0.04385397583246231,
0.6667110323905945,
0.9278547763824463,
0.38941505551338196,
0.026425490155816078,
0.0459056980907917,
1.002508521080017,
-0.6804028153419495,
-0.7319599390029907,
-0.6816525459289551,
0.05797182396054268,
0.22226500511169434,
-0.09703565388917923,
0.7709364891052246,
0.4499155879020691,
0.4824908673763275,
-0.15815800428390503,
0.6972303986549377,
0.14670921862125397,
0.47745683789253235,
-0.8319003582000732,
0.691377580165863,
-0.520014762878418,
0.36796835064888,
-0.19482839107513428,
-1.055095911026001,
-0.14488038420677185,
0.35666435956954956,
0.07749965041875839,
0.0158028956502676,
0.5810339450836182,
0.8229670524597168,
-0.1888558566570282,
0.06080489605665207,
0.19386054575443268,
0.2991763651371002,
0.3221253454685211,
0.3811954855918884,
0.5781784057617188,
-0.3444531559944153,
0.23604799807071686,
-0.12176802009344101,
-0.1913054883480072,
-0.27270951867103577,
-0.928774893283844,
-0.9882199764251709,
-0.22548525035381317,
0.10511026531457901,
-0.42281872034072876,
-0.02073422260582447,
1.0699200630187988,
0.7984278202056885,
-0.7936961650848389,
-0.3660881221294403,
-0.0023997521493583918,
-0.17828364670276642,
-0.3333495855331421,
-0.1676245629787445,
0.38117918372154236,
-0.1632096916437149,
-0.9852043390274048,
0.7787244915962219,
0.156016007065773,
0.18525388836860657,
-0.46031907200813293,
-0.03735492005944252,
-0.09662604331970215,
0.46214956045150757,
0.5421791672706604,
0.3124464452266693,
-0.6782602667808533,
-0.08547114580869675,
-0.17776241898536682,
-0.006083901040256023,
-0.2204655408859253,
1.0960686206817627,
-1.00705885887146,
0.1594114750623703,
0.8159707188606262,
1.0824155807495117,
0.3614037036895752,
0.2695026099681854,
0.946236789226532,
-0.06688939779996872,
0.6144250631332397,
0.3476979434490204,
0.4052582383155823,
0.23677700757980347,
-0.30066224932670593,
0.08709177374839783,
0.21288944780826569,
-0.0024229600094258785,
-0.7740851640701294,
0.1251753866672516,
-1.0720421075820923,
-0.5944427251815796,
0.9773735404014587,
0.04865388572216034,
-0.5343759655952454,
-0.09254281222820282,
0.03884264454245567,
0.10878630727529526,
-0.4248944818973541,
0.8675984144210815,
0.3783729374408722,
0.24709923565387726,
-0.2529211640357971,
-0.32973337173461914,
0.3586256802082062,
0.49103063344955444,
-0.790891170501709,
0.3697509765625,
0.6504439115524292,
0.2758713960647583,
-0.13123756647109985,
0.8971462845802307,
-0.16361108422279358,
0.10668779909610748,
0.36735424399375916,
-0.09352747350931168,
-0.05547359213232994,
-0.4984855651855469,
-0.5367896556854248,
0.2534393072128296,
0.15642096102237701,
0.13637785613536835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15755v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15755v2
|
Dental Severity Assessment through Few-shot Learning and SBERT Fine-tuning
| 2024-02-24T08:02:19 | 2024-04-06T08:18:57 |
Mohammad Dehghani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dental diseases have a significant impact on a considerable portion of the
population, leading to various health issues that can detrimentally affect
individuals' overall well-being. The integration of automated systems in oral
healthcare has become increasingly crucial. Machine learning approaches offer a
viable solution to address challenges such as diagnostic difficulties,
inefficiencies, and errors in oral disease diagnosis. These methods prove
particularly useful when physicians struggle to predict or diagnose diseases at
their early stages. In this study, thirteen different machine learning, deep
learning, and large language models were employed to determine the severity
level of oral health issues based on radiologists' reports. The results
revealed that the Few-shot learning with SBERT and Multi-Layer Perceptron model
outperformed all other models across various experiments, achieving an
impressive accuracy of 94.1% as the best result. Consequently, this model
exhibits promise as a reliable tool for evaluating the severity of oral
diseases, enabling patients to receive more effective treatment and aiding
healthcare professionals in making informed decisions regarding resource
allocation and the management of high-risk patients.
|
[
-0.13044710457324982,
-1.013623595237732,
0.6770235896110535,
-0.18569684028625488,
-0.2585665285587311,
-0.040041059255599976,
-0.310432493686676,
-0.5486949682235718,
0.03921595960855484,
0.22534261643886566,
-0.3948166072368622,
-0.557162344455719,
-0.8029833436012268,
0.23727206885814667,
0.03827550634741783,
0.632331132888794,
0.2651937007904053,
0.7228750586509705,
-0.22620002925395966,
0.08004487305879593,
-0.6375003457069397,
0.14211507141590118,
-0.5363573431968689,
-0.43042653799057007,
0.6468735337257385,
0.553795337677002,
0.8000379800796509,
0.2944614887237549,
1.1989532709121704,
0.354653000831604,
0.1829308569431305,
0.19632557034492493,
-0.321617066860199,
0.06898924708366394,
-0.16389727592468262,
-0.23892861604690552,
-0.35332995653152466,
-0.5301192402839661,
0.17537592351436615,
1.0450334548950195,
0.15727615356445312,
0.3627745807170868,
-0.04657648131251335,
0.4551991820335388,
-0.5516913533210754,
0.10284809023141861,
-0.5618486404418945,
0.35840606689453125,
-0.3450881838798523,
-0.1516101360321045,
-0.2246152013540268,
-0.2780783772468567,
0.3845342993736267,
-0.3277336061000824,
-0.18483710289001465,
-0.3946710228919983,
0.8649383187294006,
0.5432508587837219,
-0.15607120096683502,
-0.14349372684955597,
-0.7193092703819275,
0.8038065433502197,
-0.611433207988739,
0.17644479870796204,
0.3989165425300598,
0.49617600440979004,
-0.07429567724466324,
-0.64680016040802,
-0.2385360449552536,
-0.12459356337785721,
0.04318004846572876,
0.23942270874977112,
-0.5870009660720825,
0.21357128024101257,
0.18909838795661926,
0.15475547313690186,
-0.7772543430328369,
0.6433524489402771,
-0.4461900293827057,
-0.1580430567264557,
0.3156222105026245,
0.47570475935935974,
0.3924676477909088,
-0.486154705286026,
-0.4212416708469391,
-0.1957680583000183,
-0.3348221480846405,
0.21585586667060852,
-0.271538108587265,
0.94298255443573,
0.22681015729904175,
0.3160112798213959,
-0.2062118649482727,
0.5847756266593933,
0.17180614173412323,
-0.6686074137687683,
0.3634755313396454,
-0.055301032960414886,
-0.6924027800559998,
0.12690190970897675,
0.6401277184486389,
0.19644568860530853,
-0.43754756450653076,
0.16095618903636932,
-0.2435372918844223,
0.12577398121356964,
0.43972745537757874,
-0.8817071318626404,
-0.16306743025779724,
0.22561120986938477,
-0.5397422313690186,
-0.510757565498352,
-0.139293372631073,
-0.6233547925949097,
-0.4739236831665039,
-0.37528732419013977,
0.6062069535255432,
-0.6250044703483582,
-0.23284794390201569,
0.009954383596777916,
-0.013865156099200249,
0.07191648334264755,
0.6766501069068909,
-0.7188702821731567,
0.36752474308013916,
0.5627937316894531,
0.7511451840400696,
-0.199068084359169,
0.01810269244015217,
-0.5986077189445496,
-0.2014433890581131,
-0.28264477849006653,
1.1420658826828003,
-0.5367509126663208,
-0.1845647096633911,
-0.15034008026123047,
-0.25096026062965393,
-0.1228613555431366,
-0.9366195797920227,
0.2672520875930786,
-0.18593765795230865,
-0.40842482447624207,
0.22955945134162903,
-0.3810140788555145,
-0.27243876457214355,
0.20278453826904297,
-0.45560479164123535,
0.4553447663784027,
0.6273365616798401,
-0.2611581087112427,
0.5520146489143372,
-0.22114373743534088,
-0.7159339785575867,
0.6242818832397461,
-0.05608285963535309,
-0.8566104769706726,
0.49676623940467834,
0.13935486972332,
0.6389076709747314,
-0.2852626144886017,
0.21012139320373535,
-0.4504079520702362,
-0.08701889216899872,
0.06193605437874794,
-0.15906448662281036,
0.7177782654762268,
0.1631658524274826,
-0.04847164452075958,
0.39139318466186523,
-0.6427528262138367,
0.17278122901916504,
-0.03323638066649437,
-0.0916026309132576,
-0.2056150734424591,
-0.40574750304222107,
-0.21172812581062317,
0.2877495288848877,
0.006692454218864441,
-0.133384108543396,
-0.0037574388552457094,
-0.5103976726531982,
0.311163067817688,
0.7940988540649414,
0.4238766133785248,
0.021759124472737312,
-0.5066370368003845,
0.5815314054489136,
0.28467845916748047,
0.5275622010231018,
-0.19543114304542542,
-0.4839498698711395,
-0.2283877432346344,
-0.22212865948677063,
0.5876589417457581,
0.5762780904769897,
-0.34434446692466736,
0.43685269355773926,
-0.5808722376823425,
-0.8008059859275818,
-0.7445605397224426,
0.2592920660972595,
0.5549598932266235,
0.649034321308136,
0.38867852091789246,
-0.6929840445518494,
-0.15639854967594147,
-0.5835826396942139,
0.14626142382621765,
0.10707566142082214,
0.08726631104946136,
0.37313222885131836,
0.4417330324649811,
-0.48381397128105164,
0.69084233045578,
-0.3145419657230377,
-0.6835722923278809,
-0.15704385936260223,
0.23526501655578613,
0.045090705156326294,
0.5121373534202576,
0.5025652050971985,
-0.5537461042404175,
-0.6130560636520386,
0.33735114336013794,
-0.7655792236328125,
0.19959081709384918,
0.24977509677410126,
0.3199104070663452,
0.15404565632343292,
0.08202426880598068,
-0.2933124303817749,
0.6806530356407166,
0.33327406644821167,
0.24462907016277313,
0.3834177553653717,
-0.25542858242988586,
0.06946200132369995,
-0.31222954392433167,
-0.1235673651099205,
0.29997897148132324,
-0.371427983045578,
-0.5011825561523438,
-0.11870342493057251,
0.03879953548312187,
-0.33873674273490906,
-0.8646504878997803,
0.2398940920829773,
0.17004962265491486,
0.04304872825741768,
-0.20239463448524475,
-0.2818302512168884,
-0.15854963660240173,
0.062244486063718796,
-0.2980301082134247,
0.4391971230506897,
0.8528057336807251,
-0.7462543249130249,
0.5407072901725769,
0.05891052260994911,
-0.4597875475883484,
0.4082306921482086,
-0.6260489225387573,
0.07030535489320755,
-0.056601859629154205,
-0.09723006188869476,
-0.8140697479248047,
-0.6648999452590942,
0.031845059245824814,
-0.693773090839386,
0.4721970558166504,
-0.04930783808231354,
-0.27059733867645264,
-0.5543991923332214,
-0.25631338357925415,
0.05175253376364708,
0.3450091779232025,
-0.18283767998218536,
0.31581467390060425,
0.5270856022834778,
-0.47907331585884094,
-0.5043980479240417,
-0.7515861392021179,
-0.05633525177836418,
-0.17976579070091248,
-0.775127112865448,
0.47681042551994324,
-0.00212486507371068,
-0.3497409224510193,
0.12371286004781723,
-0.23132272064685822,
-0.4172065854072571,
0.20956633985042572,
0.3958754539489746,
0.1484905332326889,
-0.5822702646255493,
0.3771941661834717,
0.2435392439365387,
-0.4368266761302948,
-0.3418404757976532,
0.062180135399103165,
0.5793230533599854,
-0.23400427401065826,
-0.3229944109916687,
-0.9646454453468323,
0.02906174771487713,
0.31675130128860474,
-0.16220486164093018,
0.354833722114563,
0.4781647324562073,
-0.725279688835144,
0.06691666692495346,
-0.32349488139152527,
-0.2898012399673462,
-0.4047742187976837,
0.40591859817504883,
-0.5434994101524353,
-0.7018746733665466,
0.5074400305747986,
-0.4495946168899536,
-0.36724692583084106,
0.5682796239852905,
0.6683496236801147,
-0.3242025375366211,
1.1303164958953857,
0.5510365962982178,
-0.009042801335453987,
0.35156741738319397,
-0.038007598370313644,
-0.02171926572918892,
-0.16814838349819183,
-0.15044818818569183,
-0.524924099445343,
-0.16420277953147888,
-0.6991570591926575,
0.11164127290248871,
0.638225257396698,
-0.06487427651882172,
-0.17028625309467316,
0.3128414750099182,
-0.5059513449668884,
0.35381126403808594,
0.35816633701324463,
0.6374977827072144,
0.1281825602054596,
-0.09728044271469116,
-0.06040938198566437,
-0.1449301689863205,
-0.5431509017944336,
-0.5228148102760315,
1.0228573083877563,
0.4219682216644287,
0.766826331615448,
0.13623669743537903,
0.7376927733421326,
0.5527018308639526,
0.04160333424806595,
-0.9882545471191406,
-0.011666391976177692,
-0.6809960603713989,
-0.2772134840488434,
-0.6666356921195984,
-0.49132370948791504,
-1.1248942613601685,
0.15422466397285461,
-0.26428383588790894,
-0.5342490077018738,
0.29326221346855164,
0.0005739766056649387,
-1.2847483158111572,
-0.1830180287361145,
-0.8228721618652344,
1.177251935005188,
-0.40490975975990295,
-0.22895149886608124,
-0.4588504135608673,
-0.9554839134216309,
0.11106764525175095,
-0.021182682365179062,
0.24835169315338135,
-0.36544743180274963,
0.29712945222854614,
0.6045792102813721,
-0.21732884645462036,
0.9440889954566956,
-0.0597955696284771,
0.14069156348705292,
-0.10907050222158432,
0.04644829034805298,
0.06433132290840149,
0.2951328754425049,
-0.08786320686340332,
0.07831045985221863,
-0.04452567175030708,
-0.3809923827648163,
-0.5726065635681152,
0.6695197224617004,
-0.9874842762947083,
-0.41321271657943726,
-0.4130259156227112,
-0.14225900173187256,
-0.24900802969932556,
0.6995818614959717,
-0.012818960472941399,
0.4228350818157196,
-0.4109012484550476,
-0.2158399224281311,
0.815976619720459,
-0.4052788019180298,
0.2235954850912094,
0.24416960775852203,
0.04416988044977188,
-0.49560707807540894,
1.0201337337493896,
0.2825625538825989,
0.2516340911388397,
0.5151165723800659,
0.541994035243988,
0.26083987951278687,
-0.6578739285469055,
-0.4133889973163605,
0.08325120806694031,
-0.9699945449829102,
-0.9553407430648804,
-0.2675997018814087,
-0.18972551822662354,
-0.7599858641624451,
-0.03381216526031494,
-0.4411157965660095,
-0.01786402240395546,
-0.5576767325401306,
-0.06610391288995743,
0.21846018731594086,
0.7072916030883789,
-0.011239745654165745,
0.469463586807251,
-0.8098548650741577,
0.4458443522453308,
0.4483188986778259,
0.25276240706443787,
-0.2523609399795532,
-0.44318458437919617,
-0.1449727863073349,
-0.14507415890693665,
-0.4175616502761841,
-0.5596753358840942,
0.5312012434005737,
0.08779822289943695,
0.3328930735588074,
0.7865905165672302,
0.0719919502735138,
0.8478711843490601,
-0.18804633617401123,
0.39202621579170227,
0.3815455734729767,
-0.9068478345870972,
0.8043458461761475,
-0.11320701986551285,
0.2102694809436798,
0.8880840539932251,
0.4598097801208496,
-0.38810232281684875,
-0.10182525217533112,
-0.5764371752738953,
-0.6259747743606567,
0.7081649303436279,
-0.44443756341934204,
-0.040021706372499466,
0.04590579494833946,
0.08646808564662933,
0.4329398274421692,
-0.22374756634235382,
-0.37868306040763855,
-0.051704250276088715,
-0.2837608754634857,
-0.1922566443681717,
0.21575285494327545,
-0.1353216916322708,
0.0016167747089639306,
-0.5510749220848083,
0.6579539179801941,
-0.1510131061077118,
0.23672284185886383,
0.05665302276611328,
-0.8186267018318176,
-0.7208908796310425,
0.3359864056110382,
0.9956845641136169,
1.0078659057617188,
-0.5350750684738159,
0.39310649037361145,
0.2511579692363739,
-0.280558705329895,
-0.22466342151165009,
0.009866632521152496,
0.056968022137880325,
0.06997955590486526,
0.5024616122245789,
0.7326571941375732,
0.09088779240846634,
-0.6017798185348511,
0.7833265066146851,
0.13776841759681702,
-0.1366989016532898,
-0.24354752898216248,
0.10934209823608398,
-0.2117442935705185,
0.07765311747789383,
0.24429219961166382,
0.5774098038673401,
0.103685162961483,
-0.43727171421051025,
0.337997704744339,
0.33834752440452576,
-1.0274240970611572,
-0.2126004844903946,
0.11574194580316544,
0.3492922782897949,
-0.13255958259105682,
1.0525774955749512,
-0.2422170341014862,
-0.36527612805366516,
0.7775208353996277,
0.461532860994339,
0.39080342650413513,
-0.552337646484375,
0.17367273569107056,
0.426851361989975,
0.20141027867794037,
0.14230051636695862,
-0.16524143517017365,
0.43001842498779297,
-0.5770164132118225,
-0.3866662383079529,
-0.5574405193328857,
-0.23644128441810608,
0.20739230513572693,
-0.8249372839927673,
0.6243162155151367,
-0.6387466192245483,
-0.33666154742240906,
0.6833994388580322,
0.33188536763191223,
-0.822557806968689,
0.4243617057800293,
0.40504276752471924,
0.6431801319122314,
-0.8673234581947327,
0.5052854418754578,
0.5779900550842285,
-0.8989648222923279,
-0.4122757017612457,
-0.26294463872909546,
0.39044660329818726,
-1.294409990310669,
0.8657218217849731,
0.30439484119415283,
-0.12330204248428345,
0.010717318393290043,
-0.37000924348831177,
-0.7459399700164795,
0.9175907373428345,
0.428812175989151,
-0.5949259996414185,
0.17974072694778442,
0.1661788821220398,
0.485776424407959,
-0.0426672138273716,
0.42649000883102417,
0.6381206512451172,
0.6783861517906189,
-0.10674237459897995,
-1.4144272804260254,
-0.004343785811215639,
0.14152836799621582,
0.09863374382257462,
0.14186885952949524,
-0.28539973497390747,
0.8135692477226257,
-0.4979138970375061,
-0.25902268290519714,
-0.23226842284202576,
0.38686510920524597,
-0.1431555151939392,
0.44017067551612854,
0.28368091583251953,
0.8957460522651672,
0.9579029679298401,
0.04324687644839287,
0.917178750038147,
0.057542089372873306,
0.26544690132141113,
0.6533953547477722,
-0.12697447836399078,
0.6906121373176575,
-0.012671161442995071,
-0.5287795662879944,
0.22688598930835724,
0.8074073195457458,
-0.23754751682281494,
0.6062257885932922,
0.37483444809913635,
-0.19038613140583038,
-0.5302947163581848,
-0.22095844149589539,
-0.2758704125881195,
0.7202931642532349,
0.5220898389816284,
-0.22714079916477203,
-0.33036208152770996,
0.672156572341919,
-0.04529561474919319,
-0.2368931621313095,
-0.7113195061683655,
1.1834357976913452,
0.08757008612155914,
-0.28349241614341736,
0.3651200532913208,
0.06647081673145294,
0.7231796383857727,
-0.360881507396698,
-0.09300117194652557,
0.0248486939817667,
0.4932628571987152,
-0.6192197203636169,
-0.5654376745223999,
0.3538976311683655,
-0.1823328137397766,
-0.3951737880706787,
-0.1263575553894043,
0.9361425042152405,
0.09542886167764664,
-0.5741192102432251,
0.0933476984500885,
0.47171294689178467,
0.29405564069747925,
-0.16107776761054993,
-0.6866404414176941,
-0.04091442748904228,
-0.2640693783760071,
0.15346276760101318,
0.47111067175865173,
0.427319198846817,
0.04201217740774155,
0.5918948650360107,
0.3409009575843811,
0.02672690525650978,
-0.0762355774641037,
0.3915802240371704,
0.5763038396835327,
-0.5873005390167236,
0.13309665024280548,
-1.0364586114883423,
0.32254233956336975,
0.3265494108200073,
-0.32872676849365234,
0.4363175928592682,
0.4813350439071655,
0.8293434381484985,
-0.16501116752624512,
0.6836918592453003,
0.22515159845352173,
0.7387920022010803,
-0.29952263832092285,
0.6020892858505249,
-0.41350775957107544,
0.032391294836997986,
-0.4567321538925171,
-0.03691842406988144,
-1.0471256971359253,
0.6745127439498901,
-0.2535354197025299,
-0.061130594462156296,
0.6214851140975952,
0.6040590405464172,
0.006370079703629017,
-0.3471692204475403,
0.4805624783039093,
0.13290651142597198,
0.1243617832660675,
0.4083736836910248,
0.6485830545425415,
-0.20856289565563202,
0.4624938368797302,
-0.647402286529541,
-0.24179412424564362,
-0.6990736126899719,
-0.4063206911087036,
-0.5161064267158508,
-0.2976609468460083,
-0.49846550822257996,
-0.14651508629322052,
0.05674203857779503,
1.0993915796279907,
0.7858317494392395,
-0.8255475163459778,
0.049821510910987854,
0.12116623669862747,
0.22729623317718506,
-0.5463088750839233,
-0.16804945468902588,
0.6370351910591125,
-0.8061960935592651,
-0.40134748816490173,
0.22624842822551727,
0.6134506464004517,
0.10182856023311615,
-0.1009124368429184,
0.046675290912389755,
0.40514519810676575,
-0.49153995513916016,
0.6560477614402771,
0.18504206836223602,
-0.8925933241844177,
-0.14940761029720306,
0.07152999937534332,
-0.4158768951892853,
0.5331193208694458,
0.32729002833366394,
-0.9112262725830078,
0.5281617045402527,
0.18843798339366913,
0.6778983473777771,
0.4194852113723755,
-0.21738220751285553,
0.10489710420370102,
-0.3463796079158783,
-0.3249392509460449,
0.7094547152519226,
0.031613416969776154,
0.2027616649866104,
-0.3710090219974518,
0.10510781407356262,
0.14832666516304016,
-0.3712635636329651,
-0.9301679134368896,
-0.06442689895629883,
-1.164214849472046,
-0.6092907190322876,
0.6836733818054199,
-0.17743250727653503,
-0.35618820786476135,
-0.13910239934921265,
0.2907426953315735,
0.3615572452545166,
-0.4519754946231842,
0.7810115814208984,
0.38912999629974365,
-0.740995466709137,
-0.15600429475307465,
-0.5602027773857117,
0.47696998715400696,
0.18292471766471863,
-0.8914509415626526,
-0.34927377104759216,
0.12284901738166809,
0.33950933814048767,
0.14029930531978607,
0.4430239498615265,
0.004831582307815552,
0.5943146347999573,
-0.046207476407289505,
0.020986514165997505,
0.04847600311040878,
-0.303791344165802,
-0.4692084789276123,
0.26278531551361084,
0.2738654315471649,
0.08456172049045563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15754v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15754v1
|
HD-Eval: Aligning Large Language Model Evaluators Through Hierarchical Criteria Decomposition
| 2024-02-24T08:01:32 | 2024-02-24T08:01:32 |
Yuxuan Liu, Tianchi Yang, Shaohan Huang, Zihan Zhang, Haizhen Huang, Furu Wei, Weiwei Deng, Feng Sun, Qi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as a promising alternative to
expensive human evaluations. However, the alignment and coverage of LLM-based
evaluations are often limited by the scope and potential bias of the evaluation
prompts and criteria. To address this challenge, we propose HD-Eval, a novel
framework that iteratively aligns LLM-based evaluators with human preference
via Hierarchical Criteria Decomposition. HD-Eval inherits the essence from the
evaluation mindset of human experts and enhances the alignment of LLM-based
evaluators by decomposing a given evaluation task into finer-grained criteria,
aggregating them according to estimated human preferences, pruning
insignificant criteria with attribution, and further decomposing significant
criteria. By integrating these steps within an iterative alignment training
process, we obtain a hierarchical decomposition of criteria that
comprehensively captures aspects of natural language at multiple levels of
granularity. Implemented as a white box, the human preference-guided aggregator
is efficient to train and more explainable than relying solely on prompting,
and its independence from model parameters makes it applicable to closed-source
LLMs. Extensive experiments on three evaluation domains demonstrate the
superiority of HD-Eval in further aligning state-of-the-art evaluators and
providing deeper insights into the explanation of evaluation results and the
task itself.
|
[
-0.48887011408805847,
-0.8215829133987427,
0.5871167182922363,
-0.007254475262016058,
-0.03195970878005028,
0.30893585085868835,
-0.5727579593658447,
0.07882452756166458,
0.0024716220796108246,
0.4221011698246002,
-0.4386458992958069,
-0.6556546688079834,
-0.37465977668762207,
-0.026094025000929832,
-0.27101024985313416,
1.078874111175537,
-0.04934674873948097,
-0.19867371022701263,
-0.47638431191444397,
-0.001410564174875617,
-0.3053559362888336,
-0.4310876131057739,
-0.32860875129699707,
-0.439463347196579,
0.40179699659347534,
0.4075698256492615,
0.8030409216880798,
0.8630197644233704,
0.5942705869674683,
0.2950145900249481,
-0.0940566137433052,
-0.013791954144835472,
-0.5134156942367554,
-0.08800483494997025,
-0.35832908749580383,
-0.02120204269886017,
-0.6163164973258972,
-0.062243033200502396,
0.8036893010139465,
0.8169200420379639,
-0.4398820102214813,
0.3998386561870575,
0.24510644376277924,
0.9065825343132019,
-1.0081870555877686,
0.10605791211128235,
-0.6097827553749084,
-0.18715783953666687,
-0.056811992079019547,
-0.40458202362060547,
-0.5186096429824829,
-0.4266384541988373,
0.06891696900129318,
-0.33077582716941833,
0.010749135166406631,
0.10823842883110046,
0.7736479640007019,
0.384838342666626,
-0.4837507903575897,
0.1839243769645691,
-0.6472793221473694,
0.9448757171630859,
-0.4613875448703766,
0.5452771186828613,
0.4069499671459198,
0.39803212881088257,
0.05884435027837753,
-0.060056935995817184,
-0.4713161885738373,
-0.17316129803657532,
-0.04318861663341522,
-0.05745438113808632,
-0.16656996309757233,
0.23523208498954773,
-0.09782910346984863,
0.4484955668449402,
-0.6893258094787598,
0.468997985124588,
-0.28777024149894714,
-0.24253320693969727,
0.6763025522232056,
0.32745835185050964,
0.11712311208248138,
-0.2885931134223938,
-0.4157733917236328,
0.06552066653966904,
-0.5612075328826904,
-0.01735920086503029,
0.32315751910209656,
0.38968122005462646,
-0.14903175830841064,
0.5846562385559082,
-0.16618336737155914,
0.8208537101745605,
0.2589173913002014,
-0.3211432099342346,
0.2746502757072449,
-0.3762388825416565,
-0.25950887799263,
0.20475563406944275,
0.9248949885368347,
0.41204845905303955,
-0.02514304779469967,
0.049092233180999756,
-0.46048465371131897,
0.34281182289123535,
0.4372738003730774,
-0.7114405632019043,
0.1070355772972107,
0.42344769835472107,
-0.47473570704460144,
-0.42772406339645386,
-0.20831626653671265,
-0.8101270794868469,
-0.4613697826862335,
-0.7257412075996399,
0.3312767744064331,
-0.15028908848762512,
-0.13941694796085358,
0.08330246061086655,
0.2558686435222626,
0.16781353950500488,
0.2582753598690033,
-1.1199554204940796,
0.4626113474369049,
0.9614734649658203,
0.5481036901473999,
-0.42863988876342773,
-0.33351701498031616,
-0.9059929251670837,
-0.0971740260720253,
-0.3309103548526764,
0.751665472984314,
-0.771977961063385,
0.02289636991918087,
0.15315793454647064,
-0.43741321563720703,
-0.03949766233563423,
-0.6402741074562073,
0.5134850144386292,
-0.5542086362838745,
0.24481616914272308,
0.037522587925195694,
-0.5574995279312134,
0.11740025132894516,
0.5037742853164673,
-0.5477784872055054,
1.076518177986145,
0.349041610956192,
-0.6701039671897888,
0.2763155996799469,
-0.7730573415756226,
-0.15202009677886963,
0.20679856836795807,
-0.2026464194059372,
-0.3408486545085907,
0.03707687929272652,
0.4039054214954376,
0.39924684166908264,
-0.5441129803657532,
0.6365523934364319,
-0.20613567531108856,
-0.4725586771965027,
0.027340929955244064,
-0.45093709230422974,
0.860741376876831,
0.20151905715465546,
-0.19321829080581665,
0.5954734086990356,
-0.6902276873588562,
-0.005405752919614315,
-0.2618619203567505,
-0.609895646572113,
-0.1747213453054428,
-0.07802605628967285,
0.11235634982585907,
0.003956022672355175,
0.41980811953544617,
-0.45135292410850525,
0.19787302613258362,
-0.4143768846988678,
0.1900012344121933,
0.9724366664886475,
-0.27836477756500244,
0.5682961940765381,
-0.24053652584552765,
0.8331856727600098,
-0.18765614926815033,
-0.028083560988307,
-0.1666165292263031,
0.12879689037799835,
-0.5312879085540771,
-0.4947781562805176,
0.3099682629108429,
0.350923091173172,
-0.3935934007167816,
1.0486923456192017,
-0.5897043347358704,
-0.21192020177841187,
-1.0316035747528076,
0.3997407555580139,
0.4844611585140228,
0.6755321025848389,
0.22625097632408142,
0.11923755705356598,
-0.6486274003982544,
-1.1629936695098877,
-0.025278901681303978,
-0.2580597996711731,
0.01908731460571289,
0.06081228703260422,
0.5384628772735596,
-0.4427439272403717,
1.0694856643676758,
-0.3679666817188263,
-0.4267479181289673,
-0.42500659823417664,
-0.021611196920275688,
0.10232913494110107,
0.2404317855834961,
0.21387816965579987,
-0.5527071952819824,
-0.4932246208190918,
0.32361286878585815,
-0.4414961636066437,
-0.3280244469642639,
0.05533960834145546,
-0.2624592185020447,
0.23487992584705353,
0.10882607102394104,
-0.40717369318008423,
0.18237563967704773,
0.6612852215766907,
-0.2872454822063446,
0.7666170597076416,
-0.13018478453159332,
0.1729356199502945,
-0.934342622756958,
0.2489313930273056,
0.17762158811092377,
-0.2655850052833557,
-0.3513622283935547,
0.19760344922542572,
0.15609151124954224,
0.03190309554338455,
-0.2692694664001465,
0.7384805679321289,
-0.23404668271541595,
-0.21032407879829407,
-0.20791983604431152,
0.4092266857624054,
0.1427639275789261,
0.6122153997421265,
0.12445275485515594,
0.6238862872123718,
0.5706489086151123,
-0.3618899881839752,
0.25449252128601074,
0.4100305736064911,
-0.6723194718360901,
0.7535219788551331,
-0.22460711002349854,
0.18053799867630005,
-0.2818302512168884,
0.21973614394664764,
-0.8159581422805786,
-0.10044194012880325,
-0.0787714496254921,
-0.0225667767226696,
0.13088825345039368,
-0.08345811814069748,
-0.3229495882987976,
-0.3065551221370697,
-0.5894085168838501,
0.4291653633117676,
0.7206099033355713,
-0.6959255933761597,
0.5186173915863037,
0.4394156336784363,
-0.13716402649879456,
-0.7297038435935974,
-0.2008715122938156,
0.06319328397512436,
-0.4027159810066223,
-0.4426420032978058,
0.48934510350227356,
-0.1987912654876709,
-0.6103164553642273,
-0.024125749245285988,
-0.21792052686214447,
-0.08802133053541183,
0.1343778669834137,
0.09549082815647125,
0.5221737623214722,
-0.27230843901634216,
-0.1820424199104309,
-0.09155059605836868,
-0.23223499953746796,
-0.04915754869580269,
-0.16004833579063416,
0.49051642417907715,
-0.35452762246131897,
-0.3942985534667969,
-0.6908572316169739,
0.33894282579421997,
0.5272247195243835,
-0.3753409683704376,
0.36530280113220215,
0.2720946967601776,
-0.35226914286613464,
-0.12879446148872375,
-0.6175475716590881,
0.13997898995876312,
-0.45753222703933716,
0.4966416358947754,
-0.20623478293418884,
-0.7469658255577087,
0.1064530685544014,
0.19804954528808594,
0.21808308362960815,
0.2560027241706848,
0.8386098146438599,
-0.030456513166427612,
1.2570403814315796,
0.6301716566085815,
-0.2066965401172638,
0.2795253396034241,
-0.16050592064857483,
0.20756205916404724,
-1.2204530239105225,
-0.11689119786024094,
-0.5192931294441223,
-0.35046741366386414,
-0.15509919822216034,
-0.2364787608385086,
0.275313138961792,
-0.01454916875809431,
-0.40949711203575134,
0.16165028512477875,
-0.4397091865539551,
0.633902370929718,
0.04658656567335129,
0.0033828914165496826,
0.2659950852394104,
-0.004851076286286116,
0.031633224338293076,
0.007326385471969843,
-0.4625866711139679,
-0.7033352255821228,
0.8567167520523071,
0.592090904712677,
0.6661747694015503,
0.011777997948229313,
0.8686761856079102,
0.34895724058151245,
0.6158604621887207,
-1.2146334648132324,
0.4778253436088562,
-0.1343221366405487,
-0.3586375117301941,
-0.3591620922088623,
-0.3787137269973755,
-0.8619898557662964,
0.4988936483860016,
0.07683449238538742,
-1.0649194717407227,
-0.13853062689304352,
0.2905672490596771,
-0.5388281941413879,
0.050964951515197754,
-0.5518346428871155,
1.0235354900360107,
-0.417324960231781,
-0.3426063656806946,
-0.3193727731704712,
-0.3103305399417877,
0.4716212749481201,
-0.3054969012737274,
0.46341434121131897,
-0.1844821572303772,
0.06627020239830017,
0.8046694993972778,
-0.44986602663993835,
0.6744160652160645,
-0.1256164163351059,
-0.4421488344669342,
0.011808539740741253,
0.19031155109405518,
0.3900231719017029,
-0.30780670046806335,
-0.3267481327056885,
0.06743647158145905,
-0.05448693782091141,
-0.2785634696483612,
-0.8021420240402222,
0.6649554967880249,
-0.5080681443214417,
-0.8662039637565613,
-0.07821253687143326,
-0.6691883206367493,
-0.3819984793663025,
0.073787622153759,
-0.1427750587463379,
0.44915637373924255,
-0.16460241377353668,
0.277957946062088,
0.18106397986412048,
-0.04893466830253601,
0.17549915611743927,
0.40266409516334534,
-0.4732333719730377,
-0.4815361499786377,
0.9218189716339111,
-0.3475711941719055,
0.28698229789733887,
0.6135954856872559,
0.5938783884048462,
-0.4334583282470703,
-0.6005889177322388,
-0.3945932388305664,
-0.01773216389119625,
-0.7391993403434753,
-0.1728767305612564,
-0.42209309339523315,
-0.011889764107763767,
-0.15810526907444,
-0.4638315737247467,
-0.32173797488212585,
-0.05479825288057327,
0.05427469685673714,
-0.2265164852142334,
-0.02440270222723484,
0.5182990431785583,
0.29416874051094055,
0.3211071491241455,
-0.702370822429657,
0.4793221354484558,
0.14205904304981232,
0.4657396078109741,
-0.015876859426498413,
-0.6444541811943054,
-0.33036860823631287,
0.17970450222492218,
-0.19300112128257751,
-0.4705829620361328,
0.40463098883628845,
0.11640596389770508,
0.41997745633125305,
0.5701980590820312,
0.06798044592142105,
1.0993843078613281,
-0.4975547790527344,
0.670268177986145,
0.24262379109859467,
-1.1357371807098389,
0.4452594816684723,
-0.34556740522384644,
0.24417351186275482,
0.8654757142066956,
0.2559152841567993,
-0.3599421977996826,
-0.3008251190185547,
-0.3381536304950714,
-0.6675781607627869,
0.8154136538505554,
-0.03332775831222534,
0.011258045211434364,
0.055317431688308716,
0.05728546157479286,
0.34450146555900574,
0.14227046072483063,
-0.5554789900779724,
-0.05198876932263374,
0.08735673874616623,
-0.4308190941810608,
0.043923553079366684,
-0.2726952135562897,
-0.2864687442779541,
-0.47565436363220215,
0.6241393685340881,
-0.3743025064468384,
-0.14933037757873535,
-0.30855515599250793,
-0.268295556306839,
-0.2662568986415863,
0.6178728342056274,
0.20302167534828186,
0.9648677706718445,
-0.2955036461353302,
0.2969706654548645,
-0.07341579347848892,
-0.010997187346220016,
0.3078238070011139,
-0.03981700539588928,
-0.05090228468179703,
-0.41856062412261963,
0.503947377204895,
0.8135125041007996,
0.45216527581214905,
-0.9174911379814148,
0.6596333384513855,
0.15193027257919312,
-0.1928647756576538,
-0.0005704594077542424,
0.011733289808034897,
-0.008245406672358513,
-0.03535139188170433,
0.22351014614105225,
-0.0756804421544075,
0.026040440425276756,
-0.6564760804176331,
0.2865768074989319,
0.555976152420044,
-0.36751383543014526,
-0.42595458030700684,
0.49414971470832825,
0.3338549733161926,
-0.5081591606140137,
0.692596971988678,
-0.10991015285253525,
-0.6405407190322876,
0.3888356387615204,
0.5986924171447754,
1.1113200187683105,
-0.23878604173660278,
0.3816344439983368,
0.25908708572387695,
-0.06927815079689026,
0.0694272369146347,
0.20031383633613586,
-0.43442192673683167,
-0.7692179083824158,
-0.671848475933075,
-1.0441807508468628,
-0.2830412983894348,
0.2475949376821518,
-0.8193625211715698,
0.33646515011787415,
-0.18652041256427765,
0.17644459009170532,
0.2386249303817749,
-0.1657910943031311,
-0.7879523634910583,
-0.1637144386768341,
0.19104167819023132,
0.752594530582428,
-0.7950661778450012,
0.8378148674964905,
0.6877620220184326,
-0.1444695144891739,
-0.5386890172958374,
0.14959508180618286,
0.14794962108135223,
-0.8505342602729797,
0.8856953382492065,
0.3538062274456024,
-0.06609271466732025,
-0.048751264810562134,
-0.19836029410362244,
-0.708890974521637,
0.7479197382926941,
0.6412602663040161,
-0.6913199424743652,
-0.00903329811990261,
-0.0025512329302728176,
0.5471910834312439,
-0.5320528149604797,
0.3058731257915497,
1.0647692680358887,
0.7514954805374146,
-0.02072209119796753,
-1.1820368766784668,
0.013646482490003109,
-0.33834782242774963,
-0.0584748275578022,
0.3644488751888275,
-0.3161301612854004,
0.376358300447464,
-0.36935052275657654,
-0.3036911189556122,
-0.09045896679162979,
0.25384289026260376,
0.3604312539100647,
-0.012711232528090477,
0.6004335284233093,
0.3751957416534424,
0.6907117366790771,
0.06246751546859741,
1.1228008270263672,
-0.24603182077407837,
0.3498353660106659,
1.0964956283569336,
-0.6176149845123291,
0.9772645235061646,
0.5005587935447693,
-0.3232465386390686,
0.586945116519928,
0.5321069955825806,
0.16490301489830017,
0.39020320773124695,
0.15670537948608398,
-0.15551650524139404,
-0.4496390223503113,
-0.363010436296463,
0.2557395100593567,
0.6957479119300842,
0.2161107212305069,
-0.08335813134908676,
-0.4884023368358612,
-0.11320623755455017,
-0.2269798368215561,
0.2874813973903656,
-0.23549628257751465,
0.8721446990966797,
-0.19612888991832733,
-0.9106786251068115,
1.00424063205719,
-0.03584125265479088,
0.5559462308883667,
-0.5100311636924744,
-0.06112672761082649,
0.07206715643405914,
0.18038606643676758,
-0.46597716212272644,
-0.8405726552009583,
0.2754511833190918,
0.18848221004009247,
-0.06510838866233826,
-0.5480005145072937,
0.26222705841064453,
-0.5784144997596741,
-0.19417251646518707,
0.1573866307735443,
0.24852235615253448,
0.00699260737746954,
-0.13661295175552368,
-0.5946481823921204,
0.2631337344646454,
0.0219429824501276,
-0.35784053802490234,
0.4108184576034546,
0.048349928110837936,
-0.21530252695083618,
0.6608553528785706,
0.5158961415290833,
0.04811419919133186,
-0.43332186341285706,
0.29503265023231506,
0.6193715333938599,
-0.7633708119392395,
-0.43619492650032043,
-1.103446364402771,
0.8507287502288818,
0.12152431160211563,
-0.13330821692943573,
0.584902822971344,
0.8228386044502258,
0.5855464339256287,
0.15383118391036987,
0.8622646927833557,
0.1552257388830185,
0.11089445650577545,
-0.5119705200195312,
0.4540804922580719,
-0.3844063878059387,
0.5495283603668213,
-0.09069307893514633,
-1.2088063955307007,
-0.12296754866838455,
0.4610620439052582,
-0.2919822335243225,
0.0021109802182763815,
0.7442062497138977,
0.6500673294067383,
0.01873667538166046,
-0.2882532775402069,
0.3509337604045868,
0.03550247475504875,
0.3930061161518097,
0.49140843749046326,
0.9537137746810913,
0.005392222199589014,
0.32783302664756775,
-0.3415025472640991,
-0.3729347884654999,
-0.2618853449821472,
-1.013377070426941,
-0.7878788113594055,
-0.6544472575187683,
-0.5665291547775269,
0.07989656925201416,
-0.21230381727218628,
1.3662923574447632,
0.6882143616676331,
-0.6625598073005676,
-0.4184180796146393,
0.170314759016037,
0.31614619493484497,
-0.3910306692123413,
-0.3241466283798218,
0.7146620750427246,
-0.3156065344810486,
-0.8850390315055847,
0.6004953980445862,
0.49782246351242065,
-0.4195791780948639,
-0.6480523943901062,
-0.24906648695468903,
0.12963880598545074,
-0.060310523957014084,
0.7488217353820801,
-0.06288491189479828,
-1.0076630115509033,
-0.36211198568344116,
-0.21483175456523895,
-0.033400051295757294,
0.32667815685272217,
0.7859979271888733,
-1.0245736837387085,
0.5341368317604065,
0.46916306018829346,
0.8371146321296692,
0.055959247052669525,
0.29795628786087036,
0.6493901014328003,
-0.8781298398971558,
-0.24128225445747375,
0.24451659619808197,
0.4309384822845459,
0.33492815494537354,
-0.34570497274398804,
0.3198108971118927,
-0.34508851170539856,
-0.4528074860572815,
-1.0946491956710815,
0.0921158716082573,
-1.034123420715332,
-0.07603811472654343,
1.4397780895233154,
0.25224530696868896,
-0.33378851413726807,
-0.03856861963868141,
-0.30968791246414185,
-0.2906777262687683,
-0.45769625902175903,
1.019926905632019,
0.6565440893173218,
-0.15668267011642456,
-0.0503266304731369,
-0.36654964089393616,
0.3845898509025574,
0.33275577425956726,
-0.9845203161239624,
0.6685734391212463,
0.6930896639823914,
0.1410551220178604,
0.19945046305656433,
0.6788259148597717,
-0.132820263504982,
0.32962775230407715,
-0.3940281867980957,
0.12170790135860443,
-0.10882759839296341,
-0.2575109899044037,
-0.6963595151901245,
0.1330825537443161,
0.15890762209892273,
-0.006014152895659208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15751v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15751v1
|
Sparse MeZO: Less Parameters for Better Performance in Zeroth-Order LLM Fine-Tuning
| 2024-02-24T07:22:04 | 2024-02-24T07:22:04 |
Yong Liu, Zirui Zhu, Chaoyu Gong, Minhao Cheng, Cho-Jui Hsieh, Yang You
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
While fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) for specific tasks often
yields impressive results, it comes at the cost of memory inefficiency due to
back-propagation in gradient-based training. Memory-efficient Zeroth-order
(MeZO) optimizers, recently proposed to address this issue, only require
forward passes during training, making them more memory-friendly. However, the
quality of gradient estimates in zeroth order optimization often depends on the
data dimensionality, potentially explaining why MeZO still exhibits significant
performance drops compared to standard fine-tuning across various tasks.
Inspired by the success of Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT), this paper
introduces Sparse MeZO, a novel memory-efficient zeroth-order optimization
approach that applies ZO only to a carefully chosen subset of parameters. We
propose a simple yet effective parameter selection scheme that yields
significant performance gains with Sparse-MeZO. Additionally, we develop a
memory-optimized implementation for sparse masking, ensuring the algorithm
requires only inference-level memory consumption, allowing Sparse-MeZO to
fine-tune LLaMA-30b on a single A100 GPU. Experimental results illustrate that
Sparse-MeZO consistently improves both performance and convergence speed over
MeZO without any overhead. For example, it achieves a 9\% absolute accuracy
improvement and 3.5x speedup over MeZO on the RTE task.
|
[
-0.5664815902709961,
-0.7486891746520996,
0.44148606061935425,
0.23470723628997803,
-0.6287552714347839,
0.03336646035313606,
-0.3771011233329773,
-0.43271929025650024,
0.265193372964859,
0.32296648621559143,
-0.7107806205749512,
-0.5057576298713684,
-0.49274927377700806,
-0.059832289814949036,
0.1815650761127472,
0.6867223381996155,
0.15508393943309784,
0.06097656115889549,
0.15736155211925507,
-0.17599493265151978,
-0.39546072483062744,
-0.295555979013443,
-0.6944237947463989,
-0.2775869369506836,
0.8560090661048889,
0.6774945855140686,
0.46627306938171387,
0.8609558343887329,
-0.18456785380840302,
0.2862072288990021,
-0.11453952640295029,
0.25311437249183655,
-0.68150395154953,
0.012041916139423847,
0.14886951446533203,
-0.23740865290164948,
-0.7786679863929749,
-0.01217770017683506,
0.49007707834243774,
0.6701346635818481,
-0.20486360788345337,
0.10647793114185333,
-0.057537566870450974,
0.4902923107147217,
-0.9672819375991821,
-0.20602154731750488,
-0.7702360153198242,
0.05445152521133423,
-0.2520114481449127,
-0.27637872099876404,
-0.1781442016363144,
-0.044967006891965866,
-0.28147652745246887,
-0.6362809538841248,
0.4021448791027069,
0.07598234713077545,
0.646108865737915,
0.43255630135536194,
0.47968459129333496,
0.1856585294008255,
-0.6539686322212219,
1.0587568283081055,
-0.773901104927063,
0.6526736617088318,
0.2989196479320526,
0.09116405993700027,
-0.02341940440237522,
-0.24997873604297638,
-0.3296352028846741,
-0.11385530233383179,
0.4909040629863739,
0.09014160931110382,
-0.0036154137924313545,
0.49562546610832214,
0.20865756273269653,
0.32034409046173096,
-0.6724101305007935,
0.3283860385417938,
-0.3599047064781189,
-0.28976547718048096,
0.37796106934547424,
0.32233327627182007,
-0.07098400592803955,
0.2227066308259964,
-0.27213621139526367,
0.00461005000397563,
-0.878287672996521,
-0.16102361679077148,
0.4217013418674469,
0.4737541377544403,
0.08926235139369965,
0.08770737051963806,
-0.6842204928398132,
1.0040746927261353,
0.10823700577020645,
-0.4048543870449066,
0.020718755200505257,
-0.2683311998844147,
-0.34549680352211,
0.12744881212711334,
0.6983538269996643,
0.06888571381568909,
0.16467294096946716,
-0.40404120087623596,
-0.18631690740585327,
-0.14807413518428802,
0.18725720047950745,
-1.1792914867401123,
-0.26490435004234314,
-0.0307236909866333,
-0.3185040354728699,
-0.035952381789684296,
-0.388700932264328,
-0.928840696811676,
0.08640731871128082,
0.029887787997722626,
0.43028390407562256,
-0.19054342806339264,
0.15795883536338806,
0.3216009736061096,
0.24059860408306122,
-0.01080162450671196,
0.7633740305900574,
-1.3007773160934448,
0.4937879145145416,
0.5003246665000916,
0.8218268156051636,
0.14424480497837067,
-0.4362240731716156,
-0.7881704568862915,
0.2760525643825531,
-0.4837949275970459,
0.6731025576591492,
-0.6768452525138855,
-0.252531498670578,
-0.4430736005306244,
-0.26183220744132996,
-0.12268849462270737,
-0.7676000595092773,
0.3646583557128906,
-0.2518285810947418,
-0.28431236743927,
-0.15706519782543182,
-0.10802050679922104,
-0.14241409301757812,
-0.027107469737529755,
-0.31845521926879883,
0.8704953193664551,
0.27446839213371277,
0.07314406335353851,
0.4543325901031494,
0.018328353762626648,
-0.2675841152667999,
0.027109555900096893,
-0.3543485403060913,
-0.4167300760746002,
0.3453177213668823,
-0.08091495931148529,
0.6433125734329224,
-0.39360031485557556,
-0.3217150866985321,
-0.42709359526634216,
-0.9207541346549988,
-0.26782163977622986,
-0.5338779091835022,
0.23966121673583984,
0.34619811177253723,
-0.3203527331352234,
-0.0869358479976654,
-0.9356690645217896,
0.08939757198095322,
-0.06847550719976425,
-0.5529116988182068,
-0.3170284330844879,
-0.008319536224007607,
-0.1931401640176773,
-0.020253410562872887,
0.3883509635925293,
-0.7163156270980835,
0.10444197058677673,
-0.39983829855918884,
0.49896740913391113,
0.7511242628097534,
-0.25357991456985474,
0.6658753156661987,
-0.142410010099411,
0.19074301421642303,
-0.31078556180000305,
0.4552464783191681,
0.052206654101610184,
-0.5131497979164124,
-0.6198497414588928,
-0.6128432750701904,
0.2513446807861328,
0.38930171728134155,
-0.3214249014854431,
0.10703084617853165,
-0.096308633685112,
-0.34648481011390686,
-0.3402697741985321,
0.6774012446403503,
0.4179781675338745,
0.5616748332977295,
0.5340677499771118,
0.08263278752565384,
-0.03242911025881767,
-0.7597568035125732,
0.1659557968378067,
0.04498325288295746,
-0.10277431458234787,
0.698860228061676,
-0.048427753150463104,
-0.06679826229810715,
0.12197981029748917,
-0.728977620601654,
-0.16536042094230652,
-0.1751006543636322,
-0.001637918408960104,
0.26685911417007446,
0.6910779476165771,
0.7276644110679626,
-0.2706475555896759,
-0.40034428238868713,
0.027442650869488716,
-0.02986946702003479,
-0.2576574385166168,
-0.0710001140832901,
-0.1362355351448059,
0.21679061651229858,
0.32895544171333313,
-0.5869903564453125,
0.10371150076389313,
0.30732017755508423,
-0.15703420341014862,
0.09295735508203506,
-0.7379136681556702,
-0.1200721263885498,
-0.7024211287498474,
-0.24855712056159973,
-0.15938635170459747,
-0.10031191259622574,
-0.41841715574264526,
-0.29959580302238464,
0.0819072350859642,
-0.05575841665267944,
-0.030974144116044044,
0.456183522939682,
-0.5061666369438171,
0.035853639245033264,
-0.16464866697788239,
-0.11409424245357513,
0.18945489823818207,
0.8939253091812134,
-0.32997629046440125,
0.8855437636375427,
0.18813329935073853,
-0.5848724246025085,
0.0006188689731061459,
0.027746006846427917,
-0.1766253560781479,
0.3013289272785187,
-0.48969385027885437,
0.15652823448181152,
0.14375832676887512,
-0.510753870010376,
-1.0200583934783936,
0.13983216881752014,
0.49798062443733215,
-0.34420013427734375,
0.8955283164978027,
-0.17469526827335358,
-0.5835774540901184,
-0.06054819002747536,
-0.5743666291236877,
0.4943593144416809,
0.49606528878211975,
-0.4595560133457184,
0.12250983715057373,
0.1129499077796936,
-0.2600424885749817,
-0.7081494927406311,
-0.455145925283432,
-0.054172247648239136,
-0.13700321316719055,
-0.05675492808222771,
0.4040791392326355,
-0.264494389295578,
-0.0005449044983834028,
-0.1877206414937973,
-0.4570663273334503,
-0.40359437465667725,
0.41089552640914917,
-0.14055439829826355,
0.024290429428219795,
-0.4266136884689331,
-0.10898930579423904,
0.5800448060035706,
-0.28635984659194946,
-0.505450963973999,
-0.1691625863313675,
0.6749966740608215,
0.03571838140487671,
-0.002500243717804551,
-0.2310454249382019,
0.30297625064849854,
0.5394013524055481,
-0.006276623345911503,
0.6793850660324097,
0.3424038887023926,
-0.2206212729215622,
-0.6362472772598267,
-0.7189467549324036,
-0.09290997684001923,
-0.51079922914505,
0.3915121555328369,
-0.32729601860046387,
-0.9715381264686584,
0.41351428627967834,
-0.11477872729301453,
-0.07029284536838531,
0.0622563362121582,
0.4354882836341858,
-0.15985827147960663,
0.8654518127441406,
0.48220309615135193,
-0.35670047998428345,
0.7285070419311523,
-0.23647865653038025,
0.1921403706073761,
-0.6542807221412659,
-0.16580888628959656,
-0.5561577677726746,
-0.49837806820869446,
-0.3841440975666046,
-0.6096591353416443,
0.10504533350467682,
0.29440245032310486,
-0.23310169577598572,
0.2970934510231018,
-0.5291420817375183,
0.5719876885414124,
0.3768232464790344,
0.25436165928840637,
0.1649406999349594,
0.22301357984542847,
0.07431382685899734,
-0.03611929342150688,
-0.8123286366462708,
-0.10314095765352249,
0.6999300718307495,
0.011225612834095955,
0.9290577173233032,
-0.3323608636856079,
0.6522504091262817,
0.15387150645256042,
-0.12746909260749817,
-0.5925146341323853,
0.5527076721191406,
-0.3520388901233673,
-0.15299402177333832,
-0.5204474925994873,
-0.3775670826435089,
-0.8022816181182861,
0.32240140438079834,
-0.06984245777130127,
-0.7483353614807129,
0.37640804052352905,
0.07419362664222717,
-0.8223670125007629,
0.27672117948532104,
-0.512602686882019,
0.6732310056686401,
-0.07725053280591965,
-0.6994625926017761,
-0.6869309544563293,
-0.4094880223274231,
-0.1557358056306839,
0.03901376202702522,
-0.27895262837409973,
-0.6217491626739502,
-0.45106732845306396,
0.4004635810852051,
-0.7744892835617065,
0.5884193181991577,
-0.3073536157608032,
0.040305159986019135,
0.14431758224964142,
0.05931282788515091,
0.2816884517669678,
0.13122761249542236,
-0.23812489211559296,
0.4715062379837036,
-0.12194013595581055,
-0.4959869980812073,
-0.6767412424087524,
1.0203046798706055,
-0.6843445301055908,
-0.588573157787323,
0.14472739398479462,
-0.7167669534683228,
-0.15474890172481537,
0.18852078914642334,
0.15128284692764282,
0.6895942091941833,
0.157125785946846,
-0.007936150766909122,
0.9767712950706482,
-0.3690846264362335,
0.4546182155609131,
0.5494757890701294,
0.5473971962928772,
-0.6557138562202454,
1.247074007987976,
0.6420873999595642,
0.058226149529218674,
0.576404333114624,
0.12801341712474823,
-0.03114512749016285,
-1.1061140298843384,
-0.9970969557762146,
0.42880117893218994,
-0.24842281639575958,
-0.5172914862632751,
-0.2988550066947937,
-0.06409704685211182,
0.07515784353017807,
-0.41936764121055603,
-0.6545183658599854,
-0.5178176760673523,
-0.40191081166267395,
0.05038207396864891,
0.3979463577270508,
0.32572945952415466,
-0.022068733349442482,
0.4479220509529114,
-0.5200751423835754,
0.2347111999988556,
0.26058346033096313,
0.7419111728668213,
0.028034910559654236,
-0.32890790700912476,
-0.3316115438938141,
-0.04370869696140289,
-0.1203944981098175,
-0.5532389283180237,
0.19122102856636047,
0.30048635601997375,
0.7720897197723389,
0.723870575428009,
-0.04042232036590576,
1.174232006072998,
-0.6437197923660278,
0.24506570398807526,
-0.07836195826530457,
-0.7465453147888184,
0.3188874423503876,
-0.5343682765960693,
-0.15832270681858063,
0.82711261510849,
-0.04358549416065216,
0.1447366327047348,
-0.3088192939758301,
-0.38204407691955566,
-0.7594780325889587,
0.8188924193382263,
0.0001830632536439225,
0.4572082459926605,
0.12271743267774582,
1.013285756111145,
0.2585378587245941,
0.4372842609882355,
-0.17799054086208344,
-0.46641960740089417,
-0.024702467024326324,
-0.01781565323472023,
-0.3826979398727417,
-0.7389412522315979,
0.28449827432632446,
-0.4504992961883545,
0.3808996379375458,
-0.1940348893404007,
0.3231191039085388,
0.09772855043411255,
-0.023920677602291107,
-0.45200276374816895,
0.10679001361131668,
0.9387787580490112,
0.5359286069869995,
-0.45960238575935364,
0.08484470099210739,
0.3840921223163605,
-0.48429223895072937,
-0.001068129320628941,
0.07288666069507599,
-0.3925635516643524,
0.033765554428100586,
-0.11849082261323929,
0.6329213380813599,
0.6680838465690613,
-0.7115983963012695,
0.3924808204174042,
0.20237381756305695,
-0.21167677640914917,
0.25307831168174744,
0.48159754276275635,
-0.1866561621427536,
0.4589729607105255,
0.14307719469070435,
0.07398269325494766,
0.31638771295547485,
-0.11782321333885193,
0.06081180274486542,
0.6734662055969238,
-0.09169448167085648,
-0.46369534730911255,
0.8283842206001282,
-0.1487089991569519,
-0.08457419276237488,
0.3183744251728058,
0.006872097495943308,
-0.05370420962572098,
0.581442654132843,
0.4975490868091583,
0.7227326035499573,
-0.42015236616134644,
0.026367804035544395,
0.35340216755867004,
0.23741555213928223,
-0.04123866558074951,
0.3798157572746277,
-0.7179529666900635,
-0.5105844736099243,
-0.32970747351646423,
-0.7849302887916565,
-0.4022231698036194,
0.2544623613357544,
-0.3845091462135315,
0.04789934679865837,
-1.2680530548095703,
0.2679450213909149,
-0.25236064195632935,
0.39053070545196533,
-0.10302611440420151,
0.2055020034313202,
0.36825013160705566,
0.9153239130973816,
-0.44512954354286194,
1.0533267259597778,
0.3926789462566376,
-0.1018918827176094,
-0.582055389881134,
-0.11581507325172424,
-0.5378737449645996,
-0.8917372226715088,
0.1846017986536026,
0.07997938990592957,
-0.41548821330070496,
0.08397001028060913,
-0.43826133012771606,
-0.8109277486801147,
1.187827467918396,
0.8016404509544373,
-0.5289576649665833,
0.30388593673706055,
0.028467103838920593,
0.4520396292209625,
-0.1913285106420517,
-0.008499379269778728,
0.2753116190433502,
0.1413770318031311,
0.37816286087036133,
-0.5833202004432678,
0.07506683468818665,
-0.0645199567079544,
0.10585836321115494,
0.4772116243839264,
-1.2586053609848022,
1.140583872795105,
-0.22045662999153137,
0.01157023198902607,
0.4594328701496124,
0.4902563989162445,
0.14786426723003387,
0.36911338567733765,
0.24907666444778442,
0.6321030855178833,
0.8184812664985657,
0.08726352453231812,
0.6983997821807861,
-0.4602055847644806,
0.13679032027721405,
0.8069882988929749,
-0.09729284793138504,
0.8279228806495667,
0.39640894532203674,
-0.050541967153549194,
0.29511237144470215,
0.8330567479133606,
-0.07104731351137161,
0.8899634480476379,
0.14538796246051788,
-0.3384034335613251,
-0.4306061267852783,
-0.017499394714832306,
-0.24662551283836365,
0.16194356977939606,
0.3995858132839203,
0.03546549007296562,
-0.5583991408348083,
-0.3517090380191803,
0.24164894223213196,
-0.10551054775714874,
-0.694296658039093,
0.5622971057891846,
0.017267096787691116,
-0.22293886542320251,
0.9460176825523376,
0.061057668179273605,
0.5450963377952576,
-0.5853831171989441,
-0.19571015238761902,
-0.5329828858375549,
0.3800177276134491,
-0.05423470959067345,
-0.04814647138118744,
0.2912922203540802,
-0.19542430341243744,
-0.37820345163345337,
-0.30463796854019165,
0.6578369140625,
-0.38246163725852966,
-0.2171224057674408,
0.5190279483795166,
0.5284351706504822,
0.12583878636360168,
-0.1799980252981186,
-0.7079208493232727,
0.037821605801582336,
-0.31906574964523315,
-0.2579858601093292,
0.739975094795227,
0.3417090177536011,
0.053571321070194244,
0.5816203355789185,
0.5734542012214661,
0.3343547582626343,
0.20490019023418427,
-0.028218673542141914,
0.9650744795799255,
-0.445443332195282,
-0.3123484253883362,
-0.9886379837989807,
-0.2214120626449585,
0.23401296138763428,
-0.10340443253517151,
0.7598842978477478,
0.6981564164161682,
0.8111543655395508,
0.005935863591730595,
0.292329877614975,
0.18818555772304535,
0.2356802076101303,
-0.533990204334259,
0.7539543509483337,
-0.8221455812454224,
0.2813106179237366,
-0.26968520879745483,
-0.8266834020614624,
-0.365584135055542,
0.8574080467224121,
-0.16607940196990967,
0.07749303430318832,
0.03826994076371193,
0.8653030395507812,
-0.05136808007955551,
-0.399282306432724,
0.9974055290222168,
0.29197603464126587,
-0.3028116822242737,
0.8342254757881165,
0.7219709753990173,
-0.47301915287971497,
0.3587751090526581,
-0.5401847958564758,
-0.025082403793931007,
-0.16353914141654968,
-0.3891318440437317,
-0.9510762095451355,
-0.1905188262462616,
-0.10748650878667831,
-0.03615192323923111,
0.18534301221370697,
0.831444501876831,
0.7500229477882385,
-0.8077106475830078,
-0.18574020266532898,
-0.1728619486093521,
0.3527684509754181,
-0.08192071318626404,
-0.06205597519874573,
0.04589937627315521,
-0.4800407588481903,
-0.9356253147125244,
0.49356094002723694,
0.8055312633514404,
-0.01794901117682457,
0.09689989686012268,
-0.23810362815856934,
0.14146912097930908,
0.2295757383108139,
0.40728044509887695,
0.4065355956554413,
-0.5145366191864014,
-0.14311592280864716,
0.05956164374947548,
-0.004417169839143753,
0.40868669748306274,
0.6471010446548462,
-0.68342125415802,
0.24751414358615875,
0.38401928544044495,
0.5080782771110535,
0.529019296169281,
-0.09006838500499725,
0.3828284740447998,
-0.4750491678714752,
0.48310387134552,
0.05570168420672417,
0.3558511734008789,
-0.014145664870738983,
-0.5388400554656982,
0.39205625653266907,
0.4871450960636139,
-0.21685515344142914,
-0.7587130665779114,
-0.2425856739282608,
-1.079792857170105,
-0.39169567823410034,
0.9036788940429688,
-0.06402012705802917,
-0.2204459011554718,
-0.09352155029773712,
-0.029647842049598694,
0.10097762197256088,
-0.503424346446991,
0.7735681533813477,
0.19624438881874084,
-0.2728860378265381,
-0.3269948363304138,
-0.7325590252876282,
0.5440529584884644,
0.5053874850273132,
-0.3633865416049957,
0.09600234776735306,
0.49210125207901,
0.4392137825489044,
-0.16121308505535126,
0.750201940536499,
0.08123274147510529,
0.3079134523868561,
0.09153193235397339,
-0.2565625309944153,
-0.34341463446617126,
-0.6787529587745667,
-0.3002011179924011,
0.25925499200820923,
0.1583663672208786,
-0.35480326414108276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15745v1
|
GAOKAO-MM: A Chinese Human-Level Benchmark for Multimodal Models Evaluation
| 2024-02-24T06:57:15 | 2024-02-24T06:57:15 |
Yi Zong, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
The Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) have demonstrated great abilities in
image perception and language understanding. However, existing multimodal
benchmarks focus on primary perception abilities and commonsense knowledge
which are insufficient to reflect the comprehensive capabilities of LVLMs. We
propose GAOKAO-MM, a multimodal benchmark based on the Chinese College Entrance
Examination (GAOKAO), comprising of 8 subjects and 12 types of images, such as
diagrams, function graphs, maps and photos. GAOKAO-MM derives from native
Chinese context and sets human-level requirements for the model's abilities,
including perception, understanding, knowledge and reasoning. We evaluate 10
LVLMs and find that the accuracies of all of them are lower than 50%, with
GPT-4-Vison (48.1%), Qwen-VL-Plus (41.2%) and Gemini-Pro-Vision (35.1%) ranking
in the top three positions. The results of our multi-dimension analysis
indicate that LVLMs have moderate distance towards Artificial General
Intelligence (AGI) and provide insights facilitating the development of
multilingual LVLMs.
|
[
-0.3331020474433899,
-0.6096326112747192,
0.5281171202659607,
0.2873963713645935,
-0.077792689204216,
0.006814709398895502,
-0.16933979094028473,
-0.6041734218597412,
-0.3266923129558563,
0.2122691124677658,
-0.4801435172557831,
-0.4105675518512726,
-0.400173544883728,
0.04400356113910675,
-0.0615343302488327,
0.3575630784034729,
0.2578403055667877,
0.24417619407176971,
-0.3934900760650635,
-0.2516174912452698,
-0.4322545528411865,
-0.310644268989563,
-0.42130139470100403,
-0.0990847647190094,
0.5484764575958252,
-0.04090632125735283,
0.601175844669342,
0.4225424826145172,
0.5512495040893555,
0.42985597252845764,
0.03379353880882263,
0.3189237117767334,
-0.13576115667819977,
-0.30295422673225403,
0.13286752998828888,
-0.35736215114593506,
-0.5987653136253357,
0.1891947239637375,
0.9742724299430847,
0.634741485118866,
-0.07618088275194168,
0.15803787112236023,
-0.028714556246995926,
0.6841154098510742,
-0.8282777667045593,
0.3111489713191986,
-0.440134733915329,
0.2106582522392273,
-0.04169980064034462,
0.17765948176383972,
-0.5398691296577454,
-0.1042492464184761,
0.27497634291648865,
-0.9775401949882507,
-0.011156389489769936,
0.12900447845458984,
0.9190530180931091,
0.06747167557477951,
-0.7205381989479065,
-0.0028203793335705996,
-0.12144473195075989,
0.9360382556915283,
-0.6507143974304199,
0.6341012716293335,
0.2264135479927063,
0.7080602049827576,
-0.0946127250790596,
-0.5134931206703186,
-0.5655313730239868,
-0.7107051610946655,
-0.07507817447185516,
0.5821382403373718,
0.08948465436697006,
0.031750988215208054,
0.24920330941677094,
0.22662265598773956,
-0.7800885438919067,
0.04945710673928261,
-0.5459890365600586,
-0.36374205350875854,
0.6946113109588623,
0.3371707797050476,
0.3109113574028015,
-0.1384008526802063,
-0.44828179478645325,
-0.3121678829193115,
-0.25655633211135864,
0.3546537756919861,
0.2806943953037262,
0.1972048282623291,
-0.09492731839418411,
0.38459649682044983,
-0.6138968467712402,
0.8645362854003906,
-0.32603225111961365,
-0.411296546459198,
0.5909700393676758,
-0.41329795122146606,
-0.3488837480545044,
-0.4770593047142029,
1.0343073606491089,
0.6308966279029846,
0.31513532996177673,
-0.1664077341556549,
-0.011283855885267258,
0.27125057578086853,
0.1727873980998993,
-0.7446297407150269,
-0.1645236313343048,
0.10289844125509262,
-0.6616287231445312,
-0.33286890387535095,
0.24775844812393188,
-0.8770238757133484,
-0.5091724395751953,
-0.1536576896905899,
0.5537574887275696,
-0.43557924032211304,
-0.26433461904525757,
-0.22520039975643158,
-0.06139056757092476,
0.31367602944374084,
0.6276603937149048,
-0.6782942414283752,
0.07870662957429886,
0.5522150993347168,
0.9187059998512268,
-0.33430904150009155,
-0.8391734957695007,
-0.5718238949775696,
-0.027961365878582,
-0.4741203784942627,
0.6903684735298157,
-0.5777976512908936,
-0.29663702845573425,
-0.0852862149477005,
0.07456018775701523,
0.021176552399992943,
-0.5222377181053162,
0.5386717915534973,
-0.23454909026622772,
0.22892078757286072,
-0.27284830808639526,
-0.19558085501194,
-0.40261343121528625,
0.6254875659942627,
-0.6819636821746826,
0.7754297852516174,
0.1514260619878769,
-0.23493453860282898,
0.5542811751365662,
-0.5050176978111267,
-0.15381772816181183,
0.17424644529819489,
-0.2636273503303528,
-0.1392168551683426,
0.05317961797118187,
0.35711145401000977,
0.38797691464424133,
-0.3879065215587616,
0.23457187414169312,
-0.41623708605766296,
-0.33002912998199463,
0.21057943999767303,
-0.6548744440078735,
0.8077768087387085,
0.20295213162899017,
0.026679622009396553,
0.44361022114753723,
-0.9960535168647766,
0.2476920634508133,
0.23550359904766083,
-0.39308738708496094,
-0.2664664685726166,
0.17225612699985504,
0.13957101106643677,
0.48998165130615234,
0.2736835181713104,
-0.3414635956287384,
0.4075460135936737,
-0.14379194378852844,
0.39123445749282837,
0.8985024690628052,
-0.533627986907959,
0.32816675305366516,
-0.08903676271438599,
0.18033140897750854,
0.14452648162841797,
0.6332775950431824,
-0.28211185336112976,
-0.8321487903594971,
-0.549139142036438,
-0.4018227458000183,
0.02269594743847847,
0.5472201704978943,
-0.9230265617370605,
0.14013849198818207,
-0.1678486466407776,
-0.6691198348999023,
-0.721117377281189,
0.09265118837356567,
0.5010743141174316,
0.5395306944847107,
0.32038211822509766,
-0.39281830191612244,
-0.0825084000825882,
-0.940527081489563,
0.04823695123195648,
-0.44175800681114197,
-0.26989415287971497,
0.43768197298049927,
0.520757794380188,
-0.30409157276153564,
0.4404929280281067,
-0.24846045672893524,
-0.4584418535232544,
0.15397636592388153,
0.1950729340314865,
-0.0168120376765728,
0.12394937127828598,
0.6424981951713562,
-0.9769011735916138,
-0.43943071365356445,
0.31037667393684387,
-1.0024484395980835,
-0.1112307459115982,
0.04499206691980362,
-0.004291031509637833,
0.21407578885555267,
0.08076898753643036,
-0.23361647129058838,
0.21927234530448914,
0.833041250705719,
-0.4318549335002899,
0.7951302528381348,
-0.5333570837974548,
0.6235247254371643,
-0.7274780869483948,
0.05398576706647873,
0.1387256234884262,
0.06924893707036972,
-0.6195726990699768,
0.4180917739868164,
0.33618760108947754,
-0.12084092199802399,
-0.497841477394104,
0.7062342166900635,
-0.5832176804542542,
-0.24560266733169556,
-0.18184131383895874,
0.4902168810367584,
-0.04980936646461487,
0.5392431616783142,
0.010685236193239689,
0.7367987632751465,
0.810590386390686,
-0.47857773303985596,
0.7356314063072205,
-0.10396553575992584,
-0.6502248048782349,
0.7711641788482666,
-0.6219207048416138,
-0.04988137260079384,
0.13030853867530823,
-0.09894444793462753,
-1.0938791036605835,
-0.24862191081047058,
0.12644821405410767,
-0.5561696290969849,
-0.18922391533851624,
0.08513806760311127,
-0.5262844562530518,
-0.38730019330978394,
-0.3692470192909241,
0.5180624127388,
0.4816201329231262,
-0.40400028228759766,
0.9076561331748962,
0.21290023624897003,
0.33202406764030457,
-0.7611653804779053,
-0.36409586668014526,
0.04735720902681351,
-0.07220777869224548,
-0.865095317363739,
-0.009534119628369808,
-0.1800360530614853,
-0.10551438480615616,
-0.2415815144777298,
0.4096396863460541,
-0.07066365331411362,
0.05811876058578491,
0.23152582347393036,
0.5313327312469482,
-0.332817941904068,
-0.046259474009275436,
-0.4780927002429962,
-0.09345120191574097,
0.02768077328801155,
0.07216937094926834,
0.3672027587890625,
-0.5814515352249146,
-0.4147573709487915,
-0.39393851161003113,
0.099533811211586,
0.6895847320556641,
-0.4261179566383362,
0.4743947684764862,
0.9060023427009583,
-0.21572625637054443,
0.1717413365840912,
-0.4992395043373108,
0.19882024824619293,
-0.4529186189174652,
0.6175450682640076,
-0.4268523156642914,
-0.5299094915390015,
0.523287832736969,
-0.09407974779605865,
-0.0269484780728817,
0.4592128396034241,
0.640022337436676,
0.06733851134777069,
1.2039494514465332,
0.4373459219932556,
-0.2084108144044876,
0.3597971200942993,
0.033390358090400696,
-0.28663936257362366,
-0.9073519706726074,
-0.4230547845363617,
-0.2015562802553177,
-0.1830199807882309,
-0.6640973687171936,
-0.5255098938941956,
0.328982949256897,
-0.10131168365478516,
-0.16174331307411194,
0.13358810544013977,
-0.40374839305877686,
0.2715684473514557,
0.7143054604530334,
-0.02402723953127861,
0.3510150611400604,
-0.35530558228492737,
-0.17362336814403534,
0.009447346441447735,
-0.3542957305908203,
-0.3262716829776764,
0.9948933720588684,
0.14721553027629852,
0.5877895355224609,
0.19494859874248505,
0.021926462650299072,
0.30452820658683777,
0.30504465103149414,
-0.6770960688591003,
0.7831647992134094,
-0.24740132689476013,
-0.7086760401725769,
-0.387177973985672,
-0.6199652552604675,
-0.7356069684028625,
0.8121296167373657,
-0.5541461110115051,
-0.8972872495651245,
-0.028508801013231277,
0.04297579824924469,
-0.054761867970228195,
0.09578938782215118,
-0.8750022053718567,
1.1812363862991333,
-0.5481938719749451,
-0.42980024218559265,
-0.10129524767398834,
-0.6979086399078369,
0.6184443235397339,
0.0015186299569904804,
0.42887991666793823,
-0.3227992355823517,
-0.1664416790008545,
0.5014927983283997,
-0.11818219721317291,
0.4761427342891693,
-0.18601670861244202,
0.06627418845891953,
0.16153502464294434,
-0.13722719252109528,
0.15985256433486938,
-0.10816718637943268,
-0.029613126069307327,
0.38202106952667236,
0.16867223381996155,
-0.41139188408851624,
-0.6366819739341736,
0.5373855829238892,
-1.0570498704910278,
-0.4063892662525177,
-0.5500547289848328,
-0.5616660118103027,
-0.16984549164772034,
0.30074140429496765,
0.0631943792104721,
0.31680577993392944,
-0.40416616201400757,
0.34008270502090454,
0.10383494198322296,
-0.41244766116142273,
0.25658100843429565,
0.6479055881500244,
-0.5317189693450928,
-0.5521973371505737,
1.0857082605361938,
0.12008018046617508,
0.39038437604904175,
0.355740487575531,
0.5363191366195679,
-0.22160328924655914,
-0.3260499835014343,
-0.7643210291862488,
0.07699115574359894,
-0.8085656762123108,
0.20831139385700226,
-0.2822314500808716,
-0.2180681824684143,
-0.4129728376865387,
0.015891604125499725,
-0.3813019096851349,
0.15317599475383759,
0.14894558489322662,
0.35132208466529846,
-0.22942376136779785,
0.4493277072906494,
0.03215237334370613,
0.13027310371398926,
-0.6469472646713257,
0.5925982594490051,
0.48851463198661804,
0.37379780411720276,
0.21338915824890137,
-0.5559225678443909,
-0.20750024914741516,
0.061229076236486435,
-0.3507750332355499,
-0.49237677454948425,
0.2974567115306854,
0.17784062027931213,
0.9443190097808838,
0.7722411751747131,
-0.2283543050289154,
0.8545559644699097,
-0.5580102205276489,
0.9430937170982361,
0.4108547270298004,
-0.7838926911354065,
0.5733036398887634,
-0.33819150924682617,
0.3733462393283844,
0.33656027913093567,
0.21148183941841125,
-0.5987002849578857,
-0.26833248138427734,
-0.23269084095954895,
-0.6302842497825623,
0.6438230276107788,
0.23018544912338257,
-0.0621899738907814,
0.18168650567531586,
-0.15845945477485657,
0.03452741727232933,
0.14518865942955017,
-0.9546598792076111,
-0.18788659572601318,
-0.3877255916595459,
-0.003800417063757777,
-0.1741762012243271,
-0.07048040628433228,
0.035988982766866684,
-0.1692584753036499,
0.42047303915023804,
-0.15776894986629486,
0.1370062679052353,
-0.13286159932613373,
-0.12509511411190033,
0.08846904337406158,
0.13808158040046692,
0.9088811278343201,
0.7328155040740967,
-0.3682039678096771,
-0.05618053302168846,
0.2725009322166443,
-0.7431047558784485,
0.006744469981640577,
-0.08434426784515381,
-0.15641996264457703,
-0.31232550740242004,
0.5990515351295471,
0.6096729636192322,
-0.16677869856357574,
-1.0234636068344116,
0.624708890914917,
-0.21292288601398468,
-0.11366350203752518,
-0.18732935190200806,
0.11261773854494095,
-0.1040010005235672,
0.3462138772010803,
0.4734933078289032,
-0.12411144375801086,
0.21761775016784668,
-0.965608537197113,
-0.10568440705537796,
0.4954679608345032,
-0.3927041292190552,
-0.3689870238304138,
0.7321902513504028,
0.3650761842727661,
-0.19291181862354279,
0.6974097490310669,
-0.0728074386715889,
-0.23279982805252075,
0.6040002107620239,
0.3415037989616394,
0.6953555345535278,
-0.30382269620895386,
0.056769903749227524,
0.7114088535308838,
0.5019667148590088,
-0.19389872252941132,
0.010582977905869484,
0.02299318090081215,
-0.7248724102973938,
-0.22128522396087646,
-0.47445592284202576,
-0.5176746845245361,
0.16775763034820557,
-0.5641735792160034,
0.380557656288147,
-0.3619001805782318,
-0.019885381683707237,
-0.030016474425792694,
-0.05918662250041962,
-0.5272992849349976,
0.5718279480934143,
0.44968777894973755,
0.6605920791625977,
-0.6529293656349182,
0.8761724233627319,
0.6125157475471497,
-0.46141302585601807,
-0.3200721740722656,
-0.2918475866317749,
0.2360033541917801,
-0.9549485445022583,
0.7784244418144226,
0.38397541642189026,
-0.17628715932369232,
-0.496345192193985,
-0.36385974287986755,
-0.7322955131530762,
1.36678147315979,
0.11016679555177689,
-0.5569728016853333,
-0.10277111083269119,
0.07078385353088379,
0.5956000089645386,
-0.36974993348121643,
0.5567114353179932,
0.18115569651126862,
0.5388410091400146,
0.01483861543238163,
-1.0117770433425903,
-0.24767667055130005,
-0.5382165312767029,
0.1066969633102417,
-0.025144381448626518,
-0.9976593852043152,
1.148914098739624,
-0.21157865226268768,
-0.07820294797420502,
0.2802766263484955,
0.616626501083374,
0.4729848802089691,
0.5452492237091064,
0.6158625483512878,
0.31735527515411377,
0.5765458345413208,
-0.3010554909706116,
1.017028570175171,
-0.11870142817497253,
0.18460504710674286,
0.8699763417243958,
-0.26689669489860535,
1.0486217737197876,
0.27668923139572144,
-0.2922266721725464,
0.299710750579834,
0.4793514013290405,
-0.26359376311302185,
0.6935924887657166,
0.0449926033616066,
0.04049300029873848,
-0.39311930537223816,
-0.0007116642664186656,
-0.6017332077026367,
0.7115115523338318,
0.1785556674003601,
-0.13083551824092865,
0.049462176859378815,
0.1566396802663803,
-0.5514005422592163,
0.01946154423058033,
-0.42483454942703247,
0.6046515703201294,
-0.17539645731449127,
-0.5583088397979736,
0.36990293860435486,
-0.06286400556564331,
0.7766457200050354,
-0.8935313820838928,
-0.023706018924713135,
-0.13386712968349457,
0.2980256676673889,
0.0676700621843338,
-0.8094871044158936,
-0.1920868307352066,
-0.13469886779785156,
0.03863372653722763,
0.19917342066764832,
0.5860552787780762,
-0.15176860988140106,
-0.7371177077293396,
0.6001603007316589,
0.4315486550331116,
0.28429627418518066,
-0.2359926402568817,
-0.6967790126800537,
0.03152763098478317,
-0.36161619424819946,
-0.23260171711444855,
0.4420696198940277,
0.5383442640304565,
-0.20598705112934113,
0.9373905658721924,
0.7126007676124573,
-0.03263347968459129,
0.042971421033144,
0.35333094000816345,
0.5709579586982727,
-0.674767792224884,
-0.3970055878162384,
-0.8831309676170349,
0.5441642999649048,
-0.21995845437049866,
-0.6302746534347534,
0.8214942216873169,
0.5954559445381165,
1.0432072877883911,
-0.27374905347824097,
0.7017077803611755,
0.03150121495127678,
0.06319019198417664,
-0.5119362473487854,
0.9243885278701782,
-1.153091549873352,
-0.260000079870224,
-0.6017295122146606,
-0.8616088628768921,
-0.2353525012731552,
0.756957471370697,
-0.25826185941696167,
0.19626735150814056,
0.49373188614845276,
0.6159868836402893,
0.10533393174409866,
-0.3982439637184143,
1.0995789766311646,
-0.04456045851111412,
0.24459026753902435,
0.8868809342384338,
1.2577033042907715,
-0.5959898233413696,
0.6820153594017029,
-0.28690218925476074,
-0.3722219467163086,
-0.29796427488327026,
-0.814133882522583,
-1.0388661623001099,
-0.7203536033630371,
0.0058660246431827545,
0.03524719551205635,
-0.15357592701911926,
0.5096498131752014,
0.6831181049346924,
-0.6006895303726196,
-0.4061513841152191,
0.43050146102905273,
-0.13028429448604584,
-0.5788872241973877,
-0.1477089822292328,
0.2916080951690674,
-0.011130797676742077,
-0.7725192308425903,
0.190912663936615,
0.5190141797065735,
-0.15417522192001343,
-0.47780337929725647,
-0.3935159146785736,
-0.2375718355178833,
-0.13493727147579193,
1.1066479682922363,
0.04204372316598892,
-1.3281669616699219,
-0.4026605784893036,
0.24175557494163513,
-0.2816265821456909,
0.15971222519874573,
0.4847189784049988,
-0.6912519335746765,
0.8786166310310364,
0.4975651204586029,
0.26405468583106995,
0.07518459856510162,
0.08474664390087128,
0.261042982339859,
-0.36969831585884094,
0.34665602445602417,
-0.12577088177204132,
0.5526295900344849,
0.30421751737594604,
0.05419135466217995,
0.6033409833908081,
0.43869635462760925,
-0.5572503209114075,
-0.7129769325256348,
-0.06663527339696884,
-1.3874503374099731,
-0.35251641273498535,
0.9578326344490051,
-0.22697919607162476,
-0.30620041489601135,
0.0736069530248642,
-0.3884395658969879,
0.02375025302171707,
-0.2716556191444397,
0.981164276599884,
0.9203249216079712,
0.17373663187026978,
-0.4409797787666321,
-0.9106557369232178,
0.03374123200774193,
0.055461131036281586,
-1.009263277053833,
-0.03547123074531555,
0.5293281078338623,
0.05351010337471962,
0.48865076899528503,
0.694849967956543,
-0.08400436490774155,
0.6178091764450073,
0.37051457166671753,
0.12303604185581207,
-0.3175576329231262,
-0.4359641373157501,
0.051790885627269745,
0.22166910767555237,
-0.13106794655323029,
-0.20990559458732605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14652v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14652v1
|
MemeCraft: Contextual and Stance-Driven Multimodal Meme Generation
| 2024-02-24T06:14:34 | 2024-02-24T06:14:34 |
Han Wang, Roy Ka-Wei Lee
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, I.2.7; I.2.10
|
Online memes have emerged as powerful digital cultural artifacts in the age
of social media, offering not only humor but also platforms for political
discourse, social critique, and information dissemination. Their extensive
reach and influence in shaping online communities' sentiments make them
invaluable tools for campaigning and promoting ideologies. Despite the
development of several meme-generation tools, there remains a gap in their
systematic evaluation and their ability to effectively communicate ideologies.
Addressing this, we introduce MemeCraft, an innovative meme generator that
leverages large language models (LLMs) and visual language models (VLMs) to
produce memes advocating specific social movements. MemeCraft presents an
end-to-end pipeline, transforming user prompts into compelling multimodal memes
without manual intervention. Conscious of the misuse potential in creating
divisive content, an intrinsic safety mechanism is embedded to curb hateful
meme production.
|
[
-0.6817557215690613,
-0.940102756023407,
0.42772090435028076,
0.4411020874977112,
-0.5557457804679871,
0.5127066373825073,
-0.01293803658336401,
0.02412554621696472,
0.48868077993392944,
0.4136010408401489,
-0.8961971998214722,
-0.325953871011734,
-0.613779604434967,
-0.05180955305695534,
-0.30456069111824036,
0.8997226357460022,
0.15210981667041779,
-0.2752006947994232,
-0.3601014316082001,
-0.17053823173046112,
-0.25633877515792847,
-0.32864049077033997,
-0.3994903266429901,
-0.22987569868564606,
0.6120627522468567,
0.38505810499191284,
0.6831842660903931,
0.5123550295829773,
0.17128467559814453,
0.3368074297904968,
0.14069174230098724,
0.06322698295116425,
-0.4224364459514618,
0.31843301653862,
-0.4471466839313507,
-0.16166292130947113,
-0.25745949149131775,
0.3283050060272217,
0.2867293357849121,
0.1791888326406479,
0.008804441429674625,
0.44443851709365845,
-0.0017470185412093997,
0.280285120010376,
-0.39013612270355225,
-0.31521666049957275,
-0.9256362318992615,
0.15158268809318542,
-0.5990811586380005,
-0.5788498520851135,
-0.07826504856348038,
-0.3385341763496399,
-0.1794121116399765,
-0.25250428915023804,
0.0036480873823165894,
0.03942390903830528,
0.3643670380115509,
-0.06606276333332062,
-0.5483033061027527,
-0.43947213888168335,
-0.5116886496543884,
1.0266891717910767,
-0.7203814387321472,
0.19375653564929962,
-0.2206554114818573,
0.4018647372722626,
-0.3782094419002533,
-0.8551957011222839,
-0.9290453195571899,
0.11392717063426971,
0.4907655417919159,
0.1735052466392517,
-0.050906747579574585,
-0.33502790331840515,
0.1636948436498642,
0.34838056564331055,
-0.4745369553565979,
-0.05537281557917595,
-0.40993231534957886,
-0.16972525417804718,
0.5327656269073486,
0.382621169090271,
0.5830478668212891,
-0.6290485858917236,
-0.771547257900238,
-0.2958854138851166,
-0.8322225213050842,
0.1428455114364624,
0.8821429014205933,
0.07080675661563873,
-0.12893733382225037,
0.6846528053283691,
-0.0408998541533947,
0.59144127368927,
0.07877833396196365,
-0.5329732894897461,
-0.05193501338362694,
-0.15324029326438904,
-0.09501613676548004,
-0.04688281565904617,
0.8444663286209106,
0.6900394558906555,
-0.03735540807247162,
0.41511091589927673,
0.061338458210229874,
0.23911623656749725,
0.2690909504890442,
-0.840282678604126,
-0.20197723805904388,
0.342282772064209,
-0.6486400365829468,
-0.6892778277397156,
0.14320902526378632,
-0.9762734770774841,
-0.6900532245635986,
-0.29538893699645996,
0.08916907012462616,
-0.08401574939489365,
-0.7620640993118286,
-0.26334673166275024,
-0.7062367796897888,
0.14622491598129272,
0.2999703884124756,
-0.6646620035171509,
-0.18554329872131348,
0.6103787422180176,
0.9414775371551514,
0.050669968128204346,
-0.10471416264772415,
-0.29427286982536316,
0.16550235450267792,
-0.3063678741455078,
0.6612464785575867,
-0.7746714353561401,
-0.45200276374816895,
-0.05836120620369911,
0.10102222114801407,
0.39512306451797485,
-0.3964802920818329,
0.1594657003879547,
-0.3827902376651764,
0.09102046489715576,
-0.20089267194271088,
-0.41520828008651733,
-0.13115975260734558,
0.539933443069458,
-0.693746030330658,
0.5819867849349976,
0.03041103668510914,
-0.5094620585441589,
0.5121058821678162,
-0.78865647315979,
-0.24278874695301056,
0.16076534986495972,
-0.3736138641834259,
-0.18035657703876495,
0.3945220112800598,
-0.2850513160228729,
0.6837687492370605,
-0.40392404794692993,
0.1872110366821289,
-0.5483238697052002,
0.1559000462293625,
0.20655202865600586,
-0.7213503122329712,
0.6740610003471375,
0.504103422164917,
-0.4225580096244812,
0.12758904695510864,
-0.6634333729743958,
-0.003029667539522052,
0.33385658264160156,
-0.45415106415748596,
-0.3809775114059448,
0.333691269159317,
0.2343839555978775,
0.7305828332901001,
0.2160472571849823,
-0.6234310865402222,
0.18402689695358276,
0.06094338372349739,
0.6290875673294067,
1.0197983980178833,
-0.09317043423652649,
0.20741957426071167,
-0.3334597647190094,
0.3653254508972168,
0.1884978711605072,
0.34947535395622253,
-0.18950720131397247,
-0.5874679684638977,
-0.1544579118490219,
-0.13270767033100128,
-0.29880058765411377,
0.377461314201355,
-0.9392784237861633,
-0.05922514572739601,
-0.001990511314943433,
-0.6296053528785706,
-0.474520206451416,
0.5717251896858215,
-0.10628939419984818,
0.15932361781597137,
0.15638522803783417,
-0.36844414472579956,
-0.4520620107650757,
-0.679161787033081,
-0.38975733518600464,
-0.19902727007865906,
0.038096457719802856,
0.2513345181941986,
0.0730176568031311,
-0.42950913310050964,
0.43334123492240906,
-0.0028791811782866716,
0.0204105693846941,
-0.4207804501056671,
0.3877076804637909,
0.09620551019906998,
0.3703188896179199,
0.6168906688690186,
-0.7286041975021362,
-0.6060646772384644,
-0.14873062074184418,
-0.755152702331543,
-0.18989796936511993,
-0.3815360367298126,
-0.12126093357801437,
-0.08032198995351791,
0.6475054025650024,
-0.2896078824996948,
0.1312674582004547,
0.9352572560310364,
-0.49510458111763,
0.39841586351394653,
0.09720619022846222,
0.5243088603019714,
-1.424713373184204,
-0.3595302999019623,
-0.2126043438911438,
-0.3662429451942444,
-0.4339838922023773,
-0.037131406366825104,
-0.29835498332977295,
-0.29486462473869324,
-0.881733238697052,
0.6157402992248535,
-0.4436347782611847,
0.28599315881729126,
-0.39584121108055115,
0.11026949435472488,
0.09372762590646744,
0.02510986290872097,
-0.1875981241464615,
0.3900455832481384,
0.3527286946773529,
-0.4591340720653534,
0.5612183213233948,
-0.025797588750720024,
-0.1752747744321823,
1.0726430416107178,
-0.3953549563884735,
0.27906495332717896,
-0.15651531517505646,
-0.10791439563035965,
-0.938340425491333,
-0.3820344805717468,
0.2725141644477844,
-0.155019149184227,
0.2614390552043915,
-0.020716583356261253,
-0.4105185866355896,
-0.624052107334137,
-0.603674590587616,
0.32208114862442017,
0.40165525674819946,
-0.7000617980957031,
0.5388977527618408,
0.5930694341659546,
-0.14013758301734924,
-0.42981916666030884,
-0.36845725774765015,
0.27500903606414795,
-0.46768367290496826,
-0.7717318534851074,
0.0716339722275734,
-0.3717057406902313,
-0.5324298143386841,
-0.04896856099367142,
0.08799555897712708,
0.30677470564842224,
-0.05326412618160248,
0.3745149075984955,
-0.31508830189704895,
-0.1207900270819664,
0.031954504549503326,
0.47005128860473633,
0.042802512645721436,
-0.07990549504756927,
-0.27123016119003296,
0.7952384352684021,
0.0024456430692225695,
-0.5706718564033508,
-0.1014707088470459,
0.7024862766265869,
0.9397334456443787,
-0.03269677609205246,
0.5359289646148682,
0.6156991124153137,
-0.16941584646701813,
-0.27712535858154297,
-0.6383769512176514,
-0.17052476108074188,
-0.5563321113586426,
0.07609685510396957,
-0.33648666739463806,
-0.8491699695587158,
0.11253725737333298,
-0.793813943862915,
0.5328354239463806,
0.29395779967308044,
0.7322536110877991,
-0.24329720437526703,
1.1424256563186646,
0.29584553837776184,
0.29501187801361084,
0.462257981300354,
0.048829931765794754,
0.1596197932958603,
-0.588897705078125,
-0.10953076928853989,
0.02076057717204094,
-0.7021389603614807,
-0.5238567590713501,
-0.7781638503074646,
0.33906289935112,
-0.11322512477636337,
0.055398326367139816,
-0.06956882774829865,
-0.5911340713500977,
0.39028438925743103,
0.6358485817909241,
-0.03590274974703789,
0.0017337455647066236,
0.44556859135627747,
-0.17326225340366364,
-0.32605111598968506,
-0.49675896763801575,
-0.8196656703948975,
0.9782499670982361,
0.0815698504447937,
0.816275417804718,
0.23597972095012665,
0.5504371523857117,
0.8068468570709229,
0.4636271297931671,
-0.4878067076206207,
0.5747959613800049,
-0.1925220936536789,
-0.6138262152671814,
-0.1025039479136467,
0.08914320170879364,
-0.6998530626296997,
0.02931884117424488,
-0.537327766418457,
-0.21732257306575775,
-0.27348461747169495,
0.40639761090278625,
0.05162064731121063,
0.7423607110977173,
-0.2621394097805023,
0.8855500221252441,
-0.3106813430786133,
-0.608405351638794,
-0.5426982641220093,
-0.4843747317790985,
0.20853784680366516,
0.23940081894397736,
0.4392746090888977,
-0.40432870388031006,
0.11005675792694092,
0.14654497802257538,
-0.30705004930496216,
0.9738429188728333,
-0.2834866940975189,
0.22746984660625458,
0.7894843220710754,
0.44041597843170166,
0.22441282868385315,
-0.11979375779628754,
0.12566454708576202,
0.354544073343277,
-0.1452166587114334,
-0.42270198464393616,
-0.2362157255411148,
1.1012959480285645,
-0.6858814358711243,
-0.7403786778450012,
0.0021809495519846678,
-0.3810802102088928,
0.31526485085487366,
0.1284799724817276,
0.19903820753097534,
0.5359835624694824,
-0.5388273000717163,
0.5138154029846191,
0.5511597394943237,
-0.2775036096572876,
0.5525455474853516,
-0.036775607615709305,
-0.19657129049301147,
-0.42785030603408813,
1.2776415348052979,
0.24528703093528748,
0.214344784617424,
-0.029151523485779762,
0.427736759185791,
-0.35874101519584656,
-0.12189554423093796,
-0.9200193285942078,
-0.1540098339319229,
-0.7832480669021606,
-0.07987655699253082,
-0.6288903951644897,
0.08799047768115997,
-0.036969684064388275,
-0.5151678323745728,
-0.3331930637359619,
-0.4155530333518982,
-0.1484142690896988,
-0.0977451354265213,
0.22652263939380646,
0.9802694320678711,
-0.245889350771904,
0.4319802522659302,
-0.40922054648399353,
0.10891049355268478,
0.7631904482841492,
0.17593321204185486,
-0.1580919772386551,
0.005193496122956276,
0.24784643948078156,
-0.06540161371231079,
-0.6836075186729431,
-1.2760789394378662,
0.1292853057384491,
0.10334889590740204,
0.43409204483032227,
0.693088710308075,
-0.16764739155769348,
0.5006794333457947,
-0.6881165504455566,
1.0457653999328613,
0.5220950245857239,
-0.7851198315620422,
0.5831615924835205,
-0.40602773427963257,
0.09892256557941437,
0.04483626410365105,
0.19356228411197662,
-0.5348163843154907,
-0.6091929078102112,
-0.7408172488212585,
-0.8335095643997192,
0.09275555610656738,
-0.08312468975782394,
0.7460278272628784,
-0.5296130180358887,
0.07327701151371002,
0.3390367329120636,
0.5631712675094604,
-0.8334965109825134,
-0.06262587010860443,
-0.8645159602165222,
-0.20973707735538483,
0.1440334916114807,
-0.48184844851493835,
-0.28943365812301636,
-0.15207383036613464,
0.6258132457733154,
-0.31013497710227966,
-0.06508978456258774,
0.06232379749417305,
-0.11188431084156036,
-0.356964111328125,
0.24884140491485596,
0.639270007610321,
0.6006338596343994,
0.1375882625579834,
0.6323379278182983,
-0.10815392434597015,
-0.25028282403945923,
0.3298080861568451,
-0.526934802532196,
-0.11615747958421707,
0.09509427100419998,
-0.29371798038482666,
0.6093305945396423,
-0.16219981014728546,
-0.4781688153743744,
0.4364056885242462,
0.03164992108941078,
-0.10512654483318329,
-0.47572505474090576,
-0.04762943461537361,
0.4474577009677887,
0.5878675580024719,
0.04595889523625374,
0.058443497866392136,
0.10320309549570084,
-0.5609981417655945,
0.21398580074310303,
0.8012209534645081,
-0.4832588732242584,
-0.6063918471336365,
1.0665454864501953,
0.32119348645210266,
-0.41331177949905396,
0.006489343009889126,
-0.17234675586223602,
-0.05637788027524948,
0.4008225202560425,
0.7942227721214294,
0.8736799359321594,
-0.4572794437408447,
0.5362703800201416,
0.34100207686424255,
0.43996134400367737,
0.34287741780281067,
0.338838666677475,
-0.025339283049106598,
-0.4715399146080017,
-0.03358672186732292,
-0.7044550180435181,
-0.272954523563385,
0.36268141865730286,
-0.034087590873241425,
0.47462373971939087,
-0.9207990169525146,
-0.3472706377506256,
-0.08437565714120865,
-0.40857264399528503,
-0.5064478516578674,
0.11545536667108536,
0.3818553388118744,
0.6434853672981262,
-0.8888999223709106,
0.2953679859638214,
0.8680163621902466,
-0.20961691439151764,
-0.26069724559783936,
-0.13373897969722748,
0.5679337382316589,
-0.49981874227523804,
-0.05753512680530548,
0.3429776728153229,
-0.1289518177509308,
0.05997214838862419,
-1.0640232563018799,
-0.45472729206085205,
1.0996989011764526,
0.22899314761161804,
-0.4166984260082245,
0.5223696231842041,
0.2299312800168991,
0.28862297534942627,
-0.6207351684570312,
-0.014685682021081448,
-0.0705542340874672,
0.33895108103752136,
0.10190132260322571,
-0.2393452376127243,
0.20587798953056335,
-0.4001714885234833,
0.08863668888807297,
0.14368848502635956,
-0.7259120941162109,
1.1415555477142334,
0.06471873819828033,
-0.058497823774814606,
-0.2706444561481476,
0.4890734553337097,
0.3138046860694885,
0.3540519177913666,
0.7655839323997498,
0.20845571160316467,
0.44047650694847107,
0.0724562481045723,
1.0436196327209473,
-0.4747621417045593,
-0.21076668798923492,
0.6569381952285767,
0.06613455712795258,
0.6081558465957642,
0.8211625814437866,
0.23215565085411072,
0.7886718511581421,
0.5033164620399475,
0.10880136489868164,
0.3388688564300537,
0.3187747895717621,
-0.6209707856178284,
-0.548215925693512,
-0.26187947392463684,
-0.26379406452178955,
0.3770446479320526,
0.5169338583946228,
-0.26896148920059204,
-0.2886202335357666,
-0.05442916974425316,
0.2800752818584442,
0.38290107250213623,
-0.23152759671211243,
0.7456610202789307,
0.09535366296768188,
-0.37291449308395386,
0.11972998827695847,
-0.01853984221816063,
0.4982745945453644,
-0.5753297209739685,
-0.31139445304870605,
0.11832202970981598,
0.030210815370082855,
-0.11531785875558853,
-0.6981654763221741,
0.31529176235198975,
-0.08773171156644821,
-0.24058803915977478,
-0.2904667854309082,
1.016342282295227,
-0.4353993833065033,
-0.3860826790332794,
0.29639798402786255,
0.8593264222145081,
0.21510791778564453,
0.00575306685641408,
-0.9858607053756714,
0.09718338400125504,
-0.03701181709766388,
-0.32598263025283813,
0.35180601477622986,
0.5860913395881653,
-0.333397775888443,
0.40306881070137024,
1.0141046047210693,
-0.04740463197231293,
0.2798597514629364,
0.09943828731775284,
0.8711290955543518,
-0.46567246317863464,
-0.209310844540596,
-1.1561427116394043,
0.8432372212409973,
-0.47500067949295044,
-0.16031989455223083,
0.7979283928871155,
0.16448713839054108,
0.7264925241470337,
-0.24296286702156067,
1.0938689708709717,
-0.5394201278686523,
0.26910343766212463,
-0.0604112446308136,
0.8331136703491211,
-1.0291889905929565,
-0.07074043154716492,
-0.34903183579444885,
-0.8160480260848999,
-0.005031315144151449,
0.4679798483848572,
0.374568372964859,
-0.44772204756736755,
-0.04988165199756622,
0.6243957281112671,
-0.36188042163848877,
-0.14734666049480438,
0.6206740736961365,
0.09395807981491089,
0.6229925155639648,
0.06503407657146454,
1.178713083267212,
-0.0336037315428257,
0.3967364728450775,
-0.234893798828125,
-0.33222365379333496,
-0.11768070608377457,
-1.1965558528900146,
-1.2539278268814087,
-0.5839126706123352,
-0.10260295122861862,
-0.41777342557907104,
-0.33062949776649475,
1.3500587940216064,
0.624904215335846,
-0.6588009595870972,
-0.37760257720947266,
0.10490790754556656,
0.31439295411109924,
-0.06061751767992973,
-0.21714641153812408,
-0.2578878700733185,
-0.10517209023237228,
-0.8980317115783691,
0.41712486743927,
0.7743460536003113,
0.1065535694360733,
-0.7297689914703369,
0.013206765986979008,
-0.25896838307380676,
0.6230483651161194,
1.012485384941101,
0.22501853108406067,
-0.7545314431190491,
-0.27134525775909424,
0.0657736212015152,
0.15676932036876678,
-0.1016116663813591,
0.8189026117324829,
-0.3044945299625397,
0.9902382493019104,
0.6178964376449585,
0.25334981083869934,
0.027732644230127335,
-0.1073533371090889,
0.583163321018219,
-0.8670533895492554,
0.5329318642616272,
-0.06128793954849243,
0.3033550977706909,
0.5993973016738892,
-0.08343146741390228,
0.23873870074748993,
0.5189802646636963,
-0.24089279770851135,
-0.7181369662284851,
0.39585548639297485,
-0.5418791770935059,
-0.26743990182876587,
0.9973336458206177,
0.291355699300766,
-0.25373217463493347,
-0.17600898444652557,
-0.39067336916923523,
0.13547760248184204,
-0.26475590467453003,
0.8968889713287354,
0.6438180208206177,
0.17040280997753143,
-0.11141497641801834,
-0.5831775069236755,
0.5220233201980591,
0.17616721987724304,
-0.6288312673568726,
-0.32425805926322937,
0.5857345461845398,
0.3891817331314087,
0.4254162311553955,
0.6490898132324219,
-0.051648251712322235,
0.12373098731040955,
0.06742130219936371,
0.23995494842529297,
0.12618102133274078,
-0.5306086540222168,
0.3593370020389557,
0.42967653274536133,
-0.07667582482099533,
0.0033112457022070885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15733v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15733v2
|
ArEEG_Chars: Dataset for Envisioned Speech Recognition using EEG for Arabic Characters
| 2024-02-24T06:05:15 | 2024-04-01T06:59:21 |
Hazem Darwish, Abdalrahman Al Malah, Khloud Al Jallad, Nada Ghneim
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.SP
|
Brain-Computer-Interface (BCI) has been a hot research topic in the last few
years that could help paralyzed people in their lives. Several researches were
done to classify electroencephalography (EEG) signals automatically into
English characters and words. Arabic language is one of the most used languages
around the world. However, to the best of our knowledge, there is no dataset
for Arabic characters EEG signals. In this paper, we have created an EEG
dataset for Arabic characters and named it ArEEG_Chars. Moreover, several
experiments were done on ArEEG_Chars using deep learning. Best results were
achieved using LSTM and reached an accuracy of 97%. ArEEG_Chars dataset will be
public for researchers.
|
[
-0.4044812023639679,
-0.6691994071006775,
0.4269324541091919,
0.267461359500885,
-0.3593631982803345,
0.2509612739086151,
-0.2358262687921524,
-0.5419861078262329,
0.5751054883003235,
0.3473048508167267,
-0.42399728298187256,
-1.003900170326233,
-0.5599578022956848,
0.13378356397151947,
-0.30487820506095886,
0.4365425109863281,
0.05350157991051674,
0.3838517367839813,
0.38401076197624207,
-0.3276340365409851,
-0.5948251485824585,
-0.4673711657524109,
-0.7752512097358704,
-0.28024327754974365,
0.459150105714798,
0.43216198682785034,
0.34781166911125183,
0.2622840106487274,
-0.02067953161895275,
0.3289424479007721,
-0.0014755834126845002,
0.23938097059726715,
-0.05307057127356529,
0.04318724945187569,
0.19556306302547455,
-0.15815937519073486,
-0.3288975656032562,
-0.46912243962287903,
0.6456809639930725,
0.5491713285446167,
-0.06593498587608337,
-0.14355804026126862,
-0.12357190251350403,
0.6926135420799255,
-0.4259185492992401,
0.11171901971101761,
-0.4757413864135742,
0.2248462736606598,
-0.2232837677001953,
0.1337774395942688,
-0.3211946189403534,
-0.680853545665741,
-0.14953787624835968,
-0.08984380215406418,
-0.13907881081104279,
0.3084580600261688,
0.5377396941184998,
-0.05242644622921944,
-0.5774407982826233,
-0.18492351472377777,
-0.4932088553905487,
0.8452346920967102,
-0.8143404126167297,
0.629439651966095,
0.5060468316078186,
0.3229984939098358,
-0.1740274876356125,
-0.6606946587562561,
-0.5232723355293274,
-0.06131814792752266,
0.17164617776870728,
-0.032097481191158295,
-0.4214974641799927,
0.30118894577026367,
0.3279709815979004,
0.11317480355501175,
-0.685684859752655,
0.48049452900886536,
-0.2756249010562897,
-0.4633386731147766,
0.9211418628692627,
-0.016981488093733788,
0.5805237293243408,
0.15254941582679749,
-0.08437690883874893,
0.03238772228360176,
-0.8158363103866577,
0.08089209347963333,
0.30215612053871155,
0.255860835313797,
-0.3466094136238098,
0.3936535716056824,
-0.06599648296833038,
0.682806670665741,
-0.0070670233108103275,
0.004805775359272957,
0.6531558036804199,
0.09877987205982208,
-0.17863541841506958,
0.9091911911964417,
0.5522180199623108,
0.06150253117084503,
0.48718011379241943,
-0.20926985144615173,
-0.07465557008981705,
-0.21591073274612427,
0.15938422083854675,
-0.7111409902572632,
-0.038191426545381546,
0.22811947762966156,
-0.6377453804016113,
0.2958122789859772,
-0.19173286855220795,
-0.6663810014724731,
-0.40056103467941284,
-0.4057616889476776,
0.10073944926261902,
-0.7016674876213074,
-0.24748606979846954,
0.1612696498632431,
0.2269301563501358,
0.43449127674102783,
0.1547551155090332,
-0.8926740288734436,
0.3219122886657715,
0.17867814004421234,
0.6940790414810181,
-0.07554606348276138,
0.07159124314785004,
-0.20521245896816254,
-0.009851261042058468,
-0.2290901243686676,
0.6394236087799072,
-0.39409545063972473,
-0.5292604565620422,
0.22184820473194122,
-0.08365848660469055,
0.0054465304128825665,
-0.4212833344936371,
1.0470530986785889,
-0.5796071887016296,
-0.2791527509689331,
-0.41058531403541565,
-0.747252881526947,
-0.7714688777923584,
-0.2161998599767685,
-0.5469555854797363,
0.23886041343212128,
-0.3831520080566406,
-0.6918787360191345,
0.14410901069641113,
-0.4203703999519348,
-0.5858696699142456,
0.477973073720932,
-0.5859693884849548,
-0.6154717803001404,
0.17242199182510376,
0.6347470283508301,
0.37998005747795105,
-0.020626986399292946,
-0.020114483311772346,
-0.1952168047428131,
-0.5021190643310547,
0.5149296522140503,
-0.509074330329895,
0.837097704410553,
0.407603919506073,
-0.18331360816955566,
-0.22308091819286346,
-1.0113215446472168,
0.7422373294830322,
-0.2593592405319214,
-0.28037407994270325,
-0.12857064604759216,
0.3318754732608795,
0.5411040782928467,
-0.1843298077583313,
0.13226650655269623,
-0.8942256569862366,
-0.14192380011081696,
-0.5382981896400452,
0.275368332862854,
0.4283900558948517,
0.07408416271209717,
-0.19537639617919922,
0.011012045666575432,
0.3741816580295563,
0.18093325197696686,
-0.5122334957122803,
0.11240820586681366,
-0.5056188106536865,
-0.8398740887641907,
-0.5566108822822571,
0.6406859159469604,
0.7203317880630493,
-0.5457718372344971,
1.0079197883605957,
-0.16824235022068024,
-0.6621018648147583,
-0.46434202790260315,
-0.5116943717002869,
0.43775513768196106,
0.20358410477638245,
0.2901022732257843,
-0.20035432279109955,
-0.9360761046409607,
-1.3463826179504395,
-0.4102812111377716,
-0.27089723944664,
-0.24694594740867615,
0.25389304757118225,
0.1683630645275116,
-0.3904758393764496,
0.7161355018615723,
-0.3788953125476837,
-0.3684544265270233,
-0.18908938765525818,
0.3904784917831421,
0.5044975876808167,
0.6061049103736877,
0.48929938673973083,
-0.6360782980918884,
-0.4407484829425812,
0.07389482855796814,
-0.6948991417884827,
-0.17507849633693695,
0.2097487896680832,
0.16846808791160583,
0.10363444685935974,
0.32664111256599426,
-0.16292902827262878,
0.5275817513465881,
0.291668176651001,
-0.3568791449069977,
0.15632747113704681,
-0.03727711737155914,
0.4778077304363251,
-1.0251545906066895,
-0.055786728858947754,
-0.042778436094522476,
-0.22199910879135132,
-0.6000884175300598,
-0.5779241919517517,
0.26098230481147766,
-0.13715165853500366,
-0.5612760186195374,
0.33944499492645264,
-0.45804911851882935,
0.056486405432224274,
-0.3203006088733673,
-0.2535356283187866,
-0.508754312992096,
0.5860547423362732,
0.31050148606300354,
0.8364690542221069,
0.999301016330719,
-0.5401133894920349,
0.5055007338523865,
0.43880054354667664,
-0.7872251272201538,
0.48663511872291565,
-0.5832873582839966,
0.6274710297584534,
-0.012495685368776321,
-0.31732815504074097,
-0.8813452124595642,
-0.21379567682743073,
0.04961298778653145,
-0.48404648900032043,
0.5809633731842041,
0.32998406887054443,
-0.3195776641368866,
-0.23128461837768555,
-0.025665082037448883,
0.5566341280937195,
0.7916885614395142,
-0.6821795105934143,
0.5288633704185486,
0.7806810736656189,
-0.41258716583251953,
-0.5059837102890015,
-0.8012981414794922,
0.2584122121334076,
-0.20534029603004456,
-0.4621265232563019,
0.404928594827652,
-0.0036412884946912527,
-0.016822457313537598,
-0.36933860182762146,
0.036394260823726654,
-0.28681737184524536,
-0.35582825541496277,
0.46274101734161377,
-0.17369955778121948,
-0.0202279444783926,
0.1606157124042511,
0.564443826675415,
-0.048532772809267044,
-0.04258156567811966,
0.12555348873138428,
0.36116793751716614,
-0.1564841866493225,
-0.4721904695034027,
-0.6523247957229614,
0.5457193851470947,
0.3266519606113434,
-0.09644932299852371,
0.35705214738845825,
0.28965485095977783,
-0.7293277978897095,
-0.044247329235076904,
-0.6455411911010742,
0.04483629763126373,
-0.5150446891784668,
0.8897684216499329,
-0.32580816745758057,
-0.6177632212638855,
0.34877851605415344,
-0.2631811797618866,
-0.057498618960380554,
-0.13531062006950378,
0.6312981247901917,
-0.03448635712265968,
1.3359071016311646,
0.3897078335285187,
-0.400173157453537,
0.09867487102746964,
0.1373932808637619,
0.410018652677536,
-0.5965977311134338,
-0.28424614667892456,
-0.6578201651573181,
-0.6057477593421936,
-0.46028879284858704,
0.21906360983848572,
0.5799358487129211,
-0.319903701543808,
-0.05914304032921791,
0.19316688179969788,
-0.4005641043186188,
0.4925467371940613,
0.304415225982666,
0.5062830448150635,
-0.05520130693912506,
0.4215535819530487,
-0.06947355717420578,
-0.4069870114326477,
-0.3232192099094391,
-0.7457460165023804,
0.8758573532104492,
0.2342819720506668,
0.9639939665794373,
0.03232603147625923,
0.5931832790374756,
0.7343536019325256,
-0.293245792388916,
-0.6181175708770752,
0.7644086480140686,
0.07671380788087845,
-0.3374289572238922,
-0.0913759246468544,
-0.021046625450253487,
-1.1619552373886108,
-0.18915651738643646,
-0.15360534191131592,
-0.9866617321968079,
0.4819452464580536,
0.041657183319330215,
-0.3397895097732544,
0.25821512937545776,
-0.7092701196670532,
0.15190650522708893,
-0.27920955419540405,
0.04162830486893654,
-0.4916759729385376,
-0.5836939215660095,
0.02537420392036438,
-0.09541159123182297,
0.00115418981295079,
0.00908947829157114,
0.13202117383480072,
1.2130558490753174,
-0.19441498816013336,
0.6597011685371399,
-0.11730584502220154,
0.14017117023468018,
0.4342116415500641,
-0.33136221766471863,
0.2517698109149933,
0.016326386481523514,
-0.25326472520828247,
0.6968415975570679,
-0.07154562324285507,
-0.3867911398410797,
-0.1732739806175232,
0.8274171352386475,
-0.9618362188339233,
-0.30298125743865967,
-0.6116808652877808,
-0.2559325098991394,
-0.43895167112350464,
0.1286834329366684,
0.4134860336780548,
0.5841054320335388,
-0.7269515991210938,
0.07165386527776718,
0.6973347067832947,
-0.37425076961517334,
0.678501546382904,
0.4412807524204254,
-0.1479387730360031,
-0.8546680212020874,
0.8487231731414795,
0.5206295847892761,
-0.603084921836853,
0.2560873329639435,
-0.46719714999198914,
-0.39999714493751526,
-0.8347004055976868,
-0.474223256111145,
0.3155893385410309,
-0.6225703954696655,
-0.3058810234069824,
-0.3960706889629364,
-0.6920909285545349,
-0.310275673866272,
-0.06925474852323532,
0.17368096113204956,
-0.1981237530708313,
-0.4892878830432892,
-0.37671220302581787,
0.4106144607067108,
0.5248235464096069,
-0.0675821378827095,
0.3974127769470215,
-0.7787075042724609,
0.2275381237268448,
0.38264283537864685,
0.1331726312637329,
-0.06094948947429657,
-0.24695667624473572,
-0.6779913306236267,
0.24604138731956482,
-0.41369688510894775,
-1.15179443359375,
0.8664254546165466,
0.4364466369152069,
0.5520275831222534,
0.6128606200218201,
-0.050297822803258896,
0.4688400328159332,
-0.8231181502342224,
0.6157453060150146,
0.32949501276016235,
-1.114181399345398,
0.33600756525993347,
0.0676761195063591,
0.2293921411037445,
0.38784292340278625,
0.41814061999320984,
-0.6039903163909912,
-0.0033845186699181795,
-0.24279770255088806,
-0.5848262310028076,
0.8039785027503967,
0.37743282318115234,
-0.0059851366095244884,
0.0976371318101883,
0.32639026641845703,
0.4680987298488617,
0.36803045868873596,
-0.39674779772758484,
-0.43335679173469543,
0.016482865437865257,
-0.7091114521026611,
0.18184629082679749,
-0.5037913918495178,
0.23680256307125092,
-0.36055195331573486,
0.7610181570053101,
0.16844534873962402,
0.629994809627533,
-0.002981023397296667,
-0.10219195485115051,
-0.10626764595508575,
0.47503602504730225,
0.3389589488506317,
0.457314133644104,
-0.14432400465011597,
0.15027518570423126,
0.4830351173877716,
-0.9205165505409241,
0.4006015956401825,
0.038884200155735016,
-0.13351525366306305,
0.21405129134655,
0.3060573935508728,
1.1121199131011963,
-0.3004506230354309,
-0.822396457195282,
0.13719442486763,
-0.21888986229896545,
-0.1912420243024826,
-0.9009389281272888,
0.19980968534946442,
-0.158140167593956,
0.39880964159965515,
0.44095519185066223,
-0.1415042281150818,
0.21137523651123047,
-0.09654025733470917,
0.10341265052556992,
0.437813937664032,
-0.28600114583969116,
-0.34783294796943665,
0.35734644532203674,
0.40654075145721436,
-0.8743672966957092,
1.0230216979980469,
0.12756362557411194,
-0.3561713695526123,
0.6453781723976135,
0.523594319820404,
1.097090244293213,
-0.37825441360473633,
-0.20353826880455017,
0.4461638629436493,
0.05203826352953911,
0.36761000752449036,
0.890559196472168,
0.008586680516600609,
-0.7763776183128357,
-0.2149970680475235,
-0.6177317500114441,
-0.36045244336128235,
0.31215283274650574,
-0.39707186818122864,
0.6180815696716309,
-0.4674599766731262,
-0.3807724118232727,
-0.16130758821964264,
-0.036777712404727936,
-0.5406178832054138,
0.40207841992378235,
0.6385185718536377,
0.7868283987045288,
-0.7996434569358826,
0.9703403115272522,
0.5499603748321533,
-0.10309402644634247,
-0.4373685121536255,
-0.2299388349056244,
-0.28840357065200806,
-0.927373468875885,
0.7967836856842041,
0.3135416805744171,
-0.06972194463014603,
0.5005601048469543,
-0.7938127517700195,
-0.8651813268661499,
0.8289020657539368,
0.49479562044143677,
-0.9267738461494446,
0.07611154764890671,
0.35133096575737,
0.1912170797586441,
-0.3728088140487671,
0.3623563349246979,
0.3021180331707001,
0.7161059975624084,
-0.3222978115081787,
-0.5990367531776428,
-0.16368527710437775,
-0.22029109299182892,
0.06953000277280807,
0.05050986632704735,
-0.43092238903045654,
0.3099604547023773,
-0.023133374750614166,
-0.40585529804229736,
0.23720096051692963,
1.2315713167190552,
0.2431623488664627,
0.35782861709594727,
0.4196033477783203,
0.6701395511627197,
0.7020749449729919,
-0.15867550671100616,
0.28595563769340515,
-0.17060309648513794,
0.006404619198292494,
0.6545089483261108,
-0.38899993896484375,
0.581056535243988,
0.3995331823825836,
-0.34711483120918274,
0.6441184282302856,
0.7196412682533264,
0.0253509059548378,
0.8189467787742615,
0.30856746435165405,
-0.6457678079605103,
-0.3104133903980255,
0.07505431026220322,
-0.45049944519996643,
0.4276280105113983,
0.6686546802520752,
-0.3314990997314453,
-0.0545695461332798,
0.3992195129394531,
0.03741824999451637,
-0.012867770157754421,
-0.47954320907592773,
0.6756928563117981,
0.1890495866537094,
-0.2673145532608032,
0.7518029808998108,
0.09418153762817383,
0.5161997079849243,
-0.819864809513092,
-0.22103562951087952,
0.1985335350036621,
0.008867373690009117,
-0.20884166657924652,
-0.41341426968574524,
0.06549123674631119,
0.03891413286328316,
-0.13503685593605042,
0.10176698863506317,
0.7425357699394226,
-0.45392072200775146,
-0.7197417616844177,
0.06352726370096207,
0.3250506818294525,
0.5777645111083984,
0.16452325880527496,
-0.5287904739379883,
0.07455640286207199,
0.1923096626996994,
0.0245908722281456,
0.12907467782497406,
0.2088111788034439,
0.08307509869337082,
0.432931125164032,
0.12328598648309708,
0.3602212071418762,
0.1502859741449356,
-0.10491728037595749,
0.5263506174087524,
-0.8987064361572266,
-0.5434224009513855,
-0.8443435430526733,
0.31515079736709595,
-0.138257697224617,
-0.08810565620660782,
0.7765066027641296,
0.6466021537780762,
0.3157344162464142,
-0.2383653074502945,
0.999226987361908,
-0.08609353750944138,
0.7597061395645142,
-0.6901834607124329,
1.0061891078948975,
-0.19496193528175354,
-0.07855358719825745,
-0.0011048588203266263,
-0.6974214315414429,
-0.24038910865783691,
0.5668222308158875,
-0.005966308992356062,
0.29439228773117065,
0.6814498901367188,
0.7625623941421509,
-0.017382115125656128,
0.41658398509025574,
0.6915192604064941,
0.3551710844039917,
0.1722201704978943,
0.7526544332504272,
0.48948952555656433,
-0.3774808943271637,
-0.14997512102127075,
0.09582386165857315,
-0.22001118957996368,
-0.195406973361969,
-0.6215131878852844,
-0.9782562255859375,
-0.6240805983543396,
-0.5118205547332764,
-0.06448812037706375,
0.31188857555389404,
1.1507006883621216,
0.6419589519500732,
-1.1904181241989136,
-0.4385189116001129,
-0.1699376404285431,
0.07931523025035858,
-0.3205665349960327,
0.011744183488190174,
0.8665097951889038,
-0.051435038447380066,
-0.9869149923324585,
0.6262958645820618,
0.10027521103620529,
0.18220442533493042,
-0.040137890726327896,
-0.05128607526421547,
-0.27396443486213684,
0.17922960221767426,
0.22697466611862183,
0.5776949524879456,
-0.43232667446136475,
-0.3279418349266052,
-0.21682710945606232,
0.12179965525865555,
0.2485293745994568,
0.5015037059783936,
-1.0269912481307983,
0.3414013683795929,
0.4187750518321991,
0.630662739276886,
0.22211989760398865,
-0.38757362961769104,
0.4813898801803589,
-0.6700202226638794,
0.27387145161628723,
0.33594414591789246,
0.7191833257675171,
0.30027174949645996,
-0.16858424246311188,
0.2232314944267273,
-0.017255526036024094,
-0.8633844256401062,
-0.6237042546272278,
0.31702664494514465,
-1.0672831535339355,
0.16120454668998718,
0.894478976726532,
-0.10488888621330261,
-0.22272267937660217,
-0.3780577480792999,
-0.7655661106109619,
0.5873739719390869,
-0.5383475422859192,
0.7214086055755615,
0.563099205493927,
-0.2876397371292114,
-0.09446318447589874,
0.06954677402973175,
0.24257177114486694,
0.41629302501678467,
-0.6721226572990417,
-0.2165067344903946,
0.5337257385253906,
-0.22092971205711365,
-0.03404569998383522,
0.31107234954833984,
0.04883703216910362,
0.046224068850278854,
-0.19496020674705505,
0.43446066975593567,
-0.018863286823034286,
0.012056279927492142,
-0.5077939629554749,
0.07808718085289001,
0.23690582811832428,
-0.6841874718666077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15729v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15729v2
|
How Do Humans Write Code? Large Models Do It the Same Way Too
| 2024-02-24T05:40:01 | 2024-06-17T06:00:41 |
Long Li, Xuzheng He
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
Program-of-Thought (PoT) replaces natural language-based Chain-of-Thought
(CoT) as the most popular method in Large Language Models (LLMs) mathematical
reasoning tasks by utilizing external tool calls to circumvent computational
errors. However, our evaluation of the GPT-4 and Llama series reveals that
using PoT introduces more reasoning errors, such as incorrect formulas or
flawed logic, compared to CoT. To address this issue, we propose Human-Think
Language (HTL), which leverages a suite of strategies that help integrate PoT
and CoT, encompassing: (1) a new generation paradigm that uses full CoT
reasoning to control code generation. (2) Focus Attention, that directs model
attention to the CoT reasoning during PoT to generate more logical code. (3)
reinforcement learning that utilizes the accuracy of both CoT and PoT responses
as rewards to prevent repetitive reasoning steps in LLMs when solving difficult
math problems. Our method achieves an average improvement of 6.5% on the
Llama-Base model and 4.3% on the Mistral-Base model across 8 mathematical
calculation datasets. It also shows significant effectiveness on five
out-of-domain datasets by controlling the model's information flow, exhibiting
strong transferability. Additionally, HTL shows the most significant
improvement in non-mathematical natural language inference task, contributing
to a unified reasoning task framework
|
[
-0.31747713685035706,
-0.8541807532310486,
0.7156780362129211,
0.3608648478984833,
-0.07336895912885666,
0.40166914463043213,
-0.45456981658935547,
-0.29888853430747986,
-0.2989266514778137,
0.5952985286712646,
-0.42226642370224,
-0.4690113067626953,
-0.3030647337436676,
0.09594711661338806,
-0.05556317791342735,
0.9210838079452515,
-0.24832287430763245,
-0.06645843386650085,
-0.1485101580619812,
0.3069833815097809,
-0.49773794412612915,
-0.8289090991020203,
-0.5177116990089417,
-0.49923932552337646,
0.5850074887275696,
0.3767589330673218,
0.7546595335006714,
0.35504961013793945,
0.7352162599563599,
0.18507449328899384,
0.21871185302734375,
0.34599044919013977,
-0.46631109714508057,
-0.22153663635253906,
-0.20673926174640656,
-0.7781481146812439,
-0.4378505349159241,
-0.14182044565677643,
0.11797865480184555,
0.4587552845478058,
-0.3794368803501129,
0.12765656411647797,
-0.1671869307756424,
0.7575435042381287,
-0.6844374537467957,
0.37182191014289856,
-0.6232858896255493,
0.17666292190551758,
0.0029042763635516167,
-0.46745818853378296,
-0.8448371291160583,
-0.39482009410858154,
-0.09386185556650162,
-0.5302073955535889,
-0.05122773349285126,
0.16745196282863617,
0.4832186698913574,
0.4421229064464569,
-0.2813311219215393,
-0.3295210301876068,
-0.8181285858154297,
0.8457862138748169,
-0.6521879434585571,
0.09805256873369217,
0.6222617626190186,
0.19013704359531403,
-0.4934341609477997,
-0.4462767243385315,
-0.8276704549789429,
-0.2924462854862213,
0.1230921745300293,
-0.09340059757232666,
-0.14715178310871124,
-0.04786252975463867,
0.3839579224586487,
0.0075383796356618404,
-0.3758598566055298,
-0.2551765739917755,
-0.5280989408493042,
-0.09380384534597397,
0.735190212726593,
0.10301164537668228,
0.3445636034011841,
-0.06374792754650116,
-0.21033570170402527,
-0.14804258942604065,
-0.9908755421638489,
-0.07403983920812607,
0.03526054322719574,
0.12917202711105347,
-0.0347200371325016,
0.5556597709655762,
0.11473030596971512,
0.6306771039962769,
-0.10828665643930435,
-0.16281728446483612,
0.08537007123231888,
-0.08079350739717484,
-0.5306688547134399,
-0.004019823856651783,
0.7410807013511658,
0.1134239062666893,
0.7136546969413757,
-0.1762790083885193,
-0.1969301551580429,
0.6152158975601196,
0.5509318709373474,
-0.48042532801628113,
-0.4870782196521759,
0.027343301102519035,
-0.05294310301542282,
-0.48536476492881775,
-0.060101866722106934,
-0.5297611355781555,
-0.4463757276535034,
-0.7134798169136047,
0.38885918259620667,
-0.3511219322681427,
-0.10898274183273315,
0.35328176617622375,
0.17495985329151154,
0.2943069636821747,
0.30148783326148987,
-0.7918168902397156,
0.5312299132347107,
0.6926400661468506,
0.477959007024765,
-0.20278386771678925,
-0.44870343804359436,
-0.6254367828369141,
0.21667224168777466,
-0.689785897731781,
0.7753178477287292,
-0.514464795589447,
-0.23197408020496368,
-0.3676499128341675,
-0.43939661979675293,
-0.030075928196310997,
-0.5301299691200256,
0.375069797039032,
-0.4830552935600281,
0.16821381449699402,
-0.643027126789093,
-0.3852822780609131,
0.0708988755941391,
0.1732119619846344,
-0.467586487531662,
1.0312217473983765,
0.18416191637516022,
-0.7627684473991394,
0.3613623082637787,
-1.0840070247650146,
-0.48277148604393005,
-0.03090624324977398,
-0.3967110216617584,
-0.49391961097717285,
-0.051443904638290405,
0.29548078775405884,
0.16296668350696564,
-0.5303065776824951,
0.40398719906806946,
-0.14410431683063507,
-0.521965503692627,
0.5468393564224243,
-0.42054083943367004,
0.6904042959213257,
0.2627379596233368,
-0.8015196323394775,
0.37853750586509705,
-0.2673466205596924,
0.22864212095737457,
0.45929786562919617,
-0.2903735935688019,
-0.012426890432834625,
-0.063041552901268,
-0.21256539225578308,
0.3889099061489105,
-0.3130597472190857,
-0.41794487833976746,
0.36136487126350403,
-0.21138623356819153,
0.6712805032730103,
0.7606441974639893,
-0.011792567558586597,
0.39735880494117737,
-0.5470430850982666,
0.615347146987915,
0.07298120856285095,
0.06470557302236557,
0.059521839022636414,
-0.5673583745956421,
-0.8311136960983276,
-0.15299619734287262,
0.10485272109508514,
0.5985772013664246,
-0.8845260143280029,
0.29308003187179565,
-0.018471693620085716,
-0.310298889875412,
-0.4357014298439026,
0.400244802236557,
0.5542722344398499,
0.46193861961364746,
0.35277435183525085,
-0.11118849366903305,
-0.5688163042068481,
-0.4880481958389282,
-0.1170608177781105,
-0.2691623866558075,
0.07415205985307693,
0.1352064609527588,
0.5996769666671753,
-0.2586369514465332,
0.9931196570396423,
-0.732735812664032,
0.03916288912296295,
-0.5189502835273743,
0.26306068897247314,
-0.02490961365401745,
0.2879958748817444,
0.24693827331066132,
-0.6555079817771912,
-0.4183639585971832,
-0.021597912535071373,
-0.7616854310035706,
-0.012579753994941711,
-0.28325334191322327,
-0.6098883748054504,
0.28601133823394775,
0.36728793382644653,
-0.7446023225784302,
0.7338939905166626,
0.12150298804044724,
-0.46163713932037354,
0.6289278268814087,
-0.3650388717651367,
0.05329114571213722,
-0.7354072332382202,
-0.07110711187124252,
-0.09652047604322433,
-0.16365303099155426,
-0.3074931502342224,
0.22719576954841614,
0.11903645843267441,
-0.031197436153888702,
-0.3520444333553314,
0.3141026794910431,
-0.4874371886253357,
-0.2962146997451782,
-0.34658220410346985,
-0.0659448578953743,
0.15963010489940643,
0.9918492436408997,
-0.02392234280705452,
1.0004228353500366,
0.3528704345226288,
-0.6061980128288269,
0.5224002003669739,
0.16356945037841797,
-0.3516688048839569,
0.19885285198688507,
-0.640905499458313,
0.4525992274284363,
-0.08351746946573257,
0.5354263782501221,
-0.6790294051170349,
-0.1940915882587433,
0.16225065290927887,
-0.3337918817996979,
0.06454724073410034,
0.4060313403606415,
-0.6923252940177917,
-0.6467625498771667,
-0.20898683369159698,
0.3583662211894989,
0.7028268575668335,
-0.5217323899269104,
0.44432002305984497,
0.36331284046173096,
-0.07741428166627884,
-0.5246091485023499,
-0.7589406967163086,
0.2262495905160904,
-0.04961787909269333,
-0.42205876111984253,
0.18760980665683746,
-0.04727540910243988,
-0.44099363684654236,
-0.0343770794570446,
0.06408445537090302,
-0.055267397314310074,
0.10149428248405457,
0.0849083662033081,
0.5434295535087585,
-0.10091399401426315,
0.31923040747642517,
-0.15440410375595093,
-0.017688391730189323,
0.25243380665779114,
-0.38494545221328735,
0.8183399438858032,
-0.48772233724594116,
-0.4937804341316223,
-0.22936297953128815,
0.16082684695720673,
0.6134338974952698,
-0.5272091627120972,
0.41764092445373535,
0.349398672580719,
-0.27532804012298584,
-0.480541855096817,
-0.28124818205833435,
-0.1064157709479332,
-0.42874181270599365,
0.2012866735458374,
-0.33631590008735657,
-0.5909266471862793,
0.054569538682699203,
0.17103129625320435,
0.16833017766475677,
0.14773425459861755,
0.9041210412979126,
-0.21391062438488007,
0.782166600227356,
0.7042378187179565,
-0.14326153695583344,
0.14230279624462128,
-0.3826686441898346,
0.38149818778038025,
-0.8682841658592224,
-0.07235501706600189,
-0.09305670112371445,
-0.23824593424797058,
-0.22982867062091827,
-0.8977777361869812,
0.22826406359672546,
0.03401041030883789,
-0.5435844659805298,
0.4489116668701172,
-0.5926134586334229,
0.7644583582878113,
0.6797520518302917,
0.2573326528072357,
0.43598276376724243,
-0.10236633569002151,
-0.3688735067844391,
0.1483299881219864,
-0.7539248466491699,
-0.5045856237411499,
1.3319668769836426,
0.2357976883649826,
0.9959161877632141,
0.1460765302181244,
0.6990222334861755,
0.42094671726226807,
0.7993413209915161,
-0.6792566180229187,
0.43918246030807495,
0.29201188683509827,
-0.5298664569854736,
-0.44127148389816284,
-0.5354697108268738,
-0.8204774260520935,
0.1603829264640808,
0.07380245625972748,
-0.6048985123634338,
-0.20275481045246124,
0.32390621304512024,
-0.5042924284934998,
0.4858725070953369,
-0.9021692872047424,
0.6721465587615967,
-0.48353683948516846,
-0.5355080962181091,
-0.32065650820732117,
-0.4826604723930359,
0.47038814425468445,
-0.08466144651174545,
0.24513500928878784,
0.19864721596240997,
0.18939010798931122,
0.3455686569213867,
-0.4341250956058502,
0.9142563939094543,
0.10451637208461761,
-0.4151037633419037,
0.8357890248298645,
0.23902541399002075,
0.5993872284889221,
-0.06480441242456436,
0.1947406381368637,
-0.14321447908878326,
-0.33342304825782776,
-0.47251302003860474,
-0.6794468760490417,
0.41648104786872864,
-0.7896294593811035,
-0.5039223432540894,
-0.37803250551223755,
-0.7505134344100952,
-0.33208122849464417,
-0.05090901255607605,
0.1663403958082199,
0.39190536737442017,
0.05243280902504921,
-0.09997114539146423,
0.6103881001472473,
-0.3439911901950836,
0.3297273814678192,
0.09073232114315033,
-0.4358553886413574,
-0.2852916121482849,
0.9515076875686646,
-0.34091728925704956,
0.4657668173313141,
0.4737427532672882,
0.2820570766925812,
-0.1978197693824768,
0.0876685157418251,
-0.5352718234062195,
0.3286360800266266,
-0.6709630489349365,
-0.22639702260494232,
-0.6604844331741333,
-0.17366255819797516,
-0.25973695516586304,
-0.3761363923549652,
-0.1030796468257904,
-0.07303536683320999,
0.1807154417037964,
-0.12885689735412598,
0.32044005393981934,
0.7275196313858032,
0.3395146131515503,
0.17044508457183838,
-0.49623697996139526,
0.4872093200683594,
0.4363101124763489,
0.3910568356513977,
0.22778309881687164,
-0.11479022353887558,
-0.04993775859475136,
0.13204233348369598,
-0.6113511323928833,
-0.6704351305961609,
0.441253662109375,
-0.1460144817829132,
0.18645131587982178,
-0.012049838900566101,
0.07931564748287201,
0.5607860088348389,
-0.4841392934322357,
0.3532601296901703,
0.4025265872478485,
-1.1133683919906616,
0.4152384102344513,
-0.3397972285747528,
0.5047121644020081,
0.2888818085193634,
-0.12923283874988556,
-0.5202555656433105,
-0.4204489290714264,
-0.5215018391609192,
-0.320403128862381,
0.5279955863952637,
0.3729696273803711,
-0.09600886702537537,
-0.23576340079307556,
0.06988874822854996,
-0.07172560691833496,
0.2416665405035019,
-0.7937553524971008,
0.2784283757209778,
-0.07764597982168198,
-0.2947261333465576,
0.1244896650314331,
0.10395582765340805,
-0.12053309381008148,
-0.3819509744644165,
0.4008428454399109,
-0.34529247879981995,
0.4724060595035553,
0.16112038493156433,
-0.27392569184303284,
-0.505370557308197,
0.536291241645813,
0.7175488471984863,
1.0143694877624512,
0.04076016694307327,
0.20498132705688477,
0.08507093042135239,
-0.45442092418670654,
0.1960756480693817,
-0.5039196014404297,
-0.08988308906555176,
-0.41721609234809875,
0.369184672832489,
0.7586765289306641,
0.27592965960502625,
-1.1068185567855835,
0.4926530122756958,
-0.001677076448686421,
-0.34832215309143066,
-0.4533868134021759,
0.2596599757671356,
0.4177838861942291,
-0.053486958146095276,
0.1275494247674942,
0.31518128514289856,
-0.13664111495018005,
-0.7636919021606445,
0.1776120513677597,
0.13284562528133392,
-0.14676602184772491,
-0.23336724936962128,
0.5897981524467468,
0.33602461218833923,
-0.2950762212276459,
0.6963645219802856,
-0.3972969949245453,
-0.8925246000289917,
0.8683812618255615,
0.7541605830192566,
0.786309003829956,
0.1893618106842041,
0.38870805501937866,
0.15541990101337433,
0.32287025451660156,
-0.1063326820731163,
0.6236250400543213,
-0.16898824274539948,
-0.7300304174423218,
-1.0023695230484009,
-0.40174317359924316,
-0.4722434878349304,
-0.16133540868759155,
-0.41334226727485657,
0.31320756673812866,
-0.7091382145881653,
-0.1189865693449974,
-0.1283664107322693,
-0.018216319382190704,
-0.7556177377700806,
0.14104795455932617,
0.40713727474212646,
0.6494554877281189,
-0.5369386672973633,
0.9637495279312134,
0.4655144214630127,
-0.4733957052230835,
-1.1605497598648071,
0.02081969566643238,
-0.06446035951375961,
-0.7454847097396851,
0.9060391783714294,
0.12631914019584656,
-0.4165768623352051,
-0.015201803296804428,
-0.8194282054901123,
-0.793417751789093,
0.9300781488418579,
0.18810927867889404,
-0.626988410949707,
-0.21206630766391754,
0.06593134254217148,
0.589351236820221,
-0.4584975838661194,
-0.008285129442811012,
0.687957227230072,
0.40443548560142517,
0.15560674667358398,
-1.0111654996871948,
-0.002589145442470908,
-0.2658853530883789,
-0.16126321256160736,
0.625499963760376,
-0.5922574996948242,
0.9030535817146301,
-0.9345660209655762,
-0.13505913317203522,
-0.2156675159931183,
0.4362214505672455,
0.5095045566558838,
0.27087530493736267,
0.3715124726295471,
0.6742067933082581,
0.9690881371498108,
-0.01347901951521635,
1.3267848491668701,
-0.014829892665147781,
0.2172326296567917,
1.289974331855774,
-0.5659564733505249,
0.8423039317131042,
0.3710058331489563,
-0.4631323516368866,
0.7301351428031921,
0.18074333667755127,
-0.03022930584847927,
0.3064572513103485,
0.740569531917572,
-0.068708136677742,
-0.3134118914604187,
0.32861852645874023,
-0.16084112226963043,
0.42359766364097595,
0.3747733533382416,
-0.15200795233249664,
0.06438841670751572,
-0.009759673848748207,
0.23822733759880066,
0.28050869703292847,
-0.1486566662788391,
0.7322843670845032,
0.19741412997245789,
-0.9509665966033936,
0.7279799580574036,
-0.04635123535990715,
0.6145848631858826,
-0.3067527115345001,
-0.21198830008506775,
-0.05382392928004265,
0.3915642499923706,
-0.1202116310596466,
-0.6348109245300293,
0.19567357003688812,
0.31965792179107666,
-0.16690802574157715,
-0.05704236403107643,
0.3462057113647461,
-0.36617520451545715,
-0.6650744676589966,
-0.01840600185096264,
0.4685661792755127,
-0.006969509646296501,
-0.08509086072444916,
-0.568050742149353,
-0.06814014911651611,
0.06757944077253342,
0.03722478449344635,
0.18024344742298126,
0.5332114696502686,
-0.46109873056411743,
0.9855784177780151,
0.8848986625671387,
0.2391618937253952,
0.13055191934108734,
0.3386099934577942,
0.9441666007041931,
-0.962486982345581,
-0.6234545111656189,
-0.862083375453949,
0.22195401787757874,
-0.20122280716896057,
-0.4557596743106842,
0.3959813117980957,
0.314179003238678,
0.7910057902336121,
-0.0700928345322609,
1.068726897239685,
0.044046368449926376,
0.34793680906295776,
-0.42391130328178406,
0.500906765460968,
-0.02507968060672283,
0.43207353353500366,
-0.5163145065307617,
-0.9446282982826233,
-0.28706851601600647,
0.6805962324142456,
-0.6538991928100586,
-0.02127917855978012,
1.0658059120178223,
0.48364874720573425,
0.23156408965587616,
0.05513947084546089,
0.27007752656936646,
-0.028781674802303314,
0.6781898140907288,
1.0645188093185425,
0.9300718903541565,
-0.1803605705499649,
0.5705759525299072,
-0.22120893001556396,
-0.30918991565704346,
-0.053228408098220825,
-0.7014774084091187,
-0.9629116654396057,
-0.1821363866329193,
-0.2231147587299347,
-0.2669945955276489,
-0.1363576501607895,
1.3001651763916016,
0.519294798374176,
-0.6914592981338501,
-0.3745499551296234,
-0.5791106820106506,
-0.0008356723701581359,
-0.30000248551368713,
-0.2381596863269806,
0.4147622585296631,
-0.6284566521644592,
-0.41997766494750977,
0.04060179367661476,
0.4624073803424835,
-0.21973693370819092,
-0.4062615931034088,
-0.3440556526184082,
0.006263932213187218,
0.351156085729599,
0.7463735938072205,
0.23933786153793335,
-0.8689291477203369,
-0.05612650886178017,
0.3560594618320465,
-0.4795639216899872,
0.11035075038671494,
1.204535961151123,
-0.8225101828575134,
0.4639745056629181,
0.21273887157440186,
0.806887686252594,
0.309065580368042,
0.0475311279296875,
0.8738449811935425,
-0.24598917365074158,
0.0686553493142128,
0.442084938287735,
0.314286470413208,
0.4032701253890991,
-0.44398918747901917,
0.5602856278419495,
0.14648598432540894,
-0.6153078675270081,
-0.6375523209571838,
0.39865466952323914,
-0.7799947261810303,
-0.44800761342048645,
1.174367070198059,
-0.02443929761648178,
-0.522737443447113,
-0.15456749498844147,
-0.61076420545578,
0.026109013706445694,
-0.3402644991874695,
1.1151995658874512,
0.7398725152015686,
-0.2561408281326294,
-0.15086637437343597,
-0.36196601390838623,
0.4970417618751526,
0.4401223063468933,
-1.2016949653625488,
0.22803345322608948,
0.4338415861129761,
0.15484605729579926,
0.05276823043823242,
0.7166163325309753,
-0.2439984381198883,
0.5769744515419006,
0.08016830682754517,
0.32613614201545715,
-0.06483527272939682,
-0.4862990975379944,
0.25856730341911316,
-0.11670070886611938,
0.14272235333919525,
0.14381687343120575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15721v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15721v1
|
Hal-Eval: A Universal and Fine-grained Hallucination Evaluation Framework for Large Vision Language Models
| 2024-02-24T05:14:52 | 2024-02-24T05:14:52 |
Chaoya Jiang, Wei Ye, Mengfan Dong, Hongrui Jia, Haiyang Xu, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Shikun Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Vision Language Models exhibit remarkable capabilities but struggle
with hallucinations inconsistencies between images and their descriptions.
Previous hallucination evaluation studies on LVLMs have identified
hallucinations in terms of objects, attributes, and relations but overlooked
complex hallucinations that create an entire narrative around a fictional
entity. In this paper, we introduce a refined taxonomy of hallucinations,
featuring a new category: Event Hallucination. We then utilize advanced LLMs to
generate and filter fine grained hallucinatory data consisting of various types
of hallucinations, with a particular focus on event hallucinations, laying the
groundwork for integrating discriminative and generative evaluation methods
within our universal evaluation framework. The proposed benchmark distinctively
assesses LVLMs ability to tackle a broad spectrum of hallucinations, making it
a reliable and comprehensive tool for gauging LVLMs efficacy in handling
hallucinations. We will release our code and data.
|
[
-0.39692530035972595,
-0.8156971335411072,
0.6575835347175598,
0.1673382669687271,
-0.3294968605041504,
-0.05408821627497673,
-0.3071165978908539,
-0.7048613429069519,
0.27474674582481384,
0.6710897088050842,
-0.3004022538661957,
-0.8103442788124084,
-0.27647778391838074,
0.08042807132005692,
-0.693601667881012,
0.7706876397132874,
-0.03560832142829895,
0.17503102123737335,
-0.12528666853904724,
-0.22241827845573425,
-0.25191304087638855,
-0.8054707050323486,
-0.4210287630558014,
-0.2555049955844879,
0.4853246808052063,
-0.21838930249214172,
0.7254656553268433,
0.2977884113788605,
0.6833284497261047,
0.1419893354177475,
0.026358013972640038,
0.49897435307502747,
-0.505509614944458,
0.17447926104068756,
-0.1465373933315277,
-0.13363362848758698,
-0.48707836866378784,
-0.3854110538959503,
0.4806407392024994,
0.7136720418930054,
-0.5218490362167358,
0.18126355111598969,
0.0871751457452774,
0.6297692656517029,
-0.8675228953361511,
-0.02369108237326145,
-0.7623564004898071,
0.5380258560180664,
-0.1789962649345398,
-0.37153762578964233,
-0.5355842709541321,
-0.311468243598938,
-0.07923826575279236,
-0.4466845691204071,
0.18861478567123413,
0.2554442286491394,
0.515505850315094,
0.23460327088832855,
-0.04762044921517372,
-0.5754455327987671,
-0.8022853136062622,
0.606063187122345,
-0.2719513773918152,
0.6956102252006531,
0.2677161991596222,
0.3959347903728485,
0.05358869209885597,
-0.797516942024231,
-0.32445457577705383,
-0.6442225575447083,
0.15739445388317108,
-0.2045728862285614,
-0.24204355478286743,
0.2497623711824417,
0.13677027821540833,
0.3368856608867645,
-0.6304555535316467,
0.13762909173965454,
-0.41165632009506226,
-0.3044893443584442,
0.6049755811691284,
0.7215576171875,
0.1255742758512497,
-0.11878938227891922,
-0.36436131596565247,
0.1591133028268814,
-0.49126020073890686,
-0.3223342299461365,
0.02947712130844593,
0.2049308568239212,
0.1795763075351715,
0.6403193473815918,
-0.16142135858535767,
0.5512993335723877,
-0.1953599750995636,
-0.05078617483377457,
0.2135879546403885,
-0.10405194759368896,
-0.47641000151634216,
0.23617199063301086,
0.48936593532562256,
0.6081095337867737,
0.2338985800743103,
-0.43132996559143066,
-0.3689020872116089,
0.26429763436317444,
0.5366987586021423,
-0.7216202020645142,
-0.19098231196403503,
0.19683928787708282,
-0.7237774729728699,
-0.2576702833175659,
0.040471840649843216,
-1.0602015256881714,
-0.950545608997345,
-0.3963932991027832,
0.599625289440155,
-0.41667723655700684,
0.06620562076568604,
0.36111682653427124,
0.1372414231300354,
0.34149742126464844,
0.32072365283966064,
-0.6728091835975647,
0.3420998156070709,
0.6523445844650269,
0.613510012626648,
-0.6702111959457397,
-0.3704398572444916,
-0.6555005311965942,
-0.004911889787763357,
-0.5491361618041992,
0.6656900644302368,
-0.6823633909225464,
-0.34539756178855896,
0.34977564215660095,
-0.013272385112941265,
0.2267865538597107,
-0.8125125765800476,
0.582190752029419,
-0.39429914951324463,
-0.32446569204330444,
-0.06731773912906647,
-0.4739225506782532,
-0.20624558627605438,
0.05572059750556946,
-0.45719489455223083,
0.6970030665397644,
0.0438179150223732,
-0.2009163796901703,
0.4724365174770355,
-0.35653185844421387,
-0.14904341101646423,
0.4840860962867737,
-0.3646745979785919,
-0.20662494003772736,
0.43367090821266174,
0.061171066015958786,
0.5270355343818665,
-0.12357546389102936,
0.5502227544784546,
-0.2891974449157715,
-0.6012402772903442,
0.2523324489593506,
-0.6716673970222473,
0.2767673134803772,
0.16663849353790283,
-0.2919866740703583,
0.48516473174095154,
-1.0650073289871216,
-0.13269615173339844,
-0.0008539340924471617,
-0.19106577336788177,
-0.3401350975036621,
0.23667220771312714,
0.24506613612174988,
-0.33349984884262085,
0.29758429527282715,
-0.17819459736347198,
0.19727741181850433,
-0.2910495400428772,
-0.20183631777763367,
0.7185325026512146,
0.11119900643825531,
0.27105969190597534,
-0.119722381234169,
0.47095468640327454,
-0.20979313552379608,
0.5025492310523987,
-0.015927139669656754,
-0.1369481384754181,
-1.0138965845108032,
-0.04074136167764664,
-0.2743266224861145,
0.22843286395072937,
-0.6518294811248779,
0.5030955672264099,
-0.015479059889912605,
-0.36742913722991943,
-0.2933458387851715,
-0.052508726716041565,
0.5325804352760315,
0.13759806752204895,
0.38630402088165283,
-0.22820770740509033,
-0.8279697895050049,
-0.9864152073860168,
0.0881756842136383,
-0.13301852345466614,
0.00332189560867846,
0.167793869972229,
0.4594435691833496,
-0.5529614090919495,
0.44961151480674744,
-0.22796261310577393,
-0.6179113984107971,
-0.1370178759098053,
-0.017504191026091576,
-0.272516131401062,
0.08779953420162201,
0.3491479754447937,
-0.5278317928314209,
-0.06082497537136078,
0.284830242395401,
-0.9697343111038208,
-0.14523765444755554,
-0.3587183952331543,
0.004261017311364412,
0.6773433685302734,
0.37265217304229736,
-0.19545409083366394,
0.709535539150238,
0.3317968547344208,
-0.6609336137771606,
0.8784051537513733,
-0.09959273040294647,
0.33030155301094055,
-0.2913684844970703,
-0.09828308969736099,
-0.3645752966403961,
-0.05256892740726471,
-0.5724005103111267,
0.4265776574611664,
-0.08933702856302261,
0.22300000488758087,
-0.6673611402511597,
0.5698143243789673,
-0.3365514874458313,
-0.3486582040786743,
0.02314264327287674,
0.24679267406463623,
-0.0411856435239315,
0.4138528108596802,
0.05272272601723671,
0.3803618848323822,
0.7004548907279968,
-0.5748691558837891,
0.5972629189491272,
0.1744745373725891,
-0.7029175758361816,
0.42643675208091736,
-0.06403271853923798,
0.05204227194190025,
-0.03169349953532219,
-0.007873846217989922,
-0.5429619550704956,
-0.3416355848312378,
0.30130550265312195,
-0.028309578076004982,
0.05720239505171776,
0.3452695608139038,
-0.4995143413543701,
-0.19634026288986206,
-0.37272581458091736,
0.3707086741924286,
0.5347563624382019,
-0.7217342853546143,
0.7955148220062256,
0.09928429871797562,
0.3683149814605713,
-0.330251544713974,
-0.5312784910202026,
0.33838963508605957,
-0.2794809937477112,
-0.26229411363601685,
0.10958521068096161,
-0.27738651633262634,
-0.5843976140022278,
-0.12253569066524506,
-0.12852360308170319,
0.042029719799757004,
-0.07963354885578156,
0.3342655897140503,
0.25494641065597534,
-0.3126320540904999,
0.013918818905949593,
-0.3301005959510803,
0.15703418850898743,
0.1119866818189621,
0.11517863720655441,
0.9935575127601624,
-0.2873351573944092,
-0.7496592998504639,
-0.42759379744529724,
0.20849524438381195,
0.49841198325157166,
0.18700651824474335,
0.4083347022533417,
0.6412660479545593,
-0.5625574588775635,
-0.32857784628868103,
-0.7598322629928589,
0.015341803431510925,
-0.4047262370586395,
0.6803427338600159,
-0.5444070100784302,
-0.6445872783660889,
0.7275851964950562,
0.3694876730442047,
-0.19192321598529816,
0.42656204104423523,
0.7208967804908752,
0.20271655917167664,
1.013115644454956,
0.24344566464424133,
0.2917366325855255,
-0.03460283949971199,
-0.05786547809839249,
0.0472596250474453,
-0.9760740399360657,
-0.654208242893219,
-0.11966395378112793,
-0.10193608701229095,
-0.01403945591300726,
-0.5999053120613098,
0.13009332120418549,
0.3112384080886841,
-0.16930173337459564,
-0.21788819134235382,
-0.7386772036552429,
0.6326912641525269,
0.17186541855335236,
-0.05260951817035675,
0.4469974935054779,
0.13348086178302765,
0.14714737236499786,
-0.22140154242515564,
-0.1918601095676422,
-0.7242836952209473,
0.9848018288612366,
0.28968319296836853,
0.7789454460144043,
-0.18684883415699005,
0.6610261797904968,
0.6809388399124146,
0.3888591229915619,
-0.6774910092353821,
0.7417469620704651,
-0.24991273880004883,
-0.4068779945373535,
-0.3039659559726715,
-0.08264585584402084,
-0.7614753842353821,
0.4536491632461548,
-0.09311191737651825,
-1.2591699361801147,
0.33499786257743835,
-0.15495021641254425,
-0.391433984041214,
0.4856776297092438,
-0.11348560452461243,
0.6173742413520813,
-0.4187048077583313,
-0.13006943464279175,
-0.34953638911247253,
-0.1510731279850006,
0.6744391322135925,
-0.35777801275253296,
0.26312556862831116,
-0.18048276007175446,
-0.03551705926656723,
0.7947089076042175,
-0.016529077664017677,
0.8357821106910706,
0.000782096351031214,
-0.24900877475738525,
0.36886247992515564,
0.5877302289009094,
0.19227805733680725,
-0.034202028065919876,
-0.036864522844552994,
0.5086751580238342,
0.14543583989143372,
0.22764888405799866,
-0.5171331763267517,
0.6282838582992554,
-0.4538000226020813,
-0.3369910717010498,
-0.20535513758659363,
-0.3896845281124115,
-0.17487142980098724,
-0.34739378094673157,
0.23976433277130127,
0.6011505722999573,
-0.5699283480644226,
0.22788360714912415,
0.4551340639591217,
-0.3886851370334625,
0.36300361156463623,
0.4391583204269409,
-1.156747579574585,
-0.42710134387016296,
1.0555377006530762,
-0.12915848195552826,
0.08137794584035873,
0.14108023047447205,
-0.04011612758040428,
-0.18811799585819244,
-0.7957980036735535,
-0.27282360196113586,
-0.037212591618299484,
-1.0113533735275269,
-0.26021209359169006,
-0.6311774849891663,
-0.5255464315414429,
-0.15774205327033997,
-0.5240476727485657,
-0.34496626257896423,
-0.030191881582140923,
-0.4160798490047455,
0.021664714440703392,
-0.015416258946061134,
0.8038129806518555,
-0.07873541861772537,
-0.00306029268540442,
-0.6763690114021301,
0.6664992570877075,
0.07360250502824783,
0.37002676725387573,
0.29282164573669434,
-0.47708794474601746,
-0.12205871939659119,
-0.2502872347831726,
-0.23562173545360565,
-0.5883251428604126,
0.5844073295593262,
0.23520638048648834,
0.6457644104957581,
0.762678861618042,
0.05209873989224434,
0.8737196326255798,
-0.5806530117988586,
1.0753753185272217,
0.51689213514328,
-0.9913527965545654,
0.648609459400177,
0.07550408691167831,
-0.18168897926807404,
0.4959304928779602,
-0.01636718399822712,
-0.516362726688385,
-0.5475435256958008,
-0.4236581325531006,
-0.8295801877975464,
0.4209364950656891,
0.1515517234802246,
0.06947343051433563,
-0.18685367703437805,
0.24860498309135437,
0.5989920496940613,
0.06533709913492203,
-0.8750162124633789,
-0.18500907719135284,
0.2276754379272461,
-0.0591425858438015,
-0.006984245497733355,
-0.636502206325531,
-0.21464356780052185,
-0.4749208092689514,
0.2322954386472702,
0.0914173498749733,
0.008107236586511135,
0.2042739987373352,
-0.2230464667081833,
-0.2831316292285919,
0.09314480423927307,
0.648130476474762,
0.9405447244644165,
-0.43024107813835144,
0.25543898344039917,
0.3683873414993286,
-0.46069201827049255,
-0.03846513479948044,
-0.2633865773677826,
0.056251246482133865,
0.0514635294675827,
0.7100836634635925,
1.069171667098999,
0.22463002800941467,
-1.110571026802063,
0.42735379934310913,
-0.06849981844425201,
-0.35330843925476074,
-0.42437833547592163,
0.3659515678882599,
-0.45728230476379395,
0.5106850862503052,
0.5621882081031799,
-0.10988292843103409,
0.4614437222480774,
-0.6156737804412842,
0.42602357268333435,
0.398016095161438,
-0.48885825276374817,
-0.3339623510837555,
0.6977423429489136,
-0.028186745941638947,
-0.7116714715957642,
0.41040414571762085,
-0.37717097997665405,
-0.5094572305679321,
0.6463586091995239,
0.4934612810611725,
1.066490888595581,
-0.1936996728181839,
0.17374974489212036,
0.2281825989484787,
0.36140885949134827,
0.11200696974992752,
0.2246372252702713,
0.018502455204725266,
-0.5744901299476624,
-0.12844933569431305,
-1.3829352855682373,
-0.23660674691200256,
0.4175140857696533,
-0.6607586145401001,
0.2617432177066803,
-0.1796720027923584,
0.1901019960641861,
-0.11076521128416061,
-0.2688853144645691,
-0.6501097679138184,
0.03262415900826454,
0.7110642790794373,
0.6325042843818665,
-0.5817541480064392,
0.5982362031936646,
0.257463276386261,
-0.23002201318740845,
-0.1815461814403534,
0.11065775901079178,
-0.20306427776813507,
-0.8905171155929565,
0.7701770067214966,
0.24258291721343994,
-0.039266813546419144,
-0.2364068329334259,
-0.4888034164905548,
-0.680479884147644,
0.8398531675338745,
-0.07736717164516449,
-0.8469687104225159,
-0.043073512613773346,
0.2631611227989197,
0.7035452723503113,
-0.7237476110458374,
-0.18227675557136536,
0.9433995485305786,
0.5915064811706543,
0.17427203059196472,
-0.7384938597679138,
-0.007478413637727499,
0.21041515469551086,
0.07944361120462418,
0.03486589714884758,
-0.20746193826198578,
0.36665382981300354,
-0.2572315037250519,
-0.30155545473098755,
0.33818310499191284,
0.5091989040374756,
0.428169310092926,
0.7389413714408875,
0.37568017840385437,
0.43529778718948364,
0.7175348997116089,
-0.04269015043973923,
1.0472530126571655,
-0.1738666594028473,
0.29658815264701843,
1.1170597076416016,
-0.484468549489975,
0.8495113253593445,
0.3793190121650696,
-0.293709397315979,
0.13152693212032318,
0.48683005571365356,
-0.30451062321662903,
0.5934638381004333,
0.4246547818183899,
-0.22478458285331726,
-0.3664413392543793,
-0.15500220656394958,
-0.3939569890499115,
0.4814395308494568,
0.5380145907402039,
-0.22400464117527008,
-0.23706559836864471,
0.7114150524139404,
-0.5838456153869629,
-0.13773714005947113,
-0.5443658232688904,
0.6974939107894897,
0.060334496200084686,
-0.34139323234558105,
0.7983713746070862,
-0.3236578404903412,
0.6504674553871155,
-0.3705597519874573,
-0.1481904536485672,
-0.2019885629415512,
0.16860508918762207,
-0.1765320897102356,
-0.758244514465332,
0.5573034882545471,
-0.020823290571570396,
0.059897564351558685,
0.21762315928936005,
0.6190782189369202,
-0.2519490420818329,
-0.5475047826766968,
0.6791408061981201,
0.18297423422336578,
0.6861870884895325,
-0.14171276986598969,
-0.31630250811576843,
0.8162901401519775,
0.1845138818025589,
-0.21209797263145447,
0.16365213692188263,
0.35619598627090454,
-0.09318716078996658,
0.5913053154945374,
0.36237090826034546,
0.20362162590026855,
0.1375357061624527,
0.6517212986946106,
0.43242961168289185,
-0.6620800495147705,
-0.0038480116054415703,
-1.1095890998840332,
0.46982118487358093,
0.08934987336397171,
-0.4281158447265625,
0.4247654676437378,
0.7664220929145813,
0.5106111764907837,
-0.13801665604114532,
0.3849625885486603,
0.09023192524909973,
-0.03578916937112808,
-0.5846292972564697,
0.7055502533912659,
-0.8614145517349243,
0.2524920105934143,
-0.04323326423764229,
-1.2828720808029175,
-0.4455762207508087,
0.5857067108154297,
0.1428195834159851,
-0.3156628906726837,
0.7439692616462708,
0.595224142074585,
0.05329599231481552,
-0.036175765097141266,
0.9804672002792358,
0.4064883589744568,
0.1440429389476776,
0.5516082644462585,
1.3258624076843262,
-0.14408303797245026,
0.38766857981681824,
-0.11524103581905365,
-0.09871824830770493,
-0.6049661636352539,
-0.6054518222808838,
-0.9062814712524414,
-0.8690589070320129,
-0.405746728181839,
-0.3048848807811737,
0.2516465187072754,
0.8125689625740051,
0.39139559864997864,
-0.8182708621025085,
-0.13454677164554596,
0.03969210386276245,
-0.14634454250335693,
0.15146882832050323,
-0.3172494173049927,
0.577231228351593,
-0.5016235709190369,
-0.5732330083847046,
0.3068387508392334,
0.6605479121208191,
0.016437038779258728,
-0.8120787143707275,
-0.21221613883972168,
0.4702930748462677,
0.22267216444015503,
0.9082297682762146,
-0.20809203386306763,
-1.4025709629058838,
-0.401662141084671,
-0.2840802073478699,
-0.16521994769573212,
0.006493362598121166,
0.5414591431617737,
-0.6940339207649231,
0.4603070318698883,
0.0029609331395477057,
0.38381004333496094,
0.27267324924468994,
-0.3324856460094452,
0.06008956581354141,
-0.40777745842933655,
0.104698047041893,
0.3937999904155731,
0.42549440264701843,
0.06358855962753296,
-0.4485517144203186,
0.6780803799629211,
-0.031148768961429596,
-0.5013946890830994,
-1.243070363998413,
0.0548054501414299,
-1.3457789421081543,
-0.4709119498729706,
1.4293650388717651,
0.39531663060188293,
-0.14844153821468353,
-0.024990830570459366,
-0.44656071066856384,
-0.08889190107584,
0.012244055978953838,
1.036063313484192,
0.7302245497703552,
-0.3519437313079834,
0.015629062429070473,
-0.6311090588569641,
0.6059660911560059,
-0.05013873428106308,
-0.7503961324691772,
0.41305336356163025,
0.8091968894004822,
-0.22309307754039764,
0.2865758538246155,
0.533349871635437,
-0.021992851048707962,
0.23052851855754852,
0.04048696532845497,
0.49822112917900085,
0.10045810788869858,
-0.6637001037597656,
-0.46737679839134216,
0.5281761884689331,
-0.2122238278388977,
0.02738902159035206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15713v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15713v1
|
Making Pre-trained Language Models Better Continual Few-Shot Relation Extractors
| 2024-02-24T04:32:44 | 2024-02-24T04:32:44 |
Shengkun Ma, Jiale Han, Yi Liang, Bo Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Continual Few-shot Relation Extraction (CFRE) is a practical problem that
requires the model to continuously learn novel relations while avoiding
forgetting old ones with few labeled training data. The primary challenges are
catastrophic forgetting and overfitting. This paper harnesses prompt learning
to explore the implicit capabilities of pre-trained language models to address
the above two challenges, thereby making language models better continual
few-shot relation extractors. Specifically, we propose a Contrastive Prompt
Learning framework, which designs prompt representation to acquire more
generalized knowledge that can be easily adapted to old and new categories, and
margin-based contrastive learning to focus more on hard samples, therefore
alleviating catastrophic forgetting and overfitting issues. To further remedy
overfitting in low-resource scenarios, we introduce an effective memory
augmentation strategy that employs well-crafted prompts to guide ChatGPT in
generating diverse samples. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our method
outperforms state-of-the-art methods by a large margin and significantly
mitigates catastrophic forgetting and overfitting in low-resource scenarios.
|
[
-0.34622490406036377,
-0.6524956822395325,
0.6264944672584534,
0.09020084887742996,
-0.23691999912261963,
-0.007997063919901848,
-0.23459158837795258,
-0.2308463603258133,
-0.3991638123989105,
0.3126051723957062,
-0.7636579871177673,
-0.19755145907402039,
-0.5024291276931763,
0.10745049268007278,
-0.009339145384728909,
1.0671058893203735,
0.15444481372833252,
-0.013044256716966629,
-0.15709474682807922,
-0.2051846832036972,
-0.6619064211845398,
-0.5450448393821716,
-1.0929787158966064,
-0.22013647854328156,
0.6505382657051086,
0.5885260105133057,
0.42479896545410156,
0.22612662613391876,
0.2932751178741455,
0.34902098774909973,
0.03989570215344429,
0.07883966714143753,
-0.8309272527694702,
0.20018620789051056,
-0.21261681616306305,
-0.39759543538093567,
0.0633571594953537,
0.039651088416576385,
0.5743709206581116,
0.702834963798523,
-0.06857845932245255,
-0.234866201877594,
0.2889111042022705,
0.5849822759628296,
-0.8577414751052856,
0.2610715627670288,
-0.691499650478363,
-0.19255930185317993,
-0.09369371831417084,
-0.2367454618215561,
-0.3637702763080597,
-0.3741024136543274,
0.3146163821220398,
-0.640932559967041,
0.16766434907913208,
0.05179626867175102,
0.9007083773612976,
0.3250214159488678,
-0.24453169107437134,
-0.15535792708396912,
-0.6384361982345581,
0.8347986340522766,
-0.49508002400398254,
0.4796839952468872,
0.5236625671386719,
0.5629276633262634,
-0.1891617327928543,
-0.7688694596290588,
-0.4469608962535858,
-0.45362427830696106,
-0.3067047595977783,
0.14680470526218414,
-0.2665409445762634,
0.047392819076776505,
0.4064217507839203,
0.1884412318468094,
-0.4309730529785156,
0.0008994299569167197,
-0.3116087317466736,
-0.10825691372156143,
0.12010494619607925,
0.15363602340221405,
0.24860428273677826,
-0.09076526015996933,
-0.19207122921943665,
-0.025064216926693916,
-0.7568011283874512,
0.08711473643779755,
0.04594945162534714,
0.5193265676498413,
-0.014570992439985275,
0.04214424639940262,
-0.0007746818009763956,
0.6431265473365784,
0.21016854047775269,
-0.099239781498909,
0.1253555864095688,
-0.31850653886795044,
-0.1512061059474945,
-0.16069893538951874,
0.6990960240364075,
-0.11987133324146271,
0.3685617744922638,
-0.039377905428409576,
-0.16543301939964294,
-0.13360850512981415,
-0.06223893165588379,
-0.835124135017395,
-0.3384338915348053,
0.0022416659630835056,
-0.27826249599456787,
0.04805399104952812,
-0.17235435545444489,
-0.7172408103942871,
-0.2107950896024704,
-0.2610551714897156,
0.29359692335128784,
-0.8356589078903198,
-0.23046205937862396,
-0.06998559832572937,
-0.11321555823087692,
0.21737822890281677,
0.408698707818985,
-0.9726576805114746,
0.48106756806373596,
0.48266059160232544,
0.7821681499481201,
-0.0575394406914711,
-0.21294286847114563,
-1.068796992301941,
-0.13402718305587769,
-0.2299450933933258,
0.9373697638511658,
-0.6722670793533325,
-0.5022552609443665,
0.008898689411580563,
-0.09835772961378098,
-0.18493402004241943,
-0.5252717733383179,
0.37574857473373413,
-0.4166991710662842,
0.5602068901062012,
-0.48507049679756165,
-0.45961251854896545,
0.09804383665323257,
0.39252886176109314,
-0.6166034936904907,
0.967727541923523,
0.4584759473800659,
-0.6891068816184998,
0.27638742327690125,
-0.2860092222690582,
-0.1587194800376892,
0.11773397028446198,
-0.40099483728408813,
-0.20012272894382477,
0.03477565571665764,
0.4078880846500397,
0.42761293053627014,
-0.3775756061077118,
0.23464873433113098,
-0.16274043917655945,
-0.28681451082229614,
0.08892469108104706,
-0.3879355788230896,
0.6395266056060791,
0.2637988030910492,
0.10424135625362396,
-0.05531947687268257,
-0.8174530267715454,
-0.27622300386428833,
0.015792248770594597,
-0.2834851145744324,
-0.3827381432056427,
-0.2792069613933563,
-0.13364197313785553,
0.562138020992279,
-0.05710878223180771,
-0.33000999689102173,
0.08672115206718445,
-0.5668228268623352,
0.18349751830101013,
0.6619278192520142,
0.2659648656845093,
0.5763608813285828,
-0.37700435519218445,
0.7140934467315674,
0.2510403096675873,
-0.04082923009991646,
-0.9285168051719666,
-0.012759982608258724,
-0.955273449420929,
-0.271602600812912,
0.12086604535579681,
0.658144474029541,
-1.0002988576889038,
0.19474676251411438,
-0.15739813446998596,
-0.25819578766822815,
-0.28032949566841125,
0.44635000824928284,
0.48509377241134644,
0.9082370400428772,
0.62223881483078,
-0.15289227664470673,
-0.5870882272720337,
-0.5581315755844116,
0.07885952293872833,
-0.28446948528289795,
-0.05566645413637161,
0.40194788575172424,
0.3049253225326538,
-0.12488352507352829,
1.1128982305526733,
-0.5410168170928955,
-0.32052454352378845,
-0.4495725929737091,
0.2917543947696686,
0.21659919619560242,
0.6844884753227234,
0.6407490968704224,
-0.5722528100013733,
-0.4416274428367615,
-0.11591922491788864,
-0.5398406982421875,
-0.06795162707567215,
-0.436036616563797,
-0.13983522355556488,
0.1951424926519394,
0.716663122177124,
-0.5748586058616638,
-0.03321317210793495,
0.04541324824094772,
0.0036613724660128355,
0.5390293002128601,
0.0021927233319729567,
-0.004080271814018488,
-0.8723650574684143,
0.1888103038072586,
0.043196871876716614,
-0.19910870492458344,
-0.5462735891342163,
-0.18020084500312805,
-0.051939956843853,
-0.21926753222942352,
-0.5935904383659363,
0.9172879457473755,
-0.582047164440155,
0.33599653840065,
-0.19629576802253723,
0.029963258653879166,
-0.016418034210801125,
0.6300451755523682,
0.2792280316352844,
0.6284865736961365,
0.6235284209251404,
-0.707038938999176,
0.08536919206380844,
0.308858186006546,
-0.06750691682100296,
0.5372636318206787,
-0.5782358646392822,
0.24038715660572052,
-0.4942222833633423,
0.3159376084804535,
-1.2262088060379028,
-0.05570169538259506,
0.4179321229457855,
-0.36378833651542664,
0.6073777675628662,
-0.260708749294281,
-0.23437239229679108,
-0.15681833028793335,
-0.18799331784248352,
0.2822115421295166,
0.7805123925209045,
-0.6692471504211426,
0.6905712485313416,
-0.12274906039237976,
-0.49535804986953735,
-0.7069516777992249,
-0.4036913216114044,
-0.32541176676750183,
-0.13242517411708832,
-0.2699793577194214,
0.22300885617733002,
0.015006604604423046,
-0.1132335439324379,
0.014549609273672104,
-0.23688136041164398,
-0.34932029247283936,
-0.019089583307504654,
0.009893943555653095,
0.2954029440879822,
-0.3914778530597687,
0.4601316452026367,
-0.1677727997303009,
-0.3410640358924866,
-0.10634900629520416,
-0.02761080488562584,
0.6325685977935791,
0.01824972778558731,
-0.07135054469108582,
-0.24443066120147705,
0.42792218923568726,
-0.029110947623848915,
-0.10947318375110626,
0.6355946660041809,
0.513961911201477,
-0.3274570405483246,
-0.030870651826262474,
-0.8100261092185974,
-0.3705265522003174,
-0.48914235830307007,
0.2516915798187256,
-0.4888218939304352,
-0.9816890358924866,
0.5102128386497498,
-0.3030243217945099,
0.05381988361477852,
0.28479549288749695,
-0.004945128690451384,
-0.13010862469673157,
0.6212048530578613,
0.9022993445396423,
-0.2631376385688782,
0.7527580261230469,
-0.12093961983919144,
-0.1546889990568161,
-0.4263027310371399,
-0.14132854342460632,
-0.7075099349021912,
0.19842396676540375,
-0.27590709924697876,
-0.19419130682945251,
0.018481172621250153,
0.4471437633037567,
-0.42886677384376526,
0.28823089599609375,
-0.01143732387572527,
0.629840612411499,
0.35567542910575867,
0.19493500888347626,
-0.03944173827767372,
-0.08645050972700119,
-0.20417359471321106,
-0.21539553999900818,
-0.8714146614074707,
-0.23864983022212982,
0.5211350917816162,
0.16238100826740265,
0.7221041917800903,
-0.11254312843084335,
0.9663608074188232,
-0.26264688372612,
0.42917802929878235,
-0.7315108776092529,
0.2909555435180664,
-0.11723233014345169,
-0.38679683208465576,
-0.14433401823043823,
-0.5068931579589844,
-0.7992321252822876,
0.0933145135641098,
-0.3139629065990448,
-0.6988524198532104,
0.44950762391090393,
0.5197501182556152,
-0.7358498573303223,
-0.15060411393642426,
-0.6120664477348328,
0.7995005249977112,
-0.13426893949508667,
-0.6302061676979065,
0.008069846779108047,
-0.8153306245803833,
0.4520546495914459,
-0.14098459482192993,
-0.02001979388296604,
0.06638429313898087,
0.038333382457494736,
0.5034908056259155,
-0.40964528918266296,
1.0607059001922607,
-0.12316521257162094,
0.1525554060935974,
0.3602716326713562,
0.026921981945633888,
0.5469887256622314,
-0.056150663644075394,
-0.09456714242696762,
-0.19022516906261444,
-0.21614590287208557,
-0.568668007850647,
-0.822020947933197,
0.46240589022636414,
-0.5238733887672424,
-0.6718904376029968,
-0.4891457259654999,
-0.05111408606171608,
-0.3951251208782196,
0.05615498125553131,
0.4226113259792328,
0.49890708923339844,
-0.5575716495513916,
-0.03537127748131752,
0.6973145008087158,
-0.4801044166088104,
0.6456533670425415,
0.45911139249801636,
0.10275083035230637,
-0.41907939314842224,
0.9259458780288696,
-0.07931898534297943,
0.279247522354126,
0.44241195917129517,
0.26527464389801025,
-0.3475840091705322,
-0.19978941977024078,
-0.06084246560931206,
0.22691123187541962,
-0.8625309467315674,
-0.3458975553512573,
-0.8602676391601562,
-0.24400708079338074,
-0.4708053767681122,
-0.3028344511985779,
-0.20281082391738892,
-0.2189313918352127,
-0.5329155325889587,
-0.0567927323281765,
0.3140193223953247,
0.18979737162590027,
-0.20148280262947083,
0.7711441516876221,
-1.1408393383026123,
0.27774977684020996,
0.5280695557594299,
-0.04768439754843712,
0.10848481953144073,
-0.5555193424224854,
0.04674224182963371,
-0.4459086060523987,
-0.3150203227996826,
-0.7492935061454773,
0.4731595516204834,
0.44715946912765503,
0.767701268196106,
0.6538925170898438,
0.021530793979763985,
0.9235291481018066,
-0.5970657467842102,
0.7348827123641968,
0.5126067996025085,
-0.830059826374054,
0.5770503878593445,
-0.1704310178756714,
0.7074359655380249,
0.9669621586799622,
0.8449974060058594,
-0.517782986164093,
-0.07877733558416367,
-0.7839812636375427,
-0.7510297298431396,
0.6463862061500549,
-0.0011486966395750642,
0.43687334656715393,
-0.3619292676448822,
0.27382412552833557,
0.3258831799030304,
0.05494867265224457,
-0.6239879131317139,
-0.057417817413806915,
-0.26364412903785706,
-0.16862277686595917,
-0.23533476889133453,
-0.5257221460342407,
0.290536493062973,
-0.13944190740585327,
0.583097517490387,
-0.13019996881484985,
0.015475872904062271,
0.0445702038705349,
-0.2850119173526764,
0.05751973018050194,
0.6007093191146851,
0.3591320812702179,
0.5742555260658264,
-0.2528544068336487,
0.16383571922779083,
0.393280953168869,
-0.2236706167459488,
0.09332459419965744,
0.34759628772735596,
0.078101746737957,
-0.011506611481308937,
0.6837039589881897,
0.8932437300682068,
0.5650742650032043,
-0.5865231156349182,
0.5757415890693665,
0.0033029622863978148,
0.19757241010665894,
-0.1761217713356018,
0.1725185066461563,
-0.010170754045248032,
0.013190477155148983,
0.5102043151855469,
0.09726956486701965,
0.004486204124987125,
-0.6136407256126404,
0.5478790402412415,
0.2436855286359787,
-0.558306097984314,
-0.21347589790821075,
0.2716677486896515,
0.37130025029182434,
-0.03342480957508087,
0.7982692718505859,
-0.21730181574821472,
-0.6103422045707703,
0.3400816023349762,
0.6693706512451172,
0.6462523937225342,
-0.49108609557151794,
0.19419190287590027,
0.8188557624816895,
0.08332834392786026,
-0.3578738272190094,
0.10749009251594543,
-0.43086349964141846,
-0.8169498443603516,
-0.5041300058364868,
-0.4028559625148773,
-0.2408454269170761,
0.273085355758667,
-0.5279276967048645,
0.4991101920604706,
-0.6150774955749512,
0.08439265936613083,
-0.20098048448562622,
0.128114715218544,
-0.8208495378494263,
0.19245019555091858,
0.02736889198422432,
0.8766354918479919,
-0.917924702167511,
0.8646097779273987,
0.31646615266799927,
-0.8010650277137756,
-0.7209716439247131,
-0.10144065320491791,
0.045541975647211075,
-0.5909028649330139,
0.9451854228973389,
0.39295580983161926,
-0.15152503550052643,
0.1280163675546646,
-0.7538889050483704,
-0.6359598636627197,
0.6422693729400635,
0.5594825744628906,
-0.8611027002334595,
-0.06227082759141922,
-0.3281145989894867,
0.350879043340683,
-0.35842248797416687,
0.5561290383338928,
0.7099605798721313,
0.24736076593399048,
0.5521909594535828,
-0.5017147660255432,
0.09981931000947952,
-0.17733824253082275,
-0.17425617575645447,
0.02693749964237213,
-0.34758269786834717,
0.7583180665969849,
-0.2862606942653656,
-0.5931545495986938,
0.04483519867062569,
0.7152824997901917,
0.4587272107601166,
0.12289581447839737,
0.5615398287773132,
0.21311771869659424,
0.7711453437805176,
0.025112438946962357,
1.0050455331802368,
0.16852684319019318,
-0.12912620604038239,
1.646228551864624,
-0.409188836812973,
0.7149379253387451,
0.509390115737915,
0.0968548133969307,
0.3909774124622345,
0.6837448477745056,
0.1899275928735733,
0.6746892333030701,
0.12476522475481033,
-0.3715517818927765,
-0.6037437319755554,
-0.21930767595767975,
-0.3154124915599823,
0.18007105588912964,
0.43204209208488464,
-0.22808010876178741,
-0.6288653612136841,
0.07509160786867142,
0.1167115867137909,
0.16322912275791168,
-0.2018900215625763,
0.9391664862632751,
0.4653371274471283,
-0.6715092062950134,
0.719453752040863,
-0.5078255534172058,
0.8042415976524353,
-0.7954477071762085,
-0.3277883529663086,
-0.4852369427680969,
-0.1069585457444191,
-0.004972545430064201,
-0.23489870131015778,
-0.006549656391143799,
-0.07849384099245071,
-0.05992678552865982,
-0.07605773210525513,
0.8623176217079163,
-0.664678692817688,
-0.3333650231361389,
0.2530951201915741,
0.7475355267524719,
0.021794522181153297,
0.0035953728947788477,
-0.7652166485786438,
-0.03223682940006256,
-0.17479288578033447,
-0.1527235358953476,
0.2640794813632965,
0.5258392691612244,
-0.022461870685219765,
0.6957199573516846,
0.5989684462547302,
0.04838908463716507,
-0.22278593480587006,
0.1541997343301773,
1.1313227415084839,
-0.7445350885391235,
-0.5696315169334412,
-1.0244289636611938,
0.527262270450592,
-0.18698617815971375,
-0.4191615879535675,
0.3456503748893738,
0.2022361308336258,
0.5654988884925842,
-0.1354038566350937,
0.7092545628547668,
0.05331477150321007,
0.3498763144016266,
-0.692823052406311,
0.33965930342674255,
-0.2607024013996124,
0.18398040533065796,
-0.3202238082885742,
-0.8080213665962219,
-0.3193129599094391,
0.6352649331092834,
-0.3025832772254944,
0.09769321233034134,
0.891777753829956,
0.7606194019317627,
-0.20960968732833862,
-0.17958731949329376,
0.47788017988204956,
-0.00899305660277605,
0.1979406625032425,
0.9038284420967102,
1.1352763175964355,
-0.2595537304878235,
0.7022442817687988,
-0.15065674483776093,
-0.20059822499752045,
0.08528519421815872,
-1.1006940603256226,
-1.1431612968444824,
-0.6960976719856262,
-0.36027050018310547,
-0.04997754842042923,
0.19213475286960602,
1.1800373792648315,
0.7899541258811951,
-0.8331065773963928,
0.1044108048081398,
-0.16131725907325745,
0.01000423077493906,
-0.030531544238328934,
-0.180132657289505,
0.331374853849411,
-0.976121723651886,
-0.6113325357437134,
0.4626184403896332,
0.026618558913469315,
0.36667773127555847,
0.04309187829494476,
-0.20372691750526428,
-0.2805262506008148,
-0.08854328840970993,
0.5510631799697876,
0.6272574663162231,
-0.3594478964805603,
-0.25676122307777405,
-0.08226282894611359,
-0.21047909557819366,
0.17216618359088898,
0.9886354804039001,
-1.2375422716140747,
0.19698640704154968,
0.522001326084137,
0.8770657777786255,
0.4068606495857239,
0.11816219985485077,
0.8179287314414978,
-1.0393956899642944,
0.46431753039360046,
0.2382073551416397,
0.3799983263015747,
0.5290064811706543,
-0.5017320513725281,
0.4564363360404968,
0.05682139843702316,
-0.2300119549036026,
-0.580790638923645,
0.3431657552719116,
-0.8156421780586243,
-0.4396992623806,
1.0060182809829712,
-0.38927778601646423,
-0.12690137326717377,
-0.23913539946079254,
-0.3501507639884949,
0.26956310868263245,
-0.5435114502906799,
0.5603702068328857,
0.7284296751022339,
-0.05965583771467209,
-0.7258791923522949,
-0.2513100504875183,
0.9318536520004272,
0.3821423351764679,
-0.8508087396621704,
-0.014044645242393017,
0.7264425158500671,
0.2784002125263214,
0.07131603360176086,
1.0600507259368896,
0.045844666659832,
0.4046591520309448,
-0.06888984143733978,
-0.31485989689826965,
-0.06875694543123245,
-0.397384911775589,
-0.6324184536933899,
0.14046737551689148,
0.08643163740634918,
-0.04025285691022873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15708v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15708v2
|
Query Augmentation by Decoding Semantics from Brain Signals
| 2024-02-24T04:08:51 | 2024-03-03T09:18:07 |
Ziyi Ye, Jingtao Zhan, Qingyao Ai, Yiqun Liu, Maarten de Rijke, Christina Lioma, Tuukka Ruotsalo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Query augmentation is a crucial technique for refining semantically imprecise
queries. Traditionally, query augmentation relies on extracting information
from initially retrieved, potentially relevant documents. If the quality of the
initially retrieved documents is low, then the effectiveness of query
augmentation would be limited as well. We propose Brain-Aug, which enhances a
query by incorporating semantic information decoded from brain signals.
BrainAug generates the continuation of the original query with a prompt
constructed with brain signal information and a ranking-oriented inference
approach. Experimental results on fMRI (functional magnetic resonance imaging)
datasets show that Brain-Aug produces semantically more accurate queries,
leading to improved document ranking performance. Such improvement brought by
brain signals is particularly notable for ambiguous queries.
|
[
-0.5171785950660706,
-0.9213829040527344,
0.6691141724586487,
-0.038770101964473724,
-0.22570952773094177,
-0.19108876585960388,
-0.15234138071537018,
-0.6010308265686035,
0.5472992658615112,
0.4846546947956085,
-0.9361832737922668,
-0.42295774817466736,
-0.6204819679260254,
0.0694541409611702,
-0.344052255153656,
0.6834984421730042,
0.7405471205711365,
0.2515226900577545,
-0.41140174865722656,
-0.090406633913517,
-0.6043045520782471,
-0.4320316016674042,
-0.8808737397193909,
-0.45752382278442383,
0.5391662120819092,
0.1059931069612503,
0.7422451376914978,
0.48853591084480286,
0.45626795291900635,
0.24557271599769592,
-0.0012243365636095405,
0.46062397956848145,
-0.46714121103286743,
0.3675353527069092,
-0.08354378491640091,
-0.7643871903419495,
-0.29819655418395996,
-0.26361843943595886,
0.5348294377326965,
1.1655129194259644,
0.13086450099945068,
-0.39719533920288086,
-0.04397699236869812,
0.7811187505722046,
-0.6559017896652222,
0.1478801816701889,
-0.7889582514762878,
-0.2569247782230377,
-0.09912537783384323,
-0.759349524974823,
-0.4569067656993866,
-0.34443944692611694,
-0.11577995121479034,
-0.6427405476570129,
-0.018197547644376755,
0.19412006437778473,
0.9945831298828125,
0.5332605242729187,
-0.38594937324523926,
-0.10774175077676773,
-0.22073787450790405,
0.43670007586479187,
-0.534464418888092,
0.6124217510223389,
0.8321976065635681,
0.125044584274292,
-0.43505871295928955,
-0.8703661561012268,
-0.5843662023544312,
-0.1472412645816803,
-0.35684123635292053,
0.22955293953418732,
0.02994227223098278,
0.24898043274879456,
0.5397053956985474,
0.1420598328113556,
-0.4479758143424988,
-0.05014236643910408,
-0.3529040217399597,
-0.2853940427303314,
0.6145710349082947,
0.16220901906490326,
0.6179505586624146,
-0.26493629813194275,
0.01257297769188881,
-0.1791166067123413,
-0.6046718955039978,
-0.06100129708647728,
0.37699824571609497,
0.005471345502883196,
0.6467891931533813,
0.6211532354354858,
-0.5855652689933777,
1.2592897415161133,
0.29626622796058655,
0.27503445744514465,
0.4584543704986572,
-0.17373411357402802,
-0.03711927309632301,
0.3185683786869049,
0.4235175549983978,
0.6522628664970398,
-0.2057589441537857,
-0.4560099244117737,
-0.23283015191555023,
0.14522682130336761,
0.3653140962123871,
-0.685413122177124,
-0.16725817322731018,
0.42755845189094543,
-0.4953951835632324,
0.09347202628850937,
0.13744032382965088,
-0.5656378865242004,
-0.3027535676956177,
-0.35610780119895935,
0.6367087960243225,
-0.9266935586929321,
-0.2008323222398758,
0.17365527153015137,
-0.6360542178153992,
0.6094804406166077,
0.2518453896045685,
-1.0682076215744019,
-0.01216336153447628,
0.7850935459136963,
0.5034648180007935,
-0.1138760969042778,
-0.14258334040641785,
-0.570586621761322,
0.1687658280134201,
-0.2980433702468872,
1.056765079498291,
-0.7769920825958252,
-0.5827609896659851,
-0.3497481346130371,
0.09872856736183167,
-0.06672649085521698,
-0.3721868693828583,
0.8533267378807068,
-1.120124340057373,
0.3332664668560028,
-0.5587171316146851,
-0.6608636379241943,
-0.3109540343284607,
0.2643512785434723,
-0.5979971885681152,
0.8982796669006348,
0.14449681341648102,
-0.6493195295333862,
0.6023513078689575,
-0.8725176453590393,
-0.7637742161750793,
0.07925500720739365,
-0.1762029528617859,
0.23616033792495728,
0.12089546024799347,
0.6851732730865479,
-0.05609681457281113,
0.03765987604856491,
-0.34182122349739075,
-0.17463383078575134,
-0.5552732944488525,
0.21789464354515076,
-0.22234408557415009,
0.9257131814956665,
0.21102187037467957,
0.12162775546312332,
-0.13663779199123383,
-0.6756523251533508,
0.45217984914779663,
-0.08692165464162827,
-0.31745848059654236,
-0.8039081692695618,
0.04920142889022827,
-0.2718597650527954,
-0.08593036234378815,
0.40956535935401917,
-0.611616313457489,
0.20332443714141846,
-1.1089539527893066,
0.39380761981010437,
0.2036813497543335,
0.28542765974998474,
0.538048505783081,
-0.33673739433288574,
0.10805771499872208,
-0.08719213306903839,
-0.22217558324337006,
-0.46658170223236084,
-0.7564164400100708,
-0.6149452328681946,
-0.33069127798080444,
0.43056371808052063,
0.5918000340461731,
-0.7031770944595337,
0.5838148593902588,
-0.4025076627731323,
-0.17410114407539368,
-0.9638840556144714,
-0.4214555025100708,
-0.24569033086299896,
0.8505807518959045,
0.5025638937950134,
-0.15991784632205963,
-0.49582573771476746,
-0.7998043298721313,
-0.6328376531600952,
-0.01916627772152424,
-0.3320767283439636,
0.19650080800056458,
0.0507475882768631,
-0.1261400431394577,
0.8033158779144287,
-0.6921531558036804,
-0.3043283522129059,
0.3390936255455017,
0.41897153854370117,
0.35553836822509766,
0.49222126603126526,
0.2767982482910156,
-0.853131115436554,
0.12619252502918243,
-0.05574081465601921,
-0.9297667145729065,
-0.27415362000465393,
-0.06704262644052505,
-0.4056808650493622,
0.07045001536607742,
0.5121728777885437,
-0.8666130900382996,
0.3167721629142761,
-0.26493939757347107,
-0.262599378824234,
0.10932758450508118,
-0.34657803177833557,
0.757473886013031,
-0.740409255027771,
-0.017959652468562126,
-0.4073426425457001,
-0.03985530138015747,
-0.1935667097568512,
0.22055725753307343,
0.14866958558559418,
-0.13140270113945007,
0.1157049909234047,
0.2454395890235901,
-0.7541066408157349,
-0.07975432276725769,
-0.6440786123275757,
0.21638645231723785,
0.1944478303194046,
0.4278690218925476,
-0.0349978506565094,
0.720847487449646,
0.6645801663398743,
-0.528179943561554,
0.1596251279115677,
0.527725875377655,
-0.11312839388847351,
0.9109697937965393,
-0.4312346577644348,
0.30097106099128723,
-0.629997968673706,
0.017034854739904404,
-1.442584753036499,
-0.3676145672798157,
-0.022499460726976395,
-0.9545002579689026,
0.3064626157283783,
-0.043617624789476395,
-0.45071157813072205,
-0.17857374250888824,
-0.162974551320076,
0.2655598521232605,
0.5446416139602661,
-0.6294066905975342,
0.7258471250534058,
0.6062694191932678,
-0.011701305396854877,
-0.5725842118263245,
-1.0453276634216309,
0.19083313643932343,
0.10181104391813278,
-0.8521127700805664,
0.7042971849441528,
0.22647036612033844,
0.14435477554798126,
0.18076539039611816,
-0.14721770584583282,
-0.0820641741156578,
-0.06680133193731308,
0.24534934759140015,
0.19735538959503174,
-0.04626382142305374,
0.2204250544309616,
0.6016374826431274,
-0.09321891516447067,
0.39803096652030945,
-0.5358989834785461,
0.4148038327693939,
0.12774699926376343,
-0.5381765365600586,
-0.24021580815315247,
0.6156827807426453,
0.5747146010398865,
-0.5473225712776184,
0.41199377179145813,
0.5443287491798401,
-0.7728949785232544,
0.0789775550365448,
-0.6111845374107361,
-0.8407008051872253,
-0.5125594735145569,
0.15716181695461273,
-0.5625501275062561,
-0.6827431917190552,
0.4317455291748047,
-0.2030591070652008,
-0.26743119955062866,
0.46490299701690674,
0.3908785879611969,
-0.37216705083847046,
1.5192551612854004,
0.2524634599685669,
0.24312067031860352,
0.44538670778274536,
-0.25897225737571716,
0.10593559592962265,
-0.882895827293396,
-0.5246919989585876,
-0.5222848057746887,
-0.5492490530014038,
-0.36029723286628723,
-0.16412602365016937,
0.5795338749885559,
-0.06475348770618439,
0.2934844493865967,
0.12660813331604004,
-0.8858267068862915,
0.379034161567688,
0.574556827545166,
0.6926236748695374,
0.3517204225063324,
0.38332292437553406,
-0.2935560941696167,
-0.20028646290302277,
-0.6364905834197998,
0.06973396241664886,
1.0852978229522705,
-0.3082304894924164,
0.6733174324035645,
-0.09729143232107162,
0.5503885746002197,
0.3524203598499298,
0.1344914734363556,
-0.9509333372116089,
0.550987958908081,
0.26640307903289795,
-0.5279366374015808,
-0.14309656620025635,
-0.20026107132434845,
-1.3270001411437988,
0.4331849217414856,
-0.5564852952957153,
-0.8794981241226196,
0.46671104431152344,
-0.24900399148464203,
-0.3514489233493805,
-0.3256584405899048,
-0.7930249571800232,
0.5879732370376587,
-0.21988198161125183,
-0.42178013920783997,
-0.5645884275436401,
-0.7313144207000732,
0.310403972864151,
0.09285912662744522,
-0.12411137670278549,
0.17106842994689941,
-0.31293439865112305,
0.7219292521476746,
-0.4127083122730255,
0.1708427518606186,
-0.2527271807193756,
0.3024296760559082,
0.2036581188440323,
-0.3303043842315674,
0.4284253418445587,
0.000402384321205318,
-0.5513189435005188,
-0.01910293474793434,
0.12392952293157578,
-0.3472922146320343,
-1.0457432270050049,
1.0204921960830688,
-0.38776111602783203,
-0.7924314141273499,
-0.2501406967639923,
-0.6997403502464294,
-0.46363192796707153,
0.5321925282478333,
0.26194635033607483,
0.3887123465538025,
0.23871025443077087,
0.16329115629196167,
0.6866587400436401,
0.07089580595493317,
0.3466067314147949,
0.44666337966918945,
-0.06720783561468124,
-0.41535869240760803,
0.8011998534202576,
0.32068589329719543,
-0.3966848850250244,
0.6473905444145203,
-0.28599125146865845,
-0.8272448182106018,
-0.7189496755599976,
-0.13651637732982635,
0.18848709762096405,
-0.802951991558075,
-0.05324620380997658,
-0.9383198618888855,
-0.018423471599817276,
-0.3575810194015503,
0.07604200392961502,
0.2657516598701477,
-0.5725754499435425,
-0.07774968445301056,
-0.20146317780017853,
0.4101521074771881,
-0.11275599151849747,
-0.10241246223449707,
0.4748278558254242,
-0.8212845921516418,
0.5471922755241394,
0.12172640860080719,
0.1864888072013855,
-0.22615943849086761,
-0.18189701437950134,
-0.129654660820961,
0.21549257636070251,
-0.1178465485572815,
-1.4090068340301514,
0.3872247040271759,
0.1663096398115158,
0.9120635986328125,
0.24740687012672424,
0.1750877946615219,
0.7747102975845337,
-0.1723192185163498,
0.6786574721336365,
0.00596556207165122,
-0.5366910099983215,
0.8918437361717224,
-0.4604185223579407,
0.4902026951313019,
0.7570702433586121,
0.41583845019340515,
-0.048894915729761124,
-0.26959845423698425,
-0.47429728507995605,
-1.1324461698532104,
0.6896796226501465,
0.07881928235292435,
0.11101776361465454,
-0.44379180669784546,
0.7031882405281067,
-0.05188870057463646,
0.06139076128602028,
0.010981708765029907,
-0.24333719909191132,
-0.15645019710063934,
-0.13484235107898712,
0.6357302069664001,
-0.011031093075871468,
-0.22383522987365723,
-0.5339247584342957,
0.48069801926612854,
-0.18533171713352203,
0.6210834383964539,
0.47051724791526794,
-0.3115082085132599,
0.08885043114423752,
-0.10026893764734268,
0.13789771497249603,
0.6053296327590942,
-0.40581682324409485,
-0.15968544781208038,
0.27105477452278137,
-0.5629850029945374,
-0.08434853702783585,
0.4212387800216675,
-0.21335652470588684,
-0.031070956960320473,
-0.1468503624200821,
0.7107271552085876,
-0.1515273153781891,
-0.6324549317359924,
0.3564548194408417,
-0.16694249212741852,
0.004221925511956215,
-0.05201104283332825,
0.18155501782894135,
0.06796704977750778,
0.1539131999015808,
0.8282701969146729,
0.26083940267562866,
0.7361270189285278,
-0.31881141662597656,
0.5180364847183228,
0.795600950717926,
-0.18341998755931854,
0.18327008187770844,
1.0342180728912354,
0.13465993106365204,
-0.2341371774673462,
1.0286297798156738,
-0.01741744577884674,
0.022760380059480667,
0.4359390437602997,
0.4534185826778412,
0.7255759239196777,
0.13829867541790009,
-0.3645254373550415,
0.43192002177238464,
0.48625075817108154,
-0.010529136285185814,
0.653883695602417,
-0.3477970063686371,
-0.6111165285110474,
-0.8005068302154541,
-0.5264892578125,
-0.2122134566307068,
0.08845846354961395,
-0.7464583516120911,
0.3270699679851532,
-0.21045275032520294,
-0.6736839413642883,
0.19291776418685913,
-0.24031376838684082,
-0.4514607787132263,
0.606589674949646,
0.007581065874546766,
0.9031278491020203,
-0.26704615354537964,
0.8356603384017944,
0.9689727425575256,
-0.6815917491912842,
-0.43348926305770874,
0.08865753561258316,
-0.4532740116119385,
-0.8762598633766174,
0.6303719878196716,
0.19106315076351166,
-0.2292088121175766,
0.4657873511314392,
-0.4227926731109619,
-0.6727604866027832,
0.9245738387107849,
0.48457056283950806,
-0.04363754391670227,
-0.17814446985721588,
-0.07466880232095718,
0.43631088733673096,
-0.18753887712955475,
0.7734249830245972,
0.5735412836074829,
0.7640033960342407,
-0.06096901372075081,
-0.36405497789382935,
0.26759615540504456,
-0.346549391746521,
-0.06914136558771133,
0.22969864308834076,
-0.16227714717388153,
0.26631659269332886,
-0.16093863546848297,
-0.39799097180366516,
-0.07174549996852875,
1.0857326984405518,
0.029208116233348846,
0.4542599618434906,
0.4066532552242279,
0.7833583950996399,
1.009777545928955,
-0.5177924036979675,
1.183448076248169,
-0.8731952905654907,
-0.07410456985235214,
0.62912917137146,
0.1462167501449585,
0.8323653340339661,
0.6368018388748169,
0.1285281628370285,
0.41108208894729614,
0.8052347898483276,
0.16499444842338562,
0.6553537249565125,
-0.15454013645648956,
-0.2319566309452057,
-0.2884892523288727,
0.05746814236044884,
-0.5139874219894409,
0.5371708869934082,
1.0148311853408813,
-0.23169901967048645,
-0.3717276155948639,
0.17133642733097076,
-0.2641858160495758,
0.03187263756990433,
-0.39028453826904297,
0.8231463432312012,
-0.006589983124285936,
-1.2244462966918945,
0.9387575387954712,
0.03317034989595413,
0.6236027479171753,
-0.68467777967453,
-0.10520603507757187,
-0.229805588722229,
-0.2604692280292511,
-0.5561864972114563,
-0.7389733791351318,
0.607530415058136,
-0.5734316110610962,
-0.27258676290512085,
-0.022118330001831055,
1.197317361831665,
-0.41352078318595886,
-0.1743936538696289,
0.1306525617837906,
0.5308659672737122,
0.3349679410457611,
-0.45108482241630554,
-0.5558894872665405,
-0.09307114779949188,
-0.3179638683795929,
-0.13016384840011597,
0.3419039249420166,
0.36259856820106506,
0.015707340091466904,
0.4862995147705078,
0.9655342102050781,
-0.066651351749897,
0.0882369801402092,
-0.15965139865875244,
0.9299242496490479,
-0.7558515071868896,
-0.7291248440742493,
-0.5728582143783569,
0.3592471182346344,
-0.3524538576602936,
0.1314755231142044,
0.8193122148513794,
0.44995296001434326,
0.598375141620636,
-0.11901269108057022,
0.8245582580566406,
-0.10237234085798264,
0.1842450648546219,
-0.5826776027679443,
0.9864291548728943,
-0.740908682346344,
0.19370059669017792,
0.24444140493869781,
-0.8891578316688538,
-0.21717844903469086,
0.5747961401939392,
-0.5202847123146057,
0.11180559545755386,
0.8228290677070618,
1.2152007818222046,
0.02654348872601986,
0.3690207898616791,
0.3073596656322479,
0.0021155630238354206,
-0.2534872889518738,
0.3939078152179718,
0.7582878470420837,
-0.4736241102218628,
0.45250973105430603,
0.11717801541090012,
-0.25960731506347656,
-0.3448573648929596,
-0.6013892292976379,
-0.48760294914245605,
-0.5423772931098938,
-0.2930348515510559,
-0.5768884420394897,
0.2733449339866638,
0.5974744558334351,
0.7446563243865967,
-0.49884986877441406,
0.19952146708965302,
-0.07236351817846298,
0.29957371950149536,
-0.6258954405784607,
-0.30827319622039795,
0.32578611373901367,
-0.72212153673172,
-0.8952137231826782,
0.908294141292572,
0.3373675048351288,
-0.4711718261241913,
-0.007918993942439556,
0.3079129755496979,
-0.3487103581428528,
0.27923455834388733,
0.5972822308540344,
0.24479424953460693,
-0.49833524227142334,
-0.1024676114320755,
0.1285654604434967,
-0.16559019684791565,
0.23154772818088531,
0.5227110385894775,
-1.313087821006775,
0.5799234509468079,
1.1091444492340088,
1.0765902996063232,
0.7311793565750122,
0.19425857067108154,
0.5797524452209473,
-0.7120789885520935,
-0.000012057566891598981,
0.11241215467453003,
0.3428495228290558,
0.43375855684280396,
-0.7560292482376099,
0.3899734318256378,
0.2606053352355957,
-0.37905219197273254,
-0.6218858957290649,
0.0915723443031311,
-1.3188575506210327,
-0.334743857383728,
0.8800777792930603,
0.3098592162132263,
-0.6750423312187195,
-0.08976329118013382,
-0.3822952210903168,
0.2060418576002121,
-0.45601391792297363,
0.6721407175064087,
0.638857364654541,
-0.5613558888435364,
-0.13108131289482117,
-0.4527145326137543,
0.32871517539024353,
0.6460621356964111,
-0.7648259401321411,
-0.5307835340499878,
0.7740963101387024,
0.209477961063385,
0.2367761880159378,
0.7083037495613098,
-0.4629957973957062,
0.4932922422885895,
0.2422206550836563,
-0.29655343294143677,
-0.25244906544685364,
0.20433874428272247,
-0.17735187709331512,
0.6658890843391418,
0.034878335893154144,
-0.5196228623390198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15700v1
|
CoRelation: Boosting Automatic ICD Coding Through Contextualized Code Relation Learning
| 2024-02-24T03:25:28 | 2024-02-24T03:25:28 |
Junyu Luo, Xiaochen Wang, Jiaqi Wang, Aofei Chang, Yaqing Wang, Fenglong Ma
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Automatic International Classification of Diseases (ICD) coding plays a
crucial role in the extraction of relevant information from clinical notes for
proper recording and billing. One of the most important directions for boosting
the performance of automatic ICD coding is modeling ICD code relations.
However, current methods insufficiently model the intricate relationships among
ICD codes and often overlook the importance of context in clinical notes. In
this paper, we propose a novel approach, a contextualized and flexible
framework, to enhance the learning of ICD code representations. Our approach,
unlike existing methods, employs a dependent learning paradigm that considers
the context of clinical notes in modeling all possible code relations. We
evaluate our approach on six public ICD coding datasets and the experimental
results demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach compared to
state-of-the-art baselines.
|
[
-0.07183483242988586,
-0.15489128232002258,
0.33146932721138,
0.19983410835266113,
-0.4958275854587555,
-0.08554946631193161,
-0.2279578149318695,
-0.5675265192985535,
0.17820152640342712,
0.31295907497406006,
-0.16127043962478638,
-0.838188886642456,
-0.40601691603660583,
0.12337036430835724,
-0.0009019825956784189,
1.2243032455444336,
-0.15064704418182373,
0.45236775279045105,
-0.39241427183151245,
-0.37276697158813477,
-0.4429726302623749,
-0.8198106288909912,
-0.28961461782455444,
-0.32801616191864014,
0.2392110526561737,
0.45024728775024414,
0.20373933017253876,
0.948437511920929,
0.7118414044380188,
0.09363573789596558,
0.09475894272327423,
0.0475829653441906,
0.0947142019867897,
0.07948225736618042,
-0.14808353781700134,
-0.34985116124153137,
-0.7294560670852661,
-0.32612353563308716,
0.34856584668159485,
0.8090991973876953,
-0.062141016125679016,
0.13239847123622894,
-0.05576052889227867,
0.49209508299827576,
-0.4391891062259674,
0.5446519255638123,
-0.30210477113723755,
-0.016694851219654083,
-0.02377542108297348,
-0.5555088520050049,
-0.472835510969162,
-0.036669887602329254,
0.1245841383934021,
-0.332724392414093,
0.2849749028682709,
-0.2618049085140228,
0.5277522206306458,
0.1709475815296173,
-0.6467592120170593,
-0.6984289884567261,
-0.634778618812561,
0.19312137365341187,
-0.4470662772655487,
0.2367553561925888,
0.31836074590682983,
0.34007972478866577,
0.3268466889858246,
-0.7732170224189758,
-0.1385873705148697,
-0.12873481214046478,
-0.4000687897205353,
0.043813787400722504,
0.2676829397678375,
-0.00424402579665184,
0.2299184650182724,
0.4511142671108246,
-0.20246581733226776,
-0.23740129172801971,
-0.41414931416511536,
0.10327312350273132,
0.6575978994369507,
0.09801319241523743,
0.7396811246871948,
-0.31824710965156555,
-0.2480476200580597,
0.13583922386169434,
-0.8036666512489319,
0.12126269191503525,
-0.48304376006126404,
0.29404333233833313,
-0.6726152896881104,
0.09804185479879379,
0.008803639560937881,
0.5486598014831543,
0.5595784783363342,
-0.6231134533882141,
0.5536080598831177,
-0.14501459896564484,
-0.14240525662899017,
0.440620094537735,
0.23900000751018524,
0.35313504934310913,
-0.32158154249191284,
-0.3266983926296234,
-0.12843537330627441,
-0.06066373363137245,
0.45586124062538147,
-0.5964248180389404,
-0.40606263279914856,
0.07289496064186096,
-0.6110992431640625,
-0.18375644087791443,
-0.014263635501265526,
-0.4753323495388031,
-0.09167104214429855,
-0.595281720161438,
-0.033019229769706726,
-0.4377366304397583,
-0.08387663960456848,
-0.10035616159439087,
0.22316667437553406,
-0.046808794140815735,
0.33109408617019653,
-0.8288343548774719,
0.2838490605354309,
0.4007468521595001,
0.6373235583305359,
-0.2831617295742035,
0.03765372559428215,
-0.5293076038360596,
0.49417996406555176,
-0.13565292954444885,
0.6977829337120056,
-0.6070040464401245,
-0.6239613890647888,
-0.027106918394565582,
-0.0663389191031456,
0.026581021025776863,
-0.6579494476318359,
0.6459775567054749,
-0.49587225914001465,
-0.2831735908985138,
-0.08015625178813934,
-0.4206695258617401,
0.03259331360459328,
0.266862690448761,
-0.9106388688087463,
0.6105549335479736,
0.4755040407180786,
-0.9845750331878662,
0.3929841220378876,
-0.5383678078651428,
-0.9480025172233582,
0.2516067922115326,
-0.5733954906463623,
-0.40500274300575256,
-0.03401739150285721,
0.4238503575325012,
0.5625842809677124,
-0.139288529753685,
0.760903000831604,
-0.04065990075469017,
-0.06300206482410431,
-0.14358027279376984,
0.16095659136772156,
0.7729597091674805,
0.2924010753631592,
-0.42591428756713867,
0.22644004225730896,
-1.0164328813552856,
-0.3389649987220764,
-0.282349169254303,
-0.504241406917572,
-0.5448729991912842,
-0.015714222565293312,
0.1619565337896347,
0.28664630651474,
-0.2541263997554779,
-0.2357586771249771,
0.4408397376537323,
-0.4068472683429718,
0.289905309677124,
0.31477153301239014,
0.37266403436660767,
0.6368560194969177,
-0.39466339349746704,
0.5919240117073059,
0.3134707808494568,
-0.07567103207111359,
-0.5139633417129517,
-0.25698578357696533,
-0.3344181776046753,
-0.2668730318546295,
0.2938106954097748,
0.42991921305656433,
-0.8616704344749451,
0.448988676071167,
-0.5162553191184998,
-0.24137432873249054,
-0.21195700764656067,
0.09350886940956116,
0.5967066287994385,
0.9823322892189026,
0.5599304437637329,
-0.519584059715271,
-0.6018688082695007,
-0.5795544385910034,
0.09205049276351929,
-0.1740131825208664,
-0.11303896456956863,
0.6074650883674622,
0.3284852206707001,
-0.5093257427215576,
1.0479637384414673,
-0.45749834179878235,
-0.48358988761901855,
-0.4267195463180542,
0.05850472301244736,
0.09203062206506729,
1.0807443857192993,
0.710915207862854,
-0.8073502779006958,
-0.6824886202812195,
0.21449778974056244,
-0.5629442930221558,
0.018162647262215614,
-0.20231181383132935,
0.13455088436603546,
-0.17325416207313538,
0.5722228288650513,
-0.13317561149597168,
0.5440647006034851,
0.2252192348241806,
-0.09602559357881546,
0.3966052532196045,
-0.4476778507232666,
0.1033192127943039,
-1.024369716644287,
0.4067234694957733,
0.09836223721504211,
-0.3287504017353058,
-0.7323614954948425,
0.18759702146053314,
0.6080555319786072,
-0.17866671085357666,
-0.47306621074676514,
0.559116005897522,
-0.4261966645717621,
0.033070631325244904,
0.07900744676589966,
-0.12700597941875458,
0.05705207586288452,
0.39929744601249695,
0.28842633962631226,
0.5948851108551025,
0.6206925511360168,
-0.8126763701438904,
0.12251210957765579,
0.166472926735878,
-0.23352904617786407,
0.5757766962051392,
-0.4656594693660736,
-0.17717252671718597,
-0.21709513664245605,
0.6491639614105225,
-0.5097541809082031,
-0.4276932179927826,
0.18866121768951416,
-0.42070040106773376,
0.705957293510437,
-0.4440368115901947,
-0.36136290431022644,
-0.09371953457593918,
0.14969713985919952,
1.064863681793213,
0.4828031361103058,
-0.8161014318466187,
0.6045427322387695,
0.6243453621864319,
0.05521903187036514,
-0.29329004883766174,
-0.5374384522438049,
-0.09511896222829819,
-0.21653756499290466,
-0.3001471161842346,
0.7165659070014954,
-0.03796359896659851,
-0.2102549821138382,
-0.16400715708732605,
-0.27776607871055603,
-0.2350035309791565,
0.17081168293952942,
0.3381081223487854,
0.21372084319591522,
-0.2926247715950012,
0.36050331592559814,
0.1445336937904358,
-0.21021662652492523,
0.07815353572368622,
-0.40132248401641846,
0.1909027099609375,
0.16479846835136414,
-0.3694879412651062,
-0.4830820858478546,
0.45426425337791443,
0.5097021460533142,
-0.4333094358444214,
0.28388023376464844,
0.2335827648639679,
-0.8139399290084839,
-0.3984242081642151,
-0.13433019816875458,
-0.04915416240692139,
-0.40199095010757446,
0.26629436016082764,
-0.2725050151348114,
-0.6016559600830078,
0.53255695104599,
-0.10107223689556122,
-0.3011910915374756,
0.3020452558994293,
0.41752272844314575,
0.2090008705854416,
1.1987974643707275,
0.9336404204368591,
-0.2852010130882263,
0.14607442915439606,
-0.21386100351810455,
0.10090295225381851,
-1.1241322755813599,
-0.38322165608406067,
-0.5395933985710144,
0.21151092648506165,
-0.23421211540699005,
-0.4795389175415039,
0.6741552352905273,
0.25986453890800476,
-0.10621637850999832,
0.004532371181994677,
-0.5440506935119629,
0.3859727680683136,
0.03581859916448593,
0.29874148964881897,
0.37329769134521484,
0.045527320355176926,
-0.402646005153656,
0.09450869262218475,
-0.900127649307251,
-0.2845020592212677,
1.2976402044296265,
0.23613563179969788,
0.7495139241218567,
-0.1077045351266861,
0.5461374521255493,
0.4099223017692566,
0.9187345504760742,
-0.5282266139984131,
0.015921657904982567,
-0.08727753162384033,
-0.32953959703445435,
0.42321303486824036,
-0.26802048087120056,
-0.6900697946548462,
-0.1710280328989029,
0.05205940082669258,
-0.7575103044509888,
0.42642727494239807,
0.599560558795929,
-0.49195805191993713,
0.18857945501804352,
-0.5562875270843506,
0.7745043039321899,
-0.31946298480033875,
-0.30012431740760803,
-0.09407247602939606,
-0.8182341456413269,
0.3087150454521179,
0.19697162508964539,
0.37341436743736267,
0.2663326561450958,
0.06371995061635971,
0.6467395424842834,
-0.29865843057632446,
0.9999061226844788,
0.1335618644952774,
-0.29739633202552795,
0.07054705917835236,
-0.02566778101027012,
0.22596792876720428,
0.7996733784675598,
0.22541497647762299,
-0.15020565688610077,
-0.10628259181976318,
-0.4807232916355133,
-0.4285631477832794,
0.9061753749847412,
-0.681811511516571,
-0.19875286519527435,
-0.3508583605289459,
-0.35133272409439087,
-0.37598106265068054,
0.3006197214126587,
0.2331891506910324,
1.268457055091858,
-0.026678849011659622,
-0.07617882639169693,
0.6896814107894897,
-0.19686947762966156,
0.15779262781143188,
0.29612159729003906,
0.14787712693214417,
-0.49583402276039124,
0.5759153366088867,
-0.1493537873029709,
0.05329231172800064,
0.5682246685028076,
-0.151674285531044,
0.045598458498716354,
-0.4965488612651825,
-0.5154463648796082,
0.34640321135520935,
-1.1658194065093994,
-0.4213077425956726,
-0.7349247336387634,
0.06696317344903946,
-0.6545820236206055,
-0.4696328639984131,
-0.07232844084501266,
-0.16458533704280853,
-0.49143269658088684,
-0.21222268044948578,
0.14001230895519257,
0.6676410436630249,
0.07609885931015015,
0.17748060822486877,
-0.9899162650108337,
0.2939375340938568,
0.10396822541952133,
0.7113868594169617,
0.24334727227687836,
-0.04648705571889877,
-0.7087223529815674,
-0.10174201428890228,
-0.13018909096717834,
-0.9553190469741821,
0.2853679656982422,
0.13885214924812317,
0.7107941508293152,
0.708489179611206,
0.3550417423248291,
0.7365076541900635,
-0.6028752326965332,
0.6417077779769897,
0.16939134895801544,
-1.0559238195419312,
0.7140777707099915,
-0.2213887870311737,
0.3760186731815338,
0.5296106934547424,
0.5582107305526733,
-0.6116498112678528,
-0.07605711370706558,
-0.9067217111587524,
-0.8720124363899231,
0.7934615612030029,
-0.2054634690284729,
-0.08527065813541412,
-0.29156041145324707,
0.8636605739593506,
0.10496857017278671,
0.12132462859153748,
-0.5419567227363586,
-0.4400145709514618,
-0.08293871581554413,
-0.5318461656570435,
-0.2130231112241745,
-0.1713642179965973,
-0.29676353931427,
-0.4963242709636688,
0.3048381805419922,
-0.3277495205402374,
0.36566412448883057,
0.8011128306388855,
-0.5057666897773743,
-0.196706622838974,
-0.03854236751794815,
0.6303621530532837,
1.0079301595687866,
-0.1510239839553833,
0.3770318925380707,
-0.16251955926418304,
-0.4822009205818176,
-0.03706498071551323,
0.008057249709963799,
-0.26701971888542175,
0.07568497210741043,
0.5328584909439087,
0.6427890062332153,
0.3972001373767853,
-0.8560605645179749,
0.6010921001434326,
-0.08493069559335709,
0.06380166113376617,
-0.30832380056381226,
0.03346821293234825,
-0.0046379645355045795,
0.014840546064078808,
0.3437296152114868,
0.3358430862426758,
0.23472583293914795,
-0.5040686726570129,
0.813446044921875,
0.09161261469125748,
-0.6990749835968018,
-0.5965903997421265,
0.716545045375824,
0.5724759697914124,
-0.29092246294021606,
0.2875044643878937,
-0.19759993255138397,
-0.7985031008720398,
0.9201202392578125,
0.8417830467224121,
0.5741254687309265,
-0.13449198007583618,
-0.022842630743980408,
0.5607281923294067,
-0.14181680977344513,
0.047416266053915024,
-0.188787043094635,
-0.584696888923645,
-0.4090469479560852,
-0.4021579921245575,
-0.09565981477499008,
-0.11152613908052444,
0.1496831625699997,
-1.117262363433838,
0.45592448115348816,
-0.5822264552116394,
0.058670394122600555,
-0.3334674835205078,
-0.08418957144021988,
-0.4739246368408203,
0.38536545634269714,
0.35004186630249023,
0.9695314168930054,
-0.6377993822097778,
1.166816234588623,
1.0056278705596924,
-0.2875834107398987,
-0.7864545583724976,
0.19275671243667603,
-0.1719290018081665,
-0.3148752450942993,
0.8040322065353394,
0.38492220640182495,
0.1320503205060959,
0.08589328825473785,
-0.16658182442188263,
-0.9215288162231445,
0.9905996918678284,
-0.036202508956193924,
-0.216791033744812,
-0.04142332449555397,
-0.30435341596603394,
0.5808309316635132,
-1.0270072221755981,
0.2185332030057907,
0.5481113195419312,
-0.28642192482948303,
-0.16647501289844513,
-1.0021522045135498,
0.2646375298500061,
-0.6772962212562561,
-0.20886026322841644,
0.06530923396348953,
-0.36014682054519653,
0.601194441318512,
-0.27396219968795776,
-0.4004727303981781,
-0.2867181599140167,
0.37403613328933716,
0.057971592992544174,
0.44715213775634766,
0.22329938411712646,
0.23249858617782593,
0.5033301115036011,
0.27352389693260193,
0.9735803604125977,
-0.9157207012176514,
0.4525495767593384,
1.1079165935516357,
-0.39875921607017517,
0.4555242657661438,
0.24659410119056702,
0.04689851775765419,
0.4846460223197937,
0.4315372705459595,
0.13018065690994263,
0.5931516289710999,
-0.0035423587542027235,
-0.2139039784669876,
-0.16213275492191315,
0.1743660867214203,
-0.682325005531311,
-0.13827553391456604,
0.6311348080635071,
-0.5450630187988281,
-0.4218164086341858,
0.3208366334438324,
-0.047441236674785614,
0.22341853380203247,
-0.44169703125953674,
0.8542860150337219,
-0.009117448702454567,
-0.7849088907241821,
0.6703532338142395,
0.17650997638702393,
0.38034188747406006,
-0.36764657497406006,
-0.1968148648738861,
-0.14346849918365479,
0.35296767950057983,
-0.253751665353775,
-0.015491075813770294,
0.3265772759914398,
-0.015828892588615417,
-0.3896443545818329,
-0.23652471601963043,
0.6358104944229126,
-0.5378378629684448,
-0.3193618953227997,
0.21821732819080353,
0.1974492073059082,
-0.3411519527435303,
0.5332360863685608,
-0.5441742539405823,
-0.13270774483680725,
-0.029586810618638992,
0.33440783619880676,
0.5509695410728455,
0.30599266290664673,
-0.13241726160049438,
0.6536592245101929,
0.3980422019958496,
0.09788273274898529,
-0.3711189329624176,
-0.13062912225723267,
1.1257306337356567,
-0.40915971994400024,
-1.0746575593948364,
-0.49354711174964905,
0.4521980881690979,
-0.022003892809152603,
-0.27684587240219116,
0.46372875571250916,
0.5259985327720642,
0.9761483073234558,
-0.09899716079235077,
0.8899157643318176,
-0.055308274924755096,
0.5647566318511963,
-0.3882204294204712,
0.6812765002250671,
-0.353911817073822,
0.6767833828926086,
-0.25804847478866577,
-0.325738787651062,
-0.8960177898406982,
0.5683245062828064,
-0.30385109782218933,
-0.3327062427997589,
0.6524763107299805,
0.2732263207435608,
-0.25429272651672363,
-0.16576842963695526,
-0.21430528163909912,
-0.017150050029158592,
0.4189508259296417,
0.4194409251213074,
0.28097325563430786,
-0.25182095170021057,
0.18023622035980225,
-0.7781935334205627,
-0.20748701691627502,
-0.4061487019062042,
-0.8902785181999207,
-0.9660089612007141,
-0.5888022184371948,
-0.5739493370056152,
-0.3191334009170532,
0.028648603707551956,
1.3075460195541382,
0.9284334182739258,
-0.846644401550293,
-0.1902369111776352,
-0.08424479514360428,
0.21986135840415955,
-0.3283992111682892,
-0.11782551556825638,
0.8317348957061768,
-0.38868534564971924,
-0.34684547781944275,
0.03653668239712715,
0.27651554346084595,
0.10149501264095306,
0.25336164236068726,
-0.10307980328798294,
0.04912272095680237,
-0.4638769328594208,
0.5496306419372559,
0.22856318950653076,
-0.35717591643333435,
0.02377580665051937,
-0.2527625560760498,
-0.17841237783432007,
0.5815601348876953,
1.403389573097229,
-0.9529181122779846,
0.3130619525909424,
0.2831359803676605,
0.592284619808197,
0.2844613194465637,
0.5166715383529663,
0.48451563715934753,
-0.7962238788604736,
0.2063698172569275,
0.5023335218429565,
0.16134320199489594,
0.21527278423309326,
-0.5401535630226135,
0.1431571990251541,
0.33970117568969727,
-0.3313129246234894,
-0.8907766938209534,
0.23678050935268402,
-0.89175945520401,
-0.21630623936653137,
0.9599667191505432,
-0.41448697447776794,
-0.3204113841056824,
-0.47667035460472107,
-0.1886056363582611,
0.21065865457057953,
-0.27197009325027466,
0.7888254523277283,
0.012390730902552605,
-0.326917439699173,
-0.011795749887824059,
-0.3082139194011688,
0.9366483688354492,
-0.008291675709187984,
-0.7209330201148987,
-0.03862253949046135,
0.5181381106376648,
0.3303942084312439,
0.23814338445663452,
0.8070119619369507,
-0.3056274652481079,
0.5165765881538391,
-0.38314059376716614,
0.028625143691897392,
0.137936070561409,
-0.4417949914932251,
-0.49292150139808655,
0.26922574639320374,
-0.00046019296860322356,
0.27638328075408936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15690v1
|
Foot In The Door: Understanding Large Language Model Jailbreaking via Cognitive Psychology
| 2024-02-24T02:27:55 | 2024-02-24T02:27:55 |
Zhenhua Wang, Wei Xie, Baosheng Wang, Enze Wang, Zhiwen Gui, Shuoyoucheng Ma, Kai Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have gradually become the gateway for people to
acquire new knowledge. However, attackers can break the model's security
protection ("jail") to access restricted information, which is called
"jailbreaking." Previous studies have shown the weakness of current LLMs when
confronted with such jailbreaking attacks. Nevertheless, comprehension of the
intrinsic decision-making mechanism within the LLMs upon receipt of jailbreak
prompts is noticeably lacking. Our research provides a psychological
explanation of the jailbreak prompts. Drawing on cognitive consistency theory,
we argue that the key to jailbreak is guiding the LLM to achieve cognitive
coordination in an erroneous direction. Further, we propose an automatic
black-box jailbreaking method based on the Foot-in-the-Door (FITD) technique.
This method progressively induces the model to answer harmful questions via
multi-step incremental prompts. We instantiated a prototype system to evaluate
the jailbreaking effectiveness on 8 advanced LLMs, yielding an average success
rate of 83.9%. This study builds a psychological perspective on the explanatory
insights into the intrinsic decision-making logic of LLMs.
|
[
-0.39338451623916626,
-1.1442334651947021,
1.0925806760787964,
0.042281582951545715,
-0.21098802983760834,
0.3763582706451416,
-0.30924466252326965,
-0.43296369910240173,
0.004324694629758596,
0.6484569311141968,
-0.6161959767341614,
-0.22082480788230896,
-0.6009563207626343,
-0.09027427434921265,
-0.06587932258844376,
0.8262491822242737,
-0.07205557078123093,
0.12086814641952515,
-0.10342365503311157,
0.1675390601158142,
-1.0338317155838013,
-0.5033017992973328,
-0.5147506594657898,
-0.46546217799186707,
0.14975447952747345,
0.39901623129844666,
0.7427042126655579,
0.44778284430503845,
0.4881657660007477,
0.2451811283826828,
-0.14304602146148682,
-0.4160299599170685,
-0.32022833824157715,
-0.08982066810131073,
-0.21369613707065582,
-0.8761138319969177,
-0.1222134679555893,
0.1273028701543808,
0.04989216849207878,
0.517423152923584,
-0.2719671428203583,
-0.09880722314119339,
-0.04298717901110649,
0.8199670910835266,
-0.4285244643688202,
0.02534838765859604,
-0.7740041613578796,
-0.031226061284542084,
-0.13812251389026642,
0.0883205384016037,
-0.6264732480049133,
-0.20804890990257263,
-0.1254243701696396,
-0.017310796305537224,
-0.14168132841587067,
-0.004118550103157759,
0.33532556891441345,
0.2738608419895172,
-0.32146596908569336,
-0.38806095719337463,
-0.6344293355941772,
0.3177933990955353,
-0.6545295715332031,
0.4735153019428253,
0.7659551501274109,
0.15844348073005676,
-0.32715365290641785,
0.05978303775191307,
-0.5274403691291809,
-0.554366409778595,
0.09357798099517822,
-0.4239005148410797,
0.045709993690252304,
0.03578944504261017,
0.4223722219467163,
0.051388684660196304,
-0.3622196614742279,
-0.11842790246009827,
-0.3591633439064026,
0.009635969996452332,
0.2949436902999878,
0.12979665398597717,
0.4708036184310913,
-0.039898671209812164,
-0.22406792640686035,
-0.13971540331840515,
-0.6784878373146057,
0.1586131453514099,
0.2409413605928421,
0.13162222504615784,
-0.2856394648551941,
0.5422902703285217,
0.1979895830154419,
0.6820658445358276,
0.28217628598213196,
-0.14253531396389008,
0.03679376468062401,
0.04265865311026573,
-0.17451679706573486,
0.2930036783218384,
0.6696332693099976,
0.4286348223686218,
0.607850968837738,
-0.40719783306121826,
-0.2746233344078064,
0.19163654744625092,
0.5871536731719971,
-0.5521681308746338,
0.04307488724589348,
0.525129497051239,
-0.34347376227378845,
-0.527135968208313,
0.01081917341798544,
-0.5731289386749268,
-0.6194740533828735,
-0.05672445148229599,
0.33144840598106384,
-0.7426005601882935,
-0.23481252789497375,
0.2906327545642853,
-0.023168975487351418,
0.34692147374153137,
0.19589701294898987,
-0.8795907497406006,
0.3874271512031555,
0.7269678115844727,
1.0137053728103638,
0.06145189702510834,
-0.2419019192457199,
-0.4181547164916992,
0.24217893183231354,
-0.4560275375843048,
0.41373881697654724,
-0.45064878463745117,
-0.3850565254688263,
-0.21254552900791168,
-0.09117639064788818,
0.06536095589399338,
-0.5803669095039368,
0.13878826797008514,
-0.563064455986023,
-0.4266185164451599,
-0.06481396406888962,
-0.4162128269672394,
-0.07799728959798813,
0.5010233521461487,
-0.46200060844421387,
0.5249963402748108,
-0.08892180770635605,
-0.37601011991500854,
0.28212878108024597,
-0.3282807171344757,
-0.3900434970855713,
-0.09697815775871277,
-0.1390606313943863,
-0.1375737488269806,
0.3277871012687683,
0.10620395839214325,
0.3138319253921509,
-0.3162764608860016,
0.5067487359046936,
-0.5695177912712097,
-0.061970774084329605,
0.6100779175758362,
-0.26220017671585083,
1.0990372896194458,
0.3443087637424469,
-0.5560314059257507,
-0.19931316375732422,
-0.46102598309516907,
-0.2724245488643646,
0.45046544075012207,
-0.2573001980781555,
-0.5787848830223083,
0.08637993037700653,
-0.39141517877578735,
0.30432015657424927,
0.2898494601249695,
-0.7606164216995239,
0.2720720171928406,
-0.2529005706310272,
0.495326966047287,
0.9971637725830078,
-0.0005931768682785332,
0.40855133533477783,
-0.24322788417339325,
0.4115082919597626,
-0.06910565495491028,
0.3662017285823822,
-0.1261470764875412,
-0.2699013650417328,
-0.2977987825870514,
-0.01683911308646202,
-0.08430047333240509,
0.689764678478241,
-0.4528345763683319,
0.3512398302555084,
0.10043825209140778,
-0.6293424367904663,
-0.33726969361305237,
0.3648580014705658,
0.4982205629348755,
0.25278589129447937,
0.11934971809387207,
-0.2425013780593872,
-0.1026807501912117,
-0.6265286803245544,
-0.3194756507873535,
-0.5053064823150635,
0.2497968226671219,
0.19203567504882812,
0.664758026599884,
-0.1611652672290802,
0.7338871955871582,
-0.5450323820114136,
-0.1491643488407135,
-0.2908293604850769,
-0.2917957603931427,
0.5440036654472351,
0.594475507736206,
0.36018872261047363,
-0.5660763382911682,
-0.18851442635059357,
-0.2497197538614273,
-1.0377475023269653,
0.061704572290182114,
-0.3217271566390991,
-0.1683545708656311,
-0.14793990552425385,
0.8903763890266418,
-0.9908143877983093,
0.5020391345024109,
0.2462073266506195,
-0.7663899660110474,
0.8226319551467896,
-0.3140856623649597,
-0.03968130424618721,
-0.5942285060882568,
-0.571246862411499,
-0.00770498625934124,
0.0003504240303300321,
-0.5539985299110413,
0.4463151693344116,
0.2653363049030304,
-0.07546248286962509,
-0.238928884267807,
0.25458094477653503,
-0.4786183536052704,
0.009962598793208599,
-0.2883533239364624,
0.1802510917186737,
-0.3826843798160553,
0.368489533662796,
-0.08500799536705017,
0.4469780921936035,
0.46270620822906494,
-0.4084608256816864,
0.45115792751312256,
0.19697189331054688,
-0.5731946229934692,
0.47770875692367554,
-0.5482986569404602,
0.24799764156341553,
0.006377392914146185,
0.2623874843120575,
-1.1788372993469238,
-0.07157856225967407,
0.20774774253368378,
-0.33427777886390686,
0.18537573516368866,
-0.19175803661346436,
-0.5725916028022766,
-0.32589641213417053,
-0.17549288272857666,
0.5510495901107788,
0.44239622354507446,
-0.5802914500236511,
0.5445733070373535,
0.43605920672416687,
-0.15994688868522644,
-0.06766136735677719,
-0.4600096642971039,
0.31382718682289124,
-0.1984776109457016,
-0.8262944221496582,
-0.056924231350421906,
-0.22643840312957764,
-0.8553296327590942,
-0.4272873103618622,
-0.20032690465450287,
0.2524638772010803,
0.3744281828403473,
0.26754656434059143,
0.4135337769985199,
0.004253380931913853,
-0.06740015745162964,
-0.36431288719177246,
0.0010395998833701015,
0.6270480155944824,
-0.32500386238098145,
0.739935576915741,
-0.12304048240184784,
-0.39467933773994446,
-0.25727251172065735,
0.04962565377354622,
0.8618675470352173,
-0.2798818051815033,
0.9274289608001709,
-0.23769918084144592,
-0.2445371448993683,
-0.06655517965555191,
-0.7536067366600037,
-0.35460165143013,
-0.4749375879764557,
0.0076490771025419235,
-0.5041869878768921,
-0.6710109710693359,
0.4501289427280426,
-0.23161421716213226,
-0.0944872796535492,
-0.3258204758167267,
0.4563116431236267,
-0.18151265382766724,
0.9287241697311401,
0.8132187724113464,
-0.27360162138938904,
0.5804435014724731,
0.14823788404464722,
0.2310929000377655,
-0.898412823677063,
-0.30990418791770935,
-0.4757641851902008,
-0.26979291439056396,
-0.27830666303634644,
-0.2990621030330658,
0.18666674196720123,
0.40495362877845764,
-0.510286271572113,
0.35301631689071655,
-0.39311984181404114,
0.48258575797080994,
0.17938868701457977,
0.42330363392829895,
0.2959539294242859,
-0.2829950153827667,
-0.436667799949646,
0.22004419565200806,
-0.31350868940353394,
-0.45329350233078003,
1.1497286558151245,
0.49134841561317444,
1.0521653890609741,
0.29159796237945557,
0.668749988079071,
0.23279421031475067,
0.3169240951538086,
-0.7970572710037231,
0.6756553053855896,
0.4006412625312805,
-0.6166254281997681,
-0.1923559308052063,
-0.1140657290816307,
-0.7714080810546875,
0.20657789707183838,
-0.16722434759140015,
-1.3168864250183105,
0.11572734266519547,
-0.057705752551555634,
-0.21585844457149506,
0.4137285649776459,
-0.7117244005203247,
0.6814619302749634,
-0.7561622858047485,
-0.3916836082935333,
-0.3887060284614563,
-0.7831416130065918,
0.6980265378952026,
-0.42545536160469055,
0.7341808676719666,
-0.022515006363391876,
0.2144216150045395,
0.6492601037025452,
-0.7414087653160095,
0.961858332157135,
-0.36005154252052307,
-0.29475510120391846,
0.05063658207654953,
0.46077537536621094,
0.9177913665771484,
-0.004208317957818508,
-0.02518807351589203,
0.07714145630598068,
-0.21399052441120148,
-0.27098721265792847,
-0.6477371454238892,
0.3507065176963806,
-0.6309896111488342,
-0.8948805928230286,
-0.36165153980255127,
-0.42557844519615173,
-0.44675740599632263,
-0.03912730887532234,
0.10507726669311523,
0.16234424710273743,
-0.11659041792154312,
0.041437212377786636,
0.7612451314926147,
-0.2818679213523865,
0.39928191900253296,
0.642720103263855,
-0.6289371252059937,
-0.2406645268201828,
0.469449907541275,
-0.141829252243042,
0.40896672010421753,
0.1397324502468109,
0.39524415135383606,
-0.032620251178741455,
-0.7135728597640991,
-0.304033100605011,
0.45299649238586426,
-0.4873292148113251,
0.062940813601017,
-0.3813193440437317,
-0.01702853851020336,
-0.23601745069026947,
-0.4714348018169403,
-0.20425105094909668,
0.190570667386055,
0.43347421288490295,
-0.4151516854763031,
0.26621776819229126,
0.9044508934020996,
0.08671563863754272,
0.4929470121860504,
-0.8155005574226379,
0.44689953327178955,
0.1467076539993286,
0.27354007959365845,
0.3598352074623108,
-0.34996771812438965,
-0.3694552183151245,
-0.05643605440855026,
-0.21129673719406128,
-1.3083704710006714,
0.03554778918623924,
-0.5355934500694275,
0.4172159433364868,
0.534977912902832,
0.14743535220623016,
0.4147182106971741,
-0.5531559586524963,
0.576448380947113,
0.40097054839134216,
-0.9095864295959473,
0.7917104363441467,
-0.5131369233131409,
0.20529884099960327,
0.460995078086853,
-0.03185371682047844,
-0.5617132782936096,
-0.7208549380302429,
-0.6363752484321594,
-0.7934075593948364,
0.6723145842552185,
-0.05803580954670906,
0.08359568566083908,
-0.20914509892463684,
0.3329829275608063,
-0.014184311032295227,
0.21081849932670593,
-0.8553465008735657,
-0.15130867063999176,
0.09081024676561356,
-0.054749082773923874,
-0.2378142923116684,
-0.07827457040548325,
-0.21054688096046448,
-0.2277560532093048,
0.5108330845832825,
0.04957851395010948,
0.004488719627261162,
0.03546183183789253,
-0.4014192819595337,
-0.1362091451883316,
0.3684902787208557,
0.3548974394798279,
0.6328468322753906,
-0.2925674319267273,
-0.1183246448636055,
0.05776035785675049,
-0.6609669923782349,
0.5900523066520691,
-0.4117903411388397,
-0.27398473024368286,
-0.41056153178215027,
0.3162316679954529,
0.7804521918296814,
0.03131018579006195,
-0.8244542479515076,
0.5403704047203064,
-0.043700411915779114,
-0.075925812125206,
-0.38500991463661194,
0.24435113370418549,
-0.041007451713085175,
0.513971745967865,
0.3444902300834656,
0.034403055906295776,
-0.3093143701553345,
-0.9861310720443726,
0.29282885789871216,
0.7719265818595886,
-0.378080278635025,
-0.06262321025133133,
0.6667903661727905,
0.06622225046157837,
-0.6695123314857483,
0.9408265948295593,
0.08288469165563583,
-0.4929109215736389,
0.632402777671814,
0.7906020879745483,
0.9954455494880676,
-0.0587405189871788,
0.27841421961784363,
0.10418972373008728,
0.8283476829528809,
-0.23198655247688293,
0.11940602213144302,
-0.15269681811332703,
-1.0754774808883667,
-0.37596073746681213,
-0.5652603507041931,
-0.35008567571640015,
0.2221340388059616,
-0.722715437412262,
0.05479242652654648,
-0.8806898593902588,
-0.1973884254693985,
-0.3641476333141327,
-0.35857394337654114,
-0.37550169229507446,
0.3275226354598999,
0.23651835322380066,
1.2340021133422852,
-0.6190330386161804,
0.8404110074043274,
0.5975873470306396,
-0.19144025444984436,
-0.9029026627540588,
0.30569660663604736,
0.2754439413547516,
-0.8905563950538635,
0.6228500008583069,
0.15706464648246765,
-0.04533642902970314,
-0.25238704681396484,
-0.8167365193367004,
-0.5921375155448914,
0.6301406621932983,
0.49826285243034363,
-0.7557259202003479,
-0.038417182862758636,
-0.03142077475786209,
0.17502284049987793,
-0.38366520404815674,
0.09098993241786957,
1.034657597541809,
0.7500892281532288,
-0.25019481778144836,
-0.6408079266548157,
0.39199939370155334,
-0.1689826250076294,
-0.3770928382873535,
0.6692720651626587,
-0.6776376366615295,
0.6245906949043274,
-0.8235948085784912,
0.2691079080104828,
0.08095531910657883,
0.15477444231510162,
0.4579693377017975,
0.22695091366767883,
0.663536548614502,
0.7382495999336243,
0.778455376625061,
-0.16098250448703766,
1.0571626424789429,
-0.37184813618659973,
-0.0020056816283613443,
1.0199798345565796,
-0.23304860293865204,
0.8388404846191406,
0.7068996429443359,
-0.19405214488506317,
0.5882944464683533,
0.4122738540172577,
-0.018357014283537865,
0.5736870169639587,
0.3107627332210541,
-0.26104027032852173,
-0.33950379490852356,
0.3025420308113098,
0.004599197767674923,
0.6825991272926331,
0.5211021900177002,
-0.2752854526042938,
-0.1276828497648239,
0.38219788670539856,
0.15766014158725739,
-0.0909409299492836,
-0.5263325572013855,
0.9944081902503967,
0.290261834859848,
-0.7123907804489136,
0.5275096297264099,
0.07400751858949661,
0.42109984159469604,
-0.7425776124000549,
0.19763454794883728,
0.058494023978710175,
0.13668793439865112,
-0.16077210009098053,
-0.9451351761817932,
-0.02616650052368641,
0.2646169662475586,
-0.21675437688827515,
-0.2438008338212967,
0.5377561450004578,
-0.04155654460191727,
-0.15063419938087463,
0.7788563370704651,
0.5400769710540771,
0.17502184212207794,
-0.25561773777008057,
-0.722258448600769,
0.27066585421562195,
0.09029701352119446,
-0.2437526285648346,
0.6874397993087769,
0.4621935486793518,
-0.09444243460893631,
0.7893355488777161,
0.8357896208763123,
0.2698501646518707,
-0.15802490711212158,
-0.20567823946475983,
0.6950321197509766,
-1.0900235176086426,
-0.5953075885772705,
-1.3713432550430298,
0.37185466289520264,
0.06127196550369263,
-0.0552193820476532,
0.6509581804275513,
0.2408227026462555,
0.8530190587043762,
0.08624660223722458,
0.9496215581893921,
-0.08845192193984985,
-0.08461278676986694,
-0.7849004864692688,
0.6229657530784607,
-0.2695392966270447,
0.700585126876831,
-0.4771534502506256,
-0.8844594359397888,
0.17896264791488647,
0.7650971412658691,
-0.5602991580963135,
-0.11080873012542725,
0.8858060240745544,
0.670187771320343,
0.23147627711296082,
0.09496302902698517,
0.33122238516807556,
0.5819998979568481,
0.33376967906951904,
0.6801614165306091,
0.8143025636672974,
-0.024810660630464554,
0.609637439250946,
-0.15889190137386322,
-0.4300002157688141,
-0.028769811615347862,
-0.5589843392372131,
-0.8805443644523621,
-0.29595911502838135,
-0.06819604337215424,
-0.6656963229179382,
0.07982531934976578,
0.9351585507392883,
0.4480647146701813,
-0.5210223197937012,
-0.6025623679161072,
-0.28345808386802673,
0.3123320937156677,
-0.22526851296424866,
-0.2495710700750351,
-0.07873674482107162,
-0.41839125752449036,
-0.12285081297159195,
0.5116878151893616,
0.5541263222694397,
-0.1296548843383789,
-0.18943597376346588,
-0.22754789888858795,
-0.2056383192539215,
0.22955740988254547,
0.4092569053173065,
0.14988647401332855,
-0.5806773900985718,
-0.26716557145118713,
-0.3977009952068329,
-0.11114856600761414,
0.13184314966201782,
0.9134621620178223,
-0.8441693186759949,
0.3436115086078644,
0.23896925151348114,
0.7005496025085449,
0.29605910181999207,
-0.034153394401073456,
0.7547310590744019,
-0.3957875072956085,
0.06145133450627327,
-0.11420151591300964,
0.4728929400444031,
0.1344028264284134,
-0.5026271939277649,
0.44666483998298645,
0.2947499752044678,
-0.6052383780479431,
-0.6181322336196899,
0.4345341920852661,
-0.6231976747512817,
-0.7346563935279846,
1.0770381689071655,
0.09387246519327164,
-0.5287937521934509,
-0.36343708634376526,
-0.403081476688385,
-0.08674174547195435,
-0.5691874027252197,
0.854803740978241,
1.043922781944275,
0.0027951556257903576,
-0.258495956659317,
-0.6711679697036743,
0.295053631067276,
0.1871340125799179,
-0.605709433555603,
0.3836919069290161,
0.47508418560028076,
0.4117356240749359,
0.21517707407474518,
0.6800262331962585,
-0.10719087719917297,
0.29215267300605774,
0.032139960676431656,
-0.1557883322238922,
0.0017820324283093214,
-0.2761577367782593,
-0.346637099981308,
0.1871679276227951,
0.15810012817382812,
0.14868122339248657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15663v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15663v1
|
Leveraging ChatGPT in Pharmacovigilance Event Extraction: An Empirical Study
| 2024-02-24T00:38:29 | 2024-02-24T00:38:29 |
Zhaoyue Sun, Gabriele Pergola, Byron C. Wallace, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the advent of large language models (LLMs), there has been growing
interest in exploring their potential for medical applications. This research
aims to investigate the ability of LLMs, specifically ChatGPT, in the context
of pharmacovigilance event extraction, of which the main goal is to identify
and extract adverse events or potential therapeutic events from textual medical
sources. We conduct extensive experiments to assess the performance of ChatGPT
in the pharmacovigilance event extraction task, employing various prompts and
demonstration selection strategies. The findings demonstrate that while ChatGPT
demonstrates reasonable performance with appropriate demonstration selection
strategies, it still falls short compared to fully fine-tuned small models.
Additionally, we explore the potential of leveraging ChatGPT for data
augmentation. However, our investigation reveals that the inclusion of
synthesized data into fine-tuning may lead to a decrease in performance,
possibly attributed to noise in the ChatGPT-generated labels. To mitigate this,
we explore different filtering strategies and find that, with the proper
approach, more stable performance can be achieved, although constant
improvement remains elusive.
|
[
-0.034398842602968216,
-0.85334712266922,
0.7647534012794495,
0.03667796403169632,
-0.4673212766647339,
-0.016510510817170143,
-0.42466163635253906,
-0.8002573251724243,
0.07755672186613083,
0.4549940228462219,
-0.4394741952419281,
-0.513637900352478,
-0.7260528802871704,
-0.04884815961122513,
-0.3022595942020416,
1.2621688842773438,
0.12798623740673065,
0.1554764211177826,
0.1430734395980835,
0.28870120644569397,
-0.568263590335846,
-0.7805957794189453,
-0.8945715427398682,
-0.6424300670623779,
0.6081346273422241,
0.34331008791923523,
0.35210511088371277,
0.37931936979293823,
0.8847500085830688,
0.0997551754117012,
-0.2883746922016144,
0.15147404372692108,
-0.5640843510627747,
0.18541984260082245,
0.09274730831384659,
-0.2999247610569,
-0.513231098651886,
-0.0011301386402919888,
0.5717688202857971,
0.40552398562431335,
-0.38655760884284973,
-0.030383970588445663,
0.2824435234069824,
0.4483613669872284,
-0.5496507883071899,
0.4650922417640686,
-0.5057738423347473,
0.21763169765472412,
-0.1388559490442276,
-0.19983990490436554,
-0.3353928029537201,
-0.3078386187553406,
0.6105158925056458,
-0.513785719871521,
0.06297057867050171,
0.1619824469089508,
0.7815223336219788,
0.07057398557662964,
-0.17341302335262299,
-0.3191138207912445,
-0.6620908975601196,
0.45755091309547424,
-0.80401211977005,
0.343801885843277,
0.22784192860126495,
0.29948410391807556,
-0.4614821672439575,
-1.074620246887207,
-0.34142395853996277,
-0.4527876079082489,
-0.14559033513069153,
0.28993552923202515,
-0.2108156532049179,
0.31503474712371826,
0.3084162771701813,
0.45767274498939514,
-0.5388429164886475,
0.2846706807613373,
-0.4257495403289795,
-0.36236047744750977,
0.2611873745918274,
0.27697518467903137,
0.41333046555519104,
-0.23438844084739685,
-0.3985152840614319,
0.030027661472558975,
-0.8292968273162842,
-0.07826615124940872,
-0.1503709852695465,
0.3208823800086975,
-0.04243069142103195,
0.787525475025177,
-0.0150161636993289,
0.386311799287796,
-0.27531296014785767,
-0.06466096639633179,
0.025083376094698906,
-0.42928963899612427,
-0.29110467433929443,
0.25573307275772095,
1.0516011714935303,
0.45681941509246826,
0.1586952656507492,
-0.08235536515712738,
-0.07336337864398956,
-0.1432240605354309,
0.042044833302497864,
-1.2287179231643677,
-0.8001611232757568,
0.27794381976127625,
-0.5786685347557068,
-0.551028311252594,
-0.19955965876579285,
-1.1083842515945435,
-0.5830219388008118,
-0.04672672227025032,
0.3968389928340912,
-0.7346015572547913,
-0.12293446809053421,
0.348103791475296,
-0.24910761415958405,
0.19635263085365295,
0.2001648247241974,
-0.8294780254364014,
0.2037862241268158,
0.6816498637199402,
0.8382146954536438,
-0.6229868531227112,
0.11356906592845917,
-0.5627826452255249,
0.08615456521511078,
-0.2640059292316437,
0.9378496408462524,
-0.4351392686367035,
-0.818458080291748,
-0.10829907655715942,
-0.10647670179605484,
-0.198300302028656,
-0.6575238108634949,
0.7516733407974243,
-0.3696984648704529,
0.10537503659725189,
-0.25425097346305847,
-0.6991032958030701,
0.05647457391023636,
0.1011863648891449,
-0.4267328083515167,
0.7642695307731628,
-0.2600332796573639,
-0.4423848092556,
0.5404357314109802,
-0.6909269094467163,
-0.5924652814865112,
0.2326565682888031,
-0.23400795459747314,
-0.7466375231742859,
0.07880006730556488,
0.442150354385376,
0.41485336422920227,
-0.21971282362937927,
0.1915401965379715,
-0.20049867033958435,
-0.2693098783493042,
0.7217086553573608,
-0.7361229062080383,
0.5037099719047546,
0.27831900119781494,
-0.06383750587701797,
-0.12846702337265015,
-0.7144606113433838,
-0.19418060779571533,
0.07601598650217056,
-0.6369167566299438,
-0.021937822923064232,
0.13045641779899597,
0.1989273577928543,
0.017077535390853882,
0.16444408893585205,
-0.6066285371780396,
0.2455957531929016,
-0.5021668672561646,
0.34030404686927795,
0.6043172478675842,
0.7311145663261414,
0.05066128447651863,
-0.2162516564130783,
0.4314137101173401,
-0.12010230869054794,
0.24733397364616394,
-0.1041048914194107,
-0.604232132434845,
-0.430125892162323,
-0.6069387197494507,
0.4669988751411438,
0.5922514796257019,
-0.5198873281478882,
0.19746536016464233,
-0.17776456475257874,
-0.264149934053421,
-0.11314230412244797,
0.015937814489006996,
0.2952306866645813,
0.5729979276657104,
0.20366284251213074,
-0.3651151955127716,
-0.5224542021751404,
-0.8892748951911926,
-0.36624959111213684,
-0.32918593287467957,
-0.19533857703208923,
0.3123973309993744,
0.1426161527633667,
-0.28082412481307983,
0.6629357933998108,
-0.910077691078186,
-0.28085169196128845,
-0.3428395688533783,
0.04363599792122841,
0.11443877965211868,
0.3013751208782196,
0.39211782813072205,
-0.468593031167984,
-0.2757815718650818,
0.24788349866867065,
-0.5672977566719055,
-0.5178937911987305,
-0.06305228173732758,
-0.09770000725984573,
-0.31017789244651794,
0.5238791704177856,
-0.6838201880455017,
0.5271276235580444,
0.36724230647087097,
0.04421206936240196,
0.550779402256012,
-0.17739155888557434,
0.1523105800151825,
-0.9062626957893372,
-0.18447814881801605,
0.19797301292419434,
-0.30495917797088623,
-0.7209600210189819,
-0.41784846782684326,
-0.09125237911939621,
-0.3065505623817444,
-0.45298999547958374,
0.39885076880455017,
-0.4044879376888275,
0.22379471361637115,
-0.3876347541809082,
0.020498888567090034,
0.012972359545528889,
0.32881319522857666,
0.14893768727779388,
0.623587429523468,
0.3794310986995697,
-0.49398329854011536,
0.17114953696727753,
0.2508167624473572,
-0.35797280073165894,
0.22117984294891357,
-0.709611713886261,
-0.2437695562839508,
0.1749906688928604,
0.03931557387113571,
-1.041225790977478,
-0.5374711751937866,
0.5769856572151184,
-0.2791491746902466,
0.4557788074016571,
-0.5792758464813232,
-0.5906169414520264,
-0.07416320592164993,
0.004783146549016237,
-0.08546141535043716,
0.9466016888618469,
-0.304869681596756,
0.3206334710121155,
0.6781031489372253,
-0.5243891477584839,
-0.07465259730815887,
-0.5367279648780823,
0.056615233421325684,
-0.3218209743499756,
-0.09869885444641113,
-0.019583798944950104,
0.19817517697811127,
-0.11669674515724182,
-0.3099600076675415,
-0.12782816588878632,
0.08808805048465729,
-0.10962428152561188,
0.40023118257522583,
0.5363438129425049,
-0.216989666223526,
0.36542201042175293,
-0.13824941217899323,
-0.08510094881057739,
0.21452191472053528,
-0.15111961960792542,
0.36904117465019226,
-0.0434207059442997,
-0.5898478627204895,
-0.5715427994728088,
0.28311941027641296,
0.3647412061691284,
-0.21367795765399933,
0.7303622961044312,
0.5970214605331421,
-0.24601975083351135,
-0.0003777134115807712,
-0.40358564257621765,
-0.601424515247345,
-0.45274844765663147,
0.3702857792377472,
0.11993979662656784,
-0.7187418341636658,
0.4565106928348541,
-0.2772093415260315,
-0.11132273823022842,
0.1879548579454422,
0.7794525027275085,
-0.13944144546985626,
0.8318420052528381,
0.1877899467945099,
0.14533036947250366,
1.0019925832748413,
0.14045342803001404,
0.30687323212623596,
-0.749850332736969,
-0.12898659706115723,
-0.18568666279315948,
0.01524113304913044,
-0.5755540132522583,
-0.32704243063926697,
0.9321349859237671,
-0.2637830972671509,
0.05116252973675728,
-0.07913294434547424,
-0.47965365648269653,
0.3862028419971466,
0.2693420648574829,
0.619128942489624,
0.3482910692691803,
0.2869834005832672,
0.15091240406036377,
-0.2602309286594391,
-0.777093768119812,
-0.3237673342227936,
1.2166181802749634,
0.3117980360984802,
0.7046073079109192,
0.051027461886405945,
0.31945788860321045,
0.08431103080511093,
0.31566232442855835,
-0.726175844669342,
0.5702335834503174,
-0.24268244206905365,
-0.43773889541625977,
-0.022630341351032257,
-0.34777528047561646,
-1.0744974613189697,
0.26216500997543335,
-0.4268876910209656,
-1.1164652109146118,
0.3094134032726288,
-0.053382039070129395,
-0.5378865003585815,
0.07829894125461578,
-1.1792494058609009,
0.8118243217468262,
-0.13232438266277313,
-0.27897751331329346,
0.05676330253481865,
-0.4526055157184601,
0.19473929703235626,
-0.2296730875968933,
-0.0007759091095067561,
-0.27397704124450684,
0.13196592032909393,
0.6180368661880493,
-0.3745400905609131,
1.162100911140442,
0.18650662899017334,
-0.0718979462981224,
0.3650718331336975,
-0.14419282972812653,
0.6286792159080505,
0.25437870621681213,
0.2362259030342102,
0.200935497879982,
0.10128778219223022,
-0.17834189534187317,
-0.5089434385299683,
0.5982375741004944,
-0.45461538434028625,
-0.4115777015686035,
-0.3224213719367981,
-0.3800613582134247,
-0.3024580180644989,
0.18057885766029358,
0.2822429835796356,
0.653588593006134,
-0.32495415210723877,
0.10183149576187134,
0.6548230648040771,
-0.3890129029750824,
0.27980878949165344,
0.6105967164039612,
-0.16353939473628998,
-0.23068460822105408,
0.9417694807052612,
0.17218388617038727,
0.3541085422039032,
0.25651848316192627,
0.36357542872428894,
-0.2077331393957138,
-0.8913574814796448,
-0.08718793094158173,
0.08708555996417999,
-0.6910818219184875,
0.047210000455379486,
-0.6549916863441467,
-0.2995486557483673,
-0.435360312461853,
0.2749045491218567,
-0.4444766342639923,
-0.4480847418308258,
-0.26404133439064026,
-0.2089107781648636,
0.7331852316856384,
0.4337489902973175,
-0.1064659059047699,
0.5942041277885437,
-0.9804601669311523,
0.3509460687637329,
0.2313690185546875,
0.2573552131652832,
-0.41514256596565247,
-0.20577803254127502,
-0.1401810497045517,
-0.021446311846375465,
-0.32030701637268066,
-1.0858933925628662,
0.4661196768283844,
0.2347641885280609,
0.6735490560531616,
0.23807424306869507,
-0.0716986134648323,
0.6124230027198792,
-0.43753913044929504,
0.8426187038421631,
0.044007107615470886,
-0.48382508754730225,
0.8676309585571289,
-0.6191802024841309,
0.14921976625919342,
0.35841572284698486,
-0.0017485662829130888,
-0.4948679506778717,
-0.4540131688117981,
-0.509494960308075,
-1.078877329826355,
0.37186479568481445,
0.579531192779541,
-0.27155429124832153,
-0.051129087805747986,
0.5370104908943176,
-0.07214479893445969,
0.003936362452805042,
-0.4800879955291748,
-0.15325060486793518,
0.46318525075912476,
-0.06194140762090683,
-0.03882788121700287,
-0.35137686133384705,
-0.22998161613941193,
0.03826047480106354,
0.6165048480033875,
0.04696011543273926,
0.33993664383888245,
0.509437084197998,
-0.029531968757510185,
0.2174931913614273,
0.48073822259902954,
0.2988736033439636,
0.4118146598339081,
-0.2827335596084595,
-0.15860411524772644,
0.26283353567123413,
-1.1052215099334717,
-0.2135067880153656,
0.5128633379936218,
-0.0021027035545557737,
-0.1722181886434555,
0.3886469006538391,
0.7296419143676758,
0.2467343807220459,
-1.031903624534607,
0.333143025636673,
-0.23146826028823853,
0.1288439780473709,
-0.09349135309457779,
0.23271529376506805,
-0.364520788192749,
0.47435668110847473,
0.33122196793556213,
-0.19072872400283813,
0.4228740632534027,
-0.29562461376190186,
0.40870407223701477,
0.431624174118042,
-0.45889270305633545,
-0.00763227604329586,
0.529708206653595,
-0.053673047572374344,
-0.09046302735805511,
0.41368618607521057,
0.2889343202114105,
-0.34320542216300964,
0.5093526840209961,
0.3304190933704376,
0.6447508931159973,
-0.013796713203191757,
0.045160889625549316,
0.1921585351228714,
0.30200472474098206,
0.052294228225946426,
0.021845754235982895,
0.24917219579219818,
-0.6816791892051697,
-0.519005298614502,
-0.4411272406578064,
-0.7160447835922241,
0.08969975262880325,
-0.581352174282074,
0.3167248070240021,
-0.11348991841077805,
-0.41381996870040894,
0.27368226647377014,
-0.06414743512868881,
-0.21479009091854095,
0.05934753268957138,
0.1930341124534607,
0.4820643961429596,
-0.7615243196487427,
0.6615470051765442,
0.5794650316238403,
-0.23239289224147797,
-0.8720799088478088,
0.06760769337415695,
0.17701388895511627,
-0.7069305777549744,
0.22155606746673584,
-0.16398078203201294,
0.22665822505950928,
-0.24509046971797943,
-0.330506831407547,
-0.43427157402038574,
0.9365214109420776,
0.24356189370155334,
-0.5891238451004028,
0.10617218911647797,
0.38353946805000305,
0.8553189039230347,
-0.2358318418264389,
0.047486111521720886,
0.8734279870986938,
0.25645747780799866,
0.29737553000450134,
-0.9481010437011719,
-0.1240156888961792,
-0.1776081770658493,
-0.21277469396591187,
0.13275305926799774,
-0.3418578803539276,
0.5491323471069336,
-0.09984782338142395,
-0.17003414034843445,
-0.15019184350967407,
0.1854289174079895,
0.41864269971847534,
0.2558143734931946,
0.09147567301988602,
0.12868720293045044,
0.7929592728614807,
-0.2213018238544464,
1.2641382217407227,
-0.1375582218170166,
0.3597811460494995,
0.9984942674636841,
-0.368546724319458,
0.852698028087616,
0.5465061068534851,
-0.2860983610153198,
0.06389310210943222,
0.8334817290306091,
0.02944096364080906,
0.7002651691436768,
-0.12326370179653168,
-0.6120505928993225,
-0.2569166421890259,
0.022134611383080482,
-0.40939655900001526,
0.2795007526874542,
0.9117902517318726,
-0.5600747466087341,
-0.184163436293602,
0.298280268907547,
-0.14231263101100922,
-0.6112805008888245,
-0.17981551587581635,
1.1313704252243042,
0.29823586344718933,
-0.565217912197113,
0.3254302144050598,
-0.4095157980918884,
0.002414217684417963,
-0.5884050130844116,
-0.10955596715211868,
0.023796148598194122,
0.45951977372169495,
0.01726655289530754,
-0.8322615623474121,
0.15629400312900543,
-0.07020588964223862,
0.1793755739927292,
0.06830321997404099,
1.2129026651382446,
-0.43095526099205017,
-0.4300336241722107,
-0.006738824769854546,
0.5329399108886719,
0.28699055314064026,
-0.10646788030862808,
-0.47443121671676636,
0.11939158290624619,
0.1058855652809143,
-0.45231136679649353,
0.5217827558517456,
0.596394419670105,
0.11932221800088882,
0.6042776107788086,
0.9274333119392395,
0.5876442790031433,
-0.004020055290311575,
-0.04409310221672058,
0.9244116544723511,
-0.26176100969314575,
-0.3210459053516388,
-1.1660544872283936,
0.3677659034729004,
-0.2322155386209488,
-0.07590677589178085,
0.7158393263816833,
0.5425359010696411,
-0.022450603544712067,
-0.031839769333601,
0.8013458847999573,
0.3826330006122589,
0.5417147278785706,
-0.7479363083839417,
0.7615171670913696,
-0.16480469703674316,
0.7164562940597534,
-0.1161903366446495,
-0.5162771940231323,
-0.4648287296295166,
0.3542691469192505,
-0.6024414896965027,
-0.32185742259025574,
0.46614354848861694,
0.891569972038269,
0.0439201295375824,
0.3021059036254883,
0.2032184898853302,
0.285798043012619,
0.6010250449180603,
0.5975176692008972,
0.8732882142066956,
-0.49102866649627686,
0.6656711101531982,
-0.0710214152932167,
-0.18152332305908203,
-0.32135602831840515,
-0.8951977491378784,
-0.9596627354621887,
-0.17800907790660858,
-0.3816714882850647,
-0.4661368131637573,
0.39461660385131836,
0.9699724912643433,
0.6247819066047668,
-0.7839134335517883,
0.33072254061698914,
0.021621348336338997,
0.00348752667196095,
-0.11106761544942856,
-0.19859877228736877,
0.3722725212574005,
-0.25087928771972656,
-0.4842531979084015,
0.3545381724834442,
0.40428006649017334,
0.4255583584308624,
0.19329409301280975,
0.2888498306274414,
0.20650479197502136,
-0.008994937874376774,
0.6693922281265259,
0.34428471326828003,
-0.32285797595977783,
-0.19473189115524292,
-0.10557503253221512,
-0.21623016893863678,
0.2096324861049652,
0.892997682094574,
-0.6648041605949402,
0.3910011947154999,
0.4185035228729248,
0.5756393671035767,
0.8600693941116333,
-0.10243253409862518,
0.7774111032485962,
-0.7341581583023071,
0.18051613867282867,
0.20750096440315247,
0.44318529963493347,
0.06673672050237656,
-0.49536269903182983,
0.48099538683891296,
0.14876995980739594,
-0.7967430353164673,
-0.7945082783699036,
0.03663700073957443,
-1.2288404703140259,
-0.11650212854146957,
1.5213571786880493,
0.004414285998791456,
-0.21093976497650146,
-0.23484955728054047,
-0.7156651616096497,
0.16253840923309326,
-0.4458965063095093,
0.7285899519920349,
0.7362719774246216,
-0.4618917405605316,
-0.4008338153362274,
-1.1831475496292114,
0.6870430111885071,
0.04550927132368088,
-0.8328401446342468,
0.2312571108341217,
0.5725275278091431,
0.3089597821235657,
-0.0028494521975517273,
0.7964772582054138,
-0.3583315312862396,
0.2927110195159912,
-0.07385150343179703,
-0.2140987664461136,
0.20454607903957367,
0.26873886585235596,
-0.30958080291748047,
0.14293044805526733,
0.05233624577522278,
-0.3067309260368347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00804v1
|
Uncovering Customer Issues through Topological Natural Language Analysis
| 2024-02-24T00:15:09 | 2024-02-24T00:15:09 |
Shu-Ting Pi, Sidarth Srinivasan, Yuying Zhu, Michael Yang, Qun Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
E-commerce companies deal with a high volume of customer service requests
daily. While a simple annotation system is often used to summarize the topics
of customer contacts, thoroughly exploring each specific issue can be
challenging. This presents a critical concern, especially during an emerging
outbreak where companies must quickly identify and address specific issues. To
tackle this challenge, we propose a novel machine learning algorithm that
leverages natural language techniques and topological data analysis to monitor
emerging and trending customer issues. Our approach involves an end-to-end deep
learning framework that simultaneously tags the primary question sentence of
each customer's transcript and generates sentence embedding vectors. We then
whiten the embedding vectors and use them to construct an undirected graph.
From there, we define trending and emerging issues based on the topological
properties of each transcript. We have validated our results through various
methods and found that they are highly consistent with news sources.
|
[
-0.36556461453437805,
-1.2760069370269775,
0.24501179158687592,
0.05516905337572098,
-0.35478153824806213,
0.5086130499839783,
-0.05171997845172882,
-0.8478371500968933,
0.4830358922481537,
0.5694097280502319,
-0.8951835036277771,
-0.54459148645401,
-0.4164033830165863,
0.26053956151008606,
-0.398326575756073,
1.1493879556655884,
0.2117251604795456,
-0.40801793336868286,
-0.19249317049980164,
-0.027867041528224945,
-0.4735015034675598,
-0.6524122357368469,
-0.8161846399307251,
0.030154382809996605,
0.33287331461906433,
0.784557580947876,
0.5240171551704407,
0.36675742268562317,
0.6901123523712158,
0.4016072750091553,
-0.17895889282226562,
0.43518152832984924,
-0.5363781452178955,
0.3840067684650421,
0.3905472457408905,
-0.0916476920247078,
-0.08164660632610321,
-0.3064848482608795,
0.5006892085075378,
0.835543692111969,
-0.17216245830059052,
0.3128100633621216,
0.10225802659988403,
0.7266746759414673,
-0.09311522543430328,
-0.04123562201857567,
-0.6884223818778992,
0.30474719405174255,
-0.1077682375907898,
-0.26864686608314514,
-0.13754959404468536,
-0.4880448281764984,
0.6258065104484558,
-0.6925031542778015,
0.22378027439117432,
0.15086819231510162,
1.067978024482727,
0.36601540446281433,
-0.6077109575271606,
-0.38435646891593933,
-0.8417089581489563,
0.3476179242134094,
-0.2943395674228668,
0.47001105546951294,
0.3049476146697998,
0.41702792048454285,
-0.3548471927642822,
-0.6662431359291077,
-0.23984451591968536,
0.1385267674922943,
-0.4400283098220825,
-0.1356053352355957,
-0.49249768257141113,
-0.5465744733810425,
0.05220278725028038,
0.21060298383235931,
-0.5982721447944641,
0.23363618552684784,
-0.6508527398109436,
-0.07461005449295044,
0.6543490886688232,
0.23653928935527802,
0.36103111505508423,
-0.23147711157798767,
-0.38361021876335144,
0.3197314739227295,
-0.1482376903295517,
0.32824668288230896,
0.3110046982765198,
0.2626754343509674,
-0.13847285509109497,
0.34180858731269836,
-0.2379624992609024,
0.5455731749534607,
0.12871672213077545,
0.47912299633026123,
0.3453773856163025,
0.12061555683612823,
-0.3316170871257782,
0.2868490517139435,
0.6193884015083313,
0.23948566615581512,
0.22565975785255432,
-0.26271945238113403,
0.16509385406970978,
-0.36358559131622314,
0.5858417749404907,
-0.5350514650344849,
-0.37674376368522644,
0.5802953243255615,
-0.2652064561843872,
-0.35115349292755127,
0.30832329392433167,
-1.259953498840332,
-0.746467113494873,
-0.5824249386787415,
-0.24612009525299072,
-0.13948173820972443,
-0.3038784861564636,
-0.15787488222122192,
-0.11886052787303925,
0.07863076776266098,
0.1455588936805725,
-0.46560508012771606,
0.43622714281082153,
0.995267391204834,
0.9126707315444946,
-0.167881578207016,
0.22035753726959229,
-0.5569860935211182,
0.11118064820766449,
-0.3862319588661194,
0.885225236415863,
-0.5268706679344177,
-0.06070704013109207,
0.14402781426906586,
0.17163392901420593,
0.2042924165725708,
-0.573462963104248,
0.6738417744636536,
-0.3415611982345581,
0.17862319946289062,
0.10763945430517197,
-0.45648929476737976,
-0.23039986193180084,
0.7147399187088013,
-0.5852172374725342,
0.9156812429428101,
0.10454042255878448,
-0.8886865973472595,
0.27915918827056885,
-0.47452831268310547,
-0.35703930258750916,
0.4026149809360504,
-0.22218739986419678,
-1.1104447841644287,
0.05535394325852394,
0.3408316671848297,
0.5823873281478882,
-0.14840155839920044,
0.3427695035934448,
-0.4078097641468048,
-0.11773043870925903,
0.30296504497528076,
0.21263965964317322,
0.8022679686546326,
0.2576517164707184,
-0.33390772342681885,
0.1817602664232254,
-0.7130157351493835,
-0.2251286506652832,
0.37650710344314575,
0.07676717638969421,
-0.32362106442451477,
0.04960307106375694,
0.15600618720054626,
-0.033787526190280914,
0.10259944945573807,
-0.4255722463130951,
0.23066829144954681,
-0.43129605054855347,
0.32065093517303467,
0.8471821546554565,
0.45297735929489136,
0.14822621643543243,
-0.2022012323141098,
0.43788373470306396,
0.13587087392807007,
0.23118118941783905,
-0.08764312416315079,
-0.9094612002372742,
-0.8744245767593384,
-0.21604618430137634,
-0.12592542171478271,
0.5928763151168823,
-0.4705544412136078,
0.49169522523880005,
-0.3956345021724701,
-0.5324236750602722,
-0.2058495283126831,
0.13234539330005646,
-0.04708883911371231,
0.5377181768417358,
0.3061596751213074,
-0.10533391684293747,
-0.6073008179664612,
-0.8572248816490173,
-0.5281573534011841,
0.19434845447540283,
0.03817383199930191,
0.6178057193756104,
0.047292228788137436,
-0.5874761343002319,
1.2311939001083374,
-0.943257212638855,
-0.4424722194671631,
-0.16361305117607117,
0.45771124958992004,
0.4485416114330292,
0.46703118085861206,
0.2278628945350647,
-1.1277559995651245,
-0.6135965585708618,
0.5194824934005737,
-0.6553422808647156,
-0.0668426901102066,
-0.32694458961486816,
0.01991402916610241,
0.31755906343460083,
0.5407392382621765,
-0.2743057608604431,
0.44312727451324463,
0.20348219573497772,
-0.4647492468357086,
0.25631412863731384,
-0.20425572991371155,
-0.15400776267051697,
-1.178254246711731,
-0.022977188229560852,
0.4225229024887085,
-0.17734621465206146,
-0.9979161620140076,
-0.3452472388744354,
-0.28508278727531433,
-0.7106446027755737,
-0.12107069790363312,
0.2147371470928192,
-0.2065287083387375,
-0.21350233256816864,
0.12624579668045044,
0.0694752186536789,
0.023908119648694992,
0.5306463837623596,
-0.1374901980161667,
0.0430290512740612,
0.44711485505104065,
-0.7494459748268127,
0.47275543212890625,
0.4732265770435333,
-0.2725015878677368,
0.3000209331512451,
-0.5878635048866272,
0.36254456639289856,
-0.11508199572563171,
0.17570725083351135,
-0.9250106811523438,
-0.16046273708343506,
0.6333417296409607,
-0.7481476664543152,
0.16620922088623047,
-0.303346186876297,
-0.3333081901073456,
-0.5128064155578613,
0.055953674018383026,
0.26955997943878174,
0.4122377336025238,
-0.4012618958950043,
0.6655625700950623,
0.48090115189552307,
-0.32876017689704895,
-0.15030112862586975,
-0.5213751196861267,
0.25910094380378723,
-0.5408690571784973,
-0.6790328025817871,
-0.06155173480510712,
0.3482632040977478,
-0.10527597367763519,
-0.09597539156675339,
-0.035203926265239716,
-0.5124319195747375,
0.5367697477340698,
0.12515002489089966,
0.011787810362875462,
-0.11050325632095337,
0.2747805714607239,
-0.3827594816684723,
-0.4346323311328888,
0.3662787675857544,
-0.8292018175125122,
0.5018077492713928,
-0.09182726591825485,
-0.036528728902339935,
-0.6245712041854858,
0.532447338104248,
0.308473140001297,
-0.4468371570110321,
0.32360154390335083,
0.7501497864723206,
-0.6714028716087341,
-0.3229198157787323,
-0.35199788212776184,
-0.02329959347844124,
-0.5520802736282349,
0.2538864314556122,
-0.014631712809205055,
-0.7002713680267334,
0.45612388849258423,
-0.39437052607536316,
-0.05601871386170387,
0.4274318218231201,
0.3155044913291931,
-0.2898303270339966,
0.8769806027412415,
0.9602342247962952,
-0.04901371896266937,
0.28078892827033997,
-0.36151808500289917,
0.9109603762626648,
-0.4382111430168152,
-0.6873288750648499,
-0.7232719659805298,
-0.595328688621521,
-1.0273932218551636,
-0.15857350826263428,
0.46126192808151245,
0.1346803903579712,
-0.02848595567047596,
0.35814574360847473,
-0.5700411200523376,
0.052587997168302536,
0.34857773780822754,
0.07363571971654892,
0.1416132003068924,
0.24908725917339325,
-0.1952415257692337,
0.050659727305173874,
-0.34503424167633057,
-0.3116491436958313,
0.5514322519302368,
0.5005025267601013,
0.39632147550582886,
0.35991841554641724,
0.5722323060035706,
0.4116241931915283,
-0.07390253990888596,
-0.7780973315238953,
0.11710739135742188,
-0.17250728607177734,
-0.25428298115730286,
-0.29343295097351074,
-0.7027184367179871,
-1.1446151733398438,
-0.21915288269519806,
-0.3824005424976349,
-1.1986829042434692,
0.4216703772544861,
0.034829024225473404,
-0.20940957963466644,
0.3299688696861267,
-0.5917958617210388,
0.9206151366233826,
-0.38350093364715576,
-0.16882281005382538,
0.11601295322179794,
-0.5497720241546631,
0.02951565943658352,
-0.11908140033483505,
0.34766292572021484,
-0.10422635078430176,
0.24111603200435638,
0.6334787607192993,
-0.13996334373950958,
0.8788129687309265,
0.06906956434249878,
-0.059369612485170364,
0.1171383261680603,
0.035232316702604294,
0.6443966627120972,
0.2920655310153961,
0.2997022569179535,
0.1308060884475708,
-0.2575266659259796,
-0.6048721075057983,
-0.5843080878257751,
0.2883835732936859,
-0.6371724009513855,
-0.39686205983161926,
-0.5062808990478516,
-0.15445654094219208,
-0.5968633890151978,
0.1841726303100586,
0.014628047123551369,
0.5005924105644226,
-0.2868490219116211,
0.2136956751346588,
0.6188933253288269,
-0.2787737548351288,
0.43859604001045227,
0.1341758370399475,
-0.27616116404533386,
-0.18652018904685974,
1.2131836414337158,
-0.1389201134443283,
-0.21567441523075104,
0.26965096592903137,
0.5936200618743896,
-0.015291798859834671,
-0.5355669260025024,
-0.40740472078323364,
-0.01032072864472866,
-0.40810954570770264,
-0.1853594034910202,
-1.079326868057251,
-0.08635842055082321,
-0.5771806240081787,
-0.06911207735538483,
-0.08277174085378647,
-0.14274658262729645,
-0.44389957189559937,
-0.11277623474597931,
0.5393103957176208,
1.109989047050476,
0.38189688324928284,
0.22324562072753906,
-1.1569255590438843,
0.44904229044914246,
0.30711016058921814,
0.48486560583114624,
-0.17242226004600525,
-0.06504597514867783,
-0.3834608197212219,
0.1026327908039093,
-0.4039599895477295,
-0.883195698261261,
0.5846393704414368,
0.11938133090734482,
0.39571380615234375,
0.7039451003074646,
0.15212252736091614,
0.6574327349662781,
-0.401707261800766,
0.5992110371589661,
0.20989957451820374,
-0.9069879651069641,
0.6167682409286499,
-0.5414573550224304,
0.009869434870779514,
0.31649115681648254,
0.849801242351532,
-1.1420248746871948,
-0.2975916564464569,
-0.7392755746841431,
-1.0196075439453125,
0.5393992066383362,
0.2200729250907898,
0.14114703238010406,
-0.0879116803407669,
0.3431718051433563,
-0.062199875712394714,
0.09942827373743057,
-0.4749360978603363,
-0.348549485206604,
-0.05095420032739639,
-0.22171291708946228,
0.025459036231040955,
-0.19658532738685608,
0.008065279573202133,
-0.3593272864818573,
0.3400176167488098,
-0.2793177366256714,
0.19256964325904846,
0.2654220461845398,
-0.004429166205227375,
-0.15851202607154846,
0.15390722453594208,
0.5760136246681213,
0.7012155652046204,
-0.22453874349594116,
-0.31661975383758545,
0.10967129468917847,
-0.45222368836402893,
-0.37672004103660583,
0.207783505320549,
-0.05634789168834686,
0.15521863102912903,
0.16255004703998566,
0.5359516739845276,
-0.015639694407582283,
-0.5405985713005066,
0.5308679342269897,
-0.11684441566467285,
-0.26549625396728516,
-0.7532885670661926,
-0.5709911584854126,
-0.1282423734664917,
0.25114014744758606,
0.6749054789543152,
-0.09516973793506622,
0.5492983460426331,
-0.5865967869758606,
0.642192006111145,
0.3500352203845978,
-1.0986690521240234,
-0.09873021394014359,
-0.011925815604627132,
0.423407644033432,
-0.57485032081604,
0.899718165397644,
-0.17678286135196686,
-1.0833609104156494,
1.008157730102539,
0.4346291422843933,
1.1433112621307373,
-0.011347885243594646,
0.37182316184043884,
0.026724375784397125,
0.4211871325969696,
0.7143137454986572,
0.0853816419839859,
0.3236672878265381,
-0.4121875762939453,
-0.09933639317750931,
-0.3561728298664093,
-0.39549627900123596,
-0.06546025723218918,
-0.8048456311225891,
0.5571032166481018,
-0.536177396774292,
0.20835216343402863,
-0.0746641457080841,
0.26537859439849854,
-0.651171863079071,
0.35495632886886597,
0.3261376917362213,
0.5796335339546204,
-0.8758332133293152,
0.4984127879142761,
0.5713505744934082,
0.05190907046198845,
-0.5226235389709473,
0.09620863199234009,
0.3051149249076843,
-0.5911825299263,
0.7121884226799011,
0.6885342597961426,
0.13670814037322998,
-0.26078513264656067,
-0.23032338917255402,
-0.7651808261871338,
0.9571803212165833,
-0.16992469131946564,
-0.5279346108436584,
0.3019586503505707,
0.4309479892253876,
0.49344685673713684,
-0.6629638075828552,
-0.053007982671260834,
0.5622943639755249,
0.3848051428794861,
-0.020704593509435654,
-0.43618035316467285,
-0.09183147549629211,
-0.5059248208999634,
-0.3781866431236267,
0.6951462030410767,
-0.40645110607147217,
0.6041969656944275,
0.03479713574051857,
-0.4829721748828888,
-0.41289088129997253,
0.598829984664917,
-0.37524810433387756,
0.7552571892738342,
0.6479386687278748,
0.8454999327659607,
1.214219093322754,
-0.20970188081264496,
0.9411062002182007,
0.08542433381080627,
0.4559496343135834,
1.1297472715377808,
-0.10711356997489929,
0.5830536484718323,
0.30942830443382263,
0.17287790775299072,
0.6062182784080505,
0.9052322506904602,
-0.35550442337989807,
0.25879594683647156,
0.7071694135665894,
0.1766684204339981,
-0.13234484195709229,
-0.3169318437576294,
-0.3350107669830322,
0.5438515543937683,
0.5044880509376526,
-0.01336624100804329,
-0.14546969532966614,
-0.12102068215608597,
-0.1994519978761673,
-0.021920690312981606,
-0.17790862917900085,
1.248769760131836,
-0.08748169243335724,
-0.11669661849737167,
0.27497655153274536,
-0.2414681762456894,
0.2368449568748474,
-0.27156999707221985,
-0.17006921768188477,
-0.2241576761007309,
0.10974667221307755,
-0.4095301032066345,
-0.31326210498809814,
0.6533371806144714,
0.004943788517266512,
0.2230277806520462,
-0.06168852746486664,
0.40239760279655457,
-0.21611171960830688,
-0.8593706488609314,
0.4486515522003174,
0.3860056400299072,
-0.007419613655656576,
-0.0937475860118866,
-0.8007736206054688,
-0.13357383012771606,
-0.02443527616560459,
0.0015747082652524114,
-0.14507409930229187,
0.7362968325614929,
-0.09107164293527603,
0.7263008952140808,
0.8133628964424133,
-0.21145138144493103,
0.10680835694074631,
-0.09324251860380173,
1.0052257776260376,
-0.717927098274231,
-0.8076910376548767,
-0.6906073689460754,
0.7441120743751526,
-0.6963531374931335,
-0.645504891872406,
0.563839852809906,
0.5145389437675476,
0.5876680016517639,
0.3864867389202118,
0.46320822834968567,
0.3369467258453369,
0.6912059187889099,
-0.3732089698314667,
0.5209704041481018,
-0.5379807949066162,
0.4550562798976898,
-0.31546175479888916,
-0.7773591876029968,
-0.4218135476112366,
0.22434589266777039,
-0.2980074882507324,
-0.3606605529785156,
0.8975505828857422,
0.2474966049194336,
-0.17945972084999084,
0.3590053617954254,
-0.11558106541633606,
0.29886507987976074,
0.5431585907936096,
0.3429234027862549,
0.9215908050537109,
-0.18872922658920288,
0.7129071950912476,
-0.4984050691127777,
-0.057425785809755325,
-0.42287999391555786,
-1.0132763385772705,
-0.8837953209877014,
-0.5290811657905579,
-0.4545641839504242,
-0.1895843893289566,
-0.003925353288650513,
0.927457332611084,
0.6206842064857483,
-0.9706736207008362,
-0.14875860512256622,
-0.25337985157966614,
0.32258063554763794,
-0.20860330760478973,
-0.2651337683200836,
0.4416842758655548,
-0.6960430145263672,
-0.36681368947029114,
-0.006095954217016697,
0.3247891962528229,
-0.03228543698787689,
-0.11681794375181198,
0.33478912711143494,
-0.36939525604248047,
-0.2194107174873352,
0.24233847856521606,
0.06282797455787659,
-0.4478079080581665,
-0.18906225264072418,
0.2469860464334488,
0.1653839647769928,
0.1646176278591156,
1.1987731456756592,
-0.6267575621604919,
0.29155781865119934,
0.3714279532432556,
1.3817557096481323,
0.5924006700515747,
0.07256808131933212,
0.7612865567207336,
-0.9458143711090088,
-0.08113917708396912,
0.5265514254570007,
0.27456116676330566,
0.45813843607902527,
-1.0018237829208374,
0.37227699160575867,
0.1832370162010193,
-0.3363269865512848,
-0.5246340036392212,
0.4245634377002716,
-0.938127338886261,
-0.5993877649307251,
0.8425509929656982,
-0.08836471289396286,
-0.19841846823692322,
-0.7240233421325684,
0.022147994488477707,
0.17810703814029694,
-0.20158807933330536,
0.8987483382225037,
0.38122788071632385,
-0.11614294350147247,
-0.16404838860034943,
-0.4968969225883484,
0.4687308371067047,
0.3430374264717102,
-1.1011302471160889,
0.04046578332781792,
0.3469490110874176,
-0.13575038313865662,
0.4276721477508545,
0.1303342878818512,
0.412263423204422,
0.07110752910375595,
-0.5504937171936035,
-0.6153998374938965,
0.002530121710151434,
-0.6165962815284729,
-0.44211098551750183,
0.21173124015331268,
-0.41960179805755615,
-0.08829349279403687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15654v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15654v1
|
Exploring Failure Cases in Multimodal Reasoning About Physical Dynamics
| 2024-02-24T00:01:01 | 2024-02-24T00:01:01 |
Sadaf Ghaffari, Nikhil Krishnaswamy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we present an exploration of LLMs' abilities to problem solve
with physical reasoning in situated environments. We construct a simple
simulated environment and demonstrate examples of where, in a zero-shot
setting, both text and multimodal LLMs display atomic world knowledge about
various objects but fail to compose this knowledge in correct solutions for an
object manipulation and placement task. We also use BLIP, a vision-language
model trained with more sophisticated cross-modal attention, to identify cases
relevant to object physical properties that that model fails to ground.
Finally, we present a procedure for discovering the relevant properties of
objects in the environment and propose a method to distill this knowledge back
into the LLM.
|
[
-0.38748133182525635,
-1.1391233205795288,
1.1877281665802002,
0.1385212242603302,
0.008945249952375889,
0.18920347094535828,
0.08796419203281403,
-0.3400455117225647,
-0.06961888819932938,
-0.014144081622362137,
-0.8726486563682556,
-0.4507906138896942,
-0.40068694949150085,
0.14241047203540802,
-0.101560577750206,
0.6368629932403564,
-0.4197525084018707,
-0.13847123086452484,
-0.6236302852630615,
-0.14857032895088196,
-0.7294402122497559,
-0.6781003475189209,
-0.05340021103620529,
-0.4613337516784668,
0.4008721709251404,
0.5909733176231384,
0.5132425427436829,
0.22781838476657867,
0.6060553789138794,
0.29848283529281616,
-0.16145440936088562,
0.46439629793167114,
-0.26215195655822754,
0.19228672981262207,
-0.3901471793651581,
-0.6320366859436035,
-0.03897160664200783,
0.01579677127301693,
0.6009294390678406,
0.8918336629867554,
-0.02081201784312725,
-0.20780998468399048,
-0.25107961893081665,
0.11266031116247177,
-0.6431639790534973,
0.06663009524345398,
-0.5899028182029724,
0.6820902824401855,
0.14554421603679657,
-0.4794144332408905,
-0.35175785422325134,
0.29372701048851013,
0.003560034092515707,
-0.7485946416854858,
0.32321280241012573,
0.37197497487068176,
0.8615432977676392,
0.5317709445953369,
-0.8911447525024414,
-0.26246562600135803,
-0.9466277956962585,
1.0647923946380615,
-0.13281124830245972,
0.5361024737358093,
0.2062763273715973,
0.38978344202041626,
-0.3694951832294464,
-0.19023258984088898,
-0.6451651453971863,
-0.3303429186344147,
0.2071382999420166,
0.38817885518074036,
0.30387523770332336,
0.0039686826057732105,
0.35489922761917114,
0.108628049492836,
-0.3853384256362915,
-0.19663827121257782,
-0.339853972196579,
-0.25915464758872986,
0.28906989097595215,
0.4935322701931,
0.2588183879852295,
-0.32964032888412476,
-0.7239267230033875,
-0.31220129132270813,
-0.5619483590126038,
0.11121676862239838,
-0.022642336785793304,
0.04287707805633545,
-0.11472612619400024,
0.9559813141822815,
-0.0012423851294443011,
0.6289301514625549,
-0.09218694269657135,
-0.6487153768539429,
0.16439460217952728,
-0.5329723358154297,
-0.22468352317810059,
0.0270631555467844,
0.33939874172210693,
0.5750378370285034,
0.08386823534965515,
0.08175715804100037,
-0.10661102086305618,
-0.11793936043977737,
0.3913884162902832,
-0.24523857235908508,
0.06605083495378494,
0.4959344267845154,
-0.5598416924476624,
-0.0070185186341404915,
-0.15500739216804504,
-0.4034699499607086,
-0.3496478796005249,
-0.42550620436668396,
0.6122811436653137,
-0.5726725459098816,
-0.2884826064109802,
0.18683354556560516,
-0.38392481207847595,
0.06085294485092163,
0.5706467032432556,
-0.6314262747764587,
-0.25818076729774475,
0.47945138812065125,
0.9368895292282104,
0.027515579015016556,
-0.7421211004257202,
-0.18989959359169006,
0.5660494565963745,
-0.3920592665672302,
1.0014722347259521,
-0.16836638748645782,
-0.5521388053894043,
-0.014838991686701775,
0.22632384300231934,
-0.07048314809799194,
-0.6048898696899414,
0.2902544140815735,
-0.15440349280834198,
-0.07276366651058197,
-0.34356051683425903,
-0.26302263140678406,
-0.3146907091140747,
0.8289827108383179,
-0.4579828083515167,
0.7331283092498779,
-0.1405518352985382,
-0.7523980736732483,
0.5341371893882751,
-0.5479625463485718,
-0.5565105080604553,
-0.22828112542629242,
-0.21902424097061157,
-0.34246018528938293,
0.398933082818985,
-0.155947744846344,
0.5758368968963623,
0.22639159858226776,
0.07536284625530243,
-0.6366952061653137,
-0.3591582775115967,
0.5225452780723572,
-0.45226219296455383,
0.35668766498565674,
-0.08816087245941162,
-0.23447242379188538,
-0.14223608374595642,
-0.7790526747703552,
-0.25204023718833923,
0.23200839757919312,
-0.3496316373348236,
-0.3224661946296692,
0.3748779892921448,
0.1460210531949997,
0.4511565566062927,
0.40804699063301086,
-0.4556581974029541,
0.2618376314640045,
-0.037336308509111404,
0.15452177822589874,
0.5899655222892761,
0.17319123446941376,
0.26426541805267334,
-0.4270433783531189,
0.45377859473228455,
0.4435989558696747,
0.1635926365852356,
-0.37494444847106934,
-0.4374202787876129,
-0.7853206992149353,
0.1702975332736969,
-0.5098118185997009,
0.669540524482727,
-1.013944387435913,
-0.32379189133644104,
0.13401491940021515,
-0.16237948834896088,
0.10202998667955399,
0.1851811558008194,
0.5740147829055786,
0.6403219699859619,
0.3775261640548706,
-0.03793729096651077,
-0.41578492522239685,
-0.855789065361023,
0.1095370501279831,
-0.15054620802402496,
0.11947435140609741,
0.7296262979507446,
0.594783365726471,
-0.43983739614486694,
0.8004059791564941,
-0.3632653057575226,
-0.35389551520347595,
-0.12592105567455292,
0.22799481451511383,
0.104730524122715,
0.15555010735988617,
0.4101019501686096,
-0.7635444402694702,
0.16286982595920563,
0.23279960453510284,
-1.4057515859603882,
0.07205568999052048,
-0.19803856313228607,
0.09415458887815475,
0.39294397830963135,
0.534390926361084,
-0.6736244559288025,
0.404793918132782,
0.4999034106731415,
-0.5751115083694458,
0.7759836912155151,
-0.37278738617897034,
0.2435137927532196,
-0.893570601940155,
-0.1589614599943161,
0.37979552149772644,
-0.15947166085243225,
-0.3537505269050598,
0.0425751656293869,
-0.33749818801879883,
-0.24953314661979675,
-1.0149649381637573,
0.6586633324623108,
-0.7895098328590393,
-0.45609015226364136,
-0.2635188102722168,
0.4459642767906189,
-0.051206111907958984,
0.46716293692588806,
0.2846928536891937,
0.4806731641292572,
0.5076475739479065,
-0.7595657706260681,
0.7223291397094727,
0.18669363856315613,
-0.08139166980981827,
1.042441487312317,
-0.5287171602249146,
-0.11758031696081161,
-0.2793658375740051,
-0.11622152477502823,
-1.0608899593353271,
-0.5061566829681396,
0.07305838167667389,
-0.23283420503139496,
0.19342385232448578,
-0.35634246468544006,
-0.5807106494903564,
-0.2798980176448822,
-0.28287553787231445,
0.5756458044052124,
-0.10738915950059891,
-0.418150395154953,
0.6714465022087097,
0.28392356634140015,
0.10163778066635132,
-0.42205581068992615,
-0.9241856336593628,
-0.05194820463657379,
-0.3116072416305542,
-0.5480633974075317,
-0.01339829619973898,
-0.3567330837249756,
-0.5996643900871277,
0.019705165177583694,
-0.09143059700727463,
-0.06836327165365219,
0.3356018662452698,
0.5139639973640442,
0.1074872836470604,
-0.062269698828458786,
0.24105656147003174,
0.04129701107740402,
-0.11931894719600677,
0.21239089965820312,
0.296627402305603,
0.330752968788147,
-0.3648265600204468,
-0.9879852533340454,
-0.4364885687828064,
0.3361971080303192,
0.7348952889442444,
0.3740663230419159,
0.5911756753921509,
0.2535509169101715,
-0.4999203681945801,
-0.1540573090314865,
-0.3323289453983307,
-0.17708027362823486,
-0.45601868629455566,
0.4268844723701477,
-0.6001302003860474,
-0.6445450186729431,
0.5224043726921082,
-0.16492173075675964,
-0.12413886934518814,
0.025328783318400383,
0.7580674886703491,
-0.5610738396644592,
0.9938639402389526,
0.7536202669143677,
0.34864431619644165,
0.38113313913345337,
-0.28021615743637085,
0.2493518888950348,
-0.8591824769973755,
-0.8553594946861267,
-0.05856037884950638,
-0.5040184259414673,
-0.1358610987663269,
-0.7124657034873962,
0.9025254845619202,
0.1405247002840042,
-0.25908875465393066,
0.08813747018575668,
-0.2952914237976074,
0.430186927318573,
0.48010459542274475,
0.2484131157398224,
0.48280641436576843,
0.0899866446852684,
-0.542509913444519,
-0.09583371132612228,
-0.8473835587501526,
-0.48017340898513794,
0.7874040007591248,
0.35612544417381287,
0.8839601278305054,
0.24343101680278778,
0.46907395124435425,
-0.0710563138127327,
0.161121666431427,
-0.919337272644043,
0.6008161306381226,
0.3974014222621918,
-0.760538637638092,
-0.40293407440185547,
-0.3395273685455322,
-0.8560529947280884,
0.2729911506175995,
-0.19692669808864594,
-0.6200700402259827,
-0.053467538207769394,
0.248373880982399,
-0.21861298382282257,
0.23986656963825226,
-0.7108628153800964,
0.9896110892295837,
-0.6483964323997498,
-0.5465509295463562,
-0.1649836301803589,
-0.4692135751247406,
0.6287692189216614,
0.22579339146614075,
0.5314001441001892,
-0.22528034448623657,
-0.02166401967406273,
0.15667012333869934,
-0.24902497231960297,
0.9209834337234497,
-0.08016496896743774,
-0.2085050493478775,
0.44660964608192444,
0.5648301243782043,
-0.0041264733299613,
0.25518450140953064,
0.22086569666862488,
0.18639980256557465,
0.019541064277291298,
-0.32311147451400757,
-0.6693598628044128,
0.6261394619941711,
-0.6711807250976562,
-0.5199792981147766,
-0.574934184551239,
-0.7946356534957886,
-0.31150251626968384,
0.0033398307859897614,
0.09698240458965302,
0.5084810853004456,
0.05241338908672333,
0.13361622393131256,
0.8576850891113281,
-0.1548083871603012,
0.7919632196426392,
0.5493443608283997,
-0.35669106245040894,
-0.07773858308792114,
0.8002814054489136,
0.19814476370811462,
0.1318783462047577,
0.27268102765083313,
-0.017582058906555176,
-0.36843982338905334,
-0.346553236246109,
-0.47907426953315735,
0.1043868213891983,
-0.9232861399650574,
-0.19538186490535736,
-0.4095109701156616,
-0.14696353673934937,
0.2160109430551529,
-0.35716700553894043,
-0.20299841463565826,
-0.24339576065540314,
-0.28153467178344727,
-0.2510972023010254,
0.28840234875679016,
0.7072511315345764,
-0.19420775771141052,
-0.017301082611083984,
-0.9401075839996338,
0.2796938121318817,
0.34109029173851013,
0.2088753879070282,
0.005310400389134884,
-0.43869155645370483,
-0.27190250158309937,
0.08222752064466476,
-0.5979225039482117,
-0.8441258072853088,
0.24999046325683594,
-0.013096742331981659,
0.9090449810028076,
0.3562367260456085,
-0.2646137773990631,
0.650050163269043,
-0.5494899153709412,
0.8619475960731506,
0.20635056495666504,
-0.886971116065979,
1.0017588138580322,
-0.4795912206172943,
0.36341774463653564,
0.24826142191886902,
0.5978595614433289,
-0.3679013252258301,
-0.3033909797668457,
-0.451026976108551,
-0.6829795837402344,
0.3861161470413208,
-0.034145455807447433,
0.03264962136745453,
-0.21497035026550293,
0.4259129464626312,
-0.12535187602043152,
0.15166075527668,
-0.9569982886314392,
-0.2425450086593628,
-0.19582299888134003,
-0.10416846722364426,
-0.07163795828819275,
-0.22065111994743347,
-0.3673279583454132,
-0.06456852704286575,
0.3798483908176422,
-0.4052968919277191,
0.36045244336128235,
0.5351382493972778,
-0.30469006299972534,
-0.20117665827274323,
-0.10096830874681473,
1.1054120063781738,
0.7347208857536316,
-0.14151763916015625,
0.49915048480033875,
0.31994393467903137,
-0.07609202712774277,
0.3733968734741211,
-0.3031880259513855,
0.126181498169899,
-0.07461271435022354,
0.6548205614089966,
0.48627862334251404,
0.7629641890525818,
-1.0660322904586792,
0.5058979988098145,
0.10710304230451584,
-0.27077603340148926,
-0.31678980588912964,
-0.187150776386261,
-0.031191378831863403,
0.5192120671272278,
0.4641452133655548,
-0.19116619229316711,
0.13634449243545532,
-1.0923882722854614,
0.19006048142910004,
0.6186865568161011,
-0.3903685510158539,
-0.4110127091407776,
0.7651804685592651,
-0.050107166171073914,
-0.2516949772834778,
0.4833410084247589,
-0.29516348242759705,
-0.6701298952102661,
0.8857000470161438,
0.5393515229225159,
0.4235415756702423,
0.12885631620883942,
0.18984301388263702,
0.04193251579999924,
0.405153751373291,
-0.013824805617332458,
0.38288968801498413,
-0.05469430238008499,
-1.1116540431976318,
-0.5187028050422668,
-0.2887570261955261,
-0.9310932755470276,
-0.22462227940559387,
-0.1550189107656479,
0.16403509676456451,
-0.8286044597625732,
-0.09659983217716217,
-0.45057213306427,
-0.09442742168903351,
-0.5591312646865845,
0.2468290776014328,
0.23613865673542023,
0.5674662590026855,
-1.1513718366622925,
0.22534096240997314,
1.2397191524505615,
-0.5390394926071167,
-0.5795242786407471,
0.0024196552112698555,
0.33318501710891724,
-0.7950034737586975,
1.0216320753097534,
0.03671544790267944,
-0.29853686690330505,
-0.5453053712844849,
-0.5199674963951111,
-0.8676307797431946,
1.2266755104064941,
0.3002331554889679,
-0.4557451009750366,
0.34458357095718384,
0.022233804687857628,
0.5465163588523865,
0.06711990386247635,
0.3818032443523407,
-0.12264841049909592,
0.5255201458930969,
0.2569870352745056,
-1.1928178071975708,
-0.19060614705085754,
0.06735654920339584,
-0.18773186206817627,
0.017948312684893608,
-1.2384459972381592,
0.9964511394500732,
-0.4164752960205078,
-0.004815230146050453,
-0.3387891948223114,
0.48865097761154175,
0.9133419990539551,
0.9518548846244812,
0.31293603777885437,
0.9305263161659241,
0.5201014280319214,
-0.10014902055263519,
1.2466422319412231,
-0.12942135334014893,
0.6148260235786438,
0.6758242845535278,
-0.5675747394561768,
0.7111340165138245,
0.6660441160202026,
0.008131884038448334,
0.5718281865119934,
0.6182857155799866,
0.16169649362564087,
0.5535888671875,
-0.0006565527874045074,
-0.390868604183197,
-0.5488801002502441,
-0.09625562280416489,
-0.07341663539409637,
0.5810283422470093,
0.16810552775859833,
0.2282642424106598,
-0.2768186628818512,
0.5367721915245056,
-0.34427735209465027,
0.06931412220001221,
-0.39553049206733704,
0.4064987003803253,
0.1848147213459015,
-0.34041184186935425,
0.2735191881656647,
-0.04798029735684395,
0.5100424289703369,
0.00894680991768837,
-0.31666913628578186,
-0.2888587415218353,
0.23280158638954163,
-0.2236333191394806,
-1.0345110893249512,
0.4993126094341278,
-0.5090932250022888,
-0.42924004793167114,
-0.4416391849517822,
0.8185076117515564,
-0.1858946532011032,
-0.6159108281135559,
0.27556800842285156,
0.6689668297767639,
0.47848519682884216,
0.15126846730709076,
-0.5058649778366089,
0.27823227643966675,
-0.3141847252845764,
-0.23385657370090485,
0.34546130895614624,
1.0271166563034058,
-0.1396133303642273,
1.293009877204895,
0.42342132329940796,
-0.3184892535209656,
0.2999837398529053,
-0.13565857708454132,
0.6229570508003235,
-0.9772934317588806,
-0.08274268358945847,
-0.686169445514679,
0.524904727935791,
0.1097215786576271,
-0.22939330339431763,
0.9384028911590576,
0.5683499574661255,
0.8744773864746094,
-0.23339183628559113,
0.5756997466087341,
0.2030208855867386,
0.4154018461704254,
-0.9056705832481384,
0.3598472476005554,
-0.8245915174484253,
0.1614844799041748,
-0.05938606336712837,
-0.9194726347923279,
-0.4498564898967743,
1.000264286994934,
-0.138505220413208,
0.1297464370727539,
0.9150516986846924,
0.597536027431488,
-0.2364506870508194,
-0.6398000717163086,
0.7086777687072754,
0.2772044539451599,
0.17073282599449158,
0.9893957376480103,
1.357564926147461,
-0.31366217136383057,
0.549124538898468,
-0.255854994058609,
-0.10496003925800323,
-0.4016139507293701,
-1.1590099334716797,
-1.0080630779266357,
-0.4830855429172516,
-0.41591066122055054,
-0.22472351789474487,
0.03944871947169304,
0.6352735757827759,
0.8602860569953918,
-0.3380323648452759,
0.053298160433769226,
0.03765419125556946,
0.6044296026229858,
0.07065888494253159,
-0.28631791472435,
-0.2540159225463867,
-0.3185665011405945,
-0.6677777171134949,
0.822157621383667,
0.5379736423492432,
0.3479744791984558,
-0.5409201383590698,
-0.00018118589650839567,
-0.18411529064178467,
-0.12816235423088074,
0.7987655997276306,
0.34717991948127747,
-0.6621040105819702,
-0.6901339292526245,
-0.019225338473916054,
0.014404920861124992,
-0.054931335151195526,
0.7959180474281311,
-0.8860835433006287,
0.22528591752052307,
0.18941928446292877,
0.37328457832336426,
0.585551917552948,
0.003826893400400877,
0.3164951503276825,
-0.970604419708252,
0.4189509451389313,
0.13127551972866058,
0.7344636917114258,
0.32229092717170715,
-0.24920861423015594,
0.33487585186958313,
0.7581800818443298,
-0.6151247024536133,
-0.7632079124450684,
0.2959330081939697,
-1.2861049175262451,
-0.4693259298801422,
1.3000861406326294,
0.00835011713206768,
-0.3882989287376404,
-0.29801145195961,
-0.3499768376350403,
-0.10259521752595901,
0.03149542585015297,
0.9603552222251892,
1.01996910572052,
-0.42007002234458923,
-0.6635994911193848,
-0.6864731311798096,
-0.041111670434474945,
0.4356516897678375,
-0.7608463764190674,
-0.414571613073349,
0.7460607886314392,
0.37339234352111816,
0.6485422253608704,
0.28104251623153687,
0.13706782460212708,
0.2753054201602936,
0.05850600451231003,
0.141010582447052,
-0.14886562526226044,
-0.747035801410675,
-0.2979954779148102,
0.3318176865577698,
0.13778842985630035,
-0.16500224173069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15637v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15637v2
|
Addressing Order Sensitivity of In-Context Demonstration Examples in Causal Language Models
| 2024-02-23T22:39:12 | 2024-06-06T12:01:09 |
Yanzheng Xiang, Hanqi Yan, Lin Gui, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context learning has become a popular paradigm in natural language
processing. However, its performance can be significantly influenced by the
order of in-context demonstration examples. In this paper, we found that causal
language models (CausalLMs) are more sensitive to this order compared to prefix
language models (PrefixLMs). We attribute this phenomenon to the
auto-regressive attention masks within CausalLMs, which restrict each token
from accessing information from subsequent tokens. This results in different
receptive fields for samples at different positions, thereby leading to
representation disparities across positions. To tackle this challenge, we
introduce an unsupervised fine-tuning method, termed the Information-Augmented
and Consistency-Enhanced approach. This approach utilizes contrastive learning
to align representations of in-context examples across different positions and
introduces a consistency loss to ensure similar representations for inputs with
different permutations. This enhances the model's predictive consistency across
permutations. Experimental results on five benchmarks suggest that our proposed
method can reduce the sensitivity of CausalLMs to the order of in-context
examples and exhibit robust generalizability, particularly when demonstrations
are sourced from a candidate pool different from that used in the training
phase, or when the number of in-context examples differs from what is used
during training.
|
[
-0.3303731083869934,
-0.7095023989677429,
0.2911670506000519,
0.3676014840602875,
-0.1951078176498413,
-0.31013786792755127,
-0.19653919339179993,
-0.37654080986976624,
-0.3256934583187103,
0.301316499710083,
-0.24701541662216187,
-0.39206668734550476,
-0.7546312212944031,
0.20548571646213531,
-0.30875256657600403,
0.8758363723754883,
0.052111007273197174,
-0.12799502909183502,
-0.30613216757774353,
-0.3680678606033325,
-0.6093898415565491,
-0.5735577344894409,
-0.7295514941215515,
-0.33022117614746094,
0.2941371202468872,
0.36016008257865906,
0.7322244048118591,
0.8772243857383728,
0.33053842186927795,
0.38851410150527954,
0.03303222730755806,
0.2678234875202179,
-0.37303024530410767,
0.15305091440677643,
-0.4776509702205658,
-0.1910572648048401,
-0.11260775476694107,
-0.12440433353185654,
0.71295565366745,
0.9512383341789246,
0.06587588042020798,
0.06602688133716583,
0.46992161870002747,
0.26285746693611145,
-0.8390858173370361,
0.3266955316066742,
-0.7218019366264343,
-0.3133908212184906,
0.1773410141468048,
-0.2891489565372467,
-0.7034292817115784,
-0.039175692945718765,
0.137541726231575,
-0.6581693291664124,
0.4327833950519562,
0.16483008861541748,
0.903022050857544,
0.4296340048313141,
-0.5074427127838135,
0.19594022631645203,
-0.7194282412528992,
0.7275983691215515,
-0.7824841141700745,
0.5343363881111145,
0.4428951144218445,
0.24213474988937378,
-0.4325994849205017,
-0.7670294642448425,
-0.46903350949287415,
0.10896733403205872,
-0.44904986023902893,
0.03383775055408478,
-0.34588801860809326,
0.05806799978017807,
0.4514634907245636,
-0.09731677174568176,
-0.4184456765651703,
0.4309956729412079,
0.0700683519244194,
-0.26572301983833313,
0.31885409355163574,
0.2983267605304718,
-0.16729742288589478,
0.12990839779376984,
-0.4391247630119324,
-0.33155882358551025,
-0.7002941966056824,
0.21687793731689453,
0.05944126471877098,
0.4894706606864929,
-0.09188469499349594,
0.47223058342933655,
-0.6111085414886475,
0.9667564630508423,
0.6100037693977356,
0.2016596496105194,
0.21707484126091003,
-0.24612975120544434,
-0.6632207632064819,
0.05893700569868088,
0.6231544613838196,
0.37169039249420166,
-0.2131001502275467,
-0.006060438230633736,
-0.0621904656291008,
0.08698036521673203,
0.09125541895627975,
-0.822414755821228,
-0.137110635638237,
-0.053741246461868286,
-0.21890461444854736,
-0.1678781807422638,
0.18043571710586548,
-0.5046337246894836,
-0.49633511900901794,
-0.5806137323379517,
0.6098257899284363,
-0.2123788595199585,
0.1381388157606125,
0.28149887919425964,
0.24254830181598663,
0.10622512549161911,
0.33133816719055176,
-1.0009982585906982,
0.46824416518211365,
0.639926552772522,
0.31655481457710266,
-0.1527111530303955,
-0.4776657521724701,
-0.8822333812713623,
0.4004896879196167,
-0.2673836052417755,
0.71223384141922,
-0.601875901222229,
0.14362594485282898,
0.12842607498168945,
0.09058214724063873,
-0.1988058239221573,
-0.6250692009925842,
0.38634979724884033,
-0.587166428565979,
0.3481346070766449,
-0.16798105835914612,
-0.6568116545677185,
-0.07575739175081253,
-0.09998294711112976,
-0.2754260301589966,
0.837454080581665,
-0.022537346929311752,
-0.9784356951713562,
0.707033097743988,
-0.3137606382369995,
-0.5434756278991699,
-0.25350624322891235,
-0.449817955493927,
-0.5360322594642639,
0.14627832174301147,
0.27999043464660645,
0.60856693983078,
-0.0630948543548584,
0.5815334916114807,
-0.20937755703926086,
-0.4574234187602997,
0.15672889351844788,
-0.581984281539917,
0.5387357473373413,
-0.033728696405887604,
-0.6942357420921326,
0.48524317145347595,
-0.8202832937240601,
-0.26735472679138184,
-0.08845687657594681,
-0.24361319839954376,
-0.690608561038971,
0.17846395075321198,
-0.14577145874500275,
0.49553292989730835,
-0.06323128938674927,
-0.37270307540893555,
-0.08885408192873001,
-0.5295958518981934,
0.13935045897960663,
0.8874732255935669,
0.1551322042942047,
0.4410967230796814,
-0.04038260132074356,
-0.08466096222400665,
0.34176087379455566,
0.38703104853630066,
-0.08324010670185089,
-0.36405420303344727,
-0.8568177819252014,
-0.190758615732193,
0.07035873830318451,
0.17820222675800323,
-0.5094099044799805,
0.564729630947113,
-0.2970207631587982,
0.012900038622319698,
-0.18941734731197357,
-0.06114275008440018,
0.7165457010269165,
1.004607081413269,
0.4583127796649933,
-0.3301331400871277,
-0.3751615583896637,
-1.0799098014831543,
-0.3791264593601227,
-0.2042524516582489,
-0.10642155259847641,
0.13480360805988312,
0.16759447753429413,
-0.11077012121677399,
0.855718195438385,
-0.43423396348953247,
0.01582713983952999,
0.11405850946903229,
0.29578688740730286,
0.17268215119838715,
0.5829877853393555,
0.2865196168422699,
-0.9874421954154968,
-0.3833703100681305,
-0.07687348127365112,
-0.4000667333602905,
-0.1816844940185547,
-0.1461806297302246,
-0.21668578684329987,
0.27229776978492737,
0.8516309857368469,
-0.1718774139881134,
0.6169133186340332,
0.19472019374370575,
-0.6899941563606262,
0.1932654231786728,
-0.41428887844085693,
0.05321595445275307,
-0.9371095895767212,
-0.1546851247549057,
-0.13778236508369446,
-0.13999642431735992,
-0.8329849243164062,
-0.11299017816781998,
0.17056922614574432,
0.3018127977848053,
-0.35013464093208313,
0.64666748046875,
-0.29162997007369995,
-0.08958667516708374,
-0.2503683269023895,
-0.05115203186869621,
0.15164203941822052,
0.6049659848213196,
0.07743419706821442,
0.5337918996810913,
0.586060643196106,
-0.9857628345489502,
-0.278805136680603,
0.2856804430484772,
-0.344784140586853,
0.5996139645576477,
-0.6027511954307556,
-0.08714326471090317,
-0.10261710733175278,
0.005639036651700735,
-1.1814032793045044,
-0.34387123584747314,
0.09880194813013077,
-0.18877479434013367,
0.6574446558952332,
0.016211193054914474,
-0.6124106049537659,
0.05808885395526886,
-0.09092222154140472,
0.44740092754364014,
0.3474476635456085,
-0.6732282042503357,
0.25898388028144836,
0.10670582205057144,
0.08223355561494827,
-0.5773056149482727,
-0.46311911940574646,
-0.35113775730133057,
-0.3908252716064453,
-0.2321936935186386,
0.3906807005405426,
-0.11711785942316055,
-0.23172852396965027,
-0.24424509704113007,
-0.2879772484302521,
-0.07400137186050415,
0.3327957093715668,
0.3640040457248688,
0.09965073317289352,
-0.10346179455518723,
0.27121442556381226,
0.18741360306739807,
-0.1361318975687027,
-0.14908307790756226,
-0.1411169320344925,
0.48680761456489563,
-0.04413042590022087,
-0.5410052537918091,
-0.354550838470459,
0.2835109233856201,
0.41030699014663696,
-0.07820848375558853,
0.6295177340507507,
0.43494683504104614,
-0.3697359263896942,
0.0812489464879036,
-0.5854098796844482,
-0.3279113471508026,
-0.5185691714286804,
0.3629804253578186,
-0.320444256067276,
-0.911565899848938,
0.5412271022796631,
0.027351727709174156,
0.12783357501029968,
0.3861751854419708,
0.5236415266990662,
0.1437770426273346,
1.1673955917358398,
0.7001856565475464,
-0.22209957242012024,
0.7146574854850769,
0.1107177883386612,
-0.06548728793859482,
-0.8608932495117188,
-0.18400995433330536,
-0.42636963725090027,
-0.08114043623209,
-0.48459404706954956,
-0.20965152978897095,
0.20219476521015167,
0.37625518441200256,
-0.7989182472229004,
0.29920458793640137,
-0.38381463289260864,
0.5417588353157043,
0.4559404253959656,
0.10759342461824417,
0.43339815735816956,
0.29317164421081543,
-0.29061856865882874,
-0.02171904966235161,
-0.8680242300033569,
-0.3727583587169647,
0.6822657585144043,
0.08016535639762878,
0.5649163126945496,
0.16678044199943542,
0.45250606536865234,
-0.006491073872894049,
0.2818014323711395,
-0.2397185117006302,
0.32111331820487976,
-0.22745227813720703,
-0.2654382884502411,
-0.4550905227661133,
-0.11424701660871506,
-1.2707114219665527,
0.3857351243495941,
-0.073043093085289,
-0.9082580804824829,
0.7378185987472534,
0.19284237921237946,
-0.38946855068206787,
-0.14179721474647522,
-0.7469961047172546,
0.9026656746864319,
0.13072453439235687,
-0.734771192073822,
-0.03724720701575279,
-0.9317736625671387,
0.11737853288650513,
0.12420238554477692,
0.18522986769676208,
0.15341977775096893,
0.2104623168706894,
0.44754838943481445,
-0.42357194423675537,
1.1777310371398926,
-0.02847437374293804,
-0.0808933824300766,
-0.0545065738260746,
0.18203899264335632,
0.7217286825180054,
-0.02793235331773758,
-0.033316195011138916,
-0.12002161890268326,
-0.5666583180427551,
-0.47767025232315063,
-0.7166967988014221,
0.7186015248298645,
-0.6348504424095154,
-0.7656689286231995,
-0.08721671253442764,
-0.47273504734039307,
-0.47845420241355896,
0.13497677445411682,
0.5158393979072571,
0.715609073638916,
0.07675088196992874,
-0.04054673761129379,
0.6553963422775269,
-0.16448016464710236,
0.5756840109825134,
0.7413501143455505,
0.10680318623781204,
-0.1732199341058731,
0.7782613635063171,
-0.026015790179371834,
0.4982968866825104,
0.5563644170761108,
0.18904654681682587,
-0.3252534866333008,
-0.6263410449028015,
-0.24492992460727692,
0.0244828499853611,
-0.8658803701400757,
-0.2642442286014557,
-0.5974419116973877,
0.14525538682937622,
-0.529140293598175,
-0.20671364665031433,
-0.13677172362804413,
-0.28975850343704224,
-0.43260136246681213,
-0.1148112416267395,
0.24500717222690582,
0.6488742232322693,
0.11836715042591095,
0.1796257495880127,
-0.16725367307662964,
0.3460054397583008,
0.5163744688034058,
0.4947071969509125,
-0.03034859709441662,
-0.8739731311798096,
-0.12384264171123505,
-0.2779556214809418,
-0.16804897785186768,
-0.5841326117515564,
0.17607861757278442,
0.21601742506027222,
0.6410925984382629,
0.6304290294647217,
0.2279084026813507,
1.0611159801483154,
-0.5617223978042603,
0.47541293501853943,
0.08210062980651855,
-0.9106849431991577,
0.5168547034263611,
-0.3165931701660156,
0.3003043830394745,
0.5965075492858887,
0.1658879816532135,
-0.26521193981170654,
-0.7545563578605652,
-0.7235770225524902,
-1.0332441329956055,
0.717226505279541,
0.188148632645607,
-0.12357164919376373,
-0.23937463760375977,
0.2268567979335785,
0.2136465460062027,
0.0830175131559372,
-0.5063266754150391,
-0.39208805561065674,
-0.25018930435180664,
-0.1036250963807106,
-0.31049787998199463,
-0.19982078671455383,
-0.11536876857280731,
-0.3559982478618622,
0.3577107787132263,
-0.18889068067073822,
0.026373235508799553,
0.3916673958301544,
-0.14085927605628967,
0.023441774770617485,
0.27581897377967834,
0.8662709593772888,
0.6011596918106079,
-0.04923733323812485,
0.46708711981773376,
0.1589628905057907,
-0.21361564099788666,
0.13540734350681305,
0.26654526591300964,
-0.31092479825019836,
0.0468580424785614,
0.5625856518745422,
1.056957483291626,
0.5357438921928406,
-0.2891688346862793,
0.5334275960922241,
0.025687865912914276,
0.1939181685447693,
0.158977672457695,
-0.12137524783611298,
-0.4257540702819824,
0.3640568256378174,
0.2132890820503235,
0.05043058842420578,
0.468751460313797,
-0.40772393345832825,
0.3564079999923706,
0.30059126019477844,
-0.4327515959739685,
-0.20542915165424347,
0.6883688569068909,
-0.23371008038520813,
-0.0009173533180728555,
0.253702849149704,
-0.12192852795124054,
-0.3794299364089966,
0.6557490825653076,
0.8743191361427307,
0.7243459820747375,
-0.34144967794418335,
0.00042974736425094306,
0.3566996455192566,
-0.018446898087859154,
-0.16681046783924103,
0.10311436653137207,
-0.12220359593629837,
-0.7423592209815979,
-0.2120375782251358,
-0.3831360340118408,
-0.22834408283233643,
0.05193481966853142,
-0.7741175889968872,
0.18328015506267548,
-0.3387225270271301,
-0.05467311292886734,
0.0009076527203433216,
-0.296622097492218,
-0.7256078720092773,
0.24136292934417725,
-0.05581209063529968,
0.566525399684906,
-1.133908748626709,
0.7300572991371155,
0.6599105596542358,
-0.22921356558799744,
-0.8544577956199646,
0.11430522054433823,
-0.33571135997772217,
-0.5120907425880432,
0.8815746903419495,
0.051417093724012375,
-0.038783855736255646,
-0.01905953697860241,
-0.43950051069259644,
-0.8758102655410767,
1.025786280632019,
0.6220212578773499,
-0.3907528519630432,
0.40636104345321655,
0.03880823031067848,
0.5930609107017517,
-0.48378631472587585,
0.24481405317783356,
0.3052922189235687,
0.2681182026863098,
-0.10089368373155594,
-0.8590410947799683,
0.318212628364563,
-0.04474298283457756,
0.08472505211830139,
0.034610193222761154,
-0.6580833196640015,
0.7858226895332336,
-0.14913125336170197,
-0.45593124628067017,
-0.1421985775232315,
0.6854690313339233,
0.3904948830604553,
0.3755541145801544,
0.48336732387542725,
0.2787401080131531,
0.6977642178535461,
0.013566462323069572,
1.2058264017105103,
-0.10296785831451416,
0.12209803611040115,
1.5863866806030273,
-0.2875502109527588,
0.712348461151123,
0.6768038272857666,
0.0012797147501260042,
0.5253779888153076,
0.6381969451904297,
0.21518534421920776,
0.8013063073158264,
0.1549917608499527,
-0.03766839951276779,
-0.31894761323928833,
-0.3301723897457123,
-0.20413026213645935,
0.09556392580270767,
0.11965661495923996,
-0.35977545380592346,
-0.30994683504104614,
0.07388851046562195,
-0.2075498253107071,
0.25594115257263184,
-0.4073511064052582,
0.9331613779067993,
-0.21516487002372742,
-0.5753085017204285,
0.9200282096862793,
-0.17079146206378937,
0.47081130743026733,
-0.3567325174808502,
-0.20479679107666016,
-0.43862730264663696,
0.19466465711593628,
-0.1256811022758484,
-0.505963921546936,
0.12090221047401428,
-0.25462251901626587,
-0.4065960645675659,
-0.04430186375975609,
0.5424042344093323,
-0.47105881571769714,
-0.2565310299396515,
0.30634674429893494,
0.13159196078777313,
-0.028510192409157753,
0.06886453926563263,
-0.3126716613769531,
-0.06376867741346359,
-0.23813042044639587,
-0.2551823854446411,
0.6047715544700623,
0.5592412352561951,
-0.5989149808883667,
0.5389687418937683,
0.348337858915329,
-0.37389469146728516,
0.30960813164711,
0.42881959676742554,
0.8780809044837952,
-0.29081645607948303,
-0.3549574613571167,
-0.9513479471206665,
0.4942057728767395,
-0.1941184252500534,
-0.25469595193862915,
0.8827632069587708,
0.5633692145347595,
1.0930757522583008,
-0.1871684193611145,
0.31440532207489014,
0.3128775954246521,
0.28437918424606323,
-0.49894389510154724,
0.345981627702713,
-0.3639685809612274,
0.3543227016925812,
-0.4210430383682251,
-0.6056555509567261,
-0.6249738335609436,
0.4967089891433716,
-0.3184826374053955,
-0.24388204514980316,
0.5880507826805115,
0.7294791340827942,
-0.16745926439762115,
-0.3203500509262085,
0.5291408896446228,
0.39732590317726135,
0.17669831216335297,
0.509535551071167,
0.6578407287597656,
-0.5108024477958679,
0.12428143620491028,
-0.323990136384964,
-0.12312977761030197,
-0.19992172718048096,
-0.8545125126838684,
-0.812144935131073,
-0.6944239139556885,
-0.48225435614585876,
-0.19283445179462433,
0.050525814294815063,
0.7974705100059509,
0.5255528092384338,
-1.0003540515899658,
-0.0711834579706192,
-0.31729668378829956,
0.21164588630199432,
-0.3489875793457031,
-0.23154813051223755,
0.7171996831893921,
-0.5786474347114563,
-0.6383001208305359,
0.39023634791374207,
0.3217472732067108,
0.1884995400905609,
0.2268320769071579,
0.04005281627178192,
-0.1343664973974228,
0.0027942657470703125,
0.7303579449653625,
0.34253278374671936,
-0.7572503089904785,
-0.6156892776489258,
-0.18123115599155426,
-0.14101344347000122,
0.11219662427902222,
0.7195085883140564,
-0.8822664618492126,
0.5126994252204895,
0.43318742513656616,
0.6074379682540894,
0.3072948157787323,
0.187053844332695,
0.5522018074989319,
-0.9367801547050476,
0.3685341477394104,
-0.0635867789387703,
0.4334636926651001,
0.3245522975921631,
-0.4253920316696167,
0.3357972204685211,
0.07364600151777267,
-0.3937760591506958,
-0.7308803200721741,
0.4954540729522705,
-0.9601154923439026,
-0.37360548973083496,
1.1322981119155884,
-0.1828877031803131,
0.14883795380592346,
-0.47167903184890747,
-0.05433046445250511,
0.47705554962158203,
-0.27166688442230225,
0.8672521710395813,
0.4096014201641083,
-0.3321480453014374,
0.17915445566177368,
-0.24745287001132965,
0.6055893301963806,
0.7657212018966675,
-0.5067501664161682,
0.4227670431137085,
0.4999370574951172,
0.16303929686546326,
0.12486446648836136,
0.37078726291656494,
-0.08746733516454697,
0.18374979496002197,
-0.390323668718338,
-0.23730580508708954,
-0.029979821294546127,
-0.37784215807914734,
-0.8139272928237915,
0.0668838620185852,
0.16691017150878906,
-0.1426515281200409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15631v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15631v1
|
Fine-Grained Self-Endorsement Improves Factuality and Reasoning
| 2024-02-23T22:24:40 | 2024-02-23T22:24:40 |
Ante Wang, Linfeng Song, Baolin Peng, Ye Tian, Lifeng Jin, Haitao Mi, Jinsong Su, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This work studies improving large language model (LLM) generations at
inference time by mitigating fact-conflicting hallucinations. Particularly, we
propose a self-endorsement framework that leverages the fine-grained fact-level
comparisons across multiple sampled responses. Compared with prior ensemble
methods (Wang et al., 2022;Chen et al., 2023)) that perform response-level
selection, our approach can better alleviate hallucinations, especially for
longform generation tasks. Our approach can broadly benefit smaller and
open-source LLMs as it mainly conducts simple content-based comparisons.
Experiments on Biographies show that our method can effectively improve the
factuality of generations with simple and intuitive prompts across different
scales of LLMs. Besides, comprehensive analyses on TriviaQA and GSM8K
demonstrate the potential of self-endorsement for broader application.
|
[
-0.4561557471752167,
-0.7063881754875183,
0.8199721574783325,
0.28053417801856995,
-0.03668235242366791,
0.005430753342807293,
-0.27567824721336365,
-0.6530291438102722,
0.33769911527633667,
0.7185286283493042,
-0.2643145024776459,
-0.26984092593193054,
-0.48897355794906616,
0.28336721658706665,
-0.4057239890098572,
0.9280798435211182,
0.534211277961731,
-0.2073601335287094,
-0.3816765248775482,
0.019692961126565933,
-0.08891355246305466,
-0.29196488857269287,
-0.8814056515693665,
-0.34930697083473206,
0.5701242089271545,
0.3881305158138275,
0.6719231009483337,
0.6587626934051514,
0.22105556726455688,
0.4252243936061859,
-0.0413706973195076,
0.5810926556587219,
-0.5196086168289185,
0.3416939079761505,
-0.35952019691467285,
-0.18253661692142487,
-0.42867448925971985,
0.15865521132946014,
0.41286832094192505,
0.5903601050376892,
0.036097828298807144,
0.1484716236591339,
0.28272178769111633,
0.6629284620285034,
-0.7733941674232483,
0.038286950439214706,
-0.7686980366706848,
-0.002576876897364855,
-0.09934099018573761,
-0.21745456755161285,
-0.6351684331893921,
-0.5192097425460815,
-0.03240266442298889,
-0.34719905257225037,
0.5404126048088074,
0.21645183861255646,
0.5530532598495483,
0.2916702926158905,
-0.19035743176937103,
-0.40205007791519165,
-0.8127531409263611,
0.7229793667793274,
-0.8632692694664001,
0.3683502674102783,
0.347349613904953,
0.2742772698402405,
-0.4097195863723755,
-0.5750558376312256,
-0.7412336468696594,
-0.37487271428108215,
-0.3595072329044342,
0.09932176023721695,
-0.03404811769723892,
0.30101585388183594,
0.30039629340171814,
0.5069858431816101,
-0.4354357123374939,
0.2823657989501953,
-0.3383499085903168,
-0.5090385675430298,
0.6256940960884094,
0.08965195715427399,
0.12826381623744965,
-0.45553743839263916,
-0.33921101689338684,
-0.02742242068052292,
-0.6979663968086243,
-0.23200109601020813,
0.352944552898407,
0.44435063004493713,
0.009847907349467278,
0.5100760459899902,
-0.7189592123031616,
0.5590446591377258,
0.5715131163597107,
-0.20878475904464722,
0.3174220323562622,
-0.3445616066455841,
-0.25899121165275574,
0.42670637369155884,
0.7867528796195984,
0.24774500727653503,
0.2365579605102539,
-0.22470146417617798,
-0.06446826457977295,
-0.08485110104084015,
-0.043157659471035004,
-1.0030994415283203,
-0.10034853965044022,
0.5138454437255859,
-0.5463243126869202,
-0.10929835587739944,
0.09378165006637573,
-1.3314777612686157,
-0.8596834540367126,
-0.3443409204483032,
0.5310430526733398,
-0.23805102705955505,
0.04975227266550064,
0.23121406137943268,
-0.08383331447839737,
0.15449613332748413,
0.36750128865242004,
-1.1631008386611938,
-0.13010692596435547,
0.60067218542099,
0.5873047709465027,
-0.048666343092918396,
-0.2700725793838501,
-0.8563414216041565,
0.15379807353019714,
-0.38250094652175903,
1.1574221849441528,
-0.6808099746704102,
-0.19271546602249146,
0.03146709129214287,
-0.2163919061422348,
0.15359078347682953,
-0.7404006719589233,
0.5250570774078369,
-0.263467401266098,
0.5029038786888123,
-0.18769638240337372,
-0.4615074098110199,
0.046897586435079575,
0.04267450049519539,
-0.43968579173088074,
1.180197834968567,
-0.1432371735572815,
-0.5323665142059326,
0.5688314437866211,
-0.1814153790473938,
-0.5270543098449707,
0.006854346953332424,
-0.37297698855400085,
-0.26264074444770813,
0.30549895763397217,
0.3770653307437897,
0.7705996036529541,
0.010723420418798923,
0.2995043396949768,
-0.5549507141113281,
-0.14131826162338257,
0.03563231602311134,
-0.6257578134536743,
0.4625012278556824,
0.4552305042743683,
-0.4654063284397125,
0.049296047538518906,
-1.1438419818878174,
-0.184408500790596,
-0.24797284603118896,
-0.34403011202812195,
-0.43674415349960327,
0.0007310436340048909,
-0.6341506838798523,
0.23812870681285858,
0.21802149713039398,
-0.6115182638168335,
0.20714625716209412,
-0.5796990394592285,
0.08854074776172638,
0.7695521116256714,
0.060998380184173584,
0.2608630061149597,
-0.21274064481258392,
0.18836601078510284,
0.09929089993238449,
0.010324304923415184,
-0.21699237823486328,
-0.3338816165924072,
-0.9006468653678894,
-0.5254989266395569,
0.3475908637046814,
0.15355508029460907,
-0.6558868288993835,
0.7585338950157166,
-0.14497768878936768,
-0.2869260907173157,
-0.5079789161682129,
0.1776631623506546,
0.14855684340000153,
0.5209422707557678,
0.5053187608718872,
0.03125341981649399,
-0.6266865134239197,
-0.989891767501831,
-0.38522008061408997,
-0.3551081418991089,
-0.06888317316770554,
0.21354292333126068,
0.1651245802640915,
-0.19471856951713562,
0.8484437465667725,
-0.47605088353157043,
-0.25830838084220886,
-0.06250490248203278,
0.3832203149795532,
-0.0015086056664586067,
0.38595491647720337,
0.40493619441986084,
-0.3070841431617737,
-0.25277647376060486,
-0.0918046161532402,
-0.760627269744873,
-0.33337172865867615,
-0.5556783676147461,
-0.16346529126167297,
0.14432980120182037,
0.46721193194389343,
-0.7063348293304443,
0.2800822854042053,
0.4577828347682953,
-0.6005867719650269,
0.48918381333351135,
-0.3508496582508087,
0.395099937915802,
-0.9429172873497009,
-0.33293625712394714,
0.03217976167798042,
-0.2605983018875122,
-0.5265315175056458,
-0.17170162498950958,
-0.13499344885349274,
0.4155075252056122,
-0.10561586916446686,
0.6705142259597778,
-0.2904086112976074,
-0.15806584060192108,
-0.41083890199661255,
0.40925732254981995,
-0.023950869217514992,
0.08197077363729477,
-0.11951789259910583,
1.0395326614379883,
0.4391050338745117,
-0.5928061008453369,
-0.0756639614701271,
0.15183767676353455,
-0.5062806606292725,
0.4829096794128418,
-0.2934446632862091,
0.09508266299962997,
-0.3227296769618988,
0.1753370761871338,
-1.0712531805038452,
-0.44519349932670593,
0.19874654710292816,
-0.22998467087745667,
0.22514763474464417,
0.28435420989990234,
-0.4131046235561371,
-0.43392616510391235,
-0.41601791977882385,
0.05878554657101631,
0.3438275158405304,
-0.9979517459869385,
1.0362087488174438,
0.09935235977172852,
-0.051377780735492706,
-0.4901908338069916,
-0.5552636384963989,
0.300984650850296,
-0.3216554522514343,
-0.44982779026031494,
0.1575053483247757,
-0.279590368270874,
-0.41314759850502014,
-0.39082157611846924,
-0.21256527304649353,
0.09999938309192657,
0.014599633403122425,
0.08507481962442398,
0.15899349749088287,
-0.2686622142791748,
0.25236228108406067,
0.20456922054290771,
0.06529190391302109,
0.009563078172504902,
-0.16358932852745056,
0.32259270548820496,
-0.090519480407238,
0.04078302159905434,
-0.25921380519866943,
-0.013879328034818172,
0.5217023491859436,
-0.09412991255521774,
0.5448242425918579,
0.5669518113136292,
-0.10942146182060242,
-0.43837082386016846,
-1.1097776889801025,
-0.4086545705795288,
-0.5255178213119507,
-0.038484230637550354,
-0.3153081238269806,
-1.1802083253860474,
0.30754485726356506,
-0.04000379517674446,
-0.12314099818468094,
0.6404128670692444,
0.7284502387046814,
0.03278875723481178,
0.8766768574714661,
0.11207788437604904,
0.010761050507426262,
0.36676713824272156,
0.08087222278118134,
0.22720855474472046,
-0.6687934398651123,
-0.11402177065610886,
-0.5632838606834412,
0.07718873769044876,
-0.617865800857544,
-0.4608229100704193,
0.06350405514240265,
-0.0578729510307312,
-0.09093735367059708,
0.04656034708023071,
-0.5925418138504028,
0.48395106196403503,
0.2999981641769409,
0.18461449444293976,
0.519208550453186,
0.09946008026599884,
0.05566063150763512,
0.1555229276418686,
-0.6073962450027466,
-0.6744185090065002,
0.9225125312805176,
0.23537887632846832,
0.8150380253791809,
-0.020792780444025993,
0.8337006568908691,
0.6396262645721436,
0.3146844208240509,
-0.5841651558876038,
0.8074447512626648,
-0.24926947057247162,
-0.8411962389945984,
-0.4180847704410553,
-0.4976835548877716,
-0.9134227633476257,
0.32715773582458496,
-0.5546392202377319,
-0.925224781036377,
0.48873957991600037,
0.35229524970054626,
-0.9723933339118958,
0.0673840194940567,
-0.6870612502098083,
0.4953237473964691,
-0.10822039842605591,
-0.4802730679512024,
-0.4368095099925995,
-0.34770455956459045,
0.5518856048583984,
-0.31187811493873596,
0.25505703687667847,
-0.2723521292209625,
0.300019234418869,
0.6939594745635986,
-0.13708777725696564,
1.047600269317627,
-0.06066450476646423,
-0.23508454859256744,
0.4940643310546875,
0.10304447263479233,
0.5692280530929565,
0.055922962725162506,
-0.3155762553215027,
0.1571263074874878,
-0.044735491275787354,
-0.12225872278213501,
-0.7641870975494385,
0.8435624837875366,
-0.4964168071746826,
-1.1071802377700806,
-0.2578956186771393,
-0.5116111040115356,
-0.3701057732105255,
0.2757450044155121,
-0.03804532438516617,
0.6029512286186218,
-0.08788769692182541,
0.5527262091636658,
0.6910501718521118,
-0.14045707881450653,
0.404249906539917,
0.39006903767585754,
-0.2978184223175049,
-0.4737132787704468,
0.7720308899879456,
0.08134668320417404,
0.38989755511283875,
0.1354571133852005,
0.7076209783554077,
-0.3693789839744568,
-0.5399432182312012,
-0.30948707461357117,
0.20260176062583923,
-0.7761971950531006,
-0.16587620973587036,
-1.0222282409667969,
-0.05765639990568161,
-0.65846848487854,
0.07203030586242676,
-0.2677358388900757,
-0.5168237686157227,
-0.13082477450370789,
-0.2023657113313675,
0.10735184699296951,
0.7658993601799011,
-0.3590417206287384,
0.3392013609409332,
-0.4789767861366272,
0.699882447719574,
0.6638797521591187,
0.24798086285591125,
0.10606899112462997,
-0.5237032771110535,
-0.14827165007591248,
-0.0868958979845047,
-0.25319093465805054,
-0.4472702741622925,
-0.20427025854587555,
0.3232400417327881,
0.6342979669570923,
0.7247330546379089,
0.13047827780246735,
0.7976692914962769,
-0.430253267288208,
0.9205572009086609,
0.11596118658781052,
-0.939665675163269,
0.38258054852485657,
-0.17998738586902618,
-0.04196365550160408,
0.7515338659286499,
0.02116047404706478,
-0.15561972558498383,
-0.7089554667472839,
-0.5406088829040527,
-0.40630805492401123,
0.40523603558540344,
0.20190656185150146,
0.2633208930492401,
-0.3521192967891693,
0.4560107886791229,
0.29428765177726746,
0.15640883147716522,
-0.5962194204330444,
-0.15492908656597137,
-0.27831152081489563,
-0.3584116995334625,
0.02757416106760502,
-0.5725287795066833,
0.05611003190279007,
-0.24668247997760773,
0.8757988214492798,
-0.48927029967308044,
0.04103047400712967,
0.5051670670509338,
0.29755085706710815,
-0.0953211784362793,
0.3164115250110626,
0.5961012840270996,
0.44319936633110046,
-0.06493248045444489,
0.5090686082839966,
0.3747119903564453,
-0.19573818147182465,
0.06997518241405487,
-0.027232399210333824,
-0.2880615293979645,
-0.1494833379983902,
0.5152631402015686,
0.5580812096595764,
0.15848319232463837,
-0.3223206698894501,
0.19814692437648773,
0.1544906347990036,
-0.02999843843281269,
0.20917360484600067,
0.4228981137275696,
-0.035303909331560135,
0.4453098773956299,
0.3173849284648895,
-0.1254730373620987,
0.36235037446022034,
-0.734947919845581,
0.3211728632450104,
0.6066548228263855,
-0.020369496196508408,
-0.0835513174533844,
0.6878877282142639,
0.20889128744602203,
-0.17437729239463806,
0.1940889060497284,
-0.23721478879451752,
-0.2889125645160675,
0.40004751086235046,
0.605179488658905,
0.9658008217811584,
-0.3300803303718567,
0.3439471125602722,
0.6251599788665771,
0.2588626742362976,
-0.4141180217266083,
-0.027470050379633904,
-0.0515429712831974,
-0.8573020100593567,
-0.5173395276069641,
-0.7390291094779968,
-0.15294352173805237,
0.27889367938041687,
-0.35837048292160034,
0.09981669485569,
-0.40889742970466614,
-0.15611305832862854,
0.3049546778202057,
-0.05847446992993355,
-0.4017691910266876,
0.5064544677734375,
0.3350428342819214,
0.7016057372093201,
-0.7137144207954407,
0.7359780073165894,
0.1139298528432846,
-0.28456294536590576,
-0.7207841277122498,
0.47179538011550903,
-0.1263929158449173,
-0.7299384474754333,
0.6237187385559082,
0.24178069829940796,
-0.4633297920227051,
0.06475169211626053,
-0.5504659414291382,
-0.8152110576629639,
0.8285734057426453,
0.2213871031999588,
-0.6544973850250244,
0.025940658524632454,
0.09037702530622482,
0.6573130488395691,
-0.6625951528549194,
0.20840050280094147,
0.7594239115715027,
0.6337666511535645,
0.3147316575050354,
-0.564618706703186,
0.1432265192270279,
0.4388752579689026,
-0.16820308566093445,
-0.10048329085111618,
-0.7302146553993225,
0.5504981875419617,
-0.2137419730424881,
-0.24804489314556122,
0.23125168681144714,
1.245537519454956,
0.43851205706596375,
0.4536520838737488,
0.8091463446617126,
0.28373411297798157,
1.0677434206008911,
0.1704842746257782,
0.8694379925727844,
-0.6377812623977661,
0.45021429657936096,
1.4236661195755005,
-0.20172590017318726,
0.6177902817726135,
0.5138077139854431,
-0.15762802958488464,
0.7334784865379333,
0.531619131565094,
-0.1837705373764038,
0.30086126923561096,
-0.020124247297644615,
-0.28479310870170593,
-0.7665732502937317,
-0.196696475148201,
-0.241117462515831,
0.49139493703842163,
0.17546744644641876,
-0.35998326539993286,
-0.37904423475265503,
-0.06526932865381241,
-0.029381219297647476,
0.2830982804298401,
-0.3176087737083435,
0.7070288062095642,
0.20205721259117126,
-0.8904525637626648,
0.31819552183151245,
-0.38822826743125916,
0.5870260000228882,
-0.3715763986110687,
-0.03240295872092247,
-0.2941168546676636,
-0.009018771350383759,
-0.43323618173599243,
-0.7467129826545715,
0.09228219836950302,
-0.06776165962219238,
-0.18318064510822296,
0.12953144311904907,
1.0505728721618652,
-0.5141987800598145,
-0.5007980465888977,
0.34066227078437805,
0.5188658833503723,
0.1446310430765152,
0.011725369840860367,
-0.47922396659851074,
-0.08025254309177399,
-0.07686025649309158,
-0.2651125192642212,
0.08932448923587799,
0.524953305721283,
0.09411735087633133,
0.6004452109336853,
0.5853639841079712,
0.27663272619247437,
0.013588332571089268,
0.20659898221492767,
0.5539979338645935,
-0.5848163366317749,
-0.36218249797821045,
-1.044804573059082,
0.2368825227022171,
-0.27213209867477417,
-0.13266076147556305,
1.143833875656128,
0.6725465655326843,
0.6937581300735474,
-0.010211598128080368,
0.7046303153038025,
0.005707522854208946,
0.40791675448417664,
-0.7320999503135681,
0.5013839602470398,
-0.5575994253158569,
0.26133179664611816,
-0.22158469259738922,
-0.9431350827217102,
-0.27356550097465515,
0.5279694199562073,
-0.563256561756134,
0.20163457095623016,
0.5680619478225708,
1.0616990327835083,
0.018679983913898468,
0.10669706016778946,
0.5797332525253296,
0.548615038394928,
0.17014679312705994,
0.05089487135410309,
0.9942993521690369,
-0.14315684139728546,
0.2799700200557709,
-0.17795193195343018,
-0.07734058797359467,
-0.295569509267807,
-0.9728667736053467,
-1.3086531162261963,
-0.2600482106208801,
-0.45582661032676697,
-0.7385852932929993,
0.055694855749607086,
1.3474607467651367,
0.7007743120193481,
-0.9656040072441101,
0.029213419184088707,
0.16984029114246368,
0.23142176866531372,
-0.0437786728143692,
-0.1894693374633789,
0.21197699010372162,
-0.6142140030860901,
-0.6805419325828552,
0.6525649428367615,
0.4599928557872772,
0.019998354837298393,
-0.5287403464317322,
0.0474807508289814,
0.03825705125927925,
0.6016642451286316,
0.8225197792053223,
0.06111156567931175,
-0.939466655254364,
-0.9201787710189819,
-0.38001376390457153,
-0.1901675909757614,
0.42831555008888245,
0.7238017916679382,
-0.8413832783699036,
0.5770817399024963,
0.48672235012054443,
0.5779913663864136,
0.10212050378322601,
0.3794819116592407,
0.14317746460437775,
-0.4648844003677368,
-0.08443401008844376,
-0.21440933644771576,
0.33173853158950806,
0.33712202310562134,
-0.8027197122573853,
0.48445746302604675,
0.21781599521636963,
-0.5808801054954529,
-0.6255582571029663,
0.09380307793617249,
-0.925025224685669,
-0.27019405364990234,
1.450292944908142,
0.13981693983078003,
-0.18982717394828796,
-0.20944412052631378,
-0.1862696409225464,
0.11263806372880936,
-0.42235180735588074,
1.3499584197998047,
0.674723744392395,
-0.06826925277709961,
0.11437889188528061,
-0.44083449244499207,
0.6400229334831238,
0.4186219871044159,
-1.0182867050170898,
0.4402327835559845,
0.5871602892875671,
0.1678810566663742,
0.29247036576271057,
0.44440758228302,
0.1558178812265396,
0.01275587361305952,
-0.10296354442834854,
0.08382518589496613,
0.03360854834318161,
-0.7051581144332886,
-0.3412734866142273,
0.24914899468421936,
0.14300933480262756,
0.14481280744075775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15623v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15623v1
|
Language-Based User Profiles for Recommendation
| 2024-02-23T21:58:50 | 2024-02-23T21:58:50 |
Joyce Zhou, Yijia Dai, Thorsten Joachims
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Most conventional recommendation methods (e.g., matrix factorization)
represent user profiles as high-dimensional vectors. Unfortunately, these
vectors lack interpretability and steerability, and often perform poorly in
cold-start settings. To address these shortcomings, we explore the use of user
profiles that are represented as human-readable text. We propose the
Language-based Factorization Model (LFM), which is essentially an
encoder/decoder model where both the encoder and the decoder are large language
models (LLMs). The encoder LLM generates a compact natural-language profile of
the user's interests from the user's rating history. The decoder LLM uses this
summary profile to complete predictive downstream tasks. We evaluate our LFM
approach on the MovieLens dataset, comparing it against matrix factorization
and an LLM model that directly predicts from the user's rating history. In
cold-start settings, we find that our method can have higher accuracy than
matrix factorization. Furthermore, we find that generating a compact and
human-readable summary often performs comparably with or better than direct LLM
prediction, while enjoying better interpretability and shorter model input
length. Our results motivate a number of future research directions and
potential improvements.
|
[
-0.3536953926086426,
-0.3965091407299042,
0.5866690278053284,
0.09159094840288162,
-0.33605125546455383,
0.28107500076293945,
-0.166836678981781,
-0.37400177121162415,
0.5142810344696045,
0.8197000026702881,
-0.6760942935943604,
-0.510356605052948,
-0.2916567921638489,
0.08196274191141129,
-0.40393462777137756,
1.2905291318893433,
-0.06822659075260162,
-0.06862922012805939,
-0.3690820634365082,
0.020527977496385574,
-0.5787727236747742,
-0.7055639028549194,
-0.553615391254425,
-0.8253645300865173,
0.6201691031455994,
0.5565264821052551,
0.9324356317520142,
0.7456457018852234,
0.3074917197227478,
0.18926513195037842,
0.027716098353266716,
0.29346731305122375,
-0.6087031960487366,
0.22848927974700928,
-0.03139062225818634,
-0.10818858444690704,
-0.31739526987075806,
-0.015012566931545734,
0.37941232323646545,
0.7026971578598022,
-0.14655475318431854,
0.1223338320851326,
0.11295408755540848,
0.7203009128570557,
-0.3371298015117645,
0.31687048077583313,
-0.01909504272043705,
0.08251471817493439,
-0.036367323249578476,
-0.19205352663993835,
-0.36567145586013794,
-0.16229106485843658,
0.4259897768497467,
-0.34856998920440674,
0.42485544085502625,
0.44521069526672363,
0.47719353437423706,
-0.2655259966850281,
-0.45845356583595276,
-0.27635982632637024,
-1.2600128650665283,
0.719043493270874,
-0.4735683500766754,
0.6245041489601135,
0.9296833276748657,
0.37900906801223755,
-0.06286045908927917,
-0.21252603828907013,
-0.325635701417923,
-0.30069461464881897,
-0.4559861421585083,
-0.23082539439201355,
-0.25046616792678833,
-0.1624579280614853,
0.17814287543296814,
0.3699374794960022,
-0.6141071915626526,
0.012014230713248253,
-0.4228648543357849,
-0.39010077714920044,
0.4699765741825104,
0.28836145997047424,
0.1501416265964508,
-0.0782991424202919,
-0.387294203042984,
-0.1546531319618225,
-0.5993371605873108,
0.3315353989601135,
0.33865565061569214,
0.447093665599823,
-0.20857645571231842,
0.6968008279800415,
-0.4207345247268677,
0.4169943928718567,
0.28457698225975037,
-0.0956125259399414,
0.04721600562334061,
-0.48766154050827026,
-0.15191437304019928,
0.06876090914011002,
0.707611620426178,
0.7185531854629517,
0.5770383477210999,
-0.3998258411884308,
-0.35508283972740173,
-0.2528809905052185,
0.03257185220718384,
-1.1101365089416504,
-0.24184179306030273,
0.22285416722297668,
-0.6365638375282288,
-0.17768189311027527,
0.23049898445606232,
-0.693129301071167,
-0.81703120470047,
-0.2128109484910965,
0.04101642221212387,
-0.4528878331184387,
0.004869556985795498,
0.15898160636425018,
0.19440867006778717,
-0.13371047377586365,
0.16887521743774414,
-0.8860692381858826,
0.3687516152858734,
0.3855345547199249,
0.8407156467437744,
-0.2755924165248871,
-0.17291195690631866,
-0.7934162616729736,
0.008087368682026863,
0.045997023582458496,
0.8273473381996155,
-0.7351479530334473,
-0.6801526546478271,
0.42612898349761963,
-0.0045326645486056805,
0.37729400396347046,
-0.3846725821495056,
0.4414033889770508,
-0.5270155668258667,
0.417331337928772,
-0.46682682633399963,
-0.4297102093696594,
-0.19991961121559143,
0.09856563806533813,
-0.583112359046936,
0.9160581827163696,
0.12882202863693237,
-0.44198253750801086,
0.5343906283378601,
-0.521354615688324,
-0.4727261960506439,
0.11866249144077301,
0.09918719530105591,
-0.11684763431549072,
-0.0838315337896347,
0.5417314171791077,
0.944147527217865,
-0.25001034140586853,
0.39061859250068665,
-0.161770761013031,
-0.7016500234603882,
0.19471436738967896,
-0.16593630611896515,
0.2742839753627777,
0.23635703325271606,
0.16299796104431152,
0.39139705896377563,
-0.7215283513069153,
-0.48487627506256104,
0.011111633852124214,
-0.5655474066734314,
-0.13575129210948944,
0.28923511505126953,
0.4231555461883545,
0.13242915272712708,
0.4564102292060852,
-0.615182638168335,
-0.007382769603282213,
-0.39406388998031616,
0.2704923748970032,
0.7588121294975281,
-0.15260082483291626,
0.7562500238418579,
-0.28082120418548584,
0.7471652030944824,
0.09558548778295517,
-0.25153040885925293,
-0.46573418378829956,
-0.27057233452796936,
-0.6655999422073364,
-0.09422141313552856,
-0.046845339238643646,
0.6428848505020142,
-0.8959429264068604,
0.5138607025146484,
-0.13244520127773285,
-0.4210664927959442,
-0.13709506392478943,
0.5382335782051086,
0.385795533657074,
0.3333621323108673,
0.3497816324234009,
-0.41212159395217896,
-0.49016278982162476,
-0.9602336883544922,
-0.10789458453655243,
-0.5019046664237976,
-0.20736320316791534,
0.5456234216690063,
0.18033818900585175,
-0.4723944067955017,
0.8591480255126953,
-0.8373470306396484,
-0.4554970860481262,
-0.7170937657356262,
-0.27386030554771423,
0.5495877265930176,
0.13646215200424194,
0.38753294944763184,
-0.27311545610427856,
-0.5455585718154907,
-0.08601905405521393,
-0.5127237439155579,
0.014011007733643055,
-0.12216128408908844,
-0.14351379871368408,
-0.315584272146225,
0.42566654086112976,
-0.3426530361175537,
0.141920804977417,
0.373161256313324,
-0.9997361898422241,
0.28228893876075745,
-0.5247582793235779,
0.055660415440797806,
-1.209849238395691,
-0.01664469577372074,
0.6529325842857361,
-0.5785964131355286,
-0.650654673576355,
-0.2947362959384918,
-0.19911067187786102,
-0.41313686966896057,
-0.1873224526643753,
0.7143517732620239,
-0.06543246656656265,
0.10043839365243912,
-0.29013198614120483,
-0.13816925883293152,
0.02019689977169037,
0.6313387751579285,
-0.04509948939085007,
0.682988703250885,
0.367754727602005,
-0.35257500410079956,
0.3005123436450958,
0.33764970302581787,
-0.598013162612915,
0.537432849407196,
-0.6312549114227295,
0.29006192088127136,
-0.2902641296386719,
0.41072818636894226,
-0.7817424535751343,
-0.12115452438592911,
0.20920656621456146,
0.10168912261724472,
0.09336861968040466,
-0.12672752141952515,
-0.5067545175552368,
-0.13620169460773468,
-0.435474157333374,
0.17709830403327942,
0.4640759527683258,
-0.5716376304626465,
0.7656275033950806,
0.16298866271972656,
-0.16045702993869781,
-0.4148405194282532,
-0.1821284294128418,
0.17732582986354828,
-0.2028043419122696,
-0.5187968015670776,
0.4058758020401001,
-0.318738728761673,
-0.1251591593027115,
-0.20146198570728302,
0.25814327597618103,
-0.11590905487537384,
-0.11091285198926926,
0.45563143491744995,
0.4754650294780731,
-0.09592487663030624,
0.04683621600270271,
-0.3242805600166321,
-0.11162582039833069,
-0.21952232718467712,
-0.20132628083229065,
0.670657753944397,
-0.23269934952259064,
0.266286164522171,
-0.37017616629600525,
0.5336695313453674,
0.46510496735572815,
-0.2408163696527481,
0.7911572456359863,
1.0518804788589478,
-0.17177750170230865,
-0.18618746101856232,
-0.4675481915473938,
-0.4776192903518677,
-0.4931202828884125,
0.42499616742134094,
-0.04562940075993538,
-1.1854692697525024,
0.47741323709487915,
0.23163704574108124,
0.03766779601573944,
0.08238794654607773,
0.6057325005531311,
-0.5129039287567139,
1.0777828693389893,
1.0892958641052246,
-0.3145985007286072,
0.7285022735595703,
-0.1002994179725647,
0.30495497584342957,
-0.5445608496665955,
-0.3446282148361206,
-0.32575705647468567,
-0.439161479473114,
-0.3809473216533661,
-0.1325581818819046,
0.0668298676609993,
0.15886087715625763,
-0.08860371261835098,
0.43814316391944885,
-0.25504305958747864,
0.559585452079773,
0.5311495065689087,
0.13039234280586243,
0.23979178071022034,
0.201461061835289,
-0.19802196323871613,
-0.17056751251220703,
-0.435366690158844,
-0.5295563340187073,
0.8778403997421265,
0.4792919456958771,
0.9779025316238403,
0.16768012940883636,
0.4503669738769531,
0.7747829556465149,
0.2094096839427948,
-0.8941366076469421,
0.5482726097106934,
-0.527195394039154,
-0.416336327791214,
-0.20286932587623596,
-0.13606677949428558,
-0.7664809226989746,
-0.03158837929368019,
-0.5894039869308472,
-0.8725552558898926,
0.27240872383117676,
0.30862560868263245,
-0.40582361817359924,
0.16366831958293915,
-0.5952985286712646,
0.5689786076545715,
-0.14891956746578217,
-0.19015783071517944,
-0.08778362721204758,
-0.12330349534749985,
0.15916603803634644,
-0.1334877610206604,
0.2331373244524002,
-0.2493424415588379,
0.32894542813301086,
1.0016486644744873,
-0.3216760456562042,
0.9049851894378662,
-0.22193710505962372,
0.10161441564559937,
-0.07983577996492386,
0.4482901990413666,
0.6893569827079773,
0.09423651546239853,
-0.23198901116847992,
0.12270287424325943,
0.09020364284515381,
-0.12963317334651947,
-0.7182826399803162,
0.7636062502861023,
-0.7034899592399597,
-0.6106677055358887,
-0.2982338070869446,
-0.4316472113132477,
-0.29242900013923645,
0.2922484576702118,
-0.1385216861963272,
0.7976700067520142,
-0.3066653609275818,
0.3249448835849762,
0.22942794859409332,
-0.26480042934417725,
0.3064885437488556,
0.6666182279586792,
-0.7024726271629333,
-0.49364033341407776,
1.1365565061569214,
-0.240061417222023,
-0.3259059190750122,
0.3377314507961273,
0.3098841607570648,
-0.2203797698020935,
-0.5433862805366516,
-0.6440921425819397,
0.35000303387641907,
-0.7111997008323669,
0.13554203510284424,
-0.46760210394859314,
0.24912400543689728,
-0.071116141974926,
-0.3424036204814911,
-0.047901302576065063,
0.01748848520219326,
-0.2647351324558258,
-0.23481951653957367,
0.393507182598114,
1.0007820129394531,
0.3675500750541687,
0.33364301919937134,
-0.43008753657341003,
0.2302534580230713,
0.005566918291151524,
0.612297773361206,
-0.1642686426639557,
-0.37362056970596313,
-1.0112473964691162,
-0.35525786876678467,
-0.041353609412908554,
-0.5039380788803101,
0.4740380644798279,
0.28048548102378845,
0.3111891448497772,
0.6637375950813293,
0.030187619850039482,
0.25681623816490173,
-0.557582676410675,
0.7594267725944519,
0.14119000732898712,
-0.5586891174316406,
0.45383089780807495,
-0.3445894420146942,
0.6087937951087952,
0.6864199042320251,
0.37619730830192566,
-0.7172660231590271,
-0.0921340137720108,
0.17569515109062195,
-0.6110709309577942,
0.7412275671958923,
0.16274352371692657,
0.3701707720756531,
0.21515323221683502,
0.48701781034469604,
0.3102453351020813,
-0.03694945573806763,
-0.3274628221988678,
-0.26993727684020996,
-0.19107207655906677,
-0.11211004108190536,
-0.90965336561203,
-0.6527181267738342,
0.2848050892353058,
-0.21752694249153137,
0.5683128833770752,
-0.17865519225597382,
0.1467840075492859,
0.00950010959059,
0.014732955023646355,
-0.33794012665748596,
0.18403147161006927,
0.5262767672538757,
0.6714853048324585,
-0.878007173538208,
0.015012187883257866,
-0.07989677786827087,
-0.44358763098716736,
0.1315176635980606,
-0.04778525233268738,
-0.210581973195076,
-0.10009708255529404,
0.40402957797050476,
0.9587090611457825,
0.18577328324317932,
-0.8261865973472595,
0.26028087735176086,
-0.34162551164627075,
0.06066788733005524,
-0.2999587953090668,
-0.02304031513631344,
0.13873785734176636,
0.11335492134094238,
0.24693475663661957,
0.25783148407936096,
0.004360581748187542,
-0.7991370558738708,
-0.0051852017641067505,
0.20355503261089325,
-0.9430176019668579,
-0.47144144773483276,
0.4159483015537262,
0.5302825570106506,
-0.5401484370231628,
0.682620108127594,
0.23619946837425232,
-0.25772345066070557,
0.07486550509929657,
0.4424743056297302,
1.0919106006622314,
0.09682811051607132,
0.44762879610061646,
0.2262323647737503,
0.007575840223580599,
-0.09465380012989044,
0.08713757246732712,
-0.18669986724853516,
-1.1132174730300903,
-0.2718961834907532,
-0.9685491919517517,
-0.39625969529151917,
0.0005592969246208668,
-0.7018325328826904,
0.40462207794189453,
-0.6503755450248718,
-0.26524028182029724,
0.20096836984157562,
-0.020010681822896004,
-1.0006905794143677,
0.0978911891579628,
0.12143581360578537,
0.6195523142814636,
-0.7394596338272095,
0.9582802653312683,
0.784981369972229,
-0.3119302988052368,
-0.3963840901851654,
-0.03357023745775223,
0.060184769332408905,
-0.4676349461078644,
0.6387322545051575,
0.14903035759925842,
-0.3977544903755188,
-0.2122066617012024,
-0.015367927961051464,
-0.6582754254341125,
1.0654258728027344,
0.269812673330307,
-0.3225434422492981,
-0.05844729766249657,
0.02190924808382988,
0.6713503003120422,
-0.8246069550514221,
0.08396413922309875,
0.5132585763931274,
0.20384809374809265,
0.06047823652625084,
-0.7518372535705566,
0.0984504222869873,
-0.3443419337272644,
-0.019238876178860664,
0.057196833193302155,
-0.16540582478046417,
0.5482967495918274,
-0.2265079915523529,
-0.21197101473808289,
-0.1582772582769394,
0.6330963969230652,
-0.01610778458416462,
0.19162023067474365,
0.5520755648612976,
-0.03871459141373634,
0.5081807374954224,
0.29142656922340393,
1.4634912014007568,
-0.41886720061302185,
0.06038430705666542,
0.9380478858947754,
-0.36940354108810425,
1.080281138420105,
0.30141642689704895,
-0.21069040894508362,
0.8748417496681213,
0.5955731272697449,
-0.17609450221061707,
0.45261049270629883,
-0.13844308257102966,
-0.06340579688549042,
-0.5674232244491577,
-0.3663094639778137,
0.18417297303676605,
0.5182094573974609,
-0.00552064273506403,
-0.7333178520202637,
-0.1053280383348465,
0.07079607993364334,
0.04451337456703186,
0.2339891642332077,
-0.1326524168252945,
0.7153555750846863,
0.06736195832490921,
-0.493698388338089,
0.2676607072353363,
0.539179265499115,
1.0031933784484863,
-0.48849403858184814,
-0.10198166966438293,
-0.33869555592536926,
0.14777669310569763,
-0.21950748562812805,
-0.7997170686721802,
-0.019812026992440224,
0.29456424713134766,
-0.8041940331459045,
-0.7474023699760437,
0.9281648397445679,
-0.40436720848083496,
-0.9237654805183411,
0.28114065527915955,
0.6955423951148987,
0.17591136693954468,
0.12856145203113556,
-0.38151073455810547,
-0.1348002403974533,
0.16751356422901154,
-0.0544745959341526,
0.3619224727153778,
-0.42343950271606445,
-0.17892616987228394,
0.9082398414611816,
0.8297954797744751,
0.06376286596059799,
-0.6330823302268982,
0.2223653346300125,
0.4635877013206482,
-0.8914317488670349,
-0.6775742769241333,
-0.9167690873146057,
0.16147103905677795,
0.33980122208595276,
-0.38307273387908936,
0.7400384545326233,
0.5156702399253845,
0.669022262096405,
-0.05693015828728676,
0.5617793798446655,
0.39871373772621155,
0.4558015465736389,
-0.5198194980621338,
0.7956584692001343,
-0.2972105145454407,
0.7230476140975952,
-0.014400884509086609,
-1.2154377698898315,
-0.0084959352388978,
0.2073790580034256,
-0.2706105411052704,
0.3540405035018921,
0.31491222977638245,
0.7492542266845703,
-0.03889285773038864,
-0.24509458243846893,
0.5778987407684326,
0.030137918889522552,
0.44492825865745544,
0.3717888593673706,
0.5260810256004333,
0.07585196942090988,
0.44093188643455505,
-0.40160489082336426,
-0.07421702146530151,
-0.455709844827652,
-0.7335708737373352,
-1.4064292907714844,
-0.713711678981781,
-0.24973413348197937,
-0.608963131904602,
-0.09191536158323288,
1.2204582691192627,
0.7689447402954102,
-1.0263965129852295,
-0.6630180478096008,
0.456589937210083,
-0.011614474467933178,
-0.09098958224058151,
-0.21494249999523163,
0.4141794741153717,
0.48751649260520935,
-0.5235157012939453,
0.7696842551231384,
0.2615586817264557,
-0.14543086290359497,
-0.94236820936203,
-0.37149786949157715,
0.18639840185642242,
0.21745173633098602,
0.7266085743904114,
0.09581714868545532,
-0.7830630540847778,
-0.3281949758529663,
0.043103139847517014,
-0.07722709327936172,
-0.13014617562294006,
1.1036128997802734,
-0.994288444519043,
0.6790639758110046,
0.5133881568908691,
0.1999509185552597,
0.6344638466835022,
0.11879219859838486,
1.1861339807510376,
-0.6964197754859924,
-0.25639045238494873,
-0.06848383694887161,
0.46381622552871704,
0.5297420024871826,
-0.7215076684951782,
0.20878732204437256,
-0.04991718381643295,
-0.21727849543094635,
-0.5635088682174683,
0.12113862484693527,
-1.058402180671692,
-0.06681977957487106,
1.1032403707504272,
-0.19494882225990295,
0.22440233826637268,
-0.3434706926345825,
-0.319577157497406,
-0.2445639967918396,
-0.8575685620307922,
0.6467933058738708,
0.7664265036582947,
-0.15330520272254944,
-0.26959818601608276,
-0.5061479806900024,
0.5334687829017639,
0.13876299560070038,
-0.3145829439163208,
0.14257265627384186,
0.39404821395874023,
0.30930912494659424,
-0.04953429847955704,
0.4239313006401062,
0.3639964461326599,
0.10854074358940125,
-0.438981294631958,
-0.12112957239151001,
-0.5494296550750732,
-0.16478711366653442,
-0.38300904631614685,
0.21711668372154236,
0.16160596907138824,
0.421756386756897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15613v1
|
Towards Efficient Active Learning in NLP via Pretrained Representations
| 2024-02-23T21:28:59 | 2024-02-23T21:28:59 |
Artem Vysogorets, Achintya Gopal
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Fine-tuning Large Language Models (LLMs) is now a common approach for text
classification in a wide range of applications. When labeled documents are
scarce, active learning helps save annotation efforts but requires retraining
of massive models on each acquisition iteration. We drastically expedite this
process by using pretrained representations of LLMs within the active learning
loop and, once the desired amount of labeled data is acquired, fine-tuning that
or even a different pretrained LLM on this labeled data to achieve the best
performance. As verified on common text classification benchmarks with
pretrained BERT and RoBERTa as the backbone, our strategy yields similar
performance to fine-tuning all the way through the active learning loop but is
orders of magnitude less computationally expensive. The data acquired with our
procedure generalizes across pretrained networks, allowing flexibility in
choosing the final model or updating it as newer versions get released.
|
[
0.09037427604198456,
-0.5631467700004578,
0.3643350303173065,
0.04569341614842415,
-0.3950845003128052,
-0.13829481601715088,
-0.7217355966567993,
-0.4316437244415283,
0.03053171932697296,
0.6444560289382935,
-0.2605404555797577,
-0.54353928565979,
-0.6626838445663452,
0.13700616359710693,
-0.37930136919021606,
1.0270973443984985,
-0.2657569348812103,
-0.03838853910565376,
0.15986628830432892,
-0.13973306119441986,
-0.053800713270902634,
-0.643900454044342,
-0.8281276226043701,
-0.5110852718353271,
0.8790647983551025,
0.12005186080932617,
0.5766164660453796,
0.6052221059799194,
0.3689322769641876,
0.31654927134513855,
-0.21117164194583893,
0.5341644287109375,
-0.5785861015319824,
0.3937576711177826,
-0.008922165259718895,
-0.6501627564430237,
-0.6051785945892334,
0.2735442817211151,
0.8027734160423279,
0.8184056878089905,
-0.15103940665721893,
0.0213859174400568,
0.10458792001008987,
0.5001616477966309,
-0.7272638082504272,
0.13175873458385468,
-0.9336628913879395,
0.2295987457036972,
-0.20768408477306366,
-0.2546446919441223,
-0.5486905574798584,
-0.15376922488212585,
0.020228205248713493,
-0.7229775190353394,
0.17792406678199768,
-0.026657864451408386,
0.9885460138320923,
0.4708167314529419,
-0.2557278275489807,
-0.2800148129463196,
-0.7953352332115173,
0.7341614365577698,
-0.5165990591049194,
0.45704081654548645,
0.6110234260559082,
0.08380176872015,
-0.03413400053977966,
-1.1709338426589966,
-0.41717997193336487,
-0.12130545824766159,
0.060832906514406204,
0.09428943693637848,
-0.15179672837257385,
0.3285422921180725,
0.30287161469459534,
0.5321999192237854,
-0.22423654794692993,
0.4433881640434265,
-0.19594071805477142,
-0.038758162409067154,
0.6053705811500549,
-0.24164123833179474,
-0.054304562509059906,
0.2893892526626587,
-0.13030479848384857,
0.005165176000446081,
-0.6876002550125122,
-0.2175225019454956,
0.2099890261888504,
0.6826223134994507,
0.304611474275589,
0.5762882232666016,
0.06340184062719345,
0.865923285484314,
-0.008727326057851315,
0.03419509530067444,
0.40633198618888855,
-0.17373035848140717,
-0.3653334379196167,
0.03864673525094986,
0.6541218757629395,
-0.1641700565814972,
0.4504215121269226,
-0.27377527952194214,
-0.6139346957206726,
-0.14626361429691315,
0.5472958087921143,
-0.7681629061698914,
-0.5063692331314087,
-0.016082502901554108,
-0.3532090485095978,
-0.19999687373638153,
-0.11998128145933151,
-0.06652812659740448,
-0.2518879175186157,
-0.6087073683738708,
0.6717788577079773,
-0.10749398916959763,
-0.0543060302734375,
0.417745977640152,
0.3312244117259979,
-0.11755015701055527,
0.6072707772254944,
-0.961403489112854,
0.12495019286870956,
0.6130162477493286,
0.7734845876693726,
-0.2038947492837906,
0.013773258775472641,
-0.6825177669525146,
0.22341182827949524,
-0.42996230721473694,
0.5809425711631775,
-0.5746676325798035,
0.029414884746074677,
0.1837049424648285,
0.10981559008359909,
0.015850665047764778,
-0.5341287851333618,
0.5753031969070435,
-0.7485920786857605,
-0.08144916594028473,
0.13262420892715454,
-0.6912582516670227,
-0.17022448778152466,
0.341966450214386,
-0.7613884210586548,
1.1193451881408691,
-0.05141182988882065,
-0.556438684463501,
0.4650827646255493,
-0.4446757137775421,
-0.4019433856010437,
0.04466809704899788,
0.01250192429870367,
-0.6818631887435913,
0.11182693392038345,
0.15868839621543884,
0.9584367275238037,
0.18283730745315552,
0.12587253749370575,
-0.09300967305898666,
-0.2470036894083023,
-0.02096915990114212,
-0.3433069884777069,
0.5124491453170776,
0.23653338849544525,
-0.18830056488513947,
0.3249906897544861,
-0.8433038592338562,
-0.01258042361587286,
-0.08285745978355408,
-0.8282396793365479,
-0.46466732025146484,
0.05298556387424469,
-0.19314903020858765,
-0.13899379968643188,
0.3959689736366272,
-0.3363513648509979,
0.4928361475467682,
-0.4753533899784088,
0.1954636424779892,
0.7392746806144714,
-0.23988205194473267,
0.6353403925895691,
0.0739244893193245,
0.4051126539707184,
-0.24728254973888397,
-0.03849966824054718,
-0.26417332887649536,
-0.23821108043193817,
-0.9395827651023865,
-0.29033467173576355,
0.7701593637466431,
0.35191211104393005,
-0.6260815858840942,
0.6589097380638123,
-0.030793996527791023,
-0.5604289174079895,
-0.5396511554718018,
0.5605229735374451,
0.34716615080833435,
0.024091390892863274,
0.5154656767845154,
-0.17909780144691467,
-0.3559635877609253,
-0.5444230437278748,
-0.3080974817276001,
0.02465113252401352,
-0.09191220253705978,
0.22086502611637115,
0.15449535846710205,
-0.4871912896633148,
0.5136945843696594,
-0.4428229033946991,
-0.43661749362945557,
-0.4414690136909485,
0.3649793267250061,
0.269822359085083,
0.47693222761154175,
0.4752016067504883,
-0.7384458184242249,
-0.5553438067436218,
0.034441594034433365,
-0.5243560671806335,
-0.18613247573375702,
-0.22819559276103973,
-0.11379808187484741,
0.050100017338991165,
0.8245137929916382,
-0.31855544447898865,
0.24700675904750824,
0.6119170188903809,
-0.11926119029521942,
0.12444673478603363,
-0.4185897707939148,
-0.3768649995326996,
-0.7350620031356812,
0.013395029120147228,
-0.121696837246418,
-0.46501171588897705,
-0.524381160736084,
-0.10140868276357651,
0.23654213547706604,
-0.23608466982841492,
-0.2768552303314209,
0.43765220046043396,
-0.8669043779373169,
0.09957592189311981,
-0.2733649015426636,
0.13604409992694855,
-0.1538555771112442,
0.4309338629245758,
0.10459903627634048,
0.6006025671958923,
0.6673581600189209,
-0.8301215171813965,
0.22452040016651154,
0.09622108191251755,
-0.4360572099685669,
-0.30470922589302063,
-0.535987377166748,
0.16834700107574463,
-0.2204887419939041,
0.3026404082775116,
-0.6186581254005432,
0.018739240244030952,
0.047702156007289886,
-0.18032586574554443,
0.7682536244392395,
-0.12358760833740234,
-0.6466994285583496,
-0.1083623468875885,
0.01684475690126419,
0.20194272696971893,
0.33301785588264465,
-0.7209377884864807,
0.7953989505767822,
0.4286991357803345,
0.06515482813119888,
-0.49090930819511414,
-0.5328875184059143,
-0.09687065333127975,
0.035111576318740845,
-0.15874060988426208,
0.4832283854484558,
0.28987956047058105,
0.0849127322435379,
-0.07004103064537048,
-0.1403873711824417,
-0.026543091982603073,
0.36027199029922485,
-0.03065360151231289,
-0.1840691715478897,
-0.060009706765413284,
0.5460906028747559,
-0.04096148535609245,
-0.30175015330314636,
-0.18970218300819397,
-0.28752925992012024,
0.3712226450443268,
0.1847447007894516,
-0.3421550989151001,
-0.3679136335849762,
0.05274023115634918,
0.29127511382102966,
-0.5708524584770203,
0.8704233765602112,
0.733234703540802,
-0.38788124918937683,
-0.638552188873291,
-0.3788665533065796,
-0.1041065976023674,
-0.4674628973007202,
0.44822338223457336,
-0.07235350459814072,
-0.9187148213386536,
0.2832612097263336,
-0.5027354955673218,
0.5761889219284058,
0.2632901966571808,
0.4187759459018707,
-0.09378710389137268,
1.1021486520767212,
0.9291946887969971,
0.16240255534648895,
0.9288442134857178,
-0.4489423334598541,
0.29552334547042847,
-0.6477195024490356,
-0.2444096803665161,
-0.535763144493103,
-0.5010989904403687,
-0.1729823499917984,
-0.7877758741378784,
0.012515698559582233,
0.5080232620239258,
-0.17642956972122192,
0.1718500852584839,
-0.556551992893219,
0.527649998664856,
0.41412240266799927,
0.20005105435848236,
0.15101365745067596,
-0.03359752520918846,
0.03472214564681053,
-0.09437309205532074,
-0.8350223302841187,
-0.641679048538208,
1.2694088220596313,
0.46116748452186584,
0.8862562775611877,
-0.04937104135751724,
0.7525029182434082,
0.09854776412248611,
0.5899856090545654,
-0.9998618364334106,
0.5564428567886353,
-0.5372374653816223,
-0.5574379563331604,
-0.20469915866851807,
-0.4525424838066101,
-1.2525076866149902,
0.11708571761846542,
-0.6181389689445496,
-0.29246076941490173,
0.017206339165568352,
0.379062294960022,
-0.39667126536369324,
0.3868976831436157,
-0.6670193672180176,
0.7996219396591187,
-0.5127306580543518,
-0.341530442237854,
-0.2710196375846863,
-0.5099742412567139,
-0.011296539567410946,
-0.4749084711074829,
-0.18696476519107819,
-0.17050661146640778,
-0.2638531029224396,
1.0642309188842773,
-0.29501983523368835,
1.0558154582977295,
-0.27845314145088196,
-0.08435115218162537,
0.19191116094589233,
-0.34108778834342957,
0.6312784552574158,
-0.03177909553050995,
-0.33769962191581726,
-0.042902447283267975,
-0.6340811252593994,
-0.360070139169693,
-0.5567946434020996,
0.44804516434669495,
-0.9171117544174194,
-0.3752260208129883,
-0.3515852689743042,
-0.17706914246082306,
-0.3144584894180298,
0.3047434687614441,
-0.07483241707086563,
0.4551776647567749,
-0.009941702708601952,
0.4661494493484497,
0.9891744256019592,
-0.2248823344707489,
0.396686851978302,
0.5596950054168701,
-0.22319453954696655,
-0.09690093249082565,
0.5544338226318359,
0.35004347562789917,
0.045782070606946945,
0.5202017426490784,
-0.0005851382156834006,
-0.31040245294570923,
-1.1053909063339233,
-0.012015220709145069,
0.32894474267959595,
-0.7669867873191833,
-0.49286511540412903,
-0.812449038028717,
-0.27515023946762085,
-0.14928270876407623,
-0.2365722805261612,
-0.5790998935699463,
-0.3769720792770386,
-0.7288923859596252,
-0.25975093245506287,
0.39060989022254944,
0.756270170211792,
-0.002221685601398349,
0.6570172905921936,
-0.8274763226509094,
0.44988375902175903,
0.5263382792472839,
0.5084277987480164,
0.0754929706454277,
-0.6835232377052307,
-0.5404950976371765,
-0.1313379853963852,
-0.3648216724395752,
-0.6401946544647217,
0.3492506444454193,
0.7285165190696716,
0.8544856309890747,
0.47101184725761414,
0.24785026907920837,
0.7551383972167969,
-0.5785444974899292,
0.5542522072792053,
0.10333775728940964,
-0.7544248104095459,
0.7013697028160095,
-0.21646712720394135,
0.24987582862377167,
0.8234866857528687,
0.7321357727050781,
-0.11244754493236542,
-0.3976685404777527,
-0.5669679045677185,
-1.2891485691070557,
0.5873415470123291,
-0.002164313104003668,
0.31602075695991516,
-0.03096071444451809,
0.7021949291229248,
0.05569032207131386,
0.11000150442123413,
-0.8709155321121216,
-0.14219535887241364,
-0.06857167184352875,
-0.18816204369068146,
-0.3321193754673004,
-0.2028244435787201,
-0.07142043858766556,
-0.4481064975261688,
0.8378869891166687,
-0.1824396699666977,
0.07094647735357285,
0.05963599681854248,
-0.3694092929363251,
-0.012021701782941818,
-0.10894162952899933,
0.11282329261302948,
0.6670770049095154,
-0.2035282552242279,
0.3449941575527191,
0.2321239411830902,
-0.48473480343818665,
-0.11485867202281952,
0.061359476298093796,
0.04507172480225563,
0.1789870262145996,
0.6158897280693054,
1.0415823459625244,
0.5153355598449707,
-0.5702270269393921,
0.4858141839504242,
-0.19786734879016876,
-0.17442607879638672,
-0.2595720887184143,
0.23482543230056763,
0.03666273504495621,
0.13484497368335724,
0.504391610622406,
0.10951440781354904,
-0.26066914200782776,
-0.4769399166107178,
0.30661940574645996,
0.17971386015415192,
-0.43223652243614197,
-0.268562376499176,
0.5658751130104065,
0.5417724847793579,
-0.30530551075935364,
0.7605748176574707,
-0.05637820065021515,
-0.6521535515785217,
0.11148179322481155,
0.45449334383010864,
0.8185955882072449,
-0.28055402636528015,
-0.1616644412279129,
0.5344486236572266,
0.176521435379982,
-0.4488879144191742,
0.05971475690603256,
-0.15144644677639008,
-0.8140567541122437,
-0.7711679935455322,
-1.0080865621566772,
-0.2993567883968353,
0.09548874199390411,
-0.6578225493431091,
0.5363059043884277,
-0.6001307368278503,
-0.2801808714866638,
0.004597411025315523,
0.23524434864521027,
-0.5166277885437012,
0.3481227457523346,
0.25473669171333313,
1.0382366180419922,
-0.9712250232696533,
1.0884875059127808,
0.945548415184021,
-0.0402708426117897,
-0.9967425465583801,
-0.1919257789850235,
-0.47569864988327026,
-0.6991742849349976,
0.6865522265434265,
0.33051174879074097,
0.0668044164776802,
0.2145807147026062,
-0.624315083026886,
-0.7114216089248657,
0.8275818824768066,
0.3202371597290039,
-0.88441002368927,
0.012845094315707684,
-0.45217931270599365,
0.5901243686676025,
-0.2779666483402252,
-0.06400037556886673,
0.26972126960754395,
0.41530999541282654,
-0.010317900218069553,
-0.8432539105415344,
-0.24514524638652802,
-0.3889835774898529,
-0.23612837493419647,
0.40800416469573975,
-0.30224302411079407,
0.6741651892662048,
-0.04994283616542816,
-0.23453432321548462,
-0.3424298167228699,
0.9931163787841797,
0.07934663444757462,
0.059340424835681915,
0.6969274282455444,
0.7199511528015137,
1.1026612520217896,
-0.25392287969589233,
0.8377917408943176,
-0.263994038105011,
0.23988103866577148,
0.8386852741241455,
-0.038235608488321304,
1.0339771509170532,
0.23814016580581665,
-0.11206898838281631,
0.10912012308835983,
0.7579527497291565,
-0.03325590491294861,
0.5942420363426208,
0.35593074560165405,
-0.37632766366004944,
-0.6834343075752258,
0.11886420845985413,
-0.2637982964515686,
0.5557121634483337,
0.4500736594200134,
-0.46450507640838623,
-0.1535942256450653,
0.11813709139823914,
0.14665952324867249,
0.26951608061790466,
-0.6914176344871521,
0.9576053619384766,
0.1990818828344345,
-0.5320267677307129,
0.8028600811958313,
0.0141657879576087,
0.9765699505805969,
-0.9022189378738403,
0.08931460231542587,
0.07856813818216324,
0.41490817070007324,
-0.28245753049850464,
-0.571933925151825,
0.31638088822364807,
0.035391487181186676,
-0.11753689497709274,
-0.864046037197113,
0.7318215370178223,
-0.6991361379623413,
-0.4578319191932678,
0.36679813265800476,
0.1786988377571106,
0.24430951476097107,
-0.0377214178442955,
-0.761578381061554,
0.11419901996850967,
0.07998382300138474,
-0.5120205879211426,
0.2766813039779663,
0.7553241848945618,
-0.034742049872875214,
0.5999513864517212,
0.6898375153541565,
0.38973355293273926,
0.3188140392303467,
0.2234276831150055,
1.1025062799453735,
-0.5271203517913818,
-0.39305582642555237,
-0.5530750155448914,
0.41073721647262573,
-0.03020542673766613,
-0.3807596266269684,
0.7121065258979797,
0.49698466062545776,
0.7497591376304626,
0.14037007093429565,
0.5141195058822632,
0.1875578910112381,
0.5199428796768188,
-0.7001800537109375,
0.8663871884346008,
-0.7062287330627441,
0.3475216329097748,
0.034895822405815125,
-1.0980024337768555,
-0.6781367659568787,
1.0754772424697876,
-0.20231065154075623,
-0.004037259146571159,
0.47636091709136963,
0.5362741947174072,
-0.16656039655208588,
-0.20369917154312134,
0.15034985542297363,
0.26559412479400635,
0.23665140569210052,
0.24410095810890198,
0.647957444190979,
-0.3114027976989746,
0.5231653451919556,
-0.12052932381629944,
-0.32615330815315247,
-0.14997807145118713,
-1.021101474761963,
-1.0543322563171387,
-0.45692840218544006,
-0.4847085475921631,
-0.06514650583267212,
0.1652277708053589,
0.7634192109107971,
0.7819252610206604,
-0.6569199562072754,
0.10216691344976425,
-0.0442376583814621,
-0.06450749188661575,
-0.11181282997131348,
-0.05303244665265083,
0.4592441916465759,
-0.7099304795265198,
-0.8188112378120422,
0.4138283133506775,
0.014431552961468697,
0.07164843380451202,
-0.19762371480464935,
-0.05711601302027702,
-0.4330577850341797,
-0.10432921350002289,
0.6593022346496582,
0.19299472868442535,
-0.3774828314781189,
-0.002366200089454651,
-0.2693675756454468,
-0.050840865820646286,
-0.09184078872203827,
0.896892249584198,
-0.7769004702568054,
0.4489457607269287,
0.5803998708724976,
0.9739698767662048,
0.7606566548347473,
-0.09775856137275696,
0.7026122808456421,
-0.9665151238441467,
0.3302845060825348,
0.6752144694328308,
0.2490466833114624,
0.38574159145355225,
-0.0710391253232956,
0.4915614724159241,
-0.14588263630867004,
-0.6605742573738098,
-1.092787742614746,
0.10786694288253784,
-1.1179511547088623,
-0.3519838750362396,
1.206573486328125,
-0.5372530221939087,
-0.17004446685314178,
-0.2827790379524231,
-0.018116576597094536,
0.43647876381874084,
-0.18555450439453125,
0.6309165954589844,
0.42675042152404785,
0.028866566717624664,
-0.20442043244838715,
-0.5274524688720703,
0.639660656452179,
0.5492098331451416,
-0.5316190123558044,
0.3390235900878906,
0.1617775559425354,
-0.06417444348335266,
0.20030677318572998,
0.6092021465301514,
0.017324982210993767,
-0.15401926636695862,
-0.3445945382118225,
0.12740205228328705,
-0.24420800805091858,
-0.608123779296875,
-0.28208979964256287,
0.08016517758369446,
0.2919713258743286,
-0.0712108239531517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15610v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15610v2
|
Selective "Selective Prediction": Reducing Unnecessary Abstention in Vision-Language Reasoning
| 2024-02-23T21:16:52 | 2024-06-12T21:09:39 |
Tejas Srinivasan, Jack Hessel, Tanmay Gupta, Bill Yuchen Lin, Yejin Choi, Jesse Thomason, Khyathi Raghavi Chandu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Selective prediction minimizes incorrect predictions from vision-language
models (VLMs) by allowing them to abstain from answering when uncertain.
However, when deploying a vision-language system with low tolerance for
inaccurate predictions, selective prediction may be over-cautious and abstain
too frequently, even on many correct predictions. We introduce ReCoVERR, an
inference-time algorithm to reduce the over-abstention of a selective
vision-language system without increasing the error rate of the system's
predictions. When the VLM makes a low-confidence prediction, instead of
abstaining ReCoVERR tries to find relevant clues in the image that provide
additional evidence for the prediction. ReCoVERR uses an LLM to pose related
questions to the VLM, collects high-confidence evidences, and if enough
evidence confirms the prediction the system makes a prediction instead of
abstaining. ReCoVERR enables three VLMs (BLIP2, InstructBLIP, and LLaVA-1.5) to
answer up to 20% more questions on the VQAv2 and A-OKVQA tasks without
decreasing system accuracy, thus improving overall system reliability. Our code
is available at https://github.com/tejas1995/ReCoVERR.
|
[
-0.4095836579799652,
-0.4436693489551544,
0.5448967814445496,
0.09170428663492203,
-0.24240101873874664,
0.08810058981180191,
-0.05416645109653473,
-0.6737779974937439,
0.12745791673660278,
0.881163477897644,
-0.4195207357406616,
0.001486847409978509,
-0.39175352454185486,
0.01017728354781866,
-0.39497852325439453,
0.6779256463050842,
-0.11378499120473862,
0.1423201560974121,
0.040809694677591324,
-0.1172841489315033,
-0.5975721478462219,
-0.1857738047838211,
-0.7280167937278748,
-0.23646984994411469,
0.42966559529304504,
0.3685184717178345,
0.30380886793136597,
0.5763521790504456,
0.778203547000885,
0.3025710880756378,
-0.2169392853975296,
0.02516268379986286,
-0.6365124583244324,
0.42278504371643066,
-0.3410414755344391,
-0.6946212649345398,
0.1188746839761734,
-0.39646926522254944,
0.7899897694587708,
0.39385786652565,
-0.42484036087989807,
-0.027308765798807144,
-0.010849840007722378,
0.898810625076294,
-1.1816388368606567,
-0.19609825313091278,
-0.9231048822402954,
-0.013482869602739811,
-0.1550838202238083,
0.039170440286397934,
-0.7022727131843567,
-0.25078245997428894,
0.27742403745651245,
-0.6002541184425354,
0.32264411449432373,
0.11997438967227936,
0.7670082449913025,
0.6699296236038208,
-0.0062388158403337,
0.426101416349411,
-1.1032723188400269,
1.0165855884552002,
-0.11997129768133163,
0.4024549126625061,
0.49155664443969727,
0.8052025437355042,
0.05260848253965378,
-0.5463704466819763,
-0.5493130087852478,
0.010402578860521317,
0.04475688189268112,
0.4019140601158142,
-0.22597260773181915,
0.09347410500049591,
0.2762269675731659,
0.045540906488895416,
-0.4351697862148285,
-0.1192244216799736,
-0.6301484107971191,
-0.32190990447998047,
0.42383721470832825,
0.21962107717990875,
-0.1953783929347992,
0.21517477929592133,
-0.4413776397705078,
0.0991382896900177,
-0.6818253993988037,
-0.04278598353266716,
-0.285815954208374,
0.09290286898612976,
0.22015847265720367,
0.7164854407310486,
-0.5433109998703003,
0.8899394273757935,
0.1380028873682022,
-0.11251683533191681,
0.24048903584480286,
-0.3228015601634979,
-0.3173540532588959,
0.14382147789001465,
0.2864064574241638,
0.3752268850803375,
0.40836837887763977,
0.11474370956420898,
-0.47143733501434326,
0.6834771633148193,
0.34637388586997986,
-0.7041788101196289,
-0.329279363155365,
0.1332656890153885,
-0.5065289735794067,
0.054282911121845245,
-0.09728989750146866,
-0.6664611101150513,
-0.4588243067264557,
-0.09861055761575699,
0.3163304924964905,
-0.4233815371990204,
-0.16275207698345184,
0.10107133537530899,
-0.37777379155158997,
0.4218660891056061,
0.7274615168571472,
-0.42484360933303833,
0.29206520318984985,
0.4450839161872864,
0.6082361936569214,
-0.2703855037689209,
-0.09494234621524811,
-0.7620131373405457,
0.3026989996433258,
-0.4323188066482544,
0.8511070609092712,
-0.586948812007904,
-0.23151980340480804,
-0.3032790720462799,
0.08992798626422882,
-0.17244382202625275,
-0.5458157658576965,
0.5724506378173828,
-0.5231195092201233,
0.017575595527887344,
-0.45617371797561646,
-0.5531048774719238,
-0.30570417642593384,
0.4646890163421631,
-0.6208654642105103,
0.5671074986457825,
-0.006341483443975449,
-0.808146059513092,
0.6014378070831299,
-0.18929527699947357,
-0.1788037121295929,
0.1887151449918747,
-0.20060616731643677,
-0.4180780053138733,
0.07698262482881546,
0.26248520612716675,
-0.04653491452336311,
-0.03162296861410141,
-0.1125057116150856,
-0.3652113676071167,
-0.42791837453842163,
0.09550846368074417,
-0.4673701524734497,
0.5579457879066467,
0.37899988889694214,
-0.14602507650852203,
0.16029565036296844,
-0.6772908568382263,
0.12255526334047318,
0.1736811101436615,
-0.38291677832603455,
-0.45105457305908203,
0.3787361681461334,
-0.1777801662683487,
0.007237622514367104,
0.002363507868722081,
-1.056308388710022,
0.0006900299340486526,
-0.6188415288925171,
-0.002842013956978917,
0.7613321542739868,
-0.14219215512275696,
0.45068255066871643,
-0.46884751319885254,
0.5426371693611145,
0.031876180320978165,
0.24689044058322906,
-0.008365350775420666,
-0.48779451847076416,
-1.0784001350402832,
-0.38121411204338074,
-0.05265877768397331,
1.0627703666687012,
-1.197370171546936,
0.013460296206176281,
-0.04503481090068817,
-0.41410306096076965,
-0.6064640283584595,
0.05318029597401619,
0.9035743474960327,
0.6748902797698975,
0.5276213884353638,
-0.24750211834907532,
-0.7854088544845581,
-0.944146454334259,
-0.1973063349723816,
-0.35895058512687683,
-0.08543771505355835,
0.08104070276021957,
0.4684866964817047,
-0.14612695574760437,
0.9742559790611267,
-0.6323738694190979,
-0.5224617123603821,
-0.38446328043937683,
-0.6776217222213745,
-0.04888363555073738,
0.5443354249000549,
0.6734383702278137,
-0.9425985813140869,
-0.5258319973945618,
-0.05877106264233589,
-0.6151896119117737,
0.21005478501319885,
0.106779083609581,
-0.205948144197464,
0.49086421728134155,
0.22222691774368286,
-0.6218361258506775,
0.7547197341918945,
0.2999635636806488,
-0.4298076331615448,
0.5038536787033081,
0.02931254729628563,
-0.126761794090271,
-0.6385477781295776,
0.03305884823203087,
-0.062409915030002594,
-0.17247892916202545,
-0.5901898145675659,
0.10040652006864548,
0.03961274027824402,
0.4223247468471527,
-0.34685325622558594,
0.8368003964424133,
-0.344650000333786,
0.15182138979434967,
-0.337790846824646,
-0.04164062812924385,
-0.00016623169358354062,
0.008508768863976002,
0.5460076332092285,
0.5988690853118896,
0.6612703204154968,
-0.5846944451332092,
0.11830801516771317,
0.3966352641582489,
-0.4366683065891266,
0.3573182225227356,
-0.6391573548316956,
-0.039570797234773636,
-0.4579083323478699,
-0.01951904036104679,
-0.8150168657302856,
-0.19508564472198486,
0.5265606641769409,
-0.4311434328556061,
0.22945058345794678,
-0.3260716497898102,
0.27199646830558777,
-0.6110905408859253,
-0.12607549130916595,
0.26645079255104065,
0.4816453456878662,
-0.5006741285324097,
0.8026779890060425,
0.41744929552078247,
-0.19669289886951447,
-0.9689704179763794,
-0.8874308466911316,
-0.22665797173976898,
0.1758762001991272,
-0.18389637768268585,
0.23028860986232758,
-0.16851027309894562,
-0.5078553557395935,
0.2733754515647888,
-0.22609369456768036,
-0.153262197971344,
0.06735226511955261,
0.1840059757232666,
0.5093420743942261,
-0.014050109311938286,
0.008379791863262653,
-0.04568364471197128,
-0.31728774309158325,
-0.2557471692562103,
-0.47045615315437317,
0.2842137813568115,
-0.2973616123199463,
-0.37730470299720764,
-0.27152177691459656,
0.22777347266674042,
0.2938214838504791,
-0.4194367825984955,
0.6926220059394836,
0.34297114610671997,
-0.5067792534828186,
-0.1606689840555191,
-0.8846464157104492,
-0.22519303858280182,
-0.4683058261871338,
0.320480078458786,
-0.4611131250858307,
-0.6906002163887024,
0.4529012441635132,
0.5939652323722839,
0.24563957750797272,
0.2200525552034378,
0.3593498170375824,
0.04648979380726814,
1.0768113136291504,
0.6899288892745972,
-0.11846912652254105,
0.7735617756843567,
-0.23238535225391388,
-0.2155357450246811,
-0.6319454908370972,
-0.412455677986145,
-0.47344693541526794,
-0.1744428277015686,
-0.2363303005695343,
-0.34062299132347107,
-0.021848734468221664,
-0.12305700778961182,
-0.09134647995233536,
0.1009780541062355,
-0.7854645848274231,
0.697472095489502,
0.6595088839530945,
0.18123184144496918,
0.1520088016986847,
0.19469359517097473,
0.007722384762018919,
-0.060291945934295654,
-0.6544167995452881,
-0.1339332014322281,
0.8613520860671997,
0.02231096662580967,
0.8867959976196289,
0.011603896506130695,
0.700465977191925,
-0.2131815403699875,
0.5895652174949646,
-0.8839771151542664,
0.5049133896827698,
-0.34335386753082275,
-0.8572129011154175,
-0.2983185052871704,
-0.6071494817733765,
-0.833889365196228,
0.4294819235801697,
-0.1794576644897461,
-0.8144747018814087,
0.5258690118789673,
0.48201310634613037,
-0.47019708156585693,
0.23208248615264893,
-0.6216644644737244,
0.39047926664352417,
-0.1027759537100792,
-0.3261808454990387,
-0.2200779914855957,
-0.7020580172538757,
0.30943143367767334,
-0.11838371306657791,
-0.10216467827558517,
-0.09334488213062286,
-0.03015565499663353,
0.590624213218689,
-0.16401824355125427,
0.7377505302429199,
-0.5292420983314514,
0.3594101667404175,
0.6161554455757141,
0.34224995970726013,
0.420809805393219,
-0.21500322222709656,
-0.29554450511932373,
-0.21530315279960632,
0.09447989612817764,
-0.45373740792274475,
-0.4870065748691559,
0.4322595000267029,
-0.38666629791259766,
-0.7356786727905273,
-0.43338721990585327,
-0.25404343008995056,
-0.10285907238721848,
0.334855854511261,
0.36971643567085266,
0.1621873378753662,
-0.02399333007633686,
0.24878481030464172,
0.5942050814628601,
-0.0400833897292614,
0.5201147198677063,
0.687278151512146,
-0.3413219451904297,
-0.7809392213821411,
0.804519534111023,
0.16749286651611328,
0.3947073519229889,
0.49832430481910706,
0.13811291754245758,
-0.30917230248451233,
-0.8634783625602722,
-0.20498225092887878,
0.07885649800300598,
-0.7130538821220398,
-0.2721097469329834,
-0.3393315374851227,
-0.2656821012496948,
-0.09997966885566711,
-0.21029041707515717,
-0.43250301480293274,
-0.5557297468185425,
-0.01274030189961195,
-0.12389351427555084,
0.31074607372283936,
0.40210533142089844,
0.0315752737224102,
0.2586840093135834,
-0.8426210880279541,
0.4326919913291931,
0.03472309932112694,
0.4487292766571045,
-0.3653278052806854,
-0.6119152903556824,
0.001619284157641232,
0.0471920445561409,
-0.07660003751516342,
-0.5736688375473022,
0.5460803508758545,
0.38183945417404175,
0.8939917087554932,
0.6982864141464233,
0.4209393560886383,
0.7638033628463745,
-0.36299407482147217,
0.4233686327934265,
0.3678169846534729,
-0.569882333278656,
0.877088725566864,
0.18207649886608124,
0.31348931789398193,
0.7133344411849976,
-0.017040632665157318,
-0.16455674171447754,
-0.5680961608886719,
-0.13461463153362274,
-0.7344529628753662,
0.6211106181144714,
0.167337566614151,
-0.23317719995975494,
-0.06276238709688187,
0.37131834030151367,
0.12189074605703354,
0.07669549435377121,
-0.5758907794952393,
-0.029831670224666595,
-0.33776533603668213,
-0.26416587829589844,
-0.13849209249019623,
-0.46761974692344666,
-0.1789712905883789,
-0.33484330773353577,
0.5530796647071838,
-0.2234477996826172,
0.015446191653609276,
0.5874177813529968,
-0.11881148815155029,
-0.12914498150348663,
0.09423259645700455,
0.42241114377975464,
0.6461024880409241,
-0.268023818731308,
0.0912213996052742,
0.20987500250339508,
-0.8572658896446228,
0.06987335532903671,
0.10371959954500198,
-0.9618853330612183,
-0.19617678225040436,
0.1863173246383667,
0.749230682849884,
-0.423623263835907,
-0.8250269293785095,
0.251345694065094,
-0.2740013897418976,
-0.1574440896511078,
-0.5345323085784912,
0.16046525537967682,
-0.41564103960990906,
0.36737051606178284,
0.45382604002952576,
0.8290606141090393,
0.12673768401145935,
-0.007567951921373606,
0.16937105357646942,
0.5267179012298584,
-0.7165590524673462,
-0.043775469064712524,
0.7945137023925781,
0.2930142283439636,
-0.11766637116670609,
0.611931324005127,
-0.05433524027466774,
-0.5796926021575928,
0.7044198513031006,
0.5728902220726013,
0.97694331407547,
-0.34037601947784424,
-0.015165358781814575,
0.32202592492103577,
0.43461552262306213,
-0.39063671231269836,
0.8089736700057983,
0.20910948514938354,
-1.248817801475525,
-0.6073465943336487,
-0.6353659629821777,
-0.1920960396528244,
-0.2661888599395752,
-0.6534655094146729,
-0.13186852633953094,
-0.6736435294151306,
-0.374801367521286,
-0.17278555035591125,
-0.13293947279453278,
-0.3576051890850067,
0.2321065068244934,
0.10987772047519684,
1.0826576948165894,
-0.3270427882671356,
0.9469342827796936,
0.5318440794944763,
-0.2675752639770508,
-0.5525583028793335,
-0.015284684486687183,
0.15148040652275085,
-0.7332125306129456,
0.5738618969917297,
0.2200387567281723,
-0.4601436257362366,
-0.14359229803085327,
-0.4997217655181885,
-0.9538118839263916,
0.8798484802246094,
0.6800668239593506,
-0.9697645306587219,
0.3331010639667511,
-0.47746795415878296,
0.2674104571342468,
-0.07943931221961975,
-0.11857443302869797,
0.5050745606422424,
0.46631067991256714,
0.3669024705886841,
-1.009724497795105,
0.06997871398925781,
-0.23276716470718384,
0.008484927006065845,
0.34359312057495117,
-0.47790488600730896,
0.5342854857444763,
-0.8242174386978149,
-0.3686250150203705,
0.413830429315567,
0.40517792105674744,
0.538261890411377,
0.4449007213115692,
0.7121819853782654,
0.44043827056884766,
0.8146976232528687,
-0.2761981785297394,
1.2829275131225586,
-0.15057659149169922,
0.14178074896335602,
1.0755870342254639,
-0.468595027923584,
1.1494622230529785,
0.7465227842330933,
0.03748161718249321,
0.18788163363933563,
0.48852628469467163,
-0.07151602953672409,
0.782004177570343,
-0.06828029453754425,
-0.32264453172683716,
-0.6457526683807373,
-0.05977198854088783,
-0.3054415285587311,
0.561436653137207,
0.5111075043678284,
-0.2264154702425003,
0.14819897711277008,
0.052419263869524,
-0.35262376070022583,
0.01603873446583748,
-0.6309477686882019,
0.7314181327819824,
0.11787386983633041,
-0.929433286190033,
0.6975265145301819,
-0.39739179611206055,
0.35966768860816956,
-0.31681695580482483,
0.005520113278180361,
-0.1856832504272461,
0.9112966060638428,
-0.044399693608284,
-0.8607224225997925,
0.4391992390155792,
-0.32694393396377563,
-0.38154110312461853,
-0.016755545511841774,
1.078849196434021,
-0.42235058546066284,
-0.7447761297225952,
0.5380932092666626,
0.5122671723365784,
-0.1857568472623825,
-0.12092683464288712,
-0.47659832239151,
-0.05927353352308273,
0.16043873131275177,
-0.39975908398628235,
-0.052542831748723984,
0.13010357320308685,
-0.20340190827846527,
1.354785442352295,
0.4337579905986786,
0.33041784167289734,
0.04695751890540123,
0.11530852317810059,
0.933708667755127,
-0.5557394623756409,
-0.4070250391960144,
-0.7651939988136292,
0.3366028666496277,
-0.04039927199482918,
-0.09749414771795273,
0.4642343819141388,
0.5639031529426575,
0.8737602233886719,
-0.25017979741096497,
0.9583515524864197,
0.059793904423713684,
0.7310694456100464,
-0.6224640607833862,
0.5988604426383972,
-0.4956892132759094,
0.31479883193969727,
-0.11724568158388138,
-0.7226232886314392,
-0.5896305441856384,
0.7424851655960083,
-0.4899270236492157,
-0.1533023566007614,
0.4067626893520355,
0.8133420348167419,
0.23397456109523773,
-0.28371599316596985,
0.2811965346336365,
0.24216176569461823,
0.037944644689559937,
0.5881504416465759,
1.1595146656036377,
0.01340479962527752,
1.0297142267227173,
-0.3752874433994293,
-0.14026527106761932,
-0.29059022665023804,
-0.46286922693252563,
-0.5248579382896423,
-0.16212394833564758,
-0.21753808856010437,
-0.34775832295417786,
0.42597734928131104,
0.47300830483436584,
0.6926352977752686,
-1.0985530614852905,
0.044996924698352814,
-0.22739951312541962,
0.3067951202392578,
-0.44866347312927246,
-0.1960863322019577,
-0.18083186447620392,
-0.12378136068582535,
-0.4863896667957306,
0.479253888130188,
0.26343363523483276,
0.18471184372901917,
0.18321287631988525,
-0.37103819847106934,
0.13429610431194305,
-0.06724853068590164,
0.5897875428199768,
0.5748759508132935,
-0.9844846129417419,
-0.5414474606513977,
0.247324138879776,
0.14738453924655914,
-0.04955991357564926,
0.500202476978302,
-1.128967046737671,
0.6286779046058655,
0.6393560171127319,
0.49905505776405334,
0.6729018092155457,
0.16369310021400452,
0.6167970299720764,
-0.5431344509124756,
0.37183284759521484,
0.4806639850139618,
0.6577140092849731,
0.2657683193683624,
-0.11781024187803268,
0.5511228442192078,
0.3951413333415985,
-0.2798798680305481,
-0.7939149141311646,
0.5633084177970886,
-0.885914146900177,
-0.49457094073295593,
1.111283302307129,
-0.1429225504398346,
-0.2031039148569107,
-0.42554187774658203,
-0.4555714428424835,
-0.12682276964187622,
-0.4821784496307373,
0.6983245015144348,
0.19987238943576813,
-0.1398874968290329,
-0.6433330178260803,
-0.3061050772666931,
0.43785786628723145,
0.4387728273868561,
-0.4699675738811493,
0.07462654262781143,
0.6857668161392212,
0.48570361733436584,
0.36750444769859314,
0.7573236227035522,
0.10640408843755722,
0.4117380380630493,
0.22742629051208496,
0.009684273973107338,
0.07829105854034424,
-0.648108184337616,
-0.12950268387794495,
0.156684011220932,
0.1321628987789154,
-0.5398226976394653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15594v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15594v1
|
Alternating Weak Triphone/BPE Alignment Supervision from Hybrid Model Improves End-to-End ASR
| 2024-02-23T20:26:54 | 2024-02-23T20:26:54 |
Jintao Jiang, Yingbo Gao, Mohammad Zeineldeen, Zoltan Tuske
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In this paper, alternating weak triphone/BPE alignment supervision is
proposed to improve end-to-end model training. Towards this end, triphone and
BPE alignments are extracted using a pre-existing hybrid ASR system. Then,
regularization effect is obtained by cross-entropy based intermediate auxiliary
losses computed on such alignments at a mid-layer representation of the encoder
for triphone alignments and at the encoder for BPE alignments. Weak supervision
is achieved through strong label smoothing with parameter of 0.5. Experimental
results on TED-LIUM 2 indicate that either triphone or BPE alignment based weak
supervision improves ASR performance over standard CTC auxiliary loss.
Moreover, their combination lowers the word error rate further. We also
investigate the alternation of the two auxiliary tasks during model training,
and additional performance gain is observed. Overall, the proposed techniques
result in over 10% relative error rate reduction over a CTC-regularized
baseline system.
|
[
-0.29414308071136475,
-0.42162853479385376,
0.05204564705491066,
0.06251288205385208,
-0.4950663447380066,
0.12598182260990143,
-0.3834344446659088,
-0.560210108757019,
0.21588417887687683,
0.4121449589729309,
-0.25247758626937866,
-0.3539262115955353,
-0.5930389761924744,
-0.009062092751264572,
-0.2369624823331833,
0.9535796046257019,
-0.16422536969184875,
0.3522769510746002,
0.1618601381778717,
-0.08380768448114395,
-0.37897881865501404,
-0.48593881726264954,
-0.9705803394317627,
-0.5948947072029114,
0.403232216835022,
0.2304847538471222,
0.73099285364151,
0.4450470805168152,
0.7105816602706909,
0.2934422791004181,
-0.4057541787624359,
0.3524768650531769,
-0.3701593577861786,
-0.33448493480682373,
-0.33640047907829285,
-0.24989330768585205,
-0.8199243545532227,
-0.2599695324897766,
0.7854598164558411,
0.7298620939254761,
-0.3910188376903534,
0.006024360656738281,
0.27110832929611206,
0.515766978263855,
-0.7063341736793518,
-0.35635876655578613,
-0.30451422929763794,
-0.1434120535850525,
-0.146871879696846,
-0.3286956250667572,
-0.35870587825775146,
0.011555952951312065,
0.14382891356945038,
-0.5114272236824036,
0.37247803807258606,
0.2193211019039154,
1.2513515949249268,
0.3191176950931549,
-0.5317319631576538,
0.16792947053909302,
-0.9930967688560486,
0.6382523775100708,
-0.7901221513748169,
0.77793288230896,
0.22973433136940002,
0.1279267817735672,
0.03098783642053604,
-0.3995061218738556,
-0.6913632154464722,
0.15798279643058777,
-0.26212260127067566,
0.7099654674530029,
0.11183992773294449,
0.5837789177894592,
0.142557293176651,
0.6603677868843079,
-0.27726832032203674,
0.34312689304351807,
-0.4227273166179657,
-0.5077312588691711,
0.6673334240913391,
0.017911193892359734,
0.12334375828504562,
0.062109801918268204,
-0.4960261285305023,
-0.19609279930591583,
-0.4920961856842041,
0.12082894891500473,
0.5924948453903198,
0.3108549118041992,
-0.44133424758911133,
0.623801589012146,
0.18165095150470734,
0.8024470210075378,
0.3388194441795349,
-0.08310388773679733,
0.3059654235839844,
-0.6623940467834473,
-0.35096651315689087,
0.2804200053215027,
0.6987201571464539,
0.37604403495788574,
-0.05293579399585724,
-0.33358630537986755,
-0.3689842224121094,
0.4974170923233032,
0.09547699242830276,
-0.30977320671081543,
-0.09747066348791122,
0.017697254195809364,
-0.6326301693916321,
0.21196885406970978,
0.31268665194511414,
-0.3186424672603607,
-0.11993667483329773,
-0.8322892189025879,
0.5575729012489319,
-0.6932538747787476,
-0.0008448910084553063,
0.3336450755596161,
-0.30016395449638367,
0.6569088697433472,
0.2783477306365967,
-0.5625678300857544,
0.6678340435028076,
0.35514530539512634,
0.8943728804588318,
-0.47844064235687256,
-0.08750150352716446,
-0.44674187898635864,
0.6489794850349426,
-0.20372408628463745,
0.690570056438446,
-0.2275519222021103,
-0.47565311193466187,
-0.389627605676651,
0.017616314813494682,
-0.35563924908638,
-0.5733933448791504,
0.6208097338676453,
-0.31000712513923645,
0.19244982302188873,
0.1108337789773941,
-0.2674572467803955,
-0.23649610579013824,
0.011893060989677906,
-0.215272918343544,
1.0366828441619873,
-0.11575400084257126,
-0.8048527240753174,
0.20122234523296356,
-0.3986144959926605,
-0.7245239615440369,
-0.3681200444698334,
-0.0024133985862135887,
-0.7604764699935913,
0.09457851946353912,
0.3364410102367401,
0.18534880876541138,
-0.273788720369339,
0.14183589816093445,
-0.13272175192832947,
-0.7844254970550537,
0.10821380466222763,
-0.12634478509426117,
0.8341150283813477,
-0.16073746979236603,
-0.30705058574676514,
0.33931678533554077,
-0.9715747237205505,
-0.08056406676769257,
-0.2796020805835724,
-0.6179326176643372,
-0.6315626502037048,
-0.10394241660833359,
0.23338544368743896,
0.09759001433849335,
-0.002374187810346484,
-0.624910831451416,
0.05255716294050217,
-0.6075530648231506,
-0.2724100649356842,
0.7721536159515381,
0.1861722618341446,
0.41292256116867065,
-0.482584148645401,
0.20680087804794312,
0.17823322117328644,
-0.05135427787899971,
0.2282349318265915,
-0.2755465805530548,
-1.1274456977844238,
-0.42169445753097534,
0.6903497576713562,
0.7819533944129944,
-0.7314683794975281,
0.9062470197677612,
-0.12266121804714203,
-0.1463518738746643,
-0.8393673300743103,
0.1954454630613327,
0.7326352000236511,
0.561935544013977,
0.7452501058578491,
-0.9138556718826294,
-0.9274788498878479,
-1.0157971382141113,
-0.17508180439472198,
-0.07197926193475723,
-0.3300454318523407,
0.15167754888534546,
0.04098000004887581,
-0.3486016094684601,
0.49762284755706787,
-0.09351130574941635,
-0.35022225975990295,
-0.2139551043510437,
0.14907649159431458,
0.29226523637771606,
0.8283551335334778,
0.09238176047801971,
-0.407608300447464,
-0.6115206480026245,
0.07349876314401627,
-0.3831497132778168,
-0.18764756619930267,
-0.236494243144989,
-0.497794508934021,
0.16927656531333923,
0.23393595218658447,
-0.6503136157989502,
0.47276055812835693,
0.23888176679611206,
-0.27601468563079834,
0.36472368240356445,
-0.21170063316822052,
-0.002969080349430442,
-1.0827410221099854,
-0.0035635994281619787,
0.22367353737354279,
-0.12877899408340454,
-0.7005888819694519,
-0.18958769738674164,
0.2692958414554596,
0.2180688977241516,
-0.0553421713411808,
-0.05261824652552605,
-0.7896279692649841,
-0.232596293091774,
-0.20481784641742706,
-0.1911337971687317,
-0.0022819621954113245,
0.49791958928108215,
0.4188392460346222,
0.5467357635498047,
0.7498331069946289,
-0.5845523476600647,
0.17794355750083923,
0.29998502135276794,
0.08323893696069717,
0.3686552941799164,
-0.6504491567611694,
0.4394438564777374,
-0.16022472083568573,
0.519525408744812,
-0.7744450569152832,
0.07340922951698303,
0.31639596819877625,
-0.25955498218536377,
1.0227075815200806,
-0.06462335586547852,
-0.48513510823249817,
-0.330949991941452,
-0.35677674412727356,
0.08671556413173676,
0.5447582006454468,
-0.567878782749176,
0.7661972641944885,
0.061181411147117615,
0.0429869070649147,
-0.3029370605945587,
-0.7909055948257446,
-0.06511406600475311,
-0.21870309114456177,
-0.4231328070163727,
0.8205370306968689,
0.24729298055171967,
-0.19308516383171082,
-0.246088907122612,
-0.3596286475658417,
0.1342068314552307,
-0.4252687394618988,
0.11377740651369095,
0.5743368268013,
-0.3144351541996002,
-0.14996841549873352,
0.15227922797203064,
-0.14043346047401428,
-0.25639045238494873,
-0.4183306396007538,
0.3631994128227234,
0.07328224182128906,
-0.2632855176925659,
-0.8265053629875183,
0.3236050307750702,
0.054277025163173676,
-0.1284351795911789,
0.5558100938796997,
0.49732252955436707,
-0.36550530791282654,
0.10015121847391129,
-0.7897228002548218,
-0.2545742094516754,
-0.5029208660125732,
-0.0007316040573641658,
-0.16370360553264618,
-0.2504931092262268,
0.49522653222084045,
0.21986918151378632,
-0.19531232118606567,
0.25302648544311523,
0.3696522116661072,
-0.4072836935520172,
0.9234434962272644,
0.7213758230209351,
-0.14759621024131775,
0.5210022330284119,
-0.4341752231121063,
0.09280939400196075,
-1.1329823732376099,
-0.30831021070480347,
-0.14925722777843475,
-0.5615189075469971,
-0.448453426361084,
-0.4573533236980438,
0.43577343225479126,
0.24822013080120087,
-0.26214799284935,
0.3909704387187958,
-0.5769109129905701,
0.055083394050598145,
0.8026725649833679,
0.6648856997489929,
0.32559525966644287,
-0.06189512088894844,
-0.1305658519268036,
0.03884324058890343,
-0.6474109292030334,
-0.25463008880615234,
0.9345433712005615,
0.39127957820892334,
0.8929887413978577,
0.2044064700603485,
0.7449476718902588,
0.09428305178880692,
0.014175407588481903,
-0.7172425389289856,
0.41977426409721375,
-0.14452922344207764,
-0.47390496730804443,
-0.19151358306407928,
-0.32963043451309204,
-0.3597593903541565,
0.3191031515598297,
-0.14709369838237762,
-0.7473772168159485,
0.6221936345100403,
0.5034595727920532,
-0.5695689916610718,
0.24700556695461273,
-0.9182388782501221,
0.45796358585357666,
-0.37922048568725586,
-0.5996089577674866,
-0.03735150024294853,
-1.0715030431747437,
0.2676064968109131,
0.20262731611728668,
-0.15818458795547485,
0.3427117168903351,
-0.12749746441841125,
0.8554306626319885,
-0.7964379191398621,
0.9689985513687134,
-0.29142484068870544,
0.054991647601127625,
0.5051053762435913,
-0.40154507756233215,
0.8368956446647644,
-0.1793668419122696,
0.07944827526807785,
0.20901799201965332,
-0.44165506958961487,
-0.44087502360343933,
-0.42326802015304565,
0.2596209645271301,
-0.7796768546104431,
-0.36711740493774414,
-0.2888086438179016,
-0.61939537525177,
-0.5620911121368408,
-0.1961035281419754,
0.6343061923980713,
0.31148481369018555,
0.4727591574192047,
0.10857449471950531,
0.606074333190918,
-0.02700500190258026,
0.45747625827789307,
0.6920977830886841,
0.37666210532188416,
-0.3634795546531677,
0.9011802077293396,
0.1297064870595932,
0.31191661953926086,
0.39994946122169495,
-0.005778681952506304,
-0.1874590963125229,
-0.7137995362281799,
-0.3924596607685089,
0.32593777775764465,
-0.33998867869377136,
-0.4585326611995697,
-0.673271656036377,
-0.2743479013442993,
-0.411874920129776,
-0.28105705976486206,
-0.48620015382766724,
-0.4868166744709015,
-0.15620075166225433,
-0.05265685170888901,
0.2959827780723572,
0.04541831836104393,
-0.18543235957622528,
0.8648732304573059,
-0.5843190550804138,
0.2831459939479828,
-0.1060720682144165,
0.41933268308639526,
-0.16604389250278473,
-0.9259891510009766,
-0.2110319435596466,
-0.1016107127070427,
-0.3686707317829132,
-0.8058812618255615,
0.13796579837799072,
0.40101107954978943,
0.36239728331565857,
0.5287374258041382,
-0.026105675846338272,
1.1539386510849,
-0.24851544201374054,
0.3680708110332489,
0.5818203687667847,
-0.9323406219482422,
0.4338797926902771,
-0.31985995173454285,
0.3403065800666809,
0.45601338148117065,
0.20471510291099548,
-0.1517658680677414,
-0.48805275559425354,
-0.4415585696697235,
-1.0347141027450562,
0.9152674078941345,
0.33594441413879395,
-0.2856132984161377,
0.47539326548576355,
0.0200178399682045,
0.10294108837842941,
-0.05347675830125809,
-0.6485978960990906,
-0.24953380227088928,
-0.2335321009159088,
-0.3105801045894623,
-0.028511352837085724,
-0.15802115201950073,
-0.015956314280629158,
-0.5150848031044006,
1.2362470626831055,
0.03599560633301735,
0.3646790087223053,
0.31217527389526367,
0.11951212584972382,
-0.3366105854511261,
0.2382201850414276,
0.1195419579744339,
0.06371678411960602,
-0.33330827951431274,
0.05736377462744713,
0.5171610116958618,
-0.35506385564804077,
-0.01715181954205036,
0.39550644159317017,
-0.31520864367485046,
0.10986176878213882,
0.3661126494407654,
0.8554440140724182,
0.22730521857738495,
-0.3736487627029419,
0.36895108222961426,
0.3123442828655243,
-0.06456656008958817,
-0.19889776408672333,
-0.023018833249807358,
0.044790204614400864,
0.05436348170042038,
0.19568510353565216,
0.1326068490743637,
0.3843074440956116,
-0.4836975932121277,
0.1542128026485443,
0.3374113142490387,
-0.44581305980682373,
-0.4083511531352997,
0.654242992401123,
0.09721866250038147,
-0.03518962115049362,
0.5048723816871643,
0.1491711586713791,
-0.36036643385887146,
0.470558762550354,
0.9231697916984558,
0.6765868067741394,
-0.5418432354927063,
-0.2841340899467468,
0.19095024466514587,
0.3490927815437317,
0.010267602279782295,
0.5173147916793823,
-0.12976334989070892,
-0.786324143409729,
-0.44792842864990234,
-0.5703892707824707,
-0.4635710120201111,
0.01700025610625744,
-0.905701756477356,
0.6133628487586975,
-0.4196484684944153,
-0.12875667214393616,
-0.0576411671936512,
-0.34480616450309753,
-0.4140108823776245,
0.5283385515213013,
0.18826067447662354,
0.5644856095314026,
-0.8054859638214111,
0.8034164905548096,
1.0116040706634521,
-0.43826109170913696,
-0.9318886399269104,
0.15247929096221924,
0.031407978385686874,
-0.34096968173980713,
0.1901044100522995,
0.02222122810781002,
-0.2532622814178467,
-0.001931605045683682,
-0.3153488337993622,
-0.8714948892593384,
0.9231997728347778,
0.039995916187763214,
-0.8376325964927673,
-0.23361818492412567,
-0.1368800848722458,
0.6362858414649963,
-0.25390541553497314,
0.21943619847297668,
0.5715964436531067,
0.2698163092136383,
0.2493511289358139,
-1.2770862579345703,
-0.026643000543117523,
-0.3448926508426666,
0.16547468304634094,
0.3085271716117859,
-0.7541884779930115,
0.4050731360912323,
-0.09965093433856964,
-0.29262658953666687,
-0.15261991322040558,
0.7758188843727112,
0.15586216747760773,
0.45700857043266296,
0.5575864911079407,
0.5382499694824219,
0.34675678610801697,
-0.05607885494828224,
0.8918197154998779,
-0.20929460227489471,
0.09525994956493378,
1.4526714086532593,
-0.30289334058761597,
0.6807448267936707,
0.7469203472137451,
-0.18420733511447906,
0.3644656836986542,
0.747791051864624,
0.08855893462896347,
0.6523494720458984,
0.023193610832095146,
-0.19788828492164612,
-0.20234474539756775,
-0.15804573893547058,
-0.40447455644607544,
0.5102336406707764,
0.3498804569244385,
-0.4924965798854828,
0.04415208101272583,
0.055244024842977524,
-0.27106747031211853,
0.065180204808712,
-0.5255908370018005,
0.8812050223350525,
0.20001257956027985,
-0.41300541162490845,
0.7972461581230164,
0.1001657173037529,
0.9768434166908264,
-0.5369781851768494,
0.20292508602142334,
-0.11551884561777115,
0.35289254784584045,
-0.41979560256004333,
-0.16271062195301056,
0.44354432821273804,
-0.14814309775829315,
-0.17050734162330627,
-0.03755239397287369,
0.8203056454658508,
-0.6005341410636902,
-0.5266814827919006,
0.5061551928520203,
0.19436973333358765,
-0.065831758081913,
0.2887856066226959,
-0.46163102984428406,
-0.11957567930221558,
-0.06201016530394554,
-0.25794631242752075,
0.1461315006017685,
0.06458410620689392,
-0.07860659807920456,
0.21034204959869385,
0.5714359283447266,
0.3101383447647095,
0.26621103286743164,
0.21151822805404663,
1.0297025442123413,
-0.5702241063117981,
-0.6028493642807007,
-0.5797504186630249,
0.5706297159194946,
-0.36915019154548645,
-0.11648623645305634,
0.6113161444664001,
0.8608249425888062,
0.8703879117965698,
0.03396639972925186,
0.8700540661811829,
-0.03724224865436554,
0.7514813542366028,
-0.7406563758850098,
0.38442566990852356,
-0.38877928256988525,
0.43470317125320435,
-0.30083224177360535,
-0.949837327003479,
-0.3353135883808136,
0.4418976902961731,
-0.2925611138343811,
-0.03861935809254646,
0.5764163732528687,
0.8809453845024109,
-0.5910719037055969,
-0.011430815793573856,
0.15663613379001617,
0.10600969195365906,
-0.24032917618751526,
0.4038427472114563,
0.6942704319953918,
-0.6703830361366272,
0.5201607346534729,
-0.54535311460495,
-0.19426566362380981,
-0.027922360226511955,
-0.3467465937137604,
-0.8927635550498962,
-0.16778220236301422,
-0.6568000912666321,
-0.45468154549598694,
0.4685954451560974,
0.9441623091697693,
0.5170676112174988,
-1.1533337831497192,
-0.3567104637622833,
-0.1977618932723999,
-0.2788739502429962,
-0.4642595648765564,
-0.23639585077762604,
0.58809494972229,
-0.06452278047800064,
-0.6245781183242798,
0.5647469162940979,
0.2155776172876358,
0.46257203817367554,
0.332547664642334,
-0.26492345333099365,
-0.41100451350212097,
0.082890585064888,
0.2169370949268341,
0.19535677134990692,
-0.7138925790786743,
-0.32004451751708984,
-0.2976011633872986,
0.034959740936756134,
0.14825023710727692,
0.8077258467674255,
-0.4201364815235138,
0.3972969055175781,
0.2856411039829254,
0.40725278854370117,
0.5940529704093933,
0.4949571490287781,
0.8107264041900635,
-0.8633993268013,
0.2843688130378723,
0.2204369455575943,
0.4531903564929962,
0.5032604336738586,
-0.48320814967155457,
0.5655748248100281,
0.44034168124198914,
-0.1794101893901825,
-0.6340923309326172,
0.02231535129249096,
-1.1579996347427368,
0.1031179279088974,
1.2650487422943115,
0.028580430895090103,
-0.09714612364768982,
-0.28041166067123413,
-0.37995657324790955,
0.772384524345398,
-0.3876248300075531,
0.6894785165786743,
0.2460746318101883,
-0.3893652558326721,
0.001698709325864911,
-0.20353393256664276,
0.1154499426484108,
0.7421880960464478,
-0.4452304244041443,
-0.24486766755580902,
0.5394914746284485,
0.0360533781349659,
0.16041482985019684,
0.5779843926429749,
-0.06136385351419449,
0.26394930481910706,
-0.0289870947599411,
0.3875304162502289,
0.015431269071996212,
-0.1477990299463272,
-0.37149572372436523,
-0.2600514888763428,
-0.2059914916753769,
-0.5321744680404663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15589v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15589v1
|
Prompting LLMs to Compose Meta-Review Drafts from Peer-Review Narratives of Scholarly Manuscripts
| 2024-02-23T20:14:16 | 2024-02-23T20:14:16 |
Shubhra Kanti Karmaker Santu, Sanjeev Kumar Sinha, Naman Bansal, Alex Knipper, Souvika Sarkar, John Salvador, Yash Mahajan, Sri Guttikonda, Mousumi Akter, Matthew Freestone, Matthew C. Williams Jr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE, I.2.7
|
One of the most important yet onerous tasks in the academic peer-reviewing
process is composing meta-reviews, which involves understanding the core
contributions, strengths, and weaknesses of a scholarly manuscript based on
peer-review narratives from multiple experts and then summarizing those
multiple experts' perspectives into a concise holistic overview. Given the
latest major developments in generative AI, especially Large Language Models
(LLMs), it is very compelling to rigorously study the utility of LLMs in
generating such meta-reviews in an academic peer-review setting. In this paper,
we perform a case study with three popular LLMs, i.e., GPT-3.5, LLaMA2, and
PaLM2, to automatically generate meta-reviews by prompting them with different
types/levels of prompts based on the recently proposed TELeR taxonomy. Finally,
we perform a detailed qualitative study of the meta-reviews generated by the
LLMs and summarize our findings and recommendations for prompting LLMs for this
complex task.
|
[
-0.6127800941467285,
-0.38290703296661377,
1.00722074508667,
0.05209754779934883,
-0.3482561707496643,
0.008926544338464737,
-0.02436678670346737,
-0.28192198276519775,
0.3315018117427826,
0.3962075710296631,
-0.531975507736206,
-0.7165719866752625,
-0.47307339310646057,
0.6548290848731995,
-0.300781786441803,
1.4920697212219238,
-0.3507731258869171,
-0.11703625321388245,
-0.059779033064842224,
0.1775081753730774,
-0.4123006761074066,
-0.06491673737764359,
-0.3605022430419922,
-0.35879984498023987,
0.7735736966133118,
0.3618635833263397,
0.6211867332458496,
0.16193386912345886,
0.4563662111759186,
0.20608645677566528,
0.08343838155269623,
0.42793360352516174,
-0.10106518864631653,
0.45272257924079895,
-0.029748041182756424,
-0.4037720263004303,
-0.6594416499137878,
0.12644007802009583,
0.6561614871025085,
0.34582531452178955,
-0.01231988612562418,
0.5760875344276428,
0.3436121642589569,
0.8081737160682678,
-0.40599524974823,
0.05958583950996399,
-0.6285406351089478,
0.35636264085769653,
-0.2829967439174652,
-0.3072371780872345,
-0.3863888680934906,
-0.4249621033668518,
0.28637367486953735,
-0.7360007166862488,
0.43261247873306274,
-0.08824418485164642,
0.6072902083396912,
0.2768978476524353,
-0.31704574823379517,
-0.5035138726234436,
-0.8242098093032837,
0.2958190441131592,
-0.578435480594635,
-0.12166175991296768,
0.36280956864356995,
0.23748788237571716,
0.2986619174480438,
-0.7038271427154541,
-0.6860532760620117,
-0.19414743781089783,
-0.2740236520767212,
0.39787012338638306,
0.04590335115790367,
0.16264872252941132,
0.07444775849580765,
0.24710677564144135,
-0.5688338279724121,
0.19566647708415985,
-0.5162480473518372,
-0.0028868624940514565,
0.5002350211143494,
0.5518374443054199,
0.006007659714668989,
-0.33122169971466064,
-0.031085079535841942,
-0.006050507538020611,
-1.039638638496399,
-0.08191528916358948,
0.39654552936553955,
-0.04361831024289131,
0.18403317034244537,
0.7031646966934204,
-0.03417352959513664,
0.5984250903129578,
0.19960272312164307,
-0.10835768282413483,
0.11481481790542603,
-0.4987907409667969,
-0.20752190053462982,
-0.1112954244017601,
1.1032541990280151,
0.5899444222450256,
0.36580267548561096,
0.07909208536148071,
-0.3217370808124542,
-0.09584420919418335,
0.3947393298149109,
-0.6685242652893066,
0.06531670689582825,
0.5728614330291748,
-0.6842343807220459,
-0.6014294028282166,
0.26738184690475464,
-0.8709707856178284,
-0.366627037525177,
-0.4247928857803345,
0.1580764651298523,
0.029924198985099792,
-0.10773751884698868,
-0.004479697905480862,
-0.09826841205358505,
0.07374501973390579,
0.45429953932762146,
-0.9127950072288513,
-0.01315760612487793,
0.6050181984901428,
0.9107637405395508,
-0.15576134622097015,
-0.40915167331695557,
-0.46838510036468506,
0.4715122878551483,
-0.29639941453933716,
0.9188355803489685,
-0.4869983494281769,
-0.6822396516799927,
0.3282885253429413,
-0.2811894714832306,
-0.004896473605185747,
-0.33355358242988586,
0.5378096103668213,
-0.5159370303153992,
0.40286967158317566,
-0.2884429097175598,
-0.17153465747833252,
0.003926451317965984,
0.4868980646133423,
-0.5909707546234131,
0.9261234998703003,
-0.007605085149407387,
-0.9113962054252625,
0.391321063041687,
-0.7181389331817627,
-0.34264692664146423,
0.17407120764255524,
-0.20195184648036957,
-0.5203052759170532,
0.33180657029151917,
0.7145525217056274,
0.6243057250976562,
-0.5846170783042908,
0.45143502950668335,
-0.018144095316529274,
-0.20205870270729065,
0.22704210877418518,
-0.1984749138355255,
0.301804780960083,
0.18101488053798676,
-0.4866706132888794,
0.3339250683784485,
-0.21450355648994446,
-0.21097391843795776,
0.012276838533580303,
-0.2808873653411865,
0.04015996307134628,
0.07433480024337769,
-0.13575495779514313,
-0.05554887652397156,
-0.1903175562620163,
-0.20407921075820923,
0.41650909185409546,
-0.09587061405181885,
0.6618702411651611,
0.7876036167144775,
0.28914931416511536,
0.3338610529899597,
-0.6363685131072998,
0.7833786606788635,
-0.3309991657733917,
0.15897536277770996,
-0.6258072257041931,
-0.4122196435928345,
-0.675592839717865,
0.04694658890366554,
0.4589911997318268,
0.3531973958015442,
-0.8249174952507019,
0.30580881237983704,
-0.25954344868659973,
-0.6795099973678589,
-0.6972183585166931,
0.2070070058107376,
0.2434847205877304,
0.25752753019332886,
0.1460655778646469,
0.055588532239198685,
-0.16830697655677795,
-0.6068702936172485,
-0.26103562116622925,
-0.5346617698669434,
-0.22398526966571808,
0.39119192957878113,
0.5103400945663452,
-0.49826592206954956,
0.992935061454773,
-0.47474223375320435,
-0.6077333688735962,
-0.22689831256866455,
0.23918506503105164,
0.008738117292523384,
-0.11454100161790848,
0.33731508255004883,
-0.5317668318748474,
-0.7273737788200378,
-0.16545766592025757,
-0.7173363566398621,
-0.5010769367218018,
-0.40347838401794434,
0.14388027787208557,
0.22650407254695892,
0.5580524206161499,
-0.7359097003936768,
-0.05197867006063461,
0.4476710259914398,
0.05622243881225586,
0.7965347766876221,
-0.037388876080513,
0.032138995826244354,
-1.063589334487915,
0.2469872534275055,
-0.04320757836103439,
-0.0021892215590924025,
-0.26998087763786316,
0.05585578829050064,
-0.26447346806526184,
-0.11864547431468964,
-0.06029372289776802,
0.3611242175102234,
-0.6908290982246399,
0.08733659237623215,
0.009346641600131989,
0.2691686451435089,
-0.10273091495037079,
0.18960098922252655,
0.1821376234292984,
0.5999149680137634,
0.47828003764152527,
-0.4957323670387268,
0.17560359835624695,
0.3586428463459015,
-0.273080050945282,
0.37201210856437683,
-0.9748362898826599,
0.21343983709812164,
-0.3756025433540344,
0.7195886373519897,
-1.079390287399292,
-0.42127886414527893,
0.34170782566070557,
-0.33211034536361694,
0.04802161455154419,
-0.1697966456413269,
-0.6228718161582947,
-0.49591881036758423,
-0.6359384655952454,
0.17744410037994385,
0.3130069673061371,
-0.3782629072666168,
0.9505103230476379,
0.26441189646720886,
-0.5929115414619446,
-0.38327088952064514,
-0.5459678769111633,
0.2521640956401825,
-0.1760026514530182,
-0.39493146538734436,
0.39735013246536255,
-0.016265617683529854,
-0.2466372400522232,
-0.06603458523750305,
0.22989298403263092,
0.5517244338989258,
-0.22654937207698822,
0.3816114068031311,
0.3496040999889374,
0.02809590846300125,
0.1217760443687439,
0.22338388860225677,
-0.27342933416366577,
0.26765933632850647,
-0.3138583302497864,
0.37190768122673035,
-0.09733261913061142,
-0.5154096484184265,
-0.341938853263855,
0.2985328435897827,
0.7625251412391663,
-0.3779040575027466,
0.17066112160682678,
0.6876943707466125,
0.13252438604831696,
-0.361807256937027,
-0.7724608182907104,
-0.434823215007782,
-0.4426226019859314,
-0.011440734378993511,
-0.19923269748687744,
-0.9510847926139832,
0.31314805150032043,
-0.009269180707633495,
0.4021376371383667,
0.5693164467811584,
0.9638773202896118,
-0.2038409560918808,
0.7736815214157104,
0.27222734689712524,
-0.14039841294288635,
0.3875357508659363,
-0.28781843185424805,
-0.052643824368715286,
-0.9448627233505249,
-0.3284209966659546,
-0.3750583231449127,
-0.4334716796875,
-0.541189432144165,
-0.3569738268852234,
1.0287479162216187,
-0.569169282913208,
0.06904781609773636,
0.0024058064445853233,
-0.5678641200065613,
0.491680383682251,
0.5140404105186462,
-0.012213571928441525,
0.3194199204444885,
0.1099502444267273,
-0.37352418899536133,
0.25456488132476807,
-0.7108029723167419,
-0.9067157506942749,
1.4559577703475952,
0.3952641189098358,
0.6484362483024597,
-0.20823411643505096,
0.8527343273162842,
0.23712842166423798,
0.6603209376335144,
-0.6445538997650146,
0.6080931425094604,
0.14296206831932068,
-0.49628475308418274,
-0.21161839365959167,
-0.18720945715904236,
-0.8799154758453369,
0.2131754457950592,
-0.28961482644081116,
-0.05329711735248566,
-0.11479716002941132,
0.17427131533622742,
-0.6496373414993286,
0.19412434101104736,
-0.08173906058073044,
0.46681684255599976,
-0.0715193822979927,
-0.20802007615566254,
-0.31718647480010986,
-0.820959210395813,
0.5126284956932068,
-0.20991402864456177,
0.07339796423912048,
0.04422197863459587,
-0.2670518755912781,
0.5954645872116089,
-0.30844995379447937,
1.0507690906524658,
-0.10878407955169678,
-0.36441296339035034,
0.6832728385925293,
0.42308518290519714,
0.66017746925354,
0.4983021020889282,
-0.0006355397053994238,
-0.10507343709468842,
-0.12970314919948578,
0.2642837464809418,
-0.20754113793373108,
0.38119202852249146,
-0.75007563829422,
-0.7536881566047668,
-0.500582218170166,
-0.32702988386154175,
-0.22227230668067932,
0.020062340423464775,
0.5360845327377319,
0.36782145500183105,
-0.23229077458381653,
-0.15367120504379272,
0.6142771244049072,
-0.04609925299882889,
0.48796331882476807,
0.5822407007217407,
-0.2884317636489868,
-0.8079870343208313,
0.4555901288986206,
-0.03206407278776169,
0.12551246583461761,
0.32649070024490356,
0.2127082496881485,
-0.09547159820795059,
-0.7263588905334473,
-0.6849014163017273,
0.39498794078826904,
-0.41587749123573303,
-0.4195946156978607,
-0.792420506477356,
-0.019662465900182724,
-0.13480517268180847,
-0.16567158699035645,
0.2917560636997223,
-0.21144282817840576,
-0.33798620104789734,
-0.15096502006053925,
0.041382987052202225,
1.1703869104385376,
0.022976022213697433,
0.38766855001449585,
-1.1594290733337402,
0.32571449875831604,
0.5630438923835754,
-0.00797894038259983,
0.21987992525100708,
-0.32129842042922974,
0.05037359893321991,
-0.27409058809280396,
-0.6019518375396729,
-0.9367693662643433,
0.13357286155223846,
0.2541416585445404,
0.41066038608551025,
0.4732663333415985,
-0.16412077844142914,
0.18040494620800018,
-0.784384548664093,
1.1342977285385132,
0.02712198533117771,
-0.744592010974884,
0.5621015429496765,
-0.8222545385360718,
0.3671073615550995,
0.6153962016105652,
0.6582418084144592,
-0.5136292576789856,
-0.5744126439094543,
-0.2722558379173279,
-0.6550076007843018,
0.45101064443588257,
0.07147878408432007,
0.3250746428966522,
-0.033228352665901184,
0.32334572076797485,
0.393151193857193,
0.27055221796035767,
-0.8219907879829407,
0.0660632774233818,
-0.13678354024887085,
-0.07012971490621567,
-0.054814815521240234,
-0.647027313709259,
-0.37603095173835754,
0.21578341722488403,
0.6438474655151367,
-0.32855966687202454,
0.22551460564136505,
0.3296445310115814,
-0.09647687524557114,
-0.33433085680007935,
0.29827389121055603,
0.7444505095481873,
0.5855931043624878,
0.002249508397653699,
0.014291882514953613,
0.10373561084270477,
-0.3741987943649292,
0.06477726995944977,
-0.015084906481206417,
-0.5373159050941467,
0.12498170137405396,
0.5485407114028931,
0.514614462852478,
-0.14635245501995087,
-0.29157885909080505,
0.3834454119205475,
-0.03399542346596718,
-0.5951904058456421,
-0.06949054449796677,
-0.14890269935131073,
0.13922466337680817,
0.08683859556913376,
0.4509357511997223,
-0.08936236053705215,
0.2141360342502594,
-0.3636142313480377,
-0.24389763176441193,
0.6310810446739197,
0.11020628362894058,
-0.5148541927337646,
0.5751736760139465,
0.6328197717666626,
-0.022819923236966133,
0.5263655185699463,
-0.1367993801832199,
-0.797965407371521,
0.26668667793273926,
0.3407321870326996,
1.2004579305648804,
-0.0017930418252944946,
0.5905365943908691,
0.4660092294216156,
0.6228910684585571,
-0.10452984273433685,
-0.009156156331300735,
-0.2803332209587097,
-0.3248068392276764,
-0.524867594242096,
-0.5926040410995483,
-0.7049752473831177,
-0.02703525312244892,
-0.3693351745605469,
0.30071139335632324,
-0.47398972511291504,
-0.4949142634868622,
-0.07088907063007355,
-0.22943507134914398,
-0.4911847412586212,
-0.27674904465675354,
0.24808382987976074,
0.7022106647491455,
-0.9545760154724121,
0.25814640522003174,
0.5455445647239685,
-0.4437170922756195,
-0.8020552396774292,
0.30954572558403015,
0.12402351945638657,
-0.6471596360206604,
0.6103305220603943,
0.022690821439027786,
-0.17776206135749817,
-0.09121757000684738,
-0.24791358411312103,
-0.47552329301834106,
1.2101027965545654,
0.09290483593940735,
-0.8737333416938782,
-0.21202999353408813,
0.3137226998806,
0.7198599576950073,
-0.32156896591186523,
0.5115739703178406,
0.24701593816280365,
0.7720404267311096,
-0.10050828754901886,
-0.9834174513816833,
0.09757193922996521,
-0.20332863926887512,
-0.04724498465657234,
0.18648535013198853,
-0.7897735238075256,
0.607939600944519,
-0.3838878870010376,
-0.07678663730621338,
0.039453890174627304,
0.522283673286438,
0.4491083323955536,
0.24541619420051575,
0.44748008251190186,
0.28895074129104614,
0.5815871357917786,
0.03459109365940094,
0.9957208037376404,
-0.43547144532203674,
-0.053378887474536896,
0.8511661887168884,
-0.4062529504299164,
0.6686059832572937,
0.41465243697166443,
-0.24164524674415588,
0.7322766780853271,
0.706109344959259,
-0.32259178161621094,
0.18065251410007477,
0.19747301936149597,
-0.2952788174152374,
-0.07617726922035217,
0.005176875274628401,
-0.46279001235961914,
0.17396625876426697,
0.23248839378356934,
-0.5585730075836182,
-0.18002325296401978,
-0.09319832175970078,
0.03671441227197647,
-0.1789313703775406,
-0.4009263813495636,
1.035383939743042,
0.15358158946037292,
-1.2169376611709595,
0.1941569298505783,
0.026950256898999214,
0.6159465909004211,
-0.6879797577857971,
0.04946326091885567,
-0.2004380077123642,
-0.26295608282089233,
-0.40864408016204834,
-1.0173757076263428,
0.055009037256240845,
0.3326522707939148,
-0.2652701139450073,
-0.6079276204109192,
0.505163311958313,
-0.4613823890686035,
-0.5757721066474915,
-0.11504656076431274,
0.7297816872596741,
0.08658581227064133,
0.06162237003445625,
-0.45908597111701965,
0.06112171709537506,
-0.18396581709384918,
-0.22182126343250275,
0.11060319095849991,
0.4472218453884125,
-0.058146338909864426,
0.5116584897041321,
0.7859257459640503,
0.2401718646287918,
-0.3195092976093292,
0.2640676200389862,
0.8039966821670532,
-0.25093957781791687,
-0.38972166180610657,
-1.104843258857727,
0.4704488515853882,
0.2937370240688324,
-0.3652914762496948,
0.6491401195526123,
0.3137988746166229,
0.48000437021255493,
-0.4152182340621948,
1.0151561498641968,
0.1280324012041092,
0.3440326750278473,
-0.6265015006065369,
0.790145754814148,
-0.21452546119689941,
0.2685447037220001,
-0.40062353014945984,
-1.3017191886901855,
-0.38362643122673035,
0.23610615730285645,
-0.19079527258872986,
0.1901387870311737,
0.7890558838844299,
0.7013331055641174,
0.22754859924316406,
-0.09625067561864853,
-0.13971351087093353,
-0.031174901872873306,
0.5602107048034668,
0.6149559020996094,
0.9512938857078552,
-0.055801402777433395,
0.5916849970817566,
0.3154657185077667,
-0.04314539581537247,
-0.2869052290916443,
-1.3511481285095215,
-1.2200678586959839,
-0.506854772567749,
-0.14004145562648773,
-0.28413960337638855,
-0.12875241041183472,
0.8757784366607666,
0.26155635714530945,
-0.684726357460022,
-0.17311328649520874,
-0.1036825180053711,
-0.033112186938524246,
0.16013535857200623,
-0.11995256692171097,
0.4373827278614044,
-0.4616911709308624,
-0.578518807888031,
0.07712718844413757,
0.2208244353532791,
0.16160938143730164,
-0.5670888423919678,
-0.04249924048781395,
0.4850074052810669,
0.04419499263167381,
0.4183788001537323,
-0.12898525595664978,
-0.8316588401794434,
0.11277898401021957,
0.04417203366756439,
-0.12384901195764542,
-0.231673002243042,
1.3106156587600708,
-0.7773978114128113,
0.3335089683532715,
0.5636696815490723,
0.45741841197013855,
0.43498334288597107,
-0.11495555937290192,
0.7397733926773071,
-0.36526623368263245,
-0.5879030823707581,
0.339011549949646,
0.3300165832042694,
0.32868629693984985,
-0.19554732739925385,
0.6474427580833435,
-0.0017668016953393817,
-0.7244802713394165,
-0.9250190258026123,
-0.02507251314818859,
-0.7822094559669495,
0.05918333679437637,
1.4091134071350098,
0.13316258788108826,
0.22904382646083832,
0.2339877486228943,
-0.5952016115188599,
-0.13008281588554382,
-0.158750981092453,
0.9027808904647827,
0.8492629528045654,
0.09778089076280594,
-0.011771200224757195,
-0.4027955234050751,
0.7572827339172363,
0.3454219698905945,
-0.9877281785011292,
0.16041405498981476,
0.3855263292789459,
0.33719098567962646,
0.12977908551692963,
0.6706432700157166,
-0.06748675554990768,
0.38107603788375854,
-0.348293662071228,
-0.25795966386795044,
-0.3808957040309906,
-0.4472465515136719,
-0.28208455443382263,
0.25888383388519287,
0.1592082679271698,
0.4506490230560303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14651v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14651v1
|
DOSA: A Dataset of Social Artifacts from Different Indian Geographical Subcultures
| 2024-02-23T20:10:18 | 2024-02-23T20:10:18 |
Agrima Seth, Sanchit Ahuja, Kalika Bali, Sunayana Sitaram
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
Generative models are increasingly being used in various applications, such
as text generation, commonsense reasoning, and question-answering. To be
effective globally, these models must be aware of and account for local
socio-cultural contexts, making it necessary to have benchmarks to evaluate the
models for their cultural familiarity. Since the training data for LLMs is
web-based and the Web is limited in its representation of information, it does
not capture knowledge present within communities that are not on the Web. Thus,
these models exacerbate the inequities, semantic misalignment, and stereotypes
from the Web. There has been a growing call for community-centered
participatory research methods in NLP. In this work, we respond to this call by
using participatory research methods to introduce $\textit{DOSA}$, the first
community-generated $\textbf{D}$ataset $\textbf{o}$f 615 $\textbf{S}$ocial
$\textbf{A}$rtifacts, by engaging with 260 participants from 19 different
Indian geographic subcultures. We use a gamified framework that relies on
collective sensemaking to collect the names and descriptions of these artifacts
such that the descriptions semantically align with the shared sensibilities of
the individuals from those cultures. Next, we benchmark four popular LLMs and
find that they show significant variation across regional sub-cultures in their
ability to infer the artifacts.
|
[
-0.36461272835731506,
-0.765332043170929,
0.364499568939209,
0.14989572763442993,
-0.23654760420322418,
0.088267020881176,
-0.30060601234436035,
-0.2822871208190918,
0.7144544124603271,
0.03662826120853424,
-0.5887435674667358,
-0.5805403590202332,
-0.5179332494735718,
0.28563135862350464,
-0.31537482142448425,
0.6578630208969116,
-0.009133589453995228,
0.13597916066646576,
-0.5332356095314026,
-0.2864270806312561,
-0.3792891204357147,
-0.6557559967041016,
-0.48244020342826843,
-0.21898765861988068,
0.5147177577018738,
0.3880228102207184,
0.29558172821998596,
0.3075791001319885,
0.39784663915634155,
0.2198016494512558,
-0.08052722364664078,
0.39648595452308655,
-0.6339871883392334,
0.18052949011325836,
-0.40560370683670044,
-0.7594702839851379,
-0.09654326736927032,
0.08501595258712769,
0.08758075535297394,
0.5160886645317078,
-0.6105020046234131,
0.575713574886322,
-0.15833090245723724,
0.28556594252586365,
-0.6866992115974426,
0.32242950797080994,
-0.5359010100364685,
0.21419759094715118,
-0.4146353006362915,
-0.2655144929885864,
-0.06850599497556686,
-0.46651116013526917,
-0.22287724912166595,
-0.8236579298973083,
0.4878215193748474,
0.013620410114526749,
0.6519709825515747,
0.1765640377998352,
-0.2730543911457062,
-0.5516443848609924,
-0.8095320463180542,
0.941221296787262,
-0.6016544103622437,
-0.031730011105537415,
0.9425414800643921,
0.40104979276657104,
-0.16297049820423126,
-0.5499313473701477,
-1.0930126905441284,
0.43704843521118164,
-0.008016510866582394,
0.14843064546585083,
0.08670565485954285,
-0.6598342657089233,
0.02806830033659935,
0.5119332671165466,
-0.2861263155937195,
-0.026288338005542755,
-0.5486704111099243,
0.06025286391377449,
0.6924611330032349,
0.3265855014324188,
0.5470737814903259,
-0.4686289429664612,
-0.613588809967041,
-0.12827463448047638,
-0.8639870882034302,
0.10586356371641159,
0.3151417672634125,
0.3475905954837799,
-0.37696221470832825,
0.5056707859039307,
-0.4243870675563812,
0.4752419888973236,
-0.042174458503723145,
-0.15266931056976318,
0.3909008800983429,
-0.3162500262260437,
-0.20554277300834656,
-0.20247147977352142,
0.7227878570556641,
0.49029484391212463,
0.2562864422798157,
-0.11290615051984787,
0.034465331584215164,
0.13145120441913605,
0.16957485675811768,
-0.4959191381931305,
-0.15169420838356018,
0.1476500928401947,
-0.5079709887504578,
-0.3107350766658783,
-0.1400574892759323,
-0.5881296396255493,
-0.6759466528892517,
-0.5405599474906921,
0.11076901108026505,
-0.22858351469039917,
-0.6566188335418701,
-0.07498202472925186,
-0.009577418677508831,
0.5833659768104553,
0.3358367681503296,
-1.0763051509857178,
0.05837874859571457,
0.831625759601593,
0.9695594906806946,
-0.11892774701118469,
-0.33467918634414673,
0.2308722734451294,
0.08337581157684326,
-0.3570614457130432,
0.8081248998641968,
-0.6736936569213867,
-0.5781366229057312,
0.1623150259256363,
0.058096662163734436,
0.10159652680158615,
-0.6773736476898193,
0.3212295174598694,
-0.3950636684894562,
0.11238354444503784,
-0.9777895212173462,
-0.20933251082897186,
-0.2813988924026489,
0.7471153736114502,
-0.3517454266548157,
0.9917279481887817,
0.030548065900802612,
-0.6837398409843445,
0.8142110109329224,
-0.3204505741596222,
-0.26506200432777405,
0.12477301061153412,
-0.5266194939613342,
0.04408760741353035,
0.11597296595573425,
0.4506966471672058,
0.6406979560852051,
-0.4278513491153717,
0.3785560429096222,
-0.29350218176841736,
-0.4103841483592987,
0.1475699245929718,
-0.34583187103271484,
0.896105945110321,
0.43885084986686707,
-0.01890646480023861,
0.09859208762645721,
-0.492668092250824,
-0.4727109968662262,
0.2535650134086609,
0.014591485261917114,
-0.7297388315200806,
0.13325995206832886,
-0.05312752351164818,
0.04508686810731888,
-0.06947426497936249,
-0.7073220610618591,
0.2644747197628021,
-0.24691259860992432,
0.47283679246902466,
0.9257948994636536,
0.011682107113301754,
0.412506103515625,
-0.5855859518051147,
0.6682559251785278,
0.20336970686912537,
0.4458262622356415,
0.09840669482946396,
-0.4478714168071747,
-0.5995351076126099,
-0.23293866217136383,
0.12429211288690567,
0.24206465482711792,
-1.074055790901184,
-0.25016549229621887,
-0.3238458037376404,
-0.5922678112983704,
-0.2803008258342743,
0.04680006578564644,
0.09863869100809097,
0.378302663564682,
0.2501486539840698,
-0.5777425169944763,
-0.48156169056892395,
-0.6621001958847046,
0.3876244127750397,
-0.2205522656440735,
-0.3710238039493561,
0.35268959403038025,
0.2772292494773865,
0.0963997095823288,
1.0763434171676636,
-0.4075118601322174,
-0.4856756329536438,
-0.0028810733929276466,
0.12921659648418427,
-0.07328199595212936,
0.1374955028295517,
0.29043132066726685,
-0.9282462000846863,
-0.4069025218486786,
-0.2537829279899597,
-1.0771989822387695,
0.06385023891925812,
0.3020787239074707,
-0.17915427684783936,
-0.12961925566196442,
0.2928970158100128,
-0.2781217098236084,
0.37657099962234497,
0.6611668467521667,
-0.1646278202533722,
0.198821559548378,
-0.07276343554258347,
0.40223562717437744,
-1.5986568927764893,
-0.1354193538427353,
0.016173357143998146,
0.1794951856136322,
-0.3491584062576294,
0.3045846223831177,
-0.20983147621154785,
-0.14745447039604187,
-0.5912784337997437,
0.7640076875686646,
-0.5607515573501587,
0.2230052649974823,
-0.19617363810539246,
0.09448356181383133,
-0.28048205375671387,
0.458940327167511,
0.29415836930274963,
0.9200457334518433,
0.4855446219444275,
-0.453008234500885,
0.24582070112228394,
0.3837352693080902,
-0.4235241115093231,
0.9515262246131897,
-0.612601101398468,
0.17235040664672852,
-0.2885020077228546,
0.19745461642742157,
-0.6490005254745483,
-0.29530003666877747,
0.255718857049942,
-0.3894098401069641,
-0.18567633628845215,
-0.1527935117483139,
-0.638020932674408,
0.09311532229185104,
-0.13837122917175293,
0.733877956867218,
0.4748641550540924,
-0.3755267858505249,
0.5436618328094482,
0.9636037349700928,
-0.15682920813560486,
-0.385048508644104,
-0.5686948895454407,
0.055242713540792465,
-0.4566514492034912,
-0.5490243434906006,
-0.1693459302186966,
0.15331119298934937,
-0.532593309879303,
-0.31793445348739624,
0.19700491428375244,
-0.057544488459825516,
-0.004321809858083725,
0.49234601855278015,
-0.12653858959674835,
0.03492515906691551,
0.19872333109378815,
-0.13863633573055267,
0.08260688930749893,
-0.016006099060177803,
0.3334241807460785,
0.7220488786697388,
0.010653416626155376,
-0.621113657951355,
0.08087434619665146,
0.5020560026168823,
0.11756478995084763,
-0.40962541103363037,
0.6738647818565369,
0.6665328145027161,
-0.41408857703208923,
-0.18854035437107086,
-0.5520250797271729,
-0.15924091637134552,
-0.41875067353248596,
-0.15329770743846893,
-0.24152931571006775,
-0.7694860100746155,
0.8211849927902222,
-0.07833240181207657,
-0.1810348629951477,
0.1340835839509964,
0.7876854538917542,
-0.12143076211214066,
0.24262912571430206,
0.6809582114219666,
0.05276929587125778,
0.19284629821777344,
-0.31490376591682434,
0.22338053584098816,
-0.9551635384559631,
-0.40249210596084595,
-0.27942511439323425,
-0.5236200094223022,
-0.49042248725891113,
-1.1225190162658691,
0.4783095717430115,
0.07912983000278473,
0.09393645077943802,
0.07526104897260666,
-0.46923768520355225,
0.5007857084274292,
0.6277965307235718,
0.1286211460828781,
0.2596471905708313,
0.02469167858362198,
0.18221980333328247,
-0.03481375426054001,
-0.6438627243041992,
-0.6051299571990967,
1.2473500967025757,
-0.03328341618180275,
0.7327398657798767,
0.5120889544487,
0.7365928888320923,
0.5346593856811523,
0.7452951669692993,
-0.579401433467865,
0.5730093121528625,
-0.10717008262872696,
-0.5940508842468262,
-0.18144674599170685,
0.007616701535880566,
-1.0425397157669067,
0.16040852665901184,
-0.28463804721832275,
-0.573708176612854,
0.7383805513381958,
-0.17328013479709625,
-0.3210659325122833,
0.2541312575340271,
-0.518031895160675,
0.4002435803413391,
0.3500787615776062,
-0.32253506779670715,
-0.10055232793092728,
-0.4789558947086334,
0.36075296998023987,
0.1404303014278412,
0.5838363170623779,
-0.3896681070327759,
0.33029597997665405,
0.3779526948928833,
-0.22666560113430023,
1.1801131963729858,
-0.2984252870082855,
-0.08944379538297653,
0.4569462239742279,
0.046930186450481415,
0.19372142851352692,
0.13221052289009094,
-0.14919890463352203,
0.49255698919296265,
0.17211583256721497,
-0.6702672839164734,
-0.33042266964912415,
0.6413282155990601,
-0.8037053346633911,
-0.5970010161399841,
-0.49652332067489624,
-0.5499392747879028,
-0.2929741144180298,
-0.3357757329940796,
-0.19940020143985748,
0.31809842586517334,
-0.20303155481815338,
0.27692773938179016,
0.8868666887283325,
-0.2847230136394501,
0.248854860663414,
0.38380929827690125,
-0.1711845099925995,
0.03713139891624451,
0.7574698328971863,
0.06428781151771545,
0.12268282473087311,
0.23526057600975037,
0.27359455823898315,
-0.17022605240345,
-0.36949312686920166,
-0.3938649594783783,
-0.05245228484272957,
-0.7202087044715881,
-0.10342513024806976,
-0.42414945363998413,
0.04942687600851059,
-0.5234025120735168,
-0.23770752549171448,
0.020746979862451553,
-0.10345764458179474,
-0.12061356753110886,
-0.2587485909461975,
0.260466605424881,
0.7769011855125427,
-0.33183079957962036,
0.05951857566833496,
-0.4446107745170593,
0.22535838186740875,
0.4517970681190491,
-0.014309434220194817,
0.2579925060272217,
-0.1198103204369545,
-0.09231023490428925,
0.0868636891245842,
0.040141552686691284,
-0.9581993222236633,
0.3705956041812897,
-0.28590887784957886,
0.6450288891792297,
0.1999688595533371,
0.27067485451698303,
0.6029976606369019,
-0.26767706871032715,
1.0555719137191772,
-0.0649772584438324,
-0.3980516791343689,
0.5050591230392456,
-0.623029887676239,
0.14044417440891266,
0.6361623406410217,
0.6829600930213928,
-0.8036220669746399,
-0.3126867711544037,
-0.34956690669059753,
-1.1326020956039429,
0.38454222679138184,
0.01497355755418539,
0.7168945074081421,
-0.6125493049621582,
0.26829084753990173,
0.27933067083358765,
0.14847657084465027,
-0.5549011826515198,
-0.07109987735748291,
-0.1839587390422821,
-0.11476320773363113,
0.01481394562870264,
-0.3667292296886444,
-0.4697648286819458,
-0.002040880499407649,
0.5878739356994629,
-0.12146054208278656,
-0.06642942875623703,
0.4152207672595978,
-0.0477229505777359,
0.0375254862010479,
0.1563279926776886,
0.5520003437995911,
1.044561505317688,
0.03591339662671089,
0.18615086376667023,
0.22332294285297394,
-0.4840988516807556,
0.1960001438856125,
-0.19633924961090088,
-0.52944415807724,
-0.3185548186302185,
0.08929796516895294,
0.375977486371994,
-0.1923961639404297,
-0.3956751823425293,
0.47009384632110596,
-0.3047625422477722,
0.09741120040416718,
-0.5484615564346313,
-0.08759748190641403,
0.3058953285217285,
0.24080170691013336,
0.41151684522628784,
-0.29256123304367065,
0.12617218494415283,
-0.7097429037094116,
-0.09056612849235535,
0.3853420615196228,
-0.3105822801589966,
-0.15064562857151031,
0.5480580925941467,
0.4242272675037384,
-0.4626005291938782,
0.500093400478363,
-0.455221951007843,
-0.02193760685622692,
0.5435433983802795,
0.13097719848155975,
0.6660770177841187,
0.029794743284583092,
0.5492925047874451,
0.5477710962295532,
0.19948376715183258,
0.052689328789711,
0.33325085043907166,
-0.4437810778617859,
-0.8822551369667053,
-0.36571088433265686,
-1.1375846862792969,
-0.4443805515766144,
-0.2599254846572876,
-0.6257455945014954,
0.04049339517951012,
-0.33185693621635437,
-0.1485424041748047,
-0.35570910573005676,
-0.1381162703037262,
-0.676334023475647,
0.15903641283512115,
-0.013015671633183956,
0.6746072173118591,
-1.251381278038025,
0.7803196907043457,
0.6943941712379456,
-0.7525431513786316,
-1.0017186403274536,
0.2528475224971771,
0.14088018238544464,
-0.9648758769035339,
0.7297065258026123,
-0.30418726801872253,
0.07825208455324173,
-0.32437777519226074,
-0.3917073607444763,
-0.7999688386917114,
1.3107624053955078,
-0.2178668975830078,
-0.34089019894599915,
0.10857999324798584,
0.24704648554325104,
0.7156147956848145,
-0.08679977059364319,
0.22691155970096588,
-0.07528001815080643,
0.15160459280014038,
0.27653783559799194,
-0.8658702969551086,
0.2063806802034378,
-0.3411322832107544,
0.3152588903903961,
0.034866176545619965,
-0.8859071731567383,
1.0453070402145386,
0.12325340509414673,
-0.29608985781669617,
-0.06246908754110336,
0.7867220640182495,
0.5413076281547546,
0.4129369556903839,
0.4507116973400116,
0.5179653167724609,
0.6469308733940125,
-0.16981905698776245,
1.0058207511901855,
-0.06892616301774979,
0.3940165936946869,
1.1931207180023193,
-0.38311633467674255,
0.8510392308235168,
0.78237384557724,
-0.5503299236297607,
0.4943452775478363,
0.7760040163993835,
0.1689828783273697,
0.4406221807003021,
0.5996171236038208,
-0.5079744458198547,
-0.1453290730714798,
-0.4026295244693756,
-0.39599618315696716,
0.6471657752990723,
0.17298829555511475,
-0.07273656874895096,
-0.35520103573799133,
0.030624832957983017,
0.0880538672208786,
0.5817800760269165,
-0.2952132523059845,
0.8615792393684387,
0.06425485759973526,
-0.4989701509475708,
0.1615344136953354,
-0.002154166577383876,
1.0807942152023315,
-0.6856316924095154,
-0.17613469064235687,
-0.8014359474182129,
-0.157490074634552,
-0.09316603094339371,
-0.5314375758171082,
0.6146295070648193,
-0.10637582093477249,
-0.39507824182510376,
-0.34409210085868835,
0.6435877680778503,
-0.2866612374782562,
-0.5490465760231018,
-0.14421452581882477,
0.5020831823348999,
0.3235068619251251,
0.108847476541996,
-0.24611955881118774,
-0.09028677642345428,
-0.30767011642456055,
-0.0537724494934082,
0.5923934578895569,
0.5795464515686035,
-0.43941277265548706,
0.5163856744766235,
0.9143357872962952,
0.1867520809173584,
0.013636037707328796,
0.15379585325717926,
0.4820963442325592,
-0.33456361293792725,
-0.20861002802848816,
-0.6443482041358948,
0.22314375638961792,
-0.11311391741037369,
-0.40012127161026,
1.003618836402893,
0.40457820892333984,
1.326257586479187,
0.06201474741101265,
0.6234087347984314,
-0.5753579139709473,
0.4509498178958893,
-0.44576242566108704,
0.8279821872711182,
-0.5479964017868042,
0.20264801383018494,
0.14070823788642883,
-0.5680816173553467,
0.036303579807281494,
0.4777359664440155,
-0.32278600335121155,
-0.08455991744995117,
0.11532627791166306,
0.8448641896247864,
-0.03331197425723076,
0.024557938799262047,
0.24815264344215393,
-0.06614962965250015,
0.4005441963672638,
0.15976718068122864,
0.9220143556594849,
-0.16334904730319977,
0.05736218020319939,
-0.4419311583042145,
-0.1964116394519806,
0.2483774870634079,
-0.878782331943512,
-0.5526981353759766,
-0.9050077199935913,
0.043845035135746,
-0.22701396048069,
-0.03966238722205162,
0.8896827101707458,
0.75702965259552,
-0.6375443339347839,
-0.44609400629997253,
0.23791545629501343,
-0.005357593763619661,
-0.1718287318944931,
-0.3038301467895508,
0.23724521696567535,
-0.11617168039083481,
-1.0011026859283447,
0.14556843042373657,
0.1826370358467102,
-0.3135852813720703,
-0.895686149597168,
0.16897031664848328,
-0.5378851294517517,
0.2343025803565979,
0.7011107802391052,
0.32631367444992065,
-0.6659379601478577,
-0.22634682059288025,
0.08253525197505951,
0.061118174344301224,
-0.16541394591331482,
0.8003551363945007,
-0.6798652410507202,
0.5779042840003967,
0.5780849456787109,
0.354523241519928,
0.4519805312156677,
0.025264838710427284,
0.5069692730903625,
-0.9107967615127563,
0.24443776905536652,
0.16448992490768433,
0.20746631920337677,
0.5822792649269104,
-0.1959228515625,
0.7887868285179138,
0.29070374369621277,
-0.5221877098083496,
-0.6935297846794128,
0.1822347342967987,
-0.9199457764625549,
-0.28230932354927063,
1.3565764427185059,
-0.31284138560295105,
-0.32101038098335266,
-0.11733032017946243,
-0.15129955112934113,
0.23377129435539246,
0.07651069760322571,
1.2853562831878662,
0.8732276558876038,
-0.01862654648721218,
0.12034197151660919,
-0.46910831332206726,
0.2655465006828308,
0.22642764449119568,
-0.9760102033615112,
-0.02346102148294449,
0.45489799976348877,
0.510164201259613,
0.30756062269210815,
1.248252034187317,
-0.187798872590065,
-0.11777293682098389,
0.055530648678541183,
0.21839414536952972,
-0.02300955355167389,
0.04267387464642525,
0.14040856063365936,
0.3212738335132599,
-0.006279414519667625,
-0.14058542251586914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15579v1
|
CI w/o TN: Context Injection without Task Name for Procedure Planning
| 2024-02-23T19:34:47 | 2024-02-23T19:34:47 |
Xinjie Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
This paper explores the challenge of procedure planning in instructional
videos, which involves creating goal-directed plans based on visual start and
goal observations from videos. Previous research has tackled this problem with
gradually weaker training supervision, from heavy intermediate visual
observations or language instructions to task class supervision. However, with
the advent of large language models, even given only the task name, these
models can produce a detailed plan. In this study, we propose a much weaker
setting without task name as supervision, which is not currently solvable by
existing large language models since they require good prompts with sufficient
information. Specifically, we hypothesize that previous intermediate
supervisions can serve as context information, and we use captions of visual
start and goal observations as a much cheaper form of supervision. This
approach greatly reduces the labeling cost since the captions can be easily
obtained by large pre-trained vision-language foundation models. Technically,
we apply BLIP to generate captions as supervision to train the context feature
with contrastive learning loss. Afterward, the context feature is fed into the
generator to aid in plan generation. Our experiments on two datasets with
varying scales demonstrate that our model can achieve comparable performance on
multiple metrics, which validates our hypothesis.
|
[
-0.19473887979984283,
-0.4720434248447418,
0.5419945120811462,
0.10400223731994629,
-0.28077232837677,
-0.6785337924957275,
-0.2594359517097473,
0.016019031405448914,
0.2547461986541748,
0.891859769821167,
-0.8001541495323181,
-0.6378859877586365,
-0.6797065734863281,
-0.18984454870224,
-0.4871685802936554,
0.7660088539123535,
-0.06177222728729248,
0.05706264451146126,
-0.04767077416181564,
0.3229522407054901,
-0.5506346821784973,
-0.1097082868218422,
-0.6555580496788025,
-0.1714499443769455,
0.43239161372184753,
0.6878348588943481,
0.09957920014858246,
0.8102855086326599,
0.4995717704296112,
0.32653576135635376,
0.16407503187656403,
0.16640788316726685,
-0.18030919134616852,
-0.16143321990966797,
-0.23661461472511292,
-0.4389883577823639,
-0.19774383306503296,
-0.16009730100631714,
0.3131651282310486,
1.0184450149536133,
-0.09785667806863785,
-0.0024107780773192644,
0.14758753776550293,
0.5754826664924622,
-1.0756946802139282,
0.31491348147392273,
-0.618813693523407,
0.36175158619880676,
0.11727625876665115,
-0.4183373749256134,
-0.45659878849983215,
0.2781566083431244,
0.5062810182571411,
-0.572670042514801,
0.37884193658828735,
-0.13050967454910278,
0.5831928253173828,
0.44391900300979614,
-0.26196590065956116,
-0.3428824245929718,
-0.7921919822692871,
0.7724852561950684,
-0.40890663862228394,
0.1288776993751526,
0.27308744192123413,
0.5652824640274048,
-0.19131243228912354,
-0.8147315382957458,
-0.4837579131126404,
-0.13825087249279022,
-0.0544501431286335,
0.2624203860759735,
0.2043554037809372,
0.5744207501411438,
0.585064172744751,
-0.033599767833948135,
-0.47416627407073975,
-0.106486976146698,
-0.5585141181945801,
-0.017270289361476898,
0.26822271943092346,
0.15204302966594696,
0.05091143772006035,
-0.24383866786956787,
-0.6405991315841675,
-0.1325780153274536,
-0.7630664706230164,
0.11979160457849503,
-0.062321096658706665,
0.5817816257476807,
-0.3557346761226654,
0.7735455632209778,
-0.6069061756134033,
0.7736492156982422,
0.0736953616142273,
-0.3737468719482422,
-0.21639426052570343,
-0.05583886429667473,
-0.8501105904579163,
0.13984662294387817,
0.52826988697052,
0.5213295817375183,
0.36556005477905273,
-0.009586137719452381,
0.060461390763521194,
-0.1612389087677002,
0.3951776623725891,
-0.9357314705848694,
-0.3497235178947449,
0.03522302955389023,
-0.22360695898532867,
0.05705944076180458,
0.15798255801200867,
-0.4677283465862274,
-0.09077571332454681,
-0.739150881767273,
0.2212841659784317,
-0.396985799074173,
0.10503514111042023,
-0.09480062872171402,
-0.23606234788894653,
0.26199594140052795,
0.5254915952682495,
-0.9815793633460999,
0.14926737546920776,
0.5227402448654175,
0.6594105362892151,
-0.1836119443178177,
-0.363663911819458,
-0.8792505860328674,
0.7127055525779724,
-0.3740692138671875,
0.629082977771759,
-0.2827577590942383,
-0.6054458022117615,
0.572180986404419,
0.30587559938430786,
0.16752439737319946,
-0.3639017343521118,
0.10715280473232269,
-0.012477642856538296,
0.16370297968387604,
-0.3757171034812927,
-0.48399674892425537,
0.006195546593517065,
0.2627163827419281,
-0.20879526436328888,
0.29149991273880005,
0.04313148185610771,
-0.5862563252449036,
0.8883903622627258,
-0.6736511588096619,
-0.665308952331543,
0.17855800688266754,
-0.5453293919563293,
0.007348995190113783,
-0.2071080505847931,
0.16445237398147583,
0.6890643239021301,
0.18988201022148132,
0.5104116201400757,
0.0640401840209961,
-0.4739939868450165,
-0.25941768288612366,
-0.053734391927719116,
0.6016436815261841,
0.03988989442586899,
-0.6306533217430115,
0.3139716386795044,
-0.5147151947021484,
-0.12007118761539459,
-0.5094336271286011,
-0.1016857773065567,
-0.332898885011673,
0.013669220730662346,
-0.05869515612721443,
0.1403244435787201,
-0.0343327522277832,
-0.25732895731925964,
0.22902129590511322,
-0.3605109751224518,
0.12342746555805206,
0.47401830554008484,
0.22756223380565643,
0.6586682796478271,
-0.014482853002846241,
0.500490665435791,
0.045134902000427246,
0.2645777463912964,
-0.24338090419769287,
-0.34989073872566223,
-0.8757982850074768,
-0.25222331285476685,
-0.1638495922088623,
0.5638935565948486,
-1.3009350299835205,
0.03845614567399025,
-0.04505668953061104,
-0.31583210825920105,
0.24418239295482635,
0.10945706814527512,
0.8623661994934082,
0.9752908945083618,
0.5061338543891907,
-0.07818997651338577,
-0.693978488445282,
-1.2630980014801025,
-0.015463994815945625,
-0.08654885739088058,
-0.3378754258155823,
0.2581597864627838,
0.4678405821323395,
0.22466696798801422,
0.6065698266029358,
-0.8439131379127502,
-0.7577356696128845,
-0.4743266701698303,
0.10649295896291733,
0.17762738466262817,
0.5936335921287537,
0.3059955835342407,
-0.9063445925712585,
-0.5681981444358826,
-0.20888751745224,
-0.7336889505386353,
0.047735363245010376,
-0.3532581925392151,
-0.26642733812332153,
0.15712429583072662,
0.731395959854126,
-0.39995014667510986,
0.6049864292144775,
0.30447477102279663,
0.042758166790008545,
0.7246077656745911,
-0.17361260950565338,
0.1928001046180725,
-1.200114130973816,
0.1553700715303421,
0.27648600935935974,
0.08164967596530914,
-0.8093997836112976,
-0.051494404673576355,
0.026138337329030037,
-0.21114590764045715,
-1.075813889503479,
0.6375505328178406,
-0.5701637268066406,
0.03857239708304405,
-0.303030788898468,
-0.0016657010419294238,
-0.21393276751041412,
0.8367608785629272,
0.6870142817497253,
0.8317847847938538,
0.7292788624763489,
-0.9947677850723267,
0.02990121766924858,
0.5557197332382202,
-0.26981157064437866,
0.8456224799156189,
-0.5190941691398621,
-0.5653715133666992,
0.10113095492124557,
0.0716276466846466,
-0.5726786255836487,
-0.6253440380096436,
0.5337855219841003,
-0.22369344532489777,
0.4944511651992798,
-0.5503439903259277,
-0.053859956562519073,
-0.20776623487472534,
-0.08715449273586273,
-0.028378628194332123,
0.4208722710609436,
-0.37732264399528503,
0.24004672467708588,
0.17146913707256317,
0.02804441936314106,
-0.8894204497337341,
-0.9636756181716919,
0.12342015653848648,
-0.4371366500854492,
-0.11992773413658142,
0.6785940527915955,
0.07410098612308502,
-0.10005103796720505,
-0.18696855008602142,
-0.260790079832077,
-0.38989466428756714,
-0.3704078793525696,
0.5343545079231262,
0.09357858449220657,
-0.08068462461233139,
0.03422442451119423,
0.22487686574459076,
0.15863482654094696,
0.17207024991512299,
-0.23278506100177765,
0.10431406646966934,
0.47730836272239685,
-0.15613627433776855,
-0.7361611127853394,
0.5933527946472168,
0.25794628262519836,
-0.0022535459138453007,
0.4721194803714752,
0.12103445827960968,
-0.46814361214637756,
-0.3606099486351013,
-0.3847460448741913,
-0.14990052580833435,
-0.5297399759292603,
0.2346860021352768,
-0.4242400527000427,
-0.5635801553726196,
0.07898997515439987,
-0.0803384855389595,
0.129610076546669,
-0.10028446465730667,
0.26511332392692566,
-0.21220947802066803,
0.6416089534759521,
0.8285706639289856,
0.5181049704551697,
0.9056432843208313,
-0.5568879842758179,
-0.1128109022974968,
-0.9195377230644226,
-0.3115256428718567,
-0.13238957524299622,
-0.052202120423316956,
-0.4196172058582306,
-0.4552433490753174,
0.438163161277771,
0.045390013605356216,
-0.20484279096126556,
0.6260083913803101,
-0.5877022743225098,
0.2580541968345642,
0.6641847491264343,
0.10106613487005234,
0.07513751834630966,
0.058821119368076324,
0.10720743983983994,
-0.04694382846355438,
-0.5952394008636475,
-0.5943120121955872,
1.0617085695266724,
-0.3126577138900757,
0.34845760464668274,
-0.35310953855514526,
0.8872714042663574,
0.09563259780406952,
0.3026319444179535,
-0.7235689163208008,
0.922829270362854,
-0.27801886200904846,
-0.25185924768447876,
-0.53322434425354,
-0.09269369393587112,
-0.9217444062232971,
0.0915481373667717,
-0.040538959205150604,
-0.858485758304596,
0.25126639008522034,
0.5234352350234985,
-0.24420323967933655,
0.08561315387487411,
-0.8958387970924377,
1.045110821723938,
0.056825172156095505,
-0.6245132088661194,
0.21269702911376953,
-0.6802665591239929,
0.6321024894714355,
0.31238317489624023,
-0.06456661224365234,
0.24849830567836761,
-0.06019844114780426,
0.6146825551986694,
-0.8702104091644287,
0.9503217935562134,
-0.5374730229377747,
0.13746985793113708,
0.48589426279067993,
-0.09960398077964783,
0.32903751730918884,
0.08392108976840973,
0.3662993907928467,
-0.3921293020248413,
-0.0933220237493515,
-0.3376699388027191,
-0.6200940608978271,
0.6737179160118103,
-0.02381751500070095,
-0.8886265754699707,
-0.031152639538049698,
-0.48426946997642517,
-0.19046032428741455,
0.3406430184841156,
0.3956954777240753,
0.6794273257255554,
0.04217853397130966,
0.0839749202132225,
0.5511476993560791,
-0.21194568276405334,
0.5738029479980469,
0.2848586142063141,
0.14006741344928741,
-0.11019467562437057,
0.7799888253211975,
0.06187427416443825,
0.39404988288879395,
0.5164563059806824,
-0.11925878375768661,
-0.14339882135391235,
-0.7747277021408081,
-0.5010367631912231,
0.04324375465512276,
-0.6513732075691223,
-0.06405413895845413,
-0.4304432272911072,
0.028389830142259598,
-0.32254862785339355,
-0.5083415508270264,
-0.24639227986335754,
-0.185884490609169,
-0.17212921380996704,
0.10077708214521408,
-0.1908615082502365,
0.18067486584186554,
0.08460714668035507,
0.7655884623527527,
-0.35374248027801514,
0.32211974263191223,
0.3318030536174774,
0.040117427706718445,
-0.24700942635536194,
0.0015114379348233342,
-0.21052519977092743,
-0.05140630900859833,
-0.3665991425514221,
-0.924630880355835,
0.4513779282569885,
0.1242155134677887,
0.3496738076210022,
0.8223944902420044,
0.2694222331047058,
1.0807470083236694,
-0.7583659291267395,
0.8671517968177795,
0.3160319924354553,
-0.6887909173965454,
1.0485069751739502,
-0.27445000410079956,
0.45511096715927124,
0.6836362481117249,
0.4392925500869751,
-0.10042596608400345,
-0.652989387512207,
-0.5227325558662415,
-0.7606802582740784,
0.6616021990776062,
0.10439253598451614,
0.11759993433952332,
-0.1992034912109375,
0.37098875641822815,
0.08540977537631989,
0.41761815547943115,
-0.49215826392173767,
-0.0635126382112503,
-0.21789340674877167,
0.14657343924045563,
0.05777246505022049,
-0.08678135275840759,
-0.3366057276725769,
-0.03417263552546501,
0.40891745686531067,
-0.23037941753864288,
0.09558907151222229,
0.39785468578338623,
-0.02439524047076702,
0.10132915526628494,
0.19956177473068237,
0.8152821063995361,
0.7662240266799927,
-0.020659958943724632,
0.09581777453422546,
0.059470973908901215,
-0.3350803256034851,
-0.16647478938102722,
-0.16427715122699738,
-0.2248886078596115,
0.03557863458991051,
0.5975728631019592,
0.6982865333557129,
0.6589219570159912,
-0.8606929183006287,
0.5946782231330872,
0.19660158455371857,
-0.5823819041252136,
-0.7137479782104492,
0.4234323799610138,
-0.13263732194900513,
0.4070826470851898,
0.13344356417655945,
-0.18786685168743134,
0.4610678553581238,
-0.5196797251701355,
0.2780657112598419,
0.320563405752182,
-0.565104067325592,
-0.0699937641620636,
0.7040911316871643,
0.11486654728651047,
-0.4704795777797699,
0.3855137228965759,
-0.19926176965236664,
-0.16281810402870178,
0.7811996936798096,
0.29093047976493835,
0.5665947794914246,
-0.18385416269302368,
0.42625701427459717,
0.5764787793159485,
0.0648280531167984,
-0.07165513187646866,
0.3820452094078064,
-0.4123868942260742,
-0.07530363649129868,
-0.5069849491119385,
-0.39010488986968994,
-0.4172051250934601,
0.1537104696035385,
-0.7963873744010925,
0.6149252653121948,
-0.3187253177165985,
0.17497281730175018,
-0.13757508993148804,
-0.24344007670879364,
-0.6228929758071899,
0.4965299665927887,
-0.08981470763683319,
0.9084058403968811,
-0.6735879778862,
0.8135325908660889,
0.6847919821739197,
-0.5027070641517639,
-0.7135254144668579,
0.08071567863225937,
-0.11245035380125046,
-0.39687880873680115,
0.8423775434494019,
0.43145525455474854,
0.12272137403488159,
-0.2767864465713501,
-0.5205615758895874,
-0.4050915539264679,
1.0680761337280273,
0.0886312797665596,
-0.5907652378082275,
-0.5507868528366089,
0.037065453827381134,
0.4957561492919922,
-0.460133820772171,
-0.24335603415966034,
0.15541972219944,
0.44037023186683655,
0.6741187572479248,
-0.6064163446426392,
0.004323067143559456,
0.1851026713848114,
-0.06923922151327133,
0.1473953127861023,
-0.14166182279586792,
0.5563111901283264,
-0.49030905961990356,
-0.37389907240867615,
0.06841421127319336,
0.7353536486625671,
0.2585897743701935,
0.4036957323551178,
0.5485120415687561,
0.10583636909723282,
0.006472576875239611,
0.049428533762693405,
1.0766105651855469,
-0.04721227288246155,
-0.19162814319133759,
1.5076556205749512,
-0.03110448084771633,
0.7793665528297424,
0.9373214244842529,
0.05568293482065201,
0.20176610350608826,
0.4521326720714569,
-0.0743485614657402,
0.9505624175071716,
0.23506836593151093,
0.011069461703300476,
-0.2329837679862976,
-0.1803421974182129,
-0.05162271112203598,
0.5082710981369019,
0.32639482617378235,
-0.3204995393753052,
-0.19403211772441864,
0.21808966994285583,
-0.04388226196169853,
0.21974287927150726,
-0.37447255849838257,
0.6045160293579102,
-0.016603415831923485,
-1.1477125883102417,
0.44468724727630615,
-0.35902807116508484,
0.33536767959594727,
-0.5680906176567078,
-0.2295275628566742,
-0.18983830511569977,
-0.01583169586956501,
-0.17925997078418732,
-0.5830391049385071,
0.5215195417404175,
0.02334277704358101,
0.09278364479541779,
-0.3560269773006439,
0.13352420926094055,
-0.7516376972198486,
-0.3035419285297394,
-0.0261103305965662,
0.4132354259490967,
0.24996574223041534,
-0.057569704949855804,
-0.237532377243042,
-0.4427492916584015,
-0.11766115576028824,
-0.18974235653877258,
0.39294058084487915,
0.3358995020389557,
-0.14834290742874146,
0.6089620590209961,
0.32905828952789307,
0.09455814212560654,
-0.09268783032894135,
-0.046921201050281525,
0.724025309085846,
-0.4017193019390106,
-0.4793657064437866,
-0.5214982032775879,
0.790955662727356,
-0.28820791840553284,
-0.317792683839798,
0.3177119791507721,
0.5259950757026672,
0.9460350275039673,
-0.45056527853012085,
0.5090405344963074,
-0.06302861869335175,
0.12250041961669922,
-0.8031662106513977,
0.4577597677707672,
-0.7593066096305847,
0.025014633312821388,
-0.48278123140335083,
-0.8791525363922119,
-0.3564492166042328,
0.29805049300193787,
-0.2926616072654724,
-0.19648651778697968,
0.8420583605766296,
0.7254745960235596,
-0.18915052711963654,
-0.4042448103427887,
0.5394996404647827,
-0.246038019657135,
0.34973445534706116,
0.6851113438606262,
0.4784090220928192,
-0.0016804029000923038,
0.7046298384666443,
-0.5787955522537231,
-0.2939404547214508,
-0.22061574459075928,
-0.9736070036888123,
-1.311867594718933,
-0.7957789301872253,
-0.39592355489730835,
0.22854003310203552,
0.3584946393966675,
0.56499844789505,
1.0369045734405518,
-0.5195463299751282,
-0.4109993278980255,
-0.30669689178466797,
-0.03415997326374054,
-0.3360178470611572,
-0.24985742568969727,
0.46388736367225647,
-0.4182072877883911,
-1.0243619680404663,
0.5417067408561707,
0.1752135306596756,
0.0038699128199368715,
-0.22393487393856049,
-0.053355056792497635,
-0.06963139027357101,
-0.26367130875587463,
0.5765426158905029,
0.48068445920944214,
-0.9601386785507202,
-0.4177516996860504,
-0.11180712282657623,
0.07559680938720703,
-0.1898256540298462,
0.9658809900283813,
-0.5096251368522644,
0.5438023209571838,
0.09452490508556366,
0.2906613349914551,
0.8084796071052551,
-0.054051876068115234,
0.6316490173339844,
-0.9993054866790771,
0.41728347539901733,
-0.03744529187679291,
0.37856152653694153,
0.04178010672330856,
-0.36223044991493225,
0.578672468662262,
-0.13631024956703186,
-0.11120177805423737,
-0.7804485559463501,
0.4775760769844055,
-1.2886735200881958,
-0.1948988437652588,
1.0320931673049927,
-0.4019215404987335,
-0.231041818857193,
0.13963784277439117,
-0.37998318672180176,
0.37504515051841736,
-0.2799818515777588,
0.7825024724006653,
0.4259529113769531,
-0.3309180438518524,
-0.2629939317703247,
-0.9109842777252197,
0.6983771920204163,
0.2008897364139557,
-0.7840431928634644,
0.03449341654777527,
0.6000203490257263,
0.10448270291090012,
0.019861193373799324,
0.6233525276184082,
0.186244398355484,
0.481635719537735,
-0.09827899932861328,
0.06740159541368484,
-0.35675737261772156,
-0.7500147819519043,
0.259311318397522,
0.3940580189228058,
-0.2618715465068817,
-0.48795458674430847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15571v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15571v1
|
Social Convos: Capturing Agendas and Emotions on Social Media
| 2024-02-23T19:14:09 | 2024-02-23T19:14:09 |
Ankita Bhaumik, Ning Sa, Gregorios Katsios, Tomek Strzalkowski
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL
|
Social media platforms are popular tools for disseminating targeted
information during major public events like elections or pandemics. Systematic
analysis of the message traffic can provide valuable insights into prevailing
opinions and social dynamics among different segments of the population. We are
specifically interested in influence spread, and in particular whether more
deliberate influence operations can be detected. However, filtering out the
essential messages with telltale influence indicators from the extensive and
often chaotic social media traffic is a major challenge. In this paper we
present a novel approach to extract influence indicators from messages
circulating among groups of users discussing particular topics. We build upon
the concept of a convo to identify influential authors who are actively
promoting some particular agenda around that topic within the group. We focus
on two influence indicators: the (control of) agenda and the use of emotional
language.
|
[
-0.6080467700958252,
-0.9254894256591797,
0.45578503608703613,
0.437210351228714,
-0.6164194941520691,
0.1554698497056961,
-0.12776902318000793,
-0.49922555685043335,
0.8668321371078491,
0.548058807849884,
-0.6836628913879395,
-0.6025534272193909,
-1.1395126581192017,
-0.22154134511947632,
-0.5688124895095825,
0.9055876731872559,
0.20250850915908813,
-0.19139905273914337,
0.37094223499298096,
-0.055997688323259354,
-0.0341058112680912,
-0.3499542474746704,
-0.8505347371101379,
-0.24884472787380219,
0.6640454530715942,
0.2572484016418457,
0.5381596684455872,
0.1618068963289261,
0.2870437204837799,
0.22610723972320557,
-0.10442695021629333,
0.3202708959579468,
-1.0863206386566162,
0.1971089392900467,
-0.3091168999671936,
-0.05289177596569061,
-0.026647767052054405,
0.051327019929885864,
0.412673681974411,
0.23278406262397766,
-0.0703074112534523,
0.09578893333673477,
0.18398097157478333,
0.7237148880958557,
-0.5301806926727295,
0.20406940579414368,
-0.6947464942932129,
-0.1939186453819275,
-0.6371113657951355,
-0.4574982523918152,
-0.2959468960762024,
-0.6817014217376709,
-0.016456319019198418,
-0.45891979336738586,
-0.31615108251571655,
-0.03219820559024811,
0.5605015158653259,
-0.03651123121380806,
-0.7451428174972534,
-0.7433266639709473,
-0.5736802816390991,
0.6792956590652466,
-0.2933584153652191,
0.22610363364219666,
0.317958265542984,
0.1463623344898224,
-0.48212170600891113,
-0.5324434638023376,
-0.5162950158119202,
0.5407058000564575,
0.061816394329071045,
0.09707667678594589,
-0.7353848218917847,
-0.1932285577058792,
-0.05218876153230667,
-0.11167367547750473,
0.04619473218917847,
-0.18368512392044067,
-0.5198778510093689,
0.05592210590839386,
0.8331213593482971,
0.01931026019155979,
0.4922787845134735,
-0.11754079163074493,
-0.1305752396583557,
0.20962277054786682,
-0.5633979439735413,
0.2852010428905487,
0.4363842010498047,
0.1346462517976761,
-0.6034390330314636,
0.39533311128616333,
-0.13119664788246155,
0.3060341477394104,
0.5336381793022156,
0.21934160590171814,
0.0917486771941185,
-0.40295249223709106,
0.1042751893401146,
0.10252245515584946,
0.9976338744163513,
0.6297221779823303,
0.5001847147941589,
0.1948089748620987,
0.16536428034305573,
0.0284052025526762,
0.03194757178425789,
-1.0075204372406006,
-0.038748279213905334,
0.15490619838237762,
-0.8188283443450928,
-0.15730911493301392,
0.3427562713623047,
-1.3108546733856201,
-1.1039903163909912,
-0.15635651350021362,
0.0944986641407013,
-0.15694110095500946,
-0.7995796203613281,
0.21370531618595123,
-0.4624623954296112,
0.23665058612823486,
0.3508467674255371,
-0.7541877031326294,
0.18155419826507568,
0.998650074005127,
0.8857371807098389,
0.15766754746437073,
0.5164339542388916,
-0.351339191198349,
-0.019616179168224335,
-0.35800790786743164,
0.8133769035339355,
-0.8151975274085999,
-0.3601750135421753,
0.4863832890987396,
0.20181414484977722,
0.29328641295433044,
-0.05087501183152199,
0.3247995376586914,
-0.659359335899353,
-0.2764225900173187,
-0.6464897394180298,
-0.5955312252044678,
-0.2336875945329666,
-0.039995159953832626,
-0.4428523778915405,
0.574292004108429,
-0.04580723121762276,
-0.6086012125015259,
0.319667786359787,
-0.47195473313331604,
-0.5656116008758545,
0.18509870767593384,
-0.32019200921058655,
-0.08801311254501343,
0.21154944598674774,
0.12211468815803528,
0.7407400012016296,
-0.25702133774757385,
0.05948135629296303,
-0.6634069085121155,
-0.14175322651863098,
0.2783871591091156,
-0.05410201847553253,
0.7775266170501709,
0.08919006586074829,
-0.3271157741546631,
0.2820069491863251,
-0.5048114061355591,
-0.37682726979255676,
-0.1928604692220688,
0.22207790613174438,
-0.8008258938789368,
0.32271188497543335,
-0.08124654740095139,
0.11441629379987717,
0.0452776663005352,
-0.39870426058769226,
0.24880126118659973,
0.18134620785713196,
0.3324994742870331,
0.6669240593910217,
1.211663007736206,
0.3287583589553833,
-0.228875994682312,
0.47233474254608154,
0.0622975192964077,
0.12189169228076935,
0.2279013991355896,
-0.687895655632019,
-0.3942992091178894,
-0.10491012036800385,
-0.37787890434265137,
0.19174055755138397,
-0.7557024955749512,
0.20421116054058075,
0.11939717829227448,
-0.9792329668998718,
-0.5717570185661316,
0.3311353325843811,
0.17162929475307465,
-0.11655721068382263,
-0.015731189399957657,
0.09633166342973709,
-0.4788071811199188,
-0.5381420850753784,
-0.4803081154823303,
-0.004608129151165485,
0.20647971332073212,
0.23731772601604462,
0.21988272666931152,
-0.1935979276895523,
0.366850346326828,
-0.36343875527381897,
-0.14079131186008453,
-0.3324677050113678,
0.5198388695716858,
0.3382776081562042,
0.18496347963809967,
0.6731022000312805,
-0.9821118116378784,
-0.7953267693519592,
0.14583726227283478,
-0.446843683719635,
-0.39675816893577576,
-0.3132035434246063,
-0.5813483595848083,
-0.3229526877403259,
0.749868631362915,
-0.3518384099006653,
0.4966404438018799,
0.3724209666252136,
-0.567195475101471,
0.20406246185302734,
0.3294413387775421,
0.6035916209220886,
-0.8082905411720276,
-0.3720986843109131,
0.5562489032745361,
-0.12874610722064972,
-0.6895309686660767,
-0.7304953932762146,
-0.18638457357883453,
0.20218683779239655,
-0.4147997796535492,
0.3986572325229645,
-0.4282172620296478,
0.5034257173538208,
-0.062290143221616745,
0.43951085209846497,
-0.24228857457637787,
0.24947887659072876,
-0.17346009612083435,
0.13631552457809448,
0.6942799687385559,
-0.5196147561073303,
0.2423088401556015,
0.10962288826704025,
-0.6467022895812988,
0.7492581009864807,
-0.5363566279411316,
0.28523093461990356,
-0.42214664816856384,
0.024994583800435066,
-1.2976385354995728,
-0.2970055937767029,
0.5362699627876282,
-0.2649897038936615,
-0.005129643715918064,
-0.37273651361465454,
-0.17651556432247162,
0.023017816245555878,
-0.2258192002773285,
-0.24297328293323517,
0.42475754022598267,
-0.05084743723273277,
0.6955277919769287,
1.1531507968902588,
0.020375294610857964,
-0.3408961892127991,
-0.1542334109544754,
-0.14269566535949707,
-0.3597218096256256,
-0.37429285049438477,
-0.03208310902118683,
0.46371719241142273,
-0.5687835812568665,
0.20299939811229706,
0.08568761497735977,
0.13357293605804443,
-0.19617405533790588,
0.7371971607208252,
-0.43640196323394775,
0.1474393904209137,
0.21611669659614563,
0.3164513111114502,
0.1854221373796463,
0.32573938369750977,
0.13260191679000854,
0.8004614114761353,
-0.07165871560573578,
0.0474870428442955,
-0.8265923261642456,
0.6354764103889465,
0.9167123436927795,
-0.17869560420513153,
0.6522486805915833,
0.5296730995178223,
-0.45099928975105286,
-0.45691266655921936,
-0.34674665331840515,
-0.21473415195941925,
-0.5123233199119568,
0.2527141273021698,
-0.0002623252512421459,
-0.4490537941455841,
0.7845145463943481,
-0.3240646719932556,
0.04943501204252243,
0.3129228949546814,
0.6731637716293335,
-0.1256594955921173,
1.060111403465271,
0.5882732272148132,
-0.2009122371673584,
0.9643409848213196,
-0.432629257440567,
0.007273463997989893,
-0.44064265489578247,
-0.3490265905857086,
-0.4982098937034607,
-0.5086942911148071,
-0.7600163221359253,
-0.09366006404161453,
0.30764493346214294,
-0.12082228064537048,
-0.055642180144786835,
0.1702415496110916,
-0.4594297707080841,
0.11820961534976959,
0.34500953555107117,
0.47904351353645325,
-0.1657487004995346,
-0.12839432060718536,
0.4769355356693268,
0.09292790293693542,
-0.47050854563713074,
-0.44712451100349426,
0.5181072950363159,
0.10089893639087677,
0.7992913126945496,
0.1299700289964676,
0.4112958312034607,
0.9279913902282715,
0.7648327350616455,
-0.5574482679367065,
0.6813355088233948,
-0.16536857187747955,
-0.5864607691764832,
-0.11644255369901657,
-0.16364958882331848,
-1.1790093183517456,
0.05726919323205948,
-0.6698136329650879,
-1.0117549896240234,
0.7317630052566528,
0.01782853715121746,
-0.23298785090446472,
0.3570045828819275,
-0.4192657470703125,
0.8759090900421143,
-0.138777956366539,
-0.25586819648742676,
-0.6373744606971741,
-0.598354160785675,
0.1434118151664734,
-0.036630865186452866,
0.3903268575668335,
-0.5564711689949036,
0.05180339515209198,
0.8034477233886719,
-0.05599355325102806,
1.0442614555358887,
-0.4093831479549408,
0.10224347561597824,
0.6227469444274902,
-0.027831727638840675,
0.6501035690307617,
-0.04173050448298454,
-0.1928919106721878,
0.2604694068431854,
-0.09947554022073746,
-0.04789115861058235,
-0.630143404006958,
0.4784713685512543,
-0.724799633026123,
-0.4083777964115143,
0.06807804107666016,
-0.15735767781734467,
0.18596495687961578,
0.22215214371681213,
0.300634503364563,
0.5272871255874634,
-0.23028767108917236,
0.39666053652763367,
0.18788845837116241,
0.25473225116729736,
0.39307472109794617,
0.23655609786510468,
-0.19452711939811707,
-0.530256450176239,
0.6748767495155334,
0.43989071249961853,
0.2616843581199646,
0.016530774533748627,
0.4512869715690613,
-0.09647569805383682,
-0.35825687646865845,
-0.07456042617559433,
0.24384023249149323,
-0.5459456443786621,
-0.1467590034008026,
-0.728473961353302,
0.2821206748485565,
-0.28943049907684326,
-0.4036661386489868,
-0.2035350650548935,
0.06637836992740631,
-0.3774881660938263,
0.06092694029211998,
0.5823853015899658,
0.8514657020568848,
-0.18243354558944702,
1.045066237449646,
-0.4401352107524872,
0.16174007952213287,
0.002134550828486681,
0.15209372341632843,
-0.10984739661216736,
-0.013252400793135166,
-0.23501808941364288,
0.018453868106007576,
-0.32250910997390747,
-1.7910761833190918,
0.3829679787158966,
0.18717898428440094,
0.35871952772140503,
1.3601680994033813,
0.3688676953315735,
0.5048468708992004,
0.025078706443309784,
0.6070491075515747,
0.14088821411132812,
-1.0492569208145142,
0.5697380900382996,
-0.47244399785995483,
0.010774645954370499,
0.5684690475463867,
0.6497384905815125,
-0.8819819092750549,
-0.842525064945221,
-0.7738701701164246,
-0.6364398002624512,
0.2301812469959259,
-0.019743960350751877,
0.2010781168937683,
-0.2657477855682373,
0.4381997883319855,
-0.18157704174518585,
0.42155706882476807,
-0.40523800253868103,
-0.19671791791915894,
-0.008291221223771572,
-0.2717042565345764,
0.2950502932071686,
-0.4672694206237793,
-0.13623909652233124,
-0.006734984926879406,
0.6256787180900574,
0.2641332447528839,
-0.07095744460821152,
0.24046634137630463,
0.5350228548049927,
-0.26233962178230286,
-0.05724399536848068,
0.1620677262544632,
0.4615168273448944,
-0.2221183329820633,
0.3918324410915375,
-0.3645402789115906,
-0.5254351496696472,
0.04172742739319801,
-0.26915213465690613,
-0.2688564360141754,
0.182834193110466,
0.23402488231658936,
0.4941355288028717,
0.1474018692970276,
-0.30643656849861145,
0.43988236784935,
-0.035107169300317764,
-0.05384982004761696,
-0.2899084687232971,
0.1573491394519806,
0.15321435034275055,
0.5155444145202637,
0.4580976963043213,
-0.14703482389450073,
0.2612614929676056,
-0.7398517727851868,
0.3011273145675659,
0.6580813527107239,
-1.0652507543563843,
-0.719007134437561,
0.3826075792312622,
0.5446374416351318,
-0.5429064631462097,
0.16084831953048706,
-0.3965752422809601,
-0.596057653427124,
0.7384384274482727,
0.26606646180152893,
0.8676813244819641,
-0.20443841814994812,
0.04648784175515175,
0.13525700569152832,
0.3847633898258209,
0.11416708678007126,
0.6074779629707336,
-0.04456215724349022,
-0.9416512250900269,
-0.20914845168590546,
0.0512041412293911,
-0.4073809087276459,
0.11155321449041367,
-0.6489001512527466,
0.614483118057251,
-0.4601327180862427,
-0.7028868198394775,
0.5691214799880981,
0.08422341197729111,
-0.4450988471508026,
-0.2555485665798187,
-0.023565489798784256,
0.5872457027435303,
-1.0861952304840088,
0.4876157343387604,
0.5695750117301941,
0.07983832061290741,
-0.6757690906524658,
-0.019148381426930428,
0.2763245105743408,
-0.38712868094444275,
0.18012207746505737,
0.20121382176876068,
-0.3318804204463959,
0.0006972505943849683,
-1.051033616065979,
-0.48294734954833984,
0.46036025881767273,
0.055303070694208145,
-0.5601087212562561,
0.5684980154037476,
-0.2782004177570343,
0.39740675687789917,
-0.6501956582069397,
-0.14869514107704163,
0.5157908797264099,
0.6702885627746582,
0.08525755256414413,
-0.1878095120191574,
0.14974652230739594,
-0.4372819662094116,
-0.6704578995704651,
0.6124829053878784,
-0.773383378982544,
0.38712555170059204,
-0.022388599812984467,
-0.5866475701332092,
-0.5963401198387146,
0.6883237361907959,
-0.018460042774677277,
0.6934204697608948,
0.8695489168167114,
-0.31348660588264465,
0.8210955858230591,
-0.03237621486186981,
1.0094345808029175,
-0.65888911485672,
0.1722257435321808,
0.7299723625183105,
-0.1203446239233017,
0.5827534794807434,
0.6079229712486267,
0.18997830152511597,
0.4471878111362457,
0.624140739440918,
0.18645577132701874,
0.6722922325134277,
0.285143107175827,
-0.2398071140050888,
-0.3809940814971924,
-0.36725151538848877,
-0.2639848589897156,
0.4622548520565033,
0.9380114078521729,
-0.17523033916950226,
-0.04654868692159653,
0.11994904279708862,
0.5493208169937134,
0.0862136110663414,
-0.5313339829444885,
0.6492916345596313,
0.14514076709747314,
-0.6515021324157715,
-0.006010366603732109,
-0.42217543721199036,
0.46042072772979736,
-0.6664637327194214,
-0.1936625838279724,
0.008858143351972103,
0.21588094532489777,
-0.08553212136030197,
-0.802686333656311,
0.41689029335975647,
-0.1345704048871994,
0.18927925825119019,
-0.12831272184848785,
0.9076964855194092,
-0.6909053325653076,
-0.4348396360874176,
0.447521448135376,
0.4204207956790924,
0.3537522852420807,
-0.14947235584259033,
-0.3690013587474823,
0.23708902299404144,
0.0947851836681366,
-0.3552960455417633,
-0.3494725823402405,
0.8547869920730591,
-0.07287085801362991,
0.5000618100166321,
0.5698003768920898,
0.3359094262123108,
-0.05314207449555397,
-0.0369454026222229,
0.7489487528800964,
-0.3808456361293793,
-0.21906286478042603,
-1.0522687435150146,
0.3950694799423218,
-0.5596762895584106,
-0.5142455101013184,
0.9080607295036316,
0.15466171503067017,
0.26321884989738464,
0.26153916120529175,
0.5538933277130127,
-0.1692100316286087,
0.24829019606113434,
0.005978712346404791,
1.0079491138458252,
-0.4224528968334198,
-0.052457544952631,
-0.5362560749053955,
-0.18309688568115234,
-0.11567789316177368,
0.3397592604160309,
-0.24821756780147552,
-0.49603474140167236,
-0.10145679116249084,
0.6401066184043884,
0.20004652440547943,
0.287209689617157,
-0.05898495763540268,
0.37640243768692017,
0.5676233172416687,
0.3084089457988739,
0.9185760617256165,
0.0881795734167099,
0.34435781836509705,
-0.1338965743780136,
-0.508132815361023,
-0.42710351943969727,
-1.0345228910446167,
-0.9662646055221558,
-0.5607219338417053,
-0.49884817004203796,
-0.6332500576972961,
0.08868306130170822,
1.1212594509124756,
0.8720569610595703,
-0.5994610786437988,
-0.1841164231300354,
0.08009520173072815,
0.7860431671142578,
-0.6240412592887878,
-0.16849371790885925,
0.6973426342010498,
0.032554835081100464,
-0.7094457745552063,
0.0012051652884110808,
0.26323267817497253,
-0.030969062820076942,
-0.20839156210422516,
0.40901243686676025,
-0.3582912087440491,
0.6877526044845581,
0.46281856298446655,
0.1880158931016922,
-0.19019116461277008,
-0.23446683585643768,
-0.09373399615287781,
-0.043484222143888474,
-0.29846617579460144,
0.9006078839302063,
-0.15829576551914215,
0.44337520003318787,
0.6547446250915527,
0.11361173540353775,
0.6007649898529053,
0.18834127485752106,
0.30423206090927124,
-0.5734079480171204,
0.33343449234962463,
0.019592544063925743,
0.3932635188102722,
-0.022697875276207924,
-0.5921688079833984,
0.3630814254283905,
0.30219167470932007,
-0.42522597312927246,
-0.6891176700592041,
-0.01974123902618885,
-1.228334903717041,
-0.01270755659788847,
1.475850224494934,
0.07297848165035248,
-0.2510548532009125,
-0.4223853647708893,
-0.29035964608192444,
0.38395169377326965,
-0.8227986693382263,
0.8745834231376648,
0.6295830011367798,
-0.23768427968025208,
-0.17758908867835999,
-0.677969217300415,
0.5366883277893066,
-0.14875996112823486,
-0.8444998264312744,
0.02992919273674488,
0.34785640239715576,
-0.13401439785957336,
0.25017020106315613,
0.7862087488174438,
-0.027410676702857018,
-0.1958284080028534,
-0.10446534305810928,
-0.04549442604184151,
0.2693427801132202,
-0.23819273710250854,
0.18117846548557281,
0.6335242986679077,
-0.8394516110420227,
-0.397940069437027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15570v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15570v1
|
Fast Adversarial Attacks on Language Models In One GPU Minute
| 2024-02-23T19:12:53 | 2024-02-23T19:12:53 |
Vinu Sankar Sadasivan, Shoumik Saha, Gaurang Sriramanan, Priyatham Kattakinda, Atoosa Chegini, Soheil Feizi
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce a novel class of fast, beam search-based
adversarial attack (BEAST) for Language Models (LMs). BEAST employs
interpretable parameters, enabling attackers to balance between attack speed,
success rate, and the readability of adversarial prompts. The computational
efficiency of BEAST facilitates us to investigate its applications on LMs for
jailbreaking, eliciting hallucinations, and privacy attacks. Our gradient-free
targeted attack can jailbreak aligned LMs with high attack success rates within
one minute. For instance, BEAST can jailbreak Vicuna-7B-v1.5 under one minute
with a success rate of 89% when compared to a gradient-based baseline that
takes over an hour to achieve 70% success rate using a single Nvidia RTX A6000
48GB GPU. Additionally, we discover a unique outcome wherein our untargeted
attack induces hallucinations in LM chatbots. Through human evaluations, we
find that our untargeted attack causes Vicuna-7B-v1.5 to produce ~15% more
incorrect outputs when compared to LM outputs in the absence of our attack. We
also learn that 22% of the time, BEAST causes Vicuna to generate outputs that
are not relevant to the original prompt. Further, we use BEAST to generate
adversarial prompts in a few seconds that can boost the performance of existing
membership inference attacks for LMs. We believe that our fast attack, BEAST,
has the potential to accelerate research in LM security and privacy. Our
codebase is publicly available at https://github.com/vinusankars/BEAST.
|
[
-0.3986935019493103,
-1.3008003234863281,
0.24284736812114716,
0.2536105811595917,
-0.322923481464386,
0.20747952163219452,
0.009370772168040276,
-0.3605426847934723,
0.21957430243492126,
0.6150642037391663,
-0.5756293535232544,
-0.28396075963974,
-0.5782511234283447,
-0.3556801974773407,
-0.6854600310325623,
0.6716628670692444,
0.7073906064033508,
-0.028778621926903725,
0.3817238211631775,
-0.061751220375299454,
-0.37890860438346863,
-0.4703829884529114,
-0.9552250504493713,
-0.21186985075473785,
0.528266429901123,
-0.21583031117916107,
1.245709776878357,
0.9142007231712341,
0.5705693364143372,
0.3175649344921112,
-0.29066306352615356,
0.024458637461066246,
-0.6678298711776733,
0.15703843533992767,
-0.08328485488891602,
-0.11872491985559464,
-0.29583707451820374,
-0.1725539267063141,
0.3245464563369751,
0.3027353584766388,
-0.24887695908546448,
-0.03580150380730629,
-0.02357383444905281,
0.6541725397109985,
-0.623416006565094,
-0.03181922808289528,
-0.944484531879425,
0.261681467294693,
-0.4925975203514099,
-0.13343799114227295,
-0.4839800298213959,
-0.27909427881240845,
-0.19538411498069763,
-0.40430766344070435,
0.49564751982688904,
0.05762641504406929,
0.808498203754425,
0.36790281534194946,
0.07313793897628784,
-0.17694129049777985,
-0.46650779247283936,
0.28820866346359253,
-0.5750481486320496,
0.3880046606063843,
0.021024588495492935,
0.3242519497871399,
-0.5619198083877563,
-0.7612806558609009,
-0.3817950189113617,
-0.3786868155002594,
0.004157668445259333,
-0.20655296742916107,
-0.6228466033935547,
0.13703441619873047,
0.4794396758079529,
0.25740867853164673,
-0.7690064311027527,
0.2512170672416687,
-0.33763644099235535,
-0.3278152048587799,
0.5927790999412537,
0.369875967502594,
0.4570792317390442,
-0.16865170001983643,
-0.3510974943637848,
-0.23666541278362274,
-0.6042165756225586,
0.19659803807735443,
0.5782405734062195,
0.4896833002567291,
0.14186504483222961,
0.2693498134613037,
0.0915779247879982,
0.7015277743339539,
-0.004156266804784536,
0.15158475935459137,
-0.17436891794204712,
0.11659211665391922,
-0.2567403316497803,
0.20506536960601807,
1.292668104171753,
0.005565340165048838,
-0.27414757013320923,
-0.4444802403450012,
-0.14405736327171326,
0.2760399878025055,
0.5892596244812012,
-1.1217963695526123,
-0.29009872674942017,
0.28446337580680847,
-0.299893856048584,
-0.5343254208564758,
-0.05796155706048012,
-0.9605674147605896,
-1.0510056018829346,
0.43904179334640503,
0.450731098651886,
-0.5820876955986023,
-0.1723870486021042,
0.37024205923080444,
-0.030088666826486588,
0.2402522712945938,
0.05884866416454315,
-0.8102383613586426,
0.23294377326965332,
0.8211570382118225,
0.8626728057861328,
-0.029586713761091232,
-0.23648086190223694,
-0.9712011218070984,
-0.2819083034992218,
-0.4221717417240143,
0.6065240502357483,
-0.38998088240623474,
-0.777543842792511,
-0.218125119805336,
-0.1970110386610031,
-0.05723283812403679,
-0.4701237976551056,
0.7092310786247253,
-0.5781480669975281,
0.06794759631156921,
0.14442598819732666,
-0.37412142753601074,
-0.14053532481193542,
0.05010359734296799,
-0.9233018159866333,
0.8309912085533142,
-0.19883671402931213,
-0.8394373059272766,
-0.2429266721010208,
-0.7996726036071777,
-0.46987468004226685,
0.21428726613521576,
-0.026176275685429573,
-0.3210090100765228,
0.2654542326927185,
0.2790783941745758,
0.38938456773757935,
-0.26369616389274597,
0.2542363703250885,
-0.5111990571022034,
-0.6039270758628845,
0.5441857576370239,
-0.42775478959083557,
0.9312636852264404,
0.44577556848526,
-0.4527171850204468,
0.21284334361553192,
-0.6604222059249878,
0.2156178057193756,
0.4709358215332031,
0.08212640136480331,
-0.2341565638780594,
0.24568136036396027,
-0.03988521918654442,
-0.02161654829978943,
0.10049817711114883,
-0.4398251175880432,
0.3237742483615875,
-0.42486807703971863,
0.4174403250217438,
0.6908445954322815,
-0.2180417776107788,
0.1130664050579071,
0.09858851879835129,
0.48195749521255493,
-0.33320194482803345,
0.44402700662612915,
-0.1629217565059662,
-0.35456550121307373,
-0.46526414155960083,
-0.3166179060935974,
0.16408196091651917,
0.562101423740387,
-0.9443058967590332,
0.1643528938293457,
0.09753527492284775,
-0.8137983083724976,
-0.9196478128433228,
0.056434266269207,
0.7428005337715149,
0.26829567551612854,
0.3108571469783783,
-0.28666970133781433,
-0.38350215554237366,
-0.8492692708969116,
-0.646508514881134,
-0.32027187943458557,
-0.07166415452957153,
0.15251277387142181,
0.26407381892204285,
-0.3567158877849579,
0.6188068389892578,
-0.6375492215156555,
-0.19527234137058258,
-0.38344237208366394,
0.18548652529716492,
0.20078210532665253,
0.2732543647289276,
0.7999998331069946,
-0.5681697726249695,
-0.1365775614976883,
-0.15305963158607483,
-0.8181062340736389,
-0.13048838078975677,
-0.1273050755262375,
-0.24894292652606964,
-0.13612227141857147,
0.47395387291908264,
-0.5750798583030701,
0.26677680015563965,
0.40334609150886536,
-0.5019499063491821,
0.31757134199142456,
-0.09893030673265457,
-0.04869115725159645,
-0.9862521290779114,
-0.15647883713245392,
-0.007180101703852415,
-0.06203504651784897,
-0.9942406415939331,
0.4846891164779663,
0.05274028331041336,
-0.47612178325653076,
-0.7998920679092407,
0.6562846899032593,
-0.18142306804656982,
0.1521335393190384,
-0.5081175565719604,
0.21520109474658966,
-0.1112552061676979,
0.613065242767334,
-0.22121953964233398,
0.8099342584609985,
0.6676371693611145,
-0.45298483967781067,
0.3864910304546356,
0.020574932917952538,
-0.23821522295475006,
0.0651247650384903,
-0.8282358050346375,
0.6585903167724609,
-0.06848347187042236,
-0.07097358256578445,
-0.5265783667564392,
0.03521381691098213,
0.49216559529304504,
-0.7718530297279358,
0.3327586352825165,
-0.02118692174553871,
-0.23853640258312225,
-0.17971864342689514,
-0.4454033076763153,
-0.10883224010467529,
0.17755180597305298,
-0.7021263837814331,
0.5838276743888855,
0.4094507396221161,
0.17940330505371094,
-0.9290184378623962,
-0.4922184646129608,
0.3360750377178192,
-0.11671590059995651,
-0.5510803461074829,
0.16134114563465118,
-0.0019822604954242706,
-0.40766140818595886,
0.0235056784003973,
0.06463228911161423,
0.06958171725273132,
0.6633281707763672,
0.27733656764030457,
0.2700035870075226,
-0.08545184135437012,
-0.33111268281936646,
-0.4065447151660919,
-0.09770875424146652,
0.3081749975681305,
-0.11506566405296326,
0.7343367338180542,
-0.39677420258522034,
-0.2913413345813751,
-0.612834095954895,
0.37853941321372986,
0.7532888054847717,
-0.2609269618988037,
0.886468231678009,
0.764329195022583,
-0.37982362508773804,
-0.20373310148715973,
-0.2365134060382843,
-0.2865498661994934,
-0.5208123326301575,
0.7904899716377258,
-0.3449057340621948,
-0.7816859483718872,
0.5770801901817322,
0.44732415676116943,
0.18195271492004395,
0.2523461878299713,
0.37705662846565247,
0.3431991934776306,
1.2288275957107544,
0.5602803826332092,
-0.5398759841918945,
0.532481849193573,
-0.31157252192497253,
0.3179939091205597,
-0.5535311698913574,
-0.2587936520576477,
-0.6819208264350891,
-0.13522543013095856,
-0.514901876449585,
-0.36995965242385864,
0.027950923889875412,
0.03719189018011093,
-0.08976107090711594,
0.3080555200576782,
-0.5513569116592407,
0.4233962297439575,
0.42533570528030396,
0.1283281147480011,
-0.06073387339711189,
-0.18963782489299774,
-0.006554848980158567,
-0.12443546950817108,
-0.6720437407493591,
-0.2474282681941986,
0.899804413318634,
0.34867221117019653,
1.0664688348770142,
0.13052627444267273,
0.3120434880256653,
0.6830436587333679,
0.35243380069732666,
-0.785987913608551,
0.8194447755813599,
-0.16404572129249573,
-0.6185107827186584,
-0.08865437656641006,
-0.4860995411872864,
-0.9285444617271423,
0.5913997888565063,
-0.26164451241493225,
-0.8496588468551636,
-0.21149100363254547,
-0.01829507201910019,
-0.546104907989502,
0.7821105122566223,
-0.6501752734184265,
0.9991303086280823,
-0.4364118278026581,
-0.45033594965934753,
-0.15158943831920624,
-0.46432143449783325,
0.5249470472335815,
-0.04309213161468506,
0.21043384075164795,
-0.13324522972106934,
0.4152766764163971,
0.6738619804382324,
-0.25114038586616516,
0.688985288143158,
-0.3085359036922455,
0.11097177118062973,
0.11626709997653961,
0.45004498958587646,
0.5496976375579834,
0.17084422707557678,
0.0796864926815033,
0.2147323042154312,
-0.425428569316864,
-0.3250334560871124,
-0.9038336873054504,
0.5311036705970764,
-0.6795071363449097,
-0.9455586671829224,
-0.5327023267745972,
-0.4981384575366974,
0.09157417714595795,
-0.18851926922798157,
0.16755865514278412,
0.5500668287277222,
-0.4482997953891754,
0.16746358573436737,
0.826427698135376,
-0.2961583733558655,
0.49100542068481445,
0.6681146025657654,
-0.5240929126739502,
-0.3452179729938507,
1.0856271982192993,
-0.22988109290599823,
0.11594048142433167,
0.22740930318832397,
0.07483579963445663,
-0.2201290875673294,
-0.6393279433250427,
-0.6588394045829773,
0.18792544305324554,
-0.3844771683216095,
-0.18765413761138916,
-0.7000972628593445,
-0.4053024649620056,
-0.30049437284469604,
0.06202320009469986,
-0.8543911576271057,
-0.11250723153352737,
-0.15253788232803345,
0.17097145318984985,
0.3944198787212372,
0.5881661772727966,
0.24590924382209778,
0.5429783463478088,
-0.8561063408851624,
0.3125934898853302,
0.26760295033454895,
0.12551505863666534,
-0.11905621737241745,
-0.564197301864624,
-0.2722247540950775,
-0.019998740404844284,
-0.43509146571159363,
-1.0342656373977661,
0.5494740009307861,
0.001535204704850912,
0.5719909071922302,
0.7813687324523926,
0.08997570723295212,
0.7000289559364319,
-0.3019440770149231,
0.6348239183425903,
0.1539251059293747,
-0.9683927893638611,
0.42744675278663635,
-0.07765918970108032,
0.20913170278072357,
0.24628780782222748,
0.10522767901420593,
-0.7744691371917725,
-0.6387601494789124,
-0.560073971748352,
-0.6021427512168884,
0.8591119050979614,
0.4688035547733307,
0.12168662995100021,
0.16362039744853973,
0.2693052887916565,
0.01730315387248993,
0.04125182703137398,
-0.4146368205547333,
-0.780746340751648,
-0.3364143371582031,
0.26831668615341187,
-0.10974066704511642,
-0.19477087259292603,
0.04089992120862007,
-0.07804831117391586,
0.7995700240135193,
-0.07565280050039291,
0.21557949483394623,
-0.07572142034769058,
-0.14913393557071686,
0.16092289984226227,
0.42151325941085815,
0.5519893765449524,
0.23328624665737152,
-0.31365862488746643,
-0.029985569417476654,
0.07000330835580826,
-0.7814717888832092,
-0.020431481301784515,
0.5231097340583801,
-0.2989932894706726,
0.1590287983417511,
0.11366404592990875,
1.0984375476837158,
0.035703569650650024,
-0.6701905727386475,
0.22666189074516296,
-0.7178730964660645,
-0.06708833575248718,
0.040974900126457214,
0.2087765783071518,
0.03926493227481842,
0.5002572536468506,
0.3722049593925476,
0.0425744503736496,
0.0027726185508072376,
-0.4282573461532593,
0.006516425404697657,
0.632394015789032,
-0.577986478805542,
-0.37067803740501404,
1.0610392093658447,
0.01862550713121891,
-0.5929638743400574,
0.5931307673454285,
-0.37216463685035706,
-0.6651077270507812,
0.47322940826416016,
0.48374077677726746,
1.238985300064087,
-0.5394605398178101,
0.3214060664176941,
0.06379371881484985,
0.5130147337913513,
0.023018047213554382,
-0.014312462881207466,
0.2832862138748169,
-0.7257680296897888,
-0.04519732668995857,
-0.6081476807594299,
-0.6004852056503296,
0.5058505535125732,
-0.7133822441101074,
0.15580496191978455,
-0.5691767334938049,
-0.18266737461090088,
0.10187823325395584,
-0.0317230187356472,
-0.1651095449924469,
-0.04621942713856697,
0.3619270324707031,
0.7441364526748657,
-0.4278932213783264,
1.020164966583252,
0.5629673600196838,
-0.017635609954595566,
-0.5702699422836304,
-0.34770873188972473,
0.1793474406003952,
-0.5897140502929688,
0.2702682316303253,
0.23064589500427246,
-0.4163181781768799,
-0.2561406195163727,
-0.5059946775436401,
-0.5820068120956421,
0.668026328086853,
0.762032687664032,
-0.5455736517906189,
0.01111643761396408,
0.0049974434077739716,
0.406832754611969,
-0.17446106672286987,
0.14568668603897095,
0.7614324688911438,
0.10081222653388977,
-0.12216547131538391,
-0.5266079306602478,
-0.010390420444309711,
-0.5283112525939941,
-0.055950362235307693,
0.3600640296936035,
-0.6206237077713013,
0.872149646282196,
-0.24999943375587463,
-0.2588518559932709,
-0.1278017908334732,
0.874462902545929,
0.19568924605846405,
0.20069575309753418,
0.5342287421226501,
0.6083106994628906,
0.8620715141296387,
-0.1919509321451187,
1.0321563482284546,
-0.5068644285202026,
0.3028087913990021,
0.9022743701934814,
-0.15216286480426788,
0.5602171421051025,
0.27356430888175964,
0.0322955884039402,
0.13298386335372925,
0.643562376499176,
-0.01830902323126793,
0.5539968609809875,
0.28976622223854065,
-0.28847065567970276,
-0.22386406362056732,
-0.06465522199869156,
-0.6418002843856812,
0.33305180072784424,
0.453226238489151,
-0.06254218518733978,
-0.18917134404182434,
0.2658902704715729,
0.6244171261787415,
0.03418708220124245,
-0.41153860092163086,
0.49515199661254883,
-0.010623960755765438,
-0.3479337990283966,
0.7512692809104919,
0.23822790384292603,
0.6598888635635376,
-1.0290312767028809,
0.3569473922252655,
-0.3855443298816681,
0.545007050037384,
0.034773025661706924,
-0.44399699568748474,
0.07357311248779297,
0.2216404378414154,
-0.014441192150115967,
-0.027073055505752563,
0.7136095762252808,
-0.1417044699192047,
-0.4300403296947479,
0.48415812849998474,
0.37588196992874146,
0.1564021110534668,
-0.3633119463920593,
-0.8523969054222107,
0.2173358052968979,
0.10104061663150787,
-0.45029643177986145,
0.4734821021556854,
0.048481445759534836,
0.07932547479867935,
0.9277292490005493,
0.571875274181366,
0.02370002679526806,
0.11151712387800217,
0.07199867069721222,
1.0166746377944946,
-0.7510675191879272,
-0.36407384276390076,
-1.275529384613037,
-0.04647989198565483,
-0.03014579601585865,
-0.18918775022029877,
0.8391962647438049,
0.7414054274559021,
0.7257651686668396,
0.1580435335636139,
0.6779243350028992,
-0.04638266935944557,
0.2011934518814087,
-0.5521948933601379,
1.0855239629745483,
-0.4831453859806061,
0.42505258321762085,
-0.16012313961982727,
-0.5061226487159729,
-0.24375925958156586,
0.16515827178955078,
-0.07767060399055481,
-0.40739449858665466,
0.7400094866752625,
1.1155641078948975,
0.25552865862846375,
0.19328230619430542,
0.3791450262069702,
0.2379733920097351,
0.5913172960281372,
0.588256299495697,
0.9036579132080078,
-0.3768637776374817,
0.8522244095802307,
-0.35544145107269287,
0.1191326305270195,
-0.05865500122308731,
-0.5228356122970581,
-1.2208513021469116,
-0.102830670773983,
-0.28859204053878784,
-0.6290358304977417,
0.42872920632362366,
0.904873251914978,
0.3792913556098938,
-0.6193333864212036,
-0.24448198080062866,
0.3446853458881378,
0.20475952327251434,
-0.20433153212070465,
-0.2347259521484375,
0.518531084060669,
-0.24271932244300842,
-0.7031839489936829,
0.7116101384162903,
0.24069872498512268,
-0.21689128875732422,
-0.43099093437194824,
-0.1478576511144638,
0.07456760853528976,
0.1715380698442459,
0.19889602065086365,
0.43103569746017456,
-0.731484591960907,
0.015187888406217098,
0.14926603436470032,
-0.4128996431827545,
0.11608763039112091,
0.9601384997367859,
-0.854472279548645,
0.5407807230949402,
0.2764069736003876,
0.7953387498855591,
0.33234718441963196,
-0.07153598219156265,
0.3385365605354309,
-0.44113898277282715,
0.4406130313873291,
0.11294446885585785,
0.40591832995414734,
0.3425394892692566,
-0.3878162205219269,
0.3163953721523285,
0.39408472180366516,
-0.16343234479427338,
-1.0141369104385376,
0.132685586810112,
-0.7504600286483765,
-0.4994925856590271,
0.7951222062110901,
-0.15087676048278809,
-0.6016966700553894,
0.11258617788553238,
-0.3554173707962036,
0.14910706877708435,
-0.5579508543014526,
0.9793189764022827,
0.29885855317115784,
0.08963379263877869,
0.18712261319160461,
-0.6041768789291382,
0.653790295124054,
0.19361181557178497,
-0.702712893486023,
0.20295381546020508,
0.15179698169231415,
-0.0836416631937027,
0.09179805964231491,
0.3138580322265625,
-0.1437302678823471,
0.416677862405777,
0.16246825456619263,
0.24738991260528564,
-0.44563573598861694,
-0.20105858147144318,
-0.4923649728298187,
0.5590103268623352,
-0.29045480489730835,
-0.30183345079421997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15506v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15506v3
|
AgentOhana: Design Unified Data and Training Pipeline for Effective Agent Learning
| 2024-02-23T18:56:26 | 2024-03-20T06:00:14 |
Jianguo Zhang, Tian Lan, Rithesh Murthy, Zhiwei Liu, Weiran Yao, Juntao Tan, Thai Hoang, Liangwei Yang, Yihao Feng, Zuxin Liu, Tulika Awalgaonkar, Juan Carlos Niebles, Silvio Savarese, Shelby Heinecke, Huan Wang, Caiming Xiong
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Autonomous agents powered by large language models (LLMs) have garnered
significant research attention. However, fully harnessing the potential of LLMs
for agent-based tasks presents inherent challenges due to the heterogeneous
nature of diverse data sources featuring multi-turn trajectories. In this
paper, we introduce \textbf{AgentOhana} as a comprehensive solution to address
these challenges. \textit{AgentOhana} aggregates agent trajectories from
distinct environments, spanning a wide array of scenarios. It meticulously
standardizes and unifies these trajectories into a consistent format,
streamlining the creation of a generic data loader optimized for agent
training. Leveraging the data unification, our training pipeline maintains
equilibrium across different data sources and preserves independent randomness
across devices during dataset partitioning and model training. Additionally, we
present \textbf{xLAM-v0.1}, a large action model tailored for AI agents, which
demonstrates exceptional performance across various benchmarks. Begin the
exploration at \url{https://github.com/SalesforceAIResearch/xLAM}.
|
[
-0.018268845975399017,
-0.6272851824760437,
0.5941895246505737,
-0.09326202422380447,
-0.020250489935278893,
0.33921727538108826,
-0.035358816385269165,
-0.32823535799980164,
0.3060868978500366,
0.7466451525688171,
-0.4090133011341095,
-0.6743245720863342,
-0.31170985102653503,
-0.3188486397266388,
-0.42484909296035767,
0.7602249383926392,
-0.11842910945415497,
-0.021626362577080727,
-0.2300589680671692,
-0.5395329594612122,
-0.6234833002090454,
-0.3421739339828491,
-0.7926372289657593,
-0.5748981833457947,
0.684988260269165,
0.5946188569068909,
0.8272719383239746,
0.9547951817512512,
0.18504735827445984,
0.4259779453277588,
0.5129424333572388,
0.4891807436943054,
-0.4657341241836548,
0.5646706223487854,
-0.11040747910737991,
-0.5184045433998108,
-0.6746653914451599,
-0.211321160197258,
0.573605477809906,
0.5049201846122742,
-0.6121764779090881,
0.094795823097229,
-0.35346150398254395,
0.3227600157260895,
-0.6180947422981262,
0.3027339577674866,
-0.5660014748573303,
0.013020559214055538,
-0.019793352112174034,
-0.15406261384487152,
-0.44567304849624634,
-0.13362599909305573,
-0.08777999877929688,
-0.8472589254379272,
-0.12245626002550125,
0.1532854586839676,
0.6037170886993408,
0.484731525182724,
-0.6877220273017883,
-0.31921762228012085,
-0.9453311562538147,
0.7461114525794983,
-0.28595396876335144,
0.1987089067697525,
0.05898481607437134,
0.7443317174911499,
-0.0367610938847065,
-0.8111295700073242,
-0.5102329850196838,
-0.02169598639011383,
0.2415858954191208,
-0.07601255178451538,
-0.06874997913837433,
0.015244103036820889,
-0.10295961052179337,
0.18337751924991608,
-0.7165206074714661,
0.34245598316192627,
-0.0011883425759151578,
0.001704872353002429,
0.8916717171669006,
0.6623541116714478,
0.4232279062271118,
0.3500030040740967,
-0.3720875382423401,
-0.500296950340271,
-0.6818044781684875,
0.011829455383121967,
0.47468188405036926,
0.6314306855201721,
-0.04702993854880333,
0.4009835124015808,
-0.15134675800800323,
0.484229177236557,
-0.14050062000751495,
-0.04477262496948242,
0.24619637429714203,
0.09692572802305222,
-0.23483392596244812,
0.005833552684634924,
0.7933827042579651,
-0.10147883743047714,
-0.26055192947387695,
-0.38235989212989807,
-0.26619911193847656,
-0.00970022939145565,
0.6179366111755371,
-0.8535332679748535,
0.007468245457857847,
0.6207521557807922,
0.06697577983140945,
-0.128901869058609,
-0.1270369440317154,
-0.6547930240631104,
-0.5976012945175171,
-0.7206977605819702,
0.3866843581199646,
-0.30417880415916443,
-0.3418213725090027,
-0.022440800443291664,
0.21071907877922058,
0.48971328139305115,
0.32256385684013367,
-0.7161055207252502,
0.27741676568984985,
0.8162440061569214,
0.6255629658699036,
-0.31610074639320374,
-0.5159589648246765,
-0.8095342516899109,
0.20219586789608002,
-0.5227318406105042,
0.9195190668106079,
-0.6336592435836792,
-0.14003849029541016,
0.2559099793434143,
-0.02184380404651165,
-0.047731801867485046,
-0.5704237222671509,
0.21785059571266174,
-0.6666390299797058,
-0.21625898778438568,
0.04494025185704231,
-0.7156115174293518,
-0.2804989516735077,
0.21804867684841156,
-0.7435664534568787,
0.6464448571205139,
0.07169517874717712,
0.1877959966659546,
0.29675522446632385,
-0.7021828889846802,
-0.5001362562179565,
0.09030771255493164,
-0.5159386396408081,
-0.6694236993789673,
-0.20893415808677673,
-0.14022517204284668,
0.35035601258277893,
-0.2883369028568268,
0.34873393177986145,
-0.34628114104270935,
-0.1650417447090149,
0.000056291857617907226,
-0.1710185557603836,
0.7457420825958252,
0.30275869369506836,
-0.3530597686767578,
0.4904573857784271,
-0.9322112798690796,
0.11820513755083084,
0.3387933671474457,
-0.20392724871635437,
-0.2020508199930191,
0.008557368069887161,
0.10798315703868866,
0.22385963797569275,
0.0986296683549881,
-0.18797068297863007,
0.4779585897922516,
0.10084462910890579,
-0.025020979344844818,
0.9134148955345154,
-0.3343379497528076,
0.5481158494949341,
-0.2639155387878418,
0.78975909948349,
-0.08140560239553452,
0.18867401778697968,
-0.15240785479545593,
-0.13616138696670532,
-0.6119373440742493,
-0.41747745871543884,
-0.10805042088031769,
0.272293359041214,
-0.769528865814209,
0.4670109450817108,
-0.2803329527378082,
-0.7220597267150879,
-0.5491030216217041,
0.42777037620544434,
0.16121095418930054,
0.06280717998743057,
0.29044219851493835,
-0.06455773860216141,
-0.4354923665523529,
-0.4717108905315399,
0.15506578981876373,
0.03426375612616539,
0.0023688729852437973,
0.14239846169948578,
0.22978368401527405,
-0.5554714798927307,
0.9962051510810852,
-0.4408223628997803,
-0.4076600670814514,
-0.5241023302078247,
0.2856602966785431,
-0.2373589724302292,
0.29387256503105164,
0.6558689475059509,
-0.6209422945976257,
-0.5051893591880798,
0.22623294591903687,
-1.0271103382110596,
0.036313746124506,
-0.20687620341777802,
-0.48736515641212463,
0.24190784990787506,
0.39487582445144653,
-0.8693237900733948,
0.27056628465652466,
0.5042949318885803,
-0.3650956153869629,
0.0804295465350151,
-0.1351836919784546,
-0.2563643753528595,
-1.2775180339813232,
0.0682787075638771,
-0.31078657507896423,
-0.33127790689468384,
-0.6137387752532959,
0.3472619354724884,
-0.14813974499702454,
-0.09027876704931259,
-0.5004463791847229,
0.7098135352134705,
-0.5444919466972351,
-0.22679203748703003,
-0.6340619921684265,
0.08069159835577011,
-0.1035032793879509,
0.7078484892845154,
0.03449135273694992,
0.43669140338897705,
0.7426386475563049,
-0.616005539894104,
0.72980135679245,
0.2699144780635834,
0.12250755727291107,
0.5289790034294128,
-0.5468239784240723,
0.49647200107574463,
-0.12910951673984528,
0.3094834089279175,
-0.761734664440155,
-0.2951633334159851,
0.18691383302211761,
-0.1813783198595047,
0.1779019832611084,
0.20734956860542297,
-0.5827924609184265,
-0.0002607336500659585,
-0.12278963625431061,
0.34228450059890747,
0.430038183927536,
-0.7652744054794312,
1.2341469526290894,
0.6309154629707336,
0.23270969092845917,
-0.6420237421989441,
-0.2250041365623474,
-0.01305320579558611,
-0.26868006587028503,
-0.2272505909204483,
-0.15405316650867462,
-0.21306778490543365,
-0.34629160165786743,
-0.1883075088262558,
-0.0035166258458048105,
-0.13678404688835144,
0.03105255216360092,
0.489044189453125,
0.2682054340839386,
-0.024252591654658318,
0.2937048375606537,
0.009901288896799088,
-0.11505498737096786,
0.08927375823259354,
-0.333558589220047,
0.6904972791671753,
0.09897204488515854,
-0.42418232560157776,
-0.14133615791797638,
0.3649674654006958,
0.6863625049591064,
-0.12546902894973755,
0.8005604147911072,
0.5126246809959412,
-0.1795242726802826,
-0.7143296003341675,
-0.04700703173875809,
-0.03675054758787155,
-0.46509963274002075,
0.35488826036453247,
-0.19629435241222382,
-0.49277952313423157,
0.5751883387565613,
0.043594103306531906,
0.46210747957229614,
0.1781589537858963,
0.7041741609573364,
0.11942367255687714,
1.005470633506775,
0.6457585096359253,
-0.3133712708950043,
0.5637577176094055,
-0.5910125970840454,
0.08575225621461868,
-0.31328341364860535,
-0.20051877200603485,
-0.3838679790496826,
-0.3083295524120331,
-0.45966237783432007,
-0.4183177053928375,
0.05208057165145874,
-0.7220896482467651,
-0.4191609025001526,
0.31228870153427124,
-0.17422765493392944,
0.3848188817501068,
0.40913721919059753,
-0.07515506446361542,
0.35411158204078674,
-0.05978187173604965,
0.38980549573898315,
0.5387716293334961,
-0.7326751351356506,
-0.4643200635910034,
1.4492063522338867,
0.21415415406227112,
1.0051301717758179,
0.3411046862602234,
0.622799813747406,
0.33518269658088684,
0.36812517046928406,
-0.9096996188163757,
0.6289637088775635,
0.27451324462890625,
-0.7723334431648254,
-0.5951035618782043,
-0.4638330638408661,
-1.5344523191452026,
0.3996241092681885,
-0.008489735424518585,
-0.337493360042572,
0.03294650465250015,
0.09662511199712753,
-0.3408571183681488,
0.3323756754398346,
-0.5555164217948914,
0.8065028786659241,
-0.4302057921886444,
-0.4521756172180176,
-0.27238544821739197,
-0.5059782266616821,
0.14439618587493896,
-0.06983181089162827,
-0.05216437578201294,
-0.18467068672180176,
-0.18968909978866577,
0.32984304428100586,
-0.8393452167510986,
0.8878901600837708,
-0.08518797904253006,
-0.5021359920501709,
0.6587161421775818,
-0.135114386677742,
0.6819937825202942,
-0.05512348562479019,
0.23191684484481812,
0.1216169223189354,
-0.4862251579761505,
-0.6721238493919373,
-0.5888766050338745,
0.5661352872848511,
-1.0680360794067383,
-0.19510136544704437,
-0.5341781377792358,
-0.8208655714988708,
-0.17737571895122528,
0.12490693479776382,
-0.08626305311918259,
0.5386885404586792,
-0.24241721630096436,
0.06509338319301605,
0.5187081694602966,
0.09571585804224014,
0.4400598406791687,
0.9224334359169006,
-0.3767072856426239,
-0.18504033982753754,
1.0963886976242065,
0.06989757716655731,
0.1651841551065445,
0.48239290714263916,
-0.2770906984806061,
-0.34234461188316345,
-0.42530059814453125,
-0.36208850145339966,
0.00991243589669466,
-0.7127670645713806,
-0.29927802085876465,
-0.5712802410125732,
-0.12819905579090118,
-0.47988104820251465,
0.010685008950531483,
-0.7257927060127258,
-0.024012316018342972,
-0.19241642951965332,
-0.2766069769859314,
0.23688924312591553,
0.7391104102134705,
-0.013575814664363861,
0.4963949918746948,
-0.5428982973098755,
0.5402005314826965,
0.7270686030387878,
0.279692679643631,
0.024635666981339455,
-0.29058602452278137,
-0.4958416223526001,
-0.17577794194221497,
-0.5138402581214905,
-0.4397569000720978,
0.46613386273384094,
0.12673398852348328,
0.7540428638458252,
0.5514068007469177,
0.10899441689252853,
0.34014925360679626,
-0.3750203847885132,
0.39790481328964233,
-0.10423608869314194,
-0.6025872826576233,
0.4793773591518402,
-0.4148690402507782,
0.4043218791484833,
0.47698089480400085,
0.39416778087615967,
-0.22657519578933716,
-0.519366979598999,
-0.5745723247528076,
-1.0379784107208252,
0.7470508217811584,
0.29224127531051636,
0.05120588093996048,
0.27524295449256897,
0.08412085473537445,
0.3573874235153198,
0.31768494844436646,
-0.5598369836807251,
-0.5899307727813721,
-0.13365449011325836,
-0.3812107741832733,
-0.2883507311344147,
0.30365049839019775,
-0.22180673480033875,
-0.10706828534603119,
0.7616283893585205,
-0.403398334980011,
0.13649743795394897,
-0.3155824542045593,
-0.38001954555511475,
-0.17742964625358582,
0.020565388724207878,
0.35651159286499023,
0.71476811170578,
-0.16279453039169312,
0.03464404493570328,
-0.21165572106838226,
-0.5802749991416931,
0.569707453250885,
0.26022008061408997,
-0.1308480203151703,
0.05055589601397514,
0.4899883568286896,
0.9205523729324341,
-0.09180466830730438,
-1.0080171823501587,
0.12106010317802429,
-0.25425785779953003,
0.06119968742132187,
-0.5071732997894287,
0.4376606047153473,
-0.1969994306564331,
0.471790611743927,
0.4238739609718323,
-0.10804834216833115,
0.16389623284339905,
-0.8712849020957947,
0.035556476563215256,
0.2811659276485443,
-0.1561487913131714,
-0.3859767019748688,
0.46970823407173157,
0.37468838691711426,
-0.365799218416214,
0.4984082579612732,
-0.32194003462791443,
-0.12630942463874817,
0.8644278049468994,
0.2059500366449356,
1.1873259544372559,
-0.5445446372032166,
0.3085358142852783,
0.15929707884788513,
0.1803223341703415,
-0.11993962526321411,
0.10400500148534775,
-0.11989195644855499,
-0.7614631652832031,
-0.19159357249736786,
-0.3870604932308197,
-0.7321239709854126,
0.15465199947357178,
-0.4379684329032898,
0.21927225589752197,
-0.3514231741428375,
0.08144010603427887,
-0.25619927048683167,
0.01576804742217064,
-0.6845866441726685,
0.1323787420988083,
0.3500015437602997,
0.5356462597846985,
-0.7167349457740784,
0.9703786969184875,
0.9183823466300964,
-0.47541970014572144,
-0.9616890549659729,
-0.14108923077583313,
0.07104852050542831,
-0.8899978995323181,
0.09875889867544174,
0.09543144702911377,
-0.17534330487251282,
-0.16786335408687592,
-0.6830126643180847,
-0.754086434841156,
1.404079556465149,
0.6617239117622375,
-0.4312707781791687,
0.08818190544843674,
0.5778611898422241,
0.5960311889648438,
-0.7032651305198669,
0.3308507204055786,
0.6736956834793091,
0.3047945201396942,
0.18245606124401093,
-0.3789103031158447,
-0.12278691679239273,
-0.2533508241176605,
-0.15340684354305267,
0.009729711338877678,
-0.9692017436027527,
0.8492007255554199,
-0.031332146376371384,
0.003612462431192398,
-0.053965870290994644,
0.7707638740539551,
0.4484787583351135,
0.602932870388031,
0.4727626442909241,
0.5678823590278625,
0.8869401216506958,
0.19432860612869263,
0.9607698917388916,
-0.11788583546876907,
0.3109171688556671,
1.4610496759414673,
-0.6017326712608337,
0.6378815174102783,
0.10094291716814041,
-0.021967314183712006,
0.6196076273918152,
0.5110822916030884,
0.32660937309265137,
0.44916313886642456,
0.002373890718445182,
-0.14214855432510376,
-0.3900333046913147,
-0.06944767385721207,
-0.12376395612955093,
0.7655339241027832,
0.09644564986228943,
0.002462511882185936,
-0.17937183380126953,
0.08173748850822449,
0.06785594671964645,
0.08686887472867966,
-0.4486813545227051,
0.7769874334335327,
-0.006400113459676504,
-0.6249563097953796,
0.4233674108982086,
-0.47372007369995117,
0.19302473962306976,
-0.7499915361404419,
-0.14482027292251587,
-0.6356020569801331,
0.32578614354133606,
0.056435905396938324,
-0.4656931757926941,
0.1199728474020958,
-0.13845959305763245,
0.10282644629478455,
-0.11846591532230377,
0.38877779245376587,
-0.5581673979759216,
-0.3001909554004669,
0.556492805480957,
0.4100174307823181,
0.05453307181596756,
-0.12575313448905945,
-0.5185908079147339,
0.2788984775543213,
-0.38128289580345154,
-0.27753281593322754,
0.3889818787574768,
0.626369833946228,
0.17824703454971313,
1.0058287382125854,
0.281188428401947,
-0.21527136862277985,
-0.051758550107479095,
0.04336302727460861,
0.7570593953132629,
-0.5734168887138367,
-0.6046356558799744,
-0.519124448299408,
0.4707258343696594,
-0.11026263982057571,
-0.13658003509044647,
0.7586491703987122,
0.5630959272384644,
0.5559228658676147,
0.09463793784379959,
0.7214816212654114,
0.13326901197433472,
0.22796672582626343,
-0.42037099599838257,
0.6494079828262329,
-0.7652158737182617,
0.2910394072532654,
0.09108032286167145,
-0.9900497198104858,
0.14340099692344666,
0.1547677218914032,
0.10379593074321747,
0.1405699998140335,
0.6206778883934021,
0.5425907373428345,
-0.09405793249607086,
-0.24530737102031708,
0.44818881154060364,
0.23546044528484344,
0.5265207290649414,
0.5786839723587036,
0.7681905627250671,
-0.45027652382850647,
0.7235482335090637,
0.08624862879514694,
0.052501384168863297,
-0.4110579788684845,
-0.4514029920101166,
-0.986156702041626,
-0.5168454647064209,
-0.44665154814720154,
-0.019245274364948273,
-0.06653320044279099,
1.2252857685089111,
1.0353597402572632,
-0.7115355730056763,
-0.5870086550712585,
-0.2535689175128937,
0.31551820039749146,
-0.3358180522918701,
-0.15241627395153046,
0.07444670796394348,
-0.4014523923397064,
-0.9272453784942627,
0.45348870754241943,
0.08526178449392319,
0.011978507041931152,
-0.508183479309082,
-0.45395970344543457,
0.018719568848609924,
0.3681301772594452,
0.6064732074737549,
0.5922561883926392,
-0.2749797999858856,
0.004593425430357456,
-0.2792896032333374,
-0.3467012643814087,
0.22757963836193085,
0.6625692248344421,
-0.6459739804267883,
0.38768503069877625,
0.1513853222131729,
0.7964260578155518,
0.3454303443431854,
-0.11330677568912506,
0.6762118935585022,
-0.7047674655914307,
0.42179539799690247,
0.1616772562265396,
0.26697513461112976,
0.2366168349981308,
-0.4684295654296875,
0.7305613160133362,
-0.049296725541353226,
-0.5991989374160767,
-0.8003086447715759,
0.01390834804624319,
-1.172696828842163,
-0.2595576345920563,
1.053312063217163,
-0.04140254110097885,
-0.415009081363678,
0.022642234340310097,
-0.13892777264118195,
0.3469545841217041,
-0.7494725584983826,
0.8778917789459229,
0.36798450350761414,
-0.11181158572435379,
-0.0883917286992073,
-0.48460814356803894,
0.21559050679206848,
0.24688389897346497,
-1.3830772638320923,
0.08017636835575104,
0.7026033401489258,
-0.15247395634651184,
0.18030156195163727,
0.4971528947353363,
0.40780243277549744,
0.22288204729557037,
0.18275931477546692,
0.38237425684928894,
-0.048337049782276154,
-0.6808905601501465,
-0.4879487156867981,
0.24212852120399475,
0.002061170758679509,
-0.41446787118911743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00801v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00801v1
|
Self-Retrieval: Building an Information Retrieval System with One Large Language Model
| 2024-02-23T18:45:35 | 2024-02-23T18:45:35 |
Qiaoyu Tang, Jiawei Chen, Bowen Yu, Yaojie Lu, Cheng Fu, Haiyang Yu, Hongyu Lin, Fei Huang, Ben He, Xianpei Han, Le Sun, Yongbin Li
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The rise of large language models (LLMs) has transformed the role of
information retrieval (IR) systems in the way to humans accessing information.
Due to the isolated architecture and the limited interaction, existing IR
systems are unable to fully accommodate the shift from directly providing
information to humans to indirectly serving large language models. In this
paper, we propose Self-Retrieval, an end-to-end, LLM-driven information
retrieval architecture that can fully internalize the required abilities of IR
systems into a single LLM and deeply leverage the capabilities of LLMs during
IR process. Specifically, Self-retrieval internalizes the corpus to retrieve
into a LLM via a natural language indexing architecture. Then the entire
retrieval process is redefined as a procedure of document generation and
self-assessment, which can be end-to-end executed using a single large language
model. Experimental results demonstrate that Self-Retrieval not only
significantly outperforms previous retrieval approaches by a large margin, but
also can significantly boost the performance of LLM-driven downstream
applications like retrieval augumented generation.
|
[
-0.3365536332130432,
-0.6088181138038635,
0.6637577414512634,
0.06369917839765549,
-0.08028393238782883,
0.2250988930463791,
-0.2641512155532837,
-0.5116975903511047,
0.4239559769630432,
0.6803824305534363,
-0.2769283056259155,
-0.2169569581747055,
-0.35159072279930115,
0.28916361927986145,
-0.7675133347511292,
0.7348328828811646,
0.07593030482530594,
-0.03946267440915108,
-0.14695602655410767,
0.08384791761636734,
-0.2541261911392212,
-0.6585037112236023,
-0.26578232645988464,
-0.34876880049705505,
0.6102178692817688,
0.40319329500198364,
0.47951540350914,
0.7392225861549377,
0.577292799949646,
0.29216039180755615,
0.3626798689365387,
-0.2264476865530014,
-0.5353090167045593,
0.4816833734512329,
-0.41111519932746887,
-0.4739268720149994,
-0.19942358136177063,
-0.06396704912185669,
0.7313523888587952,
0.22896263003349304,
-0.24114465713500977,
0.5231941938400269,
0.0528804287314415,
0.7658404111862183,
-0.6846404075622559,
-0.1620221585035324,
-0.541790246963501,
-0.1532975137233734,
-0.3667895197868347,
-0.33628758788108826,
-0.5565799474716187,
-0.07572157680988312,
0.10283326357603073,
-0.1399686187505722,
-0.07984711229801178,
0.16876564919948578,
0.3997012972831726,
0.15487119555473328,
-0.29715535044670105,
-0.3980318307876587,
-0.6709781885147095,
0.4731166660785675,
-0.5944246053695679,
0.40997374057769775,
0.1681290566921234,
0.41494378447532654,
-0.0862501785159111,
-0.8672537207603455,
-0.4147234857082367,
-0.3166733384132385,
-0.09372767060995102,
0.10654422640800476,
-0.14268936216831207,
-0.09591776132583618,
-0.25002527236938477,
0.4798981249332428,
-0.5033578276634216,
-0.00656809750944376,
-0.4812048077583313,
0.07496391236782074,
0.43954914808273315,
-0.056562501937150955,
0.4268728792667389,
-0.39151760935783386,
-0.4358236491680145,
0.04590331390500069,
-0.7438971996307373,
-0.4736069440841675,
0.3207815885543823,
0.5216836929321289,
0.5361639261245728,
0.7227725386619568,
-0.37584948539733887,
0.4179143011569977,
-0.08918698877096176,
0.03334440290927887,
0.02953682653605938,
-0.19772286713123322,
-0.2595355808734894,
0.2217806875705719,
0.7738430500030518,
-0.05919476971030235,
-0.026713065803050995,
-0.38327494263648987,
-0.636908769607544,
-0.2952457368373871,
0.5061022043228149,
-0.8317440152168274,
0.39272043108940125,
0.11325372755527496,
-0.6796106696128845,
-0.12216541916131973,
-0.05401090905070305,
-0.7349186539649963,
-0.04886290803551674,
-0.4343668520450592,
0.8841993808746338,
-0.32932090759277344,
-0.3805938959121704,
0.05310400202870369,
0.10498422384262085,
0.44748684763908386,
0.1312851756811142,
-0.7797373533248901,
0.526056170463562,
0.5446457266807556,
0.9257450699806213,
-0.25685957074165344,
-0.18815433979034424,
-0.41703084111213684,
0.2430950105190277,
-0.4535840153694153,
0.8380166888237,
-0.6028395295143127,
-0.4365110993385315,
0.0015010237693786621,
-0.24933753907680511,
0.32666608691215515,
-0.644333004951477,
0.3399412930011749,
-0.7823494076728821,
0.23174752295017242,
0.00912256259471178,
-0.4979737401008606,
-0.008552992716431618,
0.40806838870048523,
-0.4219846725463867,
1.1291018724441528,
-0.02978726662695408,
-0.45557573437690735,
-0.1808394342660904,
-0.530491054058075,
-0.41472411155700684,
0.3141947090625763,
-0.37748804688453674,
0.0705774649977684,
0.30041083693504333,
-0.0597999133169651,
0.47413864731788635,
-0.6972248554229736,
0.27351564168930054,
-0.2516195476055145,
-0.24479548633098602,
-0.17017246782779694,
-0.30825740098953247,
0.22005285322666168,
0.41205894947052,
-0.07364343106746674,
-0.2547863721847534,
-0.6279804110527039,
0.1744145303964615,
0.18262425065040588,
-0.6387183666229248,
-0.5623058676719666,
-0.09759289026260376,
-0.23125895857810974,
0.28243693709373474,
0.9438477754592896,
-0.8114153742790222,
0.4774331748485565,
-0.30553653836250305,
0.19974955916404724,
0.6914215087890625,
-0.24087199568748474,
0.5428693294525146,
-0.20718641579151154,
0.4545450806617737,
-0.3169936537742615,
0.13224616646766663,
-0.4929320216178894,
-0.002414681250229478,
-0.6476353406906128,
-0.09490203857421875,
0.13202713429927826,
0.37706315517425537,
-0.2740457355976105,
0.38290995359420776,
-0.3649439215660095,
-0.5348756313323975,
-0.8299937844276428,
0.3413994610309601,
0.38834908604621887,
0.45421212911605835,
0.5365711450576782,
-0.25809240341186523,
-0.4985714554786682,
-1.0482195615768433,
-0.07202417403459549,
-0.2389233410358429,
-0.08165470510721207,
0.32624581456184387,
0.46246427297592163,
-0.39885610342025757,
0.9356333017349243,
-0.5298321843147278,
-0.6665748357772827,
-0.2642463743686676,
0.2756011486053467,
0.4125058948993683,
0.26847270131111145,
0.20215784013271332,
-0.7381986975669861,
-0.48029839992523193,
0.11795073747634888,
-0.8901222348213196,
-0.19669972360134125,
-0.0551479272544384,
-0.21033267676830292,
0.0725724920630455,
0.5921235680580139,
-0.44763633608818054,
0.2727905511856079,
0.1407947838306427,
-0.09296473115682602,
0.5831508636474609,
-0.6609204411506653,
-0.04822283610701561,
-0.8678893446922302,
0.2569732069969177,
-0.35619041323661804,
-0.24973253905773163,
-0.34481626749038696,
0.3385200798511505,
0.2503829598426819,
0.04133552685379982,
0.02608434110879898,
0.812480092048645,
-0.9364282488822937,
-0.5730060338973999,
-0.5818682312965393,
0.17058543860912323,
0.05488773435354233,
0.20715487003326416,
-0.19490477442741394,
0.9768426418304443,
0.5032381415367126,
-0.6743502020835876,
0.23601987957954407,
0.0913740023970604,
-0.18413889408111572,
0.4329946041107178,
-0.48439592123031616,
0.17131592333316803,
-0.7098247408866882,
0.04912054166197777,
-0.9066668152809143,
-0.11563480645418167,
-0.32129380106925964,
-0.42615774273872375,
0.5085813999176025,
-0.14905677735805511,
-0.6621360182762146,
-0.34910181164741516,
-0.23705430328845978,
0.1284686177968979,
0.4198934733867645,
-0.9427670240402222,
0.9941531419754028,
0.421409547328949,
-0.4634094536304474,
-0.6171352863311768,
-0.5704028606414795,
0.5441486239433289,
0.040907394140958786,
-0.5446942448616028,
0.3934280276298523,
-0.3089025020599365,
-0.10602985322475433,
-0.1025334820151329,
-0.014546403661370277,
0.09509199857711792,
0.050706300884485245,
-0.02239260822534561,
0.2226921170949936,
-0.20655375719070435,
0.6229307055473328,
-0.14560620486736298,
-0.02172851376235485,
0.03615632280707359,
-0.3775063753128052,
0.596018373966217,
-0.10893546044826508,
-0.4117646813392639,
0.03893597424030304,
0.6453545093536377,
0.5265825986862183,
-0.5747414827346802,
0.40313220024108887,
0.14350010454654694,
-0.2605043649673462,
-0.1251848191022873,
-1.0256798267364502,
-0.10760683566331863,
-0.4987313151359558,
0.32856833934783936,
-0.6232181787490845,
-0.7598720192909241,
0.45970475673675537,
-0.14661595225334167,
0.026455804705619812,
0.3913536071777344,
0.4906821548938751,
-0.17941169440746307,
0.9155517816543579,
0.7357286214828491,
-0.23482899367809296,
0.560053288936615,
-0.15242750942707062,
0.17561514675617218,
-1.0926563739776611,
-0.3786420524120331,
-0.5711188912391663,
-0.1834854930639267,
-0.3311949670314789,
-0.2759145200252533,
0.3448442816734314,
0.12823112308979034,
-0.2500745952129364,
0.30843088030815125,
-0.6864858269691467,
0.38331305980682373,
0.6612176299095154,
0.12003041803836823,
0.5245872139930725,
-0.07025574892759323,
-0.265279084444046,
0.18625029921531677,
-0.3381834030151367,
-0.5664152503013611,
1.164471983909607,
0.20522229373455048,
1.1382699012756348,
0.4163723886013031,
1.094526767730713,
0.4094010293483734,
0.7255186438560486,
-0.5322256088256836,
0.5489684343338013,
-0.17920738458633423,
-0.6580873727798462,
-0.32245591282844543,
-0.33970844745635986,
-0.8146000504493713,
0.450349897146225,
0.20514249801635742,
-0.7438705563545227,
0.11848360300064087,
-0.37748777866363525,
-0.1162162646651268,
0.05944869667291641,
-0.6518104076385498,
0.5386861562728882,
-0.7086494565010071,
-0.5197709798812866,
-0.37168431282043457,
-0.5495274066925049,
0.17688271403312683,
-0.4547407925128937,
0.31096312403678894,
-0.09371696412563324,
-0.19660037755966187,
0.5399437546730042,
-0.1092592105269432,
0.5640655755996704,
0.0739448145031929,
-0.11774961650371552,
0.41671526432037354,
0.506183922290802,
0.4392130672931671,
-0.13415071368217468,
-0.5595442056655884,
-0.21068333089351654,
0.060697540640830994,
-0.06335165351629257,
-0.7857861518859863,
0.8291809558868408,
-0.6865180730819702,
-0.9009267687797546,
-0.4072660505771637,
-0.03410561755299568,
0.1969521939754486,
0.6659677624702454,
-0.008208288811147213,
0.47393614053726196,
-0.3200879693031311,
0.18350426852703094,
0.3937340974807739,
-0.10724017769098282,
0.5158528685569763,
1.0169594287872314,
-0.5998250246047974,
-0.1384902447462082,
0.9181374907493591,
0.30886247754096985,
0.14107654988765717,
0.6340516805648804,
0.3062996566295624,
-0.7118015289306641,
-0.4169403314590454,
-0.28534775972366333,
0.4294271469116211,
-0.8384481072425842,
-0.44434332847595215,
-0.6891524195671082,
-0.17850922048091888,
-0.6304643750190735,
0.10554974526166916,
-0.5159001350402832,
-0.061978429555892944,
-0.4227578639984131,
-0.07813486456871033,
-0.015132030472159386,
1.0453344583511353,
-0.3199574649333954,
0.09859419614076614,
-0.8406906127929688,
0.26698780059814453,
0.26720038056373596,
0.6199448704719543,
0.1316606104373932,
-0.8508013486862183,
-0.1569584757089615,
-0.303133100271225,
-0.20031823217868805,
-0.7780665755271912,
0.6768022775650024,
0.2748194634914398,
0.6495881676673889,
0.35068225860595703,
0.15635429322719574,
0.5905407667160034,
-0.6070419549942017,
0.36970582604408264,
0.008373461663722992,
-0.670156717300415,
0.5991460680961609,
-0.1700230836868286,
0.33160483837127686,
0.6037841439247131,
0.3964029848575592,
-0.6034445762634277,
-0.18875178694725037,
-0.19258414208889008,
-0.9367276430130005,
0.49939996004104614,
-0.17797236144542694,
0.385105699300766,
-0.3947421908378601,
0.5964418649673462,
0.04342254251241684,
0.11447175592184067,
-0.8271081447601318,
0.07058048993349075,
-0.0005683544441126287,
-0.19839149713516235,
0.24149636924266815,
-0.46526652574539185,
0.08437476307153702,
0.09966431558132172,
0.7349897623062134,
-0.4606403410434723,
0.3224279284477234,
0.7620730996131897,
-0.194833904504776,
-0.19176194071769714,
0.4984833896160126,
-0.16208979487419128,
0.48619499802589417,
-0.28006789088249207,
0.2564863860607147,
-0.13856111466884613,
0.06899812072515488,
0.17971982061862946,
-0.042494308203458786,
-0.07507910579442978,
-0.32733863592147827,
0.10202069580554962,
0.1343248188495636,
0.22889910638332367,
-0.8520451784133911,
0.4753604531288147,
-0.08960587531328201,
0.2918280363082886,
-0.5978135466575623,
-0.13843309879302979,
0.030986521393060684,
0.2838223874568939,
1.079830527305603,
-0.6372371912002563,
0.43489450216293335,
-0.7757939100265503,
0.5744979977607727,
0.6466973423957825,
-0.07626268267631531,
-0.0767722874879837,
0.5663915276527405,
0.033099215477705,
-0.3511124849319458,
0.628944993019104,
-0.07362357527017593,
-0.27736321091651917,
0.33212152123451233,
0.7537223696708679,
0.9239209890365601,
-0.46497833728790283,
0.11451513320207596,
0.42473021149635315,
0.2535521686077118,
-0.3651660978794098,
0.20565208792686462,
-0.24157987534999847,
-0.5361424684524536,
-0.390062153339386,
-0.9381994605064392,
-0.13888129591941833,
-0.042887166142463684,
-0.5306382179260254,
0.19126631319522858,
-0.32075926661491394,
-0.012835318222641945,
-0.28462010622024536,
-0.04939044266939163,
-0.3767877221107483,
0.2109818011522293,
0.3159320056438446,
1.051904320716858,
-0.053315550088882446,
0.7075588703155518,
0.39277350902557373,
-0.6061521172523499,
-0.41648927330970764,
-0.26148203015327454,
-0.3769957721233368,
-0.8022480010986328,
1.023024320602417,
0.31955021619796753,
-0.3385213017463684,
0.13959547877311707,
-0.468196302652359,
-1.3150814771652222,
1.1880697011947632,
0.29838383197784424,
-0.5721416473388672,
-0.3731648027896881,
0.021601293236017227,
0.7208830118179321,
-0.5796555280685425,
0.7381228804588318,
0.3687845766544342,
0.3053198456764221,
0.13415759801864624,
-0.8251355886459351,
0.06108599156141281,
-0.07565617561340332,
-0.006569861434400082,
0.23414844274520874,
-0.8113056421279907,
0.7255979180335999,
-0.3112615644931793,
-0.521858274936676,
0.17376385629177094,
0.8767555952072144,
-0.2794865667819977,
-0.1401294320821762,
0.2626349627971649,
0.460468590259552,
0.502720057964325,
0.42114460468292236,
1.1357498168945312,
-0.7025586366653442,
0.2940947413444519,
1.2158265113830566,
-0.3541853725910187,
1.184017300605774,
0.3234916031360626,
0.06741982698440552,
0.2994898855686188,
0.333346426486969,
0.1621580272912979,
0.44466984272003174,
0.18131475150585175,
-0.385959655046463,
-0.4053340554237366,
-0.20986241102218628,
-0.14800040423870087,
0.6355757713317871,
0.4071611762046814,
-0.5146285891532898,
-0.6817607879638672,
-0.06312917917966843,
-0.33970385789871216,
0.1482287049293518,
-0.2563163638114929,
0.7745106816291809,
0.04832390695810318,
-0.8950380682945251,
0.1287699192762375,
0.07276652753353119,
0.7164522409439087,
-0.761294424533844,
-0.053164042532444,
-0.34166866540908813,
-0.03534678742289543,
-0.1530998945236206,
-0.8238422274589539,
0.23957157135009766,
-0.1603408008813858,
-0.049604542553424835,
-0.5510173439979553,
1.0930116176605225,
-0.3993653953075409,
-0.39298421144485474,
0.9890100955963135,
0.7650426030158997,
0.2746623754501343,
-0.20607347786426544,
-0.47980111837387085,
-0.18523550033569336,
-0.16534417867660522,
-0.59468674659729,
0.6984720826148987,
0.42613115906715393,
0.24604207277297974,
1.2115740776062012,
0.6589375734329224,
-0.005481631960719824,
0.17172473669052124,
-0.05067726597189903,
0.9420707821846008,
-0.8705959320068359,
-0.3790269196033478,
-0.8383976221084595,
-0.10035647451877594,
0.21647359430789948,
0.025276919826865196,
0.5380617380142212,
0.8258863091468811,
0.6495899558067322,
0.3042605519294739,
0.8934119939804077,
-0.12787330150604248,
0.6577448844909668,
-0.24513693153858185,
0.5546826720237732,
-0.8341001272201538,
0.271041601896286,
0.06744043529033661,
-0.8026015162467957,
0.08192142099142075,
0.4218062460422516,
-0.10791796445846558,
0.014116843231022358,
0.2954881191253662,
0.8137630820274353,
0.015771549195051193,
-0.21897797286510468,
0.6490681767463684,
0.4459381103515625,
0.37421172857284546,
0.14900940656661987,
0.7086040377616882,
-0.27607205510139465,
0.6623645424842834,
0.07170287519693375,
-0.2518378794193268,
-0.22686061263084412,
-0.6071147918701172,
-0.4871854782104492,
-0.6861040592193604,
0.2288549244403839,
-0.08803179115056992,
0.05177947133779526,
0.8938843011856079,
0.4971235990524292,
-0.20089709758758545,
-0.3823038339614868,
0.14558877050876617,
0.040649376809597015,
0.44287294149398804,
-0.23984304070472717,
0.04528788849711418,
-0.7452884316444397,
-0.629725992679596,
0.7395570874214172,
0.6974751949310303,
0.02178567834198475,
-0.8332030177116394,
0.04809089004993439,
-0.4546829164028168,
0.027843661606311798,
0.5926246643066406,
0.46287399530410767,
-0.5197834968566895,
-0.22455646097660065,
0.2315332144498825,
-0.43890929222106934,
0.3195945620536804,
0.7976247668266296,
-1.1166691780090332,
0.6582136750221252,
0.36705246567726135,
0.9103131890296936,
0.6525752544403076,
0.01746409572660923,
0.7309715747833252,
-0.5893923044204712,
-0.47064921259880066,
0.24470247328281403,
0.33679038286209106,
0.30907127261161804,
-0.6905795335769653,
0.6753674149513245,
-0.2085932344198227,
-0.6894218921661377,
-0.5730925798416138,
0.1552194058895111,
-0.5177062749862671,
-0.4007069170475006,
1.0093207359313965,
0.11178918182849884,
-0.48883992433547974,
-0.06352370977401733,
-0.09901820868253708,
0.1335977166891098,
-0.47483691573143005,
0.8805398344993591,
0.5559242963790894,
-0.15273621678352356,
-0.17144256830215454,
-0.43795788288116455,
-0.06674173474311829,
0.4209482669830322,
-0.728331983089447,
0.20631460845470428,
0.3262809216976166,
0.3924669325351715,
0.5012850165367126,
1.0281723737716675,
-0.21470953524112701,
-0.0978177860379219,
-0.4725501239299774,
0.4063001871109009,
0.11352695524692535,
-0.44641244411468506,
-0.2749547064304352,
0.25916004180908203,
0.11986338347196579,
0.14867010712623596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16893v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16893v1
|
The Good and The Bad: Exploring Privacy Issues in Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
| 2024-02-23T18:35:15 | 2024-02-23T18:35:15 |
Shenglai Zeng, Jiankun Zhang, Pengfei He, Yue Xing, Yiding Liu, Han Xu, Jie Ren, Shuaiqiang Wang, Dawei Yin, Yi Chang, Jiliang Tang
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) is a powerful technique to facilitate
language model with proprietary and private data, where data privacy is a
pivotal concern. Whereas extensive research has demonstrated the privacy risks
of large language models (LLMs), the RAG technique could potentially reshape
the inherent behaviors of LLM generation, posing new privacy issues that are
currently under-explored. In this work, we conduct extensive empirical studies
with novel attack methods, which demonstrate the vulnerability of RAG systems
on leaking the private retrieval database. Despite the new risk brought by RAG
on the retrieval data, we further reveal that RAG can mitigate the leakage of
the LLMs' training data. Overall, we provide new insights in this paper for
privacy protection of retrieval-augmented LLMs, which benefit both LLMs and RAG
systems builders. Our code is available at
https://github.com/phycholosogy/RAG-privacy.
|
[
-0.3637211322784424,
-0.58563232421875,
0.3868885338306427,
-0.10226723551750183,
-0.14377911388874054,
0.45669326186180115,
0.06263010948896408,
-0.6735147833824158,
0.17905573546886444,
0.9102749824523926,
-0.18734169006347656,
-0.3391389846801758,
-0.6455184817314148,
-0.2286468744277954,
-0.5319845676422119,
1.271591067314148,
0.31445565819740295,
-0.07605884224176407,
-0.13476590812206268,
-0.10700500011444092,
-0.2889314591884613,
-0.7721425890922546,
-0.5338780879974365,
0.018706824630498886,
0.47831299901008606,
0.16580550372600555,
0.5451230406761169,
0.4714008569717407,
0.6884366869926453,
0.31107527017593384,
-0.32389894127845764,
0.18826471269130707,
-0.8527578711509705,
0.6292712092399597,
-0.4140815734863281,
-0.5136111974716187,
-0.4228161573410034,
-0.08639007806777954,
0.6740838289260864,
0.31737184524536133,
-0.17605727910995483,
0.6124916672706604,
0.16729530692100525,
1.0399528741836548,
-1.1428807973861694,
-0.2632961571216583,
-0.8221709132194519,
-0.04925117641687393,
-0.7212945818901062,
-0.3075307607650757,
-0.6772326231002808,
-0.42404910922050476,
-0.18780000507831573,
-0.1834901124238968,
0.4857848882675171,
0.26519834995269775,
0.7745741605758667,
0.2942396104335785,
-0.32756465673446655,
-0.06991294771432877,
-0.8553923964500427,
0.7855550050735474,
-0.3514059782028198,
0.3784838914871216,
0.7177908420562744,
0.5023446083068848,
-0.44184643030166626,
-0.5554205179214478,
-0.3599429428577423,
-0.21911250054836273,
-0.1515292227268219,
-0.16648942232131958,
0.06713790446519852,
-0.14621998369693756,
0.2956611216068268,
0.7622891068458557,
-0.5117161870002747,
0.038913972675800323,
-0.2935298979282379,
-0.19811005890369415,
0.8741495013237,
0.031088553369045258,
0.05110859125852585,
-0.5105654001235962,
-0.6649627089500427,
-0.05684937164187431,
-0.9238618016242981,
-0.10687458515167236,
0.7956793904304504,
0.14843404293060303,
-0.11655448377132416,
0.6572107076644897,
0.11665710806846619,
0.5244066715240479,
-0.04518734663724899,
-0.14421631395816803,
0.272113561630249,
-0.09479164332151413,
-0.12782755494117737,
-0.13515520095825195,
0.7324825525283813,
-0.01607525534927845,
0.08833026140928268,
-0.4765990078449249,
-0.25968417525291443,
-0.39047712087631226,
0.3812602162361145,
-0.4935248792171478,
0.2628597617149353,
0.2323625385761261,
-0.48224538564682007,
-0.50901859998703,
0.17063894867897034,
-0.9550246000289917,
-0.9649325013160706,
0.05950099974870682,
0.44578424096107483,
-0.12616930902004242,
-0.48059046268463135,
0.037614062428474426,
-0.10093338042497635,
0.30529963970184326,
-0.15721730887889862,
-0.8179663419723511,
0.5492997169494629,
1.138805866241455,
0.4381309449672699,
-0.29117676615715027,
-0.04981990158557892,
-0.7925574779510498,
0.4419039785861969,
-0.24012795090675354,
0.615938663482666,
-0.29874539375305176,
-0.8115440011024475,
-0.0401938259601593,
0.02020139805972576,
0.1549212783575058,
-0.7394333481788635,
0.3917999565601349,
-0.893760085105896,
0.1496504545211792,
0.03531666472554207,
-0.48330119252204895,
0.20132921636104584,
0.2641769349575043,
-0.719109296798706,
0.8269754648208618,
0.02349337749183178,
-1.053942322731018,
-0.06663381308317184,
-0.37475264072418213,
-0.2541517913341522,
0.01720660924911499,
-0.23426587879657745,
-0.6559849977493286,
0.35846835374832153,
-0.10125278681516647,
0.3707430064678192,
-0.11157282441854477,
0.03005041368305683,
-0.23105977475643158,
-0.387734055519104,
0.7594739198684692,
-0.29813557863235474,
0.9161742925643921,
0.5036488175392151,
-0.19353052973747253,
-0.45796260237693787,
-0.8178355097770691,
0.07905780524015427,
0.1948111206293106,
-0.2134188562631607,
-0.5851982235908508,
-0.14954519271850586,
-0.4617220461368561,
-0.2935125529766083,
0.5568801164627075,
-0.6190587878227234,
-0.04277884215116501,
-0.47693297266960144,
-0.27657124400138855,
0.8183616995811462,
0.4032270908355713,
0.8152315616607666,
-0.30026721954345703,
0.7803424596786499,
-0.2972336411476135,
0.3771747052669525,
0.003238098230212927,
-0.3296767771244049,
-0.25445273518562317,
-0.25146564841270447,
0.6322318315505981,
0.47409602999687195,
-0.49652591347694397,
-0.07809143513441086,
-0.015921777114272118,
-0.4061644375324249,
-0.4497092068195343,
0.08867966383695602,
0.747320294380188,
0.3858720064163208,
-0.0019487463869154453,
-0.22778280079364777,
-0.45258697867393494,
-0.8666601777076721,
-0.7004872560501099,
0.07745295017957687,
0.048034511506557465,
0.6677018404006958,
0.16498522460460663,
-0.2477594017982483,
0.7361392378807068,
-0.4338250160217285,
-0.2534584403038025,
0.14281941950321198,
-0.12026997655630112,
0.09336226433515549,
0.663912296295166,
0.3588107228279114,
-0.9136351943016052,
-0.5056099891662598,
-0.13598410785198212,
-0.6023099422454834,
0.03166269510984421,
0.19800318777561188,
-0.4145592153072357,
0.3849811851978302,
0.3855806291103363,
-0.5618170499801636,
0.6045410633087158,
0.8091385364532471,
-0.23452438414096832,
0.5661207437515259,
-0.2052725851535797,
-0.1106238141655922,
-1.1236189603805542,
0.08680833131074905,
-0.39253079891204834,
-0.37989795207977295,
-0.49490880966186523,
0.42693448066711426,
0.09727412462234497,
-0.3941737413406372,
-0.6231845617294312,
0.6146124601364136,
-0.6703460216522217,
-0.3315795660018921,
-0.365689754486084,
-0.22469355165958405,
0.035531360656023026,
0.06528438627719879,
-0.49161848425865173,
0.9715969562530518,
0.5313754677772522,
-0.5802243947982788,
-0.11284187436103821,
0.19310729205608368,
-0.004796886816620827,
0.19456417858600616,
-0.17229600250720978,
0.6480956673622131,
-0.20144964754581451,
0.09146987646818161,
-0.642861008644104,
-0.3658785820007324,
0.3062942326068878,
-0.9067156910896301,
0.8991647362709045,
-0.2797989249229431,
-0.5342536568641663,
0.07385776937007904,
-0.6617913246154785,
0.33295395970344543,
0.5511705875396729,
-0.642238199710846,
0.6168347001075745,
0.8493070006370544,
0.02252722717821598,
-1.1708146333694458,
-0.7349944710731506,
0.24656884372234344,
-0.4331050515174866,
-0.4596248269081116,
0.40808650851249695,
0.06433738768100739,
-0.42137253284454346,
0.07881058752536774,
-0.11485622823238373,
-0.1294313669204712,
0.36623048782348633,
0.3377339243888855,
0.22984644770622253,
0.17156191170215607,
-0.1705499142408371,
-0.1887914538383484,
-0.4366520941257477,
0.17836537957191467,
0.23559191823005676,
0.608738899230957,
0.05766654759645462,
-0.2859213352203369,
-0.11197466403245926,
0.5145815014839172,
0.12985266745090485,
-0.5179811716079712,
0.9736483097076416,
0.4041513502597809,
-0.23330993950366974,
-0.4498870372772217,
-0.6704403758049011,
-0.15247038006782532,
-0.5781368613243103,
0.06292204558849335,
-0.04711702838540077,
-0.7912936210632324,
0.40018269419670105,
-0.10388278216123581,
-0.04856317117810249,
0.027124926447868347,
0.29806792736053467,
-0.18191678822040558,
0.8530869483947754,
0.8671107888221741,
-0.004145375452935696,
0.45804426074028015,
-0.3149590492248535,
0.23190851509571075,
-1.1271504163742065,
-0.27778053283691406,
-0.6091552376747131,
-0.28027135133743286,
-1.1326569318771362,
-0.36487916111946106,
0.3964426815509796,
0.09497158974409103,
-0.3205726742744446,
0.06462428718805313,
-0.6989128589630127,
0.8031752705574036,
0.4186137914657593,
0.17809271812438965,
0.4731560945510864,
0.13568444550037384,
0.2941316068172455,
-0.06518173962831497,
-0.1223616674542427,
-0.45731303095817566,
1.3122221231460571,
0.3404441773891449,
1.1087682247161865,
0.4039378762245178,
1.4530309438705444,
0.10266907513141632,
0.23520363867282867,
-0.38480454683303833,
0.7170763611793518,
-0.463437020778656,
-1.0493433475494385,
-0.18444159626960754,
-0.5880457162857056,
-1.2274906635284424,
0.08910051733255386,
-0.07369251549243927,
-0.9112218618392944,
0.5009177923202515,
0.09398286044597626,
-0.09914803504943848,
0.3028736412525177,
-0.7438657283782959,
0.3486085534095764,
-0.21018099784851074,
-0.7129726409912109,
0.04415368288755417,
-0.7158831357955933,
0.6096278429031372,
-0.3555293083190918,
0.34858012199401855,
0.14023269712924957,
-0.1604709029197693,
0.7016486525535583,
-0.2698282301425934,
0.6953591108322144,
-0.36870330572128296,
-0.05043531581759453,
0.12136460095643997,
0.4228809177875519,
0.6789153814315796,
0.23684172332286835,
-0.11435002833604813,
0.03827158734202385,
-0.2243691086769104,
-0.2608806788921356,
-0.49309438467025757,
0.7857480049133301,
-0.4892995059490204,
-0.8746734857559204,
-0.6428025364875793,
-0.5450318455696106,
-0.4567149877548218,
0.18312425911426544,
0.14123082160949707,
0.14393357932567596,
0.14878156781196594,
0.32228657603263855,
1.004428505897522,
-0.5797208547592163,
0.16605938971042633,
0.7678906321525574,
-0.5137125253677368,
-0.30605337023735046,
1.190817952156067,
0.057972848415374756,
0.33826956152915955,
0.1336824893951416,
0.36109837889671326,
-0.11362922936677933,
-0.7126294374465942,
-0.11024792492389679,
0.6188074350357056,
-0.41964152455329895,
-0.44443240761756897,
-0.44797688722610474,
-0.3617834448814392,
-0.3357858657836914,
0.2764449119567871,
-0.47376489639282227,
-0.5356355905532837,
-0.13652820885181427,
-0.14348892867565155,
0.45889967679977417,
0.7202315926551819,
-0.38501331210136414,
0.027860058471560478,
-0.8820605874061584,
0.5324575901031494,
0.10874782502651215,
0.46673139929771423,
-0.0965777337551117,
-0.3997156023979187,
-0.20246337354183197,
-0.23460066318511963,
-0.46616488695144653,
-0.854812741279602,
0.36396315693855286,
-0.11997998505830765,
0.525753378868103,
-0.005174968857318163,
0.11268474161624908,
0.3390589654445648,
-0.7134543061256409,
0.7623938322067261,
-0.2412654012441635,
-0.5235543251037598,
0.39376434683799744,
-0.40758463740348816,
-0.17537733912467957,
0.5986346006393433,
0.25293096899986267,
-0.12418507039546967,
-0.5874273180961609,
-0.9676721096038818,
-0.9251096248626709,
0.5937942862510681,
0.06793216615915298,
0.36495694518089294,
0.09814755618572235,
0.5185440182685852,
0.16899919509887695,
0.37180644273757935,
-0.6430560946464539,
-0.5851261019706726,
0.12384182959794998,
0.14502885937690735,
0.18566381931304932,
-0.47237634658813477,
-0.15934407711029053,
0.1383952498435974,
0.5757323503494263,
0.4825662076473236,
0.273246705532074,
-0.09615106135606766,
0.1300831437110901,
-0.07507938891649246,
0.24545007944107056,
0.2677861452102661,
0.3799174129962921,
-0.17495223879814148,
0.154366135597229,
0.015120640397071838,
-0.7821162939071655,
0.27114033699035645,
0.28362956643104553,
-0.28066280484199524,
0.04129665344953537,
-0.02765396051108837,
0.3039622902870178,
0.06487184017896652,
-0.3875991404056549,
0.5267501473426819,
-0.12494824826717377,
-0.050393931567668915,
-0.49697598814964294,
0.20382575690746307,
0.06778725236654282,
0.19380347430706024,
0.4436478614807129,
0.00860636681318283,
0.3534688353538513,
-0.37856078147888184,
0.1701994389295578,
0.5977573394775391,
0.12021889537572861,
-0.1068090870976448,
0.6097106337547302,
-0.13085301220417023,
-0.604681670665741,
-0.004433296620845795,
-0.2686244547367096,
-0.3092847764492035,
0.3085271418094635,
0.5944088101387024,
0.8665972352027893,
-0.614313542842865,
0.21849499642848969,
0.0827394351363182,
0.12000595033168793,
0.031952764838933945,
0.2703993618488312,
-0.11482134461402893,
-0.41867324709892273,
-0.38217103481292725,
-0.5943294763565063,
-0.6623352766036987,
0.19628852605819702,
-0.9604144096374512,
-0.09189862012863159,
-0.42340028285980225,
-0.28901851177215576,
-0.5376361608505249,
-0.0041997130028903484,
-0.38092753291130066,
-0.11930461972951889,
0.229875847697258,
0.5656630396842957,
-0.13461396098136902,
0.5962498188018799,
0.34152087569236755,
-0.1271555870771408,
-0.8496723175048828,
0.10183724761009216,
-0.07111668586730957,
-0.722726047039032,
0.7446374297142029,
-0.1186658963561058,
-0.2553832530975342,
-0.2394285649061203,
-0.5301882028579712,
-1.1458245515823364,
0.8923838138580322,
0.6447833776473999,
-0.5611671805381775,
-0.0995367169380188,
0.4322972297668457,
0.4596923291683197,
0.23888207972049713,
-0.4998524487018585,
0.5056668519973755,
0.23187454044818878,
-0.27980664372444153,
-0.7603244781494141,
-0.13866780698299408,
0.010641039349138737,
0.030154237523674965,
0.4637484848499298,
-0.6289557218551636,
0.8693468570709229,
-0.0483606792986393,
-0.437982976436615,
0.13536275923252106,
0.44020864367485046,
0.592948853969574,
0.502804696559906,
0.3324211537837982,
0.677496075630188,
0.8456066846847534,
0.2544642984867096,
1.467040777206421,
-0.24369177222251892,
0.36543339490890503,
1.2196985483169556,
-0.3186543583869934,
0.8815348148345947,
0.5523574352264404,
-0.027260281145572662,
0.3065606653690338,
0.129489004611969,
0.2574102282524109,
0.6684408187866211,
0.3824046552181244,
-0.5177745223045349,
0.36812570691108704,
0.006819435860961676,
-0.5821024179458618,
0.21208593249320984,
0.41563668847084045,
-0.4601280093193054,
-0.17118018865585327,
0.15065021812915802,
0.27465856075286865,
0.2974364757537842,
-0.21375033259391785,
0.9153250455856323,
0.3171836733818054,
-0.3341013789176941,
0.5994433760643005,
-0.20139765739440918,
0.607302188873291,
-0.48277103900909424,
0.051821019500494,
-0.23000700771808624,
0.28717976808547974,
-0.4540417492389679,
-0.66828852891922,
0.41238832473754883,
0.3163449168205261,
0.011983424425125122,
-0.13561803102493286,
0.9912001490592957,
-0.03988371044397354,
-0.16451609134674072,
0.31381770968437195,
0.5393266677856445,
0.1804656684398651,
0.10249163955450058,
-0.5913184285163879,
0.27492865920066833,
-0.07917611300945282,
-0.44990965723991394,
0.7902273535728455,
0.5798099040985107,
0.0450994037091732,
0.5428905487060547,
0.6337563991546631,
0.3637644350528717,
0.3060959279537201,
0.07619080692529678,
0.8115026354789734,
-0.669008195400238,
-0.3299831748008728,
-0.7819764018058777,
0.39910969138145447,
-0.2251434326171875,
-0.0038510607555508614,
1.1537039279937744,
0.6136160492897034,
0.7347345352172852,
0.1481807976961136,
0.5429538488388062,
0.18368001282215118,
1.3254966735839844,
-0.5077922344207764,
1.0621211528778076,
-0.32582810521125793,
0.6402716636657715,
-0.18630099296569824,
-0.8947106599807739,
-0.33311277627944946,
0.22116383910179138,
-0.36621156334877014,
-0.022704394534230232,
0.6583620309829712,
1.0401579141616821,
0.08736611157655716,
-0.12041690200567245,
0.16078858077526093,
0.33590686321258545,
0.5181546211242676,
0.024676332250237465,
0.9785947203636169,
-0.36829036474227905,
0.48367980122566223,
-0.48919954895973206,
-0.1376318484544754,
0.12831419706344604,
-0.8100442290306091,
-0.6698703765869141,
-0.36562809348106384,
0.0356978215277195,
-0.5934333801269531,
0.28550806641578674,
0.258528470993042,
0.35273727774620056,
-0.44511139392852783,
-0.21328501403331757,
0.09231137484312057,
0.0228156466037035,
0.26109445095062256,
-0.2613813877105713,
0.4574207663536072,
-0.31490999460220337,
-0.571128785610199,
0.47213804721832275,
-0.053235266357660294,
0.038378167897462845,
-0.5744402408599854,
0.019762026146054268,
-0.1184987872838974,
-0.13195836544036865,
0.27892348170280457,
0.46263155341148376,
-0.2602570056915283,
-0.1555280238389969,
-0.0624268539249897,
-0.122083880007267,
-0.0517880879342556,
0.7451915740966797,
-0.8579102158546448,
0.40434926748275757,
0.39891478419303894,
1.0030113458633423,
0.7273207902908325,
0.25777387619018555,
0.2920267879962921,
-1.05733323097229,
0.25089070200920105,
0.516821026802063,
0.1828337013721466,
0.5175838470458984,
-0.8355368375778198,
0.5825204849243164,
-0.20413275063037872,
-1.0188064575195312,
-1.480483889579773,
0.28338319063186646,
-0.7435399889945984,
-0.1462370604276657,
1.198935627937317,
0.07087633013725281,
-0.7278826832771301,
-0.08451901376247406,
-0.2249317169189453,
0.038343336433172226,
-0.29585444927215576,
0.8746047616004944,
0.2874760329723358,
0.03648677095770836,
0.20436647534370422,
-0.9039508700370789,
0.6393986940383911,
0.22786864638328552,
-0.6280505061149597,
0.15045537054538727,
0.21953801810741425,
0.28756511211395264,
0.3085367679595947,
0.6491600871086121,
-0.6910111308097839,
0.3156520128250122,
-0.32441282272338867,
-0.3444555401802063,
-0.18628789484500885,
-0.2277485430240631,
-0.45766183733940125,
0.09914293885231018,
0.13806912302970886,
-0.463565468788147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15491v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15491v2
|
API-BLEND: A Comprehensive Corpora for Training and Benchmarking API LLMs
| 2024-02-23T18:30:49 | 2024-05-20T14:52:31 |
Kinjal Basu, Ibrahim Abdelaziz, Subhajit Chaudhury, Soham Dan, Maxwell Crouse, Asim Munawar, Sadhana Kumaravel, Vinod Muthusamy, Pavan Kapanipathi, Luis A. Lastras
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
There is a growing need for Large Language Models (LLMs) to effectively use
tools and external Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) to plan and
complete tasks. As such, there is tremendous interest in methods that can
acquire sufficient quantities of train and test data that involve calls to
tools / APIs. Two lines of research have emerged as the predominant strategies
for addressing this challenge. The first has focused on synthetic data
generation techniques, while the second has involved curating task-adjacent
datasets which can be transformed into API / Tool-based tasks. In this paper,
we focus on the task of identifying, curating, and transforming existing
datasets and, in turn, introduce API-BLEND, a large corpora for training and
systematic testing of tool-augmented LLMs. The datasets mimic real-world
scenarios involving API-tasks such as API / tool detection, slot filling, and
sequencing of the detected APIs. We demonstrate the utility of the API-BLEND
dataset for both training and benchmarking purposes.
|
[
-0.5642507076263428,
-0.7492228150367737,
0.39527183771133423,
0.2473476529121399,
0.0028534650336951017,
0.5935618281364441,
-0.37615999579429626,
-0.4504602253437042,
0.061326030641794205,
0.6353780627250671,
-0.672619640827179,
-0.5978448987007141,
-0.24952003359794617,
0.3218657374382019,
-0.7383378148078918,
0.6197388172149658,
-0.4094752073287964,
0.27023208141326904,
-0.3367060720920563,
-0.17991548776626587,
-0.8221485018730164,
-0.5042758584022522,
-0.5642631649971008,
-0.32283639907836914,
0.3632529377937317,
0.2360040694475174,
0.34981095790863037,
0.6047306656837463,
0.24569973349571228,
0.29487183690071106,
0.20717792212963104,
0.36196237802505493,
-0.43209391832351685,
0.31687864661216736,
-0.0871521532535553,
-0.8578951358795166,
-0.15750764310359955,
0.1858624517917633,
0.4217575490474701,
1.1481729745864868,
0.09134702384471893,
0.40861982107162476,
0.07506807148456573,
0.23836463689804077,
-0.5298531651496887,
0.16048620641231537,
-0.7748558521270752,
0.20442324876785278,
-0.2758793532848358,
-0.2925961911678314,
-0.13032644987106323,
-0.35051122307777405,
0.044888220727443695,
-0.749569833278656,
0.2826663553714752,
0.47834405303001404,
0.44747379422187805,
0.23182564973831177,
-0.2610071897506714,
-0.34195536375045776,
-0.6060481071472168,
1.1272051334381104,
-0.46131718158721924,
0.5988240838050842,
0.28168785572052,
0.2650505006313324,
-0.28609418869018555,
-0.5925414562225342,
-0.5049622058868408,
0.01408454030752182,
0.1305028200149536,
-0.03661544620990753,
0.12023620307445526,
-0.21329441666603088,
0.18000495433807373,
0.5760746598243713,
-0.6858952641487122,
0.18488545715808868,
-0.29443037509918213,
-0.3012174367904663,
0.395268052816391,
0.19329124689102173,
0.3586873412132263,
0.4760693907737732,
-0.296673059463501,
-0.37792447209358215,
-0.8712545037269592,
-0.19036684930324554,
0.5823332071304321,
0.5500299334526062,
0.014070465229451656,
0.6975798606872559,
-0.1488056480884552,
0.7945848703384399,
-0.29461395740509033,
-0.24714376032352448,
0.6325368881225586,
-0.3433257043361664,
-0.3197399079799652,
-0.025030069053173065,
0.528519868850708,
0.15487711131572723,
0.1457495391368866,
-0.5281412601470947,
-0.36199721693992615,
0.44773733615875244,
0.37261369824409485,
-0.5198376774787903,
0.0344230942428112,
0.5396866202354431,
-0.2386416792869568,
-0.2876548171043396,
-0.3115556538105011,
-0.5941370725631714,
-0.2938345670700073,
-0.9531692266464233,
0.04024866595864296,
-0.43536368012428284,
-0.45271044969558716,
0.04599267244338989,
-0.26980406045913696,
0.3576010465621948,
0.14126808941364288,
-0.5932344794273376,
0.5001727938652039,
1.2373220920562744,
0.7487537264823914,
-0.7366551756858826,
-0.2918851673603058,
-0.6863718032836914,
-0.0953957661986351,
-0.5345259308815002,
0.9574808478355408,
-0.6854015588760376,
-0.43548694252967834,
0.5263715982437134,
0.12213973701000214,
0.12561851739883423,
-1.1592433452606201,
0.5102235674858093,
-0.3497154414653778,
-0.08813794702291489,
-0.20457489788532257,
-0.7673719525337219,
0.17152398824691772,
0.6093102097511292,
-0.5245513319969177,
1.643280267715454,
0.6079202890396118,
-0.3813205063343048,
0.4015142619609833,
-0.4132470488548279,
-0.44791391491889954,
0.05001683905720711,
-0.3581790626049042,
-0.1153302788734436,
0.03232791647315025,
-0.13925698399543762,
0.047024112194776535,
-0.46041184663772583,
0.14205102622509003,
-0.6586111187934875,
-0.3870657980442047,
0.399349182844162,
-0.13117650151252747,
0.6545664072036743,
0.2603846490383148,
-0.15515899658203125,
0.20163817703723907,
-0.9442703127861023,
0.06653634458780289,
-0.16576401889324188,
-0.33138689398765564,
-0.4912468194961548,
-0.3097962737083435,
0.3688185214996338,
0.10553130507469177,
0.25264936685562134,
-0.7309322953224182,
0.17092379927635193,
-0.4268987476825714,
0.3514258861541748,
0.661953866481781,
-0.42123734951019287,
0.5115000605583191,
-0.27887070178985596,
0.5451301336288452,
-0.01622037962079048,
0.15038427710533142,
-0.1122845932841301,
-0.2117675244808197,
-0.8291659355163574,
-0.3329062759876251,
0.46104201674461365,
0.6966463327407837,
-0.7284232974052429,
0.676581621170044,
-0.0984659269452095,
-0.5138799548149109,
-0.7651718258857727,
0.4636111259460449,
0.1495823711156845,
0.5822715163230896,
0.3019179701805115,
-0.48642849922180176,
-0.82304447889328,
-0.784396767616272,
-0.09249953180551529,
0.09499692916870117,
-0.4009467661380768,
0.27706533670425415,
0.216526597738266,
-0.36876729130744934,
1.125311255455017,
-0.38636669516563416,
0.03953378647565842,
-0.11121125519275665,
0.2036520540714264,
0.1377740055322647,
0.44751429557800293,
0.3754775822162628,
-0.6902306079864502,
-0.4015933871269226,
-0.1928810328245163,
-0.7167190313339233,
-0.48582372069358826,
-0.017340168356895447,
-0.5136764645576477,
-0.04851759970188141,
0.7456960678100586,
-0.39111027121543884,
0.08091580122709274,
0.6476330757141113,
0.11255745589733124,
0.743267834186554,
0.250151664018631,
-0.08624955266714096,
-0.8651949167251587,
0.1561412364244461,
-0.17234891653060913,
-0.36644724011421204,
-0.3096022605895996,
0.11876991391181946,
0.0946372002363205,
-0.25948938727378845,
-0.4854002296924591,
0.9045969843864441,
-0.4922493100166321,
-0.44445890188217163,
-0.4010545015335083,
-0.13255634903907776,
0.02378382347524166,
0.35667386651039124,
-0.06578753143548965,
1.028332233428955,
0.8162369728088379,
-0.49159348011016846,
0.4446256458759308,
0.4397084712982178,
-0.24902266263961792,
0.8175130486488342,
-0.4713856279850006,
0.07902122288942337,
0.21760667860507965,
0.0773484855890274,
-1.0840773582458496,
-0.03642251342535019,
0.135525643825531,
0.0984480008482933,
0.05673302337527275,
-0.3342236876487732,
-0.850376307964325,
-0.3247106373310089,
-0.4011673629283905,
0.41595765948295593,
0.5050389170646667,
-0.6785948276519775,
0.8114669919013977,
0.44206637144088745,
-0.26197487115859985,
-0.4031195640563965,
-0.6653806567192078,
-0.006253568455576897,
-0.3536892235279083,
-0.46033528447151184,
0.3815130889415741,
-0.37615329027175903,
-0.20585058629512787,
-0.1280876249074936,
-0.2628954350948334,
-0.06744500249624252,
0.0327296182513237,
0.35352805256843567,
0.4815228581428528,
-0.14450731873512268,
-0.08818880468606949,
-0.10095605254173279,
0.11949416995048523,
0.10630188137292862,
-0.24522873759269714,
0.8464813828468323,
0.19823242723941803,
-0.629925549030304,
-0.09009577333927155,
0.43053027987480164,
0.3863217830657959,
-0.22796690464019775,
0.28835541009902954,
0.6256878972053528,
-0.05477061867713928,
-0.42584946751594543,
-0.7790809273719788,
0.020156333222985268,
-0.49913057684898376,
0.0589158833026886,
-0.21642112731933594,
-0.7123981714248657,
0.6563600301742554,
-0.7919050455093384,
0.39434370398521423,
-0.055190060287714005,
0.53859543800354,
0.09628049284219742,
0.6917327642440796,
0.5220221877098083,
-0.23190049827098846,
0.5591269731521606,
-0.3098208010196686,
0.0953437089920044,
-0.9492881298065186,
0.058974362909793854,
-0.5539233088493347,
-0.20322856307029724,
-0.46071210503578186,
-0.48528534173965454,
0.23639047145843506,
-0.27042850852012634,
-0.21486781537532806,
0.3544880449771881,
-0.3397952914237976,
0.3568946123123169,
0.6985717415809631,
-0.04897482693195343,
0.18163682520389557,
0.10331486910581589,
-0.07388070225715637,
0.2270384132862091,
-0.3737749755382538,
-0.43767327070236206,
1.6130073070526123,
0.17348603904247284,
0.8015846610069275,
-0.2839965224266052,
0.7188196778297424,
0.1624845415353775,
0.39431342482566833,
-0.8543485403060913,
0.6221880316734314,
0.0379427969455719,
-0.416519433259964,
0.03482946380972862,
-0.3052629828453064,
-1.0087348222732544,
0.09851497411727905,
-0.1583319902420044,
-0.2145126909017563,
0.1315847486257553,
0.05434287339448929,
-0.14756518602371216,
0.039707981050014496,
-0.821884274482727,
0.8869428634643555,
-0.4514116048812866,
-0.31013983488082886,
0.1038522720336914,
-0.3394298553466797,
0.1700131744146347,
-0.22324176132678986,
0.2675240933895111,
-0.30082958936691284,
-0.15946482121944427,
0.3543703556060791,
-0.3741385042667389,
0.871630072593689,
0.10101930797100067,
-0.18008659780025482,
0.18050062656402588,
0.0637158751487732,
0.39903226494789124,
-0.09734390676021576,
-0.12134853005409241,
0.2254807949066162,
-0.009982085786759853,
-0.39477086067199707,
-0.3183310925960541,
0.5820028781890869,
-0.68234783411026,
-0.17569561302661896,
-0.36916980147361755,
-0.9046581387519836,
-0.6383602619171143,
0.17750811576843262,
-0.17858630418777466,
0.5843043327331543,
-0.249607115983963,
-0.05618537589907646,
0.7952742576599121,
-0.33233585953712463,
0.03967456892132759,
0.4376302659511566,
-0.25976651906967163,
-0.1489434540271759,
0.7794594168663025,
-0.2878147065639496,
0.18738214671611786,
0.008117993362247944,
-0.1842993050813675,
-0.37004053592681885,
-0.5918450355529785,
-0.3370339870452881,
0.0013970971340313554,
-0.5040660500526428,
-0.2596178650856018,
-0.3681240975856781,
-0.04920557513833046,
-0.3624112904071808,
-0.12010873854160309,
-0.49616897106170654,
-0.02587977983057499,
-0.11117560416460037,
0.17050543427467346,
0.24649864435195923,
0.3138647973537445,
0.1611790508031845,
0.11081475019454956,
-0.529911994934082,
0.2853122055530548,
0.038948457688093185,
0.5425849556922913,
-0.21073578298091888,
-0.11835246533155441,
-0.004232570994645357,
-0.10245662182569504,
-0.18875588476657867,
-0.4529588222503662,
0.4188164472579956,
0.04887818172574043,
0.618683397769928,
0.02283748984336853,
-0.14988133311271667,
0.7229946255683899,
-0.6957032680511475,
0.5555651187896729,
-0.08263338357210159,
-0.45059940218925476,
0.29847243428230286,
-0.19300349056720734,
0.23671303689479828,
0.8612939715385437,
0.40632569789886475,
-0.4296698570251465,
-0.6377004384994507,
-0.40930819511413574,
-1.151129126548767,
0.3783644735813141,
0.08440244197845459,
0.014999465085566044,
0.09161467850208282,
0.19529998302459717,
0.5942673683166504,
0.5310863256454468,
-0.16080905497074127,
-0.19793902337551117,
0.09557313472032547,
-0.6001830697059631,
0.18337520956993103,
0.08989367634057999,
-0.6965631246566772,
-0.03206611052155495,
0.5460819602012634,
-0.2760300040245056,
0.09315896779298782,
-0.19015435874462128,
-0.2080238312482834,
0.24057453870773315,
0.22082224488258362,
0.05876382067799568,
0.774244487285614,
-0.2347346395254135,
0.13053099811077118,
-0.09524574875831604,
-0.39394450187683105,
0.002180365612730384,
0.37356075644493103,
-0.18517225980758667,
0.07681915163993835,
0.10528041422367096,
0.6071656346321106,
0.3241825997829437,
-1.441774606704712,
0.17458757758140564,
-0.08564825356006622,
-0.05897960066795349,
-0.6619573831558228,
0.16927847266197205,
0.045234158635139465,
0.23814065754413605,
0.3192828893661499,
-0.06630732864141464,
0.3896695375442505,
-0.8959856033325195,
0.19018962979316711,
0.38872987031936646,
0.12628675997257233,
-0.0628947988152504,
0.3001299202442169,
0.26008111238479614,
-0.14132848381996155,
0.5018082857131958,
-0.4026893377304077,
-0.29313305020332336,
0.4691600203514099,
0.5071094036102295,
0.6145849823951721,
0.15774308145046234,
-0.06261201202869415,
0.24199458956718445,
-0.08899082243442535,
-0.2631109356880188,
0.4187287390232086,
-0.04252893477678299,
-0.6138288974761963,
-0.4847601652145386,
-0.8691275715827942,
-0.7250037789344788,
0.30921661853790283,
-0.6398769617080688,
0.31979453563690186,
-0.14293153584003448,
-0.002187381498515606,
0.1011786013841629,
-0.15268369019031525,
-0.8935001492500305,
-0.05947245657444,
0.23045103251934052,
1.184347152709961,
-0.9960036873817444,
0.5948945879936218,
0.6551071405410767,
-0.13880214095115662,
-0.6226587891578674,
-0.2876940965652466,
0.13740719854831696,
-1.019210696220398,
0.48791247606277466,
0.15342389047145844,
0.2649119198322296,
-0.36569902300834656,
-0.4679679870605469,
-0.7744179964065552,
0.8386823534965515,
0.5330153107643127,
-0.5247900485992432,
0.1349763125181198,
0.6918854117393494,
0.5073350071907043,
-0.4325472116470337,
0.18732185661792755,
0.883424699306488,
0.2902759611606598,
0.09177853912115097,
-1.037092924118042,
-0.16179898381233215,
-0.26514971256256104,
0.20897281169891357,
0.11939739435911179,
-0.2596988081932068,
0.785231351852417,
0.7013622522354126,
0.10392899066209793,
0.07127616554498672,
0.41783180832862854,
0.6040189266204834,
0.18193696439266205,
0.7334262728691101,
0.6503373980522156,
0.7953948378562927,
-0.25729429721832275,
0.8985992670059204,
-0.4292927384376526,
-0.028071986511349678,
1.2701292037963867,
-0.8219183683395386,
0.839576780796051,
0.6101853847503662,
-0.27261534333229065,
0.41300368309020996,
0.9757187962532043,
-0.204912468791008,
0.42949378490448,
0.3416992723941803,
-0.34592536091804504,
-0.18519507348537445,
-0.31940150260925293,
-0.30709677934646606,
0.3909284472465515,
0.2599596083164215,
-0.051905129104852676,
-0.30228838324546814,
0.2108900547027588,
-0.056569769978523254,
-0.00584110151976347,
-0.26907023787498474,
0.6716448664665222,
-0.12613308429718018,
-0.8556241393089294,
0.4442268908023834,
-0.2935624420642853,
0.963619589805603,
-0.6913963556289673,
-0.08092343062162399,
-0.23760706186294556,
0.15563379228115082,
-0.018689757212996483,
-0.8624393343925476,
0.36345532536506653,
0.01310005970299244,
0.024521198123693466,
-0.3104551136493683,
0.6406441926956177,
-0.7539623975753784,
-0.5784236192703247,
0.28514009714126587,
0.5299572348594666,
0.2607991397380829,
-0.0821920707821846,
-0.7631584405899048,
0.5417402386665344,
-0.3371882438659668,
0.00868512224406004,
0.6387688517570496,
0.4757692813873291,
0.10243657231330872,
0.6572551131248474,
0.781615138053894,
0.2776147127151489,
0.30781471729278564,
0.2258080095052719,
0.9970200061798096,
-0.25862693786621094,
-0.5252506732940674,
-0.46597397327423096,
0.18739667534828186,
-0.2789894938468933,
-0.2339305281639099,
0.5548815131187439,
1.1835566759109497,
1.0558710098266602,
-0.11230815947055817,
1.1048029661178589,
-0.08238478749990463,
0.7997868061065674,
-0.4159328043460846,
0.12374930828809738,
-0.4284076392650604,
0.1401689201593399,
0.19378253817558289,
-0.9090943336486816,
0.06309950351715088,
0.20749831199645996,
-0.042365819215774536,
-0.18020765483379364,
0.42484980821609497,
0.8620035648345947,
-0.49185052514076233,
-0.06529267877340317,
-0.11448488384485245,
-0.04877309128642082,
0.26857873797416687,
0.2660219669342041,
0.6357480883598328,
-0.3237246870994568,
0.6553948521614075,
-0.16813290119171143,
-0.28659096360206604,
-0.10455995798110962,
-0.7362040877342224,
-0.9265816807746887,
-0.521112859249115,
-0.36612820625305176,
-0.23604939877986908,
-0.14490287005901337,
0.9887704253196716,
0.8662917017936707,
-0.8713549375534058,
-0.5262003540992737,
-0.15937568247318268,
-0.21075953543186188,
-0.37957116961479187,
-0.18193940818309784,
0.12444055825471878,
-0.7135651111602783,
-0.9031929969787598,
0.611088216304779,
0.08715138584375381,
-0.015878494828939438,
-0.49958693981170654,
0.1701989769935608,
0.0685550719499588,
-0.06259310990571976,
0.6806690096855164,
0.5061195492744446,
-0.4130888283252716,
0.05591215565800667,
0.1498897522687912,
0.0938873142004013,
0.11185314506292343,
0.9717777371406555,
-0.8894444704055786,
0.4545581340789795,
0.25363996624946594,
1.0986249446868896,
0.3781324625015259,
-0.16773726046085358,
0.7617429494857788,
-1.1126502752304077,
0.4266635477542877,
0.09857539087533951,
0.45792555809020996,
0.545326828956604,
-0.03501695394515991,
0.9608928561210632,
0.08544127643108368,
-0.3592449128627777,
-1.2574187517166138,
0.06976881623268127,
-1.2857425212860107,
-0.21850095689296722,
1.1482446193695068,
0.054083146154880524,
-0.34552907943725586,
-0.42443469166755676,
-0.3605148196220398,
0.213576078414917,
-0.19275645911693573,
0.674476683139801,
0.7359048128128052,
-0.23875470459461212,
0.3036781847476959,
-0.8672178983688354,
0.3789747953414917,
0.20685575902462006,
-1.1591583490371704,
0.2640365660190582,
0.3724552392959595,
0.5669680833816528,
0.221910297870636,
0.4374227225780487,
-0.021852457895874977,
-0.031152265146374702,
-0.007071919739246368,
0.18112196028232574,
0.011437904089689255,
0.0057717738673090935,
0.16422119736671448,
0.03478924185037613,
0.04012158513069153,
-0.18516650795936584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15481v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15481v4
|
Prejudice and Volatility: A Statistical Framework for Measuring Social Discrimination in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T18:15:56 | 2024-05-24T20:02:10 |
Y Liu, K Yang, Z Qi, X Liu, Y Yu, C Zhai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
This study investigates why and how inconsistency in the generation of Large
Language Models (LLMs) might induce or exacerbate societal injustice. For
instance, LLMs frequently exhibit contrasting gender stereotypes regarding the
same career depending on varied contexts, highlighting the arguably harmful
unpredictability of LLMs' behavioral patterns. To augment the existing
discrimination assessment with the capability to account for variation in LLM
generation, we formulate the Prejudice-Volatility Framework (PVF) that
precisely defines behavioral metrics for assessing LLMs, which delineate the
probability distribution of LLMs' stereotypes from the perspective of token
prediction probability. Specifically, we employ a data-mining approach to
approximate the possible applied contexts of LLMs and devise statistical
metrics to evaluate the corresponding contextualized societal discrimination
risk. Further, we mathematically dissect the aggregated discrimination risk of
LLMs into prejudice risk, originating from their system bias, and volatility
risk, stemming from their generation inconsistency. While initially intended
for assessing discrimination in LLMs, our proposed PVF facilitates the
comprehensive and flexible measurement of any inductive biases, including
knowledge alongside prejudice, across various modality models.
We apply PVF to 12 most commonly adopted LLMs and compare their risk levels.
Our findings reveal that: i) prejudice risk is the primary cause of
discrimination risk in LLMs, indicating that inherent biases in these models
lead to stereotypical outputs; ii) most LLMs exhibit significant pro-male
stereotypes across nearly all careers; iii) alignment with Reinforcement
Learning from Human Feedback lowers discrimination by reducing prejudice, but
increases volatility; iv) discrimination risk in LLMs correlates with
socio-economic factors like profession salaries.
|
[
-0.1130915954709053,
-0.7381280064582825,
0.34472987055778503,
0.18465666472911835,
0.20047402381896973,
0.03937520831823349,
0.0012522952165454626,
-0.3724266588687897,
0.025876561179757118,
0.4781983196735382,
-0.2939441204071045,
-0.3904244005680084,
-0.7847171425819397,
-0.12539774179458618,
-0.41534101963043213,
0.7288863062858582,
0.2804623246192932,
0.29372134804725647,
-0.4225127100944519,
-0.16012409329414368,
-0.5713405013084412,
-0.9097427129745483,
-0.2257809340953827,
-0.17103220522403717,
0.38094663619995117,
0.14025966823101044,
0.4350636601448059,
0.45839443802833557,
0.39145326614379883,
0.25450167059898376,
-0.2389463633298874,
-0.3499225974082947,
-0.5172150135040283,
0.5934551358222961,
-0.16902951896190643,
-0.7179800868034363,
-0.07546863704919815,
0.0007408686797134578,
0.4079318940639496,
0.7522344589233398,
-0.2616525888442993,
0.28561288118362427,
0.047798629850149155,
0.6425849795341492,
-0.7938818335533142,
0.1257759928703308,
-0.7500033974647522,
0.18229037523269653,
-0.6215057969093323,
-0.11573709547519684,
-0.28547942638397217,
-0.5044547319412231,
0.12407587468624115,
-0.15613947808742523,
0.3514277935028076,
0.12867704033851624,
0.44930100440979004,
0.2057407647371292,
-0.7547057867050171,
-0.4232695996761322,
-0.8025456070899963,
0.9081710577011108,
-0.30286577343940735,
0.41728445887565613,
0.27323082089424133,
0.2585218548774719,
-0.29247647523880005,
-0.2515810430049896,
-0.4354172646999359,
-0.25140711665153503,
0.22449012100696564,
0.040556926280260086,
0.22671043872833252,
-0.2354108840227127,
0.35803741216659546,
0.5034161806106567,
-0.4519661068916321,
0.13872632384300232,
-0.23734205961227417,
-0.23752117156982422,
0.4985215961933136,
0.460174024105072,
0.14585888385772705,
-0.279453843832016,
-0.12939368188381195,
-0.0460725836455822,
-0.8002812266349792,
0.2334253489971161,
0.7830771207809448,
0.36310839653015137,
-0.048157304525375366,
0.6580063104629517,
0.18300992250442505,
0.37521451711654663,
-0.14094403386116028,
-0.18809916079044342,
0.4732823967933655,
-0.015698464587330818,
-0.07457226514816284,
0.13250353932380676,
0.6195712089538574,
0.40503615140914917,
0.2463604360818863,
0.19953058660030365,
-0.12658680975437164,
0.17825473845005035,
0.10563302040100098,
-0.5194530487060547,
0.21483823657035828,
-0.04528926685452461,
-0.2662782073020935,
-0.6268916726112366,
0.04399268329143524,
-1.176030158996582,
-0.9158989787101746,
0.025556694716215134,
0.054841071367263794,
-0.15273605287075043,
-0.44511285424232483,
0.09050506353378296,
-0.1418224573135376,
0.44430220127105713,
0.28745466470718384,
-0.8286604881286621,
-0.06359406560659409,
0.690784215927124,
0.7005282044410706,
-0.19655415415763855,
0.04619746282696724,
-0.46870332956314087,
0.06700540333986282,
-0.43852436542510986,
0.3446457087993622,
-0.6163711547851562,
-0.5706518888473511,
0.4785119295120239,
-0.11964757740497589,
0.24599014222621918,
-0.5389348268508911,
0.5816961526870728,
-0.3322083055973053,
0.1995600014925003,
-0.45572420954704285,
-0.4837774932384491,
-0.005137185100466013,
0.13440927863121033,
-0.44227710366249084,
0.9950459599494934,
0.14276042580604553,
-1.0136643648147583,
0.9519270062446594,
-0.5557846426963806,
-0.17252932488918304,
0.09004388004541397,
-0.48011505603790283,
-0.4842909276485443,
0.2287546694278717,
-0.28122323751449585,
0.2294515073299408,
-0.4915746748447418,
0.4317720830440521,
-0.6878383159637451,
-0.2526049315929413,
0.4401512145996094,
-0.6132177710533142,
0.9214990139007568,
0.029294319450855255,
-0.3166055977344513,
-0.06203232333064079,
-0.6668707132339478,
-0.6015831232070923,
0.20023541152477264,
-0.3281584084033966,
-0.6347192525863647,
0.3475293219089508,
-0.11612731963396072,
0.21220451593399048,
0.05668250098824501,
-0.40566766262054443,
-0.02769998274743557,
-0.4159792959690094,
0.12931102514266968,
1.2147161960601807,
-0.01712190918624401,
0.46216124296188354,
-0.24652396142482758,
0.5011718273162842,
0.12504297494888306,
0.3565984070301056,
0.48836490511894226,
-0.3206757605075836,
-0.6832161545753479,
-0.26854583621025085,
0.003888661041855812,
0.5365148186683655,
-0.6897833943367004,
0.22042202949523926,
-0.16348950564861298,
-0.31077131628990173,
-0.11342708021402359,
0.04273407533764839,
0.14331881701946259,
0.3970573842525482,
-0.15333926677703857,
-0.3265131711959839,
-0.6041722297668457,
-0.7484129071235657,
-0.5832887887954712,
-0.5974888801574707,
0.07562962919473648,
0.2535112798213959,
0.4248792231082916,
-0.13671313226222992,
0.9279314875602722,
-0.28087449073791504,
-0.17283602058887482,
0.14167243242263794,
0.16236461699008942,
0.2499391883611679,
0.22221162915229797,
0.7830273509025574,
-0.7641506195068359,
-0.30907052755355835,
-0.12560045719146729,
-0.6203612685203552,
-0.22396746277809143,
0.37946847081184387,
-0.03929287567734718,
0.28139472007751465,
0.3842177093029022,
-0.3532085716724396,
0.4586363136768341,
0.37654125690460205,
-0.5282594561576843,
0.7671672701835632,
0.26901480555534363,
0.12358683347702026,
-0.9367880821228027,
-0.4202638566493988,
0.4774283468723297,
-0.0006513980915769935,
-0.38133835792541504,
-0.29560646414756775,
-0.26171931624412537,
0.3576940596103668,
-0.4503025710582733,
0.40966787934303284,
-0.02076881378889084,
-0.07780760526657104,
0.04907843470573425,
-0.153581440448761,
-0.35260000824928284,
-0.04177131503820419,
-0.4175708591938019,
0.822046160697937,
0.6161754727363586,
-0.7215312719345093,
0.2842676341533661,
0.00728808855637908,
-0.4049202501773834,
0.7272784113883972,
-0.3655872642993927,
-0.2917681634426117,
-0.45205244421958923,
-0.21536245942115784,
-0.9750903248786926,
-0.29163694381713867,
0.1950826793909073,
-0.4560713469982147,
-0.055529624223709106,
-0.10988333076238632,
-0.4101907014846802,
-0.3477778136730194,
-0.24796268343925476,
0.3616423010826111,
0.6392289400100708,
-0.39302974939346313,
0.5636772513389587,
0.6583084464073181,
-0.2557692527770996,
-0.8530000448226929,
-0.7324021458625793,
-0.2592734694480896,
-0.6788028478622437,
-0.4144321382045746,
-0.1435098946094513,
-0.012450337409973145,
-0.8125866055488586,
-0.3319384753704071,
-0.1934332698583603,
0.12099145352840424,
0.23727819323539734,
0.44857853651046753,
0.18669576942920685,
0.147913858294487,
0.42146387696266174,
-0.06238910183310509,
0.15293368697166443,
0.3214024007320404,
-0.19629040360450745,
0.5404171347618103,
-0.05114022269845009,
-0.4969119727611542,
0.3438494801521301,
0.1841302365064621,
0.733726978302002,
0.08702198415994644,
0.7364456057548523,
0.5301047563552856,
-0.20855973660945892,
-0.031571950763463974,
-0.5521977543830872,
0.057228151708841324,
-0.4589061141014099,
0.5746232271194458,
-0.18061304092407227,
-1.1879026889801025,
0.6106157898902893,
0.11034399271011353,
0.09858279675245285,
0.4617278277873993,
0.9483034610748291,
0.07524614036083221,
0.9806499481201172,
0.8943759202957153,
0.04750239476561546,
0.6598706245422363,
0.3004090189933777,
0.1166139617562294,
-0.4435497224330902,
-0.30539652705192566,
-0.7516079545021057,
0.1734464317560196,
-0.9149856567382812,
-0.2892427444458008,
0.4011201560497284,
-0.021400857716798782,
-0.6294713616371155,
-0.23590943217277527,
-0.3967420160770416,
0.25967711210250854,
0.4355993866920471,
-0.43633103370666504,
0.2859066426753998,
0.24957162141799927,
-0.1891491413116455,
-0.44769522547721863,
-0.436642050743103,
-0.5005673170089722,
1.375495195388794,
0.40581420063972473,
0.8427534699440002,
0.4854229986667633,
0.389198899269104,
0.6212822198867798,
0.7057291269302368,
-0.5259912610054016,
0.25268223881721497,
-0.04102737829089165,
-0.8753038048744202,
-0.3879089057445526,
-0.5793679356575012,
-0.6780596375465393,
0.2963908612728119,
-0.3357422947883606,
-0.831432580947876,
0.7894615530967712,
0.19586895406246185,
0.09401952475309372,
0.24311789870262146,
-0.33802899718284607,
0.5593092441558838,
-0.004650488495826721,
-0.5455920100212097,
0.1616269201040268,
-0.2763534486293793,
0.7661737203598022,
-0.4192413091659546,
0.5290948748588562,
-0.375566303730011,
0.22563950717449188,
0.5427742004394531,
-0.3928360044956207,
0.9071536660194397,
-0.2364744246006012,
-0.30898499488830566,
0.025990957394242287,
0.21487367153167725,
0.5228772163391113,
0.2606624662876129,
-0.6023867726325989,
0.25221794843673706,
-0.16580909490585327,
-0.3511272072792053,
-0.17940424382686615,
0.5372560620307922,
-1.0102249383926392,
-0.6583782434463501,
-0.7824962139129639,
-0.5173194408416748,
-0.14258547127246857,
-0.21249373257160187,
0.41212618350982666,
-0.028645003214478493,
-0.3952229619026184,
0.32833829522132874,
0.6092348098754883,
-0.5619973540306091,
0.09982094168663025,
0.631149411201477,
-0.47817060351371765,
-0.30007725954055786,
0.6564088463783264,
0.24078677594661713,
0.33613845705986023,
0.08358585834503174,
0.13169240951538086,
-0.32452255487442017,
-0.1989269256591797,
0.11244380474090576,
-0.025645796209573746,
-0.7321339845657349,
-0.004296144936233759,
-0.5622681379318237,
-0.0007814911077730358,
-0.7230590581893921,
-0.08530620485544205,
-0.3240305781364441,
0.10923372954130173,
-0.18400396406650543,
-0.12152714282274246,
0.5563501715660095,
0.6597355008125305,
-0.23048454523086548,
0.2710830569267273,
-0.125557541847229,
-0.03314301744103432,
0.5204095840454102,
0.19740575551986694,
-0.26855790615081787,
-0.7640625834465027,
-0.06480613350868225,
-0.1430300623178482,
-0.26343321800231934,
-0.858116865158081,
0.4204980432987213,
-0.1083315759897232,
0.570801854133606,
0.2829505503177643,
0.1597009152173996,
0.26502525806427,
-0.2994162142276764,
0.9696025848388672,
0.46951553225517273,
-1.0243916511535645,
0.3172997236251831,
-0.36012592911720276,
-0.3506527245044708,
0.36197027564048767,
0.23769031465053558,
-0.7148777842521667,
-0.5827407836914062,
-0.3537270128726959,
-1.0069500207901,
0.6317122578620911,
0.03941616043448448,
0.2651522159576416,
-0.2937450706958771,
0.4244058132171631,
0.16749171912670135,
0.3558211028575897,
-1.0666911602020264,
-0.4519226551055908,
-0.3769166171550751,
-0.1754225492477417,
-0.09847366809844971,
-0.5881212949752808,
-0.27544671297073364,
-0.2231103479862213,
0.5730612874031067,
0.07043489813804626,
-0.003441910957917571,
0.025844451040029526,
-0.11683720350265503,
-0.21006736159324646,
0.3761802613735199,
0.4360840320587158,
0.5513356924057007,
-0.15392988920211792,
0.05764564871788025,
0.3076122999191284,
-0.4646143615245819,
0.5765846371650696,
-0.16738659143447876,
-0.2308785319328308,
0.006831891369074583,
0.09984496235847473,
0.8219241499900818,
-0.3549729287624359,
-0.5211507678031921,
0.7577264308929443,
-0.14811629056930542,
-0.36532506346702576,
-0.7089763879776001,
0.1556907743215561,
-0.07848861813545227,
0.38485944271087646,
0.36433348059654236,
-0.07634204626083374,
0.04655450955033302,
-0.5451865196228027,
0.00009535200661048293,
0.4777143597602844,
-0.6414225697517395,
0.01575389690697193,
0.7363410592079163,
0.1778404414653778,
-0.38440418243408203,
0.1642746478319168,
-0.2845747172832489,
-0.19792595505714417,
0.5952346920967102,
0.2448732554912567,
0.7377857565879822,
-0.38991084694862366,
0.3046974539756775,
0.1587890088558197,
0.48144736886024475,
-0.21378719806671143,
0.03376535698771477,
0.45905473828315735,
-0.8704143166542053,
-0.4510209262371063,
-0.867009162902832,
-0.31704434752464294,
0.034131813794374466,
-0.6144173741340637,
0.27042263746261597,
-0.3946051299571991,
-0.3590700328350067,
-0.2507118582725525,
-0.3251701295375824,
-0.6278461813926697,
-0.06799367815256119,
0.06670699268579483,
0.4191949963569641,
-1.1216535568237305,
0.3841237723827362,
0.5335273742675781,
-0.41907796263694763,
-0.40568989515304565,
0.29747694730758667,
0.283547580242157,
-0.6774668097496033,
0.9776102900505066,
0.000020623529053409584,
0.13035468757152557,
-0.4668843448162079,
-0.6168728470802307,
-0.8082305192947388,
0.8806321620941162,
0.6766130924224854,
-0.672695517539978,
0.2392159402370453,
0.4400104880332947,
0.3997248709201813,
-0.298356294631958,
0.17366278171539307,
0.6223374605178833,
0.41924747824668884,
-0.03241686895489693,
-0.5275115370750427,
-0.13063518702983856,
-0.07671139389276505,
0.47344139218330383,
0.08744439482688904,
-0.6121122241020203,
1.1623191833496094,
0.15725530683994293,
-0.08953223377466202,
-0.3064413070678711,
0.4454149007797241,
0.525110125541687,
0.14370127022266388,
0.5443117022514343,
0.22506237030029297,
0.7378542423248291,
-0.43613526225090027,
0.9151342511177063,
-0.2148710936307907,
0.5658235549926758,
0.7311599850654602,
-0.6106550097465515,
0.29651665687561035,
0.5523976683616638,
-0.4210518002510071,
0.4392889440059662,
0.5209422707557678,
0.1143508180975914,
0.28462308645248413,
0.6494789123535156,
-0.4583062529563904,
-0.33180877566337585,
-0.27371516823768616,
-0.47367772459983826,
0.3874921500682831,
0.5204481482505798,
-0.4212786853313446,
-0.13702355325222015,
0.14501184225082397,
-0.21319541335105896,
0.22530969977378845,
-0.25838080048561096,
0.5258108973503113,
0.15837045013904572,
-0.14621511101722717,
0.08791451156139374,
-0.06953585147857666,
0.8875873684883118,
-0.44640669226646423,
0.1607702076435089,
-0.35356786847114563,
0.07301724702119827,
-0.08594274520874023,
-0.6758922338485718,
0.30341657996177673,
0.07995853573083878,
-0.518646240234375,
0.09824947267770767,
0.5410027503967285,
-0.20207634568214417,
-0.5927104353904724,
0.44943228363990784,
0.4989204406738281,
0.030990876257419586,
0.07570101320743561,
-0.5763243436813354,
0.22834709286689758,
0.07433605194091797,
-0.35788410902023315,
0.40720847249031067,
0.7779722213745117,
-0.05253477022051811,
0.7024641633033752,
0.4947739243507385,
0.20300725102424622,
0.21825218200683594,
0.2945263385772705,
0.43397361040115356,
-0.6447402834892273,
-0.43829381465911865,
-1.0212090015411377,
0.4140874147415161,
-0.13522011041641235,
-0.2563612759113312,
0.7652282118797302,
0.2703244090080261,
0.64520263671875,
0.10227768123149872,
1.0219732522964478,
0.0008057211525738239,
0.5269631147384644,
-0.34477734565734863,
0.5423124432563782,
-0.7495023608207703,
0.5244457125663757,
-0.49578553438186646,
-0.9133592844009399,
-0.2171461135149002,
0.5006312131881714,
-0.6910234093666077,
0.19418515264987946,
0.2969563603401184,
0.8161489367485046,
0.45357710123062134,
-0.1823221743106842,
0.48557114601135254,
0.41588079929351807,
0.6137424111366272,
0.3307573199272156,
0.9678868055343628,
-0.22044368088245392,
0.6616445183753967,
0.24941523373126984,
-0.0648718848824501,
-0.5001631379127502,
-0.7728063464164734,
-0.650454044342041,
-0.366115927696228,
-0.3381343185901642,
-0.8091718554496765,
0.11893711984157562,
0.7681413292884827,
0.4280937910079956,
-0.6403022408485413,
-0.3744204044342041,
-0.2728602886199951,
0.44448623061180115,
0.06795022636651993,
-0.3837721049785614,
-0.031070001423358917,
-0.24178281426429749,
-0.7489258050918579,
-0.3147602677345276,
0.4383386969566345,
0.0809597298502922,
-0.5134080052375793,
-0.1247522383928299,
0.15618374943733215,
0.17534029483795166,
0.697866678237915,
0.18167918920516968,
-0.6976881623268127,
-0.4733786880970001,
-0.28175926208496094,
-0.25255197286605835,
-0.014577030204236507,
0.5731807947158813,
-0.30750441551208496,
0.35292550921440125,
0.46505841612815857,
0.3922927677631378,
0.20550553500652313,
-0.4047884941101074,
0.6836557984352112,
-0.8361464142799377,
0.29216039180755615,
0.11765223741531372,
0.4914025664329529,
0.29567426443099976,
-0.4565795361995697,
0.3696010112762451,
0.5857464075088501,
-0.5611041784286499,
-1.1124624013900757,
0.6113869547843933,
-0.42485618591308594,
-0.14303496479988098,
1.2236589193344116,
0.26851749420166016,
-0.17170272767543793,
-0.33011749386787415,
0.12192297726869583,
0.2157590687274933,
-0.4131895899772644,
1.0106141567230225,
0.9916844367980957,
0.14722351729869843,
-0.08542007207870483,
-0.7606993913650513,
0.5984959602355957,
0.39016443490982056,
-0.5448232889175415,
0.21121592819690704,
0.6092628836631775,
0.536686360836029,
0.07578485459089279,
0.5679280161857605,
-0.36388662457466125,
0.13369649648666382,
0.05081545189023018,
0.4885714650154114,
0.2811426818370819,
0.08545689284801483,
-0.31930214166641235,
0.39006832242012024,
0.1987161785364151,
0.2281995266675949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15473v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15473v2
|
Leveraging Domain Knowledge for Efficient Reward Modelling in RLHF: A Case-Study in E-Commerce Opinion Summarization
| 2024-02-23T18:05:06 | 2024-04-18T06:38:22 |
Swaroop Nath, Tejpalsingh Siledar, Sankara Sri Raghava Ravindra Muddu, Rupasai Rangaraju, Harshad Khadilkar, Pushpak Bhattacharyya, Suman Banerjee, Amey Patil, Sudhanshu Shekhar Singh, Muthusamy Chelliah, Nikesh Garera
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) has become a dominating
strategy in aligning Language Models (LMs) with human values/goals. The key to
the strategy is learning a reward model ($\varphi$), which can reflect the
latent reward model of humans. While this strategy has proven effective, the
training methodology requires a lot of human preference annotation (usually in
the order of tens of thousands) to train $\varphi$. Such a large-scale
annotation is justifiable when it's a one-time effort, and the reward model is
universally applicable. However, human goals are subjective and depend on the
task, requiring task-specific preference annotations, which can be impractical
to fulfill. To address this challenge, we propose a novel approach to infuse
domain knowledge into $\varphi$, which reduces the amount of preference
annotation required ($21\times$), omits Alignment Tax, and provides some
interpretability. We validate our approach in E-Commerce Opinion Summarization,
with a significant reduction in dataset size (to just $940$ samples) while
advancing the SOTA ($\sim4$ point ROUGE-L improvement, $68\%$ of times
preferred by humans over SOTA). Our contributions include a novel Reward
Modeling technique and two new datasets: PromptOpinSumm (supervised data for
Opinion Summarization) and OpinPref (a gold-standard human preference dataset).
The proposed methodology opens up avenues for efficient RLHF, making it more
adaptable to applications with varying human values. We release the artifacts
(Code: github.com/efficient-rlhf. PromptOpinSumm: hf.co/prompt-opin-summ.
OpinPref: hf.co/opin-pref) for usage under MIT License.
|
[
-0.3892047107219696,
-0.5985816717147827,
0.2717079222202301,
-0.012183290906250477,
-0.23860327899456024,
-0.030255576595664024,
-0.3460340201854706,
-0.46301689743995667,
0.34667640924453735,
0.6913493275642395,
-0.8714359402656555,
-0.4221480190753937,
-0.346635639667511,
-0.10669269412755966,
0.1406756043434143,
1.4416184425354004,
-0.00234002317301929,
-0.15442802011966705,
-0.5367597937583923,
-0.3651311695575714,
-0.08757802098989487,
-0.9809045195579529,
-0.43894362449645996,
-0.6130855679512024,
0.6983063817024231,
0.6195533275604248,
0.3269083797931671,
0.4294362962245941,
0.4608524441719055,
0.11407095938920975,
0.1837402582168579,
0.4129028916358948,
-0.7124419212341309,
0.17054952681064606,
-0.11553388833999634,
-0.32260945439338684,
-0.668580949306488,
0.03490132465958595,
0.020418338477611542,
0.5998769402503967,
-0.3971066176891327,
0.2847183048725128,
0.11530312150716782,
1.0429580211639404,
-0.7939215898513794,
0.3624548017978668,
-0.1527877151966095,
0.164075568318367,
0.038689758628606796,
-0.49490928649902344,
-0.48806726932525635,
-0.4306635558605194,
0.5149863362312317,
-1.001676082611084,
-0.11835576593875885,
0.2723214328289032,
0.9596965909004211,
0.2387780398130417,
-0.2247941792011261,
-0.1687038689851761,
-0.567073404788971,
0.9791417717933655,
-0.6466352939605713,
0.1618175506591797,
0.4664357602596283,
0.19389551877975464,
0.15650060772895813,
-0.5628655552864075,
-0.3136231601238251,
-0.11955069750547409,
-0.23577584326267242,
0.3568542003631592,
0.10386897623538971,
-0.028330840170383453,
0.18006356060504913,
0.20919457077980042,
-0.5206480622291565,
-0.10863226652145386,
-0.04329291358590126,
0.007640033029019833,
0.8548847436904907,
0.22745965421199799,
0.005431913770735264,
-0.09125243872404099,
-0.5408543348312378,
-0.3465013802051544,
-0.793352484703064,
0.4125131666660309,
0.3748966455459595,
0.4280458390712738,
-0.06279347836971283,
0.3971324861049652,
-0.38754308223724365,
0.7842201590538025,
0.21127194166183472,
-0.34745070338249207,
0.32649439573287964,
-0.04463654011487961,
-0.07435216754674911,
-0.03300531208515167,
0.5793775320053101,
0.6364985704421997,
0.3693262040615082,
0.0794048011302948,
-0.3748549222946167,
-0.18701793253421783,
0.45194491744041443,
-0.934225857257843,
-0.29494741559028625,
0.3166143596172333,
-0.6245673894882202,
-0.35217568278312683,
0.19911788403987885,
-0.5685975551605225,
-0.47413620352745056,
-0.3922003209590912,
0.4254905581474304,
-0.1806887537240982,
-0.2845872640609741,
0.16988414525985718,
-0.08224741369485855,
0.018544109538197517,
0.4064561128616333,
-1.1189934015274048,
0.31726202368736267,
0.9243696928024292,
0.5582947731018066,
-0.4491085410118103,
-0.33486121892929077,
-0.5781684517860413,
-0.023753775283694267,
-0.12843765318393707,
0.940335214138031,
-0.38105490803718567,
-0.47323834896087646,
0.16666854918003082,
-0.1624411940574646,
0.051983825862407684,
-0.6992653608322144,
0.5712543725967407,
-0.7870774269104004,
0.2745659351348877,
-0.3496074080467224,
-0.8119092583656311,
-0.2645677924156189,
0.43223318457603455,
-0.620394766330719,
0.7479128241539001,
0.14947038888931274,
-0.7455567121505737,
0.5211261510848999,
-0.756151556968689,
-0.5328841805458069,
0.04524692893028259,
-0.0054746028035879135,
-0.6613302826881409,
-0.1290895938873291,
0.3092074692249298,
0.5352766513824463,
-0.047799114137887955,
0.33971577882766724,
-0.245479553937912,
-0.18988923728466034,
0.3795683681964874,
0.09167192876338959,
0.4607301652431488,
0.21033917367458344,
-0.3471863269805908,
0.38317954540252686,
-0.507922887802124,
-0.17477473616600037,
0.15497854351997375,
-0.3545173406600952,
-0.5354346632957458,
-0.09261628985404968,
0.23917321860790253,
0.0477433055639267,
0.21915856003761292,
-0.2773650586605072,
0.3931552469730377,
-0.5316755175590515,
0.16207444667816162,
0.8458293080329895,
0.33030936121940613,
0.5674335956573486,
-0.459651380777359,
0.6827410459518433,
-0.12306731939315796,
0.26143142580986023,
-0.13952375948429108,
-0.3482733368873596,
-0.5988346934318542,
-0.21959082782268524,
0.3909492492675781,
0.4093700349330902,
-0.6501930952072144,
0.4218193292617798,
-0.2912450432777405,
-0.26874372363090515,
-0.3647312521934509,
-0.09180864691734314,
0.2621520757675171,
0.5948662757873535,
0.338882178068161,
-0.34049853682518005,
-0.37983348965644836,
-1.0011736154556274,
-0.3732389211654663,
-0.2922722399234772,
0.030855752527713776,
0.5995364785194397,
0.38149529695510864,
0.09303316473960876,
1.2256677150726318,
-0.7516725063323975,
-0.4399239122867584,
-0.5621567964553833,
0.3552633225917816,
0.3221559226512909,
0.3484615981578827,
0.24597392976284027,
-0.8985835909843445,
-0.34704193472862244,
-0.17119283974170685,
-0.7609353065490723,
-0.0833115428686142,
-0.2283344268798828,
-0.07374075055122375,
0.22331523895263672,
0.10631900280714035,
-0.3512592613697052,
0.27512162923812866,
0.21317829191684723,
-0.3315106928348541,
0.4478258788585663,
-0.17646530270576477,
0.4747389554977417,
-0.7579888105392456,
0.13779687881469727,
0.23741905391216278,
-0.5259234309196472,
-0.5698615908622742,
-0.06463829427957535,
0.153983011841774,
0.10972265899181366,
-0.5307345986366272,
0.6213871240615845,
-0.12431594729423523,
0.05066891014575958,
-0.4400877356529236,
0.15560153126716614,
0.013781892135739326,
1.0182721614837646,
0.5418123006820679,
0.5589413642883301,
0.03957374393939972,
-0.849993109703064,
0.19810736179351807,
0.3053942024707794,
-0.3221544921398163,
0.7022461891174316,
-0.61561119556427,
-0.13687697052955627,
-0.07046379148960114,
0.25345686078071594,
-0.5358836650848389,
-0.2913082540035248,
0.48823872208595276,
-0.47240370512008667,
0.15031464397907257,
-0.1134980171918869,
-0.21473675966262817,
0.012262432835996151,
-0.5295628905296326,
0.44511350989341736,
0.5418927073478699,
-0.7338454127311707,
0.6268922090530396,
0.7549876570701599,
-0.32969552278518677,
-0.7423859238624573,
-0.5114087462425232,
-0.14881311357021332,
-0.34899356961250305,
-0.3640201985836029,
0.5050449967384338,
-0.08132518827915192,
-0.2183830887079239,
0.060255952179431915,
0.09068340063095093,
0.23598724603652954,
0.11780144274234772,
0.19602233171463013,
0.47172969579696655,
0.21910670399665833,
0.33833029866218567,
-0.1453065127134323,
-0.43313872814178467,
0.08834559470415115,
-0.5371272563934326,
0.2345145344734192,
-0.11146122217178345,
-0.37925460934638977,
-0.32221320271492004,
0.2934603691101074,
0.14231349527835846,
-0.2778640687465668,
0.5648825764656067,
0.2991676330566406,
-0.2768625020980835,
-0.5631755590438843,
-0.3294844329357147,
-0.5831430554389954,
-0.3708716630935669,
0.3279922604560852,
-0.12798304855823517,
-1.000179648399353,
0.1713022142648697,
-0.1601671278476715,
0.357584685087204,
0.3708799183368683,
0.6401991844177246,
0.09732480347156525,
0.9416987299919128,
0.6669597029685974,
-0.14514432847499847,
0.5185946822166443,
-0.2261497676372528,
0.3283914029598236,
-0.5530951619148254,
-0.3106664717197418,
-0.23983930051326752,
-0.2920113205909729,
-0.20401786267757416,
-0.08648551255464554,
0.5380364656448364,
-0.0732758417725563,
-0.1298215240240097,
-0.031067339703440666,
-0.4493952989578247,
0.3302731215953827,
0.5994511246681213,
0.29745328426361084,
0.42206871509552,
-0.0021219253540039062,
0.18150024116039276,
-0.07614479213953018,
-0.7494482398033142,
-0.4122079312801361,
1.200931429862976,
0.25427043437957764,
0.8750109076499939,
0.09965755045413971,
0.7184955477714539,
0.6745469570159912,
0.3832034468650818,
-1.0383286476135254,
0.39192214608192444,
0.1024918183684349,
-0.20945708453655243,
-0.39984390139579773,
-0.4325622618198395,
-0.7541651725769043,
0.16254018247127533,
-0.31223544478416443,
-0.4932107925415039,
0.2203836739063263,
0.5551340579986572,
-0.7006806135177612,
0.1710459142923355,
-0.5361884236335754,
0.9999969005584717,
-0.2753942310810089,
-0.5964173078536987,
-0.28938838839530945,
-0.721185564994812,
0.35540488362312317,
0.305172324180603,
0.2738521993160248,
0.030612220987677574,
0.11624378710985184,
1.022781252861023,
-0.6665965914726257,
0.8813248872756958,
-0.3223426640033722,
-0.06331685930490494,
0.13601870834827423,
-0.10552725940942764,
0.6654478907585144,
0.05250604823231697,
0.1564701944589615,
-0.20138631761074066,
-0.2767418622970581,
-0.3910655379295349,
-0.7184547185897827,
0.4288567006587982,
-0.7221696376800537,
-0.48869407176971436,
-0.6099931001663208,
-0.36397936940193176,
-0.5116555690765381,
-0.11092916876077652,
0.171391561627388,
0.4496336281299591,
-0.19819775223731995,
-0.032354194670915604,
0.9543202519416809,
-0.056151945143938065,
0.29234907031059265,
0.3566139340400696,
-0.41659262776374817,
-0.4331386685371399,
1.0468237400054932,
-0.1725841760635376,
0.18860389292240143,
0.6792815923690796,
0.2943802773952484,
-0.43970581889152527,
-0.14037556946277618,
-0.6087707877159119,
0.18107011914253235,
-0.7716800570487976,
-0.18745146691799164,
-0.7681956887245178,
0.1278972625732422,
-0.26867589354515076,
-0.1299433410167694,
-0.33471837639808655,
-0.6897115111351013,
-0.26874011754989624,
-0.26555460691452026,
0.5807300806045532,
0.8424144387245178,
0.028378592804074287,
0.04364156350493431,
-0.8166126608848572,
0.15708397328853607,
0.5871731042861938,
0.2038078010082245,
0.338189959526062,
-0.5350787043571472,
-0.6454563736915588,
-0.10243085771799088,
-0.024042261764407158,
-0.5945423245429993,
0.5380216240882874,
-0.0065454780124127865,
0.58330237865448,
0.3496992290019989,
0.41444680094718933,
0.479970782995224,
-0.10071190446615219,
0.935549259185791,
0.16386310756206512,
-0.8734747767448425,
0.3932719826698303,
-0.23175862431526184,
0.11390481144189835,
0.6936554908752441,
0.475883424282074,
-0.7042296528816223,
0.006489007733762264,
-0.667296826839447,
-1.0744775533676147,
0.9021214842796326,
-0.1875699907541275,
-0.24044808745384216,
0.2442861646413803,
0.29629454016685486,
0.37692153453826904,
0.4771922528743744,
-0.6163903474807739,
-0.4333752393722534,
-0.29048100113868713,
-0.3119918406009674,
-0.01859666220843792,
-0.3147216737270355,
-0.2756025791168213,
-0.031041208654642105,
1.0714287757873535,
-0.19894102215766907,
-0.014264033176004887,
0.2642541229724884,
-0.38565611839294434,
-0.035057589411735535,
0.3100128769874573,
0.5673718452453613,
0.7463526129722595,
-0.270099401473999,
0.16693343222141266,
-0.11378521472215652,
-0.23366892337799072,
0.058809537440538406,
-0.13092659413814545,
-0.23078663647174835,
-0.3705780506134033,
0.2989865839481354,
0.7547840476036072,
0.1464323252439499,
-0.9355595707893372,
0.7241820096969604,
-0.1542520672082901,
-0.3247276842594147,
-0.16983364522457123,
-0.14744165539741516,
0.07740136981010437,
0.07225891202688217,
0.3270212709903717,
0.0043436442501842976,
0.3098819851875305,
-0.4463180899620056,
0.33823227882385254,
0.13921748101711273,
-0.6153843402862549,
-0.15710650384426117,
0.4017430543899536,
0.3518752455711365,
-0.14047536253929138,
0.30885082483291626,
-0.34476926922798157,
-0.6604498624801636,
0.28416916728019714,
0.2928274869918823,
0.8656173944473267,
-0.0027867997996509075,
0.3902687430381775,
0.32185477018356323,
-0.15554293990135193,
-0.24258986115455627,
0.06291955709457397,
-0.2956601679325104,
-0.6706893444061279,
-0.15709172189235687,
-0.4902838170528412,
-0.7555909156799316,
-0.30035921931266785,
-0.7483630776405334,
0.03981563448905945,
-0.24318841099739075,
-0.09821050614118576,
-0.249197855591774,
-0.1781931072473526,
-0.37906211614608765,
0.20617574453353882,
-0.1279790848493576,
0.5048314332962036,
-0.7185028791427612,
0.5881807804107666,
0.7655525207519531,
-0.5437140464782715,
-0.7905838489532471,
-0.0602143257856369,
0.03897646442055702,
-0.7070522308349609,
0.7242249846458435,
-0.07459015399217606,
-0.28735223412513733,
-0.2152131050825119,
-0.367967814207077,
-0.33322933316230774,
0.9838971495628357,
-0.11943107098340988,
-0.3872281610965729,
0.31786954402923584,
-0.02514941245317459,
0.41177898645401,
-0.7668395638465881,
0.23881253600120544,
0.5330584645271301,
0.49441200494766235,
0.04114678129553795,
-0.5385175347328186,
-0.0032058467622846365,
-0.3873213231563568,
-0.17164361476898193,
0.170414000749588,
-0.5198879837989807,
0.7554818391799927,
-0.32086676359176636,
-0.14334361255168915,
-0.2109418660402298,
0.6635842323303223,
0.458957314491272,
0.2732369601726532,
0.6863033175468445,
0.6126018166542053,
0.7629021406173706,
0.16083410382270813,
1.1009266376495361,
-0.3551788926124573,
0.6124890446662903,
1.0634993314743042,
-0.38535580039024353,
0.953130304813385,
0.4744867980480194,
-0.08613786846399307,
0.49829575419425964,
0.8855254054069519,
0.25298696756362915,
0.8662152290344238,
0.22213619947433472,
-0.19134140014648438,
-0.532260000705719,
-0.3945458233356476,
-0.22150863707065582,
-0.028245750814676285,
0.05927424505352974,
-0.08945132046937943,
0.02689664252102375,
0.006199532188475132,
0.08103250712156296,
0.23112636804580688,
-0.2804676592350006,
1.1356419324874878,
0.05409161373972893,
-0.8989270329475403,
0.43398573994636536,
-0.03611605614423752,
0.772532045841217,
-0.6521263122558594,
-0.20630544424057007,
-0.1834254115819931,
0.21904735267162323,
-0.27595821022987366,
-0.591594398021698,
0.01781320758163929,
-0.07735047489404678,
-0.2745521664619446,
-0.5183387994766235,
0.6877007484436035,
-0.5256152749061584,
-0.17913569509983063,
0.14023357629776,
0.5708174109458923,
-0.1813047081232071,
-0.12985552847385406,
-0.5070355534553528,
-0.2036278396844864,
0.08329916000366211,
-0.5799972414970398,
0.32805702090263367,
0.1222650483250618,
-0.006713095121085644,
0.6446178555488586,
0.570613443851471,
0.1066538393497467,
-0.5519490838050842,
0.37923213839530945,
0.7020168304443359,
-0.750054121017456,
-1.0140066146850586,
-0.814330518245697,
0.5831925868988037,
-0.2439083755016327,
-0.3026016354560852,
0.6504532098770142,
0.5543687343597412,
0.8402154445648193,
-0.2620953917503357,
1.0457693338394165,
0.2643411457538605,
0.7595787048339844,
-0.5672796964645386,
0.6219562888145447,
-0.7237794399261475,
0.4546111822128296,
-0.19223441183567047,
-0.612456738948822,
-0.2893983721733093,
0.5145071148872375,
-0.2781876027584076,
0.07578600198030472,
0.6443690061569214,
0.6920122504234314,
0.16280193626880646,
0.2830105423927307,
0.18066656589508057,
-0.16404102742671967,
0.21562175452709198,
0.5763531923294067,
0.9447034001350403,
0.005515485070645809,
0.28870540857315063,
-0.4014970362186432,
-0.5157558917999268,
-0.5137670040130615,
-0.9498822093009949,
-0.7652245163917542,
-0.5767562389373779,
-0.4039066433906555,
-0.25680243968963623,
0.17370672523975372,
1.502174973487854,
0.9179492592811584,
-0.9504904747009277,
-0.5466943979263306,
0.1959981620311737,
0.29048845171928406,
-0.649389386177063,
-0.21709728240966797,
0.49200358986854553,
-0.3020498752593994,
-0.45181867480278015,
0.05658657103776932,
0.48952656984329224,
-0.1968229115009308,
-0.2874625623226166,
-0.3111274242401123,
-0.09988301247358322,
-0.03020383231341839,
0.7322014570236206,
0.25290152430534363,
-0.6137235164642334,
-0.2520650625228882,
0.14909370243549347,
0.07847756892442703,
0.07663313299417496,
1.2202688455581665,
-0.9159102439880371,
0.27163320779800415,
0.4840029180049896,
0.898675262928009,
0.5931966304779053,
0.4005497097969055,
0.6945897340774536,
-0.6432602405548096,
-0.14940203726291656,
0.30284345149993896,
0.40378430485725403,
0.35028693079948425,
-0.46849003434181213,
0.4405953884124756,
0.3448781669139862,
-0.6151931881904602,
-0.44515320658683777,
0.3744431138038635,
-1.0731356143951416,
-0.47618478536605835,
0.99700927734375,
-0.23547878861427307,
-0.41089433431625366,
-0.09475994855165482,
-0.23038597404956818,
-0.09291863441467285,
-0.8626749515533447,
0.9566592574119568,
0.45721399784088135,
-0.46386387944221497,
-0.191140815615654,
-0.11703559011220932,
0.8547272086143494,
0.5099807381629944,
-0.9977795481681824,
0.45187073945999146,
0.4631510078907013,
-0.039718225598335266,
-0.023484468460083008,
0.8425694704055786,
0.10731881111860275,
0.37808164954185486,
-0.3644418716430664,
0.2829008102416992,
-0.3285718858242035,
-0.34773871302604675,
-0.40933534502983093,
0.47492843866348267,
0.28116631507873535,
0.011026130057871342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00800v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00800v1
|
Brain-Inspired Two-Stage Approach: Enhancing Mathematical Reasoning by Imitating Human Thought Processes
| 2024-02-23T17:40:31 | 2024-02-23T17:40:31 |
Yezeng Chen, Zui Chen, Yi Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Although large language models demonstrate emergent abilities in solving math
word problems, there is a challenging task in complex multi-step mathematical
reasoning tasks. To improve model performance on mathematical reasoning tasks,
previous work has conducted supervised fine-tuning on open-source models by
improving the quality and quantity of data. In this paper, we propose a novel
approach, named Brain, to imitate human thought processes to enhance
mathematical reasoning abilities, using the Frontal Lobe Model to generate
plans, and then employing the Parietal Lobe Model to generate code and execute
to obtain answers. First, we achieve SOTA performance in comparison with Code
LLaMA 7B based models through this method. Secondly, we find that plans can be
explicitly extracted from natural language, code, or formal language. Our code
and data are publicly available at https://github.com/cyzhh/Brain.
|
[
-0.4327389895915985,
-1.228554606437683,
0.8984100818634033,
0.5160343050956726,
-0.12110445648431778,
-0.06096099317073822,
-0.11940095573663712,
-0.34473538398742676,
0.1700439602136612,
0.7101613283157349,
-0.9673558473587036,
-0.21104121208190918,
-0.19925802946090698,
-0.2954810857772827,
0.04050641134381294,
0.6637412309646606,
0.14441609382629395,
0.4625536799430847,
-0.3325151801109314,
0.357883483171463,
-0.5702076554298401,
-0.34185266494750977,
-0.8337122797966003,
-0.6898313760757446,
0.37143418192863464,
0.3521934151649475,
0.6535888314247131,
0.43657946586608887,
0.5027801394462585,
0.14048555493354797,
-0.0038572142366319895,
0.13781587779521942,
-0.09544119238853455,
-0.19987758994102478,
-0.49764737486839294,
-0.511201798915863,
-0.4404275417327881,
-0.3244815170764923,
0.11712658405303955,
0.7557384967803955,
-0.3511025905609131,
-0.09999790042638779,
-0.03537878394126892,
0.6220435500144958,
-0.5353041887283325,
0.5629967451095581,
-0.6165500283241272,
-0.1149832159280777,
0.023425202816724777,
-0.12390172481536865,
-0.44060349464416504,
-0.4587709903717041,
-0.01072933804243803,
-0.7482526302337646,
-0.2679326832294464,
-0.4403167963027954,
0.29871153831481934,
0.2966792583465576,
0.06419602036476135,
-0.5710317492485046,
-0.49803999066352844,
0.5959765911102295,
-0.8072068095207214,
0.13104379177093506,
0.4723782539367676,
0.38468706607818604,
-0.39824676513671875,
-0.8203067183494568,
-0.7384665608406067,
-0.018552646040916443,
0.12356757372617722,
0.13432440161705017,
-0.23338451981544495,
-0.14663125574588776,
0.7064753770828247,
-0.3125837445259094,
-0.39299899339675903,
-0.15248847007751465,
-0.2796808183193207,
-0.0080313291400671,
0.6596139669418335,
0.17157241702079773,
0.4251866638660431,
-0.16770987212657928,
-0.0037527172826230526,
-0.1481567621231079,
-0.5853762626647949,
0.28434059023857117,
0.18109098076820374,
0.08132786303758621,
0.2845684289932251,
0.5748767256736755,
-0.49147099256515503,
0.6836372017860413,
-0.14776040613651276,
0.16895058751106262,
0.05221876502037048,
0.027919577434659004,
-0.22941742837429047,
-0.06203921511769295,
0.23322144150733948,
0.2070382982492447,
0.43619608879089355,
0.02289539761841297,
-0.18324688076972961,
0.7732123732566833,
0.33029794692993164,
-0.8509963750839233,
-0.5086736679077148,
0.057559046894311905,
-0.2547425925731659,
-0.11108662188053131,
-0.2762612998485565,
-0.7323594093322754,
-0.23105712234973907,
-0.7212269306182861,
0.7621871829032898,
-0.8284509778022766,
-0.13079194724559784,
0.5455809831619263,
0.08080586045980453,
-0.05709312483668327,
0.4258010685443878,
-0.9206809997558594,
0.4046052396297455,
1.063165307044983,
0.3195366859436035,
0.44774121046066284,
-0.21024124324321747,
-0.2953501045703888,
-0.004413771443068981,
-0.49880844354629517,
1.155633807182312,
-0.6548947095870972,
-0.012901617214083672,
-0.32809197902679443,
-0.6888218522071838,
0.14403732120990753,
-0.5851100087165833,
0.6258167624473572,
-0.5916616320610046,
0.18298007547855377,
-0.5223006010055542,
-0.44293463230133057,
-0.55122309923172,
0.05842066928744316,
-0.39674174785614014,
0.7623622417449951,
-0.03962932899594307,
-0.4910868704319,
0.0950818806886673,
-1.0453773736953735,
-0.458820104598999,
0.03964533656835556,
-0.35362356901168823,
-0.15255619585514069,
0.26273977756500244,
0.7213053703308105,
0.21120743453502655,
-0.3239986300468445,
0.46791741251945496,
-0.3704851567745209,
-0.2509998381137848,
0.35144513845443726,
-0.18115580081939697,
1.1803464889526367,
0.19368331134319305,
-0.3522700071334839,
0.1520286500453949,
-0.9064422249794006,
0.47690343856811523,
0.25004637241363525,
0.14168915152549744,
-0.4965881407260895,
0.2542651891708374,
-0.3990577757358551,
0.46710824966430664,
0.17524215579032898,
-0.38370808959007263,
0.21684469282627106,
-0.6142857074737549,
0.8245618343353271,
0.5477918386459351,
0.24797680974006653,
0.3596975803375244,
-0.43746787309646606,
0.21289880573749542,
-0.11311457306146622,
0.03713497519493103,
-0.23188942670822144,
-0.7587045431137085,
-0.547295331954956,
-0.3153868615627289,
0.20766118168830872,
0.6501181721687317,
-0.7622438669204712,
0.3769787847995758,
0.08680769801139832,
-0.4099389314651489,
-0.33251169323921204,
-0.11137422174215317,
0.24730461835861206,
0.6122164130210876,
0.31567856669425964,
-0.332805871963501,
-0.579208254814148,
-0.968347430229187,
-0.3757888972759247,
-0.07418935000896454,
-0.2917447090148926,
0.2312915176153183,
0.4545268714427948,
-0.14519810676574707,
0.9893321394920349,
-0.8282864093780518,
-0.10091133415699005,
0.0967402458190918,
0.28394123911857605,
0.47767165303230286,
0.448885440826416,
0.27323293685913086,
-0.41009941697120667,
-0.10390083491802216,
-0.27717089653015137,
-0.9227861166000366,
-0.4290168285369873,
-0.22627927362918854,
-0.6718628406524658,
-0.14362305402755737,
0.2602982223033905,
-0.6462623476982117,
0.6381711959838867,
0.04022865742444992,
-0.605799674987793,
0.39322733879089355,
-0.15026643872261047,
-0.11264076828956604,
-0.9512124061584473,
-0.09412609785795212,
-0.165771484375,
0.15524865686893463,
-0.41264790296554565,
0.38380804657936096,
0.38308820128440857,
-0.2557511031627655,
-0.2506827712059021,
0.2358156442642212,
-0.1549288034439087,
-0.1704968810081482,
-0.4416477382183075,
-0.09307949990034103,
-0.0025937764439731836,
0.8605598211288452,
0.07552263885736465,
0.6477511525154114,
0.6693788766860962,
-0.5568448305130005,
0.03114810213446617,
0.31163376569747925,
-0.5739858746528625,
0.5551117658615112,
-0.6328634023666382,
0.3076629340648651,
-0.3422730565071106,
0.10984964668750763,
-0.6904675960540771,
-0.10432860255241394,
0.17564377188682556,
-0.40953144431114197,
-0.1484244018793106,
0.3267490565776825,
-0.5938208103179932,
-0.32791265845298767,
-0.05142844468355179,
0.24731482565402985,
0.6405485272407532,
-0.4539721608161926,
0.7872269153594971,
0.3709022104740143,
-0.5608600974082947,
-0.14921459555625916,
-0.7304911613464355,
0.1223975419998169,
0.13421934843063354,
-0.7231066823005676,
0.48939692974090576,
-0.3721514344215393,
-0.4839276373386383,
0.13677754998207092,
-0.00930818635970354,
-0.2146603912115097,
0.02907101809978485,
0.046550262719392776,
0.30255261063575745,
-0.061106353998184204,
-0.0440802238881588,
0.5700166821479797,
-0.06354805082082748,
0.6604858636856079,
-0.44196590781211853,
0.5714026689529419,
0.07606504112482071,
-0.2739006280899048,
-0.6002024412155151,
0.4789102375507355,
0.5604150891304016,
-0.3610595762729645,
0.2927152216434479,
0.08913897722959518,
-0.9623085260391235,
-0.34883445501327515,
-0.30073022842407227,
-0.6115503311157227,
-0.36753612756729126,
0.2716389000415802,
-0.7741244435310364,
-0.3723447322845459,
0.4437340795993805,
-0.11197153478860855,
0.11097107082605362,
0.14222900569438934,
0.8748853206634521,
-0.19412554800510406,
1.1934494972229004,
0.2402256578207016,
0.5384906530380249,
0.39323917031288147,
-0.41225793957710266,
0.1552264243364334,
-0.7683720588684082,
-0.4537367522716522,
-0.1452575922012329,
-0.43252280354499817,
0.16583006083965302,
-0.6554110050201416,
0.33212295174598694,
0.3668597340583801,
-0.02174336276948452,
0.32210832834243774,
-0.5025021433830261,
0.5553866624832153,
0.6843217611312866,
0.6152169704437256,
0.15596948564052582,
0.2829880118370056,
-0.5413376092910767,
-0.24785959720611572,
-0.6313920617103577,
-0.4423770010471344,
1.1032383441925049,
0.12151429802179337,
0.463326096534729,
-0.02734602801501751,
0.4541916847229004,
-0.03371312841773033,
0.31823259592056274,
-0.7067520618438721,
0.7177796363830566,
0.10336364060640335,
-0.6854326128959656,
-0.2699570059776306,
-0.3687859773635864,
-0.6645082235336304,
0.3746508061885834,
-0.4082454741001129,
-0.6868375539779663,
-0.006963904015719891,
-0.17547045648097992,
-0.5972954034805298,
-0.0036699948832392693,
-0.6699262261390686,
0.5655344724655151,
-0.2786986231803894,
-0.6315358877182007,
-0.9122937321662903,
-0.20995701849460602,
0.4320922791957855,
-0.30141985416412354,
0.320502370595932,
-0.009154231287539005,
0.33031362295150757,
0.7044106125831604,
-0.30871713161468506,
0.6472868919372559,
-0.2837320566177368,
-0.027734775096178055,
0.7031561136245728,
0.36165517568588257,
0.42713963985443115,
0.2560490667819977,
-0.06023550033569336,
0.27162930369377136,
-0.25117629766464233,
-0.5035132765769958,
-1.0082193613052368,
0.7469482421875,
-0.5926375389099121,
-0.5799210071563721,
-0.1351824551820755,
-1.0643665790557861,
-0.36313652992248535,
0.304088294506073,
-0.22675363719463348,
0.5003069043159485,
0.12336193025112152,
-0.006713906303048134,
0.49568358063697815,
0.0003140228218398988,
0.5522106885910034,
0.1985292285680771,
-0.24768905341625214,
-0.8403363227844238,
0.3693529963493347,
0.2522317171096802,
-0.12771843373775482,
0.4273127317428589,
0.32211655378341675,
-0.3178403079509735,
-0.3029325306415558,
-0.37226876616477966,
0.18111196160316467,
-0.5527620315551758,
-0.1598983108997345,
-0.6394736170768738,
-0.046040020883083344,
-0.4280146062374115,
-0.07946550101041794,
-0.24263611435890198,
-0.7251864075660706,
-0.08673276007175446,
0.073456309735775,
0.17081153392791748,
0.5338674783706665,
-0.19268491864204407,
0.2081839144229889,
-0.2771919071674347,
0.4866744577884674,
0.6199560165405273,
0.2833750545978546,
0.22150763869285583,
-0.18089623749256134,
-0.14574453234672546,
0.401728093624115,
-0.6195058822631836,
-0.8338803052902222,
0.4623405635356903,
-0.2952970266342163,
0.4860023856163025,
0.276610404253006,
-0.18771445751190186,
0.9747213125228882,
-0.5430853366851807,
0.17018000781536102,
0.23669056594371796,
-1.0977333784103394,
0.7340052127838135,
-0.20535165071487427,
0.28277871012687683,
0.27487775683403015,
-0.0188196562230587,
0.15585127472877502,
0.039783257991075516,
-0.6113789081573486,
-0.3558376431465149,
0.6498252153396606,
0.408746600151062,
-0.16641655564308167,
0.10578136891126633,
0.5383633375167847,
0.14295902848243713,
0.05360911786556244,
-0.32502514123916626,
0.3897487223148346,
-0.15476560592651367,
-0.3320363163948059,
0.31412845849990845,
-0.08157098293304443,
0.03600168228149414,
-0.5983174443244934,
0.48980608582496643,
-0.2521032691001892,
0.3356311321258545,
0.12585100531578064,
0.15211880207061768,
-0.19576212763786316,
0.017853226512670517,
0.6830635070800781,
1.0123002529144287,
-0.018470918759703636,
0.1388189196586609,
0.19344393908977509,
-0.3146248161792755,
-0.19737014174461365,
0.16685964167118073,
-0.36194610595703125,
-0.43707796931266785,
0.16660739481449127,
0.5487955212593079,
0.33098679780960083,
-0.8163582682609558,
0.027221916243433952,
-0.03652476519346237,
-0.4375830590724945,
-0.35391125082969666,
0.1864456981420517,
0.43892428278923035,
0.7183539867401123,
0.27377092838287354,
0.4679335057735443,
0.15880228579044342,
-0.6042605042457581,
0.2869614064693451,
0.3238711953163147,
0.10386554896831512,
-0.45731914043426514,
0.8581827878952026,
-0.23648707568645477,
-0.6858794689178467,
0.7411924600601196,
-0.024732915684580803,
-0.38849788904190063,
0.6546545028686523,
0.9725145697593689,
0.5779392719268799,
0.12463060021400452,
0.05350756645202637,
0.40772828459739685,
0.22809721529483795,
-0.18527448177337646,
0.914770781993866,
-0.06478984653949738,
-0.6818159222602844,
-0.9040499329566956,
-0.4186907112598419,
-0.2951960563659668,
0.0483243465423584,
-0.630760908126831,
0.39792314171791077,
-0.7932823896408081,
-0.16825465857982635,
0.1928732991218567,
-0.06603182852268219,
-0.596970796585083,
0.32568132877349854,
0.25800013542175293,
0.939160943031311,
-0.6096930503845215,
1.0530352592468262,
0.9491356611251831,
-0.29793405532836914,
-0.7724308371543884,
-0.08573712408542633,
-0.4312862753868103,
-0.9350512027740479,
0.4666837453842163,
0.05517137423157692,
0.06040800362825394,
0.24789290130138397,
-0.535862386226654,
-0.738672137260437,
0.8971817493438721,
0.5092859864234924,
-0.566331684589386,
-0.13713696599006653,
-0.19916212558746338,
0.5149698257446289,
-0.381136953830719,
0.28478941321372986,
0.4133067727088928,
0.31921306252479553,
0.2823673486709595,
-0.44452235102653503,
-0.035119377076625824,
-0.23554424941539764,
0.055331751704216,
0.11193517595529556,
-0.1744544804096222,
0.9417643547058105,
-0.534921407699585,
-0.05458256974816322,
-0.07741272449493408,
0.7889894843101501,
0.8700684309005737,
0.7036727070808411,
0.4035368859767914,
1.0748538970947266,
0.7363093495368958,
0.22935621440410614,
0.6025563478469849,
-0.3162704408168793,
0.15098369121551514,
0.9175515174865723,
-0.3535742163658142,
1.0925127267837524,
0.5118318796157837,
-0.09897118806838989,
0.8906295299530029,
0.33307892084121704,
0.26333072781562805,
0.8942326307296753,
0.3219882547855377,
0.04413953050971031,
-0.3842361569404602,
0.2577681541442871,
-0.012524561956524849,
0.4146489202976227,
0.7892174124717712,
-0.10477074980735779,
-0.21788445115089417,
0.014465495012700558,
-0.06020302698016167,
0.5182682871818542,
-0.4746242165565491,
0.5215142965316772,
0.21776843070983887,
-1.041639804840088,
0.4289288818836212,
0.0888572409749031,
0.23645809292793274,
-0.30470195412635803,
-0.308078795671463,
-0.05382688343524933,
0.3818875551223755,
-0.0022243582643568516,
-0.7445604801177979,
0.4534590542316437,
0.025953182950615883,
-0.21491220593452454,
-0.2735758125782013,
0.6093087196350098,
-0.04898557811975479,
-0.8578717708587646,
0.11318542808294296,
0.5362712144851685,
0.09801670163869858,
-0.4155409634113312,
-0.7312217354774475,
-0.20097947120666504,
-0.03783494606614113,
-0.08901965618133545,
0.12110836803913116,
0.575659453868866,
-0.3852463960647583,
0.5844724178314209,
0.9340693950653076,
0.11541356891393661,
-0.0620124451816082,
0.08621371537446976,
0.8682921528816223,
-0.9296094179153442,
-0.7269077897071838,
-1.0227534770965576,
0.35512402653694153,
0.006973153445869684,
-0.21745432913303375,
0.27050280570983887,
0.5008832216262817,
0.8432233333587646,
-0.17686647176742554,
0.6437626481056213,
-0.06444117426872253,
0.3647986054420471,
-0.6119602918624878,
0.4783385097980499,
-0.19658108055591583,
0.1957188844680786,
-0.26805034279823303,
-1.056735873222351,
-0.5663076639175415,
1.126081943511963,
-0.3805215358734131,
-0.2365584671497345,
0.9194647073745728,
0.8415336012840271,
-0.08699331432580948,
0.4584304392337799,
0.3132407069206238,
0.16241195797920227,
0.26341018080711365,
1.1830862760543823,
0.8308761119842529,
-0.1920728236436844,
0.23988334834575653,
-0.4676752984523773,
-0.732409656047821,
0.0035967936273664236,
-0.6247438788414001,
-1.0230435132980347,
-0.30295446515083313,
-0.38833823800086975,
-0.4157888889312744,
-0.05588247999548912,
0.9646705389022827,
0.5916454195976257,
-0.6798597574234009,
-0.2045125812292099,
-0.7125897407531738,
-0.19039076566696167,
-0.6290625929832458,
-0.18345266580581665,
0.24360758066177368,
-0.22168369591236115,
-0.6516627073287964,
0.5022017955780029,
0.3267698585987091,
-0.43260741233825684,
-0.37209802865982056,
0.1983441561460495,
-0.07534033060073853,
0.4432881772518158,
0.7844337821006775,
-0.15306034684181213,
-0.8160935044288635,
-0.03484189882874489,
0.31131359934806824,
-0.14990970492362976,
-0.1268463134765625,
0.8931281566619873,
-1.160372018814087,
0.3132774829864502,
0.6479986310005188,
0.6443145871162415,
0.5530491471290588,
-0.19756437838077545,
0.4397906959056854,
0.07436607778072357,
-0.010761800222098827,
0.39083701372146606,
0.3355882465839386,
-0.025983262807130814,
-0.31736865639686584,
0.5728818774223328,
0.2680514454841614,
-0.2623785138130188,
-0.5679881572723389,
0.3742173910140991,
-0.8474347591400146,
-0.6475789546966553,
0.7114298939704895,
0.09444426745176315,
-0.52734375,
0.2855198383331299,
-0.5314804911613464,
0.3029373586177826,
-0.23845189809799194,
1.2295116186141968,
0.6949453353881836,
-0.5865933299064636,
-0.016396034508943558,
-0.47852402925491333,
-0.027660585939884186,
0.5960646867752075,
-0.9457337260246277,
-0.09829548746347427,
0.3815174102783203,
0.14748838543891907,
0.2448139637708664,
0.4876256287097931,
-0.34562352299690247,
0.40656301379203796,
0.20048682391643524,
0.24854087829589844,
-0.1851622462272644,
-0.4007307291030884,
-0.06339741498231888,
0.424688458442688,
-0.20178121328353882,
-0.05251910164952278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00799v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00799v1
|
An Empirical Study of Data Ability Boundary in LLMs' Math Reasoning
| 2024-02-23T17:38:43 | 2024-02-23T17:38:43 |
Zui Chen, Yezeng Chen, Jiaqi Han, Zhijie Huang, Ji Qi, Yi Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are displaying emergent abilities for math
reasoning tasks,and there is a growing attention on enhancing the ability of
open-source LLMs through supervised fine-tuning (SFT).In this paper, we aim to
explore a general data strategy for supervised data to help optimize and expand
math reasoning ability.Firstly, we determine the ability boundary of reasoning
paths augmentation by identifying these paths' minimal optimal set.Secondly, we
validate that different abilities of the model can be cumulatively enhanced by
Mix of Minimal Optimal Sets of corresponding types of data, while our models
MMOS achieve SOTA performance on series base models under much lower
construction costs.Besides, we point out GSM-HARD is not really hard and
today's LLMs no longer lack numerical robustness.Also, we provide an Auto
Problem Generator for robustness testing and educational applications.Our code
and data are publicly available at https://github.com/cyzhh/MMOS.
|
[
-0.43475228548049927,
-1.0397553443908691,
0.7565740346908569,
0.01947103440761566,
-0.06807230412960052,
-0.09658890217542648,
-0.34609362483024597,
-0.17520971596240997,
-0.28279587626457214,
0.8684548735618591,
-0.7883034348487854,
-0.657903790473938,
-0.4977683126926422,
-0.03479417786002159,
-0.0073387278243899345,
0.9733940362930298,
-0.06569696217775345,
-0.011753085069358349,
-0.66386878490448,
0.039588991552591324,
-0.37625494599342346,
-0.48087403178215027,
-0.45171597599983215,
-0.14538030326366425,
0.1636619120836258,
0.5686941146850586,
0.8310670256614685,
1.0659940242767334,
0.8245449662208557,
0.3119724988937378,
0.10383789241313934,
0.692354142665863,
-0.4885613024234772,
0.1376030445098877,
-0.16315490007400513,
-0.6492083072662354,
-0.8229379653930664,
-0.22434745728969574,
0.5934827923774719,
0.8352069854736328,
-0.05945728346705437,
0.17444804310798645,
-0.03951229155063629,
0.7311614155769348,
-0.5318160653114319,
0.254066526889801,
-0.7444379329681396,
-0.05137147381901741,
-0.22822487354278564,
-0.22120967507362366,
-0.345741331577301,
-0.45024052262306213,
0.023065857589244843,
-0.8186913132667542,
0.030518395826220512,
-0.09593746066093445,
0.6428877115249634,
0.8407949209213257,
-0.2963390052318573,
-0.3184036314487457,
-0.5416341423988342,
0.9312421083450317,
-0.5625929236412048,
0.5055006742477417,
0.5939053297042847,
0.4053846299648285,
-0.34463798999786377,
-0.35536816716194153,
-0.046725835651159286,
-0.165241539478302,
0.14596161246299744,
0.06762237101793289,
-0.10688940435647964,
-0.005100055132061243,
0.5980289578437805,
0.33804383873939514,
-0.29944348335266113,
0.13819238543510437,
-0.2576688528060913,
-0.060597583651542664,
0.7976322174072266,
0.40008464455604553,
0.13905425369739532,
0.05240589752793312,
-0.03633581101894379,
0.08578462898731232,
-0.649875283241272,
0.19087979197502136,
0.48009905219078064,
0.3999572992324829,
-0.03585515543818474,
0.9605669975280762,
-0.38697224855422974,
1.0118478536605835,
-0.13252024352550507,
-0.3298129141330719,
0.21865274012088776,
-0.3876091539859772,
-0.21746830642223358,
-0.37671002745628357,
0.44408199191093445,
0.1727471649646759,
0.49518823623657227,
-0.23339834809303284,
-0.2168823480606079,
0.05405639484524727,
0.018767252564430237,
-0.6370884776115417,
-0.20726104080677032,
-0.05956157669425011,
-0.15887132287025452,
-0.1047624945640564,
-0.09433894604444504,
-0.5209267735481262,
-0.21089394390583038,
-0.7380546927452087,
0.2016242891550064,
-0.5929991602897644,
-0.11966607719659805,
0.38983026146888733,
0.007758236024528742,
-0.24537456035614014,
0.2914922833442688,
-0.9542060494422913,
0.5118808150291443,
0.9030030369758606,
0.6327805519104004,
-0.05982990190386772,
0.004571970552206039,
-0.7949485778808594,
-0.036802757531404495,
-0.33356210589408875,
0.5415911674499512,
-0.6289180517196655,
-0.1901160031557083,
-0.2909247577190399,
-0.2242528647184372,
-0.050052158534526825,
-0.5593883395195007,
0.8973363041877747,
-0.4601460099220276,
0.12592998147010803,
-0.22068904340267181,
-0.6265964508056641,
0.007772644516080618,
-0.08560702949762344,
-0.4620908200740814,
0.9928250312805176,
0.277508020401001,
-0.5997584462165833,
0.37576401233673096,
-0.786533534526825,
-0.3450557291507721,
-0.06325888633728027,
-0.08006003499031067,
-0.5310301780700684,
0.058374807238578796,
0.5218650102615356,
0.5200788974761963,
-0.24852320551872253,
0.40115588903427124,
-0.4446262717247009,
-0.36486169695854187,
0.11264859884977341,
-0.42709699273109436,
0.9042695760726929,
0.29508644342422485,
-0.10047703236341476,
-0.1409919559955597,
-0.8856683373451233,
0.21557407081127167,
0.16213014721870422,
-0.2992204427719116,
-0.6186619997024536,
0.1764332354068756,
-0.5309891104698181,
-0.015264640562236309,
0.2093604952096939,
-0.2753489017486572,
0.3796069920063019,
-0.5229507088661194,
0.30794280767440796,
0.9108837842941284,
-0.20829486846923828,
0.5908726453781128,
-0.27480751276016235,
0.3514685034751892,
-0.17295098304748535,
0.1532268226146698,
-0.026440870016813278,
-0.6020739078521729,
-0.6805540323257446,
-0.5083957314491272,
0.40554437041282654,
0.7360076308250427,
-0.8376979231834412,
0.7273786664009094,
-0.2167748212814331,
-0.19327135384082794,
-0.6292516589164734,
0.45964768528938293,
0.27640801668167114,
0.5596941113471985,
0.4249444603919983,
0.05581502616405487,
-0.4254131317138672,
-0.8188625574111938,
-0.0153045654296875,
0.2077668160200119,
-0.2264566272497177,
0.5440783500671387,
0.3206201195716858,
-0.33880993723869324,
1.0859652757644653,
-0.7086072564125061,
-0.19166186451911926,
0.12621183693408966,
-0.25584253668785095,
0.3402981162071228,
0.27107593417167664,
0.4859510660171509,
-0.6571022272109985,
-0.12493306398391724,
-0.05728606879711151,
-0.993092954158783,
-0.5461478233337402,
0.038652535527944565,
-0.32064443826675415,
-0.015056711621582508,
0.199819415807724,
-0.4332358241081238,
0.23117384314537048,
0.35643869638442993,
-0.2678958475589752,
0.38059327006340027,
-0.2205912321805954,
-0.10844431817531586,
-0.7151687145233154,
-0.4676833748817444,
0.32810211181640625,
-0.02882283553481102,
-0.4223460257053375,
0.11436016857624054,
0.0371006615459919,
0.009284215047955513,
0.0011642766185104847,
0.2731204032897949,
-0.3309147357940674,
-0.12972165644168854,
-0.22036297619342804,
0.03310319036245346,
-0.2738066017627716,
0.4331791400909424,
0.02205584943294525,
0.823223352432251,
0.7678802609443665,
-0.7143290042877197,
0.44184815883636475,
-0.11286801099777222,
-0.14104679226875305,
0.6643331050872803,
-0.5569562315940857,
0.03954817354679108,
-0.06179024279117584,
-0.004671969451010227,
-0.8761653304100037,
-0.274069607257843,
0.02425755001604557,
-0.44996219873428345,
-0.13864746689796448,
-0.30716440081596375,
-0.73074871301651,
-0.3029520511627197,
-0.12964920699596405,
0.25251156091690063,
0.5722442865371704,
-0.6610454320907593,
0.45634377002716064,
0.41251879930496216,
-0.16157953441143036,
-0.3460741639137268,
-0.41686809062957764,
-0.23738780617713928,
-0.35965901613235474,
-1.0544652938842773,
0.15801727771759033,
-0.24887844920158386,
-0.5264064073562622,
0.054953087121248245,
0.12727457284927368,
-0.1612786054611206,
0.24391348659992218,
0.27914807200431824,
0.3915933668613434,
-0.22190406918525696,
0.23629629611968994,
0.4613453149795532,
-0.2774573862552643,
0.17852544784545898,
-0.22162967920303345,
0.3058842122554779,
-0.26583540439605713,
-0.5898041725158691,
-0.021699335426092148,
0.04939937964081764,
0.19591286778450012,
-0.16130533814430237,
0.45803308486938477,
0.32080039381980896,
-0.4389326274394989,
-0.42034712433815,
-0.3809221386909485,
-0.19224116206169128,
-0.5011285543441772,
0.11946810036897659,
-0.6367897391319275,
-1.0361692905426025,
0.3658141791820526,
-0.31399014592170715,
0.23610281944274902,
0.39752766489982605,
0.5252214670181274,
0.029056904837489128,
1.263961911201477,
0.31060755252838135,
0.1282661110162735,
0.087287038564682,
-0.3432604968547821,
0.05554688721895218,
-0.7814354300498962,
-0.12456893920898438,
-0.19281089305877686,
0.034509360790252686,
-0.4397223889827728,
-0.5629175305366516,
0.394138365983963,
0.22534193098545074,
-0.1965017318725586,
0.09165883809328079,
-0.6254482865333557,
0.5581014752388,
0.4874974489212036,
0.1763816475868225,
0.5815640091896057,
0.25913721323013306,
-0.17867127060890198,
-0.2949666976928711,
-0.6168653964996338,
-0.3925979435443878,
1.245573878288269,
0.5736091136932373,
0.8301283121109009,
0.06800650805234909,
0.5004090666770935,
0.11102914810180664,
0.2356465756893158,
-0.7784826755523682,
0.622694730758667,
-0.30727314949035645,
-0.3588283658027649,
-0.4479636251926422,
-0.8648978471755981,
-0.7438995838165283,
0.210987389087677,
-0.3280040919780731,
-0.6241874694824219,
-0.27060526609420776,
-0.013900295831263065,
-0.17877425253391266,
0.18885153532028198,
-0.8216301202774048,
0.3242158889770508,
-0.3371160924434662,
-0.6788943409919739,
0.15854500234127045,
-0.2796204090118408,
0.6355510950088501,
-0.25851303339004517,
0.36122655868530273,
-0.06836547702550888,
-0.03157129883766174,
0.49679791927337646,
-0.582389235496521,
0.6664888262748718,
-0.12402693927288055,
-0.21999797224998474,
0.40236157178878784,
-0.12131914496421814,
0.5703524351119995,
0.18598245084285736,
-0.14191456139087677,
0.20018072426319122,
-0.4088052809238434,
-0.29669812321662903,
-0.7810097932815552,
0.7327186465263367,
-0.7034829258918762,
-0.7056558728218079,
0.05125534534454346,
-0.8141804933547974,
-0.5091406106948853,
0.09006854891777039,
-0.028227992355823517,
0.21700802445411682,
0.2998221814632416,
0.30664414167404175,
0.8833521008491516,
0.11529000848531723,
0.0377175472676754,
0.4575533866882324,
-0.2000652402639389,
-0.38801124691963196,
0.9407765865325928,
0.4054918587207794,
0.23175865411758423,
0.0345899797976017,
0.28077366948127747,
-0.38949641585350037,
-0.537064790725708,
-0.7394942045211792,
0.19008538126945496,
-0.49277016520500183,
-0.18458065390586853,
-0.421360582113266,
-0.4010379910469055,
-0.38109081983566284,
-0.20567898452281952,
-0.2462952584028244,
-0.43360957503318787,
-0.2674165666103363,
-0.15609318017959595,
0.6869375705718994,
0.36878472566604614,
-0.2326347380876541,
0.3076430857181549,
-0.4473468065261841,
0.354962021112442,
0.3775114417076111,
0.4522798955440521,
-0.14143246412277222,
-0.50494384765625,
-0.1741543710231781,
0.28756970167160034,
-0.30945342779159546,
-0.34337329864501953,
0.14899775385856628,
-0.19788280129432678,
0.731666088104248,
0.4016191363334656,
-0.05288343131542206,
0.62371826171875,
-0.3468206524848938,
0.2430019974708557,
0.06984583288431168,
-0.8824118971824646,
0.6419411301612854,
-0.6220093369483948,
0.06862559169530869,
0.2849474847316742,
0.1932046115398407,
0.2289125919342041,
-0.41300448775291443,
-0.7588916420936584,
-0.5993704199790955,
0.5410210490226746,
0.4837528467178345,
-0.020810572430491447,
0.3629155457019806,
0.4639008939266205,
0.14702396094799042,
0.000608943693805486,
-0.4230726361274719,
-0.127066507935524,
0.030639592558145523,
-0.37718087434768677,
0.194854736328125,
0.17204177379608154,
-0.14162035286426544,
-0.5505284667015076,
0.3815005123615265,
-0.29458704590797424,
-0.04631397873163223,
-0.17965586483478546,
0.17592491209506989,
-0.10155472159385681,
0.09542961418628693,
0.44971179962158203,
0.8125407099723816,
-0.2789352834224701,
0.13865557312965393,
0.4370529353618622,
-0.468990296125412,
0.08674906194210052,
0.29841506481170654,
-0.2304205596446991,
-0.36299312114715576,
0.29139336943626404,
0.7108698487281799,
-0.15751510858535767,
-0.7435817718505859,
0.25398677587509155,
0.1817147135734558,
-0.4797465205192566,
-0.10927369445562363,
0.5719066858291626,
0.06884955614805222,
0.2633703351020813,
0.3757256269454956,
-0.0729067251086235,
0.19696925580501556,
-0.22265997529029846,
0.31497722864151,
0.530796229839325,
-0.0103923873975873,
-0.0021177493035793304,
0.5589568018913269,
0.03861568868160248,
-0.28336042165756226,
0.5001943707466125,
-0.2374192327260971,
-0.2471657544374466,
0.7352880835533142,
0.6757453680038452,
0.23835153877735138,
-0.0703991949558258,
0.03878302127122879,
0.20583829283714294,
0.39409202337265015,
-0.10730792582035065,
0.18662448227405548,
-0.021116821095347404,
-0.8251624703407288,
-0.6463541388511658,
-0.3211211562156677,
-0.4224246144294739,
0.14051631093025208,
-0.5217617154121399,
0.41926339268684387,
-0.5474503040313721,
-0.19901339709758759,
0.04832518473267555,
0.20809730887413025,
-0.6735082864761353,
0.5224083662033081,
-0.030507022514939308,
0.6687237620353699,
-0.7492672204971313,
0.6691641807556152,
0.49319422245025635,
-0.08416958898305893,
-0.7067447900772095,
-0.40985286235809326,
-0.024298297241330147,
-1.0335310697555542,
0.5098013281822205,
-0.12248345464468002,
-0.1643792688846588,
0.0509573258459568,
-0.6737772822380066,
-0.9438877105712891,
0.911708414554596,
0.4768974781036377,
-0.5679745674133301,
0.2120947539806366,
0.15651987493038177,
0.627220869064331,
-0.4915681481361389,
0.2863405644893646,
0.6254489421844482,
0.47303715348243713,
0.2613227665424347,
-0.673258900642395,
-0.028734637424349785,
-0.1978640854358673,
-0.16216833889484406,
0.33366718888282776,
-0.48586565256118774,
0.7283875346183777,
-0.4290986955165863,
0.03706229478120804,
-0.1944301426410675,
0.5787063837051392,
0.7554632425308228,
0.683412492275238,
0.6160047650337219,
0.9187235236167908,
0.9468593597412109,
-0.23007778823375702,
0.9313432574272156,
0.10500744730234146,
0.24055416882038116,
0.94448322057724,
-0.10890356451272964,
0.5255885124206543,
0.18133355677127838,
-0.19515857100486755,
0.2553899586200714,
0.738071620464325,
-0.22890613973140717,
0.5675995945930481,
0.5265907049179077,
0.022569091990590096,
-0.5118731260299683,
-0.1040196493268013,
-0.38703635334968567,
0.3457343876361847,
0.5552864074707031,
-0.3162035644054413,
-0.14084501564502716,
-0.02419787272810936,
0.11434249579906464,
0.13410863280296326,
-0.329515278339386,
0.58554607629776,
-0.038317590951919556,
-0.4834666848182678,
0.5268632173538208,
0.06954102218151093,
0.560409665107727,
-0.37533074617385864,
-0.14924202859401703,
-0.15534549951553345,
0.05968203768134117,
-0.4004676043987274,
-0.947553277015686,
0.23000505566596985,
0.17168964445590973,
-0.21466204524040222,
0.09238224476575851,
0.8513585925102234,
-0.237969771027565,
-0.7830988764762878,
0.13778862357139587,
0.6792989373207092,
0.19732679426670074,
0.07219485193490982,
-0.5834437012672424,
-0.03319168463349342,
-0.015911227092146873,
-0.0642460510134697,
0.31215402483940125,
0.8138633370399475,
-0.329962819814682,
0.7782084345817566,
1.1227763891220093,
0.20832037925720215,
-0.03926066309213638,
0.20277482271194458,
1.1126325130462646,
-0.4741585850715637,
-0.3164433538913727,
-1.048230767250061,
0.4734704792499542,
-0.3368339240550995,
-0.34979447722435,
0.8623632788658142,
0.6826538443565369,
0.6993831396102905,
0.20769338309764862,
0.8404529690742493,
0.4009789228439331,
0.5162026882171631,
-0.7839155197143555,
0.19501818716526031,
-0.5244777202606201,
0.4646591246128082,
-0.2608089745044708,
-0.9223249554634094,
-0.34827864170074463,
0.6952776312828064,
-0.7001544237136841,
0.0006112070404924452,
0.3036361634731293,
0.6108957529067993,
-0.3636170029640198,
0.08342580497264862,
0.24510644376277924,
-0.24017073214054108,
0.18712013959884644,
0.8745663166046143,
0.843312680721283,
-0.20280566811561584,
0.36134466528892517,
-0.2448405772447586,
-0.6898626685142517,
-0.11039555072784424,
-0.6806586980819702,
-1.0765217542648315,
-0.26851892471313477,
-0.20995715260505676,
-0.21394740045070648,
-0.035590630024671555,
0.6441574692726135,
0.7206937074661255,
-0.3568984568119049,
-0.02794956974685192,
-0.24641132354736328,
0.38129743933677673,
-0.1316218078136444,
-0.27632462978363037,
0.3125554323196411,
-0.2834583818912506,
-0.7296224236488342,
0.3934682011604309,
0.22069887816905975,
0.037680868059396744,
-0.2227039486169815,
-0.15089523792266846,
0.3363826274871826,
0.18486465513706207,
0.6259181499481201,
-0.107025146484375,
-0.5229771733283997,
-0.04540925845503807,
0.41284993290901184,
-0.07687834650278091,
-0.07380997389554977,
0.6587505340576172,
-0.48738181591033936,
0.4510676860809326,
0.2832355499267578,
0.9244707822799683,
0.3113011121749878,
0.31984636187553406,
0.38883674144744873,
-0.5250647664070129,
-0.05462155118584633,
0.13266846537590027,
0.3169134557247162,
0.15111921727657318,
-0.6019687652587891,
0.9218919277191162,
0.3285606801509857,
-0.540261447429657,
-0.873643159866333,
0.0328984297811985,
-0.8827632665634155,
-0.198014035820961,
1.2668894529342651,
0.0006900588632561266,
-0.021235015243291855,
-0.09416905045509338,
-0.19885145127773285,
-0.004681513644754887,
-0.3873642385005951,
0.7604365944862366,
0.8110713958740234,
-0.3946397602558136,
-0.12210999429225922,
-0.7784189581871033,
0.29150208830833435,
0.30081069469451904,
-1.1119413375854492,
-0.07365167140960693,
0.5870525240898132,
0.10756385326385498,
0.14919322729110718,
0.5182198286056519,
0.01887505315244198,
0.07608046382665634,
-0.07542151212692261,
-0.44367286562919617,
-0.46284905076026917,
-0.45899391174316406,
0.04799754545092583,
0.16165736317634583,
-0.15705150365829468,
-0.06269480288028717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15449v1
|
Repetition Improves Language Model Embeddings
| 2024-02-23T17:25:10 | 2024-02-23T17:25:10 |
Jacob Mitchell Springer, Suhas Kotha, Daniel Fried, Graham Neubig, Aditi Raghunathan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent approaches to improving the extraction of text embeddings from
autoregressive large language models (LLMs) have largely focused on
improvements to data, backbone pretrained language models, or improving
task-differentiation via instructions. In this work, we address an
architectural limitation of autoregressive models: token embeddings cannot
contain information from tokens that appear later in the input. To address this
limitation, we propose a simple approach, "echo embeddings," in which we repeat
the input twice in context and extract embeddings from the second occurrence.
We show that echo embeddings of early tokens can encode information about later
tokens, allowing us to maximally leverage high-quality LLMs for embeddings. On
the MTEB leaderboard, echo embeddings improve over classical embeddings by over
9% zero-shot and by around 0.7% when fine-tuned. Echo embeddings with a
Mistral-7B model achieve state-of-the-art compared to prior open source models
that do not leverage synthetic fine-tuning data.
|
[
-0.1634027361869812,
-0.8777316212654114,
0.5738947987556458,
0.20356467366218567,
-0.6275408267974854,
0.34445005655288696,
-0.262755423784256,
-0.3093782067298889,
0.2459559291601181,
0.5703853368759155,
0.052126649767160416,
-0.48772209882736206,
-0.916695773601532,
0.003533158916980028,
-0.6800466179847717,
0.6514896750450134,
-0.2715355455875397,
0.0712830200791359,
-0.06135566160082817,
-0.23464256525039673,
-0.6070957183837891,
-0.7667003870010376,
-0.7026501297950745,
-0.196502685546875,
0.5262967944145203,
0.2383226752281189,
0.5661784410476685,
1.1255425214767456,
0.18810270726680756,
0.21497586369514465,
0.001285582548007369,
0.22398245334625244,
-0.31191766262054443,
0.29226019978523254,
0.15341545641422272,
-0.47239774465560913,
-0.1093573048710823,
-0.09008052945137024,
0.9797501564025879,
0.70589280128479,
-0.35183122754096985,
0.12465444952249527,
0.5113121271133423,
0.3073095977306366,
-0.5859893560409546,
0.34005194902420044,
-0.6841516494750977,
-0.2123613953590393,
-0.13898059725761414,
-0.2664175033569336,
-0.5878424644470215,
-0.2507050633430481,
-0.13306060433387756,
-0.24962583184242249,
-0.07599615305662155,
0.01354256086051464,
0.5476741790771484,
0.1440090388059616,
-0.2596244215965271,
-0.3347054123878479,
-0.7362507581710815,
0.81272292137146,
-0.7818306684494019,
0.6950648427009583,
0.21996347606182098,
-0.12854419648647308,
-0.10460376739501953,
-0.9278455376625061,
-0.448064386844635,
-0.13590896129608154,
0.09035010635852814,
-0.3377569615840912,
-0.38017815351486206,
-0.21978481113910675,
-0.04959532245993614,
0.09032189100980759,
-0.15748752653598785,
0.25463685393333435,
-0.04981892183423042,
-0.10794692486524582,
0.1602376103401184,
0.26984497904777527,
0.11220335960388184,
0.07166539877653122,
-0.41769251227378845,
-0.4564448893070221,
-0.7960062026977539,
-0.011332349851727486,
0.1743774116039276,
0.3862070143222809,
0.09171798825263977,
0.39061447978019714,
0.32524043321609497,
0.5245921015739441,
0.22703540325164795,
0.1662880927324295,
0.345079243183136,
-0.14109769463539124,
-0.10277502983808517,
-0.2415912002325058,
0.5555734634399414,
0.013032889924943447,
-0.07572917640209198,
-0.2059614509344101,
-0.42334648966789246,
-0.41450899839401245,
0.11099638789892197,
-0.6186619400978088,
-0.09227611869573593,
0.06677757948637009,
-0.7460147142410278,
-0.2703883945941925,
0.25262272357940674,
-0.5340223908424377,
-0.1962106078863144,
-0.2691093683242798,
0.38474103808403015,
-0.3924761712551117,
-0.2961655557155609,
0.05700531229376793,
-0.27103254199028015,
0.16915863752365112,
0.2546769678592682,
-0.8855324387550354,
0.47473376989364624,
0.908973217010498,
0.8216967582702637,
-0.21132242679595947,
-0.5507462620735168,
-0.5511079430580139,
0.16999031603336334,
-0.46594715118408203,
0.6177630424499512,
-0.9219639897346497,
-0.6081465482711792,
0.166206955909729,
-0.05066586285829544,
-0.019351303577423096,
-0.8640333414077759,
-0.012435904704034328,
-0.4981377124786377,
0.27790459990501404,
-0.24748495221138,
-0.7484846115112305,
0.027389192953705788,
-0.14091509580612183,
-0.6394276022911072,
1.23060142993927,
-0.10880263894796371,
-0.4582121670246124,
0.48105552792549133,
-0.4251302182674408,
-0.3428961932659149,
-0.18479996919631958,
-0.2711547613143921,
-0.33384257555007935,
0.5843484401702881,
0.2865549921989441,
0.3837081491947174,
-0.07779262214899063,
0.2784649133682251,
-0.5014097094535828,
-0.43650808930397034,
0.1575668305158615,
-0.7669854760169983,
0.5752503275871277,
0.06430716812610626,
-0.42987143993377686,
-0.1785048097372055,
-0.4181593954563141,
-0.10474885255098343,
0.12148082256317139,
-0.44192570447921753,
-0.41500645875930786,
0.09492412954568863,
-0.14782322943210602,
0.013324136845767498,
0.39163100719451904,
-0.3738618791103363,
0.3730561137199402,
-0.26247578859329224,
0.3721098005771637,
1.0201938152313232,
0.06308963894844055,
0.38825705647468567,
-0.4308968484401703,
0.5071017146110535,
0.21617789566516876,
-0.0849507600069046,
-0.5318914651870728,
-0.3166627883911133,
-0.8461929559707642,
-0.5289686322212219,
0.4341731369495392,
0.45609739422798157,
-0.5650455951690674,
0.4256340563297272,
-0.34767332673072815,
-0.12743636965751648,
-0.7518811225891113,
0.3375183045864105,
0.2775253355503082,
0.036726824939250946,
0.4164969325065613,
-0.57536780834198,
-0.7251495122909546,
-0.7235628366470337,
-0.4232536554336548,
-0.24967151880264282,
0.22240124642848969,
0.3884480595588684,
0.4121268093585968,
-0.1412910670042038,
0.8383444547653198,
-0.4208144247531891,
0.05843373015522957,
-0.2661384344100952,
0.525550127029419,
0.10337869822978973,
0.562070906162262,
0.38971346616744995,
-0.3037607967853546,
-0.4547271132469177,
-0.3357066810131073,
-0.5513505935668945,
-0.11712649464607239,
-0.30853983759880066,
0.10441992431879044,
0.2148590385913849,
0.7182878851890564,
-0.5646770000457764,
0.4049204885959625,
0.5802426934242249,
-0.17631079256534576,
0.2017197608947754,
-0.30426648259162903,
-0.03823117911815643,
-1.2265510559082031,
-0.007327467668801546,
-0.6326720714569092,
-0.5475262999534607,
-0.2838360369205475,
0.005507024470716715,
0.030210275202989578,
-0.03958870470523834,
-0.2791832387447357,
1.0121349096298218,
-0.6744250655174255,
-0.011400238610804081,
-0.49221357703208923,
0.07092690467834473,
-0.11985718458890915,
0.30018535256385803,
-0.074974924325943,
0.6810191869735718,
0.5335335731506348,
-0.5353041291236877,
0.16909143328666687,
-0.0734429582953453,
-0.26206257939338684,
-0.01158836018294096,
-0.585127055644989,
0.46900153160095215,
-0.06113779917359352,
0.37895017862319946,
-1.0122451782226562,
0.09209875017404556,
0.12192969024181366,
-0.45821601152420044,
0.5294328927993774,
-0.09441713243722916,
-0.8669854402542114,
-0.18470944464206696,
-0.4358612298965454,
0.40214821696281433,
0.8173328638076782,
-0.8566740155220032,
0.46295616030693054,
0.4596572816371918,
-0.2882547378540039,
-0.6060917973518372,
-0.5589507818222046,
0.24361789226531982,
-0.09662134945392609,
-0.004784792196005583,
0.13360212743282318,
0.17266030609607697,
-0.011851710267364979,
0.2152906060218811,
0.0053780656307935715,
0.06333386152982712,
0.2634819746017456,
0.16500021517276764,
0.08837732672691345,
-0.24600312113761902,
0.415147066116333,
0.13541220128536224,
-0.19293369352817535,
-0.09822682291269302,
-0.6607909798622131,
0.9345187544822693,
0.19115957617759705,
-0.59437495470047,
-0.7672085165977478,
0.6192259788513184,
0.47453030943870544,
-0.05310558155179024,
0.9644113183021545,
0.541386604309082,
-0.43331268429756165,
-0.2603816092014313,
-0.7829437255859375,
-0.3353438079357147,
-0.4882362186908722,
0.4337899088859558,
-0.2085522711277008,
-1.1368149518966675,
0.44415518641471863,
-0.15994660556316376,
0.30178990960121155,
0.3395448625087738,
0.4720037877559662,
-0.4305104613304138,
1.136443018913269,
0.7251752018928528,
-0.38908275961875916,
0.8300328850746155,
-0.029794979840517044,
-0.06203681230545044,
-0.8684536814689636,
0.012020903639495373,
-0.42046183347702026,
-0.25154995918273926,
-0.4505693316459656,
-0.5839406847953796,
-0.051100701093673706,
0.38428977131843567,
-0.10888145118951797,
0.2550189197063446,
-0.1539427638053894,
0.2565004825592041,
0.57696932554245,
0.07416991144418716,
0.11666930466890335,
0.36499354243278503,
-0.19667811691761017,
0.04618530347943306,
-0.7006771564483643,
-0.6810858845710754,
1.2443593740463257,
0.591768205165863,
0.7235457301139832,
0.015536466613411903,
1.2315752506256104,
0.34692028164863586,
0.5913240313529968,
-0.3952989876270294,
0.39294323325157166,
-0.4193733036518097,
-0.34564733505249023,
-0.17717869579792023,
-0.3646487295627594,
-1.1546469926834106,
0.16484202444553375,
0.11145937442779541,
-0.7167487740516663,
0.3206479847431183,
0.4492289423942566,
-0.24229097366333008,
0.43811047077178955,
-0.4850040674209595,
0.49135148525238037,
0.019638147205114365,
-0.10951258987188339,
-0.3647911250591278,
-0.04637440666556358,
-0.21915963292121887,
-0.11160407215356827,
0.36280345916748047,
0.3067903220653534,
-0.27725285291671753,
0.7636826038360596,
-0.4845663011074066,
1.2386047840118408,
-0.2796022593975067,
-0.14576798677444458,
0.48160725831985474,
0.030751127749681473,
0.8844371438026428,
-0.17019926011562347,
0.03657571226358414,
0.12913115322589874,
-0.2839586138725281,
-0.37075740098953247,
-0.7489640116691589,
0.6777434349060059,
-0.6093068718910217,
-0.8106357455253601,
-0.17413492500782013,
-0.04198576137423515,
-0.07936473935842514,
0.1682053655385971,
0.06118616834282875,
0.6756105422973633,
-0.21233974397182465,
0.7406107187271118,
0.34492313861846924,
-0.14818501472473145,
0.741068959236145,
0.18519501388072968,
-0.4123844504356384,
-0.6640521287918091,
0.7741899490356445,
0.09784942865371704,
0.2682828903198242,
0.3239094018936157,
0.05970046669244766,
-0.3520447909832001,
-0.510819673538208,
-0.16963118314743042,
0.34187424182891846,
-0.7525491118431091,
-0.16279050707817078,
-0.8938215374946594,
0.007758249528706074,
-0.5736286640167236,
0.04787927493453026,
-0.5390560626983643,
-0.6243969798088074,
-0.5348895192146301,
-0.21863378584384918,
0.10764362663030624,
0.9263805747032166,
-0.3495959937572479,
0.3619580864906311,
-0.9111584424972534,
0.1042826771736145,
0.36468052864074707,
0.3241743743419647,
0.28348371386528015,
-0.7867866158485413,
-0.5129557847976685,
0.11402975022792816,
-0.17980031669139862,
-0.7738277912139893,
0.3624759912490845,
0.1612764149904251,
0.7607952356338501,
0.13508246839046478,
-0.3799569606781006,
0.8787053823471069,
-0.602222204208374,
0.8647821545600891,
0.04423801973462105,
-1.1806607246398926,
0.31299078464508057,
-0.07299549132585526,
0.43691182136535645,
0.43534132838249207,
0.060827214270830154,
-0.4549197852611542,
-0.6092128753662109,
-0.7867647409439087,
-0.8907518982887268,
0.48146945238113403,
0.10095655173063278,
0.6741663217544556,
-0.3881012201309204,
0.4805901348590851,
0.30419623851776123,
0.3915908634662628,
-0.6676108241081238,
-0.37401673197746277,
-0.08501353114843369,
-0.2944149374961853,
-0.1185518130660057,
-0.5181818008422852,
0.06690061837434769,
-0.056434039026498795,
0.4623822271823883,
0.19818787276744843,
0.5260676741600037,
0.011657360009849072,
-0.36180323362350464,
0.08564265817403793,
0.10747075825929642,
0.4779098927974701,
0.4265357255935669,
0.0005915194051340222,
0.33115658164024353,
0.3992486298084259,
-0.4374851584434509,
-0.029259344562888145,
-0.00844887737184763,
0.11540164053440094,
0.3928404450416565,
0.831581711769104,
0.8880413770675659,
0.30542421340942383,
-0.3826349675655365,
0.44459691643714905,
0.04177478328347206,
0.12474644184112549,
-0.3087542653083801,
0.025568431243300438,
-0.03682158887386322,
0.326206237077713,
0.4714016914367676,
-0.16798971593379974,
-0.13971638679504395,
-0.7624976634979248,
0.6035721898078918,
0.36983853578567505,
-0.30485856533050537,
-0.3539544343948364,
0.5030008554458618,
0.09732495993375778,
-0.5373172760009766,
0.5808807015419006,
0.02979046292603016,
-0.4113752841949463,
0.452379047870636,
0.8349030017852783,
1.0832515954971313,
-0.3850661814212799,
-0.004266027361154556,
0.26088225841522217,
0.24209201335906982,
-0.34038808941841125,
0.4787667989730835,
-0.11214663833379745,
-0.648277223110199,
-0.15956662595272064,
-0.40891459584236145,
-0.25361889600753784,
-0.06853865087032318,
-0.7736375331878662,
0.2827916741371155,
-0.6858810186386108,
-0.3661936819553375,
-0.49433520436286926,
-0.34378787875175476,
-0.9701703786849976,
-0.004399408586323261,
0.2202342301607132,
0.696615993976593,
-0.6167098879814148,
1.0633729696273804,
0.4556967318058014,
-0.1305404007434845,
-0.6880689263343811,
0.024824347347021103,
-0.24226795136928558,
-1.0022331476211548,
0.6844994425773621,
0.18638193607330322,
-0.14861415326595306,
0.2394227236509323,
-0.7005828619003296,
-1.0874449014663696,
1.082953929901123,
0.27374616265296936,
-0.5755661129951477,
-0.023044023662805557,
0.055288445204496384,
0.544357180595398,
-0.8198068141937256,
0.18397022783756256,
0.2947901785373688,
0.22898785769939423,
-0.3668297231197357,
-0.8441922068595886,
0.01324987132102251,
-0.04422829672694206,
0.066685751080513,
0.1822054237127304,
-0.4481203556060791,
0.8375346660614014,
-0.12569491565227509,
-0.5188280940055847,
0.14405283331871033,
0.694431483745575,
0.20140524208545685,
-0.15368665754795074,
0.6048752069473267,
0.5931779146194458,
0.7493840456008911,
-0.013047042302787304,
1.2032160758972168,
-0.5351507067680359,
0.45472952723503113,
1.656269907951355,
-0.08560659736394882,
1.3258557319641113,
0.6074908971786499,
0.0631432831287384,
0.8036555647850037,
0.3246656656265259,
0.0500732958316803,
0.6176760792732239,
0.03091592900454998,
-0.06342379748821259,
-0.32340580224990845,
-0.043283142149448395,
-0.5053295493125916,
0.5878239274024963,
0.3069370985031128,
-0.8239496350288391,
0.012570446357131004,
0.13842545449733734,
0.1543474793434143,
-0.25918564200401306,
0.25029996037483215,
0.9698957800865173,
0.2772729992866516,
-0.36464664340019226,
0.6228528022766113,
-0.03155554458498955,
0.50995934009552,
-0.31358855962753296,
-0.2537071704864502,
-0.4381020963191986,
-0.0173967145383358,
0.30379170179367065,
-0.5146561861038208,
0.20067580044269562,
-0.010172421112656593,
-0.04550519585609436,
-0.612382173538208,
0.2473854422569275,
-0.519763708114624,
-0.4147167503833771,
0.44339385628700256,
0.593218982219696,
0.022595759481191635,
0.18640944361686707,
-0.5250142812728882,
0.3668115735054016,
-0.023069771006703377,
-0.46504923701286316,
0.1581755131483078,
0.523101806640625,
0.30880847573280334,
0.7102833390235901,
0.7020660042762756,
0.24453336000442505,
0.16918589174747467,
0.09879615157842636,
0.9208498001098633,
-0.9816218614578247,
-0.38062581419944763,
-1.1320915222167969,
0.46904540061950684,
-0.08514563739299774,
-0.35443514585494995,
0.4228766858577728,
0.5574123859405518,
0.7083479166030884,
0.13561835885047913,
0.7625235319137573,
0.2780974209308624,
0.5777392983436584,
-0.6210421323776245,
0.407559335231781,
-0.7275867462158203,
0.6159741878509521,
0.0004733141977339983,
-0.9490750432014465,
-0.22538867592811584,
0.4965444803237915,
0.04230925068259239,
0.0669357106089592,
0.794637143611908,
0.5640109777450562,
-0.0021766647696495056,
-0.302215039730072,
0.22196176648139954,
0.35843348503112793,
0.45996543765068054,
0.23412193357944489,
0.8508608937263489,
-0.4573642909526825,
0.3659511208534241,
-0.06931410729885101,
-0.07992509007453918,
-0.2722168564796448,
-0.7951914072036743,
-0.7753225564956665,
-0.6411566734313965,
-0.23771047592163086,
-0.19800059497356415,
0.16771714389324188,
1.030877947807312,
0.6398819088935852,
-0.8334512710571289,
-0.3022405207157135,
0.1555640548467636,
0.06845080852508545,
-0.16714689135551453,
-0.19304345548152924,
0.4498026669025421,
-0.5619747638702393,
-0.7118909358978271,
0.45176830887794495,
0.2962022125720978,
0.2260846346616745,
-0.14309246838092804,
0.18896476924419403,
0.005544645246118307,
0.32490065693855286,
0.4324125349521637,
0.1916496604681015,
-0.7959386706352234,
-0.8377292156219482,
0.02570069208741188,
-0.2908889949321747,
0.1591792106628418,
0.8445554971694946,
-0.80292147397995,
0.5343291163444519,
0.4764655828475952,
0.7915154099464417,
0.24410386383533478,
-0.02029002271592617,
0.9002673029899597,
-0.6836442351341248,
0.1074395552277565,
0.17190469801425934,
0.5616778135299683,
0.24012760818004608,
-0.0775856152176857,
0.08542590588331223,
0.10759620368480682,
-0.21357238292694092,
-0.9390616416931152,
0.08619807660579681,
-0.4206946790218353,
-0.3306066393852234,
1.094307541847229,
-0.25767067074775696,
0.09108265489339828,
-0.09895657747983932,
-0.04271601885557175,
0.3760005235671997,
-0.5462139248847961,
0.8794023394584656,
0.9670213460922241,
0.018142584711313248,
-0.27877315878868103,
-0.21673086285591125,
0.33042478561401367,
0.6728062033653259,
-0.6074994802474976,
0.2208680957555771,
0.12247685343027115,
0.36222073435783386,
-0.007008227985352278,
0.6190545558929443,
-0.35369789600372314,
0.006846092641353607,
0.15887732803821564,
-0.10007789731025696,
-0.14852376282215118,
-0.38922959566116333,
-0.6424090266227722,
0.17440082132816315,
0.2970513701438904,
-0.42482295632362366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15422v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15422v2
|
A Data-Centric Approach To Generate Faithful and High Quality Patient Summaries with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T16:32:28 | 2024-06-25T17:02:10 |
Stefan Hegselmann, Shannon Zejiang Shen, Florian Gierse, Monica Agrawal, David Sontag, Xiaoyi Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Patients often face difficulties in understanding their hospitalizations,
while healthcare workers have limited resources to provide explanations. In
this work, we investigate the potential of large language models to generate
patient summaries based on doctors' notes and study the effect of training data
on the faithfulness and quality of the generated summaries. To this end, we
release (i) a rigorous labeling protocol for errors in medical texts and (ii) a
publicly available dataset of annotated hallucinations in 100 doctor-written
and 100 generated summaries. We show that fine-tuning on hallucination-free
data effectively reduces hallucinations from 2.60 to 1.55 per summary for Llama
2, while preserving relevant information. We observe a similar effect on GPT-4
(0.70 to 0.40), when the few-shot examples are hallucination-free. We also
conduct a qualitative evaluation using hallucination-free and improved training
data. We find that common quantitative metrics do not correlate well with
faithfulness and quality. Finally, we test GPT-4 for automatic hallucination
detection, which clearly outperforms common baselines.
|
[
-0.14003583788871765,
-0.5520374178886414,
0.9215524196624756,
-0.027627335861325264,
-0.3591421842575073,
-0.43651002645492554,
-0.21480661630630493,
-0.4727158546447754,
0.5796350240707397,
0.6245307326316833,
-0.17081505060195923,
-0.5704019069671631,
-0.7363005876541138,
0.37768298387527466,
-0.6311836242675781,
1.3618255853652954,
-0.14373700320720673,
0.3754642903804779,
-0.03798303008079529,
-0.1616087704896927,
-0.2659829258918762,
-0.8332673907279968,
-0.28119224309921265,
-0.340850830078125,
0.6312588453292847,
0.3086263835430145,
0.8287594318389893,
0.732044517993927,
0.6595533490180969,
0.18248949944972992,
0.1760120838880539,
0.29205790162086487,
-0.5966451168060303,
0.273996502161026,
-0.052812252193689346,
-0.35523495078086853,
-0.6476574540138245,
-0.07266900688409805,
0.5747246742248535,
0.868156909942627,
-0.2691819965839386,
-0.21164774894714355,
-0.10259676724672318,
0.7596285343170166,
-0.0845860168337822,
0.12642325460910797,
-0.448133647441864,
0.28923141956329346,
-0.011729126796126366,
-0.4117785394191742,
-0.40498897433280945,
-0.6000953912734985,
0.1535882204771042,
-0.6460720896720886,
0.5962926745414734,
-0.269145131111145,
0.8565572500228882,
0.3458152115345001,
0.019972193986177444,
-0.48917219042778015,
-0.4786592721939087,
0.4316965341567993,
-0.907637357711792,
0.25184348225593567,
0.6250156760215759,
0.23415341973304749,
-0.18469229340553284,
-0.6536582708358765,
-0.4926401972770691,
-0.17341399192810059,
-0.34012481570243835,
0.21113915741443634,
0.2885618507862091,
0.12254095822572708,
0.44606801867485046,
0.4467671513557434,
-0.5642223954200745,
-0.039354708045721054,
-0.4679698348045349,
-0.18756671249866486,
0.7497283220291138,
0.4374857544898987,
0.22494365274906158,
-0.0878472849726677,
0.2134656459093094,
0.07211430370807648,
-0.6660961508750916,
-0.5694409608840942,
0.29719078540802,
0.04942741245031357,
-0.0919836238026619,
0.8288373351097107,
-0.17027518153190613,
0.49063628911972046,
-0.06643469631671906,
-0.5731748938560486,
0.40282246470451355,
-0.21195393800735474,
-0.18313604593276978,
0.19878990948200226,
0.8847226500511169,
0.748690664768219,
0.500146210193634,
-0.5215994119644165,
-0.2905150353908539,
0.1894436478614807,
0.5212161540985107,
-0.9311802387237549,
-0.6360180974006653,
0.42848968505859375,
-0.6079339981079102,
-0.4525633454322815,
-0.0497007891535759,
-0.7146086096763611,
-0.5440152287483215,
-0.5544044375419617,
0.2718144357204437,
-0.6609147787094116,
-0.12255646288394928,
0.1346229612827301,
-0.042345449328422546,
-0.056052207946777344,
0.5536902546882629,
-1.115254282951355,
0.19921638071537018,
0.5526584982872009,
0.9237911701202393,
-0.2710185647010803,
-0.48703718185424805,
-0.5357485413551331,
0.21725940704345703,
-0.5207670331001282,
0.7828630208969116,
-0.09898826479911804,
-0.5082021951675415,
-0.034194089472293854,
0.0986659824848175,
-0.012232581153512001,
-0.8117401599884033,
0.21769994497299194,
0.13624000549316406,
0.3084353804588318,
-0.4513528645038605,
-0.6290121078491211,
-0.13818679749965668,
0.08313785493373871,
-0.642453134059906,
0.4776424467563629,
0.46262359619140625,
-0.7943939566612244,
0.5216816663742065,
-0.16302379965782166,
-0.7082341313362122,
-0.037945736199617386,
-0.4773598909378052,
-0.647776186466217,
0.447806179523468,
0.20331890881061554,
0.5676237344741821,
0.1455327272415161,
0.5541826486587524,
0.09713062644004822,
-0.5685907602310181,
0.3728044927120209,
-0.18194027245044708,
0.407326340675354,
0.06410915404558182,
-0.29733338952064514,
-0.06791725009679794,
-0.6386778354644775,
-0.3390207588672638,
0.1505880355834961,
-0.25547462701797485,
-0.1498773843050003,
-0.0053770337253808975,
-0.1207706406712532,
0.13271406292915344,
-0.21855731308460236,
-0.20143064856529236,
0.2323976457118988,
-0.4911629855632782,
0.08437132835388184,
0.4479665160179138,
0.2830684185028076,
0.04467179626226425,
-0.5925568342208862,
0.3358922600746155,
0.27068400382995605,
0.17250050604343414,
-0.30744266510009766,
-0.43941009044647217,
-0.6564381122589111,
-0.2101721167564392,
0.03314903378486633,
0.3565616309642792,
-0.7492199540138245,
0.30899226665496826,
-0.37866753339767456,
-0.25408613681793213,
-0.6313678026199341,
-0.07026480883359909,
0.4450075030326843,
0.8877196907997131,
0.473202109336853,
-0.5429593324661255,
-0.4948786199092865,
-0.826978325843811,
-0.13642734289169312,
-0.25052163004875183,
-0.21340450644493103,
0.22602485120296478,
0.5888181328773499,
-0.3700592517852783,
0.5803213119506836,
-0.47161179780960083,
-0.5067981481552124,
-0.26118844747543335,
0.0315665602684021,
0.00618422357365489,
0.29150328040122986,
0.4972332715988159,
-0.35677802562713623,
-0.2407059222459793,
-0.10977993905544281,
-1.258995771408081,
-0.008574819192290306,
-0.46070125699043274,
0.11518535017967224,
0.42454034090042114,
0.14620116353034973,
-0.551544725894928,
0.4195130169391632,
0.2976806163787842,
-0.17331363260746002,
0.5979068875312805,
-0.4536885917186737,
0.25072625279426575,
-1.2299656867980957,
0.10828094929456711,
-0.09736353904008865,
-0.29120635986328125,
-0.7438196539878845,
-0.2823913097381592,
-0.12154980003833771,
0.05532433092594147,
-0.03408699110150337,
0.1423594206571579,
-0.17763358354568481,
-0.020311640575528145,
-0.2404583841562271,
0.18234717845916748,
0.0268588624894619,
0.2951596677303314,
0.3428945541381836,
0.6002888679504395,
0.42024925351142883,
-0.31595030426979065,
0.05741569772362709,
0.5263143181800842,
-0.12011712789535522,
0.5535795092582703,
-0.5741824507713318,
0.07526227831840515,
-0.39193737506866455,
0.13050752878189087,
-0.660508394241333,
-0.8364120125770569,
0.1842687427997589,
-0.5593525767326355,
0.3340955674648285,
0.1229589506983757,
-0.5703926086425781,
-0.18019165098667145,
-0.3454326093196869,
0.024570925161242485,
0.4663555920124054,
-0.2499113231897354,
0.175314798951149,
0.4270745813846588,
-0.27794981002807617,
-0.32489728927612305,
-0.9843489527702332,
0.2769424319267273,
-0.033678971230983734,
-0.16168135404586792,
-0.02340390346944332,
0.09183158725500107,
-0.17877794802188873,
-0.1439337432384491,
0.02962827868759632,
-0.13429337739944458,
-0.1201636865735054,
0.39273974299430847,
0.1723714917898178,
-0.10384088009595871,
0.16272705793380737,
0.20969371497631073,
-0.0913735181093216,
0.3646728992462158,
0.027259809896349907,
0.4744780361652374,
0.062098290771245956,
-0.3055412173271179,
-0.7371419072151184,
0.6103753447532654,
0.6745516657829285,
0.14988194406032562,
0.7537326216697693,
0.3711739778518677,
-0.563410222530365,
-0.032924506813287735,
-0.6525720953941345,
-0.5595012903213501,
-0.3368796408176422,
0.4301470220088959,
-0.22947385907173157,
-0.5677299499511719,
0.5175560116767883,
0.3499421775341034,
0.1023864671587944,
0.39588338136672974,
0.7163916230201721,
-0.125064417719841,
1.093592643737793,
0.3138951361179352,
-0.07030687481164932,
0.00340099073946476,
-0.10259805619716644,
0.24178054928779602,
-0.6049079298973083,
-0.43937018513679504,
-0.3008606433868408,
0.13709349930286407,
-0.5313535332679749,
-0.16149760782718658,
0.4840758740901947,
-0.11695664376020432,
0.12947909533977509,
0.004694452974945307,
-0.7841429710388184,
0.4247468411922455,
0.26918771862983704,
0.32701006531715393,
0.444827139377594,
0.2535731792449951,
0.3756062984466553,
-0.3134481608867645,
-0.41523444652557373,
-0.6637641191482544,
1.1932700872421265,
0.40790510177612305,
0.7538466453552246,
-0.06941261142492294,
0.8525009751319885,
0.08609374612569809,
0.37522318959236145,
-0.6811006665229797,
0.31100958585739136,
-0.16285814344882965,
-0.2630062997341156,
-0.3362581431865692,
-0.5709767937660217,
-0.6527841687202454,
0.12355995923280716,
-0.1052575409412384,
-0.4519413411617279,
-0.031683050096035004,
0.2009895294904709,
-0.3863312602043152,
0.2208758443593979,
-0.72809237241745,
0.3834206163883209,
-0.21409133076667786,
-0.07935012876987457,
-0.07186930626630783,
-0.7187933921813965,
0.4880097508430481,
-0.3160104751586914,
-0.0643833801150322,
0.08578303456306458,
0.1764618307352066,
0.7140836119651794,
-0.6153923869132996,
0.7253754138946533,
-0.2100500762462616,
-0.23810617625713348,
0.039659738540649414,
0.12177745997905731,
0.4191899597644806,
0.24215945601463318,
-0.011052129790186882,
0.3672821521759033,
-0.07662639766931534,
-0.24640260636806488,
-0.5083853602409363,
0.5634236931800842,
-0.7095083594322205,
-0.3661169409751892,
-0.38233092427253723,
-0.8470478057861328,
-0.22358807921409607,
0.08988804370164871,
0.5490313768386841,
0.5241674780845642,
0.0401669479906559,
-0.12262528389692307,
0.8461270928382874,
-0.46630704402923584,
-0.03374730423092842,
0.3262423574924469,
-0.11187458783388138,
-0.5569310188293457,
0.8652623295783997,
0.4052209258079529,
0.19028690457344055,
0.032671619206666946,
0.11958782374858856,
-0.20605944097042084,
-0.8047195672988892,
-0.5859271287918091,
0.708626925945282,
-0.7088711261749268,
-0.049755219370126724,
-1.0510799884796143,
-0.3253183662891388,
-0.43082180619239807,
-0.3023512363433838,
-0.1633283942937851,
-0.3213886618614197,
-0.36509183049201965,
-0.23221580684185028,
0.4627918601036072,
0.8936132788658142,
0.11492560803890228,
0.19277217984199524,
-0.60868239402771,
0.6320990920066833,
0.018739724531769753,
0.418415904045105,
-0.06842979788780212,
-0.5879356265068054,
-0.3745906949043274,
-0.0570899061858654,
-0.04675939306616783,
-1.0194555521011353,
0.6173856258392334,
-0.07731623947620392,
0.3001985549926758,
0.5901870727539062,
-0.24532067775726318,
0.7470348477363586,
-0.4537550210952759,
0.8517159819602966,
0.3622969090938568,
-0.6964203119277954,
0.6097496151924133,
-0.5444733500480652,
0.17383499443531036,
0.88838130235672,
0.2569274604320526,
-0.5235744714736938,
-0.7623398303985596,
-0.5510443449020386,
-0.765348494052887,
0.6911394596099854,
0.16535057127475739,
-0.025733940303325653,
-0.1448269784450531,
0.6377201676368713,
0.4604777693748474,
0.2944900393486023,
-0.61358243227005,
-0.1843719631433487,
-0.4072614908218384,
-0.33113881945610046,
-0.14883241057395935,
-0.4474833309650421,
-0.19842419028282166,
-0.3637608289718628,
0.550366222858429,
-0.073325514793396,
0.29729050397872925,
0.5053490996360779,
-0.09778112918138504,
-0.1905655711889267,
-0.09693696349859238,
0.8206301927566528,
0.8838792443275452,
-0.26294979453086853,
0.2524183392524719,
0.20006504654884338,
-0.8582358956336975,
-0.04686295986175537,
-0.016513939946889877,
-0.2743232548236847,
0.5271685719490051,
0.4835061728954315,
0.7195821404457092,
-0.2710787057876587,
-0.6627735495567322,
0.6251552104949951,
-0.1112661361694336,
-0.4841519892215729,
-0.3279343843460083,
0.06826091557741165,
-0.05196559801697731,
-0.10439031571149826,
0.031076516956090927,
-0.22621053457260132,
0.33006563782691956,
-0.4521426856517792,
0.37044620513916016,
0.02222699671983719,
-0.31535571813583374,
-0.3996679484844208,
0.8010055422782898,
-0.2063090056180954,
-0.11188093572854996,
0.7691914439201355,
-0.02091551013290882,
-0.24070250988006592,
0.3081606924533844,
0.612893283367157,
0.7259372472763062,
-0.2997073233127594,
0.3543139696121216,
0.4806016683578491,
0.30937522649765015,
-0.4681795537471771,
0.4245328903198242,
0.20970898866653442,
-0.26731979846954346,
-0.4773118197917938,
-0.32550379633903503,
-0.5551707744598389,
0.3361804783344269,
-0.7023354768753052,
0.10436426103115082,
-0.34515732526779175,
0.00387477595359087,
0.023981038480997086,
-0.3021092712879181,
-0.29024696350097656,
0.3594265282154083,
0.011887233704328537,
0.30371972918510437,
-0.8808215260505676,
0.8447041511535645,
0.35555344820022583,
-0.6102091073989868,
-0.9701399803161621,
0.05471329391002655,
-0.1477435678243637,
-0.5791029334068298,
0.08127867430448532,
0.2583548426628113,
0.15436433255672455,
-0.38278838992118835,
-0.3346249759197235,
-0.3640563189983368,
0.8403871655464172,
0.4022919833660126,
-0.7355709671974182,
-0.17411354184150696,
0.4544195234775543,
0.8945480585098267,
-0.19818800687789917,
0.16455042362213135,
0.7261499762535095,
0.19410085678100586,
-0.12122025340795517,
-0.8717663884162903,
0.1588238626718521,
-0.12230896949768066,
-0.25264471769332886,
0.18611009418964386,
-0.29979565739631653,
0.8119745850563049,
-0.43476736545562744,
0.028440559282898903,
-0.0847097858786583,
0.32562562823295593,
0.2099132537841797,
0.40676164627075195,
0.24204976856708527,
0.5799741744995117,
1.0160523653030396,
-0.1551918089389801,
1.2363842725753784,
-0.17663699388504028,
0.1843007206916809,
1.1068251132965088,
-0.4046691358089447,
0.4037210941314697,
0.6597630381584167,
0.1623939722776413,
0.24427072703838348,
0.3157292306423187,
-0.15480995178222656,
0.47872301936149597,
0.1790592521429062,
-0.14500217139720917,
0.05431996285915375,
-0.050417277961969376,
-0.6089481115341187,
0.05432356894016266,
0.2901572585105896,
-0.8260005116462708,
-0.1430559605360031,
0.15107013285160065,
0.4019131064414978,
-0.04775261506438255,
-0.07723063975572586,
1.0919357538223267,
0.2436741143465042,
-0.8772439956665039,
0.8012940287590027,
-0.3300859034061432,
0.20450805127620697,
-0.3744259178638458,
-0.17961040139198303,
-0.5133143067359924,
0.1059507355093956,
-0.5782809257507324,
-0.6432573795318604,
0.49101972579956055,
0.24052469432353973,
-0.3087296485900879,
-0.10576356947422028,
0.2668938934803009,
-0.5366158485412598,
-0.4603114128112793,
-0.09317285567522049,
0.39775341749191284,
0.7122987508773804,
-0.013028883375227451,
-0.18454468250274658,
-0.08216273784637451,
0.148173987865448,
-0.23897592723369598,
0.334980845451355,
0.5539005994796753,
-0.13255557417869568,
0.3490274250507355,
0.37883874773979187,
0.5952999591827393,
-0.28274914622306824,
0.4924210011959076,
0.8945960998535156,
-0.5792127251625061,
-0.3738740384578705,
-0.8607370257377625,
0.32222965359687805,
-0.13305892050266266,
-0.350239634513855,
0.6131975650787354,
0.7939445376396179,
0.5145487189292908,
-0.3076612651348114,
0.8881582021713257,
0.22689512372016907,
0.6818864941596985,
-0.5185456871986389,
1.0214216709136963,
-0.47841665148735046,
0.1143743246793747,
-0.3551739454269409,
-0.6895542144775391,
-0.528896152973175,
0.653662919998169,
-0.169922336935997,
-0.13778918981552124,
0.8391007781028748,
0.8049171566963196,
-0.008823257870972157,
0.004686429165303707,
0.43165871500968933,
0.2749519646167755,
0.3410174250602722,
0.6452895402908325,
0.5669130682945251,
-0.36274904012680054,
0.2070516049861908,
-0.4062771499156952,
-0.12335078418254852,
-0.2923283874988556,
-0.4054208993911743,
-1.2097210884094238,
-0.46618011593818665,
-0.3730411231517792,
-0.6194895505905151,
0.19400662183761597,
0.7163461446762085,
0.5304309129714966,
-0.8980117440223694,
0.15106362104415894,
-0.06655669957399368,
-0.297587513923645,
-0.11484766751527786,
-0.17544999718666077,
0.7814262509346008,
-0.3455287218093872,
-0.4454461336135864,
0.057800617069005966,
0.4066435992717743,
0.3150336444377899,
-0.17105290293693542,
-0.19306859374046326,
0.5609843730926514,
-0.09480488300323486,
0.5710026025772095,
-0.18303467333316803,
-0.6908138394355774,
-0.13043107092380524,
0.0018924915930256248,
-0.3310808837413788,
0.30385783314704895,
0.821082592010498,
-0.5512257814407349,
0.599504292011261,
0.29798248410224915,
0.40746790170669556,
0.4439094364643097,
0.14186911284923553,
0.451232373714447,
-0.3658789396286011,
0.027023276314139366,
0.5125113725662231,
0.3126644492149353,
0.4675711393356323,
-0.6052241325378418,
0.5613604187965393,
0.24168884754180908,
-0.573066771030426,
-1.018430471420288,
-0.1114090085029602,
-0.8821195960044861,
-0.16836464405059814,
1.145118236541748,
-0.0639505386352539,
0.00023141401470638812,
-0.23363202810287476,
-0.3140642046928406,
0.4041982889175415,
-0.2317495197057724,
1.353682279586792,
0.5936659574508667,
-0.2557757794857025,
0.035469748079776764,
-0.8764228224754333,
0.758496880531311,
0.4544840157032013,
-1.1211233139038086,
0.2333354949951172,
0.8033837080001831,
0.25670817494392395,
-0.02115800231695175,
0.8722134232521057,
-0.42192667722702026,
0.45148733258247375,
-0.011365385726094246,
0.06147361546754837,
-0.13249652087688446,
-0.48060935735702515,
-0.42138171195983887,
0.21860580146312714,
-0.02625083178281784,
0.07770846784114838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15420v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15420v1
|
PREDILECT: Preferences Delineated with Zero-Shot Language-based Reasoning in Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-02-23T16:30:05 | 2024-02-23T16:30:05 |
Simon Holk, Daniel Marta, Iolanda Leite
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Preference-based reinforcement learning (RL) has emerged as a new field in
robot learning, where humans play a pivotal role in shaping robot behavior by
expressing preferences on different sequences of state-action pairs. However,
formulating realistic policies for robots demands responses from humans to an
extensive array of queries. In this work, we approach the sample-efficiency
challenge by expanding the information collected per query to contain both
preferences and optional text prompting. To accomplish this, we leverage the
zero-shot capabilities of a large language model (LLM) to reason from the text
provided by humans. To accommodate the additional query information, we
reformulate the reward learning objectives to contain flexible highlights --
state-action pairs that contain relatively high information and are related to
the features processed in a zero-shot fashion from a pretrained LLM. In both a
simulated scenario and a user study, we reveal the effectiveness of our work by
analyzing the feedback and its implications. Additionally, the collective
feedback collected serves to train a robot on socially compliant trajectories
in a simulated social navigation landscape. We provide video examples of the
trained policies at https://sites.google.com/view/rl-predilect
|
[
-0.28896936774253845,
-0.7175552248954773,
0.7555391192436218,
-0.25646230578422546,
-0.20926140248775482,
-0.05333469808101654,
-0.5661149621009827,
-0.09436475485563278,
0.4061136543750763,
0.729041337966919,
-0.8031361103057861,
-0.6478235125541687,
-0.4696836769580841,
-0.010475076735019684,
0.07571227848529816,
1.2676208019256592,
0.01149635948240757,
-0.46364957094192505,
0.02113248035311699,
-0.18137569725513458,
-0.13067230582237244,
-0.6780726313591003,
-0.3658709228038788,
-0.5645694732666016,
1.0451245307922363,
0.8043038845062256,
0.6829516291618347,
0.37019380927085876,
-0.005370118655264378,
0.2761422395706177,
0.16407370567321777,
0.22222359478473663,
-0.773557722568512,
0.15960094332695007,
-0.47228842973709106,
-0.5138671398162842,
-0.2352582961320877,
0.16802263259887695,
0.3084684908390045,
0.6514418125152588,
0.027429373934864998,
-0.08866970241069794,
-0.005773772951215506,
0.7880666255950928,
-0.9103524684906006,
0.14685826003551483,
-0.5550288558006287,
0.08833952993154526,
0.08442986756563187,
-0.4222622811794281,
-0.5391860008239746,
-0.35526415705680847,
0.29681164026260376,
-0.9027884006500244,
-0.028668595477938652,
-0.19933894276618958,
1.0714093446731567,
0.455529123544693,
-0.3940383791923523,
-0.10810110718011856,
-0.7855837941169739,
0.9510319232940674,
-0.20444686710834503,
0.4074619710445404,
0.640378475189209,
0.25308758020401,
-0.24568483233451843,
-0.22033657133579254,
-0.6770011186599731,
-0.39552032947540283,
0.055674780160188675,
0.21910344064235687,
0.13843058049678802,
0.3475956320762634,
0.22674348950386047,
-0.0772879496216774,
-0.6319959163665771,
0.076898492872715,
-0.2755047082901001,
-0.21425370872020721,
0.7075766324996948,
-0.12265060096979141,
-0.05079707130789757,
-0.15835629403591156,
-0.2720180153846741,
-0.7139586806297302,
-0.7029137015342712,
0.5258710980415344,
0.5371595025062561,
0.4363873600959778,
-0.16189096868038177,
0.6726697087287903,
-0.5923813581466675,
0.6435360312461853,
0.13796710968017578,
0.0886581540107727,
0.48494213819503784,
-0.03880925849080086,
-0.17438344657421112,
-0.14119362831115723,
0.7835413813591003,
0.5034404397010803,
0.5183302760124207,
-0.20006178319454193,
-0.13365015387535095,
-0.0035892073065042496,
0.31342723965644836,
-0.741542398929596,
-0.40700626373291016,
0.30271705985069275,
-0.29255232214927673,
-0.17812615633010864,
-0.11138362437486649,
-0.4840635657310486,
-0.3294602632522583,
-0.39674967527389526,
0.5549635291099548,
-0.3195294737815857,
-0.27200132608413696,
0.5351848602294922,
-0.2601735591888428,
0.33220550417900085,
0.5454436540603638,
-0.8592524528503418,
-0.010388128459453583,
0.43330836296081543,
0.5134170055389404,
-0.0932847335934639,
-0.3565068542957306,
-0.5589353442192078,
-0.01944810524582863,
-0.2783527970314026,
0.916899561882019,
-0.4751304090023041,
-0.5638176798820496,
0.02213069051504135,
-0.031760185956954956,
-0.006541205104440451,
-0.32356587052345276,
0.38094329833984375,
-0.5724346041679382,
0.3569476008415222,
-0.2602681815624237,
-0.4928451180458069,
-0.2501942217350006,
0.6124532222747803,
-0.5365694165229797,
0.4886762797832489,
0.2284626066684723,
-0.3241470158100128,
0.7522862553596497,
-0.873450756072998,
-0.48861539363861084,
0.1075989305973053,
-0.23407848179340363,
-0.1682201623916626,
-0.27122753858566284,
-0.012931019067764282,
0.49079862236976624,
0.3792511522769928,
0.11340796947479248,
-0.5028554797172546,
-0.26216408610343933,
0.1348382979631424,
-0.3365882337093353,
0.44072696566581726,
0.10198411345481873,
-0.2190171182155609,
0.6849994659423828,
-0.47535377740859985,
0.11072754859924316,
0.08833402395248413,
-0.39294707775115967,
-0.3062577545642853,
0.21690647304058075,
-0.3623597323894501,
0.16182206571102142,
0.40857207775115967,
-0.33811071515083313,
0.22569863498210907,
-0.3365888297557831,
0.05884189158678055,
0.8796139359474182,
-0.03963195160031319,
0.7917114496231079,
-0.1936640441417694,
0.6630755662918091,
-0.23114660382270813,
0.3982554078102112,
-0.2273009717464447,
0.015782469883561134,
-0.6476790308952332,
-0.1880102902650833,
0.011590770445764065,
0.4157600700855255,
-0.9344483017921448,
0.4971008896827698,
0.06480447947978973,
-0.3098360300064087,
-0.10853973031044006,
-0.017952734604477882,
0.36396124958992004,
0.5191135406494141,
0.5383318662643433,
-0.16447889804840088,
-0.2702792286872864,
-0.671898365020752,
0.055391810834407806,
-0.32242679595947266,
-0.07473481446504593,
0.766813337802887,
0.32141393423080444,
-0.08158624917268753,
0.9446424245834351,
-0.7363443970680237,
-0.014540303498506546,
-0.6563257575035095,
0.0024956900160759687,
0.1468125879764557,
0.09130191802978516,
0.5098435878753662,
-0.7673702836036682,
-0.30598893761634827,
-0.31412047147750854,
-0.5205122232437134,
0.17377988994121552,
-0.0885879322886467,
-0.46133795380592346,
0.24857620894908905,
0.37017422914505005,
-0.4730554223060608,
0.46659407019615173,
0.24653002619743347,
-0.3182804584503174,
0.552219808101654,
-0.4880011975765228,
0.12778662145137787,
-0.6131282448768616,
0.03044694848358631,
0.15617670118808746,
-0.27328360080718994,
-0.42132532596588135,
-0.09714024513959885,
-0.14914199709892273,
0.1605936884880066,
-0.5764806866645813,
0.6687955856323242,
-0.011400986462831497,
0.05197766795754433,
-0.3891037702560425,
0.2727549374103546,
-0.010053561069071293,
0.7419465184211731,
0.6874895691871643,
0.5354709029197693,
0.25377970933914185,
-0.9495489597320557,
0.0752963200211525,
0.04341476038098335,
0.07778780162334442,
0.33197328448295593,
-0.7179393172264099,
0.007520465645939112,
-0.14475640654563904,
0.4596426784992218,
-0.7506157159805298,
-0.33748018741607666,
0.4801595211029053,
-0.5636665225028992,
-0.1356850266456604,
-0.0908583328127861,
-0.24092859029769897,
-0.1794690191745758,
-0.45902249217033386,
0.20692579448223114,
0.4699768126010895,
-0.50551837682724,
0.3563184142112732,
0.4565434753894806,
0.2684498727321625,
-0.7515639662742615,
0.04857967793941498,
-0.3814330995082855,
-0.1478612869977951,
-0.2703949511051178,
0.14439694583415985,
-0.1626059114933014,
-0.07594358175992966,
-0.047901611775159836,
0.028088878840208054,
-0.04684237763285637,
0.41466274857521057,
0.2258380800485611,
0.45861050486564636,
0.1784922033548355,
0.21269239485263824,
-0.018674064427614212,
-0.12243256717920303,
-0.1518876552581787,
-0.19717273116111755,
0.8492760062217712,
-0.016505470499396324,
-0.19241149723529816,
-0.2518065273761749,
0.16104772686958313,
0.1823057234287262,
-0.16526676714420319,
0.4772927761077881,
0.1715204119682312,
0.18502086400985718,
-0.4494716227054596,
-0.03822702541947365,
-0.5193549990653992,
-0.46682503819465637,
0.3068811893463135,
-0.20227672159671783,
-1.1708225011825562,
0.14179429411888123,
-0.10058031976222992,
0.1243416965007782,
0.12839709222316742,
0.40281760692596436,
-0.2465260624885559,
0.7364432215690613,
0.641779363155365,
0.1121668592095375,
0.6688331961631775,
-0.2732574939727783,
0.06458201259374619,
-0.31449469923973083,
-0.343822181224823,
-0.3954106271266937,
-0.2632792890071869,
-0.5221707224845886,
-0.4666840136051178,
0.310001939535141,
-0.030467212200164795,
-0.538285493850708,
0.3299800753593445,
-0.366428017616272,
0.6531700491905212,
0.7693912386894226,
0.28174081444740295,
-0.019027510657906532,
-0.15804223716259003,
-0.17973655462265015,
0.23566628992557526,
-0.5349674224853516,
-0.47557732462882996,
1.2554794549942017,
-0.041157323867082596,
0.6874708533287048,
-0.07646679878234863,
1.031346082687378,
0.21745964884757996,
-0.08618879318237305,
-1.1267553567886353,
0.7556526064872742,
-0.11703236401081085,
-0.4493860602378845,
-0.5719303488731384,
-0.40593668818473816,
-1.2478574514389038,
0.18703608214855194,
-0.4661797881126404,
-0.6341016292572021,
-0.07320237159729004,
0.5041349530220032,
-0.5591097474098206,
0.066668301820755,
-0.6035432815551758,
1.0049577951431274,
-0.5352203249931335,
-0.5860356092453003,
-0.3948267996311188,
-0.8326652646064758,
0.19081710278987885,
0.375801682472229,
-0.14282624423503876,
-0.2137792855501175,
0.22449712455272675,
0.5210069417953491,
-0.2389388084411621,
0.7346472144126892,
-0.41069427132606506,
0.18000894784927368,
0.11725611984729767,
-0.01995866186916828,
0.23710979521274567,
-0.23839254677295685,
0.1422789841890335,
-0.003799308091402054,
-0.1610710769891739,
-0.29376575350761414,
-0.6560825109481812,
0.17711544036865234,
-0.8982719779014587,
-0.523764967918396,
-0.4190049469470978,
-0.42027944326400757,
-0.24076800048351288,
0.16038165986537933,
-0.05614348128437996,
0.15642037987709045,
-0.16134081780910492,
0.2348339557647705,
0.7567258477210999,
-0.5614281892776489,
0.2781321406364441,
0.7781334519386292,
-0.3952037990093231,
0.07717962563037872,
0.941486656665802,
-0.06244159862399101,
0.29052308201789856,
0.6453693509101868,
0.28712546825408936,
-0.6719642281532288,
-0.35138002038002014,
-0.3881361484527588,
0.15275700390338898,
-0.32170024514198303,
0.20777404308319092,
-0.4647069275379181,
-0.021605340763926506,
-0.1914709061384201,
-0.3885590136051178,
-0.4155060350894928,
-0.32368117570877075,
-0.2538307309150696,
-0.1038329005241394,
0.34911084175109863,
0.5287905931472778,
-0.2719781696796417,
0.3665997385978699,
-0.6478607654571533,
0.43527689576148987,
0.3389361500740051,
0.3281923532485962,
-0.2961422801017761,
-0.3964119553565979,
-0.08811885118484497,
0.003980654291808605,
-0.11156602203845978,
-0.6329452991485596,
0.30079516768455505,
-0.18444424867630005,
0.67845618724823,
0.546901524066925,
0.45083701610565186,
0.36944276094436646,
-0.5437715649604797,
0.7239133715629578,
0.19371844828128815,
-0.5915233492851257,
0.8585605025291443,
-0.3987683951854706,
0.14785520732402802,
0.9239614605903625,
0.6755502223968506,
-0.4579412341117859,
0.01581091620028019,
-0.7221800684928894,
-1.073474645614624,
0.7241908311843872,
-0.22634702920913696,
0.023761391639709473,
-0.1148785725235939,
0.33398663997650146,
0.11742135882377625,
0.2144312858581543,
-0.6497699022293091,
-0.23298008739948273,
-0.34224963188171387,
-0.09771841764450073,
-0.25632810592651367,
-0.02973770722746849,
-0.12322131544351578,
-0.04853195324540138,
0.4544902443885803,
-0.29771098494529724,
-0.13742072880268097,
0.10281916707754135,
-0.17021441459655762,
0.3084665536880493,
0.4973834156990051,
0.630399227142334,
0.31762927770614624,
-0.5200340747833252,
0.043961599469184875,
-0.27512824535369873,
-0.09587769955396652,
0.2659141421318054,
-0.17428714036941528,
-0.3318622410297394,
-0.3723095655441284,
-0.08825380355119705,
0.8211864829063416,
0.11997605860233307,
-0.84800785779953,
0.6066861152648926,
-0.1996239721775055,
-0.38831230998039246,
-0.26868265867233276,
0.5538156628608704,
-0.3404361307621002,
0.23007485270500183,
0.10267845541238785,
-0.05912851169705391,
0.0688987597823143,
-0.5671464800834656,
0.3481699526309967,
0.5154045820236206,
-0.5715728402137756,
-0.29473888874053955,
0.28326860070228577,
0.44751328229904175,
-0.3555825352668762,
0.36957481503486633,
-0.6315301656723022,
-0.6132669448852539,
0.36787423491477966,
0.09023784101009369,
0.6771261096000671,
0.09619562327861786,
0.8242546916007996,
0.4605395495891571,
0.07264286279678345,
-0.18543465435504913,
0.1721716672182083,
-0.7065640091896057,
-1.1491599082946777,
-0.5776248574256897,
-0.35764506459236145,
-0.7783932089805603,
0.12619496881961823,
-0.5525227785110474,
0.17037026584148407,
-0.5964654684066772,
-0.03373836353421211,
-0.313603937625885,
0.0036309396382421255,
-0.4839988946914673,
0.13727380335330963,
0.07845781743526459,
0.45938751101493835,
-0.7824325561523438,
0.9424522519111633,
0.6492938995361328,
-0.6351157426834106,
-1.1101152896881104,
0.0565340481698513,
-0.0660068616271019,
-0.8809847235679626,
0.9867668747901917,
0.05811826512217522,
-0.625288188457489,
-0.4090912342071533,
-0.7421666979789734,
-0.4276663362979889,
0.7012851238250732,
0.2881166934967041,
-0.43520665168762207,
0.08984442800283432,
-0.16440613567829132,
0.3215029537677765,
-0.18818680942058563,
0.47203895449638367,
0.40537717938423157,
0.3892543911933899,
0.2988061010837555,
-0.7433081269264221,
-0.209788978099823,
-0.030625183135271072,
-0.4680008888244629,
0.08518936485052109,
-0.680245041847229,
0.698765218257904,
-0.3284558653831482,
-0.10942186415195465,
-0.3771858513355255,
0.5011917352676392,
0.6786482334136963,
0.35699033737182617,
0.8446943759918213,
0.34669816493988037,
0.8531038165092468,
0.2172263115644455,
1.096754550933838,
-0.22264479100704193,
0.13186126947402954,
1.24846613407135,
-0.5881247520446777,
1.0831868648529053,
0.2910899519920349,
-0.021657228469848633,
0.6434512138366699,
0.6610491871833801,
0.4782690405845642,
0.6666088700294495,
0.19212204217910767,
-0.33001723885536194,
-0.6997661590576172,
-0.28144368529319763,
-0.07897185534238815,
0.5940072536468506,
0.227077454328537,
-0.012270846404135227,
-0.32207202911376953,
-0.21345673501491547,
0.164433091878891,
0.3383949100971222,
-0.28550028800964355,
0.773777961730957,
-0.3233872056007385,
-0.9500211477279663,
0.23798902332782745,
-0.3422989845275879,
0.9632688164710999,
-0.7369835376739502,
-0.19976870715618134,
-0.1105487123131752,
0.2574259340763092,
-0.05110670626163483,
-0.9914803504943848,
-0.014449368230998516,
-0.05611103028059006,
-0.3437417447566986,
-0.37559664249420166,
0.547127902507782,
-0.45532262325286865,
0.05830314755439758,
0.4530636966228485,
0.4837178587913513,
0.3715696632862091,
-0.08035271614789963,
-0.6929026246070862,
-0.21632036566734314,
0.2731444537639618,
-0.11036225408315659,
0.47349828481674194,
0.33363643288612366,
0.01642412692308426,
0.6199536919593811,
0.7367950677871704,
0.23806767165660858,
-0.25671103596687317,
0.24312269687652588,
0.7915039658546448,
-0.6802560091018677,
-0.4798796474933624,
-0.7390462160110474,
0.4210793375968933,
-0.27272969484329224,
-0.2571602761745453,
0.6651579737663269,
0.45554542541503906,
1.1829895973205566,
0.01774171181023121,
0.8182377815246582,
0.08621353656053543,
0.6309293508529663,
-0.5347861051559448,
0.583678662776947,
-0.6447552442550659,
0.044725723564624786,
0.0066828434355556965,
-0.5479355454444885,
-0.21136760711669922,
0.9676563739776611,
-0.5349745154380798,
0.11394182592630386,
0.4355809688568115,
0.7817591428756714,
0.18722975254058838,
-0.3235836625099182,
0.498993843793869,
-0.2293621152639389,
0.3474099040031433,
0.6676844954490662,
0.8418866395950317,
0.2765995264053345,
0.602080762386322,
-0.17358051240444183,
-0.27960169315338135,
-0.29910650849342346,
-0.8687428832054138,
-0.8657634854316711,
-0.4347272515296936,
-0.13234476745128632,
-0.2506696283817291,
0.18060944974422455,
1.4031468629837036,
0.8311840891838074,
-0.4559458792209625,
-0.4033014178276062,
-0.04578706622123718,
0.4277891218662262,
0.21032960712909698,
-0.2325260043144226,
0.22334782779216766,
-0.5012194514274597,
-0.5503035187721252,
0.475698322057724,
0.3496595323085785,
-0.16148734092712402,
-0.16879354417324066,
-0.46280866861343384,
-0.20483185350894928,
-0.011888165958225727,
0.7603088021278381,
0.7657119631767273,
-0.4647270739078522,
-0.487425833940506,
0.1366702914237976,
0.06940670311450958,
0.03187385946512222,
0.7795981764793396,
-0.9607602953910828,
0.4824422597885132,
0.4776657521724701,
0.521970808506012,
0.6362378597259521,
0.055961985141038895,
0.5935512185096741,
-0.6000277400016785,
0.3125321865081787,
0.3090926706790924,
0.15358373522758484,
0.1215912401676178,
-0.0640987977385521,
0.31747913360595703,
0.12852106988430023,
-0.6575167179107666,
-0.4064379036426544,
0.4408584535121918,
-1.1395294666290283,
-0.4817506670951843,
1.315402626991272,
-0.23245052993297577,
-0.4388188421726227,
-0.2075319141149521,
-0.24664756655693054,
0.09042578190565109,
-0.9370414614677429,
0.62559974193573,
0.40161752700805664,
-0.43962323665618896,
-0.2952616810798645,
-0.32818320393562317,
0.6378715634346008,
0.423312246799469,
-0.8244324326515198,
-0.05897010862827301,
0.8009785413742065,
0.1230711117386818,
0.0128615228459239,
0.9858733415603638,
0.17461401224136353,
0.3163261115550995,
-0.3353393077850342,
0.3413334786891937,
0.005868068430572748,
-0.6258034110069275,
-0.26442182064056396,
0.26239004731178284,
0.2692745625972748,
-0.34853774309158325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15400v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15400v1
|
Faithful Temporal Question Answering over Heterogeneous Sources
| 2024-02-23T16:03:17 | 2024-02-23T16:03:17 |
Zhen Jia, Philipp Christmann, Gerhard Weikum
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Temporal question answering (QA) involves time constraints, with phrases such
as "... in 2019" or "... before COVID". In the former, time is an explicit
condition, in the latter it is implicit. State-of-the-art methods have
limitations along three dimensions. First, with neural inference, time
constraints are merely soft-matched, giving room to invalid or inexplicable
answers. Second, questions with implicit time are poorly supported. Third,
answers come from a single source: either a knowledge base (KB) or a text
corpus. We propose a temporal QA system that addresses these shortcomings.
First, it enforces temporal constraints for faithful answering with tangible
evidence. Second, it properly handles implicit questions. Third, it operates
over heterogeneous sources, covering KB, text and web tables in a unified
manner. The method has three stages: (i) understanding the question and its
temporal conditions, (ii) retrieving evidence from all sources, and (iii)
faithfully answering the question. As implicit questions are sparse in prior
benchmarks, we introduce a principled method for generating diverse questions.
Experiments show superior performance over a suite of baselines.
|
[
-0.14617837965488434,
-1.0882495641708374,
1.0471279621124268,
0.7272337079048157,
-0.2221057415008545,
0.0516764335334301,
0.20281752943992615,
-0.598163366317749,
0.007437298074364662,
-0.03142740949988365,
-0.9281149506568909,
-0.30551818013191223,
-0.08491573482751846,
0.2133224755525589,
-0.18812784552574158,
0.9035619497299194,
-0.18474970757961273,
0.1105944812297821,
-0.37706106901168823,
-0.41888102889060974,
-0.3772387206554413,
-0.5137488842010498,
-0.5004281401634216,
-0.34196653962135315,
0.5353356599807739,
0.2773727774620056,
0.7832821011543274,
0.5891093015670776,
0.14153069257736206,
0.21954557299613953,
0.07579640299081802,
0.28766268491744995,
-0.19776834547519684,
0.3347504734992981,
-0.21919973194599152,
-0.30102354288101196,
-0.1293501853942871,
0.02221786603331566,
0.4512138366699219,
0.8617206811904907,
-0.10368566960096359,
0.4644613564014435,
-0.34523719549179077,
0.028278911486268044,
-0.8305028080940247,
-0.1755320280790329,
-0.7059670686721802,
0.33026576042175293,
-0.03205076977610588,
-0.5324585437774658,
-0.16807247698307037,
-0.7711456418037415,
0.2571091055870056,
-0.8927827477455139,
0.27349376678466797,
-0.2748177945613861,
1.1423197984695435,
0.43844151496887207,
-0.4534837603569031,
-0.016576388850808144,
-1.063942790031433,
0.6183086037635803,
-0.4337398111820221,
0.23668722808361053,
0.40711766481399536,
0.5773345828056335,
0.14157213270664215,
-0.8897782564163208,
-0.6428669691085815,
-0.004702656529843807,
0.119035504758358,
0.11844180524349213,
-0.02954939380288124,
-0.5019187927246094,
0.2569850981235504,
0.013325443491339684,
-0.670539915561676,
-0.2577194571495056,
-0.048921991139650345,
-0.29111239314079285,
0.235846608877182,
0.3812999427318573,
0.40798982977867126,
-0.06687618792057037,
-0.32929864525794983,
0.18922710418701172,
-0.41214519739151,
0.03503314033150673,
0.20074518024921417,
-0.09544059634208679,
0.20779269933700562,
0.5851587653160095,
-0.28482961654663086,
0.39334994554519653,
0.33119484782218933,
0.11829504370689392,
-0.17567279934883118,
-0.5014739036560059,
0.04270146042108536,
-0.023776359856128693,
0.39840462803840637,
0.09991653263568878,
-0.026362063363194466,
-0.5335651636123657,
0.20659948885440826,
0.2177421748638153,
0.14566011726856232,
-0.7532885074615479,
0.1107628121972084,
0.621235191822052,
-0.10596393048763275,
0.11363935470581055,
-0.2542611360549927,
-0.8410393595695496,
-0.03290115296840668,
-0.22447197139263153,
0.615968644618988,
-0.3706667423248291,
-0.09455797076225281,
-0.1779496967792511,
-0.36960482597351074,
0.36967360973358154,
0.4600163996219635,
-0.42658668756484985,
0.3923056423664093,
0.47953498363494873,
0.5068661570549011,
0.1946457177400589,
-0.17038463056087494,
-0.9429816007614136,
0.3869394063949585,
-0.3230745196342468,
0.7169637084007263,
-0.6245737075805664,
-0.10709424316883087,
-0.034402258694171906,
-0.07735418528318405,
0.08413351327180862,
-0.2021174430847168,
0.1949976682662964,
-1.1148229837417603,
0.7012050747871399,
-0.37147215008735657,
-0.3978405296802521,
0.30257952213287354,
0.4297313690185547,
-0.4376717805862427,
0.8481739163398743,
0.09087484329938889,
-0.5547599196434021,
0.2523394525051117,
-0.30169910192489624,
-0.21548180282115936,
-0.09449348598718643,
-0.37324395775794983,
-0.223993718624115,
-0.2440965324640274,
0.5606492757797241,
0.23707237839698792,
-0.13442757725715637,
0.3915744423866272,
-0.39917221665382385,
-0.23205290734767914,
0.21438005566596985,
-0.4772239029407501,
0.795415461063385,
0.43851858377456665,
-0.42180708050727844,
-0.4150567650794983,
-0.6582178473472595,
0.34353509545326233,
0.16530366241931915,
-0.20724442601203918,
-0.3635176718235016,
0.18211866915225983,
0.017431866377592087,
0.1595780849456787,
0.5124725103378296,
-0.8186584711074829,
0.15572698414325714,
-0.07642296701669693,
0.399872750043869,
0.6411576867103577,
0.34089869260787964,
0.3874460756778717,
-0.2581356167793274,
0.4736191928386688,
-0.050209999084472656,
0.5075292587280273,
0.14449402689933777,
-0.4258192479610443,
-0.26773303747177124,
0.26686468720436096,
-0.019701680168509483,
0.6974934935569763,
-0.9366447329521179,
-0.10426391661167145,
-0.40537121891975403,
-0.41130495071411133,
-0.1348564475774765,
-0.13000336289405823,
0.39248594641685486,
0.6005396842956543,
0.6571728587150574,
0.17298837006092072,
-0.420969158411026,
-0.7321392297744751,
-0.18622048199176788,
-0.4613152742385864,
-0.18307238817214966,
0.3879650831222534,
0.385976105928421,
0.07357914745807648,
1.0566915273666382,
-0.6795148253440857,
0.23788784444332123,
0.3252706229686737,
0.45727917551994324,
0.09083665162324905,
0.34519004821777344,
0.4105169475078583,
-1.0118197202682495,
-0.17935027182102203,
-0.09430091828107834,
-1.0114974975585938,
-0.12307973951101303,
-0.2657186985015869,
-0.10665401071310043,
0.13654132187366486,
0.6284030079841614,
-0.3911203145980835,
0.20863574743270874,
0.5473763942718506,
-0.7050600647926331,
0.32268255949020386,
0.040468715131282806,
0.20682838559150696,
-1.0038204193115234,
0.11026119440793991,
-0.3305661678314209,
-0.17331069707870483,
-0.44410771131515503,
-0.1132931336760521,
0.038345225155353546,
-0.26698005199432373,
-0.438222736120224,
0.7698681354522705,
-0.19696691632270813,
0.177149698138237,
0.10757600516080856,
-0.11394326388835907,
0.31903356313705444,
0.5472462177276611,
0.05560072511434555,
0.6984108090400696,
-0.1791917085647583,
-0.6537713408470154,
0.016052573919296265,
0.328271746635437,
0.02318090945482254,
0.598965048789978,
-0.9518604874610901,
0.4434797465801239,
-0.27561986446380615,
0.19825050234794617,
-0.5608664751052856,
-0.1524442583322525,
0.20350001752376556,
-0.5372483730316162,
0.04522949829697609,
-0.3128117024898529,
-0.21008175611495972,
-0.15085013210773468,
0.036639709025621414,
0.69255530834198,
0.3449690639972687,
-0.5505245327949524,
1.040073037147522,
-0.08429542928934097,
-0.3204731047153473,
-0.9666006565093994,
-0.5230926275253296,
0.03157451003789902,
0.11569293588399887,
-0.7806177735328674,
0.5781287550926208,
-0.28445008397102356,
-0.483489453792572,
0.555383026599884,
-0.6148213148117065,
-0.6926468014717102,
0.045123085379600525,
0.07137751579284668,
0.2844512164592743,
-0.397455632686615,
0.1494896113872528,
0.1522887945175171,
0.2879803776741028,
0.03929391875863075,
-0.43396157026290894,
0.3887885510921478,
-0.08747650682926178,
-0.44521069526672363,
-0.3086599111557007,
0.7221649289131165,
0.6131828427314758,
-0.18786229193210602,
0.5453838109970093,
0.7001329064369202,
-0.5317437648773193,
-0.022417644038796425,
-0.7957667112350464,
-0.14679822325706482,
-0.4155571758747101,
-0.025475241243839264,
-0.33384913206100464,
-1.023067831993103,
0.6178236603736877,
0.49955540895462036,
0.2515990734100342,
0.49467676877975464,
0.4463745057582855,
-0.3054388165473938,
0.9656078219413757,
0.299030601978302,
0.14244148135185242,
0.3723498582839966,
0.19311602413654327,
-0.333371102809906,
-0.26763588190078735,
-0.5738046169281006,
-0.762905478477478,
0.0067627280950546265,
-0.2515639066696167,
-0.2861139178276062,
0.6437988877296448,
0.08389221131801605,
-0.5189592838287354,
-0.11328065395355225,
-0.2033476084470749,
0.243343785405159,
0.6008458733558655,
0.3448501527309418,
0.3074744641780853,
-0.24751953780651093,
0.07844652235507965,
0.12766170501708984,
-0.8568292260169983,
-0.4697917401790619,
0.9020201563835144,
0.2547651529312134,
0.6205314993858337,
0.33380958437919617,
0.3221362233161926,
0.22071751952171326,
0.15304705500602722,
-0.06353587657213211,
0.3171079158782959,
0.09557469934225082,
-1.0418733358383179,
-0.5636551976203918,
-0.5816748738288879,
-1.0263928174972534,
0.01572268269956112,
-0.26971784234046936,
-0.4702267646789551,
0.5072410106658936,
0.14444278180599213,
-0.8164052963256836,
0.13518330454826355,
-0.7245032787322998,
0.7338197231292725,
-0.17569276690483093,
-0.7548552751541138,
0.04857277870178223,
-0.9035914540290833,
0.15868516266345978,
0.16250766813755035,
-0.23417003452777863,
-0.3748987019062042,
-0.2031274437904358,
0.6774523854255676,
-0.6092833876609802,
0.5723108649253845,
-0.30029821395874023,
0.24948400259017944,
0.412600576877594,
0.14997579157352448,
0.469046026468277,
0.7002266049385071,
0.1367965191602707,
-0.10787075012922287,
0.7614715695381165,
-0.9211432337760925,
-0.91009521484375,
0.5302607417106628,
-0.9715245962142944,
-0.5656200647354126,
-0.646266758441925,
-0.6230127215385437,
-0.6219903230667114,
-0.01686928980052471,
0.12509730458259583,
0.6417049765586853,
-0.43033385276794434,
-0.033850740641355515,
0.8958339691162109,
-0.3481665551662445,
0.4232036769390106,
0.8585562705993652,
0.10876684635877609,
-0.15495790541172028,
0.5484315752983093,
-0.03101028874516487,
0.15656711161136627,
0.6664665937423706,
0.3186269998550415,
-0.5265969634056091,
-0.4561987817287445,
-0.42237451672554016,
0.14371922612190247,
-0.5257989168167114,
-0.05781697854399681,
-0.974522590637207,
-0.20531439781188965,
-0.6533462405204773,
0.11227051913738251,
-0.2314123660326004,
-0.5185226202011108,
-0.3487647473812103,
0.30029815435409546,
0.35696879029273987,
0.2753508388996124,
0.05154072120785713,
-0.2921038568019867,
-1.0442463159561157,
0.9365628361701965,
1.1689841747283936,
0.31273746490478516,
-0.386309951543808,
-0.23426590859889984,
0.1526527851819992,
-0.013158108107745647,
0.0544157475233078,
-0.8968258500099182,
0.02544936165213585,
0.13563837110996246,
0.6018081903457642,
0.08640359342098236,
0.1476767361164093,
0.6761629581451416,
-0.6590907573699951,
0.9152787327766418,
-0.13423927128314972,
-0.7784214615821838,
0.6124802231788635,
-0.46408164501190186,
0.6178792119026184,
0.7127501964569092,
0.5619677901268005,
-0.5745879411697388,
-0.4004746675491333,
-0.6300172209739685,
-0.6330471634864807,
0.37519577145576477,
0.35004258155822754,
0.07384564727544785,
-0.11097612977027893,
0.5354893207550049,
0.14383070170879364,
0.13074304163455963,
-0.4149773418903351,
-0.21490295231342316,
-0.602644145488739,
-0.010529168881475925,
0.17824487388134003,
-0.25018805265426636,
-0.337990939617157,
-0.11614939570426941,
0.5157153010368347,
-0.240309476852417,
0.3975047469139099,
0.6529442667961121,
-0.17017421126365662,
-0.22436180710792542,
0.5822253823280334,
0.5050494074821472,
0.9292894601821899,
-0.4676693081855774,
0.16468378901481628,
0.222507044672966,
-0.5201389789581299,
0.4057815372943878,
0.4305587112903595,
-0.45478081703186035,
0.09470492601394653,
0.37102726101875305,
0.2986898720264435,
-0.23661960661411285,
-0.4157331883907318,
0.4030330777168274,
-0.3500522971153259,
0.0013734266394749284,
-0.46565431356430054,
-0.2623053789138794,
-0.06439786404371262,
0.44816192984580994,
0.6519878506660461,
-0.1107882708311081,
-0.09657464176416397,
-0.7164968848228455,
0.15780234336853027,
0.2286452203989029,
-0.45235371589660645,
-0.24731384217739105,
0.9227167367935181,
0.09746982902288437,
0.10041628777980804,
0.7409387230873108,
0.022767113521695137,
-0.3300088047981262,
0.8070104122161865,
0.32086288928985596,
0.641136109828949,
-0.14957834780216217,
0.3999405801296234,
0.18593068420886993,
0.28000420331954956,
0.01148474495857954,
0.8197558522224426,
0.10756342858076096,
-0.6934016346931458,
-0.7366827726364136,
-0.5561857223510742,
-0.5151956677436829,
0.1922139823436737,
-0.6079901456832886,
-0.4120907485485077,
-0.6464403867721558,
-0.07160604745149612,
0.022188739851117134,
0.058682601898908615,
-0.8821542263031006,
0.45204460620880127,
0.011776699684560299,
0.9601026177406311,
-0.7431051731109619,
0.4634941816329956,
0.5657917261123657,
-0.6592805981636047,
-0.814577579498291,
0.042523182928562164,
-0.2014733999967575,
-0.753993809223175,
0.5783081650733948,
-0.45817890763282776,
-0.021433070302009583,
-0.08791118115186691,
-0.8153326511383057,
-0.7064226865768433,
1.1048470735549927,
0.46684300899505615,
-0.08118772506713867,
-0.31101250648498535,
0.05002541467547417,
0.6847894787788391,
0.17105136811733246,
0.07547280937433243,
0.3307344317436218,
0.6342574954032898,
-0.03084295243024826,
-0.6454405784606934,
0.0985553115606308,
-0.6499947905540466,
-0.33042994141578674,
-0.059340186417102814,
-0.45504072308540344,
0.8169617652893066,
-0.043301772326231,
-0.45309722423553467,
0.31774628162384033,
1.0010377168655396,
0.1255512833595276,
0.8297935128211975,
0.5666425824165344,
0.4838240146636963,
0.7378018498420715,
-0.2927171289920807,
1.159837007522583,
0.06335292011499405,
-0.08771979808807373,
1.3517693281173706,
-0.17700864374637604,
0.4802313446998596,
0.7636422514915466,
-0.1261693239212036,
0.709777295589447,
0.6208048462867737,
0.20682696998119354,
0.33549049496650696,
-0.12638089060783386,
-0.3735955059528351,
-0.6281775832176208,
-0.48799818754196167,
-0.6979095935821533,
0.20752747356891632,
0.055537961423397064,
0.12774603068828583,
-0.40385007858276367,
-0.21771575510501862,
0.0034860754385590553,
0.2747077941894531,
-0.25595682859420776,
0.5102878212928772,
-0.19922073185443878,
-0.9310607314109802,
0.1705029010772705,
-0.16719333827495575,
0.11706046760082245,
-0.8565106391906738,
-0.14328370988368988,
-0.5036844611167908,
-0.19472147524356842,
0.03444129601120949,
-0.7328135967254639,
0.246779665350914,
-0.04151974990963936,
-0.42998743057250977,
-0.18400290608406067,
0.3914174735546112,
-0.32526102662086487,
-0.32868215441703796,
-0.08196262270212173,
1.0166372060775757,
-0.29246896505355835,
-0.18979059159755707,
-0.44788357615470886,
-0.29503104090690613,
-0.5492704510688782,
-0.15044865012168884,
-0.005822489969432354,
0.7270925641059875,
-0.25907909870147705,
0.7904837131500244,
0.45281079411506653,
-0.01024011243134737,
0.37001875042915344,
-0.0400737039744854,
0.6979148983955383,
-0.5018602609634399,
-0.5178614854812622,
-0.44150736927986145,
0.14639940857887268,
-0.11035101115703583,
-0.37301772832870483,
0.7665894627571106,
0.31746649742126465,
0.4934636950492859,
0.17640893161296844,
0.5833236575126648,
-0.15679197013378143,
0.4385574758052826,
-0.6699743270874023,
0.3287612795829773,
-0.7782528400421143,
0.09512049704790115,
-0.19625543057918549,
-0.7691357731819153,
-0.08103062212467194,
-0.11506263166666031,
-0.1973060518503189,
-0.05303218960762024,
0.9346325993537903,
0.4888302683830261,
0.11204256862401962,
0.18640069663524628,
0.031217167153954506,
0.014451582916080952,
0.22890318930149078,
0.9463136792182922,
1.2478952407836914,
-0.28720444440841675,
0.97420734167099,
-0.4093813896179199,
0.16044388711452484,
0.04059838131070137,
-0.8218162655830383,
-0.5950286388397217,
-0.5761288404464722,
-0.3365858197212219,
-0.6691368818283081,
0.503771185874939,
0.9314101338386536,
0.5877304673194885,
-0.7856680154800415,
0.3293735682964325,
0.283769816160202,
0.11627637594938278,
-0.4491519033908844,
-0.179384246468544,
0.5122437477111816,
-0.25399672985076904,
-0.6805404424667358,
0.40727758407592773,
0.04908633232116699,
0.023620648309588432,
-0.13809165358543396,
0.16150958836078644,
-0.4661109149456024,
0.12298642098903656,
0.4449928104877472,
0.7228637933731079,
-0.34331071376800537,
-0.7012801170349121,
0.49270594120025635,
-0.2576195001602173,
-0.12661685049533844,
0.9059600234031677,
-0.7782785892486572,
0.27753934264183044,
0.630968451499939,
0.9694530367851257,
0.6481755971908569,
0.11275699734687805,
0.7234838604927063,
-0.826248288154602,
-0.19845134019851685,
0.7758058309555054,
0.028221778571605682,
0.008912178687751293,
-0.5088040232658386,
0.4999898672103882,
0.3471275269985199,
-0.3974737524986267,
-0.4633750915527344,
0.21721190214157104,
-1.2314999103546143,
-0.7281694412231445,
1.1437242031097412,
0.062279775738716125,
-0.2304716259241104,
-0.758027195930481,
0.33195772767066956,
0.4423098862171173,
-0.21331697702407837,
0.8919299244880676,
0.5634893178939819,
-0.07014402747154236,
0.17026717960834503,
-0.38689565658569336,
0.3256462514400482,
0.6354455947875977,
-0.9321434497833252,
-0.46542295813560486,
0.7119668126106262,
0.45317721366882324,
0.2783987820148468,
0.8708000183105469,
-0.31654176115989685,
0.7847055792808533,
0.020488718524575233,
-0.2878322899341583,
-0.28534337878227234,
-0.5209237933158875,
-0.1074814572930336,
0.7478227019309998,
-0.2149674892425537,
-0.12844403088092804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15390v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15390v2
|
Explorations of Self-Repair in Language Models
| 2024-02-23T15:42:12 | 2024-05-26T20:47:41 |
Cody Rushing, Neel Nanda
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Prior interpretability research studying narrow distributions has
preliminarily identified self-repair, a phenomena where if components in large
language models are ablated, later components will change their behavior to
compensate. Our work builds off this past literature, demonstrating that
self-repair exists on a variety of models families and sizes when ablating
individual attention heads on the full training distribution. We further show
that on the full training distribution self-repair is imperfect, as the
original direct effect of the head is not fully restored, and noisy, since the
degree of self-repair varies significantly across different prompts (sometimes
overcorrecting beyond the original effect). We highlight two different
mechanisms that contribute to self-repair, including changes in the final
LayerNorm scaling factor and sparse sets of neurons implementing Anti-Erasure.
We additionally discuss the implications of these results for interpretability
practitioners and close with a more speculative discussion on the mystery of
why self-repair occurs in these models at all, highlighting evidence for the
Iterative Inference hypothesis in language models, a framework that predicts
self-repair.
|
[
-0.011142376810312271,
-0.6371119022369385,
0.7312326431274414,
0.2440813183784485,
0.27178606390953064,
-0.2718687057495117,
-0.31129786372184753,
-0.5360572338104248,
0.4814356565475464,
0.6940626502037048,
-0.6976155042648315,
0.27451375126838684,
-0.533419668674469,
0.13526666164398193,
-0.6718103289604187,
1.1230707168579102,
-0.03711983188986778,
-0.26062583923339844,
-0.2025517225265503,
-0.33719220757484436,
-0.4028795659542084,
-0.45713740587234497,
-0.9089267253875732,
-0.2011580616235733,
0.64217609167099,
0.48703819513320923,
0.5363304018974304,
1.0973247289657593,
0.35821691155433655,
0.44684940576553345,
-0.01165027730166912,
-0.4663979113101959,
-0.6044984459877014,
0.3569004237651825,
-0.4933967888355255,
-0.5674038529396057,
-0.5858229994773865,
-0.016559338197112083,
0.7931539416313171,
0.8526840806007385,
-0.25321757793426514,
-0.05239921808242798,
0.33768028020858765,
0.852940559387207,
-0.5322509407997131,
-0.06788372248411179,
-0.52360999584198,
-0.18226957321166992,
-0.1244373768568039,
-0.1226329356431961,
-0.3454015851020813,
0.2703910768032074,
0.10464411228895187,
-0.24861836433410645,
0.6018913388252258,
-0.0446443147957325,
0.18520382046699524,
0.6141995787620544,
-0.11497074365615845,
-0.1843489706516266,
-0.9362381100654602,
0.7795115113258362,
-0.8278088569641113,
0.2348744124174118,
0.5342199206352234,
0.23148158192634583,
-0.04619318246841431,
-0.6297487616539001,
-0.3007126450538635,
0.05763979256153107,
-0.11848463863134384,
0.058886922895908356,
-0.29954856634140015,
0.06923181563615799,
0.31197109818458557,
0.6951152086257935,
-0.4860338568687439,
0.16302557289600372,
-0.5053880214691162,
-0.20375919342041016,
0.4367188513278961,
0.23249898850917816,
0.42532435059547424,
0.034962523728609085,
-0.1574198454618454,
0.13586241006851196,
-0.6478955745697021,
-0.17325182259082794,
0.6418083906173706,
0.19964353740215302,
-0.052076421678066254,
0.35663485527038574,
-0.29887938499450684,
0.6216274499893188,
0.061477676033973694,
0.01814902201294899,
0.0018283323151990771,
-0.22004660964012146,
-0.3468782603740692,
0.10853599011898041,
0.7072036862373352,
0.06640051305294037,
0.3756282329559326,
-0.3144890069961548,
-0.03508006036281586,
-0.34150826930999756,
0.4235111474990845,
-0.5734250545501709,
-0.5165290236473083,
0.38762274384498596,
-0.5680840611457825,
-0.19780251383781433,
-0.3320204019546509,
-0.24568995833396912,
-0.4446409046649933,
-0.24094337224960327,
0.37219899892807007,
-0.3452906012535095,
-0.790570855140686,
0.3299049139022827,
0.01694970577955246,
-0.20114590227603912,
0.26144224405288696,
-1.2933001518249512,
0.06824399530887604,
0.2723328769207001,
0.6888664364814758,
-0.019597487524151802,
-0.8575628399848938,
0.027610022574663162,
0.011780710890889168,
-0.3239705562591553,
1.0478638410568237,
-0.12899836897850037,
-0.016657890751957893,
-0.17021138966083527,
0.3697754740715027,
-0.29789334535598755,
-0.5661574602127075,
0.4309585690498352,
-0.06470062583684921,
-0.07538554072380066,
-0.5039834976196289,
-0.4368007481098175,
-0.07266263663768768,
0.07865871489048004,
-0.5321156978607178,
0.4295744001865387,
0.2168940007686615,
-0.9516075253486633,
-0.023642782121896744,
-0.2461881786584854,
-0.33302929997444153,
-0.3599551022052765,
0.30594030022621155,
-0.4687209725379944,
0.49634140729904175,
-0.1971651315689087,
0.3327605426311493,
0.1123366579413414,
-0.1839834302663803,
-0.6241143345832825,
-0.16715353727340698,
0.3271039128303528,
-0.4814073443412781,
0.8433353900909424,
0.0048375483602285385,
-0.30356475710868835,
0.0868620052933693,
-0.8086498379707336,
-0.18797245621681213,
0.2523171901702881,
0.1429942101240158,
-0.42606157064437866,
0.14039504528045654,
-0.33555737137794495,
0.2602204978466034,
0.14797115325927734,
-0.6667022109031677,
0.3219042122364044,
-0.6067360043525696,
0.7026338577270508,
0.9667258858680725,
0.11381476372480392,
0.5634108781814575,
-0.09585336595773697,
0.4615895748138428,
0.2187337428331375,
0.1314728707075119,
-0.5048975944519043,
-0.09320361912250519,
-0.9358468651771545,
-0.2782157063484192,
0.13444533944129944,
-0.017229905351996422,
-0.3801116645336151,
-0.019403846934437752,
-0.008964202366769314,
-0.2738976776599884,
-0.6758019328117371,
0.2181776911020279,
0.3414779305458069,
0.6400575041770935,
0.4215085208415985,
-0.43144112825393677,
-0.6056405305862427,
-1.1720753908157349,
-0.494425505399704,
-0.13942696154117584,
0.19482451677322388,
-0.11176913231611252,
0.27930358052253723,
-0.5341897010803223,
0.8324625492095947,
-0.48612844944000244,
-0.49408984184265137,
-0.14931659400463104,
0.0715116560459137,
-0.15017959475517273,
0.6001463532447815,
0.558519721031189,
0.03768807649612427,
-0.1944810152053833,
-0.35294678807258606,
-0.6323713660240173,
-0.13224339485168457,
-0.233917236328125,
0.06572850048542023,
0.1367875337600708,
0.682457447052002,
-0.31936386227607727,
0.47393372654914856,
0.6294675469398499,
-0.4525202512741089,
0.5984312295913696,
-0.4874977171421051,
-0.017626794055104256,
-0.6130246520042419,
-0.010250277817249298,
-0.24454545974731445,
-0.24260543286800385,
-0.8011156320571899,
-0.14147020876407623,
-0.0651121735572815,
0.46956440806388855,
-0.09141596406698227,
0.6427397727966309,
-0.5099459290504456,
-0.3406708836555481,
-0.8922449350357056,
0.026743002235889435,
-0.21831050515174866,
0.378885954618454,
-0.11531946808099747,
0.46439069509506226,
0.7152762413024902,
-0.4665166139602661,
-0.08101947605609894,
0.1858573853969574,
-0.048698317259550095,
0.523964524269104,
-0.8953967094421387,
0.21254470944404602,
-0.48878318071365356,
-0.005837576929479837,
-1.3754743337631226,
-0.29528990387916565,
0.3166816532611847,
-0.2774365544319153,
0.3082208037376404,
-0.1398620903491974,
-0.20099517703056335,
-0.11335646361112595,
-0.09383916854858398,
0.6157335638999939,
0.29703807830810547,
-0.6526235342025757,
0.3968944251537323,
0.20734886825084686,
-0.3253752589225769,
-0.5943107008934021,
-0.7114980816841125,
-0.01570749096572399,
-0.1721905916929245,
-0.5452964901924133,
-0.221317321062088,
-0.4824647307395935,
-0.5220800042152405,
0.1144997850060463,
-0.24077829718589783,
-0.22857527434825897,
0.46886253356933594,
0.22926141321659088,
-0.2644292414188385,
-0.3396304249763489,
0.16989096999168396,
0.043490175157785416,
-0.15998193621635437,
0.2186874896287918,
-0.03711569309234619,
0.37786251306533813,
-0.1113654300570488,
-0.4049495458602905,
-0.026826485991477966,
0.10732119530439377,
0.4177752137184143,
-0.22566619515419006,
0.6565484404563904,
0.27225571870803833,
-0.25759926438331604,
-0.1894344538450241,
-0.7168387770652771,
-0.29261597990989685,
-0.5032979846000671,
0.2569600045681,
-0.391420841217041,
-0.6548256278038025,
0.6767646074295044,
0.3754337728023529,
-0.0731007307767868,
0.8872939348220825,
0.5058919191360474,
-0.3363852798938751,
1.0199326276779175,
0.8315787315368652,
-0.019673634320497513,
0.3888782560825348,
-0.15702372789382935,
0.10230860859155655,
-0.8819736242294312,
0.29685622453689575,
-0.43134790658950806,
-0.037676986306905746,
-0.34039875864982605,
0.06116657331585884,
-0.022867118939757347,
0.17255061864852905,
0.004942434839904308,
0.1970263123512268,
-0.4880627691745758,
0.4770243763923645,
0.41681918501853943,
0.1550721377134323,
0.3920673131942749,
-0.16962122917175293,
0.4440654516220093,
-0.031214505434036255,
-0.5688525438308716,
-0.08528989553451538,
0.8675462007522583,
0.6315116882324219,
0.8279390931129456,
0.012283840216696262,
0.6934003829956055,
-0.03421955183148384,
0.5953949093818665,
-0.7102034091949463,
0.1544332206249237,
0.018976235762238503,
-0.719126284122467,
-0.6577566862106323,
-0.2839341163635254,
-1.188966155052185,
0.2095351219177246,
0.20579290390014648,
-0.8594666123390198,
0.2862338125705719,
0.6239250898361206,
-0.32286298274993896,
0.2002376914024353,
-0.6385292410850525,
1.1763908863067627,
-0.0881897360086441,
-0.12770862877368927,
-0.30451834201812744,
-0.6738981604576111,
0.48030200600624084,
-0.10104247182607651,
0.28755247592926025,
-0.12998701632022858,
0.37034690380096436,
0.681573748588562,
-0.20509856939315796,
0.9924637079238892,
-0.1691439151763916,
-0.32477447390556335,
0.2028370350599289,
0.35409149527549744,
0.1742645502090454,
-0.08927860856056213,
0.32003602385520935,
0.14173802733421326,
0.20311309397220612,
-0.5078673958778381,
-0.7042179107666016,
0.6033677458763123,
-0.7434855699539185,
-0.7606737613677979,
-0.38034912943840027,
-0.7137256860733032,
-0.2342468947172165,
0.36878761649131775,
0.17423668503761292,
0.5121955871582031,
-0.1152709573507309,
0.14186614751815796,
0.704436719417572,
-0.013763254508376122,
0.6236488819122314,
0.6830012798309326,
-0.15453480184078217,
-0.12848414480686188,
0.8571357131004333,
0.25709617137908936,
0.46482858061790466,
-0.1366713047027588,
0.23955655097961426,
-0.005020263604819775,
-0.6603018641471863,
-0.261240154504776,
0.5885648727416992,
-0.6875213980674744,
0.1267460137605667,
-0.7316061854362488,
-0.16798342764377594,
-0.39686617255210876,
0.0549706369638443,
-0.69670170545578,
-0.6183688640594482,
-0.2443072348833084,
-0.15435098111629486,
0.04260563850402832,
1.0610307455062866,
-0.46362781524658203,
0.3487808108329773,
-0.519916296005249,
0.14546166360378265,
0.3541792929172516,
0.5642912983894348,
0.238631010055542,
-0.7406573295593262,
-0.5243401527404785,
0.15410420298576355,
0.033262692391872406,
-0.6201289296150208,
0.3220365047454834,
0.16465020179748535,
0.4009031057357788,
0.3708019256591797,
-0.12421508878469467,
0.7073500752449036,
-0.8196364045143127,
0.5239126682281494,
0.15944063663482666,
-0.7462896704673767,
0.368586003780365,
-0.33394497632980347,
0.4942595064640045,
0.36039939522743225,
0.06306814402341843,
-0.6971786618232727,
-0.8214834928512573,
-0.9336371421813965,
-0.6911752223968506,
0.5942753553390503,
-0.1499529629945755,
0.15097551047801971,
-0.1818426549434662,
0.6321493983268738,
0.30478113889694214,
-0.19838201999664307,
-0.5314459800720215,
-0.3598196804523468,
-0.5256205797195435,
-0.36177751421928406,
-0.5692437291145325,
-0.7817438840866089,
-0.1568065583705902,
-0.02387586608529091,
0.5635494589805603,
-0.3485141694545746,
0.4460223615169525,
0.5378360152244568,
-0.36258816719055176,
-0.4530084729194641,
0.127762109041214,
0.7162085771560669,
0.8116567134857178,
-0.1669541895389557,
0.05949826166033745,
-0.16565170884132385,
-0.22011081874370575,
0.028720930218696594,
-0.03537974879145622,
0.02363751456141472,
-0.29685503244400024,
0.6480530500411987,
0.7608855962753296,
0.23885303735733032,
-0.4767463803291321,
0.5273798108100891,
-0.1640060693025589,
0.002504013478755951,
-0.4967226982116699,
0.15472766757011414,
0.045239463448524475,
0.2773837149143219,
0.21771787106990814,
0.27635785937309265,
0.518904447555542,
-0.8918879628181458,
0.13370051980018616,
0.38282766938209534,
-0.526486873626709,
-0.8326573371887207,
0.7694447040557861,
-0.24661298096179962,
-0.1627969890832901,
0.5461023449897766,
0.16301138699054718,
-0.3283500373363495,
0.4697282016277313,
0.512843668460846,
1.0936837196350098,
-0.6429219245910645,
0.13452750444412231,
0.38017764687538147,
0.42950189113616943,
-0.27867600321769714,
0.057869501411914825,
0.16075260937213898,
-0.9171373844146729,
-0.45412513613700867,
-0.3207152187824249,
-0.207085520029068,
0.10819830000400543,
-0.7459980845451355,
-0.38117003440856934,
-0.37056437134742737,
0.13845065236091614,
0.24004237353801727,
-0.6553298830986023,
-0.5317915678024292,
0.44655531644821167,
-0.23798172175884247,
0.5676548480987549,
-0.9230432510375977,
0.6646297574043274,
0.4671112895011902,
-0.48876193165779114,
-0.4823927879333496,
0.27181556820869446,
-0.11511655896902084,
-0.8434401750564575,
0.47782328724861145,
0.024861479178071022,
0.045582663267850876,
0.00641990453004837,
-0.6036629676818848,
-1.1315375566482544,
0.5489658117294312,
0.5204946398735046,
-0.3261011242866516,
-0.168513223528862,
-0.04101972281932831,
0.8305652737617493,
0.06500132381916046,
0.38840389251708984,
0.6043344140052795,
0.11570075899362564,
-0.2931096851825714,
-1.0232523679733276,
0.11672814190387726,
0.19566388428211212,
-0.2658054828643799,
0.09873133897781372,
-0.8308883309364319,
0.8039703369140625,
-0.340869277715683,
0.03731950372457504,
0.15864059329032898,
0.715657114982605,
-0.3620566427707672,
-0.17632423341274261,
0.693255603313446,
0.5562835931777954,
0.4471115171909332,
0.14422918856143951,
1.090833067893982,
-0.29394909739494324,
0.6032204031944275,
1.2971947193145752,
0.19122949242591858,
0.5532082915306091,
0.4216156005859375,
-0.05312173441052437,
0.3407834768295288,
0.38243961334228516,
0.315480500459671,
0.6389144659042358,
-0.010819287039339542,
0.022068185731768608,
-0.11185286939144135,
0.1913130134344101,
-0.12677255272865295,
0.5391281247138977,
0.07284858077764511,
-0.4223990738391876,
-0.15267318487167358,
0.11182700097560883,
-0.12428896129131317,
-0.19478295743465424,
-0.4356464147567749,
0.7400086522102356,
0.20595215260982513,
-0.6491568088531494,
0.5441638231277466,
-0.31300094723701477,
0.1066441684961319,
-0.3517516553401947,
0.06264529377222061,
-0.41493022441864014,
0.5837458372116089,
-0.3149702847003937,
-0.7663532495498657,
0.7507289052009583,
-0.6153023838996887,
-0.5168129801750183,
-0.4219113886356354,
0.8891687393188477,
-0.5115854144096375,
-0.14289841055870056,
0.26565009355545044,
0.5011183023452759,
0.195794016122818,
-0.2531088888645172,
-0.474380761384964,
0.07436695694923401,
0.12640099227428436,
-0.5394067168235779,
0.5639553070068359,
0.5415217876434326,
0.35483887791633606,
0.849162757396698,
0.10800200700759888,
0.09493198245763779,
0.15675774216651917,
0.004078544210642576,
0.5341793894767761,
-0.5668389201164246,
-0.16876044869422913,
-0.8721410036087036,
0.7294676899909973,
0.1553122103214264,
-0.3356030285358429,
0.87177574634552,
0.21362896263599396,
0.7353335618972778,
-0.18132339417934418,
0.7763184309005737,
0.20265138149261475,
0.8334354162216187,
-0.4091477394104004,
0.43048524856567383,
-0.5389522314071655,
-0.0006890989025123417,
-0.26006412506103516,
-0.6970551609992981,
0.07350306957960129,
0.4951418340206146,
-0.23809580504894257,
-0.08969683200120926,
0.8278577923774719,
0.4902069866657257,
-0.061852216720581055,
0.014102738350629807,
0.5068971514701843,
0.9592207074165344,
-0.003281800774857402,
-0.019621172919869423,
0.8122422695159912,
-0.219000905752182,
0.4552399516105652,
-0.4057594835758209,
-0.2774108946323395,
0.030412256717681885,
-0.5338875651359558,
-0.8303437232971191,
-0.7488820552825928,
-0.5736059546470642,
-0.4678608179092407,
0.03268235921859741,
0.46150273084640503,
0.4306957721710205,
-0.766326904296875,
-0.039036862552165985,
-0.049533993005752563,
0.033150359988212585,
-0.43875807523727417,
-0.2139502316713333,
0.3274264931678772,
-0.6704462170600891,
-0.500663161277771,
0.43395280838012695,
0.3162776529788971,
-0.04747866094112396,
-0.5457631945610046,
0.3384377956390381,
0.33795902132987976,
0.0837329775094986,
0.5556721687316895,
0.7807275652885437,
-0.7314813137054443,
-0.7706220149993896,
-0.11390155553817749,
0.08882495760917664,
0.11954264342784882,
0.8200172781944275,
-0.4061644375324249,
0.5640138387680054,
0.21740244328975677,
0.7486810684204102,
0.45713716745376587,
-0.276217520236969,
0.8083751797676086,
-0.751293420791626,
-0.057012710720300674,
-0.008367855101823807,
0.847983717918396,
0.4620843529701233,
-0.4425773322582245,
0.5933084487915039,
0.25177276134490967,
-0.8282389640808105,
-0.9279661178588867,
0.41932395100593567,
-0.644214928150177,
-0.3459538519382477,
1.1943936347961426,
-0.33504995703697205,
-0.2540638744831085,
-0.058151308447122574,
-0.25323396921157837,
0.041966717690229416,
0.2976105213165283,
0.8394935131072998,
0.9069140553474426,
-0.2666393518447876,
-0.4983467757701874,
-0.5504838824272156,
0.4515934884548187,
0.5102784633636475,
-0.41642674803733826,
0.3725377917289734,
0.4423319697380066,
0.8814536929130554,
0.15220369398593903,
1.0191869735717773,
0.1816481053829193,
0.1646450310945511,
-0.0644073411822319,
0.20550435781478882,
0.30757513642311096,
-0.46028608083724976,
-0.6735261678695679,
-0.09514079242944717,
0.42107096314430237,
0.179526686668396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15370v1
|
Dual Encoder: Exploiting the Potential of Syntactic and Semantic for Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction
| 2024-02-23T15:07:13 | 2024-02-23T15:07:13 |
Xiaowei Zhao, Yong Zhou, Xiujuan Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Aspect Sentiment Triple Extraction (ASTE) is an emerging task in fine-grained
sentiment analysis. Recent studies have employed Graph Neural Networks (GNN) to
model the syntax-semantic relationships inherent in triplet elements. However,
they have yet to fully tap into the vast potential of syntactic and semantic
information within the ASTE task. In this work, we propose a \emph{Dual
Encoder: Exploiting the potential of Syntactic and Semantic} model (D2E2S),
which maximizes the syntactic and semantic relationships among words.
Specifically, our model utilizes a dual-channel encoder with a BERT channel to
capture semantic information, and an enhanced LSTM channel for comprehensive
syntactic information capture. Subsequently, we introduce the heterogeneous
feature interaction module to capture intricate interactions between dependency
syntax and attention semantics, and to dynamically select vital nodes. We
leverage the synergy of these modules to harness the significant potential of
syntactic and semantic information in ASTE tasks. Testing on public benchmarks,
our D2E2S model surpasses the current state-of-the-art(SOTA), demonstrating its
effectiveness.
|
[
-0.31209108233451843,
-0.6678686738014221,
0.6240583062171936,
0.32292425632476807,
-0.36949440836906433,
0.206179678440094,
-0.2738995850086212,
-0.5673770904541016,
0.39570727944374084,
0.4595775604248047,
-0.5051276087760925,
-0.35468465089797974,
-0.7006691694259644,
0.022769659757614136,
-0.22502660751342773,
1.0998246669769287,
-0.18295861780643463,
0.11788611859083176,
-0.13395512104034424,
-0.08928117156028748,
-0.19549226760864258,
-0.5885677337646484,
-0.6549258828163147,
-0.19727414846420288,
0.599646806716919,
0.2918802499771118,
0.5578396320343018,
-0.018435468897223473,
0.47294485569000244,
0.21129615604877472,
-0.08915285766124725,
0.05908903107047081,
-0.06899325549602509,
0.28260141611099243,
-0.0696486383676529,
-0.2952648997306824,
-0.5697125196456909,
-0.05564720556139946,
0.6456927061080933,
0.5767658948898315,
0.27043572068214417,
0.09839656949043274,
0.4390360713005066,
0.5313510894775391,
-0.28391534090042114,
0.4763313829898834,
-0.5673643946647644,
0.006879149004817009,
0.008674834854900837,
0.024004893377423286,
-0.11191905289888382,
-0.3029601573944092,
0.0077194455079734325,
-0.06880810856819153,
0.06693815439939499,
-0.34017413854599,
1.1070612668991089,
0.29376205801963806,
-0.41647985577583313,
-0.025946402922272682,
-0.6362082362174988,
0.305425763130188,
-0.48039963841438293,
0.4949224591255188,
0.09221022576093674,
0.055180687457323074,
0.33728286623954773,
-0.7490458488464355,
-0.7567271590232849,
-0.012308345176279545,
-0.13534753024578094,
0.3111855983734131,
-0.13056902587413788,
0.2329941987991333,
-0.04331565648317337,
0.7198485732078552,
-0.13465715944766998,
0.07774592190980911,
-0.15357153117656708,
-0.19028015434741974,
0.4979006052017212,
-0.0057300785556435585,
0.24790404736995697,
-0.7586237788200378,
-0.5293514728546143,
0.040620338171720505,
-0.42083656787872314,
0.2159222811460495,
0.547663152217865,
0.38698965311050415,
-0.0946139395236969,
0.627760648727417,
0.07416747510433197,
0.2720842957496643,
0.08393064886331558,
0.4263405203819275,
0.28924429416656494,
-0.632744550704956,
-0.07543184608221054,
-0.13616052269935608,
1.0904197692871094,
0.4813821613788605,
-0.26064160466194153,
-0.26758426427841187,
-0.46754130721092224,
0.4235915541648865,
0.33749502897262573,
-0.6421256065368652,
-0.19199174642562866,
0.40425440669059753,
-0.29382213950157166,
-0.34430012106895447,
0.2004455029964447,
-1.2326643466949463,
-0.36112186312675476,
-0.27153435349464417,
0.429749995470047,
-0.43420669436454773,
-0.5638219714164734,
0.09119333326816559,
-0.49036577343940735,
0.13117098808288574,
0.20152410864830017,
-0.7556634545326233,
0.37393561005592346,
0.7721978425979614,
0.852645218372345,
0.016237573698163033,
-0.19691906869411469,
-0.2617378532886505,
0.016857562586665154,
0.18587902188301086,
0.6711179614067078,
-0.49877262115478516,
-0.17285025119781494,
0.1188972219824791,
-0.09682639688253403,
0.05398757755756378,
-0.26127052307128906,
0.43032220005989075,
-0.7477506995201111,
0.04159388318657875,
-0.24312081933021545,
-0.23919227719306946,
-0.45554524660110474,
0.28684136271476746,
-0.8448216915130615,
1.1966298818588257,
0.16858917474746704,
-0.8748294711112976,
0.26194897294044495,
-0.84233158826828,
-0.5358477830886841,
-0.1513935625553131,
-0.47917357087135315,
-0.404926061630249,
0.23300397396087646,
0.005438678897917271,
0.40263497829437256,
-0.3501174747943878,
0.137258380651474,
-0.37193891406059265,
0.19523027539253235,
0.19455105066299438,
-0.35854822397232056,
0.5106212496757507,
-0.19425280392169952,
-0.36401012539863586,
0.17001137137413025,
-0.4566224217414856,
-0.08064118027687073,
0.14278611540794373,
-0.43452188372612,
-0.20442019402980804,
-0.05577422305941582,
0.19654010236263275,
0.495044082403183,
0.5000021457672119,
-0.9895244836807251,
-0.009324186481535435,
-0.5184206366539001,
0.6446735262870789,
0.5018855929374695,
0.03208357095718384,
0.45004069805145264,
0.23629115521907806,
0.2609514892101288,
0.2028406858444214,
-0.14703968167304993,
0.40745818614959717,
-0.36527398228645325,
-0.9115734100341797,
-0.016821281984448433,
0.2904399335384369,
0.46019384264945984,
-0.9504830837249756,
0.7789018750190735,
-0.4601326286792755,
0.17894509434700012,
-0.7809589505195618,
0.06947262585163116,
0.38022327423095703,
0.11014125496149063,
0.38929569721221924,
-0.3368096649646759,
-0.5382720232009888,
-0.9928651452064514,
-0.116731196641922,
-0.1329556107521057,
0.04428960382938385,
0.08593430370092392,
0.4042515456676483,
-0.17970530688762665,
1.1360231637954712,
-0.5396384596824646,
-0.3110823929309845,
-0.6862521767616272,
0.1128569170832634,
0.047311656177043915,
0.16887249052524567,
0.3518419563770294,
-0.9536198377609253,
-0.45108526945114136,
0.04277685657143593,
-0.7761598229408264,
0.05829421430826187,
0.22495681047439575,
-0.1510879248380661,
0.2821879982948303,
0.29586726427078247,
-0.708952784538269,
0.36405885219573975,
0.44945499300956726,
-0.399587482213974,
0.14111477136611938,
-0.014722496271133423,
0.0025801463052630424,
-1.1401596069335938,
-0.13389141857624054,
-0.018869519233703613,
-0.21111655235290527,
-0.5711942911148071,
0.03242241591215134,
0.2871565818786621,
-0.08744446933269501,
-0.08694735914468765,
0.27294397354125977,
-0.5088939666748047,
-0.1347823143005371,
-0.21298357844352722,
0.10602855682373047,
0.3586653470993042,
0.5749388933181763,
0.15711036324501038,
0.4630799889564514,
0.4292203485965729,
-0.18434438109397888,
0.6166893839836121,
0.10664664953947067,
0.06029367446899414,
0.3230074644088745,
-0.49945375323295593,
0.3300549387931824,
-0.16310569643974304,
0.2777414321899414,
-0.7157450914382935,
-0.15409556031227112,
0.37122201919555664,
-0.46626147627830505,
0.6241422891616821,
-0.1069316491484642,
-0.8010021448135376,
-0.7040629386901855,
-0.7015480399131775,
0.12116105109453201,
0.3483665883541107,
-0.632175624370575,
0.7457127571105957,
0.5368507504463196,
-0.2509317398071289,
-0.23810680210590363,
-0.8581660389900208,
0.14668042957782745,
-0.21937912702560425,
-0.7547112703323364,
0.22206096351146698,
0.3201292157173157,
0.04481754079461098,
0.2726069986820221,
-0.2372470498085022,
0.00802431721240282,
-0.0964692085981369,
0.2763524651527405,
0.3255535662174225,
-0.36816009879112244,
0.14342527091503143,
0.043017905205488205,
-0.2921443283557892,
0.2765050530433655,
-0.5377556681632996,
0.6859397888183594,
-0.33797550201416016,
-0.3564733862876892,
-0.4865609407424927,
0.7755064368247986,
0.4069172739982605,
-0.34028783440589905,
0.5485110878944397,
0.6226516962051392,
-0.44402599334716797,
-0.07195106893777847,
-0.5248737335205078,
-0.2529456317424774,
-0.3934475779533386,
0.7458602786064148,
-0.5231504440307617,
-0.9277034997940063,
0.3883504867553711,
0.1548030823469162,
-0.21579058468341827,
0.47167882323265076,
0.39459681510925293,
-0.03923334181308746,
0.9808637499809265,
0.6304025053977966,
-0.13944858312606812,
0.43075481057167053,
-0.4110093414783478,
0.5801999568939209,
-1.211482048034668,
-0.2292439192533493,
-0.11328545212745667,
-0.3722166121006012,
-0.3704467713832855,
-0.5030546188354492,
0.5062440037727356,
0.21072879433631897,
-0.07917807251214981,
0.17892049252986908,
-0.4095875322818756,
0.12216491252183914,
0.5209678411483765,
0.3610262870788574,
0.09167039394378662,
0.1990986317396164,
0.14703057706356049,
-0.05414362996816635,
-0.39042308926582336,
-0.5396604537963867,
0.8420157432556152,
0.6465466022491455,
0.476957768201828,
0.4118518531322479,
0.6680061221122742,
0.040075745433568954,
-0.33948493003845215,
-0.9677689075469971,
0.6197627186775208,
-0.6063861846923828,
-0.13510869443416595,
-0.02998659573495388,
-0.23083749413490295,
-0.590021014213562,
0.19004927575588226,
0.04747715964913368,
-0.9277828931808472,
0.12760381400585175,
0.1295417696237564,
-0.6452828645706177,
0.39337924122810364,
-0.5952088832855225,
0.9809349179267883,
-0.19646337628364563,
-0.5153250098228455,
-0.23938216269016266,
-0.8778087496757507,
-0.053302276879549026,
0.10734214633703232,
-0.10327164828777313,
-0.1438053697347641,
-0.19886524975299835,
0.5584719181060791,
-0.2581649422645569,
1.0358296632766724,
-0.37593138217926025,
0.05588461086153984,
0.31180864572525024,
-0.03454345464706421,
0.3247588574886322,
0.31659772992134094,
-0.07758782804012299,
0.43214449286460876,
-0.25083497166633606,
-0.11195056140422821,
-0.5640354156494141,
0.8045318722724915,
-0.9699249267578125,
-0.5546088218688965,
-0.3244166374206543,
-0.26385030150413513,
-0.3694919943809509,
0.0010885329684242606,
0.2814347445964813,
0.5833097696304321,
-0.06915413588285446,
-0.15006528794765472,
0.31937432289123535,
0.08588723093271255,
0.543156087398529,
0.20936284959316254,
-0.06791190057992935,
-0.48282280564308167,
0.8880316615104675,
-0.041077062487602234,
0.4735371768474579,
0.44473403692245483,
0.1467500627040863,
-0.3244186043739319,
-0.39918625354766846,
-0.6269621849060059,
0.17668908834457397,
-0.6991296410560608,
-0.4554464817047119,
-1.1090056896209717,
-0.6917501091957092,
-0.41492143273353577,
-0.0658566802740097,
-0.5278609395027161,
-0.4745509624481201,
-0.13014766573905945,
-0.18880359828472137,
0.5948975682258606,
0.851102888584137,
-0.1926000714302063,
0.13018959760665894,
-0.7868326306343079,
0.3585112988948822,
0.3097505271434784,
0.3429188132286072,
-0.1949225515127182,
-0.16201956570148468,
-0.004362170118838549,
0.12048396468162537,
-0.20235054194927216,
-1.0877264738082886,
0.26199889183044434,
0.0990908220410347,
0.330019474029541,
0.12132391333580017,
-0.2370682656764984,
0.2439602017402649,
-0.2973940968513489,
0.9220831394195557,
0.28874632716178894,
-0.84316086769104,
0.7140017151832581,
-0.20013949275016785,
0.15257486701011658,
0.7121437788009644,
0.07845258712768555,
-0.49671974778175354,
-0.5169976353645325,
-0.5673730969429016,
-1.1146727800369263,
1.1158325672149658,
0.1828216016292572,
0.09692609310150146,
-0.05385176092386246,
0.19659171998500824,
0.2020627111196518,
0.3387772738933563,
-0.8337636590003967,
-0.07324761897325516,
-0.44820135831832886,
-0.58348149061203,
0.2983423173427582,
-0.527712345123291,
0.012055905535817146,
-0.24133403599262238,
0.506934404373169,
-0.08439261466264725,
0.5665988922119141,
0.0672333687543869,
-0.08103759586811066,
0.1861172467470169,
0.24804385006427765,
-0.11051377654075623,
-0.26449185609817505,
-0.24311478435993195,
0.5632497072219849,
0.08584530651569366,
-0.5059822201728821,
-0.21740779280662537,
0.45226603746414185,
-0.02984042279422283,
0.007664431352168322,
0.1864868551492691,
1.0669161081314087,
0.2602027356624603,
0.0688025951385498,
0.8309656977653503,
-0.05209073796868324,
0.091123066842556,
-0.31683650612831116,
-0.24289903044700623,
0.13867416977882385,
0.29377588629722595,
-0.13773517310619354,
0.25801295042037964,
0.3866877853870392,
-0.5739165544509888,
0.10685884952545166,
0.3989318311214447,
-0.6420510411262512,
-0.7086049914360046,
0.3940299451351166,
0.6304267644882202,
-0.05705362558364868,
0.4897339642047882,
-0.5462880730628967,
-0.9514476656913757,
0.6705769300460815,
0.4933422803878784,
1.2052412033081055,
0.07371935993432999,
0.1436556577682495,
0.3341505527496338,
0.05481743440032005,
0.0978265181183815,
0.47025206685066223,
-0.16665031015872955,
-1.0495713949203491,
-0.07480749487876892,
-0.9919732213020325,
0.12338447570800781,
-0.07219398021697998,
-0.8018829226493835,
0.3540973365306854,
-0.2994298040866852,
-0.1707555502653122,
0.14682024717330933,
-0.13918054103851318,
-0.7557052373886108,
-0.13212507963180542,
0.45197874307632446,
0.49303311109542847,
-0.8592074513435364,
0.9368211627006531,
1.05321204662323,
-0.8043413162231445,
-0.8552125096321106,
0.3004199266433716,
0.16264748573303223,
-0.8245910406112671,
0.6736278533935547,
0.44260403513908386,
-0.3522014617919922,
-0.005684577859938145,
0.0750771090388298,
-0.6352537274360657,
0.9012101292610168,
0.033127620816230774,
-0.27321723103523254,
-0.11842294782400131,
0.25344038009643555,
0.48313504457473755,
-0.43751049041748047,
0.2826860845088959,
0.7680325508117676,
0.4129052460193634,
0.16514819860458374,
-0.9169413447380066,
0.15402914583683014,
-0.4207889437675476,
0.2515905499458313,
0.6224681735038757,
-0.5901041030883789,
0.7323853969573975,
-0.03484543040394783,
-0.31985485553741455,
-0.23505865037441254,
0.6690890789031982,
-0.2673734128475189,
-0.008118120953440666,
0.6341585516929626,
0.45329001545906067,
0.3358859419822693,
-0.14638710021972656,
1.023450493812561,
-0.3574203848838806,
0.4439290761947632,
1.090559720993042,
-0.34652888774871826,
1.0511964559555054,
0.4875168204307556,
-0.1705140769481659,
0.5527450442314148,
0.4647960364818573,
0.19986684620380402,
0.6338590979576111,
-0.2404668778181076,
-0.5857610702514648,
-0.16932250559329987,
-0.11514448374509811,
-0.16955330967903137,
0.5713799595832825,
0.5857725739479065,
-0.34325110912323,
-0.2683916985988617,
0.08892416954040527,
0.18247777223587036,
0.024973951280117035,
-0.30497199296951294,
1.0484094619750977,
0.18518778681755066,
-0.3917990028858185,
-0.04048865661025047,
-0.0752774029970169,
0.8205737471580505,
-0.5933510065078735,
0.0783381462097168,
0.11347518116235733,
0.38110044598579407,
-0.3787807822227478,
-1.3267009258270264,
0.5836979746818542,
0.06707163155078888,
-0.3461425304412842,
-0.40039944648742676,
0.9117769598960876,
-0.7144958972930908,
-0.5671389102935791,
0.8746234774589539,
0.3136737048625946,
-0.2176579236984253,
-0.22401033341884613,
-0.4815962016582489,
0.05729500949382782,
0.08057474344968796,
-0.17644885182380676,
0.15973390638828278,
0.6682848930358887,
0.2120174914598465,
0.00019807068747468293,
0.1538049876689911,
0.1969803124666214,
-0.2590261995792389,
0.4702150821685791,
1.1540764570236206,
-0.756454586982727,
-0.6396917700767517,
-0.9769874811172485,
0.6082854866981506,
-0.5555737614631653,
-0.06702224165201187,
0.6220305562019348,
0.5991324186325073,
0.47615352272987366,
0.09667188674211502,
1.0263367891311646,
-0.3526464104652405,
0.35743725299835205,
-0.6233625411987305,
0.4932723641395569,
-0.5050106048583984,
0.21886083483695984,
0.1327115297317505,
-0.7807490825653076,
-0.16800808906555176,
0.4091617166996002,
-0.4227758049964905,
-0.09310855716466904,
1.0060150623321533,
0.7119175791740417,
-0.20105578005313873,
0.4735192358493805,
-0.11184448003768921,
0.3916094899177551,
0.12189231812953949,
0.6700449585914612,
1.0225728750228882,
-0.3467000424861908,
0.28313785791397095,
-0.3312063217163086,
-0.3879055678844452,
-0.16968825459480286,
-0.543817937374115,
-0.7538343667984009,
-0.5798280835151672,
-0.39320218563079834,
-0.5383883118629456,
0.037809088826179504,
0.9374155402183533,
0.331318736076355,
-0.6934587955474854,
0.07529043406248093,
-0.12924368679523468,
-0.03853374347090721,
0.09898205101490021,
-0.25248482823371887,
0.4451332092285156,
-0.48823559284210205,
-0.5829796195030212,
0.1927177459001541,
0.6908825635910034,
-0.19311124086380005,
-0.24192781746387482,
0.23312462866306305,
-0.015901632606983185,
-0.1350780874490738,
0.6946775317192078,
-0.17993536591529846,
-0.8037409782409668,
-0.8178591132164001,
-0.3444480299949646,
-0.2955974042415619,
0.28944501280784607,
0.7664267420768738,
-0.5424008369445801,
0.3011265993118286,
0.4823392629623413,
0.5106447339057922,
0.3817847669124603,
-0.20715218782424927,
0.6149981021881104,
-0.8090419769287109,
0.1549862176179886,
0.4208279252052307,
0.40260422229766846,
0.49807631969451904,
-0.5183870792388916,
0.2705708146095276,
0.18577463924884796,
-0.2113739252090454,
-0.3219324052333832,
0.4155244827270508,
-1.1414952278137207,
-0.12458658963441849,
1.5765337944030762,
-0.02371213212609291,
-0.16770361363887787,
-0.14752386510372162,
-0.14686231315135956,
0.28262823820114136,
-0.56678706407547,
0.3354957699775696,
0.46677011251449585,
-0.3247530162334442,
0.14036941528320312,
-0.6684412956237793,
0.44043660163879395,
0.2937348484992981,
-0.7579149007797241,
0.0475071556866169,
0.4426044821739197,
0.19959135353565216,
0.269661545753479,
0.6644476056098938,
-0.1267806440591812,
0.07326905429363251,
0.2833210229873657,
0.40285176038742065,
0.08944226801395416,
-0.2654128670692444,
-0.48419469594955444,
0.3050786852836609,
0.16665910184383392,
-0.5029135942459106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15343v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15343v1
|
NuNER: Entity Recognition Encoder Pre-training via LLM-Annotated Data
| 2024-02-23T14:23:51 | 2024-02-23T14:23:51 |
Sergei Bogdanov, Alexandre Constantin, Timothée Bernard, Benoit Crabbé, Etienne Bernard
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive abilities in data
annotation, opening the way for new approaches to solve classic NLP problems.
In this paper, we show how to use LLMs to create NuNER, a compact language
representation model specialized in the Named Entity Recognition (NER) task.
NuNER can be fine-tuned to solve downstream NER problems in a data-efficient
way, outperforming similar-sized foundation models in the few-shot regime and
competing with much larger LLMs. We find that the size and entity-type
diversity of the pre-training dataset are key to achieving good performance. We
view NuNER as a member of the broader family of task-specific foundation
models, recently unlocked by LLMs.
|
[
-0.40498992800712585,
-0.10952278971672058,
0.606191873550415,
0.15345804393291473,
-0.3397693932056427,
0.05775536596775055,
-0.2180030345916748,
-0.30738794803619385,
0.3643694221973419,
0.7097769379615784,
-0.3504883348941803,
-0.497878760099411,
-1.0272845029830933,
0.3738101124763489,
-0.6731557846069336,
0.9511632919311523,
-0.19501172006130219,
0.3105795681476593,
0.13040117919445038,
-0.025299586355686188,
-0.17443180084228516,
-0.666770875453949,
-0.7021205425262451,
-0.3356620967388153,
0.6182815432548523,
0.4678906500339508,
0.3549967408180237,
0.7611146569252014,
0.748867392539978,
0.26271799206733704,
0.11399795860052109,
-0.2421056181192398,
-0.6384086608886719,
0.1773541122674942,
0.022217918187379837,
-0.6694715619087219,
-0.3045912981033325,
-0.2508305013179779,
1.045579433441162,
0.7252010703086853,
0.00598593195900321,
0.11426949501037598,
0.03680884465575218,
0.43687915802001953,
-0.45996180176734924,
-0.014148063026368618,
-0.8032923340797424,
-0.043139681220054626,
-0.3703136146068573,
-0.12036046385765076,
-0.28574010729789734,
-0.2729528248310089,
0.2069319784641266,
-0.546922504901886,
0.3393617868423462,
0.13096748292446136,
0.8255228400230408,
0.5917481780052185,
-0.5127147436141968,
-0.2929973006248474,
-0.9600868821144104,
0.7480472922325134,
-0.4892135560512543,
0.8632131218910217,
-0.03043079376220703,
0.4607072174549103,
-0.4707951843738556,
-0.8392801880836487,
-0.5991238355636597,
0.02152799256145954,
-0.011371467262506485,
-0.23263472318649292,
-0.09589289873838425,
0.07570179551839828,
0.4549596905708313,
0.3808133006095886,
-0.3648994266986847,
0.19852207601070404,
-0.2571817636489868,
-0.03472636267542839,
0.38117238879203796,
-0.01570088043808937,
0.2030021995306015,
-0.010355263948440552,
-0.34537553787231445,
-0.08110112696886063,
-0.9861239790916443,
-0.24973496794700623,
0.22461438179016113,
0.12261297553777695,
0.11932346969842911,
0.6796414852142334,
-0.28971219062805176,
0.4908807575702667,
0.021092601120471954,
-0.26842960715293884,
0.071184903383255,
0.38550347089767456,
-0.2922685444355011,
0.3194047212600708,
0.5962936878204346,
0.06569018959999084,
0.40911996364593506,
-0.4696199595928192,
-0.6657395958900452,
-0.06790326535701752,
-0.0434831939637661,
-1.0501761436462402,
-0.442423552274704,
-0.06737150251865387,
-0.30524203181266785,
0.003291293978691101,
0.14062826335430145,
-0.5391296744346619,
-0.3581910729408264,
-0.4512667655944824,
0.31908610463142395,
-0.06783947348594666,
-0.1695258766412735,
0.12187004089355469,
-0.09528756886720657,
0.37981653213500977,
0.3163750171661377,
-0.7767882943153381,
0.8198331594467163,
0.6293588876724243,
0.6743473410606384,
-0.1364772468805313,
-0.12873460352420807,
-0.8187288641929626,
0.31633564829826355,
-0.33365070819854736,
0.847927987575531,
-0.5496471524238586,
-0.25071951746940613,
-0.33704233169555664,
0.2017206996679306,
0.027043120935559273,
-0.5877495408058167,
0.3054482638835907,
-0.6885334849357605,
-0.3623702824115753,
-0.23906946182250977,
-0.7517110705375671,
-0.1400989294052124,
0.36735785007476807,
-1.1863027811050415,
0.8113513588905334,
0.1647113412618637,
-0.8760156035423279,
0.5977187156677246,
-0.6656004190444946,
-0.1438601016998291,
0.3571968972682953,
-0.4561004340648651,
-0.2691429853439331,
0.33430716395378113,
0.3348986506462097,
0.6845766305923462,
-0.45846083760261536,
0.39735838770866394,
-0.04157973453402519,
-0.4948565661907196,
0.2505269944667816,
-0.23795448243618011,
0.32662761211395264,
-0.222334623336792,
-0.26452913880348206,
0.04263570159673691,
-0.8705177903175354,
-0.3119642436504364,
0.32302621006965637,
-0.4881191551685333,
-0.2978023886680603,
-0.04897022247314453,
0.12197598814964294,
0.11138560622930527,
0.16619108617305756,
-0.6110431551933289,
0.14299309253692627,
-0.3555617928504944,
0.4911217987537384,
0.371322900056839,
0.01257406733930111,
0.6392236351966858,
-0.12969601154327393,
0.3975479304790497,
0.044763386249542236,
-0.04597892612218857,
0.13137181103229523,
-0.225660502910614,
-1.1758122444152832,
-0.36111581325531006,
0.7453962564468384,
0.3498832583427429,
-0.762851893901825,
0.14571338891983032,
-0.6409681439399719,
-0.4093359708786011,
-0.554826557636261,
0.3202320337295532,
0.023841261863708496,
0.2960309386253357,
0.3283739984035492,
-0.09776658564805984,
-0.8702720403671265,
-1.1036005020141602,
0.04759051650762558,
-0.059414613991975784,
-0.04202311858534813,
0.2148684412240982,
0.7828492522239685,
-0.3944956958293915,
0.9358310699462891,
-0.36703595519065857,
-0.4074704945087433,
-0.36248934268951416,
0.06788444519042969,
0.14191317558288574,
0.6432996392250061,
0.3413506746292114,
-0.924103319644928,
-0.20063401758670807,
-0.26431867480278015,
-0.5017977356910706,
0.03336555138230324,
-0.005990560632199049,
-0.14359067380428314,
-0.0860474705696106,
0.6513707637786865,
-0.5317366719245911,
0.25443994998931885,
0.5441600680351257,
0.20282965898513794,
0.22856174409389496,
0.0651584342122078,
0.04360085353255272,
-1.0260452032089233,
-0.1949991136789322,
-0.16554318368434906,
-0.361324667930603,
-0.6057190299034119,
-0.12194088101387024,
0.11000862717628479,
-0.02294158935546875,
-0.4883488714694977,
0.5589815974235535,
-0.7425445318222046,
-0.2661077678203583,
-0.2424057126045227,
-0.07356522977352142,
-0.09932105988264084,
0.1412346512079239,
0.4621095359325409,
0.5496845245361328,
0.6301190853118896,
-0.6634927988052368,
0.1987324357032776,
0.1301986426115036,
-0.2456955462694168,
0.35457083582878113,
-0.8651323914527893,
0.31684452295303345,
-0.28042712807655334,
0.2208608090877533,
-0.4058302938938141,
-0.4758881628513336,
0.05566665902733803,
-0.11839521676301956,
0.4175216555595398,
-0.4583176374435425,
-0.8385314345359802,
-0.1677452176809311,
0.0012717104982584715,
0.4776271879673004,
0.39241161942481995,
-0.9062496423721313,
1.0191214084625244,
0.39491358399391174,
-0.04701482132077217,
-0.48941347002983093,
-0.6757264733314514,
0.09643442928791046,
-0.31847190856933594,
-0.24925914406776428,
0.4984326660633087,
0.16693508625030518,
0.0037237892393022776,
0.006521754432469606,
-0.04221585392951965,
-0.18489527702331543,
0.1271457076072693,
0.5464038252830505,
0.15993452072143555,
-0.49045440554618835,
0.2872849106788635,
0.007875054143369198,
-0.31916743516921997,
0.054126691073179245,
-0.18965506553649902,
0.5200080275535583,
-0.14440499246120453,
-0.44001004099845886,
-0.06561458855867386,
0.33253714442253113,
0.2293831706047058,
-0.17673315107822418,
0.7718963623046875,
0.37952128052711487,
-0.9324749112129211,
-0.23151922225952148,
-0.7618309259414673,
-0.2699081599712372,
-0.39130499958992004,
0.30848410725593567,
-0.6106030941009521,
-1.1238099336624146,
0.3796237111091614,
-0.39095574617385864,
0.05778221786022186,
0.3539050817489624,
0.17913709580898285,
0.12079989165067673,
0.8804314136505127,
0.9820024371147156,
-0.10375481098890305,
0.40851929783821106,
-0.27683427929878235,
0.22317233681678772,
-1.011989712715149,
-0.3168306350708008,
-0.49088871479034424,
-0.4780026376247406,
-0.47550761699676514,
-0.3747421205043793,
-0.03593778610229492,
0.5907642841339111,
-0.4076034426689148,
0.460584819316864,
-0.47017019987106323,
0.616283655166626,
0.4960591197013855,
-0.18505364656448364,
0.27936747670173645,
-0.38377779722213745,
0.20838980376720428,
-0.16583174467086792,
-0.5763954520225525,
-0.9252066016197205,
1.0860400199890137,
0.445923775434494,
0.848635733127594,
0.05612078681588173,
1.2558780908584595,
-0.3528781235218048,
0.6159719824790955,
-0.8407413959503174,
0.6361076235771179,
-0.2065497785806656,
-0.46052828431129456,
-0.13098277151584625,
-0.30652907490730286,
-0.7382772564888,
-0.030183976516127586,
-0.4618193507194519,
-0.7227607369422913,
0.2850334942340851,
-0.001567366416566074,
-0.24657954275608063,
0.36205074191093445,
-0.44368231296539307,
0.7661536931991577,
-0.3214189410209656,
0.3686090409755707,
0.42782267928123474,
-0.3565990626811981,
0.2614426612854004,
-0.3398415148258209,
-0.1511484980583191,
-0.1797177791595459,
-0.28952106833457947,
1.0218605995178223,
-0.13482274115085602,
0.5308540463447571,
-0.1947220414876938,
0.24597062170505524,
0.01393067929893732,
0.045472562313079834,
0.5923426151275635,
0.3016137480735779,
0.05092589929699898,
0.21122680604457855,
-0.13474802672863007,
-0.11371445655822754,
-0.8154146075248718,
0.6424644589424133,
-0.6642181873321533,
-0.609563410282135,
-0.36266306042671204,
-0.4553818702697754,
0.06242261081933975,
0.3096122443675995,
0.3708122968673706,
0.3984788656234741,
-0.35430586338043213,
0.5438862442970276,
0.7920017242431641,
0.08780934661626816,
0.32504409551620483,
0.46215495467185974,
-0.3824544847011566,
-0.3120228052139282,
0.627108633518219,
0.33215197920799255,
-0.08107845485210419,
0.5708118677139282,
-0.24340295791625977,
-0.2254200577735901,
-0.8375627398490906,
-0.36993104219436646,
0.29516831040382385,
-0.9446523189544678,
-0.3877538740634918,
-1.0457099676132202,
-0.453499436378479,
-0.20397229492664337,
-0.2524603307247162,
-0.45069819688796997,
-0.3363461196422577,
-0.5235385298728943,
-0.16775117814540863,
0.4195992648601532,
0.986569344997406,
0.1288466602563858,
0.7687086462974548,
-0.666360080242157,
0.40982693433761597,
0.4048513174057007,
0.4009862244129181,
-0.33357515931129456,
-0.275434285402298,
0.04451099410653114,
-0.2477576732635498,
0.24036747217178345,
-1.0096498727798462,
0.3770809471607208,
0.31576138734817505,
0.6689449548721313,
0.3585435152053833,
0.02382527105510235,
0.4657885730266571,
-0.621080756187439,
0.4265904128551483,
0.036953914910554886,
-0.8436145782470703,
0.5775929689407349,
0.13617141544818878,
-0.03305739536881447,
0.5599950551986694,
0.6002561450004578,
-0.14625787734985352,
-0.11348403245210648,
-0.4922654926776886,
-0.7759767770767212,
0.44159984588623047,
0.20398202538490295,
0.09336881339550018,
-0.18133704364299774,
0.45918604731559753,
0.047008417546749115,
0.18554924428462982,
-0.8921617865562439,
0.0007976455963216722,
-0.13663895428180695,
-0.3739881217479706,
-0.1488153636455536,
-0.3904183506965637,
0.14131775498390198,
-0.10856824368238449,
0.6593338847160339,
-0.2003609985113144,
0.13845661282539368,
0.11835949867963791,
-0.6789531707763672,
0.17229951918125153,
0.5179951786994934,
0.016410034149885178,
0.2051742523908615,
-0.1599864810705185,
0.3875655233860016,
0.4912327826023102,
-0.47737571597099304,
0.15057474374771118,
0.3157007396221161,
-0.15424902737140656,
0.12879285216331482,
0.2301427721977234,
0.8903278112411499,
0.6523967385292053,
-0.6060004830360413,
0.5220717191696167,
-0.2495359480381012,
-0.11793723702430725,
-0.5440151691436768,
0.2112211138010025,
0.2892661988735199,
0.4621026813983917,
0.3797721564769745,
-0.17816880345344543,
0.393769234418869,
-0.16800178587436676,
0.0685345008969307,
0.29235631227493286,
-0.4260232746601105,
-0.11648180335760117,
0.6027381420135498,
-0.05392182990908623,
-0.3426171541213989,
0.7229378819465637,
-0.2586452066898346,
-0.7966880798339844,
0.5845210552215576,
0.7254709601402283,
0.7790515422821045,
-0.1711505502462387,
-0.04014008864760399,
0.3097560703754425,
0.41512978076934814,
-0.44378983974456787,
0.3058986961841583,
0.015509933233261108,
-0.813170850276947,
-0.22473540902137756,
-0.8731122612953186,
-0.32780349254608154,
0.23514193296432495,
-0.7426636219024658,
0.5613895654678345,
-0.5267015099525452,
-0.2256830334663391,
0.09575950354337692,
-0.08132012188434601,
-1.1332147121429443,
0.3165056109428406,
0.19088949263095856,
0.8943798542022705,
-0.6678748726844788,
0.914219081401825,
0.7993829846382141,
-0.26319625973701477,
-0.962337851524353,
-0.10063836723566055,
-0.16418986022472382,
-0.4300740361213684,
1.0663856267929077,
0.5302786231040955,
-0.1352689266204834,
0.46712395548820496,
-0.514655351638794,
-1.0969635248184204,
1.2234761714935303,
0.6889162063598633,
-0.961885392665863,
-0.1966312974691391,
0.12173312157392502,
0.22868293523788452,
-0.8254434466362,
0.1202574297785759,
0.7256426215171814,
0.2291414886713028,
0.12031271308660507,
-0.5760665535926819,
0.028039665892720222,
-0.18620234727859497,
0.23242440819740295,
0.41014203429222107,
-0.04685228690505028,
0.940045952796936,
-0.1408369392156601,
-0.3603290617465973,
-0.08331076800823212,
0.8778759241104126,
0.37158602476119995,
-0.07363374531269073,
0.7336814403533936,
0.46480101346969604,
0.7176222205162048,
-0.2470306009054184,
0.8249413967132568,
-0.1440344899892807,
0.0342935286462307,
1.3513784408569336,
-0.4339034855365753,
1.137019157409668,
0.4974411129951477,
0.2266535758972168,
0.4542503356933594,
0.49335744976997375,
-0.20535120368003845,
0.40181276202201843,
0.36840784549713135,
-0.18795070052146912,
-0.31125786900520325,
-0.17878390848636627,
-0.1981440633535385,
0.4654199481010437,
0.4373171925544739,
-0.3726191222667694,
-0.19847191870212555,
0.14240437746047974,
-0.2991802990436554,
-0.18265996873378754,
-0.44780540466308594,
0.9281041622161865,
0.3055817782878876,
-0.07056251168251038,
0.05338924005627632,
-0.015935901552438736,
0.8748331665992737,
-0.3759256601333618,
-0.29330316185951233,
0.2732378840446472,
0.02790542133152485,
-0.2023695558309555,
-0.610488772392273,
0.16687248647212982,
0.13413351774215698,
-0.2612415552139282,
0.05965368449687958,
1.0436854362487793,
-0.46220090985298157,
-0.5451904535293579,
0.5214793086051941,
0.4551886320114136,
0.4736071527004242,
-0.32481086254119873,
-0.3689655363559723,
0.12801864743232727,
-0.5155303478240967,
-0.25838595628738403,
0.157830610871315,
0.6199865937232971,
-0.13305534422397614,
0.581465482711792,
0.5536054968833923,
0.20053638517856598,
0.303435355424881,
0.3763134777545929,
0.9578697681427002,
-0.7584129571914673,
-0.3918234705924988,
-0.7155457139015198,
0.2968146800994873,
-0.08630014210939407,
-0.1716497391462326,
0.41843950748443604,
0.6918854713439941,
0.9176185131072998,
0.041267894208431244,
0.590184211730957,
0.19191870093345642,
0.5060448050498962,
-0.5833289623260498,
0.6631322503089905,
-0.2899034321308136,
0.14076370000839233,
-0.12936587631702423,
-1.3260661363601685,
-0.47179368138313293,
0.6779525279998779,
-0.4374715983867645,
0.02010573260486126,
0.4517502784729004,
0.7714628577232361,
-0.11957593262195587,
0.1488683819770813,
0.315888911485672,
-0.003430583281442523,
0.15420450270175934,
0.6827109456062317,
1.0414711236953735,
-0.5492772459983826,
0.39524486660957336,
-0.3145431876182556,
0.026161424815654755,
-0.20661811530590057,
-0.9611935019493103,
-1.080045223236084,
-0.618490993976593,
-0.3490441143512726,
0.08932927250862122,
-0.06884321570396423,
1.1554322242736816,
0.842670202255249,
-0.9208441376686096,
0.07450369000434875,
-0.11587662994861603,
0.021085994318127632,
0.2758753001689911,
-0.12884007394313812,
0.1119701936841011,
-0.035653166472911835,
-0.7791542410850525,
0.3290024399757385,
0.2069709450006485,
0.5115957260131836,
-0.23094910383224487,
-0.26119720935821533,
0.044499289244413376,
-0.03543740138411522,
0.318443238735199,
0.0753098726272583,
-0.6938760280609131,
-0.2634413242340088,
0.0334332138299942,
-0.06076370179653168,
0.0005655647837556899,
0.8805198669433594,
-0.9178587198257446,
0.0925670936703682,
0.22304151952266693,
0.9491389989852905,
0.5624134540557861,
-0.32318881154060364,
0.5254706144332886,
-0.641716718673706,
0.05679553374648094,
0.3787201941013336,
0.7989042401313782,
0.7138017416000366,
-0.40927332639694214,
0.4572495222091675,
-0.1879676878452301,
-0.4170595407485962,
-0.9835204482078552,
0.11954867094755173,
-0.8814015984535217,
0.10785286128520966,
1.0153652429580688,
-0.19940781593322754,
-0.3115878403186798,
-0.20359301567077637,
-0.12045372277498245,
0.39806482195854187,
-0.27712881565093994,
0.17658184468746185,
0.6071177124977112,
0.1093473732471466,
-0.564376175403595,
-0.5613596439361572,
0.4443960189819336,
-0.04333099350333214,
-0.8451563119888306,
-0.34900274872779846,
0.2419237196445465,
0.5139489769935608,
0.13903239369392395,
0.7361553311347961,
-0.0413801334798336,
0.034241560846567154,
0.05999496951699257,
0.19508863985538483,
-0.05650407075881958,
-0.7456519603729248,
-0.38529518246650696,
0.12379741668701172,
0.3783366084098816,
-0.0837210938334465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15337v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15337v2
|
Ranking Entities along Conceptual Space Dimensions with LLMs: An Analysis of Fine-Tuning Strategies
| 2024-02-23T14:17:01 | 2024-06-05T10:42:40 |
Nitesh Kumar, Usashi Chatterjee, Steven Schockaert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Conceptual spaces represent entities in terms of their primitive semantic
features. Such representations are highly valuable but they are notoriously
difficult to learn, especially when it comes to modelling perceptual and
subjective features. Distilling conceptual spaces from Large Language Models
(LLMs) has recently emerged as a promising strategy, but existing work has been
limited to probing pre-trained LLMs using relatively simple zero-shot
strategies. We focus in particular on the task of ranking entities according to
a given conceptual space dimension. Unfortunately, we cannot directly fine-tune
LLMs on this task, because ground truth rankings for conceptual space
dimensions are rare. We therefore use more readily available features as
training data and analyse whether the ranking capabilities of the resulting
models transfer to perceptual and subjective features. We find that this is
indeed the case, to some extent, but having at least some perceptual and
subjective features in the training data seems essential for achieving the best
results.
|
[
-0.8242204785346985,
-0.5902321934700012,
0.9269277453422546,
-0.0663742795586586,
-0.3413030803203583,
0.19714097678661346,
-0.4666232168674469,
-0.44534385204315186,
0.25752198696136475,
0.42119935154914856,
-0.471146821975708,
-0.7700252532958984,
-0.7711291313171387,
0.013499564491212368,
-0.3172003924846649,
1.021967887878418,
0.0807892456650734,
-0.10786560922861099,
-0.5927253365516663,
-0.2173558473587036,
-0.46425434947013855,
-0.5592569708824158,
-0.47125402092933655,
-0.2387508898973465,
0.6018900275230408,
0.5984234809875488,
0.7037350535392761,
0.6414980888366699,
0.6179584860801697,
0.3183751106262207,
-0.26133695244789124,
0.1700933277606964,
-0.8465490341186523,
0.09332628548145294,
-0.3670405447483063,
-0.40254494547843933,
-0.4204365611076355,
0.32940128445625305,
0.7221148014068604,
1.2579047679901123,
-0.12577912211418152,
0.35819894075393677,
0.051983173936605453,
0.5102036595344543,
-0.6054041981697083,
0.0744628757238388,
-1.0830076932907104,
0.033814940601587296,
-0.3407638370990753,
-0.36515724658966064,
-0.007318985648453236,
-0.19640293717384338,
0.2323625534772873,
-0.6807020306587219,
0.3848670423030853,
0.22453315556049347,
1.0493147373199463,
0.5186530351638794,
-0.4900108277797699,
-0.2871983051300049,
-0.7395852208137512,
0.8882261514663696,
-0.3797217607498169,
0.37733355164527893,
0.21398545801639557,
0.018515804782509804,
-0.007473535370081663,
-0.43526554107666016,
-0.5428164601325989,
-0.5256063342094421,
-0.05007167160511017,
-0.09132324904203415,
0.07673463225364685,
-0.006385892629623413,
0.36162176728248596,
0.3889777362346649,
-0.20626309514045715,
0.2643921375274658,
-0.13123558461666107,
-0.025515591725707054,
0.8114734292030334,
0.2907067537307739,
-0.054278742522001266,
-0.12002329528331757,
-0.30566197633743286,
-0.0913233608007431,
-0.6338745951652527,
-0.09737423807382584,
0.2693420350551605,
0.21580983698368073,
0.1151815801858902,
0.7276967167854309,
-0.4296976327896118,
0.522602915763855,
0.2716696262359619,
-0.2750687003135681,
0.1785627007484436,
-0.27736684679985046,
-0.02638406865298748,
0.010135101154446602,
0.4597114324569702,
0.37854239344596863,
0.32792454957962036,
-0.3149923086166382,
-0.3945029675960541,
0.09440330415964127,
0.5334673523902893,
-0.5948014259338379,
-0.2921590209007263,
-0.049088217318058014,
-0.11827092617750168,
-0.4031340181827545,
-0.10939908027648926,
-0.424542635679245,
-0.25732192397117615,
-0.6760590672492981,
0.3511178195476532,
-0.4104427397251129,
-0.14049652218818665,
0.07292789220809937,
-0.004510620608925819,
0.22514934837818146,
0.5789130330085754,
-0.9227675795555115,
0.31985148787498474,
0.8191928267478943,
0.7729315757751465,
-0.31807950139045715,
-0.26591911911964417,
0.019079629331827164,
0.08490674197673798,
-0.6353979706764221,
0.9969893097877502,
-0.6746891140937805,
-0.5754554271697998,
-0.16857485473155975,
-0.31283995509147644,
0.193734273314476,
-0.7912423014640808,
0.4376278519630432,
-0.5276015400886536,
-0.023891035467386246,
-0.5432640910148621,
-0.9015175104141235,
0.12989698350429535,
0.37650248408317566,
-0.41098469495773315,
0.8976121544837952,
0.21350552141666412,
-0.6589537262916565,
0.679598867893219,
-0.6834863424301147,
-0.37950754165649414,
0.0007546946872025728,
-0.2818584740161896,
-0.1272619217634201,
0.46508657932281494,
0.17150814831256866,
0.6948111653327942,
-0.16369614005088806,
0.09636660665273666,
-0.5706894397735596,
-0.288835734128952,
0.2753186523914337,
-0.10119732469320297,
0.3418057858943939,
0.2871719002723694,
-0.10344966500997543,
-0.1465703547000885,
-0.7920446395874023,
-0.01100304163992405,
0.19522005319595337,
-0.43582776188850403,
-0.5418784022331238,
0.010059360414743423,
-0.1469571888446808,
0.12374688684940338,
0.3085043132305145,
-0.30543696880340576,
0.3346114158630371,
-0.40089818835258484,
0.28646722435951233,
0.6586998701095581,
0.23957060277462006,
0.8274259567260742,
-0.07245935499668121,
0.30021482706069946,
0.23871029913425446,
-0.0647764727473259,
0.3982589840888977,
-0.2516644299030304,
-0.8801404237747192,
-0.2784537672996521,
0.5415381193161011,
0.2687285542488098,
-0.6556960940361023,
0.6347760558128357,
-0.6074627041816711,
-0.6534525752067566,
-0.44100046157836914,
0.335193395614624,
0.23343390226364136,
0.343248575925827,
0.15013520419597626,
-0.5226647257804871,
-0.13611306250095367,
-0.995583713054657,
-0.14557059109210968,
-0.14520655572414398,
-0.03921957314014435,
0.4564211964607239,
0.5313082933425903,
0.13417986035346985,
0.8414090275764465,
-0.761629045009613,
-0.3241371810436249,
0.04728037118911743,
-0.2125166356563568,
0.10737255960702896,
0.25217369198799133,
0.6355246901512146,
-0.7623472809791565,
-0.15594978630542755,
-0.21971718966960907,
-0.9092168807983398,
0.1105787605047226,
0.16501237452030182,
-0.04927881434559822,
-0.2189198136329651,
0.6057897806167603,
-0.7319509387016296,
0.10523839294910431,
0.0835556611418724,
-0.23806239664554596,
0.27502337098121643,
-0.04942036420106888,
0.005518725141882896,
-0.8495787978172302,
-0.1860053390264511,
0.2807081639766693,
-0.11950066685676575,
-0.42761924862861633,
0.30535420775413513,
-0.20033465325832367,
-0.0266441497951746,
-0.4797329902648926,
0.5463367104530334,
-0.4466821253299713,
-0.0773317962884903,
-0.15525704622268677,
0.5038372874259949,
-0.11078561097383499,
0.5585404634475708,
0.07046505808830261,
0.6316532492637634,
0.43134167790412903,
-0.8076327443122864,
0.23167471587657928,
0.23346489667892456,
-0.455156147480011,
0.9062579274177551,
-0.3353239595890045,
0.23624131083488464,
-0.1769147664308548,
0.04562302306294441,
-0.865932822227478,
-0.04713767394423485,
-0.05355798825621605,
-0.38073503971099854,
0.5164738893508911,
-0.10999032855033875,
-0.5587932467460632,
0.03917744383215904,
-0.3190564811229706,
0.3502243757247925,
0.23113323748111725,
-0.201901376247406,
0.2047673612833023,
0.7736589908599854,
-0.025979865342378616,
-0.48701828718185425,
-0.2575875520706177,
0.11244136095046997,
-0.5554344058036804,
-0.36920490860939026,
0.619496762752533,
0.13155321776866913,
-0.26210036873817444,
0.23382097482681274,
-0.23705631494522095,
0.31203585863113403,
0.4313885271549225,
0.407416433095932,
0.1384958028793335,
-0.22988498210906982,
0.13947546482086182,
-0.08903045952320099,
-0.2609706521034241,
0.09207639843225479,
-0.5550247430801392,
0.33440837264060974,
-0.19695588946342468,
-0.2753256559371948,
-0.07906930893659592,
-0.010673017241060734,
0.45508551597595215,
-0.19757819175720215,
0.7843407988548279,
0.4124387502670288,
-0.4643808901309967,
-0.23409011960029602,
-0.622881293296814,
-0.010480217635631561,
-0.4301413297653198,
0.62558913230896,
-0.5817328095436096,
-1.1096343994140625,
0.387951523065567,
-0.4051285982131958,
-0.07390076667070389,
0.5406773090362549,
0.6821579933166504,
-0.429121732711792,
0.8299472332000732,
0.9477134943008423,
-0.20803771913051605,
0.40935036540031433,
-0.5311727523803711,
0.2830522954463959,
-0.9232915639877319,
-0.3937671184539795,
-0.5919735431671143,
-0.5926195383071899,
-0.7435786724090576,
-0.2814829349517822,
0.5359882712364197,
0.27932289242744446,
-0.2467924803495407,
0.15482695400714874,
-0.40558695793151855,
0.699391782283783,
0.40392157435417175,
0.08667099475860596,
0.2952383756637573,
0.13079263269901276,
-0.3940238058567047,
-0.1386222541332245,
-0.5600051283836365,
-0.6630348563194275,
1.0702186822891235,
0.43736374378204346,
0.6996207237243652,
0.1278306245803833,
0.7210043668746948,
-0.000001261491775039758,
0.12285555154085159,
-0.9931221008300781,
0.7066298723220825,
-0.23361317813396454,
-0.5444642305374146,
-0.6346336603164673,
-0.38862550258636475,
-0.7273144721984863,
0.17472749948501587,
-0.419781893491745,
-0.6556915640830994,
0.2869899868965149,
-0.16911081969738007,
-0.4307807981967926,
0.16737481951713562,
-0.4748062491416931,
0.6018204092979431,
-0.23140168190002441,
-0.20787441730499268,
-0.41713690757751465,
-0.3545128405094147,
0.2881605327129364,
-0.12282466143369675,
-0.06063196808099747,
-0.38252508640289307,
-0.19170637428760529,
0.6297121047973633,
-0.14993806183338165,
0.5761275887489319,
-0.19438186287879944,
-0.30560529232025146,
-0.12107697874307632,
0.1124352365732193,
0.051624979823827744,
0.4676552414894104,
0.13742811977863312,
0.36778387427330017,
0.009790869429707527,
-0.48152387142181396,
-0.7819827795028687,
1.0001635551452637,
-1.0787993669509888,
-0.8257189989089966,
-0.221821129322052,
-0.2741963267326355,
-0.6652158498764038,
0.04264521226286888,
0.3695756196975708,
0.12420187890529633,
-0.3051188588142395,
0.21463872492313385,
1.0236886739730835,
0.06315963715314865,
0.12854863703250885,
0.34126976132392883,
-0.10457935184240341,
-0.16287736594676971,
0.9638885259628296,
0.44787007570266724,
0.03853386268019676,
0.5157082676887512,
-0.2603515386581421,
-0.4981310963630676,
-0.958952784538269,
-0.05725477635860443,
0.20920094847679138,
-0.7935749292373657,
-0.23232623934745789,
-0.5132846236228943,
-0.4830981194972992,
-0.11546062678098679,
-0.04964291676878929,
-0.5190588235855103,
-0.7412247657775879,
-0.39558103680610657,
-0.1997058093547821,
0.07992279529571533,
0.6378198266029358,
0.15179221332073212,
0.0032319333404302597,
-0.44147709012031555,
0.3620409071445465,
0.36440062522888184,
0.5478866100311279,
0.06259458512067795,
-0.5444665551185608,
-0.4495234489440918,
-0.17537352442741394,
-0.5403962731361389,
-0.5323171019554138,
0.044934146106243134,
0.09888876229524612,
0.6241413354873657,
0.46971362829208374,
-0.12368741631507874,
0.8718404173851013,
-0.5931452512741089,
0.8758478164672852,
0.021875163540244102,
-0.8709815144538879,
0.7362514138221741,
-0.1072690486907959,
0.06913767009973526,
0.6387549638748169,
0.5971227288246155,
-0.3626653850078583,
-0.4049036502838135,
-0.8150336146354675,
-0.7777400016784668,
0.5550013780593872,
0.1933593600988388,
0.3645826578140259,
0.011823588982224464,
0.8499302268028259,
-0.11053261905908585,
0.3727990686893463,
-0.33802318572998047,
-0.3730063736438751,
-0.14824047684669495,
-0.051212772727012634,
-0.3369583785533905,
-0.19717378914356232,
-0.20724859833717346,
-0.4595184326171875,
0.4977222979068756,
0.0078087435103952885,
0.067537322640419,
0.059964705258607864,
-0.19242586195468903,
-0.005918413866311312,
0.11425209045410156,
0.43387189507484436,
0.737361490726471,
-0.06226404011249542,
0.17250658571720123,
0.4654308259487152,
-0.2983361780643463,
0.2641594111919403,
-0.0585733987390995,
-0.11794250458478928,
-0.028511809185147285,
0.3907606601715088,
0.9595035910606384,
0.5012159943580627,
-0.22239123284816742,
0.39889851212501526,
0.09060774743556976,
-0.3570996820926666,
-0.2974032461643219,
0.4178406298160553,
0.13862235844135284,
0.3857080936431885,
0.21312357485294342,
0.08225142955780029,
0.17090895771980286,
-0.6047956347465515,
-0.012958535924553871,
0.6264457106590271,
-0.4447730779647827,
-0.3265921473503113,
0.47072604298591614,
0.11794872581958771,
-0.05620643123984337,
0.6373929381370544,
-0.12132850289344788,
-0.30780360102653503,
0.3216777443885803,
0.0730479508638382,
0.6094139814376831,
0.0774335190653801,
0.12412072718143463,
0.12795253098011017,
0.29296112060546875,
0.03314526006579399,
-0.22144192457199097,
-0.16738812625408173,
-1.0749760866165161,
-0.20394811034202576,
-0.9706084132194519,
-0.38239654898643494,
0.2951130270957947,
-0.6258302927017212,
0.34318193793296814,
-0.6208592653274536,
-0.40245744585990906,
0.38803261518478394,
0.4495129883289337,
-1.0456089973449707,
0.2752838134765625,
0.5036596059799194,
0.9165149331092834,
-0.5653581023216248,
0.7976468205451965,
0.9412850141525269,
-0.36159995198249817,
-0.7186561822891235,
0.009182139299809933,
-0.008825450204312801,
-0.6585179567337036,
0.7300460934638977,
-0.2858438193798065,
-0.10798370838165283,
0.1620161533355713,
-0.7253067493438721,
-1.0682514905929565,
1.08004629611969,
0.5904406905174255,
-0.6076873540878296,
-0.3363160789012909,
0.22490054368972778,
0.6491024494171143,
-0.5223662853240967,
0.09722030162811279,
0.6673285365104675,
0.30948638916015625,
0.10913952440023422,
-0.8680086731910706,
0.026564856991171837,
-0.039805129170417786,
0.42758652567863464,
0.1549578607082367,
-0.7861021757125854,
0.4619539678096771,
-0.17138215899467468,
-0.28437069058418274,
-0.09895408898591995,
0.7019290328025818,
0.1418350636959076,
0.19755728542804718,
0.6240900754928589,
0.9179704785346985,
0.801020085811615,
-0.13718925416469574,
0.7591527700424194,
-0.29243525862693787,
0.6482216715812683,
0.8326271176338196,
-0.5117613077163696,
1.0789209604263306,
0.4768037497997284,
-0.20551221072673798,
0.40152934193611145,
0.7904059290885925,
-0.11326786130666733,
0.7824161052703857,
0.4196609854698181,
0.06074034422636032,
-0.4983035922050476,
-0.07194824516773224,
-0.25700274109840393,
0.771999180316925,
0.6122298836708069,
-0.01890895701944828,
-0.35042691230773926,
-0.06748312711715698,
-0.3049556612968445,
0.056953076273202896,
-0.22361057996749878,
1.1439915895462036,
0.3059811294078827,
-0.45849037170410156,
0.6034544706344604,
0.04770935699343681,
0.6357457041740417,
-0.3101046681404114,
-0.02422504313290119,
-0.37235841155052185,
-0.1112753376364708,
-0.14895521104335785,
-0.9078495502471924,
0.16319331526756287,
-0.03548303619027138,
-0.16483977437019348,
-0.2146550714969635,
0.6066129207611084,
-0.18605513870716095,
-0.3956772983074188,
0.1823851764202118,
0.6877189874649048,
0.15324924886226654,
-0.16664573550224304,
-0.6614043712615967,
-0.16751602292060852,
-0.27656131982803345,
-0.24541330337524414,
0.5786513686180115,
0.9081780314445496,
-0.08449079841375351,
0.6186769604682922,
0.6170938611030579,
0.2612795829772949,
-0.19899864494800568,
0.11193902045488358,
1.0273984670639038,
-0.8807129263877869,
-0.25599998235702515,
-0.8514283895492554,
0.31600213050842285,
-0.0736587718129158,
-0.3825901448726654,
0.6159178614616394,
0.45105424523353577,
1.3257876634597778,
0.002270124852657318,
0.39549657702445984,
0.2036176323890686,
0.2819302976131439,
-0.8782199621200562,
0.8366843461990356,
-0.6844868063926697,
0.6311823129653931,
-0.0973801463842392,
-1.3446321487426758,
-0.15474316477775574,
0.5211305022239685,
-0.3043772876262665,
0.06020774692296982,
0.6688098311424255,
0.720647394657135,
-0.09759422391653061,
-0.20231804251670837,
0.5816003680229187,
0.3578417897224426,
0.055853117257356644,
0.4634605348110199,
1.2450984716415405,
-0.05539657548069954,
0.16777962446212769,
-0.35009434819221497,
-0.12472798675298691,
-0.17490331828594208,
-0.7624887824058533,
-0.8801169991493225,
-0.6861963272094727,
-0.4503133296966553,
-0.044475995004177094,
-0.1903463751077652,
0.819408118724823,
0.8989307284355164,
-0.7405228018760681,
-0.040937040001153946,
0.294800728559494,
0.17117179930210114,
0.04994359239935875,
-0.21883313357830048,
0.0984412282705307,
-0.5069152116775513,
-0.6225388646125793,
0.16515129804611206,
0.41968995332717896,
-0.14742441475391388,
-0.6261895298957825,
0.16317683458328247,
0.06378854066133499,
0.06827686727046967,
0.6750482320785522,
-0.26916176080703735,
-0.9177626371383667,
-0.44078633189201355,
0.00800821278244257,
-0.17903652787208557,
0.03855359926819801,
0.8052494525909424,
-0.8508468270301819,
-0.038549281656742096,
0.12051638215780258,
0.504747748374939,
0.49729639291763306,
-0.30096930265426636,
0.23949792981147766,
-1.1199140548706055,
-0.08172781020402908,
0.1920335441827774,
0.3286210894584656,
0.4290667176246643,
-0.42747724056243896,
0.591128408908844,
0.29538431763648987,
-0.4508298635482788,
-0.7638221979141235,
0.05813007056713104,
-0.9893028736114502,
-0.29099899530410767,
0.9696465730667114,
-0.008967390283942223,
-0.11777455359697342,
0.1436658501625061,
-0.043658848851919174,
0.14601446688175201,
-0.22976535558700562,
1.0576775074005127,
0.9917970299720764,
-0.12033654004335403,
-0.05843646451830864,
-0.5035520195960999,
0.652635931968689,
0.2825412154197693,
-0.5599880814552307,
-0.2736506462097168,
0.3644309937953949,
0.5379378795623779,
0.6202524304389954,
0.45297080278396606,
-0.05585632473230362,
-0.0763116404414177,
-0.11697345972061157,
-0.32284167408943176,
0.0937553197145462,
-0.5333574414253235,
-0.3853093981742859,
0.26091426610946655,
0.528911292552948,
0.013141777366399765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15319v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15319v1
|
GPTVQ: The Blessing of Dimensionality for LLM Quantization
| 2024-02-23T13:39:16 | 2024-02-23T13:39:16 |
Mart van Baalen, Andrey Kuzmin, Markus Nagel, Peter Couperus, Cedric Bastoul, Eric Mahurin, Tijmen Blankevoort, Paul Whatmough
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
In this work we show that the size versus accuracy trade-off of neural
network quantization can be significantly improved by increasing the
quantization dimensionality. We propose the GPTVQ method, a new fast method for
post-training vector quantization (VQ) that scales well to Large Language
Models (LLMs). Our method interleaves quantization of one or more columns with
updates to the remaining unquantized weights, using information from the
Hessian of the per-layer output reconstruction MSE. Quantization codebooks are
initialized using an efficient data-aware version of the EM algorithm. The
codebooks are then updated, and further compressed by using integer
quantization and SVD-based compression. GPTVQ establishes a new state-of-the
art in the size vs accuracy trade-offs on a wide range of LLMs such as Llama-v2
and Mistral. Furthermore, our method is efficient: on a single H100 it takes
between 3 and 11 hours to process a Llamav2-70B model, depending on
quantization setting. Lastly, with on-device timings for VQ decompression on a
mobile CPU we show that VQ leads to improved latency compared to using a 4-bit
integer format.
|
[
-0.33725863695144653,
-0.31794580817222595,
0.16100455820560455,
0.256632536649704,
-0.5337917804718018,
0.22261355817317963,
-0.2505282163619995,
-0.00016858879826031625,
0.22248944640159607,
0.23599939048290253,
-0.14682984352111816,
-0.3948926031589508,
-0.5895965099334717,
-0.2490948885679245,
-0.2582576870918274,
0.7274689078330994,
0.22792156040668488,
0.37606334686279297,
-0.4101700186729431,
-0.04142928868532181,
0.049580223858356476,
-0.7863743305206299,
-0.7839825749397278,
-0.09125375002622604,
0.5195558667182922,
0.0267220139503479,
0.8337337374687195,
0.9349199533462524,
0.6865096688270569,
0.29438742995262146,
-0.3289443552494049,
0.05261918157339096,
-0.4105265736579895,
-0.04676256701350212,
0.2624814808368683,
-0.42544177174568176,
-0.6552660465240479,
-0.08197639882564545,
0.8859379887580872,
0.4338521659374237,
-0.2215832769870758,
0.48001909255981445,
-0.11170977354049683,
0.7209839224815369,
-0.6739202737808228,
-0.059297818690538406,
-0.35224977135658264,
0.40910661220550537,
0.06113775074481964,
-0.37189605832099915,
0.028209760785102844,
-0.4350331723690033,
-0.007248935755342245,
-0.5004278421401978,
0.23712794482707977,
-0.20707106590270996,
0.5836083889007568,
0.6173537373542786,
-0.5207107663154602,
0.28684118390083313,
-0.8800466656684875,
0.750141978263855,
-0.6651390790939331,
0.4494442343711853,
0.28154653310775757,
0.3111383020877838,
0.2536914646625519,
-1.0340559482574463,
-0.5715320110321045,
-0.09985232353210449,
0.29087555408477783,
0.0530453585088253,
-0.031532950699329376,
0.1819201409816742,
0.6232925057411194,
0.6453984975814819,
-0.674254298210144,
0.14809565246105194,
-0.34916454553604126,
-0.3277633786201477,
0.7077018618583679,
0.11877814680337906,
0.22541682422161102,
-0.10959962755441666,
-0.274208664894104,
-0.19742892682552338,
-0.8755829334259033,
0.04634573683142662,
0.42259395122528076,
-0.2553667724132538,
0.17698732018470764,
0.560588538646698,
-0.4415387809276581,
0.5363042950630188,
-0.3805839419364929,
-0.18975073099136353,
0.17295944690704346,
-0.5358592867851257,
-0.45123055577278137,
0.03444010764360428,
0.8679186105728149,
0.3642646372318268,
-0.05641191080212593,
-0.04289517551660538,
-0.1790669858455658,
0.027974307537078857,
0.11855888366699219,
-1.211489200592041,
-0.4843168556690216,
0.4019679129123688,
-0.752440869808197,
-0.2761646807193756,
-0.433493971824646,
-0.4418888986110687,
-0.3069928288459778,
-0.5173462629318237,
0.6828200817108154,
-0.2890188694000244,
-0.25235477089881897,
0.1798994243144989,
-0.0913277268409729,
0.4088176488876343,
0.3991072475910187,
-0.9170905947685242,
0.2573808431625366,
0.6259155869483948,
0.9528684020042419,
0.20147351920604706,
0.14346987009048462,
-0.8094988465309143,
-0.17149053514003754,
-0.4399918019771576,
0.4108724594116211,
-0.18525436520576477,
-0.2683303654193878,
-0.24031230807304382,
-0.4642506539821625,
0.2984994053840637,
-0.48031529784202576,
0.3002872169017792,
-0.6206233501434326,
0.03578123077750206,
-0.3577929437160492,
-0.4189923107624054,
-0.019824646413326263,
0.1067420095205307,
-0.5448336005210876,
0.957980215549469,
0.011482038535177708,
-0.7089326977729797,
0.2509022653102875,
-0.15966840088367462,
-0.07102584838867188,
0.17621266841888428,
-0.10131953656673431,
-0.5277324914932251,
0.33396363258361816,
0.558613657951355,
0.600758969783783,
-0.35691773891448975,
-0.15233725309371948,
-0.09086272865533829,
-0.6092665791511536,
0.21055671572685242,
-0.5680738091468811,
0.8037409782409668,
0.22812481224536896,
0.02051655761897564,
0.0831865668296814,
-0.75470370054245,
0.6023528575897217,
-0.12571574747562408,
-0.5592296719551086,
-0.27291128039360046,
-0.17121684551239014,
-0.2710181176662445,
0.25153639912605286,
0.31476253271102905,
-0.4058193862438202,
0.5467234253883362,
-0.26421791315078735,
0.7537733912467957,
0.5603486895561218,
-0.21780847012996674,
0.5706645846366882,
0.08672340214252472,
0.6390557885169983,
-0.235901340842247,
0.4110123813152313,
0.13940726220607758,
-0.23757308721542358,
-0.6801169514656067,
-0.48589637875556946,
0.9719479084014893,
0.5785127282142639,
-1.2026201486587524,
0.24903127551078796,
-0.6755897402763367,
-0.3199131488800049,
-0.33280593156814575,
-0.21609988808631897,
0.4103085994720459,
-0.14350558817386627,
0.2011665552854538,
-0.5814582705497742,
-0.4840928316116333,
-0.6504066586494446,
-0.08641370385885239,
-0.07141228020191193,
-0.5119005441665649,
0.1213316023349762,
0.22875681519508362,
0.024280603975057602,
0.3747030198574066,
-0.19620002806186676,
-0.11897169053554535,
0.16127803921699524,
0.06707652658224106,
0.14971721172332764,
0.4864967167377472,
0.41759154200553894,
-0.6472247242927551,
-0.4271194040775299,
0.08848832547664642,
-0.7505532503128052,
0.16306552290916443,
0.01373707689344883,
-0.1271807849407196,
0.008366299793124199,
0.7008756995201111,
-0.6378912329673767,
0.5033846497535706,
0.6494553685188293,
-0.27938491106033325,
0.341749370098114,
-0.31352439522743225,
0.1800089031457901,
-0.9191749691963196,
-0.3882070779800415,
-0.012291260994970798,
-0.5229732394218445,
-0.4727688133716583,
-0.17758600413799286,
0.1501724123954773,
-0.13923706114292145,
-0.5456229448318481,
0.100656658411026,
-0.5493932366371155,
-0.5186827182769775,
-0.02820480428636074,
-0.024092616513371468,
-0.06752245873212814,
0.6071580648422241,
-0.28786179423332214,
0.9191756844520569,
0.39764952659606934,
-0.6039899587631226,
0.6180299520492554,
0.19581487774848938,
-0.2833791673183441,
0.37831994891166687,
-0.8932985067367554,
0.17103874683380127,
-0.34677600860595703,
0.03708929941058159,
-0.7860877513885498,
0.2893272936344147,
0.14946605265140533,
-0.7195722460746765,
0.44878360629081726,
-0.49724894762039185,
-0.4529549479484558,
-0.21619993448257446,
-0.5073931813240051,
0.7004820704460144,
0.5960717797279358,
-0.5885142683982849,
0.7171023488044739,
0.27630820870399475,
0.01700778864324093,
-0.6594100594520569,
-0.5651057362556458,
0.21592110395431519,
-0.24076427519321442,
-0.571256160736084,
0.5661352276802063,
-0.056142788380384445,
-0.05911315232515335,
0.022456085309386253,
-0.18191233277320862,
-0.07857829332351685,
-0.040784772485494614,
-0.013653775677084923,
0.11740047484636307,
-0.29366210103034973,
0.14254841208457947,
0.07378033548593521,
-0.09952221810817719,
0.16451402008533478,
-0.7158636450767517,
0.3455997109413147,
-0.19918201863765717,
0.1721378117799759,
-0.4857334494590759,
0.1645294576883316,
0.29360151290893555,
-0.4922986626625061,
0.7790355682373047,
1.0013535022735596,
-0.4058697521686554,
-0.19079113006591797,
-0.24459156394004822,
-0.008651521056890488,
-0.4710488021373749,
0.4622771143913269,
-0.4076026678085327,
-1.0085313320159912,
0.3249635100364685,
-0.11085891723632812,
-0.2517736852169037,
0.23167282342910767,
0.47386759519577026,
0.02463691495358944,
1.0803236961364746,
0.5547143220901489,
-0.03620278090238571,
0.6690958738327026,
-0.718088686466217,
0.36380770802497864,
-1.1020691394805908,
-0.01835758425295353,
-0.4112071990966797,
-0.34411200881004333,
-0.5671592950820923,
-0.896266758441925,
0.48780426383018494,
0.4043899178504944,
-0.3792351484298706,
0.07699819654226303,
-0.5701159834861755,
0.696635901927948,
0.724515974521637,
0.0987800881266594,
0.21186023950576782,
0.38043662905693054,
0.21856357157230377,
-0.27060768008232117,
-0.9381245374679565,
-0.18119941651821136,
1.4570244550704956,
0.3434849679470062,
0.5004708170890808,
0.2676132917404175,
0.5534585118293762,
0.2619839012622833,
0.30592072010040283,
-1.0612410306930542,
0.48068398237228394,
-0.3112183213233948,
0.16228702664375305,
-0.7451640963554382,
-0.8147523403167725,
-0.5711308121681213,
0.6736634373664856,
-0.30290845036506653,
-0.5855122804641724,
0.12049731612205505,
0.10579096525907516,
-0.7098974585533142,
0.36308565735816956,
-0.5743291974067688,
0.620979905128479,
-0.08015768229961395,
-0.3312406837940216,
-0.1694493442773819,
-0.5062612891197205,
0.42619940638542175,
0.19315268099308014,
-0.23491062223911285,
0.012358793057501316,
-0.214711531996727,
0.7222228646278381,
-0.7866941690444946,
0.3397873342037201,
-0.08698288351297379,
-0.16290242969989777,
0.10672394931316376,
0.09469626098871231,
0.5197613835334778,
0.404867023229599,
0.24143259227275848,
0.48297038674354553,
0.17636480927467346,
-0.37016743421554565,
-1.0431257486343384,
0.5806322693824768,
-0.8445842266082764,
-0.44070932269096375,
-0.3606473505496979,
-0.40033555030822754,
-0.2240879237651825,
-0.16181784868240356,
0.23773738741874695,
0.7627905011177063,
0.15259380638599396,
0.41449227929115295,
1.079982876777649,
-0.397763729095459,
0.5645833611488342,
0.05773695930838585,
-0.049790021032094955,
-0.8818777203559875,
1.1100698709487915,
0.2531956136226654,
0.21081602573394775,
0.7085440158843994,
0.026590166613459587,
-0.28650563955307007,
-0.8791254162788391,
-0.3789127469062805,
0.1535778045654297,
-0.5757741928100586,
-0.5309105515480042,
-0.5657578110694885,
-0.4108894467353821,
-0.32594671845436096,
0.43810781836509705,
-0.6671863198280334,
-0.7468007206916809,
-0.20896628499031067,
0.10501237958669662,
0.3188116252422333,
0.37391793727874756,
-0.3311651945114136,
0.3392747938632965,
-0.9681112766265869,
0.3838282823562622,
0.6735644936561584,
0.23493030667304993,
-0.09378409385681152,
-0.7990198731422424,
-0.5823358297348022,
0.01796957105398178,
-0.18848052620887756,
-0.27615249156951904,
0.632701575756073,
0.2046424001455307,
0.26619192957878113,
0.2126014530658722,
-0.23235806822776794,
0.41029906272888184,
-0.5087348818778992,
0.8412110209465027,
0.23881837725639343,
-1.1296697854995728,
0.14504767954349518,
-0.09536070376634598,
0.13973599672317505,
-0.10452508181333542,
0.43643152713775635,
-0.5194905400276184,
0.2455468475818634,
-0.3437497317790985,
-0.8529974818229675,
0.2721764147281647,
0.32276034355163574,
0.19446313381195068,
0.2573463022708893,
0.4860011339187622,
-0.4645423889160156,
0.4630192518234253,
-0.40616750717163086,
-0.40400680899620056,
-0.3681265115737915,
-0.05026950687170029,
-0.0917670726776123,
-0.7044914364814758,
-0.0014520169934257865,
-0.5897083282470703,
0.6077001094818115,
-0.35196492075920105,
0.788103461265564,
0.26045307517051697,
0.15140585601329803,
0.20756816864013672,
-0.027054190635681152,
0.6232539415359497,
0.6912592649459839,
0.028025442734360695,
0.10573136806488037,
0.11810130625963211,
-0.5829312205314636,
0.2290840446949005,
-0.04646819829940796,
0.04455389082431793,
-0.12012980133295059,
0.1176825761795044,
1.0386680364608765,
-0.172464981675148,
-0.18463823199272156,
0.7747830748558044,
-0.5087559819221497,
-0.6239006519317627,
-0.37225115299224854,
-0.14679411053657532,
-0.09708410501480103,
0.6448951959609985,
0.09694115817546844,
0.05196581408381462,
0.25400885939598083,
-0.061636634171009064,
-0.0762871503829956,
0.519062876701355,
-0.10883321613073349,
-0.20561759173870087,
0.9130126237869263,
0.013141226023435593,
-0.22914505004882812,
0.7893569469451904,
-0.23717786371707916,
-0.4716685116291046,
0.6347786784172058,
0.12077675759792328,
0.8171939849853516,
-0.21489979326725006,
0.5418994426727295,
0.35581740736961365,
0.29249900579452515,
-0.17723003029823303,
0.4221515357494354,
-0.11056959629058838,
-0.8169024586677551,
-1.072452425956726,
-0.6601920127868652,
-0.14660266041755676,
0.24075515568256378,
-0.6451201438903809,
-0.10403971374034882,
-0.598520040512085,
-0.24672628939151764,
-0.18504056334495544,
0.09962555021047592,
-0.763986349105835,
0.35648179054260254,
0.17930865287780762,
0.6573752164840698,
-0.2821623980998993,
0.9954087138175964,
0.3901109993457794,
-0.060847267508506775,
-0.9315946102142334,
-0.043164145201444626,
-0.36767303943634033,
-0.5239892601966858,
0.7225836515426636,
-0.17910882830619812,
0.21625223755836487,
0.3131364583969116,
-0.6127344965934753,
-1.1850767135620117,
1.2864857912063599,
0.4294121563434601,
-0.6920776963233948,
0.12994582951068878,
0.04415370151400566,
0.6411582827568054,
0.032586682587862015,
0.27432751655578613,
0.5378603935241699,
-0.055525269359350204,
0.09201669692993164,
-0.6488457322120667,
-0.0633874386548996,
-0.2099909782409668,
0.7635272145271301,
0.29015082120895386,
-0.6352065801620483,
0.8951927423477173,
-0.23247095942497253,
-0.0026038868818432093,
0.12122273445129395,
0.989726722240448,
-0.12033611536026001,
-0.2807343304157257,
0.31018155813217163,
0.7579857110977173,
0.9188122749328613,
-0.028559375554323196,
1.2544097900390625,
-0.2137332409620285,
0.513078510761261,
0.73280268907547,
0.19093433022499084,
0.7472655177116394,
0.5881682634353638,
-0.5803210139274597,
-0.0006307162111625075,
0.6378023624420166,
0.15539617836475372,
0.5089049935340881,
0.7447262406349182,
-0.5801775455474854,
-0.39984995126724243,
-0.004180965479463339,
-0.40404772758483887,
0.35647517442703247,
0.28053659200668335,
-0.10497181862592697,
0.2841743230819702,
0.1977667212486267,
-0.2094799429178238,
-0.2677995562553406,
-0.6054155230522156,
0.516347348690033,
0.13773131370544434,
-0.09168943762779236,
1.0119569301605225,
0.04596221074461937,
0.5982916355133057,
-0.2792343199253082,
-0.022835567593574524,
-0.3391630947589874,
0.07240530103445053,
-0.11697672307491302,
-0.3590538501739502,
0.1312866359949112,
-0.43265300989151,
-0.17635290324687958,
-0.30796295404434204,
0.4157657325267792,
-0.5177612900733948,
-0.47076481580734253,
-0.19529137015342712,
0.5277680158615112,
0.15050317347049713,
-0.4487767815589905,
-0.41386473178863525,
0.2175486981868744,
-0.04867546632885933,
-0.44622835516929626,
0.4407629668712616,
0.6364561915397644,
0.06782025098800659,
0.6572899222373962,
0.5489528179168701,
0.29719915986061096,
0.25397390127182007,
0.2107289880514145,
0.845971941947937,
-0.6194524168968201,
-0.29887011647224426,
-0.6607666611671448,
0.3453090190887451,
-0.03068395145237446,
-0.24460561573505402,
0.634174644947052,
0.3941289186477661,
1.0760904550552368,
-0.08773685246706009,
0.756071150302887,
0.2531469762325287,
0.12320811301469803,
-0.9123520255088806,
0.47605279088020325,
-0.6264805197715759,
0.5528543591499329,
0.15361647307872772,
-0.9965512752532959,
-0.5412416458129883,
0.6492223143577576,
-0.1942613273859024,
-0.0153151024132967,
0.7969886064529419,
0.719554603099823,
0.1699160486459732,
-0.2571183741092682,
0.6244283318519592,
-0.034151047468185425,
0.2275688499212265,
0.5637438893318176,
0.8856582641601562,
-0.8632500171661377,
0.5934221744537354,
-0.39539217948913574,
-0.16184532642364502,
0.08774829655885696,
-0.81031733751297,
-0.9309312105178833,
-0.3329421877861023,
-0.7239681482315063,
-0.49529287219047546,
0.011381874792277813,
0.6866828203201294,
0.7389407157897949,
-0.39642664790153503,
0.037894219160079956,
0.032866716384887695,
0.0968257486820221,
-0.2992556393146515,
-0.21592631936073303,
0.44995567202568054,
-0.03206479549407959,
-0.7052724957466125,
0.20700670778751373,
0.2134070098400116,
0.18911021947860718,
-0.39423686265945435,
-0.09134095907211304,
0.3961310088634491,
-0.06298519670963287,
0.9115897417068481,
0.0655607283115387,
-0.2965497374534607,
-0.24425539374351501,
-0.1321391463279724,
-0.05955825746059418,
0.18192458152770996,
1.1487785577774048,
-0.7881738543510437,
0.1949138343334198,
0.7064191699028015,
0.789219856262207,
0.6576074361801147,
-0.1207726001739502,
0.5789101123809814,
-0.8489164710044861,
0.312693327665329,
0.25504958629608154,
0.21809591352939606,
0.3790148198604584,
-0.6372703909873962,
0.41568103432655334,
0.2393224537372589,
-0.7643163204193115,
-0.7111977934837341,
0.05792859569191933,
-0.8041191101074219,
-0.09000269323587418,
1.1566869020462036,
-0.05933938920497894,
-0.41728582978248596,
0.40798038244247437,
-0.09176148474216461,
0.2455698400735855,
-0.17223407328128815,
0.6031412482261658,
0.3575358986854553,
0.19549570977687836,
-0.5290334820747375,
-0.6969618797302246,
0.8672807812690735,
0.2691591680049896,
-0.6537996530532837,
-0.24318313598632812,
0.26261284947395325,
0.14859485626220703,
-0.28387701511383057,
0.7522168159484863,
-0.09012861549854279,
0.20736421644687653,
0.11121535301208496,
0.31113898754119873,
-0.18134815990924835,
-0.36184993386268616,
-0.614600658416748,
-0.0906175971031189,
-0.12342161685228348,
-0.3869043290615082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15313v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15313v2
|
ArabianGPT: Native Arabic GPT-based Large Language Model
| 2024-02-23T13:32:47 | 2024-02-26T09:54:47 |
Anis Koubaa, Adel Ammar, Lahouari Ghouti, Omar Najar, Serry Sibaee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The predominance of English and Latin-based large language models (LLMs) has
led to a notable deficit in native Arabic LLMs. This discrepancy is accentuated
by the prevalent inclusion of English tokens in existing Arabic models,
detracting from their efficacy in processing native Arabic's intricate
morphology and syntax. Consequently, there is a theoretical and practical
imperative for developing LLMs predominantly focused on Arabic linguistic
elements. To address this gap, this paper proposes ArabianGPT, a series of
transformer-based models within the ArabianLLM suite designed explicitly for
Arabic. These models, including ArabianGPT-0.1B and ArabianGPT-0.3B, vary in
size and complexity, aligning with the nuanced linguistic characteristics of
Arabic. The AraNizer tokenizer, integral to these models, addresses the unique
morphological aspects of Arabic script, ensuring more accurate text processing.
Empirical results from fine-tuning the models on tasks like sentiment analysis
and summarization demonstrate significant improvements. For sentiment analysis,
the fine-tuned ArabianGPT-0.1B model achieved a remarkable accuracy of 95%, a
substantial increase from the base model's 56%. Similarly, in summarization
tasks, fine-tuned models showed enhanced F1 scores, indicating improved
precision and recall in generating concise summaries. Comparative analysis of
fine-tuned ArabianGPT models against their base versions across various
benchmarks reveals nuanced differences in performance, with fine-tuning
positively impacting specific tasks like question answering and summarization.
These findings underscore the efficacy of fine-tuning in aligning ArabianGPT
models more closely with specific NLP tasks, highlighting the potential of
tailored transformer architectures in advancing Arabic NLP.
|
[
-0.6177396774291992,
-0.708787739276886,
0.3559527099132538,
0.29275384545326233,
-0.2829635441303253,
0.36718419194221497,
-0.23576609790325165,
-0.47731783986091614,
0.1342002898454666,
0.3840293884277344,
-0.26034918427467346,
-0.6419994235038757,
-0.8734360337257385,
0.23953041434288025,
-0.4670425057411194,
1.2584726810455322,
-0.32153135538101196,
-0.17222853004932404,
0.35444703698158264,
-0.07072983682155609,
-0.4299546480178833,
-0.43210142850875854,
-0.6836205124855042,
-0.360602468252182,
0.2314121276140213,
0.35931408405303955,
1.368930459022522,
0.5367187261581421,
0.5611283183097839,
0.2100553959608078,
-0.16677038371562958,
0.17203845083713531,
-0.06557037681341171,
0.014064601622521877,
-0.07327961921691895,
-0.17547689378261566,
-0.7097296118736267,
-0.31543612480163574,
0.4426437020301819,
0.6852007508277893,
-0.3456536531448364,
0.12864625453948975,
-0.05252355709671974,
0.6338905692100525,
-0.518147885799408,
0.2045108824968338,
-0.5823447108268738,
-0.04712650179862976,
0.038387175649404526,
0.315990149974823,
-0.1365383267402649,
-0.09845903515815735,
0.030817365273833275,
-0.08757252991199493,
0.2736225724220276,
0.02695929817855358,
0.7151363492012024,
0.29681289196014404,
-0.5405796766281128,
-0.2951982617378235,
-0.8060715198516846,
0.6754319071769714,
-0.839888870716095,
0.41251668334007263,
0.2797258496284485,
0.283810019493103,
-0.019227584823966026,
-0.8717911243438721,
-0.46792376041412354,
-0.6026293039321899,
-0.10711628943681717,
0.17536661028862,
-0.24776366353034973,
0.16846273839473724,
-0.12297194451093674,
0.6252622008323669,
-0.654534101486206,
0.0908934473991394,
-0.16972824931144714,
-0.0987783893942833,
0.509953498840332,
0.27795708179473877,
0.41302138566970825,
-0.06598187983036041,
-0.08125194162130356,
0.19592681527137756,
-0.9667482972145081,
-0.08942942321300507,
0.16231083869934082,
0.38957980275154114,
-0.1586180031299591,
0.5234698057174683,
-0.25816595554351807,
0.5507529377937317,
-0.03498305380344391,
-0.1671678125858307,
-0.2626066505908966,
-0.0008570866193622351,
-0.03854529187083244,
0.2817288339138031,
0.5809853076934814,
0.1638643890619278,
0.3895490765571594,
-0.2852453589439392,
-0.40869447588920593,
0.07973471283912659,
0.13083213567733765,
-1.0946004390716553,
-0.19896025955677032,
0.22175756096839905,
-0.40655967593193054,
-0.11877179145812988,
-0.07766542583703995,
-0.23629239201545715,
-0.1894836276769638,
-0.3027413785457611,
0.3127634525299072,
-0.42602452635765076,
-0.18226267397403717,
0.43666520714759827,
0.31739041209220886,
0.2290920913219452,
0.38963809609413147,
-1.0210614204406738,
0.47065600752830505,
0.763952910900116,
1.1804108619689941,
-0.563101053237915,
-0.15419991314411163,
-0.1959628164768219,
0.3238816559314728,
-0.25872451066970825,
0.7196037769317627,
-0.7035530805587769,
-0.5389300584793091,
0.12366632372140884,
-0.24057728052139282,
0.10758081823587418,
-0.39351293444633484,
0.7047592401504517,
-0.6957920789718628,
0.03666028752923012,
0.14440268278121948,
-0.4745009243488312,
-0.4036219120025635,
0.3030347228050232,
-0.7085853219032288,
0.8149504065513611,
0.11282280832529068,
-0.6202149987220764,
0.04634464904665947,
-0.9302088618278503,
-0.4508845806121826,
0.018098533153533936,
0.027618203312158585,
-0.37567007541656494,
0.18612666428089142,
0.5767449736595154,
0.28775253891944885,
-0.44477877020835876,
0.17594899237155914,
0.32187116146087646,
-0.6081191301345825,
-0.07873137295246124,
-0.5325633883476257,
0.2086988091468811,
0.15993806719779968,
-0.36560213565826416,
0.14523160457611084,
-0.5874083042144775,
-0.15114592015743256,
-0.08587837964296341,
-0.25694549083709717,
0.11123905330896378,
0.012620124965906143,
0.4749951660633087,
0.20001918077468872,
0.3483380079269409,
-0.3700508177280426,
0.2693401873111725,
-0.5924974083900452,
0.4116872251033783,
0.5300881862640381,
-0.0375647097826004,
0.3052334487438202,
-0.3721983730792999,
0.9029552340507507,
-0.09945989400148392,
-0.03617300093173981,
-0.26998838782310486,
-0.43522003293037415,
-0.9749961495399475,
-0.3954710066318512,
0.3814246952533722,
0.6047823429107666,
-0.5466057658195496,
0.28810226917266846,
-0.3721882104873657,
-0.7670903205871582,
-0.48283034563064575,
-0.13465455174446106,
-0.00664650509133935,
0.25742805004119873,
0.5185520052909851,
-0.22684615850448608,
-0.14885106682777405,
-1.145115852355957,
-0.4334794878959656,
0.009763038717210293,
0.01076249685138464,
0.018125800415873528,
0.508147120475769,
-0.23436613380908966,
0.945927619934082,
-0.3992520272731781,
-0.20180507004261017,
-0.5909838676452637,
0.17924298346042633,
0.5798956155776978,
0.33848440647125244,
0.3640332818031311,
-0.7046229839324951,
-1.0247575044631958,
0.3649832606315613,
-0.24618661403656006,
-0.23181359469890594,
0.16129758954048157,
0.2913191318511963,
0.29607096314430237,
0.4557417035102844,
-0.9393641352653503,
0.49654337763786316,
0.5939182043075562,
-0.3774076998233795,
0.5899266004562378,
-0.0028743743896484375,
-0.03573496639728546,
-1.1534814834594727,
0.010486266575753689,
-0.1689678579568863,
-0.355877548456192,
-0.639348030090332,
0.14578469097614288,
-0.08074365556240082,
-0.1130843311548233,
-0.4812833368778229,
0.7175279855728149,
-0.29810258746147156,
0.2068575620651245,
-0.7196633815765381,
-0.28766676783561707,
-0.1858200579881668,
0.33933866024017334,
0.11942342668771744,
1.4231328964233398,
0.3738868534564972,
-0.3507515788078308,
0.09403737634420395,
0.2840906083583832,
-0.2721549868583679,
-0.0003635242464952171,
-1.1928057670593262,
0.22317098081111908,
-0.22507788240909576,
-0.01702619343996048,
-0.8004348874092102,
0.004505525808781385,
-0.09372774511575699,
-0.16851599514484406,
0.2977047562599182,
-0.2657281756401062,
-0.4586286246776581,
0.21092195808887482,
-0.1850888580083847,
0.29067620635032654,
0.8184210658073425,
-0.25312307476997375,
1.0246412754058838,
0.06947153061628342,
-0.849664568901062,
-0.531633198261261,
-0.10599447041749954,
0.2593611478805542,
-0.1934145838022232,
-0.6192575693130493,
0.5984498858451843,
0.44628995656967163,
-0.22605714201927185,
-0.21701915562152863,
-0.11395356059074402,
0.1793641299009323,
0.02902495488524437,
0.32545721530914307,
0.17090493440628052,
-0.4004661738872528,
0.06887699663639069,
0.19126473367214203,
-0.35103508830070496,
-0.09199526160955429,
-0.3240911662578583,
0.881924033164978,
-0.5146270394325256,
-0.46947500109672546,
-0.19255311787128448,
0.5509422421455383,
0.5494513511657715,
-0.6301612257957458,
0.959136962890625,
0.7804532647132874,
-0.16498906910419464,
-0.07836773991584778,
-0.43719351291656494,
-0.1136653944849968,
-0.5130525231361389,
0.8181126117706299,
-0.4503019154071808,
-0.9551489353179932,
0.520068347454071,
-0.1818009614944458,
0.10260352492332458,
0.5316120386123657,
0.8337932825088501,
0.2577597200870514,
1.4312924146652222,
0.8106735944747925,
-0.4245123565196991,
0.17215269804000854,
-0.012139776721596718,
0.37552565336227417,
-0.6545111536979675,
0.2803898751735687,
-0.4869190752506256,
-0.24047072231769562,
-0.8053500056266785,
-0.13597559928894043,
0.6453322768211365,
0.1179240420460701,
-0.643163800239563,
-0.08479095995426178,
-0.19089730083942413,
0.6754469275474548,
0.5108460783958435,
-0.26203787326812744,
0.5199095606803894,
0.32295888662338257,
0.0773974061012268,
-0.1318429410457611,
-0.5465863943099976,
-1.0485572814941406,
1.0275421142578125,
0.35921475291252136,
0.7318248152732849,
0.5078717470169067,
0.3329960107803345,
0.49454784393310547,
0.4537650942802429,
-0.7310433387756348,
0.2400803565979004,
-0.24269720911979675,
-0.19650782644748688,
-0.039534877985715866,
0.09403310716152191,
-0.7717968225479126,
0.269551157951355,
0.08354242146015167,
-0.6395418047904968,
-0.37239620089530945,
-0.002017010934650898,
-0.28187617659568787,
0.1733551174402237,
-0.5895956158638,
0.7666007280349731,
0.04762771725654602,
-0.32112038135528564,
-0.17537184059619904,
-0.43951794505119324,
0.0690046101808548,
-0.11666510999202728,
-0.04341621696949005,
-0.1449434608221054,
-0.2357177734375,
0.6136495471000671,
-0.48713910579681396,
0.7151133418083191,
0.11055033653974533,
-0.17319706082344055,
0.20110538601875305,
0.40164998173713684,
0.7175042629241943,
0.12597033381462097,
-0.07253147661685944,
0.32091671228408813,
-0.1649184226989746,
-0.5177631378173828,
-0.548407793045044,
0.5367597937583923,
-1.0161300897598267,
-0.9174894094467163,
-0.4755617082118988,
-0.7021876573562622,
-0.4320068359375,
0.12037971615791321,
0.02122434228658676,
0.15356877446174622,
-0.1754063218832016,
-0.12325437366962433,
0.23952676355838776,
-0.16441303491592407,
0.41773027181625366,
0.6934593915939331,
-0.5300779342651367,
-0.2484004944562912,
0.7258530259132385,
-0.14765557646751404,
0.22194993495941162,
0.2778976261615753,
-0.1172705590724945,
-0.2703157961368561,
-0.9667827486991882,
-0.6155428290367126,
0.23115818202495575,
-0.7031594514846802,
-0.2598676383495331,
-0.5876915454864502,
-0.32281023263931274,
-0.04716576635837555,
-0.11081738770008087,
-0.40770623087882996,
-0.5706761479377747,
0.061120208352804184,
-0.1601901650428772,
0.604856550693512,
0.9496942162513733,
0.19728420674800873,
0.7775900363922119,
-0.982749342918396,
0.05922155827283859,
0.16054092347621918,
0.14127512276172638,
0.07674139738082886,
-0.8059856295585632,
-0.2750718891620636,
0.047886598855257034,
-0.5622678399085999,
-0.7123222947120667,
0.6626175045967102,
0.3413321077823639,
-0.08682785928249359,
0.1617579460144043,
-0.35788998007774353,
0.3938966989517212,
-0.8972471356391907,
0.8920061588287354,
-0.24286220967769623,
-1.073796272277832,
0.37561747431755066,
-0.5103082060813904,
0.38820549845695496,
0.40582358837127686,
0.46158766746520996,
-0.9448758363723755,
-0.38426482677459717,
-0.30026400089263916,
-0.9671087861061096,
0.48430076241493225,
0.44413766264915466,
0.3548009395599365,
-0.04270251467823982,
0.4752495586872101,
0.278201162815094,
0.21125449240207672,
-0.5303861498832703,
-0.32987192273139954,
-0.08156263828277588,
-0.5166199803352356,
-0.17341019213199615,
-0.1431061327457428,
0.3414081335067749,
-0.16255275905132294,
0.8589912056922913,
-0.15239217877388,
0.07223235070705414,
0.01654898189008236,
-0.2731974124908447,
0.20349180698394775,
0.3625011742115021,
0.6003240942955017,
0.7321736216545105,
-0.2052476555109024,
0.08497337996959686,
0.2662045955657959,
-0.909783661365509,
0.27271056175231934,
0.2904007136821747,
-0.3362448811531067,
0.16877102851867676,
0.5669987797737122,
0.6158959269523621,
-0.333067387342453,
-0.6527934074401855,
0.3868653178215027,
0.03240412101149559,
0.33328360319137573,
-0.43179410696029663,
0.13485820591449738,
0.2334485650062561,
0.0988256186246872,
0.4390993118286133,
0.008935646153986454,
0.23718413710594177,
-0.3039495646953583,
0.01542907115072012,
0.46690377593040466,
-0.4161350727081299,
-0.361919105052948,
0.6187211871147156,
0.08420064300298691,
-0.3421928584575653,
0.6531121730804443,
-0.044256314635276794,
-0.8129773139953613,
0.6271042227745056,
0.7297452092170715,
0.6260440945625305,
-0.3131539225578308,
0.0904555544257164,
0.027575643733143806,
0.33167940378189087,
0.13985401391983032,
0.25900232791900635,
0.2656014859676361,
-0.738429844379425,
-0.775750994682312,
-0.7720860242843628,
-0.5035452842712402,
-0.011258866637945175,
-0.35593271255493164,
0.19276787340641022,
-0.330066055059433,
-0.00778961181640625,
-0.12099909037351608,
-0.015242965891957283,
-0.5925927758216858,
0.1012779027223587,
0.029919153079390526,
1.0061287879943848,
-0.791157066822052,
0.7257398366928101,
0.9005622267723083,
-0.47077542543411255,
-0.8910382986068726,
-0.060649603605270386,
-0.4158197343349457,
-1.0596662759780884,
0.680196225643158,
0.14085419476032257,
-0.25805002450942993,
0.2600135803222656,
-0.33753687143325806,
-0.9457820653915405,
0.9512729644775391,
0.31812456250190735,
-0.48227548599243164,
0.13116806745529175,
0.7296125292778015,
0.5179384350776672,
-0.25042879581451416,
0.5916743874549866,
0.7440395355224609,
0.3165491223335266,
-0.08502380549907684,
-1.1983875036239624,
-0.09132079780101776,
-0.2546662390232086,
0.15818753838539124,
0.6270723938941956,
-0.707234263420105,
1.1222243309020996,
0.03553257882595062,
0.03864135965704918,
0.14969483017921448,
0.720678448677063,
0.1500185877084732,
-0.2867586016654968,
-0.018826302140951157,
0.45355454087257385,
0.39436766505241394,
-0.0588984340429306,
1.1515653133392334,
-0.651757001876831,
0.2947649657726288,
0.8848138451576233,
-0.37826621532440186,
0.8389149308204651,
0.46475517749786377,
-0.3731164336204529,
0.5729917287826538,
0.29074546694755554,
0.24648022651672363,
0.48579540848731995,
0.1229320615530014,
-0.7255120873451233,
-0.2450942099094391,
-0.3818054497241974,
-0.5435318350791931,
0.6599951982498169,
0.3248702883720398,
-0.3201184868812561,
-0.384277880191803,
-0.11996154487133026,
0.33042243123054504,
-0.014237120747566223,
-0.5814302563667297,
0.7089726328849792,
0.15172798931598663,
-0.5075419545173645,
0.5433704257011414,
0.7771961092948914,
0.6694868206977844,
-0.6480603218078613,
-0.22426383197307587,
-0.5680396556854248,
0.1373865157365799,
-0.07507174462080002,
-0.47506099939346313,
0.2487417608499527,
0.14314934611320496,
-0.1740967184305191,
0.10580796003341675,
0.8296550512313843,
-0.34842008352279663,
-0.9245730042457581,
-0.28399595618247986,
0.8065715432167053,
0.014879501424729824,
-0.4953448474407196,
-0.4417177438735962,
0.03554566577076912,
-0.0008780289790593088,
-0.25737816095352173,
0.13707497715950012,
0.25757238268852234,
-0.32415369153022766,
0.592662513256073,
0.5474156737327576,
0.30235183238983154,
-0.2297256886959076,
0.09634990990161896,
0.6401413679122925,
-0.8446803092956543,
-0.5518758893013,
-1.2008694410324097,
0.3104039132595062,
0.15904909372329712,
-0.16941989958286285,
0.6382917165756226,
0.5011692047119141,
0.358264297246933,
-0.2373274564743042,
0.902427613735199,
0.3026789724826813,
0.4329048991203308,
-0.6339587569236755,
0.8587124943733215,
-0.2134389728307724,
0.17300578951835632,
0.03845923766493797,
-1.1309845447540283,
-0.35885050892829895,
0.760079026222229,
-0.4003216326236725,
0.41421517729759216,
0.5241259336471558,
0.8062534332275391,
-0.20087707042694092,
0.2765361964702606,
0.09313670545816422,
0.20338433980941772,
0.5650427937507629,
0.605600118637085,
1.0498939752578735,
-0.5037364959716797,
0.18308962881565094,
0.02642599679529667,
0.05428634211421013,
-0.05726422369480133,
-0.8970051407814026,
-0.9555490016937256,
-0.15014886856079102,
-0.22661665081977844,
-0.05423003435134888,
0.15142665803432465,
1.2486437559127808,
0.5008889436721802,
-0.9036331176757812,
-0.18689674139022827,
-0.230463907122612,
-0.18439768254756927,
0.12567739188671112,
-0.1989656537771225,
0.8438851237297058,
-0.19314847886562347,
-0.7034958004951477,
0.07550935447216034,
0.40546715259552,
0.3152039647102356,
-0.16808243095874786,
-0.1625269055366516,
0.25964125990867615,
0.01182328537106514,
0.7204092144966125,
-0.09061592817306519,
-0.681058943271637,
-0.21578168869018555,
0.00013018936442676932,
0.0921778455376625,
0.1317414492368698,
0.5489434599876404,
-0.8791741728782654,
-0.21927526593208313,
-0.1776881217956543,
0.7429172992706299,
0.5066967010498047,
0.004259170964360237,
0.6588479280471802,
-0.6294114589691162,
0.3383798599243164,
0.4585530161857605,
0.38224291801452637,
0.4108718931674957,
-0.06592623144388199,
0.400669127702713,
-0.3558257818222046,
-0.4498547315597534,
-0.446624755859375,
0.33744198083877563,
-0.6025338768959045,
-0.03738951310515404,
1.0606859922409058,
0.09517039358615875,
0.10834429413080215,
-0.21442516148090363,
-0.5944280624389648,
-0.01458943821489811,
-0.3840801417827606,
0.9272319078445435,
0.9818682670593262,
-0.0754556655883789,
-0.13591966032981873,
-0.6355192065238953,
0.5732526183128357,
0.8029782772064209,
-0.6842857003211975,
-0.21018856763839722,
0.2179454267024994,
0.1496431976556778,
0.057042889297008514,
0.33837077021598816,
0.10282403975725174,
0.3711114823818207,
-0.298519104719162,
0.09196925163269043,
-0.15493513643741608,
-0.11469952017068863,
-0.3170088827610016,
0.2358597368001938,
0.6782253384590149,
0.23887327313423157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15309v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15309v1
|
Counterfactual Generation with Identifiability Guarantees
| 2024-02-23T13:24:19 | 2024-02-23T13:24:19 |
Hanqi Yan, Lingjing Kong, Lin Gui, Yuejie Chi, Eric Xing, Yulan He, Kun Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Counterfactual generation lies at the core of various machine learning tasks,
including image translation and controllable text generation. This generation
process usually requires the identification of the disentangled latent
representations, such as content and style, that underlie the observed data.
However, it becomes more challenging when faced with a scarcity of paired data
and labeling information. Existing disentangled methods crucially rely on
oversimplified assumptions, such as assuming independent content and style
variables, to identify the latent variables, even though such assumptions may
not hold for complex data distributions. For instance, food reviews tend to
involve words like tasty, whereas movie reviews commonly contain words such as
thrilling for the same positive sentiment. This problem is exacerbated when
data are sampled from multiple domains since the dependence between content and
style may vary significantly over domains. In this work, we tackle the
domain-varying dependence between the content and the style variables inherent
in the counterfactual generation task. We provide identification guarantees for
such latent-variable models by leveraging the relative sparsity of the
influences from different latent variables. Our theoretical insights enable the
development of a doMain AdapTive counTerfactual gEneration model, called
(MATTE). Our theoretically grounded framework achieves state-of-the-art
performance in unsupervised style transfer tasks, where neither paired data nor
style labels are utilized, across four large-scale datasets. Code is available
at https://github.com/hanqi-qi/Matte.git
|
[
-0.6265748739242554,
-1.0001537799835205,
0.5969734191894531,
0.19551856815814972,
-0.3292747735977173,
0.15710946917533875,
-0.09498260915279388,
-0.10425472259521484,
0.04481266438961029,
0.4407750368118286,
-0.8056423664093018,
-0.21919308602809906,
-0.7269807457923889,
-0.16909952461719513,
-0.37307339906692505,
1.2599425315856934,
-0.3141900599002838,
-0.055646322667598724,
-0.43672290444374084,
-0.2632848918437958,
-0.3738146424293518,
-0.40646660327911377,
-0.2921297550201416,
-0.3594084084033966,
0.29542315006256104,
0.24275019764900208,
0.764550507068634,
0.009254091419279575,
0.27390849590301514,
0.2693900763988495,
0.46040078997612,
0.4698564112186432,
-0.46890294551849365,
0.12343048304319382,
-0.5353132486343384,
-0.1327470988035202,
-0.2544081509113312,
0.42292532324790955,
0.24052059650421143,
0.5316640734672546,
0.024192562326788902,
0.06029607728123665,
0.08775606006383896,
0.6165339350700378,
-0.6504642367362976,
0.05232037603855133,
-0.7472662925720215,
0.019380103796720505,
-0.02500494383275509,
-0.2706776261329651,
-0.4252806603908539,
-0.21898113191127777,
-0.06562670320272446,
-0.7457928657531738,
0.5148906707763672,
-0.11292978376150131,
1.0641505718231201,
0.33670759201049805,
-0.41322240233421326,
-0.1689450591802597,
-0.872919499874115,
0.9049526453018188,
-0.4824957847595215,
0.34526848793029785,
0.6283825635910034,
0.10799868404865265,
-0.28323760628700256,
-0.6090805530548096,
-0.9607665538787842,
0.018549490720033646,
-0.14175070822238922,
0.40507254004478455,
-0.33122962713241577,
-0.32857635617256165,
0.09596826881170273,
0.21714867651462555,
-0.6478578448295593,
-0.09918959438800812,
0.1719733625650406,
0.04523928090929985,
0.6385871767997742,
-0.002688586013391614,
0.2721729576587677,
-0.00875258632004261,
-0.51687091588974,
-0.2298867106437683,
-0.7187023758888245,
-0.24385033547878265,
0.24143265187740326,
-0.0393800288438797,
-0.17771804332733154,
0.36862969398498535,
-0.10300153493881226,
0.2271595299243927,
0.5140962600708008,
0.2085217386484146,
0.35211503505706787,
-0.5651641488075256,
-0.12152646481990814,
-0.15328887104988098,
0.6958371996879578,
0.6783636808395386,
0.11981449276208878,
-0.10729232430458069,
-0.30026310682296753,
0.18740400671958923,
0.47990673780441284,
-0.8669513463973999,
-0.35977691411972046,
0.21434855461120605,
-0.1937561333179474,
-0.3471437394618988,
0.07320407778024673,
-0.9631191492080688,
-0.44280922412872314,
-0.31263527274131775,
0.6153081059455872,
-0.3112872838973999,
-0.3977890908718109,
-0.19080385565757751,
-0.17216169834136963,
0.0013140138471499085,
0.3353898525238037,
-0.6918318867683411,
0.20996399223804474,
0.32293611764907837,
0.7416807413101196,
-0.29334214329719543,
-0.1756555438041687,
-0.5189869999885559,
0.0020155017264187336,
-0.8169498443603516,
0.40307098627090454,
-0.550864577293396,
-0.4212106466293335,
-0.03144129738211632,
0.2559712827205658,
-0.13759760558605194,
-0.47553750872612,
-0.02429782599210739,
-0.7101052403450012,
0.14717507362365723,
-0.42754438519477844,
-0.4060743451118469,
-0.10132815688848495,
0.025376278907060623,
-0.5662888884544373,
0.8085671663284302,
0.37677037715911865,
-0.8656402230262756,
0.5868834257125854,
-0.3961186110973358,
-0.40029144287109375,
0.06097858399152756,
-0.38940224051475525,
-0.967683732509613,
0.36005285382270813,
0.03804059326648712,
0.3692512512207031,
-0.1598738729953766,
0.6601141691207886,
-0.5560126900672913,
-0.12168235331773758,
0.5781623721122742,
-0.5795410871505737,
0.5179851055145264,
0.27708834409713745,
-0.6459245085716248,
0.009868627414107323,
-0.739879310131073,
-0.28190913796424866,
0.3719174265861511,
0.10921579599380493,
-0.2778404951095581,
0.017023373395204544,
0.3173593580722809,
0.24781057238578796,
0.009023228660225868,
-0.6023232340812683,
0.0034532288555055857,
0.2307760864496231,
0.25631222128868103,
0.6984968185424805,
0.405049204826355,
0.21079054474830627,
-0.47937554121017456,
0.34129390120506287,
0.5038875341415405,
-0.12634208798408508,
-0.21504691243171692,
-0.2494853436946869,
-0.6704281568527222,
-0.24786287546157837,
0.17685063183307648,
0.5151501297950745,
-1.284336805343628,
0.15348514914512634,
0.029710562899708748,
-0.29772767424583435,
0.021961892023682594,
0.10101407766342163,
0.6772909760475159,
0.5803859233856201,
0.566743791103363,
-0.3855266869068146,
-0.5481899976730347,
-0.845066487789154,
-0.011462369933724403,
-0.11799167841672897,
0.023492082953453064,
0.41852274537086487,
0.49995720386505127,
-0.26072263717651367,
1.0220482349395752,
-0.6763184070587158,
-0.13296553492546082,
0.02180103398859501,
0.7438914179801941,
0.03263041004538536,
0.8887893557548523,
0.9173795580863953,
-1.2047922611236572,
-0.4792642295360565,
-0.18602880835533142,
-0.683880090713501,
-0.16377338767051697,
-0.5970262289047241,
-0.05157080665230751,
0.42539823055267334,
0.6805853247642517,
-0.35036855936050415,
0.5516468286514282,
0.524340808391571,
-0.13732771575450897,
0.5220975279808044,
-0.12483876198530197,
0.41589540243148804,
-1.1324424743652344,
0.12066137790679932,
0.45800134539604187,
-0.11449970304965973,
-0.5240788459777832,
-0.12772566080093384,
-0.16829384863376617,
0.1100936084985733,
-0.3621402382850647,
0.5619020462036133,
-0.15343168377876282,
0.13534221053123474,
-0.20850275456905365,
-0.16671541333198547,
0.33362579345703125,
0.750540018081665,
0.39810967445373535,
0.8156769275665283,
0.44332510232925415,
-0.33658352494239807,
0.042403120547533035,
0.1752839982509613,
-0.18031924962997437,
0.9620800614356995,
-0.6659520864486694,
0.17863813042640686,
-0.24955593049526215,
0.2944822609424591,
-1.3262393474578857,
-0.20683211088180542,
0.21787215769290924,
-0.2979383170604706,
0.4071297347545624,
-0.29295188188552856,
-0.4759778082370758,
-0.09899554401636124,
-0.2361338585615158,
0.22956673800945282,
0.4111734926700592,
-0.6741982102394104,
0.36599627137184143,
0.25385671854019165,
-0.14545272290706635,
-0.5489774346351624,
-0.6678083539009094,
0.07982616126537323,
-0.3408675789833069,
-0.14991939067840576,
0.5182369351387024,
-0.5605644583702087,
-0.20494765043258667,
-0.018908321857452393,
-0.24307012557983398,
-0.21468807756900787,
0.20061688125133514,
0.4473626911640167,
0.5486111640930176,
-0.23517990112304688,
0.09766574203968048,
0.24437794089317322,
0.04813298583030701,
-0.013023709878325462,
-0.38169801235198975,
0.2163366824388504,
-0.05363417789340019,
-0.2736951410770416,
-0.03238885477185249,
0.47549208998680115,
0.5017215609550476,
-0.14913320541381836,
0.6925066709518433,
0.9330479502677917,
-0.397416353225708,
-0.3308449387550354,
-0.38798728585243225,
-0.04949173331260681,
-0.4664919376373291,
0.4509335160255432,
-0.5698010921478271,
-0.32341328263282776,
0.5520378351211548,
-0.053525522351264954,
-0.001476223231293261,
0.4254412353038788,
0.3657901883125305,
-0.12792806327342987,
0.9598860144615173,
0.5156784057617188,
0.3562682867050171,
0.6222700476646423,
-0.09710564464330673,
0.03145216032862663,
-0.5210104584693909,
-0.08653304725885391,
-0.14782732725143433,
-0.11101843416690826,
-0.7561842799186707,
-0.3320145905017853,
0.31133124232292175,
0.1399523913860321,
-0.20672421157360077,
0.12509530782699585,
-0.15980030596256256,
0.42937350273132324,
0.4644973874092102,
0.1901005357503891,
0.05247688293457031,
0.16399161517620087,
-0.19936086237430573,
-0.1411386877298355,
-0.3808302879333496,
-0.33973005414009094,
0.8375110030174255,
0.10341521352529526,
0.6938595771789551,
0.24676315486431122,
0.4640600383281708,
0.5724826455116272,
0.2258078157901764,
-0.45888635516166687,
0.40467798709869385,
-0.7103452682495117,
-0.3777254521846771,
-0.1160653606057167,
-0.4145206809043884,
-0.6499760746955872,
0.05166688561439514,
-0.47596418857574463,
-0.7071094512939453,
0.5317187905311584,
0.23227493464946747,
-0.07460615038871765,
0.1774616539478302,
-0.6476336717605591,
0.6724531054496765,
-0.0429295115172863,
-0.8209792971611023,
-0.03920695185661316,
-0.5028308033943176,
0.17771190404891968,
-0.6247857213020325,
-0.012281849049031734,
0.08431452512741089,
0.28608787059783936,
0.7413641810417175,
-0.27376091480255127,
1.0189019441604614,
-0.17347665131092072,
-0.2180260419845581,
0.30888041853904724,
0.3797522485256195,
0.33494991064071655,
0.32569435238838196,
0.22519688308238983,
0.4120123088359833,
-0.03257719427347183,
-0.2963569462299347,
-0.7165984511375427,
0.8607063889503479,
-0.8272975087165833,
-0.6071417927742004,
-0.18647775053977966,
-0.38435569405555725,
-0.5247994661331177,
0.4329371750354767,
0.5258908867835999,
0.6048974394798279,
-0.36280709505081177,
0.12872512638568878,
0.7699952721595764,
-0.23395487666130066,
0.6127573847770691,
0.5759318470954895,
0.017668142914772034,
-0.41187039017677307,
1.352530837059021,
0.36772462725639343,
0.23683954775333405,
0.27788758277893066,
0.14183877408504486,
-0.4137655198574066,
-0.5112799406051636,
-0.735776960849762,
-0.09926177561283112,
-0.6401163339614868,
-0.033675532788038254,
-0.5786715745925903,
-0.297391802072525,
-0.08410657942295074,
-0.3736410439014435,
-0.46664896607398987,
-0.37716302275657654,
-0.40418902039527893,
0.09202159941196442,
0.31276482343673706,
0.7488217353820801,
-0.19700053334236145,
0.19044460356235504,
-0.4460279643535614,
0.6196492910385132,
0.33918166160583496,
0.4270034730434418,
-0.16149066388607025,
-0.42584294080734253,
-0.14510458707809448,
0.03229397162795067,
-0.3166272044181824,
-0.7153088450431824,
0.34261924028396606,
0.1493653655052185,
0.472565621137619,
0.2538083493709564,
0.33261844515800476,
0.3484693467617035,
-0.44142648577690125,
0.7242962718009949,
0.3471923768520355,
-0.9727821946144104,
0.4329053461551666,
-0.44145438075065613,
0.12395458668470383,
0.49997416138648987,
0.6331450939178467,
-0.35292765498161316,
-0.41082367300987244,
-0.8265536427497864,
-0.8170274496078491,
0.5386325716972351,
0.09035874903202057,
0.09697137027978897,
-0.06310923397541046,
0.17669178545475006,
0.508042573928833,
0.4685855209827423,
-0.4608006179332733,
-0.18239134550094604,
-0.941521167755127,
-0.21061567962169647,
-0.3243032693862915,
-0.06870871037244797,
-0.3746183514595032,
0.33272528648376465,
0.7561172842979431,
-0.32869264483451843,
-0.02039220929145813,
0.202706441283226,
-0.19253788888454437,
-0.2830567955970764,
0.2008320391178131,
0.7145543694496155,
0.5952871441841125,
-0.3520786762237549,
0.4503515362739563,
-0.2810455560684204,
-0.5214505791664124,
0.20299221575260162,
0.19648237526416779,
-0.27732110023498535,
0.07331699132919312,
0.20934975147247314,
0.7424614429473877,
-0.2607290744781494,
-0.2676386833190918,
0.6745887398719788,
-0.14163701236248016,
-0.24309606850147247,
-0.27186498045921326,
0.02651357091963291,
-0.3384181559085846,
0.10312192887067795,
0.45151469111442566,
0.33370131254196167,
-0.017034880816936493,
-0.36355769634246826,
0.7606241703033447,
0.4199325740337372,
-0.43575772643089294,
-0.5595464706420898,
0.7214170694351196,
0.09585487097501755,
0.11983297020196915,
0.4629025161266327,
-0.42665895819664,
-0.2921546697616577,
0.7139153480529785,
0.5649829506874084,
1.0101709365844727,
-0.0338464081287384,
0.5348863005638123,
0.4164400100708008,
-0.03354340419173241,
0.16123348474502563,
-0.005798388738185167,
-0.023976098746061325,
-0.9093791842460632,
-0.06664673984050751,
-0.4599355161190033,
-0.2944895625114441,
0.5593751668930054,
-0.5815114378929138,
0.014628812670707703,
-0.5229688882827759,
-0.24195939302444458,
0.10822802037000656,
0.029923496767878532,
-0.6112801432609558,
0.5033053755760193,
0.20090782642364502,
0.24706773459911346,
-1.3970537185668945,
0.6331292986869812,
0.5716065764427185,
-0.6813409924507141,
-0.26427412033081055,
0.3374166488647461,
0.2068163901567459,
-0.5457267761230469,
0.675835371017456,
-0.07067739218473434,
-0.3248736262321472,
-0.17608118057250977,
-0.6009682416915894,
-0.7147366404533386,
0.7333126664161682,
0.2984431982040405,
-0.5320268869400024,
0.42583760619163513,
0.031284578144550323,
0.5292609930038452,
-0.454161673784256,
0.06961655616760254,
0.24143922328948975,
0.3420707881450653,
0.42931559681892395,
-0.537431001663208,
0.2864552438259125,
-0.3912944495677948,
0.037588633596897125,
-0.2448936402797699,
-0.580652117729187,
0.7450466752052307,
-0.30991804599761963,
-0.34660813212394714,
-0.04291732236742973,
0.5725665092468262,
0.2004823386669159,
0.5874119400978088,
0.5097522735595703,
0.22346855700016022,
0.45642808079719543,
-0.07869128882884979,
0.6688085794448853,
-0.27078884840011597,
0.35655078291893005,
1.3905797004699707,
-0.23644624650478363,
0.5274860858917236,
0.47816312313079834,
-0.05421632155776024,
0.463426798582077,
0.790036678314209,
-0.30352190136909485,
0.6764208674430847,
-0.04149651154875755,
-0.018009154126048088,
-0.2762777507305145,
-0.5579020977020264,
-0.18848653137683868,
0.4834143817424774,
0.32068175077438354,
-0.3441760241985321,
-0.007051858585327864,
-0.1211237832903862,
0.2265278846025467,
0.21533028781414032,
0.007122504990547895,
0.679976224899292,
-0.10344165563583374,
-0.7955247163772583,
0.6987789273262024,
-0.19081515073776245,
0.4608077108860016,
-0.33330148458480835,
-0.5095837712287903,
-0.4500213861465454,
0.0923629179596901,
-0.23230794072151184,
-0.7635580897331238,
0.14693583548069,
-0.25391292572021484,
-0.4379320740699768,
-0.2671155035495758,
0.5556250214576721,
-0.5020308494567871,
-0.5418810844421387,
0.04822520166635513,
0.5065787434577942,
-0.20723041892051697,
0.33105260133743286,
-0.6075003147125244,
0.055100034922361374,
-0.06613042205572128,
-0.31494268774986267,
0.3788665235042572,
0.38452136516571045,
-0.3130952715873718,
0.19298654794692993,
0.5452944040298462,
-0.1463920623064041,
-0.18243318796157837,
0.0009132436825893819,
0.7869877815246582,
-0.28479132056236267,
-0.5195474624633789,
-0.7432601451873779,
0.34181809425354004,
-0.0408741720020771,
-0.2775219976902008,
0.6547415852546692,
0.2331368327140808,
0.8688374757766724,
-0.2703622877597809,
0.8411886096000671,
-0.011004195548593998,
0.12339092046022415,
-0.6146925091743469,
0.7178506255149841,
-0.7186160683631897,
0.19825096428394318,
-0.5436903834342957,
-0.7083262205123901,
-0.060268860310316086,
0.27651289105415344,
-0.24951103329658508,
0.27234721183776855,
0.5768821239471436,
0.8546977043151855,
-0.20189522206783295,
-0.21499863266944885,
0.30834200978279114,
0.1441088765859604,
0.345499187707901,
0.37086060643196106,
0.6551138758659363,
-0.24088691174983978,
0.06882112473249435,
-0.11053843796253204,
-0.20238766074180603,
-0.157457634806633,
-1.02783203125,
-0.7236149907112122,
-1.066775918006897,
-0.862791121006012,
-0.5308893918991089,
0.052785810083150864,
0.6165581941604614,
0.9963784217834473,
-0.9056376218795776,
0.3121851682662964,
-0.19298876821994781,
0.1610788255929947,
-0.36987921595573425,
-0.25958505272865295,
0.31313204765319824,
0.06021909415721893,
-0.7916557788848877,
0.24716700613498688,
0.18346166610717773,
0.44312354922294617,
-0.19385355710983276,
0.045886822044849396,
-0.08198581635951996,
0.6192784905433655,
0.3922032415866852,
0.3457130193710327,
-0.5318845510482788,
-0.3307330310344696,
-0.3640002906322479,
-0.004344181623309851,
0.1431991010904312,
0.6738678216934204,
-0.6861141920089722,
0.5617848634719849,
0.3281439244747162,
0.5677484273910522,
0.3767939507961273,
0.06277062743902206,
0.4605900049209595,
-1.1908174753189087,
-0.03861298784613609,
-0.31087803840637207,
0.3048990070819855,
0.3492475152015686,
-0.47196781635284424,
0.5042901635169983,
0.5605916976928711,
-0.17735272645950317,
-0.6452205777168274,
0.5217171311378479,
-0.8827051520347595,
-0.5319597721099854,
1.01918363571167,
-0.42337512969970703,
-0.01621687225997448,
-0.07577408850193024,
0.15215365588665009,
0.23467056453227997,
-0.32158198952674866,
0.8036114573478699,
0.5588122606277466,
-0.14078670740127563,
-0.09627162665128708,
-0.2322600930929184,
0.4789700210094452,
0.439773291349411,
-0.6382778882980347,
0.08467642217874527,
0.6404178142547607,
0.35187283158302307,
0.38795337080955505,
0.5380870699882507,
0.01432559173554182,
0.27897319197654724,
0.3024939000606537,
-0.14282870292663574,
-0.0868707150220871,
-0.4945363402366638,
-0.11220891773700714,
0.16761094331741333,
-0.11768468469381332,
-0.3699438273906708
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.